id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09826v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09826v2 | Fairness in AI and Its Long-Term Implications on Society | 2023-04-16T11:22:59 | 2023-07-19T19:30:52 | Ondrej Bohdal, Timothy Hospedales, Philip H. S. Torr, Fazl Barez | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Successful deployment of artificial intelligence (AI) in various settings has
led to numerous positive outcomes for individuals and society. However, AI
systems have also been shown to harm parts of the population due to biased
predictions. AI fairness focuses on mitigating such biases to ensure AI
decision making is not discriminatory towards certain groups. We take a closer
look at AI fairness and analyze how lack of AI fairness can lead to deepening
of biases over time and act as a social stressor. More specifically, we discuss
how biased models can lead to more negative real-world outcomes for certain
groups, which may then become more prevalent by deploying new AI models trained
on increasingly biased data, resulting in a feedback loop. If the issues
persist, they could be reinforced by interactions with other risks and have
severe implications on society in the form of social unrest. We examine current
strategies for improving AI fairness, assess their limitations in terms of
real-world deployment, and explore potential paths forward to ensure we reap
AI's benefits without causing society's collapse. | [
0.0184319559,
0.1150505915,
-0.0454416312,
-0.0337666869,
-0.0192992315,
0.0015364861,
0.0482622907,
-0.0124319289,
0.0433636047,
-0.0290087052,
0.0322950929,
0.0639432594,
-0.005663259,
0.0046895426,
-0.012711863,
-0.03958074,
0.0081605548,
0.0074318969,
0.0601523444,
-0.0404105596,
0.0038161436,
-0.0049275216,
0.0274277963,
0.0525781028,
-0.0468331426,
0.0032964037,
0.0658733547,
0.0004037076,
0.0057306662,
-0.0124472333,
0.0132156219,
0.0195260793,
-0.0099012889,
-0.0006256527,
0.0000021491,
-0.0415881202,
0.011436224,
0.0175132472,
-0.0215856247,
-0.0248468872,
0.0361678675,
-0.0223138258,
0.0164383762,
0.0349668562,
-0.0417881981,
0.0458752252,
0.0029313427,
-0.0140416846,
-0.0064451317,
-0.0067391843,
-0.0013595638,
0.0176724531,
-0.0058893948,
0.0079033561,
-0.0168178231,
-0.0221308675,
0.01861066,
-0.041674383,
-0.041910328,
-0.0617849082,
-0.0157623738,
0.0298525058,
0.0129226102,
0.0303944368,
0.0271163955,
0.0330198184,
-0.0270880014,
-0.0561400391,
-0.0216807388,
0.0458285138,
0.0070084785,
0.0083860634,
-0.0092242593,
-0.0231609996,
0.0729695112,
-0.0278908461,
-0.0383739956,
0.0466051586,
-0.0236878674,
-0.0033054068,
0.0329876803,
0.0541835576,
0.0216206107,
0.0521543659,
-0.0040391185,
0.0669121146,
-0.0232291576,
-0.0422849879,
0.0015479614,
0.0535935126,
0.0280073714,
-0.0106187612,
0.0307159536,
0.0027083764,
-0.0368184894,
-0.0244264994,
-0.0343451239,
-0.0106325578,
0.0168938581,
-0.0215624515,
0.0078526605,
0.0332807899,
0.0014505198,
-0.009660786,
0.0587139465,
0.0092653558,
0.0053190603,
0.0326414295,
-0.0146942008,
0.0115964822,
0.0023822051,
0.0244755186,
0.0315199755,
-0.0005263516,
-0.0160243716,
0.0452333651,
0.0040903958,
0.0044405474,
-0.1214009076,
0.0116940793,
-0.0112654651,
0.0342942216,
-0.0170966703,
0.0335250236,
-0.0444174036,
-0.0385003984,
-0.0630131066,
0.0175439138,
-0.0283464752,
-0.0608868599,
0.000283238,
-0.0199092515,
-0.0297734104,
-0.0055694878,
0.0034714078,
0.0702500939,
0.0603168234,
-0.0237354096,
-0.0323245525,
-0.0407247096,
0.0213675536,
-0.0145458216,
-0.0155560244,
-0.0072839693,
0.0002704772,
0.0108896811,
-0.0085463766,
-0.0375735015,
-0.0210318137,
-0.0114705293,
-0.0769770294,
0.0490134656,
-0.0064733536,
0.0152021525,
0.0419948064,
0.0328301229,
-0.0446200632,
0.0426672436,
0.0384770148,
0.0089968443,
0.053046681,
0.0227999687,
0.0566824935,
-0.0127021708,
0.0070904219,
-0.0017799068,
0.0145790037,
0.0372884944,
-0.0685790852,
0.0043579414,
0.0263636913,
0.03758955,
0.0183085203,
0.0065835123,
0.0460973419,
0.0227813441,
-0.0538656116,
0.0429225713,
-0.0476542674,
-0.0176515579,
-0.0660637692,
-0.0026645113,
-0.078053385,
0.0093503995,
-0.0411361195,
-0.0505592637,
-0.0481950268,
0.0374257527,
-0.0466114357,
-0.0285048541,
0.010961148,
-0.0119479448,
0.0784937814,
0.0589935184,
-0.0105942059,
-0.0356563888,
0.0062066643,
-0.032895565,
0.0291721411,
0.0118698617,
-0.0037661698,
-0.1015751511,
0.001513824,
0.0540031008,
0.0092816055,
-0.0296792798,
0.010167216,
-0.0107721612,
-0.0212747734,
-0.0055660377,
0.0552376881,
0.0018577297,
-0.026799269,
-0.0070379544,
-0.0351064466,
0.0577328019,
0.0276572946,
0.0325323045,
0.0251906253,
0.0436107628,
-0.0320478976,
-0.0045495429,
-0.0373207964,
0.0222300757,
0.0088387011,
-0.0072884057,
-0.0365610607,
0.0004653969,
0.0132927112,
-0.0050258804,
-0.0419166125,
0.0014905016,
-0.014310386,
0.0069460478,
-0.0302431528,
0.0255976617,
-0.0462166108,
0.0849373117,
-0.0289518461,
-0.0713819042,
-0.0203072745,
0.0738015696,
-0.0123766763,
0.0474755652,
0.0539564677,
0.0416833833,
-0.0126297344,
0.0446895733,
0.0194741767,
-0.0426089317,
0.0219892003,
-0.0364155844,
-0.0060059852,
-0.0230054166,
-0.0823338255,
-0.0287081581,
-0.0516136587,
-0.0104518551,
-0.0360660478,
-0.0186371394,
0.0104440106,
-0.0044486318,
0.0195900314,
0.0374944881,
-0.0031918178,
0.0199646465,
0.0528634265,
-0.0423198305,
-0.0054954551,
-0.0050927722,
-0.0414944962,
-0.0336267203,
-0.0034978199,
-0.018556688,
-0.0222190991,
-0.0207926631,
-0.0236471239,
0.0372573808,
0.0467211008,
-0.008305423,
-0.0069798892,
-0.0125739975,
-0.03312454,
-0.0342468992,
-0.0354422182,
0.0367726535,
0.0894899741,
0.0146660917,
-0.0505320355,
-0.0308440477,
-0.0267475061,
0.0390061699,
-0.010800981,
0.0067129345,
-0.0067393696,
0.0495745577,
-0.0327345096,
0.0681908578,
0.0301097464,
0.0616078414,
0.0727903992,
0.0738386661,
-0.0117689976,
-0.0169159696,
0.0323005542,
0.0051663858,
0.0302970372,
-0.0365561806,
-0.0394544639,
0.0074393838,
0.0491527058,
-0.0307108797,
-0.0299977083,
0.0841737837,
-0.0834892914,
-0.0800211355,
-0.0253801681,
-0.0840295181,
0.0027012699,
0.0296267066,
-0.0450425111,
-0.0593943261,
0.0367596224,
0.053658925,
0.0728014633,
-0.0137832006,
0.0078789853,
-0.0163288843,
-0.0053803967,
0.0017829584,
0.0092336554,
0.0032290954,
0.0214293301,
-0.0586630777,
-0.0384569913,
0.012674992,
-0.0340735726,
0.0083665922,
-0.0473557897,
-0.0194885992,
-0.0284270961,
-0.0903638527,
-0.0375647284,
-0.0644453615,
-0.0118298717,
0.0235201064,
0.0274023972,
-0.0040881205,
0.0011818465,
-0.0342476256,
0.0502501652,
0.021874873,
-0.0170774143,
-0.0192110427,
0.0198578145,
-0.0733702406,
0.0057158084,
-0.0205327999,
0.0629442409,
-0.0148984147,
0.0022650415,
0.0128413131,
0.0423040725,
0.0332851484,
-0.0034723415,
0.0294620618,
0.0014717361,
-0.0014915807,
0.0033592151,
0.0239060633,
0.0070747766,
0.0041155582,
0.0447776988,
0.0564824194,
-0.0118331844,
-0.0507205166,
0.0514331684,
-0.0038418607,
-0.0186785869,
0.0302614141,
-0.0136011215,
-0.0778496936,
0.0035099308,
0.0451371036,
0.0595254414,
-0.074240379,
-0.0668755323,
0.0577368475,
-0.0513341762,
0.0396142863,
0.0070913858,
0.0083316378,
-0.0701434463,
-0.0108880196,
-0.0117163341,
-0.0519442521,
0.0197445843,
-0.0164696686,
0.0487644598,
0.0285698045,
0.0119742621,
-0.0407643914,
0.0218071304,
0.0341790207,
-0.0791620612,
0.0250055902,
0.0745827109,
0.0592521131,
-0.0449513942,
0.0272175949,
-0.0075733783,
0.0243554562,
0.0008412023,
0.0166343637,
0.0646772683,
-0.0027449133,
-0.0048879837,
-0.0536288247,
0.0069627049,
0.0159233101,
0.0412929766,
0.0475278758,
0.0280440152,
-0.0071061961,
-0.0709820315,
-0.0749453828,
-0.0353368372,
0.0168306958,
0.0565230288,
-0.0131557956,
-0.0225302707,
-0.0093392441,
-0.0489125028,
0.0065566893,
-0.0164013244,
-0.0279573333,
0.0511361063,
0.0039863796,
-0.0529708378,
-0.0016232328,
-0.0657384843,
-0.034059789,
-0.038713295,
0.0358935148,
-0.0918241143,
0.0096919537,
0.0071324459,
-0.0095786583,
0.0299476981,
0.0035425918,
0.0092895655,
0.0295638554,
-0.0069351397,
-0.0599937886,
-0.0160852596,
-0.0040940577,
0.0040103714,
0.0125345187,
-0.0149351424,
0.0835067108,
0.0595439784,
0.0231813285,
0.0310919955,
-0.0195951462,
0.005471231,
0.0874708444,
0.0364336148,
-0.0116624087,
0.0248521939,
0.0481535308,
-0.0398533493,
-0.0040934435,
-0.0090013556,
-0.0260914303,
0.0126977796,
0.0190559998,
-0.0264935009,
-0.0382262357,
-0.0108126039,
-0.0009049489,
0.0221097693,
0.0341256857,
-0.0265860874,
-0.0202843379,
0.0161564872,
-0.0292370245,
0.0204779301,
-0.0272799265,
0.020635847,
-0.0563452654,
0.027081091,
0.0429378003,
-0.0384270698,
0.0008165396,
0.0063038147,
-0.0254434831,
-0.0368195139,
0.0603473224,
0.0060484367,
0.0793097243,
0.0002387191,
-0.0056125475,
0.0034354962,
0.0545399114,
-0.0323282667,
0.0251988452,
0.0133729931,
-0.0093191061,
-0.0129619865,
0.0311075728,
-0.0222469587,
0.034864895,
-0.055460453,
-0.081458725,
0.0058756866,
0.0069953557,
0.0108538242,
0.0203556754,
-0.026789492,
0.0176382679,
-0.0109351976,
0.0154525097,
-0.0120413825,
-0.0176484417,
0.0440649875,
-0.0249960385,
-0.0145320026,
-0.0252922736,
0.0111773405,
0.0401668996,
-0.0102164634,
0.0821323916,
-0.0561424941,
-0.0161691736,
0.0337599851,
-0.0360103622,
0.0315169506,
-0.0365338139,
0.012848299,
-0.0464915857,
-0.0843905807,
-0.0237164535,
-0.0279654525,
0.0297182836,
0.0478195921,
-0.0397572368,
-0.0241548847,
0.0115603134,
-0.0352057889,
-0.0450456105,
0.0058607608,
-0.0061531626,
-0.0733556747,
-0.0121727642,
-0.0204085428,
-5.593741581e-33,
0.018782137,
-0.0052790712,
-0.0396880172,
-0.0318435468,
-0.0087630786,
-0.0125492252,
0.0203369167,
-0.0021614216,
-0.063519761,
0.0156796426,
0.0007204424,
0.0226816051,
-0.0113112843,
-0.035276819,
0.045574192,
-0.0590073541,
0.0103294235,
-0.0203883536,
0.0049173534,
0.0169259291,
-0.0562684759,
0.0215741675,
0.003062861,
-0.0649323016,
0.0486878678,
0.012004355,
0.0056542261,
-0.0222288743,
-0.0290714987,
-0.0015612119,
0.0392915606,
0.0874781385,
0.0362968966,
-0.0121855475,
-0.0134447636,
0.0378713273,
0.0012345786,
0.0189957581,
-0.0291690677,
-0.0006812647,
0.0191686768,
-0.0326656997,
0.0192926172,
0.028450394,
-0.0773784444,
0.0104234312,
0.0459217392,
-0.0095149726,
0.045309864,
0.0348296165,
-0.0177784637,
-0.0086069787,
-0.0551902801,
0.0259320308,
-0.0597684309,
0.0464225262,
0.0305112824,
0.0630472377,
-0.0380597673,
0.0203709658,
0.0142044304,
-0.0772200227,
0.0301407296,
-0.0224909931,
0.0139990989,
0.0245081317,
0.0582321398,
0.0190469474,
-0.0536747649,
-0.0894752517,
0.0151859345,
-0.0321726762,
0.0266483724,
0.0553030968,
0.0401733294,
-0.0575248934,
-0.0155182583,
0.002950588,
0.0070778467,
0.0088252379,
0.0205779318,
-0.0150796724,
-0.1179866418,
-0.0283327904,
-0.0120125031,
-0.0983660594,
-0.0235753506,
0.021786781,
0.0142543474,
-0.0006123294,
-0.0011666068,
0.0454649813,
0.0110678039,
-0.0573788323,
0.0250019114,
0.0172265787,
0.030301474,
-0.041265022,
0.0001023465,
-0.0272474848,
-0.0366377607,
-0.0130941449,
-0.0148800043,
0.0334778503,
0.0578732528,
0.0440157652,
0.0118324878,
0.0008836287,
0.0108397054,
0.001977552,
0.0002647988,
0.0369046926,
0.0664135441,
-0.0227988791,
0.0181101523,
0.0187355895,
0.022588592,
-0.0385909826,
0.0351946801,
0.0259971451,
-0.0552827455,
0.0118766865,
-0.0399826169,
0.0146931661,
-0.0126877418,
-0.0339693762,
-0.002819635,
0.0097362185,
-0.0037888237,
-0.0790178776,
-0.040089637,
-0.0710443929,
2.574e-7,
-0.0255811177,
0.0362913273,
-0.003467405,
0.0114010023,
-0.0191913545,
0.0711641982,
0.0218627434,
0.0748333707,
0.0156477522,
0.033557497,
0.0194134582,
0.0491183102,
-0.0224233624,
-0.0030194018,
0.0218363404,
-0.0309144072,
-0.0483733676,
0.0397725813,
-0.0241338909,
0.0385266915,
0.022864582,
0.0215006582,
0.0319732502,
-0.0136025604,
0.0184185542,
-0.009970692,
-0.0164894965,
-0.030772144,
0.0447657555,
-0.0198747646,
0.0111135244,
0.0354461968,
-0.0093608992,
0.0440558195,
0.0122778518,
-0.0076057962,
-0.0440952666,
0.0250935256,
-0.026171783,
0.0197638646,
-0.0043962188,
0.0047343131,
0.0113728996,
-0.0364639089,
0.0519850813,
0.017132422,
-0.0387599282,
-0.0603060499,
0.016092388,
-0.0139071755,
0.0520094819,
0.031606026,
-0.0252988171,
-0.0060692271,
0.034799125,
0.0366044901,
0.0363906249,
-0.0396905504,
-0.0167244617,
-0.0197378099,
-0.0120843351,
-0.0589414611,
0.0393640734,
0.0542945527,
-0.0150513314,
0.0077935513,
0.0208029952,
2.355106605e-34,
-0.0118738618,
0.0146559542,
0.0009362817,
-0.0481451787,
0.0352351107,
0.0276518334,
-0.0302082356,
-0.0308383834,
0.0358631425,
0.0421302505,
-0.0321900472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07741v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07741v2 | Canvas: End-to-End Kernel Architecture Search in Neural Networks | 2023-04-16T10:05:42 | 2023-04-18T06:02:01 | Chenggang Zhao, Genghan Zhang, Mingyu Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.PF | The demands for higher performance and accuracy in neural networks (NNs)
never end. Existing tensor compilation and Neural Architecture Search (NAS)
techniques orthogonally optimize the two goals but actually share many
similarities in their concrete strategies. We exploit such opportunities by
combining the two into one and make a case for Kernel Architecture Search
(KAS). KAS reviews NAS from a system perspective and zooms into a more
fine-grained level to generate neural kernels with both high performance and
good accuracy. To demonstrate the potential of KAS, we build an end-to-end
framework, Canvas, to find high-quality kernels as convolution replacements.
Canvas samples from a rich set of fine-grained primitives to stochastically and
iteratively construct new kernels and evaluate them according to user-specified
constraints. Canvas supports freely adjustable tensor dimension sizes inside
the kernel and uses two levels of solvers to satisfy structural legality and
fully utilize model budgets. The evaluation shows that by replacing standard
convolutions with generated new kernels in common NNs, Canvas achieves average
1.5x speedups compared to the previous state-of-the-art with acceptable
accuracy loss and search efficiency. Canvas verifies the practicability of KAS
by rediscovering many manually designed kernels in the past and producing new
structures that may inspire future machine learning innovations. For source
code and implementation, we open-sourced Canvas at
https://github.com/tsinghua-ideal/Canvas. | [
-0.0012255557,
0.0719304085,
-0.0171370488,
0.0720485449,
-0.0230095796,
-0.0391041823,
0.0116874436,
0.008810536,
-0.0245900042,
0.0555224679,
-0.0236394107,
-0.0020742803,
-0.0136753377,
0.0440320298,
0.0234836712,
0.0334010012,
-0.0008260719,
0.0572255924,
-0.0291200187,
-0.0111397579,
-0.0296171792,
0.0260020327,
-0.0009804342,
0.0122109782,
-0.0685889721,
0.0142818596,
-0.0207848083,
0.0441983901,
0.0310666375,
-0.0061989543,
0.0639703646,
-0.0266993437,
-0.0183594748,
0.074654378,
0.0000022444,
0.0214058813,
0.0186583232,
0.0035257547,
-0.0002075964,
0.0317999758,
0.0266418774,
0.0173231252,
-0.0315757282,
-0.0331773274,
-0.023581747,
-0.0025269261,
0.0661111623,
0.058181446,
0.0611494631,
0.0514963157,
-0.007111446,
-0.0122962529,
-0.0137737328,
-0.0322910249,
-0.008722825,
-0.0545882769,
-0.0203717891,
-0.0281961057,
-0.0026556433,
-0.0335868634,
0.0142714959,
0.0694917813,
0.0447893776,
0.001126681,
0.0571343675,
0.0416945554,
-0.0679330751,
-0.0340440497,
0.0131192487,
0.0648441911,
-0.062096145,
0.0097657144,
0.0136158466,
-0.0247834176,
-0.0150289442,
-0.0475923531,
0.0160847977,
-0.01276612,
0.0134545835,
0.0080915205,
-0.0612001754,
-0.0096568959,
0.0607060231,
0.0190286264,
-0.0061455765,
0.0211645588,
0.0346088149,
0.0399018601,
0.0041947095,
-0.0153707564,
-0.0522990115,
-0.0060933204,
0.0188685898,
-0.0225595497,
0.0092428811,
-0.0413712487,
-0.037882302,
-0.0273043159,
-0.0310561229,
-0.0493706129,
0.0542254709,
0.0485198647,
-0.0251257364,
0.0145203518,
-0.0796658248,
-0.0489252284,
-0.0738667771,
0.0030627076,
-0.0507189594,
0.0024573507,
0.0088481465,
0.0065245931,
-0.025580572,
-0.0314753726,
-0.0331266746,
-0.0284162294,
-0.0367433242,
0.0262306873,
-0.0394533612,
-0.0446618348,
-0.028604256,
0.0585442521,
0.0271390732,
0.0155533832,
-0.0110609541,
0.0094324527,
-0.0149564426,
0.0053074639,
-0.0073152003,
-0.0064983265,
-0.0077570709,
0.0345919803,
-0.0053945971,
-0.0301055014,
0.0665908307,
0.0292151719,
0.0075650215,
-0.0527831316,
-0.0247351825,
-0.0075174822,
-0.0300492179,
-0.0323074982,
0.0498456322,
-0.016069863,
0.019888049,
-0.0713242143,
-0.0188444685,
-0.0319514014,
0.0001862677,
-0.0064246859,
-0.041051615,
0.031361483,
0.0422296897,
-0.0175109822,
0.0765769407,
0.014866909,
0.0118055195,
0.0221426636,
0.0195728745,
0.0695540532,
0.0139981285,
-0.0390744247,
-0.0404729545,
0.0290342011,
0.0263660997,
0.0056221187,
-0.018379502,
-0.0120130815,
-0.0575061925,
0.0699653849,
0.0082318112,
0.0331373997,
-0.0601737648,
-0.0549811162,
0.0062315725,
0.0322231203,
0.0291879941,
0.029922545,
0.0039975289,
-0.026181452,
-0.0154387085,
-0.0741278455,
-0.0263155382,
0.0838048756,
0.0119053051,
-0.0493273251,
-0.0004786418,
0.0259543788,
-0.0320020057,
-0.033868134,
0.0291082598,
0.0270766951,
-0.0260823313,
0.0439208932,
0.0369306169,
-0.017646648,
-0.036637675,
0.0326084234,
-0.037847206,
-0.0623564757,
-0.0121548353,
-0.079881601,
0.0120621044,
0.0203961972,
0.0537848994,
0.015976537,
-0.0482092015,
0.03773693,
-0.0223402083,
0.0019938834,
0.0155891376,
0.0120511176,
0.0416057631,
-0.0768907219,
-0.0093688248,
-0.0314107724,
-0.0025852751,
-0.0284056403,
0.0047827731,
0.0294027682,
0.0299349055,
-0.0231849533,
-0.0117263431,
0.0316075496,
0.0114270104,
-0.0100615565,
0.0792311579,
0.0197477974,
0.0297804028,
0.0025235908,
-0.0094960351,
-0.0336238965,
0.0514715314,
-0.0460515507,
-0.0499347411,
-0.0390812457,
-0.0444699638,
0.0064427448,
0.0076880739,
-0.0440396369,
0.0119839087,
0.006937169,
-0.0824591219,
-0.0204516333,
0.1022505984,
-0.0059947087,
-0.0103328051,
-0.026690321,
-0.0276967715,
-0.0053919558,
0.0364627503,
-0.0009947686,
-0.0021393143,
-0.0005364766,
-0.0223925244,
-0.0070251883,
0.0044126944,
0.029827591,
0.0204589795,
-0.0326559022,
-0.018784469,
-0.0397595093,
0.0314603113,
0.0311097708,
0.0207255892,
0.0463084057,
-0.0332894437,
-0.0558064766,
0.0486597009,
-0.0302800424,
-0.0373028629,
0.0255292635,
0.0261245444,
0.0218322817,
-0.0212121326,
0.0210071579,
0.072689265,
-0.0280960612,
-0.0145643875,
0.0060829804,
-0.0128129097,
-0.0287361965,
-0.0510765016,
-0.0826541185,
0.0249189623,
0.04316286,
-0.0353984796,
0.0212166496,
0.0042150519,
-0.0227507763,
0.0062670079,
0.0358784795,
-0.0059020822,
-0.0215563327,
0.0076341396,
-0.0145435492,
-0.0270225871,
0.1009606794,
0.0080766752,
0.0428081937,
0.0316852294,
0.0368930176,
-0.0212481935,
0.0745417178,
-0.0161592532,
-0.0192046408,
0.0032978042,
-0.0103869541,
0.0045450986,
0.0277700312,
-0.0104733715,
-0.0202606171,
-0.0830684677,
-0.0277071558,
0.0158838779,
0.0010091279,
-0.0561317019,
0.0179769974,
0.0278495196,
-0.0078652166,
0.000507788,
0.0121897142,
0.0068608331,
0.005239367,
-0.0095224362,
-0.0132037215,
-0.0215029009,
-0.0243176837,
0.0358674787,
0.010132608,
0.0239543151,
-0.0114725046,
0.0304090902,
-0.0291268304,
0.0179970413,
0.0337173901,
-0.0027264473,
0.0282011535,
0.0118689835,
0.0063047898,
0.0029670566,
-0.0447333604,
-0.0269748885,
0.0131236445,
0.0127557106,
0.0013606899,
-0.0455262698,
-0.0393436514,
0.0043516909,
-0.0287009068,
-0.0257002208,
0.0832605213,
0.0100641418,
-0.0153676206,
-0.0123793436,
0.0329658203,
0.0265015475,
-0.0145057132,
0.0328786932,
0.0280371439,
0.0091975592,
0.0453139804,
0.008629173,
0.0137573425,
-0.0871435776,
0.0037622845,
0.0368306451,
0.0091675259,
-0.033625789,
-0.0102216043,
0.0307825673,
-0.0621412471,
0.0185204726,
0.0091251945,
-0.0265390389,
0.0008709964,
-0.0078439731,
0.0473163128,
0.0182436872,
0.0387740657,
0.0512595214,
-0.0348130167,
-0.0311265066,
0.0026861071,
0.0331509486,
-0.0191225372,
0.0195374247,
0.0330523625,
-0.0226549469,
0.0533394814,
-0.0001772111,
-0.0158969201,
-0.0036895068,
-0.0230632238,
-0.0013949096,
-0.0571891069,
-0.0143178012,
0.0022192905,
0.026638912,
-0.0132881729,
-0.0241067801,
0.0226220135,
-0.0183550641,
0.0003125759,
-0.012147693,
-0.0321232863,
0.0291202106,
0.0232550539,
-0.009639577,
-0.0642941669,
0.0019201117,
-0.003471412,
0.0182344373,
0.0039738594,
0.0455730893,
0.023882715,
-0.0477417,
-0.0224906746,
0.0670078099,
-0.048714444,
0.0232520886,
-0.0173152499,
0.0647677407,
0.0071498486,
-0.0031212259,
-0.0669961572,
-0.0343895853,
0.0269171856,
0.0402725898,
0.01465715,
-0.0296328943,
-0.0277789831,
0.0088585261,
0.0102877337,
-0.0814028382,
-0.0120195197,
0.0059750886,
-0.0183614623,
-0.0469804406,
-0.0075454651,
0.065586701,
-0.0192943159,
0.0294976123,
-0.0182961617,
-0.0880316645,
-0.0158051606,
-0.0305958446,
-0.0903824866,
0.0535779484,
0.0131754419,
0.0470592491,
-0.0138756093,
0.0526754595,
0.0100394646,
-0.0068478985,
-0.0065533328,
0.0641390011,
-0.0912077948,
-0.0512407757,
0.0011309728,
0.0217155628,
-0.0038753995,
0.0017350049,
-0.015143536,
0.0046174582,
0.1180098206,
0.0148891089,
0.0106077455,
0.0439910479,
0.0319906585,
-0.0785132423,
-0.0319544449,
0.0321334973,
-0.0076837204,
0.0509063341,
0.0330024548,
0.0137539031,
0.0614885651,
0.0137027483,
-0.0063899034,
-0.0189650711,
0.0216133464,
-0.0093091112,
0.0251375977,
-0.0200206079,
0.0032993474,
0.0912762731,
0.0018217658,
-0.0442421436,
-0.047150556,
0.0363142677,
0.0201445762,
-0.0273088496,
-0.0008428611,
0.1159502715,
0.0925958902,
0.0118743451,
-0.0069925841,
0.0007885682,
0.043595653,
0.0529453233,
-0.0011844081,
-0.0013265669,
0.0484707505,
0.0047697411,
0.0594699383,
-0.0430904664,
0.02110653,
0.0044110771,
-0.0112983305,
-0.0417522714,
0.0429325029,
-0.0360362642,
-0.1031553447,
-0.0690116808,
0.001839878,
0.0535900332,
0.0046211113,
0.0318121538,
-0.0387864374,
-0.014184013,
-0.0224474259,
0.0014591163,
-0.0019987754,
-0.0003028153,
0.0125173964,
-0.0032913401,
0.0095862783,
-0.0397661962,
0.006597925,
-0.0168311503,
0.0727445185,
-0.0555534288,
0.0396220237,
-0.0060394388,
-0.0232930537,
-0.0345515721,
0.0216312278,
0.0002557325,
-0.0266846977,
-0.0008189782,
-0.0333859511,
-0.0166809876,
-0.00487435,
-0.0063319663,
-0.0027458426,
0.021321753,
0.0335099809,
0.0397375189,
-0.0094815455,
0.00944704,
-0.033703085,
-0.031091148,
-0.0194022097,
-0.0121540744,
-6.26574415e-33,
0.0294980705,
0.0340251029,
-0.0149463089,
-0.0262302514,
-0.0176075436,
0.0039246692,
-0.034630619,
-0.0085255327,
-0.0249719415,
-0.0102060456,
-0.0352110639,
0.0317200124,
0.0082164332,
0.0072858706,
0.0324221142,
0.0300641507,
0.0807609111,
-0.0137442127,
0.0020180682,
0.0367546417,
0.0283418559,
0.0066153766,
0.0189164635,
-0.0117055308,
-0.0915413052,
0.0294967759,
0.0025915641,
0.0259748586,
-0.0032244998,
-0.0090504382,
-0.02077833,
0.011651108,
-0.0200799182,
0.0089337034,
0.017211521,
-0.0625593513,
-0.0677975863,
-0.0201729182,
-0.0298362467,
0.0046578525,
-0.0909789205,
-0.0275759548,
0.0496155806,
0.0100347213,
-0.0302539654,
-0.0049894224,
-0.0137594705,
0.0123775331,
-0.0072242394,
-0.0033248644,
-0.0026598633,
0.0142756319,
-0.0170556437,
-0.0109932143,
0.0140225142,
0.0232119542,
-0.0137163512,
-0.0653777346,
-0.0679177642,
0.0029271538,
-0.0848560855,
0.0192834511,
0.0304005723,
0.0702678487,
0.0135467574,
0.0422563814,
0.0443861894,
0.0132534532,
0.0007859794,
-0.0502498783,
0.0378215834,
0.0693499744,
0.0600625463,
0.0250571538,
0.0489967503,
-0.0682603717,
-0.0566889271,
-0.0234988239,
0.0250654388,
-0.0053123278,
0.0104033956,
0.0241123177,
-0.0265791807,
-0.0168419909,
-0.0341006927,
-0.0353346094,
-0.0389080271,
-0.0066271792,
0.02474471,
0.0534929708,
-0.0170686226,
-0.0204974189,
0.0110053942,
-0.0266826767,
0.1531628668,
-0.0021186641,
-0.0042873747,
0.0195536874,
0.0594625883,
-0.0025111558,
-0.0263983104,
-0.0366077945,
-0.027909888,
-0.0270029344,
0.0339300931,
-0.0130782695,
0.0080400715,
0.0769020393,
-0.0086124958,
-0.0052112313,
-0.0735309497,
0.0349753276,
0.0019197301,
0.0125691649,
-0.0158221964,
0.0223671552,
-0.0075207571,
0.0144428564,
-0.0085284384,
0.0600386709,
-0.0292884409,
-0.042218741,
0.0443375744,
0.0040327823,
-0.037173003,
0.0095783491,
-0.0364343487,
-0.0312265009,
0.0178937819,
-0.1275153905,
-0.0307196155,
0.0218765661,
2.954e-7,
-0.0282718148,
0.00227335,
-0.013110213,
-0.0177015699,
0.0257271882,
0.0370564312,
0.0441695862,
0.0104077337,
-0.0738264546,
0.0267166588,
0.0261489991,
0.0018889628,
0.0568223856,
0.0098040039,
-0.0181768425,
0.0000695443,
-0.0154994372,
0.0161318891,
-0.0070432718,
-0.0234284587,
-0.0099150166,
0.0706559718,
0.0522014424,
-0.051886972,
0.0361503772,
-0.0449600257,
0.0256350972,
-0.0057703303,
0.0635760278,
0.0393811204,
0.0051529887,
0.0263005253,
-0.0373423472,
-0.016322976,
-0.0169904772,
0.0145628946,
0.009291633,
0.042503342,
0.0536577851,
-0.0656251535,
0.0224545728,
0.0293014757,
0.0140549568,
-0.0343728624,
0.0567905232,
-0.0027386944,
-0.0096209953,
-0.0710662231,
0.005139315,
-0.0127320113,
0.0578137413,
-0.0268302634,
0.0430155136,
0.034063559,
-0.0076141977,
-0.0282519031,
-0.0215760954,
-0.094792597,
0.0086663868,
0.0127671584,
-0.038095329,
0.0147966882,
-0.0962495059,
-0.0217488687,
0.0735746771,
0.0370314904,
-0.0404817015,
2.446836261e-34,
-0.0011726773,
-0.0330603831,
0.0161406547,
-0.0074989256,
0.0057099801,
0.0144272801,
-0.0189897362,
-0.010465567,
-0.0263945609,
-0.0139245735,
-0.0537169203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07699v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07699v3 | A Clustering Framework for Unsupervised and Semi-supervised New Intent Discovery | 2023-04-16T05:30:42 | 2023-12-13T01:39:20 | Hanlei Zhang, Hua Xu, Xin Wang, Fei Long, Kai Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | New intent discovery is of great value to natural language processing,
allowing for a better understanding of user needs and providing friendly
services. However, most existing methods struggle to capture the complicated
semantics of discrete text representations when limited or no prior knowledge
of labeled data is available. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel
clustering framework, USNID, for unsupervised and semi-supervised new intent
discovery, which has three key technologies. First, it fully utilizes
unsupervised or semi-supervised data to mine shallow semantic similarity
relations and provide well-initialized representations for clustering. Second,
it designs a centroid-guided clustering mechanism to address the issue of
cluster allocation inconsistency and provide high-quality self-supervised
targets for representation learning. Third, it captures high-level semantics in
unsupervised or semi-supervised data to discover fine-grained intent-wise
clusters by optimizing both cluster-level and instance-level objectives. We
also propose an effective method for estimating the cluster number in
open-world scenarios without knowing the number of new intents beforehand.
USNID performs exceptionally well on several benchmark intent datasets,
achieving new state-of-the-art results in unsupervised and semi-supervised new
intent discovery and demonstrating robust performance with different cluster
numbers. | [
0.0347252786,
-0.0032363392,
-0.0137150437,
0.0273690503,
-0.0157928262,
-0.0096108755,
0.005147005,
-0.0226320475,
0.0861213878,
-0.0225144457,
-0.0248331409,
0.0047369665,
-0.0232192501,
0.0169926658,
-0.0058653429,
-0.01526157,
0.0552935787,
0.0091174869,
0.0394670479,
0.0569881499,
0.013516386,
0.0466871113,
-0.0198026653,
0.0597054809,
-0.0672979578,
-0.0256294403,
-0.0368867442,
-0.0069914283,
0.0018391045,
-0.0477597974,
0.00824722,
0.0349061452,
0.035432782,
0.0132078901,
0.0000018997,
-0.0807375684,
-0.0791730359,
-0.0375667736,
-0.0141151007,
0.0065794429,
0.0823421478,
-0.0197587982,
0.0156200361,
-0.0055856863,
-0.025725117,
0.0196577627,
0.017080605,
0.0217580795,
0.0356145836,
0.0281236544,
-0.0273189172,
-0.0156377349,
-0.0221019983,
0.0016604469,
0.0313015394,
-0.0538583808,
0.0193276238,
-0.0051978105,
-0.0381419063,
0.0319648124,
0.0165942535,
-0.0151095213,
-0.0277151316,
0.0022734688,
0.01348258,
0.0451971889,
0.0160887837,
0.0166952629,
-0.0387264825,
0.0615288652,
0.0200137123,
-0.0221930742,
0.0272281878,
-0.0152197862,
-0.0072800987,
-0.045766633,
-0.0128541719,
0.0171987452,
0.0031307456,
0.0283714235,
0.0522713028,
0.0194292534,
0.0141596319,
0.0140309976,
-0.0222183261,
0.063148059,
-0.014416662,
0.0009179126,
-0.0121672973,
-0.0210944284,
-0.0000652018,
-0.0126405954,
0.0289760362,
0.0245432872,
-0.0133788781,
0.0229816921,
-0.0395653285,
-0.0098934313,
0.0221835747,
-0.0197176188,
-0.0292956233,
0.022636272,
0.0008444832,
0.0663045198,
0.0031627561,
-0.041950874,
0.0212567057,
-0.0025379644,
-0.0845034197,
-0.0037166052,
-0.0887777433,
0.0104461135,
-0.0658174232,
0.0667104721,
-0.0387384072,
-0.0286454093,
-0.0132812159,
0.0500611179,
0.0226716287,
-0.0549873672,
-0.020103205,
0.0118849231,
-0.0199050102,
0.0297112726,
0.0198841188,
0.0073987739,
-0.0452013053,
0.0468256921,
-0.0072477181,
-0.0141416723,
-0.0005483035,
0.0620640181,
0.0389852375,
-0.0034810014,
-0.0230062269,
-0.0111743296,
-0.034603931,
-0.0822730809,
-0.0654718876,
-0.0483212359,
-0.0328624509,
0.0240706354,
-0.061499387,
-0.036417,
0.0216073226,
-0.0006610724,
0.0027537504,
-0.0459114723,
-0.0039304825,
-0.0083572119,
0.003205769,
0.0563947782,
-0.02119698,
0.009915188,
-0.0012984159,
0.0149316248,
0.0066539603,
0.0336177982,
-0.0187684391,
0.0417425856,
0.0641659498,
0.0304652303,
-0.0446803421,
-0.0099471807,
0.0141903199,
0.0186196826,
0.0718618408,
0.026194714,
0.001801886,
0.0066313911,
0.0041522575,
0.023773035,
-0.0219243597,
-0.0186553337,
0.0180951525,
0.0672096685,
-0.0026128048,
0.0203649364,
0.0204337705,
0.0571681485,
-0.0582113527,
-0.0406149365,
0.0155228712,
-0.0075560058,
-0.0688027591,
-0.047051318,
0.0321175344,
0.0048146872,
-0.067660369,
-0.0260929223,
0.0225525927,
-0.0138330394,
0.064131543,
-0.0525816083,
0.0344078913,
0.0359897241,
-0.0001121668,
0.0500395931,
-0.0135865426,
-0.0258238409,
0.0154406838,
-0.0383627936,
0.064948149,
0.0191354658,
0.0373762697,
-0.0656299666,
-0.0096233059,
-0.004308641,
-0.0295392945,
-0.0216036011,
0.0206192657,
-0.0324259251,
0.0194017924,
-0.0325801447,
-0.0110890782,
-0.0121628065,
0.0064425892,
-0.037317194,
-0.023228908,
0.0204463657,
0.0011730391,
-0.0989364907,
0.0066024587,
0.0175459422,
0.038980525,
-0.0010285061,
0.0660469681,
0.0404031314,
-0.002520195,
0.0476508066,
0.0453257859,
-0.0126572233,
0.0433065034,
-0.0033425265,
-0.0232543424,
-0.0131481616,
-0.0260684453,
-0.0741654336,
0.0091453101,
-0.0051143686,
-0.0373907052,
-0.0182126537,
-0.0079639778,
-0.0183296353,
0.0392092578,
-0.0464576334,
0.0377737507,
-0.0612793379,
-0.0276223533,
0.0281732772,
0.0091118254,
-0.0066990089,
0.0721054822,
0.0147929406,
-0.0378825851,
0.0246101636,
-0.0075102798,
0.0122271394,
0.0211337805,
-0.0071089906,
-0.0607928522,
-0.0670618489,
0.0099012321,
0.0268835053,
0.0302776825,
-0.0243679434,
0.0071558901,
-0.0796717331,
0.0057865474,
-0.0339068882,
-0.0396059193,
0.0283900797,
0.0368901081,
0.0261074584,
-0.0208397917,
-0.0101540312,
0.0159236174,
-0.0405017585,
0.004962177,
0.0118298177,
0.0133825215,
0.0053685424,
-0.0138867442,
0.0257466584,
-0.0343625434,
0.0037406031,
0.0176304728,
-0.0170023367,
-0.0529127866,
0.0277812462,
-0.0355880447,
-0.0221364535,
-0.0065749632,
0.0141628636,
0.0242754743,
-0.0339006186,
0.002902098,
0.0020484633,
0.0153701864,
0.0416991338,
0.0160354096,
0.0215854142,
-0.0671665967,
0.0124163534,
-0.0556285009,
0.0302318633,
-0.0296096001,
-0.0099336775,
0.1112257987,
0.045229096,
0.0552075058,
-0.0240793638,
-0.0443752632,
-0.0542567223,
0.0001803664,
-0.0187429599,
-0.0781651437,
0.0315082222,
0.0213553477,
0.0410844423,
0.0145930713,
-0.0608592182,
0.0616390258,
0.0132112578,
-0.0185832921,
-0.0823934376,
-0.0404630862,
-0.0337021016,
0.0358488113,
-0.0440321304,
0.0577346161,
0.0447492637,
-0.0436734594,
0.0296459571,
-0.0011887029,
-0.037761312,
0.0191012137,
0.0844975859,
-0.0208370294,
0.0173104648,
0.0564254113,
-0.0204771198,
-0.0231573358,
-0.0865766108,
0.0267812759,
-0.0233416781,
0.0556048825,
0.0211189073,
0.0245901011,
0.018588338,
-0.0182436164,
0.0685496703,
0.0365103558,
-0.051737152,
-0.028630564,
0.0218422953,
0.0256012939,
-0.0145596117,
-0.0192539021,
0.0051619331,
0.0097736036,
0.0783481225,
-0.0004440444,
-0.0846442282,
-0.0188110229,
0.0293274969,
0.0211972427,
0.0051494767,
0.0344470553,
0.0488146283,
0.0574576221,
0.0429193899,
-0.0327649824,
0.0808274448,
0.0669111237,
-0.0616801046,
0.019233387,
-0.0213216729,
0.0041434332,
0.0362829007,
-0.0174410921,
-0.0177352224,
-0.0556788482,
-0.0409540534,
0.0278354399,
0.0143148396,
-0.0312385056,
0.004229561,
-0.0857868567,
0.0389082357,
-0.0099425232,
-0.0573012419,
0.0005922769,
-0.0799778998,
-0.0050217547,
-0.0166528951,
-0.0444079675,
-0.0287669729,
0.029929338,
-0.046297498,
-0.0043901335,
-0.0742261559,
-0.0311606787,
0.0058754454,
-0.01849976,
0.0389881507,
0.0066545564,
0.0352633446,
0.032075759,
0.0239287484,
-0.0243971534,
-0.0607243851,
0.0292590968,
-0.0522839576,
0.0235174894,
-0.0239109881,
0.0290918481,
-0.0305864178,
0.0538144447,
-0.074693501,
-0.05884929,
0.0441654921,
0.0761477351,
-0.0380712077,
0.0197678059,
-0.0197206326,
-0.0141543821,
0.0609955974,
0.088957563,
-0.0109553505,
-0.0276316237,
0.0594688356,
-0.0051750736,
0.0334412977,
0.0151964147,
0.0086714067,
-0.0251811966,
0.0079211453,
0.0061092814,
-0.0504696034,
-0.0198253505,
0.0642244294,
0.0225647464,
0.028445838,
0.0159191582,
0.0344282761,
-0.0525026135,
-0.0443451144,
0.0054652011,
-0.0251485985,
0.0027790824,
-0.0193382688,
-0.0416685455,
0.0370912589,
-0.0417981669,
0.0170635581,
-0.0038502943,
-0.05640468,
-0.019960355,
-0.0411798507,
0.008389865,
0.0038994974,
0.0770311728,
-0.0720995739,
0.0272410642,
0.0149771227,
0.0185703412,
-0.035372939,
-0.0233553778,
0.0053544072,
0.0324769802,
0.0217376575,
0.0284446497,
-0.0264870506,
0.0259066615,
0.0227719378,
0.0128432484,
-0.0943722352,
-0.0727957487,
0.050118085,
0.0048379982,
0.0863592327,
0.0002761864,
-0.0019377017,
-0.044228211,
-0.0249879509,
0.0164401736,
-0.0035270869,
-0.0044147545,
-0.0056846472,
0.0464796387,
0.0277438611,
-0.027755741,
0.0842951015,
-0.0253050625,
-0.0049369237,
-0.0202873461,
0.0014179867,
0.0118269809,
0.0284777228,
-0.0275944471,
-0.0095364992,
0.0040505971,
-0.0074034678,
-0.035936486,
0.01940272,
-0.0079331147,
0.0713417605,
0.0137071284,
-0.0192228984,
-0.0131447343,
0.0811364651,
-0.0136278393,
0.0136471437,
-0.0127637479,
-0.0136089958,
-0.0179803558,
-0.0380557664,
0.0344587378,
-0.0432629213,
0.0167459194,
-0.0125674177,
0.0745262802,
-0.018144777,
-0.0538762994,
0.0087253675,
-0.0082325442,
-0.028204143,
0.0038624362,
0.0365435146,
-0.1250601113,
0.0347820073,
0.0193101168,
-0.0262497719,
-0.0605584085,
0.0205411315,
0.0368847996,
0.0579472445,
-0.035242036,
0.0236161985,
-0.0054168981,
0.0116743334,
0.0032006823,
-0.0448536687,
-0.0016173722,
0.0235121958,
0.0826908424,
0.0517677367,
-0.023691779,
-0.0072957594,
-0.0522918478,
-0.0365486108,
-0.0083359256,
-0.0087822266,
-0.0264357068,
-6.300849554e-33,
0.0162629299,
-0.0032945171,
-0.0072826995,
-0.0411320738,
0.0181898866,
0.0127783958,
-0.0424812771,
-0.0098424964,
0.037080843,
-0.0034057235,
0.0176345035,
0.002324126,
-0.0068044765,
0.0201091785,
-0.0034206756,
0.0090744086,
0.02999961,
0.0072643291,
-0.0215942506,
0.0377782993,
0.0596417561,
0.0007916591,
-0.0005912305,
-0.0577733368,
-0.0451613255,
0.0125743393,
-0.0169684105,
0.0456086993,
0.0304030869,
0.0515421554,
-0.0181140769,
0.030033296,
0.03120647,
-0.0417630784,
-0.0074841953,
-0.0010945398,
-0.0458164625,
-0.0444010161,
-0.0270132069,
-0.0396521054,
-0.0393077843,
-0.0070676859,
-0.008502299,
0.0055637956,
-0.0123270312,
0.0397855267,
0.0397060029,
0.0093629044,
-0.0135529302,
0.0542420857,
-0.0391558297,
0.0023839413,
-0.0684453696,
-0.0095990179,
-0.0105409641,
0.0194680598,
0.00447211,
0.0084654167,
-0.0846912935,
0.0519646518,
-0.0577568412,
-0.0185091831,
-0.0068715229,
-0.0023149995,
-0.0049294285,
0.0660477206,
0.0140038058,
0.0006074858,
-0.0108737219,
0.025665665,
-0.0030869911,
0.0656747594,
-0.0336760767,
0.030097099,
-0.0101348879,
0.0109760137,
-0.0280606151,
0.0848550051,
0.0243457705,
-0.0480189212,
0.041777648,
0.0404827073,
-0.0743640661,
-0.0313918777,
0.0250661951,
-0.0089311544,
-0.0381288268,
-0.0073296777,
0.0137882233,
0.037120726,
-0.0596788041,
0.01831338,
0.0100759724,
-0.0411067829,
0.0179669727,
-0.0068996507,
0.01727405,
0.0234621074,
0.0133474572,
-0.0023869739,
-0.0672852173,
-0.0432048999,
0.0532610044,
-0.0042301868,
0.0084807342,
0.0183129515,
0.0051446008,
0.0047530322,
-0.0157799963,
0.0057648355,
0.0186503734,
-0.0273907855,
-0.0570760146,
-0.0187221821,
0.0093287211,
0.0203402303,
-0.0151576977,
0.0937574133,
0.0372842327,
0.0070892647,
-0.0332752205,
-0.0725205466,
0.0051180031,
-0.0172218326,
-0.012953639,
-0.018605493,
0.0127606485,
-0.0314407311,
0.0298407525,
-0.0622477084,
-0.0236315858,
0.0024877093,
2.636e-7,
0.031477429,
0.0190979894,
0.0106707374,
0.0241366625,
0.0081976345,
0.0830095932,
-0.0030543911,
0.0464445725,
-0.0096482681,
-0.0011923524,
0.0439255796,
0.0388996601,
-0.0170814339,
0.0001942268,
-0.0624948032,
0.0900439546,
0.0084685953,
0.0103222737,
-0.0763914809,
0.0203289744,
0.0742209256,
0.090532437,
0.0159825739,
-0.0200085714,
0.0173649788,
-0.0142954225,
0.0035989804,
-0.0073511009,
0.0152310021,
0.0216381401,
0.0018609195,
0.0020528834,
0.0021060528,
0.0088629806,
-0.0258024335,
0.0106099667,
-0.0122784339,
0.0187014397,
-0.0235317498,
-0.0388136134,
0.0166852083,
0.0170082022,
0.0107314941,
-0.0256378036,
0.0895517468,
-0.03230666,
-0.0114030242,
0.0448572598,
0.0209914092,
0.0412004739,
-0.0514398478,
0.0198010672,
-0.0247809105,
0.0225875489,
0.0101584513,
0.0305124223,
-0.0095032007,
-0.0694725364,
0.0357062332,
-0.0169286244,
-0.0156140151,
0.0074407295,
-0.0252114125,
0.0324900039,
0.0182329658,
-0.061607711,
0.029750688,
2.143395711e-34,
-0.0211553536,
0.0061400319,
-0.0066876579,
-0.0277301669,
0.0085456697,
-0.0234128684,
-0.0377708338,
-0.0092563787,
0.0316445902,
-0.0569906197,
-0.0064942739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09102v1 | Solving Math Word Problems by Combining Language Models With Symbolic Solvers | 2023-04-16T04:16:06 | 2023-04-16T04:16:06 | Joy He-Yueya, Gabriel Poesia, Rose E. Wang, Noah D. Goodman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatically generating high-quality step-by-step solutions to math word
problems has many applications in education. Recently, combining large language
models (LLMs) with external tools to perform complex reasoning and calculation
has emerged as a promising direction for solving math word problems, but prior
approaches such as Program-Aided Language model (PAL) are biased towards simple
procedural problems and less effective for problems that require declarative
reasoning. We propose an approach that combines an LLM that can incrementally
formalize word problems as a set of variables and equations with an external
symbolic solver that can solve the equations. Our approach achieves comparable
accuracy to the original PAL on the GSM8K benchmark of math word problems and
outperforms PAL by an absolute 20% on ALGEBRA, a new dataset of more
challenging word problems extracted from Algebra textbooks. Our work highlights
the benefits of using declarative and incremental representations when
interfacing with an external tool for solving complex math word problems. Our
data and prompts are publicly available at
https://github.com/joyheyueya/declarative-math-word-problem. | [
-0.0062934593,
0.0723983571,
-0.0030218465,
0.0209189113,
-0.0638437048,
0.0036668421,
0.0264517255,
0.0112449965,
-0.0372217782,
-0.0323771648,
0.0603316426,
-0.0080230627,
0.0087173618,
0.0265781693,
0.0213933904,
-0.0313044079,
0.0228471104,
-0.0243618786,
0.0409209318,
0.0032678931,
-0.0025470322,
0.0074250954,
-0.0328319184,
-0.0346351229,
-0.0327445082,
-0.0725751072,
0.0012350406,
-0.0626910552,
0.0008913769,
-0.0150133502,
-0.0052432134,
0.0231540911,
0.0231234916,
0.0517319366,
0.0000021638,
-0.056442719,
-0.0200948603,
0.0244374592,
-0.0410362147,
0.0550555997,
0.031783212,
0.0083690407,
0.0036631594,
0.0253771935,
-0.0535656214,
0.0148410415,
0.0004341938,
-0.0047335266,
0.0783119202,
0.0398558043,
-0.0084550856,
-0.0043985429,
0.0039416789,
0.0090670306,
0.019359801,
-0.0506287068,
0.0125593022,
0.0777770132,
0.0137304394,
-0.0036783994,
-0.0627306923,
0.0506378375,
0.0369530134,
-0.0069720508,
-0.0041981922,
-0.0433727503,
-0.0336148031,
0.024337694,
-0.0281368922,
0.0391209871,
-0.0167669635,
-0.0015142759,
-0.0124516366,
-0.0236672405,
-0.031335976,
0.0318486392,
-0.055295147,
0.0444135591,
-0.0206177607,
-0.0240383409,
-0.0026372217,
-0.0139626414,
0.0205426887,
0.0215865392,
-0.035870105,
0.0531160012,
0.0272037815,
-0.0318612643,
-0.0106659858,
-0.0244756974,
-0.0551643856,
-0.0536092483,
0.0608460158,
0.0905035585,
0.0091988873,
0.0534438677,
-0.033047758,
-0.0551009588,
-0.0138014313,
-0.0649443269,
0.0290214438,
0.0830587074,
0.0542680845,
0.0435026623,
-0.010487237,
0.0815142393,
-0.0074781389,
0.0094184438,
-0.033259958,
0.0505078919,
-0.0196080375,
-0.0240172297,
-0.0546475202,
0.0344106071,
-0.0022453184,
-0.0027897898,
-0.0256783105,
-0.0036582518,
-0.0119723799,
0.0256636068,
0.0053054206,
-0.0267572161,
0.0055215792,
-0.0405990109,
0.0011877673,
0.0187028982,
-0.040028315,
0.0045244787,
-0.0255554114,
0.0192045718,
0.0026447389,
-0.0086781541,
0.0020113955,
-0.0205013491,
0.032823246,
0.1019396335,
-0.0051207086,
0.0110787144,
0.0154406205,
-0.0233087279,
0.0279843081,
-0.0999028087,
-0.0328166932,
-0.0945687443,
0.0621875003,
0.0347659215,
-0.0272057448,
-0.0486383997,
0.0340985917,
0.0071061226,
0.0652461946,
0.0469670743,
0.0191082917,
-0.0029475642,
0.047861401,
0.0083342865,
-0.0126494821,
0.0483697467,
0.0699932799,
-0.0060373098,
0.0024152752,
-0.0170585494,
0.0288525373,
0.0661558062,
0.0043526068,
0.0063301232,
-0.0624998882,
-0.0069604157,
0.0392736048,
0.0453102328,
-0.0503306091,
0.0703304261,
-0.0209269486,
0.0116242999,
0.0000193124,
0.0605803616,
0.0047599436,
0.0141897649,
0.0110693267,
-0.0052357116,
0.058408577,
-0.0237754155,
-0.0463025048,
0.0277695991,
-0.0523442626,
-0.0121188704,
0.0034910748,
0.0630019978,
0.0221824776,
-0.0682018846,
-0.0417027511,
0.0284873117,
-0.0002108783,
0.0217651483,
0.0751733109,
-0.0452963375,
-0.0013481624,
0.0467334762,
0.0178498775,
-0.0381444171,
0.0142254857,
-0.0087166745,
0.0457607955,
0.033336401,
0.099792406,
-0.0238363389,
-0.0000862412,
-0.0124244988,
0.010068086,
0.0090527469,
0.0073901243,
0.0066931574,
-0.0266408697,
-0.0425458215,
-0.0009050862,
-0.0222651027,
0.0030681617,
-0.045565933,
0.0799579248,
0.0171018057,
0.0372800939,
-0.0308691207,
0.000598943,
0.0374184549,
-0.0646200404,
-0.0367426872,
-0.0353990197,
-0.005888531,
-0.0158386901,
0.0048058173,
0.0353178196,
0.0462792031,
-0.001774165,
-0.0393199623,
-0.0332940482,
-0.0383516029,
-0.0425395444,
-0.0092039956,
0.0936258435,
-0.043400012,
-0.0174417309,
-0.0253645051,
-0.0452115461,
-0.0067137526,
0.0809754804,
-0.0447723381,
0.0240066908,
-0.0007006127,
0.0530667491,
0.0011105932,
-0.0262836404,
-0.0010350636,
0.0619291291,
0.0203450378,
0.0418925621,
-0.0014572334,
0.0211455785,
0.0010694492,
0.0308383871,
0.0354590751,
-0.0076892897,
0.0085481647,
-0.0041149273,
-0.0382826626,
0.0006759225,
-0.0285667218,
-0.0033532705,
0.0035442058,
0.021687286,
0.0276522003,
0.0386063308,
0.0058125532,
-0.0205955599,
-0.0009595009,
0.0153354434,
-0.040461652,
0.0193747021,
0.0000890756,
-0.0480670407,
0.0092070606,
0.0018640625,
-0.0441670306,
-0.0608045831,
-0.0295689777,
-0.054773625,
0.0254085902,
0.0279341675,
-0.0097107887,
-0.0424466617,
0.0387953594,
-0.0341247804,
0.0290174149,
0.0000392192,
-0.0085070161,
-0.0225656033,
-0.042475611,
0.0485049635,
0.0346787684,
-0.0116753522,
0.0493119135,
0.0363571569,
-0.0769429058,
-0.0631445125,
-0.0184832998,
-0.005887026,
0.0014092567,
0.0231572092,
-0.0493261144,
-0.020572247,
0.077472195,
-0.0052493555,
-0.0237698797,
0.0019222498,
0.0591746345,
-0.0452729389,
0.0377081223,
-0.0653818995,
-0.0160926953,
-0.0105272653,
0.0235087611,
-0.0025226297,
-0.0516565107,
0.0782476887,
-0.0212043077,
-0.0033723866,
-0.0467058457,
0.0009542649,
-0.0891043618,
0.0171947088,
0.0050387443,
-0.0032704228,
-0.0622562394,
-0.0017791549,
-0.0285185687,
-0.0050463672,
0.0469654948,
-0.0274690054,
0.0674604177,
-0.0735612437,
0.0139853945,
0.0035480771,
-0.0098457439,
-0.0125363441,
0.0052071512,
-0.0071736891,
0.0126685603,
-0.0127669526,
-0.0221158322,
-0.0106395409,
0.0065052882,
0.0314549096,
0.0188708343,
-0.0390499495,
-0.028309308,
-0.0250890665,
0.0129951714,
0.0405969396,
-0.013627368,
0.0283888597,
-0.0508134924,
0.025439715,
0.0081362557,
0.0710837245,
-0.0074616652,
0.0045938264,
0.0493341237,
0.0204963144,
-0.0421083122,
0.0125911655,
0.051558964,
-0.0040303157,
-0.0847113132,
-0.0090941275,
0.0902483314,
0.0704054534,
-0.0103492066,
-0.0156433098,
-0.074516654,
-0.0442762226,
0.0267056338,
0.0449970961,
-0.1077886224,
-0.0118755121,
0.0084760236,
-0.025773922,
0.0234889202,
-0.0211245399,
-0.0335691087,
-0.0957132578,
-0.015420584,
0.0536787659,
-0.0269704834,
0.0203226916,
-0.0113636591,
-0.0271568391,
0.002853866,
-0.0118710231,
0.0263035242,
-0.0186550561,
0.0174300112,
-0.0037726499,
0.003296979,
0.0336893424,
0.0134144733,
0.0147992745,
-0.0285405647,
0.006934491,
-0.0141713396,
-0.0327026397,
-0.0763757676,
0.0752061158,
0.0504896194,
-0.0523147359,
0.0030880072,
-0.034733329,
0.0109307524,
-0.0014466463,
-0.0273199584,
0.0381980315,
-0.0551639758,
-0.0467430167,
0.068768777,
0.0875063986,
0.0186269935,
0.0258847233,
-0.0141418371,
0.0054200049,
0.0000157799,
0.0363409109,
0.0167299174,
-0.0212725718,
-0.031663496,
-0.0327020213,
-0.0364105515,
0.0032067366,
-0.0109001948,
0.0018436917,
0.0327964909,
0.0158117693,
-0.0125749204,
0.0098291403,
0.0964729264,
0.0295651853,
0.0263529457,
-0.0179676227,
0.0276087876,
-0.0078087104,
-0.0610211343,
0.0230208617,
-0.0345924757,
0.0624992996,
-0.0476393178,
0.0339266881,
-0.0450089797,
-0.0093044033,
-0.0132181486,
0.051022321,
-0.1144771203,
-0.0646381155,
-0.0036223133,
0.0303406809,
0.0189656205,
-0.0500757881,
-0.0046062153,
0.0068889325,
-0.0159372259,
0.0014229449,
-0.04823016,
0.0187371261,
-0.0477461293,
0.0396602452,
0.0230753105,
-0.0251444634,
0.0207455587,
0.0033524868,
-0.0005269877,
0.0638177916,
-0.0052808728,
0.025144415,
0.0201572515,
0.0579225458,
-0.0433370769,
0.0216898117,
-0.0038667719,
-0.0044500357,
0.0035912464,
-0.0655054748,
-0.0277173687,
-0.0389491804,
-0.0001127931,
-0.0282124132,
-0.0411512256,
0.0147120887,
-0.0219352655,
0.0023656138,
0.0139813013,
0.0261870362,
0.0700933114,
-0.0079169413,
-0.0028415164,
0.0793662146,
-0.0547663458,
0.0326680839,
0.0047389828,
-0.0319840237,
0.0444648005,
-0.0136878267,
0.074371621,
-0.0058994689,
0.028589258,
-0.0784283951,
-0.0411376059,
0.0230902098,
-0.1043986529,
-0.0467526279,
0.0458772555,
-0.0034641381,
0.0160370842,
-0.0230597649,
-0.0312658623,
-0.0266045723,
0.0057270173,
0.0035847174,
0.0217870511,
-0.0297686942,
0.0223675352,
0.0553040281,
0.0356460996,
-0.0392635763,
0.0231821779,
-0.028580755,
0.0149517935,
0.0163597725,
-0.0078481594,
-0.0163284708,
-0.0257794652,
0.0086315069,
0.021734396,
0.0217135362,
0.0083073517,
-0.0954616144,
-0.0538782515,
-0.0325182863,
0.0091905976,
-0.0227683205,
0.0182917025,
0.028077485,
0.04509544,
-0.0249371342,
0.0022690466,
0.0088863997,
0.0668126568,
-0.0215458628,
-0.0520436987,
0.0115750711,
-5.780248086e-33,
-0.0481677651,
-0.0754458159,
0.0493933707,
0.0069127791,
0.0005575014,
-0.0100771012,
-0.0232846681,
0.0320112295,
0.0339463539,
-0.0208021775,
-0.0048529613,
0.0207960904,
-0.0039863675,
0.006010144,
-0.0080447961,
0.0208139643,
-0.0283876546,
-0.0064676339,
-0.0543366782,
-0.0504071042,
0.0105329184,
0.0048608962,
0.0473114625,
-0.0164647494,
0.0138568385,
0.0170173086,
-0.0004697932,
0.022652816,
-0.0225389376,
0.0412853025,
-0.0183330644,
0.0307143405,
-0.0076282201,
-0.0066971695,
-0.0051375348,
0.0099238744,
-0.0326461717,
-0.0224864613,
0.0335399844,
0.0038609807,
-0.037071377,
-0.042852141,
0.0112396469,
-0.0131615754,
-0.0324729197,
-0.0186250284,
0.0283892639,
-0.0345141701,
-0.0113748619,
-0.0125510395,
-0.0490767173,
0.0178922713,
-0.0378088653,
0.0119176833,
0.0142152561,
-0.0258634016,
-0.0260062385,
-0.0111612948,
0.0193121359,
0.011328985,
0.0707516,
0.0136561329,
0.0409407727,
-0.0129549745,
-0.0235261004,
0.0059157945,
-0.0172832329,
-0.0920047686,
-0.0287497658,
0.0092844022,
0.0074909874,
0.0110305846,
0.0894903168,
0.0000978869,
0.0684983507,
0.0278229211,
-0.0378956273,
-0.0085278656,
0.0236194171,
0.0176315103,
0.0121195614,
0.004316926,
-0.0302703679,
-0.0323304795,
-0.0502621382,
0.0377527662,
-0.0662267879,
-0.0147236995,
0.018353397,
-0.0406381041,
0.0098923119,
-0.0251483954,
0.003964778,
-0.0138845565,
-0.0331502259,
0.0523669086,
0.0426218994,
0.0190335792,
-0.0060932422,
0.0329130664,
-0.0231603589,
-0.0000063223,
-0.01863515,
0.010882115,
0.0245316029,
0.0047639501,
-0.0298075825,
0.0123448726,
-0.041386459,
0.0039088726,
-0.067647621,
-0.017875189,
0.0475768633,
0.0020101087,
0.0256900135,
0.0058543878,
-0.0134993587,
0.0076662023,
-0.0169130825,
-0.0514360666,
0.021030074,
0.0210547149,
0.004884392,
0.021694148,
-0.0134828277,
-0.0155781228,
-0.0156130604,
-0.0039447742,
0.0411901735,
-0.0391272232,
0.003508724,
-0.0222589392,
2.863e-7,
0.0492852256,
0.0720056146,
0.03917538,
0.0335250609,
0.0034675188,
-0.0139941331,
-0.0331247747,
-0.0428902954,
-0.00551529,
-0.0192465466,
-0.0016788606,
0.066261515,
0.0408988558,
0.0439688191,
0.006823448,
0.0365234315,
-0.004975128,
-0.0153442388,
-0.0817061365,
0.0294353683,
0.0705519691,
0.0220291968,
0.050062187,
0.007041119,
-0.0431333669,
-0.0293197595,
0.0225668903,
-0.0181145426,
-0.0072003342,
0.0182096232,
-0.0377906784,
-0.0137975393,
0.0137182595,
-0.0174695011,
-0.0076882271,
0.0416647606,
0.0426893234,
0.0853575915,
0.0351834968,
0.0267527811,
-0.0169583019,
-0.0362732746,
-0.0361794755,
-0.0086243162,
0.0456586741,
-0.0463918857,
-0.0219401885,
-0.0054388898,
-0.019537203,
-0.057172209,
0.0125536676,
-0.0067193443,
0.0550843999,
0.0453698486,
0.0159087218,
0.0018672023,
-0.0079335291,
-0.0683478713,
-0.0473022126,
0.0089927344,
-0.0350372232,
0.0063747587,
-0.0401330218,
0.0208559316,
0.0180032179,
-0.0263350494,
0.0042485548,
2.788251937e-34,
0.0536396429,
-0.0247630645,
0.0377514698,
0.0489568524,
0.040556673,
-0.0067126397,
-0.0305542294,
0.0408365726,
0.0194955748,
-0.0786212459,
-0.0062501105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07687v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07687v2 | MLRegTest: A Benchmark for the Machine Learning of Regular Languages | 2023-04-16T03:49:50 | 2023-11-09T01:29:24 | Sam van der Poel, Dakotah Lambert, Kalina Kostyszyn, Tiantian Gao, Rahul Verma, Derek Andersen, Joanne Chau, Emily Peterson, Cody St. Clair, Paul Fodor, Chihiro Shibata, Jeffrey Heinz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.FL | Evaluating machine learning (ML) systems on their ability to learn known
classifiers allows fine-grained examination of the patterns they can learn,
which builds confidence when they are applied to the learning of unknown
classifiers. This article presents a new benchmark for ML systems on sequence
classification called MLRegTest, which contains training, development, and test
sets from 1,800 regular languages. Different kinds of formal languages
represent different kinds of long-distance dependencies, and correctly
identifying long-distance dependencies in sequences is a known challenge for ML
systems to generalize successfully. MLRegTest organizes its languages according
to their logical complexity (monadic second order, first order, propositional,
or monomial expressions) and the kind of logical literals (string, tier-string,
subsequence, or combinations thereof). The logical complexity and choice of
literal provides a systematic way to understand different kinds of
long-distance dependencies in regular languages, and therefore to understand
the capacities of different ML systems to learn such long-distance
dependencies. Finally, the performance of different neural networks (simple
RNN, LSTM, GRU, transformer) on MLRegTest is examined. The main conclusion is
that their performance depends significantly on the kind of test set, the class
of language, and the neural network architecture. | [
0.0292471424,
0.0903179571,
-0.0296145864,
0.0301430915,
-0.0811247751,
0.0119220726,
-0.0132159432,
0.0259283315,
0.012355159,
-0.0423709713,
0.0717713162,
-0.0431790873,
0.0542098098,
0.0600873046,
0.0076210066,
-0.0567529202,
0.0288071707,
-0.0119036781,
0.0041586258,
0.0127102407,
-0.0147736305,
-0.0165050402,
-0.0167620163,
0.0411075018,
-0.0443253964,
0.0127719091,
-0.0097411824,
-0.0261020772,
-0.0037011676,
-0.0314014703,
0.0060040993,
0.0417818986,
0.0163030233,
0.0784100816,
0.0000018987,
-0.0719403401,
-0.0074267681,
-0.0406982265,
-0.0100196218,
0.0068616117,
-0.0431573503,
-0.0104908273,
-0.0038446486,
0.0461401753,
-0.0449552014,
-0.0088095712,
0.0410626084,
0.0150828557,
0.0218775086,
0.1099830791,
-0.0178606939,
-0.0474331751,
0.0348011069,
-0.0453830063,
0.0046523674,
-0.0104983281,
0.0177020915,
-0.0217590127,
0.0048457631,
-0.0674803928,
-0.0316043831,
-0.0024547803,
0.0267094895,
0.0346019939,
-0.058683265,
0.0151702603,
-0.0181553457,
-0.0236023311,
0.0104207173,
0.0535599478,
-0.0879846886,
-0.0187985431,
0.0036293934,
-0.0062987744,
0.0034787022,
0.001885175,
0.0294283424,
0.0192791242,
-0.0237396229,
0.0013302306,
0.0129534584,
-0.0105644446,
0.0534552373,
-0.0231497325,
-0.0849525705,
0.0615420118,
-0.0000125416,
-0.0251354519,
-0.0003819644,
-0.027556926,
-0.0162410401,
-0.0748038217,
0.0242262948,
0.040123079,
-0.0039164084,
0.0015695115,
-0.005779529,
-0.0352906175,
0.0227730926,
-0.0299690459,
-0.0019599481,
0.0284144282,
-0.0015809387,
-0.0005876719,
-0.0522801168,
0.0666087195,
0.0206823163,
0.0029372913,
0.008002731,
0.0490443408,
-0.0581084341,
0.0205088723,
-0.01504583,
0.038202744,
-0.0047853426,
0.0037199941,
-0.0651141554,
-0.0171412528,
-0.0038746984,
0.0500102937,
-0.0539471731,
-0.0064418819,
0.0111853164,
0.0281639323,
-0.0260464046,
0.0110070352,
-0.0377427936,
-0.0125320628,
0.0053755376,
-0.0627480149,
0.0103119975,
0.0213213116,
0.0453716293,
0.0015377925,
0.0076670288,
0.0754590333,
0.0366522409,
-0.0589045659,
-0.0139115127,
-0.0267654397,
-0.0086415969,
-0.0817246586,
-0.0044508027,
-0.0345236063,
0.000400261,
0.0123380991,
0.0099844299,
-0.0399220996,
0.0214749556,
-0.0102128768,
0.0215614401,
0.0533820912,
0.0263388325,
-0.0517913699,
-0.0055152872,
0.0151397865,
0.0091705285,
0.0065001491,
0.0383340679,
0.0570012666,
0.023441555,
-0.0587766916,
0.0413257629,
0.0373040363,
-0.0103410557,
-0.0451288298,
-0.0387790427,
-0.01905296,
0.0100847604,
0.0464723594,
-0.0072956397,
0.0666288808,
-0.0088609867,
-0.0333228819,
0.0116258934,
0.0300239604,
0.0658525005,
0.0229810886,
0.0583307743,
0.0314028077,
0.0136093684,
0.05283048,
-0.0121255312,
-0.0227915645,
-0.0267317574,
0.0187736768,
-0.010694311,
0.0320873186,
-0.0108863749,
-0.0493947715,
-0.0421697348,
-0.087472409,
-0.0040286677,
-0.0343528949,
0.0489309505,
-0.0278240237,
-0.0738495365,
0.0273876339,
0.0063733747,
-0.0293318145,
-0.0279445667,
-0.0086602997,
0.0458332859,
0.0024169399,
0.0038702264,
-0.0504747853,
-0.0363608897,
-0.0331834145,
-0.0623170845,
0.0103172874,
0.023563873,
0.0093811806,
0.0454291068,
-0.0308905989,
-0.0080337329,
0.0583011322,
0.0065011601,
0.062841177,
-0.038186878,
0.0302066151,
0.0322045647,
0.0305499285,
-0.0539109819,
0.0242831036,
-0.0387030467,
-0.0302930921,
0.0229536369,
0.0333101787,
0.0673400089,
0.0033388948,
-0.0083342008,
0.0149722183,
0.0590080395,
-0.0550504923,
-0.0323962383,
0.0054313904,
-0.0746487603,
-0.0223739352,
0.039508611,
-0.0163017046,
-0.0139103942,
0.0558899567,
-0.0427200422,
-0.0573938265,
0.0532058552,
-0.0659575388,
0.0185497794,
-0.0157900061,
0.017273847,
0.0132152475,
0.0578766912,
-0.0118250456,
0.0464364961,
-0.0259786267,
0.041893892,
-0.0219818074,
-0.0389822945,
0.0446007848,
-0.0169138387,
-0.0098686814,
0.0107850134,
-0.0288210381,
-0.0097570522,
0.022337677,
-0.0151232472,
-0.0180237424,
-0.0060245721,
-0.0117336884,
-0.0358175784,
-0.046722725,
0.0703026205,
-0.0492214374,
0.0098897889,
-0.000501606,
-0.0362406038,
-0.0438400246,
0.0236320104,
0.0100598587,
-0.0180568043,
0.0516510978,
0.0350013487,
-0.0677334294,
-0.030121658,
-0.0105145741,
-0.0103823207,
0.0880222023,
0.0062347585,
-0.0113750584,
-0.0294776987,
-0.0535652302,
-0.029397551,
0.0500320457,
-0.0095171025,
-0.0467825793,
-0.0001050755,
-0.0204669647,
0.0106185758,
0.0153807774,
0.0294493902,
-0.0299324449,
0.0444275849,
0.0104594184,
-0.0158531778,
0.0115802325,
-0.0215023421,
0.0459299795,
-0.0545889921,
0.0024943957,
0.0026403463,
0.0865092278,
-0.0261258055,
-0.0081681302,
-0.0237031225,
0.0131192189,
0.0293530021,
0.0018626691,
0.0012925041,
-0.0082106218,
-0.0304731783,
0.0470373929,
0.0061617936,
-0.0585882068,
0.0343347341,
-0.0364617854,
0.0032075515,
-0.0245434195,
-0.0148247182,
-0.0588458292,
0.0780103505,
0.0603601076,
-0.0035829928,
0.0228347182,
-0.0450512171,
8.773e-7,
0.0097941039,
-0.0115933511,
-0.0236975607,
0.0214279648,
-0.0528738461,
0.0099747684,
-0.044435773,
-0.0141990436,
-0.0524848439,
0.0333750732,
-0.01263081,
-0.0198736209,
0.0004033207,
-0.0383873507,
-0.0331543423,
0.0093880203,
-0.0265936516,
0.0801301077,
0.0144345323,
0.0198382605,
-0.0043060328,
0.0698493719,
0.0091771074,
0.0137845082,
0.0122010009,
0.0283088405,
0.0139827617,
0.0327765979,
-0.0007717527,
0.0199412573,
-0.079964377,
-0.0046565696,
0.023621127,
-0.0814172179,
-0.0174759738,
0.0593903959,
-0.0345788077,
-0.0718934909,
-0.0009123385,
0.1130148098,
0.0322277471,
-0.0203276314,
0.052217003,
0.0391752273,
0.0292993952,
0.0121295219,
0.0050693983,
-0.0842939094,
-0.0130212717,
-0.0014546029,
-0.0201247428,
-0.0330261774,
-0.0350907296,
0.0138041731,
-0.0860095769,
-0.0215439685,
-0.0115391202,
-0.0726607144,
-0.0354109481,
-0.0278339852,
-0.0288457144,
-0.0053143837,
0.0205665268,
-0.009798279,
-0.0257620048,
-0.0144110117,
0.0372278057,
-0.0965230763,
-0.0655718297,
0.0141468002,
-0.040472392,
-0.0141919805,
0.0434805714,
0.033583872,
-0.0355927944,
-0.0337228552,
0.0381318405,
0.0495883599,
0.0434067547,
-0.0310924351,
0.0393649414,
0.0334220044,
-0.0180270709,
0.0153908338,
-0.0196062624,
-0.0520950779,
0.0370257646,
0.0323492512,
0.0861610845,
0.0031093922,
-0.0377158001,
-0.0167533811,
-0.0310692713,
0.005568929,
0.0210612789,
0.0269940533,
-0.0289907549,
-0.0697852969,
-0.0336304158,
0.0265244991,
-0.0777934045,
0.0128453681,
-0.0230642818,
0.0283099674,
-0.0445294194,
-0.0894930363,
-0.0231726151,
0.0153956646,
0.0379696228,
-0.0177295897,
-0.0071555562,
0.0479232185,
0.0061338567,
-0.0685433447,
0.0091242334,
0.0414562672,
0.0164163709,
-0.0354488082,
0.0022543515,
0.0071804114,
0.0069383038,
-0.0240395125,
-0.0138304876,
-0.0680747703,
-0.0528761335,
0.0186853111,
0.0302396547,
0.0216205548,
-0.0092757586,
0.0167782754,
-0.0283372384,
-0.0032029036,
0.0238625258,
-0.02501004,
-0.0331614614,
0.0761140734,
-0.0479353182,
-0.0385087729,
0.0152748404,
0.0062533026,
0.010043025,
-0.0045510493,
-0.0123002995,
-0.0009314283,
-0.0215283707,
0.0213441215,
0.0287109558,
0.0354222804,
-0.0056432234,
-0.0363903865,
0.0061047985,
0.0375810824,
0.016077837,
0.0342619754,
-0.0188176688,
0.0032057045,
0.0272216443,
0.0438927896,
-0.0040149828,
-0.0465117618,
0.0092467414,
-0.0124936542,
-0.0175448637,
0.0659987107,
0.0423038229,
0.0414600596,
0.0257595126,
-0.0372160636,
-0.0066294777,
-0.0031314637,
0.0157217607,
0.0301847029,
-0.0313679129,
0.0304349791,
0.0191269387,
0.0771094263,
0.018456921,
0.0017462691,
-0.0129724368,
0.016260976,
0.0095081283,
-0.0126865907,
0.1097760871,
-0.0387004577,
0.0099107735,
-0.0389934927,
0.0318854935,
-0.0281019062,
0.0367375016,
-0.0323809832,
-0.0206827391,
-0.0154147698,
0.0220699254,
-0.0512463599,
0.0516228378,
0.0913861692,
0.0574592464,
0.0436644405,
0.0358099043,
-0.0034467855,
-0.0550797135,
-0.0121236658,
0.0159017146,
0.0290023889,
-0.03893755,
0.0168817919,
-0.0381128006,
-0.0657809228,
0.0545243211,
-0.0116876755,
0.0523899049,
0.0165972058,
0.0300754309,
0.0249626394,
0.0201265104,
0.0102207027,
-0.0403251871,
0.0180332493,
-0.0078558438,
-0.0236142166,
-0.0042886245,
-5.593076692e-33,
0.0338987932,
-0.0364882722,
-0.0144152138,
-0.0075750439,
0.0017405796,
0.0184567943,
-0.0333003253,
0.0053048101,
0.0112532945,
-0.0075562061,
-0.0078742094,
-0.0079211956,
-0.0001814076,
0.0320668146,
0.0391424261,
-0.0241523366,
0.0345955491,
0.0172558259,
0.0006052865,
-0.0168636441,
0.0358444601,
0.0530591607,
0.0709762648,
-0.0442236103,
-0.0253593288,
-0.0187972542,
0.0185489077,
-0.0153773567,
-0.0558910109,
0.0357746035,
-0.0032390202,
0.0385146998,
0.0324732624,
-0.0229186974,
0.0054748361,
-0.0042132945,
-0.0518559255,
-0.0494656451,
-0.0427386649,
0.0127470158,
-0.0637184605,
-0.0224116184,
0.050318405,
0.0023761569,
-0.0252062771,
0.0140918735,
0.022177333,
-0.0392249748,
-0.0263377503,
-0.0348756686,
-0.0330068842,
0.0548788533,
-0.0190623775,
0.0223295018,
0.0325001627,
0.0358789563,
0.0155268917,
-0.0113432566,
-0.0171863232,
0.0031450372,
-0.0035435352,
0.0689086542,
0.0321243145,
0.0039508641,
-0.0324591398,
0.0285789128,
0.0469507016,
-0.0227406882,
0.0038624036,
0.0851089358,
0.0295456406,
0.0328919105,
0.0547870286,
0.0090114083,
0.1101023778,
-0.0260193273,
-0.0982796997,
0.0037640303,
0.0713754073,
0.0598284379,
-0.0081471372,
-0.0078033917,
-0.0498448946,
0.0038404388,
-0.0062792944,
0.0230696518,
-0.0215055868,
-0.0243531074,
0.0260019209,
0.0095228758,
0.0297559742,
0.0348577946,
-0.0061703953,
-0.0259781443,
-0.0116742151,
0.0144603522,
0.0257587191,
-0.0249783695,
0.0108201429,
-0.0004252961,
-0.0435542464,
-0.0565286353,
-0.0002559803,
-0.0333793908,
0.0605234802,
-0.0349243693,
0.0384541564,
0.0281894859,
-0.0553921759,
-0.0008357916,
-0.0251870975,
0.0277181957,
-0.0114194872,
0.0729967058,
0.0538643487,
-0.0052197482,
-0.0042685913,
0.0299596302,
-0.0185702443,
-0.0267266948,
-0.030900199,
-0.0041628699,
0.0212561749,
0.0262256972,
-0.0174580738,
-0.0671035498,
-0.0346754119,
0.0279711988,
0.0011753057,
-0.0336414129,
-0.0067047672,
0.0096414601,
2.675e-7,
-0.0029152241,
0.0465578847,
0.0713253021,
-0.0018215902,
0.0216075294,
0.0077585727,
-0.0595207252,
0.0248736832,
-0.0561440587,
0.0451633409,
0.0174644347,
-0.0373853147,
0.061303664,
0.0047034607,
-0.0868348628,
-0.0321651176,
-0.0468581133,
0.0188622028,
-0.0429239497,
0.0195787586,
0.0506807342,
0.0939780995,
0.0097994758,
-0.0397948734,
0.0140591534,
-0.0365757272,
-0.0165939406,
0.0014743041,
0.0169217419,
0.0097740684,
0.0371849425,
0.0040919324,
0.0096358312,
0.036812786,
-0.0247148629,
0.0415909477,
-0.0031878627,
0.0277947765,
-0.0010275367,
-0.0230412856,
0.023575699,
0.0208427589,
-0.0086587807,
-0.0111000184,
0.0409104861,
0.002358722,
-0.0303360745,
0.0024202494,
-0.0279597081,
-0.0257004797,
0.0277901199,
0.0296985134,
0.0216186717,
0.031755276,
0.016646767,
-0.0338286869,
0.0060730577,
-0.0732032284,
0.0058301273,
0.0026720185,
-0.0179008469,
0.0183907915,
-0.0564694405,
0.0447434559,
0.0479022525,
-0.0060861497,
-0.0238244198,
2.606378854e-34,
-0.0011363995,
-0.0303540621,
-0.0101780063,
0.0078770444,
0.0181933101,
-0.0324572586,
-0.0730901808,
0.028219929,
0.0078263925,
-0.0283455811,
0.0075933011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07666v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07666v2 | ArguGPT: evaluating, understanding and identifying argumentative essays generated by GPT models | 2023-04-16T01:50:26 | 2023-09-23T14:05:58 | Yikang Liu, Ziyin Zhang, Wanyang Zhang, Shisen Yue, Xiaojing Zhao, Xinyuan Cheng, Yiwen Zhang, Hai Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI generated content (AIGC) presents considerable challenge to educators
around the world. Instructors need to be able to detect such text generated by
large language models, either with the naked eye or with the help of some
tools. There is also growing need to understand the lexical, syntactic and
stylistic features of AIGC. To address these challenges in English language
teaching, we first present ArguGPT, a balanced corpus of 4,038 argumentative
essays generated by 7 GPT models in response to essay prompts from three
sources: (1) in-class or homework exercises, (2) TOEFL and (3) GRE writing
tasks. Machine-generated texts are paired with roughly equal number of
human-written essays with three score levels matched in essay prompts. We then
hire English instructors to distinguish machine essays from human ones. Results
show that when first exposed to machine-generated essays, the instructors only
have an accuracy of 61% in detecting them. But the number rises to 67% after
one round of minimal self-training. Next, we perform linguistic analyses of
these essays, which show that machines produce sentences with more complex
syntactic structures while human essays tend to be lexically more complex.
Finally, we test existing AIGC detectors and build our own detectors using SVMs
and RoBERTa. Results suggest that a RoBERTa fine-tuned with the training set of
ArguGPT achieves above 90% accuracy in both essay- and sentence-level
classification. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive
analysis of argumentative essays produced by generative large language models.
Machine-authored essays in ArguGPT and our models will be made publicly
available at https://github.com/huhailinguist/ArguGPT | [
0.0436144806,
0.0408570282,
0.0100838132,
0.0245770998,
-0.0361034125,
0.0148960082,
0.0029722874,
-0.0178442113,
0.0240046605,
-0.1115041748,
0.0324281491,
0.0030723521,
-0.0357404388,
-0.0139478976,
0.0187526587,
-0.0431269631,
-0.009081631,
0.0194373727,
0.0477184653,
0.0114697879,
0.0326372795,
0.0271462146,
0.0004296191,
0.0499701612,
-0.0384530798,
-0.0805909187,
0.0044219154,
0.0000675729,
0.0217017308,
-0.0188135877,
0.0564944372,
0.0812709183,
-0.0035159038,
0.0248779524,
0.0000019656,
-0.0389139839,
0.0045403834,
-0.0191993397,
-0.0025759647,
0.0567762591,
0.0870859176,
0.0536529049,
-0.0281374957,
0.0348874256,
-0.0427903309,
0.0081796702,
0.0188705884,
0.0959441215,
0.0399269089,
0.0972822756,
-0.0150339045,
-0.0223311,
0.0710501447,
0.0161348972,
-0.0160876457,
0.0232250225,
0.0256512668,
-0.0121588679,
-0.0038066914,
0.0182707161,
-0.0024497805,
0.0172321275,
0.0125797698,
-0.0500131808,
-0.028747201,
0.0012412268,
-0.0525597073,
0.0075074318,
0.007341662,
0.000970117,
0.0047135223,
-0.06180498,
0.0351885557,
-0.0158712771,
0.0279244334,
0.0057765679,
-0.0422914773,
0.0608735904,
-0.0267562158,
0.0479501858,
0.096440129,
-0.0084926877,
-0.0007071379,
0.0413242429,
0.0381418988,
0.0022237117,
-0.0087915454,
-0.0445694588,
0.0182532854,
0.0269904304,
-0.0225268081,
-0.0648070723,
0.0081608593,
0.0220833272,
0.0055859284,
0.0178768039,
-0.0460728891,
-0.0409624577,
0.0401696414,
-0.0522422045,
0.0516337566,
-0.0059580142,
0.0191413891,
-0.0160798579,
-0.0042243823,
0.044990696,
-0.0326020718,
0.007000057,
0.0023945067,
0.0245420039,
-0.0742381737,
-0.0420234576,
-0.0519162975,
0.0178640652,
0.0014615761,
-0.0201790538,
-0.0116556203,
-0.0039855926,
-0.0307144374,
0.0049338583,
-0.0062369122,
0.0118126981,
-0.0112910047,
0.0140843997,
-0.0166659541,
0.0201446302,
-0.0259701721,
0.0082125757,
0.0173647981,
-0.0495881289,
0.0120640341,
0.0529106669,
0.014054616,
-0.0133819235,
-0.001471283,
-0.0130538801,
-0.0331087969,
-0.0028249132,
-0.0286635123,
-0.0635504499,
-0.0297882035,
-0.0567190498,
0.0092782713,
-0.0639397204,
-0.0184136219,
-0.0123728886,
0.0152499042,
-0.0599684678,
0.0096523408,
0.0516685247,
0.0072428519,
0.0081487615,
0.0275575183,
-0.0046197395,
0.0610834807,
-0.0105687045,
0.0000090258,
0.0156623945,
0.0484771542,
0.0237844624,
0.0431277528,
-0.0112011321,
0.0578858145,
0.0098859807,
-0.00726446,
-0.0130461799,
0.0468382686,
-0.0211356673,
-0.0451844148,
0.0202904679,
-0.0231703538,
0.0598813519,
0.0130649703,
-0.0015505833,
0.0613487735,
0.0599397458,
-0.0180779137,
0.0479055904,
0.0400147662,
0.0405102298,
0.0420592017,
0.0590969026,
-0.0045151873,
-0.0391338728,
-0.0144522944,
0.0003164769,
0.0198944062,
-0.0036286965,
0.0158627592,
-0.0704605281,
-0.0274891835,
-0.019917896,
-0.0145304855,
-0.0239916276,
0.0263729151,
0.0085651129,
-0.0446511731,
-0.0322941765,
0.0079325698,
-0.062138278,
-0.0176750496,
-0.0243181307,
0.0562234707,
0.0157284718,
0.0348624326,
-0.0169492289,
0.0264123678,
-0.0546564125,
0.0671588853,
0.0800995678,
0.0791078284,
-0.0094135702,
-0.0645833164,
-0.0262768511,
-0.0076337401,
-0.0426048376,
0.0342929587,
0.0008531195,
0.0168420915,
0.0102621401,
0.0288696215,
0.0105083724,
-0.1081172153,
0.0538839698,
-0.0011615922,
-0.0249996316,
0.0070773326,
0.0034766153,
0.0208872426,
0.0258704145,
-0.0345466547,
0.0157402344,
0.0031882653,
-0.0606964789,
-0.034771245,
-0.0168899987,
-0.0168912932,
0.0203895774,
0.0165559798,
-0.0766681507,
-0.0203763805,
0.0090640923,
-0.015203218,
-0.0269423854,
0.0011805466,
-0.0392921641,
-0.0165657979,
-0.0419806354,
0.0077491137,
0.0056129252,
0.0066003921,
-0.0237757787,
0.0365475304,
0.057322979,
0.0183480214,
-0.0132329483,
0.0051667984,
0.0310045574,
-0.0518529452,
-0.0069495435,
0.0081549352,
0.0095980624,
0.0115712881,
0.0316063911,
-0.0187310837,
-0.0387375727,
-0.0527265631,
-0.0931307971,
0.0100663714,
-0.0107165687,
0.0330675542,
0.0193670336,
-0.0643900931,
-0.0148517257,
0.0387193635,
-0.0311180092,
-0.0524924286,
0.0001781752,
-0.0159802716,
0.0313821547,
-0.0538491756,
0.0666956156,
-0.0340454876,
0.0059883613,
-0.0586278364,
0.0153762959,
0.081298545,
-0.0005058848,
-0.0315630548,
0.0558635816,
0.0178412776,
-0.0097358059,
0.0156127615,
-0.0655235574,
0.0173202455,
-0.0053270035,
0.055823613,
0.098202087,
0.0466070287,
0.0397659838,
0.0328563154,
0.0119460728,
-0.030162951,
0.0051561925,
-0.0039673881,
0.024879152,
-0.0390708968,
-0.0438813679,
0.0285499264,
0.0524283126,
0.0105632907,
-0.017429322,
-0.0436303839,
0.0634620786,
-0.0307732448,
0.0234653894,
0.0368776247,
-0.0463999063,
-0.0330426767,
0.014373349,
-0.0165176336,
-0.0153170321,
0.0334298275,
-0.0306827966,
0.0189417005,
-0.054952126,
-0.0147218751,
-0.0082618697,
0.0310661066,
0.0312544182,
-0.0017954612,
0.0064234775,
0.0282983351,
-0.0198130328,
-0.0077307429,
0.0425415151,
-0.0257295221,
0.0134625165,
-0.0210895315,
-0.0003997159,
-0.015794944,
-0.0383328311,
-0.0224749278,
-0.0400881805,
-0.030089749,
-0.015441196,
0.0090065524,
-0.0302431472,
0.0005197258,
-0.0310259648,
-0.0130288545,
0.0262806043,
-0.0628427193,
-0.0107474523,
-0.0065361885,
0.0203539971,
0.0402465388,
-0.0167124812,
-0.0307443999,
-0.0128979618,
0.0614129119,
0.0560535379,
-0.0250794608,
0.03231268,
-0.0188045874,
-0.0334013663,
-0.0092709903,
-0.0541498028,
-0.0458945818,
-0.0213082004,
0.0294784382,
-0.0887132064,
-0.0001918461,
0.1080876663,
0.0173514467,
-0.0227171537,
-0.0162502117,
-0.0333562195,
0.022163704,
-0.0110784471,
0.033439666,
-0.062202476,
-0.0205858722,
-0.0113201179,
0.0207009763,
-0.0788587332,
-0.0068718307,
0.0031132668,
-0.0989366844,
0.0561441556,
0.012208431,
0.0036341569,
-0.0048365733,
-0.0078518447,
-0.0346163735,
-0.018076878,
-0.0410341695,
-0.0369161777,
-0.0245672055,
0.0475538447,
0.0419309735,
-0.0291092191,
0.0174953714,
-0.0156651158,
-0.0186786521,
0.0191023555,
0.0226725526,
0.0700050071,
-0.0206643324,
-0.044232145,
0.0473543853,
-0.0283425748,
-0.0279809609,
-0.0095098652,
0.0355252847,
-0.0123951798,
0.00971309,
-0.015597621,
0.0620407425,
-0.0233051907,
-0.036423143,
0.0712883919,
0.0855968446,
-0.019389376,
-0.045804169,
-0.0314490125,
0.004419921,
0.0012011544,
0.0856668428,
0.0478100963,
-0.0385732874,
-0.0752055421,
-0.0743268207,
0.0283003282,
-0.0917692035,
-0.0153031358,
0.0028469695,
0.0041826353,
0.0294565763,
-0.0607941374,
-0.0805838406,
-0.0177866966,
0.0066708815,
0.0195709895,
0.0067829378,
0.0069402875,
0.0097300913,
-0.0668410063,
-0.0040875846,
0.0037971409,
-0.0051936768,
-0.0307045598,
-0.0204435345,
-0.0059844111,
-0.0186518952,
-0.029031327,
0.0105960332,
-0.0207244009,
-0.0789342895,
0.0173118394,
0.0156018334,
0.0086931428,
0.0269019362,
0.0168611743,
-0.0384183675,
0.0395762846,
0.0107340841,
0.0229717046,
-0.0013123828,
0.0252330508,
-0.0128510902,
-0.0034060045,
0.0045717908,
0.0261849482,
0.0262702629,
-0.0016988104,
0.0231651515,
-0.0287047867,
-0.0041553522,
0.0138907619,
0.0312694013,
0.036017593,
-0.0029707681,
-0.0412527993,
-0.0588602126,
-0.0173885413,
-0.0364052504,
-0.0237360615,
-0.0322401673,
0.0174247194,
0.0053629363,
-0.0092493352,
-0.0203578155,
0.0087181535,
-0.0486565977,
0.0504152961,
0.0036176015,
0.0392306149,
0.0003164322,
0.0381830558,
-0.0184388384,
-0.0102964779,
-0.0222262125,
0.0365040004,
0.0075399345,
0.0355522595,
-0.0012973553,
0.0847603753,
0.0193439126,
0.0007802761,
0.0624533817,
-0.0075634932,
-0.0553531423,
0.0062549342,
-0.0264868829,
0.0081874309,
0.0204571281,
-0.0365444273,
0.0748815089,
-0.0497583337,
-0.0210056249,
-0.0393433571,
0.0588556118,
0.0354867913,
-0.0034435671,
0.0092445463,
0.0131664658,
-0.0265811421,
-0.0189428609,
0.0407165252,
-0.0067626582,
0.028881235,
0.0367121957,
-0.0444492809,
-0.030180702,
-0.037783809,
0.00607287,
-0.0071058278,
0.0539596006,
0.0058425888,
-0.0082082301,
-0.0109310122,
-0.0315627493,
0.0355507731,
0.0218377858,
-0.0452776402,
0.0018842802,
0.0506123528,
-0.0482827537,
0.0149600012,
-0.0780469924,
0.0365224071,
-0.0294188447,
-0.026544055,
-0.0242645126,
-5.460393134e-33,
0.0016358988,
-0.0568820573,
-0.0157900173,
0.0911495686,
-0.0046041575,
0.0019088127,
-0.0322505943,
0.0024703881,
0.0079757823,
0.0848627463,
0.0021738496,
0.0176786911,
-0.0054216757,
0.055362042,
0.0101947822,
0.0115184868,
0.0449286439,
-0.0143719073,
-0.0324909128,
0.0241098367,
0.0164842829,
-0.0065512117,
0.0308824647,
-0.0599678494,
0.0599940382,
-0.0609657317,
-0.0025396086,
-0.0269625913,
-0.047828801,
0.0599418469,
-0.0174354818,
0.066711843,
0.0380285308,
-0.0199913215,
0.0310737733,
0.056377206,
-0.038236782,
-0.0307611451,
0.0018441149,
-0.0282362811,
-0.0102679608,
-0.1017125323,
0.0168824848,
0.0003063302,
-0.0224492904,
-0.0185286831,
0.074303396,
-0.004132505,
0.0326792672,
-0.0520031452,
-0.0619320385,
0.0250556692,
-0.0268694684,
-0.0122898743,
-0.0053473422,
0.038915772,
0.0059429137,
0.0609556586,
-0.0195524953,
0.0095591275,
0.0100832265,
0.0295663308,
-0.0139905624,
-0.045955997,
-0.0132847298,
0.0519030802,
0.0120093487,
0.0127203856,
-0.0418859497,
0.0245554112,
-0.0228346027,
-0.0050093494,
0.0821372494,
0.0682792887,
0.0367723405,
0.0020452491,
-0.0435617454,
-0.0008094421,
0.0335442573,
0.0129443491,
0.0152836153,
-0.0651315153,
-0.0250713471,
-0.0135899531,
-0.0238387659,
-0.1115238145,
0.0014764074,
-0.0164376609,
0.0299196914,
-0.0211362112,
0.0009841175,
0.0080842888,
-0.0164455399,
-0.0249168463,
-0.0222628005,
0.013072649,
-0.0320299193,
-0.0010042925,
-0.0049755746,
0.0061319727,
-0.0088259066,
0.0192293897,
0.0106764697,
0.0081175305,
0.0583518781,
0.0048515387,
0.0584614016,
-0.016335668,
-0.0401712172,
-0.0001072383,
-0.014153487,
0.0345018357,
-0.0253849905,
0.030550262,
0.0105976751,
0.0215518996,
0.0228089597,
0.0326631069,
0.0212815665,
0.0130948471,
-0.0477679819,
-0.0864014924,
0.0108523322,
0.0051744496,
-0.0193765014,
0.0098670051,
-0.0058313468,
0.0386646837,
0.007581112,
-0.0524326153,
0.0185459964,
-0.019768592,
2.412e-7,
0.0521650277,
0.0625523105,
0.018212324,
-0.0348525234,
0.0134548554,
0.0406200364,
-0.0032555244,
0.0108596599,
0.0230209883,
0.024257103,
-0.0227412283,
0.0151553266,
0.0810497329,
0.0242319666,
-0.0961684734,
-0.0375739038,
-0.0558685474,
-0.0140311988,
-0.0614851974,
0.0384692103,
0.1291396916,
0.0338286385,
0.0172727723,
-0.013344489,
-0.0210718997,
-0.0195481908,
0.0307122469,
-0.0104364213,
-0.000015477,
0.0245963801,
0.0489668772,
-0.043083515,
0.0117359813,
0.0165784732,
-0.02883338,
-0.0188005883,
-0.0122839045,
0.075442344,
0.0241047684,
0.0078817662,
0.0197219141,
0.0036002973,
0.007625123,
-0.0758174434,
0.0533538722,
-0.0399526916,
-0.0051636738,
-0.0356081054,
-0.0420763008,
-0.0432710275,
0.0154668968,
-0.0135177309,
-0.0027294569,
-0.004413594,
-0.0061687641,
-0.0186382495,
0.0333173051,
-0.0448251553,
-0.0316467024,
0.0108616799,
-0.0266054198,
0.0109535316,
-0.0144595029,
0.0178159121,
0.0221581552,
-0.042674873,
-0.0021516588,
2.107437981e-34,
0.03940323,
-0.0228621401,
0.0221168324,
-0.0065053809,
0.0363302939,
0.0643485561,
0.0079585249,
-0.0025867152,
-0.0112656271,
-0.0390849486,
-0.0042169113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07637v1 | TransDocs: Optical Character Recognition with word to word translation | 2023-04-15T21:40:14 | 2023-04-15T21:40:14 | Abhishek Bamotra, Phani Krishna Uppala | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | While OCR has been used in various applications, its output is not always
accurate, leading to misfit words. This research work focuses on improving the
optical character recognition (OCR) with ML techniques with integration of OCR
with long short-term memory (LSTM) based sequence to sequence deep learning
models to perform document translation. This work is based on ANKI dataset for
English to Spanish translation. In this work, I have shown comparative study
for pre-trained OCR while using deep learning model using LSTM-based seq2seq
architecture with attention for machine translation. End-to-end performance of
the model has been expressed in BLEU-4 score. This research paper is aimed at
researchers and practitioners interested in OCR and its applications in
document translation. | [
-0.015441752,
0.0299358927,
0.0287222508,
0.0590732284,
-0.0309481863,
-0.0039484161,
0.0450438745,
0.0123108011,
-0.013622161,
-0.0104099819,
-0.0532651506,
-0.0100365272,
0.0587373488,
0.038706325,
-0.0226422977,
-0.0418468975,
0.0145073701,
-0.0527200848,
-0.0603001639,
-0.0077334912,
-0.0317036584,
-0.0123583088,
0.0073063583,
-0.0109820319,
0.0380013213,
0.0033607401,
0.0037036929,
0.0088832723,
0.0286696833,
-0.0022258614,
-0.0171960033,
0.0123465629,
-0.0120235411,
0.0922392979,
0.0000021786,
-0.0442298241,
-0.0490264222,
0.0133081283,
-0.0165574662,
-0.0295680743,
0.039799843,
-0.0785008967,
-0.0124224741,
0.0175670683,
-0.0026198949,
-0.0285198204,
0.0611961484,
0.0649179146,
-0.004623495,
0.0541001037,
-0.0272385348,
-0.0692967474,
0.0516603924,
-0.0030874773,
-0.0035039915,
-0.0333206877,
-0.0029247345,
-0.0479517244,
-0.017086463,
0.0195804555,
-0.0110872174,
0.0441956036,
0.0081193503,
-0.0452987254,
0.0204440746,
-0.0035982197,
0.022484988,
0.0135444077,
-0.0111816255,
0.0771094933,
-0.0461496599,
0.0028265493,
-0.0170067884,
0.0017523003,
-0.0287987646,
-0.0155016268,
-0.0222677495,
0.0196168981,
0.002134789,
-0.0119832084,
-0.0165389087,
0.0299205426,
0.0239484776,
0.0136545459,
-0.0521389768,
0.0238025766,
0.0156062832,
-0.0321356654,
0.015922647,
-0.0422334634,
0.029286582,
0.0226026569,
0.0603632405,
0.063535966,
0.0118307201,
0.0032701385,
-0.0476222113,
-0.0694627315,
0.0018392565,
-0.0739575624,
0.0656436756,
0.0310049281,
-0.022659352,
0.0468517244,
-0.0953725725,
0.0818253458,
-0.0062257568,
0.040630281,
-0.0248344596,
-0.0430788472,
-0.026230095,
0.0215695072,
-0.04548724,
-0.0223039668,
-0.0133734457,
-0.035307724,
-0.0287667233,
-0.0221363604,
0.0276873317,
0.0042814589,
0.0151335262,
-0.0249047913,
-0.0472279936,
-0.0370929614,
-0.0211741384,
0.0249101985,
0.0360000394,
-0.012196905,
-0.0344996154,
-0.0510311201,
0.0167118814,
0.039277643,
0.0532118306,
-0.0256295651,
-0.0033631395,
0.0976679921,
-0.0154656786,
-0.0627309904,
-0.0045525632,
0.003774486,
-0.010060885,
-0.0455285497,
0.0303123053,
-0.0745097473,
0.0239806641,
-0.0034495185,
-0.0019853741,
-0.0015985989,
0.0172736198,
0.0151794758,
-0.0030314687,
0.0717394948,
-0.0452637672,
-0.0372031182,
0.0820555612,
0.0013896249,
0.0648752749,
0.0088845016,
0.0599685535,
0.0356710926,
-0.0033672752,
-0.0256682076,
-0.0105425194,
0.0510258228,
-0.0263385922,
-0.0450404659,
0.0103514772,
-0.0263798926,
0.0377430357,
0.0540182106,
0.0304445755,
0.0622177161,
-0.0139315529,
0.0407292694,
0.0324847065,
0.0419971235,
0.0405686274,
0.0444149412,
-0.0277686287,
0.0087164044,
-0.0059132986,
-0.0398669131,
-0.0148958452,
0.0444575325,
0.0799999014,
0.0162904523,
-0.0378588177,
0.0158119351,
0.0020741352,
-0.0085634729,
-0.0061926218,
-0.0510778911,
-0.0349775478,
-0.0450530872,
0.0762763396,
0.0077538495,
-0.0900492296,
0.0379499048,
-0.0573712848,
-0.0176058598,
0.0192072988,
-0.0331943743,
-0.0278351381,
0.026517909,
0.0655127913,
-0.0391787104,
0.0097633116,
-0.0205052383,
-0.0291095935,
0.0538871549,
0.0370868705,
0.0476698577,
0.0137704015,
-0.081330426,
-0.011081907,
0.0069995639,
-0.0280627422,
0.0269471351,
-0.0184109714,
0.0803057551,
0.0510251448,
-0.0006042341,
-0.0919012055,
0.026504498,
-0.0294903144,
-0.0464489609,
0.0073634717,
0.030011164,
0.0012414997,
-0.0039564609,
0.0036927189,
-0.009216263,
0.0305031519,
-0.0338298455,
-0.0142965009,
0.0096820006,
-0.058908511,
0.0075651025,
0.0347005054,
-0.0844939649,
0.0191285629,
0.0198034476,
-0.0051576844,
-0.0628011152,
-0.0031129136,
-0.0357273407,
-0.0030816093,
-0.0408454165,
0.0418800227,
-0.0195010006,
0.0165496431,
-0.0471369028,
0.0046144892,
0.0245596748,
-0.013446358,
0.0235597026,
-0.0221843515,
0.0317057259,
-0.0339849964,
-0.0104641123,
0.0136549314,
0.0060373927,
0.0144306757,
0.0040363828,
0.0419846512,
-0.0201314017,
-0.0445414335,
-0.0532756038,
-0.0273154993,
0.0089751072,
-0.0024385161,
0.0057495846,
0.0307404585,
0.022774037,
-0.0226992313,
-0.0079244524,
0.0319161415,
-0.0207599979,
-0.0587728582,
0.0406870395,
0.0098791718,
0.0110989604,
0.0137973968,
-0.0015220213,
0.0071166013,
0.0102769788,
0.0221146774,
-0.0481092148,
-0.0365471207,
0.0362267792,
0.0087882392,
0.0306216124,
0.0163131673,
-0.0310560912,
-0.0106244329,
0.0079681948,
0.024701234,
0.1044697538,
0.0188199375,
-0.0652768537,
0.0237288456,
-0.0192381237,
0.0034369645,
-0.0063748211,
0.0100026857,
0.0261396859,
0.027018778,
-0.0230074339,
0.004542897,
0.0067997333,
-0.0365614444,
0.0417827852,
-0.0103111183,
-0.0608474277,
-0.0235964376,
0.0008215659,
-0.0085234335,
-0.002613697,
-0.0203727558,
0.0172574706,
0.0044511678,
-0.0199776273,
-0.0014496937,
-0.036751084,
-0.0094685331,
-0.0616904311,
0.0346080624,
-0.0419104062,
0.0201123524,
-0.0214450806,
0.0349859148,
-0.0626079068,
-0.0557001159,
0.0157134086,
-0.0206618104,
-0.0125639476,
-0.0385546945,
0.0215733312,
-0.0120541211,
0.0293757264,
-0.0665020198,
-0.0059131226,
0.0105042607,
0.0313606933,
-0.0276819151,
-0.0161076263,
-0.0292696487,
-0.0395721309,
-0.0097903302,
0.0514294431,
-0.0127760172,
0.1146627665,
-0.0241266657,
0.0232894104,
-0.0401988365,
0.0507806093,
0.033634752,
-0.0452272892,
0.0418696366,
-0.0610753931,
0.0395124033,
-0.0347898453,
-0.0035336956,
-0.0523984283,
-0.0424731597,
-0.0281972624,
0.0162673704,
0.0057803518,
0.007305447,
-0.0340999663,
-0.0012241481,
-0.0679722503,
-0.0208220687,
0.0786400959,
0.0043528136,
-0.0547760241,
-0.0533923656,
-0.0409940928,
-0.0318096653,
-0.0474321395,
0.0037385926,
-0.0614630394,
-0.0288401246,
-0.0110116387,
0.0214807037,
0.0306664743,
-0.0001633414,
-0.0333372653,
-0.0332611613,
-0.0041820593,
0.0250260551,
-0.0593984574,
-0.0842919722,
0.0168488473,
-0.0216532927,
-0.0138882324,
0.0020558634,
0.0066074496,
-0.0064119883,
-0.0471831486,
0.0066322223,
0.0120206168,
0.0029292568,
-0.0080653736,
-0.0384449847,
-0.0241920836,
0.0956127644,
0.0454546772,
-0.029950222,
-0.0250596311,
0.0273827799,
0.0072863428,
-0.0056295325,
-0.0173568614,
0.0258577857,
-0.0108080357,
-0.0116953915,
-0.0032246984,
0.03573424,
-0.0440475345,
0.0331235789,
-0.0148394573,
0.0183446873,
-0.004212888,
-0.0309673939,
0.0016962666,
-0.0517721847,
-0.0286657792,
-0.0016135409,
-0.0246002767,
-0.0336546116,
-0.0388481617,
0.0285149664,
0.019830808,
-0.073863022,
0.0363144577,
-0.0157136209,
-0.0191084407,
-0.0329101868,
-0.0242778026,
-0.0404949971,
-0.0139779206,
0.0275349542,
0.0320996307,
0.012274635,
-0.0059387139,
0.0113843856,
-0.0192480218,
-0.0037554773,
-0.0369863771,
0.0147313019,
-0.0694290325,
0.0593984202,
0.0022659078,
-0.0106323184,
0.032026697,
-0.0302106235,
-0.0834933892,
-0.0123215476,
0.03275574,
0.0290752146,
0.0192176271,
-0.029954318,
-0.0311328936,
-0.0489652418,
0.0555438772,
0.0102942167,
0.0194426253,
-0.0493983254,
0.004844788,
-0.0153345708,
-0.0136816381,
0.0262089707,
0.0200193897,
-0.0141335605,
-0.001748429,
-0.0540491343,
0.004740864,
-0.0995086506,
-0.0192653593,
-0.0279844403,
0.0492624491,
0.002731408,
0.0182888284,
-0.0318292156,
0.0668643937,
0.0437151045,
0.0379026532,
-0.0117483763,
0.009421071,
0.0250753276,
0.0235835165,
0.013156903,
0.0418467447,
0.0414771177,
-0.0725196823,
-0.0127899293,
0.0656759292,
-0.005235699,
0.0432065018,
0.0023331542,
0.0042273086,
-0.0118014989,
0.043955531,
-0.0115550561,
0.0392104834,
-0.0000495972,
0.0154320206,
0.0084437849,
0.046171274,
0.034628775,
0.0398351774,
0.0133132078,
-0.0258884244,
-0.0498823225,
-0.0144580351,
0.0854361802,
-0.0316617079,
0.0198973324,
-0.0016376331,
-0.0078980317,
-0.0270290747,
0.0139599452,
-0.0069945613,
0.0467268452,
-0.0222038869,
-0.00206988,
0.0186138861,
0.013062289,
0.0520448573,
-0.0061310264,
-0.0371925011,
0.0331691094,
0.0150835766,
-0.0275562927,
0.0416676104,
0.0401141867,
-0.0318249501,
-0.0493704006,
-0.0312782973,
0.0595023856,
-0.0310587455,
0.0673647672,
-0.0234146658,
0.0259893555,
-0.0104707992,
0.0398836546,
0.0565792508,
-0.0112461485,
0.0120354816,
0.0037253606,
0.017564293,
0.0380610377,
-0.039255891,
-0.0202663615,
-5.918232388e-33,
0.0108356364,
-0.0462247543,
0.0047225836,
0.017316632,
-0.0192384999,
0.026936667,
-0.009472589,
-0.0320819356,
-0.0371676125,
-0.018260967,
-0.0170438737,
0.0203951448,
0.0540544167,
0.0343004279,
-0.0185258295,
0.0189380124,
0.02964909,
-0.010235155,
-0.0124210035,
-0.0052544419,
0.0208427776,
0.0517714471,
0.0716198608,
-0.0323180668,
0.0259883218,
0.0033301408,
0.0268149041,
-0.0418808572,
0.041292049,
-0.0019740784,
-0.0053023552,
0.0106799277,
0.0037079533,
-0.0091844089,
0.0162548441,
0.0426475145,
-0.0564111695,
0.0406962447,
-0.0426447652,
0.0591291599,
-0.0663553402,
-0.0380747132,
0.0191765074,
-0.0085304426,
-0.046175193,
-0.0333863199,
0.0268041994,
-0.0080308923,
-0.0244754925,
0.004303169,
-0.0593887046,
0.0334014632,
0.0220773648,
0.0057816776,
0.0898964554,
0.0232832581,
-0.0255172011,
-0.0132148731,
-0.0755361095,
-0.007785175,
0.0340352505,
0.0632477105,
0.0421840623,
0.0550479665,
-0.0355173387,
-0.0472782329,
-0.024309665,
-0.0161364246,
0.0432945378,
0.0208571162,
0.0623098165,
0.0085932035,
0.077621296,
0.0031286522,
0.0526716188,
-0.0072202715,
-0.0582486056,
0.0238483883,
-0.0218178686,
0.0381792299,
0.0613925084,
0.0041475897,
0.0302452073,
0.0355851725,
-0.0167167652,
-0.0151881762,
-0.0128584234,
-0.0066557936,
0.0024108288,
0.0215081535,
-0.0162760373,
-0.0335514657,
0.0633428395,
-0.0208420977,
0.0033100192,
-0.0425423235,
0.0122820018,
-0.004238768,
-0.0353098512,
0.0472181365,
-0.0723854303,
-0.0436206348,
-0.0029230197,
0.0402262583,
-0.0116772549,
-0.0117933908,
0.0187556371,
-0.0031692241,
-0.0386905819,
0.0033391959,
0.0079945559,
-0.0138707068,
0.0599030927,
0.0971133932,
-0.005770959,
-0.0480945073,
0.0407341607,
0.1022249386,
-0.0097125964,
-0.0017621958,
-0.0223186109,
-0.062530674,
0.0331110954,
0.014365905,
-0.0503867082,
0.0227247626,
-0.0511034541,
0.0343428031,
-0.0356043503,
-0.0374192372,
0.0037971868,
0.0305273924,
2.827e-7,
0.0382282026,
0.0496889651,
0.0262748171,
0.0367728174,
-0.0015397561,
-0.0072008767,
0.0303818472,
0.0551175475,
-0.0352930464,
0.0294269621,
0.0246173255,
0.0098452466,
0.078030318,
-0.0259472299,
-0.0872728974,
-0.0636153445,
-0.0037127875,
0.057261765,
-0.0633184835,
0.004779418,
0.0036679383,
0.0981236845,
-0.0490466841,
-0.0247169603,
0.0261981562,
-0.0185301602,
0.0498367921,
0.0242789183,
0.0393023826,
0.0109095266,
0.0661156625,
0.0146201635,
-0.0606173202,
0.0326901935,
-0.0047463565,
0.0217495635,
0.0427561775,
-0.0032905531,
-0.0250382666,
-0.0064913235,
0.0500714146,
-0.0218127873,
-0.0066120401,
-0.0642944425,
0.0652522966,
-0.0003317683,
-0.0270656161,
0.0172383823,
0.0092109833,
-0.0181105956,
0.0387730561,
-0.0201430786,
-0.0378450416,
0.0024951808,
0.0555217154,
-0.0261008479,
-0.0291473288,
-0.0430694893,
0.0148901558,
-0.0450148955,
0.0273543168,
-0.0108635547,
-0.0682329908,
-0.014181789,
0.0384336561,
0.0238715839,
-0.0021067932,
2.257636083e-34,
0.0063881269,
-0.0208412372,
-0.0251118522,
0.0313841961,
0.0192748085,
-0.0466667004,
-0.0054115271,
0.0165307801,
-0.0086793564,
-0.0530779287,
-0.029399788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07633v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07633v2 | Interpretable Detection of Out-of-Context Misinformation with Neural-Symbolic-Enhanced Large Multimodal Model | 2023-04-15T21:11:55 | 2024-04-05T23:39:52 | Yizhou Zhang, Loc Trinh, Defu Cao, Zijun Cui, Yan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent years have witnessed the sustained evolution of misinformation that
aims at manipulating public opinions. Unlike traditional rumors or fake news
editors who mainly rely on generated and/or counterfeited images, text and
videos, current misinformation creators now more tend to use out-of-context
multimedia contents (e.g. mismatched images and captions) to deceive the public
and fake news detection systems. This new type of misinformation increases the
difficulty of not only detection but also clarification, because every
individual modality is close enough to true information. To address this
challenge, in this paper we explore how to achieve interpretable cross-modal
de-contextualization detection that simultaneously identifies the mismatched
pairs and the cross-modal contradictions, which is helpful for fact-check
websites to document clarifications. The proposed model first symbolically
disassembles the text-modality information to a set of fact queries based on
the Abstract Meaning Representation of the caption and then forwards the
query-image pairs into a pre-trained large vision-language model select the
``evidences" that are helpful for us to detect misinformation. Extensive
experiments indicate that the proposed methodology can provide us with much
more interpretable predictions while maintaining the accuracy same as the
state-of-the-art model on this task. | [
0.0230770335,
0.030160157,
-0.0063120741,
0.0800970048,
-0.0270967446,
0.0228606015,
-0.0042078854,
0.0216801409,
-0.0157137979,
-0.0687844306,
-0.0214254241,
-0.0254602656,
0.0160364136,
0.059754651,
0.0223920383,
-0.0408974402,
0.0728341639,
0.0106556378,
0.034112785,
0.0087415855,
0.0426515117,
0.0272713508,
-0.0036594269,
0.029569516,
-0.0503542945,
-0.06634105,
0.0119475666,
0.0199915562,
0.0318867378,
-0.0030652666,
-0.0307385102,
0.0251675155,
0.0693639815,
0.0807750225,
0.0000018038,
-0.0066971425,
0.0053114421,
0.0089258021,
-0.0325163417,
0.0119676823,
0.048930347,
-0.0777067691,
-0.017476473,
-0.0212186743,
-0.0033739805,
-0.0079010474,
0.0558969378,
0.0919076428,
0.1000710949,
0.075385645,
-0.010355711,
-0.0176904015,
0.0116645275,
0.0096243573,
0.0160577931,
-0.0325125381,
0.0336564146,
0.0311640389,
-0.0609507076,
0.0474590361,
-0.0294631161,
0.0114985453,
0.0102296555,
-0.0321655013,
-0.0595704578,
-0.012225531,
-0.0043399958,
-0.0428673252,
-0.0018204555,
0.0843419284,
-0.0275037028,
-0.0265768617,
0.0004158217,
0.0084993206,
0.0001495357,
0.0516704991,
-0.0160313603,
0.047403574,
-0.0050298194,
0.0183877964,
0.0128587047,
-0.0171891935,
0.0466836095,
0.0354255773,
-0.0020240664,
-0.0244783163,
-0.0222722162,
0.0074806041,
-0.027733963,
-0.0271348711,
-0.0397860482,
-0.0356579125,
0.0069521843,
-0.0005403867,
-0.0052834707,
-0.0008837084,
-0.0710965171,
-0.0678303018,
0.0154733397,
-0.0955351293,
0.0086630192,
-0.0048639998,
-0.039451424,
0.0744739026,
-0.0060165874,
0.0212568901,
-0.0414707735,
0.0484261699,
0.0043537845,
-0.0223459303,
-0.0171726942,
0.0098975515,
0.0110306833,
0.0053902874,
-0.06346903,
-0.0176457334,
-0.0326003693,
-0.0226463396,
-0.0551914163,
0.0092593664,
-0.0200486369,
0.0126645369,
-0.0463325344,
-0.0447684303,
-0.0342398211,
0.0679854453,
0.0374873392,
0.0117887808,
-0.0261503365,
-0.0354325399,
0.0109213898,
0.0474080741,
-0.0258584879,
0.0080584362,
-0.0247174539,
0.0605715252,
0.0004963137,
0.0263042618,
-0.0473276451,
-0.0624313653,
-0.0372831896,
-0.0266531445,
0.0180548076,
-0.0376189016,
0.0006874163,
-0.0650654286,
-0.0064053829,
-0.0179805793,
-0.0057075983,
0.0162958819,
-0.0269396529,
0.0871357098,
-0.0118421484,
-0.0310764052,
0.0492434166,
0.0286965296,
-0.0035619179,
0.0815906674,
0.0055334051,
0.0775325745,
0.0516198501,
0.0204431117,
-0.0007462422,
-0.0115828915,
0.0376548432,
0.0109907342,
-0.0159334615,
-0.0128100328,
0.0003388459,
0.00927216,
0.0440616496,
0.0305365697,
-0.0401754119,
-0.0718508288,
0.0786711201,
-0.0570231155,
-0.0059585553,
-0.0177108552,
0.0487751104,
0.0228248145,
-0.0159210917,
-0.0073301531,
-0.0732386336,
0.044279173,
-0.0363018662,
-0.0223899819,
-0.0277501568,
0.069847852,
-0.002722977,
-0.0175257158,
0.0326615162,
-0.0230064858,
-0.0075641712,
-0.009946432,
0.033219073,
0.0126841441,
-0.0566645861,
0.0293587577,
0.0436505824,
0.0222787876,
0.0006022942,
-0.0365319178,
0.0180816427,
0.0309940781,
0.0232453514,
0.0057337834,
0.0091814054,
-0.0403627902,
0.0187127907,
0.0362902619,
0.020598866,
-0.0268157851,
-0.0143337538,
-0.0098436885,
-0.0258852616,
-0.0511034429,
0.010907351,
0.0041397312,
-0.0371048748,
0.0105006984,
0.0181011222,
-0.0387276858,
-0.0108117154,
0.0232742988,
0.059815634,
-0.0072828396,
-0.0423422903,
0.0541982055,
0.0320347846,
0.0244826432,
-0.0206094813,
-0.0264087096,
0.0445197038,
-0.0113031454,
-0.0204256885,
0.0008641487,
-0.0279965159,
-0.0381717123,
0.0212636553,
-0.0760212988,
-0.0449976213,
0.0265593342,
-0.0564854816,
0.0178609379,
0.0525889397,
-0.0485373959,
-0.0059907241,
-0.0470511205,
-0.0158959031,
-0.0156928357,
0.0275993403,
0.0211924128,
0.076328665,
-0.0290686693,
-0.0693311244,
0.032017149,
-0.0000340513,
0.0135291619,
0.0008011358,
-0.0004852545,
0.0205533523,
0.0196600519,
0.0083714081,
-0.0016226277,
-0.0423932299,
-0.0056763408,
0.0158469118,
-0.0674112812,
-0.0485990494,
-0.0119687542,
-0.0257161688,
0.0416842699,
-0.0207236595,
0.0264599249,
-0.0095005445,
0.0157998726,
0.0237038154,
-0.0129055101,
0.0186109003,
0.0127822226,
0.011538811,
-0.0028889549,
0.0122085381,
0.0003234951,
-0.0136425449,
0.0917659253,
0.0312959403,
-0.03450666,
-0.046616178,
-0.0036311361,
-0.0370778367,
0.0450997576,
-0.040918272,
-0.0090222824,
0.0008313416,
0.0277352165,
-0.0266155042,
0.0376089178,
0.0410928801,
0.0630163029,
0.0195174143,
0.0189856924,
-0.0320774578,
-0.0418980122,
0.0048683207,
0.0257240571,
-0.0292562507,
-0.0556685627,
0.0152982911,
0.0165233593,
0.0381778777,
0.022544466,
-0.020601809,
0.0393806137,
-0.0153766228,
-0.0647236705,
-0.0283637494,
-0.0451565869,
0.0229441766,
0.0347521827,
-0.0447359234,
-0.0364652574,
0.0778095424,
-0.0143320495,
0.0632184371,
0.0072877686,
-0.0153025417,
-0.0038409743,
0.0318261757,
-0.0181008074,
0.0551807545,
0.0311787818,
-0.0097365556,
-0.0384683572,
-0.0488824397,
0.0450282432,
-0.0040647285,
0.0333966129,
-0.0587338582,
0.0180017147,
0.0192399994,
-0.0190099608,
-0.0209666751,
-0.0817425549,
0.0041389605,
-0.0364410095,
-0.0238642581,
-0.0130889751,
-0.0563198142,
-0.0074223783,
0.0359530412,
-0.0071979202,
0.0089898184,
0.0090267593,
0.0052580894,
0.0341407843,
0.0325834751,
0.0071190749,
0.0398882478,
-0.0302406698,
-0.0205260348,
0.0584075004,
-0.0185491629,
-0.0280807633,
-0.0480922796,
-0.0276215617,
-0.0390029475,
0.0184063744,
-0.0167171191,
-0.0069784108,
0.0350969769,
-0.0730673149,
0.0251675807,
0.0701758936,
-0.0195589941,
-0.0316783004,
-0.0054795085,
0.0377481394,
-0.0621454157,
-0.0001162374,
-0.0265440848,
-0.0854807422,
-0.0312998109,
-0.0192231908,
-0.0288119763,
-0.0286446437,
0.0012977496,
-0.011325337,
-0.0722110644,
0.0458457917,
0.0059820306,
0.0053543439,
-0.0763524249,
-0.0197576061,
-0.0184836555,
-0.0092429807,
0.0093833059,
0.0177724175,
0.0228731763,
-0.0247907154,
-0.0246422645,
0.0364639424,
-0.0633689687,
-0.0044983835,
-0.0138659347,
0.0173704326,
0.0309519563,
0.037576668,
-0.0196105391,
-0.0665399879,
0.0057446291,
-0.0037095132,
-0.0012444379,
-0.0054632337,
0.0773911625,
-0.0408891365,
-0.0300476775,
-0.021773966,
0.0096500348,
0.0136794858,
-0.0180804338,
-0.0575702898,
0.0642582029,
-0.0058330721,
-0.0120358448,
-0.0521974191,
0.0115654767,
0.0398936346,
0.0355624445,
-0.0085477233,
0.0054805619,
-0.0463871881,
-0.0312170256,
0.004191563,
0.0064546345,
-0.0031789781,
0.0353581272,
0.0085348794,
-0.0122399712,
-0.0522998199,
-0.0095341178,
-0.0331426859,
0.0509026609,
-0.0127720125,
0.007810316,
0.0235750191,
-0.0087265233,
-0.0393820964,
0.02415956,
-0.0287618991,
0.0549732447,
0.0099964412,
0.0203503072,
-0.0073493565,
-0.0408153608,
-0.0193894655,
0.0410904326,
-0.0637442693,
-0.0210355502,
-0.0264972746,
0.0207721051,
0.0164565053,
0.0692176446,
0.0017163802,
-0.0198970586,
0.0518175475,
0.0270810388,
0.0114155011,
0.0268292148,
0.0229340978,
-0.0012452323,
0.0135854278,
0.0394754037,
-0.0140175149,
0.0211263057,
0.0033103526,
-0.0321535878,
-0.0552389473,
0.0346987396,
0.0293534473,
0.0043259198,
0.0312831439,
-0.0084152287,
0.0067637917,
-0.0328713693,
-0.0276791416,
-0.0257615857,
-0.0202631056,
0.0002037366,
0.050135944,
0.0229745675,
-0.0263030306,
0.0220267493,
0.0059228349,
-0.0110626034,
-0.0145007726,
-0.0059343134,
-0.0093525834,
0.0470459796,
0.0167514272,
0.0026611737,
0.0083283912,
-0.0140838055,
0.0231377613,
0.0031186088,
0.0234068092,
-0.0024403371,
0.0579566509,
0.0363048054,
-0.0416118577,
-0.0329941213,
-0.0178346746,
-0.0209163614,
0.0083662495,
-0.0318532214,
0.0383507721,
0.0340308771,
0.0062189596,
-0.007511707,
0.0162252709,
-0.0249055512,
-0.0075134356,
0.0261791144,
0.0249433406,
-0.0218469277,
0.0535597056,
0.0121555198,
0.0009010623,
0.0310572032,
0.0502350032,
-0.0295240618,
0.0278421063,
0.0384004824,
-0.0528829098,
-0.0408553593,
0.0018315341,
-0.0026103244,
0.0366313495,
-0.0213256311,
0.0043171002,
-0.0618701056,
-0.0715902001,
0.0543297157,
0.0378451459,
0.0253714565,
0.0436789989,
-0.0159780607,
0.0834434777,
0.0458107963,
-0.0140274977,
-0.0313906111,
0.0065164706,
-0.0104660252,
-0.0064437501,
0.0007670166,
-5.931859674e-33,
0.0122378552,
-0.0548364334,
-0.0301628485,
-0.0238342807,
-0.0131271202,
0.0476341881,
-0.0105106886,
-0.0530534387,
-0.0365334637,
0.0658895075,
0.067715764,
0.0459826551,
-0.008215053,
0.0039345501,
-0.0514948852,
-0.0116911707,
0.0507362485,
-0.0026320284,
-0.0079775238,
0.0047429795,
0.0828976631,
-0.0057252063,
0.0341680199,
-0.1139062494,
0.0511836633,
0.006459923,
-0.0512019768,
0.021008214,
0.0025160511,
0.0680921003,
-0.0169012267,
0.058502432,
0.0418435894,
-0.0101374025,
-0.0142266583,
0.0136498734,
-0.0403357111,
-0.0039046737,
0.0534864478,
-0.0025141563,
-0.0394045524,
0.0158995651,
0.0360987708,
-0.0133909099,
-0.0092622992,
-0.0254468434,
0.0291731767,
-0.0233594328,
0.0222469345,
0.015572858,
-0.0641075298,
0.0101399338,
-0.0095297806,
-0.0037636745,
-0.0180042218,
0.0204384942,
0.0349808708,
0.0321898237,
-0.0888733789,
0.0037547683,
-0.0207828972,
-0.0336720236,
0.0541392565,
-0.0287660751,
-0.0152631998,
0.082929723,
0.0127610927,
0.0013156704,
-0.0431117974,
0.0118881864,
0.0016048567,
0.0482459851,
0.040931128,
0.1425898373,
0.0484386347,
-0.017617004,
-0.1107966006,
-0.0044012619,
-0.0287580453,
0.030426098,
0.023605207,
0.0075050825,
-0.0267182793,
0.0207848419,
-0.0454587378,
-0.0225522313,
-0.0535533316,
-0.0125781195,
-0.0000498327,
0.0260595996,
-0.0402592681,
0.0689437315,
0.0295041725,
-0.0580806434,
0.0089758011,
0.0198261179,
0.0093002589,
0.0121936826,
0.0355058238,
0.0300696902,
-0.0144346859,
-0.0068321722,
0.0608026646,
-0.0097475406,
0.0086639393,
-0.0090761902,
0.0641272739,
-0.0038751494,
-0.0103098871,
0.0001914977,
-0.0298840571,
0.0029544723,
-0.0092309117,
-0.0212290213,
0.0439430028,
0.01121624,
-0.0497737713,
-0.0162153896,
-0.0118594328,
0.0336845331,
0.022183653,
0.0028606106,
-0.0227942895,
0.0399784744,
-0.0228965748,
-0.01485267,
-0.0223541558,
-0.0338842757,
0.0289931651,
-0.1138108745,
0.0072843009,
0.0324042253,
2.647e-7,
0.0109630451,
0.0472159535,
0.0074781128,
-0.0256113689,
0.0538930409,
0.075676702,
0.0168037899,
0.0028019615,
-0.0232118536,
-0.1140681803,
-0.0293762311,
0.0414682589,
0.0035773285,
0.0163645372,
0.0113923056,
0.0406190716,
-0.0045693684,
-0.0407273993,
-0.0485284925,
0.0207791589,
0.0361110792,
0.0869976208,
0.0049080821,
-0.0497156829,
0.0144747989,
-0.0265138559,
0.0708312392,
0.0148060508,
-0.0488348715,
-0.0350378826,
0.0131772067,
-0.0409489833,
0.0157285817,
0.0418000072,
-0.0043344586,
-0.0362792015,
0.0017839127,
0.008389513,
-0.018348245,
0.0126837678,
-0.0539820492,
-0.0019070707,
0.0049427859,
-0.0336163007,
0.0459624566,
-0.0524253659,
-0.0526545569,
-0.0781573281,
-0.0571752191,
0.0062251082,
0.0222417992,
-0.0171867441,
-0.0182548277,
0.0202697385,
0.0103676803,
0.0043959334,
-0.0183201246,
-0.0411427729,
0.0393085442,
0.0162644479,
-0.0483825617,
0.0042681801,
0.0047448259,
-0.0335218087,
0.0934730843,
-0.0162919667,
-0.0007478761,
2.13123715e-34,
0.0659994632,
-0.0248264577,
0.0051653776,
-0.0487288348,
0.0312531628,
0.0265255384,
-0.0848779902,
-0.0395637341,
0.0054624788,
-0.0277973711,
-0.0118395034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01759v1 | Evaluation of Speaker Anonymization on Emotional Speech | 2023-04-15T20:50:29 | 2023-04-15T20:50:29 | Hubert Nourtel, Pierre Champion, Denis Jouvet, Anthony Larcher, Marie Tahon | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Speech data carries a range of personal information, such as the speaker's
identity and emotional state. These attributes can be used for malicious
purposes. With the development of virtual assistants, a new generation of
privacy threats has emerged. Current studies have addressed the topic of
preserving speech privacy. One of them, the VoicePrivacy initiative aims to
promote the development of privacy preservation tools for speech technology.
The task selected for the VoicePrivacy 2020 Challenge (VPC) is about speaker
anonymization. The goal is to hide the source speaker's identity while
preserving the linguistic information. The baseline of the VPC makes use of a
voice conversion. This paper studies the impact of the speaker anonymization
baseline system of the VPC on emotional information present in speech
utterances. Evaluation is performed following the VPC rules regarding the
attackers' knowledge about the anonymization system. Our results show that the
VPC baseline system does not suppress speakers' emotions against informed
attackers. When comparing anonymized speech to original speech, the emotion
recognition performance is degraded by 15\% relative to IEMOCAP data, similar
to the degradation observed for automatic speech recognition used to evaluate
the preservation of the linguistic information. | [
0.0153975226,
0.0784254372,
-0.0394944213,
0.0152160153,
-0.0344762094,
-0.026714243,
0.0924217403,
-0.0145653905,
-0.0367462039,
-0.011982359,
-0.0109134531,
-0.0108198635,
0.0195882972,
-0.0084037045,
0.0052385973,
-0.0702109188,
0.0115842754,
-0.0186460167,
0.026418848,
-0.0235787407,
0.0090688569,
0.023456106,
-0.0333669037,
0.0223915838,
-0.0345697403,
-0.0159223042,
-0.0117733618,
0.0173123535,
0.0201519467,
0.0154537177,
-0.0259422567,
-0.0062278546,
-0.0063333083,
0.0409985967,
0.0000018119,
-0.0426132567,
-0.0448594429,
0.0271084011,
-0.0456510559,
-0.015067813,
0.0522583276,
0.0186860934,
-0.0340131372,
0.0380127281,
-0.0263742544,
-0.0017621712,
0.028388191,
0.0529659316,
0.0928498581,
0.0384841785,
-0.0176850297,
-0.0068637184,
0.0297363866,
0.0135832727,
-0.0263279863,
-0.0028907168,
-0.0086700413,
-0.039745979,
-0.0191483032,
-0.0535392202,
0.0260293391,
0.0355678052,
-0.0402451083,
-0.0217072479,
-0.0056007355,
-0.0142718349,
-0.0535782166,
-0.0613790229,
-0.0050754026,
0.023255609,
0.0134043908,
0.0390060619,
0.045072116,
0.0512251034,
0.0026121791,
0.0017425368,
0.0043348148,
0.0050747767,
0.0019413877,
-0.0214384161,
-0.0370563082,
0.0726245269,
0.0113183744,
0.006276316,
0.0340817124,
0.0006161344,
0.0093975775,
-0.0264353454,
0.0096665407,
-0.0816138536,
-0.026603926,
0.0075174104,
0.0615205802,
-0.0284844451,
0.0180503186,
-0.0150491372,
-0.0579122789,
-0.0754642785,
-0.0362202078,
-0.0530700497,
-0.0009111686,
0.0036660151,
-0.0226407014,
-0.0344392657,
-0.0021029131,
0.0593318976,
0.0214917008,
-0.0059955097,
0.0046106339,
0.0034010261,
-0.0018128093,
0.015197319,
-0.0151886325,
0.0660520867,
-0.0218039155,
0.0102413539,
-0.0643396676,
-0.0106361117,
-0.0837227479,
0.0235988051,
-0.0539242364,
-0.0009314023,
-0.0322206579,
0.010375578,
0.0309567768,
0.0020111089,
-0.0016927473,
0.055927705,
-0.0271038637,
-0.0362082683,
0.0312658474,
-0.0185541846,
0.0214177351,
0.0012677835,
0.0177947152,
0.0612080656,
0.0390744135,
-0.0282723457,
-0.0148928557,
-0.0199378356,
0.0379512012,
-0.0313455611,
-0.0099085541,
-0.0116240643,
0.017229097,
-0.0604488999,
-0.0088250553,
-0.0203867368,
0.0092340689,
-0.0287621021,
-0.0161008872,
0.0742636248,
0.0112951957,
0.0154611729,
0.0648736581,
0.0337973349,
0.0170601364,
0.0001866907,
0.0299562253,
-0.0140180262,
0.0538745821,
-0.0461487807,
0.0304370113,
0.0094368244,
0.0265008789,
-0.0231749434,
0.0028572257,
-0.0192850605,
-0.0178602636,
-0.014143182,
0.0062197559,
0.0332507454,
0.0038875912,
-0.0736042634,
0.0567561798,
0.0638281479,
-0.0441060662,
0.0323279463,
-0.0422361083,
0.0207597706,
0.0289637055,
-0.0269363634,
-0.0138790496,
-0.0151652256,
-0.0799088255,
-0.0633628368,
-0.0111041917,
0.0132748438,
-0.0255248062,
-0.0119380737,
0.0086165974,
-0.0549437776,
0.0143565219,
0.0045186058,
-0.037370272,
0.0058290539,
0.0189209655,
0.0140587995,
-0.0387403369,
-0.0686401129,
0.0157087855,
-0.0219522901,
-0.0012421322,
0.0431358181,
0.0189356934,
0.0166118015,
0.042141635,
-0.0769344792,
-0.09326455,
0.0150865177,
-0.0318879969,
-0.0228235051,
0.0827687383,
-0.0106960321,
-0.0078006568,
0.0277359188,
-0.0230950583,
0.0417239517,
-0.0198348612,
0.0107405083,
0.0333954096,
-0.0137049733,
0.0588456541,
-0.0335892402,
-0.0092350505,
-0.0382683724,
0.0406695977,
0.0041814456,
0.0771343336,
0.0537671708,
-0.0120048169,
-0.0039507383,
0.0176313259,
-0.0025369818,
0.0226955414,
0.0429756567,
0.0293552112,
0.0100226132,
0.0214003175,
-0.0587602295,
0.0652636513,
0.0981636047,
-0.0035714949,
-0.028089229,
0.0672537759,
-0.0197040625,
0.0055099684,
-0.0065558157,
0.0412178338,
-0.011464729,
0.0719426945,
0.0241426118,
-0.0667790771,
0.0077517354,
-0.0056026303,
-0.0294887945,
0.0191129744,
0.0002803238,
-0.0397092439,
-0.0405636095,
-0.0055277878,
-0.0138552794,
0.0277267974,
-0.0116771497,
-0.0539219677,
-0.0352530144,
-0.0235660132,
-0.0835473463,
0.0122076413,
0.0035817334,
0.0077611855,
-0.0177888181,
0.0211535394,
-0.0154546229,
0.0087471083,
-0.0280510355,
-0.0511942059,
-0.02571721,
-0.0077006132,
-0.016754033,
-0.0053941165,
-0.058431983,
-0.0101517364,
0.0020532373,
-0.0201322772,
-0.0131291337,
-0.0329434648,
-0.04740417,
-0.0046832068,
0.0150640141,
-0.0357944593,
0.0567998514,
-0.0012151247,
-0.0287295114,
-0.030275166,
0.0556115024,
0.0110594127,
0.0433992296,
0.0407759137,
0.0091790706,
0.0013016018,
0.0131113557,
-0.0297215693,
0.0186483804,
0.0095736254,
0.0396259874,
-0.030000329,
-0.0307946783,
-0.0080097374,
-0.0291954894,
0.0446555838,
-0.0019459893,
-0.0074049491,
0.0107183522,
-0.004844849,
-0.059981551,
0.0232774708,
-0.0397362113,
-0.0115719847,
-0.0153401839,
0.0252018161,
-0.016278429,
0.0102129225,
-0.0481414534,
0.005242472,
-0.0160625502,
-0.0489040092,
0.0188599899,
0.0365121029,
-0.0124366861,
0.0228809658,
0.041031234,
-0.0523829162,
0.0078081521,
-0.0502155758,
0.0070649437,
-0.0850476548,
-0.0413847156,
-0.0029283394,
-0.0337829851,
0.0093984362,
0.0124001848,
-0.0247988887,
-0.0683425292,
0.0008824325,
0.0064862883,
0.0105661647,
-0.046816323,
0.0144778052,
-0.0010402509,
0.0575411469,
-0.0097452858,
0.0028415532,
0.0017248503,
0.0047402196,
0.026610041,
-0.000644935,
0.0168753266,
0.0090427836,
0.0359232277,
0.0299771391,
0.0294017512,
0.0637624189,
0.019633133,
0.0422367044,
-0.0367521569,
0.0012498671,
-0.0075991452,
-0.0397088379,
-0.005328049,
0.0099769132,
0.0063606575,
0.0372425579,
0.0828883126,
0.0081227385,
-0.0140761714,
-0.013746704,
-0.0247824173,
-0.0095366472,
-0.0044589192,
-0.0120937377,
-0.0407168344,
0.0516260825,
0.0373460278,
0.0926221535,
-0.0594397597,
-0.0137855271,
-0.0201749355,
-0.0713131949,
0.0137830395,
0.014009391,
0.0039794231,
-0.0183228869,
-0.0421638787,
0.0218381602,
-0.0110346274,
0.0429471657,
-0.056746237,
0.0003020788,
-0.028537903,
0.0236808546,
-0.0747251064,
0.0000900795,
0.0338878557,
-0.0111664943,
0.1190473288,
0.0439444594,
0.0706916153,
-0.0567882545,
-0.0317370817,
-0.0609444305,
0.0220567938,
-0.0329354331,
-0.0015823662,
0.0770631433,
0.0195152517,
0.000817531,
0.0360107012,
0.0429476947,
0.0444334149,
0.0056882678,
0.0375778265,
-0.0096220654,
-0.0235794727,
-0.0321972296,
0.0037028883,
0.0273685176,
0.0120883454,
0.0807779059,
-0.0230690911,
-0.0120257167,
0.0012297103,
0.0123350499,
0.0945513397,
-0.0175714288,
-0.0393063836,
0.0008634376,
-0.0035652253,
-0.0944890901,
-0.0468078814,
-0.0087320823,
-0.0525364764,
0.0603239909,
0.0077704275,
-0.0039003291,
0.0565516241,
0.0327570029,
-0.0354890488,
-0.038183745,
-0.0244127791,
0.052875001,
0.0205666628,
0.022711074,
0.0157408845,
0.0141839962,
0.0069382363,
0.011216416,
-0.0009878824,
-0.01686088,
0.0826530457,
0.0052163415,
0.020782765,
0.0669705272,
-0.0270160791,
-0.0428198241,
0.0730553865,
0.0000536719,
-0.0097721526,
0.024216691,
0.1305947453,
0.0007441917,
-0.0222664922,
0.0076027433,
0.0073331781,
0.0242390037,
0.0193604399,
-0.0325061679,
-0.0442762114,
-0.0527215302,
-0.0526501983,
0.0862858072,
0.0054074922,
-0.0005780591,
0.066529572,
0.0275546927,
0.021675352,
-0.0344147645,
0.042133972,
-0.0185053274,
-0.025431199,
-0.0122964252,
0.0385546722,
0.0474122204,
-0.0152136693,
-0.0178660899,
-0.0550660864,
0.0176357999,
0.0216288231,
0.0089137815,
0.0282423645,
-0.0373829417,
0.039063789,
-0.0129991574,
0.0589271486,
0.0591718331,
0.0441298783,
-0.028925756,
-0.0104156733,
-0.0261501241,
-0.0047129551,
0.0087031033,
0.0407717489,
-0.0382714532,
0.0171694439,
-0.0170759019,
0.0207212251,
-0.0182559546,
0.016889086,
0.0323705375,
-0.0232644454,
0.0450760797,
0.0024758498,
-0.0066657434,
-0.0670253932,
-0.0218326692,
-0.022384787,
-0.0143064242,
-0.0335892215,
0.0509283058,
0.0093262903,
-0.0445520394,
0.0608190782,
-0.0429157279,
-0.0179942176,
-0.0554826483,
-0.0114441337,
-0.0021320449,
0.0102539752,
-0.0047351792,
-0.0207990017,
-0.0183540937,
-0.0392211713,
0.0732018575,
-0.0428718291,
0.0072856331,
-0.0450957604,
0.0006103419,
-0.0062988536,
-0.0156365503,
0.0174918398,
-0.0464218855,
-0.0215677377,
-0.0128020216,
-0.0145493466,
0.0292973034,
-5.337682912e-33,
-0.0109260725,
0.0319839716,
-0.0511600934,
0.0061379387,
-0.0319840685,
0.0402978174,
0.0130208414,
0.023169063,
-0.0074513271,
-0.0145439543,
-0.0358775035,
0.0146796051,
0.0109316148,
0.0070517603,
-0.051599402,
-0.0033077376,
0.0543662347,
-0.0109315831,
0.0190208461,
0.012437623,
0.0568261184,
0.0170118026,
0.0205856543,
-0.1574746072,
0.0145107294,
0.0308141802,
-0.0825155973,
-0.0118548842,
0.0202451758,
0.0065502645,
0.0107846251,
0.015642399,
-0.0277240966,
-0.0018002001,
-0.0175032299,
0.0176315568,
-0.0380874313,
-0.0262195896,
0.0038089871,
0.0160180964,
-0.0033216071,
-0.0389239341,
0.0030212195,
0.0185601041,
-0.0486675836,
-0.0020208918,
-0.0061234883,
-0.0421137773,
0.0064258059,
-0.0645162016,
0.0092243506,
-0.0063016424,
-0.0529550537,
0.0077379919,
0.0653045326,
0.0331322215,
0.0091732079,
-0.0579593368,
-0.0486451164,
0.0270414855,
-0.0062276456,
-0.024279641,
0.0195785258,
-0.0149309486,
0.0218513384,
0.0347994864,
0.0633304715,
-0.0142183062,
-0.0030449622,
0.0212007556,
0.0451141074,
0.0508202799,
0.0574133694,
0.0359564722,
-0.0223148186,
-0.0736477301,
-0.002098195,
0.0310373735,
0.0467097461,
-0.0361791477,
0.0286179706,
0.0343001597,
-0.0628137663,
-0.0097420793,
-0.052880235,
-0.0657406673,
-0.0022504977,
-0.0235534329,
-0.0027849481,
-0.0309347697,
-0.0438388288,
-0.0061380742,
0.0248996355,
-0.0574237145,
-0.0010191668,
0.0310761277,
0.0127575491,
0.0320758373,
-0.010519118,
-0.0106475567,
0.0382829271,
-0.0058289086,
0.0805696994,
0.0073078237,
0.0724173784,
-0.0446027257,
0.0005645364,
0.04915189,
-0.0676289797,
-0.0573146753,
0.0273423325,
0.0688452125,
0.0207189973,
-0.0169134233,
-0.0211133976,
0.0014356098,
0.0029509855,
-0.0293563996,
0.041395992,
0.0377280898,
-0.0302270837,
0.0366880819,
-0.0152917812,
0.0338430777,
-0.0298383441,
-0.0072582914,
0.0098374048,
-0.0122305769,
0.0365696698,
0.0185380839,
0.01353129,
-0.0632600933,
2.782e-7,
-0.077529937,
-0.0000504974,
0.0165025648,
-0.0531975999,
0.0034322564,
0.0704708397,
0.0543029979,
0.0320624672,
0.0019641598,
-0.0213674158,
0.0024827903,
-0.0470021181,
0.0835272968,
0.057880573,
-0.0355207138,
-0.0398638025,
0.0193963014,
-0.0086110784,
-0.0445621386,
0.0621791407,
0.0723915324,
0.0899327025,
0.0653192699,
-0.0552699119,
-0.0313049555,
0.0103981551,
-0.0331520997,
-0.0319316238,
-0.0353427939,
-0.0133120408,
0.0305566881,
0.0070693246,
0.0349685885,
0.0171012301,
-0.0280587394,
0.0342739932,
-0.0022738036,
0.072294414,
0.0187681857,
-0.0455771126,
-0.0113209402,
-0.005451519,
-0.0373234078,
0.0446073748,
0.0323999338,
0.0328506827,
-0.0568056181,
-0.016981747,
-0.0764342621,
-0.0108902613,
0.0324806273,
-0.0074183336,
-0.014793871,
0.0287466496,
-0.0051442832,
-0.0142067112,
-0.0169018283,
-0.0437041,
0.0015389924,
-0.0196126252,
-0.0168083441,
-0.0320428759,
0.0299563967,
0.0335554332,
0.0134601435,
0.0279264562,
0.0374975391,
2.072724623e-34,
-0.0397397727,
-0.0010391111,
-0.0137150921,
0.0219864491,
0.0057451311,
0.0046877442,
0.0428818054,
0.01011365,
0.0008798713,
-0.0456912667,
-0.0030359116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02518v1 | Analyzing the Performance of ChatGPT in Cardiology and Vascular Pathologies | 2023-04-15T20:08:48 | 2023-04-15T20:08:48 | Walid Hariri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The article aims to analyze the performance of ChatGPT, a large language
model developed by OpenAI, in the context of cardiology and vascular
pathologies. The study evaluated the accuracy of ChatGPT in answering
challenging multiple-choice questions (QCM) using a dataset of 190 questions
from the Siamois-QCM platform. The goal was to assess ChatGPT potential as a
valuable tool in medical education compared to two well-ranked students of
medicine. The results showed that ChatGPT outperformed the students, scoring
175 out of 190 correct answers with a percentage of 92.10\%, while the two
students achieved scores of 163 and 159 with percentages of 85.78\% and
82.63\%, respectively. These results showcase how ChatGPT has the potential to
be highly effective in the fields of cardiology and vascular pathologies by
providing accurate answers to relevant questions. | [
0.0322544388,
0.0061420687,
-0.0075956825,
0.001054185,
-0.0343034938,
0.0275558066,
0.001746431,
0.0427840985,
0.0406393707,
-0.0139873959,
0.0258083325,
-0.0258757621,
-0.0050803232,
-0.0042769513,
-0.0192778204,
-0.0561201312,
0.0144937998,
-0.0196564645,
0.0319665298,
-0.0130135883,
-0.0261618588,
0.0038564203,
-0.0335241072,
0.0470039696,
0.0505036749,
-0.0567013547,
0.0203855392,
-0.0644042566,
0.0077331401,
-0.0529398471,
-0.0146208005,
0.0455633737,
-0.0410505049,
-0.003977831,
0.0000023255,
-0.0817612261,
-0.0073805633,
0.0375247262,
-0.0259143542,
0.0145303076,
0.0349442102,
0.0192484315,
0.0207120609,
0.0250971783,
-0.0691751391,
-0.0163037628,
0.0362822078,
0.0285891239,
0.0533985719,
0.0366583727,
0.004158448,
0.0068782074,
0.054488007,
-0.0079953764,
0.0385250412,
-0.0492605641,
0.0337313451,
0.0416149981,
0.0498105213,
0.0149085978,
-0.0247161537,
0.0530440509,
0.0270099211,
0.0454148054,
0.0211009979,
0.0428117998,
-0.0251073837,
-0.0094580045,
0.0229211207,
0.0382570326,
0.0094969114,
-0.0009997875,
-0.0209084302,
0.0005178903,
0.0079530803,
0.0304852854,
-0.0687590018,
-0.0002690935,
-0.0206178781,
-0.0126803778,
0.0246765167,
-0.0335380882,
-0.008670642,
0.0155754946,
-0.0186647065,
-0.0420227945,
0.0210247524,
-0.0150719257,
0.0219896957,
-0.0058956789,
-0.0479673035,
-0.0218484737,
0.0195425563,
0.0572645999,
-0.0433315188,
0.0122503592,
0.0268494133,
-0.0078934142,
0.0802674815,
-0.0995653719,
-0.0115125766,
0.034059599,
-0.0052366038,
0.0142127788,
-0.0132358624,
0.0296195056,
-0.0260750018,
0.0713861287,
-0.0730621144,
0.0218686704,
-0.0854951367,
-0.0271982383,
-0.0127360905,
0.0541314185,
0.0075770472,
-0.0132082906,
-0.0959738642,
-0.0371273868,
-0.0217480976,
-0.016663434,
0.0037367356,
0.0367331468,
0.0040338491,
0.0248281788,
-0.0546119027,
0.0507624857,
-0.0249818098,
0.0051198262,
-0.0196974371,
-0.0036995707,
0.0395030454,
0.001268039,
-0.0061255693,
-0.020048596,
0.016231386,
0.0528132394,
-0.0201148782,
-0.0077767349,
0.0061463541,
-0.0384122357,
-0.0275121089,
-0.0410546698,
0.0096442522,
-0.0810053498,
0.0050904197,
0.0293294769,
0.0281676948,
0.0161844008,
0.0356477536,
0.0535248816,
-0.0321477428,
0.0235006027,
-0.0440197252,
0.0255089179,
0.0534252189,
0.0458679423,
0.034874443,
0.0040713474,
0.0505872816,
-0.05122637,
0.0094292769,
-0.0505391732,
0.0030681994,
0.0002353925,
0.0108423494,
-0.0466978066,
0.0325032808,
0.0366267711,
0.0484873056,
0.0809251368,
-0.0531047396,
0.0710763112,
0.020465415,
0.0148342941,
0.0158482548,
0.0573617592,
0.0290656295,
0.0331467763,
-0.0071601276,
-0.0491300337,
0.0400408059,
0.012609534,
0.0113430703,
0.0115876999,
0.0014203879,
0.0246111229,
-0.0345398374,
0.0026630317,
-0.0146912988,
-0.0443860777,
-0.0725068599,
0.0075891437,
-0.0172401704,
-0.0045256075,
0.0341893137,
-0.0339760445,
-0.0218008999,
0.0312058963,
0.022335628,
-0.0264206454,
-0.0193115864,
-0.0694958195,
0.0108208023,
0.034119837,
0.0670118034,
-0.0069589992,
-0.0162164271,
-0.0020730603,
0.0226670336,
0.0232496858,
0.05184526,
-0.0180736575,
-0.0143151321,
-0.0407892093,
0.0098591,
0.0211434942,
0.0009348558,
-0.0207579099,
0.0200934075,
0.05282709,
-0.044745747,
-0.0197066516,
-0.032301344,
0.0290596932,
-0.0525012054,
-0.0381904542,
-0.0133829117,
-0.0000616248,
0.014341237,
-0.0065383264,
0.0016926964,
0.0295619853,
0.0016735805,
0.0005685708,
-0.0379911251,
-0.0429658033,
-0.0336365961,
-0.0094939806,
0.0513812117,
-0.0460788161,
-0.0282678325,
0.0071227639,
-0.019281406,
-0.0232016295,
-0.0412909165,
-0.0232740901,
0.0076047117,
0.0069337958,
-0.0113667054,
0.0120330453,
-0.0094127692,
-0.04296593,
0.0223408807,
0.0425656773,
0.0347375423,
0.0432130173,
-0.0078293029,
0.0219121221,
-0.0261944458,
-0.0464923792,
0.0069868937,
-0.0078445049,
0.0293655749,
-0.0021441474,
0.0442727432,
-0.053727977,
-0.0290307216,
-0.0952347368,
0.0005872247,
0.045837231,
-0.0017177325,
0.0168891978,
-0.0052967551,
-0.0118574388,
-0.0139066558,
-0.0306369662,
0.0054228702,
0.039024312,
0.0070579224,
0.010106694,
0.040498592,
0.0200386513,
-0.0448859967,
0.015739765,
-0.0581373349,
0.0049175406,
0.0627525076,
-0.0075070537,
0.0501816273,
0.0134716481,
-0.0474780872,
-0.0149664162,
0.0512510799,
-0.0434466675,
0.0284356792,
-0.0130790602,
-0.0268160962,
0.0420509316,
0.0199947748,
0.0174417533,
0.0292277578,
-0.0055083474,
0.0047411639,
0.0124152936,
-0.0443600416,
-0.0500103943,
0.0143311815,
-0.0483010858,
-0.0399770923,
0.0624226294,
0.0316358432,
0.0020846189,
-0.028215332,
-0.0151496157,
-0.0619011857,
0.0412821248,
-0.099288851,
0.0054662633,
-0.0370693952,
0.0415766016,
0.0339111127,
-0.0050432412,
0.0762070492,
0.0087922243,
0.0347855426,
-0.0941551328,
0.0017619708,
-0.0375116281,
0.048336193,
-0.0517500564,
0.0251654517,
0.0213524811,
0.0024762014,
-0.0515305512,
0.0008076003,
-0.0062668757,
-0.0645651296,
0.0442606099,
-0.061290659,
-0.0011753254,
0.0134964529,
-0.0121436678,
-0.042769216,
0.0314092189,
-0.012725736,
0.0074611837,
-0.0135954609,
0.0263516679,
-0.0098369056,
0.0169697031,
-0.0315791629,
-0.0085622165,
-0.0457032658,
-0.0219017975,
-0.0106274793,
0.0594973266,
0.0444198735,
0.0104671102,
0.0028048749,
0.0014618721,
0.0954663903,
0.0973917544,
0.0139607936,
0.0162305217,
0.0226863194,
-0.0156374816,
0.0137318112,
-0.0360522121,
0.0119717559,
0.0338106975,
0.0030607574,
-0.0298890918,
-0.0529850945,
0.1044337824,
0.0547210164,
-0.0107680131,
-0.0050579449,
-0.0220253076,
-0.0078705996,
-0.0200928021,
0.0304308739,
-0.0971725732,
-0.0041786074,
-0.031935256,
0.0332891159,
-0.0017701373,
0.0046398505,
0.0132595459,
-0.0468601808,
0.0341985449,
0.0153726377,
-0.092111066,
0.003268596,
-0.0387561396,
-0.0245512351,
-0.0014581737,
0.003948296,
-0.0128371576,
-0.0061651897,
0.0239976365,
0.0133675374,
-0.0828853175,
-0.0243294872,
0.0776391029,
-0.0073524169,
0.0315907374,
0.0157069154,
0.0354605354,
-0.0233280845,
-0.0307812523,
0.0365589485,
-0.0149913467,
0.0148300277,
-0.0274632387,
0.0590323657,
0.0305411946,
0.0230541527,
-0.069513157,
0.0210390333,
-0.0400747955,
-0.009521083,
0.0530904233,
0.1078921258,
-0.0124151278,
-0.0202685799,
-0.0522477031,
0.0225492101,
-0.0111914622,
0.0274021607,
0.0223016962,
-0.0076013012,
0.002947923,
-0.0261318497,
0.0311071519,
0.0339998566,
-0.0343119092,
0.0116600208,
-0.0345507935,
-0.0327244066,
-0.0212898124,
-0.0430010743,
0.0746930242,
-0.0279736109,
0.0298117399,
0.0568584539,
0.0355104692,
0.022887744,
-0.0285320282,
0.0380313769,
0.0145201031,
0.0344460569,
-0.0411468036,
-0.030718483,
0.0413677096,
0.0172226448,
-0.0320624076,
0.0111716827,
-0.0135414954,
0.0156040536,
-0.0046389997,
0.0670607686,
0.0307060406,
-0.038279321,
-0.0316405408,
-0.0042040036,
-0.0239722542,
0.0146154054,
-0.0126828542,
-0.0106249144,
-0.0458479561,
-0.0053122258,
0.0256325491,
-0.0277254656,
-0.0102814101,
-0.0160842016,
-0.0073892414,
0.0452723689,
-0.0017353599,
-0.0168011133,
0.0434852764,
0.0701360628,
0.0513467304,
-0.0100339204,
-0.0377859101,
-0.0169214308,
0.0321713462,
-0.0217308216,
0.0125681767,
-0.006323223,
0.0031883961,
0.0515133552,
0.0069628879,
-0.0112678539,
-0.073900044,
-0.06403815,
-0.0348075554,
-0.043048352,
0.0583548024,
0.0235684887,
0.013023098,
0.0420242921,
0.011603931,
-0.031109374,
-0.0371248387,
0.0171304904,
0.0292854141,
-0.0018574109,
0.1010182127,
-0.0344161019,
0.0243765675,
0.0446663722,
-0.0059677209,
-0.041198276,
-0.042566102,
-0.0193910524,
0.0786931217,
0.0193138551,
0.0156433396,
-0.0217606332,
-0.0183563344,
-0.0004673977,
-0.0115159201,
-0.0030668778,
-0.0384537727,
-0.0093018515,
0.0790104046,
-0.0029062184,
0.0185193215,
-0.0384008624,
0.0880641192,
-0.0375221036,
0.0347778387,
0.0032461451,
-0.0513060018,
-0.0349933654,
-0.0190394837,
-0.0034815175,
0.0477262959,
-0.0549995489,
0.0182372257,
-0.0683089346,
-0.0561829135,
-0.0128886523,
0.0376912579,
-0.0166509934,
-0.0248098113,
0.0366983302,
0.0387647972,
-0.0197252594,
-0.0238855332,
-0.0468991511,
0.0848413929,
-0.0789261609,
-0.0027857518,
0.0223143138,
-5.907613633e-33,
-0.018345328,
-0.0329185538,
0.0692246929,
-0.0135924565,
0.017847592,
0.0232094806,
-0.0326884463,
0.0244051386,
-0.0463106483,
0.0413008556,
-0.0329363942,
-0.0077193766,
0.0134289702,
0.0429892465,
0.0149266133,
-0.0605260804,
-0.0209109914,
0.0145829134,
-0.0049875858,
-0.0071954415,
-0.0312047973,
0.0121877342,
0.0387862809,
-0.0581819899,
0.0159937739,
-0.0114182578,
0.0242641177,
-0.0136836953,
-0.0339106396,
0.0574076958,
-0.0234498717,
0.0581254959,
0.0224319026,
-0.0193056073,
0.0157379471,
-0.0097860554,
-0.0406852104,
-0.0516429357,
0.0404824503,
-0.0032938353,
-0.0280187596,
-0.0195806865,
0.0116757881,
0.0018066228,
-0.0261654276,
-0.0246640127,
0.0367703363,
-0.0463615358,
-0.0261742827,
0.0089251092,
-0.0415171608,
0.0121265119,
-0.0012729958,
-0.0154430745,
-0.0614390485,
-0.0061125453,
-0.0391048789,
-0.0007472837,
-0.0176863689,
0.0193925276,
0.0647168532,
0.0138100749,
0.0097134607,
-0.0383550599,
-0.0281380657,
0.027635444,
0.0246703308,
-0.0448087677,
0.0039038446,
0.0178094581,
-0.03991469,
0.0224530082,
0.119016096,
0.0281588715,
-0.0048887203,
-0.0219444931,
-0.0967243984,
0.0380805694,
-0.0189109314,
0.0117047438,
-0.0287016109,
-0.0295236278,
-0.0442969091,
-0.024617549,
-0.0194256827,
0.007571789,
-0.0333961323,
-0.0483717956,
0.0386675969,
-0.057727918,
0.0294714067,
-0.0264129583,
0.0297537651,
-0.0328992307,
0.0043544946,
-0.0432568081,
0.0227729809,
0.0256966855,
-0.0275678337,
0.0327026993,
-0.0458507426,
0.0310708433,
0.0062729307,
-0.0185158271,
0.0280380212,
0.0165216327,
-0.0140507938,
-0.0408038236,
-0.0499288253,
-0.0077744755,
-0.0180165824,
-0.036110945,
0.0336069576,
-0.0164890867,
0.0087307878,
0.0402187705,
0.0062116133,
0.0556826144,
-0.0115731098,
0.0091270441,
-0.0507533401,
-0.0553809889,
-0.0270127393,
-0.0282897465,
-0.0371316597,
0.0064177751,
-0.0227711163,
0.0525752828,
-0.004588929,
-0.0685137585,
-0.0063601779,
0.0195308141,
2.862e-7,
0.1085159183,
0.0619752258,
-0.0245034955,
-0.0300338212,
-0.0040526781,
-0.0076815379,
-0.0271658339,
-0.0335639045,
0.0474793948,
0.0135298623,
0.021891905,
0.0091107218,
0.0093536098,
0.0440724641,
-0.0672693178,
-0.0261078719,
-0.0669197068,
0.0100945476,
-0.0275743771,
0.0243759919,
0.0712098032,
0.0671522319,
-0.0547449626,
-0.0219312888,
-0.0226061605,
0.012201055,
0.031719815,
-0.0068929279,
-0.0192058906,
0.0333398171,
-0.0123981955,
-0.0125014307,
0.0441359691,
0.044336509,
-0.0195936821,
-0.0612216368,
0.0578709468,
0.0607426874,
-0.0208008662,
0.0094669843,
0.0294399597,
0.0144980745,
0.0365257822,
-0.0889757946,
0.0556644909,
-0.0628261417,
-0.0479065515,
-0.0403983109,
0.008452381,
-0.0152901923,
0.0724586323,
-0.0184348971,
-0.0319419689,
0.000475306,
0.0192733202,
0.0353596099,
-0.0270254649,
-0.0048701228,
0.0064418144,
-0.0168052763,
-0.0162186418,
-0.0629472733,
0.0047358526,
-0.0220048334,
0.023015989,
-0.0517730229,
-0.0283162966,
2.336435301e-34,
0.0029036985,
0.0140898265,
0.0113191018,
0.0249900203,
0.0342183746,
-0.0124268262,
0.0670091882,
0.0258826893,
-0.0060263285,
-0.0374867134,
-0.0267641656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07625v1 | Neural Approaches to Entity-Centric Information Extraction | 2023-04-15T20:07:37 | 2023-04-15T20:07:37 | Klim Zaporojets | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) has huge impact on our daily lives with
applications such as voice assistants, facial recognition, chatbots,
autonomously driving cars, etc. Natural Language Processing (NLP) is a
cross-discipline of AI and Linguistics, dedicated to study the understanding of
the text. This is a very challenging area due to unstructured nature of the
language, with many ambiguous and corner cases. In this thesis we address a
very specific area of NLP that involves the understanding of entities (e.g.,
names of people, organizations, locations) in text. First, we introduce a
radically different, entity-centric view of the information in text. We argue
that instead of using individual mentions in text to understand their meaning,
we should build applications that would work in terms of entity concepts. Next,
we present a more detailed model on how the entity-centric approach can be used
for the entity linking task. In our work, we show that this task can be
improved by considering performing entity linking at the coreference cluster
level rather than each of the mentions individually. In our next work, we
further study how information from Knowledge Base entities can be integrated
into text. Finally, we analyze the evolution of the entities from the evolving
temporal perspective. | [
0.0495234393,
0.0381005369,
-0.0200036373,
0.0122966282,
-0.0267868657,
0.0154114738,
-0.0499703735,
0.0097067887,
0.0494073927,
-0.0403982028,
0.0472882725,
0.0248580333,
-0.0033866335,
-0.0053904871,
0.0319809616,
-0.063420184,
0.0376888923,
0.0220901873,
0.017739173,
0.022250222,
-0.0067304685,
0.0002128594,
-0.0103226723,
-0.0103203878,
-0.0318085402,
0.0014502791,
-0.0222675838,
-0.0133336466,
0.0548193082,
0.0040415563,
-0.0254385397,
0.0157416128,
-0.0042304518,
0.029370252,
0.0000019328,
-0.0472122468,
-0.0444919392,
-0.0060130549,
-0.0389343128,
-0.0058992538,
0.0021113758,
0.000974306,
-0.0220762417,
-0.055411268,
-0.0350962654,
0.0014743072,
0.0314929374,
0.0701674074,
0.052937977,
0.0780535117,
-0.0146793118,
-0.0427647643,
0.0656846464,
-0.0230057817,
-0.031241674,
-0.0543418527,
0.0337827168,
-0.0455542691,
-0.0009398436,
0.0303035434,
0.0141247157,
0.0500771329,
0.02104575,
0.0088053122,
0.0436396152,
0.0693141595,
-0.0454228669,
-0.0025618279,
-0.0055938731,
0.0778627992,
0.002871119,
0.0075837602,
0.0514975786,
0.0387000591,
0.0046529607,
-0.032188382,
-0.0156533979,
0.0036592502,
-0.0176289715,
0.0104169426,
0.0397830643,
0.0162157565,
0.0169630069,
0.0122691449,
-0.043116428,
0.0473190546,
-0.0161405131,
-0.0417132713,
0.0212651137,
0.0166863818,
-0.002743317,
-0.0432380587,
0.0426991321,
0.0526531152,
0.0214081742,
0.0444417261,
-0.0511071719,
0.0144904712,
-0.0183380004,
-0.0773269162,
-0.047179006,
0.0035012853,
-0.0146432491,
0.0525359213,
-0.0360373259,
0.0094085867,
-0.0348265432,
-0.0498523526,
0.0051339152,
-0.0430845991,
-0.0599290431,
0.0073402296,
-0.026720034,
0.0551445968,
-0.0547741763,
-0.0113595994,
-0.0260184463,
0.0260645058,
0.0220245961,
0.0455815978,
-0.0175693724,
0.0218103454,
-0.0087613929,
0.0104303956,
-0.0350091644,
0.0064190119,
-0.0432170108,
-0.0337564908,
-0.0362976268,
0.0087966463,
0.01112979,
-0.0039666346,
0.0206018314,
-0.0292276628,
-0.0106621515,
0.0858625174,
0.0375039615,
-0.0265289005,
-0.0671980157,
-0.051356446,
-0.0070793303,
-0.0259587988,
-0.0322452672,
-0.0384278856,
0.037003208,
-0.0196305942,
-0.0319469683,
-0.0870670378,
0.0239543747,
-0.0025264577,
-0.0814601481,
0.0531144589,
-0.0586205609,
-0.0007433032,
0.0552744567,
0.0197328068,
0.0439382307,
0.0313194841,
0.0427603759,
0.0040985052,
0.0411936715,
0.0466594882,
-0.0521197021,
0.0233738888,
0.0439567193,
-0.032371249,
0.037204355,
-0.0094864964,
-0.0709225982,
0.0177604612,
-0.0164860189,
0.0610624589,
-0.0358809829,
-0.0181331076,
0.0319028422,
0.0337593146,
-0.0082825385,
0.0222306885,
0.0227807034,
-0.0168590937,
0.0092888819,
0.0161570683,
-0.0767871961,
-0.0028657049,
-0.0420508645,
0.0019691817,
-0.0172672682,
0.0309740584,
-0.0130460206,
-0.0292478558,
0.0351907723,
0.0224618092,
0.0205532387,
-0.0230446402,
0.0490964949,
-0.0072984747,
-0.0203764774,
0.0488932729,
0.0269609857,
-0.0158046279,
0.0197614115,
0.0146473628,
-0.0145653272,
0.0264409538,
0.0257041007,
-0.0058519291,
-0.070713155,
-0.0073953909,
-0.0030274629,
0.0295490641,
0.0015838577,
-0.0559208505,
0.015537166,
-0.0055853287,
0.0041934215,
0.0460793376,
-0.0083145536,
-0.0025259985,
0.0221599154,
0.0374093726,
0.042114947,
0.0074076224,
0.0072869523,
0.0542857051,
-0.0248424951,
0.0019575572,
-0.0316931978,
0.0704214647,
-0.0213829316,
0.0546064302,
0.016343765,
-0.0327003263,
0.0485378355,
-0.0218237713,
-0.0223587565,
0.0423508771,
0.0009010113,
-0.0300223697,
0.0299639199,
-0.0232634321,
-0.026146682,
-0.0507372655,
-0.0283893198,
-0.0480080359,
0.0188740455,
-0.0054069944,
0.0796199813,
0.0159322079,
0.0245166421,
0.0225700177,
-0.0123233711,
-0.0623804629,
0.1103766933,
-0.0132676046,
-0.026367601,
0.0190887842,
0.0068086302,
-0.0001411014,
-0.0574687421,
-0.0325369947,
0.0061722747,
0.0069089322,
-0.0477100499,
0.0265371799,
-0.0097321784,
-0.049202811,
-0.005169712,
-0.0746819973,
0.0051242257,
-0.0035464067,
0.0358289368,
0.0457509384,
0.0128742671,
-0.0060776384,
-0.0197748709,
0.0032207677,
-0.0160821807,
-0.0325271115,
-0.0178427305,
0.0502223074,
0.0277160536,
-0.0428047255,
-0.04219684,
0.0064781085,
-0.0614374503,
0.0302209854,
0.0109175686,
-0.0894573778,
-0.0577398278,
0.0211753808,
-0.019105373,
0.0442880914,
-0.004945518,
0.026119398,
-0.0149192084,
0.0165129341,
0.0449544266,
0.0785947666,
-0.0268075094,
0.0693661645,
-0.0280194152,
-0.0372978002,
-0.0245014299,
0.0432793424,
-0.0255921949,
0.0784780532,
-0.0396132246,
-0.0186282452,
0.0469800159,
0.0480447635,
-0.0199365187,
-0.0184083097,
-0.0135285854,
0.0280679315,
-0.0145846354,
-0.0229092445,
0.0235971734,
-0.0132412603,
-0.0130911693,
0.0190560985,
-0.0277129039,
-0.0007017102,
0.039162416,
0.0099559352,
0.0283625275,
-0.0204403829,
-0.0119040953,
-0.0336868055,
0.0542222075,
0.0236038156,
0.0361795053,
0.0560553335,
-0.0609341972,
-0.0211393274,
0.0640584752,
-0.0289178845,
0.0340889134,
0.0599913932,
-0.0406276807,
0.0196829196,
0.0204846766,
0.0151819941,
-0.0256047454,
0.0244557466,
-0.0195975062,
0.0143376021,
-0.0213647075,
-0.0177494586,
-0.009579448,
0.003301136,
-0.0004216689,
0.0049615665,
0.0142907863,
-0.0202922262,
-0.01295383,
0.0421650894,
0.0428777561,
0.0136920074,
0.0122438902,
0.0388862491,
0.0091276327,
0.0491205677,
0.0481937602,
-0.0071670897,
-0.0044490425,
-0.0218386147,
-0.0044592493,
-0.1197760701,
-0.0567748733,
-0.0117680002,
-0.006455828,
-0.0451137125,
-0.0233812053,
0.1211904585,
0.0421271175,
-0.0175072029,
0.0201045144,
0.0468727648,
-0.0273321755,
0.0041351975,
0.0216314942,
-0.0129688466,
-0.0100530293,
-0.0065359799,
-0.0339132473,
0.0001471906,
-0.0872472152,
0.0149685089,
-0.0549301915,
-0.01575456,
-0.0364129655,
-0.082501106,
-0.046335347,
-0.0131941652,
0.0222378131,
-0.0406670868,
-0.0328885987,
0.0104922587,
0.0139646167,
0.0058945687,
-0.0074299709,
0.0045937104,
-0.024200147,
0.0075463043,
-0.0760321543,
0.0472003482,
0.0800556466,
0.081564188,
0.0018711955,
0.031232683,
-0.0229096245,
-0.0312420279,
-0.0108513879,
0.003501866,
0.0468774512,
-0.0384233147,
-0.0019081127,
0.0068001403,
0.0245695431,
-0.0197627116,
0.0049790745,
0.0038155406,
0.0473671667,
0.0034839942,
0.0242049303,
-0.0184100717,
-0.0359780565,
-0.0083013875,
0.06123548,
-0.0240507629,
-0.0287293009,
-0.0010709547,
-0.0042117503,
0.015624322,
-0.0157684609,
-0.013353046,
0.0064085661,
-0.0592394248,
0.0030764148,
-0.0990436897,
-0.0488655791,
0.0089030433,
0.0525215603,
0.0250805635,
0.0048208414,
0.0594581813,
-0.0343827829,
-0.050633397,
-0.0119622611,
-0.0203854777,
-0.0035342558,
-0.0150707131,
-0.0007588558,
0.0339534916,
0.0352044739,
-0.0260581207,
0.0185811613,
-0.056607116,
-0.0570797138,
0.0101382956,
-0.0226931553,
0.0155205019,
0.0625614673,
-0.0653847829,
-0.0563374646,
0.0395769589,
0.0039675958,
-0.0660650283,
0.0125623979,
-0.0082583316,
0.0373587981,
-0.0059452956,
0.0407464467,
-0.0415606052,
0.0042001782,
-0.0017125191,
0.0347482711,
-0.0727601349,
-0.0499088988,
0.0029134557,
0.0023925533,
0.025968384,
0.0161587652,
0.0263250321,
-0.0147867324,
0.01071514,
-0.0096474793,
-0.0049725175,
0.0107511748,
-0.0017464026,
-0.0092132157,
0.0700429752,
-0.0142833395,
0.0265887529,
0.0233567469,
0.0124312704,
-0.0251413658,
-0.0266186725,
0.0339663774,
0.0130283898,
-0.0089401891,
0.003208308,
0.037550576,
0.029994946,
-0.0083553111,
0.0613418631,
-0.0513462909,
-0.0104867192,
0.0285419673,
-0.033486601,
-0.0179220717,
0.0439761281,
-0.0691030174,
0.0287094899,
-0.0048757102,
0.029207306,
0.0446458161,
0.0037831762,
0.0537142567,
-0.0069117197,
-0.0190178417,
0.0383631475,
0.0000394161,
0.0249923952,
-0.0084200306,
0.0046590567,
0.0221077949,
-0.0089635281,
0.0387310013,
0.0188502725,
-0.0080687981,
0.040722128,
0.0121228257,
-0.0113107515,
-0.0475407951,
-0.0071674893,
0.0158722643,
0.0069926325,
-0.0267728735,
0.029590942,
-0.0450856499,
-0.0385222845,
0.0908081383,
-0.0072617363,
0.0275517981,
0.0082758171,
0.0303302221,
0.0038469897,
0.0433687195,
-0.023739215,
-0.0373776779,
0.0089341793,
-0.0345355719,
-0.054246977,
-0.0067714923,
-6.009945927e-33,
-0.0691898391,
-0.0000884985,
0.0278370082,
-0.0034738006,
-0.0688523576,
-0.0035391992,
-0.020943284,
-0.0269806851,
-0.0572233424,
-0.0375768133,
-0.0269207079,
0.0014866533,
0.0071715848,
-0.006441934,
-0.0258061923,
-0.0099751931,
0.0030678895,
0.0091089569,
0.0226680655,
-0.0007513437,
0.0455026217,
0.0521074831,
0.1000292227,
-0.0757132396,
0.0537654087,
0.0268456824,
-0.0106948977,
0.0555147193,
0.0600398183,
0.0406763069,
-0.0204842202,
0.0060779275,
0.0061207931,
-0.0582670942,
0.0238923579,
-0.0115408814,
-0.1530417353,
-0.0473711528,
-0.025423117,
0.0192944538,
-0.0186064262,
-0.024212895,
0.049995169,
-0.012475119,
0.0681684464,
0.0346420631,
0.0562681817,
0.0106659299,
-0.026790712,
-0.0280744433,
-0.0724082366,
0.0453308634,
-0.0125150466,
0.0495225117,
0.0222439617,
-0.0131652486,
0.0074481256,
-0.0032256925,
-0.1002570614,
-0.0230783988,
0.0184730235,
-0.0021392503,
-0.0158228055,
-0.010480281,
0.0168007966,
0.0250336733,
0.032323502,
-0.0248355269,
-0.0745344386,
0.0522080101,
0.0411839299,
0.0333646573,
-0.0305703655,
0.0239888597,
-0.0240894575,
-0.0061989054,
-0.0825982094,
0.0369743668,
0.038666632,
0.0121112941,
-0.0563812852,
0.002722152,
-0.0622580573,
0.0099920109,
-0.0173032042,
-0.0654227659,
-0.0041142455,
-0.0358472578,
-0.013502717,
-0.0143108862,
-0.0531364009,
0.0480179638,
-0.0099293329,
-0.0412804894,
-0.0112847798,
0.0018234003,
0.0034162251,
0.0306330808,
0.0179074947,
0.0172236655,
-0.0762701929,
-0.0371574238,
-0.0102446629,
0.0128702,
0.0189283155,
-0.0119181341,
0.0318008102,
-0.0090120276,
-0.024695145,
-0.0147776268,
0.0112702977,
-0.0048618293,
-0.0154495314,
0.0046869982,
0.0115050003,
-0.0046132561,
-0.0032948016,
0.0088617634,
0.0856299624,
0.0258559436,
-0.0237920079,
0.0484165139,
0.0523496307,
-0.0010779378,
-0.0151661858,
-0.0279276166,
0.0235198196,
0.0196536444,
-0.004751978,
-0.068722643,
-0.0178066995,
-0.0064452449,
2.698e-7,
0.0353230163,
0.0274533778,
0.0519865714,
0.0182910468,
0.0066393763,
0.0100858668,
0.0634980276,
0.0278028343,
-0.0323788933,
-0.0458827466,
0.0072031077,
0.0064976565,
-0.0493712351,
0.0186376497,
-0.1015531719,
-0.03151967,
-0.0099162376,
-0.0163912959,
-0.0451193042,
0.0094105015,
0.0295640156,
0.0660083815,
0.0633344874,
0.0128577854,
-0.0552483648,
0.0063729445,
0.0072045564,
0.0264687464,
0.0218203478,
0.0273125526,
-0.0159451365,
0.0214966051,
-0.0616722293,
0.0455390401,
0.0114432247,
0.0864984766,
0.0307838414,
0.0441264771,
-0.0179275144,
0.0014877254,
0.0078864638,
-0.0793380961,
0.0136089884,
0.000582289,
0.0779372752,
-0.0378013663,
-0.0186250098,
-0.0103146825,
-0.0247392133,
0.0286476836,
-0.0187581833,
0.0163756367,
-0.017643204,
0.035926383,
-0.0062389816,
-0.022160653,
-0.0135024143,
-0.1073194891,
0.0143839391,
0.0105360616,
0.0047775861,
0.0045615504,
0.01569397,
0.0000141297,
-0.0017028077,
-0.0067255865,
-0.010555435,
2.068124583e-34,
-0.0393828824,
0.0116555439,
-0.0296283644,
0.0517799519,
0.0104670106,
-0.0270267632,
-0.056969028,
-0.0151477195,
0.0087173926,
-0.0536182821,
-0.01189542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07619v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07619v4 | Can ChatGPT Forecast Stock Price Movements? Return Predictability and Large Language Models | 2023-04-15T19:22:37 | 2023-09-09T15:20:54 | Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Yuehua Tang | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL | We examine the potential of ChatGPT and other large language models in
predicting stock market returns using news headlines. We use ChatGPT to assess
whether each headline is good, bad, or neutral for firms' stock prices. We
document a significantly positive correlation between ChatGPT scores and
subsequent daily stock returns. We find that ChatGPT outperforms traditional
sentiment analysis methods. More basic models such as GPT-1, GPT-2, and BERT
cannot accurately forecast returns, indicating return predictability is an
emerging capacity of complex language models. Long-short strategies based on
ChatGPT-4 deliver the highest Sharpe ratio. Furthermore, we find predictability
in both small and large stocks, suggesting market underreaction to company
news. Predictability is stronger among smaller stocks and stocks with bad news,
consistent with limits-to-arbitrage also playing an important role. Finally, we
propose a new method to evaluate and understand the models' reasoning
capabilities. Overall, our results suggest that incorporating advanced language
models into the investment decision-making process can yield more accurate
predictions and enhance the performance of quantitative trading strategies. | [
0.0210195873,
0.0660714433,
-0.009565155,
-0.0108683119,
-0.0183396842,
-0.0282547679,
0.0137373516,
0.0537124909,
0.026037639,
-0.0260102861,
0.0254955404,
-0.0448824987,
-0.0362181962,
0.0639974475,
0.0136697078,
-0.0316641368,
0.0107707772,
-0.0153870229,
0.0504195839,
-0.0226089079,
0.019816421,
-0.0150980391,
0.0795037299,
0.0212942883,
-0.0118290475,
-0.0011047295,
-0.0298981033,
0.0103347944,
-0.0254329424,
-0.0102361823,
0.0081361141,
-0.0003487649,
0.0020209297,
0.0403546393,
0.000001754,
-0.0214817058,
-0.0189298354,
-0.0037734003,
0.0581323281,
-0.0025142133,
0.0289340951,
-0.0549083129,
0.0401301868,
0.0058797933,
-0.0608956553,
-0.0054662148,
0.0502547063,
0.0596378371,
0.0365281589,
0.083717078,
-0.0145642515,
-0.0195675194,
0.0333618559,
-0.0769769624,
0.0150632691,
-0.0765113086,
0.0212740675,
-0.0022156453,
-0.0310492031,
0.0131968288,
-0.0034633761,
0.0419731699,
-0.0290999245,
0.039756991,
-0.0276150405,
0.0201214179,
-0.0071306229,
0.0094970791,
-0.0162406862,
-0.0230230559,
-0.0053052329,
-0.008482215,
0.0149033861,
-0.0022473973,
-0.0017205483,
0.0376379117,
-0.0481902882,
-0.0149758058,
0.012024275,
0.0363707393,
0.0277276449,
0.002600889,
0.0158420447,
0.0047279559,
0.002718993,
0.0593911,
-0.027059285,
-0.0187230166,
0.0271159299,
0.0278775729,
-0.0060532349,
-0.0397846252,
-0.025044458,
0.0107360287,
0.0250164103,
0.0209747069,
0.0106437225,
0.0055153966,
-0.0219726712,
-0.1295552105,
-0.0637941584,
0.0614575818,
0.0089630224,
0.0233829804,
-0.0707352832,
0.0323015153,
0.0266018212,
-0.0596501119,
0.014171198,
0.0092455577,
-0.0521569736,
-0.0190745294,
-0.0282884706,
0.0738724768,
0.001213512,
-0.0168433189,
-0.0654326007,
-0.0274970531,
-0.0119015006,
0.006036167,
0.032491643,
-0.0171745028,
-0.0425944813,
-0.0267750062,
-0.0229183193,
-0.0119962292,
-0.0273548383,
0.0236760937,
-0.0286408421,
-0.0349528417,
0.0247592814,
-0.0111525608,
-0.046112638,
0.0155422837,
0.0189705249,
0.0979824886,
0.0064846077,
0.000666946,
-0.0151182516,
-0.0771837533,
-0.0160602871,
-0.0408611894,
-0.0198196415,
-0.0249487963,
-0.0291020535,
0.0031244548,
0.0179640111,
-0.0161088482,
0.0188978948,
-0.0326931626,
-0.0346565582,
0.0470704548,
0.0374201536,
-0.0187539309,
-0.024585858,
-0.0204444882,
0.0376107544,
0.0782846808,
-0.0271294117,
0.0399135128,
0.0572568104,
-0.0061293272,
-0.0128526045,
0.0416821353,
0.0206871461,
-0.0434304848,
-0.0402315296,
0.0081620598,
-0.0006254293,
-0.0497054569,
0.0089991577,
0.0329533629,
0.0189764835,
-0.0167948268,
0.0533503927,
0.018132478,
0.0413428247,
0.086869508,
-0.0133701228,
-0.020677777,
-0.0082624806,
-0.0281643886,
0.0173729267,
0.0025620393,
-0.0538720191,
0.0288397595,
0.0068337684,
0.0182821415,
-0.0292396825,
-0.0256884284,
0.0107308393,
-0.014930144,
0.0229866616,
-0.0329427831,
0.0265030768,
-0.0985144451,
-0.0382482782,
0.0636056811,
0.0490716211,
0.0048167594,
0.0067920671,
-0.0534697473,
0.0182051677,
0.0599259362,
-0.0176141597,
0.0138589609,
0.0275655705,
-0.0109548066,
-0.0326750837,
0.0160623845,
0.019429218,
0.0332135446,
-0.0655135736,
-0.0262354556,
0.0094462326,
0.071462594,
0.0418448113,
0.0435881019,
-0.0154338833,
0.0322162472,
-0.0106564602,
0.0054913531,
-0.0212130565,
-0.0182469543,
0.0286915265,
-0.0297665056,
0.0117159141,
-0.0454368442,
0.01837801,
0.0156127568,
0.0005692313,
-0.0026774285,
-0.0057577477,
0.013247842,
-0.0949150696,
0.0337964855,
-0.0504404716,
0.0061927,
-0.01119278,
0.0099528413,
0.0521323234,
0.0137408162,
0.010652517,
-0.0233360343,
0.0256489143,
-0.0495260097,
0.0404995941,
-0.0445551239,
-0.0620347112,
-0.0049913651,
0.0011630834,
0.0073649548,
0.0282250997,
-0.0258563235,
0.0208945107,
-0.0611873269,
-0.0146508515,
0.0090343906,
-0.0060335146,
-0.0104635544,
0.0592585951,
0.0171366297,
0.0615267605,
0.0606685542,
-0.0084125325,
0.0287416931,
-0.0702072158,
-0.0755925328,
-0.0361339338,
-0.0065943799,
0.0148168085,
0.0185069554,
-0.0034121994,
-0.0009815415,
0.0008966319,
-0.0384093747,
-0.0128378607,
0.0069180964,
0.0107206572,
0.0229233522,
0.0118448902,
-0.0190386325,
-0.0333121829,
-0.0386502743,
-0.0307650268,
0.0345529988,
0.0511129461,
-0.0388956144,
-0.0155208092,
0.0052246572,
-0.0239097103,
0.0172678288,
-0.0111395475,
-0.027669413,
-0.0131895766,
-0.0430598147,
0.011239009,
0.0483190045,
0.0255646463,
0.0212692432,
-0.0318446271,
-0.022398429,
-0.0252245646,
0.0180725511,
-0.037532948,
-0.038953647,
-0.0257362425,
-0.0531513616,
-0.0218240321,
0.0530478768,
0.0065861102,
-0.0147515954,
-0.1213244796,
0.0327827111,
-0.0157160293,
0.0628371984,
-0.0481229424,
0.0107364226,
0.0078706546,
0.0598661229,
0.0349141993,
-0.0652725995,
0.0433569774,
-0.0156162083,
-0.0244945697,
-0.0105682435,
-0.0045554354,
-0.0692021996,
0.0152607979,
-0.0198014788,
0.0080794822,
-0.0476869531,
-0.0060191178,
-0.0107961027,
-0.0465608947,
-0.0050737448,
-0.0307088029,
0.0277361479,
-0.0047888169,
0.0296208691,
0.0364314727,
0.0090216398,
0.0245393012,
-0.0409854576,
-0.0542738847,
0.0222183969,
0.0854783878,
-0.0474237278,
-0.0333860554,
0.0609862246,
-0.0160699598,
-0.0496003851,
-0.0367487594,
-0.0374258421,
0.0512719043,
-0.0151178678,
0.0538799912,
-0.0423101,
0.0119160535,
-0.0276841205,
0.0482885018,
0.0041299593,
0.0382800363,
0.009383169,
-0.0206754468,
0.0161704365,
0.0139984116,
0.0342733748,
-0.0352168269,
0.0340252966,
-0.0096531827,
-0.0405250192,
0.0017364623,
0.0818954185,
-0.012154432,
0.0243491121,
-0.0045270752,
0.0363605283,
0.0411695614,
-0.029501155,
0.0055891853,
-0.0331443138,
-0.0172748882,
-0.0251937266,
0.0127740102,
0.0008094324,
-0.0435413197,
-0.0325249694,
-0.1138601005,
0.0402437598,
-0.0027684213,
-0.039801456,
-0.0243381672,
-0.0502037704,
-0.0041744853,
-0.0544783734,
-0.0111935521,
0.02248431,
-0.0221530143,
0.0437911749,
0.0155443503,
-0.1259608418,
0.0124202836,
0.0208344664,
0.0239790026,
-0.0327342376,
0.0283840168,
0.0078686094,
-0.0479450524,
0.0522727966,
-0.0279171038,
-0.0069307992,
0.0317095816,
-0.0132097639,
0.0677628964,
-0.0308522042,
-0.0195059851,
-0.0109782964,
0.0324779488,
0.0327427983,
0.0609403066,
0.0033531687,
-0.0080918875,
-0.0032554953,
-0.0926011354,
0.0229512714,
0.0695882216,
0.0129186213,
0.0472654812,
-0.0029767049,
-0.0386155397,
-0.051951427,
-0.0623587668,
0.012401375,
-0.0173334908,
-0.0579994656,
-0.029269306,
0.0149636278,
-0.0402393043,
-0.0777843148,
-0.0777187347,
-0.0196748003,
0.0336684585,
0.0001669622,
0.0452785306,
0.0424400419,
0.0380721129,
-0.0322598778,
0.0070358622,
0.0335145332,
-0.0148358159,
-0.0380407199,
0.0422435962,
0.0567031913,
-0.0088034365,
-0.0315565914,
0.0134777334,
-0.0805876628,
-0.0608730689,
0.0054704282,
0.0408202559,
0.033115074,
-0.0350047685,
0.0110645052,
0.0328299664,
0.0110953813,
0.0779851377,
-0.0244727302,
-0.0138281006,
0.0605508499,
0.0424777567,
0.0164169725,
0.0362466164,
0.0088948542,
0.0279229637,
-0.0432010368,
0.0009328927,
-0.0347843431,
-0.0111504272,
-0.0326169282,
0.0129980408,
0.0469892956,
0.0181437545,
-0.0492185205,
0.0120110586,
-0.0266148932,
0.0114155402,
0.0071673621,
-0.0236048345,
-0.0256559644,
0.0214983858,
0.0162780043,
-0.0508119911,
0.0419027731,
-0.0132987862,
-0.0517450608,
-0.0148811033,
0.0195574481,
-0.0317772962,
0.0062215785,
0.0478182025,
-0.0085803019,
0.0037579257,
-0.0480164886,
0.0246947967,
-0.001652985,
-0.0065199188,
0.0042228247,
0.0302545838,
0.0081266854,
-0.001449776,
-0.0602213591,
-0.051917024,
-0.068384707,
-0.0129703218,
0.0755695179,
-0.0226740539,
-0.0151614249,
0.0133466311,
-0.0731840879,
0.0236290041,
0.0170772932,
0.024608776,
-0.0035805714,
-0.0152684031,
0.0197882894,
-0.0161390975,
-0.0871134251,
-0.0182158723,
0.0751888677,
0.0115069365,
0.0252519008,
0.0046624439,
-0.0464020446,
-0.0317106359,
-0.0246471409,
0.075733684,
0.0094456766,
0.0135547305,
0.0244523212,
-0.0500809439,
-0.0344153158,
0.0177467652,
-0.0036715288,
0.0203821845,
-0.0094298115,
0.0144673912,
0.0583443604,
-0.0082679996,
0.080233112,
-0.0091975061,
0.0085429214,
-0.0382448323,
-0.0036877911,
-0.0616865382,
-5.872348068e-33,
-0.0020638916,
0.003223947,
-0.0006788989,
0.0218978673,
0.0360343643,
0.020989025,
-0.0310461465,
0.0390077494,
0.0064180754,
0.0347154029,
0.0257425066,
0.0242644195,
0.0005351735,
0.0082767839,
0.0484953821,
-0.0058230516,
0.024397485,
-0.0135595091,
0.0074954522,
-0.0197496824,
0.0443966947,
0.0617940873,
0.0409749523,
-0.0174005143,
0.0188435707,
-0.0166757479,
-0.0838769898,
-0.0255422592,
0.0508382395,
0.0238331091,
0.0291296802,
0.0413105711,
0.0240108166,
-0.0696997643,
-0.0018304,
0.0142411776,
0.0489509366,
-0.0441086218,
0.0270168483,
0.0015783913,
0.0373876765,
0.0356211998,
0.0348871499,
-0.0011783134,
-0.0286844987,
0.0226559453,
0.0202557463,
0.0011195578,
0.0039476547,
-0.0233768672,
-0.0349113829,
0.020833252,
0.0115298443,
0.049979303,
0.0265344586,
0.0753867701,
0.0041429456,
0.0284260344,
-0.024427088,
0.0067317071,
0.0039095706,
0.0566297434,
-0.0184762329,
0.0020196363,
-0.004225072,
0.0515766069,
-0.0027200687,
0.0101525104,
0.01679077,
0.0401789434,
0.047180485,
0.0394216664,
0.0409431085,
0.04077309,
0.040941786,
-0.03762592,
-0.0554760918,
0.0129581662,
0.0198792927,
0.0247128215,
0.0582834743,
0.0018016472,
-0.0543283373,
-0.0707977712,
0.0267263297,
0.0115161948,
-0.0035596215,
-0.036854405,
0.0136397779,
-0.0054756361,
0.0153100714,
0.0281971525,
0.0333169848,
-0.0136811826,
-0.0784002393,
0.0244708154,
-0.0534233116,
0.0069097192,
-0.0180221945,
0.0223297663,
-0.0230411887,
-0.0248978157,
-0.0134871332,
0.0308465809,
-0.0332842097,
-0.0492137484,
0.0107107088,
0.0181255154,
-0.0574317127,
-0.0533108376,
-0.0028680416,
0.0238920134,
0.0252636839,
-0.0402809754,
0.0380952582,
-0.0005646589,
-0.0074208677,
0.0306068193,
-0.0097935619,
0.0189892724,
0.0087476214,
0.0003061756,
-0.0025815601,
-0.0105007561,
0.0156532079,
0.0186216738,
0.0193996634,
0.0493393876,
0.0127981706,
-0.0313076228,
-0.0133239534,
0.0293231178,
2.562e-7,
0.0460209325,
0.0895047709,
-0.0409881845,
0.0373901501,
0.018322248,
0.0550265647,
-0.0267275833,
0.0126168625,
0.0224347245,
-0.000830173,
0.0326450504,
0.0107151689,
0.0448591337,
0.0437522233,
-0.0503957756,
-0.0727523491,
-0.0802320763,
0.0035475143,
-0.0613304861,
0.0277749542,
0.0345766507,
0.0613333806,
0.0230800025,
0.0054532993,
-0.0079179229,
-0.0420651101,
0.0558841564,
-0.0724317431,
-0.0335899293,
0.0142541267,
0.0336128138,
0.0317231193,
-0.0219123662,
0.0225897208,
-0.0164485555,
0.0065007377,
0.0227947738,
0.0130782127,
0.0145786293,
0.0508036874,
0.024745902,
0.0076478431,
-0.0523221716,
-0.0580681451,
0.0399489962,
-0.0778896213,
-0.0285924412,
-0.0454168729,
-0.031565696,
0.0246503614,
0.031272497,
-0.0078472458,
-0.0187720768,
0.034320049,
-0.0218582768,
-0.0139096361,
0.0397839509,
-0.0190628935,
-0.0467813574,
0.0376777239,
-0.0702165216,
-0.0058214301,
-0.0438841395,
0.0277215093,
0.0217882451,
-0.0482275076,
0.0541404709,
2.185167775e-34,
0.0868755952,
0.0016180353,
-0.0484529398,
0.0051545193,
0.0722874179,
0.0042327819,
-0.0153773986,
0.0458185375,
0.0106763989,
-0.0497438684,
-0.0372183733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07611v1 | A CTC Alignment-based Non-autoregressive Transformer for End-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-04-15T18:34:29 | 2023-04-15T18:34:29 | Ruchao Fan, Wei Chu, Peng Chang, Abeer Alwan | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, end-to-end models have been widely used in automatic speech
recognition (ASR) systems. Two of the most representative approaches are
connectionist temporal classification (CTC) and attention-based encoder-decoder
(AED) models. Autoregressive transformers, variants of AED, adopt an
autoregressive mechanism for token generation and thus are relatively slow
during inference. In this paper, we present a comprehensive study of a CTC
Alignment-based Single-Step Non-Autoregressive Transformer (CASS-NAT) for
end-to-end ASR. In CASS-NAT, word embeddings in the autoregressive transformer
(AT) are substituted with token-level acoustic embeddings (TAE) that are
extracted from encoder outputs with the acoustical boundary information offered
by the CTC alignment. TAE can be obtained in parallel, resulting in a parallel
generation of output tokens. During training, Viterbi-alignment is used for TAE
generation, and multiple training strategies are further explored to improve
the word error rate (WER) performance. During inference, an error-based
alignment sampling method is investigated in depth to reduce the alignment
mismatch in the training and testing processes. Experimental results show that
the CASS-NAT has a WER that is close to AT on various ASR tasks, while
providing a ~24x inference speedup. With and without self-supervised learning,
we achieve new state-of-the-art results for non-autoregressive models on
several datasets. We also analyze the behavior of the CASS-NAT decoder to
explain why it can perform similarly to AT. We find that TAEs have similar
functionality to word embeddings for grammatical structures, which might
indicate the possibility of learning some semantic information from TAEs
without a language model. | [
-0.0442039892,
0.0497988909,
0.0273432191,
0.0284008551,
-0.0122588295,
-0.0030208174,
0.0309787523,
-0.0602275729,
-0.0343445502,
0.0164983906,
-0.0228627808,
-0.0320311636,
0.0656792298,
0.0291676056,
0.0109433085,
0.0180158019,
0.0366426483,
-0.0273882467,
0.0008090361,
-0.0100412285,
-0.0162114613,
-0.0178667121,
-0.0570320003,
0.053567104,
-0.0335301161,
-0.0214826781,
-0.0285719465,
-0.0014402575,
0.028002657,
-0.0409202129,
-0.0274054073,
-0.0039185169,
0.0194229316,
0.0313460566,
0.0000021022,
-0.0034160181,
-0.0193428956,
0.0093118139,
-0.0411737636,
-0.0224823989,
0.0046197851,
0.0053371578,
-0.000733638,
0.0652339384,
0.001655135,
-0.0264500305,
0.0662731379,
0.0453967899,
0.0279380698,
0.0641088411,
0.0088610202,
-0.0484101288,
0.0484722629,
-0.022914391,
-0.0275232941,
-0.0073952656,
-0.0305078384,
-0.0196231771,
-0.013312622,
-0.0537507571,
-0.0597257242,
0.059407454,
0.0369005576,
-0.0075613623,
0.0482701957,
0.0174555909,
-0.0406291597,
-0.0162023902,
-0.0494513884,
0.0369913653,
0.007265937,
-0.0235901661,
-0.011870956,
0.0267310776,
-0.0382809117,
-0.0208181534,
0.0067110173,
0.0094703771,
0.0176047273,
0.021906374,
0.0258172564,
0.0386638865,
0.0063157012,
-0.0376617238,
-0.0376497619,
-0.0248794723,
0.0039937026,
-0.0447631441,
-0.0230318177,
-0.0148816388,
0.0435558148,
-0.0117704039,
0.0373380966,
0.0256877039,
-0.0083820373,
-0.0193689615,
-0.0380952097,
-0.0520654097,
-0.0280091651,
0.0068056118,
0.0094627403,
0.0730032101,
-0.0391726419,
0.0094654551,
-0.0598021559,
0.0845365375,
-0.0397009961,
0.0261230413,
-0.0210885368,
-0.0254983231,
0.0022850095,
-0.0098767383,
-0.0500201136,
0.0059187734,
-0.0084242756,
-0.0334071144,
-0.0545146316,
0.0396801569,
-0.0001895841,
0.0164200328,
0.0168273635,
0.0023847751,
-0.0819122717,
-0.0197747424,
0.0370759927,
0.0492812619,
0.0288580284,
-0.0060032117,
-0.0049663815,
-0.0424215309,
-0.0686610043,
0.0351099893,
0.0464454405,
-0.0085557941,
-0.0031399492,
0.0636936352,
-0.0309214871,
-0.0444193631,
0.0094720982,
0.0195150767,
-0.0313987136,
-0.0285871644,
-0.0187018905,
-0.0213606507,
0.0431378186,
0.0235562269,
0.0040231654,
-0.0071732579,
-0.0100425817,
-0.0144361695,
0.0366779789,
0.0623276755,
0.0436206907,
-0.0149689373,
0.052017305,
-0.0357275531,
0.0243502967,
0.025716532,
0.0510952547,
-0.0160879567,
-0.0478501692,
-0.015044177,
-0.0016672581,
0.0215095282,
0.0123466337,
-0.0231653117,
-0.0570837408,
0.0042042187,
0.0557374693,
0.0504635908,
0.0613810457,
0.0376401395,
-0.0048519336,
-0.0187879205,
0.0412182584,
0.0190662071,
0.0518752299,
0.0088661322,
0.0456468053,
-0.0059380196,
-0.0135546168,
-0.0408726595,
-0.0187878534,
0.0564532131,
-0.0048567564,
0.0464210659,
0.0417147279,
0.0408143401,
-0.0301631242,
-0.0120985014,
0.0136249363,
-0.0332079343,
0.0026523999,
-0.0045100576,
0.0647334903,
-0.0031465003,
-0.0689444914,
0.0242920648,
-0.0323032327,
-0.0424669534,
0.0035954635,
-0.0216096789,
-0.0088209156,
0.0046178857,
0.0283493195,
0.0040665297,
-0.047993578,
-0.0451961495,
-0.0271980464,
0.0653693676,
-0.0129178073,
0.0388501324,
0.0074514118,
-0.0697393045,
-0.0285761002,
0.0199403279,
-0.0317311436,
0.0580125302,
-0.0131761609,
0.0669992045,
0.027214529,
-0.0192064214,
0.0327950269,
0.0101288119,
0.0041380394,
-0.0261105001,
0.0083806608,
0.0471660011,
0.0547968782,
0.0333725885,
-0.007673345,
-0.004274467,
0.0174104515,
-0.0563147999,
0.0033165994,
0.0654937401,
-0.0990756899,
-0.0731972754,
0.0351172872,
-0.037105307,
-0.0044313176,
0.0615142472,
0.0200222936,
-0.0824295282,
0.0386038311,
-0.0441826209,
0.0867549554,
-0.0554182865,
0.0613688119,
0.0690052733,
0.0163883399,
0.0564106368,
-0.0019506034,
-0.0345274061,
-0.0068897507,
0.0377450995,
0.012953179,
-0.0381017998,
-0.0656021684,
-0.0416697972,
0.0008196555,
-0.0098548243,
-0.0198420435,
-0.0002299269,
-0.0204934292,
0.0082246847,
-0.0303325746,
-0.0543693565,
-0.019924663,
-0.0192685463,
0.0257043447,
-0.0373074152,
0.0215198211,
0.0154289762,
-0.0252106227,
-0.0276139267,
-0.0170452408,
-0.0197342895,
-0.0178121068,
-0.0146797579,
-0.0344769917,
-0.0647843331,
0.0070425486,
0.0188214909,
-0.0021787314,
0.0356012769,
-0.024541866,
-0.0118310731,
-0.0615860671,
-0.0360875651,
0.0328933783,
0.0182252228,
-0.0129329357,
-0.0427609012,
-0.011540072,
0.0383231379,
0.0242563691,
0.0522644855,
0.0516525768,
0.0018094907,
-0.0185039043,
0.0117192557,
-0.0424346887,
0.0333772004,
0.0024410328,
0.0201699361,
0.0123920459,
-0.0008666794,
-0.0270688105,
0.0911557749,
0.0174814295,
0.0533065312,
-0.0729964226,
-0.0461482927,
0.0048106266,
-0.0293219965,
0.0142542673,
-0.0179185234,
-0.057414867,
-0.0442892313,
-0.0306124631,
-0.0340960175,
0.0389985405,
-0.0964400619,
-0.0497217365,
-0.0149313593,
-0.0334220566,
-0.0175064132,
0.0206974074,
0.0175730642,
0.0048579406,
-0.0271714348,
-0.0826703161,
-0.0055068112,
0.028381519,
0.0149524305,
-0.0402412191,
0.0445883796,
0.0477636904,
-0.0031399832,
-0.0147806443,
-0.0199203715,
-0.040947929,
-0.0118265823,
-0.0051313993,
0.0088325329,
0.031983532,
-0.0305506662,
-0.0306425616,
0.0571589731,
0.0049772519,
0.0709807426,
-0.0086980769,
0.0055232816,
-0.0247848146,
0.074499853,
0.0363144353,
0.0230767466,
-0.0339394026,
0.0048309267,
0.0311169699,
0.0020894932,
0.0565491244,
0.010240416,
-0.0742154792,
-0.0379209667,
0.0176362991,
-0.0129140168,
0.0484470241,
-0.006122421,
0.0274862759,
-0.0306589566,
-0.0091375541,
0.0845450237,
-0.0025488841,
-0.0397468731,
-0.0216505472,
0.0160949323,
-0.0071539111,
-0.0122197876,
-0.0399165675,
-0.0546918251,
-0.0295383092,
0.0442920029,
0.0416104309,
0.0320063904,
0.0270328932,
-0.0110668037,
-0.068311058,
0.0316531882,
0.0231348425,
-0.0649791732,
-0.0560008064,
-0.0464522392,
-0.0325774066,
-0.0445512831,
0.0687009394,
0.0299709681,
-0.0242914334,
-0.0282979328,
0.0283006765,
-0.0598474853,
-0.0186327081,
-0.010090013,
-0.0167970024,
0.0861806422,
0.0357227772,
0.0078577157,
0.0182925127,
-0.0375712104,
0.0595934168,
-0.0044269636,
0.0265907291,
-0.0001800463,
-0.0113088442,
-0.0476099849,
-0.0125721972,
0.0347512737,
0.0368114486,
-0.0194775872,
0.0297366027,
-0.0127162402,
0.0945570692,
-0.0206255335,
0.0311936066,
-0.0009577789,
-0.0108905006,
0.0078884857,
0.0707090348,
-0.0025327115,
-0.0302995518,
-0.0423055962,
0.020675173,
0.0375498347,
-0.0305826105,
0.0075781113,
0.006438191,
0.0131531656,
-0.0728659034,
-0.0002891642,
-0.030774476,
0.0041616266,
0.0330551527,
-0.0023661896,
-0.0088098431,
-0.0195070412,
0.0096965954,
-0.0669330433,
0.0108298343,
-0.0134986416,
0.0107797887,
-0.0738883764,
0.0208694264,
0.0191007778,
-0.0426457934,
-0.0048977281,
0.0336597785,
-0.0625439882,
-0.0596468449,
0.0090847444,
-0.0254195947,
0.0014631994,
0.09409336,
-0.0152675686,
0.018536143,
0.1042374745,
0.0172834527,
-0.0357120596,
0.0007945116,
0.0284271687,
0.0068008923,
-0.0106800897,
0.0029908866,
-0.056784831,
-0.0007241904,
-0.0317222476,
0.051032953,
-0.0166058913,
-0.0181584246,
0.016084969,
0.018530786,
0.0610102341,
-0.0106553836,
0.0563436933,
-0.0041207494,
0.0636884645,
0.0020042467,
0.0734571666,
-0.0056101312,
0.0049474197,
0.013946997,
0.0113350945,
0.0000592138,
0.0265387185,
-0.0043422519,
-0.0314424038,
-0.0000175573,
0.0744970217,
-0.0190341957,
0.01922209,
0.0174766686,
-0.018530773,
-0.0339018479,
-0.0164775774,
0.0336080119,
0.0207111184,
-0.0153153734,
0.0294193644,
0.01230912,
0.0587118939,
-0.0166176334,
0.0148622729,
-0.0132098319,
0.0441948436,
-0.024978999,
-0.0108027728,
0.0147573082,
0.0054865754,
0.0328814574,
-0.011079533,
0.0292897578,
0.0222882275,
0.026082186,
-0.0382001586,
-0.0017156103,
0.0255161822,
-0.0112200584,
-0.0028564981,
0.0098427553,
0.0326113589,
-0.0128622213,
-0.0027654704,
-0.0292528979,
0.0325566083,
-0.0483619496,
-0.0113161914,
-0.0291324835,
-0.0464270897,
-0.0308805704,
-0.0198486671,
0.0307112709,
-0.044372797,
0.0509024449,
-0.0139076589,
0.0019391441,
-0.0057812659,
-0.0031723084,
0.006333278,
0.0025175896,
-0.0447512828,
0.0423031114,
-0.0050454619,
0.0253848191,
-0.0292180888,
-0.0201235693,
-6.539180299e-33,
-0.0105341077,
0.0087294979,
0.0008428718,
-0.0156203024,
-0.0550242551,
0.0445415601,
-0.0010041959,
-0.0140875038,
0.0188760478,
-0.0305306148,
-0.0159597024,
0.0145583069,
0.0268312078,
0.0326116085,
0.0306431521,
0.007943552,
0.0911762193,
-0.0248713866,
-0.0262005143,
-0.0114460001,
0.0410370342,
0.0240074974,
0.0221994575,
-0.0327396728,
-0.0506043211,
0.0191938262,
0.0306128673,
-0.0184496436,
0.0618826933,
0.0244383756,
-0.0068826042,
0.0175947696,
-0.014450008,
-0.0596769191,
0.0114766844,
0.0141387656,
-0.1319921315,
-0.0023414446,
-0.0278477464,
0.0454769246,
-0.0095193218,
-0.0349498019,
0.0294976681,
0.0208449103,
-0.0258085486,
-0.0470669419,
0.0138463369,
-0.0070978203,
-0.0118414629,
-0.068696171,
-0.0112751992,
0.0281289816,
-0.0397710316,
-0.0359493084,
0.0502429679,
0.0475046411,
0.0105694169,
-0.0131476419,
-0.1122826487,
0.0196241494,
-0.003663898,
0.0130562149,
0.0755641907,
0.0417602547,
0.0039563514,
-0.0069314968,
0.0244698431,
-0.0461165085,
-0.0211828556,
-0.0412400886,
0.0109330453,
-0.0088820402,
0.0011576514,
-0.0356180482,
0.037133161,
-0.0292381365,
0.0011060871,
-0.0047218953,
0.0310607292,
0.0699630603,
0.0523274541,
0.0239807367,
-0.0842455104,
0.0323874205,
-0.0156919751,
-0.0322389081,
-0.0298902653,
-0.0204318892,
0.0621517636,
0.0389425084,
0.0215947479,
-0.0269377902,
0.0732736811,
0.0108544603,
0.0561335944,
0.0415049754,
0.022846723,
-0.012578587,
-0.0311541054,
0.0355736651,
-0.0413099937,
-0.0051675942,
0.0231114496,
0.0155236349,
0.0226432234,
-0.0284546148,
-0.0033428269,
0.0613139495,
-0.092140168,
-0.0050285077,
-0.0040873387,
0.035261441,
-0.0262251254,
-0.0458196215,
0.0610839278,
-0.0163097046,
0.011885698,
0.0282590277,
-0.0343414806,
0.0557418577,
-0.0149401519,
0.0227023084,
0.0282340888,
0.015067799,
-0.0085063921,
0.0386848785,
0.0081886947,
0.0369893312,
0.0048075137,
-0.0426944532,
0.006912645,
0.0530811846,
2.913e-7,
-0.056413874,
0.0049565402,
0.0751777142,
-0.0080348244,
-0.0012486427,
-0.0132909864,
0.0204220749,
-0.0011560398,
-0.0081927218,
0.028620705,
0.0383261219,
-0.0157357194,
0.0802484155,
0.0116073769,
-0.0726303309,
0.0119074183,
-0.0881851092,
0.0526540764,
-0.0097303139,
0.009128972,
0.009333347,
0.0579444915,
-0.0466797873,
0.0099679828,
-0.0284450911,
-0.0189967658,
0.0264535509,
0.0156114306,
-0.0051250849,
-0.016472036,
0.0180636831,
-0.0218069609,
-0.0132722706,
0.0044470909,
-0.0261137057,
0.0574105047,
-0.0225504134,
-0.0239188485,
-0.0322517827,
-0.1058173478,
-0.0029234344,
0.0472283848,
-0.0423610061,
-0.0185439941,
0.029664021,
-0.0806497037,
-0.0080402372,
-0.0244128276,
-0.0756180286,
0.0359673761,
0.0257017929,
0.0083177891,
0.024620425,
0.0069349837,
0.030409798,
-0.0190225001,
-0.0112148141,
-0.0657522157,
0.0175956283,
0.0398819558,
-0.0640245229,
0.0036570898,
-0.0252056345,
-0.017382225,
0.0460093506,
0.0256888103,
-0.031074835,
2.311138984e-34,
0.025625864,
-0.052243907,
0.0408483632,
0.0262185503,
-0.0029557473,
-0.0399879254,
0.0162429735,
0.0139884222,
-0.0050824694,
-0.0693154633,
-0.0621930286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07499v1 | Robust Educational Dialogue Act Classifiers with Low-Resource and Imbalanced Datasets | 2023-04-15T08:01:59 | 2023-04-15T08:01:59 | Jionghao Lin, Wei Tan, Ngoc Dang Nguyen, David Lang, Lan Du, Wray Buntine, Richard Beare, Guanliang Chen, Dragan Gasevic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Dialogue acts (DAs) can represent conversational actions of tutors or
students that take place during tutoring dialogues. Automating the
identification of DAs in tutoring dialogues is significant to the design of
dialogue-based intelligent tutoring systems. Many prior studies employ machine
learning models to classify DAs in tutoring dialogues and invest much effort to
optimize the classification accuracy by using limited amounts of training data
(i.e., low-resource data scenario). However, beyond the classification
accuracy, the robustness of the classifier is also important, which can reflect
the capability of the classifier on learning the patterns from different class
distributions. We note that many prior studies on classifying educational DAs
employ cross entropy (CE) loss to optimize DA classifiers on low-resource data
with imbalanced DA distribution. The DA classifiers in these studies tend to
prioritize accuracy on the majority class at the expense of the minority class
which might not be robust to the data with imbalanced ratios of different DA
classes. To optimize the robustness of classifiers on imbalanced class
distributions, we propose to optimize the performance of the DA classifier by
maximizing the area under the ROC curve (AUC) score (i.e., AUC maximization).
Through extensive experiments, our study provides evidence that (i) by
maximizing AUC in the training process, the DA classifier achieves significant
performance improvement compared to the CE approach under low-resource data,
and (ii) AUC maximization approaches can improve the robustness of the DA
classifier under different class imbalance ratios. | [
0.057006076,
-0.0126683498,
-0.0422983505,
0.0429488085,
-0.0102285603,
0.0022938866,
0.0185111631,
-0.0330732428,
0.0201079287,
-0.11519669,
0.0025363928,
-0.0109401736,
0.0095592681,
-0.0281491671,
-0.0115586007,
-0.0852997303,
0.0064999191,
0.0026953514,
0.0288891271,
0.0048903874,
-0.0005996331,
-0.0252005495,
-0.0524837002,
0.0518227108,
0.0068117245,
-0.0218990948,
-0.0264349282,
-0.0064165895,
0.0350595526,
0.0198281892,
0.0594075359,
0.0631195009,
-0.0331888795,
0.0224733707,
0.000001939,
-0.0659413487,
0.0137253646,
-0.0346644036,
-0.0175320562,
-0.0119061926,
-0.016021762,
0.0427685715,
0.0072836662,
0.0414103493,
-0.0476350449,
0.0056431717,
0.0303218048,
0.0587318875,
0.0377503633,
0.0726824552,
0.005174404,
-0.0381318741,
0.0711035877,
0.0230658744,
0.0112676788,
-0.0090590147,
0.014606243,
0.0211639777,
0.0028127593,
-0.0215140302,
-0.0359997079,
0.0172240194,
0.0129433172,
-0.0684361309,
0.0008076568,
-0.0019269719,
-0.0350452922,
0.0034066909,
-0.0053747469,
0.0730778873,
0.0209461823,
0.0119961882,
-0.0080260346,
-0.0135566043,
0.0753084049,
0.0245714076,
-0.0465279259,
-0.0055113607,
-0.0068341722,
0.0072991191,
0.011125993,
0.0232383814,
-0.0214376245,
0.0279430375,
0.0336680226,
-0.0216483362,
-0.0463941582,
-0.0301213413,
-0.0120853214,
0.0312554315,
0.0160489008,
-0.0198556017,
0.0096768215,
0.0674384013,
-0.0305086561,
0.0242163595,
-0.0372078121,
-0.0321939513,
0.02814015,
-0.0079358788,
-0.012166406,
0.0330844857,
-0.0142918443,
0.0173739959,
0.0260409173,
0.0641804412,
0.0618671216,
0.0771270096,
0.0070493435,
0.0528693572,
-0.0649076179,
0.0088183889,
-0.0346112587,
0.0566974171,
0.0147917382,
0.007790315,
-0.0767734498,
0.013141036,
-0.0484011136,
0.0265507642,
0.0243196748,
0.0006140661,
-0.0021055571,
0.0485691726,
0.0032708291,
0.0287005175,
0.0309106335,
0.0306429546,
0.0127108358,
-0.0559888519,
0.0321153961,
0.0148932915,
-0.0128742168,
0.0113418931,
0.0053849514,
0.0379230641,
0.0094923191,
-0.058787521,
-0.0681332126,
-0.029647056,
-0.0204968788,
-0.0481492281,
-0.0226122271,
-0.0120033026,
0.0048437091,
0.0016510317,
-0.0067172744,
0.0101564797,
0.0150717665,
-0.0199198425,
0.0151838856,
0.0334347226,
0.0334298201,
-0.0071735866,
0.0822097138,
0.0233662352,
-0.0384281725,
0.0489456989,
0.070953697,
-0.0511658937,
0.0489799641,
-0.0432974324,
0.0345443077,
0.0111028412,
-0.0016298958,
-0.011744326,
0.0549796373,
-0.0003960125,
-0.0270966329,
0.0004951729,
0.0054845493,
0.0045901984,
0.0021724422,
-0.0462722294,
0.0505707525,
0.0109906346,
-0.0184911564,
-0.0097346725,
-0.0075292145,
0.0428869836,
0.0375937298,
0.0159932487,
0.0023396814,
-0.0328464098,
-0.0301665701,
-0.0366290286,
0.0520419441,
-0.0360476151,
-0.0327089541,
-0.1031132489,
-0.0108948238,
-0.0128539139,
-0.025617376,
0.0270233899,
0.0380919874,
-0.0319173336,
-0.0318659171,
0.010362084,
0.0413663052,
-0.0284608398,
0.0077997786,
-0.0779662952,
-0.014609809,
0.0366262384,
0.0204743054,
-0.0717812777,
-0.0082352636,
-0.0511312559,
0.0202447399,
-0.0255220961,
0.0470853597,
-0.0181418844,
0.0152159454,
-0.0439102277,
-0.0195141379,
-0.0120133972,
0.0020681748,
0.0284848381,
-0.0188639127,
0.0463517122,
-0.0222614761,
0.0488592051,
-0.0582423322,
0.0219893865,
0.0024839204,
-0.042576775,
0.0502267927,
0.0317269601,
0.0416656025,
0.0227918476,
-0.0070060007,
-0.0272406545,
0.001266228,
0.0012275489,
-0.0237741284,
-0.0109131625,
-0.0496314541,
-0.0857987776,
0.040896479,
0.0146214683,
-0.0262896921,
0.0343737826,
-0.0220510401,
-0.0367068239,
0.0421819165,
-0.070045732,
0.027470978,
-0.0202610157,
0.0462284312,
-0.0304222144,
0.0230712853,
-0.027157234,
0.0291759409,
0.0226581376,
0.0441013947,
-0.0158141498,
0.0005610622,
0.0575397573,
-0.0752997473,
0.0107279951,
-0.0270956755,
-0.0550666489,
0.0314188786,
0.0129852686,
0.0041726208,
-0.0279318709,
0.0122258523,
-0.0324387886,
0.0007033326,
-0.0079362644,
-0.008145744,
-0.0498016812,
-0.0066402731,
-0.0094645992,
-0.0201268699,
-0.0507433154,
0.0007437841,
0.0133954287,
-0.0299594328,
0.0208772738,
0.0404657274,
-0.0427852049,
-0.0128830988,
0.0150116738,
-0.006644499,
0.040690165,
0.0675194561,
0.0211021286,
-0.0345011167,
0.0664178208,
0.027242912,
0.0094282646,
-0.0097609442,
-0.0525328368,
-0.0137552554,
0.0266382471,
-0.025825901,
0.0928824246,
0.0394403152,
0.037376795,
0.0167544335,
0.0012898813,
-0.0485580154,
0.0416176841,
0.006737031,
-0.006736421,
-0.0269500483,
-0.0326466113,
0.0053969496,
0.0571478456,
0.0071895202,
-0.0194547959,
-0.0194108766,
-0.0688730404,
0.0064020986,
-0.0025658871,
-0.0353771076,
-0.0219569858,
-0.0313080363,
-0.0104747145,
0.0150816096,
-0.0251793209,
0.0597326085,
0.0174032655,
0.0155233927,
-0.0609668382,
-0.0411601439,
-0.0347934291,
0.0171926692,
-0.0241396744,
-0.0081855888,
-0.021537574,
-0.0346135683,
-0.0100887995,
-0.0399819985,
0.0539232641,
-0.037734665,
0.0103889424,
-0.0498333275,
-0.0116706425,
-0.0305154026,
-0.045303043,
-0.0428563133,
-0.0063237264,
0.0239724033,
-0.0018100538,
-0.0005618389,
-0.0306251403,
-0.0400804728,
0.0032788611,
-0.0269318875,
0.0164879896,
-0.0329584479,
-0.025746733,
0.0304634329,
0.0442345515,
0.0187975746,
-0.0172338933,
-0.0404154994,
-0.0089359144,
0.0879944339,
0.0350647271,
0.0342818312,
0.0223488957,
-0.0014953123,
-0.027628947,
0.0515492409,
-0.0054176468,
-0.0174409933,
0.0317232572,
0.0127123101,
-0.0374423675,
0.0189392678,
0.0843861327,
0.0296857767,
-0.042785123,
-0.0245342068,
-0.0150428908,
-0.0332335308,
-0.0274254922,
-0.0087552406,
-0.0502552949,
-0.0108397333,
-0.0288857054,
0.0452259257,
-0.0482711121,
-0.0257529411,
0.0177022647,
-0.0947994441,
0.054461997,
0.0047338004,
-0.0529316776,
-0.0514872372,
-0.0544977114,
0.0234528296,
-0.0343395695,
0.0261165462,
-0.0659549311,
0.0112716369,
-0.0168114379,
0.0658374429,
-0.0474905446,
-0.0502218679,
-0.0040525151,
0.0066010104,
0.0221198648,
-0.0198465325,
0.0707508251,
0.0081167324,
-0.0005974375,
-0.0037218493,
0.0024776082,
-0.0229015928,
0.0045440197,
0.0746148452,
-0.0206975602,
0.001782623,
0.0319917724,
0.0393779799,
-0.0267651603,
0.0051880386,
0.0714071095,
0.0693909004,
-0.0423784591,
0.0189730078,
-0.0409467891,
0.017515637,
0.0660126805,
0.0776325315,
0.0338345654,
-0.034394376,
-0.0268294699,
-0.0093638906,
0.0100914799,
-0.0634960532,
0.0348143429,
0.03057299,
0.0023416311,
-0.0454028212,
-0.0106513007,
-0.0563108288,
-0.002918774,
0.0040732063,
-0.0241538305,
0.0043352754,
-0.0207147822,
0.0760985613,
-0.0396721326,
-0.0227818266,
-0.0109646423,
0.0346500501,
-0.0796944574,
-0.0714629665,
0.0219741724,
-0.0253190082,
-0.0186865423,
-0.009027862,
-0.0106797405,
-0.0855763555,
-0.0063790954,
0.028526606,
0.0154182492,
0.0481311083,
0.0322124921,
-0.0333390199,
0.0408701785,
0.0209515858,
-0.0279966444,
-0.026007127,
0.0343466997,
0.0259061698,
-0.0297761913,
-0.0030936501,
-0.0202901736,
-0.0250329208,
0.0041542035,
-0.0080042006,
-0.0852641836,
-0.0947303846,
-0.0111327227,
-0.0050544958,
0.0182480197,
0.0272813793,
-0.0515719801,
-0.0154280495,
0.0521209054,
-0.0042908262,
0.0109657189,
-0.0072741774,
-0.0174920857,
0.0293396879,
0.0060740192,
-0.0265538786,
-0.0069533591,
-0.0378700756,
0.0106394235,
-0.0267930478,
0.0587739646,
0.0183266699,
0.0324026234,
0.0091581652,
-0.0131707927,
-0.0050636879,
-0.0315839052,
0.1030984893,
0.0367674977,
0.0576002523,
0.0937923267,
0.01865476,
0.0121044321,
0.043934457,
-0.0176166203,
-0.0474348105,
0.0122629451,
-0.0079739569,
0.0333065316,
-0.012372137,
0.0013667949,
-0.0270900708,
-0.0429782122,
0.0085550891,
-0.0075005423,
0.044213783,
0.0114211133,
-0.0391793698,
0.0311148465,
0.0177844167,
0.022116147,
0.051413469,
0.0453955978,
-0.0156582687,
0.0415279455,
-0.0329309776,
-0.0366642959,
-0.0695374236,
-0.0016285756,
0.0939632878,
0.0026563986,
0.0253405832,
0.0387897715,
-0.0577192865,
-0.0080286693,
-0.0174176395,
-0.0167666711,
0.0381884538,
0.0080348738,
0.0130881956,
0.0431974158,
-0.0105215283,
0.0057819467,
-0.0616297498,
0.0175616592,
-0.0648168251,
-0.0178284273,
-0.0538700633,
-4.971721031e-33,
-0.008577574,
-0.0390327424,
-0.0084402859,
0.0735139698,
0.0167635381,
0.0135300076,
-0.0246027242,
0.0148916338,
-0.027244227,
0.0273690298,
0.0271305554,
0.0239766594,
0.0029467891,
0.0278936271,
0.0126676885,
-0.0208218452,
0.0158010386,
-0.0051723411,
-0.0049170717,
0.0552426986,
0.0144635504,
-0.0215013344,
0.0203033779,
-0.0779596493,
0.0322496407,
-0.0074108969,
0.0123532973,
0.0124254581,
-0.0237407386,
0.044649668,
-0.0028596744,
0.0905582458,
0.0376817286,
-0.0039417525,
0.071150519,
0.0478904769,
-0.0144972829,
-0.0596073791,
-0.0473206341,
0.0506639518,
0.0042317929,
-0.0462007448,
0.0013383777,
0.0250730831,
-0.0447931997,
-0.0502932929,
0.0669150278,
0.0038625204,
0.0102443602,
-0.0613332056,
-0.0464253947,
0.0275591705,
-0.0897663161,
-0.0837239921,
-0.0493650436,
0.0482316725,
0.0304574445,
-0.0360877439,
-0.0077834846,
0.0601684079,
0.0416112095,
-0.0061760028,
-0.007337268,
0.0162186511,
-0.0398677588,
0.0435674973,
0.0262704547,
0.0288947187,
0.0406967215,
0.0000446927,
-0.0007265324,
-0.0034919004,
0.0447985716,
0.0508872494,
0.0145433219,
-0.0077030831,
-0.0908850357,
0.0525697209,
0.0639145821,
0.0032068305,
-0.0198123697,
-0.0241235085,
-0.0971648097,
-0.0244937632,
0.0197127126,
0.0011343848,
0.0148619357,
-0.0067633945,
0.0180596448,
-0.0111756977,
0.0030532086,
0.0142069543,
0.0091364607,
-0.0381486788,
-0.0331898034,
0.0481379889,
0.0166854206,
-0.0180474054,
-0.0281963442,
-0.0471271314,
-0.0058723441,
-0.0602310598,
0.0495219417,
-0.0353069492,
0.0364449881,
-0.0118245455,
0.0659178495,
0.0406315774,
-0.0235646181,
-0.0309191942,
0.0115076685,
0.0285600983,
0.0155907245,
0.0466958433,
-0.0228802543,
-0.0024627435,
-0.0203753803,
0.0515388511,
0.0017240354,
-0.0090860901,
-0.0224745683,
0.0024532042,
-0.0393778458,
-0.0271439981,
-0.0308051817,
-0.019575052,
-0.0032832215,
-0.0174967702,
-0.0263856705,
-0.0596939437,
0.0213930607,
-0.0701780543,
2.582e-7,
-0.0043858923,
0.0034450283,
-0.0147148343,
-0.0502111278,
-0.0158749912,
0.040832229,
0.0132509554,
0.0069116624,
0.0554128587,
-0.0129740136,
0.0283000413,
-0.017352581,
0.0402257778,
0.002656277,
-0.1080521867,
-0.0350088105,
-0.0213332884,
-0.0319038779,
-0.0163057055,
0.0474121496,
0.0849155411,
0.0387821868,
0.0337875374,
-0.0233020298,
-0.0157850739,
-0.0599560998,
0.0030079635,
-0.0079481471,
-0.0001982022,
0.0576983467,
0.071289964,
-0.0267406441,
0.0163631234,
0.0437921844,
-0.023139121,
0.0412840359,
-0.0422170311,
-0.0097892806,
-0.0197765622,
-0.0058411714,
0.0057031265,
0.0088681811,
0.0030317411,
-0.0154197365,
0.0230686329,
-0.0252655745,
-0.0105355149,
0.0254879855,
-0.0162004791,
-0.0418002717,
0.0732342303,
-0.001734228,
-0.0009711581,
0.0012220168,
-0.019373551,
-0.0634620562,
0.0395561382,
-0.0570531972,
0.0236281045,
-0.0103950799,
-0.0271366592,
-0.0162103903,
0.0243363008,
0.0006465958,
0.0293655545,
-0.0317235328,
0.0285169035,
1.899548361e-34,
0.0136562344,
-0.0077985534,
0.0177914836,
0.0248691384,
0.0184078477,
0.0243916549,
0.005514144,
0.0376372002,
0.0564187318,
-0.0119976755,
-0.008459596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07438v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07438v4 | Tractable Control for Autoregressive Language Generation | 2023-04-15T00:19:44 | 2023-11-15T23:16:46 | Honghua Zhang, Meihua Dang, Nanyun Peng, Guy Van den Broeck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the success of autoregressive large language models in text
generation, it remains a major challenge to generate text that satisfies
complex constraints: sampling from the conditional distribution
${\Pr}(\text{text} | \alpha)$ is intractable for even the simplest lexical
constraints $\alpha$. To overcome this challenge, we propose to use tractable
probabilistic models (TPMs) to impose lexical constraints in autoregressive
text generation models, which we refer to as GeLaTo (Generating Language with
Tractable Constraints). To demonstrate the effectiveness of this framework, we
use distilled hidden Markov models, where we can efficiently compute
${\Pr}(\text{text} | \alpha)$, to guide autoregressive generation from GPT2.
GeLaTo achieves state-of-the-art performance on challenging benchmarks for
constrained text generation (e.g., CommonGen), beating various strong baselines
by a large margin. Our work not only opens up new avenues for controlling large
language models but also motivates the development of more expressive TPMs. | [
0.0343860984,
0.1154273376,
-0.0010874486,
-0.0140990578,
-0.0126740038,
-0.0166079849,
0.0069218455,
0.0344102643,
-0.0166050531,
-0.0173608251,
0.0260889586,
-0.0754794851,
0.0031729683,
0.0536630601,
0.0383221917,
-0.0676457435,
-0.0011712764,
-0.0330494568,
-0.0070730145,
-0.005642016,
0.0231939219,
0.0016278463,
0.002416868,
0.0415315107,
-0.0131712854,
-0.0035017568,
0.0106666051,
-0.0165357813,
0.0003209236,
0.0082406988,
0.0058188718,
0.0693608895,
0.0120712463,
0.0350191779,
0.0000017639,
-0.023010632,
-0.033735849,
-0.0220487379,
0.0458770059,
0.0285598412,
0.0151314754,
-0.0092614107,
-0.0381096639,
0.020240901,
-0.0284261219,
0.020292528,
0.0354837701,
0.0068185213,
0.0552986786,
0.0608722046,
-0.0239039827,
0.0013598229,
0.0234845821,
-0.0575789362,
0.055975385,
-0.0303304456,
-0.0017111364,
-0.0106827989,
0.010491088,
-0.0092020854,
-0.024941003,
0.017436754,
0.0259288009,
0.0082188472,
-0.0051199743,
0.0580424406,
0.0181700569,
-0.0569292493,
-0.0090967715,
0.0599950254,
-0.0238431841,
-0.0483024642,
0.0461772345,
-0.027869381,
-0.0473014191,
0.0185821839,
-0.0245325007,
0.071933791,
-0.0069460683,
0.0489767976,
0.0227342695,
0.0092887916,
0.0287787076,
-0.0243117418,
0.0071624448,
0.0449964777,
0.0474210195,
-0.0076565421,
-0.0245310627,
0.011327371,
-0.0430050455,
-0.0453660861,
0.0122693814,
0.0109030502,
-0.0297432989,
0.0122382371,
-0.0878555328,
-0.0011549521,
0.0190404486,
0.0281279013,
0.0750394166,
0.0296085738,
0.0465710312,
-0.0051593641,
-0.0322784893,
0.0542449765,
-0.0369908214,
-0.0741273016,
0.0016995756,
0.0183840021,
-0.0161667001,
-0.0096822698,
-0.0484140292,
0.0030166567,
-0.041003406,
-0.0263627879,
-0.0359263159,
0.026807161,
0.004191271,
0.0075945458,
0.0036580334,
-0.0027641023,
-0.0821904391,
-0.0245557707,
0.0004590666,
-0.0353566892,
-0.0477455109,
-0.0341843888,
0.0276742876,
-0.0286086742,
-0.01346556,
0.0322499126,
0.0042945058,
-0.024083063,
-0.0322891474,
0.0463111922,
-0.0330260545,
0.0110278418,
-0.0261600427,
-0.0524981357,
-0.0286468081,
-0.0566565134,
0.0267685391,
-0.0276062507,
-0.03439245,
-0.0165823605,
-0.0066756452,
-0.0552752875,
0.0271369331,
0.0079833437,
-0.0105755404,
0.0236225631,
0.0114814127,
-0.016195504,
0.0106015401,
0.0056230589,
0.0350047573,
0.0407956392,
0.0706420839,
0.0299132448,
-0.0080790967,
0.0298504326,
0.0434108414,
0.039408762,
0.061924018,
0.0269248597,
0.0012247054,
-0.0432875752,
0.0138663603,
0.0225516129,
0.0555310138,
0.1002037898,
0.0073784715,
0.0225194674,
0.0554399155,
0.0007202836,
0.0171457976,
0.044909928,
0.0838634074,
-0.013202046,
-0.0357529745,
0.0353691019,
0.0071558254,
0.0279558711,
-0.0012239206,
0.064696759,
0.0483800508,
0.0350248739,
-0.0238440931,
-0.0289996304,
0.0205955319,
-0.0038578592,
0.0140410261,
-0.0365402065,
0.0428124592,
0.0385300256,
-0.0825944766,
0.005039847,
0.0034208377,
-0.0887966231,
0.0283513907,
-0.0472007245,
0.0403921492,
0.0237884149,
0.0857471377,
-0.0045369123,
0.0360023752,
-0.0068358225,
-0.0203181691,
0.0862364396,
0.0265398864,
0.0473665297,
-0.0034976779,
-0.0470857918,
-0.0157836415,
0.0043601003,
0.0271261651,
0.022934394,
0.0177017972,
0.0353148282,
0.0366530344,
-0.0008588097,
-0.0062558418,
0.0284445565,
-0.0717988238,
-0.0264275912,
0.0253796112,
-0.0034768295,
0.0351938233,
-0.0015373878,
-0.0379870385,
0.0508595034,
0.0038776498,
-0.0448128693,
-0.0242867488,
0.0238187052,
-0.0462744907,
-0.0197462216,
-0.0003946986,
-0.0499549359,
0.0180701166,
-0.0170676876,
0.0087775001,
-0.0781853124,
0.0543793403,
-0.0609124675,
0.0232795663,
-0.0485692099,
0.0025443619,
0.0277001765,
0.0258022621,
-0.012578303,
0.03947936,
-0.0256776661,
-0.0029582717,
0.0481788106,
-0.005680793,
-0.0026703558,
-0.0485584699,
0.0021922737,
-0.0257703569,
0.0232817549,
0.00132887,
0.0489599034,
0.0388235524,
-0.0018924361,
-0.0434757732,
-0.0173877589,
0.0238298941,
-0.025863165,
-0.0085173706,
0.0140317446,
0.0210300032,
-0.0106751276,
0.0186329484,
-0.0579866581,
0.0052099843,
0.0409203507,
0.0026122022,
0.0305578187,
0.0012388693,
-0.0092501417,
-0.0408664383,
-0.0148902806,
0.0207031965,
0.0102743534,
0.0405090488,
-0.0011991602,
-0.01730345,
0.0629755855,
-0.0200462025,
0.0200659893,
-0.0014530845,
-0.0167715065,
0.0149470288,
-0.0233803708,
0.1051774621,
-0.0139852809,
0.0156467464,
0.0630415231,
0.0210775323,
-0.0221906118,
0.0153053179,
0.0079755746,
-0.063477397,
-0.0151165752,
0.023404697,
-0.0727950633,
0.0361843146,
0.0801946521,
0.033522699,
-0.0217602793,
-0.0984819531,
0.0137807168,
-0.0048439954,
-0.0329379626,
0.0245343652,
0.007034583,
-0.0099531738,
0.0152861318,
-0.0321900994,
-0.0744503662,
0.060052231,
-0.0590235442,
0.0083638728,
0.0010615109,
0.0254225973,
-0.016857272,
0.0266579371,
0.0444281995,
0.0315116942,
0.0138330404,
0.0020021561,
-0.0414775535,
0.0375907421,
0.0378325582,
-0.0212459508,
0.0215871483,
-0.0314687081,
0.0238170307,
0.0247350223,
-0.0147477873,
-0.0377701707,
-0.0324965715,
0.0253303647,
-0.0002140908,
0.0692177415,
-0.0398387052,
-0.0046754084,
0.0366835892,
0.0140642552,
0.0477594994,
0.005345203,
-0.0177130289,
-0.0362558141,
0.0182040632,
0.0694692954,
-0.0321814306,
0.0028580888,
-0.0591286458,
-0.0074752374,
0.0203094892,
0.0584175996,
0.0142239472,
0.0128023075,
0.0439344943,
-0.0000552888,
-0.0076357243,
-0.0222102161,
0.0296935551,
0.044365976,
-0.0106091956,
-0.0545064248,
0.0801567435,
0.0140038151,
-0.0151854511,
0.0252078623,
0.0374457911,
0.1028825045,
-0.0117425891,
0.0211514402,
-0.0502065644,
-0.0078761149,
0.0233897753,
0.0377358384,
-0.0563141853,
-0.043639686,
-0.0440412499,
-0.0987572521,
0.0185525659,
0.0365561061,
-0.0131916534,
-0.0349773653,
-0.0060490151,
-0.0379687436,
0.0019610915,
-0.0087810969,
0.0196124204,
-0.0247965772,
0.0549277589,
0.0259995088,
-0.0223077647,
-0.044118885,
-0.0382832326,
0.0067283809,
0.0577133149,
0.078949362,
-0.0120215137,
0.0195653196,
-0.0268553756,
0.0212750509,
-0.0145650199,
-0.0185595155,
-0.0305529162,
-0.0101524545,
0.0337464958,
-0.0112318425,
-0.030554885,
0.0683868006,
-0.0259058978,
-0.013634013,
-0.0122654336,
0.0619820207,
-0.0107706087,
-0.0669563785,
-0.0204999465,
0.0171831194,
0.0538979247,
0.074112542,
0.0542565696,
-0.0476699099,
-0.067799449,
-0.0526567884,
0.041237019,
-0.0807930157,
-0.001969144,
-0.02087944,
0.0018139529,
-0.0415107496,
-0.0998616442,
-0.0240584277,
0.0022007024,
0.0586624816,
0.0054642558,
0.014766627,
0.0268960316,
-0.0364135914,
-0.0450094528,
-0.0310893916,
-0.0229453035,
-0.0086693754,
-0.0741641894,
-0.0512925908,
-0.0006828476,
-0.0357116871,
-0.0240502357,
0.0415315591,
-0.0794657618,
-0.0833318457,
-0.0521039329,
0.0505035371,
0.0370542258,
0.0007564993,
0.0004304715,
-0.0553456433,
0.0227720868,
0.020792637,
0.0044293543,
0.0289648455,
-0.0132350661,
0.0075837886,
0.0007416997,
0.0375944264,
-0.0106084459,
0.0067060487,
-0.0194576755,
0.0963342637,
-0.0182762016,
-0.0103275487,
0.0267614536,
-0.0130231362,
-0.0257646423,
-0.0879793242,
-0.0000667783,
-0.0560060255,
-0.0527270697,
-0.0135258194,
0.0238187462,
-0.0745745301,
0.038950257,
0.0136366375,
-0.0319892168,
-0.0054795677,
-0.0027116311,
-0.0332318693,
0.0323745087,
-0.0150414351,
-0.0394644178,
0.0012818604,
0.022760611,
0.0297198854,
-0.0243115332,
0.016065985,
0.0534280874,
-0.0300821196,
0.0251724664,
0.0041045118,
0.0478952117,
0.0270286743,
0.0099402126,
0.0135283032,
-0.0245551318,
-0.0340786539,
0.0150675764,
-0.0355209559,
0.0554826967,
0.068318136,
0.0368902162,
0.0800370649,
-0.0617650002,
0.0269691125,
-0.0211425722,
0.0585842468,
0.0306896381,
-0.0426304899,
0.0171477981,
-0.0119595574,
-0.0279244035,
-0.008118758,
0.0967964232,
0.0878270268,
0.0103154769,
-0.0063807955,
0.020873135,
-0.0427668244,
-0.03029247,
-0.0130049307,
-0.0131687233,
0.0015834988,
0.0209574569,
-0.041124396,
-0.0564343557,
-0.0060201637,
0.0140748657,
-0.0023151084,
-0.0207010396,
0.0457336605,
0.0005776334,
-0.0464852005,
0.0096263038,
-0.0735318139,
0.0452964418,
-0.0128843114,
-0.036910709,
-0.0185642391,
-6.210113146e-33,
-0.0366729423,
-0.0402702838,
-0.0008944615,
-0.0211647544,
-0.0063497638,
-0.0251927562,
-0.0804534405,
0.0045625949,
0.0496584028,
-0.0013730371,
-0.0002931653,
-0.0032354877,
-0.0020866231,
0.0593854636,
-0.0146753993,
0.0188919678,
0.0427255891,
-0.0339157879,
-0.040072646,
0.067570895,
0.0412701815,
0.0206336062,
-0.0137195541,
0.0079881018,
0.0131005459,
-0.0438068919,
-0.0514846444,
-0.0221010223,
0.0227658655,
0.0398789085,
-0.0519337319,
-0.0015646257,
0.0151944775,
-0.0119388755,
-0.0334711187,
0.0287646763,
-0.0339291357,
-0.0088915713,
-0.0017650621,
-0.037537422,
-0.0336731113,
-0.0412673727,
0.0215677172,
-0.0117294164,
-0.031303823,
0.0123310862,
0.015545344,
-0.0016989136,
-0.0351811275,
-0.0802914202,
-0.0492959209,
0.0184590127,
-0.0013570837,
-0.0197203327,
0.0051876381,
0.0204112586,
-0.0121190427,
0.0013526299,
0.0004269856,
0.0418724678,
0.0237133037,
0.0670383871,
0.0493697375,
0.0173399765,
0.0237837322,
0.0095679611,
-0.0173569974,
-0.0109528759,
-0.0383995734,
0.0134079382,
0.0125215668,
0.0012816715,
0.0095442925,
0.0063168583,
0.0188026056,
-0.0144274905,
-0.0578876063,
0.0284115802,
0.0114983888,
-0.0143790292,
0.0404875763,
-0.0122838337,
-0.035113696,
-0.0199078247,
-0.0479358211,
-0.0436236151,
-0.0167078301,
0.0149615873,
0.044677265,
0.0560469329,
-0.0119739147,
-0.0367626995,
0.0190143865,
0.0024452754,
-0.0407353751,
0.0102085331,
-0.0455287956,
-0.0020894569,
-0.0185442232,
0.0462738052,
-0.0386291109,
-0.029500518,
0.0335221253,
0.015516269,
-0.0179264806,
0.0239261687,
-0.0393547006,
0.0143259224,
-0.0651604682,
0.004706874,
-0.058660958,
0.0786831677,
0.012884316,
0.0011818534,
0.0183344316,
-0.0414906256,
0.0097143296,
0.0288425479,
0.0047781998,
-0.0013869575,
0.0052102874,
0.0199163817,
-0.0008262764,
0.0414237939,
-0.0344384015,
0.023749413,
-0.0267097279,
0.0558429398,
0.0383384898,
-0.0433074832,
-0.0157145411,
0.0058339047,
2.363e-7,
-0.0060508926,
0.0247608144,
0.0281839501,
0.0151746254,
0.0387270972,
0.0164207313,
-0.0112298662,
0.0275552627,
-0.0377025716,
-0.0110540288,
0.0005815512,
0.0014528477,
0.0745375007,
-0.0007402385,
-0.0133829406,
0.0090701394,
-0.0678024516,
0.0077073928,
-0.0427255556,
-0.0308147781,
0.0327876881,
0.0541280471,
-0.0208740812,
0.0031224373,
0.0415972508,
-0.0538589135,
0.0906217843,
0.0034721091,
-0.0021168657,
0.0210048407,
0.0319153443,
0.0020813094,
-0.0249445792,
-0.0498324707,
-0.0304900315,
-0.023007825,
0.0085410345,
0.0625030175,
0.0394415185,
-0.0361527689,
0.0450860672,
-0.0021901976,
-0.0106334714,
-0.0277041309,
0.0318018459,
-0.0144714573,
0.0033252593,
0.0377425775,
-0.0049806754,
-0.0051902216,
-0.0112945614,
-0.040244896,
-0.065059863,
0.0007873451,
0.0117519796,
0.0267968141,
0.0102875168,
-0.0263484418,
-0.0200103838,
-0.0271606706,
-0.0809308216,
-0.0085090669,
-0.0893798023,
0.0187575724,
0.0067472691,
-0.0366170779,
-0.0460935831,
2.619188299e-34,
0.0461669639,
-0.0512356646,
-0.0029809417,
-0.0245854482,
0.0062534707,
0.0045678783,
-0.0015323795,
0.0371109024,
0.0200272705,
-0.0719262138,
-0.0530494563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07437v1 | Medical Question Summarization with Entity-driven Contrastive Learning | 2023-04-15T00:19:03 | 2023-04-15T00:19:03 | Sibo Wei, Wenpeng Lu, Xueping Peng, Shoujin Wang, Yi-Fei Wang, Weiyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | By summarizing longer consumer health questions into shorter and essential
ones, medical question answering (MQA) systems can more accurately understand
consumer intentions and retrieve suitable answers. However, medical question
summarization is very challenging due to obvious distinctions in health trouble
descriptions from patients and doctors. Although existing works have attempted
to utilize Seq2Seq, reinforcement learning, or contrastive learning to solve
the problem, two challenges remain: how to correctly capture question focus to
model its semantic intention, and how to obtain reliable datasets to fairly
evaluate performance. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel
medical question summarization framework using entity-driven contrastive
learning (ECL). ECL employs medical entities in frequently asked questions
(FAQs) as focuses and devises an effective mechanism to generate hard negative
samples. This approach forces models to pay attention to the crucial focus
information and generate more ideal question summarization. Additionally, we
find that some MQA datasets suffer from serious data leakage problems, such as
the iCliniq dataset's 33% duplicate rate. To evaluate the related methods
fairly, this paper carefully checks leaked samples to reorganize more
reasonable datasets. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our ECL method
outperforms state-of-the-art methods by accurately capturing question focus and
generating medical question summaries. The code and datasets are available at
https://github.com/yrbobo/MQS-ECL. | [
0.0550069846,
0.0589784384,
0.0137359025,
-0.0212312583,
-0.0127111124,
0.0293375365,
-0.0203415379,
-0.0073966072,
-0.0016270875,
0.0011892937,
0.0085929455,
-0.0542762242,
-0.0079665715,
0.0214196071,
0.0198200084,
-0.0825931206,
0.0074849897,
0.0624564663,
0.0011502479,
0.0170592777,
0.0205321927,
0.0007834324,
-0.0218133368,
0.026124604,
0.0341429338,
-0.0027708451,
0.0010432582,
0.0130287716,
0.0689115748,
-0.0720515177,
0.0354934484,
0.027870845,
-0.0202695411,
-0.0484205261,
0.0000019733,
-0.0759782195,
-0.0423997678,
0.007992995,
-0.0203590207,
-0.0273388792,
0.0269814096,
-0.0673438236,
0.0295069516,
0.0409245268,
-0.034438327,
-0.0155374752,
0.0189882275,
0.067609109,
0.0808196813,
0.0602970198,
-0.0163178127,
-0.0327807069,
-0.0072715236,
0.0001853072,
0.0191146526,
-0.0174961705,
0.0376136266,
-0.0255713481,
0.0119136777,
-0.0067665009,
0.00948337,
0.0295566097,
0.0222235136,
0.0499335118,
0.0049019698,
0.0506449267,
-0.0235581174,
0.0057267612,
0.0188098121,
0.0984516218,
0.0385365188,
0.0107481899,
0.0260141212,
-0.0130175129,
0.0030224498,
0.0173082054,
-0.026857242,
-0.0029353753,
-0.0261813402,
-0.0034276396,
0.0209926683,
0.0266992934,
0.0041990085,
-0.0012720519,
-0.0388267115,
-0.0500039831,
0.0267703887,
-0.0332160518,
-0.0204299502,
-0.0218836199,
-0.0264077019,
-0.0500798076,
0.0130671374,
0.0251584984,
-0.0615544543,
0.0151784075,
0.0100984583,
-0.0427433364,
0.0759316012,
-0.0171196423,
-0.0219437219,
0.0029613276,
0.0099022612,
0.0355747789,
0.0331544019,
-0.0041651456,
-0.0014047826,
0.0256364755,
-0.0622352622,
0.0150904953,
-0.023017846,
-0.0012881401,
-0.0335425511,
0.0503753349,
0.0040542884,
0.010574949,
-0.0562917404,
-0.0005781837,
0.0076191826,
-0.0051219841,
0.0006136047,
0.0531457216,
-0.012586507,
0.0153464861,
-0.007656049,
0.0228997022,
-0.0680698976,
0.0035132163,
0.0047329403,
-0.0077624028,
0.0041401214,
-0.0122344848,
0.0163752232,
-0.0045124609,
0.0176429916,
0.0104663288,
0.02023918,
-0.0446253903,
-0.0365526713,
-0.0133378189,
-0.0184999667,
0.0026049691,
-0.0476475991,
-0.0565582402,
0.0077763954,
0.0152046029,
-0.0032222026,
-0.0302713774,
0.0060149967,
0.0389535502,
-0.0516655818,
0.0782305077,
-0.0461733527,
-0.003880172,
0.0263518039,
0.0378660262,
0.0117319105,
0.0251064412,
0.0294180289,
-0.0517140441,
0.0305354707,
-0.011146755,
-0.0052843126,
-0.0327158868,
0.044501394,
-0.0026000214,
0.0237642154,
0.034565445,
-0.0344145037,
0.0313046947,
-0.0316442996,
0.1056903899,
-0.0021546744,
-0.0200544745,
0.0285335798,
0.0515978672,
-0.0284813214,
-0.0039120479,
-0.0129553489,
0.0264229625,
-0.0303720962,
0.0537316762,
-0.0066901743,
0.012275436,
0.0230241399,
0.0435086042,
0.0437152125,
-0.0230452325,
-0.0398481116,
-0.0372304805,
-0.0079608709,
-0.0175893512,
0.0074145482,
0.0061190999,
0.0178862829,
0.012327428,
-0.0556261614,
0.0559915565,
0.0318521671,
-0.0390705131,
-0.0283635426,
-0.0236137584,
0.0332338475,
0.0366486348,
0.0300640762,
-0.0465402342,
-0.0725362897,
-0.0386648402,
-0.0047485842,
0.0054208962,
0.0182100274,
-0.0354551561,
0.0019292078,
-0.0340053216,
-0.0246620085,
-0.0196681004,
0.0045629973,
-0.064844273,
0.0116663296,
0.006863608,
-0.0010281411,
-0.0045787157,
-0.0210235119,
0.0313949101,
-0.0511726104,
-0.0229029991,
0.0225756168,
0.0086939679,
0.0095221726,
0.0307694655,
0.0049805893,
0.0453509018,
0.0255417153,
-0.0246873852,
-0.0100788902,
-0.0130819539,
-0.027974885,
-0.0629453883,
0.0085909227,
-0.0676189661,
-0.0039759027,
0.0249672588,
-0.0665389076,
-0.0365663804,
-0.0383019596,
-0.0742215142,
-0.0100530926,
0.0027562145,
-0.0274263956,
0.0543927588,
-0.0266968999,
-0.0502950661,
0.0340896137,
-0.0429392532,
0.0220138226,
0.033869341,
-0.0063521951,
0.0028631878,
-0.0340781398,
0.016115116,
-0.0339736752,
0.0129078235,
-0.0058137015,
0.0261918455,
0.0161775947,
-0.0702928826,
0.0040980848,
-0.0887842178,
0.001612147,
-0.0241743755,
0.0159769002,
0.0720283017,
0.0446158685,
-0.0042072362,
-0.024058288,
-0.0756191239,
-0.0463180952,
0.0031991594,
0.0099646663,
0.058705043,
0.0423933528,
0.0160331968,
-0.0285176113,
-0.0057505723,
-0.0260785185,
0.0200449377,
-0.0104964497,
0.0214961618,
-0.0204169527,
0.0032568208,
-0.0311738141,
-0.0286585987,
0.0307880081,
0.0068543823,
-0.0023201753,
-0.0006520239,
0.0027753324,
0.0488653965,
0.0429728702,
-0.0260901172,
-0.008504305,
0.0404912829,
-0.0312633365,
0.0256610718,
-0.0538019836,
0.0085225208,
0.019724844,
-0.0821703225,
0.0263433177,
0.0772779807,
0.0137673104,
-0.0133207403,
-0.0403137766,
0.0325674005,
-0.007741184,
0.0232747421,
-0.0456392616,
0.0512091964,
-0.0457732975,
0.0402583294,
-0.0135649331,
-0.0083396332,
0.1171303391,
0.0436895527,
0.0261698104,
-0.0885708854,
0.0085593481,
-0.0552913696,
-0.003893798,
-0.0397527851,
0.029891964,
0.0510806032,
-0.0189808756,
-0.0403444692,
-0.0166242979,
-0.0005021366,
-0.0423720852,
0.0875647217,
-0.0070953141,
0.018182423,
0.0072917058,
-0.0800883323,
-0.0521153733,
-0.0432451479,
-0.0226106942,
0.0193937272,
0.0105520608,
0.0255675316,
-0.0559408404,
0.0114365695,
-0.0052693211,
0.0574489534,
0.0109677548,
-0.0269407742,
-0.0042762063,
0.0736145824,
0.0996412262,
0.0078902859,
0.0318725929,
-0.0210321434,
0.0518934131,
0.0815867931,
0.0255069789,
0.0109921815,
0.0356054306,
0.001445448,
-0.0035751958,
-0.0542796962,
0.0161440633,
0.0184841882,
0.0320841633,
-0.0122677591,
-0.0237844158,
0.1066617966,
0.039349325,
-0.0128937839,
0.0226248372,
0.0057522086,
-0.0003182867,
0.0055182585,
0.008761161,
-0.0595001951,
-0.0341472924,
-0.0272622555,
0.0794781968,
0.0071423794,
-0.0257521421,
0.0137127293,
-0.0565686636,
-0.0135131096,
-0.0294829067,
-0.0888283253,
-0.0372303911,
-0.0445215218,
0.0022236784,
-0.0304804537,
-0.0032662062,
0.0071272566,
-0.0137181878,
0.0025145824,
0.0051975404,
-0.02126728,
-0.0313237868,
0.0036685586,
-0.0243385676,
0.0031616343,
0.0708072335,
0.024407357,
0.000579952,
-0.0108337635,
-0.0126493527,
-0.0931911618,
-0.0365284048,
0.0029890363,
0.0924362168,
-0.0072702221,
-0.0068236818,
-0.05735052,
0.0756311491,
-0.0241003372,
-0.0161785148,
0.019017281,
0.0221851543,
-0.0021025504,
-0.0264004227,
-0.0529009625,
0.0367833376,
0.0205878783,
0.0793843269,
0.0139734633,
-0.0108201988,
0.0045849425,
0.0217734966,
0.0085608317,
-0.0416797101,
-0.0012637643,
0.0066256244,
-0.0126857171,
0.0327539779,
-0.0798228681,
-0.0576879792,
0.0370556116,
-0.0310782939,
-0.0121720061,
0.0025728829,
-0.0008566597,
-0.0015318844,
-0.0674168468,
0.0153305205,
0.0274326243,
0.00355133,
-0.0410280079,
-0.0453566946,
0.0776367933,
-0.0029124042,
-0.0261164792,
-0.0026997323,
-0.0292596519,
-0.0039494256,
-0.0203555152,
0.0576267689,
0.0044285813,
0.0214167982,
0.0115288431,
-0.0018958581,
0.0188822653,
0.0320434719,
-0.0573414862,
-0.0220987275,
0.0001208935,
0.0290862191,
-0.0094276099,
0.0272226613,
-0.0174073558,
0.0151198972,
0.0030967582,
0.0665362626,
-0.0680026785,
-0.0440373495,
0.0423716083,
0.0199149903,
0.0225881431,
-0.0043404275,
0.0160682015,
-0.036509864,
0.0256117713,
0.0200205613,
0.0012034212,
-0.0271937307,
0.0120138926,
-0.0078003234,
0.0078143012,
-0.0310838558,
0.0231961925,
-0.0557068735,
-0.0315716267,
-0.0371691398,
0.011359849,
0.0272379685,
-0.0038399061,
0.0206851978,
-0.0458487272,
-0.0120925009,
0.0229221191,
0.0082469275,
0.044124566,
0.0083322218,
0.0649233237,
0.0281832907,
0.0303125102,
0.0024880229,
0.0311238747,
-0.0331260562,
-0.02786595,
-0.0200043134,
0.0123224556,
0.011127511,
-0.0088610034,
0.010675963,
0.0165326614,
-0.0186022837,
-0.0318512134,
0.0162076205,
-0.0227709059,
0.0310302172,
0.0475899018,
0.016407026,
0.0175291989,
-0.0004771298,
0.0716015846,
-0.0385484546,
0.0209831782,
-0.0100493059,
-0.0213154238,
-0.0474603362,
0.0090868957,
0.0234370753,
0.0131596327,
-0.0468591377,
0.0095987385,
-0.0821272209,
-0.0504037924,
0.0265808608,
-0.0098974369,
-0.0056797569,
-0.0089542596,
0.0975128114,
0.0097156009,
0.0081298724,
-0.0198396984,
-0.0264107697,
0.0494016707,
-0.063589789,
-0.0112550426,
0.0083265258,
-6.202832427e-33,
0.0110281175,
-0.0124735888,
0.0092435051,
-0.0329190642,
0.0259200577,
0.0473992713,
-0.0593070909,
-0.0234746747,
0.0041639963,
0.0138063477,
-0.0033143789,
0.0159103666,
-0.0117042465,
0.0710427389,
-0.0110283867,
-0.0669990405,
0.0314698331,
0.0072958679,
-0.0210177414,
0.0516032241,
-0.0252742972,
0.0661631599,
0.0246885028,
-0.0629188791,
0.0094377054,
-0.0388798229,
0.0382155068,
0.0387301408,
0.0047620414,
0.0644406825,
-0.007616993,
0.0021232816,
0.0477832034,
-0.062480662,
-0.0057887491,
0.007416321,
-0.0992979854,
-0.036402408,
-0.0112628657,
-0.0624504127,
-0.1213808879,
-0.0312871672,
0.0511758141,
-0.0132782571,
0.0189223513,
-0.0275512114,
0.0224296004,
-0.018089138,
0.0168169253,
-0.0515091754,
0.0080545954,
0.0386354476,
-0.0105126798,
-0.0056891846,
-0.0524399728,
0.0589932427,
-0.0254203454,
0.0474349782,
-0.0146090295,
0.0087460428,
0.0339003392,
0.0059272018,
0.0133235874,
0.0165842883,
-0.0245005246,
0.0312286094,
0.0157711953,
-0.0389987528,
-0.0051338174,
0.0158610158,
-0.0725132078,
-0.0153106367,
0.0425590873,
0.0395629816,
0.0174553227,
0.0359249786,
-0.0974850655,
0.0686278418,
-0.064405866,
0.0394485593,
0.0232440382,
-0.0439107046,
-0.0422491841,
-0.0086637512,
-0.0354793258,
0.0304803941,
-0.0236731973,
-0.0206569489,
0.0276055727,
0.0153209548,
-0.0530265309,
0.0182407964,
-0.0307640377,
-0.0191741828,
0.0074529038,
0.0046083163,
0.0073957318,
-0.0353871733,
-0.017798027,
-0.0090748416,
-0.0623913221,
0.052843187,
0.0163985658,
-0.0318315178,
0.02361634,
0.0348963104,
0.0386723429,
-0.0502327234,
-0.0480585322,
-0.0021178168,
0.0369510315,
0.010353501,
-0.0473683849,
0.0217158366,
0.0244969185,
0.0392396674,
0.0042689457,
0.0502558984,
0.0255147219,
0.0043063154,
-0.0610710718,
-0.0347253494,
0.0157991108,
0.0494336896,
-0.0214995909,
0.0029496551,
-0.0221966915,
0.0623158887,
0.0042994679,
-0.0687991753,
-0.0211189575,
-0.0034769517,
2.728e-7,
0.0955453217,
0.0046046185,
0.0276409704,
0.0153148472,
0.0019318473,
0.0395111926,
0.0073836497,
0.019759411,
0.0262212921,
-0.0062389285,
0.0484072343,
0.0320048817,
-0.0130371265,
0.0260574855,
-0.1061903834,
-0.009859656,
-0.0654868707,
-0.0080018947,
-0.018507136,
0.0042798324,
0.0818873122,
0.0807511583,
-0.024001129,
-0.0341303721,
0.0286570061,
0.0068395673,
0.010865137,
-0.0075919251,
-0.0044134911,
0.0381925926,
-0.0027850617,
0.0038117133,
0.0003914604,
0.0129516376,
-0.0029072547,
-0.0239268318,
0.01227012,
0.062958993,
0.0068807038,
-0.0565274209,
-0.0006300107,
-0.0016950184,
0.0370684676,
-0.0473808721,
0.0716689602,
-0.0917456746,
-0.0364680812,
0.0254585408,
-0.0365611352,
-0.0070181959,
0.0567721054,
-0.0100469366,
-0.0436318628,
0.0107731586,
0.0141844833,
0.0309904162,
-0.0135513218,
-0.0522193201,
-0.0169925578,
0.052526176,
0.020013595,
-0.03445407,
0.0254275147,
-0.0055816751,
-0.0550191738,
-0.0590686873,
-0.0029619376,
2.315818691e-34,
0.0376712047,
0.01262346,
-0.0122288251,
0.0391214192,
-0.0043011685,
-0.0471235439,
-0.0229113847,
-0.0211509001,
0.0560703278,
-0.0515441075,
-0.0188460071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07396v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07396v2 | Improving Patient Pre-screening for Clinical Trials: Assisting Physicians with Large Language Models | 2023-04-14T21:19:46 | 2023-06-29T12:59:16 | Danny M. den Hamer, Perry Schoor, Tobias B. Polak, Daniel Kapitan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.1; I.2.7 | Physicians considering clinical trials for their patients are met with the
laborious process of checking many text based eligibility criteria. Large
Language Models (LLMs) have shown to perform well for clinical information
extraction and clinical reasoning, including medical tests, but not yet in
real-world scenarios. This paper investigates the use of InstructGPT to assist
physicians in determining eligibility for clinical trials based on a patient's
summarised medical profile. Using a prompting strategy combining one-shot,
selection-inference and chain-of-thought techniques, we investigate the
performance of LLMs on 10 synthetically created patient profiles. Performance
is evaluated at four levels: ability to identify screenable eligibility
criteria from a trial given a medical profile; ability to classify for each
individual criterion whether the patient qualifies; the overall classification
whether a patient is eligible for a clinical trial and the percentage of
criteria to be screened by physician. We evaluated against 146 clinical trials
and a total of 4,135 eligibility criteria. The LLM was able to correctly
identify the screenability of 72% (2,994/4,135) of the criteria. Additionally,
72% (341/471) of the screenable criteria were evaluated correctly. The
resulting trial level classification as eligible or ineligible resulted in a
recall of 0.5. By leveraging LLMs with a physician-in-the-loop, a recall of 1.0
and precision of 0.71 on clinical trial level can be achieved while reducing
the amount of criteria to be checked by an estimated 90%. LLMs can be used to
assist physicians with pre-screening of patients for clinical trials. By
forcing instruction-tuned LLMs to produce chain-of-thought responses, the
reasoning can be made transparent to and the decision process becomes amenable
by physicians, thereby making such a system feasible for use in real-world
scenarios. | [
0.055847846,
0.0510622524,
-0.0083956476,
-0.0127334297,
-0.0486198999,
0.0212116409,
0.0212929603,
0.0169085208,
0.0377908871,
-0.0100734346,
0.0268109217,
-0.0360160694,
-0.0185009427,
0.0254331194,
-0.0102216015,
-0.0308242738,
0.0156549625,
0.0042500542,
0.0724547356,
0.0113218948,
-0.0210924614,
0.0173369851,
-0.0370112173,
0.032782618,
0.0413482748,
-0.0322156325,
0.037928734,
-0.0240873545,
0.0101397717,
-0.0961753353,
-0.0200743787,
0.0361712612,
-0.020386206,
-0.02081725,
0.0000021184,
-0.0800035223,
-0.0126569662,
0.0237317514,
-0.0479222834,
-0.0458731949,
0.0542610362,
0.010596103,
0.0109686088,
0.019330807,
-0.0268386845,
-0.0076146326,
0.0382947586,
0.0266744122,
0.0228020884,
0.0502850711,
-0.0262807105,
0.0286602229,
0.0130132446,
-0.0157033224,
0.0379169174,
-0.0427545607,
0.0474720486,
-0.0204496644,
0.0732899308,
0.0060610892,
0.0494103804,
0.0270434767,
-0.0159320217,
0.009799025,
0.0119363097,
0.0397963934,
-0.0283473115,
-0.0356406271,
-0.0017096386,
0.0478079803,
0.0304349661,
0.0101047903,
0.0187329669,
-0.0126695065,
0.0085284794,
0.0301772337,
-0.026638113,
0.0058581191,
-0.0444107279,
-0.0098613864,
0.0177580398,
0.0174472407,
0.0193548612,
0.0083599333,
-0.0288436729,
0.0185876377,
0.0077101276,
-0.0267825071,
0.047793813,
0.0104602361,
0.0183784124,
-0.0697943643,
0.0505538024,
0.0421189256,
-0.0577944405,
0.0100604696,
-0.0011734383,
-0.0154826529,
0.0861133188,
-0.0446018912,
0.020524988,
0.0137698967,
0.0146353571,
0.049485527,
-0.0180623364,
0.0055991649,
-0.0263755638,
0.044493448,
-0.0338830426,
0.0455378853,
-0.0584097244,
-0.03461143,
-0.0304322839,
0.0449889526,
0.0212235451,
0.0051181591,
-0.0753261521,
-0.0070486171,
-0.0203088075,
0.0074942377,
-0.010680872,
0.0162907057,
-0.001223319,
-0.0010565998,
-0.0550564826,
-0.0062394687,
-0.0079972027,
-0.008535251,
0.0089863297,
-0.0309609845,
0.0306769982,
-0.0086665042,
0.0128301634,
-0.015026886,
0.0465437174,
0.0521277003,
0.0113214087,
-0.0191781335,
-0.0163050331,
-0.0415100716,
-0.0190737545,
-0.0308271889,
0.0065644043,
-0.0518716834,
0.0172991958,
0.03260893,
0.0038159769,
-0.0317725427,
0.0038271423,
0.044463966,
-0.0307076219,
0.0724172667,
-0.0415411219,
0.0083463965,
0.0066291504,
0.0139356451,
-0.00899716,
0.0135940528,
0.0297467839,
-0.0126088196,
-0.0299602896,
-0.0162250493,
0.0393146053,
0.0040673427,
0.0027035587,
-0.035896562,
-0.0312063638,
0.0252744965,
-0.0044473154,
0.0561407879,
-0.0657239482,
0.0749760345,
-0.0155580603,
0.0332160033,
0.0276001804,
0.0725883543,
0.041531045,
0.0023714469,
0.0236599892,
-0.0336011723,
-0.0026766998,
-0.0080531957,
-0.0128864339,
0.0145425927,
-0.0124268401,
-0.0025532856,
-0.0263696909,
0.0064972211,
-0.0256335214,
-0.0263377558,
-0.0406801365,
0.0064094407,
0.0152593758,
0.0121508418,
0.0218824167,
-0.0266663004,
-0.0395052359,
0.0326568782,
0.0424278639,
-0.0135331396,
-0.037797492,
-0.0772863626,
-0.0173957199,
0.0774131492,
0.0570984595,
-0.0303615201,
0.0050879968,
-0.026456669,
0.0029500644,
-0.0021475838,
0.0217253082,
-0.0142539646,
-0.038457945,
-0.0352757312,
-0.0113397744,
0.0602018498,
0.0008050051,
-0.010511185,
-0.0041535832,
0.0217982326,
-0.0406280085,
-0.0252906904,
-0.0234130137,
0.0490665771,
-0.0317535065,
-0.0470042117,
0.0017422711,
-0.001862749,
0.0392620228,
0.0073421528,
0.0090084495,
0.0414507687,
0.0100557581,
-0.0255615711,
-0.0093820356,
-0.0241992772,
-0.0027300895,
-0.0386713929,
-0.0130559178,
-0.0253689736,
-0.0283305384,
-0.0616728701,
-0.0327421874,
-0.0011064846,
-0.0345444642,
-0.0414439812,
0.0106272828,
-0.0058388701,
0.0120979333,
0.020555988,
-0.0269888323,
-0.0659171939,
0.0460935682,
0.0049772453,
-0.00007089,
0.0748396218,
-0.0728300959,
0.0036668656,
-0.0477279946,
0.0014844857,
0.0357932299,
-0.0085178288,
-0.0088500511,
-0.0033455444,
0.0369360372,
-0.0292169731,
-0.0383254364,
-0.0920411497,
-0.0079636583,
0.0245275609,
0.0133355567,
-0.0161089692,
0.0090080006,
-0.019706022,
-0.0115370341,
-0.0305874553,
-0.0142314564,
0.0247755405,
0.0180550255,
0.0198523682,
0.028269114,
-0.0026688986,
-0.0087132128,
-0.0061316476,
-0.0493653677,
0.0479707085,
0.0407988392,
-0.0367091186,
-0.0163857806,
0.0353030339,
-0.0251017679,
-0.0041381265,
0.020554496,
-0.0043166154,
0.0307932347,
-0.0223874021,
-0.0044602402,
0.0531563945,
-0.0221392121,
-0.0153190577,
0.0539636351,
-0.0023008578,
-0.0295485668,
0.0254955776,
-0.003352735,
-0.0276269298,
0.0334827155,
-0.0272225812,
0.0167492963,
0.0649790764,
0.0221290234,
0.0026720639,
-0.047456596,
0.0112188626,
-0.0372971892,
0.0297447722,
-0.0548433699,
-0.0011295177,
-0.0350326262,
0.0518548004,
-0.0017082503,
-0.0310406052,
0.1366873682,
-0.0064687883,
0.0289939865,
-0.1035899594,
0.0030682255,
-0.033733286,
-0.0044363202,
0.0034004177,
-0.0070675146,
0.0542446747,
0.00189849,
-0.007614091,
-0.0277027935,
-0.0084010595,
-0.0433281586,
0.0836565867,
-0.0484361053,
0.0566481613,
0.0085399821,
-0.018603975,
-0.0510931239,
-0.0124299889,
-0.0280012023,
-0.0126007274,
0.0141200023,
0.0391149223,
-0.0540429801,
0.0144166704,
0.0025834816,
0.0682283491,
0.0076378658,
-0.0267436169,
0.0084712487,
-0.0487030186,
0.0188352652,
-0.0477948748,
-0.0064728963,
-0.0126897814,
0.0667784512,
0.0535311364,
-0.0141897602,
0.024114823,
-0.0093184551,
0.0308559015,
0.0049656313,
-0.0597675368,
0.0092554968,
0.0626826137,
0.0255481992,
-0.053126961,
0.0118348394,
0.1226924583,
0.0288889557,
-0.0835333988,
0.0041979374,
-0.0080040833,
-0.0420587212,
-0.0088154217,
0.0203165952,
-0.0734428465,
-0.0293610804,
-0.0043709688,
0.0172847491,
-0.0560325645,
-0.0190037452,
-0.0205479637,
-0.0369806066,
0.0388368778,
0.0107891122,
-0.0083261039,
-0.0158075579,
-0.027777981,
0.0006544477,
0.001865887,
-0.0304934382,
-0.0002132161,
-0.0116412137,
0.0047446596,
-0.0137459096,
-0.0843795314,
-0.0795236081,
0.0722816661,
0.0157187581,
0.0086278301,
0.0488514118,
0.0359022319,
0.0121327657,
-0.043337401,
-0.0135656931,
-0.0464072824,
0.0043554772,
-0.0249876212,
0.0836086199,
0.0361733064,
0.0266568791,
-0.0698409006,
0.0368676633,
-0.0361803956,
-0.0215030201,
0.0198064148,
0.1165651232,
-0.0569408759,
-0.0338331759,
-0.0527346767,
0.041986715,
0.0168323964,
0.0365913585,
0.0131917736,
-0.0283035431,
0.0054281512,
-0.0020631058,
0.0217796508,
-0.0288139358,
-0.0191018283,
0.032921847,
-0.0215809401,
0.0192904528,
-0.0486391447,
-0.0349051543,
0.0800790563,
0.0265513677,
0.0197024774,
0.038473554,
0.0355081968,
0.0068341433,
-0.0070214346,
0.056436751,
0.0231697876,
0.0228334516,
-0.0467749424,
-0.0324542671,
0.0351781994,
-0.0052638436,
-0.0097433608,
0.0333025642,
0.0154598951,
-0.0082549108,
-0.0274048764,
0.0392112173,
0.0393155105,
-0.0339136161,
0.0020849702,
-0.0094653005,
0.0373310484,
-0.0063895546,
0.0016686599,
-0.0496852584,
-0.0352799818,
0.0065733641,
-0.0067992522,
-0.0107697984,
-0.0239693131,
0.04211016,
-0.0037922955,
0.0162925087,
-0.0363966338,
-0.0193920657,
0.0704962537,
0.0409224853,
0.0319926329,
-0.0157391448,
0.0004834655,
-0.0355070084,
0.0146536753,
-0.0188943204,
-0.0108117778,
-0.0155965108,
-0.0139272623,
0.0126217389,
-0.0280800778,
-0.0111096213,
-0.0905704722,
-0.0935310647,
-0.0375065245,
-0.0242984146,
0.0415776782,
0.0047237109,
0.0305840559,
0.0816511512,
-0.0280568004,
-0.0157684777,
-0.0133254007,
-0.0227296781,
0.0235810298,
-0.0276405364,
0.1160474122,
-0.0015718562,
0.0316835791,
-0.0274580494,
0.0237774812,
-0.0290868245,
-0.0395932831,
-0.0020491905,
0.0277997069,
0.0175756533,
0.0147665609,
-0.0039599133,
-0.0389298983,
0.0079622911,
-0.0350469463,
0.0122613553,
0.0113376575,
-0.0089100227,
0.0559050329,
0.0170190595,
-0.0158543307,
-0.0878209621,
0.0463321097,
-0.012476516,
0.0092166755,
-0.0239957497,
-0.0462623797,
-0.0577208214,
-0.0216224045,
-0.0053218636,
0.018363094,
-0.0517524146,
0.0234675203,
-0.1001440436,
-0.0157022197,
0.0120260073,
-0.0144590633,
-0.0057160947,
-0.0375188105,
0.0400911979,
0.0574022867,
0.0006620146,
-0.0426641218,
-0.0198825877,
0.0476367772,
-0.0245543942,
-0.0268676542,
-0.0445408747,
-5.591544141e-33,
-0.0073882677,
-0.0175740737,
0.0330948681,
-0.0210977904,
0.0181563366,
-0.000851203,
-0.0546267405,
-0.0035414225,
0.0104564475,
0.0519454405,
-0.0224749669,
-0.0079825958,
0.0015138756,
0.0355370156,
0.0069445064,
-0.0318292901,
0.0327197388,
0.0323683657,
-0.0299902745,
0.0233025867,
-0.0388944522,
0.0234567393,
0.0098194554,
-0.0355856307,
0.0318232961,
0.0160365812,
0.0525684878,
-0.0057386244,
-0.0417926423,
0.0736567155,
-0.0039178422,
0.0346982516,
0.0560786873,
-0.0030795143,
0.0037441666,
0.0242157672,
-0.0329005122,
-0.0533824675,
0.0098449551,
-0.0366508327,
-0.0079830121,
-0.0361529067,
0.044451803,
-0.0204527993,
-0.029729981,
-0.0071162959,
0.0279361978,
-0.0376151167,
-0.0184714943,
-0.0081727961,
-0.0460908152,
0.042155195,
0.0120283151,
-0.0043543829,
-0.0306223482,
0.0270957686,
-0.0526725538,
0.0298907273,
-0.0098085282,
0.0255402084,
0.040365465,
0.0020878462,
0.0049249586,
-0.0259341709,
-0.036254935,
0.0736953393,
-0.0145027973,
-0.0098695494,
-0.0249706414,
-0.0137709305,
-0.0513963141,
0.0136965197,
0.0409221649,
0.0052858684,
0.02621831,
0.0188955199,
-0.1010037586,
0.0211835057,
-0.0419328921,
0.0408714861,
0.0597908162,
-0.0345930569,
-0.0523109324,
-0.0440683849,
-0.0285851434,
-0.0008742866,
-0.044516474,
-0.03788957,
0.0553044043,
-0.0106621329,
-0.0132475235,
-0.0072712246,
0.0302077495,
0.0135170314,
-0.0239655618,
-0.027102543,
0.0256404467,
0.0098588187,
-0.0340213515,
0.0075238044,
-0.0478665978,
-0.0017965101,
0.0255376752,
-0.016323112,
0.0525253527,
0.0403452963,
-0.0200588759,
-0.0450111367,
-0.0619025454,
-0.0068292115,
-0.0005600015,
0.0244081393,
-0.0307226591,
0.0388089679,
0.0389237218,
0.0554328263,
0.0207777079,
0.0746753365,
-0.0088492502,
-0.0794169456,
-0.0546904504,
-0.0282835066,
-0.0098843593,
0.0194944013,
-0.0438918397,
0.0235776156,
-0.0205593426,
0.0555167757,
0.0410887524,
-0.0441544242,
0.0069585745,
0.0118073132,
2.886e-7,
0.0845249146,
0.0610289983,
-0.032483317,
-0.0191254802,
0.0295542814,
0.0182423443,
-0.0122558009,
-0.0202269387,
0.0417395569,
-0.0249428432,
0.0493699796,
0.0142471576,
0.0237453077,
0.0300868545,
-0.0679468066,
-0.0372941121,
-0.0395231396,
-0.0224758759,
-0.0455386601,
-0.0201655049,
0.1117469817,
0.0274913032,
-0.0238337163,
-0.0160489641,
0.0129913948,
-0.0423226878,
0.0079170028,
-0.0159180984,
-0.0108210174,
0.045283556,
0.0295802169,
-0.0303241443,
0.0282125715,
0.1220192537,
-0.0113968113,
-0.01562603,
-0.0293221921,
0.0955622196,
-0.0560955442,
0.0582731143,
-0.0015214026,
-0.0209899917,
0.0329378471,
-0.0273979884,
0.0456458554,
-0.082130082,
-0.0379601046,
0.0002912759,
0.0053135529,
-0.0507048778,
0.0808375329,
0.0134828668,
-0.0347217955,
0.0170206763,
0.0243636724,
0.0379896685,
-0.0370919965,
-0.0521035753,
0.0218456648,
0.0459879674,
-0.0525451563,
-0.0434829555,
0.0091586513,
-0.0086924788,
0.0103626791,
-0.0868901387,
0.0215261355,
2.747187465e-34,
0.0400224924,
0.0194928162,
0.028418446,
0.0176173616,
0.0551339984,
0.0082008308,
0.0130564841,
0.03164538,
0.0332646072,
-0.0691628978,
0.0090474039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07382v1 | Zero-Shot Multi-Label Topic Inference with Sentence Encoders | 2023-04-14T20:27:09 | 2023-04-14T20:27:09 | Souvika Sarkar, Dongji Feng, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Sentence encoders have indeed been shown to achieve superior performances for
many downstream text-mining tasks and, thus, claimed to be fairly general.
Inspired by this, we performed a detailed study on how to leverage these
sentence encoders for the "zero-shot topic inference" task, where the topics
are defined/provided by the users in real-time. Extensive experiments on seven
different datasets demonstrate that Sentence-BERT demonstrates superior
generality compared to other encoders, while Universal Sentence Encoder can be
preferred when efficiency is a top priority. | [
-0.0046083792,
0.0028312472,
-0.0020109897,
0.033059027,
-0.0385961533,
0.0206950232,
0.0403991304,
-0.0035412929,
-0.065775685,
-0.0620115511,
0.0025462299,
0.0381823555,
-0.0434583575,
0.0062233135,
-0.0095598958,
-0.0516120791,
-0.004508106,
-0.0068606487,
0.0525922589,
0.0232601427,
0.0294590518,
0.0163040943,
-0.0143121006,
0.0526288785,
-0.0054261447,
0.0160277504,
-0.0367235094,
0.0073106228,
0.0198774394,
-0.0113510098,
0.0447844304,
0.0327654034,
0.0490524694,
-0.0271122977,
0.0000015898,
-0.0344908684,
-0.0295007285,
-0.0607035644,
0.0161233284,
-0.0347483307,
0.0110972915,
-0.0547629483,
0.0579219945,
0.0382632203,
-0.0023716823,
0.018167574,
0.0206644312,
0.0654536337,
0.0234695263,
0.051671952,
-0.0612725392,
-0.0172344744,
0.0000718155,
-0.0136811994,
0.0388636775,
-0.0301397368,
0.0221733078,
-0.0701565221,
0.008667971,
0.0264671817,
0.0034295577,
-0.0105861789,
0.0239203013,
-0.0132900178,
0.0474874526,
0.0144651122,
-0.0683782697,
-0.0358210206,
-0.0131535111,
0.0817428008,
-0.0133928508,
0.0292394105,
0.0361974649,
-0.0128858965,
-0.0303989314,
-0.0190409645,
-0.0503131188,
0.0399004631,
-0.0040094531,
0.0334160328,
0.0039019666,
0.0063257897,
-0.0010614248,
-0.0238843039,
0.0126797501,
0.0839246735,
0.0532926992,
-0.0501536503,
-0.0209997837,
0.0523300394,
-0.0258286074,
-0.0651196316,
0.0328892544,
0.035796538,
0.0200564321,
0.0089729326,
-0.0357587636,
-0.0495457314,
-0.0018526432,
-0.0251969341,
-0.0215313192,
0.0172973312,
-0.0266619716,
0.0261830203,
0.0071940892,
-0.0075610494,
0.0101025263,
0.0065270327,
-0.0392234176,
-0.0692777336,
-0.0275588576,
0.0061348476,
-0.0312312562,
0.055530116,
-0.0007850329,
-0.0259553641,
-0.0385580175,
0.0366951562,
0.0490611978,
-0.0118461223,
-0.0195411108,
-0.0006752928,
-0.0556982905,
-0.0091531286,
-0.0066725635,
0.1009394974,
-0.0544452816,
0.0538525768,
-0.022887582,
0.0098559558,
-0.0121587766,
0.0475429222,
0.0571601167,
-0.0420048758,
-0.0062185712,
-0.0065170177,
-0.0315517746,
-0.0756924599,
-0.0568533577,
-0.0263240803,
-0.0383070707,
-0.0008804326,
0.0269028619,
-0.0563792773,
0.0281527732,
0.0332309566,
-0.0108749894,
0.0213680565,
0.0060199988,
0.0281823426,
-0.0257180594,
0.0357252508,
-0.0209822636,
-0.014026287,
0.0252493061,
0.0132238446,
0.0450764932,
0.0940908641,
0.0143901519,
0.0769576803,
0.0206162576,
0.0439153016,
0.0201859213,
0.0212148894,
-0.0070869522,
0.0220377184,
-0.0002582133,
-0.0238065477,
-0.0069270758,
0.0048387144,
0.0001739972,
0.0105086807,
-0.053041447,
0.0462338589,
0.0191884208,
0.0476510972,
0.00722975,
-0.0276150834,
0.0291603711,
-0.0159998685,
-0.0347981267,
-0.0019985358,
0.0473418944,
0.034454409,
0.0043641478,
-0.0169207472,
0.0715418234,
-0.0131795034,
-0.050885167,
-0.0211078301,
-0.0342718959,
-0.0526249073,
-0.037562862,
-0.0462482311,
0.1051560864,
0.0054195044,
-0.0198115408,
0.0376116112,
0.0291141327,
-0.0421655774,
-0.0143457502,
0.0143218823,
0.0054902858,
0.0493631847,
0.0542077944,
-0.0368893147,
-0.0279217009,
-0.0242053457,
0.039717339,
0.0568188541,
-0.0349218771,
-0.0273133311,
0.0489256755,
-0.0626951456,
-0.040001411,
-0.0449420586,
0.0201055091,
0.0157644693,
-0.0074004596,
0.0426800027,
0.0075321626,
-0.0339806713,
0.0705476403,
0.0202355664,
0.0275315363,
0.0209082086,
0.0676421523,
-0.0007237709,
0.0065395525,
0.0058616432,
-0.0038402958,
-0.0294621587,
0.0309499186,
-0.0801696256,
-0.0564986654,
-0.0274645369,
-0.0175652076,
-0.0966342464,
0.0125540951,
-0.0705493838,
0.003754708,
-0.0117597599,
-0.0322672054,
-0.0248970482,
0.0117204655,
-0.0067511611,
0.0013416857,
-0.0101498961,
-0.0417410806,
0.0012246879,
0.0063536479,
0.0057314388,
0.0515577793,
0.0150627317,
0.0132889999,
0.0134821692,
-0.0358186662,
0.0239389706,
-0.0368320458,
0.0020110828,
0.0102280043,
-0.0121912519,
-0.0180521626,
0.0576131642,
0.0124448529,
0.0034079412,
-0.0138094788,
-0.1242172271,
0.0196921136,
-0.0400778987,
0.0106889028,
0.0362075567,
0.0312547497,
0.0201677904,
-0.0287437458,
-0.0079719564,
-0.0119272703,
-0.0236171875,
0.0087445173,
0.0886328518,
-0.0259729587,
0.0001177392,
0.0110261012,
-0.0197004899,
-0.0552867204,
0.0772314519,
0.0243241042,
-0.0280267689,
0.0002199576,
-0.0192286763,
-0.0250041466,
-0.0420553647,
0.0015688736,
0.0069615552,
0.019956708,
-0.0254241619,
0.0690136701,
0.0093467282,
0.0157250073,
0.0660519972,
0.0176072512,
0.0042315731,
-0.0086113671,
0.0008821754,
-0.0168209691,
0.0175366104,
-0.001901282,
-0.0159986075,
0.0353775211,
0.0688635185,
0.0039253156,
0.0315002799,
-0.0489692576,
-0.0244574659,
0.0181349609,
0.0076370789,
-0.0859793276,
0.0086470088,
0.0229577199,
0.0237355586,
-0.011417741,
-0.0096788406,
0.0939744785,
-0.0044974512,
-0.0245863199,
-0.0513493083,
-0.0120699136,
-0.032996498,
0.0318728574,
0.0104390094,
0.0088365376,
0.0256061517,
0.0023499376,
0.0189947281,
0.0149740027,
0.0116257779,
0.0339212157,
0.0249267928,
-0.0203964692,
0.0530745685,
-0.0283760037,
-0.0229103789,
-0.0135781448,
-0.0550940521,
-0.0029033832,
0.0174449943,
-0.0302865468,
-0.0130647421,
-0.052006606,
-0.0336929709,
0.0363607705,
0.0226547867,
-0.0234938469,
-0.0101152696,
-0.0104297129,
0.0890511796,
0.0923127085,
-0.0729917437,
-0.0827501714,
-0.039637655,
0.0052049463,
0.033303529,
0.0214363169,
0.0307372175,
-0.0111322906,
-0.0018405191,
-0.0124974139,
-0.0118027367,
0.0208854508,
0.0239510406,
0.0354710408,
-0.0002973394,
-0.0087513076,
0.1255050898,
0.0452268869,
-0.0550117791,
-0.0212594438,
-0.0113243042,
0.0026619043,
-0.0079124356,
-0.008068583,
-0.1161199063,
-0.0696217865,
0.000614933,
0.018821029,
-0.0184243154,
-0.0237886887,
-0.0294173025,
-0.0718437657,
-0.0045218794,
-0.0258716419,
0.0056875832,
0.0074734543,
-0.0939888135,
0.0086989217,
-0.0132117234,
-0.0180368107,
-0.0172773357,
0.0335684195,
0.011949935,
-0.0014464301,
-0.02453674,
-0.04798517,
0.0159840155,
-0.0111093959,
0.0007754705,
0.0084080985,
0.022818489,
-0.0104704183,
0.0161431804,
-0.0210262705,
-0.0136893457,
-0.0411888063,
-0.0038319994,
0.0737969205,
-0.0546406358,
0.0078755692,
-0.0040849573,
0.017467076,
-0.0730192885,
-0.027231032,
0.0217809398,
0.0659997985,
-0.0275709815,
-0.0357073136,
-0.0235856716,
-0.0557342321,
0.01413392,
0.0544559583,
0.0018569882,
-0.0596361347,
-0.026488658,
-0.0360545106,
-0.0265775025,
-0.0192387141,
-0.0094862441,
-0.02428318,
-0.0274684038,
-0.0809241161,
-0.0346889198,
-0.053319104,
0.059451066,
0.0338306502,
-0.0231153406,
-0.0110507263,
0.0010040882,
-0.0047570881,
-0.020355029,
-0.003820776,
-0.0029749542,
-0.0110085569,
-0.0212308243,
-0.0016544011,
0.0568718277,
0.022226721,
0.0096273646,
-0.0177181549,
-0.0653950274,
-0.0377522968,
-0.0376491025,
-0.0161692463,
0.0032201556,
0.0038152195,
-0.0322623141,
-0.0340203345,
0.0487241037,
0.0771431327,
-0.0272802077,
0.000964958,
0.0121763293,
0.0165670682,
0.0190651082,
0.027547583,
-0.0629543886,
0.0561825708,
-0.0407431386,
0.0213815514,
-0.0454492941,
-0.042052839,
-0.0156644937,
0.0176556185,
0.0872634426,
0.0179062765,
-0.0227275025,
-0.0414686017,
-0.0064601703,
-0.0434998535,
-0.0132630644,
-0.0396451578,
0.0111233387,
-0.0045642918,
0.0142696695,
-0.022644598,
0.0431057326,
-0.0259523001,
0.000752637,
0.0056974627,
0.0265109725,
0.0377062,
0.039364215,
-0.0077243941,
-0.020360101,
-0.0135894092,
0.0098462952,
0.0288200248,
0.0263540298,
-0.0294104572,
0.0183931123,
0.0229090713,
0.0064867144,
0.0094707534,
-0.0105688348,
-0.0808435977,
0.0593015961,
-0.0192587897,
0.035399504,
0.0311205909,
0.0259277243,
0.0469445884,
-0.0161227323,
-0.0075962711,
-0.0056505715,
0.0637745559,
0.0027375089,
-0.0302926116,
-0.0020152919,
-0.0018151114,
-0.0619670562,
0.0279150847,
0.0843805447,
0.0132198427,
0.0439529978,
-0.0051513519,
-0.0207192954,
-0.0178807136,
0.0239015557,
0.0255917758,
0.0051015993,
0.0096416492,
0.0175413564,
0.0262110922,
0.0188984498,
0.0608596168,
-0.0622541159,
-0.0158779137,
0.0129337292,
0.0496217683,
0.0437404327,
-0.0340266153,
-0.0158034135,
-0.0429601185,
0.0268089045,
0.0175431818,
-0.0500076152,
-0.0268345773,
-6.397866042e-33,
-0.015894128,
-0.0439621583,
-0.0324066505,
-0.0218740217,
0.0351710841,
0.017209094,
-0.0354213566,
0.0066960584,
0.0042024669,
0.0058646551,
0.0128708119,
0.0431566276,
0.0034525888,
0.0262159593,
0.0288679153,
-0.0340529084,
0.0473140553,
-0.0056328578,
-0.0167746115,
0.0163280983,
0.0546303168,
0.0414128229,
0.0513187125,
-0.0314940512,
0.0121276081,
-0.0304507669,
0.0069804993,
-0.0009621807,
0.0925171524,
0.010227629,
-0.0030877315,
0.0695126578,
0.0297507104,
-0.0429061018,
0.0171131007,
0.0403272025,
-0.0366171151,
-0.0657572523,
-0.0757180974,
-0.0147735374,
-0.0221233312,
-0.0452726893,
0.0188822355,
0.0374023579,
0.0303719416,
-0.0209740084,
0.0759328008,
0.0126930336,
0.0077901091,
-0.0696929172,
-0.020701902,
0.0146385701,
-0.0342309177,
0.0026072913,
0.0124451127,
0.0561397709,
0.017010564,
0.046094276,
-0.002437325,
0.0252876822,
-0.0095021902,
0.019895602,
0.0165483989,
-0.024696121,
-0.0155309904,
0.0447315611,
-0.0180222802,
-0.0011620641,
-0.0390502661,
0.0022846754,
0.0041529345,
0.0330623202,
-0.0026843462,
0.0515754521,
0.0365474522,
0.0453687795,
-0.0834429488,
0.0515490808,
0.0310964137,
-0.0166018847,
0.007890258,
0.0297558289,
0.0176160652,
-0.0380827971,
0.0217083562,
0.0066122664,
-0.0253942758,
-0.0262436047,
0.0174511038,
0.0202943366,
0.0371477082,
0.0320414118,
0.0334575847,
-0.0177150797,
-0.002103633,
0.0451225452,
-0.0276332796,
0.0361355394,
0.0145662874,
0.0205395296,
-0.0693207681,
-0.0110437702,
0.0467818417,
0.0338183269,
0.0086750155,
-0.0070990468,
0.0579844899,
-0.0224180687,
-0.0350757577,
-0.0337689221,
-0.0104445834,
-0.0481159426,
-0.038251251,
0.0275900364,
-0.0296496972,
0.0255964324,
-0.0304581486,
0.0640322194,
0.0379014574,
0.0233580805,
-0.0140056126,
-0.0621660836,
0.0016174839,
-0.0121646225,
-0.0253431443,
0.002904139,
-0.0222420339,
0.0130596329,
0.0350535437,
-0.0641300306,
-0.0052238693,
-0.0265197828,
2.464e-7,
0.0534818992,
0.0654982328,
0.0175721869,
-0.0627872571,
0.0193521213,
0.0467212945,
0.0045731221,
0.0621262044,
-0.0147952363,
-0.0017112372,
0.044558946,
0.022445038,
0.0056586731,
0.0577442236,
-0.0694929883,
0.010301441,
-0.0620998256,
-0.0282646194,
-0.0930513963,
0.0354660936,
0.0692742392,
0.0426976234,
0.0286480896,
0.0117034512,
0.0190807674,
-0.0273558646,
0.0548353828,
0.0490111597,
-0.0277097076,
0.0250914134,
0.0215628278,
0.0233075935,
0.0039887424,
-0.0213569533,
-0.0034963069,
0.0172627252,
0.007606803,
0.0417282879,
-0.0529333204,
-0.0408098251,
0.0050384453,
0.0125764478,
-0.0185868293,
0.0333258174,
0.0928793177,
-0.0593353249,
-0.0204389356,
-0.0058498448,
0.0099288691,
0.0345573574,
0.0192628466,
0.010568995,
-0.0357245505,
-0.0037342436,
0.0244391859,
-0.0025299632,
-0.0243289806,
-0.0588645674,
0.0210412275,
0.0310215838,
-0.0473154746,
-0.0133871837,
-0.0385035425,
0.0087360544,
0.0159154963,
-0.0911668092,
0.0290454775,
1.877762112e-34,
0.0020526256,
-0.0104090795,
-0.0495879799,
0.0153390104,
0.0015573115,
-0.0340736695,
-0.0618060939,
-0.0488811135,
0.0045835888,
-0.0521360487,
-0.005647317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07333v1 | The Self-Perception and Political Biases of ChatGPT | 2023-04-14T18:06:13 | 2023-04-14T18:06:13 | Jérôme Rutinowski, Sven Franke, Jan Endendyk, Ina Dormuth, Markus Pauly | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | This contribution analyzes the self-perception and political biases of
OpenAI's Large Language Model ChatGPT. Taking into account the first
small-scale reports and studies that have emerged, claiming that ChatGPT is
politically biased towards progressive and libertarian points of view, this
contribution aims to provide further clarity on this subject. For this purpose,
ChatGPT was asked to answer the questions posed by the political compass test
as well as similar questionnaires that are specific to the respective politics
of the G7 member states. These eight tests were repeated ten times each and
revealed that ChatGPT seems to hold a bias towards progressive views. The
political compass test revealed a bias towards progressive and libertarian
views, with the average coordinates on the political compass being (-6.48,
-5.99) (with (0, 0) the center of the compass, i.e., centrism and the axes
ranging from -10 to 10), supporting the claims of prior research. The political
questionnaires for the G7 member states indicated a bias towards progressive
views but no significant bias between authoritarian and libertarian views,
contradicting the findings of prior reports, with the average coordinates being
(-3.27, 0.58). In addition, ChatGPT's Big Five personality traits were tested
using the OCEAN test and its personality type was queried using the
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) test. Finally, the maliciousness of ChatGPT
was evaluated using the Dark Factor test. These three tests were also repeated
ten times each, revealing that ChatGPT perceives itself as highly open and
agreeable, has the Myers-Briggs personality type ENFJ, and is among the 15% of
test-takers with the least pronounced dark traits. | [
0.0221026763,
0.0223864187,
-0.0251271613,
-0.0040714899,
-0.0486061834,
0.0087833907,
0.0052254554,
-0.0162991304,
0.0812570453,
-0.0107743787,
-0.0118266651,
-0.0125859557,
-0.0221870132,
-0.0019684983,
0.017163597,
-0.0421658456,
0.0753620565,
0.0294559225,
0.0896274075,
-0.0268175155,
-0.0112428702,
0.0339191332,
0.0110601382,
0.0417474061,
0.0140827373,
-0.0181261916,
0.0054356498,
-0.037012402,
0.0514541008,
-0.0051608798,
0.0125590153,
0.0348270573,
-0.0235381816,
-0.0019244739,
0.000002162,
-0.0237117354,
-0.0132155661,
-0.0069998601,
0.0585424416,
-0.0073683551,
0.0897729397,
0.0902592093,
-0.0131245516,
0.0693988129,
-0.027545467,
-0.0354029238,
0.0123652061,
0.0404532552,
0.0597658269,
0.0111936042,
0.012554178,
-0.0133211175,
-0.0359118991,
0.008646219,
-0.0110809859,
0.0179109536,
0.0687106326,
-0.016783705,
-0.0955205187,
0.0201056823,
-0.0004657353,
-0.0196983367,
-0.0085578179,
-0.013087634,
-0.0702608302,
-0.0174386129,
-0.0313207433,
-0.0442502573,
0.040657822,
0.0283838063,
0.096024543,
-0.0223748144,
-0.0218091216,
0.0247745998,
0.0115452791,
0.0318255201,
0.0070355516,
0.0350460187,
-0.0101186614,
-0.0026506591,
0.0629726276,
0.0341447927,
-0.0459219143,
0.0130552724,
-0.0292117018,
0.0732872188,
-0.010695586,
-0.0072396505,
0.0161880665,
-0.0407802425,
-0.009961023,
-0.056430392,
-0.0268000253,
-0.0052379132,
0.037649136,
0.0150093641,
0.0170795619,
0.0298668202,
0.0342713594,
-0.0799835399,
-0.0210124664,
0.0570288263,
-0.0585731044,
0.0410450809,
0.0712620765,
-0.0088808797,
0.0098189488,
0.0375925079,
-0.0057932623,
-0.0184538215,
0.0047899946,
-0.0120903607,
0.0272030514,
-0.0195188448,
0.0564622842,
-0.0032434948,
-0.0668315142,
-0.0173581392,
-0.02961668,
0.0151111363,
-0.0080901496,
-0.0349873379,
0.0104455762,
0.0056869262,
-0.0655398592,
0.104423508,
-0.0628981963,
-0.0028023052,
-0.0405121222,
-0.0437816009,
0.0573431663,
0.023665091,
-0.0309012141,
-0.0275881588,
-0.0001202994,
0.0178053826,
0.0182275698,
-0.0045006033,
0.0165772401,
0.0116487695,
-0.0408331305,
-0.0680933073,
0.0076304716,
-0.0169118904,
0.0068488936,
0.0184229575,
-0.0096046673,
-0.039701242,
0.0130926184,
0.0055470145,
-0.0140264509,
0.0114425533,
0.0050456058,
0.0384824648,
0.0352137238,
0.0380741991,
0.0136362454,
0.0341691077,
-0.0054605124,
-0.0200452562,
0.012934614,
-0.0392891355,
0.0191930234,
0.0069265133,
-0.0393757522,
0.0449534804,
0.0143907182,
0.0282875951,
-0.0088688498,
-0.0523222871,
0.0319154374,
0.0407363251,
0.0118304323,
0.0135855889,
0.0630105361,
0.0167113617,
0.0465704948,
0.0746365562,
-0.0668248832,
0.0435720012,
0.0185727421,
0.0222821254,
0.0006463695,
0.0101428442,
-0.004930228,
-0.0181656647,
-0.0141905434,
0.0546608232,
0.0083297454,
-0.001464325,
-0.010099316,
0.0298373383,
0.0522104055,
0.0155934403,
0.0139094982,
-0.0412574708,
-0.0147957606,
-0.0299129561,
0.0574238449,
-0.0289033595,
-0.0524872206,
-0.0885561109,
0.0457502007,
-0.007927563,
-0.0401035771,
0.0254212543,
-0.0181144662,
-0.0357321054,
0.02134775,
0.0458295234,
0.1137587577,
0.0034233823,
-0.0762607232,
-0.0111078648,
0.0083918842,
0.0186389592,
-0.0134786749,
0.0728942901,
-0.0043740594,
0.0685486495,
0.0044103945,
0.0481829047,
0.0185585581,
-0.0244993102,
0.0083534392,
-0.0109532531,
-0.0463632345,
0.0187688041,
0.067920655,
-0.0118527906,
-0.0139949732,
0.0078102322,
-0.0046681296,
0.0038551895,
0.0043587754,
0.048627615,
-0.0229931939,
0.0995656252,
-0.0045415643,
-0.0197652671,
0.0141606499,
-0.0069447178,
0.0184449423,
0.0164065864,
0.049960129,
0.0412541963,
-0.0027723091,
-0.0049521858,
0.0089498777,
-0.0513513237,
0.0026209797,
-0.0069538085,
0.0331947468,
-0.0098160338,
0.0018057509,
0.0081090927,
-0.0396872237,
0.0830453932,
0.0070338161,
-0.0239264593,
0.0048933942,
0.0093076136,
0.0286375377,
0.0430520363,
-0.0101868445,
-0.0453124978,
-0.0369465165,
-0.0357946046,
-0.0216366556,
-0.0018629768,
0.0363097973,
0.0247535128,
-0.0328379348,
-0.037317317,
0.0704301819,
-0.019504426,
0.0251740944,
-0.0031047862,
0.0450346507,
-0.0058429134,
-0.0105656562,
-0.0338360593,
-0.0187079813,
0.0295250658,
-0.0445033088,
-0.0372248068,
-0.0201082435,
-0.0160225127,
0.0218708292,
-0.0207100175,
-0.0795613602,
-0.0169429164,
-0.0586575717,
-0.0870024264,
0.0399631746,
0.0117464634,
0.014849335,
0.020772798,
0.0752289072,
0.0506287217,
0.0231928974,
0.0102609824,
-0.0388199724,
-0.0280828252,
-0.0159362182,
0.0048219603,
-0.0209899787,
-0.0457796939,
-0.0287344065,
0.0620544404,
0.024040876,
0.0229043383,
-0.0201756414,
0.0328038968,
-0.0412955843,
-0.0114756562,
-0.0060942299,
-0.0151594793,
-0.0178036094,
0.0421476439,
0.0240996908,
0.0050285314,
-0.011691438,
0.0033755519,
0.0507835895,
-0.0162468012,
-0.0134525085,
-0.0065772599,
0.0699603781,
-0.0035907843,
-0.0123854252,
0.0342706256,
0.0028642146,
-0.0563720986,
-0.0600638315,
0.0373567902,
-0.0400314108,
0.0094906623,
-0.0132260798,
-0.0118318275,
-0.0231417343,
0.0199202225,
-0.0323396996,
-0.0491677672,
-0.0020146775,
-0.01940253,
0.0500618778,
-0.015340874,
0.019056974,
0.035711728,
0.0339504294,
-0.0447380506,
-0.0257567,
0.0473690704,
0.0183173083,
-0.0533161238,
0.0171271451,
-0.0030684457,
0.0566777401,
-0.0092090983,
-0.0368449464,
0.0226330087,
-0.0749305636,
0.0174283478,
0.0106937932,
-0.0629471764,
0.0323998109,
-0.002087787,
-0.0214542169,
0.0099435374,
0.0269519221,
-0.0100120176,
0.0176589638,
0.047080148,
0.0032468007,
-0.0000924407,
-0.0144196153,
0.0101108402,
0.0153663894,
0.0358228348,
0.0147677045,
-0.045212552,
0.0570654944,
0.0078823399,
-0.0474265516,
-0.0881865174,
-0.0085363816,
-0.0512294136,
-0.0520865582,
-0.0088211372,
0.0074272878,
-0.0288199615,
0.0183218811,
0.0253854264,
0.0169824008,
0.0054623224,
0.0221474133,
0.0206905659,
0.0237012263,
0.0046071797,
-0.0149649968,
-0.094150655,
-0.0234865751,
0.039178066,
-0.0145745538,
0.0322769657,
0.0051583196,
0.0547397882,
0.0011263634,
-0.0220796,
0.0383954458,
-0.0148304878,
-0.0323996097,
0.0244902875,
-0.0040978016,
-0.0551827103,
0.0060447594,
-0.0698153526,
-0.0075060423,
0.0301145464,
0.0476001166,
0.0182153713,
0.0068032015,
-0.004336542,
-0.0428480729,
0.017623812,
0.0328025185,
0.0437963419,
0.0312754437,
0.0015520498,
0.007340631,
0.0474404879,
-0.0265040305,
0.0054120338,
0.0341928415,
-0.0485508777,
-0.0081698466,
0.0147326821,
-0.0473920405,
-0.0100948811,
-0.0907440558,
-0.0099081481,
0.0141844926,
-0.0097093154,
-0.0142915715,
0.0152188186,
0.0324538089,
0.009486272,
-0.0081622945,
0.0075773937,
-0.0101483371,
0.0138389943,
-0.0521190912,
0.0051231659,
0.005451947,
-0.0240917951,
-0.0162057038,
-0.0081764786,
0.0037327709,
0.0937743634,
-0.0159052238,
0.0265181828,
-0.0512649901,
0.0058100466,
0.0272609945,
0.0017873353,
0.0232431758,
-0.0147210248,
0.0306862891,
-0.0142827071,
0.0615796931,
0.0323672816,
-0.0070667784,
-0.0088136476,
-0.004252662,
-0.0018077806,
-0.0653871149,
-0.0144106951,
-0.0560874753,
0.036966119,
0.0264000408,
0.0278278943,
0.000487155,
0.0174484756,
-0.0385603048,
-0.0613120832,
-0.0618826672,
-0.0153356204,
0.0154861733,
-0.0701991096,
0.0289089922,
-0.0432743914,
-0.0144081609,
0.0139124058,
-0.056959182,
0.011272517,
-0.0385060534,
0.0742819533,
-0.0027627596,
0.0275530498,
0.0132661276,
-0.0131886806,
-0.0195188969,
0.0084833512,
-0.011133234,
0.0026496977,
-0.0007002951,
0.086290054,
-0.0109883109,
-0.0298984312,
0.0511902161,
0.0180670768,
-0.019717874,
-0.0655911043,
-0.0029469053,
0.0496712252,
-0.020193046,
0.010343154,
0.017137317,
-0.0375686213,
-0.000502867,
-0.0092195962,
0.0285715908,
-0.0102766817,
-0.0650176704,
0.058664944,
-0.0366782509,
-0.0370006077,
-0.0287051518,
-0.0058454224,
-0.0070353197,
-0.0067485911,
0.0108170388,
-0.008822144,
-0.0253670886,
-0.014083514,
-0.0288036093,
-0.0051649129,
-0.03714386,
-0.0130974101,
-0.0772878453,
-0.0313189402,
-0.0415752679,
0.0225593951,
0.0013038019,
0.0100118043,
-0.0252447091,
0.0301777553,
-0.016848173,
-0.0245944262,
-0.0366583727,
0.002774508,
-0.0833735764,
-0.0081012659,
0.0308063719,
-6.445577888e-33,
-0.046390079,
0.0026251117,
0.0465714894,
-0.0225607231,
-0.0296874847,
-0.0778285936,
-0.0188712534,
0.0739161819,
-0.0890395567,
-0.0094016511,
-0.0000342944,
0.0136381695,
0.0120202526,
-0.0553677157,
0.0130970683,
-0.0227956679,
-0.0025991269,
0.0022390226,
-0.0024343086,
-0.0347179435,
0.0300874207,
-0.0234079137,
0.0726549029,
-0.0611154847,
0.0368228927,
-0.0178717878,
-0.0212767869,
-0.0498322807,
0.0168829262,
-0.020224167,
-0.0113706877,
-0.0164131839,
0.0228902176,
-0.0024321177,
0.0037572996,
0.0516331643,
-0.0078467745,
-0.0485901572,
0.0118845738,
0.0096046617,
0.0186604615,
-0.0238154754,
-0.0128739728,
-0.0021888083,
-0.0553136617,
-0.018676566,
0.0092621995,
0.0136186853,
0.0347685665,
0.0759382099,
-0.0278690215,
0.0014900271,
-0.0052555837,
0.0219416469,
-0.0958256125,
0.0415520594,
0.012694383,
0.0194563922,
-0.053455025,
0.0289221425,
-0.0389235355,
-0.0123761464,
0.0230707396,
-0.0072371894,
0.0309426691,
0.0555823743,
0.0424646735,
0.0649553761,
-0.0910654142,
-0.0504819825,
0.0771799311,
-0.0599090755,
0.0323237069,
0.0529125147,
-0.0076253102,
-0.0911033973,
-0.0019555071,
-0.0591069646,
0.1235437989,
0.0015214796,
0.0142465439,
-0.0050836401,
-0.0361986421,
-0.0218784288,
-0.0052129314,
-0.0584601611,
-0.0120919375,
-0.047575701,
0.0297340043,
-0.0373965502,
0.0069802189,
-0.0389609039,
0.0867069885,
-0.0108308159,
-0.000553176,
-0.0048226989,
-0.0747068673,
-0.0102026975,
-0.0129647637,
0.0013983246,
-0.0546345562,
-0.0233327355,
-0.0335246176,
0.0028008854,
0.0277856495,
0.0126948534,
-0.0350134112,
-0.0024039629,
-0.0666612834,
-0.0240857191,
0.0209737811,
-0.0117919371,
0.0560500361,
0.0199988279,
-0.0014466965,
0.0080334814,
0.0240255464,
-0.0044517992,
0.0577366427,
0.025432419,
-0.0397969261,
-0.0099414345,
-0.0465439111,
-0.0150787132,
0.0000063591,
-0.0180334914,
-0.0403843299,
0.0639045611,
0.0214581955,
-0.0322128348,
-0.0028978016,
-0.0352263749,
2.774e-7,
-0.0043888567,
0.077296786,
-0.0618797056,
0.0458908714,
0.0135039184,
0.0270827916,
0.0155555364,
0.0238063298,
0.0058821705,
-0.0394058526,
-0.0136596886,
-0.0445614979,
0.0152182067,
0.0575112924,
-0.0217874218,
0.0432543047,
-0.0422769599,
0.0009120408,
-0.0464027561,
0.0370565876,
0.0037804395,
0.0129656531,
0.0102262814,
0.012903844,
-0.0264934581,
0.0016738023,
0.0286723431,
-0.0176661536,
-0.0472748727,
0.034888979,
0.0224248394,
0.0019658024,
0.0395887829,
0.0359184891,
0.0370794982,
-0.012574017,
-0.0158390161,
0.0453687012,
0.0096215513,
0.0369764417,
0.0060090404,
-0.0050736116,
-0.0018002931,
-0.050823871,
0.0489247255,
-0.0604934432,
-0.015010546,
-0.0589372404,
-0.0215088334,
-0.0028208392,
0.0616351515,
0.0078689996,
-0.0029202856,
0.035044644,
0.0307645872,
-0.0335684977,
0.0109338798,
-0.0075659608,
-0.0002132408,
-0.0849990323,
-0.0051708124,
-0.0702108145,
-0.0152123896,
0.0447990373,
0.0253297929,
0.0204088744,
-0.0005924631,
2.574646017e-34,
-0.0101982011,
-0.0079881214,
-0.0261649359,
-0.0864528567,
0.1068540886,
0.0258237831,
0.0469230078,
0.0326805003,
-0.0343848057,
-0.0432215929,
-0.007453301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07327v2 | OpenAssistant Conversations -- Democratizing Large Language Model Alignment | 2023-04-14T18:01:29 | 2023-10-31T11:38:07 | Andreas Köpf, Yannic Kilcher, Dimitri von Rütte, Sotiris Anagnostidis, Zhi-Rui Tam, Keith Stevens, Abdullah Barhoum, Nguyen Minh Duc, Oliver Stanley, Richárd Nagyfi, Shahul ES, Sameer Suri, David Glushkov, Arnav Dantuluri, Andrew Maguire, Christoph Schuhmann, Huu Nguyen, Alexander Mattick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2 | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences has proven to
drastically improve usability and has driven rapid adoption as demonstrated by
ChatGPT. Alignment techniques such as supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) greatly reduce the required
skill and domain knowledge to effectively harness the capabilities of LLMs,
increasing their accessibility and utility across various domains. However,
state-of-the-art alignment techniques like RLHF rely on high-quality human
feedback data, which is expensive to create and often remains proprietary. In
an effort to democratize research on large-scale alignment, we release
OpenAssistant Conversations, a human-generated, human-annotated assistant-style
conversation corpus consisting of 161,443 messages in 35 different languages,
annotated with 461,292 quality ratings, resulting in over 10,000 complete and
fully annotated conversation trees. The corpus is a product of a worldwide
crowd-sourcing effort involving over 13,500 volunteers. Models trained on
OpenAssistant Conversations show consistent improvements on standard benchmarks
over respective base models. We release our code and data under a fully
permissive licence. | [
0.0419128053,
0.0704226196,
-0.008711338,
0.0475049056,
-0.0466086306,
0.0024902255,
-0.0304575041,
-0.0364031419,
-0.0163509157,
-0.005243659,
-0.0628725216,
-0.0190528929,
0.0305802319,
0.0221556406,
0.0133922696,
-0.027333444,
0.0475798883,
-0.0090865493,
0.0008790045,
0.009516337,
0.0432779007,
0.0367582887,
-0.0240619332,
0.0539785437,
0.0088739982,
-0.0231476258,
-0.0323566087,
0.0063390322,
0.0263042096,
0.0071868636,
0.0225956496,
0.069009766,
0.0026644147,
0.0867986158,
0.0000018185,
-0.0570534393,
-0.0054091848,
-0.0220673587,
-0.0276302528,
0.0043260907,
0.024886433,
0.00284065,
-0.0216941219,
0.02039258,
-0.0383922122,
0.0201382879,
0.0740965605,
0.010951329,
0.0676469281,
0.0936092511,
-0.0080587128,
-0.0045605279,
0.0061752088,
-0.024108734,
-0.012811874,
-0.0580768771,
0.0020721408,
0.0067836666,
-0.0080353152,
0.004903716,
0.0189156141,
0.0251098331,
-0.007795434,
-0.0397776626,
0.0095989918,
0.0145090837,
-0.064991802,
-0.0477309301,
-0.0076646353,
0.1026863232,
0.0146993846,
-0.0276095588,
-0.0210463796,
0.0032482184,
0.0186335891,
-0.020935826,
-0.0561499409,
-0.0073922095,
0.0128420051,
0.0246000998,
0.0017365814,
-0.0215109047,
0.0228413157,
0.0182696376,
0.0386062004,
0.0393454917,
0.0193660446,
-0.0290611126,
-0.00058256,
0.0189138614,
-0.0020122142,
-0.0745365694,
-0.003386338,
-0.0163493641,
-0.0647655576,
0.0164516568,
-0.0609152094,
-0.0009953483,
0.0385459214,
-0.0529666245,
0.0128647843,
0.0673887059,
-0.007592591,
0.0515942872,
0.0390966572,
0.0478766523,
-0.0338531733,
0.0140582509,
-0.0272219423,
-0.0111059556,
-0.0356108174,
-0.0006237712,
-0.0128738824,
-0.0200722776,
-0.0487117954,
-0.0224414896,
-0.0508265235,
0.0406146124,
0.0068541868,
0.0479488298,
0.0021894812,
-0.0104073379,
-0.0387845375,
-0.023944322,
-0.0126312338,
0.0603697635,
-0.0334960222,
0.0075157788,
0.0246151388,
-0.0612885915,
-0.0130454609,
0.0255486574,
-0.0150464671,
-0.0326183699,
-0.0306602214,
0.0372497886,
-0.0077297487,
-0.0029438187,
0.0156735126,
-0.0082244016,
-0.0184343439,
-0.0611501001,
-0.0403971523,
-0.0668328926,
0.0332875364,
0.0080262236,
-0.0169664491,
-0.0326913893,
0.0119396066,
0.0237528924,
-0.0170525517,
0.0689878687,
-0.0433675721,
0.0346863754,
0.0333585404,
-0.0296641234,
-0.0061793188,
0.0764634088,
0.0331996866,
0.034515366,
0.0594719201,
-0.0052621374,
0.0092260204,
0.0676260144,
-0.0123915309,
0.0188269783,
0.0154993162,
0.0167271011,
0.0123502845,
0.0641489699,
0.0367430039,
0.0271841548,
-0.0046445765,
-0.0154903242,
0.085084103,
0.0504484065,
-0.0218193494,
0.0241939537,
-0.0062129647,
0.0441531427,
-0.0062107393,
-0.0262053106,
-0.0570424944,
0.0317871049,
-0.0322963111,
0.0134386299,
0.0412060134,
0.0453672558,
-0.0229115952,
-0.0235476978,
-0.0040242649,
-0.0087188073,
-0.0014204161,
0.011506374,
0.0284013171,
-0.0160891507,
-0.0231290106,
0.0355911553,
0.049862545,
-0.0498632789,
-0.0300589763,
-0.0131072002,
0.0333506018,
0.074442856,
0.0463980623,
0.0036416221,
-0.0432704464,
-0.0271897204,
0.0149730379,
0.072524175,
0.0643580556,
-0.0093796998,
-0.0028956486,
-0.0536818914,
-0.0224180035,
0.0179757811,
-0.0172230639,
0.0111088865,
0.018264927,
-0.0147214681,
-0.0057218708,
-0.0190254878,
-0.0569391176,
0.0040040421,
-0.0258656479,
-0.0066464934,
-0.0221857764,
0.022927694,
0.0327602215,
0.0342921503,
-0.0101114716,
-0.0057273074,
0.0019509537,
0.0044596456,
0.0192963891,
0.0356792882,
-0.0470297635,
0.0011255344,
0.0542311296,
-0.007436044,
-0.0683297366,
0.051476568,
-0.048371274,
-0.0330007114,
-0.0134198256,
-0.0200670697,
0.0234012492,
-0.0261986218,
0.0393971875,
-0.0048822276,
-0.0141358189,
-0.0357473418,
0.0209956914,
0.0160497501,
0.0045639337,
0.0010642107,
-0.026372591,
0.031626679,
-0.0385732055,
-0.0172648877,
0.0273337048,
-0.0173838828,
0.0135140428,
0.047252275,
0.0257637855,
-0.0683216155,
-0.0186494552,
-0.1236315742,
0.0267169531,
-0.0182127617,
0.0476383008,
0.0382332914,
0.0453758277,
-0.0291241258,
-0.0250594933,
-0.0622768141,
-0.002391208,
0.0077425865,
0.014678563,
0.0505369753,
-0.014429979,
-0.0037875387,
-0.0996995792,
0.0098566134,
-0.0089277579,
-0.0008091702,
0.0226778556,
-0.0245048143,
-0.0536330603,
0.0035265244,
-0.0369309075,
0.0164543055,
-0.0091136154,
-0.0699181855,
0.0085475547,
0.0115728229,
0.0324689895,
0.0576795153,
0.0083720768,
-0.0094578722,
0.0114339273,
0.0128867356,
-0.0778979436,
-0.0012146869,
-0.0254614316,
-0.0630682185,
-0.0556593835,
0.0058593308,
0.0140059115,
0.0741682053,
-0.0204427242,
0.0194963906,
-0.0742828026,
0.0018662036,
0.0167920571,
0.0041356427,
-0.027641803,
0.0127757424,
-0.0419601388,
0.0440820344,
-0.0478685535,
-0.0617145039,
0.07507056,
-0.0242871512,
-0.0110345539,
-0.0588579066,
-0.0302607398,
-0.0255450346,
0.034913592,
-0.0283835139,
0.0271810554,
0.0182371922,
-0.0369449221,
-0.057167612,
-0.0006012447,
0.0345959216,
-0.0369146615,
0.0406628959,
-0.0489768013,
0.0137562826,
0.0031330353,
-0.0708794296,
-0.0360052958,
-0.0603702106,
-0.0604005754,
-0.0171627365,
0.0175115652,
-0.0593507513,
-0.060339611,
-0.0100944145,
0.0089607434,
0.0316495858,
-0.0143816285,
0.0024689767,
-0.0218663365,
0.0173701849,
0.0823920593,
0.0248422604,
-0.0130051654,
-0.0241422541,
0.0268907547,
0.0412548073,
0.0183334667,
0.0053842114,
-0.0057837637,
-0.0367644988,
0.0338328592,
-0.020236386,
-0.0045584971,
-0.0100004347,
0.0641512871,
-0.0048507475,
-0.0029533296,
0.1308694333,
0.0167203154,
-0.0709849298,
-0.02067337,
-0.0487729758,
0.058866512,
0.0226845555,
0.0220169295,
-0.104832679,
-0.0423561372,
0.0147156566,
0.02361908,
0.0297602229,
-0.0091784531,
0.0121675925,
-0.1434289366,
0.0082486132,
0.0211079903,
-0.0505901016,
-0.0295021683,
-0.0030480337,
0.030764807,
-0.0488884188,
0.034686774,
-0.0075906347,
0.0218119696,
-0.0011762853,
-0.0031003414,
-0.0161152761,
-0.0471814275,
0.0236739404,
-0.0443205647,
0.0902215466,
0.0763901398,
0.0454938598,
0.0372871421,
-0.0157277379,
0.0381926335,
0.0244925581,
-0.0115415603,
0.0124347303,
0.0367782563,
-0.0191794615,
-0.0135150058,
-0.027858099,
0.0514092408,
-0.0190714486,
0.0078350352,
0.0240664836,
0.0512198023,
0.0026043602,
0.0431472808,
0.0126929022,
0.0079374341,
0.038269002,
0.0662999377,
0.0277064703,
-0.0542973094,
-0.0072154878,
-0.0298459064,
-0.0098584713,
-0.0061680772,
-0.018939713,
0.0056215469,
-0.0119176665,
-0.0270499457,
-0.070534952,
-0.0402762853,
0.0170665439,
-0.0252287984,
0.0253711026,
-0.0241077002,
0.0101877591,
-0.0136568788,
-0.0208161734,
0.0684181228,
-0.0402664766,
0.0285085365,
-0.0865836442,
-0.0015966623,
0.0005906066,
-0.0309387799,
0.0003434287,
0.0249343794,
-0.0808950663,
-0.0962969363,
-0.0215616692,
0.0239691604,
0.0162680224,
0.0830650777,
-0.0222681146,
-0.0527116917,
-0.0281887967,
0.0329142809,
-0.0518116206,
-0.0050193267,
0.0124715483,
0.0355498157,
-0.0056806542,
0.0524883196,
-0.0342601649,
-0.0135990269,
-0.0009290007,
0.0270299483,
-0.0361149497,
-0.08354792,
0.0191634689,
0.0165076014,
0.0657727942,
-0.0100645544,
0.0019826477,
-0.0302556846,
0.0004598822,
-0.0112066986,
-0.0304383356,
-0.0283449255,
-0.0417144224,
0.027405791,
-0.0390841998,
0.0215514079,
0.0185243916,
-0.0349204503,
0.0371429659,
-0.047367271,
-0.0053739687,
0.0097472519,
0.0223604739,
0.0167736337,
0.0136958417,
-0.022470085,
0.0233269818,
0.0162732471,
0.0540159047,
-0.004087049,
0.0703640804,
0.0136062773,
-0.0062821223,
0.0401577987,
0.0399332717,
-0.0294413064,
-0.0651338771,
-0.0086243143,
0.0254526436,
0.0679537579,
-0.0086343624,
0.084043473,
-0.0194350816,
-0.0174507145,
-0.0213471353,
0.0621681027,
-0.0442805067,
0.0115500707,
0.0152456379,
0.0123886717,
-0.0477064475,
0.0068739899,
0.0472778231,
-0.0428718887,
0.0097225662,
-0.008008536,
0.0037239536,
-0.028296005,
-0.0060947998,
0.0210468154,
-0.0003352973,
-0.0209145118,
-0.0172388311,
-0.0225510523,
-0.0404634476,
-0.0262753107,
0.0283318479,
-0.0365258753,
0.0119499145,
0.0501587354,
0.048037868,
-0.0530395508,
-0.0034382746,
-0.0320942476,
-0.0171559956,
-0.0428269133,
-0.028999446,
-0.0337380916,
-6.190599205e-33,
-0.0159326959,
-0.0104130991,
0.0077022254,
0.0079430314,
-0.0528371371,
-0.0291799307,
-0.0206510276,
0.0268982332,
-0.0147210024,
0.009589158,
-0.0161411092,
0.021834176,
0.0170837082,
0.016058255,
0.0323040597,
-0.0042808284,
0.046183072,
0.008913774,
-0.0348110758,
0.0220668446,
0.0348691083,
0.0050998484,
0.0610893033,
-0.0961052626,
0.0388506539,
-0.003597667,
-0.0255036894,
0.0443072282,
0.0188503545,
0.0672107935,
0.0030414031,
0.0271059275,
0.0023335442,
-0.0136271473,
-0.0052772118,
0.053974241,
-0.0281104762,
-0.0194507688,
0.0547426865,
0.0246958584,
-0.0116500296,
-0.0235718973,
0.0346337259,
-0.030110484,
-0.0062763337,
0.0115356222,
0.0392505452,
-0.0261476096,
-0.0075951885,
0.0219142959,
-0.0737289041,
0.0231270995,
-0.0439492054,
-0.0478653572,
0.0086505311,
0.054799974,
0.0133189159,
0.01273946,
-0.0337708369,
0.0493171029,
-0.0169928037,
0.0239747819,
0.099823527,
0.0215544514,
0.0006296866,
0.0502293557,
-0.0130566359,
0.0038375489,
0.0134356627,
-0.0033114641,
-0.0088093197,
0.0311778393,
0.012908604,
0.0814959481,
-0.0110502988,
-0.001933614,
-0.0285744313,
0.0376934409,
0.0126878824,
0.0213947203,
-0.0115777124,
0.0316853486,
-0.0708644241,
-0.0024705643,
-0.0226359218,
0.0026448863,
-0.027051948,
-0.0336678997,
0.0153542617,
-0.0273401719,
-0.0021627184,
-0.0280996766,
0.0293983016,
-0.037752077,
-0.0046023307,
0.0078043309,
-0.0302732829,
0.0118081644,
-0.0150933703,
0.0016453071,
-0.0600750484,
-0.0221303497,
-0.0247907769,
0.0233851559,
0.0233981535,
0.0193549786,
0.0310183614,
-0.0008866565,
-0.0552551784,
0.0367805995,
-0.0167349223,
0.0160200931,
-0.0359927788,
0.0168324076,
0.040962819,
-0.0151324458,
-0.0088472776,
0.0936822146,
0.0186671801,
0.022066094,
-0.0325689651,
-0.0529040396,
-0.0081219962,
-0.0119116399,
-0.0177994445,
0.0172509905,
-0.0221431907,
0.0088878814,
0.0182508174,
-0.0156192295,
-0.0061768726,
-0.001208429,
2.52e-7,
0.0102957478,
0.0361701213,
0.0395636894,
0.0242884941,
-0.0033874349,
0.0573374517,
-0.0002522397,
0.0312876627,
0.0180893876,
-0.0033983288,
0.0211858004,
-0.0033851236,
0.1013830751,
0.0044939793,
-0.1065578684,
-0.0033598882,
-0.0950865,
0.0126448935,
-0.0554768629,
0.0107783936,
0.040188238,
0.101467669,
0.0141417272,
0.0129090417,
0.0007564428,
-0.0191538669,
0.0456762128,
-0.0699128956,
-0.0500366241,
0.0296989698,
0.0192428138,
0.0104480777,
-0.0168929882,
-0.0309626721,
-0.006612977,
0.0205477457,
-0.0055447216,
0.0595735759,
-0.0117021622,
-0.0255891625,
-0.0220365599,
-0.0093996329,
0.0005818826,
-0.0644081831,
0.0178287625,
-0.0662225112,
-0.0414886661,
-0.0371749178,
0.0105525162,
-0.0250750128,
0.0505125634,
-0.0142181171,
-0.0031631817,
0.0171037484,
0.0310172327,
-0.0125634084,
-0.037271332,
-0.0419718288,
-0.0338424817,
-0.0029002533,
-0.0370103531,
-0.0380197242,
-0.0142834401,
-0.0022444781,
-0.0038059771,
-0.0217365324,
0.0351685956,
1.848380493e-34,
0.0224988796,
-0.0009411322,
0.032111384,
0.0359373391,
0.0277802087,
-0.0037903714,
0.0158392116,
0.0219433401,
0.0439032875,
-0.051621832,
0.0000652875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07258v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07258v2 | Learn What Is Possible, Then Choose What Is Best: Disentangling One-To-Many Relations in Language Through Text-based Games | 2023-04-14T17:11:26 | 2023-04-26T10:35:13 | Benjamin Towle, Ke Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models pre-trained on large self-supervised corpora, followed by
task-specific fine-tuning has become the dominant paradigm in NLP. These
pre-training datasets often have a one-to-many structure--e.g. in dialogue
there are many valid responses for a given context. However, only some of these
responses will be desirable in our downstream task. This raises the question of
how we should train the model such that it can emulate the desirable
behaviours, but not the undesirable ones. Current approaches train in a
one-to-one setup--only a single target response is given for a single dialogue
context--leading to models only learning to predict the average response, while
ignoring the full range of possible responses. Using text-based games as a
testbed, our approach, PASA, uses discrete latent variables to capture the
range of different behaviours represented in our larger pre-training dataset.
We then use knowledge distillation to distil the posterior probability
distribution into a student model. This probability distribution is far richer
than learning from only the hard targets of the dataset, and thus allows the
student model to benefit from the richer range of actions the teacher model has
learned. Results show up to 49% empirical improvement over the previous
state-of-the-art model on the Jericho Walkthroughs dataset. | [
0.0561365522,
0.069944039,
-0.0360296071,
0.0656608939,
-0.0129462834,
0.0130432863,
-0.029693773,
-0.0256685242,
-0.0049125953,
-0.0532379821,
-0.0181257036,
-0.028817134,
-0.0205440726,
0.0273159239,
0.0323653743,
-0.0795692354,
0.0091211032,
-0.0532183088,
0.0240892228,
0.0013049345,
-0.0073244702,
0.0136946719,
-0.0265452582,
0.051318597,
0.0082951384,
0.007485901,
-0.0359217264,
-0.0056118723,
0.0096641891,
-0.0139161833,
0.0437147245,
0.0577542596,
0.0439526029,
-0.044608593,
0.000002085,
-0.0282569565,
-0.0055297581,
-0.0548278242,
-0.0175179746,
-0.0333119743,
-0.0165376291,
0.0054775844,
0.0407715067,
0.0158479512,
-0.0553252883,
-0.0197279435,
0.0492461659,
0.0433847941,
0.0552907474,
0.0730759054,
0.0127148069,
-0.0339248702,
-0.0045304615,
-0.0183649231,
0.0393374451,
-0.0541076697,
0.0074130865,
0.0257948283,
0.0051417928,
0.0150740286,
-0.0433989167,
0.0014348496,
0.0076172547,
0.0147742564,
-0.0042080665,
0.0311099421,
0.0030894957,
-0.0249851309,
-0.0045963973,
0.0919361264,
-0.027358694,
-0.0146311065,
0.0318175666,
-0.0189925004,
-0.0047215149,
0.007403106,
-0.015493568,
0.0024261412,
0.0100743901,
0.0434328765,
-0.0036684652,
0.0187611189,
0.0172992684,
0.0016958154,
0.0050484831,
0.0138682816,
-0.0288166087,
-0.014213833,
0.0082339225,
0.0198032986,
-0.0460921973,
-0.0498016141,
-0.0354616269,
0.0244512092,
-0.0681825578,
0.0345336162,
-0.0462438427,
0.0048785126,
0.0125089306,
-0.0031575828,
0.0436076075,
0.0278519578,
0.016778104,
0.0490735471,
0.0498714894,
0.0025954042,
0.0217528585,
0.0197931901,
-0.0394967645,
0.0122408392,
-0.0747851357,
-0.0020644413,
-0.0323056579,
0.065009892,
-0.0408166125,
-0.0083979666,
-0.0024869631,
-0.0099307587,
-0.0383677222,
0.0220249426,
0.0286823791,
0.0462070554,
-0.0767109245,
-0.0159684848,
-0.0567638017,
0.0414077379,
-0.0497441925,
0.0303190891,
0.0046514231,
-0.0353591703,
-0.0418307707,
-0.0222524274,
0.0244856887,
-0.03695447,
0.0193564426,
0.0473683216,
-0.0314479098,
-0.0305827893,
0.0105853174,
-0.0388883799,
-0.0287939385,
-0.1002643853,
0.0290674157,
-0.0521873645,
0.055290442,
-0.0113980481,
-0.0084265759,
-0.0389671512,
0.0220595319,
-0.0063957032,
-0.0258835051,
0.0979480371,
0.0438138507,
-0.0009643506,
0.0135655347,
0.0268165972,
-0.0103837382,
0.1162748113,
0.0312250797,
-0.0056508537,
0.02914319,
-0.001006996,
0.0147738513,
0.0362675115,
0.0282842517,
0.0097137447,
0.0237224828,
0.0199424438,
0.0152894817,
0.0131105529,
0.0236193687,
0.0040579783,
-0.0492405966,
-0.0041643046,
0.0585296042,
0.0049630124,
0.0097017745,
-0.0171792116,
0.0180090182,
0.0537837818,
-0.0032480541,
0.0339879878,
-0.0468974859,
0.0031458349,
0.0006710017,
-0.0041895728,
0.0300959107,
0.0145040387,
-0.0297189821,
-0.053354919,
0.0364423171,
-0.0193669815,
0.0275459848,
0.0525851361,
0.0448410586,
0.0251229145,
-0.0403097533,
0.0363061726,
0.0539188124,
-0.0254542474,
0.0292498451,
-0.0522893555,
0.0027047365,
0.0174238682,
0.0477642938,
-0.0608716011,
-0.0457128361,
-0.032186076,
0.0038918336,
0.0398780666,
0.0216244366,
-0.0448955037,
0.0810376033,
-0.0418255366,
-0.0340108573,
-0.0212775189,
0.0386208184,
0.02496792,
0.0046379976,
-0.028766105,
-0.0117712785,
-0.0129740145,
0.0321713015,
0.0289951768,
0.0032949077,
-0.0883926079,
0.0113464361,
0.0081665879,
0.0542912036,
-0.0186147802,
0.0025958125,
-0.0167169981,
0.0431686006,
-0.0295495931,
0.0196817834,
-0.0089397049,
-0.0403300971,
-0.0735965595,
0.0316947848,
-0.0216816626,
-0.0109882569,
0.0466552004,
-0.0458576493,
-0.0286297482,
0.0098208599,
-0.0134135988,
0.0536081865,
0.0106056314,
0.0075360648,
0.0131968865,
0.0009231796,
-0.0245646704,
0.0470960066,
0.0067043453,
0.0030373181,
-0.0179447811,
-0.0236390196,
-0.0073079867,
-0.0292311069,
-0.0052145673,
-0.0007283396,
-0.0153195839,
0.021592848,
0.0487677008,
0.0120366029,
-0.0634958893,
-0.0455655605,
-0.053572312,
0.0037380408,
-0.0213984735,
0.0066555901,
0.036038857,
-0.0202848054,
-0.0024878948,
-0.022072209,
-0.0237248763,
-0.0378000438,
0.0054066177,
0.0121035213,
0.0328591838,
0.0272572022,
0.0116984341,
-0.058706142,
-0.004885328,
-0.0151443854,
0.0348456241,
-0.0379528664,
0.0233695712,
-0.0301911831,
0.0274774041,
-0.0065459358,
0.0719615966,
-0.0380742997,
-0.0432463065,
0.0234087259,
-0.0250962656,
0.0450138487,
0.0788212121,
-0.0064210319,
0.0573769063,
0.0491996519,
-0.0535096042,
-0.0530430824,
0.0519784167,
-0.0382069275,
-0.0557037815,
-0.0722805858,
-0.0289867241,
-0.0049849884,
0.0678001717,
0.0231654011,
-0.0211181846,
-0.1012239009,
0.006155367,
0.0089642871,
-0.0464702547,
-0.0453473218,
-0.0116109755,
-0.013544431,
0.0024397082,
-0.0265947059,
0.0122874407,
0.0758171976,
-0.0025093611,
0.0029048084,
-0.0531133488,
0.0138699226,
0.0092303837,
0.0909042954,
0.0256063454,
-0.0101448745,
0.0260709971,
0.006388885,
-0.0921101421,
-0.0485623442,
0.0761115626,
-0.0256099179,
0.0627259091,
-0.0550265796,
-0.0166232549,
0.0036931026,
-0.0504547507,
-0.0321118496,
-0.0548865795,
-0.0010429948,
-0.0242858157,
0.0084503219,
0.0167435296,
-0.0407113396,
-0.0229943469,
0.0014864218,
-0.0043112906,
-0.0168251283,
-0.0218305904,
-0.0214356761,
0.0422373116,
0.0970961079,
0.0191818997,
-0.0228925385,
-0.0378412642,
0.0181088205,
0.0355359316,
0.0223900136,
-0.0265774354,
0.0045862277,
0.0065530594,
0.0170417838,
-0.0211231392,
-0.021664029,
0.0566225313,
0.0553861409,
-0.0485033318,
-0.0367942154,
0.0939069614,
0.0016420027,
-0.0028292576,
-0.0050797607,
0.0431882814,
0.059325587,
-0.0097856224,
0.0172973014,
-0.0583311915,
-0.0515330322,
-0.0197883341,
0.0097962376,
0.0063324166,
-0.0433611497,
-0.0085994937,
-0.116923444,
-0.004349059,
0.0039902595,
-0.0017700302,
-0.0404754207,
-0.0194406826,
-0.0091780443,
-0.0386678614,
-0.0064166323,
-0.0275457036,
0.0036204148,
0.0314526856,
0.0104478542,
0.0206264779,
-0.0293917451,
0.0229076874,
-0.030787224,
0.0620769449,
0.0340122879,
0.0652347505,
0.0027237558,
0.0142516037,
-0.025239177,
0.0009100625,
-0.0276922341,
0.0251522362,
0.0919001549,
-0.017841775,
0.0161447302,
0.0266543273,
0.0363476463,
-0.0122924456,
-0.0303307809,
0.0133617586,
0.0399181806,
0.0157167111,
-0.0278687384,
0.0003079057,
0.0155149586,
0.0703211725,
0.0573264062,
-0.0091175055,
-0.0584309064,
-0.0452110693,
-0.0256460011,
0.0228880942,
-0.0438576005,
-0.0002697507,
-0.0394550115,
0.0171877146,
0.007654231,
-0.050394509,
-0.0698272362,
0.0088501647,
0.0267809108,
0.0065608742,
0.0083839744,
0.0118188271,
0.037785694,
0.0178232621,
0.0192312375,
-0.0227926467,
-0.0223450344,
-0.0078627607,
-0.0468193293,
0.0363287702,
-0.0563959405,
-0.0264955945,
0.0045733601,
-0.1074282676,
-0.0625904948,
-0.0027102146,
0.084117122,
0.0193435457,
0.071962133,
0.0171795618,
-0.0505768694,
0.0153466053,
0.0120738493,
-0.0615786128,
0.0022404348,
0.0479777157,
0.0167801008,
0.0070314859,
0.0266020745,
-0.0452251323,
0.0254693814,
0.0361537859,
0.0503510199,
-0.0529161431,
-0.0468792468,
0.0191198159,
-0.0567998439,
0.0978933424,
-0.0055689006,
-0.0208732821,
-0.0405114889,
0.0102847088,
-0.0201913733,
-0.0017914027,
-0.0414538197,
-0.0279087331,
0.0344827846,
-0.0070489286,
-0.009946621,
-0.0174290929,
-0.0109713692,
0.0402132645,
-0.0322693996,
-0.0121046994,
0.0913609564,
-0.0341210701,
0.0185961872,
0.0002103728,
-0.0008267611,
0.0293519869,
0.0325762928,
0.0378436819,
0.0301829018,
0.0447675809,
0.0336977318,
-0.0228674039,
0.0122507615,
-0.0009475638,
-0.0475584008,
-0.0132506471,
-0.0358654633,
-0.0082816109,
0.0514040627,
-0.0081394473,
0.0310496241,
-0.0178574212,
-0.0035878129,
0.0129370261,
0.0499151796,
-0.0066562933,
-0.0406403244,
0.0330253914,
0.0508428067,
-0.014527861,
-0.0009810547,
0.0915505216,
0.0162565485,
0.0454863459,
0.0203224309,
0.0159524009,
-0.0365747996,
-0.0264193695,
0.0151904905,
0.0603487529,
-0.0130217839,
0.0516980216,
-0.0393654704,
-0.0592721812,
-0.0294665582,
0.023911912,
-0.0068761804,
-0.0008799465,
0.0581206493,
0.0293781124,
-0.0102353878,
-0.039372962,
-0.0612278506,
0.0109722102,
0.0010637282,
-0.0129190087,
-0.0499483757,
-6.510601093e-33,
-0.0281287692,
-0.0221265424,
0.020739805,
0.0159379356,
-0.0036719022,
-0.0273287315,
-0.0185616482,
0.0067274007,
-0.0467824861,
0.0334531516,
-0.0264263023,
0.021438919,
0.0063261753,
0.0452324115,
0.0141357435,
-0.043184869,
0.0487974547,
-0.0183791947,
-0.0257188752,
0.0325174555,
0.0172416754,
-0.0012798426,
0.0515615605,
-0.0571217388,
0.0192381702,
-0.0218439735,
-0.0331190675,
0.0362939946,
0.0017008026,
0.0480072089,
-0.0070805782,
0.0430920683,
0.0109504219,
-0.0245890878,
0.0053558969,
0.0365155041,
-0.0541402735,
-0.0689898729,
0.0036858078,
-0.003689663,
-0.0154818399,
-0.016451396,
0.0047381995,
0.0052917879,
0.0222494826,
-0.055606205,
0.0397968218,
0.0125832558,
-0.0066083036,
-0.0059162253,
-0.0455973186,
-0.0157601219,
-0.0240017492,
-0.062848717,
0.0163218807,
0.0468437634,
0.0107516684,
-0.0210219864,
-0.054128103,
0.0265419334,
0.0553720072,
0.0340028927,
0.0351483747,
0.0304100737,
0.0101792524,
0.0527315177,
-0.0294507574,
-0.0052626231,
-0.0275667906,
-0.032179229,
0.0283727366,
0.0538249314,
0.0005493568,
0.0520402752,
0.0420852602,
-0.0068518836,
-0.080238685,
0.0135575132,
0.0168809798,
0.0226242822,
-0.0025102024,
0.0040006242,
-0.0429526269,
-0.0380107462,
-0.0623969473,
-0.0228421353,
0.0130791971,
-0.0366827324,
0.0347521529,
0.0154894739,
-0.0211058948,
-0.0003803858,
0.0327365287,
-0.0611174516,
-0.0368603654,
0.0380660631,
-0.0144430343,
-0.0044402503,
-0.0123542631,
-0.0022601532,
-0.0645854697,
-0.0340278894,
0.0357933827,
-0.0211654007,
0.005916419,
0.0260273106,
0.0205954146,
0.0317615345,
-0.0681931227,
0.0033496593,
-0.0130665973,
0.0372135155,
-0.0031223181,
0.0499869287,
0.0298105832,
-0.0043858215,
-0.0316266268,
0.0407572612,
0.0235589128,
-0.0618166551,
-0.0152941747,
0.0436999463,
-0.0158769228,
0.0014888822,
0.0081927525,
-0.0155047616,
-0.0227399766,
-0.005961366,
0.0284780916,
-0.0241257455,
-0.0180618577,
0.0031874201,
2.755e-7,
0.0299253277,
0.0370605886,
-0.032329835,
0.014223461,
-0.0092529971,
0.0860514566,
-0.0081537124,
0.0260671116,
0.0390708186,
-0.042187117,
0.0383089446,
0.0367645323,
0.0224261563,
0.0365215428,
-0.0732052699,
0.0043639555,
-0.0272700246,
0.0007177225,
-0.0078436024,
-0.0751453117,
0.0409912281,
0.0920774192,
0.0502132364,
0.0210546032,
-0.0183739085,
-0.0057496168,
0.0440410152,
-0.040907912,
-0.0005166769,
0.0577167571,
-0.0160911251,
-0.0370308161,
-0.0183256194,
0.0328536071,
-0.0536579117,
0.033156205,
-0.0215400625,
0.0697035193,
-0.018070912,
-0.0698585808,
-0.038756106,
0.0189691465,
0.0075401645,
-0.0548437461,
0.080768466,
-0.0860142782,
-0.0412872359,
0.0155045688,
-0.010072574,
-0.0191184729,
-0.0063287583,
-0.0044392883,
-0.0227727015,
-0.0052640024,
0.0148403225,
0.0056111631,
0.0104161305,
-0.0768364593,
-0.0283859614,
0.0246951897,
-0.0391917899,
-0.0249084458,
0.0098732123,
-0.0220955927,
0.0090496158,
-0.0561067872,
0.0041317982,
2.405301362e-34,
-0.0056787166,
-0.0265318472,
0.0205554515,
-0.0015259786,
0.0360690691,
-0.0078828493,
-0.0175119136,
0.023941312,
0.0698402822,
-0.039536994,
-0.0262232143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07242v1 | Covidia: COVID-19 Interdisciplinary Academic Knowledge Graph | 2023-04-14T16:45:38 | 2023-04-14T16:45:38 | Cheng Deng, Jiaxin Ding, Luoyi Fu, Weinan Zhang, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7 | The pandemic of COVID-19 has inspired extensive works across different
research fields. Existing literature and knowledge platforms on COVID-19 only
focus on collecting papers on biology and medicine, neglecting the
interdisciplinary efforts, which hurdles knowledge sharing and research
collaborations between fields to address the problem. Studying
interdisciplinary researches requires effective paper category classification
and efficient cross-domain knowledge extraction and integration. In this work,
we propose Covidia, COVID-19 interdisciplinary academic knowledge graph to
bridge the gap between knowledge of COVID-19 on different domains. We design
frameworks based on contrastive learning for disciplinary classification, and
propose a new academic knowledge graph scheme for entity extraction, relation
classification and ontology management in accordance with interdisciplinary
researches. Based on Covidia, we also establish knowledge discovery benchmarks
for finding COVID-19 research communities and predicting potential links. | [
-0.0025829542,
0.0454343483,
-0.0015093586,
-0.0070279362,
-0.0259063262,
-0.0244521108,
0.0439520776,
0.0194636062,
0.0565593205,
0.0066689425,
-0.0144881131,
0.0222818274,
0.016363332,
0.0421652682,
0.0087061627,
-0.030917298,
0.0420394912,
0.0266934223,
0.0345344283,
-0.0266023725,
-0.0367321558,
-0.0006593243,
-0.0321363062,
-0.0153899463,
0.0663568974,
-0.0507494211,
0.0380009636,
-0.0101800654,
0.064826183,
-0.0534922965,
0.0718856379,
-0.00277444,
-0.0145628816,
0.054509867,
0.000001994,
-0.0617297404,
-0.0784581229,
0.0247411896,
0.0393642895,
-0.048489403,
0.0294556599,
-0.0532405525,
0.0461961068,
0.0062894379,
-0.047288876,
-0.0605012774,
0.0294959936,
0.0267912783,
-0.0257185046,
0.0354115963,
-0.0108996723,
-0.0622653998,
0.0668398291,
-0.0111167841,
-0.0177837759,
0.0350131392,
0.0414132923,
0.0342036597,
0.0710837245,
0.0254667439,
0.018953478,
0.0352205969,
-0.0205238834,
-0.004739197,
0.074557595,
0.0994472057,
0.0133281667,
-0.0040076859,
0.0020391869,
0.0307687689,
0.0622846261,
-0.0120697562,
0.0981858149,
0.0054355846,
-0.018447265,
0.0811302587,
-0.035616599,
-0.0471175723,
-0.0304421484,
-0.0158833731,
0.0462061539,
0.0427201167,
0.0478902869,
0.0145159476,
0.0036676163,
0.036010772,
-0.009786373,
-0.0251320414,
-0.0045615206,
-0.0300688632,
0.0411815345,
-0.011900492,
0.0148336422,
0.003330477,
-0.0257288907,
-0.0106674638,
0.0524036475,
-0.0468214788,
0.0797611848,
-0.0248635653,
-0.0514497757,
-0.0413197167,
0.019119801,
0.0257288348,
0.0381774269,
-0.066931814,
-0.0529489368,
0.0115408273,
0.0309922434,
-0.013486648,
-0.0922586173,
0.0123543777,
0.0350122266,
0.0184285957,
0.0439901613,
0.0181395952,
-0.016188927,
-0.031319771,
-0.0350406878,
0.0066563808,
0.013566318,
0.0368068516,
-0.0234627482,
-0.0019490604,
-0.009851262,
0.0406503975,
-0.0179649089,
0.0131709259,
-0.0362951942,
0.0374566093,
0.0116656478,
-0.0226470008,
0.0417354405,
-0.029954819,
-0.0065569421,
0.0247335434,
0.033433035,
0.0063644685,
0.0250500832,
-0.0290451217,
-0.0156958289,
-0.0351621844,
0.0404462591,
-0.087154381,
0.0297986753,
0.0238053147,
0.017527882,
-0.0387022123,
-0.019809369,
-0.0421514846,
-0.0756029338,
-0.0075827087,
-0.1074936613,
-0.0634636581,
0.0618299954,
0.023569135,
-0.0470379442,
-0.0271458384,
-0.0353510231,
-0.0158339832,
0.0361602269,
0.0159362946,
-0.0392448939,
-0.0443666726,
0.0493438914,
-0.0303653944,
0.0462649316,
0.0007032031,
0.0281489808,
0.0344146863,
0.0069591575,
0.0238430183,
-0.0126586473,
-0.062589027,
-0.0014511519,
0.0327124484,
0.0293237902,
0.0065834038,
-0.0120478589,
0.0289138146,
-0.0224929154,
-0.0030796719,
0.0199035667,
0.0304676443,
0.0069715497,
0.0158234388,
0.0516051352,
0.0354499593,
-0.0107480567,
0.001191806,
-0.0021420745,
0.0166851413,
-0.0243346114,
-0.0216072295,
0.0528130382,
-0.0516651496,
0.0375872478,
-0.046591796,
0.0749006569,
0.0197202861,
0.0206080526,
-0.0015921503,
0.0241850093,
0.0551818833,
0.0389743298,
-0.0509340651,
-0.0793524235,
0.0022102948,
-0.0178924054,
0.0161255933,
0.0266293827,
-0.0228828471,
-0.0294151492,
0.0088192094,
-0.0021797409,
-0.0078139817,
0.0056439061,
-0.0180792846,
0.0111586386,
0.0442089513,
-0.0577902906,
-0.0323048122,
-0.0138273695,
0.0065820254,
-0.0614625178,
0.0579080209,
0.0048026363,
-0.0091304565,
0.0292037427,
0.0243312176,
0.0055500506,
0.0203560609,
0.0662181005,
-0.0677664056,
-0.0451431572,
0.0022045046,
0.031432122,
-0.0102945603,
0.042911984,
-0.0674835294,
0.016205091,
0.0110423742,
-0.0289782509,
-0.0011026055,
0.0721008778,
0.0521632731,
0.0122305881,
0.0384429172,
-0.034805987,
-0.0119794579,
0.0050990419,
0.0269726161,
0.0649646074,
-0.0181312673,
0.0051945327,
0.0037949244,
-0.060153354,
0.007714028,
0.00340693,
0.0169995427,
-0.0048207096,
-0.0041868207,
-0.0076611545,
0.0400091037,
-0.0667479709,
-0.0421969853,
0.022995539,
-0.0309453234,
0.0305780582,
0.0400779061,
0.0224377997,
0.0105589274,
-0.0106382892,
0.0222086962,
0.0273991358,
0.000349979,
0.0108672781,
-0.0243696831,
-0.0318175629,
0.0528036505,
0.008596505,
0.0030853471,
-0.0304570198,
-0.028064508,
-0.0374346264,
0.019008873,
0.0055863471,
-0.0464300066,
0.0354131907,
0.0171433557,
-0.0530456826,
0.0173462667,
-0.0310840402,
0.0330802314,
-0.0178691689,
0.0122201303,
0.0028445479,
0.0501258075,
-0.0186005011,
0.0522303917,
0.0399165973,
-0.0056332876,
-0.0057043289,
0.0195161738,
-0.063752763,
0.0424788408,
-0.0056201024,
-0.0254948661,
-0.0115767187,
0.0114338407,
0.0179615524,
-0.009135046,
-0.0179517288,
-0.0096221501,
-0.0176938605,
0.0153378751,
0.0217026416,
0.0322937258,
0.0155258272,
-0.0097036334,
-0.008982758,
0.013060675,
0.0148712527,
0.0304936543,
0.063135162,
-0.0493162274,
-0.0308561996,
-0.0358978324,
0.0131960297,
-0.0380405337,
-0.0081779286,
0.0447768532,
0.0344820954,
0.0018380552,
-0.0164567772,
0.0138320839,
-0.0208066069,
-0.0424966142,
0.0025151926,
0.0186776742,
0.0074381218,
0.001888993,
-0.0196502786,
0.0429732278,
-0.0296322517,
0.0871396661,
0.033165019,
-0.0365343094,
-0.018261455,
0.0084177079,
0.0185810905,
0.0106120436,
-0.0128861126,
-0.0282723662,
0.0132045057,
0.0538361222,
0.0396728888,
-0.0614631996,
0.0136320731,
0.0137652541,
0.0259702243,
0.0459183827,
-0.0143888937,
-0.0372448266,
-0.0260388181,
-0.020808978,
-0.0061724111,
-0.091021657,
-0.0343345664,
-0.0148092574,
-0.0091592157,
-0.0221053641,
0.0059664375,
0.0523025133,
0.0231988616,
-0.0591970906,
-0.0110923536,
-0.0382748768,
-0.0098361038,
0.0033402257,
0.01704075,
-0.0560349822,
0.0162251033,
-0.0389356017,
0.0184172951,
-0.0074731526,
-0.0718986318,
0.0110308025,
0.0125445686,
0.0444238782,
0.0092982184,
-0.02577346,
-0.0076703723,
-0.0570092127,
0.0473946072,
0.0007787916,
-0.0777826235,
-0.0447385423,
-0.0078825867,
-0.0004764542,
0.0239182096,
-0.0065400624,
-0.0312714092,
-0.0049370276,
-0.0262985658,
0.0326536372,
-0.0582865328,
0.0494199172,
-0.0336112753,
-0.0711782575,
-0.0399487577,
-0.0361475609,
-0.0093202321,
-0.05110256,
0.0869624242,
-0.0202936027,
0.0352541059,
-0.0012141063,
0.0083644632,
-0.0349751599,
-0.0261051618,
0.0377157666,
0.1190402359,
-0.0054780878,
-0.0439618081,
-0.0630783737,
-0.0009775518,
-0.0212201998,
0.0248060934,
-0.0123207169,
0.0122593604,
0.0015784464,
0.0362061411,
0.0627225861,
-0.0137918741,
0.0106418133,
-0.0145674963,
-0.0478337742,
-0.0672303811,
-0.0219516624,
-0.0005984485,
0.0145478891,
-0.0266750418,
-0.0242927764,
-0.0090499399,
0.04204062,
-0.0387143083,
-0.0843442082,
-0.018063942,
0.0090202037,
0.0246415902,
-0.0162805915,
-0.0742748454,
0.0612251572,
0.0145791993,
-0.0361489952,
0.0035848576,
0.0323108733,
-0.0480788127,
-0.0236540008,
-0.0135812927,
0.0109725948,
0.0409203507,
-0.0056549069,
0.0096422099,
0.0868900269,
0.0566926673,
-0.0592647605,
-0.0455254801,
0.0096823163,
-0.0586386882,
-0.0262022354,
0.0021372105,
-0.0292615108,
0.0043704035,
-0.0116302641,
-0.0028070908,
-0.061819721,
-0.0172298737,
-0.0091208247,
-0.0174218658,
0.0447892845,
-0.0195620507,
-0.0313775577,
-0.0488360822,
-0.0177091099,
0.0382512324,
-0.0021924304,
0.0339559577,
-0.0057904064,
-0.0334728025,
-0.0063418103,
-0.0094124321,
0.0640309379,
0.0037749829,
-0.0247703679,
-0.0522962697,
0.0017900142,
0.0076070013,
0.0669586882,
0.0297419745,
-0.0243076812,
-0.0051929066,
-0.0342317671,
-0.0195055008,
0.0237020347,
-0.0098460987,
-0.0023942257,
-0.0045535634,
-0.0058026584,
-0.0326334238,
0.0076057757,
-0.0668186024,
-0.0294795446,
0.0059448131,
0.0241963137,
0.0476541594,
0.053814169,
0.0175664369,
-0.0261459891,
-0.0231195558,
-0.0327718779,
0.0371531509,
-0.0404133387,
0.0086933151,
0.0108314566,
0.0038591502,
-0.0297094751,
-0.0174199622,
0.0555052347,
-0.0195753109,
0.0306464508,
0.0378619283,
-0.0251979996,
-0.0061931876,
-0.0150484378,
0.0521630906,
0.040683046,
-0.0174820889,
0.0087400693,
-0.0571334921,
-0.0243069287,
0.09821181,
-0.0085619893,
-0.0546566434,
0.0047454853,
-0.0133268489,
0.0068939957,
0.0352022201,
-0.0233418066,
-0.0027078185,
0.0490705557,
-0.0601204559,
-0.0401578173,
-0.0022302137,
-6.741630549e-33,
0.0275064819,
-0.0281375032,
-0.0103970598,
0.0100924186,
-0.0048521277,
0.0472437106,
-0.0180795584,
-0.0372848734,
-0.0047437157,
0.0356605165,
0.0044027478,
-0.0024902283,
-0.0181234907,
-0.0163663439,
0.0486134887,
-0.0026329574,
0.0413757898,
0.0071648019,
0.0123759285,
0.0538150109,
0.0255777836,
0.0320853069,
0.0119855953,
-0.084118396,
0.0190100633,
0.0144199943,
0.0581229925,
0.025045054,
0.0374673158,
0.0409172922,
-0.0218892153,
0.0354822055,
0.0178114641,
-0.0308104511,
0.0374913663,
-0.0212121699,
-0.1091506779,
-0.0507563613,
0.0146638127,
-0.0459157936,
-0.0244503245,
-0.0724799708,
0.0119327605,
0.0539234169,
0.0406426825,
-0.0736351162,
0.0666523278,
0.0167259853,
-0.0265578348,
-0.0804573372,
-0.0323237926,
0.0362903588,
-0.0156551674,
0.0508190878,
0.0070812162,
-0.0296425447,
0.0160742812,
0.081598103,
-0.055320207,
0.0371913873,
-0.0488373972,
-0.008744658,
0.0182143115,
-0.0191448778,
0.0065193828,
0.0403438807,
-0.0602386482,
-0.0137567325,
0.080302313,
-0.0085164784,
0.0019250204,
0.043740768,
-0.0236169994,
0.0312710069,
0.0031506808,
-0.0397762619,
-0.0948876441,
0.0462596454,
-0.0082086092,
0.0181481559,
-0.0213408004,
0.0210163426,
0.0272712205,
-0.00254597,
0.0425427407,
-0.049490165,
-0.0034720693,
-0.0175001305,
-0.0515977368,
-0.0304598399,
-0.0207231157,
0.0596380942,
-0.0087641217,
-0.0331639573,
-0.037557736,
0.0686136931,
0.027852511,
0.0144172227,
-0.0098270671,
0.0099073788,
-0.11371959,
-0.0413889885,
-0.0244732052,
0.0267493986,
0.0324137248,
0.011283543,
0.0228221323,
-0.0087585356,
0.0056239907,
-0.0160169471,
-0.0069688382,
-0.0053982101,
-0.0291932113,
0.0059433011,
0.0029190381,
0.0692217499,
0.0324879847,
0.0015319646,
0.075364776,
0.0678892285,
0.0152022913,
0.037851382,
-0.0365383029,
-0.0014295632,
0.0033041807,
-0.0043287082,
-0.0294988137,
0.0439338423,
-0.0314790271,
-0.0568807013,
-0.0157932788,
-0.0591881573,
2.96e-7,
0.0749948025,
0.0326067582,
-0.0203230549,
0.0023485066,
0.0191965792,
0.0065249186,
-0.0063913716,
0.0182660706,
-0.0109081808,
-0.0100541608,
0.0090756882,
0.0215198305,
-0.0195529964,
0.0432250537,
-0.0353917256,
-0.001035613,
-0.0183907486,
-0.0066145561,
-0.0557806194,
-0.0348524861,
0.0126018766,
-0.0282493159,
0.0320897661,
0.018273022,
-0.0060676327,
0.0061708493,
0.001422457,
-0.0007405775,
0.0202726759,
0.0290535819,
-0.0108429678,
0.0183921736,
-0.0181150641,
0.0264608283,
0.001448765,
0.0212097447,
-0.0519652925,
-0.0411694013,
0.0088197459,
0.0278748702,
0.0387078971,
-0.0417240076,
0.0209157281,
-0.0228493586,
0.0422818512,
-0.064350687,
-0.0236671809,
0.012652196,
-0.0450576544,
0.0341586471,
0.0340517201,
-0.0130243842,
-0.0258654095,
0.0171081945,
-0.0341034755,
0.0032250802,
-0.0150835263,
-0.0474050604,
0.0404887535,
0.0517384373,
-0.0100671062,
-0.0522829369,
0.0408449359,
-0.0053054574,
0.0189041458,
-0.0122751044,
0.072349228,
2.269208274e-34,
0.0269776713,
0.0271271691,
-0.0669431612,
-0.0003317565,
-0.0212702304,
-0.0677652508,
-0.0900023282,
0.0008637418,
0.006524012,
-0.0259110183,
-0.003572979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07235v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07235v4 | Mapping of attention mechanisms to a generalized Potts model | 2023-04-14T16:32:56 | 2024-04-04T13:24:36 | Riccardo Rende, Federica Gerace, Alessandro Laio, Sebastian Goldt | cond-mat.dis-nn | cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.CL, stat.ML | Transformers are neural networks that revolutionized natural language
processing and machine learning. They process sequences of inputs, like words,
using a mechanism called self-attention, which is trained via masked language
modeling (MLM). In MLM, a word is randomly masked in an input sequence, and the
network is trained to predict the missing word. Despite the practical success
of transformers, it remains unclear what type of data distribution
self-attention can learn efficiently. Here, we show analytically that if one
decouples the treatment of word positions and embeddings, a single layer of
self-attention learns the conditionals of a generalized Potts model with
interactions between sites and Potts colors. Moreover, we show that training
this neural network is exactly equivalent to solving the inverse Potts problem
by the so-called pseudo-likelihood method, well known in statistical physics.
Using this mapping, we compute the generalization error of self-attention in a
model scenario analytically using the replica method. | [
0.0010046621,
0.0330805257,
-0.014876538,
0.042883426,
-0.026125839,
0.0015390069,
0.0043409863,
0.0012904148,
-0.0067830575,
-0.0001341553,
-0.0071486891,
-0.0673311278,
-0.0133334389,
-0.0005696996,
0.0468756035,
-0.0507943369,
0.060239397,
0.0004583129,
-0.0468740053,
-0.0323819518,
-0.007989401,
-0.0497031622,
0.0261300653,
0.0071189026,
0.0000554389,
-0.0097141452,
-0.0162895117,
-0.0332821943,
0.0152602419,
-0.018803874,
0.0035527584,
0.0575156547,
0.0060219038,
0.063879095,
0.0000021717,
-0.0272588972,
-0.0031376439,
-0.0001529493,
0.0216312427,
0.0093912883,
-0.016185835,
-0.0272641722,
-0.0140292989,
-0.0044276994,
-0.0043289298,
-0.0103384005,
0.1172423288,
0.0574121512,
0.0299792718,
0.054188773,
-0.0003937453,
-0.0169528443,
0.0166268703,
-0.066890344,
0.0333787538,
-0.0422570854,
0.0317638703,
-0.0369352475,
-0.0262313597,
-0.017138483,
-0.0246371254,
0.0731354952,
0.0381054245,
0.0336763933,
0.0155891115,
0.0743981823,
0.0012009169,
0.0386782698,
-0.0219679754,
0.0537143461,
-0.0585698634,
-0.0312769376,
-0.0250314027,
0.0011249658,
-0.0217508432,
0.0277358629,
-0.0433837585,
-0.0034190149,
0.0356762148,
-0.0048098559,
-0.0034069871,
0.0238271579,
0.0356023386,
0.0054148533,
-0.0397417583,
0.0667063445,
0.0332837813,
-0.0617097802,
-0.0462747999,
-0.0000349509,
-0.0193387177,
-0.0357662439,
0.0178887416,
0.0035463707,
0.0547378249,
0.0056202845,
-0.0261651948,
-0.0506689772,
-0.0231192578,
-0.026007127,
0.0454546809,
0.0223016981,
-0.0099148387,
0.0468859971,
-0.0087550431,
0.0615863577,
-0.0729970485,
0.0574576706,
-0.0284134634,
0.0296769701,
-0.0188701898,
-0.0328234211,
-0.0517150871,
0.0284467861,
-0.0069402941,
-0.0357259288,
0.0045754528,
-0.0067182342,
-0.0030219944,
-0.0520746894,
-0.0169007517,
0.0247337222,
-0.0561312996,
-0.0584289841,
0.0201546866,
0.0163798779,
0.0070823119,
-0.0184636507,
-0.0010835422,
-0.0187383164,
-0.089297086,
0.0121823382,
0.0083604483,
-0.0242947098,
-0.0235019177,
0.0966102406,
0.0122443717,
-0.0374406762,
-0.0098756487,
0.0224878155,
-0.0397474915,
-0.02290258,
0.0249364469,
-0.0492850766,
0.0056854254,
0.0022469771,
0.0035936334,
-0.0478518121,
0.0102478536,
0.0286935419,
-0.0250215195,
0.0869653001,
0.0261022132,
-0.0153686125,
0.0129063521,
0.0273492578,
-0.0090509756,
0.0299849138,
0.0157468431,
0.0128050605,
-0.0052861776,
-0.044990629,
0.0370696522,
0.0477471054,
0.041414883,
0.0139931366,
-0.0186826792,
-0.0457022227,
-0.014452382,
0.0127392942,
0.0441398248,
0.0562289953,
-0.0241226349,
-0.0651732981,
0.0457958616,
0.0494169518,
0.0079429224,
0.0835409835,
0.0303263869,
0.0464498997,
-0.0110681737,
0.0652923808,
-0.0573086999,
0.0613218136,
-0.0687651932,
-0.0184131172,
0.0127049061,
-0.0278087147,
-0.0468092673,
-0.0241876021,
0.0019552922,
0.0158376768,
0.001035325,
-0.0293469466,
0.0606622286,
0.0005291123,
-0.0421143584,
0.0435952507,
0.0226918943,
-0.0226677898,
-0.0199829042,
-0.0227821376,
-0.0125502665,
0.0168907605,
0.0005700455,
-0.0576106012,
0.0081544286,
-0.0055573643,
-0.0450360775,
0.0557577461,
-0.0163951404,
0.0385283381,
-0.0145240631,
-0.0038836575,
0.0084368279,
-0.0118954591,
0.0204986222,
0.0408513322,
-0.046832215,
-0.0028413869,
0.0378367305,
-0.0017871676,
0.0448338091,
0.0410830192,
-0.0571311414,
-0.0583398864,
-0.0106595103,
0.0074484404,
0.0497673824,
0.0011268761,
-0.0112454658,
0.0487730056,
0.0146712977,
-0.0393131971,
-0.0411103368,
0.0118558817,
-0.0385693908,
-0.0257684886,
0.0397825763,
-0.1120330542,
0.0226036105,
0.0732044578,
0.0097288284,
-0.0642658249,
0.0536179803,
-0.0385004841,
0.0245998856,
-0.0365710892,
0.004827186,
0.0344447754,
0.065748021,
-0.0303078908,
0.0404964872,
-0.0303049721,
0.0686395317,
0.0209888685,
0.0140453586,
-0.0073053986,
-0.0600990057,
-0.0177697837,
-0.0145555679,
-0.017741669,
0.0029087309,
0.0151874647,
-0.0179026984,
-0.0157097615,
0.0142037589,
-0.0202543903,
-0.0047622481,
-0.0328917764,
-0.0003980152,
0.0464884862,
-0.0022451477,
-0.0168852229,
-0.0010695342,
-0.0171957165,
-0.0059167184,
-0.0047900868,
0.0079691671,
0.029792605,
-0.0531271994,
-0.0175298825,
-0.0551933534,
-0.0425725952,
-0.0061516883,
0.0322056189,
-0.0047416436,
-0.0645387769,
-0.0681774691,
0.0672376156,
0.0172972046,
0.0588062741,
-0.0179334078,
-0.0563128069,
-0.0038640087,
-0.0478460044,
0.0451478735,
0.0387325585,
0.0147389565,
-0.010552384,
0.0345259234,
0.0026689477,
-0.0381211415,
0.0004398077,
-0.0589150861,
0.0184504334,
0.0077760504,
-0.0086574359,
0.031493403,
0.0874416754,
0.0031769883,
-0.0389716253,
-0.0920226648,
0.0021040898,
0.004404902,
-0.0233738273,
-0.0203150883,
0.0210758727,
-0.0239676442,
-0.0061857048,
-0.0166736078,
-0.0268730205,
0.0488298275,
-0.0142597314,
0.0087510832,
-0.0204934366,
-0.0116724102,
0.0158319175,
0.0419012047,
0.0699336454,
0.0216357596,
0.0118188206,
-0.0134614222,
-0.0567351468,
0.042875804,
-0.0306275375,
-0.0030982285,
0.010849542,
-0.0125602549,
0.0276423432,
0.005444197,
-0.0111603718,
-0.0266863946,
-0.0790300816,
-0.0001900871,
-0.001758097,
-0.012349206,
-0.0131988917,
-0.0237353593,
0.0166017972,
0.0327650569,
0.068612434,
0.0110773556,
-0.0144342389,
-0.03052691,
0.0419085696,
0.0278609265,
0.0081881061,
0.0303319935,
-0.0362386294,
0.0366676636,
0.0464989468,
0.037159916,
0.0515470803,
0.0123676257,
-0.0171418283,
0.0465770513,
-0.0238215961,
-0.0288394131,
0.0205721147,
0.013223825,
-0.0379262678,
-0.0273713693,
0.0760213286,
0.0140012996,
-0.0531347468,
0.0060548447,
-0.0049805557,
-0.0083056893,
0.0112360697,
0.0171584152,
-0.0600511506,
0.0000801575,
-0.010963873,
-0.0185516719,
0.0058949916,
-0.0324404463,
-0.0108639384,
-0.106759876,
0.0042581283,
0.015716251,
-0.0375631675,
-0.0626752451,
-0.005397629,
0.0170624703,
-0.0026123025,
-0.0070811738,
0.0182409454,
0.0088662608,
-0.0022124532,
0.0268849172,
0.0081530502,
-0.0439419001,
0.0153390905,
-0.0334444791,
0.0303005241,
0.0762756541,
-0.0263687186,
-0.0489587337,
-0.0465104729,
-0.0326439664,
-0.0292493496,
-0.0103482818,
0.0320478119,
0.0676183105,
-0.0040946677,
-0.0003504041,
0.0053126984,
0.0330488272,
-0.0440080799,
-0.0027521837,
-0.0030841967,
0.0645579696,
0.0056182174,
-0.0376385897,
-0.0199467577,
-0.0001492494,
-0.0085800886,
0.0838491097,
0.0399673954,
-0.030444311,
-0.0429438874,
-0.0636667162,
0.0653475374,
-0.0283523407,
-0.048143331,
0.0369807184,
0.0374014266,
-0.083026506,
-0.0677771345,
0.0049804901,
-0.0194581617,
0.0562384799,
0.0010581498,
-0.0328317694,
0.0240466557,
-0.0210599862,
-0.0130379153,
0.0293238182,
-0.0443547368,
-0.0162784792,
-0.0481469668,
-0.017512653,
0.0577783771,
-0.0680530667,
-0.023726454,
0.0174356364,
-0.0943552405,
-0.0717484355,
0.0687653273,
0.0238854997,
0.0248584915,
0.0306690168,
-0.0406606719,
-0.0613848083,
0.0219112709,
0.0426090136,
-0.0380420238,
0.0138725862,
0.0276039932,
-0.0390323587,
-0.001350794,
0.0220740996,
0.0145938378,
0.0681815371,
0.0432034843,
0.0290787648,
-0.0258671343,
0.0229279473,
0.075060457,
0.0000763915,
0.1064578369,
0.0028298136,
-0.0063001388,
-0.0127314627,
-0.0109302877,
0.0106213326,
-0.0055496194,
-0.0602991804,
-0.0191171505,
0.0248552058,
0.0002409882,
-0.0295500942,
-0.0534699149,
0.0069624404,
-0.0294331145,
-0.0165922083,
-0.0320831425,
0.0087583,
-0.0032162182,
0.0244835597,
-0.0007405365,
0.0130554596,
0.0040913341,
-0.0064834426,
0.0180060677,
-0.0044244127,
0.0177525599,
0.0191584136,
-0.0026843485,
-0.0308209155,
0.0215705018,
-0.111616537,
-0.0437162332,
-0.0382839218,
0.0340778381,
0.038655825,
-0.0334030762,
-0.0019972548,
-0.0375306793,
-0.02870588,
-0.0005279423,
0.0083218301,
0.0017810767,
0.0046045417,
0.0349963754,
0.031895671,
-0.0017087989,
-0.0154317785,
0.0706189275,
0.0164103527,
-0.0089698005,
-0.0218119118,
-0.0222969465,
-0.0121307531,
0.0207366087,
-0.0230906941,
0.0556179583,
0.0309863277,
0.024850823,
-0.0479116738,
-0.0748923644,
-0.0033327388,
0.0176597182,
0.0463108905,
-0.0067772665,
0.0364957713,
0.0566490851,
-0.0185786914,
0.0206637811,
-0.0007842109,
0.0582677536,
0.0529516712,
-0.0330973715,
-0.0127729662,
-7.046386275e-33,
-0.0281641763,
-0.0375381447,
-0.0309662037,
-0.0150472503,
-0.0102906143,
0.0126005802,
-0.0209130924,
0.0062246057,
-0.0036961962,
0.0026181701,
-0.0277532041,
0.0280916374,
0.0074841566,
0.0440388471,
-0.014029515,
-0.0238758679,
0.0134602766,
0.0004594357,
0.0288843587,
0.0040761493,
0.0067968909,
0.0376757011,
0.0905910805,
-0.007295405,
0.0031088479,
-0.0188138299,
-0.006707205,
0.0116824796,
-0.0426815785,
0.0253683329,
-0.0619282052,
0.0305172857,
0.0179609619,
-0.0479818583,
-0.0209623054,
0.0177613944,
-0.0605067201,
-0.0484240539,
-0.0048521836,
-0.0224564169,
-0.0371548459,
-0.0275468919,
0.0966223404,
-0.0238368381,
-0.0274251383,
-0.0240935609,
0.0379761718,
-0.0068246708,
-0.0248552393,
0.0488470383,
-0.0394240357,
0.0321129225,
-0.0235470477,
0.0060793557,
0.0418182798,
0.0179353692,
0.0113296825,
0.0413503312,
-0.0976488739,
0.0207460579,
0.0067181108,
0.0571489483,
0.0353740081,
0.0243981536,
0.028585609,
0.0400180183,
0.0674601495,
-0.0163431186,
-0.0771493837,
-0.0428561121,
0.021346176,
-0.0045842417,
0.0876726955,
-0.0144088585,
0.0595854782,
-0.0020585083,
-0.0557757728,
-0.0189692266,
-0.0541045591,
0.0011695174,
0.0442770496,
0.0283285566,
-0.0439778604,
-0.0110865459,
-0.0129169123,
-0.0322048552,
-0.0131911822,
-0.0122631881,
0.0133630019,
-0.0250866897,
-0.028446475,
0.0008769587,
0.0374339409,
-0.0385085084,
0.0232928172,
-0.0084429383,
0.0138112083,
0.0348889939,
0.0211329926,
0.038354706,
-0.0620457344,
0.0248622969,
-0.0478444211,
0.0533529408,
-0.0051535363,
-0.0009974099,
0.0211704634,
0.0435559973,
-0.0630783066,
-0.0230266806,
-0.0449092574,
-0.0146180345,
0.0132159907,
-0.0088364799,
0.0526990443,
0.010776341,
-0.0076826741,
0.0291926488,
0.0269765202,
-0.0147134904,
-0.0130998539,
0.0539897196,
-0.0255443715,
0.0220350325,
-0.0113254664,
-0.0032298421,
-0.0433736481,
-0.0003874987,
0.0807703063,
-0.0455607623,
-0.0218880586,
0.0198685862,
3.036e-7,
0.0489084721,
0.0021772787,
0.0285276528,
0.0073198811,
0.0302231759,
0.0191245656,
-0.0060490584,
0.0690613762,
0.0258414894,
-0.0361472033,
0.0394425429,
0.0313089825,
-0.0010941179,
-0.0177230313,
-0.0831164941,
-0.0172989108,
-0.0387545303,
0.0266293827,
0.0308657978,
0.0120274117,
-0.0094099343,
0.1162312254,
0.0463990681,
0.0237404089,
0.0134669002,
-0.023198206,
0.0500213131,
-0.0222021677,
0.0357418582,
-0.0008607458,
0.0115509704,
0.0004637467,
-0.0256978013,
0.0151887992,
-0.0072302283,
0.0425908379,
0.0594629683,
0.0166674387,
-0.0166771151,
0.0343919434,
-0.0100440811,
-0.0053525344,
0.0230032839,
-0.0470424555,
0.0575138256,
-0.0658836886,
-0.0378659405,
-0.0354082137,
-0.0110248663,
0.0025829049,
0.0331534594,
0.0068419501,
-0.0151875988,
-0.0106823128,
-0.0133780297,
0.0075200461,
-0.0005493994,
-0.0828100517,
-0.0294704214,
0.0103217447,
-0.0714807585,
0.0105006117,
-0.0585372038,
-0.0633675158,
0.055296313,
-0.0339699425,
-0.032827463,
2.78591702e-34,
0.004602822,
-0.0035873109,
0.0123325819,
-0.0143731562,
0.0066218618,
-0.0204103906,
0.0336802974,
0.0039582914,
0.0560601614,
-0.0636745021,
-0.0293543842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09103v1 | ChatGPT: Applications, Opportunities, and Threats | 2023-04-14T16:25:03 | 2023-04-14T16:25:03 | Aram Bahrini, Mohammadsadra Khamoshifar, Hossein Abbasimehr, Robert J. Riggs, Maryam Esmaeili, Rastin Mastali Majdabadkohne, Morteza Pasehvar | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Developed by OpenAI, ChatGPT (Conditional Generative Pre-trained Transformer)
is an artificial intelligence technology that is fine-tuned using supervised
machine learning and reinforcement learning techniques, allowing a computer to
generate natural language conversation fully autonomously. ChatGPT is built on
the transformer architecture and trained on millions of conversations from
various sources. The system combines the power of pre-trained deep learning
models with a programmability layer to provide a strong base for generating
natural language conversations. In this study, after reviewing the existing
literature, we examine the applications, opportunities, and threats of ChatGPT
in 10 main domains, providing detailed examples for the business and industry
as well as education. We also conducted an experimental study, checking the
effectiveness and comparing the performances of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, and found
that the latter performs significantly better. Despite its exceptional ability
to generate natural-sounding responses, the authors believe that ChatGPT does
not possess the same level of understanding, empathy, and creativity as a human
and cannot fully replace them in most situations. | [
0.0382501669,
0.0515201353,
-0.0184793696,
0.0009344187,
-0.0288146008,
-0.0081513198,
0.0135382814,
-0.0227834415,
0.0175327752,
-0.0365872607,
-0.0271720979,
-0.0073272372,
-0.0309067164,
0.0694690794,
-0.0085892752,
-0.0884642974,
0.0149656003,
0.0267222989,
0.0243134014,
0.0140391318,
0.0091337794,
0.030518122,
-0.0403512903,
0.0608055852,
-0.0510561839,
-0.0235510282,
-0.0329396166,
-0.0228399951,
0.0381698757,
-0.0018440544,
0.0234444365,
0.0351891257,
0.0252319183,
0.0377578288,
0.0000021462,
-0.0367885455,
-0.0099003566,
-0.0162480921,
0.0131563535,
-0.0339567848,
0.0326161049,
0.0143348612,
-0.0387253165,
0.0401869453,
-0.0798722208,
-0.0172090754,
0.0563933924,
0.0976420119,
0.0695061013,
0.1009207964,
-0.0414326712,
-0.0458092056,
0.0264177397,
-0.0106818778,
0.0077825701,
-0.0415657461,
-0.0174470805,
0.0167773459,
-0.0113224462,
-0.0266908146,
0.001297332,
0.0037785177,
0.0389249548,
-0.0399919674,
-0.0076464596,
0.042160932,
-0.0338705145,
-0.0546932518,
-0.0310574193,
0.0823459327,
-0.0151437521,
0.0056581856,
-0.0129238917,
-0.0216959808,
0.0189847536,
-0.040571142,
-0.040163435,
0.0514544249,
0.0044122445,
0.02833643,
-0.0201691687,
0.0474356078,
-0.0227295402,
-0.0069679641,
0.0131891016,
0.0169923566,
0.0137175703,
-0.0107814688,
-0.0331909657,
0.016627755,
0.0048508001,
-0.0715074912,
0.0080997227,
0.0346999988,
-0.0434165671,
0.0088208886,
-0.0470794179,
-0.0052577071,
-0.008809424,
-0.022863362,
-0.0188964065,
0.041761931,
-0.0168585125,
0.0025940188,
-0.0101860892,
0.0369245373,
-0.0369122736,
0.0104726795,
-0.0248137526,
0.0019182274,
-0.0507348664,
-0.0325681604,
-0.0545520298,
0.0288908463,
-0.0389352851,
-0.0483574606,
-0.0607078709,
0.0474663451,
0.0044964529,
-0.0135054635,
0.0274621304,
0.0474629663,
-0.0567034185,
-0.0037270226,
-0.0281343441,
0.0250959843,
-0.0324292853,
0.0207026824,
0.0524444655,
-0.0863837674,
0.0132390056,
0.0360464528,
0.0187954567,
0.0098280581,
-0.0047509591,
0.0710920841,
-0.0476120859,
-0.0068844608,
-0.0467210487,
-0.0283947997,
0.0028185504,
-0.0726845264,
0.0371517688,
-0.0461948365,
0.0199472327,
-0.0229238383,
-0.0132212127,
0.0075391992,
0.0089006219,
0.0156992245,
0.0107146669,
0.0259213205,
-0.0051589627,
0.0028192613,
0.0512632951,
0.0195875317,
0.0266336072,
0.0453073047,
0.0597926602,
0.0283204392,
0.0112084132,
-0.0313537903,
0.0330077522,
0.0119604999,
-0.0073055383,
-0.0441748351,
0.0474246591,
-0.0228068549,
-0.0219200514,
0.0448405854,
0.0076501677,
0.0445129424,
-0.0390680023,
0.036329329,
0.0534585007,
0.033400435,
0.0291508473,
0.1062009186,
0.0422591306,
0.0652395487,
-0.0193802472,
0.0060455743,
-0.0126104746,
0.0524862707,
-0.0075487532,
0.0090906918,
0.0021424384,
0.037128076,
-0.0366816744,
-0.026073996,
0.0384002961,
-0.0285618957,
0.0317933895,
-0.0186707415,
0.0124319512,
0.0352508612,
-0.0764434785,
0.0341807976,
0.0036389374,
-0.0727347806,
-0.0275289323,
-0.0563177057,
0.0169557184,
0.0574097596,
0.0436925776,
-0.0048958338,
-0.0214229226,
-0.0422434993,
-0.0291892458,
0.0788725689,
0.0396593884,
0.0117507018,
0.0021931815,
-0.0359193087,
0.016269356,
-0.0293961354,
-0.0042449352,
0.046155937,
0.0063721421,
0.0348141789,
0.0213980526,
0.0431556553,
0.031699229,
0.0148450397,
-0.0207177177,
-0.0192313269,
0.0318875089,
-0.0060730418,
0.0203234758,
0.0292641148,
-0.026834229,
0.0006268967,
0.0131096393,
0.0059589124,
-0.0539782941,
0.0437694192,
-0.0869280249,
-0.0219023451,
-0.0054247458,
-0.0806271955,
-0.0148757827,
0.0261857174,
-0.0229851566,
-0.0487998538,
0.0384348817,
-0.0303245317,
0.0535852201,
-0.0407988876,
-0.0117447646,
0.0172363557,
0.0463583842,
0.015007142,
0.0274052452,
0.0492296442,
-0.0546244867,
0.0031099299,
0.0316548981,
0.0176572371,
-0.0400883406,
0.022426825,
0.0199688394,
-0.0322792307,
-0.0002324343,
0.0322492681,
0.0573228523,
-0.0494668335,
-0.01697376,
-0.1203713939,
0.0303595159,
-0.0051540472,
-0.0210455768,
0.0165077094,
0.0313535556,
-0.0157625042,
-0.0048794476,
-0.0900869444,
0.0502084568,
0.0676873922,
-0.0329277068,
0.0295536034,
0.0017096878,
0.0023076411,
-0.0342538282,
0.0194977112,
0.0126949484,
0.0294470098,
0.0604074933,
-0.0001004549,
-0.0214188769,
0.0409376547,
-0.0446587652,
0.049068328,
0.0040958552,
-0.0723998249,
0.024975298,
-0.0124165285,
0.0652710721,
0.0138720255,
0.061398048,
0.0349867456,
-0.0233851634,
-0.0264215041,
-0.030593669,
0.0302966591,
-0.0543624684,
-0.0081215277,
-0.0259212907,
-0.0049083009,
-0.0027383587,
0.0206361525,
0.0308340061,
0.0134937689,
-0.0687862858,
0.0187957436,
0.0358778574,
-0.0160034355,
0.0244665034,
-0.000655708,
-0.0218483824,
0.0229348522,
0.01454225,
-0.0253003724,
0.0434224643,
0.0012484402,
-0.0390310436,
-0.056467481,
0.0053790188,
-0.0252855178,
0.0498866066,
-0.0294978749,
0.0169890318,
0.0147673516,
-0.0284233503,
-0.0329248607,
0.0184055977,
0.0134463692,
-0.0195958279,
-0.0132847568,
-0.0298774149,
-0.0042649573,
-0.0060344972,
-0.0318049155,
-0.0802595466,
-0.0155717665,
-0.0078384606,
0.0061281482,
0.0761602968,
-0.0282861106,
-0.0332296416,
0.0026530651,
-0.0168194175,
0.0332137011,
-0.009702892,
-0.0225208122,
-0.0265717935,
0.0367937684,
0.0563858002,
0.0195042379,
0.0173813645,
0.0336929969,
0.0645661578,
0.05224929,
-0.0059810155,
-0.0153339896,
-0.0378373563,
-0.0117004877,
-0.0073372754,
-0.0054149264,
0.0189735219,
0.0120593784,
0.0339942575,
-0.0339838564,
-0.0205770507,
0.1037121192,
0.0118822707,
-0.0341842882,
-0.0192231219,
0.0052649304,
0.0012825557,
-0.0340255015,
0.0412435047,
-0.1197869331,
-0.0119316997,
-0.0155595224,
0.0077650254,
-0.0224002916,
-0.00408665,
-0.0221029874,
-0.0936506018,
0.0546046644,
-0.0114602353,
-0.0358754657,
-0.002955005,
-0.0005379386,
-0.041846469,
0.0058990396,
0.0324154273,
-0.027888583,
0.010823762,
-0.0219213348,
-0.0152331078,
-0.0420328192,
-0.0381117053,
0.0131867435,
-0.0225453805,
0.0487770177,
0.0888548866,
0.0556015074,
-0.0063852463,
-0.0042534638,
0.0021496406,
0.0346440151,
0.0076625454,
0.0171997007,
0.0411043316,
-0.0082337558,
-0.0066317604,
-0.0330014043,
0.0520242564,
-0.0155438958,
-0.0065369671,
0.0077768923,
0.0438324511,
-0.0462903604,
-0.0276816152,
-0.0164073166,
0.0509179868,
0.0281833392,
0.0553206205,
-0.0101811811,
-0.037618801,
-0.0500213988,
-0.0146609694,
0.0163165182,
-0.0724565014,
-0.0386123993,
-0.0209048651,
0.03734098,
-0.0416806675,
-0.0752733499,
-0.0581314564,
0.0124729555,
0.0006558031,
-0.0182779469,
-0.0874185115,
0.0312789232,
0.0415504277,
-0.0249853525,
0.0010269156,
0.0003708826,
-0.0117584942,
-0.0512294173,
-0.0225176718,
0.0265753195,
-0.0697633922,
-0.0031844245,
0.0170092564,
-0.0849879086,
-0.0457977019,
0.0078660119,
0.0548874028,
0.0193316862,
0.0333356261,
0.0094576627,
0.0004357361,
0.0295944456,
0.0528081916,
-0.0502435155,
-0.0072072395,
0.0236394573,
0.0269759651,
0.0166213773,
0.0004063184,
-0.0281571895,
0.0567230321,
-0.0233316608,
0.008777068,
0.0136136832,
-0.0512707308,
0.0304162763,
-0.0157143269,
0.0326598473,
0.00542515,
0.0047854185,
-0.0566843115,
-0.0127515895,
-0.0480225049,
0.0164479949,
-0.0734037161,
0.0014565777,
0.0128969895,
0.0131666288,
0.0233055372,
-0.0115892403,
-0.0685816631,
0.0000420533,
-0.0158302467,
0.0123561639,
0.0224832129,
-0.0258945301,
-0.0006797868,
-0.0111386525,
-0.0060609723,
0.0059879418,
-0.0036405725,
0.0170783326,
-0.00835797,
0.1049781665,
0.0092865806,
-0.011023486,
0.0379173234,
0.0401589982,
-0.0545226522,
-0.0485628769,
-0.0300090834,
0.0775483251,
0.0400519259,
0.0233846828,
0.0291505177,
-0.0609497577,
0.0319700055,
0.0145912934,
0.0521595851,
-0.0208451115,
-0.0380670391,
-0.0126961395,
-0.0211862586,
-0.0131509956,
-0.0160257854,
0.0446868427,
-0.0506653599,
0.0102765951,
0.0019540195,
-0.004065875,
-0.0602886006,
-0.0358867235,
0.0108491005,
-0.0051601199,
0.0208179764,
0.0161434077,
-0.0102580637,
-0.0229065008,
-0.0346850343,
0.0054372028,
0.0058350759,
-0.0075253081,
0.0657862872,
0.0602360927,
-0.0283797719,
-0.019520808,
-0.0201813634,
0.0186943822,
-0.0460378379,
-0.0193950515,
-0.0399482064,
-6.427356256e-33,
-0.0189900193,
-0.0256918743,
0.0177144222,
0.0381741375,
-0.0614668801,
-0.0368622877,
-0.029487012,
0.0293018054,
0.0100240363,
0.0304705985,
-0.026869081,
0.0275404304,
0.0052499836,
0.0569575019,
-0.0152377542,
-0.025461264,
0.0488710888,
-0.0051286179,
-0.0013137438,
0.0728954077,
0.0184409153,
0.0331404433,
0.0446472317,
-0.0724083036,
-0.0184865408,
-0.0245381203,
-0.0289272163,
-0.0204685107,
0.0059115081,
0.0346300937,
-0.0332182162,
0.0210793,
0.0083223907,
-0.0415089205,
-0.0148804402,
0.0543342642,
-0.022863768,
-0.0191581342,
-0.0134080434,
0.0229194053,
-0.0414552614,
-0.0295972545,
0.0090354653,
-0.0128478836,
-0.0005601247,
-0.0154398605,
0.0453982353,
0.0073159169,
0.0331232771,
-0.0330560543,
-0.0787911341,
-0.0049203956,
-0.0384715758,
-0.0498838574,
-0.0138018643,
0.0718015581,
0.0036159835,
-0.0223911814,
-0.0292842239,
0.056928236,
0.0226086024,
-0.0352618508,
0.0349139534,
-0.0119839124,
0.0015138403,
0.0441137515,
0.0078153294,
0.002169783,
-0.0506958552,
-0.0040764636,
-0.009986544,
0.0554160476,
0.0268071555,
0.0556050614,
0.0054067071,
-0.0142063778,
-0.0342530943,
0.0327714421,
0.0265749246,
-0.0008359323,
0.0175572392,
0.0015775199,
-0.0034634913,
-0.0012019194,
0.0227915477,
0.0028991024,
0.0016598664,
-0.0569602698,
0.02719808,
0.0060816663,
0.0046644434,
-0.0208281707,
0.0306491461,
-0.0530443676,
0.0413047113,
0.0013292478,
-0.0585310236,
0.0116370255,
-0.0246129036,
-0.0113599226,
-0.0328143016,
-0.0300399624,
0.0670698062,
0.0461317748,
0.0203492884,
0.0365806967,
0.0006477541,
0.030557204,
-0.0128846187,
0.0145445438,
-0.0191150773,
0.0756979957,
-0.0093365526,
0.0018140685,
-0.0293767191,
-0.0091960542,
-0.0374522321,
0.0376642086,
-0.0009287866,
0.034512639,
-0.053628739,
-0.0355652347,
0.0196086764,
-0.0003558102,
-0.0566873327,
0.0322606713,
-0.0410095528,
-0.0151213408,
0.0171688721,
-0.0679152161,
-0.0179713834,
-0.0011501113,
2.816e-7,
-0.0095062982,
0.0331160054,
0.0523397326,
0.0212138519,
0.0305371583,
0.0296133999,
0.0431632623,
0.0336469114,
0.0239169616,
0.0343435779,
0.0469179712,
0.013673231,
0.0482820086,
0.0193032473,
-0.095129922,
-0.0310031231,
-0.0890541747,
-0.037534982,
-0.0467684455,
-0.0189455282,
0.1142170727,
0.0625885278,
0.0010654974,
-0.0131516121,
0.0283389874,
0.0278189313,
0.0627792031,
-0.0178842433,
-0.0028860988,
0.0155959427,
0.0177314077,
0.0408019982,
-0.016221391,
-0.0137479836,
-0.0134130847,
0.004955167,
-0.0120490668,
0.0426353328,
0.0086027039,
-0.049541343,
0.0408431068,
0.0228773654,
0.020646764,
-0.0572203062,
0.047464706,
-0.1256116778,
-0.0283828638,
0.0012647313,
-0.0175937898,
-0.0093007516,
-0.0012944433,
-0.026370503,
-0.0218549743,
-0.0011587223,
0.0159852132,
-0.0006353128,
0.0210232753,
-0.0548579656,
0.0225415658,
-0.0256607011,
-0.0864028931,
-0.0226153471,
-0.0290688891,
-0.0393143371,
0.0370971635,
0.0177853554,
0.0075086774,
2.258036945e-34,
0.023158174,
0.0115191648,
-0.0001655825,
0.0102277836,
0.0235374048,
0.0245213229,
0.0798273012,
-0.0014647007,
0.007758379,
-0.0466300137,
-0.0452145673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07183v1 | Just Tell Me: Prompt Engineering in Business Process Management | 2023-04-14T14:55:19 | 2023-04-14T14:55:19 | Kiran Busch, Alexander Rochlitzer, Diana Sola, Henrik Leopold | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | GPT-3 and several other language models (LMs) can effectively address various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, including machine translation and text
summarization. Recently, they have also been successfully employed in the
business process management (BPM) domain, e.g., for predictive process
monitoring and process extraction from text. This, however, typically requires
fine-tuning the employed LM, which, among others, necessitates large amounts of
suitable training data. A possible solution to this problem is the use of
prompt engineering, which leverages pre-trained LMs without fine-tuning them.
Recognizing this, we argue that prompt engineering can help bring the
capabilities of LMs to BPM research. We use this position paper to develop a
research agenda for the use of prompt engineering for BPM research by
identifying the associated potentials and challenges. | [
0.0353557616,
-0.0117189009,
-0.0299343411,
0.0012281266,
-0.0422844887,
-0.0136210844,
-0.0112241507,
-0.005280117,
0.0104389088,
-0.0387462899,
-0.0196833368,
0.0104243243,
-0.0162553266,
0.0945330411,
-0.0158137102,
-0.085520871,
0.0256833881,
-0.0000616034,
0.080287829,
0.0295081325,
-0.0078058369,
0.035861738,
0.0011347902,
0.0223895404,
0.0094287833,
-0.003962372,
-0.0171563849,
-0.0046165944,
0.0167060047,
-0.0360421427,
0.0164271891,
0.0317981392,
0.0125889014,
-0.0137812924,
0.0000021108,
-0.0961257592,
-0.0093974862,
0.013129808,
-0.0497145019,
0.0086698961,
0.0020587686,
-0.0191338323,
-0.0204822067,
0.0362902842,
-0.0272978842,
-0.0056914529,
0.0125286067,
0.0812883601,
0.0619505607,
0.0465998203,
-0.025733836,
0.0057496652,
0.0034762607,
-0.0290167443,
-0.0014927136,
-0.0750653967,
0.0086737806,
-0.0498776101,
0.0344983228,
0.0631947219,
0.0412603989,
0.0098218415,
-0.0188101903,
0.0281090792,
-0.0535621345,
0.0241041053,
0.0654835477,
0.0136958594,
-0.0432140231,
0.021763159,
-0.0048923483,
0.0557885654,
0.0015989778,
-0.0394474305,
0.0182436965,
-0.050973516,
-0.0416724309,
0.0375064835,
-0.0330303386,
-0.0092382729,
-0.0419013165,
0.0125223901,
-0.0290279761,
-0.0233064108,
0.005159311,
0.0695042461,
-0.0135371899,
-0.041461505,
-0.0033482728,
0.0362393484,
0.0375983529,
-0.0219346434,
-0.0191775933,
0.051279638,
-0.0599734858,
0.0243362356,
0.017701868,
0.0561422445,
0.0127283596,
0.0016681844,
0.0169954691,
0.0105907954,
0.0074667064,
0.0265356489,
-0.0153021514,
0.0184420869,
0.0330150053,
-0.0015632878,
-0.0290116332,
0.0099970028,
-0.0900367275,
-0.000994826,
-0.0676792637,
-0.0135722477,
-0.0213467553,
-0.0057540452,
-0.0270556193,
0.0637501106,
-0.0153369829,
0.0473781526,
0.037338499,
-0.036275506,
-0.042081777,
-0.0259562023,
-0.0760092437,
0.0075167641,
-0.0083664693,
0.0325739421,
-0.0271196123,
-0.0368833058,
-0.0055549177,
-0.0198887326,
-0.0037715496,
-0.0031569335,
-0.0123180179,
0.0496365912,
0.009965389,
-0.0256813541,
-0.1078750044,
-0.0461828038,
0.024641959,
-0.0471841395,
-0.0125680855,
-0.0057096677,
0.0110024391,
-0.0080552408,
-0.0159828234,
0.0461995341,
-0.00936596,
0.0187073909,
-0.0131987203,
0.0560883582,
-0.0086647058,
0.027225567,
0.0156902242,
-0.0209848564,
0.0157991089,
0.050986208,
0.0157198794,
0.0180921238,
0.0612008013,
-0.0421222076,
-0.0003786832,
0.0582521744,
-0.045408655,
-0.0128404358,
0.0626745149,
0.0118341921,
0.0134134749,
-0.0637739152,
0.0283316355,
-0.0029019359,
0.0277895126,
0.0936187431,
0.0568960682,
0.0166692492,
-0.0286180098,
-0.0022910626,
0.0617886633,
0.0556431636,
-0.0075349361,
0.0204645712,
-0.0050135674,
-0.0201177131,
-0.023066679,
0.0555145182,
-0.0132777579,
0.0217353776,
-0.0494452156,
-0.0571490042,
0.007627306,
0.0099289408,
-0.0120028015,
-0.0067659691,
0.0464966595,
0.0241994187,
-0.092352882,
0.0494697876,
-0.0308653153,
-0.0026282747,
-0.0123053137,
-0.0305195432,
-0.0179367401,
0.068330124,
0.026464181,
-0.0929934233,
0.0329424143,
-0.0462343358,
0.005171868,
0.0434280261,
0.0750795156,
-0.0024040642,
-0.0295031089,
0.0014977874,
-0.0717886016,
-0.009461455,
0.0015357223,
-0.0069206664,
-0.0137375239,
0.0167126991,
0.0006851571,
0.0218848828,
-0.0549841411,
0.0683790594,
-0.0208843984,
-0.0544482879,
0.0257793739,
-0.0054703322,
0.0362587422,
0.0343470946,
0.0013671534,
0.0213676486,
0.0450442657,
-0.0190361366,
-0.0071206586,
0.0098447371,
-0.0164873544,
0.0098265512,
0.0036417714,
0.0145096201,
0.0074896743,
-0.0303377751,
-0.0903501511,
-0.0675436333,
0.004146718,
-0.0240467153,
0.0035088332,
-0.0244797952,
0.0376826599,
-0.0176050272,
-0.0237549637,
-0.0591921769,
0.0411067121,
0.0345185809,
0.0157561172,
0.0208479464,
0.0016298882,
0.0203319602,
-0.003832137,
-0.0167793948,
0.0590112545,
0.0168960579,
0.0237902831,
0.0566138886,
0.0248980206,
-0.0319854021,
-0.0110450946,
-0.0714044571,
0.0073563559,
-0.0085454229,
0.0221076533,
0.0330591984,
0.0086794756,
-0.047893852,
-0.0544739626,
-0.0205612835,
-0.0159647297,
0.0353562832,
-0.00213682,
0.0512362197,
0.033652164,
-0.0099426052,
0.0051624994,
0.0171021037,
-0.0088772532,
-0.004263334,
0.0402394086,
0.0020280876,
-0.1186511144,
0.0313257724,
0.0100017721,
0.0205758382,
0.015625786,
0.0318648629,
0.0147991022,
0.014661748,
0.0570735522,
0.0028372912,
-0.0100526661,
-0.0168499108,
0.0062991576,
-0.0037133922,
-0.0082081929,
0.0011371344,
-0.0725110993,
-0.0491124876,
0.0011821208,
-0.0426561348,
0.0618545935,
0.0320562758,
0.0286170859,
-0.0043590772,
-0.024308892,
-0.0009006405,
-0.0058632395,
0.0503050499,
-0.0470601805,
-0.0624923185,
-0.0115531143,
0.0718604326,
0.0014227881,
-0.0366991311,
0.0579281114,
-0.0227251388,
0.0118922358,
-0.0572531447,
-0.03148821,
-0.0376121476,
0.0697725639,
-0.022865355,
-0.0020055561,
0.0029821654,
-0.0401830748,
-0.0429068469,
-0.0025583389,
0.0458719395,
-0.0003178045,
-0.0085628191,
-0.0568358898,
0.012829897,
-0.0216765627,
-0.0170006696,
-0.0392632782,
-0.0084126666,
-0.0334547982,
0.064610444,
0.0185674205,
0.0391203724,
-0.0058057881,
0.0368117914,
0.0084820576,
0.0513511002,
0.0339763537,
-0.0471035317,
-0.0456240922,
-0.025554331,
0.0182742104,
-0.0218580291,
0.0187017843,
-0.0183389951,
0.0388614908,
-0.0110686487,
0.0106037548,
-0.0470290855,
-0.0132482285,
-0.0205172468,
-0.0013218222,
-0.0909922272,
0.0096750604,
0.038782537,
0.0342324562,
-0.0504495502,
0.001870896,
0.0959142596,
0.0322210193,
-0.0192603283,
-0.0159268063,
0.0004969205,
-0.0174252652,
0.0350084826,
0.0359650701,
-0.005090131,
0.0040974696,
-0.0052620503,
0.0385805927,
-0.0071914573,
-0.0273517892,
-0.0247139409,
-0.1124660596,
0.0457804091,
-0.0356627405,
-0.0204952639,
-0.0363579616,
-0.0547615215,
0.0032287971,
-0.0302036013,
0.0095309839,
0.0146109182,
-0.0367698669,
-0.0403598845,
0.0351752415,
-0.0718101189,
-0.0557860471,
0.0323055573,
-0.0151283415,
-0.0482394286,
0.0558144785,
-0.0199377909,
-0.0257239696,
-0.007507842,
0.0715521425,
-0.045177158,
0.0308146663,
0.0156946294,
0.0332017466,
0.0119694527,
-0.0189229269,
-0.0049162749,
0.0138576217,
-0.0583757274,
-0.0026167415,
0.0596463941,
0.1003158465,
-0.0294955149,
-0.0136575541,
-0.0036064109,
0.0039839451,
0.0291743148,
0.0533707216,
-0.0253593754,
-0.0404108241,
-0.0395164602,
-0.0197985731,
0.012969669,
0.0348153748,
-0.0344624855,
0.0149118518,
-0.0838420838,
-0.0201262515,
-0.0453952886,
-0.0682731271,
0.0411413051,
0.0065775933,
0.0290560517,
0.0187287871,
0.0437084436,
0.0294461288,
-0.02768033,
0.0045344504,
-0.0350071155,
0.0518803224,
-0.0324651413,
-0.0103471912,
0.002971692,
0.0356124043,
-0.0086002713,
0.0180616546,
-0.055699192,
-0.0219633393,
-0.0342556946,
0.0672501922,
0.0222121645,
0.0223657098,
-0.016810298,
-0.0019752793,
0.0115343025,
-0.0272863843,
-0.028121395,
-0.0307389665,
0.0050427909,
0.052451998,
-0.0325153023,
-0.0082351249,
-0.0400707163,
0.0386917293,
-0.0100338208,
0.0046826839,
-0.018544618,
-0.0990804881,
-0.0005817828,
0.026288541,
0.025126176,
0.0085118292,
-0.053068988,
-0.0632133856,
-0.0204867572,
0.0108979996,
-0.0190759376,
-0.0195129085,
0.0304607507,
-0.0404367708,
-0.0451855808,
0.0364911966,
-0.0026788409,
-0.0846423879,
-0.003817562,
-0.022922989,
0.0084116161,
-0.0136402557,
0.0277230367,
-0.0129480772,
-0.0083340025,
-0.0323061347,
-0.0011590631,
0.0120991375,
0.037800543,
0.0239300448,
0.0840128884,
0.0238125268,
0.0495275296,
0.0067321109,
0.0199511983,
-0.0596686415,
-0.0046895891,
0.0037368503,
0.0101128528,
0.0214331206,
-0.0412178598,
0.0074552959,
-0.0527724288,
0.0181143694,
-0.0090338616,
0.0301187877,
0.0397342518,
0.000234037,
-0.0145917302,
0.0305070356,
-0.0496161059,
-0.018597478,
0.0537346825,
-0.0328294598,
-0.0049395175,
-0.0323066674,
-0.0464481227,
-0.0821299404,
-0.0343538523,
0.0220240429,
0.0284813251,
0.0022727668,
-0.0107652508,
-0.07063476,
-0.018828053,
-0.0054367296,
0.0005896948,
-0.0040535815,
-0.0527581088,
0.0235254709,
0.0710041896,
0.0060370555,
0.0191834681,
-0.0300883707,
-0.0184666459,
0.0351858661,
0.0052534016,
-0.0431282111,
-5.482766098e-33,
-0.0270968564,
-0.0421514735,
0.0287918802,
0.027200086,
-0.0133691384,
0.007745611,
-0.0205052495,
-0.0057115359,
0.0181343816,
0.0119661614,
-0.0529422387,
-0.0227789413,
0.0234312303,
-0.0217448175,
0.0345381387,
0.0178310238,
0.0819328129,
-0.0271840934,
-0.0358396098,
0.0357653908,
0.0482687801,
0.0142951971,
0.0381878763,
-0.0248328466,
0.0895058662,
-0.002262793,
-0.0504570268,
0.0522563569,
0.0298675522,
0.016843481,
-0.026269624,
0.0606284551,
0.0487322211,
-0.0569846034,
-0.0274148788,
0.0429042205,
-0.0106939757,
-0.0278407484,
0.0046659657,
0.0189768262,
-0.0009307778,
0.0151612321,
0.0008181476,
-0.056863822,
-0.0164158791,
0.0199040212,
0.0427532606,
-0.0392234549,
-0.0001233392,
-0.0092175445,
-0.0660427436,
0.0066965055,
-0.0201977305,
0.0097035291,
0.0352909751,
0.0204803608,
0.0070461943,
-0.0324458443,
-0.0469276272,
0.0073518362,
0.0380217619,
-0.0037950755,
0.0534217693,
0.0200878289,
-0.0060565299,
-0.0017847973,
-0.03667631,
0.0619834252,
0.0271150041,
0.033002235,
-0.0001994622,
0.0603553019,
0.0374873132,
-0.0471699871,
-0.042613823,
0.0063184556,
-0.0142963389,
0.0712200627,
-0.0036124745,
0.0396644473,
0.054550834,
-0.0495204441,
-0.0020678591,
-0.0451932736,
-0.0086075272,
-0.0129856495,
0.0070196269,
0.0338786207,
0.0040473705,
0.0311709251,
-0.02480538,
-0.0101394653,
0.0289950222,
0.0062777428,
-0.0050930153,
-0.0090619856,
-0.037679188,
-0.0033360897,
0.00167365,
-0.0070559266,
-0.0387796052,
-0.0408328474,
0.0072542238,
0.0210909005,
0.0097046969,
-0.0172329918,
0.0015101718,
0.0067581655,
-0.0654631034,
0.0363133252,
-0.0383283235,
0.0995536223,
-0.0160190184,
0.0336301662,
0.0065601342,
0.0096933674,
0.0086746896,
0.048590783,
-0.0035526564,
-0.0587694235,
0.0215633959,
0.0779399425,
-0.011912114,
0.0367744714,
-0.016448414,
-0.0138000641,
0.0157081727,
0.0489331745,
0.0613755733,
0.0105500966,
-0.0230654161,
0.0092351204,
2.624e-7,
0.0310831182,
-0.0017852777,
0.0309520066,
0.0687226802,
0.039513234,
0.0391992182,
-0.0091984961,
-0.000975697,
0.0068572722,
-0.0276761521,
0.0476974957,
-0.0194432996,
0.0420017056,
0.0233324654,
-0.0703911558,
-0.097166948,
-0.0410154276,
0.0199739337,
-0.1047528982,
0.0378897227,
0.0730585083,
0.046992626,
-0.0141384751,
0.0020731818,
-0.0175363347,
-0.029365493,
0.0015397586,
-0.0421887562,
0.0229850076,
0.04372105,
0.0701580867,
-0.0104408637,
0.0023092043,
0.0359236002,
-0.0166801326,
0.0154183181,
-0.0079540042,
0.0700300708,
0.036010202,
0.0048012766,
0.0096122529,
-0.0199107714,
0.0128513807,
-0.0219362974,
0.0453047529,
-0.0863249376,
-0.0270432048,
-0.0212438703,
-0.0291525032,
-0.0543390587,
0.0095906146,
0.0092211133,
-0.0251900405,
0.0554648489,
-0.0164792668,
-0.002945906,
-0.0071534696,
-0.0299805515,
0.0448086783,
-0.0006566412,
-0.0123506607,
-0.0427593328,
-0.0016871168,
0.0084994622,
0.0145941619,
-0.0227710027,
0.0428230651,
2.361022189e-34,
0.0446770974,
-0.0321535803,
0.0302652027,
0.0057780175,
0.018852789,
0.0215602349,
0.0046534524,
0.0380734019,
0.0287485179,
-0.0796195567,
-0.0072426051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08244v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08244v2 | API-Bank: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Tool-Augmented LLMs | 2023-04-14T14:05:32 | 2023-10-25T06:54:12 | Minghao Li, Yingxiu Zhao, Bowen Yu, Feifan Song, Hangyu Li, Haiyang Yu, Zhoujun Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent research has demonstrated that Large Language Models (LLMs) can
enhance their capabilities by utilizing external tools. However, three pivotal
questions remain unanswered: (1) How effective are current LLMs in utilizing
tools? (2) How can we enhance LLMs' ability to utilize tools? (3) What
obstacles need to be overcome to leverage tools? To address these questions, we
introduce API-Bank, a groundbreaking benchmark, specifically designed for
tool-augmented LLMs. For the first question, we develop a runnable evaluation
system consisting of 73 API tools. We annotate 314 tool-use dialogues with 753
API calls to assess the existing LLMs' capabilities in planning, retrieving,
and calling APIs. For the second question, we construct a comprehensive
training set containing 1,888 tool-use dialogues from 2,138 APIs spanning 1,000
distinct domains. Using this dataset, we train Lynx, a tool-augmented LLM
initialized from Alpaca. Experimental results demonstrate that GPT-3.5 exhibits
improved tool utilization compared to GPT-3, while GPT-4 excels in planning.
However, there is still significant potential for further improvement.
Moreover, Lynx surpasses Alpaca's tool utilization performance by more than 26
pts and approaches the effectiveness of GPT-3.5. Through error analysis, we
highlight the key challenges for future research in this field to answer the
third question. | [
0.0504687838,
0.0456174165,
-0.0329200998,
0.0458201058,
-0.0258904193,
0.0074957935,
-0.0293661747,
0.0128012504,
0.0341109037,
-0.0597348213,
-0.0425265431,
-0.00705601,
-0.0153181683,
0.0159158893,
0.0165702868,
-0.0594764613,
0.0470406078,
-0.0157667678,
-0.0036166951,
0.0273219682,
0.0013701065,
0.0333412513,
-0.0164599027,
0.0707657039,
0.0132286008,
-0.0155031905,
-0.0196574535,
0.0101176705,
-0.0174179897,
-0.0344642438,
0.029072186,
0.0385523364,
0.0102162845,
0.0513677709,
0.0000020479,
-0.0723336861,
0.0008717687,
0.0128039848,
-0.0387179404,
0.0053714546,
0.0175878052,
-0.0006517704,
0.0087958202,
0.0506167449,
-0.0635765344,
-0.0315818712,
0.0259635542,
-0.0232075341,
0.0674253926,
0.088463068,
0.0025078261,
-0.0023309537,
0.00110757,
-0.018954996,
-0.0609234199,
-0.0597559437,
-0.0223703198,
0.0057217772,
0.0415998772,
0.0042205444,
0.0280705877,
0.0217067879,
0.0357904583,
0.0017639803,
-0.0173946805,
0.0148655688,
-0.0726902857,
-0.0258134827,
-0.0289021321,
0.0620741732,
0.0101172207,
-0.0044832444,
0.0119286161,
-0.0208896417,
-0.0135981254,
0.0049632788,
-0.0663645118,
0.0076028048,
0.0076458133,
-0.0004408415,
-0.0127133923,
-0.0187249854,
0.0285399314,
0.0056033786,
0.002967424,
0.0537305549,
0.012698303,
0.0016986504,
0.0036176136,
0.0048688753,
-0.0018427492,
-0.0724344626,
-0.0018498686,
0.0535060242,
-0.0350335538,
0.0361868553,
-0.0241905823,
-0.0107132671,
0.0423983745,
-0.039636761,
0.0399915762,
0.0452681594,
-0.0359624103,
0.0174269564,
-0.007674457,
0.0276646428,
0.0122249955,
0.015737107,
-0.0232418906,
0.0002812053,
-0.0574679114,
-0.0127206175,
-0.0235562921,
0.0412696972,
-0.0400861762,
-0.0178505816,
-0.0235218536,
0.0627155527,
0.0320262276,
0.0145259406,
0.0087997299,
-0.0285657775,
-0.0185811352,
-0.0323333368,
-0.0440795086,
0.0031495567,
-0.0120371431,
0.0307214223,
0.0181811601,
-0.0854915157,
-0.0197246112,
0.0168810543,
-0.0309233181,
-0.0136558954,
-0.0024277365,
0.1384790391,
0.0008908152,
-0.0107574342,
-0.0601742901,
-0.0467896312,
0.0337859653,
-0.0519834571,
-0.0084742224,
-0.0672724769,
0.0300938804,
0.0458549671,
-0.014058155,
-0.0152882235,
0.005431076,
0.0164369941,
-0.0075844284,
0.037348114,
-0.0127691692,
0.0184288174,
0.0352408327,
0.0171557516,
-0.0215131268,
0.0816101804,
0.0170983672,
0.0325944759,
0.0281327236,
0.0060378755,
-0.014235544,
0.0865730718,
-0.026870558,
-0.0060857655,
-0.002949001,
0.0327176154,
0.0152750453,
0.0329030417,
0.0158448257,
0.0293109622,
-0.019771751,
-0.0084341411,
0.0482322909,
0.0476443209,
0.0243855752,
-0.000171579,
0.0733966082,
0.0183111075,
0.0278951097,
-0.033321742,
-0.0747548789,
0.0019193372,
-0.030797001,
0.019821398,
0.020089034,
0.0193268619,
-0.0099076582,
-0.0445487611,
-0.0297019519,
-0.0120042702,
-0.0527416915,
-0.0002474642,
0.0376677439,
0.0015673622,
-0.0436408147,
0.0706569999,
0.0125325806,
-0.0294330809,
-0.0372972898,
-0.0586502478,
-0.0090478584,
0.0424364731,
0.0834572539,
-0.0389521867,
-0.0606763996,
-0.0050796526,
-0.0100318305,
0.0594050512,
0.0776907578,
-0.0204224735,
0.0055229529,
-0.0569560714,
-0.0191781633,
-0.0033352706,
0.0113781914,
0.0251324214,
0.0629233047,
0.009451706,
0.0193277393,
-0.0721690431,
-0.0072474969,
0.0383127555,
-0.0283707064,
-0.0224036854,
-0.0079201199,
-0.0162809175,
0.0444406308,
0.0200308226,
-0.0173123293,
0.0089066075,
0.0216022562,
-0.0151727954,
-0.0127499411,
0.0174452215,
-0.0498575196,
0.0199184734,
0.0629978627,
0.0434131213,
-0.0218129307,
0.0291152,
-0.0406836569,
-0.0451091863,
0.0171501897,
-0.0244752076,
0.073380962,
-0.0235833153,
0.0351201221,
0.0144962221,
0.0000188791,
-0.0388906486,
0.0369735993,
-0.002537675,
0.0012573281,
-0.0051601254,
0.0137720462,
0.0235313941,
-0.0075961584,
-0.0107480688,
0.0385553166,
-0.0013167302,
0.0182852894,
0.0024077049,
0.036039345,
-0.0388187282,
-0.0322047174,
-0.1387993842,
0.0159994401,
-0.0296108164,
0.0329615735,
0.0158994906,
0.0263294764,
-0.0182446316,
-0.0165853444,
-0.0183091927,
0.002642818,
-0.0118143642,
0.0347209647,
0.0103145232,
0.0206888933,
-0.0372467116,
-0.0461938642,
0.0166817624,
-0.0149195716,
0.0192270633,
-0.0142687708,
-0.0447883792,
-0.01776083,
0.0336512998,
-0.0086152731,
0.0188621394,
-0.0199542493,
-0.0179093033,
0.0203686059,
-0.0136356251,
-0.0041528121,
0.0072596497,
-0.0278045591,
0.005736717,
0.0291553363,
-0.0063958406,
-0.1018372178,
0.0247951299,
0.0165348891,
-0.0577400476,
-0.0423346907,
-0.0115019539,
0.0279470105,
0.0623043217,
-0.0039725895,
0.0257940944,
-0.0105222519,
-0.0052540274,
0.0141221769,
-0.0389246233,
0.0246648714,
0.0052909576,
-0.0242681894,
0.0374054685,
-0.0040978496,
-0.0956430137,
0.0518153198,
-0.0464869477,
-0.0361924954,
-0.0256357845,
-0.0306449849,
-0.0558742508,
0.0759570524,
0.0007240014,
-0.014970921,
-0.0225546211,
-0.0478194878,
-0.0367296301,
-0.0121657206,
-0.0058184061,
-0.0430126227,
0.0793064907,
-0.1007980928,
0.0333216712,
-0.0154298758,
-0.0331692025,
-0.0347718149,
-0.0012018754,
-0.0674820915,
0.0310916789,
-0.0121537549,
-0.0296957325,
0.0097128162,
0.0003554036,
-0.0078951446,
0.0739804879,
0.0081668654,
-0.0098818718,
-0.0009156328,
0.0021248399,
0.0275011174,
0.0356725678,
0.0078329658,
0.0104407631,
0.0295855384,
0.0119269518,
0.0365794748,
-0.0306031685,
-0.0477620177,
-0.0105433175,
0.0228556599,
-0.0665350631,
-0.0288698059,
0.0329090729,
0.0323171876,
-0.0765439495,
-0.0075166263,
0.1045961455,
0.0360212103,
-0.0377862938,
-0.0027442812,
-0.0311448481,
0.0352787003,
0.0409204625,
0.05377331,
-0.0963001177,
-0.0581655949,
-0.0049356222,
0.0378272496,
0.0007313355,
-0.0258988272,
-0.0205385871,
-0.1590434909,
0.0283374451,
-0.0036917173,
-0.0122617725,
0.0379645303,
-0.0328762196,
-0.0076202755,
-0.0054196017,
0.0210716836,
-0.0006556313,
-0.0011926307,
-0.0065466068,
0.0065647364,
-0.0567707047,
-0.0315935798,
0.0221560653,
-0.0037907218,
0.0507626086,
0.082128711,
-0.0119441617,
-0.0007271055,
0.0181009471,
0.1064297929,
-0.0034450158,
0.0154461637,
-0.0371808559,
0.0214865971,
-0.0024835987,
-0.0126065221,
0.0290897023,
0.0169857033,
-0.0359128192,
-0.0111707747,
0.0180874877,
0.077850312,
-0.0381001569,
0.0292293467,
-0.0231879726,
-0.0091759702,
0.0028332721,
0.0429563709,
0.033170253,
-0.0174395442,
-0.0407217182,
-0.0362284929,
-0.053344287,
-0.0436313264,
-0.0102308402,
-0.0169643573,
0.0042819418,
0.0210055765,
-0.0591583699,
-0.0438028201,
0.0544677228,
0.0100148246,
0.026076341,
0.0237826984,
-0.009961837,
0.0323846824,
-0.033470992,
0.029271964,
-0.0187029224,
0.0106706079,
-0.0558841899,
-0.0430759937,
0.0426277705,
-0.000355212,
-0.0019560098,
0.0786361024,
-0.0635436773,
-0.0960473716,
-0.021305196,
0.0696913898,
0.0306566413,
0.03426186,
-0.0193687975,
-0.0533063151,
-0.0143480543,
0.0785390735,
-0.0358606502,
0.007071116,
0.0148047311,
0.0546856411,
-0.0019558789,
0.0438966155,
-0.0691337213,
-0.0253222957,
-0.0147494152,
0.0463863574,
-0.0284129586,
-0.0589248464,
0.0014261534,
0.0235045161,
-0.0114103854,
-0.0015612843,
-0.0017213904,
-0.0182582811,
0.0362652093,
-0.0089942627,
-0.0069708526,
-0.0551308617,
0.0112536028,
-0.021106774,
-0.0258246157,
0.0119224135,
0.0098909177,
-0.0331457034,
0.0323917046,
0.0049064318,
0.0175383724,
0.0090699065,
-0.0083080335,
0.0155546898,
-0.0053537539,
-0.0266842805,
-0.0086555779,
-0.004216189,
0.0522516258,
-0.0399875529,
0.0728857145,
-0.0164534226,
0.0098594548,
0.0197797846,
0.0194629692,
-0.0412675925,
-0.1037041768,
-0.0089496588,
0.0274837967,
0.032994248,
-0.0397474617,
0.0580262281,
-0.0522182062,
0.0115769701,
-0.0359532088,
0.0301674139,
-0.0064414307,
-0.007529682,
0.0230709836,
0.0215915851,
-0.0384963527,
-0.0104022287,
0.0685937479,
-0.0173110366,
0.047621984,
0.012589464,
0.0031945519,
-0.054989785,
-0.055623766,
0.0620369427,
0.0042589689,
-0.0155384066,
-0.0099096941,
-0.0648286194,
-0.0541936606,
-0.0078819431,
-0.0050224122,
-0.0060706441,
-0.0244256519,
0.0267951079,
0.0811058804,
0.0114416294,
-0.0030800814,
-0.0396539979,
-0.0051077749,
-0.0452661514,
-0.0347660668,
-0.0167666692,
-5.692435719e-33,
-0.0427604169,
-0.0245167874,
0.0504796281,
-0.0045727515,
-0.0131916469,
-0.0074035157,
-0.0330466144,
0.0155618405,
-0.0340696834,
-0.0230912231,
-0.0182970576,
0.0001128487,
0.0295029711,
-0.0004876711,
0.0365441106,
0.0213630218,
0.014527753,
-0.0095159765,
-0.0130532505,
0.007275132,
0.0176227763,
0.0219270829,
0.0552410781,
-0.0773031786,
-0.0149125028,
0.0116124647,
0.0133044273,
0.0228742938,
0.0028044456,
0.0635546818,
-0.0025055469,
0.0160627104,
0.0216921102,
-0.0284918379,
-0.0255973116,
-0.0149073862,
-0.0319200121,
-0.0243771225,
0.0666483045,
0.0211843271,
0.0183872823,
-0.0158928055,
0.039355088,
-0.0167755503,
-0.0080842627,
0.0002617459,
0.0131797949,
-0.0129766613,
-0.0372503549,
-0.0046737124,
-0.0562466569,
0.0373717844,
0.0057591605,
-0.0162775759,
0.0120990723,
0.0194124822,
0.0048063318,
0.013501334,
-0.021034006,
-0.0118913595,
0.0032198403,
0.0491241664,
0.0951930135,
0.0193645675,
-0.0141514661,
0.0627758875,
-0.0028490911,
-0.0093217166,
0.0234365426,
-0.0020340707,
0.0256042611,
0.0591791831,
-0.001581473,
-0.0014679804,
-0.0305734258,
0.0286721066,
-0.0118177217,
0.0304054469,
0.0398347788,
0.0347018056,
0.0162639525,
0.0124881994,
-0.0218543485,
-0.0011079168,
-0.0279251505,
-0.0204144977,
-0.0276540443,
-0.0271637756,
0.0547374748,
0.0093372259,
0.0339556858,
-0.000130357,
0.0289469957,
-0.0208400581,
-0.0147783058,
0.0083152456,
-0.0277684126,
0.0315119922,
-0.0004939343,
0.0290543456,
-0.0438057855,
-0.0235706307,
-0.0279981792,
0.0169461574,
0.049196478,
-0.0148178916,
-0.0020396449,
0.0092206495,
-0.0729912445,
0.0118703377,
-0.0664113164,
0.0444682315,
-0.0338151343,
0.0270857494,
0.0351371765,
-0.0271754786,
-0.0194458142,
0.0602860153,
-0.0258114524,
-0.0301702544,
-0.0345942751,
-0.0099432543,
0.0054818667,
-0.0105797816,
-0.0405028649,
0.0180856157,
0.0161491279,
0.0240078308,
0.0175910927,
0.0118636861,
0.0026157622,
-0.0030858298,
2.681e-7,
0.0471897721,
0.0176775474,
0.0348318182,
0.0600048453,
-0.0007445434,
0.0306948815,
-0.031440001,
0.013508087,
0.003874586,
-0.0233266745,
-0.0201623831,
0.0165663548,
0.0686889663,
0.0343794264,
-0.0988256186,
0.0037859273,
-0.0112447096,
-0.0070346161,
-0.0792206973,
-0.0200169031,
0.0342523679,
0.0840639696,
0.0040472215,
-0.0171052311,
-0.033670105,
-0.0703425705,
0.0261439346,
-0.0437263325,
-0.0284018852,
0.0413585752,
0.0121851377,
0.0607015714,
0.0120069478,
-0.0041572927,
-0.0325784832,
0.0270524845,
-0.0073001641,
0.0934952125,
0.004560886,
-0.0440853611,
0.0220339317,
-0.0355834216,
0.0041703614,
-0.0302194543,
0.0298805255,
-0.0380104482,
-0.0227532741,
-0.0149289835,
0.020835517,
-0.0108398488,
-0.0246882234,
-0.0159012955,
0.0279554389,
0.051924333,
0.0102596655,
-0.0376675203,
-0.0156652164,
-0.0805390403,
-0.0414183959,
0.0376783311,
-0.0391474925,
-0.0595286414,
-0.0718591288,
0.0033161147,
-0.0259333197,
-0.0222362205,
-0.0137466006,
2.679264555e-34,
0.029611215,
-0.0081027662,
0.039330449,
0.1014198959,
0.0384771414,
0.0249317791,
0.0431124456,
0.0436510704,
-0.0087961219,
-0.0611287802,
0.0009573161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07130v1 | OPI at SemEval 2023 Task 9: A Simple But Effective Approach to Multilingual Tweet Intimacy Analysis | 2023-04-14T13:49:28 | 2023-04-14T13:49:28 | Sławomir Dadas | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our submission to the SemEval 2023 multilingual tweet
intimacy analysis shared task. The goal of the task was to assess the level of
intimacy of Twitter posts in ten languages. The proposed approach consists of
several steps. First, we perform in-domain pre-training to create a language
model adapted to Twitter data. In the next step, we train an ensemble of
regression models to expand the training set with pseudo-labeled examples. The
extended dataset is used to train the final solution. Our method was ranked
first in five out of ten language subtasks, obtaining the highest average score
across all languages. | [
0.0505433753,
0.0740725324,
-0.0372964777,
-0.0003683016,
-0.0220021792,
0.0214942154,
0.0198185071,
0.0050625047,
0.039571438,
0.0261385832,
-0.0269670542,
-0.0657545179,
0.0001222789,
0.0559450686,
0.019169338,
-0.0050228308,
0.0264572334,
0.0393071808,
-0.0223859157,
-0.0080135446,
0.0298873577,
0.0235674847,
0.0386696085,
-0.0230073035,
-0.0166842472,
0.007912674,
-0.017936714,
-0.0105734626,
0.0026990094,
0.0126831476,
0.0454620011,
0.0719214603,
0.0020347659,
0.0197451003,
0.0000023116,
-0.0411312506,
-0.0378932618,
-0.041379746,
0.0653407499,
-0.0412105769,
0.077172108,
-0.0423989408,
0.0290431064,
0.025759872,
-0.0478293225,
0.0120401876,
0.060321942,
0.0055879671,
0.0512454212,
0.0526781455,
-0.0416547917,
0.0312461387,
-0.0054858844,
-0.0481631868,
-0.0008674872,
0.012431046,
0.0215604939,
-0.0379563831,
-0.0414401554,
0.0010652044,
0.0165180806,
0.0381535366,
0.0094357859,
-0.0042066388,
0.0629988462,
0.0103707938,
-0.013632494,
-0.0739625618,
0.0078704366,
0.0454338789,
0.0390096121,
-0.0130348559,
0.0092042573,
0.0233796462,
-0.0109979399,
0.000185366,
-0.0314072892,
-0.0317612402,
0.019091269,
-0.0004440124,
-0.0472554304,
0.0672777444,
0.0026373425,
0.0627162457,
0.020869473,
0.0513310842,
-0.019255098,
-0.0415872484,
0.0616790205,
0.0371222571,
-0.0164383706,
-0.028959902,
0.0601545945,
-0.0129853012,
0.0017833707,
0.0069568674,
-0.0265454948,
-0.0288123749,
0.0214366987,
-0.0433055609,
0.0009931028,
0.0091362083,
-0.0003976037,
0.0142028015,
0.0221724883,
0.0153349862,
0.0125825396,
-0.0511109233,
-0.0111534782,
-0.0043675033,
-0.0319860354,
0.009641544,
-0.002559375,
0.023241533,
-0.0164293312,
-0.0100159356,
-0.0206436478,
0.0252338871,
-0.0185888205,
0.0012244947,
-0.0285872724,
0.0123496661,
-0.0041503632,
0.0026775557,
0.0138545353,
0.0346238986,
-0.0740745515,
0.0044685728,
-0.0452556796,
-0.0417105071,
0.005609795,
0.0151372971,
0.0554611646,
-0.0345349424,
-0.0007452765,
0.0087766601,
0.0001787902,
-0.0494557656,
0.026035266,
-0.0412791856,
-0.018356787,
-0.0516508259,
-0.0200972855,
-0.0814104155,
0.0731120855,
0.0376305245,
-0.0061781541,
-0.0580397099,
0.0061787022,
0.0030057051,
-0.0332157128,
0.0272465721,
-0.027783474,
0.0503344759,
-0.0124954181,
0.0440858342,
0.0510146059,
0.0687084347,
-0.0361501388,
0.0962112099,
0.077354379,
0.007945695,
0.0105840676,
0.0342008322,
0.0024339557,
0.0382542573,
-0.0021511314,
0.0149970436,
0.0146388477,
-0.0022260693,
-0.0075513893,
0.0117626972,
0.0167751648,
-0.0145253576,
0.0670537725,
0.0602190532,
-0.0241996963,
0.0661708042,
-0.0261183083,
0.0288846865,
0.0149359321,
-0.0066189035,
-0.0232030414,
0.0202012397,
-0.0030141082,
-0.0321171321,
0.0541152172,
0.02109107,
-0.0296806674,
-0.0512058027,
0.0086811632,
-0.0286013223,
0.0053706137,
-0.0092631374,
0.0431978106,
-0.0525417514,
-0.0080496306,
0.0418553092,
0.063005358,
-0.0769386068,
0.0140262665,
-0.0072600474,
-0.0139976544,
0.0588120148,
-0.0080984402,
-0.0265204571,
0.0042526792,
-0.0591826439,
0.0837178528,
0.0176458545,
-0.0051285219,
0.0126894815,
0.0471167825,
-0.0144191338,
-0.0128261754,
0.0083898883,
0.0228361692,
0.0321768075,
0.0046839183,
0.0442137979,
-0.0180470217,
-0.0000386813,
-0.0463317707,
0.0107222954,
-0.0503697172,
-0.0022601706,
0.0098585766,
0.0266880076,
0.0063554039,
0.0567529313,
-0.025763182,
-0.0366364196,
0.0344313346,
0.0024437825,
-0.0029694065,
0.0068186903,
-0.0023109824,
0.0574530177,
0.040931575,
-0.0168738812,
-0.0609033555,
0.0373929702,
-0.0261943489,
-0.0034493566,
0.0822507814,
-0.0035286457,
0.0315010585,
-0.0247025881,
-0.038295567,
-0.0989406034,
0.0185810607,
0.0161115974,
0.0251603015,
-0.0352364406,
0.0101073598,
-0.0243744012,
-0.0692479983,
0.0318593346,
0.0351239182,
-0.026364211,
-0.0237119365,
-0.0298474617,
0.0242975652,
0.0218864512,
0.0246147737,
-0.0669538677,
-0.0576718375,
-0.1118069887,
-0.0261682644,
-0.0534089804,
-0.0042864424,
0.0068623601,
0.0233879555,
-0.0039503747,
0.0017982008,
-0.0500140265,
-0.0081968959,
-0.0033910116,
0.0028672006,
-0.0010814701,
-0.0179163739,
0.0344473794,
-0.0527024046,
-0.0010052738,
-0.0250597894,
0.0342937894,
0.0188092198,
-0.0296746586,
0.0165533107,
0.0137585336,
-0.0677410141,
-0.0238802731,
-0.000858917,
-0.0502620675,
-0.0345295854,
-0.0218600295,
-0.0291742291,
0.0289947577,
0.0025491384,
0.0513698272,
0.0251119472,
-0.0121942228,
-0.0322805494,
0.0062045678,
-0.0077227042,
-0.0106009357,
-0.0189920887,
-0.0603173859,
0.0074862381,
0.0005923032,
-0.0561135523,
-0.0024693597,
-0.0497045405,
0.0285274051,
-0.0081859259,
-0.033025302,
-0.0100989565,
0.0133131724,
0.0086960653,
0.0320704877,
-0.0066040019,
-0.068359077,
0.0312584937,
0.0188323483,
-0.001252524,
-0.0422686562,
-0.062581718,
0.0081907921,
0.0788906664,
-0.0085272733,
0.0153422318,
0.0263678804,
-0.0041314783,
0.0002335674,
-0.018525267,
-0.0070971572,
-0.0289731119,
0.0074788942,
0.0401530899,
-0.0176831055,
0.0425161608,
-0.022438487,
-0.0056196121,
-0.0318523087,
-0.0439737476,
-0.0434049442,
-0.0132563934,
-0.044976186,
-0.0069476748,
0.0058429856,
-0.0139287384,
-0.0670953915,
-0.0411334969,
-0.0208347645,
0.0033846195,
0.0306909233,
0.080960393,
-0.0508658588,
-0.0233632587,
-0.0318379775,
0.0143844206,
0.0261874385,
0.0114352843,
0.0117988056,
0.0053200512,
-0.0177996662,
0.0213190932,
0.0245352592,
0.0094821528,
-0.0613725483,
0.0456699915,
0.0094919391,
0.012727594,
0.1265281439,
0.0207881574,
-0.0683111772,
-0.0255876258,
-0.0280258078,
0.0457461067,
-0.001725146,
0.0244328286,
-0.0565247573,
0.006874437,
-0.0107383225,
0.00533725,
-0.0081741661,
-0.0512762405,
-0.0343700051,
-0.0703729466,
-0.0352200568,
-0.0109461313,
-0.0445510894,
-0.0197664034,
-0.0950126722,
0.0200634506,
-0.036231637,
0.0165753979,
-0.0460235924,
-0.0098057929,
0.0067982287,
0.0049277577,
-0.0140099013,
-0.0660654232,
0.0154952966,
-0.0629089177,
-0.0093015255,
0.0163469352,
0.0870173275,
-0.0581001788,
-0.0010599502,
0.0005505429,
0.0453387611,
-0.0223478172,
-0.0338911712,
0.0695676208,
-0.0015722599,
0.0120479902,
-0.0201463718,
0.0163195003,
-0.0169123542,
0.0302289966,
0.0047417805,
0.0492742695,
-0.0125854481,
-0.0372866653,
0.0100502167,
0.0090099173,
0.0427626111,
0.0327626765,
0.025610622,
-0.0798320249,
0.0116530042,
-0.0124590239,
0.0504303128,
-0.0003848792,
-0.0304402187,
-0.0508077592,
0.0006834103,
-0.0637889355,
-0.0487504974,
-0.0588077381,
0.0364054553,
0.0174328871,
0.0105255237,
-0.0029293825,
-0.0224282071,
-0.0219771564,
-0.0581333265,
0.0446243659,
0.0102396132,
0.029737426,
0.0124663627,
0.0194689948,
0.0191424787,
0.0088849021,
0.0318607315,
-0.0374113023,
-0.0589917265,
-0.0633462742,
0.0062867645,
0.039004907,
0.0249238163,
0.039166484,
-0.0277268477,
-0.0751511827,
0.0097235981,
0.0715919733,
-0.0386048816,
-0.0106850341,
0.0362637863,
-0.0120153725,
0.004405729,
0.0572011024,
0.0124329561,
0.023477409,
0.0242495872,
-0.0723749474,
0.0054701683,
-0.0385965519,
-0.0411524214,
-0.0198468789,
0.0497472361,
0.0226953086,
-0.0331331529,
-0.0490047857,
-0.0651204139,
-0.0020182643,
0.0051735332,
-0.0395801626,
0.0086498968,
0.0316148028,
0.0475938693,
-0.0592577159,
-0.0177090038,
-0.0469239652,
-0.0147059383,
-0.0771083608,
0.0149406372,
0.0103587648,
0.0153401019,
-0.0088061057,
0.0084238816,
-0.0262926221,
-0.0077713239,
0.0143942181,
-0.0018509607,
0.0090719471,
-0.0212986525,
0.017169917,
-0.0232483614,
0.0202547871,
0.0575163253,
0.0118915401,
-0.0019533304,
-0.0358195975,
-0.0334090181,
0.0495495945,
-0.0452904031,
0.0612821169,
0.0145748453,
-0.0042727841,
-0.004802559,
0.0330648571,
-0.0352210701,
-0.02720806,
-0.015238299,
-0.0019364173,
-0.02220436,
0.0606658272,
0.0488855988,
-0.0498043224,
-0.0184983313,
0.0744639486,
-0.0302601736,
0.0202803425,
0.0439324118,
0.0336042941,
0.0460527427,
-0.0227021109,
0.0192677099,
-0.0094099734,
-0.0743267983,
0.048780147,
-0.0826847404,
-0.020399129,
0.0267641433,
0.0308754556,
0.0494127087,
0.0083762817,
0.0470477343,
-0.0403034128,
-0.0504964627,
-0.0320140757,
-0.0649749711,
0.0116717527,
-6.993677843e-33,
0.0565090738,
-0.0580780879,
-0.0646865964,
0.02554035,
-0.0558931082,
-0.0020223805,
-0.0128057469,
0.0415622331,
-0.0275138095,
0.0165023878,
-0.0292093474,
0.0438835472,
0.0110368198,
0.0067667663,
0.0505671352,
0.026693929,
-0.0025463735,
0.0093015572,
-0.0062285699,
0.0614736788,
0.01455821,
0.0461297259,
0.034398213,
-0.1090313941,
0.0552151613,
0.0012173023,
-0.0355327912,
0.0136090992,
0.0769993141,
0.0183740798,
-0.0240011346,
0.0794370174,
0.0216831919,
0.0043007466,
0.0349977687,
0.0758412108,
-0.0190590955,
-0.0624203309,
-0.0232352912,
0.0161373299,
-0.0007686289,
-0.0200810302,
-0.0061201141,
-0.0137787117,
-0.0049781427,
-0.0309897326,
0.0531634353,
-0.005131667,
0.0316106193,
0.0093004461,
0.0036729551,
0.0223372895,
0.0111966431,
0.0011276171,
0.0679248422,
0.1068180874,
0.0294117462,
-0.0164217446,
-0.0179877207,
0.021215992,
-0.0317734368,
0.0134144844,
-0.013127856,
-0.0502661765,
0.0069466336,
0.0303630009,
0.0058249962,
0.0119759124,
0.0082857134,
0.029204946,
0.0243492331,
0.0570388399,
0.0177770369,
0.0532227345,
-0.0151609639,
-0.0373444743,
-0.0589395761,
0.0042099049,
0.0467905477,
0.0128360074,
-0.0134487152,
-0.0187144,
-0.0040108603,
-0.0124495625,
-0.0065252259,
-0.0561616309,
-0.0423623845,
-0.074529767,
-0.0211345684,
-0.0170209166,
-0.0559226014,
0.0060938071,
0.0062517533,
-0.052848801,
-0.0481906831,
0.0221419241,
-0.0320432708,
0.0442703292,
0.046760451,
0.0250160974,
-0.0111892251,
-0.030599026,
-0.0291387532,
0.0228365101,
0.0469002798,
-0.0161572229,
0.0309455246,
0.00731336,
-0.0570664331,
-0.0060959612,
-0.0212645736,
0.0119932527,
-0.0131751681,
0.0304735936,
-0.0308973212,
0.017063871,
-0.0055542495,
0.0399730578,
0.0691720024,
0.0394328758,
-0.0364442952,
-0.0187693108,
-0.0218966473,
0.0025011008,
-0.0049753501,
-0.0345047899,
-0.026219666,
-0.0389157087,
0.0292801335,
0.0212612972,
-0.0280825309,
-0.0645822883,
2.971e-7,
-0.0099456701,
0.0607087314,
-0.0029705102,
-0.0123808132,
0.003229202,
0.0262749344,
-0.0045494311,
0.0665520281,
0.007201829,
-0.0107562775,
0.0251643881,
-0.0167988315,
0.104804188,
0.0396385528,
-0.0775692537,
-0.0177691709,
-0.0621744581,
-0.0129086459,
-0.0601909831,
0.0054683923,
0.0105674351,
0.0509424359,
0.0569306612,
0.0145220328,
-0.0443133228,
-0.0044176956,
0.0344289131,
-0.0804244205,
0.0025847515,
0.0319975838,
0.0161058046,
0.0068987687,
-0.0229711272,
0.0131275542,
-0.0366739184,
0.0048519652,
0.0201676246,
0.0509803332,
0.0068133776,
0.0051329285,
0.0380351692,
0.0126192728,
-0.0006951655,
-0.0770654902,
0.0487774014,
-0.02366101,
-0.0646071732,
-0.0013400173,
0.0233908407,
-0.0047280649,
0.0981125459,
-0.0178016182,
-0.0346726924,
0.0501102395,
0.0142549397,
-0.0051884926,
-0.0176022612,
-0.0170459226,
0.0168101098,
-0.0108205359,
0.0200051386,
-0.0126914596,
0.0064020064,
0.0134788007,
0.0064541698,
0.0057886546,
0.0659259558,
2.103968207e-34,
0.0175697785,
-0.0432940349,
0.0218916815,
-0.0029081358,
0.0444947705,
-0.0014399292,
-0.0090928972,
0.0002401457,
0.0402109027,
-0.0292662214,
0.0227171276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07127v1 | OPI at SemEval 2023 Task 1: Image-Text Embeddings and Multimodal Information Retrieval for Visual Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-04-14T13:45:59 | 2023-04-14T13:45:59 | Sławomir Dadas | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of visual word sense disambiguation is to find the image that best
matches the provided description of the word's meaning. It is a challenging
problem, requiring approaches that combine language and image understanding. In
this paper, we present our submission to SemEval 2023 visual word sense
disambiguation shared task. The proposed system integrates multimodal
embeddings, learning to rank methods, and knowledge-based approaches. We build
a classifier based on the CLIP model, whose results are enriched with
additional information retrieved from Wikipedia and lexical databases. Our
solution was ranked third in the multilingual task and won in the Persian
track, one of the three language subtasks. | [
-0.0014272378,
0.0153840091,
0.01517116,
0.0641719848,
-0.0209244322,
0.0183774047,
-0.04315155,
0.044984445,
0.0133440858,
-0.0522641055,
0.0157072339,
0.0310910679,
0.0110213244,
0.0254319515,
0.0514837019,
-0.057080809,
0.0603836589,
-0.0079536708,
-0.0384063162,
0.0012244204,
0.0227157921,
-0.0001301409,
-0.0155105852,
-0.002738538,
-0.0580028631,
0.0065615084,
0.0275158584,
0.0091550965,
0.0470309667,
-0.0074494616,
-0.0371215902,
0.010648137,
0.0702598095,
-0.0002553629,
0.0000018935,
-0.0197011512,
-0.0025022309,
0.0046832212,
0.0263116807,
-0.0579332747,
0.0225820243,
-0.0650294274,
0.0445062555,
-0.0350024588,
-0.0325952806,
0.0477936603,
0.0758115575,
-0.0036077576,
0.0784200653,
-0.0005206547,
-0.0260098595,
-0.0283712633,
-0.0372274555,
-0.0166176967,
0.032745596,
-0.0124940518,
-0.0039053345,
0.0133248987,
-0.0372148156,
-0.0122500826,
-0.0868799612,
0.0550989024,
-0.039518781,
0.0071943309,
0.0386688039,
0.0039111185,
-0.0490476824,
-0.0365221947,
0.0027295991,
0.053878542,
-0.0084643811,
-0.0003146269,
-0.029442424,
0.024277091,
-0.0310510714,
0.0536544062,
-0.0298802573,
0.0090396181,
0.0141597213,
0.0020320362,
-0.0354302935,
0.0219049919,
0.0232352652,
0.0021389115,
-0.0203848295,
0.0310013872,
0.0179291647,
-0.0063978923,
0.023357885,
0.0083331894,
-0.0401747636,
0.0319540128,
0.0079995366,
-0.0034913302,
0.0055134706,
0.0346835367,
-0.0007446834,
-0.0394564755,
0.0077224807,
-0.082798928,
-0.0248416178,
0.0354157314,
-0.0043582739,
0.1031084731,
-0.0456966087,
0.0016686785,
0.0208772682,
0.0301905405,
-0.0273166802,
-0.0123386206,
-0.0473424271,
0.0167047083,
-0.0391292833,
0.00163081,
-0.0318586007,
-0.0486679301,
-0.0510786735,
-0.0129904626,
-0.0511669666,
0.0418064892,
0.0113970498,
0.0101798028,
-0.0221700296,
0.0125569645,
-0.0462780073,
0.0333733559,
-0.0268065203,
-0.0163452569,
-0.0750328824,
0.0139306076,
-0.0009404559,
0.034101557,
-0.0099071609,
-0.030772917,
-0.006004863,
0.0413610488,
-0.0295670144,
-0.0306193307,
-0.0072006076,
-0.0371981747,
-0.0387426056,
-0.0063690497,
0.025034504,
-0.0556824803,
0.0387887843,
0.0025410787,
0.0189011227,
-0.073493503,
0.0215493478,
-0.0037676375,
-0.0659109131,
0.1400018781,
-0.0189270452,
-0.0300074797,
0.0105984062,
0.0381801166,
0.0030018357,
0.0780717805,
0.013362458,
0.0366464145,
0.0706407353,
0.0372654647,
-0.0510011502,
0.0312275998,
-0.002089689,
-0.0262841955,
-0.0358617008,
-0.0347807184,
-0.0172518473,
0.0463276096,
0.0137972543,
0.0394412242,
-0.0351860896,
-0.000040926,
0.0274090003,
0.0493365042,
-0.008242243,
-0.0466944948,
0.0065152203,
0.0095842527,
-0.0186963491,
-0.0055481573,
0.006231071,
0.0254525747,
0.0359158479,
0.0198895596,
0.0324910507,
0.0346990116,
-0.0016482081,
-0.0189971197,
-0.008961929,
-0.0373328887,
0.0099984501,
0.0450977311,
0.083462514,
-0.0000644063,
-0.0263258312,
0.0580664203,
0.0288033877,
-0.0251882896,
0.0095198639,
-0.0259390995,
-0.0150780035,
0.0592579991,
0.0460213944,
-0.0492903478,
0.0076552187,
0.0182014722,
-0.0029529158,
0.0302693434,
-0.0196251236,
-0.0280902758,
0.0211866219,
-0.0592123978,
-0.0633028448,
-0.0127507281,
0.0097535793,
-0.0151512288,
-0.0051227603,
0.0413585342,
0.024140019,
-0.0702058449,
0.0034389168,
0.0373766758,
0.0269749407,
0.0002410117,
-0.0795387179,
0.0675377399,
-0.0364518426,
0.0085034184,
-0.037651211,
0.0091854809,
0.0178420525,
-0.0584415831,
0.0404158048,
-0.0026672119,
0.0017648627,
-0.0529798605,
0.0366365239,
-0.1045637578,
-0.0263299644,
0.0245181452,
-0.0342546552,
-0.0197972655,
0.0216083769,
-0.0218896251,
0.0152507713,
-0.0499241538,
0.0068638837,
-0.0022544842,
0.0189836025,
-0.0511716865,
0.0555969663,
-0.0321808234,
0.0076771635,
0.0156384688,
0.0005059284,
0.0073699043,
0.0206501707,
-0.0659045726,
0.0262002572,
0.0119767906,
0.0227180999,
0.0024740547,
-0.0068819216,
-0.0521614254,
-0.0058205435,
-0.0600311086,
-0.019275615,
-0.0097445212,
-0.0353696868,
-0.0471925959,
-0.0102254916,
0.0300155655,
-0.0619489364,
0.0088554742,
0.0125087257,
-0.0195559226,
0.0207025837,
0.0233276989,
0.006519659,
0.0437041,
-0.0225654449,
-0.0164730437,
0.0073349518,
0.0927641019,
0.0020707499,
-0.0474083796,
0.0033610987,
0.0255036429,
-0.0888780951,
0.0139851058,
-0.006478454,
0.0072563211,
0.0284386463,
-0.019054411,
0.049859222,
0.0383552015,
0.0049563143,
0.0326767899,
0.0441543497,
-0.0184999909,
-0.0186775718,
-0.0026941434,
0.0107042827,
0.0177868418,
0.012373969,
-0.0097222095,
-0.0380400084,
-0.0171292722,
-0.0008430026,
-0.0018425437,
-0.0435379334,
0.034538947,
-0.021422077,
-0.0282959118,
-0.0867137164,
0.0470066443,
0.0156611912,
0.0281475876,
-0.040372517,
-0.040973559,
0.0389407985,
0.0044351872,
0.0455184579,
-0.001953966,
-0.0028816785,
-0.0153049342,
0.0756191835,
-0.0020829483,
0.0504761487,
-0.0260403827,
0.0362419151,
-0.0655003861,
-0.0125119938,
0.0763901398,
-0.0508726798,
0.0236296169,
-0.0453953668,
0.0083486801,
-0.0084318118,
-0.0126879383,
-0.0207788181,
-0.0088463882,
-0.0303316992,
0.0075542172,
0.0248881951,
0.0210723076,
0.0079511572,
0.0482281744,
0.0363283083,
-0.0243631247,
0.0388335213,
-0.0154607585,
0.0097295484,
0.0445968769,
0.0813875571,
-0.0118830064,
-0.0266150385,
-0.0437687635,
0.0070691383,
0.0302097015,
0.0116822971,
-0.0604767613,
-0.028164031,
0.0220621247,
0.052866336,
-0.0284904633,
-0.019386569,
-0.0313478708,
0.0180737525,
-0.0241303407,
0.0135075785,
0.0689055622,
0.0214121304,
-0.0523220226,
-0.0327400006,
-0.0064955959,
-0.0020758973,
0.0288103111,
0.0043432242,
-0.064996697,
-0.0351887904,
-0.0312383901,
-0.019825669,
0.0557820201,
0.005328849,
-0.0322046652,
-0.0662633404,
0.021011278,
0.001459048,
-0.0299839564,
-0.059922263,
-0.0061105937,
0.0096280817,
-0.0108019803,
-0.0561300889,
-0.0313839614,
0.0013722922,
0.0007867809,
-0.0052431333,
0.016892612,
-0.0449742898,
-0.0029322102,
-0.0784706548,
-0.0189370811,
0.0367458388,
0.0578414239,
0.0058552758,
-0.0638806745,
-0.048395209,
-0.0105680507,
-0.0252501667,
-0.0174210761,
0.0581351332,
-0.0471394584,
-0.0239350926,
0.0123509439,
-0.0298989974,
0.0204810239,
-0.0099660009,
-0.0252840202,
0.0552441329,
-0.0251089018,
0.0165738259,
-0.0461553931,
0.010646319,
-0.0077493032,
0.025565017,
-0.0154917417,
-0.007417249,
-0.0193025004,
0.0006281165,
0.0447345041,
-0.0260439478,
-0.0068899328,
-0.0213706549,
-0.0334426202,
0.0245556347,
-0.0574474819,
0.0010810603,
0.0473123193,
0.0580082461,
0.013047751,
0.0327298343,
-0.0177215487,
0.0268733464,
-0.0660827607,
0.0304270983,
-0.0303102136,
0.0206388664,
0.0121923564,
0.0081993043,
0.0377355516,
0.0014896465,
-0.0234693121,
0.0691901743,
-0.0418615155,
0.0148504209,
-0.0067142886,
0.0747266784,
0.0174252,
0.0177268721,
-0.0119864754,
-0.0156859793,
0.0341171436,
0.0074578943,
0.0417546928,
0.0114015043,
-0.0355052538,
-0.0103445183,
-0.0362885706,
0.0210320801,
-0.0354126133,
-0.0009925243,
-0.0392185636,
0.0169233494,
-0.0070438883,
-0.0328320414,
-0.0108010368,
-0.012623935,
0.0574526191,
-0.0492181219,
-0.0052854386,
-0.0507294796,
-0.0338614471,
0.0090340637,
-0.0288659334,
-0.0201255269,
0.0220536664,
-0.0160613805,
-0.009302197,
0.0004554914,
0.0574289002,
0.0294146463,
-0.014411822,
-0.0249207709,
-0.0405868217,
0.0456934348,
-0.0420978889,
-0.0565546118,
0.0293682031,
0.0137481485,
-0.0008884287,
-0.0287073664,
0.0073638866,
-0.0221703798,
0.0361881889,
0.0125816325,
-0.0155460127,
-0.0323988199,
0.0621100292,
0.0135840448,
0.0116989566,
-0.0068194554,
0.0402313285,
0.1229398027,
-0.0363344327,
0.0453096293,
0.0058394014,
-0.0366165452,
0.0109411133,
0.0253531504,
0.0023391119,
-0.0092290938,
0.031917274,
0.0116572399,
0.0128113497,
0.0160710793,
0.0433739796,
0.00118246,
-0.0125786113,
-0.0062333038,
-0.0650670156,
-0.006410778,
-0.0241421796,
0.0050032353,
0.0441448167,
-0.0140069276,
0.0036769628,
-0.0735346228,
-0.0862196982,
0.0151454881,
0.0403429307,
-0.0429699495,
0.0576275401,
0.062213473,
0.0427195989,
0.0384795703,
-0.0061592394,
-0.0368718356,
-0.0353355855,
-0.0383549742,
-0.0130708283,
0.0113999965,
-5.841549749e-33,
-0.0362365767,
-0.0281924009,
0.0095866229,
-0.008274558,
-0.0576192625,
0.0167875923,
0.0043447209,
-0.0059988894,
-0.0574672483,
0.0283907242,
0.0282900687,
0.0010540757,
0.0144635197,
0.0074854069,
0.0045683915,
0.0195278265,
0.0367422216,
0.0119693279,
-0.0134448083,
-0.0069689397,
0.0502596386,
0.0375698172,
0.0579579547,
-0.0208113324,
0.0423536487,
0.0365335606,
-0.0106933201,
0.0171977337,
0.0654149875,
0.0547360778,
-0.0211399328,
0.0549870133,
0.0143815503,
-0.0131449234,
-0.0017599426,
-0.0341719612,
-0.0592818148,
-0.0422777906,
0.0281837415,
0.0133389775,
-0.105361782,
0.0077874074,
0.0377660431,
-0.02294272,
0.0183036495,
-0.0035742836,
0.0760877281,
-0.0124152685,
-0.0560446754,
-0.014388415,
-0.0293098707,
0.0228755623,
-0.0233248342,
-0.0533023998,
0.0675255358,
0.0094857784,
0.0712137669,
0.0098891575,
-0.0685121492,
0.0693411231,
-0.0765087679,
0.0118850823,
0.0953566954,
0.0462366007,
-0.0108273514,
0.0784013569,
-0.0243225172,
-0.0709843934,
0.0348468199,
-0.0484116487,
0.0304210093,
0.0610308684,
0.0380173475,
0.0590244271,
0.0125190793,
-0.0250122398,
-0.0109283421,
0.0347304977,
-0.004311854,
0.0698456019,
-0.0061738212,
-0.0000106385,
-0.0013216758,
-0.0088154962,
-0.0671188831,
-0.0063599716,
-0.0335685946,
-0.015704846,
0.0187176708,
0.0100672692,
-0.0233190861,
0.0449571833,
0.0417273976,
-0.0282719452,
0.0372659601,
0.0224533454,
0.01362029,
0.0253968984,
-0.0020947596,
0.0149618918,
0.0127638811,
-0.0075470074,
0.0136814797,
0.0068015247,
0.0016688841,
-0.0057314229,
0.0074094059,
-0.0022155994,
0.0204303246,
0.0227317903,
-0.0335719138,
-0.0660938546,
-0.0444936343,
0.0029959553,
0.0165208988,
0.0145658599,
-0.0344501548,
-0.0054347352,
0.0388492309,
-0.0013810971,
0.0175251178,
-0.0703540444,
0.0175676215,
0.0074797273,
-0.0204489231,
0.0254326183,
-0.0329518579,
-0.0009717565,
-0.0198286008,
-0.0495148636,
-0.0184278376,
0.0131194703,
2.699e-7,
0.0921074599,
0.0212870296,
-0.0282252356,
0.044166062,
-0.0200066511,
-0.0128138196,
-0.0218079276,
0.0374357291,
-0.0485353023,
-0.0307652149,
0.0097752353,
0.0442024805,
0.0178261213,
0.0009447327,
0.0000848904,
-0.03783416,
0.0138638671,
0.0087517574,
-0.0336563364,
-0.0159694459,
0.0975102261,
0.0954485461,
-0.0029993362,
-0.0202352218,
-0.0368976295,
-0.046974577,
0.0995730981,
-0.0205374062,
-0.0151312836,
-0.0378785692,
0.0028447588,
0.0356584787,
-0.0178363863,
0.0409180447,
-0.0468178913,
-0.0343074501,
0.1008555293,
0.0268090554,
-0.0298588965,
-0.0069940453,
-0.0279083997,
0.045647122,
0.013401269,
-0.0366672315,
0.0658885986,
-0.0244719889,
0.0118593136,
-0.0184684806,
-0.0223527811,
0.0359423682,
0.0734611228,
-0.0239894427,
-0.083554998,
0.0147318877,
0.0191153754,
0.0126135359,
-0.0264200773,
-0.0851046965,
0.0141100446,
0.0109370444,
-0.0025638468,
0.0003747967,
0.0080577154,
-0.0739487559,
0.0319263563,
-0.0214384962,
-0.0728471354,
1.582339145e-34,
0.034967266,
-0.0067169969,
-0.0003798974,
-0.0271513537,
0.0335380659,
-0.0439009331,
-0.0435529426,
-0.0041949926,
-0.0025772643,
-0.0060265348,
-0.0085172383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07125v1 | Keeping the Questions Conversational: Using Structured Representations to Resolve Dependency in Conversational Question Answering | 2023-04-14T13:42:32 | 2023-04-14T13:42:32 | Munazza Zaib, Quan Z. Sheng, Wei Emma Zhang, Adnan Mahmood | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Having an intelligent dialogue agent that can engage in conversational
question answering (ConvQA) is now no longer limited to Sci-Fi movies only and
has, in fact, turned into a reality. These intelligent agents are required to
understand and correctly interpret the sequential turns provided as the context
of the given question. However, these sequential questions are sometimes left
implicit and thus require the resolution of some natural language phenomena
such as anaphora and ellipsis. The task of question rewriting has the potential
to address the challenges of resolving dependencies amongst the contextual
turns by transforming them into intent-explicit questions. Nonetheless, the
solution of rewriting the implicit questions comes with some potential
challenges such as resulting in verbose questions and taking conversational
aspect out of the scenario by generating self-contained questions. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework, CONVSR (CONVQA using Structured
Representations) for capturing and generating intermediate representations as
conversational cues to enhance the capability of the QA model to better
interpret the incomplete questions. We also deliberate how the strengths of
this task could be leveraged in a bid to design more engaging and eloquent
conversational agents. We test our model on the QuAC and CANARD datasets and
illustrate by experimental results that our proposed framework achieves a
better F1 score than the standard question rewriting model. | [
0.0645690784,
0.0102425432,
-0.0297050346,
0.022686623,
-0.0365714468,
-0.0085981498,
0.0091205481,
-0.007454359,
0.0181601886,
-0.0370660387,
-0.010896272,
0.0038453226,
-0.0374970771,
0.0699911416,
-0.0044253096,
-0.0771558359,
0.0300088413,
-0.0196269844,
0.0144294361,
-0.0155627262,
0.0173164308,
-0.0116760805,
-0.0116590904,
0.0338738784,
0.0056460495,
-0.0412362739,
-0.032664679,
0.0200212374,
-0.0028953282,
0.0068651135,
0.0511679947,
0.0458989292,
0.0369039699,
0.0098070586,
0.0000018244,
-0.0602385662,
-0.0118494527,
-0.0171661004,
-0.0472500846,
0.0002322087,
-0.0187993925,
0.007705173,
0.0315499306,
0.0071641416,
-0.0607459806,
0.0140409647,
0.0311674904,
0.0464663953,
0.0794098824,
0.0557971075,
-0.0126004005,
-0.0379986651,
0.0093647623,
0.014985377,
0.0168132409,
-0.0441474542,
-0.0084710028,
0.0624685511,
0.0197472032,
0.0347949602,
-0.0383030102,
0.0479131415,
0.0390368402,
-0.0186014604,
-0.0066769836,
0.0114231743,
-0.0461451896,
0.0064952523,
-0.0203939583,
0.1087708026,
0.0096173426,
-0.0158997029,
-0.0145750586,
0.0003500964,
0.0306896586,
-0.0042021782,
-0.0661232397,
-0.0041898573,
0.0060203867,
-0.0263087936,
-0.001032299,
0.0202834681,
-0.0260282662,
-0.0119231166,
-0.0246053301,
0.0443519764,
0.0230044462,
-0.0191773959,
-0.0482587367,
-0.0168822426,
-0.0055094501,
-0.0602434985,
0.0237768218,
0.0476937741,
-0.0314407535,
0.0271365903,
-0.0481295548,
0.0202829521,
-0.0050588264,
-0.0063692438,
-0.034402214,
0.0270637833,
0.0031691184,
0.0502573662,
-0.0050245426,
0.0619546808,
-0.0174113885,
0.0078267753,
-0.0411396697,
-0.0058332188,
-0.0456676446,
-0.0229898393,
-0.0622336231,
0.0547382534,
-0.0486753136,
-0.0094975727,
-0.0041497895,
0.0803961605,
0.0208229888,
-0.0040035956,
-0.0340211913,
0.0486072749,
-0.0221664347,
-0.0076499209,
-0.0516056046,
0.0442147069,
-0.0714817345,
0.0186624676,
0.0117991855,
-0.0339810252,
-0.0111907516,
0.0241443645,
0.0381253697,
-0.0201103222,
-0.0078041041,
0.0535727516,
-0.0126531255,
-0.0554235131,
0.0131683256,
-0.0379230119,
-0.0049971472,
-0.0438006446,
-0.022888653,
-0.0235216692,
0.0621644519,
0.0126158996,
-0.0338097587,
-0.0173824038,
0.0114960307,
0.0220645238,
0.0179078449,
0.0771406814,
-0.0034688783,
0.0049358802,
0.0400853716,
0.0121660475,
-0.0318014808,
0.017905904,
0.042090144,
-0.0039551347,
0.0653961971,
-0.0145179452,
0.0405271798,
-0.011583264,
-0.0129790381,
0.0027702702,
-0.0019699228,
0.0661275461,
-0.0440912731,
0.0338132195,
0.0254680905,
0.050044097,
-0.0119344853,
-0.0303564072,
0.0335633606,
0.033689864,
-0.0095660519,
0.0093693715,
0.0453509241,
0.0301280711,
0.0108790547,
0.0771623105,
-0.0301230289,
0.0507670641,
-0.0126251047,
0.0185504518,
-0.009312626,
-0.0043858909,
-0.0442737751,
-0.0538523495,
0.0385201536,
0.0231434293,
0.038794525,
0.0081053302,
-0.0133478288,
0.0222563706,
-0.0587139055,
0.0203142855,
-0.0219815783,
-0.0533407442,
-0.0065578036,
-0.0327308886,
0.0536944456,
0.0531181954,
0.0450806506,
-0.0309113823,
-0.0917884037,
-0.019383911,
-0.004541276,
0.0191586204,
0.027004702,
-0.0481735095,
0.0349607542,
-0.0375167504,
0.0119326338,
-0.0252431091,
-0.0125043131,
0.0140928403,
-0.0192487836,
-0.0066355937,
0.0172310024,
-0.0436223894,
0.0101473918,
0.0336471684,
-0.0035032681,
-0.0263273921,
0.0086039659,
0.0132570658,
0.0167965125,
0.0141934399,
0.0243869573,
0.0149217863,
0.0416147076,
-0.0310970396,
-0.0341924801,
0.0381409526,
-0.0492663495,
-0.0896487832,
-0.0037719661,
-0.0697508752,
-0.0221341178,
0.0386982299,
-0.0192523375,
-0.0658489168,
-0.0091648931,
-0.0547952354,
0.0419722535,
-0.039231807,
0.0000803124,
0.0358602777,
0.0158024356,
-0.0565559752,
0.0562165752,
0.018635422,
0.0173425563,
0.0270341076,
0.0042046895,
0.0052810679,
-0.0447427258,
0.0284761749,
-0.0250574052,
0.0153403338,
-0.0148191098,
0.0437324122,
-0.0008072021,
-0.0704514831,
-0.0008394169,
-0.0722230971,
0.0075552394,
-0.0231723469,
0.0004985977,
0.0632468387,
0.029662041,
-0.0029453693,
-0.0389011763,
-0.0762182176,
-0.0050164247,
-0.0013852771,
0.0126359351,
0.0721930936,
0.0315346681,
-0.0335571803,
-0.0431555323,
0.0042888187,
-0.0260521062,
0.0152969183,
0.0177692045,
0.0134434048,
-0.0469479822,
0.0017125763,
-0.0121574579,
0.0185148753,
-0.011659638,
-0.0284701083,
0.0177735239,
0.0046341387,
0.0430119224,
0.0625483096,
0.0107864356,
0.0052132062,
0.0232823733,
-0.0156682003,
-0.0423588753,
0.0409261063,
-0.0296857059,
0.0181261804,
-0.0055472786,
-0.0471277796,
0.0327222459,
0.0244721491,
0.0144571913,
0.037127465,
-0.056842532,
0.0296007898,
0.0299261697,
-0.025104383,
-0.0143300947,
-0.0015737409,
-0.02817454,
0.0579066612,
0.0029621068,
0.0079423562,
0.0896077082,
0.0130286301,
-0.04657102,
-0.0567096062,
0.0085117044,
-0.0471209735,
0.0563420057,
-0.0047728913,
0.0078709275,
0.0330932029,
-0.0631072372,
-0.0821273476,
-0.0008792646,
-0.0047391308,
0.0004104425,
0.0365749374,
-0.0370413437,
0.0025905624,
0.0326363929,
-0.0283582974,
-0.0551444516,
-0.0527692623,
-0.0131278262,
0.0168378316,
-0.004654631,
-0.0032713327,
-0.0091750817,
0.0269111544,
0.0060046809,
0.0323771685,
-0.0281816926,
-0.0107511114,
-0.0333555304,
0.0883011147,
0.0903086886,
0.0524303131,
0.0234732069,
-0.0088766646,
0.0881105587,
0.0408080518,
0.002390818,
-0.0112964334,
0.0130069517,
-0.0143624023,
0.0100897308,
-0.0504269898,
-0.0137004778,
0.0000046114,
0.0907864347,
-0.0596881583,
-0.0449273661,
0.1130105034,
0.0433574095,
-0.0031760617,
0.0231113434,
-0.0274769329,
0.0373600237,
0.0401684679,
0.0421685539,
-0.0830863267,
-0.0472259596,
-0.025264943,
-0.0070075323,
-0.0103053991,
-0.0346096046,
0.0043178094,
-0.0904944167,
0.0588221475,
-0.0250556078,
-0.0460720249,
-0.0281214602,
-0.0106784757,
0.0221925396,
0.0289982185,
0.0078053037,
0.0025378463,
-0.0078720525,
-0.0031563274,
-0.0263077002,
-0.0214620642,
0.0147867855,
0.040554788,
-0.0177189112,
0.0258747749,
0.048096396,
0.0355400667,
-0.0021191726,
-0.0018193297,
-0.0042361659,
-0.0474607386,
-0.0086239297,
0.003646337,
0.0372372456,
-0.0206271913,
-0.0110145388,
-0.0411064625,
0.0418718308,
-0.0096644079,
-0.0122516621,
0.0380599797,
0.0436183214,
-0.0424774662,
-0.010039893,
-0.0262484048,
0.0256940741,
-0.0060614143,
0.0790479258,
0.0376780741,
-0.0366105288,
-0.04958307,
-0.0174000189,
0.0129645457,
-0.0558787026,
0.002262739,
-0.0177338105,
0.010499754,
0.0468771756,
-0.0938963294,
-0.0997551009,
0.049916219,
0.0079514887,
-0.0294243898,
-0.0094197458,
0.0066803861,
0.0136795575,
-0.0106858443,
-0.0105608171,
-0.0113620805,
-0.0024968132,
-0.0263292529,
-0.0085049402,
0.011788439,
-0.0250233598,
-0.0219225865,
-0.006667308,
-0.0475549102,
-0.0411528684,
0.003061045,
0.0573162287,
0.0186100751,
0.0204755664,
-0.004694412,
-0.0255197529,
-0.0091785556,
-0.0093907788,
-0.0371271856,
0.0155420182,
0.0214455891,
0.0433409475,
-0.0142260212,
0.0645317286,
-0.043853458,
-0.010457024,
-0.0503161028,
0.088611193,
-0.0900449604,
-0.0785902813,
0.0411831364,
-0.0106859989,
-0.0267195683,
0.0215141717,
-0.0007867315,
-0.0121016707,
0.053336896,
-0.0561231524,
-0.0182748158,
-0.0458160341,
0.0359249227,
-0.0107394643,
-0.0019484382,
0.0048985658,
-0.0121555869,
-0.0770849138,
0.0279572699,
-0.0345204547,
-0.0004653712,
0.049876824,
-0.0135718109,
-0.0025101709,
-0.0072811125,
-0.0111990636,
0.0259562396,
0.0168914739,
0.065925613,
0.0219320972,
0.0774533227,
0.0139198266,
-0.0019042935,
-0.0350457281,
0.0376948975,
-0.1021251902,
-0.0393238664,
0.0424671434,
0.0430159159,
0.0099310372,
0.0206364077,
0.0305630714,
-0.0127930129,
-0.0022130685,
0.0200340673,
0.003886872,
0.0189664755,
-0.0242148191,
0.0853372589,
0.0471068397,
-0.0099732839,
0.0275695883,
0.0562177151,
-0.021991441,
0.0393276699,
0.0136218937,
0.0143850017,
-0.0593124181,
-0.0342188664,
-0.005685675,
0.0421398394,
-0.0011581259,
0.0310260039,
-0.0434261486,
-0.0500231162,
0.0301551782,
-0.0206363481,
-0.0089526549,
-0.0425063223,
0.0370698459,
0.0389989428,
0.0213240013,
-0.0647764355,
-0.0384594835,
0.0454239622,
-0.0241259541,
-0.0424673483,
-0.0513839163,
-6.242977764e-33,
-0.027135456,
-0.0140629411,
0.0215292815,
0.0043916418,
-0.0345661119,
0.0032660456,
-0.068948023,
0.0087420326,
-0.0319595411,
0.0167275388,
-0.0272981226,
0.0224847421,
0.000344314,
0.0143392785,
-0.0353118144,
-0.0638136193,
0.0232565943,
0.0158038922,
-0.0181721766,
0.026512919,
0.0287081078,
0.0243686549,
0.0080508552,
-0.0435587987,
0.0042873751,
-0.043639645,
-0.0226075463,
0.0359675549,
0.0166663416,
0.0514385253,
-0.016270496,
0.0064407615,
0.0307939481,
-0.0117053604,
0.0212392136,
0.0513949841,
-0.0673675463,
-0.0273162499,
0.0466873944,
0.0183254685,
-0.0865363777,
-0.0440204665,
0.0178654268,
-0.046920985,
0.0454008244,
-0.013831567,
0.0178038143,
0.0039000651,
0.0276052132,
-0.0114410538,
-0.0612932928,
-0.0108827204,
-0.0297598727,
-0.0574939027,
-0.0304775741,
0.0850071162,
0.0174067616,
0.0006533446,
-0.0135923447,
0.0022572514,
-0.0209054928,
0.0115958955,
0.0043951897,
0.0182690006,
-0.0037722858,
0.0211824607,
0.0275748055,
-0.0141781587,
-0.0042323,
-0.0061535779,
-0.0135085005,
0.017852135,
0.020963151,
0.0325869359,
0.0054955562,
0.040668238,
-0.0393095464,
0.0127355354,
0.0097476123,
0.0364353955,
-0.0247281063,
-0.0080212392,
-0.0534367934,
-0.0154896807,
-0.0327585116,
0.0216913801,
-0.0302357972,
-0.0452215523,
0.0401340127,
-0.0345230699,
-0.0105300173,
-0.0047906549,
0.0313923918,
-0.0473957136,
0.0257841088,
-0.0158502534,
-0.0177979711,
0.0450284183,
0.0200489145,
0.0525108278,
0.0004950392,
0.0589083061,
0.0453550741,
-0.0162524432,
0.0261444654,
0.0251269154,
-0.007638617,
0.031646207,
-0.0342152603,
-0.0207018703,
-0.010453755,
0.0021316442,
-0.0601089336,
0.0161160324,
0.0060872133,
0.067861937,
-0.0342585295,
0.0495756865,
0.0072073564,
0.0154908905,
-0.0539972372,
-0.0350054987,
-0.0021252304,
0.0547731221,
-0.0582720935,
-0.018465383,
-0.0110482015,
0.0124163898,
-0.0195013415,
-0.0740061775,
-0.0156964697,
0.0057785772,
2.589e-7,
0.0408905335,
0.0333456323,
0.0301685575,
0.0388208926,
-0.0228806213,
0.024400942,
0.0378320329,
0.0188356955,
0.0456827842,
-0.0419198461,
0.035187684,
0.0032039802,
-0.0128824897,
-0.0013848761,
-0.1273191571,
0.0227683596,
-0.0409528539,
-0.040927507,
-0.0190106239,
-0.0135477986,
0.1046931073,
0.0837154984,
-0.0073800865,
-0.0055673593,
-0.039028991,
-0.0164919943,
0.017879203,
0.0139694437,
-0.0316766612,
0.0357971527,
-0.0195201971,
0.007354443,
0.0031301493,
0.0244738646,
0.0150329918,
0.0144072594,
0.0271324087,
0.0626570284,
-0.0020414561,
-0.088456139,
-0.0191611703,
0.0109910546,
0.0171061289,
-0.0334315784,
0.0875841677,
-0.0260886922,
-0.0145684993,
0.0224457979,
-0.0485588759,
0.0161993466,
-0.0274457131,
-0.0120229954,
-0.0472925976,
0.0157599095,
0.0179336425,
-0.0083856229,
0.0213297494,
-0.0600359961,
-0.007795969,
-0.0024818522,
-0.0108987279,
-0.003301237,
-0.0244153496,
-0.0395566411,
0.0087507656,
-0.0343011729,
-0.0105358111,
2.388802886e-34,
0.0386979543,
0.0165744163,
0.0315917209,
0.0776263773,
0.0177034512,
-0.0145969065,
0.0000084456,
0.0000982883,
0.0712809339,
-0.1007254422,
-0.0246890299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07101v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07101v1 | Task-oriented Document-Grounded Dialog Systems by HLTPR@RWTH for DSTC9 and DSTC10 | 2023-04-14T12:46:29 | 2023-04-14T12:46:29 | David Thulke, Nico Daheim, Christian Dugast, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper summarizes our contributions to the document-grounded dialog tasks
at the 9th and 10th Dialog System Technology Challenges (DSTC9 and DSTC10). In
both iterations the task consists of three subtasks: first detect whether the
current turn is knowledge seeking, second select a relevant knowledge document,
and third generate a response grounded on the selected document. For DSTC9 we
proposed different approaches to make the selection task more efficient. The
best method, Hierarchical Selection, actually improves the results compared to
the original baseline and gives a speedup of 24x. In the DSTC10 iteration of
the task, the challenge was to adapt systems trained on written dialogs to
perform well on noisy automatic speech recognition transcripts. Therefore, we
proposed data augmentation techniques to increase the robustness of the models
as well as methods to adapt the style of generated responses to fit well into
the proceeding dialog. Additionally, we proposed a noisy channel model that
allows for increasing the factuality of the generated responses. In addition to
summarizing our previous contributions, in this work, we also report on a few
small improvements and reconsider the automatic evaluation metrics for the
generation task which have shown a low correlation to human judgments. | [
0.0535009876,
0.0197984502,
0.0100755775,
0.0182111524,
-0.0208891388,
-0.0120137762,
0.0101166498,
-0.0122014573,
0.0266581718,
-0.0826350823,
-0.0445186943,
0.0083693396,
-0.0322102755,
0.0397262312,
-0.0036669616,
-0.0591335557,
0.0384323075,
-0.0403341241,
0.0308676697,
-0.0138684371,
0.0089163883,
0.0217817426,
-0.0509853102,
0.0237545539,
-0.0299505387,
-0.0269695688,
-0.0250555854,
0.0014798898,
-0.0064039198,
-0.0419152528,
0.0346726552,
0.048360467,
0.037532825,
0.065756537,
0.0000020945,
-0.0545129105,
0.0162653327,
-0.0031316052,
-0.0864308998,
-0.0267367736,
0.0149473026,
0.0219364613,
-0.005728134,
0.0101179918,
-0.0227055233,
-0.0380056053,
0.0155058121,
0.0863229185,
0.0463762805,
0.0576586016,
-0.0225057881,
0.0054049687,
0.0307884589,
-0.0027266773,
0.0243354291,
-0.0368444547,
-0.0142134856,
0.0349276625,
0.046281375,
0.016076833,
0.0475842729,
0.0035252706,
-0.0167083517,
-0.0947119743,
0.0340477675,
0.0218860619,
-0.042604737,
0.0050765383,
-0.0189204905,
0.1001392603,
0.073655732,
0.0197506323,
0.0174801368,
-0.0039122049,
-0.0037968836,
-0.0235481039,
-0.0598838776,
-0.0188298635,
-0.0245663095,
-0.0238477699,
-0.0030096495,
0.0506379195,
-0.0332296751,
0.0236809626,
-0.0042889724,
0.052844882,
-0.0005535267,
-0.0499290414,
0.0354710072,
0.0163443051,
0.0212614927,
-0.058331266,
0.026706554,
-0.0067045032,
-0.0441989526,
-0.0007281871,
-0.04251948,
-0.0116583938,
-0.0062407847,
-0.042286709,
0.004463383,
0.0079203378,
-0.027616227,
0.0682004467,
0.0027916576,
0.0483478568,
0.0050553507,
-0.0189354401,
-0.0291851051,
0.0101100756,
-0.0165285282,
0.0118486797,
-0.0491712391,
0.0501529202,
-0.086853303,
-0.042170506,
-0.0087921927,
0.0368138887,
0.010719873,
0.0118018156,
0.0217048973,
0.0335075706,
-0.049058944,
0.0066007427,
-0.022088958,
0.0180920586,
-0.0100028608,
0.0273834392,
0.0198498126,
-0.0431805551,
-0.0018242653,
0.0589827746,
0.0443306156,
-0.027066106,
-0.01516842,
0.0520424284,
-0.0318675041,
-0.0148189459,
-0.0428825766,
-0.0179462805,
-0.0371099487,
-0.0568414181,
-0.0121413115,
-0.0052236798,
0.0206449516,
-0.0075136195,
-0.0396302193,
-0.0039696419,
0.0130635072,
0.0022555031,
0.0139659029,
0.0450331308,
-0.0029620607,
-0.0292581543,
0.0907160193,
0.0001339304,
-0.0578232408,
0.0578727536,
0.0331754647,
0.0280968752,
0.0400293842,
-0.0126142651,
0.0123007903,
0.0086679142,
0.0051350305,
0.0191451665,
0.0448712893,
0.0461599119,
-0.0529814623,
0.0195222888,
0.030308133,
0.0403726883,
-0.0524495989,
0.0284510124,
0.0667379573,
0.0630703494,
-0.0088068899,
-0.0102460384,
-0.0146914488,
0.0452864058,
0.0081186043,
0.0310934931,
-0.0184467435,
0.0134202847,
-0.002778342,
0.0227935966,
0.0296723787,
-0.0261368509,
-0.0357507691,
-0.0318697505,
0.0099758375,
0.0103652785,
0.0074109468,
-0.001141047,
0.0546446443,
0.0099426406,
-0.0671444982,
0.0228944439,
-0.0012301406,
-0.0752954558,
-0.0126416236,
-0.0418815389,
0.0301869791,
0.0541482903,
0.0635244027,
-0.0271259341,
-0.0632315204,
-0.0614106618,
-0.0106077492,
0.0761353672,
0.0450488888,
-0.0421324074,
0.0069379597,
-0.0673568919,
-0.0201645829,
0.0123632988,
-0.0059495727,
0.0347056836,
-0.0243181996,
0.0095681101,
0.0376001224,
-0.0168996714,
0.0029386582,
0.0083818659,
0.0258601513,
-0.0277041495,
0.0368379653,
0.0043908209,
0.08079274,
0.0493438505,
-0.0246708486,
-0.0152403535,
0.0402889885,
-0.0083323345,
0.0030244894,
0.0296023991,
-0.075597696,
-0.0489839837,
-0.001714075,
-0.0338683836,
-0.0107591329,
0.0079399552,
0.0013194586,
-0.0770488903,
0.041837804,
-0.0633010641,
0.0080828713,
-0.053763587,
0.0119615169,
0.0386395417,
-0.0121350717,
-0.0368133672,
0.0584273227,
0.0346203521,
-0.0276634805,
0.0573147871,
0.0040835105,
0.0256498288,
-0.06687323,
0.0133138327,
-0.0023211432,
-0.0101601612,
-0.0119733494,
0.022203302,
0.0080137886,
-0.0261927117,
-0.0142703298,
-0.0883544758,
-0.0274592135,
-0.0158351008,
0.0151742138,
-0.0039887801,
-0.0009079417,
-0.008996984,
-0.0323041715,
-0.0506685823,
0.0007480021,
0.0610974394,
-0.0275601391,
0.0188851692,
0.0191207901,
0.0145967482,
-0.0549592488,
0.0313658789,
0.0214424748,
0.0124530951,
0.0234978721,
-0.0041664485,
-0.0571039654,
0.0385796614,
-0.0092188371,
0.0475254431,
-0.0278310496,
-0.0035114703,
0.0337376371,
0.0052579213,
0.0292322841,
0.0388741121,
0.0385965519,
0.0497822873,
-0.0263296664,
-0.0108394455,
-0.072923705,
0.0380240269,
0.0073643434,
0.047533717,
-0.0067884242,
0.0226970129,
0.0438567959,
0.0208219718,
0.0243722051,
0.0179030616,
-0.0279961042,
-0.0012046891,
0.0098285088,
-0.0225707665,
-0.0008192501,
-0.044923529,
-0.0297945142,
0.047028441,
-0.0017941307,
-0.0300437268,
0.0630447417,
-0.0534210913,
-0.0343909413,
-0.0723912045,
0.0029601906,
-0.0086479364,
0.043879699,
-0.0465434529,
-0.0096807843,
0.0154316761,
-0.0573551208,
-0.0261366572,
-0.0325131081,
0.0298149511,
-0.0299519189,
0.0818673372,
-0.0391748957,
0.0312777422,
-0.033292789,
-0.0563455224,
-0.0599086508,
0.0010652324,
-0.0093034524,
-0.0220546573,
0.0474632606,
-0.0267722271,
-0.0374402702,
0.0169352181,
0.0253309626,
0.0908603519,
-0.0139237344,
0.0025548143,
-0.0212796237,
0.0580721498,
0.0427892245,
0.0247895978,
0.0081199063,
0.0123627577,
0.06910263,
0.0294072274,
0.0425973013,
-0.0129569834,
-0.0120883342,
-0.0435148366,
0.0329123959,
0.0026871928,
-0.0106926486,
-0.020393081,
0.0394689925,
-0.0491306372,
-0.0165644716,
0.1212551072,
0.015987698,
-0.0378937796,
-0.0346198194,
-0.046589762,
0.0082761412,
0.002718718,
0.0265637413,
-0.0541499369,
-0.0305307526,
0.0029631744,
0.0611461662,
-0.0052427803,
-0.0007145426,
0.0004450003,
-0.0705178604,
0.0846573189,
0.0079807052,
-0.0022972426,
-0.0464200079,
-0.0074476674,
0.00058492,
0.0060909721,
0.0280427318,
0.0003536629,
0.0196361691,
-0.0253763609,
0.0228304211,
-0.0029085418,
-0.02049453,
0.024487244,
0.0053105303,
0.056396421,
0.0613645054,
0.0533495359,
0.049419377,
-0.0297589488,
-0.0122523382,
-0.0047854413,
0.0021304921,
0.0072939969,
0.0155055271,
-0.0056965034,
-0.0082701687,
-0.0208816044,
0.0552647859,
-0.0063872398,
0.0186793972,
0.0479897335,
0.0399791822,
-0.0954248011,
0.0232945308,
-0.0123540582,
0.0357488133,
0.0381548069,
0.0705748275,
0.0251613483,
-0.0253993049,
-0.0364547968,
-0.0119464444,
0.030416375,
-0.062048614,
0.0233839322,
-0.0182106309,
-0.0002519286,
0.0212489832,
-0.1000708714,
-0.0515385717,
0.0182219967,
0.0378479436,
-0.0114658624,
-0.0240486972,
0.0206238907,
0.0293463189,
-0.0011900543,
0.0095258476,
0.0000283776,
-0.0075759781,
-0.0787762627,
-0.0210754108,
0.0393509306,
-0.0612576716,
-0.0147973998,
0.0391213261,
-0.0138058895,
-0.0570148677,
-0.0076892367,
0.0159741826,
0.0248116516,
0.0618969314,
-0.0163239334,
-0.0206557959,
0.0139542101,
-0.0036733663,
-0.0718340129,
-0.0124933682,
0.0711663738,
0.0092042796,
-0.0595872737,
0.0201434046,
-0.0555232801,
0.0468591638,
-0.0281463135,
-0.0071058553,
-0.0247748233,
-0.0851406455,
-0.0129208276,
0.0089677339,
0.0328387693,
0.0093645453,
0.0065910141,
-0.0402478874,
0.0695177391,
-0.0160941053,
-0.0156277977,
-0.035491962,
-0.0189973582,
-0.031763874,
-0.0157108679,
0.0211530011,
-0.0033827233,
-0.0716544166,
0.0646222606,
-0.024259029,
0.0199013222,
0.0176337585,
0.0265043005,
0.0021695639,
-0.0350848474,
-0.0408677161,
0.037361145,
0.0095550409,
0.0369912684,
-0.0155650415,
0.1043569893,
-0.0044985269,
-0.0469570532,
0.0694546178,
0.0086683594,
-0.0735560432,
-0.0067774029,
-0.0425284579,
0.0147106675,
0.0096188607,
0.001784125,
0.0548542701,
-0.0274092462,
0.0228409637,
-0.0278112777,
0.0197027232,
0.0188876521,
-0.0143475775,
0.0029966973,
0.0334533751,
0.0098055666,
0.0233369842,
0.0608096346,
-0.005779143,
0.0196513347,
0.0073987404,
-0.0063930093,
-0.0915360749,
-0.0660131946,
0.0082174223,
0.0312774181,
-0.003450131,
0.0327664986,
-0.0361837,
-0.0050135548,
0.0123452172,
0.0066251024,
-0.0236754026,
-0.0277989935,
0.081907697,
0.0357668474,
-0.0069377776,
-0.0114509817,
-0.0239761639,
0.0248728618,
-0.0391426422,
-0.0071920832,
-0.035443604,
-5.978803041e-33,
-0.0434180722,
-0.0173572805,
-0.0000832706,
0.0131094689,
-0.032337442,
-0.011731646,
-0.0407258943,
0.0042643012,
-0.0051591443,
0.0043135649,
-0.0195341483,
-0.019809911,
0.0131335035,
0.0625713393,
-0.0312552303,
-0.008493307,
0.0561431199,
-0.033734452,
-0.0051168734,
0.0641989931,
0.0424860306,
-0.0022270049,
0.0282088425,
-0.077888079,
0.0303276386,
-0.0056002503,
0.0138541209,
-0.0118885785,
0.0112266475,
0.034730766,
-0.013109114,
0.034726616,
-0.0106408168,
-0.0632538423,
-0.0107011497,
0.0347042009,
-0.0694758222,
-0.0256174337,
0.0021039555,
0.0325607471,
0.0025046882,
-0.0105855092,
-0.0235322434,
-0.016108999,
0.0025450867,
0.0148325656,
-0.0055958848,
-0.0222503915,
-0.0323553346,
-0.0155540397,
-0.0598938651,
0.0338106789,
-0.0354465209,
-0.0559591576,
-0.0164979119,
0.0911932066,
0.0092754653,
-0.0400693566,
-0.0656262413,
0.0280410983,
-0.0052002324,
-0.0000142981,
0.0376954675,
0.0121740438,
-0.004296069,
0.0655272976,
-0.0121223675,
-0.0012113407,
-0.0302446522,
-0.0496491604,
-0.0319638439,
0.0327893533,
0.0426213183,
0.0341938324,
-0.0008815671,
0.0007163665,
-0.0262102056,
0.0438818075,
0.0685836971,
0.0179808289,
0.025264116,
-0.0028693855,
-0.0564664416,
0.003934911,
-0.0139406873,
-0.0103141433,
-0.0108594028,
-0.0329982862,
0.0495554544,
0.029362753,
-0.0133129433,
-0.0392689593,
0.0427513681,
0.0137106823,
0.0341360196,
0.0165674742,
-0.0113513311,
0.0005388958,
-0.0167298187,
-0.0080123618,
-0.0279205181,
-0.0204518754,
0.0882019624,
0.0483753979,
0.0028481267,
0.0171449352,
-0.0199531429,
0.0051647825,
-0.0441752858,
0.0164961629,
-0.0097397473,
0.0782408044,
-0.0342653431,
0.019871546,
-0.0024577151,
-0.0319466293,
-0.0113058211,
0.0562935434,
-0.0408176519,
0.0069008507,
-0.0392116494,
-0.0445451736,
0.0200036261,
0.0232029743,
-0.0476753376,
0.0192439333,
0.0225484353,
-0.0406617522,
0.0145413149,
-0.0252859984,
0.0104532056,
-0.0016298908,
2.798e-7,
-0.0294154659,
0.024480721,
0.0439204685,
-0.0331986248,
0.0276882052,
0.0440724082,
0.0171164423,
0.0127895474,
0.0115711577,
-0.0311369635,
0.0218000356,
-0.0235051513,
0.0667535737,
0.013828042,
-0.1351627111,
-0.0653867498,
-0.0645658299,
-0.0332169309,
-0.0363480225,
-0.0107638706,
0.0485561937,
0.0538851582,
-0.0420118645,
-0.0114142084,
-0.0059248428,
-0.0179650169,
0.0052321972,
0.0043531959,
0.0084119942,
-0.00100685,
0.065949969,
-0.036424648,
-0.0443632826,
0.0411939621,
-0.0256084967,
0.0378200561,
0.0168611277,
0.0572936498,
0.0047715493,
-0.0399379842,
0.0026042194,
0.0172329005,
0.0247006752,
-0.0195286144,
0.0566058978,
-0.0363666676,
-0.0024876122,
-0.0310291853,
-0.0395157784,
-0.022016624,
-0.0170234237,
-0.0282512568,
0.0000260734,
0.009543716,
0.0119673749,
-0.0160212517,
0.0271045864,
-0.0802783668,
0.0315714292,
-0.0020237423,
-0.0542492308,
-0.0523814,
-0.0374162532,
-0.0223347936,
0.0337072387,
-0.002931284,
0.0029420215,
2.270212725e-34,
0.0273515433,
0.0043433518,
-0.0097095361,
0.0180270411,
0.0246230029,
0.000115519,
0.020453088,
-0.0181575771,
0.0570433065,
-0.0824258104,
-0.0078785885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07065v1 | SEA: A Scalable Entity Alignment System | 2023-04-14T11:39:07 | 2023-04-14T11:39:07 | Junyang Wu, Tianyi Li, Lu Chen, Yunjun Gao, Ziheng Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Entity alignment (EA) aims to find equivalent entities in different knowledge
graphs (KGs). State-of-the-art EA approaches generally use Graph Neural
Networks (GNNs) to encode entities. However, most of them train the models and
evaluate the results in a fullbatch fashion, which prohibits EA from being
scalable on largescale datasets. To enhance the usability of GNN-based EA
models in real-world applications, we present SEA, a scalable entity alignment
system that enables to (i) train large-scale GNNs for EA, (ii) speed up the
normalization and the evaluation process, and (iii) report clear results for
users to estimate different models and parameter settings. SEA can be run on a
computer with merely one graphic card. Moreover, SEA encompasses six
state-of-the-art EA models and provides access for users to quickly establish
and evaluate their own models. Thus, SEA allows users to perform EA without
being involved in tedious implementations, such as negative sampling and
GPU-accelerated evaluation. With SEA, users can gain a clear view of the model
performance. In the demonstration, we show that SEA is user-friendly and is of
high scalability even on computers with limited computational resources. | [
0.0003220228,
0.0430413075,
0.0016648466,
0.0375613682,
-0.013499476,
0.0215929206,
0.0245944466,
-0.020693766,
0.030802004,
0.0328034423,
0.0039837519,
0.0271231085,
0.021325022,
0.0294568874,
0.0153646609,
-0.0141646918,
0.0513817668,
0.0657490194,
-0.0056691137,
0.0030155454,
0.022308765,
0.035010986,
-0.027183881,
-0.0078071342,
-0.0110676792,
-0.0193677917,
-0.0276507046,
0.0373667032,
0.0584506765,
-0.0049045132,
-0.0135479728,
0.0157913361,
0.0121087646,
0.0708891898,
0.0000021486,
-0.0264447629,
-0.0187025573,
0.00908479,
-0.0606576316,
0.0289327912,
-0.0091176042,
-0.0182950143,
0.0247904006,
-0.0124163385,
-0.0191759784,
-0.0597850792,
0.0535575971,
0.0109631279,
0.0475948043,
0.0397951752,
-0.0331867412,
-0.0466245562,
0.0030405431,
-0.0170640536,
-0.0272935424,
-0.0708075091,
0.0364598334,
0.0358328074,
-0.0047970074,
-0.0395472534,
-0.0026461123,
0.076009199,
-0.000144591,
-0.0000518437,
0.0186999533,
0.0264603477,
-0.0041657612,
0.032910075,
0.0042273118,
0.0845598951,
-0.0259794015,
-0.0317413062,
0.0451777615,
-0.0104941558,
0.0097170556,
-0.002092856,
-0.0071869693,
-0.0296516269,
-0.0126168234,
0.0058171889,
-0.0524715409,
-0.0482618846,
0.0495558009,
-0.0343508907,
-0.0213119145,
0.0351481475,
0.0234510694,
-0.0145983417,
0.0042130696,
0.0203808397,
-0.0113378549,
-0.0667593852,
0.02964155,
0.0223583523,
-0.06916067,
0.0061190291,
-0.0753614381,
-0.0060942448,
-0.0035836515,
-0.0497301072,
0.0005579591,
0.0158196837,
0.0308399647,
0.0807253197,
-0.0372089446,
0.0587875471,
-0.0200586636,
0.0144577445,
-0.0185639486,
-0.0251054782,
-0.0571412854,
0.0120634418,
-0.0192588251,
0.0121331969,
-0.0078383498,
-0.0383516774,
-0.0572557449,
0.0152361663,
-0.0112032164,
0.0954116061,
0.0255207494,
0.0394697711,
0.0523705743,
0.0136248488,
-0.0345817283,
0.037321128,
-0.0591910928,
0.00040738,
-0.0220570955,
-0.0164703671,
0.0146726249,
-0.0078500239,
0.0445480049,
-0.0158409625,
0.0218396429,
0.0172665305,
0.0183415525,
0.0163561311,
-0.063689895,
-0.0147719458,
0.0278282799,
-0.0354923308,
-0.0309675094,
-0.0418524779,
0.1137039289,
0.0179290473,
-0.0451806933,
-0.073196657,
0.0099920388,
-0.0069291065,
-0.0330661014,
0.0691261664,
-0.042145066,
0.0410962105,
0.0559719466,
-0.035258092,
0.0097053833,
-0.0102477586,
0.0508079343,
-0.0268261917,
0.0227880925,
-0.0201397967,
-0.0517330319,
0.0413852036,
0.0590255819,
-0.0436880589,
0.0223395247,
0.0173074622,
-0.0165222175,
0.1065067798,
0.0086442465,
0.05702563,
-0.0034613968,
-0.0341215916,
0.0553273223,
0.035308782,
-0.0190048572,
0.010156312,
0.0309061576,
0.0011632978,
-0.0071969852,
-0.0387937352,
-0.064851433,
0.0164705701,
-0.010386995,
0.0301701333,
0.0190161448,
0.02369822,
-0.0361392945,
0.0222749021,
-0.0103472965,
0.015309033,
0.0094405171,
-0.0059415712,
0.0148329996,
-0.023189323,
-0.0418124795,
0.0539935976,
0.0013566362,
-0.0311106797,
-0.0094407238,
0.0206922852,
-0.014677139,
0.0877021477,
0.0539685562,
0.0287129674,
-0.0738783479,
-0.0011986186,
-0.0373401083,
0.0399408154,
0.0405354388,
-0.0186100211,
-0.0135023501,
-0.0614983402,
-0.0250313021,
0.0241455622,
-0.0315768458,
0.0326704495,
0.0698072389,
0.0272071846,
0.0197273176,
-0.0979176834,
-0.0242872778,
0.0369822383,
-0.0320798904,
0.0003055179,
-0.0384412445,
0.0491613448,
0.0046630492,
0.0422977172,
-0.0045336057,
-0.0210894849,
0.0284034107,
-0.0077903108,
-0.0004061706,
-0.0392154865,
-0.005911578,
0.0142317647,
0.0496640876,
-0.0175726749,
-0.0400358737,
0.0034857392,
-0.0470047072,
-0.0462860353,
-0.0307038128,
-0.0159111582,
0.0211645402,
0.0224551912,
0.0294077303,
-0.0037975134,
-0.0135606164,
-0.0069384165,
0.0674715713,
0.0122041004,
0.0156704746,
0.0023951903,
-0.0298341457,
0.0411137231,
-0.063093178,
-0.0289912634,
-0.0419627279,
-0.0003297695,
-0.0077320291,
-0.0182982329,
-0.0423893668,
-0.0595541112,
0.0538856275,
-0.11792849,
0.070765622,
0.030765336,
0.047852356,
0.0323572457,
0.0276282262,
-0.0017593839,
-0.0200902615,
-0.052925054,
0.0125661055,
0.007902585,
-0.0037393114,
0.0405730456,
-0.0045506358,
-0.0388733409,
-0.0323055834,
-0.0262434073,
-0.047669258,
0.0402497612,
0.0433463566,
-0.0451760031,
-0.0324362256,
0.0395928137,
-0.0729343817,
0.0292268768,
0.0349208154,
0.0221419912,
-0.0114445211,
0.053078074,
0.0116088223,
0.0509101897,
-0.0350460969,
-0.0353867896,
-0.0208511911,
-0.0008965688,
-0.0720885247,
0.0121702561,
0.0037531962,
0.009402385,
-0.0097346678,
-0.0244176406,
-0.0323155597,
0.0274893008,
0.0082937013,
0.01999796,
-0.0618851185,
0.0264087934,
0.022417333,
0.0427641161,
-0.023558531,
-0.0065886807,
0.0497462712,
-0.0525973029,
-0.0632663071,
0.0174524095,
0.0746012926,
-0.0254243929,
0.0198626053,
0.0296841748,
0.0023188461,
-0.0126551613,
0.0492877401,
0.0077814846,
0.0387545936,
-0.0302311294,
-0.0317240246,
-0.0109629417,
0.0228345282,
0.0303833969,
-0.0415369049,
0.0294215828,
-0.0056187538,
0.059765216,
-0.0230618361,
-0.0327809714,
-0.0454826318,
0.0321400799,
-0.0255462844,
0.0125228157,
0.0180531666,
-0.0318931118,
-0.0833952129,
0.0314462259,
-0.005547646,
0.0166533757,
0.0133760972,
0.0064669787,
-0.0274353623,
0.0135238776,
0.0519404933,
-0.0058552581,
0.0197154954,
0.0045357896,
0.0026963369,
0.0262248125,
-0.0034209338,
-0.0190926306,
-0.0357007533,
-0.0473859385,
-0.0224084277,
-0.0951297283,
0.0271737874,
-0.0146980844,
0.0144001124,
-0.0356938094,
0.0447207205,
0.0953940749,
0.0064999922,
-0.0136619313,
-0.0140059367,
0.0151749682,
-0.0038482235,
0.0407170355,
0.0156400055,
-0.0828396752,
-0.0223526247,
-0.0059285308,
0.0151825929,
0.0613532029,
-0.0720756724,
0.0125857722,
-0.0861297473,
-0.0400939547,
0.0083204638,
-0.0486311391,
-0.0743707195,
-0.0357747786,
0.0243801642,
-0.032190036,
-0.0001969219,
0.0161414072,
0.0248334501,
-0.0058627641,
-0.0202368777,
0.0144756148,
0.0074981945,
0.002600271,
-0.1033787653,
0.0651806369,
0.0082932422,
0.0276636835,
0.0398745164,
-0.0248479526,
-0.0196838807,
0.0240942426,
-0.0321959145,
0.0116142202,
0.0550593548,
-0.0476488322,
-0.0061402423,
-0.0470131673,
0.0165788177,
-0.0451534614,
0.0192392077,
0.0137431761,
0.0576573871,
0.0252541713,
-0.0082733706,
0.0009844855,
-0.0308940243,
0.0086975135,
0.0639198199,
-0.0023017887,
0.005633872,
-0.0290652439,
0.0053986539,
0.0259285495,
-0.0208750479,
-0.0056581739,
0.0611656792,
-0.0384854861,
-0.0069368663,
-0.0240769126,
-0.0171795301,
0.017071452,
-0.0063452045,
0.0390085354,
-0.0297415666,
0.0440985374,
-0.0388172492,
-0.0938238129,
0.0037473114,
-0.0489649586,
0.0215154588,
-0.0321791582,
0.0063380632,
-0.0175009556,
0.0137641281,
-0.0434910506,
0.0114928121,
-0.0831620693,
-0.0659260005,
-0.0204637144,
-0.0309825893,
0.0061612413,
0.0481676236,
-0.0127693098,
0.0193456169,
0.0203654543,
0.0302166101,
-0.058175955,
0.0021118952,
-0.0514346622,
-0.0235714093,
-0.0115287248,
0.0230399389,
-0.0523240566,
-0.003141548,
0.0178969372,
0.0243090782,
-0.0456734039,
-0.0626562089,
-0.0082004564,
0.0473003387,
-0.0023604042,
0.0255421158,
-0.0233580358,
-0.0347613953,
0.0036726936,
-0.0049430626,
0.0171787553,
0.0124620767,
-0.0494642928,
0.0066427868,
0.0286887456,
-0.0039374228,
0.0075330194,
0.0595021509,
-0.0357216522,
-0.0503033958,
-0.049985975,
-0.0179793816,
-0.0170187056,
0.0187570639,
-0.0275378544,
-0.0375768542,
0.0515231378,
0.0186605286,
0.0616382286,
-0.065032661,
-0.0084958822,
0.0353204086,
0.02080312,
-0.0319464765,
0.0114818383,
-0.0038214442,
-0.0207184851,
-0.0042366763,
0.0190412309,
0.0841226652,
0.0179984663,
0.0418000966,
0.0008124192,
-0.0066720592,
-0.0096496772,
0.0026129647,
-0.0379293486,
-0.0087699099,
0.004067577,
0.0037731617,
0.0045813257,
0.0149672236,
0.0209557097,
-0.0014495681,
0.0689065829,
-0.041140005,
-0.0521238744,
-0.0583262518,
-0.0484455451,
0.0047042924,
-0.0003392262,
-0.0386647545,
-0.0586919934,
0.0086708991,
-0.0573290288,
0.0149943978,
0.0579482503,
-0.0413261242,
0.0330860391,
0.0315169618,
-0.0000973631,
0.0075880429,
-0.0490371808,
0.0342689566,
0.0628806502,
-0.0781560689,
-0.034492638,
0.0032662391,
-6.008187461e-33,
-0.045936659,
-0.0177852158,
0.0600925088,
-0.0315219946,
-0.026873121,
0.0104384767,
-0.0346705578,
-0.0188827794,
-0.0449008979,
0.0099797361,
-0.0159083549,
0.0146608464,
0.0146450782,
-0.0086548803,
-0.0086168619,
-0.0512575246,
0.035064429,
0.0238402151,
0.0004725429,
-0.0047857296,
0.0105723115,
0.0391902179,
0.0392717272,
-0.0929257199,
0.0083886059,
-0.0232922155,
0.0055014943,
0.010658781,
0.0284420196,
0.0281446297,
-0.0120703951,
0.0079887426,
-0.0028695927,
0.0032203707,
0.0168848764,
-0.0145236636,
-0.1128471121,
-0.0202254858,
0.0161501262,
0.0493744574,
-0.0252551623,
-0.0093802568,
0.0682542995,
-0.0036132913,
0.0255135112,
-0.0169363543,
0.0510896295,
0.0184904803,
-0.0079973843,
-0.0283455141,
-0.0333021097,
0.0303174835,
-0.0123820491,
0.0258074962,
0.0182735957,
-0.0219320673,
0.0166773479,
-0.0394908786,
-0.1086916476,
-0.0010865269,
-0.0313194804,
-0.0086218435,
0.0716146454,
0.0324896351,
0.0160905495,
0.0359410904,
0.0067731971,
-0.0546164177,
-0.0215630718,
0.0332980603,
-0.0083495267,
0.0275953412,
0.0043441569,
0.015718447,
-0.0048361947,
-0.0238247495,
-0.0869653821,
0.0398583412,
-0.0013687167,
0.0073028896,
-0.0195365641,
0.0076112235,
-0.035374973,
0.0014341412,
-0.0193345565,
-0.0292099845,
-0.024153769,
-0.0469989181,
0.0315834545,
-0.030233698,
-0.010423718,
0.0424104035,
-0.0107310237,
-0.0564815216,
-0.0210763533,
0.0452574752,
0.062579073,
0.0078488886,
-0.0101660108,
0.009353945,
-0.0380782261,
-0.0347500816,
-0.0053200838,
0.0028008176,
0.0525885858,
0.0373814404,
0.036713399,
-0.0206558034,
-0.0491776019,
0.0129330149,
-0.0083268285,
-0.0231622923,
-0.0706724972,
-0.0330104977,
0.053605631,
0.0345290378,
0.0364364497,
-0.0042180442,
0.0669207647,
0.0030865131,
-0.0046806275,
0.0228723362,
0.0458245389,
0.0205425601,
-0.0132727446,
0.0220466163,
-0.026808165,
-0.0006567552,
-0.016945295,
-0.0603145845,
0.0071312971,
0.0184146427,
2.843e-7,
0.0349183902,
0.0077945907,
0.0753429756,
0.0241807438,
-0.0113863843,
0.0109335994,
0.042343244,
0.0278351884,
-0.030249143,
-0.0164639708,
0.0711956024,
0.0357383043,
-0.0080775209,
0.0424306765,
-0.0584666803,
-0.0265932046,
-0.0411795639,
0.01891746,
-0.0599726997,
0.0597147644,
0.024625089,
0.0428737514,
0.0596494712,
0.0243498832,
0.025158653,
-0.0020586066,
-0.0106826145,
-0.0064973771,
0.0301635973,
0.0263186712,
0.000426831,
-0.0112284441,
-0.0428875051,
0.0789996088,
0.0183524136,
0.053966172,
0.0222393647,
0.0539446734,
-0.0386613086,
0.0545761995,
-0.0579674281,
-0.072507225,
0.0020229442,
-0.0612803251,
0.039229665,
-0.0006410165,
0.012775097,
0.0084267035,
-0.0285712872,
0.0103945751,
0.0054874592,
0.0513148345,
0.0189417452,
0.0043300251,
0.0390209481,
-0.0207592119,
-0.0414226614,
-0.0577955581,
-0.006219015,
0.0224746186,
-0.0260510035,
0.0007604569,
-0.0223660376,
-0.0127104316,
0.042736873,
-0.0348524749,
0.0019624587,
2.401659166e-34,
-0.0367944129,
0.0230230987,
0.014260185,
-0.000182598,
0.0503415689,
-0.034250211,
-0.0412682071,
0.02022787,
-0.029898569,
-0.0598891154,
0.023291694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08247v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08247v2 | MedAlpaca -- An Open-Source Collection of Medical Conversational AI Models and Training Data | 2023-04-14T11:28:08 | 2023-10-04T23:28:00 | Tianyu Han, Lisa C. Adams, Jens-Michalis Papaioannou, Paul Grundmann, Tom Oberhauser, Alexander Löser, Daniel Truhn, Keno K. Bressem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) like OpenAI's GPT series continue to make
strides, we witness the emergence of artificial intelligence applications in an
ever-expanding range of fields. In medicine, these LLMs hold considerable
promise for improving medical workflows, diagnostics, patient care, and
education. Yet, there is an urgent need for open-source models that can be
deployed on-premises to safeguard patient privacy. In our work, we present an
innovative dataset consisting of over 160,000 entries, specifically crafted to
fine-tune LLMs for effective medical applications. We investigate the impact of
fine-tuning these datasets on publicly accessible pre-trained LLMs, and
subsequently, we juxtapose the performance of pre-trained-only models against
the fine-tuned models concerning the examinations that future medical doctors
must pass to achieve certification. | [
0.0201836061,
0.1111712456,
-0.010652923,
0.0016818388,
-0.0301374849,
0.0087754205,
0.0405822992,
0.012764493,
0.0212257411,
0.0093373731,
-0.0231558494,
-0.0310392771,
0.0135248331,
0.0586347654,
-0.0023879511,
-0.0379145779,
0.0191496573,
-0.0071393326,
0.0402466841,
-0.0043210089,
-0.0258652437,
0.0120052015,
-0.053973712,
0.0807980448,
0.0264475271,
-0.0095397923,
-0.0027245902,
-0.0231973436,
0.0182994138,
-0.0565788597,
-0.0140205193,
0.046526514,
-0.0130215101,
0.0367091596,
0.0000020148,
-0.0350710303,
-0.0043930416,
0.0289395098,
-0.0710405409,
-0.0310240258,
0.0153960269,
-0.0630732849,
0.0100476751,
0.0228376053,
-0.0588293113,
-0.0311803073,
0.039597977,
0.0435617864,
0.0591684692,
0.0753527284,
-0.0109558916,
0.0253550392,
0.0343144089,
-0.0376125835,
-0.0113029601,
-0.070285514,
0.0244826712,
-0.0448166542,
-0.0062207859,
-0.010178104,
0.0194993168,
0.0256327465,
-0.0137541275,
0.0350351073,
-0.0163646117,
0.0385194682,
-0.0450191237,
-0.0346649438,
-0.0275020078,
0.0727469176,
-0.0093627693,
-0.0255849194,
0.0101701822,
0.0070722317,
0.0019706129,
-0.0338640846,
-0.0434067994,
0.0419397652,
-0.0068905517,
0.0169942807,
-0.0019274419,
-0.0235427152,
0.0334637836,
0.0120238103,
0.0087939426,
-0.0001271737,
0.0097038308,
-0.0138864284,
0.0090888767,
-0.0236595366,
-0.0087385606,
-0.0507534556,
0.0325727686,
0.0218179561,
-0.0286683477,
0.0039316313,
-0.0593610629,
-0.0303967316,
0.0622884557,
-0.0156305116,
0.0293654446,
0.0111337192,
-0.0078363856,
0.0276629962,
0.000594263,
-0.0004173483,
-0.015386817,
0.0558976829,
-0.0036914046,
0.0068459972,
-0.0226117354,
0.0085975621,
-0.0047998661,
0.0233774651,
-0.0137222325,
0.0152784297,
-0.0842976049,
0.004662653,
-0.0240334943,
0.0503181554,
0.0113835018,
0.0370602421,
-0.0292681493,
-0.0079179229,
-0.0058018188,
-0.0179288965,
0.012785932,
0.0323192105,
-0.0024216718,
-0.0769990534,
-0.020103015,
0.0008059171,
0.0173541568,
0.0181229692,
0.0075200517,
0.0534241386,
0.043910075,
-0.0395566039,
0.0272801369,
-0.0499665104,
0.002461164,
-0.0177092869,
0.0407160558,
-0.035108,
0.0411032327,
-0.0118038543,
0.0128667708,
-0.0743689537,
0.0151241077,
0.026668746,
-0.050216116,
0.0835064277,
-0.0429514535,
0.0145874927,
-0.0048816833,
0.0455915146,
0.0205463022,
-0.0145775564,
0.0507633239,
-0.0456481539,
0.0366040207,
-0.0450023711,
0.0454608612,
0.0044842362,
0.0557619072,
-0.0424178466,
0.0207436047,
0.0306375194,
0.0396435745,
0.0675368384,
-0.044049371,
0.0660166815,
0.0158188473,
-0.0522943363,
0.0443238914,
0.1088384241,
-0.002720261,
-0.0102275722,
-0.019415779,
-0.0241400804,
0.0079773236,
-0.0335946344,
-0.0244668089,
-0.0047887005,
-0.0015463721,
-0.0295225196,
-0.044274196,
0.002385777,
-0.0443746671,
-0.0207658317,
-0.0385101326,
-0.063761279,
-0.0407530703,
0.0066755945,
0.012386336,
-0.0045251525,
-0.0128305089,
0.0615540184,
0.0491547063,
-0.0790126026,
-0.0515068024,
-0.1042729169,
0.020648038,
0.0760533437,
0.0502192862,
-0.0321570747,
-0.0110487128,
-0.049126856,
0.0087907007,
0.0240193624,
0.0034347828,
-0.0081180222,
0.0749398619,
-0.0614049472,
0.0071316222,
0.0259662829,
0.0219748635,
-0.0047778869,
0.0068203593,
0.0141193019,
-0.0217823666,
-0.0227415282,
-0.0165949427,
0.0498853996,
-0.0570625551,
-0.0386404991,
0.0315179676,
0.0026022834,
0.0722515956,
0.0218535531,
-0.0091844779,
0.0161861721,
0.0353604481,
-0.0010133006,
0.0234613344,
0.0029768476,
-0.0126053169,
0.0377760194,
0.0041142823,
-0.0416507721,
0.0140898321,
0.0239773635,
-0.0470570587,
-0.0232619029,
-0.0347373486,
0.0034028676,
0.0503265783,
-0.0051441491,
0.0174662601,
0.0225299969,
0.0298476182,
-0.0032531302,
-0.0311747622,
-0.0261963811,
-0.0149594368,
-0.0051023741,
-0.0327989869,
0.0245778169,
-0.0471227132,
-0.0230933279,
0.0013207288,
-0.0158377346,
0.0230898224,
-0.0346537493,
0.0149400607,
-0.0157704614,
-0.0280132275,
-0.122753337,
-0.0098621901,
0.0093590794,
-0.0060690949,
0.0163387936,
0.0373263881,
-0.0132206604,
-0.0388998836,
-0.0377289914,
-0.0007630175,
0.0214357171,
-0.003982503,
0.0082880678,
0.0300716013,
-0.0017847854,
-0.0293528233,
-0.0115434853,
-0.0250897873,
0.0258127004,
-0.0035728426,
0.0082617588,
0.0152895385,
0.0244769473,
-0.027501747,
0.032755319,
-0.0247784331,
-0.0430120565,
0.0377889276,
-0.0048554861,
-0.0540369302,
0.0788852945,
-0.0068312879,
0.0083093345,
0.0447593965,
0.0080174552,
-0.0169251245,
0.0069618421,
-0.018461667,
-0.0565539561,
0.0112541793,
-0.0084112519,
0.0024025135,
0.0548968315,
0.0021496336,
-0.0032674305,
-0.031275101,
0.0115366904,
-0.0012396738,
0.0023403,
-0.0251962338,
0.0263799932,
-0.0357910544,
0.0614321269,
0.0126925772,
-0.0537327453,
0.074505128,
-0.0261098649,
0.0321089998,
-0.0346908793,
-0.0300306361,
-0.0351590253,
0.0367957726,
-0.0145215178,
0.0255068261,
0.0366448946,
-0.0192652382,
0.0071191574,
0.0211815536,
-0.024132736,
-0.0800893381,
0.0157757457,
-0.0297579803,
-0.0096927918,
-0.0012920049,
-0.0691602901,
-0.0538789853,
-0.0153801348,
-0.040550828,
-0.0014913874,
-0.0296721496,
-0.0091841761,
-0.0396991745,
-0.0015459383,
-0.0329048932,
0.0584121458,
0.0342315659,
-0.0076386426,
-0.0066108187,
-0.0004765908,
0.0221634451,
0.0084623722,
-0.0061294432,
-0.00819543,
0.0413407721,
0.0639997944,
0.0373731628,
0.0332278907,
0.0016237621,
-0.0334062576,
-0.0023022776,
-0.0160356723,
0.0196134225,
0.0458254702,
0.0252135321,
-0.0476295054,
-0.0088339988,
0.0992763713,
0.0165969748,
-0.0724122301,
0.0200976431,
0.0169843566,
-0.0169717893,
-0.0335006006,
-0.0116247619,
-0.113604553,
-0.0220810547,
0.0211770944,
0.0709650293,
-0.0391113721,
-0.0189742502,
0.0044283802,
-0.060442809,
0.0372947119,
0.0019312992,
-0.039989002,
-0.0176699124,
-0.0532123446,
-0.003163764,
-0.0333358347,
0.0240139738,
-0.0279893279,
0.0043192478,
-0.021477012,
-0.0216388535,
-0.0510918424,
-0.0889447555,
0.0415436104,
-0.0150275547,
0.0772929192,
0.0780556798,
0.0422982685,
-0.0105489632,
-0.0433490574,
0.0029258742,
0.0209179763,
-0.015152893,
0.0082335407,
0.083163172,
0.0031606008,
-0.0076735145,
-0.0399737544,
0.0932040513,
-0.0572975874,
-0.0168844294,
0.0225255378,
0.0430039167,
-0.0423406214,
-0.0300605893,
-0.0257157758,
0.0120144924,
0.020611627,
0.0568764061,
0.0038236089,
-0.0150985774,
-0.0098452019,
-0.0018003458,
0.0705246031,
0.0059927357,
-0.0111348629,
0.0330760032,
0.0342475846,
-0.0545976497,
-0.0370234922,
-0.0229619388,
0.0316875465,
-0.0161230117,
0.0325554796,
-0.0038709349,
0.0306453817,
0.0225565955,
-0.0485967062,
0.0751008689,
-0.0068282341,
-0.0027072141,
-0.0839067101,
-0.0439791642,
0.0399635136,
-0.0033716953,
-0.0129558742,
0.0191940404,
-0.0344366208,
-0.0167355817,
0.0299381241,
0.0799153596,
0.0244785938,
0.0128867086,
-0.0199789684,
-0.0308582205,
0.026680598,
0.0444048084,
-0.0676507875,
0.0063668797,
0.0263065509,
-0.0243966337,
-0.0109465038,
0.0231671184,
0.0005949397,
0.0129057309,
0.0207792018,
-0.0374202468,
-0.0144197717,
-0.0629607141,
0.0166178122,
0.0475931242,
0.0696959347,
0.0217421222,
0.0042208857,
-0.0409383625,
0.0472829752,
-0.0242843833,
0.040506918,
-0.0400403291,
-0.0072103166,
0.032959491,
-0.0072682397,
-0.0012642478,
-0.0196447186,
-0.0636239946,
-0.0263760779,
-0.0647637993,
0.0514426939,
0.02608959,
0.0063018771,
0.0278763399,
-0.0180134475,
-0.0129392017,
0.062506184,
-0.0325099751,
0.0409965627,
0.0046879854,
0.0560713783,
-0.0255211163,
0.038055025,
0.0347725004,
0.09303312,
-0.0541409813,
-0.0687837154,
-0.0052678804,
0.0580385029,
0.0218927618,
0.0223529991,
0.0055230875,
-0.0250212252,
0.0268332791,
-0.0136789475,
0.054610081,
-0.0337315388,
-0.00628667,
0.0391378999,
0.0105616339,
-0.0089053875,
-0.0095658638,
0.0963771343,
-0.026785139,
0.0786917657,
0.0061107296,
-0.0147557883,
-0.0537154004,
-0.0411018096,
0.0131694442,
0.0253720358,
-0.0483433269,
0.0096526602,
-0.036736764,
-0.0457794294,
-0.0048052785,
-0.0066929953,
-0.0138699058,
-0.0266967658,
0.0513807684,
0.0251560137,
-0.0012025769,
-0.0181829929,
-0.0118243666,
0.0011097676,
-0.0349225812,
-0.038692534,
0.0227888171,
-5.82523205e-33,
0.0102071902,
-0.0079362979,
0.0144003322,
0.0032871556,
0.0284912717,
0.0423605107,
-0.0249639004,
-0.0003694016,
-0.0349888317,
-0.0031365552,
-0.046865467,
0.0321226642,
0.0186604206,
0.0542393252,
-0.0010157791,
-0.0325110033,
0.0301464535,
-0.0188719612,
-0.0178419594,
0.0503124185,
-0.003018169,
0.0332197547,
0.0153141264,
-0.0865421742,
0.0206474196,
0.0108908303,
-0.0086162081,
0.0013130442,
-0.0673815981,
0.0625663102,
-0.0384266675,
0.0119404308,
0.0347856469,
0.0199745204,
0.0179485269,
0.0107249776,
-0.0456812866,
0.0223371424,
-0.0280751921,
-0.0006753091,
-0.0326936655,
-0.0622878782,
0.0392895043,
-0.0312888809,
-0.0393755808,
-0.013018433,
0.0028274308,
-0.0354677476,
-0.0042015552,
-0.0204696152,
0.0114790779,
0.0242918618,
-0.0248995814,
-0.0339419842,
0.0137252957,
-0.0206257794,
-0.0470115282,
0.0111911977,
-0.0195504446,
0.0236523505,
0.0507052764,
-0.0043122862,
0.0033991947,
-0.0487488657,
0.0045168702,
0.0344411284,
0.0554977283,
-0.0279864408,
-0.0113687962,
0.0044829152,
-0.0410460494,
0.058171887,
0.0763479769,
-0.0022790222,
-0.0037095083,
-0.0478335321,
-0.08889696,
0.0200302061,
-0.050138697,
0.0270145442,
0.0231720544,
-0.0278692022,
-0.076573804,
0.0117996512,
-0.0202510804,
-0.0361769348,
-0.0137727056,
0.0136335511,
0.0330609754,
0.0064269807,
0.0029823803,
-0.0098500513,
0.0091301966,
-0.0342573673,
0.0462024361,
-0.01218131,
0.0623308159,
-0.0076628923,
-0.0399812423,
-0.0134041309,
-0.0557884052,
-0.0271031465,
0.0361723155,
-0.0203833152,
0.0751202777,
0.0185170118,
0.0205989126,
-0.001004188,
-0.0555745177,
-0.00302982,
0.0049441215,
0.0186400581,
0.0228427537,
0.0429228991,
0.0426873453,
0.0017426673,
0.0193990711,
0.0508349501,
-0.0189919844,
0.0092576165,
-0.0767572746,
-0.0334728844,
-0.0048272568,
-0.0080276914,
-0.0478563085,
-0.0230566747,
-0.0342420675,
0.0390822925,
0.0530968606,
-0.025405461,
-0.0121194543,
-0.0191886462,
2.759e-7,
0.038069021,
0.0265638176,
0.022572754,
-0.0057325009,
0.0217277836,
0.030272074,
-0.0095509076,
0.0422846042,
-0.0136945341,
-0.0086706597,
0.0190867856,
0.0034589367,
0.0573201925,
0.0280455053,
-0.0649621114,
-0.0311167985,
-0.0724667907,
-0.0108952373,
-0.0464746729,
-0.0409106016,
0.0259253737,
0.1005803868,
-0.0257702991,
-0.0324276239,
0.0164192468,
-0.0021534108,
0.0454007089,
-0.0496100076,
0.0054025538,
0.0167053416,
0.0263132676,
0.0353943743,
-0.0013028036,
0.011922894,
-0.0209568981,
-0.0042935028,
-0.0259566717,
0.1308779567,
-0.046793554,
-0.006733139,
0.0248859804,
-0.006303987,
-0.0031367284,
-0.0315963291,
0.0680059046,
-0.0162702929,
-0.0732607171,
-0.0301577281,
0.0358474441,
-0.0514855608,
0.0656909645,
-0.0258836988,
0.0066367444,
0.0077672089,
0.0107292496,
0.0039709629,
-0.0024151935,
-0.0688076243,
-0.0300437007,
-0.0347364582,
-0.0205271691,
-0.0421709828,
0.0526074991,
-0.0216310527,
-0.0048928442,
-0.0514554456,
0.0341005512,
2.293668199e-34,
0.0091477269,
-0.0101015214,
0.0085145207,
0.0346505716,
0.0199947152,
-0.0250005648,
0.0682618618,
0.0036540909,
0.0211906079,
-0.0562548265,
-0.0191078316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07022v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07022v2 | Label Dependencies-aware Set Prediction Networks for Multi-label Text Classification | 2023-04-14T09:31:17 | 2024-03-14T02:56:32 | Du Xinkai, Han Quanjie, Sun Yalin, Lv Chao, Sun Maosong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-label text classification involves extracting all relevant labels from
a sentence. Given the unordered nature of these labels, we propose approaching
the problem as a set prediction task. To address the correlation between
labels, we leverage Graph Convolutional Networks and construct an adjacency
matrix based on the statistical relations between labels. Additionally, we
enhance recall ability by applying the Bhattacharyya distance to the output
distributions of the set prediction networks. We evaluate the effectiveness of
our approach on two multi-label datasets and demonstrate its superiority over
previous baselines through experimental results. | [
0.0097326441,
0.0086923391,
0.0033928982,
0.0123115443,
-0.0204403009,
-0.0215613674,
-0.0008776046,
0.0370751061,
0.0712220594,
-0.0370183662,
-0.0021636249,
0.0165240038,
-0.0372188017,
0.0200554542,
0.0064827562,
0.0028219568,
0.0191213265,
0.0226712413,
0.0341156125,
-0.001836998,
-0.0139450673,
0.049102325,
0.0114854611,
0.0269270483,
-0.0620107688,
-0.0416220166,
0.0317111872,
0.0581396557,
-0.0212903954,
-0.0355422907,
0.0431893319,
0.0304344706,
-0.020036038,
-0.0231198221,
0.0000018708,
-0.0256556924,
-0.0226973817,
-0.0299579613,
0.016397126,
-0.0069124326,
-0.0354889221,
0.0018235479,
0.0578946993,
-0.0001708459,
-0.0136719812,
0.0096314335,
0.024465045,
0.0034438283,
0.0244921241,
0.0592310168,
-0.0429382138,
-0.0322817713,
0.0086165555,
0.0113067906,
0.0268493332,
-0.0749367326,
0.0066505931,
-0.0352645256,
0.0095426207,
0.0088493945,
-0.0097802421,
0.0216029137,
0.0026809708,
-0.0090896115,
0.0696398318,
0.0182566158,
-0.0184735395,
-0.0055575138,
0.0354165882,
0.0914812312,
0.0022733354,
-0.0299047027,
0.0026173743,
-0.0366861559,
0.0120583847,
0.0331542976,
0.0088399146,
-0.0420024209,
-0.0457930677,
-0.0220080428,
-0.0687239319,
0.0161953643,
0.0239040814,
-0.0173976682,
0.0484885201,
0.0538598336,
-0.0213751644,
0.0023983517,
-0.0037371605,
0.0038311162,
-0.0203838833,
-0.026959369,
0.0219669286,
0.0044711074,
-0.0359312892,
0.0187449548,
-0.029785879,
-0.0608579479,
0.025646152,
-0.0131888259,
0.0134962872,
-0.0323269665,
-0.0438493937,
0.0106914649,
-0.0074717412,
0.0218195096,
-0.011487687,
0.0591317452,
-0.0243566129,
-0.0147995222,
-0.0519532785,
-0.0206897873,
-0.0180768128,
0.0599377938,
0.0880853832,
0.0155481445,
-0.0479031242,
-0.0482730418,
-0.0282517727,
0.0218219049,
0.0463377237,
0.0375337824,
-0.0242299587,
-0.0328113101,
-0.0186305325,
0.014386056,
-0.0416272171,
0.0149656879,
-0.0311999954,
0.0115374075,
0.0017705751,
0.001304285,
0.0329288393,
-0.0074920258,
0.0290367566,
0.0387479924,
-0.008189939,
-0.0429085046,
-0.0566662662,
-0.0089048846,
-0.019482512,
-0.0562275127,
0.0379869528,
-0.0605947264,
0.0167355631,
0.0220488589,
-0.0135732321,
-0.0370642394,
0.0028127795,
0.0171469655,
-0.0356689431,
0.0642206222,
0.0687006265,
-0.0066469014,
0.0673983246,
-0.0180551093,
0.0423274413,
0.0244380552,
-0.0077972328,
0.0497753955,
0.0287446436,
0.0202991553,
0.0025903543,
0.0017141148,
0.0349477045,
-0.0205719508,
-0.0458304286,
-0.0119952941,
0.0452662408,
0.0171917155,
-0.0629543364,
0.0021793179,
-0.0061998223,
-0.013878244,
-0.0056945863,
-0.0108065186,
0.0022488278,
-0.0294358488,
0.0075499532,
-0.0215355121,
-0.0284847468,
-0.0087754261,
0.0117868902,
0.0307586621,
-0.00264155,
-0.0020424491,
0.0301936865,
-0.0043063667,
-0.0215658508,
-0.0264344979,
-0.0044954643,
-0.0802871361,
0.0206150338,
-0.0367004834,
0.0838005841,
0.027574148,
-0.0337917432,
0.0309460759,
0.0445153154,
0.0007153449,
-0.0160527788,
0.0130313272,
-0.0196870361,
0.0221083257,
0.0023494221,
-0.0678645894,
0.0211307704,
-0.0034729685,
0.0579369292,
-0.0318854563,
0.0156671517,
0.0013062658,
-0.007571273,
-0.064390853,
-0.0175984725,
-0.0136357602,
-0.0037607471,
0.0829832479,
-0.0217960253,
0.0401846692,
0.0262247492,
-0.0332463458,
-0.0079357205,
0.003146267,
0.0263536293,
-0.0107787717,
0.0466756821,
0.0389304943,
0.017115701,
0.0100309663,
0.0009199979,
0.0039428272,
0.0274427366,
-0.0341761149,
-0.0447750576,
-0.0606425181,
-0.0411972627,
-0.0448811948,
0.0245917141,
-0.0279952399,
0.0132180806,
0.0125139076,
-0.0302219298,
-0.0711903274,
0.0271711592,
-0.0066826297,
-0.0356136449,
0.0307613965,
-0.0468515381,
0.005671028,
0.0101667531,
-0.0252859201,
0.0894978866,
0.0360808,
0.0553502478,
-0.0519285053,
0.0432379358,
0.04863986,
0.0014704794,
0.0261365417,
0.0341701508,
-0.0069727525,
0.0212851726,
0.0356676765,
0.0066644088,
-0.0463993326,
-0.0036781635,
-0.0210402645,
-0.0102524366,
0.0212542862,
-0.0321392082,
-0.0442621857,
-0.0188808329,
0.0222227667,
-0.0645699427,
-0.0369793698,
0.060557235,
-0.0278927572,
-0.0112745976,
0.0207115412,
-0.0000815505,
-0.0087557733,
0.0354686715,
-0.0529984236,
-0.0423195474,
0.0925921798,
0.0364224762,
-0.0543462783,
0.0130904904,
0.0464451164,
-0.0634088665,
-0.0186179522,
0.0120498277,
0.0202023704,
0.0136491125,
-0.0164610669,
-0.0330135636,
0.0288246013,
-0.0015430395,
-0.0283894259,
0.0273400359,
0.0126727987,
-0.0170091651,
0.0191713814,
-0.0333001986,
-0.008739274,
-0.0004163924,
-0.0275583118,
-0.0665840879,
0.0034239029,
0.0296352208,
-0.0160937477,
-0.0736894757,
-0.0583968163,
0.0139986817,
0.0051282328,
-0.0798510164,
0.0098898951,
-0.0051422943,
0.0049896613,
0.0006805335,
-0.0308486987,
0.0655195639,
0.0292012934,
0.0282805189,
-0.0072898362,
-0.0219019856,
-0.0270010363,
0.0816530958,
0.0729597956,
0.015886208,
0.0780326799,
-0.00924116,
-0.0639864355,
0.014119124,
0.035761714,
-0.0169194285,
-0.0213837046,
0.0054901177,
0.051743757,
0.0069577051,
-0.0165251363,
0.0185023621,
0.0076018255,
-0.0037059954,
-0.006420474,
-0.0348885097,
0.0036329071,
0.0051081949,
-0.0335072763,
-0.0070540905,
0.0062286081,
-0.0125930961,
0.0087253824,
0.0052364799,
0.0712284818,
0.0291942079,
-0.0592783689,
-0.0682266653,
-0.0140798353,
-0.0335582457,
0.0153052378,
-0.0039846259,
0.0004498989,
-0.0054242597,
0.0159414858,
-0.0196975898,
0.0345636494,
-0.0204789713,
-0.0018100853,
0.0023584017,
0.0156245967,
-0.0044141547,
0.0235248059,
0.0584954694,
-0.0561693646,
-0.0241012275,
0.0113061611,
0.0404444523,
0.064171657,
0.0134672793,
-0.0466743782,
-0.0263346154,
-0.0375271812,
0.0084650721,
0.0112091005,
-0.0514439829,
0.0050044935,
-0.0771090463,
-0.0210485067,
0.0035053925,
-0.0454647616,
0.0076074307,
-0.0409569293,
-0.0176984649,
0.0174934864,
-0.0397784822,
-0.0663595423,
0.0355319232,
-0.0201949235,
0.0598182045,
-0.0202151071,
0.0110299801,
0.0576881841,
0.0252967477,
0.0098898765,
-0.0223405752,
0.0335764997,
-0.0613913462,
0.0241811946,
0.0256752465,
-0.0194528624,
-0.0256866198,
0.0183185022,
0.0900402963,
-0.0069419793,
-0.0039645825,
0.0411800928,
0.0109653939,
-0.0557395443,
-0.0399937816,
0.0175394174,
0.0620753467,
0.0005726567,
-0.0100502502,
-0.0172170363,
-0.0536329001,
0.0065957806,
-0.0243067537,
0.0167427063,
-0.0614934787,
-0.0048456993,
-0.0186108332,
0.0550837927,
-0.0444391109,
0.003163863,
0.0288146399,
-0.0634275302,
-0.033551842,
-0.0281627327,
-0.0221186262,
0.0015527511,
0.0073331082,
-0.0412240066,
0.0205119364,
0.0021835165,
0.0131533872,
-0.0278437007,
-0.0127721792,
0.00118711,
0.0508383401,
-0.0120129595,
-0.0211321935,
0.047932215,
-0.0142718134,
-0.0443615578,
0.003672146,
-0.0112653282,
-0.053309232,
-0.0339491777,
0.0094684456,
0.0111560766,
0.0251360107,
-0.0063105379,
-0.0255594999,
0.0271639079,
0.0808955431,
-0.0219398867,
-0.0123328082,
0.0178513937,
-0.0200483166,
-0.0490196384,
0.0277785212,
-0.0617305897,
0.0523814783,
-0.0067278682,
0.0154047254,
-0.0068735932,
-0.0794001743,
0.0223776698,
0.0467519574,
0.0477225073,
-0.0021246204,
0.0082889562,
-0.0615561493,
0.0071379109,
-0.0011840264,
-0.0292704087,
0.014346296,
-0.0128189595,
0.0370102637,
-0.0156759936,
-0.0082522435,
-0.0700808167,
0.0368491895,
0.0314040519,
0.0229461268,
-0.0235553905,
0.0206424203,
0.0625663623,
0.0423724391,
0.0051514753,
-0.0017822691,
0.0045185592,
0.0579903536,
-0.0039086505,
-0.0158827864,
-0.002546238,
0.0395139493,
0.0067102411,
-0.0580962822,
-0.038608294,
-0.0243512988,
0.0605562702,
-0.0315029882,
-0.0039743502,
0.0235817935,
-0.0026610869,
-0.0178132653,
-0.0078401631,
-0.0288576577,
-0.0336626768,
0.0671582147,
0.0359216332,
-0.020939827,
0.0346250795,
-0.0007567672,
-0.0123532536,
0.0470750034,
0.0818954632,
0.0574753881,
0.028901184,
0.0044372901,
-0.0519639403,
-0.0446403585,
-0.0051249932,
-0.0379111208,
0.0469393022,
0.0299823619,
0.023074476,
-0.0053238501,
-0.0513209477,
0.0735191926,
-0.0521407053,
0.0194024779,
0.0294900313,
0.0404281542,
0.0321603604,
0.0568401255,
0.0228341315,
-0.0338486098,
0.0027087568,
-0.0126785999,
-0.0143524501,
0.0033491189,
-5.50766968e-33,
-0.0174405873,
-0.0771721452,
-0.0354061425,
0.0348327272,
0.0107261501,
0.0219815429,
-0.0297626536,
-0.0129546039,
-0.0188687611,
0.0361496247,
-0.0099698333,
0.0443895906,
0.0021443816,
0.0112128267,
0.028827792,
-0.0500871167,
-0.0168707706,
-0.0212057065,
0.0249446817,
0.0341170318,
0.0864252895,
0.0477765538,
0.0301232487,
-0.0958070904,
-0.0066060931,
-0.0766589567,
0.0012719233,
-0.0161593575,
-0.0029785794,
0.039480824,
0.0141542973,
0.0837951377,
0.0431804284,
0.0070768138,
0.0446991958,
0.0307474062,
-0.0467427522,
-0.0614975058,
-0.0797341168,
-0.0083555756,
-0.0299892463,
0.006046419,
-0.0113954199,
0.0332513265,
0.0471585356,
-0.0411570631,
0.1012409255,
-0.015226664,
-0.0831056088,
-0.0260350481,
-0.0017047505,
0.013483909,
-0.0208749697,
0.0026591781,
0.0021496678,
0.0546459295,
0.0091514699,
0.0381451398,
-0.0132787358,
0.0060692434,
-0.0587629788,
0.0054757255,
-0.0261288099,
0.0598448217,
-0.0302805472,
0.0419289321,
0.0270218179,
-0.0041862247,
0.0053847432,
-0.0066383458,
-0.0123236626,
0.0493876822,
-0.0220592413,
0.0477380566,
-0.010383362,
-0.0819767937,
-0.1237707809,
-0.0037713717,
0.0010637688,
0.010590462,
-0.0148893967,
0.0355153382,
-0.0091954181,
-0.0299500227,
0.0100741107,
-0.0138340192,
-0.0356350169,
-0.0030671044,
0.0070005036,
-0.0096088992,
0.006125269,
0.042802427,
-0.0248917658,
-0.0244235154,
-0.0485752784,
0.065874815,
-0.0378615335,
0.0579454266,
-0.0075210962,
0.0265847109,
-0.059046071,
-0.0270201638,
-0.0115209995,
0.0137163717,
0.0470217057,
0.0003285921,
0.101113975,
0.0011053018,
-0.0562527589,
-0.0333808549,
-0.0079424763,
-0.0424262956,
-0.0490583181,
-0.0237986892,
-0.0084504802,
0.0288657304,
-0.0036783384,
0.0707105026,
0.0607937835,
0.0265048128,
0.0147080887,
-0.0377199687,
0.0296172518,
0.0272863545,
-0.0457992069,
-0.033896625,
-0.0124688512,
0.0106353024,
0.0793026313,
-0.0354190581,
-0.0007540855,
-0.0147405397,
2.672e-7,
0.052046597,
0.0512872003,
-0.000011409,
-0.0229716673,
-0.0123979589,
0.0416640975,
-0.0276131965,
0.0541736819,
-0.0331623778,
-0.0437210165,
0.0697580352,
-0.0218274668,
0.0130977705,
0.040866714,
-0.0695502311,
0.0368534029,
-0.0928716511,
-0.012152792,
-0.0626388118,
0.0260996558,
0.0410983711,
0.0413270295,
0.0883248821,
-0.0177627392,
-0.0241652541,
0.002576902,
0.0488492511,
0.0069819782,
0.0248866994,
0.0039263619,
0.0017605246,
0.0064351181,
-0.0582467467,
0.0982899517,
-0.036445193,
-0.0015824033,
0.094450213,
-0.0145524349,
-0.0315511189,
-0.0064296266,
0.0236090869,
0.0416967012,
-0.0193679295,
0.0125259245,
0.0606450215,
-0.0164962392,
-0.0317226872,
0.0323359668,
-0.0379024409,
-0.0024317983,
0.0516658574,
0.0526382662,
-0.0212706793,
-0.0059276456,
-0.0118404701,
-0.0098673822,
-0.0104869185,
-0.0829759389,
-0.0196299981,
0.0536617823,
-0.0126712294,
-0.0018696992,
-0.0032927531,
0.0349553004,
0.0464314893,
-0.0789176151,
0.0107839843,
1.839226331e-34,
-0.0029701432,
-0.0040556677,
-0.0227113087,
-0.0403302796,
0.0332459584,
-0.0783447474,
-0.0700163394,
0.0139537342,
0.0066338261,
-0.0498029329,
0.0077581117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07007v1 | Dialogue Games for Benchmarking Language Understanding: Motivation, Taxonomy, Strategy | 2023-04-14T09:11:36 | 2023-04-14T09:11:36 | David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | How does one measure "ability to understand language"? If it is a person's
ability that is being measured, this is a question that almost never poses
itself in an unqualified manner: Whatever formal test is applied, it takes
place on the background of the person's language use in daily social practice,
and what is measured is a specialised variety of language understanding (e.g.,
of a second language; or of written, technical language). Computer programs do
not have this background. What does that mean for the applicability of formal
tests of language understanding? I argue that such tests need to be
complemented with tests of language use embedded in a practice, to arrive at a
more comprehensive evaluation of "artificial language understanding". To do
such tests systematically, I propose to use "Dialogue Games" -- constructed
activities that provide a situational embedding for language use. I describe a
taxonomy of Dialogue Game types, linked to a model of underlying capabilites
that are tested, and thereby giving an argument for the \emph{construct
validity} of the test. I close with showing how the internal structure of the
taxonomy suggests an ordering from more specialised to more general situational
language understanding, which potentially can provide some strategic guidance
for development in this field. | [
0.0403545238,
-0.0097072674,
-0.0774894729,
0.0779446959,
-0.0466725193,
-0.0071747773,
0.0043648062,
0.0065315384,
0.00909096,
-0.0135640064,
-0.0137802633,
-0.0397130474,
0.0447108336,
0.0265579205,
0.0346995741,
-0.0469201356,
0.0324887149,
0.0141036119,
0.0329419859,
0.0276212804,
0.0042893775,
-0.0029208909,
-0.0303706974,
0.041230455,
0.0194901899,
0.015152839,
-0.0465224646,
-0.0486812741,
0.0071293144,
-0.0038980932,
-0.0164931584,
-0.0073942523,
0.0547211915,
-0.0007582566,
0.0000020991,
-0.0637249798,
0.0376742668,
-0.0300891455,
-0.05467356,
-0.0272718128,
0.0257367156,
0.0585894063,
0.0290733483,
-0.0233733878,
-0.0794479474,
0.0078242077,
0.0035133229,
-0.0300130341,
0.0197991636,
0.0509917252,
0.02147834,
-0.0098819714,
-0.0227515716,
0.0236318521,
0.0020617063,
-0.0500823632,
-0.0034925696,
0.0735106915,
0.0581455231,
-0.0210104026,
-0.0485888645,
0.0150942383,
0.0082533136,
-0.0224464908,
-0.0187423378,
0.0116597489,
-0.0161908939,
-0.0073070065,
0.003252398,
0.0230518859,
0.0658144504,
-0.0071717449,
-0.0091196746,
0.025210131,
0.0345622264,
0.0272860508,
-0.0274481121,
0.0015155372,
-0.0089813592,
-0.0149340546,
0.0120033566,
-0.0047420398,
-0.0092289392,
0.0078069107,
0.0303542931,
0.0527896211,
-0.034107063,
0.0003299848,
0.0071765124,
-0.0024639643,
-0.0045399228,
-0.0705858245,
-0.0314252973,
0.0614548922,
-0.0701352432,
0.0616722368,
0.0125303231,
0.0070394911,
0.0213164855,
-0.0235913005,
0.0135241887,
0.03677167,
0.0495320074,
0.0360066742,
0.0573242977,
0.0608948134,
0.0499895103,
-0.0076014833,
-0.0425462201,
0.0279423166,
-0.0638883114,
-0.0471376553,
-0.054032445,
0.0136282463,
-0.0194562897,
2.061e-7,
0.0003856309,
-0.0040105255,
-0.0401564986,
0.0703322589,
-0.067932792,
-0.0187025368,
-0.0270146187,
-0.0000286588,
-0.0292052012,
-0.0141295288,
-0.063268505,
0.0253718589,
-0.0259449221,
-0.0685290471,
0.0231494568,
-0.0017944445,
-0.0226122644,
0.0035858888,
-0.0162879508,
0.0318604335,
-0.007955201,
-0.018726483,
0.0425585993,
-0.0226894263,
-0.0145769743,
-0.0716291294,
0.0182466712,
-0.0512701906,
-0.014476995,
-0.0070309681,
0.0039833789,
-0.0467432626,
0.0111705912,
-0.0199464262,
0.0129692899,
0.0647882149,
0.0188341942,
0.0104643032,
0.0467384718,
0.0393275283,
0.0091655618,
0.0460212789,
0.0324074775,
-0.0753351822,
0.0156668946,
-0.0490203276,
0.0112382993,
0.0348720811,
-0.0128667597,
-0.030450413,
-0.0133942887,
0.0341704562,
0.0013476883,
0.0183536448,
-0.0029639057,
0.0033884922,
-0.0424709022,
0.0150683215,
0.0267234128,
0.0630793646,
0.0098807123,
0.0188318882,
0.0306975376,
0.0139137739,
0.0078622717,
0.0515208319,
0.0275918096,
-0.0209887102,
-0.0041512353,
0.0065055033,
-0.0514530987,
-0.0201361664,
0.0030226076,
-0.0510875694,
0.0037728378,
0.033395689,
0.0427417979,
0.0369033068,
0.0040725656,
0.0060661947,
0.0104847532,
0.0122397654,
-0.0135407746,
-0.0391677953,
0.0275494494,
-0.0711735189,
-0.0077144862,
0.0341055989,
0.0164378844,
-0.0296594854,
-0.0220300332,
0.007815511,
-0.0063777375,
0.0635675639,
0.0463483483,
-0.0346038491,
0.0025192404,
-0.0127859907,
0.0149751538,
-0.0396107994,
0.0016824889,
0.0004321787,
-0.0592542663,
0.0238417406,
-0.0210603625,
-0.0020274336,
-0.0017500176,
0.0044033374,
-0.0022532553,
-0.0443518646,
-0.0472728834,
0.0176270455,
0.036740154,
0.0167703964,
-0.0176466927,
-0.003259416,
0.0153598646,
0.0006841681,
0.0458797365,
0.0780279264,
-0.0418393463,
-0.0044435374,
0.0244264305,
-0.0673020855,
-0.0366321057,
-0.0103803342,
0.0252245646,
-0.0241052639,
0.0636133552,
-0.0673394352,
0.064566277,
-0.0063401847,
0.0181462802,
-0.0727622584,
-0.0165646579,
-0.0310412478,
0.0373125747,
0.0192055367,
0.0143189039,
-0.0196656715,
-0.0072568231,
0.0381909609,
-0.051712092,
-0.0237396285,
0.0537193902,
-0.0140276132,
0.007148941,
0.0394104607,
0.0108449552,
-0.1104551703,
-0.0019673593,
-0.0917196348,
-0.0366631113,
-0.0130330501,
0.0087569514,
0.0333387218,
-0.0477369055,
-0.0018581375,
-0.0067835045,
-0.0036978601,
-0.0038067659,
0.0316179059,
-0.0143732093,
0.0316836275,
0.0457642376,
-0.0370141529,
0.0096600372,
0.0146286497,
-0.0273028538,
0.0315339118,
0.0268884264,
0.0138537688,
-0.0484026857,
-0.0169775728,
-0.0317278951,
-0.0354409479,
-0.0239371546,
-0.0529808588,
0.0741603523,
0.042684637,
0.0141580645,
0.048123233,
0.026618313,
0.0398720838,
0.0083675776,
-0.0719819143,
-0.0298226234,
0.0066132322,
0.0345092751,
-0.0302613825,
-0.0702165365,
-0.0820670798,
-0.011324496,
0.0365196802,
0.0360722579,
0.0504111759,
-0.0342061482,
0.0631517917,
-0.0477050394,
-0.0374250412,
-0.0687465072,
-0.0688465238,
-0.0435324013,
0.040786542,
-0.0248636752,
0.0154151097,
0.0584084354,
-0.017873494,
-0.0473465435,
-0.0308534019,
0.0064490763,
-0.0093225855,
0.1220364422,
-0.021503469,
0.0141769191,
0.0091297412,
-0.0662915856,
-0.0446813852,
-0.0513815731,
0.0406019762,
-0.0393858813,
0.0598011017,
-0.0690314844,
-0.0026796579,
0.0163923595,
-0.0124512902,
-0.0534048229,
0.0286692195,
-0.0205862299,
0.008555511,
0.0109132901,
0.0315760449,
-0.0126999216,
-0.0119354026,
0.0135923754,
0.0070092492,
0.0322898887,
-0.0289984848,
0.002607177,
0.0078702001,
0.0000119652,
0.0739462078,
0.0053540124,
0.0147503428,
0.0507818647,
0.0205006711,
0.0067065526,
-0.0185903888,
-0.0136804897,
0.0261234175,
0.02582209,
-0.0288302973,
-0.0308284555,
0.0403776541,
0.0734401792,
-0.0637341142,
-0.0623638332,
0.0875370204,
0.0205697343,
0.0143309534,
0.0171741396,
-0.0457094684,
-0.0238218457,
0.0309347939,
0.0394444093,
-0.0957156941,
0.018791778,
-0.0199372675,
-0.0070007988,
-0.0481507219,
-0.0290208831,
-0.0500051156,
-0.0744361207,
0.0119284568,
0.0058729607,
-0.0817876458,
0.0110508585,
0.0401210673,
0.0186437573,
0.0315995961,
0.058304511,
0.0258116219,
0.0197382681,
-0.0022595094,
0.0083462195,
-0.0209378246,
-0.0127105685,
0.0403680056,
0.0115406401,
0.1056549996,
-0.010932737,
0.0638881922,
-0.0114290155,
-0.0267891753,
0.021370817,
-0.0098302905,
-0.0009609734,
-0.0000523089,
-0.0027517166,
0.0087681133,
0.0014805415,
-0.0094368458,
-0.0141311409,
0.0028597501,
-0.0158920921,
0.0447509214,
0.0476389118,
-0.0356353335,
-0.0327460654,
0.0341207571,
0.0308748204,
0.0255775042,
0.0333407782,
0.0494183935,
0.0019977491,
0.0308155771,
-0.0297834966,
0.006280269,
0.0044883755,
-0.0680261701,
-0.0128282318,
0.0716303289,
0.0190770514,
-0.0345227458,
-0.0850603655,
0.0321379006,
0.047989931,
0.018833274,
0.0034123138,
0.0058330749,
0.0210872069,
-0.0175431836,
0.0162977073,
0.0062231245,
-0.0002328164,
-0.0186663363,
-0.0401904248,
-0.0232875906,
-0.0516357943,
-0.036125809,
-0.0217175409,
-0.0013960197,
-0.0347039849,
0.0299962722,
0.0352749191,
0.0319845527,
0.0021133232,
0.0220914297,
-0.0123588676,
-0.0696048811,
-0.0575919673,
-0.0071346341,
0.0166202746,
0.0159362238,
-0.0338513292,
0.0241399352,
0.0233475547,
0.0235028714,
0.003744602,
-0.0376167968,
-0.003228425,
-0.055453036,
-0.0501667112,
0.0414964743,
0.0091051105,
0.0019661034,
-0.001312113,
-0.0174358878,
-0.0158983562,
-0.0015233374,
-0.0157931726,
-0.0675740913,
0.0045671696,
-0.0549846552,
-0.0213394519,
-0.0054135318,
0.0250251796,
-0.0283321384,
-0.0869575441,
0.015279484,
0.0305264257,
0.0272149313,
0.0566581674,
-0.0017153302,
-0.0450069159,
0.0271610525,
0.0114738317,
0.0260574631,
-0.0103879673,
0.0933601558,
-0.0009051453,
0.0715212524,
0.0223049596,
-0.0459449477,
0.0418267548,
-0.0168274809,
-0.0038937735,
-0.0281600449,
0.0623037331,
0.0295694713,
0.0234606341,
-0.0402664952,
-0.0085007846,
-0.0182380266,
0.0469697341,
0.0229823664,
-0.0170612689,
-0.0101826284,
-0.0855018571,
0.0184308235,
0.0336047001,
-0.008205127,
-0.0224160645,
0.0132711502,
-0.0539424904,
-0.0151276924,
-0.0004618718,
0.0320912823,
-0.0488401875,
-0.0424513072,
-0.0052845199,
0.0428814292,
-0.0017239949,
0.0236567128,
-0.0708453134,
-0.0518001057,
-0.0320553072,
0.0665589571,
0.0244029202,
-0.0230382495,
0.0253448058,
0.0479968823,
-0.0028911547,
-0.0140290232,
-0.0414220467,
0.0731839165,
-0.0150110647,
0.0265741665,
-0.030120844,
-5.623193224e-33,
-0.0600534007,
-0.0916076601,
0.0618695989,
-0.0098991077,
-0.0164346062,
-0.0044499775,
-0.0475013442,
0.0376083441,
-0.0415108725,
0.0116221132,
-0.0126829781,
0.0050310581,
-0.0052071153,
-0.0285405777,
-0.0028693469,
-0.0129682133,
-0.0042980211,
0.0303803831,
-0.0373854712,
-0.0273614172,
-0.0017960094,
-0.0501525924,
0.0588220917,
-0.0242236648,
0.0827508047,
-0.0086339526,
-0.0082726255,
0.0180745795,
-0.002911069,
0.0080207326,
0.0191815384,
0.0341479033,
0.0321976393,
0.0100087319,
0.014316869,
0.0528386533,
-0.0321069919,
-0.0674347579,
0.0985424221,
0.0471691191,
-0.0108331395,
-0.0124120554,
0.0347210094,
-0.0158101115,
-0.0385492072,
0.0337354019,
0.0190458167,
-0.0027562398,
0.0228671804,
0.0510214008,
-0.0550924651,
-0.0103469212,
-0.0738522336,
-0.0030603525,
0.0010362576,
-0.0065919701,
-0.0198340695,
-0.0738379881,
-0.0428159907,
0.0585854501,
-0.0296463426,
0.0052017295,
0.0753165036,
0.0065909037,
0.0158789996,
0.0525538139,
-0.0088412529,
0.0593318939,
0.0403994359,
-0.0351473987,
0.0572874248,
0.0094770454,
-0.000409516,
0.0631595179,
-0.0121232029,
-0.0149046276,
-0.0119829113,
-0.0070994003,
0.0738404095,
0.0127177583,
-0.0360557623,
0.0199330095,
-0.0433284827,
-0.0222231857,
-0.0644993484,
0.0341724232,
-0.0002840311,
-0.0379091799,
0.0229695886,
-0.0609102845,
0.0169659965,
-0.0114518953,
-0.0036509773,
-0.0344929472,
0.000274356,
-0.0436160453,
-0.0024161292,
-0.0008391623,
0.0118830586,
0.0352091193,
0.003101324,
-0.012339795,
-0.0170656927,
0.0523115471,
0.03901577,
0.0198452659,
-0.0187710952,
-0.0026710897,
-0.0073934952,
-0.0076970626,
-0.0408887602,
0.0162241049,
-0.0276026241,
-0.0303632878,
0.0484058298,
0.0489379205,
-0.0304647237,
0.0027985058,
0.0273912754,
-0.0781265423,
-0.0578119718,
0.0202241167,
-0.0661628693,
0.0083182333,
-0.0552797839,
-0.0263061598,
-0.0177696832,
0.045674134,
0.0478068292,
0.0040081283,
0.0192880277,
-0.0255693626,
2.867e-7,
0.0181998201,
0.0698484927,
-0.021050306,
0.028757723,
0.0044389446,
0.0022056543,
-0.0477383621,
0.0178281628,
0.0203182735,
-0.0304275583,
0.035547886,
0.0336798728,
0.0122677013,
0.0200411137,
-0.0349327177,
-0.0426734425,
-0.0270640031,
0.0195247047,
-0.0396343619,
0.0524606258,
0.0523961559,
-0.0046167346,
0.0001643966,
0.0102157779,
-0.0466340445,
-0.0579867996,
-0.0007600482,
-0.0450500064,
0.0123146689,
0.0247552991,
-0.000670424,
0.0306766033,
0.0183513612,
0.0635023639,
0.0348316692,
0.0083294762,
-0.0305891894,
0.0533226654,
-0.0151230525,
-0.0005439469,
-0.0532546043,
-0.0275192559,
0.0076077166,
-0.0628080815,
0.0168003663,
-0.0338277593,
-0.027369177,
0.0191962086,
-0.0101119904,
-0.0292289332,
-0.0065924251,
0.0019542133,
-0.0250117257,
0.0323388316,
0.0224013366,
-0.0519330651,
0.0420593321,
0.0023995326,
-0.0042856177,
0.0239833351,
-0.0253222045,
-0.0373479649,
-0.0008382228,
-0.0432894155,
-0.0220007543,
-0.0506131463,
-0.0049624257,
1.734075606e-34,
-0.0181076732,
0.0270222705,
0.06230928,
0.0110701406,
0.063981697,
0.0051878016,
0.0074217846,
0.0558176674,
0.0677798837,
-0.0072565051,
-0.006447711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07002v1 | SimpLex: a lexical text simplification architecture | 2023-04-14T08:52:31 | 2023-04-14T08:52:31 | Ciprian-Octavian Truică, Andrei-Ionut Stan, Elena-Simona Apostol | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text simplification (TS) is the process of generating easy-to-understand
sentences from a given sentence or piece of text. The aim of TS is to reduce
both the lexical (which refers to vocabulary complexity and meaning) and
syntactic (which refers to the sentence structure) complexity of a given text
or sentence without the loss of meaning or nuance. In this paper, we present
\textsc{SimpLex}, a novel simplification architecture for generating simplified
English sentences. To generate a simplified sentence, the proposed architecture
uses either word embeddings (i.e., Word2Vec) and perplexity, or sentence
transformers (i.e., BERT, RoBERTa, and GPT2) and cosine similarity. The
solution is incorporated into a user-friendly and simple-to-use software. We
evaluate our system using two metrics, i.e., SARI, and Perplexity Decrease.
Experimentally, we observe that the transformer models outperform the other
models in terms of the SARI score. However, in terms of Perplexity, the
Word-Embeddings-based models achieve the biggest decrease. Thus, the main
contributions of this paper are: (1) We propose a new Word Embedding and
Transformer based algorithm for text simplification; (2) We design
\textsc{SimpLex} -- a modular novel text simplification system -- that can
provide a baseline for further research; and (3) We perform an in-depth
analysis of our solution and compare our results with two state-of-the-art
models, i.e., LightLS [19] and NTS-w2v [44]. We also make the code publicly
available online. | [
0.0047121462,
-0.0125695784,
-0.0165228751,
0.0230079293,
-0.0563625656,
0.0071989698,
-0.0064354851,
0.0317412317,
-0.0056079589,
-0.0107157296,
0.0183187798,
0.0550267175,
0.0442847982,
-0.0116447033,
0.0365082696,
-0.0964985713,
0.048768647,
0.0189075246,
-0.0132985516,
0.0006111046,
0.0462647751,
-0.0034691715,
0.0227812435,
0.0216675848,
0.0109934509,
-0.0062058643,
0.0069889077,
0.0162065271,
0.0172165185,
0.0151980445,
0.0068602329,
0.048674982,
-0.0010252519,
0.0105301058,
0.0000020679,
-0.0088982554,
-0.0234575327,
-0.0095592402,
0.04639652,
0.080205597,
0.091975376,
-0.0192558859,
0.0041539497,
0.0550399013,
-0.0152212884,
-0.0286455005,
0.0561793372,
0.0755497515,
0.0627001151,
0.0558625422,
-0.0496242233,
-0.0624442473,
-0.0245661456,
-0.0171814952,
-0.0086371414,
-0.0233923662,
0.0072887382,
0.0049998937,
-0.0013195057,
-0.0022736567,
-0.0409449376,
0.0554442033,
-0.0028032281,
-0.012687915,
0.026060028,
0.0296114702,
-0.0316039845,
-0.0050307084,
0.0159848779,
0.0612859949,
-0.055937551,
-0.0368845649,
0.003267843,
0.0177720319,
0.0142681422,
0.0164846089,
-0.055487521,
-0.0323047601,
0.0238144305,
0.0201591197,
-0.0049209152,
-0.0067277029,
0.0040921662,
-0.0093769608,
-0.0108017018,
-0.0210022461,
0.0448044315,
-0.0557456166,
-0.0439223088,
-0.0152649526,
0.0097159222,
-0.0692742765,
0.0555267073,
0.0193901043,
-0.0033590812,
0.0054584751,
-0.055988051,
-0.1053776294,
-0.0117107145,
-0.0540677793,
0.0348646678,
0.0257827844,
0.0260815881,
0.0181976333,
-0.0690763071,
0.0574774183,
0.0066044349,
-0.0010618903,
-0.0527244322,
0.0115100546,
-0.0185213592,
0.0119289411,
-0.0714899004,
0.042654302,
-0.0326464958,
-0.0550870113,
-0.0330589823,
0.0176962465,
0.0276493505,
-0.0259093605,
0.014137364,
0.0074960524,
0.0102629671,
-0.0045747333,
0.0171820261,
0.0387810022,
-0.0562861972,
-0.0010177653,
-0.0247487575,
-0.0233250316,
-0.0054916763,
0.0288148392,
0.0814672336,
0.0146911759,
-0.023638282,
-0.014977661,
-0.0364937298,
-0.0364836343,
0.0002119619,
-0.0038492046,
0.02966973,
-0.0172522664,
-0.030123597,
-0.0588925742,
0.0282509811,
0.0036868046,
0.0117078405,
-0.0093810223,
0.0149604911,
0.0399177335,
-0.0670840591,
0.0524702929,
-0.05271063,
0.0300106164,
0.0105903549,
0.0097859856,
0.0387341455,
0.0177497752,
0.0344912261,
0.0144388983,
0.045171231,
-0.0240317136,
0.0438525937,
0.0238993075,
-0.0140231298,
-0.002993522,
0.008891861,
-0.0368874781,
-0.0853595659,
0.0263437163,
0.003544155,
0.0910847932,
-0.0490289032,
0.0444217734,
0.05440294,
0.0359092057,
0.0061141574,
0.0697745383,
0.0363080651,
0.0571017824,
0.0404326133,
0.0452066958,
-0.0034630725,
0.0074704536,
-0.0190772805,
0.027460916,
0.0290220212,
0.0065333033,
-0.0391194709,
-0.0191963892,
0.0092260735,
-0.0567139611,
0.0676226541,
-0.037551932,
0.0036656258,
0.0286640115,
-0.095297195,
0.0622471496,
0.0002667087,
-0.0861123577,
-0.0154402293,
-0.0122765582,
-0.026005622,
0.0687284023,
0.0695509315,
0.0236756541,
-0.0290067941,
0.000489996,
-0.006016803,
0.0543663651,
0.0407665335,
0.0032275412,
0.002077166,
-0.0906143785,
-0.0111067845,
0.0323341414,
-0.0059561408,
-0.0178996604,
0.0346543007,
-0.0151376221,
0.0371653736,
-0.0373871289,
0.0070027476,
0.0396205373,
-0.011669185,
0.0095664226,
0.0111857792,
0.0228282437,
-0.0133193014,
0.0101858666,
-0.0059177899,
0.0510619953,
0.0127232289,
-0.0408881567,
-0.0194083117,
0.0305044111,
-0.030883899,
-0.0768523887,
0.0104950201,
-0.0807343721,
0.0156499259,
0.1046987101,
-0.0309892818,
-0.0407822169,
-0.0017946066,
-0.0959365666,
0.0426623262,
-0.0431400537,
0.0523291901,
-0.0292706452,
0.0232855249,
-0.0212214068,
0.0453645177,
0.0189137608,
0.0327148698,
0.023370631,
-0.0292389579,
0.027552966,
-0.0015063104,
-0.0118844667,
-0.0850632414,
-0.0379930884,
-0.01889419,
0.0393341966,
0.0208617952,
0.0055554719,
-0.0397394896,
-0.0988010317,
-0.0181038026,
0.0069644023,
-0.0080744652,
0.0381991267,
0.0491668582,
0.0107192136,
-0.0033120485,
-0.0435966887,
0.0440237671,
0.015233336,
0.0084818611,
0.0637649149,
-0.0455556549,
-0.0792498142,
-0.0316967964,
-0.0008391918,
0.0080591841,
0.0404832065,
0.0079326062,
-0.0184206311,
-0.0368913375,
0.0623784214,
-0.0195800141,
-0.021722272,
0.0438359007,
-0.0530116484,
-0.0464505926,
0.0120327584,
0.084968552,
0.0413195156,
0.0593090318,
0.013401865,
0.0146870464,
-0.0045705955,
-0.0017355544,
0.0034756756,
-0.0249322802,
0.0338285193,
-0.0132878972,
-0.0714639798,
0.0459761731,
0.0184240416,
0.0346129723,
0.0256068353,
-0.0566377044,
-0.0069644102,
0.0139367497,
0.0062615699,
-0.0300410818,
-0.0158122517,
-0.0285950657,
-0.0145391058,
-0.0223099887,
-0.0202028379,
0.0194810312,
-0.0174202919,
0.0073147714,
-0.087364316,
0.0168942083,
-0.0313489065,
0.006776744,
-0.00315738,
0.0540425852,
-0.0084405476,
-0.0097850757,
-0.0518464819,
-0.0199121945,
0.0262759496,
-0.0412606969,
0.0072509446,
-0.0217859931,
-0.002659312,
-0.0478156656,
-0.0562590286,
-0.0206080303,
-0.056284532,
-0.0062956121,
-0.0048905108,
0.0995318145,
-0.0357278846,
-0.0223851521,
0.0047557899,
0.0134744309,
0.0287890602,
-0.0261465348,
-0.0117947431,
-0.015526915,
0.0612410232,
0.0588292181,
0.00054391,
0.0191265438,
-0.0034361763,
0.0376531258,
0.0355798937,
0.0120235467,
0.000231708,
-0.0060598347,
-0.0206871349,
-0.0063456846,
-0.0544494912,
-0.0166405868,
0.0246649366,
0.0216059163,
-0.0082974127,
0.0061690691,
0.1227147281,
0.0237452015,
-0.0041824924,
-0.0044598109,
-0.0031419862,
0.0249804556,
-0.0160472021,
0.0265334528,
-0.0502801985,
-0.0207907595,
0.027007604,
0.0024720244,
0.0336719714,
-0.0019790048,
-0.0250706635,
-0.0456741713,
0.0460904129,
0.0051359381,
-0.0414283536,
-0.0638203919,
-0.0027644536,
-0.0216406081,
0.0345015563,
-0.020035563,
0.0147854434,
-0.0474022999,
0.0007250834,
-0.0438912101,
-0.0781339183,
-0.0128026353,
-0.0425662026,
-0.0308605079,
0.0200385731,
0.0273378845,
0.0613811612,
0.0184044521,
-0.0518615246,
0.0222804137,
0.0124459751,
-0.0189041905,
-0.0262157097,
0.0460053347,
0.0333748683,
-0.0088122645,
-0.054505311,
0.0058247503,
0.0008746938,
-0.003500618,
0.0095928032,
0.0471304804,
0.0315306932,
-0.0314606205,
-0.0113064293,
0.0149952201,
-0.0165395532,
0.0860992149,
0.0541125052,
-0.0006641964,
-0.0563616008,
0.0066861291,
0.015378789,
-0.0778879449,
-0.0403662063,
-0.0175494496,
-0.0107965972,
-0.0469592847,
-0.0642807484,
-0.0328168422,
0.0357231386,
0.0239622165,
0.0176952034,
0.0359921455,
0.0256876256,
0.0137358578,
-0.0532409251,
-0.0642230511,
-0.0158484261,
0.0354893319,
-0.0190319214,
0.0166805219,
-0.0071969195,
0.0187742971,
0.0067217578,
-0.0244462024,
-0.0635352805,
-0.0240044147,
-0.0092502553,
0.0306421444,
0.0147752827,
0.0088394992,
-0.0118732024,
-0.0236160401,
0.0407629572,
0.0316973738,
-0.0226125866,
0.0535820872,
0.0183037631,
-0.0054988763,
0.0180936921,
0.0478563681,
-0.0301568601,
-0.0090592382,
-0.0269497409,
0.0510736555,
-0.0030983184,
-0.0287643038,
-0.0008628865,
0.0281283073,
0.000042101,
-0.021904977,
0.0257501602,
0.0023869767,
-0.0189535934,
-0.0714292526,
0.0091485316,
-0.0384222977,
0.0346992984,
0.0194228776,
0.0364975408,
-0.0130040934,
0.0504324771,
-0.0106056901,
-0.0165413134,
0.0148836588,
0.0055398415,
-0.0590205751,
-0.0219226386,
0.0077425949,
-0.0167075526,
-0.0320401713,
-0.0354186781,
-0.0414052568,
-0.0307866149,
-0.0352011919,
0.0124885058,
-0.0006210631,
-0.0073946104,
-0.061830271,
0.0473585948,
-0.023746701,
-0.0204068646,
-0.0211806707,
0.048863709,
0.0214210264,
0.0101401834,
0.0869347304,
-0.0316485018,
-0.0135668293,
-0.0121883499,
0.034979023,
-0.0028122037,
-0.0232564509,
0.004317631,
0.0000011723,
0.0001899181,
-0.0293614585,
0.083408162,
-0.0292446688,
0.0073126885,
0.0031200075,
-0.0232064612,
-0.0720033199,
-0.0096283946,
0.0243791305,
0.0501680002,
-0.0105101885,
-0.029952243,
-0.0461536683,
-0.0393772684,
0.0175417159,
0.0012288677,
0.0105233788,
-0.0206319168,
0.0430338681,
0.0194449276,
-0.0109361019,
-0.0394002609,
-0.0034157161,
0.0317744799,
-0.0243237801,
-0.0817869902,
-0.0269636679,
-6.324313891e-33,
0.0166512765,
-0.0035081881,
-0.028403854,
-0.004971975,
-0.04292579,
0.0099817095,
-0.0764185637,
0.0029685097,
-0.012458344,
0.0372012034,
-0.0108643044,
-0.0110662375,
0.0118526667,
0.0136305941,
-0.0410981327,
0.0418380126,
0.0623998418,
-0.0175454896,
-0.0104370546,
0.0050380072,
-0.0333848409,
0.0442690402,
-0.0044937162,
-0.0795956999,
-0.0678733066,
-0.0208268687,
-0.0314948149,
-0.0042497641,
0.0616525561,
0.0159080811,
-0.0254828259,
0.0125690531,
0.0222830325,
-0.021361839,
-0.0241708215,
0.0684840083,
-0.0692582577,
-0.0336840972,
0.0451241471,
-0.0174662881,
-0.0653063133,
-0.0449553393,
0.0385968797,
-0.0400166884,
-0.0097226836,
-0.0001464272,
0.0286292955,
-0.0223136954,
-0.0047899205,
-0.039437186,
-0.0710059628,
0.0290181357,
-0.0128313964,
-0.0474344008,
-0.0027196559,
0.0272759479,
-0.0067527131,
0.001027077,
0.0089556379,
0.0306618251,
0.0400905795,
0.0467530601,
0.0166658144,
-0.0222206488,
-0.0017951442,
0.026456302,
0.0228797775,
-0.0164008029,
-0.0401892513,
0.0078031248,
0.0126034711,
0.0417958535,
0.0726965666,
0.0487497523,
0.0399215221,
-0.0348607525,
-0.0295459628,
0.0401816256,
0.0312522352,
0.0266757365,
0.0277099647,
0.0077582477,
-0.0462580845,
-0.0358005315,
-0.0013685658,
0.0296832342,
-0.0272090975,
-0.0401377715,
0.0264823679,
0.0333803296,
-0.0332162082,
-0.0266321972,
0.0111350911,
-0.0274892505,
-0.0098527772,
0.0268426035,
-0.0118580665,
0.0345373601,
-0.0045573669,
-0.0340880118,
0.0121583352,
-0.016294077,
0.0206579715,
0.034367688,
-0.0122024547,
0.0177535191,
0.0121206082,
0.0188717563,
-0.0812345818,
0.0094317887,
0.0181643907,
-0.0381255969,
0.0088313809,
-0.0425085016,
-0.0041420567,
0.0147193382,
0.0207734276,
0.0016842892,
0.0388079956,
-0.027563069,
-0.0325609371,
-0.0085400455,
0.0534806475,
0.0347296968,
0.0142909093,
0.020477239,
-0.0483802222,
0.0268373843,
0.0368392467,
-0.0429851711,
-0.0240720976,
-0.0073464843,
2.727e-7,
0.051888708,
0.0514794253,
0.0513055101,
-0.0165074989,
0.0042507653,
0.0257325582,
0.0508639999,
0.0083034281,
-0.0368939713,
0.0559055731,
0.0458704792,
-0.0045309337,
0.0486538,
-0.0388789363,
-0.0880697295,
0.0154880127,
-0.0461872704,
-0.0449367017,
-0.0334022194,
0.0012486649,
0.1012676433,
0.0623326674,
0.0031674213,
0.0169278812,
-0.0248736329,
-0.0128499512,
0.0289305989,
-0.035239324,
0.001728246,
0.011484243,
0.0129131954,
-0.0303350128,
0.0132806115,
-0.0325145908,
-0.0252759568,
0.0181642305,
0.0261405539,
0.0743539706,
-0.0199050661,
0.0481654033,
0.024300199,
-0.0692253783,
-0.0192763861,
-0.0348212942,
0.0537296198,
-0.0538178235,
0.0173296556,
-0.0067615504,
-0.0128471544,
0.0506159887,
0.0243847948,
-0.0011133542,
-0.0854319111,
0.0271805879,
0.0447919294,
-0.0109729739,
-0.0068668616,
-0.0826737881,
-0.0213347077,
-0.0042939358,
-0.0224072058,
0.0072590467,
-0.0627387986,
0.019494677,
0.067946963,
0.0030941777,
0.0225736573,
2.789925639e-34,
0.0458547398,
-0.016275702,
0.0155071979,
0.0117034763,
0.0262710266,
-0.039927043,
0.0120046325,
0.0229657181,
0.0083524762,
-0.0728956237,
-0.0143795405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06975v1 | HuaTuo: Tuning LLaMA Model with Chinese Medical Knowledge | 2023-04-14T07:54:17 | 2023-04-14T07:54:17 | Haochun Wang, Chi Liu, Nuwa Xi, Zewen Qiang, Sendong Zhao, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as the LLaMA model, have demonstrated
their effectiveness in various general-domain natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Nevertheless, LLMs have not yet performed optimally in biomedical domain
tasks due to the need for medical expertise in the responses. In response to
this challenge, we propose HuaTuo, a LLaMA-based model that has been
supervised-fine-tuned with generated QA (Question-Answer) instances. The
experimental results demonstrate that HuaTuo generates responses that possess
more reliable medical knowledge. Our proposed HuaTuo model is accessible at
https://github.com/SCIR-HI/Huatuo-Llama-Med-Chinese. | [
0.088048622,
0.0461183526,
0.0030592836,
0.0082831904,
0.0155107668,
0.00684461,
-0.0194347501,
0.0335526839,
0.0325292088,
-0.0279327799,
-0.0725915879,
-0.0517188422,
-0.0032002178,
0.0264438801,
0.0197564997,
-0.0385407247,
0.0202427935,
0.0134980278,
0.0537848212,
-0.0113298949,
0.005102125,
-0.0074275043,
-0.0250878409,
0.0396061167,
0.0538112409,
-0.0290822107,
0.0569060929,
-0.012981222,
0.0163798463,
-0.0783186406,
0.034397725,
0.0348799489,
-0.048905801,
-0.0349243544,
0.0000017444,
-0.0560962856,
0.0019426444,
0.002673391,
-0.0243840627,
0.0074171657,
0.0102549186,
-0.0262223519,
0.0023830913,
0.04111531,
-0.0655411333,
-0.0133812791,
0.0175545067,
0.0739809722,
0.0602552071,
0.0649607927,
0.0033927264,
-0.0232107565,
0.0474638008,
-0.0358268805,
0.0162068829,
-0.0536705367,
0.0408981554,
0.0020378213,
0.03347959,
0.0076737814,
-0.0009796363,
0.0418852828,
-0.0150959305,
0.0098388512,
0.0068203611,
0.041883871,
-0.0036480187,
-0.0140628098,
-0.0211310629,
0.0950467214,
-0.0071449727,
-0.0109311845,
-0.0068317484,
0.007324981,
-0.0125669912,
-0.0107557112,
-0.0578609854,
-0.01288734,
-0.0072153131,
0.0196528137,
0.0398068689,
-0.0086267106,
0.0226565152,
0.0053166295,
-0.0061810645,
0.0281338152,
0.0016544261,
-0.0326071978,
-0.0058694682,
-0.0194966234,
-0.0186511483,
-0.0335831046,
0.048164729,
0.0818388537,
-0.0241229124,
0.0117375851,
0.0262591727,
-0.0068115955,
0.0885569826,
-0.049793154,
0.0050775064,
0.0145894494,
-0.0286175478,
0.0117343673,
-0.0229842793,
0.0232697651,
-0.0558271334,
0.0310364775,
-0.0656832308,
-0.0152163198,
-0.0378467478,
-0.0296067353,
0.003301159,
0.0418889225,
-0.0468170121,
0.0060281614,
-0.0758882686,
-0.0048500611,
0.008163848,
-0.0115212509,
0.00595243,
0.0406551547,
-0.0343505852,
-0.0067633442,
-0.0683458224,
0.0307507757,
-0.035524603,
0.0660232902,
-0.0401989557,
-0.0428858772,
0.0026381698,
-0.0010150215,
0.0147374189,
0.0029812008,
0.0381824486,
0.0623758063,
0.0010600274,
-0.0186936874,
0.0024864648,
-0.0108801806,
-0.0334187075,
-0.0337268114,
0.0197817869,
-0.0468460396,
0.0323714167,
0.0023924119,
0.0333800986,
-0.0414506122,
0.041428946,
0.0256335828,
-0.0467700064,
0.0697655827,
-0.0323265232,
0.0103821475,
0.0104116285,
0.026877882,
0.0346800983,
0.0295980982,
0.0368353166,
-0.0446082875,
0.0138280699,
0.0004272854,
0.008136983,
-0.0096612498,
0.0210597962,
-0.0466548949,
-0.0009100243,
0.0450523496,
-0.0131958015,
0.0743333325,
-0.0151021099,
0.0731642768,
0.0110998014,
-0.0160727985,
0.0217565298,
0.0669853389,
-0.003158855,
-0.0008967128,
-0.0074662198,
-0.0575454906,
0.031055484,
0.0015483091,
-0.0247003473,
0.0278138909,
-0.0054659867,
0.017085975,
-0.007768705,
0.0142498147,
-0.0569279455,
-0.0544356257,
-0.0265268609,
-0.0208130702,
-0.0524360687,
-0.0067020226,
-0.0044507068,
0.0170077421,
-0.0011208481,
0.0382948034,
0.0346984155,
-0.0164906327,
-0.0021233887,
-0.0760758892,
0.0418799557,
0.0622513704,
0.0427941531,
-0.0307467058,
-0.0495045334,
-0.0039674803,
-0.04723344,
0.0504401252,
0.0195702221,
-0.0320111886,
-0.0100343414,
-0.0523421466,
-0.0021972379,
0.0251084492,
-0.0026714641,
-0.024307739,
0.016291691,
0.0207897332,
-0.0079456652,
-0.0403206013,
0.0030249071,
0.0461962223,
-0.0430507362,
-0.0358058885,
0.0148110427,
-0.0316303372,
0.0453749448,
0.015593742,
-0.0005343189,
0.0531424358,
0.0362135656,
-0.067247346,
-0.0331465341,
-0.015330608,
-0.0304514281,
-0.0687645674,
0.0408219583,
-0.0286584906,
0.0113318227,
0.014304854,
-0.0552041829,
-0.0377354175,
-0.0534658395,
0.0043866369,
-0.0004285395,
-0.0342225805,
0.0070111435,
0.0317475647,
0.0352593325,
-0.0557638854,
0.0377998315,
-0.0143419234,
0.0258871336,
0.0171188302,
-0.0094715161,
-0.0163225327,
-0.0408123359,
-0.0270665903,
0.0139336921,
0.0085253119,
0.0243760031,
-0.0281932969,
0.0352307111,
-0.027695464,
-0.0506526157,
-0.0737692192,
0.022728635,
0.0029747675,
0.0173279624,
0.052055724,
0.0048731309,
-0.0238691308,
-0.024358891,
-0.0690929294,
0.0022487449,
0.0136725251,
0.0159276258,
0.055189088,
0.0182338934,
0.0273346025,
-0.0498386212,
0.0058393278,
-0.0267781597,
-0.012787939,
0.0206683427,
-0.0186215993,
-0.0185657833,
-0.0118942754,
-0.0438156836,
0.0080211721,
0.011591888,
-0.0508824326,
-0.0051607997,
0.0220366754,
0.0217517205,
0.045310799,
-0.0036389127,
-0.0202058088,
0.0453607515,
0.0520233326,
-0.0006377751,
0.0335844569,
-0.0576969013,
-0.0336634219,
-0.0105934087,
-0.0336934216,
0.0143533694,
0.0879064798,
0.0368425325,
-0.0122941732,
-0.0285799,
-0.0157178212,
-0.0221869741,
0.0123208789,
-0.0105617642,
0.0217185598,
-0.045890525,
0.036320135,
-0.0110726384,
-0.019000737,
0.0859046578,
-0.0099530118,
0.0298896115,
-0.0836751834,
-0.0014971853,
-0.0661788806,
-0.0058289184,
-0.0124324616,
0.0102337366,
0.0059746709,
-0.0092411702,
-0.0190988705,
0.0085029406,
-0.0511854999,
-0.0732887834,
0.0351149924,
-0.0116494158,
0.0076526543,
-0.005134278,
-0.041252967,
-0.0544410758,
0.0056329235,
-0.0432737581,
0.0155503871,
-0.002070385,
0.0317261741,
-0.0002420391,
0.022359103,
-0.0033324589,
0.0529821627,
-0.01121525,
0.0090461569,
-0.034781374,
0.0608426481,
0.0390860848,
0.0549023822,
0.0330855846,
0.0002711097,
0.0606733784,
0.0706251562,
0.0276381504,
0.0204118304,
0.049545262,
-0.0046627563,
-0.0020606674,
-0.0249556229,
0.0077522881,
0.0377491266,
0.0512062535,
-0.0438324846,
0.0065073748,
0.1019072235,
0.051024396,
-0.0202477518,
0.0257606134,
-0.018905282,
-0.0159084499,
0.0246701967,
0.0310038514,
-0.0643918961,
-0.0342023261,
-0.035497278,
0.0357460715,
-0.0139904758,
-0.007521634,
0.0294694994,
-0.0782410279,
0.0225688498,
-0.0237628054,
-0.0195347145,
-0.0437582023,
-0.0470565446,
0.0052533275,
0.0084427148,
0.0201911703,
0.0088588083,
-0.0198906045,
-0.0117165986,
0.0268019997,
-0.0357443579,
-0.06293495,
0.0554592796,
-0.0050562476,
0.0641364902,
0.0682310909,
0.0517212413,
-0.0017842314,
-0.0166694708,
-0.0138831818,
-0.0409013219,
0.0114175864,
-0.0147157256,
0.0379058905,
0.0257684384,
-0.0132607445,
-0.0262719486,
0.0569373555,
-0.0747023225,
-0.0038976779,
0.0250061806,
0.0557954535,
-0.0180399623,
-0.0208034366,
-0.0523333885,
0.0231745075,
-0.0131685575,
0.0552253462,
0.0171976835,
-0.0188777279,
-0.0361394361,
0.0056510638,
-0.004858261,
-0.0423517227,
-0.0428252369,
0.0443333536,
-0.0065359385,
0.0169085544,
-0.1116518304,
-0.0083411923,
0.0199207496,
-0.0516604707,
0.0161279589,
0.0494279191,
0.0392411202,
-0.0065857363,
-0.0280604921,
0.0111979181,
0.0127773061,
-0.0039478266,
-0.0630807951,
-0.009111302,
0.0936477557,
-0.0143945003,
-0.01819304,
0.0017555685,
-0.0386651605,
-0.0294952188,
-0.0181700587,
0.0418769829,
0.0096181557,
-0.015054415,
-0.0209886134,
-0.0241553336,
0.0389667526,
0.0480416156,
-0.0482141264,
0.0031548848,
-0.0050264415,
0.0046921838,
-0.0026081312,
0.0271349065,
-0.0012438339,
0.0452621281,
0.0290259663,
0.0498424098,
-0.021290496,
-0.0427843034,
0.0262871664,
0.0329198316,
0.0228704065,
0.0014610881,
-0.0160029009,
-0.0411597267,
0.0596732311,
-0.0069065252,
0.0200769026,
-0.0178809352,
-0.0051780604,
0.0431437828,
-0.0349118151,
-0.0028312104,
-0.0335083827,
-0.0553557202,
-0.0055034366,
-0.0317923911,
0.0427327678,
0.0124163562,
-0.011510944,
0.0033357462,
-0.0164888501,
-0.0021647427,
0.0225243215,
0.0105782459,
0.0451765023,
0.0059121563,
0.0386899784,
-0.033210393,
0.00524591,
-0.0174577292,
0.0234467518,
-0.0621786788,
-0.0265950002,
-0.021606572,
0.0561714545,
0.0291843303,
0.0166048519,
0.0052617779,
0.0031434959,
0.0048812437,
-0.0189023837,
0.0186583865,
-0.0233220775,
0.0326487049,
0.0956867337,
0.0011182344,
-0.0064954772,
-0.0286925957,
0.0995121524,
0.0139424931,
0.0664474145,
0.005894572,
-0.0117811961,
-0.0394192412,
-0.0235730335,
0.001870439,
-0.0065736426,
-0.0617650598,
0.0372628905,
-0.0426535048,
-0.0454941094,
0.0260771867,
-0.0155013865,
-0.0362858512,
-0.0396670625,
0.02483337,
0.0313977934,
0.0195717979,
-0.0091811875,
-0.033316806,
0.0332167558,
-0.0202805363,
0.0045049475,
0.0396288186,
-6.29368859e-33,
-0.0206166655,
-0.030548837,
0.0212464686,
-0.0151999556,
0.033103019,
0.0215560347,
-0.0252337884,
-0.0061509158,
-0.065640159,
0.0036814075,
-0.0367619321,
0.0016739322,
0.0154296132,
0.0299472027,
-0.0059526018,
-0.0180216227,
0.0182588976,
-0.012086343,
0.0002938697,
0.042218484,
-0.0133099277,
0.0446607098,
0.0328489169,
-0.0611210428,
0.0048449426,
-0.0141564719,
0.0293304399,
0.0370896496,
-0.050007049,
0.0815103725,
-0.0704500154,
0.0482454747,
0.0535724796,
-0.0099124704,
0.0001253659,
0.0101052718,
-0.0963856652,
-0.028306704,
0.0220195111,
-0.0374753997,
-0.0389748514,
-0.0437709503,
0.0652061328,
-0.0000141468,
0.009223192,
-0.0020820796,
0.0273313019,
-0.0622083545,
-0.0010766739,
-0.032649152,
-0.0321366191,
0.0207333621,
0.0168847423,
-0.0174418911,
-0.0337617844,
0.0001171018,
-0.0470408946,
0.0571589991,
-0.0292064883,
-0.0210110545,
0.0570733361,
0.0525948256,
0.0044728951,
-0.0246562995,
-0.0226762332,
0.0238324385,
-0.015473525,
-0.0325389691,
-0.0300849527,
-0.0056740413,
-0.0480477363,
0.0204485729,
0.056457378,
0.0338881128,
-0.0072639217,
-0.0355568305,
-0.1306576133,
0.0263795275,
-0.0152516495,
0.0594397038,
0.0313046537,
-0.0133777419,
-0.0288271643,
0.0147334188,
-0.0262457356,
0.0225665122,
-0.03621516,
-0.0046134624,
0.0323829427,
0.0102257738,
-0.0277862027,
-0.0064879209,
-0.0024262178,
-0.0374683067,
0.0242262222,
-0.0078708995,
0.0193482153,
0.0076528946,
-0.00838992,
0.0178549308,
-0.0904877931,
0.0054057539,
0.0000193892,
-0.0521736778,
0.0106650768,
0.0146072181,
0.0143662859,
-0.0454275534,
-0.0836767778,
0.0085609062,
0.0082468092,
-0.0075040753,
0.0333375745,
0.0568515472,
-0.0083379429,
0.0254388172,
-0.0022113277,
0.0392136611,
0.0120594865,
0.0028558222,
-0.0536132306,
-0.0372701585,
-0.0096270852,
0.0353753716,
-0.0737183988,
0.0177180357,
-0.0267173294,
0.0643072948,
-0.0200812407,
-0.0484823175,
-0.0220624208,
0.005334367,
2.468e-7,
0.1103909165,
0.031828288,
0.014332301,
0.0093523739,
0.0390238166,
0.0052504181,
-0.0034155136,
0.0373589247,
0.0113474485,
-0.0243525077,
0.007219601,
0.0208113808,
-0.0007312306,
0.0314045548,
-0.0756330118,
0.006312659,
-0.0526266918,
-0.0229147337,
-0.0078152679,
-0.0523675643,
0.0516705215,
0.115128465,
-0.0643925741,
-0.0301496331,
-0.0205377191,
-0.0317092836,
0.0573604815,
0.0219707098,
-0.019856682,
0.0849632993,
0.0294961985,
0.022532044,
0.008169814,
0.0258724838,
-0.0176304188,
0.0168918725,
0.0197110828,
0.106624268,
-0.0298809726,
-0.0361242145,
0.0392097272,
0.0120016197,
0.0350948088,
-0.0565169863,
0.0673884898,
-0.0333905704,
-0.0466530547,
-0.030274203,
0.0391823091,
-0.0097445287,
0.0585870035,
-0.0369782969,
-0.0119415345,
0.0243622549,
0.0254055876,
0.0170813911,
-0.038258452,
-0.0616725646,
-0.0573435947,
0.0057694055,
-0.0346290395,
-0.0463646241,
0.0047440561,
-0.0624647923,
-0.0271374714,
-0.0731599554,
0.0171464086,
1.830234373e-34,
0.0092061209,
-0.0061219777,
-0.0110032437,
0.0739683881,
0.0000359252,
-0.0217350889,
0.0026867611,
0.0158054028,
0.0222920142,
-0.0851356015,
-0.0088182166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06962v1 | Prompt Engineering and Calibration for Zero-Shot Commonsense Reasoning | 2023-04-14T07:07:42 | 2023-04-14T07:07:42 | Chenkai Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt engineering and calibration make large language models excel at
reasoning tasks, including multiple choice commonsense reasoning. From a
practical perspective, we investigate and evaluate these strategies on smaller
language models. Through experiments on five commonsense reasoning benchmarks,
we find that each strategy favors certain models, but their joint effects are
mostly negative. | [
0.0325901359,
0.0361230634,
-0.0059822206,
0.0109010329,
-0.0608308949,
-0.008239476,
0.0310554467,
0.0186095573,
0.0012675062,
-0.062581718,
0.0189319886,
0.0058523114,
-0.004106028,
-0.0122437282,
0.0046875435,
-0.0180397741,
0.0458883382,
-0.0418595299,
-0.0015684519,
-0.0192872528,
-0.0177911799,
-0.0015085966,
-0.0228002109,
0.0007327842,
0.0223669186,
-0.0020511278,
-0.0007897187,
-0.0250219274,
-0.0114258891,
-0.0073480462,
-0.0441037975,
0.053705778,
-0.0228250958,
0.03139662,
0.000001924,
-0.0374706686,
0.0321457125,
-0.0112386113,
-0.0352792256,
-0.0057970514,
0.0254873689,
-0.0154371914,
0.0150525579,
0.010019308,
0.0001453233,
0.0324509479,
0.0412564129,
0.0003691755,
0.0209127944,
0.0297242627,
0.0040602125,
-0.0423366018,
-0.0050282888,
0.0033736425,
0.0515429564,
-0.0811959058,
0.0166096371,
0.0349190496,
0.0401984714,
0.0130745787,
-0.0194846671,
0.0337154418,
0.0334096551,
-0.0012508684,
-0.0179791767,
0.0608166084,
-0.0376899727,
-0.0250924937,
-0.0233253092,
0.0713239536,
0.0395778418,
-0.0338958763,
-0.0198473465,
-0.0304214135,
0.0285899993,
0.04373933,
-0.0332402624,
0.0349730104,
0.0177844353,
0.0060033165,
0.0361653306,
-0.0204202682,
0.009298142,
0.0487643704,
-0.0041368478,
0.0918812975,
0.0013856182,
-0.0207962431,
-0.0212890245,
0.0027955889,
-0.0187581833,
-0.0581100658,
-0.018518867,
0.0632974729,
-0.0261494778,
0.0275548715,
-0.0166860484,
0.0099978037,
0.0273285881,
-0.0231590346,
0.0266851299,
0.0689394325,
0.0153371654,
0.0677912384,
-0.0384747721,
0.0309912395,
0.0145041868,
0.0262869354,
-0.021696711,
0.0081367763,
-0.0735078529,
-0.0033814854,
-0.0178856906,
0.037361823,
-0.0239959955,
-0.0089569679,
-0.0351860598,
-0.005811722,
0.0236724149,
0.0256771203,
0.011582464,
0.0011871262,
-0.0375567675,
-0.0379842371,
-0.0488203429,
0.0485171564,
-0.0802093521,
0.0582564659,
0.0320953056,
-0.0415137596,
-0.0268376488,
-0.0085845934,
0.0297233146,
-0.0281384084,
0.0091551729,
-0.0036074563,
-0.004662009,
-0.0130013349,
-0.0423202664,
-0.0402718261,
-0.0088444306,
-0.0543263294,
-0.0336727351,
-0.0632939115,
0.0144694271,
0.0414953232,
-0.0064853476,
-0.0085323201,
-0.015187108,
0.0108935423,
-0.0566992536,
0.0794378519,
0.0126372911,
0.000680122,
-0.0302731618,
0.0128140002,
0.0172306672,
0.0897065327,
-0.0260615256,
-0.0345577896,
0.0324522741,
0.0005439983,
-0.0033015832,
0.0112788659,
0.0259575192,
0.0043528355,
-0.0146183744,
0.0345811658,
0.0078192549,
0.0397562981,
0.0241538044,
0.0064018015,
-0.0435918756,
0.0060578696,
0.0508087873,
0.0794403329,
-0.0121265417,
-0.0223052651,
0.0199293867,
-0.0299427435,
-0.0102411853,
-0.0026930142,
-0.057807453,
0.015652718,
-0.0827799961,
0.0192837846,
-0.0142912073,
-0.0060236747,
-0.05217994,
0.0055542798,
-0.0201729052,
0.0118492497,
0.0068498375,
-0.0092068464,
0.0311157182,
-0.0048085498,
-0.0121225007,
0.0829574242,
0.0155545399,
-0.0585739948,
-0.0119607076,
-0.0502844341,
0.0339630246,
0.0246824827,
0.042903088,
0.0119029256,
-0.0527604371,
0.0192067903,
0.0184504017,
0.0346539132,
0.0596249625,
-0.0185540803,
0.0059420136,
-0.0327409804,
-0.0088093095,
0.0097869523,
0.0168285444,
-0.0181322321,
-0.0061954623,
0.0078259232,
-0.0257737171,
-0.0430529825,
0.0409564413,
0.0070121023,
-0.0190035067,
-0.0272822212,
-0.0600380525,
-0.018964434,
0.0105217537,
0.0027154023,
0.0208788998,
0.0178750288,
0.0091195079,
0.0000600448,
-0.005963291,
0.0248392168,
-0.0281307083,
-0.0698478371,
0.0401656032,
0.0006331446,
-0.0496538915,
-0.0102360118,
-0.0085280593,
-0.0437564366,
0.0161121394,
0.0227503367,
0.0162185505,
-0.0532203317,
0.0043585277,
-0.0445481576,
-0.0440292396,
-0.0033897804,
0.1218173429,
-0.0274766535,
0.0335828513,
0.0081574712,
0.0059017153,
0.0101431441,
-0.0488893539,
-0.032090798,
-0.002738348,
0.0093056047,
-0.0062608724,
0.0065910639,
0.009547147,
-0.0432512872,
-0.0104213273,
-0.0743304715,
-0.0048480411,
-0.0131479297,
-0.0129571632,
-0.006768431,
0.002571533,
0.0163361263,
0.0111562023,
-0.0230979882,
0.0102446061,
0.0248712171,
0.0512348674,
0.0385626629,
0.010617706,
-0.0151120815,
0.0212315004,
-0.0084143672,
-0.0246417131,
0.0229926482,
0.0255802833,
0.0979631171,
-0.033971522,
0.0231957678,
-0.0451942608,
0.0060366294,
0.0157638472,
-0.0526090376,
0.027212169,
-0.0046572909,
-0.0086822147,
0.091313988,
-0.0412017517,
0.0084564229,
0.0271490552,
0.0062294123,
-0.0405541062,
0.0043482184,
-0.0119887115,
-0.0089228144,
-0.0142281186,
-0.0007471608,
-0.0535348468,
0.077045396,
-0.0078907758,
-0.0063226218,
-0.0785413831,
0.0602254048,
0.002215236,
-0.0121964784,
-0.0642868504,
0.0162465498,
-0.0010120353,
0.0860961527,
-0.0189533997,
-0.0101852175,
0.0590077974,
-0.0037893574,
0.0199803635,
-0.0343841836,
0.0521755442,
-0.0035539123,
0.0386078097,
-0.0419918709,
0.0109050805,
0.0147821689,
0.0026725437,
-0.0406581871,
-0.064546898,
0.0640779659,
-0.015162209,
0.012324851,
-0.0479149744,
0.0386988409,
-0.0377596952,
-0.062522687,
-0.0273211896,
-0.0668133572,
-0.0435026065,
0.0408993252,
0.0049034865,
-0.00580246,
-0.0483282469,
0.0067703025,
0.0260192454,
0.0126071488,
0.0005168476,
-0.0103253787,
-0.0048378385,
0.0485873297,
0.0259599704,
0.0335353538,
0.00791521,
0.018943999,
0.0106352754,
0.0578795075,
0.0694813207,
0.0127909537,
0.0160469413,
0.0430957451,
0.0366102867,
-0.0345501043,
-0.0077095605,
0.0493240133,
0.0634003431,
-0.0186068863,
-0.0230669305,
0.0980151296,
0.0586707294,
0.0185275134,
0.0005477782,
-0.0371527188,
0.0227673799,
0.0141856428,
0.0108386986,
-0.0966113284,
-0.0589581691,
0.0342908762,
-0.0151150888,
-0.0396486223,
-0.0781251788,
0.0294176526,
-0.1342366338,
0.0163102653,
-0.0033473673,
-0.0653914213,
-0.0267270077,
-0.0542178005,
0.0076460722,
-0.0202333461,
-0.0001696195,
0.0496847816,
0.018144846,
0.0049727159,
-0.0030172002,
0.0210716836,
-0.0839109495,
0.0599620678,
-0.0391816348,
0.0844428763,
0.0188976135,
0.0385441408,
0.0075667105,
-0.0927984491,
-0.0030214048,
-0.0451887697,
0.0171647742,
-0.0340359248,
-0.0239094105,
0.0007503781,
0.0021671453,
-0.0144518567,
0.0573969185,
-0.047843039,
-0.0347011201,
-0.0027542801,
0.0786108002,
-0.0128238639,
-0.0000726408,
-0.0192803405,
-0.0018788539,
0.0020485334,
0.0885001943,
0.0285671018,
0.0090277288,
-0.0560328588,
-0.0486623608,
-0.0660530478,
-0.0528025851,
-0.0466690175,
0.0140386652,
0.0277134255,
-0.0156137701,
-0.0244137291,
-0.02900034,
0.0473304875,
0.0609073788,
-0.0100424727,
0.0004017843,
-0.0297324415,
0.0323727801,
-0.0086471345,
0.0301037431,
-0.0549700633,
-0.0040530278,
-0.0331413522,
0.0391759388,
0.0270691942,
-0.0148727298,
-0.0286305919,
0.005825765,
-0.0281680208,
-0.0636288673,
-0.0063864538,
0.0485715792,
0.0381409451,
-0.0037205704,
-0.0480304249,
-0.0391983129,
0.0372448079,
0.0353013948,
-0.0191813074,
0.0118063828,
0.0265789721,
-0.0097375745,
0.0348219983,
0.0664909184,
0.0034634692,
0.0214405302,
0.0226980411,
0.075423114,
-0.0539981797,
-0.0121222492,
0.0075748451,
0.0318623446,
0.0208505206,
0.0065369629,
0.0159506835,
0.0054584327,
-0.0028876434,
-0.0457441621,
-0.0402034633,
0.0192098469,
-0.000535863,
0.0436546355,
-0.0253005624,
-0.0277565904,
0.0134263365,
-0.044467587,
0.059012942,
-0.0128664281,
0.0173301362,
0.066192694,
0.0075166961,
0.0225939751,
-0.0446524322,
-0.0221832413,
-0.0056566456,
-0.0457288884,
0.0532046705,
-0.0025894407,
0.073533006,
0.0324160978,
-0.0036224634,
-0.0409928337,
-0.0231041238,
-0.0778036714,
-0.0007509373,
0.0563761219,
0.0803173184,
0.024075333,
-0.0088280542,
-0.0130399037,
0.0031301531,
-0.0233794339,
0.0199779198,
0.02403678,
0.0430041552,
-0.0255031418,
0.0534286126,
0.0261760857,
0.0045962138,
-0.0007072372,
0.0594324581,
-0.0464135148,
0.0299078766,
0.0174393971,
-0.0068889344,
-0.012354102,
-0.0179061703,
0.0014527888,
0.0234806538,
0.0157866646,
0.0314239524,
-0.1185600907,
-0.0394044742,
0.017960554,
0.0462582633,
0.0110168997,
-0.0069849137,
-0.0093564494,
0.0785091743,
0.0150985839,
-0.0437027812,
-0.0194975324,
0.0311095119,
-0.0910168961,
-0.0019404569,
-0.04746975,
-6.52304517e-33,
-0.0235483497,
-0.0027641379,
0.0285672061,
-0.0550409816,
0.0127379391,
-0.022425551,
-0.0397484861,
0.0166268703,
-0.0548149198,
0.0106214117,
-0.0487885363,
0.0281931609,
0.0071305661,
-0.0028951985,
0.0165350195,
-0.0295355394,
0.0079232212,
0.004022805,
-0.0750945881,
-0.0391190127,
0.0447109118,
-0.0467264801,
0.0187053047,
0.032867454,
0.0400283001,
-0.0074999342,
0.0054669636,
0.0264795572,
-0.0345946141,
0.0565493889,
0.0080396077,
0.035872981,
0.0184118114,
-0.0240351409,
0.0317846388,
0.0292737819,
-0.05682154,
-0.0536887608,
0.0686654374,
-0.0264598429,
-0.018446682,
-0.0262812711,
-0.0011071258,
0.0156208212,
-0.0477501638,
-0.0068086837,
-0.0010593061,
-0.0517341234,
-0.0245861113,
0.0161285214,
-0.0266262665,
0.0073888311,
-0.0147115169,
-0.0212181192,
-0.0164101701,
0.0140827764,
-0.0136494804,
0.019280361,
-0.0555971637,
0.0235953741,
0.0326516591,
0.0078018685,
0.0549362972,
-0.0050279875,
0.0025408105,
0.0414487459,
-0.0371485762,
0.0034363482,
-0.0534616634,
0.0219870377,
0.0315548033,
0.0417846963,
0.0553173274,
0.082515806,
0.0484720543,
0.0068597659,
-0.0490574129,
0.0123633211,
0.0239857528,
0.0479292497,
0.0570872091,
0.0081309834,
-0.0660243854,
-0.027364511,
-0.062707454,
-0.0347066633,
-0.0502367988,
0.0061798044,
0.0126636634,
-0.0226708315,
-0.0554859042,
-0.0007167608,
0.05526077,
-0.0057190512,
-0.0074072969,
0.0488313995,
0.0142216049,
0.0135833723,
-0.0156290401,
0.0329801887,
-0.0668245479,
0.0069306446,
0.0096410485,
0.0387027711,
-0.0097654304,
0.0332059711,
0.0148586808,
0.0041925074,
-0.0227447767,
-0.0493037216,
-0.0353627428,
-0.0037776723,
-0.02206444,
-0.0045774798,
0.0505425148,
0.0208247546,
0.0170986131,
0.0040735039,
-0.0026636899,
-0.041419033,
-0.0113418326,
0.0384983681,
-0.0033155035,
-0.001547315,
-0.0116453301,
0.0020667873,
-0.0453679487,
-0.018048713,
-0.0058481684,
-0.0305917561,
-0.0113552967,
0.0655386522,
2.478e-7,
0.0186377168,
0.0153783755,
-0.0094201081,
0.006563609,
0.0076924199,
0.0513510816,
-0.0207855571,
0.0011313539,
0.016724918,
-0.0463185422,
-0.0033470835,
0.0670155659,
0.0059642782,
0.0142340893,
-0.0432475545,
-0.0004426857,
-0.0324172713,
0.0057085631,
-0.0194974262,
-0.0035839912,
0.0543621257,
0.0537699908,
0.0047614947,
-0.0052857562,
0.0264982879,
-0.0557025634,
0.0223091915,
-0.0076609999,
0.0080461465,
0.0054668197,
-0.0048245024,
0.0238969624,
0.0338470787,
0.0729559138,
0.0295727141,
-0.0009159867,
-0.0330690928,
0.0612052456,
-0.0254642852,
-0.0197758283,
-0.0483674482,
-0.0813260078,
-0.0067859921,
-0.0610381626,
0.1206666976,
-0.0778603926,
-0.0331236683,
-0.0097787548,
-0.0224187691,
0.0223906171,
-0.0089345928,
0.0200615451,
-0.0245270543,
-0.0071839401,
0.0214944351,
-0.0030331789,
-0.0142282145,
-0.0455113314,
-0.022289142,
0.0132275671,
0.0200715158,
-0.0820783675,
-0.0066975998,
-0.0435302928,
0.03648993,
-0.1036181226,
-0.0285944287,
2.086976344e-34,
0.017573474,
-0.009624335,
0.0268281233,
0.0126125058,
0.0230068043,
-0.0128439544,
-0.0197738912,
-0.0016279466,
0.0681580454,
-0.0857423991,
-0.0092698587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08242v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08242v3 | The Deep Latent Position Topic Model for Clustering and Representation of Networks with Textual Edges | 2023-04-14T07:01:57 | 2024-02-13T14:14:14 | Rémi Boutin, Pierre Latouche, Charles Bouveyron | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI, stat.ME | Numerical interactions leading to users sharing textual content published by
others are naturally represented by a network where the individuals are
associated with the nodes and the exchanged texts with the edges. To understand
those heterogeneous and complex data structures, clustering nodes into
homogeneous groups as well as rendering a comprehensible visualisation of the
data is mandatory. To address both issues, we introduce Deep-LPTM, a
model-based clustering strategy relying on a variational graph auto-encoder
approach as well as a probabilistic model to characterise the topics of
discussion. Deep-LPTM allows to build a joint representation of the nodes and
of the edges in two embeddings spaces. The parameters are inferred using a
variational inference algorithm. We also introduce IC2L, a model selection
criterion specifically designed to choose models with relevant clustering and
visualisation properties. An extensive benchmark study on synthetic data is
provided. In particular, we find that Deep-LPTM better recovers the partitions
of the nodes than the state-of-the art ETSBM and STBM. Eventually, the emails
of the Enron company are analysed and visualisations of the results are
presented, with meaningful highlights of the graph structure. | [
0.0122973621,
0.0153647577,
-0.0282729305,
0.0316006392,
-0.0251668133,
-0.0068552704,
0.0066019613,
-0.021374654,
0.0331669822,
-0.0106417043,
0.0334340408,
-0.0176341441,
-0.0181044396,
0.0774406865,
0.0406531543,
-0.0470906049,
-0.010325294,
-0.0061471891,
0.0234805029,
-0.0190974418,
0.045924291,
0.0000776428,
0.0297773201,
-0.0030308121,
-0.0207350049,
-0.0072509926,
-0.0448289923,
-0.0167200044,
0.027253313,
-0.0078814439,
-0.0235237256,
0.0326502137,
0.0703491941,
-0.0202492494,
0.0000021482,
0.0220799632,
-0.0467046499,
-0.0409136824,
-0.0090684472,
0.0261894427,
0.0487671755,
-0.032901112,
0.0222958531,
0.0123970648,
-0.0400049724,
0.0196871795,
0.0289062187,
0.0500794016,
0.046431236,
0.0459451973,
-0.0491833277,
-0.0181193165,
0.0329471156,
-0.0398687422,
0.0101511581,
-0.0330447443,
0.0252182577,
0.0057090237,
-0.0007746278,
0.0757657588,
-0.0120976018,
0.0089741554,
0.0220402814,
-0.0499919094,
0.0713389143,
0.0314694941,
0.0391194411,
-0.0169337299,
0.0081462963,
0.0662929267,
0.0076695159,
0.0316356719,
0.0382407717,
-0.0231286716,
-0.0218022,
0.0568784811,
-0.0429217219,
0.0176236108,
0.0183014963,
0.0111122727,
0.0085172653,
0.0451180972,
0.0306902807,
-0.0465758815,
-0.0150518352,
0.0090769166,
-0.0044983104,
0.0028545631,
-0.0401393138,
0.0000997312,
-0.01703614,
-0.0125449998,
0.06873741,
-0.0102577535,
0.0459039137,
0.0079890462,
0.0121127954,
-0.0246156156,
-0.0246137101,
-0.0337122828,
-0.0260034129,
-0.0565950237,
0.0333449356,
0.0408383384,
0.0212224554,
-0.0240013152,
-0.0475094542,
-0.0208503529,
-0.0128038386,
-0.010688073,
-0.0045231213,
-0.0131263286,
-0.0107641108,
0.0346501507,
-0.0243639015,
-0.033634983,
-0.0370303616,
0.03445803,
-0.0519190617,
-0.0289836898,
-0.0094837202,
0.051800862,
-0.0009073504,
-0.0025911271,
0.0093132854,
-0.0085994154,
-0.0581031367,
0.0515145324,
-0.0097669335,
0.0379372053,
0.0291685835,
0.0190778431,
0.0498339087,
-0.0149611337,
-0.04521906,
0.0231807139,
-0.0082021896,
-0.0029852008,
-0.0139817977,
-0.0152545208,
-0.0052600764,
0.0192579757,
0.0337883085,
-0.0620158426,
0.0355831906,
0.0103795864,
-0.0116401613,
0.0184295438,
-0.0327362679,
-0.0330442041,
-0.0426444523,
0.0408139043,
-0.004817971,
-0.0271506812,
0.0602928214,
0.0177518353,
0.0249722637,
-0.0125693511,
0.0137872444,
0.057940755,
0.0190286227,
0.0104207098,
-0.0192332137,
0.0003876742,
0.0404264256,
-0.0151643027,
0.0320538655,
-0.015950311,
-0.0541376658,
-0.0105680395,
0.0300569925,
0.0379408896,
-0.0542206839,
-0.0523410067,
-0.0089075109,
0.0614070669,
-0.0010724027,
0.0392295606,
-0.0154998833,
0.0424312875,
-0.0205046237,
-0.0006983227,
0.0426500514,
0.0392585248,
0.0169865545,
-0.0161881912,
0.0529941358,
-0.0205663331,
-0.0260638259,
-0.0129446248,
0.0510548577,
0.0011634122,
0.0504566059,
-0.0393652841,
0.0688406751,
-0.0480679981,
-0.01334647,
0.0305584334,
0.0064974022,
0.0317151658,
-0.0031583277,
0.0326930396,
-0.008459786,
0.0303693451,
-0.0023860903,
-0.0287908558,
0.0227058213,
-0.0283999592,
0.0041701742,
-0.0367923118,
-0.0177009106,
-0.0024992921,
-0.0557883233,
-0.0316694938,
-0.0434117839,
-0.0436219573,
0.0004258743,
0.051656954,
-0.0499832854,
0.0015639452,
0.0266637895,
-0.0204617921,
0.038042333,
-0.0099007748,
0.0055853189,
0.0731187463,
0.0407836251,
0.0031219912,
0.0263742264,
0.0672105253,
0.0094106598,
-0.0213569235,
0.0292514991,
-0.0378349796,
-0.0132266115,
-0.0445177108,
-0.0447655506,
-0.0047895606,
-0.0028503886,
-0.0818554237,
-0.0088774217,
-0.0195609611,
-0.0235470217,
-0.0573904701,
0.086429432,
-0.0438807718,
-0.0037813445,
-0.0229321271,
-0.0551473759,
-0.0059471657,
0.0029441309,
0.0114489589,
0.0601526834,
-0.0473113805,
0.0115762679,
0.0373549908,
0.0177085921,
0.0098707378,
-0.0389374048,
-0.025994176,
-0.0218002219,
0.0062044812,
0.0394115411,
0.0660737976,
-0.0195133928,
0.0058005829,
-0.0182523448,
-0.0888919383,
0.0033048287,
-0.025430819,
-0.0194167458,
0.0127906306,
0.008360872,
0.0320745185,
0.0084062926,
-0.05144272,
0.0264642294,
-0.0075885332,
0.0050449125,
0.0410712585,
-0.0162006803,
0.0211601872,
-0.0600562133,
-0.0502109975,
-0.0290792603,
0.0673310384,
0.0405122861,
-0.0297762845,
-0.0004310195,
0.018376179,
-0.0169302635,
-0.0156965703,
-0.0544921197,
0.0327634923,
0.0198995788,
-0.026715694,
0.068923004,
0.0010052259,
0.028456049,
0.127620846,
-0.008622691,
0.0101037528,
-0.045986101,
-0.0209228061,
-0.0596761405,
0.0580920689,
-0.0233486518,
-0.0547085851,
-0.0116506945,
0.0164455902,
0.035517402,
0.0130198821,
-0.0333229825,
0.0022173417,
-0.0064967857,
0.0128931338,
-0.051188238,
-0.0406974182,
0.0413463749,
-0.0092668962,
-0.0263088048,
-0.0476076901,
0.0681064874,
0.0115555255,
0.0393844619,
0.0150561696,
-0.0558502078,
-0.0015588884,
0.0451040827,
0.0477645956,
0.0067332541,
-0.030291127,
-0.0417185165,
-0.0122310715,
0.0602468587,
0.0354884751,
0.0033646848,
-0.0227738693,
0.031443987,
0.0182835795,
0.0490953177,
0.0215555988,
0.0111402981,
-0.0445050597,
0.0325350091,
0.0204489641,
0.0751626194,
-0.0051501486,
-0.0244085789,
0.0191315673,
-0.0004885985,
-0.0226757452,
-0.0043582148,
0.0046966095,
-0.0188743174,
0.0744985715,
0.0371773615,
-0.0834321827,
-0.0196577888,
-0.054406058,
-0.0072923764,
0.0348654017,
0.0039019932,
-0.000015637,
-0.0565122962,
0.0136979707,
-0.0366431922,
0.0027570545,
-0.0028429134,
-0.0413997583,
0.0367475711,
0.0450573117,
-0.0066254986,
0.0884800553,
0.0256018247,
-0.0856788605,
0.0038037789,
0.0199277941,
0.0170337539,
-0.0067053367,
0.0117825912,
-0.0637812093,
0.0434614681,
-0.0384279266,
-0.0130876377,
0.0301126596,
-0.0589251965,
0.025899753,
-0.0177879501,
0.0218330603,
0.0093074879,
0.0065872916,
-0.0051474911,
-0.115202561,
-0.0045518256,
-0.0291989278,
-0.0013421229,
-0.03782757,
0.0153548671,
-0.015456412,
0.0245224722,
-0.0430600233,
-0.0059697097,
-0.0022347299,
-0.0431019142,
0.0291950982,
-0.0172613785,
-0.0005122029,
-0.0073769973,
0.0214942079,
0.0081738774,
-0.0159144662,
-0.0237517077,
0.003983472,
0.0451810546,
-0.0088227084,
0.0139531288,
-0.0534057021,
0.0352563336,
-0.0365822762,
-0.0055490863,
-0.0449165627,
0.061580874,
-0.0348392725,
-0.0282076709,
-0.0545113645,
-0.0047469749,
-0.0075031719,
0.0020185218,
0.0231272485,
-0.0051984051,
-0.0031571803,
-0.0488305427,
0.0576656014,
0.0585735105,
0.0097331479,
-0.031929642,
0.0033841771,
-0.0175321158,
-0.0264833514,
-0.0295329858,
0.0091337459,
0.0056676189,
-0.0441162549,
-0.0138694402,
0.054127086,
-0.0776596367,
-0.0396185592,
0.0128604621,
0.0062965997,
0.01614739,
0.0219160803,
-0.0142494384,
0.0371992253,
0.0025948002,
-0.0290764626,
-0.0171619225,
-0.0722958595,
-0.0723127648,
-0.0372283868,
-0.009241526,
0.0134290028,
0.0594310053,
-0.0452404954,
-0.0712901801,
0.0476922654,
-0.0022445712,
-0.0189934783,
-0.0426483862,
-0.0374133438,
-0.0109910341,
-0.0192682706,
-0.0097947,
-0.0397853032,
0.0326319709,
-0.0331225395,
-0.0084062861,
-0.1205263287,
-0.0791629851,
-0.0202077441,
-0.0180887841,
0.0470716879,
0.0696680024,
-0.0499995239,
-0.0937595889,
-0.0750192702,
-0.0316926576,
-0.0042804978,
0.006530094,
-0.0114359977,
0.0251324642,
-0.0214520041,
-0.0097780842,
-0.0020437527,
0.022199966,
0.0242848247,
-0.0287856609,
0.0228376891,
0.0192812756,
-0.0083513064,
-0.0076336167,
0.044667013,
0.015395618,
0.0058929669,
-0.0106498217,
0.0115633775,
0.0242507067,
0.007278509,
-0.0098476093,
0.0001352687,
-0.0266420357,
0.0319031402,
-0.0626473576,
-0.0088100573,
0.0022149894,
0.041742906,
0.0145991668,
-0.0064909011,
0.0518089198,
-0.0159458984,
0.0110111162,
-0.0235972274,
0.0624873415,
-0.0040684049,
-0.0444033854,
0.0300015528,
0.026566077,
-0.0308872852,
0.0516522303,
0.0501692854,
0.0331666917,
-0.0441557951,
-0.0097242584,
-0.0637049377,
-0.0251584835,
0.0259908941,
0.0494007468,
0.0643844008,
-0.0072444454,
0.0095995246,
0.0124105792,
-0.0460403748,
0.0249499567,
-0.0024015054,
-0.0161551051,
0.0250592977,
0.0403322913,
0.0990375802,
-0.000884307,
0.0474544279,
-0.0446581654,
-0.0030664511,
0.0072061387,
-0.0752349719,
-0.024742486,
-6.675707356e-33,
0.0172170121,
-0.0717328191,
-0.0243670456,
0.0018510718,
-0.0369830802,
0.0377867669,
-0.0509174913,
0.0187800247,
-0.0027033582,
0.0200699698,
0.0091408119,
0.0294501744,
-0.0048294286,
0.0110212173,
-0.0053511919,
0.0016567984,
0.0256768968,
-0.00999323,
0.033487834,
0.0680149347,
0.0342440829,
0.0359611809,
0.0103361495,
-0.0593316965,
0.0687598661,
-0.0340270773,
0.0326999202,
-0.002987667,
0.0878896043,
0.0228784438,
-0.0540998839,
0.0269158985,
0.0291762352,
-0.002779129,
-0.0139182666,
-0.0023201604,
-0.0404189564,
-0.0580409095,
-0.0233275257,
-0.0318762995,
-0.0216451623,
-0.0319579914,
0.0690065324,
0.0391915739,
0.0549935251,
-0.038331341,
0.0979728922,
0.0581443869,
-0.0402119979,
-0.0128736915,
0.0147999534,
0.0439095944,
-0.0711323991,
0.024273457,
-0.0019636301,
-0.0150303636,
0.0348129757,
0.0155726774,
-0.0805131271,
0.0335792601,
-0.0064773895,
-0.022811953,
0.0257187579,
-0.0103649721,
0.0211186539,
0.0484055318,
-0.0031488892,
0.0404989012,
-0.0405441187,
0.0343172587,
0.0009660028,
0.0749659166,
0.0088486262,
-0.0180560276,
-0.0702032819,
0.0053465543,
-0.0810019076,
0.0468468219,
0.0092619434,
-0.0358738936,
0.0124679729,
0.0600244403,
-0.0277374703,
-0.0687758103,
0.0075090732,
-0.0505147353,
-0.0097159287,
-0.0338514149,
-0.0304784793,
-0.0126682892,
-0.0381445773,
0.002033954,
0.0172505882,
-0.0340840779,
-0.0384990871,
0.0385143496,
0.0191662088,
0.0604455099,
0.0081164492,
0.0299854167,
-0.0527361482,
-0.0066284095,
-0.0147497458,
-0.0267620925,
-0.0306231044,
0.0138590885,
-0.0159390178,
-0.0392806083,
0.0166616961,
-0.0188806877,
0.0116319116,
-0.0554506481,
-0.0594245531,
0.017341733,
0.004247929,
0.0260773618,
-0.0102432324,
0.0832321122,
0.0408677645,
0.0513451286,
0.0354406387,
-0.0006691194,
-0.0171851274,
0.0015977635,
-0.0121517451,
-0.0273158681,
-0.0402743705,
0.0469204374,
0.075534299,
-0.0528136976,
-0.0128631257,
-0.0322223082,
2.798e-7,
0.0631737709,
0.0234921947,
0.0692094415,
-0.0066389991,
0.0461141653,
0.0443629473,
0.0299552772,
0.0390721262,
0.0067961407,
-0.0477845855,
0.0491974652,
0.0635202006,
-0.0234111659,
0.0216287691,
-0.0176501833,
0.0340113938,
-0.0782249048,
-0.022297807,
-0.0278724544,
0.0038345293,
0.0292527787,
0.0493989401,
0.0179243088,
0.0210742354,
-0.0286648702,
-0.010930296,
0.0695832372,
-0.0421171971,
-0.0431494452,
0.0204895139,
0.0543025471,
-0.0252906978,
-0.0209471732,
-0.0026429836,
-0.0004407456,
-0.0003448626,
0.0138306217,
0.0075297528,
-0.0098213097,
0.0009916787,
0.012899044,
-0.0496944971,
-0.0023970921,
-0.04034058,
0.0157045182,
-0.0669107214,
-0.0496011302,
0.0324964672,
-0.0606685095,
-0.0034325039,
0.0268296394,
0.007068546,
-0.0151183233,
0.0380580612,
-0.0260735694,
-0.023567684,
0.0290622935,
-0.032247711,
0.0711155757,
0.0220783409,
-0.0628919378,
0.0012469144,
-0.0067925504,
-0.0112553081,
0.0708031058,
0.0511930212,
0.0665574744,
2.240373765e-34,
0.0390811227,
0.015731629,
-0.0221065804,
0.0081396969,
0.0154335126,
-0.0224916134,
-0.0314937979,
-0.0024600804,
0.0024568161,
-0.0837271661,
-0.0444095172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06939v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06939v3 | Multimodal C4: An Open, Billion-scale Corpus of Images Interleaved with Text | 2023-04-14T06:17:46 | 2023-10-28T04:19:41 | Wanrong Zhu, Jack Hessel, Anas Awadalla, Samir Yitzhak Gadre, Jesse Dodge, Alex Fang, Youngjae Yu, Ludwig Schmidt, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In-context vision and language models like Flamingo support arbitrarily
interleaved sequences of images and text as input. This format not only enables
few-shot learning via interleaving independent supervised (image, text)
examples, but also, more complex prompts involving interaction between images,
e.g., "What do image A and image B have in common?" To support this interface,
pretraining occurs over web corpora that similarly contain interleaved
images+text. To date, however, large-scale data of this form have not been
publicly available.
We release Multimodal C4, an augmentation of the popular text-only C4 corpus
with images interleaved. We use a linear assignment algorithm to place images
into longer bodies of text using CLIP features, a process that we show
outperforms alternatives. Multimodal C4 spans everyday topics like cooking,
travel, technology, etc. A manual inspection of a random sample of documents
shows that a vast majority (88%) of images are topically relevant, and that
linear assignment frequently selects individual sentences specifically
well-aligned with each image (80%). After filtering NSFW images, ads, etc., the
resulting corpus consists of 101.2M documents with 571M images interleaved in
43B English tokens. | [
0.041779127,
0.0697337613,
-0.0025471605,
0.0419366881,
-0.0391770378,
0.0283056349,
0.0364390425,
0.022227332,
0.0130611956,
-0.0850954875,
-0.0359483585,
-0.0274507627,
-0.0228828248,
0.035846062,
0.0106210001,
-0.0877698213,
0.0108175371,
-0.0269645192,
0.0091919675,
0.030566724,
0.0679876953,
-0.0000232634,
0.0061316285,
-0.0131747499,
-0.0414168015,
-0.0053325775,
-0.0063639404,
0.0405420773,
0.0180941653,
-0.0071026958,
0.0188213754,
0.0527828932,
0.0435158312,
-0.0079434831,
0.0000017123,
0.0089837089,
0.0216894075,
0.0048703454,
0.0328071602,
-0.0098152524,
0.0602730699,
-0.0236501228,
0.0115067558,
-0.0152621437,
-0.0353941917,
0.011075221,
0.0591453202,
0.0530022942,
0.0804174468,
0.0805115476,
-0.0404738449,
-0.0288829431,
-0.0221919734,
-0.0178614724,
0.0253202654,
-0.0162476413,
0.0074531226,
-0.0300583337,
-0.0005530571,
0.0550381206,
-0.0366175994,
0.0501141958,
0.0007596179,
-0.0279189646,
0.0273151174,
0.0468774438,
-0.0498420522,
-0.0541945361,
-0.0255411565,
0.1035908163,
-0.049077332,
-0.0116562992,
-0.008559634,
-0.0036643476,
0.0042748991,
-0.0107740145,
-0.0660012811,
0.0204481203,
0.0089446036,
0.0250026006,
-0.0690779015,
-0.0088478588,
0.0023401708,
0.020318646,
0.0132582663,
-0.0341786891,
0.0121358484,
-0.0068256492,
0.0127120391,
0.0253144838,
-0.0214970205,
-0.0532509312,
0.0205501262,
0.005412579,
0.0136694498,
0.0255184416,
-0.0575120635,
-0.0163928233,
0.0044835289,
-0.0425525345,
0.0021948765,
-0.0158333927,
-0.0540952533,
0.071279116,
-0.0004286782,
0.004310831,
-0.0242846478,
0.0184032004,
-0.0386386067,
0.0032832045,
-0.0239666831,
-0.0012755842,
-0.0036961236,
-0.0015325298,
-0.0652711615,
-0.0632674322,
-0.0154367788,
0.0210636277,
-0.01512965,
0.0000215518,
-0.024399275,
0.0164444037,
-0.0286321826,
0.0024337706,
-0.0054687816,
0.0278043039,
0.0111830691,
0.0351829566,
0.0005798404,
-0.035927292,
0.0114639662,
0.0190923195,
0.0450747795,
-0.0385561101,
-0.0028568148,
0.0574285202,
-0.0621770248,
-0.051459007,
0.0053104651,
-0.0321437791,
-0.0664575472,
-0.0363505632,
0.0316683687,
-0.0729570165,
0.0293316804,
-0.0166123211,
0.0205885097,
-0.0233422685,
0.0141143156,
0.04274901,
-0.0514406487,
0.1281568855,
0.0169971678,
-0.03553712,
0.0087726861,
0.0235782526,
0.0122535722,
0.0674663931,
0.018400196,
0.0680311099,
0.0701581538,
0.0141633963,
0.0310408585,
0.0360290632,
-0.0127541777,
0.0113466401,
-0.0242424719,
0.0092876051,
0.0098181954,
0.0101093678,
0.0402994156,
0.0476118103,
-0.0281115025,
0.0017061725,
0.0882957578,
0.0390166454,
-0.0319386423,
0.0087923203,
0.0254973937,
0.0302050617,
0.005526769,
0.0104798377,
-0.0785100311,
0.0454934053,
0.0002845525,
-0.0071561383,
0.052395016,
0.0365090743,
-0.0367703028,
-0.0124670696,
0.010923665,
-0.0365806222,
0.0266722478,
-0.0154617662,
0.0372200385,
-0.0006279816,
-0.0304882415,
-0.0081102308,
-0.0076763164,
-0.0559133217,
-0.0130125238,
0.0207589753,
0.0208558571,
0.0693560839,
0.0081937537,
-0.0132215247,
-0.0116204768,
-0.0068072625,
0.0926981345,
0.0410908163,
-0.0197555888,
0.014410397,
0.0154156275,
-0.0597875342,
-0.0602688976,
-0.0155017544,
-0.0233449619,
-0.0180921089,
-0.0016345897,
0.0302069988,
0.0166784674,
0.0230391826,
-0.0267235804,
0.0241246037,
0.0585419349,
-0.0075081401,
-0.0201876853,
0.0429499485,
-0.0094052823,
-0.0176548846,
-0.0304212272,
0.0064043161,
0.0251155794,
-0.0229129419,
-0.0141195199,
0.0388947092,
-0.0259672217,
-0.036437545,
0.0258422457,
-0.0983672589,
-0.0170218386,
0.0158786681,
-0.0756974369,
-0.0248361472,
-0.0057428442,
-0.0386624895,
0.0190693848,
-0.0433513746,
-0.0068402239,
0.0284654573,
0.0408058017,
0.0052232784,
0.0534081124,
0.0104107885,
-0.0183016546,
-0.0204044189,
-0.0047319345,
0.0063507068,
-0.0156667959,
-0.0233193468,
-0.0123961167,
-0.0096849538,
0.0245950017,
0.0277611911,
0.0292807836,
-0.0625290796,
0.0110910023,
-0.1212290302,
-0.0096048806,
-0.0009698535,
0.0026147678,
-0.0126680471,
0.0039457409,
0.0219428539,
-0.0599535219,
-0.0546072051,
0.0144345565,
-0.0280830748,
0.0381090231,
0.0346921571,
0.0067071095,
0.0451974832,
-0.022298133,
-0.032451123,
0.0297633726,
0.0701366588,
0.0078289239,
-0.0265783053,
-0.0119482763,
-0.0227235965,
0.0024796205,
0.017513819,
-0.0078499829,
-0.0221072864,
-0.0033045092,
-0.0230322871,
0.0102992058,
0.0665933862,
0.0360498689,
-0.0117230108,
-0.0243615173,
0.0269793849,
-0.0497597232,
-0.0045720907,
0.038794145,
-0.0059926198,
-0.0101000993,
-0.0218913164,
-0.0020626923,
0.0054086847,
-0.0444356166,
0.0172709394,
-0.0390585773,
0.0233572666,
0.0190758146,
-0.0227206256,
-0.0880677402,
0.0048645465,
-0.0057007056,
0.0212685242,
-0.0518223792,
-0.0606161617,
0.0109865339,
-0.0038726651,
-0.0207178295,
-0.0110858269,
0.0004303577,
-0.0138922725,
0.0646815822,
0.0262627173,
0.0369506888,
0.0144993206,
-0.0044747791,
-0.0364144892,
0.0071770232,
-0.0044472232,
-0.0106676342,
0.0661428422,
-0.0325004794,
0.0111529408,
-0.0285950899,
-0.0877083838,
-0.0290658362,
-0.0777681395,
-0.0133445794,
-0.0476185381,
-0.0042716567,
-0.0058361269,
-0.0179153271,
0.0098660346,
0.0183669161,
0.0209719501,
0.0100266077,
0.0008012913,
-0.0046047075,
0.0962778628,
0.0759790018,
0.0081261536,
-0.0470991917,
-0.0167345069,
-0.0411375426,
0.0606099404,
0.0239009652,
-0.0004649498,
-0.03294117,
0.0616345778,
-0.0003844356,
0.0161296278,
-0.0123666795,
0.0060915793,
0.0429237112,
-0.0129136611,
-0.009586296,
0.0545593873,
0.0235125963,
-0.0815045908,
-0.0341561623,
0.0568624213,
-0.0115374429,
0.0363280736,
0.0230367519,
-0.082444489,
-0.0522500686,
-0.0052003344,
-0.0340076797,
0.0102895265,
0.0191609524,
-0.0431933962,
-0.0823528692,
0.0307595655,
0.0144885406,
-0.004944487,
-0.0178728942,
-0.0148366988,
-0.009132674,
-0.0106111923,
-0.0249097552,
-0.0113058425,
-0.032252416,
-0.0099711688,
0.0024060523,
0.0380166806,
-0.0457387753,
-0.0112185376,
-0.0380827188,
-0.0205464847,
0.0106733805,
0.0480491072,
-0.0287061241,
-0.0557529032,
0.0476562977,
0.0350833945,
-0.0223781317,
-0.0061036241,
0.0862632468,
-0.0380371287,
-0.0277898535,
-0.0176460817,
0.0362854041,
0.0098393131,
-0.0240182895,
0.0057945023,
0.0585846305,
0.0160236601,
-0.0040335124,
-0.0596428327,
-0.000390701,
0.0410392247,
0.0299788564,
0.0136762019,
-0.0745319352,
-0.0227770023,
-0.0265554357,
-0.0206273869,
-0.028318461,
0.0050938162,
0.0016726629,
-0.0328589454,
-0.0160527322,
-0.0998529121,
0.0084072454,
0.033063408,
0.0422577783,
0.0068462258,
-0.0228284374,
-0.0362941101,
0.0301890466,
-0.0653870255,
0.0391033292,
-0.0053631784,
0.0346432775,
-0.0592622645,
0.0182981454,
0.0371928997,
-0.0544188544,
-0.0168859363,
0.0450041518,
-0.0968904197,
-0.0246142671,
-0.0426713377,
0.0736154318,
0.0102241328,
0.0354098678,
0.0095262239,
-0.0597546063,
0.0610261746,
0.0801873356,
-0.0318289064,
-0.0346588306,
0.0125158262,
-0.0196092688,
0.0011506628,
0.025817845,
-0.0475303121,
0.0210241117,
0.0052249637,
-0.0168743078,
-0.0167068206,
-0.0017295997,
-0.0030473729,
-0.0208023116,
0.0346941836,
-0.0334815718,
0.0155356014,
-0.021372024,
0.0036150578,
0.0272561628,
-0.0344759487,
-0.0561817139,
0.0148045477,
0.0132633662,
0.0322660431,
-0.0334103145,
0.0240362138,
0.0067448504,
0.0202363767,
-0.0140272416,
-0.0210539941,
0.0294462219,
-0.0225089397,
0.0033315402,
0.0147446208,
0.0216397215,
0.0233120956,
-0.0178149156,
0.0164362621,
-0.0502014197,
0.034320727,
0.0293373466,
-0.0139137553,
-0.0413841419,
0.0508281514,
-0.0353183076,
0.015064328,
-0.0328271054,
0.0106240921,
0.0549475625,
-0.0491481088,
0.0365124606,
-0.0280264225,
-0.0525724366,
-0.0197892264,
0.0343889631,
-0.0200814605,
-0.0383679047,
0.0496153645,
0.0179590955,
-0.0048343875,
0.0206038859,
0.0666436106,
-0.0171068981,
-0.0040945294,
0.0459355153,
-0.0282118153,
-0.0437538065,
0.0043842061,
0.0391251072,
0.0490584001,
-0.0100223441,
0.0138986185,
0.0062895631,
-0.0463023484,
0.0096583311,
-0.0196771137,
-0.0289196335,
0.0393269733,
0.0511462428,
0.0381600372,
0.0194752086,
0.0021710792,
-0.0056940536,
-0.0023558848,
0.0094246026,
-0.0296087395,
0.0046621952,
-5.991256669e-33,
0.0010836157,
-0.0290210862,
0.0181883648,
0.0250209682,
-0.0233561974,
-0.0036470473,
0.0017917933,
0.0099502057,
0.0226166695,
0.0112020988,
0.0026858526,
-0.0012599119,
0.0135956593,
0.0543266423,
0.0225735195,
0.0202410053,
0.0226417016,
-0.0045407456,
-0.0136559894,
0.0310271438,
0.0384484604,
0.0499551669,
0.0384480692,
-0.0298352391,
-0.0008205764,
0.0070288796,
-0.0323106907,
-0.0076532708,
0.0247381479,
0.0603355505,
-0.0318901762,
0.0293690953,
0.015468711,
0.0133237354,
-0.0141764274,
0.0833992884,
-0.0796446428,
0.001817134,
0.006652181,
0.0440848283,
-0.0595478192,
-0.0350674689,
0.0521423742,
-0.0418022983,
0.0583241433,
-0.0328919329,
0.0760139376,
-0.0194083024,
0.008069708,
-0.0057004816,
-0.0323762819,
-0.0045476346,
-0.033164341,
-0.0215045065,
0.059500616,
0.0645629168,
0.0196324624,
0.0412452668,
-0.059736602,
0.0336400867,
-0.0166416392,
0.0246780943,
0.0444812626,
0.0166726317,
-0.0101160714,
0.0602222197,
0.0066524381,
-0.0400023609,
0.0038178789,
0.0055076508,
0.0200272445,
0.0587735958,
0.0019450905,
0.067153208,
0.0524485596,
0.0021688722,
-0.0388675705,
0.0092370082,
-0.0211481694,
0.0354513191,
-0.0097100986,
0.0199093036,
0.0227172971,
0.0175269041,
0.0020329652,
-0.0125231883,
-0.0545671917,
-0.0246166401,
0.0253454447,
0.0176676977,
-0.0177688673,
0.0554381162,
0.0866693184,
-0.0243832413,
-0.0598569773,
-0.005323648,
-0.0182623044,
0.0406013578,
0.0020262562,
0.0046064146,
-0.0462430604,
-0.0360139683,
0.0375045054,
-0.0009270597,
-0.0071778037,
-0.0067162081,
0.1166544557,
0.024572093,
-0.0542204566,
-0.0000907939,
-0.0246172454,
-0.0150330244,
0.0029725558,
0.045134414,
0.0327714793,
0.024671413,
-0.0684112161,
0.012213069,
0.0100857196,
0.0002928669,
-0.0246172454,
-0.0778763518,
-0.0103355125,
0.0095661767,
-0.009583259,
0.0178907532,
-0.0528587438,
0.0080900397,
0.0417506956,
-0.0987593159,
-0.0163545962,
0.0735803396,
2.505e-7,
0.0274607986,
0.010384813,
0.0210718159,
-0.0110505512,
0.0245195236,
0.0305301175,
-0.0274278317,
0.0595227927,
-0.0253077615,
0.0092722643,
0.0000368921,
-0.0003535849,
0.0546337441,
-0.0230199881,
-0.0464185551,
0.0022537636,
-0.0457751602,
-0.0005975172,
-0.0534499772,
-0.0127071217,
0.0401791632,
0.1018277332,
0.0223465711,
-0.0321532302,
0.0292063653,
-0.0272224788,
0.0923371017,
-0.0240661893,
-0.0133082317,
-0.0356382169,
-0.0153771667,
0.0390842743,
-0.0456661656,
0.018449435,
-0.0286840014,
-0.0216409825,
0.0784620419,
0.0445454121,
-0.0127084553,
-0.0130101424,
-0.0380160585,
0.017416209,
-0.0322475247,
-0.0355579183,
0.0813529193,
-0.0301742274,
0.000793141,
-0.0298864208,
-0.0501819365,
-0.0313035659,
0.0123705408,
-0.0361387879,
-0.0424600504,
0.0366852172,
0.0513304733,
-0.0128343971,
-0.0303460453,
-0.1094861627,
-0.0203426369,
-0.004441171,
-0.0379115008,
0.0165654086,
-0.0773361847,
0.0200249404,
0.0384574831,
-0.0456022806,
-0.0354984589,
1.65789347e-34,
0.0298382957,
-0.0099233417,
0.016436832,
-0.0055443691,
0.0029904544,
0.0104628038,
-0.0192798786,
-0.0012994765,
-0.0099140173,
-0.0591353923,
-0.0067616631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06910v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06910v2 | HCAM -- Hierarchical Cross Attention Model for Multi-modal Emotion Recognition | 2023-04-14T03:25:00 | 2024-01-09T11:45:34 | Soumya Dutta, Sriram Ganapathy | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Emotion recognition in conversations is challenging due to the multi-modal
nature of the emotion expression. We propose a hierarchical cross-attention
model (HCAM) approach to multi-modal emotion recognition using a combination of
recurrent and co-attention neural network models. The input to the model
consists of two modalities, i) audio data, processed through a learnable
wav2vec approach and, ii) text data represented using a bidirectional encoder
representations from transformers (BERT) model. The audio and text
representations are processed using a set of bi-directional recurrent neural
network layers with self-attention that converts each utterance in a given
conversation to a fixed dimensional embedding. In order to incorporate
contextual knowledge and the information across the two modalities, the audio
and text embeddings are combined using a co-attention layer that attempts to
weigh the utterance level embeddings relevant to the task of emotion
recognition. The neural network parameters in the audio layers, text layers as
well as the multi-modal co-attention layers, are hierarchically trained for the
emotion classification task. We perform experiments on three established
datasets namely, IEMOCAP, MELD and CMU-MOSI, where we illustrate that the
proposed model improves significantly over other benchmarks and helps achieve
state-of-art results on all these datasets. | [
-0.0206745099,
0.0241865832,
-0.0011496422,
0.0555633269,
0.0223797653,
-0.0208907612,
0.009648731,
-0.0449519865,
0.0057801735,
-0.0608876273,
-0.087630637,
-0.0424475372,
-0.0089655351,
0.0037478688,
-0.0117579568,
-0.0528098494,
0.0275980253,
0.0445336141,
0.0282887816,
0.016431557,
-0.0033906344,
0.0148387067,
0.0002329888,
0.0189468656,
-0.0522891134,
-0.0380075686,
-0.0182614867,
0.0458025262,
0.0225306526,
-0.0296308659,
0.0316822194,
0.0466102175,
0.0399832539,
0.0132888807,
0.0000019019,
0.0190383028,
0.0312430952,
-0.0135508897,
-0.0064258468,
-0.0024628125,
0.0286482871,
-0.0045731454,
-0.031162696,
0.0177446827,
0.0113596031,
0.0192412473,
0.0123037379,
0.0911993459,
0.1120716631,
0.0575576313,
-0.0216348637,
-0.026796069,
0.0398864783,
-0.0367638543,
-0.0035384637,
-0.0177650135,
-0.005071722,
-0.000645088,
0.0143310651,
0.0005643176,
-0.0432238802,
0.0339896642,
-0.0020680474,
-0.010804086,
0.000829367,
0.0115255518,
0.0096131358,
-0.0128076319,
-0.0284473579,
0.1007981971,
-0.0284234881,
0.0216613878,
-0.0291165449,
0.0111990478,
0.006057201,
-0.0422417819,
-0.0233196337,
0.0126472376,
0.0150134228,
0.0189572554,
-0.0252109673,
0.0383311138,
0.0160586871,
-0.0146515258,
0.002536006,
-0.0017374187,
-0.0391492732,
-0.0260449219,
0.0218957532,
-0.0163312238,
0.0315310396,
-0.0046491683,
0.016464144,
0.0115434369,
0.0207341276,
-0.0073473207,
-0.0535469241,
-0.0398594439,
-0.0158430133,
-0.0687869862,
0.008440949,
0.0326590054,
-0.071402289,
0.0671696141,
0.0102894818,
0.0072561232,
-0.0402408168,
-0.0252332874,
-0.0229063425,
-0.0385284126,
-0.0264419783,
0.0204273257,
0.0029692489,
0.0270120632,
-0.0468970872,
-0.0665712878,
-0.0612008795,
0.0050766924,
-0.0395664759,
-0.0255647451,
0.0158700049,
0.0006210897,
-0.0068852948,
0.0111310398,
0.0262234379,
0.0406450704,
0.0013172483,
0.0445682593,
-0.0324330181,
-0.0326971635,
-0.0239039455,
0.0611451901,
0.0169102773,
0.0012191678,
0.014108927,
0.0753863603,
-0.0156010929,
-0.0269510653,
-0.0156582352,
-0.0142971985,
-0.0602748655,
-0.0430040509,
0.0281322505,
0.0117532741,
0.0565061457,
-0.0485396013,
-0.0127712283,
0.0126594789,
0.0066821314,
-0.017591469,
-0.0434828661,
0.0620402247,
0.0717491582,
-0.0097086076,
0.021862017,
0.0028668251,
0.0044945059,
0.0484895036,
0.0604523718,
0.0346830413,
0.0042924932,
-0.0290455483,
0.030330712,
0.0103727439,
0.0005775051,
-0.0290174447,
-0.0173712093,
-0.0013804771,
-0.0307819787,
0.0629917309,
0.0692051128,
0.0498010106,
-0.0163139049,
-0.0342058316,
0.0555075221,
0.0172232687,
0.0291310921,
0.0388706364,
-0.0019348154,
0.0347995274,
-0.0041570594,
-0.0247454792,
-0.0271631759,
0.0568553358,
-0.016936196,
-0.0212878641,
0.0682059377,
-0.0014806102,
-0.0381173231,
-0.0257702898,
0.0163119286,
-0.0284247883,
-0.0189634413,
-0.0055188923,
0.019972058,
-0.0439230166,
-0.0638358071,
0.0362069979,
-0.0024984605,
-0.0592823178,
-0.0040000528,
-0.0009151431,
0.0157285891,
0.039576795,
-0.0291458964,
-0.0794348642,
-0.0258530006,
-0.0587735921,
0.0058908374,
0.0222804938,
0.0147575671,
0.0295130312,
0.0378171578,
-0.0517059676,
-0.0016197375,
-0.0200941116,
-0.0119781252,
0.0186999235,
-0.0862242356,
0.027057834,
-0.0033501217,
0.0142413257,
0.0656119213,
0.0142696742,
0.0147366775,
-0.0058315257,
0.0031213637,
0.0211391989,
0.0641966015,
0.0468454771,
-0.0025778576,
-0.0026209862,
0.0539637767,
-0.0265898481,
-0.0131083187,
0.0209422372,
-0.0548711866,
-0.0521151759,
0.0403076001,
-0.0639185756,
-0.0094287489,
0.0213523041,
-0.0335172638,
-0.0464531146,
0.0442983769,
-0.0313450471,
0.0383377746,
-0.0524736121,
0.0098106842,
0.0153733455,
0.0806181058,
0.0380356535,
0.0350643545,
-0.0209480152,
-0.0245322436,
0.001212935,
0.0093912873,
0.0104736676,
-0.0178915709,
-0.0689842328,
0.0184766855,
-0.0075064693,
0.0137470569,
-0.0361617543,
-0.0370083153,
-0.0296272282,
-0.0717191994,
-0.0899922997,
0.0144441789,
-0.0144263199,
-0.0011347726,
-0.0225192718,
-0.0065155593,
-0.0030315747,
-0.0209589954,
-0.0361606851,
-0.0003382971,
-0.0030674993,
-0.0045585204,
0.0009467476,
-0.0154694226,
0.0339712612,
-0.0547551103,
0.0052781752,
-0.0173530243,
0.0333459191,
-0.0414675437,
-0.0095230239,
0.0032906611,
-0.0215247273,
0.0042829751,
0.0382613763,
-0.0168266725,
-0.0496219322,
-0.0163484681,
0.0337656103,
0.0477233194,
0.061905954,
0.0316052772,
0.0690705106,
0.0134424316,
-0.0109893866,
-0.0247299466,
0.0970361456,
0.0240067784,
0.0406459495,
-0.014109456,
0.006301363,
-0.0251990482,
0.0692804679,
-0.0135186967,
0.0087857423,
-0.0311861597,
-0.0509812459,
0.046447061,
-0.0293727387,
0.0255336165,
-0.0485926718,
-0.032542672,
-0.0257834066,
0.0025436659,
-0.0243090447,
0.0166541524,
-0.0393513553,
-0.0555085279,
-0.038512703,
-0.0049922508,
-0.0379601829,
0.0361277759,
-0.0605462529,
0.0115906959,
0.0019819885,
-0.0147499582,
-0.0083599547,
-0.0158699974,
-0.0064101242,
-0.0535062067,
0.0293519143,
0.0308291316,
-0.0273331963,
0.0023943642,
-0.0275781546,
-0.0209172182,
-0.0515538007,
-0.0383166447,
-0.0088036153,
-0.0073687257,
0.0029322321,
-0.0748319849,
-0.0248247534,
0.0506572686,
-0.0067779259,
0.0146026853,
0.0238567367,
-0.0117679872,
0.0809672475,
-0.0197095927,
0.074885048,
-0.0116156973,
-0.0018463922,
0.0357297808,
0.0169866718,
0.0202071033,
0.0201650038,
-0.0148865143,
-0.0014578862,
0.0206112135,
0.0428559743,
-0.0368937925,
-0.0107332179,
0.015625868,
-0.0428324677,
0.0504367054,
0.0713825449,
0.0003263114,
-0.0545821004,
-0.0025580097,
-0.0105112828,
-0.046355173,
0.008134325,
0.0211273767,
-0.0324898846,
-0.0584138706,
0.0083085429,
-0.0119975833,
0.0504917577,
-0.0023186915,
0.0158415027,
-0.0449617803,
0.0219485331,
-0.0182099398,
-0.0191446412,
-0.0611987263,
-0.0197382644,
0.0148908868,
0.0022663036,
0.0090071103,
-0.0599781983,
-0.0050509409,
-0.0541819744,
0.0204942599,
-0.0048452164,
-0.0452439673,
0.0487051494,
-0.0350269265,
0.0415651016,
0.0118396142,
0.0994659066,
-0.0260181129,
-0.0565521754,
0.0186041091,
-0.0142286997,
-0.0037288389,
0.0134012168,
0.0240961201,
-0.0698534176,
0.0023839511,
0.0066104424,
0.0388879254,
-0.0243923161,
-0.0055806898,
-0.0485008284,
0.1055234969,
-0.0046127019,
-0.0374214947,
-0.0587620251,
0.044977013,
0.0375776924,
0.0548371747,
0.0295586269,
-0.0501936562,
-0.0162006114,
-0.0176002383,
0.0322776884,
-0.008600899,
-0.0118715344,
0.040043544,
0.0328014754,
-0.044699382,
-0.0168036614,
-0.0843429714,
-0.0149591118,
-0.0198426992,
-0.016351331,
-0.0404250324,
0.0192388427,
-0.0011351374,
-0.0284130499,
0.0617292635,
0.0230039321,
0.0349495262,
-0.0308985002,
0.0229503866,
0.0607134365,
-0.0277596507,
-0.01781586,
0.0008598039,
-0.0270333719,
-0.0295488387,
-0.0198373012,
0.013850309,
-0.0042980635,
0.028158173,
-0.009942947,
-0.0302204769,
0.0343978405,
-0.0210975315,
-0.0474352911,
-0.0025627541,
0.073679544,
0.0312295314,
-0.0307226442,
0.0248741563,
-0.0270965137,
0.0495705977,
0.0149535621,
0.0134071615,
-0.0059976606,
-0.0721844137,
-0.0352102444,
-0.0592622496,
0.056943316,
0.0287687108,
0.0083639631,
-0.035204269,
0.0138644157,
0.036056906,
0.0205252767,
-0.057006035,
-0.0202413984,
-0.0041824915,
-0.0448253863,
-0.037020456,
-0.0066493955,
0.017623106,
-0.0523820855,
0.0024406095,
0.1088826805,
0.0209241472,
-0.0142967366,
-0.0572891012,
0.0264847912,
0.0020114796,
-0.0086923474,
0.0007000766,
0.0100018559,
0.0124431849,
0.0438031517,
-0.0065064728,
-0.0182675906,
-0.0018704139,
0.0424995013,
-0.0281144492,
0.0485277399,
-0.0271187574,
0.0154555645,
0.037857376,
-0.0160152838,
0.0023153597,
0.0153865702,
0.0293097571,
-0.0093865152,
0.0361730233,
-0.0455279611,
-0.0163464509,
0.0280185249,
-0.0028054598,
-0.0361836739,
0.0212435182,
0.0410929844,
-0.0339634567,
0.0320026055,
0.0036132871,
0.0229343642,
-0.0658134818,
0.0132987062,
0.1011699364,
-0.0052086478,
-0.0118175605,
0.0283951387,
-0.0379826128,
-0.0457048453,
0.0594159812,
-0.0400832146,
-0.0257796701,
-0.0247798339,
0.0057941373,
0.0386072062,
0.0238563325,
0.0356844142,
-0.0099092647,
0.0261147078,
-0.0313718542,
-0.0104809469,
-0.0060337577,
-5.684922473e-33,
0.0028157886,
0.0178654194,
-0.0506587364,
-0.0211660098,
-0.0606848858,
0.0245086271,
-0.023316076,
0.0022523589,
-0.0511810631,
0.0137742991,
-0.02622707,
0.0455485769,
-0.0002545794,
0.0333434269,
0.0143636372,
-0.0202729013,
0.0378916748,
-0.0082456255,
-0.0050966148,
0.0279544126,
0.0314628519,
0.0562601201,
0.0736999512,
-0.0857141316,
0.0016873588,
-0.003689026,
0.0053589796,
0.0145732369,
0.0382645875,
0.0637237504,
-0.0299136378,
0.0412740894,
0.0079372972,
-0.0213246904,
0.0069397702,
0.0820320845,
-0.0448555239,
0.0177870095,
-0.0375983827,
-0.0008020379,
-0.0450691171,
-0.0448983908,
0.0351048,
0.0591550991,
0.0409414023,
-0.0472301841,
0.0245413166,
-0.0047210273,
-0.0150008155,
-0.0483096913,
-0.0299424175,
0.023408642,
-0.0490954332,
-0.0539612398,
0.0358644873,
0.0585850216,
0.0343231298,
0.0567027368,
-0.0813041702,
0.0079285679,
-0.0458806045,
-0.0253514219,
0.0307499431,
-0.0205166638,
-0.0440317616,
0.0518944487,
0.0072342334,
-0.0097076148,
-0.0432082266,
-0.0298572294,
0.0057079811,
0.0494859293,
0.0220438223,
0.0158945378,
-0.0179785341,
0.0096523771,
-0.0352483764,
0.0241680145,
0.0192793719,
0.0284479633,
0.0364328958,
0.0135410205,
-0.0124078849,
0.033529222,
0.0039772335,
-0.0250838101,
-0.0321221314,
-0.0055885226,
0.0162729304,
-0.0157265514,
0.0262247305,
0.0080751367,
0.0266057234,
-0.0051102401,
0.0227096342,
0.0177560002,
0.0306423791,
0.0357342362,
0.004663303,
0.0519152321,
-0.001067133,
-0.0029277832,
0.0637296513,
0.0005154724,
0.0294625945,
-0.0077076941,
0.0250938237,
0.0311627146,
-0.0454781689,
-0.0299134534,
0.0102121029,
0.0089445561,
-0.0273928698,
0.0915248767,
-0.0106592355,
0.0178479236,
-0.0048849327,
0.0139661143,
-0.0140028354,
0.0696676672,
-0.0321468711,
-0.0496796444,
-0.0018157129,
0.0251529366,
-0.0047256025,
0.008922427,
-0.0208157096,
-0.0121945348,
0.0164430961,
-0.0401509888,
-0.0052963523,
0.0468785837,
2.724e-7,
-0.0023196577,
0.0122111328,
0.0217682421,
-0.0599676147,
0.029908143,
0.0609011911,
-0.0148893725,
0.0812430531,
0.0050272024,
-0.0348455161,
0.0363612697,
0.000899869,
0.0658689514,
0.0001737697,
-0.0825157166,
-0.0433414355,
-0.040362332,
0.0122738509,
-0.0077114971,
0.0029654617,
0.0857832283,
0.1438683271,
0.0029847042,
0.0272787325,
-0.0054215845,
0.0298401173,
0.0421376899,
-0.0142954011,
-0.0029297639,
-0.0231862385,
-0.0148184141,
-0.0282873996,
-0.0463488214,
0.0037002799,
-0.014046846,
0.0511535816,
0.0387088917,
0.0459935702,
0.0117925098,
-0.0880637765,
-0.0116867973,
0.0527247377,
-0.0458203256,
0.0031016006,
0.0141274892,
-0.0765692964,
-0.0587941706,
-0.0204868913,
-0.0165453516,
0.0254992973,
0.0531914383,
-0.0010444719,
-0.0224293359,
-0.0089532426,
-0.0105898958,
-0.0583652258,
-0.0070251748,
-0.0966783911,
-0.0067889183,
-0.0053150211,
-0.0984631479,
0.0197802186,
-0.0404602773,
-0.019811945,
0.108651109,
0.0016722091,
0.0149997473,
1.539562515e-34,
0.027119318,
-0.0422730632,
-0.0016532433,
0.0141851371,
0.0032958451,
-0.0052831289,
-0.0398529135,
-0.0444456898,
0.044430729,
-0.0637122095,
-0.0013857485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06875v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06875v4 | nanoLM: an Affordable LLM Pre-training Benchmark via Accurate Loss Prediction across Scales | 2023-04-14T00:45:01 | 2024-04-06T05:50:39 | Yiqun Yao, Siqi fan, Xiusheng Huang, Xuezhi Fang, Xiang Li, Ziyi Ni, Xin Jiang, Xuying Meng, Peng Han, Shuo Shang, Kang Liu, Aixin Sun, Yequan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As language models scale up, it becomes increasingly expensive to verify
research ideas because conclusions on small models do not trivially transfer to
large ones. A possible solution is to establish a generic system that
accurately predicts certain metrics for large models without training them.
Existing scaling laws require hyperparameter search on the largest models,
limiting their predicative capability. In this paper, we present an approach
(namely {\mu}Scaling) to predict the pre-training loss, based on our
observations that Maximal Update Parametrization ({\mu}P) enables accurate
fitting of scaling laws close to common loss basins in hyperparameter space.
With {\mu}Scaling, different model designs can be compared on large scales by
training only their smaller counterparts. Further, we introduce nanoLM: an
affordable LLM pre-training benchmark that facilitates this new research
paradigm. With around 14% of the one-time pre-training cost, we can accurately
forecast the loss for models up to 52B. Our goal with nanoLM is to empower
researchers with limited resources to reach meaningful conclusions on large
models. We also aspire for our benchmark to serve as a bridge between the
academic community and the industry. Code for {\mu}Scaling is available at
https://github.com/cofe-ai/Mu-scaling. Code for nanoLLM will be available
later. | [
-0.0409026593,
0.0609378405,
0.006344331,
0.0314077064,
0.0019188095,
-0.0025912733,
0.0110001061,
0.0510648564,
-0.0285442714,
-0.018546965,
-0.0550803244,
-0.0179746635,
-0.0149759697,
0.0286242403,
0.0530923679,
-0.0244220775,
0.0141458334,
-0.0362299271,
-0.04885865,
-0.0348705202,
0.0064240638,
-0.0081753572,
0.0075590224,
0.0253601316,
0.0072656688,
0.0053400123,
-0.0075098886,
0.0447021797,
0.0144072119,
-0.0463827625,
0.0117239719,
0.0048809019,
0.0141871385,
0.0462469086,
0.0000020901,
-0.0580536537,
-0.0042235213,
0.0094518727,
-0.033783555,
0.0634464473,
0.0315057933,
-0.0249416307,
-0.0250050407,
0.0242755935,
-0.0169543307,
-0.0100818044,
0.0573000796,
0.0207037646,
0.0336025655,
0.0840708613,
0.0027301658,
-0.0486775897,
0.062896736,
-0.0352808572,
-0.0212569088,
-0.0421789326,
0.0358688943,
0.000618919,
-0.0395456962,
-0.0087623028,
-0.0081539387,
0.0214145016,
0.0122919725,
0.007878175,
-0.0194466915,
0.0308966897,
0.013212746,
-0.0033234796,
-0.0158032402,
0.039607197,
-0.0319300331,
-0.0471183136,
0.014795972,
-0.0421853103,
-0.0413658023,
-0.0172560345,
-0.0417782143,
0.0250605866,
0.0389580652,
0.0139433742,
-0.0072073187,
-0.0073145684,
0.0735855103,
0.0154297994,
-0.0213791188,
0.0500195362,
0.0319238007,
-0.0266776439,
-0.0011611048,
-0.0304355361,
-0.0296600126,
-0.0078527546,
0.0084792236,
0.0175752249,
-0.0185822211,
0.0302964151,
-0.0246485621,
-0.0139942775,
0.0269624386,
-0.0530748591,
0.0962119028,
0.003392413,
0.0078707645,
0.055746939,
-0.0289394353,
0.0361481719,
-0.0489862263,
0.0146538205,
-0.0341761447,
0.0142803118,
0.007194235,
-0.004616695,
-0.026004307,
0.0345703065,
-0.0063444008,
0.0242095161,
-0.0376669392,
0.0080408445,
-0.009282588,
0.0082908897,
0.0207239147,
-0.0121848891,
-0.0383299217,
-0.0214965977,
-0.0058568236,
0.0498191118,
-0.0444534197,
0.0038630851,
0.0007325594,
-0.0331894085,
-0.0183922723,
0.0306712911,
-0.0469944999,
-0.0134233655,
0.0643262118,
0.1078738719,
0.0232571904,
-0.036946401,
-0.0914098844,
-0.0133143635,
-0.0096299211,
-0.0587019175,
-0.0027328236,
-0.0521213673,
-0.0016101543,
-0.0283098985,
-0.0030307444,
-0.0352824554,
0.0003772003,
-0.014014286,
-0.0089436844,
0.0525220372,
0.0046546953,
-0.0080757616,
0.025877513,
-0.0130108427,
0.01601406,
0.0886475965,
0.0166003946,
0.0096169896,
0.0446157306,
-0.0176647641,
-0.0406532362,
0.0639151856,
0.0535335951,
0.0338995606,
-0.0499308147,
-0.0147030978,
0.0459413454,
0.0509309135,
0.0453345329,
0.0243397932,
-0.0408572555,
-0.0501344651,
0.0503789075,
0.0683137998,
0.0371917821,
0.0350987352,
0.0118099917,
-0.0277241077,
0.0071454863,
-0.0364752337,
-0.0445178114,
0.0011561469,
-0.0096053733,
0.0014461059,
0.0583257005,
0.025793504,
-0.0423608348,
-0.0549810976,
-0.0208023787,
0.0005532584,
-0.0534097217,
-0.024832027,
0.0553722344,
-0.0116658472,
-0.0190486927,
0.1136611402,
0.0410328545,
-0.0471346937,
-0.0059514116,
-0.0428932942,
-0.0231854469,
-0.0052532577,
0.0372265242,
-0.0579241067,
-0.0162889957,
0.0178243853,
0.0228341725,
0.0096003609,
0.0484138466,
0.0120579218,
0.0415737368,
-0.0489404239,
0.0149657242,
0.0034677773,
0.0084272008,
0.0103485808,
0.0385933779,
0.0167164747,
0.0101868324,
-0.0818598494,
-0.0434605032,
0.0261349678,
-0.067286469,
-0.0613471977,
0.0112560857,
-0.0217177346,
0.0312543474,
0.0091600334,
-0.0399372689,
0.0000703271,
0.0473697558,
-0.0124908248,
-0.0113107786,
-0.024700962,
-0.0343585573,
-0.0071869809,
0.0446271077,
-0.0300062336,
0.0520122088,
0.0222957693,
-0.0669616982,
-0.047714401,
0.0222525764,
-0.0037162961,
0.0559988879,
-0.0396560133,
0.0308632199,
-0.0409577601,
0.0199395362,
-0.0437001809,
0.0096360529,
-0.0216240622,
0.0151606025,
-0.0168506764,
0.0093682967,
0.0094880769,
-0.0422013029,
-0.0495276302,
0.0432143398,
-0.0097435983,
0.0522387214,
-0.0063356613,
-0.0140872961,
-0.0232181344,
0.004259015,
-0.0417828113,
0.015349091,
-0.0405857675,
0.0516224355,
0.0327244885,
0.0138573302,
-0.008991234,
-0.0192302223,
0.0046175919,
-0.0213521961,
-0.0250143781,
0.0162361246,
0.0343621857,
-0.0064988118,
-0.0062647839,
-0.046378158,
-0.0509966686,
0.0002238581,
0.0671974123,
-0.0136952288,
0.0171656124,
-0.0833823755,
0.0729754865,
-0.0096043274,
0.0243283454,
-0.025441831,
-0.0427998863,
-0.0065535884,
-0.0346372798,
-0.0162790474,
0.0556327887,
0.0002119292,
0.0006270529,
0.0593447275,
0.027083395,
-0.0594780557,
-0.0021874446,
-0.0184432846,
-0.0497158095,
-0.0520776547,
-0.0230617169,
0.0211470239,
0.0836646333,
-0.0420865826,
-0.0012499702,
-0.0220881719,
-0.0084042065,
0.0065040183,
-0.0220939815,
0.0047320742,
0.0467153043,
-0.0307241287,
0.0497652926,
0.0255998652,
-0.0832000673,
0.0089544216,
-0.0324417166,
0.0020741697,
-0.0213196296,
-0.043650616,
-0.0625580624,
0.0493489169,
0.0115647949,
0.0175167266,
0.0137804281,
-0.0089089433,
-0.047951974,
0.008482228,
0.0286205187,
0.0171384215,
0.0267638545,
-0.0450151265,
0.02224846,
-0.0107200937,
-0.0280312169,
-0.0021436745,
0.0091297356,
-0.009266221,
-0.0095570581,
0.0142222708,
-0.0558539182,
-0.0134235984,
-0.0083555784,
-0.0110396622,
0.0410850346,
-0.0017582641,
-0.0107350657,
-0.0006156831,
0.0392276011,
0.0033984133,
-0.0022281196,
0.0523076653,
-0.0420730077,
0.0125341257,
0.0633726642,
0.056155052,
0.0004846157,
-0.0917872339,
-0.0132281398,
0.0343367532,
-0.0457791649,
-0.0135328444,
0.0335695371,
0.0482051224,
-0.0431761034,
0.0123573579,
0.0856525376,
-0.0010740469,
-0.0581181906,
0.0301947184,
0.0064536524,
0.0829569623,
0.0195676368,
0.025859287,
-0.0462491512,
-0.0135982772,
-0.0026109673,
0.0412524454,
0.0163639504,
-0.0301641468,
0.0074833762,
-0.0833020061,
0.0143040046,
0.0270856544,
-0.0001628524,
0.0186033845,
-0.0578685924,
-0.00956662,
-0.0475736298,
0.0074964915,
0.0152913742,
-0.0526672639,
-0.0214929562,
0.0298092794,
-0.0209669024,
-0.0419412777,
0.0291702375,
-0.0449696556,
0.0446125641,
0.0142377084,
0.029366577,
-0.0134097477,
-0.016949486,
0.0715968087,
0.0220346451,
0.006652961,
-0.0158712342,
0.0772000924,
0.0290269759,
-0.0043130768,
0.0318582095,
0.0214455891,
-0.0263639782,
0.0060536042,
0.0340675265,
0.055373542,
-0.0063414467,
-0.0377608351,
0.0068023833,
-0.0218368955,
-0.0464454591,
0.0605139211,
0.0217467621,
-0.0079186959,
-0.0673857331,
-0.0187790357,
0.0024202783,
0.0017708692,
-0.0303024091,
-0.0012322874,
-0.0186298937,
0.0064638192,
-0.0355389155,
0.0197918992,
-0.0174142048,
0.0605533533,
-0.0058182273,
-0.0480426028,
-0.0044389083,
-0.0062420699,
-0.0637036189,
0.0158971064,
-0.0423667245,
0.0121470187,
-0.0856085047,
0.0362090841,
0.0611833222,
0.0091133462,
-0.0170596112,
-0.001615023,
-0.147837624,
-0.0851792619,
-0.0309278145,
0.0416517332,
0.0263106916,
0.0585057847,
0.0260081645,
-0.065335013,
0.0738589689,
0.0209295768,
-0.0120560462,
0.0601792336,
0.0907039866,
-0.0118480381,
-0.0235107113,
0.0372719839,
-0.0122317346,
-0.0052106041,
0.0208089855,
0.0295851398,
-0.0173413083,
-0.0399134234,
-0.0245545395,
0.0174064618,
0.0260456037,
-0.0157964062,
0.0059955022,
0.001810723,
0.0393675342,
0.0290109739,
0.0370205157,
-0.0267793201,
0.0069385343,
0.0269978885,
0.006170128,
0.008897556,
-0.0171258524,
0.0234194007,
0.0058086435,
-0.0262421146,
0.0270350017,
-0.0257092044,
0.0235114209,
0.0822869688,
0.010889682,
-0.004270867,
0.02703223,
-0.0163488016,
0.0457908772,
-0.0147837093,
0.0266094338,
0.019668337,
0.0359542035,
-0.0313434042,
0.0180824157,
-0.0658819601,
-0.107425876,
-0.0547287911,
0.0217617918,
0.051266294,
0.0207227282,
0.0408494622,
-0.0402705856,
-0.0128128948,
-0.0130665898,
0.0066371253,
-0.0283624642,
0.0005483757,
0.0318465084,
0.0195157826,
-0.0161345843,
0.0386495404,
0.0587247349,
0.0530723557,
0.048728101,
0.025831826,
0.0351678096,
-0.0133535564,
-0.0549921393,
-0.0063684112,
0.0142105147,
-0.0175538659,
-0.0469773337,
-0.0352317952,
-0.0655616522,
0.0092128236,
0.003292205,
-0.0145312222,
-0.0204769708,
0.037509948,
0.0435164534,
-0.0150526911,
0.0244194977,
0.011436902,
-0.0037465375,
-0.0007737705,
-0.0262701325,
0.0062808911,
-6.289813867e-33,
0.0028563046,
0.0348953977,
0.0273107328,
0.0054706698,
-0.0046594702,
0.0220035706,
-0.0161768664,
-0.0005075143,
-0.0156568289,
0.0070104315,
-0.0024388894,
0.0100085968,
0.01017249,
0.0314203352,
0.0045618084,
-0.0255635362,
0.0750924125,
-0.0251380857,
0.0002573782,
0.0296550076,
-0.0138070919,
0.0317584947,
0.0795466825,
-0.0185277965,
-0.0234614611,
0.0247676224,
-0.035487853,
0.0475391708,
-0.007621164,
0.0373972841,
-0.0239031184,
0.0543766357,
-0.0176754016,
-0.0784307644,
-0.0220437385,
-0.080064401,
-0.0458441712,
-0.0190402996,
0.002058726,
0.0028973955,
-0.0239085853,
-0.002451478,
0.0404614694,
0.0185773354,
-0.0406789668,
-0.0312223043,
0.0107665975,
-0.0030267683,
-0.0450578295,
-0.02607367,
0.008171373,
0.0313875452,
-0.0030034264,
0.037031427,
0.0347060896,
-0.0202630237,
-0.0192215163,
0.0217472762,
-0.0521352403,
0.0050506913,
0.057071276,
0.0509047471,
0.0681585297,
0.0309986137,
-0.0113595109,
0.0537782051,
0.0643306822,
0.024035681,
0.0259625614,
-0.0056997929,
0.0633565933,
0.0320473723,
0.0125314835,
0.02249741,
0.0386846736,
0.0058499477,
-0.05403997,
0.0010552615,
0.0228318293,
0.0560216196,
-0.0057379692,
0.0570294708,
-0.008058494,
-0.0395511985,
-0.0345634706,
-0.0369724147,
-0.0243920926,
-0.0259142648,
-0.0003660043,
-0.0013676935,
0.0045483983,
0.0091240164,
0.0021580267,
-0.0431532785,
-0.0328047276,
0.0129862661,
-0.0018224953,
0.029393699,
-0.0078981826,
0.0413444899,
-0.0506325513,
-0.0366991088,
-0.0438945182,
-0.0089187929,
0.0319836549,
-0.0240206197,
0.001211987,
0.0225171279,
-0.0683454573,
-0.0185523089,
-0.0465774313,
-0.0375815444,
0.0517562218,
0.0370739177,
0.0180329643,
-0.0208641067,
0.0193357896,
0.0474599712,
0.0300851353,
-0.0196411274,
-0.0297161695,
0.0317620449,
0.0267097186,
0.0470439978,
-0.0465017334,
0.005028592,
-0.0531588122,
0.0180339627,
0.0753231049,
-0.0768476576,
-0.0412536263,
0.0032793216,
2.695e-7,
0.0264477916,
0.0544376299,
0.026060218,
0.006629569,
0.0026027686,
0.047396794,
-0.0129427696,
0.0200497136,
-0.0199105162,
0.0146356067,
0.0282139201,
0.0175549183,
0.0626690388,
0.0010152973,
-0.0802619457,
0.009730814,
-0.098990187,
0.0192282088,
-0.0466791168,
-0.0302235987,
-0.032987982,
0.0940927565,
0.0309333485,
-0.0439359322,
-0.000216181,
-0.0374084897,
0.0509798713,
-0.0600823499,
0.029754838,
0.0277032703,
-0.0238626711,
0.014086185,
-0.0269544963,
-0.0011615792,
-0.0320317335,
0.0132976566,
-0.0215029586,
0.044422321,
0.0221526902,
-0.0296563581,
0.012391069,
-0.0102245705,
-0.0200676266,
-0.0644569397,
0.0419954993,
-0.0178032536,
-0.0371938013,
-0.0510988422,
-0.0016077458,
-0.0491232947,
0.0243638065,
-0.0519798473,
0.0041201715,
0.0300066192,
-0.0115324054,
-0.0021911063,
-0.0239136219,
-0.0795601681,
-0.0451256149,
0.0288601611,
-0.024680512,
-0.070048295,
-0.0758723244,
0.0089979619,
0.0206579249,
-0.0466833897,
0.0011272384,
2.827280416e-34,
0.0557243414,
-0.0370221958,
0.0167351365,
0.042312067,
0.0042741122,
-0.0113864457,
-0.0195548534,
0.0135498224,
-0.0066083381,
-0.0830403417,
-0.0105964039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08243v1 | Stochastic Code Generation | 2023-04-14T00:01:05 | 2023-04-14T00:01:05 | Swapnil Sharma, Nikita Anand, Kranthi Kiran G. V | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models pre-trained for code generation can generate
high-quality short code but often struggle with generating coherent long code
and understanding higher-level or system-level specifications. This issue is
also observed in language modeling for long text generation, and one proposed
solution is the use of a latent stochastic process. This approach involves
generating a document plan and then producing text that is consistent with it.
In this study, we investigate whether this technique can be applied to code
generation to improve coherence. We base our proposed encoder and decoder on
the pre-trained GPT-2 based CodeParrot model and utilize the APPS dataset for
training. We evaluate our results using the HumanEval benchmark and observe
that the modified Time Control model performs similarly to CodeParrot on this
evaluation. | [
-0.0202350412,
0.0629643947,
0.0058506904,
-0.0193781964,
-0.0052516563,
-0.0084650842,
-0.0229676068,
0.0034843041,
-0.0523351617,
-0.0127828903,
0.0244443845,
-0.0334405303,
0.0147356344,
0.0891468823,
0.0446089022,
-0.0268957876,
0.0206113774,
-0.0295143314,
-0.0131601589,
0.0165344905,
0.0147903981,
0.0174473617,
0.0327873752,
0.0561579168,
0.0059849978,
-0.0472313873,
-0.0474227816,
0.0220301729,
0.0014590196,
-0.0613758862,
-0.0052529117,
0.0660874918,
0.0137723396,
0.0315377489,
0.0000021992,
-0.0095122661,
-0.0307261832,
-0.0096644415,
0.0435442477,
0.0320411809,
0.023953395,
-0.0422243774,
-0.0412991457,
0.0256124958,
-0.0248714089,
-0.0102856923,
0.0561233126,
-0.0086635025,
0.0514106527,
0.0594267063,
-0.0070715751,
-0.0381553844,
0.0404532403,
-0.0217077229,
0.0171809979,
-0.0215221792,
-0.0083837593,
0.0280958023,
-0.000812217,
-0.0114076789,
-0.0332202353,
-0.0136641264,
0.0395019799,
-0.0010851822,
0.0347267427,
0.0641948804,
-0.0065280953,
-0.0151408156,
-0.0193259977,
0.028650485,
-0.0651920438,
-0.0355832018,
0.013797882,
-0.0349347666,
-0.051688049,
-0.0518537872,
-0.0147288712,
0.0372671224,
-0.0161848385,
0.0442446806,
0.0343261845,
-0.0129889371,
0.0140281199,
-0.0497164875,
-0.0138808871,
0.0368144698,
0.0375246964,
-0.0372170545,
-0.059180133,
0.0294698402,
0.0093195252,
-0.0650475696,
-0.0017808157,
0.0626642108,
-0.0087218145,
0.0059089819,
-0.0904545635,
-0.0507615842,
-0.0068581984,
-0.0515147075,
0.0015886959,
0.0422744416,
0.0173509326,
-0.00631428,
-0.0367909819,
0.0517409816,
-0.0054803691,
-0.026191093,
-0.0239576064,
0.018454615,
-0.0329351649,
-0.0023119694,
-0.0615031235,
0.0420809872,
-0.0221718606,
-0.0335390307,
-0.055663716,
0.0246527568,
0.0390600711,
0.0187369082,
0.0225697514,
-0.014747439,
-0.0658274814,
0.0023099522,
0.0213639382,
-0.0130453743,
-0.0178331006,
-0.0525220856,
0.0123539893,
-0.0352234356,
-0.0109863868,
0.0377291441,
0.0127148312,
-0.0184429102,
-0.014458362,
0.0396877602,
-0.0405973159,
0.0289531294,
-0.048634626,
-0.0562639758,
0.0031384174,
-0.0212427787,
-0.0111589152,
-0.0670328438,
-0.0103924219,
0.0003110725,
-0.0159043185,
-0.0502598621,
0.0245850589,
0.0099440692,
0.0099827768,
0.0156896859,
-0.0862681121,
0.0020414924,
0.0065901801,
-0.0060927672,
0.0519558787,
0.0455938391,
0.0837542489,
0.0404343531,
-0.0156169524,
-0.0265655611,
0.0192117784,
0.0421128422,
0.0173428375,
-0.0023517117,
0.0250589121,
0.0047346908,
0.0412229262,
0.0101099936,
0.0727590546,
0.052217599,
-0.0269770771,
0.0434378088,
0.0292977318,
-0.000138994,
0.0230596401,
0.0614760704,
0.0959261581,
0.016889818,
-0.0322445184,
0.0040979236,
-0.0006014155,
0.0617749654,
0.0014606382,
0.0393301435,
0.0284096785,
0.0417261161,
-0.0264850259,
-0.0264447406,
0.0090231309,
-0.0359266028,
0.0248335674,
-0.0394321494,
0.049811326,
-0.0038441233,
-0.1015064716,
0.0139507586,
-0.0057092817,
-0.0686614141,
0.0090298736,
-0.0248374604,
0.0336633772,
0.0723480806,
0.0499783643,
0.013355677,
0.0213675499,
-0.0353222713,
-0.0054010148,
0.024762122,
0.0097349733,
0.0078199739,
0.00949609,
-0.0798072219,
-0.0290119555,
-0.0344072059,
-0.0149812829,
0.0423935354,
0.0000350375,
0.0337750018,
0.0469209142,
0.0329785235,
-0.0203403085,
0.0389242396,
-0.0187614728,
-0.0147035336,
-0.014285598,
-0.0272594113,
0.0428664945,
-0.0345579758,
-0.0466519333,
0.0295046233,
0.0124569368,
-0.0111627784,
0.0016616528,
0.0061526275,
-0.0637666956,
-0.0443264917,
0.0177435689,
-0.0600291081,
-0.0183129068,
0.0133868968,
0.0045520845,
-0.0673587993,
0.0338388905,
-0.0365520678,
0.0189391058,
-0.037129499,
0.0188587345,
0.002334283,
0.0111166853,
-0.0010887785,
0.037012849,
-0.0034908964,
-0.0100291977,
-0.0235984921,
0.0635956898,
0.0413892716,
-0.0244794525,
0.0165166836,
0.0113114472,
-0.0117263831,
0.0077112904,
0.0238381904,
0.0648501143,
-0.0087345224,
-0.0552641116,
-0.0826380774,
0.0093412893,
-0.0508044548,
-0.0042468519,
0.0282114148,
0.0026402271,
0.0095846308,
0.0072064577,
-0.0579815358,
0.0081659704,
0.009424652,
-0.0186719615,
0.0129773254,
-0.028378861,
-0.0381766818,
-0.0273018312,
-0.006770852,
0.0051148194,
0.0087249521,
0.0326304734,
-0.0019464991,
-0.0657482743,
0.0863542855,
0.0025524518,
-0.0020158356,
0.0089203026,
-0.0538906232,
0.0439670347,
-0.0224250723,
0.1061390489,
-0.0039470876,
0.0316570774,
0.0394162387,
0.0433872528,
-0.0034669719,
-0.0080461428,
0.0249553211,
-0.014293069,
-0.0296825077,
-0.0291720796,
-0.0564567,
0.0418062992,
0.0784034953,
0.0338246524,
0.0140896961,
-0.1203632057,
-0.0203260556,
0.0039953655,
-0.0318432152,
-0.0051199826,
-0.0256955307,
-0.0090651792,
0.0317211449,
-0.0332779363,
-0.0667211637,
0.0544488318,
-0.0484818257,
-0.0085158926,
-0.0060154963,
0.0008790596,
-0.0243331157,
0.0268416554,
0.0144028766,
0.0229429007,
-0.028307572,
-0.0333514512,
-0.0265911072,
0.0324541964,
-0.0017685466,
-0.0184452087,
0.0094849765,
-0.0275669396,
0.0078830114,
-0.017296914,
-0.0325706713,
-0.013520767,
0.0111541133,
-0.008365199,
0.0008704818,
0.043765638,
-0.006434741,
0.0333165377,
0.0290242825,
-0.011349842,
0.0437776521,
0.0002629963,
-0.0361131318,
-0.0212452654,
-0.0116660027,
0.0462798364,
-0.0545837842,
-0.0307701696,
-0.0640835539,
-0.0041286205,
-0.0020290241,
0.0215166453,
0.0543470271,
-0.0680316389,
0.0192831047,
-0.0048765847,
0.0205421597,
-0.0054169595,
0.0703809559,
0.0671038851,
-0.0297123995,
-0.0494691804,
0.1228644773,
-0.0035246916,
-0.0297514144,
0.0068866187,
0.0030331411,
0.0784986764,
0.0122654494,
0.0231102593,
-0.0412581749,
-0.0198468529,
-0.0186810289,
0.0410345122,
-0.0071148253,
-0.0063515739,
-0.0183680393,
-0.0629606023,
0.0171809252,
0.0288497303,
-0.0511046499,
-0.0618643984,
-0.0194447711,
-0.0699755251,
0.0085484171,
-0.0214046016,
0.0479636863,
0.0043459558,
0.0456427597,
0.0148653686,
-0.0432173274,
-0.0011987807,
-0.009738382,
-0.004909148,
0.0580719747,
0.1325804293,
-0.0007159423,
-0.013124302,
-0.0043917922,
0.0080900053,
-0.0021171046,
0.0042577032,
0.0001542119,
0.0011239718,
-0.011910188,
0.0077128783,
0.0115135303,
0.0329511762,
-0.071465157,
-0.0092880772,
0.0246652793,
0.0578028113,
-0.0234642997,
-0.0622313432,
-0.0145987589,
-0.0084414249,
0.0468672886,
0.0456146523,
0.0301173683,
-0.0132315215,
-0.0822904184,
-0.061932873,
0.0082598869,
-0.067257449,
0.0230653808,
-0.0366859026,
0.0222832132,
-0.0183872543,
-0.0439646654,
-0.0470455103,
-0.0040111225,
0.0274873301,
0.009220833,
0.0174549278,
0.0471938774,
-0.0152993845,
-0.0607062131,
-0.0229739118,
-0.0097783841,
0.0120753394,
-0.0698743239,
-0.0379590057,
-0.0286620222,
-0.0285106432,
0.0034998138,
0.0141548682,
-0.0984494239,
-0.0615561344,
-0.0151999509,
0.0393273644,
0.0175245535,
0.0310719982,
-0.027262371,
-0.0267878026,
-0.0233782362,
-0.009263861,
-0.0418013446,
0.0380447209,
0.0111908698,
0.0075783422,
0.0039434745,
-0.0061655631,
-0.0329091772,
0.00105264,
-0.0074813473,
0.0148860971,
0.0047571589,
-0.0024812128,
0.0235137288,
0.0112111047,
0.0190333184,
-0.0457274579,
-0.0178818759,
-0.0068310397,
-0.0266808458,
-0.0210769568,
0.0211179368,
-0.0514487512,
0.0238310844,
0.029926002,
-0.0323055051,
0.0021698549,
0.0426523499,
-0.0000802003,
0.0199833792,
0.0157217421,
0.01073974,
-0.026287362,
0.0330313556,
0.070202738,
-0.0242695715,
0.0006362763,
0.0276351776,
-0.0222722255,
0.01042974,
-0.000745297,
0.0349145085,
0.0263683628,
0.0434921719,
0.0430961512,
0.000974874,
-0.0339697413,
-0.0362731963,
-0.0481550172,
-0.0179893039,
0.052064009,
0.0438403711,
0.0619326234,
-0.0310984943,
0.0404237472,
-0.0290721525,
0.1149647832,
-0.0094386721,
-0.0185149852,
0.0249304548,
-0.0066285296,
-0.0382498838,
-0.0507150181,
0.0941275582,
0.0542969219,
-0.0044461777,
-0.0220364239,
0.0126847727,
-0.0220752098,
0.0061691212,
0.0028469509,
0.0146835968,
-0.0227876492,
0.0017153512,
-0.0047196453,
-0.0236840881,
-0.0101611912,
0.0457211435,
0.0523484014,
-0.0043463958,
0.0734741837,
0.0630254447,
-0.0773848146,
0.0335949212,
-0.0195294712,
0.0017866093,
0.0328236744,
-0.0454438552,
-0.0176405068,
-6.484140715e-33,
-0.043171294,
-0.0375327542,
0.0309207048,
-0.0041477326,
-0.0224684831,
-0.0560799614,
-0.0766914561,
0.0059499191,
0.0249154419,
-0.0079270387,
0.0237298813,
0.040677987,
0.0035927068,
0.018374145,
0.0247823913,
0.0258257482,
0.0763568804,
-0.0157599002,
-0.0357800014,
0.0590285137,
0.0017814643,
0.0364182256,
-0.0094565991,
-0.0257093403,
-0.0297753327,
-0.0249400605,
0.0121384431,
-0.054344207,
0.052635517,
0.0331539214,
-0.0104955826,
0.0097542675,
0.0075262906,
-0.0212694816,
-0.0316545181,
0.0052112089,
-0.0085421605,
-0.0312804878,
-0.0327907018,
-0.0084996158,
-0.0283163153,
-0.0735434666,
0.033862628,
0.0086875409,
-0.0502501801,
-0.0097941579,
0.0446103886,
0.0258402638,
-0.0330323167,
-0.0849162415,
-0.0788009614,
0.0431647263,
-0.0084657157,
0.0153752686,
0.0142084006,
-0.0340125822,
-0.0303297061,
0.0296625067,
0.0104529522,
0.0028898627,
0.0173001084,
0.0573608577,
0.0408616774,
0.0127419336,
0.019181652,
0.0233011302,
0.0049017197,
0.0240186285,
-0.0646595284,
0.0756094083,
0.0276630446,
0.0068803816,
0.0395566784,
-0.0027171066,
0.0570976399,
-0.0254821926,
-0.0550928898,
0.0298413131,
-0.0248277541,
0.0137571171,
0.0321362056,
0.038498424,
-0.0006288978,
0.0017920195,
-0.0340535045,
-0.0284882337,
0.009210472,
-0.0574713871,
0.0414219908,
0.0320741758,
0.0068378099,
-0.0381321758,
0.0393444039,
-0.0026760667,
0.0096910484,
0.0039349021,
-0.064953886,
0.0276921056,
-0.0249308813,
0.0405777693,
-0.0238178633,
-0.0286577642,
0.0444817208,
0.0166872628,
0.0410098135,
0.0270508975,
-0.0018601541,
0.0255008973,
-0.0484312885,
0.0155891227,
-0.040656738,
0.0204433594,
0.0091828732,
-0.0064726374,
0.0028237314,
-0.0356611796,
0.0092808586,
0.0378464982,
-0.0359174497,
-0.0362330005,
-0.0366894864,
-0.0496633425,
0.0509989001,
0.0304742046,
-0.0297136474,
0.0102614714,
-0.0655466393,
0.008239124,
0.0460452661,
-0.0342960469,
-0.0547776669,
0.0627006292,
2.766e-7,
0.0143042542,
0.0236098468,
0.0268060844,
0.0398021042,
0.0259436537,
0.000432291,
-0.0124640893,
0.0478673913,
-0.0301736835,
-0.0329293311,
-0.0116963452,
0.0235073473,
0.0554321297,
0.0100628696,
-0.0327055007,
0.0061085727,
-0.0423793159,
0.0251689274,
-0.0718616843,
-0.0100549376,
0.0411793329,
0.0713196322,
-0.0277712606,
0.0213414822,
0.064525187,
0.043086201,
0.0563283153,
0.0241364967,
0.0212521628,
0.0107106715,
-0.0452840663,
0.0181174427,
-0.0371701643,
-0.0365511589,
-0.0323725976,
-0.0240640789,
0.0087481122,
0.0801940113,
-0.0253335331,
0.0306409933,
0.0808320343,
-0.0096246684,
-0.034156967,
-0.0530695505,
0.0365288183,
-0.0080710687,
-0.0042148754,
0.0191235244,
-0.0314445123,
0.0167815257,
-0.0148874121,
-0.0153623903,
-0.0024002874,
0.0061021554,
0.0236281008,
-0.0027929826,
0.0203425419,
-0.0245134085,
-0.0205282643,
-0.0046373648,
-0.0296471175,
-0.0389749035,
-0.0859783962,
0.0274965204,
0.0604667924,
-0.0114251645,
-0.0270921234,
2.55903559e-34,
0.0483634286,
-0.0425072908,
0.000957128,
0.0025702247,
0.0206228402,
-0.0240120813,
0.0178901814,
0.0321138874,
-0.0005300025,
-0.0373620503,
-0.0660709664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06861v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06861v1 | Evaluation of Social Biases in Recent Large Pre-Trained Models | 2023-04-13T23:29:58 | 2023-04-13T23:29:58 | Swapnil Sharma, Nikita Anand, Kranthi Kiran G. V., Alind Jain | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large pre-trained language models are widely used in the community. These
models are usually trained on unmoderated and unfiltered data from open sources
like the Internet. Due to this, biases that we see in platforms online which
are a reflection of those in society are in turn captured and learned by these
models. These models are deployed in applications that affect millions of
people and their inherent biases are harmful to the targeted social groups. In
this work, we study the general trend in bias reduction as newer pre-trained
models are released. Three recent models ( ELECTRA, DeBERTa, and DistilBERT)
are chosen and evaluated against two bias benchmarks, StereoSet and
CrowS-Pairs. They are compared to the baseline of BERT using the associated
metrics. We explore whether as advancements are made and newer, faster, lighter
models are released: are they being developed responsibly such that their
inherent social biases have been reduced compared to their older counterparts?
The results are compiled and we find that all the models under study do exhibit
biases but have generally improved as compared to BERT. | [
0.0453235023,
0.0912416652,
-0.030675659,
0.0113052987,
0.0018925059,
0.0174515918,
0.0297362208,
-0.0104834316,
0.0179366581,
-0.0570498779,
-0.0610575341,
-0.0182320122,
0.0257054996,
0.0106318574,
0.0159969218,
-0.0849948972,
0.0598495826,
0.0119563313,
0.0219434332,
-0.0647022352,
0.0235412363,
0.0277198013,
0.0221882854,
0.0527531467,
-0.0099050095,
0.0151068261,
0.0476586111,
0.0100208046,
0.0076090898,
-0.0136305131,
0.0518161133,
0.1006388143,
-0.0026200009,
0.0600024685,
0.0000018971,
-0.0608026572,
0.0055913567,
0.0001789225,
-0.0169616975,
0.0390099362,
0.0613650307,
0.0303527564,
-0.0005418191,
0.0392765366,
-0.0632158965,
-0.0287509579,
0.0612258241,
-0.0212581865,
0.0171940178,
0.0199269019,
-0.0187228397,
-0.0567604676,
-0.0106390594,
-0.0195462517,
-0.0230503008,
-0.0209425613,
0.0417924933,
-0.0575720929,
-0.043925412,
-0.041277457,
-0.0075542969,
-0.0058507929,
0.0048074261,
0.0214858055,
0.0336397998,
0.0286793802,
-0.0664527118,
-0.0734963492,
-0.0357978344,
0.080400236,
-0.0051842965,
-0.0406031609,
0.0025892875,
-0.0074381363,
-0.0027822724,
0.0364171304,
-0.0061851102,
-0.0013884933,
0.0053872382,
0.0237540398,
-0.0242831726,
0.0135325138,
0.0140148727,
0.0220191609,
-0.0031006185,
0.0451375321,
0.0357935019,
-0.0076664495,
0.0227287356,
0.0395160243,
-0.0142731844,
-0.045156192,
0.0310732722,
-0.034300454,
0.0079218335,
-0.001118666,
-0.0516967326,
-0.0011674098,
0.0167254098,
-0.0503862388,
0.0305680353,
0.0182335731,
-0.0210137554,
0.0183966085,
0.0027534715,
-0.0047574914,
0.00631093,
0.0161724463,
0.003034634,
0.0155961337,
-0.0011161671,
0.0127339745,
-0.0498733632,
-0.0067928536,
-0.0199252553,
0.0188614838,
-0.0293602366,
-0.0032503514,
-0.0269338936,
-0.022112079,
0.0179848596,
0.0211251155,
-0.0098731238,
-0.0126478598,
-0.0083318232,
0.0194590166,
-0.0489182062,
0.027241746,
-0.027481297,
-0.0961472318,
0.0493922494,
-0.0180711411,
0.0329592191,
-0.0408521481,
-0.0010264645,
0.0086087808,
0.0182772353,
-0.0412965752,
-0.0326438695,
-0.0126612876,
-0.0338301659,
-0.0511518009,
-0.0334316865,
-0.0313861929,
0.0057082102,
0.0399214886,
0.003684642,
-0.0452265143,
-0.0276261158,
0.0135003738,
-0.0836287215,
0.0294884685,
-0.0233019497,
0.0347643532,
0.0618604943,
0.009081698,
0.0161588714,
0.0947547555,
0.0008877249,
-0.0304063708,
0.0437202007,
-0.0487000383,
0.0088880891,
0.0591160804,
0.0163448323,
-0.0096283657,
-0.0202561039,
0.0103553012,
-0.0096682897,
-0.0373190865,
0.0536108389,
0.0693396255,
-0.0165405162,
-0.0551344976,
0.09724994,
0.0273062084,
-0.0172166489,
0.045235794,
-0.0111259017,
0.0331581123,
0.0436522476,
-0.0236995313,
-0.0528635345,
-0.0101646222,
-0.0354686156,
-0.0328954086,
-0.0007123422,
0.0558825061,
-0.0358740836,
0.0035105799,
-0.0032576006,
0.0055921134,
0.0585851073,
0.0210015718,
0.0331250764,
-0.0096839424,
-0.0212008897,
0.0580437519,
0.0526879169,
-0.0600294955,
-0.0155855175,
-0.0512868762,
0.0296971761,
0.0447605215,
0.007996575,
-0.0081318486,
-0.0096931336,
0.0115857124,
-0.016064791,
0.020782372,
0.0778087378,
-0.0146578141,
0.0160781015,
-0.0445107482,
-0.026374653,
0.0407621264,
0.0277180523,
0.0136719914,
0.0654038563,
0.0435569361,
-0.0030528149,
-0.0471580736,
-0.026310686,
0.0164560713,
-0.0008805268,
0.0284983255,
-0.0547291115,
0.0189219508,
0.0288623273,
0.0304628685,
-0.0547016487,
-0.0045092176,
-0.0098228091,
0.024532754,
0.0432477407,
0.0299746431,
-0.0556963533,
-0.0093941204,
0.0082267979,
-0.0346353725,
-0.0176223014,
0.0900617093,
0.0117142349,
0.0103414822,
0.0513387732,
-0.0196826775,
0.0839620829,
-0.0091847423,
0.0100473939,
-0.0536839887,
0.0205760449,
-0.0155388834,
0.0211671181,
-0.0127543565,
-0.0348109901,
-0.0115820672,
-0.0480161197,
0.0160900205,
-0.044776313,
-0.0437507927,
0.0175924301,
-0.0015714628,
-0.0078760488,
0.0280498154,
-0.0114119723,
-0.0293491278,
-0.0157930423,
-0.1058335304,
-0.0507940464,
-0.031312231,
0.0171316154,
0.0054645692,
0.0085873986,
-0.0403771549,
-0.0458183847,
-0.0313259177,
-0.0085476525,
-0.0377981104,
0.0552407615,
-0.0084489565,
-0.0203009695,
-0.0321996063,
-0.0539490618,
-0.0439936705,
-0.0180015583,
0.0539804213,
0.0255102217,
-0.0458944663,
-0.0120436829,
-0.0003940189,
-0.0273159854,
0.0284081921,
0.0011619604,
-0.0311930235,
0.019155398,
0.0385522284,
0.0458067581,
0.0590208955,
0.0207846649,
0.0276472941,
0.019310113,
0.033523649,
-0.0435954481,
-0.02899638,
-0.014506097,
-0.0215447918,
-0.0276728198,
-0.0641499087,
-0.0125479074,
0.069292292,
0.0167373568,
-0.0193794705,
-0.0534749888,
0.0262063909,
-0.0375507101,
-0.0599016808,
-0.0156986807,
-0.0673693195,
-0.0078288848,
0.0134816039,
-0.057329081,
-0.0618151873,
0.0263993125,
-0.0085190125,
-0.0156428702,
-0.0117018679,
0.0152722513,
-0.0082802046,
0.0320278145,
0.0216205642,
0.0422816984,
0.0041717044,
-0.0173865445,
-0.0473731421,
-0.0249034464,
0.0441738106,
-0.0325363576,
-0.0150729623,
-0.0144444257,
0.0246444903,
0.0022861015,
-0.0502735376,
-0.0033696454,
-0.0952331126,
-0.0680746809,
-0.0137353353,
0.0366774164,
-0.0297840163,
0.0319123529,
0.0039822268,
-0.0330815315,
0.0285979025,
0.0098460512,
0.0054517514,
0.0196481831,
-0.0034490312,
0.0162044372,
0.0011702329,
0.018394487,
-0.0359598808,
-0.004970585,
0.0159522109,
0.0689823404,
-0.0093563572,
-0.0356765352,
0.0246271752,
0.0526860766,
-0.0009853258,
-0.0336628556,
0.0139104063,
0.0779493228,
-0.0088401986,
0.0472973883,
0.0966044441,
-0.0021772375,
-0.0548847429,
0.0203234199,
0.0027551244,
0.0496987738,
0.0298932418,
-0.0040000863,
-0.0912147015,
-0.015454798,
0.0200119577,
0.0271770824,
-0.0014515425,
-0.042566292,
0.0165208559,
-0.1353522092,
0.0274884887,
-0.0061481036,
-0.0368887372,
0.0285895262,
-0.0332425199,
0.0086543197,
-0.0255178902,
0.0168043617,
-0.0097646527,
-0.0008238032,
0.0132569009,
0.0434337966,
-0.0987309068,
-0.0250301063,
0.0378872752,
-0.0613441654,
0.0740543008,
0.0636581704,
0.031059267,
-0.0222536363,
-0.0110518727,
0.0514672287,
-0.0086939186,
0.0034507352,
-0.0225489177,
0.0699194521,
-0.0488349907,
-0.0305860471,
-0.0287234206,
0.0382067002,
0.0143994847,
0.0142457653,
-0.0313669592,
-0.0025258092,
0.035464745,
-0.0659770072,
-0.013343499,
0.0031951373,
-0.0019148628,
0.0824549124,
0.0332328863,
-0.039930664,
0.0054920241,
-0.0169939883,
0.0185359176,
0.0205483884,
-0.0318698511,
0.0314893313,
-0.0155252172,
-0.0841433629,
-0.0447560139,
-0.0301136393,
0.0435747541,
0.0288433526,
0.0087708589,
-0.0426836386,
0.0581826381,
0.0005906799,
-0.018242361,
0.0503060892,
-0.0034791864,
0.0314711519,
-0.0515510924,
-0.0423840396,
-0.007239779,
-0.0055327225,
-0.0332463011,
-0.0291431397,
-0.0355101973,
-0.0731399432,
0.0823790506,
0.0394253433,
0.0318087377,
0.0302756745,
-0.020869134,
-0.0833000541,
0.0597097129,
0.0318083167,
-0.0138146905,
0.0403148346,
0.0428144522,
-0.0097259358,
-0.0047563096,
0.0358110368,
-0.0119404914,
0.0386041068,
0.0243116748,
-0.012706954,
-0.0262377523,
-0.0366528258,
-0.0201250389,
0.0137980264,
0.0904933736,
-0.033981856,
0.0118707949,
-0.0498395227,
-0.014187647,
-0.0211412814,
0.0146558313,
-0.0257266164,
-0.0391873792,
0.0238960292,
0.0265159849,
-0.042432338,
0.0060601942,
-0.0244627688,
0.0181970317,
-0.0531963855,
0.070519127,
0.0343657397,
0.0556655899,
0.0305062179,
0.0236775447,
0.0039101909,
0.0330947153,
-0.0206624735,
0.0274669845,
0.0253598057,
0.0112526231,
0.0055686841,
-0.0102072107,
0.0050425637,
0.0223334432,
-0.040216282,
-0.0500446446,
-0.0249863863,
0.0423351377,
0.0198196527,
-0.0082924049,
0.0615510605,
0.0202752911,
-0.000651132,
-0.0033334936,
-0.0149371745,
-0.0047244853,
-0.0259572305,
0.0184444562,
-0.0284203887,
-0.0387762003,
0.0432817563,
0.0881953016,
0.0333215967,
0.0720675737,
-0.0134027973,
-0.0305788685,
0.0005801223,
-0.007720246,
0.0496832617,
-0.0183264986,
-0.036731489,
-0.0399340764,
-0.0637121424,
-0.0616790652,
-0.027767906,
0.0003308794,
0.0178041793,
0.0023002147,
0.0473397821,
0.0488456562,
-0.0284084547,
-0.0305649247,
0.0023129263,
-0.0226711985,
-0.0474513471,
-0.0049056076,
0.0111642899,
-6.648607069e-33,
0.0068297782,
0.0256058443,
-0.0359879322,
-0.0336166956,
-0.0058575813,
-0.0135692339,
-0.0290642176,
0.026151564,
-0.0654050857,
0.0175147764,
-0.0110629313,
0.0139994398,
0.0295981187,
-0.0139389522,
0.0067834025,
-0.0299172793,
0.0573544428,
-0.0197242349,
-0.013684676,
-0.0072491257,
-0.0190079678,
0.0342215449,
0.0566952005,
-0.0410884582,
0.0229341388,
0.0206342265,
-0.0072603519,
-0.0190626495,
0.0200315546,
0.0153264087,
-0.0186785217,
0.0553587377,
0.0069666398,
-0.0021155253,
-0.029705802,
0.0552369617,
-0.0570695065,
-0.0172466021,
0.0111975214,
0.0449294485,
0.0209274385,
0.0090100141,
0.0522744954,
0.0076430873,
-0.0840346515,
0.0382845402,
0.0310111083,
0.0110661201,
0.0179919861,
0.0240216088,
-0.0340124108,
0.020895686,
-0.0154097397,
0.0117994864,
-0.0204789694,
0.0127342157,
0.0042004213,
0.0183937084,
-0.0077268649,
0.0334426239,
0.0248874314,
-0.020488143,
0.0502289794,
-0.0008734238,
0.0398267768,
0.0771047547,
0.0857360139,
0.041241087,
0.0089699207,
-0.0589492917,
0.0509908237,
0.0238316059,
0.0025325115,
0.0520830229,
0.0155544151,
-0.0329126753,
-0.0316955559,
-0.0012146292,
0.0358703099,
-0.0146505209,
0.0279039517,
0.0014327232,
-0.0946532935,
-0.0508777313,
-0.0351291038,
-0.0576397814,
-0.0143851684,
-0.0070792385,
0.0325014442,
-0.011886864,
-0.0061374004,
0.0341088362,
0.0201834142,
-0.0587512851,
-0.0323551372,
-0.0203426648,
-0.0159933288,
0.0170046296,
-0.0099169118,
0.028762104,
-0.0823107287,
-0.012613439,
0.01035411,
0.0582823418,
0.0024571049,
-0.006707347,
-0.0001905307,
0.0173464399,
-0.080038853,
0.0146397296,
-0.0039420128,
-0.0091862101,
0.0304893479,
0.0086572766,
0.0637504533,
-0.0069240709,
0.0022304296,
0.0156867784,
0.0100534828,
0.035046991,
-0.0406570844,
-0.0228444319,
-0.0007102975,
0.0319698714,
-0.0001735021,
-0.0270661823,
-0.0208507217,
-0.0209303349,
0.0304039158,
-0.0142820245,
-0.0310988165,
-0.0463839136,
2.501e-7,
0.0229515042,
0.0626916289,
0.023101259,
-0.0221061837,
0.0218293499,
0.0254854374,
0.031656228,
0.0545102172,
0.0179363489,
0.0313025713,
-0.0096600521,
0.0311008804,
0.0236295685,
0.0147988377,
-0.0432118066,
-0.0150154997,
-0.1166178957,
0.0245650634,
-0.0369433798,
0.010989625,
-0.0290010143,
0.065109469,
0.017307343,
-0.0069013662,
-0.0265796874,
-0.0341092125,
0.034838751,
-0.0605311953,
0.0023051475,
-0.0006220417,
0.0169174448,
0.0263299104,
0.0021826916,
0.0224605221,
-0.0025043944,
0.0231734291,
-0.0061945198,
0.0121537624,
-0.032419689,
0.0298214275,
0.0128036635,
0.0094452705,
-0.0395931341,
-0.0754143596,
0.0734974071,
-0.0013306889,
-0.050562717,
-0.0199162215,
-0.0521147475,
-0.0484021977,
0.0263793133,
-0.021108957,
-0.0008675417,
-0.0190813579,
0.0274096411,
-0.029492911,
-0.0189713687,
-0.0629150197,
-0.0074901343,
-0.0002628261,
-0.0113663888,
-0.0906733945,
-0.0079112146,
0.0218223501,
0.0249030683,
-0.0098543167,
0.0400687866,
1.814363707e-34,
0.0399333499,
0.0056031626,
0.0246266369,
-0.0357162058,
0.0299339611,
-0.007981509,
-0.004139204,
-0.0324812196,
0.0293605477,
-0.0374765173,
0.0099540399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06858v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06858v3 | Vax-Culture: A Dataset for Studying Vaccine Discourse on Twitter | 2023-04-13T23:04:30 | 2023-06-11T22:11:10 | Mohammad Reza Zarei, Michael Christensen, Sarah Everts, Majid Komeili | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Vaccine hesitancy continues to be a main challenge for public health
officials during the COVID-19 pandemic. As this hesitancy undermines vaccine
campaigns, many researchers have sought to identify its root causes, finding
that the increasing volume of anti-vaccine misinformation on social media
platforms is a key element of this problem. We explored Twitter as a source of
misleading content with the goal of extracting overlapping cultural and
political beliefs that motivate the spread of vaccine misinformation. To do
this, we have collected a data set of vaccine-related Tweets and annotated them
with the help of a team of annotators with a background in communications and
journalism. Ultimately we hope this can lead to effective and targeted public
health communication strategies for reaching individuals with anti-vaccine
beliefs. Moreover, this information helps with developing Machine Learning
models to automatically detect vaccine misinformation posts and combat their
negative impacts. In this paper, we present Vax-Culture, a novel Twitter
COVID-19 dataset consisting of 6373 vaccine-related tweets accompanied by an
extensive set of human-provided annotations including vaccine-hesitancy stance,
indication of any misinformation in tweets, the entities criticized and
supported in each tweet and the communicated message of each tweet. Moreover,
we define five baseline tasks including four classification and one sequence
generation tasks, and report the results of a set of recent transformer-based
models for them. The dataset and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/mrzarei5/Vax-Culture. | [
0.0488870144,
0.0797016919,
-0.0067685861,
-0.0351381786,
-0.0045032306,
0.0374326594,
0.0197481681,
-0.0287904628,
0.0028790375,
-0.0367792621,
0.033047948,
-0.0173017103,
-0.001389484,
0.02199471,
0.0030341146,
-0.0627651364,
0.0216554496,
0.0699138418,
0.059751492,
-0.008113767,
0.0180685204,
0.0293446034,
-0.0115103852,
0.0644974336,
0.0023601844,
-0.0044582114,
0.0374383852,
-0.0155908754,
0.0854208395,
-0.0993513986,
0.0681981072,
0.0300683286,
0.0189278126,
0.0703932345,
0.0000016765,
-0.0028943345,
-0.020901816,
-0.0012425891,
-0.0021773721,
-0.0191121958,
0.0781819895,
-0.0457836837,
0.0108908918,
0.0445012189,
-0.074031502,
-0.0324277282,
0.0701186284,
0.0327138975,
0.0490111746,
0.0875649452,
-0.0203907657,
-0.0372981653,
0.0175043829,
-0.0051049963,
-0.0064769476,
-0.0058649634,
0.0601739921,
-0.0077780471,
-0.0360196158,
0.0650282055,
0.0261595268,
0.0238183681,
-0.0325100049,
-0.0106140785,
-0.0029984405,
0.0014724036,
-0.023460038,
-0.0607994236,
-0.0004412121,
0.054233484,
0.0465877838,
-0.0272133034,
0.0584958568,
-0.0043860604,
-0.0018614145,
0.0293224622,
-0.0307658222,
0.0058407248,
-0.0191234443,
0.0410852097,
0.0087506678,
0.0036114119,
0.0482480638,
0.0253115743,
0.0174213704,
0.0234518033,
-0.028598791,
-0.0263715666,
-0.0203579925,
-0.0051805293,
0.0100914193,
-0.0428267457,
0.0278802551,
0.0070609497,
-0.0013591895,
0.0247259419,
-0.001994119,
-0.0701266751,
0.0404675715,
-0.1038718745,
-0.0350976884,
-0.0012898081,
0.0197513066,
-0.0183578376,
0.0352248065,
-0.0307241548,
-0.0234358199,
0.0118332077,
0.0515020192,
0.0318299308,
-0.0734622255,
0.0118603371,
-0.0095114177,
-0.001399682,
0.0293098371,
0.0451861359,
-0.1016601995,
-0.0263050627,
-0.0542258583,
-0.0159592386,
-0.0508231632,
0.0112498701,
-0.0019175337,
0.0149523756,
0.0092537208,
0.0995077044,
-0.0134931142,
0.0179095883,
9.1e-7,
-0.0244108886,
0.0065160287,
0.0158506669,
0.0211055912,
-0.0173563678,
-0.0171261132,
0.0137099158,
0.0433172286,
-0.0052171885,
0.005854717,
-0.0074307965,
-0.037763115,
-0.0367881991,
0.0041423715,
-0.0541988425,
0.0202959515,
0.0080561936,
-0.0108973822,
-0.0454631634,
0.0128621534,
0.0332316607,
-0.0624584071,
0.0454912633,
0.0011349772,
0.0064159553,
0.074657321,
0.049715817,
0.0149141224,
0.0399483368,
0.0154057853,
0.0550243482,
0.0335168391,
-0.0128316637,
0.0148825357,
0.0116621759,
0.0541927405,
0.0000694412,
0.0363935381,
-0.013733509,
-0.0150931785,
0.0035136628,
-0.0396234803,
0.0516747572,
-0.0095849652,
-0.0215283502,
0.0342367776,
0.0391786434,
-0.0681401864,
-0.0675279051,
0.0277712382,
0.0534649976,
-0.0245706439,
-0.0078679975,
-0.0162521917,
-0.0146437846,
-0.0291411094,
-0.0457236171,
-0.0000418633,
0.0427566096,
-0.0251688156,
-0.0142904511,
-0.0302818213,
-0.0069736335,
0.0470056236,
-0.0144619364,
0.014297124,
-0.0187391378,
-0.0422981791,
0.0366107784,
0.0460939109,
-0.0303584002,
-0.0154649112,
-0.0500364453,
0.0136911599,
0.0151662249,
0.0072239521,
-0.0031381345,
-0.0483792946,
-0.0588903353,
0.0394437686,
0.0346100926,
0.0404501408,
-0.0366335325,
-0.0538029261,
0.0021672277,
-0.0216724612,
0.0086029517,
0.02994298,
-0.0049301619,
0.0423591882,
0.0199639779,
0.0139296139,
0.0535008237,
-0.0237316974,
0.0296080429,
-0.0299384128,
-0.0139097571,
-0.0038843218,
0.0335308686,
0.0736545771,
0.0526369251,
0.0306329094,
-0.0128829079,
0.0465969704,
-0.0211620443,
-0.0207181647,
0.0008597793,
0.0028147278,
0.0027446912,
0.0056621158,
-0.0476927347,
-0.0401301421,
0.0280222483,
-0.059254162,
0.0348962657,
0.0421154052,
-0.0082642231,
-0.0064789224,
-0.0216042548,
-0.0141519038,
-0.0452098884,
0.0324927382,
-0.0100607984,
0.0312884748,
-0.0540334545,
-0.0168095808,
-0.0070907008,
-0.0898795873,
-0.0190767832,
-0.0316669606,
0.0456874333,
-0.0242727939,
-0.0121748848,
-0.0135500226,
0.0376753695,
-0.0472681485,
-0.0115484614,
-0.0069284039,
-0.0683824793,
-0.0280612819,
-0.015451788,
0.0245717987,
0.0186260138,
0.0204699393,
0.0048990678,
-0.001732556,
-0.0378212258,
-0.0075515774,
0.0544689074,
0.0411850661,
0.0410307683,
-0.0274214391,
0.0014547579,
-0.0311378073,
-0.0006043794,
-0.0659950897,
0.0107242418,
0.0265656393,
-0.0681442916,
-0.0043757791,
-0.0682897121,
-0.0412990265,
-0.0238124114,
-0.012603703,
-0.0253391825,
0.0163476355,
0.0270004608,
-0.0217287783,
0.0014449438,
0.0549908206,
0.0636950135,
0.0335908979,
0.0475505516,
0.0006638939,
0.002583073,
-0.0590244159,
0.0144671639,
-0.0070853438,
-0.0601384379,
0.0149559705,
0.1075255424,
0.0112886019,
0.0054073846,
-0.0415311716,
0.0489277504,
-0.0442446172,
-0.0217700638,
0.0039447588,
-0.0285764672,
-0.0067882729,
0.0232954528,
-0.0311107673,
-0.0090958616,
0.0453461595,
0.0245044418,
0.0381210148,
-0.0461537912,
-0.0333744138,
-0.0114307487,
-0.0209061988,
0.0194362383,
0.0160613302,
0.0424567834,
0.01978557,
0.0349841639,
-0.044332318,
-0.0180485193,
-0.0431761853,
-0.0428767353,
-0.0037773312,
0.0042274483,
-0.0029214846,
-0.0210997444,
-0.0510937721,
-0.047731813,
-0.0480115823,
-0.0314197764,
0.0217958111,
-0.0313118957,
-0.0516363643,
0.0021045785,
0.0001758435,
0.0185504686,
0.0227106158,
-0.0246095546,
0.047898557,
0.0083675878,
0.020350825,
-0.0338398255,
0.0079948707,
-0.0346045233,
-0.020024607,
0.0573757254,
-0.0063203024,
0.0050718896,
-0.0193483885,
-0.0314138681,
-0.0055115675,
-0.0158568528,
-0.0128159085,
-0.0081408555,
0.0539932027,
-0.0220377631,
0.039859388,
0.0744148642,
0.0207867455,
0.0054604718,
0.009558267,
-0.0028123618,
-0.0020573132,
-0.0125425681,
0.0169341825,
-0.1124660969,
0.0012515383,
-0.0195959844,
0.0138420835,
-0.0611794181,
-0.0428538173,
-0.0052564992,
-0.0230229553,
0.0472974107,
-0.002756943,
-0.0141589772,
-0.0247657914,
-0.0786295533,
0.0033523522,
-0.0399216972,
0.0135193886,
-0.0374135599,
0.0265766829,
-0.0003675421,
-0.0019961498,
-0.0756057054,
-0.0452837013,
0.0175442528,
0.017658338,
0.032296408,
0.0339889154,
0.0837274268,
0.0276293941,
-0.0400715433,
-0.0246168692,
0.0271919332,
-0.0437859669,
-0.0144426487,
0.0920093954,
-0.0220520943,
-0.0105642062,
-0.0410710983,
0.0423632152,
-0.0426758528,
-0.0389275514,
-0.0148335053,
0.0675447881,
0.0181547124,
-0.0497587323,
-0.045100458,
0.0660231486,
0.0354820006,
0.0464276336,
0.019295061,
-0.0199997742,
-0.0047446899,
-0.036150381,
0.0422181934,
-0.0682119504,
-0.0363435633,
-0.0056345072,
-0.02164202,
-0.0698263571,
-0.0359720215,
-0.019995939,
-0.0042938469,
-0.0187344085,
-0.0048181349,
-0.0701076314,
0.0441771597,
-0.0025231813,
-0.0474110134,
0.0005249859,
0.0057668784,
0.0006879902,
0.014129377,
-0.0348938704,
-0.0065661902,
0.02076835,
0.0006019357,
0.0471366607,
-0.0556242466,
-0.0768627375,
0.0183545109,
0.0191232432,
0.0184292179,
0.0125177512,
0.0388419032,
0.0273980778,
0.0881761685,
0.0730819628,
-0.0201728996,
-0.0554450974,
0.0321579278,
0.0154008465,
0.0067778109,
0.0140037779,
0.0271297023,
0.0167251732,
-0.0022874789,
-0.010458977,
-0.1066413447,
0.0276071373,
0.0100078303,
-0.0111866686,
0.0593118705,
-0.0129392128,
-0.0402178653,
-0.0471359119,
-0.029857209,
-0.0103329234,
-0.0248572864,
0.0105695538,
-0.0261252951,
0.0269540064,
-0.0289312359,
-0.0389362052,
0.0067571742,
-0.0534144342,
0.0172326975,
-0.0578345172,
0.0630438402,
0.026012497,
0.068135865,
0.0117020905,
-0.0250573307,
0.0037327744,
0.0262538325,
-0.0108261909,
-0.0053891214,
-0.005300581,
-0.0060208319,
-0.0213599913,
0.035579823,
0.0392483808,
-0.0038640909,
-0.0411441736,
-0.0052940156,
-0.0418802053,
-0.0010610574,
-0.0056913877,
-0.0070634475,
0.0554194301,
0.0058037383,
-0.0514444821,
-0.0116784777,
0.0565167554,
-0.0433215126,
-0.0260855667,
0.0065041729,
-0.0197392181,
-0.0490505025,
-0.0179122631,
0.0481726006,
-0.0180365853,
0.0834189579,
0.0515003987,
-0.0642196983,
-0.0423937328,
-0.0262496937,
0.0182720236,
0.0184685066,
-0.0131568294,
0.0260756873,
-0.0455253869,
-0.0329586007,
0.0370745659,
-0.0421474278,
0.0145753743,
0.0109127816,
-0.0295220036,
0.0428398587,
0.0114819137,
0.0065249936,
-0.0495034195,
0.027309265,
-0.0128325,
-0.0508431122,
-0.0169119909,
-5.832570074e-33,
0.010543935,
-0.0417706668,
-0.0230093487,
0.0291868448,
0.0010459989,
0.0195308942,
-0.012958576,
-0.0015588022,
-0.0081396047,
0.0566793382,
0.0247334093,
0.0132990386,
-0.0070903371,
0.0308345333,
0.0061860462,
0.0123925619,
0.0454210229,
-0.0179947801,
-0.0067519895,
0.0316168815,
0.0411678776,
0.0191323049,
0.0318911634,
-0.1014129966,
0.062043339,
-0.0143478755,
0.0133921551,
0.0139397616,
0.0103256255,
0.0522543676,
-0.0092838835,
0.0392032713,
0.036313124,
-0.0318559855,
0.0334443636,
0.0682831407,
-0.0381995812,
-0.0180795062,
-0.0223960783,
-0.0263787359,
-0.0170806441,
-0.0634383187,
0.050505925,
-0.0028577419,
-0.0197616331,
0.0002338783,
0.0374158099,
-0.005690387,
0.020131819,
-0.0371291898,
-0.0731892511,
0.0257764254,
-0.0447065458,
0.0134947952,
0.0024224855,
0.0903359875,
-0.0068292427,
0.1007620171,
-0.0210771263,
0.0385740288,
0.0112009337,
0.00438357,
0.0183931645,
-0.0135666607,
0.0010758274,
0.0274241697,
0.016679205,
0.0025479326,
-0.0752820745,
0.0049735676,
-0.0295629948,
0.0238694157,
0.0058944602,
0.0697443336,
0.0174004603,
-0.0242757779,
-0.088951245,
0.0293229409,
-0.0034501362,
0.0339242145,
-0.01553082,
-0.0160742104,
-0.006608332,
0.0065950481,
-0.0092744334,
-0.0638809055,
0.0011111797,
-0.0045362129,
-0.0318361111,
0.0132267773,
-0.0521061942,
0.0337140821,
-0.0099781882,
-0.0092601432,
-0.0211761836,
0.0261056889,
0.0125986878,
-0.035744112,
0.013920201,
0.013850064,
-0.0520869493,
0.0184497591,
0.013207091,
0.0096678408,
0.047271464,
-0.0009677133,
0.0581086054,
-0.0097655384,
-0.0519707091,
-0.0190213155,
0.0126643023,
0.0591095798,
-0.0465896539,
0.0367152803,
0.0377188958,
0.02641505,
0.0141092921,
-0.0063145198,
0.0201380793,
0.0156593602,
0.0212205574,
-0.0327537879,
-0.0472832955,
0.0377571397,
-0.0341858231,
-0.0109709632,
-0.0021831179,
0.0552971512,
-0.0113912951,
-0.0919068977,
-0.0020703687,
-0.0631446987,
2.478e-7,
0.0778507963,
0.0916711017,
-0.0076473258,
-0.012221422,
0.0223619267,
0.0315330699,
0.0057121762,
0.0348036997,
-0.0258479919,
-0.0579765588,
0.0208984204,
0.0195214227,
0.0155983213,
0.0423076861,
-0.0489162244,
-0.0169503279,
-0.0674241483,
0.039521683,
-0.0264356993,
0.0082988711,
0.0354040861,
0.0388727784,
0.0111253718,
-0.0208175909,
-0.0300059784,
0.0556358211,
0.0606218241,
-0.0099670682,
-0.0280229691,
0.0200651828,
0.0234986693,
-0.0351472013,
0.0145367887,
0.0168536678,
-0.054563351,
-0.0449294038,
-0.0264486987,
0.0453407094,
0.0023870755,
-0.0052969223,
0.0151242875,
-0.0164764691,
-0.0029879077,
-0.0300387647,
0.0063015288,
-0.0871097296,
-0.0812736675,
-0.0396283269,
-0.0480153821,
0.0361257456,
0.0486207642,
0.0077725565,
-0.0016816432,
0.0210816618,
0.0053756689,
0.0161714461,
0.0097828768,
-0.0562814437,
0.0087399911,
-0.0122904638,
-0.0321372338,
-0.0308184978,
0.0150754405,
-0.0218083598,
0.0090412591,
0.0000624786,
0.080301702,
1.734002597e-34,
0.0422360227,
-0.0108552007,
-0.0365279503,
-0.0390160196,
0.0148652922,
-0.0018669995,
0.006597504,
0.0082816901,
0.0183904152,
-0.0007235772,
0.0287767779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06845v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06845v2 | SemEval-2023 Task 12: Sentiment Analysis for African Languages (AfriSenti-SemEval) | 2023-04-13T22:26:10 | 2023-05-01T10:18:04 | Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Idris Abdulmumin, Seid Muhie Yimam, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Ibrahim Sa'id Ahmad, Nedjma Ousidhoum, Abinew Ayele, Saif M. Mohammad, Meriem Beloucif, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the first Africentric SemEval Shared task, Sentiment Analysis for
African Languages (AfriSenti-SemEval) - The dataset is available at
https://github.com/afrisenti-semeval/afrisent-semeval-2023. AfriSenti-SemEval
is a sentiment classification challenge in 14 African languages: Amharic,
Algerian Arabic, Hausa, Igbo, Kinyarwanda, Moroccan Arabic, Mozambican
Portuguese, Nigerian Pidgin, Oromo, Swahili, Tigrinya, Twi, Xitsonga, and
Yor\`ub\'a (Muhammad et al., 2023), using data labeled with 3 sentiment
classes. We present three subtasks: (1) Task A: monolingual classification,
which received 44 submissions; (2) Task B: multilingual classification, which
received 32 submissions; and (3) Task C: zero-shot classification, which
received 34 submissions. The best performance for tasks A and B was achieved by
NLNDE team with 71.31 and 75.06 weighted F1, respectively. UCAS-IIE-NLP
achieved the best average score for task C with 58.15 weighted F1. We describe
the various approaches adopted by the top 10 systems and their approaches. | [
0.0250706524,
0.0686350688,
0.0108280685,
0.0631792396,
-0.0129821794,
0.0622189045,
-0.0096584251,
-0.0181711018,
-0.0126489401,
-0.0369731002,
-0.0417939685,
-0.0825762004,
0.039140325,
0.0007102433,
-0.0099572083,
-0.0235460699,
0.0124869952,
0.0299738385,
0.0423900336,
-0.0194546822,
0.0073440243,
0.0456576683,
-0.0201699231,
-0.0068897712,
-0.0374480635,
0.0091029825,
-0.0181509499,
-0.0121674687,
-0.0003188553,
-0.0067500621,
0.0161222033,
0.0424162112,
-0.0508900099,
0.0117761092,
0.0000021863,
-0.0400153995,
0.0013415839,
-0.0228362083,
0.0158378631,
-0.031522356,
0.066276513,
-0.0417446606,
-0.0213984903,
0.0265313853,
-0.0301408432,
-0.025553599,
0.061473161,
0.020192882,
0.0640959963,
0.0863504931,
-0.0068533807,
-0.0405621193,
-0.0081046475,
-0.0221752208,
-0.0028424254,
0.0026754588,
-0.0134823928,
-0.0281918123,
-0.0303016622,
0.0235450119,
-0.0216960683,
-0.0003676768,
-0.0112722293,
-0.0042656474,
0.0196275078,
-0.0395360664,
-0.0487371348,
-0.0591368079,
0.0084840562,
0.0071838228,
0.0188909825,
0.0024641673,
-0.048368521,
0.0162547063,
-0.0470959581,
-0.0522659458,
-0.0050312802,
0.0151543906,
0.0035485711,
0.0548717938,
0.0134022543,
0.0797262043,
0.0443491675,
0.0425688997,
-0.0254479274,
0.0342944749,
-0.0344367921,
-0.0048199557,
0.0653538927,
0.0730587766,
0.0048192749,
0.0275518801,
-0.002225071,
-0.0274575315,
-0.0057336586,
-0.0405949652,
0.0637053996,
-0.0223427992,
0.0313171893,
-0.0957453549,
0.0276969466,
0.0052510058,
-0.0276043043,
0.0321197025,
-0.0551935881,
0.0024930935,
0.0175476335,
-0.0369528458,
-0.0046996051,
-0.0312776342,
-0.0448538363,
0.0068025198,
0.04163149,
0.0395923406,
-0.0299710389,
0.0453933664,
-0.0966658667,
-0.0267490745,
-0.0438033417,
-0.0118533792,
-0.0185839143,
-0.0141576631,
0.0575819165,
-0.0112024555,
-0.0097111799,
0.0265546869,
-0.0366014689,
0.0181163978,
-0.0861740187,
-0.0541737042,
0.0389444679,
0.00963818,
-0.0290820654,
0.0193004683,
0.0369300321,
0.0749151334,
0.0129150143,
-0.0571142398,
-0.0585493408,
-0.0231259465,
-0.0022588151,
-0.0461127795,
-0.0376976915,
-0.0589030012,
0.0446369424,
0.0143196788,
0.0348799564,
0.0237149894,
-0.0005397543,
-0.0214818381,
0.0254752729,
0.0553647354,
0.0097476849,
-0.0145732341,
0.0298904479,
0.0192786735,
0.0448265001,
0.0518526547,
-0.0336532183,
0.0266444758,
0.0290363953,
0.023391977,
-0.0231088921,
-0.0015212699,
0.010398183,
-0.0159806237,
-0.0103982566,
-0.0036039951,
0.009438809,
-0.0221751798,
-0.0010223457,
0.0011881497,
0.0271245874,
-0.0279521383,
0.0106905382,
-0.0043744738,
-0.0311664008,
0.0348552242,
-0.0001699488,
-0.0364827253,
0.0025568833,
-0.019483367,
0.0114077209,
0.0185090695,
-0.0144770667,
-0.0623990297,
0.0808578208,
0.0363450199,
-0.0273867827,
-0.0637761578,
0.0186509341,
-0.0501606278,
0.0152959181,
-0.0035657501,
0.0437057652,
-0.0287571158,
-0.011245288,
-0.0447638631,
0.0586776249,
-0.0692341253,
-0.008944056,
-0.0344582088,
0.0266627017,
0.0194397271,
-0.0221481882,
0.036183469,
-0.0204171203,
-0.014680489,
-0.0148869622,
0.0234816689,
0.000317828,
-0.0144376596,
0.0536481403,
-0.0546736419,
0.0110084126,
-0.0018179798,
0.0139231505,
0.0119539248,
0.0205311403,
0.0954168886,
-0.0088185091,
0.0238378737,
-0.0000606405,
-0.0026465117,
0.0166011415,
-0.0018642254,
0.027215844,
0.0379943661,
0.0643510297,
0.048622828,
-0.0087474808,
-0.0115151927,
0.008543103,
-0.0409449935,
-0.017074937,
0.0297874268,
-0.0334148444,
-0.0398744158,
0.0134147638,
-0.0114954775,
0.0038148758,
0.0322897583,
0.0013333978,
-0.0103940042,
0.0719907507,
0.0223858617,
0.0281394273,
-0.0238048416,
0.0163318701,
-0.0444820598,
0.0221199449,
0.0191613119,
0.0366708189,
0.0262750778,
0.0044983043,
-0.0232373551,
-0.0195239745,
0.0693294257,
0.0296643954,
-0.0292124636,
0.0372019708,
0.0181193221,
-0.0246583596,
0.0213705748,
0.0133456057,
-0.0145716751,
-0.0209121574,
-0.070269987,
-0.0189228561,
-0.0080183716,
0.0368147269,
-0.0309979115,
0.0511882491,
-0.002491191,
0.018959431,
-0.0245706569,
0.0059754816,
0.000891955,
-0.0074817799,
-0.0029447514,
-0.0126146097,
0.0335405841,
-0.0268741194,
0.0130388299,
0.0412708484,
0.0189148337,
0.010885465,
-0.0169545207,
0.0107645961,
0.0045564389,
-0.0407073013,
-0.009538346,
0.0263579395,
-0.0375983305,
0.0009626355,
-0.0359113999,
-0.040365655,
-0.024094427,
-0.0082753142,
0.0328591652,
-0.0131655363,
0.0242094416,
-0.0118854176,
0.0045569572,
-0.0356104933,
0.0370170213,
0.0075009284,
-0.0056829765,
-0.001983112,
0.0799550489,
0.0185866188,
-0.0182259399,
-0.0357862748,
-0.0243937355,
-0.0257445611,
-0.0140920402,
-0.0026971078,
0.0047669737,
0.040272031,
-0.0090011302,
0.0012280518,
-0.0398245119,
0.0597186387,
0.0328719504,
-0.0089822384,
-0.0677799433,
-0.0050226711,
-0.0438961461,
0.0387817286,
-0.0371159539,
0.0027215758,
-0.0072621703,
0.0358949862,
0.0150563829,
-0.0341516361,
0.0191533789,
0.0005479533,
0.0119984476,
0.0087161865,
-0.0054936637,
-0.0013682112,
-0.0550370328,
0.0367843769,
-0.0295302235,
-0.0574736111,
-0.0236089118,
0.0396374054,
0.0086207176,
0.0146796219,
-0.0168577898,
-0.024702454,
-0.0498304404,
0.0119142607,
-0.0142770084,
0.0616294667,
0.0333562642,
-0.0269918647,
-0.0317764133,
0.0254623108,
0.0009116132,
0.0029762711,
0.0457189828,
-0.0405859686,
-0.0095380535,
-0.0208711736,
-0.0342787877,
0.0420689359,
-0.0120569877,
-0.0334412679,
-0.0646667704,
0.0103746383,
-0.0256880075,
0.0438381471,
0.0766084343,
0.0469750576,
-0.0440194048,
0.0038964958,
-0.0082355728,
0.0028003303,
-0.0153974062,
-0.0095890863,
-0.0626891181,
-0.0273987055,
-0.0228774231,
-0.0116845239,
-0.0400097035,
-0.0062697008,
0.007479616,
-0.0941474736,
-0.0004838077,
0.0165148955,
-0.0149462242,
-0.0405298248,
-0.0527199171,
-0.03837106,
-0.0335641727,
-0.0422937572,
-0.0577367656,
0.0463693924,
0.003846982,
0.0426680036,
-0.0235305652,
-0.0665599555,
0.0305076521,
-0.0062030456,
0.0324601047,
0.0258754157,
0.0171563718,
-0.0264432691,
-0.0304430537,
0.0107679702,
-0.0308940765,
-0.0226763189,
-0.0916256458,
0.020822268,
0.0075892145,
-0.0438510738,
-0.019234335,
-0.0423546843,
-0.0523741618,
0.0162107851,
-0.0098891053,
0.0585575104,
-0.0151706915,
-0.0333691947,
-0.0609656759,
0.0103767002,
0.0155525757,
0.0172338597,
-0.014268945,
-0.0634604692,
-0.0257864483,
0.0117920693,
0.0200304501,
-0.0626914799,
0.0023576622,
-0.027205253,
0.0306862239,
-0.025686603,
-0.0558059998,
-0.0910584554,
-0.0045752097,
-0.0008409736,
-0.0363974571,
-0.0009491625,
-0.0293712635,
0.0090699838,
-0.0293339826,
-0.0051394082,
0.0323552974,
0.0293462705,
-0.0117140776,
-0.0259428471,
0.0557489507,
-0.0006117491,
0.0260778964,
-0.0292261429,
-0.0668063238,
-0.0337262899,
-0.0135349836,
0.0428428277,
0.0080600195,
-0.017757576,
0.0260821432,
-0.0467666276,
0.0233429018,
0.0048096632,
-0.0092046736,
0.0032656945,
0.0522908866,
0.0648287162,
-0.0135803428,
0.0418143347,
0.046265889,
0.0551028922,
0.0371857472,
-0.0282970052,
-0.000470051,
-0.0350562036,
-0.0304026846,
-0.0539571792,
0.046758607,
-0.0348534696,
-0.0510942973,
-0.0285240971,
-0.0148912771,
0.0372881703,
0.0191333778,
-0.0254569668,
-0.0110999346,
0.0122583658,
0.0422955044,
-0.0677570328,
-0.0149111906,
-0.0180484895,
-0.0396486707,
0.021021435,
0.0717036948,
0.0864813775,
-0.0106893852,
-0.00883439,
0.0682270378,
-0.0049530044,
-0.0068168174,
0.004823945,
0.0065251878,
-0.0329990909,
0.0020682351,
-0.0065967157,
0.0200413,
0.0014319038,
0.0236110613,
0.0472979769,
0.1059818491,
-0.0398650207,
0.0314206257,
0.0407658704,
-0.0246593654,
0.0308391154,
0.0159364734,
-0.0021624367,
0.001081998,
0.0365495384,
-0.0367191695,
-0.0246174298,
0.0071131554,
-0.0124627575,
-0.0149168037,
0.0360537022,
0.0387337357,
-0.0904915333,
0.0207063239,
0.0602080524,
0.0188411046,
-0.0207313262,
0.0090402979,
0.0495304465,
-0.0449860096,
0.0037732315,
0.0623379536,
-0.063261874,
-0.0647628903,
0.0753559172,
-0.0418731645,
0.0096868547,
0.0390479788,
0.0109425038,
0.038998004,
0.0392798297,
0.0751707703,
-0.0491208173,
-0.0269195344,
-0.0420064665,
-0.0064644264,
0.0000012942,
-6.319133634e-33,
0.028437281,
0.0305640809,
-0.0626748949,
-0.0050627058,
-0.0120212771,
0.0018079004,
0.0059512346,
0.0612255558,
-0.03923795,
0.0379015505,
-0.000428398,
0.0040518795,
0.0042878301,
0.0309456512,
0.0689228922,
0.0054372642,
0.0029102624,
0.0025636165,
-0.0290015303,
0.01292112,
0.0147337969,
0.0509360619,
0.0609179549,
-0.0893897042,
0.0694103092,
-0.0121952323,
-0.0441128202,
0.0050435765,
0.0412177518,
0.0510970764,
-0.0432214066,
0.0891457349,
0.0456704311,
0.001972259,
0.0310185347,
-0.0219604969,
-0.0182208233,
-0.0243276116,
-0.0068443073,
0.047295358,
-0.0305754505,
-0.0626177788,
-0.0139106745,
0.02052439,
-0.066944398,
-0.0028045487,
0.0074433559,
-0.041863922,
0.0044733565,
-0.0230839495,
-0.0533620752,
0.0367847122,
0.0277785789,
-0.0205342509,
0.0416001193,
0.0670831874,
-0.0142108612,
-0.0091151167,
-0.0421513282,
0.0319643393,
-0.0345924348,
0.0137268528,
-0.0278369673,
0.010268121,
-0.0355122313,
0.0532618612,
0.0413355753,
-0.030739557,
0.0218159929,
0.0584282391,
0.0057875486,
-0.0638246089,
0.0152550768,
0.1113563776,
0.0279087517,
-0.0344246067,
-0.0422565155,
0.0197656862,
0.0693086982,
-0.0017836323,
0.0010102622,
-0.0095595485,
-0.0298479851,
-0.0234260019,
0.0446603894,
-0.0365274549,
-0.0203118976,
-0.0190260038,
-0.0086481161,
-0.030100381,
0.0015253148,
0.0299874879,
-0.0029840416,
-0.0205508601,
-0.032075759,
0.0158223845,
-0.0242321286,
0.0242814869,
0.0381844789,
-0.0134162055,
-0.0418805927,
0.0021331967,
-0.0468641184,
0.0574338436,
0.0132788047,
-0.0080850087,
0.0598597229,
0.0574964993,
-0.08011581,
-0.0018107217,
-0.019579852,
0.0461697318,
-0.0006425027,
0.1054043993,
-0.0477846302,
-0.0142717501,
-0.006293254,
0.0375305489,
-0.007703918,
0.0210034885,
0.0301679112,
0.0033777056,
0.0093211159,
-0.006511136,
-0.0423551798,
-0.0303248167,
-0.012441366,
-0.0052489699,
-0.0343176387,
-0.0425900109,
0.0113186585,
-0.0331708677,
2.822e-7,
0.0216844399,
0.0122887418,
-0.0103877466,
-0.061815571,
-0.0133394282,
0.0545722581,
-0.0309789088,
-0.0185438469,
-0.0174927823,
0.0663070008,
0.0002119341,
-0.0090838922,
0.071826905,
0.032604672,
-0.0880377218,
0.0380660854,
-0.007834143,
-0.0049930671,
-0.003298912,
0.0100598028,
0.0479451418,
0.1645290852,
0.0166915543,
-0.0384600461,
-0.0725175068,
0.0123578282,
0.0552861691,
-0.024727352,
-0.0222682785,
-0.0287261978,
-0.0344478637,
0.0278131776,
-0.0343853906,
-0.0311501659,
-0.0389466956,
-0.0048605651,
-0.0017161587,
0.0588888042,
0.0055967052,
-0.0097486628,
0.0434459373,
0.0400855467,
-0.0202162862,
0.0043251663,
0.0231631193,
0.0162011068,
-0.0802995488,
-0.0560244024,
0.012530406,
0.0088736033,
0.0759803727,
-0.0115983794,
-0.0218223818,
-0.0019423753,
0.0003332971,
-0.062401101,
-0.0672050044,
-0.0534355231,
-0.0087893531,
-0.0043630223,
0.0187559184,
0.0173414499,
0.0356861874,
0.035047181,
0.0605088621,
0.0066523249,
0.0360802077,
2.033862596e-34,
0.0324787833,
-0.0487349294,
0.0086658206,
0.0148876617,
-0.0235803165,
-0.0083993692,
-0.0287713148,
-0.0201789476,
0.0454040356,
0.055647701,
0.0329601765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06798v1 | On the Opportunities and Challenges of Foundation Models for Geospatial Artificial Intelligence | 2023-04-13T19:50:17 | 2023-04-13T19:50:17 | Gengchen Mai, Weiming Huang, Jin Sun, Suhang Song, Deepak Mishra, Ninghao Liu, Song Gao, Tianming Liu, Gao Cong, Yingjie Hu, Chris Cundy, Ziyuan Li, Rui Zhu, Ni Lao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.0; I.2.4; I.2.7; I.2.10; I.5.1 | Large pre-trained models, also known as foundation models (FMs), are trained
in a task-agnostic manner on large-scale data and can be adapted to a wide
range of downstream tasks by fine-tuning, few-shot, or even zero-shot learning.
Despite their successes in language and vision tasks, we have yet seen an
attempt to develop foundation models for geospatial artificial intelligence
(GeoAI). In this work, we explore the promises and challenges of developing
multimodal foundation models for GeoAI. We first investigate the potential of
many existing FMs by testing their performances on seven tasks across multiple
geospatial subdomains including Geospatial Semantics, Health Geography, Urban
Geography, and Remote Sensing. Our results indicate that on several geospatial
tasks that only involve text modality such as toponym recognition, location
description recognition, and US state-level/county-level dementia time series
forecasting, these task-agnostic LLMs can outperform task-specific
fully-supervised models in a zero-shot or few-shot learning setting. However,
on other geospatial tasks, especially tasks that involve multiple data
modalities (e.g., POI-based urban function classification, street view
image-based urban noise intensity classification, and remote sensing image
scene classification), existing foundation models still underperform
task-specific models. Based on these observations, we propose that one of the
major challenges of developing a FM for GeoAI is to address the multimodality
nature of geospatial tasks. After discussing the distinct challenges of each
geospatial data modality, we suggest the possibility of a multimodal foundation
model which can reason over various types of geospatial data through geospatial
alignments. We conclude this paper by discussing the unique risks and
challenges to develop such a model for GeoAI. | [
0.0171447117,
0.1139755771,
-0.0028048034,
0.005831114,
-0.0162320379,
0.04908932,
0.0465462841,
-0.0484095365,
0.0077690268,
-0.0458344333,
-0.0252163298,
-0.0451594405,
0.0167253707,
0.0141268577,
0.0318015106,
-0.115519926,
0.0283446386,
-0.0124236681,
0.0017110297,
0.0202790461,
-0.0488600731,
-0.0034048005,
-0.0237425938,
0.0318181664,
-0.0196577739,
0.01135711,
-0.0213224664,
0.0036934211,
0.017920617,
-0.0525761619,
0.0123839164,
-0.013616601,
0.0389734097,
-0.0309351869,
0.000002074,
-0.0224091411,
0.0157639775,
0.0104011102,
0.0323618166,
-0.0367857628,
0.006419586,
-0.0101615191,
0.0191452708,
-0.0260214321,
-0.043989554,
-0.0383780189,
0.0834625736,
0.0297449045,
0.0393125974,
0.0455215685,
-0.0299750846,
-0.0716706961,
0.0342740119,
-0.0078203939,
-0.0046732281,
0.0199547354,
0.0053956527,
-0.0294080228,
-0.0420530736,
0.0200839322,
-0.0328715183,
-0.0160743911,
-0.0050552445,
0.0664171502,
0.0001606275,
0.0462438092,
-0.0033297383,
-0.0086917467,
-0.0209271181,
0.0478421785,
-0.0128066214,
-0.0066591268,
0.0329783782,
0.0594202802,
-0.0536885336,
0.0255573373,
-0.051289387,
0.0002535204,
0.0007080979,
0.0519741178,
-0.0165853854,
0.0265559535,
0.0525954328,
0.067032516,
-0.061390128,
0.0743077844,
-0.0274534244,
-0.0185417421,
-0.0263717026,
0.0053794426,
0.0032722717,
-0.0375876762,
-0.0414903462,
0.0483591706,
-0.0032120771,
-0.0179053657,
-0.0002369669,
0.0531060994,
0.0066763293,
-0.0055963006,
0.0370664485,
0.0169809982,
-0.0727931261,
0.0942851603,
0.0030329628,
-0.0125158392,
-0.0055685565,
0.0595801808,
0.0292722508,
-0.0599312298,
-0.0471983999,
0.0153699415,
-0.0158379003,
0.0273225605,
-0.0218292568,
0.0007457216,
-0.0312941559,
0.0161792096,
-0.0217249636,
0.004834889,
-0.0634669214,
0.0295168273,
-0.007921882,
-0.0259760674,
0.0048830817,
0.0025433344,
0.0063719614,
0.0427707657,
-0.004859278,
-0.0037295085,
0.0237468593,
0.0272281021,
0.0257085394,
0.0166549832,
0.0027657181,
0.0544469878,
0.0569963083,
-0.0237025451,
-0.0902580991,
0.0104127722,
0.0078235576,
-0.0447941497,
0.044821538,
-0.0234289896,
-0.0233217794,
-0.0049359654,
-0.0192938056,
-0.0423249565,
-0.0312310569,
-0.0182129107,
-0.0486093536,
0.0832272619,
0.0033521692,
0.0149328113,
0.0614637099,
-0.0087733837,
0.011906038,
0.0803967714,
0.0278763305,
0.0566792302,
0.0454114042,
-0.0051052715,
-0.016112363,
0.0061727045,
0.0325780287,
0.052625142,
-0.0255277343,
0.0035201213,
-0.045470465,
-0.0088222213,
0.01580723,
-0.0076571042,
-0.0047358712,
0.0223214161,
0.0622872598,
0.0394237898,
0.0140047399,
-0.0127378777,
0.0908828676,
0.007994676,
-0.0530031696,
-0.0279175788,
-0.0538039915,
-0.0147173172,
-0.0630466938,
-0.00174601,
-0.0227350406,
0.0491023436,
-0.0494685918,
-0.0336050913,
0.0078526065,
-0.0440919362,
0.0165361166,
0.0119447345,
0.0846857503,
-0.0250673406,
0.0139271403,
0.0119456062,
0.0319381468,
0.0039687646,
-0.0102641443,
-0.0327320136,
0.0081520928,
-0.0032604251,
-0.0321520269,
-0.0198708363,
-0.0073065273,
0.0057177898,
0.0671534911,
0.0054549919,
0.041829329,
0.0207045861,
0.0181448236,
-0.0610802621,
-0.0481947698,
0.0181200076,
0.0351393931,
-0.0220977087,
0.0355567187,
0.0412744693,
0.0405732393,
-0.0510822497,
0.0109867975,
-0.0080439886,
0.0087983869,
-0.0112934588,
-0.0308822449,
0.0668945163,
0.006275747,
-0.0320650749,
-0.0066572595,
-0.0009702701,
-0.0017427544,
-0.0242417678,
0.0090904916,
0.0327520706,
-0.0351668075,
0.0140777929,
-0.0084405821,
0.0129808476,
0.0380328372,
0.0248594489,
-0.0521369204,
-0.0338786654,
0.013965793,
-0.0152757056,
0.0332484692,
-0.0342697985,
0.0042158365,
0.0070217284,
0.0125547787,
-0.0386709794,
0.0320670232,
-0.0307286866,
-0.0482042208,
0.0041298144,
0.0226459075,
0.0518454798,
0.0178003851,
-0.0164689701,
-0.0590978265,
-0.0312016308,
-0.0011908009,
-0.0345759504,
-0.0003884238,
0.0076643601,
-0.0077947685,
-0.125909999,
-0.0043084505,
-0.0132261962,
-0.0162641983,
-0.0139424857,
-0.031431023,
-0.0149807585,
-0.0461520851,
-0.0045719962,
0.0335228853,
0.0014254209,
0.0205664616,
0.023045551,
-0.0373611934,
0.0173526946,
0.0120652411,
0.0038991382,
-0.022609679,
0.0495405681,
-0.0169877764,
-0.0631261915,
-0.0091865296,
-0.00458183,
-0.0334338583,
0.0322394259,
-0.0048622726,
-0.0231820792,
-0.0050939079,
-0.0251588896,
-0.0041270829,
0.0025658784,
-0.0033738525,
0.0088527221,
0.0011608512,
-0.0419969261,
-0.0068158838,
0.0246995259,
-0.0183474775,
0.044824481,
-0.0149253774,
-0.021074973,
0.0078729372,
0.0506628677,
0.0003331924,
0.0131274005,
-0.0039438019,
0.0373307243,
-0.024947919,
-0.0084770517,
-0.0275737327,
0.0137317451,
0.0299912691,
0.0413137004,
-0.0612045527,
-0.0801787898,
-0.000776415,
-0.0124270208,
0.0223688837,
-0.0071352497,
-0.0119770672,
-0.042560339,
0.0518416464,
-0.0007648089,
0.036825709,
0.0331274904,
-0.0100242095,
0.0027779886,
-0.062407963,
-0.0355403908,
-0.0083067706,
0.0153420009,
-0.0477179289,
0.0050056912,
-0.0094299177,
-0.0621358566,
-0.0321326032,
-0.02294695,
-0.0333874263,
0.0162159763,
-0.0583817735,
-0.0305330064,
0.0263876747,
0.0707857683,
0.0071465573,
0.0403752364,
0.0030994874,
-0.0032092535,
-0.0016002398,
0.0301945191,
0.0362088457,
0.0897411481,
-0.0374701135,
0.0204275567,
-0.0435248762,
-0.032724537,
-0.0137329418,
0.0062524332,
-0.0307684075,
0.063142404,
0.0113349594,
-0.0031081049,
-0.0491402671,
0.0137596894,
0.0556081757,
-0.031577345,
-0.0325258896,
0.0481302254,
0.0172233004,
-0.032000538,
-0.001381874,
-0.0005934357,
-0.0205703117,
0.0093394732,
-0.0212461706,
-0.0318162777,
-0.0292854384,
0.0076326909,
-0.0376624763,
-0.0001988032,
-0.0170708466,
0.0026329104,
-0.0969342068,
0.0887106359,
0.0166350845,
-0.0580415092,
0.0134948166,
-0.048573941,
-0.0096176462,
0.006665715,
-0.0712505355,
-0.0686681122,
-0.0236819107,
-0.0240835249,
0.0481011607,
-0.0598469526,
-0.0877508447,
-0.0180121753,
-0.0545048565,
0.010686608,
0.0358180664,
0.0446344577,
-0.02686207,
-0.0577491485,
-0.0120534915,
0.0393256694,
0.0595064275,
-0.029314613,
0.0554977879,
0.0084450105,
-0.0191537384,
0.0113438433,
-0.0121793309,
-0.026102541,
-0.0184884705,
-0.0032847079,
0.0537947454,
-0.0764436871,
0.0598260574,
-0.0653753877,
0.0209782906,
0.0548900627,
0.0085880645,
0.0090140756,
-0.0050862646,
-0.056307666,
0.0028692028,
-0.0268987082,
-0.0654147714,
-0.0035188303,
0.0321593359,
-0.0176936686,
-0.0435198024,
-0.0079214871,
-0.0337515175,
-0.0015707752,
0.0550165251,
0.014861932,
-0.0419847779,
0.0380752608,
-0.039107129,
-0.0820915103,
0.0367233083,
-0.0198508631,
-0.0038146826,
-0.0308988262,
-0.0139983501,
0.0482177585,
-0.0374030061,
0.0044425684,
-0.000111933,
-0.0741130486,
0.0074408161,
0.0122922873,
0.0675311834,
0.0189726129,
-0.0155364415,
-0.0290925261,
0.0043723374,
0.0751757994,
0.0165048335,
-0.0138068544,
-0.0074199187,
0.0443534069,
-0.012918842,
0.0238012802,
-0.0076311543,
-0.0106567806,
0.0834442005,
0.0467444398,
-0.0561407171,
-0.0431707166,
0.0727862418,
-0.0491248332,
-0.0048597022,
0.1468324363,
-0.0009248948,
-0.0117673567,
-0.0192924645,
-0.0129509494,
0.0134281134,
0.021981502,
-0.0056600948,
0.0058981925,
0.0217647441,
0.047093004,
-0.0283129849,
0.0433262996,
0.0195098724,
-0.0303691402,
-0.0480293371,
-0.0226409752,
0.0147937099,
0.0293198768,
-0.0283835735,
0.0347558036,
-0.0167508703,
0.0264595151,
-0.0083115865,
-0.0049942392,
0.0039030237,
0.0331488326,
0.0246461965,
0.0417334586,
-0.0689111501,
0.0538484044,
-0.0256064758,
-0.0455478877,
-0.031049097,
0.0146912066,
0.0894415081,
-0.0130793164,
-0.0218877234,
0.0009257136,
-0.0007185507,
0.0144248819,
0.0095227798,
0.0456217192,
-0.0507665835,
0.0274965204,
-0.0138054565,
-0.0371451788,
0.0417242795,
0.033887323,
0.0267718732,
0.0317629315,
0.0026306845,
-0.0080564581,
-0.022332048,
0.0106712375,
0.033986751,
0.0156676788,
-0.0103733847,
0.0287806373,
-0.0658157691,
-0.0336858742,
0.0591230616,
-0.0436005034,
-0.0116118621,
0.0141125368,
0.0149977934,
0.041410137,
-0.0117591862,
-0.0281693731,
-0.0432496443,
-0.0154681318,
-0.0446810499,
-0.0070021055,
0.0229159165,
-5.953013797e-33,
0.0113265514,
-0.0484471433,
0.0798751861,
-0.0301330984,
-0.0208399184,
0.0382425599,
-0.0239945073,
-0.039777793,
-0.0246395543,
-0.0181528851,
-0.0056334436,
-0.0354124419,
0.0135670388,
0.0415142961,
0.0343791805,
0.0105283195,
0.0317519419,
0.0189759899,
0.0022188786,
0.0009560208,
0.0475917123,
-0.0022594428,
0.0453805737,
-0.1090310216,
-0.0597055666,
0.0345338918,
-0.048806645,
0.0196549278,
0.0258326195,
0.0720907375,
-0.0399268754,
0.0437452421,
0.0520822033,
-0.0103404736,
-0.0275251381,
0.0156482756,
-0.0590893701,
-0.009515861,
-0.0057962076,
0.0036719427,
-0.0410184525,
-0.0067632045,
0.0210608598,
0.0242106412,
0.0120746316,
-0.0044037686,
0.0411890447,
-0.0387667939,
-0.0418619365,
-0.0186692812,
-0.0597763211,
0.0434165858,
0.0197955575,
-0.0243021641,
0.0008358725,
0.0116885733,
-0.0009067758,
0.0522542112,
-0.0332557,
0.0440847203,
0.0416390039,
-0.0367495827,
0.0002997114,
0.030838199,
0.0237168688,
0.0640037879,
0.0238680206,
-0.0126986541,
-0.0542019084,
-0.0358890221,
0.0592203811,
0.0647901073,
-0.041834604,
0.0686539859,
0.0182178598,
-0.02833841,
-0.0691913441,
0.0288004745,
-0.0285709966,
0.0282267611,
-0.0043249046,
-0.0243030395,
-0.0270726401,
0.0037750646,
-0.0149238557,
-0.0486210436,
-0.0203790013,
-0.0057056304,
0.0438272655,
0.013961385,
0.0254756026,
0.1036580727,
0.025119476,
-0.028833149,
-0.0239510797,
0.0276721679,
0.0176636167,
0.0181956347,
-0.0056635458,
-0.0021209191,
-0.0518783368,
-0.0726590157,
0.0016901596,
0.0525628924,
0.0032763851,
0.056141872,
0.0349026956,
0.0600157753,
-0.0254471116,
-0.018289065,
-0.0057710879,
-0.0136621194,
-0.0041370513,
0.0203300007,
0.0162779782,
-0.0092311157,
0.0034562463,
0.0491037592,
0.0055214521,
0.0212339014,
-0.0013880379,
-0.0238072369,
-0.0309602693,
0.0521667674,
0.0140054664,
-0.0169111118,
-0.0062827407,
-0.0585759841,
-0.0244955011,
-0.0524140522,
-0.0068052667,
-0.0044631343,
2.897e-7,
0.0064112162,
0.0645775795,
-0.0024060376,
-0.02210523,
-0.0074668485,
0.0172119681,
-0.0156465676,
0.0246160999,
-0.054312434,
0.0362974368,
0.0363328084,
0.0429137945,
0.0426867045,
0.0419338532,
-0.0667308941,
0.0813457072,
-0.0301704984,
-0.013144115,
-0.0895975828,
0.0146946628,
0.0258938298,
0.0741206482,
0.0347440541,
-0.0488932021,
0.0492756292,
-0.01643507,
0.0508806631,
-0.0345951281,
-0.0277152956,
0.0024186475,
0.0220544524,
0.0318623558,
0.0220921692,
-0.0014168544,
-0.021810079,
0.0011646735,
0.0149831809,
0.0404928029,
-0.0441846699,
-0.0214512218,
-0.0159249045,
-0.0357515775,
-0.0094566159,
-0.0629672483,
0.0601791963,
-0.0427829139,
-0.0260974634,
-0.0179738756,
-0.0292058922,
0.0237602573,
0.0485200956,
0.0203212649,
-0.0203788094,
-0.0317519605,
0.0188879538,
-0.005476763,
-0.0220413636,
-0.0653997436,
0.0011890273,
0.0519257076,
0.0137070389,
0.0187032167,
0.0048392555,
-0.037540786,
0.0563459434,
-0.0431015231,
-0.0266391244,
2.484325577e-34,
-0.0015165316,
-0.0122038573,
-0.0074741254,
-0.0567543581,
0.0011039858,
0.0087781632,
-0.0342786796,
-0.0162049867,
-0.0014753615,
-0.0062289489,
0.0380328819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11130v1 | Automated Mapping of CVE Vulnerability Records to MITRE CWE Weaknesses | 2023-04-13T19:46:54 | 2023-04-13T19:46:54 | Ashraf Haddad, Najwa Aaraj, Preslav Nakov, Septimiu Fabian Mare | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | In recent years, a proliferation of cyber-security threats and diversity has
been on the rise culminating in an increase in their reporting and analysis. To
counter that, many non-profit organizations have emerged in this domain, such
as MITRE and OSWAP, which have been actively tracking vulnerabilities, and
publishing defense recommendations in standardized formats. As producing data
in such formats manually is very time-consuming, there have been some proposals
to automate the process. Unfortunately, a major obstacle to adopting supervised
machine learning for this problem has been the lack of publicly available
specialized datasets. Here, we aim to bridge this gap. In particular, we focus
on mapping CVE records into MITRE CWE Weaknesses, and we release to the
research community a manually annotated dataset of 4,012 records for this task.
With a human-in-the-loop framework in mind, we approach the problem as a
ranking task and aim to incorporate reinforced learning to make use of the
human feedback in future work. Our experimental results using fine-tuned deep
learning models, namely Sentence-BERT and rankT5, show sizable performance
gains over BM25, BERT, and RoBERTa, which demonstrates the need for an
architecture capable of good semantic understanding for this task. | [
-0.0149391647,
0.0594266132,
-0.0033818712,
0.0133703332,
-0.0190020036,
-0.0181454513,
-0.0051913154,
-0.0252156649,
0.0516582169,
-0.0564306788,
0.0081153652,
0.0252480786,
-0.0109625859,
0.0292924456,
0.0560123175,
-0.0076567223,
0.0539638139,
0.0049218461,
-0.024191374,
0.0133945867,
-0.0293003041,
0.0007603993,
-0.0401666798,
0.0570747033,
0.0346686691,
-0.005493762,
-0.0123731634,
0.0428739823,
0.0783409402,
-0.0418155938,
0.0015890935,
-0.0019016883,
0.0122261187,
0.0027080555,
0.0000019892,
-0.0272499323,
-0.028922556,
0.013726173,
0.006683378,
0.0184110701,
-0.0504224077,
-0.0440190025,
-0.013069463,
0.0439040735,
0.0053158607,
0.0133229028,
0.0215449613,
0.026506234,
0.0826756358,
0.0768569931,
-0.0000464096,
0.0291307699,
0.0332557112,
-0.0193675328,
-0.0139808385,
-0.0430127755,
0.0194774363,
-0.0032391311,
0.0026226572,
0.0242694952,
0.0261218026,
-0.0037545264,
0.0062777284,
0.0117840711,
0.0254002735,
0.0363668241,
-0.0458927564,
0.0414185524,
-0.0120615419,
0.0661862716,
-0.0436283164,
0.0043281773,
0.0085426457,
-0.0055613196,
0.0171680488,
-0.0143604083,
0.0518247224,
0.0026292552,
0.0022857424,
-0.019792784,
0.0077871154,
0.0108963894,
0.0101734065,
-0.0080389064,
-0.0083803842,
0.0115626743,
-0.0051350025,
-0.0314417109,
0.022088889,
-0.0489022657,
0.0025734259,
-0.0134829702,
0.0243081879,
0.0056585674,
-0.0322534963,
0.0061701168,
-0.0526216477,
-0.0457311608,
0.0619891025,
-0.0200338271,
-0.0093406001,
0.0026417847,
-0.0303524658,
0.0146847656,
-0.0213123132,
0.0296630785,
-0.0162400939,
0.0634976327,
-0.0174232684,
0.0025169929,
-0.0908218473,
-0.0305397306,
0.024682153,
0.0287436135,
0.045532912,
0.006107192,
-0.0554855429,
-0.0164304115,
-0.058920294,
0.0710257217,
0.0173385199,
0.0125252781,
-0.0324050412,
0.0480328426,
-0.0134257637,
0.0000366898,
-0.0452217534,
-0.0007905973,
-0.0308138654,
-0.0352987908,
-0.0029790178,
-0.0238260608,
-0.0214089975,
-0.0587571114,
0.0028708966,
0.0808553994,
0.0412973017,
-0.0036656582,
-0.00936954,
-0.0144787999,
-0.0186868999,
0.0297384318,
-0.0236238372,
-0.0439585298,
-0.0295037515,
-0.0117423423,
0.0282011814,
-0.0033701258,
-0.0097487094,
-0.0068623377,
-0.0582701676,
0.0844216719,
-0.0055461917,
-0.0185817368,
0.0416105911,
-0.0065439898,
0.0400878452,
-0.0153182866,
-0.0027457485,
0.0502319187,
-0.00752337,
-0.0221236404,
0.0255596712,
0.0189794432,
0.0018268079,
-0.000418146,
0.0126784993,
0.0262700524,
-0.0104028657,
0.0128302108,
0.0076089166,
0.0026178726,
0.0182757024,
-0.0544257574,
0.0192314684,
0.0160053521,
0.0135881873,
0.0266558677,
0.001955525,
0.0466916487,
-0.0030496197,
-0.066557169,
-0.0564251281,
0.0403399952,
-0.036894653,
-0.0378287658,
-0.0410577618,
0.0041084844,
-0.0275269598,
0.0008157173,
-0.0370374359,
-0.0054019252,
-0.0400208533,
-0.0125745283,
0.0359340347,
0.0371033251,
0.000257798,
0.0163772367,
0.0121059604,
-0.0202980731,
-0.0063364133,
-0.0571622662,
-0.0600584373,
0.0711124092,
0.0358363017,
-0.0812378898,
-0.084935531,
-0.0181623325,
-0.048894614,
-0.0155766038,
0.010141179,
-0.0039949319,
0.0073415674,
-0.0425892957,
-0.0144545762,
-0.0245055035,
0.0110490918,
0.0564692765,
-0.0249465667,
-0.0217511039,
-0.002970451,
-0.0975042582,
-0.0334005319,
0.0424933322,
0.069155179,
-0.0397221223,
0.0483353585,
0.0499892794,
0.0547749102,
0.0226262808,
-0.0012619882,
0.0588919371,
0.0422515757,
-0.0146930851,
-0.0546365641,
-0.0177227072,
0.0254599098,
0.0119367335,
-0.0066097286,
-0.0817834213,
0.0224206187,
0.111501798,
-0.0649447143,
-0.015311473,
0.0319486372,
-0.0313962959,
-0.0501604751,
0.0258161314,
-0.0125158653,
0.0304482114,
-0.0140830074,
-0.0415006056,
0.0861095488,
0.0074014575,
-0.004151674,
-0.0010063729,
0.0185739882,
0.0125370715,
-0.0541463271,
-0.035023246,
-0.0111895632,
-0.0653816611,
0.007717717,
0.0209256336,
0.0172887426,
-0.007394596,
0.0096421996,
-0.0889551565,
0.0043536681,
-0.0064711021,
0.0494012684,
0.0315565653,
-0.0149419867,
-0.0069859875,
-0.0292838719,
-0.0176254995,
-0.0471413173,
-0.0327234156,
0.0123016406,
0.0483052507,
-0.0077040903,
0.0046312446,
-0.0428251363,
-0.0447308049,
-0.0449727625,
0.0584758185,
0.0040561603,
-0.0091466308,
-0.0195098594,
0.0169513412,
-0.0141024245,
-0.0004780079,
-0.0094008958,
-0.0786918178,
0.0223411918,
0.0053629,
-0.0183074567,
0.0121380519,
0.0334971361,
0.0998004153,
0.0629008189,
0.0447924659,
-0.0356344506,
0.0191906523,
0.006895477,
-0.0551821925,
-0.0036146846,
-0.0017819401,
0.0404576547,
0.0021136692,
0.0471720695,
0.0009022014,
-0.0602511577,
-0.023943387,
0.0089942496,
0.0027159704,
-0.0704139695,
-0.0471564047,
0.0127711715,
-0.0196498893,
-0.0017017786,
-0.0217762552,
0.0677065998,
0.0109139793,
0.046713911,
-0.1050932184,
-0.0324418917,
-0.0452189855,
0.0407323726,
-0.0077544525,
0.0050938805,
0.0269884076,
-0.0388864465,
-0.0195228122,
-0.0241549518,
0.0271247942,
-0.0029829689,
-0.0350796171,
0.0024457376,
0.0071081943,
-0.0172918309,
-0.0242988113,
-0.055718191,
-0.033479359,
-0.0062723854,
0.031274166,
0.0053809173,
-0.0180514883,
-0.0044684983,
-0.0076217172,
0.0413965397,
0.0362572782,
0.0489284322,
-0.0418642834,
0.0001123434,
0.0181645956,
0.0237313509,
-0.051160872,
0.0103017781,
0.0209213458,
-0.0060016774,
0.017627921,
0.1194085032,
0.0333457217,
-0.0498384424,
0.003349361,
-0.0082295695,
-0.0932901576,
0.0255497284,
0.0272071343,
0.0107195834,
-0.0248907618,
0.0144706341,
0.0714157075,
0.0367973782,
-0.0232622884,
0.0493115522,
0.0060879262,
-0.0020857148,
0.0301983226,
0.0337912962,
-0.0609776452,
0.001393233,
0.0082947807,
0.0606565624,
-0.0274539534,
-0.0641422719,
0.0247459877,
-0.1002791747,
0.0227928348,
-0.03405644,
0.0173983946,
-0.0080357213,
-0.0517981574,
-0.0043313815,
-0.0199933499,
-0.025413258,
-0.0160232913,
0.0125294114,
-0.0073025357,
0.0183898564,
-0.0425898694,
-0.0609690398,
0.0277112313,
-0.0393797494,
0.0132940533,
0.0728091672,
0.0252869278,
-0.0568904504,
0.013863218,
0.0331082419,
-0.0635618642,
0.0198702887,
0.0278933439,
0.0953861177,
-0.0154444873,
-0.0317693911,
0.0321166515,
0.047008384,
-0.0507047288,
-0.0048199096,
0.0565553606,
0.0125477575,
-0.0351379737,
0.0528472178,
-0.022695262,
-0.0402522795,
0.0378362909,
0.054848738,
0.0215544365,
-0.0127760516,
0.0213117842,
-0.0102813812,
0.0417089798,
-0.0314499661,
-0.022657942,
0.0261729006,
-0.0267413221,
-0.0331906304,
-0.0918744355,
-0.0444799736,
0.0132705662,
0.0293902718,
0.0186503287,
-0.0847033486,
0.0143299764,
0.0284179747,
-0.0604082905,
0.0235054288,
0.0375732258,
0.0573082566,
-0.0281514507,
-0.0202664472,
-0.0115854684,
0.009259603,
-0.060731478,
0.0010442071,
-0.0610287711,
-0.0254376214,
-0.0299666505,
0.0462386385,
0.0188725926,
-0.0256938189,
-0.0621664375,
-0.0104644476,
0.105751574,
0.0462238751,
-0.0309820864,
-0.0549231209,
0.0520921908,
-0.0716660991,
-0.0361943766,
0.0067623099,
-0.0512026735,
0.0125289652,
0.0022345381,
0.002122307,
0.0221038666,
0.0041429615,
0.0360837467,
0.0195381399,
0.0812694579,
0.0036796525,
-0.0080738543,
0.0013007809,
0.0226077046,
-0.0156567227,
-0.0311018005,
0.0094715375,
0.0378809422,
-0.0002807217,
-0.0242105778,
-0.0067132711,
-0.002408385,
0.0009182261,
0.0224089101,
-0.0603769645,
0.0377311595,
0.0567043945,
0.0497969948,
0.0179675575,
-0.0035668174,
-0.0103583504,
0.0269621927,
0.0076057916,
0.0331862345,
-0.0076324665,
-0.0171288848,
-0.0070234379,
0.0188115984,
-0.0137251802,
0.0493664481,
-0.0621700995,
-0.053005565,
-0.0077952091,
0.0607686713,
0.0444595218,
0.0506521203,
0.039510306,
-0.033895459,
-0.0074330294,
-0.0307550654,
0.017894892,
-0.0187397823,
-0.0200174991,
0.035153348,
0.0272603594,
-0.0033833378,
-0.0007778047,
0.0704726353,
0.0060833329,
0.0456043631,
0.0128152315,
-0.0541258417,
-0.0354801081,
-0.0106112491,
0.0100751435,
0.0296830013,
-0.0211397968,
-0.0367086008,
-0.0287087839,
-0.0523885414,
0.0496727377,
-0.0127496645,
0.0344411507,
0.0279441178,
-0.0023705803,
0.0460864007,
-0.0297604706,
0.0232218821,
-0.0712536424,
0.0072173541,
-0.0469537787,
-0.0583603494,
0.0009576303,
-5.764935802e-33,
0.014965035,
-0.0165280327,
-0.0312148407,
-0.017566504,
0.0181115866,
0.0433174223,
-0.0155706992,
-0.038044259,
-0.012380112,
0.0081137717,
0.0301842056,
-0.0017470152,
0.0169144459,
0.0056772982,
0.0052427528,
-0.0178662967,
0.0208793562,
0.0194034986,
-0.018766541,
0.0309614707,
0.0393384062,
0.0167133342,
0.0189935621,
-0.0701976642,
0.0304627381,
0.0160089452,
-0.0279109329,
-0.0086251665,
0.0247847997,
0.0573122799,
-0.0081634261,
0.0489217751,
0.0179794729,
-0.0245575998,
0.0373763032,
-0.0301648788,
-0.0579788871,
-0.0197520833,
-0.0722025633,
-0.0300517492,
0.0134244161,
-0.0125482418,
0.02334553,
0.0092092995,
0.0555579215,
-0.025039481,
0.056224145,
0.0162750278,
0.0175715424,
-0.0935243443,
-0.005664621,
0.0269135255,
-0.075718917,
0.0015614092,
-0.0486019775,
0.0349365398,
0.0177354123,
0.0209482424,
-0.0386608541,
0.0124164866,
0.0283555444,
0.0197329372,
0.0544092618,
-0.0050059985,
-0.0383472741,
0.0257434994,
-0.0284580532,
-0.0218738373,
0.039193254,
0.0138177089,
0.0194244776,
0.0512375906,
0.0258696079,
0.0659700409,
0.0274223238,
0.0030997978,
-0.0718975738,
0.0688144937,
-0.0145394905,
0.0493063256,
0.0043112193,
0.0210741516,
-0.0710223019,
0.0060095121,
-0.0095096873,
-0.0273457579,
-0.0345008522,
-0.000101848,
0.0278211776,
-0.0441280194,
-0.0756100044,
0.0612698048,
-0.011801674,
-0.0028505388,
0.0087235393,
0.0252587851,
0.0071931393,
0.0179925896,
-0.0237416271,
0.0024327938,
-0.0025410745,
-0.0091028409,
0.0265247598,
0.0360222943,
0.0306133777,
-0.0167131051,
0.0313757844,
0.0278904121,
-0.0542963147,
0.0119470498,
-0.0062080044,
0.0040883678,
-0.074103497,
0.1090615243,
-0.0075793634,
-0.0008538564,
0.0168425702,
0.0159950759,
0.001524338,
-0.0049444148,
-0.0102701839,
0.0208744854,
-0.018784672,
0.0234155077,
-0.0025060647,
-0.003446962,
-0.0100547764,
0.0354852155,
0.0098800054,
-0.0405342951,
-0.0057080709,
-0.0032783735,
2.854e-7,
0.0407579951,
0.0158020407,
0.0551853031,
0.0009372393,
-0.0245550107,
0.0531397574,
0.0019376456,
0.1108342111,
-0.0074776174,
-0.0293797497,
0.0295693334,
-0.0233068839,
0.0200164393,
0.028428277,
-0.0005546586,
-0.0253119636,
-0.0750317499,
-0.0027433217,
-0.0829364359,
0.0222726036,
0.1033857092,
0.0584845096,
0.0096132429,
-0.0244083572,
-0.0017092173,
-0.0089127487,
-0.0161415506,
0.014878598,
-0.007235555,
-0.0117667411,
0.0471434295,
0.0220483169,
0.0017853823,
0.0761403814,
-0.0580729358,
-0.0240602344,
-0.0062262844,
0.0021815533,
0.0215948112,
-0.0265953802,
-0.0454087146,
-0.0112349819,
0.0180341266,
-0.0517271794,
0.0396248922,
-0.0539921895,
-0.0182072427,
0.0298939906,
-0.0350590982,
0.0180693194,
0.0341856144,
-0.0410050713,
-0.0122889187,
-0.0024913286,
-0.0023381782,
-0.0368232951,
0.0073417514,
-0.0950454101,
-0.0158446934,
-0.0175326802,
-0.0530466326,
-0.0110038007,
0.0283817053,
-0.0127163166,
0.040689379,
-0.0202250201,
-0.001163333,
2.745211166e-34,
0.0045292932,
-0.035693299,
-0.0266318992,
-0.0399230942,
0.0200058576,
0.0133002168,
0.0073687835,
0.0141705573,
-0.0294009969,
-0.0155081926,
-0.0317699462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06795v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06795v2 | Efficient Sequence Transduction by Jointly Predicting Tokens and Durations | 2023-04-13T19:38:27 | 2023-05-29T21:08:11 | Hainan Xu, Fei Jia, Somshubra Majumdar, He Huang, Shinji Watanabe, Boris Ginsburg | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This paper introduces a novel Token-and-Duration Transducer (TDT)
architecture for sequence-to-sequence tasks. TDT extends conventional
RNN-Transducer architectures by jointly predicting both a token and its
duration, i.e. the number of input frames covered by the emitted token. This is
achieved by using a joint network with two outputs which are independently
normalized to generate distributions over tokens and durations. During
inference, TDT models can skip input frames guided by the predicted duration
output, which makes them significantly faster than conventional Transducers
which process the encoder output frame by frame. TDT models achieve both better
accuracy and significantly faster inference than conventional Transducers on
different sequence transduction tasks. TDT models for Speech Recognition
achieve better accuracy and up to 2.82X faster inference than conventional
Transducers. TDT models for Speech Translation achieve an absolute gain of over
1 BLEU on the MUST-C test compared with conventional Transducers, and its
inference is 2.27X faster. In Speech Intent Classification and Slot Filling
tasks, TDT models improve the intent accuracy by up to over 1% (absolute) over
conventional Transducers, while running up to 1.28X faster. Our implementation
of the TDT model will be open-sourced with the NeMo
(https://github.com/NVIDIA/NeMo) toolkit. | [
0.0077731721,
0.0626650304,
0.0132183284,
0.0105647119,
-0.0420279428,
-0.0454871953,
0.0461442284,
-0.0131448628,
-0.0692954287,
-0.0079193972,
-0.0240184739,
-0.03043277,
0.0486167409,
0.0560522117,
0.0075095808,
-0.0488480218,
0.0250139348,
-0.0225682184,
0.0123413419,
0.0240006782,
0.0102218054,
0.0010449393,
-0.0417964533,
0.081817925,
-0.005554433,
0.037917953,
-0.038700249,
0.0012261329,
0.0082826465,
-0.0436912812,
-0.0100136595,
0.0298923254,
0.0321671665,
0.0443149805,
0.0000017605,
0.0129317269,
0.0132908588,
-0.0085853804,
-0.0351186134,
0.0012394504,
-0.0219900887,
0.0171163231,
-0.028533116,
0.0479371585,
0.0086410148,
-0.0348169431,
0.0428937189,
0.0175229665,
0.0036976731,
0.0625838339,
0.0078236032,
-0.0005689917,
0.036851082,
-0.0697446987,
0.040526554,
-0.0406881794,
-0.0139676463,
-0.068271637,
0.01760225,
-0.0067001577,
-0.0316493325,
0.0442026146,
0.0613972582,
-0.0050427285,
0.0227322672,
0.0335351378,
-0.0162566099,
-0.0573910214,
-0.046648033,
0.0476973578,
-0.0487621427,
0.0116848089,
0.0146374451,
0.0140330344,
-0.0057245432,
-0.0533462204,
-0.0030047048,
-0.0214895774,
0.0018384499,
0.0105472812,
-0.0020690958,
0.0253381934,
0.0284328572,
-0.0301553849,
-0.042152252,
0.0096256919,
0.0179016721,
0.0046084588,
-0.0328975692,
-0.0101218335,
0.0314548053,
-0.0477140322,
0.0481702797,
0.0298843868,
-0.0258366037,
-0.0101845777,
-0.0377248228,
-0.0447354615,
-0.0242707878,
-0.0028733625,
-0.0396167487,
0.065753229,
-0.0530083589,
-0.0075856526,
-0.0549385808,
0.0590503253,
-0.0136155002,
-0.0070374021,
-0.0753897876,
-0.0188435297,
-0.0177216623,
-0.0001883981,
-0.0220178366,
0.017198097,
-0.0627906248,
-0.0711170733,
-0.0740526766,
-0.0024645608,
0.0033042079,
0.014379927,
0.0422950312,
0.0225004926,
-0.0616881177,
-0.0153197199,
-0.0021431958,
0.0505529866,
-0.0234282371,
0.0400405228,
0.0321500935,
-0.0750425458,
-0.0299476944,
0.0240497347,
0.0098715639,
-0.0382336751,
0.0213581771,
0.0792270377,
-0.018141279,
-0.0472984724,
-0.0200923923,
-0.0175945032,
-0.0378650427,
-0.0496716239,
0.0327413827,
-0.0709860399,
0.0354162306,
-0.008868333,
-0.00817014,
-0.0162226781,
0.0210495461,
0.0058695129,
0.0223990194,
0.0679774731,
0.0086101089,
-0.0332445763,
0.0353533626,
0.0163275339,
0.0091568232,
0.0317315161,
0.0621317327,
0.0327899456,
-0.0062486855,
-0.0095833465,
-0.0013849235,
0.0537228659,
0.0361436456,
-0.0419535041,
-0.0139826229,
-0.0108476309,
0.0315298885,
0.083104603,
0.0345736109,
0.0519167334,
-0.0188438017,
-0.0363412946,
0.0424008593,
0.0592420064,
0.0349042118,
-0.0007950285,
0.0803381801,
-0.0249428973,
-0.035051439,
-0.00208795,
-0.0054870066,
0.0634290501,
0.0373562947,
0.0094882967,
0.0932722315,
0.0513575263,
-0.0399741456,
-0.0216167066,
0.0077689765,
-0.0318904072,
-0.0041498081,
-0.022077607,
0.042085398,
-0.0108079724,
-0.0669889674,
0.0617200322,
-0.0200707857,
-0.0263118576,
0.0141991591,
-0.016552994,
0.0068829092,
0.0296474453,
0.010156841,
-0.0056465915,
-0.0388289392,
-0.0062245592,
-0.0607232228,
0.0413168818,
0.0087211113,
0.0022894172,
0.0347050056,
-0.05699775,
-0.0175997168,
0.0412452556,
-0.0048142169,
0.066534631,
0.0165111385,
0.068685323,
0.0521837026,
-0.0321568325,
0.0347267129,
0.0039377222,
-0.0150764361,
-0.0297607481,
0.0303702652,
0.0348257311,
0.0740870833,
0.0118413512,
0.0049069095,
0.0154802864,
0.0252094362,
-0.0562936738,
0.0059932726,
0.0453191102,
-0.1155733243,
-0.049642399,
0.0192601327,
-0.0252344664,
0.0190913752,
0.0432580709,
-0.0011048523,
-0.0770636126,
0.0345140882,
-0.0197862033,
0.0200724825,
-0.0291731264,
-0.0088066682,
0.05366835,
0.0096167475,
0.0479519367,
-0.0214557555,
-0.0125590283,
0.014681696,
0.03054896,
-0.0360413194,
-0.0053311042,
-0.0494296812,
-0.0040376629,
0.0359640792,
-0.0030991526,
-0.0238669515,
0.0139021901,
-0.022350302,
-0.0052637216,
-0.0315056592,
-0.0796632469,
0.0124324057,
-0.0021080892,
0.0431286618,
-0.007434465,
0.0440624952,
0.0137454998,
0.0029625311,
-0.0472585298,
-0.0187041108,
-0.0090426151,
-0.0285776146,
0.0009770717,
0.0253623482,
-0.065283142,
-0.0013496078,
-0.0075612334,
0.005922114,
0.0343336798,
-0.0381414928,
-0.0343178324,
-0.0119161382,
-0.0505036637,
0.0255325902,
0.0330451466,
-0.013041582,
-0.0401186645,
0.0177975111,
0.0100737158,
0.0183925647,
0.0246637352,
0.0099128764,
-0.0089003313,
-0.0077199745,
-0.0178022981,
-0.0101847211,
0.024382906,
-0.0142663503,
0.0361972861,
-0.0125891212,
-0.0020571484,
-0.0250496175,
0.071054332,
-0.0117124869,
0.0206393618,
-0.0874337181,
-0.0210326221,
0.012956962,
-0.0387511104,
-0.0057936222,
-0.0284856334,
-0.0404801741,
-0.0086784055,
-0.0053215073,
-0.0345822722,
0.0401389189,
-0.0731715187,
-0.040463943,
-0.0412035957,
-0.0089564361,
-0.0169797093,
0.0594029091,
0.0234620403,
-0.0034443138,
0.0010176973,
-0.053116668,
-0.0029677721,
0.0108570876,
-0.0225519333,
-0.0272339433,
0.0241056904,
-0.0180393215,
-0.0017101726,
-0.0311302152,
-0.0263840239,
-0.024262771,
0.027863076,
-0.0420871936,
0.0306328069,
0.0209645852,
-0.0496632271,
-0.03618991,
0.0166182015,
-0.001883515,
0.0928575024,
-0.0188393705,
0.0189831238,
-0.0093654906,
0.0489537716,
0.0057720793,
0.0068524708,
-0.0187017787,
0.0006077642,
-0.0035241044,
0.0360086113,
0.0478430726,
0.0258884784,
-0.0584891811,
-0.0112387296,
0.0043364782,
0.0032227586,
0.00374627,
0.0534323975,
0.0632057339,
-0.0637298599,
0.0106698712,
0.0963406563,
-0.006266159,
-0.0156712066,
-0.0048605767,
0.0240008291,
0.0184187107,
-0.0010813826,
-0.0272725429,
-0.0595657453,
-0.0586898327,
0.0473465174,
0.0434647761,
0.0004519236,
0.0135205947,
-0.0169146657,
-0.0451558903,
-0.0089736748,
0.0228386223,
-0.0582107268,
-0.0688767284,
-0.0265418254,
-0.0264568813,
-0.0114881657,
0.0535156205,
0.0175373796,
0.0272058491,
0.0075142737,
0.031924922,
-0.0627722144,
-0.0199580044,
0.028075641,
-0.01729762,
0.0675999969,
0.0409811065,
0.0101618944,
0.0097031835,
-0.0381233878,
0.0227161311,
-0.0308166854,
0.0322833508,
-0.0017045016,
0.0183961354,
-0.0156884156,
-0.0173077788,
0.0075583318,
0.0595172495,
-0.0361155048,
0.0000050449,
-0.0068198852,
0.0680632144,
0.0145679861,
-0.0171848536,
-0.0354276374,
0.0061678672,
0.0114139449,
0.0531651191,
0.019364858,
-0.0391699523,
-0.0316192359,
0.0084587941,
-0.0216225516,
-0.0860359222,
0.0064454754,
-0.0504818708,
0.0184480213,
-0.0873098001,
-0.0431761257,
-0.022596743,
0.0067436937,
0.0596702881,
0.0075484701,
0.0353683345,
0.0214000363,
0.0402464867,
-0.0136659211,
-0.0053561712,
0.0171227846,
0.0300870948,
-0.0688687712,
0.0381772481,
0.0131079778,
-0.0364722013,
-0.0057619377,
0.0647766367,
-0.0682471991,
-0.0338442661,
-0.0180569589,
0.0068830326,
0.0224778019,
0.064524062,
-0.0061528203,
0.0526412763,
0.0469138622,
0.0450394936,
-0.0556059927,
0.0064008655,
0.0580691807,
-0.0261896588,
-0.0202455074,
0.0101783546,
-0.0322962627,
0.0044590966,
-0.01231068,
0.0151850628,
0.0111184828,
-0.0396331064,
0.0034142348,
-0.0004539602,
0.0706042424,
-0.0062027252,
0.0579141192,
-0.028706979,
0.0596244223,
0.0164642017,
0.0817767233,
-0.0510957502,
0.0060904911,
0.0380899087,
0.0343670845,
0.0141975358,
-0.0192200914,
0.0374880433,
-0.0349185206,
0.0071242349,
0.0454955474,
0.002058117,
0.0136316745,
-0.0003556316,
-0.044311896,
-0.0151486071,
-0.0200824961,
-0.0137398625,
0.0344061404,
-0.0638934076,
0.0199134573,
0.0291370172,
0.0275099296,
0.0308160409,
0.0240557212,
-0.0199380144,
0.0205311477,
-0.023776494,
0.0177555811,
0.0516784489,
0.0038889479,
0.0012685674,
-0.020622829,
0.0173344593,
-0.0291998368,
0.0731858462,
-0.0345453024,
0.0002802878,
0.0035400828,
-0.0087114992,
-0.0001594554,
-0.0295970067,
0.0452485457,
0.0008405106,
0.0505766794,
0.0139205195,
0.0260451511,
-0.0343056582,
-0.0233624782,
-0.019006798,
-0.0136782508,
-0.0366574749,
-0.0070336517,
0.0146302916,
-0.0313978568,
0.0356817804,
0.0018181737,
0.0109311566,
0.0025150131,
0.0412467271,
0.0282765422,
-0.0191158392,
-0.0309382677,
0.0088833524,
-0.009612293,
0.0201338828,
-0.0070820334,
0.0208000112,
-5.599901171e-33,
-0.0227658432,
0.0240098499,
0.0152396429,
-0.0194581095,
-0.0486188345,
0.0242496077,
-0.0206401665,
-0.014222512,
0.0038533132,
-0.0375247337,
-0.005628678,
-0.0095029445,
0.0296138637,
0.0227619652,
0.0263119321,
-0.0040802821,
0.0709956959,
-0.0044936128,
0.0006320558,
0.0073116543,
0.0388239287,
0.0228321515,
0.067518346,
-0.013874908,
-0.0418978743,
0.048535943,
0.0212857854,
-0.0265348405,
-0.0085893469,
0.0116750821,
0.0110506741,
0.0114880633,
-0.00640852,
-0.0706065297,
-0.0304916222,
0.0426186882,
-0.1063022241,
-0.0336278193,
0.0042113159,
0.0536985621,
-0.0611925423,
-0.0449836999,
0.0359448344,
0.013095485,
-0.0433979519,
-0.0167524032,
-0.0152228484,
-0.0148088792,
-0.0111494185,
-0.0291588698,
-0.0189485885,
0.030113332,
-0.0157032534,
-0.0294388868,
0.0607160293,
0.0449973233,
-0.0034986087,
-0.086571306,
-0.0920886174,
0.0082941866,
-0.0325475857,
0.0774762109,
0.0182064045,
0.0178487357,
-0.003165494,
0.0341732278,
0.0734621957,
-0.0930304304,
-0.0066221035,
0.0225670021,
0.008707894,
-0.0099572306,
0.0640994832,
-0.0391407683,
0.0712554678,
-0.0446082167,
-0.0573974997,
0.0298817735,
0.0340179577,
0.0392596908,
0.0493057817,
0.0240108203,
-0.0038155483,
0.0096851783,
-0.0397532657,
-0.0131776324,
-0.0179082006,
-0.0240302533,
0.0353647284,
0.0523033552,
0.0321683213,
-0.0029722957,
0.0849684998,
0.0186915137,
0.0266777407,
0.0202231705,
0.0071014804,
-0.0064063501,
-0.0085469056,
0.0341723897,
-0.069467634,
-0.0270494763,
0.0631505102,
0.0281157177,
0.0085462714,
-0.0301867984,
-0.0008345232,
0.0529647581,
-0.0503351651,
-0.02985809,
-0.0512753874,
0.0384826772,
-0.0083872918,
-0.005353251,
0.0741511956,
-0.0092552025,
-0.0152255008,
0.0064790933,
-0.0649242625,
-0.0082324604,
-0.0350937583,
0.017327901,
0.0226629172,
0.0311417282,
-0.0507646464,
0.0031784561,
-0.0424407795,
-0.0019181008,
0.0172457173,
-0.0351245105,
-0.0300990511,
0.0420454778,
2.695e-7,
-0.0226614587,
0.0008399602,
0.0792253464,
-0.0117651597,
0.0232421663,
0.01220142,
-0.0117282644,
0.054825902,
-0.0014953905,
-0.0096036959,
0.0200062133,
-0.0207789838,
0.0298886579,
0.0070205908,
-0.1060260236,
-0.0442786291,
-0.0585577562,
0.0505956374,
-0.0305641629,
0.0253755879,
0.014718228,
0.0912796035,
0.0061799297,
-0.0190457236,
0.0636164024,
-0.0293469969,
0.0105170915,
0.014580437,
0.0312810652,
-0.0160266999,
0.0332749747,
-0.0076184534,
-0.0179863516,
0.026039822,
-0.0166772436,
0.0030749955,
0.0266354643,
0.0442690291,
-0.0127202105,
-0.0677928627,
-0.0217327401,
0.0242504962,
-0.0235906504,
-0.022816414,
0.071464479,
-0.0200594254,
-0.025332123,
-0.0272314064,
-0.0422393344,
0.0397440009,
-0.0108737452,
0.0337893665,
0.0246947799,
0.010460509,
0.0239622332,
0.0088299792,
-0.0173848793,
-0.0716681182,
-0.0099404575,
-0.010526415,
-0.0675926358,
-0.0318098366,
-0.1264982074,
-0.0029194544,
0.0055156816,
-0.0371140912,
-0.0684635192,
2.322640691e-34,
0.0038924236,
-0.0406568795,
0.016221663,
-0.0021975404,
-0.0252034068,
-0.0466289259,
-0.0096354922,
0.0039049766,
0.0059268824,
-0.0363668427,
-0.0697461218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06767v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06767v4 | RAFT: Reward rAnked FineTuning for Generative Foundation Model Alignment | 2023-04-13T18:22:40 | 2023-12-01T14:28:06 | Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Deepanshu Goyal, Yihan Zhang, Winnie Chow, Rui Pan, Shizhe Diao, Jipeng Zhang, Kashun Shum, Tong Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Generative foundation models are susceptible to implicit biases that can
arise from extensive unsupervised training data. Such biases can produce
suboptimal samples, skewed outcomes, and unfairness, with potentially serious
consequences. Consequently, aligning these models with human ethics and
preferences is an essential step toward ensuring their responsible and
effective deployment in real-world applications. Prior research has primarily
employed Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) to address this
problem, where generative models are fine-tuned with RL algorithms guided by a
human-feedback-informed reward model. However, the inefficiencies and
instabilities associated with RL algorithms frequently present substantial
obstacles to the successful alignment, necessitating the development of a more
robust and streamlined approach. To this end, we introduce a new framework,
Reward rAnked FineTuning (RAFT), designed to align generative models
effectively. Utilizing a reward model and a sufficient number of samples, our
approach selects the high-quality samples, discarding those that exhibit
undesired behavior, and subsequently enhancing the model by fine-tuning on
these filtered samples. Our studies show that RAFT can effectively improve the
model performance in both reward learning and other automated metrics in both
large language models and diffusion models. | [
0.0160789993,
0.0966408923,
-0.0144892205,
-0.0176287387,
-0.0303312708,
0.0136186285,
-0.0080838725,
-0.0191880856,
-0.0316539481,
0.0246064961,
-0.0510566458,
-0.0039746268,
0.0102228653,
0.010765844,
0.0221281834,
-0.0627468303,
0.0423427597,
-0.0105161238,
0.0158060063,
-0.0290489029,
0.0176827814,
0.012856123,
0.0086860443,
0.0372276492,
0.0164036117,
-0.0136322863,
0.0315177366,
0.0237227492,
0.066007629,
-0.005570808,
0.0163750164,
0.0749614686,
-0.0016395416,
0.061849229,
0.0000022986,
-0.053304106,
-0.004689537,
0.0210022461,
-0.0021239556,
-0.0164748896,
0.0599135682,
0.0250588469,
-0.0391984954,
0.0148471957,
-0.0259652846,
0.0145279057,
0.0632545948,
0.054222703,
0.0232226215,
0.030293636,
-0.0025692799,
-0.0059897476,
0.012076281,
-0.0489414185,
0.0034667226,
-0.0232397765,
0.0430247933,
0.0151888514,
-0.0216951221,
-0.056514807,
-0.0663418472,
0.0160120167,
-0.0036935539,
0.0018792818,
0.058002796,
0.0605529696,
0.0140457796,
-0.0529988259,
-0.0044676932,
0.0781201571,
-0.0533817448,
-0.01763287,
0.0307869203,
-0.0519704111,
0.0179032534,
0.0200890154,
-0.0226698909,
0.0091141686,
-0.0045349775,
0.0302017815,
0.0125148529,
-0.0122868372,
0.0354736298,
0.0306641925,
0.0039472068,
0.033525072,
0.0079414332,
-0.025176011,
-0.0091471085,
0.0116024707,
-0.0166580565,
-0.0544411689,
-0.0177766215,
-0.0415165871,
-0.0310638677,
0.0085567245,
-0.0239541251,
0.0068468517,
0.0213309079,
0.0222006086,
0.0407337025,
0.0183701217,
0.0144116376,
0.0323566757,
-0.0071787494,
0.0147932917,
-0.0260556228,
0.0544147082,
-0.0392481983,
0.044077646,
-0.0060667512,
0.0080055995,
0.0080135278,
-0.0077912728,
-0.0442761034,
-0.0145261036,
-0.0794162601,
-0.0051197791,
-0.050397478,
-0.0029357416,
0.0243100878,
0.0353743806,
-0.053478986,
0.020691704,
-0.0293436218,
0.0155190649,
-0.0458984412,
0.0351811275,
0.0409909934,
-0.0106350239,
-0.0031729734,
-0.0168464668,
-0.015461267,
-0.0232979059,
0.003987784,
0.05533351,
0.0230380464,
0.0110907797,
-0.0044506006,
-0.0200115722,
-0.000278422,
-0.0603940897,
-0.0269271433,
-0.0638780892,
0.0222446173,
-0.0344145335,
-0.0099015525,
-0.0428147055,
-0.0125161828,
-0.0158080719,
-0.0391315334,
0.0463329516,
0.026001716,
0.0070494595,
0.0212554559,
-0.0131703941,
0.0072304611,
0.0505491868,
0.0421873704,
0.0554919355,
-0.0051414976,
-0.0069897082,
-0.0047874185,
0.0268163923,
0.0523409583,
0.0242049582,
-0.0272981916,
-0.0177139975,
-0.0187266525,
0.0651386529,
0.0706053302,
0.0208781362,
-0.0493661352,
0.0175351165,
0.074494347,
0.0388267674,
0.0216376446,
-0.0026998615,
0.0195223708,
0.0019024559,
-0.0486527868,
0.0088675246,
-0.048961591,
0.0262712706,
-0.0077304845,
0.0123575432,
0.0141290417,
0.0560780689,
-0.0290301107,
-0.0356861614,
0.0265650693,
-0.0035149264,
0.0195191335,
0.0404120088,
0.0445986167,
0.004920694,
-0.0424888991,
-0.0496037267,
0.0549863242,
-0.0333913304,
0.0163914617,
-0.0645348132,
0.0844960585,
0.0909497142,
0.0436643809,
-0.0002244326,
-0.0032270283,
-0.0246129092,
-0.0330119021,
0.0112539381,
0.0205009542,
-0.0202006772,
-0.0232048165,
-0.0208810084,
-0.0532920174,
0.0462691896,
0.0103042014,
0.0417499691,
0.0102311876,
-0.0296080653,
-0.0272689555,
-0.0044949814,
-0.0642467216,
0.0351116024,
-0.028266225,
-0.0194862653,
0.0082951458,
0.0005376018,
0.0508572087,
-0.0229742154,
-0.0216202829,
-0.0029862986,
-0.000124195,
0.0217310656,
-0.016029302,
-0.0000880232,
-0.0635378808,
-0.0051272167,
0.0008375293,
-0.0503588393,
-0.0066679455,
0.0422655977,
-0.0554771721,
-0.0108496565,
-0.0019586722,
0.0151355704,
0.0018473902,
-0.052997876,
0.0208724048,
-0.0247418154,
0.0115745617,
-0.0578665771,
0.0515422896,
-0.007063061,
0.0124889761,
-0.0240494795,
-0.0013578892,
0.0035255931,
-0.0525803305,
0.0027952143,
-0.0028011608,
-0.017143961,
0.0404998213,
0.0683116615,
0.0252898913,
-0.0561692081,
-0.0122807892,
-0.0524528623,
0.0052872021,
-0.006215333,
0.0011893701,
0.0033235601,
0.006110406,
-0.0246264432,
0.0029358866,
-0.0377156809,
-0.0048706545,
0.0413879007,
-0.0070009166,
0.0063478383,
-0.0174834114,
-0.0071535045,
-0.0646841601,
-0.0221253354,
-0.0069646565,
0.0088454355,
0.0222164746,
0.0313086025,
-0.0447910018,
0.0153945703,
-0.0327796154,
0.0145469485,
0.0037631874,
-0.0457818285,
-0.0028211877,
0.0203496218,
0.0450945944,
0.1159938723,
0.0255542435,
0.049927365,
0.0277338587,
0.0264456812,
-0.0719034374,
-0.0075258864,
-0.0656122714,
-0.0205974337,
-0.0236719288,
-0.0058178538,
-0.0120155411,
0.080277428,
0.0184983164,
0.0029296954,
-0.0801262259,
0.0574303493,
-0.0157881118,
-0.04017362,
-0.0016323648,
0.0030719163,
-0.0483515933,
0.0164354425,
-0.0599058084,
-0.0731748044,
0.083917819,
0.0186129212,
0.0356198549,
-0.0228823796,
0.0224211272,
0.0036646083,
-0.0173642654,
0.0122021865,
0.0347336233,
0.0182870869,
-0.0069518117,
-0.0735988915,
-0.021097837,
0.0788308755,
-0.0244362205,
0.0107293632,
-0.011530553,
-0.0031835469,
-0.0175997633,
-0.0598723367,
-0.0509064049,
-0.0565244295,
0.0307490546,
0.0070859883,
0.0282377601,
-0.0166719332,
-0.0182370953,
-0.0272450205,
0.026628796,
0.0012695598,
-0.0297706183,
-0.0125616929,
-0.013408999,
0.0096154101,
0.0867457166,
-0.009919785,
0.0489335991,
-0.0326359123,
0.0024860722,
0.012467443,
0.0325039066,
0.0427038558,
-0.001737466,
0.0167124923,
0.0428966098,
-0.0208036415,
0.0163211487,
0.0566213168,
0.0471004918,
-0.0138903046,
-0.0098423501,
0.0834961459,
0.0096510295,
-0.0233979728,
0.0157768205,
0.001475477,
0.0822564214,
0.0197498072,
0.0134075312,
-0.0514321178,
-0.0124858441,
0.0076758517,
0.0596111305,
-0.0206659529,
-0.0238694809,
0.0482481644,
-0.1213849038,
0.0704720989,
0.0332714766,
-0.0493845381,
0.0219388548,
-0.0165742841,
0.0228905864,
-0.0447296426,
-0.0118381139,
-0.0032655161,
0.0108034918,
-0.0068408898,
0.037469957,
0.0147867091,
-0.0940662473,
0.0247389395,
-0.0735121295,
0.0579567514,
0.1271289438,
0.0345474444,
0.0088945227,
-0.0545642227,
-0.0154310148,
0.011543571,
-0.0152106965,
0.0011885945,
0.0246686172,
-0.0051200078,
-0.00120796,
-0.0313441791,
0.0806527212,
0.0148150446,
0.0035540133,
-0.0466198362,
0.0614661723,
0.0139596276,
-0.0092180744,
-0.0378308892,
-0.0181807987,
0.041870892,
0.0680121779,
0.0072934735,
-0.0601177998,
-0.0376045927,
-0.0276142955,
-0.0163072124,
-0.0269598868,
-0.0527412593,
0.0078600533,
0.0089359349,
-0.0460283495,
-0.0871494114,
-0.0260718297,
-0.0124300681,
0.0242840927,
0.0175437871,
-0.0144747561,
-0.0124955606,
-0.0190811846,
-0.0187846366,
0.0418735668,
-0.0329587199,
0.0404489674,
-0.059527941,
-0.0329214595,
0.0079298243,
-0.0699574053,
-0.0484166332,
0.0276133977,
-0.04101656,
-0.0671187341,
0.0249074362,
0.0694924966,
0.0151519002,
0.0616871268,
-0.0330992006,
-0.0269484837,
0.0779868439,
0.0762021989,
-0.0457212701,
0.0210997332,
0.0152339386,
-0.0262708105,
-0.0227252338,
0.0202011187,
-0.0466407649,
0.0673395619,
0.0453155339,
0.0397675261,
0.022744434,
0.0173790548,
0.0301272906,
-0.0078569707,
0.0791371912,
-0.0582222901,
-0.0336503349,
-0.0615139827,
-0.0271246396,
0.0305911005,
-0.0349298157,
-0.0257848538,
-0.0488913953,
0.0668382272,
0.0148749147,
-0.0103842653,
-0.001651742,
0.0145532722,
0.036144305,
-0.0658159629,
-0.0037244407,
0.0039270092,
0.0341946706,
0.0093942825,
0.0405612141,
0.0130533166,
0.0168148801,
-0.0024926539,
0.0467229672,
-0.0036712068,
0.046341788,
0.0481922105,
0.0439875349,
-0.0029487042,
0.0208129119,
-0.0335317291,
-0.0310613867,
-0.0855440944,
-0.0101696039,
0.0481677316,
-0.0021238076,
0.0560963713,
-0.0175333135,
-0.0153770084,
-0.0227396581,
0.012595172,
-0.043452017,
-0.0259791166,
0.0115716727,
0.0198052451,
-0.0111712841,
-0.0373900682,
0.0372997001,
0.0038723336,
0.0356750414,
-0.0722325966,
-0.0099912118,
-0.0167214889,
-0.0297102332,
0.0138815492,
-0.0233654119,
-0.0091846287,
-0.0060024424,
-0.0709786862,
-0.0480617918,
-0.0546083339,
0.0687534586,
0.0152337113,
-0.0190741587,
0.0622363053,
0.0337302759,
-0.0749603435,
-0.0026795932,
-0.0457210392,
-0.0535623096,
-0.0424640551,
-0.0244018734,
-0.0250594057,
-6.859159413e-33,
-0.0494904779,
0.0004545996,
0.0009951486,
0.0021384289,
-0.0599348359,
-0.0407724902,
-0.0007375269,
0.0024321422,
0.0149295889,
0.0184735283,
-0.0082217073,
-0.0122777531,
0.0010798621,
0.0063994001,
0.0146021638,
0.0088265687,
0.0700204074,
-0.0063419365,
-0.0666916966,
0.0405933522,
0.0069401613,
0.0194320995,
0.038111385,
-0.0826453939,
0.0064108204,
0.0076470575,
-0.0248940717,
0.0039203316,
-0.0186120588,
0.052847676,
-0.0124854892,
0.0165808778,
-0.0182198454,
-0.0555374026,
-0.0197869688,
-0.0033407598,
-0.0971308127,
0.0078174612,
0.0275142491,
-0.0153201511,
-0.0598655269,
-0.0219438523,
0.052969899,
0.0068650651,
-0.0578213297,
-0.0131673804,
0.0503542498,
-0.034449093,
-0.0129951676,
-0.0209654793,
-0.0872780383,
0.0067099002,
-0.0211378243,
-0.0201324318,
0.0052902242,
-0.0042718854,
-0.0146759907,
0.0296106357,
0.0074323863,
0.0180886146,
0.044344347,
0.0255369805,
0.0892161578,
0.0508119352,
0.0423297025,
0.0553383753,
0.0011476558,
-0.012558477,
0.018356679,
-0.0279283356,
0.0408868827,
0.0508538671,
-0.001619943,
0.0648520887,
0.0301185641,
-0.0097173955,
-0.0360024981,
0.0469437279,
-0.0508942455,
0.0282697137,
0.0397793055,
0.0296538156,
-0.0311600119,
-0.0153372148,
-0.0742781013,
-0.0525099263,
-0.0139865056,
-0.0226553809,
0.0418701656,
0.0246293228,
-0.0325260088,
-0.0329754464,
0.0185564179,
-0.039612446,
-0.0173597671,
0.016602831,
-0.0229893997,
0.0030048194,
0.0063478695,
-0.0132092293,
-0.0812226534,
-0.015965648,
0.0100458069,
0.0084235407,
0.0138998721,
0.0242447965,
0.0308766663,
0.0132048111,
-0.0224415604,
0.0404707827,
-0.0319739543,
0.0253105666,
-0.0091741402,
-0.0045983354,
0.0395401083,
0.0005539015,
-0.001046009,
0.0121588511,
0.0063823136,
-0.0085614715,
-0.0333890915,
-0.0037529361,
-0.0167256221,
0.0296489522,
-0.029648738,
-0.0033891848,
-0.0087620914,
0.0188616216,
0.0560325608,
-0.0468215682,
-0.0263024159,
0.0267409608,
2.989e-7,
-0.0225730352,
0.0392937884,
0.0179009475,
-0.0018816233,
0.0011036952,
0.053380888,
-0.0131842885,
0.0311334543,
0.0108128833,
-0.0059677064,
0.0352863893,
0.0267047901,
0.0458029918,
-0.0205980111,
-0.0374913514,
0.0252414998,
-0.0756557584,
0.0421658345,
-0.0186505876,
-0.0356788039,
-0.011756083,
0.0603968836,
0.0317317769,
-0.0111588901,
0.0537624285,
0.0347969048,
0.0657937676,
-0.04220118,
0.0183511544,
0.0234544147,
-0.0104154125,
-0.0103984913,
-0.0162842888,
-0.0245779082,
-0.010577512,
0.017668331,
-0.0074659367,
0.0334708691,
-0.0299258381,
-0.0171945058,
-0.0424755402,
0.016959494,
0.0359975137,
-0.0722352341,
0.0069648684,
-0.0722974017,
-0.0065351757,
-0.04726962,
-0.0170061402,
-0.0366550423,
0.0292197354,
-0.0179255996,
-0.0064096213,
0.0010134951,
0.021263998,
0.0388608836,
-0.021808723,
-0.0602751337,
-0.0025643664,
0.0108167147,
-0.0396222323,
-0.0778974295,
-0.0187359303,
0.0501264706,
-0.0306110866,
-0.0503697544,
-0.0108945062,
2.812859258e-34,
0.0245029796,
-0.0153821567,
0.0188072287,
-0.0463575013,
0.0179298427,
0.0294734649,
-0.0051759118,
0.0147717297,
0.043921385,
-0.0260291938,
-0.0135478368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06762v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06762v3 | Shall We Pretrain Autoregressive Language Models with Retrieval? A Comprehensive Study | 2023-04-13T18:04:19 | 2023-12-21T00:18:48 | Boxin Wang, Wei Ping, Peng Xu, Lawrence McAfee, Zihan Liu, Mohammad Shoeybi, Yi Dong, Oleksii Kuchaiev, Bo Li, Chaowei Xiao, Anima Anandkumar, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large decoder-only language models (LMs) can be largely improved in terms of
perplexity by retrieval (e.g., RETRO), but its impact on text generation
quality and downstream task accuracy is unclear. Thus, it is still an open
question: shall we pretrain large autoregressive LMs with retrieval? To answer
it, we perform a comprehensive study on a scalable pre-trained
retrieval-augmented LM (i.e., RETRO) compared with standard GPT and
retrieval-augmented GPT incorporated at fine-tuning or inference stages. We
first provide the recipe to reproduce RETRO up to 9.5B parameters while
retrieving a text corpus with 330B tokens. Based on that, we have the following
novel findings: i) RETRO outperforms GPT on text generation with much less
degeneration (i.e., repetition), moderately higher factual accuracy, and
slightly lower toxicity with a nontoxic retrieval database. ii) On the LM
Evaluation Harness benchmark, RETRO largely outperforms GPT on
knowledge-intensive tasks, but is on par with GPT on other tasks. Furthermore,
we introduce a simple variant of the model, RETRO++, which largely improves
open-domain QA results of original RETRO (e.g., EM score +8.6 on Natural
Question) and significantly outperforms retrieval-augmented GPT in both
fine-tuning and zero-shot evaluation settings. Our findings highlight the
promising direction of pretraining autoregressive LMs with retrieval as future
foundation models. We release our code and model at:
https://github.com/NVIDIA/Megatron-LM/blob/main/tools/retro/README.md | [
0.0283326022,
0.0861256197,
0.00975696,
0.0138364518,
-0.0253657512,
0.0093592936,
-0.0339839831,
0.0193650015,
-0.0425245725,
-0.0500341095,
-0.0262102839,
-0.0438701287,
-0.0244460981,
0.0542140231,
0.0033711193,
-0.0144543378,
0.0440887697,
0.0162372924,
0.0142129045,
0.0007673023,
-0.0013862434,
0.0051764562,
0.0005775209,
0.0265082344,
0.0076640402,
-0.0015697255,
0.000543502,
0.0156642254,
0.0115398923,
-0.0306740236,
0.0115095424,
0.0354636274,
0.0475803241,
0.0671601444,
0.0000019894,
-0.0165525842,
-0.0128105152,
-0.0095005194,
-0.0301623587,
0.0221733712,
0.0137028564,
0.0058233105,
0.0072243228,
0.0293630715,
-0.054754775,
-0.0628443062,
0.0273150783,
0.0270920303,
0.0582989976,
0.0814121515,
0.0066976994,
0.0008435737,
0.0544536002,
-0.0442486852,
0.032964699,
-0.0263540503,
-0.0167763066,
-0.00679219,
-0.0130041763,
0.0560424365,
0.0100611681,
0.0515334159,
0.034447249,
0.0053148177,
0.0062234215,
0.0369154774,
-0.0224821791,
-0.0070590787,
-0.0217407942,
0.0348545536,
0.0214843489,
-0.034519162,
-0.0165752135,
0.0233700946,
-0.0453249551,
-0.0301296059,
-0.027679991,
0.0241901837,
0.0128450049,
0.0275707655,
0.0105965948,
-0.0073181847,
0.0371821858,
0.0018663765,
-0.0293779932,
0.0363487378,
0.0412790105,
-0.0207289793,
-0.0088978158,
0.0357103199,
-0.0252456926,
-0.0024923054,
0.0013305546,
0.0224510469,
-0.0272650551,
0.0141253583,
-0.0204118062,
-0.0285239331,
0.0091630202,
0.0451948419,
0.0331190228,
0.0579228401,
-0.0336618684,
-0.0020293964,
-0.0305109117,
0.0410724618,
-0.0188709721,
-0.0218623187,
-0.0291824937,
0.0039341557,
-0.0262571033,
-0.0489301756,
-0.0593508892,
0.0470106602,
-0.0440283902,
0.0044262749,
-0.039086543,
0.012481465,
0.0286038592,
-0.0502997413,
-0.0038093275,
0.0361485668,
-0.0797804072,
-0.013546342,
-0.0064508482,
0.0419232361,
-0.0182241499,
0.0023153198,
0.0628430992,
-0.0907839313,
-0.0350187682,
0.0013657059,
0.0059105516,
-0.0677258745,
0.0072218692,
-0.0054130573,
-0.0400416404,
-0.0518897176,
-0.0270000268,
-0.0382774062,
-0.0193521827,
-0.0841810331,
0.0172956679,
-0.0299982075,
0.0145045575,
0.0168916397,
-0.0057330318,
-0.001990004,
-0.0155587597,
0.0349784829,
0.0192155149,
0.0178276747,
0.0099639352,
-0.0028197311,
0.0260222927,
0.0081896195,
0.0197443701,
0.0468976311,
0.0203968175,
0.0328688622,
0.0046390626,
0.0210805349,
-0.0128301159,
0.0050701671,
0.0597761013,
0.0293873809,
-0.0373659097,
0.0129708583,
-0.0044362652,
0.0083030406,
0.0380996652,
0.0550341532,
-0.0557261631,
0.0199585911,
0.0362873003,
0.0075859581,
0.0366010368,
0.0499474406,
0.0565190725,
-0.0020264329,
0.0114848521,
0.0124255996,
-0.0081893727,
0.0250978023,
-0.0492700152,
0.0215815846,
0.0360907726,
0.0221193172,
-0.04187309,
-0.0146719078,
0.0353564471,
0.0005939956,
-0.0193922352,
-0.003753938,
0.0583353192,
0.015020703,
-0.0865170732,
0.0248345137,
-0.0165324453,
-0.0958195254,
0.0127790496,
-0.0883899778,
0.0087753078,
0.013818684,
0.09881863,
-0.0153193083,
-0.0043517691,
0.0082916347,
-0.0209270678,
0.0424924046,
0.0630897954,
0.0263912417,
0.0174321886,
-0.050101351,
-0.0052387714,
-0.0324836336,
0.0373504646,
0.0235540774,
0.0444788113,
0.0541470647,
0.0681016073,
-0.0339334309,
0.0053912895,
0.0480451733,
-0.0298442356,
-0.059341453,
0.0016581024,
-0.0008953444,
0.0043220595,
0.0057133138,
-0.0246966053,
0.0380539037,
0.0396754332,
-0.0445857458,
-0.0048910892,
0.0217929743,
-0.0915642679,
-0.0747520328,
0.0066147414,
0.015971845,
0.0032483391,
0.0792300105,
-0.0212195981,
-0.0549976528,
0.0452068858,
-0.02059553,
0.0678297281,
-0.0996740237,
0.0006025601,
0.0124963569,
0.0035655445,
-0.0286932681,
0.0553134754,
0.0246090479,
-0.0018247808,
0.0085499361,
0.0043058107,
0.0395856872,
-0.0394451879,
-0.0572004132,
-0.0295434538,
-0.0002948771,
0.0329981521,
0.0462167859,
0.009966189,
-0.0230034329,
-0.0101887491,
-0.0686678439,
0.0218691658,
-0.0579380207,
0.0023955212,
0.0059273196,
0.0223860182,
0.0027770703,
-0.0063601276,
-0.0044326819,
0.0124814063,
0.0627738312,
0.0258731525,
0.0281132646,
0.0137612727,
0.0352564603,
-0.0321885236,
-0.0119722113,
0.0170920826,
0.0458404757,
-0.0044129305,
0.0238666758,
0.0012512261,
0.0601106174,
-0.0210372824,
0.0144819347,
-0.0144651737,
-0.0412872061,
0.0328602828,
-0.0351675227,
0.0689136833,
0.0480606891,
0.007584291,
0.0407933332,
-0.0187645033,
-0.0097716618,
-0.0410916246,
0.0313914828,
-0.041408591,
-0.0648991689,
0.0147124762,
0.0072799171,
0.0252049454,
0.051234927,
-0.0118480297,
-0.0156077091,
-0.0707525387,
-0.0163976066,
-0.0034926329,
-0.014785191,
-0.037429709,
-0.001750725,
-0.0269758143,
0.0120917642,
-0.0362108983,
-0.0810512826,
0.0604459122,
-0.0234508924,
-0.0138960425,
-0.0131497569,
0.023082016,
-0.0415154211,
0.0835501924,
0.0066696852,
0.0112420805,
-0.0040991157,
-0.0381676741,
-0.0384220518,
0.035285268,
0.0000270802,
-0.0467277206,
0.0489934757,
-0.0194920115,
0.0257048644,
-0.0076767937,
-0.065429613,
-0.0486187264,
-0.0333966091,
0.0071388092,
-0.007312262,
-0.0037387179,
0.004502763,
-0.0482583642,
0.0126451105,
0.0233937837,
0.0421504676,
-0.0324163474,
-0.0078506246,
-0.0013063558,
0.0285114031,
0.056398835,
-0.0132367956,
-0.0005586683,
-0.0271697529,
0.0184042715,
0.0453305431,
0.039257165,
-0.0191735234,
-0.0287957042,
0.0199382734,
0.020692233,
-0.0112184826,
-0.0378173664,
0.0145756667,
0.0486899614,
-0.0560851432,
-0.0756798983,
0.0711361989,
0.0259670429,
-0.0483458564,
-0.0347037539,
0.0119836573,
0.0758292899,
-0.0114042507,
0.0345475003,
-0.0735405162,
-0.0332551971,
-0.0033012046,
0.0339401662,
0.0038734311,
0.0103024151,
-0.025203649,
-0.122784853,
0.024849074,
0.0190782715,
-0.045685228,
-0.0468745828,
-0.0031129566,
-0.0528553762,
0.0048614731,
0.0097409906,
0.0740020871,
-0.0193578582,
0.0274163764,
0.0114775123,
-0.0006744727,
-0.0334417224,
-0.0022198546,
-0.0289908946,
0.0055641686,
0.1106334999,
0.0169488098,
0.0264018998,
-0.0216612425,
0.0021546842,
-0.052580148,
0.0229740981,
-0.0063052699,
0.0476321131,
-0.0315586589,
-0.0042828401,
-0.0358422883,
0.0026613916,
-0.0297204535,
0.0095849205,
-0.0112984003,
0.0540102385,
-0.0410488583,
-0.0019434564,
-0.0251382366,
-0.0228344686,
-0.0043051071,
0.05747284,
0.023424698,
-0.0083260825,
-0.0683018789,
-0.0294998325,
0.05260792,
-0.0866715088,
0.0034870382,
0.0045284079,
0.0209045522,
-0.0249104891,
-0.062189918,
-0.0331002213,
-0.0143375881,
0.0544436015,
-0.0333780721,
0.0058589624,
-0.0697875023,
-0.0028613317,
-0.0687360838,
0.0398222432,
-0.0302852299,
-0.0191056728,
-0.0640317947,
0.0033374766,
0.035556443,
-0.0319201425,
-0.0019111981,
0.0016871688,
-0.0702932477,
-0.0557141416,
0.010873328,
0.0325576253,
0.0205695648,
0.045221176,
0.0183814615,
-0.0283107925,
0.0440832973,
0.0533273108,
-0.0328550115,
0.024112979,
-0.0052224938,
-0.0187491607,
-0.0300218556,
0.0322079249,
-0.0408476964,
0.0037743349,
-0.0122084673,
0.0508355871,
0.0455715656,
-0.0250216406,
0.0450435765,
0.0485320203,
0.0671445355,
0.003575267,
0.0068228478,
-0.022837406,
-0.006979377,
-0.0185943805,
0.0130953584,
-0.0709604174,
0.0100333951,
0.0175485685,
-0.0203756541,
-0.0345787629,
0.0130310636,
0.0070372284,
0.1063494757,
-0.0527396724,
-0.0074212071,
-0.040883638,
0.0177601594,
0.0351988561,
-0.0028622986,
-0.0310949925,
-0.0086267143,
-0.008500671,
0.0432329886,
-0.0384989493,
0.0420633219,
0.0069903093,
0.0007011914,
0.012901471,
0.0147171533,
-0.0692350566,
-0.0055713058,
-0.0340428688,
-0.0181817356,
0.0622667074,
0.007164367,
0.0849530399,
-0.0413319357,
0.0139593501,
-0.0221655071,
0.0127940746,
0.021028826,
-0.0216310974,
0.0133301578,
-0.0018447136,
-0.0310179554,
0.0029053802,
0.0650760531,
0.0140152453,
0.0376486145,
0.0154972477,
0.0025645772,
-0.0093228417,
-0.0127472822,
0.0106384214,
-0.0093745077,
-0.0038424951,
-0.0085783349,
-0.014756348,
-0.0543317609,
0.0053009312,
-0.0092022019,
-0.023773808,
-0.0145613998,
0.0233316328,
0.0544997156,
-0.0156532731,
-0.0408938937,
-0.0490056276,
0.0484448522,
-0.0372371115,
0.0115712173,
-0.0096026706,
-6.695051585e-33,
-0.0244864449,
-0.000628697,
0.0463519692,
-0.0608363748,
-0.0607188046,
0.0013592561,
-0.0447947048,
-0.0081088319,
-0.0175332781,
-0.0068977801,
-0.0122125233,
0.0316049047,
0.0023912662,
0.0512409136,
-0.0227114651,
0.0144903027,
0.0655932501,
-0.0174735356,
-0.0257340986,
0.0485179275,
0.0206322074,
0.0678643361,
0.0275773518,
0.019189544,
-0.0181829333,
-0.025736196,
0.0021196094,
0.0063526221,
-0.0136401989,
0.035903234,
-0.0173366051,
0.0305807833,
0.0099763293,
-0.0126516335,
-0.0120115047,
0.0155026624,
-0.0736382008,
-0.0186976511,
-0.0257055387,
-0.008141797,
-0.0072845756,
-0.0209117122,
0.0252867416,
-0.0061698565,
-0.0160398707,
-0.0077580791,
-0.0294601507,
0.0016000256,
-0.0314974599,
-0.033966355,
-0.0449586771,
0.019116044,
0.0314645395,
-0.017395772,
-0.0026750872,
0.0635357648,
0.0035839793,
0.0440151766,
-0.0522889644,
0.0086465096,
-0.0135937398,
0.0467108153,
0.0291403271,
0.032548096,
0.0247065574,
0.0412064493,
-0.0117868446,
-0.0131013263,
-0.0498207137,
0.002080173,
0.0359673761,
0.0147381872,
0.0062672892,
0.013616465,
0.0713868886,
-0.031374231,
-0.0721574128,
0.0340117738,
-0.0140342973,
0.0519075543,
0.0368737541,
0.009098555,
-0.0177802388,
-0.0069249426,
-0.0321639627,
0.0292586721,
-0.0373113118,
-0.0402860083,
0.0692584664,
0.0601770654,
-0.0013002717,
-0.0321777202,
0.0547611415,
-0.0251766741,
0.0227036308,
0.0187192913,
-0.0775667801,
-0.0010595578,
-0.0414971486,
0.0642266199,
-0.0367337465,
-0.0335112587,
0.0391424559,
0.0095105693,
-0.0293283798,
-0.0095988717,
-0.0029067581,
0.0423543863,
-0.0698533878,
0.0130359642,
-0.0464987829,
0.0416902229,
0.0130764497,
-0.0116216429,
0.0194785167,
0.0108487522,
0.0078798663,
0.0556356609,
-0.0145671321,
-0.0018404338,
-0.0379207954,
-0.0462110266,
0.0469686873,
0.0070567993,
0.0002528415,
0.0223624669,
-0.0198732149,
0.0154875834,
0.0105532138,
-0.0574002974,
-0.0215804707,
0.0262622423,
2.687e-7,
0.049211517,
0.0199011695,
0.0622780807,
0.0195590481,
-0.0222858656,
0.0220900029,
-0.0114340559,
0.0008474162,
0.0362252779,
0.0451348722,
0.0154423947,
0.0216077734,
0.0821983442,
0.020768933,
-0.0588771068,
0.0352898501,
-0.0848404914,
-0.0045395945,
-0.0484744571,
-0.0342820622,
0.0510593206,
0.0675947145,
-0.0430991575,
-0.0087763909,
0.0326139107,
-0.0395400375,
0.1072878838,
0.0100189215,
-0.0451416373,
0.0038612753,
0.0322411843,
0.0635075048,
-0.0125338389,
-0.020511087,
-0.0303194728,
0.0073342021,
-0.0161355734,
0.0547330715,
-0.0054600774,
-0.1195296049,
0.0349872783,
0.0214858465,
0.0051586581,
-0.0280300807,
0.0622739159,
-0.0337291509,
0.010012351,
-0.0092128124,
-0.0678766891,
-0.001157505,
0.0119562,
-0.0446795821,
-0.0216655638,
0.0182647128,
0.0168410353,
0.0305931736,
-0.0278103445,
-0.0958763659,
-0.0189930405,
0.0278772879,
-0.0436843298,
-0.0289921146,
-0.069964774,
0.0054191761,
-0.0052032867,
-0.0449430458,
0.0171139482,
2.713165858e-34,
0.0536824279,
-0.0479380749,
0.013439131,
0.0064652008,
0.0365014076,
0.0029478078,
-0.004550545,
0.0149191432,
-0.0098869586,
-0.0869081169,
-0.035678044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06708v1 | Verbs in Action: Improving verb understanding in video-language models | 2023-04-13T17:57:01 | 2023-04-13T17:57:01 | Liliane Momeni, Mathilde Caron, Arsha Nagrani, Andrew Zisserman, Cordelia Schmid | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Understanding verbs is crucial to modelling how people and objects interact
with each other and the environment through space and time. Recently,
state-of-the-art video-language models based on CLIP have been shown to have
limited verb understanding and to rely extensively on nouns, restricting their
performance in real-world video applications that require action and temporal
understanding. In this work, we improve verb understanding for CLIP-based
video-language models by proposing a new Verb-Focused Contrastive (VFC)
framework. This consists of two main components: (1) leveraging pretrained
large language models (LLMs) to create hard negatives for cross-modal
contrastive learning, together with a calibration strategy to balance the
occurrence of concepts in positive and negative pairs; and (2) enforcing a
fine-grained, verb phrase alignment loss. Our method achieves state-of-the-art
results for zero-shot performance on three downstream tasks that focus on verb
understanding: video-text matching, video question-answering and video
classification. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work which
proposes a method to alleviate the verb understanding problem, and does not
simply highlight it. | [
0.0024076635,
0.0119402371,
-0.0053504617,
0.0715268105,
-0.0288853757,
-0.0071967435,
-0.0272416715,
-0.0040696342,
-0.0522004254,
-0.0753819793,
-0.031719666,
-0.0657797903,
-0.0082113715,
0.0483849309,
0.016798364,
-0.0383386537,
0.0712530687,
-0.0076292008,
-0.0235610139,
0.0150042027,
0.0531859696,
0.0183150154,
-0.0082131308,
0.0147143397,
-0.0350720696,
-0.0216831975,
-0.0110755656,
-0.0134073673,
0.0564171188,
-0.0098642623,
-0.0048417458,
0.0213514455,
0.0669765323,
0.0053288895,
0.0000014952,
-0.0247332323,
-0.0074673905,
-0.0094888592,
0.0044500972,
0.0039794203,
0.0046938919,
-0.064384751,
0.0177308675,
0.028773265,
-0.0520210154,
0.001147287,
0.0330046862,
0.0136722811,
0.0527080484,
0.051977098,
-0.0208146758,
-0.019314494,
0.0055577951,
-0.0243772194,
0.0126420315,
-0.0020153539,
0.0169166792,
0.0184190422,
0.0251151025,
0.0224214736,
-0.1062880456,
0.0455309935,
0.0128837554,
-0.0079937065,
-0.0189452842,
0.0216709767,
-0.04468951,
-0.0214775894,
0.0036708086,
0.082931757,
0.005049556,
-0.0043250998,
0.0126282293,
-0.0228865538,
-0.0313490257,
0.0071691745,
-0.0288914666,
0.0345352441,
0.0573383756,
0.0313102752,
-0.0027966541,
-0.0174794327,
0.0063919034,
0.0145522943,
0.045070257,
-0.0253540743,
0.0157451555,
0.0112210559,
-0.0396014713,
0.0139557635,
-0.0163917169,
-0.0311681964,
-0.0050423113,
0.0097203348,
-0.0174449757,
0.0129088322,
-0.0419003256,
-0.0087288739,
-0.0190482605,
-0.0357073285,
0.0310975835,
0.0378103144,
-0.0221107062,
0.0687157065,
-0.0187498312,
0.0419127457,
-0.0181283485,
0.0272036474,
-0.0336923599,
-0.0250372924,
-0.041377347,
0.0226798505,
-0.0182253793,
-0.0001929376,
-0.0841543972,
-0.0336688161,
0.0086533949,
0.0070584156,
-0.031910833,
-0.0233198386,
-0.0156901777,
0.01105309,
-0.0091248462,
-0.0409358628,
-0.0152728092,
0.0468555726,
-0.0060264161,
0.0806776211,
-0.0527770296,
-0.0689578503,
-0.0426022783,
0.0201384276,
0.0149579737,
-0.0255206171,
0.0078113773,
0.0098785469,
-0.0464473255,
-0.0847808346,
-0.0080485027,
0.018670598,
-0.0420472547,
-0.0394868925,
0.0173636489,
-0.0510488749,
0.0305565465,
-0.0022465209,
-0.0081267105,
-0.0416779555,
0.0177017562,
-0.0087451478,
-0.0288723018,
0.0897115469,
0.0174402688,
0.0034571188,
-0.024832515,
0.0117682964,
-0.0135434326,
0.0399457254,
0.0160595272,
-0.0220647063,
-0.0046740752,
0.0560434684,
0.0476080738,
0.0408093855,
0.0060397433,
0.0371527225,
-0.0902931318,
0.0078952368,
0.0260940827,
0.0323419832,
0.0702198371,
0.0677282959,
-0.0180483125,
-0.0315391235,
0.081463486,
0.0330212303,
-0.0782803893,
-0.0496548116,
0.0638811216,
0.0282340534,
-0.0199755225,
-0.0266136564,
-0.0259996299,
0.039233204,
-0.008839922,
-0.0040494027,
-0.0517964475,
0.015815381,
-0.0828090757,
-0.0086240573,
-0.032666117,
-0.0152690364,
0.0502339713,
0.0323898345,
0.0664084926,
0.0087103294,
-0.0277874004,
0.0308231432,
0.0179675948,
-0.0044602971,
0.0310107861,
-0.0251213647,
0.0306332875,
0.0212445203,
-0.0028760524,
0.0016603384,
-0.0467862599,
-0.0033077768,
0.0334916487,
0.0262831729,
0.0267932042,
-0.014084449,
0.0400363058,
-0.0439397432,
-0.0377299301,
-0.0191389713,
0.0219187196,
-0.0043343068,
-0.0061365603,
0.0038885621,
0.01667591,
-0.0073229149,
-0.0134156793,
0.0423444994,
0.0117275519,
-0.0085240426,
-0.01851633,
0.0070310025,
0.0366954319,
-0.0033499894,
-0.0167939831,
-0.0189761892,
0.0155234048,
-0.0130431475,
0.0032651694,
0.0307940189,
-0.0095511936,
-0.0870620012,
0.0380014665,
-0.0261383876,
-0.0392181799,
0.0842833519,
-0.0352419019,
-0.0464593805,
0.031633839,
-0.0220739599,
0.0274275541,
-0.0573652424,
0.0090960022,
0.0520910546,
0.0104963239,
-0.0110043334,
0.004738309,
-0.0095251277,
-0.0207573026,
0.0061675268,
0.0271319151,
-0.0050765979,
-0.0302911811,
-0.0701899976,
-0.0299131852,
-0.006035082,
0.0119249942,
-0.001867699,
-0.0113693774,
-0.0737821013,
0.018096948,
-0.0657002702,
0.020685045,
-0.0292407311,
0.0304128136,
-0.0101227723,
-0.0183090847,
0.0038715566,
-0.0595350675,
-0.0020699387,
0.0255802404,
0.0162874386,
0.0257327985,
0.0196257904,
0.0333885849,
-0.0157336276,
-0.0307748243,
0.0106537696,
0.0113209039,
0.0102061536,
-0.0423719846,
-0.0018703693,
0.0275523774,
0.0504713878,
-0.0022860605,
0.0605145358,
-0.037905816,
-0.0268417113,
-0.0019925756,
0.0030004608,
0.0286989547,
0.0630921349,
-0.0133430539,
0.0295836031,
0.0237177555,
-0.0249686856,
-0.0420270525,
0.0012135059,
-0.0253679119,
-0.0491423383,
-0.0269802622,
0.0109447325,
-0.0376622677,
0.0421757996,
-0.0203005057,
0.025286084,
-0.0770361274,
-0.0088023199,
-0.0128475092,
-0.0194120184,
-0.0306930654,
0.0186306611,
-0.0236283559,
-0.0035722191,
-0.054147549,
-0.0257593226,
0.0340026468,
-0.0268656127,
-0.0318758301,
-0.0108289951,
-0.0131919729,
0.0062377937,
0.0868503675,
0.02370633,
0.0251368415,
0.0179105047,
-0.0128642917,
-0.1052917019,
-0.0606566519,
0.0206333827,
-0.0066509666,
0.0635832399,
-0.080196701,
0.0205758214,
-0.0115923174,
-0.0338829197,
-0.0304316692,
-0.0622846223,
-0.0354395546,
-0.0057291775,
-0.0355808027,
0.0010889375,
0.0067889523,
0.0195786022,
0.0229132306,
0.0259679891,
-0.01223619,
0.0200393423,
-0.0314700007,
0.0591357127,
0.0735829696,
0.0062305671,
-0.029524764,
-0.0420847796,
0.0050282362,
0.0664256141,
0.0125726601,
-0.0243402272,
-0.0506364666,
0.0322300605,
0.0503939204,
0.0218158364,
-0.0330146141,
0.0141999675,
0.0783246234,
-0.0456470326,
-0.0098493714,
0.0827795938,
0.0129779866,
-0.0211006198,
-0.0113591272,
0.0161676835,
-0.0112084169,
0.0213907268,
-0.0074908668,
-0.0519945025,
-0.0605176985,
-0.0156188821,
-0.0127269793,
0.0364583209,
0.0240631737,
-0.0315857753,
-0.1206572279,
0.0107278861,
0.0132964244,
-0.0368382931,
-0.0343817696,
-0.0001192648,
0.0323115923,
-0.049645137,
0.0122147584,
-0.0280498695,
-0.0024032719,
0.0247895662,
0.0014990838,
0.0125346668,
-0.0753911212,
0.0390311889,
-0.0750861391,
0.0704437792,
0.0107299779,
0.0378586203,
-0.0033003623,
-0.0574932918,
0.0179831535,
-0.045840878,
-0.0008767316,
-0.0059369314,
0.0316935293,
-0.0429503098,
-0.0284974966,
0.0313885212,
0.0328655504,
0.0023316254,
-0.0604117438,
-0.0451707318,
0.0543758161,
-0.0231802948,
0.0385167189,
-0.0262742229,
0.00431359,
0.0407834202,
0.0870359316,
-0.0140014384,
-0.0063552484,
0.0148781361,
0.0325834602,
-0.0620159544,
0.004106618,
-0.0410200395,
-0.0476447269,
-0.0102138761,
0.0399084613,
-0.0143806841,
-0.0331923664,
0.0651844889,
0.028840825,
-0.0316602103,
-0.0119481841,
0.010109433,
0.0299243405,
-0.0491035469,
0.1027294025,
-0.0439764149,
0.0416986905,
-0.0259954184,
-0.0083437925,
0.0695997328,
0.0077707092,
-0.0176399257,
0.0266804937,
-0.0523889512,
-0.0538867377,
-0.0311174486,
0.0686609074,
0.0157365426,
0.0913332254,
0.0095202867,
0.0248810928,
-0.0358589552,
-0.0145183848,
0.006370266,
0.0338784456,
0.0040531866,
-0.0526227988,
-0.0227828398,
0.0432744771,
-0.0270978548,
0.0133556873,
0.0175074637,
0.0463701747,
-0.0775261968,
0.0009515673,
0.0311863013,
-0.0649814233,
0.0895299539,
-0.0097059188,
0.0054312907,
-0.0425359793,
-0.0186776146,
0.0024293773,
0.0216509737,
-0.0773225501,
0.0143647594,
0.0456081666,
0.0014554033,
-0.0316489264,
0.0287420768,
-0.0260949079,
-0.011653157,
-0.0133535881,
-0.0366445631,
0.0224222522,
-0.036272224,
0.0080804685,
0.0410231017,
0.0222547911,
0.0198345743,
0.0141188381,
0.0024011063,
0.0248419382,
0.0571801104,
0.0159075689,
-0.0006869248,
-0.0071581053,
0.0129579827,
-0.0196276754,
-0.0132087208,
-0.0245448593,
0.0052341898,
0.0319489948,
-0.0620865449,
0.013263098,
0.0001664256,
-0.0300904922,
-0.0145271393,
0.0493697599,
-0.0406302735,
-0.0299049262,
0.0803093612,
0.0149410972,
-0.0212775003,
0.0122450227,
0.0608871616,
-0.0189481713,
0.0374164395,
0.0011173002,
0.0170085151,
0.0047159344,
-0.0108024729,
0.0584361963,
0.0056291483,
-0.0223869663,
0.0176526252,
-0.0604386665,
-0.0756519586,
-0.0134022059,
0.0079472903,
-0.0317100547,
0.0171897821,
0.0674343109,
0.014054493,
-0.0075828955,
-0.0075203152,
-0.0166820865,
-0.0353425965,
-0.0250636954,
-0.0085567059,
-0.0238229148,
-5.193553712e-33,
-0.0402140878,
0.0208643805,
0.0302505177,
-0.0095829014,
-0.0303014833,
0.0456830114,
-0.0272726193,
0.0161269903,
-0.0289912838,
0.0395562761,
0.0286767334,
0.0617827885,
0.0119376853,
0.0272328835,
0.0169899352,
-0.0511553623,
0.051983472,
-0.0290967319,
-0.0043564052,
-0.0247834362,
0.0177969206,
0.0259371977,
0.0472254157,
-0.0546142943,
-0.0064582257,
0.002891459,
-0.0389227308,
0.0518491752,
0.0368772075,
0.0671970695,
-0.0045569548,
-0.035746295,
0.002316985,
-0.0548014604,
-0.0364618413,
0.0055186371,
-0.0174378417,
0.0161325298,
0.040028926,
0.0123302341,
-0.0732838586,
0.0142097063,
0.0218640994,
0.0076768692,
-0.0127902329,
0.015014152,
0.0280207004,
-0.0241037309,
0.0415316038,
0.0041064485,
-0.0358476341,
0.0052706799,
-0.0081331432,
-0.075702928,
0.0218624864,
-0.0100641893,
0.0261828713,
-0.0261230823,
-0.0498132855,
0.0024141588,
-0.0279316939,
0.0539944805,
0.1020307764,
0.028783001,
-0.0081709623,
0.0420832634,
-0.0172808468,
-0.0728011429,
0.0284592956,
-0.0115088401,
0.0336038396,
0.0394523479,
0.029414501,
0.0694167539,
0.0196298342,
0.0245354902,
-0.0104218153,
0.0131626241,
-0.0453211144,
0.078566663,
-0.0385204442,
0.0250830781,
-0.0007460394,
0.0045230263,
-0.0159385279,
-0.0112196058,
-0.0085769696,
0.0000233758,
0.0307870749,
0.0116830384,
0.0120825376,
0.0025453209,
0.0891407207,
-0.0372330733,
0.0189966578,
0.0619951375,
-0.0224892329,
0.0336401276,
0.0090558259,
0.0406649224,
-0.0674551353,
-0.0247581117,
0.0223680884,
0.0010445997,
-0.0331842713,
0.0044988827,
0.0106486641,
0.0501266494,
-0.0338023268,
-0.0043408386,
-0.0171511751,
-0.0251252651,
-0.0188559033,
0.057367336,
0.0455163158,
0.0364495404,
-0.026021935,
0.0602481253,
0.0021594653,
-0.0389087126,
-0.0017891405,
-0.0482218117,
-0.0097993463,
0.0113506056,
-0.0173358377,
0.0094185118,
-0.0275663175,
0.012248694,
0.0465542227,
-0.0597439632,
0.0019379114,
0.0272392072,
2.333e-7,
0.0421678312,
-0.0104743177,
-0.0150957257,
0.0101017021,
-0.0143204108,
0.0702580661,
-0.0142826084,
0.0659300387,
0.0101913176,
-0.0112838838,
0.0426514409,
0.0659112036,
0.025692394,
-0.0243749656,
-0.0240807217,
0.0251273308,
-0.0476669185,
-0.0390719622,
-0.0187876765,
0.011994943,
0.0390511341,
0.1334529519,
0.0449276604,
0.0121974237,
-0.007627192,
-0.0464034341,
0.0653847679,
-0.0128918104,
-0.0429889075,
0.003541013,
0.004600964,
-0.017534744,
-0.0336656012,
0.0226669051,
-0.0211671162,
0.0329447836,
0.0276141893,
0.0659452379,
-0.0305376928,
-0.0380430669,
-0.0457305722,
0.0091089578,
-0.0292580929,
0.00234271,
0.0748381987,
-0.0746954083,
0.0001841951,
-0.029906366,
-0.026546875,
0.0256188661,
-0.0076029934,
0.0135875698,
-0.0076814229,
-0.0023244049,
0.0200103801,
0.0078434264,
-0.0663529187,
-0.1119505242,
-0.0027025526,
0.0140087437,
-0.0237290151,
0.0043410612,
-0.0028137411,
0.0146873258,
0.0550701693,
-0.0272075851,
-0.0781815797,
1.33326383e-34,
0.0101988548,
0.0004398653,
-0.0143763246,
-0.0062201642,
-0.0298531801,
0.0106183328,
-0.0276612062,
0.0118117537,
0.004509354,
-0.0298657604,
0.0023281011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06671v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06671v2 | Diagnostic Benchmark and Iterative Inpainting for Layout-Guided Image Generation | 2023-04-13T16:58:33 | 2023-04-14T15:37:40 | Jaemin Cho, Linjie Li, Zhengyuan Yang, Zhe Gan, Lijuan Wang, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Spatial control is a core capability in controllable image generation.
Advancements in layout-guided image generation have shown promising results on
in-distribution (ID) datasets with similar spatial configurations. However, it
is unclear how these models perform when facing out-of-distribution (OOD)
samples with arbitrary, unseen layouts. In this paper, we propose LayoutBench,
a diagnostic benchmark for layout-guided image generation that examines four
categories of spatial control skills: number, position, size, and shape. We
benchmark two recent representative layout-guided image generation methods and
observe that the good ID layout control may not generalize well to arbitrary
layouts in the wild (e.g., objects at the boundary). Next, we propose
IterInpaint, a new baseline that generates foreground and background regions in
a step-by-step manner via inpainting, demonstrating stronger generalizability
than existing models on OOD layouts in LayoutBench. We perform quantitative and
qualitative evaluation and fine-grained analysis on the four LayoutBench skills
to pinpoint the weaknesses of existing models. Lastly, we show comprehensive
ablation studies on IterInpaint, including training task ratio, crop&paste vs.
repaint, and generation order. Project website: https://layoutbench.github.io | [
-0.0147695178,
0.0301428996,
0.023075942,
-0.0033296254,
-0.0458928943,
-0.0096140066,
0.0533078574,
-0.0010684582,
-0.0345484205,
-0.005891094,
-0.0150455311,
-0.0702415034,
0.015547039,
-0.0016834798,
-0.0003979456,
-0.0533329286,
-0.0982449204,
-0.035173595,
-0.0770952478,
-0.0028235037,
-0.0495078079,
-0.0191244017,
-0.0191296544,
-0.0358805843,
-0.0639066547,
-0.0289252866,
-0.0499659181,
0.0587386303,
-0.0003040445,
-0.028576253,
0.0205607172,
0.0471320599,
0.0121158697,
-0.0034406704,
0.0000022609,
0.0172669236,
0.0449655838,
0.0225625541,
0.082120575,
0.0734819546,
0.0265036002,
-0.0760182664,
-0.0605965592,
-0.0624630861,
-0.0034958667,
0.0638520271,
0.07048738,
0.0737065077,
0.0625886843,
-0.0113750277,
0.0009253034,
-0.0339182578,
-0.0435916185,
-0.0306501891,
0.0250495076,
0.081404373,
0.0219541974,
-0.0049931998,
0.0010646288,
-0.0412000567,
-0.0539845303,
0.0280856881,
0.0702461377,
-0.0039209025,
0.0022938212,
-0.0007328379,
0.0138114598,
-0.0289036073,
-0.0082308156,
0.0070329555,
-0.0870018005,
0.0031014215,
-0.0065061864,
-0.0390834287,
-0.012298611,
-0.0027167187,
-0.0485042222,
0.0148451459,
-0.0228834748,
-0.0263653379,
-0.0960343257,
-0.0023891565,
0.0080581913,
-0.0765282661,
-0.0456563979,
-0.0571715087,
0.0446147993,
0.0039753974,
-0.0794571415,
0.0256913193,
-0.0167827979,
-0.0630290806,
0.0377579369,
-0.0039973115,
-0.000807013,
-0.0038542545,
-0.055351153,
0.0123884073,
0.010516,
0.0503347814,
0.0400374494,
-0.0107274521,
-0.0256972667,
-0.0024943913,
0.0017153816,
0.0370814726,
-0.051278919,
0.0881239846,
-0.0591297708,
0.0330890603,
0.0134524498,
0.0057340697,
0.0005115488,
-0.0608467683,
-0.0375626348,
-0.0335538574,
-0.0282509699,
0.0061690309,
-0.0341621153,
-0.0025252635,
0.0082875099,
0.0610793866,
-0.077166155,
0.0027538848,
0.0000051207,
-0.044556547,
-0.0004669639,
0.0121059008,
-0.0117212031,
-0.0128608281,
-0.0304041225,
0.000273929,
0.0084829554,
-0.00050208,
-0.0113760764,
0.0645437315,
-0.0296825189,
0.0147543559,
-0.0362328626,
0.0341405794,
-0.0138831809,
-0.0490465984,
0.0521696024,
-0.0416458771,
-0.0271153171,
-0.0493177176,
-0.0160125401,
-0.0220238697,
0.0166731626,
0.0135954302,
0.0275754202,
-0.0230774954,
0.020663701,
0.0132938735,
-0.0060418658,
-0.0120018702,
0.005991763,
0.012242632,
0.0197489541,
0.0550873429,
0.001626046,
-0.02188343,
0.0233654734,
0.0379318297,
0.0635722801,
0.0458891466,
-0.0217333641,
-0.0299900882,
0.0306905061,
0.0310115665,
0.086980179,
0.0007290244,
-0.0519600473,
0.0124219079,
0.0764881819,
-0.0061846175,
0.0141415093,
0.0179496538,
0.0323046483,
0.0139986388,
0.0081567131,
0.0239668451,
-0.009468602,
0.0414372459,
0.0522874482,
0.0613269992,
-0.0211901497,
0.017104635,
-0.0430932865,
-0.0199172031,
0.0192008428,
-0.0107091656,
0.0162105542,
-0.0372063294,
0.0604989491,
0.0841897503,
-0.0279687382,
0.0090436451,
-0.0362850092,
-0.0262281485,
-0.0443880446,
0.0111634238,
-0.0282832831,
0.000135471,
0.0042513306,
0.0264997724,
-0.0383048765,
-0.0079017691,
0.0474247411,
0.0795412213,
0.0124750212,
0.0069775446,
0.0492917262,
-0.0084488504,
-0.042911008,
-0.0365399867,
-0.0008054017,
0.0358201452,
0.065183416,
-0.0058808727,
-0.0229283627,
-0.0498774014,
-0.0172449481,
0.0547260493,
-0.0082817171,
-0.0079764593,
0.0319292098,
0.0060623954,
0.022992447,
-0.0027884776,
-0.0455578901,
-0.0273591224,
0.0250820983,
-0.0159777626,
0.0307607632,
-0.0018292284,
-0.0229514372,
-0.0253040679,
-0.029213341,
-0.0462783426,
-0.0625910237,
-0.0018273272,
0.0002336815,
0.0110397507,
0.0211742036,
0.0124192629,
-0.0028905883,
-0.0251835119,
-0.0384657383,
-0.0095122959,
-0.0090887109,
-0.0207530037,
0.0441105068,
-0.0387035534,
-0.0003213565,
0.0662348866,
0.0557233579,
-0.0248681344,
0.0074933977,
0.0086149955,
-0.0454591364,
-0.0113950316,
-0.0489096716,
-0.0268792789,
0.0625736564,
-0.0507652238,
-0.0046735792,
0.000598241,
0.0062878076,
-0.0292719267,
0.0014411334,
0.0288450774,
-0.0213401895,
0.0117885452,
-0.0002665368,
0.0175888073,
-0.0232462548,
0.0045101726,
-0.0024558324,
-0.0033639621,
-0.0111951884,
0.0088732447,
-0.0053556142,
0.0311707128,
0.0629567504,
-0.035411641,
0.0498373285,
-0.014418113,
-0.0284205656,
0.0512983017,
0.0028691664,
0.0130514866,
-0.0276972242,
-0.007334874,
-0.0062156962,
-0.0108302245,
-0.0072861989,
0.1120566353,
-0.0030212614,
0.0044225259,
-0.0169063993,
0.0034156437,
0.0046022558,
0.0062741865,
0.0157958642,
-0.0221331008,
0.0494388975,
-0.011609124,
0.0033461354,
-0.0016645807,
0.0482628345,
0.0438213982,
-0.0552337691,
-0.0054182606,
-0.0143927215,
-0.0096874172,
0.0140028298,
0.0380821824,
-0.0226785094,
0.0257929098,
-0.0839517713,
-0.0692498013,
0.0136831505,
-0.0105416318,
-0.0352196433,
0.0256216303,
0.0224652998,
0.0300882738,
0.0532633588,
0.0416869558,
0.0154100722,
0.0183967799,
-0.0466886684,
-0.0268747751,
0.0098610986,
0.0044213585,
0.0113647571,
-0.0211916007,
-0.0827412531,
-0.0110667776,
-0.0235119015,
-0.0334414318,
-0.0155553464,
0.0092205554,
0.0586302355,
-0.0381809026,
-0.0032708936,
-0.0406874306,
0.0106506124,
0.0200325213,
0.0128378524,
0.0301372372,
-0.0219279528,
-0.0073166424,
0.0057831965,
0.0200594012,
0.0026087814,
-0.0211608224,
-0.0233931951,
-0.0481901392,
-0.0446804985,
0.0425167829,
0.0053260839,
0.0462603159,
-0.0422763303,
0.0502958857,
0.0051674983,
0.0526333787,
-0.0157708935,
0.02704354,
0.1004964188,
-0.0020671014,
-0.0627070665,
0.0185025614,
-0.0056484411,
0.0027148617,
-0.012738402,
0.0353742093,
0.0535113662,
0.0534267835,
-0.0030336231,
-0.0312738717,
0.0020304914,
-0.0318943895,
-0.0212519504,
0.0155526763,
0.0085904505,
-0.0097915269,
-0.0552743897,
0.0924581736,
0.0469193347,
-0.1245279387,
-0.0695091635,
-0.0078425817,
0.0364586115,
0.0112693142,
-0.0486532487,
0.0294175241,
-0.0238133743,
0.0037764004,
0.0179117974,
0.0212550648,
-0.0319389366,
-0.0359062552,
-0.0300454386,
-0.0318888947,
0.0781258866,
-0.0168879926,
0.0412851833,
-0.0159153044,
0.0367116295,
0.0232128333,
0.0030360036,
-0.015276636,
0.0688442439,
0.0687634647,
0.0008493082,
-0.0271844491,
0.0598296821,
-0.0424280167,
-0.0006562602,
0.0214841235,
-0.0142925885,
0.0162587278,
0.0130632333,
-0.0220923647,
-0.0296206344,
0.0468661897,
-0.0030791236,
0.0542875454,
-0.0027807292,
-0.0961665586,
-0.0437599942,
0.0598422475,
-0.0811134204,
0.0383350849,
0.005408966,
-0.0234679226,
-0.055857949,
-0.0381770693,
-0.0112730991,
0.0428803116,
0.0901096165,
0.0013798728,
-0.072175473,
-0.0862867162,
-0.0068224892,
-0.0635737181,
-0.0143565834,
0.0067573381,
0.0312168878,
-0.0256735403,
-0.0296423156,
-0.0009313596,
-0.0365678221,
0.0052936208,
0.0576299988,
-0.0463631563,
-0.0225956198,
-0.0067373104,
0.0655198917,
0.0168844927,
0.070021227,
0.0152039705,
0.0061975354,
0.093162097,
0.0143404081,
0.0729935318,
0.0288879853,
0.0168444924,
-0.0096789105,
-0.0035415557,
-0.0009882391,
-0.0349227823,
0.0097712958,
0.0117110284,
-0.0035057336,
0.0274815038,
0.0312999971,
0.0010502621,
-0.0651341677,
-0.0329085961,
-0.0314750187,
0.0343392529,
-0.0071689463,
0.0218662936,
-0.0372540839,
0.0057414691,
-0.0389286354,
0.0121993395,
0.0334384367,
0.0341545194,
0.009740999,
0.0083984621,
0.0177049339,
0.0562576614,
-0.0131404037,
-0.0462269522,
-0.0377109274,
0.0031355144,
0.0210149419,
0.0312895775,
0.0127168447,
0.0382765457,
-0.0320614353,
0.0366197489,
0.0431300513,
0.0001653039,
0.0288041718,
0.0016494904,
-0.0269565713,
0.0065341489,
-0.019126283,
-0.0154800005,
-0.0644470751,
0.0443256795,
0.0606705733,
-0.0259297844,
0.0631153882,
-0.0017864343,
-0.0130486852,
-0.0014330734,
0.0459488519,
0.0382173248,
-0.0323538259,
-0.0265600588,
-0.0078125792,
0.0291425157,
-0.0634818077,
0.0767843798,
0.0121462597,
0.0262632333,
-0.0550586581,
0.0129845971,
-0.0331840105,
0.0006363794,
0.0457426235,
0.0442805327,
0.0139008686,
-0.0056305942,
0.0059419838,
0.0155141586,
0.0043774103,
0.0356212929,
-0.0363206565,
-0.0212473571,
0.0630977079,
0.016264556,
-0.0275336187,
0.01223379,
0.0242607109,
-0.0232675057,
-0.0032531791,
-0.0121854311,
-0.0124401255,
-5.301901965e-33,
-0.0500673801,
-0.0049505653,
0.0263613854,
-0.0241885744,
0.0031393999,
-0.0654741526,
-0.0146589875,
0.0243949927,
0.0536721982,
0.0139183048,
-0.0177152473,
-0.0226021726,
0.0029902954,
0.0394725837,
0.0122508714,
0.0349306166,
0.0640558228,
0.0131791523,
-0.0364128724,
0.0060024248,
-0.0187801979,
0.0328492709,
0.0204595421,
0.0000725408,
-0.0784420669,
-0.0358647294,
0.0265623312,
-0.0335938223,
-0.0381416641,
-0.0186197627,
0.0494957864,
-0.0492292121,
0.0025906207,
-0.0213694926,
-0.0094896192,
-0.0211750995,
-0.0582496785,
-0.0561469086,
-0.0557301454,
0.02835357,
-0.0524598919,
-0.0320402756,
0.0450614765,
-0.0046584955,
-0.0190233234,
-0.0609366,
0.0351658203,
-0.0388990827,
0.0149375917,
0.0066730236,
-0.0185688324,
-0.009827896,
-0.036286395,
-0.0839575157,
-0.0120908506,
-0.0086077834,
0.0243397895,
0.0211097486,
-0.0750859454,
0.0202425011,
0.0276791845,
0.0157655906,
0.0252819844,
0.0630980879,
0.0393059254,
0.0215372723,
-0.0046999864,
0.0197717901,
0.0453381054,
-0.0292738359,
-0.0164750572,
0.0465335213,
-0.042334836,
0.009066171,
0.0619664155,
0.0354251005,
-0.044268921,
0.0529038832,
-0.0687707737,
0.018444201,
0.0174737033,
0.0347047374,
0.022896558,
-0.0141443275,
0.0297025908,
-0.0509923436,
-0.0289277919,
-0.0272451341,
0.0524634942,
0.0362164378,
0.0018882884,
-0.0200164504,
0.0154437218,
0.0221632142,
0.0438699201,
0.012078071,
-0.0658172667,
0.0603828356,
-0.0352402143,
-0.0608990155,
-0.0446661934,
-0.0227335542,
0.0112633901,
0.0931997076,
-0.0096708732,
0.0099481111,
0.0175398774,
0.0223067235,
0.0062476834,
0.0047342363,
-0.0367597565,
0.0537901819,
0.0206286423,
0.0052228784,
-0.0004690074,
-0.0136964573,
-0.0112131527,
-0.0010917761,
-0.0205068365,
-0.0008866446,
-0.0133095058,
0.0012644088,
-0.037719883,
-0.0149630122,
-0.0055813794,
-0.007677915,
-0.0557776727,
0.007594977,
0.0320127159,
-0.0488077365,
-0.0522284657,
-0.0157189146,
2.76e-7,
-0.0065578115,
-0.0009225291,
0.0130712492,
0.0137900449,
0.0121124471,
-0.0089723803,
-0.0491567291,
-0.0259384308,
-0.0153837157,
-0.0414901525,
0.0385991558,
0.0429619923,
0.021549521,
-0.0035559528,
-0.0357879288,
0.073655121,
-0.0243453681,
0.0158525202,
-0.0058498424,
-0.002800778,
-0.0073263473,
-0.003496171,
-0.0117064938,
-0.0526777804,
0.0676848367,
0.0238101222,
0.0354784541,
0.0031334532,
0.0510187373,
-0.0153642641,
-0.0172661021,
0.0303441156,
0.0045134588,
-0.002684504,
-0.0124007184,
-0.047494404,
-0.0023128919,
0.0022369584,
-0.0440149046,
0.0395173505,
0.0180941708,
0.0439753719,
0.0192629397,
-0.0595137104,
0.0047415448,
-0.0522840358,
0.0287573785,
-0.0319574885,
-0.0299179982,
0.0113484543,
0.0253077932,
-0.0337781683,
-0.0012342669,
0.0087582599,
0.0498041734,
0.0490708947,
0.0104572289,
0.0368121341,
-0.047199823,
0.0074816309,
-0.0472425111,
-0.0034999533,
-0.0620884672,
0.0211001709,
-0.0247516409,
0.0119153708,
-0.0600162521,
2.316795362e-34,
-0.0195044428,
0.0470544659,
0.0484001562,
-0.0078161191,
0.0241167527,
0.0390401706,
0.0146009522,
0.0074700583,
-0.0359842442,
0.0485565104,
0.0054114969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06653v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06653v3 | Graph2topic: an opensource topic modeling framework based on sentence embedding and community detection | 2023-04-13T16:28:07 | 2023-06-06T11:56:27 | Leihang Zhang, Jiapeng Liu, Qiang Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | It has been reported that clustering-based topic models, which cluster
high-quality sentence embeddings with an appropriate word selection method, can
generate better topics than generative probabilistic topic models. However,
these approaches suffer from the inability to select appropriate parameters and
incomplete models that overlook the quantitative relation between words with
topics and topics with text. To solve these issues, we propose graph to topic
(G2T), a simple but effective framework for topic modelling. The framework is
composed of four modules. First, document representation is acquired using
pretrained language models. Second, a semantic graph is constructed according
to the similarity between document representations. Third, communities in
document semantic graphs are identified, and the relationship between topics
and documents is quantified accordingly. Fourth, the word--topic distribution
is computed based on a variant of TFIDF. Automatic evaluation suggests that G2T
achieved state-of-the-art performance on both English and Chinese documents
with different lengths. | [
0.0138241397,
0.0058374899,
-0.0096036782,
0.0247126389,
-0.0396590494,
0.0029036466,
-0.0079886122,
-0.0228662528,
0.0127577484,
-0.0594355576,
0.0057525453,
0.0021600607,
-0.0071062692,
0.0530681908,
0.0061228639,
-0.0312694311,
0.0165360197,
0.0126416655,
-0.004050687,
0.021652678,
0.0636448935,
0.0519026257,
0.0473168232,
0.0103846593,
-0.00325813,
-0.0117986482,
-0.0036120696,
-0.0163943172,
0.0132148629,
-0.0042092269,
0.0115869371,
0.024860099,
0.0467600413,
0.0014285191,
0.0000017421,
-0.011560956,
-0.0462976247,
-0.0307067707,
0.0622074381,
0.0371972658,
0.1079490036,
-0.0415229984,
0.0423568152,
0.010159974,
-0.0275238138,
0.0047915345,
-0.0032957194,
0.0706524476,
0.0427590832,
0.0424329676,
-0.0454884619,
-0.0266186018,
0.0348900557,
-0.0050198436,
-0.0032064207,
-0.0212998763,
0.0161763243,
0.0292778462,
0.0296912547,
0.0288609117,
-0.0296642166,
-0.0156767759,
-0.0183834564,
-0.0283468105,
0.0814206824,
0.0226398148,
-0.0154989036,
0.0045101386,
0.0052479524,
0.0849639028,
0.0093199154,
-0.0413035452,
0.0636711642,
-0.0156036913,
-0.0547479875,
0.0415113121,
-0.0521000586,
0.0106229158,
0.0034463704,
0.0479162633,
0.0545400046,
-0.031231679,
0.0581916049,
-0.011503173,
-0.0122548761,
0.0630677491,
0.0156209068,
0.0068958164,
-0.0336329043,
-0.000302343,
-0.0476287603,
-0.0015237754,
0.0382933319,
0.0039088125,
0.0125207407,
0.0005611026,
-0.0157059003,
-0.0417536795,
0.0126200411,
-0.0311408713,
-0.0136548914,
-0.0391171724,
-0.0013214715,
0.0434145145,
0.0112384055,
-0.0488966741,
-0.0272302702,
0.0057567316,
-0.0764438659,
-0.0104899481,
-0.0529785901,
0.0151263513,
-0.0390643552,
0.0406875312,
0.0025854614,
-0.070692353,
0.0176883824,
0.0491645299,
-0.0058706999,
-0.0316619948,
-0.01031355,
0.0095396731,
-0.0041048001,
-0.020923797,
0.0131958323,
0.0304144099,
-0.0491587371,
0.0523151234,
-0.0282932576,
0.0457382984,
0.030667413,
0.0352945477,
0.0512887351,
0.0339396521,
-0.0434684679,
-0.0065092631,
-0.0025361672,
-0.0560941696,
-0.0334474929,
0.0090652751,
-0.0025867794,
-0.00947705,
0.0219850056,
-0.0990348011,
0.0154532772,
0.042331364,
-0.0154777542,
-0.0048586787,
0.0125856064,
0.0104534701,
-0.0518560782,
0.0142615754,
-0.0495885909,
0.0033951993,
0.0758652389,
0.0037994669,
0.0140525745,
0.0446313322,
0.0211140458,
0.0319583155,
0.0603478551,
0.0366657339,
-0.0097372606,
-0.0351366252,
0.0072876401,
0.0093243727,
0.0453290008,
0.0170492865,
0.02456313,
-0.0150654884,
0.0129985204,
0.0585631728,
-0.0431985185,
0.0056023644,
0.0046614716,
0.0627745166,
-0.0021821323,
-0.0027285446,
-0.0189002957,
0.0576132685,
-0.0270280112,
-0.0156488828,
0.0447448306,
-0.0243291073,
0.000097538,
-0.0129688513,
0.0329915173,
-0.016391037,
-0.0454187766,
-0.0049675247,
-0.0198303722,
-0.0234527085,
0.0747547448,
-0.0769283101,
0.0676636994,
-0.0183690842,
-0.0025651958,
0.0383421555,
0.0331106819,
0.0115907378,
0.0270401482,
0.0357196704,
0.0286808573,
0.0400278307,
0.0610370822,
-0.0218683854,
0.0193802509,
-0.0362340808,
0.0326066166,
-0.0137365749,
-0.0069728317,
-0.0266177934,
-0.0429172665,
-0.0544833057,
-0.0227134656,
-0.0405897833,
0.0094741276,
0.0195813309,
-0.0245968197,
-0.0055455919,
0.0026922144,
-0.0560303368,
-0.0074067046,
0.034125682,
0.0201951396,
0.0630879477,
0.0175110046,
-0.0438357741,
0.0130223371,
0.0167313386,
-0.001975395,
0.0116211465,
0.029437162,
-0.0152937565,
-0.0386229716,
-0.0194989629,
-0.0243222639,
-0.0202415828,
0.0249485672,
-0.0804367885,
0.0250945184,
0.0138789313,
-0.031163834,
-0.0335125178,
0.0437544063,
-0.044198852,
-0.0004588127,
-0.0417935885,
-0.0166277159,
-0.0448350124,
0.0167710129,
0.0009417896,
0.0211474337,
-0.021146372,
0.032916747,
-0.0127985245,
0.0075699077,
0.0152970385,
-0.0483809374,
-0.0207031053,
0.0089158174,
0.0121359518,
0.0427999757,
0.053795144,
-0.0005468394,
0.0029303574,
-0.0110339727,
-0.1209766641,
0.0246954504,
-0.0272342563,
-0.0144698443,
0.0233071204,
-0.0178065598,
0.0126431091,
-0.0032669478,
-0.0291542001,
0.0207992718,
0.0116753206,
-0.0070955129,
0.0455920659,
-0.0297413766,
0.0239689536,
-0.0255986731,
-0.0300782733,
-0.0304732192,
0.063343145,
0.0151027031,
-0.0359054357,
-0.0248624757,
0.0515473336,
-0.0054948786,
-0.0374521948,
-0.0476593859,
0.0339487568,
0.0009097483,
-0.0292789489,
0.0899352953,
0.0261066686,
0.0208359212,
0.0499836169,
0.0618027374,
-0.0018732772,
0.0015610238,
-0.0508038104,
-0.0376425348,
0.064660579,
-0.0171866026,
-0.0514393374,
-0.0001774714,
0.0211101491,
0.0316963345,
0.0142383119,
-0.0308823772,
-0.0241158307,
-0.040124245,
0.0350870602,
-0.0498068035,
-0.0046273568,
0.0348746702,
-0.0183468275,
-0.0409758799,
-0.0331954658,
0.0478752777,
0.0135690542,
0.034062352,
-0.0561324395,
-0.0240580738,
-0.0507807694,
0.0097570904,
0.0242394079,
0.0014916124,
-0.0100376513,
0.002441139,
0.0015044756,
0.0123441704,
0.0232134908,
0.0016286903,
-0.0200871341,
-0.0006884342,
0.0205742829,
0.0032429174,
0.0304027833,
0.0189384948,
-0.0202373341,
0.0198240355,
0.0385759622,
0.0565142781,
0.0039827684,
0.020015955,
0.011425999,
0.0091542201,
-0.0189079735,
-0.0246987902,
-0.0007853314,
-0.0136253033,
0.0789720938,
0.0719772503,
-0.0737503543,
-0.0262075681,
-0.0320582129,
0.0095064249,
0.0278998371,
0.0387648717,
0.0040589068,
-0.0458992086,
-0.004537371,
-0.0409198403,
-0.0514519624,
-0.0280392878,
-0.0342218876,
0.0300420914,
0.0183007773,
-0.0000499111,
0.080983378,
0.043876458,
-0.0442327894,
-0.0230499897,
-0.0028226266,
0.0074651223,
0.007849385,
-0.0291564409,
-0.0591081157,
0.023469789,
-0.0089021269,
0.0193899721,
0.0499214455,
-0.0172998421,
0.0107431086,
-0.0440921299,
0.0323735662,
0.0220541358,
-0.0116457511,
-0.0101507902,
-0.1068697274,
0.0081547862,
0.0053768824,
-0.0425196961,
-0.0124465479,
-0.0152217569,
-0.0041847304,
-0.0049187019,
-0.0444615744,
-0.0021336961,
0.0087964209,
-0.0277431905,
0.0036016994,
-0.017309336,
0.0326596312,
0.0249680337,
0.0415474214,
-0.0274336617,
0.0006145624,
-0.0575027354,
-0.0041212267,
0.0324520543,
-0.0096814996,
0.0331940874,
-0.0361683778,
0.0412493162,
-0.0348786525,
-0.0198460799,
0.0040542237,
0.0971233845,
-0.0331701376,
-0.0446969196,
-0.0347147025,
-0.0100400737,
-0.011576511,
0.0376125425,
0.0027760258,
-0.0251462553,
-0.0134156868,
-0.0084824655,
0.0334342532,
0.0162802394,
0.0244447961,
-0.0128949853,
0.0065789083,
-0.0244921278,
-0.0680063441,
-0.0468611643,
0.0176014323,
-0.0100082159,
-0.0112905493,
0.0251732934,
0.0255607367,
-0.0361882858,
-0.0535076149,
0.0280117299,
-0.0251683425,
-0.0180383977,
-0.0353543945,
-0.0305986907,
0.0539665073,
-0.0178785622,
0.0036494664,
-0.0039354451,
-0.0795841813,
-0.0379090533,
-0.0351297148,
-0.0340800695,
-0.0022676508,
0.0286077354,
-0.0564282797,
-0.0227580089,
0.0347288847,
0.0261871964,
-0.0796358362,
-0.0097478935,
0.0122455992,
-0.0071455222,
0.0011291439,
0.0157269444,
-0.0647920668,
0.0491589084,
-0.0176874902,
0.044184532,
-0.0471739508,
-0.0680289492,
-0.0171611123,
0.0142414803,
0.0647998825,
-0.0110383779,
-0.0093134027,
-0.103289336,
-0.0484285057,
-0.0258723292,
-0.0020707708,
-0.0152826793,
0.018680742,
0.0420940742,
0.0004596794,
-0.0347838774,
0.0126844505,
-0.0063845585,
0.0417178161,
0.0188206751,
0.013938983,
0.0093980348,
0.0285844933,
-0.0088360244,
0.0334816463,
-9.31e-7,
-0.0211181212,
-0.0367614888,
-0.0289737508,
-0.0173405949,
0.0542776585,
0.0045889192,
-0.0504298769,
-0.0330791213,
0.0203489512,
-0.0873615667,
0.0357417166,
-0.0206165593,
0.0594628006,
0.0436299592,
-0.0055166879,
0.0104888761,
-0.0498960093,
-0.0278976392,
-0.0572496541,
0.0985744148,
0.0198539831,
-0.0380442888,
0.0108796675,
0.0252450649,
-0.0305833668,
0.0527815372,
0.0422348194,
0.0325153917,
-0.0211433992,
0.0269633159,
-0.0455048047,
-0.0381641276,
0.0136194676,
0.0252088364,
0.0685138032,
-0.0324115083,
0.0220321119,
-0.0088191312,
0.0030943458,
0.0455372632,
-0.0260373391,
-0.0313856862,
0.0075239851,
0.0633817315,
0.0666377023,
-0.027735414,
0.0493054017,
-0.0894398913,
0.0466266982,
-0.0149462754,
-0.0610314645,
-0.0066308295,
-6.061380784e-33,
0.0027979061,
-0.0288605709,
-0.0320088677,
0.0568117872,
0.0071706916,
0.014584071,
-0.0475447476,
0.0031929191,
0.007558322,
0.0281320196,
0.0010117842,
0.0406784303,
-0.0198865645,
0.0038715773,
-0.0402368866,
0.0051138722,
0.0305652991,
-0.0180025492,
0.0039666845,
0.0694795176,
0.0613992251,
0.047444772,
0.0207421817,
-0.0300470162,
0.0216378644,
-0.0660639331,
0.0256516226,
-0.0258684848,
0.1108109429,
0.0289675239,
-0.0420583189,
0.0555416867,
0.0505565181,
0.0014443402,
0.0018586883,
0.0322321728,
-0.0666770861,
-0.0539786406,
-0.0397086442,
-0.0460991152,
-0.0037515101,
-0.0332709178,
0.0023633232,
0.0123871481,
0.0328237861,
-0.0141180772,
0.1042222306,
0.0095956856,
-0.0389946252,
-0.023950655,
-0.034915816,
0.0438850373,
-0.0107946461,
0.0078405952,
-0.0198009424,
-0.0254234206,
0.0028240676,
0.0639139563,
-0.0015431542,
0.0194807928,
-0.0133852419,
-0.0016352296,
-0.0097258138,
-0.0150431935,
0.007599534,
0.0429661237,
-0.0420077816,
0.0104329409,
-0.0024743804,
0.0390631966,
0.0436756238,
0.0434258953,
0.0100115119,
0.0201920886,
-0.0400153287,
-0.0023592494,
-0.0752407759,
0.0530935228,
0.0317636058,
0.000140313,
0.0293586478,
0.0475314669,
-0.0107417097,
-0.044013638,
-0.0035461083,
-0.0275628287,
-0.0029695889,
-0.0399228893,
0.0045558154,
0.0102942288,
-0.0206581727,
-0.01637608,
0.0347503871,
-0.06620913,
-0.0120776324,
0.0800482184,
-0.050107196,
0.0321850963,
-0.0048835366,
0.044355303,
-0.098737821,
-0.0452446602,
0.0050354046,
-0.0027887861,
-0.0251899585,
-0.0322418511,
-0.0111518446,
-0.0179013815,
-0.0074228537,
0.000509607,
0.0023934932,
-0.0739684328,
-0.0405569412,
0.0107716247,
-0.0053710188,
0.0276061036,
-0.0045783874,
0.0791425332,
0.0554484166,
0.050193835,
-0.0208359696,
-0.0596151501,
-0.0235325079,
0.0321426466,
-0.0165940672,
0.0075337193,
-0.0431300774,
0.0642515719,
0.0389433652,
-0.0564168543,
-0.0228799302,
-0.0226954836,
2.556e-7,
0.0783692598,
0.0411659442,
-0.0035418593,
-0.0295075085,
0.0258070678,
0.0118234828,
-0.0333958417,
0.0644656792,
-0.0287519954,
-0.0059258323,
0.044632189,
0.0669395328,
-0.0126764057,
0.0424728803,
-0.0608568005,
0.0658129752,
-0.0605373532,
-0.0185004063,
-0.0498666838,
0.0041700075,
-0.023494672,
0.062191613,
0.0260614771,
0.02330181,
-0.0560867824,
-0.0448038876,
0.0798974335,
-0.0325657167,
-0.058186274,
0.0524114221,
0.0348952971,
0.0109497691,
-0.0209515449,
-0.0542351343,
-0.0011367192,
0.036458876,
0.0462031625,
0.0353385806,
-0.0130878864,
0.0196946878,
0.0079101315,
-0.057638187,
0.00009419,
-0.0413829647,
0.0561154447,
-0.0328086019,
-0.0058852667,
-0.0417620502,
-0.0191330891,
0.0033699025,
0.0257362351,
-0.0217424221,
-0.0297489762,
0.014000047,
-0.0120098079,
-0.0234534759,
0.0236775279,
-0.0393524803,
0.0228018928,
0.0332496352,
-0.0171237495,
-0.0274065416,
-0.0212943312,
0.0177200325,
0.0432700701,
-0.0133816367,
0.0613730438,
1.889413396e-34,
0.0503214709,
-0.0181320328,
-0.0714066625,
-0.030735109,
0.0190375019,
-0.052731432,
-0.0757572725,
0.0090743257,
0.0196384192,
-0.0615510195,
0.0208761562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06638v1 | How Useful are Educational Questions Generated by Large Language Models? | 2023-04-13T16:05:25 | 2023-04-13T16:05:25 | Sabina Elkins, Ekaterina Kochmar, Jackie C. K. Cheung, Iulian Serban | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Controllable text generation (CTG) by large language models has a huge
potential to transform education for teachers and students alike. Specifically,
high quality and diverse question generation can dramatically reduce the load
on teachers and improve the quality of their educational content. Recent work
in this domain has made progress with generation, but fails to show that real
teachers judge the generated questions as sufficiently useful for the classroom
setting; or if instead the questions have errors and/or pedagogically unhelpful
content. We conduct a human evaluation with teachers to assess the quality and
usefulness of outputs from combining CTG and question taxonomies (Bloom's and a
difficulty taxonomy). The results demonstrate that the questions generated are
high quality and sufficiently useful, showing their promise for widespread use
in the classroom setting. | [
0.0286757089,
-0.0026884775,
-0.0280828495,
0.0351592079,
-0.057379283,
0.0009733401,
0.0489042997,
-0.0220099464,
0.0084229643,
-0.0533246435,
0.0219688173,
-0.0517251976,
-0.0413218401,
0.0307973754,
0.0344990939,
-0.0696948096,
0.0012930357,
-0.0133305239,
-0.0264306348,
0.019269079,
-0.0012710037,
0.011704226,
-0.0162243247,
0.0412953645,
-0.0086086085,
-0.0145053025,
-0.0518684983,
-0.0000813748,
0.0108018499,
-0.0088809608,
0.0181502979,
0.0547143854,
-0.023357695,
0.0225454755,
0.0000018663,
-0.0474506691,
-0.0319614038,
0.00754323,
-0.0123049384,
0.0300798696,
0.0642624348,
0.0665583834,
-0.0168482084,
0.020840371,
-0.0533812679,
0.0226919055,
0.0210863575,
-0.005299578,
0.0590380467,
0.0158899799,
0.011913321,
-0.0226376783,
0.0347109623,
-0.0003202731,
0.0610217191,
-0.0029732955,
-0.0068775397,
0.0388838612,
0.0822201073,
0.0367711261,
-0.0233699325,
0.014851111,
0.0325051174,
-0.0654137731,
0.0023444728,
0.0085232742,
-0.0003016098,
-0.0311951116,
0.0241930708,
0.0535481647,
0.0200455245,
0.0036620656,
0.0168655347,
-0.0232939906,
0.0366185755,
0.0674027726,
-0.0552248396,
0.0417974181,
0.0045064469,
-0.0150535339,
0.0156835876,
-0.011532926,
-0.0216039885,
0.0279348046,
-0.006616564,
-0.0154786156,
0.0239809249,
-0.0080992691,
-0.0309813414,
0.0319194421,
-0.0289342236,
-0.0759646371,
0.0088215806,
0.0445585623,
-0.0085333046,
0.0346791036,
-0.0385654308,
-0.0475883856,
0.0379726775,
-0.010635579,
-0.0188372899,
0.0377919413,
0.0164707992,
-0.0019579297,
0.0024162824,
0.0533138178,
-0.0058426457,
-0.0050060619,
-0.0511635989,
0.0291379392,
-0.0462627336,
-0.012744857,
-0.0516870804,
0.0516090728,
0.0124424649,
0.0077059623,
-0.0572345257,
0.0052428516,
-0.0154556818,
0.018711701,
-0.0226290263,
0.0014147338,
-0.0151704671,
-0.0041091768,
-0.0168248862,
0.0183073487,
-0.0428825505,
-0.0188476183,
0.0566377044,
-0.0551702119,
0.03228838,
0.0274038538,
0.0194071885,
0.0046072537,
-0.0062001026,
-0.0027495828,
-0.0296439752,
-0.0111602042,
-0.0114547638,
-0.0761925876,
0.0002311038,
-0.0056693885,
0.0128075164,
-0.0877500102,
0.000093013,
0.022209987,
-0.0080131916,
-0.015365229,
0.0194898155,
0.0403171964,
0.0327330455,
-0.0163644087,
0.0009691091,
-0.0013553048,
0.0755292475,
0.0207362995,
0.0285733975,
0.0450882092,
0.036960464,
0.0049891053,
0.0348851718,
-0.0378497764,
0.0285399519,
0.0043037408,
0.0202929527,
0.0233205464,
-0.0265663508,
0.0113074696,
0.0346254371,
0.0287116189,
-0.0393329561,
0.0780884475,
-0.0223897975,
0.0494187772,
0.0093117934,
0.0322580524,
-0.0084610144,
0.0302209407,
0.0807708055,
-0.004807076,
0.0169472303,
0.0566185862,
0.0069599333,
-0.0004240278,
-0.0196183082,
0.0096616624,
0.0400772132,
0.0095807174,
0.0108718155,
-0.0768224299,
-0.0044325353,
0.0174847338,
0.0224282481,
0.0308338255,
0.0401265249,
0.0070807673,
-0.0085550966,
0.0216250289,
-0.0064616874,
-0.0789526179,
0.0519199111,
-0.0775191635,
0.0550735109,
0.0162325855,
0.0700521022,
-0.0268284418,
-0.0613628328,
0.0147323888,
0.0398613811,
0.061293155,
0.0676658601,
-0.0096832504,
-0.0548114926,
-0.0357369222,
0.0032990773,
-0.0032294865,
-0.0008438222,
-0.0211114306,
0.0025957839,
0.0175255854,
0.033680167,
-0.0350510515,
-0.0750290528,
0.033280462,
-0.0658673719,
-0.0349160731,
-0.0158679709,
0.0026018687,
-0.0232278351,
0.0308491178,
-0.0131602008,
0.0502531528,
0.0266484134,
-0.0360954702,
-0.0218707323,
-0.0361466072,
-0.0472009145,
-0.0088814469,
0.0407390073,
-0.0488757007,
0.0078914547,
-0.0265530869,
-0.0209423844,
-0.0363847949,
0.024921611,
-0.0475707464,
0.0300806127,
-0.0147061478,
0.0222195778,
-0.0047085169,
-0.0461723879,
-0.0572113767,
0.0479664132,
0.0401648283,
0.0613140576,
-0.0136663737,
0.0234079547,
0.0400232784,
-0.0184142143,
-0.0050780824,
0.0361449234,
-0.0295830704,
0.0181255545,
0.0287236478,
0.0226337127,
-0.0786285326,
-0.0364381969,
-0.0371853262,
-0.0034656581,
-0.0098887589,
0.0250191186,
0.0349390395,
-0.0119001158,
-0.0050332439,
0.0249389037,
-0.1077491641,
-0.0160977282,
0.0505437329,
-0.0255352017,
0.0143861771,
0.0134948799,
0.0167008229,
-0.0327178203,
-0.0170133337,
-0.0118185049,
0.0356155559,
0.0934093371,
0.0605276078,
-0.044763688,
0.0523807071,
-0.056256175,
-0.0344117768,
0.0367091633,
-0.0299868379,
0.0270680077,
-0.0386878401,
0.0426656343,
0.0256328825,
0.0248004626,
0.0074546938,
0.0201519709,
-0.0149873365,
-0.031620495,
0.0046343198,
-0.0165465362,
-0.0228202585,
0.003152987,
-0.0723561868,
0.0098807821,
0.0323187113,
0.0195013732,
-0.0458870828,
-0.0251925867,
0.0651123449,
-0.0801008418,
0.0184283238,
-0.0819346234,
-0.0243420955,
0.0096457805,
0.0587475076,
0.0152992988,
-0.0324284881,
0.0611149073,
0.0010584492,
-0.0087929787,
-0.0838674679,
0.0360523537,
-0.0175271798,
0.0423320793,
0.00103059,
0.0371951498,
0.0412951261,
0.0051470427,
-0.0746288151,
0.040445067,
0.0235016774,
-0.0556312874,
0.0049286,
-0.06759049,
-0.0239750464,
-0.014840412,
-0.0146758873,
-0.0550566241,
-0.0076557985,
0.034102466,
-0.0124222683,
0.0614482388,
-0.006210227,
0.003417514,
-0.0266180951,
0.0387689918,
0.0061068051,
-0.0408221148,
-0.0190560389,
-0.0055623758,
0.0957025364,
0.0690643862,
0.0153592983,
0.0292174611,
-0.0361069776,
0.0501288958,
0.0684152395,
0.0206074379,
0.0076308986,
0.0354472362,
0.0055574146,
0.0366441607,
-0.0431905575,
-0.0213350896,
0.038794402,
0.0392582864,
-0.0758162439,
-0.0605595261,
0.0708532482,
0.0789998919,
-0.0134570235,
-0.0244884007,
-0.0487065352,
0.0368173681,
0.0057423282,
0.0472817533,
-0.0672472268,
0.030489713,
-0.0083086565,
0.0193733703,
-0.049441196,
-0.0277516674,
-0.0086070718,
-0.1392078251,
0.0365578346,
0.000911222,
-0.0429685265,
0.0242678933,
-0.0168931168,
-0.0311303176,
0.0584858283,
-0.0138607537,
0.0195059869,
-0.01077931,
0.0307711791,
0.065753527,
0.015401301,
-0.0534721352,
-0.024505645,
0.0087704463,
0.0200116113,
0.0542405397,
0.017665891,
-0.0213323031,
-0.0314580463,
0.034619309,
-0.0188169256,
-0.037867438,
0.02030701,
-0.0163394846,
0.041794464,
-0.0270083789,
-0.0536087863,
0.0521410927,
-0.0112913968,
0.0034197683,
0.0463709459,
0.0832166299,
0.0179711133,
-0.0139049841,
-0.0507479273,
0.018975893,
0.0120646534,
0.0599808358,
0.0631999224,
-0.0784513727,
0.034747608,
-0.0570111685,
0.0107125249,
-0.0661634356,
-0.0464503989,
0.0213774145,
-0.0103418818,
0.0228516217,
-0.0901972726,
-0.0424593762,
0.0680507869,
0.0256022047,
0.0010557892,
-0.0253929384,
0.0274484996,
-0.0052561611,
-0.0288021564,
-0.0022246675,
0.0027512154,
-0.0203121081,
-0.11587286,
-0.0358423553,
-0.019606445,
-0.036873702,
-0.0213213246,
0.0391722769,
-0.0619395748,
-0.0659849048,
0.0134421522,
0.0266233217,
0.0204249062,
-0.071707055,
0.0139639853,
-0.0286767334,
-0.0056709158,
0.0154100731,
0.0203824677,
-0.0080938227,
-0.0474503934,
0.0197456125,
0.0090231989,
0.0019534009,
-0.0314144492,
0.0300330631,
0.0162970796,
0.030101059,
-0.0122650499,
-0.008891684,
0.0327833071,
0.0484243706,
-0.0229830854,
-0.0520045571,
-0.0050472049,
-0.0088912481,
-0.0234767161,
-0.0590393469,
-0.0352046825,
-0.0390041955,
0.0082633132,
-0.004668409,
-0.0093884803,
0.0094343359,
0.0039526867,
-0.0261746813,
0.0500728376,
-0.0002121496,
0.0277977325,
-0.0344294831,
0.005205268,
0.0333809257,
-0.0051113926,
-0.0283566341,
-0.0344208814,
-0.0175137296,
0.0535176732,
-0.0001505622,
0.080865778,
0.0146018043,
0.0074056354,
0.0362592749,
-0.0029070601,
-0.0112450151,
-0.0628510267,
-0.0203465838,
0.0159473829,
-0.0167046525,
0.037043754,
-0.0165883265,
-0.0323901698,
-0.017735539,
-0.0057735974,
0.0190130621,
0.044712916,
-0.0541165769,
0.0300012287,
0.0082327221,
0.0153384618,
-0.0395100266,
0.0400439985,
0.005790045,
-0.0072767111,
0.0092007276,
0.0071484568,
-0.0321082473,
0.0028829749,
-0.0203513745,
0.0047249137,
0.0191303398,
0.0304698236,
-0.0687456727,
-0.0535386167,
-0.0086370008,
0.0427057035,
0.0260575525,
-0.0063790064,
0.0561901554,
0.0346472152,
-0.0323776044,
0.043513909,
-0.0396578237,
0.0665455014,
-0.0692626536,
-0.0464126989,
-0.0005299741,
-5.536349538e-33,
-0.0299260151,
-0.0759675205,
0.0109018311,
-0.0453789644,
-0.0004400617,
0.0009570627,
-0.0395468995,
0.0556037873,
0.013197043,
0.0274145175,
0.0077117183,
-0.007958943,
-0.0123128677,
0.0527498163,
0.0086831991,
-0.0166564919,
0.0189974234,
-0.0070247292,
-0.0206127595,
0.0582884625,
0.0310206953,
-0.024083402,
-0.0108594894,
-0.0053122183,
0.0577300861,
-0.0640155897,
0.0073169009,
-0.0181869846,
-0.0296089873,
0.0577465296,
-0.036120072,
0.0388457589,
0.0127431406,
-0.0303472839,
-0.0097484486,
0.0306301974,
0.0104067521,
-0.0432467535,
-0.0078723924,
-0.0442608222,
-0.0155106001,
-0.051145982,
0.0338037089,
0.0003163482,
0.0023588312,
0.0162806455,
0.0437653959,
-0.0017216725,
0.0081376424,
-0.0415442586,
-0.0724017695,
0.0095768869,
-0.0304300226,
-0.0101669384,
-0.0451878794,
0.0817774013,
-0.0032610537,
0.0174757596,
0.0161718875,
0.0420072079,
0.0764070451,
0.0288384575,
0.0226910058,
0.0023977221,
-0.0131537616,
0.0291837715,
0.0049098516,
0.0174942352,
-0.012177065,
0.0095971534,
0.0165172331,
0.0085963765,
0.1059259623,
0.0828238428,
0.0119259348,
0.0105892932,
-0.0640600696,
0.0392941795,
-0.0057983045,
-0.0525016151,
-0.0099906437,
-0.0569122992,
-0.0383165218,
-0.0231525321,
-0.0273457598,
0.0298805609,
-0.0172768198,
-0.0190630443,
0.0313728638,
-0.0536086485,
-0.0543369576,
-0.0260014981,
0.0133139333,
0.0049019023,
-0.0253709536,
-0.0253964141,
-0.0334835798,
0.0456469059,
-0.0352334641,
0.0241903905,
-0.0182929523,
0.0068216315,
0.0056522116,
-0.014735993,
-0.0022530209,
0.0458433814,
0.0004577476,
-0.000621624,
-0.0447482727,
0.0133082969,
-0.0415348299,
0.0466739051,
0.0229425896,
-0.004768657,
0.0111390082,
-0.0026884868,
0.0137667665,
0.0199588053,
0.0321266688,
-0.0378933698,
-0.032174021,
-0.006207264,
0.0179985519,
0.0040611355,
-0.0338310637,
-0.0126551921,
-0.0466093868,
0.0641118288,
0.0381160453,
-0.0412970297,
-0.0129204635,
-0.0362300426,
2.47e-7,
0.0568730533,
0.0265307892,
-0.0085842973,
0.0087839309,
0.0073054247,
0.0114195189,
0.0249069277,
-0.0400897525,
0.0299806762,
0.0215833355,
-0.0127608208,
-0.017422745,
0.0403756499,
0.0457243212,
-0.0677266046,
-0.0100113899,
-0.0184466317,
-0.0003263638,
-0.0337918587,
0.0176354721,
0.1017106101,
0.0114374794,
-0.0038265355,
0.0085150497,
-0.0090896711,
-0.0168058034,
0.0361697264,
-0.0074195196,
0.0056993398,
0.0473428257,
0.0198566299,
0.0042995643,
0.0186693892,
0.0081272982,
-0.0223482624,
-0.0231491141,
0.0090876119,
0.0130040022,
0.0453530625,
-0.0123245949,
0.0183268227,
-0.0266220812,
0.0118701234,
-0.1083039567,
0.0401512608,
-0.0392221361,
0.0203929581,
0.0456518717,
-0.0220294334,
-0.0410356447,
-0.009328289,
-0.0644508377,
-0.0214777011,
0.0208700225,
-0.0020101124,
-0.0258378368,
0.0448998287,
0.0026377351,
-0.0170686152,
-0.0064936434,
-0.0389085338,
-0.063095279,
-0.0670533702,
0.0052394918,
-0.0413351581,
-0.026237281,
-0.0069064745,
2.027329419e-34,
0.0340889618,
-0.0040297289,
0.0240152087,
-0.0140528958,
0.02527982,
0.0033593401,
-0.0083372593,
0.0095748622,
0.0252538119,
-0.0336658806,
-0.019671293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06634v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06634v2 | PGTask: Introducing the Task of Profile Generation from Dialogues | 2023-04-13T16:02:19 | 2023-08-26T05:55:48 | Rui Ribeiro, Joao P. Carvalho, Luísa Coheur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | Recent approaches have attempted to personalize dialogue systems by
leveraging profile information into models. However, this knowledge is scarce
and difficult to obtain, which makes the extraction/generation of profile
information from dialogues a fundamental asset. To surpass this limitation, we
introduce the Profile Generation Task (PGTask). We contribute with a new
dataset for this problem, comprising profile sentences aligned with related
utterances, extracted from a corpus of dialogues. Furthermore, using
state-of-the-art methods, we provide a benchmark for profile generation on this
novel dataset. Our experiments disclose the challenges of profile generation,
and we hope that this introduces a new research direction. | [
0.0649914443,
0.068927981,
-0.035259597,
0.0079782736,
-0.0303987004,
-0.023946967,
0.0319240801,
-0.0380535275,
0.0080701103,
-0.0001127077,
-0.0075155022,
-0.02333197,
-0.0160689522,
0.124609679,
0.020950377,
-0.0988928601,
0.0371290632,
0.002722505,
0.015311202,
0.0251258686,
0.0129735311,
0.0545841493,
-0.0288669672,
0.0505043045,
-0.036762014,
-0.0249840822,
-0.0380767435,
0.0169395041,
0.0573504046,
-0.0071623763,
0.06569653,
0.0292081703,
-0.0060079242,
0.0069240131,
0.0000018143,
-0.0121325869,
-0.0043893112,
-0.0336018577,
0.0071443217,
-0.0219133459,
0.0644709244,
0.0410359316,
-0.0098797781,
0.0278895535,
-0.0717678815,
0.0324789993,
0.0123218559,
0.0262059253,
0.0634510443,
0.059343271,
-0.0232543144,
-0.0518182255,
-0.018710874,
-0.0400741994,
0.0047317017,
-0.0378257819,
-0.0302867759,
-0.0334012955,
-0.0274477843,
-0.0313767195,
0.0060846629,
0.0071175345,
-0.018541012,
-0.0092057185,
0.0476818085,
0.0077222274,
-0.017961381,
-0.0124224275,
-0.0088359192,
0.1136878729,
0.0753072202,
0.0189131293,
0.0070580323,
-0.0323305316,
0.0341127515,
-0.0352664292,
0.0150502548,
0.0075626192,
-0.0278585032,
-0.0166528318,
-0.0262852404,
0.0635996088,
-0.0194798615,
-0.0134355174,
-0.0283215251,
0.0108516803,
-0.0025786317,
-0.0208572224,
-0.0194127932,
-0.0061881794,
-0.0084306877,
-0.0518787429,
-0.0051790494,
-0.0084741758,
-0.0584729239,
0.0128250346,
-0.0628981292,
0.0109446859,
0.0053702197,
0.0381489024,
0.0293401629,
0.0158496387,
0.0260386858,
-0.0191921201,
0.0095200632,
0.038121596,
0.0036302742,
-0.0544718392,
-0.0184732806,
0.0081947539,
-0.0888468549,
-0.0117820539,
-0.0568502098,
0.0337513834,
-0.0455035381,
-0.026690051,
-0.0589796454,
0.0493013188,
0.0185633618,
0.0272443295,
0.0035736298,
0.0522257537,
-0.049503576,
0.0099000977,
-0.0296149869,
-0.0007164801,
-0.0781356618,
-0.0237942208,
0.0524839945,
-0.0137567502,
0.0128598791,
0.0360896327,
0.0231782664,
-0.0296102185,
0.0058485465,
0.0565460734,
-0.0016821044,
-0.0529240482,
0.0297692511,
-0.0752318352,
-0.0216004662,
-0.0866152048,
-0.0838398933,
-0.0251741856,
0.0530993678,
-0.0050233942,
-0.0130383046,
-0.0514719337,
0.0129806101,
0.0157253612,
-0.001501979,
0.0440451428,
0.0138063896,
0.0301754419,
0.0093315542,
0.0085107917,
-0.0087855319,
0.014801776,
0.0300804731,
0.020282723,
0.0277894959,
0.0185505897,
-0.0079475371,
0.0401295647,
-0.0067572454,
-0.026668543,
0.030406015,
0.0294637438,
-0.0422500186,
0.0450384989,
0.0306320935,
0.0513949804,
-0.0369333513,
-0.0044065416,
0.0461627096,
0.0772036165,
-0.0097619286,
0.0432375818,
0.0741790682,
0.0576890744,
0.0089033777,
0.0260953177,
0.0094014229,
-0.0322668366,
0.0260773078,
0.0164706856,
0.0027908867,
0.0517770238,
-0.0272442009,
-0.0323317684,
0.0363395177,
-0.0169475339,
0.0398806036,
-0.0129885525,
-0.0057649459,
0.0284362622,
-0.0585070178,
0.061705526,
0.0032616237,
-0.0961900055,
-0.0516665578,
-0.002144505,
0.0080229845,
0.0859906599,
0.054657232,
0.0109236185,
-0.0437867865,
-0.0111045511,
-0.0531213246,
0.0365912169,
0.0442029499,
-0.0287451427,
0.034994185,
-0.0553734787,
-0.015862843,
-0.0410185419,
-0.0255750362,
0.0257312395,
0.032278534,
-0.000726527,
0.0406612046,
0.0147656593,
-0.0037539634,
-0.0045971693,
-0.0660368726,
-0.0292721689,
0.0548513159,
0.0160317011,
0.0116713876,
0.0453932732,
0.0200345051,
-0.0242999494,
0.0469149016,
-0.027424071,
0.0375274457,
0.0618821494,
-0.0343868211,
-0.0044962559,
0.0065296832,
-0.0573909208,
-0.0463417172,
-0.0126810018,
-0.0208566748,
-0.0639284924,
0.006964399,
-0.0356892981,
0.0070185144,
-0.0386478901,
-0.0204449259,
0.0281016286,
0.0352628045,
-0.028050527,
0.0659142509,
0.0348664634,
-0.0142825134,
0.0323753692,
0.0057856482,
0.007063413,
-0.0859486312,
0.0303314906,
-0.0468423963,
0.003475626,
-0.0169831309,
0.0081524039,
0.0098299244,
-0.0721567199,
-0.0335852504,
-0.1057914346,
0.0241957158,
0.0012783399,
0.0094729448,
0.0129782381,
0.052007243,
-0.0370427482,
-0.0324535258,
-0.0854845941,
-0.0230345912,
0.0362812206,
-0.0339025036,
0.0580326468,
0.0206187461,
-0.0120572522,
-0.0467121229,
0.0145060215,
0.0070361439,
0.0159427058,
-0.0112665845,
-0.041129414,
-0.0273594279,
0.0171305463,
-0.0470181219,
0.0165426321,
0.0007261952,
-0.0118113561,
0.0200149529,
0.0111763328,
0.0498345532,
-0.0019187437,
0.0551487915,
0.0254673194,
-0.0386248417,
-0.0009480324,
-0.0114883054,
0.0417498983,
-0.0502616316,
0.0270472988,
-0.0200432949,
-0.0597930104,
0.0315257087,
0.0176880471,
0.0084432978,
0.0228827801,
-0.0666521788,
0.0471859574,
0.0543063618,
-0.0028636046,
0.0215852987,
0.0223543551,
-0.0147955483,
0.0204335451,
0.0034942469,
0.0026332866,
0.0557529964,
-0.0080239531,
-0.0027643065,
-0.0320794918,
-0.0194857847,
-0.0430293307,
0.0551977418,
0.0203518551,
0.0359774306,
0.0152225029,
-0.0346882753,
-0.028972296,
-0.022288572,
0.0244303439,
-0.0200224612,
-0.0071860333,
-0.007028807,
-0.0030117133,
0.0322614238,
-0.0568633378,
-0.0694956779,
-0.0847250298,
-0.0349193253,
-0.0068394369,
0.0121451942,
-0.0555192605,
0.0025354011,
-0.0204613321,
-0.0282074045,
-0.0127018597,
-0.0220110957,
0.0084769335,
-0.04675759,
0.0426642261,
0.0515784509,
0.0273206178,
-0.0079295905,
-0.0216589458,
0.0353243947,
0.0432395712,
-0.0103885047,
0.033317972,
0.0150754927,
-0.012644154,
-0.0136449281,
-0.0219266098,
-0.0026179969,
0.0172234103,
0.0673411191,
-0.0030569334,
-0.0387432687,
0.0986370742,
0.0241501946,
-0.0225196313,
0.0056370818,
0.0124768149,
0.0577839352,
0.0024084903,
0.044562716,
-0.0577880591,
-0.0207446609,
-0.0285815448,
0.0580177382,
-0.0406892151,
-0.0322997086,
-0.0236620903,
-0.1031551883,
0.0308389422,
0.0144581748,
-0.0145685067,
-0.0262683313,
0.0082557332,
-0.0418264717,
-0.0105861984,
0.0373129658,
-0.0246459022,
-0.0236672219,
0.0114947977,
-0.0015007196,
-0.0171037577,
-0.0447206162,
0.017807927,
-0.0176550075,
0.0395601392,
0.0843841955,
0.0504385345,
0.0516912155,
-0.0195277762,
-0.0121423109,
0.0069372016,
0.008600492,
0.0216172207,
0.0701057464,
0.0004358571,
-0.0168266315,
-0.0352008343,
0.0572591051,
-0.0410519764,
-0.0160542503,
0.028884707,
-0.0186603628,
-0.0370087884,
0.0211601667,
-0.0029810234,
0.0588252768,
0.0432774387,
0.0873900801,
0.0232117418,
-0.0513413586,
-0.0246682391,
-0.022172641,
0.0234342813,
-0.1123698577,
-0.0342768952,
0.018124681,
0.0033328596,
0.0503387116,
-0.0536340177,
-0.0682795495,
0.0113152871,
0.0233869497,
-0.0149424914,
0.0234958846,
-0.0175320599,
-0.0177516714,
-0.0547696874,
0.0011356577,
-0.0164192896,
-0.0044126674,
-0.0565168597,
-0.0660849586,
0.0207045712,
-0.0647866577,
0.0047024735,
0.0203862805,
-0.0629353672,
-0.0541800484,
-0.0185041707,
0.0223096143,
0.0219208151,
0.0568321161,
-0.0164369922,
-0.0158807877,
0.0230724104,
0.0110308547,
0.0045964606,
-0.0142543986,
0.0044997935,
0.0372221693,
-0.0415499881,
0.0358888023,
0.0111706452,
-0.0157348514,
-0.0290164519,
0.0266404413,
-0.0512984619,
-0.0985011458,
0.000638605,
0.0217696931,
0.0164667647,
-0.0123135811,
-0.0375691727,
-0.0165438242,
0.0181209091,
-0.0414301008,
-0.0363199897,
-0.0225602072,
0.0007057225,
0.0159444381,
-0.0265849084,
0.0282954834,
-0.0182329454,
-0.0752714798,
0.0411937982,
-0.0678937212,
-0.0414328389,
-0.0122739645,
-0.011778391,
0.0272638947,
-0.018848436,
-0.0034378578,
0.0375555232,
0.0082551036,
0.0464220271,
-0.0070556407,
0.0386974923,
0.0091691967,
0.0069573247,
-0.0177464373,
0.0469070561,
-0.0378845818,
0.0117755942,
-0.0257968772,
0.0419508852,
-0.0163114481,
0.0233702678,
0.039629139,
-0.0207243655,
-0.0093250563,
-0.0060631912,
0.064359501,
0.0087719327,
-0.0202116091,
-0.0169995241,
-0.0039110095,
-0.0446664244,
-0.0015541922,
0.0679990947,
0.0206746515,
0.0144774737,
0.0159416106,
-0.0074201454,
-0.0794407129,
0.0244259425,
-0.0025828958,
0.041396182,
0.024429271,
-0.0055758338,
-0.0400257483,
-0.0395204313,
0.0488816537,
0.0211099349,
0.0038478367,
0.005185571,
0.0372542031,
0.023593083,
-0.0100372015,
-0.0043480908,
-0.045866318,
0.0327436067,
-0.0430126078,
-0.0236947052,
0.0029015536,
-5.788490505e-33,
-0.0589687005,
-0.0317929946,
0.0211371966,
0.0404176787,
-0.0478600822,
-0.0393716656,
-0.0092198802,
0.0116736097,
0.0160574336,
-0.0097233923,
-0.0245303996,
-0.000660909,
0.0129284272,
0.053478051,
-0.0076599605,
0.0077818879,
0.0589507483,
0.0216574334,
-0.0201963075,
0.061438188,
0.0368904434,
0.0319118388,
-0.0014455034,
-0.0581929721,
-0.0091477446,
-0.0470849909,
-0.0296599157,
0.0031237311,
-0.0021387464,
0.0740453526,
-0.0067805797,
0.0220878795,
0.0083474722,
0.0483394563,
-0.0207737535,
0.0441071056,
-0.0671888515,
-0.0124845784,
-0.0139247747,
0.0155440671,
0.002542478,
-0.0785802081,
-0.0201808419,
-0.0380622931,
0.0009724837,
0.0078446176,
0.0329976194,
-0.0318295583,
0.0083526503,
0.0148774181,
-0.0243041869,
0.0103374738,
-0.024871802,
-0.0342107452,
0.0278334413,
0.0635440797,
0.00496807,
-0.0257002469,
-0.0084655648,
0.0190743003,
-0.0225642473,
0.0038278878,
0.0136914039,
0.0303465743,
-0.0100944377,
0.0361924246,
0.0391552225,
0.0163581204,
-0.0123757012,
0.0147427274,
-0.0489849411,
0.0638800263,
-0.0342180766,
0.0626317114,
-0.0470933989,
-0.0078425985,
-0.0368330255,
0.0555851497,
0.0578879528,
-0.0253694896,
0.0080684042,
-0.0207952373,
-0.0137414187,
0.0030864461,
-0.011466871,
-0.0517580435,
-0.0089987693,
0.0041081263,
-0.0022460876,
0.0292275585,
-0.0441113263,
-0.0122387847,
-0.0105635263,
-0.0331665799,
0.01323599,
0.0090431133,
-0.0772766322,
-0.0036771218,
-0.0088114785,
0.0009563828,
-0.0193797518,
-0.03239806,
0.0353740156,
0.0125998696,
0.0382062346,
0.0174224656,
0.0265749842,
-0.0175679903,
-0.0311342217,
-0.0035479923,
-0.0138986446,
0.1003207192,
-0.0728513747,
0.0463213474,
-0.0084708985,
0.0373962,
-0.0437291376,
0.0572097823,
0.005539191,
0.0303776972,
-0.0222667325,
-0.0163406432,
0.0508698598,
0.0319559723,
0.001261475,
0.0281629767,
-0.0167890992,
0.026790116,
0.0595107861,
0.0023650371,
-0.0162178278,
-0.0057857987,
2.39e-7,
0.0010378577,
0.0116014574,
0.0597864762,
0.0251481812,
0.0080027487,
0.0644061267,
0.0269362982,
0.0468664058,
-0.0011886118,
-0.016368974,
0.0378653146,
0.0156570859,
0.066455245,
0.0077993269,
-0.0819201544,
-0.0307011064,
-0.0091342367,
-0.0162160862,
-0.0546336658,
0.0371918716,
0.0854668915,
0.0239051729,
0.0022577683,
-0.0159178954,
0.027446948,
0.0075342678,
0.0489266329,
-0.0025505787,
-0.0662233308,
0.0357686132,
0.0022960599,
-0.0113850525,
-0.0184870064,
0.0081507433,
-0.0085764695,
0.0283955727,
0.0059085437,
0.054038018,
0.027047703,
-0.0739088356,
-0.0076030912,
0.0415692814,
0.0031611568,
0.0390897654,
0.0322274268,
-0.0008752435,
-0.0094613628,
-0.0328899771,
-0.0168033969,
0.0147470552,
0.017874632,
-0.0253971908,
-0.0482597984,
0.0143508986,
0.0349243358,
-0.0203539692,
-0.0091997338,
-0.077854082,
0.0254925303,
0.0114566265,
-0.0573710687,
-0.0231390912,
-0.0125964088,
0.0043210797,
0.0064133876,
-0.027416829,
0.0152070289,
1.805358892e-34,
0.0075595155,
0.0469800457,
0.0138954259,
-0.0263819415,
0.0280895177,
-0.0462221801,
-0.0247030891,
0.0000146362,
0.0252313111,
-0.0824044421,
-0.015047715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03123v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03123v3 | ChatGPT Needs SPADE (Sustainability, PrivAcy, Digital divide, and Ethics) Evaluation: A Review | 2023-04-13T16:01:28 | 2024-03-27T16:03:32 | Sunder Ali Khowaja, Parus Khuwaja, Kapal Dev, Weizheng Wang, Lewis Nkenyereye | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT is another large language model (LLM) vastly available for the
consumers on their devices but due to its performance and ability to converse
effectively, it has gained a huge popularity amongst research as well as
industrial community. Recently, many studies have been published to show the
effectiveness, efficiency, integration, and sentiments of chatGPT and other
LLMs. In contrast, this study focuses on the important aspects that are mostly
overlooked, i.e. sustainability, privacy, digital divide, and ethics and
suggests that not only chatGPT but every subsequent entry in the category of
conversational bots should undergo Sustainability, PrivAcy, Digital divide, and
Ethics (SPADE) evaluation. This paper discusses in detail the issues and
concerns raised over chatGPT in line with aforementioned characteristics. We
also discuss the recent EU AI Act briefly in accordance with the SPADE
evaluation. We support our hypothesis by some preliminary data collection and
visualizations along with hypothesized facts. We also suggest mitigations and
recommendations for each of the concerns. Furthermore, we also suggest some
policies and recommendations for EU AI policy act concerning ethics, digital
divide, and sustainability. | [
0.0853037536,
0.0261576958,
-0.028348159,
-0.0020123846,
-0.08643087,
-0.0099770576,
0.052170936,
0.0096470583,
0.0906393528,
-0.035581965,
-0.0288693029,
0.0120675229,
-0.0129598714,
0.0646795183,
-0.0101838643,
-0.0103120189,
0.0467318408,
0.0150501598,
0.0334735997,
-0.0173059087,
0.0298764706,
0.0116684055,
0.0101742493,
0.0523515269,
-0.0225865263,
-0.0122579038,
-0.0132521736,
-0.0036577897,
0.0056862109,
0.0058395355,
0.0075500719,
0.0229685586,
0.0214273948,
0.0873844102,
0.0000022393,
-0.0645035282,
-0.0359768756,
0.0260583647,
-0.0375462137,
-0.0399487317,
0.0751772597,
0.0392739326,
-0.0337346718,
0.049276948,
-0.0485008657,
0.0391111486,
0.0680590421,
0.0459990241,
0.052193217,
0.0625860095,
-0.0262506418,
0.009008145,
0.0226538684,
0.0104988338,
-0.0267500281,
0.0133529464,
0.0101829544,
-0.0150614819,
-0.0308775473,
0.0235816017,
0.0155330189,
0.0538177937,
0.0287651569,
-0.0171598531,
-0.0168301985,
0.0119521488,
-0.0468770489,
-0.0854974762,
-0.0378731415,
0.0482345708,
0.047160212,
-0.0132432403,
0.0207773503,
0.0344222859,
0.0215194952,
-0.0399088487,
-0.0464853384,
0.0331859589,
-0.0147425681,
-0.0093329418,
0.000191531,
0.0158041976,
-0.0181680713,
0.03040809,
0.0298998803,
0.0299302619,
-0.0185107347,
-0.0427905433,
-0.0228857528,
-0.0042454698,
0.0217504483,
-0.0273530893,
0.027276339,
0.0229611322,
-0.0161146484,
0.005023493,
-0.0104566365,
0.0156217916,
0.0089110332,
-0.0487093888,
-0.0129166618,
0.0384723954,
0.0355774164,
0.0043383874,
0.0629348829,
0.0348981991,
-0.0023156481,
0.0611716807,
-0.0106033357,
0.0010089811,
-0.0408060215,
-0.0187364966,
-0.0260906052,
0.0205661077,
-0.046843268,
-0.0310230944,
-0.0226127282,
0.0271031018,
-0.016854411,
0.004853569,
0.0112177748,
0.001583448,
0.0240098741,
0.0006775106,
-0.0115080196,
-0.0101157064,
-0.033088211,
0.0033585185,
-0.0003593974,
-0.0733704343,
0.0484927185,
0.0110442834,
0.0056705144,
0.0034545974,
-0.0052618762,
0.1051930785,
0.0245243851,
-0.0426816791,
0.0217829384,
-0.0362242721,
0.0125135873,
-0.0842655674,
-0.0039199297,
-0.0294547658,
0.0428504199,
-0.0248494353,
-0.0170359761,
0.0023845911,
0.0160868261,
0.0181839149,
-0.0365980305,
0.0288269371,
-0.0614993162,
0.0155397309,
0.0139792506,
0.0327764116,
-0.0233564246,
0.0563322641,
0.0305649582,
0.0289126877,
0.056212455,
-0.0063742865,
0.009979587,
0.016040979,
-0.0219627712,
-0.0264397711,
0.0227383859,
-0.0030622226,
-0.0496295355,
-0.012155843,
-0.0218729563,
0.0813496187,
-0.0242294185,
0.015753651,
0.0901807174,
0.0651109293,
-0.0046496051,
0.0311137624,
-0.0272214413,
0.0548101589,
0.0164483264,
-0.0135702752,
-0.025717102,
-0.0060017724,
-0.0231031608,
-0.0441774949,
-0.0043201665,
0.0270080194,
0.0007915346,
-0.0435506031,
0.0298074372,
-0.0394541994,
0.0855397508,
0.0259957965,
-0.0027977601,
-0.0442145243,
-0.0176143683,
-0.0130776269,
0.0010458307,
-0.0707426295,
-0.0600209795,
-0.0743309036,
0.0438115895,
0.0721267536,
0.0310148597,
0.04684259,
-0.0030390024,
-0.0453989021,
-0.0730871409,
0.0348920189,
0.017510023,
-0.0044486118,
0.0049167662,
-0.027243128,
-0.0343396775,
-0.0048986403,
-0.0333372094,
-0.0155393519,
-0.0007630469,
0.0421970338,
0.0103525957,
-0.0162156262,
0.0322894007,
-0.0069613997,
0.0361286066,
0.0471605547,
-0.076851815,
0.0156514477,
0.01008741,
0.054556258,
-0.0148819434,
0.0021271969,
0.0209315307,
-0.0011526371,
-0.0218507573,
0.0390911885,
-0.0009416813,
0.0169116501,
0.0379585549,
-0.0559534803,
-0.0107069695,
0.0700403079,
0.0082695074,
-0.0214333311,
-0.0257414971,
-0.0394166708,
0.0732159317,
-0.0279618371,
0.0097580794,
-0.0717671588,
0.0160492957,
0.0081584845,
0.0160633717,
-0.0075602499,
-0.0010417985,
-0.0216233879,
0.0116446661,
0.0385276899,
-0.0043616612,
-0.0102075292,
0.0501469448,
-0.0367865711,
0.0449536406,
0.0666894168,
0.0571750142,
-0.070252575,
0.0148591101,
-0.1434484124,
0.0049252557,
0.0015593964,
0.0255284961,
0.0236942843,
-0.003694138,
-0.0137305595,
-0.0144198108,
-0.0533764586,
0.0148173561,
-0.0216071047,
0.0216072332,
0.0263616387,
-0.0359801948,
-0.0459100306,
-0.0061992817,
0.023884261,
0.0004218956,
-0.0216151755,
0.0341644473,
-0.0507993214,
-0.0046170359,
0.042517934,
-0.0368168317,
-0.0258276835,
-0.0079829935,
-0.0758324713,
0.0219610333,
0.028343359,
0.0107119437,
0.023872694,
0.053002689,
0.0385558605,
-0.0103748934,
0.0170440637,
-0.0510054156,
-0.0084958682,
0.0123758195,
0.0111311553,
-0.0251535065,
-0.0202639382,
0.0256245639,
0.0002965316,
-0.020369878,
0.0207200348,
-0.0385997258,
0.0393354371,
-0.0319493972,
-0.0558003299,
-0.0141077237,
0.0013131952,
-0.0496370792,
0.0421319976,
0.0242344737,
-0.0742053762,
0.0167749058,
-0.0165080894,
-0.0064537637,
-0.0280818585,
-0.0467362143,
-0.0072748824,
0.0660796985,
-0.0209136494,
0.0436222367,
0.0133032873,
-0.0387654267,
-0.011204497,
-0.0163999386,
0.0140426783,
-0.0388321243,
-0.0139696375,
-0.0081725083,
0.0018094515,
-0.0097177261,
-0.0483574271,
-0.0244023353,
-0.0416506156,
-0.032902699,
0.0229288656,
0.0307236984,
-0.0217577685,
-0.0402992181,
0.0268932525,
0.0341950096,
0.0050845607,
-0.0005152235,
-0.0086680623,
-0.0039027573,
-0.019155059,
0.0217016898,
0.0178885516,
0.0175056718,
0.03696879,
0.0446540974,
0.0721414313,
-0.0268901307,
-0.0121226572,
0.033212509,
-0.0256073084,
0.0161294378,
0.0155383423,
-0.0237741619,
0.0040421351,
0.060353253,
-0.039928332,
0.0282901097,
0.094896391,
0.0020433408,
-0.0454125889,
0.0026299101,
-0.0073848111,
-0.0226479471,
-0.0180864725,
0.0006333645,
-0.0737639219,
0.0078068739,
0.0245864373,
0.0181231722,
-0.0633829534,
-0.0109260594,
-0.018273741,
-0.0642423779,
0.047677625,
0.0043886011,
-0.0443785712,
-0.024882542,
-0.0233541429,
-0.0234474614,
0.006196822,
0.041969616,
-0.045713909,
0.0082529997,
-0.0108261527,
0.0058743879,
-0.0685697347,
0.0145962266,
0.0208349731,
-0.0415528379,
0.091287367,
0.0836802796,
0.0709226429,
-0.0109251477,
0.0019647628,
0.0034000746,
0.023295654,
-0.0157280136,
0.0020192079,
0.0202047825,
-0.0193860196,
0.0139691858,
-0.0578779541,
0.0034397996,
-0.0123191392,
-0.0076768002,
0.0271864962,
0.0127455713,
-0.0356193632,
-0.0333792008,
-0.0141109098,
0.0128649976,
0.0188196935,
0.0509048067,
-0.0062563103,
-0.0383976474,
-0.0421972573,
-0.0445848219,
-0.0067996653,
0.010162795,
-0.0102868471,
0.003720955,
-0.0090824775,
-0.1073989719,
-0.0553254746,
-0.0419144705,
-0.0234307852,
0.0303588118,
0.0085448558,
0.0136274621,
0.0411809571,
0.0509739667,
-0.0081835398,
-0.0112264976,
-0.0351762958,
0.0295635387,
-0.0542947724,
0.0265922043,
0.0276016649,
-0.0127690686,
0.0194060951,
-0.0076654288,
-0.0124719841,
-0.0401203781,
0.0161700994,
0.041821558,
0.027696915,
0.0333913527,
-0.0149312485,
-0.0027089692,
0.0075423378,
0.0623806939,
-0.0463808328,
0.000331546,
0.0745740235,
0.060350582,
-0.0008203494,
0.0252317246,
-0.0153883267,
0.0005152262,
-0.0295844618,
0.0245477501,
-0.0172270834,
-0.0264315754,
0.0344916247,
0.0694916621,
0.002183886,
-0.002789357,
0.0374385379,
-0.0173895806,
-0.0326569676,
-0.0129205482,
0.0016923273,
-0.0577927195,
-0.0220115092,
-0.0179807395,
0.0135983648,
0.0273391046,
0.0262178965,
-0.0624070689,
-0.043377921,
-0.0160605647,
0.0513434149,
-0.0276116338,
0.0342119411,
-0.009564722,
0.0084297396,
-0.030194601,
0.0199120566,
0.0135625815,
-0.0043991017,
-0.0048528267,
0.0416502245,
0.000282541,
-0.0491211787,
0.0265802164,
0.0924151391,
-0.039830666,
-0.08613462,
0.0250429995,
0.0786286965,
0.0195342693,
0.0693259388,
0.0212218221,
-0.0341085568,
0.0043875817,
-0.0116559463,
0.020671133,
-0.018949341,
-0.0437129885,
-0.018834997,
-0.0139467865,
-0.0672524124,
-0.0083673084,
0.0152539127,
-0.0351412669,
0.0153125608,
-0.0118061043,
-0.0190205425,
-0.0374712832,
-0.0229846686,
0.0146474661,
-0.0191055834,
0.0128548751,
-0.0078787301,
-0.0436185785,
-0.0692260787,
-0.037111748,
0.0028686812,
0.0016865908,
-0.0335075893,
0.0531906337,
0.0494551733,
-0.0121734543,
-0.0207472555,
-0.0591457039,
0.0033262493,
-0.048733145,
0.0065632705,
-0.0094454298,
-6.513935089e-33,
0.0274361465,
-0.0283877235,
0.0144323679,
0.0167920627,
-0.0612743832,
-0.0126143787,
-0.0170842241,
0.0208671335,
-0.0478102639,
0.0030538891,
-0.0398521386,
0.0117222946,
0.0231148824,
-0.0061032269,
-0.0233217943,
-0.037138585,
0.0347749218,
-0.0043081781,
0.0026194842,
0.0408415943,
0.0182063803,
0.0159487519,
0.0387200974,
-0.0765784979,
0.0515141673,
-0.0080218455,
-0.0450677574,
0.0062866001,
-0.0062898542,
0.0324457213,
0.0103158001,
0.0619366802,
0.0258825086,
-0.0087699778,
-0.0011844356,
0.0987175927,
-0.0372330137,
-0.028925186,
0.0131088654,
0.0282153711,
-0.0213361178,
-0.039016623,
-0.0022883585,
-0.0527550541,
-0.0491372049,
0.0358124822,
-0.0085688056,
-0.0088083157,
-0.0293695927,
-0.0145112155,
-0.0551458523,
-0.0213930886,
-0.0398758762,
-0.032994628,
0.0071963021,
0.0717628151,
0.0209970586,
-0.0083207581,
-0.0595501214,
0.0539891683,
-0.0412351079,
-0.0837189183,
0.0387173817,
-0.0415240116,
0.0466852225,
0.0486170985,
0.0061530918,
0.0171744246,
-0.0203381814,
-0.0436099656,
0.014136808,
0.0287611205,
0.0187185425,
0.0101615265,
-0.0399224013,
-0.0633213893,
-0.0237960946,
0.0225429591,
0.0948365629,
0.0220696535,
0.0068230983,
-0.0067213643,
-0.0702386871,
-0.0174212512,
0.0014082671,
-0.0215170793,
-0.0184968635,
-0.0437770225,
0.0371745043,
-0.0280078035,
-0.0198243409,
-0.0870969445,
0.0300103277,
-0.0944329724,
0.0098091811,
0.0076080854,
0.0157182757,
0.0149517329,
0.0165702701,
0.0261994731,
-0.0283565912,
-0.043054875,
0.0050138035,
0.0220365059,
0.0198711269,
-0.0046665934,
-0.0010739581,
0.0219364427,
-0.0253441799,
-0.0148964263,
-0.0091533354,
0.0475721397,
0.0139905494,
-0.0329546444,
0.0046521001,
-0.0218543261,
-0.0146781839,
0.036375273,
0.0272024237,
0.0362503082,
-0.0530978963,
0.0292300899,
-0.030175684,
0.0070637041,
-0.0113384491,
0.0071968497,
-0.0692194626,
0.0118180234,
0.0203801095,
-0.0156699158,
-0.0347820111,
-0.0333155394,
2.972e-7,
-0.0284689944,
-0.0007832461,
-0.0151495524,
0.0036157677,
0.0081215976,
0.0885526612,
0.0469781272,
0.0643046051,
-0.0235302709,
0.0164643973,
0.0092920791,
-0.0207443368,
0.0682986975,
0.0128638996,
-0.0589495413,
-0.0285890382,
-0.0614645667,
-0.0405003838,
-0.0412988067,
0.06571123,
0.0528373607,
0.0506749116,
0.0082575222,
-0.0144887445,
-0.011581501,
-0.0043208045,
0.0069728163,
-0.0729475394,
-0.0103988005,
-0.0066892388,
0.013035072,
0.0251358189,
0.0273094699,
-0.0142678199,
0.0329456665,
0.0204655156,
0.0088753644,
0.0753025338,
0.0160542876,
-0.0068493509,
0.0201012176,
-0.0567455515,
0.0166371521,
-0.0695830658,
0.0624593645,
-0.0180171244,
-0.0742143765,
-0.0680606067,
0.0325956009,
-0.0321218036,
0.0527023897,
-0.0241122451,
-0.0326584727,
0.0156804435,
0.0011494441,
-0.040822003,
0.0273606274,
-0.0303674098,
0.0496443212,
-0.063569963,
-0.0094664143,
-0.0837667361,
-0.0203066636,
0.0268233567,
0.0186784845,
0.0110751409,
0.0480628461,
2.22020095e-34,
0.0052192877,
-0.0306344833,
0.0172144212,
0.0425697602,
0.0497426614,
0.071098052,
0.0697226673,
-0.0074871085,
0.0130489115,
-0.0077824192,
-0.0055679255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06623v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06623v3 | Exploring the State of the Art in Legal QA Systems | 2023-04-13T15:48:01 | 2023-09-15T10:19:53 | Abdelrahman Abdallah, Bhawna Piryani, Adam Jatowt | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering questions related to the legal domain is a complex task, primarily
due to the intricate nature and diverse range of legal document systems.
Providing an accurate answer to a legal query typically necessitates
specialized knowledge in the relevant domain, which makes this task all the
more challenging, even for human experts. Question answering (QA) systems are
designed to generate answers to questions asked in human languages. QA uses
natural language processing to understand questions and search through
information to find relevant answers. QA has various practical applications,
including customer service, education, research, and cross-lingual
communication. However, QA faces challenges such as improving natural language
understanding and handling complex and ambiguous questions. Answering questions
related to the legal domain is a complex task, primarily due to the intricate
nature and diverse range of legal document systems. Providing an accurate
answer to a legal query typically necessitates specialized knowledge in the
relevant domain, which makes this task all the more challenging, even for human
experts. At this time, there is a lack of surveys that discuss legal question
answering. To address this problem, we provide a comprehensive survey that
reviews 14 benchmark datasets for question-answering in the legal field as well
as presents a comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art Legal Question
Answering deep learning models. We cover the different architectures and
techniques used in these studies and the performance and limitations of these
models. Moreover, we have established a public GitHub repository where we
regularly upload the most recent articles, open data, and source code. The
repository is available at:
\url{https://github.com/abdoelsayed2016/Legal-Question-Answering-Review}. | [
0.0751886517,
0.030830875,
0.0002758706,
0.036290653,
-0.0528718606,
0.0170354899,
0.0138771469,
0.0020981336,
-0.0026307912,
-0.0620055459,
-0.0342491046,
-0.0251475461,
-0.043267455,
0.0045996034,
-0.008689981,
-0.0146710714,
0.0419759303,
0.0207580514,
0.0431383997,
-0.0174774025,
0.0228514988,
0.0427423976,
0.0142472703,
0.0151110496,
-0.0308136474,
-0.0212827828,
-0.0048796125,
-0.0069305529,
0.0121642807,
0.0231056958,
0.0325336121,
0.0658408552,
0.0173434783,
0.0255263411,
0.000001566,
-0.0540569462,
0.0265546907,
-0.0030791033,
-0.0431774445,
0.0111713037,
0.0025745195,
-0.0306664594,
-0.0139595661,
0.0227899328,
-0.0488790385,
0.0135205388,
-0.0116392458,
0.0212501269,
0.0426966473,
0.0642932579,
0.0144966748,
-0.0537988022,
0.0738739297,
-0.0437861159,
0.0030891907,
-0.0715512335,
0.025368169,
0.0050495407,
0.0267584976,
-0.0165728554,
0.0187899861,
0.0076185488,
0.0642968789,
-0.0260579381,
-0.0506881215,
-0.0195438471,
-0.0359955356,
0.0193284974,
-0.013823824,
0.0957893878,
0.0314923152,
-0.0117114494,
-0.0091741672,
-0.0069273361,
0.0284779016,
-0.0013393201,
-0.0269805193,
0.0772334859,
0.0102386009,
0.002720254,
-0.0048563806,
0.0198991746,
-0.0122918496,
0.0443390906,
0.0086084539,
0.0542099364,
-0.0003080403,
-0.0383739695,
0.0306602139,
-0.0001891159,
-0.0028667455,
-0.0534300357,
0.0402358025,
0.0693486035,
-0.014362691,
0.0256659463,
-0.0292624272,
-0.0609112196,
0.0940673798,
-0.0516783856,
-0.0073233917,
-0.0001044768,
-0.0183672756,
0.0892686769,
-0.033691138,
0.0324669033,
-0.0058041704,
0.0195841826,
-0.0146944961,
-0.0750191286,
-0.0065473034,
-0.0344746634,
-0.0574426651,
0.0521503314,
-0.0850509778,
0.0019997039,
-0.0065608579,
0.0165332202,
-0.0101678623,
0.0109318662,
-0.0114888148,
0.0499828719,
-0.0151508097,
-0.0282823909,
-0.0504053272,
-0.0148506397,
-0.0908896178,
0.0450924449,
0.0010580494,
-0.0406163186,
0.014624049,
0.0035415748,
0.0164742097,
-0.0117958169,
0.0133053903,
0.0702114254,
-0.0084114522,
-0.028817324,
-0.0080326935,
-0.0602580309,
0.0072712619,
-0.0731608942,
-0.0368561745,
-0.0597729795,
0.0295964275,
-0.0241703726,
-0.0582617037,
-0.0438378751,
0.0087630851,
0.0845758319,
-0.0099904258,
0.072935313,
-0.0036884132,
-0.0145125855,
0.0094728637,
0.0295885913,
0.0511230193,
0.0144202588,
0.0322360508,
0.0087768752,
0.0373680107,
0.0083704507,
0.0216328409,
0.0239777397,
0.0139236636,
0.0106813638,
0.023355566,
0.0646763742,
-0.0380670391,
0.047304824,
0.0218789633,
0.0520245656,
0.016365502,
-0.0760098249,
-0.0120711392,
0.0713415667,
-0.0180715322,
0.0563068576,
0.0078938361,
0.0219978876,
0.0470835604,
-0.0288983844,
-0.0586037226,
0.0413371958,
-0.0132007943,
-0.0008907526,
-0.0592411272,
0.0059720813,
-0.0538508445,
-0.0449455045,
0.0084337583,
-0.0028905401,
-0.004630507,
0.0157472771,
0.0312700383,
0.0182085074,
-0.036761377,
0.0252182018,
-0.0011086699,
-0.0323072411,
-0.0233104546,
-0.0208241493,
0.040743757,
0.0244814474,
0.0330841579,
-0.0598139316,
-0.0409099646,
-0.0261444002,
0.0123564452,
0.0570896231,
0.0426003523,
-0.0100805741,
0.0214748289,
-0.0270660575,
-0.0344599076,
-0.0339701138,
-0.0047205254,
0.0164170768,
-0.0028392854,
0.0331746303,
0.0392768458,
-0.0719958618,
0.0264301952,
0.0363575965,
-0.0092922859,
-0.043922741,
0.0345542133,
0.0101169916,
0.0146018732,
0.0390572175,
0.0117196525,
-0.0126732076,
0.0502991378,
-0.0001005672,
-0.0019470638,
-0.0091013061,
0.0071007144,
-0.0276591387,
0.036612533,
-0.0442126095,
-0.0246545114,
0.0481763147,
-0.0687053576,
-0.0364466496,
-0.0217881035,
-0.0327740982,
-0.0394571759,
-0.0680971071,
-0.0687965229,
0.0184769258,
0.0017351661,
-0.0214932207,
0.0423380807,
-0.0023239064,
-0.0202048812,
0.0080588022,
0.01886723,
0.0564045385,
-0.03488639,
-0.0081908442,
-0.0445940569,
-0.0529884957,
0.0147655578,
0.0094815623,
0.029965058,
-0.0487441421,
-0.0010325079,
-0.0529052019,
0.0156485811,
-0.0354870558,
0.0219595823,
0.005721299,
-0.0208248794,
-0.0029829845,
-0.0510009862,
-0.0787734166,
-0.0024953363,
0.0432180166,
-0.008724832,
0.0252159536,
-0.0014328341,
0.0002235884,
-0.0331369899,
-0.029866254,
-0.0217893645,
0.0210833997,
0.0080511896,
0.0018917208,
-0.0013254145,
0.0102444375,
-0.0258035939,
0.0092142848,
-0.0147948414,
-0.0055985861,
-0.023468703,
0.0398290232,
-0.0337501578,
0.029759137,
0.0292882901,
0.0041426681,
-0.0118605066,
0.0357395001,
-0.0645145178,
0.0303009935,
0.002483472,
0.012337774,
-0.0206574406,
-0.0211608596,
0.0141864168,
0.0185277294,
-0.0099000987,
-0.0084654205,
-0.0080904225,
0.0343136378,
0.0252759289,
-0.0285868309,
-0.0334754102,
0.0017987094,
-0.0120878108,
0.0327798203,
0.0017408894,
-0.0328829661,
0.0472341105,
0.0279367436,
0.0244343318,
-0.0558054522,
0.0024773723,
-0.0644681007,
0.0661913902,
-0.0058043525,
0.0176386256,
-0.0242909063,
-0.0531391762,
0.0072457297,
-0.0063198744,
0.0167511385,
-0.0489496663,
0.0597022548,
-0.0005559087,
0.0424824543,
-0.0406937599,
-0.0421821959,
-0.0493493229,
-0.0460197069,
-0.0153418547,
0.0527234487,
-0.0203911569,
0.0255684815,
0.003520045,
-0.0217175893,
-0.0099074906,
0.0073780618,
0.013526924,
-0.0158371925,
-0.0446298346,
0.0850854591,
0.0398318954,
0.0495654643,
0.0386461206,
0.027786348,
0.0007508754,
0.0265334547,
0.0090086898,
0.0096241068,
0.0188747961,
0.0049896059,
-0.0038786014,
-0.0570169874,
0.003182584,
0.0191740785,
0.0224957261,
-0.072022453,
0.009853472,
0.075321354,
0.0490621664,
-0.0056868098,
-0.007263402,
-0.0226455834,
-0.0133688701,
0.028890254,
0.053832639,
-0.115789108,
-0.0253461078,
-0.0251415484,
-0.0069895028,
-0.0204556901,
-0.013973143,
-0.0160565227,
-0.0918657184,
0.0733654052,
-0.0410429165,
-0.0325985253,
-0.0307089444,
-0.016306527,
0.0063570873,
0.0053911759,
0.0548157543,
-0.0154768191,
-0.026340887,
-0.0184792466,
0.0117381923,
-0.0367392264,
0.0180396475,
0.0634598285,
-0.0550382696,
0.0354771912,
0.0546164289,
0.0375298858,
-0.027739957,
-0.016894659,
-0.0116174659,
-0.0295269266,
-0.0126255006,
0.0168463793,
0.0322812162,
0.0157827828,
-0.0012311939,
-0.0424539708,
0.0496666133,
-0.0584349521,
-0.0037042303,
0.0281453822,
0.0557532348,
-0.0255275443,
0.0044359108,
-0.0569506735,
0.0121875908,
-0.0243897233,
0.0752884522,
0.0131314592,
0.0005197948,
-0.0817641839,
-0.0256864112,
-0.0059690415,
-0.0740367845,
-0.0096510611,
-0.0125867752,
0.0259605162,
0.0340772904,
-0.0520373583,
-0.0770884082,
0.0133156208,
0.0064356159,
-0.0135051934,
0.0233802106,
0.0231430177,
-0.0120149618,
-0.0567822307,
0.0210023448,
-0.0566201471,
0.0157365985,
-0.015779607,
0.0208587088,
-0.008363585,
-0.0038162305,
-0.0297832973,
-0.0168894269,
-0.040024858,
0.0077205701,
-0.0247648358,
0.0115652429,
0.0066534607,
-0.0092837913,
-0.0714281052,
-0.0689516738,
0.0151112005,
0.0329357944,
-0.0222590789,
-0.0209135767,
0.0481712744,
-0.0092910426,
-0.0414411426,
0.0398795567,
-0.0392471589,
0.016204834,
0.0231416747,
0.025763439,
-0.0212693904,
-0.0267790649,
0.0273976699,
0.025294112,
-0.0197628215,
0.0425476171,
-0.0071846279,
-0.0079529174,
0.0041964082,
-0.0183269531,
-0.013543712,
-0.0311647207,
0.006946044,
0.0236296542,
-0.0345888026,
-0.0313721001,
0.0579051524,
-0.0131029626,
0.0177314412,
-0.0399807766,
0.0187603999,
0.0536621176,
-0.0103948899,
-0.0293412004,
-0.0224311631,
-0.003467117,
0.0328008384,
0.0013715791,
0.0847695544,
0.0053890226,
0.0375195332,
0.0028632008,
-0.0126141189,
-0.005698944,
0.0147935646,
-0.0434807092,
-0.0468680896,
-0.0308489446,
0.0545081459,
0.0385943651,
-0.0065548532,
-0.0216114633,
0.0003015167,
-0.0072960672,
0.0078854179,
-0.0089421347,
0.0044842013,
-0.0233570524,
0.0753354803,
0.0185839161,
-0.0011053402,
0.0521077104,
0.0432772972,
0.0197590757,
0.0358615033,
0.0006182654,
-0.0082057025,
-0.028899068,
-0.0026757764,
-0.0096999006,
0.0314808637,
-0.031612549,
0.004061488,
-0.0544059612,
-0.0274991915,
-0.0019925144,
-0.0078560831,
-0.0023661472,
0.029159192,
0.0348963737,
0.0582062788,
0.0539775714,
-0.0514189452,
-0.0141947297,
0.0374980681,
-0.0345268957,
-0.0320312418,
-0.0151435975,
-5.412380067e-33,
-0.0183737166,
-0.0376457609,
0.012221016,
-0.0127282776,
-0.0014799774,
-0.0125513906,
-0.0135764014,
-0.0419266596,
-0.0607044175,
0.0307076406,
-0.0394645073,
0.0324044563,
0.0165182184,
0.017865967,
-0.0117911408,
-0.0644828752,
-0.0141228298,
-0.0271596946,
0.0136913424,
0.0479221717,
-0.0133401304,
0.0230195913,
0.029205963,
-0.0468126275,
0.0186586305,
0.0257665757,
-0.0089519061,
0.0186339505,
-0.083763741,
0.0733821169,
-0.0249693096,
0.053309612,
0.0433169529,
-0.0403681807,
0.0055715498,
0.0723386109,
-0.1153145507,
-0.0042436975,
-0.0000672838,
-0.0006651467,
-0.0474713184,
-0.023798408,
0.0373040438,
0.001456849,
0.0240033772,
0.0027390716,
0.0474300757,
-0.0179726314,
-0.0070693567,
-0.0728986785,
-0.072372511,
0.0223364662,
-0.0374975428,
-0.0108055854,
-0.0111386748,
0.0469752736,
-0.001622709,
0.051044628,
-0.0681934506,
-0.0457481518,
-0.0040361397,
-0.0176439118,
0.0352746621,
-0.0700160563,
-0.0375609994,
0.0156199969,
0.0052328985,
-0.0165344905,
-0.0492987633,
-0.0009994654,
0.0099464431,
0.0731929913,
0.0636590496,
0.0649574548,
0.034538921,
0.0176848937,
-0.0764553398,
0.0111282682,
0.0296598319,
0.04205231,
-0.0043275538,
-0.0468635596,
-0.0329393558,
0.0135063156,
-0.0491114035,
-0.0008289732,
-0.0156682264,
0.007283512,
0.0502933003,
0.002647293,
0.0179479383,
-0.0238283686,
-0.0031484282,
-0.0731067657,
0.0162588824,
0.0471763238,
-0.0043150014,
0.008756632,
0.0217201374,
0.082481429,
-0.0580283627,
0.0378080755,
0.0166382324,
-0.0489405617,
-0.0187683869,
-0.013168904,
0.0474046096,
-0.0343840159,
-0.05584291,
0.0142565286,
0.0243927129,
0.0551132634,
-0.0142752789,
0.0513093397,
-0.0051291855,
0.0442252345,
0.0236504525,
0.0488106944,
0.0177895259,
-0.0007477686,
-0.0368287377,
-0.0306926426,
-0.0088125486,
0.0019624694,
-0.013998053,
0.0314834751,
-0.0245624743,
0.0460624248,
-0.0018380595,
-0.0107134245,
0.0135070207,
0.0701239631,
2.095e-7,
0.0999034643,
0.005983321,
0.0231570378,
0.0304905735,
-0.0121544329,
0.0254075769,
0.0478774421,
0.0728290454,
0.0238059759,
-0.0284694377,
-0.0002820475,
0.0233513527,
0.0354423337,
0.029916171,
-0.0542378314,
0.0050334781,
-0.0708970129,
-0.031534262,
-0.0455584042,
0.0146795418,
0.0374565087,
0.1002369374,
-0.0095736999,
-0.040496666,
-0.0118651846,
-0.0237028375,
0.0442569777,
0.0024847926,
-0.0054412475,
-0.0024905077,
0.0777519643,
-0.0243089274,
0.0249855965,
0.0243563224,
-0.0092200218,
0.0679635704,
-0.0170937832,
0.0436149202,
0.0008394246,
-0.0130955307,
-0.0191884153,
-0.0516680256,
0.0511787236,
-0.0366504341,
0.0910614058,
-0.0320604853,
0.0014359555,
-0.0259824879,
-0.0276404154,
-0.0239871647,
0.0269410796,
-0.0145456446,
-0.0163402632,
-0.0312079005,
0.0489014685,
-0.0556942299,
0.0230751261,
-0.0845416635,
0.0328974649,
0.0333947092,
-0.0274233371,
0.0493500419,
-0.0144724241,
-0.0080479905,
0.0455331467,
-0.0521385781,
0.0016396024,
1.460260957e-34,
0.0305301268,
-0.0038314294,
0.0146244839,
0.0400318988,
0.0045390632,
0.030387884,
-0.0313871056,
-0.0216611158,
0.0018900718,
-0.0782510191,
0.0248061325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06588v1 | ChatGPT-4 Outperforms Experts and Crowd Workers in Annotating Political Twitter Messages with Zero-Shot Learning | 2023-04-13T14:51:40 | 2023-04-13T14:51:40 | Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | This paper assesses the accuracy, reliability and bias of the Large Language
Model (LLM) ChatGPT-4 on the text analysis task of classifying the political
affiliation of a Twitter poster based on the content of a tweet. The LLM is
compared to manual annotation by both expert classifiers and crowd workers,
generally considered the gold standard for such tasks. We use Twitter messages
from United States politicians during the 2020 election, providing a ground
truth against which to measure accuracy. The paper finds that ChatGPT-4 has
achieves higher accuracy, higher reliability, and equal or lower bias than the
human classifiers. The LLM is able to correctly annotate messages that require
reasoning on the basis of contextual knowledge, and inferences around the
author's intentions - traditionally seen as uniquely human abilities. These
findings suggest that LLM will have substantial impact on the use of textual
data in the social sciences, by enabling interpretive research at a scale. | [
0.0211218502,
0.0547566824,
0.0229881462,
0.0072143595,
-0.0221044514,
0.0384644866,
0.0055957702,
-0.0072414516,
0.0352249928,
-0.0744933635,
0.0390122607,
-0.0278986096,
-0.0142313428,
-0.0058752378,
0.0035970432,
-0.0493486933,
0.022978425,
0.0330571383,
0.0721661076,
-0.0264454149,
0.0214781668,
0.0156285595,
-0.0001569321,
0.0505956188,
-0.0343818963,
0.0046740393,
-0.0207236465,
-0.0006424904,
0.049473621,
0.0027857104,
0.0020499243,
0.0677002519,
0.0216787718,
0.0904648975,
0.0000016691,
-0.0121560805,
-0.0204144605,
0.0095876316,
-0.0048763584,
-0.0358285122,
0.0750876665,
-0.0119430637,
-0.005210042,
0.0283212978,
-0.0389964879,
0.010165629,
0.0700608641,
0.0197031796,
0.0651135221,
0.0774715692,
-0.0126011688,
-0.0151559729,
0.0137820886,
-0.0199258849,
0.0489026979,
-0.0689799637,
0.0530964322,
-0.0297116525,
-0.0407381505,
0.0690484717,
0.0163378306,
0.0320348144,
0.0028950842,
0.0034232992,
-0.0125304265,
0.0142586557,
-0.046847377,
-0.0137509918,
0.0100231785,
0.0438610278,
0.0235689208,
-0.0281196106,
0.0228870809,
-0.0011853614,
-0.0026576982,
0.0377679132,
-0.0376947112,
0.0222538561,
-0.0097147338,
0.0204520654,
-0.0020430202,
0.0088866409,
0.0197899044,
0.0590525195,
-0.0008850402,
0.0324942544,
-0.0356078409,
-0.0217766613,
0.0097161913,
0.0476903506,
-0.0044913725,
-0.0352784991,
-0.004112687,
-0.0034274524,
0.0013768389,
0.0090069212,
-0.0225015413,
-0.012765591,
0.0255250279,
-0.0697361752,
-0.015052598,
0.0081142979,
0.0036658011,
0.0879544541,
0.0405074097,
-0.0247340146,
-0.0091221398,
0.0066120955,
0.037663646,
-0.0338583067,
-0.0861753523,
-0.0050063701,
-0.0027010252,
-0.0125492821,
0.000823883,
0.0030285427,
-0.0345412455,
0.0011839925,
-0.0074598552,
0.0157986712,
-0.0346028656,
-0.0088020302,
-0.0225385483,
-0.0306744836,
-0.0372804105,
0.062874198,
-0.0106699439,
0.0306809563,
-0.0409532227,
-0.0231610686,
0.0124225328,
0.0478270613,
0.0285231918,
-0.0163601432,
-0.0052818251,
0.0298467446,
0.0244931262,
-0.0058008269,
-0.0040777125,
-0.0064066057,
-0.0115229338,
-0.072525017,
-0.0047575478,
-0.0616207793,
0.028858589,
0.0199046116,
-0.0015284986,
-0.020766912,
0.0172815211,
0.0486775488,
-0.0415684059,
0.068572171,
-0.0239723492,
0.0117269987,
0.0259071365,
0.0232837293,
-0.0114250267,
0.1014884859,
0.0206772685,
0.0730861276,
0.0264858063,
-0.0149470987,
0.0379365683,
0.0410714746,
-0.0018758578,
0.0174528193,
0.0007034402,
0.0090899114,
-0.0275522191,
-0.0131789343,
-0.0088495649,
0.0407483615,
-0.020916719,
0.0069637201,
0.0658430681,
0.0724800155,
-0.0132240113,
0.0178736839,
0.0046872795,
0.0589182563,
0.017109327,
-0.0392999277,
-0.0315659344,
0.0160429999,
-0.0409360267,
-0.0422300175,
0.0308841541,
0.0062300335,
-0.0194654986,
-0.0004213993,
-0.0139460014,
-0.0086884126,
0.0196992178,
-0.0044358335,
0.0399505645,
-0.0640908331,
-0.0250410233,
-0.0089050755,
0.0417700857,
-0.0465104654,
-0.0056007747,
-0.0446214676,
0.0066644792,
0.0425720736,
-0.0123699233,
-0.0281145424,
-0.0070356978,
-0.0579616539,
0.059399832,
0.0716562942,
0.0259477403,
-0.031388741,
-0.0408710353,
-0.023738727,
-0.0289592464,
0.0221908297,
0.0226958729,
0.0510023572,
0.0332870446,
0.0162844397,
0.0147241652,
0.0079074083,
-0.0247279983,
0.0043169432,
0.002523198,
-0.0220108517,
0.004552287,
0.0175689254,
0.0104389917,
0.0533176139,
-0.0174495131,
-0.0458046086,
0.0039186468,
-0.0049474481,
-0.038150318,
-0.0163921509,
-0.0192686003,
-0.0048896503,
0.0249594897,
-0.0350051895,
-0.0674539357,
0.014433899,
-0.0482235141,
-0.0075619728,
0.0459087603,
-0.0089801298,
-0.0030714963,
-0.051715605,
-0.0436354019,
-0.0566215403,
-0.0072719106,
-0.0389401056,
0.0890722349,
0.017016381,
-0.0306991022,
-0.0068350444,
-0.0465722121,
0.0327796973,
-0.0165869072,
-0.0446082242,
-0.0189748183,
0.0273456611,
0.0604822263,
0.027543189,
-0.0205309354,
-0.0514930636,
-0.0467099994,
-0.1002495587,
0.0053120106,
-0.034621533,
0.037235368,
0.0237846971,
-0.0009418661,
0.0075809131,
0.0110289967,
-0.0250561163,
0.0004780593,
-0.0281046145,
0.0121193016,
0.0357940011,
-0.0154722389,
0.0090471497,
-0.0068491651,
0.0208774079,
-0.0422040857,
0.0116479574,
0.0549202785,
-0.0549961589,
0.0123249348,
0.0057167388,
-0.0108372336,
-0.0083941463,
-0.023889659,
-0.0265730117,
0.020448491,
-0.0211180281,
-0.0152570531,
0.04439307,
0.0094536701,
0.0518588498,
-0.0166115109,
0.0303480048,
-0.0527895764,
-0.0140311299,
-0.0282992739,
0.0028769721,
-0.0301134661,
-0.0027231569,
-0.0272845365,
0.0786812231,
-0.0063254735,
0.0027428009,
-0.0581294112,
0.0478627905,
-0.0238344949,
-0.0019471566,
-0.050515186,
0.0263547041,
-0.0154043948,
-0.0013995647,
-0.0161371324,
-0.0192796029,
0.0171504319,
0.0097104721,
0.0439835116,
-0.0025345841,
-0.0334115103,
-0.0334049761,
0.0604040362,
0.0011990773,
-0.0053302478,
-0.001476783,
0.0144051863,
0.0055908272,
-0.0157680139,
0.0148271983,
-0.0374746248,
0.0089064566,
-0.0070732324,
0.032476563,
-0.0329995044,
-0.0224800128,
-0.0258821752,
-0.099741064,
-0.0733776018,
0.0026034571,
-0.0032343166,
-0.0569534861,
-0.0166746024,
0.0092717698,
0.0452182479,
-0.031030111,
-0.0130876359,
-0.0167360492,
-0.0002669498,
0.0260753948,
0.0026747943,
-0.012606157,
-0.0331757702,
-0.0108128581,
-0.0118987132,
0.0486846268,
-0.0199099742,
0.0516641624,
-0.0452619232,
-0.0686373636,
-0.0107961996,
-0.0043359459,
-0.0332791135,
-0.0358337387,
0.0532113463,
-0.019758461,
0.0528905652,
0.1102349609,
0.0294853449,
-0.0565825365,
-0.0273700841,
0.0114083104,
-0.0138948765,
0.0115301963,
0.0038195187,
-0.1307578236,
-0.0254076999,
-0.0063059325,
0.0091683632,
-0.0152366748,
-0.0493900627,
0.0003948237,
-0.0815026164,
0.0255444683,
-0.0098508261,
-0.0399935469,
0.0214907434,
-0.0737694055,
0.0413860269,
-0.0734307989,
-0.0236836784,
-0.0279138945,
0.0124712139,
0.0184253808,
0.0311775394,
-0.0515902825,
-0.0765911341,
0.0288886409,
-0.0285518151,
0.0629430562,
0.0336576886,
0.0675479025,
-0.0128452806,
0.0088802306,
0.0332269445,
0.012796496,
-0.0039871247,
-0.0045966338,
0.0920753032,
-0.0525113977,
0.0046224473,
-0.0170414019,
0.0373429246,
-0.0221760962,
0.0013802644,
-0.0064243521,
0.061194215,
0.0062957355,
-0.0042420132,
0.0046123946,
0.0131950546,
0.0425306,
0.0817868784,
0.0220171958,
-0.0502463616,
-0.0448571406,
-0.0625676662,
-0.0104626147,
-0.0465686433,
-0.0578761846,
-0.0005088628,
-0.0292019732,
-0.0565637313,
-0.0033682517,
-0.043279238,
0.0582563132,
0.017286431,
-0.034647882,
0.0090145506,
0.0268788934,
0.0125454636,
-0.0161107462,
0.0270225927,
-0.0588897727,
0.0311215185,
0.0082676653,
-0.0565820746,
0.0006917481,
-0.0068496601,
-0.0157267284,
-0.0012173164,
-0.0959001556,
-0.0495070592,
0.0203797799,
-0.015265814,
0.0262685623,
0.0222259741,
-0.0286445469,
-0.0666058958,
0.0273006428,
0.1157497987,
-0.0325067341,
-0.0171888266,
0.0265178606,
0.0905820504,
0.0059600258,
0.0287607275,
-0.0038635661,
0.0365204997,
0.0373817049,
-0.0514108241,
-0.0850905031,
0.0293588713,
-0.0128808562,
0.0111596268,
0.0546685793,
-0.0032293114,
-0.0681369677,
-0.0189131834,
-0.0628088415,
-0.0166607387,
-0.0426552445,
-0.0045755217,
-0.0279152784,
0.0278950315,
-0.0395660736,
-0.04613005,
0.0003577313,
-0.0067014433,
0.0323909447,
-0.0556211434,
0.0310644452,
0.0165658426,
0.0366660655,
0.0280033052,
-0.0100108394,
-0.0158691984,
-0.0091357464,
0.0246934984,
0.0214840379,
0.0024153278,
0.0117487665,
0.0091382125,
-0.0013951352,
0.0474339128,
-0.0135557866,
-0.0570692532,
-0.0456642359,
0.0032235971,
0.0768049955,
0.0258349292,
0.0074284882,
0.0350364819,
-0.010719764,
-0.0294060037,
0.0046700309,
0.0155937048,
0.0011600885,
-0.0149128977,
0.0015536897,
0.0000027778,
-0.0610266514,
0.0344364941,
0.062910229,
0.0098209968,
0.0178766754,
0.0353599973,
-0.0363963172,
-0.0266934726,
0.0211558491,
0.0059999786,
0.0040349215,
0.0187106729,
0.0113706253,
-0.0577299967,
-0.0417503379,
0.038286861,
-0.0134042315,
0.0059400885,
0.0435986295,
-0.0248766765,
0.0482093021,
-0.0254114568,
0.0395599455,
-0.0533034131,
0.015668517,
-0.009211421,
-0.0298111755,
0.0067030182,
-6.439956821e-33,
-0.0010281561,
-0.0527494401,
0.0019227441,
-0.0134115098,
0.0136587089,
0.0219214074,
-0.006911241,
0.0282010008,
-0.0039482554,
0.0250675194,
0.0068135513,
0.0299718734,
0.0193393286,
0.0337016322,
0.0198998246,
-0.0227397233,
0.0031355349,
-0.0088206166,
-0.0106260153,
0.0347106867,
0.0425966121,
-0.0198545586,
0.0390585661,
-0.0909190774,
0.0381880924,
-0.0086873611,
-0.0264285393,
-0.0015023133,
0.028947074,
0.0020977776,
-0.0373360328,
0.0214894321,
0.060839504,
-0.0125843007,
0.0190147776,
0.0808907151,
-0.032838542,
-0.0197375342,
-0.021563394,
-0.0011503641,
-0.0169445183,
-0.0144081572,
0.0074361418,
-0.0089134835,
-0.0421593226,
-0.016767608,
0.047824055,
0.0094487332,
0.0289775804,
-0.0007238758,
-0.0266381465,
0.062929377,
-0.0295423381,
-0.0051477402,
0.0003105486,
0.0259302892,
0.0479200669,
0.0552083179,
-0.0819293931,
0.0324972421,
-0.0360742211,
-0.0295162853,
0.007231636,
-0.0128720012,
-0.0008854296,
0.0676530227,
0.0369305164,
0.0369817391,
-0.0776783004,
-0.0258886795,
0.0050425045,
-0.0014786661,
0.0364167467,
0.0935887992,
0.0366429351,
-0.0347049981,
-0.0822012722,
0.0107460525,
0.0714995563,
-0.0064932778,
0.0303715263,
-0.0209453069,
-0.0261961203,
-0.0194141939,
-0.010934676,
-0.0741149411,
-0.0413813405,
-0.0225400031,
-0.0300688706,
0.0183436982,
-0.0062442939,
0.0395526439,
0.0436750427,
-0.0534547307,
-0.0133220181,
0.0341377407,
-0.0323721804,
0.0412015133,
-0.007184552,
0.0134419855,
-0.0671639293,
-0.0176420808,
-0.0089213764,
0.0429744907,
0.0204944443,
-0.0126171745,
0.0732369274,
0.0222442634,
-0.0546092764,
-0.0216564536,
-0.0258054864,
0.0080105411,
-0.0226334874,
0.0006258143,
0.0336601473,
0.0212004893,
0.027358003,
0.0339960456,
0.030038327,
0.0323351361,
0.0421855561,
-0.0254492462,
-0.0469308943,
-0.0528962426,
-0.0103026554,
-0.0109795816,
-0.0044092308,
-0.0135655496,
-0.0083000902,
-0.0416650139,
0.0056509334,
-0.034211535,
2.505e-7,
0.0551288761,
0.0981538594,
-0.0274754073,
-0.0258166473,
0.0147277825,
0.0422218591,
0.0138059799,
0.0210660864,
-0.0375897363,
-0.0174042452,
0.0046914238,
0.0388525426,
0.052082736,
0.0308285728,
-0.0940138176,
-0.0123818079,
-0.0557176284,
0.0160175171,
-0.0477192923,
0.0522480607,
0.0394286886,
0.0528491922,
0.0612855703,
-0.0186488852,
-0.0084160985,
-0.0406395569,
0.068773821,
-0.0244224537,
-0.0450737327,
0.0254487321,
0.0330399685,
-0.006393292,
0.0183005072,
0.0307687335,
-0.0005452521,
0.0011512544,
0.0015519968,
0.059750732,
-0.0148727037,
0.0166633315,
-0.0128261866,
-0.0308152679,
0.0210703611,
-0.0197787806,
0.0859130472,
-0.0639682114,
-0.0729423165,
-0.059156727,
-0.0164791867,
-0.0215086881,
0.0514998361,
0.0249386355,
-0.0099461982,
-0.0094247032,
-0.0028840513,
-0.0320450924,
-0.0307516772,
-0.0552167706,
0.012573516,
-0.0261715744,
-0.0432230607,
-0.0618111566,
0.0212804377,
-0.0112178773,
0.0766294971,
-0.0363388695,
0.0439709798,
1.731910584e-34,
0.0385507718,
0.000217685,
-0.0115443217,
-0.0218607914,
0.0496772043,
0.0505538285,
0.0105102742,
-0.0165757108,
0.0226887129,
-0.0594833829,
0.017602928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06556v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06556v2 | Are LLMs All You Need for Task-Oriented Dialogue? | 2023-04-13T14:03:14 | 2023-08-03T15:31:50 | Vojtěch Hudeček, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instructions-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) gained recently huge
popularity thanks to their ability to interact with users through conversation.
In this work we aim to evaluate their ability to complete multi-turn tasks and
interact with external databases in the context of established task-oriented
dialogue benchmarks. We show that for explicit belief state tracking, LLMs
underperform compared to specialized task-specific models. Nevertheless, they
show ability to guide the dialogue to successful ending if given correct slot
values. Furthermore this ability improves with access to true belief state
distribution or in-domain examples. | [
0.0206085667,
0.0563331805,
0.0221779086,
0.0466108769,
-0.0222200397,
0.0014960614,
-0.0249292608,
-0.0422606915,
0.0299220588,
-0.024560295,
-0.0496411212,
-0.0838369951,
-0.0101120472,
0.0338058881,
0.0225954838,
-0.0264159273,
0.031693656,
-0.062984623,
-0.0000888982,
-0.0122993924,
-0.0134372255,
-0.0118078487,
-0.0379425064,
0.0408977456,
0.0213044286,
-0.0070893555,
-0.0457728617,
0.0249300785,
0.0014587864,
0.0025580754,
-0.0127368672,
0.0096723409,
0.0342366509,
0.03844909,
0.0000018043,
-0.0346448459,
0.0120209344,
-0.019460937,
-0.0759123638,
0.0118722199,
-0.0262272265,
0.0019869478,
-0.0319461934,
0.0238594096,
-0.0162311532,
-0.0202927534,
0.0507645421,
0.0868677422,
0.067452468,
0.102592662,
0.0059109442,
-0.0180286523,
0.0411851965,
-0.0420850851,
0.0116810454,
-0.0891686976,
0.0405011252,
0.0192612894,
0.0004765661,
0.0307220016,
-0.0012491642,
0.0163138602,
0.0118537601,
-0.0357480459,
-0.0656016245,
0.0047905752,
-0.0130940136,
-0.0165259074,
-0.0445221402,
0.0718534961,
0.0275429673,
0.0195860732,
0.0171512831,
0.0058935746,
-0.0093147811,
-0.0064367093,
-0.0386685915,
0.0169311706,
-0.0261024665,
0.0125672929,
0.0030054396,
0.002779142,
0.0231766347,
0.0079093855,
-0.0614264905,
0.099060379,
0.0043037841,
-0.0356150307,
0.0092168385,
-0.0283418037,
-0.0249613542,
-0.0634225532,
-0.008059429,
0.0188743565,
-0.0696449429,
0.0321328565,
-0.0445043743,
0.0672745034,
-0.0269320905,
-0.0416599028,
0.0244162846,
0.0590492338,
0.0047930824,
0.0717881918,
0.0365992188,
0.0483079292,
-0.0341386385,
-0.0271921325,
0.0022772653,
-0.0119990529,
-0.042106986,
0.0316301435,
-0.0317010954,
-0.0003566233,
-0.0393107124,
-0.0500929505,
-0.0244280472,
0.0789613873,
0.0002154654,
0.0668841824,
0.032787066,
-0.0057941591,
-0.030306831,
-0.0185096078,
-0.048399508,
0.0438868627,
0.0246075019,
-0.000665936,
0.0199206118,
-0.0511253551,
-0.0201092698,
0.0306933131,
-0.01339522,
-0.0303446837,
-0.0093442537,
0.0536744706,
0.0015366579,
-0.0194108561,
-0.0104368217,
-0.0088469032,
-0.0236790832,
-0.1051703021,
-0.020677099,
-0.0099295201,
0.045523081,
-0.0010845488,
0.001508438,
-0.0344869234,
0.0212281384,
0.0215838552,
-0.0250372589,
0.0592940003,
0.0213280935,
0.0165524893,
-0.0031429799,
-0.0010832509,
-0.0224707946,
0.0523453802,
0.0284679271,
0.0371887088,
0.0183904935,
-0.0096973348,
0.0171867311,
0.0436176062,
-0.0102983592,
0.0178459249,
0.0135338893,
0.0473353378,
0.0164496489,
0.0280307233,
0.0104748132,
0.0721104369,
-0.0236096755,
0.0061130342,
0.082610108,
0.0165501963,
0.0091869151,
-0.0292222779,
0.0355130285,
0.0345267393,
0.0108540319,
0.0201356709,
-0.0683800951,
0.0135789402,
-0.0095316702,
0.0130405277,
0.06086291,
0.0122907832,
-0.0372258872,
-0.0155804195,
0.010401465,
0.0002922641,
0.0030493292,
0.034749046,
0.0611795858,
-0.0352355093,
-0.0842610896,
0.0124933338,
-0.0064170724,
-0.0170445144,
-0.047795292,
-0.0369501077,
-0.0023120663,
0.0845318064,
0.0385055691,
-0.008051021,
-0.0633388832,
-0.0194783621,
0.0159805398,
0.0416482054,
0.0332277939,
-0.0057615433,
0.0347230099,
-0.044831302,
-0.0130801322,
0.0030081801,
-0.0036257487,
0.0242445245,
-0.0015602658,
-0.021455206,
0.0098738372,
0.0036245009,
0.0317149311,
-0.0082010971,
0.0109753516,
0.0068760812,
-0.014539253,
0.0041519655,
0.0542139895,
0.015384322,
-0.0167000219,
-0.008141771,
0.0411514975,
0.0126784919,
0.0171056092,
0.0143691413,
-0.0448932983,
-0.0432569832,
0.019071009,
0.0118166758,
-0.0187074821,
-0.0131965671,
-0.0187867135,
-0.0655363947,
-0.0130672464,
-0.0416326672,
0.0395348594,
-0.0292916149,
0.0493205041,
0.0380014367,
-0.0066744648,
-0.0162561126,
0.0262549706,
-0.0123058353,
0.0050542704,
0.0485109948,
-0.0076643983,
0.0020737676,
-0.0893327594,
-0.0033236295,
0.0181269236,
0.0192819461,
-0.0141035262,
0.0164319575,
-0.0166568011,
-0.0263727084,
-0.0425038338,
-0.1056654975,
0.0076697171,
-0.0266087595,
0.0205536243,
-0.0078511033,
0.0207480676,
-0.0183270164,
-0.0062706755,
-0.0319531448,
-0.0253020264,
0.0301833097,
0.0007907515,
-0.0063236728,
0.0316496193,
-0.0488807708,
-0.0439404175,
0.0189017523,
0.0057166698,
-0.0040326309,
-0.0110790394,
-0.0469986722,
-0.0780024678,
0.038028799,
-0.0138126742,
0.0518446602,
-0.0522785299,
-0.0305192899,
0.0065387897,
0.0008436552,
0.0712898225,
0.0534562208,
-0.0137976529,
-0.010221649,
0.013207417,
-0.0474906079,
-0.0387629494,
0.0528712124,
-0.0161377657,
0.0106925825,
-0.074052155,
-0.0161461197,
0.0244251993,
0.0469724797,
0.0144635681,
0.0204605404,
-0.0540678985,
-0.0228911303,
0.0292859357,
-0.0307458639,
0.0091290781,
-0.0064063384,
-0.0336196609,
0.0314291902,
-0.0245189555,
-0.0282797683,
0.0692780912,
-0.0573712736,
-0.0236065071,
0.005959013,
-0.0160939731,
-0.0163290408,
0.0373536162,
0.0165478345,
-0.0041437135,
0.020556353,
-0.0153514687,
-0.0080824634,
0.0215544533,
-0.0076547149,
-0.0218847077,
0.0590535626,
-0.0724084973,
0.0238715094,
-0.0068717441,
-0.0390924029,
-0.0319813043,
-0.0337917097,
-0.0199902002,
-0.0046496536,
0.0565093756,
-0.0538502671,
-0.0341112092,
0.0293984562,
0.0445376374,
0.025444869,
-0.0014387992,
-0.0003635255,
-0.0309930164,
-0.0102378456,
0.0524393693,
0.0144955646,
-0.0113283172,
-0.0415680185,
0.0535613559,
0.0380338579,
0.0598498434,
-0.0230481196,
-0.0003985318,
-0.0312344953,
0.0502464473,
-0.0084251566,
-0.0290321,
0.027976308,
0.0765657648,
-0.0187440794,
-0.0025339662,
0.1231937855,
0.0045678634,
-0.0390150286,
-0.020453807,
0.0066043562,
-0.0058520255,
0.0092478553,
0.0318937451,
-0.0965742841,
-0.027885532,
0.0224514939,
-0.0022937108,
0.0150777698,
-0.0381812528,
-0.0324141271,
-0.0939115584,
0.0307023097,
-0.0111687258,
0.0269077793,
-0.0387062281,
-0.0150446547,
0.0368626304,
-0.0069328155,
0.0269519594,
0.022953948,
0.0025713677,
-0.0420152508,
0.0070434432,
-0.0084964149,
-0.0124029042,
0.0259702578,
-0.0111746779,
0.0837099105,
0.0644031242,
0.0102419723,
0.0241671726,
-0.007894394,
-0.0141490223,
0.0204477534,
-0.0162866358,
0.0041424464,
0.005608303,
-0.0229357965,
-0.0093700998,
-0.0078883134,
0.025334511,
-0.0139706433,
0.0100251799,
0.0262545198,
0.0431044288,
-0.0860337391,
0.0099124536,
0.0185200982,
-0.0074610244,
0.0373741165,
0.0905358717,
0.0124977892,
-0.0620888472,
-0.0319012403,
-0.0426837876,
-0.034466587,
-0.0350101963,
0.0095241535,
-0.0190917477,
0.0027301444,
0.0118436422,
-0.0369478203,
-0.0341836028,
0.026574539,
0.0610639006,
-0.0170328356,
-0.0092602735,
0.0430213138,
0.0012662676,
0.002310046,
-0.0176376719,
-0.0448266007,
0.0251328964,
-0.1052169204,
-0.0159427971,
0.0486931466,
-0.0212926473,
0.0067395158,
0.0195247233,
-0.0838085487,
-0.0710335448,
-0.0067454535,
0.0494120009,
0.0209544487,
0.0379287079,
-0.0072047454,
-0.0370671973,
-0.0430071577,
-0.0469153076,
-0.0370038636,
0.025622813,
0.0432563387,
0.085798949,
-0.0058694864,
0.0595311671,
-0.0375287086,
-0.0029864237,
-0.0065945643,
0.0440301113,
-0.0669294894,
-0.1141273975,
-0.0007841137,
0.0011258493,
0.0492127202,
0.0140611324,
-0.002973588,
0.0124921948,
0.0472468212,
-0.0501970202,
-0.0165062919,
-0.0637773648,
0.000969789,
0.0175544694,
-0.0108935963,
0.0124715641,
-0.0066720448,
-0.0054538697,
0.0174563993,
-0.0490155406,
-0.0278011933,
-0.0060141003,
-0.0413906723,
0.0478634611,
-0.0128022647,
-0.0066722804,
0.0354959741,
0.0500616096,
0.0314313173,
0.0192068908,
0.1064614654,
0.0224695243,
-0.0295315888,
0.000737732,
0.0266134571,
-0.0742826536,
-0.0646085516,
0.0137608917,
0.0347057879,
0.0572219081,
0.0295607019,
0.0489116199,
-0.0342468582,
0.0170599669,
-0.0425561555,
0.0623475313,
0.0442108847,
-0.0150950626,
0.0567388982,
0.0232500825,
-0.0281999446,
0.0350805372,
0.0791410357,
0.0300981198,
0.0340136662,
0.0061990018,
-0.0101963906,
-0.0486713573,
-0.0455270857,
-0.0274299625,
0.0304873995,
-0.0161414295,
0.0066958969,
-0.0183243006,
-0.0342434682,
-0.0113203619,
0.00941425,
-0.0222129673,
-0.0590443574,
0.033305265,
0.0439953022,
0.0033834148,
-0.0034668054,
-0.0339996181,
-0.0315313749,
0.0256653428,
-0.0155772436,
-0.0515011586,
-6.087289047e-33,
-0.038448777,
-0.0172288176,
0.0399699956,
0.0065828939,
-0.0160012376,
-0.0311463047,
-0.0432457104,
0.0174173675,
-0.0318640657,
-0.0078783743,
-0.0155145526,
0.0354120359,
0.0275950152,
0.0398477465,
-0.0166463368,
-0.0129200965,
0.0456794873,
0.0083827265,
-0.0137002738,
0.0220314618,
0.0356767438,
-0.0046220659,
0.0212172754,
-0.0552174635,
0.0495819747,
0.0087291198,
-0.0136899725,
0.0475086272,
-0.0018237663,
0.0341168977,
-0.0174196828,
0.0264298655,
0.0037823559,
-0.0641735941,
-0.0163605716,
0.018294163,
0.00726448,
0.0057076253,
0.0633503869,
0.0052035633,
-0.0127547374,
-0.0030339949,
-0.005465515,
-0.01471972,
-0.0087346081,
0.0360126793,
-0.0105082802,
-0.0030456509,
-0.0202842169,
-0.000920474,
-0.0161332693,
0.014040526,
-0.0066775396,
-0.0696197972,
0.0094410572,
0.0131114889,
0.0216445979,
-0.0436154902,
-0.0271554608,
0.0277156327,
-0.0286689997,
0.0138453348,
0.0523726493,
0.0385378413,
0.0263414085,
0.0420298316,
0.0385077,
0.014876782,
-0.0275407508,
-0.0314907432,
-0.0469580963,
0.0455587581,
-0.0097891148,
0.01084325,
-0.0531503148,
0.0353645571,
-0.0479732007,
-0.0044684252,
0.050892286,
0.0439618342,
0.027114274,
0.0331248455,
-0.0621183254,
-0.0278262533,
-0.0273148045,
0.0605228692,
-0.0094338879,
-0.0134795429,
0.0277411547,
0.0199077483,
0.018213233,
0.0043548206,
0.0758426413,
-0.0222938713,
-0.01391715,
0.0409153774,
-0.0095786517,
0.0044524171,
-0.0267003421,
0.0054539251,
-0.0649129152,
-0.0023281204,
0.0161740128,
0.0077013755,
-0.0072264667,
0.0093217827,
-0.0404769108,
0.0182337686,
-0.056111753,
-0.0122259697,
-0.0557059571,
0.0447947979,
-0.0377613381,
0.0466033109,
0.0570902862,
-0.0198307633,
-0.0209325776,
0.0739105642,
-0.0252557229,
-0.0368452407,
-0.0128752459,
-0.0264399871,
0.0166518856,
0.0026577506,
-0.0338713899,
0.0078645134,
-0.0126615064,
-0.0288924593,
-0.0233331285,
-0.0192996617,
-0.0060873758,
0.0080486862,
2.591e-7,
-0.0058582299,
0.0376474224,
0.0228685923,
0.0666423663,
0.0125716506,
0.0350883864,
-0.0209114589,
-0.014583054,
0.0332725681,
-0.0336981043,
0.0066610561,
0.0429217108,
0.0503413975,
-0.0116311684,
-0.105719164,
-0.0242848881,
-0.0214840882,
-0.0044791237,
-0.0345233493,
-0.0083337789,
0.0263558645,
0.0863469467,
-0.0012869253,
0.0308914147,
0.0179786533,
-0.0083809085,
0.051471971,
-0.0463878699,
-0.0474026799,
0.0416226797,
0.0217430294,
0.0005088575,
-0.0372193679,
0.0306376405,
0.0211192127,
0.0308026895,
-0.0263277497,
0.1080674902,
0.0298338328,
-0.0516227037,
-0.0157893784,
-0.0098375184,
-0.0030352909,
0.0017931266,
0.053321965,
-0.0457691103,
-0.034857776,
-0.0082750013,
0.0025411719,
-0.0323314779,
-0.0277890172,
0.0143574337,
-0.0234795213,
-0.0203062817,
0.0126957688,
-0.0343478322,
0.0022751191,
-0.0605500564,
-0.0081707826,
-0.0061232797,
-0.0732902884,
-0.079756923,
-0.0296822656,
-0.0543915741,
0.0111776534,
-0.0426799916,
-0.0159040056,
2.266662824e-34,
0.0593845062,
-0.0126110418,
0.0104714315,
0.0375537276,
0.0478237569,
-0.0041553667,
-0.0339727029,
0.0003588401,
0.0567197539,
-0.1114892215,
-0.0193809215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06459v1 | Masakhane-Afrisenti at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Sentiment Analysis using Afro-centric Language Models and Adapters for Low-resource African Languages | 2023-04-13T12:54:29 | 2023-04-13T12:54:29 | Israel Abebe Azime, Sana Sabah Al-Azzawi, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Jesujoba Alabi, Ayodele Awokoya, Mardiyyah Oduwole, Tosin Adewumi, Samuel Fanijo, Oyinkansola Awosan, Oreen Yousuf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | AfriSenti-SemEval Shared Task 12 of SemEval-2023. The task aims to perform
monolingual sentiment classification (sub-task A) for 12 African languages,
multilingual sentiment classification (sub-task B), and zero-shot sentiment
classification (task C). For sub-task A, we conducted experiments using
classical machine learning classifiers, Afro-centric language models, and
language-specific models. For task B, we fine-tuned multilingual pre-trained
language models that support many of the languages in the task. For task C, we
used we make use of a parameter-efficient Adapter approach that leverages
monolingual texts in the target language for effective zero-shot transfer. Our
findings suggest that using pre-trained Afro-centric language models improves
performance for low-resource African languages. We also ran experiments using
adapters for zero-shot tasks, and the results suggest that we can obtain
promising results by using adapters with a limited amount of resources. | [
0.0174434539,
0.0802513734,
0.004232402,
0.0527725555,
-0.0013863056,
0.0478590466,
0.0448782444,
-0.0032913391,
-0.0149564994,
-0.0569024496,
-0.037522655,
-0.0747185498,
-0.0005251138,
0.0065811793,
-0.027283201,
-0.0418905951,
0.0163124446,
0.0079632532,
-0.0069814799,
-0.0170915779,
-0.0191368069,
0.0491269454,
0.0189490076,
0.0011476153,
-0.0236647148,
0.006737601,
-0.0094490033,
0.0078123612,
-0.0289014671,
0.0004576535,
0.0010854051,
0.0361862555,
-0.0239848886,
0.0204979293,
0.0000024034,
-0.0349289738,
-0.0272003002,
-0.0222098771,
-0.0210471842,
-0.0158757847,
0.0921503529,
-0.0614975728,
-0.0105628921,
0.0231801812,
-0.0390248224,
-0.0210627131,
0.087387152,
0.0223545115,
0.0546711087,
0.0852659717,
-0.0322194546,
-0.007087369,
0.0221331604,
-0.0134448875,
0.0027202852,
-0.0364451073,
0.0185376573,
-0.0202943012,
-0.0059519215,
0.0073092189,
-0.0310386848,
-0.0000297879,
-0.0117307659,
0.0114062354,
0.0014373274,
-0.0363090783,
-0.0442866646,
-0.0380083025,
-0.026993962,
0.0086096292,
-0.044083111,
-0.0138190491,
-0.0427684374,
0.0064674136,
-0.0282478239,
-0.0281965677,
-0.0357572772,
0.0147475377,
0.0356689729,
0.0297022574,
0.017598778,
0.0433553383,
0.0398777984,
0.0149593968,
-0.0461798646,
0.0560903288,
-0.0155273555,
-0.0013148062,
0.0456582978,
0.0662959591,
0.0239648633,
-0.0151359811,
-0.0141414907,
-0.0186626911,
0.022041399,
-0.0217834972,
-0.0081893653,
-0.0459405817,
0.0014200747,
-0.0787755474,
0.0783564374,
0.0456676371,
-0.0049558836,
0.0332880318,
-0.060624782,
-0.0220521502,
0.0034009335,
-0.0223451406,
-0.0224377029,
-0.0408418775,
-0.0574806742,
-0.0128645292,
-0.0069779404,
0.0414093137,
-0.040996924,
0.0373406373,
-0.0472940393,
-0.0105103534,
-0.0207689311,
-0.0418114588,
-0.0116892131,
-0.0319844633,
0.0077894949,
-0.0369257256,
-0.0009792969,
0.0648289472,
-0.0237482954,
0.0248316657,
-0.0587855279,
-0.0796789825,
0.0180644803,
0.0193251129,
0.0025449928,
-0.0157972071,
0.0364279263,
0.0572128519,
0.001800372,
-0.0460807048,
-0.0656265616,
0.0125971818,
0.0030118567,
-0.0431588292,
-0.0298974868,
-0.0561436005,
0.0327441692,
0.023605559,
0.0586490668,
-0.0034144002,
-0.0175159816,
-0.0176558606,
-0.012771558,
0.0666451678,
0.0129415626,
-0.0111821322,
0.0180934202,
-0.0085965656,
0.0332168266,
0.0887205377,
-0.0101494519,
0.0281907674,
0.0344184861,
-0.0211139042,
-0.0383451991,
0.0264713056,
0.0091738179,
-0.0057494352,
-0.02415457,
-0.0090664448,
0.0115209762,
-0.0425565392,
0.0376910232,
0.0033949912,
0.0297609456,
-0.0059374063,
0.0368006639,
0.0226780027,
-0.0197673049,
0.026005201,
0.0308564696,
-0.0265922938,
-0.0299130585,
-0.0168474019,
-0.0026670026,
0.0327350162,
-0.0254086703,
-0.0693349689,
0.0364860669,
0.0638133734,
-0.0396675542,
-0.0287639946,
0.0274354126,
-0.0394989103,
0.0210997779,
0.008699948,
0.0441434868,
-0.0074188132,
-0.0382697135,
-0.0112203872,
0.0585978962,
-0.0637474582,
-0.009250124,
-0.0503125787,
0.0203515738,
0.0331755169,
-0.0406777859,
0.0256836023,
-0.0067621577,
-0.0215067845,
0.0373929925,
0.0281483512,
0.0356847718,
0.004265164,
0.0592454672,
-0.042149879,
0.0182880331,
0.0012109586,
0.011593787,
0.0491841063,
-0.0194563884,
0.0944854021,
-0.0070051923,
0.0112720029,
-0.0477891751,
0.0033463356,
-0.0261886753,
-0.0298701543,
0.0588124171,
0.008982053,
0.0443771593,
0.029993074,
-0.005352091,
-0.0217511877,
-0.0131852403,
-0.0571598746,
-0.0075943228,
0.0342236757,
-0.0416813567,
-0.0296119321,
0.0111911055,
-0.0035279668,
0.0312067512,
0.0369331017,
0.019128155,
-0.0365253016,
0.0659835786,
0.0554559976,
0.0312725082,
-0.0176123176,
0.0212163143,
-0.042161569,
0.0449754782,
0.0201818272,
0.0057401452,
0.0640929863,
-0.0231703203,
-0.0276310313,
-0.0561112687,
0.0535227433,
0.033896666,
-0.0340518504,
0.0424604341,
-0.0045870012,
-0.0098738559,
0.0064142072,
0.0285058599,
-0.0036625694,
-0.0074044149,
-0.1045628339,
0.0062448531,
-0.0277033858,
0.0160229076,
-0.0270974822,
0.0627532974,
-0.0057212398,
0.0245103166,
-0.0065345559,
0.0316172205,
-0.0125930076,
0.0069134273,
-0.0191843491,
-0.0108974297,
0.0529544763,
-0.0239318125,
-0.0006783204,
0.0278386865,
0.0426786803,
0.0037337851,
-0.0090509085,
0.0132058347,
-0.0161966756,
-0.006359404,
-0.0055523408,
0.036101155,
-0.0488672405,
-0.0088026496,
-0.0250466913,
-0.0133556956,
0.0165536143,
-0.0286195502,
0.0238146931,
0.0145442896,
0.0046097934,
-0.018486442,
0.0065889531,
-0.0123103317,
0.0133720329,
-0.0152748395,
-0.0058503002,
0.0002387621,
0.074326545,
-0.0040600691,
-0.0281438399,
-0.0636176914,
0.0136164688,
-0.0207998455,
-0.0339915603,
0.0054950272,
0.0309751201,
0.0229087789,
0.0123641631,
-0.0022944447,
-0.0039176526,
0.0507314391,
0.0168418027,
-0.0164408069,
-0.0369122215,
-0.0042894203,
-0.0265701264,
0.0076638456,
-0.0184190907,
0.0255462341,
-0.0150260739,
0.0468293726,
-0.0013953277,
0.0016814912,
0.0261763353,
0.012911031,
0.0241697095,
0.0121398475,
0.0111917788,
-0.0164167974,
-0.0567862727,
0.0228543952,
-0.0491656363,
-0.0418983251,
-0.0005073568,
0.0082199704,
-0.0165284835,
-0.0291590765,
0.026128931,
-0.0001134188,
0.0039291694,
0.0024021338,
-0.0247795805,
0.0407736786,
0.0086858636,
0.0014843012,
-0.0337880664,
0.0018989306,
-0.0281942226,
0.0138707571,
0.0047467165,
-0.0227100514,
-0.0072021419,
-0.0002118002,
-0.0163648091,
0.0472916737,
-0.0244542416,
-0.0279858001,
-0.0254673213,
0.0336900167,
-0.0238887016,
0.0421526879,
0.0887763202,
0.0195761807,
-0.0450648703,
-0.0021395935,
-0.0615232922,
0.015522466,
-0.0216722526,
0.0289308093,
-0.0749748424,
-0.0435358211,
-0.0341438204,
-0.0134196151,
-0.0206614882,
-0.0269689951,
0.0004558451,
-0.1250855178,
0.0003295216,
0.0203144737,
-0.0300683025,
-0.0226699859,
-0.0291034542,
-0.0211657844,
-0.0321798138,
-0.0216454733,
-0.0497483201,
0.0218598507,
-0.0113016367,
0.0375270285,
-0.0206248704,
-0.0715932921,
0.0148117626,
-0.0066277427,
0.0435749851,
0.023243852,
0.0072141634,
-0.0400393978,
0.0187335853,
-0.004932594,
-0.0246073101,
0.0005567339,
-0.0562682077,
0.0182090513,
0.0006444994,
-0.0328381844,
0.0362867862,
-0.0253395438,
-0.0547856502,
0.0206417069,
-0.0013803907,
0.0683689713,
0.0093598953,
-0.0542398468,
-0.0575455874,
-0.0287056342,
0.0221887231,
0.0501072742,
0.0147729414,
-0.0921554863,
-0.0256874524,
-0.0007753537,
-0.0089894319,
-0.0785090327,
-0.0028973459,
-0.0007397669,
-0.0094372565,
-0.0587012023,
-0.0492460579,
-0.0626990944,
0.0136676729,
0.0308932699,
-0.0085172169,
0.0019643242,
0.0015541969,
-0.0112817464,
-0.0175065771,
-0.0136546623,
-0.0156205483,
0.0253799986,
-0.0122984909,
-0.0216818582,
0.0398249552,
-0.003053887,
0.0294087846,
-0.0459456556,
-0.0617974922,
-0.0423669629,
0.0081808837,
0.0683748201,
0.0100141494,
0.0087688453,
0.0285558756,
-0.0746671483,
0.0028149162,
0.0329890922,
0.0254124515,
0.0103383418,
0.0670557022,
0.0249215402,
-0.0121700075,
0.0533292741,
0.0244840365,
0.0800809711,
0.0424248949,
-0.0170718934,
-0.0324164592,
-0.0261491612,
-0.0347379223,
-0.0444722436,
0.0247304644,
-0.0300536398,
-0.0779309571,
-0.0024385646,
0.0101258727,
-0.0026276009,
0.0216377396,
-0.0563209914,
-0.0450039804,
0.0460281931,
0.024869306,
-0.0532967113,
-0.0046272334,
-0.0315797515,
-0.0092848577,
-0.0103727253,
0.0688940659,
0.0605541803,
0.0080276476,
0.0184390713,
0.068070069,
0.001314518,
-0.0001803741,
0.0282473955,
0.0167611241,
-0.0399399213,
0.0062867873,
-0.0115595879,
0.0400710665,
-0.0012518367,
0.0044753063,
0.0252552256,
0.0666910633,
-0.0391147062,
0.0140054179,
0.0503372438,
-0.0484274253,
0.0596310273,
0.0226661265,
-0.0111819403,
-0.0066860137,
0.0224317405,
-0.0152218435,
-0.0113576734,
0.0118367951,
0.0015317985,
-0.0067918436,
0.0396344773,
0.0518308356,
-0.0574697033,
0.0220439229,
0.063926816,
0.0357533209,
-0.0159685519,
0.028380096,
0.0681953877,
-0.0318842307,
0.0110322759,
0.0682689101,
-0.0408949181,
-0.0689082965,
0.0778142512,
-0.0745594129,
0.0006283338,
0.0120472861,
0.0073399264,
0.0258658156,
0.0065341652,
0.072439976,
-0.0479893982,
-0.0161123499,
-0.0377667174,
-0.0095451614,
0.0232656002,
-7.225387616e-33,
0.0072233952,
0.0130197881,
-0.0277391095,
-0.0147915361,
0.0087622367,
-0.0205547009,
-0.0127491038,
0.0378670618,
-0.0454765074,
0.0212735999,
-0.0383002944,
-0.01082855,
0.0126042543,
0.050764218,
0.042993702,
0.0255935248,
0.0389036685,
0.019118255,
-0.021519009,
0.0017690399,
0.0519232936,
0.0674284324,
0.0675768778,
-0.0691198111,
0.036028143,
-0.0188303068,
-0.0221094526,
-0.0273513198,
0.0801930279,
0.0349957012,
-0.022078298,
0.0772527829,
0.0396878235,
-0.0046653897,
0.0126702143,
-0.0090980716,
-0.0278474577,
-0.0308605339,
0.0134748723,
0.0436109602,
0.006734814,
-0.0602085255,
0.0033522032,
0.0137815056,
-0.0216785055,
-0.0029089344,
0.0055622654,
-0.0497001894,
-0.0076294327,
-0.0208870042,
-0.1152311787,
0.0316247828,
0.0157352462,
0.0057949498,
0.0694993585,
0.0773491338,
-0.0280880202,
-0.0035037147,
-0.0451491699,
0.0020199232,
-0.0191438291,
0.0196738932,
0.0096895015,
0.0209972262,
-0.0496658795,
0.0254194587,
0.0111500481,
-0.0201270338,
0.0132180294,
0.0439293869,
0.053695444,
-0.0352287143,
0.0196064003,
0.116600357,
0.058241345,
-0.0636751726,
-0.03196894,
0.020112507,
0.0567033738,
-0.0016244567,
0.0167676378,
-0.006308076,
-0.0214002673,
-0.037959788,
0.0222457647,
-0.0465281941,
-0.0308922566,
-0.0464008525,
0.014694619,
-0.0347654037,
-0.0209448542,
0.0507853888,
0.0474233478,
-0.0355577879,
-0.0372812711,
0.0021461467,
-0.0422278978,
0.0172820538,
0.0221517738,
0.0154076954,
-0.0559128933,
-0.017310774,
-0.025122378,
0.0303470995,
0.0101688467,
0.0018747844,
0.0670011267,
0.0687795132,
-0.0929947272,
-0.0057677417,
-0.0093809729,
0.0305593908,
0.0119954217,
0.1062128916,
-0.0369215123,
0.0129704708,
0.009177126,
0.0520655885,
0.00737456,
-0.0282976385,
0.0371829942,
-0.0171974227,
-0.0024061627,
-0.0206887405,
-0.0688222498,
-0.0283171106,
-0.0144776711,
-0.009887551,
-0.0033546244,
-0.0563326962,
-0.0059121414,
-0.0062412987,
3.082e-7,
0.0124800298,
0.0256453883,
-0.0457842909,
-0.078719236,
-0.0148509797,
0.0434447564,
-0.0070156236,
0.0053039063,
-0.0044523147,
0.0654572248,
-0.0059005837,
0.0247843955,
0.0707131252,
0.0376584418,
-0.0795929953,
0.0088290554,
-0.0187873617,
0.018754283,
-0.0264497101,
0.0118621243,
0.0266076215,
0.1544009298,
-0.0042464458,
-0.0262898095,
-0.0543291792,
-0.0142587163,
0.0609013699,
-0.0458046608,
-0.0276329089,
-0.0125578074,
-0.0131935542,
0.0361837037,
-0.0385751911,
0.0068195793,
-0.0413045771,
0.0222246815,
0.0019715494,
0.0592688322,
-0.0190726742,
0.00783097,
0.0240259022,
0.0309972074,
-0.0330969319,
-0.0152013963,
0.065794386,
-0.0160140693,
-0.0731272325,
-0.0794154778,
-0.0132213384,
0.024147097,
0.0504013486,
-0.0260235853,
-0.0236814637,
-0.0005195907,
0.0355675481,
-0.0453639179,
-0.0751244277,
-0.0317532867,
0.0117082167,
0.0021529447,
0.027490871,
0.0138714379,
-0.0009602942,
0.0034849616,
0.0468572341,
-0.0230314918,
0.0583125614,
2.692149534e-34,
0.0439382531,
-0.0233785436,
0.0310900137,
0.0135054197,
-0.0371154472,
-0.0028557635,
-0.0408310257,
0.0033675514,
0.0246051513,
-0.0306538735,
0.0249100421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06447v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06447v5 | PDFVQA: A New Dataset for Real-World VQA on PDF Documents | 2023-04-13T12:28:14 | 2023-06-06T02:26:42 | Yihao Ding, Siwen Luo, Hyunsuk Chung, Soyeon Caren Han | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Document-based Visual Question Answering examines the document understanding
of document images in conditions of natural language questions. We proposed a
new document-based VQA dataset, PDF-VQA, to comprehensively examine the
document understanding from various aspects, including document element
recognition, document layout structural understanding as well as contextual
understanding and key information extraction. Our PDF-VQA dataset extends the
current scale of document understanding that limits on the single document page
to the new scale that asks questions over the full document of multiple pages.
We also propose a new graph-based VQA model that explicitly integrates the
spatial and hierarchically structural relationships between different document
elements to boost the document structural understanding. The performances are
compared with several baselines over different question types and
tasks\footnote{The full dataset will be released after paper acceptance. | [
0.0084150201,
0.0046467856,
0.0160586014,
0.049887009,
0.0026192195,
0.0371269844,
0.0112451408,
-0.0138079897,
0.0206670854,
-0.0245596711,
-0.0359711014,
0.0094682453,
-0.0152376899,
0.0407142676,
0.010364431,
-0.0492555089,
0.0313803405,
-0.0313347466,
-0.0133048678,
0.014339746,
0.0291986894,
0.0143677648,
-0.0050386712,
-0.0291999262,
-0.016361909,
-0.0679672137,
-0.0589449331,
0.0227763373,
0.0275056679,
-0.0011786849,
-0.0199971553,
0.0191472135,
0.0610594377,
-0.0010111436,
0.0000015423,
0.0065642223,
-0.0281575639,
0.0308316778,
-0.0000085767,
0.0131183825,
0.020059485,
-0.0598376952,
0.0315324627,
-0.0221337993,
-0.0289465617,
-0.0111732967,
0.0360910669,
0.0771792158,
0.0321346261,
0.019659305,
-0.0175781734,
-0.00784906,
0.0093776416,
0.0012868516,
0.0527295284,
-0.060419295,
-0.0222964715,
0.0536392108,
0.0403999202,
0.00310289,
-0.0406047627,
0.0215122048,
0.0366459005,
-0.0378469676,
-0.000163986,
0.0340027697,
-0.0243788846,
0.0045107757,
-0.0184018817,
0.0961655453,
0.042414315,
-0.0105599612,
0.0038100823,
-0.0057545812,
-0.0131453173,
0.0515530966,
-0.0795142874,
-0.0182486698,
-0.0629179105,
-0.0415470861,
-0.0135170911,
0.0159196481,
0.00243883,
-0.0028243335,
-0.0063120844,
0.021865515,
-0.0031294653,
-0.0055736299,
0.0128766447,
0.0029230979,
-0.0466055796,
0.0000844768,
0.0120352535,
0.0598276705,
0.023452187,
0.0073164273,
-0.029599756,
-0.0648729131,
0.0116860792,
-0.0636961162,
0.0042243009,
-0.0344974622,
-0.0411280841,
0.1235020086,
-0.0177767389,
0.0931167826,
-0.0191236213,
0.0306658894,
-0.0523082353,
-0.0044539459,
-0.0022800365,
-0.0215898342,
-0.0595613644,
0.0107686203,
-0.0256281961,
-0.0716550797,
0.0391690135,
0.0133317849,
0.0014114121,
0.0239796918,
0.0198568087,
0.0437920652,
-0.0283248518,
-0.0230940245,
0.0023970723,
0.0326480344,
-0.0528293177,
0.0057141758,
-0.045548182,
-0.0018432295,
-0.0042462912,
0.0309327487,
0.031080246,
-0.0248696245,
0.0075362949,
0.0491392612,
-0.0131094046,
-0.0211058799,
0.0121466629,
-0.0050588893,
0.021824766,
-0.0429211967,
0.0477051176,
-0.0293808747,
0.0518876612,
-0.0052889809,
-0.0307835937,
0.0476880297,
-0.0199951511,
0.0069701415,
-0.0216732379,
0.0816391557,
0.0004912539,
-0.0224305596,
0.0649178773,
0.0090894811,
0.0116455406,
0.0440150276,
-0.0050431015,
0.0383628123,
0.0377309434,
-0.0142716654,
0.0000661648,
0.0396681018,
0.0032436533,
-0.0263990425,
0.0166273601,
0.0483646877,
-0.003595832,
0.0063779005,
0.0091023203,
0.0051341048,
-0.0551592894,
-0.0372762606,
0.0038172118,
0.063503392,
-0.0090177758,
-0.0380530991,
-0.0372923352,
0.0456198007,
0.032120578,
0.0200257655,
-0.0374261178,
0.0452234298,
0.0258802716,
0.0185388997,
-0.0370299779,
-0.0239897072,
-0.0239945445,
-0.0174774211,
-0.0169744622,
0.0444791168,
0.0381103121,
0.0063282992,
0.0677907541,
0.0500316508,
-0.0506659262,
-0.0259001479,
-0.0329527371,
-0.0132939331,
-0.0310575962,
0.0325960144,
0.0691647902,
0.0462758318,
0.0760577619,
-0.0346172266,
-0.0243134983,
0.0069348337,
0.0347129218,
-0.0031210415,
0.0345354788,
-0.0339432992,
0.0209701527,
-0.0761984959,
-0.0428946055,
-0.0461960286,
-0.0382183865,
-0.0034062683,
0.0288258679,
-0.0147229619,
-0.007706055,
-0.1149694696,
-0.0005113855,
0.0352539346,
0.0485394336,
-0.0546417795,
-0.0254116524,
0.0278619938,
0.0060152547,
0.0253849961,
-0.018371271,
-0.0178797375,
0.0235206466,
-0.0268290471,
0.0402487069,
-0.0144457286,
-0.013888685,
-0.024846537,
0.0107922107,
-0.0677070096,
-0.0235686526,
0.0173451677,
-0.0663946271,
-0.0264825411,
-0.0061994232,
-0.0254563782,
-0.016207464,
-0.0331967063,
-0.0494838543,
0.0385693945,
0.0160215329,
-0.0289430935,
0.069367379,
0.0137661723,
0.0224628393,
0.0066473531,
0.054328531,
0.0220925771,
-0.034616217,
0.0408722907,
-0.0047538327,
-0.004077083,
-0.004494383,
0.0132199265,
0.0416354947,
-0.0381772965,
0.0134181855,
-0.0640208274,
-0.0052891271,
-0.0222551692,
0.0355992503,
0.0348115154,
-0.014172487,
-0.0023453198,
-0.0679229796,
-0.0541293398,
0.0186003838,
-0.0091416631,
-0.0209371969,
0.047392834,
-0.0082946988,
0.0294026826,
-0.0162794795,
-0.0447706059,
-0.0014331444,
0.0611619577,
0.0646808073,
-0.0389473289,
0.0202056412,
-0.002201342,
0.0266648512,
0.033202976,
-0.0240054969,
-0.0014989115,
0.007198154,
-0.0353031047,
0.0161286369,
0.1211652756,
-0.0221616346,
0.0335436165,
-0.0070981351,
-0.0199248642,
-0.0529974364,
0.0350252911,
0.0103952512,
0.045518294,
0.0140528027,
-0.0141444728,
-0.014575352,
0.0116925221,
-0.0212150011,
0.0209316593,
-0.0124128126,
0.0110371076,
0.0119561451,
-0.0039701187,
-0.079717271,
-0.0055366666,
0.0541662388,
0.0413661748,
-0.0431831554,
-0.0472647659,
0.0327773802,
-0.0343332142,
-0.0252275076,
-0.0330279991,
0.0418969132,
-0.0373910554,
0.0865831077,
0.0384456851,
0.0176650546,
-0.0116558764,
-0.0334499776,
-0.0369164236,
0.0058163013,
0.0269044321,
-0.0050067548,
-0.0210061353,
-0.0404104926,
0.0545771532,
-0.0360947847,
-0.0273294393,
-0.0028610872,
0.0161937047,
-0.0114766294,
-0.0001357178,
-0.0488233492,
-0.0206983145,
-0.0371234082,
0.037271332,
0.0304786097,
0.0587959178,
-0.0538088195,
-0.0024111224,
-0.0238379426,
0.0996432453,
0.0883516669,
0.0253611952,
0.0093149962,
-0.0464163832,
0.0069180741,
0.0458468311,
-0.0297782253,
-0.0129116718,
-0.0036145754,
0.0245343484,
-0.0050979955,
0.0017681631,
0.0005463711,
-0.0209949855,
0.0120345652,
-0.0953482315,
-0.0387332365,
0.0320918262,
0.0320973173,
-0.0166953746,
-0.0560923442,
-0.0606623106,
0.0168608129,
0.0233049635,
0.0480454564,
-0.1064306051,
-0.0253121983,
-0.0059590321,
0.0329138413,
0.042598974,
0.0307279509,
0.0162187442,
-0.0369413123,
0.0717091337,
-0.0203692149,
-0.0275760479,
-0.0260807015,
-0.0168414302,
-0.0053320057,
-0.0032469903,
0.0052245832,
-0.0112547437,
-0.025939567,
-0.0095294127,
0.0125727123,
0.0123377796,
0.0399227217,
-0.0007951331,
-0.0181644838,
-0.0801179931,
0.0619154572,
0.0123434355,
0.0051672859,
-0.0460250638,
0.020250082,
-0.0362000726,
0.0067527345,
0.005196705,
0.0498159081,
-0.0112676416,
-0.002163053,
-0.0424841121,
0.0565665103,
-0.033755783,
-0.0229026508,
0.0086916778,
-0.0052980524,
-0.0136576481,
-0.0391380675,
-0.0554737858,
-0.0091854418,
-0.0687384307,
0.0422179475,
0.0621345118,
0.0182145834,
-0.1212390512,
-0.0305663105,
0.0268306639,
-0.0578118488,
0.0079923924,
0.0103410091,
0.003630437,
0.0014037433,
-0.0569090806,
-0.0174682438,
0.0352170467,
0.0348028205,
-0.0281045064,
-0.0250856113,
-0.0108283581,
-0.0136151072,
-0.0798469186,
0.0518073738,
0.0110176103,
0.0313071571,
-0.021669697,
0.0220207684,
0.0138006909,
-0.0324767493,
-0.0443325676,
0.0248908997,
-0.0608894303,
0.0033659723,
-0.0181859899,
0.0515755638,
0.0101962388,
0.0454621054,
-0.0183223262,
-0.0440677069,
0.0361170731,
-0.0303469095,
0.0031262038,
-0.0302352775,
-0.0066383686,
-0.0458594598,
-0.0204046406,
-0.0078161797,
-0.0617428012,
-0.0133374464,
-0.0155664273,
0.0063466392,
-0.0076408996,
0.0255949702,
-0.0058549927,
-0.0094259828,
-0.0265045501,
0.0392945521,
0.0458023734,
-0.0173959024,
0.0315287076,
0.0132617969,
-0.0183402728,
-0.0363662131,
-0.0031095054,
-0.0184721909,
-0.0252511147,
-0.0184411965,
0.0058837864,
0.0318258442,
0.0539428405,
-0.0197883099,
0.0141518395,
0.0768833309,
-0.0097538671,
-0.0063872589,
-0.0245547649,
0.0124157723,
-0.0006132674,
-0.0125061423,
0.0792723596,
0.0113693718,
0.0560253672,
0.0441324264,
-0.0097790584,
-0.0274092536,
0.0156900231,
-0.0466536246,
-0.0634444281,
-0.0151697295,
0.034062691,
0.0199414343,
-0.0272138529,
0.0132709565,
0.0000684914,
-0.0330166146,
0.0066924836,
-0.0007941163,
0.0266587064,
-0.0099569261,
0.072525017,
0.0615694709,
0.0268932916,
-0.0025573736,
0.0609997362,
0.0363215506,
0.0004427045,
-0.018620573,
-0.007998975,
-0.0354122445,
0.0078595905,
0.0157506354,
0.027291419,
0.0182322767,
0.0143878395,
-0.0171653777,
-0.0334841646,
0.0209526401,
0.0499618128,
-0.0024723073,
0.040650066,
0.0460793823,
0.0635380149,
0.035804987,
-0.0623058416,
-0.0132132759,
0.0379129797,
-0.0475087315,
-0.0199656021,
-0.0177416541,
-4.875449145e-33,
-0.0462270789,
-0.0531726219,
0.01621636,
0.004525552,
-0.011328483,
0.0318386406,
-0.0405370295,
-0.0552354865,
-0.0096614603,
0.0382829681,
-0.0234560873,
0.0165027771,
0.0251451153,
0.0225635823,
-0.0268239919,
-0.023918109,
0.0413706154,
-0.0370775498,
-0.0167183429,
0.0197597425,
-0.013170938,
0.0149978586,
0.0476379991,
-0.033082664,
0.0122382902,
-0.0091857538,
-0.0152194807,
0.0044999262,
0.0012156704,
0.0663582981,
-0.0324637368,
-0.0434693173,
0.0306691043,
-0.0066999276,
-0.011989506,
0.0686920658,
-0.1521171927,
0.0033974601,
0.0107625481,
0.067406632,
-0.048669897,
-0.0268386789,
0.0269624982,
-0.039361164,
0.0462148525,
-0.0323281251,
0.0665460601,
-0.0097490549,
-0.0301143173,
-0.0590905435,
-0.0385748893,
0.0157516412,
-0.0559939221,
0.0048000007,
0.0227157958,
0.0336854681,
-0.0008848834,
0.0451355129,
-0.0795706213,
-0.0256582294,
0.0037312845,
0.0038057305,
0.0764764473,
0.0317359008,
0.0273957737,
0.0044703241,
0.0375699364,
-0.0307172798,
-0.0273846146,
-0.0266919732,
0.0330506861,
0.0262431074,
0.0441105887,
0.0072456873,
0.0285119042,
0.0698944554,
-0.0555580631,
0.0637181997,
-0.0489793234,
0.0740531236,
-0.0211418942,
-0.0067766085,
-0.0210599788,
-0.0069242925,
-0.0100087151,
-0.0045174561,
-0.0337075144,
0.0103556607,
0.0361734629,
-0.0015676883,
0.0118822828,
-0.0119423093,
0.04851548,
-0.0278769284,
-0.0090750987,
0.0561976507,
-0.0050378684,
0.0564651117,
0.0076460303,
0.0305131283,
-0.0247652717,
0.0146717019,
0.0304910392,
-0.0250118207,
-0.0073678563,
0.0159960724,
0.0448305085,
-0.0205972679,
-0.0343406163,
-0.0057459213,
-0.0162238237,
-0.023903152,
-0.0281467102,
0.0594781265,
0.0298910607,
0.0010240562,
-0.0234447885,
0.0591326691,
-0.0320636965,
0.0235637389,
-0.0138981091,
-0.0092186425,
-0.0352245234,
0.0285960585,
-0.0154519295,
-0.011740285,
-0.0308338106,
-0.0160612632,
0.0032339788,
-0.0363437533,
0.0109101916,
0.0805774406,
2.087e-7,
0.0625676885,
0.0146388169,
0.0863909051,
0.0193853173,
0.0168951135,
0.0248320159,
-0.0089569809,
0.0231229253,
-0.0188790523,
-0.0191000067,
0.0210293494,
0.0450504869,
0.0296149515,
-0.0040171519,
-0.0805088952,
0.0399471708,
-0.0560716055,
-0.0361128412,
-0.0724814087,
-0.0220662616,
0.0035053403,
0.0523292944,
-0.0625120178,
-0.0161209553,
0.018939361,
-0.0301920213,
0.0360163152,
0.0028428093,
0.0246570781,
-0.0046708821,
0.0158870146,
-0.043376185,
-0.0285473857,
-0.0182134733,
-0.0028994186,
0.0326356404,
0.0700195059,
0.0288216025,
-0.000481047,
-0.0105822841,
-0.0320182629,
-0.0303027816,
0.0225339513,
-0.0555343889,
0.081248343,
-0.0053924732,
-0.0259803943,
-0.0149759259,
-0.060180366,
-0.021793399,
-0.0116408207,
0.0118223615,
0.0303010475,
0.0458997525,
0.0400552154,
-0.074741289,
0.0045340271,
-0.0504815131,
0.0180297755,
-0.0173723754,
0.0109949168,
0.0285302103,
-0.0362461396,
0.0114554297,
0.0032946733,
0.0004158438,
-0.0626381263,
1.525138602e-34,
0.0461590476,
-0.0110166017,
-0.0053814496,
0.0285185911,
0.0391141288,
-0.0581781231,
-0.0262172148,
-0.005889432,
0.0071457233,
-0.0888250694,
0.006594155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06446v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06446v2 | SpectFormer: Frequency and Attention is what you need in a Vision Transformer | 2023-04-13T12:27:17 | 2023-04-14T22:20:46 | Badri N. Patro, Vinay P. Namboodiri, Vijay Srinivas Agneeswaran | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Vision transformers have been applied successfully for image recognition
tasks. There have been either multi-headed self-attention based (ViT
\cite{dosovitskiy2020image}, DeIT, \cite{touvron2021training}) similar to the
original work in textual models or more recently based on spectral layers
(Fnet\cite{lee2021fnet}, GFNet\cite{rao2021global},
AFNO\cite{guibas2021efficient}). We hypothesize that both spectral and
multi-headed attention plays a major role. We investigate this hypothesis
through this work and observe that indeed combining spectral and multi-headed
attention layers provides a better transformer architecture. We thus propose
the novel Spectformer architecture for transformers that combines spectral and
multi-headed attention layers. We believe that the resulting representation
allows the transformer to capture the feature representation appropriately and
it yields improved performance over other transformer representations. For
instance, it improves the top-1 accuracy by 2\% on ImageNet compared to both
GFNet-H and LiT. SpectFormer-S reaches 84.25\% top-1 accuracy on ImageNet-1K
(state of the art for small version). Further, Spectformer-L achieves 85.7\%
that is the state of the art for the comparable base version of the
transformers. We further ensure that we obtain reasonable results in other
scenarios such as transfer learning on standard datasets such as CIFAR-10,
CIFAR-100, Oxford-IIIT-flower, and Standford Car datasets. We then investigate
its use in downstream tasks such of object detection and instance segmentation
on the MS-COCO dataset and observe that Spectformer shows consistent
performance that is comparable to the best backbones and can be further
optimized and improved. Hence, we believe that combined spectral and attention
layers are what are needed for vision transformers. | [
0.0007950148,
0.0001274469,
0.0055528991,
0.0817222074,
-0.0261590816,
-0.0182302594,
0.0575036034,
-0.0342681035,
-0.0375935435,
-0.018642731,
-0.0676488727,
-0.0208474658,
0.0206710268,
0.045344796,
0.0242224596,
-0.0516890027,
-0.0194463674,
0.0003221459,
-0.06923756,
0.0026723498,
0.006594996,
-0.0132882558,
0.0127503555,
0.0132946745,
-0.0756747648,
0.0153772058,
-0.0180199873,
-0.0218676832,
0.0798052698,
0.0115793385,
0.0091567924,
0.0342248082,
0.0190918893,
0.0140231587,
0.0000022667,
0.0152822779,
0.0151741682,
0.0126106916,
0.0016643818,
-0.0212877952,
0.0459248126,
-0.0269211326,
-0.008071037,
-0.0024277575,
-0.0240378026,
-0.0046190675,
0.0670239553,
0.0716577545,
0.0450229533,
0.0301285498,
-0.0198850017,
-0.0444843955,
0.036920391,
-0.0139215058,
-0.0139192725,
0.0064128712,
-0.0096159624,
-0.0670781881,
-0.060910549,
0.0132567361,
-0.0490117744,
0.0385011956,
0.0259771086,
0.0076855151,
0.0750859678,
0.0464234911,
-0.103830263,
-0.0224042591,
-0.0065787039,
0.0501559786,
-0.0018049994,
-0.0086678667,
-0.0183592215,
0.0529055297,
-0.0140457852,
0.0099128047,
-0.0340680704,
0.006011121,
0.0080874069,
0.003299654,
-0.0501949713,
0.0281743594,
-0.0186808184,
-0.002166851,
-0.04106123,
-0.0379109047,
-0.002904979,
0.0268971417,
0.0246420149,
-0.0117539978,
-0.0241206698,
0.0051669176,
0.0366118066,
0.0211342648,
-0.0067826784,
-0.0353206024,
-0.069622688,
-0.032251887,
-0.0176014025,
-0.0396021046,
0.0467767827,
0.0053546838,
-0.0700617805,
0.0437288806,
-0.0445397496,
0.0352190435,
-0.0522800833,
0.0493902937,
-0.0502685234,
-0.0261245091,
-0.0316347107,
0.0226544049,
-0.0607219934,
-0.011047448,
0.0419791825,
-0.0447217077,
-0.0164150447,
-0.0185837336,
0.0231855232,
-0.0262549724,
-0.0121694151,
0.0053143348,
-0.0696757883,
-0.0111420481,
0.0222866312,
0.0112930965,
0.0283187442,
-0.0152556337,
0.0173955541,
-0.0379814655,
-0.049293194,
0.0607781149,
0.0170789659,
-0.007675169,
0.0193925202,
0.0618701652,
-0.0162807591,
-0.0704129636,
0.0033445635,
0.0380888507,
-0.0137597769,
-0.0538586937,
0.0298649985,
-0.0305979252,
0.0080180354,
-0.0092742713,
-0.003778629,
0.0412840806,
0.0143901557,
0.0046154787,
0.0198862534,
0.0534308478,
0.0144793065,
-0.0119127147,
0.0334683694,
-0.0126300696,
-0.0303054545,
0.0260236561,
0.0423373878,
0.0494380593,
-0.0308124777,
-0.0314256176,
0.0215627775,
0.0124356691,
-0.0214461572,
-0.0071596187,
-0.0332582667,
-0.0156771466,
-0.0525236391,
-0.0390795767,
0.0717105418,
0.0210975688,
-0.0130678266,
-0.0205700658,
0.0423818529,
0.0108097801,
0.030750582,
0.0428509824,
0.0361696556,
0.0084081413,
0.0031270518,
0.0062509174,
-0.0672608465,
0.1012978181,
0.0142975142,
-0.0405559093,
-0.0426017307,
0.0236129034,
-0.052169323,
-0.0018598211,
0.0079049021,
-0.0079638511,
-0.0328089818,
0.0133167012,
0.0802131593,
0.0247233119,
0.0228025913,
0.1095781848,
-0.015594909,
0.0096531846,
-0.0267947149,
-0.0665348098,
-0.0276059881,
0.0240042955,
-0.0085992515,
-0.028418133,
-0.0044864975,
-0.0071832309,
0.01237485,
0.0317540728,
0.0316820331,
0.0441627428,
0.0207001362,
-0.0350704193,
-0.0066296076,
0.0055673486,
-0.0150861321,
0.023404941,
-0.019849306,
0.0049009533,
0.025525393,
-0.0373102948,
0.024986634,
0.0432149246,
0.0501667857,
-0.005863843,
-0.0080699427,
0.0087943133,
0.0224216562,
-0.041894637,
-0.0188192222,
-0.0104027996,
0.0428967662,
-0.0495486408,
0.0307148304,
-0.007638419,
-0.0251347404,
-0.0038037964,
0.0188702848,
-0.0804637671,
0.0068527032,
0.0745884329,
-0.032553073,
-0.0354539864,
0.0426479951,
-0.0388657637,
-0.03550262,
-0.0130458316,
0.0357006565,
0.0061384276,
0.0577595122,
0.0121142156,
0.0294365287,
0.0213687904,
-0.0179498997,
-0.0191025846,
-0.0320189297,
-0.0044377171,
-0.0372072309,
0.017206246,
-0.0113810031,
-0.0512925163,
-0.0229048375,
-0.0125670927,
-0.0200764071,
-0.002182099,
-0.0209847223,
-0.0329516791,
0.0140099004,
-0.0369226895,
0.0066944342,
-0.0257524084,
0.016756257,
0.0395079739,
-0.0122710438,
-0.0369234569,
0.0746028423,
-0.0567101091,
-0.0081314687,
0.0127162747,
-0.0416242853,
-0.0491357818,
-0.0101858471,
-0.0201101657,
0.0426307581,
0.0389785729,
-0.0090514813,
-0.0440636538,
-0.0456389412,
0.0282654539,
0.0484684668,
0.0235175006,
-0.0286142919,
-0.0258269608,
-0.0372533649,
-0.0271740481,
0.0036186101,
0.1122100875,
0.0344561823,
-0.0012974947,
0.0136240982,
0.026120659,
-0.0038509411,
0.0074025672,
-0.015686892,
0.0178971812,
-0.0198996998,
0.0174760185,
-0.0099543827,
0.0324352309,
-0.0251959078,
-0.0012887156,
-0.0183242951,
-0.0093307141,
0.003235454,
-0.0328991711,
0.0128638931,
-0.0030918131,
-0.0156306941,
-0.0103440667,
-0.0274141636,
-0.0402507111,
0.0231692754,
0.0023386083,
-0.0177612491,
0.025959136,
0.0112037072,
-0.0231825616,
0.0160583388,
0.0461958535,
0.0378551222,
0.0048242882,
-0.0062577385,
-0.0339609645,
-0.0127369706,
0.0216766782,
-0.0144241108,
0.0732764229,
0.0002045014,
-0.0095082242,
-0.0622877143,
-0.0190866012,
-0.0377314314,
0.0113337059,
-0.0020071454,
0.0276006572,
-0.0045723906,
-0.0088553466,
-0.0976800844,
0.0308288038,
0.028923247,
0.0888896212,
-0.0071183071,
-0.0353953093,
0.0103903636,
0.0380726419,
-0.0087680966,
0.03257294,
0.0599997416,
-0.0196673162,
0.035119839,
0.0771752745,
0.0009560994,
0.0039666481,
-0.0813578889,
-0.0050655236,
0.0217592064,
-0.0070161954,
-0.0219787341,
-0.0288568456,
0.0527863801,
-0.0788935199,
-0.0346108563,
0.0223504063,
-0.0147345066,
-0.0097191129,
0.0062021501,
0.0320181996,
-0.0314268172,
0.0100999149,
0.0166757945,
-0.0178231951,
-0.0283136349,
-0.001392186,
0.0079882545,
0.0418023318,
0.0095521342,
-0.002504779,
0.0224004574,
0.067421101,
-0.0027013416,
-0.0537889972,
-0.0179861616,
0.0158962812,
0.0090706572,
-0.047980763,
-0.0310880281,
-0.0195911303,
-0.0323620327,
-0.0305904765,
0.0270654429,
0.0182167906,
0.0045565302,
-0.005324685,
-0.0148723349,
-0.0570493266,
0.0415562838,
-0.0031852641,
0.0070698443,
-0.0617225096,
0.0152387088,
-0.012177716,
0.0153595451,
0.009965484,
0.0951409787,
-0.0032103381,
-0.0118947076,
0.0121382177,
0.0165780205,
-0.043862693,
-0.0076532648,
-0.0295784511,
0.0050861472,
-0.0025218891,
-0.0155411894,
-0.0492882989,
-0.001779823,
-0.0473280512,
0.0203988384,
0.0095139984,
-0.0072481446,
-0.0110546388,
0.0194565114,
-0.0020998847,
-0.0553248636,
-0.0702659786,
0.0276758857,
0.0295476895,
-0.0928985104,
0.0190422405,
0.002980863,
0.003908732,
0.0411869138,
-0.0068993866,
-0.0939276367,
0.0292670522,
0.0045608263,
-0.0290876795,
0.0480841286,
-0.0047140233,
0.0117068784,
-0.0611171871,
0.0032119746,
0.0741377249,
-0.0471017621,
0.0063744155,
-0.0048506148,
-0.0810088664,
0.00768096,
0.0330482386,
0.0480843931,
0.013130771,
0.0139488913,
-0.031859573,
-0.014253566,
0.0368540436,
0.0343522355,
-0.0286981761,
0.0310412273,
0.0309551731,
-0.082850717,
-0.0276907906,
0.0093860785,
-0.0330812931,
0.089198567,
0.0391167589,
-0.0355678611,
0.0051891245,
-0.0076743742,
0.0326924808,
-0.0133147808,
0.1089670211,
-0.0093171271,
0.0839715675,
-0.0081545338,
0.0336373784,
0.0651490837,
0.0035631643,
-0.0538407378,
-0.0008941781,
0.0073759705,
0.0230435114,
0.0103878872,
0.0357981734,
0.0374397077,
-0.0404572897,
-0.0065716319,
0.0260689557,
-0.0334002264,
-0.0304545332,
-0.0273473151,
0.0235694442,
-0.0123350108,
-0.0229854845,
0.0699339136,
0.0415693372,
-0.0007435812,
0.0437711403,
0.0330913626,
-0.0009696257,
-0.0531763025,
0.0236709546,
-0.0835521743,
0.0037592386,
-0.0222468153,
-0.0197979622,
-0.0039317613,
-0.040153522,
0.0197589565,
-0.0052512083,
-0.0229475554,
-0.0329338498,
0.0186583921,
0.0310540739,
0.018968353,
0.023100106,
0.0058612125,
0.0171210766,
-0.0257246941,
0.0209156834,
-0.0156850144,
-0.0390945859,
0.0251937266,
-0.0140166767,
-0.0634116977,
-0.0170485955,
-0.035974279,
-0.066031009,
0.0256724488,
0.0092696138,
-0.0230195429,
-0.0180393159,
0.0234616008,
-0.0548832491,
0.0309805721,
-0.0071705882,
0.0315180048,
0.0155387986,
0.0459194966,
-0.0662308112,
0.0134996083,
-0.0193481762,
0.0322606936,
0.0154854544,
0.0217472743,
-6.078096681e-33,
-0.0165924374,
0.0179382954,
0.0059678378,
0.0642667636,
-0.0497466139,
0.0065797004,
-0.0063301618,
0.0014392297,
-0.0345448442,
0.0215940792,
-0.0402772613,
0.0169372484,
0.0321646258,
0.0452116057,
0.0139379837,
-0.0166058335,
0.0724259168,
0.0062955464,
-0.0233467296,
-0.0032262495,
0.0161067564,
0.0230402779,
0.0808902085,
-0.0476249829,
-0.0924111903,
0.013992724,
-0.0425398871,
-0.0147819147,
0.0105056297,
0.0520551056,
-0.0174894575,
0.0277153291,
0.0002802577,
-0.0468433909,
-0.0308580659,
0.0170623232,
-0.0911399499,
0.0044946289,
-0.079525575,
0.0678040534,
-0.0514179096,
-0.0329217538,
0.0726935342,
0.0063645341,
0.0198946539,
-0.0620209761,
0.0296395048,
-0.0275719911,
-0.0144768637,
-0.0390040874,
-0.032808736,
0.0354893059,
-0.0215991624,
-0.0556751713,
0.0663848296,
0.0586927459,
-0.0171410665,
0.0119692162,
-0.0820370242,
0.0250075404,
-0.0048413086,
0.0344569795,
0.0424171314,
0.0752667785,
-0.0160084926,
0.0258324426,
0.0449144505,
-0.0569852702,
0.017870428,
-0.0826453939,
0.0284226034,
0.0669045672,
0.0397541113,
-0.0005664024,
0.0238151308,
-0.0116826091,
-0.0426553972,
0.002633529,
-0.0520277061,
0.0681276768,
0.0214205515,
-0.0017454823,
-0.0224301554,
0.0001909649,
0.013314683,
0.0120413173,
-0.0389230773,
0.0199302491,
0.0140344622,
0.0394367017,
-0.0255318806,
0.0389555879,
0.0150360772,
-0.0247342922,
0.0161577296,
-0.0192940738,
0.0030119822,
0.0402593836,
0.0129547985,
0.0074533313,
-0.0430724099,
-0.021501286,
0.0330098979,
0.0602353774,
-0.0004260604,
0.0111620445,
0.0846001282,
0.0766500533,
-0.0502764434,
-0.0253927615,
-0.0403693952,
0.0026136152,
0.0158649404,
0.0600487292,
0.0254337564,
-0.0061834222,
-0.0132099539,
0.056246195,
-0.0386141576,
-0.0316587798,
-0.0314313695,
0.0309261885,
0.0525362901,
0.0395562202,
-0.0158100929,
0.0125699872,
-0.06674622,
-0.0083010541,
0.0303244852,
-0.0608373582,
-0.0343141258,
0.028294839,
2.957e-7,
0.0180174559,
-0.0021684323,
-0.010179366,
-0.0441448167,
0.0060243304,
0.0606923327,
-0.0045957849,
0.0714568645,
-0.0277747959,
0.0100456644,
0.0005750431,
0.0815554485,
0.0133402441,
-0.0018320595,
-0.0399420522,
-0.0262033585,
0.0280822366,
0.0293516908,
0.010634372,
-0.0134245567,
0.0227131173,
0.1023448333,
-0.0248616431,
-0.0174598489,
0.0411243401,
0.0132722687,
0.0530426987,
0.0000921885,
0.0258020777,
0.0210181233,
-0.0320627913,
0.0475054607,
-0.0520123988,
0.0528845005,
-0.0275338888,
0.0087639438,
0.0017245922,
0.0199983735,
-0.0252213478,
-0.008947962,
0.0361277536,
0.0453698859,
0.0318222791,
-0.0295943432,
0.0363028049,
-0.0801587924,
-0.0559357144,
-0.0244700406,
-0.0491562262,
0.007620668,
-0.0243223999,
0.0023682441,
0.0132719185,
0.0129097421,
0.0064554089,
-0.0348406956,
-0.0563413985,
-0.0884612426,
0.0064894296,
-0.0166597869,
-0.0270507764,
-0.0092646433,
-0.0514520444,
-0.020342458,
0.0651269257,
0.0578787439,
-0.0706125125,
2.343159496e-34,
0.0022619343,
0.0113858525,
0.0069200001,
0.0085658906,
-0.050735198,
-0.0092146387,
-0.0005223079,
-0.0039067115,
-0.0037380815,
-0.0344106331,
-0.0290193129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06377v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06377v3 | Emergence of Symbols in Neural Networks for Semantic Understanding and Communication | 2023-04-13T10:13:00 | 2023-06-25T05:53:06 | Yang Chen, Liangxuan Guo, Shan Yu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SC, q-bio.NC | The capacity to generate meaningful symbols and effectively employ them for
advanced cognitive processes, such as communication, reasoning, and planning,
constitutes a fundamental and distinctive aspect of human intelligence.
Existing deep neural networks still notably lag human capabilities in terms of
generating symbols for higher cognitive functions. Here, we propose a solution
(symbol emergence artificial network (SEA-net)) to endow neural networks with
the ability to create symbols, understand semantics, and achieve communication.
SEA-net generates symbols that dynamically configure the network to perform
specific tasks. These symbols capture compositional semantic information that
allows the system to acquire new functions purely by symbolic manipulation or
communication. In addition, these self-generated symbols exhibit an intrinsic
structure resembling that of natural language, suggesting a common framework
underlying the generation and understanding of symbols in both human brains and
artificial neural networks. We believe that the proposed framework will be
instrumental in producing more capable systems that can synergize the strengths
of connectionist and symbolic approaches for artificial intelligence (AI). | [
0.0051825969,
0.0631030425,
-0.0597228296,
0.0134937307,
-0.018844448,
0.0026984983,
0.0080337692,
-0.0013110602,
-0.0001191568,
0.0051515568,
0.0007133175,
0.0021562413,
-0.0245357435,
0.0464344956,
0.0363833569,
-0.0289425179,
0.0361709408,
0.032282047,
0.0262166578,
0.0004723139,
-0.0473109931,
-0.0108978739,
0.0231352989,
0.0219222177,
-0.0676718578,
0.0082925465,
-0.0388371982,
-0.006471992,
0.0206622873,
-0.0394695774,
-0.0634426773,
-0.0097663719,
0.0341615826,
0.0340933464,
0.0000019883,
-0.0287519172,
0.0450244695,
-0.0084001115,
-0.035548117,
-0.0439045504,
0.0167691112,
-0.0358750746,
0.0096568866,
-0.0174093284,
-0.0609636158,
0.0011833715,
0.0416127443,
0.0205218773,
0.0093816267,
0.0290345084,
-0.0094108796,
-0.0220026691,
0.0422458611,
-0.0255415197,
0.017551573,
-0.0053531444,
-0.0053976732,
-0.0047996892,
-0.0213204492,
-0.0228175446,
-0.0235993769,
0.0312347263,
0.0854368955,
0.0290475376,
0.0107822279,
0.060154248,
0.0172931291,
-0.0247185156,
-0.0187494885,
0.0494607911,
-0.0556130782,
-0.0327984244,
0.0091848308,
-0.0162154119,
0.0588331819,
-0.0009717278,
0.0005547794,
0.0282511543,
0.0320127346,
0.0453423187,
0.0622129142,
0.0111509543,
0.0392909721,
0.0182024911,
-0.0123385675,
0.0398812965,
-0.0165571067,
0.0236992519,
0.0089863744,
-0.0479963757,
-0.0293256566,
-0.0395739339,
0.0020246902,
0.0638023689,
0.0283322819,
0.0124250818,
-0.0324757174,
-0.0263233036,
-0.0083243018,
-0.0637407005,
0.0431175455,
0.0535699464,
0.0158731993,
0.0274438988,
-0.0761170611,
0.0314335711,
-0.0400246717,
0.0498593561,
-0.042533081,
-0.0109137371,
-0.0538370013,
-0.0337258354,
-0.0526367389,
0.0618986599,
-0.0049889972,
-0.03666538,
-0.0225526411,
0.0546194017,
-0.016510861,
-0.015496959,
-0.0556007512,
0.0273205414,
0.005177116,
-0.0016363157,
-0.0222872011,
-0.0260377787,
-0.0413970239,
0.009656027,
0.0100708762,
-0.0010072853,
0.0086729154,
0.0179737676,
-0.0086581176,
0.0330426171,
0.0328470133,
0.1083595157,
-0.0124722496,
-0.0171412677,
-0.0164164193,
-0.0611203425,
0.0344903767,
-0.0336739607,
0.0373536721,
-0.0170244388,
0.0502750538,
-0.0180121716,
-0.0489555113,
-0.0848265067,
0.0185366515,
-0.0231788829,
0.0346558429,
0.0319106095,
-0.0570055582,
-0.0012477955,
0.0315935127,
0.0048829387,
0.0145392623,
0.0067164642,
0.0894038901,
0.0428433977,
-0.017304657,
0.0280190185,
-0.0319265388,
-0.0050371173,
0.0259575788,
-0.0390567742,
-0.0446366146,
-0.0633166209,
-0.0290221609,
0.0592829175,
-0.0449435003,
0.0226404704,
-0.0327513963,
-0.0457250811,
0.0214747414,
0.0771489516,
0.0701801255,
0.0575853027,
0.0991810039,
-0.033627633,
-0.0030545681,
-0.0611624904,
-0.0478850156,
0.0521217547,
-0.0244975574,
-0.012806708,
-0.0941796973,
0.0008386302,
-0.024593858,
-0.0512694642,
0.039524477,
-0.0172241796,
0.0084010931,
0.0084963413,
0.0180646125,
0.0132348426,
-0.0191501714,
0.0007163563,
-0.023477111,
0.0007563069,
0.0364826433,
-0.0647600964,
0.0367128178,
0.0629597679,
0.0007616811,
-0.0095826043,
-0.0009442585,
0.0001230627,
-0.0277717654,
0.0620116182,
0.0018074692,
-0.0014843332,
-0.0001829727,
-0.0156145738,
0.0235950127,
0.0176764876,
-0.0016858667,
0.0457548089,
-0.0273163803,
0.0435733385,
0.0102892127,
-0.016029885,
-0.0172903221,
0.0497049019,
0.0433643013,
0.0197665077,
0.0311632212,
0.0018711635,
0.0286706258,
0.0292361602,
-0.0076375268,
0.0111727556,
0.0320641436,
-0.0675548017,
-0.0958623067,
0.0362649448,
-0.0506954789,
0.044649072,
0.0353120081,
-0.0771632493,
0.0431378707,
0.0376571715,
0.0280475747,
-0.0271584745,
0.0582906902,
-0.0493039675,
0.0288093109,
-0.0352436677,
-0.0319087394,
-0.0016937316,
0.0349722728,
0.008576381,
0.0686836317,
-0.0073640654,
-0.0696981177,
-0.0202321596,
0.0400112607,
0.0048529985,
-0.0112917703,
-0.0064403727,
-0.0078331335,
-0.018834902,
-0.0143140098,
0.0003449621,
0.0314007849,
-0.0036184229,
-0.0284424666,
-0.0382182375,
0.0162716322,
0.0018688871,
-0.0263578892,
-0.0000413916,
-0.0401992202,
0.0285468027,
0.0115383724,
-0.0241869483,
0.0990368277,
0.0106853703,
-0.017123308,
0.059351977,
-0.000029762,
-0.0643550158,
-0.0104158875,
-0.040943373,
-0.0470842272,
0.0579755083,
0.0877616256,
-0.0064819581,
-0.0302164797,
0.0053378101,
-0.0281346664,
-0.0021050987,
-0.0181320868,
-0.0533078648,
0.038229309,
-0.0167009942,
-0.0625670627,
0.0386450849,
0.0100349728,
0.0654138923,
0.0228912234,
0.0304323472,
-0.0417730622,
0.0104961209,
-0.0504265428,
0.0626030862,
-0.0227409899,
-0.0071900995,
-0.0108121904,
0.0480327122,
0.0135827949,
0.0136110345,
-0.0202758778,
0.0505326465,
0.0236871075,
-0.0585612096,
-0.0206693783,
-0.0532101169,
-0.0063718152,
0.0501371697,
0.0029358214,
-0.0266481806,
0.0361601077,
0.0491234809,
-0.0030891001,
-0.0025707181,
-0.0344018601,
-0.0146209365,
0.0924999267,
-0.0005401702,
0.0187409092,
0.0145926196,
-0.030740859,
-0.0291861705,
0.0084884521,
-0.0033111172,
-0.0138332276,
-0.0121171307,
-0.0314436927,
-0.0128277587,
0.0250250455,
0.009019522,
-0.0562447831,
0.0339274295,
-0.0145977708,
0.0255322121,
-0.00715377,
-0.0069673429,
-0.0004646739,
-0.0324613042,
0.0007903509,
-0.0091643715,
0.0359636955,
-0.0126671446,
-0.0460045598,
-0.0440571159,
0.0212624557,
0.0345408022,
0.0451038219,
0.0075322855,
0.0251364019,
-0.0034442551,
-0.0288060214,
0.0163028389,
-0.0501056127,
0.0460398495,
-0.0116715245,
-0.013145037,
-0.009229226,
0.0357722715,
-0.0096335234,
-0.0327378251,
0.0045905532,
0.0516216233,
0.0323255025,
-0.0147465784,
0.031273786,
0.0222875327,
-0.0378746092,
0.0254142731,
0.03492181,
-0.1129876897,
-0.0117161451,
-0.0114958389,
-0.0548612215,
-0.0120540038,
-0.0378567278,
-0.0136903701,
-0.0268136077,
0.025219202,
-0.0072650774,
-0.1098803654,
-0.0151087521,
0.0097156148,
-0.0244858898,
0.0434995964,
-0.0355208293,
0.0171370301,
0.0422005653,
-0.0218272768,
-0.0014902323,
-0.0077566463,
-0.0158792362,
-0.0475461669,
-0.0298318937,
0.0074094618,
0.0223616362,
0.0241030976,
-0.0396518856,
-0.0195289273,
0.0069369641,
-0.0038488146,
0.0292127021,
-0.0263281558,
-0.0155235035,
0.013368018,
-0.0386139937,
-0.0387425274,
0.0399587676,
-0.0718252361,
-0.0368443765,
-0.0298291575,
0.0631640404,
-0.0237268806,
-0.0319657773,
-0.0453082882,
0.0142653752,
-0.0058620162,
0.020101184,
0.0150083937,
-0.06803938,
-0.0163348559,
0.0103536453,
0.0063154632,
-0.022408478,
-0.0544311404,
-0.0006756489,
0.0424182229,
-0.0617892891,
-0.0601940714,
-0.0341116488,
0.0071908864,
0.021095356,
0.0505683757,
-0.0446407646,
0.0073260544,
-0.0234428216,
-0.0550797619,
-0.0082144914,
0.0005049124,
-0.0118395938,
0.0182200801,
-0.0321576819,
-0.0233706068,
-0.0783665478,
-0.0312302765,
0.0282382518,
-0.0494053513,
-0.0423042662,
0.0260166451,
0.0277235974,
0.0153747564,
-0.0540801026,
-0.0028686658,
-0.0195489749,
0.039802704,
0.0897747576,
0.0107615432,
-0.0081157852,
-0.0131638832,
-0.0041181701,
0.0168937519,
0.0329132937,
-0.0231630728,
0.0659124404,
-0.0040624728,
0.0071853683,
-0.0544948727,
0.0411987193,
0.022837488,
-0.007654083,
-0.025232885,
-0.0055914302,
-0.0486017503,
-0.036252182,
-0.0321449228,
-0.0159223564,
0.0085018016,
-0.0474790074,
0.0171325132,
-0.0124008516,
0.0370614752,
0.011731267,
-0.0561422706,
0.063115783,
0.0118291611,
0.0451750159,
0.0094873067,
0.0102990782,
0.0537086353,
-0.0355983712,
0.0284708049,
0.015868146,
0.0347702727,
-0.0413279496,
-0.0004322061,
-0.0219123866,
0.007276597,
0.0296344757,
-0.0028073473,
-0.0506104529,
0.0069002337,
-0.0515656136,
-0.1142538115,
0.0353529379,
0.0340883583,
0.063346833,
0.0657255799,
-0.0330749713,
-0.081980221,
0.0311509874,
0.0358998589,
0.0216360893,
-0.0398489684,
-0.0255324524,
0.0194715671,
0.0327992365,
0.0002059165,
-0.0525463335,
0.0002554069,
-0.0632709116,
0.0356532,
-0.0201801546,
0.044207789,
-0.0392869525,
0.0067125745,
0.0110427449,
0.0392792448,
-0.0002666485,
0.05025886,
-0.0347760022,
-0.034317337,
0.058808174,
0.0751564726,
0.0548443757,
0.0345853716,
0.0646756068,
0.0137302624,
-0.0010199978,
-0.0535536036,
0.0215036981,
-0.0027189618,
0.0022648943,
-0.0447115712,
-0.015828684,
-5.844543219e-33,
-0.000836236,
-0.0443138927,
0.0059512202,
0.0389311537,
-0.0203951988,
0.0042756824,
-0.0211890936,
0.0279317573,
-0.0117619745,
0.0361875184,
-0.0024682826,
0.0462597795,
-0.0000569504,
-0.0239756424,
0.0271477252,
-0.0489322096,
-0.0006738736,
-0.0380972028,
0.0361999422,
0.0149017759,
0.0402683243,
0.0194511823,
0.026084749,
-0.0652449876,
-0.0274405442,
0.0292876195,
-0.005924887,
-0.0027871646,
-0.0026792304,
0.0146685401,
-0.0085946638,
0.032417357,
0.0270535108,
0.0124254469,
0.0135194398,
0.0033462029,
-0.0364423133,
-0.0603735782,
-0.0038454297,
0.0135137234,
-0.0699178502,
-0.0565207377,
0.0768536851,
-0.038071584,
-0.0280829985,
0.0135530671,
0.0339814685,
0.0129570654,
-0.0040828213,
-0.0624379516,
-0.0472984388,
-0.0232734419,
-0.0011783635,
0.0031637014,
-0.0014228708,
-0.0424562693,
-0.026863914,
-0.0304300804,
-0.0552459955,
0.0435723662,
-0.0400070325,
-0.0377769992,
0.0033176763,
0.006212268,
0.0199364889,
0.039717894,
0.0810013935,
-0.0108267758,
-0.0062703313,
0.0184160229,
0.0644993186,
0.0522990897,
0.0548062734,
0.0228546895,
0.0670093074,
-0.0251007117,
-0.0665842816,
-0.034668915,
0.044580806,
-0.0077271392,
0.0256777499,
-0.0093193185,
-0.0011634696,
0.022399703,
-0.0192476623,
-0.0018602133,
-0.0368901528,
-0.0331579335,
0.0027409727,
-0.0023822966,
0.0045848079,
0.019772375,
0.0034863465,
-0.0599173084,
0.0362275951,
-0.0042165555,
0.0504311621,
0.0343895741,
0.0353853889,
-0.0288091041,
-0.0182124116,
-0.0477387905,
-0.0078840153,
0.0160490088,
0.0488204621,
0.0393776633,
0.0118533075,
0.0358558819,
0.0114371972,
-0.0168750547,
-0.0087455679,
-0.015955301,
0.0398097187,
-0.104616724,
0.011859932,
0.021461254,
-0.0192579105,
-0.0345741212,
-0.0075063617,
0.0055756662,
-0.01842607,
0.0562770106,
-0.0195937846,
0.0422595814,
-0.0430856459,
-0.0199159496,
-0.0533966608,
0.0436504409,
0.0361107104,
-0.090813987,
-0.0200891476,
0.0462755822,
2.858e-7,
0.0051241056,
0.02162751,
0.0224048607,
0.0813689008,
0.0406638011,
-0.0125675332,
0.0360107608,
-0.0014178816,
-0.0158251524,
-0.0219945554,
0.0303260833,
0.0602326728,
-0.0380378217,
0.0083084349,
-0.0623023994,
0.0315316655,
0.0172163658,
-0.0296752527,
-0.0148286903,
0.0237753522,
0.0827665031,
0.0633627102,
0.0316891335,
-0.0294884816,
0.0149784014,
-0.0008706568,
0.0228075571,
-0.0354624689,
0.0671869293,
-0.0346242562,
-0.0173513237,
-0.0006014433,
-0.0098121138,
0.047480043,
0.0124579966,
0.0103105158,
0.0038006131,
-0.0279828161,
-0.0259931199,
0.0116711743,
-0.0174324531,
-0.0045791767,
-0.011725625,
0.0043305275,
0.0355144478,
-0.1112531573,
-0.0215571877,
0.0159221757,
0.0150921298,
0.0104680033,
0.0003560479,
0.0050236541,
-0.0011576314,
-0.0124560036,
0.0078984369,
-0.0006630655,
0.0385264382,
-0.0466215424,
0.0395116322,
0.0419508405,
-0.0301410798,
0.0276122019,
-0.0526441112,
-0.0336706899,
0.0502846614,
-0.0243301801,
-0.0458272398,
1.845650224e-34,
-0.0133808041,
-0.0348966792,
0.0256359726,
0.0385194793,
0.0208154228,
0.0135293696,
-0.0600706637,
0.0103988908,
0.0414610207,
-0.0289720111,
-0.0397973247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06375v1 | Towards hypergraph cognitive networks as feature-rich models of knowledge | 2023-04-13T09:56:45 | 2023-04-13T09:56:45 | Salvatore Citraro, Simon De Deyne, Massimo Stella, Giulio Rossetti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Semantic networks provide a useful tool to understand how related concepts
are retrieved from memory. However, most current network approaches use
pairwise links to represent memory recall patterns. Pairwise connections
neglect higher-order associations, i.e. relationships between more than two
concepts at a time. These higher-order interactions might covariate with (and
thus contain information about) how similar concepts are along psycholinguistic
dimensions like arousal, valence, familiarity, gender and others. We overcome
these limits by introducing feature-rich cognitive hypergraphs as quantitative
models of human memory where: (i) concepts recalled together can all engage in
hyperlinks involving also more than two concepts at once (cognitive hypergraph
aspect), and (ii) each concept is endowed with a vector of psycholinguistic
features (feature-rich aspect). We build hypergraphs from word association data
and use evaluation methods from machine learning features to predict concept
concreteness. Since concepts with similar concreteness tend to cluster together
in human memory, we expect to be able to leverage this structure. Using word
association data from the Small World of Words dataset, we compared a pairwise
network and a hypergraph with N=3586 concepts/nodes. Interpretable artificial
intelligence models trained on (1) psycholinguistic features only, (2)
pairwise-based feature aggregations, and on (3) hypergraph-based aggregations
show significant differences between pairwise and hypergraph links.
Specifically, our results show that higher-order and feature-rich hypergraph
models contain richer information than pairwise networks leading to improved
prediction of word concreteness. The relation with previous studies about
conceptual clustering and compartmentalisation in associative knowledge and
human memory are discussed. | [
0.004360233,
0.0132499514,
-0.0217468943,
0.0099659376,
-0.0050413967,
0.0158561561,
0.0037105263,
-0.0079115257,
0.0374874733,
-0.0141313011,
-0.0152993435,
-0.0313548297,
0.0314698927,
0.0380935892,
0.0256957915,
-0.0346833058,
0.0267525502,
0.0300406516,
0.0479216315,
0.0077059246,
-0.0033657884,
0.0345615856,
-0.025264211,
-0.0027455885,
-0.0275749341,
0.0016057958,
-0.0043155858,
0.0009672834,
0.0348537788,
-0.0419732742,
-0.042885121,
0.0342619792,
0.0187313221,
-0.0225763656,
0.000001902,
-0.0735839307,
0.0046897116,
-0.0247629303,
0.0061696689,
0.0080809435,
0.0061673932,
-0.0209582634,
0.0154183852,
-0.04337072,
-0.0097058462,
-0.0304402281,
0.0416570939,
0.0467347838,
0.0079232538,
-0.0029977623,
-0.0247083437,
-0.0432638824,
0.0483627021,
0.0220980439,
0.0360818803,
-0.0049509415,
0.0293282326,
0.0314372182,
-0.0594288409,
-0.0387838483,
-0.0118873166,
-0.0195742603,
0.0030068066,
0.0468726866,
0.0369366258,
0.0306113306,
-0.035274975,
0.0082682902,
0.0137718404,
0.0981716067,
-0.0167211834,
0.0039232466,
0.0257011745,
0.0110908989,
-0.014085683,
0.0574771762,
-0.0307317544,
-0.0035196072,
-0.0396420173,
-0.0169430245,
-0.0020100088,
0.0031945661,
0.0172100849,
0.0317703225,
-0.0134506337,
0.0527932793,
-0.0128819933,
-0.0095134461,
0.0598458014,
-0.0235855523,
-0.0593204051,
0.0055678678,
0.0068054087,
0.0087920539,
0.0509388298,
0.0467338115,
0.0321424045,
0.0110952323,
0.0368181095,
-0.0490987413,
-0.0008745048,
-0.0024516198,
-0.0038747939,
0.0021981881,
-0.0540731214,
0.0259215571,
-0.0095584998,
-0.0145369871,
-0.0209383275,
0.0029368692,
-0.0853216127,
0.0011821899,
-0.0198924821,
0.0950052664,
0.045314271,
-0.0237130448,
-0.0865798295,
0.0230077729,
-0.0494093373,
0.0334142931,
-0.0225439947,
0.034338627,
0.0341786966,
0.0005464385,
-0.0337011628,
-0.0036006991,
-0.0430849791,
0.0236022044,
-0.0085892342,
0.0215425119,
0.0378923155,
-0.0017142801,
-0.0004902488,
-0.0127623584,
-0.0016857671,
0.0382316299,
0.0258095432,
-0.0299650207,
-0.0406246483,
-0.0866247788,
-0.0086339954,
-0.0343865976,
0.0395956337,
-0.0619119778,
0.0223284401,
0.0308467261,
-0.0080702212,
-0.050061848,
-0.0062484513,
-0.0075358143,
-0.0826424435,
0.0308378711,
0.0301203039,
-0.0183455516,
0.0106518418,
0.0089616301,
-0.019904701,
-0.031471543,
0.0417090915,
0.0539257564,
0.0191872492,
0.0033523291,
-0.0142935626,
-0.0253396053,
0.0063962797,
-0.0181675367,
-0.0470587946,
-0.03072902,
0.020481864,
0.0374399424,
0.010376323,
0.047231324,
-0.0338825621,
-0.0096903862,
0.0146146268,
0.0603793673,
0.0150099844,
0.0428026617,
0.0430436954,
-0.0249852687,
0.0298993643,
0.0135260783,
-0.0376830101,
0.0286369771,
-0.038298443,
0.0356470458,
0.0170201436,
0.0124729555,
-0.0402478613,
-0.0313504487,
0.0073403707,
-0.0216677692,
0.0597409047,
-0.0299960095,
0.0560527407,
-0.0082218684,
-0.0245615821,
0.0241986662,
0.0597935878,
-0.0331839211,
-0.0069619226,
-0.0110073229,
-0.0088922819,
0.0729298145,
0.0083773527,
-0.019585643,
0.0182068795,
0.0179069135,
-0.0667286515,
-0.0393070653,
-0.0109141488,
0.0023804186,
-0.0162313581,
-0.0519978292,
0.0357277356,
0.0046446035,
-0.0082457317,
0.0683099255,
-0.0471753851,
0.0024733345,
0.0022692739,
0.016215533,
-0.0005586767,
-0.0302923918,
-0.0069447863,
0.0254304968,
-0.0258929227,
0.0162718203,
0.0179540385,
0.0358675048,
0.0112228431,
0.0120947333,
0.0303628799,
-0.0249058027,
-0.0138972886,
-0.0219824072,
-0.0353610404,
-0.0148322033,
-0.0170444567,
-0.0052671931,
0.0342920758,
0.0039822138,
0.0020542089,
-0.0247251056,
0.0667596906,
-0.015097891,
0.0889545679,
-0.0199470446,
0.0054711765,
0.0069373725,
0.0127733154,
0.0229395367,
0.1040254161,
-0.0334031247,
0.0206703879,
-0.0288347993,
-0.0155088492,
0.0234812144,
-0.0224548038,
-0.0145948017,
0.0230519641,
0.020201534,
-0.0048592677,
0.0049211504,
-0.0676215589,
-0.0778505281,
0.0267012399,
-0.0708010122,
-0.0145651773,
0.0296475105,
-0.0243544318,
-0.0145825632,
-0.0369035527,
-0.0012807139,
0.0029479722,
-0.0307531729,
0.0869206563,
-0.0216832086,
0.0391609073,
0.012804104,
0.0033776911,
-0.0312280804,
-0.0190633591,
-0.0459051505,
-0.052292265,
0.0741470382,
0.0200341884,
-0.0378444046,
0.0436934754,
0.0479932912,
-0.0925444663,
-0.0268414225,
-0.0093815355,
-0.014563119,
-0.0142163839,
0.0125207035,
-0.0089172749,
0.0574660785,
0.0063004741,
0.0205827039,
0.043961525,
-0.0183482673,
-0.0182281863,
-0.0238179378,
-0.052810926,
0.0148671865,
0.0264882501,
-0.00163827,
-0.0456971042,
0.0317938775,
0.0819566324,
-0.0048084203,
-0.016729949,
0.012206818,
0.0079622343,
0.0003849964,
-0.0624775812,
-0.0610048883,
-0.0010881345,
0.0149434712,
-0.0117687769,
-0.0444361567,
0.0418379083,
0.0375541821,
0.0531882942,
0.0047786161,
-0.0022860218,
-0.0055492669,
0.062739715,
0.0362273119,
0.039803043,
0.039375335,
-0.0420297943,
-0.0361750536,
-0.0298502333,
0.0030327549,
-0.0516281351,
0.025785666,
-0.0410464257,
-0.0233446639,
0.0434858128,
0.0365220644,
-0.0242889095,
0.0099225929,
-0.0212036446,
0.0292351469,
0.0102550015,
-0.0128069865,
-0.0066799172,
-0.0333780721,
0.0180572737,
-0.0533152409,
0.0366993807,
-0.0436737873,
0.0259272978,
0.0883746743,
0.0295043886,
-0.02831362,
0.0299585648,
-0.0027639472,
-0.0082060173,
0.0426215343,
-0.0112419305,
-0.0298228543,
-0.0197878666,
0.0413846411,
-0.019619219,
-0.0355204567,
-0.0139537295,
-0.0032574965,
-0.0250680782,
-0.0313215926,
0.0219751578,
0.0746280998,
0.0578830726,
-0.0653749183,
0.0338044614,
0.0369544216,
0.0172590073,
0.0333933868,
-0.0184905417,
-0.0331741571,
0.022566488,
-0.0271658804,
-0.0168169755,
-0.029145686,
-0.0580501668,
0.0077977264,
-0.0638436973,
-0.028195519,
0.0090000341,
-0.0596479066,
0.006445603,
-0.044970572,
-0.0127362432,
0.015314606,
-0.0259201191,
-0.0244131535,
0.0116095124,
-0.021432681,
0.0144298086,
-0.0300937928,
0.0210664142,
0.0645268708,
-0.0018553565,
0.0518567041,
-0.0309043135,
0.054667443,
-0.0246671941,
-0.0496202111,
-0.0242314637,
-0.0653832406,
0.0566865802,
0.00340092,
0.049662374,
0.0158727914,
0.0203636847,
-0.0510966778,
0.0160607304,
-0.0229936279,
-0.0558890626,
-0.0191163383,
0.0633554012,
-0.0223562345,
-0.0195078813,
-0.0229243636,
0.0076309443,
-0.0285025109,
0.0529139638,
-0.0069314227,
-0.0179258175,
0.0289966408,
-0.0061655259,
0.0407604575,
0.027180491,
-0.0433000587,
0.0023102423,
-0.0125049213,
0.0410342142,
-0.0643548071,
-0.022183381,
-0.0069919261,
0.0236461144,
-0.0227063689,
-0.0067846086,
0.0300855841,
-0.0247897059,
-0.1044750363,
0.0551532432,
0.0431240574,
-0.0353307202,
0.0100463051,
-0.0497800298,
0.0591199361,
-0.0344991721,
-0.0219200552,
-0.0001432447,
0.0227268953,
-0.0250416026,
-0.0073522571,
-0.0103736278,
0.0144725339,
0.0373489149,
0.0275934264,
0.0007045067,
0.0409245677,
0.011961136,
-0.0689591691,
-0.0070916638,
-0.0300251059,
0.0552514903,
-0.006818912,
0.0135140698,
-0.040791072,
0.0355414376,
0.0214147288,
-0.0251621921,
-0.0258105006,
-0.0485199578,
0.0226960666,
0.0317194536,
0.048079405,
0.014940328,
-0.0095663741,
-0.0358440615,
-0.021643864,
0.0161313824,
-0.0031887498,
0.025879899,
-0.0131725427,
0.0133216837,
0.0045645782,
-0.056835264,
-0.071492523,
0.0411974713,
0.0019557297,
0.0141742192,
-0.0427522585,
-0.0242695212,
-0.0051008975,
-0.0140233571,
0.0313847736,
-0.0227394234,
-0.0266728681,
-0.0375023633,
0.0071752123,
-0.0148697542,
0.0627159774,
-0.0149544645,
-0.0350012854,
-0.0870396569,
0.0275843535,
-0.0176716261,
-0.0022515734,
0.0237611122,
-0.0345145017,
0.0351306498,
-0.0419756733,
-0.0042888504,
-0.0616406687,
0.012708365,
-0.0240608696,
0.0178655889,
-0.0224609468,
-0.0267210696,
0.0149978762,
0.0351516753,
0.0117144501,
0.0394182019,
0.0306554735,
-0.0462471247,
0.0333843976,
0.0140596628,
-0.0588468872,
-0.0257737823,
0.027890401,
0.0482778922,
0.088978,
-0.0104999729,
0.0278652199,
-0.0941321477,
-0.0473527573,
0.0689451396,
-0.0121280132,
0.0416450389,
0.037619181,
0.0837123096,
0.0197297391,
-0.0310999621,
-0.0047722002,
-0.0250332616,
0.0090267528,
-0.0562953278,
-0.0000709326,
0.0106984004,
-6.063730671e-33,
0.0075907344,
-0.0523617975,
-0.019608086,
0.0171179362,
-0.053559754,
0.0217646398,
-0.0185164139,
0.024203781,
-0.027410619,
0.0326205865,
0.0177813172,
-0.0150747709,
-0.0120969005,
-0.019064283,
0.0237032343,
0.0333476029,
-0.0123799583,
0.0324740745,
0.0029618866,
0.037668027,
0.1137220636,
-0.0036526916,
0.0464133359,
-0.0933099687,
0.0003335123,
0.0071241823,
0.0384544507,
-0.0039878329,
0.0168951955,
0.0618558042,
-0.010907854,
0.0835087001,
0.0405692793,
-0.0270150341,
0.0188242383,
0.0426293835,
-0.0869723856,
-0.0525921285,
0.0182184651,
-0.0365607999,
-0.0232138745,
-0.0442925058,
0.0535656847,
-0.0173866469,
-0.0033014372,
-0.0277264751,
0.064252235,
-0.0135838697,
-0.0570118539,
-0.0626654848,
-0.0391782783,
-0.0058980929,
-0.0229987055,
0.033365123,
-0.0205742922,
-0.0363944285,
-0.0311128814,
-0.0052629877,
-0.1103894934,
0.0269019045,
-0.0761539713,
-0.0212201849,
0.0321315713,
0.0207813382,
0.0554644838,
0.0942152962,
0.0530355386,
0.0324166156,
0.0169968791,
0.0766256228,
0.0174750201,
0.039022658,
-0.0044415002,
0.0119467266,
0.0391438045,
-0.0503188632,
-0.0600668602,
-0.0159080606,
-0.0262953509,
0.0151871638,
0.042323187,
-0.0006478109,
-0.0559099428,
-0.02618552,
-0.0402624421,
0.0526827648,
-0.0411795788,
-0.0687082112,
-0.0142341359,
-0.0426823124,
-0.004355331,
0.0180948377,
-0.0198425408,
-0.018779831,
0.0059894701,
0.06617596,
0.0038845718,
0.0542854182,
0.001899966,
-0.0060002692,
-0.0262443982,
-0.0216407105,
-0.0485498719,
-0.0030691142,
0.0424193665,
0.0378047116,
0.0020271209,
-0.0090078656,
-0.0221682098,
-0.0228278823,
-0.0125229042,
-0.0640929341,
0.0049003037,
-0.0921915248,
0.0256685466,
0.0520988889,
-0.0202653389,
0.0244142171,
0.0326344408,
0.0005588101,
0.0001825234,
0.021834664,
-0.0277117323,
0.0292595569,
-0.0169630218,
-0.0122671314,
0.007318587,
-0.0217316113,
0.0690749139,
-0.0168738384,
0.0023941265,
0.0140578505,
2.873e-7,
0.0019047976,
0.0451801643,
0.0028985692,
-0.0303028952,
0.0220334511,
0.0015195787,
0.0118335793,
0.0053400868,
0.0117616011,
-0.0669393018,
0.0067519592,
0.0677757114,
-0.045916263,
0.0277274717,
-0.030291358,
0.0211528577,
0.0048848377,
-0.0332414806,
-0.0415185988,
0.04933751,
0.0699299499,
0.0393899083,
0.0534702539,
0.0111096306,
-0.0230315439,
-0.0271492098,
0.0120586008,
-0.0086741801,
-0.0072955708,
-0.0081309332,
-0.0158061553,
-0.0089073237,
-0.0192317255,
0.0817477778,
0.025584355,
-0.0156464316,
0.0483224094,
-0.0358117744,
-0.0061366041,
-0.0416240767,
0.0102756768,
-0.0201502051,
-0.002557728,
-0.0181903578,
0.0425695926,
-0.0644958913,
-0.0648634732,
0.070013009,
-0.0160683244,
0.0331574008,
0.0277269613,
0.0434019081,
0.0145512307,
0.007281513,
-0.0272939261,
0.0215202346,
0.0264561623,
-0.0590704158,
0.0521449745,
0.105129838,
0.0047418503,
-0.0555896685,
0.0222460162,
-0.0317166597,
0.0497762077,
-0.0503988974,
-0.0054239766,
1.997602269e-34,
-0.0117248138,
-0.0071958825,
0.0161438938,
-0.019076651,
0.0310126562,
-0.0576494858,
-0.0583920702,
0.015996471,
0.0591240413,
-0.1061870903,
0.0187050328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06371v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06371v2 | Sign Language Translation from Instructional Videos | 2023-04-13T09:50:43 | 2023-04-14T08:43:20 | Laia Tarrés, Gerard I. Gállego, Amanda Duarte, Jordi Torres, Xavier Giró-i-Nieto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The advances in automatic sign language translation (SLT) to spoken languages
have been mostly benchmarked with datasets of limited size and restricted
domains. Our work advances the state of the art by providing the first baseline
results on How2Sign, a large and broad dataset.
We train a Transformer over I3D video features, using the reduced BLEU as a
reference metric for validation, instead of the widely used BLEU score. We
report a result of 8.03 on the BLEU score, and publish the first open-source
implementation of its kind to promote further advances. | [
-0.0275443681,
0.0244862009,
-0.0010769002,
0.025854215,
0.0043062717,
0.0175996888,
0.0665984228,
0.0013856012,
0.0080304453,
-0.0691531897,
-0.0250072554,
-0.0211096518,
0.0553638339,
0.0416330546,
0.0192122608,
-0.1066472158,
0.0018510096,
-0.034844365,
-0.0586639903,
-0.0088977423,
0.0296457969,
0.0202522557,
-0.0473136157,
0.0235365387,
-0.078840591,
0.0275684334,
0.0120516662,
0.0443368182,
0.0525126942,
-0.0295407232,
-0.0465985127,
0.0105806952,
0.0508345179,
-0.0132297855,
0.0000020716,
-0.0251257047,
0.011471943,
-0.0096244719,
0.0356420465,
0.0214035939,
0.0363976695,
-0.0956584886,
-0.0228191111,
0.0282940734,
-0.0485771149,
-0.0455563962,
0.0250869542,
0.061589282,
0.0274416953,
0.0268159844,
-0.0171863493,
-0.0099122673,
0.012629455,
-0.0308566708,
0.0100759836,
0.0134788472,
-0.0033135836,
0.0070917811,
-0.0197352599,
-0.0091652814,
-0.0601080544,
0.0784148127,
0.0281822458,
-0.0438760631,
-0.024262134,
0.0050096856,
-0.0402364731,
-0.0025295212,
-0.027265612,
0.0571761355,
-0.0178630669,
0.0370171145,
-0.0083272699,
-0.0123625817,
0.0220374577,
0.0393882915,
-0.0239874683,
0.0364824347,
0.0337349772,
-0.0314875506,
-0.0280981716,
0.0396910235,
0.0144961132,
-0.0725983456,
-0.0057267044,
-0.0121730333,
0.0416896231,
0.0053960206,
-0.0071710921,
-0.0202580392,
0.0237308629,
-0.0166996531,
0.0547696501,
-0.0305073392,
0.0389561318,
-0.0107732937,
-0.0186506081,
0.0309551079,
-0.0400338136,
-0.0177801643,
-0.029412454,
0.0729108155,
-0.0165102314,
0.0277264733,
0.0194746479,
0.0559266768,
-0.0208502747,
0.0412921384,
-0.0427599177,
0.0373429283,
-0.025651034,
0.0190210231,
-0.0334957391,
-0.0587538891,
0.0003981943,
-0.001428672,
-0.0097288601,
-0.0179836694,
0.0186525173,
-0.0411471911,
0.0247106086,
0.0284847189,
-0.002664947,
0.0128487665,
0.0176029932,
0.0716645643,
-0.0040934407,
0.048247464,
-0.0541753806,
-0.0702947825,
0.0021006512,
0.0404010862,
0.0190304164,
0.0034645868,
0.0111062098,
0.0343593284,
-0.0392852239,
-0.0445231162,
0.0246748347,
0.0318240188,
-0.0235830937,
-0.0264340825,
0.0365799181,
-0.0467547551,
0.0316804275,
-0.0154754743,
0.0081832614,
-0.0462833457,
0.0038804854,
-0.0339536257,
0.023991609,
0.0300838482,
0.0065011596,
-0.0013665209,
0.0562505126,
0.0170091484,
-0.053718999,
-0.0001230106,
0.0468729697,
0.0061546103,
0.013333845,
-0.0008542688,
0.0142754111,
0.1028880328,
-0.0138018541,
0.0335442014,
0.0132851191,
-0.0383495316,
0.0185788274,
0.0353123136,
-0.0390168279,
0.0440680869,
-0.0188480411,
-0.0252742711,
0.0275142286,
0.065690808,
-0.0052933884,
-0.0327762477,
0.0222643409,
0.0515156351,
0.0034097249,
-0.0421692804,
-0.019544363,
0.039984066,
-0.0018856482,
-0.0476911701,
-0.0528352223,
0.0333962515,
-0.0486473292,
-0.0136251394,
-0.0136424545,
-0.032687515,
0.052436538,
-0.0209578108,
0.0489991382,
0.0317793526,
-0.0185595844,
0.0272595901,
-0.0271826424,
-0.0572015904,
0.0264840592,
0.0226138458,
-0.0281608123,
-0.0024845949,
0.0048569371,
0.0225067772,
-0.0252202004,
-0.0278415438,
0.0206310377,
0.0007638365,
0.0107275806,
0.0033326538,
0.0520613715,
-0.0413909592,
-0.0367852598,
0.0585594401,
-0.0013691441,
0.0029458825,
-0.0510122292,
0.0597625785,
0.0211976804,
-0.0300173778,
0.0028874564,
0.0508170985,
-0.0291883145,
-0.0127064828,
0.0254604481,
0.0295253675,
0.0402648076,
0.0367087126,
0.0063287155,
-0.0534032993,
0.0285121165,
-0.0432899967,
0.0013508057,
0.0711320564,
-0.0394816287,
-0.0268315133,
0.0446885712,
-0.0843153968,
-0.0061491202,
0.0236249566,
-0.0051358622,
-0.0497175977,
0.0547273755,
-0.010510331,
-0.0078637656,
0.013901365,
0.0141812274,
0.0169371609,
0.0074809119,
-0.0220677648,
-0.0231433399,
-0.0151042566,
-0.054729227,
-0.0156762823,
-0.040793471,
0.0303325336,
-0.0368927494,
0.0182829965,
0.028554393,
-0.0132243335,
0.0041435142,
0.0343312807,
0.0508430414,
-0.0160423517,
0.0128857149,
-0.0630088598,
0.0112261325,
-0.0274444651,
0.0313074104,
0.0081075085,
-0.0129014663,
0.0106849447,
-0.0164132752,
-0.0471366905,
-0.0158166792,
0.0093994634,
-0.0738305673,
-0.0249663386,
0.0051330822,
-0.0437267646,
-0.0147476709,
-0.0297434572,
-0.0023410171,
0.014490732,
0.0390263274,
-0.0428092554,
-0.0276355948,
0.0042784098,
0.0305978674,
0.0107406909,
-0.0384096615,
-0.0080937585,
0.0207415447,
0.0127407443,
-0.0445514359,
-0.0091812713,
0.0019460724,
0.0053326115,
0.0171741042,
-0.0009530084,
-0.0360624865,
-0.0130819799,
-0.0101096211,
0.0196000058,
-0.070008032,
-0.0536829308,
-0.0054400861,
0.015249786,
0.0261107069,
0.051594276,
-0.0706063658,
-0.0557117537,
-0.0019408856,
-0.035325259,
0.0066944971,
0.0194604974,
-0.0037785496,
-0.0228124578,
0.0066899918,
-0.0289472435,
0.0141550321,
-0.0938089192,
-0.0374132507,
0.0374116153,
0.0393810645,
-0.0302581675,
0.0587856248,
-0.0250146072,
0.0056083277,
-0.051517237,
-0.024388615,
-0.0179153886,
0.0266819913,
0.01515444,
0.0032257978,
0.021725161,
-0.0421797335,
0.0016261234,
-0.0469845086,
0.0152663663,
0.0299475305,
0.0088626212,
-0.025083553,
-0.0316247642,
0.0075325123,
-0.0579265878,
-0.0579257384,
-0.0065301624,
0.0159780029,
0.050212983,
0.0176355857,
0.002190274,
0.0051249089,
-0.0615244098,
0.0006051919,
0.0288286563,
-0.0088625206,
-0.0477902517,
0.0103200935,
0.026480861,
-0.0034452672,
-0.0136222551,
-0.0598498769,
-0.0015877762,
0.0520565286,
0.0467062965,
-0.0239458699,
0.0054200012,
0.0438417755,
-0.0229386836,
0.0414373353,
0.0709058493,
-0.0024949762,
-0.038146995,
0.0119315404,
0.0341238007,
-0.0209088977,
0.0064271828,
-0.0299616698,
-0.0838760883,
-0.0774849281,
-0.0130434399,
0.0574382097,
0.0752191842,
0.0219866578,
0.0006611726,
-0.0176681597,
0.0272418614,
0.0583461113,
-0.0569073036,
-0.0266602878,
0.0148616228,
0.0084062107,
-0.0210362393,
0.0118072042,
-0.0215277411,
-0.0280034021,
0.0052775028,
0.009940465,
0.0201535113,
-0.0903264955,
0.0173992366,
-0.0025549934,
0.0292578507,
0.0094003938,
0.0003850801,
0.0112408865,
-0.0869065672,
0.0259786379,
0.0187242366,
0.0142994141,
-0.0191961266,
0.0363594741,
-0.0137204546,
-0.0146253817,
0.0294683557,
0.0755221397,
-0.0696925819,
0.0103175454,
0.0373105891,
0.029122835,
-0.0326992683,
-0.0068208976,
0.0170616135,
-0.0532843657,
-0.0191284195,
0.0383157283,
-0.0429657623,
-0.0370708443,
0.0323513821,
-0.0062023085,
0.0094388798,
0.0765058175,
-0.0653483048,
0.0057490943,
-0.021580575,
-0.0473173223,
-0.0556968264,
-0.022521507,
0.0690138936,
0.0461627021,
-0.0044131191,
-0.0221566651,
0.0667762458,
0.0177341606,
-0.0282474533,
0.0867210776,
-0.0279027577,
0.0615768805,
-0.0641789511,
-0.0022326359,
-0.0185593944,
-0.0381020792,
0.0103169028,
-0.000865335,
-0.0438431203,
-0.0330848359,
0.0008086691,
0.0551681109,
0.0103267748,
0.0368157141,
0.0084135365,
0.0121618705,
-0.0478457659,
0.0442600474,
0.0099384515,
0.0244227927,
0.0204461813,
-0.0750183985,
-0.0168921389,
-0.0009523928,
0.0091612833,
0.0282323491,
-0.0041522649,
0.0067061195,
-0.0642188415,
-0.0277530272,
-0.0376803614,
0.0374889858,
0.0345323421,
-0.0304782148,
-0.0329524428,
-0.0447344892,
0.0449718498,
-0.0284463577,
0.043079257,
-0.0987211987,
0.0099958666,
0.0533430055,
0.0192927085,
0.0287558865,
0.0230898857,
-0.0019192417,
-0.025234852,
-0.0059305513,
0.0525744185,
-0.0033900843,
0.0231573526,
0.0102772703,
0.0334596932,
0.0173309334,
0.0660565272,
0.0035097615,
0.0159327183,
-0.004135075,
0.0626579002,
0.0030232242,
0.0191295836,
0.0568092428,
0.0524649657,
0.0348152518,
-0.0459708087,
-0.0112497695,
0.0276340172,
-0.0009079508,
0.0317092426,
0.083309032,
-0.0141811855,
0.0312257502,
-0.0345567726,
0.0368643217,
-0.0245215986,
-0.0634440035,
0.053162735,
-0.0608127713,
-0.0119711664,
0.0421075188,
-0.0045148721,
-0.0743030682,
-0.0129944412,
-0.0160747543,
0.0231684279,
-0.0356176943,
-0.0255663451,
0.0287792012,
-0.0537176542,
-0.0476409048,
0.0280282646,
-0.0343425982,
-0.0058287401,
-0.0294802487,
-0.0150314374,
-0.0102049112,
0.0150081813,
0.0497383252,
-0.0139721502,
-0.0322294794,
0.0034437284,
-0.005010006,
-0.050729882,
-0.0579776578,
-0.0338537805,
-0.0386998914,
-5.741248489e-33,
-0.045640856,
-0.0171763021,
-0.0127432477,
0.0055139051,
0.0032799121,
0.0008675277,
-0.0302210227,
0.0422474779,
-0.0156939384,
0.0260661952,
0.0156133007,
-0.0147031527,
0.0038938604,
-0.0018309592,
-0.018060375,
-0.0361578763,
0.0287937336,
-0.0084526809,
-0.0455893949,
0.0384629108,
0.0202494897,
0.007240687,
0.0923690796,
-0.1351251304,
-0.0457873344,
-0.0267775748,
-0.0475147367,
-0.0046633533,
-0.0140073234,
-0.0147643238,
-0.0050624209,
-0.0343222618,
-0.0073718908,
0.0054615489,
0.0149754463,
-0.0043403017,
-0.0135642327,
0.032586541,
-0.0409111679,
0.1205904931,
-0.0544704497,
0.034840066,
0.0032350626,
-0.0122347688,
-0.0864121318,
0.0081644366,
0.0285833757,
-0.0225730464,
0.0051972819,
-0.0313200131,
-0.0174611099,
0.0279996749,
-0.0400086604,
-0.0594035499,
-0.0005241713,
0.0433367305,
-0.0131892152,
-0.0600046553,
-0.0210965648,
0.0148324547,
-0.0229312126,
0.0153021067,
0.1075228825,
-0.0641187504,
0.0068867477,
0.0369782336,
0.0211777613,
-0.0606611297,
0.0454989411,
-0.059974391,
0.0782799125,
0.0215907693,
0.040928416,
0.044379022,
0.0292808525,
-0.0437629409,
0.0002220257,
0.0521594621,
0.019140739,
0.0449119993,
-0.0528205186,
0.0141187627,
0.0189607386,
0.0103371516,
-0.0587598234,
0.0337177552,
0.044764258,
-0.0240147226,
0.0327669606,
0.0166590735,
-0.0073227934,
-0.0137717379,
0.0908263624,
-0.000814163,
0.0063816635,
0.0135828508,
-0.0262882989,
0.0481012054,
-0.0142065957,
-0.0034002042,
-0.0454792641,
-0.0221213941,
0.0682818741,
-0.0349689126,
0.0455644168,
-0.0310874078,
0.0063873269,
0.0915686861,
-0.0095093036,
-0.0014096327,
-0.0230426155,
0.0317161307,
0.0014844651,
0.0112567022,
0.0543588735,
0.0023742053,
-0.0240425486,
0.0476478003,
-0.0146279298,
0.0027877502,
-0.0301308818,
0.0180361904,
0.0075437687,
0.0263961498,
-0.0878446996,
0.0124718277,
-0.0016331858,
-0.0715561584,
0.0573296547,
-0.094541885,
-0.0035870136,
0.0343395211,
2.786e-7,
0.0146185029,
0.0647126585,
0.0096992003,
0.0075677745,
0.0010475847,
0.0739278197,
-0.0144978166,
0.0153898336,
0.0320070833,
0.0297295786,
0.016333323,
-0.0032258464,
0.0379076302,
0.0173395053,
-0.0325994566,
0.0083286092,
0.0135228252,
0.0071076364,
-0.0105337156,
0.0367875658,
0.0466756783,
0.0761838332,
-0.0017269236,
-0.0131484931,
0.0171324704,
-0.0705779865,
0.0564052872,
-0.0226688795,
0.0099439211,
-0.0316270515,
0.0484805144,
-0.0150442524,
-0.040146891,
0.006671058,
0.0071742656,
0.0049360315,
0.0063478784,
0.0349696651,
-0.0444875844,
0.0268083028,
-0.0134177404,
0.0124522066,
-0.0515099987,
0.0470940471,
0.0342384316,
-0.0131526263,
-0.0061215507,
-0.0226271972,
-0.0452020876,
0.0110641634,
0.009856306,
0.0124850757,
0.0467638671,
0.0441361293,
0.0302132349,
-0.0445716642,
-0.0078009237,
-0.0311954785,
-0.0068604262,
-0.0367994383,
-0.0098308967,
0.0299908239,
-0.0005911986,
0.029843118,
-0.0429461598,
0.0330791064,
-0.0610876866,
1.845970155e-34,
0.0141318124,
0.0044867182,
0.0266598333,
-0.0130656967,
0.0030476246,
-0.0346879661,
0.0286154728,
0.0091082202,
-0.0352036767,
-0.0109383613,
-0.0239146892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06364v2 | AGIEval: A Human-Centric Benchmark for Evaluating Foundation Models | 2023-04-13T09:39:30 | 2023-09-18T14:23:02 | Wanjun Zhong, Ruixiang Cui, Yiduo Guo, Yaobo Liang, Shuai Lu, Yanlin Wang, Amin Saied, Weizhu Chen, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating the general abilities of foundation models to tackle human-level
tasks is a vital aspect of their development and application in the pursuit of
Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). Traditional benchmarks, which rely on
artificial datasets, may not accurately represent human-level capabilities. In
this paper, we introduce AGIEval, a novel benchmark specifically designed to
assess foundation model in the context of human-centric standardized exams,
such as college entrance exams, law school admission tests, math competitions,
and lawyer qualification tests. We evaluate several state-of-the-art foundation
models, including GPT-4, ChatGPT, and Text-Davinci-003, using this benchmark.
Impressively, GPT-4 surpasses average human performance on SAT, LSAT, and math
competitions, attaining a 95% accuracy rate on the SAT Math test and a 92.5%
accuracy on the English test of the Chinese national college entrance exam.
This demonstrates the extraordinary performance of contemporary foundation
models. In contrast, we also find that GPT-4 is less proficient in tasks that
require complex reasoning or specific domain knowledge. Our comprehensive
analyses of model capabilities (understanding, knowledge, reasoning, and
calculation) reveal these models' strengths and limitations, providing valuable
insights into future directions for enhancing their general capabilities. By
concentrating on tasks pertinent to human cognition and decision-making, our
benchmark delivers a more meaningful and robust evaluation of foundation
models' performance in real-world scenarios. The data, code, and all model
outputs are released in https://github.com/ruixiangcui/AGIEval. | [
-0.0038165289,
0.0883394554,
-0.0253184643,
0.0110650882,
-0.0570989922,
0.0133127645,
0.0039334842,
-0.004366918,
0.0214907322,
-0.0110707339,
0.0202148557,
-0.0524512157,
-0.0160449985,
0.0319556631,
-0.0020830366,
-0.0300289448,
0.0159072373,
-0.0115353484,
0.0117832404,
0.0060357009,
-0.0345155671,
-0.0092039863,
-0.021730816,
0.0229797438,
-0.0260870419,
-0.0236608386,
0.0065917438,
-0.0129920226,
0.0085861683,
-0.0294778105,
0.0003966723,
0.072048597,
0.0017669295,
0.0026845951,
0.0000022221,
-0.0436137356,
-0.0024334153,
0.0051045059,
-0.0465602316,
0.0117718875,
0.0357991308,
0.0508177057,
-0.0030058241,
0.0323933512,
-0.0723487809,
-0.0106198126,
-0.00709204,
0.0253310148,
0.0493927561,
0.0659370422,
0.0054424037,
-0.0129958056,
0.0515514389,
-0.0309764855,
-0.0240142383,
-0.062805064,
0.0017500221,
0.0249344166,
-0.0140534714,
-0.0339869596,
-0.0239443462,
-0.0195548665,
0.0557049215,
0.0461310185,
-0.0145372916,
0.0246643499,
-0.0763029903,
0.0130478712,
0.0000091502,
0.0453507416,
0.0090381671,
-0.0152916936,
-0.0034842922,
0.0157835726,
0.0384721197,
0.0102785556,
-0.056817431,
0.0131469527,
-0.0343795158,
-0.001408919,
0.006102622,
0.0101507381,
0.0226171557,
0.0224644076,
-0.0211594105,
0.0819596872,
-0.0033052871,
-0.0045943675,
0.0520935953,
0.0165212061,
-0.0303798374,
-0.0364910327,
-0.0026529087,
0.0071481783,
-0.0427450649,
-0.0146478778,
-0.0197068509,
-0.0093882652,
0.0171201881,
-0.0032545459,
0.0326594897,
0.0507629663,
0.0183596741,
0.0624572709,
-0.0297918394,
0.1009843647,
0.0013210397,
0.0355878063,
-0.0301094074,
-0.0098709967,
-0.0811308101,
0.0103505226,
-0.0104046687,
0.0499326363,
-0.0423445851,
-0.0032154741,
-0.0539948754,
-0.0173077416,
-0.0443614237,
0.0326483212,
-0.0142479949,
0.0169215892,
-0.0050571798,
0.0125663783,
-0.0591013543,
-0.0438514352,
-0.0776278526,
-0.0116305547,
0.036667835,
-0.035840746,
0.0086098518,
-0.0352879427,
-0.027677495,
-0.0180559251,
0.0411316529,
0.0602361001,
0.0170673896,
-0.0111743044,
-0.023008801,
-0.0325292759,
0.0454879552,
-0.094794035,
0.0196322706,
-0.0375472382,
0.0383570865,
-0.0023774351,
-0.0186359175,
-0.0467005074,
0.0073719569,
0.0261715241,
0.0243918765,
0.0499470532,
0.0627096221,
-0.0075166537,
0.0161489788,
0.0264539365,
-0.0675647929,
0.0400551483,
0.0157704223,
0.0424788259,
0.017424725,
-0.0314682759,
0.0209651832,
0.0419596024,
-0.000418531,
-0.0243717544,
0.0227230601,
0.0444923751,
-0.0203976482,
0.0321204625,
-0.0201707631,
0.0224726889,
-0.0085618217,
-0.0001826844,
0.0477373227,
0.0845953673,
0.0189196691,
0.0632314235,
0.0283761434,
0.0001736101,
0.0454674847,
-0.0123069081,
-0.0966483802,
0.0040172795,
-0.0737404898,
0.0203916486,
-0.0649891272,
0.0303271078,
-0.0190725978,
-0.0459540822,
0.0143179791,
-0.0004247321,
0.0096254479,
0.0290098097,
0.058952637,
-0.0517733619,
-0.0301544983,
-0.0006126976,
-0.0099146245,
-0.0395714603,
-0.0092254635,
-0.0470830575,
-0.0000807865,
0.009917737,
0.0634800643,
-0.049423568,
-0.0385167375,
0.0055555892,
0.0017110999,
0.0039529302,
0.0776783824,
-0.0131111061,
-0.0136730671,
-0.0345917195,
-0.0097753946,
0.0269177929,
0.0135805001,
0.0256046094,
0.0527559146,
-0.0092302747,
0.0068135643,
-0.0370729752,
-0.0037556309,
0.0345881842,
-0.0545458198,
-0.0211131051,
-0.0287120994,
-0.0059790914,
0.0509876944,
0.0136469994,
0.0001096784,
-0.0061485199,
0.0170302466,
0.0150339417,
-0.0321796536,
-0.0269777328,
-0.0299425479,
0.0252889805,
0.0278961919,
-0.0471576266,
-0.0133618535,
0.0728529394,
-0.0537412986,
-0.0466802381,
0.0063653137,
-0.0107559292,
-0.0026501908,
-0.0274653845,
0.0323571973,
-0.0328941941,
-0.0187221337,
0.0103455335,
0.0847232565,
0.0015857593,
-0.0002025503,
-0.003076185,
-0.0037774311,
0.0516066849,
-0.0777635872,
-0.0050755139,
-0.0296150446,
-0.0356278457,
0.0252024196,
0.0303294063,
0.041148141,
-0.0623344891,
0.0112305628,
-0.0859542936,
0.0410008132,
-0.0186867043,
0.0186167471,
0.0198686291,
-0.0572312437,
-0.0115458556,
0.0107241301,
-0.0634225309,
0.0133476779,
0.0189701337,
-0.0255997125,
-0.0111297704,
-0.0089167953,
-0.0237480272,
-0.0291259792,
-0.0054090684,
-0.0611316003,
0.0116893891,
0.0349254869,
0.0286072269,
0.0262101162,
0.0344535373,
-0.0071574734,
0.02447927,
-0.0150781609,
-0.0070118215,
0.0213002302,
-0.0228081066,
-0.041400861,
0.0771635026,
-0.0138858203,
0.0406825542,
-0.0109320646,
-0.0212690737,
-0.0140996976,
0.0311029069,
-0.0003454967,
0.0310200546,
-0.0286370032,
-0.0305874087,
-0.0167579167,
0.0262642,
0.0049640122,
0.0110185295,
-0.0471029542,
0.0502429865,
-0.0320960246,
-0.0180844665,
-0.0603868403,
0.0319962949,
0.0011530017,
0.0511675403,
-0.0550653338,
-0.0153415315,
0.0554814264,
0.0024377364,
0.0344910696,
-0.026862273,
0.0224879999,
-0.0456082635,
0.0735671744,
0.0105275633,
-0.0047175712,
-0.0116895456,
-0.0035553006,
-0.0609890521,
0.0089546731,
0.0339379534,
-0.0654656217,
0.0500948951,
-0.0440591425,
-0.0235412102,
0.002527562,
-0.0751976445,
-0.0309419911,
-0.0013647103,
-0.0038129513,
0.045243673,
-0.0098642772,
-0.0399988964,
-0.0365690477,
-0.0406590477,
-0.0222242102,
0.0220995042,
-0.0292003062,
-0.0127958097,
-0.0014207372,
0.0067756064,
0.0107147451,
0.0214451347,
0.0332291685,
-0.0499764755,
0.0466834269,
0.0459666401,
0.0820701569,
0.0047149067,
0.0060176738,
0.0433670394,
-0.0126526607,
-0.0379072949,
-0.0314118043,
0.042614352,
0.0028876881,
-0.0588183068,
-0.0036093616,
0.1288233995,
0.0181202926,
0.0230840594,
0.004988722,
-0.0144901648,
-0.0052703437,
0.0385822915,
0.0080352593,
-0.0715612918,
-0.0297941137,
0.0259119142,
0.0407858677,
-0.0178552847,
-0.0686682463,
0.0437215939,
-0.10675928,
0.0455924496,
0.0282719526,
-0.0443417579,
0.0133835161,
-0.0090284413,
-0.0006363741,
-0.0561267138,
-0.0339564197,
-0.0197108239,
0.0241747629,
0.0008122328,
-0.007309603,
-0.0360598266,
-0.0296615195,
0.09601634,
-0.0293440763,
0.0080860881,
0.0505895987,
0.0289848242,
-0.0321113057,
-0.014196815,
0.0192938838,
-0.0037491817,
-0.0094372798,
0.0190118328,
0.0561146624,
0.0038823446,
0.0258013848,
-0.027007021,
0.0419608094,
-0.0514772795,
0.0053366185,
0.0710485578,
0.0921903774,
0.0054646982,
-0.0169281065,
-0.0279959515,
-0.0385075696,
-0.03831264,
0.0913412198,
0.0115170972,
-0.0360195488,
-0.0565584414,
-0.031938117,
-0.0154162068,
-0.0406618975,
-0.0315878987,
0.0174184199,
0.0475366376,
-0.0025671611,
-0.0282642953,
-0.0681194663,
0.0257398672,
0.0171996299,
0.0105301542,
-0.0355065949,
0.038766101,
-0.0041610906,
-0.0437468141,
0.0538096093,
-0.0194832012,
0.017977776,
-0.0753828287,
0.010114721,
-0.0055010365,
-0.0345297977,
-0.0589522123,
0.0325873196,
-0.0276770182,
-0.0179774556,
0.0159838554,
0.0452109911,
0.0328902267,
-0.0095259864,
-0.044711154,
0.0191842951,
0.0166824199,
-0.0385765024,
-0.047533337,
0.0189139135,
0.0253017712,
-0.0850953907,
-0.01579687,
-0.0127623091,
-0.0076417425,
0.0589554645,
0.0304324944,
0.0319128148,
0.0054524522,
0.0022572523,
0.0353814438,
0.0665484965,
0.045354642,
0.0397911109,
-0.0146349762,
-0.0051209619,
-0.0036779675,
-0.024028061,
-0.017482968,
-0.0217151456,
-0.045520898,
0.0704921558,
0.0211354624,
0.0011406819,
0.0033343728,
0.0140718389,
0.0047383858,
-0.033657562,
-0.010915556,
0.0234465506,
0.080318287,
-0.0034627446,
-0.0493463762,
-0.0151895927,
-0.0370216072,
-0.0040618153,
0.0686729997,
-0.0171069801,
0.1092719212,
0.000243091,
0.0157104842,
0.0176204145,
0.0151732368,
-0.0676632226,
-0.0572571978,
-0.0475124158,
0.0235713217,
0.0364955179,
0.0250058472,
-0.0317692123,
-0.0626978055,
0.0008543835,
-0.0289190114,
-0.0232114028,
0.0119125312,
-0.0125742313,
-0.0019089121,
0.0433201678,
0.0104144756,
-0.0050703445,
0.0341216959,
0.0311631467,
0.0488453023,
-0.0184895135,
-0.0251801107,
-0.0497593805,
-0.0288485978,
-0.0113105727,
0.0124225011,
0.0073939948,
0.0173515268,
-0.1257979125,
-0.0517989583,
0.0471377335,
0.0490714125,
0.0262837783,
-0.0007818669,
0.0333302394,
0.0477729179,
-0.0640155077,
-0.0164499898,
-0.0077287802,
0.0031013237,
-0.0745445564,
0.0023001772,
-0.0287109688,
-5.931894939e-33,
-0.0373719782,
-0.0110835955,
0.0477449521,
-0.0208194423,
-0.0127679259,
-0.0065273107,
-0.0212001931,
0.0302299429,
-0.0440484919,
0.0022378336,
-0.0260986742,
0.033870101,
-0.0098234108,
0.0089383004,
0.0120752016,
-0.0127909258,
0.0075240037,
-0.0177997611,
-0.0514984019,
0.0072022672,
-0.0223417189,
0.0167726297,
0.0363273881,
-0.0797941014,
-0.0207571294,
-0.0124704884,
-0.005000677,
-0.0071211285,
-0.0450338125,
0.0542571545,
0.0048324759,
0.0165603887,
0.0327453464,
-0.0453020968,
0.0262687989,
-0.0105226515,
-0.0793560892,
-0.0255927332,
-0.0126690939,
-0.0029801754,
-0.0027947824,
-0.0116707003,
0.0103218313,
-0.0033704673,
-0.0540636405,
-0.0445631668,
0.0241159126,
-0.0589029118,
0.0347159579,
0.006564443,
-0.040594127,
0.0217207894,
-0.0267614126,
0.0099052545,
-0.0272368398,
0.0435133651,
-0.0381932035,
-0.0041395766,
0.0040805922,
-0.0038559004,
0.005559586,
-0.0190880708,
0.0413884483,
-0.0130390199,
0.0020333354,
0.05797299,
0.0431181304,
-0.0106128668,
-0.0075507103,
-0.0714719221,
0.0349342413,
0.0774166584,
0.0790027827,
0.0971987545,
0.0380207486,
0.0069584385,
-0.0932767838,
0.0442568846,
0.0372999795,
0.0320340097,
-0.0035409487,
-0.0298939422,
-0.0783963352,
0.0149539756,
-0.0477378741,
-0.03569616,
-0.024719527,
-0.0018582869,
0.0775870308,
-0.0175411087,
0.0100044645,
0.0066379881,
0.0146429949,
-0.0472700857,
0.0379011706,
0.0398570225,
0.0120510822,
0.0391389988,
-0.0046614399,
0.0459954143,
-0.0344525799,
-0.0415925533,
-0.0036847857,
0.0204660483,
0.0576807484,
-0.0088631194,
0.023798557,
0.0195576213,
0.0002071799,
-0.0247538593,
-0.0368199311,
0.0202375278,
0.0371703245,
0.0030852603,
0.0426949933,
0.0221601669,
0.0326717496,
-0.0006491257,
-0.0096911732,
0.0129628545,
-0.0500276387,
-0.006839769,
0.0417165905,
-0.0047930027,
0.0217794906,
-0.0148035688,
-0.024273606,
-0.024759924,
0.0054124598,
-0.0454445779,
0.0032467344,
0.034532398,
2.871e-7,
0.0419510417,
0.0483663492,
0.000413964,
0.0106668426,
-0.0195413157,
0.0437506735,
-0.0528010204,
0.0056570382,
0.0362687372,
-0.0059024207,
0.0385204181,
0.0435204506,
0.0520862788,
0.021636717,
-0.0543207601,
-0.0093704397,
-0.0159111116,
-0.021825213,
-0.0427417308,
0.0478641726,
0.0302786268,
0.0541008264,
0.0475443229,
-0.0274082199,
0.0378402658,
-0.0327352583,
0.0385212451,
-0.0307792574,
-0.0006779507,
-0.0102288956,
-0.0073969411,
0.0219399929,
-0.0187012292,
0.0581506342,
-0.0012932826,
0.0326295383,
0.0189995673,
0.0636193678,
0.0057114526,
0.014896201,
-0.0097034331,
-0.0346160308,
0.0158420373,
-0.0330021121,
0.0656071454,
-0.0090743136,
-0.0413326547,
-0.0005524507,
-0.0604947582,
-0.0375437513,
-0.0022059223,
0.018218156,
0.0016451231,
-0.0353989229,
0.0152678182,
-0.008205845,
0.0036298626,
-0.0330743492,
0.008548351,
0.0330784507,
-0.0426828377,
-0.0637732148,
-0.0280406196,
0.0137805101,
0.0335475653,
-0.0751414672,
-0.0364446081,
2.955728428e-34,
0.0251499955,
0.016667759,
0.0408021212,
-0.0125711169,
0.0582325123,
0.0222572703,
-0.0189235806,
-0.0188938081,
-0.0020689804,
-0.0484783091,
0.0000696438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06337v1 | Computational modeling of semantic change | 2023-04-13T08:33:50 | 2023-04-13T08:33:50 | Nina Tahmasebi, Haim Dubossarsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this chapter we provide an overview of computational modeling for semantic
change using large and semi-large textual corpora. We aim to provide a key for
the interpretation of relevant methods and evaluation techniques, and also
provide insights into important aspects of the computational study of semantic
change. We discuss the pros and cons of different classes of models with
respect to the properties of the data from which one wishes to model semantic
change, and which avenues are available to evaluate the results. | [
0.0440566503,
0.0465414599,
-0.0742376372,
0.0073032193,
-0.0633163452,
-0.0250243843,
-0.0420443676,
0.0130804284,
-0.0436935723,
-0.0547375157,
0.0496920273,
-0.0172621366,
0.0240488537,
-0.0268500317,
-0.0028392377,
-0.0715766549,
0.1032805219,
0.0011987471,
-0.0369816609,
0.0298055969,
0.0210342053,
-0.0298682004,
0.014456897,
-0.0135254888,
-0.0035982195,
-0.0058604586,
-0.0205126237,
0.008223895,
-0.0141135799,
0.0019807648,
-0.0424375944,
0.0299173798,
0.0228383802,
0.0576678514,
0.0000018159,
-0.092586562,
-0.0664961487,
-0.0089227781,
0.0060887546,
0.0627467856,
0.0680333599,
-0.0008510781,
-0.0291700307,
-0.0380718857,
-0.0057806168,
0.0129131153,
0.0313760675,
-0.0412895307,
0.040586479,
0.0541930087,
-0.0283325389,
-0.0165938139,
-0.0064050569,
0.0074824663,
0.0011780255,
0.0075242943,
0.0537652113,
0.0131010059,
-0.0169333816,
-0.028362928,
-0.0673278645,
0.0091251433,
-0.0514842682,
0.0132453479,
-0.0060795797,
0.0006540969,
-0.0043251826,
0.0261866823,
0.0051586581,
-0.0266546495,
0.0198555011,
-0.0489117391,
0.0336537287,
0.0248433128,
-0.0024967205,
0.0666624159,
-0.0086697098,
-0.0212326478,
0.009908569,
0.0039650565,
0.058801122,
-0.0129180634,
0.0302844699,
0.0525487624,
-0.0707166791,
0.0497911945,
0.0527939275,
-0.0507126413,
-0.0315390565,
-0.026060069,
0.0075843311,
-0.0675085038,
0.0037840304,
-0.0047167521,
-0.0293016676,
0.0428940728,
-0.0120792203,
-0.0431022532,
0.0213218536,
-0.0584102795,
-0.0049702786,
-0.0084026726,
0.0022822381,
0.0472787283,
-0.0125745907,
0.0002888073,
-0.015093117,
-0.0497821681,
-0.0291362721,
-0.0012414717,
-0.0610052347,
0.0157552548,
-0.0482135229,
0.0183891244,
-0.0169066601,
-0.0186212622,
-0.050676737,
0.043864619,
0.0330944359,
-0.039852038,
-0.0287008137,
-0.029849261,
-0.0418591201,
0.0291208178,
-0.0428810269,
0.0065011755,
-0.0377735347,
0.0069671259,
-0.0417275019,
-0.0164890941,
0.0084088556,
0.011764626,
-0.0073657078,
0.0052761813,
-0.0237276349,
0.0658862591,
-0.0020770025,
0.0025875729,
-0.0477708913,
-0.0004444171,
-0.0511583686,
-0.0173717141,
-0.0266829953,
-0.0633289739,
-0.0155069493,
-0.0224352237,
0.0146167753,
-0.0396236144,
-0.026604481,
0.0209065247,
-0.0452698618,
0.0497514755,
-0.0806306601,
0.0091713052,
0.0212521628,
-0.0370447151,
0.0331101939,
0.051209081,
0.032595966,
-0.0414165482,
0.0884794295,
-0.0168058984,
-0.0476398356,
0.0508263931,
-0.0438153967,
0.0417411849,
-0.0338036306,
-0.0268732365,
0.0255673323,
0.0515478887,
0.0054923357,
0.0525799431,
-0.0137077738,
-0.0572803654,
0.0221003089,
0.0710641742,
0.0146018639,
0.0085225254,
0.0032247109,
-0.0003364451,
-0.0149931377,
0.0229542274,
0.0290140938,
-0.0578498058,
-0.0260700416,
-0.0149044525,
-0.0052406639,
-0.0071735238,
0.0075044888,
-0.0021134424,
-0.0210379902,
0.0092438525,
0.024532523,
-0.0927346051,
0.048900608,
0.0232340824,
0.0372108109,
0.0418682769,
0.0295714326,
-0.0231683329,
0.0282432921,
-0.0099590169,
0.0277184006,
0.0436700881,
0.0565368049,
-0.0583520532,
0.0439837053,
0.0050521381,
-0.0305805616,
0.0248094127,
-0.0134771457,
-0.0221012328,
-0.045146089,
-0.0204259884,
0.0541791543,
0.0268601123,
0.0329821222,
0.0055682743,
-0.0222017765,
0.0019837182,
-0.0114298761,
-0.0272029974,
0.0131374747,
0.0405992754,
-0.0079334816,
0.0388302319,
-0.0170560982,
-0.0250426177,
0.0486366116,
0.0044057476,
-0.0196073428,
0.010659283,
-0.014094159,
0.0141874347,
-0.0334698297,
0.0542478971,
0.0054858392,
0.0093049565,
0.047741428,
-0.015062971,
0.0362778679,
-0.013121631,
0.0090445476,
-0.0177736543,
0.0620470755,
-0.0773415565,
0.0612830296,
-0.0135286991,
0.0625523776,
-0.0308435261,
0.0004885505,
-0.0716621801,
0.0525711216,
0.0031368821,
0.0042670062,
-0.0025222814,
0.0252186675,
0.0451647267,
-0.014442021,
-0.019098334,
0.0264837481,
-0.0002295027,
-0.02504519,
0.0555960275,
-0.0807642117,
-0.0551593155,
-0.0081461063,
-0.0360726677,
-0.0092953444,
-0.0213120561,
0.0270375106,
0.0553596355,
0.0085037062,
-0.0290370453,
0.0261444524,
0.0454836525,
0.0625741109,
-0.0329382531,
0.0616984889,
0.056493517,
-0.0373212248,
-0.007950075,
-0.0985602736,
-0.0249139052,
-0.0375231728,
0.0827536508,
0.0276488233,
-0.0605231486,
-0.0454985946,
0.0199654046,
-0.0620036498,
0.0146689825,
0.0192450024,
-0.0115446448,
0.0161624439,
-0.008216016,
0.0775514245,
-0.0179137606,
0.0351489633,
0.0604270957,
0.064343676,
-0.0720980093,
-0.0167527925,
-0.0512977429,
-0.0165152866,
-0.0087601393,
-0.0711719319,
-0.0638750792,
0.0513329133,
0.0480818227,
0.0214546509,
-0.029815767,
-0.0208764244,
0.0066868174,
-0.1019206643,
-0.0212972481,
-0.0106957331,
-0.0138329668,
-0.0524115078,
0.0390072353,
0.0101385247,
-0.0184596684,
0.0088895839,
-0.001984529,
0.0748820752,
-0.0846782848,
-0.0272089299,
-0.0473936275,
0.065541096,
0.0064506233,
-0.0000309371,
0.0378047042,
-0.0087726032,
-0.0152463196,
-0.0060296929,
0.0282168407,
0.008399738,
0.0457768254,
-0.1027323529,
0.0463544615,
0.0390222818,
0.0249746777,
0.0300497096,
-0.0487822667,
-0.011076618,
0.0182610918,
0.0302077997,
-0.006557134,
0.0054230615,
0.0256757345,
-0.0117114456,
0.0471073799,
0.0220249221,
-0.0240519643,
-0.045725774,
0.0293377824,
0.0180378184,
-0.0142396744,
-0.01742802,
0.0277029518,
-0.0091374274,
0.0397098586,
0.0102088954,
-0.0038318476,
-0.0793341249,
-0.0195503365,
-0.0002732787,
-0.0742851347,
-0.0031579556,
0.0031205756,
-0.0311828945,
-0.005017058,
0.0025470555,
0.08052589,
0.0675662309,
-0.0283250362,
0.0515598729,
-0.0128788482,
-0.0213778503,
0.0279088132,
-0.0222361293,
-0.0862248018,
-0.010585608,
0.0082040429,
-0.052278962,
-0.0538725853,
-0.0716494843,
0.0063993856,
-0.0397811048,
0.0029148094,
-0.0161549412,
-0.0461568981,
0.0575154871,
-0.0448900945,
0.0402438939,
-0.0255050678,
-0.0743585974,
-0.0197210126,
-0.0124686873,
0.0171400737,
0.0102503914,
-0.0491441563,
-0.021445265,
-0.0106086591,
-0.0365916826,
0.038647864,
0.0332016982,
0.0457881019,
-0.0620751046,
-0.0040045022,
0.0202895589,
-0.0373006836,
0.007393748,
-0.0406937487,
0.0491545014,
0.0203575902,
0.0178095177,
-0.0055939015,
-0.0389630981,
0.0113574658,
-0.0226985421,
0.0320303775,
0.0255377144,
0.0098098572,
-0.0140782678,
-0.0392513797,
-0.0085485009,
-0.0139305554,
0.0193091743,
-0.0001842414,
-0.0286293663,
0.016577322,
-0.0013792082,
-0.0098194182,
0.037902873,
-0.0404573344,
-0.0658129752,
-0.0601408258,
-0.0303417314,
-0.1005549058,
0.0026215902,
-0.0348498821,
-0.0055455989,
0.0409186035,
0.0257168487,
0.0275833253,
-0.0156771131,
-0.0624012575,
-0.0141970227,
-0.0241260845,
0.0334405228,
-0.014691053,
-0.0150752608,
0.087345846,
0.0492770225,
-0.0139295245,
0.0029628009,
-0.0576652996,
-0.0509105213,
0.0267854612,
-0.0406373553,
0.0211546291,
0.0145803588,
-0.0109279817,
-0.0298103932,
0.0162103549,
-0.0065875277,
0.0137023907,
0.0777752399,
-0.0199573338,
0.0027200603,
-0.0187763851,
-0.0022875646,
0.0238569304,
0.0059436462,
0.0136092836,
0.017065322,
-0.0441852026,
-0.0209544059,
0.0374635421,
0.0118288053,
0.0471473448,
0.0028254059,
-0.0328295827,
-0.0050474755,
-0.0174258538,
-0.022078231,
-0.0040488583,
0.0322809517,
-0.0613115206,
0.0144991353,
0.0269864518,
-0.0664817393,
0.0259483047,
-0.0481674075,
0.0201077089,
0.0029680694,
-0.0497953109,
0.0486614034,
0.0408065915,
-0.0155751426,
0.0428049788,
0.0157975256,
-0.0198636688,
-0.0430756882,
0.0167506896,
0.0021510385,
0.0030172449,
0.0110372789,
-0.0076844567,
-0.0241950266,
0.0306376368,
-0.0080487859,
0.0166947525,
0.0303707104,
0.013030339,
0.0315521061,
-0.0088810436,
0.0749428347,
-0.0345523097,
-0.0099579729,
-0.0392178521,
-0.0219156053,
0.024131408,
0.0047084535,
0.0149996215,
0.0159899108,
0.0067132995,
0.0412530787,
0.0255534183,
-0.027682608,
0.0311518945,
-0.020105524,
-0.0377597921,
0.0049973498,
0.004633809,
-0.0017943231,
0.0122837732,
-0.0135462619,
-0.0045422385,
-0.0604846925,
-0.0161664393,
0.0154013615,
-0.0025039543,
0.061068587,
0.0088912966,
0.0331603847,
0.1003275365,
0.0245619286,
0.0367142521,
-0.0458281487,
0.01587376,
-0.028598154,
-0.0193724614,
-0.0049159965,
-5.24328594e-33,
-0.0070771594,
0.0103452569,
0.0031478992,
-0.0068982635,
-0.0321155712,
-0.0027102518,
-0.0012561894,
0.017630605,
0.0178400502,
-0.0009417832,
0.0065172217,
0.0245254841,
0.0057856124,
-0.0232269894,
0.0459700152,
0.018736545,
0.0561465174,
0.0089355083,
-0.0139509859,
-0.0612706244,
0.0610856563,
-0.0256525762,
0.0290943868,
-0.0512387231,
0.0621947572,
0.051724907,
-0.0015875138,
0.0118149063,
-0.0071678017,
-0.0119660981,
-0.0092060631,
0.0555838645,
0.0453415774,
-0.0170157999,
-0.0247892067,
-0.002816922,
-0.0336530171,
-0.049793493,
0.0527244136,
0.0059905127,
-0.0209890474,
-0.0561777316,
-0.0114828153,
-0.0048037791,
-0.0315605812,
0.0129200295,
0.0363039076,
-0.0301943403,
-0.0221676286,
0.0131897554,
-0.0783785135,
0.0534892231,
-0.0312838331,
0.0270871241,
0.009806592,
-0.0336977951,
0.0068561966,
-0.0093303891,
-0.0325751416,
0.0373129621,
0.0408420078,
0.0537731126,
-0.0090416213,
0.0166970976,
0.0132975709,
0.0634935349,
0.0176935159,
0.0026651693,
0.0311259702,
0.0364942253,
0.0281876791,
-0.0142199565,
0.0251762606,
0.0372995362,
0.0152865555,
-0.003332068,
-0.0403838754,
0.0055870228,
0.0371530168,
0.0273803174,
0.0276850704,
0.0408321694,
0.0093927821,
-0.0196199697,
-0.0325233713,
0.0002291911,
-0.005877573,
-0.0168013182,
0.0012349373,
-0.0483250841,
0.0024953645,
0.0536938459,
-0.0061605815,
-0.0114139533,
-0.021696467,
-0.0513035879,
-0.0144246025,
0.0627027228,
0.0204466563,
0.0146167995,
-0.0211253408,
-0.0252212323,
-0.0076022078,
-0.0200191773,
0.0248960499,
-0.0158131607,
-0.0284367912,
-0.0242418945,
-0.018461857,
-0.0235527083,
0.0467008762,
-0.0845124573,
-0.0405521803,
-0.0542003475,
-0.0388824381,
0.0211747438,
-0.0046209819,
0.0200289655,
0.0809131935,
0.0028378253,
0.0162134841,
0.0122962324,
0.0059065097,
0.0247368533,
-0.0045949263,
-0.0030465503,
-0.0027535369,
0.0529797822,
0.0306564793,
-0.0352251008,
-0.000275262,
-0.0236874837,
2.525e-7,
0.0691601932,
0.0987312049,
0.0222740024,
-0.0074068154,
0.0540665351,
-0.0207253061,
-0.0222849995,
0.0404299647,
0.0105599705,
-0.0063142157,
0.0096145691,
-0.0201315247,
-0.0081064198,
0.0167006664,
-0.0451316647,
-0.0212680437,
-0.0263628922,
-0.0032637161,
-0.0843276009,
0.0368949994,
0.0588283986,
0.0520172454,
0.0538623258,
0.0054059266,
-0.0385214761,
0.0091177998,
0.0419382937,
-0.0332820043,
-0.0210228059,
0.050009571,
0.0049857888,
-0.0226632915,
0.0154114449,
0.0391461328,
-0.0004842296,
0.0171856172,
0.0568250157,
-0.0277095269,
-0.0143552097,
0.1069154441,
-0.0085393069,
-0.0448773876,
0.0057970812,
-0.0133426031,
0.0561189391,
-0.0065196748,
-0.0073601073,
0.0015932114,
-0.0408000126,
0.0412429087,
0.0526559949,
-0.0079141483,
-0.0509878397,
0.0091571687,
0.0178886615,
0.0796627626,
-0.057213176,
-0.0675402135,
0.0193786249,
-0.0077450736,
-0.0266275853,
-0.052576758,
-0.0156134656,
-0.0057904362,
-0.0065490818,
-0.054875724,
0.0386243947,
1.638635566e-34,
0.0279653687,
0.069977738,
-0.0006812655,
0.0016084625,
0.0295365695,
-0.013338292,
-0.0010770283,
0.0454318449,
0.003600569,
-0.0673396364,
0.0174508132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06307v1 | Rule-based detection of access to education and training in Germany | 2023-04-13T07:32:09 | 2023-04-13T07:32:09 | Jens Dörpinghaus, David Samray, Robert Helmrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a result of transformation processes, the German labor market is highly
dependent on vocational training, retraining and continuing education. To match
training seekers and offers, we present a novel approach towards the automated
detection of access to education and training in German training offers and
advertisements. We will in particular focus on (a) general school and education
degrees and schoolleaving certificates, (b) professional experience, (c) a
previous apprenticeship and (d) a list of skills provided by the German Federal
Employment Agency. This novel approach combines several methods: First, we
provide a mapping of synonyms in education combining different qualifications
and adding deprecated terms. Second, we provide a rule-based matching to
identify the need for professional experience or apprenticeship. However, not
all access requirements can be matched due to incompatible data schemata or
non-standardizes requirements, e.g initial tests or interviews. While we can
identify several shortcomings, the presented approach offers promising results
for two data sets: training and re-training advertisements. | [
0.0387836657,
0.0199172292,
-0.0250805393,
-0.0266393796,
-0.0424844623,
-0.0055044964,
0.0099340128,
0.0092724739,
0.0353295282,
-0.0372457616,
0.0391134769,
0.0176349934,
-0.0057166894,
0.0189986322,
-0.0277582314,
-0.0328453556,
0.0223504901,
0.0402284563,
-0.049072206,
0.0071141054,
-0.0083180666,
0.034053959,
-0.0126262065,
0.0483131781,
0.0127982302,
0.023829937,
0.0275777392,
-0.04159569,
0.0485117696,
-0.00665265,
0.068774879,
0.0175256971,
-0.0144908307,
-0.0224127211,
0.0000016575,
-0.0419861004,
-0.060120225,
-0.0072880685,
-0.0148537699,
-0.0496453047,
0.0255401712,
-0.0043803174,
0.027268881,
0.0429343432,
-0.0151568092,
0.0227168426,
0.0258081146,
0.0120337615,
0.0452898443,
0.0408330597,
-0.0003896162,
-0.0500639267,
-0.0438819006,
-0.0052475748,
-0.044699423,
-0.0521191917,
0.0695009083,
-0.0529101342,
-0.0273747724,
-0.0061054537,
-0.0049622618,
-0.0020478112,
-0.0388735905,
-0.0321998782,
0.0189668778,
0.0162120741,
0.0412913673,
0.0181720369,
-0.0001542874,
-0.0079948734,
-0.0083323615,
-0.0191318356,
-0.012484543,
-0.0157166347,
0.0313831568,
0.0536232591,
0.0001305902,
-0.001467003,
-0.0230175201,
0.0110138347,
0.0108557148,
0.032867264,
-0.0386332162,
0.0107172914,
0.0128729856,
0.0913475603,
-0.0094813621,
-0.0388002209,
0.025860982,
0.0166106876,
0.0416585878,
-0.0601053424,
0.0487826429,
0.0269958358,
0.0085748406,
-0.0189538337,
-0.0511421226,
0.0004209929,
0.0137930689,
-0.0015829281,
-0.0420069918,
0.0114441905,
-0.0134965489,
0.0619095117,
-0.0030940336,
-0.0033738588,
0.0685998499,
-0.0151992161,
-0.0503005907,
-0.0122775882,
-0.1116465107,
0.0371474661,
-0.0639474317,
-0.028643135,
-0.0416469797,
0.0447385572,
-0.0624622442,
0.0045080734,
-0.0105555393,
0.0068200738,
-0.0300983451,
-0.0139665911,
0.005184812,
0.0394849777,
-0.0897982642,
-0.0309103671,
0.0126262484,
-0.0089692017,
-0.0685194582,
0.0365094841,
0.0673633069,
0.0194558222,
0.0299947504,
-0.0241896491,
0.0193218235,
0.0120335044,
0.0574634559,
0.0124913147,
-0.0435363315,
-0.0684297457,
0.008442766,
0.0269498508,
-0.01195323,
-0.0386196375,
-0.0068568862,
-0.0285169948,
-0.0022402054,
-0.0477663502,
0.0208861679,
0.0187285636,
-0.0580672286,
0.012517551,
-0.0398289785,
0.0176136177,
0.0011734035,
-0.0124063333,
-0.0034568382,
-0.0532839634,
-0.0224168487,
0.0216527972,
0.0346195735,
-0.0403270647,
0.051368814,
0.0410681181,
-0.0182581898,
-0.0115852347,
0.0262904912,
0.0269131027,
-0.0069078617,
-0.0585113168,
0.0414837524,
-0.0433367714,
-0.0332257114,
-0.0340726748,
-0.0054233363,
0.0522130616,
0.0711036101,
-0.0622001626,
0.0055870642,
0.0343139283,
-0.0055487002,
0.004404882,
0.0034966243,
-0.0566282272,
-0.0217722096,
-0.0198787451,
-0.0551812798,
0.0297953729,
-0.0182875972,
-0.0269808285,
0.0088784117,
0.0199691113,
0.0212524403,
-0.004538801,
0.0276649948,
-0.0128928805,
0.0027196093,
0.012397293,
0.0308474433,
0.0315332152,
-0.0180656593,
-0.0561870821,
-0.0376430489,
0.1108058095,
0.0421403572,
-0.0273772944,
0.0053232126,
0.0012150481,
-0.0142265232,
0.0405983552,
0.0450313985,
-0.0366361104,
0.022609707,
-0.0171743054,
-0.0471728295,
0.0470495448,
0.0046684043,
0.0309477821,
0.0251407921,
0.0097486759,
0.0089467932,
-0.0138136027,
-0.0219806954,
0.0318751857,
0.0414932966,
0.0203856006,
0.0254885536,
0.0406937301,
-0.0550542809,
0.0068165623,
0.026248198,
0.0145708928,
-0.0022064163,
-0.0177476015,
0.0024175332,
-0.0013591268,
0.0721147209,
0.0330736563,
0.0083568348,
-0.0445622876,
-0.0488172956,
-0.0154323392,
-0.0160218924,
0.0048497776,
-0.0058832709,
-0.0134137794,
0.0718271732,
-0.0251744874,
0.0401270688,
0.0016178242,
-0.0266917832,
-0.0445329808,
0.0437069163,
0.0227901936,
0.0067437389,
-0.043466486,
-0.0769861042,
0.0414038338,
-0.0510639846,
0.0079597989,
-0.0488245785,
-0.0222391542,
0.0469511263,
0.0041450188,
0.0164783038,
-0.0155525664,
0.0415463559,
-0.0212910399,
-0.0018867307,
0.0389267728,
0.0266027227,
0.024506174,
-0.0195999295,
-0.011025344,
0.003740611,
-0.0264848769,
0.0175451804,
0.0176023878,
-0.0183117241,
0.0735623762,
-0.0062414859,
-0.0618760325,
-0.0051901508,
-0.0030256219,
-0.0140434615,
0.0003554781,
0.0566713661,
0.0149948522,
-0.050700698,
0.0065342337,
-0.0395999067,
0.0564346313,
0.0013606494,
0.0051487442,
-0.0554631837,
0.0468218476,
-0.055710081,
0.0057571754,
-0.0088909175,
-0.0125184236,
0.0753056109,
0.0119846743,
-0.0364838541,
-0.0117704449,
-0.0264911968,
0.0512727834,
-0.0210008286,
-0.0503878146,
0.0413428508,
-0.0490980856,
0.0242055785,
-0.0192088578,
0.0244799871,
0.0311635211,
-0.0143364798,
0.0048440481,
-0.0930953324,
0.0205575433,
0.0156098409,
0.0449763536,
0.0127937943,
-0.0112857996,
-0.0027029107,
0.0059783231,
0.07892102,
-0.031661056,
-0.0923123807,
-0.0404937416,
0.0256281476,
-0.0086112963,
0.070755519,
0.0237758979,
-0.0188137759,
-0.0203002132,
-0.0112633277,
0.0369297601,
-0.0289203171,
0.0031575458,
-0.0143686812,
0.0247091614,
0.0260720979,
-0.027022101,
-0.0605786927,
-0.0420282595,
0.0483337007,
0.0324099362,
0.0191918518,
-0.0167527162,
-0.0580507889,
0.0334946178,
-0.0570891164,
0.0472511128,
0.0361573398,
-0.0396282226,
0.0022009248,
0.0471672826,
0.0512827188,
-0.0072080866,
-0.0545258634,
-0.0066259233,
-0.0582173765,
0.0335424952,
-0.0146344258,
0.0274580196,
0.0090501634,
-0.0112609044,
0.0037884924,
-0.0946581513,
0.0411000401,
-0.0157786459,
-0.0881775618,
-0.0244246479,
0.0387852788,
0.048813872,
0.0400282368,
0.0062676636,
0.0090533355,
0.0113112144,
-0.052548524,
0.0303702988,
0.0682586804,
-0.0815752223,
0.0404124409,
0.0105868438,
0.0719147623,
-0.0591202155,
0.0194897875,
-0.0181626491,
-0.0514232479,
0.0576868393,
-0.0136005152,
0.0050013815,
-0.0390039533,
-0.0145460498,
-0.0037914175,
-0.0183876194,
-0.0385848545,
-0.0312722586,
-0.0330828391,
0.0014349034,
0.0364914313,
-0.0129117426,
-0.0610913336,
0.033885736,
-0.0519297458,
0.027435312,
-0.0081933178,
0.0433303937,
-0.0096864142,
-0.0365138426,
-0.0140906293,
0.01134119,
-0.0216397829,
0.0064325971,
0.0603896715,
-0.0390964597,
-0.0081280563,
-0.0121687492,
-0.0083425976,
-0.0063734697,
0.0090686707,
0.0690782666,
0.0408978984,
0.0008430079,
0.0145286657,
-0.0219370555,
-0.0214599445,
-0.0039106561,
0.0972014517,
-0.0317468531,
-0.0364277586,
0.0378940031,
-0.0432660468,
0.0242851507,
0.0240343437,
-0.0064772149,
0.0334206074,
-0.1013188064,
-0.0488478392,
-0.034271542,
0.0050291391,
0.044557631,
0.0496288911,
0.0184221994,
0.0048414464,
0.0066229859,
-0.0266380161,
-0.0843287855,
0.0098593282,
-0.0367548503,
0.078008391,
-0.0637749955,
-0.0089004487,
-0.0411966182,
-0.0120095238,
-0.0930845439,
-0.0781871006,
-0.0051003592,
-0.0318846293,
-0.0215833075,
-0.0638258979,
0.0335446633,
0.0385983773,
-0.013148102,
0.002781223,
-0.0053034248,
0.0479586571,
0.0017196346,
-0.0139316907,
0.0290459394,
-0.0361408778,
-0.0149827143,
-0.0030873774,
-0.0105209006,
0.0459524393,
-0.010453715,
-0.0459110625,
-0.0081878817,
0.0326104797,
0.0445777029,
0.0496977381,
0.0014746201,
0.023655422,
-0.0161587335,
-0.0625782609,
0.0067116837,
0.0481398031,
-0.0274370685,
-0.0146239949,
-0.0194953848,
0.0774868578,
0.0290161204,
0.0145717058,
-0.0158530455,
0.0108604152,
-0.010432235,
-0.0412409939,
0.0217294972,
-0.0115842018,
0.0306388773,
-0.0179531686,
-0.05133361,
0.0193322431,
-0.0150567209,
0.0203614272,
0.0397063643,
-0.0168487392,
0.0036994615,
0.0128206778,
0.0088186236,
0.0041721077,
0.00927292,
0.0045743207,
-0.0299709737,
-0.0378257781,
0.0465172306,
0.0288902577,
-0.0302848592,
0.0051458455,
-0.0282634478,
-0.0139133194,
0.0154488953,
-0.0439344794,
0.0122876903,
-0.0352297239,
-0.0014976918,
-0.0110919066,
0.0033656105,
0.0150172487,
0.0329710022,
0.0319475271,
0.0702998191,
-0.050406307,
-0.0917054191,
0.0034119114,
-0.0177220888,
0.0742032006,
0.0070701027,
-0.0176377185,
0.0019245072,
-0.0662612915,
-0.0436738841,
-0.030142691,
0.0218242928,
0.0061062546,
0.0215266515,
-0.0004599323,
0.0272309463,
0.0369817242,
-0.0004195763,
-0.0434891805,
-0.0388419442,
0.0009583692,
0.0021676363,
-0.0353490375,
-5.534431646e-33,
-0.0088728638,
-0.0702486783,
0.0186249893,
-0.0110012693,
0.0067256507,
0.0198273137,
0.061415188,
-0.0769180283,
-0.0272621326,
-0.0268016197,
0.0419759192,
0.0155758038,
0.017221069,
-0.0007389313,
0.0319344923,
0.014814564,
0.0269918852,
0.0305924546,
-0.0106146596,
-0.0263762772,
0.0206306148,
-0.0048645316,
0.0522576757,
-0.017050311,
0.0208129771,
0.0114388941,
-0.0450335741,
0.0519331992,
0.0147421556,
0.0601857752,
0.0011223259,
0.0207470637,
0.0306824446,
-0.0152614228,
0.0343078114,
-0.0020248997,
-0.0612750277,
-0.0276262835,
0.0039528608,
0.0208064914,
0.0476456322,
0.0043427418,
0.0219047647,
-0.0001272529,
-0.0323790759,
0.0097154835,
0.0665694103,
0.0004176,
0.0242605004,
0.0440953933,
-0.0057983552,
0.0127414931,
-0.0213101041,
0.0250385255,
0.0029127579,
0.0172973555,
0.0442312844,
-0.0296245981,
-0.0676702261,
0.0610438585,
0.0284754336,
0.0104967002,
0.007796281,
-0.0593964309,
-0.0114171915,
0.0058321585,
-0.0059519582,
-0.0278468337,
0.0672751442,
-0.0057059843,
-0.0084762098,
0.0428209268,
-0.0424817167,
-0.0500212088,
0.0655698031,
-0.011777008,
-0.0168779232,
0.0427844077,
0.0257156566,
0.0244969632,
-0.0417851359,
-0.0150779132,
-0.0763511956,
-0.0279859118,
-0.0059649218,
-0.0265451409,
-0.0168734547,
0.0169294029,
0.0925815776,
0.0273632258,
-0.01119434,
0.0023375128,
-0.0645823404,
-0.0333014503,
-0.0034349761,
-0.0530058183,
-0.0115802297,
-0.000652861,
-0.0151109491,
0.0171144977,
-0.0357870385,
-0.0592301525,
0.0095973648,
-0.0288671646,
0.0263968185,
0.0439903848,
0.0035294679,
-0.0141928839,
-0.0500485115,
0.005553172,
0.0191921592,
0.0065053236,
-0.0340276621,
-0.0354522318,
0.0264819227,
0.0106401462,
0.0209934227,
-0.0361799821,
0.0468487963,
0.0021605412,
-0.033944983,
-0.0544935539,
0.0331459269,
0.0133314133,
0.0255636312,
0.0088080121,
0.0096924035,
-0.0451109856,
0.0283641089,
-0.0123008126,
0.0046713115,
-0.014237185,
2.381e-7,
0.0727002323,
0.0222388748,
-0.0610316247,
0.0581935942,
-0.0268362295,
-0.0118745342,
0.0119778942,
0.0174447354,
0.0227510519,
0.0867578462,
0.0146623915,
-0.0674716234,
-0.0194498766,
0.0464439467,
-0.0414895155,
-0.0247342698,
0.0140052345,
-0.058284305,
-0.0898754746,
0.0103496704,
0.0906898677,
0.0188634116,
0.0801328868,
-0.0167595781,
-0.0143431183,
-0.019602485,
-0.0180062372,
0.0314727724,
0.0200348422,
0.0207662582,
0.0708220601,
0.0315477699,
0.0222620778,
0.0736154243,
-0.035196349,
0.0622465201,
0.027565321,
0.0564539842,
-0.0306273289,
0.0700400621,
-0.0218951683,
-0.0667421892,
-0.0253877975,
0.0148274265,
0.0378365777,
-0.0290570706,
0.0550745204,
-0.0198954903,
-0.0818031952,
0.0039169933,
0.0026806777,
0.0424578153,
-0.0347164087,
-0.0043619932,
0.0111604901,
-0.0226679277,
-0.0019449211,
-0.0170467105,
0.0617306568,
0.0069803246,
0.0150624439,
-0.0534626395,
0.0311880521,
0.080476217,
0.0170005746,
-0.0485077575,
-0.0271954779,
2.138277718e-34,
0.0356086195,
0.03536845,
-0.0178338718,
-0.0151493559,
0.0345318913,
0.0192091055,
0.0065375487,
-0.0054765316,
-0.0493666902,
-0.007070608,
-0.0245662443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11090v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11090v4 | Towards Responsible and Safe AI in the Era of Foudnation Models: A Reference Architecture for Designing Foundation Model based Systems | 2023-04-13T05:01:03 | 2024-05-26T23:51:04 | Qinghua Lu, Liming Zhu, Xiwei Xu, Zhenchang Xing, Jon Whittle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | The release of ChatGPT, Gemini, and other large language model has drawn huge
interests on foundations models. There is a broad consensus that foundations
models will be the fundamental building blocks for future AI systems. However,
there is a lack of systematic guidance on the architecture design.
Particularly, the the rapidly growing capabilities of foundations models can
eventually absorb other components of AI systems, posing challenges of moving
boundary and interface evolution in architecture design. Furthermore,
incorporating foundations models into AI systems raises significant concerns
about responsible and safe AI due to their opaque nature and rapidly advancing
intelligence. To address these challenges, the paper first presents an
architecture evolution of AI systems in the era of foundation models,
transitioning from "foundation-model-as-a-connector" to
"foundation-model-as-a-monolithic architecture". The paper then identifies key
design decisions and proposes a pattern-oriented reference architecture for
designing responsible foundation-model-based systems. The patterns can enable
the potential of foundation models while ensuring associated risks. | [
0.0222495925,
0.084558621,
-0.0334720835,
0.017183423,
-0.032477539,
-0.0306710545,
0.006804355,
-0.0390750431,
-0.0067336266,
-0.0145901302,
-0.0084467465,
-0.0086201793,
-0.0292797573,
0.0837619603,
-0.0026265229,
-0.029190097,
0.0850190595,
-0.0528894551,
0.00063015,
0.0203953106,
0.0021790978,
0.0095191924,
0.0088324137,
0.0176475961,
-0.0510674194,
-0.0136381146,
-0.022114275,
-0.0011921328,
0.0057263216,
-0.0143091176,
-0.0011731132,
-0.0156830326,
0.026513584,
0.0276550911,
0.000002147,
-0.0161290206,
0.0109312581,
0.0402026288,
-0.0251005366,
-0.0423339941,
0.029222941,
0.0299170632,
-0.0245515388,
-0.0047109015,
-0.0227526166,
-0.0212701485,
0.0828455836,
0.0951124504,
0.0415798351,
0.0165855046,
-0.0021497791,
-0.0162548777,
0.1019520611,
0.021476686,
-0.0619968809,
-0.0293962359,
0.0306741092,
0.0015039115,
0.0159110054,
0.0106572621,
0.0046275826,
-0.0226998162,
0.025896186,
-0.0055516586,
0.0018495395,
0.0011947859,
0.0032098747,
-0.0702677816,
-0.0458908863,
-0.0035198221,
0.0351230539,
-0.0094556734,
0.0279377792,
0.0352724865,
-0.0108801927,
-0.0211982727,
-0.0201089159,
0.042310033,
-0.023254456,
-0.011063912,
0.0836350843,
0.0097968085,
0.0247614179,
0.0436842255,
0.0038468947,
0.0727692023,
-0.0083441949,
0.0174516644,
-0.0014836456,
-0.027525302,
0.0538469627,
-0.0515396483,
-0.0129368547,
0.0293193012,
-0.0493861958,
0.0063830805,
-0.0619403049,
0.0437575094,
0.0147446198,
-0.0230051279,
-0.0060864161,
-0.0137178637,
0.0180622023,
0.0205430295,
0.0245376565,
0.0011599261,
-0.0557542145,
0.0206315164,
-0.0126368552,
0.0336974822,
-0.0282046217,
0.0070317099,
-0.0457325354,
0.0741457492,
-0.014935202,
-0.0042311433,
-0.0081213508,
0.0897898749,
-0.0441155732,
0.0036139726,
-0.0442676358,
0.0069921757,
0.0080378205,
0.0060346406,
0.0136042954,
-0.0421920605,
-0.0042599556,
-0.0050199851,
0.0249871593,
-0.1093876511,
0.0227568094,
0.0034995326,
-0.0614954084,
-0.0082996562,
-0.0161590837,
0.0839562267,
0.0410701446,
-0.0176086687,
-0.0606573224,
-0.0656371415,
0.0629441142,
-0.037169002,
0.0163679402,
-0.0275237672,
-0.0340515003,
-0.0268308315,
-0.0097659752,
-0.0271438528,
0.00946128,
-0.0031163809,
-0.0197976772,
0.014783782,
-0.0393909179,
0.0068867886,
0.0156139815,
0.0462100282,
-0.0630323514,
0.0457408465,
0.035811197,
-0.0040387213,
0.0198332369,
-0.0067029903,
0.0227900594,
-0.0033923348,
-0.0309882481,
0.0185553133,
0.016922893,
0.0332097039,
-0.0333424583,
-0.024171995,
-0.042842295,
0.0389109291,
-0.0156639945,
0.0485887453,
0.0478825085,
0.0448349863,
-0.0108218146,
0.0758651271,
0.0071449955,
-0.0207684264,
0.0186637696,
-0.0447667874,
-0.052772209,
-0.0111395568,
-0.0566820167,
-0.002965119,
-0.1399217695,
0.0559386611,
-0.0310552511,
-0.0190958884,
0.0235902984,
-0.0491387956,
0.0178769436,
0.0141039528,
0.0257291514,
-0.0001194418,
-0.00303457,
-0.0150841298,
-0.0351143032,
-0.0293041263,
-0.0221804157,
-0.1081366464,
0.0285498239,
0.0608579218,
0.0154955806,
-0.0416405983,
-0.0726479515,
-0.0093369419,
-0.0207752604,
-0.0033250605,
0.008873092,
-0.0192518346,
0.0348023362,
-0.0013412301,
-0.0170786735,
0.0508220755,
0.0227812734,
0.0089138877,
-0.0448068716,
-0.0035314057,
-0.0537667423,
0.064276889,
-0.0262425561,
0.0248388145,
-0.007895451,
0.0118034612,
-0.0501628853,
0.0097362539,
0.0418248922,
0.0072286124,
-0.0417766944,
0.0125504853,
0.0586682968,
0.0462559238,
-0.0353354327,
0.0023646615,
-0.0191698149,
0.1314095855,
-0.0200263448,
-0.0201717205,
0.0274312198,
0.0052779131,
-0.0117407795,
-0.031236425,
0.0193268936,
-0.0323314108,
0.0194256566,
-0.0003210678,
0.0243723039,
-0.0377066843,
-0.0304702334,
-0.0138584711,
0.0115000978,
-0.0223012883,
-0.0892098472,
0.0046167532,
0.0161203295,
0.041170273,
-0.0386706516,
-0.0239027776,
0.0140234204,
-0.0244523268,
0.0405934304,
0.0531787127,
0.0129165594,
-0.0013593721,
0.0416374467,
-0.0481775738,
0.0074608386,
0.0061460878,
0.0135849174,
0.0054829828,
0.010317428,
-0.0071668075,
-0.0086196288,
0.0508425198,
0.0411157571,
-0.0088390382,
0.0125116669,
-0.0105848666,
0.0108804712,
-0.0843672007,
0.0110308183,
0.0017102589,
-0.0354522951,
-0.0088051409,
-0.0128586479,
-0.0539719611,
-0.061954055,
0.0243489835,
-0.0114365537,
0.0245903488,
-0.0006459188,
-0.0130136609,
0.0281796996,
-0.0075973407,
-0.0660780296,
0.0529695004,
-0.0296006128,
0.0683305413,
0.0226498507,
-0.0136859939,
0.0305666253,
0.0027393405,
0.0121716699,
0.0446723849,
-0.0041157049,
0.0289971717,
-0.007910572,
-0.0132871689,
-0.0385520309,
-0.0061082719,
0.0030403254,
0.0273527782,
-0.0162906218,
-0.0490548871,
0.0260331705,
-0.1067261472,
-0.0190499313,
0.0435830355,
-0.0326609053,
-0.0613324381,
0.0540271662,
-0.000851799,
0.0337472484,
0.0027450866,
-0.0375988856,
-0.0121810855,
0.0177880675,
-0.0082215257,
0.0036310102,
0.0677924901,
-0.0273821503,
-0.0575994961,
-0.0026250074,
0.0090860175,
-0.0362385474,
0.0183788165,
-0.0411384925,
-0.024727229,
0.0022891983,
-0.0720467269,
-0.0546786226,
0.0285786428,
-0.0382055342,
0.0305320043,
-0.0590416789,
-0.0095808608,
-0.038162753,
0.0047986535,
0.0211401936,
-0.0285775922,
0.0027017707,
-0.0011968085,
-0.0265513733,
-0.034763854,
0.0206217598,
-0.0327380151,
0.0443391092,
0.020166086,
0.0374178775,
0.0245249216,
0.0298056118,
-0.002587372,
-0.0265349541,
-0.0078126248,
0.0385130495,
0.0112129971,
-0.0488935784,
0.0406633429,
0.0093944557,
-0.0439782403,
-0.0324767008,
0.0277510863,
-0.012223972,
0.052346658,
0.0236975495,
0.0003488561,
-0.0321221575,
0.0217275638,
0.0365590677,
-0.0488812365,
0.0287105367,
0.0054943501,
-0.0043069916,
-0.0427059904,
-0.0203979127,
0.0422031581,
-0.0032045927,
0.0640905872,
0.0220787507,
-0.0668716282,
0.0047287936,
-0.0283625387,
-0.0085635204,
-0.000169791,
-0.0111733973,
0.0143457036,
0.0035884702,
-0.0417181663,
0.0028426915,
-0.001273214,
-0.0011270372,
-0.0326139182,
-0.0398411117,
0.0386026204,
0.0837820321,
-0.0255842526,
-0.0602842309,
0.012310083,
-0.0001214926,
0.0096752625,
0.0321877412,
-0.0069113565,
-0.0100916373,
0.010131008,
-0.0095599089,
-0.0668273047,
-0.0021610421,
-0.0262588784,
-0.0227219798,
0.0271299519,
0.0989695489,
-0.061888203,
-0.0029578747,
-0.0908197463,
-0.0451022722,
0.0228826515,
0.0233134348,
-0.0346050523,
-0.0074670799,
-0.040474426,
0.0214068871,
-0.0155168008,
-0.0027920685,
-0.0086367372,
0.0172350146,
-0.0271180589,
-0.0854045004,
-0.035791073,
-0.017436998,
-0.0515809208,
0.0231464151,
0.0389466025,
-0.0517584868,
0.0582500324,
0.0268392749,
-0.0189497955,
-0.0110119851,
-0.014723476,
0.0013759816,
-0.032910984,
0.0471851565,
0.0015711528,
-0.0390295386,
0.00453756,
0.0350249447,
0.0515412837,
-0.0153114488,
0.069339186,
0.1052765623,
0.0345513597,
-0.0582969971,
-0.0279433243,
-0.0351700559,
0.0492657386,
-0.0014644286,
-0.0401109904,
0.0012850916,
0.0349933393,
-0.0953961536,
0.0233521312,
-0.0120797055,
-0.0635945648,
0.0273766648,
0.0266197007,
-0.0041568796,
-0.0256102514,
0.0332274586,
-0.0085515641,
0.0465760902,
0.0155432327,
0.0055290409,
0.0491371974,
0.0073310691,
0.012811779,
-0.0318438746,
-0.0103040952,
-0.0197601281,
0.050897982,
-0.0125424378,
0.0174741074,
0.0427024774,
-0.0218683947,
0.005930434,
0.0427610166,
0.0258414317,
0.0438547172,
0.0192756876,
0.1107678711,
-0.0052442807,
0.0169907156,
-0.0137516828,
-0.0070884721,
-0.0139745893,
0.0203049239,
-0.0044032759,
0.053770069,
-0.0009278829,
-0.0093797818,
-0.0228485968,
0.0576964244,
-0.0570132658,
-0.0814692229,
-0.0032712573,
0.0544873402,
0.0075313412,
0.0694959611,
-0.011645372,
-0.064406544,
-0.0026370131,
-0.0476718247,
0.0073353848,
0.0375925936,
-0.047363814,
-0.0124205323,
0.0451290682,
0.0138652874,
-0.0394299701,
0.0002799045,
0.0035378938,
0.0498834662,
-0.0215016603,
-0.0690020844,
-0.0202547535,
-0.0115741342,
0.0055667274,
0.0151923494,
-0.019633539,
-0.0258436184,
-0.0898186415,
-0.0559046231,
0.0357866846,
0.0428875461,
0.021140689,
-0.0198647492,
0.0395420156,
-0.0062377402,
0.0436939746,
-0.0680503547,
0.0059292177,
-0.0254741739,
-0.0855083317,
-0.0062196925,
-0.0143042319,
-5.777356737e-33,
0.0222937688,
0.0166828316,
0.0239647869,
0.0055628759,
-0.0578125268,
0.0093309022,
0.0331884287,
0.0243546516,
-0.0436727889,
0.0023013356,
-0.0106016118,
0.0103152692,
0.0059111556,
-0.0162562598,
0.0100002224,
0.0076511647,
0.0116916979,
-0.014313166,
0.0084658712,
0.0344579481,
0.0083991475,
-0.0027924972,
0.0443370678,
-0.105702579,
-0.0105370814,
-0.0067549152,
-0.0174578819,
0.0409990884,
-0.0356434509,
0.0383029394,
0.0242939815,
0.0478421114,
0.0106096314,
0.0202566758,
0.0215018429,
0.0528349951,
-0.0366093144,
-0.0258167516,
-0.0002039776,
0.0029794942,
-0.0279404465,
-0.0449681655,
0.0218534488,
-0.015581103,
-0.0106164087,
0.0149768274,
-0.0114197182,
-0.0410043783,
0.0269649066,
0.0098547097,
-0.0506702065,
-0.0008209413,
0.0043147174,
0.0027740921,
-0.004310763,
-0.0246068127,
-0.0169464778,
-0.0635305792,
0.0144005995,
0.0071174707,
-0.0257984772,
-0.0603844747,
0.0183575023,
0.0456515886,
-0.0017449931,
0.0098723397,
0.0460837446,
0.0139590744,
0.0183561929,
-0.0542855747,
-0.020856047,
0.1303418279,
0.0166897774,
0.029815549,
-0.0266868453,
-0.0114366906,
-0.0950831398,
0.0323930755,
0.0468121767,
0.0908861458,
0.0065780161,
-0.0148370005,
-0.0709261447,
0.0069912248,
0.0012751737,
-0.0302689504,
-0.0101063298,
0.0137462756,
0.0245960746,
-0.0089170625,
-0.0246934108,
0.0205509365,
-0.0062941918,
-0.074094817,
0.0436254218,
0.0080130491,
0.0353739187,
0.0065187272,
-0.0059647467,
0.0229781084,
-0.0003636209,
-0.0656936541,
-0.0171831567,
-0.0000643605,
0.0301907975,
0.0114064096,
0.0193317831,
0.0637669042,
0.0203856137,
-0.0024841989,
-0.008508482,
0.027009083,
0.056248907,
-0.0356167108,
0.0160108395,
0.0058377124,
0.0353267938,
0.0355720855,
0.0428368114,
0.0079997098,
-0.0361409634,
0.0067341579,
-0.0172852296,
0.0087654963,
0.0091977343,
-0.0064925184,
-0.0274645742,
0.0258133858,
0.0282373056,
-0.0913533792,
-0.021277111,
0.0166997351,
3.049e-7,
-0.0175788142,
0.0067451941,
0.0473208353,
0.0197016373,
0.0396721102,
0.0394444391,
0.0384383202,
0.0693452135,
-0.0112366946,
0.0451484844,
0.0207920391,
0.0003920001,
-0.0205302816,
0.015090757,
-0.0130160153,
-0.0190032832,
0.0027666474,
-0.0139122847,
-0.0504712835,
-0.0007475428,
0.04565873,
0.0107656755,
0.0240129717,
-0.0441461541,
-0.0040079807,
0.0139778145,
-0.0031747173,
-0.0053556259,
0.0570375025,
-0.0081639029,
-0.0407278612,
0.0898514166,
-0.0082545411,
0.0212285519,
0.0374685787,
0.0176128354,
-0.0371231362,
0.0397223048,
-0.0509800017,
0.0258557182,
0.0222067647,
-0.0498577319,
0.0099356296,
-0.0026423386,
0.05726308,
-0.0207872279,
-0.0135579295,
-0.0153518422,
-0.0695348009,
-0.0114938328,
-0.0464106947,
-0.0140228113,
-0.0184298605,
-0.0089376559,
-0.009351097,
-0.0029949234,
0.0150307445,
0.0063796123,
0.0670709014,
0.0051734922,
0.0237034354,
-0.0680728704,
0.0040720478,
0.0111472076,
-0.0057114386,
-0.0470935367,
0.0090524787,
2.617611483e-34,
-0.0354906246,
-0.0658481568,
0.0163017325,
0.029074885,
0.0430371203,
0.0238537528,
-0.0375298336,
-0.0099725714,
0.0379748233,
0.0137425791,
-0.0379273444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.07297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.07297v2 | Language Instructed Reinforcement Learning for Human-AI Coordination | 2023-04-13T04:47:31 | 2023-06-10T20:00:45 | Hengyuan Hu, Dorsa Sadigh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MA | One of the fundamental quests of AI is to produce agents that coordinate well
with humans. This problem is challenging, especially in domains that lack high
quality human behavioral data, because multi-agent reinforcement learning (RL)
often converges to different equilibria from the ones that humans prefer. We
propose a novel framework, instructRL, that enables humans to specify what kind
of strategies they expect from their AI partners through natural language
instructions. We use pretrained large language models to generate a prior
policy conditioned on the human instruction and use the prior to regularize the
RL objective. This leads to the RL agent converging to equilibria that are
aligned with human preferences. We show that instructRL converges to human-like
policies that satisfy the given instructions in a proof-of-concept environment
as well as the challenging Hanabi benchmark. Finally, we show that knowing the
language instruction significantly boosts human-AI coordination performance in
human evaluations in Hanabi. | [
0.0601332784,
0.0667657629,
0.0040784255,
-0.0269345846,
-0.0221382212,
0.010808737,
-0.0090187034,
-0.0155054117,
0.0125838965,
-0.0051202211,
-0.0490420535,
-0.0241202526,
0.0162178632,
-0.0037095649,
-0.0044732899,
-0.0739910677,
0.0293798652,
-0.0335336849,
0.023047071,
0.0048931446,
0.0307675116,
-0.0243013948,
-0.011829135,
0.0568894334,
-0.0195971001,
0.0299190357,
-0.0326972269,
-0.0327794291,
0.0448405966,
-0.0312430914,
0.0014449654,
0.0221527684,
0.050885275,
-0.0198028609,
0.0000019094,
-0.0594524518,
0.0151905799,
-0.0479957275,
0.0120083811,
-0.0505290814,
0.0340399519,
-0.0331717134,
-0.0096479338,
0.0216615889,
-0.0609120987,
0.0497326665,
0.0250123218,
0.0358075239,
0.068565391,
0.0735318065,
0.0115553122,
0.015616918,
-0.0179478209,
-0.0181045234,
-0.0070958389,
-0.0909014419,
0.0284212269,
-0.0319753923,
0.040329989,
-0.0121630728,
-0.0099374251,
-0.0407938808,
0.0385002308,
0.0080870157,
-0.0527021028,
0.0513361469,
-0.0086925812,
-0.0374637432,
-0.0070731346,
0.0861292258,
0.0000978076,
-0.0056829387,
0.0007018234,
-0.004452717,
0.0251044016,
0.0292989314,
0.003359599,
0.0288521014,
0.0086639747,
0.0192055423,
0.0058763875,
-0.012904318,
0.014923906,
0.0216173455,
-0.0159006156,
0.1052175537,
-0.040836297,
-0.0300012007,
0.0446673781,
0.0127551481,
0.0072487369,
-0.0647096559,
-0.0079498775,
0.0470459908,
-0.0960210562,
0.0009419358,
-0.0629180297,
0.0051898737,
-0.0135763362,
-0.0152088916,
0.057503026,
0.0581803918,
0.0256984029,
0.0266986433,
0.0291099064,
0.0840294212,
0.0042529693,
0.0137091838,
-0.0296053588,
0.0138317663,
-0.0422379263,
0.0132849785,
-0.0592901446,
0.0121957064,
-0.0078922473,
-0.0097391801,
-0.0410401933,
0.0215886105,
-0.0895607322,
0.0513990931,
-0.0209390949,
0.0291800648,
-0.0371286385,
-0.0194722787,
-0.0755774379,
-0.0353801176,
-0.0656526685,
0.01864071,
0.0282883253,
-0.0308337267,
-0.0141304638,
0.0149036627,
-0.0092596505,
-0.0188496914,
0.00863091,
0.0706051141,
-0.0234353766,
0.002588267,
0.009150642,
-0.0223276298,
0.0219643507,
-0.0545216836,
-0.0250666626,
-0.0355053172,
0.0533763953,
-0.0137837138,
-0.0397625975,
-0.0749237463,
-0.0007884991,
0.0129818181,
-0.0233808197,
0.0869330913,
0.0192891676,
0.0078787291,
0.0047992822,
0.0028393061,
-0.0547190718,
0.056165535,
0.057941407,
0.0446347483,
-0.0024034937,
0.0456462614,
0.0310155675,
0.0590845235,
0.0054248986,
0.012304008,
0.0206368435,
-0.0009860261,
-0.0030923372,
0.0779618248,
0.064848043,
0.0272668917,
-0.0380641706,
-0.0173226967,
0.0513832346,
0.0771959946,
-0.0159400962,
0.0041998592,
0.0640796721,
0.0479628034,
-0.0205115192,
-0.0262325369,
-0.0696820021,
0.0337468237,
0.0027149885,
-0.0108847897,
0.001949621,
-0.0044222972,
-0.0317369811,
-0.0430232137,
0.0407710262,
-0.0227841716,
0.0452949218,
0.0011742467,
0.0226431061,
-0.0037392494,
-0.0429346748,
-0.0283343662,
0.0432015881,
-0.0084616346,
0.0241275486,
-0.0414376706,
0.0388784409,
0.0715500489,
0.0084276134,
-0.0332569368,
0.0139285456,
-0.008287196,
-0.0072019403,
0.036901433,
0.0358715244,
-0.0334291942,
0.0228375997,
-0.0108611621,
-0.0411241092,
0.0251516383,
-0.0177762154,
0.0524856821,
0.0167408977,
0.0104327705,
-0.0104767364,
0.0431803688,
-0.0294436496,
0.0470310487,
-0.0312131066,
0.0066322885,
-0.0129665295,
0.0095602768,
0.0470156707,
-0.0166836008,
-0.0373288766,
0.0077520758,
0.0100635542,
0.0064183935,
-0.0242467225,
0.0111107323,
-0.0218825564,
0.0123759788,
0.0145787084,
-0.0154145993,
-0.0201778151,
0.0179024488,
-0.0245176777,
-0.0151272817,
0.0384796038,
0.0262415837,
0.0270806495,
0.0159033872,
-0.0046823779,
0.0434443429,
-0.0201908313,
-0.0132334111,
0.0259324759,
-0.0148621434,
-0.0253299177,
0.0156275872,
-0.015431514,
-0.0183310527,
-0.0505760349,
0.0294883326,
0.0377599485,
0.0038543625,
0.0332146622,
0.0775109679,
0.0637673885,
-0.0362312123,
0.0091924798,
-0.0626703426,
-0.0175053291,
-0.0298829265,
-0.0076361527,
-0.012517645,
-0.0010314875,
-0.0076448238,
-0.0237948652,
-0.0276467167,
0.0095603298,
-0.0104876719,
0.0081142476,
0.022083303,
0.0527662747,
-0.0233809389,
-0.0570019372,
0.0206694882,
-0.0013873772,
-0.0078866649,
0.0457176603,
0.0440999903,
-0.0587518997,
0.0127340704,
-0.0394844338,
0.0601206645,
-0.0260654688,
-0.0429417826,
0.0549347922,
-0.0315450542,
-0.0014673582,
0.090243049,
0.0014464837,
0.0459551401,
0.0453773402,
0.0184348021,
-0.0784611404,
0.051831156,
-0.0282263625,
-0.0336610079,
-0.0733894706,
-0.0035714067,
0.0282538906,
0.0410973616,
-0.0308005977,
0.0276984349,
-0.059743464,
0.0028562138,
0.0055489945,
-0.0779690892,
-0.0292247925,
-0.00469248,
-0.0481226556,
0.0135106649,
-0.0503490455,
-0.0253395718,
0.0762194097,
0.0338239968,
-0.0014779412,
-0.0194361154,
-0.0127876913,
-0.0044793906,
0.0182533246,
0.0204422027,
0.0235225689,
-0.0625684932,
-0.0064976718,
-0.0829594657,
-0.0185646843,
0.0084661115,
0.015395904,
0.0087602967,
-0.0638152808,
0.0100538088,
-0.0030454367,
-0.0536256209,
-0.0447080247,
0.0053726882,
-0.0436283313,
0.0248299297,
0.0246904362,
-0.0406139195,
-0.0228163768,
-0.0339870341,
0.0244315062,
0.0170893576,
0.0081452094,
-0.0372947454,
-0.0242688749,
-0.0427415445,
0.0546125993,
0.0248383656,
-0.0377537832,
-0.0566360652,
0.01056406,
0.0377601199,
0.061591018,
-0.029906325,
-0.0376511067,
0.0191056132,
0.0181813315,
-0.0375584774,
0.0383456536,
0.0835825652,
0.0417064503,
0.0001954215,
-0.0206154566,
0.100528039,
0.0307476874,
-0.036710538,
0.0125110289,
-0.0001080214,
0.0391048305,
-0.0070614475,
0.0235928204,
-0.0387513787,
-0.0403751358,
-0.0065911128,
0.0376836397,
0.0228787791,
-0.0545767955,
0.0124894632,
-0.0998143926,
-0.0136554325,
-0.0025269145,
-0.0593976676,
-0.0089642433,
-0.0443996899,
0.0123451995,
-0.0614741854,
0.023088811,
0.000344939,
0.030784402,
-0.0004886671,
-0.0050991792,
-0.0068780268,
-0.0192082897,
0.0193070676,
-0.0863292143,
0.0535224378,
0.0847863331,
0.0381243341,
-0.0229469966,
-0.0225606207,
-0.0219604634,
0.0569766425,
0.0171267856,
0.0107236449,
-0.006880499,
-0.0334138572,
0.0091367215,
-0.0088317804,
0.0633468255,
-0.0293121953,
-0.0132604921,
0.0200704504,
0.0250290912,
-0.0373779498,
-0.0129209282,
0.0000092812,
0.0268143136,
0.042407386,
0.0663702264,
-0.0397587195,
-0.1050117388,
-0.054435838,
-0.0351528972,
-0.0525091738,
-0.0543022566,
-0.024726158,
-0.0091929249,
-0.0263598301,
-0.0126145603,
-0.074385576,
-0.0951566547,
0.01863713,
0.0194319915,
0.0123948343,
-0.0655569583,
0.0514521152,
0.0320313573,
0.0302113257,
0.0200564545,
-0.0164671969,
0.0241321567,
-0.0534862392,
-0.0293632168,
-0.0256507359,
-0.0316665135,
-0.0205619689,
0.030230308,
-0.0210525393,
-0.0741387829,
0.0027670132,
0.0795551538,
0.0153861567,
0.0887185708,
0.0019353546,
-0.0298283882,
-0.0072326791,
0.0109174028,
-0.0297164023,
0.017282756,
0.024306111,
0.0366822742,
0.0039531481,
0.0434105508,
-0.0628265813,
0.0145933945,
0.0021161516,
0.0201176386,
-0.0547287352,
-0.0518921204,
0.0392943025,
-0.0460378155,
0.0137931481,
-0.0462397933,
0.000896815,
0.0108275013,
-0.0379010923,
-0.0228127539,
-0.0424808711,
-0.0368488729,
-0.0158792995,
0.0451895073,
0.0035364183,
0.0294342395,
0.0171340406,
0.0144779487,
-0.0049797078,
0.0014654564,
-0.0116902841,
0.0348016545,
0.0677721649,
0.0267150048,
0.0200937837,
0.0236098524,
0.0135301808,
0.0031621645,
0.0505570583,
0.0276428014,
0.0782920048,
0.0461484194,
0.0097425133,
0.0006286618,
0.0138069587,
-0.0574241504,
-0.0854845122,
0.0150997583,
-0.0091097783,
0.061517477,
0.0118459901,
0.0247339085,
-0.0689555407,
0.026705483,
0.0080054495,
0.0314640328,
-0.0428910479,
-0.0237114113,
0.0296210591,
0.0180400591,
-0.0056727221,
0.0363023095,
0.0606267303,
0.0150955664,
0.0256306175,
-0.05286102,
0.0163102336,
-0.0221986175,
-0.0214062091,
0.0219576433,
0.0324716344,
-0.0200866591,
0.0080807889,
-0.0221193377,
-0.0439096317,
-0.029307304,
0.0486655384,
-0.0078820949,
-0.0019654916,
0.059758205,
0.0107431989,
-0.0487878658,
-0.0189092476,
-0.0326153971,
-0.0351446234,
-0.0139673306,
-0.0423087738,
-0.0628059953,
-5.626062532e-33,
-0.0123962797,
-0.0308983102,
0.0409631394,
-0.022246724,
0.002931908,
-0.0620609447,
-0.0138945486,
0.0024653235,
-0.0253688879,
0.0365138799,
-0.0074207112,
0.01508376,
0.0111272791,
-0.0060373535,
0.0357797965,
-0.0129305813,
0.0053359624,
-0.0436300933,
-0.0529456548,
-0.0002621361,
0.0152431959,
-0.0075572194,
-0.0098267812,
-0.0673172846,
0.0287595447,
-0.0099096289,
-0.0448114909,
0.0229875613,
0.01105168,
0.0337612964,
0.0160654541,
-0.0123583693,
-0.0063321823,
-0.0197674129,
-0.0104102651,
0.0374232233,
-0.0566326194,
-0.0489018001,
-0.0251458548,
0.0025415129,
-0.0971684679,
-0.0052546537,
-0.006133263,
-0.0077073625,
-0.040067926,
0.0368166454,
0.0370738283,
0.0096016834,
-0.0029044102,
0.0419642255,
-0.0166768692,
-0.0142131029,
-0.0532919429,
-0.0431899689,
0.0161230862,
0.030086292,
-0.0222057998,
-0.0259162672,
-0.0561446548,
0.0234880913,
-0.0287563968,
-0.0372919552,
0.0438426733,
0.0400531217,
0.0377385654,
0.0373520516,
0.0221945513,
0.0043433579,
0.0121840136,
-0.0118849864,
0.0152843706,
0.0509083197,
-0.0130198747,
0.0331793502,
-0.0319060981,
-0.0078037544,
-0.0177378859,
0.049842529,
0.0046742968,
0.0607574284,
-0.0269908104,
0.0169568956,
-0.0730467066,
-0.0243487637,
-0.0079291565,
0.0001901838,
-0.0067848628,
-0.0319059491,
0.0399845093,
0.0411526449,
0.0325934552,
-0.0293361638,
0.0164391678,
-0.0280732177,
-0.0060561039,
0.036902301,
-0.0328993499,
0.0074981363,
0.0059555625,
-0.0240738764,
-0.0930117145,
-0.0452968813,
0.0086626476,
-0.008593888,
0.0251889639,
0.035173662,
0.0317597613,
0.0290998071,
-0.0251425374,
-0.0197869707,
-0.0235612597,
0.0267234538,
0.0463936999,
-0.037231721,
0.0612084679,
-0.0053087729,
-0.018075984,
0.0626501366,
-0.0073269643,
-0.0820557699,
-0.008185681,
0.0094839707,
0.0006615333,
-0.0213495698,
-0.0384575129,
0.0155454818,
-0.0458452664,
0.007775621,
-0.0131951831,
-0.0379301198,
-0.0232919883,
0.0052629556,
2.625e-7,
-0.03506485,
0.0203540716,
0.0276982952,
0.0587331541,
0.0052497005,
0.0683661327,
-0.0374887623,
0.0508356169,
-0.0098150736,
0.0292940922,
0.0702812672,
0.0509592108,
0.019183781,
-0.0262304638,
-0.0408938564,
0.0011271808,
-0.0437941402,
-0.0283348206,
-0.0391933769,
-0.0361639298,
0.0459793732,
0.0413276404,
0.015186592,
0.0115170991,
0.043524202,
-0.0332250148,
0.0585972853,
-0.0484381728,
0.0173302069,
0.0124631887,
-0.019998163,
0.0225303173,
-0.0215177629,
0.0110662514,
-0.0038424716,
0.0188154355,
-0.0134067237,
0.0770629272,
-0.0456950516,
-0.0129942065,
-0.0342681482,
-0.0018088806,
0.0253613219,
-0.0100714983,
0.0432646163,
-0.0602597371,
0.0071665496,
0.0234668273,
0.0109797781,
-0.0160324834,
-0.0198954605,
-0.0060667293,
-0.0140313897,
0.0015484662,
0.0202470999,
0.0260634143,
0.0075052716,
-0.0308190342,
0.020394858,
0.0444004275,
-0.0303788409,
-0.0243551824,
-0.0004940179,
0.0409076922,
-0.0008955115,
-0.0254166834,
0.0099776452,
1.613289773e-34,
-0.0077915997,
-0.0251660496,
0.0044771857,
0.0034273723,
0.0519877709,
0.021548789,
-0.0434850976,
0.0198243465,
0.0964467376,
-0.0204720534,
-0.0327827856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06248v1 | LasUIE: Unifying Information Extraction with Latent Adaptive Structure-aware Generative Language Model | 2023-04-13T04:01:14 | 2023-04-13T04:01:14 | Hao Fei, Shengqiong Wu, Jingye Li, Bobo Li, Fei Li, Libo Qin, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Universally modeling all typical information extraction tasks (UIE) with one
generative language model (GLM) has revealed great potential by the latest
study, where various IE predictions are unified into a linearized hierarchical
expression under a GLM. Syntactic structure information, a type of effective
feature which has been extensively utilized in IE community, should also be
beneficial to UIE. In this work, we propose a novel structure-aware GLM, fully
unleashing the power of syntactic knowledge for UIE. A heterogeneous structure
inductor is explored to unsupervisedly induce rich heterogeneous structural
representations by post-training an existing GLM. In particular, a structural
broadcaster is devised to compact various latent trees into explicit high-order
forests, helping to guide a better generation during decoding. We finally
introduce a task-oriented structure fine-tuning mechanism, further adjusting
the learned structures to most coincide with the end-task's need. Over 12 IE
benchmarks across 7 tasks our system shows significant improvements over the
baseline UIE system. Further in-depth analyses show that our GLM learns rich
task-adaptive structural bias that greatly resolves the UIE crux, the
long-range dependence issue and boundary identifying. Source codes are open at
https://github.com/ChocoWu/LasUIE. | [
0.0323612764,
0.0632407144,
0.0307534989,
0.0374328792,
-0.0133917127,
0.0420515947,
-0.0331689268,
-0.0145382108,
0.0013972368,
-0.0347599648,
-0.0608136766,
-0.0320057198,
-0.0285042208,
0.0330809318,
0.0320032723,
-0.0100981062,
0.0227808859,
-0.0322610289,
0.0643331856,
0.0101819057,
0.0032811144,
0.0506863333,
0.0008492668,
0.0057156514,
-0.0068396567,
-0.0302737132,
0.0083579728,
0.0234680735,
0.0089005688,
-0.0045002527,
0.037156269,
0.0235271603,
0.0160573274,
0.022842152,
0.0000021929,
-0.0072070877,
-0.0368640311,
0.0036440881,
-0.0531837232,
-0.0377801545,
0.0330630019,
-0.0497003384,
-0.0328955725,
-0.0188587494,
-0.0243427474,
-0.0563873276,
0.0430425294,
0.0389315747,
-0.0056062024,
0.0871130154,
-0.0263135117,
-0.0520031489,
0.0470219515,
-0.0361840017,
0.0596593469,
-0.0436846986,
0.0296002887,
0.0112408474,
-0.0341018587,
0.0318684876,
-0.0148909166,
0.0207196251,
0.0166477934,
-0.0158975888,
0.0237878542,
0.054686401,
0.0114875343,
-0.0326070935,
-0.0326410308,
0.0925858915,
-0.0173412953,
-0.031436801,
-0.0128750503,
-0.0186327267,
-0.0212762468,
-0.0092501109,
-0.0468421094,
0.0334066786,
-0.0443825647,
0.0249561965,
0.07307221,
0.0133410729,
0.0383017808,
-0.0115010934,
0.008878042,
0.0318752155,
0.0307361279,
-0.0375470258,
0.0125793014,
0.0284428652,
0.0037985037,
-0.0121102305,
-0.0276567154,
-0.0267247409,
-0.0094728814,
0.0014423106,
-0.0055299834,
-0.0582051575,
-0.0232420638,
-0.0475854203,
0.0104002357,
0.0220328756,
-0.0179843865,
0.0684545189,
-0.023410093,
0.0476831011,
-0.0425848216,
-0.0094679277,
-0.0314569362,
-0.0336975232,
-0.0437809639,
-0.0074709849,
-0.0128838038,
0.0290214159,
-0.0495511144,
-0.0258612931,
0.0033016184,
0.0221089125,
-0.0041826949,
-0.0130822035,
0.0553723276,
0.0248446874,
-0.0649805591,
-0.0202341806,
0.0404772796,
0.0244357437,
-0.0334675722,
0.0009540006,
0.0098956507,
-0.0179523639,
-0.0322561115,
0.0463839807,
0.038073916,
-0.0300670583,
0.003195276,
0.049315542,
-0.0450961292,
-0.0188673008,
-0.0498844683,
-0.0140177365,
-0.0011140346,
-0.0495477244,
0.0457834303,
-0.0449242219,
0.0681261942,
-0.0085795475,
-0.0122086583,
-0.0615442395,
0.0015333327,
-0.0093717016,
-0.046148207,
0.0735411942,
-0.0181644317,
-0.0308462568,
0.0070343981,
-0.0156455208,
0.0264618061,
0.0761126056,
0.0329214297,
0.0495617278,
0.0247400422,
0.0134431357,
-0.0111515047,
0.0400157273,
-0.0265068766,
-0.0203734171,
0.0104596158,
-0.0006731864,
-0.0188534409,
-0.0283219926,
0.0648006871,
0.0318674855,
-0.0323020257,
0.0240446758,
0.0563242473,
-0.01250243,
0.0401087403,
0.0195106547,
0.0529484861,
0.0410155021,
-0.0291644055,
-0.0039142217,
-0.0418166146,
0.0097715547,
-0.0314277634,
0.0531156659,
0.0085411323,
0.0420166105,
-0.0078423051,
0.0001004205,
0.0058723767,
-0.0380690023,
0.012330424,
0.0088831931,
0.078208603,
0.0381908268,
-0.0647827387,
0.024337627,
0.0460109524,
-0.0405742899,
0.0031709522,
0.0084082987,
0.0360220112,
0.0280518029,
0.0144042373,
-0.009517666,
-0.0210649651,
-0.0073689255,
-0.0036924905,
0.0273331776,
-0.0277000591,
-0.0510135777,
0.0505238958,
-0.0637345463,
-0.0776147917,
0.0184938852,
0.019840138,
0.0106475316,
0.0212331228,
-0.0379304551,
0.0184633322,
-0.0619755276,
0.0096436618,
0.0302447267,
-0.0365315191,
-0.0593508258,
0.0169284586,
-0.0062163663,
0.0058907364,
0.0223875884,
-0.0303808916,
-0.0065452154,
0.045656018,
-0.0496419184,
-0.0271877907,
-0.0146060111,
-0.0787615329,
-0.0466974005,
-0.0104480889,
0.0085875578,
0.0142056625,
-0.0014454897,
-0.0388442948,
-0.0422099903,
-0.0086170472,
0.0131836878,
0.0247332063,
-0.0423855484,
-0.0020247763,
0.0353495106,
0.0067821816,
-0.0563728213,
0.0816320255,
0.0105775986,
-0.0399007462,
-0.0011833021,
-0.0001099433,
-0.0216176789,
-0.0071923938,
0.0179913808,
0.0332546458,
0.0152740842,
-0.0164869111,
0.043714568,
0.0194026791,
-0.0272519588,
-0.0289074611,
-0.0797680691,
0.0041843588,
-0.0644364879,
0.050397981,
0.0549864918,
0.0349332541,
-0.0059952843,
-0.0269368831,
-0.0215213057,
-0.0031381028,
-0.0278492402,
-0.0226643756,
0.0068945424,
0.0060496386,
0.001516355,
-0.0347659066,
-0.0267320201,
-0.0190108139,
0.0559995733,
0.0225992128,
-0.0836571306,
-0.0360000134,
-0.022601191,
0.0308919586,
0.0270176232,
-0.0258064289,
-0.0005338741,
-0.0337418951,
-0.0386614762,
0.0547804721,
0.0583426617,
-0.0051851026,
0.0052644596,
0.0000987958,
-0.0052993237,
-0.0473520607,
0.0192207973,
-0.0266970024,
0.0339565352,
-0.060010124,
0.0050917645,
0.0378516912,
0.0884753317,
0.0216406919,
0.0239872374,
-0.0519778319,
0.0000165613,
-0.0022426557,
-0.0398901775,
-0.0125086885,
-0.0078414716,
0.0014465154,
-0.0156183811,
-0.0416634642,
-0.0443963967,
0.0693145171,
-0.0172906723,
-0.038710773,
-0.0163444467,
0.0036365078,
-0.0580856763,
0.0821842402,
0.0180935822,
0.0063881199,
0.0729266927,
-0.0514068156,
-0.0332910344,
0.0482022166,
0.0122721298,
0.0103835762,
0.0227464642,
-0.0511678793,
0.0194728803,
-0.0185191333,
-0.0500848554,
-0.0253997538,
-0.0344327576,
0.0202737749,
0.0231472403,
0.0456802808,
-0.0117357746,
-0.0019139076,
-0.02153139,
0.0185213257,
0.0308664124,
-0.0109340958,
-0.0073440424,
-0.0268162452,
0.0784188583,
0.0479110777,
-0.0027135289,
-0.0161515661,
-0.0237250365,
-0.0046654707,
0.067750819,
-0.0094189867,
0.0095505035,
-0.0000082334,
0.0310965218,
0.0388086922,
-0.0157748424,
-0.025913123,
-0.0001146406,
0.0411010161,
-0.0445594154,
0.0046543721,
0.1100307778,
0.0196422637,
-0.055472482,
-0.0150756184,
0.0116050048,
0.0669644326,
0.0088829938,
0.0070187878,
-0.1005993485,
-0.0399686657,
-0.001888536,
0.0035832289,
0.0281702336,
-0.0251112543,
0.0073811109,
-0.0626663938,
0.022567872,
0.0190124847,
0.0162557922,
-0.0296081826,
0.0017254046,
-0.0191710889,
-0.0414929986,
-0.0045289802,
0.032749407,
-0.042635031,
0.0223857537,
0.0353074297,
-0.0485448465,
-0.0493991524,
-0.0034430749,
-0.0250882804,
0.0182151552,
0.0960883051,
0.0065208892,
0.0069097686,
0.0099423854,
0.0392258614,
-0.0024490724,
-0.0193382502,
-0.0007335289,
0.0402439386,
-0.0267227814,
0.0080964314,
-0.0062004896,
0.0398872569,
-0.0649585128,
0.004383259,
0.0107791228,
0.0572325215,
-0.0010872153,
-0.0185349789,
0.0313682221,
-0.0601496026,
0.018483175,
0.065328151,
0.0126519101,
-0.0153010115,
-0.0571506582,
-0.0437532179,
0.0092239184,
-0.0390429609,
-0.0126539432,
0.042612277,
0.0130808149,
-0.0292335767,
-0.076964967,
-0.0762364417,
0.0407584049,
-0.0176803023,
-0.0145997144,
0.0156377312,
-0.0303424075,
-0.0301886238,
-0.0445570983,
-0.0044442215,
-0.0244609099,
-0.0319695026,
-0.0431717634,
-0.019756062,
0.0280281976,
-0.0323932916,
-0.0192762986,
0.0322982669,
-0.056871593,
-0.0514591821,
0.0110993767,
0.0223612785,
0.0037625795,
0.0703902245,
-0.0138465343,
-0.0209671371,
0.0562692136,
-0.0041887057,
-0.0483823195,
0.0221723709,
0.039622061,
-0.0394480489,
-0.0031919789,
0.0497505292,
-0.0633869916,
0.0535634235,
0.0062118913,
0.0648137182,
-0.0056515825,
-0.0061929915,
0.040729396,
0.0099393316,
0.0472948924,
-0.0284462459,
0.0067741466,
-0.0602529086,
0.0194598772,
-0.02686969,
-0.0130354064,
-0.068729721,
0.0168447029,
0.0365270376,
-0.0145748407,
-0.0039284984,
0.0716917515,
0.0286990181,
0.0582475439,
-0.096502848,
-0.0034086565,
-0.0146357091,
0.0105728004,
0.0142463455,
-0.0080082025,
-0.0122144548,
0.033367075,
-0.0014196362,
0.0166144259,
-0.041867055,
0.036525581,
0.0035011463,
-0.0122469151,
-0.02593535,
0.0246989448,
-0.0355023444,
0.0075833905,
-0.0619275644,
-0.0156901162,
0.0634108633,
0.0051190429,
0.0798862725,
-0.0107613886,
-0.0051363404,
-0.0251294393,
0.0417775102,
0.0164759401,
-0.0373532251,
0.0380454734,
0.0167172402,
-0.0463919751,
-0.0184770674,
0.0920567065,
0.0564139634,
0.0208434686,
-0.0129667418,
0.0206794795,
-0.0551997423,
-0.0301717203,
0.0002901421,
0.0134687042,
-0.0374555066,
0.0005880894,
-0.0078800088,
-0.0156235211,
0.0172613468,
-0.0064364397,
-0.0026986063,
-0.0108664706,
0.0527507998,
0.0623697974,
-0.032707151,
-0.0736001432,
-0.0439516306,
-0.0455592237,
0.0106444582,
0.0093430597,
-0.0518740639,
-7.103942887e-33,
-0.0323109813,
0.0185567997,
0.0171154905,
0.0046274313,
-0.0140205454,
0.0327231176,
-0.0361622386,
-0.0112041924,
-0.007276909,
0.0300885513,
0.0076043252,
-0.0060420861,
0.0254302286,
0.0703132674,
0.0188995451,
0.0035137739,
0.048036553,
-0.0032888744,
0.0000138022,
0.0447164215,
0.0168213192,
0.0612682104,
0.0884105861,
-0.0835433826,
0.0442721844,
-0.0006180929,
0.0125134438,
-0.0102207018,
0.0654528514,
0.0443479754,
-0.0124274716,
0.0314966291,
0.0364312604,
-0.0305820759,
-0.0160838794,
0.0174306035,
-0.1491529197,
0.021337213,
-0.00791917,
-0.030004533,
-0.0440883152,
-0.038115263,
0.0108507192,
-0.024660483,
0.0383135416,
-0.055081673,
0.0384798869,
-0.0165739376,
-0.0106343385,
-0.0624704845,
-0.0975990891,
0.0415398031,
0.0247658882,
0.0367931388,
0.0283015016,
0.0439792275,
0.015528284,
0.03154305,
-0.0461831056,
-0.0169550888,
-0.0375401042,
0.0459511131,
0.0401344933,
0.0458833985,
-0.0004560704,
0.0404556505,
0.0167456474,
-0.0106020365,
-0.0583209842,
-0.0316016153,
-0.015280419,
0.0498848669,
-0.0271315072,
0.0052209939,
0.0102417525,
0.0420030542,
-0.0897862986,
0.0210032575,
0.0361875705,
0.0352446623,
-0.0244207364,
0.0533044338,
-0.0483411923,
-0.0089811822,
-0.0069581252,
0.0230689552,
-0.0038683757,
-0.0204027724,
0.0282078125,
0.0183788221,
-0.0034015633,
0.0202153958,
0.0327885188,
-0.0223816279,
0.0108984159,
0.0273043867,
-0.0036777339,
0.02144612,
-0.0016265161,
0.013834592,
-0.0688822344,
-0.0140164131,
0.0197523553,
-0.0130895749,
-0.001079857,
0.0021907575,
0.0354902931,
0.0361308977,
-0.0427848324,
-0.0109435013,
-0.0465568863,
-0.0087464759,
0.0176617969,
0.0764966011,
0.0274972077,
0.0301833227,
-0.0273034275,
0.0405578874,
0.0282406528,
0.0385772698,
-0.0022608063,
-0.0006189666,
0.0015684273,
0.0363345407,
-0.000941398,
0.0023547101,
-0.0293940362,
-0.0224936772,
0.0319899954,
-0.0383228883,
0.0090343785,
0.0493753105,
2.836e-7,
0.0534488484,
0.0134860724,
0.0690155998,
0.0135322111,
0.0039223894,
0.0230193716,
0.0255964268,
0.0379624404,
-0.027545793,
-0.0202859435,
-0.0008586813,
0.0050138831,
0.0364342928,
-0.0016621565,
-0.1067255363,
0.003430906,
-0.035355635,
-0.0332448781,
-0.0407173261,
-0.0192361418,
0.0208944436,
0.0904170051,
-0.038135495,
0.0068951487,
0.0057692043,
-0.0456457287,
0.0857504606,
-0.0105033247,
-0.0161316209,
0.038106028,
-0.0069526047,
-0.0285256729,
-0.0289089195,
0.0285918657,
-0.032685902,
0.0055565122,
0.0093157152,
0.0681621954,
-0.018334873,
-0.0348601043,
0.0137893567,
-0.0231943727,
0.0082150493,
-0.0023322161,
0.075607039,
-0.0451525189,
-0.0214627832,
0.0054617063,
-0.0308310837,
0.0550287701,
-0.0523900613,
-0.0033118555,
-0.0168943293,
0.0321028158,
0.0508114807,
-0.0214651488,
-0.0373385362,
-0.0735035017,
-0.0215218328,
0.0140503692,
-0.0341612771,
-0.0021025939,
-0.0102366563,
-0.01271223,
0.0047839028,
-0.0440656729,
-0.0013241835,
3.00745018e-34,
0.0058003017,
0.0044575222,
-0.0208341647,
0.0708333775,
0.0276366062,
-0.0325661823,
-0.0468303896,
0.0094781518,
-0.015351506,
-0.0757314563,
-0.0079469122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06203v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06203v2 | LeafAI: query generator for clinical cohort discovery rivaling a human programmer | 2023-04-13T00:34:32 | 2023-08-14T18:45:55 | Nicholas J Dobbins, Bin Han, Weipeng Zhou, Kristine Lan, H. Nina Kim, Robert Harrington, Ozlem Uzuner, Meliha Yetisgen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: Identifying study-eligible patients within clinical databases is a
critical step in clinical research. However, accurate query design typically
requires extensive technical and biomedical expertise. We sought to create a
system capable of generating data model-agnostic queries while also providing
novel logical reasoning capabilities for complex clinical trial eligibility
criteria.
Materials and Methods: The task of query creation from eligibility criteria
requires solving several text-processing problems, including named entity
recognition and relation extraction, sequence-to-sequence transformation,
normalization, and reasoning. We incorporated hybrid deep learning and
rule-based modules for these, as well as a knowledge base of the Unified
Medical Language System (UMLS) and linked ontologies. To enable data-model
agnostic query creation, we introduce a novel method for tagging database
schema elements using UMLS concepts. To evaluate our system, called LeafAI, we
compared the capability of LeafAI to a human database programmer to identify
patients who had been enrolled in 8 clinical trials conducted at our
institution. We measured performance by the number of actual enrolled patients
matched by generated queries.
Results: LeafAI matched a mean 43% of enrolled patients with 27,225 eligible
across 8 clinical trials, compared to 27% matched and 14,587 eligible in
queries by a human database programmer. The human programmer spent 26 total
hours crafting queries compared to several minutes by LeafAI.
Conclusions: Our work contributes a state-of-the-art data model-agnostic
query generation system capable of conditional reasoning using a knowledge
base. We demonstrate that LeafAI can rival an experienced human programmer in
finding patients eligible for clinical trials. | [
0.0177174993,
0.0851769075,
-0.0105706621,
-0.0325255133,
-0.0045363796,
0.0362101234,
0.0008389134,
0.0221284628,
0.0177711993,
0.0211856309,
0.0407420695,
-0.0231589992,
-0.0407560021,
0.0663338229,
-0.038876351,
-0.0265433267,
0.0173032973,
0.0316523463,
0.0244732238,
0.0139982691,
-0.0618939176,
0.0197175443,
-0.0084701581,
0.0380085669,
-0.0010305943,
-0.0074596987,
-0.0004384863,
0.0080064842,
-0.0150364814,
-0.0514789931,
0.0047691106,
0.0351211093,
-0.0090544233,
0.0165636763,
0.0000019791,
-0.0721010193,
-0.0563851595,
0.0262987986,
-0.0620403811,
-0.0519666262,
0.0302363858,
-0.0169928353,
0.0150407981,
0.0028626223,
-0.0366853401,
-0.0199003331,
0.0332481302,
0.0178187825,
0.0121868206,
0.0307794083,
-0.0134277595,
-0.0356944352,
0.0399910398,
-0.001302961,
0.0552050211,
-0.0393584184,
0.0297923274,
0.0055288174,
0.0744283423,
-0.0415707156,
0.0687558725,
0.0419750884,
-0.0004358605,
-0.0132631157,
0.0161866713,
0.0159128103,
-0.0391444154,
-0.0147106219,
-0.0056956406,
0.0511085391,
0.015602625,
-0.0022464967,
0.0396791808,
0.0013492267,
-0.0172646418,
0.0098025706,
0.0081271548,
0.0082090218,
-0.0292568784,
-0.0319808275,
-0.0006249971,
-0.0061999601,
0.0405332446,
-0.0065157292,
-0.0540533997,
0.0458978638,
-0.0002239233,
-0.0048791557,
0.0430454463,
-0.0283283833,
0.0187755059,
-0.0557930879,
0.0556722507,
0.0573344342,
-0.0616710819,
0.0161782168,
-0.0145208482,
-0.0276350453,
0.0738067925,
-0.0462507792,
-0.0185945388,
-0.0154927922,
-0.004663799,
0.0470665991,
-0.006159781,
-0.0234884359,
-0.0230671559,
0.04983918,
-0.0310250632,
-0.0326837562,
-0.0818967298,
-0.0185522754,
-0.0247275848,
0.0470530652,
-0.0085453633,
0.0363223329,
-0.0865656585,
0.0214662738,
0.0064404723,
0.0144334035,
0.038259767,
0.0539286137,
-0.017441472,
0.0069732484,
-0.0585964769,
-0.0220473427,
0.0047009131,
-0.0347405486,
-0.0044475379,
-0.0787317306,
0.0448210947,
0.0003957461,
0.0261502732,
-0.0348262377,
0.0344990529,
0.051711794,
0.057972502,
-0.0127904331,
-0.0630701929,
-0.073198989,
-0.0016369619,
0.0088951364,
0.0387399159,
-0.0465626493,
0.0193734858,
0.0014363567,
-0.0280897822,
-0.0617680587,
0.0003632905,
0.0223377887,
-0.0266039893,
0.0609986968,
-0.080473952,
-0.0130222905,
0.0102916453,
0.0189195871,
0.0108766593,
0.0029736976,
0.0464448631,
-0.0150549291,
0.0019733966,
-0.0045293514,
-0.0011774186,
-0.0134310592,
0.0280337613,
-0.0635735765,
-0.0101719247,
0.0454342104,
-0.027379537,
0.0872572511,
-0.0832806826,
0.0338188671,
0.0290813688,
-0.0178023633,
-0.0036286716,
0.034113951,
0.061680235,
0.0097107133,
0.0182147902,
-0.0421416536,
-0.0228858888,
-0.0558324903,
-0.0009823425,
0.0302798748,
0.010098218,
0.003924367,
-0.0688290671,
0.0057681897,
-0.0228737034,
-0.0524018742,
-0.0239307582,
-0.0153137669,
-0.0287520979,
-0.001312332,
0.0412308127,
-0.0102592641,
-0.0139728161,
0.051310923,
0.0488901287,
-0.03237544,
-0.0228489321,
-0.0455670282,
-0.0435957052,
0.0791033804,
0.0506845005,
-0.0836893693,
-0.0384650864,
-0.0018579916,
-0.008694306,
0.0037896053,
0.0025349013,
-0.0218800232,
0.0078618433,
-0.0219003521,
0.0049225139,
0.0403835364,
0.003295029,
-0.0102521908,
-0.0012775866,
0.0175029263,
-0.0268003475,
-0.0915618166,
-0.0117103914,
0.0403850637,
-0.0653229952,
-0.0053582438,
0.024951309,
0.0191303268,
0.0289994031,
0.0546001121,
-0.0051045511,
0.0476538762,
0.0443231128,
-0.0338893086,
-0.0550406612,
-0.0253699608,
0.0133637423,
-0.0241958536,
0.0131301237,
-0.0321673304,
-0.0340098701,
-0.0491711721,
-0.0367092378,
-0.0117765749,
-0.0071415515,
0.009220412,
0.0025393355,
-0.0057497947,
0.0036066384,
0.0401182771,
-0.0288300738,
-0.0744458809,
0.0462701395,
0.0122293895,
-0.0289932918,
0.0482742339,
-0.1094284207,
0.0337289609,
-0.0430242866,
0.0118665984,
0.0205415934,
-0.0297219027,
0.0031702693,
-0.0258584376,
0.0088205067,
-0.0321808644,
0.0242648963,
-0.0398943648,
0.046624057,
0.0332181118,
0.029337693,
-0.0006492398,
0.0298676342,
0.0031140286,
-0.036618039,
-0.0510515906,
-0.0010609739,
0.0211832486,
-0.0313742869,
0.0609790348,
0.0552529134,
-0.0315939598,
-0.0323994346,
-0.0139485858,
-0.0619390793,
0.0441431664,
0.0208790023,
-0.0371316746,
0.0572261252,
-0.0009738134,
-0.0500839464,
0.0285933688,
0.0183310676,
0.0435373075,
0.0094061345,
-0.0038046662,
-0.0373451784,
0.0596406609,
-0.0176124033,
0.0330594555,
0.0327196866,
-0.0049310694,
0.0051256958,
0.0330712236,
-0.0344655327,
-0.0142342579,
0.031738881,
-0.0363644399,
0.0474554002,
0.0279393848,
-0.006303471,
-0.0203859769,
-0.0400686599,
0.0063779866,
0.0042490116,
0.0151293548,
-0.061211668,
0.0601989254,
0.0222645085,
0.0428300425,
0.0055787461,
-0.0117830243,
0.1011495367,
0.0108549539,
0.0481726974,
-0.0543033406,
-0.0038411696,
-0.0472922213,
0.020768173,
0.0026722292,
0.0228747297,
0.0209407937,
-0.0189712867,
0.0012363532,
-0.0035346847,
-0.0111320382,
-0.0435524732,
0.064647302,
-0.0392472707,
0.0533873849,
0.0022253608,
0.0087441467,
-0.051607769,
0.0516935401,
-0.0082807299,
0.0515872538,
0.0052389316,
0.0293103531,
-0.0471886545,
0.0089457007,
-0.0266142152,
0.0299767144,
0.0412910581,
-0.0197495744,
-0.0120625915,
-0.0347760394,
0.0263137165,
-0.024390161,
-0.004472841,
0.0147614824,
0.0345883705,
0.0215712991,
-0.0217292812,
-0.0013405234,
-0.0166705474,
0.0365165249,
-0.0173715316,
-0.0851920024,
0.0260991827,
0.0575571768,
-0.0374025144,
-0.0838980675,
0.0277563445,
0.0702662095,
0.0470718332,
-0.0117998943,
0.0096173724,
0.0178173855,
-0.0256821476,
-0.0113706281,
0.0399652235,
-0.1158688292,
-0.026875902,
-0.0058399606,
0.0226773527,
-0.0039754258,
-0.0734757856,
0.0132329678,
-0.0005370764,
0.0399064124,
-0.0279333144,
-0.0364366584,
-0.0031224445,
-0.0453254096,
-0.0223075002,
-0.0280036554,
-0.0482678227,
0.0141100409,
0.0063303858,
-0.0265726186,
-0.0047012926,
-0.0122415321,
-0.0782237649,
0.0346472375,
-0.0496061407,
0.0259867832,
0.0597845912,
0.0615652613,
0.0206793547,
-0.0475102812,
-0.0233588833,
0.0323035643,
0.0100440783,
-0.0295393057,
0.0822804719,
0.0035022167,
0.0056839129,
-0.0578812063,
0.0116754575,
-0.0806433186,
-0.0089852586,
-0.0084877256,
0.0971497297,
-0.0465857796,
-0.0080772527,
-0.06786035,
-0.0211154539,
0.0063114306,
0.042463772,
-0.0221607704,
0.0156864468,
-0.0251745991,
0.0076474454,
0.0325756073,
-0.0350470319,
0.0071273739,
0.0597081184,
-0.0747852325,
-0.0252906494,
-0.0332920067,
-0.0295269266,
0.0741575509,
-0.0171278063,
0.0246648174,
0.0217051171,
0.059669476,
-0.0109041706,
-0.0714061037,
0.0321634114,
-0.0142411282,
0.0322123282,
-0.0581531785,
-0.0394167192,
0.0072093457,
-0.0020148437,
-0.0299844891,
-0.0155203436,
0.0222357474,
-0.0044040135,
-0.0204742551,
-0.0054885703,
0.0268601961,
-0.0522290692,
0.0138003435,
0.0061548813,
-0.0231281221,
0.043438632,
-0.0051624756,
-0.0728246272,
-0.0399120748,
-0.0307115167,
-0.0237794127,
0.0173161756,
-0.0196056254,
0.0280905347,
-0.0173257198,
0.0185640343,
-0.0223965906,
-0.0077459663,
0.0724908113,
0.0635005012,
0.0307412222,
0.0132468175,
-0.0617936961,
-0.0366640203,
0.0482761003,
-0.0227102321,
0.0026633153,
-0.036468666,
0.0129876537,
-0.0020641482,
0.0048959292,
0.0141795874,
-0.0363664888,
-0.0402704291,
-0.0192941371,
-0.0323339626,
0.0507484265,
0.0321837813,
0.0352986194,
0.0475360565,
-0.0247468241,
0.0234485101,
0.0243865438,
-0.0067459298,
0.0454955958,
-0.0405026563,
0.0140584381,
0.0095468797,
0.0463976376,
-0.0287717488,
0.0031077422,
-0.0178676862,
-0.0196141712,
0.0173351988,
0.00063934,
0.0342017785,
0.0257729683,
-0.0015707379,
-0.0232809614,
0.0076161083,
-0.0239105299,
0.0199216809,
0.0104705198,
-0.0051538316,
0.019977292,
0.0083067995,
-0.0330187231,
-0.0822056085,
0.0804703012,
0.0229014587,
0.0501056947,
-0.0265022665,
-0.0635887757,
-0.0446405783,
-0.021067882,
0.0647729933,
-0.0167937297,
-0.0632609501,
-0.0129896104,
-0.0473111197,
-0.0249350108,
0.0209651832,
0.0314438567,
-0.0278867055,
0.0201276932,
0.0484931655,
0.0403549038,
0.0363019705,
-0.0581594966,
0.0037849543,
0.0335182473,
-0.0566421412,
-0.0472072512,
0.0185161922,
-5.679884745e-33,
-0.0119296843,
-0.0219561718,
0.0408427678,
-0.0177655965,
0.0284104031,
-0.0184853096,
-0.0493002385,
-0.0243153013,
-0.0022180846,
0.0028981583,
-0.0133652026,
0.0154716754,
0.0184857696,
0.0204243679,
0.0156942438,
-0.0455807894,
0.0260830447,
0.037616387,
0.0157597903,
-0.0064203171,
0.0137305036,
0.0508090667,
0.0045497781,
-0.048378855,
0.0077135568,
0.0563032664,
0.0591866709,
0.0322201438,
-0.0312298741,
0.0697714984,
-0.0048430264,
0.0217831172,
0.0251170285,
-0.0090041086,
0.021480279,
-0.0152337803,
-0.0978806615,
-0.0131936148,
-0.0351726077,
-0.0127292033,
-0.009824831,
-0.0224939268,
0.0641504154,
0.0000094955,
0.0085584102,
-0.0205951426,
0.0366816521,
-0.0372571796,
-0.0125161856,
-0.0782125816,
-0.0144350659,
0.0504831262,
0.0054240213,
0.0327108614,
-0.0328942575,
-0.0281486306,
-0.0214662589,
0.0541892983,
-0.0318919122,
0.022113394,
0.0175675135,
0.0090715066,
0.0157490689,
-0.0229726285,
-0.014845605,
0.0310209747,
0.0265737288,
-0.0105300881,
-0.0113350675,
0.0628792867,
-0.0273290817,
0.0572002158,
0.0240236707,
0.0010412805,
0.0388594903,
-0.0091073234,
-0.1345187426,
0.0534686483,
-0.0608480945,
0.0265985839,
-0.0255572572,
0.0270175654,
-0.0340857171,
-0.0094283521,
-0.0169844385,
0.0271513797,
-0.0497783534,
-0.0391789936,
0.0429669879,
-0.0158005655,
-0.03405945,
0.0345861763,
0.0040806653,
-0.0176043101,
-0.0340802632,
-0.0144523848,
0.0585314184,
-0.0332859941,
-0.0288892165,
0.0262009539,
-0.0275219996,
-0.0102013983,
0.0283066332,
-0.0714132115,
0.046922937,
0.0519938432,
0.0269617606,
-0.0130702574,
-0.0324071199,
0.0061274031,
0.0001423798,
-0.0031716782,
-0.014794223,
0.0278569367,
0.0136323906,
0.0494030453,
0.0359247848,
0.031314265,
0.0194120612,
-0.023104405,
-0.0772450864,
-0.0115559259,
-0.0080150478,
0.0037546132,
-0.0229921099,
0.0048027262,
-0.0439800955,
0.0184570197,
0.0345711783,
-0.0577809438,
0.0015174171,
0.0108697535,
2.946e-7,
0.0894511268,
0.0202276167,
0.0147690093,
0.0168716218,
0.0108633544,
-0.0029667122,
0.0077609825,
-0.0205271468,
0.011312128,
-0.0218987726,
0.0509830341,
-0.0035055496,
0.0001283066,
0.0497191809,
-0.0525694937,
-0.0358255096,
0.0063096308,
-0.0508220643,
-0.047210481,
-0.0061197295,
0.0639523417,
0.0340043828,
-0.0155734625,
-0.0222151335,
0.0363258161,
-0.011669822,
-0.0217507537,
-0.0085063735,
0.0148130776,
0.0631569773,
0.0349359661,
-0.0090168314,
0.0165897813,
0.0888121352,
-0.012334303,
-0.0123705016,
-0.0253959671,
0.0683232918,
-0.0550987162,
0.0385126472,
0.0316825695,
-0.0660036951,
0.0410728417,
-0.0089535173,
0.053719718,
-0.0291119386,
-0.0327921696,
0.0376147963,
0.0116176605,
-0.0221248847,
0.0335446633,
0.0169418138,
0.0015310969,
-0.006571745,
0.0398234092,
0.0178576931,
-0.0077945516,
-0.0265543628,
0.0268867481,
0.0557967201,
-0.0327412598,
0.0074227522,
0.0103349704,
0.0080954311,
0.0103621334,
-0.0338710062,
0.0159039721,
2.850234698e-34,
-0.0002737956,
0.0441211052,
-0.011645725,
-0.0182252936,
0.044401139,
-0.0099003129,
-0.0000033477,
-0.0083389971,
-0.0341353342,
-0.0377265364,
-0.0184382834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06186v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06186v3 | Using Large Language Models for (De-)Formalization and Natural Argumentation Exercises for Beginner's Students | 2023-04-12T23:05:02 | 2024-04-10T14:19:26 | Merlin Carl | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.LO | We describe two systems currently being developed that use large language
models for the automatized correction of (i) exercises in translating back and
forth between natural language and the languages of propositional logic and
first-order predicate logic and (ii) exercises in writing simple arguments in
natural language in non-mathematical scenarios. | [
0.0120619098,
0.0288707055,
-0.0168530941,
0.0285322852,
-0.0598404482,
0.0003379584,
0.0111463992,
-0.0294794757,
0.0050014341,
-0.0999970064,
0.0449199006,
-0.0019071987,
-0.0020590178,
-0.0145958047,
0.0256109666,
-0.1284370571,
0.0276222769,
-0.0318202041,
0.0664102435,
-0.0062225196,
-0.0013956424,
-0.0018320751,
-0.0257114768,
0.0114221424,
0.0204916596,
-0.0850199535,
-0.0451238155,
-0.0092419498,
-0.0164490063,
-0.010417833,
-0.0206405595,
0.0312553644,
-0.0048108902,
0.0200285688,
0.00000182,
-0.0800437406,
0.0213816278,
0.031017581,
-0.0466591381,
0.071097523,
0.0214695185,
0.0411111526,
-0.0326538235,
0.0164392348,
-0.0287569389,
-0.0351520702,
0.0601546429,
0.048821792,
0.0772180408,
0.073845394,
0.0137525601,
-0.0701730251,
0.0155632161,
0.013762881,
-0.0234044325,
0.0195264835,
0.043273624,
0.0866306052,
0.0624650754,
0.0038443515,
-0.0016137288,
0.0125623066,
0.0263243429,
-0.0626781657,
-0.0153079825,
-0.0035920823,
-0.0068494943,
0.0271115843,
-0.0120448265,
0.0223387517,
0.0191009082,
-0.046775192,
-0.0167094711,
0.0073204916,
0.0165384989,
0.0136086037,
-0.0547150001,
0.0772555023,
-0.0034984157,
0.0076630865,
0.0665725842,
-0.0636203364,
0.0006021427,
0.030556526,
-0.0244176295,
0.0443060137,
0.0281017981,
-0.0283961389,
0.0014334775,
-0.0103578279,
-0.0158430394,
-0.0870843455,
0.0345506482,
0.0773936734,
-0.0042775553,
0.0121620996,
-0.0350378752,
-0.0086316345,
-0.0099551082,
-0.0867218152,
0.0418843217,
0.0282959007,
0.0284842737,
0.036264699,
-0.0023018788,
0.0347429924,
0.0035212494,
-0.0025232828,
-0.0188976247,
0.0140942493,
-0.0516076908,
-0.0201026537,
-0.0850390047,
0.0453001298,
-0.0215654075,
0.0288149174,
-0.0238103122,
-0.01487746,
-0.0503747463,
0.0273394231,
-0.0169696249,
-0.0122898994,
-0.0108223697,
-0.0231201816,
-0.0517971739,
0.0277413409,
-0.0110988095,
0.0039253468,
-0.0113543347,
-0.036750406,
0.0197153445,
0.0236646291,
0.0013658861,
-0.0018426875,
-0.0194325615,
0.0540569946,
-0.0165625364,
0.0501991995,
-0.0476203039,
-0.0342691429,
0.0046124542,
-0.047317151,
-0.0267097224,
-0.1088914871,
-0.0442558043,
0.0035833889,
0.0164366849,
-0.0303953253,
0.0153317982,
0.0204422139,
0.0030851709,
0.0442875773,
-0.0264907498,
-0.0129041225,
0.0240040999,
-0.013830916,
0.0166158415,
0.0256894212,
0.0220363066,
-0.0328758247,
0.017593855,
-0.0480508283,
0.0042793755,
0.023778569,
-0.0403424129,
-0.0029841017,
-0.0334310979,
0.0079938937,
-0.0123265795,
0.0283461232,
-0.024558099,
0.0874885619,
-0.0136838732,
0.0512988865,
0.016839955,
0.048156146,
0.03021794,
0.0202803239,
0.0543507561,
0.0154278278,
0.0688515007,
0.0410737433,
-0.0270642415,
0.0013491416,
-0.0487143807,
-0.0027133469,
-0.0424144566,
0.0255547501,
-0.0021594027,
-0.0671314895,
0.0083799064,
-0.0000544626,
0.0133303674,
-0.0133311953,
0.0523721203,
0.0396293066,
0.0328959189,
0.0210574418,
0.0028000132,
-0.0320481621,
0.0123606753,
-0.0120135974,
0.0259148665,
0.0366251431,
0.029666245,
-0.0393187627,
0.006029842,
-0.0378044136,
0.0377513468,
0.0591476858,
0.0753071383,
-0.0389393121,
-0.0393352471,
-0.0149368085,
0.0204929076,
0.0013034886,
0.0328114741,
-0.0241041202,
-0.0022934636,
0.0127623882,
0.0333523341,
-0.0066179382,
-0.0555163175,
0.0228555594,
-0.008888769,
-0.0629225597,
-0.0176346749,
0.0095598046,
0.0176685974,
0.0383299105,
-0.0135426996,
0.0363509655,
0.0037974275,
-0.0132963946,
-0.0137094352,
-0.0198291596,
-0.0203053113,
0.023978468,
0.0866334885,
-0.0525613762,
-0.01660336,
0.0021871254,
-0.0276397821,
-0.033389736,
0.0331471376,
-0.0264747124,
0.0373552665,
0.0037070569,
0.0374812298,
0.0005742105,
-0.0457241982,
-0.018692527,
0.0265521966,
0.0959261209,
0.0275357962,
-0.0117995003,
-0.0067117726,
0.0181799494,
-0.0498787984,
-0.0096132709,
0.0335454419,
-0.0051226653,
0.0273824967,
0.0340572186,
-0.0051989332,
-0.0212717559,
0.0193181969,
-0.0400801525,
-0.0078604259,
-0.0012502705,
0.0241424125,
0.0254239365,
-0.0278588068,
0.0023517783,
0.0084513929,
-0.0253807418,
-0.025237821,
0.0064764326,
-0.0160199609,
0.0147961741,
-0.0121128829,
-0.0315420069,
-0.015400134,
-0.0223947205,
-0.0736475587,
0.039249327,
0.0306933038,
-0.0095092533,
-0.07459528,
0.0494359881,
-0.008567417,
0.0207118858,
0.0336916894,
-0.024805231,
0.0326293036,
-0.0087718368,
0.0334554017,
0.0662635267,
0.0003045321,
0.03384725,
0.073953025,
-0.038708888,
-0.038115792,
-0.0131589416,
0.0297976155,
0.0107539129,
-0.0607400537,
-0.0538184419,
-0.0247662701,
0.0313654356,
0.0068202801,
-0.0039640772,
-0.0089024482,
0.0652291775,
-0.0656950101,
0.0438209549,
-0.0125113036,
-0.051573649,
-0.0009228366,
0.0199112613,
0.0123453932,
0.0129163601,
0.073547475,
-0.0109431874,
0.0008410096,
-0.0605704859,
-0.0175893307,
-0.0202187058,
0.0542698614,
-0.0131682772,
0.0292193461,
0.0247274172,
-0.0091568921,
-0.0042603384,
-0.0548919626,
0.0737441555,
-0.01496688,
0.0513844155,
-0.0885913894,
-0.0083362684,
-0.0086018844,
-0.0192907527,
-0.0366549008,
0.0233417172,
-0.0616228767,
0.026794672,
-0.0379458666,
0.0003324851,
-0.0295665711,
0.0074914373,
0.0229506977,
-0.0207668375,
-0.017745804,
-0.0164107066,
-0.0121431034,
0.0189816412,
-0.0196497235,
-0.0080514168,
-0.0144313788,
-0.0094907293,
0.0592883304,
0.0518002808,
0.0065033878,
0.0133212861,
-0.0729908943,
-0.0119058313,
0.0058179921,
-0.0758003145,
-0.0168488882,
0.033906322,
0.0147149246,
-0.066412732,
-0.0033009513,
0.0998869464,
0.0143900998,
0.0147066228,
0.0145863295,
-0.071167551,
-0.0209319405,
0.0089436145,
0.0374616235,
-0.0871271864,
0.009403822,
0.0039594173,
-0.0002640299,
-0.0315871425,
-0.018127514,
0.0100153396,
-0.1175868288,
0.0665905029,
0.0718375966,
-0.0032914884,
-0.013049148,
-0.0315494351,
0.0017402775,
0.0165959559,
-0.0181356091,
0.0330821127,
-0.037701264,
-0.0096671544,
0.0241609979,
-0.0314442553,
-0.0158648174,
-0.0106121907,
-0.0384723581,
0.0318115503,
-0.0112347174,
0.0379661992,
-0.0379345417,
-0.0059469314,
0.0442761295,
0.0219278,
-0.0132180182,
-0.0079975622,
-0.039617952,
0.0360933952,
-0.0140229557,
-0.0642742291,
0.0512560643,
0.0120849339,
-0.0593059175,
0.0557560846,
0.0923496857,
-0.0357606001,
-0.032912951,
-0.0134021994,
0.0007235287,
-0.0020219306,
0.0402043276,
0.0387352034,
-0.0040061502,
-0.0382095203,
-0.0965784416,
-0.047312513,
-0.0062133116,
-0.035900116,
0.0024355834,
-0.022996068,
-0.0095873801,
-0.0189196207,
-0.0182487499,
0.0696094632,
0.0443794355,
0.0426041968,
0.0125913862,
0.081253849,
-0.0022904549,
-0.0281094275,
0.0214262474,
-0.0437978394,
0.0241702739,
-0.0248790458,
-0.0031186959,
-0.0220540036,
0.0254985131,
-0.0210830253,
0.0126813632,
0.0271693412,
-0.0729753077,
0.0215835068,
0.0390480086,
0.0293542668,
0.0020845076,
0.0021104754,
-0.0455973931,
-0.0180415474,
0.0035176263,
0.016868785,
0.0028873575,
0.0186624099,
-0.0213972162,
0.0088609243,
-0.0050891764,
0.0109195188,
0.0019206946,
-0.0029930242,
0.0573098585,
-0.0210006405,
-0.0348750763,
0.0508286059,
0.0962915421,
0.0304021575,
0.0348460004,
-0.0179486759,
0.0015842825,
0.0113409944,
-0.0833628327,
-0.0476246104,
-0.0011416479,
0.026404243,
0.0226351041,
0.0113512836,
0.0049840296,
-0.018130267,
-0.0430027544,
0.021778712,
0.053790275,
0.0556195155,
0.0092474278,
0.0290565044,
0.0515377186,
-0.03314263,
-0.0111007486,
-0.0030262317,
0.0054461588,
0.0532941744,
-0.0213194378,
0.0326382183,
0.0327516869,
0.0292587746,
-0.0424240567,
-0.0481111072,
0.0077460734,
-0.0854850635,
0.0068162456,
0.0134722535,
0.0388907567,
-0.0139079047,
0.0298248548,
-0.0666383579,
-0.0083476165,
-0.0049721277,
0.0400208496,
0.0163955446,
-0.0393083394,
0.0309751015,
0.0275750086,
-0.0009685194,
-0.023737343,
0.0043844115,
-0.031086091,
0.0097253975,
0.0437070467,
-0.0298530627,
-0.0196671933,
-0.0439291708,
-0.0307876281,
-0.0171680786,
-0.0114585683,
-0.036914479,
-0.054961171,
-0.0679049194,
-0.0317659974,
0.0451244451,
0.0010379698,
-0.0226946753,
0.0255428832,
0.060240116,
0.0160689875,
-0.0285447892,
-0.0250575244,
0.0734882057,
0.0017169879,
-0.0330558196,
-0.0131307179,
-5.446728012e-33,
-0.0424256735,
-0.0345770977,
0.0355010033,
0.0121665457,
0.0047828536,
-0.0524169505,
-0.0197086092,
0.0372021534,
0.0178298615,
0.0665680096,
-0.0030581045,
0.00405405,
0.0215781946,
-0.007684798,
-0.0060846191,
0.0336955227,
0.0532185175,
0.018394541,
-0.0179145876,
-0.0183094777,
0.0100135021,
-0.0357523002,
0.060740754,
-0.0701516047,
0.0427319333,
0.0093443245,
-0.0040708003,
0.0043944586,
-0.0394779444,
0.0216333158,
0.0177151095,
0.0499854982,
-0.0151125034,
-0.0034298187,
-0.0056130239,
0.0422833972,
-0.0657950416,
-0.0257365853,
0.0665530935,
0.0105159581,
-0.0128450636,
-0.0664023384,
0.0251609478,
0.002168302,
-0.0418727174,
0.0232683904,
0.0340115689,
-0.0336460806,
0.0087075345,
0.0360110961,
-0.0859542415,
0.0141404364,
-0.0434482992,
0.0144368717,
-0.03660376,
-0.002242794,
-0.0408660918,
-0.0385531038,
-0.007761098,
0.022148449,
0.074317053,
0.0220305379,
0.0315502398,
-0.0422417447,
0.0027188668,
0.0189443026,
0.0061921403,
0.0105385147,
-0.0211490057,
0.0204224102,
0.0008122378,
0.0265762992,
0.0382919274,
0.0356688797,
0.0319479741,
0.0179208592,
-0.0904416144,
0.0004350993,
0.0034653915,
0.0852884203,
-0.0038462516,
-0.0167513266,
-0.0219586175,
-0.0406210758,
-0.0602223612,
-0.0114812981,
-0.0019626385,
-0.0233131032,
-0.0123859709,
-0.0565746054,
-0.0351328664,
-0.0117431404,
-0.0127554024,
-0.0389829017,
-0.0566145852,
-0.0011089918,
0.0114516122,
0.0195475444,
-0.034407299,
0.0333467126,
-0.0175832268,
-0.0181921832,
-0.0069515244,
-0.025093358,
0.0383419581,
0.0163021777,
-0.0229322575,
0.0266075227,
-0.0402719267,
0.0026954554,
-0.02787273,
-0.0470904596,
0.0174994059,
0.0204133056,
0.0289815646,
0.0472837277,
0.0256374776,
0.0397822037,
-0.0119544631,
-0.0785010979,
-0.0197259784,
0.0071323765,
0.0087348577,
-0.0170619208,
-0.004290387,
-0.0219523013,
-0.0304847118,
0.0307584107,
0.0693435371,
-0.0469005853,
0.0136288796,
0.0105694393,
2.515e-7,
0.0374172293,
0.0833431333,
0.0266593564,
0.0306886397,
0.0024235193,
0.0088713951,
-0.0218473375,
-0.0144624272,
0.0403103456,
0.0187053569,
-0.0176725108,
0.0279676039,
0.0230709501,
0.0389753133,
-0.0642055422,
-0.0266742036,
-0.0228574313,
-0.0354684368,
-0.062791802,
0.0163399633,
0.0608947314,
0.023326546,
0.0422358513,
0.0171920881,
-0.0352462977,
-0.0733636618,
0.0210937299,
0.0050364211,
0.0005799863,
0.0373198725,
0.0580048524,
-0.0297572557,
0.0330687687,
0.0153882541,
0.026354121,
-0.0337756164,
-0.0204345603,
0.0676680282,
-0.0208253674,
0.074907355,
-0.0353258438,
-0.0631360933,
-0.0084587829,
-0.0148890521,
0.0273694787,
-0.0738543645,
-0.0262201428,
0.0187246352,
-0.0761173517,
-0.0355491191,
-0.0319882073,
-0.0009922939,
-0.0023870461,
-0.0003800027,
0.0045087687,
0.0020210987,
0.0149135469,
-0.0058174524,
-0.0307001714,
0.0446864255,
0.0043954556,
-0.0361418836,
0.0095630167,
-0.0081125693,
0.0265028048,
-0.0229743142,
0.0248977244,
1.901993481e-34,
0.0443357788,
-0.0001290944,
0.0451754779,
0.0070701339,
0.041759558,
0.0078232503,
-0.0303153638,
0.0218860358,
0.0200128909,
-0.0667830557,
-0.0200820565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06184v1 | LINGO : Visually Debiasing Natural Language Instructions to Support Task Diversity | 2023-04-12T22:55:52 | 2023-04-12T22:55:52 | Anjana Arunkumar, Shubham Sharma, Rakhi Agrawal, Sriram Chandrasekaran, Chris Bryan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Cross-task generalization is a significant outcome that defines mastery in
natural language understanding. Humans show a remarkable aptitude for this, and
can solve many different types of tasks, given definitions in the form of
textual instructions and a small set of examples. Recent work with pre-trained
language models mimics this learning style: users can define and exemplify a
task for the model to attempt as a series of natural language prompts or
instructions. While prompting approaches have led to higher cross-task
generalization compared to traditional supervised learning, analyzing 'bias' in
the task instructions given to the model is a difficult problem, and has thus
been relatively unexplored. For instance, are we truly modeling a task, or are
we modeling a user's instructions? To help investigate this, we develop LINGO,
a novel visual analytics interface that supports an effective, task-driven
workflow to (1) help identify bias in natural language task instructions, (2)
alter (or create) task instructions to reduce bias, and (3) evaluate
pre-trained model performance on debiased task instructions. To robustly
evaluate LINGO, we conduct a user study with both novice and expert instruction
creators, over a dataset of 1,616 linguistic tasks and their natural language
instructions, spanning 55 different languages. For both user groups, LINGO
promotes the creation of more difficult tasks for pre-trained models, that
contain higher linguistic diversity and lower instruction bias. We additionally
discuss how the insights learned in developing and evaluating LINGO can aid in
the design of future dashboards that aim to minimize the effort involved in
prompt creation across multiple domains. | [
0.0468668155,
-0.007027423,
-0.0243349057,
0.0159344301,
-0.0031468503,
0.0105206836,
0.0171620362,
-0.0234715696,
0.0419951528,
-0.0225932952,
-0.0417522714,
-0.0024788252,
-0.0078515513,
0.0486913212,
0.0100106727,
-0.1134687215,
0.0144491233,
-0.0270294379,
0.0373367444,
0.0158669036,
0.0240521543,
0.0274077132,
-0.0218547955,
0.0738431215,
0.0026867716,
-0.054056678,
-0.0232200529,
0.0047487039,
-0.0093578827,
-0.0258294009,
0.0155159961,
0.0792108998,
0.0069256411,
0.0071573602,
0.0000022628,
-0.0571571775,
0.0129986741,
-0.0496871322,
-0.0585131571,
-0.0212082565,
0.0305024851,
0.0152841229,
0.0323281214,
0.0211057402,
-0.0537861995,
0.0021292355,
0.0477049686,
0.0361167565,
0.0537311137,
0.0078922752,
0.004050131,
0.0253009629,
-0.0768423826,
-0.0006774035,
0.0552877709,
-0.0215520374,
-0.0421066992,
0.0246658679,
0.0128327962,
0.0186248999,
-0.0225474257,
0.0116465138,
0.0220787656,
-0.0060146591,
0.0279679745,
0.0274175983,
0.0425196365,
-0.0553644039,
-0.0406471938,
0.0818752721,
-0.0599981733,
0.0014320905,
-0.0359234959,
-0.0207516961,
0.0435368903,
0.0414841361,
-0.0671142787,
0.0207167305,
-0.0203576889,
-0.0322510451,
-0.0140792774,
0.0166902654,
0.0072080675,
0.015859466,
0.0117530227,
0.0227571633,
-0.0083232466,
0.0081413724,
0.0409941748,
0.0546884649,
0.0133297546,
-0.0779549852,
0.0234085824,
0.0176643319,
-0.1021487266,
0.0120488834,
-0.022894768,
-0.0282024816,
0.018334249,
0.003002594,
0.0737069845,
0.0080720512,
-0.0593567304,
0.0285774339,
0.0227995757,
0.021338217,
0.0173951313,
-0.0047205146,
-0.0201895479,
-0.0044507408,
-0.0297431946,
-0.0043756492,
-0.0384897329,
-0.0273600854,
-0.0280681998,
0.0302630197,
-0.0131487176,
0.0086399959,
-0.0492001772,
-0.0076215547,
0.0327589251,
0.025897244,
-0.0475900993,
-0.0139436396,
-0.074231796,
0.0017938878,
-0.0888202339,
0.0298977736,
-0.0032187365,
-0.0765316784,
-0.013726891,
0.0014585,
-0.0003951175,
-0.027041316,
-0.0034330029,
0.0372425243,
-0.0027760265,
0.0083903642,
-0.0185537953,
-0.0515692458,
-0.0004588275,
-0.0205059256,
-0.0075785997,
-0.0452679656,
0.039858371,
0.0202975348,
0.007966307,
-0.0268757734,
-0.0187500119,
0.0411230214,
-0.0263882112,
0.0546547472,
-0.0203373469,
-0.0031307575,
0.0240592044,
0.0148503892,
-0.05051044,
0.0823979229,
0.0052912752,
0.0179006457,
0.0343851894,
-0.0188718475,
0.0371936299,
0.0253788456,
-0.0169906877,
-0.005670948,
0.0024582185,
0.0082132993,
-0.0073368424,
0.0057035838,
0.036008995,
0.0110531589,
-0.0011898357,
0.0279857814,
0.045444712,
0.0632884577,
0.0021660505,
-0.0035846613,
0.0614468157,
0.0344211012,
-0.0115209008,
0.0407373309,
-0.0507613085,
0.0549519211,
-0.0116616832,
-0.0060266689,
-0.0054278523,
0.0392697565,
-0.0247657914,
-0.0544091687,
0.0032061979,
0.0157921147,
0.0259827599,
0.0203146711,
0.0226166844,
0.0364047363,
-0.0113918064,
0.0220444575,
0.0335570835,
-0.0616569109,
0.0159907993,
-0.0222586654,
0.0406751111,
0.0799172819,
0.0122585297,
-0.0407004356,
-0.0162468199,
-0.0269170236,
0.0303558204,
0.044923503,
0.0534317754,
-0.0078769308,
0.0093034515,
-0.0472027361,
-0.0895877779,
-0.0194317494,
0.0032064512,
0.0114814043,
0.0380697362,
0.0060102646,
0.0069931266,
-0.0461987853,
-0.0710198507,
0.0354837477,
0.0118183391,
-0.026532447,
-0.0017255266,
0.0395941511,
-0.0285502467,
0.0376701318,
0.0233509801,
0.0138781322,
-0.0130952829,
0.0014947607,
-0.0021720482,
0.008929329,
-0.0327339172,
-0.0217446927,
0.0131992204,
-0.0866039693,
-0.0339037813,
-0.0052066534,
-0.0526668839,
-0.0202688575,
0.0189743508,
-0.0248047058,
-0.0084963562,
0.0151135782,
-0.0208473708,
-0.0025736699,
-0.0256253723,
-0.0291570947,
0.0754603744,
0.035933841,
0.0077937669,
0.0100068478,
-0.0441953652,
0.0037963134,
-0.0255554058,
0.0250593442,
-0.0224166904,
-0.0057086218,
-0.0028405937,
0.0430426337,
0.0305255447,
-0.0794323459,
0.0154375713,
-0.1035766974,
-0.0031961813,
-0.0350806415,
-0.0027143047,
0.0435294285,
0.0294220503,
-0.0268099494,
-0.0661087707,
-0.0454892255,
-0.0310132802,
-0.0156449843,
0.0284137614,
0.0267044399,
0.0154719055,
0.0371412858,
-0.0315905809,
0.0034145415,
-0.0145004084,
0.0144998282,
0.0602897406,
0.0007547166,
-0.0542767346,
0.0075608585,
0.0031150819,
-0.0051967935,
0.0255034007,
0.0304135364,
0.0495021977,
0.0008263123,
0.0703859106,
0.0489595383,
0.0102939159,
0.0545954108,
0.0508017875,
-0.0017798796,
-0.075426057,
0.0257872734,
-0.0181943271,
-0.0065862215,
0.0085510667,
-0.0707156733,
0.0437140502,
0.0616978966,
0.0207319017,
0.0088542616,
-0.0593962818,
0.0224210396,
-0.0263078045,
-0.0253952276,
-0.0677596405,
-0.0156888496,
0.0097195627,
0.0243050121,
-0.0290508326,
-0.0702360496,
0.0583760664,
0.0040661125,
-0.0027076509,
-0.0626462549,
-0.0374720506,
-0.023669539,
0.086093463,
-0.0280415826,
0.0158028323,
0.0298719388,
-0.0233385991,
-0.0578806661,
0.0247675311,
0.0184158031,
-0.0198090505,
0.0474850908,
-0.0773866326,
-0.0502273142,
-0.0095445765,
-0.013757064,
-0.0452712514,
-0.0406198204,
-0.037177518,
-0.0274013076,
0.0535783432,
0.0048837489,
-0.0118925003,
-0.0329706855,
0.0354038104,
0.033131443,
0.0031255865,
-0.0221266076,
0.0008433595,
-0.0228771642,
0.0327677019,
0.0284558516,
-0.0203359574,
-0.0374469906,
0.0054183807,
0.0264288448,
0.0317413509,
-0.0415525846,
-0.0024476966,
0.0075462353,
0.0240754522,
-0.039378874,
0.0037027916,
0.0569517352,
0.0835586786,
-0.0401872583,
0.0069494178,
0.1227488369,
0.0405879244,
-0.0830228701,
0.0053925631,
-0.0268596821,
0.0407961309,
0.0493164845,
0.0335858725,
-0.088854678,
-0.0507978611,
-0.0012701923,
0.0161248557,
0.0092190132,
-0.0305796601,
-0.0299409032,
-0.1023318097,
0.0226233359,
-0.0161572993,
-0.0099386619,
-0.0039978037,
-0.0419039391,
0.0036543503,
-0.0176612493,
0.0077950512,
-0.0339790545,
-0.0113715027,
0.0448575392,
0.0330996774,
-0.032400813,
-0.0635382459,
-0.0094379941,
-0.0708968192,
0.0248007644,
0.0433640592,
-0.0016428326,
-0.0054865158,
-0.0076957415,
0.0061456072,
0.0398902632,
0.050130181,
-0.0242932774,
0.0973811075,
0.0055679036,
-0.0134249032,
-0.0480284579,
0.0330146253,
0.0035353899,
0.0036123758,
0.0569620766,
0.0572722889,
-0.0187868569,
-0.0021816953,
-0.0095846644,
-0.0020486519,
0.0728055388,
0.0792878047,
0.0517408885,
-0.0671121404,
-0.0120895505,
-0.079608798,
0.0208665803,
-0.0438029692,
-0.0524867363,
0.0234915391,
-0.0232283603,
-0.0185732394,
-0.0450237915,
-0.0636076033,
0.1036459059,
0.0350359119,
0.0482812598,
-0.0062909606,
0.0148808854,
-0.0029061341,
-0.00955295,
0.0793414786,
-0.0316055417,
0.0493109152,
-0.0451448821,
-0.080355607,
-0.0446657389,
-0.0161755662,
0.0078826491,
0.0464945659,
-0.0376728512,
-0.0251085386,
-0.0006264287,
0.0444199815,
0.0188883506,
0.0278430562,
-0.0058694337,
-0.058535181,
0.0305747408,
0.0138273556,
-0.043001052,
-0.0615388639,
-0.0129567562,
0.0105998544,
0.0056467904,
0.0073135844,
-0.0530295298,
-0.0030216342,
-0.0062829815,
0.0110752555,
-0.02886004,
-0.0289395787,
0.0153776687,
-0.0282277074,
0.0526251942,
-0.0193547998,
0.0319795422,
-0.0280658193,
-0.0181342922,
0.0016468078,
-0.0295431055,
-0.0244120993,
0.0065460657,
0.017561201,
-0.0506586097,
0.0314189382,
0.0658071786,
-0.0547718517,
-0.0076173856,
-0.0894339308,
0.033115577,
0.0183132589,
0.0186482035,
0.0014076099,
0.0201241169,
-0.0247804578,
0.0165288411,
0.0042568455,
0.0386322029,
0.0428462364,
0.0617183112,
0.0017527821,
-0.0059271781,
-0.0042377482,
0.0270382613,
-0.0428747386,
-0.0677940547,
0.0340491794,
0.0017467855,
0.0254868232,
-0.0468971841,
0.0261965189,
-0.0010634329,
0.0172716659,
-0.0000997489,
0.0035926027,
0.0125447866,
0.0020189763,
0.0329684392,
0.0087841218,
-0.0148254614,
-0.0631266981,
0.0983107984,
-0.0200824868,
0.0442138873,
-0.0237858947,
-0.0354040787,
-0.0400645807,
-0.0244550947,
0.0389918573,
0.0143352728,
-0.0366308577,
0.0051846495,
-0.0535059199,
-0.0563055687,
-0.0231856667,
-0.0013432115,
0.006212852,
-0.0064331284,
0.0622255057,
0.0368241891,
-0.0417189635,
-0.0224765204,
-0.0038269476,
0.0259698611,
-0.0074397186,
-0.0115819722,
-0.0562714189,
-6.290463327e-33,
-0.0182103906,
-0.0586006492,
-0.0125224562,
-0.0456960574,
0.0659758672,
-0.0185952056,
-0.0225923099,
0.0306323804,
-0.0141650504,
0.0365022905,
0.0019547285,
-0.0119817453,
0.0261512343,
0.0028251673,
0.04815064,
0.0045827758,
0.0678297803,
0.0035222794,
-0.0196624082,
0.0293576661,
0.0079457732,
0.0075186277,
0.0249288324,
-0.0659337044,
0.0864432454,
0.0248462483,
0.0125291254,
0.0078830635,
0.0285895932,
0.024491258,
-0.010478857,
0.0538970381,
0.0214543566,
-0.0571808517,
-0.0695136935,
0.0570909791,
-0.0153530678,
-0.0763287172,
0.0360719599,
0.0158199258,
-0.0792539641,
-0.01885405,
0.0024322367,
0.0181701221,
-0.0300625227,
-0.0027689314,
0.0623248965,
0.0180040095,
0.020451352,
0.0290733501,
-0.0350691862,
-0.0012856015,
-0.0411408283,
-0.0483807176,
-0.0019328675,
0.059094891,
0.0120757148,
-0.0391168706,
-0.0164737087,
0.0436762162,
0.022448387,
-0.0035240739,
0.0786549449,
0.03855104,
-0.028102167,
0.0506686233,
0.0173394512,
0.0227266923,
-0.028044587,
0.009773029,
-0.0073427102,
0.030491367,
0.0380055867,
-0.0059820842,
0.0397382975,
0.0199376438,
-0.0141064702,
0.061557021,
0.0128482627,
0.0255157743,
-0.0025657439,
-0.0122076003,
-0.0540038534,
-0.0144765358,
-0.0277885292,
-0.0153035782,
-0.0271759089,
-0.026665926,
0.0427755713,
-0.0029575888,
0.0004688204,
0.0018409375,
-0.0061435048,
0.0029926549,
-0.0175426658,
0.0062478092,
-0.0036954554,
0.0057260869,
0.0154827191,
-0.0348084718,
-0.0235771332,
-0.002767751,
0.0103394166,
0.0111483848,
0.0220244285,
0.039999526,
0.0342389829,
-0.0097846091,
-0.0639988631,
0.0047155037,
-0.040307492,
0.0221728031,
0.0220173597,
0.024482673,
0.0444216542,
0.0063556349,
-0.0532136634,
0.0621728897,
0.002284921,
-0.0286765918,
-0.0155891404,
-0.0243257415,
-0.0110896891,
-0.0059173885,
-0.024466902,
-0.0381061696,
-0.0215067547,
-0.0334429704,
0.0444399789,
-0.0103269937,
-0.0340478867,
-0.0313465707,
2.728e-7,
0.0337652676,
0.0398660935,
0.0290514901,
0.0395063981,
-0.0073902169,
0.0419201031,
0.0098557901,
0.0186158083,
-0.0104052667,
-0.0417403989,
-0.0376600064,
0.0306946766,
0.0267791227,
0.0328519531,
-0.0697541386,
-0.0383525677,
-0.0065636002,
0.0506176911,
-0.0700528026,
0.0271420795,
0.0749408454,
0.0271428879,
0.0061914278,
0.007641816,
0.0011498949,
-0.0450974144,
0.0008220802,
-0.0463891812,
0.0197158176,
0.0059049544,
0.0484496132,
0.0237161331,
0.0066623003,
0.0370126516,
-0.0347637571,
-0.0267683007,
-0.0002811498,
0.0361216441,
-0.0096431058,
0.0124984458,
-0.0343662165,
-0.0064215795,
0.0174886845,
-0.043916747,
0.0389013328,
-0.031262584,
0.0062755677,
-0.0178406518,
0.034776926,
-0.0129355183,
0.0417999402,
-0.0231400672,
-0.0200200826,
0.0047872211,
0.0212772489,
-0.0088519966,
-0.0418804772,
-0.0334957354,
-0.0408781171,
0.029582167,
-0.0242406204,
-0.0161756147,
-0.0616030879,
0.0134934383,
-0.0047991499,
-0.0223748442,
0.0235964637,
2.255565881e-34,
0.0167463552,
0.0317842439,
0.0656616315,
-0.0070901858,
0.0474374443,
-0.0023580426,
-0.0480856299,
0.002484025,
0.0395699292,
-0.0446020663,
-0.0385750681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.08178v1 | Textual Explanations for Automated Commentary Driving | 2023-04-12T21:50:20 | 2023-04-12T21:50:20 | Marc Alexander Kühn, Daniel Omeiza, Lars Kunze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.RO | The provision of natural language explanations for the predictions of
deep-learning-based vehicle controllers is critical as it enhances transparency
and easy audit. In this work, a state-of-the-art (SOTA) prediction and
explanation model is thoroughly evaluated and validated (as a benchmark) on the
new Sense--Assess--eXplain (SAX). Additionally, we developed a new explainer
model that improved over the baseline architecture in two ways: (i) an
integration of part of speech prediction and (ii) an introduction of special
token penalties. On the BLEU metric, our explanation generation technique
outperformed SOTA by a factor of 7.7 when applied on the BDD-X dataset. The
description generation technique is also improved by a factor of 1.3. Hence,
our work contributes to the realisation of future explainable autonomous
vehicles. | [
-0.012069216,
0.014231544,
0.0086912783,
0.0628774017,
0.0144835627,
0.01364318,
0.0339289606,
-0.0511881299,
-0.040109504,
-0.0154505018,
0.0349743478,
0.0022067341,
-0.009402927,
0.0740857273,
0.0584812202,
-0.0420690924,
0.0200355928,
-0.0671975315,
-0.0015097364,
0.0150422808,
0.0146363676,
0.0534425192,
-0.0345982127,
0.0437572226,
-0.0295779668,
0.0042431294,
-0.0317771845,
0.007857996,
0.0293204747,
-0.006007778,
-0.032601472,
0.0036690866,
0.0847771093,
-0.0044076769,
0.0000022618,
-0.0144585706,
0.0157994814,
0.0156339165,
-0.0527791828,
0.0128288008,
-0.0010422908,
-0.001515238,
0.0439478643,
0.0374746248,
0.0012916184,
0.0346755385,
0.0160943773,
0.0450223573,
0.0583150648,
0.0711461082,
0.0023256198,
-0.0588912964,
0.0106162541,
0.0296973102,
0.017034689,
-0.0213965252,
-0.0267032553,
-0.0071584438,
-0.0050932718,
0.0035063552,
-0.0174025092,
-0.0007876397,
0.0710220933,
-0.0673187003,
0.0299309436,
0.0146119688,
0.0473062471,
-0.0290973205,
-0.0128318164,
0.0525761247,
0.018243609,
-0.0735679641,
0.0071249097,
-0.0183655079,
-0.0189952906,
-0.0469876938,
-0.0329287425,
-0.0022938347,
0.0020472878,
0.0054153777,
-0.0142309936,
0.0245880149,
0.0569346249,
0.0221247263,
-0.0024863209,
0.064717643,
-0.0178399403,
-0.0157831423,
-0.0338376015,
0.0063107996,
-0.0220977832,
-0.0647706464,
-0.0210178867,
0.07170894,
-0.0697312653,
-0.0025666016,
0.0134032825,
-0.0114525631,
-0.0415914282,
-0.02328608,
0.0319542922,
0.0307768304,
-0.062810801,
0.0252912249,
-0.0039069909,
0.0966879055,
0.0538770258,
0.0050866995,
-0.0089022825,
-0.0231116917,
-0.0392264836,
-0.020086024,
-0.0283344649,
0.0024874604,
-0.0527774729,
-0.0198906977,
-0.0142424935,
0.0381082818,
-0.0078049507,
0.0217289422,
0.0170843378,
0.079024896,
-0.0199227706,
0.0045622848,
-0.0374649204,
-0.0197593644,
-0.0598517358,
-0.0020596602,
0.0487526432,
-0.0351048894,
0.0012323519,
0.0548414811,
-0.0282897223,
0.000767131,
0.0019324202,
0.0627826974,
-0.0050090444,
-0.0050512259,
-0.0375086144,
-0.0607645586,
-0.0607037693,
-0.0525909662,
-0.0275998637,
-0.0241199434,
0.0084385257,
-0.0182096027,
-0.0346193388,
-0.0272542909,
0.0029145093,
-0.0056174002,
0.010647417,
0.0650277436,
-0.0487014316,
0.0035629515,
0.0077775912,
0.0174904931,
0.0028335743,
0.0314762667,
0.0299752317,
0.0300843734,
0.0236109626,
-0.0039630104,
0.0215747021,
-0.0429274626,
0.0221984722,
-0.0157907475,
-0.027020555,
0.0133777782,
-0.0823305175,
0.0784010813,
0.0530569516,
0.0151469046,
-0.0212441478,
-0.0036218571,
0.0261703357,
0.0279891286,
0.0113469856,
0.0268199928,
0.0736750811,
0.0350353755,
-0.0266202874,
-0.005969042,
-0.0478270799,
0.0508340113,
-0.0052283867,
0.0128785633,
0.0292033441,
-0.0249243435,
-0.0397631675,
-0.076257199,
0.0003409986,
-0.0066733276,
0.0063077537,
0.0128423171,
-0.002997739,
-0.0135322688,
-0.0339794792,
0.0421582945,
0.0243267175,
-0.0020101741,
0.0128688188,
-0.0627357587,
0.0589578599,
0.0956978798,
0.0215535685,
-0.0216047075,
-0.0207780823,
-0.0380949937,
0.0387608558,
0.0259750411,
0.0010548944,
0.0100499876,
0.0320155844,
-0.0348741487,
-0.0531896055,
-0.0522775762,
0.0154871009,
-0.0165435635,
0.0030192207,
-0.0071595656,
0.0366329215,
-0.0493393317,
-0.0536227413,
0.0286696497,
0.0148436157,
-0.0501849614,
0.0014978035,
0.0025027455,
-0.0004417525,
0.052653905,
-0.000615241,
0.0256714728,
0.0274674799,
0.0034990176,
-0.0248657912,
0.0334298983,
-0.0596966855,
-0.0139001813,
0.0111531215,
-0.0188858081,
0.01788125,
0.0588457882,
-0.0416103378,
-0.0612680987,
-0.0212297179,
-0.0513573512,
0.0175594129,
-0.0237388369,
-0.0207058527,
0.0389411114,
-0.0023874666,
0.008323364,
0.0384988301,
0.01496947,
-0.0060883658,
0.0220766477,
0.0404893793,
0.0089766448,
-0.0024665964,
0.0133381831,
-0.0027012208,
-0.0519533791,
-0.0315239802,
-0.0064586243,
0.0020963103,
-0.0253643859,
0.0306506399,
-0.0484489463,
-0.0307633821,
-0.046301391,
-0.0094477981,
0.0383610837,
-0.0036749979,
0.0241447557,
-0.0064152353,
-0.0338398442,
0.0145302899,
0.0209236294,
-0.0102909626,
0.0404607952,
0.0007340284,
-0.0504922234,
-0.0147053376,
0.0155213596,
-0.0427635238,
0.0350580737,
0.0447528847,
-0.0189745277,
-0.0818841457,
-0.0096745286,
-0.0406462476,
0.0081589036,
-0.0371817388,
-0.0483837426,
0.0392236635,
0.03111309,
-0.0214540847,
0.0382392779,
0.0374399275,
0.0323260203,
0.0176828168,
0.0422838777,
-0.0394024178,
0.0193109959,
-0.0461468995,
0.0054677655,
-0.0297117755,
-0.015020974,
-0.0139030432,
0.0410241298,
-0.0166820884,
0.0218904968,
-0.0583302975,
-0.0178885888,
0.0026587348,
-0.045384828,
-0.0274873897,
-0.0461370461,
-0.0271700248,
0.057104066,
-0.0424766093,
-0.0376046859,
0.0723248422,
-0.0554608405,
-0.012109952,
-0.0189121142,
-0.0234128907,
-0.0112320418,
0.0857817158,
-0.0036015869,
0.0228226278,
0.0096455617,
0.0227716789,
0.0069155451,
-0.037588343,
0.0074364021,
0.027432682,
0.0210870672,
-0.0552267842,
0.0011798097,
0.0182036161,
-0.0269941799,
-0.0274584144,
-0.0657476783,
-0.0535085239,
0.0486544855,
0.0290793888,
-0.0714265406,
0.0038194288,
0.009649015,
0.0278770942,
0.0478122234,
0.0063878139,
-0.0023879225,
-0.0240926873,
-0.0344586894,
0.0609005317,
0.0411860906,
0.044779785,
-0.0346855372,
0.054078985,
0.0082069272,
0.0130457645,
0.0084653581,
-0.0656512901,
-0.018938899,
-0.0192044526,
-0.013688704,
-0.0137223182,
0.0537041686,
0.0614324249,
-0.0697242096,
-0.0227193888,
0.1085821465,
0.0161694102,
0.0014327847,
0.0484727584,
0.0054614055,
0.0383257456,
0.0056994609,
0.0060072984,
-0.0741313249,
-0.0612259805,
-0.0043615722,
0.0354414918,
0.0357267633,
0.0262804013,
-0.010269464,
-0.0437561497,
0.0188418571,
-0.0388521999,
-0.0525825135,
-0.0347589068,
-0.033655379,
-0.0643690601,
-0.0095348135,
0.0491132475,
0.0210101884,
0.0232543517,
-0.0023751268,
0.0487545282,
-0.0677747354,
-0.0167836212,
0.033576142,
-0.029278364,
0.0380584225,
0.0781224445,
0.0210008994,
0.0044152983,
-0.0370167531,
0.0166022107,
0.0217106659,
0.0467948392,
-0.0285938997,
0.0573594011,
-0.023545295,
-0.017441636,
-0.028233584,
0.0550870262,
-0.0438580252,
-0.0010937424,
-0.0521091931,
0.0602157861,
-0.0347061828,
-0.0060602301,
-0.0154933985,
0.0225529261,
0.0044682212,
0.0861303806,
0.0355579145,
-0.016872583,
-0.0567885526,
-0.015463965,
-0.0380595513,
-0.0827934146,
-0.0267589148,
-0.0490957461,
0.0365916602,
-0.0178420693,
-0.0280913748,
-0.0585413203,
-0.0021277773,
0.0026448977,
-0.0313693248,
-0.004225607,
-0.0377377234,
-0.0399649069,
-0.045525562,
0.0095120994,
0.023812959,
0.0281767547,
-0.0021489223,
0.0094470009,
0.0177184902,
-0.027941132,
-0.0385448076,
0.0133652333,
-0.0075665354,
-0.0143794687,
0.0061307931,
0.0153933885,
0.0169804152,
0.0887823552,
-0.0306331478,
-0.0823825076,
0.0280635338,
-0.0036615254,
-0.0030469841,
0.0047577908,
0.0304710753,
0.0032112307,
0.0221137125,
0.0548880063,
-0.0546430536,
-0.0007192078,
-0.0306440517,
-0.0368858352,
0.0008894497,
-0.0018231118,
0.0213266239,
0.0085636303,
0.0403710306,
-0.0238424912,
0.0200895667,
-0.0220868532,
0.0374440439,
-0.0315989926,
-0.0063200621,
-0.049947463,
0.0794516504,
-0.0169126187,
-0.0220560357,
0.0190079194,
-0.0112230005,
0.0000475735,
-0.0189685971,
-0.0091082659,
0.0334840566,
0.0431425087,
0.0107832998,
-0.0191756133,
0.0189847518,
-0.0142169762,
0.013984086,
-0.0021038235,
0.0358569622,
0.0061397846,
0.0653500706,
0.0302082729,
0.0086936178,
0.0246935058,
0.0010769391,
-0.0675139278,
-0.0552490465,
-0.0322986357,
0.0138886934,
0.0146583309,
-0.0076888013,
0.0595351718,
-0.0053166458,
0.0079947468,
0.0054713665,
0.0930560231,
0.0261140801,
-0.0080489907,
0.0463876352,
0.0067790556,
-0.0391614959,
-0.037282411,
0.0470258556,
0.0388358608,
0.0309509784,
0.0209096782,
-0.0139253568,
-0.0202003364,
-0.0327110291,
0.0108435955,
0.0573591813,
0.0007659722,
-0.019516591,
-0.0073402794,
-0.0346095376,
-0.0085895192,
0.0301046241,
-0.0047136978,
-0.0204918999,
0.032668516,
0.0299474467,
0.0058774813,
-0.0536592081,
0.0239579454,
-0.0240078829,
-0.0309657622,
-0.0076912045,
-0.0155294146,
-6.930245229e-33,
-0.0223970599,
-0.0122968908,
0.0233735964,
-0.0394140929,
-0.0125415809,
-0.0015861536,
-0.0628707036,
-0.0206306297,
-0.0129646175,
0.0612877905,
0.0223540142,
0.0501958802,
0.0169150662,
0.0443265922,
-0.0228837822,
-0.0837577879,
0.0528382547,
-0.0031114875,
-0.0054273098,
0.0606380478,
0.0511652268,
0.0270837247,
0.019419631,
-0.058316309,
0.0594879724,
-0.0071702884,
-0.0414797999,
0.021311231,
-0.0270426907,
0.0534302741,
-0.0059965998,
0.0273133852,
0.0115088802,
-0.0340835191,
-0.0242361575,
0.042631682,
-0.0150959725,
-0.020191893,
0.0510835759,
0.0237573422,
-0.0944355056,
-0.0326153897,
0.0455522649,
-0.0130127547,
-0.0020007922,
-0.0052650026,
0.0416520573,
-0.0135557149,
-0.0143445777,
-0.0313819386,
-0.0331950188,
0.0114384824,
-0.02100279,
-0.0460423902,
0.0351139382,
0.0692309514,
-0.0091598518,
-0.0049944972,
0.0000589157,
-0.0388739258,
0.0124235256,
0.0344819464,
0.0933443457,
-0.0057456396,
-0.025968546,
0.0444081984,
0.026307188,
-0.0329656713,
-0.0931286663,
0.031880971,
-0.0294370055,
0.0805421919,
0.075562492,
0.0584012493,
-0.000685776,
0.0034573437,
-0.0900098532,
0.0254116915,
-0.0381572284,
0.0279432125,
0.0470080301,
-0.0139452331,
-0.0964026749,
-0.0266541261,
-0.0502343252,
0.0050789942,
-0.027911434,
-0.0265334994,
0.0458868667,
0.001907248,
-0.0686939359,
-0.0216905847,
-0.0063165189,
-0.0834272057,
0.0587075613,
0.0119580356,
-0.0470402204,
-0.0251782499,
-0.0196170919,
-0.0134755932,
-0.0418209843,
-0.0120647103,
0.0212792754,
0.0363123976,
0.0368492864,
-0.0022402103,
0.0286788493,
0.033053156,
-0.0015705811,
0.0192593895,
-0.0784630179,
-0.0190846808,
-0.0180389788,
0.0056479983,
0.0315203629,
0.025909286,
-0.0451493748,
0.0205399245,
-0.0175533891,
-0.0092967721,
0.0152016683,
-0.0322691686,
-0.0122578237,
0.0165748484,
-0.015653437,
0.0020010443,
-0.0047325091,
-0.0449776053,
0.0402979851,
-0.0532405376,
-0.0004770279,
0.0314438865,
2.67e-7,
0.0103951143,
0.0156845786,
0.0357706696,
-0.0233524181,
0.0400572121,
0.0508794412,
0.0569407791,
0.004743794,
-0.060013894,
-0.0172475483,
0.0046421685,
0.0601045638,
0.0519184098,
-0.0040616356,
-0.016624283,
-0.0227824561,
-0.0865432769,
-0.0248939227,
-0.0496103279,
-0.0098559642,
0.0947257504,
0.0782925263,
-0.0148919458,
-0.0206981003,
0.0364452079,
0.0045582284,
0.008978162,
-0.0161098484,
0.0271306448,
-0.0202589557,
0.0403352715,
0.0354646146,
-0.003939853,
0.0035574774,
-0.0151691902,
-0.0101470565,
-0.0504035465,
0.0520493574,
-0.0037858316,
-0.0657828525,
-0.00993519,
-0.0398946218,
0.0189475473,
-0.0690803975,
0.048368942,
0.0183342937,
0.0183226932,
-0.0303727761,
-0.0379934013,
-0.0274535064,
-0.0071545769,
0.0115358755,
0.0220099501,
0.0049473294,
-0.0053157075,
-0.0435899571,
0.018834943,
-0.0923500955,
-0.0367780328,
0.005214388,
-0.0012517242,
0.0543408282,
-0.0338457376,
0.0327168591,
0.0555201918,
-0.0374785177,
-0.036719285,
2.091138099e-34,
0.0106527386,
0.0207068939,
-0.0057483427,
-0.0100663453,
0.0318346284,
0.0379616022,
0.0003880227,
-0.0210529082,
0.0363316238,
-0.0225220993,
-0.0382802747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06148v1 | Detection of Fake Generated Scientific Abstracts | 2023-04-12T20:20:22 | 2023-04-12T20:20:22 | Panagiotis C. Theocharopoulos, Panagiotis Anagnostou, Anastasia Tsoukala, Spiros V. Georgakopoulos, Sotiris K. Tasoulis, Vassilis P. Plagianakos | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread adoption of Large Language Models and publicly available
ChatGPT has marked a significant turning point in the integration of Artificial
Intelligence into people's everyday lives. The academic community has taken
notice of these technological advancements and has expressed concerns regarding
the difficulty of discriminating between what is real and what is artificially
generated. Thus, researchers have been working on developing effective systems
to identify machine-generated text. In this study, we utilize the GPT-3 model
to generate scientific paper abstracts through Artificial Intelligence and
explore various text representation methods when combined with Machine Learning
models with the aim of identifying machine-written text. We analyze the models'
performance and address several research questions that rise during the
analysis of the results. By conducting this research, we shed light on the
capabilities and limitations of Artificial Intelligence generated text. | [
0.0748897493,
0.0060276035,
0.0091224657,
0.0481708162,
-0.0675331727,
-0.0027336595,
0.0273902491,
0.0176067911,
0.0198505744,
-0.0526399016,
-0.0083975419,
0.0129194148,
0.0130647533,
0.0696239993,
0.0255970452,
-0.0109131346,
0.0134654911,
0.0371870622,
0.0507852584,
0.0205268934,
0.0083098439,
0.0256377552,
0.0427383184,
0.0404108688,
0.0304635819,
-0.0411611609,
0.0325793698,
-0.0073270886,
0.0105255274,
-0.0155200157,
0.0260480456,
0.0499212444,
-0.0151384827,
0.1148125306,
0.0000014844,
-0.0433975421,
-0.0458457097,
0.0236656331,
0.009305995,
0.0392773226,
0.087657094,
-0.0417641588,
-0.0216222424,
0.0345386676,
-0.0442449898,
-0.0170257017,
0.0028000474,
0.0646385476,
0.0331254154,
0.0791460797,
-0.0396870896,
-0.0056685624,
0.0775318071,
0.0318489447,
-0.0150794154,
-0.0062372903,
0.0200896431,
0.0189347677,
0.004382784,
0.0714275017,
0.0562497675,
0.0157190003,
-0.0208761618,
-0.0476044305,
-0.0024030854,
0.0106890053,
-0.0735379457,
-0.0015085315,
0.0005433002,
0.0012704409,
-0.0545608997,
-0.0729903281,
0.0751504973,
-0.0145131759,
-0.0029776047,
0.0378062762,
-0.0045586494,
0.0119682783,
-0.0298568234,
0.0007510076,
0.045879174,
0.0126895197,
0.0023386553,
0.0455618873,
0.0105011705,
0.043246273,
0.0023093533,
-0.0691180006,
-0.0213647373,
-0.0169357695,
-0.0140826087,
-0.0430267453,
0.0509527437,
0.0242679305,
0.0441043116,
-0.0067620394,
-0.0664980859,
-0.1074615046,
0.0355397724,
-0.0359318368,
-0.0280040577,
0.0113735786,
0.0214153603,
0.0133698741,
-0.0345677063,
0.0330808237,
-0.0208344106,
0.0144234803,
-0.0095878281,
0.0088106561,
-0.0193466786,
-0.0486613289,
-0.0220261216,
0.0334933102,
-0.0253714938,
-0.0308278725,
-0.0259303972,
0.019910302,
0.0081760027,
0.0260718837,
-0.0363649726,
-0.0274207182,
-0.0356646962,
-0.0054084053,
0.0222887248,
0.0030737612,
0.0356578752,
0.0058919499,
-0.0180683564,
-0.0429108478,
-0.0026078511,
0.0659139156,
0.0152151072,
-0.0016220566,
-0.0072226916,
0.0118894326,
-0.0201835278,
-0.0331686437,
0.019829955,
-0.0739358515,
-0.0048662168,
-0.0421185903,
0.0298260096,
-0.0345979296,
-0.0042197197,
-0.0069462503,
-0.0299570002,
-0.0188640207,
-0.0176339,
0.0312120821,
-0.0129116355,
0.0208120458,
-0.0521421395,
0.0031438377,
0.0799696892,
-0.0035662099,
-0.0389457196,
-0.0406633802,
0.0188518111,
0.0459627025,
0.0359897614,
-0.0180363525,
0.0666677207,
0.0230579991,
0.055679664,
-0.0241862368,
0.069918327,
-0.0185520183,
-0.0272702258,
0.0322613008,
0.0088422615,
0.065252237,
-0.0179685112,
-0.0155042643,
0.0275530573,
0.082876876,
-0.0284075346,
0.0484143384,
0.0395662226,
0.0557315014,
0.051703088,
0.0408856049,
0.0070278714,
-0.0344038121,
-0.0315888338,
0.012842508,
0.0053220503,
-0.0030510952,
0.0227047224,
-0.0153045757,
-0.0163107347,
-0.0006712431,
-0.0245553721,
-0.0572322682,
0.0478623286,
0.0060269507,
-0.0503754318,
-0.0640243366,
-0.0356927812,
-0.0086667165,
0.004368301,
-0.0732815042,
0.0396373123,
0.0282256398,
0.0863894671,
-0.0143735996,
0.0110845556,
-0.01494148,
-0.0202116854,
0.0851143599,
0.0371082798,
-0.001790493,
-0.0707436949,
-0.004975562,
-0.0020104686,
0.0000609106,
0.0078576496,
-0.0084985951,
0.006909451,
0.0138484482,
0.0346251056,
-0.0114522334,
-0.0623671338,
0.0401433744,
-0.0514362901,
-0.0331244841,
-0.0002586026,
-0.0279890168,
0.0429710411,
0.0053244871,
-0.0169359688,
0.04789133,
0.035658177,
-0.0130071705,
-0.0131322285,
0.0068396544,
0.0149771711,
0.0083925994,
0.0084508602,
-0.0652974993,
-0.0182125978,
0.0578820929,
-0.0149670262,
-0.0075699198,
0.0234326459,
-0.0374018773,
0.0036764042,
-0.0837384686,
-0.0228600148,
-0.0023974322,
0.0216120649,
0.0036256318,
0.0550585203,
-0.0070637399,
0.0199660752,
0.0399618894,
-0.0082408488,
0.0484708957,
-0.0444358252,
0.0148018673,
-0.0067051826,
-0.0078083328,
-0.0145458458,
0.0285758488,
0.0023650385,
0.0230393261,
-0.0233322512,
-0.0483685359,
-0.0091941962,
-0.0038989699,
0.0102251116,
0.050965745,
-0.0652826428,
0.0041436828,
0.0265539363,
-0.0085034072,
-0.0497389399,
0.0537602529,
-0.0288757291,
0.0489310548,
-0.0255282819,
0.041954942,
-0.014474825,
0.0137687782,
-0.0418268815,
0.039071776,
0.0536113307,
-0.0436011776,
-0.085203737,
0.0181371812,
0.0156617556,
-0.0152951516,
-0.0127115585,
-0.0036601936,
-0.0252932031,
-0.0173900574,
0.0021784483,
0.0555075519,
0.0415206999,
0.0334022865,
0.025046451,
0.0597787015,
-0.0041421591,
-0.0388356894,
-0.0481384806,
0.0627680272,
0.0361188203,
-0.0792335495,
0.0807022378,
0.0052054431,
0.0163241159,
0.0103553385,
-0.0048992881,
0.0272367187,
0.0094282962,
-0.0239327513,
0.024501957,
-0.0346322767,
-0.029606564,
0.016226545,
0.0045868764,
-0.0418036059,
0.0352903455,
-0.0392738134,
0.0042330781,
-0.0930292532,
0.0018391401,
0.007333586,
-0.0117293289,
-0.0111565385,
0.0294463281,
0.0369639881,
0.0020667382,
0.0058069974,
0.0140927173,
0.0352515094,
-0.0398757681,
-0.0496645346,
-0.0242526624,
0.0377486497,
-0.0024660835,
0.0330975056,
-0.0151466373,
-0.044079937,
0.0179494433,
0.0118313376,
0.0366179235,
-0.0338080339,
-0.0388432853,
0.0393329337,
0.02591056,
0.0828536525,
-0.0417456552,
-0.009255968,
-0.0370139107,
0.054520838,
0.0589522682,
-0.0336898006,
0.0378312245,
0.000747064,
-0.0169304851,
0.0413725376,
0.0003555955,
0.0171461143,
-0.0160993338,
-0.0740014464,
-0.0298937708,
-0.0573444031,
0.0160155911,
-0.0028132191,
-0.0250389185,
-0.0351099223,
0.0002106768,
0.0979326442,
0.0211939346,
-0.0394292958,
-0.0222433452,
-0.0295083914,
-0.0035032227,
-0.0331114493,
0.0301390849,
-0.0580554344,
0.0179781802,
-0.0028817402,
0.0193531662,
-0.0548303612,
-0.0024717948,
-0.0093883732,
-0.0764412284,
0.0570896193,
0.0254060347,
-0.0527076684,
-0.0447305553,
-0.0326481052,
-0.0418939255,
0.0273055267,
0.0003041482,
-0.0288492683,
0.0098055378,
0.002378966,
-0.0047088345,
-0.0550306402,
-0.0805979222,
-0.0264993366,
0.0066812281,
0.0204223916,
0.0485768281,
0.0556800216,
-0.0274218973,
-0.0401198342,
0.0200599506,
-0.0127720963,
-0.0431169644,
-0.0209401101,
0.0334403515,
-0.0164404195,
0.0271955729,
-0.0023198361,
0.079502739,
-0.0100996494,
-0.0055417186,
0.0139318639,
0.0855317414,
-0.044116836,
-0.0582721382,
-0.0638070479,
-0.0041550468,
0.0222197976,
0.0705261379,
0.0066200481,
-0.012039707,
-0.067600742,
-0.0277269799,
0.0510289893,
-0.0060028676,
-0.0346866027,
-0.0373612344,
-0.011420141,
-0.0168163013,
-0.0947721824,
-0.0235879924,
-0.017734183,
-0.0128671946,
0.0193822756,
0.0243168194,
0.0337972715,
-0.0142205833,
-0.0577668622,
-0.017993154,
-0.0182970148,
-0.0009142456,
-0.0152022904,
-0.0195867363,
0.02065216,
-0.0185270049,
-0.0256561209,
0.0166401546,
0.0133678708,
-0.03580302,
-0.0187604222,
0.0179701578,
0.0294517372,
0.0052498048,
-0.0076913387,
-0.0158046484,
0.0508417897,
0.028435681,
0.01599502,
-0.0039638123,
-0.0128726158,
-0.02857388,
-0.031126108,
-0.0315202922,
-0.0085716033,
0.0443478078,
-0.0241529327,
-0.0412647277,
-0.0437104031,
0.0141775645,
0.049101349,
0.0328092128,
0.0144827226,
-0.026589781,
0.0223066136,
-0.0240907725,
-0.0507094152,
-0.0486602485,
0.0117169283,
-0.0246331878,
0.02813139,
0.0200437382,
0.0167212151,
-0.0036219074,
0.0425091274,
-0.056718722,
0.0155312568,
-0.0014886326,
-0.0107725961,
-0.0518959239,
0.0834709555,
-0.0070877769,
-0.0146951824,
-0.0167097952,
0.0099325813,
-0.0223908015,
0.0346072949,
0.0116604529,
0.0217687432,
0.0417185389,
-0.0035860827,
0.0400015824,
0.0435755253,
-0.1047374457,
0.0008886225,
-0.0759322196,
0.028224051,
0.0099528106,
0.0053234128,
0.0447329096,
-0.0857706442,
-0.024809476,
-0.04481465,
0.0490627512,
0.0293499138,
0.0121791894,
-0.048897177,
-0.0127142426,
-0.052457083,
-0.0097484132,
0.0731883794,
0.0267815292,
0.0089459112,
0.0108969063,
-0.0580064096,
-0.0395799577,
-0.0280106217,
-0.021568859,
-0.0178460907,
0.0056056818,
-0.0120833237,
-0.044732675,
-0.0051227906,
0.0442688838,
0.0339030288,
0.0403503329,
-0.0323737711,
-0.0242753625,
0.0578072928,
-0.0342433341,
0.0037794723,
-0.036827568,
0.0390140861,
-0.0457492955,
-0.0455038585,
-0.0215249229,
-4.681499924e-33,
0.0244460162,
-0.1013080627,
-0.0128037957,
0.0483613871,
0.0067831217,
0.021871563,
-0.0712052584,
-0.0557015426,
0.0069280923,
0.0178465284,
-0.0105135972,
0.0019537196,
-0.004313353,
-0.0093622701,
-0.0240815505,
0.0461658947,
0.0186104272,
-0.0264258273,
-0.0294925477,
0.0380114764,
0.0476117395,
0.0034538829,
0.026706975,
-0.0733827353,
0.0407028198,
-0.0658704042,
-0.0381201692,
-0.0102566918,
-0.0208206922,
0.0346078277,
-0.0678244606,
-0.0217609517,
0.0330691375,
-0.0045210849,
-0.0057259784,
0.0305241495,
-0.0144488215,
0.0186851602,
-0.0074531846,
-0.0183996297,
-0.0348295383,
-0.0474014133,
0.0643792599,
-0.0270779934,
-0.0578233488,
0.0204142146,
0.0747546926,
-0.0269134231,
-0.02004431,
-0.0857788026,
-0.0813832283,
0.0236297268,
0.0033618715,
0.0373552665,
0.0344561301,
0.0275721923,
-0.0014327351,
0.0437430851,
-0.0224574264,
0.0012700373,
0.0076336088,
-0.0003621288,
0.0011315992,
-0.0436521582,
0.0194889158,
0.0176841822,
0.001767793,
0.0175858941,
0.0035120836,
0.0009520081,
0.0189687964,
-0.0176273752,
0.0987006575,
0.0715498999,
0.0652285367,
-0.0406872071,
-0.0010211495,
0.0661481321,
-0.0179454647,
-0.0292207804,
0.0303264279,
-0.0451015942,
0.001933502,
0.0249313191,
0.0439579301,
-0.0544811785,
-0.0026468625,
-0.0180768538,
0.0266478155,
-0.0098809954,
-0.044754941,
0.0180350523,
0.0098630292,
-0.0501036569,
0.0113057122,
0.0004549916,
-0.0326468386,
0.0165456142,
0.0113922572,
0.0180113185,
-0.048871465,
-0.0442765728,
0.0076891831,
0.0228402466,
0.0092984233,
-0.008121687,
0.0335776135,
0.0011902855,
-0.0218300913,
0.029755557,
0.0244902764,
0.0195300765,
0.0085379817,
0.0126368375,
-0.0057825274,
-0.0269545522,
0.0502803661,
-0.0250486061,
0.008479205,
0.029024316,
-0.0104944687,
0.0403805822,
-0.0093261702,
0.0251686256,
-0.0217284113,
0.0162819959,
-0.021470394,
0.0130855367,
0.0077556432,
-0.046555616,
0.0339438394,
-0.0191162005,
2.17e-7,
0.0372080132,
0.0787561834,
0.0432071611,
-0.0208500717,
0.0398516282,
0.0199831724,
0.0217145011,
0.0425188057,
-0.003076127,
-0.0054151956,
0.021699544,
-0.0403102152,
0.0371563211,
-0.0110460026,
-0.0822087601,
0.038556274,
-0.0699748024,
-0.0187482052,
-0.0654904619,
0.0554718934,
0.0452976674,
0.0224460177,
-0.0256363023,
-0.0277455803,
0.0097167026,
-0.0331644788,
0.0349337608,
0.0167721063,
0.0111008156,
0.0162648782,
0.0638211221,
-0.002872651,
0.0018997942,
0.0120517854,
-0.034742441,
0.0140035944,
0.0131059177,
0.0512484871,
0.0125923017,
0.0142942397,
0.004782863,
-0.0270248782,
0.0482111499,
-0.0390863381,
0.0282594506,
-0.0155793466,
0.0062264819,
-0.0603968315,
-0.0494125411,
-0.042861294,
-0.0007225394,
-0.031158261,
-0.0083627868,
0.0417482592,
-0.0222705062,
0.0065120072,
0.0390967466,
-0.0345714986,
0.0282526109,
-0.0018981083,
-0.0388422944,
-0.0155619141,
-0.0320845991,
-0.024050327,
0.0613798723,
-0.0424202457,
0.0195941534,
2.043481446e-34,
0.0636457577,
-0.0318976641,
-0.0129530318,
0.0259358026,
-0.0020594019,
0.0167302918,
0.0271662436,
0.0338319615,
-0.0115333255,
-0.022947276,
0.0194954816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03514v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03514v3 | Can Large Language Models Transform Computational Social Science? | 2023-04-12T17:33:28 | 2024-02-26T17:16:12 | Caleb Ziems, William Held, Omar Shaikh, Jiaao Chen, Zhehao Zhang, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are capable of successfully performing many
language processing tasks zero-shot (without training data). If zero-shot LLMs
can also reliably classify and explain social phenomena like persuasiveness and
political ideology, then LLMs could augment the Computational Social Science
(CSS) pipeline in important ways. This work provides a road map for using LLMs
as CSS tools. Towards this end, we contribute a set of prompting best practices
and an extensive evaluation pipeline to measure the zero-shot performance of 13
language models on 25 representative English CSS benchmarks. On taxonomic
labeling tasks (classification), LLMs fail to outperform the best fine-tuned
models but still achieve fair levels of agreement with humans. On free-form
coding tasks (generation), LLMs produce explanations that often exceed the
quality of crowdworkers' gold references. We conclude that the performance of
today's LLMs can augment the CSS research pipeline in two ways: (1) serving as
zero-shot data annotators on human annotation teams, and (2) bootstrapping
challenging creative generation tasks (e.g., explaining the underlying
attributes of a text). In summary, LLMs are posed to meaningfully participate
in social science analysis in partnership with humans. | [
0.0316765979,
0.0820075646,
-0.0026599565,
0.0265892241,
-0.0215674695,
0.0307194088,
0.0244522579,
-0.0128342835,
-0.0158624724,
-0.0651726499,
0.0091758957,
-0.0589373522,
0.0033960517,
0.0149191609,
0.0385589637,
-0.0415234305,
0.0217750221,
0.0026227294,
0.0481352992,
-0.0207866915,
0.0068153124,
0.036804948,
0.014263954,
0.0618696697,
-0.0102593573,
-0.0054996936,
-0.0171221215,
-0.0029903024,
0.0334856957,
-0.0112409042,
0.0185354892,
0.0736629888,
0.0262709763,
0.0840135515,
0.000001794,
-0.0368069038,
0.0276425686,
0.0008278658,
-0.0317978524,
-0.0166927967,
0.0528372973,
-0.0111211948,
-0.0029061385,
0.0011268596,
-0.0308619309,
0.012127975,
0.0849037766,
0.0263620988,
0.043142084,
0.0618559457,
0.0234655626,
-0.0459105298,
0.0087695578,
-0.0397459455,
0.011583548,
0.0090172132,
0.0365964063,
-0.0345923863,
-0.0003690716,
0.0321636461,
-0.0121066757,
0.0186235122,
0.0249924567,
-0.0387901887,
0.0167618208,
0.0375384279,
-0.067249313,
-0.0312790535,
0.0091681536,
0.0828678831,
0.0102369282,
-0.0354862884,
0.0324371792,
0.0086567802,
-0.0181043744,
0.0103955669,
-0.0479761176,
0.0576308295,
0.0169091634,
0.0307228826,
0.0286167972,
-0.0216520615,
0.0449817553,
0.0631763041,
0.0052136146,
0.076406613,
-0.0076078228,
-0.0012555767,
0.0108328685,
0.0122160632,
-0.0046174871,
-0.0778265893,
-0.0197425075,
0.0059313434,
-0.0308944639,
0.0308358241,
-0.0130081484,
-0.0091027031,
0.0284146611,
-0.0288032237,
0.0533885509,
0.0116624422,
0.0112503814,
0.0659054741,
0.0380648226,
-0.0024606609,
-0.0082605323,
0.0225495808,
0.017691236,
-0.0321936905,
-0.0703198016,
-0.010073239,
-0.004401945,
-0.0258443505,
-0.0307848249,
0.0206955578,
-0.0042619249,
-0.0198276229,
-0.041005753,
0.0055866404,
-0.0177674126,
0.0341172405,
-0.0315868706,
-0.0147178434,
-0.0374636166,
0.0307216365,
-0.0391380489,
0.0013261226,
0.0281099435,
-0.0627742186,
0.0016772182,
0.0349218473,
-0.0096733309,
-0.0260921251,
0.025532959,
-0.0003359026,
0.0095346747,
0.0021409332,
-0.0189492386,
-0.0280172601,
-0.0298128854,
-0.0755248144,
0.0205904245,
-0.0720544234,
0.0281245634,
0.0303047802,
-0.0082035856,
-0.0683950558,
0.0139417574,
0.0289610364,
-0.0576333925,
0.0791618899,
-0.0293138232,
-0.0032402766,
0.0136608277,
0.0316628516,
0.0016504002,
0.0820638388,
0.0477011278,
0.0243457351,
0.024713235,
-0.0107295541,
0.038538333,
0.0104081687,
0.0034577043,
0.0332374051,
-0.0213897489,
-0.0159663558,
-0.0097149322,
0.0114245927,
0.0375282913,
0.063213557,
0.0047191172,
-0.0345188081,
0.075233683,
0.0630280375,
-0.0193109922,
0.0327729918,
0.0565652177,
0.0207822658,
-0.0150900465,
-0.0255499389,
-0.032085415,
0.0285365302,
-0.0371034443,
-0.0207874551,
0.0223112367,
0.0182898492,
-0.0331812873,
-0.0174471997,
-0.0355346054,
-0.0142464275,
0.0215146262,
0.0105080567,
0.0501028337,
-0.0120064337,
-0.0169962142,
-0.0119679766,
0.0468554273,
-0.0551427789,
0.0066439034,
-0.0419239514,
0.0711687654,
0.0428579301,
0.0448667854,
-0.0147634447,
-0.0088538565,
-0.0450241081,
0.0631309673,
0.0812589526,
0.0620497018,
-0.0450485162,
-0.0326560177,
-0.0283228848,
-0.0201873314,
-0.0279185306,
0.00831939,
0.0273415539,
0.0319010429,
-0.0211364571,
0.0257505644,
-0.0451390222,
-0.0588921644,
0.0392563343,
-0.0282040481,
-0.0011142351,
-0.0064555886,
-0.0049414337,
0.0312692113,
0.0433004461,
-0.0232070442,
0.0056815902,
0.0066171032,
-0.0452348627,
-0.0379432291,
0.0092907595,
-0.0074638496,
-0.0103764404,
0.0380868763,
-0.0363670774,
-0.0353022739,
0.0566047244,
-0.0242530853,
-0.0160579588,
0.0603650101,
-0.0213892031,
0.0072554909,
-0.0375332944,
-0.0177589003,
-0.0395901799,
0.0170877296,
-0.0265963189,
0.0695253611,
0.0251054801,
0.0235613342,
-0.0152677698,
-0.0295820385,
0.0116528915,
-0.0173259489,
-0.0338290371,
-0.0046930462,
0.0355502032,
0.0032480441,
0.0300149452,
-0.0273617711,
-0.0453712381,
-0.0057130987,
-0.0844274163,
0.0022381719,
-0.0270852149,
0.018172618,
-0.0066682929,
-0.0281736907,
0.0090317167,
0.0192245245,
-0.0474232212,
-0.002658092,
-0.011639514,
0.0340751112,
0.0441007689,
-0.0292157289,
-0.0172520019,
-0.0221212599,
0.0176498424,
-0.0344931036,
0.0621169992,
0.0542748012,
-0.0018030169,
-0.0170730148,
-0.0045739813,
-0.0666006804,
-0.0029996014,
-0.0098642334,
-0.0189188961,
0.0442807637,
0.0253024381,
0.0415187702,
0.0429410376,
0.0145986453,
0.0307362713,
0.0350694694,
0.0292636305,
-0.0458711982,
-0.0347972512,
-0.0316892564,
0.0027942529,
-0.0087202545,
-0.0278930571,
-0.0127012208,
0.1143523827,
-0.0103942212,
-0.0180240534,
-0.0551415123,
0.0634871051,
-0.0175788607,
-0.0277567655,
-0.0527096428,
-0.0252656471,
-0.0090613337,
0.0585825853,
-0.0558306091,
-0.0459690168,
0.0584299378,
-0.0267513618,
-0.0054508098,
0.0109044882,
-0.0128464317,
-0.024463227,
0.072953023,
0.0001394545,
0.0122476434,
0.0080954758,
0.0247882456,
-0.0206552632,
-0.0131891891,
0.0091202538,
-0.0388503335,
-0.0039787902,
-0.0532986112,
0.0128646735,
-0.0297098868,
-0.0225662831,
-0.050014317,
-0.0681925118,
-0.0560420156,
0.0444580354,
0.0307157896,
-0.0285690539,
-0.0053352993,
0.0021443726,
0.0486083031,
-0.0031299817,
0.0154962931,
-0.000348791,
-0.0059588328,
0.0101946834,
0.0339170471,
0.0099743027,
0.0323939845,
-0.0461789891,
0.0020826487,
0.029310083,
0.0314702131,
0.0231647324,
-0.039732784,
-0.0170761961,
0.0103425933,
-0.0191810373,
-0.001306745,
-0.0077829645,
0.0592282191,
-0.0586970896,
-0.0007337673,
0.1078116447,
0.0334556326,
-0.0382536389,
0.0121420166,
-0.0018135161,
0.0112518687,
0.0547671728,
0.013545421,
-0.0903152972,
-0.0122917769,
0.0062019415,
0.0115819555,
-0.0175511762,
-0.0622033253,
-0.0253126696,
-0.1277326196,
0.0581361167,
0.0069996696,
-0.0232834108,
-0.0151076801,
-0.0798637196,
0.0140272584,
-0.0123340515,
-0.0410264395,
-0.0218069386,
0.0384153724,
0.0284646135,
0.0266933609,
0.000730143,
-0.0545051843,
0.051796075,
-0.045791328,
0.0948976949,
0.053905502,
0.0537243225,
0.0018690006,
-0.0625789836,
0.0319695137,
-0.0121323187,
-0.0236423481,
0.0043338262,
0.0498504266,
0.0018031856,
-0.0073634977,
-0.0114478711,
0.0413365327,
-0.0505263209,
-0.0257513281,
-0.0067881388,
0.0820294768,
-0.0012106135,
-0.0401970744,
0.0012893951,
0.0135831479,
0.0219848994,
0.1036281735,
0.0724261552,
-0.0390694961,
-0.0302836094,
-0.0723946989,
-0.0122322356,
-0.0769910812,
-0.0596690103,
0.0176534448,
-0.0136497151,
-0.0691175386,
-0.0257206839,
-0.036973767,
0.0593869053,
0.0183397662,
0.0173185132,
-0.0260523818,
-0.0030290161,
-0.0145308319,
-0.0444482155,
0.0545120612,
-0.06889797,
0.0180874672,
-0.02075487,
-0.0554232076,
-0.0093234731,
-0.0174539946,
-0.0199168511,
-0.001086476,
-0.05857943,
-0.0829540715,
0.0080923149,
-0.0083316118,
0.0261291396,
0.015940588,
0.0036899466,
-0.0891553834,
0.0318630822,
0.078696996,
-0.0139907561,
0.0005942713,
-0.0075904178,
0.0257479511,
0.0164483041,
0.0385190174,
-0.0104419049,
0.0392103232,
0.0474961586,
0.0380672291,
-0.0511795506,
0.0066566956,
0.0085085193,
0.0003325507,
0.0483379439,
-0.0485753715,
-0.0576695204,
-0.0297435746,
-0.0713062361,
-0.001092162,
-0.0546992198,
-0.010284517,
-0.0342456996,
-0.0058522848,
-0.0343520194,
-0.0117514888,
0.0309301037,
-0.052129887,
0.0607360303,
-0.0469783582,
0.013257443,
0.0177719761,
0.0256575439,
0.0038321556,
0.0013744525,
0.0015853123,
0.020400038,
-0.0284163933,
0.0386471972,
0.0130027765,
0.0207858626,
0.0152956126,
0.0145512503,
0.0235143304,
-0.0124587025,
-0.0323690325,
-0.0251731537,
0.0155907283,
0.0242115855,
0.0266554765,
0.0106376531,
0.0401386023,
-0.0008106832,
-0.0344582647,
-0.0182272848,
0.0236139577,
0.0001989613,
-0.0621669292,
0.0118609034,
0.0157766659,
-0.0640999824,
0.0132061727,
0.0714157,
-0.0012881852,
0.0190352071,
0.0116755553,
-0.0322767869,
-0.0046100612,
-0.0096929641,
-0.0181661751,
-0.0051812669,
0.0194225647,
0.031828288,
-0.0858813301,
-0.0676207989,
-0.0033970452,
0.0108474279,
-0.0066476045,
-0.0006423725,
0.0327365771,
0.0423259325,
-0.0540629812,
0.0344292186,
-0.0737801716,
0.0544841364,
-0.0269075874,
-0.0020790428,
-0.0214459337,
-6.744659651e-33,
-0.0109362435,
-0.0657126829,
0.0107483491,
-0.0086684423,
-0.0012020792,
-0.0060663638,
-0.0740531832,
0.0246696938,
-0.0110340631,
0.0616463087,
0.0119442018,
0.0014379007,
-0.0019041575,
0.0193578955,
0.0287016407,
-0.0160970017,
0.0199404731,
-0.0081573073,
-0.0460726656,
0.0310344938,
0.0310597755,
-0.0186335035,
0.0346584804,
-0.0752046928,
0.0466462411,
-0.0109958155,
0.0137589686,
0.0179807022,
0.0237752683,
0.0173792206,
-0.0184268411,
0.0475146361,
0.0462914594,
-0.0564264245,
0.0119424285,
0.0498106591,
-0.0417664573,
-0.0017216119,
0.0209098477,
-0.047888469,
-0.0355057195,
-0.0403104946,
0.0307922531,
-0.0045270384,
-0.0227732994,
0.009414806,
0.0452130847,
-0.0200305916,
0.0187726263,
-0.0409401096,
-0.0681155547,
0.0353487693,
-0.0284785293,
-0.0348002091,
-0.0104927728,
0.0342708826,
0.0037961234,
0.0888140425,
-0.0427027754,
0.0504477546,
0.0057843472,
0.0024674658,
0.0789653137,
0.0065470445,
-0.005517581,
0.0842003897,
0.0092465254,
0.0313137211,
-0.0751838982,
0.0229810905,
0.0210988894,
0.022375349,
0.0616687872,
0.0836530402,
0.0245893113,
-0.0044883862,
-0.0455965549,
0.0217250679,
0.0320447125,
-0.0333347246,
0.0104497531,
-0.0072115329,
-0.0154168736,
-0.0336881019,
-0.0425270721,
-0.0632732362,
-0.0366957486,
0.0045429808,
0.0036881852,
-0.0239970069,
-0.047655005,
0.0194001999,
0.0177157447,
-0.0251303744,
0.0067625497,
-0.0020760747,
0.0000683343,
0.0153465411,
0.019888211,
-0.0031886946,
-0.0819615424,
-0.0091924565,
0.0006549216,
0.0395047218,
0.0354986712,
0.0006834753,
0.0607098117,
0.0163457375,
-0.0415518135,
-0.0109082712,
-0.0615254939,
0.0170774776,
0.0030950832,
-0.0032794594,
0.0130592706,
0.0398438834,
-0.0009214756,
-0.003297488,
0.0415955707,
0.0096916659,
0.0309334137,
-0.0021668077,
-0.0357907973,
-0.0093758013,
-0.039763812,
-0.0253692418,
-0.0128731215,
0.0176726524,
0.0400966108,
-0.0408288091,
-0.0244617369,
-0.0257782768,
2.548e-7,
0.0541448332,
0.0667544752,
-0.0021777125,
-0.0045755808,
0.0094947712,
0.0382398814,
0.0195781738,
0.0049903891,
-0.0346431918,
-0.0536742471,
-0.0316645987,
0.0394056626,
0.0677062348,
0.0256840754,
-0.0725353584,
-0.0179459713,
-0.0587323569,
0.0077590593,
-0.0569768064,
0.0165625233,
0.0008654214,
0.0431151055,
0.0662112385,
-0.009360523,
0.0050141569,
-0.0138681037,
0.0592642464,
-0.0161453169,
-0.0183622949,
0.0318796262,
0.0010450922,
-0.0141665712,
0.0099203065,
0.0167716537,
0.0043608178,
-0.001503157,
-0.0101209749,
0.0393841155,
-0.0121496767,
-0.0125155961,
0.0025555422,
-0.0218625665,
-0.0017731208,
-0.0563744083,
0.0822657421,
-0.0374829248,
-0.0588608906,
-0.0411739349,
-0.0076668421,
0.0132743595,
0.0088195736,
-0.0255972687,
-0.0074442322,
-0.0153680481,
-0.0044660671,
-0.0292257834,
-0.003125092,
-0.0562984198,
-0.0226477571,
-0.0032595235,
-0.0500085242,
-0.0610524863,
0.0060733105,
0.0069639762,
0.0104432395,
-0.0482183173,
0.0170228314,
2.418241443e-34,
0.0422281511,
-0.0003632473,
-0.0121108368,
-0.0264858082,
0.0510838479,
0.022045318,
-0.0302141886,
-0.0270151421,
0.0382284224,
-0.0446974151,
-0.0070554521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05973v1 | HiPrompt: Few-Shot Biomedical Knowledge Fusion via Hierarchy-Oriented Prompting | 2023-04-12T16:54:26 | 2023-04-12T16:54:26 | Jiaying Lu, Jiaming Shen, Bo Xiong, Wenjing Ma, Steffen Staab, Carl Yang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Medical decision-making processes can be enhanced by comprehensive biomedical
knowledge bases, which require fusing knowledge graphs constructed from
different sources via a uniform index system. The index system often organizes
biomedical terms in a hierarchy to provide the aligned entities with
fine-grained granularity. To address the challenge of scarce supervision in the
biomedical knowledge fusion (BKF) task, researchers have proposed various
unsupervised methods. However, these methods heavily rely on ad-hoc lexical and
structural matching algorithms, which fail to capture the rich semantics
conveyed by biomedical entities and terms. Recently, neural embedding models
have proved effective in semantic-rich tasks, but they rely on sufficient
labeled data to be adequately trained. To bridge the gap between the
scarce-labeled BKF and neural embedding models, we propose HiPrompt, a
supervision-efficient knowledge fusion framework that elicits the few-shot
reasoning ability of large language models through hierarchy-oriented prompts.
Empirical results on the collected KG-Hi-BKF benchmark datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of HiPrompt. | [
0.0421272479,
0.0526120476,
0.0280692745,
-0.0060186079,
-0.0170001816,
0.0236669723,
-0.0318928733,
0.0268056057,
0.0500035882,
-0.0164354984,
-0.0185207706,
-0.0123087075,
0.022136841,
0.0145309363,
-0.0062063574,
-0.0203955211,
0.0489038751,
0.0466277972,
0.0075736707,
-0.0090044243,
-0.0224756207,
0.0187332612,
-0.034648519,
0.0274094343,
0.0018362548,
-0.0104464367,
0.0324314237,
-0.0063423072,
0.0504496992,
-0.0304233581,
0.0024985292,
0.0328536965,
0.0184450019,
0.0280565657,
0.0000018134,
-0.0247378089,
0.0015796503,
0.028881833,
-0.0392539464,
-0.0353337452,
0.0095698871,
-0.0466744341,
0.0111713288,
-0.0299996417,
-0.0242805798,
-0.0436962731,
0.0224981736,
0.0598225892,
0.0234155692,
0.0206983555,
-0.0053364146,
-0.0279128104,
0.0717908144,
-0.0205194671,
0.0003611549,
-0.0328122191,
0.0533813573,
-0.0257097259,
0.0393266603,
0.024338834,
0.007832408,
0.0367166027,
-0.0194284692,
0.0046843253,
0.0831685141,
0.0626094192,
-0.0214384422,
0.0074523361,
-0.0090373494,
0.1041315272,
-0.0197301116,
0.0007205768,
0.0174178425,
0.0010819695,
-0.0165586472,
0.0288710091,
-0.0416739061,
-0.0179766975,
-0.0190119352,
0.0000153265,
0.009946418,
-0.0081762336,
0.0472644903,
-0.0014739205,
-0.0221453439,
0.0371844582,
0.0244176742,
-0.0420223959,
0.0296229627,
-0.0040087244,
-0.0045803157,
-0.0497919098,
-0.013488438,
0.0429770872,
-0.048333481,
0.0072514364,
-0.010331112,
-0.0013646238,
0.060622558,
-0.0487618074,
-0.0259690937,
0.0246196464,
-0.0023181429,
0.0774860308,
-0.0642208606,
0.0034989994,
-0.0449640453,
0.0625203177,
-0.026241364,
-0.0151380561,
-0.105972521,
-0.0154643646,
0.021955451,
0.0417228229,
-0.0164460316,
-0.0275748111,
-0.0778276026,
-0.0011923658,
-0.0209673382,
0.0404705666,
0.0016778418,
0.0538382605,
0.0265577696,
0.0048407288,
-0.0633857772,
0.0215306077,
-0.0091177225,
0.0122235855,
-0.003280163,
0.0210390519,
-0.0046039401,
-0.0114930775,
-0.0011367726,
-0.0180396475,
0.0224846322,
0.0677954182,
0.001208803,
0.00061246,
-0.0305233505,
-0.0418481752,
-0.019769121,
-0.024286883,
0.0235908553,
-0.0520270877,
0.0954108536,
-0.0135119502,
-0.0108253183,
-0.0067313937,
0.0157571603,
-0.0007927113,
-0.0740355253,
0.0962034315,
-0.0746621266,
-0.028343657,
0.0089616841,
0.0205533039,
-0.0456268266,
0.0256239772,
-0.0209418032,
-0.0349333659,
-0.0166286044,
-0.0079403305,
-0.041890204,
-0.0401185006,
0.0341485515,
-0.0314307474,
-0.0121983141,
-0.0015805212,
-0.0053798649,
0.0803409517,
0.0085269734,
0.0274163969,
-0.0304498505,
0.0084986975,
-0.0003749476,
0.0774996877,
0.0038734684,
-0.0588516295,
0.0158767533,
-0.0266563352,
-0.0285467282,
-0.0123515576,
-0.0294715595,
0.0182476733,
-0.028017357,
0.0021873903,
0.0209829342,
0.0374777876,
-0.0241747983,
-0.0087153865,
-0.0128290104,
0.0063888589,
-0.0284356847,
0.0020981459,
0.0398158617,
-0.0013375407,
0.0208414402,
0.0388919748,
0.0769895911,
0.015567394,
0.0089693666,
-0.024554709,
-0.0168038867,
0.0698240027,
0.052007515,
-0.0272267368,
-0.0416501239,
-0.0010875732,
-0.0238444172,
0.0070154425,
-0.021118857,
-0.0486484952,
0.0005566078,
-0.0421535224,
-0.0485173911,
0.0135164605,
0.0135234054,
-0.0129946209,
-0.0174434595,
0.0009565768,
-0.0016696639,
-0.0401292853,
0.0134923747,
0.0268554278,
-0.0278843381,
0.0071595223,
0.0079969289,
0.0177282672,
0.0365797766,
0.0265259501,
-0.0061316378,
0.0499077141,
0.025305463,
-0.0396704376,
-0.0968973264,
-0.0619149692,
-0.0336501487,
-0.0893593132,
0.0534708723,
-0.0143147809,
-0.0359188691,
-0.0672895312,
-0.0506224073,
-0.0512391366,
-0.0293028746,
0.0115477759,
0.0225489233,
-0.0004059555,
0.0024428335,
0.0327556357,
-0.0339928009,
-0.0606083758,
0.1009903625,
-0.0285049342,
0.0158705637,
0.0328276195,
-0.0393641852,
0.0311608966,
0.0150148161,
-0.0067201792,
0.0065066214,
-0.0026923318,
-0.0023452458,
-0.0045840358,
-0.0132346181,
-0.0431953445,
0.0034500421,
-0.0900828689,
0.0290024448,
0.0621945001,
-0.0169627573,
-0.0113143707,
0.0057296739,
0.0445895754,
-0.0223866012,
-0.0595915243,
0.0123239579,
-0.0073724594,
0.0476547666,
0.0431983732,
0.0413783677,
0.0017625482,
-0.0096714618,
-0.028987607,
-0.0667443946,
0.0216155872,
-0.0051828013,
-0.0221135635,
0.0327730402,
-0.0377417319,
-0.0722203925,
0.0165064819,
-0.0065598879,
0.0060141981,
0.0243484527,
-0.0004114895,
0.0111697875,
0.0534053668,
-0.0312350169,
-0.0239094254,
0.0573173724,
0.0030475282,
-0.0382881463,
0.0164794028,
-0.0242569912,
-0.007022074,
0.027241664,
0.0282739699,
-0.0270927213,
0.0582791455,
0.0181927737,
-0.0113493958,
-0.0474109165,
-0.0082224859,
-0.0006850982,
0.0167321041,
-0.0954945907,
0.0084110023,
0.008751845,
0.04984143,
-0.0385259017,
0.0301997494,
0.1325932294,
0.0052650752,
0.0275915973,
-0.005416756,
-0.028079167,
-0.0428875275,
-0.0216625221,
-0.0038948448,
0.029299017,
0.0055641108,
0.0129265143,
-0.0386177786,
0.0195294339,
-0.0021092074,
-0.0333117172,
0.0222801864,
0.0039188522,
0.0441321023,
-0.0029131612,
-0.0578660667,
-0.0421528146,
0.0054469542,
-0.0263025872,
0.0306494758,
-0.000315235,
-0.021171933,
-0.0454107933,
-0.0095803067,
0.0147454394,
0.0451918691,
0.0325910114,
-0.0266423244,
-0.0316817574,
0.0401868373,
0.0432047099,
-0.0269622784,
0.0199522916,
0.0138956495,
0.0383974314,
0.053144291,
0.0381599143,
-0.0000333991,
0.0023666231,
0.0139843775,
0.01195841,
-0.0072384547,
-0.0053437185,
-0.017867079,
-0.0232917275,
-0.0178625677,
0.0419134051,
0.0875924677,
0.0289864801,
-0.0417286418,
0.0004966579,
-0.0059147407,
0.0067645418,
0.0167674515,
0.0256769173,
-0.0821984187,
-0.0342589729,
-0.0119185494,
-0.0048626941,
0.0011076013,
-0.0642669573,
0.0311866943,
-0.0809658542,
0.0005875003,
0.0094341906,
-0.0033309704,
-0.0183100346,
-0.0357162245,
0.0291560944,
-0.0067003407,
-0.023788454,
-0.0298315249,
0.0088192169,
-0.0334581025,
-0.0092605231,
-0.0065113436,
-0.0663163364,
0.0431082919,
-0.034114033,
0.0528614782,
0.0349021219,
0.0501255617,
0.0112212673,
-0.0381083675,
0.0035807714,
-0.0018747193,
-0.0303734187,
0.0094300425,
0.0457441807,
-0.0239800625,
-0.0086719254,
-0.050429929,
0.0285199918,
-0.0392059535,
-0.0159561913,
-0.0323244259,
0.1132077873,
0.0003667085,
-0.002039328,
-0.0727193132,
-0.0011445039,
0.0033874821,
0.0575647093,
-0.0244019069,
0.0013302988,
0.016350707,
0.0405391268,
0.0393789224,
0.0136759058,
0.0093649793,
0.0789033249,
-0.0353726819,
-0.000531491,
-0.0641110614,
-0.0026012436,
0.069648914,
-0.0085691828,
0.0232499037,
0.0461228192,
0.0074378732,
-0.0321963057,
-0.0339679979,
0.0535738729,
0.0059906212,
0.0092252661,
-0.0444315337,
-0.0116558624,
0.0452318117,
0.0226109028,
-0.0412477739,
0.0022515575,
0.0429902636,
-0.0632136315,
-0.0572574362,
0.0163017772,
0.0061885687,
0.0124189649,
-0.0411250815,
-0.0153417373,
0.0792395622,
0.0761143714,
-0.0633189008,
-0.037390098,
-0.0207125209,
-0.0209965147,
-0.0260960329,
0.0156069035,
-0.0500912555,
0.0135263959,
-0.0004042705,
0.0426194519,
-0.0416615903,
-0.0206054747,
0.0414090902,
0.0139492135,
0.0657034069,
-0.0493763536,
0.0339426845,
-0.0447314531,
-0.0033439568,
-0.0076113469,
-0.0098948991,
-0.0266144983,
-0.0266330168,
0.048494,
-0.0251013339,
0.0392659791,
-0.0081591597,
-0.0068786931,
0.0011532148,
0.004264486,
-0.0561152473,
0.0230584517,
-0.0031370721,
0.0447183549,
-0.003267552,
-0.0178597812,
0.0388889834,
-0.0071730688,
-0.0137087936,
-0.0519097075,
0.0316392742,
0.0587936379,
0.0195949525,
-0.0333783329,
0.0325770564,
-0.0540376417,
-0.0236548465,
0.0137197301,
-0.0241433587,
0.0649308935,
0.0112215858,
-0.023340134,
0.0021427185,
-0.0243571401,
-0.0086822184,
0.0034774235,
-0.0385169648,
0.0089160223,
0.0556669459,
0.033182282,
0.002152144,
-0.0078977449,
0.0741789192,
0.027631836,
0.0523440503,
-0.0012625045,
-0.0271213464,
-0.0394846164,
-0.0110403383,
0.0375887565,
0.0698652416,
-0.0522718802,
0.0357579477,
-0.0732644051,
-0.0383277871,
0.0275112838,
-0.0066231643,
-0.0884851068,
0.0420344099,
0.0494523384,
-0.0020584071,
0.0240487028,
-0.038678024,
0.0009792327,
0.0017139054,
-0.0423919819,
-0.0412515178,
0.0202811342,
-6.370039152e-33,
-0.0170958955,
-0.0307626631,
0.0261657424,
-0.0271527581,
-0.0021301603,
0.0201843493,
-0.0034979049,
-0.0149197718,
-0.0274282191,
0.0638110414,
-0.0294165574,
0.0013104267,
-0.0176892392,
0.0069407849,
0.0228076708,
-0.017534595,
0.010667921,
0.0394917279,
0.0246513505,
0.0093954485,
0.0527612977,
0.0370685682,
0.0070865289,
-0.0783968419,
-0.0114371078,
0.0304591246,
0.0433270521,
0.0510467142,
-0.0381334461,
0.0560168736,
-0.0342832394,
0.0605923459,
0.02345757,
0.0172796547,
-0.005113069,
0.0223599672,
-0.103011407,
-0.0461824313,
0.0124631841,
-0.0506781302,
-0.044956401,
-0.0343243927,
0.0285306312,
0.0014399108,
0.0297094658,
-0.0522340499,
0.0280935001,
-0.0368755683,
-0.0635903403,
-0.0460048839,
-0.0416886769,
0.0199915804,
0.0397894941,
0.0142499711,
-0.0103903739,
-0.0120175881,
0.0150799481,
0.0391795039,
-0.0428527482,
-0.0052581667,
0.0119749233,
0.0151003702,
0.0025895494,
0.0151555631,
0.0012027069,
0.0825417638,
-0.0164510366,
-0.0156245027,
-0.0207016598,
0.0078515513,
-0.0217481162,
0.0573032498,
0.0246366318,
0.0319264345,
0.0291315019,
0.0166089982,
-0.0848049596,
0.0226173121,
-0.0183983613,
0.040994823,
-0.0213010516,
0.0042035202,
-0.0310153905,
-0.033217255,
-0.0372236893,
0.013304783,
-0.0499083586,
-0.0235158298,
0.0077232793,
-0.0011429312,
0.0196189508,
0.0177641287,
-0.0157582406,
-0.0444728471,
0.0168526582,
0.0211477261,
0.0617084578,
-0.0115711335,
-0.0113676582,
0.0121221524,
-0.0717441738,
-0.0256621242,
0.0484887324,
-0.0253303014,
0.044870276,
0.0506686568,
0.0564096197,
-0.0385347307,
-0.0024387804,
-0.0202003159,
-0.0044943402,
-0.0320405774,
-0.037485119,
-0.0175793413,
0.0303706061,
0.0620026663,
0.0026273881,
0.0392460488,
0.0193218682,
0.0266309641,
0.0003769935,
0.0285707023,
0.0063769976,
0.0166488905,
-0.0010095757,
-0.0041115973,
-0.0391502567,
0.0187686663,
0.0228046365,
-0.0539784133,
-0.0118598435,
0.0030641428,
2.844e-7,
0.0365672037,
0.0187201537,
-0.0037653209,
-0.0473713987,
0.0099823382,
0.0252533127,
-0.0210234355,
0.0004625429,
-0.0491517484,
-0.0789847597,
0.0265563466,
-0.0068043526,
0.0015165905,
0.0363853201,
-0.0710708648,
-0.044329606,
-0.0877364576,
-0.0449224934,
-0.0360328667,
-0.0287418328,
0.0690053254,
0.0594945736,
0.0221341662,
-0.0438223593,
0.0306421071,
-0.0005771595,
0.0550514311,
0.0206252225,
0.0030795324,
0.0266281702,
-0.0048689931,
0.0207497664,
0.0110259587,
0.0869402364,
-0.0097850347,
0.0012354387,
0.0281868633,
0.0445254222,
-0.0574118905,
0.0004824448,
0.0067131752,
-0.0023293849,
0.0135612544,
-0.0262216702,
0.0659612343,
-0.111310035,
-0.0301548578,
0.0168368537,
-0.0373268984,
0.0174215566,
0.0376401506,
-0.0022758846,
-0.0151772825,
-0.0068215271,
0.0204447787,
0.0480909683,
-0.0191095006,
-0.1064947173,
0.0289856698,
0.0904140919,
-0.0084833819,
-0.0328192376,
0.0211847071,
-0.0017490719,
0.0397511274,
-0.0716907382,
-0.0021220066,
2.571999548e-34,
0.0096647246,
0.0095229028,
0.0209270418,
-0.0049619433,
0.0202625114,
-0.0169855617,
-0.0447979681,
-0.0065529486,
0.0255220234,
-0.0686932057,
0.0234832559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05970v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05970v1 | Boosted Prompt Ensembles for Large Language Models | 2023-04-12T16:47:15 | 2023-04-12T16:47:15 | Silviu Pitis, Michael R. Zhang, Andrew Wang, Jimmy Ba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Methods such as chain-of-thought prompting and self-consistency have pushed
the frontier of language model reasoning performance with no additional
training. To further improve performance, we propose a prompt ensembling method
for large language models, which uses a small dataset to construct a set of few
shot prompts that together comprise a ``boosted prompt ensemble''. The few shot
examples for each prompt are chosen in a stepwise fashion to be ``hard''
examples on which the previous step's ensemble is uncertain. We show that this
outperforms single-prompt output-space ensembles and bagged prompt-space
ensembles on the GSM8k and AQuA datasets, among others. We propose both
train-time and test-time versions of boosted prompting that use different
levels of available annotation and conduct a detailed empirical study of our
algorithm. | [
0.021255279,
0.0569460355,
-0.0045523802,
0.0257227682,
-0.0524979606,
0.0307642426,
0.0356639735,
-0.0236352868,
-0.0006547624,
-0.0414359719,
-0.0177623183,
-0.0748399943,
0.0162548497,
0.0019492271,
0.0241308101,
-0.0236402079,
0.0434176475,
-0.0824214965,
-0.0161446035,
-0.0420286693,
-0.0331302844,
0.0067114499,
-0.0197783541,
0.0339977704,
0.0294004288,
-0.0444193967,
-0.0567489378,
0.0034491983,
-0.0114756525,
-0.0310992654,
-0.0250744559,
0.1034901589,
-0.0101096937,
0.0769694671,
0.0000020311,
-0.0619917959,
-0.0207225438,
-0.0233406797,
-0.0885911286,
-0.0019804521,
-0.0195529032,
0.0262445416,
0.0039410242,
0.0241342597,
-0.0021960079,
0.0007662368,
0.0317900218,
0.0168167055,
0.0639615953,
0.0639682785,
0.0185675155,
0.0018790584,
-0.0099036573,
-0.0321303159,
-0.0012901515,
-0.0100837443,
0.0168720428,
-0.0450308882,
0.0341473185,
0.0490562357,
-0.0020735371,
0.0509986654,
0.0188878123,
-0.0269403663,
-0.0069863759,
0.0223920364,
-0.0400814489,
-0.0202001091,
-0.0191025306,
0.0611183643,
0.0222733151,
-0.018973032,
-0.0375314765,
-0.0211231522,
0.0053552878,
0.0204257388,
-0.0188657288,
0.047015287,
-0.02519021,
0.0291122664,
0.0126479669,
0.0068993196,
0.0481066965,
0.0024116957,
-0.0108625265,
0.1335337311,
0.0188492276,
-0.0390184335,
0.0167211425,
0.0357377306,
-0.013359081,
-0.0694094747,
-0.0305602308,
0.0162587017,
-0.0657553077,
0.0283708107,
-0.0224249419,
0.0162749588,
0.0149139836,
0.0417416766,
0.0481019169,
0.0358903445,
-0.0308209974,
0.0658173263,
-0.018470617,
0.0222396553,
0.0121025732,
-0.0177379847,
-0.0407726578,
-0.006751888,
-0.0445324033,
0.0001252181,
-0.05031012,
0.0022488432,
-0.0124484152,
-0.0051685842,
-0.0322363824,
0.0028209819,
0.0144212339,
0.0402213708,
0.0234197434,
-0.0125179514,
-0.0189187378,
-0.0116639351,
-0.0110927895,
0.0000858793,
-0.0340344608,
0.0093391435,
0.0450195558,
-0.0737067461,
-0.02421505,
-0.0137291113,
-0.0352508686,
-0.0389845371,
0.0031497336,
-0.0041815778,
0.0039314004,
-0.057308048,
0.0017185328,
-0.0095629171,
-0.0345605165,
-0.0626716092,
-0.0179133471,
-0.063557744,
0.0352744684,
0.0097729545,
-0.0056405207,
-0.0145717841,
0.0005829344,
0.0073770005,
-0.0011007767,
0.0922261253,
-0.0401115045,
0.0309156701,
0.0105656255,
-0.0035357093,
-0.0359505564,
0.0836527124,
-0.0204407908,
0.0180629957,
0.0307823066,
0.0069753481,
0.0129320519,
0.0430226065,
0.0223037098,
0.0081716506,
-0.041939225,
0.0120521821,
0.0285603311,
0.0268336367,
-0.011863092,
0.0255733021,
-0.0146637866,
0.0056152567,
0.0421823487,
0.029051939,
-0.0008626728,
-0.030902531,
0.0288400277,
-0.027473947,
0.0208741501,
0.0065762093,
-0.0576683544,
0.0074389372,
-0.0637557954,
0.0062580104,
0.0558146834,
0.0336311162,
-0.0234182533,
-0.0228969995,
-0.0153296692,
0.0119014373,
-0.0489178188,
0.0411023684,
0.0517228991,
0.0005431263,
-0.0258761495,
0.0354012698,
0.024209965,
-0.0299958177,
-0.0279335938,
-0.0538939238,
0.0565407984,
0.0696277544,
0.0403852053,
-0.0024164256,
-0.0141256927,
-0.0266217664,
0.0423259102,
0.0306173712,
0.0112947803,
-0.02394915,
0.016592389,
-0.0278665312,
-0.0174331944,
0.0162231121,
0.0180465095,
0.0229858942,
0.0248345472,
-0.0086490093,
-0.0089006172,
0.0168025382,
0.01106562,
0.0316324085,
0.0063743158,
-0.0291808303,
0.0362832025,
0.0105451895,
0.0192986876,
0.0205828138,
-0.0119863944,
0.0105688116,
0.009081631,
-0.0376725867,
-0.0357652716,
-0.0144455684,
-0.0551350378,
-0.0975736007,
0.0415264219,
0.0592736863,
-0.0499100722,
-0.0354610234,
-0.0419432633,
-0.0610472076,
-0.0374366716,
0.0139868716,
-0.0015054279,
-0.0465107895,
0.054017216,
-0.020022355,
0.0281619374,
-0.0430385321,
0.0720846951,
-0.0036467919,
0.0462156571,
0.015822852,
0.0761059597,
0.0127484389,
-0.0701782778,
-0.048008129,
0.0523893051,
0.0103026228,
-0.0295320079,
0.0116253449,
-0.0318279266,
-0.0566215143,
-0.0077605778,
-0.0908962935,
-0.0083156377,
-0.0288452134,
-0.0009626347,
-0.0019996767,
0.0012593671,
-0.0264631007,
-0.0322093554,
-0.0035778,
-0.020835625,
0.0293282215,
0.0387253463,
0.0217021052,
-0.0061467914,
-0.0216903277,
-0.0113846408,
-0.0326688439,
-0.0149168596,
0.0619105101,
0.0085746627,
-0.0305403043,
-0.0880997255,
-0.0259341449,
-0.0361573026,
-0.0077581452,
0.0010051192,
0.0066289105,
0.0346172713,
-0.039235767,
0.0405354351,
0.0600808449,
0.0066480087,
-0.0027111557,
0.0773622617,
0.0208441745,
-0.0381414667,
-0.0060284133,
-0.0164225958,
-0.0180210546,
0.0240603164,
-0.0075718998,
-0.0022386182,
0.0556149594,
-0.0159400832,
-0.0177028514,
-0.0384810232,
0.0128378384,
-0.0092217196,
-0.0098363766,
-0.0830762684,
-0.0316474065,
-0.014975667,
0.0801704973,
-0.0062326915,
-0.0548589453,
0.0917502567,
-0.0504777469,
-0.0212127268,
-0.0404327288,
-0.0105919363,
-0.0076792939,
0.0726722404,
-0.0090452787,
-0.002075,
0.0656510592,
-0.0034825369,
-0.0094127273,
-0.014444543,
0.0193423815,
-0.0261260252,
0.0310625769,
-0.0248784628,
0.0413318686,
0.0050261957,
-0.052424375,
-0.0690121502,
-0.0716890469,
-0.043210689,
0.0117668519,
-0.0129006505,
0.001888598,
-0.0095545435,
-0.0030376208,
0.0023176977,
0.0303741861,
-0.0373733789,
0.0017279207,
-0.0130084977,
0.0359940901,
0.0346389003,
0.0082104867,
0.0263392143,
-0.0531059131,
0.0861131251,
0.0105239125,
0.0276523735,
0.0315854773,
-0.0324048251,
0.0241233464,
0.0309592206,
-0.0153715303,
-0.0271193292,
0.0267337374,
0.0646043196,
-0.0335523486,
-0.0179654118,
0.1343778372,
0.0472805053,
-0.0476876423,
-0.0046139322,
-0.0189717691,
0.0351966619,
0.0294664484,
0.0525037721,
-0.0474065728,
-0.0451656468,
0.0430187583,
0.0131458202,
-0.0062509398,
-0.0410733111,
-0.021500038,
-0.126977697,
0.0460379571,
-0.0061463495,
-0.048982095,
0.0241626706,
-0.0666127056,
0.006155367,
0.003398651,
0.01431455,
0.0491931923,
0.0119116288,
0.0198714044,
0.0092215249,
0.0030662259,
-0.0711483955,
0.0337697156,
-0.0409948602,
0.0850960836,
0.0615496039,
-0.0238605607,
0.0109180482,
-0.0168052968,
0.0089394609,
-0.0034521183,
0.0004184081,
0.0008453791,
0.0407491326,
0.0059178141,
-0.0103567904,
0.0026945963,
0.0302375071,
-0.0199101157,
-0.0256363936,
0.0245741419,
0.0826090276,
-0.037563201,
-0.0058108042,
0.0061565186,
-0.0150327431,
0.0375399329,
0.0947682187,
0.0194492377,
-0.0277266204,
-0.0088957818,
-0.0426096842,
-0.0250393599,
-0.0144947348,
0.0150090819,
0.0369904377,
0.0232249927,
0.0016310287,
-0.0445638821,
-0.0351852514,
0.0673667341,
0.0624821782,
-0.0124894669,
0.052577205,
-0.0681252554,
0.0265381429,
-0.0059453193,
0.052224908,
-0.027916545,
0.0343541652,
-0.057232298,
-0.0026010531,
0.0051581757,
-0.0078835888,
-0.0207048487,
0.0082032587,
-0.0472601354,
-0.0733026713,
-0.0020163618,
0.0373613909,
0.0260178931,
0.0392196439,
-0.0214254074,
-0.044847846,
0.0434825793,
0.0676493123,
0.0220009722,
-0.0033481924,
0.0068121566,
0.0095175086,
-0.009970922,
0.0560047328,
-0.0267884843,
0.0174814779,
-0.0007998805,
0.0507820286,
-0.0167642422,
-0.0233772062,
0.0356782787,
0.0273598507,
0.0672889724,
-0.0644668862,
-0.0251753405,
-0.0314393379,
0.0168703981,
-0.022600105,
-0.0340529196,
-0.0185322333,
0.0408428386,
0.0252069291,
-0.0452901796,
0.0150165269,
-0.032558348,
-0.0081540318,
0.0393586233,
-0.0289318059,
-0.0027932113,
0.0238762386,
0.0293668676,
0.046390567,
-0.0064340984,
-0.005921586,
0.0121781202,
0.0129058668,
0.0209403839,
-0.0111917844,
0.0668137074,
0.0561184101,
0.018412102,
-0.0360087082,
0.0159421191,
-0.0793259367,
-0.0593011528,
0.0013187227,
0.0496579967,
0.0435752273,
-0.0158532523,
0.0051767812,
-0.0147952586,
-0.033372324,
-0.0153149078,
0.0176936369,
0.0266185813,
-0.0475376844,
0.0497267023,
0.0241171885,
-0.0288556423,
0.0339727961,
0.0523022041,
-0.0447726548,
0.0227495283,
0.0238767229,
0.0228012409,
-0.0423589498,
-0.0156288538,
-0.0404586419,
0.0328015201,
-0.0268280469,
0.0275275279,
-0.0393014103,
-0.056073565,
-0.0154228806,
0.0291508567,
-0.0219155271,
0.0128582781,
0.0241378732,
0.074019745,
0.0028582553,
0.0161207002,
-0.0498804711,
-0.00185413,
-0.0148827797,
-0.0216685142,
-0.0185837038,
-6.295680318e-33,
-0.0364191458,
-0.0026843254,
0.0176039413,
-0.051016435,
0.0102023454,
-0.0065996158,
-0.0393913314,
0.0128608607,
-0.0125595853,
0.0052430369,
-0.0515518785,
0.0014636515,
0.0157527849,
0.0289729331,
0.0310140196,
-0.0011192757,
0.0603070743,
-0.0063222405,
-0.0524363779,
0.0099949697,
0.0502216965,
0.0332361162,
0.0022009721,
0.0052267024,
0.0463583767,
-0.0251835305,
-0.0273896307,
0.0402092561,
-0.028105706,
0.0315525606,
-0.0297062099,
0.006789051,
-0.003714862,
-0.0693041012,
-0.0179375559,
0.023998918,
-0.0640237853,
-0.0306525771,
0.0006057298,
-0.0061520645,
-0.0499147512,
-0.004645214,
-0.0142575586,
-0.0192253198,
-0.0100620352,
-0.0043587466,
-0.0108611872,
-0.0260012504,
-0.0262674931,
0.0194815621,
-0.0013929977,
0.0184566826,
0.0001529177,
-0.0221895576,
0.0305670556,
0.0544134155,
-0.0064242515,
0.0409814753,
-0.0020864604,
0.0108654955,
0.0341908298,
0.0299805254,
0.063651152,
0.0291983802,
-0.0079409657,
0.0649863854,
0.0346127935,
-0.0368191339,
-0.0543692149,
-0.0016338933,
-0.0010077346,
0.0083029298,
0.0510767624,
0.0186809022,
0.0432863981,
0.0141969612,
-0.0394307636,
0.0267948899,
0.0744226426,
-0.0404848084,
0.0175306704,
-0.0071646087,
-0.0402720422,
-0.0443675742,
-0.0485514998,
-0.0641374215,
-0.0435618795,
-0.0291801244,
0.0368867926,
-0.0090835011,
-0.0353232995,
-0.0237547141,
0.0519885309,
-0.0214286819,
-0.054816898,
0.021798417,
-0.0114780609,
0.0001688148,
0.0191114619,
0.0457759909,
-0.0206786804,
0.0002888369,
0.0186980758,
0.0052241534,
0.006539633,
0.0146301966,
0.0524143986,
0.0229359809,
-0.0656229407,
0.0043168883,
-0.0382243507,
0.0229807571,
-0.0198261198,
0.0191270839,
0.0314970538,
0.0186846294,
0.0062051988,
0.0558508895,
0.0048526176,
-0.0256874282,
-0.0083472542,
-0.0185125712,
-0.0193101205,
0.0084564537,
-0.005370005,
0.0013005279,
-0.0129593415,
0.0073666014,
0.0420918725,
-0.0251117516,
0.0139193693,
0.0340162255,
2.636e-7,
0.0269754659,
0.0385892242,
0.0072871898,
-0.0001089731,
0.0048352377,
0.0151570542,
-0.0574292056,
-0.0245818477,
0.0225340184,
-0.044347629,
-0.0096587669,
0.0237929411,
0.0539452471,
0.0436787605,
-0.1031144857,
-0.004809774,
-0.0851310045,
-0.0005492163,
-0.0697414279,
-0.0050643967,
0.0493760854,
0.1161220297,
0.0316822082,
-0.0340093784,
-0.0051204627,
-0.012385359,
0.0352764167,
-0.0197425392,
0.0217682458,
0.0016080115,
0.0396135636,
-0.0093082869,
0.0018959682,
0.0530618131,
0.0079897661,
0.0211411603,
-0.0153714428,
0.0282292645,
0.0241028629,
0.0060233246,
-0.0378568135,
-0.0033719812,
0.0097060353,
-0.0701231211,
0.0986733362,
-0.0315141492,
-0.0320558175,
-0.0559393018,
-0.0044520954,
-0.0349840447,
0.0412140973,
0.0047119656,
-0.0009137477,
0.0299692117,
-0.0040585129,
-0.0065956837,
-0.0059507145,
-0.0890037268,
-0.0391768776,
-0.0040490231,
-0.0294143669,
-0.0417861231,
-0.0122939097,
0.0161777362,
0.0163199864,
-0.0895616934,
0.0033844362,
2.56428307e-34,
0.0499517508,
-0.013416131,
0.0142349657,
0.0407710075,
0.0118306465,
-0.0337632261,
0.0059183817,
0.0004827066,
0.0155881345,
-0.0867646337,
-0.0179373622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05967v1 | Angler: Helping Machine Translation Practitioners Prioritize Model Improvements | 2023-04-12T16:43:39 | 2023-04-12T16:43:39 | Samantha Robertson, Zijie J. Wang, Dominik Moritz, Mary Beth Kery, Fred Hohman | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Machine learning (ML) models can fail in unexpected ways in the real world,
but not all model failures are equal. With finite time and resources, ML
practitioners are forced to prioritize their model debugging and improvement
efforts. Through interviews with 13 ML practitioners at Apple, we found that
practitioners construct small targeted test sets to estimate an error's nature,
scope, and impact on users. We built on this insight in a case study with
machine translation models, and developed Angler, an interactive visual
analytics tool to help practitioners prioritize model improvements. In a user
study with 7 machine translation experts, we used Angler to understand
prioritization practices when the input space is infinite, and obtaining
reliable signals of model quality is expensive. Our study revealed that
participants could form more interesting and user-focused hypotheses for
prioritization by analyzing quantitative summary statistics and qualitatively
assessing data by reading sentences. | [
0.0284034014,
0.0735829547,
-0.0363406353,
0.0136507824,
0.0039344565,
0.019940611,
0.0138059277,
0.0082281195,
-0.047892835,
-0.0127449566,
0.0319940709,
0.0411156826,
0.0429862626,
0.0218598526,
0.0131479185,
-0.0684080571,
0.0228757374,
-0.0010483462,
-0.0006479495,
0.0356200263,
-0.0024737325,
0.0280469526,
-0.0086723026,
0.0756292418,
0.0149571542,
-0.0226723775,
-0.0048573366,
0.0199796278,
0.0152960075,
-0.0301536396,
-0.0264618564,
0.0318922475,
-0.0268586669,
0.0421361737,
0.0000022834,
-0.0360945724,
-0.0129171535,
0.0367854834,
-0.0542347655,
0.0438527502,
0.0567861497,
-0.0235121492,
-0.0051370645,
0.0259527192,
-0.0337419435,
0.0258862954,
0.040573705,
-0.0185337774,
0.0504842512,
0.0039492231,
-0.0118989022,
0.0150903622,
-0.0164892673,
-0.0015398568,
0.0085742576,
-0.0451269113,
-0.0312831365,
0.054250963,
0.0008971767,
-0.0044336864,
0.0147995735,
0.0398620144,
0.0132492315,
-0.0229926798,
0.0180358458,
0.0213811602,
0.0190351177,
-0.0842531398,
0.0065500289,
0.0305551849,
-0.0255223513,
0.0128912004,
-0.0353017896,
-0.063408047,
0.0205836669,
0.0092485184,
-0.0140308784,
-0.0331140645,
-0.0263639335,
-0.0400902219,
-0.0356576107,
-0.0094273873,
-0.0019390937,
0.0181396659,
-0.0797609091,
-0.0272354651,
-0.0353480689,
-0.0127798049,
0.0358314477,
0.0301624481,
0.0006209063,
-0.0202411208,
0.0346565358,
-0.011437838,
-0.0436246768,
0.0046519027,
0.0269031487,
-0.0513210371,
0.027695952,
-0.0685757548,
0.0511996634,
0.0265538171,
-0.012594386,
0.0098655066,
0.0352775343,
0.0228036679,
0.0014882738,
0.0109785032,
-0.0131673468,
0.0309035033,
-0.0231163446,
0.0103965746,
-0.0197590794,
-0.0544676743,
0.0002148988,
0.0320067741,
-0.018067304,
0.0144735249,
-0.0198004022,
0.0278572738,
-0.0211664364,
0.0087166894,
-0.0151187247,
0.0115249902,
-0.031600412,
0.0356327444,
-0.0350952633,
0.0048829135,
0.0004334568,
-0.0624138191,
-0.0077577247,
0.0020706714,
-0.047907941,
-0.0003645888,
-0.0104334615,
0.0397963077,
0.0084468871,
0.0173380822,
0.002147201,
-0.0530112423,
-0.0031743667,
-0.0160162766,
-0.0497194901,
-0.0366709121,
-0.0146380085,
0.059721645,
0.0211580731,
-0.048034925,
-0.014717279,
0.017576905,
-0.0293298662,
0.073269777,
-0.0244528316,
0.0142370015,
0.0164702628,
0.0256193578,
-0.0153640732,
0.0439269915,
0.0169606339,
0.0312718637,
0.013506799,
-0.0391132012,
0.0418485105,
0.0090000741,
-0.0170237739,
0.0228630137,
-0.0424860194,
0.0167168938,
-0.0589924715,
0.0276402608,
0.0019980704,
0.0055642198,
-0.027002804,
0.040793173,
0.0296166334,
0.0375924036,
0.0314126424,
0.0196001045,
0.0253516603,
-0.0059640734,
-0.0196112357,
-0.0194932632,
-0.0155831724,
0.0166630205,
-0.0146155758,
-0.0139202932,
-0.0234080125,
0.0404575989,
0.0256085675,
-0.0747404248,
-0.0376793332,
0.0289260186,
-0.0088702347,
0.0240695421,
0.0503011383,
0.0231115464,
-0.0218378827,
0.0120917475,
-0.034691792,
-0.0614673793,
-0.0573540069,
-0.0226062778,
0.0031219835,
0.082050994,
0.0274347048,
-0.0394441783,
-0.0290023014,
-0.0133518223,
-0.0180946235,
-0.0148344282,
0.0936048254,
0.0128026409,
-0.0137651796,
-0.0035457886,
-0.0492504723,
0.0199259128,
0.0119654285,
0.0065028761,
0.013783263,
0.0457255058,
0.0288840998,
-0.0650895014,
-0.1352275908,
0.0372899137,
-0.0033869792,
0.0260546934,
0.0143227754,
0.0125991777,
0.022643676,
0.0363429151,
-0.0088817021,
0.0194251668,
0.0430769138,
0.0196333062,
0.0000703737,
0.0506334752,
0.0258892495,
0.0410001464,
0.011661279,
-0.0600418821,
-0.0509514473,
-0.0008641207,
-0.0718336776,
0.009704073,
-0.0056198798,
-0.0350735933,
-0.024263218,
0.0198542047,
0.0331518315,
-0.0461954363,
-0.026479356,
-0.0540391579,
0.0288199559,
0.0089894291,
-0.0059177,
-0.0139192026,
-0.0128634954,
0.0119413435,
-0.0331271738,
0.0197059885,
0.0551987067,
0.0124200843,
0.0355918966,
0.0435625613,
0.0193409659,
-0.0488137975,
-0.0033490036,
-0.0802362263,
-0.0442638211,
0.0019836123,
0.0405863971,
0.0042491937,
0.0166366305,
-0.0160962287,
-0.0227001179,
0.0191572458,
-0.0516610704,
-0.0025127872,
0.0158150066,
0.0334336795,
0.0121988701,
0.0233683046,
-0.0419203117,
-0.0010155768,
-0.0242731031,
0.0486931391,
0.0712823421,
-0.0073032612,
-0.0809707269,
0.014605605,
-0.0034143555,
-0.0412633941,
0.0113564124,
0.0240634698,
0.0392224304,
0.0066601369,
-0.0169984847,
0.0443564691,
-0.0252580512,
0.1033413634,
0.0254343823,
0.0290435459,
-0.0626133531,
-0.0103266304,
0.0438841656,
-0.0182454716,
0.0231840815,
-0.0709043592,
0.035328608,
-0.0010657434,
-0.0160231069,
0.0044673304,
-0.0160688926,
0.0779378712,
-0.0449431688,
-0.0138684679,
-0.0421316698,
-0.0173851419,
0.0206612349,
0.0797213838,
-0.0039111464,
-0.0608435385,
0.0508663207,
-0.0118948678,
0.0108722197,
-0.0642148331,
-0.0415318161,
-0.0254339576,
0.0597455129,
-0.0500178076,
0.021642454,
-0.0222114362,
-0.0030290571,
0.001325635,
0.0081309378,
0.0312002916,
-0.0239640456,
0.034999907,
-0.0611160845,
-0.0217374675,
0.0057253232,
0.0167464111,
-0.0121384794,
-0.0370217822,
-0.0701624081,
-0.0560595691,
0.0409701578,
-0.0286900606,
-0.0316299684,
-0.0094797509,
0.0414435528,
0.0238701962,
0.0261297114,
-0.0642500073,
0.0300231874,
-0.0364344865,
-0.0473254621,
0.0002917994,
0.049904488,
-0.0815542564,
0.047305543,
0.0299954489,
0.0370734185,
-0.0226452481,
-0.0684403703,
-0.0254234988,
0.0054642609,
-0.0023090565,
0.0067499988,
0.0108169392,
0.0341895558,
-0.0331530981,
0.0185992047,
0.0450173058,
0.0456783809,
-0.0569281988,
0.0368047431,
-0.0308849774,
0.0407550186,
0.0422489606,
0.0499330945,
-0.0839327052,
-0.0131533267,
0.0236481111,
0.0861087069,
-0.0138939619,
0.0041063451,
-0.0067142397,
-0.0469177775,
0.0465428829,
0.0089823194,
-0.0296987537,
-0.0407949723,
-0.0384833179,
-0.0340821594,
-0.0540560223,
0.0570610613,
0.0060839038,
-0.0012361738,
0.0216558371,
0.0220067576,
-0.0278644282,
-0.0797058269,
0.0104355952,
0.0020357906,
-0.0314592868,
0.066893436,
0.0155286416,
0.0107094031,
-0.014321059,
0.0231745727,
0.0248487405,
0.050806243,
-0.0393093936,
0.0839347318,
0.0373080969,
-0.0027719054,
-0.0005609866,
-0.0219124146,
-0.0071032299,
0.0102756023,
0.0423236266,
0.0181777328,
-0.0295748934,
-0.0041841641,
-0.003143318,
-0.0197819062,
-0.0171010401,
0.0027356786,
0.0800345019,
-0.0416151956,
-0.0096742064,
-0.057495743,
0.013403398,
-0.0411033109,
-0.0444627851,
0.0106449891,
-0.0258329157,
-0.0542200543,
-0.0286733918,
-0.0478775501,
0.0441388041,
0.0303910766,
0.0182309505,
-0.0330295116,
0.0114338072,
0.0038778468,
-0.0214435775,
0.0733331218,
0.0428792536,
0.0524407327,
-0.0107669355,
0.0100199506,
0.0004602746,
0.0267057419,
-0.0065270402,
0.0517359935,
-0.0381926224,
-0.0455509797,
-0.0149535183,
0.0624288842,
0.0324632451,
-0.0154559035,
-0.0272360202,
-0.0845589563,
-0.0309560206,
0.0444103219,
-0.0330107771,
-0.0441168658,
0.0061370754,
-0.0189024117,
-0.0289233718,
-0.0344941802,
-0.0010052855,
-0.0149264932,
-0.0274658781,
-0.0044926968,
-0.0558679998,
-0.0562239997,
0.0258801226,
0.0260925498,
0.0427874401,
-0.0136661306,
-0.0529676378,
-0.0125487568,
0.0094026737,
0.0046075727,
-0.0197853465,
-0.0376196764,
0.0006873183,
0.0062457663,
-0.0487779602,
0.0279986262,
0.0090259472,
-0.0433416106,
-0.0630822107,
-0.0541975386,
0.0535851493,
-0.013638299,
0.045738034,
0.0374879576,
0.0117526483,
-0.0266752634,
-0.0096983174,
-0.0161786638,
0.0477845073,
0.0177636407,
0.0499269664,
-0.0121266609,
0.0436581559,
0.0348654538,
0.03831001,
-0.0249739233,
-0.1076911762,
0.0055283047,
-0.0057213125,
0.0252600964,
0.0114399735,
0.0725931674,
-0.0020070972,
-0.0063455659,
-0.001634764,
0.0153021878,
0.0000423593,
0.0310510285,
-0.0360408388,
0.0098766098,
-0.0201353915,
-0.0416197814,
0.0505256541,
-0.02300887,
0.0086468766,
-0.0449836664,
-0.0568393916,
-0.0132340342,
-0.0030110974,
0.0437784903,
-0.0268600844,
-0.0188864712,
-0.056254331,
-0.0901063085,
-0.0705996975,
-0.0339664631,
0.0068768933,
0.0113659035,
-0.0329817496,
-0.0039021329,
0.09048637,
-0.0300143007,
0.0118910633,
-0.0237105004,
0.0041994797,
-0.0198755451,
-0.0259288885,
-0.030767275,
-6.105806389e-33,
-0.0104733305,
-0.088041462,
-0.0051587373,
-0.0463862307,
0.0330518335,
-0.0205834191,
-0.0181835517,
0.0510363914,
-0.0048320149,
0.022117069,
-0.0076285829,
0.018129997,
-0.0002064366,
-0.0396292359,
0.0589973889,
0.0443127453,
0.0616080314,
0.0463654473,
-0.0307930745,
0.0093260631,
-0.0397025906,
0.0091469949,
-0.0009205624,
-0.1098039374,
0.0611085147,
0.0481408462,
-0.0020681075,
0.0012547554,
-0.0270519573,
0.0369940065,
0.0348255374,
0.0220408794,
0.0064164386,
-0.0400959179,
-0.0529673137,
-0.0526079908,
-0.0239953604,
0.0055395393,
0.008333616,
0.0259745922,
-0.0217682347,
-0.0156803168,
0.0531334355,
-0.0037877799,
-0.0232250895,
0.0157187339,
0.0398465097,
-0.0108963959,
-0.0437433831,
0.0336340964,
-0.0378229916,
0.0387354419,
-0.0774996132,
0.0263858326,
0.0259492155,
0.0975672603,
-0.0090780742,
-0.0242460221,
-0.0504741557,
0.004174497,
0.0575242415,
-0.0378856808,
0.1170878783,
0.0147132212,
-0.0590055846,
0.0075887307,
0.0137494905,
0.006559839,
0.0127106039,
-0.0117709851,
0.0223066192,
0.0531075262,
0.0687137544,
0.0064868629,
0.0196648743,
-0.0367778242,
-0.0002576555,
0.0546745621,
-0.0352614485,
0.0043113586,
0.0209344942,
0.0281790756,
-0.0707952902,
-0.0257737637,
-0.0381234027,
-0.0363341831,
-0.0392183624,
-0.0214542225,
0.0070017413,
0.0057230201,
-0.0313522555,
0.0317805856,
0.0126669779,
0.0127314515,
0.004892597,
-0.0430799983,
-0.0426757671,
0.0178411715,
-0.0176333636,
0.0049451296,
-0.0094769662,
0.0219546817,
-0.0431025811,
0.0592624657,
0.0796550289,
-0.0258691814,
0.0459704101,
-0.0458493717,
-0.0495178886,
0.0111638866,
-0.019440528,
0.0118003944,
-0.0051108892,
0.0157732759,
0.0160337742,
0.0038138279,
-0.0236083139,
0.0527138785,
0.0211960785,
0.0066031697,
-0.0589484982,
0.0034053999,
-0.0171721466,
-0.0123088825,
-0.0084497454,
-0.0499795973,
-0.0063068033,
0.0454653539,
0.094325684,
-0.0303545129,
-0.0636418238,
-0.0175851136,
2.815e-7,
0.0873108953,
0.0856621638,
-0.0091297701,
0.0059949751,
-0.0071623628,
0.0472289659,
0.0016036923,
-0.0019131878,
0.0238682237,
0.0419839621,
0.0371161066,
0.0083375685,
0.0785637274,
0.0556342006,
0.0087748701,
-0.0445590056,
-0.030418545,
0.0327369049,
-0.0794329569,
0.0296808928,
0.064099215,
0.027354937,
-0.0130073037,
0.0116808098,
0.0075942222,
-0.0130473431,
0.0000288627,
-0.0290893223,
0.0396438316,
0.0047981702,
0.0681912452,
0.0287197605,
0.0017675475,
0.0200955123,
-0.0129691986,
-0.0762526467,
-0.0030369302,
0.0198310893,
-0.0244706273,
0.0159266498,
0.0129837738,
0.0178884473,
0.0116213216,
-0.0824810043,
0.0011696512,
-0.0447878391,
-0.0239139199,
0.0038007549,
0.0391675197,
-0.019981375,
0.0704274029,
-0.0162493419,
0.0041354815,
0.0444787331,
-0.0010260349,
-0.0181635115,
-0.0288236979,
0.0180378687,
-0.014650858,
0.015783621,
-0.0058843275,
-0.0371590182,
-0.0303593911,
-0.0045706593,
-0.0077092485,
0.0184502248,
0.0114281094,
2.543780107e-34,
0.0404519215,
0.0109522175,
0.0325872302,
-0.0011230797,
0.0752219409,
0.005008555,
0.0087869763,
0.013222903,
0.0118692862,
0.0023146798,
-0.0152162528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05934v2 | ASL Citizen: A Community-Sourced Dataset for Advancing Isolated Sign Language Recognition | 2023-04-12T15:52:53 | 2023-06-20T03:20:18 | Aashaka Desai, Lauren Berger, Fyodor O. Minakov, Vanessa Milan, Chinmay Singh, Kriston Pumphrey, Richard E. Ladner, Hal Daumé III, Alex X. Lu, Naomi Caselli, Danielle Bragg | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Sign languages are used as a primary language by approximately 70 million
D/deaf people world-wide. However, most communication technologies operate in
spoken and written languages, creating inequities in access. To help tackle
this problem, we release ASL Citizen, the first crowdsourced Isolated Sign
Language Recognition (ISLR) dataset, collected with consent and containing
83,399 videos for 2,731 distinct signs filmed by 52 signers in a variety of
environments. We propose that this dataset be used for sign language dictionary
retrieval for American Sign Language (ASL), where a user demonstrates a sign to
their webcam to retrieve matching signs from a dictionary. We show that
training supervised machine learning classifiers with our dataset advances the
state-of-the-art on metrics relevant for dictionary retrieval, achieving 63%
accuracy and a recall-at-10 of 91%, evaluated entirely on videos of users who
are not present in the training or validation sets. An accessible PDF of this
article is available at the following link:
https://aashakadesai.github.io/research/ASLCitizen_arxiv_updated.pdf | [
-0.0553360693,
0.0396374874,
-0.003665939,
0.015202282,
-0.0172905475,
0.0275752507,
0.0390009619,
0.0044986368,
0.0797360018,
-0.0206667222,
-0.031152552,
-0.0189031269,
0.0012078473,
0.0047309045,
-0.0067958655,
-0.0649133772,
0.0204212032,
-0.0097960122,
-0.0422526523,
-0.0295201689,
0.0440177247,
-0.0003626396,
-0.0328342803,
0.0402428657,
-0.0617594384,
0.02712355,
0.0247689635,
0.0207224563,
0.0251646321,
-0.0388754904,
-0.0305616334,
0.0267728642,
0.0468773171,
0.0205023382,
0.0000019183,
-0.0243093167,
0.007235806,
-0.0134767015,
-0.0095870402,
0.0012096609,
0.0033117984,
-0.0639085323,
0.0102876546,
0.0471659787,
-0.0402680039,
-0.1024279222,
0.049211219,
0.0267766174,
-0.0114722503,
0.0186419114,
-0.000474603,
-0.0041018226,
0.0008289765,
-0.0257153977,
-0.012827551,
0.0110471342,
0.0106739793,
-0.0403003991,
-0.0073040044,
-0.0405874252,
-0.0003774703,
0.0734859854,
0.0217597969,
-0.0169137418,
-0.0119961789,
0.0130873257,
-0.0636090711,
-0.0129476497,
-0.0021279969,
0.0365875885,
0.0137276584,
-0.0172365252,
0.032453604,
-0.0065319501,
0.0050352369,
0.0311827976,
-0.0209626276,
0.0319389068,
-0.0000182274,
-0.0133271776,
-0.0679189861,
0.0101877963,
0.044374153,
-0.0090462333,
0.0339548178,
-0.0018593482,
0.0204344317,
0.0170207135,
-0.0338605158,
-0.0269084238,
0.0347507857,
-0.0045464649,
0.0333920717,
-0.0471721888,
0.0100341588,
-0.034061119,
-0.0068706577,
-0.0237167403,
-0.0155568169,
-0.0456644781,
0.0039520324,
0.0148350811,
-0.0259255208,
0.02593977,
0.0533596799,
-0.0112052867,
-0.0017180044,
0.0595309138,
0.0019760667,
0.0382727273,
-0.0332880542,
0.0208501145,
-0.0278717969,
-0.0333880968,
-0.0009283439,
-0.0029240313,
0.0105346832,
-0.0314294919,
-0.0219354182,
-0.0343049504,
0.0096347025,
0.0480129421,
0.0265796762,
-0.0170759894,
0.0333612077,
0.0524418652,
0.0101304892,
0.0562689155,
-0.022865843,
-0.0739485696,
0.0148691516,
0.0069819666,
0.0563380644,
0.0172789525,
0.0284938421,
0.015714515,
-0.0227823816,
-0.0571658574,
0.0224445108,
0.0295940097,
-0.0037151815,
0.0191939939,
-0.0022407714,
-0.0390931182,
0.0330874845,
-0.0026244749,
-0.0020486715,
-0.1047233939,
0.0006120139,
-0.0112772128,
0.0535672866,
0.0748810247,
-0.0322860479,
-0.0077474285,
0.0702204704,
-0.0181288868,
-0.0079047605,
0.0202441476,
0.0114737544,
0.0247574784,
0.0430971496,
-0.0223892052,
0.0116109224,
0.0537181459,
-0.0188147277,
0.0133440886,
-0.0058585382,
-0.022282308,
0.0097623924,
0.014748401,
-0.0242312271,
0.0416399091,
-0.0031264203,
-0.0452280305,
0.029042,
0.0822379515,
0.0185456555,
-0.055580046,
-0.0306767691,
0.0415431,
0.012938451,
-0.0805961564,
0.0020825202,
0.030536063,
0.0185583495,
-0.0457152799,
-0.0480843559,
0.004619366,
-0.0379981361,
-0.0131734312,
-0.0337834954,
-0.0240749121,
0.0220022053,
0.0514069721,
0.0712057278,
-0.0115026468,
-0.0180806331,
-0.0089612948,
0.0082787899,
-0.0378061235,
0.018638026,
-0.0398759246,
-0.0052187443,
-0.0136919739,
-0.0188574493,
-0.0210860539,
-0.0013674153,
0.0104593346,
0.0068760989,
0.0187181458,
-0.0240262393,
0.0056835921,
0.0390701555,
-0.0448102839,
-0.0342681892,
0.0960586965,
0.0076427995,
0.0415465385,
-0.0362827629,
0.0339290798,
0.0104781771,
-0.0006458432,
-0.0235817395,
0.0517522022,
0.0210137963,
-0.0477925315,
0.0308431648,
0.0235775802,
0.0366746932,
0.0362455808,
-0.02486494,
-0.0242640469,
0.0224483702,
-0.0476788245,
-0.0081717148,
0.0240701567,
-0.0447167754,
-0.0300522503,
0.0544878319,
-0.0919529721,
-0.0036629611,
0.0699465945,
0.0176641513,
-0.0407646298,
0.0394790135,
0.0070067318,
0.0439293422,
-0.0523352399,
-0.0060775089,
0.0265913066,
-0.0342166871,
-0.007072309,
-0.0085162986,
-0.0325548276,
-0.0425419286,
-0.0656120852,
-0.0532767288,
0.0590461157,
-0.0397375897,
-0.0097787697,
0.0151544167,
-0.0268303454,
0.0545221306,
0.050625734,
0.0403615646,
-0.0252995752,
0.0183846019,
-0.0625133812,
-0.0334815942,
-0.0463577621,
-0.0089420723,
-0.0469366498,
-0.0172509961,
0.0169756189,
-0.0730338693,
-0.0224696249,
-0.038250573,
0.0140258083,
-0.0433837436,
-0.0413678735,
-0.0019264573,
-0.0396090373,
-0.0246511362,
-0.0368313789,
0.0223461557,
0.0007580267,
0.021507185,
-0.046672713,
0.019378474,
-0.043523293,
0.0352373049,
0.0181102809,
-0.023961572,
-0.0258836858,
0.0463064015,
0.0045777904,
-0.0838753134,
-0.0347441882,
0.0062514325,
0.020270111,
0.0289693158,
0.0334329903,
0.0036130289,
-0.0159098059,
0.0082358941,
0.0129904309,
-0.0316512771,
0.0193413757,
-0.0010918985,
0.0227772444,
0.0231394321,
0.0228535421,
-0.0612783358,
-0.0590497442,
-0.0224170219,
-0.0501733683,
-0.0688130632,
0.0253373794,
-0.0478003547,
-0.0064166035,
-0.0252439026,
-0.0819051787,
-0.0032506967,
-0.0423680209,
-0.0217597205,
0.040848989,
-0.0159779061,
-0.0140591906,
0.0652336776,
0.0210921373,
0.0266739018,
-0.0482702963,
-0.0355618037,
-0.0023361195,
0.0338372588,
0.0466592833,
-0.0358451754,
0.036022421,
-0.0149171017,
0.0168053787,
-0.0252253097,
-0.0197923649,
-0.0145766065,
0.0083296532,
-0.0306685176,
0.0074082823,
0.0140762636,
-0.0650645941,
-0.0011086577,
-0.0279762074,
0.0182233341,
0.0489675365,
0.0626772419,
0.0198287461,
0.0003745529,
-0.0472622104,
0.0037245785,
0.0107354876,
-0.0431382358,
-0.0212476589,
-0.0133009236,
0.009641557,
0.0271591675,
0.0265117716,
-0.0327609293,
-0.0070254686,
0.0407444946,
0.0384197235,
-0.0027156386,
0.0363062508,
0.0398873687,
-0.0104986001,
0.0370890461,
0.0450355746,
-0.0000339717,
-0.0918221101,
-0.0125062121,
0.0179085284,
-0.0087848082,
0.006449623,
-0.0360398702,
-0.0861722678,
-0.0569648184,
0.0194628406,
0.0576230288,
0.0520048067,
0.0053873667,
-0.001760599,
-0.0278522782,
0.030964328,
0.0117571549,
-0.0500513241,
-0.0374882743,
-0.002369236,
0.0136786187,
0.0036228325,
0.0192255974,
-0.0024533644,
-0.0269752033,
-0.0017624657,
0.0334730856,
-0.0574389361,
-0.0982505083,
0.0459067486,
-0.0115659731,
0.0509963334,
0.0251842756,
-0.0131179821,
-0.0142282555,
-0.0973851085,
-0.0126710106,
-0.0145580955,
0.0118349697,
-0.0340475067,
0.0325696655,
-0.001274992,
-0.0502752848,
-0.0019407078,
0.0884041935,
-0.0818976387,
-0.0035106321,
0.048849754,
0.023175234,
-0.0106549701,
0.0173379499,
-0.0017911426,
-0.0677429736,
0.0143215815,
0.0154019641,
-0.0023830314,
-0.0094551435,
0.0126162497,
0.022444576,
0.0189397093,
0.0577233173,
-0.0465665385,
0.0249563958,
-0.0252390467,
-0.0839280039,
-0.0082471156,
-0.0114540365,
0.0659603179,
0.0657852739,
-0.0221183095,
0.0074456693,
0.0445768163,
0.0259616338,
-0.07378833,
0.0685573742,
0.0064476952,
0.055766698,
-0.0635928512,
-0.0389342792,
-0.0462107956,
-0.0171545818,
0.0119622517,
0.0166443828,
-0.049495019,
-0.0382113345,
0.0476776063,
0.0310053471,
0.0108326143,
-0.0026684755,
-0.0035395245,
-0.031673938,
-0.0247266646,
0.0867885277,
0.0118683353,
0.0315632373,
0.0307524111,
-0.0527791493,
-0.044677522,
0.0167747829,
0.0140518248,
0.0348821469,
-0.0133554861,
-0.0330969281,
-0.1211239696,
0.0134129608,
-0.0191391613,
0.0527752042,
0.0476903729,
-0.0333048217,
-0.0306573138,
-0.0471713357,
0.0036479777,
0.011439966,
0.0340984017,
-0.0655949041,
-0.0324892402,
0.0203419793,
-0.0227739736,
-0.020836411,
0.0426193252,
0.0161950625,
0.0052258945,
0.0142745227,
0.0916243419,
0.0658470318,
0.0515900552,
-0.0045859083,
0.0173994489,
0.0181837007,
0.0601709522,
-0.0071817823,
0.0162378959,
0.0224648248,
0.0073266188,
0.0078176782,
0.0169946644,
0.0271466579,
0.0219647139,
0.0548820049,
-0.0810073391,
-0.002825873,
0.0520495214,
0.0103408024,
0.0188304856,
0.0246612038,
-0.0039324067,
0.0294776708,
-0.0545559935,
0.0149874501,
-0.0453728251,
-0.0430725105,
0.034209583,
-0.0128249256,
-0.0377742685,
0.018149795,
0.0237798057,
-0.0552577004,
-0.0245682318,
-0.0408402011,
0.0248895474,
-0.0293209944,
0.0033220714,
0.0222951174,
0.0054760459,
-0.0232100878,
0.0241777413,
-0.0243950244,
-0.0333602317,
-0.003932457,
0.0067178127,
0.0069488208,
0.0387487598,
-0.0039338642,
-0.0100522544,
-0.0056308499,
-0.0124446666,
0.00096402,
-0.0718470663,
-0.034382008,
-0.0231424738,
0.0072025764,
-5.400448065e-33,
-0.0018522252,
-0.0318332128,
-0.0115253674,
-0.0304378681,
0.0050342814,
0.0470773764,
0.0168896019,
0.0481225066,
-0.0004230252,
0.0226905979,
-0.0173439365,
0.0030044443,
-0.0128836408,
0.0294005033,
0.0147926724,
-0.034154024,
0.04717182,
-0.0264374372,
0.0185272042,
0.0062631699,
0.0360105,
0.0190626308,
0.0646373779,
-0.1164698899,
-0.0136371488,
-0.0047273538,
-0.0376920849,
-0.0329873376,
0.0034321323,
-0.0119728958,
-0.0124544399,
0.0197119154,
0.0070013208,
0.0170741323,
0.0115771675,
0.0049392791,
-0.0151841231,
0.0074568721,
-0.0699955225,
0.0832158029,
-0.0420869775,
0.0440397635,
0.0265419278,
-0.0068623428,
-0.0704555735,
0.0112907737,
0.0388393849,
-0.001662725,
-0.0290006306,
-0.0150916725,
0.0459738858,
0.0587253086,
0.000936545,
-0.0293141194,
-0.0000563251,
-0.0244695637,
-0.0167707242,
-0.0885170698,
-0.0563756675,
0.0289239082,
-0.0231357925,
0.0005299433,
0.0648800954,
-0.0129200583,
0.0486842655,
0.0569467247,
0.0611992665,
-0.0603357479,
0.0269917566,
-0.0940722525,
0.0660473555,
0.0434364229,
0.0092906402,
0.1097264513,
0.0503747612,
-0.0672558248,
0.004428199,
0.0125765428,
0.0563161559,
0.0519930683,
-0.0441685356,
0.0369607694,
-0.0229456872,
0.0011873175,
-0.0566173568,
0.0131798042,
0.0128305517,
-0.0154773593,
0.0531168394,
0.0096679572,
-0.0182776432,
-0.0005014286,
0.0588489063,
-0.0294194501,
-0.0130414292,
0.0138621163,
0.0263004769,
0.0470266007,
0.0248383582,
-0.0023816666,
-0.0535529554,
-0.0002231739,
0.0232452899,
0.0138002681,
0.0161291659,
-0.0046412088,
-0.0012894019,
0.0838018879,
-0.0484761409,
-0.0009362166,
-0.0002829385,
0.0253742822,
0.0166001581,
0.0004392209,
0.0644030124,
-0.0249367971,
-0.0099859107,
0.0490494967,
-0.017017154,
-0.0001099075,
-0.0000096401,
-0.0083027808,
-0.0247209854,
0.0308255665,
-0.0247515161,
0.0265716277,
-0.0352846459,
-0.077821821,
0.0595293418,
-0.02318375,
0.0277611464,
-0.0176536124,
2.571e-7,
-0.0035591403,
0.0174325723,
0.01474333,
0.0216679405,
0.0015558799,
0.0426978804,
0.0070010917,
0.0456634089,
-0.0101006171,
0.0233256891,
-0.0097207921,
0.0147947473,
0.0319942683,
0.0107868491,
-0.0327314511,
0.0500092581,
-0.0241237339,
0.0509904996,
-0.0039704433,
0.0242241174,
0.0150127597,
0.0540044978,
0.0092484318,
-0.0433897004,
0.0407545306,
-0.0947176442,
0.0508195423,
-0.051112216,
0.0331294686,
-0.0522988215,
0.0726292655,
-0.0290695764,
0.0136645995,
-0.0158709548,
-0.0164724682,
-0.0110460287,
0.0140888775,
-0.002830744,
-0.0835185796,
-0.0006443301,
0.0089267772,
0.0273512602,
-0.0518434756,
0.0192374215,
0.0524521694,
0.017913796,
0.0149330245,
-0.0501098745,
-0.0272053927,
-0.0135052316,
0.0384117328,
0.0215538163,
0.0296004191,
0.0471443981,
0.0178636648,
-0.0590576343,
-0.0195726193,
-0.0783513561,
0.002793971,
-0.0241456125,
-0.017790949,
0.0395674221,
-0.010739902,
0.0408711173,
-0.0333378464,
0.0064517912,
-0.0407401063,
1.367298065e-34,
0.0091538951,
0.0214743074,
0.0160324443,
-0.0098199761,
-0.0144357402,
-0.0446116477,
0.0471820273,
0.0414912254,
0.0012250764,
0.0021729381,
0.0171264466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05929v1 | ReDWINE: A Clinical Datamart with Text Analytical Capabilities to Facilitate Rehabilitation Research | 2023-04-12T15:49:41 | 2023-04-12T15:49:41 | David Oniani, Bambang Parmanto, Andi Saptono, Allyn Bove, Janet Freburger, Shyam Visweswaran Nickie Cappella, Brian McLay, Jonathan C. Silverstein, Michael J. Becich, Anthony Delitto, Elizabeth Skidmore, Yanshan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB | Rehabilitation research focuses on determining the components of a treatment
intervention, the mechanism of how these components lead to recovery and
rehabilitation, and ultimately the optimal intervention strategies to maximize
patients' physical, psychologic, and social functioning. Traditional randomized
clinical trials that study and establish new interventions face several
challenges, such as high cost and time commitment. Observational studies that
use existing clinical data to observe the effect of an intervention have shown
several advantages over RCTs. Electronic Health Records (EHRs) have become an
increasingly important resource for conducting observational studies. To
support these studies, we developed a clinical research datamart, called
ReDWINE (Rehabilitation Datamart With Informatics iNfrastructure for rEsearch),
that transforms the rehabilitation-related EHR data collected from the UPMC
health care system to the Observational Health Data Sciences and Informatics
(OHDSI) Observational Medical Outcomes Partnership (OMOP) Common Data Model
(CDM) to facilitate rehabilitation research. The standardized EHR data stored
in ReDWINE will further reduce the time and effort required by investigators to
pool, harmonize, clean, and analyze data from multiple sources, leading to more
robust and comprehensive research findings. ReDWINE also includes deployment of
data visualization and data analytics tools to facilitate cohort definition and
clinical data analysis. These include among others the Open Health Natural
Language Processing (OHNLP) toolkit, a high-throughput NLP pipeline, to provide
text analytical capabilities at scale in ReDWINE. Using this comprehensive
representation of patient data in ReDWINE for rehabilitation research will
facilitate real-world evidence for health interventions and outcomes. | [
-0.0023300443,
0.1099511608,
-0.0169364829,
-0.0295187775,
0.0034028208,
0.0370213017,
0.0188331399,
0.0492044799,
-0.0079415012,
0.0069318279,
0.0597774647,
0.0314705893,
0.0615762658,
0.0799183846,
0.002356072,
-0.0052541196,
0.0214748885,
0.0530768223,
0.0124726491,
0.0245212801,
-0.0154938111,
0.0194421783,
-0.0469056927,
0.009079067,
0.0081380568,
-0.0268295966,
0.0226110443,
0.0425046682,
-0.0263607055,
-0.0854045302,
-0.0172956102,
0.0367406942,
0.0238627288,
-0.0210853163,
0.0000025548,
-0.0308547188,
-0.049600888,
0.0336710103,
-0.0470957458,
-0.0646232367,
0.0655933693,
-0.0737019107,
0.0528836995,
0.0206611678,
0.0047589638,
-0.0197082385,
0.0439603254,
0.0141214402,
-0.0317383036,
0.0095816515,
-0.0231362227,
0.0032336735,
-0.0404795855,
-0.00863868,
0.0356506184,
0.0768997148,
-0.0052484497,
0.0640667677,
0.0425646901,
-0.0392858125,
0.003972833,
0.0193482321,
-0.0382685065,
0.0720869526,
-0.011883582,
0.0393001698,
0.0121630533,
-0.0169438962,
-0.0188497212,
0.0371455364,
0.1036618501,
0.0305606313,
0.046786584,
-0.0064322879,
0.0097983852,
0.0304402355,
-0.0303608794,
-0.0139531931,
0.0199429411,
-0.0440178476,
-0.0251603927,
0.0115697058,
0.0015275972,
-0.0572378151,
-0.0134061025,
-0.0146556497,
0.0101169497,
0.0028428556,
0.0336382799,
-0.0064368551,
0.0698250011,
-0.0066622663,
0.0224336665,
-0.0095281377,
-0.0164984781,
-0.0100764083,
0.0039880234,
-0.0472841039,
0.1043820232,
0.0071132826,
0.0177458599,
0.0459504761,
0.0337291099,
-0.0063138991,
0.0280224439,
-0.0449629985,
-0.0219436288,
0.0033008282,
0.0281166248,
0.0329812504,
-0.0566957109,
0.0029107656,
0.005513472,
0.0029701809,
-0.0419701152,
0.0046510147,
-0.0297084674,
0.0317033939,
0.0187836438,
-0.0177997556,
0.0139656821,
0.034189228,
0.0052696075,
0.0327830985,
-0.0190329421,
0.0148454886,
0.0237007141,
0.0481288433,
-0.0019889055,
-0.0342441946,
0.027581064,
-0.0290599633,
0.0249784514,
-0.0362735502,
0.0663568676,
0.0300700013,
0.0602055192,
0.016210705,
-0.0098532801,
-0.044279974,
-0.0126189571,
-0.0038789499,
0.0118059488,
-0.0663613826,
0.0645686984,
0.0252204146,
0.0384666249,
-0.0288097877,
-0.0180948414,
0.0198456496,
-0.0989845321,
0.0242342241,
-0.0894437432,
0.0253130179,
-0.0040782322,
-0.0320933796,
0.047976546,
-0.0353132449,
0.0097445138,
-0.0297083948,
0.0049534189,
-0.0083224019,
-0.0233312007,
0.0043247957,
0.0222025067,
-0.0428708866,
-0.0542845875,
0.0276269671,
0.019653162,
0.0410451591,
-0.0980729386,
0.0341036581,
0.0082921535,
0.0860192627,
0.0324165896,
0.052331686,
0.0576686487,
0.011707739,
-0.0596163049,
-0.0369098671,
-0.0049662935,
-0.107038945,
0.0073901978,
0.016615238,
0.067748718,
-0.0064122616,
-0.0379184708,
0.0264606159,
-0.0204376448,
-0.0247303639,
-0.0409638882,
-0.0012639045,
0.0262729321,
0.0021187947,
0.0434810109,
-0.0240713004,
0.0057387799,
-0.0103207352,
0.0234705191,
-0.0190179907,
-0.0209629461,
-0.0256879311,
-0.0705499649,
0.0422394127,
0.0298398305,
-0.0372735709,
0.0240344107,
-0.0695196986,
-0.0046001323,
-0.0067865285,
-0.0359027982,
0.0414743461,
0.0075015794,
0.00354704,
-0.0006098579,
0.0307359323,
0.0061224224,
-0.0141079836,
-0.0381008536,
0.0052083461,
-0.0574106276,
-0.0156750493,
-0.0736408308,
0.0508954488,
-0.0486519858,
0.0392960832,
0.0457764342,
-0.0223051086,
0.0144672738,
0.034968026,
-0.0072926856,
0.0026666319,
0.0225264877,
-0.001117947,
-0.0428477451,
0.0274147578,
0.063802503,
-0.0245737042,
0.004003298,
0.0163913481,
0.042132549,
-0.0307783876,
-0.0196289159,
-0.0123267882,
-0.0039042933,
-0.0421233363,
0.0384855904,
0.0241444185,
-0.0073537505,
0.0448897891,
0.0150568336,
-0.0354301445,
0.000285278,
0.0111187287,
-0.0296892468,
0.008910575,
-0.1135882586,
0.0193704199,
-0.0512437671,
0.0186163168,
-0.005838898,
-0.0863978788,
0.020928394,
0.0097246245,
-0.0048020575,
-0.0219174623,
0.0167374201,
-0.0307755247,
0.033509098,
0.032984484,
0.0291249622,
0.0067632287,
0.0273781195,
-0.0410215631,
-0.0356206261,
0.0092300912,
-0.0431083776,
0.0497148,
0.0047518467,
0.0221157018,
0.0248440076,
0.0304881576,
-0.0160179604,
0.0058349641,
-0.0176962242,
0.0262805279,
-0.0026366813,
-0.0266618021,
0.0288911033,
-0.0425685719,
-0.0128842164,
-0.0273698345,
0.0153523479,
0.0145808468,
0.0046191332,
0.03141528,
0.0355574451,
-0.0130489068,
-0.0469460525,
0.0118382294,
0.0589762405,
-0.035098657,
-0.0103145745,
-0.0166011825,
-0.0475445949,
-0.0070922202,
0.0196421072,
-0.0709488615,
0.0499238968,
-0.0036594807,
0.0373100713,
0.0215004217,
0.0089275511,
-0.0741133168,
0.0218068808,
0.0563212112,
-0.0672982037,
0.0212519225,
-0.0411893949,
-0.0051810043,
-0.0373775661,
-0.0183519106,
-0.0085227592,
0.0028392817,
0.0305864494,
-0.0604819246,
-0.0063762148,
-0.0453209914,
-0.0145628052,
0.0253435429,
-0.0127549712,
-0.0050674281,
-0.0047922018,
0.0693930835,
0.0002081967,
-0.0088202534,
-0.0224452354,
-0.0091356188,
-0.0131948581,
0.0554904044,
0.0008922983,
0.0155756557,
-0.0221591499,
0.0458286293,
-0.0085733198,
-0.034424901,
0.0086303214,
0.031910263,
-0.0329162478,
-0.0687865913,
0.0475204475,
0.061721649,
-0.0229251459,
0.0027265556,
0.0106873997,
-0.0614972897,
-0.0165959112,
-0.0052871793,
-0.0145232603,
0.0027414607,
0.0185383745,
0.0578554161,
-0.0063095316,
-0.006720861,
-0.0248839911,
0.0164803825,
-0.004598225,
-0.0461842194,
0.0035186829,
0.0436527841,
0.0091319503,
-0.0139451139,
0.0248880051,
0.0428101011,
0.0162806306,
-0.0637487099,
-0.0024177355,
0.0082045589,
-0.0272133145,
-0.0072336812,
-0.0203100294,
-0.0833140239,
-0.0187379848,
-0.0054358649,
0.080400914,
-0.0373256281,
0.0029581455,
0.0082352469,
0.0246797744,
0.0153355468,
-0.0170202181,
-0.0651383176,
-0.0268078409,
-0.0182225574,
0.0128055997,
-0.02155222,
-0.0551014431,
0.0011289656,
-0.0356776454,
0.0372532494,
0.0037123929,
-0.064757064,
-0.0790134743,
-0.016424777,
0.0018634403,
0.0760205686,
0.0319927447,
0.036451906,
-0.0165944453,
0.0182646587,
-0.0158713795,
-0.0200231411,
0.0132175414,
-0.058618594,
0.0827859789,
0.0151549345,
0.0236909892,
-0.0719238147,
0.049965173,
-0.0401475877,
-0.0291967969,
-0.003737364,
0.0398270525,
-0.0684254915,
0.032573469,
-0.040012531,
-0.0301994979,
0.0416177399,
-0.0073605496,
0.0032752559,
0.0314208791,
-0.0162044391,
0.0290769152,
0.030140467,
0.0048851017,
0.0087002553,
0.0129852574,
-0.0780460611,
0.0312473401,
0.0029320435,
-0.0103963837,
0.0545205548,
-0.0120677827,
0.0095047709,
0.053774409,
0.0357194021,
0.0000497062,
-0.0974941626,
0.0656221434,
0.0160218738,
0.0569443703,
-0.0138869369,
-0.0441485941,
-0.0181630645,
0.0189784188,
-0.0170098972,
-0.0285035651,
0.0290027093,
0.0375967771,
0.0583780371,
0.0182390716,
0.0186115112,
-0.0778978616,
0.031868346,
0.0166393537,
0.0115876496,
0.0332803242,
-0.0683260113,
-0.0320249796,
-0.04873579,
0.0242837239,
0.0022119349,
-0.0403648317,
-0.0036942116,
0.0202059522,
-0.0297368262,
-0.0322833396,
0.0008800437,
-0.0060503883,
0.0103990557,
0.0385936163,
0.0344860032,
-0.0027261251,
0.0047314493,
-0.0434049815,
-0.0037367081,
-0.0390131809,
0.0185374264,
-0.0227580946,
0.0345463268,
0.0074301157,
-0.0288085975,
-0.015324627,
0.0263364185,
-0.070924677,
-0.0131056672,
-0.0915958434,
0.0694629923,
-0.0216985885,
0.048794046,
0.0138750831,
-0.0229889676,
-0.0078921914,
0.0223537087,
-0.0301207174,
0.0445549525,
0.0004368421,
0.0237955153,
-0.024339661,
0.0103743961,
-0.0386498906,
0.0270463303,
0.0103785852,
-0.0084740026,
0.0391206257,
-0.0202825163,
-0.0060191834,
0.0566590093,
0.0400185063,
-0.0302707329,
0.0081568351,
-0.0591132343,
-0.0048495308,
-0.0009690014,
0.0530398116,
0.0074917944,
-0.0448412485,
-0.0491544753,
-0.0580350459,
0.0497703254,
-0.010085565,
-0.0163374972,
-0.0423720703,
-0.0404685289,
-0.0147564346,
-0.0219834298,
0.0591105148,
0.0083379503,
-0.0724409521,
-0.038620308,
-0.0160569008,
-0.0133667234,
0.0050013592,
-0.0230341218,
-0.0102824671,
-0.0278309751,
-0.0055347583,
-0.0668326765,
-0.0110329352,
-0.0195489563,
-0.0145452879,
0.0622367226,
-0.0514813103,
-0.0629718751,
0.0133081609,
-6.056822805e-33,
0.0351704918,
0.006458018,
-0.0221793037,
-0.0259521753,
-0.041755069,
0.0328369625,
-0.0202534422,
-0.0047134077,
0.0119397696,
-0.0051840423,
0.0133347772,
0.0188215971,
0.0177925266,
0.0328346938,
0.0483274758,
-0.0113459118,
0.0015937734,
0.0106858183,
-0.0085365511,
-0.0279493034,
-0.0274109896,
0.0245455205,
0.0320928022,
-0.0734353364,
0.0405772552,
0.0287507437,
-0.0078169527,
-0.0126083661,
-0.0211586282,
0.0227962285,
-0.027068669,
0.0098561337,
0.0332589373,
-0.0289231129,
-0.0103348242,
0.0184412543,
-0.0685807914,
-0.0007201273,
-0.0119487979,
-0.0482339412,
-0.0358296297,
0.0378567651,
0.06803298,
0.0233679563,
-0.022029968,
-0.010535541,
-0.014755724,
-0.0619391911,
0.0131551335,
-0.0111828288,
0.0409814455,
0.0304051321,
-0.0087766917,
0.0281531196,
-0.0398973934,
-0.0254247487,
-0.0511974134,
0.0441349484,
-0.0741204545,
-0.026408257,
-0.0454832911,
-0.0091827363,
-0.0099036898,
0.0017802416,
0.0151691288,
0.0142625542,
-0.0376161337,
-0.021045424,
0.0060641067,
0.0449716672,
-0.0420798436,
0.0287536494,
0.0439218134,
0.0486430749,
0.0370456353,
-0.0337932333,
-0.1010297388,
0.0475569069,
-0.0242284629,
-0.0290879998,
0.0123917339,
0.0005567255,
0.0062937709,
-0.0044038333,
-0.0299138874,
0.0265622847,
-0.0270223748,
-0.0043791928,
-0.0268845651,
-0.0057950537,
-0.0151376128,
0.0395095125,
0.0351288877,
0.0000299871,
-0.0162765682,
0.0258913022,
0.0465195514,
0.0054029264,
-0.0416789725,
-0.0194937512,
-0.0468752235,
0.014998327,
0.0053588678,
0.0188492145,
0.061810568,
-0.0271022972,
0.0103098918,
-0.0307133067,
-0.0593017079,
0.0190162398,
0.0223818477,
0.0245682616,
-0.0225656703,
-0.0266228244,
0.0423167013,
0.0417421311,
0.0094759101,
0.1154442728,
0.0015959608,
-0.0177577995,
-0.0669194981,
-0.0380330272,
0.0026981754,
0.0019102728,
0.0252733734,
0.003513864,
0.0001349816,
0.0100167533,
0.0285007339,
-0.0254256614,
0.0320908129,
-0.0092904167,
3.16e-7,
0.0363036171,
0.0157713462,
0.0291121528,
-0.0012802734,
0.0669944435,
0.0029398338,
0.005908181,
0.011823399,
0.0390287116,
0.0055810953,
0.0501730815,
0.0206078533,
0.0521979146,
0.0124891661,
0.0670767799,
-0.0384633355,
-0.0362003297,
-0.0409540832,
-0.0614187755,
0.0054548532,
0.0571890697,
-0.0107732546,
-0.0201787315,
0.0022022503,
-0.0127681885,
0.0287685171,
-0.0357704759,
-0.0458687097,
0.0069340277,
-0.0221217535,
0.0095640551,
0.0104790349,
0.0161215849,
0.0092889704,
-0.0428968295,
-0.0165080596,
-0.0751259252,
0.046348609,
-0.0695374906,
0.0431368127,
0.0295366365,
-0.0471849144,
-0.0105126323,
0.0124501223,
0.0747729316,
-0.0728747323,
-0.0103130341,
0.0192124844,
-0.015981026,
-0.0031394053,
0.1054875031,
-0.0075943838,
-0.0159776378,
0.0114225922,
0.0201702472,
0.0516101271,
-0.0626857355,
0.0096734678,
0.0274832845,
0.0580515414,
-0.0472366549,
-0.0021110158,
0.0517013483,
-0.0277329106,
-0.0238141939,
-0.077908881,
0.014601538,
3.312367216e-34,
-0.0016120648,
0.0317707621,
0.0069144713,
-0.0059641162,
0.0523721874,
-0.0461212881,
0.0417498425,
0.0121808723,
-0.0300583318,
-0.0693334937,
-0.030145729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05860v2 | Learning Homographic Disambiguation Representation for Neural Machine Translation | 2023-04-12T13:42:59 | 2023-04-13T00:31:20 | Weixuan Wang, Wei Peng, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Homographs, words with the same spelling but different meanings, remain
challenging in Neural Machine Translation (NMT). While recent works leverage
various word embedding approaches to differentiate word sense in NMT, they do
not focus on the pivotal components in resolving ambiguities of homographs in
NMT: the hidden states of an encoder. In this paper, we propose a novel
approach to tackle homographic issues of NMT in the latent space. We first
train an encoder (aka "HDR-encoder") to learn universal sentence
representations in a natural language inference (NLI) task. We further
fine-tune the encoder using homograph-based synset sentences from WordNet,
enabling it to learn word-level homographic disambiguation representations
(HDR). The pre-trained HDR-encoder is subsequently integrated with a
transformer-based NMT in various schemes to improve translation accuracy.
Experiments on four translation directions demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed method in enhancing the performance of NMT systems in the BLEU scores
(up to +2.3 compared to a solid baseline). The effects can be verified by other
metrics (F1, precision, and recall) of translation accuracy in an additional
disambiguation task. Visualization methods like heatmaps, T-SNE and translation
examples are also utilized to demonstrate the effects of the proposed method. | [
0.0144753978,
-0.0076070437,
-0.0231130794,
0.0327845886,
-0.0258398149,
0.0496679991,
0.0116803693,
-0.0160418022,
0.0541933998,
-0.0267135259,
-0.0266019478,
-0.0156228608,
0.031922996,
-0.02630038,
0.0252739973,
-0.0473244563,
0.0287702214,
0.0148176914,
-0.0561951809,
-0.0057429746,
-0.0046088509,
0.0613940544,
-0.0054921247,
0.0339075886,
-0.0215105116,
-0.0115342718,
0.0018503169,
0.0429981276,
0.0616437979,
0.0064963498,
-0.0174983721,
0.0416920222,
0.0482732765,
0.0676185787,
0.0000020073,
-0.0302832834,
-0.0415698513,
-0.0088558262,
0.0173481759,
-0.0422736406,
0.0677913055,
-0.0842411369,
0.0370604843,
0.0134059452,
-0.0138523392,
0.0080467481,
0.0345496573,
-0.0073147155,
0.0417201519,
0.0166178979,
-0.0117380479,
-0.0478048064,
-0.0266332552,
-0.0454750769,
-0.0136494962,
0.0260857027,
-0.0257547107,
-0.0076797898,
-0.082940869,
-0.0079990076,
-0.0484561287,
0.0733246133,
0.030545665,
0.0519755632,
0.0083096195,
0.0099869417,
0.0176783111,
-0.004511138,
0.001168858,
0.0887323096,
-0.0691002682,
-0.0197991487,
0.0002122621,
-0.0257691219,
-0.0259137675,
0.036031656,
-0.0147260148,
0.0380148403,
0.0001851045,
0.0222776514,
0.035412319,
0.0062646656,
0.0357573368,
0.0087208822,
-0.0182447843,
0.0019595078,
0.0480563305,
-0.0002135897,
-0.0121780569,
0.0271756053,
-0.0023751992,
0.0066418624,
0.045796752,
0.0092519959,
0.0260471739,
0.0263778586,
-0.0064993836,
-0.0527491719,
0.000794027,
-0.0823510364,
-0.0121678691,
0.0544537865,
-0.0004880535,
0.0155724362,
-0.0175615773,
0.0366955511,
-0.0234256126,
0.0105215432,
-0.0382005572,
-0.031730026,
-0.049812343,
0.0067222943,
-0.0521428101,
0.0048223729,
-0.0207070634,
0.0004439514,
-0.0577163175,
-0.0152553124,
-0.013768224,
0.021416422,
0.0250594746,
-0.013597656,
-0.0927622542,
0.0108939577,
-0.0363976359,
0.0806635767,
-0.0409859642,
-0.00749203,
-0.0271681007,
-0.041360721,
-0.0399550758,
0.0242921412,
0.0075274552,
-0.0308539569,
-0.0094768517,
0.0625401065,
-0.0117310425,
-0.0410178825,
0.0027550894,
-0.0468403175,
-0.041191034,
-0.0451388881,
0.0754567087,
-0.0832584575,
0.0654694885,
-0.0001568299,
0.0018047706,
-0.0551916286,
-0.0111718215,
-0.0051330319,
-0.0125228334,
0.1034999043,
-0.0353213511,
-0.0773155913,
0.0168490633,
0.0081991814,
-0.0087408638,
0.0559970774,
0.0481902733,
0.0506068692,
0.0336146727,
0.0309309661,
-0.0026841867,
0.0102040675,
-0.0241055228,
0.0285503324,
-0.0265335497,
-0.0424715765,
-0.0449432284,
0.0600629523,
0.0051698801,
0.0484649464,
-0.0576870926,
-0.0040855692,
0.029509915,
0.034009207,
0.0385694653,
-0.0193165429,
0.0585984886,
0.031852521,
-0.0317805894,
0.0041655428,
-0.028144991,
0.0272476133,
0.0002324694,
0.0065444028,
-0.0122819524,
0.0324260034,
-0.0090357075,
-0.0495758653,
-0.0112903249,
-0.0401068851,
0.02124919,
-0.0064140921,
0.0508947335,
0.0340279788,
-0.0260945801,
0.0832793191,
0.0297045074,
-0.0574873686,
0.0396450981,
0.0109226443,
-0.0324077196,
0.080997102,
0.0398063026,
0.0115465811,
-0.036618799,
-0.0338964686,
-0.0726725683,
0.0480341092,
0.0142992605,
0.0011228174,
0.0255764388,
-0.0995394588,
-0.0382348336,
-0.0095666172,
0.0130942827,
0.0084226141,
0.0085074734,
0.0209857468,
0.0742236003,
-0.0630921721,
-0.0064935703,
0.0128930854,
-0.000033953,
-0.006606021,
-0.0067532151,
0.0399313122,
-0.0150604863,
0.0099256905,
-0.0138912434,
-0.0113965422,
0.0149087124,
-0.0420249216,
-0.0421413481,
0.0118409628,
-0.021867983,
-0.1161387414,
-0.0000991846,
-0.1101756617,
-0.0225850008,
0.0547024645,
-0.0628939718,
-0.032492213,
-0.0027091403,
-0.0137306703,
-0.0035857395,
-0.03001884,
0.0018350742,
0.0178102665,
0.0020083517,
-0.051468648,
0.0595809221,
-0.0023577795,
-0.0062069194,
-0.0459060073,
0.0189393349,
0.0078220908,
0.0050911065,
-0.0401350819,
0.0492061749,
0.053213492,
0.0073964838,
0.0155088548,
0.0075364588,
-0.0216857549,
-0.0283540823,
-0.0412262008,
0.0052691102,
-0.0395526737,
-0.0133831035,
0.0433648229,
0.0148766655,
0.0271035992,
-0.0386218689,
0.021788843,
0.0728039742,
-0.0080474727,
0.0002875753,
0.0522006378,
-0.0498008132,
-0.0184928533,
0.0136855301,
-0.0327583179,
-0.0355764478,
0.0489717275,
0.0078490954,
-0.0297353603,
-0.0458346084,
0.0093262056,
-0.0707813427,
-0.0024101599,
-0.02187429,
-0.0415076017,
0.0334573872,
-0.0117895249,
0.0177118909,
0.0212287586,
-0.0097784176,
0.0428306274,
0.0932186693,
0.033136975,
-0.0301664267,
-0.0142932711,
-0.0487406142,
0.0327698216,
-0.0065415446,
-0.0309857801,
-0.0077349562,
0.0297199115,
0.0442733131,
0.009156812,
-0.0219642222,
0.00696006,
-0.0163569953,
-0.010853,
-0.0250121802,
0.0336568728,
0.0072287302,
0.0241410956,
-0.0057395636,
-0.0495048799,
0.0639469251,
-0.0076547931,
0.0506186821,
-0.0736633763,
0.0007791771,
-0.0377581343,
0.0482166745,
-0.0024199027,
0.0351514891,
-0.0205624141,
-0.051707197,
-0.0438909121,
-0.0181589741,
0.0277993046,
-0.0232169721,
0.0738810003,
-0.0617520884,
-0.0247060191,
-0.0162302572,
0.0052852267,
-0.0327723213,
0.0366214626,
-0.035960108,
-0.0022901697,
0.0557294115,
-0.003267209,
0.0201955661,
-0.0069945417,
0.0007446645,
0.0373945981,
-0.010984567,
-0.0121513335,
-0.0379062258,
0.0470654257,
0.0489039049,
0.0041281534,
0.0457407832,
-0.0283665676,
0.0014629697,
0.0091422293,
-0.0289703421,
-0.0409899242,
-0.060133446,
0.0159604028,
0.03266792,
-0.0074734571,
-0.0030982431,
0.0018700645,
0.0450660139,
-0.0409023799,
-0.0125650382,
0.1061447859,
0.0407015197,
-0.0738312304,
0.0092539946,
0.0263200589,
0.0430113338,
-0.0159113444,
-0.0033660333,
-0.1057097614,
-0.0598231219,
-0.0297810622,
-0.0145321107,
0.0493185483,
-0.0100805229,
0.0254450236,
-0.0688291192,
0.0185003765,
0.0288195927,
-0.0326850377,
-0.0732057169,
0.0132162338,
-0.0108570233,
-0.0284633115,
0.0237308573,
-0.0485916622,
-0.0074400967,
-0.0025764536,
0.0006461589,
0.0116398362,
-0.0245125201,
-0.0290365685,
-0.0488221198,
-0.0135267284,
0.0018723254,
0.042941846,
-0.003958262,
-0.0225380138,
-0.0247137584,
-0.006039626,
0.0072203358,
-0.0343373977,
0.0425174832,
0.0097955698,
-0.020186998,
-0.0184476767,
-0.0383061804,
-0.0428502075,
0.0070558921,
-0.0204513706,
0.0509796627,
-0.047994677,
-0.0112830698,
0.0048702322,
0.011005058,
-0.0060634199,
0.0397794135,
0.0120319687,
0.0084794816,
-0.0459941849,
-0.0162254628,
0.0259915292,
-0.0060240161,
0.0144431097,
0.0027157813,
-0.0509048104,
-0.0034755853,
-0.0579470322,
-0.0573065765,
0.0359109156,
0.0199181084,
0.009625447,
-0.0038960089,
0.0554235466,
0.0141894771,
-0.0371522196,
0.0277346037,
-0.0475305617,
-0.0085952319,
0.0202769525,
0.0131137511,
0.0220148321,
0.0136373611,
-0.0101089114,
0.0648386925,
-0.0820254311,
-0.0178523231,
0.0185511969,
0.028572673,
0.0138569083,
0.0612865165,
-0.051097244,
-0.00569276,
-0.00005871,
-0.0212976374,
0.0110047981,
-0.0101477373,
0.0042702267,
0.0365748145,
-0.0241913423,
0.0533940271,
-0.0176842455,
0.0112284934,
0.0097991731,
0.0445105173,
0.0046908981,
-0.0885957852,
0.0145799024,
-0.0093160179,
0.0352060869,
-0.0230596345,
0.0208988525,
-0.032509435,
-0.0101471096,
0.0003696145,
-0.0017693531,
-0.0196443386,
0.0053719804,
0.0221486427,
0.0149212535,
-0.0244404152,
0.0451326706,
0.0016953691,
0.0081266211,
-0.014411726,
-0.0342849158,
0.0041019581,
-0.0024454687,
-0.037323501,
0.0251332447,
-0.0390859321,
0.0426900685,
-0.0050042025,
0.0080739986,
-0.0248654801,
0.0432205535,
0.0141364038,
-0.0109896492,
-0.0779934302,
0.0337265655,
-0.0408287421,
0.0059699262,
-0.0082216328,
0.0066335937,
0.066876106,
-0.0078259269,
0.0711853281,
-0.0195366852,
-0.0005863428,
0.0258888341,
0.0672669411,
-0.0188472047,
-0.003326704,
0.0428631604,
-0.0042037261,
0.0113275582,
-0.0108512733,
0.038361527,
0.0056770681,
0.0163496416,
0.0078967344,
-0.0318580158,
-0.0091686668,
-0.0260379016,
-0.0127202123,
-0.0158558674,
-0.0061792233,
-0.0265140198,
-0.0463950448,
-0.0883128718,
0.0116025889,
0.0044325511,
0.0084490683,
0.031604223,
0.0538055077,
0.0520760305,
-0.0036517375,
-0.0727216974,
-0.0223249998,
0.0309354626,
0.0131832492,
-0.0093218042,
-0.0443498529,
-6.596224836e-33,
-0.0252072513,
-0.0407843143,
-0.0045292438,
-0.0816637129,
-0.043264132,
-0.0239358786,
-0.0061697457,
-0.060246855,
-0.0181191489,
0.0339103863,
0.0307488609,
0.0490619428,
0.0175660998,
0.0104170432,
0.0152025493,
-0.0310206991,
0.0822670311,
0.0348366499,
-0.023875352,
0.025260115,
0.0681949109,
0.0059351553,
0.1000217274,
0.0125344787,
0.0075440845,
-0.019948598,
0.0133777699,
0.0134156402,
-0.0088504311,
0.0230468083,
0.0186927263,
0.079133898,
0.0332075544,
-0.0198545009,
-0.0065876036,
-0.012579089,
-0.0964534655,
-0.0589839891,
0.0012025959,
0.0205620527,
-0.0409691036,
-0.0669052899,
0.0781529471,
-0.0278073847,
-0.0268180463,
-0.0303846747,
0.0346793942,
0.0314988978,
-0.0349370614,
-0.0278757419,
-0.0536706857,
0.0141580394,
-0.0015316792,
0.0212241355,
-0.0153892571,
0.0292395838,
0.0054133767,
0.0039368756,
-0.1264001429,
0.0027613095,
0.0163080711,
0.0011535666,
0.0256719757,
0.0320813507,
-0.0135254608,
0.009379643,
-0.0004734028,
-0.0106087066,
-0.0045847362,
0.0060797199,
0.0416811742,
0.0049031922,
0.0600154512,
0.0173887275,
0.0654012263,
-0.0067195771,
-0.0497202165,
-0.0057217893,
-0.0145408334,
0.047404062,
-0.0159295313,
-0.0153659275,
-0.0288088266,
-0.0304887258,
-0.0734724924,
0.0345921181,
-0.0088288924,
-0.0420626998,
0.0044372473,
0.0026848454,
-0.0070923716,
0.0444478914,
0.0396541953,
-0.0102080647,
0.0490535647,
0.0194695015,
0.0147725372,
0.016378738,
0.0322962552,
0.0292613711,
0.0240105838,
-0.0224607643,
0.0136964526,
0.0429368429,
0.0182594359,
-0.0160366446,
0.0213150028,
-0.0195818059,
-0.004832672,
0.003779284,
-0.0373194553,
-0.0588365681,
-0.0059555909,
-0.0294542834,
0.0335793458,
0.0242042355,
-0.0080657871,
0.0168206301,
0.0189565662,
0.0164850987,
0.0038676753,
0.0694432035,
-0.0114359017,
0.0483105034,
-0.0406958982,
0.0137477778,
-0.0444145203,
0.0225589983,
0.0715969354,
-0.1031099632,
-0.0239476152,
0.0077877496,
2.874e-7,
0.0582407899,
0.0527197197,
0.0004468211,
0.003485614,
-0.0094869751,
0.0080020297,
0.0083666872,
0.0249048322,
-0.0130235562,
0.0107190199,
0.0186497178,
0.0386032499,
0.0302286446,
0.0325336829,
-0.0350185037,
-0.0300871599,
-0.0064949701,
0.0390528254,
-0.0332581326,
0.0380366407,
0.0912488475,
0.0870387331,
0.0095426124,
0.0076403292,
-0.0325387642,
0.0268173479,
0.0547458455,
0.0031236983,
-0.030465439,
-0.0251069963,
0.03270353,
-0.0057202904,
0.0129019534,
0.0128083238,
-0.0227556396,
-0.0048301513,
0.0649693981,
0.0413969755,
0.0000848802,
-0.0186270773,
-0.0078670178,
-0.0295899138,
0.0116085326,
-0.0333073922,
0.0704461187,
-0.1065418422,
-0.0081099803,
-0.0131083066,
-0.0150371436,
0.0372408219,
0.0523359701,
-0.0039771823,
-0.0507412776,
0.0108706346,
0.0449027792,
0.0129900863,
0.0052308487,
-0.0643160343,
0.0189118944,
0.0328178406,
0.0101512866,
0.0013197663,
0.0016614447,
-0.0395960175,
0.0311072823,
-0.039981544,
-0.0119723743,
2.505002568e-34,
0.0164711587,
-0.0040075867,
0.0203096718,
-0.0259444565,
0.0443131253,
-0.0281459093,
-0.0255615208,
-0.0018119223,
0.0332227051,
-0.0813575611,
-0.0171862934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05845v1 | Rethinking Dense Retrieval's Few-Shot Ability | 2023-04-12T13:20:16 | 2023-04-12T13:20:16 | Si Sun, Yida Lu, Shi Yu, Xiangyang Li, Zhonghua Li, Zhao Cao, Zhiyuan Liu, Deiming Ye, Jie Bao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot dense retrieval (DR) aims to effectively generalize to novel search
scenarios by learning a few samples. Despite its importance, there is little
study on specialized datasets and standardized evaluation protocols. As a
result, current methods often resort to random sampling from supervised
datasets to create "few-data" setups and employ inconsistent training
strategies during evaluations, which poses a challenge in accurately comparing
recent progress. In this paper, we propose a customized FewDR dataset and a
unified evaluation benchmark. Specifically, FewDR employs class-wise sampling
to establish a standardized "few-shot" setting with finely-defined classes,
reducing variability in multiple sampling rounds. Moreover, the dataset is
disjointed into base and novel classes, allowing DR models to be continuously
trained on ample data from base classes and a few samples in novel classes.
This benchmark eliminates the risk of novel class leakage, providing a reliable
estimation of the DR model's few-shot ability. Our extensive empirical results
reveal that current state-of-the-art DR models still face challenges in the
standard few-shot scene. Our code and data will be open-sourced at
https://github.com/OpenMatch/ANCE-Tele. | [
0.0078542233,
0.040639881,
0.0085283648,
0.0154458415,
-0.0060151978,
-0.0076903193,
0.0401750505,
0.0282624494,
-0.0273351986,
-0.0221338756,
-0.0372899361,
-0.0304920431,
-0.0612363182,
0.0139006004,
-0.012341016,
-0.0257280655,
0.0389669612,
0.0440520234,
0.0025246197,
0.0163910054,
-0.0346029699,
0.0012392517,
0.023988165,
0.0069853258,
0.0344629437,
0.0155074233,
-0.0394796915,
0.0621151775,
0.0157395396,
-0.0375022553,
0.0476227254,
0.0444582105,
0.0681765229,
0.044108212,
0.000001809,
-0.0376878232,
-0.0324406922,
0.019389553,
-0.0579182282,
-0.0017843995,
-0.0155126397,
0.0219013747,
0.0630649924,
-0.0422551706,
-0.0056363414,
-0.0487544313,
0.0065776934,
0.0119013973,
0.0199876204,
0.0450476781,
-0.0090689827,
-0.0184494685,
-0.0021219659,
-0.0312812738,
0.0324992202,
-0.0479130112,
0.0402849875,
-0.0249062311,
0.0053274995,
0.0226699635,
0.0130757205,
0.005394923,
0.0095073152,
0.0412625857,
0.04719254,
0.0124035245,
-0.112113744,
0.0081202863,
0.0261560418,
0.0459422059,
-0.0258436333,
-0.0218311343,
0.0010873177,
0.0137067717,
-0.0223400891,
-0.0537699535,
-0.051116351,
-0.0180237181,
-0.0038479171,
0.0087350747,
-0.1065620705,
0.0650431663,
0.0054278937,
0.0287971981,
0.000751399,
-0.045474764,
0.0096484032,
-0.0372679718,
-0.0077836751,
0.0157008953,
-0.0374604054,
0.0284415074,
-0.0139693152,
0.006129297,
-0.0177612752,
-0.0276164133,
0.0063861129,
-0.0129521759,
0.0417042486,
0.006240922,
0.058896184,
0.0131666819,
-0.0359038487,
0.0958134308,
-0.0181911029,
0.0228515342,
0.0162189584,
0.0287527945,
-0.0088967793,
-0.0126189524,
-0.0637469739,
0.004046625,
-0.044777479,
0.0532498434,
0.0091694472,
0.0024438063,
-0.0306136217,
-0.0099701006,
0.0240499694,
0.0055078217,
-0.0209093131,
0.0335650072,
-0.0644683465,
-0.0082157729,
0.030251557,
0.027557645,
-0.0179396924,
-0.0030726928,
0.0240904093,
-0.0349946283,
-0.0339189731,
-0.003728583,
0.028551029,
-0.0273791179,
0.0370878428,
0.0310101546,
-0.0232153647,
-0.1034966856,
-0.0127502242,
-0.0398231335,
-0.0062102987,
-0.0326576196,
-0.0119990828,
-0.0504844002,
0.0100267092,
-0.0191685781,
0.0077075381,
-0.0201704185,
-0.0096477382,
0.0267910678,
-0.0304692872,
0.0359461792,
-0.0178894587,
0.0224010758,
0.0299655497,
0.0081991544,
0.0223790072,
0.0743804649,
-0.0485056788,
0.0484389849,
0.0272471327,
0.0232081674,
0.0416334085,
-0.0089348741,
0.0262020472,
0.0096047297,
-0.0348629318,
0.0354355164,
-0.0589296892,
0.0113395918,
0.0115529159,
-0.0151171936,
-0.0712975636,
-0.0365339667,
-0.0116994325,
0.0192748513,
0.0427497327,
-0.032820724,
0.0113338912,
-0.0138508156,
-0.0312344618,
-0.0317352228,
-0.0075080697,
0.0423170701,
-0.0502529778,
-0.0200928506,
0.0337082073,
0.018686492,
-0.054446958,
-0.0106821731,
0.0130572636,
0.0446640104,
-0.0608198345,
0.0205651298,
0.0789456964,
0.0027887155,
0.0355469137,
0.0508771278,
0.034101259,
-0.0143275205,
-0.0250113755,
-0.030049555,
0.0313104168,
0.0349590927,
0.0534435101,
-0.0450120606,
-0.0213375259,
-0.0009127402,
0.0242438726,
-0.0250866991,
0.044766102,
-0.0261061992,
0.0823003054,
-0.0210716538,
-0.0709757879,
-0.0346863829,
0.0150807993,
0.0097820004,
0.0278436858,
0.0123788193,
0.0397415832,
-0.0888226628,
0.0304747708,
-0.005581622,
0.006151807,
-0.0508996733,
0.0374777354,
0.0134577639,
-0.028906431,
-0.0106210494,
-0.0357764922,
-0.0219588578,
0.0432858281,
0.0054165525,
-0.0016003692,
-0.0567574613,
-0.0093288282,
-0.0203995351,
-0.0114225214,
0.0328216739,
0.0203322526,
0.0241597444,
-0.0425254889,
-0.0086943405,
0.0163667463,
0.0196742583,
-0.009538332,
-0.026177438,
0.0035418563,
-0.0241577607,
-0.0006170836,
-0.0575521849,
0.0426448882,
0.020467611,
0.034248013,
0.0104148993,
-0.0010483303,
0.0694914535,
-0.0670252442,
-0.048990842,
-0.0076623843,
-0.0634399056,
0.0263300743,
0.0394318625,
0.0048892396,
-0.0409680456,
0.0269867107,
-0.0475867838,
0.0145702986,
-0.031220261,
-0.0203328095,
-0.0244397689,
0.0066803293,
-0.0099415034,
-0.0610973947,
0.0018734457,
-0.0150361769,
-0.0307397787,
0.0369896963,
0.0018452555,
0.0287109762,
0.0222167727,
-0.0251098722,
-0.0515052825,
0.0394742526,
0.0342500024,
-0.0529105328,
-0.0203824826,
0.0125171747,
0.0295499694,
-0.0415672511,
-0.0022396666,
-0.0067380094,
-0.0124934129,
0.0240908433,
-0.0751362815,
-0.0576602668,
0.054942552,
-0.0243613347,
-0.0263053179,
-0.0102685634,
-0.0063269194,
-0.0772755295,
0.0319367312,
-0.0307547394,
-0.0429382212,
0.0062267971,
-0.0039888844,
-0.0198517647,
0.008510205,
-0.0063413326,
0.0102516962,
-0.0246856082,
0.0168725513,
0.0277215932,
-0.028173089,
-0.0776058063,
0.0638349056,
0.0400227532,
0.0360489637,
-0.0553415604,
-0.020111654,
0.0380754061,
0.0232493281,
-0.0135534108,
0.0098951301,
-0.0141467005,
-0.032768622,
0.0683246106,
-0.0268158894,
0.0063616568,
0.0187573582,
-0.0116323475,
-0.0142138964,
-0.0333087891,
0.0159301255,
-0.0379807204,
0.0225517973,
0.0164695922,
0.007331402,
-0.0137605499,
-0.0844381526,
-0.0181918796,
-0.0266910661,
-0.0088177491,
0.0519351885,
-0.0957440957,
-0.0024048483,
-0.0420811623,
0.0066834763,
0.006378734,
0.0639934987,
-0.0226443224,
-0.0381067656,
0.0078705093,
0.0407960936,
0.0445060171,
-0.0041850554,
-0.0616501048,
0.0303698983,
0.0332713015,
0.0546432696,
0.0090159141,
0.0203562975,
-0.0594641417,
0.020690104,
0.0493569411,
0.0175621007,
-0.0126001248,
-0.0077309506,
0.0345071591,
-0.0264197532,
-0.0502897017,
0.0373159796,
-0.0011609703,
-0.0541526638,
-0.0321514234,
-0.0123044904,
0.0311903004,
0.0580505505,
0.0484620035,
-0.0474963486,
-0.0313577093,
-0.0009448929,
0.0580010302,
0.0163923316,
-0.028051082,
0.0235502515,
-0.1142731085,
0.0723868832,
0.0061571375,
0.0011315071,
-0.0152743272,
-0.051636409,
0.0155505314,
-0.0362667367,
-0.0007695924,
0.0281411409,
0.01486714,
-0.0309221484,
0.030090807,
0.0468085483,
-0.0464051366,
0.0503856093,
-0.0262355637,
0.001461584,
0.0312010571,
-0.0018063947,
0.008807146,
0.021322269,
-0.0027911486,
-0.0466124937,
0.0189968497,
-0.0000376332,
0.1049901024,
-0.0163294841,
-0.0184756834,
0.0155354831,
-0.0182081405,
0.0032862199,
-0.0349672697,
-0.0040351036,
0.0269885194,
-0.0224901009,
0.0256061014,
-0.0646491349,
-0.0437786914,
-0.0038004478,
0.0473804362,
-0.0126135545,
0.0198890474,
-0.0200130362,
0.0218273625,
0.0107013797,
-0.0346143208,
-0.0039673909,
-0.0007289216,
-0.0408438779,
-0.0123319542,
-0.0330993086,
-0.0050611412,
0.0085518677,
0.0727827996,
-0.0542720407,
-0.0303620119,
-0.072890915,
-0.0028757197,
-0.0542341694,
0.0162920617,
-0.0374535471,
0.0029371872,
-0.0306380838,
0.0099277981,
0.0434692502,
-0.0396929458,
-0.0066167237,
-0.0381637104,
-0.0455162562,
-0.0154113872,
-0.0026792805,
0.0422232337,
0.0141882543,
0.0375644565,
-0.009152798,
-0.0874574706,
0.0982776582,
0.0584723167,
-0.0046494459,
0.0066792709,
0.0169737414,
-0.0156407692,
-0.0517730601,
0.013666193,
-0.0933722854,
0.064371191,
0.0394081138,
0.009850218,
-0.0672956854,
0.0261750985,
0.016402496,
-0.0118814642,
0.1319283992,
0.0182836391,
0.0339103416,
-0.0015169701,
0.0349701568,
-0.0111799939,
-0.0151955346,
-0.0137217371,
-0.0117453244,
0.0297335982,
-0.0013626021,
-0.0163280312,
0.0395497456,
0.0102359289,
0.0884349942,
-0.0832353011,
-0.0642796382,
0.0291764401,
-0.0192247648,
-0.0130515853,
0.0190860834,
-0.0451723076,
0.0437395163,
-0.0147830136,
0.0579148456,
-0.0131080812,
0.0341262296,
0.0151414704,
0.0103471493,
-0.0388358384,
0.012857182,
-0.0793904066,
-0.0018527154,
-0.0324094184,
-0.01334811,
0.0326250829,
-0.0315419696,
-0.0137784407,
0.0153991049,
-0.0156899281,
-0.0343115963,
-0.0230670758,
-0.019714091,
-0.0477445163,
-0.0316991806,
0.0542428084,
0.0257417671,
0.0586321615,
0.0583258718,
0.0187457353,
0.043793615,
-0.0251088794,
-0.0276697725,
-0.0199164376,
0.0228707418,
0.1224763244,
0.0477861315,
0.0041782144,
-0.0493700318,
-0.007678329,
0.0021227226,
0.0665082857,
-0.0420896001,
0.002490978,
0.0242261961,
0.0358918421,
0.061237935,
0.0049265502,
-0.0253750794,
-0.0267976392,
-0.0360120647,
-0.0133628715,
0.0180707779,
0.0124902166,
-6.370233843e-33,
0.0236905329,
0.0420944355,
0.0185677204,
-0.046081271,
0.0063435226,
0.0257789772,
-0.0065546595,
-0.005151663,
-0.0403715484,
-0.0019257894,
-0.0252270009,
0.0038067468,
0.0160174724,
0.0315802209,
0.0443448126,
-0.0296025705,
0.0731342435,
-0.0191097241,
-0.0161906835,
0.0217278246,
0.0294340011,
0.0813601837,
0.0304764006,
-0.0295708589,
-0.0705545768,
0.0069586206,
-0.0309070665,
0.0319894142,
0.0081628691,
0.0459455028,
0.0020514277,
0.0383194126,
0.0124989208,
-0.0013140149,
-0.0325406566,
-0.0477583185,
-0.0544654764,
-0.030299006,
-0.0726529956,
0.0028655056,
0.0024706163,
0.0303117577,
0.0150612285,
-0.0427479185,
0.0125752874,
-0.0308378581,
0.0204013381,
-0.0211998429,
-0.068163231,
-0.0521144979,
0.0217245314,
0.0312558897,
-0.0006262375,
-0.0356055982,
0.0417072773,
0.0116323875,
0.0176662393,
0.037746761,
-0.0762892067,
-0.0015189726,
-0.0469775982,
0.032073494,
-0.0175413433,
0.0200948399,
-0.0094807623,
0.0884340554,
0.0497307554,
0.0137969553,
0.0095301419,
-0.0178196188,
0.0345769636,
0.0734089538,
-0.002728451,
0.0819607675,
0.0704896674,
-0.0108822174,
-0.0326115265,
0.0143107083,
-0.017057132,
0.0400370657,
0.0323995166,
0.0397550389,
-0.0572809316,
-0.0171143804,
-0.0097202472,
-0.0401703678,
-0.0436366089,
-0.0097845616,
0.0185418818,
0.0849093124,
-0.0278057661,
0.009035673,
0.0721519366,
-0.0099141393,
0.0157077499,
0.0073072882,
-0.0097979689,
0.0362404957,
0.0027644837,
0.0048026242,
-0.0351755843,
-0.0407982804,
0.0609933808,
0.0138589069,
-0.0140854679,
0.0032026619,
0.0575048551,
0.0517793,
-0.0472684614,
-0.013567036,
-0.0051701488,
-0.0244404897,
0.0005371275,
0.0050332849,
-0.0262566246,
0.0139215775,
0.0166252833,
0.0540299676,
0.0296220705,
0.0051586605,
-0.001085492,
0.0091445884,
0.0235380866,
-0.0199604295,
0.023624735,
0.0269235782,
-0.037080735,
-0.031204069,
0.0178502742,
-0.0093513057,
0.0211515501,
0.0501230471,
2.617e-7,
0.018133793,
-0.0056995349,
-0.0165207796,
-0.0197529811,
-0.0241506416,
0.0199754294,
-0.0247839838,
0.0538699292,
0.0087721739,
-0.028325893,
0.0164559502,
0.0184430182,
0.0213115048,
0.020454023,
-0.0900848433,
0.013092258,
-0.0093671642,
-0.025450876,
-0.0650863647,
-0.0546599887,
0.0477979816,
0.0912223533,
0.0173857715,
-0.0180193502,
0.0191925,
-0.0494618043,
0.0642649308,
0.0048497315,
0.0209678393,
0.0213320442,
0.0333410166,
0.056633085,
0.0113941086,
-0.0120954094,
-0.007192391,
0.0294424538,
0.0363810882,
0.0559601113,
-0.0121143535,
-0.0544868708,
-0.0119605763,
0.0047551533,
0.0163479038,
-0.0093343947,
0.0597649291,
-0.062316861,
0.0136428187,
0.0151359681,
-0.0483442433,
0.0124984914,
0.0255481414,
-0.0126578445,
-0.0010793867,
0.0030218251,
0.0033659877,
0.0288395621,
-0.0267713182,
-0.0922045484,
0.0102406079,
-0.0205383748,
-0.0362941027,
0.0177155659,
-0.0057011256,
-0.0496539138,
-0.0102623887,
-0.0267008636,
-0.0239087287,
1.912047172e-34,
0.0237193517,
0.029679453,
0.0025298751,
-0.0395508856,
-0.0142597612,
-0.0296542495,
-0.0124022523,
0.0181961916,
0.0044058328,
-0.0553650521,
0.0036283473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05783v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05783v3 | Measuring Gender Bias in West Slavic Language Models | 2023-04-12T11:49:43 | 2023-05-25T08:51:47 | Sandra Martinková, Karolina Stańczak, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models have been known to perpetuate biases from the
underlying datasets to downstream tasks. However, these findings are
predominantly based on monolingual language models for English, whereas there
are few investigative studies of biases encoded in language models for
languages beyond English. In this paper, we fill this gap by analysing gender
bias in West Slavic language models. We introduce the first template-based
dataset in Czech, Polish, and Slovak for measuring gender bias towards male,
female and non-binary subjects. We complete the sentences using both mono- and
multilingual language models and assess their suitability for the masked
language modelling objective. Next, we measure gender bias encoded in West
Slavic language models by quantifying the toxicity and genderness of the
generated words. We find that these language models produce hurtful completions
that depend on the subject's gender. Perhaps surprisingly, Czech, Slovak, and
Polish language models produce more hurtful completions with men as subjects,
which, upon inspection, we find is due to completions being related to
violence, death, and sickness. | [
0.0633251667,
0.0793874189,
-0.0476599745,
0.0229352135,
0.0048145144,
0.0403703861,
0.0589895286,
-0.0315890983,
0.016441239,
-0.0447856635,
0.0096661886,
-0.0151931681,
-0.0036876977,
-0.0271232873,
0.040604651,
-0.0606864169,
0.043265257,
0.0312628821,
0.001297113,
-0.0444357246,
0.006678232,
0.0341083221,
0.0124631142,
0.0477487743,
-0.0049574976,
-0.0291017443,
0.0448692217,
0.0134598101,
-0.0182531998,
0.0015605027,
0.0554989576,
0.0509494729,
-0.0052359058,
0.0132835507,
0.000001685,
-0.0806215182,
0.030396428,
0.0013318578,
0.00380987,
-0.0072203241,
0.0702426583,
-0.0490045138,
-0.0132022863,
0.0046432228,
-0.0157194566,
-0.0439011976,
0.0507730395,
0.0455251299,
0.0235287938,
0.014153854,
-0.0007623753,
0.0038659363,
-0.0428000726,
-0.0353352427,
-0.0401479639,
0.0456728972,
0.0578447245,
-0.0204659756,
-0.0710188597,
-0.010356429,
-0.0327257328,
0.0069055846,
-0.0118907588,
0.0151614863,
-0.0230412707,
-0.0016456199,
-0.028861003,
-0.073239997,
0.0360941067,
0.0226060953,
-0.0155568114,
-0.0124447122,
0.0234698225,
0.0133217564,
-0.0004833232,
-0.006343985,
-0.0163374133,
0.029399801,
0.0187767521,
-0.0179800484,
0.0049047829,
-0.0131285442,
0.0219649188,
0.0477788262,
0.0413473845,
0.0866279006,
0.0118231708,
-0.0115575427,
0.0487820469,
-0.0189558361,
-0.0003361683,
-0.0612257347,
0.0154333217,
-0.0114455046,
-0.0189573504,
0.0075888303,
-0.0380626731,
-0.0423910841,
0.0600402243,
-0.0791076049,
-0.0017338212,
0.0449988171,
-0.0210339259,
-0.0106107946,
-0.0338139348,
0.0296471734,
0.0041926401,
0.015883822,
-0.0578537323,
-0.0541737452,
0.0051979809,
-0.0141569404,
-0.0279998146,
-0.0249472186,
-0.0024955221,
0.0541910827,
-0.0662421808,
-0.0040120692,
-0.0509638898,
0.0130886352,
-0.0013082825,
0.0251086485,
-0.0270547606,
0.0108476104,
0.0123972939,
0.0040763472,
-0.0852076635,
0.0236977171,
-0.072898373,
-0.0445093513,
0.0341638513,
0.0088504804,
-0.0399112962,
-0.0644149184,
0.0467261896,
0.0318750963,
0.0332039222,
-0.0115415156,
-0.001877219,
-0.0082292585,
-0.0357923992,
-0.0645320565,
0.0031069473,
-0.0493413992,
0.0089137787,
0.0289355572,
-0.0219526459,
-0.0511670895,
0.0075546438,
0.0173830297,
-0.0706406832,
0.0512133501,
0.0637187511,
0.0050316532,
0.0603025965,
0.0007085931,
-0.0005944165,
0.0779156312,
0.0191823132,
0.0288281254,
0.0473585315,
-0.0089501133,
0.001277962,
0.037621174,
0.0597451031,
0.0406369679,
-0.0517170951,
0.0493102185,
0.002576496,
-0.0015120547,
0.0847277045,
0.0072351024,
0.0172785856,
-0.0311261863,
0.0551874936,
0.0448526889,
0.0109201362,
0.0575271584,
0.0497815683,
-0.0147624165,
-0.0261234436,
0.0324097127,
-0.0733098537,
-0.0383413658,
-0.0064435382,
-0.0115713775,
-0.0187695865,
0.0296590757,
-0.018493792,
-0.0290877018,
-0.0080081066,
-0.0106537007,
0.0701695457,
-0.0019434493,
0.0469000749,
0.0223089438,
-0.0044927131,
0.0346209705,
0.0682031587,
-0.0483711511,
0.0072646569,
-0.0154744368,
0.0228990801,
0.015210459,
-0.0121375499,
-0.0436930805,
0.0235057287,
-0.0239347219,
0.004012356,
0.0175121203,
0.0353553146,
0.002372097,
0.0168296732,
-0.0192175359,
-0.0067976294,
0.0192046706,
0.0225235764,
0.0125890085,
0.0169745144,
0.0380800888,
0.0124939689,
-0.0375546888,
-0.0521414205,
0.0337635912,
0.0144761484,
-0.0210332833,
0.0204379112,
0.0128392251,
0.0301574748,
0.0004880941,
-0.0211564191,
0.0027444826,
0.0204054788,
-0.0163400676,
-0.0177096371,
0.0291707925,
-0.0181836337,
-0.0249049291,
-0.0013692591,
-0.0737860054,
-0.0486255027,
0.0355745144,
0.0020091678,
0.0067184852,
0.0940273777,
-0.0351079442,
-0.0167574417,
-0.02988391,
-0.0099898828,
-0.0193210337,
0.0508210026,
-0.0142280273,
0.0249464754,
-0.0386593081,
0.0328832753,
-0.0095355157,
-0.0325655006,
-0.0015266394,
-0.0360950641,
-0.0692129359,
0.0268643182,
-0.0123547027,
-0.010009367,
0.0236937813,
-0.0413576961,
0.0006767144,
-0.0037531387,
-0.0982971936,
0.0019346585,
0.0040530558,
-0.023675397,
-0.0133712953,
0.0019805869,
-0.0341925956,
0.0053507602,
-0.0189586487,
-0.0544593893,
0.0383408442,
0.0384224094,
-0.0027879509,
-0.018887734,
0.0255029909,
-0.0371602178,
-0.0309717171,
-0.0436134636,
0.0255189128,
-0.0318708234,
-0.0169662721,
-0.0249794889,
0.0060252771,
-0.0385067351,
0.0116123492,
-0.0295053571,
-0.0830481127,
0.0151980622,
0.0559423827,
0.065726459,
0.1046878025,
0.0089269876,
0.0322351605,
0.0787070468,
-0.0056959232,
-0.0184356831,
-0.0025420608,
-0.0220775306,
0.0072952914,
0.0233447514,
-0.0933317095,
-0.024773458,
0.0447865501,
0.037710119,
-0.0362003148,
-0.0459751263,
0.0285422727,
-0.0715946108,
-0.0435765497,
-0.027302295,
-0.0597479232,
0.0015130445,
0.0198700428,
-0.0292631034,
-0.0279586483,
0.0348656848,
0.0089631481,
-0.0115886284,
0.0076698745,
-0.0168935265,
-0.0161775779,
0.0462736003,
0.0180124491,
0.0201090872,
0.0099862199,
-0.0097115934,
-0.0651580617,
-0.0702423379,
0.0204648841,
-0.026178658,
0.0070928838,
-0.0187587179,
-0.0220044833,
0.0008494798,
-0.0261625648,
-0.0306110308,
-0.0729003996,
0.0046070511,
-0.0181000941,
0.0074814809,
0.0236663911,
0.0079464633,
0.0059192241,
0.0017450184,
0.0018890059,
-0.0367419049,
0.0290825795,
-0.0037654082,
-0.0274263378,
0.0405586585,
-0.0496197641,
0.0616576485,
-0.0072129136,
-0.0123932045,
0.0374882482,
-0.0043447819,
0.0415644422,
0.0179800969,
0.0327199996,
0.0407248698,
-0.0104268389,
-0.017906636,
-0.0339627489,
0.0119012492,
-0.0488750376,
0.0092295986,
0.0779861137,
0.0059059151,
-0.0057694521,
0.0293819513,
-0.0108153308,
0.0280729812,
0.0387728661,
0.0053951181,
-0.0788918734,
0.0300169345,
0.0352316685,
-0.0100776535,
-0.1002200469,
-0.0567165427,
-0.0085513629,
-0.1150146127,
-0.0099823726,
0.0013072107,
-0.0372191556,
-0.0180298798,
-0.0092356922,
0.0119489757,
-0.0147180669,
0.0066281068,
-0.002652332,
0.0045072245,
-0.0033194362,
0.0125098769,
-0.0482061766,
-0.0113362195,
0.0224949513,
-0.0483973622,
0.0632959679,
0.0281478353,
0.0575921535,
-0.044436872,
0.0136964535,
0.0313069709,
-0.0015929745,
-0.0200223029,
-0.0267484058,
0.0379916318,
-0.0156108327,
-0.0302960426,
-0.0482912995,
0.0499513671,
0.0520458668,
-0.0002552995,
0.0056727645,
0.0131263863,
0.0445137434,
-0.0308620874,
-0.0414854102,
-0.0014725437,
0.0308763925,
0.0739610121,
0.00199055,
-0.0228032041,
-0.0136677092,
-0.0371860005,
-0.008495436,
0.0448567159,
-0.0774067789,
0.0122786602,
-0.0183012728,
-0.0332092792,
-0.0266187023,
-0.0832215548,
0.036302384,
-0.0248580202,
0.0077515249,
-0.0498900898,
-0.0248375237,
0.0058789905,
-0.0689907819,
0.0514477789,
0.0223571602,
0.0209867246,
-0.0158561952,
-0.0164911244,
-0.0244631171,
-0.0393692292,
-0.0091875745,
0.04490529,
-0.0258751716,
-0.0593315549,
0.0745768249,
0.0664396212,
0.0219419543,
0.0334760696,
0.0021730382,
-0.0723952353,
0.0315103717,
-0.0014941522,
-0.028161142,
0.0285283048,
0.0401370674,
0.0089298673,
0.0415587388,
0.0366541557,
-0.0106021035,
0.0412811674,
0.0370961353,
-0.0336658768,
-0.026066063,
-0.0135007864,
-0.0032127341,
-0.004187583,
0.0326494686,
-0.0505242646,
-0.01008901,
-0.036040999,
-0.0095310463,
-0.0250396226,
-0.0664611086,
0.0135168526,
-0.0168152563,
0.0350423008,
0.0324410535,
-0.0395348705,
-0.043277137,
-0.0650051087,
-0.0215983316,
-0.0472055338,
-0.0110245552,
0.0172658768,
0.0444250032,
0.0151064862,
0.0430881977,
-0.0061723306,
0.0214131642,
-0.0206215698,
-0.0031176612,
0.002560321,
-0.0196464434,
-0.0084706796,
0.0054449262,
-0.0091517651,
-0.0083886534,
-0.0194993727,
0.0316028558,
-0.0230917539,
-0.0358651541,
0.0078935353,
-0.0594573393,
0.072654143,
-0.0086794719,
-0.0245708469,
-0.0067805541,
0.0077164606,
-0.0024359287,
-0.0099335844,
0.0126853846,
0.0096933013,
-0.0257163309,
-0.0190649498,
0.0286326222,
0.0423909016,
0.0636611953,
0.0133860987,
-0.0404357277,
-0.0170691609,
-0.0017602188,
0.0292683523,
-0.0455125533,
-0.0427337736,
0.0066862516,
-0.0864373371,
-0.0609434992,
-0.0227346774,
-0.027547501,
0.005089683,
-0.0157320704,
0.0004403008,
0.0469428562,
-0.0064687794,
-0.0271813627,
-0.0559538268,
0.0612019189,
0.0339428931,
-0.0328052826,
-0.0163737889,
-5.415754838e-33,
-0.0485978872,
-0.0198030528,
-0.0314272083,
-0.0063517815,
-0.0085944301,
-0.0217890628,
0.0222200491,
0.0209142994,
-0.0257378202,
0.0465236083,
0.0165677909,
0.0240155645,
0.019535007,
-0.0313046947,
0.0092331758,
0.01754977,
0.0445896424,
0.013324338,
-0.0071503529,
-0.0297596883,
0.0095865484,
0.0233767405,
0.0608651228,
-0.0742837489,
0.1165800169,
-0.0290532205,
-0.0207325649,
-0.0068854298,
-0.0086050211,
0.0342909507,
-0.0093945414,
0.0714222714,
0.0125009669,
-0.019300973,
0.0178355817,
0.0487994254,
-0.0474238433,
-0.0269448757,
0.0436540879,
0.048395507,
0.027379537,
-0.0119175389,
0.0495674685,
0.0005186237,
-0.0573962145,
0.0002308814,
0.0430158973,
-0.0124688474,
0.0529135205,
0.0056359363,
-0.0620071776,
-0.0086922031,
-0.0314893425,
-0.0041877739,
0.0047775805,
0.047486715,
0.013283574,
0.0202493891,
-0.0444399565,
0.0160073191,
-0.0154409735,
0.0122347008,
-0.0018868943,
-0.0249774624,
0.05091279,
0.030590944,
0.0788689703,
0.0219311938,
-0.0169780441,
0.0123972865,
0.0619174838,
0.0037488246,
0.0557996593,
0.072677739,
0.0027172666,
-0.0429422781,
-0.0720795244,
-0.0461142883,
0.0185440835,
0.0368173644,
0.0162165519,
-0.044713296,
-0.021231398,
-0.0649741292,
-0.0211707223,
-0.0958503187,
-0.0203651339,
0.0005068177,
0.0363706797,
-0.024502743,
-0.0310388878,
-0.021357622,
-0.0192115102,
-0.0368444659,
-0.0387060829,
0.0157373305,
-0.0078287711,
-0.024336081,
0.0351978168,
0.0398290791,
-0.0225747842,
0.0103362948,
-0.0070051532,
0.0003822606,
0.0422725901,
0.0085665397,
0.0186886471,
-0.0051728035,
-0.0580026247,
0.0181009136,
-0.0122635253,
0.0285877977,
0.0178835299,
0.0563082695,
0.041848667,
0.0357606038,
-0.0172253512,
-0.0264022946,
0.0739315152,
-0.0111395204,
-0.0492445603,
-0.0354077518,
-0.0039755027,
0.0525046885,
0.0016011656,
0.0018786631,
-0.0001712258,
0.0484514534,
0.0987923592,
-0.0288025979,
0.0052601299,
-0.0544098914,
2.356e-7,
0.013991137,
0.0709240437,
-0.0166133773,
0.0377500914,
0.0165107641,
0.0318089165,
-0.0154401995,
0.0405694023,
0.080068469,
0.0257078819,
-0.0324261338,
0.002131039,
0.0175803695,
0.0574250706,
-0.0553211682,
0.0433435738,
-0.0718928277,
0.0105135366,
-0.0193540733,
0.0237942915,
-0.0229167007,
0.0691539198,
0.0648864731,
-0.0095402952,
-0.0434849076,
-0.0095330393,
0.0331579223,
-0.0277473107,
-0.0208296701,
0.0159486234,
0.0180839226,
-0.0015786228,
0.0390712507,
0.040514987,
0.0284293424,
-0.0000241304,
0.0434873663,
0.0028480955,
-0.0218587872,
-0.0130897257,
0.022879282,
-0.0373988338,
-0.044842571,
-0.0735273212,
0.0761320591,
-0.0029365653,
-0.019320922,
-0.0356545858,
-0.0106673501,
0.0205923896,
0.1049832329,
-0.0321827717,
-0.0298340768,
0.0170214493,
0.052780997,
0.0042615184,
0.0128455553,
-0.0395855345,
-0.058405295,
-0.017527109,
-0.0076741935,
-0.0577888638,
0.0008028031,
0.0397633202,
-0.0125112934,
-0.0343188196,
0.0029482844,
1.768738225e-34,
-0.0014433739,
0.0519763492,
0.018050855,
-0.0227610059,
-0.0000282767,
0.0051435558,
0.0057234098,
0.0273944531,
0.0374574549,
0.0033095421,
-0.0226370301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05764v1 | Measuring Normative and Descriptive Biases in Language Models Using Census Data | 2023-04-12T11:06:14 | 2023-04-12T11:06:14 | Samia Touileb, Lilja Øvrelid, Erik Velldal | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate in this paper how distributions of occupations with respect to
gender is reflected in pre-trained language models. Such distributions are not
always aligned to normative ideals, nor do they necessarily reflect a
descriptive assessment of reality. In this paper, we introduce an approach for
measuring to what degree pre-trained language models are aligned to normative
and descriptive occupational distributions. To this end, we use official
demographic information about gender--occupation distributions provided by the
national statistics agencies of France, Norway, United Kingdom, and the United
States. We manually generate template-based sentences combining gendered
pronouns and nouns with occupations, and subsequently probe a selection of ten
language models covering the English, French, and Norwegian languages. The
scoring system we introduce in this work is language independent, and can be
used on any combination of template-based sentences, occupations, and
languages. The approach could also be extended to other dimensions of national
census data and other demographic variables. | [
0.0342656747,
0.124929063,
-0.0291454364,
-0.0215620305,
-0.0231735911,
0.0163444467,
0.0538449585,
-0.0474084243,
-0.0343861692,
-0.0648619309,
0.0158726461,
-0.0869076848,
0.0096522812,
-0.0345297083,
0.033379972,
-0.0103375101,
0.0107785612,
0.0294621568,
0.0174628329,
-0.0319675617,
0.0022192248,
0.0522492602,
0.0065255887,
0.0632217973,
-0.0153483339,
0.0046443148,
0.0433306806,
-0.0032055855,
0.0011617579,
0.0589162558,
0.0795349181,
0.0621034987,
-0.0046313829,
-0.0252433028,
0.0000016789,
-0.0680779368,
0.0103696855,
0.0121194357,
0.0019273181,
0.0002412577,
0.0541390069,
-0.0199179053,
-0.0347332321,
0.0370960794,
-0.012966956,
-0.0280646775,
0.0533230789,
0.0062935501,
0.0047276653,
-0.0020812047,
-0.0157338046,
-0.0410465673,
-0.0607488975,
-0.033917103,
-0.0625003129,
0.0399656184,
0.0455938578,
0.0027133105,
-0.0612457283,
-0.0226250533,
-0.0318499915,
0.0167910624,
-0.0100110164,
-0.0080078254,
-0.0198478922,
0.0307266433,
-0.0102339061,
-0.0384503864,
0.0231974144,
0.0036807035,
0.0338075235,
-0.0300832484,
0.0392188132,
-0.0015151196,
0.0151407951,
0.0459835827,
-0.0210519135,
0.0234548505,
0.0236121807,
-0.0110576386,
0.0335499793,
-0.0165221635,
-0.003108039,
0.0261377469,
-0.0466702282,
0.0754569322,
0.0169088654,
-0.0358135924,
0.0307397842,
0.0047259126,
0.0168349668,
-0.0436413996,
0.0213604085,
-0.0392082147,
0.0033393702,
0.0053828307,
0.0105493311,
-0.0335656591,
0.0283680353,
-0.02836149,
0.0191357657,
0.0197765008,
-0.0362750515,
0.0036982223,
0.0214678086,
0.011811682,
0.0201399885,
-0.0043373634,
-0.0505706854,
-0.0397009552,
-0.0571840443,
-0.0140350219,
-0.0200763531,
-0.0590597317,
0.0162298381,
0.0559267178,
-0.0529115982,
-0.0322026163,
-0.0270247404,
0.0006072751,
0.0092223352,
0.001429103,
-0.0360383876,
0.0203445088,
-0.0205928851,
0.0361939929,
-0.0268708859,
0.0497181714,
-0.0413086228,
-0.054853756,
0.0634118766,
0.0147766257,
0.0070529324,
-0.0372634269,
0.0027285579,
-0.0193461031,
0.0122320047,
0.026100684,
0.0190351233,
-0.0180662684,
-0.0627956465,
-0.052766826,
-0.0089325216,
-0.0919967815,
0.0174737014,
0.029280426,
0.0077439458,
-0.0634759367,
0.0016059438,
0.0037752278,
-0.0557046905,
0.0018160978,
0.0228119176,
0.0401460901,
0.0479473732,
-0.0153769674,
0.0388991199,
0.0715562627,
0.0539283976,
-0.0334003568,
0.0217614081,
-0.0464255288,
0.0267849993,
0.0602946654,
0.0116466591,
0.0231586508,
-0.0145515697,
0.0279763713,
0.0130464761,
0.0068067312,
0.1004835516,
0.029269591,
0.0231973287,
0.0072009005,
0.0322659723,
0.0843615979,
0.0295334496,
0.0277216695,
0.0473168194,
0.0204494409,
0.0072507123,
0.0134873325,
-0.05148324,
-0.0369693153,
0.0125037218,
-0.0367904231,
-0.043815542,
0.0332462527,
-0.0122225005,
-0.0504496917,
-0.0072056651,
0.0191987343,
0.0250703916,
0.0214406289,
0.0351235345,
0.009657762,
0.0439355001,
0.0472021624,
0.025221901,
-0.0627190024,
-0.0015586894,
-0.0050349799,
-0.0202283617,
0.0248405524,
-0.0383223705,
-0.0097713526,
-0.0227187946,
-0.0490250178,
0.0009222053,
0.0387624763,
0.0540172532,
0.0037537902,
0.0321117602,
-0.0474207364,
-0.0011287041,
0.0403240062,
0.0334891304,
-0.0058063855,
0.0331625715,
0.0376853235,
0.0322672576,
-0.076105617,
-0.0622202754,
0.0242490452,
-0.0367992893,
-0.005910343,
0.0399875045,
-0.0015319773,
-0.0106339799,
0.018754974,
-0.0446477383,
0.0132190399,
-0.0029676042,
0.0031201891,
0.0323191136,
0.0453859456,
-0.0211251061,
0.0074209003,
-0.0068850443,
-0.0364068523,
-0.0398211814,
0.0102209337,
-0.0079712793,
-0.0030658378,
0.0521714464,
-0.0068195211,
0.0150684193,
-0.0247821864,
0.0063796411,
-0.0015359751,
0.0122331521,
-0.0266216043,
0.0010520872,
-0.0167356934,
0.0129694054,
-0.0163156744,
-0.0362022147,
0.0217276681,
-0.0792974234,
-0.0485540852,
-0.020848481,
-0.0223221816,
0.0544173308,
0.037572626,
-0.0297846273,
-0.0046024816,
-0.0474857315,
-0.0601889156,
-0.0066945064,
-0.0324759893,
0.027883891,
0.0013947028,
-0.0049854233,
-0.0437133536,
0.0075007384,
-0.0259057768,
-0.0380348861,
0.0133088334,
0.0353950374,
0.0376998261,
-0.0190445054,
-0.0016542809,
-0.0343451835,
-0.0312446635,
-0.0545358472,
0.0148332454,
0.0027950294,
0.0145522915,
-0.0258635301,
-0.0128295589,
-0.0309218578,
-0.0076554045,
0.0003730229,
-0.04171874,
-0.0022531874,
0.0368166454,
0.0651898906,
0.0640356764,
0.0165456235,
0.0142990705,
0.0452826284,
-0.0062085069,
-0.0415029153,
-0.0322505981,
-0.0051365606,
0.007553597,
-0.0205423646,
-0.0893886685,
-0.0113944309,
0.0453128964,
0.0234190803,
-0.0469638593,
0.0007031664,
0.0288813747,
-0.0478366353,
-0.0422369838,
-0.0474318899,
0.0248729251,
-0.0079765273,
0.0634612739,
-0.0184735153,
-0.0195566602,
-0.0348918587,
0.0068491898,
-0.0029112124,
0.0011855159,
-0.0533584356,
-0.022310229,
0.0361993164,
0.0152061637,
0.005110804,
0.0566083491,
-0.0182125028,
-0.0835165083,
-0.0413352586,
0.0118202697,
-0.0333792791,
0.0071021239,
-0.0412778072,
-0.0007813036,
0.0195030142,
-0.0390337221,
-0.0201304816,
-0.0747472048,
0.0005705321,
0.0508901961,
0.0191253442,
-0.000702384,
-0.0025568788,
0.0171792675,
-0.002982703,
0.0255069751,
0.0029814527,
0.0225897748,
-0.0243274495,
0.0031563765,
0.048461426,
0.0423719659,
-0.019566752,
-0.0375013538,
-0.0609575957,
0.0016630914,
-0.016617639,
0.0687173977,
-0.0229436234,
-0.014963042,
0.0397377796,
-0.0490215421,
-0.0375757962,
0.0080010155,
0.021156935,
-0.0441023074,
0.0235342868,
0.1018526331,
0.0169772934,
0.0078524593,
0.01271345,
0.03160901,
0.0352097116,
0.0429103523,
0.019404985,
-0.0571445823,
0.0538404435,
0.0025148548,
-0.0089754676,
-0.0434625596,
-0.0112589207,
-0.0383775011,
-0.1091397032,
0.0377488583,
-0.0144074,
-0.0331134088,
0.0261060707,
-0.0064916867,
0.0148526086,
-0.050075084,
0.0146095185,
-0.0170786288,
0.0018207473,
0.0113484459,
0.0495295413,
-0.0776609778,
-0.0824793801,
0.0208131801,
-0.0846400559,
0.0741651952,
0.0260571577,
0.0575443581,
-0.0668613836,
-0.0106223375,
0.0260265507,
-0.0150895305,
-0.0219760239,
0.0135908946,
0.0077358098,
-0.044150874,
-0.0244084671,
-0.0452908911,
0.0284657292,
0.0184327103,
0.005418011,
0.0197020713,
0.0199296027,
0.0105152689,
-0.0248747393,
-0.0036227626,
0.0042169266,
0.0295315627,
0.0841891319,
0.0183672514,
-0.0359486267,
-0.0155813051,
-0.0390810743,
-0.0029425698,
0.0503326096,
-0.0440353304,
-0.0046016709,
0.0141944923,
-0.0587515868,
-0.0082425131,
-0.0542167053,
0.0567332692,
0.0289520714,
0.0243875794,
-0.0576017573,
0.0665066764,
-0.0320338942,
-0.0629097596,
0.046089597,
-0.0246312264,
0.0167760067,
-0.0170675498,
-0.056476716,
0.0233403817,
-0.0047561452,
-0.0450679362,
-0.0435840227,
-0.0410529412,
-0.0458830036,
0.0620980635,
0.0146661187,
0.0190026388,
0.033724457,
-0.0004739195,
-0.0526725315,
0.0422105603,
0.0522238053,
-0.0378076509,
0.0285904892,
0.0313347876,
-0.0109625459,
0.0088694654,
0.0032122708,
-0.0220826287,
0.0422107056,
0.0051237312,
0.000343548,
-0.0393199287,
-0.0528734513,
0.0041365852,
0.0057282052,
0.0102613587,
-0.0401250683,
0.0280166455,
-0.0613594502,
-0.0322596058,
-0.0011679683,
-0.0447106808,
-0.0092107328,
-0.0276291445,
0.0535364263,
0.0335376412,
-0.0158343129,
0.0152936094,
-0.0299705919,
0.0093976725,
-0.0342105106,
0.0202286709,
-0.0115450667,
0.0389082395,
-0.0164310224,
0.0057578566,
0.0105391731,
-0.004640854,
-0.0076718922,
0.0695790574,
0.0362867899,
-0.0024078675,
-0.0024812047,
0.0266064685,
0.0057654316,
0.0098310029,
-0.0501928851,
0.0019026645,
-0.0307688881,
0.0058630286,
0.0096194204,
-0.0881904587,
0.032353662,
-0.0203347709,
0.0064272028,
-0.0350588597,
0.0201805625,
0.0332429148,
0.0065540732,
0.0315942355,
-0.0312114786,
-0.0150936684,
-0.0206553265,
0.0235178135,
0.0725003704,
0.0246008486,
0.0050095646,
-0.0304884072,
-0.0168747548,
-0.0166705977,
0.0197601747,
-0.0381253958,
-0.0311876908,
-0.002398985,
-0.0749268457,
-0.05743815,
-0.019870501,
-0.0080783842,
-0.0077328454,
-0.0252235644,
-0.0157307032,
0.0534682088,
-0.0233131405,
-0.0230095666,
-0.0433666669,
-0.0042886585,
-0.0101808626,
0.0216601063,
-0.0416885354,
-5.822346947e-33,
-0.0443223044,
-0.0355650187,
-0.0076815346,
-0.0388029628,
0.0025460995,
-0.0072888327,
0.0187157709,
0.0094494084,
-0.0156010604,
0.0232690088,
-0.0041161212,
0.0183929447,
0.0257082451,
0.0055733719,
0.02306653,
0.016281642,
0.0386116356,
0.0268574804,
-0.0096270479,
-0.0726845488,
-0.0399716347,
0.0089503014,
0.0975771323,
-0.0580303483,
0.0900816321,
0.0041459012,
0.0011939337,
-0.0203029644,
-0.0217718668,
0.0363789387,
-0.0035196019,
0.0705110952,
0.0068619754,
-0.04009673,
0.0112525374,
0.0670625418,
-0.0684628859,
-0.043549981,
0.0491063856,
0.0391428135,
0.0433686376,
-0.016540857,
0.0281135999,
0.0163599718,
-0.0637583584,
-0.0033369879,
0.0688027218,
0.0119842812,
0.0739133134,
0.0293874331,
-0.0283087343,
0.0129165482,
-0.025827257,
0.0328584388,
0.0088378852,
0.0249904357,
-0.0091374526,
-0.0383079201,
-0.0664588064,
0.0167576894,
0.0213711355,
0.0278518423,
0.0316878818,
0.0021525547,
0.0426886491,
0.0151986927,
0.058332175,
0.052182097,
-0.0508219562,
-0.0446098708,
0.082414113,
-0.0234395023,
-0.0091433842,
0.060473755,
0.0533952005,
0.0116953654,
-0.0389068052,
-0.0501024276,
0.0397393554,
0.0014576773,
0.0317920968,
-0.0324291289,
-0.0447536409,
-0.0831857473,
-0.0624498911,
-0.0567320921,
0.0102639385,
0.0126333181,
0.0370040759,
-0.0057950285,
-0.0049650054,
0.0208174568,
0.0053388672,
-0.0696890652,
-0.0487315878,
-0.0184238907,
-0.0404095724,
-0.0360231027,
0.0254506022,
0.0399986878,
-0.0850744471,
-0.0028201211,
0.001035326,
0.0511883423,
0.0382499173,
0.0573816858,
-0.0067133661,
0.0053708423,
-0.0765166134,
-0.0140512213,
-0.0119466642,
-0.0014075865,
-0.0171727724,
0.0143244527,
0.0433552563,
0.0321410373,
0.0111849057,
-0.025164865,
0.0543526039,
-0.0010914102,
-0.0192676317,
-0.0334382541,
0.0036079588,
0.0264454782,
-0.0155395549,
0.0024837891,
0.0149870105,
-0.0153605025,
0.0616635159,
0.0196385104,
0.002031971,
-0.0317430981,
2.202e-7,
0.0692280978,
0.0503028519,
0.0063329898,
0.0335596129,
-0.0035128428,
-0.0170606878,
0.0242960695,
0.021389788,
0.0693442747,
0.0061294949,
-0.0171866715,
0.0070318221,
0.0219310001,
0.017186882,
-0.0766312107,
0.0208869055,
-0.0566959828,
0.0452924222,
-0.021562336,
0.0509547591,
0.0024077108,
0.0780298337,
0.0284189023,
0.0103048058,
-0.0488105901,
0.0048358925,
0.0331734493,
-0.0265758205,
0.0141318487,
0.0399865471,
0.0366224907,
0.0326387398,
0.0475919805,
0.058922749,
0.0201831609,
0.0253276005,
0.0188197736,
0.0474783815,
-0.0300292224,
0.0757021308,
-0.0051832385,
-0.0266568754,
-0.0446182229,
-0.0572181828,
0.0549707823,
-0.0236177966,
-0.0235275645,
-0.0441113152,
-0.0477281064,
0.0072969948,
0.0540879816,
-0.0146932891,
-0.0258519035,
-0.0020071887,
0.0532492846,
-0.0110434648,
-0.0189847182,
-0.0077987374,
-0.029811848,
0.0110504106,
0.0166748632,
-0.075983502,
0.053479366,
0.0297681186,
-0.0001170168,
-0.0432068221,
0.0300963465,
1.873673366e-34,
0.0312802084,
0.0894765481,
0.0077225729,
-0.0105443792,
0.038132295,
-0.0120030651,
0.0318555571,
0.0230802782,
0.0200027544,
-0.0077863792,
-0.0058703232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05642v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05642v2 | Global Prompt Cell: A Portable Control Module for Effective Prompt Tuning | 2023-04-12T06:46:33 | 2023-05-13T07:45:59 | Chi Liu, Haochun Wang, Nuwa Xi, Sendong Zhao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a novel approach to tuning pre-trained models, prompt tuning involves
freezing the parameters in downstream tasks while inserting trainable
embeddings into inputs in the first layer. However, previous methods have
mainly focused on the initialization of prompt embeddings. The strategy of
training and utilizing prompt embeddings in a reasonable way has become a
limiting factor in the effectiveness of prompt tuning. To address this issue,
we introduce the Global Prompt Cell (GPC), a portable control module for prompt
tuning that selectively preserves prompt information across all encoder layers.
Our experimental results demonstrate a 5.8% improvement on SuperGLUE datasets
compared to vanilla prompt tuning. | [
-0.0135913324,
0.036552079,
0.0148110781,
0.034330707,
0.0299129114,
0.0124182347,
0.0711956173,
-0.0293595679,
-0.0527170934,
0.041067984,
-0.0318244919,
-0.0067791776,
-0.027924411,
0.0588265136,
0.0073968335,
-0.0464741103,
0.0125291115,
0.0067083412,
-0.0067733652,
0.0055717141,
-0.0020665997,
-0.0236536041,
-0.012588976,
0.0312111732,
-0.0323325545,
-0.015395442,
-0.0596091524,
0.0640417039,
0.0332810953,
-0.0117209693,
0.0171709545,
0.0811077207,
0.0398488007,
-0.0050165593,
0.0000022475,
-0.0348827615,
0.0029267517,
-0.0414515883,
-0.0672160089,
0.0368289836,
-0.0030650871,
-0.0511753894,
-0.0299635697,
-0.0066996189,
-0.0003903123,
-0.0070508402,
0.0476235822,
0.0167811196,
0.0584523603,
0.0664679855,
-0.0084067276,
-0.0195141044,
-0.0034028862,
-0.0437415391,
0.0165636912,
-0.0178175773,
-0.0055221175,
-0.046131935,
-0.0370457619,
-0.0201537553,
-0.0278489515,
0.0298476238,
0.0655137077,
-0.0075837257,
0.0293660779,
0.0029184511,
0.0166852195,
-0.0574503317,
-0.0312544778,
0.0515161082,
-0.0814186856,
0.0229566712,
-0.0551152714,
-0.0560957044,
0.0209358633,
-0.0239489749,
-0.0044996152,
-0.0122958804,
-0.0032637441,
-0.0048104925,
-0.0841583535,
0.0299774371,
0.0154698826,
-0.0633071363,
-0.029200606,
0.0377987847,
-0.0041477508,
-0.0063436362,
0.0075243423,
0.0066600279,
-0.0215180367,
-0.0339684598,
0.0357236527,
0.0071684392,
-0.07547196,
-0.0321671553,
-0.0607608967,
0.0236058235,
-0.0220972747,
0.0475280471,
0.0917220563,
0.0461128391,
-0.038020771,
0.0213543642,
-0.0539011136,
0.0595237128,
-0.0032765449,
0.0829350725,
-0.0326910242,
-0.0008310998,
0.0087592751,
0.0036135395,
-0.0346833393,
-0.0358252153,
-0.0606691949,
-0.0140467919,
-0.0045298897,
0.0392864123,
0.0241448488,
0.005626576,
-0.0223365482,
0.0146706831,
-0.066822201,
-0.0173411015,
-0.0171487238,
-0.0045829779,
-0.0646668449,
0.0397219434,
0.0337334685,
-0.0234070271,
-0.0455367863,
-0.0119841779,
0.0366660506,
0.0077188127,
0.0273556467,
0.0124689052,
-0.0190803148,
0.0091058994,
-0.0088101476,
0.0091025652,
0.0252661668,
-0.02081527,
0.0128970621,
0.0057110898,
0.0463623181,
-0.0134920273,
0.0181586277,
-0.0462125093,
-0.0414024144,
-0.0282003228,
0.0299654584,
0.0851208791,
0.001799829,
-0.0423092917,
-0.0014695246,
0.0059796786,
-0.0040297615,
0.0238810349,
-0.0124103017,
0.0737932473,
0.029406229,
-0.0383206122,
0.0196347293,
0.0155732529,
0.0388386101,
0.0005616995,
-0.0134897707,
0.0081182504,
0.1136612967,
0.0389851034,
0.0395284481,
-0.0480099432,
-0.0181642398,
-0.03151384,
0.0406813994,
0.0121025387,
0.000708739,
-0.023105748,
0.0328707434,
0.006748335,
-0.0170720872,
0.0086255157,
-0.0370543227,
0.047154773,
-0.029661173,
0.0031662933,
0.0042169178,
0.0596120693,
-0.080802232,
-0.0739364401,
0.0390610546,
-0.0091941468,
-0.0517628789,
0.0198621284,
-0.0249918699,
-0.0052045663,
-0.059628807,
-0.0037248279,
-0.005526111,
-0.0363206491,
0.0007756021,
-0.030315889,
0.0103673413,
0.0667983517,
-0.0151797272,
0.010250926,
-0.0378543995,
-0.0425494686,
0.0516965427,
0.0422373898,
0.0049628317,
-0.0182480458,
0.0843752846,
-0.0522716641,
-0.0732054785,
-0.0101560615,
-0.0070639164,
0.0386267267,
-0.0287831649,
0.0081216916,
0.0192565434,
0.0658612102,
0.0429016799,
0.029743379,
-0.0093808435,
-0.0350926258,
-0.0010252058,
0.0294587724,
0.0419118851,
-0.0054311589,
-0.0256149378,
-0.0556184277,
0.029075332,
-0.0215065144,
0.0246737394,
-0.0285329502,
-0.0856065527,
-0.0461202748,
-0.004463423,
-0.0077019278,
0.0087824501,
0.0078985021,
-0.0597555749,
-0.0318896361,
-0.0489688404,
0.0595881939,
0.0413665585,
-0.0342629515,
-0.0013880426,
-0.0322115757,
0.0099419327,
-0.0379451662,
0.0060798107,
-0.0076958402,
-0.0180693902,
0.0508072451,
0.0743097663,
-0.0099443328,
-0.0535488427,
-0.0185909346,
0.013451471,
0.0095877917,
0.0167492051,
0.0214281864,
0.018996615,
-0.0165505931,
-0.0312005244,
-0.0345315076,
0.0200763736,
-0.0358513407,
-0.0267339386,
0.0231308397,
0.0133440774,
-0.0494512357,
-0.0444941744,
-0.0016383901,
0.0079729185,
-0.0126715666,
-0.0188840739,
-0.0099789463,
0.0173163768,
0.0195125118,
-0.0271813013,
-0.0042920327,
0.0603234544,
0.0041113491,
-0.018836556,
-0.0446476527,
-0.0281089656,
-0.0024009352,
-0.0119952708,
-0.0046443101,
0.0071281148,
-0.0661308244,
-0.0052312706,
0.0178300124,
0.0017594461,
0.1112624779,
-0.0182452388,
0.0109702945,
-0.0062643667,
0.025070129,
-0.0479113534,
0.0160876121,
-0.0589050204,
-0.0552855618,
-0.0080531947,
0.0625562295,
0.021217661,
0.0254025403,
-0.0064031784,
0.0187222566,
-0.0528375246,
0.0527549312,
0.0078001781,
-0.0131477844,
-0.0720917881,
0.0083558355,
-0.0252897684,
0.0308698807,
-0.0327965878,
-0.0476752408,
0.0396764465,
-0.0114217754,
-0.0196898244,
0.0301429369,
-0.0132813277,
0.0259242151,
-0.0122528058,
0.0261370093,
0.0067428672,
0.0394903459,
-0.0307792723,
-0.0210090317,
0.0176553838,
0.0063774982,
0.0024656886,
-0.0524488725,
0.0274508204,
-0.0524311922,
-0.0146883894,
-0.0612056702,
-0.0412106365,
-0.0438338295,
0.0022845848,
-0.0104500595,
0.0079527972,
-0.0253277104,
-0.011899204,
-0.0219180603,
-0.0078467168,
0.0820443481,
-0.0341917761,
0.0212876555,
-0.0497164242,
-0.0030724844,
-0.0021820697,
0.0265541878,
-0.00588129,
-0.0101816831,
0.0538375899,
-0.015661791,
-0.0034856484,
-0.0336749293,
-0.0513089746,
0.0673199594,
0.0170552675,
0.02512623,
0.0041466346,
0.0198798273,
0.0641211793,
-0.0309586003,
0.0271511823,
0.0652840063,
0.0295642801,
-0.0522051677,
-0.0345753245,
0.0411105156,
0.0638920665,
0.0348002836,
0.009000808,
-0.0342793502,
-0.0461514294,
0.0191423278,
0.0223348755,
0.048296988,
0.0328394435,
0.0059136455,
-0.061249014,
0.0519552492,
0.0334685929,
-0.0282369107,
-0.0483415239,
-0.0014247512,
-0.0085850824,
-0.0207657181,
0.0450228825,
0.024227377,
0.0002170016,
0.0123423943,
0.0370025299,
0.025474675,
-0.0818283036,
-0.0055427994,
-0.0291049629,
0.024367094,
0.0801066235,
-0.0289368648,
0.0067595285,
-0.0363909453,
0.0377338231,
-0.0140978303,
0.0008310159,
-0.0165746473,
0.0362792835,
-0.0049223257,
0.0084437476,
0.0167590734,
0.0486705229,
-0.0033805748,
0.0026824097,
0.0172922779,
0.0293239616,
-0.0108352304,
0.0416868925,
-0.0098195812,
-0.0337331705,
0.0157354176,
0.0351326652,
0.0455429703,
-0.0196874011,
-0.0064283572,
-0.0554287173,
0.0120007293,
-0.0503755435,
-0.0014456027,
0.0055123977,
0.0030215774,
-0.0222910009,
0.0171425268,
-0.0147075746,
0.036414735,
0.0595062599,
0.0013937965,
-0.0495889857,
-0.0606138781,
0.0474640131,
-0.0594017282,
0.0465307459,
-0.0129400231,
-0.0197789315,
-0.0912835672,
-0.0107167596,
0.0478630103,
0.0010570232,
-0.018431006,
-0.0013751698,
-0.0122986035,
-0.0437515192,
0.0011174334,
0.0560056046,
0.018050056,
0.08991763,
-0.0287018567,
-0.0361154415,
0.1087798402,
0.0113806073,
-0.0592074767,
0.0271469876,
0.0645274445,
-0.0391585417,
-0.0116265593,
0.0146756917,
-0.0449701771,
0.0486578904,
0.0176992267,
-0.031123938,
0.0246466212,
-0.0775531903,
0.0251202378,
-0.026685182,
0.070441775,
0.0111662643,
-0.0177114625,
-0.0580887869,
0.0704326555,
0.0261340905,
0.0184468795,
-0.0378958136,
0.0142199034,
-0.0072918497,
-0.0069523575,
0.0049086064,
0.0041091172,
0.0251806565,
0.0321435742,
-0.073744446,
0.0131045599,
-0.006856835,
0.0205671377,
0.0114457859,
0.0327206627,
-0.0059678303,
0.0671782941,
0.0271383729,
0.0160880592,
-0.0023945752,
0.0128962575,
0.0354645289,
0.0589377135,
-0.0389664061,
0.0865236893,
-0.061218109,
-0.0737087354,
-0.074628152,
-0.0101455376,
0.0405055024,
0.0010174871,
-0.0155992759,
0.0656205714,
-0.0282021724,
-0.0108945444,
0.0416450985,
0.0424526446,
-0.034183383,
0.0396347567,
-0.0203421973,
-0.0078788809,
-0.021010587,
0.0143013028,
-0.0203375556,
0.0382668637,
-0.0210379809,
0.0363286547,
-0.0453286767,
0.0263313614,
0.0362339877,
0.0112971347,
-0.0143639091,
0.0211970471,
0.0178884231,
-0.0234902315,
-0.0185406879,
0.0190637205,
-0.0180311576,
0.0271883942,
0.047816854,
-0.011117138,
-0.038128648,
-0.029788522,
0.0143533312,
-0.0284786616,
0.0128187034,
-0.0113359271,
0.0384847932,
-6.8031978e-33,
-0.0591634735,
0.0452398285,
-0.0000801723,
-0.0238789357,
0.0010208673,
0.0193960462,
-0.0085259425,
-0.0210288577,
0.005320332,
0.0062416694,
-0.0346806869,
0.0038931468,
0.0243985876,
0.00125562,
-0.0212306697,
-0.0247557294,
0.0716062188,
-0.0315431096,
-0.024867354,
0.0408432744,
0.0096922414,
0.0280472226,
0.0273893978,
-0.0095186401,
-0.0431048274,
0.0245961826,
-0.0336961746,
-0.0042945845,
-0.0010139802,
0.0244337339,
-0.0058288015,
-0.0095646102,
-0.0437630154,
-0.0472549535,
-0.0363130569,
0.0545517504,
-0.0496792011,
-0.0659097284,
-0.0746373832,
0.0152256135,
-0.0527093299,
-0.0596082062,
-0.0051487964,
-0.0164440293,
-0.0557856523,
0.0012495175,
0.0448560975,
0.0008976066,
-0.0142958537,
-0.0312325228,
-0.031849198,
0.0008938861,
-0.0113878567,
-0.039115265,
0.0642945543,
0.0603614077,
0.0189294592,
0.0085041812,
-0.0612503812,
-0.0141536007,
0.026265284,
0.0236986745,
-0.0013288675,
0.0395396575,
-0.0004597352,
0.0424253196,
0.0084257042,
-0.0333856046,
0.0208178647,
0.0368005522,
0.0063261637,
0.003565819,
0.0333705433,
0.0100403773,
0.0582488254,
-0.0348423757,
-0.0267509706,
0.0531809181,
0.0166944023,
-0.0278343968,
0.0047190697,
0.0069794618,
0.0306330789,
-0.0245728921,
-0.0460006185,
-0.0393723622,
0.0059796995,
-0.0370944403,
0.0623519048,
0.0305078477,
-0.0055074026,
-0.0328291319,
0.0746194869,
-0.010706218,
0.0771335885,
0.0158004966,
-0.0023168686,
0.0154624553,
0.0281407498,
0.0134104397,
-0.0354833715,
-0.0287854839,
0.045280844,
-0.0072061173,
0.019432487,
-0.0067736544,
0.0163501464,
0.0765659139,
-0.0273216069,
0.0039072805,
-0.0263066627,
0.0285720415,
0.0427981205,
0.0243238844,
0.0194317233,
-0.0174804553,
-0.0090695284,
0.0533440262,
-0.0391085222,
-0.0327152796,
-0.0226419158,
-0.0134857297,
0.0333862714,
0.0479349606,
-0.0028112642,
-0.0103520788,
-0.0404268056,
-0.0082117757,
0.0185968932,
-0.0704689622,
-0.012016125,
-0.0063213552,
2.885e-7,
-0.0217111446,
0.0086102225,
0.008389608,
-0.0115655698,
0.0103486562,
0.0084476946,
-0.0237672701,
0.0090124672,
0.0129133351,
-0.0673875064,
0.0399230793,
0.0512015074,
0.0310407113,
-0.0084134582,
-0.0806900784,
-0.005651617,
-0.0377793647,
0.0813925266,
-0.0568824038,
0.0042813048,
0.0052873702,
0.1181347594,
0.0055674883,
0.0121391611,
0.0642427802,
0.03090504,
0.0060423408,
-0.054881312,
0.0317210853,
0.004971623,
0.0091169663,
0.0310275275,
-0.0182920806,
0.0385991111,
-0.0267296694,
0.0318454877,
0.0124677895,
0.061199978,
-0.0114512844,
-0.0555482991,
-0.0056265602,
0.0489789918,
0.0093578491,
-0.072036393,
0.0645435154,
-0.0392530337,
0.0110273641,
-0.0011172477,
-0.0341352113,
-0.0094327861,
0.0645339936,
-0.0226658974,
0.0054803803,
0.0157842655,
0.0633073002,
0.0204928517,
-0.0272363704,
-0.0664313734,
0.0060774633,
0.0029189535,
-0.0255584214,
-0.0222118832,
-0.0383017287,
-0.0416627266,
0.0349692851,
-0.0389445163,
-0.0222167429,
2.788036813e-34,
0.021807218,
-0.0214675367,
0.0843496099,
-0.0149252731,
0.0196481291,
-0.0117072342,
0.0332168937,
0.0003076208,
0.0292691831,
-0.0566155575,
-0.0505353957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05613v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05613v1 | ChatGPT Beyond English: Towards a Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models in Multilingual Learning | 2023-04-12T05:08:52 | 2023-04-12T05:08:52 | Viet Dac Lai, Nghia Trung Ngo, Amir Pouran Ben Veyseh, Hieu Man, Franck Dernoncourt, Trung Bui, Thien Huu Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Over the last few years, large language models (LLMs) have emerged as the
most important breakthroughs in natural language processing (NLP) that
fundamentally transform research and developments in the field. ChatGPT
represents one of the most exciting LLM systems developed recently to showcase
impressive skills for language generation and highly attract public attention.
Among various exciting applications discovered for ChatGPT in English, the
model can process and generate texts for multiple languages due to its
multilingual training data. Given the broad adoption of ChatGPT for English in
different problems and areas, a natural question is whether ChatGPT can also be
applied effectively for other languages or it is necessary to develop more
language-specific technologies. The answer to this question requires a thorough
evaluation of ChatGPT over multiple tasks with diverse languages and large
datasets (i.e., beyond reported anecdotes), which is still missing or limited
in current research. Our work aims to fill this gap for the evaluation of
ChatGPT and similar LLMs to provide more comprehensive information for
multilingual NLP applications. While this work will be an ongoing effort to
include additional experiments in the future, our current paper evaluates
ChatGPT on 7 different tasks, covering 37 diverse languages with high, medium,
low, and extremely low resources. We also focus on the zero-shot learning
setting for ChatGPT to improve reproducibility and better simulate the
interactions of general users. Compared to the performance of previous models,
our extensive experimental results demonstrate a worse performance of ChatGPT
for different NLP tasks and languages, calling for further research to develop
better models and understanding for multilingual learning. | [
0.0128063392,
0.0155729987,
0.0124908453,
0.0546765216,
-0.0709680319,
0.0080650374,
0.0411159657,
-0.0053091822,
0.022308724,
-0.0737262964,
-0.0527176149,
-0.068513304,
-0.0058125895,
-0.004920302,
0.0343915559,
-0.0467727371,
0.0467908345,
-0.0250957794,
-0.0180573463,
-0.0024490862,
0.0229666177,
0.0271994621,
0.0037454485,
0.0748572871,
-0.0112942578,
-0.0210137311,
0.0114873685,
-0.0060422393,
0.0073165367,
-0.020930348,
0.0050898166,
0.0331942365,
0.0032321846,
0.0730587989,
0.0000019145,
-0.0247530863,
-0.0093351137,
-0.0025679502,
0.0126293842,
-0.0093521178,
0.0641952977,
-0.0121843712,
-0.0141038178,
0.030330563,
-0.0304062515,
-0.0296707395,
0.0448785238,
0.0209411588,
0.0498714037,
0.0677691177,
-0.0105283512,
-0.0257985163,
0.010256228,
-0.0302843451,
0.0376894176,
-0.0348536111,
0.0202947985,
0.009141719,
-0.0088855876,
0.0304161571,
-0.0170095656,
0.0115423156,
0.0113781011,
-0.0012432253,
-0.0311150365,
0.0463998318,
-0.0511249267,
-0.0555709302,
-0.020267453,
0.0596793331,
-0.0600702465,
-0.0197194684,
-0.0008199166,
0.0101747159,
-0.0299692918,
-0.0282186083,
-0.0670985878,
0.0483913086,
0.0061496273,
0.0373727866,
0.0237748772,
0.0101231718,
0.0098562082,
0.0116240177,
0.0171721727,
0.0088656666,
0.0375837199,
-0.0192025211,
0.0057640728,
0.0346836448,
-0.0210444871,
-0.0609097108,
-0.004558627,
0.0222381651,
-0.0420732424,
0.0238394495,
-0.0345276855,
-0.0146122053,
0.0476528294,
-0.0541424491,
0.0132170748,
0.0524636284,
-0.0071794549,
0.0331107453,
-0.0475040339,
0.0516260341,
-0.0029011676,
0.0011368447,
-0.0413692668,
-0.030590063,
-0.0596488006,
-0.0178738106,
-0.0328085087,
0.0132845491,
-0.0318337753,
-0.036875993,
-0.0602916665,
-0.0022356263,
0.0050570541,
0.0027629749,
0.0294954646,
-0.0220497008,
-0.052526027,
-0.0011933026,
0.0256472789,
0.0393427387,
-0.0252386574,
-0.005648803,
0.0181734506,
-0.0625923946,
-0.0019672825,
0.0231328085,
-0.0012988589,
-0.0257158093,
-0.0052767266,
0.086735189,
-0.018198777,
-0.0300840326,
-0.0471617915,
-0.0274509136,
-0.0245792605,
-0.1032405421,
0.0008193154,
-0.0844995379,
0.0550323017,
0.0052576759,
0.0184213594,
-0.0155419149,
0.0223003458,
0.0468479134,
-0.0251237284,
0.0662342235,
-0.0006450684,
-0.002725119,
0.0175155811,
0.0022686906,
-0.0071066124,
0.1140212342,
0.0215161275,
0.0023946068,
0.0450389162,
0.0142854974,
0.0041275136,
0.0729961097,
0.0095606791,
0.0103913648,
0.0236126762,
-0.045469366,
0.00766365,
0.0331891775,
0.0282662194,
0.0564275496,
-0.0622258447,
0.0114300214,
0.0357050374,
0.0433753803,
0.0253421962,
0.030971555,
0.0917191878,
0.0173287224,
-0.0218959842,
0.0192298703,
-0.0045542396,
-0.0023401622,
-0.0209549069,
0.0213877559,
0.0169401038,
0.0673167706,
-0.0426891409,
-0.005415556,
-0.0075895339,
-0.0266930889,
0.0142153213,
-0.0222700648,
0.0532511286,
0.0281340666,
-0.0279426519,
0.0322284065,
0.0760214999,
-0.0416270681,
0.0329140685,
-0.0517106652,
-0.0008662637,
0.0552993827,
0.0566706322,
0.0123962294,
-0.0353401192,
-0.0093672033,
0.0009562212,
0.079831861,
0.0489870012,
-0.0149909323,
0.0038271472,
-0.0807194412,
0.0069476585,
-0.0049570804,
0.00373814,
0.0431851931,
0.025417624,
0.0251501929,
0.0184040312,
-0.0062212804,
-0.0126588168,
0.0275790878,
-0.0669726506,
-0.0053528417,
0.002297814,
-0.0159364138,
0.0150897475,
0.0032582993,
-0.0131153474,
0.0010918112,
0.0083793756,
-0.03617955,
-0.0122737037,
0.0368513912,
-0.0458332486,
-0.1159850433,
0.0382908098,
-0.0368193015,
0.0051303403,
-0.0051679541,
-0.0380190201,
-0.0425033942,
0.0055412045,
-0.0070759701,
0.0125032989,
-0.0540215485,
0.0181238074,
0.0319732539,
0.0056106811,
-0.0365739278,
0.0500577204,
0.0165256616,
0.033442758,
0.0177334659,
0.0201842133,
0.0167921595,
-0.0363079347,
-0.0426087603,
0.0352342874,
-0.0052040811,
0.0072943657,
0.0364086032,
0.0549269728,
-0.0403276533,
-0.0272047352,
-0.1208227724,
0.0443207398,
-0.0177446809,
0.0098663578,
0.0230339374,
0.0055346973,
-0.0010549451,
-0.0018622061,
-0.0705557838,
0.0167405773,
0.0638206601,
0.034404546,
0.0207636952,
-0.0146617973,
0.0056087645,
-0.0411167741,
0.0004809746,
0.0146998279,
0.0603919961,
-0.0132117197,
-0.0284494273,
-0.0358460881,
0.0219675992,
-0.0414882489,
-0.0028100489,
0.0079194512,
-0.0407523774,
0.0069687716,
-0.0056282794,
0.0748495236,
-0.0009760724,
0.0025715542,
0.0187529661,
-0.0041166781,
-0.0281211771,
-0.0567613356,
0.0129626766,
-0.035340637,
-0.027700942,
-0.0123233628,
-0.0405087434,
-0.018374905,
0.0791618451,
0.0023501932,
-0.0070911767,
-0.0694249794,
0.0119848885,
-0.0391875468,
-0.0174608603,
-0.0445984192,
0.0285349227,
-0.0252622068,
-0.0020767825,
-0.0352207124,
-0.0251000673,
0.0428535677,
-0.0440063067,
-0.030485427,
-0.0693110749,
0.0264228657,
-0.0505848639,
0.0540647544,
0.0218065232,
0.0445433557,
-0.0117403567,
-0.0031582292,
-0.0356428251,
0.0213351138,
0.0159727912,
-0.0171174817,
0.009531335,
-0.040755365,
0.0052946424,
-0.0209887195,
-0.026999997,
-0.0358847901,
-0.022028124,
-0.0125637082,
0.0038260766,
0.0230734609,
0.0058362824,
-0.0233505499,
0.0245962776,
0.0193722676,
0.0129826916,
-0.0240139533,
-0.0082053561,
-0.0156636648,
0.0470140241,
0.0487086251,
-0.0280813873,
-0.0158578623,
-0.0287346933,
0.0371258669,
0.0648234189,
0.0258201361,
0.0117439274,
-0.0023427906,
0.0066300309,
0.0142598627,
-0.0235251486,
-0.0243186243,
-0.0077797337,
0.0569949932,
-0.0316629857,
-0.0245728437,
0.0986873358,
0.0276019163,
-0.0487013161,
-0.0030942368,
0.0038199453,
0.0598382726,
0.0169894416,
0.0113083832,
-0.1013710201,
-0.0402612276,
0.0002755486,
-0.0085788034,
-0.0058349455,
-0.0242313966,
-0.0346113443,
-0.1448688209,
0.0232089385,
0.0157762673,
-0.0565494187,
0.0106447525,
-0.0353454053,
-0.0147999926,
-0.0312057883,
0.0248118807,
-0.0157660302,
-0.0184720028,
0.0078300107,
0.0257661752,
-0.018247433,
-0.0682899132,
0.0245503299,
-0.0458545201,
0.0564792305,
0.0439985991,
0.0337188542,
0.0141424574,
0.0110054268,
0.0304175839,
0.018472204,
-0.0178400464,
-0.028986562,
0.0381616727,
-0.0024116125,
-0.0142465169,
0.005506733,
0.0179207474,
-0.0084885927,
-0.0041342783,
0.0177749936,
0.0522797816,
0.0116208903,
-0.0046701781,
0.0076707616,
0.0222621411,
0.0238415077,
0.0865172744,
0.0224989913,
-0.0530331694,
-0.0570389628,
-0.0316200033,
-0.0112649668,
-0.0555460677,
-0.049966339,
0.0251954421,
-0.0208429527,
-0.0261545442,
-0.0819858834,
-0.0670390949,
0.0336239003,
0.0099938652,
-0.0145277446,
0.0050018723,
-0.0098634744,
0.018271504,
0.0150872087,
0.0008796205,
-0.0323548168,
0.0031695608,
-0.0544019677,
-0.0085962331,
0.0460760631,
-0.0463329703,
-0.0039744079,
0.0174280275,
-0.0963115245,
-0.0699822083,
-0.0235184617,
0.0541968308,
0.0208422989,
0.0537890233,
-0.0071650995,
-0.0204929654,
0.0167295225,
0.0319068506,
-0.0194460638,
-0.0082778158,
0.0009966154,
0.0472965054,
-0.0096173733,
0.0456783026,
-0.0145140095,
0.0389012098,
-0.0171403289,
0.0571467653,
-0.013982404,
-0.0022515333,
0.0205563363,
0.0084609482,
0.0214941464,
-0.0598090775,
0.0022331497,
-0.0398734026,
-0.0369417071,
-0.0478263162,
-0.0182291474,
-0.0625854358,
-0.0188858397,
0.0213115383,
-0.027197687,
-0.0127493422,
-0.0263281912,
-0.0328565054,
0.0370418802,
-0.0208585504,
0.0031526408,
0.0079478621,
-0.0145828743,
0.0225745402,
0.0046471418,
-0.0246119034,
0.0055864705,
-0.0171779189,
0.0110905617,
-0.0422276929,
0.075139381,
-0.0008595627,
-0.0145673938,
0.0099392245,
0.016196968,
-0.0256936755,
-0.0087612253,
-0.0332014263,
0.0752521306,
0.1049202606,
0.0099371364,
0.0899195597,
-0.0418541916,
-0.0192968063,
-0.0312172752,
0.0440605208,
0.0030264372,
-0.041152928,
0.0067429966,
-0.0089003341,
-0.0329461694,
-0.0069960686,
0.1321576536,
0.0192588884,
0.0318673514,
0.0213897079,
0.0013719272,
-0.0414349325,
-0.015086472,
0.0102068586,
-0.0105995052,
0.0107635986,
0.0227352716,
-0.0573051348,
-0.0490667336,
-0.0196946599,
-0.0105497884,
0.017212607,
0.0092417924,
0.0534922071,
0.0787589699,
-0.0130987456,
0.0357508324,
-0.0633674935,
0.0036408848,
-0.0072754696,
-0.0250035319,
-0.0159232579,
-6.127892458e-33,
-0.0330187827,
-0.0160306133,
0.0403767638,
0.0129832607,
-0.0128198555,
-0.0089649418,
-0.0186729115,
0.0187058952,
0.0062455265,
0.0092847049,
-0.0097109936,
-0.0430112593,
0.0210642479,
0.0494176857,
0.0101677738,
-0.0006455235,
0.0543520935,
-0.0132972496,
0.0057815779,
0.045028735,
0.0383902341,
0.0326716788,
0.0714952648,
0.0031265565,
0.0130793639,
-0.0207517892,
-0.0073868395,
0.0007327892,
0.0192775801,
0.0659205616,
-0.0419474393,
0.0523913242,
0.0382573567,
-0.0315133929,
-0.0332289115,
0.0072640046,
-0.0405975357,
-0.0267771464,
0.0113560855,
0.0213180166,
-0.0278233029,
-0.0056307651,
0.0113048628,
-0.0394571275,
-0.0136166727,
0.0025249289,
0.0084761716,
-0.010337064,
-0.0303393621,
-0.0139723551,
-0.0811230168,
0.0424883142,
0.0042142514,
-0.0519044548,
0.0224061608,
0.0580716915,
-0.0134295141,
0.0106441984,
-0.0446018502,
0.024058139,
-0.0082218964,
0.0151545247,
0.0447122566,
0.0121329883,
-0.00143531,
0.0646051541,
0.0066684047,
0.0003883277,
0.0005201428,
0.0073221512,
0.0179059859,
0.0270124227,
0.0326762833,
0.0810834914,
0.0217045844,
0.0054576932,
-0.0714974925,
0.0255053528,
0.0519945472,
0.0145536019,
0.0318415016,
-0.0147725586,
-0.0051454925,
-0.0318708941,
-0.032135535,
-0.0121020144,
-0.0290912353,
-0.0512247644,
0.0319001786,
0.029251134,
0.0030061745,
-0.0258582663,
0.068241477,
-0.0245000012,
-0.0372810178,
0.0236977357,
-0.0385060683,
0.0156035731,
-0.0154962894,
0.0387532972,
-0.0843765363,
-0.0497761853,
0.0047401874,
0.0210617818,
-0.0226050895,
0.0087622907,
0.0509883314,
-0.0016519302,
-0.0576475263,
0.028268747,
-0.0478325821,
0.0440661572,
-0.0089521483,
0.035110414,
0.030179698,
-0.036807172,
-0.0202750992,
0.0475339256,
0.0549283288,
-0.016177319,
-0.0147962505,
-0.0320139043,
-0.0155192558,
0.0271084607,
-0.0307070818,
0.0466730222,
-0.0503772497,
-0.0185227226,
0.0267672092,
-0.0365980119,
-0.0009791045,
-0.0050923186,
2.534e-7,
0.016278673,
0.0328303687,
-0.0033706527,
0.0099231834,
0.0365849435,
0.0126874577,
-0.0228085853,
0.0319261588,
0.0066103977,
0.0279078931,
-0.0223788675,
0.0253805369,
0.0661020204,
0.0441703089,
-0.0773976967,
-0.0033598272,
-0.0700944439,
0.0042136326,
-0.0584334619,
-0.017382605,
0.0575532466,
0.0926979333,
-0.020191526,
-0.0016327464,
-0.0016137024,
-0.0544974059,
0.1134226099,
-0.0110295592,
-0.0612527952,
0.0387772769,
0.0244119689,
0.044801116,
0.0127236601,
-0.0172757711,
-0.0152345989,
-0.0221111439,
0.0275644436,
0.0488714129,
0.022426378,
-0.0099425772,
0.0559111536,
-0.0011740942,
-0.0252332017,
-0.0629787073,
0.0746974871,
-0.0685177594,
0.0048112832,
-0.031193519,
0.0135481441,
0.0028481181,
0.0462929904,
-0.0634643659,
-0.0656928346,
0.0359010808,
0.0420969315,
-0.0028702195,
-0.0387454517,
-0.0486431196,
-0.0296128392,
-0.0125475638,
-0.0529151708,
-0.0290549155,
-0.0294908155,
-0.0154767232,
-0.0085613718,
-0.0418803245,
-0.0125846583,
2.423207677e-34,
0.043615263,
-0.0247085132,
0.0178618096,
0.0148606412,
0.0182095915,
-0.0093054045,
0.0219868869,
0.0334970243,
-0.0227709934,
-0.0323644169,
-0.0174752697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05591v1 | Semantic Feature Verification in FLAN-T5 | 2023-04-12T03:37:57 | 2023-04-12T03:37:57 | Siddharth Suresh, Kushin Mukherjee, Timothy T. Rogers | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This study evaluates the potential of a large language model for aiding in
generation of semantic feature norms - a critical tool for evaluating
conceptual structure in cognitive science. Building from an existing
human-generated dataset, we show that machine-verified norms capture aspects of
conceptual structure beyond what is expressed in human norms alone, and better
explain human judgments of semantic similarity amongst items that are distally
related. The results suggest that LLMs can greatly enhance traditional methods
of semantic feature norm verification, with implications for our understanding
of conceptual representation in humans and machines. | [
0.0132257966,
0.0011215761,
-0.0448055714,
0.0593035407,
-0.0408422686,
0.0230203271,
-0.0248764548,
0.0051392005,
-0.0203289576,
-0.0460354313,
-0.0377762653,
-0.071209386,
0.0243865941,
0.0266046952,
0.0223104525,
-0.046124842,
0.0342508405,
-0.0096909599,
0.0044519827,
0.0021059692,
-0.028495675,
0.0008293896,
0.0140735283,
0.0099050626,
-0.0037210602,
-0.0085100541,
0.0190743431,
-0.0326652564,
-0.0162825435,
-0.0413445793,
-0.0286655314,
0.0298630279,
0.0228659362,
-0.0077810283,
0.0000017594,
-0.0739680454,
0.0365740284,
-0.0092307841,
0.0171647258,
0.0305356402,
0.0697023198,
-0.0303762052,
0.0210423227,
-0.0483651012,
-0.0150217051,
-0.0256769359,
0.0466785431,
0.0361052155,
0.0101797711,
0.005017004,
-0.0140063791,
-0.054685995,
0.054111477,
0.0344911031,
0.0372744724,
-0.0003003636,
0.0406736545,
0.0062995041,
0.0250273086,
0.0200554747,
-0.0097711971,
0.007462108,
0.0168148801,
0.0440734215,
-0.0032133691,
0.0191910528,
0.0307492185,
-0.0294605494,
0.0370394588,
0.0612102002,
0.0251081288,
-0.0463317968,
0.0015596387,
0.0017701063,
-0.0159771498,
0.0660794675,
-0.0374999344,
0.063650474,
0.0103547741,
0.0140195554,
0.0678568855,
-0.0222960878,
0.0459534377,
0.0238805488,
-0.0182877872,
0.0823722631,
0.0046712193,
-0.0581463836,
-0.0143217593,
-0.0349770151,
-0.0481320508,
-0.0413825102,
-0.0157210641,
0.0145311514,
-0.0118302051,
-0.0138189411,
0.0275813695,
0.0307682194,
0.0733367056,
-0.0255420003,
0.0269589741,
0.0321019441,
-0.0412428416,
0.0128930295,
-0.0240123421,
0.0480928011,
-0.0284816027,
0.0112917731,
-0.0345176235,
0.0073912293,
-0.0652548,
-0.0160210729,
0.0409389623,
0.0262733698,
0.0141203748,
-0.0047163879,
-0.0406142063,
0.0282993801,
-0.0023149624,
0.0077996156,
-0.048118528,
-0.0184722468,
0.0135369403,
0.0516987629,
-0.0717120618,
-0.0172253642,
-0.0334483124,
0.0465112068,
-0.0239450503,
-0.0361835919,
0.0213347636,
0.0140777752,
-0.034464851,
-0.0330455229,
-0.0008396468,
0.0393641703,
0.0406249911,
-0.0199186094,
-0.0051795333,
-0.0528569221,
0.0062561189,
-0.0382694304,
0.0303910375,
-0.0693834722,
-0.0071522966,
0.0089764064,
-0.0230007637,
-0.0188897327,
-0.0225556437,
0.0258943662,
-0.0240154602,
0.0906986743,
-0.0274787825,
0.0154829649,
-0.003475327,
0.0256070439,
0.0081316466,
-0.0045033456,
0.0092243133,
0.0226603262,
0.0358912796,
0.02265778,
-0.0381999351,
0.0121543976,
-0.0433107018,
-0.04236947,
-0.0650686622,
-0.0017716214,
-0.019677639,
0.0401063003,
0.0330933146,
0.0699959695,
-0.0109992642,
-0.0406292491,
0.0361512937,
0.1213889793,
0.0116809225,
0.0168384463,
0.0570084453,
-0.0260436293,
0.0271050762,
0.0386539996,
-0.0561433509,
-0.0040763109,
-0.0340018533,
0.0279597808,
-0.0422130078,
0.0347692743,
-0.0157473516,
-0.0122116832,
-0.043865975,
-0.0162310395,
0.0253263414,
-0.0574303381,
0.0341530405,
-0.0189496819,
0.0487989634,
0.0084553044,
0.030384507,
-0.0247454755,
-0.0219649523,
-0.0255898777,
0.0620419867,
0.0542580895,
0.0517344289,
-0.0194447748,
0.011856637,
0.0136767188,
-0.0278678685,
0.0326823443,
0.0384528264,
-0.0215417538,
-0.0286234114,
-0.0275568683,
-0.0008674971,
0.0170076583,
0.0209955685,
-0.0363853537,
-0.0234558545,
-0.0440716185,
-0.0068366933,
-0.0435767248,
-0.020136347,
0.0555241443,
0.0064207716,
0.0248139352,
-0.0442125797,
0.0106343795,
0.0353201181,
0.0004649701,
0.0069650286,
0.0310013015,
0.0545524471,
-0.0143309999,
0.0245901272,
-0.0058673257,
-0.0384771414,
0.0259519741,
0.0621881373,
-0.0262311846,
-0.0552312955,
0.0475605987,
0.0088720974,
0.0058033615,
0.0029888775,
-0.0147076547,
0.0292480532,
-0.0633933991,
0.0154218264,
-0.0137345064,
0.0137731107,
-0.0275168158,
0.0737486184,
-0.0086756796,
0.0174871944,
-0.0123525551,
-0.044365745,
0.0145910475,
-0.0166727938,
-0.0145341717,
0.0330970027,
0.0260148421,
-0.0093132649,
-0.0110170105,
0.0135094151,
-0.038994208,
0.01522444,
-0.0602692924,
0.0002351549,
0.0200838726,
-0.0158714186,
0.0178673975,
-0.0223761108,
0.0090025552,
0.0188196227,
-0.010866968,
0.0015839214,
0.0102280285,
0.0653465241,
0.0808967054,
-0.0438255332,
-0.0769993663,
-0.0220061857,
-0.0200375356,
-0.0614752285,
0.0439130925,
0.0350704975,
-0.0140072769,
0.0005991295,
0.0449878499,
-0.0763463527,
-0.0173904859,
0.0030177173,
-0.0069548772,
0.0118533978,
0.0290740393,
0.0396589898,
0.0197268575,
0.0030260193,
0.0377603583,
0.0955405757,
0.0309290774,
0.0042133252,
-0.0583183542,
-0.0297741648,
0.0057048076,
0.0066592186,
-0.0295991208,
-0.0048985179,
0.0107512753,
0.025801165,
-0.0040176003,
-0.0220612157,
0.0492753126,
-0.0151884519,
-0.0154187456,
-0.0388348736,
-0.030210264,
-0.0446245484,
0.0729840025,
-0.0174784083,
-0.0293742642,
0.0756467432,
-0.0179652199,
0.0303002428,
0.0072966348,
-0.0195464976,
-0.0335400216,
0.0532517098,
0.0343193524,
0.01723589,
0.0074768346,
0.0006273843,
-0.0394705087,
0.0058765244,
0.0327081122,
0.0099285264,
0.0886306167,
-0.0557462536,
0.0071914913,
0.0001418151,
-0.0332139283,
-0.0250900406,
0.0073134345,
-0.0260230917,
0.0552895367,
-0.0206575468,
-0.0107845785,
-0.0036072452,
-0.0116841728,
0.0364934839,
-0.0243591405,
0.0354653187,
-0.0170761812,
-0.0247963835,
0.0414097309,
0.0249640904,
0.0082817106,
0.0461213216,
-0.0109828366,
-0.010439829,
0.0410523415,
-0.0237952713,
0.0068495744,
-0.0087755257,
0.0463200063,
0.024371326,
-0.038340535,
-0.0327885896,
0.0448294543,
0.0369596928,
-0.0235044882,
-0.0022986208,
0.1129253283,
0.0441388562,
-0.0060250526,
0.0404994078,
-0.0239198525,
0.0125857359,
0.0287117958,
-0.0222970434,
-0.0751203746,
-0.0069537405,
0.0166926123,
-0.0308404583,
-0.0287583191,
-0.0462389402,
0.0036969795,
-0.0474528633,
0.0400277339,
-0.0199874062,
-0.0415728875,
-0.0679425448,
-0.0622484162,
0.0191210639,
-0.0004878458,
0.0059762741,
0.0148791596,
-0.0323855653,
-0.0049381205,
-0.0204864908,
-0.0230592676,
-0.0536407828,
0.0756193548,
-0.0444124155,
0.0607598387,
0.0395952649,
-0.0028608893,
-0.0332227647,
-0.1172285378,
0.0357689746,
-0.0240220893,
0.0195545759,
-0.000901549,
-0.0005903752,
0.0072471639,
0.0254582725,
-0.0653225705,
0.001933624,
-0.0360479876,
-0.0658299699,
-0.0397753417,
0.1188594848,
-0.0202776659,
-0.0471154414,
-0.0169433728,
0.0060347081,
-0.0722337365,
0.0991320983,
0.0715104118,
-0.0016481387,
-0.0211754888,
-0.03303767,
-0.054735221,
0.0747726113,
-0.0734653622,
-0.0253390819,
-0.0015480291,
0.0251846816,
-0.090537563,
-0.0517966338,
0.0057340218,
-0.0095754424,
-0.0109657189,
0.0066833566,
-0.0160697065,
-0.0565919019,
-0.0583478324,
0.0227632876,
-0.0205296203,
0.0039192135,
-0.0331022181,
0.0077357828,
0.0303323977,
-0.0170238987,
-0.0327849425,
-0.0108262226,
-0.01515307,
-0.0429275148,
0.0169643871,
-0.0108156931,
0.0267598033,
-0.0144569529,
0.0058026724,
-0.0320309773,
0.0337200873,
0.0100794267,
-0.0819841549,
0.0295215305,
-0.0211989656,
-0.0249939878,
0.0226626936,
0.0252064262,
0.0004579332,
0.0252806023,
0.001117983,
0.0276487656,
-0.0137045924,
-0.0740771517,
0.0451588519,
0.0658340603,
0.0438069366,
0.004427705,
-0.0489071533,
-0.0146236671,
-0.0550148785,
-0.0276177544,
-0.0197812188,
0.0054213912,
0.0099265445,
-0.0076290932,
0.0258778371,
-0.0331049263,
-0.0277140681,
-0.012630458,
0.0520319007,
0.0397852995,
-0.0356372036,
-0.005702192,
0.03178747,
-0.016852133,
0.0123743415,
-0.0174965952,
0.0162287224,
-0.0859944448,
0.0406608097,
-0.0242640525,
0.0433317907,
0.0334870256,
0.0232468378,
-0.0768714473,
0.0340801664,
-0.0364678614,
-0.0385467783,
-0.004798573,
-0.0020801262,
0.0401885398,
-0.0240366049,
-0.0010078583,
-0.0704871416,
-0.0097662285,
-0.0200560223,
0.0008789352,
-0.0288911313,
-0.0097389324,
0.0598654486,
0.049439095,
-0.0241021682,
-0.04318377,
0.0556001626,
-0.0185681246,
0.0257672835,
0.0117966393,
-0.0328809246,
-0.0130213192,
0.005029859,
0.0486728512,
0.0310144424,
-0.0278315134,
0.0000044991,
-0.0692551136,
-0.0940790027,
0.0498618707,
0.0559066497,
0.027678173,
0.0231117755,
0.039467968,
0.0548964553,
0.02250023,
-0.0491947867,
0.0094398148,
-0.0275507439,
-0.0048099081,
-0.009208722,
-0.0423156321,
-5.886655304e-33,
-0.0341788866,
-0.056251999,
0.0114890495,
0.0408278108,
-0.0170088038,
-0.0455112122,
-0.0092233531,
0.0057312869,
-0.025286328,
0.0618678518,
0.0275485329,
-0.0118752727,
-0.0064462749,
-0.0389448032,
0.0347014107,
-0.0190426148,
0.0171595681,
-0.0151854176,
-0.0150172086,
-0.0441268682,
0.0227805153,
-0.0394124165,
0.0456762612,
-0.0460507087,
0.0362880044,
0.0199338775,
0.0386165194,
0.0408833027,
-0.0206351392,
0.0582473651,
-0.0459053665,
0.0515927561,
0.0710195005,
0.0185976662,
-0.0238377862,
-0.0018115483,
-0.0248638168,
-0.0678535774,
0.0601608008,
-0.0346753858,
-0.0118303988,
-0.0299605876,
0.0546670407,
-0.0404975489,
-0.0307814963,
0.0097320033,
0.0714495331,
-0.0380239449,
-0.0038296178,
0.0097022224,
-0.0188757852,
0.0091555808,
0.0071376599,
0.0375743099,
0.0382519253,
0.0001701974,
-0.0230963454,
0.0052812463,
-0.0600376464,
0.0588738732,
-0.0204671919,
-0.0025765779,
0.0444294401,
-0.0220908355,
0.0297757983,
0.0782197863,
0.0557008982,
-0.0383154638,
-0.0530143082,
0.0207138341,
0.0425803326,
0.0578298531,
0.0016719056,
0.0738298073,
0.028192332,
-0.0165860988,
-0.0522035323,
0.0416684039,
-0.0280774813,
0.0715771541,
-0.0241514891,
0.0161285773,
-0.0343883522,
-0.0261673331,
-0.0258164071,
0.0293140374,
-0.0598494746,
-0.0428221896,
0.0337639935,
-0.0620582029,
0.029989766,
-0.0311893485,
-0.001567009,
-0.0144140134,
-0.0105683375,
-0.02346614,
-0.001758881,
0.02326837,
0.0176412165,
-0.0080018984,
-0.0655396208,
-0.0198632535,
0.0017236406,
-0.0223125331,
0.0275052674,
0.0423149765,
0.0170644838,
-0.0030531194,
-0.0177916642,
-0.0122683169,
0.0046002101,
-0.1072933674,
0.0107413819,
-0.0528246909,
0.027358612,
0.0062327296,
-0.0041140136,
0.0104182055,
0.0100813434,
-0.0245977119,
-0.0531877242,
0.0258958582,
-0.0215562619,
0.0407183878,
-0.0214043241,
-0.0020720593,
-0.0407224633,
0.0127095925,
0.057646066,
-0.0109118959,
-0.0046399725,
-0.0173873808,
2.525e-7,
0.040756546,
0.0645882413,
0.0120861353,
0.0429289229,
-0.0178729296,
0.0164745785,
-0.0210607294,
-0.0078814356,
0.01731156,
-0.0287474245,
0.0159974098,
0.0359901376,
-0.0157634113,
0.0531335883,
-0.0126300324,
0.0204172358,
0.0016349441,
-0.0157717168,
-0.0195742343,
0.0159678739,
0.0713648349,
0.0467460528,
0.0109578781,
-0.0116472766,
-0.0129682813,
-0.0318308771,
0.048113253,
-0.0655831695,
-0.0074429978,
-0.0146729145,
0.0110549452,
-0.0423910506,
0.0537508279,
0.0689856932,
0.0451666787,
0.0072094146,
0.0206435379,
0.032402996,
-0.0054544047,
0.0078019602,
-0.021442702,
-0.0411875583,
-0.0080221295,
-0.0848271474,
0.0325476862,
-0.0324185304,
-0.0470520295,
0.0102131069,
-0.0126007898,
0.0087369969,
0.0254653301,
0.0226758979,
-0.0305346176,
-0.013519207,
0.0215870291,
0.0260013063,
-0.0076786894,
-0.0512851588,
0.0009648473,
0.0587218702,
-0.0531422794,
-0.0344235897,
-0.0187716521,
-0.045024924,
0.035602238,
-0.0491924956,
-0.0163457766,
2.560647532e-34,
0.0024745476,
-0.0005417034,
0.0260760039,
0.0133998161,
0.0211455449,
-0.0131534748,
0.0359302126,
0.0379643366,
0.0107547343,
-0.0726016834,
0.0151266027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05406v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05406v2 | Galactic ChitChat: Using Large Language Models to Converse with Astronomy Literature | 2023-04-12T03:02:20 | 2023-09-12T00:42:21 | Ioana Ciucă, Yuan-Sen Ting | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.IM | We demonstrate the potential of the state-of-the-art OpenAI GPT-4 large
language model to engage in meaningful interactions with Astronomy papers using
in-context prompting. To optimize for efficiency, we employ a distillation
technique that effectively reduces the size of the original input paper by
50\%, while maintaining the paragraph structure and overall semantic integrity.
We then explore the model's responses using a multi-document context (ten
distilled documents). Our findings indicate that GPT-4 excels in the
multi-document domain, providing detailed answers contextualized within the
framework of related research findings. Our results showcase the potential of
large language models for the astronomical community, offering a promising
avenue for further exploration, particularly the possibility of utilizing the
models for hypothesis generation. | [
0.0710647479,
0.0636833981,
0.022663869,
0.0224506445,
-0.0209516063,
0.0071356394,
0.0267150942,
0.0403579399,
0.0189546142,
-0.0204253662,
-0.037001539,
-0.040876966,
-0.0033329993,
0.0281208381,
-0.0163510367,
-0.0661438704,
0.0351312757,
-0.062993519,
0.0759979859,
-0.0253578164,
-0.0171015542,
-0.0159957223,
0.0040633143,
0.006308164,
-0.0084083099,
-0.0391163751,
-0.0108449245,
-0.0233676527,
0.0114641134,
-0.0270475037,
-0.0211239811,
0.0682922006,
0.0208291095,
0.095317632,
0.0000017104,
-0.0644129217,
0.0084272381,
0.0268111303,
-0.0004392439,
0.0437738374,
0.0590492487,
-0.0381432734,
-0.0022691339,
-0.0143642472,
-0.0290986449,
-0.0155312642,
0.0708349198,
0.0254426561,
0.0401104987,
0.0501029082,
-0.0064571612,
-0.0489135906,
0.0420976169,
-0.0381675735,
0.0266018324,
-0.0203827098,
0.0444349907,
0.0284617133,
0.0392765738,
0.0573747866,
-0.0161418598,
0.0443524718,
0.0219400097,
-0.0461702459,
0.0176895615,
0.0415099859,
-0.0655991584,
0.0128339995,
0.007435136,
0.0368821546,
0.0552110821,
-0.0305954106,
-0.0141450902,
-0.0076486464,
-0.0386397243,
0.0465133525,
-0.0886329189,
0.0160871055,
0.0073592481,
-0.0002948593,
0.0284097157,
0.0074964915,
0.0128283668,
0.0228883736,
-0.037011236,
0.0877640843,
0.0281928238,
-0.0589567795,
-0.0069782445,
0.0148652084,
-0.0075051971,
-0.0867639557,
0.005220423,
0.0388621427,
-0.0058755269,
0.0271963906,
-0.0203525051,
-0.022973286,
0.0400991663,
-0.0355512314,
0.02060996,
0.0289423205,
0.0050458657,
0.0803210735,
0.0341409631,
0.0193015989,
-0.0204346664,
-0.0451442972,
0.0272922069,
-0.0397957079,
-0.0225044191,
-0.0361694656,
-0.0326008797,
0.003365743,
-0.0155716231,
-0.0533405542,
0.0139339156,
0.0180217456,
0.0397412851,
0.0151371034,
0.0162107777,
-0.0092883762,
-0.0810696632,
-0.0305282082,
-0.0364221558,
0.0401473194,
-0.0134597365,
0.000751447,
0.0253339354,
-0.0614850521,
-0.0165232997,
0.0570765957,
-0.013399899,
-0.0279957615,
-0.0045794845,
0.059169326,
0.0415043384,
-0.0546680056,
0.0332440324,
-0.0376618281,
-0.019117156,
-0.0694513172,
0.0200980268,
-0.0425303616,
0.0160162933,
0.0210794471,
-0.0233471785,
-0.0319719464,
0.0082259262,
0.0233757719,
-0.0429281518,
0.0385366865,
-0.0525694974,
0.0089396499,
0.040362861,
0.0154385464,
-0.0062345085,
0.0477402471,
0.0439819805,
0.0218286254,
0.0505832918,
-0.0158032998,
0.0202178173,
0.0081232386,
0.0029659637,
0.0102347992,
-0.0161016528,
0.0323745161,
-0.0489981249,
0.0426465422,
0.0081249736,
0.0628321618,
-0.0256513301,
0.0083640199,
0.0016100606,
0.0850486159,
-0.0093569113,
0.04066718,
0.0077626868,
-0.0055957804,
0.0158732347,
0.0192536917,
-0.0117641445,
0.0686819851,
-0.0089246547,
0.0103520509,
0.0429384559,
0.0109562762,
-0.0117845824,
-0.007142595,
-0.0124511616,
0.0166836064,
-0.0411609821,
-0.0241144933,
0.0787136555,
0.0042620879,
0.0072866771,
-0.0085299863,
0.0582345836,
-0.0583005771,
0.0061046123,
-0.0136886574,
0.0682984889,
0.0323517136,
0.0637606606,
-0.0322211236,
0.0053314976,
0.0084054405,
0.0302381702,
0.1164261177,
0.0825050697,
-0.018778149,
-0.0249683671,
-0.0396298245,
-0.003951034,
-0.0377776548,
0.0065903091,
0.031164851,
0.0299140252,
0.0069892686,
0.0035446058,
-0.0130194305,
-0.0101070805,
0.0342263766,
-0.0420298241,
-0.0636708885,
-0.0206452496,
-0.0264556706,
0.0378879532,
-0.0150608458,
-0.0359948538,
0.0179638285,
0.0487428866,
-0.0064138109,
0.0023587008,
-0.0043847756,
0.0087435273,
0.0157301966,
0.024156237,
-0.0508865751,
-0.0354867727,
0.0045456593,
-0.0045056082,
-0.0488036275,
0.01457112,
-0.0099480907,
0.0316958353,
-0.0353529453,
-0.0317191184,
-0.0073525179,
0.0068306304,
-0.0321337245,
0.0378380902,
0.011217284,
0.025801314,
0.0528020859,
0.0102731287,
0.0438109189,
-0.0340325832,
-0.0390905254,
0.033497598,
0.037988387,
-0.0291460194,
0.0365258567,
0.0074674594,
-0.0027877816,
-0.0417659804,
-0.0786298811,
-0.013194235,
-0.0090717804,
0.004124403,
0.040257968,
0.012047424,
-0.0235162098,
-0.0176900942,
-0.0095043397,
0.0197828244,
0.0233463868,
0.0108600296,
0.0439431593,
0.0251346529,
0.0043302821,
-0.0453988463,
-0.02310488,
-0.0530025251,
0.0502219908,
0.0709877908,
-0.0344002396,
-0.0790344924,
0.0126622031,
-0.0171797741,
0.0133992881,
-0.008856101,
-0.0043680468,
0.057290528,
-0.0684063286,
0.0130371973,
0.0718150511,
0.0067661386,
0.0397934802,
0.0519385003,
-0.0360661224,
-0.0226698052,
-0.0121425353,
-0.0284654628,
0.0115824901,
-0.0062744417,
0.0034545925,
0.0533808433,
0.0265760887,
-0.0342760235,
-0.0087502766,
-0.0334981494,
0.0169263761,
-0.0143527975,
-0.0095763486,
0.016569335,
-0.0180032831,
-0.0411951989,
0.0170194823,
0.0328470282,
-0.028923383,
0.0587446727,
-0.0553206876,
-0.023968529,
-0.0605329461,
0.0062710778,
-0.0229711272,
0.0414470471,
-0.0223975722,
0.0118401069,
0.0193460826,
-0.0124953482,
-0.0279548354,
0.0463852473,
-0.0318358764,
0.0256783962,
0.0247880556,
-0.055775065,
0.0237986259,
-0.0086168647,
-0.004359493,
-0.0017369329,
-0.0125220157,
-0.013160551,
0.0321495682,
-0.0027273349,
-0.0669165403,
-0.0516768135,
0.0016381243,
0.021101201,
0.010585635,
-0.0377670713,
-0.0252133682,
-0.0413701124,
0.0425627604,
0.1035464779,
0.0093062799,
0.0149212787,
-0.0315162241,
0.0054492657,
0.0613604486,
-0.0076683951,
0.0020237425,
-0.0198403522,
-0.0532097481,
0.0245463736,
-0.0257675871,
0.0055942493,
-0.0056608394,
0.0426773876,
-0.0455062911,
-0.0381980166,
0.1031794101,
0.0306308176,
-0.0610084683,
-0.0236150324,
-0.0221224893,
0.0401943997,
-0.0114587024,
0.0218187924,
-0.096010305,
-0.0033552269,
-0.0264034923,
-0.0201656763,
0.0267252307,
-0.0177930333,
-0.0196540188,
-0.0682940632,
0.0372703001,
0.0042036171,
-0.0308481306,
-0.0103821773,
-0.048909422,
0.0102517782,
0.0105722332,
-0.0277693905,
0.0296800695,
0.0023993666,
-0.0077296002,
-0.0184290428,
0.0380832478,
-0.0434968509,
0.0225885566,
-0.0146749141,
0.0366578735,
0.0375209488,
0.0409755073,
-0.0033815771,
-0.0195532106,
-0.0009004688,
-0.0387399085,
0.0061068903,
0.0042637242,
0.0120137027,
0.0106068291,
0.0258679781,
-0.016040761,
0.0533437431,
-0.0621095151,
0.0051959846,
0.032013353,
0.0743134469,
-0.0490093641,
-0.0398965292,
-0.0503830835,
-0.0111984555,
0.0108411536,
0.0823952779,
0.008817642,
-0.0279133022,
-0.0605103374,
-0.0459637232,
-0.0252242275,
0.0055722562,
0.0097472547,
-0.0328904837,
0.0568462834,
-0.0479486287,
-0.0328382328,
-0.0341794714,
0.001384046,
0.0145021863,
0.0177383982,
0.0152004426,
0.0124660954,
-0.0087631224,
0.0201042593,
0.0303980447,
-0.0423022434,
-0.0094385659,
-0.0504524074,
-0.0119586224,
0.039738901,
0.0112277642,
-0.0211263467,
0.0066426969,
-0.0832613483,
-0.07473699,
-0.0267259106,
0.0122984126,
0.0407305248,
0.009812505,
-0.0247330479,
-0.067807287,
-0.012258362,
-0.005592023,
-0.0169126373,
0.0239072274,
-0.0379589535,
-0.0170177408,
0.0247416738,
0.0045438157,
-0.0155623369,
0.0069485866,
-0.0202736016,
0.0058872295,
-0.0569151528,
-0.0659625977,
0.0160591807,
0.0205158684,
0.017258456,
-0.0269120745,
-0.0010720172,
-0.0069697248,
-0.0061625289,
-0.0578310378,
0.0216707718,
-0.0117532546,
0.0205440652,
0.0125613157,
0.0158204753,
0.0108354986,
0.020944532,
-0.0332927741,
0.019493904,
-0.0500548333,
0.0123214433,
0.0208742302,
0.0297680274,
0.0530675463,
-0.0126773864,
-0.0157123674,
-0.0324812531,
-0.0456091687,
0.0331894681,
-0.0059587485,
0.0586648919,
0.0773879364,
-0.0182566345,
0.0335582234,
0.0404566787,
-0.149245441,
-0.0509290211,
-0.0169017334,
0.0369249992,
0.0214676652,
0.0485987514,
0.0225967038,
-0.097547479,
-0.0226347037,
0.0033485068,
0.0376195423,
0.0557616763,
-0.0214353818,
0.0644932389,
0.0251177903,
-0.0069769882,
0.0044614961,
0.0995794386,
-0.0338992625,
0.0051326831,
0.009624308,
0.0195781775,
-0.0293910783,
-0.0385652706,
-0.043027889,
0.0452376977,
-0.0239624679,
0.0133759761,
-0.0375811644,
-0.0102779865,
-0.0275623687,
0.0275933277,
0.0045851171,
-0.0420565829,
0.0283195656,
0.0538345985,
-0.0141836368,
-0.0328315198,
-0.0020513986,
0.0265505016,
-0.0720887855,
-0.0557240434,
-0.0494319648,
-5.913583308e-33,
-0.0254414324,
-0.0404898711,
0.0281948596,
0.0315542631,
-0.0031673959,
-0.0262776949,
-0.0897013769,
-0.030454075,
-0.0090224538,
0.0135885244,
-0.0013276709,
0.021217946,
-0.00658753,
0.0104907928,
0.0222862829,
0.0146343205,
0.0414614379,
-0.0074589625,
-0.0301133841,
0.0508833006,
0.0576177835,
-0.0020851246,
0.0003668965,
-0.0896096379,
0.0396469124,
0.0042575542,
-0.0096472828,
0.0061701895,
-0.0475760512,
0.0494708233,
-0.077066578,
0.0358358361,
-0.0048047951,
0.015412176,
0.0119217401,
0.0624106601,
-0.0225929618,
-0.0228875931,
0.0019566657,
-0.0044546085,
-0.0202055536,
-0.0278334897,
-0.0064573404,
-0.0158184785,
0.0041518547,
-0.0034243048,
0.0403915942,
-0.0280439388,
-0.036564704,
-0.0078507662,
-0.0617813431,
0.0132935168,
0.0090144062,
0.0272421576,
0.0274810567,
0.0200208742,
0.0042988253,
0.098804377,
-0.0201712046,
0.0555094071,
0.0272933263,
0.0089832656,
-0.0055768192,
-0.0375434794,
0.0302709341,
0.0453168564,
-0.0046959822,
-0.0031042804,
0.0257857312,
-0.0322436355,
-0.0051264577,
0.0134296399,
0.0345944762,
0.0294779856,
0.0552828088,
-0.0013701277,
-0.0504371375,
-0.0034374064,
0.0242771599,
-0.002634241,
-0.0038098011,
0.0260335058,
-0.0022964436,
0.0199765805,
0.0372572169,
-0.031019995,
-0.0243491326,
-0.0546365939,
0.0051329914,
-0.0319894813,
-0.005351041,
0.0078444798,
0.0144665008,
-0.0578826591,
-0.0222012587,
0.0499985591,
-0.0470938087,
0.0426903926,
0.0125689022,
-0.0002119249,
-0.0898725241,
-0.0107898554,
0.0365005061,
0.0111816581,
-0.0000714054,
0.0372632034,
0.0137728499,
0.0265226699,
-0.0436862484,
0.0057996609,
0.0049193315,
-0.0191672705,
0.0430681966,
-0.0076021273,
0.0055893902,
0.0073430366,
0.0306363609,
0.071616672,
0.011695642,
0.0140553629,
-0.0247600172,
-0.0074094441,
-0.0255578477,
-0.0166474227,
-0.0236210804,
-0.0040688319,
-0.0071977526,
-0.0158452168,
0.0331811793,
-0.0435993671,
-0.0060258647,
0.0425978303,
2.441e-7,
0.0423919633,
0.0539808646,
0.0494980998,
0.011038878,
0.0423395112,
-0.0072257603,
-0.0210555308,
0.0235495772,
0.0477153771,
0.0319727957,
-0.0231687147,
-0.0400598273,
0.0225616135,
0.0353868864,
-0.1259817928,
-0.0204372238,
-0.0591755621,
-0.0698918477,
-0.0785183161,
-0.0182070248,
0.0432344899,
0.0354039185,
-0.0127244564,
-0.0028245659,
0.0020175499,
-0.0346766338,
0.0640416071,
-0.0040955171,
0.0379671566,
0.0511674359,
-0.0227932837,
-0.01205556,
-0.0259789415,
0.029467918,
-0.0168246571,
0.0255094618,
0.0010902807,
0.0474638045,
0.0031293954,
-0.0055121938,
0.0270236637,
-0.0135414517,
0.0343334787,
-0.0583934374,
0.0362547487,
-0.0275001973,
-0.0351778492,
-0.0031289349,
0.0019981156,
-0.0579094552,
-0.0090609696,
-0.0349244475,
0.0068524657,
-0.0186816789,
-0.0236339383,
0.0023140251,
0.0149353985,
-0.0630017519,
-0.0042173732,
0.0192801338,
-0.0671861842,
-0.0428466424,
-0.0262312945,
-0.0576224029,
0.0181963462,
-0.0103727635,
-0.0069228793,
2.3819003e-34,
0.0566553138,
-0.0001975652,
-0.0347255059,
0.0258851126,
0.0359752066,
-0.0021648379,
0.0189124979,
0.030732844,
0.0416301973,
-0.117679365,
-0.0262100883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05578v1 | Does Informativeness Matter? Active Learning for Educational Dialogue Act Classification | 2023-04-12T02:42:20 | 2023-04-12T02:42:20 | Wei Tan, Jionghao Lin, David Lang, Guanliang Chen, Dragan Gasevic, Lan Du, Wray Buntine | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Dialogue Acts (DAs) can be used to explain what expert tutors do and what
students know during the tutoring process. Most empirical studies adopt the
random sampling method to obtain sentence samples for manual annotation of DAs,
which are then used to train DA classifiers. However, these studies have paid
little attention to sample informativeness, which can reflect the information
quantity of the selected samples and inform the extent to which a classifier
can learn patterns. Notably, the informativeness level may vary among the
samples and the classifier might only need a small amount of low informative
samples to learn the patterns. Random sampling may overlook sample
informativeness, which consumes human labelling costs and contributes less to
training the classifiers. As an alternative, researchers suggest employing
statistical sampling methods of Active Learning (AL) to identify the
informative samples for training the classifiers. However, the use of AL
methods in educational DA classification tasks is under-explored. In this
paper, we examine the informativeness of annotated sentence samples. Then, the
study investigates how the AL methods can select informative samples to support
DA classifiers in the AL sampling process. The results reveal that most
annotated sentences present low informativeness in the training dataset and the
patterns of these sentences can be easily captured by the DA classifier. We
also demonstrate how AL methods can reduce the cost of manual annotation in the
AL sampling process. | [
0.0525498763,
-0.0251083765,
-0.0558559932,
0.0189841148,
-0.0089338971,
0.0268537495,
0.0177421905,
-0.0304654762,
0.0189066846,
-0.1223865375,
0.0243603513,
-0.0085610757,
-0.0209365562,
0.0135985855,
0.0027380872,
-0.0656886995,
0.0184216686,
-0.0081701493,
0.0456275791,
0.0170966052,
0.0108094281,
-0.0194307305,
-0.0458323509,
0.037847247,
-0.0176005028,
-0.0081785582,
-0.0376517512,
-0.0511777326,
0.0170607585,
0.0113275331,
0.0421046801,
0.06604366,
-0.00022603,
-0.0133201415,
0.0000017785,
-0.0568216257,
0.0089467708,
-0.0338187926,
-0.0366574191,
0.035582535,
-0.0298356991,
0.0552159995,
0.0481393635,
0.01450931,
-0.0570011772,
-0.0126668159,
0.0277065374,
0.0337675512,
0.0450930893,
0.0270177722,
0.0104768276,
0.0137604345,
0.0191768948,
-0.0051525189,
0.0304498896,
-0.0207885616,
0.0269851983,
0.0482201986,
-0.0084919371,
0.0274011139,
-0.0026115624,
0.0274468791,
-0.004438065,
-0.0674681142,
-0.0064084111,
-0.0065337806,
-0.0317324623,
-0.0051142643,
0.0067994068,
0.0501494184,
0.0816875547,
0.0270353202,
0.0114677874,
-0.0553302094,
0.0555096418,
0.0749321803,
-0.0463253073,
-0.00408486,
0.0023225523,
0.0181717202,
0.0084592812,
0.0005292259,
-0.0161368381,
0.0064457948,
0.0516626015,
-0.0002706254,
-0.0669471398,
-0.0417323187,
0.0391073376,
0.0431537181,
-0.0147215631,
-0.0343607068,
0.0100238854,
0.0439983122,
-0.020357985,
0.023171477,
-0.0111035798,
-0.0339439288,
0.0402817614,
-0.0392360501,
0.0040684058,
0.0086099682,
-0.0183477234,
0.0249854233,
0.0448916815,
0.0298011675,
0.0587356612,
0.0655201375,
-0.0378438346,
0.0561412126,
-0.0760208517,
-0.0134740891,
-0.0470755547,
0.0736196935,
-0.014663781,
-0.0029418019,
-0.0393580496,
0.0005023273,
-0.0407227017,
0.0057400898,
-0.0374047346,
-0.0099065965,
-0.0310890228,
0.0632447526,
-0.0289241318,
-0.0122454204,
-0.0036583003,
0.0454496406,
-0.0093460111,
-0.033941336,
0.0209426414,
0.0164788235,
0.0134561406,
0.0109341554,
-0.0201448258,
0.013077097,
-0.0076592853,
-0.0370522514,
-0.022741111,
-0.0277277809,
0.0124294162,
-0.0027676737,
0.0002039055,
-0.0142173097,
-0.0113307657,
-0.0287617594,
0.0123720123,
-0.0024404379,
0.0170995798,
0.0099624991,
0.0064512887,
0.0244365726,
0.0253988765,
-0.0201285351,
0.0347516164,
-0.0030597486,
-0.0115421116,
0.0697813928,
0.0374744721,
-0.0004506558,
0.064094305,
0.0006672565,
0.0272431057,
0.0132880546,
0.0233511459,
0.0031665792,
0.0499120057,
0.0149708344,
-0.0401450656,
-0.0154306293,
-0.0468305685,
-0.0019938836,
-0.0267828386,
0.0097488258,
0.0282367971,
0.0252835788,
-0.0632508174,
-0.0484261326,
0.04383884,
0.0767082199,
0.0618788972,
0.0360524282,
0.0027557774,
-0.0356077701,
-0.0052763093,
-0.0190394912,
-0.0027225304,
-0.021997232,
-0.019757038,
-0.1018500403,
-0.0076650232,
-0.0141855301,
0.0045317551,
0.0462147072,
0.020276932,
0.0089037614,
-0.0082803853,
0.0480430052,
0.0531763881,
-0.0059055514,
-0.0102620851,
-0.0609404556,
0.0233611371,
0.0020972474,
0.0026649844,
-0.0736490414,
-0.0551437326,
-0.0445009246,
0.0555768795,
-0.0045846505,
0.0562883839,
-0.0701132715,
-0.0046701408,
-0.0517493971,
-0.0489218086,
-0.026714718,
0.0283506401,
0.0022941821,
-0.0091278674,
-0.0198900681,
-0.0029829252,
0.0188001245,
-0.0798126012,
0.0493966863,
0.0010158441,
-0.0529196598,
0.0253308751,
0.0100242253,
0.0776439905,
0.0205520075,
0.0059052571,
-0.0340300836,
0.0022316691,
0.0003301798,
-0.0021740349,
0.0062458324,
-0.006347918,
-0.0456540063,
0.0168396253,
-0.0038215104,
-0.0408196449,
0.0133556686,
-0.051958397,
-0.0309014041,
-0.0402273908,
-0.0464120954,
-0.0413957536,
-0.0357458591,
0.0161666702,
-0.026903607,
-0.0084408047,
-0.0449420735,
0.0425085425,
0.0002174912,
0.0065356297,
0.0324515477,
-0.0288611166,
0.0467672087,
-0.0562818646,
0.0035052109,
-0.0180594791,
-0.0065410081,
-0.0156875309,
0.0199680552,
0.0269708727,
-0.0414723046,
0.0222607981,
-0.0378055759,
-0.0094304606,
-0.0091139693,
-0.0027356024,
-0.0223984271,
-0.008767671,
-0.0046241763,
0.0005612638,
-0.047006581,
-0.0088060517,
-0.0272593647,
-0.0012787543,
0.0364660025,
0.0551959649,
-0.0360568762,
-0.0359110348,
0.0121114803,
-0.0143008111,
0.0226563867,
0.0563916117,
-0.0558895729,
-0.0283350609,
0.0388759039,
0.0263628643,
-0.0089211278,
-0.0168887302,
-0.0415141992,
0.0203018896,
0.0165151339,
-0.0701050833,
0.0741261095,
0.0231607072,
0.0608627014,
-0.0083442247,
-0.0030313348,
-0.0541621521,
0.0565402992,
-0.0301930439,
0.0180628914,
-0.0596270077,
-0.0602197684,
0.0157960281,
0.0374694541,
0.0051569762,
-0.029237695,
-0.019863354,
-0.0087258117,
-0.0194261149,
-0.0266368221,
-0.0468182862,
-0.0145302443,
-0.0311449505,
0.010618587,
0.0056015821,
-0.046549242,
0.0506039746,
0.0087836441,
0.0082882689,
-0.0753074139,
-0.0006516901,
-0.0152607085,
0.0432502143,
0.0128468992,
-0.0055944561,
-0.0094066812,
-0.0363565534,
-0.001395872,
-0.0363218449,
0.0649844483,
-0.0175875351,
0.0207121726,
-0.0621793643,
-0.0069072652,
-0.00430403,
-0.0301207285,
-0.0584967174,
-0.0298579056,
0.0086118644,
0.0224294085,
0.0010737394,
0.0041952902,
-0.0067457831,
0.0079195378,
-0.0033305322,
0.0194043573,
-0.0059913257,
-0.0182537325,
-0.0083705643,
0.0108480044,
0.0265900586,
-0.0052784546,
-0.0497630723,
-0.0220057443,
0.050776761,
0.0269476939,
-0.0074724322,
0.0127192819,
0.0180512667,
0.0000191475,
0.0215991996,
-0.0363437198,
-0.0312394612,
0.0348490998,
0.0182099883,
-0.0287691467,
0.0193876214,
0.0902776122,
0.042412594,
-0.0242758635,
-0.0088923573,
0.0193474777,
-0.0523281544,
-0.0139980465,
0.0066636144,
-0.0583820716,
-0.0156846698,
-0.0450127609,
0.0372093543,
-0.0591633506,
-0.0280407332,
0.0154015087,
-0.0760341659,
0.0512349308,
-0.0014534476,
-0.0277807079,
0.0128697781,
-0.0241402965,
0.0162191167,
-0.0260139983,
0.0292166099,
-0.0664070696,
0.0136466846,
0.014948206,
0.1004615575,
-0.0584104434,
-0.0247937776,
-0.000002882,
0.0337990336,
0.0204758346,
0.0016493752,
0.0629460812,
-0.0019401227,
0.0258052684,
0.041229099,
-0.0064573744,
0.005200095,
-0.0000223084,
0.0839775205,
-0.0000696424,
0.006857045,
0.0247416031,
0.0515597127,
-0.0048157014,
-0.0132649746,
0.0603031144,
0.0501382239,
-0.0343124829,
0.0570331216,
-0.0269638859,
0.0243007485,
0.0448681638,
0.0475234054,
0.0358077511,
-0.0179200433,
0.005135654,
-0.0088360887,
0.009803501,
-0.0381078012,
-0.002780891,
0.0182978902,
-0.0440872833,
-0.0075831539,
-0.0546389222,
-0.0682374015,
0.0540983081,
0.0593739301,
0.0277120899,
0.0533855297,
0.0193733983,
0.0407387801,
0.0014910584,
-0.0013254336,
-0.0323671252,
-0.0092854202,
0.0066555552,
-0.1161649674,
0.0094033228,
-0.0211815611,
-0.053909678,
-0.0049150838,
-0.021012729,
-0.0669551939,
0.0316495299,
0.0440670401,
0.0225507934,
0.0814583153,
0.0120939296,
-0.0194373336,
0.006548984,
0.0048761405,
0.0383002795,
-0.0290938001,
0.0596144274,
0.0248770788,
-0.0090673398,
0.0076291128,
-0.0181018375,
-0.0068887398,
0.0310011469,
-0.0028863964,
-0.0841743276,
-0.0779605061,
-0.0005578151,
0.0217398014,
0.0357315242,
0.0200778432,
-0.039841067,
-0.0417317972,
0.0516879559,
0.0142485565,
-0.0228229407,
-0.0417192802,
0.0237872936,
-0.0118690496,
0.0209124964,
-0.0322837755,
-0.0023359016,
-0.0227576867,
0.0592967384,
-0.0258499477,
0.0294937082,
0.0348499417,
0.0086754784,
-0.0072950092,
-0.0192768928,
-0.033674784,
-0.0052196113,
0.0745276809,
0.0523922741,
0.0645854622,
0.0992068946,
0.0196034703,
0.025752319,
0.0059317229,
-0.0194641333,
-0.0550268255,
-0.0069816168,
-0.0477858894,
0.0519407429,
-0.0000312334,
-0.048721958,
0.0136884199,
-0.0401492678,
0.0045662075,
0.0379454046,
0.0537907109,
0.0228866041,
-0.0449955985,
0.022983944,
0.0192615539,
0.011613992,
0.0364916474,
0.0656966791,
-0.0144358547,
0.0210448988,
-0.0300069544,
-0.0386329256,
-0.0489120185,
-0.0180272814,
0.0770045519,
0.0245060865,
0.0169499964,
0.0229103342,
-0.0234974772,
-0.0059695668,
-0.0195730738,
-0.0322175995,
0.019342199,
-0.0143379113,
0.0386130884,
0.0625919253,
0.0039064335,
-0.0039785774,
-0.0757156536,
-0.0138627673,
0.001923445,
0.0214155465,
-0.0387830697,
-4.954944155e-33,
-0.038110476,
-0.0135609424,
-0.0163872819,
0.0925850347,
0.0011755527,
0.0342215151,
-0.0038858803,
-0.0190381519,
-0.0050633475,
0.0643402711,
0.0304341689,
0.0168087576,
0.0209284704,
0.0173439756,
0.0232237205,
-0.044641301,
0.0270853247,
-0.0085179778,
-0.0100721344,
0.0392762497,
0.0200332049,
-0.0209943503,
0.0328886025,
-0.1043315381,
0.077729255,
-0.0050634653,
0.0035253617,
0.0139521062,
-0.0257882923,
0.0511240549,
0.0110435979,
0.0430211239,
0.0112400539,
-0.0270999745,
0.0228215139,
0.0015826649,
-0.045186583,
-0.0510067642,
0.0166293439,
0.0541093014,
0.0072002481,
-0.0199776758,
-0.0322059095,
-0.0068134721,
-0.0113143325,
-0.0128204962,
0.069163993,
-0.0194672197,
-0.0322293043,
-0.0647763386,
-0.0453068689,
0.0124370623,
-0.0945441052,
-0.0149088781,
-0.0121960137,
0.0201601461,
0.0029295548,
-0.0518224426,
0.011366101,
0.036118798,
0.0469307154,
0.0055035488,
-0.0341402888,
0.0058646677,
-0.0039237752,
0.0750594959,
0.0363601483,
0.018947145,
0.0232083667,
0.0205653459,
-0.0274464916,
-0.0031143057,
-0.0024468875,
0.0484902076,
0.0065306062,
0.0334044844,
-0.0710275844,
0.0170276985,
0.1098255962,
-0.0084614931,
0.0133061018,
-0.0513654314,
-0.0844291076,
-0.0322732814,
-0.0169302877,
0.0191040449,
0.0362083912,
-0.0297356639,
0.0193965379,
-0.0087275719,
-0.0369031318,
0.0244151652,
-0.0030280326,
-0.018668877,
-0.0154403923,
-0.0090803243,
-0.000573407,
-0.0074466034,
-0.0515332855,
-0.0616741925,
-0.0478164218,
-0.073080875,
0.01501323,
-0.0270885956,
0.0428571552,
0.0093600368,
0.0624329112,
0.0169850606,
-0.0076640393,
-0.0172717869,
0.003143538,
0.0119560705,
-0.0243129786,
0.0225635692,
-0.0025943602,
0.0023957673,
-0.0220159851,
0.0637241006,
0.009064083,
-0.0382993296,
-0.0223753098,
-0.0542198531,
-0.0302985162,
-0.0274683032,
-0.0440792069,
-0.0414005816,
-0.0018765926,
-0.0254197661,
-0.030092407,
-0.0543139726,
0.0241399575,
-0.0145857846,
2.362e-7,
0.0046234727,
0.0235545058,
-0.0210433062,
-0.0292864498,
0.0031418924,
0.0386457704,
0.0212772172,
-0.0188644603,
0.0761824623,
0.0132258898,
0.0413278565,
-0.0107441759,
0.0116647454,
0.0431508645,
-0.1269861162,
-0.0867552385,
-0.0219513606,
-0.0450540408,
-0.0164901204,
0.0369389504,
0.0452046692,
0.0339296199,
0.0333709233,
-0.0052767433,
-0.0117604416,
-0.0996793807,
-0.0049998634,
-0.0222286992,
-0.0101367366,
0.0792472214,
0.0609887987,
-0.0392516106,
0.0150775611,
0.0595423728,
-0.0355381668,
0.0307035167,
0.0066101612,
0.0418284722,
0.0109967869,
0.0066626631,
-0.0186034516,
-0.0161455926,
0.0386176929,
0.0300090723,
0.0548271164,
-0.050599128,
-0.01566061,
0.0539163053,
-0.0305071287,
-0.0701579303,
0.0155058792,
0.0298708938,
0.0385694206,
0.0098493705,
-0.0300570149,
-0.0254349671,
0.0125529896,
-0.0505358838,
0.0215012133,
-0.047341764,
-0.0282176044,
-0.053072203,
0.0310508981,
0.0109417625,
-0.0105809784,
-0.0298874173,
0.022864949,
1.912371122e-34,
0.0385419726,
0.0095069809,
0.0216486659,
0.0460531116,
0.0001567902,
0.0259900875,
0.0268016811,
0.0199620053,
0.038298063,
-0.0186522733,
0.0105180591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05534v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05534v3 | Distinguishing ChatGPT(-3.5, -4)-generated and human-written papers through Japanese stylometric analysis | 2023-04-11T23:29:56 | 2023-06-03T01:52:58 | Wataru Zaitsu, Mingzhe Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the first half of 2023, text-generative artificial intelligence (AI),
including ChatGPT, equipped with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, from OpenAI, has attracted
considerable attention worldwide. In this study, first, we compared Japanese
stylometric features of texts generated by GPT (-3.5 and -4) and those written
by humans. In this work, we performed multi-dimensional scaling (MDS) to
confirm the distributions of 216 texts of three classes (72 academic papers
written by 36 single authors, 72 texts generated by GPT-3.5, and 72 texts
generated by GPT-4 on the basis of the titles of the aforementioned papers)
focusing on the following stylometric features: (1) bigrams of parts-of-speech,
(2) bigram of postpositional particle words, (3) positioning of commas, and (4)
rate of function words. MDS revealed distinct distributions at each stylometric
feature of GPT (-3.5 and -4) and human. Although GPT-4 is more powerful than
GPT-3.5 because it has more parameters, both GPT (-3.5 and -4) distributions
are likely to overlap. These results indicate that although the number of
parameters may increase in the future, GPT-generated texts may not be close to
that written by humans in terms of stylometric features. Second, we verified
the classification performance of random forest (RF) for two classes (GPT and
human) focusing on Japanese stylometric features. This study revealed the high
performance of RF in each stylometric feature: The RF classifier focusing on
the rate of function words achieved 98.1% accuracy. Furthermore the RF
classifier focusing on all stylometric features reached 100% in terms of all
performance indexes (accuracy, recall, precision, and F1 score). This study
concluded that at this stage we human discriminate ChatGPT from human limited
to Japanese language. | [
0.0487073548,
0.0208862219,
-0.0069905864,
0.010414754,
-0.0317319408,
0.0088538323,
0.0305081345,
0.048928,
0.0020030753,
-0.033843156,
-0.0213949978,
-0.04828275,
0.0419555381,
0.0313989706,
0.0066515747,
-0.0573576503,
0.0197784975,
0.0017735622,
0.0474881083,
0.0275483113,
0.0189336594,
-0.0075747059,
0.0354793817,
0.0512924567,
-0.0045978306,
-0.0310719628,
0.0256521925,
-0.0503412858,
0.0148523469,
-0.0193802938,
-0.0238146335,
0.0517673977,
-0.0474071316,
0.086210981,
0.0000018604,
-0.0558400266,
0.0079886224,
0.0137199657,
0.0536003821,
0.0119914021,
0.0701072067,
0.0216966495,
-0.0489802472,
0.0315981396,
-0.0475375243,
-0.0230913274,
0.0506207943,
0.0492226072,
-0.0225808993,
0.090218395,
-0.0324845687,
-0.0776666552,
0.0888116956,
0.021369705,
0.0254832078,
0.0293750931,
0.0068925461,
-0.0453665778,
-0.0179567281,
0.0235332903,
0.0086799441,
-0.0174832456,
0.0174582954,
-0.002425428,
-0.0142324194,
0.0338929184,
-0.0626335517,
0.0161566827,
0.0190387703,
-0.019589616,
0.007474327,
-0.053439118,
0.0064578196,
-0.0023373,
-0.0035635845,
0.0317714773,
-0.0367318429,
0.0189428665,
-0.0546432398,
0.0013535185,
0.0394170024,
0.0209208727,
-0.0051928801,
-0.0153863179,
0.0028541503,
0.0672641397,
0.0264615007,
-0.0514880456,
-0.0088408291,
-0.0306801498,
-0.0400898457,
-0.0332333371,
-0.0002148618,
0.0061783036,
0.0306984745,
0.017737845,
-0.0375354029,
-0.0905904695,
0.0407173187,
-0.0723759681,
-0.0232237857,
0.0092176395,
0.0041204882,
-0.0217050333,
-0.0083713848,
0.0463188998,
-0.0151267359,
0.0272850394,
-0.0115363747,
0.0071453163,
-0.0518568829,
-0.0453529283,
-0.0339570642,
0.0138689289,
0.0238814801,
-0.0420129709,
-0.0891496912,
0.0092872689,
0.0433381349,
-0.056289468,
0.0229299087,
-0.0055003604,
-0.0525935963,
0.0300464053,
-0.0170091707,
0.0031300343,
-0.0136822816,
-0.0061098947,
-0.0294476449,
0.0055943974,
0.0400730669,
0.0724748522,
0.0138874482,
-0.0289672986,
0.0091880662,
0.0241037142,
0.0053518363,
-0.0340810642,
-0.0165140405,
-0.0115954466,
-0.0560351387,
-0.0270683728,
-0.0073746787,
-0.0501493067,
-0.0436566137,
0.011970982,
-0.0107835811,
-0.0308177955,
-0.0037466274,
0.0450222902,
-0.0379220992,
0.0209109001,
-0.0201928522,
0.010010561,
0.0558966398,
-0.0380394459,
0.0187936407,
-0.0138057545,
0.0607105084,
0.0105366074,
0.0644526705,
-0.0285206046,
0.0576510318,
0.0386139154,
-0.0168864243,
-0.0202294961,
0.0327429287,
-0.0311780963,
0.0054511637,
0.0118991919,
0.0131575866,
0.0474443585,
0.0028722838,
-0.0078633251,
0.0397131369,
0.0717322752,
0.0247495379,
0.0690798908,
0.0323860496,
-0.0027022292,
0.0459996313,
0.046288006,
0.0096202185,
-0.0099083846,
-0.1074076369,
0.0405685715,
-0.0113146752,
0.0057563768,
0.014546195,
-0.0403406583,
-0.0441263504,
-0.0056651412,
0.0054339985,
-0.0648058951,
0.0622544475,
-0.0087905917,
-0.0319253094,
-0.0201136116,
0.000716864,
-0.0529632419,
-0.0617383122,
-0.0374243371,
0.0014933938,
0.001626114,
0.0380962081,
-0.0425847694,
0.0363952443,
0.0315001309,
-0.0289850626,
0.0452148691,
0.0152042564,
0.0193926878,
-0.0404122248,
-0.0331373736,
0.0137607837,
0.021698134,
-0.0083544469,
0.0344152153,
0.0380251817,
0.0671093613,
0.006679615,
-0.0050195814,
-0.0580786839,
0.0391714014,
-0.0062557543,
-0.0169261377,
0.0018306015,
-0.0165591948,
0.0566961057,
0.0098409979,
-0.0358287022,
0.0348851345,
-0.008992142,
-0.0413993075,
-0.0190234948,
0.0445018932,
0.0016730593,
0.0312752388,
0.0295607522,
0.0024917845,
0.0122226765,
0.038471777,
0.0129038431,
-0.0308363512,
-0.0159989912,
-0.0098152542,
0.0240865797,
-0.0796156898,
0.0271985829,
-0.0342428461,
0.0417578444,
-0.0252670553,
0.0686762407,
0.0152178239,
0.0318686776,
-0.0297367815,
-0.0447351746,
0.0863896757,
-0.0084948763,
-0.0195237417,
0.0255969819,
0.0033156278,
0.0191221014,
0.0310858395,
0.0285260789,
-0.0012875298,
-0.0535934046,
-0.0904270262,
0.0119761061,
-0.0074184579,
0.0475132726,
0.0109346528,
-0.0149840396,
-0.0340793952,
0.0043469975,
-0.014746014,
-0.0051585757,
0.0062001999,
0.006047389,
0.0638486296,
-0.0217179153,
0.0098621445,
-0.0040208828,
-0.0006509058,
-0.02951077,
0.021275891,
0.0646813586,
-0.0473309904,
-0.0440836549,
0.0617570616,
-0.0058889459,
-0.0177159999,
0.0071038576,
-0.0680198446,
0.0254242234,
-0.0218737014,
0.0436403006,
0.0151160117,
0.0467006266,
0.031898953,
0.0211435221,
0.0389945544,
0.0248991176,
-0.0119956248,
-0.0061804382,
0.0079373978,
0.0139143569,
-0.0170009062,
0.0623182096,
0.0284074377,
0.024107717,
-0.0158425756,
-0.0293358564,
0.0126891714,
-0.0254581999,
0.0087925233,
0.0084180776,
-0.0098247891,
-0.0274016485,
0.0294960383,
0.025955772,
-0.0436296426,
0.0331873856,
-0.0359575264,
0.0006772609,
-0.1020940617,
0.0103349965,
-0.0457679592,
0.0587523952,
0.0192443728,
-0.004095057,
0.0225458592,
-0.0373269245,
-0.0410643779,
0.0216512643,
0.0529094487,
-0.0125353718,
-0.0548640527,
-0.0284173582,
0.0020458619,
-0.0132646495,
0.0173123889,
0.022809403,
-0.0974373817,
0.015249325,
-0.0024830929,
0.052346658,
-0.0742166191,
0.0062180255,
0.0317853242,
0.0089353863,
0.0352945775,
-0.0398251824,
-0.0161082,
0.0212532114,
0.0408717431,
0.0367971472,
-0.0261702575,
-0.0105551826,
0.0094275698,
-0.0024923519,
0.0270418841,
-0.0092746252,
0.0209547207,
-0.0225670785,
-0.0406554379,
-0.0055316752,
-0.0575145446,
-0.0699540973,
0.0249060523,
0.022338029,
-0.0168003924,
0.0260035433,
0.1221653372,
0.0272103269,
-0.0484957173,
-0.0352139063,
-0.0419994257,
0.0340206288,
-0.0154317934,
0.0348566025,
-0.0706962049,
0.0076123499,
-0.0161220506,
0.0166468509,
-0.0476549789,
-0.0143979667,
0.0086306566,
-0.1057035401,
0.0427547954,
-0.0051773652,
-0.1012630686,
0.0044836765,
-0.0337857902,
-0.0350496992,
0.0137486327,
-0.0049876813,
-0.0208089855,
-0.0294034537,
0.028778227,
0.0016799513,
-0.1178810075,
-0.0251537766,
-0.0127411764,
0.0023638571,
-0.0190785527,
0.0341438539,
0.0807432905,
-0.0426921844,
-0.0093582505,
0.0088056121,
0.0029283699,
0.0221001785,
-0.0446701422,
0.056807939,
0.0304049831,
-0.0108048078,
-0.04379455,
0.0246627536,
0.001643364,
0.0116395997,
0.0417017303,
0.0376945548,
-0.0111797256,
-0.0295774769,
-0.0339193009,
-0.018400142,
-0.0152602829,
0.0254886709,
0.0084011881,
-0.0317478999,
-0.0773382038,
-0.0108847059,
0.0291710421,
0.0204533637,
-0.0198515821,
-0.0104150595,
-0.0242496021,
-0.06836202,
-0.1073007882,
-0.0560312606,
-0.0227878261,
0.0170170739,
0.0051658791,
0.0370029695,
-0.0106534706,
0.0185973458,
-0.0118374657,
-0.0483629592,
0.0404824466,
0.0006347544,
-0.0541017577,
0.0058512627,
0.0281918272,
-0.0220202617,
-0.0025543929,
-0.0073738,
-0.009476346,
-0.0412181728,
0.0005850913,
0.0118357921,
0.0234578121,
-0.0009205121,
-0.0071480526,
-0.0390428938,
0.0111350641,
0.0667934641,
-0.0072987489,
-0.002256484,
0.0174037628,
-0.0307846237,
-0.0119429883,
-0.0090120453,
0.0128832357,
0.0107635763,
-0.0179360453,
-0.026826255,
-0.0095119514,
-0.0235930383,
0.007951078,
0.0583995767,
0.0499877743,
-0.0524057075,
-0.0185418148,
-0.0162657145,
-0.0073777991,
-0.047104843,
0.0147862872,
-0.0145444507,
-0.0231205467,
0.0317535885,
0.012921189,
-0.0607940443,
0.0242335573,
-0.0135986619,
0.0151785454,
-0.0377597958,
0.0246863421,
0.0043845405,
0.091307126,
-0.0321263112,
-0.0156070236,
0.0094142612,
-0.0353968777,
0.0023888622,
0.036373131,
0.0195870735,
0.0606770925,
-0.0132491998,
0.0056604561,
0.019382501,
0.0504441485,
-0.1030994058,
-0.0168083776,
-0.0287581757,
0.030946454,
0.0249723494,
0.0034260978,
0.0404324904,
-0.0633460581,
-0.0233953856,
-0.0135144591,
0.0543924905,
0.0286904238,
0.0256274529,
-0.0389464498,
-0.0209571049,
-0.0399165899,
-0.0307076257,
0.1161728203,
0.0565253831,
-0.0365222916,
0.0179942083,
-0.080720678,
-0.0095596611,
-0.0138699273,
0.0317477882,
0.0187385138,
0.0190687906,
-0.0313511156,
-0.0591751114,
-0.0282276664,
0.0171349812,
0.0151338559,
0.0414148793,
-0.0299490485,
-0.0089929812,
0.0558097959,
-0.0432556644,
0.0161029249,
-0.0336653143,
-0.0062233196,
-0.005056682,
-0.0047629271,
0.0114734974,
-5.362934e-33,
-0.0132255582,
-0.0541556403,
-0.0041359062,
0.0699404255,
-0.0069498424,
-0.0216619149,
-0.0210125744,
-0.0086089196,
0.0035829938,
0.0190242399,
-0.0536563396,
-0.007618051,
0.0114457756,
0.0092681246,
0.0501558334,
0.0379955545,
-0.0070393579,
-0.0285136998,
-0.0028496729,
0.0339093469,
0.0595628023,
-0.0094611216,
0.0535103865,
-0.0414575338,
0.0183144305,
-0.0265123714,
-0.0048422236,
-0.0348329321,
-0.0111255096,
0.0250529367,
-0.0185599439,
0.0477697253,
0.0239154547,
-0.0211616512,
-0.0135204252,
0.0001862875,
-0.0193385165,
-0.0530944131,
-0.0042937775,
0.0147405723,
0.0237410311,
-0.031681329,
0.0353092812,
-0.0198527891,
-0.0239375606,
-0.0084789302,
0.0825687572,
-0.0144793959,
-0.0532096848,
-0.0666591376,
-0.0636909977,
0.0310256053,
0.0186494347,
0.0306112114,
-0.0099315494,
-0.0233795829,
-0.02784089,
-0.0018599957,
0.007834468,
0.0040641692,
-0.0033414306,
0.0035248382,
-0.026052678,
0.0015683016,
0.0048416588,
0.0098173534,
0.0284667388,
0.0253377724,
-0.023011487,
-0.0122624906,
0.0303085819,
-0.0015452791,
0.0449838303,
0.0920280293,
0.1007118896,
-0.0366096683,
-0.0367321558,
0.0562914312,
0.025220396,
-0.0153104234,
-0.0062413281,
-0.0115177222,
-0.0644584373,
-0.0410595573,
0.0603118911,
0.0231823549,
-0.0015616434,
-0.0402894951,
0.0196823329,
-0.0618829615,
-0.0036844367,
0.0008598484,
0.0057133706,
-0.0386258438,
-0.0221276004,
0.0331839547,
-0.0372749232,
0.0794927701,
-0.0382605605,
-0.0133194411,
-0.0078237569,
-0.0350506008,
-0.015883429,
0.0355433822,
0.028888179,
0.0062904353,
0.0469407812,
0.0085180681,
-0.06315054,
0.0059829098,
0.0313713066,
0.002101064,
0.0409886502,
0.0290216003,
-0.0122430408,
-0.012843227,
0.050786484,
-0.002490151,
0.048211731,
0.0267174952,
-0.0652649403,
-0.0395745449,
0.0163408816,
-0.0372116193,
-0.013798533,
0.0057726274,
0.0067679384,
0.0169521496,
-0.002564759,
-0.0335862935,
-0.0019569586,
-0.0044065332,
2.621e-7,
0.0759636387,
0.0354680941,
0.0372932442,
-0.0148448786,
0.0195714682,
0.0103705684,
0.0157390852,
0.0107861375,
0.0212606471,
0.0590864159,
0.0579183549,
-0.0203904491,
0.0516853444,
0.0222977009,
-0.0986653343,
0.0240474083,
-0.1006323546,
0.0016585654,
-0.0894332156,
0.0424450226,
0.0475002378,
0.0303000845,
-0.0057633161,
-0.025600208,
-0.019289,
-0.0327090621,
0.0510165133,
-0.0072046686,
0.0057748267,
0.014155793,
0.021616932,
0.0049491166,
0.0077951774,
0.0274081472,
-0.0229502283,
0.0155246267,
0.0214681532,
0.0174570382,
-0.0399702974,
0.0421202853,
0.0489786863,
0.0204435252,
-0.0047384901,
-0.0706440136,
0.0350368768,
0.011696944,
-0.0331788659,
-0.0163905267,
0.0151658785,
-0.0528696738,
0.0405648462,
-0.0137036787,
0.0151715875,
0.0395965688,
0.0037814237,
-0.0450858548,
0.0093116732,
-0.0176862087,
-0.0277237166,
-0.0072309868,
-0.00690899,
-0.0204721745,
-0.0413200185,
0.0100427223,
0.0589312166,
-0.0352443568,
0.0314949714,
2.523285638e-34,
0.0398122333,
0.0018133267,
-0.0046651196,
0.0070418939,
0.0133024771,
0.0234832242,
0.0985289216,
0.0491349623,
-0.0060038911,
-0.0398395807,
0.0029317015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05524v1 | Understanding Causality with Large Language Models: Feasibility and Opportunities | 2023-04-11T22:30:03 | 2023-04-11T22:30:03 | Cheng Zhang, Stefan Bauer, Paul Bennett, Jiangfeng Gao, Wenbo Gong, Agrin Hilmkil, Joel Jennings, Chao Ma, Tom Minka, Nick Pawlowski, James Vaughan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We assess the ability of large language models (LLMs) to answer causal
questions by analyzing their strengths and weaknesses against three types of
causal question. We believe that current LLMs can answer causal questions with
existing causal knowledge as combined domain experts. However, they are not yet
able to provide satisfactory answers for discovering new knowledge or for
high-stakes decision-making tasks with high precision. We discuss possible
future directions and opportunities, such as enabling explicit and implicit
causal modules as well as deep causal-aware LLMs. These will not only enable
LLMs to answer many different types of causal questions for greater impact but
also enable LLMs to be more trustworthy and efficient in general. | [
0.0248800237,
0.0990248546,
-0.0219160728,
0.0182252806,
-0.0061415988,
0.0084474655,
0.0501090102,
0.0060129017,
0.0217868295,
-0.028901631,
0.0395372622,
-0.0068870597,
-0.011227794,
0.0444389582,
0.053424295,
-0.0036359865,
0.0193820205,
-0.044995252,
0.0246525723,
-0.0142148929,
-0.0247376114,
-0.0355164446,
0.0145851038,
0.0503910854,
-0.0358881317,
0.0271895733,
-0.0029553843,
-0.0095293028,
-0.0232408736,
-0.0106245615,
-0.0201437362,
0.0216129385,
0.0551154837,
0.079305768,
0.0000020318,
-0.021390928,
-0.0201649349,
-0.0079980073,
-0.0247335341,
0.0063444488,
-0.0391128473,
0.004015903,
0.0197081342,
-0.0000947595,
-0.0238706525,
0.0050522219,
0.0462124906,
0.0452532135,
-0.0001819787,
0.0851647332,
-0.0068400875,
-0.0640798509,
0.0216091424,
-0.0583539344,
0.0247873366,
-0.0307014361,
0.0428193025,
0.0192099866,
-0.011038091,
0.0117006171,
-0.0460111536,
0.0062574358,
0.0456311479,
-0.0224623755,
0.0074624368,
0.0057396842,
0.0298660584,
-0.0121084461,
0.0261713117,
0.0625157133,
0.0250408538,
-0.0234808866,
0.0189013742,
-0.0155361453,
0.0080452897,
0.0722763166,
-0.041789446,
0.0164779481,
0.0373572223,
0.0043464163,
0.047692813,
0.0140625974,
0.0968450606,
0.056171868,
-0.0655849054,
0.1062555164,
0.0316934213,
-0.018245561,
-0.0220021307,
0.039013572,
0.0123443864,
-0.0657962337,
-0.0240809023,
0.0214480199,
-0.0627725646,
0.0331883021,
0.0323496126,
0.0126189711,
0.0032525195,
-0.0443923548,
0.0202769749,
0.022742264,
0.0010156177,
0.0513188951,
-0.019042192,
0.0426941961,
-0.0762256905,
0.013798818,
-0.0050891177,
-0.0120643442,
-0.023760492,
-0.0325524881,
0.0317963697,
-0.0190785471,
-0.0252941214,
-0.0025607757,
-0.0270607285,
0.029945232,
-0.0208213571,
-0.0214004908,
-0.023423383,
0.0039961273,
-0.0165329576,
-0.0518383086,
-0.0434723534,
0.01502058,
-0.0626187995,
0.0846461281,
-0.0296029039,
-0.0267596077,
0.0020256315,
0.0342873186,
-0.0118395574,
-0.0408862233,
0.0180128384,
0.1036575735,
0.0196551327,
-0.0127723068,
-0.0169326887,
-0.0479666851,
-0.0135038951,
-0.0621014647,
0.0002917509,
-0.0611185543,
-0.0159316882,
0.0254253298,
0.0119057773,
-0.0587880276,
0.0146951908,
-0.0373674035,
-0.0673003122,
0.0408145711,
0.0218575653,
0.0086232256,
0.0084928758,
-0.0172592439,
0.0400532,
0.0516453683,
0.0443589203,
0.0272891726,
-0.0020335664,
-0.0068877633,
0.0255257003,
0.0158669259,
0.0253683068,
0.0145876771,
-0.0445592105,
-0.0393452458,
0.001991997,
0.0171294939,
0.0095728254,
0.0096088713,
-0.004948596,
0.0101505909,
0.0580500886,
0.0025947238,
0.0064414539,
0.0172882397,
0.0738423914,
-0.0601886362,
-0.0318770409,
0.0181687288,
-0.0503983945,
0.0353266969,
-0.0146090668,
-0.0331731215,
0.0428416505,
-0.039737884,
-0.0390835516,
-0.0456364825,
-0.0013741642,
-0.0035668206,
-0.0076607433,
0.0193146747,
0.0706780329,
-0.025805898,
-0.0189603232,
0.0298907943,
0.0182567406,
-0.0123633416,
0.0178140588,
-0.0238569528,
0.0232908968,
0.0501546487,
0.0334091671,
-0.0408899151,
0.0039837495,
-0.0030558538,
0.0092712091,
0.0239246748,
0.0352217443,
-0.0095449788,
-0.0215942245,
-0.0184551291,
-0.0229014587,
-0.0061416337,
0.034332864,
0.0265718084,
-0.0025085164,
0.0022513168,
-0.0013805921,
0.0220114905,
0.0020457814,
0.0257527996,
-0.0433090217,
-0.0211799871,
0.0005398276,
0.0119458139,
0.0403698795,
0.0073403977,
-0.0353583209,
0.0236032009,
-0.001471463,
-0.0498041771,
-0.0721394271,
0.0202422161,
-0.0164598264,
0.0199532192,
0.0080847908,
-0.0538195819,
-0.0109600481,
0.0337598287,
-0.0169848111,
-0.0681506619,
0.0924749523,
-0.0269776601,
0.0179163422,
-0.0136766806,
-0.0046185344,
-0.0094772018,
0.014957929,
-0.0454175808,
0.0665591434,
0.023708351,
0.0094672842,
0.0107032079,
0.0286448821,
0.0360917449,
-0.0001466148,
-0.0118314819,
-0.0297343787,
-0.0064251553,
-0.0115754493,
0.0848942325,
-0.0543797016,
-0.0141592259,
-0.0387116522,
-0.034073282,
-0.0054667327,
-0.0144844335,
-0.0259590466,
-0.0186170563,
-0.0077081965,
0.013227717,
-0.0231129508,
-0.0267483443,
0.0217743535,
-0.0068763867,
0.0211189706,
0.0256282594,
-0.011559057,
0.001890084,
-0.0630330741,
-0.017301783,
-0.056940075,
0.0470361374,
0.0655410886,
-0.0254170205,
-0.0269993171,
-0.0069365376,
-0.0185223334,
0.0174604263,
-0.0227741115,
-0.0411250554,
0.0073149544,
-0.0432180353,
0.0167084709,
0.0577513352,
-0.0278178975,
0.0338947289,
0.0477136783,
-0.0279862694,
-0.0417940468,
-0.0006345261,
-0.0607408918,
-0.0176963024,
-0.0588176958,
0.001433715,
-0.0442621149,
0.1026604697,
-0.0113879461,
-0.0367551893,
-0.0304571986,
0.0188428536,
-0.0226175673,
-0.0258255638,
-0.0374896787,
-0.0364040136,
-0.0066686329,
0.0762290582,
-0.0093407594,
-0.0880049169,
0.0463903397,
0.0157780033,
0.0212396216,
0.0131642241,
0.005421998,
-0.0511347391,
0.0509806275,
0.0435330011,
0.0011012499,
0.011595252,
-0.0295203999,
-0.0565065816,
-0.0166152604,
0.0183853395,
0.031674847,
0.0302856062,
-0.0888213664,
0.072464712,
0.0231934581,
-0.0447476134,
-0.0511347577,
-0.0579647869,
-0.0294797849,
0.0209809281,
0.0247960147,
-0.0218284298,
-0.0546769053,
-0.0068358006,
0.0420032963,
0.0156227574,
-0.0190576762,
0.0068229176,
-0.0195424818,
-0.0224566869,
0.0503882803,
-0.024935022,
0.0382992886,
-0.0458715446,
0.0070720124,
-0.0284790695,
-0.0373957269,
0.0008002912,
-0.0423717685,
0.0286784004,
-0.0088389292,
-0.0206298195,
-0.011064196,
0.0127785653,
0.0117366156,
-0.0491151065,
0.0187697392,
0.0964174122,
0.0319182314,
-0.0234391615,
0.0123349158,
0.0231977124,
-0.0315968581,
0.0271623004,
-0.0037386983,
-0.0821703076,
-0.0273198914,
0.0176939555,
-0.054997839,
-0.0133667449,
-0.0456934981,
0.0174837727,
-0.080707103,
0.019208217,
-0.0090149464,
-0.0148023553,
0.0052338908,
-0.0433709063,
-0.0282956846,
-0.0268580709,
-0.0184972007,
-0.02242456,
0.0336940438,
-0.0146613754,
0.0092258174,
0.0008521082,
-0.0449651331,
0.0187273826,
-0.0236771647,
0.054699976,
0.0547389239,
-0.0015291189,
-0.0400623567,
0.0182703622,
-0.0120438701,
0.0229458734,
-0.0039640828,
-0.0100876028,
0.023805799,
0.0452032536,
-0.036608465,
-0.0257137194,
0.0441992655,
-0.0325719789,
0.0028695166,
-0.0279175211,
0.0715970695,
-0.0326995812,
-0.0273401346,
0.0000108497,
-0.0162175391,
-0.0017606043,
0.055732403,
-0.0220384952,
-0.0230963193,
-0.0522459559,
-0.0257070865,
-0.051192496,
-0.0158613864,
-0.0740611181,
-0.0311338902,
0.0521325506,
-0.0488551445,
-0.0446550138,
-0.0230630897,
0.0030186244,
-0.0085723354,
0.031171592,
0.0447381362,
0.0176854786,
-0.0239941515,
-0.0258794725,
0.0313049592,
-0.0395587124,
0.0407893881,
-0.032122016,
-0.0035081152,
0.0243438855,
-0.0157477036,
-0.0101727331,
0.0441553593,
-0.0625586137,
-0.0786900595,
-0.0116870133,
0.0376516134,
0.0249086414,
0.0161615759,
-0.0330000371,
-0.0848060921,
0.0321097225,
-0.0004962967,
-0.0341119543,
-0.0127137424,
0.0297759473,
-0.0176554825,
-0.0007084858,
0.0602723137,
-0.0486515574,
0.0258073844,
0.024167344,
0.0095306439,
-0.0262633357,
0.011245993,
0.0108392434,
-0.0250600874,
0.0495828055,
-0.0308167897,
0.0141836964,
-0.0146061182,
0.0139649268,
-0.0213139225,
-0.0233540572,
-0.0079407478,
0.0265827179,
0.035119582,
0.0160734318,
-0.0123131452,
-0.0295817796,
-0.0048619607,
0.0131952148,
-0.0019149566,
0.0450536162,
-0.0038228678,
0.0277254321,
0.0390667617,
0.0326427333,
0.022123415,
0.0367632248,
0.0092911199,
0.0498773493,
0.0002516199,
0.0359850079,
0.0114716459,
0.0271589998,
-0.0412679054,
-0.0613590851,
-0.0948835239,
-0.0515200049,
0.0483781248,
0.0115977339,
0.0857976526,
-0.0157157499,
0.0032065636,
-0.0526037328,
-0.0001158877,
-0.0070434534,
0.0189494155,
0.0413762815,
0.001075601,
0.0337160639,
0.0092164455,
-0.060333997,
0.0435260758,
0.090630725,
0.0563090369,
0.0454214364,
-0.0247670822,
-0.0037895113,
0.013206182,
-0.0626797229,
0.0277479663,
0.0155486641,
-0.0586502291,
0.0365324989,
-0.0661842376,
-0.0509446822,
-0.0271538571,
-0.032846991,
-0.0039149807,
0.0001035014,
-0.0023604382,
0.0212317426,
-0.0139840757,
0.0143237682,
-0.0345296524,
0.0307376869,
-0.0390401557,
-0.022296695,
-0.0001934636,
-6.649121347e-33,
-0.0156337954,
-0.0223696996,
0.0354087912,
-0.0272556841,
0.0292440392,
0.0289027374,
-0.0659917295,
0.0196381081,
-0.0229425207,
0.0578351431,
0.0172141083,
0.0407059342,
0.0073600295,
0.0300345663,
0.0426794961,
-0.0216935035,
0.0306319762,
0.0392391682,
0.0130623234,
0.0224972088,
0.0483590178,
0.010086148,
0.0100516342,
-0.0731161237,
0.0313314945,
0.0102601349,
0.0004845484,
0.0230642501,
-0.0364493243,
0.0411316715,
-0.0324951187,
0.0184422638,
0.0261184666,
-0.101827763,
-0.0028860171,
0.0126615316,
-0.0243131816,
-0.0261647087,
0.0532617792,
-0.0145814866,
-0.0282634627,
-0.0639075115,
0.0112635661,
0.0189527143,
0.016927477,
-0.000531044,
0.0254672151,
-0.0080934418,
0.0031287416,
-0.0138481604,
-0.0849803463,
0.0221906044,
-0.0399160832,
0.0059712427,
0.0040354491,
-0.0212545805,
0.0013504421,
0.0302051883,
0.0047735581,
0.0362378694,
0.0152651118,
0.015054551,
0.0273360051,
0.0259454753,
0.0054477761,
0.0667443573,
-0.0335566327,
-0.0103603555,
-0.0417217202,
-0.0156071819,
0.004663378,
0.0615214035,
0.0661964938,
0.0591422245,
0.0101598268,
0.0299216546,
-0.1335469037,
-0.0130690448,
0.0289001688,
0.0052717878,
0.0336196795,
0.0140304836,
-0.0194397774,
-0.029478753,
-0.0486730896,
0.0161529668,
-0.0459614433,
-0.011927302,
0.0161278304,
0.0076942481,
0.0108782593,
-0.0170817319,
0.064647384,
-0.0770349801,
-0.0090543041,
0.0355612412,
-0.0236263331,
-0.0051152795,
0.0108900191,
0.0146782501,
-0.0749286115,
-0.0168587938,
-0.0073105018,
0.0041897688,
0.0252296422,
0.0162373837,
0.0247508697,
-0.0053628921,
-0.0236098263,
-0.0099579925,
-0.0371631011,
-0.0495345183,
0.0302984491,
-0.0089584021,
0.0288848933,
0.0542815439,
-0.0134308701,
0.0529988818,
0.0125579843,
0.026755251,
0.0546882078,
-0.0297643784,
-0.0248929113,
0.0269959532,
-0.0528311729,
-0.030487828,
-0.0430122353,
0.0337068774,
0.0380718485,
-0.0599813126,
-0.0122377314,
-0.0200024061,
2.73e-7,
0.0607893281,
0.0629382133,
0.0164707713,
0.0434391052,
0.0553826094,
0.025582714,
0.0027358693,
0.0053822948,
-0.015345932,
0.0294350609,
0.0452404693,
0.0246682595,
0.0761870965,
-0.0073809074,
-0.0459970906,
0.0127339754,
-0.0386605971,
-0.0234519877,
-0.0393622443,
-0.020470839,
0.0261494927,
0.1067819595,
0.0384268276,
-0.000482716,
0.0225433409,
-0.0327472426,
0.061733529,
-0.0313435234,
-0.0031473823,
0.0156856831,
-0.022300642,
0.009684898,
-0.0379619598,
0.0570986755,
-0.0104716513,
0.0105265025,
-0.0256400332,
0.0504597574,
0.001828324,
-0.0025887697,
-0.0561454855,
-0.0621014833,
0.018497372,
-0.0313086659,
0.0716356561,
-0.0368610099,
-0.0622482225,
0.0449771769,
-0.0024985548,
0.0058545489,
0.0185272992,
0.0026459945,
-0.0059849522,
0.0060208826,
-0.0157850049,
0.0298912674,
0.0070397449,
-0.0782979429,
-0.0370920673,
0.0075092511,
-0.0253640823,
-0.0644349679,
-0.0310044326,
-0.0192803349,
0.0417550355,
-0.0302341599,
0.0284789279,
2.391334101e-34,
0.0388248675,
0.0397090092,
-0.0033407493,
-0.0278901011,
0.0425028354,
-0.0140207615,
-0.0746801198,
0.0414200798,
0.0600216538,
-0.1100690141,
0.0004401773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05523v1 | MoMo: A shared encoder Model for text, image and multi-Modal representations | 2023-04-11T22:26:10 | 2023-04-11T22:26:10 | Rakesh Chada, Zhaoheng Zheng, Pradeep Natarajan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | We propose a self-supervised shared encoder model that achieves strong
results on several visual, language and multimodal benchmarks while being data,
memory and run-time efficient. We make three key contributions. First, in
contrast to most existing works, we use a single transformer with all the
encoder layers processing both the text and the image modalities. Second, we
propose a stage-wise training strategy where the model is first trained on
images, then jointly with unimodal text and image datasets and finally jointly
with text and text-image datasets. Third, to preserve information across both
the modalities, we propose a training pipeline that learns simultaneously from
gradient updates of different modalities at each training update step. The
results on downstream text-only, image-only and multimodal tasks show that our
model is competitive with several strong models while using fewer parameters
and lesser pre-training data. For example, MoMo performs competitively with
FLAVA on multimodal (+3.1), image-only (+1.1) and text-only (-0.1) tasks
despite having 2/5th the number of parameters and using 1/3rd the image-text
training pairs. Finally, we ablate various design choices and further show that
increasing model size produces significant performance gains indicating
potential for substantial improvements with larger models using our approach. | [
0.0020196401,
0.0808495581,
0.0085894475,
0.0604751892,
-0.0074168039,
0.0053801769,
0.0413982719,
-0.0155690759,
-0.0348206758,
-0.0530977659,
-0.1083519757,
0.0040995646,
-0.0070909499,
0.0540072061,
0.0148953414,
-0.062692903,
-0.01037711,
0.0092588775,
-0.037625093,
-0.010704821,
0.042983409,
0.0148821119,
0.0200770572,
0.0244663674,
-0.0270143654,
-0.0096244616,
-0.0413773172,
0.0259084832,
0.0091998382,
-0.0211107787,
0.0230878796,
0.0473973081,
0.0609098934,
-0.0181840062,
0.0000023195,
0.0210358445,
0.0056037302,
-0.025722051,
0.0227289107,
-0.0115596773,
0.0719816312,
-0.0454685949,
0.0147698028,
0.0178822596,
-0.004127129,
-0.0278501175,
0.0669951737,
0.0577066988,
0.0615818277,
0.0600887612,
-0.0349339619,
-0.0311838426,
0.0199743211,
-0.0372128598,
-0.0007656789,
-0.0164143909,
-0.0130784251,
-0.0056833168,
-0.0413736925,
0.0362238698,
-0.0605956055,
0.0463704094,
0.0374253951,
0.0073850565,
-0.0032088654,
0.0463196114,
0.0535007343,
-0.0186817609,
-0.0255900361,
0.0673797429,
-0.0437430143,
-0.0080887685,
-0.0154453805,
-0.0157816838,
0.0077056848,
0.028211128,
-0.0219034348,
0.0147248022,
-0.0036572518,
0.0329041854,
-0.0693125427,
0.0456025973,
0.0023238389,
0.0047136433,
0.0054012206,
-0.0513263047,
-0.0003779206,
0.0127572138,
-0.0191946402,
0.0009570041,
0.0066941348,
-0.0270712338,
0.0256578997,
0.0127902236,
0.0374660827,
-0.0213378686,
-0.0585556068,
-0.0405517034,
-0.0154263927,
-0.0479292646,
0.0249004681,
0.032677263,
-0.0691686198,
0.0401436538,
-0.0435666926,
0.0313843712,
-0.0134565141,
0.0643763691,
-0.0197345149,
-0.0184812415,
-0.0522921234,
-0.0422287434,
-0.0223996583,
0.0113472417,
-0.0531748831,
-0.0496842228,
-0.0088197328,
0.0173368789,
-0.0167423915,
-0.00651281,
0.0436087623,
0.0309234206,
-0.0354543552,
-0.0329456888,
-0.0113045787,
0.0587631501,
0.0187033098,
0.0517527796,
0.0067041107,
-0.0271123983,
0.0042447383,
0.0245398618,
0.0332327113,
-0.0091310116,
0.0063218814,
0.0662107244,
-0.0527213216,
-0.0261701923,
-0.0260600485,
-0.0067340098,
-0.0323244222,
-0.0486231074,
0.0079547726,
-0.0279782824,
0.0488105528,
-0.0042630439,
0.0269763321,
-0.035832379,
-0.0099058999,
0.0072470736,
0.0289763343,
0.0976129547,
0.0479572378,
-0.0286022983,
0.0468008257,
0.0321702883,
-0.002801263,
0.0627945885,
0.0404807851,
0.0539063364,
-0.0084995423,
-0.0196342599,
0.0017727372,
0.0360289849,
0.0078492519,
-0.0125440471,
0.0033021756,
-0.0203103144,
0.0185605232,
0.0234183501,
0.0454095639,
0.0556352697,
-0.0412500836,
-0.0404757261,
0.0842815191,
0.0012909328,
0.0369080566,
0.0257079899,
0.0098939277,
0.0102201803,
0.0112122223,
-0.0289267488,
-0.0359448977,
0.0732418746,
0.0290132351,
-0.0356607325,
0.0101538664,
0.0387662277,
-0.0609933026,
-0.0258763507,
0.0166049507,
-0.0462788492,
0.0200663786,
-0.0104885418,
0.0352804773,
0.0105674155,
-0.0807948112,
0.0271459669,
-0.0086610634,
-0.0416325964,
0.0142576331,
0.0095157018,
-0.0026421768,
0.0163524561,
0.0082668625,
-0.0041353046,
0.0172455385,
-0.0188184772,
0.0069151656,
0.0172488671,
-0.0165923368,
0.0022463845,
0.0496489294,
-0.0843657702,
-0.0590715148,
-0.0545257665,
-0.016708361,
0.011188129,
-0.040994402,
0.0397144519,
0.0229014456,
0.0188120343,
0.0279974882,
0.0330110788,
0.0148328682,
-0.008786384,
0.0108477054,
0.0046313233,
0.027457092,
-0.0338315032,
-0.0071541816,
-0.0056646429,
0.0151326945,
-0.0544983111,
-0.0369332545,
0.046518296,
-0.1002316177,
-0.0575020388,
0.0014497158,
-0.0366128795,
0.0358267054,
0.0428924672,
-0.0279228128,
-0.0327304453,
-0.0057516629,
-0.0183177833,
-0.0176066831,
-0.0219099615,
-0.0109974127,
0.0191765707,
0.019975299,
0.0337464213,
0.0327650048,
-0.037112534,
-0.0373064801,
-0.0274338033,
0.0287349503,
0.0293878745,
0.0077899867,
-0.0387233533,
-0.0060214275,
-0.000772463,
0.0158421751,
0.0197796542,
-0.0114855301,
-0.0038163166,
-0.0342101939,
-0.1174247414,
-0.0207250379,
-0.0278228205,
-0.0110286297,
0.0124019468,
0.002492113,
0.0158806182,
-0.0505272411,
-0.0190082248,
0.0433982462,
-0.0025187761,
0.0205403455,
-0.0075454428,
0.0078634387,
0.0445314646,
-0.0089510214,
-0.0038578939,
0.0427034535,
0.059343677,
-0.0214343388,
-0.0212447327,
-0.0129831452,
-0.0127302827,
-0.0120125394,
0.0107219778,
-0.0185417309,
-0.0321917683,
-0.0112921959,
-0.0025446848,
0.0500899889,
0.0463037416,
0.0312233809,
0.0318972729,
0.0198610276,
0.0099946614,
-0.0435906202,
-0.001050934,
-0.0050313491,
0.0156569835,
-0.0186846033,
0.0043773605,
-0.0303603224,
0.0430588424,
0.0097126178,
0.0331789441,
-0.0517576374,
-0.0160478577,
0.0085096722,
-0.0596649572,
-0.0414688624,
-0.003729007,
-0.0014786259,
-0.0219604522,
-0.0389417596,
-0.0460703224,
0.0217940267,
-0.0270691104,
-0.0333184898,
-0.0007157242,
0.0145173715,
-0.0180259142,
0.072102271,
0.0122674443,
0.0436905324,
-0.0094387718,
-0.0193538181,
-0.0318178199,
0.00454392,
0.0553591177,
-0.0016199823,
0.0338100158,
0.0045223264,
0.0165583249,
-0.0224950183,
-0.0713862181,
-0.0101903956,
-0.0206796918,
-0.0121142659,
0.0140794413,
-0.0442848504,
0.0168208741,
-0.0250434168,
0.0035109282,
0.0039147339,
0.0810769722,
-0.0101859663,
-0.0126265623,
-0.0332358591,
0.0398225263,
-0.0048384438,
0.0160448216,
-0.0656555146,
-0.0545889512,
0.0087124556,
0.0667374805,
0.0045878445,
-0.0194652025,
-0.0448742807,
0.0283503849,
-0.0048544533,
0.0583339594,
0.0003775217,
0.0153129855,
0.0622747503,
-0.0523841046,
-0.0106760329,
0.0732360482,
-0.0023329668,
-0.0510730185,
-0.0357734673,
0.0183202289,
0.0003723164,
0.0195251666,
-0.0199295413,
-0.0651618093,
-0.0821379125,
-0.0057106288,
-0.025316976,
0.0400615111,
0.0301342793,
0.0077565941,
-0.0559427552,
0.0087974267,
0.0057039554,
0.0050046579,
-0.0343444385,
-0.0221848823,
-0.0171304103,
-0.0393634066,
-0.0168712158,
-0.0212105121,
-0.0107449777,
-0.0262280107,
0.0187160317,
0.0313255265,
-0.0534639619,
-0.0076634903,
-0.0389640331,
-0.0264979694,
0.0180960204,
-0.005642551,
-0.0033840656,
-0.0518739,
0.0368706584,
0.0220090058,
0.0085519589,
-0.0175069068,
0.072875753,
-0.0427387208,
-0.0085163442,
-0.0061364588,
0.0379251763,
-0.0309136976,
-0.026477091,
-0.0251848716,
0.0277236737,
-0.0066441041,
-0.0217904262,
-0.0168102831,
-0.0205592811,
-0.0161709618,
0.0385684222,
-0.005783584,
-0.0283377655,
-0.0228142794,
-0.0019965193,
0.0143832732,
-0.0240472686,
-0.0243958607,
-0.0087728295,
0.0178878158,
-0.0103813931,
-0.0450741686,
-0.0122622168,
-0.0013920178,
0.0303051993,
0.0029901962,
-0.0468759462,
0.0018763776,
-0.0129597867,
-0.064970538,
0.031487003,
-0.0090008518,
-0.0028312029,
-0.0202636588,
0.0001567972,
0.0720527396,
-0.0172281135,
-0.0189068075,
-0.0064815301,
-0.1170194,
-0.0119971372,
-0.0654905811,
0.0645085648,
-0.0039125443,
0.0459240973,
0.0516783148,
-0.0398867391,
0.0748437569,
0.026798876,
-0.0466483906,
0.0123285949,
0.0324362963,
-0.0324717164,
-0.0000256208,
0.0044857068,
-0.0184470993,
0.024812974,
0.0028122035,
-0.0176761858,
0.0208338387,
-0.0191624686,
0.0248555001,
-0.0814034939,
0.0243207645,
-0.0044741156,
0.0265643373,
-0.0578463264,
0.0202427134,
0.002623881,
0.0086361188,
-0.0690699741,
0.0343266092,
0.0234367289,
0.0157494489,
0.0132368067,
0.0421373062,
0.0620446987,
0.006737628,
-0.0394916572,
0.0121345492,
0.0224259868,
0.0139213055,
-0.0331710204,
0.039559491,
0.0111808889,
0.0062473523,
0.0165903457,
0.0035310672,
-0.0405522361,
0.083065398,
0.0150122084,
0.0026179436,
-0.0335001014,
0.0626065806,
0.0005852577,
-0.0059187603,
-0.0700487122,
0.0236939043,
0.0239482168,
0.0026526768,
0.0031862727,
-0.0046824999,
-0.0112633593,
-0.0394763947,
0.0504271761,
-0.0259406026,
-0.0024469788,
0.0472204909,
-0.0177025758,
0.0093915416,
-0.0219190139,
0.0612056479,
-0.0248910245,
0.0455460399,
-0.009757028,
-0.0049297716,
-0.0408710837,
0.0100535601,
0.0472045392,
0.0223019253,
-0.0039531509,
0.0136756934,
0.0449516252,
-0.0325313322,
0.002653149,
-0.00986192,
-0.0026794479,
0.0330493748,
0.0725543573,
0.0388902053,
-0.0023350478,
-0.024613183,
-0.0052605593,
0.0176872406,
0.0162135344,
0.0139023233,
0.0083366921,
-6.684483891e-33,
-0.0044034822,
-0.0008676456,
0.030283777,
-0.0329511687,
0.0038297139,
0.0323919356,
-0.0176836289,
0.0070842253,
-0.0078010294,
0.0020939293,
0.0458843708,
-0.0056045013,
0.0016465235,
0.0531765744,
0.0188480094,
-0.0067534698,
0.0590648055,
-0.0319721736,
-0.0314501449,
0.017252475,
0.0502833687,
0.0127552263,
0.0587325655,
-0.0704376847,
-0.0310061984,
0.0202066768,
-0.0584594533,
-0.0306255911,
0.0362202302,
0.053876847,
-0.0242399722,
0.0045763818,
0.0269278977,
-0.0425710157,
-0.0469147637,
0.0340025574,
-0.0862841234,
-0.0060373889,
-0.0457855463,
0.0245816316,
-0.0952185914,
-0.0165625773,
0.0799919367,
-0.004417486,
0.0040320996,
-0.0323079377,
0.0379724503,
0.0224839859,
0.0256858096,
0.0112901721,
-0.0460575521,
0.0114651043,
-0.0193078592,
-0.049342256,
0.0718875155,
0.0391515493,
0.0361825973,
0.0238540061,
-0.0814394727,
0.0124051748,
-0.087164402,
0.0227943268,
0.0664230064,
0.0224558301,
-0.0022539673,
0.04882586,
0.0175013803,
-0.043967545,
-0.0338402353,
-0.0007488858,
0.0235953145,
0.0756789222,
0.026190985,
0.0610010698,
0.0295569841,
-0.0265795197,
-0.0561700203,
0.0360749327,
-0.0194406491,
0.0237132832,
0.02054503,
0.0439622588,
0.012876872,
-0.0001264075,
-0.0546620898,
-0.0170623399,
-0.0239114817,
-0.0118608531,
0.0541149788,
0.0670802146,
0.0063890596,
0.0277283601,
0.0874771699,
-0.0386078805,
-0.0198108573,
0.0142073585,
-0.03043239,
0.0582277477,
0.0101759816,
0.0197191592,
-0.0477997139,
-0.0175275113,
0.0842123032,
-0.01474897,
0.0031181418,
0.0073857703,
0.0410414636,
0.0483135693,
-0.0498615988,
-0.0142016849,
-0.0413147211,
-0.0158120207,
0.0159195401,
0.0602108464,
0.0184082203,
0.0181884877,
-0.0573663302,
0.0402720347,
-0.0194867533,
0.000678277,
-0.0462595597,
-0.047409445,
0.0163612422,
0.029495012,
-0.0037347265,
0.0152168805,
-0.0759746358,
-0.0803934261,
0.0366305336,
-0.0495687239,
-0.0084177507,
0.051473435,
2.839e-7,
0.0211626645,
-0.007201442,
0.0083994018,
-0.0499288626,
0.043254856,
0.0683512837,
-0.013295575,
0.0842532292,
-0.0042776633,
-0.02994968,
-0.0068277144,
0.0457904711,
0.0325501747,
0.0058164182,
-0.0090464279,
0.0096577704,
-0.0435911044,
-0.0048651169,
-0.0261622295,
0.0017940055,
0.037212003,
0.1093284115,
0.0057775313,
0.0037599278,
0.037594948,
-0.0151857482,
0.1302932948,
0.0060787145,
0.0111964121,
-0.0125160459,
-0.0278405789,
0.0416522883,
-0.041316811,
0.0040332596,
-0.0243127029,
-0.0003529461,
0.0437592268,
0.0351840481,
-0.0286420435,
-0.0529143363,
0.0135636758,
0.0639549941,
-0.0535597615,
-0.0321771614,
0.0810314715,
-0.0596058629,
-0.0455414578,
-0.0502762534,
-0.0113845207,
0.0375531092,
0.0440258272,
0.0317838416,
-0.0602763519,
0.0181627069,
0.0363828354,
0.0114703542,
-0.0513145551,
-0.0887635425,
-0.0046460233,
-0.0264711529,
-0.0585349947,
0.0015545995,
-0.0921844169,
-0.0233642496,
0.0548798293,
-0.058893539,
-0.0233971365,
2.065036155e-34,
-0.0391872153,
-0.0344006382,
-0.0095288716,
-0.0012118112,
-0.0064604483,
-0.0239269286,
-0.0222076923,
-0.0142516783,
-0.0196013451,
-0.05083251,
-0.0209051557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05512v1 | Mathematical and Linguistic Characterization of Orhan Pamuk's Nobel Works | 2023-04-11T21:37:50 | 2023-04-11T21:37:50 | Taner Arsan, Sehnaz Sismanoglu Simsek, Onder Pekcan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, Nobel Laureate Orhan Pamuk's works are chosen as examples of
Turkish literature. By counting the number of letters and words in his texts,
we find it possible to study his works statistically. It has been known that
there is a geometrical order in text structures. Here the method based on the
basic assumption of fractal geometry is introduced for calculating the fractal
dimensions of Pamuk's texts. The results are compared with the applications of
Zipf's law, which is successfully applied for letters and words, where two
concepts, namely Zipf's dimension and Zipf's order, are introduced. The Zipf
dimension of the novel My Name is Red is found to be much different than his
other novels. However, it is linguistically observed that there is no
fundamental difference between his corpora. The results are interpreted in
terms of fractal dimensions and the Turkish language. | [
-0.0095298411,
-0.0255947374,
-0.0325301401,
0.0291837938,
-0.0756355077,
0.0356067754,
0.0192075688,
0.0292117409,
-0.0713463202,
0.0095640682,
0.0946404487,
-0.099007979,
0.0358237028,
0.0392888263,
0.0056429966,
-0.0730403066,
-0.0347252637,
-0.0309306998,
0.0227083489,
0.0226984471,
-0.0278493538,
0.0030938096,
-0.0255858358,
0.0115018208,
0.041026786,
-0.0361349843,
-0.0114552323,
-0.0495083258,
0.0106123229,
-0.0050457693,
-0.05125257,
0.0024963571,
-0.0602708384,
0.0171074942,
0.0000015735,
-0.059045475,
-0.0227067526,
-0.0103599606,
0.0936379507,
-0.0536555685,
0.0920615494,
-0.0027971175,
-0.0421833806,
-0.0511897914,
-0.0060047619,
-0.013740465,
-0.0169810224,
0.1206757799,
-0.0100950636,
0.0711428225,
-0.0124784913,
-0.1345043182,
0.0506528988,
0.0212954171,
0.0150348991,
0.0451295264,
0.0144887613,
-0.0035873789,
0.0277617555,
0.0233934671,
-0.0198209099,
0.0150010455,
-0.00534704,
0.0016159782,
-0.0117658395,
0.0006710199,
-0.0359261483,
0.0236924924,
0.0503641926,
0.0085384073,
0.0346325859,
-0.0206820574,
0.0375173725,
0.0273313951,
-0.0269065592,
0.0505555756,
-0.0549778678,
0.0178289413,
-0.0450239629,
-0.0112277037,
0.0213338993,
0.0515423939,
-0.0283872243,
-0.0141932778,
-0.0218880866,
0.0906587914,
0.0337062664,
-0.0099193808,
-0.0347105116,
-0.0653764084,
0.0337041728,
-0.0080255195,
-0.0170643032,
0.0062787565,
0.0512040704,
0.0018428403,
0.0115701417,
-0.0669025779,
-0.0024759427,
-0.0824302882,
-0.0035503502,
-0.0320466161,
0.0473754555,
0.0312479343,
0.0101266028,
-0.009482488,
-0.0100701135,
0.0329886079,
-0.0671569556,
0.0411858745,
-0.0023714637,
-0.0279554632,
-0.0046195104,
-0.0018451839,
0.0129576512,
0.0078655435,
-0.0419568568,
-0.0105640525,
0.041593276,
-0.0295500197,
-0.0484668761,
-0.0151136015,
-0.0004855266,
-0.0181617551,
-0.0588591881,
-0.0435820222,
-0.0540407076,
-0.0123547688,
-0.0678976849,
0.0339947864,
0.0433957502,
0.0415626094,
0.0098030586,
0.0045551695,
-0.0145800896,
0.027820427,
0.0467043594,
-0.0519788489,
-0.0027957039,
0.0399219282,
-0.0131949568,
-0.0220124908,
0.0061759539,
-0.0318220593,
-0.0210818201,
-0.0078781471,
-0.0106372461,
0.0045625274,
-0.038234707,
0.0257286876,
0.0125632994,
0.0762159303,
-0.0163476523,
0.0205172207,
0.0420170985,
-0.0028631156,
0.0129901068,
0.0011532581,
0.0430104621,
0.028063314,
0.0275969971,
-0.0439902544,
0.0499499738,
-0.020289924,
-0.0749261603,
-0.0088727279,
-0.0489859208,
0.0034201904,
0.0147495167,
0.0138688292,
-0.0190715156,
0.028180195,
0.0235983152,
-0.0305153131,
0.0158011131,
0.127753526,
0.032678403,
0.0453586951,
-0.0580849834,
0.0084762452,
0.0864082724,
0.0629233271,
0.0740457624,
-0.0191561952,
0.0325784236,
0.0137454597,
0.0218821466,
0.0370955691,
0.0349412709,
-0.0258361101,
0.0085759191,
0.0090682767,
0.0035158843,
-0.0695525408,
0.0857816264,
-0.0015312668,
0.0218299013,
-0.0680820048,
0.0301148109,
0.0051109344,
-0.0288286787,
0.0251979828,
0.0375710167,
0.0274860114,
0.0453240462,
-0.0673497915,
0.1124970913,
-0.0072926241,
-0.0445704758,
-0.0153758349,
-0.0481699072,
0.0100924848,
-0.0319253616,
-0.0547661558,
0.0213789251,
0.0114867194,
0.0031396633,
0.0121645294,
-0.036542695,
0.0691631436,
0.0042415038,
0.0197668988,
0.000750693,
-0.0032045827,
0.0341831222,
-0.0181302354,
-0.0292490385,
-0.0095671872,
0.0156873148,
0.0278150681,
-0.029289877,
0.0433635302,
0.0035701001,
-0.047095269,
-0.0317696184,
-0.0146354418,
-0.0117728086,
0.0167439319,
0.034272749,
-0.0502822399,
0.0786575302,
-0.0215345081,
0.0248397309,
-0.0011627408,
0.0636077598,
-0.0109391799,
0.0399236977,
-0.0060174726,
0.0628077313,
-0.0465489775,
0.0028967911,
-0.0396277495,
0.0096568149,
0.0120610232,
0.0677143186,
-0.0230617728,
0.0186524037,
0.0424106792,
0.0199752972,
0.0133186756,
0.0494685955,
0.0058590439,
-0.0083221383,
0.0319227688,
-0.0310020167,
-0.0138055561,
-0.0567967668,
0.0489379205,
-0.0565570816,
-0.0041913958,
0.0160458572,
-0.0026731456,
-0.022937594,
-0.0161108542,
-0.0042688157,
-0.0201070793,
-0.0321774781,
0.0184927154,
-0.0395929664,
0.0206390563,
-0.0258309711,
-0.0264993273,
0.0060260999,
-0.0233863574,
0.0077440771,
0.0166966673,
0.0431740023,
-0.0467385501,
-0.006817936,
0.0103315888,
-0.0244340561,
-0.0240625348,
-0.0310310554,
-0.0496767312,
0.0180930663,
-0.0400816612,
0.0730560794,
0.030450318,
0.0189625584,
0.012858185,
-0.0097143948,
-0.0164177958,
0.0390125364,
-0.0375825651,
-0.0139978947,
0.1001276076,
0.0146658709,
-0.0220833812,
0.0371437818,
0.0008798458,
-0.0232315883,
-0.0279093888,
0.0040169898,
0.0316493511,
-0.0585689284,
0.0192719903,
0.0158098787,
0.0363508388,
-0.0496813282,
0.0674076453,
0.0120384106,
-0.0107797831,
-0.0346983932,
-0.0055261757,
0.0131564625,
-0.0523637347,
-0.0064648842,
-0.0558893569,
0.090315707,
0.0666568875,
0.00726248,
0.0523714796,
0.0071224724,
-0.0220224615,
0.0242369808,
0.0001509197,
-0.0091179321,
-0.0057481104,
0.0320713446,
-0.0069824951,
0.0030759168,
0.017340241,
0.0080478676,
-0.0445485599,
0.0533516593,
-0.0432414711,
0.0541344322,
-0.0714789554,
-0.0190843269,
0.0321952403,
0.0440656282,
-0.0167002715,
-0.0083059082,
-0.0072528077,
0.0013608566,
0.064838089,
0.0490003191,
-0.0330711864,
0.0204842333,
-0.0061391331,
-0.0075766556,
0.0294873156,
-0.053866934,
0.0429921485,
0.0485295914,
-0.0164227281,
-0.0123940855,
0.0036427872,
-0.0241543036,
0.0040023443,
-0.0326113962,
-0.0012234141,
0.0212036073,
0.0514791049,
-0.0057986029,
0.0431402326,
0.0110173859,
-0.0197535995,
-0.0489368923,
0.03546381,
-0.0162596665,
0.0074195317,
0.0753960162,
-0.0158267412,
-0.0212062728,
-0.018488571,
-0.013369428,
0.030674601,
-0.0324197672,
-0.0307800081,
0.0165759772,
-0.0350814722,
0.0024613065,
-0.0318641737,
-0.0085402038,
0.0201859362,
-0.1007601991,
0.0217782464,
-0.0240328982,
0.0386926867,
0.0200326405,
-0.0220590699,
-0.0047890195,
-0.0619971603,
-0.0227317158,
-0.0234259348,
-0.0464503318,
0.0347254276,
-0.0592356808,
-0.0209410023,
-0.0920693427,
0.0813697353,
-0.0276572816,
0.0175058041,
0.0145851225,
0.077046968,
-0.0020695811,
-0.0802326351,
-0.0287955925,
-0.0062760934,
-0.0003769826,
0.0015482457,
-0.005730832,
0.0240943804,
-0.0180635154,
-0.0284537636,
0.0076753562,
-0.0586025976,
-0.0112713557,
0.003632972,
0.0371415243,
-0.061338827,
-0.0249944963,
-0.0009432437,
-0.0196561255,
-0.0124819484,
0.0038577879,
-0.0013029488,
-0.0796959698,
-0.0438230149,
-0.0201525502,
-0.0776752159,
0.1083395854,
0.0254855677,
0.0294055101,
0.0114783654,
-0.000646612,
0.0040422515,
-0.0508135818,
0.0198150389,
0.0099585252,
-0.012326167,
-0.0002673881,
-0.0020263423,
-0.019189233,
-0.0082998611,
-0.0219906494,
-0.028614318,
-0.0170342904,
0.0257630888,
0.0273411106,
0.0157278311,
-0.0712837502,
0.0191535223,
-0.0169606674,
0.0243541971,
-0.0289609767,
-0.0500433296,
0.0511257611,
-0.0349221118,
-0.0184688736,
-0.0036926386,
0.0067060236,
0.0502531789,
0.0204461627,
-0.0386234447,
-0.027915692,
-0.0361570492,
-0.0523942672,
-0.0396326631,
0.0070937565,
-0.0183088668,
-0.0183466263,
0.0008934655,
0.0111583099,
-0.0216868781,
-0.0199087076,
-0.0151483268,
0.0173546076,
-0.020188069,
0.0067600943,
-0.0340098292,
-0.0888002664,
-0.027412504,
-0.0080359979,
-0.018104339,
0.0211974196,
-0.0092867473,
0.0251069721,
0.0386901237,
0.0136116203,
0.0075138728,
0.0189276449,
-0.0133518046,
-0.0417181775,
0.0303473789,
0.0301470365,
-0.0134763904,
0.0206443183,
-0.0026311919,
-0.0052897376,
0.0626750961,
-0.0281508192,
-0.0054881866,
0.0107156262,
-0.0331193097,
0.0074723479,
-0.0213196799,
0.0065962649,
-0.0407022685,
-0.0042463844,
-0.0010965879,
-0.0242960919,
0.0215259977,
0.008744739,
-0.0395961516,
0.0129178418,
-0.0210344419,
0.0062420471,
0.0426389724,
-0.0236219727,
-0.0750872716,
0.0311328247,
-0.0542311408,
0.0056684776,
0.0179107357,
-0.0140816411,
0.0463185459,
0.0361871794,
0.0144388173,
-0.0832904726,
-0.0188335124,
0.0295603741,
0.0282280128,
0.0284977574,
0.0256161671,
0.0396575369,
0.0160923563,
0.007370288,
0.0431351364,
-0.0265638251,
0.0247586519,
-0.0572846308,
0.0132612018,
0.0328862593,
-4.831154314e-33,
-0.0016896769,
-0.0050279186,
-0.0258948971,
0.0344312713,
-0.022165738,
-0.027251564,
0.0434597656,
-0.0070877643,
0.0284896232,
0.0006938563,
-0.0028584376,
0.0078864582,
-0.0057313181,
-0.0211576782,
0.0286599752,
0.0249693282,
-0.0165526178,
-0.0288651809,
-0.0217221621,
-0.0003572691,
0.0330228955,
-0.0218087453,
0.0483412668,
-0.0399104096,
0.0352887847,
-0.0354905576,
0.0296521485,
0.0123518119,
0.033443708,
-0.0262339618,
0.0112182656,
0.0308127161,
0.0312053002,
-0.05631271,
0.0052984022,
0.0178574026,
-0.011364568,
-0.0578131117,
0.015373216,
0.0390364863,
0.0519901216,
-0.0293697901,
-0.0132425809,
-0.0222702734,
-0.0036297448,
-0.0101506971,
0.0248885546,
-0.0256834328,
-0.0319240279,
-0.0219268426,
-0.0310330223,
0.0128835188,
-0.0194996372,
0.0224469826,
0.0274352767,
-0.0558175258,
0.0323621593,
-0.0663885474,
0.0250825454,
0.0240577236,
0.0172252599,
0.0252179503,
-0.0508543886,
-0.0005382365,
0.0127392104,
0.0432638265,
0.0828198716,
0.0580302365,
0.0107938889,
-0.0198290367,
0.0163059235,
-0.0438655242,
-0.0044144858,
0.0309823956,
0.0091437874,
0.0322248377,
-0.0326663144,
0.0279245265,
-0.0102511784,
0.0007877499,
-0.0040668757,
-0.0151015427,
-0.0671343356,
-0.032687027,
0.0567010865,
0.0664369315,
0.0276416484,
0.0078809895,
-0.0427361466,
-0.0447434634,
0.0386415198,
-0.0240379758,
-0.0514618494,
-0.0086237052,
0.0011098299,
-0.0445084907,
-0.0033139337,
0.048641324,
-0.0138431629,
0.024423765,
0.0157792643,
-0.0227673762,
-0.0604152828,
0.0287941843,
0.0347678028,
-0.0061846687,
-0.0279032588,
-0.00221449,
-0.0591702089,
-0.0410879552,
0.0350540765,
-0.0582742579,
0.0763801709,
0.0522085242,
-0.0081459973,
0.003293596,
0.0264821462,
0.0320298411,
0.0518230684,
-0.0046762908,
-0.002615571,
-0.0642131045,
0.0065631391,
-0.0227384549,
-0.0172470417,
0.0265407525,
-0.0481550545,
-0.0030564792,
0.0351622775,
-0.0179814808,
-0.0096067945,
-0.0019735612,
2.572e-7,
0.0162232146,
0.0219861921,
0.0500604734,
0.0042151511,
0.0238699634,
0.0126148686,
-0.0397060066,
0.0438579805,
-0.0614066608,
0.0416044369,
0.0290770065,
-0.0016362041,
0.0111259967,
0.0139243137,
-0.0805396661,
0.0629189014,
-0.0158243962,
-0.0173986983,
-0.0515685081,
0.0448915772,
0.0331271999,
-0.0096449275,
0.0410464592,
0.0000432364,
-0.0082290024,
-0.0319861844,
0.016669631,
-0.023852827,
0.0257102214,
0.0096933125,
0.0566644147,
-0.0450735278,
0.0034225441,
0.0060269465,
0.0481685959,
-0.0053656502,
0.0489294678,
-0.0289398022,
0.0190737881,
0.0872673243,
0.0003356092,
-0.0894622952,
-0.0176832452,
-0.0470471904,
0.0266269483,
0.0479450449,
-0.0728293732,
0.0200655609,
0.0299077388,
-0.0050592283,
0.0341163278,
0.0437814146,
-0.0360636674,
0.0243298858,
0.0066613774,
-0.0418732837,
0.0590808652,
0.007803503,
0.0105324071,
0.0618793368,
-0.0141418558,
-0.0367218778,
-0.0216774959,
0.0186129529,
0.0558929071,
-0.023930693,
0.0135225188,
2.111984527e-34,
0.0099069197,
0.0063876486,
-0.0199416671,
-0.0139056649,
-0.0306397155,
-0.0073421295,
0.0235074647,
0.0021715341,
0.0077667842,
-0.0496085361,
-0.0152365081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05510v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05510v2 | chatClimate: Grounding Conversational AI in Climate Science | 2023-04-11T21:31:39 | 2023-04-28T15:07:41 | Saeid Ashraf Vaghefi, Qian Wang, Veruska Muccione, Jingwei Ni, Mathias Kraus, Julia Bingler, Tobias Schimanski, Chiara Colesanti-Senni, Nicolas Webersinke, Christrian Huggel, Markus Leippold | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in recent years,
achieving remarkable results in question-answering tasks (QA). However, they
still face two major challenges: hallucination and outdated information after
the training phase. These challenges take center stage in critical domains like
climate change, where obtaining accurate and up-to-date information from
reliable sources in a limited time is essential and difficult. To overcome
these barriers, one potential solution is to provide LLMs with access to
external, scientifically accurate, and robust sources (long-term memory) to
continuously update their knowledge and prevent the propagation of inaccurate,
incorrect, or outdated information. In this study, we enhanced GPT-4 by
integrating the information from the Sixth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental (IPCC AR6), the most comprehensive, up-to-date, and reliable
source in this domain. We present our conversational AI prototype, available at
www.chatclimate.ai and demonstrate its ability to answer challenging questions
accurately in three different QA scenarios: asking from 1) GPT-4, 2)
chatClimate, and 3) hybrid chatClimate. The answers and their sources were
evaluated by our team of IPCC authors, who used their expert knowledge to score
the accuracy of the answers from 1 (very-low) to 5 (very-high). The evaluation
showed that the hybrid chatClimate provided more accurate answers, highlighting
the effectiveness of our solution. This approach can be easily scaled for
chatbots in specific domains, enabling the delivery of reliable and accurate
information. | [
0.0508068874,
0.0696542561,
0.0048704953,
0.0264815576,
-0.0349923447,
-0.0035694896,
0.00808708,
-0.0210437849,
0.0563037172,
-0.0236165226,
-0.011099481,
-0.0251411255,
0.007907683,
0.0570839234,
-0.003374812,
-0.0755174085,
0.0495545492,
-0.0524502061,
0.0257903356,
-0.0359411538,
0.0193870347,
-0.022668073,
-0.0263478793,
0.0115368655,
-0.0218744259,
-0.0467402339,
-0.0232752822,
-0.0219320804,
0.0241581146,
-0.0393901654,
0.0225988384,
0.0469772443,
0.0257296879,
0.034630347,
0.0000022446,
-0.032056462,
-0.0078312038,
-0.0020235279,
-0.0316102542,
0.0047924682,
0.0437942222,
0.0172347333,
0.0110569848,
0.0197711214,
-0.0807642341,
0.0208721496,
0.0936218649,
0.0075494633,
0.0915906876,
0.0366031826,
0.0087836497,
0.0185841266,
0.0446041077,
0.028863715,
-0.006667451,
-0.0086631095,
0.0385506973,
0.0448628329,
0.0123990765,
0.0257508196,
-0.0032480911,
0.0690403506,
0.0347962156,
-0.0269871559,
-0.003128621,
0.0513127893,
-0.0577937514,
-0.0335095264,
-0.0240842402,
0.0595054999,
0.0502820611,
-0.0335861258,
-0.0254025478,
0.0175473001,
0.0121859005,
-0.0189383049,
-0.067708917,
0.0078583946,
0.0028394114,
-0.0176728722,
-0.0190845858,
0.0008128744,
-0.0207292158,
0.0382051282,
-0.0163578726,
0.0989244431,
-0.0093409978,
-0.0333107524,
-0.0279037524,
-0.0056874095,
0.0276602432,
-0.0653957576,
-0.0087101972,
0.0448600352,
-0.0310704429,
0.009589267,
-0.0038721962,
0.0227422453,
0.0035957398,
-0.0676873326,
-0.0186194051,
0.0387701951,
-0.0098257195,
0.0276484471,
0.055491101,
0.0532233939,
0.0199809205,
0.0162797719,
0.0001161739,
-0.0358847789,
-0.0569499694,
-0.0543838143,
-0.0229786709,
0.0110442322,
-0.0092543857,
0.0109011838,
0.0066705937,
-0.0074391449,
-0.0170615371,
0.0124858981,
-0.0095891403,
0.0257054493,
-0.0155836353,
-0.0079470482,
-0.0587813221,
0.038071584,
-0.0452395752,
0.0246105026,
0.0361882597,
-0.1071043164,
-0.0183075182,
0.016393844,
-0.0026907634,
0.0242794212,
0.0027344427,
0.0714439899,
0.0169399716,
0.0101283221,
0.029027788,
-0.0221655481,
0.0056618419,
-0.0804067552,
0.0048227557,
-0.0340125337,
0.0320700072,
-0.0025125095,
-0.0133494418,
-0.0312486421,
-0.003313056,
-0.0093571218,
-0.0318455324,
0.0781567618,
-0.0554255322,
-0.0219202582,
0.0512318611,
0.0243675634,
-0.0174143203,
0.0544362031,
0.0319041908,
0.0275415089,
0.0151811391,
-0.0123978117,
0.0402253084,
-0.0121568395,
0.0203632638,
0.023045592,
0.0165606495,
0.0392373092,
-0.0263035204,
0.0221405495,
-0.0102514606,
0.0406651236,
-0.0063832439,
-0.004356388,
0.0786669552,
0.0198767371,
-0.0584203824,
0.031973727,
0.0039564278,
0.0234577227,
0.0296120215,
0.0096509047,
-0.0542387143,
0.0811351463,
-0.0348444842,
-0.0209744144,
0.0315066054,
0.0172122344,
-0.0175331887,
-0.0568341725,
-0.0065824375,
0.010600972,
-0.0115274349,
0.0132962288,
0.0034051859,
-0.0312376153,
-0.0051913369,
0.0128710791,
-0.0026434818,
-0.0219471194,
-0.0216443446,
-0.0326555632,
0.0191711579,
0.060557019,
0.0063360916,
-0.0006697035,
-0.0551344641,
-0.0172967333,
0.012538488,
0.0467727631,
0.06953758,
0.0100340303,
-0.0376096666,
-0.024370851,
-0.02214358,
-0.0296159908,
0.0057436777,
0.0143006649,
0.0206165761,
0.0314449109,
-0.0151209421,
0.0097684693,
-0.0204463042,
0.0128394943,
-0.0362818725,
-0.0185860097,
-0.0426378213,
-0.0176757053,
0.0564173684,
-0.0044387812,
-0.0137562538,
0.0249209926,
0.027826719,
0.0149256298,
-0.0693015531,
0.0670169145,
-0.0386434682,
0.0139546515,
0.0534192026,
-0.0173656829,
-0.0176970568,
0.0283063278,
-0.023080539,
-0.0350800119,
0.0360717215,
-0.0322848447,
0.0423901118,
-0.0225358177,
-0.0187793635,
-0.0157050621,
0.0343885235,
0.007565144,
0.0297523346,
-0.0011279044,
-0.0195759088,
0.0149582326,
0.0188925955,
-0.0029339478,
-0.0463794731,
0.0089601055,
0.0110356528,
0.008307836,
-0.0191670749,
0.0182810687,
-0.023847457,
-0.0818377361,
0.0068704309,
-0.0869448557,
0.0012336721,
0.0082043055,
0.0200169515,
0.0186110903,
-0.0203222558,
-0.0084195174,
0.0033030626,
-0.0249374025,
0.0123602618,
-0.0108914711,
0.0379313715,
0.0381248333,
-0.007731304,
0.0173708517,
-0.0695685968,
0.0384194069,
-0.0223075151,
0.0480651669,
0.0508168377,
-0.0560109913,
-0.0495363623,
0.0072426307,
-0.0865131766,
0.0313467868,
-0.011775868,
-0.0472658798,
0.0291626137,
-0.0274858251,
0.0089668259,
0.0373042375,
0.0482092686,
-0.0000243906,
0.035480991,
-0.0229089186,
-0.085170649,
0.0341654681,
-0.0028533102,
-0.009979967,
0.0325051956,
0.0072851046,
-0.0203765016,
0.0177341327,
-0.0005302386,
0.0265484881,
0.0134507027,
0.0948362947,
-0.0153727531,
-0.0321406424,
-0.0223626643,
-0.0129584074,
-0.0280104373,
0.0324346125,
-0.008823717,
-0.0768970177,
0.0648068041,
-0.028877547,
0.0000133165,
-0.0826206505,
-0.0195626989,
0.0046348362,
0.0495324023,
-0.0301068015,
0.0140276933,
0.0134715699,
0.0336030684,
-0.0308855455,
-0.0519582629,
-0.012281511,
-0.0205029789,
-0.0266462956,
-0.0717673749,
0.0314711779,
0.00750806,
-0.0159246251,
-0.0442443714,
0.0018666981,
-0.0601310842,
0.0274048429,
0.0154403662,
-0.0644615665,
-0.0671861321,
0.0162980873,
0.0630779713,
0.0141942743,
-0.0242919289,
-0.016416274,
0.0083722733,
-0.0042545553,
0.0647795424,
0.0704408213,
0.0433940925,
0.0108363619,
0.039508719,
0.049360536,
0.020658832,
0.0053075654,
-0.0426759012,
-0.0365934223,
0.0040926561,
0.0039584553,
0.0040782639,
-0.014282627,
0.0447417498,
-0.0719361827,
-0.0155536374,
0.096275568,
0.0225904919,
-0.0351614021,
-0.0198027287,
-0.0340220258,
0.0209463947,
0.0055495496,
0.0050182701,
-0.0624127425,
-0.0059131323,
0.0024320281,
-0.0098508634,
-0.0314876847,
-0.0350481458,
-0.0466251671,
-0.068159923,
0.0607696623,
0.008765867,
-0.0449530743,
-0.0273481347,
-0.0880522951,
-0.0059567485,
0.0296152234,
-0.0038890815,
-0.0194633864,
0.0271361358,
-0.0017335776,
0.0147521133,
-0.0616452172,
-0.0001157486,
0.0520732105,
-0.0118472604,
0.0752776712,
0.0850221664,
0.0622815378,
-0.0056522232,
-0.0077848146,
0.0308933072,
0.0247836336,
-0.0191284083,
-0.0035653596,
0.0051378757,
0.0288241152,
0.0000264476,
-0.0287316442,
0.0256315265,
-0.0051959171,
0.0139836129,
0.0417108499,
0.0972027257,
-0.0456068739,
0.0046137804,
-0.0103870016,
0.0467005484,
0.0347700231,
0.0735051781,
0.0063995305,
0.0009294801,
-0.0668882579,
-0.0807354525,
0.002230224,
-0.0318580158,
-0.0422827713,
-0.0055989758,
0.0105702151,
0.004978539,
-0.0653709546,
-0.0337011144,
0.0534772538,
0.0023580145,
-0.0170896426,
-0.0149892289,
0.0776611194,
0.0253540929,
-0.0150216585,
0.0245546047,
-0.0580178984,
0.0167566948,
-0.0307410844,
-0.0514803417,
0.0624719672,
0.0062160962,
-0.0008559863,
0.0710221827,
-0.0534973852,
-0.0456161574,
0.0027424328,
0.0556092337,
0.0264110416,
-0.0009611764,
0.0091444412,
0.0011743039,
0.0262696873,
0.0636996701,
-0.0308879167,
0.0178226586,
0.0098354276,
0.0473042019,
-0.0000759839,
0.006688057,
-0.0287366472,
0.0053982288,
-0.0374333449,
0.0189137477,
-0.0299937576,
-0.0344828218,
0.020276865,
0.0224395785,
0.0124217859,
0.0200305954,
-0.0436255187,
0.0067761205,
0.001869001,
-0.0079555968,
-0.0108177643,
-0.0285765119,
0.0367281064,
-0.0116503015,
0.0076768589,
0.0141718965,
0.0214410294,
-0.0373560563,
0.0055132094,
-0.0259885229,
0.0045216861,
0.0282310452,
0.0134987086,
-0.0124649322,
-0.0042673484,
-0.0276608393,
-0.0340255052,
-0.0094730128,
0.0275121052,
0.0183336549,
0.0270826444,
0.0020625589,
-0.0284619853,
-0.0027874457,
0.0285729691,
-0.1095442027,
-0.1027011201,
-0.0340654664,
0.0879131183,
0.0201634113,
0.0863956437,
-0.0043799481,
-0.0507839285,
-0.0046672951,
-0.0209259726,
-0.021885464,
0.0470042005,
-0.0307633933,
0.0597132295,
0.0171061363,
-0.038684167,
0.0103610987,
0.0244880207,
-0.0161619,
0.0989564732,
0.0035257656,
-0.0233061425,
-0.0304963998,
-0.0678318813,
-0.0742054954,
-0.0230361763,
0.0244817436,
0.0096561909,
-0.0445588455,
-0.0359291323,
-0.0030802481,
0.0096816849,
-0.0315682851,
-0.0231283549,
0.0128658926,
0.0312497839,
-0.0179560389,
-0.0545713454,
-0.0066052079,
0.0531500839,
-0.0487764217,
-0.0143848071,
-0.0308663379,
-6.65270734e-33,
-0.0383323804,
-0.0437414311,
0.029277863,
0.0322475322,
-0.0256774537,
0.027914308,
-0.0302938651,
-0.0107931923,
-0.0613457225,
0.0154212937,
0.0056352955,
0.0012559488,
0.0115167582,
-0.012352501,
0.02332443,
-0.0198747925,
0.0289836526,
-0.0149266552,
-0.0121971909,
0.0251117386,
0.0763997212,
0.0025625206,
0.0527875051,
-0.1041525379,
0.036963366,
-0.0164933633,
-0.021534482,
0.0181987211,
-0.0538182966,
0.0416140072,
-0.0257108659,
0.0548502617,
0.0065463111,
-0.0399938375,
-0.0404520854,
0.0196487531,
-0.0565910712,
-0.0344124399,
0.021992702,
-0.025764998,
-0.0198099725,
-0.0089697195,
-0.0067603248,
0.0126574449,
0.0128134945,
0.0042268778,
0.0255226903,
-0.0406881943,
-0.000291047,
-0.000269162,
-0.031487938,
0.0233396199,
-0.0115679763,
-0.0136801386,
-0.0480798036,
0.0592982657,
0.008565682,
0.0376302451,
-0.0724654719,
0.0517516658,
0.0432481132,
0.0066110371,
0.0564861,
0.0014743885,
0.0248833206,
0.0730832517,
0.0157142263,
0.012014403,
-0.0436083525,
-0.0484599844,
0.0145553881,
0.0043207603,
0.04249046,
0.0657824948,
0.0126331868,
-0.002170678,
-0.027502168,
0.0270180069,
0.0603989437,
0.0535019785,
0.0099992156,
-0.0048938105,
-0.0051426184,
-0.0093170339,
-0.0411908627,
0.0488889515,
-0.0404363945,
-0.0194859169,
0.0305095427,
-0.0226815194,
0.0067556808,
0.0003832704,
0.0258019287,
-0.0478898808,
0.0157443341,
0.0412416346,
-0.0042576259,
0.0222561751,
0.0217026696,
0.0274872277,
-0.0516671501,
0.0175762288,
0.0066126538,
0.0314920545,
0.0102180867,
0.0102280369,
-0.0141583644,
0.028385831,
-0.0217634421,
-0.0242199823,
-0.0474451222,
0.0201946758,
0.000829172,
-0.0379693843,
-0.0284722224,
0.0191732608,
-0.0014419931,
0.0370736159,
-0.0110332007,
0.0376658291,
-0.0035366213,
-0.00102332,
-0.0499052703,
0.0092748497,
-0.039738968,
-0.0035075904,
-0.0511253886,
-0.0049439408,
-0.052660767,
-0.0645318851,
0.0116193686,
0.0109199733,
2.855e-7,
0.0184629075,
0.0525738895,
0.0170134399,
-0.0161937308,
0.0187895037,
0.0195421837,
-0.0061461101,
-0.0073231766,
0.0036797137,
-0.0102896821,
-0.0327937976,
0.0220378023,
0.0417085551,
0.0481665283,
-0.0600320585,
-0.0668140277,
-0.0828537643,
-0.0696026161,
-0.0668686554,
-0.0321444012,
0.0597148575,
0.0694480017,
0.0274039414,
0.011479957,
-0.0000122622,
-0.0176188182,
0.0671536922,
-0.0347195119,
-0.0264679473,
0.0226533134,
0.0251289569,
-0.0050302371,
0.0205042716,
0.0252877157,
0.0023865474,
-0.042374853,
-0.0356612653,
0.0512731746,
0.0279176254,
-0.0773964375,
0.005105305,
0.0000907902,
0.0179140251,
-0.0760485455,
0.0530881397,
-0.0437617525,
-0.0252454299,
-0.0288072005,
-0.0225182585,
0.0018817576,
0.02415842,
-0.0376089178,
-0.0037216726,
0.01799706,
-0.0388586782,
-0.0168883409,
0.0101626636,
-0.0248293318,
-0.0043463469,
-0.0360270888,
-0.0504043177,
-0.0733465031,
-0.0393581577,
-0.0510904044,
0.0318941996,
-0.0186735801,
0.044603046,
2.168290936e-34,
0.0422726199,
0.0077264938,
-0.0114392126,
0.0019152663,
0.0299076065,
0.0168375093,
0.0763723329,
0.0123225935,
0.0255328454,
-0.0454405472,
-0.0068500927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09093v1 | Improving Items and Contexts Understanding with Descriptive Graph for Conversational Recommendation | 2023-04-11T21:21:46 | 2023-04-11T21:21:46 | Huy Dao, Dung D. Le, Cuong Chu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | State-of-the-art methods on conversational recommender systems (CRS) leverage
external knowledge to enhance both items' and contextual words' representations
to achieve high quality recommendations and responses generation. However, the
representations of the items and words are usually modeled in two separated
semantic spaces, which leads to misalignment issue between them. Consequently,
this will cause the CRS to only achieve a sub-optimal ranking performance,
especially when there is a lack of sufficient information from the user's
input. To address limitations of previous works, we propose a new CRS framework
KLEVER, which jointly models items and their associated contextual words in the
same semantic space. Particularly, we construct an item descriptive graph from
the rich items' textual features, such as item description and categories.
Based on the constructed descriptive graph, KLEVER jointly learns the
embeddings of the words and items, towards enhancing both recommender and
dialog generation modules. Extensive experiments on benchmarking CRS dataset
demonstrate that KLEVER achieves superior performance, especially when the
information from the users' responses is lacking. | [
0.0448555686,
0.0026165191,
0.0148668746,
0.0317134708,
-0.0116914725,
-0.0123951072,
0.0045206617,
-0.0402578637,
0.0566555969,
-0.0483571738,
-0.0248721614,
0.0074813236,
-0.0057183723,
0.077646412,
-0.014653556,
-0.0337311104,
0.0085164765,
-0.0003731461,
-0.0124547016,
0.016368961,
0.0234250966,
0.0369211361,
0.0037006952,
0.0273262747,
-0.0020035813,
-0.0291520525,
-0.0333490036,
0.0138908224,
0.0027861614,
-0.036865335,
0.0373794511,
0.0230206661,
0.0142364223,
-0.0015839004,
0.000001811,
-0.0203083307,
-0.011017059,
-0.022798894,
-0.0001522147,
-0.0458253026,
0.0409442633,
0.038412001,
0.041101981,
0.0320141837,
-0.0386230797,
-0.0138859246,
0.0287349243,
0.0769016072,
0.0259577688,
0.0450854525,
-0.0207856596,
0.0082754642,
0.0039927452,
-0.0340163596,
0.0320668779,
-0.0438841693,
-0.0263080113,
0.0273833945,
0.0212824587,
0.0497093014,
-0.0185441971,
0.0008190525,
-0.0048724799,
-0.0418793373,
0.0795324221,
0.0223899446,
-0.013950442,
-0.0161393341,
-0.009888391,
0.1505638957,
0.0117648439,
-0.0021835009,
-0.0191886872,
0.00506027,
0.0062644645,
-0.0349076949,
-0.0301273093,
-0.0100459894,
-0.033846993,
0.0084791714,
-0.0209325161,
0.0250891633,
0.0340828188,
-0.0048741992,
0.0005089375,
0.0473395512,
0.0037025062,
-0.023580296,
-0.0133106299,
-0.009587178,
-0.0217417572,
-0.0542501584,
0.0023250415,
0.0120996488,
-0.0830795467,
0.0334180556,
-0.0329867899,
0.0631450117,
-0.0019372409,
-0.0257478449,
0.0215853564,
0.0252323672,
0.0241447594,
0.0470437929,
0.0004521601,
0.0310421642,
0.0153907621,
-0.0055110413,
-0.0867974535,
-0.0265444163,
-0.0389786437,
-0.0112797925,
-0.0228255186,
0.0402666219,
-0.0584009662,
-0.0739284158,
-0.0431060866,
0.0758571029,
0.0001228419,
0.0315904878,
0.0138701722,
0.1014737785,
-0.0322991237,
0.024419304,
-0.0519664586,
-0.0065153595,
-0.0538729951,
-0.0016177227,
0.027086651,
0.0012563565,
0.0307347644,
0.0439187847,
0.043887604,
-0.0340763368,
-0.0499463901,
0.0186238121,
0.006885902,
-0.0301629622,
0.0217768773,
-0.0191546995,
-0.0366071202,
-0.0179938562,
-0.0230540801,
-0.0449325405,
0.0383519754,
0.0408894755,
-0.0066494145,
-0.0224484652,
0.0327889211,
0.0186053254,
-0.0304212049,
0.0806919783,
-0.0284632202,
-0.0265142396,
0.0051611341,
0.0310616046,
-0.0358249731,
-0.0081288926,
0.0107173445,
0.0625777841,
0.0616406351,
0.0111901751,
-0.0036458722,
-0.0323649049,
-0.0016959611,
-0.0249242447,
-0.0345829129,
0.0477285199,
-0.062683247,
0.0461014062,
0.0286511164,
0.0691657588,
-0.0535814837,
-0.0207846854,
0.0398264043,
0.0379992127,
0.043600332,
0.0382717699,
0.0431915633,
0.0667724758,
-0.0541159026,
-0.0063607162,
-0.003876993,
0.0408801809,
0.0100915628,
-0.011487524,
0.0550148599,
-0.0235151798,
-0.028969964,
-0.0309420619,
0.0178033616,
-0.0599216782,
0.0771186501,
-0.000662379,
-0.0146271884,
0.0083807968,
-0.0428921357,
0.0080115814,
0.0318658948,
-0.0368858539,
-0.0206823759,
-0.0040508537,
0.0456413738,
0.1222719401,
0.0645565614,
0.0144616803,
-0.0758506209,
-0.0044985646,
-0.0399188213,
-0.0005578077,
0.0247324593,
-0.045646809,
0.0246900748,
-0.0529966317,
-0.059988115,
-0.0397776365,
-0.0222892053,
0.042069573,
-0.0036972221,
-0.000484399,
0.0495114289,
-0.0180454683,
0.0004882837,
-0.0201459769,
-0.0029304905,
-0.0131396344,
0.0509973429,
-0.0011848403,
0.0213150363,
0.0146964472,
0.0310895499,
0.0238505024,
0.0160863549,
0.0035362837,
-0.013961005,
0.0325703211,
-0.0670336634,
-0.0699425489,
0.0211898275,
-0.0175207667,
0.0406119786,
0.0148726553,
-0.0121873152,
-0.0726774558,
0.0324908085,
-0.0190168861,
0.0274670571,
-0.0391021185,
-0.0072514634,
0.0401117168,
0.0192898605,
-0.0233266056,
0.0474345423,
0.0202163663,
0.034827698,
0.0110383118,
0.0688631535,
0.014280417,
-0.040470317,
-0.0234389901,
-0.0038711985,
0.0088562798,
0.0213469993,
0.0255594049,
0.0128360447,
-0.0501492284,
0.0265344959,
-0.1180403382,
0.0122047178,
0.0374326967,
-0.0171977505,
-0.003712778,
0.0430960543,
0.0267202519,
-0.0344518162,
-0.0606676042,
0.0160438158,
0.0153060239,
-0.0054079215,
0.0268387329,
0.0167708397,
-0.0034665,
-0.047008682,
0.0127415489,
0.007730145,
0.0498589091,
-0.0099484511,
0.0139678437,
-0.0262078661,
-0.000458085,
-0.0489200801,
0.0152351856,
-0.0081371581,
0.0153097305,
-0.0123105841,
0.0136613622,
0.0321536474,
0.0125112999,
0.02092438,
0.0549604222,
-0.0018165502,
-0.0260636341,
-0.0737436041,
0.0012536402,
-0.0514374189,
0.0269279107,
-0.008433532,
-0.0014719694,
-0.006272126,
0.0236230865,
0.0036678705,
0.0012556033,
-0.044050917,
0.0111503489,
0.0338023193,
0.0210581049,
-0.0548957735,
-0.0305116251,
-0.0166824777,
0.0281023197,
-0.0371098891,
-0.0231000744,
0.0710863546,
-0.0236076806,
-0.0086398358,
-0.0370602198,
-0.0278607253,
-0.0605146326,
-0.0037614282,
0.0163760483,
0.032173831,
-0.0149945011,
-0.0312746093,
-0.021627279,
-0.0059005916,
0.0432331041,
-0.0437315851,
0.0034319614,
0.0185871776,
-0.0084595568,
0.0228747856,
-0.041790124,
-0.0402592197,
-0.0464194082,
0.0351283103,
0.0150323967,
0.0178244282,
-0.0171298031,
-0.0190327279,
-0.0018633668,
-0.0272060167,
0.045385953,
-0.0095418841,
-0.0224599037,
-0.0068011973,
0.0633823276,
0.0790600553,
-0.0378553197,
-0.0060675601,
0.000107408,
0.0675781444,
0.0376217999,
0.0114333201,
-0.0525278039,
-0.0363756195,
-0.0157883018,
0.0254389886,
0.0144876288,
-0.0189221986,
0.0213938113,
0.008846635,
0.0451509245,
-0.0455592088,
0.115590781,
0.0456534289,
-0.0715285316,
0.0174728148,
-0.0042932373,
0.020247763,
0.0335376188,
0.0294897351,
-0.0544622093,
-0.0082698129,
-0.0100590754,
0.0421088859,
0.0279845167,
-0.0361939184,
-0.0063700848,
-0.0978301838,
0.024623761,
-0.0033446879,
-0.0074922903,
-0.0066593513,
-0.0298364256,
-0.0251345728,
0.0073926235,
0.0146494536,
-0.0207374152,
-0.0076076672,
0.0106396731,
-0.0102083124,
-0.0109847076,
-0.0013017954,
0.0371802114,
-0.0208009426,
0.0171493813,
0.0133600328,
0.0455191731,
0.0397365354,
0.0205665026,
0.0149903232,
-0.034687832,
-0.0228661038,
-0.0038310902,
0.0078746155,
-0.035725981,
0.0139676919,
-0.052142337,
-0.0041936901,
-0.0437662788,
-0.0502762944,
-0.0298995804,
0.0319483802,
-0.0397248156,
0.0228411946,
-0.0346708,
0.0331515111,
0.048117768,
0.0672687516,
0.0270210132,
-0.0174416248,
-0.0014703164,
-0.0578375719,
0.008532255,
-0.0085341064,
0.0379794464,
0.0155622717,
0.016429875,
0.035773728,
-0.0939867198,
-0.0604717843,
-0.0057538766,
0.0048238239,
-0.0117538888,
0.0214879327,
-0.0152170528,
-0.0296463724,
-0.0282013174,
0.0152622703,
0.0044509326,
-0.0039758673,
-0.0001952299,
0.0098507004,
0.015099057,
-0.0597381108,
-0.0107217506,
-0.0241026953,
-0.0056930543,
-0.0364353284,
-0.0796477422,
0.0423088074,
0.0176317357,
0.0836237818,
-0.0474825352,
-0.0304650459,
0.0064051175,
0.025410369,
-0.0354481712,
-0.0507447757,
-0.0023847504,
0.090697974,
0.0036989299,
0.0387942605,
-0.0600483306,
0.020391969,
-0.0194617081,
0.0358335562,
-0.0123859793,
-0.0743757188,
0.0019784833,
-0.0045656813,
0.020049192,
0.0022705051,
0.0331481881,
-0.0349686146,
0.0395987742,
-0.0358577967,
-0.0668817461,
-0.0536055751,
0.0284465626,
0.0398591012,
-0.023588771,
-0.0093278494,
-0.030621089,
-0.0134858778,
0.0634844303,
-0.0531134084,
-0.0049329125,
0.0213113166,
-0.0722534433,
0.0234042909,
0.0218864828,
-0.0142794522,
0.0213887431,
0.0190029349,
0.0271911994,
-0.0094405115,
0.0900697932,
-0.0097742314,
-0.0405255668,
-0.019709792,
0.0412583388,
-0.0303693395,
-0.0144055784,
-0.0298912711,
0.0244876184,
0.008952586,
-0.0246391203,
0.020035509,
-0.0065974453,
0.0012162786,
-0.0426582359,
0.068448022,
-0.0208929833,
-0.0540521406,
0.0370789841,
0.0379718952,
-0.0199582875,
0.0256902762,
0.0539012179,
0.0013771488,
-0.0066340421,
0.0087389974,
-0.0526954792,
-0.0607554615,
-0.025571838,
0.0112282932,
0.0690827593,
-0.0249077938,
0.0396665037,
-0.0123046236,
-0.051181186,
0.0175357834,
-0.0318383202,
0.0049279765,
-0.0039154296,
0.0626328364,
0.0568037666,
0.0242039263,
0.024998486,
-0.080839999,
0.0062914668,
-0.0342118442,
-0.0199967213,
-0.0400213897,
-5.519422052e-33,
-0.0187593102,
-0.0462762788,
0.0081118224,
0.0267562587,
-0.011708336,
-0.0056345658,
-0.0350096337,
-0.0035630011,
0.0391828008,
0.0173558369,
-0.0046935109,
0.0096819354,
0.0026168651,
0.0603930131,
-0.0381891169,
-0.0229932908,
0.021605581,
0.0376194082,
-0.020559907,
0.0610388033,
0.0598271191,
0.063060157,
0.0034167815,
-0.0613333769,
0.0167483818,
-0.0454332754,
0.0205845926,
0.0201262776,
0.0526754633,
0.0823555291,
-0.0385212339,
0.0577968247,
0.0227490813,
0.0202018414,
0.0120107522,
0.0187208112,
-0.0829792842,
0.0036689243,
0.0217612069,
-0.0070399311,
-0.0462892391,
-0.0022973416,
-0.0090872711,
-0.0148633653,
0.0303289238,
-0.0032765279,
0.0151998997,
-0.0128732482,
-0.0759430751,
-0.0298220944,
-0.0358266905,
0.0291090664,
-0.0186831113,
-0.0402770936,
-0.0068237707,
0.0442888252,
0.005277222,
0.0177308638,
-0.021210948,
0.0073419143,
-0.0613072254,
-0.0025479221,
-0.012710778,
0.0044224933,
-0.0621135347,
0.0613753721,
0.0225378834,
-0.0281301346,
0.0003772441,
0.0191563927,
-0.0445431322,
0.0835340172,
-0.0024093625,
0.0611092113,
0.0050875912,
-0.0112653729,
-0.0408457778,
0.05228623,
0.0031976986,
0.0088470038,
0.021946976,
0.0223783273,
-0.046650447,
-0.048491057,
-0.0302889626,
0.0022253064,
-0.0689481422,
-0.0369766019,
0.0371995345,
0.0428042822,
0.0001674376,
0.0082689058,
0.0023968131,
-0.0589879006,
-0.0053743166,
0.0393859893,
-0.0232486874,
-0.0286025349,
0.0003071676,
0.021480348,
-0.0403897576,
-0.0623072237,
0.0432021692,
-0.0277463794,
-0.0397194251,
0.0196327791,
0.0386421494,
-0.0048591774,
-0.0207625832,
0.0259534698,
-0.0252499357,
-0.0234855171,
-0.0710797533,
0.0478453077,
0.0353892744,
0.0260055605,
-0.0553146675,
0.0881340578,
-0.0055881869,
0.0424882732,
-0.0129726809,
-0.083587721,
0.0320427418,
0.0084562441,
-0.026511047,
-0.0279707424,
0.0114680445,
-0.0041186037,
0.0468314327,
-0.041666545,
-0.0147537785,
-0.0324134827,
2.569e-7,
0.0117387502,
0.0272600465,
0.0134494128,
-0.0080679283,
0.0378289036,
0.0396847017,
0.0177794341,
0.0586893968,
0.0053418977,
0.0188332964,
0.0380438454,
0.0080546672,
0.0054436661,
0.0104448777,
-0.0374363288,
0.0189246312,
-0.0924244076,
-0.0396972485,
-0.0257850587,
0.0026664042,
0.0655198619,
0.0682984293,
0.0061804182,
-0.0034273244,
-0.0192443877,
-0.0439556241,
0.0537870079,
-0.0437273309,
-0.0196180195,
0.0013002907,
0.0266893208,
0.0221941024,
-0.0048277602,
-0.0167356487,
-0.0130808866,
0.0349458344,
0.0339012705,
0.0392833948,
-0.0001235443,
-0.0644451976,
-0.0124430973,
0.0049042371,
0.0250858739,
-0.0595677197,
0.0686006993,
-0.0468545631,
-0.0305924453,
-0.0290150177,
-0.0597455762,
0.0096870149,
0.0173476953,
-0.0342947096,
-0.0036527023,
-0.0070906258,
0.0171844736,
0.0034531092,
0.0117898798,
-0.0994406492,
-0.0237697847,
0.0191508755,
-0.0357454605,
-0.0258278437,
-0.0293850228,
0.0092704222,
0.0193999782,
-0.0170364752,
0.0199074093,
2.291822535e-34,
0.0378849059,
0.0349902809,
-0.0177764837,
-0.0235853791,
0.0354581811,
-0.0355746634,
0.003732271,
0.0066137728,
0.0583793819,
-0.0788550451,
-0.0274939165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05489v1 | User Adaptive Language Learning Chatbots with a Curriculum | 2023-04-11T20:41:41 | 2023-04-11T20:41:41 | Kun Qian, Ryan Shea, Yu Li, Luke Kutszik Fryer, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Along with the development of systems for natural language understanding and
generation, dialog systems have been widely adopted for language learning and
practicing. Many current educational dialog systems perform chitchat, where the
generated content and vocabulary are not constrained. However, for learners in
a school setting, practice through dialog is more effective if it aligns with
students' curriculum and focuses on textbook vocabulary. Therefore, we adapt
lexically constrained decoding to a dialog system, which urges the dialog
system to include curriculum-aligned words and phrases in its generated
utterances. We adopt a generative dialog system, BlenderBot3, as our backbone
model and evaluate our curriculum-based dialog system with middle school
students learning English as their second language. The constrained words and
phrases are derived from their textbooks, suggested by their English teachers.
The evaluation result demonstrates that the dialog system with curriculum
infusion improves students' understanding of target words and increases their
interest in practicing English. | [
0.0789176598,
0.0079384437,
-0.0235738512,
0.0049824533,
-0.01517314,
-0.0033784544,
0.0212694351,
-0.0221123826,
0.0232906863,
-0.018178191,
0.0005333038,
0.0226965956,
-0.029182151,
0.0451752432,
-0.0229312927,
-0.0887069404,
0.0347233638,
-0.0031984719,
0.0008192627,
-0.0003120959,
0.0447520912,
0.0141904904,
-0.050840918,
0.0774301812,
-0.0300916675,
-0.0351637974,
-0.0443276837,
-0.0039536655,
-0.0011737187,
0.0000044533,
0.0332578048,
0.026758071,
0.0038155089,
0.0304502081,
0.0000018965,
-0.0343544893,
-0.0158867612,
-0.0156915542,
-0.0640078336,
-0.0261403825,
0.0775711238,
0.0431730077,
-0.0127895586,
0.0195439532,
-0.0407858975,
0.0510823764,
0.0706843436,
-0.0135623626,
0.0904620141,
0.044573471,
-0.0030705994,
-0.0074150781,
-0.0113021247,
0.0334211141,
0.0232198015,
-0.0377167799,
-0.0471446998,
0.067822963,
0.0722272247,
0.0201597419,
-0.0432729311,
0.0464946181,
0.0295579266,
-0.0402557738,
0.0448714569,
0.0206982009,
-0.0045241774,
-0.0506204776,
-0.0331979729,
0.0657267421,
0.029342521,
-0.0229146592,
-0.0010178527,
-0.0087486813,
0.0490975827,
-0.0040105507,
-0.0490699857,
0.0200781561,
-0.0298407059,
0.0134212431,
-0.0030447284,
-0.0137322722,
-0.062330056,
0.0002169712,
0.0048120134,
-0.0342973359,
0.0115983654,
-0.0092362566,
-0.0417469628,
0.0233458187,
0.0454957113,
-0.0362483934,
0.0355094261,
0.0464184694,
-0.0183113758,
0.0474395752,
-0.0521127842,
-0.0413554683,
-0.0186822396,
-0.0021180473,
-0.0467368923,
0.0735867471,
0.0011531387,
0.0353785381,
0.0334770679,
0.0751693174,
0.0616558604,
0.033871077,
-0.0394742526,
-0.0117698982,
-0.0467781387,
-0.0303727314,
-0.0758205652,
0.047183089,
-0.0367953666,
-0.0318931378,
-0.0277933255,
0.0473219529,
0.018339701,
0.0146343922,
-0.0004720944,
0.0213746913,
-0.053906817,
-0.0160936732,
-0.0262865089,
0.0118957246,
-0.0178249069,
-0.0071180291,
0.0272902548,
-0.0696417764,
0.0032995886,
0.0073653725,
0.0300741214,
0.0020753699,
-0.0269447062,
0.0337111689,
-0.0609601624,
-0.0293806884,
0.0407338776,
-0.008166411,
-0.040774297,
-0.0212423485,
-0.0210062172,
-0.0536469221,
-0.0114299981,
-0.0038675135,
0.0197973512,
-0.0493745916,
0.0101154381,
0.0022970627,
0.025508482,
0.038440261,
-0.0227903817,
-0.0038810354,
0.0525745824,
0.033442568,
0.0265226662,
0.0565787442,
0.0506493263,
0.0012791479,
-0.0048571634,
-0.0286754798,
0.007866771,
0.0207660049,
-0.0087558841,
-0.0403162539,
0.0052000498,
-0.0283423401,
-0.0083361715,
0.0232476164,
-0.0209730472,
0.04477714,
-0.0505187586,
0.0137382522,
0.0332672708,
0.0609611273,
-0.0472312719,
0.0442302935,
0.0143859033,
0.0326227397,
0.0475366972,
0.0187762789,
-0.0010047248,
0.0045380001,
-0.0095232595,
-0.0058002812,
0.0192409437,
0.0198322758,
0.0074232514,
-0.0666678473,
0.0169965271,
-0.0097704753,
0.0489945374,
-0.0188727137,
0.0471680202,
0.0560670868,
-0.016829757,
-0.0378075279,
0.0078110439,
-0.0850918218,
0.0042816447,
-0.0403509736,
0.0116241006,
0.0936441422,
0.0676083192,
-0.0046096742,
-0.0545909517,
0.0280370582,
-0.0243945383,
0.0611454397,
0.0270676203,
-0.0307609774,
0.0120387273,
-0.0189036299,
-0.0080168778,
0.0087975869,
-0.0080317622,
-0.00992689,
0.0009413662,
0.0329128914,
-0.0144697074,
0.0249663722,
-0.0266480744,
0.01256363,
-0.0518202521,
-0.0232924148,
-0.02515902,
-0.0084545631,
0.0199438874,
0.0320280902,
0.0120719587,
-0.0166867208,
0.0182814058,
-0.0096749207,
0.0095512923,
0.0528843217,
-0.0564175285,
-0.0695190206,
0.0328737125,
-0.0465767272,
-0.004758806,
0.0030643188,
0.0114240283,
-0.0447020531,
0.055365447,
-0.0628453195,
0.0514517054,
-0.0144611895,
0.0117427194,
-0.0207097922,
0.0095969215,
-0.0400901772,
-0.0075308913,
0.0341523103,
-0.0302939676,
0.0460683256,
0.0224548168,
-0.026301004,
-0.0110806385,
-0.003289497,
0.033405073,
-0.0238376576,
0.022049183,
0.0170797128,
0.0058007091,
-0.094430469,
-0.0236788075,
-0.06248983,
-0.0236140639,
0.0325305797,
-0.0269825589,
0.0098103974,
-0.0124266567,
-0.0058330959,
-0.0427629575,
-0.0424483865,
0.0527299307,
0.0267335176,
-0.0359266996,
0.0170086529,
-0.005609889,
-0.0254157707,
-0.0553821512,
0.0193288755,
0.0166387018,
0.00327936,
0.0726009384,
0.016348185,
-0.0557968765,
0.0313790143,
-0.0067794411,
0.0242695734,
0.014944735,
-0.0590293407,
0.0454881042,
-0.0108193429,
0.0861984789,
0.0611389466,
0.0330747738,
0.0781122595,
0.0072737546,
-0.0333600938,
-0.0888148621,
0.023202518,
0.0034359,
-0.0431521758,
-0.0288255028,
-0.0401105881,
-0.0036596749,
0.0289732106,
0.0687078834,
0.0241791531,
-0.0894452631,
0.0684800521,
0.0181116555,
-0.0485719405,
-0.0288833175,
-0.0288337823,
-0.0504776239,
0.0121511091,
0.01125581,
-0.0257508755,
0.0803327858,
-0.0138460947,
-0.0310600549,
-0.0400102027,
0.0075137233,
0.0117947925,
0.0293166023,
-0.0193147026,
0.0232584029,
0.0251754466,
-0.027724389,
-0.0216682777,
0.0206290726,
0.0516798906,
-0.0825521797,
0.0086661419,
-0.0487042964,
-0.0372132733,
0.0096637877,
-0.0213462673,
-0.07386709,
0.0269731991,
-0.011936564,
-0.0308728311,
0.0643967539,
-0.0224492345,
-0.0232295245,
-0.0190480743,
0.0008374971,
0.0456883274,
-0.0142587516,
-0.0143795367,
-0.0200247262,
-0.0291607827,
0.0402059779,
0.0632887855,
-0.038876567,
-0.0154155651,
0.0951587483,
0.043387536,
0.0436460525,
-0.0248381738,
-0.0175971054,
-0.0021190769,
0.0380941294,
0.0306938998,
0.0225971285,
0.0157395769,
0.0373902544,
-0.0579522587,
-0.0524051152,
0.087925978,
0.0162022579,
-0.0342549644,
-0.0084604053,
-0.0560544133,
0.0356125049,
0.00528837,
0.0386145897,
-0.0491136983,
-0.0245411228,
-0.0032520932,
0.0499555133,
-0.0103186853,
0.0054335878,
-0.0234809816,
-0.0720694214,
0.030644767,
0.0328370482,
-0.0279449094,
-0.0378407873,
-0.0086975731,
-0.0291551836,
0.004807781,
0.0252114907,
0.0212504249,
0.0058546429,
0.0187744498,
0.0242056847,
-0.0156753622,
0.0018354359,
-0.0122718867,
0.0191976,
0.0896981061,
0.0381904989,
0.0171736758,
0.027197903,
0.0183640812,
0.0004516036,
0.0268155206,
-0.0297248811,
-0.0173259508,
0.0146070076,
-0.0069907885,
-0.0287622567,
-0.0298983529,
0.0244932882,
0.0064552589,
-0.0333738104,
0.0417674929,
0.0482908152,
-0.0111592757,
0.024453776,
-0.0231651384,
0.0366731733,
0.0108375344,
0.0475761816,
0.0536901578,
-0.071845144,
-0.0089227417,
-0.0664435327,
0.0087151527,
-0.0458011888,
-0.0558558181,
0.0130508738,
-0.002405023,
-0.0273062661,
-0.1163953692,
-0.030207675,
0.0445889644,
0.0247009005,
0.0288971569,
0.0125403441,
0.042912893,
0.027311774,
0.0023142195,
-0.0458752848,
-0.0186762437,
-0.039694123,
-0.0776233673,
-0.0459013321,
-0.012053689,
-0.1016799733,
-0.0010598667,
0.0319060534,
-0.021884637,
-0.0465654507,
0.0146604897,
0.025086619,
0.0204772875,
0.0448548906,
0.0021972812,
-0.0240361542,
-0.0288462806,
0.0324096233,
0.0191654135,
-0.011499363,
0.01859219,
0.0500386767,
0.0100713354,
-0.0126531404,
-0.0296236072,
-0.014543335,
-0.0351237543,
0.0100984713,
-0.0316870585,
-0.0862688497,
0.0549067594,
0.0444218367,
-0.0121399136,
-0.0146022188,
-0.0299554355,
-0.0348015651,
0.0155770583,
-0.0289415196,
0.0010428639,
-0.0523101129,
0.0010036065,
0.0173079558,
-0.029157117,
0.0410453342,
-0.0209626537,
-0.0310064331,
0.0520155318,
0.0180998649,
0.0388357677,
-0.0156092616,
0.0185278282,
0.0005361864,
0.007692636,
-0.0015342315,
0.0198276397,
-0.0215335935,
0.0512632877,
0.0062885885,
0.0894285962,
0.0009603011,
-0.0360343307,
0.0510580279,
0.0129809305,
-0.0342462957,
0.0069636162,
0.0002110778,
0.0162745826,
-0.0304524358,
0.0288176462,
0.0441586971,
-0.0598466434,
0.0489496924,
-0.023130931,
0.0487825423,
-0.0254583415,
-0.0773124322,
-0.0074540647,
-0.0031078714,
0.0279700216,
-0.0439996533,
0.0405683108,
0.0110714268,
0.0072383801,
0.0093395934,
0.0250507314,
-0.0596568733,
-0.0249519367,
-0.0076963613,
0.0182297081,
0.0028586655,
0.0404531658,
-0.0218643174,
-0.0351009071,
-0.0501701646,
0.0460663699,
-0.0031616411,
-0.0391105711,
0.0617711768,
0.0221849084,
-0.0582415238,
-0.0225039776,
-0.0351870283,
0.0710596666,
-0.0180206895,
-0.0164247677,
-0.0048406003,
-5.760318314e-33,
-0.0607282519,
-0.0398049206,
0.0339264125,
0.0397795327,
-0.0209659226,
-0.040066272,
-0.0602603629,
0.0165353417,
0.007357249,
-0.0094768414,
-0.0159968082,
0.0118915243,
-0.003273376,
0.0373924412,
0.0086360946,
0.0004604807,
0.0324927047,
-0.0060525788,
-0.0070763663,
0.0448731184,
0.0599331371,
-0.0081064841,
0.0487900898,
-0.0253309067,
0.0144305071,
-0.0206654146,
-0.000354458,
-0.0288479123,
0.0010808283,
0.0464842767,
-0.0286279619,
0.0404022224,
-0.0119434744,
-0.0056907292,
-0.041581355,
0.0286875796,
-0.0656324401,
-0.0471854322,
0.0201667622,
0.0268445648,
-0.0162731335,
-0.0572339892,
0.0079719881,
-0.0332038775,
-0.022498386,
0.0066772499,
0.0334830917,
-0.0351968557,
0.0070389993,
0.0406393558,
-0.0879627913,
0.0134227071,
-0.0683729947,
-0.0654788464,
0.0126467003,
0.0685582533,
0.0182905048,
-0.0506878421,
0.021766508,
0.0779285431,
0.001631635,
0.006758919,
0.0616182052,
0.0128543628,
-0.0063891942,
0.0759938732,
0.0177328922,
-0.0047396468,
-0.0195569452,
-0.0189591404,
0.0295453221,
0.0137773044,
0.047185313,
0.0929157436,
0.0315635167,
-0.0247201938,
0.0018879608,
0.0472870283,
0.0449885651,
0.011630835,
-0.0172003787,
0.0015916978,
-0.0479314141,
0.0138107175,
-0.0213559866,
0.0374475233,
-0.0005866306,
-0.0239806511,
0.0252887979,
0.002730259,
-0.013449382,
-0.0866356269,
-0.0008752298,
-0.0223106854,
0.0301983766,
0.0325769484,
-0.0328628421,
0.0038069834,
-0.0378018767,
0.0177964643,
-0.0173337273,
-0.0098248934,
0.0634633526,
0.0004338812,
0.0163591336,
0.0310087092,
-0.0497127324,
0.0261220485,
-0.0287515037,
0.0045085051,
-0.0614882074,
0.0515841581,
0.0020395522,
-0.0395301096,
0.0182315223,
-0.0009175068,
-0.0579326674,
0.0089927278,
0.0041175289,
-0.0481656156,
-0.0702065527,
-0.0492394194,
-0.0073400177,
-0.0246729348,
-0.053437829,
-0.0071037235,
-0.0081845876,
0.0175939873,
0.0141903395,
-0.0584182143,
0.0063149589,
-0.0050396658,
2.646e-7,
0.0139953149,
0.0488996394,
0.0329110175,
-0.0010323441,
0.0257738903,
0.0232357159,
-0.0025059376,
0.0166500062,
0.0134201478,
-0.0189583171,
-0.015955437,
0.0248426571,
0.0441951491,
-0.0054183863,
-0.0783620477,
0.0027126085,
-0.0321035013,
-0.0025593068,
-0.0220194347,
0.0264681466,
0.100827761,
0.0268486012,
0.0177507624,
0.0010869926,
0.0068106386,
-0.0040141232,
0.0017421512,
-0.0162838921,
0.0321321189,
0.0281114262,
0.0050290213,
-0.0073328018,
0.0235128682,
0.0058633126,
0.0117577119,
0.018376302,
0.0049008764,
0.0546722263,
0.0073109465,
-0.0209917389,
0.0185582358,
0.0299337823,
-0.0410324633,
-0.0329821333,
0.0084615238,
-0.0141711514,
0.0123894047,
-0.016008554,
-0.0164498277,
-0.0123582492,
-0.0298069082,
-0.0278310962,
-0.021569578,
0.0056274096,
-0.0185437594,
-0.0108538028,
0.0457262509,
-0.0145619679,
0.0154901342,
-0.0485289842,
-0.074491784,
-0.0400487483,
-0.0599068329,
-0.0203003846,
-0.0219215713,
0.0024420696,
0.0177228432,
1.756331594e-34,
-0.0069488934,
-0.0109842755,
0.0407783501,
0.0627339557,
0.0203794371,
0.0115479836,
0.045211371,
0.0555129871,
0.0567562841,
-0.0433578454,
-0.0583525673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05468v1 | A Survey of Resources and Methods for Natural Language Processing of Serbian Language | 2023-04-11T19:33:41 | 2023-04-11T19:33:41 | Ulfeta A. Marovac, Aldina R. Avdić, Nikola Lj. Milošević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.HC, A.1 | The Serbian language is a Slavic language spoken by over 12 million speakers
and well understood by over 15 million people. In the area of natural language
processing, it can be considered a low-resourced language. Also, Serbian is
considered a high-inflectional language. The combination of many word
inflections and low availability of language resources makes natural language
processing of Serbian challenging. Nevertheless, over the past three decades,
there have been a number of initiatives to develop resources and methods for
natural language processing of Serbian, ranging from developing a corpus of
free text from books and the internet, annotated corpora for classification and
named entity recognition tasks to various methods and models performing these
tasks. In this paper, we review the initiatives, resources, methods, and their
availability. | [
0.0483572371,
0.0027292424,
-0.0014730789,
0.036095798,
-0.019111624,
0.0446376093,
-0.0178918876,
0.0171810854,
0.0269864071,
-0.0060444605,
-0.0142708151,
-0.0174891409,
0.0064595877,
-0.0496294461,
0.0017061073,
-0.0692920163,
0.0720476583,
-0.0055767423,
0.0031385461,
0.0297691096,
0.0316912681,
0.016753871,
-0.0563991889,
-0.0124434838,
-0.0224151891,
0.018605819,
0.0185384918,
-0.001586952,
0.0411166288,
-0.0534227043,
-0.0331908949,
0.0245771166,
-0.0365840271,
0.0164783988,
0.0000013545,
-0.0765753314,
-0.018867448,
-0.0033096084,
-0.005421889,
-0.0155862467,
0.042741105,
-0.0655684546,
-0.0221089851,
-0.0207349975,
0.0044060638,
-0.0070543895,
0.0650848001,
0.0214315429,
0.0314392596,
0.042806834,
0.0100293485,
-0.0657521933,
0.0338481292,
0.0307474602,
-0.0567436516,
0.0149968909,
0.0111584617,
-0.0327360593,
0.0095043499,
0.0053660464,
-0.0099385493,
0.044518929,
-0.0560958609,
-0.0236143917,
-0.0096565001,
-0.0050306041,
-0.0430627465,
-0.0246908758,
0.0171766337,
0.018758405,
-0.0010834079,
-0.0052220863,
0.0526980609,
-0.0014035477,
-0.0031120395,
0.0102357743,
-0.0096669169,
-0.0064458996,
-0.0197762717,
0.0333005227,
0.0554300845,
0.0454052202,
-0.0047566835,
0.0209973194,
0.067554675,
0.0717796758,
0.0252428632,
-0.0011664034,
0.0384250656,
-0.008005322,
0.0173468441,
-0.0104941959,
0.0312784873,
0.0037131996,
0.0195261482,
0.0222021658,
-0.0160274599,
-0.0319415741,
0.0214075539,
-0.0621740371,
0.0220140219,
0.0145235239,
0.0258536134,
0.0265329275,
-0.0364572331,
-0.0178640485,
-0.0164771341,
0.0049959873,
-0.010414226,
-0.0267997887,
-0.0605794154,
0.0189476814,
-0.0824468732,
0.0196920317,
-0.049392771,
0.0132175284,
-0.0546037406,
0.019763954,
0.0314770788,
-0.0262238421,
0.0179889668,
-0.0036571363,
0.0189371705,
-0.0093878862,
-0.0257070586,
0.0223570056,
-0.0272538122,
-0.0228399727,
-0.0824985653,
-0.0572162531,
0.0720241666,
0.0099693472,
0.0239767917,
0.00036671,
0.055793684,
0.0167298876,
0.0139774689,
-0.0440627299,
-0.053109061,
0.0203240719,
-0.0004903222,
-0.065519616,
-0.0228413623,
-0.0538670979,
0.0226003882,
0.026316477,
-0.0005628945,
-0.0263982974,
0.0128496401,
0.0222045276,
-0.0237926953,
0.0814058408,
-0.0542728491,
-0.012111729,
0.047508385,
-0.0378463119,
0.0954245776,
0.0190190151,
0.0246213414,
-0.04403916,
0.0789389983,
0.0119853755,
0.0046908115,
0.0360258743,
-0.0462596752,
-0.0234319475,
0.0004297526,
0.0523263328,
-0.0279785618,
0.0041234647,
0.0151060335,
0.0495463908,
0.0120253609,
-0.0013001015,
0.0055072019,
0.0546867363,
-0.0211430117,
0.018564051,
0.0328721069,
0.0017474678,
0.0358147621,
-0.0509961769,
-0.0154867787,
-0.0201653931,
0.0132442731,
0.0113521479,
-0.0589730181,
0.0274264589,
0.0040865736,
-0.0136482744,
-0.0218980033,
-0.0398550071,
0.0551158041,
-0.0502028167,
0.069414407,
0.0079369554,
-0.0062216008,
-0.004806078,
0.0311880819,
0.004862824,
0.0239066277,
0.0083483476,
0.0000448593,
0.0245971829,
0.0012799178,
-0.0614313111,
0.0125012659,
-0.0024356456,
0.009398316,
0.0388350114,
0.0058736745,
-0.0508496799,
-0.0247859564,
-0.0236438662,
0.0437408574,
0.0509955436,
0.0211829543,
0.0336837471,
-0.0505771413,
0.0472224876,
0.021453727,
-0.0010108524,
-0.0004807518,
0.0343259163,
0.0048167226,
-0.0018291775,
0.0036034945,
-0.006084532,
0.0137063656,
0.0486873426,
0.0400939621,
0.0395243019,
0.0190705266,
-0.0354449339,
0.016148366,
0.0491028652,
0.0698279515,
-0.0386500768,
-0.0077986433,
-0.0454754494,
-0.0190501846,
-0.0291608721,
0.034584552,
-0.0266489368,
0.037983954,
-0.0291371942,
0.010119535,
-0.0227010231,
0.0114941988,
-0.0071393694,
0.0363171138,
-0.0222109165,
0.0573642813,
0.0190129951,
0.0226214603,
0.0198751129,
-0.0134553472,
0.0023341286,
-0.0157964136,
-0.022807112,
0.0487387478,
-0.0402538031,
-0.0306328125,
-0.0220158286,
-0.0326890722,
-0.0374750383,
0.0540299267,
-0.0784294084,
0.0362085439,
0.0128384195,
0.0964466631,
-0.0104409661,
0.0261805709,
-0.0368774645,
-0.0194314122,
0.0309271012,
0.0134769008,
0.0614804924,
-0.0013257281,
0.0300405025,
0.0065491511,
-0.0038913263,
-0.0185059141,
-0.0093031768,
-0.0102379369,
-0.0583344288,
0.0065482715,
-0.0404089317,
-0.0628924444,
0.031723626,
-0.0108753415,
0.029095212,
0.0008430469,
-0.0377244875,
-0.0215217452,
0.0366321802,
-0.0069213393,
-0.0051192814,
-0.0249586198,
-0.0091892118,
0.0173226986,
-0.0426811911,
0.04233386,
-0.0331077762,
-0.0258125905,
0.0573948547,
-0.0578268841,
0.0313821733,
0.0533324964,
0.0563870147,
-0.0022666906,
0.0092590963,
0.0140680103,
-0.0503706001,
-0.09177614,
0.0278779883,
0.0187885351,
-0.0303352196,
-0.0317316093,
0.0414756723,
0.0406494699,
0.0261800047,
0.05822815,
-0.0309744906,
-0.0305340514,
-0.0720372871,
-0.0191104785,
-0.042188935,
0.0097507508,
0.0045480351,
0.0021238166,
0.006395983,
-0.0624311343,
0.0263749231,
0.0137557508,
0.0506156944,
-0.0030254719,
0.0218063761,
-0.0285299849,
0.0084085269,
-0.005888246,
-0.0152216759,
-0.0233270563,
-0.0525781773,
-0.015162603,
0.0000367766,
0.0152191687,
0.0154534867,
0.0158852469,
0.0257445816,
-0.0238089692,
0.0157946534,
0.003477399,
0.0097936057,
0.0006090451,
0.0649497136,
-0.009844251,
-0.0487161092,
0.0173055492,
0.0591427498,
-0.0112851718,
0.0063942731,
0.0068654688,
-0.0339571089,
0.0095175076,
-0.0167273451,
0.0160654299,
-0.071560286,
-0.0398667306,
-0.0121222092,
0.0170515366,
-0.0299951844,
-0.026326742,
0.0649532229,
0.0240987446,
0.0124419378,
0.014924325,
0.0047773328,
-0.0598794781,
0.0292674005,
0.0155547718,
-0.0359439552,
-0.0010504054,
0.0075341356,
-0.0039127031,
-0.0586747974,
-0.0564338341,
0.0491111279,
-0.1123692766,
0.0080381222,
-0.0222529527,
-0.0133351684,
0.0069541587,
-0.0859016702,
0.0009639149,
-0.0332080983,
-0.0707612634,
0.0067720311,
-0.0483740494,
0.0127392262,
0.0403290875,
-0.0314376503,
-0.0773923695,
-0.0046712835,
-0.0381194353,
0.0209256727,
0.0297671333,
0.0555258915,
-0.0386540964,
0.0241566803,
0.0136012007,
-0.0950019732,
0.0089277308,
-0.0343288407,
0.03498023,
0.0254876707,
-0.0358407125,
-0.0919530243,
0.0504881591,
-0.0269074403,
-0.0182294846,
-0.0192309935,
0.040511664,
0.0007376142,
0.0069149896,
-0.0051114359,
-0.0251735467,
0.0479318127,
0.021769464,
-0.0584760383,
0.0206071399,
0.0064536817,
0.0231376197,
0.0062005892,
-0.012143271,
-0.0425521359,
0.0184450354,
-0.0348977745,
-0.0242068339,
-0.0615864508,
-0.0776320025,
0.0380970575,
0.0127196815,
-0.029696513,
0.0348277278,
0.012513848,
0.0359950103,
-0.0332553312,
0.0213587936,
-0.009489865,
0.0135554187,
-0.0290324278,
0.0233075935,
0.0328204632,
0.0162765551,
-0.0332927778,
0.0326162726,
-0.0033584859,
-0.0546505637,
0.0335141458,
0.0177724715,
0.0257761944,
0.0084659467,
-0.0291483905,
-0.0025270616,
0.000069833,
0.0087791588,
-0.0310951099,
-0.0300583933,
-0.0186086968,
0.0293040927,
-0.0235336255,
0.0275877696,
0.0248099696,
0.0198823903,
0.0036798005,
-0.0204661973,
-0.0404784866,
-0.0335984454,
-0.000646357,
0.0061306213,
0.0615257099,
-0.0465127937,
-0.0377868153,
-0.0554302596,
-0.0123941069,
-0.0189377051,
-0.015952291,
0.0385152623,
0.0043534036,
0.0377500169,
-0.0154786333,
-0.0534810126,
0.0435490012,
-0.033176627,
-0.0200571511,
0.0327386297,
0.0564814582,
0.0555657521,
0.0475100987,
-0.0053553977,
0.0092486944,
0.0321636684,
0.0537448786,
0.0053455313,
0.004167377,
-0.0368000455,
-0.0202301871,
-0.0169637464,
-0.0187593903,
-0.0453105234,
0.0269041397,
0.0266265906,
0.0817933977,
-0.0198825337,
0.0682590231,
0.0518709272,
-0.0245107654,
0.0551937036,
-0.0247798227,
-0.0125154769,
-0.0001090463,
0.0268435646,
-0.0398261696,
-0.0077538383,
0.007234775,
0.0023683803,
-0.0489651002,
-0.0321398042,
-0.0100613954,
-0.0212161317,
0.0123915365,
0.0518852882,
-0.0261628609,
-0.0096473135,
0.0194198433,
-0.0321127102,
-0.016412748,
-0.0555225983,
-0.0112491883,
-0.0633851066,
-0.0238687899,
0.0036818481,
0.0158275254,
-0.0412685461,
-0.0041028648,
0.0405405201,
-0.0169006921,
0.0634152666,
-0.002000164,
-0.0383962132,
0.017374564,
-0.0577716306,
-0.0098750116,
-0.0182313938,
-4.728947652e-33,
-0.0465807021,
0.0078398772,
-0.0053971889,
-0.0016319975,
0.014949129,
-0.0189139843,
0.0343074165,
0.0301702376,
0.004779405,
0.0065788748,
-0.0205080174,
-0.023991758,
0.0434987918,
-0.0404085405,
0.0560279228,
-0.0148314238,
0.0154546993,
-0.0030937979,
0.0069041746,
-0.0101547446,
0.0647954941,
0.0129562709,
0.1367663145,
-0.0701583251,
0.0478868298,
-0.0349580124,
-0.0153968111,
0.0166811384,
0.0751765817,
0.0482685119,
-0.0409349538,
0.0299617294,
0.0255119931,
-0.0571443662,
0.0044069677,
0.0053764642,
-0.0999557078,
-0.0075114584,
0.0294911321,
0.0696384981,
-0.0103713842,
-0.029431263,
0.0088561783,
-0.0081180912,
-0.0338754021,
0.0704834983,
0.0199837349,
-0.0411574244,
0.0562779754,
0.0103328144,
-0.1333614588,
0.0376222916,
-0.0156788062,
0.0007811083,
0.0346945971,
-0.0048622978,
0.0158348437,
-0.0321482494,
-0.0686204433,
-0.0115351742,
-0.0640745163,
0.0172698013,
0.0182100777,
-0.0454669856,
-0.0086312098,
-0.0068564555,
0.0132505363,
-0.0590757951,
0.0500170141,
0.0246875063,
0.038293086,
0.0594062917,
0.0248310063,
0.1007799953,
0.076060079,
-0.0387653559,
-0.0526702441,
0.000060898,
0.0702296197,
0.0423463434,
-0.0761155263,
-0.0313523337,
-0.051216282,
-0.0181009639,
0.0264721867,
-0.0776076838,
-0.0123475324,
-0.0361277126,
0.0291801766,
-0.0006924265,
-0.0245459527,
0.0738482922,
-0.0015528748,
-0.0030812814,
-0.0869250372,
-0.0112362457,
0.0453827791,
0.0552943386,
-0.0325415581,
0.0384215117,
-0.0516121909,
-0.0296486337,
-0.0249828734,
0.0007112941,
0.0141276792,
-0.0068339184,
-0.003668813,
-0.0061193001,
-0.0203254502,
0.0351728722,
0.0373260342,
0.034048032,
-0.0192153715,
0.0866856426,
0.0095394598,
-0.0118601145,
0.014613267,
0.0233544353,
0.040747039,
-0.0005197391,
-0.0207907241,
-0.0272459649,
0.0480694585,
-0.0162645988,
0.0142530687,
0.0263582058,
-0.0023940825,
0.0173982121,
0.0095801158,
0.0089524109,
0.0342456773,
-0.0126636457,
2.054e-7,
0.054018978,
0.0555986241,
0.0143602062,
-0.0279188529,
0.0127056725,
-0.0058941687,
-0.0230296906,
0.0187509898,
-0.0113542387,
0.0301672351,
-0.010857828,
-0.0412903726,
0.0153952176,
0.0464720316,
-0.108725369,
-0.0156127457,
0.002600529,
-0.0490379781,
-0.0545029268,
0.0304369405,
-0.029331008,
0.0635834038,
0.0241983347,
-0.0318236724,
-0.0937772244,
-0.0272722449,
0.0126153836,
0.0058000758,
-0.0084285717,
0.0313821435,
0.0510830879,
0.0351617783,
0.0120191742,
0.0079113636,
-0.0277278218,
0.0424106382,
0.0105543295,
0.0226958711,
-0.0553560965,
0.0082468959,
0.0314859077,
-0.0408917926,
-0.0554815345,
-0.0175099988,
0.1032733768,
-0.0043182974,
-0.0393492654,
-0.0194588508,
-0.011205717,
0.0010419262,
-0.0087149357,
-0.0119891521,
-0.0097773997,
0.0185541939,
0.03428597,
-0.0467620976,
-0.0417362228,
-0.026637191,
0.0076842858,
-0.0002722411,
-0.0259030871,
0.0103887934,
0.0075427513,
0.0450951196,
0.0149311954,
-0.0347316675,
0.014450782,
1.223099691e-34,
-0.0108326096,
0.0562122762,
0.0079707969,
0.0331080668,
-0.0490174368,
0.0047640945,
-0.060111329,
0.0655906647,
-0.0306765903,
-0.0353743099,
0.0035810778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05454v1 | Zero-shot Temporal Relation Extraction with ChatGPT | 2023-04-11T18:59:05 | 2023-04-11T18:59:05 | Chenhan Yuan, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The goal of temporal relation extraction is to infer the temporal relation
between two events in the document. Supervised models are dominant in this
task. In this work, we investigate ChatGPT's ability on zero-shot temporal
relation extraction. We designed three different prompt techniques to break
down the task and evaluate ChatGPT. Our experiments show that ChatGPT's
performance has a large gap with that of supervised methods and can heavily
rely on the design of prompts. We further demonstrate that ChatGPT can infer
more small relation classes correctly than supervised methods. The current
shortcomings of ChatGPT on temporal relation extraction are also discussed in
this paper. We found that ChatGPT cannot keep consistency during temporal
inference and it fails in actively long-dependency temporal inference. | [
0.0098417383,
0.029633591,
0.0175375938,
0.0725518093,
-0.0537389554,
0.0112067489,
0.0371167734,
0.0384387635,
0.0187396985,
-0.0343914516,
0.0042302408,
-0.016903745,
-0.0064200498,
-0.0020081787,
-0.0654148608,
-0.0796595141,
0.0503578261,
0.0097558359,
0.0293104593,
0.0570153259,
0.0018510952,
0.0011013154,
-0.0553074442,
-0.0077579599,
-0.024925461,
-0.056299258,
-0.0258296486,
-0.0534722805,
0.0586126074,
-0.0756057277,
-0.014727884,
0.0354537554,
0.0041693905,
0.018814398,
0.0000017711,
-0.0321866125,
-0.0184020679,
-0.0077988338,
-0.0397725143,
-0.0043979809,
-0.0276101306,
-0.0150651662,
0.0088556772,
-0.0405200906,
-0.0510216169,
-0.0551320799,
-0.0065194052,
0.0712142885,
-0.0191056132,
0.0651842058,
-0.0389675647,
-0.0040579294,
0.023287382,
-0.0127549293,
0.0585983209,
-0.0450690314,
0.0042431019,
0.0083780102,
0.0603077374,
0.0151521545,
-0.0015524862,
0.0056141498,
0.0016198386,
0.0019315763,
0.0200953837,
0.0880722478,
-0.0670718402,
0.0249751788,
-0.0180053376,
0.0602322593,
0.0503067337,
-0.005888693,
0.0189081971,
0.0267789923,
-0.0265335832,
0.0198087003,
-0.0468231589,
-0.0063011758,
-0.0344123915,
-0.0012749494,
0.017926937,
0.0587137043,
-0.0115467347,
-0.0003558667,
0.0186183769,
0.0476692356,
0.0122854738,
-0.0127735445,
-0.0357928909,
0.0126546565,
0.0241045691,
-0.0332074724,
-0.0049387184,
0.0556080937,
0.0331672244,
0.0059361113,
-0.0176843312,
0.0143450918,
-0.0338502973,
-0.0521027073,
-0.0478978343,
0.0186103154,
-0.0267462023,
0.0849291235,
-0.040383663,
0.0455728434,
-0.0126223518,
-0.0336986072,
0.0221058205,
0.0180418789,
-0.0659180209,
0.0248622727,
-0.0328600183,
0.0236444697,
-0.016551977,
-0.017596852,
-0.0186093971,
0.0236642491,
0.0196557678,
0.0103150764,
-0.0403869301,
-0.014910697,
-0.034849748,
-0.0082249455,
-0.0166138448,
-0.0012547182,
-0.0218365602,
-0.0164881386,
-0.0336463302,
-0.0383892432,
-0.0251148734,
-0.0006138444,
0.0465942435,
-0.0400563888,
-0.0291022249,
0.0902934298,
-0.0301721003,
-0.0337664634,
-0.040007364,
-0.0437726416,
0.0022493466,
-0.039065782,
-0.0091280406,
-0.0233034901,
0.0325604938,
0.0224621911,
-0.0207452159,
0.0456787087,
0.0132674361,
-0.0250361245,
-0.0491467677,
0.0641865879,
-0.0077610142,
-0.0072952029,
0.0011152887,
0.0301955789,
0.0054126787,
0.0496028922,
0.0252137892,
-0.001389225,
0.0414576791,
0.0435856394,
-0.0017526116,
0.0131570008,
-0.0021178606,
-0.0269633587,
-0.0124113169,
-0.0122497668,
0.042181842,
-0.0200449377,
0.0080888504,
-0.001953555,
-0.051305782,
-0.0309772901,
0.0226603299,
0.0072034355,
0.0009580415,
-0.0158884488,
0.0727504939,
-0.0163238272,
0.029945299,
0.0342562348,
-0.0395695604,
0.0208181143,
-0.0215018336,
0.0315754041,
-0.0796974078,
0.0041892994,
-0.0140116094,
0.0221734475,
0.000930687,
-0.0178775359,
-0.0287593473,
-0.0395718701,
0.0803275481,
-0.0108828126,
-0.0296730157,
0.0406362116,
0.0414159484,
0.0230462831,
-0.0368694551,
0.0090269605,
0.0438427962,
0.0488888025,
0.062776804,
-0.035312131,
-0.0860089585,
-0.0171041526,
0.0146690905,
0.0374349803,
0.0420007557,
-0.0401774347,
0.0272367373,
-0.0193127003,
-0.0258568339,
0.0420930721,
0.0171663798,
0.0024104898,
0.0648875982,
0.0469133705,
0.0186148733,
0.0111268498,
0.0368650146,
0.005690373,
-0.0116681103,
-0.0580652468,
-0.0153216636,
0.0174993481,
0.0014859051,
0.0110552013,
-0.0207700823,
-0.0262059551,
0.0289626177,
-0.0262792446,
0.0173608903,
0.077869162,
-0.0573685355,
-0.0943217725,
0.0007476274,
0.0095224539,
-0.0356940515,
-0.0467732996,
-0.0351683237,
-0.0256116856,
0.0004290713,
0.0740423501,
0.0539036952,
-0.0115812924,
-0.0029141591,
0.0551405735,
0.0008042367,
-0.0279219281,
0.07442981,
0.0327972285,
-0.0145525886,
0.0260625686,
-0.0032355981,
0.0023444591,
-0.0253305938,
0.0008894671,
0.0372373648,
-0.000490104,
-0.0717454478,
0.0065591787,
0.0116286213,
-0.0587799922,
-0.0098647028,
-0.0736108497,
0.0248768684,
0.0107074641,
0.0566426739,
0.0029144816,
0.0096336743,
-0.0381923318,
-0.0181987118,
0.0104208663,
0.0134830754,
-0.0366931409,
-0.0024893091,
0.0634048805,
0.0398941599,
-0.0164124276,
-0.0193271153,
0.0119344257,
-0.0608189702,
0.0531985462,
0.0183443185,
-0.0497826189,
0.0173425525,
0.0317506157,
-0.0048726941,
0.0273252223,
-0.0182636548,
0.0077536032,
0.020610556,
-0.0307438001,
0.0193107706,
0.0396944359,
-0.0031656113,
0.0489471518,
-0.0118798297,
-0.046954345,
-0.0210004989,
0.0397054888,
-0.0246619936,
0.0301671363,
0.0182293523,
0.0262547173,
-0.0505814664,
0.0560254119,
-0.015372281,
0.0417623296,
-0.0258547869,
-0.0069856746,
0.0029351895,
0.0370237567,
-0.0066756811,
0.022839345,
0.0006040347,
-0.013958483,
-0.044789046,
-0.0015178847,
0.0292838234,
-0.0234651733,
-0.0289522596,
0.0204481184,
-0.0052329185,
-0.0454266593,
0.1095519811,
0.0084998487,
-0.0163595267,
0.0404009968,
-0.0492688715,
-0.0320430398,
-0.0377186649,
0.0736965239,
0.0327242054,
-0.010713594,
-0.0384121239,
0.0480371565,
-0.0367524177,
0.013274366,
-0.0676937401,
-0.0759137645,
-0.0236278698,
-0.0051583881,
-0.0674202815,
0.0060563171,
0.0009824521,
0.050802581,
-0.0303032007,
0.0282749813,
-0.0527643971,
-0.0304328371,
-0.0216728114,
0.0982235149,
0.0707451403,
-0.0379277989,
-0.0352442935,
0.0093211569,
0.0409231372,
0.0257200412,
0.0272724945,
0.0129677001,
-0.0363070816,
0.0002566431,
-0.0592866428,
-0.0486120097,
-0.002404683,
-0.0173120964,
-0.0048544845,
-0.0687495545,
0.0001377776,
0.1053545773,
0.0283639338,
-0.0235987734,
-0.0222721323,
0.0274234675,
-0.007776415,
-0.0111542325,
0.0004294289,
-0.0880863592,
-0.018016234,
-0.0168161057,
-0.0595201887,
-0.0141253369,
-0.0405299142,
-0.0342263728,
-0.0731691122,
0.0069839042,
0.000847118,
-0.020893015,
0.023204932,
-0.0277843513,
0.0239817481,
-0.0164910294,
-0.0293853339,
0.0234645028,
-0.0294819251,
0.0110227447,
-0.0236885939,
-0.0298380926,
-0.0404777266,
0.0508317202,
0.014105062,
0.0425676294,
0.0059249159,
0.0213537011,
0.003688693,
0.02321513,
0.0474526659,
0.0073060496,
-0.0052532754,
-0.0367604494,
0.0767183676,
-0.0422948785,
-0.0062277322,
-0.0137306536,
0.0191894043,
0.0139759425,
-0.0283446573,
0.0211496223,
0.0738827959,
-0.0147592863,
-0.0212382618,
-0.0208696723,
0.0022637448,
-0.0024928909,
0.0463339016,
-0.0177981965,
0.0247542225,
-0.0675321072,
0.0341859199,
-0.0255042873,
-0.0592161678,
0.0038941039,
-0.0335011221,
-0.0440210365,
-0.0318344906,
-0.0538527034,
-0.0769572631,
0.0156679228,
0.0307238679,
-0.0302204341,
0.0038724402,
-0.0045445771,
0.0445057005,
-0.0322917439,
0.0117277587,
-0.0122566894,
-0.0203846358,
-0.0119588245,
0.0147128617,
0.0361146405,
0.0066944552,
-0.0099823466,
-0.00900645,
-0.0605658069,
-0.0183078703,
-0.0394395478,
-0.0273396522,
0.0159309655,
0.0891584009,
-0.0200091004,
0.0519630164,
0.0293717198,
0.0796958506,
-0.0339921601,
-0.0216032825,
0.0167724453,
0.0214078054,
-0.0132566746,
0.0176844038,
-0.0130250836,
0.0364909023,
-0.0090614371,
0.0128511749,
-0.0392281599,
0.0156672448,
0.0066389223,
-0.0010886937,
0.0775220245,
0.028831806,
0.0200407896,
-0.0179309882,
0.002357776,
-0.0729737803,
0.0218711644,
-0.0212508701,
0.0358197391,
-0.0363008529,
0.0075790933,
-0.0252931658,
-0.0236538686,
-0.0255348179,
0.0269738678,
-0.0117134284,
-0.0083110128,
0.0290253088,
-0.0082330517,
0.0123327486,
-0.024412021,
-0.0143551361,
0.0092033856,
-0.0003337635,
0.0131534347,
-0.0276269745,
0.0529737063,
0.0226420257,
0.0100676557,
-0.0055643767,
-0.0289087184,
-0.0805882812,
0.0644970238,
-0.002810678,
0.0657666177,
0.0708628371,
-0.0641499236,
0.0310568009,
-0.0259001888,
-0.0088134808,
0.0265239999,
0.0506664105,
0.0228041895,
0.0152714336,
0.0045734136,
0.0075099291,
-0.0129621774,
0.0495183244,
0.0755269453,
-0.0166286621,
0.0371816717,
0.0670587718,
-0.0187165178,
-0.0271618273,
-0.0004164236,
-0.0186542962,
-0.0427262932,
0.0147688435,
0.025518341,
-0.0581544079,
-0.0116727455,
0.0495765805,
-0.0293411203,
-0.0206581634,
0.0194525439,
0.0003362141,
0.0330698378,
0.0459374897,
-0.0440159291,
-0.0048016799,
0.0538185164,
0.001477215,
-0.0278123617,
-0.0580825694,
-5.949742616e-33,
-0.0480832681,
-0.0394980945,
0.0278183594,
0.0481613204,
-0.0516580306,
0.0477220528,
-0.0276386905,
-0.0257473309,
-0.0028218606,
0.0379855111,
-0.0282744262,
0.0092632631,
0.0213651676,
-0.0390605107,
0.0151726706,
-0.0259490218,
0.0135708591,
-0.0088725053,
0.0237884726,
0.0228455476,
0.0591253713,
0.0469092652,
0.0542976297,
-0.0603619777,
0.0105485786,
-0.0182932224,
0.021068003,
-0.0023094502,
0.0662974641,
0.0413937345,
-0.0198962241,
-0.0271449573,
0.0466480516,
-0.0167623628,
-0.001198716,
0.000823564,
-0.1472335011,
-0.061478667,
-0.0127847418,
0.0062842118,
-0.0058482392,
-0.017229436,
-0.049427703,
-0.011309226,
0.0407587029,
-0.0671540499,
0.025887683,
-0.0415665433,
-0.0240284093,
-0.0670514181,
-0.0794719085,
0.0656199455,
0.0035988751,
-0.0130619407,
0.0666007102,
0.0251492523,
0.0535959788,
-0.0259019174,
-0.0038667514,
-0.0231583286,
-0.0000187525,
0.0175657067,
-0.0027663307,
0.0011265875,
-0.0153375017,
0.0318952538,
-0.0276313815,
-0.019711433,
-0.0229904056,
0.0313315392,
-0.0064993431,
0.019855665,
-0.0242762268,
0.0019585553,
0.0379236639,
0.0069153402,
-0.0707487017,
0.0155936722,
0.0910168588,
0.0343953408,
-0.0275880042,
-0.0001172371,
-0.0395918861,
0.0256834812,
0.05223516,
-0.0049660495,
-0.0024719501,
-0.0320060961,
0.0124046179,
0.0118554328,
0.0395774692,
0.0136215184,
0.0566135123,
-0.0163942501,
-0.014456843,
0.0076671089,
-0.0545576587,
0.0124788228,
-0.0072935242,
-0.007796193,
-0.0452555232,
-0.0374411531,
0.0087457905,
0.0306541417,
0.0116772344,
0.0133525403,
0.0530471876,
-0.0113751609,
-0.030309407,
-0.0509489775,
-0.0013010358,
-0.0004896871,
-0.0091991853,
-0.0161656421,
0.0118432008,
0.0069411392,
-0.0121283326,
0.0581444614,
0.0113978749,
0.044052057,
-0.0029064515,
0.0460209884,
-0.0073742527,
0.0153202713,
-0.0034138295,
0.0050321771,
-0.0008977554,
0.0251036324,
-0.0165129639,
-0.0264829267,
-0.0014986567,
0.0094293812,
2.404e-7,
0.0051813689,
0.0064650276,
0.0662197173,
0.0482736938,
0.0113987103,
-0.0029809349,
0.0031467623,
0.0152061488,
-0.0241723061,
0.0128418393,
0.0403720625,
0.0107902922,
0.035920348,
0.0326730981,
-0.0460368805,
-0.0467684567,
-0.0645460561,
-0.0848100334,
-0.0767070428,
-0.0351219587,
0.1099638864,
0.0393021628,
0.0430243053,
0.0370963179,
-0.0263968147,
-0.0404586568,
0.0654628128,
0.0073771868,
-0.0518185534,
0.0357067101,
0.0400545821,
-0.0131969266,
-0.0384264365,
0.0340846889,
0.0002881886,
0.0068393759,
-0.0369687639,
0.0433213897,
-0.0423985347,
0.00652052,
0.0013199019,
-0.0276266038,
-0.0079072788,
0.0183693785,
0.1131762415,
-0.0611334965,
0.0061778664,
-0.017454464,
-0.0419599116,
0.0339892507,
-0.0188416149,
0.0454051495,
-0.0245466083,
0.039308507,
0.0267950837,
-0.0225439928,
-0.0454281531,
-0.0829128101,
0.0142538128,
0.0484244414,
0.0019409652,
-0.0035944479,
0.0202787761,
-0.0368218683,
0.0182707384,
-0.0178589392,
-0.016908871,
1.927223447e-34,
0.0200930145,
0.0255056359,
-0.0233480632,
0.0382958502,
0.0247280896,
-0.0320095234,
0.0012299785,
0.0146879461,
0.0079307156,
-0.0502302907,
0.012404317
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.