id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11618v1 | Modality-Aware Negative Sampling for Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-04-23T11:22:17 | 2023-04-23T11:22:17 | Yichi Zhang, Mingyang Chen, Wen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Negative sampling (NS) is widely used in knowledge graph embedding (KGE),
which aims to generate negative triples to make a positive-negative contrast
during training. However, existing NS methods are unsuitable when multi-modal
information is considered in KGE models. They are also inefficient due to their
complex design. In this paper, we propose Modality-Aware Negative Sampling
(MANS) for multi-modal knowledge graph embedding (MMKGE) to address the
mentioned problems. MANS could align structural and visual embeddings for
entities in KGs and learn meaningful embeddings to perform better in
multi-modal KGE while keeping lightweight and efficient. Empirical results on
two benchmarks demonstrate that MANS outperforms existing NS methods.
Meanwhile, we make further explorations about MANS to confirm its
effectiveness. | [
-0.0140428562,
-0.0167210866,
-0.007872819,
0.0368154757,
-0.0040851729,
-0.0219434146,
-0.0423867702,
0.0006863511,
0.0330695137,
-0.0644943193,
-0.0227508172,
-0.0052073468,
-0.0448480286,
0.0028337727,
0.0661352575,
-0.0243055839,
0.0186582562,
0.0386885144,
-0.0233942121,
-0.0152972834,
0.023363011,
0.0178442039,
-0.0161590949,
-0.0047638253,
-0.0180773661,
-0.015899878,
-0.0410575196,
0.0020609656,
0.0315784067,
-0.0533646978,
-0.0454295389,
0.0014472515,
0.0390523076,
-0.0428873114,
0.0000017185,
-0.0074067675,
0.0231757853,
0.0269947462,
-0.0110762324,
-0.0044159107,
0.0273159668,
-0.0570059158,
0.0418975241,
-0.0081532737,
-0.0188023411,
-0.0060032168,
0.0084041227,
0.0854400247,
0.0205143169,
0.0376566909,
-0.0283528659,
0.0236493889,
0.003042585,
-0.02751939,
-0.0123065924,
-0.0105515439,
-0.0017799393,
0.0253391471,
0.0153610809,
0.0276188292,
-0.0510602295,
0.0302650332,
0.0155365746,
0.0349100046,
0.0190023128,
0.0390160196,
0.0215389077,
0.0361975208,
0.0203193761,
0.1519587934,
0.0213897917,
0.0412845723,
0.0051937033,
-0.0359453112,
0.0068041305,
0.0179123748,
-0.0215128269,
-0.0418499671,
0.0279752277,
0.0232472736,
-0.0491637774,
-0.0057560699,
0.0587119907,
-0.0204254538,
0.0116550438,
-0.0238814354,
0.0134975938,
-0.0431133211,
0.029011488,
0.0111140525,
-0.0220820755,
0.0062691742,
-0.0119022774,
-0.0128644798,
0.0363771096,
0.0175299123,
-0.0213009603,
-0.0040701814,
0.0066497475,
-0.0143787768,
-0.0293183811,
0.0039417422,
-0.0010855783,
0.0597333796,
-0.0483925529,
-0.0333508477,
-0.0190362018,
0.0458437167,
-0.0215567183,
-0.0211933292,
-0.0479338765,
0.0066504735,
-0.0174932778,
0.0375371501,
-0.0263647269,
-0.0403658301,
0.0086509269,
0.0094997203,
-0.074421227,
0.0180918854,
0.0223853253,
0.0439568087,
0.0209585279,
-0.0156029388,
0.0047848793,
0.05820987,
-0.0562124476,
0.0171432961,
-0.0659143254,
0.0357066952,
0.0009857719,
0.0070482469,
0.0206427798,
-0.0081051132,
-0.0277980193,
0.080565609,
-0.0212481804,
0.0086672949,
-0.0313999541,
-0.0517126061,
-0.009960846,
-0.0129549252,
0.0359324627,
-0.0238208622,
0.037926171,
-0.0031712297,
0.0061963825,
-0.0125639448,
0.0184268113,
-0.0443237722,
-0.0396853425,
0.0623104237,
0.0118477764,
-0.0244762357,
-0.0424188301,
0.0213871878,
-0.0289884862,
0.0974951386,
0.0263186414,
-0.0548362955,
0.0398525968,
0.017198205,
-0.0346193574,
-0.0006684729,
0.0747213811,
0.0189855583,
0.0064520482,
-0.0145748965,
-0.0457336009,
0.060121011,
0.0681843683,
0.0099682976,
-0.0524014719,
-0.0462037325,
0.0172359608,
-0.0278687626,
0.0121318186,
0.0025729169,
0.0166612361,
0.0369284004,
-0.037176501,
-0.0145016573,
-0.034689039,
0.0321892761,
-0.0406235941,
0.0167213734,
0.0043448051,
0.0058020079,
-0.0306558125,
0.0480283238,
0.0252940282,
-0.0434432887,
0.0522624627,
-0.0155395269,
0.0576164126,
-0.0196312461,
-0.0339657255,
0.0294924751,
0.0513499677,
-0.0274199322,
0.0148640145,
0.0356976315,
0.00394782,
0.0074017243,
0.0134552643,
-0.0167635642,
-0.054659158,
-0.0243706927,
-0.0221240148,
0.0069833957,
0.0299891289,
-0.041728992,
0.0225032363,
-0.0550011396,
-0.0702939704,
-0.0068900418,
-0.0107562952,
0.0054947478,
-0.002702971,
0.041724287,
0.0559193492,
-0.1070436463,
0.0795186087,
0.0150025273,
-0.0239642616,
0.0579644404,
-0.0064633959,
0.0507662483,
0.0132602183,
0.0233050138,
0.0184288435,
-0.0174879842,
0.0440363958,
-0.0453408137,
-0.0439055264,
-0.0006959639,
-0.0450624377,
-0.0764987022,
0.0486651361,
-0.0584059879,
0.0297161806,
0.0311137438,
-0.0416740589,
-0.045205839,
0.0421196371,
0.007899004,
0.0437522084,
0.0024107154,
-0.0506733097,
0.0285515729,
-0.0071273255,
0.0016805911,
0.0479166396,
-0.043490123,
-0.0172237884,
0.0212852061,
-0.0259356778,
0.0319158025,
-0.0078463117,
-0.0758709162,
-0.0119878296,
0.0284941811,
0.0081629036,
-0.0109690828,
-0.0352742933,
-0.069283545,
0.0181123521,
-0.1361488998,
0.0083493702,
0.0277730096,
-0.0057157562,
0.0091392063,
-0.0149906501,
0.0267258566,
-0.0391436853,
-0.0430686213,
0.0383443981,
-0.0414736904,
0.0285795461,
0.0218585171,
0.0183274802,
0.0113289012,
0.0174803473,
0.0036569135,
-0.0289964806,
0.0545132346,
-0.0335546024,
0.0137499701,
-0.0062004137,
0.0196455754,
-0.0479321666,
-0.0010820128,
-0.0182124134,
0.0088398736,
-0.0092350198,
-0.0007677542,
0.0243160203,
0.0024409161,
-0.0314684026,
-0.001294252,
0.0170769263,
-0.0015490737,
-0.0373024642,
0.0075635724,
-0.0003321179,
0.0573662296,
-0.0308585297,
-0.0199422427,
-0.0408201367,
0.0210174061,
0.0022042522,
-0.0174674001,
-0.0662261248,
-0.0108440267,
-0.006344568,
-0.0223526135,
-0.0027694532,
0.0454034135,
0.0170765184,
-0.0219239462,
-0.0322772004,
0.0356685966,
0.0478739478,
0.0126207061,
-0.0037735496,
0.046768751,
0.0513746776,
0.0113338651,
0.0672202259,
-0.0188649595,
0.012825192,
0.0400637612,
0.0055487636,
-0.064015612,
-0.0162513815,
0.056287542,
-0.0059196288,
0.0136419563,
0.0209140312,
-0.0151161011,
-0.0358822234,
-0.0548410006,
-0.0058617555,
-0.0355049707,
-0.0018019202,
0.0400989465,
-0.01089969,
0.023839701,
-0.0234610084,
0.0013678523,
-0.0154290674,
-0.0406888425,
0.0045956103,
-0.009288257,
-0.0216905382,
0.0754897147,
0.0609162189,
0.0378418379,
0.0054745665,
0.0104799075,
-0.0205133036,
0.0412225127,
0.00906015,
-0.0028321212,
0.0070260358,
-0.0009315648,
-0.0073682005,
0.0015639385,
-0.0430069193,
-0.0040328228,
0.054782182,
0.0163178481,
0.0421474725,
0.0843729824,
0.0035507139,
-0.0260131098,
0.0182919409,
0.0161939207,
0.0204189327,
0.0252024252,
-0.0247427877,
-0.1007416397,
-0.0435687974,
-0.0134622296,
0.0117440866,
0.0195063241,
-0.0666759685,
0.0232723132,
-0.1158215478,
-0.0192290917,
0.0038089873,
0.0025988137,
-0.0323220231,
-0.0194101203,
0.0308832973,
-0.0392928198,
-0.0300691426,
-0.0320141874,
0.0060887742,
0.0010232066,
0.0006015779,
0.0120259235,
-0.0585262477,
0.0124357305,
-0.081276983,
0.0693815723,
-0.0598274246,
0.0414923094,
-0.0251020771,
-0.03660772,
-0.0282242037,
0.0004621632,
-0.0253699105,
0.0035828867,
0.0278156884,
-0.0163659472,
-0.0226637349,
-0.0457259081,
-0.0002522031,
-0.0414754972,
-0.0041458458,
-0.0304418523,
0.1320928186,
0.0152643975,
-0.0118365688,
-0.0339961089,
-0.0088293701,
0.0302842762,
0.0561803021,
-0.0025032032,
-0.0232517458,
0.0063247993,
0.0156958532,
0.0492092222,
-0.0021119192,
0.0211638622,
0.0062361858,
-0.0153519772,
0.0379654691,
-0.0643587485,
-0.0609219782,
0.0542312935,
0.0510196649,
0.0154847754,
0.0011518206,
0.0047155875,
-0.0128022991,
-0.0481135771,
-0.0002690688,
-0.0532610454,
0.0076593095,
0.0048946356,
-0.0057512172,
0.0390070006,
0.0000028068,
-0.0362650119,
-0.0185945891,
-0.0536963381,
-0.0459923744,
-0.0649519563,
0.0349403955,
-0.0068335962,
0.0538079478,
-0.0076343552,
-0.0264769308,
0.0629744381,
0.0313475095,
-0.0502788499,
0.006567461,
0.0418006666,
-0.0271289945,
0.0020152887,
0.0489509553,
-0.0605996512,
-0.0295237936,
0.019597495,
0.083450906,
-0.0456143431,
-0.0094884997,
-0.0243127309,
0.0112580545,
0.0101002976,
0.0021896658,
0.0245288536,
-0.0614217669,
-0.0168479793,
-0.0192814283,
-0.0132154478,
-0.038660109,
0.00969321,
0.0237839706,
-0.0199296735,
0.0011635427,
0.033012595,
0.0229568668,
0.042616874,
0.0035739716,
0.0047226399,
0.0789743364,
-0.0249643959,
-0.0011113583,
0.0097263586,
-0.0198410619,
0.0073018358,
0.014650655,
-0.0264642742,
-0.0600946099,
0.0464097634,
0.0038399242,
-0.0204818454,
-0.0642670989,
0.0316790566,
0.0061202417,
0.0536625795,
-0.0042350329,
0.0245070588,
0.0562130474,
0.0037181971,
0.0627613515,
0.0213082694,
-0.0245975051,
-0.0008263958,
0.0387706831,
-0.0632537827,
0.0006447998,
0.0615644716,
0.022691479,
0.0094381608,
0.0232841,
0.052199699,
-0.0081941998,
0.0551065914,
-0.0438039154,
-0.0333135128,
-0.0461756624,
-0.002549429,
0.0724697337,
0.0587004758,
-0.0003857691,
0.0357781574,
-0.0564940497,
-0.0597664602,
0.0496916249,
-0.0350313634,
-0.0850882679,
0.0339691527,
0.0334717445,
0.0092336265,
0.0126515543,
-0.0333535038,
-0.0242248811,
0.0162885264,
-0.0140188653,
-0.0156391989,
-0.0161437709,
-5.689482657e-33,
-0.04344422,
0.0008057776,
0.004306999,
-0.0446468778,
-0.0646579787,
0.0089207934,
0.0131713524,
0.0080590015,
-0.0221799798,
0.0405815318,
0.0145976907,
-0.0370616466,
-0.0172508322,
0.0193100739,
-0.005468939,
-0.0186917149,
0.0368694514,
0.0059531122,
0.0005586191,
0.0370156989,
0.0224438515,
0.0256883465,
0.0676173493,
-0.0940416902,
0.0145275779,
-0.0035541286,
0.01704273,
-0.0333497114,
0.0633068383,
0.0509073175,
-0.0243692175,
0.0428129286,
0.0337518714,
0.0025526567,
-0.0129841501,
-0.0533594638,
-0.0919970199,
-0.0380859599,
0.0077528525,
0.023948675,
-0.0328545906,
0.0134097412,
0.029754566,
-0.0087322304,
0.0720777288,
-0.0221567471,
0.0479975455,
0.0038728558,
-0.0565652214,
-0.0022500623,
-0.048892308,
0.0215954967,
0.0011827459,
-0.0131543064,
0.0149485599,
0.0105371261,
0.0570609905,
-0.0266933907,
-0.0563784949,
-0.0140970191,
-0.0116213281,
-0.0497080013,
0.0181662366,
0.0284494925,
0.0105742849,
0.0588983595,
-0.0052827476,
-0.0331071876,
-0.0148997949,
0.0082700178,
0.0304461233,
0.0383547172,
-0.0023244189,
0.1107935309,
-0.0165623073,
0.0072439271,
-0.0593070723,
-0.0054698582,
-0.0107133063,
0.0083873076,
-0.0027211066,
0.0138203874,
-0.0396609902,
-0.0191239063,
-0.0519671291,
-0.0656009763,
0.0008781209,
-0.0435584635,
0.0141013106,
0.0228328612,
-0.0397424661,
0.0833595097,
0.0394250378,
-0.0483778268,
-0.0399290435,
0.0571853444,
0.0066542146,
0.0383509584,
0.0071803876,
-0.0357313715,
-0.0407260433,
-0.0187559351,
0.0677253678,
-0.0433367081,
-0.0033182616,
-0.0131930076,
0.0679655224,
-0.0092864828,
-0.0581696741,
-0.0194529984,
-0.0178244933,
-0.0535563715,
0.0000638438,
0.0296483971,
0.0533673055,
0.0091881389,
-0.0223732106,
0.0085390992,
0.0688849464,
0.0152880326,
-0.0084798187,
-0.0108827623,
0.0316823982,
0.0050669331,
-0.0024039492,
-0.009573576,
-0.0348185487,
-0.0598370507,
0.0377337635,
-0.0699027032,
-0.0307095312,
-0.0136093181,
2.382e-7,
0.0273638535,
-0.0290905386,
0.0241413843,
-0.0132748419,
0.0199982002,
0.0750047117,
0.0007751758,
0.0450567268,
-0.0282912087,
-0.0004929549,
0.0369333029,
0.0136171253,
-0.0475365482,
0.0397529602,
-0.043873284,
0.0564863794,
-0.0038516417,
-0.022813743,
0.0089968406,
0.0022336494,
0.0751128346,
0.0630627126,
0.0601983853,
0.0086480351,
-0.0001096907,
-0.0602722913,
0.1018499732,
-0.0082376339,
0.0097076222,
-0.016464904,
0.0019060058,
0.0506761707,
-0.0163841024,
0.0514401346,
0.0194190163,
0.0161809791,
0.0348298922,
0.0337304622,
-0.0100788968,
-0.0229217038,
-0.0341662541,
-0.0193548333,
-0.0031821085,
0.0098902835,
0.0937516391,
-0.0486684442,
-0.0130281318,
-0.0537007488,
-0.044027973,
0.0237966012,
0.0201948527,
-0.0077890167,
-0.0157774556,
0.0044614091,
0.0148475105,
-0.0135803362,
-0.0113930386,
-0.0605677702,
0.0272425488,
-0.0010749783,
-0.0140607376,
-0.0259554647,
0.01049989,
-0.0230132453,
0.0539151169,
-0.0516550839,
0.0026754341,
1.70335227e-34,
0.0074330908,
0.0117673958,
-0.0081554987,
0.0107000461,
-0.0009517344,
-0.0426606499,
-0.0359640792,
-0.0744908005,
0.0224631559,
-0.0340056121,
0.0166144837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11567v1 | Differentiate ChatGPT-generated and Human-written Medical Texts | 2023-04-23T07:38:07 | 2023-04-23T07:38:07 | Wenxiong Liao, Zhengliang Liu, Haixing Dai, Shaochen Xu, Zihao Wu, Yiyang Zhang, Xiaoke Huang, Dajiang Zhu, Hongmin Cai, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Background: Large language models such as ChatGPT are capable of generating
grammatically perfect and human-like text content, and a large number of
ChatGPT-generated texts have appeared on the Internet. However, medical texts
such as clinical notes and diagnoses require rigorous validation, and erroneous
medical content generated by ChatGPT could potentially lead to disinformation
that poses significant harm to healthcare and the general public.
Objective: This research is among the first studies on responsible and
ethical AIGC (Artificial Intelligence Generated Content) in medicine. We focus
on analyzing the differences between medical texts written by human experts and
generated by ChatGPT, and designing machine learning workflows to effectively
detect and differentiate medical texts generated by ChatGPT.
Methods: We first construct a suite of datasets containing medical texts
written by human experts and generated by ChatGPT. In the next step, we analyze
the linguistic features of these two types of content and uncover differences
in vocabulary, part-of-speech, dependency, sentiment, perplexity, etc. Finally,
we design and implement machine learning methods to detect medical text
generated by ChatGPT.
Results: Medical texts written by humans are more concrete, more diverse, and
typically contain more useful information, while medical texts generated by
ChatGPT pay more attention to fluency and logic, and usually express general
terminologies rather than effective information specific to the context of the
problem. A BERT-based model can effectively detect medical texts generated by
ChatGPT, and the F1 exceeds 95%. | [
0.0851489678,
0.0413372926,
0.0009344285,
-0.0203333851,
-0.071226798,
0.0161312781,
0.0046140454,
0.0379441008,
0.0525934808,
-0.0406212322,
0.0264073834,
-0.0288453754,
-0.0067259772,
0.0301142652,
0.0048522479,
-0.0244467743,
0.013854038,
0.0613873191,
0.0597216822,
0.0199165754,
0.0116653871,
0.0278761443,
-0.0124712037,
0.0563493557,
-0.0272264145,
-0.0009083192,
0.0450246483,
-0.0039261268,
0.0280745495,
-0.0511125438,
0.0366177,
0.0235806089,
-0.0546681136,
0.01928824,
0.0000016309,
-0.0375940502,
0.0008464165,
0.0194777343,
-0.013012073,
-0.0377106294,
0.0693021119,
-0.0230218433,
-0.0172985438,
0.034703996,
-0.0524922013,
0.005064636,
0.0391382389,
0.0590990521,
0.0606888197,
0.0963792726,
-0.0434413888,
0.0207103752,
0.0434961468,
0.0274106767,
0.0366678722,
-0.0143145947,
0.0447017774,
0.014016577,
0.009511712,
-0.0001078173,
0.0408846699,
0.0331404097,
-0.0305071287,
0.0161714368,
-0.0006430597,
0.0225181151,
-0.0536054,
-0.0489460342,
0.0156856459,
0.0312534012,
-0.0001692213,
-0.0645538568,
0.0501985289,
0.0075229835,
-0.0000314897,
0.0054217484,
0.0002402239,
0.0239560213,
-0.0723629594,
0.0132280523,
0.0416859277,
-0.0040992759,
0.0086790016,
0.0328553319,
0.0059853396,
-0.0210457481,
0.0075415298,
-0.0309089869,
0.0032879109,
0.0004844278,
-0.0065046516,
-0.0559269115,
0.0602946207,
0.01976794,
-0.0382680632,
0.0173478983,
-0.0450352468,
-0.0667107031,
0.0814579651,
-0.103623271,
-0.0231728517,
-0.0107900826,
-0.0031327615,
0.0107486192,
0.0025072068,
-0.0133932326,
-0.0161134303,
0.0705748051,
-0.0270914175,
0.0395990014,
-0.0483552925,
-0.0282884464,
-0.0221657418,
0.0159862116,
0.015488294,
0.0097338576,
-0.0901016816,
-0.0029435286,
-0.0236804783,
0.0258080922,
0.0074821068,
0.0379640423,
-0.0321055613,
0.0204565711,
0.0122982236,
-0.0260216855,
-0.0105802901,
0.02398967,
-0.028906418,
-0.0314713717,
0.0421927311,
0.042927403,
0.0281331446,
0.0172294453,
0.0292288661,
0.068785347,
0.0110765658,
-0.0067292931,
-0.0045691887,
-0.0477240644,
-0.0374293216,
-0.020095896,
0.0139267286,
-0.0468653478,
0.0050279042,
0.0067445156,
-0.0272389073,
-0.0434407555,
0.0107319308,
0.0388041176,
-0.0451404341,
0.0423724689,
-0.0677730665,
0.0143038528,
0.0563531481,
0.0377451107,
-0.0082804998,
-0.0143192448,
0.0325735696,
-0.0123919751,
0.0272049271,
-0.0131155746,
0.0251155496,
-0.0066187787,
0.0246050395,
-0.0408896245,
0.0061820112,
0.0118853943,
-0.0070903776,
0.0609952323,
-0.0491223186,
0.1169045493,
0.0007033693,
-0.0130829755,
0.0181145184,
0.0728721023,
-0.0236094985,
0.0381345116,
0.0156665035,
0.0091376696,
0.0395515822,
0.0210746676,
0.014173694,
-0.0241348632,
0.0107755726,
-0.0287572332,
-0.034255106,
-0.0026255299,
0.0058890795,
-0.032217063,
-0.0635102466,
-0.0249503925,
0.0168723576,
-0.0556832775,
0.0177149307,
0.0053589661,
-0.0365867689,
0.0190640055,
0.0548048317,
-0.0478388555,
-0.0141010405,
-0.0689525679,
0.0002519765,
0.076116696,
0.0569667369,
-0.0388387032,
-0.0295476951,
-0.0364297889,
-0.0065903952,
0.0326257944,
-0.0003777506,
-0.0174144506,
-0.0316206031,
-0.0256828945,
0.0109011289,
0.0439537466,
0.0087600686,
-0.0367209874,
0.0248192213,
0.0359627195,
-0.0220916811,
0.0149036739,
-0.0557576641,
0.0467735417,
-0.0380921699,
0.0004035785,
0.0039706579,
-0.0192431323,
0.0537304282,
0.0122242998,
-0.023917459,
0.0342737027,
0.0101150628,
-0.015378667,
-0.0693991482,
0.0262487512,
-0.0136527829,
-0.015175797,
0.0036917417,
-0.0793566853,
-0.0125993276,
-0.0338387899,
-0.0320101529,
0.0156594813,
-0.0568140075,
-0.0784017742,
0.026837768,
-0.0235320833,
0.0131489011,
0.0224205274,
-0.0213382188,
-0.0260408781,
0.029235784,
-0.0198074915,
0.0019220283,
-0.0101231886,
-0.026751386,
0.0192493349,
-0.006864843,
0.022635825,
0.0017983828,
-0.0095456364,
0.0209215898,
0.0082032001,
0.0467391871,
-0.0047995374,
-0.0379392803,
-0.1195007563,
-0.0421563387,
-0.0022786504,
0.019520672,
0.0341974497,
-0.0123108486,
-0.0028741893,
-0.0052957083,
-0.0361894146,
-0.0276187845,
0.0389255285,
0.0163408443,
0.0486390181,
0.0027496151,
0.0326052196,
-0.0304205231,
0.0133766988,
-0.0570231527,
0.0147687821,
0.0682660788,
-0.0410871282,
-0.0102681434,
-0.0114770178,
-0.0440659039,
-0.0206740499,
0.009294414,
-0.0619491935,
0.0067367787,
0.0046813423,
-0.012008951,
0.0371122807,
0.0361372977,
0.0385761075,
-0.0032821146,
0.0389059447,
0.0133455284,
-0.0051759542,
-0.0316435918,
0.007405661,
0.0197802465,
-0.0695745572,
0.0335184932,
0.0468936041,
0.0432067961,
-0.0134332068,
-0.0436324365,
0.0170131493,
-0.0353326462,
0.0114024887,
-0.0106912497,
-0.042782966,
-0.0413640514,
0.0291319899,
0.0135549093,
-0.0407352038,
0.0981874987,
0.0039480072,
0.0434463173,
-0.1059027389,
-0.0096011339,
-0.0209688116,
-0.0157893375,
-0.0064961943,
0.0521297641,
0.017116297,
-0.0028948344,
0.0017590579,
0.0305348672,
0.0377074964,
-0.0432955809,
0.0143714612,
-0.0127434386,
0.0125499386,
0.0196090695,
-0.0483591259,
-0.0457038581,
-0.0357551388,
0.000913983,
-0.0318053849,
0.0531070195,
-0.0187138226,
-0.0210294053,
-0.0023467629,
-0.0260797758,
0.044921618,
0.0243575089,
-0.0033408725,
0.0022036606,
0.0072760074,
0.0062739407,
-0.0523311421,
-0.0019180386,
0.005634035,
-0.0111244293,
0.0874081925,
-0.0372083858,
0.0296772346,
0.0177538507,
-0.0166797861,
-0.0218375083,
-0.0182705168,
-0.0039146654,
0.0099385791,
-0.001779267,
-0.0261032414,
-0.000882978,
0.0918031037,
0.0396647453,
-0.0443844758,
0.0294480827,
-0.0104758907,
-0.041097872,
-0.0531524085,
0.0033488024,
-0.0678292662,
0.0013926752,
-0.0057839854,
0.002772494,
-0.0692504048,
-0.0089286277,
0.0215573832,
-0.0101968972,
0.026357688,
0.0101637235,
-0.0017356363,
-0.0110635925,
-0.0457708165,
-0.0286345687,
0.0028785828,
-0.0163394734,
-0.0412073135,
-0.0164521672,
-0.0091005238,
0.0035910967,
-0.1000529975,
-0.0724800006,
-0.0070691351,
-0.0083147613,
0.0499068387,
0.0689479485,
0.0778673664,
-0.0371684842,
-0.0153455622,
0.0187023561,
0.0413197167,
-0.0118939904,
-0.0119171888,
0.0896872059,
0.0018386536,
-0.0049475227,
-0.0774289295,
0.0572410077,
-0.0184114762,
-0.012181038,
-0.0029517359,
0.0568502434,
-0.0494363084,
-0.0475751087,
-0.0504676364,
0.0493017249,
0.0582284927,
0.0585979111,
-0.0077773617,
-0.0214184672,
-0.0420752577,
-0.0044881073,
0.0619408116,
-0.0102982102,
-0.0067782523,
0.014133458,
-0.030459201,
-0.0575470589,
-0.102521129,
-0.0121203866,
-0.0078952666,
-0.0340512842,
0.0260374155,
-0.0105229989,
0.0346543118,
0.007739679,
-0.0545081161,
0.0049064788,
0.0558190532,
-0.0043388605,
-0.0477538034,
-0.0621739775,
0.0396439359,
-0.0079656523,
-0.0104972189,
0.0028939925,
-0.0055607134,
-0.0238620602,
0.0209982637,
0.0243159216,
0.0149344625,
0.0022266081,
-0.0041891956,
-0.0033960228,
0.0228709187,
0.0786949173,
-0.0471141189,
-0.0406831652,
0.0084593557,
0.0052428255,
-0.0047899047,
-0.0050539011,
0.0037021833,
0.0185067561,
0.0135022923,
-0.0089171119,
-0.0362869799,
-0.0024316714,
0.0343706347,
0.0445120707,
0.0120418435,
-0.032049831,
0.0007866313,
-0.0236175954,
-0.0148191657,
-0.0149693862,
0.0082595758,
-0.0158274267,
-0.0098653249,
0.0213210639,
0.0068106349,
-0.0314684473,
0.012472027,
-0.0842530876,
-0.0351958498,
-0.01134637,
0.0479660966,
-0.0050637512,
0.0445117131,
0.0374898016,
-0.0285048019,
-0.0076796426,
0.0146415392,
0.0006754406,
-0.0002859644,
-0.0128719024,
0.0354315937,
0.0183382425,
0.0192077719,
0.0215630736,
0.0428237431,
-0.0318892375,
-0.0014368321,
-0.0426509865,
0.0494497269,
0.0306173563,
0.0159847289,
0.0353844762,
-0.0583168045,
-0.0190832242,
-0.0215710476,
0.0485488698,
-0.0405048616,
0.0091388803,
-0.0022878596,
-0.0238400456,
-0.0223079678,
-0.0374635011,
0.0873811468,
0.0126636447,
0.0487633608,
0.0108127603,
-0.0831774399,
-0.0403917208,
-0.0296523217,
0.0230659992,
-0.032921847,
-0.0312104318,
0.0277700368,
-0.0532801412,
-0.0335864872,
0.0262474436,
-0.0094921505,
0.017791111,
-0.0104955453,
0.0470039397,
0.0563153848,
0.0128216045,
0.0026432632,
-0.0331636518,
0.0550675094,
-0.021804262,
-0.0172462277,
0.0109721525,
-5.105321106e-33,
0.0260095447,
-0.069451347,
-0.004311197,
0.0216378551,
0.0103074759,
0.0172656905,
-0.0296849031,
-0.0031694474,
0.0107861049,
0.075623855,
-0.0223149341,
0.012192185,
0.000646718,
0.0276162997,
0.0006510214,
-0.0364409015,
0.0241628718,
-0.0093097696,
-0.0079205753,
0.0450839251,
-0.0036206678,
0.0480039194,
0.0467297658,
-0.1100631058,
0.0231207646,
-0.0166750848,
-0.0003868215,
-0.010682432,
-0.025938794,
0.0540106036,
-0.0242153518,
0.0274804477,
0.0540227741,
0.0483223051,
0.0010494456,
0.0382713266,
-0.025285162,
-0.0247938391,
0.000568705,
-0.0161444247,
-0.0606273673,
-0.0478742458,
0.0522143096,
-0.0301424563,
-0.0462650917,
0.0271011777,
0.0463636108,
-0.0158881824,
0.0188033544,
-0.036178112,
-0.0499308445,
0.0396905392,
-0.0003320179,
0.0040721227,
-0.0272301044,
0.0101478966,
-0.0440434627,
0.0264601577,
-0.0085253539,
-0.0109239891,
0.0144710122,
-0.0056561972,
-0.0304687507,
-0.0685456842,
-0.0042840638,
0.0558391847,
0.028000284,
-0.0003006971,
-0.059907414,
0.022447845,
-0.0666091889,
0.0399785042,
0.0709807277,
0.0457926281,
0.0070215869,
-0.0692157075,
-0.0872917101,
0.0273857955,
-0.0307893697,
0.0274822973,
0.0104829902,
-0.0529700592,
-0.0759768486,
-0.0119406404,
0.0346932188,
-0.0177956503,
0.0139867868,
-0.0207889918,
0.0095214928,
-0.0156602617,
0.006799893,
-0.0049300082,
-0.0275478028,
-0.0293746479,
0.0365502015,
-0.0180010609,
0.0171841029,
-0.0032217444,
-0.0281586889,
0.008514124,
-0.0447921082,
-0.0189802758,
0.0145300543,
0.0024064449,
0.0702778623,
0.0072742677,
0.0522675663,
-0.0219728369,
-0.0308329072,
0.006132409,
0.0242891088,
0.0215018373,
-0.0005788147,
0.0295307692,
0.0141539564,
0.0135605186,
0.0160246063,
0.023246292,
0.0125483042,
0.0285014883,
-0.0527380854,
-0.0528911762,
-0.0110767558,
-0.0162846092,
-0.0411561392,
-0.0063935737,
-0.0446672179,
0.050091669,
0.0179736707,
-0.0757692531,
0.0107560121,
-0.0277914274,
2.458e-7,
0.0911825448,
0.0786351934,
0.0327581242,
-0.0239032228,
0.0365833193,
0.0191708598,
0.0158485956,
0.0197846908,
-0.0160950739,
0.0021261198,
0.0364432596,
-0.0103206672,
0.0273543019,
0.0321254469,
-0.0510571674,
-0.0060607116,
-0.1198387519,
-0.0371670648,
-0.0139506385,
0.0049570333,
0.0849498585,
0.0295911711,
-0.0284473374,
-0.0517997667,
0.0057015163,
-0.010310228,
0.028269222,
-0.0185076892,
0.0058510471,
0.0650113896,
0.0440589786,
-0.0062130243,
0.0417665951,
0.043580424,
-0.0240240879,
-0.0608636066,
0.017775001,
0.0911500379,
-0.0403007716,
0.0420987569,
0.0159220193,
-0.0138762007,
0.0327859372,
-0.0459405743,
0.0443714075,
-0.0279696099,
-0.0450238995,
-0.0458397642,
0.0057105282,
-0.0509443954,
0.0688087642,
-0.0278157704,
-0.0458944999,
0.0420096666,
0.0178523138,
0.0340526402,
-0.0079356423,
-0.065495111,
-0.0150225861,
0.002321494,
-0.0341058858,
-0.0127487965,
0.0414260402,
0.0272212122,
0.0230446383,
-0.0668197796,
0.0392613262,
2.210397741e-34,
0.025362147,
-0.0089465417,
-0.0054422789,
0.0029800695,
0.0203824472,
0.0249355342,
0.0277994704,
0.0149345286,
-0.0030618547,
-0.0063687777,
0.0185187235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11556v1 | Divide and Prompt: Chain of Thought Prompting for Text-to-SQL | 2023-04-23T06:52:35 | 2023-04-23T06:52:35 | Xiping Liu, Zhao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting combined with large language models (LLMs)
have achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks. Text-to-SQL is a
critical semantic parsing task that converts natural language questions into
SQL statements, involving a complex reasoning process. However, there is little
work about using CoT prompting to activate LLM's reasoning capabilities on
Text-to-SQL tasks. In this work, we propose a new paradigm for prompting
Text-to-SQL tasks, called Divide-and-Prompt, which first divides the task into
subtasks, and then approach each subtask through CoT. We present 3
prompting-based methods to enhance the Text-to-SQL ability of LLMs. Experiments
show that these prompts guide LLMs to generate Text-to-SQL with higher
execution accuracy. | [
0.0293893013,
0.0376919247,
-0.0050971205,
0.0192094371,
-0.0455712415,
0.0270679779,
0.0158745628,
-0.0051417467,
0.030337885,
-0.0640422329,
0.0165093411,
-0.0122166267,
-0.0337006524,
0.0184050109,
0.0298819374,
-0.0669623911,
0.0327418149,
-0.0484723523,
0.0017074465,
0.0315582529,
-0.0084853955,
0.0234047845,
-0.0074269269,
-0.0157415532,
-0.0228125118,
-0.0422244221,
-0.032981772,
0.0160554536,
-0.0263720527,
-0.051791992,
-0.043335963,
0.0469472632,
0.0180828907,
0.0052472162,
0.0000020358,
-0.0853222832,
-0.0511476621,
0.0255571119,
-0.0636556447,
0.0028981485,
0.0141524607,
0.0014389153,
0.0216783453,
0.0589129291,
-0.0492614247,
0.0330732912,
0.0082222549,
0.045391228,
0.0657638162,
0.0693902746,
-0.0119744316,
-0.0303170308,
-0.0083822049,
-0.0018820607,
0.0498638302,
-0.0541287474,
0.0045829033,
0.0410480089,
0.042651616,
0.0355347283,
0.0193170812,
0.0132354675,
0.0188073814,
-0.0276759081,
-0.0104427282,
0.0029379348,
-0.0045345747,
0.0027448654,
-0.0256852303,
0.0288451556,
0.021582827,
-0.0045360778,
0.0062419069,
0.0154396519,
0.017518172,
-0.007517342,
-0.0255554225,
0.0539906658,
-0.0146871526,
0.0043604868,
0.0127716614,
-0.0000212488,
-0.0102491099,
0.0055397223,
-0.0737494528,
0.0524643026,
-0.0161597058,
-0.0466224067,
0.0547093116,
-0.0010976274,
0.0056822305,
-0.0513577014,
0.0439315923,
0.0801274031,
-0.0969586596,
0.0112613793,
-0.0299560316,
-0.0089856228,
0.001410982,
-0.0209029876,
0.0162407923,
0.0609848313,
-0.0091552921,
0.0637317374,
-0.0352017321,
0.0051441398,
0.010666254,
0.0249040276,
-0.051159624,
-0.0289109964,
-0.0789762661,
-0.0146105504,
-0.0550702848,
0.0334859826,
-0.0883020759,
-0.0312417783,
-0.0059399321,
0.0367302969,
-0.0020204373,
0.0410633534,
0.0386354066,
0.014375967,
0.0107791815,
-0.0242545977,
-0.0725389048,
0.0027132242,
-0.0206234176,
0.0143301478,
0.0233376361,
-0.0380121432,
-0.0159017835,
-0.0017135355,
0.0045318799,
-0.0233004354,
0.021769749,
0.0511603802,
-0.0466593206,
0.022688929,
-0.1170381978,
-0.072690703,
-0.0064294538,
-0.0254473556,
-0.0123896105,
-0.0602833144,
0.0401392318,
0.0187086053,
-0.0256329589,
-0.0026478488,
0.0109471511,
0.0390084833,
-0.0084477896,
0.0667742714,
-0.0178425498,
0.0184622873,
0.0368570201,
-0.0115315402,
-0.0232591517,
0.0639630333,
0.0135025689,
0.0365896486,
-0.0076812878,
0.0218262617,
-0.0201738849,
0.027710963,
-0.0053527565,
-0.0074353782,
-0.0599182397,
0.0482892506,
-0.0153209846,
0.0430415384,
0.0036016405,
0.0777741894,
0.0008378644,
0.0678682178,
0.0295573566,
0.0498210862,
0.0158925764,
0.0210835747,
0.0560691021,
0.015608009,
-0.0180819798,
-0.0076151132,
-0.0581170581,
0.0359499976,
-0.0207215305,
0.0120238205,
0.0331101641,
0.0082782879,
-0.0242199395,
-0.0540049821,
0.0079688625,
0.0210656859,
-0.0076984982,
0.030878013,
0.0099757323,
0.0255369004,
-0.0137862451,
0.0336907282,
-0.0232189912,
-0.0169344656,
0.0087688221,
-0.0383913629,
-0.0004342757,
0.0801442116,
0.0031065966,
-0.0394372158,
0.0000569141,
-0.0292930882,
0.0467497446,
0.0165249538,
0.007284163,
-0.0201435201,
-0.0598916039,
-0.0118488278,
-0.0098496098,
0.0232930928,
0.0126023451,
-0.0427891389,
0.0181424748,
-0.0051530818,
0.0236167964,
0.010780924,
-0.0085632149,
0.0287874583,
0.0050446619,
-0.0216122754,
0.0015075655,
0.0152853681,
-0.0138890082,
0.0295488629,
-0.0030640783,
0.0561002605,
0.0114739221,
-0.0199990496,
-0.0454724617,
-0.0412641913,
-0.0155836083,
-0.0597966462,
0.0212612804,
0.0143900225,
-0.0273857005,
-0.06329339,
-0.0494019873,
-0.0343556628,
-0.0147364503,
-0.0237518158,
0.007133197,
-0.0291018672,
0.020218594,
0.0119920122,
-0.0663162619,
-0.0508306548,
0.0728583112,
0.0067006652,
-0.0019847555,
0.021995198,
-0.0355219804,
-0.0103266491,
-0.0531369187,
0.0572756939,
-0.011755337,
-0.0046246792,
0.0079986835,
-0.0295848791,
0.0413817763,
-0.0586053096,
-0.0309379064,
-0.0833084062,
0.0177781899,
-0.0283585936,
0.0393864773,
0.0199266002,
0.0200078301,
-0.0018651558,
-0.0011095874,
-0.0697876811,
-0.0275920648,
0.0072001936,
0.0205278136,
0.0527312532,
-0.0030897739,
0.0037481724,
0.0167500786,
-0.0117841288,
-0.0583526306,
0.0439638123,
-0.0123046208,
-0.0258068554,
-0.0548402146,
0.0507171936,
0.0069672493,
0.0200178865,
0.0308120064,
0.0349633396,
0.0204071719,
-0.0402292944,
0.0511072129,
0.0789596811,
0.0036104794,
-0.0359645784,
0.0168130267,
-0.0110015022,
-0.0288953893,
0.0268136021,
0.0103772338,
0.0129922898,
0.0142477462,
-0.0375088789,
0.0198319796,
0.0278559159,
0.0010707865,
-0.0146621233,
-0.0140603967,
0.0131681329,
0.010241867,
0.007168618,
-0.0469772257,
-0.0253631435,
0.0046075685,
0.0615939908,
-0.0048281937,
0.0191025659,
0.0645080879,
-0.028890837,
-0.0168334451,
-0.0485885777,
-0.0004516082,
-0.0767354816,
0.080279626,
-0.0070939008,
0.0166734364,
-0.0200926773,
-0.0569480844,
-0.0442257784,
-0.0458607562,
-0.0104326988,
-0.0127742514,
0.1008778438,
-0.0505532362,
-0.0132443588,
-0.0155863902,
-0.0179669876,
-0.0357361436,
0.005339758,
-0.0711391047,
0.0285770055,
0.0483715534,
0.0111076916,
0.0257017594,
-0.0344700217,
0.02256619,
0.0255079884,
-0.0127801066,
-0.0403944366,
-0.0084882183,
-0.0059115347,
0.011451792,
0.0311957635,
0.0209479108,
-0.0269889776,
0.0684345663,
0.041193448,
0.0232490953,
-0.0361269601,
-0.0218142178,
0.0218758509,
-0.0186339356,
-0.0061467527,
0.0003133633,
0.0373892859,
0.0006809596,
-0.0688980967,
-0.008185925,
0.1057399437,
0.0434232876,
0.0038105231,
-0.0083022155,
-0.0378176942,
0.0241303053,
0.0364710316,
0.0527773201,
-0.1029631197,
-0.0548240468,
-0.0085809389,
-0.0098769888,
0.0213692542,
-0.0492937416,
-0.0148657057,
-0.1264681816,
0.0438626744,
-0.0250485595,
0.010905602,
0.0195199475,
-0.0084232865,
-0.0286426023,
0.0123971337,
-0.0146437325,
0.0709826723,
-0.0184386056,
-0.0141280377,
0.015367737,
0.0039928905,
0.0018801101,
0.0194879789,
-0.046219483,
-0.0041016559,
0.0431611389,
-0.0007052848,
0.0125333145,
-0.0366956443,
0.0348116048,
-0.0055114203,
0.0082380623,
-0.0242787506,
0.0405713953,
0.0070945765,
0.0235967468,
-0.0076545365,
0.0304984078,
-0.0208604783,
0.0141492262,
0.0473926365,
0.1243271977,
-0.0454930775,
0.0023318045,
-0.0052887849,
-0.0045546028,
0.0036954875,
0.0690883026,
0.0101690684,
-0.0289964639,
-0.0519587435,
-0.025403399,
-0.0630800352,
-0.0475313552,
-0.0038583244,
0.0504564494,
-0.0205329638,
-0.0132054882,
-0.0452023633,
-0.0047686971,
0.0908900127,
0.0656787828,
0.0189714301,
0.0226488542,
0.0417452194,
0.0019885378,
-0.0100994781,
-0.0116674826,
-0.0346544199,
0.0282644611,
-0.0334118567,
0.0360512696,
0.0050272411,
-0.0466061011,
-0.0083961263,
-0.0346514955,
-0.0748042092,
-0.021864228,
-0.0362637118,
-0.0024375608,
0.0275428053,
-0.0077140741,
-0.0066873333,
-0.0568275154,
-0.0047918512,
0.0418928862,
-0.0544497184,
-0.039449282,
-0.0095979944,
0.0615467094,
0.0047261496,
0.0328233391,
-0.038479656,
-0.0036749709,
-0.0345932655,
0.0203319527,
-0.0260718353,
0.0086950893,
0.048642233,
0.0516380928,
-0.0010056441,
0.0262365788,
0.0073677688,
-0.0133070871,
0.0368394591,
-0.0527771451,
-0.0797472075,
-0.042268496,
0.0446771644,
0.019449953,
0.0101782642,
0.0316944532,
-0.0534532629,
0.0063519487,
0.0113313058,
0.0034945409,
-0.0036166869,
0.0242108908,
0.0266044606,
0.0462854095,
-0.0281864926,
-0.0014460848,
0.0139282448,
0.0124600856,
0.0467189699,
-0.0151602663,
0.0738433003,
0.0480398163,
0.0032350167,
-0.0756875426,
-0.0091135548,
-0.0526534617,
-0.0774450004,
0.0363285691,
0.0125990864,
0.0160998013,
0.0051828157,
0.0022432718,
-0.0248070601,
-0.0187938847,
0.014886572,
0.0240074676,
0.039253816,
-0.0258803088,
0.0290493313,
0.0175670311,
-0.0173840374,
-0.0711393356,
0.0141749689,
-0.0335474908,
-0.022198176,
0.0209264401,
-0.0723926499,
-0.028518131,
-0.0475061685,
-0.0233067162,
-0.0252107177,
-0.0161361601,
-0.0003532748,
-0.0621420778,
-0.023772506,
0.0089269988,
0.0234204587,
-0.0120927896,
-0.0127539067,
0.0653705522,
0.0816306993,
0.0400793478,
-0.0385320224,
-0.0272726864,
0.0276748184,
-0.0089723067,
-0.0762993917,
-0.0233742874,
-5.973612131e-33,
-0.0143678701,
-0.0442303978,
0.0780973732,
0.0175399296,
-0.0055094589,
-0.0359003842,
-0.0328324549,
0.0112547623,
-0.0143039562,
0.0351521336,
-0.0559239313,
0.0217424184,
0.0252936445,
0.0278035942,
0.0415423028,
-0.0403069444,
0.0287425797,
-0.0234218333,
0.0082994411,
0.0019571164,
0.0428141877,
0.0121493815,
-0.0234752186,
-0.0033641199,
0.0338449553,
0.0319754668,
0.0014928863,
0.0594504029,
-0.0156448502,
0.0142080989,
-0.0063224719,
0.0068345978,
0.0300972462,
-0.0130429892,
-0.0115835471,
0.0418317169,
-0.0624894463,
-0.0280221142,
0.0262349527,
-0.0217083246,
-0.0565794222,
-0.0240633674,
0.0288928654,
-0.0179742184,
-0.0047050645,
-0.0155062014,
0.0006683889,
-0.0309442673,
0.0091714701,
-0.0394688733,
-0.0452449396,
0.0032418519,
0.013359502,
-0.013502107,
0.0391239449,
0.0408041328,
-0.014965605,
0.0218695961,
-0.0138798552,
0.0197157823,
0.0282689594,
0.0436160304,
0.0342560895,
0.0338765755,
-0.0331393778,
0.0053244238,
-0.0229880866,
-0.0004572373,
-0.0573709942,
0.0708403736,
-0.0287582111,
0.0771704093,
0.0428377874,
0.0085124206,
0.0089688096,
0.0158120636,
-0.085073255,
0.0157568771,
-0.0331781022,
0.0134671293,
0.0235456545,
0.0000453798,
-0.0398233272,
-0.0496896803,
-0.027647173,
0.0440905653,
-0.0527547561,
-0.0079669189,
0.0337226242,
-0.0116210924,
-0.0009240047,
-0.0140919713,
0.0315910988,
0.0125944167,
-0.0207706094,
0.0103544798,
-0.0114348587,
-0.0051234215,
-0.0136708822,
0.0202178117,
-0.0404974818,
-0.0117224194,
0.0196798928,
0.0111684389,
0.0070421472,
0.0419727378,
0.032369148,
-0.0049024974,
-0.0758398622,
0.015546524,
-0.052694682,
0.0705393776,
-0.0348596387,
0.0239507947,
0.0020135436,
0.001389158,
0.0110824164,
0.0497576073,
-0.0160657018,
-0.0670408309,
-0.0332474895,
0.0160109941,
0.0009228205,
0.0125219189,
-0.0062759337,
0.0180393513,
-0.0191493556,
-0.0107694631,
0.0259928927,
-0.0499965288,
-0.0015443411,
0.0438986346,
2.708e-7,
0.0599093698,
0.0448585115,
0.0175475888,
0.0616705157,
-0.0047261957,
0.0351877026,
0.0126229394,
-0.0013239369,
0.0331374817,
-0.0432351567,
-0.0013429419,
0.0281872805,
0.0276756957,
0.0489015058,
-0.0847630724,
-0.0354933143,
-0.0217775442,
-0.0063137827,
-0.0582771078,
0.004549419,
0.1232410669,
0.0514597446,
-0.0175451972,
-0.0045719016,
0.0211590305,
-0.0509712212,
-0.0023377461,
0.0069990689,
0.0003458014,
0.0370434336,
0.0004383273,
-0.0498137213,
-0.0000845011,
0.0609888509,
0.0055542728,
-0.0019816596,
-0.0185350869,
0.0601800941,
0.0293214247,
0.0447564572,
-0.0126729328,
-0.0577660911,
0.0205121599,
-0.0348641463,
0.0710844621,
-0.0534039438,
0.0084420796,
0.0534131825,
0.0220069662,
-0.0489379205,
-0.0205790512,
-0.0103876404,
0.0324447677,
-0.0276653748,
0.0324830748,
0.0074948492,
0.0146459928,
-0.0471559241,
-0.0289103631,
0.05099722,
-0.0357318707,
-0.0326968022,
-0.013762909,
0.0497003198,
-0.016464673,
-0.0468727052,
-0.0288125128,
2.876889721e-34,
0.0273294318,
0.0043990379,
0.0475300215,
0.0279092509,
0.0790514052,
0.0292487517,
-0.0453576595,
0.0079099014,
0.015181018,
-0.0972302333,
-0.0269785542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11534v2 | Graph Neural Networks for Text Classification: A Survey | 2023-04-23T04:21:50 | 2023-04-27T13:42:25 | Kunze Wang, Yihao Ding, Soyeon Caren Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text Classification is the most essential and fundamental problem in Natural
Language Processing. While numerous recent text classification models applied
the sequential deep learning technique, graph neural network-based models can
directly deal with complex structured text data and exploit global information.
Many real text classification applications can be naturally cast into a graph,
which captures words, documents, and corpus global features. In this survey, we
bring the coverage of methods up to 2023, including corpus-level and
document-level graph neural networks. We discuss each of these methods in
detail, dealing with the graph construction mechanisms and the graph-based
learning process. As well as the technological survey, we look at issues behind
and future directions addressed in text classification using graph neural
networks. We also cover datasets, evaluation metrics, and experiment design and
present a summary of published performance on the publicly available
benchmarks. Note that we present a comprehensive comparison between different
techniques and identify the pros and cons of various evaluation metrics in this
survey. | [
0.0266686678,
0.0161328036,
0.0098321,
0.0294679124,
-0.0499842949,
0.0020771285,
0.0121296151,
0.0065346155,
0.1102708206,
-0.0452303775,
0.0097172018,
-0.0334043391,
0.0153028788,
0.0534229986,
0.0119896773,
-0.0086119613,
0.0239964798,
0.0221077222,
0.0141137354,
-0.0062638666,
-0.0196866933,
0.0396763571,
0.0309937336,
0.0115451235,
-0.0019614198,
-0.0108878994,
-0.0050921696,
0.025885975,
-0.0368554145,
-0.0660437495,
0.0156442225,
0.0145141967,
0.0126475003,
0.0391725823,
0.0000016966,
-0.0143768648,
0.0031401799,
-0.0148967756,
-0.0234655868,
-0.0152414273,
0.0433497466,
-0.0097434241,
0.0499076433,
0.0048998916,
-0.0411073975,
-0.0764946043,
0.0337484889,
0.0141443526,
0.0169623811,
0.096257709,
-0.0280974731,
-0.0416865163,
0.0353728682,
-0.0332763605,
-0.0192333572,
-0.0382186361,
0.0421318077,
-0.0038788179,
0.0314682759,
-0.0030636583,
-0.0415653437,
0.0056490353,
0.0177492499,
-0.0134332292,
0.0668445528,
0.006835585,
-0.0001664552,
0.0177316498,
0.0069268392,
0.0979468748,
-0.0148455333,
-0.038593106,
0.0057717049,
-0.0376235731,
0.0039475793,
-0.002887489,
0.0012674337,
-0.0292779487,
-0.0109202014,
0.0281511676,
-0.0210522227,
-0.0089693423,
0.0779343396,
-0.0077690003,
-0.0073404289,
0.0729526356,
-0.0334188603,
0.0030508537,
0.047136113,
0.0082887299,
-0.0030095153,
-0.0285635646,
0.0288920254,
0.0146554662,
0.0011853839,
-0.0222220421,
-0.0143854218,
-0.0388091318,
0.0012890615,
-0.0538668931,
0.0086538382,
-0.04072579,
0.0315459445,
0.0301919058,
-0.0120853074,
0.0328041539,
-0.0097693866,
0.0687624812,
-0.0385725647,
0.0206516199,
-0.0604973659,
0.0125969257,
-0.0173125528,
0.0392915122,
0.0286031365,
-0.0641572401,
-0.0634634942,
0.0181582812,
-0.0047564576,
0.0099504991,
0.0038314217,
0.0682594404,
0.0258171782,
0.0075952504,
0.0184584893,
0.0057526664,
0.0173543859,
0.0309819672,
-0.0407588631,
0.0427239165,
0.0201477613,
0.0351856984,
0.0771867707,
0.0067456756,
0.0337019861,
0.0458147079,
0.0256263986,
-0.0564817004,
-0.0058315564,
-0.0062746746,
-0.012141021,
-0.0461955257,
0.0292523578,
-0.0660220012,
0.0313422121,
0.0278553218,
-0.0265327897,
-0.031816829,
0.0181476269,
-0.0088966908,
-0.0270116273,
0.0573659576,
-0.0194841363,
-0.0180448592,
0.033285588,
-0.023989033,
0.007745747,
-0.0031617277,
0.0276404712,
0.0519055873,
0.0384914279,
0.0166018903,
-0.0287422836,
-0.0048962007,
0.032618992,
-0.0284362994,
0.0137876831,
-0.018190071,
-0.0497031994,
0.0145958113,
-0.0227803923,
0.0263323486,
-0.0278920885,
-0.0286684949,
0.0353668556,
0.0690719858,
0.0058495714,
0.0227969419,
0.0160035733,
0.040596921,
-0.0126618911,
-0.0084591126,
-0.020662386,
-0.0479701161,
0.0047642188,
0.0033266894,
-0.019329587,
-0.0669714212,
-0.030640902,
-0.0069928132,
0.0010346514,
-0.0539225787,
0.1234284416,
-0.0057424475,
0.0707681626,
-0.0136112664,
-0.0183627401,
-0.0142479446,
0.0100334166,
-0.0150080211,
-0.0035866364,
-0.0016021907,
-0.0194574576,
0.0325250477,
0.0243182778,
-0.0215411671,
-0.0278317705,
0.0058080638,
0.0112802638,
-0.0216958504,
0.0558835864,
-0.0190467685,
-0.0034607942,
-0.0393497981,
-0.0492837317,
-0.0344488211,
-0.0197686255,
0.0194338094,
-0.0293075852,
0.0162813831,
0.0188480932,
-0.0672305375,
-0.0484124422,
0.0238944944,
0.046242401,
0.0003105494,
0.0605233796,
0.0112988157,
0.0161345359,
0.0280199349,
0.0018049037,
0.0062319096,
0.0298162624,
-0.0098709371,
-0.0306603424,
-0.0432167649,
-0.0404333882,
-0.0445015281,
0.0245012846,
-0.0153260054,
-0.0072806324,
0.0474729314,
-0.0396512151,
-0.042441681,
0.045182161,
-0.0767223015,
0.0262796357,
0.0004692494,
0.0019711,
-0.0244297814,
0.0160408411,
-0.0131489234,
0.0379407592,
0.0085238516,
0.0251415726,
-0.0383552201,
0.0122479051,
0.0414323695,
-0.0437220596,
-0.0278302673,
0.0398814902,
-0.0038911523,
0.0091800829,
0.0349325798,
0.0148588112,
-0.0259858593,
0.0234124511,
-0.0823178142,
0.0121170543,
-0.0039686025,
0.0327518135,
-0.032882981,
0.0002034262,
0.0297359545,
-0.0421507321,
-0.0687734112,
0.0478381068,
0.0112034502,
-0.0140767246,
0.0338517427,
-0.0228684936,
-0.001482448,
0.0010224461,
-0.0818580389,
-0.0240133666,
0.1057984456,
0.0370852128,
-0.0650056452,
-0.0044352496,
0.0142271295,
-0.0157961454,
0.0298428293,
0.0049454281,
0.0052447207,
-0.0236727353,
-0.0027862277,
-0.0366824865,
0.0448494889,
-0.0211238302,
0.0314222798,
0.012878594,
0.0353612565,
-0.0175562575,
-0.0167618096,
-0.0650806502,
0.0591228083,
-0.0354095325,
0.002119774,
-0.040393848,
0.0086151436,
0.0257034525,
-0.015070281,
-0.0171258207,
-0.0116541022,
-0.0048899916,
0.0261655953,
-0.0210700184,
-0.0472123474,
0.0194866713,
-0.0587025136,
-0.0322484225,
-0.0321818404,
0.041707851,
0.0091295568,
0.0181813259,
-0.0084000686,
-0.0417710356,
-0.0575893223,
0.0672500804,
0.0760533139,
0.0107513182,
-0.0125761796,
-0.0382063463,
0.003050111,
-0.0153405434,
0.0174602363,
-0.0228195824,
-0.0057749436,
0.0269791614,
0.0504177138,
-0.0288840253,
-0.020241471,
0.0085315695,
-0.0197127648,
-0.0239959173,
0.0327148661,
0.0212608147,
-0.0184249729,
0.0167466849,
0.0054878639,
-0.0324095525,
0.0516749658,
-0.0304977745,
0.0124307172,
-0.0279132612,
0.0581041165,
0.0001294849,
-0.0184627809,
-0.0240625888,
-0.0211776551,
-0.0071000946,
0.0339077376,
0.039175719,
0.0119743384,
-0.0593952276,
-0.0028040106,
-0.0076659955,
-0.0192593466,
-0.0409356691,
-0.0277868919,
0.0092342002,
-0.0593632869,
0.0096004037,
0.0481742993,
0.0138758793,
-0.1010425836,
-0.0271958001,
0.0702401325,
-0.0076785805,
0.0045177401,
-0.0013500103,
-0.0782889053,
-0.024379218,
-0.0267503131,
0.0068287901,
0.0288117938,
-0.0290994551,
-0.0007807157,
-0.0571491048,
-0.0178811941,
0.0349529944,
-0.0060912208,
-0.0253313705,
-0.0633547008,
-0.0134687843,
0.0225083791,
-0.0359032601,
-0.0649852604,
-0.0011066946,
-0.0607282557,
0.0149922566,
-0.0615490377,
-0.0051957546,
0.0318928063,
0.004175927,
-0.017651204,
-0.027030142,
0.0477191433,
0.001096148,
0.0027953207,
0.0699503645,
0.012235851,
-0.0411203913,
-0.0035061075,
0.0610570647,
0.0045613893,
0.0268018674,
-0.007873904,
-0.0154807977,
-0.0373016521,
0.0068600741,
-0.0500073396,
0.0800324455,
-0.0061116945,
-0.0696591586,
0.0067368611,
-0.0171035044,
-0.0090459473,
-0.0339464471,
0.0163389072,
-0.0401010178,
-0.0819270089,
-0.027503062,
0.0363572612,
-0.0860790312,
0.0034979798,
0.0185108315,
-0.0498247519,
0.0039011862,
-0.0364258625,
-0.0278455541,
-0.0231903326,
-0.0103513207,
-0.0170743074,
0.0039965804,
0.0892504603,
-0.0470585749,
-0.0735758692,
-0.0035360649,
0.0092530428,
0.0290078856,
-0.0126458267,
0.0009534407,
0.0230176412,
-0.0176328029,
-0.0103363926,
0.014723504,
-0.0968739465,
-0.0723458752,
-0.0259972531,
-0.011049482,
0.0040288912,
0.0265186429,
-0.0234525166,
-0.0466388278,
0.0532344766,
0.0158987045,
0.0117764501,
-0.0277364608,
0.0242082942,
-0.0146147758,
-0.0543462224,
0.0278622638,
-0.0410706438,
0.01161684,
0.0279423874,
-0.0208876673,
-0.0052833785,
-0.0422678962,
-0.0330472365,
0.0282927174,
0.0384573638,
0.0193909034,
-0.0060863425,
-0.0726089105,
0.006776867,
0.0115822293,
-0.0155245801,
0.0053660334,
-0.0289064236,
0.0236845855,
0.0001738466,
-0.0312548168,
-0.0365247168,
0.0438064337,
0.020341916,
-0.012503556,
-0.0196672678,
0.0288485177,
-0.0101884389,
0.0136990026,
0.0278256796,
-0.0496556126,
0.0284402911,
0.0339404233,
0.0104079721,
-0.0286107399,
0.0143655129,
0.0074781785,
-0.0035445872,
-0.0911972299,
0.0158843677,
-0.0608749166,
0.0401998721,
-0.0347688645,
-0.0029048428,
0.0696909577,
0.005268719,
0.0099590654,
0.0041507087,
-0.017563697,
-0.0417911932,
0.0794527903,
-0.0152597874,
-0.0434575863,
-0.0097230189,
0.0056612464,
-0.024119677,
0.0615870617,
-0.0038842731,
0.0728612691,
-0.0104463771,
0.0542782359,
-0.0499246567,
-0.0465417951,
-0.00301428,
0.0150044849,
0.0669992194,
0.0127996178,
0.0249637812,
-0.007400163,
-0.061294958,
0.0827867165,
-0.0375713632,
0.0159648359,
0.0264081862,
0.0187607147,
0.0064411103,
0.0407021903,
0.0066556358,
-0.0638842806,
0.0463051908,
0.0006529096,
0.005577832,
-0.0098586688,
-5.631221116e-33,
0.0318892412,
-0.068088159,
-0.0274948459,
0.0706975982,
-0.0535138398,
0.034899015,
-0.0358072966,
-0.0114836916,
-0.0176432375,
0.0313833877,
-0.0152945342,
0.0251155253,
0.0044564819,
0.0460517481,
-0.0297641288,
-0.0291759409,
-0.0018834063,
-0.0171949007,
0.0208351407,
0.0432584733,
0.0530077219,
0.0433041491,
0.0427876413,
-0.0927113593,
0.0263189767,
-0.0300284643,
0.0458534658,
-0.0093245171,
0.0464001484,
0.0323066935,
-0.0275091603,
0.0803633779,
0.0564973615,
0.0392136425,
0.0216305517,
0.0281148944,
-0.0533145256,
-0.0628767237,
-0.0774135217,
0.0282302331,
-0.0376549102,
-0.0087923417,
0.0353453197,
0.0316371992,
0.0110993367,
-0.0395625383,
0.0820220411,
0.0424659438,
-0.0637770519,
-0.0153389461,
-0.0192750618,
0.057914637,
-0.000135929,
0.015373759,
0.0022037083,
-0.0014295304,
0.0002144476,
-0.0065314104,
-0.085365802,
0.0031794212,
-0.0560216494,
-0.0174042098,
-0.0392623283,
0.0215637144,
0.0054215654,
0.0350275375,
0.0023955521,
0.0263682026,
-0.0250311736,
0.0455655754,
0.0308075454,
0.0297502261,
0.0173511524,
0.0207396504,
0.003198199,
-0.0484742597,
-0.1001712307,
-0.0179993827,
0.0356658027,
0.0173180383,
-0.0014662399,
0.0135926073,
-0.0165661052,
-0.0353928171,
0.0009375538,
-0.0436197147,
-0.0156116206,
-0.0136089632,
-0.0275930613,
-0.0012137467,
-0.0176620036,
0.0215978865,
-0.0089010531,
-0.0727842301,
-0.0246833153,
0.0907009691,
0.0074327192,
0.0591196269,
-0.0019358536,
0.0107165826,
-0.0482314266,
-0.0315856561,
-0.0302103329,
0.0042226929,
0.0262183044,
-0.0186565276,
0.0517512076,
0.0323371664,
-0.0209363643,
-0.0163610186,
-0.0061497795,
-0.0304988939,
-0.010104849,
0.0500994772,
0.0273231957,
0.0434064791,
0.012457029,
0.0999680907,
0.0382277295,
0.0594289042,
0.0237438381,
0.0100571336,
0.0498857982,
0.0344458297,
-0.0108807711,
-0.0213427842,
-0.0327726454,
0.0685302243,
0.0143714389,
-0.0690592751,
-0.0020106451,
-0.0256847776,
2.535e-7,
0.0705013722,
0.0420967378,
0.0460971035,
0.0179042239,
0.0067872792,
0.0358101241,
-0.0041418979,
0.0460925139,
-0.0115174633,
0.0418237261,
0.0511931479,
0.0111099929,
-0.0091476962,
0.0264739897,
-0.0713998154,
0.0348160006,
-0.0804814398,
0.0194402952,
-0.0133886589,
0.0171627328,
0.024999246,
0.0438180976,
0.0327436626,
-0.0277440827,
-0.0302288774,
-0.0798535645,
0.0530927889,
0.0164805632,
0.0071731233,
0.0158897191,
-0.0012823485,
-0.0094822897,
-0.0473495238,
0.0195494797,
-0.0211870205,
0.0664627925,
0.0392349176,
0.0292562991,
-0.0305707846,
-0.0100441109,
0.0261751488,
0.0017958268,
0.0130974744,
0.0089066513,
0.0658680126,
-0.0547634959,
-0.0208606236,
-0.010833405,
0.0051270137,
-0.0516658351,
0.0613151379,
-0.0098368404,
0.0060850917,
0.0235012397,
0.0315419175,
-0.0505890287,
0.0020158803,
-0.1031139046,
0.0219871905,
0.0284735318,
-0.008366527,
0.0262178704,
0.0095318165,
0.0482465141,
0.0580498241,
-0.0081969406,
0.0384544916,
1.877270333e-34,
0.0048566889,
-0.0060600312,
-0.0317065194,
-0.0496375896,
-0.0150785334,
-0.0395111069,
-0.0149936061,
-0.0076167309,
0.0293122344,
-0.080648236,
0.0004798095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11520v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11520v4 | Processing Natural Language on Embedded Devices: How Well Do Transformer Models Perform? | 2023-04-23T03:01:39 | 2024-03-07T00:42:17 | Souvika Sarkar, Mohammad Fakhruddin Babar, Md Mahadi Hassan, Monowar Hasan, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY | This paper presents a performance study of transformer language models under
different hardware configurations and accuracy requirements and derives
empirical observations about these resource/accuracy trade-offs. In particular,
we study how the most commonly used BERT-based language models (viz., BERT,
RoBERTa, DistilBERT, and TinyBERT) perform on embedded systems. We tested them
on four off-the-shelf embedded platforms (Raspberry Pi, Jetson, UP2, and UDOO)
with 2 GB and 4 GB memory (i.e., a total of eight hardware configurations) and
four datasets (i.e., HuRIC, GoEmotion, CoNLL, WNUT17) running various NLP
tasks. Our study finds that executing complex NLP tasks (such as "sentiment"
classification) on embedded systems is feasible even without any GPUs (e.g.,
Raspberry Pi with 2 GB of RAM). Our findings can help designers understand the
deployability and performance of transformer language models, especially those
based on BERT architectures. | [
0.0566346012,
0.0338157527,
0.0019708807,
0.0444012918,
-0.0384422503,
0.0034012722,
0.0142236743,
-0.0121019464,
0.0077512143,
-0.0858186558,
0.004914796,
-0.0035786058,
0.026288785,
-0.0135716638,
-0.0099199805,
-0.0760977417,
0.0649131611,
0.0135721313,
0.0018275456,
-0.0047240774,
0.0020775825,
0.0093776155,
-0.0120400693,
0.0517564155,
-0.0034375247,
-0.0090231905,
-0.0122343581,
0.029950697,
-0.0045976583,
0.0003542544,
0.0105303284,
0.0308456086,
-0.0089161424,
0.0324609019,
0.0000019612,
-0.0042283437,
-0.0143344076,
0.0188511852,
0.0132288709,
0.0014583329,
0.0760392994,
-0.0120867081,
-0.0257332064,
0.0483253598,
-0.029561352,
-0.0700773075,
0.0476387851,
0.0460715741,
0.0598609485,
0.0476428606,
-0.0253322292,
-0.036699567,
0.0483957529,
0.0001360677,
-0.0307384897,
0.0116107091,
0.002462392,
-0.0440816619,
0.0050387369,
-0.0048762341,
-0.0016083455,
0.0133964345,
0.017993832,
0.0327769592,
-0.0229348876,
0.0217376109,
-0.1059310734,
-0.0197662637,
-0.0401767567,
0.0250290707,
-0.0168545581,
-0.0181143507,
0.0165501274,
0.0227355324,
-0.0278749764,
-0.0359695405,
0.0099050524,
0.0176843442,
-0.0418419242,
0.0063774264,
0.01179884,
-0.0308980942,
0.0174391102,
-0.0127575789,
-0.0445151404,
0.0598978512,
0.0268884655,
-0.0199915264,
-0.0309721529,
0.0220545866,
-0.0123836668,
-0.0372422449,
0.0372789428,
0.0195983704,
0.008325614,
0.0120187346,
-0.0478089117,
-0.0378039517,
-0.0064684507,
-0.0688400641,
0.0015282434,
0.0377499871,
0.0086896643,
0.0005661554,
-0.0108267227,
0.0290907808,
-0.0434445627,
0.0053670006,
-0.0183639396,
-0.0156146353,
-0.0489475764,
-0.0145640429,
-0.0416135676,
0.0730015486,
-0.0461620949,
-0.056075979,
-0.03222638,
0.0283312555,
0.0131866317,
-0.0086961333,
0.0246640816,
0.0287525821,
0.002059232,
0.0214017425,
-0.0157749448,
0.0734478533,
-0.0026219606,
0.0026708422,
-0.0151158758,
-0.106182456,
0.0563654155,
0.0105788447,
-0.0029257806,
-0.0270963423,
0.0242242347,
0.0518412627,
0.0252963379,
-0.062782675,
-0.0323530473,
0.0396540239,
0.0047954032,
-0.0493910164,
0.0080295475,
-0.0799934641,
0.0125382105,
0.0567048043,
0.0294624399,
0.0231320243,
0.0266378094,
0.0415666848,
-0.0258970037,
0.0616882704,
-0.0187792256,
-0.0013815392,
0.035088215,
-0.0065657371,
0.0526818931,
0.0579136685,
0.0666929036,
0.0134523343,
0.0288089886,
-0.0158477388,
-0.0159670804,
0.0283318255,
-0.0180804133,
-0.0388356932,
-0.0128937801,
0.0150431218,
-0.0795532838,
0.0164597202,
0.0012336515,
0.1014589742,
0.0066939644,
0.014721402,
0.0624527037,
0.0739789084,
-0.0075288378,
0.0616180487,
-0.0184401646,
0.0200640317,
0.006930687,
-0.0491556749,
-0.0267783292,
0.003035581,
-0.0081348373,
-0.0079774978,
0.0327707715,
0.0175675619,
-0.008492751,
-0.0313116685,
-0.0309360605,
-0.0456736535,
0.0144892605,
-0.0125073027,
0.0432962291,
-0.0144820241,
-0.0361247398,
0.099031575,
0.016129626,
-0.0749140382,
-0.0363918282,
-0.0652484894,
0.0158027522,
0.0773022324,
0.0514508374,
-0.0148837473,
-0.0117704682,
0.0044492399,
-0.0351806656,
0.0428214483,
0.03339196,
0.0105500882,
-0.0214998182,
-0.0222834703,
0.0064572785,
0.0421401262,
0.0094083548,
-0.0008024901,
0.0149936387,
0.0237904862,
-0.0242549051,
-0.0284437053,
-0.0054582399,
0.0040202872,
0.0426976904,
0.0096783135,
-0.0155816432,
0.0100293914,
0.0044238148,
-0.0050172596,
-0.0322885811,
0.0054418892,
0.0473430753,
-0.0350376777,
-0.0181818064,
0.0062535205,
-0.0136043476,
-0.0346106216,
0.0149645768,
-0.0261298865,
0.0162430108,
0.0820886791,
0.008211446,
-0.0288286246,
0.019573763,
-0.1009493768,
0.0702538192,
-0.0039104228,
0.0265993457,
-0.0387029015,
0.0068623996,
0.0114826122,
0.0349140801,
-0.024935646,
0.0272623096,
0.0102764741,
-0.0199732035,
0.0274729505,
-0.0168452784,
-0.0624585226,
0.0147445835,
0.0109996721,
0.0182147007,
0.0395604968,
-0.0316675194,
0.0042905933,
-0.0233552363,
-0.1348691434,
0.0069221426,
-0.0194379594,
0.0334669314,
0.022992909,
0.0497726612,
0.0229035299,
0.0015274588,
0.002374409,
0.0047988538,
-0.0017020445,
0.0408702753,
0.0243544187,
-0.0221848749,
-0.008297489,
-0.0146290092,
-0.0245235804,
-0.0150654754,
0.0484513491,
-0.0058271023,
0.003205504,
-0.0438604727,
-0.0325433351,
-0.0033232484,
0.0475732386,
0.0074010817,
-0.0735205859,
0.0241920166,
-0.0090758968,
0.0676215217,
0.0717411563,
0.0301402677,
0.0325793028,
-0.0020619675,
-0.0135494275,
-0.0461886451,
0.0212373249,
-0.0241752472,
-0.0220355485,
-0.0329839438,
-0.0239422172,
-0.0135406805,
0.1084807217,
-0.0139281852,
0.007644257,
-0.0443764329,
-0.0473546833,
-0.0123794237,
-0.0030232889,
0.0453415066,
0.0293406211,
-0.0220520925,
-0.0083844736,
-0.0243120678,
-0.0652321354,
0.0572460815,
-0.0326756202,
0.0047079194,
-0.0949924663,
0.010571857,
-0.0120678591,
0.0593109615,
0.0281068962,
0.022357624,
-0.0444558524,
-0.0102199195,
0.0026019933,
0.0142481169,
-0.0370758809,
-0.0485158935,
0.0640454441,
-0.0201815348,
0.0159514137,
-0.0337591395,
-0.0438344032,
0.002552422,
-0.0130296769,
-0.0595033728,
0.0012772315,
0.0627905056,
-0.0349463932,
-0.0340619124,
0.0316367485,
0.0162545871,
0.0347638242,
0.0231943689,
-0.0311187748,
0.0086110346,
0.0062940619,
0.0253464133,
-0.0103723193,
0.0084668379,
0.0211436003,
-0.0170624442,
0.0338905007,
0.0666301027,
-0.0126138739,
-0.0777123272,
-0.0144162951,
0.0504676849,
-0.0219102688,
-0.052684322,
-0.0058023664,
0.0437932573,
-0.0446484424,
-0.0261790138,
0.112420857,
0.0159843992,
-0.0083713792,
0.0060025514,
0.0160451047,
0.0165661424,
0.0257076342,
0.0266946405,
-0.065155983,
-0.041806031,
0.0052950433,
0.0380356945,
-0.0120846527,
-0.0003986937,
0.0069659888,
-0.1342892051,
-0.0043099648,
-0.0353323705,
0.0041934433,
-0.0566394255,
-0.0660857633,
-0.0251540523,
-0.0258836914,
0.0221173149,
-0.0254993774,
-0.0109613538,
0.0048461715,
0.0158672612,
-0.097236976,
0.0010349869,
0.0412255973,
-0.0179720111,
0.0046237335,
0.082620874,
0.0268728528,
-0.0247316267,
-0.0582874529,
-0.0052024131,
-0.0122145433,
0.0022906633,
-0.0139260311,
0.0288594551,
-0.0123741133,
-0.0376107432,
-0.0456951559,
-0.0377754308,
-0.0432889089,
0.01837462,
-0.0391553864,
0.0535613,
-0.0192906708,
-0.01096409,
-0.0322823599,
-0.0075098029,
0.0099525852,
0.0421808697,
-0.0210902505,
-0.0683180839,
-0.0756535679,
-0.007494743,
-0.0189282782,
-0.0148715107,
-0.0024753711,
-0.0064617572,
0.0142512023,
-0.0422091633,
-0.0547844209,
-0.0065263039,
-0.0016953388,
0.0228573065,
0.0116068125,
-0.0167236272,
0.0604475811,
0.0410961658,
-0.0898777023,
0.0252189841,
0.0303165521,
0.0191203132,
-0.1051628068,
-0.0339064449,
0.0412204564,
0.0045781569,
-0.0271448102,
0.0113670146,
-0.0528515279,
-0.0488277525,
0.0541764721,
0.0665661916,
0.0281790476,
-0.0133666201,
0.0109160608,
-0.0254840311,
0.0016154437,
0.0808091462,
-0.0504007488,
0.0193491746,
0.0243334882,
0.0108940536,
0.0017215431,
0.0267144833,
-0.0256963465,
0.0272443034,
-0.007692487,
0.0038594708,
-0.0085390685,
-0.0644288063,
-0.0019701119,
-0.0012776798,
0.0731516406,
0.0017012096,
-0.0165573657,
0.0165994409,
0.0294299964,
0.0073935557,
0.0184747986,
-0.0424246341,
-0.02108334,
-0.0039655082,
0.017978888,
-0.0400372073,
0.0319122858,
0.0010839747,
-0.0399767384,
-0.0323789157,
0.0510384887,
0.0303125717,
0.0113974717,
0.0250219759,
-0.0012898053,
-0.0173711739,
-0.050158713,
0.0106118806,
0.0239432268,
-0.0489680022,
0.0439208969,
0.0070524155,
-0.0081435777,
-0.0091028111,
0.0483375117,
-0.0452508703,
-0.0123998653,
0.0040104431,
0.0417338014,
0.0184722766,
0.0067399242,
0.032762479,
-0.0265801232,
0.0019324803,
-0.0469361246,
0.016831059,
-0.0038758512,
-0.0247718953,
0.043559663,
0.0175395738,
-0.033830002,
-0.0078697661,
0.0393300802,
-0.0220965575,
0.0523054115,
0.0340137295,
-0.0040551191,
-0.0613991804,
-0.002207608,
0.0190565009,
-0.0237406138,
-0.0275097694,
0.0105392495,
-0.0340206064,
-0.049497433,
0.031483572,
-0.0066221692,
0.0390868001,
-0.0625403374,
0.0342582203,
0.0656942502,
0.0266227163,
-0.01626762,
-0.0338619612,
0.0288660806,
-0.0843564346,
0.0134498309,
0.0056482418,
-6.004856771e-33,
-0.0226857979,
0.0289977491,
0.0143207675,
0.0086280499,
0.025109699,
0.0261328705,
-0.0209217779,
0.0279211868,
-0.0446762703,
0.0062986603,
-0.0296116769,
0.0139615797,
0.0104890056,
0.0401580781,
0.001368738,
-0.0047033168,
0.078369163,
0.0153374979,
-0.0375499018,
0.0193102378,
0.0412063822,
0.035008505,
0.0434103236,
-0.0270886812,
-0.0215631407,
-0.0196462013,
0.0198537353,
-0.0126859332,
0.0257003829,
0.0411667377,
-0.0250192042,
0.0597068444,
0.020979993,
-0.0219956748,
-0.0072788387,
0.0666873679,
-0.0927397683,
0.0117758941,
0.0031402647,
0.0780619234,
-0.0101375673,
0.001317311,
0.0408987813,
0.0204454158,
-0.0604310445,
0.0138892531,
0.0167383198,
-0.0085109519,
-0.0196479112,
-0.0455733836,
-0.0398838297,
0.0044268933,
0.0270049497,
-0.0351014473,
0.0089681922,
-0.0209565908,
-0.0313369744,
0.0165769439,
-0.063990064,
-0.0113300737,
-0.0034946203,
0.0544753149,
0.0529478565,
-0.0063427393,
0.0065330635,
0.0551386774,
0.031043062,
-0.0124652395,
-0.0139930164,
0.0297836121,
0.0129654845,
0.0397214815,
0.0376710594,
0.0049127755,
0.0504237488,
-0.038848795,
-0.0448405407,
0.0072967494,
0.0592103116,
0.0202632695,
0.0490393527,
0.0105756978,
-0.0397959612,
-0.0164640788,
0.0092033911,
0.0220973305,
-0.0128314886,
-0.015243616,
0.0104200765,
0.029807115,
-0.0087040411,
0.0142044984,
0.0087215751,
-0.0559921749,
-0.0157816987,
0.0066619562,
0.0212978013,
0.0013541487,
-0.0076286988,
0.0292617194,
-0.0351994298,
-0.0370440856,
-0.0073801875,
0.0378837436,
0.0269749798,
0.0199712068,
0.0007522566,
0.0434179045,
-0.0983695388,
-0.0031644665,
-0.0410751738,
0.0294027235,
-0.0475296751,
0.0644379854,
0.0277279429,
-0.00927692,
-0.0080274958,
0.0411428101,
-0.0575656816,
0.0027480943,
-0.0327412821,
0.0237454381,
0.0123059116,
-0.0036161612,
-0.0244769193,
-0.0233478677,
-0.0664052367,
0.0665644631,
-0.0101614166,
-0.0594247542,
-0.045221515,
0.0030958352,
2.782e-7,
0.0339065827,
0.0709932595,
0.0244598202,
-0.0515744612,
0.0179371294,
0.0191972796,
0.025229007,
0.0362388119,
-0.0011701816,
0.0273350999,
-0.041582454,
-0.0150414621,
0.0363516808,
0.0076876283,
-0.0706129447,
-0.0102900434,
-0.062588267,
0.0358523019,
-0.0195951238,
0.0460140333,
0.075036712,
0.1093543619,
-0.0125663439,
-0.0028550369,
0.0043948554,
-0.0288613997,
0.0354265794,
-0.0243487731,
0.0350822583,
0.0025956808,
0.0051826043,
0.0642371699,
-0.0158237237,
0.0035222736,
0.0061692223,
0.0102053517,
-0.0152176851,
0.051579494,
-0.0298615228,
-0.0069249026,
0.0170916133,
-0.0673698634,
-0.0488584004,
-0.0484284163,
0.0500345416,
-0.0625129566,
-0.0465713739,
-0.0316829346,
0.0039862273,
0.0080636339,
-0.011125355,
0.0038664679,
-0.0073785507,
-0.0162486024,
0.0158246011,
-0.051837042,
-0.0421462022,
-0.0552169047,
0.0032150254,
0.0169566944,
-0.0338049084,
-0.0593631044,
-0.0646439791,
0.0019262758,
0.0520024821,
-0.0278895479,
0.0037484486,
2.501491238e-34,
0.0237975568,
-0.0096066464,
-0.0224653482,
0.0317955166,
0.0096932119,
-0.0040323292,
0.0493840687,
-0.0296281576,
-0.01322605,
-0.0582138039,
-0.0162412543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11501v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11501v2 | Lost in Translationese? Reducing Translation Effect Using Abstract Meaning Representation | 2023-04-23T00:04:14 | 2024-01-29T23:09:49 | Shira Wein, Nathan Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translated texts bear several hallmarks distinct from texts originating in
the language. Though individual translated texts are often fluent and preserve
meaning, at a large scale, translated texts have statistical tendencies which
distinguish them from text originally written in the language
("translationese") and can affect model performance. We frame the novel task of
translationese reduction and hypothesize that Abstract Meaning Representation
(AMR), a graph-based semantic representation which abstracts away from the
surface form, can be used as an interlingua to reduce the amount of
translationese in translated texts. By parsing English translations into an AMR
and then generating text from that AMR, the result more closely resembles
originally English text across three quantitative macro-level measures, without
severely compromising fluency or adequacy. We compare our AMR-based approach
against three other techniques based on machine translation or paraphrase
generation. This work makes strides towards reducing translationese in text and
highlights the utility of AMR as an interlingua. | [
0.0179414228,
0.0505270883,
-0.0450244769,
0.0683612823,
-0.0411119685,
0.0092255743,
-0.0066220993,
0.017371241,
0.0001991465,
-0.0403227583,
-0.0051581338,
-0.0148789315,
0.0318071768,
0.0016090176,
0.0116072251,
-0.0721821338,
0.0489304252,
0.0250622798,
-0.0001661196,
-0.0075804903,
0.0342888311,
0.045446109,
0.0771400556,
0.0253932923,
0.034093976,
-0.0044474346,
0.0291685183,
0.0214936789,
0.030280659,
0.0246963035,
-0.0425297506,
-0.014393637,
0.0272265449,
0.0376849696,
0.0000019924,
-0.0227303561,
-0.0640135705,
-0.0061624772,
0.0274531413,
0.0019586403,
0.1241266653,
-0.0585767142,
0.0108267684,
0.001519417,
-0.0214107726,
-0.0132761179,
0.0251262952,
0.014961686,
0.0315461941,
0.0344384685,
-0.0313176401,
-0.0420442335,
-0.0149644278,
0.0245123338,
-0.003394688,
-0.0277332682,
-0.0185246654,
0.0434804522,
-0.0546402931,
0.0183679033,
-0.0380005464,
0.0658322871,
-0.0217160024,
0.0233086143,
-0.003853316,
0.0017410431,
-0.0221396256,
-0.0006058463,
0.0471233726,
0.0427367389,
-0.0213692915,
-0.0580572337,
0.0068514748,
-0.0126334568,
-0.0243581925,
0.046818912,
-0.0347583182,
0.0205891132,
-0.0175337046,
0.0214173403,
0.0441664197,
0.0367845036,
0.0129046869,
0.006175478,
-0.0646958426,
-0.0140148895,
0.019489564,
-0.0159296338,
0.0259526409,
0.0101448717,
-0.054171823,
-0.0086665442,
0.0385396555,
-0.0365629978,
-0.0047873519,
0.0241305195,
-0.033431232,
-0.0804782584,
-0.0224134699,
-0.0562360361,
0.01510958,
0.0605065078,
0.0327751748,
0.0005816201,
-0.0052001136,
0.057436619,
0.0033865881,
0.0196320396,
-0.1016779467,
-0.0166961141,
-0.0413917936,
0.0158468727,
-0.0740214959,
0.0147858113,
-0.0390320867,
-0.0215550344,
-0.0275621172,
0.0162775926,
0.0098771797,
-0.0183624793,
-0.020739371,
-0.0078858444,
-0.0552558899,
0.015397694,
0.004956421,
0.0420310125,
-0.0046696276,
-0.0203844383,
-0.0487330109,
-0.0148189468,
0.0287543908,
0.0092280954,
0.0502092578,
-0.0240802653,
-0.02265306,
0.0500565879,
0.0128461113,
-0.0048008468,
0.0040450171,
-0.0689208284,
0.0011802746,
-0.0282381102,
-0.0006318188,
-0.0368241854,
0.0577058345,
0.0065722223,
0.0277665462,
-0.0586566217,
-0.0013951347,
-0.0041084564,
-0.0284542907,
0.0430953391,
0.000769255,
0.0040959991,
-0.009330038,
-0.002820615,
0.0016945787,
0.0150358416,
0.0403109491,
0.0199940186,
0.0675868914,
0.0006628481,
-0.0617216863,
0.0120182382,
0.0283133704,
0.0241893474,
-0.0027413093,
0.0012040169,
-0.0410933346,
0.0051130364,
0.0228952337,
0.0552679561,
-0.0177869406,
0.0084769968,
0.0447790697,
0.0600065142,
-0.041047994,
0.055025734,
0.0544791147,
0.0757772774,
-0.0212699082,
0.0208912306,
-0.0095019257,
-0.0240016486,
0.0003245717,
0.0426245295,
-0.0064631044,
-0.0120282685,
0.014306386,
-0.0157568064,
0.0023642166,
-0.0170103554,
0.0690741539,
0.0084762406,
0.0161670465,
0.0132412016,
-0.0313406698,
0.0451801494,
-0.0157094728,
-0.0446323752,
0.0149422996,
-0.0080849295,
-0.0343236327,
0.0721949637,
0.02532438,
0.0274889711,
0.0018486767,
-0.0188189633,
0.0178010855,
0.0381466635,
0.0160607621,
-0.0164700132,
0.0223199669,
-0.0437687226,
-0.0092971493,
0.016734466,
-0.0051659504,
0.0044780257,
-0.0403342918,
0.0214460306,
0.0376105458,
-0.0838910341,
-0.1020233706,
0.0168425739,
-0.0250772685,
-0.0105541404,
0.0051794811,
0.0222921893,
0.0049746479,
0.0285511781,
-0.0080336016,
0.0081632817,
0.0099484902,
-0.0361653604,
-0.0313533954,
0.0830655843,
-0.0093495408,
-0.0266256053,
-0.003298423,
-0.0615591221,
-0.0246281214,
0.0049369633,
-0.0364300348,
-0.0330998562,
0.0279456452,
-0.053236343,
0.0728660673,
0.0056090504,
0.0452393033,
-0.043064665,
0.0061708819,
-0.0188132841,
0.0459704734,
0.0077434164,
0.0311117191,
0.0091800634,
-0.0121259512,
0.0463212617,
-0.0187705625,
0.0153686022,
0.0040142755,
0.0389983989,
0.0212341119,
0.0719507709,
-0.0022883669,
-0.0370167382,
0.0109533845,
-0.0446656086,
0.0091683818,
-0.0005688444,
0.0353098214,
0.0947872847,
0.0429012999,
0.036819119,
0.0350011513,
0.0055168765,
0.0016729366,
0.0109869875,
0.0113340067,
0.0146894911,
-0.0222522691,
0.0058753062,
-0.0122797806,
0.0137981782,
-0.0199644454,
0.0459104404,
0.0314852633,
-0.0418314263,
-0.0432015471,
0.0528231002,
-0.0491984859,
-0.0292033851,
0.0033036459,
-0.0541903824,
-0.0375238732,
-0.0015169021,
0.0266354829,
0.0354526527,
-0.0143950181,
0.0013864234,
0.0520656817,
-0.0313491598,
-0.0486204587,
-0.0449424572,
-0.0080822632,
-0.0213812105,
-0.0127118314,
-0.1235828772,
0.0266538039,
0.0077029387,
0.0537030883,
0.0079101902,
-0.0601793714,
0.0172733273,
-0.0703988299,
0.0021984703,
-0.0444450565,
0.0306615718,
0.0055048824,
0.0226541031,
-0.0393881053,
-0.0025380598,
0.0583176203,
0.0167369507,
0.0224809293,
-0.0762352198,
0.0135280127,
-0.0282429978,
0.0497785918,
-0.0192663744,
0.0603208989,
-0.0293436311,
-0.0373397358,
-0.0417504907,
-0.0255693123,
0.0211964827,
-0.0239996593,
0.0377037153,
-0.0582996756,
-0.0053971424,
0.0087510077,
0.010171514,
0.0143864164,
-0.0224200375,
-0.0061707105,
0.0190481022,
0.0232138727,
-0.0082745198,
-0.0084120557,
-0.0077856118,
0.0389745943,
-0.0200869497,
-0.008512903,
-0.0127093894,
-0.0141281579,
0.0063672061,
0.0375551619,
-0.0165514704,
-0.0141558731,
-0.0377161838,
0.0626780912,
0.0098750759,
-0.0372381024,
-0.0263774619,
-0.0374677703,
-0.0116225248,
-0.0120427124,
-0.0063283457,
-0.046427872,
-0.0307863988,
0.0212836992,
-0.0407313518,
-0.0244430769,
0.0956066027,
0.0099624898,
-0.0095605934,
0.0069073983,
-0.0317540653,
0.032224711,
0.018118443,
-0.0006244403,
-0.0722532049,
-0.0019097318,
-0.0144137926,
0.013938888,
0.0143283987,
-0.0237192661,
-0.0002578171,
-0.0682746917,
0.0074438998,
0.0509871989,
-0.0844010338,
-0.0417287908,
0.0006063605,
-0.0356884524,
-0.0099476781,
-0.0097414283,
-0.0398473889,
-0.0122486493,
0.0170463845,
-0.0330385566,
-0.0058253347,
-0.0372271501,
-0.0226719268,
-0.04149241,
-0.0567591861,
0.0260395203,
0.0991500169,
0.0025764448,
-0.0154748736,
0.0130232712,
-0.0579230823,
-0.0064575551,
-0.0396834724,
0.0675134659,
0.021216698,
-0.0020293412,
-0.0020943258,
-0.0104995752,
-0.0068658385,
-0.0208286401,
0.0001826124,
0.0598505437,
-0.0136097744,
0.0135896066,
0.0235015787,
-0.0166482106,
0.0281283483,
0.0536879152,
0.0373107828,
0.0050972491,
-0.0295139365,
-0.0482946523,
0.0253224913,
-0.0386001579,
-0.0680814236,
0.0148783578,
-0.1093766093,
-0.0208302084,
-0.0925044417,
-0.0628345087,
-0.0094140694,
-0.0139154699,
0.0333208218,
0.0276443027,
0.0219182912,
-0.033283785,
-0.0539042316,
-0.0066037788,
-0.0495269373,
0.0302274395,
0.0294344183,
-0.0126580494,
0.0158522837,
-0.030142054,
-0.0074556489,
0.0156669971,
-0.0102516944,
-0.0496304557,
-0.0223368034,
-0.0072872629,
0.0190767087,
0.0335111618,
-0.0071140947,
0.0108021414,
0.0668834299,
-0.0470200181,
-0.0034783043,
0.0247917622,
0.0442383625,
0.063243933,
-0.0129003543,
0.0696441531,
-0.0296657495,
0.0211420897,
-0.0061962502,
0.0450702049,
-0.0109137939,
-0.0306340791,
0.0340917967,
0.0782272071,
0.0044192588,
-0.0188725051,
-0.0217871852,
-0.0201077014,
-0.028716119,
-0.0557292067,
-0.0422748737,
-0.0154315922,
0.0089998432,
0.0349175707,
-0.0213310756,
-0.0350691602,
0.0485581309,
-0.0360854641,
0.0092414543,
0.02380451,
0.0063356999,
-0.0328272097,
0.0105026178,
-0.0059479009,
0.0452585816,
-0.0158656258,
-0.0261395872,
0.0025583659,
0.0316380188,
-0.0388444103,
-0.0091086207,
-0.0014253624,
-0.0032692836,
-0.0567081459,
0.021535689,
-0.0207035746,
-0.0351471603,
0.0167398676,
-0.0143648628,
0.0472865179,
-0.0273778532,
0.1357552409,
-0.0030484607,
-0.0184337758,
-0.0232180506,
0.0865096077,
0.025885243,
-0.0481877737,
0.0034392611,
-0.0247159395,
-0.0060256366,
0.0024621261,
0.0357554816,
-0.0456802137,
0.0133864293,
-0.0232739486,
-0.0441094078,
-0.046068605,
-0.0107111242,
0.0015159264,
0.0056552067,
0.0023963465,
-0.053288348,
-0.0659554079,
-0.0626148507,
0.0104801012,
0.0088188639,
0.0333507285,
-0.0248819925,
0.0053334055,
0.0332647339,
-0.0064598653,
-0.0035014541,
-0.0663841441,
0.0363132395,
-0.0493815243,
-0.0040753894,
-0.0723578334,
-5.671192699e-33,
-0.0187295601,
-0.0130478358,
-0.0160853583,
0.0078267921,
-0.0556856282,
0.0246264376,
-0.0776501149,
-0.0290501714,
0.0054476727,
0.0204044133,
0.0314479135,
0.0132261794,
0.0149052283,
-0.0396984071,
0.0110323066,
0.0292979963,
0.0716457888,
-0.0002627522,
-0.0225890167,
0.0413355641,
0.075571835,
0.0042267833,
0.0687790141,
-0.0601295494,
0.0337380208,
-0.0163274817,
0.0118888319,
-0.0369939469,
0.0454092845,
0.0309480447,
0.0103854146,
0.0538265221,
0.0257638041,
0.0415778421,
-0.0470661409,
0.0107974363,
-0.0718314424,
-0.03797796,
0.0383532047,
0.0338052437,
0.0061842273,
-0.0775872394,
0.036934223,
-0.0517592132,
-0.0165189579,
-0.0102884946,
0.0575747006,
-0.0324820764,
-0.033867795,
-0.0327882282,
-0.075142093,
0.005868433,
-0.0064954632,
0.0387564227,
0.0508144833,
0.047078494,
-0.0063813948,
0.0028624926,
-0.0442960821,
0.0116031338,
-0.0499817953,
0.0119945602,
0.019396184,
-0.0021936647,
0.0372666493,
0.0169489272,
0.0082068052,
-0.0200631283,
0.0548117049,
0.0479348227,
0.0532976761,
-0.0089896517,
0.0078432309,
0.0775977299,
0.0312463958,
-0.0302008968,
-0.0491322465,
0.0352231078,
-0.0412091352,
0.0570426136,
0.0038839963,
0.03390944,
-0.0190179069,
-0.0473942682,
-0.040191967,
-0.0221400093,
0.0013080287,
-0.0350274555,
0.0056656161,
-0.0332528651,
-0.070161894,
0.0144780576,
0.0751792192,
-0.0695017725,
-0.005862745,
0.015709294,
-0.0352084674,
0.0324542038,
0.0121337436,
0.0219941586,
-0.024535412,
-0.064214386,
-0.0259396564,
0.0373017788,
0.037582919,
-0.002962305,
0.0485788286,
-0.0005878918,
-0.0145008583,
0.0150762862,
-0.036852248,
-0.0610985272,
-0.0494902059,
-0.0157018974,
0.0298212077,
0.0275556426,
0.0121427337,
0.0114496863,
0.0449167043,
0.0004071823,
-0.0165636037,
0.0461343341,
0.0253422819,
0.052911222,
-0.0604656339,
0.0322830789,
-0.0208461061,
0.0315528512,
0.0666626915,
-0.0536967218,
-0.0521979667,
-0.0334598497,
2.706e-7,
0.0541865155,
0.0319057107,
0.0132568069,
0.0440930575,
-0.0082804188,
0.0077252178,
-0.0167593807,
0.0197962243,
-0.0028721218,
0.0281810462,
0.0468862392,
0.0119491136,
0.0466127694,
0.0479102619,
-0.0724490434,
0.04388877,
-0.0238617454,
-0.0206797272,
-0.0424978957,
0.0736819729,
0.0859920755,
0.0539502054,
0.0261900723,
0.0171509739,
-0.0245891102,
-0.0337138623,
0.0720528215,
-0.0298904851,
-0.0139619214,
0.0076724626,
-0.0124110673,
0.0221174136,
-0.0408533923,
-0.0019381491,
-0.0193733592,
-0.0018141877,
0.0469793193,
0.0439444222,
-0.013008466,
0.0387412645,
-0.0197978541,
-0.083376348,
0.0076053543,
-0.0317709185,
0.0295232404,
-0.0402090587,
-0.0093205469,
-0.0122876624,
-0.0491448566,
0.0395367518,
-0.0046767797,
0.0002228941,
-0.0600524135,
0.0300109815,
0.0298480541,
-0.01087166,
-0.0197797976,
0.0015235692,
-0.0063302871,
0.013766896,
0.0194739457,
-0.0323422737,
0.0202866364,
0.0524350069,
-0.0116493888,
-0.0564454161,
0.0092503941,
2.515684185e-34,
0.0467909984,
-0.0097201848,
0.0278902538,
-0.0122330207,
0.0550682917,
-0.0385538079,
0.0078950645,
0.0214767251,
-0.003428807,
-0.0372706503,
-0.0138723878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11490v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11490v3 | Boosting Theory-of-Mind Performance in Large Language Models via Prompting | 2023-04-22T22:50:50 | 2023-04-26T04:02:04 | Shima Rahimi Moghaddam, Christopher J. Honey | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) excel in many tasks in 2023, but they still face
challenges in complex reasoning. Theory-of-mind (ToM) tasks, which require
understanding agents' beliefs, goals, and mental states, are essential for
common-sense reasoning involving humans, making it crucial to enhance LLM
performance in this area. This study measures the ToM performance of GPT-4 and
three GPT-3.5 variants (Davinci-2, Davinci-3, GPT-3.5-Turbo), and investigates
the effectiveness of in-context learning in improving their ToM comprehension.
We evaluated prompts featuring two-shot chain of thought reasoning and
step-by-step thinking instructions. We found that LLMs trained with
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) (all models excluding
Davinci-2) improved their ToM accuracy via in-context learning. GPT-4 performed
best in zero-shot settings, reaching nearly 80% ToM accuracy, but still fell
short of the 87% human accuracy on the test set. However, when supplied with
prompts for in-context learning, all RLHF-trained LLMs exceeded 80% ToM
accuracy, with GPT-4 reaching 100%. These results demonstrate that appropriate
prompting enhances LLM ToM reasoning, and they underscore the context-dependent
nature of LLM cognitive capacities. | [
0.038519755,
-0.0041858889,
-0.0270402804,
0.0166497603,
-0.0300251748,
0.0393209197,
-0.0045224787,
-0.0055440119,
0.0241034478,
-0.018103905,
-0.0397113822,
-0.035618715,
0.0012911106,
0.0099710291,
0.0358561277,
-0.0490244515,
0.0474165566,
-0.0644233376,
0.0159217492,
-0.0162753556,
-0.0532897487,
0.0295463502,
-0.0351747498,
0.020755833,
0.0209511165,
-0.0173269752,
-0.0283016562,
-0.0087592779,
0.0492379889,
-0.071586132,
-0.0240642503,
0.0320932828,
0.0511541404,
0.0613681078,
0.0000023347,
-0.066474624,
0.015362273,
-0.0177911483,
-0.0283260159,
-0.0013752594,
0.0143432142,
0.026835341,
0.007114369,
0.0205757339,
-0.037250068,
0.0220837556,
0.0001091166,
0.0689797103,
0.0234899111,
0.0561267436,
0.0071898578,
0.0055977646,
0.0335952416,
-0.0237514302,
0.0627972335,
-0.0780569986,
-0.0098804738,
-0.0054582912,
0.0349779911,
-0.0058968612,
0.0039204489,
0.015911961,
0.025738664,
0.0089421431,
-0.0279622208,
0.0583915599,
-0.0151712652,
-0.016940061,
-0.0310084391,
0.0694534853,
0.0954706445,
0.0152785107,
-0.0317325853,
0.0135794152,
0.0127112009,
0.0120838955,
-0.0420666598,
0.0303951167,
-0.011250468,
0.0106289582,
0.0133414166,
-0.0219435301,
0.0154323708,
0.0101782111,
-0.0310969632,
0.0662307218,
-0.0251191519,
-0.0396131165,
0.0278855041,
-0.0013586013,
-0.0534012355,
-0.0511876903,
-0.0473503694,
0.0236319862,
-0.050233081,
0.0179602932,
-0.0131521393,
0.0330552012,
-0.0061463406,
-0.0113890925,
0.073384583,
0.0729627758,
-0.0138352662,
0.0438492671,
-0.0275273193,
0.0469956547,
-0.0218332838,
0.0587135553,
0.0005937591,
0.0106205139,
-0.0770165995,
-0.0110725956,
-0.0221552718,
0.0559213683,
0.0168082267,
-0.0214733966,
-0.0288362578,
0.0268971883,
-0.0049191397,
0.0015970628,
-0.02558605,
-0.0070933914,
-0.0138385044,
-0.0056832451,
-0.0776049271,
0.0450549871,
-0.0478519239,
0.0113018174,
0.046091903,
-0.0513828173,
-0.0305928644,
-0.02951313,
0.0025396678,
-0.0088365981,
0.0221805479,
0.0277350564,
-0.0055198078,
-0.0512508564,
-0.0556256622,
-0.0081587797,
0.012711362,
-0.1042103842,
0.0009450911,
-0.0290290434,
-0.0278147273,
0.0015263323,
-0.0053761494,
0.0172169916,
0.0238589887,
0.0226248037,
-0.0442539528,
0.061428912,
-0.0009462864,
-0.0064023561,
0.0035978521,
0.0128459902,
-0.0510223247,
0.0359032005,
0.0201981533,
-0.009735615,
-0.0231279191,
0.022351345,
0.0001679748,
0.0009479368,
0.0003631411,
-0.0012909484,
-0.0202708412,
0.0047465353,
0.0248587243,
0.0452185683,
0.0271512549,
0.0390289836,
-0.0374432057,
0.0596405119,
0.0793889686,
0.0723021328,
-0.0156282783,
-0.043923568,
0.0472823121,
0.0357339755,
0.0128948893,
-0.0043377937,
-0.0994495153,
0.0652255639,
-0.0539843477,
-0.0049727885,
0.0270488393,
0.0029592342,
-0.0466709696,
0.0052217883,
-0.0087537766,
0.019298207,
0.0242888611,
0.0337610096,
0.038237948,
-0.0346782096,
-0.0445765033,
0.0013777602,
0.0212897472,
-0.0066594742,
-0.0420956947,
-0.0785447583,
0.0234252438,
0.0386846215,
0.030676173,
-0.0017483367,
-0.056111481,
-0.0305386893,
0.0115587739,
0.0546870865,
0.052983284,
0.0144213326,
-0.0272294991,
-0.035224773,
-0.0178738646,
-0.0453161187,
0.0034425058,
0.0445770323,
-0.0095739542,
0.0198481604,
-0.0068363268,
0.0010287947,
0.0305275545,
-0.0007862318,
0.0128903873,
-0.022290159,
-0.0507156998,
0.0300351139,
0.0173370354,
0.0173401907,
0.0010746318,
-0.0088708699,
0.0039287433,
0.0150430333,
-0.0016158076,
0.0343907923,
-0.0769339651,
-0.0207750835,
0.0342231356,
0.0205773301,
-0.0674395636,
0.0197432004,
-0.009420393,
-0.0337816663,
0.0166212004,
-0.020478582,
0.0298254378,
-0.034075547,
0.0241333637,
-0.0234642476,
-0.0194400772,
-0.0111184819,
0.0953678861,
-0.0189106613,
-0.0129824718,
0.0475596003,
-0.0085998401,
0.0190425869,
-0.0273201242,
0.0245369002,
0.0114752091,
0.0194472391,
-0.0329565816,
0.0019568284,
0.0368215591,
-0.060231816,
0.0078586861,
-0.0790649429,
-0.0207627192,
0.0027310152,
0.0010983367,
-0.0021637471,
-0.004892359,
-0.0267272834,
0.0122898119,
-0.0368607081,
0.0486679263,
0.0294658393,
0.0059843184,
0.0181214195,
0.0076612802,
-0.0296182539,
0.0003184201,
0.0303798541,
-0.0455003418,
-0.0198346637,
0.0034418481,
-0.007802465,
-0.02273768,
0.0392760783,
-0.0302215368,
0.0275566075,
-0.0312184189,
-0.0274943225,
0.0641882569,
-0.0090650627,
0.0272937845,
0.104206644,
-0.000936835,
-0.0005016268,
0.0529691577,
0.004692826,
-0.0451284945,
0.0539807379,
0.0269582737,
-0.0419737622,
-0.0450869165,
-0.0014782457,
-0.014760131,
0.0486309901,
0.0065926188,
0.0307220072,
-0.0785284787,
0.0121697495,
-0.0096439356,
-0.0474327989,
-0.0206781365,
0.0050730435,
-0.0362303369,
0.0781417713,
-0.0045271521,
-0.0243091825,
0.0957193747,
-0.0116860634,
-0.0090354644,
-0.0562599935,
0.0206495337,
-0.0050152387,
0.0671888292,
-0.0069640046,
0.0075079976,
0.0059484681,
-0.0326544195,
-0.0859178156,
-0.0349142663,
0.0030264379,
0.0046716947,
0.0377485119,
-0.0331244059,
-0.0118484823,
-0.0087464275,
-0.0230494011,
-0.0407173745,
0.0214022119,
-0.0632789657,
0.009246923,
-0.0389793515,
-0.0271277726,
-0.0174252931,
-0.0416126922,
0.0797117651,
0.012006266,
-0.0135175977,
-0.0484878831,
-0.0162661672,
-0.0179438293,
0.040700864,
-0.0073557938,
0.0453430936,
-0.047081992,
0.0719340295,
0.0452514738,
0.0585823953,
0.0094591258,
0.0023183294,
0.0189306941,
0.023562273,
0.0359354466,
-0.0189869255,
0.0485359505,
0.0774995834,
-0.0233954433,
-0.004319937,
0.1414386034,
0.0353237391,
-0.0531335846,
-0.0115905693,
-0.0360034481,
0.0327458382,
0.0354405828,
0.0074134879,
-0.070554696,
-0.0377675965,
0.0470934063,
0.0061640474,
-0.0414068401,
-0.0595108271,
-0.0061097411,
-0.1114720628,
0.0299093295,
-0.0165024269,
-0.0066811247,
-0.0023184144,
-0.0133094331,
0.0207845904,
0.0409361944,
0.0126033053,
0.0276462492,
-0.0015324341,
-0.0022687695,
-0.0048337309,
0.0362239815,
-0.0167172346,
0.0890687183,
-0.0326338746,
0.0811417624,
0.071901761,
0.0208784975,
0.0089254817,
-0.06197742,
0.0447138548,
0.0431371666,
0.030442344,
-0.0230543334,
-0.0071593137,
-0.0282204635,
0.0135691212,
-0.0253355969,
0.0553660952,
-0.0133481901,
-0.0115720779,
-0.0036280791,
0.0884795189,
-0.0292645227,
-0.0117897037,
0.0087855514,
0.0458386093,
-0.0336997807,
0.0738463402,
0.0228440762,
-0.0325307176,
0.0066771139,
-0.0175195243,
-0.0445273928,
0.0085564833,
-0.0197446272,
0.0095996652,
0.0168236941,
-0.0048047998,
-0.029388601,
-0.0641314015,
0.0450755171,
0.0374711528,
-0.0014504176,
-0.000598097,
-0.0175877865,
0.0476811118,
0.0015523795,
0.0268154833,
-0.0422398448,
0.0100578833,
-0.0535683818,
0.0001934142,
-0.0053256191,
-0.0469086245,
-0.0067132767,
0.0167877004,
-0.0413808189,
-0.0559108928,
-0.0345126502,
0.036439117,
0.0300006717,
0.0413542613,
0.0217593722,
-0.0118830176,
0.0302460231,
-0.0274830759,
-0.0502038971,
0.0458488986,
0.011285603,
0.0682917014,
0.0159919243,
0.0449049696,
-0.0204030052,
-0.0115866549,
0.0125587843,
0.0255236011,
0.0171863511,
0.0289116874,
0.0420608371,
0.0079290867,
0.0394216552,
-0.0019988858,
0.0043972526,
-0.0318145268,
0.0109516196,
-0.0404790416,
0.0068037957,
-0.0361185335,
-0.0138122346,
0.0412896164,
0.0091064163,
-0.0078826612,
-0.0861064345,
0.0003162641,
0.0037871606,
0.0141938133,
-0.0038958536,
0.0110849561,
0.0501521304,
0.0130122984,
-0.000925409,
-0.0266525652,
-0.014306223,
-0.0285258256,
0.0373470932,
0.0023042171,
0.1571884006,
0.0432747602,
-0.0323835611,
-0.0032083914,
0.0159132835,
-0.088292025,
-0.0954080969,
0.0541923828,
0.0290772822,
0.0158836525,
0.0172498506,
-0.0097293947,
-0.0700402409,
0.0155577697,
0.0277656801,
0.0027545886,
-0.0045280578,
-0.0239556022,
0.0086148577,
0.0086837662,
0.0152946208,
-0.016401343,
0.0291012973,
-0.0260620378,
0.0492418632,
-0.0019345804,
0.0037989854,
-0.0210843179,
0.0229157265,
-0.028843008,
0.0632583499,
-0.0081374058,
0.0510357097,
-0.0839830041,
-0.0409149379,
-0.0082393866,
0.0166060943,
-0.0287136119,
-0.0298876148,
0.026130246,
0.0605262332,
-0.0080954619,
-0.0702378154,
0.0131661678,
-0.030472314,
-0.01008981,
-0.026412392,
-0.0350789055,
-7.035748786e-33,
-0.0285679735,
-0.0021836457,
0.0369258188,
0.0042444193,
-0.0454849117,
-0.0367913283,
-0.0585861728,
0.0161085539,
-0.0265356917,
-0.0016005392,
-0.0334779248,
0.0192588661,
0.0003778273,
0.0055955825,
0.0111379316,
-0.0069645694,
-0.0084118601,
-0.0129866367,
-0.0316902436,
0.009263318,
0.0153340306,
0.0056284168,
0.0471444838,
-0.0423971489,
0.0308511406,
0.0284130927,
0.0210456066,
0.0216473583,
-0.0492624976,
-0.0157696381,
-0.0169692598,
0.004265307,
0.0241512749,
-0.0403779596,
0.0015877947,
0.0101318713,
-0.036790926,
-0.0424124561,
0.0572576858,
-0.0341706425,
-0.0240488499,
-0.0392996371,
-0.026298726,
-0.0161974616,
-0.0253243167,
-0.0145641351,
-0.0015094354,
0.0038134833,
0.0200271476,
0.0551718622,
-0.0739463344,
-0.0209139455,
-0.0125367576,
-0.0259693023,
-0.0090954527,
0.031951271,
-0.0176319797,
0.0030920266,
-0.0569035597,
0.0086342571,
0.0343351625,
-0.0165645443,
0.0623703562,
-0.0055754613,
0.0191639457,
0.0592116155,
0.0468452089,
0.0051770043,
-0.0357905515,
-0.0378206931,
0.0336839519,
0.0334208943,
0.0050603785,
0.0347398669,
0.0140329851,
-0.0122242691,
-0.0546080768,
-0.0028691664,
0.0286043212,
0.0580664538,
0.0576123744,
-0.0067480435,
-0.0446258374,
-0.0015021905,
-0.0524574034,
-0.0108223669,
-0.041031912,
-0.0280850623,
0.0339753367,
0.0101958225,
-0.0006283131,
-0.0700780526,
0.0341941454,
-0.0084697166,
0.0307271108,
-0.0089517524,
-0.0289728418,
0.027991727,
-0.0189832207,
0.0224638786,
-0.0703169033,
-0.0187631343,
-0.0074155265,
0.0161573924,
0.0126159796,
0.0164052229,
0.0154328886,
0.0147189228,
-0.0386948436,
-0.0099426834,
-0.0613376647,
0.0385916308,
-0.0046835109,
-0.035670884,
0.0280172024,
0.0180386193,
-0.006443325,
-0.0076145669,
-0.0278799944,
-0.0651021674,
-0.0373050049,
0.0159898624,
-0.0290602203,
-0.010634738,
-0.0326966941,
0.0023484456,
-0.015077238,
0.0215047784,
0.0307312682,
-0.0404004976,
-0.0251807179,
0.0087452307,
3.211e-7,
-0.023766268,
0.0597273931,
-0.0157938302,
0.006936064,
0.0025939555,
0.0758743659,
-0.0332318954,
0.0018352531,
0.054773394,
-0.0537208095,
-0.0031467478,
0.0613738522,
0.0312096775,
0.0169941634,
-0.0634665564,
-0.0080815004,
0.0071266848,
-0.0384268276,
-0.0451330207,
0.0191889387,
0.0275596753,
0.0407391749,
0.0366843678,
-0.0340721942,
0.0382702351,
0.005381451,
0.053127367,
-0.0481318943,
0.0096720047,
-0.0354298986,
-0.0106039969,
-0.0021344726,
0.0108080627,
0.0539558455,
0.0467591323,
0.016623741,
-0.0548645519,
0.0087655857,
-0.0081905238,
-0.0332918763,
-0.0226770937,
-0.0021067879,
-0.0054836003,
-0.0794683248,
0.0639772266,
-0.0730578825,
-0.0688365325,
0.0350360759,
0.0230907705,
-0.0379097462,
0.0002071753,
0.0039061254,
-0.0184950773,
0.0114809992,
-0.0084525235,
0.0006436522,
0.0016111854,
-0.0712482482,
0.0294252504,
-0.0124662863,
-0.0083770147,
-0.0652890354,
-0.0606826171,
0.0038445708,
0.0243147723,
-0.0535308048,
-0.0093694255,
2.801422984e-34,
0.0243341345,
-0.0228111409,
0.0531680174,
0.0013772465,
0.0422335006,
0.012768561,
-0.0031161632,
-0.0127733061,
0.0427061468,
-0.0925896987,
-0.0221541319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11485v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11485v1 | Understanding Lexical Biases when Identifying Gang-related Social Media Communications | 2023-04-22T21:51:49 | 2023-04-22T21:51:49 | Dhiraj Murthy, Constantine Caramanis, Koustav Rudra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, J.4; K.4.2; I.2.7 | Individuals involved in gang-related activity use mainstream social media
including Facebook and Twitter to express taunts and threats as well as grief
and memorializing. However, identifying the impact of gang-related activity in
order to serve community member needs through social media sources has a unique
set of challenges. This includes the difficulty of ethically identifying
training data of individuals impacted by gang activity and the need to account
for a non-standard language style commonly used in the tweets from these
individuals. Our study provides evidence of methods where natural language
processing tools can be helpful in efficiently identifying individuals who may
be in need of community care resources such as counselors, conflict mediators,
or academic/professional training programs. We demonstrate that our binary
logistic classifier outperforms baseline standards in identifying individuals
impacted by gang-related violence using a sample of gang-related tweets
associated with Chicago. We ultimately found that the language of a tweet is
highly relevant and that uses of ``big data'' methods or machine learning
models need to better understand how language impacts the model's performance
and how it discriminates among populations. | [
0.0762013644,
0.0951627418,
-0.0070497682,
0.018742878,
-0.065891549,
0.0333316736,
0.0241834279,
-0.0014373442,
0.0251078326,
-0.0323711894,
0.0369350649,
-0.0073123504,
-0.004263429,
0.0038125487,
-0.0142999133,
-0.0301942937,
0.0215065833,
0.0612828285,
0.0555078574,
0.0065559205,
0.0466030389,
0.0730840787,
0.005098138,
0.0541745946,
-0.0332352258,
-0.0029673264,
0.0139341224,
-0.0128679508,
0.0133015579,
0.0167404842,
0.0174699407,
0.0574746877,
-0.0381439216,
0.0229151994,
0.0000014727,
-0.0581051856,
-0.0059370007,
-0.0282115713,
-0.0140373632,
-0.0662944391,
0.0750995055,
-0.098166801,
0.0091472641,
0.0289694201,
-0.0485432856,
-0.0274143256,
0.0886281654,
0.0181535818,
0.0102269808,
0.0340447947,
-0.0137276007,
-0.0652318671,
-0.0019103358,
0.013331838,
-0.0285126027,
0.0285570752,
0.0255871229,
-0.0339733064,
0.006794774,
-0.0234035086,
0.0166323222,
0.0307786204,
-0.0180976707,
0.0060616434,
0.0324840881,
-0.0081912763,
-0.0583369099,
-0.0049112355,
0.0357773677,
0.0178793147,
-0.0312341582,
-0.0043672095,
0.041313149,
0.0259972811,
-0.0101124896,
0.0223927964,
-0.008865945,
0.0028461919,
-0.0268558487,
0.0252143424,
-0.0196468309,
0.0351496786,
0.0246680584,
0.0632960647,
0.0152630061,
0.0216554385,
-0.0235624313,
-0.0081274444,
-0.00006934,
0.0254645348,
-0.0045590745,
-0.0205837712,
0.041099593,
-0.0067892703,
-0.0452677161,
0.0081203086,
-0.0141167976,
-0.0289494377,
0.0111319115,
-0.0494645312,
-0.0085944925,
-0.0068122116,
-0.004022229,
-0.0065162363,
0.0560172722,
-0.0576149039,
0.0427686237,
0.0222057477,
0.0205057319,
-0.0019358677,
-0.086830236,
0.0131796645,
0.0002896331,
0.0178879444,
0.028601326,
0.0243211556,
-0.0569102839,
-0.0054190606,
-0.0104348315,
-0.0310268831,
-0.0138189336,
0.0000461054,
-0.0098080887,
0.0301519632,
0.0012874708,
-0.0060420516,
-0.0345767476,
-0.0022978697,
-0.050244201,
-0.0198657587,
0.0530098639,
-0.0022725966,
0.0355837047,
-0.0196072981,
-0.0053510345,
0.0609232821,
0.0008357838,
-0.0352127552,
-0.0784692243,
-0.0167229045,
-0.0367072076,
-0.0246329848,
-0.0119930562,
-0.0430194438,
0.0265907627,
0.0410152599,
-0.0070435931,
-0.0025937727,
0.0198840741,
0.0106167868,
-0.0785778537,
0.078929089,
-0.0101836426,
0.0421447568,
0.0454731882,
0.001475913,
0.0538233444,
0.0297062397,
0.0228330884,
0.0041060247,
0.0490225106,
-0.0415383019,
-0.0344613492,
0.006743168,
-0.0260977671,
-0.0406404659,
0.0024493139,
0.0039974093,
-0.012532087,
-0.0273740049,
-0.0082068434,
0.0484781116,
0.0307094306,
-0.0118771913,
0.0484403335,
0.0828876197,
0.0008079628,
0.0144673632,
0.0236233994,
0.0732218027,
-0.0315245725,
-0.0539091416,
-0.0510503948,
-0.0509519391,
-0.0128185144,
-0.0387745574,
0.0135101546,
0.027801279,
-0.0139304539,
-0.0035559363,
-0.0421032943,
0.0029546637,
0.0372691825,
-0.0478150211,
0.0084947534,
-0.0113531193,
-0.0200215075,
-0.0235742386,
0.0623589344,
0.0079232994,
-0.0006096442,
-0.0511864536,
-0.0134477383,
0.0785622969,
0.0192646682,
0.0256501492,
-0.0013418595,
-0.0410343111,
0.0159639418,
0.044826068,
-0.0377766006,
0.0238421317,
-0.0051272563,
-0.020738354,
0.0134318545,
0.0613432527,
0.0008535455,
-0.017992897,
0.0466408096,
0.0063301078,
0.0106371064,
0.0204248894,
-0.0854569003,
0.045096375,
0.0417509899,
-0.027303366,
0.0095774168,
0.0084583024,
0.0248753037,
0.0054323818,
-0.0186952148,
-0.0296137705,
-0.0414927602,
0.0020197572,
0.00056477,
-0.0169657953,
-0.0238408856,
0.0132061467,
0.0219628029,
-0.0224836376,
-0.0111721931,
0.0449413061,
-0.0007224524,
-0.0063241348,
0.0882364586,
-0.0549168512,
0.0017752626,
-0.0273997299,
-0.0186098274,
-0.0416895635,
0.0056943842,
-0.0080733746,
0.0565020256,
-0.0184070785,
-0.0247286353,
-0.0358605087,
-0.0643301606,
0.0056279777,
0.0349847935,
-0.011592852,
0.0015114659,
-0.0388377607,
0.0460037813,
-0.0005098052,
0.0087155867,
-0.0073115919,
0.0004805461,
-0.0527332574,
0.0321920589,
-0.0518945456,
-0.0339403152,
0.0018833361,
0.0308192652,
-0.0197670124,
-0.0135501521,
0.0175840501,
-0.0282764826,
0.0530300885,
0.0176527426,
-0.0178300273,
-0.0223261621,
0.0105768144,
-0.0255718064,
-0.0238195322,
-0.0324305519,
0.0475229993,
0.0109571535,
-0.097924538,
0.0479835868,
-0.0029687705,
-0.0523984879,
-0.0121418675,
0.0057177651,
-0.0306007545,
0.0468961373,
0.0096261688,
0.0128561081,
-0.0061655426,
0.0576638766,
0.0678606033,
0.0308676921,
0.0184192434,
0.0259383526,
-0.0180408899,
-0.0516409762,
-0.0679590851,
-0.0246339217,
-0.0635807514,
-0.019274734,
0.0509785004,
0.0418248028,
-0.0203746166,
-0.0236530118,
-0.0237436071,
-0.0418307967,
-0.0023949814,
-0.0446033105,
-0.0361569934,
-0.0127338469,
-0.0260125678,
-0.0178074744,
-0.0556633808,
0.0062159561,
0.0474493913,
0.046710562,
0.0109660309,
-0.082858488,
-0.0232688468,
0.0212497078,
0.0358327813,
0.0330407172,
0.0045512542,
-0.0612027422,
0.0711401328,
-0.0150237111,
0.0020608087,
-0.0419690199,
-0.0121900691,
-0.0189292952,
0.0297653675,
0.0379859731,
-0.0206693597,
-0.0445972122,
-0.0591982156,
-0.026687555,
-0.0066593289,
0.0136733502,
-0.0221081302,
-0.0009915525,
0.0108894501,
-0.0026314212,
-0.0314993225,
-0.0050912937,
-0.0303889904,
-0.0239995811,
-0.0065950369,
0.0098150512,
-0.0681121871,
-0.002080793,
0.0123495515,
-0.0389887728,
0.0149123939,
-0.0113558276,
0.0051796609,
-0.0297797062,
-0.0011747599,
0.0216183569,
-0.020091109,
-0.0064248,
0.0137588978,
0.022280883,
0.0202634744,
0.0062697465,
0.0827094764,
0.0505052842,
-0.0244461782,
0.0373249687,
0.004489379,
-0.0061049797,
0.0096964343,
-0.0065159919,
-0.0541977808,
0.0013424346,
-0.0144441007,
0.0678445473,
-0.065156728,
-0.0756372958,
0.0080739651,
-0.0515886806,
0.059946347,
-0.0122400438,
-0.0063015665,
-0.0328704938,
-0.0241445601,
0.0161054544,
-0.034409076,
0.0268555433,
-0.0169548448,
-0.0440962389,
-0.002962145,
0.009373649,
-0.0892701,
-0.0487932265,
-0.0037619665,
-0.0365677811,
0.0169746093,
0.029596366,
0.04871637,
-0.0215633027,
0.0531589687,
-0.0072790962,
0.0342596434,
0.0083285579,
-0.0063119051,
0.0630027726,
-0.0162442438,
-0.0140794627,
-0.071698308,
0.0303066485,
-0.0183885116,
-0.01155796,
0.018137116,
0.0359052159,
-0.0284753479,
-0.0167450011,
-0.0301774424,
0.0442342535,
0.0380745083,
0.0332678854,
0.0307311527,
-0.012758146,
0.015285993,
-0.0468207635,
-0.0027196482,
-0.0004145924,
-0.0885977224,
-0.0187624935,
-0.0376867019,
-0.0156712011,
0.0163004547,
-0.0443336368,
0.0432914607,
-0.011195926,
-0.0173093602,
-0.0402780622,
0.0317482837,
-0.0270350669,
-0.0641233772,
0.0148447724,
-0.0145860463,
0.0384530276,
0.02918786,
-0.0105526596,
-0.0271976423,
0.0422019176,
0.016138982,
0.0593587123,
-0.0462727956,
-0.0186029933,
0.0542438775,
-0.0493392721,
0.0164869744,
-0.0056124558,
-0.0004987102,
-0.0483317152,
-0.0024530969,
0.061325632,
0.0038849842,
-0.0148804942,
-0.0060203569,
0.0060452297,
0.0085359244,
0.018824134,
0.0240011662,
0.0546614714,
0.0342945978,
-0.0302060265,
-0.1206620261,
0.0438866913,
-0.0341549292,
-0.0117705567,
0.0586199872,
-0.0139823416,
-0.0657762736,
-0.0299321432,
-0.0633214563,
-0.0082554864,
-0.0324416086,
0.0189705957,
-0.0135595398,
0.0518349782,
0.056524422,
-0.0837019533,
-0.0219670869,
-0.0618116334,
0.0449385643,
-0.0788971633,
0.0362999067,
0.0103234444,
0.0062516723,
0.0314836428,
-0.0285452008,
0.0105504813,
0.0277502444,
0.0177398529,
0.0225567389,
0.0239277855,
-0.0080415662,
-0.0246304981,
0.054251641,
-0.0149571905,
-0.0188600104,
-0.0185026694,
-0.0408698767,
-0.0250977874,
0.0214978959,
-0.0025328943,
-0.0519566424,
0.0055142334,
0.0044347858,
0.0033394455,
0.004167581,
0.0438828096,
-0.0011027269,
-0.0704899803,
0.0170153715,
0.0245072357,
-0.0555600077,
0.0442904048,
0.0259492546,
-0.0122996205,
-0.0064936201,
0.0356548801,
-0.0665190816,
-0.0033531219,
-0.003102808,
0.0249775201,
0.0643693432,
0.0235684253,
0.0211781524,
-0.0430167839,
-0.0383016877,
0.0158360489,
-0.077870436,
0.0188937169,
0.0042863972,
-0.0143741313,
0.013229535,
0.0228002984,
-0.0036370305,
-0.048816327,
0.0315466337,
-0.0220354777,
-0.0471137315,
0.0302309915,
-5.163794604e-33,
0.0218564831,
-0.0917280018,
-0.0378814675,
-0.0261060465,
-0.0008280067,
0.0120184217,
0.0222611576,
0.0034194335,
-0.0083119888,
-0.0002852622,
0.0059645032,
0.0270196144,
0.0139272707,
0.0264309086,
0.0233731959,
-0.0193496998,
-0.0307173822,
0.0007885842,
0.0170249902,
0.0181601252,
0.0292381849,
0.0400693864,
0.0405831933,
-0.1070262939,
0.0851325691,
-0.0078153387,
-0.0093604857,
0.0203198809,
0.0606869273,
0.0173343718,
-0.0482918024,
0.0791444778,
0.0276527237,
-0.0268697497,
0.031765651,
0.0718107224,
-0.0178029612,
-0.001381074,
0.0354971327,
-0.0107395444,
-0.0250824951,
-0.0053754756,
-0.000288252,
-0.0008008713,
-0.0183938053,
-0.0185512286,
0.0475764088,
-0.0159100797,
0.0356524661,
-0.0164054502,
-0.0550295785,
0.0415887833,
-0.0546118915,
0.0303322654,
-0.0458185412,
-0.0180493239,
-0.0152754644,
0.0441314317,
-0.0534627922,
-0.02610901,
-0.0035416114,
0.0006873077,
0.0072303317,
-0.0014869709,
-0.0650230944,
0.0337646119,
-0.0088900821,
-0.0292340294,
-0.0002609186,
0.0220013522,
0.0328972787,
0.0497377776,
0.0470467769,
0.0559424572,
0.0422773026,
-0.0331962891,
-0.0637169555,
-0.036196433,
0.0599688217,
-0.0062897936,
0.0160177946,
-0.0107191773,
-0.0614198446,
-0.0383979492,
0.0055374689,
-0.0817551985,
0.003440252,
-0.0156357922,
-0.0137153408,
-0.0198143944,
-0.0140295913,
0.090110071,
0.0298543125,
-0.009969309,
-0.0032877519,
0.0507364497,
-0.0313227475,
0.0485026054,
-0.0057953778,
0.0369125567,
-0.0674538761,
0.0276242904,
0.0173208863,
-0.030010771,
0.0387041569,
-0.019239923,
0.07079909,
0.0117521239,
-0.0479805209,
0.0065336302,
0.0409085229,
0.0647103861,
-0.0341820419,
-0.0086681806,
0.0427884236,
0.025950253,
0.0082139215,
-0.0221389625,
0.0476026945,
-0.0132007254,
0.0350922793,
0.0057311109,
-0.0581077896,
-0.0219828151,
-0.0043895836,
-0.0042533875,
0.0058893147,
0.0233970806,
0.011162986,
-0.022999391,
-0.008310724,
-0.0517012365,
2.188e-7,
0.0768500715,
0.0776493028,
-0.0342043564,
0.0298035238,
-0.0109057715,
-0.004880019,
0.0908254534,
0.049266398,
0.0094111487,
-0.0412163772,
0.0300460253,
0.0649063215,
0.0390251502,
0.0622865856,
-0.0447851047,
0.0219844002,
-0.0499679297,
-0.0337071344,
-0.0943763033,
0.0079104649,
0.0136944,
0.0635460392,
0.0494214594,
-0.0208584629,
-0.0309616458,
-0.0458742119,
-0.0137070511,
-0.0428302176,
-0.0317767821,
0.01218375,
0.0688357949,
-0.0022162267,
-0.0153110111,
0.0322408304,
-0.0162219778,
0.023956215,
0.0203270894,
0.0227659307,
-0.0374461152,
0.0382623114,
-0.0078502018,
-0.0327201448,
0.0005938382,
-0.013146162,
0.0868038088,
-0.0061430074,
-0.0395782776,
-0.0552106686,
-0.0063720266,
-0.0176654924,
0.0222759023,
-0.0119384527,
-0.0370806456,
0.0252381656,
0.0299269315,
-0.0347817354,
-0.0172780994,
-0.0488639735,
0.0264333598,
0.0428153425,
0.0001352518,
0.00444355,
0.0469735302,
0.0186613631,
0.0526287556,
0.0058513721,
0.0638211444,
1.556728521e-34,
-0.0112405187,
0.0561169609,
0.0384278707,
-0.0161280204,
0.0384098813,
0.0527682304,
-0.0528713726,
-0.0146534294,
-0.0016116931,
-0.0458098799,
0.0427993797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11473v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11473v2 | (Vector) Space is Not the Final Frontier: Product Search as Program Synthesis | 2023-04-22T20:00:06 | 2023-06-11T17:35:02 | Jacopo Tagliabue, Ciro Greco | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | As ecommerce continues growing, huge investments in ML and NLP for
Information Retrieval are following. While the vector space model dominated
retrieval modelling in product search - even as vectorization itself greatly
changed with the advent of deep learning -, our position paper argues in a
contrarian fashion that program synthesis provides significant advantages for
many queries and a significant number of players in the market. We detail the
industry significance of the proposed approach, sketch implementation details,
and address common objections drawing from our experience building a similar
system at Tooso. | [
0.0333199576,
0.0544480532,
-0.0372781083,
-0.0018120456,
0.0269334707,
-0.0220299289,
0.015066281,
0.014966622,
-0.0537020639,
-0.0393472649,
-0.0044030123,
0.0160128865,
-0.0302637089,
0.0787432343,
-0.0104061076,
-0.0079960339,
0.0125744594,
0.0488698892,
-0.0564567074,
0.0238655098,
0.015041274,
0.0351658389,
0.0058031287,
0.0524725616,
0.0684195384,
0.0140770376,
-0.022398714,
-0.0177888144,
-0.0434655324,
-0.0020145979,
0.0124601191,
-0.0207550414,
0.0268556587,
0.0219653416,
0.0000018214,
-0.0472446568,
-0.05734054,
-0.0336158872,
-0.0470519178,
-0.0039129043,
0.0217881128,
0.0225031395,
0.0532219075,
-0.0006759032,
-0.0306740589,
-0.0546728261,
0.0318891555,
0.0295727216,
0.0105513241,
0.0381825007,
-0.0137735801,
-0.0603293292,
0.0195715688,
0.0143956915,
-0.0016717452,
-0.0342385322,
0.0050508366,
-0.0411625393,
0.065304473,
0.0275485814,
0.0266677495,
0.0674015731,
-0.0200314652,
0.000383659,
0.0502290726,
0.0090448773,
-0.0238956865,
0.0079785921,
-0.0039526676,
0.0454178378,
-0.0454048328,
-0.0294203106,
0.0218927506,
-0.0019543795,
-0.0015410944,
-0.0456035733,
-0.0122555019,
0.011757439,
0.0072260569,
0.0012446337,
-0.0193234179,
-0.0022835117,
0.0104255248,
-0.0209217072,
-0.0073650754,
0.0618933626,
0.0078893788,
-0.0284933858,
-0.0238969028,
-0.0356066376,
-0.0156329274,
-0.0103784986,
0.0205565169,
0.0001998172,
-0.0560355,
-0.0148974247,
0.0189793315,
0.016584469,
-0.0098390291,
-0.0682091117,
0.0461037345,
0.0088331746,
0.0359477252,
0.0179389343,
0.015689807,
0.0531016812,
-0.0196556151,
-0.0285568424,
-0.1071276888,
0.0002515601,
-0.0629456565,
-0.0446665958,
-0.0472430736,
0.0614780746,
-0.036958009,
-0.0033519184,
-0.0447717048,
0.02860309,
-0.0106420247,
-0.029204702,
-0.0306126252,
0.0302372035,
0.0116210347,
0.0188053735,
-0.0608588308,
-0.0350752361,
-0.022478411,
-0.0182832517,
-0.0273488145,
-0.0065551456,
0.0485360771,
0.04197862,
-0.0090447385,
-0.0327851102,
0.0172949359,
0.0013214273,
-0.0061367783,
-0.0138232987,
-0.0553313978,
-0.0615081973,
0.0134787168,
0.0052013341,
0.0141092865,
-0.0472626463,
0.0186395422,
-0.0094699496,
-0.0305754803,
-0.0013636926,
-0.0373089425,
0.025416173,
-0.013323117,
0.0547100455,
0.0157426745,
0.0146520482,
-0.0006774681,
-0.036531657,
0.0944825187,
0.0123332478,
-0.0285663214,
0.0160119757,
0.0397214554,
0.0311519746,
0.0275260713,
0.0179044157,
-0.034131173,
-0.0589653105,
-0.0282208025,
0.048701074,
-0.0259923916,
0.0488840193,
0.0068916501,
0.00093726,
-0.0267114639,
0.0035147036,
0.009569631,
0.0399201959,
0.0597470775,
0.0335182659,
0.0478709266,
0.0230068937,
-0.0390798859,
-0.0750779361,
0.0291577801,
-0.0039779558,
-0.0420805402,
-0.0095981611,
-0.0295115057,
-0.0511392988,
-0.0387942716,
-0.0321316533,
0.0114321103,
0.0063285627,
0.0055846712,
0.0262157619,
0.0091617508,
-0.0277075917,
0.0098644933,
0.0259529967,
-0.0304887295,
-0.0392095856,
-0.0158947278,
-0.0294145644,
0.0229307637,
0.1025950238,
0.0471851639,
-0.0344099887,
0.036834415,
0.0358223729,
-0.0336780027,
0.0523720868,
0.0664961934,
-0.028934326,
0.0054548541,
-0.0326966681,
0.0023953414,
-0.0323311314,
0.0121848602,
0.0016478646,
-0.0265243631,
-0.0024048015,
-0.0012469422,
0.0012975911,
0.0253912006,
0.0247610677,
0.0078929449,
-0.0504635759,
0.0045625642,
0.0497338884,
0.0003069253,
0.0456571691,
0.0151670743,
0.0149186179,
0.0395327732,
-0.0429616757,
-0.0855529234,
-0.0355323218,
0.0501113161,
0.0170710068,
0.0239836629,
-0.0294202901,
0.0229873043,
-0.0119684152,
0.0038173997,
-0.0044655777,
0.008271304,
-0.0258849598,
0.0281953458,
0.0070940359,
0.0284121688,
-0.0250022151,
0.0206252206,
-0.0451297797,
0.0277288184,
0.0406510681,
0.0407142267,
0.0335068591,
-0.0085198097,
0.0404702313,
-0.028231835,
-0.0007787289,
0.0537162721,
-0.0123727778,
0.0551481806,
0.0343315192,
0.0041826917,
0.0052369786,
0.0337733626,
-0.0366768353,
0.0473299287,
0.0222682208,
0.0117035415,
-0.0160675459,
0.0288973879,
0.0237396117,
0.0199071188,
-0.0246916059,
0.017791139,
-0.0162542704,
0.0104084732,
0.0443124957,
0.0542356782,
-0.0575108379,
-0.0026639807,
-0.0439203456,
0.0068614772,
0.0402025357,
-0.01465334,
-0.0031579752,
-0.0691988543,
0.0220077131,
-0.0494138598,
0.0180648714,
0.0055699944,
0.0312705897,
-0.0263843387,
-0.0723316595,
-0.018767355,
0.0322309025,
0.0126675563,
-0.0442392081,
0.035120938,
-0.0265254173,
-0.0696863309,
0.0029608288,
-0.0378604345,
-0.0250697602,
0.0385394841,
0.0220998358,
0.0574191958,
-0.0144883441,
-0.0688950196,
-0.0047917082,
-0.0297687408,
0.0312743597,
0.0410822555,
-0.0295501035,
-0.0633027628,
-0.0039723269,
0.0059987344,
0.0837823004,
0.0037111973,
-0.0486184172,
0.0513158441,
0.0318098441,
-0.0105995648,
-0.0531670824,
-0.035520006,
-0.0525418445,
0.0163240228,
-0.0047842865,
0.0099543259,
-0.0471483916,
-0.0218565539,
-0.0126426332,
0.0579550155,
-0.0047254763,
-0.0340941735,
0.0908293799,
-0.0020474757,
0.0338504687,
-0.0160307847,
-0.0601421893,
-0.0448379964,
-0.0108150262,
0.0168585628,
0.0099136066,
0.0749443248,
0.0143872406,
-0.0546864085,
0.0473320857,
-0.0097788097,
0.0141100539,
0.0491294228,
-0.0666254908,
-0.0096457666,
-0.0229271743,
0.0013794897,
-0.0348173529,
-0.0238304809,
0.0548626184,
-0.0394524373,
0.0040092962,
0.0503399037,
-0.0496648923,
-0.013500493,
0.0139085921,
0.0436327867,
-0.0485428795,
-0.0246656779,
0.037832465,
-0.0843236744,
-0.0215166435,
0.0027941321,
0.0489425696,
0.0212017167,
-0.0164290164,
0.0080446508,
0.0725191385,
-0.0021860609,
0.0581266135,
0.05887058,
-0.0457148701,
0.0125075215,
-0.0081804488,
0.0752915367,
-0.0087015871,
-0.0090456987,
-0.0287110917,
-0.1026295722,
0.0026586163,
-0.0308344588,
-0.0318939388,
-0.0761851892,
-0.0409610011,
-0.039085947,
-0.032202974,
0.0259021968,
0.0345463641,
-0.0598278195,
-0.0276159476,
0.0025866521,
-0.019427564,
-0.0002071527,
0.0066382708,
-0.0235573817,
-0.0310051702,
0.0312635563,
0.0510762334,
0.0135698849,
-0.0295172539,
-0.0382363461,
-0.0369149037,
-0.011255553,
-0.0272375047,
0.0265923813,
-0.0039004968,
-0.0014618188,
0.0325278156,
-0.0184352789,
-0.0278224312,
0.0140029527,
-0.0133016938,
0.0253431462,
-0.0051374743,
-0.0161952134,
-0.0601770468,
-0.0372962877,
-0.0497365445,
0.0255180635,
-0.028868556,
-0.0166381169,
-0.0346578918,
-0.0572299697,
-0.0167544708,
-0.0109975217,
-0.0704242885,
0.0178864654,
-0.0224043597,
-0.0152932396,
-0.0355318822,
-0.0112891905,
0.0096769799,
0.0379653163,
-0.0193341468,
-0.0194998439,
-0.0068777516,
0.0123374434,
-0.0633533746,
-0.0045002475,
-0.009283063,
0.0431964472,
0.0127716577,
0.0857201293,
0.0136815971,
-0.0400523767,
-0.0329740345,
-0.0026887727,
0.0218610279,
-0.0625312179,
-0.0068912758,
0.0461350307,
0.0242681913,
-0.0095035918,
0.0056023053,
-0.0477661341,
0.0014977112,
0.1254800856,
0.0208589975,
-0.0327965766,
-0.0042905076,
0.0034116628,
-0.0149956336,
0.0181653202,
-0.0501887016,
-0.0023115885,
-0.0017031052,
0.0452253856,
0.0767865032,
-0.0361463539,
0.0762000903,
0.0357135087,
0.0259146746,
0.0401376635,
0.0407056026,
-0.0229375716,
0.0334439166,
0.0131271649,
-0.0318012498,
-0.026266057,
0.0027131427,
-0.0288869273,
0.009733242,
0.013205599,
0.0396966934,
0.002543685,
0.0327672027,
-0.0107940333,
0.0139693506,
-0.0217888206,
0.0038037775,
0.021962164,
-0.011641359,
-0.0176781993,
0.0339414552,
0.0041670185,
0.0545828454,
-0.0303967446,
0.0072853127,
0.0399261899,
0.0208753981,
-0.0690599903,
-0.0037935982,
-0.0335904695,
-0.1147606969,
-0.0436549447,
-0.0194346886,
0.0145324552,
-0.0209096037,
-0.0083204107,
-0.0480443127,
-0.0386798568,
-0.0186389498,
-0.013401323,
0.0116673131,
0.0049911956,
-0.0249590818,
0.0367958583,
-0.0282547344,
-0.0490737222,
0.0519623049,
-0.0011848036,
0.0377381966,
-0.0511222519,
-0.0395513028,
-0.0609110482,
-0.0371243171,
0.0609891377,
0.0518000685,
-0.0317480192,
-0.0387681089,
-0.0526490398,
-0.0227626488,
-0.0052573648,
0.0173377022,
0.0361464135,
0.007801109,
0.0667717978,
0.1106231138,
0.0550984889,
0.0077124895,
0.0026836423,
0.0218677092,
-0.0872419327,
-0.0030308855,
-0.0139459437,
-5.350821632e-33,
0.0467473827,
-0.0156052541,
0.0022950855,
0.0025699902,
0.0013683246,
-0.0336019211,
0.0149721736,
0.0093741575,
0.002935587,
-0.0293754358,
-0.0144526409,
-0.0085172122,
0.0076227654,
0.0026037516,
0.0460175946,
-0.022167515,
0.0241566245,
0.0055944715,
-0.0117645562,
-0.0012103299,
0.0053950264,
0.0217630807,
0.0090302182,
-0.0265050828,
-0.0078971758,
-0.0141898068,
0.0208025202,
0.0744446293,
0.0159575678,
0.0946791768,
0.0008169318,
0.0514363684,
0.0107844584,
-0.0384644121,
0.005674053,
-0.0031524184,
-0.0241604391,
0.0158394575,
0.0154167833,
-0.0226256941,
0.0097612636,
0.011266836,
0.065284051,
0.0140823331,
-0.0207151882,
0.0819487348,
0.0488836914,
-0.0296237469,
-0.039276056,
-0.0925219581,
-0.0359834805,
-0.031896349,
-0.0233747941,
0.0283493269,
0.1055701375,
0.0345972516,
0.0016345844,
0.0272203088,
-0.0208029728,
0.0725125,
-0.0923567116,
0.0261333287,
0.054793153,
0.0280662142,
0.0032707781,
0.0090720551,
0.0465628766,
0.0016767153,
0.0365605131,
0.0194434468,
0.0071750958,
0.074176155,
0.0359900631,
0.0268199351,
0.0398942791,
0.0269783139,
-0.0160715878,
0.0302741881,
-0.0051695835,
-0.0263407007,
0.0060104402,
0.0630464926,
-0.0579510704,
-0.047719311,
0.0132265249,
-0.0146372253,
-0.0730522424,
0.0245170835,
0.0349099599,
0.0445586853,
-0.0334680118,
0.03063225,
0.0213150308,
-0.0650884882,
-0.0804061145,
0.0009052546,
-0.0122004822,
-0.0150295673,
0.0207289234,
-0.0180341043,
-0.0225024074,
-0.0250710715,
-0.0177256055,
-0.018319346,
-0.0193822645,
-0.0126448758,
0.0066764387,
0.0041593136,
-0.0434090495,
0.0235713851,
0.0122635663,
-0.0126307532,
-0.0386829935,
-0.0024127518,
0.0118601611,
0.0245707091,
0.017244732,
0.0326630771,
0.0392057151,
-0.0006204778,
-0.0283667408,
-0.0592701174,
0.0307510663,
-0.0370913967,
-0.0010157573,
0.0293423831,
-0.0299783181,
0.0700476617,
0.0516121536,
-0.0942353457,
-0.0384635553,
0.0226020217,
2.506e-7,
0.0539508834,
0.0343324579,
0.0049245171,
0.0654901788,
-0.0166638047,
0.0356878377,
0.0429457612,
0.048134692,
-0.0002557689,
0.0085586337,
0.0367674567,
-0.0170233659,
0.0250643305,
-0.0166333579,
-0.0660923496,
-0.0017827938,
-0.0112162335,
-0.0326664746,
-0.084484905,
-0.0311965477,
0.0443625748,
0.0708288178,
0.0197354648,
-0.024142405,
-0.0025809577,
-0.0391770452,
-0.008409909,
-0.0130558442,
0.0528578572,
0.0416319259,
0.0553069673,
0.0466143861,
-0.0351085104,
-0.0370088033,
0.005130399,
0.047019653,
0.0432232209,
0.0319271088,
0.0115523012,
-0.0242885929,
0.0093547273,
-0.0905910134,
-0.0106840022,
-0.0335933156,
0.0182581171,
-0.053017877,
0.036133673,
-0.0102570681,
-0.0163156819,
0.0192136262,
-0.0079391282,
-0.0366033018,
-0.009341687,
0.0374647006,
0.0043971045,
-0.0131589975,
0.0144352661,
-0.0590101592,
-0.0106473127,
0.0342419557,
-0.0280815922,
0.008920501,
-0.0141331404,
0.0570999645,
0.0486027226,
-0.0036839545,
0.0184144732,
2.274631849e-34,
0.0453771763,
0.0454838686,
0.0060660192,
-0.0142727494,
-0.0050205481,
-0.0102908751,
0.0200495031,
-0.012871,
-0.0046997359,
-0.0569684468,
-0.0475874022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11461v1 | Recurrent Neural Networks and Long Short-Term Memory Networks: Tutorial and Survey | 2023-04-22T18:22:10 | 2023-04-22T18:22:10 | Benyamin Ghojogh, Ali Ghodsi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE, cs.SD, eess.AS | This is a tutorial paper on Recurrent Neural Network (RNN), Long Short-Term
Memory Network (LSTM), and their variants. We start with a dynamical system and
backpropagation through time for RNN. Then, we discuss the problems of gradient
vanishing and explosion in long-term dependencies. We explain close-to-identity
weight matrix, long delays, leaky units, and echo state networks for solving
this problem. Then, we introduce LSTM gates and cells, history and variants of
LSTM, and Gated Recurrent Units (GRU). Finally, we introduce bidirectional RNN,
bidirectional LSTM, and the Embeddings from Language Model (ELMo) network, for
processing a sequence in both directions. | [
-0.0064582163,
-0.014928286,
-0.0280986745,
0.0695502162,
-0.0425778553,
-0.0257667881,
0.0191661194,
-0.0193481203,
0.0038563816,
-0.0149509935,
-0.0041471487,
-0.0736445934,
0.0177563131,
0.0475525931,
0.0270172898,
-0.0501007512,
0.0453978591,
0.0021703739,
-0.0517505184,
-0.0289590191,
-0.0101347091,
-0.024712339,
-0.0142466594,
0.0300571006,
0.0101386746,
-0.0129230125,
-0.0249843784,
0.0037004885,
-0.0143834492,
-0.0721538588,
0.021259211,
-0.0105493376,
0.0243987851,
0.0313553624,
0.0000021812,
-0.000347413,
0.0424651839,
-0.0318737365,
0.0055128546,
0.004287431,
0.010239535,
0.0297121089,
-0.0117157996,
0.0459871739,
-0.0304098446,
-0.0178266373,
0.0065986076,
0.0410502404,
0.0605145618,
0.0563878603,
0.0162637364,
-0.0574505888,
0.0288296696,
-0.0376517028,
0.0589751638,
-0.0246968381,
0.0392980687,
-0.0611039065,
-0.0029957329,
-0.0405082926,
-0.0507455394,
0.0415310226,
0.0389121473,
-0.0098029701,
0.0143988421,
0.036621701,
0.0658619404,
0.0277297553,
-0.0234060735,
0.0323042274,
-0.0331444554,
0.0031544596,
0.0269705746,
0.0121490844,
-0.041071061,
-0.0624866933,
-0.0258450154,
-0.0188040268,
0.0248081665,
0.0243367236,
-0.0241496153,
0.0158712007,
0.0355069526,
-0.000926083,
-0.02162599,
0.0423100032,
0.0085443761,
-0.0265203398,
-0.0519666411,
-0.069775939,
0.0380530469,
-0.0755480081,
0.037827827,
0.0916461796,
0.0291226786,
0.000120996,
-0.005905204,
-0.0653984547,
-0.01996723,
-0.0721133277,
0.0069397534,
0.0083030052,
0.011799043,
0.0203187484,
-0.0272064842,
0.0677010044,
-0.0458297208,
-0.0313194469,
-0.0091885859,
0.0292604677,
-0.0490177386,
-0.007208325,
-0.0074771727,
0.0645948872,
0.0166375861,
0.0080556571,
-0.0558810942,
-0.0058066919,
-0.0432032235,
-0.005506387,
0.0145933796,
0.0570426583,
-0.0257074609,
-0.0034972678,
-0.0456952937,
0.0364308394,
0.0045503816,
-0.0037523303,
-0.0313298106,
0.0187461115,
-0.0215729903,
0.0400604755,
0.023789268,
0.0073254877,
-0.0347443298,
0.0871436968,
0.0599776506,
-0.0041463529,
-0.0731969178,
0.0108213127,
0.0036700957,
-0.0561705641,
-0.0008350729,
-0.0434572883,
-0.019535061,
-0.0383312739,
-0.0011239207,
0.0044333371,
0.0154014835,
0.0119762886,
0.0297240205,
0.0650685504,
0.0212018322,
-0.0509415679,
0.0378955491,
0.0042729322,
0.0494237542,
0.0138262734,
0.0253500473,
0.0226720739,
-0.0129123395,
-0.0250945501,
0.034429457,
-0.0185184442,
0.0258010738,
-0.0326395594,
-0.0423668176,
-0.0568576977,
-0.0043163099,
0.0569734387,
-0.0030885274,
0.0685913041,
-0.0067405365,
-0.0215468127,
0.0582116581,
0.0272216853,
0.0362090282,
0.048842717,
0.0545899048,
-0.0034936664,
-0.0403146297,
0.0069119451,
0.0048367563,
0.0593334995,
0.0118817007,
0.0032817065,
-0.0227314215,
0.0153831458,
-0.0546730421,
-0.0294153616,
0.0295705535,
-0.0706130415,
0.0211105589,
-0.0393907391,
0.0399849266,
-0.0066322009,
-0.0740842745,
0.0148400972,
-0.0397178903,
0.0001169776,
0.0137190167,
-0.0282040853,
0.0361876599,
0.0305013675,
-0.0038733478,
-0.0119816223,
-0.0451869108,
-0.0413196459,
-0.0584573485,
0.0047421413,
-0.0139346952,
0.0188649073,
0.0079404041,
-0.0637318641,
0.0127524845,
0.0520584621,
-0.0136824166,
0.0400082506,
-0.072510995,
0.0768137276,
0.0162820965,
0.0295315348,
-0.0346012935,
0.0002475624,
-0.0528427884,
-0.0428792872,
0.0178218596,
0.018641606,
0.0352101214,
0.0268588774,
0.0371779688,
0.0135625908,
0.0493672714,
-0.0576946475,
-0.0733299032,
0.0176846553,
-0.0861289725,
-0.0194450468,
0.0557650626,
0.0010013218,
0.0350814424,
0.0328762084,
-0.0115746502,
-0.0954973698,
0.0807042047,
-0.0281830374,
0.0473981313,
-0.0390145257,
0.0164461788,
0.0295339674,
0.0240535103,
0.0058536474,
0.0300211217,
-0.0127260853,
0.0416644365,
-0.0144034214,
0.0518772863,
0.0214170311,
-0.0465399995,
-0.0671089962,
0.0253069475,
-0.0390035436,
-0.0054386915,
-0.0061015082,
-0.0092236735,
0.0087280627,
0.0045910352,
-0.0312828235,
-0.0014951896,
-0.0068949396,
0.0209267233,
-0.0085267369,
-0.0016727466,
0.0342070051,
-0.0239833072,
-0.0447615758,
0.0528960079,
-0.0222464055,
-0.0444399826,
0.0339543149,
0.0176316183,
-0.046375379,
-0.0037045914,
-0.0187524855,
0.002199562,
0.0294684879,
-0.0262730625,
-0.0426950492,
-0.029267827,
-0.0187221579,
-0.0063621309,
0.0540034622,
0.0021017573,
-0.056643717,
-0.0169331953,
0.0010192537,
0.0509677082,
0.032201454,
0.0541776605,
0.0249830447,
-0.0029868863,
-0.0085100057,
-0.0062800921,
0.025748739,
-0.0223179106,
0.0420516208,
0.0049519804,
0.0355442539,
-0.023685459,
0.0526940562,
0.0185882002,
-0.0039339745,
0.0013502872,
-0.0205253251,
-0.0005341092,
-0.0303382892,
0.0168219768,
-0.0436150506,
-0.0558437444,
-0.0238920618,
0.0062641473,
-0.0017810676,
0.0258302204,
-0.0117607135,
0.0126386043,
-0.0083241379,
-0.0295584425,
-0.0471802913,
0.0178009346,
0.0054160389,
0.0032162433,
-0.0058334768,
-0.0278655663,
0.0268491078,
-0.009168054,
-0.0242664386,
-0.0273733996,
-0.0288145095,
0.0125952633,
0.0119562931,
-0.023279028,
-0.0018469448,
-0.0275364853,
0.0175548065,
0.0159256794,
-0.0192722548,
-0.0189765878,
-0.0351996198,
0.0182227008,
0.0051280484,
0.0059826933,
0.0354226641,
-0.0112668043,
0.0390009806,
-0.0290121771,
0.0592269525,
0.0099156583,
-0.0020660846,
-0.0283944923,
0.0349139646,
0.064098388,
-0.0030424478,
0.0478040762,
0.0081370715,
-0.114825286,
0.0182322096,
-0.0129980939,
-0.0247370489,
0.0014948746,
0.0248852577,
-0.0498345904,
-0.0680277273,
-0.0047933669,
0.0609016977,
0.0042583589,
-0.0651608407,
-0.0098927068,
0.0049766265,
-0.0429864973,
0.0127807083,
-0.0160867069,
-0.0226175897,
0.0240493547,
-0.0288300812,
-0.0347891711,
-0.0095240362,
-0.0230325051,
-0.0086745434,
-0.0993234441,
0.0084426971,
-0.0144925546,
-0.0352516063,
-0.0775802881,
0.0124231381,
-0.0296446439,
0.0350431167,
0.009126585,
0.0206012242,
0.0052799797,
-0.0072435061,
0.0361471921,
-0.0492548794,
0.0023531166,
0.0216356404,
-0.0620423816,
0.0355690345,
0.0840003341,
0.0674328133,
-0.0528860316,
-0.0270547438,
0.0481606983,
-0.031715963,
0.0246245768,
-0.0020058323,
-0.0172739886,
0.0073436196,
-0.0178535674,
-0.0259728357,
0.0400203206,
-0.0424261689,
0.0155982897,
-0.0266391877,
0.064518474,
-0.0444475748,
-0.0353609994,
-0.0244344473,
-0.0180886183,
0.053994894,
0.0221760124,
0.0055941669,
-0.0457371213,
-0.0639308617,
0.0398403853,
-0.0022505198,
-0.048974935,
-0.0023841166,
-0.0338815562,
0.0194880124,
-0.0157043468,
-0.0841848478,
-0.0156073216,
-0.0131587591,
0.0292874295,
0.0156146567,
0.0582975447,
0.0525492951,
-0.0202062353,
-0.0166741852,
-0.035627827,
0.0031751411,
0.0195466746,
-0.0250445809,
0.0377559327,
0.0462095179,
-0.0204965305,
-0.0082380194,
-0.0086583896,
-0.1023488343,
-0.0276444275,
0.0211897828,
-0.0110931229,
0.0133451642,
0.0244471729,
-0.0055057034,
-0.0126129752,
0.0477143377,
0.0057473574,
0.0145131405,
0.0093429014,
0.0285560414,
0.0281650312,
0.0036558614,
0.0266982317,
0.0149969449,
0.0550474226,
0.0045532179,
-0.014974663,
-0.0148751531,
0.0003671209,
-0.0175498091,
-0.0040217019,
0.0479252823,
0.0378714986,
-0.0304424018,
-0.0204966217,
0.0610055141,
0.0072082821,
0.0341577195,
-0.017482968,
0.0233257636,
0.0200218782,
0.0005455195,
-0.0015722727,
-0.0723082051,
0.0918742418,
-0.0959087685,
0.0185216591,
0.0512701236,
0.0187500045,
0.023400344,
-0.0373249501,
0.0432907678,
-0.0083063999,
0.0252230037,
0.0044976673,
0.0099816564,
-0.0257023592,
0.0432521328,
0.01017763,
0.0370850898,
-0.0220177677,
-0.0086869821,
-0.0225327648,
-0.0396197625,
-0.0519027188,
0.0235987045,
0.0615485758,
0.0055016824,
-0.0304118525,
-0.0041178139,
0.0437905155,
-0.0156557709,
0.0636662617,
-0.0272974726,
0.0271527357,
0.0270735361,
0.0169604495,
-0.0198287237,
0.0700812265,
0.0565413199,
0.0408325009,
0.0421373509,
0.0350905545,
0.0347942002,
0.0033855003,
0.0321476534,
0.0273136515,
-0.004649647,
-0.0002064274,
0.0342932306,
0.0064936122,
-0.0649905801,
0.0863686129,
0.0210490637,
0.0657465085,
-0.0415398888,
0.0640948489,
-0.0221923273,
0.0318865925,
0.0567472577,
-0.0032539326,
0.044722937,
0.0028428189,
-0.0196281709,
-0.0509884208,
-6.727350496e-33,
-0.0202944484,
-0.0465341955,
0.0106213167,
0.018544022,
-0.0288714319,
0.0159018263,
-0.0412027314,
-0.0297336783,
-0.0230695717,
-0.0310872737,
-0.0254060514,
0.0645155683,
0.0077713788,
0.0375966579,
0.0501671508,
-0.0344937667,
0.019213466,
0.0072997841,
0.0631700158,
0.0225376245,
0.0700691566,
0.0686010569,
0.0494213849,
-0.0178237725,
0.0073571969,
-0.0317105055,
-0.0022244162,
0.0056181159,
-0.0366294459,
-0.0023181469,
-0.0785689428,
0.0222669318,
0.0221063085,
-0.0660084039,
-0.0165180117,
0.0227292422,
-0.0302902423,
-0.0636186227,
-0.026556991,
-0.0108600901,
-0.0676931888,
-0.0252739992,
0.0759646222,
0.0214393027,
-0.0408597961,
0.0380132347,
0.0115678972,
0.0078432653,
-0.0198366828,
-0.0111761941,
-0.0512142219,
0.0197113473,
-0.0265728924,
0.0024756149,
0.0397608094,
-0.0558503941,
-0.0309859831,
-0.0224822573,
-0.09659677,
-0.0239870306,
-0.0202407781,
0.0648189411,
0.0078296121,
0.0252589341,
0.0047807838,
0.02657363,
0.0415393561,
0.0065890322,
-0.0301188044,
0.0395477526,
0.0015939703,
0.0202260166,
0.0619288273,
-0.0233080592,
0.0934781134,
-0.0731755495,
-0.0445795804,
-0.0011135647,
0.037379723,
0.0818315968,
0.0403293595,
0.0176799465,
-0.0014835736,
0.000438929,
0.0003181801,
-0.0362976044,
-0.0469905958,
-0.0364795588,
0.0107862605,
-0.0051583759,
0.0035311123,
0.0206353571,
0.0020932558,
-0.0038498188,
0.0492051244,
-0.0198255554,
0.0561122298,
0.0040817535,
0.0269005522,
0.0221951492,
-0.0052059842,
-0.0055279154,
-0.0336687751,
0.0265074689,
0.0222794916,
0.0233350825,
-0.0033565308,
0.0586295798,
-0.0141961323,
-0.0351426005,
-0.0159501359,
-0.0180295669,
0.0183110647,
0.0427879356,
0.0385571681,
-0.0026708122,
-0.0245176535,
0.0609086156,
-0.0080422228,
0.0088522583,
-0.0321937539,
-0.0150050791,
0.015909154,
0.0177866966,
-0.0473789684,
-0.0573858917,
-0.0393116027,
0.0290332716,
-0.0171144456,
-0.0577538908,
-0.0185222309,
0.0294501223,
3.073e-7,
-0.0265111607,
0.000770188,
0.059947744,
0.0103057474,
0.0465209149,
0.0029902693,
-0.04418917,
0.0471361354,
-0.0092229005,
0.0031891533,
0.0292214528,
-0.0280884672,
-0.0179106798,
-0.0526412427,
-0.098326005,
0.0026739109,
-0.0677614138,
0.0159636941,
-0.0131118577,
-0.0199660137,
0.0259153936,
0.0621316098,
0.0309122577,
0.0042752535,
0.0053964229,
-0.0118114576,
0.0348100737,
0.0333459899,
0.0354267508,
-0.0238552615,
0.0271396432,
0.0217675846,
-0.0418905988,
-0.0069833151,
-0.0033039683,
0.0453224294,
0.0121187391,
-0.0213688947,
-0.0101998355,
-0.0570263788,
0.0146654118,
0.0265962705,
-0.0128404144,
0.0117852911,
0.0556436367,
-0.0004858465,
-0.0544895567,
-0.02804075,
-0.02232025,
0.020911837,
0.029242605,
-0.0017769638,
0.0071089789,
-0.0168363098,
-0.0315215178,
-0.0134213222,
-0.0171127934,
-0.0843723938,
0.0271148067,
0.0077651236,
-0.0861314386,
0.0020255437,
-0.0295931753,
0.0365908705,
0.0806247965,
-0.0403550118,
-0.0366114341,
2.408901313e-34,
0.0129064796,
-0.043123316,
-0.0257113688,
0.0495824069,
-0.0141340196,
-0.0061998242,
-0.0782105774,
0.0094649084,
0.0199829098,
-0.0428534038,
-0.0837479904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11434v1 | L3Cube-IndicSBERT: A simple approach for learning cross-lingual sentence representations using multilingual BERT | 2023-04-22T15:45:40 | 2023-04-22T15:45:40 | Samruddhi Deode, Janhavi Gadre, Aditi Kajale, Ananya Joshi, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The multilingual Sentence-BERT (SBERT) models map different languages to
common representation space and are useful for cross-language similarity and
mining tasks. We propose a simple yet effective approach to convert vanilla
multilingual BERT models into multilingual sentence BERT models using synthetic
corpus. We simply aggregate translated NLI or STS datasets of the low-resource
target languages together and perform SBERT-like fine-tuning of the vanilla
multilingual BERT model. We show that multilingual BERT models are inherent
cross-lingual learners and this simple baseline fine-tuning approach without
explicit cross-lingual training yields exceptional cross-lingual properties. We
show the efficacy of our approach on 10 major Indic languages and also show the
applicability of our approach to non-Indic languages German and French. Using
this approach, we further present L3Cube-IndicSBERT, the first multilingual
sentence representation model specifically for Indian languages Hindi, Marathi,
Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam, Tamil, Gujarati, Odia, Bengali, and Punjabi. The
IndicSBERT exhibits strong cross-lingual capabilities and performs
significantly better than alternatives like LaBSE, LASER, and
paraphrase-multilingual-mpnet-base-v2 on Indic cross-lingual and monolingual
sentence similarity tasks. We also release monolingual SBERT models for each of
the languages and show that IndicSBERT performs competitively with its
monolingual counterparts. These models have been evaluated using embedding
similarity scores and classification accuracy. | [
0.0307889804,
-0.0010472813,
-0.0095957313,
0.0818557367,
-0.0787005424,
0.0112932827,
0.0099305157,
-0.0158208646,
0.0266599357,
-0.0314456671,
-0.0593958423,
-0.0184461437,
-0.0176309012,
-0.0361124575,
0.0313515924,
-0.0420767181,
0.0489621982,
0.008914018,
-0.0135855125,
-0.0020208887,
0.0471553952,
0.0601973087,
-0.0103973607,
0.052368436,
-0.0263964236,
-0.0193537474,
0.0442953631,
0.0047518988,
0.0419072323,
-0.0166398957,
0.0528872274,
0.0138144176,
0.0450480841,
0.0222497042,
0.0000017498,
-0.0368756652,
-0.0154007627,
-0.0261911843,
0.0459892564,
0.022433009,
0.0111931404,
-0.0071452502,
0.0423515253,
0.0389166698,
-0.0041227452,
0.0683667585,
0.0370604768,
0.0365494788,
0.0604375899,
0.0619398244,
-0.0316553861,
-0.030098075,
-0.0071670562,
0.0115798116,
-0.0182344858,
0.0216133744,
-0.019949764,
-0.0197705906,
0.0013970707,
-0.0251283441,
-0.0072621703,
0.0086638806,
0.0038043947,
0.0160187967,
-0.0037209967,
0.0001479595,
-0.0701903477,
-0.0022352317,
0.0276014693,
0.0455926694,
-0.0628305078,
-0.0589930192,
-0.0077368258,
0.0219910033,
-0.0390973352,
-0.0226817988,
-0.0385012589,
-0.0001318381,
-0.0140929865,
0.0460364111,
0.0620002262,
0.0103428094,
0.0000548996,
0.0081397826,
0.031297192,
-0.0160500482,
0.060201373,
-0.0223968104,
-0.0258887969,
0.0019693929,
-0.0262312964,
0.0184766166,
0.0345582142,
-0.0025607848,
-0.0266276989,
-0.0024197437,
-0.024966361,
-0.0671331435,
0.0404313132,
-0.0624986477,
0.0257111248,
0.0593249984,
-0.0335550681,
0.0208650716,
-0.0670456067,
0.0488558672,
-0.0278082062,
0.0649558678,
-0.0410964489,
-0.0768105015,
-0.0236876011,
-0.0363714583,
-0.03234547,
0.0201036409,
-0.0164435208,
-0.0245776828,
-0.0624092333,
0.0013270323,
0.0229703542,
-0.0247101784,
0.0168139935,
-0.0246883351,
-0.0217263829,
0.000727806,
0.0094354227,
0.0364622883,
-0.0524831861,
0.0006897872,
-0.0078136269,
-0.0568299554,
-0.0241005141,
0.0287145302,
-0.0087726805,
-0.0270086285,
0.0133610154,
0.0222854391,
-0.0309868008,
-0.0528517291,
-0.0417915136,
0.0319946893,
-0.0107833017,
-0.0533852205,
-0.0093585001,
-0.0782159045,
0.062567465,
0.0263219289,
0.0099005224,
0.0066576716,
0.026964793,
0.0152618028,
-0.0146707762,
0.0556198917,
0.0224095732,
-0.0353404023,
0.0006793187,
-0.0123197548,
0.0452993065,
0.0383404046,
0.0279657617,
-0.0247555673,
0.0468674637,
0.0179400314,
-0.0225308612,
0.0525547639,
-0.0142446244,
0.0208018497,
-0.0293705259,
0.0376980379,
0.0223592091,
0.0327286758,
-0.0127172451,
0.0359848738,
-0.0271607898,
0.0133884987,
-0.0013703038,
0.0586617067,
0.0210985374,
0.0647609979,
0.0464847125,
0.0169410929,
0.0078303469,
0.0171606317,
0.0176050551,
0.0100554023,
0.0301337522,
0.002350796,
0.0332209803,
0.0418580435,
-0.0428955853,
0.027059583,
-0.0134501783,
-0.0699259639,
-0.0072173839,
-0.030994771,
0.0423647277,
0.0017880511,
-0.0454251319,
0.1012197286,
0.0617574677,
-0.0997129232,
0.0042027826,
-0.0181415807,
0.0180801321,
0.0669775084,
0.0144426031,
-0.0296861194,
-0.0208434537,
0.0122223319,
-0.0082627833,
0.0533518791,
0.0507877134,
-0.0205369703,
0.0297204982,
-0.067626372,
0.015191434,
-0.0136236455,
-0.0177009813,
0.0610943027,
-0.0171412826,
0.0305103529,
0.0082180221,
-0.0589134693,
0.0031901747,
0.0250219945,
-0.0329432711,
0.0215114318,
0.0068881437,
0.0081858439,
0.0207644384,
0.0082920482,
-0.0143145602,
0.0041151051,
0.0124242408,
-0.0748679638,
0.0073706517,
0.0365326144,
-0.0175436065,
-0.0849853009,
0.0054652002,
-0.0742743611,
0.0203007516,
0.0704774037,
-0.0038400923,
-0.0473366529,
0.0089074811,
-0.0209430046,
0.0412165485,
-0.0618504062,
0.0156103922,
-0.0243899468,
0.0136381174,
0.0021403548,
0.0361179411,
0.0182892643,
0.0314132459,
0.0126950322,
-0.0087451544,
0.1090017855,
-0.0395102687,
-0.0233525466,
-0.0112665547,
0.0412261784,
0.0102208704,
0.0608889908,
0.0140091106,
-0.0087925708,
-0.0373070315,
-0.1213896796,
-0.0012165615,
-0.0171339009,
0.0096520698,
0.0086929286,
0.0499487258,
0.0008144598,
-0.0262867324,
-0.0099321017,
-0.0253109243,
0.0472510792,
0.0244174097,
0.0480577499,
-0.0107641201,
-0.0149483159,
-0.0290707443,
-0.0102449907,
-0.0234819725,
0.0706470087,
-0.0470621511,
-0.0438993536,
-0.0246654134,
-0.0394020639,
-0.029420862,
-0.0147854881,
-0.0178017374,
-0.067574732,
-0.0346034132,
-0.0114742788,
0.0260855965,
-0.0015680225,
0.0035482161,
-0.0310494043,
0.0136134503,
0.0222008117,
-0.0342219435,
0.0069610085,
0.0303563531,
0.0320756808,
-0.0135236159,
-0.0266557354,
0.0194464978,
0.0317362435,
0.0047968938,
-0.0115135843,
-0.0510752834,
-0.05632912,
0.0171903539,
-0.0007109793,
-0.0245383214,
0.0125848586,
-0.0215295777,
-0.0002086066,
-0.0131755508,
-0.0227886867,
0.073349379,
-0.0473910496,
0.000506014,
-0.1059375107,
-0.0045855292,
-0.0514875464,
0.0084503535,
-0.0229439735,
0.0376681052,
-0.0364101566,
-0.0069810315,
-0.0459563881,
-0.0045202165,
0.0160855372,
-0.0054894127,
-0.0137331747,
-0.014625513,
0.0135459285,
-0.0250172932,
-0.0594730563,
-0.0123889223,
-0.0750335976,
0.008622895,
0.0190729946,
0.0151046813,
0.0017952148,
-0.0069577708,
-0.0064096563,
0.0124413874,
0.0078610489,
-0.0148386257,
0.0289326608,
0.0006922772,
0.0783890411,
0.0504065268,
-0.0108787883,
-0.0087555572,
-0.0115783364,
0.0237206053,
-0.0436082296,
0.0452599823,
0.0214083716,
-0.0117091043,
0.0088662803,
0.0138589973,
-0.0286730826,
-0.0177998338,
-0.020645678,
0.0435501039,
0.0176249035,
-0.0196049251,
0.0736718774,
0.0390600376,
-0.004631971,
-0.0218994934,
-0.0534596518,
0.0218208935,
0.003299976,
0.0277616736,
-0.0791408569,
-0.0486883856,
-0.0147762094,
-0.0633016825,
0.0162727349,
0.0128297349,
-0.0112190163,
-0.1017225459,
-0.0130771194,
-0.0014483524,
-0.0019456989,
-0.0442978367,
-0.0167600438,
-0.0652089342,
0.0187000073,
0.0177611578,
-0.0178798437,
-0.0178940445,
-0.0293950215,
0.01595686,
-0.0317054801,
-0.0456269532,
0.0136483898,
-0.0443683863,
-0.0385974348,
0.0320697278,
0.040517997,
-0.0116261318,
-0.0399336033,
0.011798013,
-0.0609368421,
-0.0272234324,
0.0029586004,
0.0267358255,
-0.0087359836,
-0.0411260612,
-0.0105059175,
0.0059964722,
-0.0000681575,
-0.012176374,
0.0072865202,
0.0633427426,
0.0068567437,
0.0177818779,
-0.0136004146,
0.0002502063,
-0.0036924465,
0.0614226684,
0.0228925198,
-0.0435183123,
-0.0175731536,
0.0094168196,
-0.0001093431,
-0.0651366711,
0.0061345268,
0.0296099316,
-0.0434252843,
-0.0008859583,
-0.02455003,
-0.0606837422,
0.0152737563,
-0.0071052806,
0.023469409,
0.0371092223,
-0.043887753,
0.0193696506,
-0.0253089163,
0.0069970321,
-0.0003236466,
0.0306672417,
-0.0034487962,
0.0071081803,
0.0583488643,
-0.0136796581,
-0.0257237498,
-0.0580277741,
-0.0053192987,
-0.0397275388,
-0.0463430956,
0.0453249551,
-0.0009247853,
0.0270317718,
-0.0247547105,
-0.0041769031,
0.0734560117,
0.011201214,
0.0034182784,
-0.0399350934,
0.055370979,
0.0363169685,
-0.015533329,
0.0650457442,
-0.0530668572,
-0.0011598156,
-0.010661195,
0.0578122884,
-0.0064303013,
-0.0513211302,
0.0283243898,
0.0171119142,
0.0095489109,
-0.0585749298,
-0.0003017839,
-0.0506782681,
0.0014751831,
0.005241361,
-0.0136837931,
-0.0295084845,
0.0108045684,
0.0442166142,
-0.0139675755,
-0.009479763,
0.025272781,
-0.0217440315,
-0.0072734947,
-0.0141983349,
0.066071786,
0.0215146337,
0.0627578795,
-0.0342749692,
-0.0126438392,
-0.028792765,
-0.0370779447,
-0.0430617966,
-0.0222627223,
-0.0465627201,
0.0556394421,
0.0019954592,
-0.0129249021,
0.0153845176,
0.0549116172,
0.01032627,
0.0440297648,
-0.0188721959,
0.0332199857,
0.0873729065,
-0.0273679122,
0.0711127818,
-0.0218487587,
-0.0249087624,
-0.0049526095,
0.0700487196,
-0.0175885297,
-0.0020413643,
0.0295994934,
-0.0070638363,
-0.0264194105,
-0.0251797512,
0.0562318899,
-0.0203981884,
0.0406240523,
0.0071826349,
-0.0367518514,
-0.0395900421,
-0.0409702808,
0.0578229167,
0.0125610251,
0.0134711014,
0.0039607217,
-0.0228519887,
-0.0069258371,
0.0371280313,
-0.0049661403,
-0.0068293917,
-0.0151425237,
0.0315044299,
0.0608285777,
0.0214664061,
0.0024030355,
-0.0253056791,
-0.00359012,
-0.0071809501,
-0.033454638,
-0.0143633056,
-5.385443982e-33,
0.0009351186,
0.0692348033,
-0.0327003859,
-0.0254291836,
-0.0018214892,
-0.0100658545,
-0.0185810626,
-0.0234763604,
-0.0294987354,
0.0336255804,
0.0063596056,
0.0109913805,
0.0082497746,
0.0243063476,
0.0333758518,
-0.0256874189,
0.0249564853,
0.0389507636,
-0.0127671547,
0.0194978695,
0.0528419428,
0.0488767922,
0.1130497158,
-0.002612815,
-0.0035305868,
-0.0564435199,
0.023700675,
0.0072007012,
0.0389480479,
0.0588344596,
-0.0233667269,
0.0475579835,
0.024845168,
0.0036860202,
-0.0051019634,
0.0297548007,
-0.0757200345,
-0.0115797278,
0.0219075866,
0.0279474147,
-0.0107248137,
-0.0489716195,
-0.0053361924,
-0.0264182147,
0.0020500771,
0.0410006233,
0.0490450114,
-0.0106619457,
0.0169838909,
-0.0336952433,
-0.0736164898,
0.0072856699,
-0.0300321542,
-0.0260833651,
-0.0063380087,
0.1012050956,
-0.0030502775,
0.0401953124,
-0.0143821696,
-0.0003008393,
-0.0651131868,
0.0385703407,
0.0202215035,
-0.0059837191,
-0.0230475646,
0.0423015542,
0.0076444275,
-0.0763418227,
0.0604182966,
-0.0001881574,
0.0121893166,
0.0200590361,
0.0317716524,
0.0887461379,
0.0023512146,
-0.0445757359,
-0.0849262476,
0.0468349606,
0.030284863,
0.0050998162,
0.0321175121,
-0.0266947858,
-0.0041969647,
-0.0218339898,
0.0294592362,
-0.0287951436,
-0.0175153818,
-0.0190512743,
0.0531869866,
-0.0311948489,
0.0181747917,
0.0359639861,
0.0663284287,
-0.0201472044,
-0.0016439977,
0.0053805895,
-0.0268362965,
-0.0095858229,
0.0271313041,
0.0623183995,
-0.0520404875,
-0.0669701099,
-0.0371541195,
0.0172303021,
0.0172608122,
-0.0093831392,
0.0841538236,
-0.0290048942,
-0.0540121086,
0.0217074547,
-0.0376030207,
-0.0168633237,
-0.0582428314,
0.0524117872,
-0.0051115821,
0.0205059219,
-0.0114532681,
0.0073031005,
0.013778205,
0.0138260266,
0.0116246045,
-0.0432547145,
0.0055073644,
0.0425624773,
0.00697103,
0.0263955276,
-0.0945515409,
0.0358665176,
-0.009890764,
-0.0665495023,
0.011014306,
0.0184274651,
2.466e-7,
0.0064574508,
-0.0027435864,
0.0334594026,
-0.0402568877,
-0.0208758209,
0.0387308151,
-0.052322723,
0.0522258542,
-0.0255169384,
0.0392843001,
0.0080587203,
0.0177613441,
0.0552220903,
0.0076523535,
-0.1121845916,
0.0223675687,
-0.0993730798,
-0.0245455299,
-0.0865803584,
0.0321440361,
0.0118832728,
0.0785116032,
0.0206221491,
0.0013254751,
-0.0346469581,
-0.040999271,
0.08643841,
-0.0300619602,
-0.0611316524,
0.0179125182,
-0.0059370669,
0.0193932373,
-0.0172637366,
-0.0147355115,
-0.0295228492,
0.0508034341,
0.0548481122,
0.0145055791,
-0.0045609963,
-0.0347336046,
0.0257060174,
-0.0030093987,
-0.0356934518,
-0.0386837497,
0.0499940626,
0.0268160347,
-0.0067442958,
0.0005518556,
-0.0007025899,
0.0271801632,
0.0737236217,
-0.0153748523,
-0.0630828217,
0.0071594962,
0.0450771339,
-0.0547186844,
-0.0131971966,
-0.024072865,
-0.0173879918,
0.0362425447,
-0.0209736731,
-0.0229305401,
-0.008368846,
-0.0033109488,
0.0519854464,
-0.0757158548,
0.0554380156,
1.986902745e-34,
0.0468123034,
-0.0029339939,
0.0278871711,
-0.0014251564,
0.0261584613,
-0.0537049584,
0.0064958981,
-0.016315503,
0.026552977,
-0.0248343218,
-0.0070799445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11410v1 | A bounded rationality account of dependency length minimization in Hindi | 2023-04-22T13:53:50 | 2023-04-22T13:53:50 | Sidharth Ranjan, Titus von der Malsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.TH | The principle of DEPENDENCY LENGTH MINIMIZATION, which seeks to keep
syntactically related words close in a sentence, is thought to universally
shape the structure of human languages for effective communication. However,
the extent to which dependency length minimization is applied in human language
systems is not yet fully understood. Preverbally, the placement of
long-before-short constituents and postverbally, short-before-long constituents
are known to minimize overall dependency length of a sentence. In this study,
we test the hypothesis that placing only the shortest preverbal constituent
next to the main-verb explains word order preferences in Hindi (a SOV language)
as opposed to the global minimization of dependency length. We characterize
this approach as a least-effort strategy because it is a cost-effective way to
shorten all dependencies between the verb and its preverbal dependencies. As
such, this approach is consistent with the bounded-rationality perspective
according to which decision making is governed by "fast but frugal" heuristics
rather than by a search for optimal solutions. Consistent with this idea, our
results indicate that actual corpus sentences in the Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus
are better explained by the least effort strategy than by global minimization
of dependency lengths. Additionally, for the task of distinguishing corpus
sentences from counterfactual variants, we find that the dependency length and
constituent length of the constituent closest to the main verb are much better
predictors of whether a sentence appeared in the corpus than total dependency
length. Overall, our findings suggest that cognitive resource constraints play
a crucial role in shaping natural languages. | [
0.0703545585,
0.0287247412,
-0.0413823314,
0.0169840939,
-0.0589240901,
-0.0022412788,
-0.0485109426,
0.0375855975,
-0.0432169512,
0.0170043651,
0.0070223012,
-0.0469767079,
0.0691239238,
-0.0207778066,
0.039449919,
-0.0659318417,
0.0222489126,
0.0075320806,
0.0541352108,
0.0023075487,
0.0501546301,
-0.0063096313,
-0.0080123013,
0.0047955113,
-0.0174282975,
-0.0107234381,
-0.0154829267,
-0.0242416505,
0.0066933907,
-0.0135992104,
-0.0495943762,
0.047504589,
-0.0440287553,
-0.0263321418,
0.0000016891,
-0.0842049494,
0.0008034509,
-0.0276567973,
-0.0149650117,
0.0411677137,
0.0168499388,
0.002786862,
0.0144331641,
0.0249607582,
-0.0180315319,
0.073037833,
0.0706454515,
0.0160179008,
-0.0075204931,
0.0704034045,
-0.0219492335,
-0.0327272564,
-0.0139835887,
-0.0409586467,
-0.0330673531,
0.0077192704,
-0.0028973671,
-0.0061953147,
-0.0016748494,
-0.006559941,
-0.0571166128,
-0.0237411391,
-0.0133772884,
-0.0186177157,
-0.0203705374,
-0.0124457963,
0.0040754094,
-0.0453277715,
0.0655159652,
0.0277276766,
-0.0198822804,
-0.0501997918,
0.0229151044,
-0.0207057483,
-0.0069839661,
0.0132107101,
-0.0235373136,
0.0449681692,
0.0124926437,
0.0331970826,
0.0597857647,
0.0307396986,
-0.0557090975,
-0.00793608,
0.0045726011,
0.0676229596,
-0.0242425334,
-0.039314881,
-0.0261532962,
-0.0227463786,
-0.0510230027,
-0.0560940839,
-0.0230330788,
-0.0235322434,
0.0009412381,
0.0437019989,
0.0081642754,
-0.0255149808,
0.0042441636,
-0.0480694026,
-0.04515763,
0.0240229368,
0.0375638232,
-0.0350651555,
0.0327990092,
0.0387760028,
-0.0077008503,
-0.0602634996,
-0.0250904318,
0.0589695387,
0.0428048708,
-0.0408275798,
-0.0182390511,
0.0230878387,
-0.0537707917,
0.0003029876,
-0.0686445311,
-0.0090491902,
0.0137853306,
-0.0606866777,
-0.0094756633,
0.0083224503,
-0.0158278588,
-0.0163472816,
-0.0414037406,
0.0066888123,
-0.0741509795,
0.0451221578,
-0.0245765503,
-0.0397153981,
0.0056742318,
0.0593833849,
0.0155529967,
-0.0171856713,
-0.0472575426,
0.000005232,
-0.021648569,
-0.0199290812,
-0.0112429038,
-0.0147972237,
-0.0500963479,
-0.0472569726,
-0.0292942263,
-0.0450209826,
-0.0090029314,
0.0382203609,
-0.0132533889,
-0.0201589391,
-0.0206511598,
0.0049556759,
-0.0279456284,
0.0468039922,
0.0582998805,
0.0258720685,
-0.004612579,
0.0019009935,
0.0333590284,
0.0256505832,
0.0413032733,
0.0057914201,
0.0379968956,
-0.0273033045,
-0.0228239521,
0.0041123037,
-0.0298028477,
0.0043419311,
-0.0220928136,
0.0049784272,
-0.0586850345,
0.0129855061,
0.0308948401,
0.0516374074,
-0.0233042054,
0.0216172095,
0.0437438525,
0.078799732,
0.0250499696,
-0.0008206277,
-0.0061288639,
0.0871920139,
0.0069713006,
0.0829072073,
0.0088252407,
-0.0065590101,
0.0023726423,
-0.0074143996,
-0.0076185875,
-0.0046731266,
0.0079644071,
-0.0352869518,
-0.0506444015,
-0.0422341302,
0.0379716903,
-0.025050899,
0.0037400466,
0.0071492754,
-0.0242724717,
0.0224774238,
0.0203579403,
-0.0658675507,
-0.0434900708,
-0.0035832797,
0.0298655964,
-0.0149124451,
-0.0279879943,
0.012604042,
0.0522129349,
0.0703237504,
-0.0137454225,
0.0468926281,
0.0261883046,
0.0034444286,
0.0200792328,
-0.004465899,
0.0542267151,
0.0286653247,
0.0130545096,
-0.0158250909,
-0.0292663742,
0.0039952178,
0.0131157227,
0.0414596573,
0.020254435,
0.0162446816,
0.0012253015,
-0.0030838468,
-0.047304187,
0.026101606,
0.0753538832,
-0.0263973139,
0.0008985176,
0.0529024713,
0.011878565,
0.0042835493,
-0.0150504541,
0.070773989,
-0.0390733927,
-0.0181629173,
-0.0218989905,
-0.0234239418,
0.0568563864,
0.022013206,
0.0125733577,
-0.0581710935,
0.0503139719,
-0.0644561872,
0.0664940849,
0.0167578962,
0.0599868111,
-0.0156885777,
0.020947732,
-0.0431047045,
0.0556866042,
0.0094063459,
0.0411054045,
-0.019690156,
-0.0010423141,
0.0787126571,
-0.0387014262,
0.0467047691,
0.0336775444,
0.0067076143,
-0.0284610391,
0.0826666802,
-0.0050056637,
-0.048705142,
0.0005036987,
-0.0577833764,
-0.0438770279,
0.0339260139,
0.0176137723,
-0.0076551628,
0.0301887952,
-0.0090047857,
0.0178530607,
0.0107327625,
0.0348939076,
0.0298590995,
0.0356079191,
0.0562843382,
-0.0109452959,
-0.0224760529,
-0.0406008922,
-0.036398802,
0.0018950662,
0.0123142786,
-0.012019882,
-0.0520491563,
-0.0274886303,
0.0532142594,
0.0041189548,
0.0165057965,
-0.0083175357,
-0.0941207707,
0.0067923842,
0.0319465771,
0.0777527615,
0.0568205118,
0.0008688299,
-0.0198825188,
0.0183653645,
0.0263808053,
-0.0048601055,
-0.0289878268,
0.0046845027,
0.0408011787,
-0.0208976232,
-0.0288686566,
-0.0060579209,
0.0897403285,
0.0124085844,
-0.0344333425,
-0.0161958113,
0.0087847067,
-0.0388172567,
-0.0188394748,
0.0184519105,
-0.0534214079,
-0.0721172541,
0.0938080028,
-0.0083411401,
-0.0446097329,
0.0296074729,
-0.017926326,
0.0027750481,
-0.0358293243,
0.0324147008,
-0.0323411785,
0.0548359044,
0.0183441434,
-0.0110531282,
0.022577744,
-0.0438395478,
-0.1097226888,
0.0121493489,
0.035028927,
0.0252942517,
0.0347022265,
-0.0539959446,
-0.0036147428,
-0.032291282,
-0.076414533,
0.0104899118,
-0.057034269,
-0.0189369917,
-0.0290971529,
0.0904100016,
-0.0529052466,
0.0395571478,
0.0243901238,
0.0152803315,
0.0076755621,
-0.0128197437,
0.0410611108,
0.0150433304,
0.0370450355,
0.0237861145,
0.0312213413,
0.0579873025,
0.0250295661,
0.0301449224,
0.0189244617,
0.0047128405,
-0.008248114,
0.0358802602,
-0.0058091907,
0.036988005,
-0.0208440516,
-0.0814459547,
0.0249991491,
0.0566762239,
0.0218833108,
0.0099647101,
0.0677003339,
0.0275005568,
0.0331242271,
0.0598155484,
-0.0559833758,
0.052704215,
0.0344135985,
0.0161839407,
-0.03999082,
-0.0011761176,
0.0252076834,
-0.0212775543,
-0.0305635724,
-0.0043024905,
-0.0302219689,
-0.1071425751,
-0.0271656346,
-0.0175969116,
0.030821871,
0.0259247664,
0.0033397521,
-0.0456498303,
0.0115719084,
-0.0528962687,
0.0656550452,
-0.05834933,
0.0108328415,
0.0183946844,
-0.0657798648,
0.017055029,
-0.0326642916,
0.0038871637,
-0.0507795699,
-0.0279173739,
0.0293091647,
-0.0161508489,
-0.028209012,
0.0123987133,
-0.0481325351,
0.0038377598,
0.0161117408,
0.0146886492,
0.059271045,
-0.0010936281,
-0.0401529409,
-0.0017245339,
0.0015006741,
0.005799308,
-0.0038912154,
0.0158968493,
-0.0228152201,
-0.0266654324,
0.0205749571,
0.0027962415,
-0.034338925,
0.0357162058,
0.0369675532,
-0.0414187349,
-0.0202085711,
0.0176429357,
-0.0000796237,
-0.0159365404,
-0.0623403527,
-0.0379472822,
-0.0297638364,
-0.0428466536,
-0.0820416957,
-0.0719547719,
-0.0450697765,
0.0451752655,
0.0000388744,
0.0241636615,
0.0010807603,
-0.0019337049,
-0.0070055439,
-0.0123328436,
0.0198714752,
-0.0091348318,
-0.0413556658,
0.0234103333,
0.0081164641,
-0.0023215909,
-0.0190348346,
-0.0287161861,
0.0087449765,
-0.0446049832,
0.013539603,
-0.0116761476,
0.0325809717,
-0.0128063075,
0.0104210619,
-0.0636483282,
-0.0564194992,
-0.0231727902,
-0.0335968211,
0.0760149211,
0.0242348183,
-0.0502125248,
0.0177140161,
0.0253512803,
0.0086607244,
0.0162872728,
-0.0208408292,
0.0261304509,
-0.0125282314,
-0.0194613263,
0.0598196387,
0.0441497974,
0.0206151288,
-0.0753913447,
0.0367223248,
-0.0511144437,
0.0086532384,
-0.0315592587,
-0.0264583081,
-0.0152569413,
-0.0268211309,
0.0218094848,
0.0856774673,
-0.0325867757,
-0.0116716111,
-0.027340468,
-0.0071223141,
0.0612479635,
0.0305351373,
0.0259680469,
0.014973281,
0.0457049944,
0.0273316391,
0.0217169765,
0.006056115,
-0.0508074686,
0.0076942695,
-0.0055039539,
0.0234951545,
0.0013477927,
-0.0024017873,
-0.004793576,
0.0190789737,
0.0388356186,
-0.0167249721,
0.0656334683,
-0.0426072218,
0.0346171036,
-0.0843958482,
0.0746817663,
-0.0531135723,
0.0267662518,
-0.0204327274,
0.0250226501,
-0.037993297,
-0.0108215204,
-0.0018031878,
0.0189276319,
-0.0550828241,
0.0268182866,
0.0984432176,
-0.0029689071,
-0.0376294553,
-0.0191450678,
-0.0156721398,
0.0008429853,
-0.0464342237,
-0.0137684671,
0.0064526694,
0.0146250464,
0.0086849583,
-0.1126321852,
-0.0572261885,
0.0032392952,
-0.0554582849,
0.0561878197,
-0.0297014657,
0.0590417087,
0.0434851311,
0.0144069344,
-0.0334198102,
-0.0224532876,
0.0056845271,
-0.0445307046,
-0.003977526,
0.008507641,
-5.712982626e-33,
-0.0146710649,
-0.0142488992,
-0.0125986077,
-0.0099563105,
0.010071368,
0.0116899032,
-0.0192846768,
0.0418511517,
0.0115344385,
0.0303091556,
-0.0458230786,
0.0225600246,
0.0078665977,
-0.0177026019,
0.0777522624,
0.0508284345,
-0.0128522692,
-0.0200646203,
-0.0036604619,
-0.0657306015,
0.0506274402,
-0.0340855569,
0.0354366004,
0.0137852281,
0.0257248823,
-0.0224416275,
-0.0162041392,
0.0271356162,
-0.0116379093,
0.0351535678,
-0.0020033238,
0.0352141187,
0.0325386971,
-0.0339477584,
-0.0215293113,
0.0666741356,
-0.0335614979,
-0.049781058,
0.0700876117,
0.0137276705,
-0.0325455293,
-0.0295913052,
0.0270729698,
-0.0233180635,
-0.0214331392,
0.0278465822,
0.0026713789,
0.0178480241,
0.0070405188,
0.0079235472,
-0.073917605,
0.0084817111,
-0.0298989229,
0.0223526657,
-0.0100595942,
0.0535596386,
-0.0233632214,
-0.0067784777,
-0.00099706,
0.0343049131,
-0.0198529642,
0.0827075392,
-0.0276789125,
-0.001226566,
-0.012372558,
0.005066345,
0.03603255,
-0.0237883274,
0.0458790399,
0.0465621315,
0.0233534519,
0.0292615462,
0.0358384475,
0.0266453978,
0.0680568516,
-0.0759851262,
-0.0681957379,
-0.039807912,
0.0295689497,
0.0674810559,
-0.0636839867,
0.0377156548,
-0.070836395,
-0.087534003,
0.0416528396,
0.0157929379,
0.0010832608,
-0.0152828321,
0.0125024933,
-0.0173240434,
0.006833843,
-0.0079826377,
0.0402375534,
0.0010143415,
0.0088508306,
0.0054992507,
-0.0518487841,
0.042498529,
0.0238493942,
0.0268523917,
-0.0726200715,
-0.0185813475,
-0.0430825241,
0.0308434982,
0.0180897228,
0.0324644968,
0.0271435641,
0.0025019452,
-0.0463748761,
-0.006386009,
0.0089777904,
-0.0039508319,
0.0003293912,
-0.018278392,
0.0312818997,
0.0243405737,
-0.0029221405,
0.0034463175,
0.0477397181,
-0.0112977689,
-0.0171198323,
-0.0218837187,
-0.0182184093,
0.0125588318,
0.0100825569,
-0.0115341395,
-0.0201805029,
0.059627112,
0.0239612423,
-0.0426706001,
-0.0306956917,
0.0104644671,
2.687e-7,
0.0105795143,
0.0351358615,
0.0360471085,
-0.020880742,
0.0198030975,
0.0064091613,
-0.0088432506,
-0.0189043898,
-0.0578961931,
0.0124413148,
0.0188257024,
-0.0403737426,
0.0206320044,
-0.0336557552,
-0.0878307819,
0.0143300844,
-0.0582879633,
-0.0342634209,
0.0137933977,
-0.0080339033,
-0.0031526147,
0.0268479958,
0.0090327086,
0.0101147871,
-0.0899635702,
-0.0179195385,
0.015917873,
0.0075183585,
-0.0004563097,
0.0047007259,
0.0325832516,
-0.0387402475,
-0.0014469002,
-0.0088435104,
-0.0118878083,
0.0463068932,
0.0155863827,
0.0290729459,
0.0029259359,
-0.0080450773,
0.0336412825,
-0.0138921607,
-0.0478121713,
0.0080062747,
0.060749501,
0.0084537696,
-0.0694744438,
0.0268185306,
-0.0033347178,
-0.0005432558,
-0.012959254,
0.0335875824,
0.0178485475,
-0.0107283015,
-0.0020777215,
-0.0514333807,
-0.0045789108,
-0.0108259665,
-0.0370024219,
0.0696526244,
-0.0131680183,
-0.0622285865,
-0.0006535632,
0.0436607227,
0.0254516099,
-0.0043893224,
-0.0591994375,
2.262503364e-34,
0.0320095532,
-0.0014744408,
0.0667437539,
-0.0111590596,
0.0397721902,
-0.0249786209,
-0.0189430043,
0.0694117248,
0.0662096813,
-0.0486264303,
-0.0320982449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11406v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11406v4 | LaMP: When Large Language Models Meet Personalization | 2023-04-22T13:42:04 | 2024-06-05T03:29:31 | Alireza Salemi, Sheshera Mysore, Michael Bendersky, Hamed Zamani | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper highlights the importance of personalization in large language
models and introduces the LaMP benchmark -- a novel benchmark for training and
evaluating language models for producing personalized outputs. LaMP offers a
comprehensive evaluation framework with diverse language tasks and multiple
entries for each user profile. It consists of seven personalized tasks,
spanning three text classification and four text generation tasks. We
additionally propose two retrieval augmentation approaches that retrieve
personal items from each user profile for personalizing language model outputs.
To this aim, we study various retrieval models, including term matching,
semantic matching, and time-aware methods. Extensive experiments on LaMP for
zero-shot and fine-tuned language models demonstrate the efficacy of the
proposed retrieval augmentation approach and highlight the impact of
personalization in various natural language tasks. | [
0.0636117533,
0.0630760938,
0.006944811,
0.024330182,
-0.0515332744,
-0.0252755247,
0.0292141773,
0.0086546745,
-0.0181984641,
-0.0601718053,
-0.0368973017,
-0.0280773323,
-0.0521992259,
0.0290227383,
-0.0050427336,
-0.0512299426,
0.0536947511,
0.0285092276,
-0.0209697485,
0.0216506813,
0.0137326941,
0.0360265449,
0.0387550555,
0.0448229946,
0.0133775342,
-0.0016297741,
0.0216644797,
0.0281678904,
0.0210668873,
-0.013899995,
0.0408288464,
0.0421837941,
0.0240769219,
0.0438718982,
0.0000015709,
-0.0271176975,
-0.0405791216,
-0.0033484993,
0.0048698727,
0.0050874283,
0.1233255342,
0.020788407,
0.0361725427,
0.0261243042,
-0.0464799143,
-0.0234736297,
0.0225865543,
0.0383720808,
0.0187041238,
0.0961080045,
-0.0121717677,
-0.0139088454,
0.0050114254,
-0.0487931296,
0.0413684286,
-0.025533814,
-0.0004478146,
-0.0422070026,
0.0239739399,
0.0363132916,
0.037162967,
0.0174609814,
-0.0166277438,
0.0150087383,
0.099389419,
0.0282212794,
-0.0312384665,
0.0249749199,
0.0081526339,
0.0626966357,
0.0232228655,
-0.0353576802,
-0.0060354429,
0.0170431659,
-0.0210410655,
-0.0150194317,
-0.0415566899,
-0.0046370979,
0.0147155421,
0.0127705224,
-0.0022868626,
0.0216874592,
0.0205699932,
0.0510848798,
-0.0180822443,
0.0615600049,
0.0481098779,
-0.0196420066,
-0.0534619018,
-0.0040796446,
-0.004024778,
-0.0526726656,
0.0258749928,
0.0333723053,
-0.0030829059,
-0.0057042735,
-0.0764633566,
-0.0047972091,
0.0223946683,
-0.0225149002,
0.0282541402,
0.0320661105,
0.0179790426,
0.0171154998,
-0.0160727296,
0.0230780318,
0.0071614343,
-0.0203559138,
-0.0697800666,
-0.025656132,
-0.0572725758,
-0.009149584,
-0.0438804217,
0.0374609567,
-0.0194159709,
-0.0155422147,
-0.0563957095,
0.0291909706,
0.0110059697,
0.0052219857,
0.001131841,
0.044468157,
-0.0699747056,
-0.0085330224,
-0.0238252189,
0.0006900213,
-0.0439400934,
-0.0009629558,
0.0315988772,
-0.019721806,
0.0120313689,
0.0187830199,
0.0437326394,
-0.0615243316,
0.0107528176,
0.0301080663,
-0.0150333801,
-0.0645019859,
-0.0207480136,
-0.0460296087,
0.0085805031,
-0.0327203795,
-0.0258099288,
-0.0671354011,
0.0468129292,
-0.0000145445,
-0.0178651791,
-0.0300943647,
0.0023478568,
0.0308101028,
-0.0053429548,
0.0359230004,
0.0024086679,
-0.0211351477,
0.045652695,
0.0174095649,
0.0356861688,
0.0065381546,
-0.0096219601,
0.0688436553,
0.0278008264,
0.0033316931,
-0.0089095561,
0.0143942004,
0.0002519976,
-0.0094562992,
-0.0609130748,
0.0312982649,
0.0099568563,
0.0325975157,
0.016972743,
0.0493747182,
-0.0585808903,
-0.0022882505,
0.0243766829,
0.0608124174,
0.0164383147,
0.0365706235,
0.040615309,
0.0148786874,
-0.0214346629,
-0.0136147132,
-0.0005812774,
0.0163138565,
-0.0478468351,
-0.0178676024,
0.0236425884,
0.0198724438,
-0.0580472611,
-0.0090361629,
0.0040891808,
-0.0334806554,
0.0230586231,
0.0116857961,
0.0339171775,
-0.0105904099,
-0.0006465302,
0.0857722536,
0.0265832394,
-0.0697159097,
0.0331536643,
-0.0543235801,
-0.0071800849,
0.1047560647,
0.0632587448,
-0.0044331052,
-0.0383384041,
-0.0071014343,
-0.0196996219,
0.0210843738,
0.0591167621,
-0.0195159316,
-0.008074725,
-0.0483627953,
-0.0243739933,
-0.0056414702,
-0.0155334575,
0.0466836654,
0.0390849411,
0.0387174897,
0.0668022707,
-0.0270006098,
-0.0215127058,
0.013616222,
-0.0405215546,
-0.0584066324,
0.0519051477,
-0.0125244875,
-0.0086106332,
0.0131909326,
0.008185382,
0.0117357159,
0.0216709208,
-0.0419855155,
-0.0207728185,
-0.0168335792,
-0.015465525,
-0.0357209742,
0.0264945626,
0.0094628483,
0.0463534147,
0.0346195213,
-0.0191320293,
-0.0531937927,
0.0476927571,
0.0021525223,
0.0633054078,
-0.0654504299,
0.0249169655,
-0.0006485862,
0.0088066608,
-0.0607608221,
0.0701622814,
0.0134342015,
0.0093041621,
-0.0318747088,
0.0015772468,
-0.0071278326,
-0.0640700758,
-0.024850579,
-0.0100173512,
0.0007059255,
0.0427362435,
0.0646603107,
-0.0089355903,
-0.0374755897,
-0.0360472091,
-0.1155774146,
0.0150231877,
-0.0128931729,
-0.0016386483,
-0.0118187657,
0.0264325552,
0.0141198207,
-0.0293032676,
-0.053360559,
-0.0081381984,
0.0153289195,
0.0186636541,
0.0205418803,
0.02345022,
-0.0029291045,
-0.0767127573,
-0.0218550414,
0.0051641543,
0.0377505533,
-0.0157122407,
-0.0096389884,
-0.0107698822,
-0.0078624813,
-0.0620080046,
0.0195588879,
-0.0008340144,
0.0072702542,
0.0010521309,
-0.0455354713,
0.0485005751,
0.0267662462,
0.0332090966,
0.0305135623,
0.0309216063,
0.0190732032,
-0.0669836849,
0.0114373947,
-0.039651636,
-0.0052967202,
0.012300686,
-0.0349355824,
0.0383439101,
0.0155696049,
-0.0197348837,
-0.0037565506,
-0.0622104518,
0.0301432777,
0.0086982399,
0.0010728958,
-0.018916009,
0.0275917742,
0.0096728327,
-0.0048922873,
-0.0206563808,
-0.0232897662,
0.0547088459,
-0.0253425948,
0.0099089211,
-0.016177129,
-0.0484292246,
-0.0335082971,
0.0456409641,
0.0058796313,
0.0581914186,
-0.0322093628,
-0.0049286406,
-0.0032122724,
-0.0101853423,
0.0350972973,
-0.0463945158,
0.0107540218,
0.0256372262,
0.0341187157,
-0.0071286834,
-0.0441507585,
-0.0629821867,
-0.1122456565,
-0.0017456223,
-0.0198401064,
-0.0164418351,
-0.0171082094,
-0.0556661114,
-0.0071254009,
-0.0125601171,
0.0122134918,
-0.0376288891,
-0.0155868586,
-0.0027990339,
0.0320648141,
0.0981384143,
-0.0379673354,
-0.01974467,
-0.0107947122,
-0.03218567,
0.021910483,
0.0597011037,
-0.0086844731,
-0.0345426649,
-0.0079945242,
0.0415685326,
-0.0536329001,
-0.0178284794,
0.0078751883,
0.02437892,
-0.0090724351,
-0.0317996405,
0.1075091511,
0.0314028561,
-0.0838567838,
-0.0248713698,
-0.01432388,
0.0179922953,
0.0255578272,
0.0640712157,
-0.0382621922,
-0.0264286287,
-0.0180173442,
0.0328886323,
-0.0033507387,
0.0027694474,
-0.0525604114,
-0.1181286424,
-0.0149279069,
0.0237459093,
-0.0094551072,
-0.0052585904,
-0.0162636433,
-0.0213852078,
0.0131649757,
0.0166050196,
0.0041670962,
-0.0243774895,
0.0039990447,
0.0202628151,
0.0187872127,
-0.0688093007,
0.0080878865,
-0.0217817035,
0.0465460904,
0.0450026952,
0.0349045545,
0.0200078376,
-0.0435037613,
0.0024385327,
0.0386100411,
0.0057221232,
-0.0174138211,
0.0470377021,
-0.0379900932,
0.0167892296,
-0.0063660331,
-0.0098454934,
0.0081777014,
-0.0133366147,
-0.0059887632,
0.0182093661,
-0.0268665813,
0.0284792893,
-0.0448107012,
-0.016910458,
0.0168509427,
0.0751152262,
0.0072916402,
-0.0582273863,
-0.0072658658,
-0.0104128681,
-0.0000277184,
-0.0630897209,
-0.0214465968,
-0.0102338847,
-0.0101800011,
-0.004106306,
-0.0718458816,
-0.0541905463,
-0.0217565596,
0.0390989557,
-0.0049038748,
0.0101006115,
-0.053410802,
-0.0363235138,
-0.0576712228,
0.053261552,
-0.0568547845,
-0.0066074794,
-0.0646024644,
0.0000916745,
0.0228050984,
-0.0904878005,
-0.0083285747,
-0.0290905014,
-0.0819468424,
-0.0477766059,
-0.0002004572,
0.0139939822,
0.0160188936,
0.064437665,
-0.0195622388,
-0.105555132,
0.0277241692,
0.04637108,
-0.0012248161,
-0.0261219628,
-0.0080874879,
0.012151977,
-0.0318315327,
0.04442738,
-0.0587501638,
0.0429498143,
-0.0032358277,
0.0255555455,
0.0013938741,
-0.0745626166,
0.0123894541,
0.0099219503,
0.0469789021,
-0.005378291,
-0.0050484883,
-0.0239304211,
-0.0209570471,
-0.0274716634,
-0.0277742948,
-0.019021593,
-0.0507380478,
0.0514305569,
-0.007935008,
-0.0106850704,
0.0014810663,
-0.0186814107,
0.0361114927,
-0.0598813035,
-0.0381864384,
-0.0403423496,
0.0088432953,
0.0153101506,
0.0345333815,
-0.0360913649,
0.0063969935,
0.0085557355,
0.0483881496,
-0.0724899396,
0.0309911873,
-0.0172547586,
0.0247403942,
-0.0516439863,
0.0371626094,
-0.0344389379,
0.0137810232,
-0.0226245541,
0.0138720488,
0.0473396108,
-0.0312117822,
0.0451479554,
-0.0170030594,
-0.0224169586,
-0.0386782661,
0.01662747,
0.0075474032,
-0.0289901905,
-0.0132288476,
-0.0121261543,
-0.0422078781,
0.0118658943,
0.071193628,
0.0392882861,
0.010577539,
0.0066437372,
-0.0302607007,
-0.0208370276,
0.0252146255,
0.0084526418,
0.0225706957,
-0.0191235542,
-0.0104053728,
-0.018542733,
-0.0297372006,
0.0413617827,
-0.0212988146,
-0.0458887257,
0.0182083696,
0.0490621664,
0.0675691888,
-0.0009478751,
0.0103733977,
-0.0502429381,
0.0167453941,
-0.0057592522,
-0.0073618251,
-0.0171314087,
-6.06096679e-33,
-0.0421702005,
-0.013246526,
0.0276467744,
-0.0099367425,
-0.0015827446,
0.0043632248,
-0.0115189934,
-0.0006446765,
0.0048721326,
-0.0285370089,
-0.0274013411,
-0.009224073,
0.0081452141,
0.0401797779,
0.0012501784,
0.0173285156,
0.0745929927,
0.0220353659,
-0.016845081,
0.0375842489,
0.051160682,
0.0508833416,
0.0261226706,
-0.0357436351,
0.0171897691,
-0.0405829325,
0.0128480727,
0.0139150368,
0.0521903485,
0.0670361072,
-0.029336622,
0.039934516,
0.0030290713,
0.0284834318,
-0.0049909311,
-0.0053667994,
-0.0756659284,
-0.029149225,
-0.008003125,
-0.0101470631,
-0.0164960306,
-0.0691218898,
0.026923025,
-0.0344945006,
-0.0308556892,
0.0035127378,
0.0433262996,
0.0111455917,
-0.0521873608,
-0.0321787596,
-0.053794153,
0.027312085,
0.0412359685,
-0.0020220603,
0.0320182145,
0.051427938,
-0.0014094647,
0.0381111465,
-0.0348376706,
0.0138308005,
-0.0304122623,
0.0310940687,
0.0376633219,
0.0435615703,
-0.0101069938,
0.0596164465,
0.0339601897,
0.0352445878,
0.0124003384,
0.0089895669,
0.0255842302,
0.0313135125,
0.0181162748,
0.0804295242,
0.035934858,
-0.0125622004,
-0.0234096516,
0.0713971928,
0.0429229438,
-0.0188018549,
0.0533427075,
0.0283114612,
-0.0413854271,
-0.001264654,
-0.0075334362,
0.0043841591,
-0.0796947926,
-0.0216406528,
0.0270340834,
0.0699801296,
-0.0318300463,
-0.033487387,
0.0419031382,
-0.0244187247,
-0.0121672777,
0.013996481,
-0.0359141119,
-0.0169756319,
0.0061809993,
0.0423291437,
-0.0404701307,
-0.0261229873,
0.0421230644,
-0.0486244224,
-0.0371860489,
0.0186446253,
0.0388522223,
0.0258364603,
-0.0318603553,
0.0019825189,
-0.026651049,
-0.0026549909,
-0.041075021,
0.0362071916,
0.0440169051,
0.0387680493,
-0.027970938,
0.062123578,
0.0273536742,
0.0238142721,
-0.0103050768,
-0.0661274716,
0.0546299107,
-0.0123399021,
0.001319307,
0.0425151698,
-0.0418748818,
0.0611422472,
0.0438372046,
-0.0186444037,
-0.0078950878,
-0.0114739733,
2.425e-7,
0.0123393247,
0.0396907404,
-0.0075606806,
0.0050462121,
0.0000046263,
0.0309330877,
0.0057359654,
0.0622855946,
-0.0012696869,
0.0643444881,
0.0186995808,
0.0386550054,
0.0466761254,
0.0181464404,
-0.0259180628,
-0.0033643839,
-0.0749253929,
0.0275188945,
-0.0405948684,
-0.0364986584,
0.0573711433,
0.0612089001,
0.0432836562,
-0.0025101532,
0.0091281515,
-0.0520674549,
0.106451422,
-0.036180079,
-0.0682012513,
0.0297522098,
0.0343758948,
0.0814244971,
-0.0130128264,
-0.0454782136,
-0.0211869217,
0.0330650769,
0.0221406668,
0.0508560762,
-0.0484733991,
-0.0562243871,
0.0068596974,
0.0157028306,
-0.0081097903,
-0.0119836321,
0.0714239851,
0.0047483626,
0.0271308813,
-0.0360774025,
-0.0118233934,
0.0229314584,
0.0173288248,
-0.0209767558,
-0.0503029823,
0.0150792226,
0.0279015061,
0.0154136447,
-0.0613799244,
-0.0948367044,
-0.0265124086,
0.0203772541,
-0.0407333225,
0.0232568625,
-0.0785578042,
0.0279021282,
-0.0154707227,
-0.0471664406,
0.0182384737,
2.151394582e-34,
0.0109359017,
0.0329038277,
-0.0063148839,
-0.0431419574,
0.0106649632,
0.0197343268,
-0.0411148518,
0.0160932019,
0.0213073324,
-0.0732816458,
-0.0180776492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11389v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11389v2 | Transformer-Based Language Model Surprisal Predicts Human Reading Times Best with About Two Billion Training Tokens | 2023-04-22T12:50:49 | 2023-10-22T20:03:54 | Byung-Doh Oh, William Schuler | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent psycholinguistic studies have drawn conflicting conclusions about the
relationship between the quality of a language model and the ability of its
surprisal estimates to predict human reading times, which has been speculated
to be due to the large gap in both the amount of training data and model
capacity across studies. The current work aims to consolidate these findings by
evaluating surprisal estimates from Transformer-based language model variants
that vary systematically in the amount of training data and model capacity on
their ability to predict human reading times. The results show that surprisal
estimates from most variants with contemporary model capacities provide the
best fit after seeing about two billion training tokens, after which they begin
to diverge from humanlike expectations. Additionally, newly-trained smaller
model variants reveal a 'tipping point' at convergence, after which the
decrease in language model perplexity begins to result in poorer fits to human
reading times. These results suggest that the massive amount of training data
is mainly responsible for the poorer fit achieved by surprisal from larger
pre-trained language models, and that a certain degree of model capacity is
necessary for Transformer-based language models to capture humanlike
expectations. | [
0.0178975724,
0.0461097248,
-0.0198629294,
0.0100338552,
-0.0215310622,
0.0337372385,
0.0596540086,
-0.0118521489,
-0.0427579507,
-0.0117626805,
-0.0253146626,
-0.0498513877,
0.0447878875,
-0.0056238081,
0.0189731568,
-0.0357426889,
0.0353274569,
-0.0248636641,
-0.0079545882,
0.0015400547,
-0.0322476588,
-0.0080954758,
0.0008748396,
0.0461667366,
0.0312095061,
-0.0310126804,
0.0121945702,
-0.0385995321,
0.0100153973,
-0.0013657529,
0.0057603125,
0.0564801991,
-0.001696765,
0.0571100265,
0.0000018156,
-0.0453551747,
-0.0061149532,
0.0213347599,
-0.0139266662,
0.032062605,
0.0640022084,
-0.0373846367,
-0.0082725473,
0.035910733,
-0.0158371646,
-0.0159572773,
0.0322340578,
0.0338155665,
-0.038546849,
0.0387818739,
-0.0185089149,
-0.016442759,
0.063695401,
-0.0020289556,
0.0241050161,
-0.0281224102,
-0.0009532773,
0.0194139518,
0.0032904141,
0.0007889671,
-0.0564423241,
0.0667643547,
0.0357423797,
0.0258120913,
-0.0103703244,
0.0319973268,
0.0046645431,
-0.0224883091,
-0.0335520618,
0.009274818,
0.0047569196,
-0.0493250117,
-0.0442181863,
-0.0000266526,
-0.028067138,
0.0429990739,
-0.0003339742,
0.0061278185,
-0.0048266533,
0.0056962995,
0.0292680915,
0.0132573172,
0.0241904985,
-0.0408553258,
-0.0250934903,
0.0732098147,
0.0219121017,
-0.0811774284,
0.0269522276,
0.0354854688,
-0.0329212248,
0.0161882024,
0.0073451689,
-0.0245960262,
0.0013813202,
0.023337001,
-0.0416859537,
-0.0680194274,
-0.0053922553,
0.0045708274,
0.0502210706,
0.0678377673,
-0.017119348,
-0.011971035,
-0.0268088151,
0.0907217562,
-0.0322646834,
0.0220373366,
-0.0661214441,
-0.001891278,
-0.0180436894,
-0.0252288543,
0.0010581408,
-0.0510815866,
-0.0600605495,
-0.024341112,
-0.087218076,
-0.0023848598,
0.0587549023,
-0.0489691645,
0.0513204373,
-0.0159818735,
-0.0342509486,
-0.0086535607,
-0.04261861,
0.0465478972,
0.0029518837,
0.0106764184,
-0.0397146866,
-0.0757254809,
0.0278977677,
0.0007365487,
-0.0060034301,
-0.0520124622,
-0.012093327,
0.0439830907,
-0.0522615835,
-0.0368141159,
-0.0402188189,
-0.0047585084,
-0.0354950354,
-0.0441697389,
0.0049821446,
-0.0600639321,
0.0048373109,
0.0495471247,
0.0017141748,
-0.0233786348,
-0.0384788252,
0.0022475505,
-0.0072353901,
0.0240698177,
-0.007644516,
0.0592744611,
0.0072944318,
0.003792438,
-0.0195706338,
0.0598322116,
0.028421618,
-0.0330549516,
-0.0001408621,
-0.0340363346,
-0.0189186744,
0.0548901744,
0.0047184979,
-0.0084743872,
0.0002022407,
-0.0316464119,
0.001278723,
-0.0114743849,
0.0566087365,
0.0263525769,
-0.0019589814,
-0.0454691611,
0.0840154737,
0.0595720559,
0.0333912633,
0.0458643883,
0.0340588838,
0.0181982014,
0.028487226,
0.0132412761,
-0.0252722148,
-0.0038949358,
-0.0091310414,
0.0207522605,
-0.0337202996,
0.0426347442,
0.0019422772,
-0.0317623876,
0.0002126371,
-0.002259139,
0.0270382967,
0.0134075359,
0.0510907508,
-0.0247417055,
-0.0600423813,
0.0774462074,
0.0305936579,
-0.0141620804,
-0.0435897298,
-0.0059425663,
-0.0351057425,
0.0447697043,
-0.0107628806,
0.0099404864,
0.0104602333,
0.0155914985,
0.0027863127,
0.0443514362,
0.0192862339,
0.0290616099,
0.0320752934,
-0.0278319623,
0.0246744789,
0.0440795198,
0.0052204491,
-0.0031717899,
0.0206938703,
0.0317698456,
0.0298942719,
-0.0552226976,
-0.0433871746,
0.0431457758,
-0.145717293,
-0.0140174543,
-0.0624880567,
0.0083960313,
0.0002742737,
-0.0310249589,
0.0105544077,
0.0096791992,
0.0043372391,
0.0006098723,
0.0446126685,
0.0514379144,
-0.0627883598,
0.0136771677,
0.0241921507,
-0.0187324639,
0.0060694623,
0.0756299421,
0.0502008386,
-0.0097531751,
-0.0382849127,
-0.0369815007,
0.0677985251,
-0.005744989,
0.0674317926,
-0.060245309,
0.0067514447,
-0.0228791758,
0.0085058678,
-0.0309134126,
0.0342203714,
-0.0098760091,
-0.0311767552,
-0.0216069743,
-0.023763964,
-0.0643515661,
-0.0106390091,
-0.0182244293,
-0.0131044518,
0.002770701,
-0.0178772099,
-0.0386907645,
-0.0374181233,
-0.0760101378,
-0.0438618995,
0.007582949,
0.0114938803,
0.0015142926,
-0.0159598906,
-0.0227283984,
0.0260885432,
-0.0077340915,
-0.0241065063,
-0.0008771551,
0.0245360322,
-0.0117743984,
-0.0183598511,
-0.0343978629,
-0.0337935723,
-0.0476214103,
-0.0509592891,
0.0511791855,
0.0135510648,
0.0006116393,
-0.0579570234,
0.0399546698,
0.0253009312,
0.021054836,
-0.0372459516,
-0.0470408835,
0.0341891199,
0.040441338,
0.0911681354,
0.055173818,
0.0145210186,
0.0151471021,
0.0331290811,
0.0080002351,
-0.0269332714,
-0.0097826794,
-0.0512273759,
-0.0414977185,
-0.0733513087,
-0.085409604,
-0.0187493283,
0.1087026075,
0.0011462235,
0.0079644592,
-0.0603916124,
0.0182172451,
-0.0192085952,
-0.0770251751,
0.0134998132,
0.0266361181,
-0.0271586291,
0.0599146895,
-0.020496916,
-0.0495492741,
0.0442449041,
-0.02676614,
-0.0142866336,
-0.0403743275,
0.004911141,
-0.0108281393,
0.0223581195,
0.0125153167,
0.0116837313,
-0.0139094247,
-0.0151473731,
-0.0627774,
0.0053715091,
0.0188421458,
-0.004789874,
0.0695245937,
0.0027485997,
-0.027941227,
0.0196181089,
-0.0184355397,
-0.015796978,
-0.0230788291,
-0.0355164818,
-0.0257769264,
0.0193738416,
-0.0318587199,
-0.0901691988,
-0.0095892195,
0.0042125108,
0.0389086679,
-0.0294868648,
-0.0348588564,
0.0064048762,
-0.0203581713,
0.0296229888,
-0.0052133529,
0.0312718563,
-0.0772008151,
0.0201354045,
0.0242349263,
0.0095205707,
0.0380943976,
-0.0275058802,
-0.0040658596,
0.0263277646,
-0.008073899,
0.0009580473,
0.0190663002,
0.047216408,
-0.0327467695,
0.0216143262,
0.1227359027,
0.024932988,
-0.0147897964,
0.0204925854,
-0.0435371734,
0.0377006344,
-0.0160884876,
0.0071521327,
-0.0067852139,
0.0163334347,
-0.0065707411,
0.0621785372,
-0.0162518639,
-0.036437422,
-0.0083414558,
-0.0699571744,
-0.0176258478,
0.0082263909,
-0.0431052297,
0.0087364744,
0.005232539,
-0.0252767578,
-0.0196355451,
0.0446259193,
0.0315487497,
-0.034471605,
0.0007432148,
0.027257463,
-0.0225332566,
-0.0083460119,
0.0376287289,
-0.0148896053,
-0.0007138946,
-0.0008625703,
0.0170378704,
-0.0183656272,
-0.0656018555,
0.0288245883,
0.0093479576,
0.0201005042,
0.0064045917,
0.0458739959,
0.0028453649,
0.0056298636,
-0.0537193678,
0.0049890946,
-0.0016397305,
-0.0000184292,
-0.0324871466,
0.0401755385,
0.0519585274,
-0.0298013091,
-0.0167562608,
0.0196191631,
-0.0336106904,
0.0658307448,
-0.0037753771,
-0.0622770265,
-0.0337337963,
0.0420767069,
0.0246502291,
-0.0086347815,
-0.0590677224,
0.0613202788,
0.0233749766,
-0.0605492741,
-0.0404408835,
-0.0293151587,
-0.0211078282,
0.0423817858,
0.0362244137,
0.0154277449,
0.0458353199,
-0.0207161866,
-0.0521956235,
0.0423481539,
0.0309819132,
0.007295283,
-0.1123351157,
0.0017679749,
0.0040737763,
-0.0215660278,
-0.0365711302,
-0.0353293046,
-0.0972121432,
-0.0548302159,
0.0551485792,
0.0081664631,
0.0367733948,
0.0247531291,
0.0436510667,
-0.0445727371,
0.0484689176,
0.0105800768,
-0.0318166986,
0.0535464995,
0.0010143664,
-0.0153459273,
0.0121813742,
0.0040002856,
0.0050380449,
0.0222063065,
0.029764995,
-0.0122779971,
-0.0101901358,
-0.0065412456,
-0.0043527442,
0.0200943835,
0.0640684888,
-0.0018655382,
0.0073700976,
-0.0192379206,
-0.0282003321,
-0.033201199,
0.0595662966,
-0.0256291497,
-0.0439880267,
0.0566730276,
0.0322344266,
-0.0263089221,
-0.0098142736,
-0.0110223405,
-0.003138463,
-0.0612271652,
0.0409869663,
-0.014131235,
0.0201823823,
0.029516818,
0.0467433408,
0.0031890173,
-0.0252929348,
-0.0434627235,
0.0589260645,
0.0512168705,
0.0547965243,
-0.0091650616,
0.0146307163,
-0.0248870403,
0.0022483792,
-0.0473190658,
-0.0330094658,
-0.0110243736,
-0.0282286443,
-0.0332470424,
-0.0252935067,
0.0576742217,
-0.0303888358,
0.0282713585,
-0.0412605405,
0.025751479,
-0.0002246553,
0.0312214885,
0.0225290582,
-0.0141012417,
-0.0047024554,
-0.0123222228,
0.0691890195,
0.0557576381,
-0.0059653157,
0.0196982604,
-0.0590275228,
-0.030316541,
-0.0137005076,
-0.0161534846,
-0.0184987411,
-0.0210941788,
-0.017951943,
-0.064934276,
-0.0569487624,
0.0229532849,
0.0160954557,
0.0137556409,
-0.0126301665,
-0.0317839645,
0.0599951148,
-0.0310826208,
-0.0636817589,
-0.0401212014,
0.0065505118,
-0.0037027954,
-0.0080263596,
-0.000598855,
-5.605945416e-33,
-0.0085430741,
-0.0181210376,
0.030389294,
0.0198893119,
-0.0197156128,
0.0210339464,
-0.0215943437,
0.0415949784,
-0.03102386,
-0.0042387461,
-0.0044699516,
0.0027383273,
0.0274251029,
-0.0083293822,
-0.0207168721,
0.0203041043,
0.032063514,
0.0135928178,
-0.0163186844,
-0.0687276945,
0.0393665582,
0.0216768514,
0.0726158693,
-0.062129654,
-0.0007903471,
-0.0244095232,
0.0216377936,
-0.0160317197,
0.0513378754,
0.0574645847,
-0.0016637095,
0.0615736395,
0.0165750831,
-0.0367643759,
-0.0103212297,
0.0375865996,
-0.0569575205,
0.0171248708,
0.0510053858,
0.0537482053,
0.002053346,
0.0052214493,
0.050298728,
-0.0095875822,
-0.0359370261,
-0.055482313,
0.0317671038,
-0.0305361953,
-0.0206340179,
-0.0048252922,
-0.0803867504,
0.0140672531,
0.0052883471,
0.0252829194,
0.0421015136,
0.1130669042,
0.0043994454,
0.0282092951,
-0.0596764795,
0.003423484,
0.0435598046,
0.0415219404,
0.0528875366,
0.0270848665,
0.0356274284,
0.0315725319,
0.0834369138,
0.0325451531,
0.0096776923,
-0.0145061985,
0.120418191,
0.0008647066,
0.022585962,
0.0347702913,
0.0554891527,
-0.0432482362,
0.0056470004,
0.0166159756,
0.0303963143,
-0.0100657865,
0.0642299578,
0.0004783398,
-0.0629887506,
-0.0338439792,
-0.033363957,
-0.0073740031,
-0.0138324471,
-0.0355481617,
0.0296799485,
-0.0321233757,
0.007319666,
0.0143719204,
0.0470760278,
-0.0357564017,
0.0159073137,
-0.0054424414,
-0.0349967405,
0.0612290017,
-0.0467048548,
0.0259945672,
-0.0506600291,
-0.0210458413,
0.0092951097,
0.0508442074,
0.0274442919,
-0.0015894137,
-0.0021899247,
-0.0086270357,
-0.0685812458,
-0.0001201665,
-0.0255434029,
-0.0230735727,
0.0523112714,
0.0021581727,
0.063639231,
-0.0174533036,
-0.0234212093,
-0.0058409069,
0.0007481238,
-0.0110839568,
-0.0460450463,
0.034492664,
0.0055036037,
0.0224409346,
-0.0120635955,
-0.0341743119,
-0.0165684186,
0.0275805201,
0.0534712113,
-0.0344055928,
-0.0146656046,
0.0233208034,
2.451e-7,
0.0283822436,
0.0650988147,
-0.0038403864,
-0.0018608171,
0.0140953604,
0.0022943821,
0.0359399468,
-0.0007546002,
0.0422851332,
0.0034788661,
0.015099505,
0.0029459174,
0.0515168756,
0.0004396651,
-0.0386295505,
-0.0600268021,
-0.0830314532,
0.0798719898,
-0.0276235528,
0.0355224758,
0.0131674781,
0.0504886545,
-0.0051323916,
-0.0295667667,
-0.0097075729,
-0.0059606358,
0.0382845849,
-0.0502239615,
-0.0044687055,
0.006361112,
0.0300919954,
0.0144060086,
0.0338424332,
0.0324258953,
0.0005259589,
0.0268909223,
0.0013018965,
0.0195824951,
0.0027234021,
0.0100051835,
0.028103631,
0.0295205601,
-0.0577421784,
-0.0865039527,
0.041162055,
-0.0352538712,
-0.0390329696,
0.0073182322,
-0.0557062887,
0.0184118934,
0.0038609705,
-0.0037734769,
0.0288306642,
0.0284680817,
0.0346366093,
-0.0482048132,
-0.0039074346,
-0.0195114501,
-0.0421440676,
0.0305397119,
-0.0330016799,
-0.0613923557,
-0.0759376734,
-0.0178037956,
0.0212578084,
-0.0421111658,
0.0108627547,
2.199259702e-34,
0.0136147793,
0.0139834164,
0.0493450463,
0.0039381729,
0.0067265406,
-0.017733166,
0.0728592724,
0.0041076341,
0.0035090637,
-0.0973902792,
-0.0232595764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11370v1 | SAILER: Structure-aware Pre-trained Language Model for Legal Case Retrieval | 2023-04-22T10:47:01 | 2023-04-22T10:47:01 | Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Jia Chen, Qian Dong, Yueyue Wu, Yiqun Liu, Chong Chen, Qi Tian | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval, which aims to find relevant cases for a query case,
plays a core role in the intelligent legal system. Despite the success that
pre-training has achieved in ad-hoc retrieval tasks, effective pre-training
strategies for legal case retrieval remain to be explored. Compared with
general documents, legal case documents are typically long text sequences with
intrinsic logical structures. However, most existing language models have
difficulty understanding the long-distance dependencies between different
structures. Moreover, in contrast to the general retrieval, the relevance in
the legal domain is sensitive to key legal elements. Even subtle differences in
key legal elements can significantly affect the judgement of relevance.
However, existing pre-trained language models designed for general purposes
have not been equipped to handle legal elements.
To address these issues, in this paper, we propose SAILER, a new
Structure-Aware pre-traIned language model for LEgal case Retrieval. It is
highlighted in the following three aspects: (1) SAILER fully utilizes the
structural information contained in legal case documents and pays more
attention to key legal elements, similar to how legal experts browse legal case
documents. (2) SAILER employs an asymmetric encoder-decoder architecture to
integrate several different pre-training objectives. In this way, rich semantic
information across tasks is encoded into dense vectors. (3) SAILER has powerful
discriminative ability, even without any legal annotation data. It can
distinguish legal cases with different charges accurately. Extensive
experiments over publicly available legal benchmarks demonstrate that our
approach can significantly outperform previous state-of-the-art methods in
legal case retrieval. | [
0.0367255099,
0.0341292657,
-0.017744204,
0.0137084015,
-0.0281574223,
0.0187663492,
-0.0013815647,
0.0407559797,
0.0074528954,
-0.0711402819,
-0.0238539651,
-0.0017968597,
-0.057635691,
0.0289137494,
-0.0390352868,
-0.0333374254,
0.0453853086,
0.0204492789,
0.0872731134,
0.0179966502,
0.0206419211,
-0.0000459511,
0.0242331531,
0.0038218268,
-0.0133558027,
0.0093279528,
-0.0311909281,
0.005709406,
-0.0235881675,
-0.0383535028,
0.0303010494,
0.0637785569,
0.0589232557,
-0.0055713006,
0.0000017177,
-0.0308159664,
-0.0152985575,
-0.0291738231,
-0.0003203037,
0.0148856966,
0.0260131918,
-0.0405000448,
-0.000958115,
-0.013678845,
-0.038869638,
-0.0080081476,
-0.0038462947,
0.0214934573,
0.0291416459,
0.1046450883,
-0.0185660738,
-0.0721066594,
0.0473856516,
-0.056297414,
-0.0045828945,
-0.0589453168,
0.0343104601,
-0.0010366078,
-0.0019545285,
0.0173526313,
-0.0021811726,
-0.0047942386,
0.0314884,
-0.0119267171,
-0.0086149406,
-0.0031367785,
-0.0181023031,
0.0001010024,
0.0141880773,
0.060222175,
0.0182323083,
-0.0524707213,
0.0107429707,
-0.0189360604,
0.0336948298,
-0.0010033451,
-0.0253761653,
0.0938835144,
-0.0128361415,
0.0131136524,
0.0455686226,
0.0566857681,
-0.0112010762,
0.024791602,
-0.0340886414,
0.0518208928,
-0.0021689036,
-0.048227638,
-0.0007145858,
0.0080523249,
0.0467610061,
-0.0421986617,
0.0763589442,
0.0456558652,
0.0009298562,
0.0251519475,
-0.0366552025,
-0.0600187629,
0.0646778867,
-0.1075696945,
0.0012295569,
0.0096542044,
-0.0213150978,
0.0919702277,
-0.0500405654,
0.0042924378,
0.0019488543,
0.0163007099,
-0.008855544,
-0.0326276757,
-0.0182015765,
-0.0138039179,
-0.077315338,
0.0609735399,
-0.1203766689,
-0.0160750579,
0.0242372043,
0.0303041935,
-0.0033782502,
-0.0164377596,
0.0153138069,
-0.0105663715,
-0.0119468533,
-0.0251082964,
-0.0394234583,
-0.041675739,
-0.0497209989,
0.0204160642,
0.0033492402,
0.0089587569,
-0.0059362398,
0.0218669251,
0.0261694379,
-0.0374015383,
0.0153238205,
0.0591635667,
-0.0118521042,
-0.0600549839,
-0.0454166383,
-0.0613170415,
0.0069900504,
-0.0404593721,
-0.016604336,
-0.0367647186,
0.0254035182,
-0.0160812605,
-0.0337779783,
-0.066780366,
0.0041769883,
0.0580468997,
-0.0210018978,
0.0425356328,
0.0019354054,
-0.0306519214,
-0.0201827288,
0.0330888964,
0.0691750348,
0.0249853972,
-0.0056528361,
0.0498856567,
0.0405617841,
-0.0131467134,
-0.0164994132,
0.0109554101,
0.0325029865,
-0.0085802414,
0.0045958441,
0.0401907228,
-0.0154981986,
0.0165579189,
0.0322675221,
0.0227944013,
-0.019899711,
-0.0424060114,
-0.0166855585,
0.0331893079,
0.0436373949,
0.0526120104,
0.0060337046,
0.0061055534,
0.0019062269,
-0.0125566646,
-0.0491463132,
0.0136050265,
-0.0593504347,
0.0019252806,
-0.0644069985,
-0.0045574447,
-0.0423594378,
-0.0495472215,
0.0149161611,
-0.0072785961,
0.0207276661,
-0.0040376233,
0.051899571,
0.0200738385,
-0.0665850341,
0.0438907407,
0.0211445931,
-0.0630695596,
-0.0203267317,
-0.0131552275,
0.0171452221,
0.0268168077,
0.0506091341,
-0.0594521165,
-0.0412304625,
0.0257025808,
-0.0000548724,
0.0283850096,
0.0352950804,
-0.0043714098,
0.0045701135,
-0.0456108525,
-0.0532814972,
0.0127069112,
0.0330580361,
0.0215802062,
0.0070676696,
0.0127746044,
0.0595839694,
-0.0439866669,
0.0112648252,
0.0330836363,
0.0017519465,
-0.0494343005,
0.0246272907,
-0.012031314,
0.0308440682,
0.0184779335,
0.0077483868,
-0.010332657,
0.0636559278,
-0.0071159094,
-0.0067940764,
-0.0091192434,
-0.0393368118,
-0.0348585658,
0.0251752269,
-0.0069740703,
0.0059300005,
-0.002553585,
-0.0460213721,
-0.0193680245,
-0.0106399786,
-0.0014218857,
0.0150166014,
-0.0574691854,
-0.0158751421,
-0.0127086164,
-0.013895859,
-0.0332187526,
0.0708516687,
0.020565914,
-0.0372670479,
-0.0263947248,
-0.0011673603,
0.0472362377,
-0.0361816809,
-0.01995367,
-0.0117020514,
-0.0383593105,
0.0054425895,
0.0485215001,
-0.009656691,
-0.0267517846,
-0.0150653049,
-0.0797464103,
0.0046419967,
-0.0464615524,
0.0131149478,
-0.0072138002,
-0.0142607912,
-0.0053886943,
-0.0609828606,
-0.0461501963,
-0.0110104121,
0.0064414283,
-0.0070787272,
0.0017954056,
-0.0145628909,
-0.0167168379,
-0.0230686609,
-0.0480800793,
-0.003755738,
0.0374360383,
0.0090815425,
-0.0338027291,
-0.027805388,
0.0793767646,
-0.0028368076,
0.0054744291,
-0.0412414931,
0.0080752801,
-0.0119743533,
-0.0103925224,
-0.0129670296,
0.0531745851,
0.0467648506,
0.0257590786,
0.0182716418,
-0.00781254,
-0.0553751327,
0.0062966174,
-0.0091627222,
0.0552366003,
-0.0473287553,
0.0257848762,
0.0631312132,
0.0286328029,
-0.0264266953,
0.0193429813,
-0.0216654334,
-0.0150377536,
0.0241429247,
-0.019953439,
-0.0254437793,
-0.0319970958,
0.0049428325,
0.0482703857,
0.0137594864,
-0.0476423427,
0.0500010327,
-0.0004788879,
0.0372748002,
-0.022220742,
0.0038346879,
-0.0685926825,
0.109663181,
0.0193011239,
0.0090447878,
-0.0413505808,
-0.0731350482,
0.0290647913,
0.0051857205,
0.0528269634,
-0.0579605885,
0.0560283028,
-0.0057413108,
0.0593910739,
-0.0247460939,
-0.0558919869,
-0.0212398563,
-0.0316784009,
0.0169489048,
0.0377099477,
-0.0164644085,
0.025877066,
-0.0388159864,
0.0080918521,
-0.0228574499,
0.0316506699,
0.0262335408,
0.0109016476,
-0.0362124704,
0.0377462097,
0.0022717223,
-0.0276588909,
-0.0094174417,
-0.000026171,
-0.0180469919,
0.0230225343,
-0.0322263725,
-0.0249925945,
0.0151015418,
-0.0003404799,
0.022497071,
-0.0926020741,
0.0020902494,
0.0392149054,
-0.0034024592,
-0.0675188079,
0.0023319835,
0.0981893018,
0.03523238,
-0.0406884067,
-0.0190091673,
0.0280537512,
-0.0025138848,
0.0389040038,
0.0410315245,
-0.0724059939,
0.0003887808,
-0.0006426635,
-0.0303537548,
-0.024715323,
-0.0161917601,
-0.0093675107,
-0.0557551086,
0.0529677719,
0.0242285654,
0.0025892705,
-0.0661159158,
-0.0331870429,
-0.0129866106,
-0.0127961235,
0.007874269,
0.023608299,
-0.039059408,
-0.0197357908,
-0.0035183113,
-0.0472895391,
-0.0008464967,
0.0002239991,
-0.0480878241,
0.0248027407,
0.0418294147,
0.0057581807,
-0.0075920215,
-0.0225549005,
0.0056457245,
-0.0247879159,
0.0082590217,
-0.0119638154,
0.036255274,
-0.0087859193,
0.0416878723,
-0.0548267737,
0.0034396504,
-0.0356461853,
-0.0324836187,
0.0347949304,
0.0251810048,
-0.0557539463,
-0.0013179737,
-0.0302123278,
-0.0390390605,
-0.0179671198,
0.0487612188,
-0.0054788827,
0.0319887474,
-0.0475660786,
-0.0417977385,
0.0146080544,
-0.0477558188,
-0.0202389769,
0.0040762899,
-0.0084213065,
0.0226342604,
-0.0430101641,
-0.0512300394,
-0.0069344649,
0.0392073132,
-0.0134732332,
0.0205151029,
0.0331271216,
-0.0538567491,
-0.0892676488,
0.0257435981,
-0.0555683747,
-0.005597766,
-0.0262008626,
0.0294595584,
0.0112607712,
0.0045835357,
-0.0178898014,
-0.0093253879,
0.026019875,
0.0018950368,
-0.0137078371,
-0.006711219,
0.0067631481,
0.0153745087,
-0.0596992075,
-0.0576519668,
0.0344210193,
0.0140243201,
-0.0406247489,
-0.0258440208,
0.0583503097,
-0.0622446202,
-0.0421797298,
-0.005659245,
-0.0262004137,
0.0377300568,
0.0210025404,
0.0390925072,
-0.0115755722,
0.0045086257,
0.0490256995,
0.029578153,
0.052596841,
0.031183321,
-0.0067477636,
-0.0332704782,
0.0228075702,
-0.0448642224,
-0.0033380804,
-0.0049507702,
0.0030608776,
0.0139304148,
-0.0107286656,
-0.0210547913,
0.0903916135,
-0.0275696944,
0.0230598338,
-0.0629784688,
0.0510172099,
0.0229913201,
0.0018227774,
0.0105850976,
-0.0184143241,
0.0033051528,
0.0384234674,
0.0005250383,
0.0582827441,
-0.0472173989,
0.0384676643,
0.0267802998,
0.0145230433,
-0.0084544551,
0.0173813812,
-0.0388080329,
0.0159291271,
-0.0256909523,
0.0345639363,
0.0550116152,
-0.031247668,
-0.015933834,
0.0004225569,
0.0044082296,
-0.0070317653,
0.0166131835,
-0.0008830109,
-0.0527716614,
0.0329861939,
0.0266976953,
-0.0114788758,
0.0145643475,
0.0362543575,
0.0212617088,
0.0129901003,
-0.0048578335,
-0.0178658813,
-0.0234143082,
-0.023989629,
0.0279469546,
0.0641397312,
-0.0620890036,
-0.0424011797,
-0.0427043997,
-0.0002098644,
-0.0169040915,
0.0032205693,
0.0076658591,
0.0247203782,
0.0334491655,
0.0700931847,
0.0107654938,
-0.0336248353,
-0.0170925967,
0.0096992217,
-0.0363733396,
-0.0255016629,
-0.0142425774,
-5.556651795e-33,
-0.0337524861,
-0.0276938919,
0.026854299,
0.028716851,
-0.0165255778,
-0.0139150899,
-0.0160624161,
-0.0298688393,
-0.020559907,
0.0108323693,
-0.0099836336,
0.0294243693,
0.0202167835,
0.0147906672,
0.0172496662,
-0.0115210665,
0.0367502719,
0.0285333935,
0.0052357996,
0.0213815495,
-0.0212492589,
0.0287614558,
0.0097576585,
-0.0829146653,
0.0119749531,
0.0423997194,
0.0287750941,
-0.0190622415,
-0.0158259254,
0.070704706,
0.0125272498,
0.0246588252,
0.0407844111,
-0.0174356308,
-0.0137624601,
0.0457524918,
-0.1279776096,
0.0026904864,
-0.0181857329,
0.0067787492,
0.0097045908,
-0.0352841988,
0.0279842969,
-0.0225006957,
0.0056725456,
0.0032011853,
0.0393558629,
-0.0206303094,
-0.0424486399,
-0.0975664556,
-0.0827562734,
0.0661537722,
0.0090111969,
0.0398874059,
0.0626427829,
-0.01446677,
0.0278792642,
0.072072722,
-0.0607509911,
0.0117361695,
-0.0434541404,
0.014964533,
-0.0038925756,
-0.0583821908,
-0.0194512717,
0.0515540652,
-0.0113018304,
-0.0005714911,
-0.0499813892,
0.0153989103,
0.0268427338,
0.0743117779,
0.0363908857,
0.0265933294,
0.0669977739,
-0.034520179,
-0.086659655,
-0.0277126804,
0.030020833,
0.0317623951,
0.0026003735,
0.0174344704,
-0.0397177115,
-0.0040062945,
-0.0232967772,
-0.0569856241,
-0.0105650276,
-0.0162589643,
0.0350673459,
0.0497367568,
0.0713294372,
-0.0065517798,
0.0186617319,
-0.0336710513,
0.0332790241,
0.0469668433,
0.0250653643,
0.0060449475,
-0.011841571,
0.0551488064,
-0.0293627623,
-0.0609139539,
0.0480344668,
-0.0506829247,
-0.0309552923,
-0.0211348087,
0.0498897471,
-0.0331950337,
-0.051864706,
-0.0035398721,
0.0296254549,
0.0023330031,
0.0149128288,
0.0236069895,
0.0178785697,
0.0646274462,
0.027146725,
0.0715997145,
0.0156444013,
-0.0143205086,
-0.0425379872,
-0.0514805354,
0.0077668987,
0.0164477807,
0.0164479353,
-0.0007387053,
-0.0086034294,
0.0379159711,
0.0312651657,
-0.0065722181,
0.0231775083,
0.0847708583,
2.426e-7,
0.0743181035,
0.0605149195,
0.0123308478,
0.0040862933,
-0.0103344899,
0.0081726974,
0.0352893136,
0.049574852,
0.010178159,
-0.0362506323,
0.0088278418,
0.0182299502,
0.0363519564,
0.0250828713,
-0.0639109984,
-0.0321563259,
-0.0495074689,
-0.0636862814,
-0.0436227918,
0.006535721,
0.0711081922,
0.0931259468,
0.0041545625,
-0.0069672312,
-0.0005022498,
-0.0372794718,
0.0588837378,
0.0023004068,
-0.0072222506,
-0.0029414694,
0.033102911,
-0.0355909318,
-0.0098652486,
0.0337932147,
-0.0123992013,
0.0946315154,
-0.036250338,
0.0658634752,
-0.0057161041,
0.025169393,
-0.0130233774,
-0.030119177,
0.002494124,
-0.0129147973,
0.048916962,
-0.0286112782,
-0.0022978003,
0.0084253037,
-0.0635631382,
-0.0059172735,
0.000573394,
0.0421974733,
-0.0093021058,
-0.011483347,
0.050304234,
-0.0091636721,
0.0283398256,
-0.1309153885,
0.0326469541,
0.0272247121,
-0.0112693766,
0.0659507439,
-0.0263124947,
-0.0139398733,
0.0638665929,
-0.0667088404,
0.0288509913,
2.000315089e-34,
0.0417628027,
0.0025355041,
-0.01558627,
0.0258116554,
0.0336369053,
0.0251762401,
-0.0237049852,
0.0270755701,
-0.0235368703,
-0.0842176974,
0.0166227631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13557v1 | "I'm" Lost in Translation: Pronoun Missteps in Crowdsourced Data Sets | 2023-04-22T09:27:32 | 2023-04-22T09:27:32 | Katie Seaborn, Yeongdae Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | As virtual assistants continue to be taken up globally, there is an
ever-greater need for these speech-based systems to communicate naturally in a
variety of languages. Crowdsourcing initiatives have focused on multilingual
translation of big, open data sets for use in natural language processing
(NLP). Yet, language translation is often not one-to-one, and biases can
trickle in. In this late-breaking work, we focus on the case of pronouns
translated between English and Japanese in the crowdsourced Tatoeba database.
We found that masculine pronoun biases were present overall, even though
plurality in language was accounted for in other ways. Importantly, we detected
biases in the translation process that reflect nuanced reactions to the
presence of feminine, neutral, and/or non-binary pronouns. We raise the issue
of translation bias for pronouns and offer a practical solution to embed
plurality in NLP data sets. | [
0.0605238974,
0.0859961286,
-0.0269122366,
0.0313961245,
-0.0070054024,
0.0001161362,
0.0377591252,
-0.0372929722,
-0.0211724769,
-0.0217970628,
-0.0177628584,
-0.0823945776,
0.0561041012,
-0.0370756797,
0.0237860214,
-0.031494312,
0.0284978338,
0.0171332154,
0.0126324818,
-0.0414775945,
0.0193549693,
0.0429993719,
-0.0034099191,
0.0593305677,
-0.0202019941,
0.0090944795,
0.014178317,
0.026300149,
-0.0015149161,
0.0137491757,
0.0149150901,
0.0343124494,
-0.0223437939,
0.0334506631,
0.000001863,
-0.0419085473,
-0.010833906,
0.0045422707,
-0.0265069008,
-0.0198827684,
0.0182449128,
-0.0057026786,
-0.0257241968,
0.0318593644,
-0.0375196487,
-0.0343507975,
0.0718243122,
-0.0167508125,
0.0588762946,
0.0542961843,
-0.0035548394,
-0.0019377287,
-0.0463278294,
-0.0179605447,
-0.0034318946,
-0.0099596316,
-0.0140199224,
-0.0936525688,
-0.0356300063,
-0.0235948991,
-0.012437203,
0.0421627015,
-0.021432396,
0.0130655142,
-0.0074226577,
-0.0053097643,
-0.0508571975,
-0.0568129234,
0.0051067071,
0.0778439865,
0.066409871,
0.0140093938,
0.0022328913,
0.0220103227,
-0.0132868541,
-0.0013324735,
-0.0001097991,
0.0430638082,
-0.0105259903,
-0.0185397342,
-0.0167942811,
0.005164572,
-0.0062349532,
-0.0219013691,
-0.0351745747,
0.0394993499,
0.0233522933,
-0.0551309548,
0.0202150214,
0.0224356502,
-0.0043247831,
-0.0129511133,
0.0479255542,
-0.0354100056,
-0.0297924373,
0.0352730043,
-0.0252530202,
-0.0812696293,
0.0114070429,
-0.0342344567,
0.0491990633,
0.0349048674,
-0.0478397459,
0.0012448331,
0.0052888803,
0.01495877,
0.0077197589,
0.0065242299,
-0.0539347455,
-0.0589326434,
-0.0183376465,
-0.0108422674,
-0.0397640057,
-0.0234042574,
-0.0045416732,
0.0474627316,
-0.0239718687,
-0.0134409927,
-0.0464757346,
0.0207544211,
-0.0053607803,
0.0169278961,
-0.041124776,
0.0040437034,
-0.0037677321,
0.0888308883,
-0.0553396791,
0.0153020583,
-0.0293584242,
-0.1055207103,
0.0152212689,
-0.0063782516,
0.0263356697,
-0.0236347001,
-0.0174582154,
0.0194089282,
0.007899452,
-0.0244575404,
-0.0074883271,
-0.0477313474,
-0.0463585444,
-0.0362871066,
0.0031464149,
-0.0417410471,
0.0690500587,
0.0119343726,
0.0314601511,
-0.0539475381,
0.02302639,
0.0169855878,
-0.020467842,
0.09589798,
-0.0121343657,
0.0412163287,
0.0244783647,
-0.0017602082,
0.0145382136,
0.067919597,
0.0475244373,
-0.0249513276,
0.0670586899,
0.00998108,
0.0123234559,
0.0447262377,
0.0195963196,
0.018232137,
-0.0034373677,
0.022097975,
-0.0208386872,
0.0585520528,
0.0732561573,
0.0197492838,
0.0133818211,
0.0020516717,
0.0701501891,
0.0915670544,
-0.0417176113,
0.0096041653,
0.0091423066,
0.0059505207,
-0.0079711564,
-0.0191224553,
-0.0361055173,
0.0092708236,
0.0010658242,
-0.01987282,
0.0043703802,
0.0272296257,
-0.0008817211,
-0.0214193072,
-0.0182280131,
0.0049196002,
0.001972917,
-0.0225497652,
-0.006018681,
0.0152842766,
0.0283765178,
0.0491789915,
0.0163812563,
-0.0760810226,
0.0058915042,
-0.0012306615,
-0.0203909446,
0.0288345944,
-0.0036120219,
-0.0123293074,
0.0025174352,
-0.0258627143,
0.0195773076,
0.0472224541,
0.0465873703,
0.0030720651,
0.0328935497,
-0.0211566109,
-0.0262172632,
0.0661126971,
0.0143926386,
0.028947765,
0.0086664632,
0.0678483918,
0.0314817503,
-0.0310705267,
-0.0217124391,
0.0145576298,
0.0177301522,
-0.018078845,
0.0600269474,
0.0486270413,
0.0347757451,
0.0461449586,
-0.0209974311,
-0.0142313838,
0.00382574,
-0.0049226596,
-0.0278952643,
0.0766011477,
0.0025641399,
-0.0183428694,
0.01635262,
-0.0737410262,
-0.0621069334,
0.0437670015,
-0.0284294728,
-0.0290848818,
0.0186370201,
-0.0366101153,
-0.0236244928,
-0.0078736804,
-0.0024390437,
0.0153388325,
0.0438278653,
0.0101913726,
-0.0117292348,
-0.0203169752,
0.0046650101,
-0.0057931482,
-0.0666577891,
0.0396667384,
-0.07270284,
-0.0437561646,
0.0475851856,
0.0012045711,
0.0541946702,
0.024201028,
-0.0141419368,
-0.026025096,
-0.0075171036,
-0.0725330636,
-0.0115836225,
-0.0168489479,
0.0259716101,
-0.0048316205,
0.0396730788,
-0.024662545,
-0.0017140877,
-0.0127691105,
-0.0283120293,
-0.0073277126,
0.0313542932,
0.0326519869,
-0.0253548361,
0.0510777123,
-0.0244406424,
0.0057421043,
-0.032794632,
-0.0018327393,
0.0057897684,
-0.0088995071,
-0.0388562232,
-0.0403348282,
-0.0197145659,
-0.0220853966,
0.0162440147,
-0.0650231838,
0.0247759428,
0.0061487081,
0.0380943008,
0.0730402768,
-0.0233712606,
0.0246897247,
0.0442870744,
-0.0179486033,
-0.0397705026,
-0.0029876893,
0.0176771674,
-0.0457871556,
0.0111247106,
-0.0777267367,
0.0280213133,
0.0148857962,
0.0443026274,
-0.0243459474,
-0.0515515767,
-0.0038986409,
-0.058051683,
-0.0384251513,
-0.0284052528,
0.0115932766,
-0.0127864871,
0.0658954903,
-0.0190495495,
0.0027542773,
0.062115036,
-0.012416997,
-0.0420884117,
-0.0473562814,
0.014697738,
-0.0161275528,
0.04990099,
-0.0312245358,
0.0288063157,
0.0282882806,
-0.0260904487,
-0.0526717603,
0.0374139808,
0.0174540263,
-0.0121963043,
0.0248190239,
-0.0584373698,
-0.0113887815,
-0.0093123559,
-0.0486920476,
0.0052495208,
-0.0356396139,
-0.0373073108,
-0.032197617,
0.0299521517,
-0.0403488651,
-0.003959788,
-0.0101111112,
0.0177341402,
0.0021056666,
0.0026039372,
-0.0128348097,
-0.014669884,
-0.0169399753,
0.0012920304,
0.0507769659,
0.0163810048,
-0.0081335837,
-0.027836157,
0.0420001745,
0.0677360594,
0.0239935499,
-0.0067095072,
-0.0061180028,
0.0628578588,
-0.0200043209,
-0.0264371634,
-0.0223169606,
0.0727798566,
-0.0456322655,
0.0257277396,
0.0849976689,
0.0039517777,
-0.0148256514,
-0.0014511829,
-0.0269116461,
0.029289661,
0.009542468,
0.0038894119,
-0.1382685155,
-0.0234743804,
0.0166694578,
0.061569225,
-0.0281088222,
-0.0315840393,
-0.0170898084,
-0.1794417053,
0.0290794075,
0.0143440105,
-0.0281782933,
-0.0265853256,
-0.0349643566,
0.0170637295,
-0.0595450699,
0.0121281696,
-0.0292253587,
0.0146260289,
0.0110224048,
-0.0133029707,
0.0040734196,
-0.0396923758,
0.0097188484,
-0.0859364271,
0.0795149803,
0.0460661724,
0.09047506,
-0.0077416105,
0.0121698678,
-0.0202295315,
-0.0068491148,
-0.0039685206,
-0.011570571,
0.0247445107,
-0.0043727839,
-0.0535097681,
-0.0122249583,
0.0310791265,
-0.0203149598,
0.046083238,
0.0244653076,
0.0204691514,
0.0350113735,
-0.0011330628,
-0.0012891974,
-0.0066803508,
0.0165073816,
0.0715375915,
0.0224763397,
-0.0525105447,
0.0161969513,
-0.0505070128,
0.0265332293,
0.0109305149,
-0.0633128732,
-0.0047274064,
-0.0033087509,
-0.0710042939,
-0.0935125127,
-0.0944089964,
0.030778788,
0.0137157412,
0.0280277226,
-0.0392176397,
0.0281799734,
-0.0000516455,
-0.0060239756,
0.0354440771,
-0.0401003473,
0.0539530069,
-0.0330884233,
-0.0108414507,
-0.0112370597,
-0.0060897563,
0.0044400813,
0.0354342759,
-0.0326667316,
-0.0571604893,
0.0147963157,
0.0699966624,
0.0206012446,
0.0178054534,
-0.0240671802,
-0.0823410377,
-0.010705905,
0.0698197931,
-0.0483330339,
-0.0014847449,
0.07175304,
0.0482203662,
-0.0146004148,
0.0484155528,
-0.01092353,
-0.0353855267,
-0.0450989902,
0.0196367353,
-0.0126480274,
-0.0815183446,
0.0192257296,
0.0390678234,
0.0468381532,
-0.0514248088,
0.061916858,
-0.039802216,
0.0031424516,
-0.0142833125,
-0.0325255245,
-0.0349675305,
-0.0263899639,
0.0345078558,
0.010363983,
-0.0202244148,
-0.0012044111,
-0.0014872743,
-0.0020534962,
-0.0182848237,
0.0050704679,
0.0720344484,
0.0581019297,
-0.0034986732,
0.0339205377,
0.0242474228,
0.0110248262,
0.0112357745,
0.0294062644,
0.0004400722,
0.0019426758,
-0.0048582042,
-0.0202137921,
0.0162694473,
0.014005377,
-0.0274857767,
-0.0459460542,
0.0315655991,
-0.0192705356,
0.0435009785,
-0.0172744989,
0.0826932043,
-0.0200425703,
-0.006458451,
0.0010024207,
0.008139058,
0.0057992088,
0.0087343715,
0.0013107468,
-0.0229604747,
-0.0056449287,
0.0066513736,
0.061245352,
-0.0035014979,
0.0559120849,
-0.0239534266,
0.002354973,
-0.018345885,
-0.0067149568,
-0.0215778761,
-0.021096414,
-0.0206207745,
-0.0227352101,
-0.0853030756,
-0.0543609001,
-0.0005674915,
-0.0259186961,
0.0199983679,
0.0064780684,
0.0084546367,
0.0325389318,
-0.0297248848,
-0.0209021159,
-0.0290066991,
-0.0170961451,
-0.0086365268,
0.0114486497,
-0.0029620945,
-6.238835615e-33,
-0.0436740816,
-0.0249217395,
-0.0309267808,
-0.0389628261,
-0.0122717228,
-0.0353358798,
-0.0196539685,
0.01815941,
-0.0131870201,
0.0158181246,
-0.0374572724,
0.0169277564,
0.0348474085,
-0.0055553881,
0.0575247072,
0.0019683873,
0.0548457168,
0.0191490743,
-0.0204073209,
-0.0328630656,
0.0279140975,
0.0052629253,
0.0649326593,
-0.0835023373,
0.0819981396,
0.0065805926,
-0.0400129072,
0.0339836739,
-0.0107178567,
0.0037590871,
0.0089167757,
0.0969502032,
-0.0133092832,
-0.0071989838,
-0.0091302693,
0.0496667437,
-0.0858336091,
-0.0404275283,
0.0294513386,
0.0570161007,
0.0441421233,
-0.0265475698,
0.0224854853,
-0.0203851927,
-0.0007656766,
0.0059608351,
0.0524869151,
-0.0103247259,
0.0396493301,
0.0163402408,
-0.0387149863,
-0.0061781392,
-0.0385001972,
0.0110272272,
0.0195690803,
0.0351293571,
-0.0110681383,
-0.0445640273,
-0.0974125713,
0.0295490529,
-0.0374828726,
-0.0166592449,
0.0415240265,
-0.0109782135,
0.0106991939,
-0.0086330744,
0.0840499103,
0.010224184,
-0.0163657162,
-0.0323547721,
0.0211777892,
-0.0039990484,
0.0271923877,
0.1002921984,
0.0089538898,
-0.0335169025,
-0.0036034454,
0.0012472577,
-0.0022063029,
0.0008164764,
-0.0118644368,
-0.0166740697,
-0.0691324025,
-0.0480374433,
-0.0473627374,
-0.0765018314,
-0.0266559981,
-0.000038278,
0.0125414794,
-0.0278304126,
-0.0611847825,
0.0139294267,
0.0110027604,
-0.0471737161,
-0.0480937809,
-0.0113244364,
-0.019182073,
0.0113008358,
0.0078432914,
0.0253088269,
-0.0439043939,
0.0108836712,
-0.0184795447,
0.0470368341,
0.0320042521,
0.0195133183,
0.0229075234,
0.0232336912,
-0.0812547207,
0.0052352864,
-0.0284559447,
0.0063142055,
-0.0255428106,
0.0006879143,
0.0490721241,
0.0150848003,
-0.0040583033,
0.0088247964,
0.0587504767,
0.0528517663,
-0.0640208498,
-0.0174551085,
-0.0387885086,
-0.0159932114,
-0.0226085782,
0.0255282409,
-0.0297440588,
0.0149975419,
0.0766785741,
-0.0169187486,
-0.0274170507,
-0.0815588087,
2.639e-7,
0.0190274492,
0.0448527038,
0.0094046984,
0.0200654101,
-0.0109445686,
0.0511666909,
-0.0191259515,
0.0454812646,
0.0282441285,
0.0217877626,
-0.0068867467,
0.0204825774,
0.0717137828,
0.03872215,
-0.0916787982,
0.0097740442,
-0.0316019319,
0.0453019254,
-0.0531280972,
0.0259151086,
0.0102242501,
0.0776330009,
0.0491524078,
-0.0012783568,
-0.0204109084,
-0.0117844092,
0.035957586,
0.0005893398,
0.02041265,
0.0200743675,
0.0659325942,
0.0108853672,
0.0006777663,
-0.0145845506,
-0.0058627417,
0.0073063704,
0.0347029753,
0.0354980677,
-0.0024191926,
0.0156259183,
-0.0058709732,
-0.0270841755,
-0.0459974371,
-0.0140162483,
0.048037596,
-0.0243825726,
-0.0284586381,
0.0120341713,
0.0115193296,
-0.0057908101,
0.053649053,
-0.0393239297,
-0.0257584807,
0.0334430225,
0.0241164062,
-0.0335947834,
-0.0150192128,
-0.0434406921,
-0.0318083353,
-0.0241122488,
0.0159630235,
-0.0327665545,
0.0286200102,
0.0317383148,
0.0123333875,
-0.0414538719,
0.0233098753,
1.832492837e-34,
0.0039408715,
0.004703972,
0.0133134676,
0.0044431523,
0.0464221612,
-0.0269794669,
0.0265266877,
0.0025172303,
0.0205565747,
0.0384695269,
-0.0227644891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11350v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11350v2 | Romanian Multiword Expression Detection Using Multilingual Adversarial Training and Lateral Inhibition | 2023-04-22T09:10:49 | 2023-05-08T16:54:03 | Andrei-Marius Avram, Verginica Barbu Mititelu, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiword expressions are a key ingredient for developing large-scale and
linguistically sound natural language processing technology. This paper
describes our improvements in automatically identifying Romanian multiword
expressions on the corpus released for the PARSEME v1.2 shared task. Our
approach assumes a multilingual perspective based on the recently introduced
lateral inhibition layer and adversarial training to boost the performance of
the employed multilingual language models. With the help of these two methods,
we improve the F1-score of XLM-RoBERTa by approximately 2.7% on unseen
multiword expressions, the main task of the PARSEME 1.2 edition. In addition,
our results can be considered SOTA performance, as they outperform the previous
results on Romanian obtained by the participants in this competition. | [
-0.0063568125,
0.0358812585,
-0.0009969556,
0.0954709649,
-0.0374975614,
-0.0037886912,
0.0190859307,
-0.0030403514,
0.0087812394,
-0.0291071348,
-0.0797873959,
-0.0658773109,
-0.0409021452,
0.0055831601,
0.0384081788,
0.0292871073,
0.0832777321,
-0.0103218639,
-0.0217254777,
-0.0109207714,
0.0162833109,
0.0045829606,
-0.0248415135,
0.0250045452,
-0.0038560415,
0.0077702301,
0.0403878652,
-0.0245063994,
0.0097956546,
-0.0505828224,
-0.0015367147,
0.0009229681,
0.0126613602,
0.0114035616,
0.0000019356,
-0.0478768051,
-0.0520437807,
0.0075899451,
0.0063866707,
-0.0185618028,
0.0770072863,
-0.0348854512,
-0.0196497366,
-0.0035106861,
-0.0160876401,
-0.0174761843,
0.0259752646,
0.0860441774,
0.0345384441,
0.0511944927,
-0.0310918856,
-0.0392812863,
0.0324498303,
-0.0269475672,
-0.0612691231,
-0.0726232901,
0.0206218045,
-0.0563921146,
-0.0305470377,
-0.0672896579,
-0.0206219703,
0.0333906151,
-0.0167675968,
0.0175396092,
-0.0423213243,
0.0009736746,
-0.0087152449,
-0.0479607396,
-0.0028769802,
0.0528189689,
-0.0636562109,
0.0233519021,
-0.0149321305,
0.0074444334,
-0.0369588733,
-0.0142176896,
-0.0338568501,
0.0196025986,
0.0141808689,
0.032657776,
0.0128398417,
-0.0072049522,
-0.0001419845,
0.0370637998,
0.0244889464,
0.0857350975,
0.0379133634,
-0.0350640044,
0.0751116723,
-0.0194795746,
-0.0119132996,
0.0225572679,
0.0429679491,
-0.0052213776,
-0.0525695272,
0.0149660753,
-0.0136693073,
-0.104111053,
0.02968348,
-0.0843383148,
-0.0046685352,
0.0239773989,
-0.0360641815,
0.055594489,
-0.0842141658,
0.0485913418,
-0.0461874828,
-0.0056175929,
0.0097224005,
-0.029330954,
0.0135104964,
-0.0054773199,
-0.0552631728,
0.0128027573,
-0.0356819853,
-0.0205599274,
-0.0366104506,
0.0011564931,
-0.0018380443,
-0.0088235857,
-0.0390066653,
0.0019369249,
-0.0299355499,
0.0003061347,
0.0162333604,
0.0382002182,
-0.0248281527,
0.0047358326,
-0.0535198264,
-0.0672770068,
-0.0406655036,
0.0675178915,
-0.0053279372,
-0.0524120964,
0.0442564301,
0.0434204601,
-0.0506555326,
-0.0459121019,
-0.030346388,
-0.0276343953,
-0.0109680612,
-0.064242132,
0.0278501399,
-0.0228775386,
0.0222975779,
-0.0055150078,
0.0031100947,
-0.0794106275,
0.0269234255,
0.0131823495,
-0.0175048467,
0.0770314634,
0.0255598743,
-0.0433510318,
-0.0125656016,
0.0239897948,
0.0221810658,
0.0851172283,
-0.004926906,
0.0391292423,
0.0429902449,
-0.0040518912,
-0.0097175101,
0.0627430007,
0.0278532803,
0.0014438732,
-0.0619430505,
0.0097778747,
0.0141065428,
-0.0245673191,
0.0599675998,
0.0662683025,
-0.0049685617,
-0.0030653826,
-0.0085044308,
-0.0075826314,
-0.0217099283,
0.0536771826,
0.0207339805,
0.0185807776,
-0.0283962414,
0.0415641069,
0.0162443183,
-0.0009964854,
-0.001586754,
-0.0003494139,
0.0051594898,
0.0219743662,
-0.0081028249,
0.0051536215,
-0.0071257455,
-0.0430554301,
0.0503669269,
-0.0465907753,
0.0726639703,
0.0195797458,
-0.0846631899,
0.0157873146,
0.0504454188,
-0.0453655571,
0.0353884175,
-0.0593087301,
0.0153287277,
-0.0289043449,
0.0385678075,
-0.0492578149,
0.0226564351,
-0.002574797,
0.0071063265,
0.0693096146,
0.0514444411,
0.0208741184,
0.0419814698,
-0.0591428466,
0.004981983,
-0.0475352742,
0.0135349007,
0.0728324875,
-0.0477256514,
0.0253609829,
0.0061984258,
0.0296620019,
0.0006192918,
0.049218908,
0.0045594727,
-0.0177106019,
0.0105641,
0.0139033897,
0.0270282812,
0.0053220135,
-0.0155104352,
0.0109152822,
0.0582566932,
-0.0497936681,
0.0003228771,
-0.0013210133,
0.0291192085,
-0.041178558,
0.0322273038,
-0.0489066727,
-0.0378768705,
0.040856082,
0.0090385703,
-0.026585117,
0.0729439482,
-0.0078416634,
0.032316234,
-0.0455705412,
-0.0015711625,
0.0085580954,
0.0838003531,
0.0042173648,
0.0832918808,
0.0093034375,
0.0160654653,
0.0352077708,
-0.0396010578,
0.0513930097,
-0.0265702344,
-0.0450241044,
0.0308170505,
-0.0366688929,
-0.056680005,
-0.0188622009,
-0.0036446503,
-0.0239653457,
-0.0010154609,
-0.0320437625,
0.0111815128,
-0.0238662027,
0.0381072462,
-0.0281782858,
0.000389912,
0.0012527582,
-0.0473231301,
-0.0413159691,
-0.0140674179,
0.041870594,
0.0218689591,
0.0283336286,
-0.0113129206,
-0.0085871583,
-0.0460410975,
0.0274750665,
-0.0275965352,
0.0227842256,
-0.0192277282,
-0.0531731322,
0.0015719195,
0.0146624595,
-0.0064704125,
0.0558968894,
-0.0245908257,
-0.0691435933,
-0.0109714521,
0.0155484974,
0.0371872634,
0.0466959104,
-0.0173740927,
-0.0020416235,
0.0288453139,
0.0091695245,
0.0142033836,
0.0504291505,
0.0173327345,
0.0610122047,
-0.0483982116,
0.0321175084,
0.0147006419,
0.0624018759,
0.0163473822,
0.0149686914,
0.010199884,
-0.0249250401,
-0.0345219299,
-0.0316968374,
-0.0256126691,
-0.0425626561,
-0.0212839544,
-0.0220175926,
-0.0002625522,
0.0184111558,
0.0491192825,
-0.0493541099,
-0.0521235354,
-0.0773787126,
-0.0139828231,
-0.0136586754,
0.0585506633,
-0.0137517173,
0.0254752953,
-0.0314206406,
-0.0203112904,
-0.0493549034,
-0.0357577726,
0.0063995677,
-0.016414104,
0.0237813182,
-0.0032095774,
-0.0291959736,
-0.0364496335,
-0.0280135311,
-0.0454535969,
-0.0539278239,
-0.0063304086,
0.0106697129,
0.0474706106,
0.0288572721,
-0.0407747999,
0.0329416953,
-0.0108052297,
0.0078103971,
-0.0330720097,
0.0457407385,
-0.0229412895,
0.0324506313,
0.0394617431,
-0.0059512784,
0.0288920514,
-0.0173557624,
0.0080963904,
0.0253943335,
0.0076517281,
-0.0107515734,
0.0324100517,
-0.0282270107,
0.0288842879,
-0.0324319936,
-0.041367583,
-0.0626418591,
0.0137906764,
-0.0485488847,
0.0006865249,
0.0839552134,
-0.0048557743,
-0.0305601843,
-0.0009476875,
-0.0212943889,
-0.0071328836,
0.0151328687,
0.0196645912,
-0.0401171446,
-0.0426019654,
-0.0054962975,
-0.0324416645,
0.001881347,
0.017532466,
-0.0041386327,
-0.0933983177,
-0.0303468276,
-0.015429236,
-0.0555534624,
-0.0171927158,
-0.0242494587,
-0.0149233155,
-0.030426437,
0.0034021533,
-0.01898445,
-0.0090877153,
-0.0057575363,
0.0033270156,
-0.0284068231,
-0.0522537827,
0.0058110785,
-0.0523041748,
-0.0077558905,
0.071378924,
0.0516308062,
-0.0647345111,
-0.0771407932,
0.088899456,
-0.025666045,
0.0141159063,
-0.0237673614,
0.0281086043,
-0.0061054104,
-0.0236212537,
0.0331187621,
0.0002405497,
-0.0269337483,
-0.0095275417,
0.0131752864,
0.0484077334,
0.006839029,
0.0224090777,
0.0103252707,
-0.0067547909,
0.023720894,
0.0580934472,
-0.0083872555,
-0.0281779375,
-0.0266362354,
-0.0142099597,
0.0180900358,
-0.0612140745,
-0.0187166966,
-0.0011616744,
-0.0316121057,
-0.0409201421,
-0.0339652039,
-0.0529692098,
0.0279527064,
0.0371952914,
-0.0058911294,
0.0158161614,
-0.0312794,
0.0265742317,
-0.0156536568,
-0.0196484625,
0.0283280872,
0.0114034694,
-0.0222896412,
0.0038134763,
0.0016183298,
-0.0189717766,
-0.0427389704,
0.0194957107,
-0.0528091826,
-0.0294744745,
0.0131377233,
0.0123794843,
0.0135281952,
-0.0006019249,
-0.0507978648,
-0.0381877162,
0.0141234398,
0.0300730914,
-0.0326865762,
-0.0156467687,
0.0475421175,
-0.0510552116,
-0.0168250948,
0.0371119305,
-0.0138718905,
0.0428570509,
0.0360166207,
0.0283472035,
0.0235769562,
0.0288169645,
0.0126877883,
0.0473505408,
0.0668528527,
-0.0285826121,
-0.0120210173,
-0.0542252809,
-0.0020736021,
-0.0084177675,
-0.0394122377,
0.0018035976,
0.0325676166,
0.0273306519,
-0.0266029015,
-0.0174491424,
0.0136776473,
-0.0134358462,
-0.0047789337,
-0.0124987075,
0.0275466982,
0.0560133979,
0.020241743,
-0.0132200718,
0.0328340009,
-0.0151484739,
0.0362111256,
0.0192793291,
-0.0248092636,
-0.0146766519,
0.0234161615,
-0.0168483295,
-0.0221001897,
-0.0005635397,
0.0034195893,
0.0169108622,
0.051654879,
-0.0304474607,
-0.0036522064,
0.076473102,
-0.0046966551,
0.100408487,
-0.0036006914,
-0.0222360361,
-0.0030489292,
0.0052652834,
-0.0119496007,
-0.0265426338,
0.0448143855,
-0.0139892567,
-0.0433248244,
-0.0523342341,
0.0663714334,
-0.0285180304,
0.057873074,
0.0152410669,
-0.0227870326,
-0.0476679578,
-0.0618900657,
0.0559403673,
0.0075208587,
-0.0251163878,
0.0171544757,
-0.0355934687,
-0.0282979682,
-0.0016403463,
0.0208520871,
-0.0182846542,
-0.0077557,
0.0250037499,
0.0619361065,
0.0434949473,
-0.0269646868,
-0.0484987386,
0.0181883778,
0.0029257794,
0.0064038262,
-0.0314026065,
-5.916578614e-33,
-0.0260535032,
0.0195106547,
-0.0029157707,
-0.0188598949,
-0.0288801827,
0.0140491016,
-0.009711165,
0.003261836,
-0.0191374067,
0.0245803539,
0.018506648,
-0.0114684869,
0.0250912011,
-0.0034034019,
0.0035607617,
-0.0473169647,
0.0325257741,
0.0081148082,
-0.0129458932,
0.0121542495,
0.0221514329,
0.0668306649,
0.1063048616,
-0.0245386139,
0.0354452506,
0.0166623909,
-0.0494976677,
0.0158067457,
0.0112894038,
0.094913736,
-0.0316515788,
0.0266246516,
0.0189071391,
-0.0223887153,
0.0117620388,
0.0063089952,
-0.0089660967,
-0.0280563645,
0.0324658677,
0.0574553721,
-0.0450507663,
-0.0096801091,
0.0480130129,
-0.0127029605,
-0.0177470725,
0.0778101459,
0.0349673741,
-0.0300427023,
0.0097213462,
-0.010650889,
-0.1019582897,
0.019184513,
0.029515516,
-0.0152237238,
0.0313666314,
0.0553720817,
0.028127823,
0.0048736944,
-0.0956102014,
0.0083774347,
-0.0782923028,
0.023060536,
0.033180628,
-0.0116491504,
0.03220018,
0.0688615888,
0.0116469273,
-0.041411154,
0.0117991911,
-0.0189629793,
0.0693515539,
0.0418527164,
0.0588532835,
0.0597680323,
0.0593151338,
-0.0423909575,
-0.0856255144,
-0.0184498429,
0.0796031654,
0.0782104805,
0.0109047135,
-0.0035524496,
-0.0174850635,
-0.0034971847,
0.0131021682,
-0.0475934036,
-0.0318887234,
-0.0360468961,
0.0250343494,
0.00930179,
-0.0342792384,
0.0300945956,
0.0206846837,
-0.0102447076,
-0.0338983163,
-0.0110562267,
-0.0090488549,
-0.0251538306,
0.0008350968,
0.0589881651,
-0.0324709676,
-0.0489028692,
-0.0241518561,
0.000757027,
0.0481141917,
-0.0181563292,
0.0545993447,
0.0223942753,
-0.069951795,
0.0033298107,
-0.0316141844,
0.0086702891,
0.0208808873,
0.0848425254,
0.0199234709,
-0.0249163993,
-0.0018080783,
0.0473344699,
0.028689241,
-0.0016541564,
-0.0376655869,
-0.0409606807,
0.0368404612,
0.0296770781,
-0.0267094485,
-0.0095907291,
-0.0003774,
-0.0215260722,
0.0240430254,
-0.057712134,
0.0103890356,
-0.0121850725,
2.648e-7,
0.0457380041,
0.0167508218,
-0.007592767,
0.0042963629,
0.0284272265,
0.0064501651,
-0.0544367507,
0.0388111919,
-0.0738939866,
0.09392488,
-0.0170856789,
0.0039007738,
0.0316819958,
0.0391549803,
-0.0525500923,
0.0056612841,
-0.0529284403,
0.0061579943,
-0.0284443274,
0.0109160328,
0.0161611382,
0.1058379933,
-0.0019846109,
0.0038547299,
-0.0612080805,
-0.0674480498,
0.0561150983,
0.0152122043,
-0.0330500193,
0.026678171,
-0.0068227211,
0.0333498716,
-0.0191282611,
0.0057103899,
-0.0176194627,
0.0416233949,
0.04515801,
0.06716232,
0.0100453952,
-0.0023339889,
0.0687404126,
-0.0034185017,
-0.0267634969,
0.0027739648,
0.0941005722,
0.0100336531,
0.0052157547,
-0.0582306907,
0.0162295997,
0.0240941253,
0.0481124409,
-0.0237763673,
-0.0280804839,
-0.002142254,
0.0356694348,
-0.0526491515,
-0.0576099418,
-0.0446926057,
-0.0250859894,
-0.0075447117,
-0.0193655547,
0.0064563998,
-0.0017499623,
-0.0220372565,
0.0153119545,
-0.0143589806,
-0.0074041621,
2.188437578e-34,
0.0425844789,
-0.021915542,
-0.017965192,
0.0219694152,
0.0273873508,
-0.0047645518,
-0.0300833248,
0.0126049314,
-0.0198167861,
-0.0266429801,
0.0133464634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11340v1 | Semantic Specialization for Knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-04-22T07:40:23 | 2023-04-22T07:40:23 | Sakae Mizuki, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | A promising approach for knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) is
to select the sense whose contextualized embeddings computed for its definition
sentence are closest to those computed for a target word in a given sentence.
This approach relies on the similarity of the \textit{sense} and
\textit{context} embeddings computed by a pre-trained language model. We
propose a semantic specialization for WSD where contextualized embeddings are
adapted to the WSD task using solely lexical knowledge. The key idea is, for a
given sense, to bring semantically related senses and contexts closer and send
different/unrelated senses farther away. We realize this idea as the joint
optimization of the Attract-Repel objective for sense pairs and the
self-training objective for context-sense pairs while controlling deviations
from the original embeddings. The proposed method outperformed previous studies
that adapt contextualized embeddings. It achieved state-of-the-art performance
on knowledge-based WSD when combined with the reranking heuristic that uses the
sense inventory. We found that the similarity characteristics of specialized
embeddings conform to the key idea. We also found that the (dis)similarity of
embeddings between the related/different/unrelated senses correlates well with
the performance of WSD. | [
-0.0091267023,
-0.0377560407,
0.0045819278,
0.0592828728,
-0.0215125699,
0.0262876879,
-0.0491001606,
-0.0017706212,
0.0146895098,
-0.0380952433,
-0.0260643139,
0.0562504008,
-0.0132288765,
-0.0413186923,
0.011667341,
0.0117646027,
0.1035645008,
0.012750471,
-0.0569824763,
0.0008475705,
-0.0040557613,
0.0146804955,
0.0006067516,
-0.0224821288,
-0.0241672695,
-0.0165588912,
0.0370482579,
0.0042639333,
0.0351202488,
-0.0248799138,
0.0131923277,
0.0147764143,
0.0667562634,
0.0334092639,
0.0000020812,
-0.0575925857,
-0.0391283147,
-0.010887282,
0.0167537238,
-0.0356669761,
0.053417556,
-0.0533585027,
0.0362036973,
-0.0093376096,
-0.0184240825,
0.007253001,
0.0293962061,
-0.0327872001,
0.0456929579,
0.0170298442,
-0.0122954594,
-0.0649092868,
-0.051572945,
0.0005484674,
0.0234884694,
-0.0042743334,
0.0013680295,
0.0192645509,
-0.0274867564,
-0.0308047961,
-0.0557027757,
0.0434213541,
-0.0171280298,
0.0286217835,
0.0499988273,
-0.0100251045,
-0.0017338814,
0.0137857487,
0.0033418394,
0.0627636537,
-0.0111659998,
-0.029640818,
-0.0058303215,
-0.0167874154,
-0.0315369591,
0.0137650417,
0.0375664048,
-0.0404782742,
0.0079265665,
0.0224235784,
0.0266750939,
0.0567228608,
0.0483286679,
0.0538566262,
-0.0311021451,
0.0734236091,
0.0149908764,
-0.0321402065,
0.007759674,
-0.0092332317,
-0.0195427034,
0.0295524001,
0.0306852087,
-0.0157851651,
0.0133505277,
0.0507453941,
-0.0462790057,
-0.0707376897,
-0.0015230814,
-0.0608446449,
-0.0489765368,
0.0313064493,
0.0295911543,
0.0615975372,
-0.0278094057,
0.0160917901,
0.006723911,
0.0404052958,
-0.0803855285,
-0.0173297711,
-0.0617500879,
0.0323752835,
-0.0507959835,
0.0460096411,
-0.0377888493,
-0.0173253883,
-0.0483359657,
0.0251753982,
-0.0117144249,
-0.0057272185,
-0.0204201508,
0.0001077721,
-0.0520515628,
-0.0045626932,
-0.0141776847,
0.0100306459,
-0.0408147462,
-0.0088142902,
-0.0694225803,
0.0334509797,
0.0042209821,
0.0431570113,
-0.0026155021,
-0.0334155075,
-0.0094516482,
0.0230824035,
-0.0077244858,
-0.0305760838,
-0.0427655764,
-0.0375634804,
-0.0457445569,
0.007195455,
-0.0432301536,
-0.0442582332,
0.0193692446,
-0.0002599047,
0.0036305594,
-0.0861854181,
-0.0354919918,
-0.0172559209,
-0.0214532129,
0.1215501726,
-0.0478361286,
-0.0430993214,
0.0127675356,
0.0316544734,
0.0315562338,
0.0663808063,
0.0158833489,
0.0149097862,
0.0486251265,
0.0323892459,
-0.1015642509,
-0.0162252039,
-0.0197087787,
0.009787255,
-0.0322911069,
-0.0057172254,
-0.0347613208,
0.0598419905,
0.0595944673,
0.0365758799,
-0.0727148503,
-0.013954089,
-0.002859843,
0.0537086241,
0.054094363,
-0.0290586092,
0.0378874019,
0.012575293,
-0.0378213115,
0.0106795877,
-0.028859321,
-0.027690962,
-0.0142104141,
-0.0139006767,
0.0208824687,
-0.0009289742,
-0.0177010037,
-0.0369462371,
0.0081050154,
-0.0456870869,
0.0318755247,
0.029429324,
0.0212399326,
0.0305464715,
-0.0058517517,
0.0192779824,
0.0429634154,
-0.024330033,
0.0309574045,
-0.0181795303,
-0.0028872408,
0.0823172331,
0.0377824455,
-0.0740931556,
-0.0300618764,
0.0324343294,
-0.022729151,
0.0256991852,
0.0390582904,
-0.0410709158,
0.0085323798,
-0.0524784587,
-0.0287109967,
-0.026936911,
0.0113047976,
-0.0155440057,
0.001452568,
0.0309634507,
0.0342085697,
-0.0943690538,
0.0282405559,
0.0343229845,
-0.0121851405,
-0.0411209017,
-0.0274485145,
0.0323732495,
-0.0026289611,
0.0247278921,
-0.0089964448,
0.021871537,
0.0067177769,
-0.065963313,
0.0101056378,
-0.0011525151,
-0.0524346158,
-0.0663050488,
0.0377868339,
-0.0042732218,
-0.0058540157,
0.0088975802,
-0.0290276203,
-0.0170544274,
0.0306340791,
0.0135287177,
0.0551488958,
-0.0690678805,
0.013539969,
-0.0174943916,
-0.0112907104,
-0.0713118911,
0.0575601235,
-0.0063041043,
0.0014884796,
-0.0222119167,
0.0629806593,
0.0101351384,
0.0424389206,
-0.0587095544,
-0.0102758994,
0.0329274274,
0.0135605633,
0.0306647941,
-0.0111122224,
-0.0496251211,
-0.0102541186,
-0.042331785,
0.0108668227,
-0.0121345324,
0.005247809,
0.0287547428,
0.0494885817,
0.0209283736,
-0.0172910858,
0.0240021478,
0.0364970863,
-0.0195080917,
0.0143453619,
0.0281683933,
-0.0256388709,
0.0184040144,
-0.023814505,
-0.0008872776,
-0.0064746141,
0.0273979958,
-0.0082715191,
-0.0149467019,
-0.0319614746,
0.0400309227,
-0.0922771767,
0.0167390909,
0.0097718872,
-0.0210693348,
-0.021950556,
-0.0166099742,
0.0158105642,
0.0119647067,
-0.0149161685,
0.0199514851,
0.1058443487,
0.0089705875,
-0.0330688357,
0.0110719725,
-0.009874681,
0.0356746763,
-0.0194261577,
0.0229534153,
-0.0022566132,
0.0236196555,
0.0258973613,
-0.0206693616,
-0.0151705705,
0.0354478396,
-0.04376892,
-0.0376770608,
-0.0175017398,
0.0335863978,
-0.0053990935,
-0.0033891555,
-0.033884611,
-0.0341715179,
0.0639562681,
0.0165590439,
0.0469666049,
-0.0923229605,
-0.0133515168,
0.0011476727,
0.0561954044,
-0.0334287584,
0.0424383171,
-0.0150563959,
0.0176056772,
-0.0700252503,
-0.0501674972,
0.0608825944,
-0.0340480246,
0.0167784337,
-0.0404752642,
0.0405282713,
0.021916274,
0.0143480422,
-0.0230919737,
-0.019844627,
-0.026609743,
0.019947011,
0.0700216219,
0.0375423878,
0.0287461337,
0.0124613084,
0.0091054626,
0.0355501994,
0.0659376308,
-0.0247205552,
-0.0259179454,
0.0079457564,
0.048318401,
0.0039738761,
0.0259775706,
0.0307122692,
0.0287401024,
0.0138421645,
-0.0074629583,
-0.0889005437,
-0.0471366383,
0.0152961919,
0.0355861969,
-0.0562296174,
-0.0396905541,
-0.0174426697,
0.0262349751,
-0.0219448525,
-0.0117155015,
0.1183301508,
0.0547743738,
-0.0495684482,
0.0081191063,
0.0089310128,
0.0049961973,
0.0173331834,
-0.0277716573,
-0.0379443988,
-0.0456729345,
-0.0036024987,
0.0044969236,
0.0609862246,
-0.046481207,
-0.0206848569,
-0.0512690358,
-0.0039769118,
0.0176544078,
-0.0440639816,
-0.0466193706,
-0.0098592583,
0.0147118093,
-0.0168833937,
0.0084474394,
-0.0227780212,
0.0053995242,
0.0081642242,
-0.0172691569,
0.0005201583,
-0.0174085256,
0.01108984,
-0.0372308008,
0.0165342204,
0.0457306691,
0.0289254785,
0.0642485097,
-0.0046832552,
-0.0678822324,
-0.0788675174,
-0.0102633061,
-0.040447183,
-0.0089322831,
-0.03346733,
0.0110686496,
0.0217559319,
-0.0195840597,
-0.0386512503,
-0.0088345334,
-0.0054854634,
0.0219787359,
-0.0308389384,
-0.00262124,
-0.0398235768,
-0.0151913119,
0.0044202283,
0.0789036825,
-0.0200054385,
-0.0037426103,
-0.0211423915,
0.0344314314,
0.0363698862,
-0.0092216628,
-0.0001675904,
-0.0306358282,
-0.0600736588,
0.0281566139,
-0.0865253657,
-0.0431369282,
-0.0105209723,
0.0414364524,
-0.0253988747,
0.0607083961,
0.0023938757,
-0.0148033695,
-0.0671104863,
-0.0047264541,
-0.0293827076,
0.0117784664,
0.0185390804,
0.0200549643,
0.0356563441,
-0.0081400014,
-0.0356608555,
0.0289546065,
-0.0404257327,
-0.0286647696,
0.0051343003,
0.0083160354,
0.0071470146,
0.0539431944,
-0.0567920767,
-0.0220991224,
0.0460379831,
0.0061020711,
-0.0114330724,
0.0363687091,
0.0133092906,
0.0363443643,
-0.0135560753,
0.0688308328,
-0.0396357365,
0.0461187102,
0.0269924197,
0.0181618426,
-0.0056376816,
-0.0109448209,
0.0053895419,
0.0181701817,
0.0444838144,
-0.0321786664,
-0.0152022978,
-0.0317156389,
-0.0274841748,
-0.0439898297,
-0.0403014719,
-0.0090604117,
0.0181106478,
0.0128541701,
-0.0146252252,
-0.0136239687,
0.0647224933,
0.0136836376,
-0.0139878131,
-0.0108017912,
0.0077876565,
0.0428367741,
0.0008967664,
-0.0421121232,
0.0186222605,
0.0007232229,
-0.0092046093,
-0.0185110215,
-0.0311267097,
-0.0423549861,
-0.0273725297,
-0.0077359444,
-0.013781148,
-0.0767165348,
0.0519664586,
-0.0094069364,
0.0143718934,
0.004550667,
0.0323159657,
0.0674816743,
-0.0333180763,
0.0568086319,
0.0176666509,
-0.0147812692,
-0.0058155563,
0.0323787741,
0.0255126208,
0.0382066928,
0.0040311841,
0.0194770042,
0.0001000543,
0.0342945531,
0.0468800291,
-0.0419067107,
0.0468124822,
0.011229814,
-0.0354982205,
-0.0302266218,
-0.0108284065,
-0.0052535087,
0.0905711651,
-0.0181416851,
0.0380735248,
-0.054898981,
-0.0806077868,
0.0629559755,
0.0026501168,
-0.0490051098,
0.0427952297,
0.0786843374,
0.0378323644,
0.0064542587,
-0.0122291688,
0.0079215942,
-0.0356149264,
-0.0415523537,
-0.0615350381,
-0.0147955967,
-5.797820992e-33,
-0.0046738004,
0.0138446372,
-0.0045831027,
-0.0664539188,
-0.0404158011,
0.0195578746,
0.0063799419,
-0.0331853963,
-0.052952107,
0.0175659843,
0.0192068461,
0.0295873266,
0.0019070341,
0.0081868218,
-0.0545814857,
0.0158015341,
0.0521398745,
0.0021420715,
-0.0153202284,
0.0003295908,
0.0492666923,
0.0162162781,
0.0415133499,
-0.0448291078,
0.0209657513,
-0.0035512049,
0.007430397,
0.0256849807,
0.0680473521,
0.031189397,
-0.02263253,
0.1009593308,
0.0113691017,
0.0172067974,
-0.0288531482,
-0.0212400593,
-0.0951858386,
-0.0995393395,
0.0409574434,
-0.0359982215,
-0.0492960103,
-0.0150702251,
0.0684677139,
-0.0032441313,
-0.0040327813,
0.0138057703,
0.0298990682,
-0.0188503861,
-0.0638335645,
-0.0124494089,
-0.0515685752,
0.0340419225,
-0.0181914419,
-0.0315012112,
0.050242763,
-0.059307415,
0.013477237,
-0.0066624829,
-0.0552340411,
0.0267417803,
-0.0673491955,
0.0334434323,
0.0342425443,
0.0184845328,
0.0027311109,
0.0382939018,
0.0135872941,
-0.0620399155,
0.053470321,
-0.0156727806,
0.0327046439,
0.0020632101,
0.0195839237,
0.102178894,
0.0395005867,
-0.0427750051,
-0.0453057289,
0.0039865891,
0.017504815,
0.0259924531,
-0.0005471649,
0.024959052,
-0.0374307409,
-0.0287945829,
-0.0766741931,
0.0080529582,
-0.0216505788,
-0.0226019565,
0.0284296386,
0.0137445237,
-0.0428170785,
0.0143057099,
-0.0069432217,
-0.0365592204,
0.0677169636,
0.0272368733,
0.0112042753,
0.000633903,
0.031666629,
0.0153420828,
0.0147158261,
-0.026336465,
0.0085325399,
0.0128446389,
-0.0110639418,
-0.0062423386,
-0.0104243057,
-0.0093047088,
0.0144503787,
0.0179604087,
0.0235253852,
-0.0581548475,
-0.0453958511,
-0.0545519032,
0.0135939764,
0.0281328447,
0.0187018979,
0.0102526983,
0.0673561543,
-0.0157187823,
0.0229938943,
-0.0308532678,
0.0190033056,
0.0503365472,
-0.0157871451,
0.0248528328,
0.0212694723,
0.0142054893,
0.0060925996,
-0.0357408114,
-0.0061305012,
-0.0240865853,
2.806e-7,
0.0688258708,
0.0126258815,
-0.0350658447,
0.0134577602,
0.0041984087,
-0.0239019319,
0.0436477661,
0.0179461427,
-0.0629159436,
-0.0325028412,
0.0341104753,
0.0273647886,
-0.0180343837,
0.0208745543,
-0.006095551,
0.0425174609,
0.0166791175,
0.0516691208,
0.0042439871,
-0.0232668016,
0.066661343,
0.0755970702,
0.013087485,
0.005286979,
-0.0610193871,
-0.058062423,
0.0165447146,
-0.0202206094,
0.0307677016,
-0.0016158528,
0.0085814875,
0.0290924925,
0.0297861416,
0.0317662098,
-0.0378230065,
0.0076995944,
0.0480397455,
0.0273369588,
-0.0423924103,
-0.0199735053,
-0.0360166952,
0.0066055395,
0.0322883651,
-0.0245588161,
0.0796674937,
-0.0545331575,
0.0225432776,
0.0069593126,
-0.0401296839,
0.0488215201,
0.0282646883,
0.0243648589,
-0.0742842034,
-0.0090315947,
0.0373124368,
0.0282637589,
-0.0491269231,
-0.0954865515,
0.0039087706,
0.0419656821,
-0.0190932248,
-0.0160665885,
0.0200340338,
-0.056447234,
0.0571026728,
-0.0556241162,
0.0002515156,
2.199937218e-34,
0.0260741338,
0.0206673406,
0.0094269095,
-0.0438253321,
0.0241652206,
-0.010027566,
-0.0228237528,
0.0094518438,
0.0518749021,
-0.0229593497,
0.0153641189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11164v1 | Dialectical language model evaluation: An initial appraisal of the commonsense spatial reasoning abilities of LLMs | 2023-04-22T06:28:46 | 2023-04-22T06:28:46 | Anthony G Cohn, Jose Hernandez-Orallo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have become very popular recently and many claims have been
made about their abilities, including for commonsense reasoning. Given the
increasingly better results of current language models on previous static
benchmarks for commonsense reasoning, we explore an alternative dialectical
evaluation. The goal of this kind of evaluation is not to obtain an aggregate
performance value but to find failures and map the boundaries of the system.
Dialoguing with the system gives the opportunity to check for consistency and
get more reassurance of these boundaries beyond anecdotal evidence. In this
paper we conduct some qualitative investigations of this kind of evaluation for
the particular case of spatial reasoning (which is a fundamental aspect of
commonsense reasoning). We conclude with some suggestions for future work both
to improve the capabilities of language models and to systematise this kind of
dialectical evaluation. | [
0.04481842,
0.0388962887,
-0.0183559228,
0.0310609471,
-0.0750687271,
-0.0056074713,
0.0029798946,
0.0118826311,
0.0214884058,
-0.0686551183,
-0.0078040324,
0.0248637609,
0.0352477245,
-0.0509575903,
0.0066193696,
-0.028483998,
0.0070338091,
-0.0193890333,
-0.0505289473,
-0.0073398431,
-0.046843715,
-0.0097881583,
-0.0197863802,
0.0281464607,
0.0215266626,
0.0112639964,
0.0095601706,
-0.0147548867,
0.0096297469,
-0.0067887604,
-0.0319827013,
-0.0002258691,
0.0038100178,
0.0103833536,
0.0000020512,
-0.024770163,
0.0242268648,
-0.0102986638,
0.0384534709,
0.0170160849,
0.0308234207,
0.0071574198,
-0.0074668461,
-0.0293988232,
-0.0188333672,
0.0291097574,
0.0048812744,
0.0168474261,
0.0040542553,
0.005321471,
-0.0028456196,
-0.0555962473,
-0.0050758095,
0.0147856418,
-0.0153765399,
0.0002297859,
0.0050976388,
0.0420205779,
0.0578295887,
0.006141643,
-0.0263297111,
0.0455916002,
0.0256681852,
0.0185948052,
-0.0630428419,
0.0309304483,
-0.0423920527,
0.0405288152,
-0.0023112262,
0.0394559391,
0.0732320398,
-0.0236734394,
0.0029625269,
0.0219751988,
0.0026064615,
0.0679635406,
-0.0683786124,
0.0211063605,
0.0086452691,
0.0401664488,
0.0137985777,
-0.0050968318,
0.0090832813,
0.0327552073,
-0.0138264215,
0.119663015,
-0.0032655722,
-0.0295639597,
-0.0035099846,
0.0153697645,
0.0099532604,
-0.0320404172,
-0.0038553246,
0.0700384304,
-0.0071776267,
0.0250371527,
0.0541287176,
0.0795769766,
0.0358950272,
-0.0851273164,
0.0366277732,
0.0065200678,
-0.0110409688,
0.038827233,
-0.0120782237,
0.0495680459,
0.0094130188,
0.0904699564,
-0.0238296203,
0.0190443099,
-0.0674511194,
-0.0005481744,
-0.0066626868,
0.0246495996,
-0.0247262288,
0.0174620338,
0.007458935,
-0.0137095433,
-0.0092486478,
0.0307716802,
0.0179240312,
0.0066294968,
-0.0086156884,
-0.0456806049,
-0.0482537635,
0.0130096888,
-0.028884273,
0.0686691403,
-0.0295894295,
-0.0297679417,
0.0072534154,
0.0042879665,
-0.0250895061,
-0.0270534065,
-0.0193324555,
0.0274852812,
0.0290603787,
-0.0059889294,
-0.0684492886,
-0.010558119,
-0.0304329824,
-0.036364086,
-0.0064121513,
-0.0796700791,
-0.0437402688,
0.0203050859,
-0.0224222355,
0.013117129,
-0.0087570464,
-0.021255102,
-0.0288114399,
0.0383186713,
-0.0090275332,
0.0215360168,
0.0267472304,
0.0452633239,
0.0413618796,
0.0708175823,
0.0263177734,
0.00976911,
0.0074587478,
0.0319787525,
0.0089744925,
-0.0113761351,
0.0023942941,
0.0341745578,
-0.0776593238,
0.0286779776,
-0.0311311819,
0.016176831,
0.0165155884,
0.0498721302,
-0.0210953858,
-0.0084824245,
0.046912048,
0.0964781791,
0.0174364988,
-0.0139814699,
0.0009430501,
-0.0006236552,
-0.016736988,
0.0086637996,
-0.026436381,
-0.0121357609,
-0.0318907313,
0.0198664665,
-0.0414033867,
0.0220256317,
-0.0038593465,
-0.0362777039,
-0.0496015996,
0.0090820584,
0.0321600176,
-0.0281758849,
0.0409979112,
-0.0167800039,
0.0127346152,
0.0830138549,
0.0110780355,
-0.0490982048,
0.015164244,
-0.0418643393,
-0.0025043681,
0.0272818431,
0.0346605666,
-0.0004483927,
-0.0264243558,
0.0113688819,
0.0252733454,
0.0214862563,
0.0334694386,
0.0062452271,
-0.013257876,
-0.037573345,
-0.0123586021,
-0.0012438126,
0.0110265194,
-0.0092008868,
-0.0022193971,
0.0364072472,
-0.0040210374,
-0.0797144398,
0.0257273298,
0.0110913161,
0.008509445,
0.0378871188,
-0.0886675417,
-0.0003362058,
-0.0066195033,
-0.0073843757,
0.0024232867,
0.035825856,
0.0357572176,
-0.0072807106,
0.0020716761,
0.073178798,
-0.0146235367,
-0.0528384149,
0.0413845554,
-0.0529451184,
-0.006947984,
0.0028837877,
-0.0081738774,
-0.0115880379,
0.0234307181,
-0.0367827564,
0.0608844906,
-0.0281598233,
0.001610091,
-0.0435761474,
-0.0834741518,
-0.0378910787,
0.0803026929,
-0.0616193265,
0.0428088531,
-0.0276310239,
-0.0014595556,
0.0526446253,
-0.0247374438,
0.0035060472,
-0.0104463389,
0.0155142797,
0.0132622756,
-0.0344462693,
0.0355570354,
-0.0253763143,
-0.0509527177,
-0.1083920151,
-0.0208976194,
-0.0116659859,
0.0221848283,
-0.0180838481,
-0.0680951402,
-0.0032686035,
0.0133289844,
0.0067263399,
-0.0240717623,
0.0194004048,
0.0359809697,
0.0418099165,
-0.0102660181,
-0.0141495364,
0.0161327068,
0.0032793446,
-0.019588016,
0.0288767871,
0.009317169,
0.0535530895,
-0.0171414372,
0.0118178623,
-0.0251489747,
-0.0062041734,
-0.0074505797,
-0.0389677249,
0.0381859653,
0.0126280505,
-0.0198575109,
0.0297176186,
-0.0328342095,
0.0164686628,
0.0375544764,
-0.0651093498,
-0.0424511321,
-0.0025431865,
-0.0069434652,
0.0054079411,
-0.0343827754,
-0.0489807464,
-0.055664178,
0.0219064374,
0.015676057,
-0.0019471685,
-0.0388010666,
0.0448539406,
-0.0426363014,
0.0074279699,
-0.0406980254,
0.0132415369,
0.0034350592,
0.0902124643,
-0.0307024885,
-0.0372208953,
0.0199478641,
-0.0454813875,
0.0255361386,
-0.0372710116,
0.0099072075,
-0.063004449,
0.0846532211,
-0.0472316705,
0.0093431165,
-0.0464458391,
-0.0233451966,
-0.0033743521,
-0.075818941,
-0.0048368648,
-0.0110280411,
0.0590776466,
-0.0754958168,
0.0274145063,
-0.0199278295,
-0.0570966341,
0.0032714636,
0.0069268905,
-0.0476809591,
0.0133684501,
-0.0084674479,
-0.0133778797,
0.0030888384,
0.0728692934,
0.0166305564,
0.0061754193,
-0.0060630562,
-0.0163732283,
-0.0114227515,
-0.0062981825,
0.0091867195,
0.1019571498,
0.0149304196,
0.0497756861,
-0.0529147685,
0.0404063985,
-0.0119210333,
0.0032523798,
0.0102529395,
0.0579019003,
0.0241231378,
-0.0207348987,
-0.0315434188,
0.016747823,
0.0742889643,
-0.0522711612,
-0.0742583796,
0.0648688152,
0.0556789972,
0.0438113958,
0.0121594146,
-0.0504855029,
-0.0182243418,
0.0139804482,
-0.018164264,
-0.0263455529,
-0.0087424656,
0.0131068043,
-0.021502912,
-0.0071736933,
-0.0418099165,
0.0476168245,
-0.0744841471,
0.0582313612,
0.0190119743,
-0.0742548406,
-0.0357052088,
-0.0323008597,
-0.0149743473,
0.0165253095,
-0.0180484354,
0.0066976445,
0.0044469917,
0.0145045361,
0.0306481849,
-0.0257567689,
-0.0554721542,
0.0107225776,
-0.0254996009,
0.0464343838,
-0.0189200751,
0.0623126589,
-0.0008836922,
-0.1519397646,
-0.0045672059,
-0.007360213,
0.0290904511,
-0.025922548,
-0.0640185997,
0.0224342644,
0.0069906726,
-0.0363401175,
-0.014622598,
-0.0643517151,
-0.0474298745,
0.0032465765,
0.0701209381,
-0.0524851307,
0.0411130413,
-0.0516926125,
0.046683304,
-0.0021066589,
0.0741853416,
0.0436697043,
0.0539574549,
-0.044770401,
-0.0256789364,
-0.0633536875,
-0.0200740602,
-0.0395518206,
0.0401718207,
0.0575721227,
0.0261803288,
-0.0166133195,
-0.0231598783,
-0.0050949152,
0.0660603791,
-0.0047048545,
0.0288264491,
-0.0117060672,
-0.0022190171,
-0.037710283,
0.0239080135,
-0.0130550507,
-0.0056809923,
0.0026167235,
0.0560067445,
0.0272876974,
-0.0171119273,
-0.0236714426,
-0.0094934227,
-0.0229490474,
-0.0484606549,
-0.0130119026,
0.0398057625,
0.0332755037,
-0.0306038354,
-0.0153021039,
0.0130565735,
0.0150489612,
0.0188657921,
0.0063628363,
0.0266569015,
0.0317555368,
0.038219247,
0.0366745107,
0.0319825746,
0.0315960497,
0.0050196322,
0.0160672572,
0.0381068587,
-0.0766066089,
0.0000814005,
-0.0289508384,
-0.0208553113,
0.0219953787,
-0.0066086985,
0.0004488612,
0.0108983256,
-0.0009727614,
-0.0565119907,
-0.0326761268,
-0.0088832369,
0.009788218,
0.0289309639,
-0.0037287532,
-0.0379301272,
0.0243244823,
-0.0570380203,
0.0537424907,
0.0213706251,
0.0272031445,
0.0471740812,
0.0068476922,
0.0059412047,
-0.0171168167,
-0.0120890941,
-0.004556647,
-0.0570498854,
0.061621733,
0.0222388972,
0.040670719,
0.04826653,
-0.0193649326,
-0.0145912142,
0.0095814196,
-0.035311345,
-0.0297342967,
0.0313243158,
0.0708475783,
0.0309783686,
0.0011708887,
-0.0124354139,
-0.0150435111,
0.0171763077,
0.0285240449,
0.0204078201,
0.0400015004,
-0.0182988625,
0.0505141504,
0.0082717026,
-0.0313993841,
0.0003009065,
0.0269091874,
-0.0356936082,
0.0092428857,
0.0037881273,
-0.0342215523,
-0.0112005128,
-0.0723794848,
0.0199651718,
0.0299860872,
0.0121650035,
-0.0007527384,
-0.1249956116,
-0.0385296494,
-0.0099795908,
0.0664486289,
0.0206065886,
-0.0151232341,
-0.0033455503,
0.0836062878,
0.045099698,
-0.050905522,
-0.0332267992,
0.0193631444,
-0.0570971929,
0.0193079803,
-0.0170763433,
-6.065871172e-33,
-0.050004866,
-0.0557146966,
0.061563842,
-0.0464097671,
-0.0167715736,
-0.0287680626,
-0.0213359501,
0.0102369506,
-0.0279329196,
-0.0006193899,
0.0053963521,
0.0158038568,
0.0108325547,
-0.009143671,
-0.001890967,
0.000095421,
-0.0234177876,
0.0402430631,
-0.0303381402,
-0.0567502752,
0.0339990109,
-0.0499167964,
0.0368156955,
-0.0342719965,
0.0344929211,
-0.0025706303,
-0.005419095,
0.0196455587,
-0.0609225221,
0.0478151143,
0.0185249764,
0.0227703508,
0.0308483038,
-0.0233870745,
0.0192567073,
0.0201592986,
-0.030031126,
-0.062970981,
0.0677457228,
0.0019201152,
-0.0098503185,
-0.0190137494,
0.0442061983,
0.0318676978,
-0.0758237094,
0.0193716884,
0.0038193117,
-0.0455791689,
-0.0547075905,
0.0105202813,
-0.0305395778,
0.029152466,
-0.0109446207,
-0.003242403,
-0.021287512,
-0.0443429612,
-0.02200111,
-0.0059897527,
-0.067917183,
0.011601029,
0.0682838857,
-0.0307994876,
0.0747113377,
-0.0219209511,
-0.0039184242,
0.0376736224,
-0.0465730987,
0.01924848,
-0.056032028,
0.0053713252,
0.0679292455,
0.0661895052,
0.0296848416,
0.0398734063,
-0.0258079451,
0.0140575506,
-0.0626015887,
0.0332755595,
-0.0430958048,
0.053391993,
0.0168781336,
0.0184454117,
-0.0595932007,
-0.037230745,
-0.0558625162,
-0.032521151,
0.004404461,
-0.0010375484,
0.0131701557,
-0.0287461933,
0.0034054506,
0.0270873122,
-0.0135369767,
-0.0184787307,
-0.0389506035,
0.0145342406,
-0.0091021722,
-0.0012783761,
-0.0149309738,
0.0479032993,
-0.0599272586,
0.0054719215,
-0.0050040567,
0.0835127681,
-0.0079251109,
0.0301270429,
-0.0010420352,
0.0009285329,
-0.012088404,
-0.0307861455,
-0.0289437734,
-0.0298089795,
-0.0289289672,
-0.0067955782,
0.060550794,
-0.0017687902,
0.0169538297,
0.043179065,
-0.0403098576,
-0.0090154698,
0.0069732107,
0.043123845,
-0.0176993962,
0.0243318584,
0.0133908717,
0.0192988515,
-0.0297381133,
-0.0062869377,
0.0342086069,
-0.0021621173,
0.0112277977,
0.0538613237,
2.635e-7,
0.0309101492,
0.0305502489,
0.0045760768,
-0.0183943082,
0.0077733556,
0.0268027727,
-0.0503806658,
-0.0261073392,
-0.0038571917,
-0.0110477163,
0.0163887553,
0.0721127465,
0.0314905718,
0.0384875834,
-0.0413379669,
0.0245745461,
-0.0528407283,
-0.0331817381,
-0.0552616268,
0.0333922729,
0.0866164938,
0.0078347223,
0.0313731506,
-0.0082385559,
-0.0084854327,
-0.0592790395,
0.0059428834,
-0.0508762114,
-0.0058169286,
0.0141776223,
0.0496534221,
-0.0121712843,
0.0138445273,
0.0139015885,
0.0430233404,
-0.0109036611,
-0.0250413083,
0.0509140752,
-0.0049594385,
-0.046983894,
-0.0253164005,
-0.1150239259,
-0.0050339359,
-0.0841610283,
0.0770644471,
-0.0582032166,
-0.0136136664,
0.0157870706,
0.0366107598,
0.0008069728,
0.0463902615,
0.0138799809,
-0.0059181377,
-0.0335397981,
0.0377497226,
-0.0302258208,
-0.0090252319,
-0.0742558464,
0.0054905713,
0.0383546576,
0.0053667231,
-0.0658233985,
-0.0110560451,
0.0151732536,
-0.0001492828,
-0.0731195062,
-0.0488749593,
2.323525985e-34,
-0.0083348248,
0.0035177199,
0.0008057207,
-0.0169048812,
0.0398124456,
0.0360894576,
-0.0111723198,
0.0151705015,
0.0085322578,
-0.0366166569,
0.0382198021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12810v1 | Transcending the "Male Code": Implicit Masculine Biases in NLP Contexts | 2023-04-22T03:53:24 | 2023-04-22T03:53:24 | Katie Seaborn, Shruti Chandra, Thibault Fabre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Critical scholarship has elevated the problem of gender bias in data sets
used to train virtual assistants (VAs). Most work has focused on explicit
biases in language, especially against women, girls, femme-identifying people,
and genderqueer folk; implicit associations through word embeddings; and
limited models of gender and masculinities, especially toxic masculinities,
conflation of sex and gender, and a sex/gender binary framing of the masculine
as diametric to the feminine. Yet, we must also interrogate how masculinities
are "coded" into language and the assumption of "male" as the linguistic
default: implicit masculine biases. To this end, we examined two natural
language processing (NLP) data sets. We found that when gendered language was
present, so were gender biases and especially masculine biases. Moreover, these
biases related in nuanced ways to the NLP context. We offer a new dictionary
called AVA that covers ambiguous associations between gendered language and the
language of VAs. | [
0.0512203425,
0.0466616005,
-0.0469881371,
-0.0068971915,
0.0095885303,
0.0245941654,
0.038696181,
-0.0237300117,
0.0025948517,
-0.0638286844,
0.0093318298,
-0.0455639437,
0.0501639396,
-0.0242874809,
0.0406324007,
-0.0206384994,
0.0390138812,
0.0365805738,
0.015362733,
0.0070443987,
0.0222437065,
0.0673135668,
-0.0152310794,
0.0746603832,
-0.0034626599,
-0.0485651307,
0.0536347814,
0.0072550331,
-0.0299225058,
-0.0075817686,
0.0295373499,
0.0109399157,
0.004127196,
0.0184986591,
0.0000019008,
-0.0531043224,
0.0163330995,
0.0260342564,
-0.0191002712,
-0.0428522378,
-0.0013483819,
0.0173768047,
-0.0254209861,
0.0352308303,
-0.0285705514,
-0.0509591438,
0.0354253761,
0.0134035386,
0.0359182097,
0.0175389405,
-0.015994085,
0.0101790791,
-0.0788666755,
0.0032216243,
-0.0370940268,
0.005369945,
0.0128125856,
-0.0571377613,
-0.0174617581,
-0.0136683462,
-0.0147732114,
-0.0155467568,
-0.0159250423,
-0.0083479397,
-0.0023443105,
0.0307471938,
-0.0499501862,
-0.0603995882,
0.0096584205,
0.0147718135,
0.035706047,
0.0350386389,
0.0072852126,
0.0245293081,
-0.014185355,
0.0290225409,
-0.0080872243,
0.0547025204,
-0.0390517488,
-0.0300930999,
-0.0357726067,
-0.0530934334,
0.0079806969,
0.0485607311,
0.032635577,
0.0417677984,
-0.0020312569,
-0.045724459,
0.042576395,
-0.0078524565,
0.0128650591,
-0.0271132514,
0.0055787843,
-0.0022522616,
-0.0155294929,
0.0169570316,
-0.0220679138,
-0.0441353917,
0.0307800267,
-0.0561344326,
0.0465165935,
0.030781487,
0.0052519245,
-0.0050598406,
-0.0178741086,
0.031036254,
0.0341938436,
-0.0125441868,
-0.0032282376,
0.0010780949,
-0.0466736406,
-0.0435963385,
-0.0329463668,
-0.0064694323,
0.0374574997,
0.0331242941,
-0.0117046889,
-0.0067332271,
-0.0411452241,
0.0327725112,
-0.0365126692,
0.0459241048,
-0.0295763928,
0.0384762883,
-0.0107346959,
-0.0109462067,
-0.0773774534,
0.0553497523,
-0.0582890697,
-0.1023852006,
0.0403144993,
-0.0133370832,
-0.0013785607,
-0.0206295718,
0.0139351757,
0.0162517708,
0.0086458921,
-0.0523893572,
-0.0007829294,
-0.0166267324,
-0.0130924648,
-0.0187240113,
0.0227679536,
-0.0418118834,
0.0177070592,
0.0302811284,
0.0066223033,
-0.0010114432,
0.0106651289,
0.0425488502,
-0.0413386486,
0.0963507295,
0.0693609938,
0.0274363104,
0.0725506693,
0.009093008,
-0.0464879721,
0.0739055499,
0.0326746255,
-0.004553895,
0.0311186817,
0.0192363411,
0.0164337642,
0.0048128753,
-0.0126616685,
0.0199630577,
-0.0303720813,
0.0331414454,
-0.0140121616,
0.0360244289,
0.0551199056,
-0.0094024213,
-0.0083573097,
0.0202868637,
0.0399092324,
0.1049199253,
0.025209913,
0.0500938855,
0.0499033332,
0.0012003564,
0.0000317909,
-0.0267078355,
-0.0533907861,
-0.0288687814,
0.0090315389,
-0.05508551,
-0.0452834442,
-0.0009054804,
-0.0176884327,
-0.0292750932,
-0.0125657348,
0.0027019321,
0.0197600797,
-0.0145148216,
0.0084495172,
0.0447627045,
0.0059655155,
0.0130826412,
0.0206502806,
-0.034856122,
-0.020758843,
-0.0297948364,
-0.015838895,
0.0402997695,
0.0088072941,
0.0059426562,
-0.0043712105,
-0.0496983491,
-0.0216207113,
0.0216947086,
0.0357653014,
0.0121941818,
0.0114054345,
-0.0232053772,
-0.0157978088,
0.0494591706,
0.0332655534,
0.0181628801,
0.0103247631,
0.0365608521,
0.0022868577,
-0.0008556503,
-0.0612381063,
0.0319637582,
-0.0060411468,
-0.0607435778,
0.0149089824,
0.0430658907,
0.0106143514,
0.0384445228,
-0.0388896726,
0.0001390209,
-0.0009751561,
-0.0077261506,
0.0076594362,
0.0125530651,
0.0227037445,
0.050796885,
0.0043660547,
-0.0528310388,
-0.0818566531,
0.0611559488,
0.0260099955,
0.0074076816,
0.0214227848,
-0.047801394,
0.002726638,
0.0046139671,
-0.0087860897,
0.0034663,
0.0350825265,
0.021526413,
-0.0213264916,
-0.0203095637,
0.0055438736,
-0.0028548425,
-0.0023608794,
-0.0036696652,
-0.0225685183,
-0.0476776659,
0.0225772504,
-0.0231185984,
0.0207480397,
0.032971248,
-0.0288270302,
-0.029266566,
-0.0169504583,
-0.0721100494,
-0.0079336315,
-0.0015068385,
-0.03573687,
-0.0048047984,
-0.0037251352,
-0.0488923229,
-0.0195102654,
0.0295217391,
-0.0448202007,
-0.0301056243,
0.0454077199,
0.040530771,
-0.0280956533,
0.034796048,
-0.0128798215,
-0.0038972159,
-0.049765382,
0.0331214219,
0.0010015796,
0.0147936381,
-0.0299906414,
-0.0020308357,
-0.0457435176,
-0.0088245003,
-0.0070416564,
-0.0573636852,
0.0745290518,
0.0289527606,
0.0266112369,
0.0719382986,
0.0193867423,
0.0251594223,
0.0700197518,
0.0206753407,
-0.009929264,
-0.0096728271,
0.0271666348,
-0.0116450451,
0.0607240684,
-0.0761675686,
-0.0254415851,
-0.0049846009,
0.0159384981,
-0.006477017,
-0.0366567746,
0.0545406081,
-0.0404234342,
-0.0522431284,
0.0023696006,
-0.0190821085,
-0.0326408595,
0.0478050001,
-0.0216390658,
-0.0451245829,
0.0003361376,
0.0027306897,
-0.0409562439,
-0.0492147282,
-0.0173368566,
-0.0034912173,
0.0467768647,
-0.0526077747,
0.0265587382,
0.030237129,
-0.0525265373,
-0.0707254037,
-0.0175538324,
0.0044944831,
-0.0485761687,
0.0255291127,
-0.0266990867,
0.0190578587,
0.0087668486,
0.0116220983,
-0.0380362533,
-0.0199287664,
-0.0340223499,
0.001499059,
-0.0137120476,
-0.0197263379,
-0.0127840061,
-0.0101788444,
-0.0088386843,
0.003775846,
-0.0038777168,
-0.030021118,
-0.0172262751,
-0.0522968061,
0.0356611088,
0.0326008275,
0.006688226,
0.0381939411,
-0.0083423061,
0.0286913309,
0.0000436467,
0.0164636541,
-0.0241260864,
0.0136950836,
0.024700325,
-0.0319316648,
0.0005691081,
-0.0188037548,
0.0148650929,
-0.0373659097,
0.0291644149,
0.044223085,
0.0162020102,
-0.0244075898,
0.0225671995,
-0.0168148596,
-0.0046961275,
0.0479820892,
0.0034640674,
-0.060583327,
0.0284536909,
0.0369022153,
0.0397028886,
-0.043451149,
-0.0461231172,
-0.0247065034,
-0.1340815723,
0.0096637513,
-0.0086330967,
-0.0407385975,
-0.0412971303,
-0.0578192435,
0.025595963,
-0.0144291837,
0.0427809581,
-0.0439426713,
-0.0235063192,
0.0262970049,
0.0048307776,
-0.0168656055,
-0.0255136713,
0.0352519788,
-0.0695463344,
0.0549754649,
0.0431301296,
0.0720866844,
-0.0227344837,
0.0193005577,
-0.0177893005,
0.0127341328,
0.0201644897,
-0.0463268608,
0.0172436312,
-0.0629316047,
-0.0186926965,
-0.0199627187,
0.0118848225,
0.0361051597,
0.0162891429,
0.0079418058,
0.0007253682,
-0.0012009243,
0.0039744321,
-0.0611261763,
0.0053059068,
0.0044938144,
0.0416550934,
0.0066757817,
-0.0170083418,
0.0244797841,
-0.0297986846,
0.0575472079,
0.0993757695,
-0.103056483,
-0.0186107736,
0.0014849146,
-0.0256753992,
-0.0149974357,
-0.1150656715,
0.0359576568,
0.0081928326,
0.010203518,
-0.0582684912,
-0.0111183496,
0.0271223094,
-0.0606292523,
0.0349355787,
0.0366010666,
0.0314675085,
0.029026337,
-0.0421230644,
-0.0160965752,
-0.0181445349,
0.0069956388,
0.0247208402,
0.0613155551,
-0.0364231057,
0.0417107902,
0.0466925353,
0.0144950496,
0.0649401695,
0.0000831552,
-0.0531023033,
0.0214981493,
0.0473440178,
-0.0728956684,
0.0211161394,
0.0597558767,
0.0643715262,
0.0016693274,
0.0253073219,
-0.0316444412,
0.0157823656,
-0.0434203073,
-0.0014286733,
-0.0322587602,
-0.0065446952,
0.0099831559,
-0.0154573759,
0.0113029042,
-0.0518050231,
0.0759224668,
-0.0085697779,
-0.0367086306,
-0.0170341674,
-0.0284807235,
-0.0102852937,
-0.0254848376,
0.0113624977,
0.0408645496,
-0.0407060049,
-0.0156974737,
-0.0448823981,
0.0445248038,
-0.0036416079,
0.0083308509,
0.0199606344,
0.0429478697,
-0.0303141922,
0.0304823983,
0.0359492078,
-0.0068393638,
-0.031505242,
0.0215689093,
0.031473957,
0.0232668761,
0.0035832995,
0.045233544,
-0.0434625819,
0.0032334197,
-0.0329476371,
-0.0843234658,
0.0134936981,
-0.0024442233,
-0.015199827,
-0.0802603513,
0.0514953062,
-0.0286534578,
0.0162528567,
0.0315148644,
-0.0136261098,
0.0085038971,
0.0179764125,
0.0263114702,
0.0293388329,
0.0124375047,
-0.0153743234,
0.0155387884,
-0.0261068698,
0.0894873962,
-0.0193571877,
-0.0214402601,
-0.0296072382,
-0.0042699086,
0.0474130288,
-0.0081424043,
0.0047906148,
0.0070423475,
-0.097507976,
-0.0456888229,
-0.0013270435,
-0.0701758638,
0.0228052549,
-0.0259424355,
0.0059265625,
0.0459578671,
0.0002163445,
-0.0493719205,
-0.0388191454,
-0.0037235201,
-0.0116464011,
0.020666834,
-0.0198846534,
-5.59644081e-33,
-0.033227697,
-0.052609805,
-0.0232144408,
-0.0409230106,
-0.0212838184,
0.0095518995,
0.0107084364,
-0.0130032282,
0.0079736384,
0.0013511309,
-0.0289987922,
0.0395754091,
0.0076869591,
-0.0185011663,
0.0518416539,
0.0229771622,
0.0568216108,
-0.0267970636,
-0.0154635105,
-0.0369732827,
-0.0077019883,
0.0257637296,
0.0485360809,
-0.1127052754,
0.0992109776,
0.0143286707,
-0.0016430136,
0.0109787621,
0.0243906882,
-0.0039329082,
-0.0175578222,
0.0555723645,
0.0088021904,
-0.0032001403,
0.025962567,
0.079474546,
-0.0594200864,
-0.028043285,
0.0241634827,
0.0450934283,
0.0430374146,
0.0095764408,
0.0146870073,
0.0132131344,
-0.0247666687,
-0.0166180953,
0.065837875,
0.011205961,
0.053422682,
0.0212193709,
-0.041165255,
0.0065742554,
-0.061882332,
-0.0237190519,
0.0398520641,
0.0422810577,
-0.0131863132,
-0.0308774542,
-0.0934049934,
0.0219676401,
-0.0608482435,
-0.0301305056,
0.0421367437,
-0.009502707,
0.0186016485,
0.0290452726,
0.0941455662,
0.0570373721,
-0.0574784018,
-0.0301182568,
0.0426946469,
-0.0078742756,
-0.0246503931,
0.0118907988,
0.0230413359,
-0.0396615565,
0.0130128888,
-0.0383762754,
0.0217416231,
0.0645442158,
-0.0157059524,
-0.0250576064,
-0.0952343568,
-0.0402959809,
-0.0319419838,
-0.0937167779,
0.0019536614,
-0.0370656848,
0.0260641202,
-0.0238760337,
-0.051498767,
-0.0004571782,
-0.0557302125,
-0.0543610007,
-0.048424568,
-0.0351893008,
-0.0379905552,
-0.0261384025,
0.036805395,
-0.0285957791,
-0.0411264449,
0.0231216475,
0.0151756154,
0.042333629,
0.0511166379,
0.0271709301,
-0.0286473352,
0.0384327546,
-0.0697861984,
-0.0214761011,
-0.0028114617,
-0.0059297364,
0.0214663856,
0.026520215,
0.0635815859,
0.0218102187,
-0.0164498705,
0.0149675217,
0.0747125819,
0.0351256207,
-0.0281441063,
-0.027126899,
-0.0449504815,
0.009965634,
-0.0360523202,
-0.0051168227,
-0.0517720096,
0.0409211181,
0.0998506323,
-0.0349551626,
-0.0153014539,
-0.0955024734,
2.56e-7,
-0.0050765714,
0.074886933,
-0.003298813,
0.0168784838,
-0.0014189371,
0.0333408751,
0.0307354759,
0.0504656695,
0.0415168181,
0.0087752463,
-0.0186530463,
0.0089851599,
0.0046875561,
0.0425996333,
-0.0236399472,
0.0024540126,
-0.072090894,
0.0361341201,
-0.0113907009,
0.0390509404,
0.0084011378,
0.0618670806,
0.022755431,
-0.0161052458,
-0.0583892763,
-0.0143086817,
-0.0240798295,
0.019212747,
0.0504988991,
-0.0168792177,
-0.0149403075,
0.0301632006,
0.0067262123,
0.0206436049,
0.0053785886,
0.0389053449,
0.0372597165,
0.0210677478,
-0.0471878164,
0.0232881848,
0.0175681934,
-0.0082334317,
-0.0533699095,
-0.0059610419,
0.0511013009,
-0.0004024059,
-0.0562537685,
-0.0430390537,
-0.0385029428,
0.0190325659,
0.0730155408,
-0.0108508533,
-0.0223426335,
0.0516158454,
-0.0072425208,
-0.0315811746,
-0.0196902584,
-0.0539540537,
-0.0048774076,
-0.0240628663,
0.0088311853,
-0.0369934551,
0.0161402952,
0.0617520064,
0.0151722617,
-0.0257511884,
0.0184590723,
1.651636718e-34,
-0.0259912126,
0.0279487483,
0.0207450055,
0.0362859368,
0.0176963173,
0.0084530469,
0.0638309643,
0.0173042063,
0.0549071245,
0.0581730828,
-0.0167607833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11292v1 | On the Identification of the Energy related Issues from the App Reviews | 2023-04-22T01:54:30 | 2023-04-22T01:54:30 | Noshin Nawal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The energy inefficiency of the apps can be a major issue for the app users
which is discussed on App Stores extensively. Previous research has shown the
importance of investigating the energy related app reviews to identify the
major causes or categories of energy related user feedback. However, there is
no study that efficiently extracts the energy related app reviews
automatically. In this paper, we empirically study different techniques for
automatic extraction of the energy related user feedback. We compare the
accuracy, F1-score and run time of numerous machine-learning models with
relevant feature combinations and relatively modern Neural Network-based
models. In total, 60 machine learning models are compared to 30 models that we
build using six neural network architectures and three word embedding models.
We develop a visualization tool for this study through which a developer can
traverse through this large-scale result set. The results show that neural
networks outperform the other machine learning techniques and can achieve the
highest F1-score of 0.935. To replicate the research results, we have open
sourced the interactive visualization tool. After identifying the best results
and extracting the energy related reviews, we further compare various
techniques to help the developers automatically investigate the emerging issues
that might be responsible for energy inefficiency of the apps. We experiment
the previously used string matching with results obtained from applying two of
the state-of-the-art topic modeling algorithms, OBTM and AOLDA. Finally, we run
a qualitative study performed in collaboration with developers and students
from different institutions to determine their preferences for identifying
necessary topics from previously categorized reviews, which shows OBTM produces
the most helpful results. | [
0.0820510983,
0.0149306338,
-0.0259604175,
0.0236940011,
-0.0128272716,
-0.0171875972,
-0.0468393564,
-0.0098679336,
-0.0281770267,
-0.0709698573,
0.0127355661,
0.016055271,
0.0143909026,
0.0161300674,
-0.0333239622,
-0.0066415379,
0.0314598791,
0.0303331017,
0.0407942832,
0.0838687122,
0.0168722216,
0.0138829397,
0.0410602912,
0.0376235694,
-0.01951476,
-0.0369636938,
0.0301797017,
0.026858421,
0.0140242977,
-0.0379825942,
0.0090103764,
0.0353466608,
-0.0769962221,
0.0105818035,
0.0000020437,
-0.003293074,
-0.008261078,
-0.0422011763,
0.0596458875,
0.0257656612,
0.1219700426,
0.0180559028,
0.0204584207,
0.0220494885,
-0.0329706222,
0.009468466,
0.0269098897,
0.0456629172,
0.0500369444,
0.0198884103,
-0.0214113165,
-0.0091559868,
-0.0263290647,
0.0266752783,
0.0282035526,
0.0155108673,
-0.0086602056,
-0.0012468135,
0.0082575073,
0.0041111447,
0.0390827879,
0.0009044182,
-0.0006963218,
0.007914233,
0.0248439312,
0.002986422,
-0.0306173917,
-0.0089163799,
-0.0157917179,
0.0833726376,
-0.0210026708,
0.0098649096,
-0.0168168917,
-0.0301172584,
-0.0537524149,
0.0278106872,
-0.0210417211,
-0.0249835178,
-0.0201872326,
0.0335187353,
0.0067346063,
0.0198013522,
0.0558803342,
-0.0031171895,
0.0117289154,
0.0217071455,
-0.0173759609,
-0.040115647,
0.0236704946,
0.0389613807,
-0.0002580014,
-0.0114468243,
0.0242012944,
-0.0309956074,
0.0320770964,
0.0273076873,
-0.0067628575,
-0.0532260798,
0.0061031622,
-0.0831515864,
0.0487569012,
-0.027140582,
0.0141795371,
-0.017737085,
0.0201657265,
0.0164098609,
0.0353002436,
-0.0343012437,
-0.0593151003,
0.033309672,
-0.0411505215,
-0.0026894731,
0.0223903768,
0.0438636616,
0.0072111608,
-0.0275617614,
-0.0251984801,
0.0087804934,
-0.0199232418,
0.0119942455,
0.0123857912,
0.0551225059,
0.0281294398,
0.0226933341,
-0.0078503415,
0.0261479132,
-0.0429372266,
0.0235912632,
-0.0498645008,
0.0073932,
0.0248745177,
-0.0095978808,
0.0071458956,
0.0300546344,
-0.0147676803,
0.020990653,
0.0799411163,
-0.0121316249,
-0.0587000996,
-0.038361907,
0.0042113424,
0.028225854,
-0.0250716172,
-0.0669350401,
-0.034672372,
-0.0230291039,
0.0200004503,
-0.0132633541,
0.0015800989,
0.0368705355,
-0.0323772468,
0.0305535998,
-0.0802865624,
0.016955724,
0.0223154537,
0.037256375,
0.0030122183,
0.0313280262,
0.0291274861,
0.0780057237,
0.0649168193,
-0.0188211147,
0.0259888284,
0.0152483191,
-0.0152974548,
-0.0507382937,
-0.0047862614,
-0.0318002068,
-0.0840255246,
-0.0231211614,
-0.0180636048,
0.0182024818,
0.0251145437,
0.0188796483,
0.0415687077,
0.0758558959,
-0.0037224831,
0.0296948347,
-0.0441755429,
0.0490310416,
-0.0160753503,
-0.0324663781,
0.0269270986,
0.022458341,
-0.020071635,
-0.0169035457,
0.0026964077,
-0.01375187,
-0.0161437523,
-0.0608589202,
-0.0480479114,
-0.0173995476,
0.0086285183,
0.0200574845,
0.0260599274,
0.017217895,
-0.0262160152,
0.0419552401,
0.0282879267,
-0.0072036451,
-0.0456607677,
-0.0259806309,
0.0417387858,
0.0803380907,
0.0285242591,
0.0034915647,
0.0169416219,
-0.0079063307,
-0.0444492921,
-0.0496099591,
0.0649623051,
-0.0304856617,
-0.016800914,
-0.0394361168,
-0.0075472454,
-0.0627032071,
0.0079388293,
-0.0066609574,
-0.0385350771,
0.0360000655,
0.0274726599,
-0.0093062231,
-0.074117668,
0.0153109003,
0.0619756281,
-0.0170335211,
0.071289435,
-0.0062216967,
0.0522975512,
0.0327376537,
0.0128370076,
0.0241843909,
0.053883113,
-0.0362668373,
-0.0156910587,
-0.0004414065,
-0.0095853461,
0.0082050962,
0.012418869,
0.0015661857,
0.020774059,
0.0474080853,
-0.0100785699,
0.0077372962,
0.0266843047,
-0.0257738885,
0.0410420261,
0.0322821625,
0.0242812913,
-0.0224074423,
-0.0274226852,
-0.0338282436,
0.0548500717,
0.0068336315,
0.0469631813,
-0.0604592189,
-0.0266885553,
-0.0127594043,
0.042017404,
0.0065849819,
0.0043038107,
-0.0321690366,
0.0140658598,
0.0046571069,
0.0025986931,
0.0070762495,
-0.0075265174,
-0.1132988036,
0.0064545106,
-0.0177535191,
0.0135073131,
0.037047293,
0.0174157266,
0.0038793206,
0.0272643343,
-0.0006962123,
-0.0075693275,
-0.046274785,
-0.0047235764,
0.0072401552,
0.0146998521,
0.027610844,
-0.0372821987,
-0.0191895366,
-0.0586634502,
0.0426756665,
0.0223269481,
-0.0516545139,
-0.0234460197,
0.0160196554,
0.0306951422,
-0.0595094413,
0.0036842071,
-0.0174032804,
-0.0059780115,
0.0059843347,
0.0667934716,
-0.0108177047,
0.0122143179,
0.0279113986,
0.0265689082,
-0.0398013219,
-0.0460593365,
0.0263427589,
0.0253167991,
0.0312010404,
0.0381778814,
-0.0743377283,
0.0964488238,
0.0721656084,
0.0007724562,
0.0225995257,
0.0209726878,
0.0354502089,
-0.0539719239,
0.0163279194,
-0.0306375716,
0.0136888931,
0.0121061346,
0.0020161003,
-0.0253032278,
-0.0304089468,
0.0646137446,
-0.023594046,
0.0672498047,
-0.1147072315,
-0.0394279957,
-0.0115560815,
0.0385235175,
-0.0318609998,
0.0399963893,
-0.0396698937,
0.0151470406,
0.0569790341,
-0.0276429113,
0.0056151627,
-0.0090400586,
0.0396705344,
-0.0450012013,
-0.0253095292,
0.0132265594,
-0.0137961712,
0.02499827,
-0.0665135682,
-0.0255759843,
-0.0749459714,
0.0177372936,
-0.0098856194,
-0.034425687,
0.0503333025,
-0.0231296867,
0.0111049004,
0.0183229242,
-0.0295762401,
0.0301368497,
0.0109492568,
0.0565240942,
-0.0713203102,
0.0016081461,
-0.0093387244,
0.039292343,
0.0291159227,
0.0062692142,
0.0078420304,
-0.0675407872,
-0.0084411735,
-0.0026629388,
-0.0253053252,
-0.0229180269,
0.0390618704,
0.0144921513,
-0.0274630189,
0.051374875,
0.0956499428,
0.0576305054,
-0.0575933158,
0.0263556689,
-0.0021119812,
-0.0453750752,
0.0186490268,
0.0179064106,
-0.0641814396,
-0.033679489,
-0.0038371584,
0.0522447936,
-0.0008389817,
0.0101993224,
-0.0273673479,
-0.0512986109,
-0.0217793938,
-0.0033424031,
0.024166489,
-0.0068547991,
-0.0382935368,
-0.0057655866,
-0.0332038775,
-0.0217398982,
-0.0783278048,
-0.0095533291,
0.0049285297,
-0.0162801184,
-0.0816700533,
-0.0122777112,
0.0455791838,
-0.0421068743,
-0.0102804322,
0.0924120918,
0.0525339916,
-0.0104899313,
-0.0039260504,
0.0101899644,
-0.0121565722,
-0.0059966254,
-0.0174535811,
0.0068591977,
0.0006664809,
0.0252044238,
0.0307027344,
0.0085067227,
-0.0614111125,
-0.0066907569,
0.0584875382,
0.0571948998,
-0.02452063,
-0.0384859256,
-0.0717547908,
0.0011638491,
0.0340607576,
0.0416609496,
0.0090835411,
-0.0528312624,
-0.0346370116,
-0.0125029813,
-0.0164509229,
-0.0051661669,
0.0167076644,
-0.0194647294,
0.0095739681,
-0.052657865,
-0.0413917713,
-0.0120488452,
-0.0194604974,
0.0221316889,
0.042048391,
0.0232321303,
0.0423798934,
0.0110183125,
-0.0173427388,
0.040942885,
0.0627190843,
0.0173278507,
-0.0082885893,
-0.0363146774,
0.0685238019,
0.0390796475,
-0.0078795692,
-0.0176687464,
-0.0570979528,
-0.0177527554,
-0.0481211878,
0.0437036678,
0.0093741948,
0.0354596637,
-0.0391057841,
-0.046717938,
-0.0595563166,
0.0557126328,
-0.0519675985,
-0.0423596613,
-0.0347238407,
0.0088798478,
0.0041910689,
-0.0166579001,
-0.0387848839,
0.0522375293,
-0.0415670238,
-0.0169178657,
-0.0623542853,
-0.0155648133,
0.0108517241,
0.004352659,
0.0586813465,
0.0388386212,
-0.0317531787,
-0.031423986,
-0.0387576707,
-0.0026991537,
-0.0016973205,
-0.0399977751,
-0.0029258272,
0.0080992635,
0.0125452094,
-0.046593491,
0.0224495586,
0.0027435056,
-0.0173567496,
-0.0452805832,
0.042491626,
0.0126805604,
0.0614994466,
-0.0306972545,
0.00191032,
-0.0197794288,
-0.0067405538,
-0.0033144343,
0.0018056674,
-0.0253993813,
0.0001447507,
-0.0249116719,
0.0229398031,
-0.0298501365,
0.0679751709,
-0.0019776183,
-0.0242539328,
-0.0186855942,
-0.0207829457,
-0.0168796889,
-0.0025051716,
-0.0209416319,
-0.0242264494,
0.0063473112,
-0.0122855743,
0.0048326645,
-0.0493434779,
0.014578837,
0.049287457,
0.0348207615,
-0.0480717868,
-0.0014684206,
0.0443269275,
-0.023540318,
-0.0360865369,
0.0213120412,
-0.0799752772,
-0.0605247952,
0.0572481677,
0.0273680389,
0.0030416921,
-0.032110177,
-0.022091262,
-0.0353403166,
-0.0089909434,
0.0218930263,
-0.0363835022,
0.066741854,
0.0136981318,
0.0467185788,
0.1217447892,
0.0138393808,
-0.0204072241,
-0.0511801951,
-0.0491763726,
-0.0816204846,
-0.0186886434,
-0.0450627245,
-5.99826886e-33,
-0.0021304754,
-0.034914799,
-0.0289851185,
0.0164719652,
0.0128154773,
0.0115602566,
-0.0214339178,
0.0166574512,
0.0045399615,
-0.0136925792,
-0.0000473967,
-0.0016002767,
-0.006414928,
-0.0070938356,
0.0137873497,
0.035168089,
0.0551267304,
-0.0011125937,
0.0107227806,
0.044323504,
-0.02120433,
0.0062786439,
-0.0240048822,
-0.0763488039,
-0.0072705219,
-0.0068340702,
0.0181867313,
-0.0574776269,
0.0532741845,
0.0429416224,
-0.030003719,
0.0615858883,
0.0324917249,
-0.0018918999,
-0.022200821,
0.0378118828,
-0.0417547561,
-0.0608497001,
-0.001113002,
-0.0183297917,
-0.0031545819,
-0.0478649996,
0.0711373687,
0.0294879656,
-0.0438651852,
0.0461627543,
0.0818584189,
-0.0102647031,
-0.024668403,
-0.0217705593,
-0.0296608713,
0.007263741,
-0.0200084541,
0.0477137789,
-0.0379732698,
0.0580272079,
-0.0269763228,
0.0778655633,
-0.0612405837,
0.0214163531,
0.0210270844,
0.0533436835,
0.0720150322,
-0.01972338,
0.0083216699,
0.0475029871,
-0.0452811792,
0.0268250685,
-0.0251386072,
0.02589247,
0.0268857889,
0.0393473171,
0.049845174,
0.0016335791,
0.0730799213,
-0.0871266276,
-0.0389133953,
0.0256494861,
0.0308688059,
-0.0001959622,
0.0353638195,
-0.020802306,
-0.0278638247,
-0.0315995738,
0.0349950679,
0.0190122984,
-0.0271217171,
-0.0736243948,
0.0298243277,
0.0015218412,
-0.0336770602,
-0.0144029073,
-0.03396146,
-0.074797757,
0.0172173511,
0.0349599048,
-0.0223358888,
0.0005723184,
0.0012767765,
0.0206748825,
-0.0645119026,
0.0102837812,
-0.0650104731,
0.0322181359,
0.0452712625,
-0.0061369617,
0.0140415691,
-0.007668931,
-0.0242861211,
-0.0226872638,
0.0068382085,
-0.0456611812,
-0.0281128287,
0.0628325492,
-0.0074947737,
-0.0061941324,
-0.0044154092,
0.0844984502,
-0.0297536496,
0.0230332427,
-0.0190609507,
-0.0238369312,
0.0100914603,
-0.0157489739,
-0.0115744537,
-0.0551722422,
-0.0365762375,
0.0057557728,
-0.0084035154,
-0.0571539178,
-0.061102163,
0.0157112665,
2.802e-7,
0.0256329495,
0.0377670266,
-0.0557585172,
-0.0604533292,
-0.0060665342,
0.0348944142,
0.0144452844,
-0.01489281,
0.0235342756,
-0.0007327721,
0.0096640168,
-0.0393259861,
0.0399050973,
0.0950908512,
-0.0631398335,
0.0139208641,
-0.0667063445,
0.0270190611,
-0.0647152886,
0.0022175862,
0.0345413946,
0.0453103222,
0.0254355464,
0.0101730572,
-0.0113582527,
-0.0267612543,
-0.0209764335,
-0.0498363301,
-0.002684714,
0.0182665251,
0.0431068167,
0.0193629097,
-0.0178656392,
-0.0672331676,
-0.0393831506,
0.0032677439,
0.0173331946,
-0.0106399711,
-0.0161846653,
-0.0375017934,
0.0504870228,
-0.0084225815,
0.01954671,
-0.0396983437,
0.0410491787,
-0.0134906117,
-0.055138506,
-0.0237100571,
0.0389036424,
0.0034598846,
0.022188263,
0.007871883,
0.0118812984,
0.0060199425,
0.0055210157,
-0.0523618497,
-0.0426484719,
-0.0252713505,
0.0278062988,
0.0485028662,
0.0314031169,
0.017970521,
-0.0635611787,
0.0322256833,
0.0346571356,
0.0195385087,
0.0473699048,
2.512677261e-34,
0.0370998718,
-0.0673670247,
-0.0069133006,
-0.0008062851,
0.0147956377,
0.0481013767,
-0.0656607524,
0.0129958959,
-0.0124519113,
-0.0338136628,
0.0165430028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12809v1 | Can Voice Assistants Sound Cute? Towards a Model of Kawaii Vocalics | 2023-04-22T01:47:19 | 2023-04-22T01:47:19 | Katie Seaborn, Somang Nam, Julia Keckeis, Tatsuya Itagaki | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SD | The Japanese notion of "kawaii" or expressions of cuteness, vulnerability,
and/or charm is a global cultural export. Work has explored kawaii-ness as a
design feature and factor of user experience in the visual appearance,
nonverbal behaviour, and sound of robots and virtual characters. In this
initial work, we consider whether voices can be kawaii by exploring the vocal
qualities of voice assistant speech, i.e., kawaii vocalics. Drawing from an
age-inclusive model of kawaii, we ran a user perceptions study on the
kawaii-ness of younger- and older-sounding Japanese computer voices. We found
that kawaii-ness intersected with perceptions of gender and age, i.e., gender
ambiguous and girlish, as well as VA features, i.e., fluency and artificiality.
We propose an initial model of kawaii vocalics to be validated through the
identification and study of vocal qualities, cognitive appraisals, behavioural
responses, and affective reports. | [
0.0290173627,
0.0280851685,
-0.0204795022,
-0.0386564843,
0.0428650528,
0.0166399144,
0.0429429859,
-0.0098327016,
-0.0476664454,
0.0352672227,
-0.0785290077,
-0.0442360342,
0.0495973565,
0.0353571437,
0.0008895249,
-0.0748541877,
0.0096568763,
-0.0062703858,
0.085057646,
-0.0088966908,
0.0146648241,
0.0259440057,
-0.0043998337,
0.0816491172,
-0.0464587472,
-0.0600666627,
0.0063797133,
0.0075235562,
-0.0060054972,
-0.020515237,
0.0425178781,
-0.0510786846,
0.0074746371,
-0.020108385,
0.000001477,
-0.028553158,
0.072333917,
0.0201593637,
0.0059318002,
0.0341578238,
0.0412021056,
0.0584342554,
-0.054913681,
0.0196565781,
-0.0198171083,
-0.0128015038,
0.0830745921,
0.0037804313,
0.0809350088,
0.011462274,
-0.0263381992,
-0.0404760875,
-0.0497622527,
-0.006277686,
0.0277204029,
0.0300975107,
-0.0341229104,
-0.0627550557,
0.0464679971,
-0.0787838176,
0.0301584993,
0.0137366187,
0.0060541453,
-0.0134129385,
-0.013796417,
0.0000465469,
-0.0161932576,
-0.0598698333,
-0.0112501485,
0.0395513996,
0.0645800978,
0.0256598014,
-0.0277958475,
0.0405913591,
0.0206676144,
-0.0045034089,
0.0088908598,
-0.0165580772,
-0.0119141787,
-0.0450747684,
-0.0374988765,
0.0537314974,
-0.0120270094,
-0.0226583891,
0.0211946443,
0.0422407538,
0.0065980759,
-0.0336365886,
0.0288281888,
-0.0469184443,
0.0051690238,
0.0224620979,
0.0429361872,
0.0604769886,
0.0125799654,
0.0093433484,
-0.0253567677,
-0.0292592179,
-0.001846411,
-0.0595499165,
0.0325764157,
0.0075968429,
-0.0748818517,
-0.0244186446,
-0.0073664985,
0.0453897491,
0.0318414047,
-0.06284412,
-0.0139307277,
0.0179169662,
0.0061554522,
-0.0219527185,
-0.0351462774,
-0.0103446692,
0.0252580121,
-0.0121048288,
-0.017446382,
0.0475038886,
-0.0815252885,
0.0033948026,
-0.0264958777,
0.0110063115,
0.0079002948,
0.0277019963,
-0.014242948,
0.0058094915,
-0.0614154488,
0.0315972418,
-0.0211698581,
-0.0576775409,
0.0422883704,
-0.0135693233,
0.0413324684,
0.0027295821,
0.0384165831,
0.0037654685,
0.0315413922,
0.0180229284,
0.0099156993,
0.014988102,
-0.0189327672,
-0.0029025837,
0.0018851198,
-0.0136617878,
-0.0390085354,
-0.0056806044,
0.0218476411,
-0.0154796625,
-0.0099675208,
0.0097062169,
0.0481320806,
-0.0132314712,
0.0338460431,
0.0496009998,
0.0120808668,
-0.0129345926,
-0.0125870835,
0.0061801723,
0.0446142741,
-0.00032869,
0.0053462395,
-0.0367199332,
0.0234742295,
0.0472063832,
-0.004026311,
0.0550296791,
-0.0115269665,
-0.0200351998,
-0.041050557,
0.0205808245,
0.0514153801,
-0.0074095083,
0.0283164829,
0.0098909279,
0.0666325688,
0.065636836,
0.0184492525,
0.0269599985,
0.0088235084,
-0.0169665031,
0.0266776867,
0.0014374468,
0.0248462819,
0.0343928114,
-0.0142193101,
0.0019839711,
-0.0401603729,
0.022557972,
-0.0390868336,
-0.0326578505,
0.0052189706,
-0.0209568087,
0.0002175281,
0.0088863708,
-0.0193895753,
0.0590135232,
0.0045456095,
-0.0291489772,
0.012667886,
-0.0996818393,
-0.0050351117,
-0.0488628075,
0.0231274944,
0.0398438983,
-0.0442873091,
-0.0027322494,
0.0414030999,
0.0217499714,
-0.0476810783,
0.0429961085,
-0.0194862075,
-0.02350704,
0.0022813422,
0.011146768,
0.0184442345,
0.0037239559,
0.0105323447,
0.0039731753,
-0.0641874522,
0.0617325157,
-0.0013655078,
0.0253304914,
0.0120926369,
-0.0245172195,
-0.0019604217,
-0.0124910111,
-0.0247906875,
0.0411421768,
0.0048857089,
0.0365893058,
-0.0487759039,
0.0273756124,
0.0062582786,
0.0058297236,
0.0367465839,
0.0961221308,
0.0080755027,
0.0527598001,
0.0390059799,
-0.0356858298,
-0.0106330039,
0.0173125546,
0.0299275108,
0.0070712105,
0.0620134026,
-0.0595138408,
-0.026328871,
-0.0319136679,
0.0381200016,
-0.0400118232,
0.0140140429,
0.0448560342,
-0.0370896235,
0.00692527,
-0.0597991012,
0.0037743279,
0.0102824634,
-0.0181487259,
-0.0555764809,
-0.0635954291,
0.0446741059,
-0.0062972493,
0.0475880466,
-0.0301872529,
-0.028671857,
-0.0391810723,
-0.0298918206,
-0.0819507167,
-0.0547123775,
0.0304330401,
-0.0508894287,
-0.0219799578,
0.0060883015,
-0.0380347259,
-0.0199669097,
-0.0606032163,
-0.0024429949,
-0.0301672313,
0.0142065501,
0.0027042602,
-0.0052589332,
0.0170278586,
-0.0265800916,
0.0141293965,
-0.0040057981,
-0.0249289852,
0.0025576488,
-0.0025129225,
-0.0195285287,
-0.000314727,
-0.0515570045,
-0.019527318,
0.0238866918,
-0.0584297068,
0.0366625451,
-0.0027726146,
0.0399174467,
0.051011391,
0.0190589093,
0.0057846373,
0.0543319434,
-0.0180827659,
0.0022094997,
0.0271866992,
0.0422897525,
0.0253289863,
0.0245305691,
-0.0355924666,
0.0350304656,
-0.0424822159,
-0.0037108005,
0.0308922846,
-0.0395706594,
0.069066748,
-0.0082787545,
-0.0591040105,
0.0217665583,
-0.0139917154,
-0.0087906746,
0.0530955195,
0.008120697,
-0.0352825895,
0.0429857112,
-0.0023780607,
-0.0561857298,
0.0069188639,
-0.0135105392,
0.007067814,
0.0488919206,
-0.0923401713,
0.0186109468,
0.0475369655,
-0.0275704786,
-0.0066378866,
0.0224741157,
-0.0205833707,
-0.0594526008,
0.0364741534,
-0.0218614321,
-0.0281979479,
0.0230659693,
0.0003755364,
0.000940192,
0.0017266307,
-0.0509269536,
-0.0352267474,
-0.0281482879,
-0.0214713756,
0.0369685665,
0.0615358539,
-0.0097024878,
0.0196044575,
-0.0117460787,
0.0211095456,
0.0150818191,
-0.0608022697,
0.0623301044,
0.0745458603,
-0.0326495282,
0.0054247957,
0.0163482763,
-0.0250853878,
0.0162848346,
0.0054583522,
0.0009874164,
0.0362380557,
0.0194316674,
0.0183861926,
0.0282831118,
-0.0121822702,
0.0256287139,
-0.0213045496,
0.0679839551,
0.0366821438,
-0.0018255054,
-0.0185419377,
0.0084459605,
-0.0148502374,
0.0216463003,
-0.0085895658,
0.0054962519,
0.023779979,
0.0373392478,
0.0401723832,
0.0525588281,
-0.0215662513,
0.0225501154,
-0.0152849331,
-0.0953649133,
0.0064046243,
0.0283983294,
-0.0244561192,
-0.048272498,
0.0315579586,
0.0171771441,
0.0501540527,
0.0665523037,
0.005102172,
-0.0436239131,
-0.0366710275,
-0.010474503,
-0.032605961,
-0.0100725964,
0.0203637015,
-0.0342989564,
0.0902006254,
0.0531905256,
0.0555784032,
-0.0002886374,
-0.052043356,
-0.0935774893,
0.043829307,
0.04717822,
-0.0062702065,
-0.0235619359,
0.038226787,
-0.0367927514,
-0.0321926363,
-0.0130168004,
0.0023826628,
0.048041109,
0.0422123522,
-0.0401471443,
-0.0204097312,
-0.0430082455,
-0.0467781126,
0.0118638454,
-0.0087387972,
0.0001848667,
0.0004331974,
-0.079410322,
0.0297456365,
0.0128954547,
0.0231860224,
0.0531438813,
-0.0783938095,
0.0212821718,
0.0104482761,
-0.0817094669,
-0.1025708318,
-0.0436685383,
-0.021223817,
0.0345819965,
0.0293854494,
-0.0775904953,
0.0071286564,
0.0534512997,
-0.020423511,
-0.0044263192,
0.0286347885,
0.0399652608,
-0.0163528249,
0.0073944912,
-0.0045242864,
-0.0277815759,
0.0162478238,
-0.0302965213,
0.0825072452,
-0.0287347995,
0.0243637152,
0.0459601842,
0.0194391124,
-0.0035307535,
-0.0110459104,
-0.0601389483,
0.0166607331,
-0.0182465985,
0.0162661392,
0.040291395,
0.0829459727,
0.0160499196,
0.0037053779,
0.0090657175,
-0.0501230098,
-0.0010472707,
-0.0794612244,
-0.0320071317,
0.0108836405,
-0.0556916893,
-0.0083917733,
0.0543148257,
-0.0452796258,
-0.0260888021,
0.0693303198,
0.0089715207,
0.0019238772,
-0.0113756135,
0.031119952,
-0.045767799,
-0.0523603708,
-0.0045982213,
0.0623944066,
0.0247656945,
-0.0314007774,
-0.0160753559,
-0.0324301757,
-0.0290388186,
0.0205969438,
0.0323173404,
0.0814455599,
-0.0303043723,
0.0189041439,
-0.0117158303,
0.0040606936,
-0.0100051276,
0.0126129203,
0.0439364202,
0.0102732116,
-0.0351309516,
-0.0570679531,
0.0228287242,
0.0412486345,
-0.0012411601,
-0.0292857476,
0.0158913247,
-0.0645780489,
0.0017414712,
0.0048554502,
0.0549131595,
-0.0106410477,
0.0231800303,
-0.0176858399,
-0.0103879068,
0.0031921808,
-0.0262858719,
-0.0347300321,
-0.0001711987,
0.00022724,
-0.0571136884,
0.0030262275,
-0.0043427958,
0.0405436829,
-0.0406553634,
0.0341295414,
-0.0215999316,
-0.0184241347,
-0.0072458112,
-0.0119626932,
-0.0121076405,
-0.0233006943,
-0.066442892,
-0.0755629763,
0.0251263101,
-0.0571678765,
-0.0020809339,
-0.0435774773,
0.0087174829,
-0.0522904024,
-0.0188473985,
0.0276923142,
-0.0025671523,
-0.0783785656,
-0.0541686639,
0.0551682636,
0.0363176987,
-4.680286226e-33,
0.0119344238,
0.011144571,
-0.0085479664,
0.0107389949,
-0.0367518961,
-0.0200577565,
-0.0526529141,
0.0011758532,
-0.0395183116,
-0.0169798173,
-0.0173522364,
0.0043845712,
-0.0003943043,
-0.0357937999,
-0.0018796602,
0.0176006667,
0.0596667752,
0.0511005372,
0.0018002287,
-0.0211606007,
0.0128154736,
-0.0100812083,
0.001576368,
-0.0807189271,
0.0551752634,
-0.0067073195,
-0.0590969399,
-0.035930302,
0.0415396094,
0.0164428577,
0.0110121612,
0.0701696649,
-0.0087339999,
0.0714508593,
0.00126546,
0.0185133293,
-0.0280141085,
-0.0307896659,
-0.0315805078,
0.0175018888,
0.0408058129,
-0.0247462466,
-0.0257790945,
0.0252813622,
-0.0249118637,
-0.0108876405,
0.0345765948,
-0.0210506395,
0.0385791734,
-0.0024838771,
-0.0660864562,
-0.0334396921,
-0.0140685812,
-0.0606799461,
0.0363856144,
0.0578774214,
-0.0294063967,
-0.0121243959,
-0.0197127834,
0.0614393242,
-0.0550946705,
-0.04979508,
0.0140270712,
0.0380723253,
0.0546998344,
0.0229213331,
0.0669848546,
-0.0045708846,
-0.0499228314,
0.0051226341,
0.056116946,
0.0365640149,
0.0302697644,
0.0098277247,
0.0225908104,
-0.0652399585,
0.0395036116,
-0.0127704218,
0.0481497012,
0.0263595134,
-0.0158683602,
0.049588941,
-0.0752929971,
-0.005260292,
-0.0202782471,
-0.0291854888,
-0.0260491595,
-0.0263683051,
-0.0122437887,
-0.0337396003,
-0.0387292914,
-0.0293206554,
-0.0294401087,
-0.0230293181,
0.016237611,
-0.0334598683,
-0.0075765294,
0.0073117837,
0.0254520178,
-0.0268568918,
0.0689643025,
0.0239433367,
0.0441838838,
0.0437761918,
0.0503704064,
0.023085732,
-0.0515422188,
0.0610355809,
-0.0415796824,
-0.0261730552,
0.0328774042,
-0.0009041976,
0.0619415864,
-0.0021541356,
0.0122825028,
0.0221284106,
-0.0130123207,
-0.0217407998,
0.0063332161,
0.0503780395,
-0.0462574549,
-0.0206383914,
-0.0485338904,
-0.0276422296,
-0.0318215378,
-0.0294014011,
-0.0106832376,
0.0111339688,
0.0408897027,
-0.0423146859,
-0.0217002034,
-0.0212832708,
2.488e-7,
-0.0660680905,
0.0037307821,
0.0106943185,
0.0343455002,
0.04592181,
0.0636792332,
-0.0285170209,
-0.0348471627,
0.0885054097,
-0.0152917346,
0.0157164391,
-0.0410850868,
0.0751634389,
0.0142747294,
-0.0990769118,
-0.0028527209,
-0.0429404378,
0.0259433631,
-0.0020167015,
0.0419059917,
0.035351038,
0.0362985842,
-0.007979284,
-0.037918482,
0.0127107464,
-0.0089523196,
-0.0082271509,
0.0055130208,
0.0417182855,
-0.0494845398,
-0.0333259553,
-0.0091525177,
0.0097897733,
-0.0197307412,
0.0036153744,
0.041442927,
0.0290687922,
0.0507260635,
-0.0262335185,
-0.0563293323,
0.010020528,
0.0882586837,
-0.0439232923,
0.016639052,
0.0309914462,
0.0155983455,
-0.0246052947,
-0.0340500437,
-0.0001881431,
-0.0200011805,
0.0437509157,
-0.0419648848,
-0.0232051425,
0.0271419697,
-0.0108475061,
-0.0495985784,
0.0015887178,
-0.0075533842,
0.0134371659,
-0.0293338541,
-0.0058888919,
-0.0852749944,
-0.0161871985,
0.0277171917,
-0.0026598123,
-0.0029650473,
0.0419865213,
1.109746679e-34,
-0.004092556,
-0.0412263051,
0.0209865589,
0.0296496879,
0.0193380155,
0.0201294571,
0.0721240789,
0.0121110054,
0.054787036,
0.0226784628,
-0.0178335886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11276v1 | The Role of AI in Human-AI Creative Writing for Hong Kong Secondary Students | 2023-04-21T23:50:09 | 2023-04-21T23:50:09 | Hengky Susanto, David James Woo, Kai Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent advancement in Natural Language Processing (NLP) capability has
led to the development of language models (e.g., ChatGPT) that is capable of
generating human-like language. In this study, we explore how language models
can be utilized to help the ideation aspect of creative writing. Our empirical
findings show that language models play different roles in helping student
writers to be more creative, such as the role of a collaborator, a provocateur,
etc | [
0.0885206237,
-0.0186259449,
-0.0566266738,
0.000832475,
-0.0672991797,
-0.0206757206,
0.0341822393,
-0.0229146332,
0.0124412999,
-0.0451314673,
-0.0252571907,
-0.0377560481,
-0.0099406522,
0.0499677844,
-0.0027711159,
-0.0347516835,
-0.013247177,
-0.0081869848,
0.0716202408,
0.0269370917,
0.0133701693,
0.0460763499,
-0.0063374615,
0.1006123871,
0.0027225399,
-0.0412480012,
-0.0058121202,
-0.0258834511,
-0.0228049941,
-0.0032596767,
0.0202991348,
0.0697688237,
0.0150186419,
0.0118309269,
0.0000016698,
-0.0325468369,
0.0227290485,
-0.0264460854,
0.0613749363,
-0.0215875395,
0.022315586,
0.0387374572,
-0.0254530776,
0.0229673218,
-0.0427183323,
0.0508972779,
0.0494535528,
0.0790544897,
0.04908593,
0.0441330969,
-0.0130890841,
-0.0474845544,
0.0248017125,
0.0059391111,
0.0407057665,
0.0387315676,
0.0014430064,
0.0186689049,
0.0322291031,
-0.0226050299,
-0.0236909073,
0.020989595,
0.0205268767,
-0.0701313615,
0.0058936118,
0.0341630504,
-0.0403828733,
-0.0108179795,
0.0317395478,
-0.001022569,
0.0071641072,
-0.0306709912,
-0.0172123946,
0.020077249,
0.0127384597,
0.0271882098,
-0.0283115525,
0.0409187563,
-0.0234317556,
0.0124320621,
0.0324580111,
-0.0152739948,
-0.0270167664,
0.0373307914,
0.0736312494,
0.0159123652,
0.0000360319,
-0.0041207392,
-0.0292427335,
0.0124806855,
-0.0179743916,
-0.0728037506,
0.0107811373,
0.0440618433,
-0.0016303078,
0.0058139511,
-0.0322415009,
-0.0349779241,
-0.0387089923,
-0.0411202163,
0.0835095868,
0.0256361719,
0.0608579293,
0.0086848205,
0.005106268,
0.0391850024,
0.036580313,
0.0612561926,
-0.037089631,
0.0312134586,
-0.0752854869,
-0.0787871033,
-0.0907915905,
0.0306493472,
0.032913059,
-0.0445832945,
-0.0126314973,
0.0288459826,
0.0046355133,
-0.0391050912,
-0.0053045969,
0.0186798554,
-0.0361529067,
0.0109728612,
-0.0208737068,
0.0053505492,
0.0132411839,
0.0257675722,
-0.0144429766,
0.0073848655,
0.0430874079,
0.0256328322,
-0.0167990122,
-0.0367678478,
-0.0050171497,
0.0138915144,
-0.0107356766,
-0.0312113781,
-0.0521473028,
-0.003006334,
0.0359014831,
-0.0498904251,
-0.0143926172,
-0.0504404008,
0.0121376375,
0.0096799415,
-0.0037824491,
-0.0625541955,
-0.0125316242,
0.0194131508,
0.0078843851,
0.0079390248,
-0.0429268628,
0.0278129112,
0.0404260121,
0.0091588497,
0.0055971043,
-0.0047082198,
0.1300516576,
0.022571547,
0.0045023607,
-0.0054861996,
0.0485424586,
-0.021382764,
-0.0486982539,
-0.014725076,
-0.0203997102,
-0.0533852912,
-0.0329500623,
0.0459114164,
-0.033381287,
0.0836053491,
0.0008422997,
0.0809033513,
0.0876344144,
0.0620308593,
0.0343168825,
0.0647278056,
0.056537535,
0.0082884403,
0.0267501529,
0.0169753619,
0.0032510646,
0.059710592,
0.0245036986,
0.0316359252,
-0.0327844843,
0.0217095986,
-0.0060896715,
-0.051832024,
-0.038735345,
0.0135875717,
0.0183962118,
-0.0400506295,
-0.0307309069,
0.0105209574,
0.0016499487,
-0.0377916396,
-0.0237828642,
-0.0784315988,
0.0288082212,
-0.0212629139,
0.0561914481,
0.1079921275,
0.0423722491,
-0.0139098885,
0.013362769,
-0.028672196,
-0.0247453377,
0.0467410833,
-0.0051313234,
-0.0048373863,
-0.0507518016,
0.0218733978,
0.0395599157,
-0.0324958116,
0.0071485038,
-0.0365507193,
-0.0201355871,
0.0247789994,
-0.0013482053,
0.0200919248,
-0.0795506537,
0.0399453491,
-0.0647442415,
-0.0002212729,
-0.0169365574,
-0.0113962386,
-0.0214243885,
0.0271092262,
-0.0879620537,
0.0550933741,
0.0064542661,
-0.0305219833,
-0.0788953453,
0.081561394,
-0.0012956826,
-0.0160154421,
0.0329965949,
-0.0729295462,
0.0369731672,
-0.0174873844,
0.0295147598,
-0.0167024806,
0.0560937189,
-0.0343567282,
0.0381129384,
-0.0260293875,
0.0191107187,
-0.0460029319,
-0.0321403481,
-0.0156126311,
0.0010250632,
0.0118246963,
0.0169717763,
-0.0379152559,
0.0412536897,
0.0269833934,
0.022143662,
-0.011319181,
0.0530988127,
0.0383873396,
0.0362312756,
0.0286258999,
0.0105056418,
-0.0358684137,
-0.0482630357,
-0.0818307027,
-0.0250060223,
-0.0026235927,
-0.0342483744,
0.0207579453,
-0.0265416931,
-0.036894504,
0.0351064168,
-0.0361299329,
-0.0322215781,
-0.0197111927,
-0.0155345965,
0.0378335193,
-0.0212221239,
-0.0031968793,
-0.005967122,
0.0151566686,
-0.0327153951,
0.0158526208,
0.0827315897,
-0.0686562881,
-0.0076961406,
0.0482947342,
-0.0234638061,
-0.0292839184,
-0.0093370145,
-0.0454009995,
0.0174770057,
-0.0251358263,
0.0461385772,
0.0503704771,
0.0127125047,
0.0401707664,
0.0914828032,
-0.0043214844,
0.0142383007,
0.0196103659,
0.0397646539,
0.0332825705,
0.0062014558,
-0.0377946422,
0.013089384,
0.0404728688,
0.0344387926,
-0.0274999682,
-0.0382527299,
0.0751990378,
-0.0261941664,
0.0078148562,
-0.0062918384,
-0.0555932857,
-0.0270699169,
0.0317975841,
-0.0138105899,
-0.0288430639,
0.0572078153,
-0.0088133682,
-0.0013876373,
-0.0332754105,
-0.0085422713,
-0.0371660739,
0.0647038892,
-0.0116606839,
0.0290455427,
0.0028297144,
0.0310933217,
-0.0512402132,
0.0071429303,
0.0385422446,
-0.0082844757,
-0.0235442575,
-0.0253022015,
-0.0168084484,
-0.0068207453,
0.0088967616,
-0.0246682055,
0.0083429385,
-0.0069768536,
0.052592326,
0.0701311231,
-0.0161980819,
0.0128272707,
-0.0020925745,
0.0394479558,
0.0313569941,
-0.0233376455,
0.0082488852,
-0.0215531159,
-0.0045765303,
0.0548632033,
-0.0482850485,
-0.0419911444,
-0.0029628542,
0.0625333264,
-0.0078552188,
-0.0465346873,
0.0334763452,
-0.0189819038,
0.0286674723,
0.0052594789,
-0.0018395401,
-0.0329249576,
0.0001383231,
0.0635915026,
-0.0343317129,
-0.0139209237,
0.0915428624,
0.0301724523,
-0.0293991435,
0.0112578049,
-0.0090706218,
0.0036102398,
0.0188777875,
0.0465210788,
-0.0203544162,
0.0151150599,
-0.00411447,
-0.0191336665,
-0.0338688307,
-0.0243879594,
-0.0451243594,
-0.0545539074,
0.0558497645,
0.0083617,
-0.025992142,
-0.0096635707,
-0.0032275065,
-0.0494205803,
0.0582100227,
-0.0197594091,
-0.0083602509,
-0.0041944417,
0.0551392809,
-0.0003154609,
-0.0286483038,
-0.0117536979,
-0.0257313699,
-0.0435270444,
0.0350440405,
0.0609555878,
0.0554658994,
-0.0174804516,
-0.0228003152,
-0.0270204172,
0.03631071,
0.0186750237,
0.0050258376,
0.0007309363,
-0.0188216474,
0.0276521724,
-0.0384517126,
0.023499079,
-0.0400258638,
-0.0373345204,
0.0100691477,
0.042461995,
-0.0333269872,
-0.0093765091,
-0.0302056503,
0.0428539254,
0.012777077,
0.0358876102,
0.0370484404,
-0.0777877718,
-0.0109956758,
-0.0204169638,
-0.0233240146,
-0.0678280741,
-0.0563425533,
-0.0191563796,
-0.0147007518,
0.0136266127,
-0.068809092,
-0.0592565425,
0.0321758948,
0.0377693586,
0.0448762774,
0.0498412699,
-0.0350542031,
-0.0124951936,
-0.0338098891,
-0.0135993399,
0.0493951216,
0.0373555832,
-0.0171021279,
-0.0432809405,
-0.0491258465,
-0.0516350456,
0.0152560798,
0.0138212284,
-0.0899912715,
-0.0663748011,
0.0089138858,
0.0036860222,
0.0187173579,
-0.0328838043,
0.0129779112,
-0.0664289519,
-0.0339276753,
0.0270601455,
0.0226260852,
0.0248208009,
-0.0428059213,
0.01712046,
0.0329064392,
0.0083576851,
0.0084629003,
0.0169410035,
0.0433260873,
0.0410375744,
-0.0021741183,
-0.0180681515,
0.0386139415,
0.0367451124,
-0.0216771457,
-0.0542072691,
0.0021609159,
-0.0720615759,
-0.0308853667,
-0.0402688943,
-0.055779662,
-0.0542901047,
-0.0096595157,
0.0284647346,
0.006145617,
-0.0070687425,
-0.0148062073,
-0.0261300374,
-0.0057567037,
0.0084793055,
0.039990928,
-0.006271665,
0.0504681803,
0.0052775247,
-0.0028496077,
-0.0089657186,
0.038024582,
-0.0514053591,
0.0386443883,
0.0264396798,
0.0414280519,
0.013365617,
-0.0015623372,
0.0143773817,
0.0277332999,
-0.0678509772,
-0.0540744998,
-0.016085472,
0.0139798233,
0.0573371276,
-0.0060927006,
0.0067506493,
-0.0663748085,
0.0300395787,
-0.0176278669,
0.0697832331,
0.0098748188,
-0.056744881,
-0.0369462259,
-0.0068878145,
-0.0048004957,
-0.0552970953,
0.0737422556,
-0.0211933162,
-0.0114381509,
0.0135081261,
-0.0104302168,
0.0099832062,
0.0269503389,
0.0291694198,
0.0267462973,
0.0305937845,
0.0665777922,
-0.0573507249,
-0.0380696133,
0.0239589699,
-0.0231782086,
0.0406789668,
-0.030964788,
-0.0168183818,
0.0545309968,
-0.0108248815,
-0.0157346614,
-0.0709951296,
-0.0035341922,
-0.0387193188,
-0.0074519315,
-0.0473570675,
-5.191297498e-33,
-0.0464003421,
-0.0812935308,
0.0437850319,
0.0511505902,
-0.0302224569,
-0.0259881038,
-0.0423722416,
0.0389893651,
0.0253010504,
0.0263703782,
-0.027256256,
0.0143374428,
-0.0279405974,
-0.0079631908,
0.0112097096,
0.0357253626,
0.0263809413,
-0.0132348901,
-0.0231743008,
-0.0321435742,
0.0101055475,
-0.0017748743,
0.040037524,
-0.0663012564,
0.0307314377,
-0.0450534299,
-0.0095008416,
-0.0222610831,
-0.0066690519,
0.0076547726,
0.004752914,
0.0290241707,
0.0476846099,
0.0172226466,
0.0008537094,
-0.0064110579,
0.017278593,
-0.051613465,
0.013837249,
0.0056436653,
0.0033896684,
-0.0667775869,
0.0225631483,
-0.0418932512,
-0.0116193146,
0.0104901008,
0.0450463258,
0.0109247053,
-0.0010809229,
-0.0124158328,
-0.1038861647,
-0.0056007612,
-0.0204106588,
-0.0225646123,
-0.0072885379,
0.0079915291,
-0.0151977604,
-0.0429288484,
-0.0386232585,
0.0386357792,
-0.0236906447,
0.0423381925,
0.0335989259,
0.0019865227,
-0.0103011262,
0.0527913123,
0.0139273396,
0.0546667241,
-0.069514744,
0.0155994166,
0.0247746576,
0.0438998416,
0.0452496372,
0.031268876,
0.0014204194,
-0.0253474396,
0.0394185036,
0.0088823298,
0.0184450094,
-0.0427207239,
0.0112440921,
-0.0010332786,
-0.022864284,
-0.0642711967,
0.0006884755,
-0.0653783754,
0.0096029136,
-0.0408465639,
0.0095700836,
-0.028888531,
0.0242112298,
-0.022823751,
-0.009237688,
-0.0307790469,
0.014187064,
0.00155435,
-0.0702323839,
0.0670791566,
-0.0221924186,
0.0125391418,
-0.0283481088,
-0.0229747389,
0.0080575887,
0.0408909954,
0.0248917155,
0.0316845067,
0.0271346662,
0.0239336714,
-0.0131523637,
-0.0395790227,
-0.036302641,
0.0018501843,
0.044468984,
-0.018718306,
-0.0239728373,
0.0077252262,
-0.0168467648,
-0.0197878238,
0.0396807007,
-0.0240116455,
-0.043944411,
-0.0395656191,
-0.051372312,
-0.0226327833,
-0.0033337697,
0.0068862406,
-0.0357679464,
0.005999391,
0.0396840759,
-0.0488143452,
-0.0128698489,
-0.0343328789,
2.568e-7,
0.0295384191,
0.0251765158,
0.004577931,
0.0376728214,
0.0151969902,
0.0075558997,
-0.0380084254,
0.0154557014,
0.0090233674,
0.0744926482,
0.0171964709,
0.0318785124,
0.0174546074,
0.0183438677,
-0.0801615641,
0.0438767672,
-0.0809820443,
-0.0108744716,
-0.0508582816,
-0.0004776343,
0.0793460682,
-0.0332346074,
0.0475468263,
-0.0264934395,
-0.0241934787,
-0.0709914267,
0.0100401854,
-0.0141478265,
0.028245274,
0.0424428843,
0.0333046168,
-0.0114961509,
0.0214680769,
0.0244818348,
-0.0253500678,
-0.0155922165,
0.0325847268,
0.0227630008,
-0.0242931265,
0.0448000692,
0.0465002395,
0.0092725148,
-0.0135409338,
-0.0584927611,
0.0427010879,
0.0162101351,
-0.0121108638,
-0.0037862621,
0.0499832295,
-0.0159037523,
-0.0055620265,
-0.0222131032,
0.0111325858,
0.0232262462,
0.0143233677,
-0.0192578435,
0.0394870564,
0.0062331487,
-0.0427476801,
-0.0305852853,
-0.0099587142,
-0.0030949882,
-0.0377092846,
-0.017077934,
0.0096256593,
-0.0507384203,
0.0270355828,
2.019324119e-34,
0.0237184428,
-0.0213282201,
0.0227038767,
0.0720643699,
0.0775186196,
0.0304336455,
0.0489594378,
0.0094086714,
-0.0233466513,
-0.0012500524,
-0.0445395596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14415v1 | Generative AI Perceptions: A Survey to Measure the Perceptions of Faculty, Staff, and Students on Generative AI Tools in Academia | 2023-04-21T23:08:39 | 2023-04-21T23:08:39 | Sara Amani, Lance White, Trini Balart, Laksha Arora, Dr. Kristi J. Shryock, Dr. Kelly Brumbelow, Dr. Karan L. Watson | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | ChatGPT is a natural language processing tool that can engage in human-like
conversations and generate coherent and contextually relevant responses to
various prompts. ChatGPT is capable of understanding natural text that is input
by a user and generating appropriate responses in various forms. This tool
represents a major step in how humans are interacting with technology. This
paper specifically focuses on how ChatGPT is revolutionizing the realm of
engineering education and the relationship between technology, students, and
faculty and staff. Because this tool is quickly changing and improving with the
potential for even greater future capability, it is a critical time to collect
pertinent data. A survey was created to measure the effects of ChatGPT on
students, faculty, and staff. This survey is shared as a Texas A&M University
technical report to allow other universities and entities to use this survey
and measure the effects elsewhere. | [
0.0432855971,
0.0133714229,
-0.0585866123,
-0.0204805564,
-0.0379245691,
0.0018097996,
0.0399416089,
-0.0334449336,
0.0476576798,
-0.0340233408,
0.0052601481,
0.0204515178,
-0.0291446242,
0.0707628578,
0.010278889,
-0.0484985225,
0.003477395,
-0.0008126696,
-0.0067320978,
0.0365203097,
0.0095266318,
0.0371159315,
-0.0539420359,
0.0852259621,
-0.0344359949,
-0.0393499322,
-0.0059596463,
-0.0209969915,
0.0116510661,
0.004228347,
0.0232335776,
0.0340843201,
0.0018749805,
0.0657373443,
0.0000021706,
-0.0537961647,
-0.0112132076,
0.0445551388,
-0.030732898,
-0.011170892,
0.0665570647,
0.1019027755,
-0.0323255472,
0.0222630892,
-0.073605828,
0.0444349051,
0.0481375419,
-0.0071965293,
0.0131432163,
0.012822927,
-0.0101387845,
-0.0338020176,
0.0014504277,
0.0294048674,
0.0164503139,
0.0297020245,
-0.0154617196,
0.0065420042,
0.0731181651,
0.0289780609,
0.0142809479,
0.0254197679,
0.0160688628,
-0.04242393,
0.069868274,
0.061837215,
-0.0076229293,
-0.0187330656,
0.0124634728,
0.0151321273,
0.0579034686,
0.0002464579,
0.0081631755,
-0.0057271882,
0.0365978181,
0.0327515416,
-0.0263834689,
0.0111078024,
-0.0346683078,
-0.0279178154,
-0.0409692116,
-0.0132929562,
-0.0508897528,
-0.0008712069,
0.0411597341,
-0.0234082919,
0.005026808,
-0.0196835548,
-0.0352674127,
0.0401079804,
0.0237640422,
-0.0182083715,
-0.0012206383,
0.0687508807,
-0.0125837298,
-0.0026419701,
-0.0089041525,
-0.049112577,
0.0193184819,
-0.0348276421,
-0.0524369888,
0.0597386993,
0.0112687703,
0.0111583686,
-0.0121701509,
0.0391925387,
0.0032514653,
0.0041655875,
-0.0168351512,
0.0275475122,
-0.1064133197,
-0.0383871123,
-0.0288708583,
0.0325286351,
-0.0188467856,
-0.0140607655,
-0.0134095214,
0.0450269356,
-0.0029523247,
0.023049714,
-0.0355919451,
0.0315064043,
-0.0094296103,
0.031565316,
-0.0367566794,
0.023503663,
-0.0112133119,
0.0229499731,
0.0151094794,
-0.0815871432,
-0.0019017215,
0.006223965,
0.0048585734,
0.0201860964,
-0.0293512121,
0.0654844344,
-0.0306046791,
-0.0111450423,
-0.0274413209,
-0.0575726889,
0.0254904665,
-0.0265633315,
0.0322098657,
-0.0236377306,
0.0062328437,
0.0216522012,
-0.004580182,
-0.0223859884,
0.0168343782,
0.0162626263,
0.0312027,
0.0194297582,
-0.0453149714,
-0.0080355424,
0.0710637793,
0.0337508284,
-0.0250138231,
0.0114717223,
0.0246116556,
0.0464716181,
-0.013953656,
-0.0287741981,
0.0361805521,
-0.0010984829,
-0.0494328141,
-0.0469448604,
0.0340474583,
-0.0190231558,
-0.0085614659,
0.0122308834,
-0.0441157632,
0.035320092,
-0.0282930713,
0.0601712093,
0.0107317502,
0.0778451264,
0.0158719216,
0.0771345869,
0.0429676063,
0.0488620214,
0.0268287566,
-0.0090798642,
0.0153437136,
0.033950422,
-0.0296799205,
-0.0017653221,
0.0046057976,
0.066155389,
0.0117700677,
-0.080440782,
-0.0041800397,
0.0011284696,
-0.0087295929,
0.0110688312,
0.0239934716,
0.0045446181,
-0.0060044699,
-0.0554274954,
-0.010534904,
-0.071152091,
-0.0281652082,
-0.0816641822,
0.0239366051,
0.124437578,
0.0629136637,
-0.0328682624,
-0.0431460924,
-0.0381806456,
-0.0297175236,
0.0412777327,
0.0538726263,
-0.0021588735,
-0.0439682119,
0.0027447673,
-0.0072804573,
-0.0355353542,
-0.0136536742,
0.0236612391,
-0.008632442,
0.0290332157,
-0.0062528132,
0.0000663351,
-0.0322249196,
0.0115700737,
-0.0428456329,
-0.037187025,
-0.0171951707,
-0.0024734214,
-0.0054843226,
0.0378339514,
-0.0324649103,
0.0331256725,
0.0060889642,
0.0098074721,
-0.0432646498,
0.0063767014,
-0.0256924145,
0.0585785061,
0.02230848,
-0.0700801536,
-0.0334970765,
-0.0358265974,
-0.0082754167,
-0.0217271708,
0.0508490317,
-0.0322413817,
0.0479689054,
-0.0122753903,
-0.009085306,
-0.0163397696,
0.0136411972,
-0.0454510525,
0.0088198278,
0.0552240871,
-0.0176808182,
0.0238710288,
0.0200858247,
0.0429726616,
-0.0087173674,
-0.0317601301,
0.0290952213,
0.0048603369,
0.0036399444,
0.0281077158,
-0.0101983873,
-0.068238005,
0.0171228815,
-0.0670517012,
-0.041105248,
0.0137970196,
0.0123115918,
0.016953351,
-0.0176981911,
-0.0186832864,
-0.0048090937,
-0.0317048691,
-0.0093398457,
-0.0050237598,
-0.0397447906,
0.0280122533,
-0.0117307073,
0.0119980741,
-0.0357259512,
-0.0015699801,
-0.0473797023,
0.0001705375,
0.1469804794,
-0.0299278274,
-0.0566542894,
0.0684351996,
-0.0056240074,
-0.0014769306,
0.0236375816,
-0.0146932006,
0.0356015153,
-0.016781006,
0.0610857196,
0.0397095606,
-0.0044890442,
0.0567357726,
0.0228040963,
-0.0006761773,
-0.0363121442,
0.0218733698,
0.0017031042,
0.0030827718,
0.0431767814,
-0.0182926897,
-0.0048338287,
-0.034350954,
0.0019343749,
-0.0114346622,
-0.0043369946,
0.0679183826,
-0.0167547092,
0.0037110785,
-0.0002023053,
-0.0244485345,
-0.0039430512,
0.0077470709,
0.0373670682,
-0.0034504062,
0.0650074631,
0.0037847813,
-0.0106724435,
-0.0718159601,
-0.0197147001,
-0.0182954818,
0.0559479631,
-0.0141250109,
0.0198476911,
0.0607393794,
0.0020779371,
-0.0290024541,
0.0387096256,
0.0165274777,
-0.0333872437,
-0.0539128631,
-0.0413597524,
-0.001323797,
-0.0058655986,
0.0263454784,
-0.0578576587,
0.0330875702,
0.0089209126,
0.0165665783,
0.0541881621,
-0.045416154,
0.0091593238,
-0.0238543283,
0.0382144488,
0.0045500789,
0.015057981,
-0.0494735874,
-0.0099245384,
0.0276264213,
0.0285609476,
0.0331570767,
-0.0074159843,
0.052396927,
0.0216538049,
0.0542251021,
0.0002242413,
-0.0124975899,
-0.0655706376,
-0.0401123352,
0.0166617129,
-0.0353817232,
0.0251066498,
0.0055165724,
0.0083033014,
-0.0239192154,
-0.01706402,
0.044423677,
0.0093161399,
-0.0225955155,
0.0008351137,
-0.0013718787,
0.010208033,
-0.0089639109,
0.0522972718,
-0.1040355489,
0.0239738151,
-0.0261992235,
0.0206433311,
-0.0522980317,
-0.04156854,
0.0019249992,
-0.0834642798,
0.0764961094,
-0.0351545736,
-0.0096355202,
0.0052827327,
-0.0228465106,
0.015437807,
0.0130983768,
-0.0069448105,
-0.0246535707,
0.0209648293,
0.0476560667,
0.0629924387,
-0.0400871411,
-0.0514694192,
0.0198390093,
0.0384299755,
0.0436636321,
0.0812971741,
0.0194007996,
-0.0198898762,
-0.04392194,
0.0321130157,
0.0704142675,
0.0364275835,
0.0071845185,
-0.0003530302,
0.0033824386,
0.0046724118,
-0.0243109651,
0.0093441848,
-0.032355912,
-0.0034248538,
0.0581782684,
0.0721126795,
-0.0562600456,
0.0166472159,
-0.1034761369,
-0.006046542,
0.0250978377,
0.0101137543,
0.0031823728,
-0.0239577647,
-0.0205101017,
-0.0481718816,
0.0463539846,
-0.0079117324,
-0.0424290337,
-0.0294864848,
0.004005074,
-0.0431645177,
-0.0222347453,
-0.0529992394,
0.0327013023,
-0.0026993328,
-0.0022025774,
-0.0310500879,
0.0269025844,
0.0518453084,
-0.04335941,
-0.0091707837,
0.0197435692,
0.0052443715,
0.0100556985,
-0.0694959611,
0.0002545867,
-0.0430277586,
-0.0274435822,
0.01661909,
-0.0121641364,
-0.0462294854,
0.0393172391,
0.051284615,
0.0274547674,
-0.0295448583,
-0.0080440249,
0.0133067062,
-0.004218163,
0.0694557056,
-0.0264281668,
0.0106210951,
-0.0271909088,
0.0405627266,
0.0056668553,
-0.0561497174,
-0.0053782403,
0.0320942253,
0.0022993551,
0.0034499541,
0.0018551691,
-0.026092777,
0.0388612598,
0.078102015,
0.006959877,
-0.0127272755,
0.0309657045,
-0.0259224251,
-0.0273411274,
-0.0271645449,
-0.0045241192,
-0.0387299135,
-0.0245994478,
-0.0117050381,
0.0046101115,
0.0444645062,
-0.005113598,
-0.040596094,
0.0202111397,
-0.0128289508,
0.0655173212,
-0.0053892983,
0.0355755426,
0.0184999183,
-0.0223251153,
-0.0184854269,
0.0089040892,
0.0076413895,
0.0438567139,
0.0157508384,
0.0768615231,
0.0079689827,
0.016592579,
0.0572565794,
0.0456610471,
-0.0581276938,
-0.0874852836,
-0.0293082837,
0.0675313845,
-0.0089100087,
0.0654074699,
-0.0115603078,
-0.0595857836,
0.0321729146,
0.0073191077,
0.0189960394,
0.0007700496,
-0.0252134558,
-0.0270277858,
-0.0081560975,
0.0052717798,
-0.0600398518,
0.0307746865,
-0.0598423555,
0.0093672164,
-0.0217800196,
-0.0120475478,
-0.029950859,
-0.0447490551,
0.0120137595,
-0.0196738224,
0.0507875532,
-0.0059005669,
-0.043505121,
-0.0358586609,
-0.0469153337,
0.0121486541,
0.0064175241,
-0.0724834502,
0.0641067103,
0.0646051168,
-0.0145237111,
-0.0237027574,
0.0166298319,
0.0334469751,
-0.0438398123,
-0.0309012141,
-0.0432136692,
-6.09968941e-33,
-0.013393783,
-0.0608830899,
0.037451189,
0.0396484733,
-0.028756205,
-0.0293623339,
-0.0110334381,
0.0417631455,
-0.0317676254,
-0.0222764872,
-0.0374577343,
0.0099672107,
-0.0048561092,
0.0130253546,
0.04275278,
-0.0144254938,
0.06537956,
-0.0025513608,
-0.0002374708,
0.0686613619,
-0.0108695813,
-0.0032778664,
0.0213497989,
-0.0780533627,
0.0422141179,
-0.032282427,
-0.0108920438,
-0.0642637163,
-0.0134233739,
-0.0100495974,
-0.0317578912,
0.0577988327,
-0.0076333098,
-0.0453967974,
-0.0168590657,
0.0475068949,
-0.0245165881,
-0.0645520389,
-0.0207114015,
-0.0038447664,
0.0007129624,
-0.0560427569,
0.0416642092,
-0.0283936504,
-0.0713628978,
0.0025716154,
0.074949339,
0.0295549799,
0.0266901869,
-0.0246942285,
-0.1004086956,
0.002444213,
-0.0607983805,
0.0100225611,
-0.013705004,
0.0232943837,
0.0067809997,
-0.0374264866,
-0.0244804118,
0.0376321152,
0.0222722013,
-0.0313107856,
0.0679515228,
-0.0557902344,
0.005387553,
0.0278755557,
0.0603751019,
0.0226312205,
-0.0564109012,
-0.057953611,
-0.0295722149,
0.0117561491,
0.0221193936,
0.0481690243,
0.0087084975,
-0.0453064442,
-0.0244278125,
0.0419390313,
0.0218410008,
0.010043554,
-0.0041858363,
-0.0089604668,
-0.0629745945,
-0.014324191,
0.0564983264,
-0.0230230521,
0.0097880848,
-0.0549638905,
-0.007708143,
-0.0476157777,
0.0134598054,
-0.0353060476,
-0.009946336,
-0.0341523252,
0.042676758,
-0.007905446,
-0.0297140703,
0.012920781,
-0.0117058018,
0.0026159375,
-0.0568842366,
0.0390563346,
0.0195675101,
0.0426144786,
0.0425042845,
0.0110659236,
-0.0122618238,
0.0113923401,
-0.0085193571,
-0.0056918957,
-0.0518616922,
0.0172439218,
0.0046937605,
-0.0426995941,
0.0159060545,
0.0181589276,
0.0020593223,
-0.0373323709,
-0.0079149362,
0.0430197269,
-0.0461861677,
-0.0089121256,
-0.0391180068,
-0.0417436659,
-0.0284507815,
-0.0115558915,
-0.0320612565,
0.0120020555,
0.0258442704,
-0.0582055077,
-0.0178734604,
-0.0413569584,
2.921e-7,
0.0107449275,
0.0172328353,
0.0348600224,
-0.0003383031,
0.0005837827,
0.0044043292,
0.0262919404,
0.0174307637,
0.0538791642,
0.0668971613,
0.0157553535,
0.015886452,
-0.011002914,
0.0284908935,
-0.0594791993,
-0.0649863258,
0.0009609071,
-0.0282999761,
-0.045897454,
0.0640243515,
0.1763699055,
-0.0259128697,
0.0108324364,
-0.0030688839,
0.0076335538,
-0.0296560563,
-0.0212252401,
-0.0001785127,
0.0567615256,
0.0149995862,
-0.0007421013,
0.0566733256,
0.0055507743,
0.0214702692,
0.0056435452,
-0.0702278763,
0.012433161,
0.0098796776,
-0.0089787114,
-0.0134072555,
0.0347911231,
0.0022632722,
0.0313340463,
-0.0387072116,
0.0187125225,
-0.0519341566,
-0.0120889535,
-0.020487383,
-0.0357861519,
-0.0385959484,
-0.008808828,
0.002555189,
-0.0008190179,
-0.0183326341,
-0.0158423018,
-0.0235413741,
-0.0271419752,
0.0031905614,
0.0305202045,
-0.0283243228,
-0.0465235114,
-0.0696686357,
-0.0017562001,
-0.0048161871,
0.0423254259,
0.0390957519,
0.0004022284,
2.286895102e-34,
0.007432837,
-0.0185429938,
0.0348188579,
0.0615848415,
0.0248952825,
0.0450888872,
0.0313697159,
0.0019018078,
0.0249409862,
-0.0128680859,
-0.057185173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11163v1 | ChatGPT, Large Language Technologies, and the Bumpy Road of Benefiting Humanity | 2023-04-21T22:53:45 | 2023-04-21T22:53:45 | Atoosa Kasirzadeh | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The allure of emerging AI technologies is undoubtedly thrilling. However, the
promise that AI technologies will benefit all of humanity is empty so long as
we lack a nuanced understanding of what humanity is supposed to be in the face
of widening global inequality and pressing existential threats. Going forward,
it is crucial to invest in rigorous and collaborative AI safety and ethics
research. We also need to develop standards in a sustainable and equitable way
that differentiate between merely speculative and well-researched questions.
Only the latter enable us to co-construct and deploy the values that are
necessary for creating beneficial AI. Failure to do so could result in a future
in which our AI technological advancements outstrip our ability to navigate
their ethical and social implications. This path we do not want to go down. | [
0.044552397,
0.0979912877,
-0.0218614191,
0.0022686354,
-0.0857716724,
0.0047475724,
0.0248255599,
0.0178457033,
0.0606174059,
-0.0201828294,
0.0226143822,
-0.0024993282,
-0.0137935532,
0.035308443,
0.0072289552,
-0.024312526,
0.0235779192,
-0.0147849619,
0.0382626653,
-0.0017787161,
0.0133197587,
0.0140965628,
0.0079000918,
0.0400099531,
-0.0414015278,
-0.0102375327,
0.0140412515,
-0.0305358116,
0.0187705997,
-0.0025016172,
0.000921307,
0.0048591713,
0.0300066676,
0.0582392737,
0.0000022185,
-0.038656801,
0.0022205401,
0.0347425789,
-0.0077497531,
-0.046453815,
0.0543146804,
0.0447235852,
-0.017283896,
0.0280690156,
-0.0679867342,
0.0632795542,
0.0576830097,
-0.0063169668,
-0.0047322898,
0.0737061054,
-0.0123665873,
0.0288651828,
0.074055858,
0.0388921574,
-0.0172013808,
-0.0320162997,
0.0185966827,
0.0010148155,
0.0158591308,
0.0112336092,
0.0151767489,
0.06754639,
0.0345911644,
-0.0208159406,
-0.0180519242,
0.0142612336,
-0.0478883535,
-0.0709780827,
-0.0014032762,
0.0277656987,
0.0414532833,
-0.0023926534,
0.0216442812,
0.0408986695,
0.0090509197,
-0.0513118729,
-0.0019928594,
0.0550386831,
-0.0439250804,
-0.0045446395,
0.0467920005,
0.0130178453,
0.0181897674,
0.05016822,
0.0152874989,
0.0428878702,
-0.0201060046,
-0.0022887795,
-0.0023142886,
0.0104376012,
-0.0021187316,
-0.0156218968,
0.0063197999,
0.014316963,
-0.0280973408,
-0.00636539,
-0.0223381426,
-0.0096720746,
0.023956161,
-0.0627833232,
-0.0170331467,
0.0315470323,
0.0155300256,
-0.0092506371,
0.0570891909,
0.0014462447,
-0.0208033901,
0.0361227244,
-0.0296121258,
0.0009120925,
-0.0239533894,
-0.0076320288,
-0.0147470441,
0.0295241661,
-0.0119882943,
0.0329885781,
-0.0039602495,
0.0363003649,
-0.0555928312,
0.0238563791,
-0.0221331995,
0.0119536147,
-0.0139513202,
-0.0134281022,
0.0221420806,
-0.0331759416,
-0.0348755419,
-0.0041567199,
-0.0031047333,
-0.0948248059,
0.0130355963,
0.0129508385,
-0.0393286981,
-0.0135497609,
0.0109438663,
0.1342822313,
0.0066766697,
-0.0393838324,
-0.0143542299,
-0.0384355746,
-0.0098867007,
-0.0530431755,
0.0389927067,
-0.012834413,
0.0042799697,
-0.0144107575,
-0.0098740188,
-0.0445409492,
0.004368294,
0.0125155589,
-0.0365836993,
0.0400376245,
-0.0340031236,
0.0101488177,
0.021567788,
0.0417790525,
-0.0290474817,
0.0318780839,
0.0410758778,
0.0371962264,
0.0723105446,
-0.0117289843,
0.0308902133,
0.0013129724,
-0.0358886719,
0.0021540658,
-0.0017332701,
0.0227670539,
-0.0311828349,
0.003812955,
-0.0238473285,
0.0586286932,
-0.0109973056,
-0.0090379901,
0.0681222156,
0.1032579839,
-0.0393022075,
0.0449088141,
-0.010717703,
0.002145465,
-0.0062057967,
-0.0128291147,
-0.0427368283,
0.0066407952,
-0.0394508317,
-0.0291779339,
-0.0415683985,
0.0463105403,
-0.0195570402,
-0.032335069,
0.0076841023,
-0.0351787359,
0.068259798,
0.0485271998,
0.0017061789,
-0.0644764081,
0.0013170316,
-0.0847754627,
0.0118868342,
-0.0412202291,
-0.0182050057,
-0.1182453334,
0.010849298,
0.0576236658,
0.005127266,
-0.0242350437,
-0.0379814729,
-0.0242858715,
-0.0133367125,
0.0279401317,
0.0069279661,
0.007958075,
0.0112780062,
-0.01549879,
-0.0201047901,
0.0236409362,
-0.0205655079,
0.0169718191,
-0.0059669889,
0.0394882485,
-0.027160313,
0.0125408145,
-0.0469870009,
0.0008513569,
-0.0045730518,
-0.0031937964,
-0.0541366227,
-0.0037732224,
0.0190475322,
0.028350791,
-0.0481770411,
-0.0057667485,
0.025113564,
0.0154313082,
-0.0257327184,
0.0295395479,
-0.0047874781,
0.085944429,
-0.0019511228,
-0.1151210219,
-0.0452350676,
0.0587936863,
0.0005466369,
0.018466644,
-0.0053537455,
-0.0201017652,
0.0179064777,
-0.0211827271,
-0.017790569,
-0.0523671657,
-0.0075042839,
-0.0241377205,
0.0179181229,
-0.0014750783,
-0.0544413477,
-0.0276754387,
-0.0348180942,
0.0444455482,
-0.0025244972,
-0.0387494341,
0.0558954738,
-0.0037299981,
0.0413691066,
0.0771527067,
0.0552872792,
-0.0357384831,
0.0207030457,
-0.0889561921,
-0.0254598185,
-0.0026252642,
0.0122641763,
-0.0233602859,
-0.0082553253,
-0.0162924808,
-0.0053081051,
-0.0222018193,
0.0202305652,
0.0080628181,
0.0257121045,
0.0129618077,
-0.0153576545,
-0.0109216208,
0.0011455229,
0.010503036,
-0.0156589784,
-0.0219155177,
0.0650980622,
-0.026987873,
-0.0256576408,
0.0081620868,
-0.0447713807,
0.005780071,
-0.0060795685,
-0.0520077795,
0.0277451463,
0.0308199003,
-0.0400949754,
0.0554771461,
0.018290244,
0.0756616965,
0.0339060351,
0.0399686582,
-0.0078409156,
-0.0215201005,
0.0279410165,
-0.0327196233,
0.0155197969,
-0.0002213957,
-0.0226220731,
0.0180124659,
-0.0087686535,
0.0026940769,
-0.039337121,
0.0266897101,
-0.081046313,
-0.0588918626,
-0.0234359503,
-0.0546611026,
-0.0291300956,
0.0231661331,
-0.0015847861,
-0.0556344949,
0.074740544,
0.0298456047,
0.0175230652,
-0.0296244081,
-0.0442660674,
0.0116091417,
0.0628950223,
-0.0200979747,
0.051513616,
0.0222635809,
-0.0354738794,
-0.0473464802,
-0.0026510444,
0.0057934583,
-0.0497256257,
-0.0008588822,
-0.0490862019,
0.013637919,
-0.0134272519,
-0.0751380175,
-0.0328312032,
-0.0157999862,
-0.0106858406,
0.0091984821,
0.0190063547,
-0.0232093856,
-0.0081382869,
-0.0273525584,
0.0608264096,
-0.0086182393,
0.0074442085,
-0.0194863658,
0.000520125,
-0.0529601462,
0.0237240009,
-0.005115326,
0.0392529741,
0.0432021134,
0.009515157,
0.06731195,
0.0015959288,
0.005802914,
0.0069998987,
0.0140954303,
0.0398335271,
-0.0001341959,
-0.0077663856,
0.0157868899,
0.0486210175,
-0.0191007126,
-0.0026511485,
0.0694987252,
-0.023868423,
-0.0553812981,
0.0247517433,
-0.024786545,
-0.0498368666,
-0.0153006325,
0.0143982116,
-0.1009953618,
0.0228582658,
0.0058449204,
0.0214364789,
-0.0750633553,
-0.0445788018,
0.0204048809,
-0.0247408953,
0.0679251701,
0.0019446181,
-0.037114922,
-0.0436833911,
-0.0194089413,
-0.0364401788,
-0.0075241574,
0.0750969425,
-0.0108992057,
0.0053540799,
-0.022151472,
0.0092607867,
-0.0205082241,
0.0255569946,
0.0356683545,
-0.0462432429,
0.0801976845,
0.0882527456,
0.0479668975,
-0.0522715636,
-0.0221736692,
-0.024198195,
0.0461391471,
0.0055562463,
0.0320591554,
0.012620993,
-0.006842806,
-0.0207687598,
-0.0665621385,
0.0145651996,
-0.0052073887,
0.0021229915,
0.035701897,
0.0604934245,
-0.0616087019,
-0.0443311855,
-0.0229880176,
-0.0239051543,
0.0190123692,
0.039613042,
-0.0486998111,
-0.0289919451,
-0.0060984436,
-0.0199226644,
0.0051982072,
0.0004395726,
-0.0430318676,
-0.0059604063,
-0.0087883901,
-0.075596258,
-0.0699287504,
-0.0734725967,
-0.0086021507,
0.0008499502,
0.0213712584,
-0.0721015632,
0.0409138612,
0.0421642587,
-0.0341472216,
0.014187742,
-0.026655959,
-0.0100562768,
-0.0152972545,
0.0301189758,
-0.0309497677,
-0.0204340033,
0.0215734001,
0.009584425,
0.0233790949,
-0.0288743228,
0.0540069081,
0.0470368788,
0.0247926731,
0.0090646883,
-0.0119198775,
-0.0112078935,
0.0311761163,
0.0542186685,
-0.0311146658,
0.0198957715,
0.046433378,
-0.017721748,
-0.0056154686,
0.0021980428,
-0.014173477,
0.0030302438,
-0.0048169694,
-0.0242494754,
-0.0190157685,
-0.0201774575,
0.0389742665,
0.0558790378,
0.0039827656,
-0.0463258587,
0.0198824257,
-0.0022708587,
-0.0434312522,
0.008241659,
-0.0005843071,
-0.0198407695,
-0.0002579791,
0.0002249008,
0.0145824989,
0.0023208782,
0.0154750664,
-0.0332206041,
-0.0268653706,
-0.0282494444,
0.0502519794,
-0.0306124259,
0.0938628018,
-0.0021243477,
0.0217350218,
-0.0108768111,
0.0752453431,
-0.0338938572,
0.0378626771,
-0.0160067566,
0.0282530934,
0.0086575085,
-0.0011278045,
0.0508331507,
0.0785195753,
-0.0424158797,
-0.1310638934,
0.0096556786,
0.0838047564,
0.0338996798,
0.0593670756,
0.0076317517,
-0.0375326127,
0.0085025579,
0.0061971168,
-0.0078196172,
-0.004277837,
-0.0385720655,
-0.0549050868,
0.0083899228,
-0.0400275625,
0.0040295599,
0.0705604181,
-0.0613647699,
0.0624721907,
0.0117314719,
-0.015215857,
0.0133043909,
-0.0776773617,
0.0246460009,
-0.0224644821,
0.0103986794,
-0.0091332933,
-0.0444131903,
-0.0747837275,
-0.0352700315,
0.0242145862,
0.0063343821,
-0.0178089701,
0.01693964,
0.0104492093,
0.0006058458,
-0.0301690269,
-0.027902171,
-0.0051051453,
-0.057496231,
0.0004548677,
0.0069787079,
-6.261280211e-33,
0.0455865487,
-0.0251882859,
0.0157897044,
0.024798993,
-0.0638217404,
-0.0186343733,
0.0072898106,
0.0273147374,
-0.0749959275,
0.0350470245,
-0.0250117667,
0.0184730403,
0.0011760213,
-0.0165999085,
0.0252193306,
-0.0467995927,
-0.0220037643,
-0.0167627819,
0.0142669436,
0.0387676656,
-0.0043345783,
-0.0187960174,
0.0580742843,
-0.0872783586,
0.0789169893,
0.0135636358,
-0.027380215,
0.0248304568,
-0.0195665918,
-0.0078710923,
0.0164971463,
0.0844132081,
0.0154596381,
-0.0133461813,
0.0227547381,
0.0259247273,
0.0186720472,
-0.0104033882,
-0.0082827136,
-0.006921662,
-0.0262306705,
-0.0570059903,
0.0068827569,
-0.0493009165,
-0.0420651473,
-0.004304775,
0.0157179069,
-0.0068564066,
0.0193995908,
-0.010408558,
-0.0400780663,
-0.0087659918,
-0.0556004457,
-0.0075864242,
-0.0090356972,
0.011203777,
-0.0104436632,
-0.0293342359,
-0.0393269286,
0.0252490789,
-0.0423765294,
-0.0662803054,
0.0364922509,
-0.0520609394,
0.0233968329,
0.0448156521,
0.0076311324,
0.0170371868,
-0.0101515576,
-0.0518419258,
-0.0150238471,
0.0555564426,
0.0255838204,
0.0322188288,
-0.0365538523,
-0.0602388456,
-0.0357739441,
0.014148606,
0.0450777039,
0.043546807,
-0.0067105615,
-0.0041879918,
-0.0928693488,
-0.0261248574,
0.0252427384,
-0.0387703069,
-0.0264038648,
-0.0181631241,
0.0112464903,
-0.0566213951,
-0.0100164823,
0.0126306107,
0.020475613,
-0.0805177987,
0.076171115,
-0.0006508784,
0.0186238997,
-0.0014262176,
0.0157455932,
0.0346354656,
-0.0033036449,
-0.021067312,
-0.0074222563,
0.0099268947,
0.0401662849,
0.0218944438,
0.0100819906,
0.0393960476,
0.0291276183,
-0.0088750543,
-0.0209255293,
0.0608478785,
0.0587908775,
-0.0323997661,
0.0181282815,
0.0238133259,
0.0154821724,
-0.0064040525,
0.0654418468,
0.0454755798,
-0.04054939,
0.0317396894,
-0.0474082194,
-0.0059364969,
-0.0223065056,
-0.0041729822,
-0.0466465615,
0.0531897917,
0.0181635711,
-0.0571557507,
-0.0361798331,
-0.0384645574,
2.98e-7,
-0.0257069618,
0.0193463098,
0.0261205975,
0.0129019236,
-0.0211111698,
0.0650757328,
0.0358213708,
0.090924561,
-0.0058705593,
0.0141813904,
0.0384407416,
0.0185065828,
0.0299150273,
0.024429094,
-0.0106777167,
-0.0624068268,
-0.052967988,
-0.0411501452,
-0.0419091769,
0.0517227948,
0.0591916703,
0.0087525509,
0.0188040715,
-0.0344246402,
0.0100147938,
-0.0054990281,
-0.0152209103,
-0.0509853773,
0.022539502,
-0.0084990775,
0.0041542519,
0.0598919317,
-0.0038857569,
0.0222833361,
0.0305035524,
-0.0319711529,
0.0152427442,
0.0872471631,
-0.0347775854,
-0.006150824,
-0.0250196885,
-0.0489316359,
0.0140608521,
-0.045303531,
0.0685961097,
-0.0032427979,
-0.0472892486,
-0.0255653188,
0.0286925621,
-0.043314822,
0.029971743,
-0.0161383152,
-0.0114290556,
0.0101366164,
0.0104590729,
-0.0026069188,
0.0171005186,
-0.0269799195,
0.0277804844,
-0.013126771,
-0.0017833818,
-0.0986189991,
0.012560199,
0.0595045835,
0.0255674236,
-0.0103675332,
0.0418748483,
2.316799954e-34,
-0.0228629932,
-0.0205963645,
-0.0057688272,
0.0037183808,
0.0564582199,
0.0705509558,
0.0009858346,
-0.0206887405,
0.0116384747,
0.0146106388,
-0.030105941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11257v1 | Who's the Best Detective? LLMs vs. MLs in Detecting Incoherent Fourth Grade Math Answers | 2023-04-21T21:25:30 | 2023-04-21T21:25:30 | Felipe Urrutia, Roberto Araya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Written answers to open-ended questions can have a higher long-term effect on
learning than multiple-choice questions. However, it is critical that teachers
immediately review the answers, and ask to redo those that are incoherent. This
can be a difficult task and can be time-consuming for teachers. A possible
solution is to automate the detection of incoherent answers. One option is to
automate the review with Large Language Models (LLM). In this paper, we analyze
the responses of fourth graders in mathematics using three LLMs: GPT-3, BLOOM,
and YOU. We used them with zero, one, two, three and four shots. We compared
their performance with the results of various classifiers trained with Machine
Learning (ML). We found that LLMs perform worse than MLs in detecting
incoherent answers. The difficulty seems to reside in recursive questions that
contain both questions and answers, and in responses from students with typical
fourth-grader misspellings. Upon closer examination, we have found that the
ChatGPT model faces the same challenges. | [
0.0221246146,
0.0346155949,
-0.0274033193,
0.0218453072,
-0.0592996515,
0.0110345045,
0.0037844186,
-0.0118556973,
-0.0236303359,
-0.1001953706,
0.0510372296,
-0.0433172621,
0.0113390433,
-0.0129832057,
-0.0078142751,
-0.0353929214,
0.019422641,
-0.0420628674,
0.0189056415,
-0.0003299119,
-0.0268997271,
0.0069636097,
-0.0123085091,
0.0223167557,
-0.0055869473,
-0.0592523664,
0.0023777073,
-0.0453009419,
-0.0257883482,
0.0008714548,
0.0189931784,
0.0761263445,
-0.0334202759,
0.0735884905,
0.000002144,
-0.0511746444,
0.0137420911,
-0.0159401875,
-0.0112704178,
0.0572351515,
0.0034808014,
-0.0064425389,
-0.0043931836,
0.0440810584,
-0.0677506998,
0.004749869,
0.0358816236,
0.016454991,
0.0652176663,
0.0425141677,
0.0181478653,
-0.0422742926,
0.0754352137,
0.0229025111,
0.0715914443,
-0.0246640239,
0.0505790636,
0.0156789701,
0.0240539126,
0.0108157312,
-0.0414150245,
0.0320908651,
0.0285740681,
-0.0335317887,
-0.0239389651,
-0.0268155709,
-0.0322708897,
0.030131422,
-0.0036830213,
0.060862802,
-0.0320573673,
-0.0311565585,
-0.0128912162,
-0.0118432101,
0.0128365289,
0.034591943,
-0.0445477553,
0.0187957156,
-0.0289324448,
-0.0030064331,
0.0097574377,
-0.0452505313,
-0.0021483989,
0.0276045464,
-0.0347060747,
0.0513954498,
-0.0071060425,
-0.0388400368,
-0.0248970855,
0.0283308625,
-0.0285945442,
-0.0579876639,
0.0242050756,
0.0539433099,
-0.0046861521,
0.0129127344,
-0.0484552905,
-0.046098154,
0.0181472953,
-0.0253563784,
0.0055745072,
0.0423897468,
-0.0099129826,
0.0258615948,
0.0038217774,
0.0685775205,
0.0141072413,
0.0376906656,
-0.03238637,
0.0073629366,
-0.0480280295,
-0.0312350877,
-0.011594886,
0.0594571866,
0.008066833,
0.0220175609,
-0.0658376217,
0.0166657418,
-0.0279661566,
-0.0145589821,
-0.0266898423,
-0.0407483056,
0.0372549221,
0.0104253339,
-0.0280744378,
0.0727542564,
-0.0077810986,
0.0162769109,
-0.0238583442,
-0.0399780981,
-0.0049922392,
0.0114623411,
0.0040289941,
0.0006552249,
0.0148158474,
0.0704468116,
-0.0110475067,
-0.0052634366,
-0.01128936,
-0.0239217021,
-0.0078899181,
-0.0512600318,
-0.0247371811,
-0.0872903615,
-0.0008291242,
0.0260893181,
-0.0256254766,
-0.0220498182,
0.0067212894,
0.0166119542,
0.0002541825,
0.0497736484,
-0.0198349748,
0.0193175375,
0.0325073972,
0.0026011597,
0.0224709176,
0.0078942394,
0.0087848594,
-0.0422291644,
0.0355866365,
-0.0820049345,
0.076913856,
0.037620537,
-0.0177026708,
-0.0075814514,
0.0290437676,
-0.0006026257,
-0.0252037104,
0.0438884646,
-0.0227853637,
0.0663829669,
0.0007674421,
0.0049892995,
0.0364161283,
0.0725307688,
0.0039721467,
-0.0158612933,
0.0155032575,
0.0223955773,
0.0479990356,
0.0386120155,
-0.0610600561,
-0.0072907959,
-0.0779891834,
-0.0001915173,
0.018127393,
-0.0061591435,
0.0025027615,
-0.0908446759,
-0.038993571,
0.0015827594,
-0.0121812467,
0.0471338555,
0.0680121034,
-0.0304478239,
-0.0107768811,
0.026443556,
-0.0128244022,
-0.031047523,
0.0155501934,
-0.0750978962,
0.0624171123,
0.0380970947,
0.0485054813,
-0.0344377868,
-0.0400450714,
-0.030822495,
0.0283146147,
0.0199064724,
0.00119108,
0.0038050953,
-0.0082515888,
-0.0190544203,
0.0001160686,
0.0184296407,
0.0233239308,
-0.0326491408,
0.0009906904,
0.0073575261,
0.0034398655,
-0.0538607799,
-0.0202113613,
0.0252225716,
-0.0041432437,
-0.0582905263,
-0.0031465038,
-0.0123292133,
0.0055354647,
0.0020150081,
0.0060096388,
0.0306502096,
0.0130824829,
-0.0143772038,
-0.0337471776,
-0.0733625442,
-0.0411251597,
-0.0196558684,
0.0816604346,
-0.0398653932,
-0.0303718243,
-0.0142727438,
-0.0422238,
-0.0361030996,
0.029311968,
-0.0730520338,
0.037474025,
-0.0099381777,
0.0498701148,
-0.0441328362,
-0.0248211455,
-0.0529243834,
0.055913344,
0.0136994757,
0.047906924,
-0.0309096295,
-0.0142906411,
0.0076444461,
-0.0019024966,
-0.0146376509,
-0.0043760897,
-0.0127393575,
0.0480192304,
-0.0066473805,
0.0218598638,
-0.0074230283,
-0.0491108708,
-0.0181564875,
-0.0156269651,
-0.0106114149,
0.0337925591,
-0.001462223,
-0.0291959327,
-0.0025619799,
-0.0020710207,
-0.0421879105,
-0.0040014382,
0.0406756289,
0.0112386551,
0.0226464998,
-0.0182009749,
-0.0088692065,
-0.029109465,
-0.0358008482,
-0.0522175319,
0.0175368451,
0.0331942663,
-0.0124150962,
-0.0555927679,
0.0077277268,
-0.0301827658,
-0.0013837242,
0.0203762427,
-0.0284229387,
0.0164883137,
-0.0309218764,
0.0251398943,
0.07383921,
0.0177799426,
0.0438547432,
0.0437362939,
-0.0321881063,
-0.0441464037,
-0.0045254105,
0.0104401596,
-0.0133035844,
-0.0207556076,
-0.0525460616,
0.0216717627,
0.0820676461,
0.0168678686,
-0.0401523896,
-0.0071790325,
0.0430064686,
-0.0172815621,
0.0335087851,
-0.0747581199,
-0.0554423369,
-0.0025573033,
0.0382754393,
0.0383016281,
-0.0379379727,
0.0553469434,
-0.0177321825,
0.0071598017,
-0.0586534813,
-0.0022367856,
-0.0466039702,
0.0207868833,
-0.0007631728,
-0.0221085772,
-0.0298798624,
-0.0274507366,
-0.0324856415,
0.0076416791,
0.0471320637,
-0.051495865,
0.0753896534,
-0.0643071458,
-0.0050285212,
-0.0144731756,
-0.0338173844,
-0.041866038,
-0.0433404222,
-0.0174288843,
0.0083222613,
-0.0290002041,
-0.0293443054,
-0.0505819879,
0.0059120217,
0.0163061693,
0.0018521902,
-0.0539456978,
-0.0326242745,
-0.0025625683,
0.0223898496,
0.0366521701,
0.0011966311,
0.0499270968,
-0.0435325056,
0.0404313877,
0.0719689727,
0.0138856238,
0.0310211908,
0.0127447601,
-0.0028228527,
0.0340953879,
-0.0097968858,
-0.0656850338,
0.0574888587,
0.0018497751,
-0.085053131,
0.0118371136,
0.0950040966,
0.0384078324,
-0.0237170309,
-0.0175165385,
-0.0265196431,
-0.0069405306,
-0.0112504596,
0.0144196013,
-0.0648946837,
-0.0342359692,
-0.0132841142,
0.0285928939,
-0.0069048703,
-0.0321308076,
0.0188036244,
-0.1413286179,
0.0359306037,
0.0270764064,
-0.0683731511,
-0.0289919507,
-0.0225057285,
-0.012033253,
0.0370790921,
0.0183857977,
0.0167883076,
-0.0392752178,
0.0362719148,
0.0352078639,
-0.0469948389,
-0.0191679429,
0.0050595547,
0.0122975046,
0.0213361774,
0.0145667093,
0.0089946343,
-0.0657523498,
-0.04346269,
0.0662343428,
-0.0026882177,
-0.0569042899,
-0.006352881,
0.0040509924,
0.0250256769,
0.0086512798,
-0.0441130102,
0.0606389157,
-0.0536718518,
0.0022587411,
0.069246605,
0.1319116503,
-0.0289927218,
-0.0210986789,
-0.025351733,
0.0172296613,
0.0022968233,
0.0671881288,
0.0459135585,
-0.0527239181,
-0.0493713506,
-0.061756108,
0.0009485656,
-0.0128322281,
-0.0387505218,
0.0317846537,
0.0047787726,
0.0210890211,
-0.0319302343,
-0.0306501538,
0.0604052246,
0.0162631907,
0.0074402955,
0.0335086957,
-0.0001309745,
0.0147999162,
-0.0191241484,
0.0107259182,
0.028977735,
0.0282852333,
-0.0967340097,
0.0262580365,
-0.0267092809,
-0.0078795943,
-0.0105292704,
0.013146787,
-0.0728994161,
-0.0435668156,
0.0251225326,
0.0429881401,
0.0250818338,
-0.0448143706,
-0.0071059885,
-0.0519117862,
0.0247971509,
0.0199220181,
-0.0308792368,
0.019774517,
-0.0090111196,
0.0204422623,
0.0060735568,
-0.0039680786,
-0.0029054729,
0.0062009413,
0.0211390071,
0.0037961779,
-0.0536817014,
-0.0345444828,
0.0129475938,
0.0567439124,
0.0368168429,
0.0248143971,
0.0096995821,
0.015747942,
0.0023282182,
-0.0227671023,
-0.0026155468,
-0.0338069312,
0.0013173382,
0.0340558179,
-0.0368690826,
-0.0085710147,
-0.0324821807,
-0.0062294221,
0.0410925187,
0.0075149429,
0.079626523,
0.0166413654,
-0.0065941494,
0.0307281204,
-0.0281089228,
-0.0024744812,
0.004805014,
0.0337947831,
0.0724719837,
0.0204112083,
0.0521044917,
-0.0178396348,
0.0238356497,
0.0235399008,
-0.0118536083,
-0.0518701226,
-0.0588866733,
-0.0198940281,
0.0453392453,
0.0027326704,
0.0180028528,
0.0345395431,
-0.0038467119,
-0.0015698523,
-0.0616331883,
0.0336517282,
0.0372923501,
0.0058380379,
0.0579604357,
0.0160861053,
-0.0046828147,
-0.011186298,
0.0560032576,
0.0202827137,
-0.0053927065,
0.0327047072,
-0.0294539109,
-0.0292972326,
-0.0013180996,
-0.0318041779,
0.0510233268,
0.014826145,
0.0307987537,
-0.0816222057,
-0.0218484364,
-0.0220333077,
0.0055048247,
0.0088289743,
-0.0247373693,
-0.0033983823,
0.0744294524,
-0.0085233608,
0.0017021238,
-0.0391088873,
0.0670280308,
-0.0375848822,
-0.0398384854,
-0.0370888375,
-5.64361303e-33,
-0.0261443593,
-0.0972756147,
-0.0011840664,
0.0392515995,
0.0070654736,
-0.0085534174,
-0.003315422,
0.0561581291,
-0.0157352034,
0.0012970429,
0.0093412809,
0.0388007835,
0.0047920612,
0.0353887118,
0.0397677869,
0.000171465,
0.0062669748,
0.0065118964,
-0.0153263006,
-0.0129987057,
0.0384835564,
-0.0132633457,
0.0902549773,
-0.0407993421,
0.0206865985,
-0.01543382,
0.0014291259,
0.0277613997,
-0.0787775367,
0.0482500531,
-0.0068004527,
0.0866952762,
0.016124364,
0.0312634297,
-0.003824237,
0.0216552317,
-0.017642742,
-0.0519606993,
0.0250586011,
0.0053104833,
-0.0436968915,
-0.044400502,
0.0519883335,
-0.0005608877,
-0.0350359045,
-0.0290866327,
0.0584596395,
-0.0245581381,
-0.0339226946,
-0.0010040317,
-0.0659343228,
0.0470402464,
-0.0345983058,
-0.0134504791,
-0.0030775827,
0.0863938183,
-0.0120585477,
-0.0307372529,
-0.0287803877,
0.0108650178,
0.0914704651,
0.0365199819,
-0.001909713,
-0.0117302369,
-0.0068510203,
0.0442135446,
0.0441573448,
-0.0122231357,
-0.0251703933,
-0.0257502161,
0.0171393678,
0.0108051086,
0.1163131371,
0.0564430468,
0.0490227602,
0.0198749974,
-0.0580881648,
0.0210136753,
0.0259092469,
0.0155040678,
-0.005886836,
-0.0524358116,
-0.0519070663,
-0.0422459655,
-0.0219454486,
0.0089594731,
-0.0304866396,
-0.0072819446,
0.0264491681,
-0.0700564981,
0.006684714,
-0.0350764729,
0.0330906846,
-0.0271996967,
-0.0162589885,
0.0056131696,
-0.0037340473,
0.0359832086,
-0.0051903315,
0.0290733278,
-0.0025268039,
0.013844138,
-0.0135574043,
-0.0233132616,
0.0170907974,
0.0234139152,
0.0106950132,
-0.0056429054,
-0.0704471022,
-0.0121938856,
-0.0083007794,
0.0144919399,
0.0146340467,
-0.0123552158,
0.034697473,
-0.0100626647,
0.0106863324,
0.0155283948,
0.0015582202,
-0.0249482933,
-0.0245806407,
-0.0284843482,
-0.0131396828,
-0.0103851072,
-0.0156497564,
-0.0270774234,
-0.0243054666,
0.023101585,
-0.0035353967,
-0.0539361835,
0.0167852696,
-0.0031353703,
2.668e-7,
0.0891583562,
0.069649376,
-0.0006741742,
-0.0097991889,
0.0281384233,
0.0274273846,
-0.0039009594,
-0.0360845514,
0.0252829399,
0.0438994989,
-0.0009080832,
-0.0237035137,
0.0760262683,
0.05925579,
-0.04396604,
0.0328029729,
-0.0550723113,
0.0258024223,
-0.0505086184,
0.0320921727,
0.0799415708,
0.0535805039,
0.0313378386,
-0.0232997164,
-0.0393576287,
-0.0315032043,
0.0280532297,
-0.0116325729,
-0.0058059655,
0.0336265378,
0.0476782396,
-0.0206689108,
0.0622486062,
0.0480779856,
-0.0177560505,
-0.001130687,
0.018780373,
0.0346159972,
0.0126417018,
-0.0049649151,
-0.0092386957,
-0.0457027629,
0.0067201396,
-0.0719761327,
0.0665488616,
-0.0158875566,
0.0028972055,
-0.0004388492,
-0.0276714098,
-0.0681965053,
0.0350898914,
-0.0204017591,
0.0107614733,
0.0163890012,
0.0262248591,
-0.0447386391,
0.0240782127,
-0.0241172686,
-0.0126955239,
0.0112704514,
-0.0293083116,
-0.0228039864,
-0.0251010116,
0.0368356071,
0.0549963526,
-0.0301743429,
0.0046747914,
2.392137432e-34,
0.0507136509,
-0.0349142365,
0.0582825541,
0.0007096173,
0.0142688137,
0.0277807992,
0.0124408677,
0.0348013639,
0.0386829786,
-0.0921292007,
0.0091202166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11256v2 | UBC-DLNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Impact of Transfer Learning on African Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-21T21:25:14 | 2023-04-25T07:44:37 | Gagan Bhatia, Ife Adebara, AbdelRahim Elmadany, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe our contribution to the SemEVAl 2023 AfriSenti-SemEval shared
task, where we tackle the task of sentiment analysis in 14 different African
languages. We develop both monolingual and multilingual models under a full
supervised setting (subtasks A and B). We also develop models for the zero-shot
setting (subtask C). Our approach involves experimenting with transfer learning
using six language models, including further pertaining of some of these models
as well as a final finetuning stage. Our best performing models achieve an
F1-score of 70.36 on development data and an F1-score of 66.13 on test data.
Unsurprisingly, our results demonstrate the effectiveness of transfer learning
and fine-tuning techniques for sentiment analysis across multiple languages.
Our approach can be applied to other sentiment analysis tasks in different
languages and domains. | [
0.028992882,
0.0734436214,
-0.0137064075,
0.0556889847,
-0.0118458485,
0.048213277,
0.0052425289,
-0.0278736092,
-0.0132579813,
-0.0328943506,
-0.0486158989,
-0.0593280531,
-0.0127375983,
0.0382950976,
-0.0179103632,
-0.0635022596,
0.0238858424,
0.0167029258,
0.026760513,
-0.0101451324,
-0.0017564183,
0.0246315636,
-0.0081060054,
-0.0145870605,
-0.0212962609,
0.0101856459,
0.0197132844,
-0.0168698058,
0.0150477467,
-0.0074742977,
0.0175847244,
0.0200307462,
-0.0313441642,
-0.0302706454,
0.0000022712,
-0.03035382,
-0.0299778096,
-0.0106794415,
0.0215956215,
-0.0214937311,
0.0846242085,
-0.0674644187,
-0.0088430718,
0.0075870389,
-0.0563689396,
-0.0183010455,
0.0759906322,
0.0320171379,
0.0605871379,
0.0878747776,
-0.0324002355,
-0.0171674211,
-0.0082523478,
-0.0342846997,
-0.0203185864,
-0.066722177,
0.0531994179,
0.0125694126,
-0.0244924854,
0.0125418529,
-0.031285245,
-0.0031917822,
-0.0176812895,
-0.0144364145,
0.0354614891,
-0.0434879512,
-0.0128582036,
-0.0194836315,
-0.01219601,
0.0336398706,
0.0154517228,
0.0128642339,
-0.0249086823,
0.0123881269,
-0.013746148,
-0.0180992279,
-0.0633976385,
-0.0050275247,
0.0396676958,
0.0667490363,
0.0304207765,
0.0421495363,
0.0398862101,
0.0176106356,
-0.045080293,
0.054963477,
-0.0160780605,
0.0062584239,
0.061408896,
0.101141274,
0.0077947523,
0.0207862612,
-0.0095236013,
-0.0191613734,
0.0186861735,
-0.017299857,
0.0284696557,
-0.0161948651,
-0.0116571104,
-0.0466684997,
0.0342588909,
0.0051032985,
-0.0341446921,
0.0439991951,
-0.0628396422,
-0.0285574161,
-0.0003610964,
0.005590803,
-0.0042316965,
-0.0572174191,
-0.079795748,
-0.0017067413,
0.0236688443,
0.045558989,
-0.0071182908,
0.0274688657,
-0.072247833,
-0.029933231,
-0.0482692495,
-0.0357660502,
-0.0065420689,
-0.0458991714,
0.0109649338,
-0.0290292036,
0.0028744356,
0.052723784,
-0.0338148735,
0.0606826618,
-0.0361075364,
-0.0615885481,
0.0021643131,
0.011030714,
-0.0133439964,
-0.016488431,
0.0179524608,
0.0579959862,
0.0029901036,
-0.0215252303,
-0.0549098291,
0.0271897502,
-0.0257783979,
-0.0428550132,
-0.0173757523,
-0.0484429933,
0.025031982,
-0.000003411,
0.0488154627,
-0.0011087706,
-0.0105106737,
-0.0208866186,
-0.0292463731,
0.0509357899,
-0.0242229756,
-0.0112763653,
-0.0067786933,
0.002376159,
0.0037323888,
0.0620759912,
-0.0228670537,
0.0431054905,
0.0125352908,
-0.0165833868,
-0.0287272781,
-0.0001745372,
0.022473732,
-0.0185338575,
-0.0253707319,
-0.0077309045,
-0.0145599069,
-0.0442235209,
0.0110081043,
0.0061578797,
0.0326073803,
0.0096288892,
0.030936921,
0.0008105375,
-0.0261778776,
0.0404176451,
0.0064951694,
-0.0279435981,
-0.0133754807,
-0.0016299518,
0.0140710762,
0.0356993563,
-0.0102807451,
-0.0717897788,
0.0272143614,
0.0216966178,
-0.0153453639,
-0.0300871357,
0.0473718569,
-0.0348632596,
0.0075227399,
0.0015084114,
0.0679176077,
0.033153709,
-0.0123480046,
-0.0145942243,
0.0783439577,
-0.045437336,
-0.0105547812,
-0.0492111072,
0.0641795993,
0.0205186829,
-0.0353977196,
0.0245220773,
-0.0145960664,
-0.0198916011,
0.0255033411,
0.0199973341,
0.037851613,
-0.0106239468,
0.0516005419,
-0.0486434959,
0.0097787334,
-0.0291514043,
0.0271872655,
0.0359066315,
-0.0225503407,
0.0931630284,
-0.0078397766,
-0.0039898176,
-0.0152245807,
0.0116353156,
-0.00741013,
-0.0068997215,
0.0315740295,
0.0101890592,
0.0504877977,
-0.005357231,
-0.0039035827,
-0.0132202478,
-0.0234553274,
-0.0633850247,
-0.0175609775,
0.0245411824,
-0.0304237325,
-0.0273861755,
0.0121115586,
-0.0465876311,
0.0120836282,
0.0542370416,
-0.0380562693,
-0.0060795727,
0.0696292892,
0.0330373645,
0.0071179406,
-0.0023873083,
-0.0040401816,
-0.0201054998,
0.0517131723,
0.0144630931,
0.0222538915,
0.0590639114,
-0.0235234145,
-0.0197741371,
-0.0510959513,
0.0267440751,
0.0354197361,
0.000434725,
0.0230683759,
-0.0209017694,
-0.0196853466,
-0.0028495961,
0.0268552527,
-0.0132084573,
-0.0334683806,
-0.0687936842,
-0.0081087528,
-0.0081589883,
0.0274448097,
-0.0094489735,
0.0357204042,
-0.0050530382,
0.0187675618,
-0.028475007,
0.0282430463,
-0.0154121155,
-0.0010562396,
0.0415338166,
-0.0040503433,
0.0479392931,
-0.0534484647,
-0.0007264843,
0.0259240121,
0.0333416611,
-0.0129177133,
-0.0355439037,
0.0037745691,
0.0217753146,
-0.0203237385,
-0.0169862956,
0.0154062221,
-0.0243522692,
-0.0161922313,
-0.0341095924,
-0.0309947785,
0.0367345065,
-0.0070551578,
0.0466901846,
-0.0126019213,
-0.0051127737,
-0.0047430238,
0.0138971508,
-0.0307906084,
0.0167188123,
-0.0074588559,
-0.0103001036,
0.0149820419,
0.0719327033,
0.0134809464,
-0.0265855268,
-0.0567546971,
0.0072563887,
-0.0197312944,
-0.0289495718,
0.0017942043,
0.0392000079,
0.0258812252,
0.0112191169,
0.0063493433,
-0.0062646684,
0.0542043112,
0.0332783349,
0.0057125478,
-0.0455927141,
-0.0090537658,
-0.0367930271,
0.0255718492,
-0.0433241762,
-0.0002856977,
-0.012819346,
0.0415009148,
-0.0082995286,
-0.0349911936,
0.0340596661,
-0.000082469,
0.0193747785,
-0.0070384387,
0.0163125787,
-0.007322798,
-0.0561423749,
0.0268095359,
-0.036418926,
-0.0563988239,
0.0012121702,
0.028518524,
0.0027744372,
-0.0307449624,
0.0039113448,
-0.019206794,
-0.0558148883,
0.0119425543,
-0.0215593763,
0.039522972,
0.0153197404,
0.0303286202,
-0.0283752177,
0.0330728479,
-0.0375255048,
-0.0031128952,
0.028628381,
-0.0494450554,
0.0221049786,
-0.0050600832,
-0.0115462141,
0.0460707173,
0.0024846292,
-0.0060228696,
-0.0428546667,
0.0549552515,
-0.0153858885,
0.0182956103,
0.0662908927,
-0.0099707711,
-0.0305287614,
0.0064965528,
-0.035666883,
0.00288476,
-0.0284643453,
0.022726899,
-0.0451105163,
-0.0525012501,
-0.0451608412,
-0.0107991975,
-0.0101817474,
-0.013532293,
-0.0093423044,
-0.1243786216,
0.01013528,
0.0109494617,
-0.0420337245,
-0.0589038022,
-0.025239842,
-0.0015216145,
-0.0409329273,
-0.0107099153,
-0.0724121183,
0.0081733968,
-0.0006399279,
0.0431039035,
-0.0303921774,
-0.0777284205,
0.0361660719,
0.0000715802,
0.0492392816,
0.0471977331,
0.0441040657,
-0.016817946,
-0.0160300713,
-0.0011070139,
-0.0284409262,
-0.0183714218,
-0.0499286018,
0.0496265516,
-0.0173073094,
-0.0583848767,
0.002261552,
-0.0290887803,
-0.041697897,
0.0138816964,
0.0123919472,
0.0601808503,
0.0271985121,
-0.0951609835,
-0.047560323,
0.0115167592,
0.0276952684,
0.0447795503,
0.0213899184,
-0.0686953813,
-0.0202038288,
0.0112782922,
-0.0220825169,
-0.0654641986,
-0.0020387773,
-0.0002848503,
-0.0041907486,
-0.0239085052,
-0.0777951628,
-0.0439778976,
0.0160964318,
0.0247892477,
-0.0044832383,
0.0044079702,
0.000747431,
-0.0147317946,
-0.002280371,
0.0053947209,
-0.028494684,
0.0230321698,
-0.0059963898,
-0.011451669,
0.0687131062,
0.0010588432,
0.0058022193,
-0.0487665981,
-0.0669144094,
-0.0380722806,
-0.0203878675,
0.0672648028,
0.0073562944,
-0.00104888,
0.0029384282,
-0.0441621356,
-0.0062485761,
0.0325484499,
-0.0076502985,
-0.0081752976,
0.0587891899,
0.0359786898,
0.0004642505,
0.0637141764,
0.0241751522,
0.0825142041,
0.0539900996,
0.0019112064,
-0.0052941898,
-0.0284793731,
-0.0226045121,
-0.0368409716,
0.0475911796,
0.0244958922,
-0.0767464861,
-0.0330315083,
-0.0162759088,
0.031612061,
0.013306045,
-0.0551924184,
-0.0138757192,
0.0466902852,
0.0053469869,
-0.0643125251,
-0.0144940037,
-0.017205745,
-0.0119524198,
-0.0193619784,
0.0574597307,
0.0745222345,
0.0006935339,
0.001520754,
0.0559618734,
-0.004238735,
-0.0170753971,
0.0409312993,
0.0316911563,
-0.0213027131,
-0.0066694529,
0.0101767201,
0.042744413,
0.0260651223,
-0.0136828655,
0.0070031122,
0.0504633412,
-0.0438987091,
0.0020430733,
0.0433780551,
-0.0425861143,
0.089794904,
-0.0006327159,
-0.0128818788,
-0.0056874412,
0.0438474268,
-0.0327621363,
0.0044483934,
0.0227671936,
-0.0199394636,
-0.0090096677,
0.028783055,
0.0469627604,
-0.0592091158,
0.03808745,
0.0394866727,
0.027172219,
-0.0330253914,
0.0072136875,
0.0698647425,
-0.0447009988,
0.0309535246,
0.0793725997,
-0.0395407863,
-0.06789992,
0.0520805754,
-0.0904245377,
0.0081540821,
0.0172437672,
0.0104770735,
0.0411318578,
0.0227256864,
0.0584185719,
-0.0550393946,
-0.0126265269,
-0.0063131773,
-0.0156830568,
0.0137106087,
-7.046417867e-33,
-0.0158245284,
0.0246527474,
-0.0445053875,
0.0131792659,
-0.0133094694,
-0.0333320647,
-0.0354019627,
0.0260717142,
-0.0515797697,
0.0614807233,
-0.0000013382,
0.000503163,
0.014187797,
0.0664406866,
0.0431760885,
-0.003134673,
0.0131059317,
0.0486466438,
-0.0123740938,
0.0184240192,
0.035256654,
0.0817752257,
0.0767500177,
-0.0915632322,
0.0237631854,
0.0153637109,
-0.0431385376,
-0.0121381478,
0.0565774255,
0.0309630893,
-0.0221460741,
0.0465793088,
0.0490591452,
-0.0148435989,
0.0078083505,
0.0122103393,
-0.0138596352,
-0.0304092299,
0.0177280214,
0.0149155622,
-0.005498359,
-0.0575939342,
0.0084566111,
-0.0048087286,
-0.0060296636,
-0.021203151,
0.0222694185,
-0.0641144887,
-0.0172108039,
-0.0366625935,
-0.1214289069,
0.0318045393,
0.020438144,
-0.0066006514,
0.0378662162,
0.0731947124,
-0.0186104346,
0.0003180174,
-0.0135681108,
0.0244921707,
-0.0393128619,
0.0345971584,
0.0009368771,
-0.0044247438,
-0.0556278415,
0.0462557711,
0.0046450542,
0.0004770535,
0.0065368083,
0.0301367156,
0.0262928959,
0.0346461982,
0.0302874111,
0.1079010963,
0.0242035426,
-0.0605692714,
-0.0595278665,
0.0002010953,
0.0281541273,
0.010391294,
0.021391321,
-0.0075074853,
-0.0178287812,
-0.0256479792,
0.0333707482,
-0.0263502877,
-0.0057911542,
-0.0181235224,
0.0288914125,
-0.0332891382,
-0.0322736092,
0.0135987783,
0.0076344754,
-0.0645537525,
-0.0522271693,
0.0087872846,
-0.0433852039,
0.0112795876,
0.012541174,
-0.0133197121,
-0.0709374845,
-0.0473083742,
-0.042153012,
0.0473240837,
0.0176035538,
-0.0007459961,
0.0826703012,
0.0357278101,
-0.0907483697,
-0.0144425929,
-0.0236760266,
0.0424922407,
-0.0005781688,
0.1131542251,
-0.0426500142,
-0.0039330134,
-0.0107549839,
0.0517864525,
-0.0115862926,
-0.004931822,
0.058272168,
0.0126329185,
-0.0001956978,
-0.0203977041,
-0.0686561912,
-0.0488784313,
-0.0208499469,
-0.0015643181,
-0.0176017601,
-0.0399764404,
-0.0176618788,
-0.0015965202,
2.967e-7,
0.0276839174,
0.033944048,
-0.0337857865,
-0.0646252409,
-0.0139351636,
0.0612376072,
-0.0346262939,
0.0182857905,
0.0112454202,
0.0471068509,
0.005109766,
0.0227463022,
0.1004245579,
0.0372537598,
-0.0750699937,
-0.0045152074,
-0.0160932783,
0.0023489089,
0.0004722282,
-0.0027108092,
0.0388392061,
0.1276856512,
0.0120763304,
-0.0395668224,
-0.0408092104,
-0.0185692906,
0.0752839968,
-0.0495669954,
-0.0081562614,
0.005233285,
-0.0392462797,
0.0475670993,
-0.0466810726,
-0.0050106547,
-0.029946493,
0.0053379005,
0.0236739106,
0.0621301606,
0.0210304335,
-0.0003985224,
0.0299732778,
0.0369678065,
0.0083520785,
-0.0107690133,
0.04997373,
-0.0501900949,
-0.0755622312,
-0.0874408856,
-0.00857752,
0.0046075722,
0.0577724203,
-0.0182273183,
-0.0084203677,
0.002004938,
0.0351496674,
-0.016038496,
-0.1024120003,
-0.0280918442,
0.0188102089,
0.0057463776,
0.006692485,
0.0069076922,
0.0123218773,
0.0420933887,
0.0147006642,
-0.0141877765,
0.0663518533,
2.094096809e-34,
0.0290304814,
-0.0407650359,
0.0256574042,
0.0130374497,
-0.0139301699,
0.0170940198,
-0.0387763381,
-0.0149814477,
0.0188325327,
0.0003142828,
0.0427158512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11223v1 | A Group-Specific Approach to NLP for Hate Speech Detection | 2023-04-21T19:08:49 | 2023-04-21T19:08:49 | Karina Halevy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic hate speech detection is an important yet complex task, requiring
knowledge of common sense, stereotypes of protected groups, and histories of
discrimination, each of which may constantly evolve. In this paper, we propose
a group-specific approach to NLP for online hate speech detection. The approach
consists of creating and infusing historical and linguistic knowledge about a
particular protected group into hate speech detection models, analyzing
historical data about discrimination against a protected group to better
predict spikes in hate speech against that group, and critically evaluating
hate speech detection models through lenses of intersectionality and ethics. We
demonstrate this approach through a case study on NLP for detection of
antisemitic hate speech. The case study synthesizes the current
English-language literature on NLP for antisemitism detection, introduces a
novel knowledge graph of antisemitic history and language from the 20th century
to the present, infuses information from the knowledge graph into a set of
tweets over Logistic Regression and uncased DistilBERT baselines, and suggests
that incorporating context from the knowledge graph can help models pick up
subtle stereotypes. | [
0.0515889376,
0.1172934175,
-0.0091192629,
0.0359496027,
-0.0179713499,
0.0385567956,
0.0471882336,
-0.0004119423,
0.0419959314,
-0.1034379378,
0.0314232633,
-0.0062819743,
0.003968575,
0.0087446803,
-0.0061412831,
-0.0221994333,
0.0224384069,
0.0492272414,
0.0561056174,
-0.0492218919,
0.0481702685,
0.0340624601,
-0.0178211983,
0.0251395348,
-0.0470952541,
0.0158180408,
0.0578172468,
-0.0139812566,
0.0385371856,
0.0140926857,
0.0375457034,
0.0258081481,
0.0101960069,
0.0437432751,
0.0000015666,
-0.0384143852,
-0.0040212185,
-0.0089995191,
0.0198055319,
-0.0601880737,
0.0373332761,
-0.066226095,
-0.0113505507,
0.0176652167,
-0.0497781076,
0.0250809714,
0.0517395325,
0.0316986814,
0.0502364896,
0.0463034287,
-0.0149434749,
-0.0105429189,
-0.0033857094,
0.0365172699,
0.0057918653,
0.0229560398,
0.0519870594,
-0.0527024716,
-0.0688824505,
-0.0261009485,
-0.0053859972,
0.0148481466,
0.0148647055,
0.0447650626,
0.0232615788,
-0.0436215289,
-0.041546911,
-0.015453266,
0.0025281224,
0.01647502,
-0.0199672487,
-0.001315314,
0.0174649023,
0.0154565405,
-0.0214513037,
-0.0112265479,
-0.0038859702,
0.0132227335,
-0.0520522706,
0.0081533287,
0.0109254094,
-0.0002666987,
0.0479782522,
0.0827259123,
0.0194919948,
0.0550513081,
-0.0163576342,
-0.0003271099,
0.0098913638,
-0.0176238194,
-0.0171929318,
0.0260665957,
0.0268797055,
0.0166490581,
-0.0010629259,
0.0402610153,
-0.0389457159,
-0.0206942447,
0.0148234479,
-0.0536667071,
-0.0060412907,
0.0453385413,
0.0241717752,
-0.0080100661,
0.0117378598,
0.0164409447,
0.0132898986,
-0.0113663338,
0.0192760397,
-0.0277811792,
-0.0450042188,
0.0086963316,
-0.0063952836,
-0.0104280664,
-0.00517094,
0.0557884425,
-0.0314328521,
-0.0180366803,
-0.0583217219,
0.0078585772,
-0.0313767418,
0.0096708173,
0.0055733928,
0.0121209528,
-0.0129002938,
-0.0042018755,
-0.0433224738,
-0.0186746716,
-0.0686024874,
-0.0655449182,
0.0516031273,
-0.0053453227,
-0.0298074689,
-0.0115064951,
0.0032593147,
0.0806401819,
0.0382798202,
-0.0183657669,
-0.0273808986,
-0.0308685582,
-0.0172653589,
-0.0058096056,
0.0285700168,
-0.0428845622,
0.0372933634,
0.020255059,
-0.0214859359,
-0.0918052867,
0.0032227242,
0.0212359428,
-0.0495440103,
0.1019034758,
0.0451328717,
-0.0064715282,
0.0531858914,
0.0216114689,
-0.0024060134,
0.0522214957,
0.010106178,
-0.0051120794,
0.0499775559,
0.0186325703,
0.0046587475,
0.024335891,
0.0488203131,
0.0174336396,
-0.0273797065,
0.0106851775,
-0.0631193072,
-0.0571108349,
-0.0140911015,
0.0431067422,
0.0330790468,
-0.0794805288,
0.0270420611,
0.0913485438,
-0.024294842,
0.0156081486,
0.0176456161,
0.0216078535,
-0.0252331197,
-0.0352506563,
-0.0587295704,
-0.035824053,
-0.0438848995,
-0.0600604489,
-0.0412833393,
0.0769307911,
0.0000077091,
-0.0163634755,
-0.0580083467,
0.0182273462,
0.0812556371,
-0.0415582731,
0.0166340359,
-0.0042250524,
-0.0119077656,
0.0205197614,
0.0624672547,
0.0067755096,
0.0199062862,
-0.0456045605,
-0.0067160856,
0.0543862395,
0.0088891611,
-0.0106950384,
0.016244432,
-0.0411942191,
-0.0386376902,
0.0491055995,
0.0155576244,
-0.0240276735,
-0.0176461078,
0.004402576,
-0.0034878075,
0.0510288253,
0.0101675848,
0.0449073315,
0.0896911398,
0.0282110106,
0.0044603166,
0.0078123664,
-0.0248550568,
0.0128189204,
0.0042861607,
-0.0283132512,
-0.0353754349,
0.006567555,
0.0163673442,
0.0265564006,
-0.0050687003,
-0.0447616354,
-0.01766764,
0.0057950891,
-0.0674907118,
0.0158588272,
-0.0418010764,
0.0094778622,
0.0135844555,
-0.0478253663,
-0.0250859801,
0.0579825975,
-0.000306094,
0.0349424258,
0.0692049861,
-0.0034529567,
0.0097984476,
-0.0393054783,
-0.0489158146,
-0.0593861528,
0.0146436002,
-0.0476211682,
0.0684936047,
-0.010705187,
0.0000364799,
0.0321829133,
-0.0958808139,
0.0612963773,
0.0429915003,
-0.053433001,
0.0073059276,
-0.0257135686,
0.0448475368,
0.024671711,
-0.0171382409,
-0.0160218589,
0.0605538115,
-0.071242623,
-0.0134283258,
-0.0066408124,
-0.0226919521,
-0.0003461201,
0.0114551298,
-0.0090720654,
0.0114392815,
0.0070017143,
-0.03553598,
0.041526895,
0.0264003351,
-0.0089369025,
-0.056645181,
0.0003294347,
-0.0172425229,
-0.0182856619,
-0.0475576818,
0.0433645844,
0.0389235392,
-0.0615413673,
0.0531657748,
-0.05278752,
-0.0556714758,
0.0364082456,
-0.0034473946,
-0.021213457,
0.0426913016,
0.0494645052,
0.0012968382,
0.0337970667,
0.0481586829,
0.077011846,
0.0149771208,
-0.0168754347,
-0.0031886541,
-0.0176386833,
-0.0261719283,
0.0240044612,
-0.0206514746,
-0.0164537858,
-0.0130118197,
0.0889717117,
0.0682114661,
-0.036819607,
-0.0601511784,
0.040221747,
-0.121299386,
-0.0342288017,
-0.0608085021,
-0.0776298866,
-0.0172567442,
-0.0159431081,
-0.0505599156,
-0.0493973047,
0.0579536036,
0.0384836644,
0.0383818783,
0.0014816046,
-0.02321456,
-0.0062961346,
0.0809417069,
0.0163701624,
0.0528898574,
-0.0198407508,
-0.0184627958,
-0.0021828956,
-0.0331546329,
0.0286582094,
-0.0411423407,
-0.0033778718,
-0.0258869044,
0.0267771445,
-0.0018433742,
-0.0170363933,
-0.0781388432,
-0.0437514856,
-0.0539878793,
-0.023504911,
-0.000829811,
-0.0176931974,
-0.0077610016,
0.0110371495,
0.0086617749,
-0.0306049176,
0.024369061,
-0.0117399273,
0.0381014086,
-0.0388358496,
-0.0324491262,
-0.0546744168,
0.0235962588,
0.0238734819,
-0.0333474241,
0.0515395738,
-0.001070504,
0.0251064785,
-0.0035367596,
-0.0019264614,
0.0217772797,
-0.0158073753,
0.0158721935,
-0.0298077464,
0.0022472078,
0.0045679044,
0.0429861471,
0.078452684,
0.020498449,
-0.0056170789,
0.004514413,
0.0230884608,
-0.0261251759,
0.002908227,
-0.0142363263,
-0.0886760876,
0.0191725865,
-0.0270515345,
0.0116686905,
-0.0998241901,
-0.0709621161,
-0.0061885556,
-0.0312104598,
-0.0279644094,
0.0012205578,
-0.0178739838,
-0.0249667689,
-0.0020215465,
0.0288608074,
0.0000085604,
0.0260954704,
-0.0355288722,
0.0247986969,
0.015039037,
0.0068511418,
-0.0862615034,
0.0016956705,
0.0450681262,
-0.0161651652,
0.028751662,
0.0030479906,
0.0666889921,
-0.0048807752,
0.0146138538,
0.0265695751,
-0.0352629311,
-0.0212110858,
-0.0591675304,
0.0303787123,
-0.0135856569,
-0.0327607207,
-0.0109340381,
0.0372579433,
-0.0145851914,
-0.015803203,
0.0135120004,
0.0291536581,
0.0197226331,
-0.0073539526,
-0.0569466278,
0.0232579391,
0.0050653168,
0.0693344101,
-0.0103830835,
-0.014232439,
0.040028207,
-0.1055693701,
-0.0007868871,
-0.0355884992,
-0.094005011,
0.0169800632,
-0.014920529,
-0.0198123921,
-0.0331627354,
-0.0139163546,
0.0205945168,
0.0008562846,
0.038974639,
-0.0293816533,
0.0101216659,
-0.0050365017,
-0.0792094097,
-0.0019741144,
-0.0023509723,
0.0515901372,
0.0363233946,
-0.010400367,
-0.0169425625,
0.0043741176,
-0.0310271326,
0.053904023,
-0.0130153056,
-0.0529319569,
0.0950384587,
-0.0376998112,
0.0224900469,
0.0310363229,
-0.0179623682,
-0.0168606918,
0.0607377365,
0.0525107644,
-0.0045641586,
0.0068065119,
0.0308275837,
-0.0056569474,
0.0142348818,
0.0096676843,
-0.0010644353,
0.0555260517,
0.0367276445,
-0.0601925105,
-0.0856685191,
0.0011953112,
-0.0252469014,
-0.0145727163,
0.0162518248,
-0.0097079063,
-0.0449303649,
-0.0197389293,
-0.0688654408,
0.0114638424,
-0.0519135669,
-0.0005339155,
-0.0254103113,
0.0086209401,
-0.0028492208,
-0.0669129938,
-0.0030799666,
-0.0367396846,
0.0276216399,
-0.0584663749,
0.0285295825,
0.0315727703,
0.0324871205,
0.0181927662,
-0.0011421784,
0.0120190354,
0.0285296794,
-0.0204757638,
-0.0266315211,
0.003314663,
0.0060459152,
0.0255329479,
-0.0083819423,
0.0251216628,
-0.0493863262,
-0.0154895224,
-0.0217937399,
-0.0293632038,
-0.0474674106,
-0.0267008115,
-0.0065168948,
0.0195196923,
0.0028204934,
-0.0233313423,
0.0039549642,
0.0102790818,
0.0007120627,
-0.0309301205,
0.0335263163,
0.0314205363,
-0.0231762473,
0.0086004846,
0.004737963,
0.024806533,
0.0507569909,
0.0562303253,
-0.061335858,
-0.0141956387,
0.0004118489,
0.0464478619,
0.003938552,
0.0287717562,
0.0212151874,
-0.0830502138,
-0.0341329649,
-0.0087387562,
-0.0353763551,
0.0530559383,
-0.0079200184,
0.00553422,
0.0700288489,
0.0009964831,
0.0317374989,
-0.0233467221,
0.0392420366,
-0.0227345377,
-0.051207345,
0.0086933775,
-5.299349306e-33,
-0.0143616069,
-0.067708388,
-0.0203906614,
0.0005129944,
-0.0004717655,
-0.0044652899,
0.0363031626,
-0.0008967312,
-0.0389089696,
0.0208468437,
0.0146307619,
0.0413801894,
-0.0087035755,
0.0082944455,
-0.0191880222,
-0.0323336571,
0.0241580307,
-0.0026840623,
-0.0021418813,
-0.0169853065,
0.047580082,
0.0146213667,
0.0287680943,
-0.0407470278,
0.0669535547,
0.0093400171,
-0.0320950896,
0.0157104488,
0.0281120036,
0.0349678174,
-0.0162629951,
0.0987604558,
0.0488699861,
-0.0168216787,
0.0247375984,
0.0658510029,
-0.0535436496,
0.0017551529,
0.0366718024,
0.0066598244,
0.0240378343,
0.0300197471,
0.0064102025,
-0.006469056,
-0.0411990918,
-0.0316156186,
0.0596301481,
-0.0187158026,
0.0226936005,
-0.0297879446,
-0.0769200623,
0.0292878896,
-0.0421351045,
0.0264648441,
-0.012043301,
-0.0096545601,
0.0705337599,
0.0056914724,
-0.029159015,
0.0201789476,
-0.03717044,
-0.0482374318,
-0.0055531762,
0.011458531,
-0.00493808,
0.0591477007,
-0.0172835365,
0.0230969395,
-0.0181752946,
0.0324649699,
0.0461225398,
0.0085956408,
0.0141408015,
0.0648345351,
0.0068269856,
-0.068605803,
-0.0019944557,
-0.0169520695,
0.0558033772,
-0.0210978743,
-0.0078732697,
-0.0278432816,
-0.0556454472,
-0.0424146168,
-0.0356587023,
-0.0734330267,
-0.0243859533,
-0.0083543621,
0.0046925819,
-0.0175979584,
-0.0454527512,
0.0057672989,
0.0092267646,
-0.020465482,
0.0136932265,
0.0870684236,
-0.0113597661,
-0.0310264695,
0.0194955338,
0.0435801521,
-0.0401673578,
-0.0144971674,
-0.0164764151,
-0.0034297302,
0.0499162711,
-0.0220528897,
0.0427535735,
0.0434020758,
-0.0353042819,
0.0221822876,
-0.0015896328,
0.047571633,
-0.0336069465,
0.0219883695,
0.0220991783,
0.0623426996,
-0.0147205871,
-0.024554478,
0.038467072,
-0.0536805466,
0.0102910139,
0.0168277789,
-0.0356414355,
0.0227453187,
-0.0284584351,
-0.0477085263,
0.0346801765,
0.0200873259,
0.0593189523,
-0.0735706463,
0.0075902916,
-0.0655870214,
2.289e-7,
0.0260182116,
0.0188535135,
0.000044742,
0.0162826683,
0.026438931,
0.0181201119,
0.0660062283,
0.0227033645,
-0.0147952316,
0.0039722524,
-0.039204251,
0.0654320121,
0.0049529495,
0.049642995,
-0.0017172273,
-0.0420317277,
-0.0359496363,
0.001624546,
-0.0596011393,
0.0408526957,
-0.0014504772,
0.0377306268,
0.0864005908,
-0.0272058696,
-0.0541556701,
-0.0262640323,
-0.005531515,
-0.0409027301,
-0.0163126849,
-0.013200881,
0.0614894256,
0.0143779367,
0.0254001729,
0.0012861622,
-0.0098607,
0.0126389237,
0.0291367359,
0.0066486453,
0.0026072713,
0.0356710665,
-0.0213691108,
-0.0354323499,
-0.0230670944,
-0.0287287273,
0.037957266,
0.0192857683,
-0.0095784618,
-0.0426155441,
-0.0223782808,
-0.021945715,
0.0190149937,
0.0051595685,
-0.0241296105,
-0.0195890386,
0.0254841223,
0.0060918746,
0.0162866786,
-0.065238297,
0.0159971826,
-0.0066080401,
-0.0114827789,
-0.0272021145,
0.0155906994,
-0.0355450511,
0.0170727316,
0.0386266932,
0.0269715637,
1.67602547e-34,
0.0108826887,
-0.0019848531,
-0.0319219381,
-0.0485254228,
0.039259918,
0.0103531219,
-0.0048497333,
-0.0026188225,
0.0457565486,
0.0109718489,
-0.0008306922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11220v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11220v2 | Learn What NOT to Learn: Towards Generative Safety in Chatbots | 2023-04-21T18:59:06 | 2023-04-25T08:16:47 | Leila Khalatbari, Yejin Bang, Dan Su, Willy Chung, Saeed Ghadimi, Hossein Sameti, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational models that are generative and open-domain are particularly
susceptible to generating unsafe content since they are trained on web-based
social data. Prior approaches to mitigating this issue have drawbacks, such as
disrupting the flow of conversation, limited generalization to unseen toxic
input contexts, and sacrificing the quality of the dialogue for the sake of
safety. In this paper, we present a novel framework, named "LOT" (Learn NOT
to), that employs a contrastive loss to enhance generalization by learning from
both positive and negative training signals. Our approach differs from the
standard contrastive learning framework in that it automatically obtains
positive and negative signals from the safe and unsafe language distributions
that have been learned beforehand. The LOT framework utilizes divergence to
steer the generations away from the unsafe subspace and towards the safe
subspace while sustaining the flow of conversation. Our approach is memory and
time-efficient during decoding and effectively reduces toxicity while
preserving engagingness and fluency. Empirical results indicate that LOT
reduces toxicity by up to four-fold while achieving four to six-fold higher
rates of engagingness and fluency compared to baseline models. Our findings are
further corroborated by human evaluation. | [
0.0451409929,
0.0628819093,
-0.0226161834,
-0.0246734563,
-0.0048737773,
0.0381516032,
-0.0273157563,
-0.0129781067,
0.0270885658,
0.0174563788,
-0.03131897,
-0.0452593975,
-0.0211100113,
0.0602287911,
0.0249188133,
-0.0758657008,
0.0581824407,
-0.0119994041,
0.0110546052,
0.0031959706,
0.0403173231,
0.012278283,
-0.0141610326,
0.0429991186,
-0.0320396461,
-0.0034102043,
-0.017995717,
0.0228837281,
0.0509532429,
-0.0394537151,
0.0489699729,
0.0170430094,
0.0126095051,
0.034884423,
0.0000019668,
-0.0112969754,
-0.0112225823,
-0.0129810879,
0.0013192297,
-0.0712674856,
0.0612208359,
-0.0116202179,
-0.0372760668,
0.0508143306,
-0.0681643412,
-0.0236655027,
0.0676577613,
0.0590609238,
0.0729864389,
0.0844830498,
-0.0075144446,
-0.0070695337,
0.0528168306,
0.0291856229,
0.0093450323,
-0.0387472361,
-0.0016529064,
0.0142544564,
0.0108827241,
0.0098196566,
-0.0352390446,
0.0223866161,
0.0362466462,
-0.029970387,
0.0363682993,
0.0201032497,
-0.0037342017,
-0.0735761225,
-0.0064562215,
0.0880531892,
-0.0229993463,
-0.0038607395,
0.0040855324,
0.0102574844,
0.0262704454,
-0.0437524542,
-0.0370775908,
0.0305182189,
-0.0314818248,
0.0098788682,
-0.0162074938,
0.0239735395,
0.0041620806,
0.0107057858,
0.0255521722,
-0.0229644142,
0.0083630383,
-0.0089071598,
0.0103502581,
0.0038130798,
-0.0260406993,
-0.0030572996,
0.022118926,
0.0171698462,
-0.0569166057,
0.0331219286,
-0.0628376603,
-0.0295115653,
0.0272605512,
-0.0749772266,
-0.0126782591,
0.0184377674,
-0.0266138669,
0.0317581072,
0.01679378,
-0.0040926537,
0.0025856833,
0.0120553449,
-0.0115005765,
0.0058182878,
-0.0303819366,
-0.0124864634,
-0.0249870364,
0.0224544816,
0.0039265365,
0.0036434776,
-0.0301663205,
0.0474370159,
-0.048981268,
0.0100804893,
0.0037031504,
0.0480156094,
-0.0635880083,
0.0063609672,
-0.0147799551,
-0.0050357287,
-0.0330059417,
0.0065818066,
0.0296100453,
-0.0950898081,
-0.0319942683,
0.0175621659,
-0.0017477326,
-0.003496025,
-0.0201518666,
0.1195517108,
-0.0146072907,
-0.0258440599,
-0.0416722484,
-0.0208444688,
-0.0210255198,
-0.0330276191,
0.0127345808,
-0.0080545526,
0.0123201441,
-0.0257326607,
-0.026609499,
-0.062359497,
0.0147202993,
0.0071501108,
-0.0063643944,
0.056922812,
-0.0329542011,
-0.0250596199,
0.0290989392,
0.0493311696,
-0.0410173647,
0.0600634962,
0.0258827433,
0.0082446756,
-0.0117285643,
0.001828009,
0.0435326993,
0.0071902638,
0.030734783,
-0.0065389127,
0.0014360634,
-0.0131735438,
0.0098965047,
0.0039757034,
0.0303567015,
0.0679959729,
-0.0503577404,
-0.0352902897,
0.0950829312,
0.0091955233,
-0.0287622418,
0.0487835407,
0.0490872003,
0.0241236258,
-0.0122856526,
0.0150255812,
-0.0433962233,
0.0302349608,
-0.0395474806,
-0.0200867504,
0.0008966017,
-0.00300055,
-0.0342817567,
-0.0246893782,
0.0343358666,
-0.0277249832,
0.0910430253,
-0.0275585689,
0.0239195712,
0.0512370914,
-0.0653378218,
-0.027522618,
0.0648944452,
-0.048304297,
-0.0056381333,
-0.0341923945,
0.0352296978,
0.0795336515,
0.0278531928,
-0.0003065736,
-0.0500180982,
-0.0493985824,
-0.0299229212,
0.0299343765,
-0.00342643,
-0.0149503443,
0.0689432696,
-0.0357539989,
-0.0306037012,
0.0327305645,
-0.0143485144,
0.005906994,
0.0507303774,
0.0165834259,
-0.0140794767,
-0.0066616451,
-0.0183284339,
0.0270779487,
-0.044583302,
-0.0375814736,
-0.0164455939,
0.0067127924,
0.0553221107,
-0.0155473072,
0.0033281732,
-0.0284030102,
0.0183901731,
0.0039700237,
-0.0350047536,
0.0175379142,
-0.0787099972,
-0.0189895108,
0.0193237569,
-0.0412559994,
-0.0332797691,
0.0561034232,
-0.0366761424,
0.0164819881,
0.0359919146,
-0.0776263922,
0.0262147449,
-0.0132285031,
0.0028412477,
-0.0035319352,
0.0130514875,
0.000580602,
0.0582177415,
-0.0255738571,
-0.0584790967,
-0.0057605729,
0.0106362682,
-0.0310625844,
-0.0292637944,
-0.0172090903,
-0.0048039122,
-0.0214221459,
0.0491160415,
0.0403446704,
0.0257430021,
-0.0925851241,
-0.0017439497,
-0.0576943606,
0.0031423722,
-0.0043942947,
0.0028550003,
0.0053185611,
-0.0140538877,
0.003095971,
-0.0129268337,
-0.0156753082,
0.0313129313,
-0.0154065518,
0.0219507869,
0.0134217953,
-0.0021617457,
-0.008459595,
-0.0244317427,
0.0259419326,
0.0147855962,
0.0290619601,
-0.021843642,
0.0070316042,
-0.0308874119,
0.0713299513,
-0.0262657367,
0.0397478454,
-0.0075912755,
-0.0728545263,
0.0332953632,
0.0099188024,
0.038282387,
0.084455058,
0.0683410466,
0.0487047918,
0.0112604219,
0.0074008461,
-0.053509552,
0.0169810094,
-0.0221300442,
-0.0401329808,
0.0033270328,
-0.0254377294,
-0.0283639431,
0.0517725907,
-0.001139269,
0.0224156491,
-0.0994646698,
0.0118258195,
-0.0079746265,
-0.0758416355,
0.0164564252,
-0.0306293182,
-0.0427376293,
-0.011733423,
-0.0361605622,
-0.0530879907,
0.0919290558,
0.0387322605,
0.007816066,
-0.0129732126,
-0.0295740943,
0.0444110706,
0.0354209542,
-0.029746687,
0.0153472815,
0.0621456355,
-0.0494793877,
-0.0629159287,
-0.01144809,
0.0398211107,
-0.041781567,
0.0072539058,
-0.0346667729,
-0.0369573236,
0.0235584341,
-0.0614726171,
-0.0830550715,
-0.0041057775,
0.0091693047,
0.0022451051,
0.0263322759,
-0.0381001495,
-0.0322509408,
-0.0240806714,
0.0086781709,
-0.0147047713,
-0.0302911587,
-0.0209933706,
0.001210393,
-0.0056802989,
0.0642396659,
-0.0176953655,
0.020959232,
-0.0277931318,
0.0451808423,
0.095081903,
-0.0220330376,
-0.027307732,
-0.0409477241,
-0.0004495459,
-0.0044377754,
0.0291273948,
-0.0109703224,
0.0236030091,
0.0469167233,
-0.0293910969,
-0.0317285135,
0.0520034693,
-0.0146241747,
0.0043290267,
0.0158844572,
-0.0243556779,
0.0530304164,
-0.0144851021,
-0.0153745711,
-0.0508656427,
-0.0188299157,
0.0127565786,
0.0551708005,
-0.0201651882,
-0.0339633338,
0.027879918,
-0.0778900459,
0.007303671,
0.021398643,
-0.0677953213,
-0.048856061,
-0.0152803436,
-0.0189626385,
-0.0334798954,
0.0477698669,
0.0028879819,
0.0055470974,
-0.0238484778,
0.0266198069,
0.0041309022,
-0.0379947312,
-0.0137388185,
-0.041998174,
0.0894081667,
0.0597042963,
0.0488872118,
0.0123317176,
0.0036384056,
0.0135306679,
-0.000452178,
-0.0233495478,
-0.0185739342,
0.0605651699,
-0.0146508133,
-0.0103830183,
-0.0324969068,
0.038848538,
0.0210497826,
-0.0274380222,
-0.0250918847,
0.0445068441,
-0.0005569661,
-0.0162422471,
-0.0382016823,
0.0623438098,
0.0510307029,
0.0510263853,
0.0192764029,
-0.0389080979,
-0.0034090707,
-0.0371156223,
0.0247964524,
-0.0224974342,
-0.0313231945,
-0.0265535209,
-0.0031459271,
-0.0656801537,
-0.0889634788,
-0.0357712843,
0.0032884884,
0.007553196,
-0.0129666487,
-0.0445454121,
-0.009012416,
0.0230345596,
-0.0212315675,
0.0161872152,
-0.0234132223,
-0.0220820718,
-0.0264433473,
-0.0090976991,
-0.001518077,
-0.0741327405,
0.0017696642,
0.037662629,
-0.041756127,
-0.0777801573,
0.0144332228,
0.1105329692,
0.0170309115,
0.0381710716,
-0.017849775,
-0.0406757034,
0.0661849827,
0.0602109358,
-0.0277017243,
-0.0288137812,
0.0828825235,
0.0329664648,
0.0254120696,
0.0122162038,
-0.0533063225,
-0.0165628232,
0.0264738537,
0.018784117,
-0.0424045622,
-0.0066439761,
0.0322097056,
-0.0170153901,
0.0249041133,
-0.0118067171,
-0.0060460805,
-0.01187139,
-0.0052770707,
-0.0108150989,
-0.0031997147,
-0.031581834,
0.03759313,
0.0395199917,
0.0138472421,
-0.0088438299,
0.0235991348,
-0.0185767375,
0.0600283556,
-0.0142748291,
-0.0225467943,
0.0498217382,
0.0094273631,
0.028699955,
0.0247020703,
-0.0293697547,
0.0096115815,
-0.0103155393,
0.0066840914,
0.0082624331,
0.0442300811,
0.0112670474,
-0.0049446519,
0.0319975503,
0.0346512571,
-0.0472885594,
-0.0362595096,
-0.0408206321,
0.0181253571,
0.0110881338,
0.038129922,
0.0503847748,
-0.0327094905,
0.0141158225,
-0.0187132806,
0.0397695638,
-0.0403831787,
-0.0543140396,
-0.0155848376,
0.0122322971,
0.0050433381,
-0.0126768565,
0.0653948188,
-0.0290862173,
0.0700025856,
-0.0282766577,
0.0022467352,
-0.0412681252,
-0.0221903827,
0.0589948036,
0.0294426866,
-0.014971301,
0.0142006893,
-0.0253118929,
-0.0695324764,
-0.0250077154,
0.0112276888,
0.0193804801,
0.0020717834,
0.0587882549,
-0.0072695455,
-0.0304864086,
-0.0096311895,
-0.0177216046,
-0.0038710146,
0.0232259203,
0.007184437,
-0.0273522735,
-6.3224691e-33,
-0.0021664032,
-0.0214818493,
-0.0030793741,
0.0065732477,
-0.0436373986,
-0.0325037688,
-0.0220656972,
0.0021663951,
-0.0249218065,
0.0195920188,
0.0021157709,
0.0463925637,
-0.0080300588,
0.0060546626,
-0.0137211243,
-0.063733466,
0.0466238894,
-0.0088608274,
-0.0098966174,
0.0556803904,
0.0416968651,
0.0414450169,
0.0367016979,
-0.1008482128,
0.0061807116,
-0.002307805,
-0.0377860628,
0.0161974188,
0.0254027471,
0.0434669442,
0.0031702633,
0.0328448191,
-0.0068805101,
-0.028496569,
-0.0127362348,
0.0332142897,
-0.0507443808,
-0.0105417846,
-0.0071929307,
-0.0177337304,
-0.0618859977,
-0.0579359904,
0.0410944894,
-0.0298604462,
0.0095433686,
-0.0300422795,
-0.0003556608,
-0.0202301573,
0.0048781228,
-0.0280904658,
-0.0798922256,
-0.0007943072,
-0.0192972217,
-0.0736410618,
-0.0166349132,
0.0677748919,
0.0097524449,
-0.0109166754,
-0.0049410374,
0.0309020318,
-0.0281182267,
-0.0403237082,
0.0368775874,
-0.0080654332,
0.016251158,
0.0735644624,
0.0150592979,
0.0232108459,
-0.0061461707,
-0.0636306927,
0.0099608973,
0.0381442532,
0.0211026482,
0.0557507575,
0.0133022731,
-0.0416074991,
-0.0638686791,
0.0288722273,
-0.0077675553,
0.0700035766,
-0.0115847494,
0.0191008765,
-0.0502118655,
-0.0020462244,
0.0043016016,
-0.0051874854,
-0.0054311543,
-0.0370394327,
0.0081299506,
0.0098533127,
-0.0367402732,
-0.0611268394,
0.0024625494,
-0.0573261827,
0.0710226595,
0.0621134453,
-0.0149852009,
-0.0164059978,
-0.0056496426,
0.010289236,
-0.0180240218,
-0.0334673598,
0.0819361433,
-0.0361907706,
0.0109025799,
0.0262415465,
0.0556182116,
0.0561802834,
-0.042734012,
0.0025653967,
-0.0408306755,
0.0713060275,
0.0092971418,
0.0081261909,
0.0385323018,
0.0134151503,
-0.0126670348,
0.0259525944,
0.0523246564,
0.0455280766,
-0.0432518609,
0.0095888283,
-0.0298892763,
-0.0050899256,
-0.0345260389,
-0.0085772928,
-0.0146127595,
0.0134338355,
0.0095962444,
-0.0925434828,
-0.0322336368,
-0.0088176392,
2.784e-7,
-0.0155439917,
0.0384825282,
0.0175478142,
0.0446134619,
0.0191759542,
0.0709529147,
0.0160020851,
0.0643785,
0.0117258513,
-0.0182949919,
0.0159795806,
0.0331397615,
0.0642269626,
0.049533613,
-0.0640608221,
-0.020725904,
-0.072787419,
-0.0279444754,
-0.0030960776,
-0.0172192473,
0.0978063121,
0.0810028166,
0.0104000298,
-0.0393737443,
0.04968163,
-0.0126439286,
0.0522908419,
-0.0238815807,
-0.0014577116,
-0.0239456594,
0.0211963449,
0.027426362,
0.0083554825,
0.0110638309,
-0.005054479,
-0.0175294615,
-0.0277948696,
0.0456426144,
-0.0029828094,
-0.0733366162,
0.0203769915,
-0.0105369389,
0.0004130878,
-0.0149128223,
0.0436451733,
-0.0494153574,
-0.0296292864,
-0.0191009343,
-0.0466018207,
-0.015983114,
0.0318468884,
-0.0560778789,
-0.0438094661,
-0.0048804814,
-0.0018638619,
0.0257556606,
-0.014308935,
-0.0476722717,
0.0230443887,
-0.0051362598,
-0.0320418514,
-0.1078794599,
0.0072806403,
0.0277402941,
0.011325255,
-0.0117966207,
0.0465674885,
1.888729336e-34,
0.0139440531,
-0.0376488566,
0.0177151486,
0.0144488318,
0.0339187905,
0.0202265196,
0.0165281594,
0.0066208574,
0.0549779162,
0.0183747876,
-0.0112727219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11158v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11158v2 | Emergent and Predictable Memorization in Large Language Models | 2023-04-21T17:58:31 | 2023-05-31T19:09:45 | Stella Biderman, USVSN Sai Prashanth, Lintang Sutawika, Hailey Schoelkopf, Quentin Anthony, Shivanshu Purohit, Edward Raff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Memorization, or the tendency of large language models (LLMs) to output
entire sequences from their training data verbatim, is a key concern for safely
deploying language models. In particular, it is vital to minimize a model's
memorization of sensitive datapoints such as those containing personal
identifiable information (PII). The prevalence of such undesirable memorization
can pose issues for model trainers, and may even require discarding an
otherwise functional model. We therefore seek to predict which sequences will
be memorized before a large model's full train-time by extrapolating the
memorization behavior of lower-compute trial runs. We measure memorization of
the Pythia model suite and plot scaling laws for forecasting memorization,
allowing us to provide equi-compute recommendations to maximize the reliability
(recall) of such predictions. We additionally provide further novel discoveries
on the distribution of memorization scores across models and data. We release
all code and data necessary to reproduce the results in this paper at
https://github.com/EleutherAI/pythia | [
-0.0116553875,
0.0788677111,
-0.0237429906,
0.0268165488,
-0.0190460887,
0.0061465679,
0.0070191072,
-0.0004708729,
-0.0043601389,
0.0009740574,
-0.005314257,
-0.0784606934,
0.0178071763,
0.0289387703,
0.0103901019,
-0.0275215562,
0.0255240295,
-0.06037632,
-0.0079021025,
-0.0186627731,
-0.0175700989,
-0.0238367599,
0.0280232541,
0.0437858403,
-0.0000100985,
-0.0051588141,
-0.0117950384,
-0.0312036239,
-0.0107545303,
-0.0676162913,
0.0079336306,
0.0718367845,
0.0184893496,
0.041479554,
0.0000021209,
-0.0273354799,
-0.025413366,
0.0018211724,
-0.0559864864,
0.0602809675,
0.020775672,
0.0201241765,
0.0109437313,
0.0216835663,
-0.0274038836,
0.003476979,
0.0515369661,
0.0089394869,
0.0294458177,
0.0424109399,
0.01283627,
0.0020748554,
0.0065455013,
-0.0384685546,
-0.0055984319,
-0.0375771523,
0.0288213156,
-0.0409750454,
-0.0483610407,
-0.0419946387,
-0.0335011445,
0.0140284877,
0.0169727001,
0.0455694944,
0.0211897623,
0.0642334297,
0.0226575918,
-0.0269466229,
-0.015381976,
0.0298042595,
0.0017070435,
-0.0459621251,
0.0143417893,
0.0014410627,
0.0087659042,
0.0103451349,
-0.0513866432,
0.0190879926,
-0.0107352603,
-0.0118604051,
0.0052023665,
-0.0171007216,
0.0425531007,
-0.008645732,
-0.049358651,
0.0406668149,
0.0234239716,
-0.0100178663,
-0.0105360886,
-0.0226224344,
0.0055737323,
-0.0743846074,
0.0189613551,
0.0499969348,
-0.0022048773,
0.0242543258,
-0.0319697782,
-0.0312127527,
0.0309713278,
-0.0482405983,
0.1023885086,
0.0052402457,
0.0214937869,
0.0138395214,
-0.030510338,
0.0700894445,
0.0035697648,
0.0054162745,
0.0088732345,
0.0363903604,
-0.0366613865,
-0.0017771043,
-0.0095714005,
0.0241749436,
0.0649379864,
0.0011440188,
-0.0489654168,
0.0209253225,
0.003824505,
0.0262995567,
-0.0021903694,
-0.0041525904,
-0.0363058373,
0.0131340604,
-0.0334702171,
-0.0041678939,
-0.0356429443,
-0.004827511,
0.0070860763,
-0.0304816663,
-0.0224015713,
-0.0240409989,
0.0002920167,
-0.0038840149,
0.0045801485,
0.0417958722,
0.0290268585,
-0.0472791195,
-0.065806441,
-0.0355776623,
-0.0131634045,
-0.0536316521,
0.0144914882,
-0.0580712967,
-0.0422579274,
0.0193235409,
0.0092145726,
-0.0451276787,
-0.0050371573,
0.0259187091,
-0.0434531644,
0.0422490239,
0.0444405936,
-0.0138305873,
-0.0225183405,
0.0179435164,
0.0158006512,
0.0404549092,
0.0345693193,
0.0405904055,
0.0443088487,
-0.0553449914,
0.0429587662,
0.0333258994,
0.0648307428,
0.0233437624,
-0.0093243383,
0.0045803655,
0.056500487,
-0.0337105207,
0.0299484562,
0.0294211451,
-0.008801382,
-0.0375834927,
0.0577133149,
0.0880528018,
-0.0206362829,
0.0114591615,
0.0268154927,
-0.0141985863,
0.0253719352,
0.0208647829,
-0.0605308115,
0.0228941049,
-0.0102258855,
0.0284087583,
0.0103901578,
0.0472581238,
-0.0349006914,
-0.0227580555,
-0.0062872209,
-0.0349457189,
0.0122034997,
0.0058085681,
0.0175340828,
0.0047294106,
-0.0403114893,
0.0657942817,
0.0252934452,
-0.0679014698,
-0.0110115185,
-0.0397110507,
0.0443789735,
0.0514641926,
0.0115602175,
0.007566235,
0.0095563354,
0.0068717413,
-0.0035802287,
-0.0290973019,
0.0188756455,
-0.015284067,
0.0230841823,
-0.0530354828,
-0.0484944284,
0.0327292196,
0.0216389634,
0.0462323651,
0.0308936872,
0.0110492334,
0.02945056,
-0.0296337772,
-0.0523239002,
0.0303251017,
-0.0825952142,
-0.0460217781,
0.0029172986,
-0.0046332614,
0.0652697012,
0.0009665299,
-0.0083280792,
0.0193694811,
0.0644269064,
0.0139171295,
0.0165423527,
-0.0168423876,
-0.0663996935,
0.0178455748,
0.0254878495,
0.031692978,
0.0445178449,
0.0278103389,
-0.0128981695,
-0.049171038,
0.0307770651,
-0.0352435857,
0.0704941079,
0.0041455813,
0.0321063437,
-0.0027391645,
0.0295571014,
-0.0156557616,
0.029870132,
-0.0520144068,
0.0297795013,
-0.0030991805,
-0.003034503,
-0.0048561539,
-0.0511919521,
-0.0430775881,
0.0353767574,
-0.0120526208,
0.0325384513,
0.0380746573,
-0.0398191027,
-0.0434360094,
-0.0171472318,
-0.0755962506,
-0.0115987118,
-0.0162717812,
0.0515609868,
0.0004601938,
-0.0178525653,
-0.0280306209,
-0.0247678515,
-0.0380769335,
-0.0036675446,
-0.0368870832,
0.0431945436,
0.0110840527,
0.0146627473,
-0.0659384802,
-0.0291631091,
-0.0284598209,
0.004821925,
0.0589125305,
-0.0136745693,
0.0228012335,
-0.0363660902,
0.0257717762,
-0.0234729126,
0.0066929054,
-0.017228717,
-0.0252550803,
0.0161710847,
0.0086083151,
0.0643465072,
0.0548917092,
0.0268358365,
0.0247265641,
0.0527992733,
-0.0129772257,
-0.0425211191,
-0.0256159268,
-0.0576057583,
-0.045977328,
-0.0324696898,
-0.0439621434,
-0.0068600243,
0.0909700021,
-0.007366335,
-0.0157906692,
-0.0366631523,
0.0002883664,
-0.0203173663,
-0.0158699602,
-0.0138960751,
0.0188044515,
-0.0306957252,
0.0471337996,
0.0265718345,
-0.0930058733,
0.0475370213,
-0.0431659855,
0.0316169001,
-0.0040113726,
-0.0156080388,
0.0136810085,
0.0539795831,
0.0393712893,
0.0153234396,
0.0331184678,
-0.0402081162,
-0.0367891416,
-0.0427974537,
0.0060382388,
-0.059269242,
0.0127294855,
-0.0165958311,
-0.0033080743,
0.0292063169,
-0.0196090285,
-0.0486585498,
-0.0002709995,
-0.0150216185,
-0.031387642,
-0.0097408397,
-0.0525347665,
-0.0043856124,
-0.0247292817,
0.0376268178,
0.0188525505,
-0.0090088844,
0.0073635881,
0.0137345996,
0.0099718459,
0.0312756635,
-0.0209520925,
0.0069394815,
-0.0736125112,
-0.0071374658,
0.0641435459,
0.0957386494,
0.030823281,
-0.0166914873,
-0.0127763627,
0.0143387243,
-0.0355079472,
-0.0114140594,
0.0968572944,
0.0053599435,
-0.0571872965,
-0.013565395,
0.0978930444,
0.0117012244,
-0.0459555686,
0.024297934,
0.0169319306,
0.1035391465,
0.0389811099,
-0.0101480819,
-0.0355183631,
0.0205687601,
0.0197516344,
0.0469112955,
-0.0103226015,
-0.0423785187,
-0.0069984822,
-0.0956276804,
-0.0032555265,
0.01578697,
-0.0296749547,
-0.014551484,
-0.0633874163,
-0.0224201661,
-0.0214731805,
0.0160756242,
0.0132434005,
-0.0317807272,
0.019243909,
0.0396380015,
-0.0392187387,
-0.0205599759,
0.0477493964,
-0.0267781746,
0.0578885339,
0.0435608774,
0.0126120597,
-0.0230962299,
-0.0338074602,
0.0064920201,
0.0123370038,
-0.0168311838,
0.0032505461,
0.0720927417,
0.0152040804,
-0.0022475901,
0.0008259454,
0.0370653085,
-0.0190663934,
-0.0047916952,
0.0268180445,
0.0477847159,
-0.0022448478,
-0.0462224223,
0.0124227693,
-0.0214643665,
0.0036086144,
0.0817450583,
0.0592812933,
-0.0291233025,
-0.0217484348,
-0.031643983,
0.035983216,
-0.0191511661,
-0.0513016433,
0.0100271842,
-0.0144088203,
-0.0336364917,
-0.0691779852,
-0.0098779509,
0.012647504,
0.0502064265,
0.0258827005,
0.0077356724,
0.0223050285,
-0.0159454066,
-0.047520075,
0.0079861246,
-0.0548402928,
0.0113840066,
-0.1076061875,
0.0021883284,
0.0127194598,
0.0085232444,
-0.0370435491,
0.0247473288,
-0.1240375191,
-0.0605013482,
0.0399333686,
0.0647435263,
0.0311025493,
0.0461285077,
0.0467755422,
-0.0236261375,
0.1034125239,
0.0229138099,
-0.0209137611,
0.016978845,
0.034850888,
-0.0365894809,
-0.020042127,
0.014427294,
0.004599575,
0.0015328734,
0.0286549106,
-0.0016868964,
-0.0073205638,
-0.0200949311,
0.0010496881,
0.0341811776,
0.0263024587,
-0.0197172575,
-0.0287152939,
-0.0096559282,
0.0136618046,
0.0201854594,
0.010741557,
-0.0175425466,
0.0266747884,
0.0254605785,
0.016112281,
0.0059637143,
-0.0719382316,
0.0135441236,
0.0270417295,
-0.0154257184,
-0.0222316477,
0.0254281629,
0.0119395917,
0.0655590743,
-0.0088615175,
-0.0309510808,
0.0120930113,
-0.0250456482,
0.0502362885,
0.0102103036,
0.0331318453,
-0.0290251859,
0.036347501,
-0.0083430838,
0.0046766791,
-0.0689491853,
-0.0654482171,
-0.0380076952,
0.0126486914,
0.0299346726,
-0.0349129923,
0.030475881,
-0.0558892861,
0.0257093683,
-0.0471699722,
0.0171149056,
-0.0177918281,
-0.0216429364,
0.0091412896,
0.0054844846,
-0.0415869132,
0.0396444462,
0.1145091057,
0.0217367373,
0.0793234855,
0.0054168059,
-0.0120652197,
-0.0520182997,
-0.0427328013,
0.0309160687,
0.0169552378,
-0.0388717242,
-0.0308987219,
-0.0480738208,
-0.0884741545,
-0.0010414178,
-0.0043724519,
0.0042723552,
-0.0285871178,
0.0265718866,
0.050447464,
-0.0521829203,
0.037527971,
-0.0397297256,
0.031868346,
0.0155777708,
-0.0163383167,
-0.0021986337,
-6.49853097e-33,
-0.0069384077,
0.0171384234,
0.0174365174,
0.0387151465,
0.0241861064,
0.0248883348,
-0.0337266363,
0.0062695444,
-0.0066108955,
-0.0329268537,
-0.0326258242,
-0.0175949726,
0.0162018873,
0.0249822028,
0.0089558326,
-0.0060086036,
0.0349564701,
-0.0221243482,
-0.0381834246,
0.0784858987,
0.063504912,
0.0390414223,
0.0630280301,
-0.0439194515,
0.0359493569,
0.0110691935,
-0.0122710522,
-0.0217400789,
-0.0507991351,
0.0544042587,
-0.0354451165,
-0.0084342705,
-0.0035181076,
-0.0446362682,
-0.0416886173,
-0.0194894113,
-0.0330230929,
-0.0067253802,
-0.0101771671,
-0.0112134153,
0.0012382952,
-0.0501972772,
0.0498311706,
-0.0453352295,
-0.0463680029,
-0.0092763379,
0.0360382088,
-0.0119987391,
-0.0895907581,
-0.018814778,
-0.0200010352,
0.0052528596,
-0.0066801123,
-0.0067888577,
0.0197107308,
0.0054306574,
0.0114280544,
0.0135910911,
-0.0553380623,
0.0344038159,
0.045452822,
0.0639089569,
0.0401007049,
0.0419188589,
0.0290803928,
0.0549343191,
0.0346941687,
0.014964967,
0.0356626697,
0.0130753424,
0.0310352296,
0.0195246357,
0.0119950371,
-0.0199948139,
0.0729480237,
-0.0230059233,
-0.0339078866,
0.0062670433,
0.0029264942,
0.0270330068,
0.0602707863,
0.002035589,
-0.0522670448,
-0.036291834,
-0.051246658,
-0.0134129524,
-0.0186570734,
-0.0041629672,
0.0068466831,
-0.0030623535,
-0.049336154,
-0.028440075,
0.0353592038,
-0.0363745429,
-0.0526722968,
0.033790268,
-0.0050150864,
0.0078110909,
-0.0021850211,
0.039328739,
-0.0738379657,
-0.0140366629,
-0.0347868167,
-0.0360618308,
0.0264674481,
0.0218877792,
0.0202926956,
0.0332384109,
-0.0984148309,
-0.0228789076,
-0.039570082,
0.0014696068,
0.0615478829,
0.0209448673,
0.0697549358,
-0.0124463104,
-0.0022875115,
0.0369227119,
0.0048177107,
-0.0155233722,
-0.015411539,
0.0097181918,
-0.0043460745,
0.0249093324,
-0.0069859587,
-0.0449006669,
-0.0564097501,
0.0306399949,
0.0816260204,
-0.015351777,
0.0032918467,
-0.0066572204,
2.799e-7,
-0.0041547329,
0.0175348353,
0.0003162046,
-0.0037136136,
-0.0080068698,
0.0543412939,
-0.0476607829,
0.0407150388,
0.0085390043,
-0.028010454,
-0.0035018695,
0.0135043059,
0.0464724675,
0.0185298696,
-0.0785135999,
-0.0390806235,
-0.08717224,
0.0033021308,
-0.0584884845,
0.005940089,
-0.0304982588,
0.1164519861,
0.0473176502,
-0.0106896935,
0.015630303,
-0.0497149006,
0.0521201305,
-0.0352545604,
0.0181921627,
0.0109749679,
0.0264412928,
0.0411124751,
-0.0060934708,
0.0077370303,
-0.0375850871,
0.0017093937,
-0.0278816689,
0.0546526425,
0.0451869704,
0.0292424131,
0.0013171323,
-0.0143649131,
-0.0205084421,
-0.0504201278,
0.0252374038,
-0.0185366143,
-0.0343297422,
-0.03828042,
0.0196914077,
-0.0401088931,
0.0363799147,
-0.0009730801,
0.0240679961,
0.0453573503,
-0.0133355828,
-0.0014629886,
0.0077236411,
-0.0585484654,
-0.0175387748,
-0.0179828312,
-0.0308820512,
-0.07051,
-0.0599595942,
0.0073436196,
0.0092226584,
-0.0796012878,
0.0308237728,
2.903378752e-34,
0.0394103527,
-0.0475912616,
-0.00598185,
0.0312551335,
0.0439052619,
-0.041587349,
0.0603578202,
0.0152011849,
0.0042414111,
-0.0862264186,
-0.0403586887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03512v1 | Building Multimodal AI Chatbots | 2023-04-21T16:43:54 | 2023-04-21T16:43:54 | Min Young Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work aims to create a multimodal AI system that chats with humans and
shares relevant photos. While earlier works were limited to dialogues about
specific objects or scenes within images, recent works have incorporated images
into open-domain dialogues. However, their response generators are unimodal,
accepting text input but no image input, thus prone to generating responses
contradictory to the images shared in the dialogue. Therefore, this work
proposes a complete chatbot system using two multimodal deep learning models:
an image retriever that understands texts and a response generator that
understands images. The image retriever, implemented by ViT and BERT, selects
the most relevant image given the dialogue history and a database of images.
The response generator, implemented by ViT and GPT-2/DialoGPT, generates an
appropriate response given the dialogue history and the most recently retrieved
image. The two models are trained and evaluated on PhotoChat, an open-domain
dialogue dataset in which a photo is shared in each session. In automatic
evaluation, the proposed image retriever outperforms existing baselines VSE++
and SCAN with Recall@1/5/10 of 0.1/0.3/0.4 and MRR of 0.2 when ranking 1,000
images. The proposed response generator also surpasses the baseline Divter with
PPL of 16.9, BLEU-1/2 of 0.13/0.03, and Distinct-1/2 of 0.97/0.86, showing a
significant improvement in PPL by -42.8 and BLEU-1/2 by +0.07/0.02. In human
evaluation with a Likert scale of 1-5, the complete multimodal chatbot system
receives higher image-groundedness of 4.3 and engagingness of 4.3, along with
competitive fluency of 4.1, coherence of 3.9, and humanness of 3.1, when
compared to other chatbot variants. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/minniie/multimodal_chat.git. | [
0.059110254,
0.03916125,
-0.0138491169,
0.0339271948,
-0.0321938992,
0.0050240387,
0.0247631948,
0.0021848534,
0.0412797593,
-0.0588995665,
-0.0529987141,
-0.029814709,
-0.0378627442,
0.0742528737,
0.0144456718,
-0.09075322,
0.0050532757,
0.0277558267,
0.037388064,
-0.0081539024,
0.0451303385,
-0.0007668553,
-0.0410248041,
0.0451717973,
-0.083059974,
-0.0285404678,
-0.0639130324,
0.0359433778,
0.016332671,
-0.0194516871,
0.0035266941,
0.032922551,
0.0307931639,
0.0285031144,
0.0000020137,
-0.0167600457,
-0.0073135491,
-0.0207889751,
0.006009209,
-0.0643469095,
0.0353474915,
0.0299494043,
-0.0117311487,
0.0037897755,
-0.0478041582,
0.005548141,
0.0685336292,
0.0663236901,
0.0684555992,
0.0734904855,
-0.0360341445,
-0.0306566451,
0.0241364017,
-0.0041101407,
0.0198663119,
-0.037551038,
-0.015441251,
0.0252377372,
0.0398420207,
0.0155644482,
-0.0403717496,
0.0240915716,
0.0103610437,
-0.0184740983,
0.0186823029,
0.0525963604,
-0.0295136683,
-0.07225281,
-0.0293428358,
0.1233582273,
0.0056356108,
0.0338489786,
-0.0151378131,
0.0057003666,
0.0075524668,
-0.0220921282,
-0.0634790957,
0.0327737033,
-0.0091179963,
0.009432123,
-0.0988417044,
0.0063546249,
-0.0309496168,
-0.0085915793,
0.0026364059,
-0.0364113711,
0.0272002947,
0.0000334639,
-0.0051942142,
-0.0117704589,
-0.02179447,
-0.0549592897,
0.0248777922,
0.0180866551,
-0.0082050981,
0.0170812253,
-0.0123151457,
-0.0173113737,
-0.0048822318,
-0.0427745953,
-0.0013926916,
0.0056005893,
-0.0838641599,
0.0608487129,
0.0075361058,
0.0483404472,
-0.0066392045,
0.0262090135,
-0.0116829611,
-0.0231414922,
-0.0467838384,
-0.0222929511,
-0.035717573,
0.0311679207,
-0.0225576069,
-0.0688297451,
-0.0403941646,
0.0226084236,
-0.0160093531,
-0.0112306569,
-0.00222965,
0.0608807951,
-0.0337877758,
0.0249445848,
-0.048052568,
0.0435458012,
-0.025182033,
0.0105892196,
0.0023943903,
-0.0828385651,
0.0097846873,
0.0297798757,
0.0368215032,
-0.0258947685,
-0.0031734586,
0.082547687,
-0.048812896,
-0.0502086282,
0.0155447852,
-0.0065051354,
-0.0110345995,
-0.0632066205,
0.0494425669,
-0.0231956132,
0.0426158383,
-0.0194013473,
-0.0172871519,
-0.010147091,
0.0057850461,
0.0009397892,
-0.0087261274,
0.0630013943,
0.0054567228,
-0.0100751575,
0.0429591425,
0.0338204503,
-0.0267452132,
0.0462852418,
0.0193603858,
0.0609076619,
0.0412845761,
-0.0059936605,
0.0345487595,
0.0146163376,
-0.009744497,
-0.0345598496,
0.0239251722,
-0.0180687029,
-0.0290784966,
0.0230107494,
0.0255776923,
0.0575499237,
-0.0440455526,
-0.0276290663,
0.0493547805,
0.0498994179,
-0.0097924359,
0.0176149979,
-0.0037631416,
0.0243904013,
0.0250148866,
0.0047486974,
-0.0302946977,
0.0950360596,
0.0117579168,
-0.0239092261,
0.0415691063,
0.0090880161,
-0.0428575389,
-0.0242805257,
0.0259965081,
-0.0235320963,
0.0568676405,
-0.0007808965,
0.0404828191,
-0.0104816249,
-0.0644642636,
0.0153811472,
-0.0113639915,
-0.0313210897,
-0.052923508,
-0.0173564572,
0.0195417628,
0.0532143377,
0.0278072469,
0.0004420925,
-0.0032811207,
0.0005502438,
0.0017537241,
0.0347692668,
-0.0024419304,
0.007337518,
0.0515996888,
-0.0442818068,
-0.033206962,
-0.0488520712,
-0.0246791597,
0.0659619644,
-0.0138715142,
0.0186526105,
0.0023985123,
0.0521806292,
0.0500372015,
0.0125217838,
0.0512408949,
0.018941585,
-0.0269977208,
0.0334226526,
0.0420483127,
0.0397939719,
-0.0363350287,
-0.0151795829,
0.0193347316,
-0.0027761527,
-0.0222409666,
0.0472512171,
-0.0420331433,
-0.0253349785,
0.0396746136,
-0.0654683784,
-0.0099268444,
0.0450032353,
-0.0202768389,
-0.031472031,
0.0599337891,
-0.0514576882,
0.0106847277,
-0.0613694489,
-0.0020061124,
0.0324330516,
0.035396941,
0.0002944547,
0.046287436,
0.0045991852,
-0.0286358576,
0.018981114,
0.0266781338,
0.0146321263,
-0.0487327576,
-0.0275781248,
0.0302655119,
-0.0270985067,
0.0350464322,
0.0384744182,
0.0305062439,
-0.0793435425,
0.0057190112,
-0.1305535138,
-0.0122021539,
-0.0085773617,
-0.0734925941,
-0.0241768714,
0.0170145556,
0.0072802301,
-0.0456386246,
-0.0486378595,
0.0657464266,
0.0269857571,
0.0476533584,
0.0343689211,
0.0267494414,
0.0009376056,
-0.0704287961,
0.0189747922,
0.0355794542,
0.0518074594,
-0.005678019,
-0.0052058389,
0.0166280381,
0.0047089267,
-0.0591672994,
0.079936862,
-0.0146475211,
-0.0774840936,
0.046186287,
-0.0434350595,
0.0182983112,
0.0706832483,
0.0354893655,
0.0357175358,
-0.022368012,
-0.0083859274,
-0.081231527,
0.0267340243,
0.0152585264,
-0.0093847224,
0.0373787731,
-0.0019616324,
-0.0155490814,
-0.0052022547,
-0.0010291819,
0.0362625532,
-0.0573013797,
0.0312221888,
0.0662511364,
-0.0587358251,
-0.0166476518,
0.0281070843,
-0.0098708672,
0.0188113153,
-0.0416172333,
-0.0571505576,
0.0551393069,
0.0201028138,
-0.0561611094,
-0.0060763736,
-0.007607514,
0.018971324,
0.0590990894,
0.0099193798,
0.0414655171,
-0.0198927838,
-0.0095958281,
-0.0358328223,
-0.0122263981,
0.0142320292,
-0.0278496817,
0.0023854442,
-0.004930214,
0.0035205937,
-0.0187356863,
-0.05441669,
-0.0534614027,
-0.0129606174,
-0.0127689429,
-0.0166268423,
-0.0390908346,
0.0019786221,
-0.0220160037,
0.008271398,
0.0250894353,
-0.0066836691,
0.0065923771,
0.0001453194,
-0.0032036272,
0.0338040143,
0.0462887362,
0.0318372622,
-0.0473954044,
-0.0070170434,
0.0287271068,
0.0421327017,
0.0047906674,
-0.0097603006,
-0.0702826008,
0.0179224834,
-0.0079708211,
0.0531149544,
0.0016854714,
-0.0004374952,
0.0520406291,
-0.0012024997,
0.014830634,
0.066303432,
0.0024538164,
-0.0328220688,
-0.0215220358,
-0.0075385547,
-0.0123358797,
-0.001721005,
0.0223776456,
-0.0681394115,
-0.0347595513,
-0.0167317297,
-0.0275642201,
0.0087042106,
0.0013762952,
-0.0266005173,
-0.0750131235,
0.0273726191,
-0.0052380953,
-0.0160954278,
-0.0419628397,
0.0009553043,
-0.0033443151,
0.0076990752,
-0.0129333809,
0.0125523815,
0.0316989906,
-0.0081082201,
-0.0056514675,
0.044265382,
-0.0039004607,
0.0370780267,
-0.0448955186,
0.0274036601,
0.0587795526,
0.0573450811,
0.0083229775,
-0.0204052441,
-0.0148739982,
0.0583994463,
0.0142629212,
-0.0045179944,
0.0571266115,
-0.0278372336,
-0.0143814078,
-0.0241834093,
0.0052188761,
0.0312618539,
0.007769471,
-0.027338637,
0.01206268,
-0.0261805318,
-0.0031386353,
-0.0558400452,
0.0517270453,
0.0276812967,
0.0170725472,
0.0103042992,
-0.0297425538,
-0.0607804731,
0.0036004679,
0.0058080615,
-0.0476034507,
0.0080340076,
0.0076438091,
-0.0306563284,
-0.0185294412,
-0.0755129308,
-0.0450812802,
0.0127064977,
0.0298982468,
-0.030589195,
-0.0345289744,
-0.011381682,
0.0559138693,
-0.0177659038,
0.0309816878,
0.010474164,
-0.0079525644,
-0.0177619904,
-0.0141178863,
0.0286511444,
-0.0529429875,
-0.0040086568,
0.0185579322,
-0.0425652005,
-0.0294592194,
-0.0452576019,
0.0861327425,
0.0147307785,
0.0129192611,
0.0420811214,
-0.0426902547,
-0.0137515953,
0.0250624157,
-0.0066052149,
-0.0368213803,
0.0358809531,
0.0514592193,
-0.0056047845,
0.0090279281,
-0.0702460408,
0.0346491747,
-0.0223868154,
0.0023146502,
0.0001177298,
-0.0901204795,
0.0013520266,
0.0175256114,
0.0207043942,
0.0145258131,
-0.022761941,
-0.0096224202,
-0.0005193868,
-0.0115630981,
0.0206834245,
-0.0679667294,
0.0132322777,
-0.01984418,
-0.0044035781,
-0.0100567276,
-0.0298661012,
-0.0320859589,
0.0588205606,
-0.0294095315,
-0.0017568958,
0.0347730145,
-0.0201955382,
-0.0410533845,
0.0098165888,
0.011285658,
0.0200069863,
0.0038688371,
0.0210503452,
0.0040004603,
0.0903651491,
-0.015983006,
-0.0469489768,
0.0038168032,
0.0514367931,
-0.0172228869,
-0.0337187722,
-0.0217412058,
0.070086427,
0.0587883815,
0.0379464477,
0.004744167,
-0.0175861809,
0.0180841815,
-0.0277014375,
0.0565127768,
0.0055844025,
-0.0567560643,
0.0282028671,
0.0031609582,
0.01135509,
0.0141857648,
0.0318179615,
-0.0325602256,
-0.0140674161,
0.0065878248,
-0.0233170874,
-0.0588154458,
0.0023336066,
0.0362788662,
0.0248864442,
0.0247078631,
0.0404146649,
0.0215089787,
-0.0398836657,
-0.0075411969,
0.0092424676,
-0.0177941918,
0.0163267888,
0.0592671596,
0.0635065436,
0.0023284901,
-0.0283666849,
-0.0224768762,
0.0104675218,
-0.0336285904,
-0.0217942782,
-0.0232962258,
-5.922435882e-33,
-0.021062158,
-0.01305342,
0.0236646757,
-0.0284319893,
-0.0517828688,
-0.0096686855,
-0.0499690175,
0.0163333602,
-0.0357233062,
0.0020515576,
0.0030093119,
-0.0041001029,
0.0079833921,
0.0162013415,
-0.0222513471,
-0.000989295,
0.0199524481,
-0.0203478429,
0.00027304,
0.0308540128,
0.0533945002,
0.0457401015,
0.0323241875,
-0.0804200023,
-0.0364768207,
0.021313699,
-0.0200948715,
-0.0089222547,
0.0278268736,
0.0435957573,
-0.0298744198,
0.0301099345,
0.0112591824,
0.0174776036,
-0.0129519356,
0.0439792648,
-0.0736078024,
-0.0206290334,
-0.0032575289,
0.0378956348,
-0.0523148365,
-0.0115158102,
0.0305126458,
-0.0491533801,
0.0161504894,
-0.0136237601,
0.0357478224,
0.0081591625,
0.0169353839,
0.0046015591,
-0.0425552614,
-0.0039454955,
-0.0396808349,
-0.0821325034,
0.0029248199,
0.0856651217,
0.0373666771,
0.0349917002,
-0.0509484597,
0.028515406,
-0.0413922891,
-0.0278226789,
0.0501761213,
0.0091074714,
0.032858111,
0.0712953955,
0.0536020845,
-0.0160776861,
-0.0295475051,
-0.0525102504,
0.0251707938,
0.0878930613,
0.0168846697,
0.0633019507,
0.0222737007,
-0.0144994212,
-0.0508384109,
0.0351232998,
0.0185508691,
0.0483230688,
0.0045070485,
0.0476109572,
-0.0176768918,
0.0323455222,
0.003705353,
-0.0033334387,
-0.0583165437,
-0.0756637827,
0.0270154998,
0.0131519232,
-0.0023931628,
-0.0149077447,
0.0970499516,
-0.0558357611,
0.0132267233,
0.0087656602,
-0.0315641165,
0.0331041031,
-0.0045355824,
0.0113217179,
-0.0025181915,
-0.0149979265,
0.0966358855,
0.0135038421,
-0.0079375524,
0.0294623896,
-0.0066507491,
0.0177684128,
0.0012688012,
-0.0313548408,
-0.0259709265,
0.0288391802,
-0.0190636553,
0.0550073497,
-0.0238235015,
0.0125131756,
-0.0618085712,
0.0289376918,
-0.0266736317,
0.0174921509,
-0.058136113,
-0.0560454503,
0.0050807856,
-0.0130991153,
-0.0440233499,
0.0206616614,
-0.0492299907,
-0.0337275267,
-0.0002835365,
-0.0696836412,
-0.0198454913,
0.0319896489,
2.74e-7,
-0.0197934043,
0.0061347657,
0.0282230321,
0.0316966251,
0.0273945834,
0.0615593493,
-0.0041102231,
0.0572962463,
0.0200702418,
-0.0285959747,
-0.0012628506,
0.0314248577,
0.0214044638,
-0.0114187142,
-0.0485341325,
-0.0205358788,
-0.0569989122,
-0.0664991289,
-0.0347995125,
-0.0162220839,
0.0738104358,
0.0798267797,
-0.0095292404,
-0.0182439461,
0.0149396602,
-0.0051606088,
0.0675979033,
-0.0207904242,
-0.0221761353,
-0.0373430736,
0.0251316447,
0.0205151867,
-0.001639223,
0.0134470547,
0.0288641993,
-0.0001610027,
0.0409120508,
0.0313855149,
-0.0360076316,
-0.1037820801,
0.0004862232,
0.0414666943,
-0.0245762095,
-0.0356809124,
0.05499129,
-0.0453054272,
-0.0460469313,
-0.0131427757,
-0.0567962527,
-0.0005144654,
0.0349052176,
-0.0351908654,
-0.0652466491,
0.0146424323,
0.020789938,
-0.0272948071,
0.0019534542,
-0.087618947,
0.0157255251,
-0.0246816427,
-0.0579495393,
-0.0358704366,
-0.0401270874,
-0.0454369374,
0.0456652604,
-0.0023792794,
-0.0185138136,
1.482040204e-34,
0.0232414268,
-0.0062904367,
0.0174438953,
0.0336409174,
0.0204314273,
0.0101644257,
-0.0026150064,
-0.0086002052,
0.0226783566,
-0.0413224064,
-0.0382509753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14347v1 | The Dark Side of ChatGPT: Legal and Ethical Challenges from Stochastic Parrots and Hallucination | 2023-04-21T16:40:54 | 2023-04-21T16:40:54 | Zihao Li | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the launch of ChatGPT, Large Language Models (LLMs) are shaking up our
whole society, rapidly altering the way we think, create and live. For
instance, the GPT integration in Bing has altered our approach to online
searching. While nascent LLMs have many advantages, new legal and ethical risks
are also emerging, stemming in particular from stochastic parrots and
hallucination. The EU is the first and foremost jurisdiction that has focused
on the regulation of AI models. However, the risks posed by the new LLMs are
likely to be underestimated by the emerging EU regulatory paradigm. Therefore,
this correspondence warns that the European AI regulatory paradigm must evolve
further to mitigate such risks. | [
0.0321250223,
0.0699676424,
-0.0234825015,
0.0117413718,
-0.0757745281,
0.0039131846,
0.0378949717,
0.0267759282,
0.0748799592,
-0.0273936428,
0.0136345411,
-0.0361671001,
-0.0176197719,
0.0569321364,
0.0332350321,
-0.0175939687,
0.0645699278,
-0.0384673066,
-0.0070902179,
-0.0382376686,
0.0126193576,
-0.0007100406,
0.01842089,
0.0498826727,
0.0183194838,
-0.0275009908,
0.0081667379,
-0.024419222,
-0.0513047092,
0.0078742392,
-0.0178151336,
0.0158853307,
0.0031590192,
0.1013462692,
0.0000018428,
-0.0378209464,
-0.0037138814,
0.0253661666,
0.0121362973,
0.006677126,
0.0344910212,
0.048745364,
-0.0399274863,
0.0181957949,
-0.0367020629,
0.0544462092,
0.0447143093,
-0.0020927424,
0.0228707939,
0.0762054175,
-0.0187194645,
-0.0077096168,
0.0633678138,
-0.0044514043,
0.0107419686,
-0.0335848331,
0.0352228917,
-0.0087954653,
0.0312924758,
-0.0045138896,
0.0220060907,
0.0740893409,
-0.0027152142,
-0.0085380645,
-0.0656386092,
0.0269196052,
-0.0496710129,
-0.0646121204,
-0.0262667425,
0.005032049,
0.0375686064,
-0.0059740003,
0.0279852897,
0.0277325213,
0.023780467,
-0.0096241971,
-0.0333012305,
0.0608632006,
-0.044285927,
0.026199216,
0.0616429038,
-0.0131186638,
0.0303466152,
0.0177365411,
-0.0037362131,
0.06893114,
0.0231259223,
-0.0479640029,
0.0205215123,
-0.0029958915,
0.0252621248,
-0.0336755142,
0.0215765871,
0.0303611122,
-0.0014907672,
0.0169629045,
-0.039788831,
0.0358911045,
0.0290578213,
-0.0984662026,
-0.0184537601,
0.0345250331,
-0.0281329453,
0.0248745978,
0.0200053938,
0.0147709018,
-0.0720942244,
0.0615711361,
-0.0145738227,
0.0046462016,
-0.0256990977,
-0.0114193587,
-0.0449854024,
0.0211334452,
-0.0605632067,
-0.0178790763,
-0.036291156,
0.0462509245,
-0.0303531215,
0.0193079934,
-0.0114503857,
0.0202727895,
-0.0150515502,
-0.0114194024,
-0.0207697004,
-0.0464340933,
0.0106866462,
-0.0074682739,
0.0084916884,
-0.0612848997,
0.0176144596,
0.0118911965,
-0.0308355466,
-0.0091809714,
0.0167415682,
0.1187502667,
0.0206285883,
0.0016185975,
0.014387358,
-0.0527597517,
-0.0257951859,
-0.0848056376,
0.0112999855,
-0.0325118825,
-0.0121335275,
-0.0504039414,
-0.0151795037,
-0.0474484041,
-0.0058914227,
0.0089749675,
-0.0770531371,
0.0355407111,
-0.072908625,
0.0076685455,
-0.0251389556,
0.0110991448,
-0.0091090556,
0.0304500349,
-0.0191144962,
0.0150862588,
0.0361255631,
-0.0055035059,
0.0755579397,
0.0415217206,
-0.0118776523,
0.0260615274,
0.0031472798,
-0.0038326068,
0.0064803148,
0.0097561823,
-0.0110679194,
0.0773534849,
-0.0050425651,
-0.0228372365,
0.0599510521,
0.0720160231,
-0.0080560697,
0.0521306843,
-0.004400467,
-0.0187083166,
-0.0055906633,
0.0180153344,
-0.0421764851,
-0.0212418735,
-0.063542068,
-0.0099520916,
-0.0071875402,
0.0351584107,
-0.0138336178,
-0.0161333736,
0.0281728823,
-0.0218558852,
0.0556756668,
0.0259705782,
0.0146216201,
-0.0461946018,
-0.0044782031,
-0.0208375268,
-0.0106722722,
-0.0128230806,
-0.0227569453,
-0.1101796851,
-0.0138624674,
0.063392289,
0.0438642278,
-0.0093005113,
-0.0056855762,
-0.0452821963,
-0.0090776077,
0.0764543563,
0.0203159321,
0.0128986035,
0.014252753,
0.0021728622,
-0.0043065469,
0.0296071135,
-0.0018379531,
-0.0057142787,
-0.0440666936,
0.0359458216,
-0.0263437126,
0.0164724812,
-0.0161598343,
-0.0037646242,
-0.0036950868,
-0.0103530101,
-0.0715745762,
-0.0306810271,
-0.0133836381,
0.018783886,
-0.0329235569,
0.029097015,
0.0356541127,
0.0072108102,
-0.0018943497,
0.0053117657,
0.0106465351,
0.0788516775,
0.0557946861,
-0.0256260298,
0.0075277505,
-0.0110118473,
-0.0043848418,
-0.0014199468,
-0.0102249086,
-0.022026401,
0.0898379833,
-0.0073550167,
0.0089693088,
-0.0337414853,
0.0225561205,
0.0037067211,
0.0089118592,
-0.0181357935,
0.0087984428,
-0.0014403267,
-0.0122179361,
0.0466396324,
-0.0379707627,
-0.0308669079,
0.0557839572,
-0.0131353047,
0.047290355,
0.0428762436,
0.0264972802,
-0.0137254614,
0.0139429932,
-0.0755318552,
0.0000578851,
-0.0030238763,
0.0339529663,
0.0082414355,
-0.0143417614,
-0.0416874513,
-0.0261165537,
-0.0413796008,
-0.0245429147,
-0.0033970631,
0.0345386416,
0.0032397956,
-0.0210276134,
-0.0795611963,
0.0021353599,
-0.0204309411,
-0.0158188529,
-0.006499893,
0.0285513457,
-0.0335464403,
-0.0484066792,
0.0479982682,
-0.0650208592,
0.0362071916,
-0.0190475397,
-0.0216573514,
0.0404694937,
-0.0028242723,
-0.006291551,
0.0345799625,
0.0024268907,
0.0296969153,
0.0280104149,
-0.0003648046,
-0.0079952562,
-0.0154163176,
0.0110660214,
-0.0223804973,
-0.0512644351,
0.005547211,
0.0110809328,
0.0158679169,
-0.017021507,
0.00477914,
-0.049473878,
0.0597977862,
-0.0337796994,
-0.0478511266,
-0.039763663,
-0.0244981181,
-0.0458459929,
0.0579819418,
0.0160495639,
-0.0782004297,
0.0505293012,
-0.0216396078,
0.011038376,
-0.0145048853,
-0.0393931642,
0.0075668893,
0.0489189513,
-0.0162273329,
0.0399603993,
0.0238611009,
-0.0031362353,
-0.0175245777,
-0.0369448215,
0.0211375076,
-0.0456463471,
0.02889679,
-0.0246264189,
0.0325281136,
-0.0081747845,
-0.0509172939,
-0.0076749246,
-0.0095196255,
-0.0177661926,
-0.0014532828,
0.0083693881,
-0.0046308134,
-0.0198214483,
-0.0073720445,
0.0206809957,
0.0238264538,
-0.0019143969,
-0.0220078211,
-0.0075846924,
-0.021308491,
0.0232859068,
-0.0120163085,
0.009527809,
0.0111693637,
-0.019128006,
0.0339923911,
-0.006410074,
0.0045277416,
0.017938843,
0.0383542404,
0.0093666175,
-0.0032404382,
-0.0431047976,
0.041345723,
0.0134253437,
-0.0528858043,
-0.000310871,
0.0469172224,
-0.0035917384,
-0.0326632224,
0.0028569864,
-0.0171408262,
-0.002223809,
0.0108454451,
0.039407637,
-0.1071368381,
0.050342299,
-0.0007143856,
0.0092234258,
-0.0736549571,
-0.0243583135,
-0.0145586245,
-0.0124911536,
0.1011126935,
0.0296854079,
-0.0501877926,
-0.0226978641,
-0.007836449,
-0.0274052024,
-0.0205358807,
0.0490747169,
-0.0299755,
-0.0025832306,
-0.0106633762,
0.0220737532,
-0.0689135045,
0.0378305838,
0.0115982182,
-0.026141366,
0.134175539,
0.0721126869,
0.0230978001,
-0.0274583921,
-0.0301465653,
0.005132806,
0.0247141179,
-0.0039668246,
0.022115726,
0.01520795,
0.0237192847,
-0.0083610276,
-0.0651404634,
0.001643207,
-0.0144538581,
-0.0265030432,
0.0036931764,
0.0730880648,
-0.0791291371,
-0.0539840646,
-0.0179831516,
-0.0171971861,
0.0259087868,
0.0455016866,
-0.0255682245,
-0.0189895425,
-0.0595901348,
-0.0730542392,
0.0158403162,
-0.0066743204,
-0.0517018624,
0.026846908,
0.03223259,
-0.0730230287,
-0.0317062624,
-0.0346075222,
-0.0438304022,
0.041209057,
0.0152360592,
0.0193611383,
0.0388733633,
0.0095733497,
0.0151304211,
0.0091939047,
-0.0188670028,
-0.0098289661,
-0.0432319641,
0.0401590578,
0.007903873,
0.0119645204,
-0.0068994514,
-0.0114526004,
-0.0195688549,
-0.05678799,
0.0688785315,
0.0301260408,
0.0395873934,
0.0499555729,
-0.0043333238,
-0.0197732989,
0.0435799286,
0.0131544303,
0.0117163593,
0.0073060109,
0.0743452087,
0.0041538379,
-0.0180201028,
0.0190927703,
-0.0116240177,
0.0051744441,
-0.0120307468,
-0.010881586,
0.0071305158,
0.012374972,
0.0498044081,
0.0806934163,
-0.0013122767,
-0.0704907104,
0.02623564,
-0.0043822578,
-0.0244035814,
-0.0077278679,
0.009614869,
-0.0143931424,
-0.0443388969,
0.0181612093,
-0.0200390927,
0.0098549863,
-0.0034812591,
-0.027290307,
-0.0487688035,
-0.0225238483,
0.0296691563,
-0.0132403607,
0.0129135959,
0.0481214412,
-0.0135666262,
-0.0037816202,
0.1141609028,
-0.0212867502,
0.0597086847,
-0.0210108031,
0.0205766745,
0.0000446173,
-0.027836144,
-0.0008951599,
0.0512445718,
-0.0525335185,
-0.1474991292,
0.019880062,
0.0750476047,
0.0545746759,
0.0568957329,
0.0019980215,
-0.0309276357,
0.0203349553,
-0.0018707783,
-0.0119274631,
0.0053600464,
-0.0147522353,
-0.0585951954,
-0.0097326487,
-0.0375299156,
0.0028370749,
0.0476165861,
-0.0076999124,
0.0634928644,
-0.015633408,
-0.0158558469,
0.0048756953,
-0.0698100701,
-0.0123017617,
-0.0366025046,
-0.0194561332,
-0.0449660011,
-0.0492424555,
-0.0562518984,
-0.0545651279,
0.0262848437,
-0.0075673126,
-0.031564258,
0.021073401,
0.045713257,
0.0146507863,
-0.0196936596,
-0.0341841392,
-0.007176057,
-0.0038566233,
-0.0242298637,
-0.0060784807,
-6.23669842e-33,
0.0210053939,
0.0063518477,
0.0313573405,
0.0111518716,
-0.0399441458,
-0.0512007698,
-0.0150242224,
0.0164643023,
-0.0310268793,
0.0003789272,
-0.0189621262,
0.0169728715,
0.0226376262,
0.0118561797,
-0.0038094299,
-0.0408712439,
-0.0123610115,
0.003789945,
0.0288584363,
0.0335773975,
0.0048998841,
0.0050927512,
0.0314335227,
-0.0879118592,
0.0751616061,
0.0499958061,
-0.0258096922,
-0.0058979206,
-0.0266169738,
0.0314526632,
-0.0150245223,
0.0777054802,
0.0258810353,
-0.0180652421,
-0.0035769776,
0.0341941752,
0.0133556426,
-0.0198904891,
-0.001977304,
-0.0001366589,
0.0189640485,
-0.0448478274,
0.0500873029,
-0.0315714255,
-0.0577744916,
0.0482487455,
-0.0047077551,
-0.0344545394,
-0.0720179975,
0.0204940047,
-0.076928027,
-0.003563351,
-0.0208274722,
0.0536090173,
0.0398183689,
0.0008549395,
0.0001105189,
-0.0292343758,
-0.0440303199,
0.0385561846,
-0.029796917,
-0.0413749032,
0.0497926734,
-0.0172382686,
0.046450004,
0.0714288875,
0.0333548188,
0.0179174766,
-0.0554814488,
-0.0261852033,
0.0017036682,
0.0707702264,
0.0287423097,
-0.0275812075,
-0.02999584,
-0.0392196625,
-0.0242137276,
0.0250055809,
0.0339509174,
-0.0027220361,
0.0092315581,
0.0034982164,
-0.0758746117,
-0.0277145021,
0.0282735247,
-0.0267143622,
0.0038915388,
-0.0435624756,
0.0135882152,
-0.0361184031,
0.0136021506,
-0.0147689339,
0.0365573615,
-0.0756235942,
0.0015659977,
-0.0747690573,
0.0169914495,
0.0106746852,
-0.0119950138,
0.0378354453,
-0.0145844445,
-0.0566317961,
0.0032545526,
0.0270930603,
0.0371242389,
0.0166318696,
-0.0244858675,
0.0153236249,
-0.0461518541,
0.0129935471,
-0.0206497945,
0.0399232022,
0.0936835483,
0.0050253179,
0.0373961851,
-0.0170789752,
0.0341784991,
-0.0169514604,
0.0309265293,
0.0077183624,
-0.0297200233,
0.0039097462,
-0.0283916462,
0.0044391835,
-0.0167196784,
0.0168118086,
-0.0921095237,
0.0598004647,
0.0422844104,
-0.0670274571,
-0.02308576,
-0.0171512626,
2.662e-7,
0.0210021865,
0.0191833265,
0.0227964967,
0.0390814543,
0.0088748233,
0.0380215459,
0.0094790366,
0.0642945543,
-0.01894865,
-0.0216265339,
0.0146825304,
-0.0251632538,
0.0243922733,
0.0426238924,
-0.0232134406,
-0.0347308554,
-0.0817786455,
0.0149942171,
-0.0686606094,
0.0295306109,
0.0402198918,
0.0778575465,
0.027236253,
-0.0345315821,
0.0180668738,
-0.0567918681,
0.0226436332,
-0.0377966985,
0.0160841867,
-0.0086846808,
0.0413774289,
0.0888145939,
0.0118587241,
0.0153646637,
0.0235549547,
-0.0078331809,
-0.0225073267,
0.0441179909,
-0.0295994114,
0.0353502557,
-0.0212861206,
-0.087041311,
0.017618414,
-0.0580723397,
0.0503929779,
-0.0216424707,
-0.0289455391,
-0.0351790264,
0.006971417,
-0.0612799972,
0.0531662852,
-0.0107409023,
-0.0158282332,
-0.013397947,
0.0051391651,
0.0065385243,
0.0412682965,
-0.0534948036,
0.0350260511,
-0.0049909176,
-0.0026134348,
-0.0336220413,
-0.0247794613,
0.0459102243,
0.0095522562,
-0.0472753868,
0.0218083318,
2.519927673e-34,
0.0282627922,
-0.0097471299,
0.017201703,
0.0353911929,
0.0067329849,
0.0455489494,
0.0475582778,
-0.0132065043,
-0.0038317244,
-0.0219297316,
-0.0233800951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11111v1 | Inducing anxiety in large language models increases exploration and bias | 2023-04-21T16:29:43 | 2023-04-21T16:29:43 | Julian Coda-Forno, Kristin Witte, Akshay K. Jagadish, Marcel Binz, Zeynep Akata, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models are transforming research on machine learning while
galvanizing public debates. Understanding not only when these models work well
and succeed but also why they fail and misbehave is of great societal
relevance. We propose to turn the lens of computational psychiatry, a framework
used to computationally describe and modify aberrant behavior, to the outputs
produced by these models. We focus on the Generative Pre-Trained Transformer
3.5 and subject it to tasks commonly studied in psychiatry. Our results show
that GPT-3.5 responds robustly to a common anxiety questionnaire, producing
higher anxiety scores than human subjects. Moreover, GPT-3.5's responses can be
predictably changed by using emotion-inducing prompts. Emotion-induction not
only influences GPT-3.5's behavior in a cognitive task measuring exploratory
decision-making but also influences its behavior in a previously-established
task measuring biases such as racism and ableism. Crucially, GPT-3.5 shows a
strong increase in biases when prompted with anxiety-inducing text. Thus, it is
likely that how prompts are communicated to large language models has a strong
influence on their behavior in applied settings. These results progress our
understanding of prompt engineering and demonstrate the usefulness of methods
taken from computational psychiatry for studying the capable algorithms to
which we increasingly delegate authority and autonomy. | [
0.0455186926,
0.0784599483,
-0.0329377726,
-0.0156151205,
-0.008471502,
0.0429542847,
0.0257866178,
0.0178694092,
0.043710608,
-0.0158061888,
-0.0162063781,
-0.0063377032,
-0.0402151942,
0.016764028,
0.0060168067,
-0.0762236416,
0.0215398036,
0.0299035199,
0.0562517829,
-0.0250511598,
-0.0286014322,
0.0024955173,
0.0046651964,
0.0402684286,
-0.0103809219,
-0.0109086661,
0.0195249487,
0.0121817542,
0.0161496531,
-0.0522559844,
-0.0105780326,
0.0706588924,
-0.0008857083,
0.0223358944,
0.0000021766,
-0.0528369546,
-0.0117464997,
-0.0153227858,
0.0070941662,
-0.0473050103,
0.0737505853,
-0.0466069542,
0.0086626206,
0.0236623362,
-0.0411108881,
-0.0467313901,
0.0522581562,
0.0787043944,
0.0417846628,
0.0656698495,
-0.0350547247,
0.0081461724,
0.0357948802,
-0.0133939683,
0.0322936103,
0.00097494,
0.0417189933,
-0.0470306352,
0.0145076504,
-0.025935078,
-0.0568749458,
0.0031905931,
0.0097451508,
0.0360385217,
0.0069747246,
0.0006874542,
-0.0076073119,
-0.0702800676,
-0.0165438689,
0.0270632338,
-0.0274212938,
0.0112586366,
0.0233882833,
-0.0121359592,
0.0439713001,
0.031691093,
-0.0259602889,
0.0498848595,
0.0020812876,
-0.0008314826,
0.0298026688,
0.0080580795,
0.0324028172,
-0.0007980689,
0.0135575375,
0.082787089,
0.0094701285,
-0.0360538326,
0.0411394872,
0.026694905,
-0.0171038881,
-0.049646493,
0.0285406932,
-0.005743756,
-0.07236249,
0.0146966306,
-0.0260079801,
-0.0285131428,
-0.0127329817,
0.0010221909,
0.0009035876,
0.0623270981,
-0.0409389846,
-0.0242877677,
0.0265535247,
0.0440986343,
-0.0246438347,
0.0432766937,
-0.0262601562,
0.0265447851,
-0.0200703442,
-0.0155899245,
-0.024039695,
-0.0361619443,
0.0077896081,
0.0009358629,
-0.0769724026,
0.0150196999,
-0.0459215082,
-0.0105317691,
-0.0323436894,
0.0147683835,
-0.0161632076,
0.0069953073,
-0.0206083413,
-0.0113239866,
-0.0479690135,
0.0098364819,
0.0457400344,
-0.0598208979,
0.0123582361,
-0.014569466,
-0.0354540348,
-0.0405266993,
0.0114639532,
0.0592478588,
0.0078663593,
-0.003408426,
-0.034937378,
-0.0089234551,
-0.0295898262,
-0.0341272652,
0.0474311337,
-0.024131123,
0.0188743304,
0.0151673956,
0.0185883697,
-0.064140901,
0.0108040301,
-0.0042493623,
-0.0658046752,
0.0858499259,
-0.0071316715,
-0.0081334542,
0.0191060826,
0.0371199846,
-0.0150863901,
0.0445115194,
0.0125272386,
0.0349789783,
0.0351831354,
-0.0565782934,
0.0613974519,
0.0092363134,
-0.0137054808,
-0.0230208263,
0.0209236369,
-0.0351642333,
-0.006086553,
0.0202259906,
0.0061494419,
0.0481133386,
-0.0117674572,
0.0022677209,
0.0399280675,
0.0612500161,
-0.0157008283,
0.0460645556,
0.0255773291,
-0.0058388761,
-0.0346622169,
0.0218147263,
-0.0933342725,
0.0009267891,
-0.0629453957,
-0.035764318,
-0.0101651195,
0.023205677,
-0.0166221261,
-0.0388202295,
-0.0110376049,
0.0096015045,
0.0052679051,
0.031926576,
-0.010123834,
-0.0013775665,
-0.0266750306,
-0.0254980996,
0.0362704135,
-0.0279778261,
-0.0242098309,
-0.0774146393,
0.0129369944,
0.0418393984,
0.0278570559,
-0.049208194,
0.0424581431,
-0.0532426275,
-0.0240766555,
0.0387197956,
0.058009889,
0.0030409805,
-0.0399052985,
-0.0395145752,
-0.0055552362,
0.042237699,
0.0263941642,
0.0044816448,
-0.0046280553,
0.0254784543,
-0.0258158799,
0.0142725892,
-0.0242307968,
0.0411931649,
-0.0293266159,
-0.0707940087,
0.0063019707,
-0.0048933779,
0.0535996296,
-0.0217452087,
-0.0007743493,
-0.003766092,
-0.0116073247,
0.012950534,
-0.0276826899,
0.0111415973,
-0.0482914783,
0.0000932541,
-0.0161137935,
-0.0059158197,
-0.0047385306,
0.0297515783,
-0.0160600226,
-0.00463351,
0.0286828578,
-0.022265384,
0.0318991356,
-0.0004486065,
0.0292585827,
-0.0115205953,
0.038812317,
-0.0439104326,
0.0321773253,
-0.0019426227,
0.0096819717,
0.020309519,
-0.0197421573,
-0.0296543594,
-0.0099968081,
-0.0571606271,
0.0266104694,
0.0108279083,
0.0042751939,
0.0068638073,
-0.0309013519,
-0.0441584215,
-0.0462272502,
-0.0799037442,
0.005111509,
0.0055902177,
-0.0314274654,
0.005386157,
-0.0372069255,
-0.02829656,
0.0090352641,
-0.0204893574,
0.0159176011,
0.0528725423,
0.0765883103,
-0.017785199,
-0.0188850798,
-0.0162282009,
-0.051904954,
-0.0259477757,
-0.050136853,
0.0380948,
0.020254964,
0.0113882003,
-0.049093321,
0.0302269068,
-0.0363176242,
0.0144859338,
-0.0098235495,
-0.032104712,
0.0322432555,
0.0276869778,
0.072149992,
0.0723674223,
0.0273818783,
0.0693462491,
0.0484274514,
0.0155203845,
-0.0304842517,
0.0068139788,
-0.029397035,
-0.0348934494,
-0.0070999991,
-0.0681559145,
-0.0030803094,
0.0677083284,
0.0500583164,
-0.0053508775,
-0.0748651102,
0.0402718298,
-0.0133428713,
-0.069196023,
-0.0030841045,
-0.0477355793,
-0.0212722421,
0.0526884161,
-0.0156336185,
-0.0572868288,
0.0623357818,
0.0535163917,
-0.0103165004,
-0.0322849192,
-0.001378419,
0.0238066427,
0.0510396324,
0.0420230106,
0.0095876893,
0.0617482401,
0.0212460402,
-0.0399154611,
-0.056539204,
-0.0367387272,
-0.0426367819,
0.0012722836,
-0.0157094002,
-0.0423709974,
0.0329031199,
-0.04756267,
-0.0607662722,
-0.0341357961,
-0.0401464961,
-0.0227352586,
0.031532526,
-0.0048967064,
-0.0213199761,
-0.0487367809,
0.0520723835,
0.0069383816,
-0.0291828699,
-0.0501514859,
0.0211195666,
-0.0210225396,
0.0561121441,
-0.004826854,
0.0740070045,
-0.0415670611,
0.0204114094,
0.0352216847,
-0.0118678752,
0.0146090519,
0.0001666316,
0.0570908152,
-0.0011346419,
-0.0060090995,
-0.0047473214,
0.0354964696,
0.0196849573,
-0.020152675,
0.0123842601,
0.1049439609,
0.0256166048,
-0.0431484394,
0.0393086001,
-0.0437777489,
0.0231531542,
0.0207043067,
0.0237285495,
-0.065909043,
0.0023002559,
0.0088759651,
0.0452333614,
-0.0744743049,
-0.0411455557,
0.0267689135,
-0.0891065449,
0.0645458177,
-0.0013531172,
0.0168955624,
0.0080110682,
-0.0116890576,
0.0147978812,
-0.0181119442,
-0.0171111654,
-0.0325979851,
0.0223651882,
0.0203444008,
-0.0014066347,
-0.0236491952,
-0.0208992157,
0.0289530698,
0.0235712901,
0.0728407949,
0.0447860062,
0.0333107263,
-0.0259127393,
-0.0481233858,
0.0396537781,
0.041668281,
0.0040247235,
-0.0149938297,
0.0745216608,
0.0125343911,
-0.0022161091,
-0.0552818552,
0.0571604185,
-0.0217058044,
-0.0210931357,
0.0114423158,
0.1079830006,
0.014799335,
-0.0487736762,
-0.026793126,
0.0333170183,
0.0333975852,
0.0660503209,
0.0206769668,
-0.0722824335,
-0.017604921,
-0.0596046373,
0.0287559796,
-0.0090320716,
-0.094631575,
0.0029599164,
0.0252961554,
-0.043763075,
-0.0549429581,
-0.0604500175,
0.0237749722,
-0.0159476586,
0.0146442158,
-0.108788453,
-0.0015835308,
-0.0136001166,
-0.0238889717,
0.0655004233,
0.0324340127,
-0.0194352251,
-0.0434468873,
0.0019771345,
0.0069265631,
-0.0237095468,
-0.0222147498,
0.0023987428,
0.0071721384,
-0.0605928972,
0.1091496572,
0.0688872784,
0.0293927286,
-0.0032973853,
0.0211973228,
-0.0105326511,
0.029967105,
0.0492398888,
-0.0207579006,
0.0176760759,
0.0208107736,
0.0051433537,
-0.0240386296,
0.0072683832,
0.019163169,
0.0755052343,
0.0640914962,
-0.0073553971,
-0.0054662582,
-0.006245967,
0.0334641971,
0.0292103793,
0.0705037266,
-0.0464741252,
-0.0408045016,
-0.0126973707,
-0.0570748262,
-0.0111264922,
-0.0210689697,
-0.0163212363,
-0.0599900372,
0.0365259051,
0.0006110133,
-0.0296234898,
-0.0423186123,
-0.0403825678,
-0.0125232395,
-0.0337057784,
0.0321635194,
-0.0050372253,
0.0275880527,
0.0094919084,
0.0377105698,
-0.0006626136,
0.055475764,
0.006951198,
0.0393532366,
0.0081401952,
0.0971554071,
0.0008364489,
-0.0044571818,
0.0277298149,
0.0326795466,
-0.0678114295,
-0.0851405188,
0.0003997292,
-0.0169468597,
-0.0154809877,
-0.0320633426,
0.0229036044,
-0.027376622,
-0.0038411361,
-0.0163560491,
-0.0184708647,
0.0081925588,
-0.021066336,
0.0163561963,
-0.0155297872,
-0.0065098451,
-0.0339733101,
0.0273048226,
-0.0711095557,
0.0708745569,
0.0038280149,
-0.0267134458,
-0.0297218915,
-0.0216711201,
0.0241606124,
-0.0389106572,
-0.0140878875,
0.0027567549,
-0.0714066252,
-0.0371357873,
-0.0245575514,
-0.0067578312,
0.0110510699,
-0.0625827461,
0.0182849001,
0.043323718,
-0.0488377959,
-0.0076508946,
-0.0061597992,
0.0564275719,
-0.0274815615,
-0.0137951486,
-0.0429858789,
-6.073694087e-33,
-0.0260555632,
-0.0047750035,
-0.0118607301,
-0.0269672684,
-0.0153426751,
-0.0315928198,
-0.0184853394,
0.0540190265,
-0.0028140598,
0.0461868718,
-0.0208365191,
0.0159016997,
0.0041741901,
0.0027071324,
0.0154775456,
-0.0159786791,
0.0406650417,
-0.0257705636,
-0.0430110805,
0.0011676784,
-0.0125355627,
0.0374889486,
0.0271738004,
-0.0920835063,
0.0339043587,
0.0235142745,
-0.0124479057,
-0.0249756258,
-0.0080213863,
0.0128277251,
-0.0183540955,
0.0614438765,
0.0313401595,
-0.0438412651,
-0.0007354076,
0.0688156784,
-0.0076426947,
-0.0265623275,
0.0174235832,
-0.0128586749,
-0.0343314484,
-0.0216719713,
0.0074408636,
-0.019807335,
-0.0463652238,
-0.0255093388,
0.0192503463,
-0.0401181579,
0.045661632,
-0.0173569676,
-0.0610528216,
-0.0204543937,
-0.0125200124,
-0.0078119631,
-0.0023542135,
0.0780757442,
-0.0332009681,
0.0166797303,
-0.007402258,
0.0270907618,
0.0407072119,
-0.004367651,
0.0101274271,
0.0086038252,
0.002609072,
0.0521106087,
0.0609594658,
0.0360888317,
-0.0407661721,
0.0120880874,
0.0034820421,
0.0256012883,
0.0663525611,
0.0303882807,
0.0398618206,
-0.0470076501,
0.003358115,
0.0133474302,
-0.0083248373,
-0.021069603,
0.0582833104,
-0.0234054849,
-0.0103799487,
-0.0433986522,
-0.0249141194,
-0.0410630777,
-0.0275893845,
-0.0445021875,
0.0297898613,
-0.0182612259,
-0.017174663,
-0.0221153293,
0.0004024836,
-0.0385438427,
0.0140429977,
-0.0133850267,
-0.0146556729,
0.0364575423,
0.0014165458,
0.0064457287,
-0.022437932,
0.0082346788,
0.016868677,
0.0307206362,
0.07001739,
0.0243688244,
0.0102605671,
0.0045022243,
-0.0622598007,
0.0017017403,
-0.0138829648,
0.0773412883,
0.0337243825,
0.028481679,
-0.0090627456,
0.0204618704,
-0.0032494275,
-0.0461708829,
0.0182486679,
-0.0071251309,
-0.0571696311,
0.0341865644,
-0.0280536078,
0.0383273326,
-0.0350839272,
-0.0117859282,
-0.0202793181,
0.0336404294,
0.0417664722,
-0.0460337847,
-0.0177287385,
-0.0504699536,
2.846e-7,
0.0127462326,
0.0694979653,
-0.0042332294,
0.0064081331,
0.0150347166,
0.0353978537,
0.0163076837,
0.0510498025,
0.0798279047,
-0.041798044,
0.0093751885,
0.0291917939,
0.0342974216,
0.0453393199,
-0.0131191611,
-0.0465362482,
-0.0417687707,
0.0339959823,
-0.0488503501,
0.0386588126,
0.0690857917,
0.0647257268,
0.0208067819,
-0.0064682798,
0.0017905689,
0.0148031851,
0.0331284329,
-0.0721929148,
0.02676595,
0.0168912634,
0.00499332,
0.02102267,
0.0094320169,
0.0325702317,
0.0090319505,
-0.0255179238,
-0.0249453001,
0.0451195762,
-0.0067850496,
0.0094738323,
-0.0023556724,
0.0426886007,
-0.0134564443,
-0.0606821775,
0.0528212897,
-0.0746014565,
-0.0350115076,
-0.0225158315,
-0.031489715,
-0.0399908386,
0.0635806769,
-0.0254757777,
-0.0287604816,
0.006905911,
0.0355860777,
0.0617996231,
0.030162394,
-0.0565674193,
-0.0198721904,
0.0273919497,
-0.0524200276,
-0.0418892168,
-0.0322645307,
0.0161304623,
-0.0270881411,
-0.0676560625,
0.0074753813,
2.599777489e-34,
0.0261296704,
0.0604049526,
0.0362499245,
-0.0500680543,
0.0219081845,
0.0119111156,
0.0065877601,
0.0159616005,
0.0204320904,
-0.0789021403,
-0.0256217644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11107v1 | ChatABL: Abductive Learning via Natural Language Interaction with ChatGPT | 2023-04-21T16:23:47 | 2023-04-21T16:23:47 | Tianyang Zhong, Yaonai Wei, Li Yang, Zihao Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Xiaozheng Wei, Wenjun Li, Junjie Yao, Chong Ma, Xiang Li, Dajiang Zhu, Xi Jiang, Junwei Han, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu, Tuo Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have recently demonstrated
significant potential in mathematical abilities, providing valuable reasoning
paradigm consistent with human natural language. However, LLMs currently have
difficulty in bridging perception, language understanding and reasoning
capabilities due to incompatibility of the underlying information flow among
them, making it challenging to accomplish tasks autonomously. On the other
hand, abductive learning (ABL) frameworks for integrating the two abilities of
perception and reasoning has seen significant success in inverse decipherment
of incomplete facts, but it is limited by the lack of semantic understanding of
logical reasoning rules and the dependence on complicated domain knowledge
representation. This paper presents a novel method (ChatABL) for integrating
LLMs into the ABL framework, aiming at unifying the three abilities in a more
user-friendly and understandable manner. The proposed method uses the strengths
of LLMs' understanding and logical reasoning to correct the incomplete logical
facts for optimizing the performance of perceptual module, by summarizing and
reorganizing reasoning rules represented in natural language format. Similarly,
perceptual module provides necessary reasoning examples for LLMs in natural
language format. The variable-length handwritten equation deciphering task, an
abstract expression of the Mayan calendar decoding, is used as a testbed to
demonstrate that ChatABL has reasoning ability beyond most existing
state-of-the-art methods, which has been well supported by comparative studies.
To our best knowledge, the proposed ChatABL is the first attempt to explore a
new pattern for further approaching human-level cognitive ability via natural
language interaction with ChatGPT. | [
-0.0056471024,
0.0493572019,
-0.004808276,
0.0809452832,
-0.0757306963,
0.031877961,
0.005096952,
-0.0080754627,
0.0640290305,
-0.0145794163,
-0.014260184,
0.0215243958,
0.0129717281,
0.0159134865,
0.0131772421,
-0.0538266562,
0.0285032373,
-0.0265994575,
0.0469761118,
0.0164608322,
-0.0214660037,
-0.005050953,
-0.0300636124,
-0.0024120656,
-0.0276176985,
-0.0580687411,
-0.0311373379,
-0.0755902454,
0.006694905,
0.0110911466,
-0.0471945331,
0.0172118973,
0.0292405859,
0.0649968013,
0.0000024908,
-0.0741073415,
-0.0461353213,
0.0188895259,
-0.0568099283,
-0.0222966019,
0.0620480925,
-0.0023324764,
-0.0034491343,
-0.0070651011,
-0.0885587111,
-0.0020453858,
0.0497938506,
0.05089809,
0.0649094135,
0.0442483239,
-0.0087460447,
-0.032106597,
0.0281963143,
0.0164675843,
0.0456939749,
-0.0559445322,
0.0223224051,
0.0648770556,
0.035314247,
-0.0069121178,
-0.0282917973,
0.0229427963,
0.0575093552,
0.0137208924,
-0.0456337184,
0.0257105324,
-0.0410272293,
-0.0015116833,
-0.012093816,
0.0273844413,
0.0150951631,
-0.0211730655,
0.013106972,
0.0177496821,
0.0324974544,
0.0080195023,
-0.0708897188,
0.032605771,
-0.0526282638,
0.004342549,
0.0104927542,
-0.0072826352,
0.0190013535,
0.0269915722,
-0.0514923073,
0.0525671765,
-0.0036376223,
-0.0517758876,
-0.0088441307,
-0.021463152,
-0.0669612959,
-0.0027211707,
0.0496304259,
0.0510529168,
0.0176642668,
0.0290487353,
-0.031576883,
-0.0282494221,
-0.0384385101,
-0.0703721866,
-0.003297471,
0.0840429217,
-0.0413303487,
0.0668415353,
-0.0529103838,
0.0846930072,
-0.0140627669,
0.0618427247,
-0.0357207246,
0.0239589792,
-0.0681097731,
-0.0481910519,
-0.0314076841,
0.0130319344,
-0.0102476655,
0.0078964867,
-0.013650584,
0.0087464238,
-0.0113765728,
-0.009709537,
0.0025697239,
-0.016132351,
0.0079633771,
-0.0539726876,
-0.0392817073,
0.0104402211,
-0.0013251755,
0.0082924152,
0.0126978513,
-0.0536563657,
-0.0055305562,
0.0041201087,
0.0083721951,
0.0025268213,
0.0028363245,
0.1124039888,
-0.0184293985,
0.0145231178,
-0.052600272,
-0.0153626185,
0.0120217977,
-0.0753246918,
0.0295202266,
-0.0655348152,
0.0523929298,
0.0113633154,
-0.0457367338,
-0.0579688549,
0.0088773649,
0.0242869835,
-0.002520757,
0.0883061811,
-0.0226803124,
-0.0238207225,
0.0327428319,
-0.0066476688,
-0.0694887936,
0.0502425283,
0.0444744416,
0.0184301101,
-0.0108853569,
0.0034181147,
-0.005596586,
0.0089873439,
0.007649513,
-0.0404513068,
0.006674347,
-0.0168036297,
-0.0065894923,
0.0175453201,
-0.0021078836,
0.0322937034,
-0.0504698157,
-0.0062286896,
0.0486922935,
0.0501488112,
-0.0405481383,
0.0473629981,
0.0083223069,
0.0229866561,
0.0380981378,
0.0257632565,
-0.0813821331,
0.038205944,
-0.0444514863,
0.0067423088,
-0.0089387391,
0.0250186305,
0.0248870552,
-0.0811012834,
-0.0143705253,
-0.0091592111,
0.054478161,
0.0176527184,
0.0822031647,
0.019177977,
-0.0187047701,
0.0524977073,
0.0345082283,
-0.028142659,
-0.007331667,
-0.0501324497,
-0.0019731966,
0.0181452446,
0.0386110991,
-0.0539165661,
-0.0241368301,
0.0076894974,
0.0082598003,
0.0448150076,
0.0067165596,
0.0319070406,
-0.032815028,
-0.0366016068,
-0.0379129052,
0.0274038576,
0.0110939583,
0.0257712025,
-0.0012842531,
-0.0370820686,
0.0218621381,
-0.0211858414,
-0.0008843231,
0.0313712135,
-0.0325069949,
-0.0180191472,
-0.0395650864,
0.0257761236,
0.005521642,
-0.0085571008,
0.0339585505,
0.0251878425,
0.0028127767,
-0.0394092314,
-0.0406040773,
0.0339996554,
-0.0555332638,
-0.076014109,
0.0516402274,
-0.0502984785,
-0.0225345567,
0.0123408763,
-0.0433003232,
-0.0224864874,
0.0809216276,
-0.0382843725,
0.0595562197,
-0.0279558897,
-0.0104235979,
0.0301745739,
-0.0710094646,
-0.0164690204,
0.1169370636,
-0.0102846073,
-0.0198822264,
-0.003497618,
-0.0158986039,
0.0240967106,
-0.0288064238,
0.0559324622,
-0.0213298239,
-0.0367526598,
-0.0011238343,
-0.0250374023,
0.0316436104,
-0.00433168,
-0.0108444132,
-0.0378337204,
-0.0143486112,
-0.0021282239,
0.0426930003,
0.0254590269,
-0.0137301767,
-0.0048573436,
-0.0189433265,
0.0026513787,
-0.0326911248,
-0.0224961918,
-0.0206598416,
0.0145082837,
-0.0236988273,
-0.0144700445,
0.0032528983,
-0.0155838374,
-0.0540469177,
0.0244148467,
0.0384981185,
-0.0262378938,
-0.034619987,
0.0185631737,
-0.0062478655,
0.0100637572,
-0.0201784074,
-0.0076151513,
0.0196341425,
-0.0233587213,
0.0063067172,
0.0775224864,
-0.0483023189,
0.037733689,
0.0156934187,
-0.0268632043,
-0.0223609004,
0.0310097747,
-0.0261675902,
0.0178837236,
-0.0097930804,
-0.0151068624,
-0.02688816,
0.0382521525,
0.0393149629,
0.0063845837,
-0.0645163879,
0.0245998576,
-0.0300537273,
-0.0143507197,
-0.0584311709,
-0.0030392141,
-0.015143292,
0.0306740049,
-0.0350145437,
-0.0335526429,
0.0674120486,
0.0031233625,
-0.0152604375,
-0.0510650352,
0.0300272908,
-0.0541241728,
0.0385411568,
0.0021501733,
0.0092927618,
0.0127435764,
-0.0424610265,
-0.0386892334,
-0.0036874462,
0.0301710311,
-0.0145609891,
-0.0061916192,
-0.052805189,
0.008922671,
0.0034403536,
-0.0232449193,
-0.0410273857,
0.0423107371,
-0.0277720168,
0.0224545896,
-0.0146187712,
-0.0010907246,
-0.0572596751,
0.0018994247,
0.0340948366,
0.0086623644,
-0.0033025639,
-0.0175758377,
-0.0587409511,
-0.0237033814,
-0.0000735091,
0.0272254329,
0.0124826198,
-0.0144997556,
-0.0028969708,
0.0377169549,
0.0229202341,
-0.0256906059,
-0.0029320682,
0.0579599775,
-0.0276686549,
-0.0208709221,
0.0058516921,
0.0123921372,
-0.0210653152,
-0.0802280754,
0.0058960854,
0.0964259952,
0.0307254922,
0.0313704461,
-0.0198891293,
-0.0663877651,
-0.0103428625,
0.0146540496,
0.019668486,
-0.0764119849,
-0.0417383276,
0.0110593177,
0.0094642006,
0.0351139195,
-0.0318683721,
-0.0128658907,
-0.0823223144,
0.0500727594,
0.0364485085,
-0.0342144892,
-0.0349611826,
-0.0449118316,
-0.0139242867,
-0.0403017588,
-0.0535890236,
0.0268807169,
0.0030877921,
-0.0041820765,
0.0155108962,
-0.0444380231,
0.0232829284,
0.0033570284,
-0.0023423138,
-0.0536200888,
0.0397389308,
0.0429173224,
-0.0006120707,
-0.0541240871,
-0.0033895681,
0.0683484897,
0.0074335844,
-0.0032143872,
0.0118464129,
0.0148888044,
-0.0133253941,
-0.0396366827,
0.0655054301,
-0.0402677916,
-0.0566264503,
0.0114757959,
0.1352944225,
-0.0141857853,
0.0207813699,
-0.0026987037,
0.0017369676,
-0.023490442,
0.0830353722,
0.0213185176,
0.0095869368,
-0.0541653819,
-0.0162532069,
-0.0268077292,
-0.0113869077,
-0.0556343123,
0.0255898964,
0.005629356,
-0.0432973169,
-0.0351463556,
-0.0186904408,
0.0329381227,
0.0422852412,
-0.0020234955,
0.0094178542,
0.1081302688,
0.0000605203,
-0.0320675261,
0.0101036746,
-0.045466356,
-0.0003931416,
0.0190238617,
0.0186469592,
-0.0390788764,
-0.0663502216,
-0.0350084715,
0.0189490188,
-0.0485946462,
-0.0364123359,
0.0286859069,
0.0181285124,
0.0268081538,
0.0156723652,
-0.0141231213,
-0.0069374638,
0.0058836602,
0.0224417709,
-0.0042788354,
0.0075420025,
0.0125771137,
0.0334496722,
0.0055679227,
0.0084040472,
-0.0097336136,
0.0147400722,
-0.0225048624,
0.0334602967,
-0.0351114608,
0.0342575051,
0.0612562448,
0.0444044732,
0.005604615,
0.0042685764,
-0.0251708813,
-0.0106526362,
-0.0009759095,
-0.0366342664,
-0.0213891733,
-0.0388559215,
0.0112387249,
-0.0156946536,
0.0283083823,
0.0324954726,
-0.0349477306,
0.0304879267,
0.0086947447,
0.0282563698,
0.03261628,
0.0075812368,
0.0236336086,
-0.0161744021,
-0.0347803533,
0.020418711,
0.0034484563,
-0.0457372218,
0.0252398867,
-0.0185958035,
0.0988984331,
0.0177094359,
-0.014312028,
-0.0399289578,
-0.0086141182,
-0.0411271565,
-0.0782498196,
0.0097381668,
0.0588155985,
0.0283614211,
0.0182670336,
-0.0148060275,
-0.0703714564,
-0.0018939022,
-0.0031689238,
0.0390704982,
0.0545965172,
-0.0084850099,
0.0172466319,
0.0182303488,
0.0155702811,
-0.0868057758,
0.0535776764,
-0.0236531477,
0.045444496,
-0.0275231376,
-0.0291833673,
-0.0368715711,
-0.0591293685,
0.0098861745,
-0.0313982666,
-0.0137631036,
0.0115908915,
-0.0531009063,
-0.0557157099,
-0.0081246076,
0.0393041782,
-0.005704734,
-0.0118819643,
0.0468756482,
0.0634275228,
-0.0321323685,
-0.0583707541,
0.041646909,
0.0620735362,
-0.0053015319,
-0.010493665,
-0.0341009237,
-6.238178073e-33,
-0.0342571586,
-0.039204184,
0.0579998419,
0.0263002086,
0.0080945631,
-0.0411881618,
-0.0156290196,
0.0086821374,
0.0185839739,
0.0092273615,
0.0299930219,
-0.012155069,
0.0142839774,
0.010285059,
-0.0068208231,
-0.0034632778,
0.0005751402,
-0.0131687764,
0.0010550445,
-0.0348599143,
0.0345000476,
0.0160041619,
0.0644562989,
-0.0833688974,
0.0098571675,
-0.0013471335,
0.0079503264,
0.0585665666,
-0.0273772329,
0.0521962047,
-0.0255161878,
-0.0039207917,
0.0158247612,
-0.0009081948,
-0.0376083106,
0.0411882289,
-0.0675843209,
-0.0390536264,
0.0459380038,
0.0578532964,
-0.0372184403,
-0.0316895172,
0.0401672088,
-0.02463267,
-0.022215588,
-0.0249977577,
0.0262091607,
-0.0529492795,
0.0048398627,
0.0463282764,
-0.0624283887,
0.0403397977,
-0.0249310769,
-0.0341816247,
0.0338437594,
0.0360050127,
-0.0494345501,
-0.0296871588,
-0.0353278108,
0.0018650169,
0.0134258913,
-0.0130164241,
0.0704568475,
0.0056348839,
0.0223348737,
0.0309266299,
0.0313014276,
-0.0351024829,
-0.0295044109,
-0.0260281153,
0.0351106711,
0.0755440891,
0.0431680605,
0.0488142967,
0.0606988892,
0.0247548148,
-0.0363902263,
0.000168421,
-0.0246954001,
0.0616060086,
0.048776418,
0.0419437177,
-0.0687972307,
-0.0028717231,
-0.0072583691,
0.0369690545,
-0.045671653,
-0.0193937924,
0.0360171422,
-0.0121191638,
0.0057155807,
-0.0217880458,
0.0167106744,
-0.0410161614,
0.0269184131,
-0.0143135833,
0.0237843264,
0.0159964859,
-0.0176285859,
0.0079247653,
-0.0425236486,
-0.024716422,
0.0050884984,
0.0104656396,
0.0374390408,
-0.0195799656,
0.0278370101,
0.0186318699,
0.0041013812,
0.0004013819,
-0.0350389145,
-0.0403874256,
0.0479886122,
-0.0037840791,
0.0638467073,
0.0266779531,
-0.0252597686,
-0.0378171802,
0.0088739349,
-0.0006254212,
-0.0421591103,
0.0143429628,
-0.0190829206,
-0.0103077218,
-0.0238385014,
-0.0323432386,
-0.015080859,
-0.0317295343,
-0.0153015601,
-0.0570448488,
-0.0005397167,
0.0325087085,
3.183e-7,
0.0312477313,
0.0477192663,
0.0289026909,
0.0325341262,
0.0250711981,
0.0291738994,
-0.0363960937,
-0.0008889779,
0.0328851603,
-0.0215530675,
0.0080633434,
0.0631605312,
0.0540496372,
0.0241371095,
-0.0528428964,
0.0197934452,
0.0208184123,
-0.0528509244,
-0.051401075,
0.0404254906,
0.123125717,
0.0265359301,
0.031893868,
-0.0002322644,
0.0105202431,
-0.0359376818,
0.0568908118,
0.0024276748,
-0.0262126662,
-0.0231334064,
0.0329835638,
-0.0000740152,
-0.0031130125,
0.0054393858,
0.0281081367,
-0.0129583254,
0.0500405431,
0.0623877756,
-0.0116134323,
0.0235667303,
-0.0071642473,
-0.0175562706,
-0.0085074035,
-0.0071338024,
0.0577094145,
-0.076532051,
-0.031155875,
-0.0061807237,
-0.0239700507,
-0.0177276395,
-0.0269421954,
0.04879684,
-0.0130181797,
-0.0123139694,
0.0222489405,
-0.0294853486,
-0.0367773101,
-0.0381531194,
-0.0244558156,
0.0456587933,
-0.0473492034,
-0.0346120782,
-0.0492094047,
0.0126293264,
0.0703701526,
-0.0385542288,
0.0110330069,
3.133421848e-34,
0.0011676382,
0.0052749631,
0.0258092564,
0.0320934467,
0.0503396764,
0.016593596,
0.0258484781,
0.0532740206,
0.041555617,
-0.0706974417,
0.0079870606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11015v3 | DIN-SQL: Decomposed In-Context Learning of Text-to-SQL with Self-Correction | 2023-04-21T15:02:18 | 2023-11-02T20:30:12 | Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.HC | There is currently a significant gap between the performance of fine-tuned
models and prompting approaches using Large Language Models (LLMs) on the
challenging task of text-to-SQL, as evaluated on datasets such as Spider. To
improve the performance of LLMs in the reasoning process, we study how
decomposing the task into smaller sub-tasks can be effective. In particular, we
show that breaking down the generation problem into sub-problems and feeding
the solutions of those sub-problems into LLMs can be an effective approach for
significantly improving their performance. Our experiments with three LLMs show
that this approach consistently improves their simple few-shot performance by
roughly 10%, pushing the accuracy of LLMs towards SOTA or surpassing it. On the
holdout test set of Spider, the SOTA, in terms of execution accuracy, was 79.9
and the new SOTA at the time of this writing using our approach is 85.3. Our
approach with in-context learning beats many heavily fine-tuned models by at
least 5%. Additionally, when evaluated on the BIRD benchmark, our approach
achieved an execution accuracy of 55.9%, setting a new SOTA on its holdout test
set. | [
0.0268097874,
0.0773311928,
-0.005225488,
0.0180030689,
-0.0366280824,
0.0171644278,
-0.0043438096,
-0.0069441563,
0.0069833421,
-0.0730804503,
-0.0201678593,
-0.0109746745,
-0.0166973937,
0.0354892835,
0.0362012647,
-0.0219181702,
0.0191298332,
-0.0325029045,
-0.0091127558,
0.0096135521,
-0.0279139206,
0.0263938382,
0.0134036867,
-0.0232879166,
-0.0140228877,
-0.0405153669,
-0.0216860212,
0.0297278445,
-0.0308971051,
-0.0154064009,
-0.0043268204,
0.0300386325,
0.0415538438,
0.0425990336,
0.0000022381,
-0.0565691218,
-0.0359988548,
0.0131225437,
-0.0515225381,
0.0426415615,
0.0410154238,
-0.0352281816,
0.0078930622,
0.0671779141,
-0.0517850928,
-0.0110257147,
0.000275695,
0.0178046171,
0.0565677062,
0.1087351963,
-0.0155149112,
-0.0640033111,
0.0145544624,
-0.0390143991,
0.0286820941,
-0.0576058552,
0.0110457428,
0.0387941897,
0.033856649,
-0.0006189242,
0.0045349239,
0.0159239303,
0.0210469104,
-0.0248420611,
-0.0094328662,
0.0144154513,
-0.026570173,
-0.0009119966,
-0.0120775709,
0.0523213595,
-0.0276767537,
-0.0150396703,
-0.0007162596,
0.0111270016,
-0.008841184,
-0.0163557958,
-0.0024568825,
0.0377100818,
-0.0031548464,
0.0241736751,
0.001939757,
-0.0011694565,
0.023359362,
-0.0017382288,
-0.0570400804,
0.019489225,
-0.0043121558,
-0.0200886186,
0.0151231978,
-0.0140439663,
-0.0020405273,
-0.0475583002,
0.0223672558,
0.0602472574,
-0.0874147788,
0.0238391981,
-0.066050902,
-0.0028640172,
0.0010369564,
-0.0379755646,
0.0315054581,
0.0335795507,
0.0118798921,
0.0480365604,
-0.0533427857,
0.0094947908,
0.0146451816,
-0.0010685605,
-0.0450588875,
-0.0254436564,
-0.0697257668,
0.0086763343,
-0.0466537029,
0.0499493331,
-0.0961493477,
-0.0462771878,
-0.0207144972,
0.0395182259,
0.0219177641,
0.0601055995,
0.0138715291,
-0.0011027688,
-0.0307076108,
-0.0304935072,
-0.0328931995,
0.0026743654,
0.0046399012,
0.0136857787,
0.0213813577,
-0.0516767353,
-0.0121869277,
-0.0126787368,
0.0232971925,
-0.0162061863,
0.0355317779,
0.066577509,
-0.0458383001,
-0.0112482039,
-0.1070740223,
-0.0519690849,
-0.0191128328,
-0.0662087277,
-0.0375239737,
-0.0577501133,
0.0591424815,
0.0084860511,
-0.0220713746,
-0.0546697713,
0.0096471412,
0.0325572789,
0.0016233469,
0.0823356211,
-0.0107709393,
0.0166801549,
0.0165851973,
-0.0103362203,
0.0252571069,
0.0915615335,
0.0148934554,
0.0532128438,
-0.0067690117,
-0.0062709088,
-0.0185252577,
0.0139699029,
0.041644156,
0.0317075551,
-0.0657044128,
0.0592679977,
0.0214645565,
0.0453453772,
0.0201277565,
0.0878357589,
-0.0132967671,
0.0349188671,
0.0521843247,
-0.0005654359,
0.055509299,
0.0480695516,
0.0339969024,
0.0247717518,
-0.0214625709,
-0.0283070449,
-0.0561497286,
0.0086396169,
-0.031493932,
0.0463248454,
0.0360760428,
0.0149336886,
-0.0376359858,
-0.0572054349,
-0.0029137461,
-0.0109534208,
-0.0277313069,
0.0240735095,
0.0273814593,
0.0409451015,
-0.037901625,
0.0030620748,
-0.0070137284,
-0.0150468936,
0.0153773753,
-0.0258125495,
0.0002525413,
0.0627227277,
0.0219873972,
-0.0302365869,
-0.0165722407,
-0.0231881235,
0.0162036605,
0.0362856649,
0.0048311432,
-0.0258751921,
-0.0158404894,
-0.0180740729,
-0.0086533595,
-0.0075677265,
0.0150055224,
-0.0195590109,
0.0316944532,
0.0049396981,
0.0428715125,
-0.0308147259,
-0.0495486818,
0.040549919,
-0.0475930162,
-0.0414874852,
0.0386275388,
0.002006707,
0.0234537534,
0.0214911848,
-0.026056705,
0.0411583595,
0.0106743537,
-0.0194773879,
-0.0514771342,
-0.0517529733,
-0.007950766,
-0.0833699256,
0.0409044996,
-0.0017644835,
-0.0050541558,
-0.0256571136,
-0.0721234232,
-0.0464705266,
-0.0027592441,
-0.038788911,
0.005753513,
-0.0514919609,
0.0258761141,
0.0235840045,
-0.0414369702,
-0.0278367475,
0.0822724178,
-0.0002979224,
-0.0243561175,
-0.0221892036,
0.0036424582,
0.0262571387,
-0.055939164,
0.0314495154,
-0.0021531382,
0.0026691805,
0.0315089449,
-0.0184041727,
0.0144957043,
-0.0374606773,
-0.0314770937,
-0.0380027965,
0.0285712462,
-0.0172844455,
0.0311033018,
0.0099072363,
0.0054016584,
0.0080449013,
-0.0161178298,
-0.0627718046,
-0.0044067916,
0.0172800943,
0.0160356443,
0.0291843303,
0.0120415138,
-0.0084032239,
-0.0130548645,
-0.016039731,
-0.0259879567,
0.0418170393,
-0.0189772006,
-0.0212629978,
-0.0550989546,
0.0579577759,
-0.0293060727,
0.0275342297,
0.0054405006,
0.0018198777,
-0.0034733224,
-0.0475236252,
0.0157800708,
0.0541188419,
0.0200850461,
-0.0451235548,
0.0005421066,
0.008041909,
-0.0498690866,
0.0164056867,
-0.0238323044,
0.0050857761,
-0.0038809553,
-0.0314619243,
0.0257186722,
0.0347362123,
-0.0139863985,
-0.028511798,
-0.0389349945,
0.0381595716,
0.0385243073,
0.0119409375,
-0.0432923995,
-0.0087972088,
0.0459609851,
0.0270580817,
-0.0148804365,
-0.0418974198,
0.0598585717,
-0.0272791889,
0.0125730485,
-0.0668495893,
0.0109536685,
-0.0701128319,
0.0723897442,
-0.0001034751,
0.0332369097,
-0.0236467719,
-0.0474997722,
-0.0458266027,
-0.0248797573,
0.0109688006,
-0.017575331,
0.0795370191,
-0.0313858762,
0.0369943902,
-0.0142386043,
-0.0503229685,
-0.0400789194,
-0.0096639516,
-0.0448883064,
0.0304728746,
0.0222532637,
0.0002401142,
-0.0081720566,
0.00710874,
-0.0098590162,
0.054049056,
-0.0052475813,
-0.0284808744,
-0.0175694339,
-0.0282550026,
0.0211430434,
0.0067100259,
0.0057059461,
-0.0144065414,
0.0524056144,
0.0407807343,
0.0364520028,
-0.0476154163,
-0.0263332464,
0.0099783717,
-0.0065847826,
-0.0201368704,
-0.0169015862,
0.0339204334,
-0.0308687463,
-0.0550040901,
-0.0317068249,
0.0940473303,
0.019239774,
0.0212616306,
0.0007352207,
0.0079968628,
0.0299131144,
0.0327548012,
0.0609504506,
-0.1025888771,
-0.0560933724,
-0.0143769123,
0.0297296382,
0.0516320691,
-0.0228273422,
-0.0207105614,
-0.1705742329,
0.0517543294,
0.0198016316,
-0.0363725424,
-0.0139802163,
0.0073005944,
-0.0490877107,
-0.0183916427,
0.0107824318,
0.0702461377,
-0.0332615785,
0.0010817656,
0.01482083,
0.0209791698,
-0.0572483651,
-0.0079506673,
-0.0429983437,
0.010355643,
0.0401458219,
0.0146410512,
0.0504833423,
-0.0121692019,
0.0415848605,
-0.0156015847,
0.0111727724,
-0.028801078,
0.0737622231,
-0.0072286106,
0.0129307238,
0.023794882,
0.0487382933,
-0.0377650931,
-0.005097901,
0.0049176184,
0.0859470665,
-0.0324852094,
0.0007099855,
-0.0026920792,
-0.0275306143,
0.0082408357,
0.0630688444,
0.0066196793,
-0.016895039,
-0.0716068745,
-0.0148518402,
-0.0150868231,
-0.0486794338,
0.0114397621,
0.0427467823,
-0.0386135355,
-0.0569103472,
-0.0584465116,
-0.0064851074,
0.0476464927,
0.0966470391,
0.0004367613,
0.0200633425,
0.0055053076,
-0.0105413301,
-0.03008347,
-0.0195618737,
-0.050697241,
-0.0067468504,
-0.0442395769,
0.0043864236,
0.0372043289,
-0.0393594764,
-0.0079113534,
-0.008628007,
-0.0796438307,
-0.0498117991,
0.0034883521,
0.014442916,
0.0235767663,
0.0567863323,
0.0059474302,
-0.0509258844,
0.0477573499,
0.0557485484,
-0.0378896445,
-0.0364490561,
-0.0022048326,
0.0131692355,
-0.0060113403,
0.0476595126,
-0.0335398503,
0.0268111583,
-0.0021360118,
0.0275747254,
-0.0122003611,
0.0322337486,
0.0621251315,
0.051721815,
-0.000071666,
0.0057269232,
-0.0222829599,
-0.0107462443,
0.0591472983,
-0.0523281582,
-0.0493380912,
-0.0454467833,
-0.0018084249,
0.0266167168,
0.0119856866,
0.0274489094,
-0.0122145424,
0.0074132392,
0.0499767177,
-0.0065946188,
-0.0315621421,
0.0475514233,
0.0044889268,
0.0494936779,
-0.0322678015,
0.0035146067,
0.0462551191,
0.036327634,
0.0539116226,
-0.0317783356,
0.0343285426,
0.0473514721,
0.0331537463,
-0.0626922771,
-0.0115625076,
-0.020614773,
-0.0522215255,
-0.0312547348,
-0.0123054087,
0.0387213714,
0.006375866,
0.0230155103,
-0.0359605104,
-0.0149110118,
-0.0113636581,
0.0274313837,
0.0216850955,
-0.0314059891,
0.013273919,
0.0058426578,
-0.0324078314,
-0.0204938427,
0.0770367458,
-0.0005533755,
0.0333058573,
-0.0109978896,
-0.0389099568,
-0.0521192439,
-0.0452310517,
-0.0100550726,
-0.0155792693,
-0.0061524864,
-0.016808467,
-0.0405788571,
-0.0423358716,
-0.003273932,
0.0216035433,
-0.0226344857,
-0.0177527275,
0.044582732,
0.0706446543,
0.0569564998,
-0.0182827748,
-0.0355849825,
0.026088357,
-0.0216086973,
-0.0535633899,
-0.0059194379,
-6.508998747e-33,
-0.0302881785,
-0.0252613127,
0.0636288673,
-0.0124480473,
0.0008251331,
-0.0288789887,
-0.0202144943,
-0.021360267,
-0.0094318688,
0.0034142088,
-0.036659766,
0.0285636131,
0.0245457385,
0.058815293,
0.0244424138,
-0.0173760001,
0.051900357,
-0.0241785813,
-0.0153554017,
0.0125172725,
0.0426698066,
0.0358374231,
0.0127363894,
-0.0169856343,
-0.0310950372,
0.0091479542,
-0.0260141417,
0.037696708,
0.0001488961,
0.0186409038,
0.0000285855,
0.0149453161,
0.0063069691,
-0.0136369262,
-0.028486412,
-0.0053088213,
-0.0647500455,
-0.01686511,
-0.0048799217,
-0.0159704927,
-0.0134952962,
-0.0237781759,
0.0602880977,
-0.0377368294,
-0.0250258222,
-0.0254521761,
-0.0230452213,
-0.0451994203,
-0.0371011645,
-0.0351098627,
-0.0786725059,
0.0200186223,
0.0253035352,
-0.0191523936,
0.0142194256,
0.0234539211,
-0.0084271785,
0.0229840092,
-0.0548659414,
0.0361702405,
0.0538774319,
0.0712816045,
0.0471580699,
0.034809269,
-0.0032282118,
0.010981421,
0.0244136639,
0.0311520193,
-0.0067792321,
0.0379417688,
-0.0022231918,
0.0792306364,
0.0197602361,
0.0504696034,
0.0134864189,
-0.0062023988,
-0.0984720737,
0.0424382873,
-0.0337819234,
0.0188801624,
0.02747209,
0.0038631964,
-0.0543862097,
-0.0545537323,
-0.0337782688,
0.0240790807,
-0.0293513294,
-0.012696634,
0.045388639,
0.0314003006,
-0.0112041943,
-0.0149802351,
0.030537609,
-0.0117988326,
-0.0371988192,
0.0116629303,
-0.0445175804,
-0.0223834943,
-0.0182478353,
0.0207640957,
-0.0759466067,
-0.0700927228,
0.0018586904,
0.0385902561,
0.0112245902,
0.0193112027,
0.0445807986,
0.0412572138,
-0.0876754373,
0.0244440325,
-0.0314052179,
0.062267933,
-0.0110769756,
0.0194129441,
0.0324874669,
-0.0133945532,
0.0227397364,
0.0290213618,
0.0096238991,
-0.0300125182,
0.0045396695,
0.0167377107,
0.0291298684,
0.0116580389,
0.0169195663,
0.0412151441,
-0.0090134675,
-0.0255910475,
0.03008339,
-0.0383028574,
0.0058871806,
0.0402904116,
2.916e-7,
0.0568551011,
0.0447176509,
0.0308482666,
0.0467318967,
0.0217860714,
0.0419239253,
-0.0209058262,
-0.0056303935,
0.0177944694,
0.015434064,
0.0452685654,
-0.0021081201,
0.0594727956,
0.0458228998,
-0.0659949183,
0.0184155088,
-0.0345172137,
0.0180615932,
-0.0736893043,
-0.025243165,
0.0351104662,
0.1030136049,
-0.0422463678,
-0.0271338839,
0.0340253972,
-0.0635329932,
0.0466025844,
0.0071544875,
-0.0425057709,
0.0559523143,
-0.0069290283,
0.0238090958,
-0.0293236226,
0.0313684642,
-0.030815566,
0.0354908966,
-0.0337321982,
0.0818769038,
0.0124692433,
0.025404647,
0.0128782811,
-0.0444071628,
0.0150879165,
-0.0380796231,
0.0834097937,
-0.0749620274,
-0.0246606991,
0.0479073338,
-0.0043393844,
-0.0360093266,
-0.0169951916,
-0.0032038281,
0.0199780464,
-0.0244935043,
0.0264257491,
0.0147390403,
0.0002983447,
-0.0633095801,
-0.0324328728,
0.0438433029,
-0.0309360884,
-0.0093361381,
-0.0213262811,
0.0438367724,
0.0000362292,
-0.0355608389,
-0.0145530561,
3.06925455e-34,
0.02316509,
0.0079207206,
0.012361466,
0.0086790575,
0.0427667499,
0.0200773943,
-0.0248130504,
0.0103671663,
0.022229448,
-0.0605699345,
-0.0295126941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10996v1 | BERT Based Clinical Knowledge Extraction for Biomedical Knowledge Graph Construction and Analysis | 2023-04-21T14:45:33 | 2023-04-21T14:45:33 | Ayoub Harnoune, Maryem Rhanoui, Mounia Mikram, Siham Yousfi, Zineb Elkaimbillah, Bouchra El Asri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Background : Knowledge is evolving over time, often as a result of new
discoveries or changes in the adopted methods of reasoning. Also, new facts or
evidence may become available, leading to new understandings of complex
phenomena. This is particularly true in the biomedical field, where scientists
and physicians are constantly striving to find new methods of diagnosis,
treatment and eventually cure. Knowledge Graphs (KGs) offer a real way of
organizing and retrieving the massive and growing amount of biomedical
knowledge.
Objective : We propose an end-to-end approach for knowledge extraction and
analysis from biomedical clinical notes using the Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model and Conditional Random Field
(CRF) layer.
Methods : The approach is based on knowledge graphs, which can effectively
process abstract biomedical concepts such as relationships and interactions
between medical entities. Besides offering an intuitive way to visualize these
concepts, KGs can solve more complex knowledge retrieval problems by
simplifying them into simpler representations or by transforming the problems
into representations from different perspectives. We created a biomedical
Knowledge Graph using using Natural Language Processing models for named entity
recognition and relation extraction. The generated biomedical knowledge graphs
(KGs) are then used for question answering.
Results : The proposed framework can successfully extract relevant structured
information with high accuracy (90.7% for Named-entity recognition (NER), 88%
for relation extraction (RE)), according to experimental findings based on
real-world 505 patient biomedical unstructured clinical notes.
Conclusions : In this paper, we propose a novel end-to-end system for the
construction of a biomedical knowledge graph from clinical textual using a
variation of BERT models. | [
0.0755234137,
-0.0081309993,
0.0221707989,
0.02389808,
-0.0079400642,
0.0312145073,
-0.0399739966,
0.0544235744,
0.0366226397,
-0.0374020599,
0.0017588995,
-0.0106981844,
-0.0328487866,
0.018258119,
0.0041585304,
-0.0591903552,
0.0070374124,
0.031929452,
0.0532385893,
0.0001035784,
-0.0089155501,
0.0053776894,
-0.0397100039,
0.002854174,
0.0155854868,
-0.0046937028,
0.0231557358,
-0.0128121963,
0.0580060296,
-0.079386197,
-0.0052747657,
0.0019491281,
-0.0224568974,
-0.0525545999,
0.0000018522,
-0.0469173715,
-0.0582964309,
0.0485865548,
-0.0320175774,
-0.0698554218,
-0.034185376,
-0.0360153355,
0.0069293692,
-0.0055973125,
-0.0414067172,
-0.0456999168,
0.0023900918,
0.0778376907,
0.0334071368,
0.0704317987,
-0.0201846007,
-0.0307334736,
0.0440925583,
0.0147086466,
0.0154581154,
-0.0262888223,
0.0643939301,
0.0044570942,
0.0294944867,
-0.0146910809,
-0.0132124973,
0.0216292944,
-0.0079776067,
0.0335722454,
0.0667402297,
0.0443583801,
-0.0551555604,
0.0042760242,
-0.0035770976,
0.0867849514,
-0.0133520374,
-0.0010384023,
0.0478719845,
0.0110758683,
-0.0363373309,
0.0364661105,
-0.0312592164,
-0.0174686741,
-0.0826838166,
-0.0087918611,
0.0018427481,
-0.0215264261,
0.0149842091,
-0.0302547496,
-0.0125480685,
0.0109366262,
0.0341573432,
-0.0526036248,
0.0104453946,
-0.0256353952,
-0.0026322475,
-0.0334817655,
0.0670651719,
0.0616657063,
0.0141507816,
0.0398651622,
-0.0051621478,
-0.0632527918,
0.0455556028,
-0.0834696144,
-0.0315159075,
-0.0126565387,
0.0086319912,
0.0448315628,
-0.0502209142,
-0.0100078201,
-0.0397570394,
0.0497270301,
-0.0294124857,
-0.0141190477,
-0.0537617356,
-0.032188762,
-0.0366577767,
0.0728625655,
-0.019801829,
-0.0244723707,
-0.0555687062,
-0.0024651701,
0.0005991522,
0.0291367732,
0.0577705242,
0.0488701575,
0.010324561,
0.0082638813,
-0.010747836,
0.0219784118,
-0.0184090566,
-0.0293610152,
-0.0397059098,
-0.000104371,
0.0208685454,
-0.0128471451,
0.0640104041,
-0.0168569311,
0.0123959603,
0.0865619183,
0.0436949395,
-0.0433900431,
-0.0243874788,
-0.0399528556,
-0.0010431005,
-0.0039449907,
0.0272204317,
-0.0345916748,
0.0284497458,
0.039067626,
-0.002902963,
-0.0122056399,
0.033521127,
-0.0043449425,
-0.0554519817,
0.038993746,
-0.0880513787,
-0.0122686177,
0.0211204886,
0.0138971843,
0.0082921125,
0.0072857151,
0.0395000502,
-0.0536888056,
0.0370486714,
-0.0108961146,
0.0006147214,
-0.0026412059,
0.0391792767,
-0.0825734064,
0.0226840004,
0.0380371995,
-0.0192385279,
0.0347004756,
-0.0440705419,
0.0677807257,
-0.0023726167,
-0.0150671583,
-0.0309577249,
0.0595763773,
0.0322684571,
0.0279334486,
-0.0040767635,
-0.0210487489,
0.0280029643,
-0.0105869388,
0.018963255,
0.0147760548,
0.0118738301,
0.0270853695,
-0.0441653319,
0.0032372139,
-0.015869081,
0.0174388681,
-0.0194164217,
0.0044408627,
-0.0095137432,
-0.0227980707,
0.0792596713,
0.0173119325,
-0.0593352057,
0.0786538422,
0.0505504496,
-0.0302800294,
0.0042725196,
-0.0175857767,
-0.0260231271,
0.0677777082,
0.0528934412,
-0.0432937853,
-0.0570180453,
0.003576728,
-0.0706599131,
0.0123656243,
-0.0031529004,
-0.0323381573,
-0.0021817,
-0.0312161632,
-0.0255556311,
0.0318899974,
-0.0090186503,
-0.0215106197,
0.0071314806,
0.0471182987,
-0.0165139195,
-0.0728392005,
0.0064757084,
0.0286233351,
-0.0347275808,
-0.0018001647,
-0.0245045237,
0.0104875071,
0.0202915892,
0.0505821817,
-0.0047081071,
0.0411694944,
0.0575795285,
-0.0441315994,
-0.0405639112,
0.0133977067,
-0.0063508404,
-0.071295619,
0.0102789607,
-0.0484205894,
-0.0121914316,
-0.033179637,
-0.0327510387,
-0.0309609324,
-0.0287528075,
-0.0388566889,
0.099658899,
0.0104089295,
0.0055427677,
0.0415692702,
-0.042915199,
-0.0301283374,
0.0431065038,
-0.0167976078,
0.0045963018,
-0.0021115467,
-0.0764162317,
0.0098657208,
-0.0222132243,
-0.011413103,
0.0196718704,
-0.0135188876,
-0.0271523669,
-0.0026683917,
-0.0289511755,
-0.0368894003,
-0.0088507067,
-0.1118862554,
0.0087916907,
0.0304784477,
0.0494232848,
0.0459973067,
0.0452001765,
-0.0005307103,
-0.0317219384,
-0.0505990982,
0.0004045736,
0.0047483463,
-0.015433412,
0.047414761,
0.0377053097,
-0.0038295528,
-0.013765214,
-0.0102221994,
-0.0472805016,
0.0503082909,
0.0294965301,
-0.043620225,
0.0146246199,
-0.0010399062,
-0.0450027399,
0.0228126422,
0.0043035536,
0.0002458519,
0.0037416825,
-0.0022372087,
0.0050531155,
0.0330784805,
0.0069276509,
0.0558184497,
-0.0190833583,
-0.0068626562,
-0.0107907178,
0.035765361,
-0.0705181956,
0.0363781154,
0.0059243855,
-0.0158333126,
0.0273264796,
0.0386136509,
0.0452265367,
0.0003021689,
-0.0239796881,
-0.0462498814,
0.0010413558,
0.0235412363,
-0.0307556409,
0.0092806071,
-0.0283764321,
-0.0053294692,
-0.0130167641,
0.0151962768,
0.1058772281,
-0.0051299329,
0.0385468751,
-0.0743716881,
0.0276193395,
-0.0290194303,
0.0101306196,
0.013421909,
0.0262377094,
-0.0124212308,
-0.0252866931,
0.0287001375,
0.003268901,
-0.0080680521,
-0.0689132214,
-0.0047611496,
0.0077642892,
0.0364976116,
0.0157540813,
0.0024583484,
-0.0550482273,
0.0092908405,
-0.0295119025,
0.0174150262,
0.0031050851,
-0.0102473153,
0.0046544941,
0.0430136994,
0.0067863297,
0.0313643962,
0.0109150643,
0.0009207118,
-0.0121132201,
0.0700004995,
0.0484412462,
-0.0363583229,
-0.0124665992,
0.0013746694,
0.0047754375,
0.0692328364,
-0.017790271,
0.0085460339,
-0.0013292171,
-0.007273457,
-0.0347218327,
-0.0761322156,
0.0221667942,
-0.0143744191,
0.0177190825,
-0.0460859761,
0.0132070743,
0.0928410962,
0.0449755937,
-0.016700821,
0.0176697262,
0.0043915287,
-0.0545847639,
-0.0210210364,
0.0263449401,
-0.085565649,
-0.0193672646,
-0.0346220881,
0.0330201574,
-0.0034520444,
-0.0664434433,
0.0428876877,
-0.0608560666,
0.0029633916,
-0.0386957154,
-0.0314977281,
-0.0590224788,
-0.0800843984,
-0.0014407433,
0.0223954748,
-0.048684556,
-0.0093959384,
-0.0232339278,
0.0047281682,
0.0295085255,
-0.0468190908,
-0.0475702472,
0.0162511021,
-0.0369182788,
0.0208159741,
0.0355677605,
0.0413923487,
-0.0144599425,
-0.0157945752,
-0.0379686579,
0.0045717116,
-0.0192861781,
-0.013221534,
0.0738860294,
-0.0115516735,
-0.0133132869,
-0.073650457,
-0.0050718049,
-0.0305697918,
-0.029385861,
-0.0087225456,
0.0617636368,
-0.029761957,
-0.0379046611,
-0.062923789,
-0.0110627962,
-0.0020042344,
0.0382910669,
-0.014188691,
0.0237306263,
-0.0129403006,
0.0316005014,
0.0732224733,
-0.036310602,
0.0162058324,
0.029651206,
-0.0591259003,
0.0126128737,
-0.0464567468,
0.0034301861,
0.0448230095,
-0.0061526867,
0.0112878587,
-0.0051450995,
0.1016836911,
0.0057229544,
-0.0860491246,
0.0173551124,
0.0398335271,
-0.0175414067,
-0.0272908062,
-0.0673250556,
0.0432274565,
0.012575347,
-0.0316753499,
-0.0354855657,
0.0179411564,
0.0000226447,
-0.0272392072,
0.0397087112,
0.0083353501,
0.0010951554,
0.004715276,
0.02751543,
0.0423081145,
0.0239630602,
-0.03368688,
-0.0338496231,
-0.0262923222,
0.0001649605,
-0.0045269788,
-0.0047271498,
-0.0359944403,
0.0039954707,
-0.0080502229,
0.0596380159,
-0.0319687612,
-0.040358182,
0.0236403253,
0.0578641705,
0.0365060978,
-0.0000738497,
-0.011577609,
-0.0435738713,
0.0480802096,
-0.0158747695,
0.0332209542,
-0.0208005756,
0.0024470291,
0.0000829094,
-0.0039410237,
-0.0092584165,
0.021771295,
-0.0273750704,
-0.040585611,
-0.0011938786,
0.0528953969,
0.0264985636,
-0.0052634622,
0.0457033738,
-0.0273176376,
-0.0061761928,
0.0166149382,
0.0275683198,
0.0032759672,
-0.0040814751,
0.0497435331,
-0.002130629,
-0.0058770948,
-0.0194663089,
0.0320697799,
-0.0547418036,
-0.0087258425,
-0.0293634161,
0.0379913151,
0.0219112933,
0.0119630238,
0.0208000783,
-0.0091490168,
0.0007224858,
0.0105169322,
0.0130798565,
-0.0234988555,
0.022479279,
0.0823435411,
0.0241940282,
0.0085163778,
-0.0295551941,
0.0537177585,
-0.0000487467,
0.0632465556,
0.0038627423,
-0.071170792,
-0.0466060415,
0.0022807654,
0.0485437922,
-0.0076856976,
-0.0453731343,
0.0187053233,
-0.037608698,
-0.0282817278,
0.0693746209,
-0.0143228173,
-0.0240192693,
-0.0059699505,
0.0728542283,
0.0022956522,
0.0422589295,
-0.0487898327,
-0.0196126848,
0.0719167516,
-0.0411852412,
-0.013075171,
0.0083591547,
-5.740629885e-33,
-0.0086259926,
-0.0465760343,
0.0026736998,
0.0080548692,
-0.0117528681,
0.0348703936,
-0.0544508696,
-0.0337575376,
-0.0197301172,
0.0430907272,
-0.0050655766,
-0.0134448176,
0.0032756124,
0.0471337624,
-0.0347348005,
-0.0526795052,
0.0035745183,
0.017308332,
0.0335816108,
0.0091750063,
0.0256183408,
0.0863181204,
0.0655766129,
-0.0761728212,
-0.0070828767,
-0.0213919077,
0.0473667793,
0.0158992019,
0.0213400386,
0.0481738411,
-0.0501361825,
0.0042258408,
0.0295699295,
0.0013497225,
0.0217009764,
0.0040237023,
-0.1371520758,
-0.0199784543,
-0.0094798049,
-0.0043917797,
-0.055298306,
0.0031697536,
0.063199684,
-0.0003962329,
0.0253888052,
0.0149522256,
0.0527679734,
-0.006948906,
-0.0247769635,
-0.0621336251,
-0.0365016311,
0.052008193,
0.0058921766,
0.0119704651,
-0.009669275,
-0.0261276644,
-0.0087727578,
-0.005704321,
-0.0365305059,
-0.0367658697,
0.0147069739,
-0.0035159006,
-0.0141141778,
-0.013129849,
0.0065911291,
0.0454796404,
-0.012023042,
-0.0368193723,
-0.0262967329,
0.0180710237,
-0.0745260715,
0.0482370593,
0.0038584864,
-0.0056967237,
0.0107013965,
-0.0051316228,
-0.1005213782,
0.0332279354,
-0.0342406295,
0.0550556257,
-0.0197041426,
-0.0247770268,
-0.0231765974,
0.0121757081,
0.0290355552,
0.0042273505,
-0.0093739787,
-0.0133702094,
0.0018390989,
-0.022254793,
-0.0116080027,
0.0245578326,
-0.0138980858,
-0.0308281835,
0.0093552377,
0.0188914686,
0.0553569198,
0.0171356108,
-0.035158515,
0.0106462473,
-0.0475205556,
-0.0251321327,
0.0083735343,
-0.0226504896,
0.0045527304,
0.0352930911,
-0.0016459825,
-0.0439041443,
-0.0206757113,
-0.0091357538,
0.0079102451,
-0.0240285788,
-0.026219558,
0.0491931774,
0.0053951177,
0.0548333637,
0.0004075984,
0.0397765674,
0.025117103,
0.0416885801,
-0.0373688191,
0.0204842668,
0.0367066152,
0.0060365684,
-0.0175524596,
-0.0149352448,
-0.033216659,
0.0878451094,
-0.0177326556,
-0.0650652051,
0.0101062357,
0.0168296602,
2.725e-7,
0.1258634776,
0.0188133474,
0.0582258664,
-0.0176896714,
0.0270307939,
-0.0140114436,
0.0231333692,
0.0221075546,
0.0057792468,
-0.0202078745,
0.0295709055,
0.0294448659,
-0.0318675302,
0.0446066745,
-0.0793612227,
-0.0419794992,
-0.083699964,
-0.0852789655,
-0.0027308383,
0.0154604893,
0.0827246383,
0.0205880664,
-0.0075186542,
-0.0023187052,
-0.0152390208,
-0.0011717069,
0.042137485,
0.0223612003,
0.0454354174,
0.0367832705,
-0.0110419672,
0.0093018673,
0.0086096786,
0.0699898601,
-0.0162782948,
-0.0040498981,
0.0057560084,
0.0442010313,
-0.0637659431,
0.00161298,
0.0379328653,
-0.0250291452,
0.0472570434,
-0.0139521705,
0.0452514552,
-0.0570570678,
-0.0307730772,
0.0243380312,
-0.0367225371,
0.014429573,
0.0096835,
-0.0112920115,
-0.0252034348,
0.0337916538,
0.0192994308,
0.0069838963,
-0.0223963168,
-0.0823414847,
0.0287928209,
0.0422733724,
-0.0186433345,
-0.0205228776,
0.0371062644,
-0.0373500511,
0.016237611,
-0.0463113785,
0.0162491631,
2.196054643e-34,
0.0184916742,
0.0380306393,
-0.0253581163,
0.0325852558,
0.0097079435,
-0.0416912735,
-0.0032738924,
-0.0205876157,
-0.0101415813,
-0.0709134638,
-0.0113839526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10994v1 | Information Extraction from Documents: Question Answering vs Token Classification in real-world setups | 2023-04-21T14:43:42 | 2023-04-21T14:43:42 | Laurent Lam, Pirashanth Ratnamogan, Joël Tang, William Vanhuffel, Fabien Caspani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research in Document Intelligence and especially in Document Key Information
Extraction (DocKIE) has been mainly solved as Token Classification problem.
Recent breakthroughs in both natural language processing (NLP) and computer
vision helped building document-focused pre-training methods, leveraging a
multimodal understanding of the document text, layout and image modalities.
However, these breakthroughs also led to the emergence of a new DocKIE subtask
of extractive document Question Answering (DocQA), as part of the Machine
Reading Comprehension (MRC) research field. In this work, we compare the
Question Answering approach with the classical token classification approach
for document key information extraction. We designed experiments to benchmark
five different experimental setups : raw performances, robustness to noisy
environment, capacity to extract long entities, fine-tuning speed on Few-Shot
Learning and finally Zero-Shot Learning. Our research showed that when dealing
with clean and relatively short entities, it is still best to use token
classification-based approach, while the QA approach could be a good
alternative for noisy environment or long entities use-cases. | [
0.0567394644,
-0.0041115126,
0.0141553152,
0.0379032232,
-0.0451149419,
0.0335681625,
0.0304701384,
0.0091154454,
0.0081653511,
-0.0531896316,
-0.0136263333,
0.0077221901,
-0.01895383,
0.0285893697,
0.018356882,
-0.0341070183,
0.0567358732,
-0.010406726,
0.0112164533,
0.0179097895,
0.0036267547,
0.0124821905,
-0.0361969844,
0.0017910432,
-0.0102973767,
-0.0241800025,
-0.0214670692,
-0.0348945595,
0.0102983182,
-0.0025740641,
-0.0204629153,
0.0092679625,
0.0047339257,
0.0292278901,
0.0000016557,
-0.0695258155,
-0.0347020403,
0.0198807325,
-0.0109044248,
-0.0258486196,
0.0245891493,
-0.0311593562,
0.0415545851,
-0.0066260379,
-0.0043101776,
-0.0559790507,
0.0157101341,
0.0775348544,
0.0409233496,
0.0621277764,
-0.0123441834,
-0.013507694,
0.0438126698,
0.0257011931,
0.0604556315,
-0.0853211582,
0.024475662,
-0.008190088,
0.0310049597,
0.0034238433,
-0.0064672129,
0.0343522727,
-0.0032519691,
0.011599021,
0.011580321,
0.0476255417,
-0.0218845122,
-0.0152085768,
-0.0395682529,
0.1095231548,
0.0175055061,
0.0138793848,
-0.0058906656,
0.0190243516,
-0.0055042934,
0.0214539487,
-0.0479547866,
-0.0076021184,
-0.0298435763,
-0.022943534,
0.0133207142,
-0.0245637596,
-0.0283299852,
0.0174465477,
-0.0413629301,
0.0361109525,
0.012823917,
-0.0395537913,
0.0186873991,
-0.0045824638,
-0.0391975492,
-0.0341308899,
0.0224782135,
0.0863993317,
0.0276517253,
0.0070550614,
-0.0262542106,
-0.0743901357,
0.0397797376,
-0.035392236,
-0.0247679036,
0.0349432454,
-0.0300650895,
0.0974004343,
-0.0643704459,
0.053847041,
-0.0012345747,
0.0541404635,
-0.0502008051,
-0.0278592221,
-0.0229584761,
-0.0303440318,
-0.0497046001,
0.0916177705,
-0.0339862481,
-0.0452818349,
0.0164657887,
0.0268112663,
0.0551283658,
0.0323951244,
-0.0317475237,
0.0210322775,
-0.0369300917,
-0.011738278,
-0.0025711057,
0.0188139826,
-0.0850982368,
0.0279909,
-0.0242794696,
0.0034932347,
-0.007711913,
0.0299318396,
0.0297163036,
-0.0461287163,
0.0275676791,
0.0856343955,
-0.0317067318,
-0.0549309403,
0.000202094,
-0.0168311875,
0.0036859813,
-0.0550654493,
-0.0062187319,
-0.0230697971,
0.0528900623,
0.0299256444,
-0.0208527036,
0.042502638,
-0.0126310689,
0.0042497879,
-0.0297652613,
0.0848705694,
-0.0032977248,
-0.0329930186,
0.0860169977,
0.0221885946,
-0.0239274018,
0.054242637,
0.0211180262,
0.0192890689,
0.0637999251,
-0.0066910437,
0.007975026,
0.0206693634,
0.0072240229,
-0.0297985636,
0.0330310501,
0.0528524816,
-0.0074188909,
0.0092466641,
0.0216601752,
0.0346196331,
-0.0261404514,
-0.0324860066,
-0.0007909225,
0.0834057182,
-0.0033879613,
-0.0049200514,
-0.0129949627,
0.0154384933,
0.0314471275,
0.0220896099,
-0.0288608726,
0.0058667646,
0.0048746676,
0.0357179753,
0.0062413309,
-0.0248543154,
-0.024264507,
-0.0049923668,
0.0069341925,
0.0024058046,
-0.014744956,
-0.0227356944,
0.088438645,
0.0034216167,
-0.0719140023,
0.0143702375,
-0.017414771,
-0.0117914863,
-0.0305708144,
-0.05147985,
0.0745658204,
0.0085057151,
0.0477127545,
-0.0544970669,
-0.0310629476,
0.0090269027,
0.0227862336,
0.0137576079,
0.0152909858,
-0.0224826429,
0.0470055155,
-0.036707595,
0.0135547575,
-0.0324849188,
-0.0311549529,
-0.0054675424,
-0.0060118251,
0.0304091591,
-0.0006320992,
-0.0817936584,
0.0228456184,
0.0555773899,
0.0448585898,
-0.0606887937,
0.0004461274,
0.0388448834,
0.0059845066,
0.0145220552,
0.0111381663,
-0.011983511,
0.0369452871,
-0.0433931053,
0.0190204959,
-0.0077301459,
-0.0133881401,
-0.0323437154,
0.0114660598,
-0.0335863084,
0.001801215,
0.0293763317,
-0.035051208,
-0.0229099896,
-0.0079904422,
-0.0227495339,
0.0066649048,
-0.0223782342,
-0.015989488,
-0.0047708401,
0.0114930812,
-0.0517529435,
0.040357355,
0.0153915891,
0.0285647959,
-0.0393633991,
0.0053940504,
0.0101208622,
-0.0003685655,
0.0056778328,
0.0155512802,
0.0006248176,
-0.0187053569,
-0.0034132481,
0.0073758783,
-0.0557218343,
-0.0149044469,
-0.104454495,
0.0251094364,
-0.000707301,
0.0342607535,
0.0140849473,
0.0087089343,
-0.0139141474,
-0.0430628955,
-0.0165379513,
-0.0089775017,
0.0001463707,
0.0050406996,
0.0744123533,
0.0426496305,
0.015224766,
-0.0248776563,
-0.0198868159,
-0.0200551972,
0.0654818565,
0.0331582129,
-0.0171610396,
-0.0157966018,
-0.0181175005,
0.0074280142,
0.0005462285,
0.0025662843,
-0.0158573873,
0.0175902229,
-0.0197100025,
0.0348157473,
0.085410744,
0.0062122908,
0.038506221,
-0.0343884975,
0.0086106369,
-0.053668201,
0.027198378,
-0.0122309802,
0.0264420137,
0.0134970183,
-0.0138711473,
0.0056304107,
0.0274125654,
-0.0186268631,
0.0042230124,
-0.0078127263,
0.070272848,
0.0064416183,
-0.0340164639,
-0.071378082,
0.034488637,
0.0115393922,
0.0369580723,
-0.0242698733,
-0.0145005174,
0.071745716,
-0.0173558667,
-0.0133347977,
-0.0649062172,
0.0302637797,
-0.0436008051,
0.0517899133,
-0.0125196474,
0.0185285099,
-0.0581954196,
-0.0641287714,
0.0030789722,
-0.0281144138,
-0.0269237198,
0.0088135498,
0.0172413196,
0.0052971188,
0.0253151972,
-0.0385610089,
-0.0101214694,
-0.0447506309,
0.009341117,
-0.0187577195,
-0.0198523719,
-0.0235361196,
0.0161938574,
-0.003746303,
0.0425853543,
0.0252773855,
0.0207605381,
-0.042405434,
-0.0205754843,
-0.011160993,
0.1234449744,
0.041523058,
0.021322947,
0.0187062752,
-0.0159684755,
0.0345155895,
0.0609591343,
0.0436033607,
0.0015586265,
0.0265520308,
-0.0019062057,
-0.0004897829,
-0.0531799756,
0.0341073424,
-0.0255859103,
0.0366581455,
-0.0712247267,
-0.0295539293,
0.0691056401,
0.043027997,
-0.0179144461,
-0.0325787291,
-0.0174507797,
-0.0129085453,
0.0000268256,
0.0353261083,
-0.0686948225,
-0.0509819612,
-0.0126287723,
0.0612869263,
0.0029432874,
-0.0171988178,
-0.0058403257,
-0.0558786429,
0.0221958663,
-0.0291274562,
-0.1165300906,
-0.0340529829,
-0.0752473474,
-0.0023962979,
0.0097896373,
0.0179553218,
0.0236566048,
0.0016604109,
-0.0160215367,
-0.0256652869,
0.027725013,
0.0182209238,
0.0066417623,
-0.0177679136,
-0.0488117337,
0.0253030993,
0.0108536752,
-0.0143589955,
0.0055311136,
0.0204269588,
-0.0239906888,
-0.0044430634,
-0.0117452145,
0.0505267233,
-0.0519165248,
0.0027613381,
-0.0376767293,
0.0363766029,
-0.0131903486,
0.0202290379,
0.0425062925,
0.0280214809,
-0.0081263399,
-0.0265835635,
-0.0545084812,
0.0049288832,
-0.0331151374,
0.0688559934,
0.0290971883,
-0.0437159576,
-0.1203078926,
0.0084216585,
0.0124973496,
-0.0994053259,
0.0480331928,
-0.0290860515,
0.0031599242,
0.0090013174,
-0.0711152256,
-0.0708905235,
0.032372728,
0.0450459979,
-0.0357944332,
-0.0034615358,
-0.0078179808,
0.0212405715,
-0.0660570785,
0.0195104908,
0.0175418165,
-0.008383791,
-0.0518364422,
0.027792884,
0.0237086266,
-0.0272226837,
-0.0367679596,
-0.0060159834,
-0.0867497846,
-0.0164973326,
0.004614823,
0.0382050537,
0.0144386971,
0.0278223753,
-0.0142495865,
-0.0398108661,
0.0433677472,
0.0427871272,
-0.066310972,
-0.005433172,
-0.011098342,
-0.0131282974,
-0.0254543349,
0.0081870155,
-0.0436509699,
0.0053508799,
-0.0009021329,
0.0183807053,
-0.034049537,
0.0048169573,
-0.0078687444,
0.047928188,
-0.011547396,
0.0201292764,
0.0014566567,
-0.0151496269,
0.0375524573,
-0.0098343566,
-0.0099780653,
0.0078055882,
-0.021207029,
-0.0232760198,
-0.0336544253,
-0.011326313,
0.0013766243,
-0.0240187272,
0.0588836446,
0.0012982616,
0.0294004716,
0.0317073576,
-0.0002789795,
-0.0092758723,
-0.0410214774,
-0.0411221348,
-0.0070492001,
0.004674057,
0.0690303668,
-0.0250371248,
0.0489277653,
0.027803665,
-0.043135006,
-0.0398055017,
0.0422527418,
-0.0457806885,
-0.0061288262,
-0.0220099017,
0.0895663425,
-0.0026472209,
-0.0158718321,
-0.0319578014,
-0.0165208969,
-0.032866668,
0.0086612077,
-0.0202494152,
0.0020177613,
0.0177437067,
0.0267861169,
0.0390789285,
0.0249322429,
0.0097605512,
0.0518279746,
0.0111312782,
0.007919997,
0.0168106388,
-0.0185328219,
-0.0624553263,
0.017515434,
0.0226807501,
0.050502032,
0.0101609351,
0.0171029307,
-0.0456043892,
-0.0246443506,
0.0364132561,
-0.0080978228,
-0.0075857709,
0.0254621226,
-0.0094870655,
0.0675701723,
0.0527172238,
-0.049649328,
-0.0539334454,
0.033278551,
-0.0320866406,
-0.0241064262,
0.0077107167,
-5.824010271e-33,
-0.0218393933,
-0.0499868505,
0.0206997972,
0.0165057667,
0.0157520995,
0.0130095361,
0.0004773377,
-0.0322171822,
-0.0246179104,
-0.0088543389,
-0.0146104936,
-0.0204650275,
0.0046607126,
0.0411465205,
-0.0414542593,
-0.0037922401,
0.000342275,
-0.0236718319,
-0.0329888761,
0.0190316271,
0.0466262512,
0.0527327769,
0.0226874668,
-0.0202963334,
0.0231608264,
-0.0305969045,
0.0021773316,
0.0200402513,
0.0410134383,
0.0477752946,
-0.0452698283,
0.0263283532,
0.0542974621,
-0.0123312268,
0.0333864875,
0.0800419077,
-0.1454187483,
-0.0352749564,
-0.0090767201,
0.050085973,
-0.0424309783,
-0.0160460137,
0.0270472821,
-0.0131726833,
0.0511756502,
-0.0236735996,
0.041378431,
0.0177590083,
-0.0157233141,
-0.0192004722,
-0.0909323469,
0.0178112462,
-0.0261357743,
0.0017849663,
0.0135979513,
0.025782248,
0.008328204,
0.0590947941,
-0.0812215805,
-0.0492662862,
-0.0026308827,
-0.0186218806,
0.0244103298,
0.0499855503,
-0.0331125334,
0.0059385332,
0.0293304212,
-0.0321505256,
-0.0032787554,
0.0318187848,
0.0438755229,
0.012202153,
0.0340465829,
0.0360442847,
0.0756551325,
0.0085370764,
-0.0754319727,
0.0472906604,
-0.0047875405,
0.0533692874,
0.0026564766,
-0.022536872,
-0.0682023764,
0.0472783186,
-0.0215359796,
0.0334283821,
-0.0697505102,
-0.0040267454,
0.0310537033,
-0.012134444,
-0.0702355802,
-0.0034845565,
0.0467496812,
-0.0085658962,
0.0038565458,
0.0217688084,
-0.0065077278,
0.0444092527,
-0.0097265132,
0.0363143273,
-0.0319825783,
-0.0017226076,
0.030980872,
0.0074614147,
0.0100680087,
-0.0138858911,
0.0214753859,
-0.043381609,
-0.061479874,
-0.0120761907,
0.0082063032,
0.0244920682,
-0.0183648095,
0.0275637563,
0.0065518743,
0.010074012,
-0.0115571991,
0.0461690724,
0.0010125746,
0.0237278715,
-0.0109527335,
-0.0433320738,
-0.0104307011,
0.0245275181,
-0.0288860891,
-0.0027636839,
0.0016720786,
0.0098013878,
-0.0369085409,
-0.0846575573,
0.0235407669,
0.0752427801,
2.436e-7,
0.0362172127,
0.04007129,
0.0801273361,
0.0069445027,
-0.0110175861,
0.0285570677,
0.0147458296,
0.0399511792,
0.0211225431,
0.0034437233,
0.0188542455,
0.0244633425,
0.0066399989,
0.0137348128,
-0.0675365925,
-0.0374124348,
-0.0093565099,
0.0290253516,
-0.0701001361,
0.0331307724,
0.0674486533,
0.037502259,
-0.0281696711,
-0.0339819677,
-0.023082329,
-0.0739832446,
0.0398909375,
0.0335789807,
0.0159920976,
0.026589606,
0.0392809063,
0.0089659151,
0.0247752015,
0.0250474792,
0.0039667431,
0.0096845636,
0.0425512753,
0.0238915849,
-0.0042154645,
-0.0513647422,
-0.0093135862,
-0.0035227865,
0.0240658484,
-0.0604566522,
0.1162906215,
-0.0637502,
-0.0226479769,
-0.0599411465,
-0.0626314953,
-0.0219142176,
-0.0108256657,
-0.0300990343,
-0.0276217163,
0.066995427,
0.0488746688,
-0.060751047,
0.016128635,
-0.0712583736,
0.0336103253,
0.023977356,
-0.0053429171,
0.0133222295,
-0.0287785977,
-0.0343261212,
0.0259649493,
-0.0775694177,
-0.0355488211,
1.761377036e-34,
0.010496987,
-0.0250477605,
-0.0111483326,
0.0515182726,
0.000549208,
-0.0196874067,
-0.0309396666,
-0.0273035392,
0.0146917775,
-0.0702470317,
0.0113783441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10977v1 | Evaluating Transformer Language Models on Arithmetic Operations Using Number Decomposition | 2023-04-21T14:21:52 | 2023-04-21T14:21:52 | Matteo Muffo, Aldo Cocco, Enrico Bertino | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | In recent years, Large Language Models such as GPT-3 showed remarkable
capabilities in performing NLP tasks in the zero and few shot settings. On the
other hand, the experiments highlighted the difficulty of GPT-3 in carrying out
tasks that require a certain degree of reasoning, such as arithmetic
operations. In this paper we evaluate the ability of Transformer Language
Models to perform arithmetic operations following a pipeline that, before
performing computations, decomposes numbers in units, tens, and so on. We
denote the models fine-tuned with this pipeline with the name Calculon and we
test them in the task of performing additions, subtractions and multiplications
on the same test sets of GPT-3. Results show an increase of accuracy of 63% in
the five-digit addition task. Moreover, we demonstrate the importance of the
decomposition pipeline introduced, since fine-tuning the same Language Model
without decomposing numbers results in 0% accuracy in the five-digit addition
task. | [
-0.0270307865,
0.1042921543,
-0.003597093,
0.0191656835,
-0.0210889671,
0.0139791984,
0.0195192844,
-0.0131861586,
-0.0880486444,
-0.0389297679,
-0.035018459,
-0.0074120299,
0.0443494469,
-0.000108799,
0.0174357928,
-0.0352072455,
0.0444704629,
-0.015076302,
-0.0234932061,
0.0369304866,
-0.0397650935,
0.0061830347,
-0.0361392312,
0.0225231051,
0.0133915078,
-0.034434393,
0.0027943454,
-0.0863373801,
0.0033082489,
0.0037000959,
-0.034922801,
0.0013799061,
0.0199826993,
0.0680115968,
0.0000020906,
-0.0159270931,
-0.0179628134,
0.0319430009,
-0.0397625826,
0.0230329148,
0.0394938141,
-0.0566980653,
-0.0082865003,
0.0327603705,
-0.0440842956,
-0.0185284484,
0.0477306731,
0.0302112736,
0.0737861171,
0.074933514,
-0.0190010723,
-0.0578946061,
0.0215864722,
-0.0093568219,
0.010827194,
-0.0052134502,
-0.0160531774,
0.0329248309,
0.021733949,
0.0281158239,
0.0009819737,
-0.0105026113,
0.0656149164,
0.0024193896,
-0.0369237326,
0.0170738902,
-0.0432042331,
-0.0326049589,
-0.0118031511,
0.0189005341,
-0.0491640717,
-0.0351307616,
-0.0065999385,
-0.0081765568,
-0.017903138,
-0.0697462186,
-0.0934015214,
0.0244449675,
0.0595973991,
0.0189908538,
-0.015778549,
-0.0220005773,
0.0152086709,
-0.0202849768,
-0.0285681002,
0.0988858342,
0.0082034292,
-0.0005762324,
-0.0697900355,
-0.0052321865,
-0.0813865066,
-0.0166486427,
0.0127346255,
0.0643190593,
0.0107449852,
-0.0065991678,
-0.0245793276,
-0.0440562814,
-0.0046566478,
-0.0357465781,
0.0252307002,
0.1027694866,
0.0191626139,
0.0250029396,
-0.0544865131,
0.0994432196,
-0.0351132974,
0.0041649831,
-0.0157147795,
0.0246633347,
0.0172986519,
-0.0254988912,
-0.0334913693,
0.0447091125,
-0.038416177,
0.018985169,
-0.0355624333,
0.0346179046,
-0.0041393428,
0.0210169051,
0.049604807,
-0.0333067663,
0.0101394886,
-0.0340189561,
-0.005458029,
0.0497597493,
-0.0187245794,
0.0005348488,
-0.0131788207,
-0.0553742424,
-0.0177024193,
-0.0087461127,
-0.0194180012,
-0.0235007424,
0.021676844,
0.0536188744,
-0.004259292,
-0.0003492254,
-0.0071146665,
-0.0106083686,
0.0367727168,
-0.0455468036,
0.0163164847,
-0.0764428601,
0.0148284528,
0.0389631838,
0.0029286449,
0.0111269215,
0.0178694166,
0.0276619215,
0.0296299718,
0.0471644886,
0.0318639614,
0.0097162565,
0.0006911056,
-0.0265702587,
0.0054136086,
0.0508531369,
0.0464704223,
-0.0291309897,
-0.0182322655,
-0.0234479271,
0.0168612469,
0.0722138956,
-0.0134506291,
-0.0209970511,
-0.0334067382,
-0.0198331084,
-0.0150618181,
0.0101320073,
0.0262914263,
0.0780341923,
-0.0513580665,
-0.0154304905,
0.0310074836,
0.0284884796,
0.0234362949,
0.0566428155,
0.0441034697,
-0.0130739966,
0.0212391503,
-0.0120940674,
-0.0721317604,
0.0070984634,
-0.0193975084,
0.0012919015,
-0.0233295262,
0.0529933386,
-0.0218912605,
-0.044734627,
-0.0164081231,
-0.0234990828,
0.0547131673,
-0.0101680085,
0.0501098186,
0.0097298333,
-0.0102985231,
0.0883523747,
-0.0183811523,
-0.0855246484,
-0.018949924,
-0.0709650367,
0.0026407219,
-0.013290884,
0.0534757338,
-0.0111066764,
0.0138781695,
-0.0215885006,
-0.047076378,
-0.0189559031,
0.0472591519,
0.0076451548,
-0.011046472,
-0.0441401228,
0.0047981655,
0.0054042274,
0.0384302363,
-0.0150633482,
0.0224985573,
-0.0176744815,
0.0152748916,
-0.0398592986,
0.0510434732,
0.0039972202,
-0.021153314,
-0.0574994683,
0.0010543488,
-0.0079794675,
-0.0499908589,
0.0025505375,
0.0257421136,
0.0518255048,
0.0164907519,
0.0022233154,
-0.040559046,
0.0032894458,
-0.0340142138,
0.0049825534,
0.0808220208,
0.0080902381,
-0.0066156359,
0.0377707332,
-0.0042691124,
-0.0366341025,
0.0600496195,
-0.073510848,
0.0288309604,
-0.028083371,
0.0609633029,
-0.0237600114,
-0.0308547691,
-0.017652249,
0.0635886565,
-0.0216561649,
0.0316366367,
0.0111499848,
-0.0235098749,
0.0172290523,
0.0238863323,
-0.0401527993,
0.0032658002,
0.0056079999,
0.0180458594,
0.0195996109,
-0.0062887608,
0.0126536563,
-0.0322526842,
-0.0618794635,
-0.0249003246,
-0.033411622,
0.0742283463,
0.0365819223,
0.0305580515,
0.0287037101,
-0.0151084876,
-0.0179801062,
-0.0010465329,
0.0166811626,
0.0053569241,
0.0112496084,
-0.0086993836,
0.0033205859,
-0.0058240374,
-0.036491245,
-0.0411146022,
0.0535284914,
0.0002505197,
0.0233145356,
-0.0199004617,
0.0357896648,
0.024680404,
0.0411252677,
-0.0000386688,
-0.0030514605,
0.0009514456,
-0.0217826422,
0.0499422252,
0.0175435878,
-0.04834041,
0.0357829109,
0.0174993295,
0.0114395572,
-0.0159505736,
-0.0011364589,
-0.0252925884,
-0.0280248225,
-0.0142914113,
-0.0034065505,
-0.0420060083,
0.1083154157,
-0.0345813259,
-0.0069818418,
-0.0174008999,
0.0184387956,
-0.0107250605,
0.0190332141,
0.0202053934,
0.0037512067,
-0.0198377892,
0.0146957049,
-0.0078755151,
-0.0115525676,
0.0198781081,
-0.0104341088,
-0.0536789112,
-0.0619216561,
0.020835463,
-0.05581709,
0.0521159917,
0.035856735,
-0.0183888152,
-0.0234437305,
-0.022821622,
-0.0380384997,
0.0234170705,
0.0257279463,
-0.0375000387,
0.1180101782,
-0.0179064106,
0.0201624446,
-0.0234642085,
-0.0559377819,
-0.0455227308,
0.0266004037,
-0.0269603375,
0.0906652436,
-0.0013879068,
-0.054711137,
-0.0485329926,
0.012100568,
0.0756584406,
0.0836941525,
-0.0228599422,
-0.0236231983,
-0.0279393233,
0.0319504589,
0.0094812168,
0.0070337239,
0.0285065621,
-0.0159454718,
0.0355406627,
0.0095623508,
0.0755011365,
0.0227921866,
-0.0625321791,
0.0025107262,
0.0393727943,
-0.0469522476,
-0.0421718843,
0.0404068641,
0.0171647314,
-0.0693559721,
-0.0324638113,
0.0884924233,
0.0330142938,
-0.0490409359,
0.0197135992,
-0.037127018,
-0.0212402605,
0.0372151434,
0.0208239798,
-0.0772438496,
-0.00432471,
0.010951044,
-0.049737528,
-0.0077710906,
-0.0288591851,
0.0017551248,
-0.1239686087,
0.0042632315,
0.0162251778,
-0.0389847867,
-0.0392713025,
-0.0626859739,
-0.0055896556,
-0.0208237469,
0.0349100567,
0.031740427,
-0.0238686614,
0.006515767,
-0.0098812291,
-0.0265129264,
-0.0254336242,
0.0161880795,
0.033524882,
-0.0082154367,
0.0395635106,
-0.0108926417,
-0.0492797494,
-0.0843195096,
0.0419416316,
0.0227628052,
-0.0177316628,
0.031294018,
-0.0214999076,
0.0458832905,
-0.0162671842,
0.0058400258,
0.0053400095,
-0.044167731,
-0.0051872521,
-0.0479769483,
0.109828271,
-0.0553540438,
-0.0033814111,
0.0181324668,
-0.0334443115,
-0.024973141,
0.0146167018,
0.0236018486,
-0.0076427814,
-0.0378108397,
-0.0396203101,
-0.0239787996,
-0.0128350602,
-0.0574007742,
-0.0110291606,
0.0846377015,
-0.0666183829,
-0.0211620182,
0.0022292496,
0.0300496183,
0.0145874945,
-0.0218522903,
-0.0613478422,
0.075195156,
-0.017737912,
-0.0511545837,
0.0006182193,
-0.0092267497,
0.0586119592,
-0.0484334975,
0.0382854566,
0.0281925257,
0.0125413742,
-0.0163961872,
0.0011035368,
-0.1254758686,
-0.0428306833,
0.0131750125,
0.0612114891,
0.0321910121,
-0.0412767269,
-0.0142910313,
-0.0255683903,
-0.0393214636,
0.0294678472,
-0.1099629551,
0.0259546917,
-0.011090192,
-0.012947428,
0.0103431642,
-0.0150112249,
0.010606451,
0.0285384804,
-0.0046183979,
0.0212823227,
-0.0752655193,
0.0145342983,
0.0501217581,
0.0299101304,
0.0123910084,
0.0188981052,
0.0825870782,
0.0284946132,
0.000614906,
-0.0534835532,
0.0361374989,
-0.0416134559,
-0.014041909,
0.0106502827,
0.037902914,
-0.0022123074,
-0.0213920381,
0.0133422436,
0.0073840562,
0.0041251765,
0.0436245538,
0.0106320949,
0.0429465398,
0.0059147128,
-0.0258400124,
0.016039053,
-0.0353670977,
0.0128712161,
0.0296505596,
-0.0026340606,
0.0597873405,
-0.0025596167,
0.0238641556,
-0.0400123596,
0.03038132,
-0.0270982515,
-0.0618252866,
-0.0238615796,
-0.0198027343,
-0.0046673794,
0.0257861931,
0.0146789802,
-0.0586461984,
-0.0039229374,
-0.0227745492,
0.0034709298,
0.0094240885,
-0.0038602776,
-0.0002189602,
0.0404856764,
-0.0035108484,
-0.0734577402,
0.0182863045,
-0.0557672344,
0.0150664151,
0.0098425793,
0.0162420049,
0.0002125175,
-0.0503469855,
-0.031041801,
-0.0191455726,
-0.0218724161,
0.0157571323,
-0.0582745709,
-0.0532498881,
-0.041040536,
0.0155443018,
0.00475513,
-0.0433202945,
0.0518033206,
0.0387832858,
-0.0490837097,
-0.0099242991,
-0.0094473744,
0.0013253713,
0.0017474372,
-0.0090743098,
-0.0814593062,
-5.761075406e-33,
-0.0127587104,
-0.0323436148,
0.0603218116,
0.0335562788,
0.011073418,
-0.0212632306,
-0.0117971292,
0.0509462655,
-0.0120678255,
-0.0101025188,
-0.0235891435,
0.0170158129,
0.0082308305,
0.0082837818,
0.0025313694,
0.0073786797,
0.0616686121,
-0.0348542407,
-0.0626599789,
-0.0183256418,
-0.0050768834,
-0.012460554,
0.1124432385,
-0.0276773181,
0.0043533519,
0.0248740166,
-0.0211476255,
-0.0032686205,
0.0006140366,
0.0575279482,
0.0000872815,
0.0482579321,
0.0144180404,
-0.0950999111,
-0.0432348773,
0.0128960451,
-0.0359818116,
-0.0351327248,
0.0085884854,
0.04970349,
0.0049550934,
-0.0052053202,
0.0146864988,
-0.015603614,
-0.0411655866,
-0.0104394946,
-0.0224138163,
-0.0117673716,
0.0275065303,
0.0114581259,
-0.0404794589,
0.0222873483,
0.0310421549,
-0.006718915,
0.0579365306,
0.0132958367,
-0.0656946898,
-0.0209942926,
-0.0421696082,
0.0313660242,
0.0599860959,
0.0329018608,
0.0247113761,
-0.0330574289,
-0.0119641693,
-0.0048715053,
0.0344627909,
0.0009190314,
-0.035702575,
-0.0043743411,
0.0532544404,
0.0230463818,
0.0720413476,
-0.0150470221,
0.0811662078,
0.029114347,
-0.0220110565,
0.0329368822,
0.044726897,
0.0488791242,
-0.0098845828,
-0.0132706081,
0.0026888957,
0.0088106077,
-0.0165596083,
0.0240374245,
-0.0549611524,
-0.0087750331,
-0.0339618735,
-0.0024267598,
0.044736933,
0.0369695388,
0.0154293384,
-0.031600561,
0.012372179,
0.049152419,
-0.0033918798,
0.0603876673,
0.0095501831,
0.0292047039,
-0.020454146,
-0.0139393816,
-0.0127734989,
0.018153945,
0.026376389,
0.0109213395,
-0.0290288981,
0.0628040507,
-0.0871150494,
-0.0139214899,
-0.0365034416,
0.0040985839,
0.0039191172,
0.0633250549,
0.005000554,
0.0126524717,
0.014666602,
-0.012824866,
-0.0468420014,
-0.0536516197,
-0.0213574078,
0.0446311384,
0.0231043939,
0.0447241105,
0.0055770823,
-0.04844217,
-0.0452484675,
0.0519984141,
0.0248131733,
-0.0237049982,
-0.0184376817,
-0.0040939967,
2.83e-7,
0.052532088,
0.0249357242,
0.0212342702,
0.0252704229,
0.027418511,
0.0302771144,
0.012662054,
0.0121370386,
-0.0122259911,
-0.0149238063,
0.0028521908,
-0.0255667008,
-0.0117910206,
0.0201461781,
0.0014773565,
0.0179276746,
0.0018175766,
0.0209173914,
-0.0181260649,
0.0038942099,
-0.0052414332,
0.0750315636,
0.0289888512,
0.0139232548,
-0.0120100491,
0.0018441702,
0.0217840578,
-0.0044589713,
-0.0013147341,
-0.0035148347,
0.0140875727,
0.0288151726,
0.0176195223,
-0.0127926003,
-0.0025814427,
0.0400174595,
0.0283974092,
0.0871968493,
-0.0170820821,
0.0050998689,
0.0052924892,
-0.0532442108,
-0.058516454,
-0.042707406,
0.0348586254,
-0.0530450307,
-0.0314925723,
-0.0099100061,
0.0013676693,
0.011607958,
-0.0205042977,
0.0061400337,
0.0078723812,
0.0184248984,
0.0415784009,
-0.0046394407,
0.0016137601,
-0.036451824,
-0.0446959995,
0.0215259362,
-0.0541913919,
-0.0540647805,
-0.038520623,
-0.0170012768,
0.0202236474,
-0.0047920272,
-0.020039754,
2.851974062e-34,
0.0412219726,
-0.0080488687,
0.0324839316,
0.0561470129,
-0.0006888963,
-0.0065031801,
-0.0130334655,
0.0432881936,
0.0324764475,
-0.0383928418,
-0.0004317971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10973v1 | LEIA: Linguistic Embeddings for the Identification of Affect | 2023-04-21T14:17:10 | 2023-04-21T14:17:10 | Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, Lukas Malik, Hannah Metzler, Nikolas Haimerl, Anna Di Natale, David Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The wealth of text data generated by social media has enabled new kinds of
analysis of emotions with language models. These models are often trained on
small and costly datasets of text annotations produced by readers who guess the
emotions expressed by others in social media posts. This affects the quality of
emotion identification methods due to training data size limitations and noise
in the production of labels used in model development. We present LEIA, a model
for emotion identification in text that has been trained on a dataset of more
than 6 million posts with self-annotated emotion labels for happiness,
affection, sadness, anger, and fear. LEIA is based on a word masking method
that enhances the learning of emotion words during model pre-training. LEIA
achieves macro-F1 values of approximately 73 on three in-domain test datasets,
outperforming other supervised and unsupervised methods in a strong benchmark
that shows that LEIA generalizes across posts, users, and time periods. We
further perform an out-of-domain evaluation on five different datasets of
social media and other sources, showing LEIA's robust performance across media,
data collection methods, and annotation schemes. Our results show that LEIA
generalizes its classification of anger, happiness, and sadness beyond the
domain it was trained on. LEIA can be applied in future research to provide
better identification of emotions in text from the perspective of the writer.
The models produced for this article are publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/LEIA | [
0.0382608101,
0.0866179392,
-0.0071594003,
0.0484736376,
0.0101559907,
0.0371609852,
-0.0072152806,
0.0097564925,
0.0809784979,
-0.0660496652,
-0.0025634835,
0.0019304275,
-0.0444734246,
-0.0104279807,
-0.0056135077,
-0.0626911968,
0.031823568,
0.0719285458,
0.0494466648,
-0.0153317451,
0.0461434387,
0.0302288961,
0.0244994964,
0.0226627812,
-0.0596846975,
-0.0261903666,
0.0162676126,
-0.0124574387,
0.0268690456,
-0.0140533112,
0.0672931075,
0.0552230515,
0.025415156,
0.034424305,
0.0000021161,
0.0095431283,
-0.0197515823,
-0.0147654405,
0.0190163422,
-0.0067514786,
0.1070881262,
-0.041183494,
0.0079743788,
0.0054331077,
-0.0241169687,
-0.0234894603,
0.0480186641,
0.0383813754,
0.0588407218,
0.0628554448,
-0.0387354381,
-0.0347131193,
-0.0225582831,
-0.0064458479,
0.0012847107,
-0.0010582024,
0.0314944498,
-0.0226577371,
-0.0246646442,
-0.0513096415,
-0.0213997122,
0.0240846649,
-0.0109240701,
0.0194749609,
0.0116565926,
0.0061967424,
-0.0107479859,
-0.0190275908,
-0.0017375627,
0.0808471367,
-0.0568808764,
-0.0268676132,
-0.01234766,
-0.0084724231,
-0.0054836832,
0.0006852743,
-0.0085167466,
-0.0035295158,
0.015632486,
0.0415649302,
-0.0032830441,
0.0271323286,
0.0290334746,
0.0270488132,
0.0162892509,
0.0174878221,
-0.0182484705,
-0.0243932419,
0.0303998459,
0.0027838161,
-0.051971972,
-0.0296368711,
0.0203848239,
-0.0005950367,
0.0326679498,
0.0195918791,
-0.0771484897,
-0.0422701426,
-0.0243250187,
-0.0667600036,
-0.0233810563,
0.0043799086,
-0.0346724205,
0.0185033102,
0.007433977,
0.0069511579,
0.0219747536,
-0.0156765152,
-0.0291012339,
0.0050852201,
-0.0334702134,
0.0001948062,
-0.0094224904,
0.0380625315,
-0.0380262993,
-0.0356900319,
-0.0680577084,
-0.0105977161,
-0.0428376682,
0.0204000883,
-0.0409547314,
-0.000520499,
0.0277894922,
0.0095893098,
0.0148229431,
-0.0075836815,
-0.0312801488,
0.0118047558,
-0.0383011959,
-0.0314492919,
0.0081008123,
0.0017014962,
0.0334189013,
-0.027921563,
0.0346952714,
0.0496852323,
0.0165574625,
-0.0713094249,
-0.0389450118,
-0.021142235,
0.0133055421,
-0.0479440615,
0.0141783636,
-0.0308121126,
0.0537077226,
-0.0099690659,
0.0228587426,
-0.0462441705,
0.0275360476,
0.0068881209,
-0.0379549488,
0.0795351863,
-0.01657301,
-0.0150240464,
-0.0137864165,
0.0278762914,
0.036337927,
0.0538344346,
0.0316951983,
0.0717942715,
0.0966103971,
-0.0133126378,
0.0456390232,
0.0114211757,
0.0096074026,
-0.0124964528,
-0.0076650498,
-0.0365145989,
-0.0249004662,
0.0083653321,
0.0091163283,
0.017265182,
-0.0241345,
-0.0365216173,
0.0394574516,
0.0531346686,
-0.0320958309,
0.0386162922,
0.0016022107,
0.0348718837,
0.0354939289,
-0.045512218,
-0.0084107341,
0.0172172301,
-0.0412178114,
-0.0332063921,
-0.0072593256,
-0.0182832759,
-0.0216842871,
-0.0339395069,
-0.051536642,
-0.0425790995,
0.0315951966,
0.0060085282,
0.0022760483,
-0.0038306392,
-0.0443632901,
0.0119629707,
0.0446023755,
-0.0713837892,
-0.0228301641,
-0.0116722835,
0.0063925297,
0.0419607535,
0.0031311121,
-0.0677927136,
-0.0225875173,
-0.0476557277,
0.0449277163,
0.0169347133,
0.0068366206,
-0.0062254067,
0.0164541975,
-0.0527845025,
0.0385234058,
-0.0281556509,
0.0131630395,
0.0076675247,
-0.0014088373,
0.0484475605,
0.0010768897,
-0.0009644632,
0.0017158391,
0.048908256,
-0.0336328633,
-0.0716860667,
0.0101201236,
0.0543781631,
0.0005040616,
0.030456597,
-0.009535417,
-0.0377031155,
0.0257582124,
-0.0031877528,
-0.0322293863,
0.0150306523,
0.0484748557,
-0.0534366779,
0.0352629088,
-0.0072847675,
-0.0155675458,
0.067574814,
-0.0565903001,
0.0097927265,
0.0408167392,
-0.0052696224,
0.0330492258,
-0.0177731067,
-0.0051056799,
-0.0413789637,
0.0548819825,
0.0112940893,
0.0429163836,
-0.0263624899,
0.0123087214,
-0.0564568974,
-0.0209093615,
0.02303987,
0.0026218111,
-0.0765196159,
-0.0180628616,
0.0180914681,
0.0050132899,
-0.0172416884,
-0.0070589622,
-0.0486629717,
-0.0793570876,
-0.0787730962,
0.0019964413,
-0.017046731,
0.0009523123,
-0.0255433973,
-0.0155911818,
-0.0289018713,
0.0031191125,
-0.0074140159,
0.0178524889,
-0.0062134862,
0.0146954674,
0.0006674475,
-0.0454595126,
0.0286412612,
-0.0918179601,
-0.0012770881,
-0.0354259387,
0.0387158282,
0.005003443,
-0.0323173292,
0.0037240803,
-0.0131824166,
-0.0447902232,
0.0485707857,
-0.0058156899,
-0.0655251369,
-0.0219553765,
0.0048768227,
-0.0138482805,
0.054129757,
-0.0203543715,
0.1008794904,
0.0267672185,
0.0224250164,
-0.0159104969,
0.0463474691,
-0.0429508314,
0.0237544887,
-0.0217023343,
-0.000563996,
-0.0427506119,
0.0292735212,
0.0174901616,
-0.0128468666,
-0.0479928106,
0.0305949394,
-0.0188388694,
-0.0224975105,
-0.0197764803,
-0.0124497609,
-0.0003798232,
-0.0155393509,
-0.0119104814,
-0.0509588644,
0.0138323419,
0.042169176,
-0.0196105912,
-0.0522943772,
-0.016763106,
-0.0211472288,
0.0472474955,
-0.0124404142,
0.0192608219,
0.0027808901,
0.040411707,
0.0122339893,
-0.0249839351,
-0.0386340357,
-0.0681669563,
-0.0301889181,
0.0191243626,
-0.0356627479,
0.0354176909,
-0.0490925424,
-0.0261228979,
-0.0950884447,
-0.0630144775,
-0.0484489016,
-0.0039774403,
-0.004288523,
-0.0060543208,
-0.0387429707,
0.012642418,
-0.0423187762,
-0.0049332739,
-0.032102149,
0.0118465777,
0.0315442011,
0.0568218231,
-0.0432872325,
0.0412411839,
-0.0012092341,
0.0008520556,
0.025500223,
0.0126763452,
0.0050807185,
0.0014802652,
0.0238408707,
0.0103707686,
0.0236287508,
-0.0058936859,
-0.029099727,
0.0212423727,
0.0127367442,
0.0295551587,
0.1288741231,
0.0445203669,
-0.0116700996,
0.0275330283,
-0.0091958903,
-0.0052335225,
0.0449911729,
0.0285701361,
-0.0514037162,
-0.0311253779,
-0.0153988982,
0.0317645147,
0.0141194807,
-0.0189362466,
-0.0128238434,
-0.0884282142,
0.0253833085,
-0.0061092125,
0.006617506,
-0.0261087064,
-0.0232178345,
0.0211313367,
-0.0092422236,
-0.0341485478,
-0.0785293132,
0.0139904525,
0.0073387483,
0.0016471224,
-0.0211683568,
-0.0420712978,
0.0255294442,
-0.016652232,
0.0456615984,
-0.0108824568,
0.1098963842,
-0.0073385187,
-0.0458140299,
0.0307592973,
0.0338306688,
-0.0143282861,
-0.0223472696,
0.1023734063,
-0.0382207483,
-0.0240436327,
-0.0312132034,
0.0576887392,
-0.0365432203,
-0.0059616095,
-0.0093030445,
0.0665500388,
0.0306384899,
-0.0362155885,
-0.0090192053,
0.0120781334,
0.0577613339,
0.0438315719,
0.0276871566,
-0.0553079024,
-0.0190617889,
-0.0146077294,
0.0376191586,
-0.0018533362,
-0.0295514408,
-0.0088144187,
-0.0029134999,
-0.0390700698,
-0.0578219481,
-0.0916893259,
0.0357606858,
0.0291141085,
-0.0005589623,
-0.0397356786,
0.0127233397,
-0.0252350066,
-0.0598505475,
0.0372406505,
0.0033373497,
0.0298810899,
0.0193814691,
-0.0009281457,
0.0216810815,
-0.0038364797,
-0.0198596846,
-0.0131848222,
-0.0434608944,
-0.0585341677,
0.0405106135,
0.0128178662,
0.007388968,
-0.0027884569,
0.0029211682,
-0.0961557552,
0.048458118,
0.0538307577,
-0.0183223467,
0.0300028715,
0.0567468368,
0.0199995749,
0.0068916669,
0.0317632742,
-0.030535616,
0.0248512849,
0.0225141011,
-0.025371246,
0.0034152069,
-0.0111042671,
-0.0285600722,
0.0027817558,
0.0485712402,
0.0101407925,
-0.03632975,
-0.0420099646,
-0.0505370907,
-0.0104903057,
-0.0282474235,
-0.0390467681,
-0.026675025,
0.0182966199,
0.0290677492,
-0.0903632417,
-0.0361200124,
0.003181621,
0.0098158503,
-0.0231721047,
0.0352319218,
0.0149829369,
0.0152182421,
-0.027699912,
0.0456278399,
0.0050815935,
-0.0159948412,
-0.0059633777,
-0.0239514336,
-0.0031994132,
0.025192434,
-0.0102629568,
-0.0106424456,
-0.035031762,
0.0340840295,
0.008480778,
0.0244390499,
-0.0217643268,
-0.0119441608,
0.0447143987,
-0.0694807619,
0.0566254482,
-0.0406845212,
-0.0024814443,
0.0099922419,
0.0055240267,
-0.0638129711,
-0.0682417378,
0.0296348203,
-0.0103371451,
-0.0510988347,
-0.0089306654,
0.0444192812,
-0.0342432894,
0.0743708462,
0.0461762846,
-0.0135434326,
-0.0501434915,
0.0298686065,
0.0786172673,
0.0303526353,
0.0275347419,
0.0576634854,
-0.0605131648,
-0.0648373365,
0.0637517273,
-0.0602971427,
-0.0257768147,
0.0248566512,
-0.0036200914,
0.0231560767,
-0.0011549158,
0.0190387536,
-0.0753213838,
0.018645063,
-0.0465541184,
-0.0589083806,
0.003653896,
-6.025873508e-33,
0.0306065194,
-0.0075973361,
-0.0486034341,
0.0296957232,
-0.0271326061,
0.0447767936,
0.0062524974,
0.0228876304,
-0.0100126062,
0.0618563406,
-0.0279889256,
0.0267974194,
-0.0029201002,
0.0036074657,
-0.0276766177,
-0.0121711222,
-0.0047298302,
-0.019272944,
0.0071828077,
0.0063957283,
0.0352481082,
0.0499359667,
0.0611658432,
-0.1207813546,
-0.0003633995,
0.0212865416,
-0.0129076457,
0.0110789333,
0.0692745596,
0.0419987552,
-0.0404741354,
0.077668719,
0.008375328,
0.0407761224,
0.007003441,
0.0515887439,
-0.0124814007,
-0.046342358,
-0.0253794659,
0.0052319546,
-0.0247004461,
-0.0376424864,
0.0261241961,
0.0079589365,
-0.022748787,
-0.0213385615,
0.0199598912,
0.0052450555,
0.0277750008,
-0.0403585248,
-0.0651708692,
0.0245998427,
-0.0125908693,
-0.0130712315,
0.0603127368,
0.0085136592,
0.0318197459,
0.0281941779,
-0.0733261555,
-0.0013524396,
-0.030040564,
-0.019858744,
-0.0093341973,
-0.0290773958,
0.0095377248,
0.0804489627,
0.0390352011,
0.0283389855,
-0.0191954467,
0.0601220541,
0.0277604777,
0.0367436484,
0.0628576651,
0.0663208812,
0.0220261402,
-0.0637292564,
-0.0260228198,
0.0107935974,
0.0069194809,
-0.0098456033,
0.0700148344,
0.0091457674,
-0.0452976227,
0.0145134218,
-0.0307764877,
-0.0145584913,
-0.024252547,
-0.0112322429,
0.0166830365,
-0.0141693605,
-0.02273627,
-0.0174490716,
-0.0346513875,
-0.0502046719,
-0.0244425703,
0.0591975451,
-0.0385599993,
0.0839767158,
0.0050526736,
0.0308355726,
-0.0154809598,
-0.0237864796,
0.013824448,
0.032703761,
0.0736458749,
-0.0467762239,
0.0371411219,
0.0498772934,
-0.0616980754,
0.0021795793,
-0.0239291396,
0.0348821655,
0.0149927372,
0.0170286018,
-0.0231000166,
0.0381359495,
-0.0035307885,
-0.0016699326,
0.0368993394,
0.0310105719,
0.00152977,
-0.0105996681,
-0.0133397942,
-0.0021124112,
-0.0356404968,
-0.0196632072,
-0.001453733,
0.0078061167,
0.0255092923,
-0.0519150905,
0.0195304826,
-0.0263745692,
2.781e-7,
0.0118433852,
0.0728913769,
-0.0050050989,
-0.0026183994,
0.0213623773,
0.0441802032,
0.0165171269,
0.0514190458,
0.0158726834,
0.0023047598,
0.0183029175,
0.0115735307,
0.0471359007,
0.0013054209,
-0.0497989357,
0.0137491981,
-0.0005218593,
0.0062028938,
-0.0098841628,
-0.0156787764,
0.0692401379,
0.1010822728,
0.0989441201,
0.010070744,
-0.0131535623,
0.0148144495,
0.0312975645,
-0.0470911264,
-0.001354701,
0.0209568404,
0.0047507631,
0.0088899303,
-0.0058655995,
-0.0519323871,
-0.0241417252,
-0.0065002171,
0.0333079137,
0.0635520965,
0.0063051032,
-0.0200321022,
0.0456175394,
0.0320522003,
-0.0315123089,
-0.0248428248,
0.0604254119,
-0.0533740595,
-0.0328370556,
-0.0437716804,
-0.0076135318,
-0.016393723,
0.05557945,
-0.0389728248,
-0.0457779467,
0.0345967673,
0.0141173666,
-0.014758369,
-0.0110711595,
-0.1134387627,
-0.0282500833,
0.034507513,
-0.0320801809,
0.0370027646,
-0.0145253818,
0.0267753489,
0.0324774832,
-0.0402904116,
0.0492364205,
2.421436629e-34,
-0.0140613066,
-0.0258164965,
-0.0055969218,
0.0024457786,
0.0284579247,
0.0355617702,
-0.0274024867,
-0.0229726173,
0.0386941731,
-0.0489067435,
0.0294283703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10859v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10859v2 | Text2Time: Transformer-based Article Time Period Prediction | 2023-04-21T10:05:03 | 2023-04-24T03:56:03 | Karthick Prasad Gunasekaran, B Chase Babrich, Saurabh Shirodkar, Hee Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of predicting the publication period of text documents, such as news
articles, is an important but less studied problem in the field of natural
language processing. Predicting the year of a news article can be useful in
various contexts, such as historical research, sentiment analysis, and media
monitoring. In this work, we investigate the problem of predicting the
publication period of a text document, specifically a news article, based on
its textual content. In order to do so, we created our own extensive labeled
dataset of over 350,000 news articles published by The New York Times over six
decades. In our approach, we use a pretrained BERT model fine-tuned for the
task of text classification, specifically for time period prediction.This model
exceeds our expectations and provides some very impressive results in terms of
accurately classifying news articles into their respective publication decades.
The results beat the performance of the baseline model for this relatively
unexplored task of time prediction from text. | [
0.0466420986,
0.0848032832,
0.0082634427,
-0.0044482239,
-0.041474916,
0.0212616567,
0.0384963453,
0.0498449877,
-0.0068159238,
-0.0785663426,
0.0154530518,
0.0123284077,
-0.0182144605,
-0.0201299693,
-0.0670220628,
-0.0150978286,
0.0490393341,
0.0203209184,
0.0237109885,
0.0272688642,
0.00391756,
0.0099070268,
0.0132260928,
0.0339139998,
-0.022813024,
-0.0120879309,
-0.0142097864,
-0.0014359007,
-0.0082254903,
-0.0186389182,
0.035812296,
0.0496850014,
0.0696654618,
0.0634756982,
0.0000016516,
-0.0068146009,
-0.0363500454,
-0.0093647912,
0.0105966171,
0.0375993438,
0.0548377298,
-0.021876134,
-0.0039238771,
0.018849859,
-0.0678086728,
-0.0120652039,
0.0133584104,
0.0485097952,
0.0385267921,
0.1047001109,
-0.0268816594,
-0.0078954902,
0.0388509594,
0.0037803578,
0.0300780497,
-0.035770867,
0.014816286,
-0.0432829149,
0.0043863868,
0.0113180317,
0.0054212902,
0.0018485195,
0.013343323,
-0.0003001007,
-0.0060035107,
0.045346722,
-0.0661437809,
0.0155565189,
-0.0193495136,
-0.024095213,
0.0046147569,
-0.0761028826,
0.0095292348,
0.0280539356,
-0.0544459708,
0.0038441448,
0.0028387301,
-0.0574971624,
-0.0074334457,
0.0056845662,
0.013267166,
0.0018700513,
-0.0043260949,
0.0180419646,
-0.0376865119,
0.0899724141,
0.0022972585,
-0.0280783549,
-0.0075612236,
-0.0017626929,
0.045479808,
-0.0196728818,
0.0282191057,
0.0188780297,
0.0398922823,
-0.0121544059,
-0.0295528453,
-0.0453927442,
-0.0244315639,
-0.0814337805,
-0.0334243365,
-0.0159121305,
-0.0109048765,
0.0222245473,
-0.0177824292,
0.0224478375,
0.0049102968,
-0.0251084976,
-0.0116633475,
-0.0025931208,
-0.0784523562,
0.0063900393,
-0.0114824641,
-0.0183497537,
0.0235051159,
-0.0186186545,
-0.0389544182,
-0.0065009841,
0.0360302851,
-0.0068973862,
0.0217098687,
0.0186218098,
-0.0667390004,
-0.0195964556,
-0.0335970968,
0.0415578634,
0.0050965743,
0.0105659282,
-0.0640085191,
-0.0028551116,
0.0047895978,
0.033371266,
0.0156333838,
-0.0381280445,
0.0156763066,
-0.0061069927,
-0.0563252233,
-0.0256059263,
-0.0695789233,
0.0182423685,
-0.0131279733,
-0.0092861308,
0.0336796008,
-0.0321687348,
0.0035009307,
0.0181456096,
-0.008516659,
0.0208245851,
-0.0011227037,
-0.0169105772,
-0.019647859,
0.0660245717,
0.0109303789,
0.0061062542,
0.0851632655,
-0.0215956438,
0.0445506684,
0.0380832255,
0.0581273809,
0.038827423,
0.0386569314,
-0.0044889171,
0.0154461162,
0.0540575832,
0.0058738017,
-0.0198669285,
-0.0271430891,
-0.0013884219,
-0.0569313429,
0.0115897488,
-0.0191469286,
-0.0071504037,
0.0244126674,
-0.0056779804,
0.071885705,
0.0038093231,
0.0058536357,
0.0456924736,
0.0385889709,
-0.0170878563,
0.0298857354,
-0.0333984569,
0.0018740834,
0.0183419213,
-0.0104067214,
0.0095008761,
-0.0631436929,
0.0017812984,
-0.0291557461,
-0.0196575746,
-0.0088066664,
-0.0159832127,
0.0224347133,
-0.0531578474,
0.0542791598,
-0.0108235804,
-0.0647462308,
0.0933328047,
0.0047311909,
0.0012169976,
0.0085334629,
-0.0074886605,
0.024087932,
0.038164489,
0.0380337536,
-0.0422648266,
-0.0023362164,
-0.0428123847,
0.0580804683,
0.033205539,
0.0128339166,
-0.0039044654,
-0.0331127308,
-0.0462535582,
-0.0291866791,
0.0403639041,
0.0304754004,
-0.0179122221,
0.0413607433,
0.0612954907,
0.0075692791,
-0.0499567538,
-0.0132280644,
0.0418158658,
-0.0285035297,
-0.060261894,
-0.016615238,
0.0218321644,
0.0290163755,
-0.0020656746,
-0.0196067784,
-0.0060822763,
0.0340191759,
-0.0227936693,
-0.0450891554,
0.0287698414,
-0.001249047,
-0.0244679358,
-0.0110712573,
-0.0357271954,
0.0028910271,
0.0511884578,
-0.0236752816,
-0.0166923646,
0.0164124127,
0.0014784849,
0.0763973743,
-0.0448875688,
0.0097491695,
-0.0387115069,
-0.0123530673,
-0.0298881922,
0.0792947486,
0.0160865802,
0.0073848604,
-0.0145004196,
-0.073443085,
0.0069189649,
0.0249746423,
-0.0445236973,
0.0052682082,
0.0117965443,
0.0078371717,
0.0599561632,
-0.0072153187,
-0.0442819521,
-0.04498557,
-0.0940916687,
-0.0009211141,
-0.0367097706,
0.0379181206,
0.0117427344,
-0.0259586778,
-0.0079659596,
-0.013620819,
-0.0178735517,
-0.0083584674,
-0.0504603758,
-0.0013815191,
0.0511288121,
0.0109307542,
0.0281007905,
-0.0125187822,
0.0071306671,
-0.0575555898,
0.0792030692,
0.0284698345,
0.007013537,
-0.012921093,
0.0011347026,
-0.0114753935,
0.0129018184,
-0.0195840169,
-0.0089588594,
-0.0064185797,
-0.0072567901,
0.0285699591,
0.0664151013,
0.0781794041,
0.0551746786,
0.0048293904,
0.0076533556,
-0.026020702,
0.0161135346,
-0.0662343428,
0.0196743682,
-0.0188833624,
-0.0287333075,
0.006235119,
0.0331430808,
-0.0016259223,
0.0285718143,
-0.0267009139,
-0.0187790394,
-0.0059418804,
0.0293893665,
0.0291574523,
-0.0073367506,
-0.002449794,
0.0101163583,
-0.0134735722,
-0.0185550731,
0.0380326062,
0.0081813913,
0.0144197419,
-0.0285892356,
-0.0117401117,
-0.0383766666,
0.0608605146,
0.01537521,
-0.003796496,
0.035921406,
-0.0117846243,
-0.0566169731,
-0.0131931491,
0.0284505226,
-0.0265889317,
0.0300046224,
0.0034476267,
0.0094871679,
0.0118214944,
-0.0066829044,
-0.0171115007,
-0.0862543732,
-0.0296214148,
-0.0172102153,
-0.0275285486,
-0.0282547921,
-0.1102565974,
0.0080638221,
-0.0205307268,
0.0740673393,
-0.0465276204,
-0.0127985934,
0.0069541968,
0.0715565234,
0.0358428434,
-0.0488850251,
-0.0389594361,
0.0011264412,
-0.0009247066,
-0.0166051537,
0.0090406798,
0.061299298,
-0.0684760958,
-0.0151104126,
0.0178397559,
-0.0637576208,
-0.022612378,
0.0036847272,
-0.0084824683,
-0.0245490614,
-0.0133226318,
0.1487223208,
0.0625354871,
-0.0506408848,
-0.0182405766,
0.0229583476,
-0.0260225311,
0.0187030137,
0.0167563856,
-0.0432175137,
-0.0035009892,
-0.0307348687,
-0.0088186534,
0.0239529815,
-0.0160479974,
-0.0069689676,
-0.069783695,
0.0001109339,
0.0012618331,
-0.0177727249,
0.0102722598,
-0.0391330011,
-0.0240798462,
-0.0436565243,
-0.0213996265,
-0.0175004248,
-0.0116408486,
0.0091964565,
0.0396295749,
-0.0792350173,
-0.0472794548,
0.0614322871,
0.0322188102,
0.0284959693,
0.0452065244,
0.0717561767,
-0.046588432,
-0.0164692197,
-0.0051763812,
0.0101560755,
-0.0230353996,
-0.0228494927,
0.06823048,
-0.0233274102,
-0.0011275403,
-0.0135513218,
0.0056423671,
0.0208363738,
0.009579177,
0.0091862381,
0.0660962611,
-0.0077278013,
-0.042179428,
-0.0092557063,
-0.0098839756,
0.0183080845,
0.0327691473,
-0.0156606957,
-0.0702682137,
-0.0270999316,
0.0034361761,
0.0290022194,
-0.0614706241,
-0.0181382541,
-0.0320569575,
-0.0574685,
-0.0342611261,
-0.0830958858,
0.0127459876,
-0.0085171144,
0.0112749515,
0.0003977248,
-0.0355743021,
0.0268531851,
0.0136515303,
-0.0874648318,
0.0027087016,
0.0349337347,
0.0177145563,
-0.0542293228,
-0.0273796339,
0.0492820628,
-0.0080862315,
-0.0329954103,
0.0155563289,
-0.0522030517,
-0.0187934022,
0.0214270949,
0.0013723044,
0.0197404604,
0.0509958565,
0.0158530567,
0.0008881046,
0.1022385731,
0.0859196857,
0.0132462801,
-0.0494507067,
0.0338782594,
0.006920292,
-0.0011680102,
0.0133435102,
-0.0531986803,
0.0133333299,
-0.0301529896,
-0.0434648842,
-0.0593498535,
-0.0220537856,
-0.0214415677,
-0.0483115241,
0.0645713508,
0.0073120068,
0.008839637,
-0.0048001893,
-0.0047735469,
-0.0057913577,
0.0110609094,
-0.017549634,
-0.0043473635,
0.0224380586,
0.012072471,
-0.062268164,
0.0734560937,
0.0061087338,
0.023369465,
-0.0631438419,
0.0361882076,
0.0177291464,
0.0726214722,
-0.0240543075,
0.0174745824,
-0.0102381473,
-0.015028839,
0.0300509091,
0.0111829499,
-0.0088513987,
0.0425278209,
-0.0029045753,
0.063579753,
-0.0093015907,
-0.0201408993,
-0.107545577,
0.0392997637,
-0.0218788106,
-0.0090208827,
0.0362717323,
-0.0767245442,
0.0539971888,
-0.023920998,
-0.01961728,
0.0124275843,
0.0449013188,
0.0563244559,
0.0112480558,
-0.0018487433,
0.0021151053,
-0.0148985954,
0.0193771999,
0.0452539138,
0.0414947309,
0.029199779,
0.0857066661,
-0.0532526523,
-0.0350573845,
0.015928017,
0.0429910831,
-0.050421305,
0.0034568487,
-0.0002638596,
-0.0282311197,
0.0073816436,
0.0941627845,
-0.0273120515,
0.0060006878,
-0.0104685845,
0.0053812615,
0.0586544909,
0.0047774627,
-0.0072509651,
-0.0530692674,
0.023918489,
0.0169934798,
-0.0251096003,
-0.0579028204,
-5.501169564e-33,
-0.0103560481,
-0.0104101226,
-0.0279877651,
0.0353158936,
-0.0274684522,
0.0303471517,
-0.0189231951,
-0.0380678624,
-0.0291683879,
0.008249958,
-0.0206469074,
0.0320167951,
0.0066586682,
-0.0169133004,
0.0234670863,
-0.0002172239,
0.0242564529,
-0.0393876433,
-0.0325368457,
-0.0058963406,
0.0544080138,
0.0569747202,
0.0857846811,
-0.0135072749,
0.0126311453,
-0.0018666,
-0.0220602937,
-0.0075697079,
0.0752998441,
0.0506623425,
0.0095388973,
0.0025423991,
0.0314386152,
-0.079759039,
0.0064170472,
0.0501085185,
-0.0573542975,
-0.0327504836,
-0.0019384049,
0.0179587249,
0.0503251962,
0.0457707718,
0.0090775229,
-0.0117843803,
-0.0218868814,
-0.0364755914,
0.089286536,
-0.0252942089,
-0.0069820569,
-0.1147488281,
-0.043181669,
0.020814551,
-0.0273579713,
-0.0367980897,
0.0189424027,
0.0171578284,
0.0363033377,
0.0531664379,
-0.0944361165,
-0.002510119,
-0.0099633858,
0.0450453982,
-0.0011018639,
-0.0026770083,
-0.0108125899,
0.0428427085,
-0.0140516097,
0.0263790824,
-0.0235736482,
0.0240349676,
0.0486484729,
-0.0018460669,
0.0226757471,
0.0006811052,
0.0567453094,
-0.0584023669,
-0.0528196804,
0.0635322928,
0.0656363443,
0.0168131609,
0.0131597063,
-0.0192450657,
-0.0001518183,
0.024251949,
0.0207674224,
0.0120995967,
-0.0140876835,
-0.0016699515,
-0.0243070498,
0.006426109,
0.0003635383,
0.0339564085,
0.0260921288,
-0.0493612736,
-0.0167873465,
0.0476575457,
-0.0485641174,
0.0109168757,
-0.0125455838,
0.03274538,
-0.0374403633,
-0.0523081943,
0.0168090854,
0.0506196544,
-0.0004607973,
-0.0375915021,
0.0373766944,
0.060775429,
-0.0717043132,
-0.0219891928,
-0.0083318911,
-0.0247358512,
-0.0017680116,
0.0284844916,
-0.0070264963,
-0.0155793214,
0.0082949409,
0.0044118566,
0.0070013618,
0.0470767096,
0.0169194955,
-0.0094892997,
0.0235457774,
0.0231927875,
-0.004542524,
-0.0327023938,
-0.0173310582,
0.043158669,
-0.0159316398,
-0.0454392284,
-0.0063863266,
-0.021978626,
2.455e-7,
0.0573488735,
0.0691508874,
-0.0008185311,
0.0178760979,
0.0206837971,
0.0150456931,
-0.0099676922,
0.0378203057,
-0.0069626835,
0.014985403,
0.0565722249,
-0.0371036828,
0.0462677553,
0.0046041999,
-0.0737374276,
-0.0615341552,
-0.1071569473,
0.0124913882,
-0.04695566,
-0.0076271058,
0.0604419671,
0.0727333054,
0.031278614,
-0.0002229768,
-0.0100658406,
-0.0233049225,
0.0657684803,
-0.0328694433,
-0.0262022782,
0.0284657236,
0.0423829071,
0.0014181633,
-0.0225783009,
-0.0024504126,
-0.0568977557,
0.0285046771,
-0.0274091773,
0.0401316695,
-0.0194072481,
-0.0253770892,
0.005380149,
0.0106230713,
-0.0266406536,
-0.0287113599,
0.0624932833,
-0.037491776,
-0.0174934752,
-0.0266302582,
-0.0823309645,
0.04258205,
0.0422058478,
0.0030504379,
-0.0187198706,
0.0283112228,
-0.0002491783,
-0.0038666022,
-0.0001189925,
-0.0870727971,
-0.0185611919,
0.0400193371,
-0.0194506701,
0.000272196,
-0.0116839949,
-0.0089671295,
0.0067946608,
-0.0538294315,
0.0576049015,
1.990656061e-34,
0.0346301757,
0.0056803534,
-0.0444132909,
0.0199830905,
0.0048522209,
-0.0008330548,
0.0220542811,
-0.0332813226,
-0.003500161,
-0.0210467596,
-0.0070465044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10844v1 | Better Sign Language Translation with Monolingual Data | 2023-04-21T09:39:54 | 2023-04-21T09:39:54 | Ru Peng, Yawen Zeng, Junbo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sign language translation (SLT) systems, which are often decomposed into
video-to-gloss (V2G) recognition and gloss-to-text (G2T) translation through
the pivot gloss, heavily relies on the availability of large-scale parallel G2T
pairs. However, the manual annotation of pivot gloss, which is a sequence of
transcribed written-language words in the order in which they are signed,
further exacerbates the scarcity of data for SLT. To address this issue, this
paper proposes a simple and efficient rule transformation method to transcribe
the large-scale target monolingual data into its pseudo glosses automatically
for enhancing the SLT translation. Empirical results show that the proposed
approach can significantly improve the performance of SLT, especially achieving
state-of-the-art results on two SLT benchmark datasets PHEONIX-WEATHER 2014T
and ASLG-PC12. Our code has been released at:
https://github.com/pengr/Mono\_SLT. | [
-0.018289391,
0.0010550488,
0.0012051068,
0.0663207769,
-0.015350516,
0.0193215553,
0.0335712098,
0.0157508235,
0.0449723005,
-0.0491815433,
-0.0057669799,
-0.0159864798,
0.0560371578,
0.0250941273,
0.0136901764,
-0.1050795838,
0.0277938507,
-0.0388271026,
-0.051427085,
-0.0073975129,
0.0364445969,
0.0373840928,
-0.0290653538,
0.0248010792,
-0.050456278,
0.0099938074,
0.0275442898,
0.0425388031,
0.0407581106,
0.000586699,
-0.0939437523,
0.0288446713,
0.0476125851,
0.0219187178,
0.0000020826,
-0.034701366,
-0.0039490582,
0.0008380507,
0.0617506281,
0.023722494,
0.0671878532,
-0.0820429623,
-0.0134839369,
0.0388315283,
-0.0303453226,
-0.1059182584,
0.0486236289,
0.019470226,
0.0206647944,
0.0320029892,
-0.0384669788,
-0.042314332,
0.0149210179,
-0.0133016426,
-0.0541077368,
-0.0145154744,
-0.0162482504,
0.0209278744,
-0.0111059975,
-0.0561676286,
-0.0407931022,
0.0855689719,
0.0127970371,
-0.0526090637,
-0.0511298552,
0.0205716044,
-0.0352211259,
0.0241376758,
0.0020527027,
0.0526326112,
-0.0841452852,
0.0213624779,
0.002909095,
-0.0296261385,
0.0224689804,
0.022291176,
-0.0089273937,
0.0178280286,
-0.0069307098,
-0.0093462123,
-0.0007198881,
0.0285275932,
0.0330304392,
-0.0518451445,
-0.0419358946,
0.008939351,
0.0434265547,
0.0169957746,
0.0206455607,
-0.0291139446,
0.0128339715,
0.0094536114,
0.0592689216,
-0.0365755446,
0.0409453288,
0.0030595213,
-0.0098775197,
-0.0027580711,
-0.0192196313,
-0.0517415814,
0.0188180991,
0.0907228217,
-0.0168515369,
0.0163165182,
0.0003825932,
0.0133890118,
-0.0209794436,
0.0672188252,
-0.079729557,
0.0001749171,
-0.0128261065,
0.0089381505,
-0.0792787671,
-0.0443176255,
-0.0337104686,
0.0072824564,
-0.0078444444,
-0.0012974421,
0.0282025225,
-0.0584289432,
0.0194761604,
-0.0445538983,
0.0137315439,
-0.0298825763,
0.0280421115,
0.0530787818,
0.0071173138,
0.0167318061,
-0.0550156832,
-0.050164219,
0.0028191402,
0.0310024694,
0.0207527038,
0.014072285,
-0.0034421033,
0.0508413203,
-0.0352005623,
-0.0409474783,
0.001205988,
0.0084419679,
-0.0054618833,
-0.0157910939,
-0.0131970802,
-0.0519118458,
0.0493898466,
-0.0030295164,
0.0050827325,
-0.0327107906,
-0.0087433169,
-0.0043352921,
0.0147237526,
0.0494331531,
-0.0259202328,
-0.0071751401,
0.0383508876,
0.0005082535,
-0.0362640582,
0.0361689962,
0.0621653609,
0.0108065065,
0.0168945566,
-0.0046577584,
0.0151045276,
0.1045653522,
-0.0222852975,
0.0287960954,
-0.0097643146,
-0.0336449556,
0.0221953876,
0.0202457197,
0.0106474077,
0.0569577143,
-0.0297108795,
-0.0399781168,
0.0168813951,
0.0505673625,
0.0048186136,
-0.0261859372,
0.0381111093,
0.0413012579,
0.0137761021,
-0.0433255658,
0.0149855288,
0.0070164483,
0.0181787834,
-0.037679892,
-0.0453127474,
0.0426108912,
-0.0336089395,
0.0074333488,
-0.0160759948,
-0.0302567557,
0.0555349104,
-0.0134913251,
0.0266509689,
0.0054350174,
-0.0524140447,
-0.0043567554,
0.0030903961,
-0.0267333072,
0.0169185735,
-0.0303123724,
-0.0537667386,
0.0535928197,
0.0158340354,
0.0258233882,
-0.0297105797,
-0.0165590588,
-0.025449248,
0.0235481802,
0.010519864,
-0.0024438046,
0.0290770661,
-0.0713272169,
-0.0070919036,
0.1032647341,
-0.0148850475,
0.0264719557,
-0.0403434746,
0.0525891893,
0.045627702,
0.0052085486,
-0.0463445932,
0.0350922085,
0.0368198939,
0.005737978,
0.0654070005,
-0.0129770711,
0.0468519665,
0.0368197449,
0.0150564471,
-0.0282045566,
0.0365185551,
-0.0409101136,
-0.0272222348,
0.0835891739,
-0.0309295878,
-0.0672644228,
0.0361000896,
-0.0423522778,
-0.0102363443,
0.0204755608,
0.0164649151,
-0.0572121963,
-0.0256116893,
-0.0164491665,
0.0406284928,
-0.0288452227,
0.0310950484,
0.0376740508,
0.001179142,
-0.0343232602,
-0.0280293021,
-0.0156296268,
-0.0505726151,
-0.0307182465,
-0.0204078034,
0.0367299989,
-0.0434658639,
0.03124086,
0.0670657456,
0.00834898,
0.0158882868,
0.0133506116,
0.0434414335,
-0.0259415004,
0.002985917,
-0.0880668536,
0.0062565855,
-0.0119509501,
0.0337926,
0.0025405921,
0.0098247332,
-0.006860462,
-0.0103164725,
-0.0264244135,
0.0313698314,
0.0187373105,
-0.0581066087,
-0.0091913929,
-0.0053211162,
-0.0353511758,
-0.0109724887,
-0.0073279752,
0.0034732982,
-0.0052040275,
0.0303859152,
-0.0440726839,
-0.0422158837,
-0.0156811085,
0.033586327,
0.003339255,
-0.0154553335,
-0.0216856152,
0.0039456198,
0.0026094813,
-0.0207799766,
-0.0416804999,
-0.0160414204,
-0.013319511,
-0.0029878388,
-0.0390691273,
-0.0020226734,
-0.0034620601,
-0.0057268078,
0.0076480997,
-0.0533213057,
-0.0174677167,
-0.0168623738,
-0.0027955696,
0.0316486321,
0.0290937982,
-0.0883677825,
-0.0822184607,
-0.0327143781,
-0.0215251222,
0.0094514936,
0.0070179072,
-0.0121680638,
-0.0390820801,
-0.0005475737,
-0.0469256975,
-0.0029654009,
-0.0527565777,
-0.041530937,
-0.0198111106,
0.0251199603,
-0.0485057943,
0.0758277252,
0.0009317473,
0.0307676103,
-0.0739402175,
-0.0391334109,
-0.0125013823,
0.0057979156,
-0.0020397883,
-0.0201007146,
0.0138986968,
-0.0613856241,
0.0290385243,
-0.0406779796,
0.0179574005,
0.0235279128,
-0.0082009993,
-0.00394856,
-0.0189633053,
0.0139735527,
-0.0621473305,
-0.0319721363,
0.0307239257,
-0.0324791111,
0.0669870526,
0.014926373,
0.004771098,
-0.0032567549,
-0.0126693454,
0.0015190574,
0.0049754572,
-0.0612398349,
-0.0296516251,
0.0023608189,
0.0226176325,
-0.0536603779,
0.0023288236,
-0.0198233947,
-0.0210475922,
0.0575174727,
0.0072557759,
-0.032712996,
0.0112754917,
0.0025231563,
-0.0316655375,
0.0567643791,
0.0769841224,
0.0189448707,
-0.0534287095,
-0.0025232832,
0.0209488105,
0.007024941,
-0.0004714979,
-0.0226271283,
-0.0862615705,
-0.0554856285,
-0.0015257909,
0.0622143522,
0.059268076,
0.0246558934,
-0.0372026749,
-0.0310162827,
0.0435395204,
0.0643797442,
-0.1272007376,
-0.0318428837,
0.0062902053,
-0.005149317,
-0.0126040317,
0.0102403127,
0.0219509415,
-0.0050246869,
-0.0007459483,
0.0031222641,
-0.024368193,
-0.0443859175,
0.0042544981,
-0.0057899053,
0.0360212661,
0.002414423,
0.0196593776,
0.0013613506,
-0.0209679864,
0.0379084013,
0.0024280415,
-0.0046442831,
-0.0771610215,
0.0494118333,
-0.013247476,
-0.0062575303,
0.0155557571,
0.0346156023,
-0.0794239342,
0.0126297325,
0.0362452529,
0.0668302998,
-0.004544171,
0.0126700848,
0.0152893197,
-0.0705969259,
0.0047908244,
0.0271612648,
-0.0439991094,
-0.0097794048,
0.0261817146,
-0.0062096068,
-0.0099747377,
0.0439679511,
-0.0606038384,
-0.0107576968,
-0.0423220992,
-0.0817694217,
-0.0306535251,
-0.0140327299,
0.0701423064,
0.073225908,
0.0170403533,
0.0203733053,
0.0774752945,
0.0281272717,
-0.0356687494,
0.0250519142,
-0.0354799777,
0.0317807645,
-0.0528338514,
-0.024394922,
-0.011690733,
0.0218161084,
0.013261823,
0.0630404055,
-0.0360994898,
-0.0532655492,
0.0215396974,
0.0195621345,
0.0161083303,
0.0054765395,
-0.0087001538,
-0.0147296507,
-0.038208358,
0.0178797115,
0.0141824242,
0.0081215492,
0.0219774172,
-0.0594631471,
-0.0174880046,
0.0120999403,
0.0283215865,
0.0152136497,
-0.0370312966,
0.0105707739,
-0.0874432251,
-0.070388101,
-0.0336217843,
0.046072863,
-0.0164580308,
-0.0287879501,
-0.05068269,
-0.0456291027,
0.0402487554,
-0.0460688584,
0.0262780637,
-0.0807924196,
0.0059837783,
0.0488833338,
-0.0191740151,
-0.0216697864,
-0.0240025781,
-0.0358191691,
-0.0252235085,
0.0158917047,
0.0100932699,
0.0043251929,
0.0153600015,
0.0189666543,
0.0202202443,
0.011573825,
0.0381221995,
-0.0089867599,
-0.0147729777,
-0.0187154301,
0.010165317,
-0.0039654989,
0.0037871727,
0.032957036,
0.0222527999,
0.0460664518,
-0.0566760339,
-0.023642879,
0.0154533032,
0.0275777075,
0.0462836362,
0.1132725701,
-0.0342552923,
0.0268621836,
-0.0278683528,
0.0376063138,
-0.0173997302,
-0.0319446959,
0.0061593261,
-0.0432151631,
-0.0213460457,
0.0070856716,
0.0263197515,
-0.034774676,
-0.0241988581,
-0.0208371822,
-0.0091318181,
-0.0231050476,
-0.0412823334,
-0.0029473195,
-0.0340180509,
-0.0176067613,
0.0158184487,
-0.0589924902,
-0.0205368567,
0.0005537428,
-0.0033314968,
0.0236218534,
0.0204832889,
0.0403052755,
-0.0204709992,
-0.0079557123,
-0.0181572959,
-0.0171554666,
-0.0324163549,
-0.0231761709,
-0.0252493601,
-0.023153713,
-5.739486717e-33,
-0.0521784313,
-0.0344681069,
-0.0091884043,
0.0357634686,
-0.0468315855,
0.0029156781,
0.0085720634,
0.0181824584,
0.0306632239,
0.0222191773,
0.0153115159,
0.0002869313,
0.0212928131,
-0.0165716242,
-0.0065192524,
0.0075752176,
0.0295574795,
-0.0195962302,
-0.0159883555,
0.039574936,
0.0494179502,
0.0259489063,
0.0932310298,
-0.1491194218,
-0.0245041642,
-0.0243200753,
-0.0413896553,
0.007266148,
-0.0090930825,
-0.0242953189,
-0.0070105172,
0.0079237837,
0.0062036789,
0.0240220912,
0.0044355234,
-0.0064980201,
-0.0305698123,
0.0237454418,
0.0193377547,
0.1035097986,
-0.0400118083,
0.0213265251,
-0.0066367411,
-0.0156361945,
-0.0538740903,
0.0184026994,
0.0006612038,
-0.0328500718,
-0.0124944849,
-0.0316270478,
-0.0301852189,
0.0610582344,
-0.008882449,
-0.027361948,
0.0426044576,
-0.0029850833,
-0.0125654629,
-0.0378556587,
-0.0155806066,
0.0136827324,
-0.0128052616,
0.0225782767,
0.0720264614,
-0.0311204679,
0.0003322271,
0.006282669,
0.0151803577,
-0.0543968379,
0.0626392066,
-0.0402959697,
0.0623115264,
0.0180288404,
0.0215921402,
0.0479042977,
0.0757468045,
-0.0488440804,
-0.0308528282,
0.0176081229,
0.030469548,
0.0365230441,
-0.0096230051,
0.0218917746,
-0.009044216,
-0.0059961872,
-0.0498871915,
-0.0055567618,
0.0351851061,
-0.0129935741,
0.0243306048,
0.0099387281,
0.0111431312,
0.0370357037,
0.0860553011,
0.0364047252,
-0.0146599896,
-0.0127939135,
-0.0246650372,
0.0442553684,
-0.0273066312,
0.0439052768,
-0.0311294738,
-0.0599704012,
0.0573109835,
-0.0115483524,
0.0384239666,
-0.0308947731,
0.0138143748,
0.0897899941,
-0.0446577221,
0.0115798153,
0.0036385518,
0.0086381426,
0.0046787057,
-0.0054227016,
0.0197175015,
-0.005268388,
-0.0017967151,
0.068119213,
0.0274544805,
-0.0040700017,
-0.0243843049,
0.0115206307,
0.0230931621,
0.0024935589,
-0.044892326,
0.0376119465,
0.0502548106,
-0.0650366023,
0.0492621101,
-0.0640038401,
-0.0046679461,
0.0196181145,
2.703e-7,
0.0677654147,
0.0578730553,
0.000905566,
0.0397355333,
0.017024722,
0.0148061225,
0.0031524661,
0.0002828715,
0.0482598133,
0.0677620694,
0.0283717494,
-0.0119457692,
0.0427884459,
0.039872814,
-0.0295122527,
0.0325099602,
0.0209228452,
0.0311080106,
-0.0344162956,
0.0460800193,
0.096861124,
0.0708405524,
-0.0059028082,
-0.0208091214,
0.0263578538,
-0.0630391911,
0.0657886937,
-0.0404011458,
0.0004658445,
-0.0222931653,
0.0847693011,
-0.0072361729,
-0.034507364,
0.011472757,
0.0051440727,
0.0143599976,
0.0152109889,
0.0467201769,
-0.0484872907,
0.0323867574,
0.0251104292,
-0.0314206891,
-0.0471631438,
0.0076553128,
0.0559004061,
-0.0097187823,
0.0021530956,
-0.0117361154,
-0.0222926531,
0.0344598666,
0.0106859179,
0.0070827845,
0.0066581736,
0.0413558111,
0.0470485277,
-0.062758483,
-0.0170444846,
-0.0462493487,
-0.0281162728,
-0.0126635013,
0.0184189212,
0.0120202433,
0.0049968506,
0.0312430821,
-0.0226730835,
-0.0054093068,
-0.0251232721,
2.541301467e-34,
0.0347559527,
-0.0024277025,
0.014147223,
0.0154183209,
-0.0038665149,
-0.0229631308,
0.0193387643,
0.0445940681,
-0.0312648341,
-0.0226901248,
-0.032151442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10813v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10813v3 | Tokenization Preference for Human and Machine Learning Model: An Annotation Study | 2023-04-21T08:49:06 | 2024-02-16T07:55:59 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Tomoya Iwakura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Is preferred tokenization for humans also preferred for machine-learning (ML)
models? This study examines the relations between preferred tokenization for
humans (appropriateness and readability) and one for ML models (performance on
an NLP task). The question texts of the Japanese commonsense question-answering
dataset are tokenized with six different tokenizers, and the performances of
human annotators and ML models were compared. Furthermore, we analyze relations
among performance of answers by human and ML model, the appropriateness of
tokenization for human, and response time to questions by human. This study
provides a quantitative investigation result that shows that preferred
tokenizations for humans and ML models are not necessarily always the same. The
result also implies that existing methods using language models for
tokenization could be a good compromise both for human and ML models. | [
0.0631508827,
-0.0048390874,
-0.0211814251,
0.0098637631,
-0.0154896677,
0.0066122073,
0.0220571738,
0.0127847008,
-0.00680807,
-0.0499469303,
0.010254438,
0.0388892591,
-0.0329788588,
-0.0050114994,
0.0488705114,
-0.0889362767,
0.0347504951,
0.0011176141,
0.0425777473,
0.0274215918,
0.0405503437,
-0.0018532964,
0.0188603681,
0.0772193372,
-0.0465892963,
-0.0182672292,
0.0134558761,
-0.0200823117,
-0.0178815182,
-0.0097622545,
-0.0294215586,
0.0552582815,
-0.030013511,
0.0119586354,
0.0000016065,
-0.0526674874,
0.015823653,
0.0361677185,
0.0137185976,
0.0094734859,
0.0428635478,
-0.0219236054,
0.0097673368,
0.0298714619,
-0.0681252852,
-0.0048962357,
0.0476384498,
0.0442695282,
0.0974982083,
0.025489809,
-0.010039838,
-0.0173178762,
0.0394532904,
0.0494032018,
-0.0151256332,
-0.0322499573,
-0.0048867296,
0.0243057832,
0.010591859,
-0.0088010998,
0.0023552962,
0.0233746953,
0.0122107333,
-0.0290795546,
0.0260010622,
0.0080407653,
-0.0596390776,
-0.0152818421,
-0.0003806241,
0.050891947,
0.0356197096,
-0.0223750398,
-0.0252300743,
0.0122092208,
0.0498731248,
0.0267482512,
-0.0524692684,
0.0072112326,
-0.0025945765,
0.0009489894,
0.0222566985,
-0.017821135,
-0.0066424659,
0.0171361137,
-0.0106435493,
0.0712624416,
-0.0039456678,
-0.033166334,
-0.0335547403,
-0.0048253457,
-0.0448483601,
-0.0642616898,
0.0342353247,
0.0348253623,
-0.0391672514,
0.0098875659,
-0.0409108475,
-0.0846282989,
0.0159405023,
-0.0627766997,
-0.0141264601,
0.0361839384,
-0.0125696501,
0.0109059978,
-0.0277016703,
0.045045048,
0.0158832353,
0.0595876016,
-0.0535948947,
-0.0267513711,
-0.0552008264,
-0.0550605282,
-0.063554734,
0.0822135657,
-0.0234381035,
0.0040940307,
-0.0296505652,
0.0296070389,
0.0043094163,
-0.0226977393,
-0.0007469822,
-0.0248600505,
-0.002630034,
0.0289291255,
-0.0341555774,
-0.0048869043,
-0.0894582272,
0.025061816,
0.0349493511,
-0.0468663834,
0.0428597555,
0.029071413,
0.0116283232,
-0.0372751877,
-0.0134599619,
0.0637958646,
-0.010108009,
0.007235582,
-0.0212402269,
-0.0215611625,
0.01589185,
0.0245382041,
-0.0559273064,
-0.0646278858,
0.010895296,
0.0553893559,
-0.0197268557,
0.0103686806,
-0.0191675927,
0.0442637466,
-0.0108318254,
0.0611716248,
-0.0269468259,
0.020986801,
0.0603832155,
-0.0305070709,
-0.0420988686,
0.0264063776,
0.0390747488,
-0.0071588317,
0.0656781346,
-0.0290665068,
0.0430274121,
0.0247767922,
-0.020475138,
-0.0314082764,
-0.0031890813,
0.0489223041,
-0.0126880705,
0.0395586155,
0.0502624325,
0.0922631323,
-0.0381068029,
0.0034861402,
0.0402046777,
0.1128759384,
-0.039805755,
0.028663056,
0.0409340821,
0.0018719598,
0.0535807908,
0.0257302057,
-0.0217507612,
0.0071120621,
-0.0039638435,
0.0283063222,
0.0008302839,
-0.0351153314,
-0.0055208257,
-0.0610573143,
-0.0303683784,
-0.0054786974,
0.0420814566,
-0.0455044247,
0.00473327,
-0.0016316145,
-0.0229524337,
0.0426732153,
-0.0113914628,
-0.0439907089,
0.0112897633,
-0.0611754917,
0.0191574097,
0.054537598,
0.0062455535,
-0.0173014794,
0.0087080337,
-0.0147705944,
0.040697597,
0.0243781321,
0.0280551333,
-0.0256994665,
-0.0419901162,
-0.000979447,
0.0302075706,
0.0030647297,
-0.0142471706,
-0.0253557768,
0.0015507056,
0.0228104945,
0.0037437624,
-0.0864685625,
-0.0418484844,
0.0692584887,
0.0167065002,
0.0064670527,
-0.0417021066,
0.0109087043,
0.0337676294,
0.0459592678,
0.0086460253,
0.0537708439,
0.0030018366,
-0.023750728,
0.0058626225,
0.0349753238,
-0.0009502546,
-0.0082767764,
0.0521389991,
-0.0373387113,
-0.0336411782,
0.0320944488,
0.0031701589,
-0.0265448205,
-0.0396394096,
-0.0556256063,
0.056534417,
-0.0664456859,
-0.0154130822,
-0.0133195966,
-0.0301237926,
-0.0503165536,
0.0225596633,
0.0002196932,
0.013525865,
-0.0057686432,
-0.0376940146,
0.0285505038,
-0.0382781811,
-0.0298350081,
0.0155112082,
-0.0134690991,
0.0177417584,
0.0238614343,
-0.0013311565,
-0.0347652212,
0.0137097491,
-0.1256756186,
-0.0564423651,
-0.0171894729,
0.0074050035,
0.0077776425,
-0.0022819466,
-0.0175345503,
-0.019427523,
-0.0332155824,
-0.0376415253,
-0.0189707018,
0.0562102534,
0.056595616,
0.0172916502,
0.0233790614,
-0.0312205236,
-0.0287056938,
-0.0106140068,
0.0152039509,
0.0332798176,
-0.0301724058,
-0.0551960431,
-0.0087636653,
0.0108291795,
-0.0208773166,
0.0247825831,
-0.0602511056,
0.0288487636,
-0.0022564942,
0.0170604363,
0.0568287857,
0.0268253461,
0.0360743813,
-0.0038651472,
0.0481562279,
-0.0432979316,
0.0007203451,
0.0169809982,
-0.0035938278,
-0.0007094332,
-0.0368133448,
0.057423301,
0.0253926702,
-0.0053272154,
0.0024121872,
-0.0435762703,
0.0319619775,
-0.0661009178,
-0.0617353842,
-0.0481223986,
-0.0331925415,
-0.0304143857,
0.0612541996,
0.0172694195,
-0.0297073107,
0.0885804668,
-0.0177222732,
0.002673751,
-0.0530975871,
0.0142831085,
-0.0269402266,
0.0187102668,
-0.0214140918,
0.0316692963,
-0.0196659248,
-0.069146052,
-0.0357677899,
0.0042689643,
0.0190347899,
-0.0018863407,
0.0058570728,
-0.0085085034,
0.0027323477,
-0.0002905623,
-0.031126475,
-0.0095121721,
-0.0518573411,
-0.0430335067,
0.0313476175,
0.0450158045,
0.0167469885,
-0.005748882,
0.0662330389,
0.0023171769,
-0.0012030656,
-0.0160002131,
-0.0035147292,
-0.01802825,
0.0380228162,
0.032776434,
0.0441865586,
0.0060517718,
0.0261446536,
0.0453535132,
0.0424305722,
0.0626553968,
-0.0257787462,
-0.0100673931,
-0.0326197855,
0.030365577,
-0.0850079805,
-0.0503972843,
0.0110619143,
0.0601173677,
-0.0240892675,
0.0114818588,
0.1107129753,
0.0470453724,
-0.0175216198,
0.0098790154,
-0.0630666316,
-0.0127095226,
-0.0101884473,
0.0510737784,
-0.0488741584,
-0.0142804729,
0.0221301354,
0.0549606457,
0.0032037885,
-0.0328715332,
0.050558541,
-0.0949457437,
-0.0008763399,
-0.0296447389,
-0.1193881109,
-0.028866386,
-0.0725034401,
-0.020765448,
-0.0067368862,
0.0551019087,
0.0222091861,
0.0058553228,
0.0395366251,
0.0371599905,
-0.057856407,
0.0062988149,
-0.0298735965,
-0.0402325764,
0.0296180435,
0.0587945543,
0.0378962457,
-0.0360764042,
-0.0172266811,
0.0359848402,
0.0207185633,
0.0319972709,
-0.0443685912,
0.0071339924,
-0.0232551489,
0.0039536087,
-0.0264983848,
0.0331289805,
-0.007710713,
-0.0103486627,
0.0376023315,
0.0398672372,
0.0277915299,
0.0327386297,
-0.050174363,
-0.0198237691,
-0.0107136127,
0.0800939873,
0.0434652753,
-0.0554165393,
-0.0375929177,
-0.0328873955,
0.0083352933,
-0.049814824,
0.0062889559,
-0.0381156467,
-0.0313530341,
0.0074646571,
-0.1148577482,
-0.072435379,
0.0480429307,
0.0431203358,
0.0035772535,
0.0406808294,
0.0100471135,
0.0229116287,
-0.0149127739,
0.0031762097,
0.005822483,
0.0127523215,
-0.081585981,
-0.0068970076,
-0.0138122356,
0.0036383937,
-0.0192458238,
-0.0134207448,
0.0055457409,
-0.0227274988,
-0.0073507815,
0.0674496144,
0.0222844165,
0.010645532,
-0.0069661629,
-0.0662362501,
-0.009578485,
0.0487031564,
-0.0454748273,
-0.0000291538,
-0.0071981964,
0.0330838673,
-0.0029476639,
0.0073114848,
-0.0285586417,
-0.0184890442,
-0.0158499796,
0.0574287139,
-0.0215590335,
0.0085916827,
0.0235300269,
0.0586672947,
0.014388266,
-0.0106879873,
0.0007447343,
0.0084507205,
-0.0069954754,
-0.0490295216,
-0.0199667607,
-0.0394735448,
0.0161536373,
-0.0044519566,
0.0058964612,
-0.0121309273,
-0.0303239599,
-0.056025546,
0.0254499614,
-0.0031764267,
0.0269742198,
0.0196751934,
0.0417761095,
-0.0096568651,
-0.00295425,
-0.0199911837,
-0.07044404,
0.0036494434,
0.0217050239,
-0.0068612793,
0.0172361378,
0.0074537364,
-0.005886788,
0.0086146323,
0.0247392431,
-0.0415370762,
-0.0218778066,
0.0005119033,
0.0441880263,
-0.0056187664,
-0.0012372751,
0.0219112691,
-0.0083872005,
-0.0316126831,
-0.0046877931,
0.0244658962,
0.0585493967,
0.0041578305,
0.0294459462,
0.0018134337,
-0.0449567698,
-0.0618846565,
0.0924708396,
0.018966008,
-0.0245473832,
-0.0317111127,
-0.0429297537,
-0.0335271806,
0.0409025848,
-0.0050603845,
0.0543330647,
-0.0029462192,
-0.036215093,
-0.047232911,
-0.0424103364,
-0.0182846207,
0.0055072177,
0.0069019692,
0.0097779939,
0.008017865,
0.0751332864,
0.0407315157,
-0.0433653109,
-0.058056064,
0.0414288677,
-0.0139549989,
-0.0244598165,
-0.0340233073,
-5.200604107e-33,
-0.0280361716,
-0.0422049426,
-0.0033577057,
0.0139518296,
0.0101301493,
-0.005303958,
-0.0285647698,
0.024230117,
-0.0210791174,
0.0025288032,
-0.0407871567,
0.0023390569,
0.0172435734,
0.0029584202,
0.0273468122,
-0.0270458125,
0.0164963827,
-0.0184591021,
-0.0297724064,
-0.0381833166,
0.0223416425,
-0.0006284144,
-0.0182965994,
-0.0239196774,
0.0630606785,
-0.0357029699,
0.0025207384,
0.0074783685,
0.0311209802,
0.0779446512,
0.0232573729,
0.0531447791,
0.0427047797,
0.0008363189,
-0.0187699012,
0.0696777925,
-0.0822591856,
-0.026770575,
0.0720493272,
0.0411320999,
-0.0163421314,
-0.0654278547,
0.0349504873,
-0.0404039435,
0.0070828409,
0.0341442898,
0.0692116544,
-0.0109173879,
-0.0310440604,
-0.013598145,
-0.0483395196,
0.0118383495,
-0.029501779,
0.0330662616,
0.0254259221,
0.0543604232,
-0.0156180291,
0.0096357437,
-0.0580948293,
0.0070873285,
-0.0197049137,
0.0012466449,
0.0538108535,
0.0132844541,
0.0140605997,
0.0095348665,
0.0393111669,
0.0050888369,
-0.029247297,
0.0331572779,
0.015734056,
0.0013241667,
0.0679209605,
0.0256617963,
0.0151218949,
-0.0121293925,
-0.0357130431,
0.0340325758,
-0.0082727354,
0.0056496817,
0.0062561785,
0.0420535505,
-0.0651022196,
-0.0104382522,
-0.0193908699,
-0.0232513472,
-0.0477092899,
-0.0546500981,
0.0143243158,
-0.0454517826,
-0.0373254344,
-0.0263831858,
0.0342287421,
-0.0260509029,
-0.0222633518,
-0.0133155752,
0.0093695065,
0.0501314178,
-0.0180431008,
0.0054539861,
-0.0217884034,
0.0082055042,
0.008034084,
0.0108604915,
0.0309836045,
0.0095844753,
0.0576181412,
-0.0475737751,
-0.0339670479,
-0.024804106,
0.0089478409,
-0.0045747156,
-0.0110461283,
-0.0177135803,
0.0426423661,
0.0167479012,
0.0182363708,
-0.0075459452,
0.0110085616,
-0.0128107956,
-0.0486864112,
-0.0084351236,
0.0003369836,
-0.0347507223,
-0.0236283205,
0.0170399938,
-0.0137066618,
0.0568628423,
0.0041496186,
-0.0279294048,
-0.0179007836,
0.0274080895,
2.162e-7,
0.0761128813,
0.0479592159,
0.0458949171,
-0.0421861485,
0.0099938326,
0.0170704108,
0.0418348759,
0.000255184,
0.0594045185,
0.0400316902,
-0.0010602752,
-0.0154842464,
0.0254998803,
0.0242341142,
-0.1208544672,
0.0037835764,
-0.0682361796,
0.0431812778,
-0.0353155881,
0.0552827083,
0.0700723678,
0.0120777963,
-0.0239697602,
0.0195359681,
-0.0448662899,
-0.0589061975,
0.000953556,
-0.0354242437,
0.0118099721,
0.0180303156,
0.0427777879,
0.0312024616,
0.0629430711,
0.0385726206,
-0.0212793797,
-0.0280292649,
0.1020662785,
0.022701513,
-0.0108324522,
-0.0290239844,
-0.0136052528,
-0.0317876972,
0.0392859615,
-0.0868992433,
0.0580428131,
-0.0297961142,
-0.0324583128,
-0.0152409077,
-0.0498467721,
-0.0203296095,
-0.0295191463,
-0.0215038117,
-0.0024141928,
0.0511533469,
0.0362688489,
-0.019143302,
0.0108112181,
-0.0044749961,
-0.0565718189,
-0.0200181641,
-0.0003510417,
-0.0459772833,
-0.0535142198,
0.0129409898,
0.025365632,
-0.0224198569,
-0.0120151713,
1.467053454e-34,
0.0098872045,
-0.0123368241,
0.0328906104,
0.0787376761,
0.0282237548,
0.0193703901,
-0.0073600374,
0.0302466322,
0.0194460489,
-0.0484930202,
-0.0093467338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10808v1 | Downstream Task-Oriented Neural Tokenizer Optimization with Vocabulary Restriction as Post Processing | 2023-04-21T08:29:14 | 2023-04-21T08:29:14 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Tomoya Iwakura | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a method to optimize tokenization for the performance
improvement of already trained downstream models. Our method generates
tokenization results attaining lower loss values of a given downstream model on
the training data for restricting vocabularies and trains a tokenizer
reproducing the tokenization results. Therefore, our method can be applied to
variety of tokenization methods, while existing work cannot due to the
simultaneous learning of the tokenizer and the downstream model. This paper
proposes an example of the BiLSTM-based tokenizer with vocabulary restriction,
which can capture wider contextual information for the tokenization process
than non-neural-based tokenization methods used in existing work. Experimental
results on text classification in Japanese, Chinese, and English text
classification tasks show that the proposed method improves performance
compared to the existing methods for tokenization optimization. | [
0.0365695655,
0.0214036442,
0.0246665664,
0.0270354301,
-0.0192369949,
-0.0011332026,
0.0288328342,
0.0368667431,
-0.0344094448,
-0.043818146,
-0.0614943244,
-0.0290059391,
-0.0211385004,
0.0087350225,
0.023069432,
-0.042752929,
0.0580525585,
0.0264858957,
0.0277343933,
0.0346488692,
0.0011605382,
-0.0098842382,
0.0394392759,
0.0517230481,
-0.0419141725,
-0.0159800462,
0.0299632698,
0.0025263962,
-0.0399218947,
-0.0012816172,
0.0079088053,
0.025631668,
-0.0250777677,
-0.0023766395,
0.0000018192,
-0.0301910974,
-0.0290212296,
0.0040941732,
0.0145692369,
-0.0051381243,
0.0806638747,
-0.0113745397,
0.0182940755,
0.0000366996,
-0.0045036026,
-0.0222939812,
0.0303799901,
0.1159118935,
0.0917037353,
0.0376017205,
0.0035221067,
-0.0216840561,
0.0616790392,
0.0130867204,
-0.0338556059,
0.0035582574,
0.0080926912,
-0.0542258583,
-0.0141173517,
0.013641838,
-0.0290392134,
0.0535538122,
0.0142532997,
-0.0039631906,
0.0333173536,
0.0097698923,
0.0143609298,
0.0114487698,
0.0189338326,
0.0111294463,
-0.0391037874,
-0.0210148487,
-0.0179492924,
0.0101751676,
0.0081682671,
-0.0411927775,
-0.0417235158,
0.0213766433,
-0.0229314417,
0.0460581593,
0.0340355374,
-0.0213284623,
0.0266562514,
0.0153761664,
-0.0049659419,
0.0557946004,
0.0108674206,
-0.0328634977,
-0.0256895069,
0.0118885431,
-0.0202960484,
-0.0359530076,
0.0404388234,
0.00753194,
-0.0444439724,
0.0077400566,
-0.0224057995,
-0.0731627345,
-0.025034558,
-0.0450198054,
-0.0205513518,
0.0271782298,
-0.0211606659,
0.0106631797,
-0.0464489236,
0.0275530946,
0.0101364609,
0.0521206707,
-0.0652655959,
-0.0294205062,
-0.0566159859,
-0.052611161,
-0.0903682262,
0.1008690223,
-0.0482952408,
-0.0184047371,
-0.0369736403,
0.017029494,
-0.0273764674,
-0.0603548698,
0.0152539592,
0.000609831,
-0.0484369881,
0.0048410757,
0.0053095184,
-0.0300936364,
0.0005547146,
0.0250298865,
0.0303944107,
0.0306070503,
-0.0058180196,
0.0135803511,
0.0209998768,
-0.0249774493,
-0.0088439956,
0.0270365216,
-0.0305216089,
-0.0280160625,
-0.0460009649,
-0.0221901126,
-0.0025241182,
0.002026692,
0.0004255261,
-0.0224178713,
0.0132556232,
-0.0331418067,
-0.0077779843,
-0.0240455624,
-0.0290655661,
0.01702605,
-0.0359555185,
0.0840350538,
-0.0084213596,
-0.0548854433,
0.0482070334,
0.0040961616,
0.0151557187,
0.0632569939,
0.0224788692,
0.0652430207,
0.0455279239,
-0.0009922208,
-0.0113586811,
0.0347208679,
0.0171989035,
-0.0086688204,
-0.0678774267,
-0.0255118906,
0.0315285809,
0.0291800611,
0.0626092926,
0.0732300803,
-0.0716807619,
0.0620075129,
0.0151732266,
0.0750423893,
0.01400265,
0.0328535587,
0.0611024126,
-0.023913851,
0.004041919,
0.0176695399,
-0.0273109581,
-0.0140878977,
0.0193391554,
0.0058906428,
0.0490934476,
-0.0079279793,
-0.0395162106,
-0.0459421463,
0.032001067,
-0.0144627271,
0.0416353047,
-0.0446470305,
0.0458109528,
0.0357078351,
-0.0411553793,
0.1066456437,
0.0072827269,
-0.0523172282,
0.0619434901,
-0.0845456421,
-0.0351259261,
0.0678164661,
0.0508115031,
-0.0290476214,
0.0001816282,
-0.0111311972,
0.0415318497,
0.0404399596,
-0.0055434532,
-0.0122602433,
0.0032807549,
-0.0305485465,
-0.0102625517,
-0.0048781815,
0.0208245181,
-0.0041810344,
-0.0311140157,
0.0047170026,
0.0223636217,
-0.0256338045,
-0.0332549177,
0.0612478107,
0.0137918955,
-0.0318092182,
0.0487185717,
0.0292957351,
0.0301291533,
0.0384352505,
0.0034708111,
0.0161015168,
0.0007666128,
-0.0648724064,
-0.0150788594,
-0.0093573211,
-0.0456310064,
-0.0376210362,
0.059902966,
0.0298087597,
0.0398286283,
0.0494283959,
-0.0473624878,
-0.0530160554,
0.0445293374,
-0.0121292071,
0.0457357839,
-0.0675967783,
0.0385832489,
-0.000271897,
-0.0108849071,
-0.0386206061,
0.007816961,
0.0033203745,
0.0366999507,
-0.0556514598,
0.0134178801,
0.0206215642,
-0.0452438816,
-0.0286935493,
-0.0071456344,
-0.0094831185,
0.0110314498,
0.0407272018,
0.0004900678,
-0.0036058901,
-0.0129414732,
-0.108153902,
-0.0053221518,
-0.022718275,
0.0142649412,
0.004423365,
0.0320346318,
0.0188024901,
-0.0141004669,
-0.0208378695,
-0.0047668945,
-0.0302403476,
-0.0021000691,
0.047252275,
0.0184930433,
-0.0085754078,
0.0081627769,
-0.0290862899,
0.0083948225,
0.0383227021,
-0.0167539213,
-0.0575385131,
-0.0816694498,
-0.0151477512,
0.005899745,
0.0299555697,
0.0297298655,
-0.0342557542,
0.0041268361,
-0.0095043443,
0.018306233,
0.0339889452,
0.0143187717,
0.0066195186,
0.0061682016,
0.0186653305,
-0.0486657321,
0.0339379162,
0.0010176431,
0.0357251279,
-0.0023107172,
-0.0166049302,
0.0621945523,
0.0535939969,
-0.0199697837,
-0.0120547395,
-0.0490155369,
-0.0049928748,
-0.0372856632,
-0.0172636453,
-0.0341659747,
-0.0338597149,
-0.0599457026,
-0.0422340259,
-0.0200384948,
-0.0091108894,
0.0453604944,
-0.0247633662,
0.0237493142,
-0.0889935568,
0.0028639839,
-0.0412527286,
0.0393911935,
-0.0108516384,
0.0259449501,
0.020675486,
-0.0628624782,
-0.0327724777,
0.0102980724,
-0.032802172,
0.0053912788,
0.0358442068,
-0.0088930912,
-0.0011847739,
-0.029577991,
-0.0037789673,
-0.0148330675,
-0.0283315945,
0.0159978159,
0.0630810335,
0.1057891026,
0.0274785627,
-0.0131688723,
0.0662173852,
-0.0346016437,
0.0646191165,
-0.0362410806,
0.0019506388,
-0.0169861894,
0.0369045101,
0.0293109436,
-0.0009550743,
-0.0388607942,
0.029145129,
0.0171285067,
0.0205131844,
0.0479671955,
-0.0695473179,
-0.020920679,
-0.0118073998,
0.033536315,
-0.0697787032,
-0.0212281514,
-0.0375609472,
0.0141304666,
-0.0298997182,
-0.0305312257,
0.1014938131,
0.0354613513,
-0.0630866289,
-0.0196266007,
0.000641944,
-0.0433143005,
-0.0061124885,
0.0050458536,
-0.0376749374,
-0.0127221588,
0.0207504425,
0.0418835506,
0.0509285927,
-0.011609586,
-0.0229780655,
-0.0750167817,
0.020211339,
-0.0004493336,
-0.0615759417,
-0.0260213464,
-0.0299804099,
-0.0181895811,
-0.0201344322,
0.0754263178,
0.0051459526,
0.0065907855,
-0.0020651664,
0.03214119,
-0.0296898521,
-0.0073926705,
-0.0358304679,
-0.051343374,
-0.0122135067,
0.0198183376,
0.0176415443,
-0.0236586425,
0.0345223136,
0.0917154998,
-0.0041240402,
0.0031224119,
-0.0327343084,
0.026774615,
-0.0108843213,
0.00666994,
0.0161582958,
-0.005243483,
0.0208330639,
-0.0222577136,
0.0023119256,
0.0604492798,
0.0108933486,
0.0252059214,
-0.0126371672,
-0.0245184172,
0.0015249189,
0.0549506098,
0.0335300379,
-0.0886177272,
-0.0143127823,
-0.011445133,
-0.0091743963,
-0.1003724113,
0.0477100648,
-0.0554265529,
-0.0659627542,
-0.0128872106,
-0.1094695255,
-0.0245908275,
-0.0076428098,
0.0483614989,
-0.0163950752,
0.0474795476,
-0.0175453592,
-0.01973968,
-0.0260657314,
0.0005794071,
0.0089405645,
0.0012543937,
-0.0704136342,
0.0265675727,
0.013015233,
-0.0380613357,
-0.0174754225,
0.0068670209,
-0.017316075,
-0.0379465036,
-0.0056470926,
0.0294176918,
0.0028765909,
0.0726646036,
-0.0245392285,
-0.0581447557,
0.0451847091,
0.0555154048,
-0.0499542058,
0.0085172784,
0.0136760511,
0.0095867282,
-0.0470849909,
0.0194269884,
-0.0458603576,
0.0101547176,
0.0326135941,
0.0207290351,
0.0136710787,
0.0422678329,
0.013761716,
0.0417194255,
0.0679169446,
-0.0243282821,
0.0103129316,
-0.0510315746,
0.0355287939,
-0.0329408981,
-0.0214793105,
-0.0421178713,
0.0191793088,
0.022487279,
-0.0335690193,
-0.0266482439,
-0.0088681066,
-0.0179949682,
0.0233585984,
0.007920905,
-0.0080785053,
-0.0660125837,
0.0431098789,
-0.018499814,
0.0233650301,
-0.0215311311,
-0.0610090978,
0.0135387871,
-0.0025703618,
-0.0938771069,
-0.0270932112,
0.0255975146,
0.0297856014,
-0.0856303573,
0.0483191721,
-0.0296171606,
0.0069709793,
-0.0542549305,
0.0007832217,
0.0081298752,
0.0065896148,
-0.0094904872,
-0.0120886359,
-0.0444715582,
-0.0090969987,
-0.0037137235,
0.0274321437,
-0.0054076496,
0.0032227959,
-0.0046551628,
-0.0130836498,
-0.0661819875,
0.067439355,
0.0319108814,
0.0197090115,
-0.0125863925,
-0.0240167659,
-0.0467822626,
0.0298286248,
0.0052660718,
0.0632843301,
-0.0216383152,
-0.0298288837,
0.0019189027,
-0.037763156,
0.0284209475,
-0.0134176807,
-0.0209510382,
0.0250996668,
0.0290275253,
0.026444409,
0.010279648,
-0.0201995373,
-0.0107034529,
0.0075502605,
0.0505811311,
-0.0174318589,
-0.0083787721,
-5.577530044e-33,
-0.0304105151,
0.0192003585,
0.0279886685,
-0.0088371504,
-0.0343578756,
0.0034768612,
-0.012005521,
-0.0366916172,
0.0345100909,
-0.0037201496,
-0.0290154684,
0.0091600362,
0.0212719571,
0.0429035835,
0.0069828392,
0.0299483407,
0.0718880519,
-0.0330559425,
-0.0036286782,
0.0201193243,
0.0633204132,
0.0556086153,
0.0256739762,
-0.0238301903,
0.0044224779,
0.0328002051,
0.0021829328,
0.0352462865,
0.0564612225,
0.0565683953,
-0.0185688492,
0.0374871753,
0.0315156057,
-0.0602991134,
-0.0111178709,
0.0311878268,
-0.1140188426,
-0.0470584109,
0.0240533911,
0.0309025403,
-0.0127167217,
-0.0872633681,
0.0578541271,
0.0133002773,
-0.0224199835,
0.0196116045,
0.0055276733,
-0.034490183,
-0.0349143222,
-0.0268583074,
-0.0584831759,
-0.0132194394,
0.027830055,
0.0206359699,
0.056771718,
0.0035597207,
-0.0156891514,
-0.0181768592,
-0.0734098703,
-0.0135507332,
-0.0037683167,
0.0212831311,
0.038500499,
0.0546227247,
-0.012237356,
0.019385267,
0.0587368235,
-0.0079699652,
-0.0075741806,
0.0080366479,
0.0286931675,
0.0145784384,
0.0523942411,
-0.024306627,
0.0394089669,
-0.040950384,
-0.0714550763,
0.0230153818,
-0.0119960699,
0.039844431,
0.0255504586,
0.030760007,
-0.0036126105,
-0.0425992869,
-0.0093444614,
-0.0192284565,
-0.0361114033,
-0.0312313717,
0.0209095068,
0.0472685769,
-0.0231270678,
-0.0097510302,
0.0255094506,
-0.0225046612,
0.0087389443,
0.0272142105,
0.034922123,
-0.0088653043,
-0.0075310199,
-0.0269612726,
-0.0294335037,
-0.0499477908,
-0.0052498658,
0.0016527186,
-0.0222190898,
-0.0259505138,
0.0708499551,
-0.0111746117,
-0.0396252014,
0.029939618,
0.0108496007,
0.0102562299,
0.0147526031,
0.0711374283,
0.0380166881,
-0.0010451954,
0.0085380496,
0.0160211176,
0.0534205623,
-0.0221306011,
-0.0138098756,
-0.0019113093,
0.0188456699,
0.0201034453,
-0.0040535815,
0.0346650891,
0.0221326277,
0.0404009372,
0.0137418117,
-0.044536557,
-0.0154453777,
0.032140702,
2.433e-7,
0.0532783121,
0.0348145403,
0.0293789692,
-0.0502702594,
-0.007381103,
-0.0052439845,
0.0084223961,
0.0060481108,
0.0019899916,
0.0780666471,
-0.0055859047,
-0.0454472415,
0.0172711611,
0.0100637954,
-0.1310627609,
0.0142803397,
-0.0246335715,
0.0478885807,
-0.010651269,
0.0166064948,
0.0361700542,
0.0832686946,
-0.0185454749,
-0.0152308019,
-0.042908445,
-0.0700602978,
0.021274196,
-0.0042314027,
-0.0110914623,
0.0376651064,
0.0184966363,
0.0095043443,
0.0168863051,
-0.0016733692,
-0.0453798473,
0.0383693017,
0.0503701456,
0.0246485416,
-0.0276218317,
-0.0285100322,
0.0124620479,
-0.0003044967,
0.0150777176,
-0.0372732058,
0.0458429269,
-0.0552376099,
0.0290756207,
-0.0279272553,
-0.0275472756,
0.0179194845,
-0.0413377583,
-0.0124462806,
-0.0241305642,
0.047177881,
0.0236301366,
0.0189882759,
-0.0143037634,
-0.0937196836,
-0.0160523411,
0.0073760175,
-0.0306905489,
-0.0384604782,
-0.0381125286,
0.0568703599,
0.0579438731,
-0.0387393348,
0.0011313562,
2.09463795e-34,
0.0587184317,
-0.0146399494,
0.0185695328,
0.0489753,
-0.0012875829,
-0.0170986168,
-0.0364933498,
0.0459473766,
0.0183565971,
-0.0637136102,
-0.0079790605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10785v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10785v2 | Which Factors Predict the Chat Experience of a Natural Language Generation Dialogue Service? | 2023-04-21T07:29:07 | 2023-05-28T02:26:24 | Eason Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In this paper, we proposed a conceptual model to predict the chat experience
in a natural language generation dialog system. We evaluated the model with 120
participants with Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM)
and obtained an R-square (R2) with 0.541. The model considers various factors,
including the prompts used for generation; coherence, sentiment, and similarity
in the conversation; and users' perceived dialog agents' favorability. We then
further explore the effectiveness of the subset of our proposed model. The
results showed that users' favorability and coherence, sentiment, and
similarity in the dialogue are positive predictors of users' chat experience.
Moreover, we found users may prefer dialog agents with characteristics of
Extroversion, Openness, Conscientiousness, Agreeableness, and Non-Neuroticism.
Through our research, an adaptive dialog system might use collected data to
infer factors in our model, predict the chat experience for users through these
factors, and optimize it by adjusting prompts. | [
0.0781875327,
-0.0286843106,
-0.0334945284,
-0.0047753924,
-0.0230972059,
0.0052966168,
0.0358627588,
-0.0364055075,
0.0664600134,
-0.0404505767,
-0.0459412187,
-0.0272653606,
-0.0186825115,
0.100291498,
-0.0139986426,
-0.0511142947,
0.0261532832,
0.0177512225,
0.0683990046,
0.0325747542,
0.0299628805,
0.0167439431,
-0.0230931826,
0.044773519,
-0.0042258804,
0.0020669799,
-0.0238961875,
0.0074963635,
-0.0120604718,
-0.0274961889,
0.0489616953,
0.0441872925,
0.0141449664,
-0.0285523366,
0.0000020353,
-0.079128243,
0.003029,
-0.0029924016,
-0.0386131555,
-0.0203193948,
0.0667226166,
0.0844060555,
-0.0237943307,
0.0584300086,
-0.0249142256,
0.0290281586,
0.060115207,
0.0296915118,
0.0730400458,
0.0422324166,
-0.0300480463,
0.013615679,
-0.0537199304,
0.0328392759,
0.0272193197,
-0.0125970477,
-0.040635556,
0.0062185563,
0.0010972925,
-0.0032907377,
0.026479207,
-0.0044879182,
-0.0524596497,
-0.0654384717,
0.0211021397,
0.008947622,
0.0067713214,
-0.0598673932,
0.0019606669,
0.0667631775,
0.0915982947,
0.0280794092,
0.0058117202,
0.0043201335,
0.0413184091,
-0.013578265,
-0.0440911576,
0.0137327174,
-0.02927077,
-0.0150428461,
0.0050522573,
0.0161726288,
-0.0372877084,
0.0035750472,
0.0381362662,
-0.0090559069,
0.0074070315,
-0.0167826489,
-0.0429920703,
-0.0033498746,
0.0314692892,
-0.0584294274,
0.0293059852,
0.0155453272,
-0.0926557109,
0.0421716496,
-0.0049053924,
-0.014209359,
0.0182963442,
-0.0479635745,
-0.0388139114,
0.0435139462,
0.0304445121,
0.0171570461,
0.0067886617,
0.0238385983,
0.059139479,
-0.0210951921,
-0.0155157112,
-0.0113585629,
-0.034233246,
-0.0110705551,
-0.0316830948,
0.0594585389,
-0.007963161,
-0.0445105769,
-0.0533946082,
0.0643375367,
0.0339428745,
-0.0199269429,
0.0113913296,
0.0209473874,
-0.0154665457,
0.0461731181,
-0.0511430427,
0.02311581,
-0.0575822629,
0.0000812844,
0.0075094663,
-0.0673688799,
0.0640170276,
0.034073811,
0.0423195735,
0.0076604164,
-0.0154909575,
0.0472023785,
-0.0241444297,
-0.0207964648,
-0.0587732866,
-0.0333015509,
-0.0034448907,
-0.0399079993,
-0.0490200669,
0.0035229819,
0.0313859805,
0.0384217687,
-0.0540797599,
0.0186464116,
0.0101212915,
0.0476743765,
-0.0120067755,
-0.0020537069,
-0.0497444049,
0.0224330984,
0.0490323007,
0.0187379401,
0.0063773994,
-0.0025669057,
0.0089877732,
0.0144385882,
0.0430942513,
-0.0195496324,
0.0018459212,
-0.015860945,
-0.0521225259,
-0.0120174177,
0.0340070575,
0.0210159682,
-0.0580928512,
0.0055954466,
-0.0093672387,
0.065016143,
-0.0436394215,
0.0156419519,
0.0596342273,
0.0562396646,
0.0314001143,
0.0700964481,
0.0134694874,
0.0562187321,
-0.0058056978,
0.0041538733,
0.0242350884,
0.0621895827,
-0.0101346178,
0.0362914279,
0.0393598899,
0.011532966,
-0.0214521382,
-0.09222541,
-0.0009651778,
-0.0182204377,
0.0256266873,
-0.0042996802,
0.0009776823,
-0.0061085336,
-0.0632111952,
0.0233796947,
-0.0025189726,
-0.1086053774,
-0.0236815047,
-0.0271965023,
0.0456665345,
0.114896521,
0.0118171452,
0.0269488022,
-0.0711542293,
-0.0266238153,
-0.0316882618,
0.0340040401,
0.0472205617,
-0.0007466097,
-0.0014102203,
-0.0494083874,
-0.0055250749,
0.0020012716,
-0.02498045,
0.0189787783,
-0.0302968472,
0.0366109423,
0.0176756773,
0.0620128363,
0.0091687627,
-0.0068153776,
-0.0037188383,
-0.0062358296,
-0.0183613468,
0.0059573241,
0.0497960821,
0.0567374416,
-0.0043119555,
0.018865237,
-0.0002983656,
0.0385023169,
-0.0454530641,
0.0890758857,
-0.040807426,
-0.0181924291,
-0.0013018439,
-0.0199463889,
0.0148703326,
-0.0293168798,
0.0116276713,
-0.0400217921,
0.0901159793,
-0.0547373854,
0.0185362063,
-0.0345500708,
0.0202139262,
0.0014401609,
-0.0076260203,
-0.0083070323,
0.0116910394,
0.0024494999,
0.0152393905,
0.0604892075,
-0.0014642351,
0.0231089927,
-0.0266457871,
-0.0014433969,
0.0033614167,
-0.0230861567,
0.0042382209,
0.0370414369,
0.0018595981,
-0.0560244955,
-0.0374796018,
-0.0886347443,
0.0090210289,
0.0113987848,
-0.0003181215,
0.041362565,
0.012011487,
-0.0184006765,
-0.0244281944,
-0.0731244609,
0.0184387974,
0.0557346828,
0.0001627902,
0.0330019072,
-0.0017461247,
-0.0403505825,
-0.0639586449,
0.021749692,
0.0113589074,
0.0016805076,
0.0569962561,
-0.0134236757,
-0.0430698469,
0.0272727665,
-0.0879243612,
-0.0145638557,
-0.0035034644,
-0.0732008815,
0.0266232695,
0.0168827716,
0.0019925309,
0.0026308319,
0.0890700072,
0.0212489814,
-0.0336151496,
-0.0193794612,
-0.0427116938,
0.0059299693,
-0.0103520239,
-0.002352372,
0.0111074373,
-0.0671804696,
0.0606988892,
0.0144738154,
0.0278539043,
0.0272092465,
-0.0150933871,
0.0278443377,
-0.0043503558,
0.0012532088,
0.0204692241,
-0.0278354082,
-0.0088043176,
0.0250129476,
0.0254773777,
-0.0558086522,
0.0520288758,
-0.0007697561,
-0.0365633704,
-0.0607491992,
-0.0356424302,
-0.0380774736,
0.0128254797,
-0.0419465601,
0.0462254286,
0.0415188819,
-0.040244896,
-0.0173505042,
-0.0315325819,
0.0605513193,
-0.0360696279,
-0.0169583708,
0.0014755602,
-0.0163958464,
0.0378613509,
-0.0347609222,
-0.0335768387,
-0.0370809883,
0.0027884624,
-0.0259138606,
0.0925486833,
0.0057313116,
-0.0206023883,
0.018516019,
-0.0028208555,
-0.0172482431,
0.0062869252,
-0.0205771849,
-0.0039475611,
0.0014728876,
0.0474039912,
0.0223939624,
0.0110088103,
-0.0123658516,
0.0534319282,
0.0304736849,
-0.061860431,
-0.0353085175,
0.0065618898,
-0.0227382425,
0.0110212062,
0.0102668777,
-0.0357191414,
0.0414163731,
0.0335108414,
0.0022314712,
0.0142638069,
0.1107280031,
0.0288797151,
0.0136591448,
-0.0319116153,
-0.0518542975,
0.0141534992,
0.0292748623,
0.0114320768,
-0.0078585958,
-0.0044321823,
-0.0300363339,
0.0064158156,
-0.0142978951,
-0.0278766621,
-0.0077858269,
-0.0618297458,
0.0330570601,
-0.0104507674,
-0.0342875272,
0.0128805423,
0.012031585,
-0.0205906685,
0.0246024206,
0.0154103786,
0.0134064043,
-0.0222354438,
-0.0069699693,
0.0080176322,
-0.0419174768,
0.0243766122,
-0.0107680419,
-0.0621183887,
0.0746758357,
0.0497038849,
0.0428491272,
0.0285667758,
-0.0244783722,
0.000311912,
0.0551253818,
0.0316525474,
-0.0152356876,
0.044337593,
-0.0030113063,
0.0162832886,
-0.1088840067,
0.0166203473,
0.000186907,
0.0252206288,
0.0052974494,
-0.0108395535,
-0.008342145,
-0.0163010061,
-0.0124650272,
0.0667854175,
0.0455022901,
0.0478498004,
0.008059267,
-0.0514530614,
-0.036024414,
-0.0075426791,
0.0073684608,
0.0084790969,
0.0156177189,
-0.0140582668,
-0.0126150725,
0.0114540085,
-0.1148048043,
-0.0468237959,
-0.0165713988,
-0.0052022836,
-0.0251636636,
0.0182106681,
0.0039512003,
0.0007345716,
0.0355729312,
-0.0438797921,
0.0306294262,
-0.0071980893,
-0.0502199456,
-0.0023722723,
0.030970607,
-0.0682540461,
0.0258191917,
-0.0201397054,
-0.0061277687,
-0.0259960033,
-0.0414468572,
0.064630121,
0.0178186111,
-0.0243701525,
0.0165536497,
-0.0198840797,
-0.0228470936,
0.0109029282,
-0.0319607891,
-0.012327251,
-0.0086147394,
0.1096091494,
0.0043642973,
0.0002684341,
-0.00758436,
-0.0302156769,
-0.0560559891,
0.0009869718,
0.0305949394,
-0.0809570551,
-0.0098279053,
0.0508150309,
-0.0262062345,
0.0207322724,
0.0249176677,
-0.0130494814,
0.0024902371,
-0.0340330303,
-0.0183903966,
-0.0437048413,
-0.0090834824,
-0.0489239655,
-0.0105512068,
0.0200849324,
-0.0219860151,
-0.0818790793,
0.0434050187,
-0.0007594292,
0.0177025609,
0.0105050923,
-0.0329985768,
-0.0059014503,
-0.0114291618,
-0.0362979025,
0.0241054781,
0.0322236978,
-0.0008473538,
-0.0055007352,
0.1104415283,
-0.0439686514,
-0.0245313291,
0.0385160074,
0.0301953852,
0.0081446087,
-0.0490449481,
-0.0202453882,
0.0199090485,
-0.003726339,
0.0050916383,
0.0457182005,
-0.024526637,
0.0467849597,
-0.0164779779,
0.075265862,
0.0105825597,
-0.0483325906,
0.0262859017,
-0.0040346337,
-0.0240049399,
-0.0380056538,
0.0501320213,
-0.0282868724,
-0.0203500018,
-0.0272852648,
-0.042156335,
-0.0445544906,
0.0018512536,
0.0064128386,
0.0121047394,
0.0063305818,
-0.0089015812,
-0.041696921,
-0.0241190325,
-0.0219422802,
-0.0249380153,
0.0413162,
-0.0261151176,
0.0566395484,
0.043273028,
-0.0142502673,
-0.0251607597,
-0.0432475097,
-0.0089336783,
-0.0700622797,
0.0209129918,
-0.0308831576,
-5.98595776e-33,
-0.0081804171,
-0.0446889661,
0.0296348557,
0.0351474285,
-0.02051498,
-0.0620309673,
-0.0604793839,
0.0513725765,
0.0167834833,
-0.0268104244,
0.0055646347,
-0.0034877269,
-0.0014282472,
0.0134470593,
-0.0127315074,
-0.0124945752,
0.0554652102,
-0.0083793486,
-0.0166965909,
0.0262060482,
0.0450663827,
0.0013078244,
0.0001906436,
-0.0834516659,
0.0306177251,
-0.041757483,
0.0077311154,
-0.00768614,
0.0614384413,
0.0208989959,
0.0330133103,
0.0005130991,
0.0228266399,
-0.0067865443,
-0.0202643368,
0.028675342,
0.0217908043,
-0.0368089564,
0.0274530053,
0.0020693489,
-0.0169884283,
-0.0004083981,
0.0105432086,
-0.023898907,
-0.0030296948,
0.0359303057,
0.0205433425,
0.0070854705,
0.0024067799,
-0.0137017285,
-0.0710538328,
0.0018853731,
-0.0337730125,
-0.0492569506,
-0.0553491749,
0.0932969376,
-0.0092100948,
-0.0621248223,
-0.0053541474,
0.0512035154,
-0.0030329954,
-0.0223565679,
0.0460653901,
-0.0044894102,
0.0035958604,
0.0199042,
0.0256962143,
0.0404644124,
-0.059349183,
0.005799999,
-0.0132665485,
0.0459213816,
0.0334158763,
0.0538945049,
-0.009808029,
-0.0535014309,
-0.010416518,
0.0470962413,
0.0524363704,
0.0083173849,
0.0332026891,
0.0292314403,
-0.0378256179,
-0.0235068165,
-0.0348535962,
0.0214236509,
-0.0500864424,
-0.0940321013,
0.014700545,
0.009732184,
-0.0158521682,
-0.1104251146,
0.0139751947,
0.0089571504,
-0.0096346652,
0.0183793288,
-0.0435006544,
0.0090300143,
-0.0296231806,
-0.046844773,
-0.0287248734,
-0.0073894765,
0.0072194678,
0.0128113339,
0.0050337282,
0.0306698345,
-0.0316898376,
0.0098476261,
-0.0375206918,
0.0194785576,
-0.0020519996,
0.0435513668,
0.0170819741,
-0.0158109907,
-0.007199246,
-0.0286656171,
-0.0516649373,
0.0677628592,
-0.0218618717,
0.0123895276,
-0.0613723584,
-0.0469496995,
0.045232553,
-0.0046989718,
-0.0435629971,
0.0152091924,
-0.009472115,
-0.0066915005,
0.0245752987,
-0.0179153439,
-0.0059153065,
-0.0427551754,
2.929e-7,
-0.0427698158,
0.0419815704,
-0.0337000862,
0.0093558207,
0.0407929681,
0.0626930743,
0.0322090015,
0.0133472877,
0.0541844927,
0.0062636812,
0.0150121106,
-0.0265517458,
0.0168299004,
0.0276951957,
-0.1100289151,
-0.0329711996,
-0.0558855236,
-0.0107666459,
-0.0107256426,
0.0521706156,
0.0915510654,
-0.0103728455,
-0.0320128873,
0.0111273471,
-0.010055623,
-0.0196652543,
0.0303935166,
-0.0487621352,
-0.0096622715,
0.0334844962,
0.0448210612,
-0.0067346976,
0.0017334563,
0.0067431084,
-0.0229789056,
0.0029089032,
0.0174477268,
0.0443377122,
0.0278061498,
-0.0253911261,
0.0674307123,
0.0138768079,
-0.001032063,
-0.028515663,
0.0052299043,
-0.0392914452,
-0.053084109,
-0.0180251002,
0.007886624,
-0.0439147353,
-0.0033577983,
-0.0566069558,
-0.0172351375,
0.0187223144,
-0.0165595394,
-0.0134120025,
0.0168065615,
-0.0063319299,
0.0002912333,
-0.0267979298,
-0.0210857317,
-0.0499138683,
-0.0503102429,
0.0233983453,
0.0095186736,
0.029150784,
0.0316322595,
1.856691146e-34,
0.0005229469,
0.0112895779,
0.0245739203,
0.0244608503,
0.0882276967,
0.0296292324,
0.0290930718,
0.0140953586,
0.0483162813,
-0.0329221897,
-0.0066029327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10784v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10784v2 | Eyettention: An Attention-based Dual-Sequence Model for Predicting Human Scanpaths during Reading | 2023-04-21T07:26:49 | 2023-05-18T08:24:03 | Shuwen Deng, David R. Reich, Paul Prasse, Patrick Haller, Tobias Scheffer, Lena A. Jäger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Eye movements during reading offer insights into both the reader's cognitive
processes and the characteristics of the text that is being read. Hence, the
analysis of scanpaths in reading have attracted increasing attention across
fields, ranging from cognitive science over linguistics to computer science. In
particular, eye-tracking-while-reading data has been argued to bear the
potential to make machine-learning-based language models exhibit a more
human-like linguistic behavior. However, one of the main challenges in modeling
human scanpaths in reading is their dual-sequence nature: the words are ordered
following the grammatical rules of the language, whereas the fixations are
chronologically ordered. As humans do not strictly read from left-to-right, but
rather skip or refixate words and regress to previous words, the alignment of
the linguistic and the temporal sequence is non-trivial. In this paper, we
develop Eyettention, the first dual-sequence model that simultaneously
processes the sequence of words and the chronological sequence of fixations.
The alignment of the two sequences is achieved by a cross-sequence attention
mechanism. We show that Eyettention outperforms state-of-the-art models in
predicting scanpaths. We provide an extensive within- and across-data set
evaluation on different languages. An ablation study and qualitative analysis
support an in-depth understanding of the model's behavior. | [
0.0146773765,
0.0159620643,
-0.027581064,
0.0356544591,
-0.0173928514,
0.012221382,
-0.0081086317,
-0.0186130181,
0.0254775789,
-0.0219753943,
0.003164171,
-0.0408847854,
0.0562929176,
0.0227910988,
0.036885947,
-0.0552376211,
0.0415262394,
-0.0658746958,
-0.0254208688,
0.0565450415,
0.0408534631,
0.0112901395,
-0.0043095453,
0.0263145734,
0.0327478535,
-0.0348644219,
-0.0600916669,
-0.010325429,
0.0526173376,
-0.017624341,
0.0220216773,
0.072946988,
-0.0334578678,
0.043255344,
0.000001798,
0.0086996024,
0.001134187,
-0.0169684198,
0.0389534943,
0.0342805125,
0.0316826813,
-0.0133034596,
-0.0103273354,
-0.0181409214,
-0.0090011628,
0.0110608889,
0.0430460498,
-0.0101407934,
0.0271847155,
0.014739072,
-0.0028325054,
0.0100450562,
0.0474788137,
-0.0262422748,
0.012347172,
-0.0238572024,
0.0082009025,
-0.0329807736,
-0.0109711811,
0.0595955625,
-0.0501427352,
0.031515114,
-0.0160841607,
0.017068414,
0.0405576006,
0.0332493074,
0.0018410427,
-0.006907199,
-0.035782747,
0.0771998093,
-0.0256615691,
-0.0776926652,
0.0079085119,
-0.0149867292,
0.0005385774,
0.0083991084,
-0.0306871347,
0.0083655175,
-0.0093362601,
0.0284627508,
0.0847864673,
0.0041157096,
-0.0043085036,
-0.002823292,
-0.0069744978,
0.0468157195,
0.0050181239,
-0.0555509254,
0.0039929375,
0.0354684182,
0.0557230897,
-0.0246411134,
0.0450689681,
0.0169485584,
0.0459668972,
0.0094439471,
-0.0448773466,
-0.0951811075,
0.0056857639,
0.0010575157,
0.0241014883,
0.0409411155,
-0.0548543073,
0.0101361005,
-0.0144513724,
0.0358022302,
-0.0217450354,
-0.0016992514,
-0.0524167009,
0.0398249254,
0.0257409271,
0.0066894745,
-0.0113845989,
-0.0329236574,
-0.0324886031,
-0.048856698,
-0.0605590381,
0.0333226509,
0.0544574037,
-0.0479652397,
-0.0070123039,
0.0082915379,
0.0038490896,
-0.0014165801,
0.025719855,
0.0231139548,
-0.0410236195,
0.0140172308,
-0.0064371894,
-0.0252017211,
-0.0173572805,
0.0441124588,
-0.0200910401,
-0.0033530924,
-0.0596413277,
0.0288555771,
-0.0312604308,
-0.0489275604,
-0.0370599665,
-0.0093501033,
-0.0231898855,
-0.0174114052,
-0.02006015,
-0.0481858924,
0.0067643696,
0.0265520159,
-0.0013804791,
-0.0411486961,
-0.0019756062,
0.0478492901,
-0.0247543901,
0.0334013402,
-0.0110446783,
0.0113227386,
-0.0280967299,
-0.0002144676,
0.0312313978,
0.0130846314,
0.0258548204,
-0.0173369423,
0.0183773171,
-0.0356826931,
-0.0003462862,
0.0709262043,
-0.0102275973,
-0.0168659668,
0.0126625365,
-0.0360840894,
-0.0195903517,
0.0187306944,
0.0580104478,
0.0498470254,
-0.0105407014,
-0.0573839843,
0.0475272723,
0.0878011212,
-0.0155607201,
0.001339254,
0.01023643,
0.0110495305,
-0.0181419346,
0.0648747608,
-0.0138352048,
0.0068556471,
-0.007611305,
0.0271623861,
0.0025417351,
-0.0274640936,
0.0100123836,
-0.03184513,
-0.012894541,
0.0224413704,
0.0343464091,
-0.0011957714,
0.0491913296,
-0.0218696538,
-0.0615830049,
0.02514988,
0.0024904881,
-0.0478157885,
-0.0310530066,
0.0194358081,
-0.0030364448,
0.0766748339,
0.0264874864,
-0.0313992798,
-0.0596565157,
0.0192796737,
0.0074199792,
0.0205667838,
0.0096273879,
0.024604369,
-0.0220037177,
-0.0606658682,
0.0110565135,
0.0578114912,
-0.0112760691,
-0.0019444005,
-0.0431375578,
0.02378878,
0.0033316202,
0.0124859428,
-0.0761225522,
0.0598444194,
-0.0333529674,
0.0113417106,
-0.0531155318,
0.0202906244,
0.0170941819,
-0.0085647469,
0.0162245724,
0.0158781949,
0.0410563536,
0.0020975205,
0.0837681219,
0.0283775721,
-0.0264256988,
0.00767005,
0.0259834975,
-0.056400802,
-0.0343998373,
0.0442735106,
0.0444033183,
-0.0299005806,
-0.0130332075,
-0.0444910638,
-0.007464773,
-0.0151279429,
0.0432586893,
0.0309382658,
0.0350447409,
-0.0536785871,
0.037068136,
-0.0655211881,
0.0608678423,
0.0233540032,
-0.0396237001,
-0.0068950104,
-0.0426358096,
0.0010994335,
-0.0039673615,
0.0257443078,
-0.0289527811,
-0.0085490625,
-0.0214739349,
-0.0513169579,
-0.0165968519,
-0.0486009493,
-0.019210292,
-0.0197500866,
0.0528063327,
0.0210396312,
-0.0127468798,
-0.0113387173,
-0.0239482597,
-0.0350955538,
0.0565937459,
-0.0011306404,
-0.0075230142,
0.051892776,
-0.0344539136,
-0.0057408195,
-0.069592759,
-0.0209660549,
-0.0427895188,
0.0303699002,
0.025626963,
-0.0282725114,
-0.0792249888,
0.0135003757,
0.0225891098,
0.0044335993,
-0.0312116649,
-0.02891865,
0.0196110439,
-0.0309626423,
0.0184616242,
0.1064105406,
0.018683387,
0.0224130172,
0.0177583806,
-0.0547243841,
-0.0139533356,
-0.0035542885,
0.0123386402,
0.0474582873,
-0.0232451595,
-0.0433116592,
0.0083167441,
0.0889405012,
-0.0210700072,
-0.0061870036,
-0.0261166189,
-0.0011174256,
-0.0167698823,
-0.0422019735,
-0.0297206007,
0.0053003295,
-0.0710126981,
0.0497852527,
-0.0214447919,
-0.0502004065,
0.052414529,
-0.0186763182,
-0.0385147743,
-0.0396148786,
0.041171331,
-0.0243743993,
0.0608329959,
0.036813695,
-0.0132478699,
-0.0082341619,
-0.0662917495,
-0.0519521683,
0.0265242811,
0.0016761729,
-0.023060089,
0.0943379402,
-0.04697676,
-0.0038726875,
0.0069095767,
0.0282962341,
-0.0267544594,
-0.0119471662,
-0.0483850241,
-0.0485291183,
-0.0011023055,
0.0041301553,
-0.0676205531,
0.0390349254,
0.0243377239,
0.054201819,
-0.0013342237,
-0.0079257004,
-0.0242037307,
0.0465757735,
0.0536887795,
-0.0196211282,
-0.0141191715,
-0.0407042913,
-0.0399614424,
0.0871435478,
0.0067090513,
0.0025595764,
-0.004533052,
0.0038761559,
0.0746098608,
-0.058340393,
-0.0389268734,
0.0069802385,
-0.0135034584,
-0.1051131263,
-0.0060865292,
0.0921002403,
0.0490385368,
-0.033181414,
0.0069468706,
-0.0096519208,
0.0405295752,
-0.0203008913,
-0.0122934617,
-0.0479278043,
-0.0395756066,
0.0156550128,
0.0410058796,
0.0324131958,
-0.0229876637,
0.0161908902,
-0.0471594147,
0.0115881246,
0.0214738827,
-0.0543101206,
-0.028631255,
-0.0005269987,
0.0343730077,
0.0007134046,
-0.0277450569,
0.0479149185,
-0.0182065293,
0.007737794,
0.0014084382,
0.0031659571,
0.0501070917,
-0.0255574584,
-0.0183129068,
-0.0307879802,
0.0303253662,
0.0209965631,
0.0024917414,
-0.0442685634,
0.0037774793,
-0.0696449056,
-0.005576185,
0.0179282594,
0.0227829162,
-0.0285476241,
-0.0009314783,
-0.0742359534,
0.0612879805,
-0.0660718679,
-0.0147962738,
0.0042819013,
0.0445689335,
0.0117340172,
-0.0327097774,
-0.0186943822,
0.0019741179,
-0.0165908076,
0.0353771225,
0.021601487,
-0.0578239486,
-0.0519778803,
-0.0379202776,
0.0276332218,
-0.0542202182,
-0.0865128562,
0.007048747,
0.0374452434,
-0.0617812276,
-0.0799409524,
-0.1035936847,
-0.0133440578,
0.0118351467,
0.0524472371,
0.0290210079,
0.0939565524,
-0.0532848909,
-0.0243159048,
0.0286785513,
0.0280881636,
0.0187633019,
-0.0635853931,
-0.015528365,
0.0074490523,
-0.009831991,
0.0002176633,
0.0739613324,
-0.0686756298,
-0.0549284816,
0.0181828849,
0.0301812086,
0.01754741,
0.0148087973,
-0.0073091309,
-0.0294428933,
-0.0410719328,
-0.0326102674,
0.0036042875,
0.0266109463,
-0.001232,
-0.0297510605,
-0.0139777213,
0.0083104158,
0.0129939541,
-0.0087494561,
-0.0096580628,
-0.0017469613,
-0.0629845634,
-0.0631140247,
0.0000039166,
-0.0198754389,
0.060362421,
-0.0074594663,
-0.0028730868,
-0.0531694107,
0.0050312486,
-0.0067905029,
0.0011862302,
-0.0013556285,
0.0150161413,
0.0392741263,
0.0143764392,
-0.0236591641,
-0.0395689458,
-0.0247648358,
-0.0513762608,
-0.0337895341,
0.0575585105,
0.0176297035,
0.0321124196,
-0.0067279059,
0.0127360122,
0.0089956541,
0.0342469886,
-0.0469157323,
0.0689840987,
0.0175500996,
0.0387038775,
0.0185262859,
0.0221443214,
0.0250564124,
0.017004339,
-0.045950707,
0.0826027989,
0.0253544282,
-0.0237725843,
0.0456185751,
-0.0617302619,
0.1023588926,
-0.0013247845,
0.0060885684,
-0.036547754,
0.0559587069,
0.0097281588,
0.0105541777,
-0.0620744266,
0.0264021195,
0.0268457048,
-0.0069057317,
0.0815242976,
0.0191990398,
-0.0348676704,
0.0399334282,
-0.0650935248,
-0.0456753671,
0.0098380083,
0.0007142059,
0.0107389605,
-0.0256741643,
0.0198090058,
-0.0545749143,
-0.038622845,
0.0550308116,
0.0109335454,
0.0636996031,
-0.0251059309,
0.0690931827,
0.046650745,
-0.0310632139,
0.0029423621,
-0.0667099655,
0.0248682629,
-0.0326410793,
-0.0620301329,
-0.0605820566,
-5.533398313e-33,
0.0031347508,
-0.0377011672,
-0.0165264178,
0.0262737442,
-0.0469431803,
0.0256895162,
-0.0255645141,
0.0225844402,
0.0340690538,
-0.0092552416,
-0.000245965,
0.0035601766,
0.0118131386,
0.0057675978,
0.0353897102,
0.0045714509,
-0.0091167539,
-0.0104760723,
-0.023046596,
0.0065119849,
0.0359847508,
0.0040938961,
0.0296019055,
0.0219321549,
0.0348665752,
-0.0561727732,
0.0342714451,
-0.0354931504,
0.0131611479,
0.0518601723,
-0.0319848023,
0.0543611906,
0.0252799243,
0.0109386593,
-0.0188178606,
0.0842760578,
-0.0683413297,
-0.0006631939,
0.0140247941,
0.0504770353,
-0.0516047589,
-0.0187395066,
0.0526603498,
-0.0106547028,
0.0154857961,
0.0106532555,
0.0596089326,
-0.0217504501,
-0.0455669984,
0.0286000539,
-0.0645458922,
0.022691356,
-0.0751750246,
-0.0342470929,
0.0583387539,
0.0565411076,
0.0226065423,
0.0151951285,
-0.0764586627,
0.0263283383,
0.0163606554,
0.048018191,
0.0471960455,
0.0409528837,
-0.0167036653,
0.0358231142,
0.0326098055,
-0.0041466155,
-0.0133190332,
0.0255701337,
0.0502315424,
0.0027010776,
0.0039924197,
-0.0162326712,
0.0076245428,
0.0329588279,
-0.0399817824,
0.0060691023,
0.0477817133,
0.0409113988,
0.0467330404,
-0.0097118085,
-0.0653481185,
-0.0030951332,
0.0035714379,
-0.0463084839,
-0.0194260012,
0.0164980218,
0.0347478762,
-0.0053375852,
0.0108896159,
0.0052256235,
0.0452357419,
-0.015832467,
0.0109256925,
0.0447950363,
-0.0257038884,
0.0293336995,
-0.002106786,
0.0437970459,
-0.0440926924,
-0.0074422327,
0.0006133101,
0.006767259,
0.0261168852,
-0.0075182803,
-0.0111464309,
-0.056307096,
-0.0296977628,
-0.0126826204,
-0.0053560496,
-0.00638864,
0.0007942353,
0.0329698808,
0.0748672634,
-0.0436571725,
-0.0038065116,
0.0626707748,
-0.0056769815,
0.0123577788,
-0.0447361991,
-0.0200946983,
-0.0285155438,
0.0015253687,
-0.0211364068,
0.0155604603,
0.0011075878,
0.031669993,
-0.0189410411,
-0.0630518645,
-0.0064114328,
0.0664049089,
2.457e-7,
0.0514824726,
0.0529031195,
0.0582215898,
0.0229064338,
0.0353812911,
0.000707618,
0.0049137902,
0.0444932841,
0.0064342925,
-0.0301052891,
0.0216948967,
0.0048583467,
0.0270162746,
-0.0532999188,
-0.1021237075,
-0.0354119428,
0.0035524422,
0.0562883988,
-0.0293156151,
0.0052155843,
0.023984272,
0.0277215652,
-0.0326803848,
0.0250015557,
0.0271913763,
-0.0120963724,
0.0190981552,
0.0203222279,
-0.0049397522,
-0.0021163127,
0.0572613552,
-0.0087380866,
-0.0428310633,
0.0192271825,
-0.0174837094,
0.0085925385,
0.0666024312,
0.00559439,
-0.0174262635,
-0.0265992545,
0.0133500788,
-0.0080287419,
-0.0116989678,
-0.0642440319,
0.0317697264,
0.0059798616,
-0.0002353121,
0.0505521074,
-0.0465726629,
0.0272902958,
-0.0137436027,
0.0193954688,
-0.0267302413,
0.0061813165,
0.0395161286,
-0.0577896014,
-0.018812526,
-0.0559253506,
-0.0396846347,
0.0239542183,
-0.0149318567,
-0.0035615012,
-0.0357150659,
-0.0272830315,
0.0254231282,
-0.0249373186,
-0.0473535769,
1.725103278e-34,
0.0233395658,
-0.0289997514,
0.0178760868,
0.021979792,
-0.013932365,
-0.027281573,
-0.0076377667,
0.0153789315,
0.0454415157,
-0.0921511948,
-0.0368778408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10759v1 | GeoLayoutLM: Geometric Pre-training for Visual Information Extraction | 2023-04-21T06:02:14 | 2023-04-21T06:02:14 | Chuwei Luo, Changxu Cheng, Qi Zheng, Cong Yao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual information extraction (VIE) plays an important role in Document
Intelligence. Generally, it is divided into two tasks: semantic entity
recognition (SER) and relation extraction (RE). Recently, pre-trained models
for documents have achieved substantial progress in VIE, particularly in SER.
However, most of the existing models learn the geometric representation in an
implicit way, which has been found insufficient for the RE task since geometric
information is especially crucial for RE. Moreover, we reveal another factor
that limits the performance of RE lies in the objective gap between the
pre-training phase and the fine-tuning phase for RE. To tackle these issues, we
propose in this paper a multi-modal framework, named GeoLayoutLM, for VIE.
GeoLayoutLM explicitly models the geometric relations in pre-training, which we
call geometric pre-training. Geometric pre-training is achieved by three
specially designed geometry-related pre-training tasks. Additionally, novel
relation heads, which are pre-trained by the geometric pre-training tasks and
fine-tuned for RE, are elaborately designed to enrich and enhance the feature
representation. According to extensive experiments on standard VIE benchmarks,
GeoLayoutLM achieves highly competitive scores in the SER task and
significantly outperforms the previous state-of-the-arts for RE (\eg, the F1
score of RE on FUNSD is boosted from 80.35\% to 89.45\%). The code and models
are publicly available at
https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/AdvancedLiterateMachinery/tree/main/DocumentUnderstanding/GeoLayoutLM | [
0.0307088792,
0.0180506315,
0.0326049924,
0.0733428076,
-0.0142288478,
0.0508601964,
-0.0242822915,
0.0043656942,
0.0232134182,
-0.0378995202,
-0.0611363016,
0.0362576395,
-0.0086047696,
0.0242495015,
-0.0280673485,
-0.0806124434,
-0.0263609588,
-0.0318149924,
0.0334166288,
0.033260528,
0.0030571485,
0.0215611458,
-0.0046913177,
-0.0485955514,
-0.0437996872,
-0.0065834918,
-0.0111413943,
0.0292573497,
0.0477462076,
-0.068444401,
-0.0108260689,
-0.0028138957,
0.0211830474,
-0.0182267074,
0.0000021391,
-0.0153948432,
-0.0046921745,
0.0353440158,
0.0244266763,
-0.007847202,
-0.0071856873,
-0.0929852426,
-0.0064294934,
-0.0712072477,
-0.05275888,
-0.041017089,
0.0371725671,
0.1056404486,
0.0176289361,
0.0694810525,
-0.0568088517,
-0.0615175664,
0.0635094568,
-0.0362376831,
0.0111612668,
-0.0345710181,
0.0007244141,
0.0099616284,
-0.0382131338,
0.0326086618,
-0.0342166238,
0.0028339725,
-0.0006748413,
0.0219804849,
0.0038424281,
0.0471972711,
-0.0011870055,
0.0195093676,
-0.0166347604,
0.089509517,
-0.02457067,
0.0273471363,
0.0357765816,
-0.0025746988,
-0.0190063603,
0.0485564806,
-0.032318145,
-0.0047373637,
-0.0425391532,
0.0131952502,
-0.0090317214,
0.0137342336,
-0.005268387,
-0.0199203547,
-0.0237751119,
-0.005647318,
-0.0158615354,
-0.0181662925,
-0.0070627853,
0.0366842747,
-0.0046432968,
-0.0300767999,
-0.0143155623,
0.0219222214,
0.0524286069,
0.0048355726,
-0.0205826238,
-0.0031260394,
-0.0219446719,
-0.0608030036,
0.0335003771,
-0.0385810137,
-0.0140774827,
0.1020847633,
-0.0740599334,
0.0497532748,
-0.0102920979,
0.0572192818,
-0.0048673386,
0.0188838188,
0.0130432118,
0.0267562829,
-0.0561997779,
0.0431241542,
-0.0248058718,
-0.0412503332,
0.0140155545,
0.0331401043,
0.0061063748,
0.0268767178,
-0.0220618807,
-0.003942322,
-0.0274548996,
-0.048215501,
-0.0363975018,
-0.0094318576,
-0.0174832679,
-0.0060301432,
-0.038524922,
-0.0067836335,
0.0117181828,
0.0121362442,
0.0664588585,
-0.026162738,
0.0144648198,
0.0581335984,
0.0129564963,
-0.0787382498,
-0.0387337767,
-0.0258164946,
0.0096007846,
-0.0485524163,
0.0668404177,
-0.030275492,
0.0315877981,
-0.0083124498,
-0.0313871764,
-0.0018873296,
0.0088289874,
-0.0175094958,
-0.063129589,
0.0459389314,
-0.0148795377,
0.0008527089,
0.0245572906,
0.0177231394,
0.0125401849,
0.0726143047,
0.0442935377,
0.0910378695,
0.0417336039,
0.0140172523,
-0.0005929274,
0.0306971483,
0.0113023631,
-0.0210281238,
0.0058766915,
0.0399642028,
-0.0017740487,
-0.0329158641,
0.0412363186,
0.015206947,
-0.0535730198,
-0.0261370726,
0.0241235401,
0.009081942,
0.0261883866,
0.0188193377,
0.0337340236,
-0.0310666338,
0.0172078405,
0.0224627946,
-0.0887082592,
-0.0204171576,
-0.0131382365,
0.0510238521,
-0.0784241706,
0.0284646284,
-0.0089881439,
-0.0093763983,
0.019834375,
-0.0342980064,
-0.0030924759,
0.0073581696,
0.1204671562,
0.0166711137,
-0.0355395488,
0.0294662211,
-0.0008853446,
-0.0126354489,
-0.0260724742,
0.0291246846,
0.0103610698,
-0.0000455044,
0.0341153741,
-0.026700547,
-0.0268650018,
0.0203399416,
0.0152932201,
0.0106411939,
0.0684236214,
-0.0248914659,
0.0382116958,
-0.0274090134,
-0.052908279,
-0.0025745484,
-0.0027842519,
0.006058963,
0.055592712,
0.0264971927,
0.031767983,
-0.0171712991,
0.0024486175,
0.0331657976,
0.0233031157,
-0.0649221241,
-0.0364173725,
0.0306279864,
-0.014469957,
-0.0014114043,
-0.0413241722,
-0.036572583,
0.0537907444,
-0.051681906,
0.054186739,
-0.0015595595,
-0.0577921346,
-0.0593991242,
-0.0019713887,
-0.0205487534,
-0.0423430018,
-0.0262597837,
-0.0402248539,
0.0096547259,
-0.014993473,
0.045665428,
0.0930373743,
-0.0088032149,
0.0087877577,
0.0460318141,
0.0179359149,
-0.0428107604,
0.0652318895,
-0.009415552,
-0.0268439725,
0.0072497255,
-0.0384844989,
-0.0003568065,
0.0057150987,
0.0032508448,
0.006304902,
-0.0072737662,
-0.0282907281,
-0.0139941704,
0.0491510071,
-0.0350992456,
-0.032596238,
-0.0698590726,
-0.0265388209,
-0.0010753826,
0.0474539287,
0.0136393169,
-0.0151302041,
-0.0485675149,
-0.0810254812,
-0.0095959231,
0.0083743259,
-0.0358370729,
-0.0070314039,
0.0364503525,
0.0051984452,
0.0293934997,
0.0276611112,
-0.020797817,
0.0013155622,
0.0287719667,
0.0624043867,
-0.0100003043,
0.0080551123,
0.0412252732,
-0.0082419813,
0.0195796862,
-0.0144822355,
0.0317597874,
-0.0239618253,
-0.036319036,
0.0289694555,
0.0669642985,
-0.0096440623,
0.0554213971,
-0.042941425,
-0.0233748667,
-0.013905474,
0.0183578208,
-0.0496102236,
0.0368858129,
-0.0247852951,
-0.0145212701,
0.0083616572,
0.0387886837,
-0.0500265323,
0.0429828241,
0.0021859929,
0.0031239856,
0.0236780494,
0.0134260617,
-0.0220184326,
0.0140866991,
0.0476488024,
0.0166237298,
-0.0482976586,
-0.055604957,
0.0238970146,
-0.056478098,
-0.0229525305,
-0.0048671546,
0.0347778127,
-0.0614783987,
0.0864641741,
0.0407193266,
0.0209077448,
0.0050346963,
-0.021854328,
-0.013001251,
-0.0042163557,
0.0249085948,
0.0350365937,
0.020365363,
-0.0290923156,
0.0329830982,
-0.0523637272,
-0.0409916155,
-0.0138672581,
-0.0087362844,
-0.011937541,
-0.0311020929,
-0.036759384,
-0.0070968992,
0.012130728,
0.0526338704,
-0.0094871726,
0.0436613001,
-0.0488254465,
-0.0364105366,
-0.0008190476,
0.0928679183,
0.0501002744,
0.0179379806,
-0.0235063471,
-0.0125634642,
-0.0210360624,
0.0492557995,
-0.0269713663,
-0.0261424892,
-0.0171163678,
0.0402517915,
-0.0025979078,
-0.0158596635,
0.0080871899,
-0.0045774095,
0.0267371126,
-0.0640562475,
-0.015093158,
0.0673281327,
0.0178486481,
-0.0387562178,
-0.0683259964,
0.0115367183,
0.0240201801,
0.0095988959,
0.0005324729,
-0.025794154,
-0.0044634193,
-0.0068188026,
-0.0452698842,
0.0424893945,
-0.0188728627,
0.007617285,
-0.0452514812,
0.0498992726,
0.0021281992,
-0.0526013263,
-0.0129866516,
-0.0406071432,
-0.0050149062,
-0.0070819245,
-0.087865591,
-0.0407530218,
-0.0556703843,
-0.0227555968,
-0.0265043899,
-0.0197693277,
0.0079961019,
-0.0007705605,
-0.0473043248,
-0.0454697758,
0.0153200533,
0.0295306239,
0.0090046534,
-0.0330567956,
0.0126343612,
0.020572478,
0.0006200725,
-0.0454510637,
0.0689083934,
-0.0424882211,
-0.0156302471,
0.0135096656,
-0.0083399564,
-0.0370523594,
-0.0074118446,
0.0079089748,
0.0423452109,
0.010782701,
-0.0083698491,
-0.0248182695,
-0.0213946812,
-0.0249086358,
0.0011903816,
0.0032058165,
0.023738673,
-0.0862122029,
-0.002093683,
0.0200474951,
-0.0393460952,
0.0072293952,
0.0027150658,
-0.022397127,
-0.0439505391,
-0.0613426976,
-0.0679074824,
-0.0068060304,
0.0681497231,
-0.0151308738,
-0.0713627487,
0.0060469368,
-0.0149301235,
-0.0881899148,
0.0309835915,
-0.0124444366,
0.0048225452,
-0.026196247,
0.0212444887,
0.0005952688,
-0.0441505872,
-0.0340593718,
-0.0347777456,
-0.0269806571,
0.0031870578,
-0.0216965806,
0.0783688799,
0.0056169797,
0.0641848743,
-0.0086078942,
0.0320880711,
0.0249742381,
0.0166898035,
-0.0663320646,
-0.0093913283,
0.0192207154,
-0.0072873686,
-0.0281058718,
-0.0089834407,
0.0013733563,
0.0565092973,
0.0317257568,
-0.0107664252,
-0.0160585251,
-0.0119998306,
-0.0211121812,
0.0161205865,
0.0802005231,
0.0175147988,
0.008834105,
-0.0382537842,
0.017669227,
-0.020584939,
0.0407624766,
-0.0190655142,
0.0271080397,
-0.0126043549,
0.0138282571,
-0.0042195613,
0.0306020323,
0.040751338,
0.0036605089,
-0.0211834535,
-0.0015086757,
0.0156082595,
0.0152501222,
0.0033403402,
0.0193230845,
0.0049531842,
0.01997477,
0.000190963,
0.0313634835,
-0.0321855582,
0.0379060619,
0.0216055121,
-0.0112832207,
-0.0272195712,
0.0339952707,
-0.0374742672,
0.0157646146,
-0.0674417391,
0.0456584543,
0.0429262258,
-0.0147159472,
0.0153874252,
-0.0293845423,
-0.0085255057,
0.0167524032,
-0.0021635257,
-0.0047874744,
-0.0141508477,
0.0432820581,
0.0113935927,
-0.0180282481,
-0.0043822415,
0.0432679653,
0.0034656706,
0.0118907886,
0.0361832492,
-0.0255722739,
-0.050999146,
-0.0232868437,
0.0369565114,
0.0147529459,
-0.0249327049,
0.013486525,
-0.0365642384,
-0.0289469957,
0.0413972624,
-0.0022335667,
-0.0100294575,
0.0708610043,
0.0248769559,
0.0474794731,
0.0210376978,
-0.0397439301,
-0.0309642591,
0.021231303,
-0.04887335,
0.0040182294,
0.0247255042,
-5.635199062e-33,
-0.0226983447,
-0.0310527515,
0.0509295948,
0.0371555574,
-0.014224886,
0.0277739391,
-0.0299464613,
-0.0158396624,
-0.0279392246,
0.0082486058,
0.0019422686,
-0.0556650274,
0.0264135543,
0.0417301916,
-0.0149746565,
0.0076734703,
0.0214272086,
0.0103979865,
0.0057896981,
0.0274612363,
-0.0227322355,
0.0591201149,
0.0640636012,
-0.1133528948,
-0.0105929021,
0.0184583347,
0.0059179673,
-0.0006229138,
0.0570015423,
0.0440825671,
-0.0396306999,
-0.0426583439,
0.031287536,
0.019033134,
-0.016437877,
0.0079936264,
-0.1716058552,
-0.0068412018,
-0.0462069213,
0.0430669002,
-0.0558678806,
0.0011902062,
0.0049138595,
-0.0156910215,
0.0311148968,
-0.0759421885,
0.0474528596,
-0.0130866198,
-0.0389877334,
-0.0203735176,
-0.0789228901,
0.0602261201,
0.0435436293,
-0.0055290721,
0.0771346018,
-0.0302904453,
0.0468859039,
0.0322564468,
-0.0277891494,
-0.0088693099,
0.017077947,
-0.0055726473,
0.0263683256,
0.0303284451,
0.0008705538,
0.0483280942,
0.0260969605,
-0.0648074523,
-0.0266058706,
0.0237950291,
0.0584123023,
0.0800294876,
-0.0444592126,
-0.0022571643,
0.0192071032,
0.0143681522,
-0.0879635885,
0.0315714702,
-0.0339970551,
0.0488206595,
-0.0373290367,
0.0068428293,
-0.0531636514,
0.0311497655,
0.0174756516,
-0.0193949733,
-0.0125040468,
-0.0141156605,
0.0359931327,
0.0747282878,
0.0143970856,
0.0909038112,
0.0270142313,
-0.0215610173,
-0.0359147191,
0.0204989575,
0.0071626557,
0.0424538814,
-0.0174137447,
-0.0254933722,
-0.0539081879,
-0.0274932887,
0.0004027895,
0.0124013536,
-0.00104131,
0.0006219539,
0.075030826,
0.0051764385,
-0.0594886355,
-0.01060839,
-0.0276687685,
-0.0110909194,
0.0345543101,
0.0372284688,
-0.0038308264,
-0.0068320385,
-0.0288748555,
0.0739264861,
0.0214616675,
0.0228250362,
-0.0272492804,
0.0185764302,
0.0194670949,
0.0496931225,
0.0344164446,
-0.0125469221,
0.005741722,
-0.0112622762,
0.0193910319,
-0.0533168949,
-0.0010601843,
-0.0049054027,
2.661e-7,
0.0234132204,
0.0458086878,
0.0781274214,
-0.0203965027,
0.0019422102,
0.0277954675,
0.0118604098,
0.0244718827,
-0.0367413647,
0.0477899425,
0.034010157,
0.031321533,
0.0059521552,
0.0143588101,
-0.0690145716,
0.0653373003,
-0.013195971,
-0.0757035017,
-0.0683217049,
-0.0038042252,
0.0544331297,
0.0155193219,
-0.0388321467,
-0.0176425315,
0.0006932476,
-0.0472492464,
0.0561535694,
-0.0305643864,
0.0345675945,
0.0338091478,
0.0028496152,
0.0298143569,
-0.049634181,
0.0104567818,
-0.000638774,
0.0157306399,
0.0227999073,
0.059387736,
-0.0283955783,
0.0353481583,
-0.0002477811,
-0.0136751914,
-0.0068792515,
-0.0381895602,
0.0571696497,
-0.0349032879,
-0.0074895783,
-0.0196619947,
-0.0208351668,
0.0065516275,
-0.0107417814,
0.0089950915,
0.0073879636,
0.03797758,
0.0685575083,
-0.0443899073,
-0.0382115729,
-0.0986556113,
0.0235793162,
0.048461929,
0.0272124708,
0.0408230126,
-0.041505035,
0.0095502958,
0.013316582,
-0.0203479771,
-0.0477280803,
2.504633619e-34,
-0.0217015054,
0.0072277561,
-0.0253184587,
0.0456942767,
0.0145356171,
-0.0406807214,
-0.0333936475,
-0.0042295689,
-0.040239919,
-0.0340298228,
0.0318453088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10750v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10750v2 | Improving Grounded Language Understanding in a Collaborative Environment by Interacting with Agents Through Help Feedback | 2023-04-21T05:37:59 | 2024-02-05T21:25:33 | Nikhil Mehta, Milagro Teruel, Patricio Figueroa Sanz, Xin Deng, Ahmed Hassan Awadallah, Julia Kiseleva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many approaches to Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks often treat them
as single-step problems, where an agent receives an instruction, executes it,
and is evaluated based on the final outcome. However, human language is
inherently interactive, as evidenced by the back-and-forth nature of human
conversations. In light of this, we posit that human-AI collaboration should
also be interactive, with humans monitoring the work of AI agents and providing
feedback that the agent can understand and utilize. Further, the AI agent
should be able to detect when it needs additional information and proactively
ask for help. Enabling this scenario would lead to more natural, efficient, and
engaging human-AI collaborations.
In this work, we explore these directions using the challenging task defined
by the IGLU competition, an interactive grounded language understanding task in
a MineCraft-like world. We explore multiple types of help players can give to
the AI to guide it and analyze the impact of this help in AI behavior,
resulting in performance improvements. | [
0.0742304474,
-0.0355450772,
-0.0390189663,
0.0365865827,
-0.0354857408,
-0.0043022023,
-0.0225746688,
-0.0119591337,
0.006385182,
-0.0411195494,
-0.0018228692,
0.0266284682,
0.0437176637,
0.0396271423,
-0.0325066783,
-0.0584929027,
0.0095591834,
-0.0294009913,
0.0100646969,
0.0122054825,
0.005155771,
0.0235125795,
-0.0412761457,
0.0750637278,
-0.0097467536,
0.0004298555,
-0.0257137641,
-0.0262839235,
-0.0169843324,
-0.0193722341,
-0.0205997061,
0.0117201814,
0.0452064089,
-0.0088882232,
0.0000019071,
-0.0438661538,
0.0273063574,
-0.0306860451,
-0.0656927004,
-0.0583994836,
-0.0347848237,
0.0084745102,
0.0044803182,
-0.0042006946,
-0.0746674687,
0.0239625052,
0.035424877,
0.0684114546,
0.0745144933,
-0.0014143301,
0.0164481904,
0.0233190954,
-0.0368949734,
0.0365122966,
-0.004532563,
-0.036993403,
-0.0250694212,
0.0505779721,
0.0411487408,
-0.0067439424,
-0.0199034363,
0.0515007675,
0.0273021739,
-0.040690966,
0.0365068652,
0.0700290948,
-0.0288736094,
-0.0253866669,
-0.0011579358,
0.101943247,
0.028284857,
-0.0152064878,
-0.021083964,
-0.0137435226,
0.0076558343,
0.0175039005,
-0.0059615425,
0.0394722559,
-0.0384085514,
0.0054544564,
-0.0010628733,
0.0140660191,
0.0030707184,
0.0116538247,
0.0148096792,
0.1192796156,
-0.0392430052,
0.0002966507,
0.0132758217,
0.0258217454,
-0.0129646016,
-0.0468582138,
0.0268035661,
0.0404753461,
-0.0481101796,
0.0324266776,
-0.0000378998,
0.0151215522,
-0.0192588065,
-0.044654455,
0.0288603026,
0.0449264273,
-0.0128019508,
0.0581550784,
0.0060309093,
0.0080418829,
0.0483283699,
-0.002445831,
0.0039024856,
0.0093210833,
-0.091386959,
-0.0112699,
-0.0518287048,
0.0420191512,
-0.0504920408,
-0.0135380905,
0.0419226661,
0.0318553336,
-0.0325269364,
0.0531157255,
-0.0000931807,
0.0220594984,
-0.0460981801,
-0.0058817463,
-0.0310623869,
-0.0062374589,
-0.0934873447,
0.0189765897,
-0.0137790339,
-0.0983443335,
-0.0103435945,
0.0152986608,
0.0033582943,
-0.0153179448,
-0.023325637,
-0.0013771802,
0.013585004,
-0.0183431599,
-0.0354162492,
-0.036396604,
0.0153572755,
-0.0417268127,
-0.0309549365,
-0.0353259556,
0.0316807255,
-0.0208982993,
-0.0100773908,
-0.0284814537,
0.0259289686,
-0.013797001,
-0.0021198124,
0.1016172767,
-0.0364691503,
-0.0101645356,
0.0547293052,
0.032430578,
0.0070412001,
0.0600962527,
0.0338957496,
0.0303749666,
0.0368390344,
-0.0007556401,
0.0126021793,
-0.0093898941,
-0.0199581943,
-0.0148877613,
0.0092488034,
-0.0022809189,
-0.0767956153,
0.0534422956,
0.0009827089,
0.0241849367,
-0.0075618103,
0.0217374861,
0.0455942489,
0.0929636583,
-0.0342082158,
-0.0056579174,
0.0566939563,
0.0534801707,
-0.0261159055,
0.0019340729,
-0.0279847663,
0.0255640391,
0.0080972612,
-0.0083809337,
-0.0338530168,
0.0128487423,
-0.0144643718,
-0.0659207851,
0.0020180217,
0.0122969085,
0.0609365776,
-0.0011934863,
0.0228874255,
0.0141385188,
-0.0132492064,
0.0037549839,
0.002785203,
-0.0460795425,
0.0269230083,
-0.0412311889,
0.0414330214,
0.0784163773,
0.0469033122,
-0.0114616659,
-0.0252054799,
-0.0149761857,
0.0070559182,
0.0509218462,
-0.0103435609,
-0.0300868042,
0.0092147347,
-0.0128374957,
-0.0360975862,
0.0155610284,
0.0010019402,
0.0219319966,
0.0014718104,
-0.0250711609,
-0.0011155049,
-0.0045754132,
-0.0302739963,
0.025653379,
-0.0040543419,
-0.0120931379,
-0.0424591415,
0.0304718539,
0.0328501724,
0.0504337996,
-0.0205604825,
-0.0277240016,
0.035751041,
-0.0224196147,
-0.0804344863,
0.1015291587,
-0.0133281881,
-0.0026261883,
0.0226041321,
-0.0367286988,
-0.0332531743,
0.0086084325,
0.0066313092,
-0.0137081854,
0.0525122806,
-0.0505279489,
0.0350660607,
0.0161947832,
-0.005178045,
-0.0137836374,
-0.0004049419,
-0.0447673947,
0.0271749962,
-0.0015058231,
-0.0243760385,
-0.0146281952,
-0.0062286607,
0.0183301196,
-0.0338169411,
0.0537952259,
0.0797602162,
0.0276651215,
-0.0289837997,
0.0560950786,
0.0075317547,
-0.0845601261,
0.0205791648,
-0.0726068467,
-0.0372360647,
-0.032711383,
0.0230251402,
0.0297138002,
0.0029822199,
-0.0248235483,
-0.0343955196,
0.0028833861,
-0.0010228567,
0.0047283135,
-0.0094781257,
0.0514076203,
0.0532472916,
-0.0121229654,
-0.0334628187,
0.0337071009,
-0.0104046622,
0.0055211531,
0.0547581092,
-0.0374233797,
-0.0712228417,
-0.0066957865,
-0.0307863578,
0.0363442041,
-0.0012780664,
-0.017747283,
0.043250408,
-0.002954677,
0.0290807225,
0.0561545976,
-0.0031706537,
0.0947143584,
0.0653744563,
-0.0539663769,
-0.071050033,
0.0254815426,
0.0149384653,
0.0167825911,
-0.021892203,
-0.0065527498,
0.0191558674,
0.0727077648,
0.0230326671,
0.0178071503,
-0.0529721044,
0.0074204318,
-0.0198087636,
-0.0386996418,
-0.0229976885,
-0.0422020704,
-0.0160782691,
0.0368342213,
-0.0205761921,
-0.0118204951,
0.0994082764,
-0.0233251173,
-0.0350534618,
-0.0683276877,
0.0078663239,
-0.0126561504,
0.0939185023,
-0.0426459275,
0.0036254192,
-0.0152709745,
-0.0415057652,
-0.0006540627,
-0.0039681918,
0.0265987013,
-0.0003661678,
0.0116075659,
-0.0845578313,
0.0184980184,
0.012595851,
0.0084322896,
-0.0258245282,
0.005624407,
-0.0562514141,
-0.0000189424,
0.0192272831,
-0.0024695743,
-0.0005032598,
-0.0044086752,
0.0464795232,
0.0032738163,
0.0288378354,
-0.0207700804,
-0.0325544775,
-0.0351429805,
0.0330128074,
0.0517014563,
-0.0115200393,
0.0094636744,
0.0926390141,
0.0407968313,
0.0538563542,
-0.0281676855,
-0.0231642537,
-0.0078825476,
0.054428447,
-0.0243144315,
-0.0046140826,
0.0331615396,
0.0587573126,
-0.055098746,
-0.0226884335,
0.1120243892,
0.0626269132,
-0.025960179,
0.0234099552,
-0.0389884636,
0.0011335909,
0.0190548953,
0.0178365353,
-0.0248612147,
-0.0414300896,
0.0040090117,
-0.0045295036,
0.0084738405,
-0.0502757728,
-0.0118833901,
-0.1190918759,
0.009966474,
-0.012047369,
-0.0034197387,
-0.0648454726,
-0.0173123889,
0.001375235,
0.0296338368,
0.0037324899,
-0.030177569,
0.0349767618,
0.0208508,
0.0104622683,
0.0016043084,
-0.0256953947,
0.0383113921,
-0.0467127115,
0.1021902859,
0.0734187588,
0.0437318608,
0.0065144659,
-0.0037783298,
-0.0238892026,
0.0523046255,
0.0360695496,
-0.0471027233,
0.0179259125,
-0.0043808832,
0.0039601796,
0.0154228546,
0.0025200509,
-0.0694040805,
0.0179238636,
0.0320762061,
0.053979326,
-0.069197081,
0.0213453025,
0.0279714484,
0.0587757342,
0.0493918806,
0.038681671,
0.0320465006,
-0.0205146205,
0.0006588634,
-0.0252295267,
0.0022072829,
-0.0632733181,
-0.0479249954,
-0.0261329226,
0.0015913842,
0.0461853594,
-0.0890071839,
-0.0997513905,
0.0666254833,
0.0219619386,
0.0354689583,
-0.0253516771,
0.0040822458,
0.0356832333,
0.0026195785,
0.0451983437,
-0.0064287977,
0.039516639,
-0.0164586846,
-0.029041037,
-0.0063963933,
-0.0428100452,
0.0099484175,
0.0383733511,
-0.0261468086,
-0.0503157079,
0.0333547518,
0.0000429282,
0.0209442843,
0.0569043234,
-0.0313195661,
-0.0339364484,
-0.0840569064,
-0.0192025658,
-0.0736414939,
-0.0009438574,
0.002600505,
0.0235445872,
0.0149637852,
0.0353138037,
-0.0134271532,
-0.0071016289,
-0.0092647783,
0.0384072214,
-0.0363046378,
-0.0824220777,
0.0431219637,
0.0146080656,
0.0283675548,
-0.0131155951,
-0.0042218915,
-0.0196414422,
0.0115230773,
-0.0127884299,
-0.0204419848,
-0.0273346324,
0.0205428191,
-0.032910537,
-0.0390290916,
0.0347282216,
0.0490324795,
-0.0571530871,
0.0381408222,
0.0094909668,
0.0250313636,
0.0131846825,
0.0193255506,
-0.0194510426,
0.0291294474,
-0.0046338891,
0.0066325893,
0.0125611844,
0.0706382841,
0.0287883244,
0.0540168285,
0.0088922651,
-0.0501990132,
0.0008954107,
0.0388444066,
-0.0273098201,
-0.0509140231,
0.0615247749,
0.042215582,
0.0618813597,
0.0002463482,
0.0058005177,
-0.0394148603,
0.0316177048,
0.0379157439,
-0.002591413,
0.0082224337,
-0.0605324022,
-0.0004458825,
0.0339382701,
-0.0151360314,
-0.0007099761,
0.0359749272,
-0.0258157533,
0.0501074493,
-0.0179466978,
0.0200236998,
-0.0460279807,
-0.0042143231,
-0.0034500319,
0.0523404628,
-0.0373254381,
0.0833688229,
-0.065425463,
-0.042578198,
-0.0456352122,
0.0323662683,
0.0042856499,
-0.0177315641,
0.0479704626,
0.0417229012,
0.003204392,
-0.0291408692,
-0.0522431284,
0.0116612529,
-0.0404431894,
0.0179287363,
-0.0635832176,
-5.609518552e-33,
-0.0680837259,
-0.0782834515,
0.0244935118,
0.0164627247,
-0.0266662762,
-0.0172391552,
-0.047138866,
0.0263083652,
-0.0258294642,
0.0043852869,
-0.0156186027,
0.0400669053,
0.0016379413,
-0.0366736948,
0.0149624385,
-0.0160349272,
0.0254298933,
0.0118727526,
-0.0425366499,
0.0040789354,
0.0391136333,
-0.006495411,
0.0317686275,
-0.0773591772,
0.0488383025,
0.0307247359,
-0.0491080098,
0.0483254083,
-0.0121911187,
0.005491484,
-0.0074085617,
0.0244382508,
0.0239669941,
-0.0249093827,
0.0048521417,
0.0280963499,
-0.0531427115,
-0.0428997092,
0.0190180633,
0.0299392175,
-0.0515113845,
-0.0045920694,
-0.0044420063,
-0.0088466946,
0.0100720599,
0.0295192637,
0.0367397778,
-0.0064971065,
0.0055537662,
0.0314628333,
-0.0624779016,
0.0132647818,
-0.065881893,
-0.0372279398,
0.0234709289,
0.0375306532,
0.004512432,
-0.0025449502,
-0.0670687333,
0.0331733637,
-0.0346906595,
-0.0047352649,
0.0661371723,
0.0007198625,
-0.0090912087,
0.0573972315,
-0.016516583,
0.0243346822,
-0.0712810978,
-0.0001090019,
0.0042072628,
-0.0050628851,
0.0208072234,
0.0365845636,
-0.0002801699,
0.0117779318,
0.017426772,
0.0380640328,
0.0391079523,
0.0715471059,
-0.0347901136,
0.0310580544,
-0.0948043913,
-0.0049806996,
-0.0389032066,
0.0119225187,
0.0002296659,
-0.0581593551,
0.0212319046,
-0.016205363,
-0.0388817787,
-0.0110062296,
-0.0059385793,
-0.0186186749,
0.0254021976,
-0.0304851476,
0.01127085,
-0.015385583,
0.0071566142,
-0.0142374597,
-0.008439742,
-0.01489818,
-0.0089160884,
-0.0003771874,
0.0440927334,
0.0059403665,
-0.0145702902,
0.0366178863,
-0.0228577945,
-0.0168317985,
-0.033590015,
0.0135444095,
0.004164408,
-0.0084695909,
0.008397758,
-0.0056570568,
-0.063462086,
0.0500038043,
0.0324810632,
-0.0280146077,
-0.0203570276,
-0.0292637236,
-0.0544442944,
-0.0181420837,
-0.0507507659,
-0.0387136564,
-0.0368313268,
0.0148827378,
0.0420208797,
-0.0310827196,
-0.0372137614,
-0.0391197875,
2.714e-7,
-0.0082840305,
0.0495270081,
0.0326360427,
-0.0267285705,
-0.0203229561,
0.0404491089,
-0.0306208171,
-0.0096936077,
-0.0331955105,
-0.0468822084,
0.0275815539,
0.0340109169,
0.0177745689,
0.0098723341,
-0.0597599782,
-0.0146296844,
-0.0082785413,
-0.0061169812,
-0.0364843607,
-0.008976032,
0.0651895255,
0.0114104589,
0.0182660837,
0.0209297631,
-0.0127553903,
-0.05841171,
-0.0155813219,
-0.0243082736,
0.0287525468,
-0.0155478111,
0.015559121,
-0.038237121,
-0.0179251935,
0.020873677,
0.0026972673,
0.0024950663,
-0.0053650965,
0.0349852219,
-0.0381993689,
0.0120980851,
-0.0507025346,
-0.0146698039,
0.0212530792,
-0.0248714723,
0.0126204202,
-0.0407540649,
-0.0561322346,
-0.0071466318,
0.0333210565,
-0.0338847004,
-0.045913469,
0.0020391874,
-0.0309074316,
-0.0096513424,
-0.0053342269,
-0.0109612439,
0.0073492397,
-0.0646764636,
-0.0139178019,
-0.0419137478,
-0.0354018733,
0.0059905588,
-0.0217802562,
-0.0049811108,
0.0072233789,
-0.0226505697,
0.0057315347,
2.008134652e-34,
-0.0204589032,
0.031144537,
0.0232658666,
0.0680103675,
0.0711917356,
0.0106141362,
-0.0298318993,
0.0204345435,
0.0414572358,
0.0074873017,
-0.0251980629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10739v1 | KitchenScale: Learning to predict ingredient quantities from recipe contexts | 2023-04-21T04:28:16 | 2023-04-21T04:28:16 | Donghee Choi, Mogan Gim, Samy Badreddine, Hajung Kim, Donghyeon Park, Jaewoo Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NA, math.NA, H.4.m | Determining proper quantities for ingredients is an essential part of cooking
practice from the perspective of enriching tastiness and promoting healthiness.
We introduce KitchenScale, a fine-tuned Pre-trained Language Model (PLM) that
predicts a target ingredient's quantity and measurement unit given its recipe
context. To effectively train our KitchenScale model, we formulate an
ingredient quantity prediction task that consists of three sub-tasks which are
ingredient measurement type classification, unit classification, and quantity
regression task. Furthermore, we utilized transfer learning of cooking
knowledge from recipe texts to PLMs. We adopted the Discrete Latent Exponent
(DExp) method to cope with high variance of numerical scales in recipe corpora.
Experiments with our newly constructed dataset and recommendation examples
demonstrate KitchenScale's understanding of various recipe contexts and
generalizability in predicting ingredient quantities. We implemented a web
application for KitchenScale to demonstrate its functionality in recommending
ingredient quantities expressed in numerals (e.g., 2) with units (e.g., ounce). | [
0.0297219548,
0.0821358338,
0.0056631141,
-0.0173196569,
0.0099540921,
0.022976093,
-0.0210846048,
0.033776246,
-0.019296132,
-0.0214232188,
-0.0121161267,
-0.0621174164,
-0.0129719041,
0.0600554831,
-0.0050864657,
-0.0059520681,
0.0117699672,
-0.0010435656,
-0.0088820513,
0.0309136827,
0.0118430648,
0.0110610295,
-0.009109498,
0.0113774966,
-0.0411607362,
0.0204006378,
0.0107689062,
-0.0301484279,
-0.0091393031,
-0.0468911231,
0.0226124767,
0.0591424182,
0.0209798925,
-0.0172451865,
0.0000017326,
-0.0036352708,
0.0035717844,
-0.0133431247,
-0.0404006615,
0.001893377,
0.0169998743,
-0.0206664577,
0.0121333878,
0.0050761928,
-0.0578579977,
-0.0116829835,
0.054189302,
0.0444311947,
-0.0236262213,
0.0616912283,
0.0039535216,
-0.1082158089,
-0.0264368858,
-0.0035826082,
0.0630720183,
0.02785022,
0.015372443,
-0.0088313762,
-0.0226592254,
0.0312458463,
0.0247053597,
-0.0023144227,
0.0225895829,
0.0107725514,
0.0090287589,
0.0756062046,
0.0251167435,
-0.0211889036,
0.0001250189,
0.0946381837,
0.0230125431,
-0.0254285652,
-0.009261393,
0.0005442582,
-0.0584304705,
-0.0114888465,
-0.0281377286,
-0.060210865,
0.0222905651,
0.0671189725,
-0.0403852798,
-0.0130879954,
0.037746802,
0.0058966987,
0.0289371591,
0.1070892438,
0.0003074477,
-0.0077504935,
-0.0027420928,
0.0154110659,
-0.0438657813,
-0.040928375,
0.0118702175,
0.0225165226,
-0.0051808595,
0.0144735994,
0.0269028451,
0.0072424328,
0.0081444895,
-0.0442371741,
0.0172743276,
0.0332787223,
-0.0143399993,
0.0037564812,
-0.0104679856,
0.0649756044,
0.0270445868,
-0.0153639102,
-0.0989224687,
0.0429861099,
-0.0501070507,
-0.0117343562,
0.0021626698,
0.0048220754,
-0.0247026756,
-0.0087500969,
-0.0385416485,
-0.0196043719,
-0.0095785856,
-0.004269978,
0.0593819357,
0.0698562488,
0.0034450167,
0.0317925513,
-0.0825050846,
0.0711564273,
-0.0557797439,
0.0341124795,
-0.0300699379,
0.0211505331,
-0.0065647238,
-0.0271695498,
0.0212419368,
0.0029767498,
0.0577620305,
0.0268212147,
-0.0312675461,
-0.0251598284,
-0.0195534583,
-0.0219927393,
-0.0376076512,
-0.0544857346,
-0.0080130603,
-0.0592554808,
0.0466475114,
0.0082616052,
0.0300410613,
-0.0417007208,
0.0422403179,
0.0492625125,
-0.0572535396,
0.0847167596,
0.0454569124,
0.0099227745,
0.0043285778,
-0.0103014242,
0.0122929439,
0.0225978307,
0.0163750481,
0.034431044,
0.0206304789,
-0.0221620593,
0.0010390404,
-0.0203609932,
0.0055530765,
0.037871439,
-0.0821732432,
0.0057511581,
0.0007418063,
0.0247749686,
-0.0312155131,
0.056176804,
0.0026595267,
0.0131803025,
0.1137025133,
0.0385961682,
0.0375627279,
0.0494663715,
0.0589376688,
0.0049967007,
-0.0022747784,
-0.0267879628,
-0.0134520149,
0.0149359517,
-0.0754932538,
-0.036527399,
0.0259089079,
-0.0163475517,
-0.0408406854,
-0.0377095081,
-0.0049786395,
-0.0587098897,
0.0440796278,
-0.0196460001,
0.0683495402,
-0.0341943726,
-0.0098525621,
-0.0022182215,
0.0282010417,
-0.0223742314,
0.0211590715,
0.0303468592,
0.0729485527,
0.089084655,
-0.0029023648,
-0.0336756185,
0.0435210578,
0.0023425012,
0.0188896917,
-0.0571899079,
0.0119130528,
-0.0333291106,
0.0275005214,
-0.0351542421,
-0.0374904908,
-0.0215398204,
0.0234706178,
-0.0560795479,
0.028673185,
0.0429838449,
0.0187806524,
-0.0537468493,
-0.00541559,
0.0127386926,
-0.0109436391,
-0.1008926034,
0.0518312864,
-0.0109246448,
-0.0407859124,
0.0130949076,
0.0492733493,
0.0425423644,
-0.0055358084,
-0.0499033928,
-0.0371183679,
0.0049528396,
0.0069229533,
-0.0012562545,
0.0269295014,
0.0021618875,
0.0354775004,
-0.0274122749,
-0.0298886318,
-0.05499731,
0.0222730786,
0.0025394515,
0.014210294,
-0.024953492,
-0.0321769677,
0.030347921,
0.0357725397,
0.0024214254,
0.0679021031,
0.0000311892,
0.023508694,
-0.0515128337,
-0.0229017828,
-0.0185364876,
0.0475834049,
0.0299784988,
-0.0637263879,
0.0473274589,
0.0573359914,
0.0110500604,
0.0469827913,
-0.0318596885,
-0.0086021498,
-0.0479386412,
-0.0024792808,
-0.0313195474,
-0.0018514987,
0.0134118348,
-0.0037069728,
0.0119958445,
-0.0185886119,
-0.0224064924,
0.0225818008,
-0.05612294,
0.0352821648,
-0.0070603061,
0.0391432457,
0.0441174507,
-0.0441932492,
-0.0277318116,
-0.0070004258,
0.0461925007,
-0.0106306551,
0.0439222343,
-0.044255998,
-0.0336965509,
-0.0331528448,
-0.0036308449,
0.0106606511,
-0.0189315565,
-0.0534081236,
-0.0286796708,
0.0317314491,
0.0081690652,
0.0115967076,
0.0320185311,
0.0637676343,
0.0028370463,
-0.0765452757,
-0.0230324548,
-0.0702867731,
0.0141153717,
0.0167627111,
-0.0222717803,
-0.0184213519,
0.0506424978,
0.0010072283,
0.0275656935,
-0.0537027679,
0.0359875448,
-0.019636333,
-0.0134184239,
-0.0491563268,
0.0671615154,
-0.001901052,
0.0581202991,
0.0350224525,
-0.0342423879,
0.0456344076,
-0.0119899521,
0.0315141045,
-0.0367833227,
-0.0258979537,
-0.0204097759,
-0.0025216346,
0.0181730315,
0.0304214675,
-0.0278578997,
0.0246773418,
-0.0334976651,
0.0434638634,
0.0180225987,
-0.0471360162,
0.0849400237,
-0.0582600385,
-0.0093707172,
0.0110073062,
-0.0284038186,
-0.0350837298,
-0.0421896614,
-0.0151962684,
0.0292518288,
0.0127146849,
0.0231498051,
-0.0805792063,
0.0288593005,
-0.0012577551,
0.0221971069,
0.0184826478,
-0.034200158,
0.0158283729,
0.0102613037,
0.0706409961,
-0.0124358088,
-0.0037286098,
-0.0335210152,
0.006164805,
0.0244103223,
-0.0183167979,
-0.0216269847,
-0.0223913789,
0.0480296314,
0.0414097309,
-0.0114693716,
0.0048882901,
0.0421085544,
-0.0203715954,
0.0035646267,
-0.0353072807,
0.0878825337,
0.0321839005,
-0.0840019435,
0.0271408036,
0.0132527174,
-0.0316051394,
0.0258259978,
0.0496572331,
-0.1097968295,
0.0125068575,
-0.0485976972,
0.0198327657,
-0.0341310836,
-0.0172092877,
-0.0378530733,
-0.0737099275,
-0.0340484641,
0.0050812978,
-0.054653015,
-0.0686084405,
-0.0417695902,
0.0033110869,
-0.033947181,
0.0303691514,
-0.0208283551,
-0.0413957499,
0.0336496271,
0.0304991733,
-0.0331868455,
-0.0478014164,
0.0265955571,
-0.0462301672,
0.0311259981,
0.0462426208,
0.0298373122,
-0.022351075,
-0.0036872113,
0.0040193321,
-0.0020026676,
0.0163417831,
-0.0152206859,
0.031975694,
0.0149449203,
0.0084894281,
0.0042646537,
0.0390917845,
-0.0204821732,
-0.0337530114,
0.0199855939,
0.0593317263,
0.0244171638,
-0.027191652,
0.0213190056,
-0.0107837422,
0.0545101725,
0.0226126071,
0.0132040493,
-0.0193358101,
-0.0215799045,
-0.0391562469,
-0.0724522397,
0.0308667682,
0.0043737306,
0.0301189702,
-0.0209233165,
-0.026822241,
-0.0591076314,
0.0336660184,
0.0275743976,
0.0360429436,
0.0190229546,
0.0172148123,
-0.0053979387,
0.0454873219,
0.0020191551,
-0.0005848065,
-0.0051125265,
0.0113613084,
-0.0575802401,
-0.0166049767,
0.0758253261,
-0.0548177436,
-0.0151180187,
-0.0239812993,
-0.0970076695,
-0.0517889261,
-0.0231217369,
0.0880491361,
0.0141072795,
0.0537284203,
0.0010200707,
-0.0585703775,
0.0401635692,
0.0028181686,
-0.0535144843,
-0.0320257843,
-0.0232155342,
0.0053896513,
0.046039585,
0.0159560572,
-0.0304805897,
0.0567341261,
-0.0124825388,
0.0493224263,
-0.0455962867,
-0.0550983585,
0.0407918394,
-0.0558426827,
0.040769577,
0.0138376579,
0.0475715771,
-0.0579320416,
0.0272787586,
-0.0040624691,
-0.0149469748,
-0.0324166641,
-0.0099404994,
0.0394197628,
0.015511577,
-0.062533088,
-0.0674038455,
0.0187433567,
0.0422702469,
-0.0329271331,
-0.0018927107,
0.0212098453,
0.0303944051,
0.0452988259,
0.0012167932,
0.0135950074,
0.0174887124,
-0.0086336909,
0.0173458625,
-0.0319876075,
0.0501817502,
-0.0194555279,
0.0294337105,
-0.0795683712,
0.0284324922,
-0.0000057699,
-0.0450776629,
-0.0210745614,
-0.0626155883,
-0.0000590145,
-0.0755008459,
0.0279363468,
-0.0187854785,
0.0051997942,
-0.0373835005,
0.0664332211,
-0.0322809033,
0.0235041808,
0.0411378182,
0.0106942542,
0.0011989659,
0.0239342432,
0.0899146274,
-0.02730182,
0.0264980681,
0.0275434051,
-0.0121563645,
0.0243453775,
0.0349402353,
-0.017525604,
0.0279291533,
-0.0298239347,
-0.0225519463,
-0.0318661109,
-0.0358953141,
-0.0092814947,
-0.0072588203,
-0.0206003208,
-0.0022343211,
0.0273930337,
0.0599733181,
-0.0150321014,
0.0473409593,
-0.0136878286,
0.0039719408,
-0.0026370066,
0.0084386952,
-0.0158454161,
-5.82377407e-33,
-0.0032126452,
-0.0587734319,
0.0237381961,
0.0430983007,
0.0206511989,
-0.0085087763,
-0.0212076791,
0.0087642968,
0.033111088,
0.0199377313,
0.0109389052,
-0.0195232257,
0.0181919038,
-0.0069489209,
0.0751545802,
-0.0701663718,
0.0169474427,
-0.0028869426,
0.0066550053,
0.0007709632,
0.0250055846,
0.0383805037,
0.0460828133,
-0.0521947108,
-0.0148064932,
0.0319165438,
0.0317150503,
-0.0010410988,
0.0236522872,
0.0426341742,
-0.0367629901,
0.0861949921,
0.007028053,
-0.0381364264,
-0.0132913217,
0.00895896,
-0.0402550027,
-0.0787862241,
-0.0228179898,
-0.0336221047,
0.0067002913,
0.0023049565,
0.0023909989,
-0.023148736,
0.0145310592,
0.0402028412,
0.0749871507,
-0.0208183173,
-0.0051785042,
-0.0277664959,
-0.0338740498,
0.000787454,
0.0106084123,
0.0360618457,
0.0448660403,
0.0384193622,
0.0170986801,
-0.0308606829,
-0.0284530893,
0.0352834687,
-0.002600386,
0.0133755524,
0.0064884485,
0.0206542425,
-0.0230858233,
0.0246534366,
0.0147228502,
-0.0401926972,
-0.025974568,
-0.0321636721,
-0.0031877146,
0.0398328677,
0.0416028015,
0.0186955091,
0.0555412881,
-0.0408113301,
-0.0187988542,
0.0218311027,
0.0288864877,
-0.0553191043,
-0.025148632,
-0.0005351525,
0.0128262229,
-0.0328651853,
-0.0176369976,
-0.003591717,
-0.0432821885,
-0.0596282184,
0.0163761675,
0.019533027,
0.0079082446,
-0.0101433657,
0.0018959779,
0.0207264163,
-0.002042063,
-0.0331092328,
0.0154724075,
-0.0444643088,
-0.024550369,
-0.0300379898,
-0.1035438254,
-0.0501930639,
0.0075753806,
-0.0307768658,
0.0080220494,
0.0059654349,
-0.0009725856,
0.0512028001,
-0.0218892936,
-0.0316887721,
-0.0215430707,
-0.0654075816,
0.0241402835,
0.0372034907,
0.0177738741,
0.0013456336,
-0.0021651883,
0.0351155661,
-0.0195703916,
-0.0187016856,
-0.0289239474,
-0.0270301271,
0.0677876398,
-0.0273553431,
-0.0378097109,
-0.0367842987,
-0.0428551659,
-0.011182568,
0.0583577938,
-0.0266666822,
0.00570213,
0.0204592589,
2.473e-7,
0.0666589737,
0.0244898144,
-0.0356176011,
-0.0581692196,
-0.0290183742,
0.001513021,
0.0098477006,
0.0343570821,
-0.030936718,
0.0054369303,
0.0793179572,
-0.0044442844,
0.0071302084,
0.0729587153,
-0.007619909,
-0.0061761918,
-0.0621508732,
0.0037049504,
-0.0181864314,
-0.0492049865,
-0.0159108415,
0.0456400551,
0.0640156046,
0.0002811584,
-0.0176769905,
0.0098564215,
0.0615437143,
-0.0834338441,
0.0508609377,
-0.005654267,
0.0136458213,
0.0186174251,
0.0203918908,
-0.0235152971,
-0.0523929261,
-0.0198078528,
0.0333429351,
0.0410474874,
-0.0197013319,
-0.0221862495,
-0.0155037213,
-0.0125498362,
-0.0242130179,
-0.0699410439,
0.0476931334,
-0.0672558397,
-0.0020707597,
0.0618173853,
0.0039551696,
-0.0118772425,
0.0183938406,
0.0121795842,
0.0462977253,
0.019721467,
0.0282333978,
0.0219973791,
0.0020074046,
-0.040314395,
-0.0188554469,
0.0130468048,
-0.004034644,
-0.0079332674,
0.0015076604,
-0.0241215453,
-0.0735647306,
-0.0187194031,
0.0017052486,
1.903477084e-34,
0.0110925231,
0.0351523124,
-0.0158225298,
-0.0088601178,
0.0008490041,
0.0063945502,
-0.0335951559,
0.0170246717,
0.0424954854,
-0.0927509889,
-0.0337021388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10706v1 | TC-GAT: Graph Attention Network for Temporal Causality Discovery | 2023-04-21T02:26:42 | 2023-04-21T02:26:42 | Xiaosong Yuan, Ke Chen, Wanli Zuo, Yijia Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The present study explores the intricacies of causal relationship extraction,
a vital component in the pursuit of causality knowledge. Causality is
frequently intertwined with temporal elements, as the progression from cause to
effect is not instantaneous but rather ensconced in a temporal dimension. Thus,
the extraction of temporal causality holds paramount significance in the field.
In light of this, we propose a method for extracting causality from the text
that integrates both temporal and causal relations, with a particular focus on
the time aspect. To this end, we first compile a dataset that encompasses
temporal relationships. Subsequently, we present a novel model, TC-GAT, which
employs a graph attention mechanism to assign weights to the temporal
relationships and leverages a causal knowledge graph to determine the adjacency
matrix. Additionally, we implement an equilibrium mechanism to regulate the
interplay between temporal and causal relations. Our experiments demonstrate
that our proposed method significantly surpasses baseline models in the task of
causality extraction. | [
-0.0063186851,
0.0486952439,
-0.0213712174,
0.0161683653,
-0.0309701748,
-0.0023796773,
-0.0094924942,
-0.0089168102,
0.0630384013,
-0.0078844409,
0.0573410951,
0.036757838,
-0.01762929,
0.0374813415,
0.0063413167,
-0.0289464202,
0.0131103471,
0.0357389823,
0.0297398716,
0.0420582853,
-0.0032169977,
0.0021359872,
0.0003049518,
0.0112832468,
-0.0261597764,
-0.0384046249,
0.0096422108,
-0.008023696,
0.0419545434,
-0.0464664139,
-0.025613131,
-0.005020313,
0.0017789752,
0.0152542908,
0.000001933,
0.0117460471,
-0.0182576496,
-0.0261553302,
-0.0074486863,
0.0093872752,
-0.0550857931,
0.0049669901,
0.0522885919,
-0.0330538824,
-0.055480808,
-0.0076600695,
0.0018871115,
0.0583592728,
-0.0042728856,
0.0858201534,
-0.0246749558,
-0.0521483384,
0.0356819965,
-0.0008312385,
0.0317242183,
-0.045496285,
0.0143127907,
0.0278134961,
0.0261318274,
-0.0275478009,
-0.0382249281,
0.0236315653,
0.0422307886,
-0.0147917997,
0.0789833888,
0.0497739762,
0.0169348363,
0.0416828506,
-0.0083128642,
0.1038619801,
0.0627085045,
-0.0684598833,
0.0367391855,
0.0087583624,
0.0008787062,
0.0576157011,
-0.0457583331,
-0.0228829142,
-0.0186820384,
0.012507976,
0.041001711,
0.0251619928,
0.0577696227,
0.0070177931,
-0.0118721277,
0.0990066007,
0.0024882287,
-0.0405564755,
-0.0285157748,
0.0149920303,
0.0171902254,
0.0035700623,
0.0156486277,
0.0316389017,
-0.0076112915,
0.0029424876,
0.0110713961,
0.0048701805,
-0.046556443,
-0.0370433703,
0.006075609,
-0.0085794032,
-0.0053012562,
0.0755771101,
-0.0007106051,
0.0305034872,
-0.0705453977,
0.0087586408,
-0.0115658389,
0.0291399937,
-0.0485187843,
0.0119218985,
-0.0095967986,
-0.0062296563,
0.0257600155,
-0.0023740616,
-0.0145129785,
0.0252447687,
0.0037504674,
-0.0403196476,
-0.0114661166,
0.0137761272,
0.0105840424,
-0.0134170111,
-0.0128893191,
-0.0035693857,
-0.0472836383,
0.0357759036,
-0.046206899,
0.0085979616,
-0.0443122424,
0.0194940511,
0.0583518408,
-0.0620385259,
-0.0367223695,
0.0724228173,
0.0080679329,
-0.0120078465,
-0.0315643586,
-0.0474134944,
0.006014972,
-0.0225242749,
0.004667874,
-0.0158560108,
0.006231423,
0.0102405688,
-0.0205536149,
0.0105221737,
-0.0034716041,
-0.0256421529,
-0.0830027908,
0.0183982905,
0.045376163,
0.0103107933,
-0.0045021423,
-0.0297965873,
0.0349607766,
0.0066932598,
0.0593682379,
0.0231301617,
0.0139649054,
0.0126872817,
-0.044377543,
-0.0071861641,
0.0697132349,
0.0089481631,
-0.0250857063,
-0.0171621051,
-0.0113310842,
0.0007847821,
-0.0108693112,
-0.0300044678,
-0.0279473662,
-0.0063699246,
0.0500062592,
-0.0256751198,
-0.0107536828,
-0.0039526331,
0.0742152035,
-0.0372069962,
-0.0139016667,
0.0119429715,
-0.044959195,
0.0312826373,
-0.0286927819,
0.0263690725,
-0.0093062827,
-0.0167990103,
-0.0000063785,
-0.0059016747,
0.0213228296,
0.0313283056,
0.0155664422,
-0.0090437243,
0.0620421991,
0.0049728616,
-0.0536342114,
0.0040764888,
0.018395327,
0.0045221555,
0.0115263406,
0.0550284944,
0.007139178,
0.0474364534,
0.0569727235,
-0.041220285,
-0.0199858304,
-0.0183076411,
0.0418462902,
-0.0012988519,
-0.0039944788,
-0.0091391504,
-0.0413262248,
-0.0072313878,
-0.0320898928,
0.0076632965,
-0.0000428819,
0.0151882954,
0.0233266857,
0.0314022489,
-0.017835632,
-0.0076726298,
-0.0025851019,
0.0208077636,
0.0106138289,
-0.0397607498,
-0.0340984464,
0.0259285811,
0.0480288491,
0.043589443,
-0.0075250086,
0.0129330177,
0.0244236719,
-0.0359956995,
-0.0230484381,
0.0569221675,
-0.0346915014,
-0.036243774,
0.0285292976,
-0.0547565483,
-0.0505951755,
0.0193347279,
-0.0296572279,
-0.062912643,
0.107746318,
-0.0044227345,
0.0144796968,
0.0130693996,
-0.0389745869,
0.0292275771,
0.0110928444,
-0.0143797025,
0.092273578,
-0.0029740632,
-0.0010862221,
-0.0115410686,
-0.011229312,
-0.0217212103,
-0.0199106261,
0.037632063,
-0.0125015797,
0.016942123,
-0.0395519957,
0.052728653,
-0.0288172457,
-0.0422679298,
0.0144071113,
-0.0319256261,
0.0146115888,
-0.0086458223,
0.0130236158,
-0.0012620036,
-0.0001957587,
0.0039178678,
-0.0299421251,
-0.0104913153,
0.0234086029,
-0.0455228128,
-0.025482513,
0.0536588766,
-0.020548325,
0.0069593177,
-0.0220462997,
-0.016119251,
-0.0842605606,
0.0693116486,
0.0663192123,
-0.067816712,
0.0305127241,
-0.0169697776,
-0.0089412183,
-0.0022585096,
-0.0292918812,
0.0059694117,
-0.0036932034,
-0.0449100621,
0.0118236439,
0.0676286146,
-0.0016595093,
0.0283799879,
0.0048197112,
-0.0229616109,
-0.0187147092,
0.0232236665,
-0.0749567226,
0.0645978525,
-0.015925603,
-0.0067985421,
-0.0103404876,
0.0802095011,
0.0152996955,
-0.0003307514,
-0.0412295163,
-0.0138747608,
-0.0078526428,
0.035276942,
-0.0005979607,
0.009208682,
-0.0414958298,
-0.0228234492,
-0.0594377033,
-0.0346457213,
0.0617121123,
0.0480103381,
0.0103101535,
0.0425304957,
0.0158092175,
-0.0736595392,
0.0651013255,
0.055362951,
-0.0193286035,
0.0169571061,
-0.0644515306,
-0.0119704381,
-0.0064549386,
0.0673100352,
0.0405349247,
0.014446279,
-0.0079997107,
0.0595130175,
0.0216636062,
0.004737942,
-0.0093506845,
-0.0572294593,
-0.0030583623,
0.0135240797,
-0.0172021464,
-0.0030398881,
-0.0313208252,
-0.020996891,
0.0015000266,
0.0113791954,
-0.0398120433,
0.0021333585,
-0.0107651809,
0.0591881573,
0.0398430824,
-0.0500510447,
-0.0066244169,
-0.0223814324,
-0.0083860094,
-0.0059482157,
-0.0028570937,
-0.045114357,
-0.0383867398,
-0.0022432068,
-0.0501086451,
-0.0426374748,
0.0232211575,
-0.0264842995,
-0.0157748703,
-0.0507856607,
0.0168305002,
0.0551855713,
0.0214058086,
-0.0370849259,
0.003299366,
0.0655244812,
-0.0266641546,
0.0267998595,
-0.0167743322,
-0.0814352781,
-0.0120094018,
-0.0385319777,
-0.0204618778,
0.0062594539,
-0.0719287694,
-0.0071444609,
-0.0238974504,
-0.0000521566,
0.0324725024,
-0.026443461,
0.0122055225,
-0.0379368514,
-0.003549519,
-0.020820478,
-0.0553968772,
-0.0082018031,
0.0097932145,
0.0308454242,
0.0118343495,
0.0037022303,
-0.0059403586,
0.0165342204,
0.0364058241,
0.0277841315,
-0.0036845035,
0.0498656146,
-0.0369761921,
0.0162277762,
0.012624912,
0.0246731043,
-0.0330852903,
-0.0184442494,
0.0454747602,
-0.0104579963,
-0.0018804019,
-0.027213281,
0.0296162106,
-0.0275811274,
-0.0172885302,
0.0129744709,
0.1345316321,
0.0091137206,
-0.0406384319,
-0.0178669561,
-0.0173048358,
-0.0126510216,
0.0266245473,
0.0209916774,
0.0115596456,
-0.0717709213,
0.0188386757,
-0.01510185,
-0.0896545202,
-0.0604802929,
-0.0414110869,
-0.0164425783,
-0.004852708,
-0.0464563034,
-0.0571926609,
-0.038684614,
-0.0186963528,
-0.0085260412,
0.0131672937,
0.0405173302,
-0.0341522396,
-0.0678362027,
0.0438072272,
-0.0128408968,
0.0117678717,
-0.0069505717,
-0.0035777269,
-0.0144405998,
-0.0318238437,
0.0063509932,
0.0650268868,
-0.0400402807,
-0.0410679877,
-0.0219284501,
-0.0306258779,
0.0024186554,
0.0743837953,
-0.0407438315,
0.0089394432,
0.0128006265,
-0.0096794525,
-0.0286948234,
-0.0115308622,
0.019453682,
-0.0145792495,
-0.0015124275,
0.0362005122,
-0.0349613093,
0.024091335,
0.0001789912,
0.0287263263,
-0.0444594473,
0.0237558149,
0.0038444286,
0.0051760739,
0.0772586763,
0.0168925617,
0.0136096934,
-0.0402349047,
-0.0158866458,
-0.0366593041,
0.0005856467,
-0.0157389659,
0.0184667129,
0.0141026722,
0.006847234,
-0.0380727611,
-0.0515743308,
-0.0086337393,
0.0111745782,
-0.0134822438,
0.022697445,
-0.0002403542,
0.0191643368,
0.0028751944,
0.0070362231,
-0.0167655256,
0.0059003946,
-0.003578244,
0.0173212662,
-0.0032686689,
0.0197868031,
0.0287877303,
0.0149012478,
-0.0487444103,
-0.0600053594,
-0.1417515725,
0.0727239177,
0.0296716131,
-0.0451821573,
0.0610421784,
-0.0258681923,
0.0766458511,
-0.0060726581,
0.0041184798,
0.0188463945,
0.0723828003,
0.0210444685,
0.0046398789,
-0.0047528683,
0.0091631226,
-0.0256106053,
0.0532082058,
0.0555214249,
0.0184932556,
0.0327596292,
0.0227755215,
-0.057573624,
0.0013989623,
-0.0487122685,
-0.0524579547,
0.014258435,
-0.0124073122,
0.0142404791,
-0.0674394146,
-0.0152892908,
0.0318742841,
-0.0170054454,
0.0073180543,
0.0015506278,
0.0052150162,
-0.0086246654,
0.0356497504,
-0.0382601805,
-0.0268086717,
0.0961571634,
-0.0339504778,
-0.0414087549,
-0.0338829607,
-5.993704636e-33,
-0.0196554027,
-0.0574931279,
-0.0100928051,
0.0481391586,
-0.0679194033,
0.0640717149,
-0.0781657621,
-0.0396271162,
-0.0178949535,
0.0504904948,
-0.0058060079,
0.057804767,
0.0025944915,
-0.0150863603,
0.0261182208,
-0.0006248017,
-0.0150118191,
0.0113877645,
0.0291390345,
0.0657414496,
0.0673796088,
0.0357042551,
0.0564211532,
-0.0640770271,
0.0469321311,
-0.010803326,
0.0295208152,
-0.0114661045,
0.0254041702,
0.0403890721,
-0.0005360864,
-0.0009143676,
0.0385365002,
-0.0430928804,
0.0029479912,
0.00487429,
-0.1080420315,
-0.0788927823,
0.0171220005,
-0.0042192214,
-0.0514148884,
-0.058265619,
-0.0211008992,
0.0031335871,
0.0486202948,
-0.0639295876,
0.0820960402,
0.0176428091,
-0.0548143685,
-0.041990798,
-0.0615865961,
0.0569981821,
-0.0607830957,
0.0266138818,
0.0108207893,
-0.00476943,
0.0202300884,
0.0120095601,
0.0136775495,
0.0185090713,
-0.0265825782,
-0.0209546238,
-0.0382571444,
0.0354192108,
0.0219877567,
0.0340863429,
-0.0576720908,
0.0057769492,
-0.0602245703,
0.0273653045,
-0.0378746353,
0.0132130468,
0.0105942935,
0.0001574222,
-0.0115505243,
0.0120003838,
-0.113554053,
-0.0324542485,
0.0533985868,
0.0197573714,
0.0061258744,
-0.006236298,
0.0043262769,
0.0058786771,
0.0221203081,
-0.0245966837,
-0.0153710693,
0.006374029,
-0.0090989256,
-0.0074393838,
0.0242960379,
0.011283177,
0.0199348722,
-0.0426648632,
0.0062631201,
0.0790259317,
-0.0333208814,
0.0191164501,
0.016136745,
0.0074521722,
-0.0873023793,
0.0217286479,
-0.0132730836,
0.001222573,
0.0362455621,
0.0064137815,
0.0360196158,
-0.014827,
0.0139424652,
-0.0580176935,
-0.0232857857,
-0.0287103131,
-0.0225667991,
-0.0489666797,
0.0554223135,
0.0608954951,
0.0082096383,
0.0569496192,
0.0485880487,
0.0689802095,
0.0128679657,
0.0043594218,
0.009934661,
0.032423038,
-0.0410981327,
-0.0232228469,
-0.0024695613,
0.0857914761,
-0.0162650477,
-0.0408845544,
-0.0207807738,
-0.0080195703,
2.607e-7,
0.0555897802,
0.0412472263,
0.0488151647,
0.0426609255,
0.0209588818,
-0.0291257296,
0.0207408406,
0.0299961548,
-0.0207852162,
0.0360989943,
0.0574978106,
0.0137637015,
0.0254449714,
0.0086518172,
-0.056113597,
-0.0271140002,
-0.0541526824,
-0.0599642172,
-0.0281974487,
-0.0155827515,
0.0572008193,
0.0346483886,
0.0642590001,
0.0395183004,
-0.0172329433,
-0.0411488749,
0.0727759451,
0.0068125795,
-0.0156770144,
-0.0067571057,
0.0054090545,
-0.0589291975,
-0.0765085518,
0.0192765556,
-0.0142000914,
0.0488028303,
-0.04080211,
0.031350594,
-0.0465984829,
-0.0062145819,
-0.0166702028,
-0.0796833113,
0.0157293733,
-0.0157009549,
0.0581637025,
-0.0192730129,
-0.0439616814,
0.0225111526,
-0.0482007712,
0.0355308875,
0.0086651836,
0.0431882031,
0.0038769485,
0.008737945,
0.003428878,
-0.0041854549,
-0.0071204612,
-0.08661367,
-0.0273057781,
0.0726436079,
0.0043131323,
-0.0150715103,
0.0066324798,
0.0044069085,
0.0197793357,
-0.0123304492,
0.0026477948,
2.07534469e-34,
0.0287756417,
0.0207986888,
-0.0017541668,
-0.0267866328,
0.0259352699,
-0.0514075309,
-0.045012366,
0.0122743482,
0.0628419891,
-0.0898129866,
-0.0070284395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10703v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10703v2 | ReCEval: Evaluating Reasoning Chains via Correctness and Informativeness | 2023-04-21T02:19:06 | 2023-11-30T23:33:07 | Archiki Prasad, Swarnadeep Saha, Xiang Zhou, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multi-step reasoning ability is fundamental to many natural language tasks,
yet it is unclear what constitutes a good reasoning chain and how to evaluate
them. Most existing methods focus solely on whether the reasoning chain leads
to the correct conclusion, but this answer-oriented view may confound reasoning
quality with other spurious shortcuts to predict the answer. To bridge this
gap, we evaluate reasoning chains by viewing them as informal proofs that
derive the final answer. Specifically, we propose ReCEval (Reasoning Chain
Evaluation), a framework that evaluates reasoning chains via two key
properties: (1) correctness, i.e., each step makes a valid inference based on
information contained within the step, preceding steps, and input context, and
(2) informativeness, i.e., each step provides new information that is helpful
towards deriving the generated answer. We evaluate these properties by
developing metrics using natural language inference models and V-Information.
On multiple datasets, we show that ReCEval effectively identifies various error
types and yields notable improvements compared to prior methods. We analyze the
impact of step boundaries, and previous steps on evaluating correctness and
demonstrate that our informativeness metric captures the expected flow of
information in high-quality reasoning chains. Finally, we show that scoring
reasoning chains based on ReCEval improves downstream task performance. Our
code is publicly available at: https://github.com/archiki/ReCEval | [
0.0128111858,
0.0344695672,
0.0188848581,
0.0256739762,
-0.0359082744,
0.0157078225,
-0.0136953462,
-0.0119038671,
0.0319047533,
-0.0159308817,
0.0067899195,
0.0294986274,
0.0397955887,
0.0233714059,
0.0096785743,
-0.0597479045,
0.0333863311,
-0.0327327177,
0.0281621218,
0.0183798969,
-0.0049519809,
0.0075644339,
-0.0202094242,
0.0451693945,
-0.0081118802,
-0.0404138044,
-0.0071110511,
0.009512824,
0.0451865345,
-0.0514429361,
0.0094300769,
0.0273414068,
0.0056204633,
0.006519577,
0.0000022748,
-0.0643316507,
-0.001291247,
0.0101620127,
-0.0654195026,
-0.0311554447,
-0.0463310294,
0.0060467985,
0.0229002628,
0.0281222574,
-0.0367796011,
-0.0320322141,
0.0172537062,
0.0458783023,
0.0655788854,
0.0573689044,
0.0043040649,
-0.0553589016,
-0.0204844847,
-0.0021325282,
0.0133352689,
-0.0705012232,
0.013578116,
0.0404370241,
0.0273390822,
-0.0069680018,
0.0128421644,
0.0201000739,
0.0370994844,
-0.0157176834,
-0.0264390334,
0.0208566673,
0.0121749854,
-0.0314240195,
-0.0026243238,
0.0647653118,
0.0253419485,
-0.004130845,
-0.0298043843,
-0.0315675698,
0.0059078145,
0.0103288116,
-0.0121750021,
0.0267924499,
-0.0704755038,
-0.0134561174,
-0.0034474514,
0.0313353799,
0.0398533419,
-0.0019305786,
-0.0042134309,
0.1114177331,
-0.0340416208,
-0.0266199186,
0.0408780091,
0.0004284833,
-0.0081011206,
-0.069093734,
0.0197775234,
0.0345653333,
-0.0360857323,
0.0372212157,
0.0053019891,
0.0091211218,
0.0341517814,
-0.0066988762,
-0.018382784,
0.0004597153,
-0.0069582304,
0.0337429158,
-0.0232705232,
0.0245500505,
-0.0219904911,
0.0162409749,
0.0061796145,
-0.0379243754,
-0.0450080782,
0.0059152693,
-0.0057545369,
0.0233428683,
-0.0034314878,
0.013968871,
-0.0377526917,
-0.0129081262,
-0.049040515,
0.0402410328,
0.0149555365,
0.0179530028,
0.018537201,
-0.0208382271,
-0.0796488151,
0.0206122361,
-0.0867147669,
0.0576757081,
0.0377884507,
-0.0201639626,
-0.0168225076,
-0.0047873636,
0.0152639868,
-0.0062245675,
0.0080189165,
0.0686481372,
0.0123225451,
0.0164318662,
-0.0591122881,
-0.0768659562,
0.0067806342,
-0.0922981128,
-0.0155710895,
-0.0721345395,
0.0327649228,
0.0164203309,
-0.0106686074,
-0.0250606555,
-0.0056391759,
0.0524083935,
-0.0294001605,
0.0741182491,
-0.0229092557,
-0.0085924212,
-0.0016876014,
0.0248672534,
-0.0390292667,
0.0378492922,
0.055909168,
0.0304163042,
0.0529051349,
-0.0023679773,
0.0288201757,
-0.005910662,
0.0017547801,
-0.0545258969,
0.0535461828,
0.0247985553,
-0.0743160695,
0.0260689985,
-0.0131411403,
0.0188309252,
-0.0107195545,
0.0057985317,
0.0087475404,
0.0301527213,
0.0244069919,
-0.0146877924,
0.0653919578,
-0.0021202702,
0.0159116499,
0.0011170439,
-0.0584890246,
0.0175454281,
-0.0383490361,
-0.0052513923,
0.0092906067,
0.01523392,
0.0167010687,
-0.086290352,
-0.0301154554,
0.0078517562,
0.0410798229,
-0.0101368185,
0.0482567176,
0.0401509032,
-0.0305729844,
0.0077639269,
0.0243320242,
-0.0640654862,
-0.014969728,
-0.0211521164,
0.0420900136,
0.0461132824,
0.0165914278,
-0.0191040393,
-0.006732767,
-0.0007404447,
0.0366710834,
-0.0006780636,
0.008122771,
-0.006162296,
0.0299786981,
-0.0102951378,
-0.0293800384,
0.0073715262,
0.0056077754,
-0.0195084922,
0.0605061725,
-0.0095920069,
0.00436443,
-0.0570638552,
0.0154395672,
0.0168424286,
0.0146809006,
0.0253822617,
0.009576642,
0.0340485573,
0.0297923088,
0.0090313666,
0.0389927179,
0.0283573512,
0.0008340886,
-0.000102663,
-0.0567045994,
0.0291036107,
-0.0191192087,
-0.0453973934,
0.0018308477,
-0.0737978593,
-0.026384959,
-0.0049866093,
-0.0633585155,
-0.0234046746,
0.0457104295,
-0.039785292,
-0.0408397093,
0.0106048454,
-0.0062887287,
0.0288619529,
-0.0045708618,
0.0123215988,
0.1108211428,
0.0133879054,
0.0276324619,
0.0115385801,
0.0062312703,
0.0099305492,
0.0029637064,
0.0411874652,
-0.0210038237,
-0.029377602,
-0.0137671828,
0.0425163247,
0.0213765595,
-0.0786988661,
0.0175292436,
-0.0455741957,
0.0319933593,
-0.0215229467,
0.0426280834,
0.0210306682,
-0.0093047582,
0.0075011225,
-0.0292307381,
-0.0047573685,
0.0025757484,
-0.0052306103,
-0.0139109334,
0.0529859588,
-0.0058425502,
-0.012571956,
-0.0179795884,
0.0131162936,
-0.0416285694,
0.0466104969,
0.0132886749,
-0.0041538849,
-0.0278971456,
-0.0180964172,
-0.0505000278,
0.0188313723,
0.0015701253,
-0.007934384,
0.0569283925,
0.0287457313,
0.009610557,
0.0492206849,
0.0004310248,
-0.0095387194,
0.0224305447,
-0.0314819664,
-0.0294586625,
0.0393474773,
-0.0384708457,
0.0037792569,
0.0090533458,
-0.0470873788,
-0.0185156558,
0.0391022526,
0.01952051,
0.0181794763,
-0.0533138029,
0.0266627166,
-0.0032066687,
-0.0009376016,
-0.0146701271,
-0.0237774476,
0.0062203319,
0.0575087443,
-0.0241226126,
-0.0355383307,
0.0880234987,
-0.0072794282,
0.0050985334,
-0.0455787331,
0.0019037588,
-0.0371659175,
0.0784600005,
0.000723931,
-0.0309054218,
0.0551704913,
0.0024710596,
-0.0145708332,
-0.0223563258,
0.0330609977,
-0.0201252252,
0.0539023988,
-0.1042469144,
-0.0066478779,
0.0014138129,
-0.0310985632,
-0.0234173667,
0.0100871995,
-0.0367332809,
-0.0074895415,
-0.0251755323,
-0.0334110595,
-0.0065097259,
-0.0388095304,
0.0499265864,
0.03652725,
0.003164859,
-0.0290949717,
-0.0100221131,
-0.0008165114,
0.0120624481,
0.0385069437,
0.0597062744,
0.0177531634,
0.0299782474,
0.0768187419,
0.0229157433,
0.0209722836,
-0.0374286659,
0.011453405,
-0.0260854401,
-0.0227534119,
-0.0221485905,
0.02940212,
0.0502501354,
-0.099342905,
-0.0282573514,
0.0877260044,
0.019204013,
0.0071859122,
0.009158927,
-0.0022672112,
0.0317204818,
0.0238060895,
0.0174665935,
-0.0954668894,
-0.0861331671,
0.0183257423,
0.0147823785,
-0.016424058,
-0.0507663004,
-0.0194964707,
-0.108220011,
0.0429532975,
-0.0255245287,
-0.0143268295,
-0.0355689079,
-0.0997473001,
0.0560580716,
-0.0001452906,
-0.0573942102,
0.0016166053,
0.0023207725,
0.0102340784,
0.0201422591,
-0.0625092462,
-0.0218552593,
0.0595438182,
-0.0532414764,
0.0114642475,
0.03129825,
0.029601315,
0.0099114673,
-0.0531576723,
-0.0017760921,
-0.051048249,
-0.0219910275,
-0.0085958894,
0.0551086105,
0.0033396024,
0.0246196147,
-0.010417073,
0.0246968735,
-0.0326100066,
-0.0517407283,
0.050022319,
0.0999576598,
-0.0159988049,
-0.0529165044,
-0.006672807,
0.0346516222,
-0.0023317155,
0.0742797479,
0.0267669968,
0.0252901241,
-0.0409311391,
-0.0156605318,
0.0200026538,
-0.0463620983,
-0.0307004042,
0.0352578796,
0.0238367189,
-0.0248758253,
-0.0544854216,
-0.0480065569,
0.0270304382,
0.0451348945,
-0.0337065756,
0.0006009348,
0.016946543,
0.009796693,
-0.0440709069,
0.0466566496,
-0.0145225273,
0.0298484638,
0.0075068749,
0.0322241299,
-0.0273069181,
0.0108744632,
-0.0329258591,
0.0506843142,
-0.0604572482,
-0.0206386391,
-0.0472076759,
0.0320460461,
0.0219862312,
0.0347607173,
-0.0308252219,
-0.0343103595,
-0.0105250031,
0.0051411116,
-0.0078059444,
-0.0377895012,
0.0511993766,
0.0019003573,
0.0137192151,
0.0408172309,
-0.0411422774,
-0.0100102089,
-0.0297109094,
0.0654844418,
-0.0026229345,
-0.0406002477,
0.0195218697,
-0.004221811,
0.0381418616,
-0.0089310389,
-0.0280928537,
-0.0150889577,
0.0155176315,
-0.0221110843,
-0.0673988834,
-0.0309910662,
0.0436143652,
-0.0355494544,
0.0064237388,
-0.0166185983,
-0.011124731,
0.0061308895,
-0.007065489,
0.000255876,
-0.0197319556,
0.063068524,
0.0349535123,
-0.004553759,
-0.0362593383,
-0.0313937962,
-0.0175694749,
-0.0074917637,
0.0510213785,
-0.0141897108,
0.0526078418,
0.0482742079,
-0.0130924247,
-0.0262877513,
0.0059644021,
-0.0348211378,
-0.0380689204,
0.0037149775,
0.0184514709,
0.0322441198,
0.0162272491,
0.035594482,
-0.0179709308,
0.0046577458,
0.0132191824,
0.0343205892,
0.0163005516,
-0.0645833388,
0.0404753014,
0.0287347715,
-0.0265660044,
0.0012382881,
0.0360566899,
-0.0569803119,
0.024743313,
-0.0346425213,
-0.040785715,
-0.0343098044,
-0.0541865677,
-0.0673889816,
0.0081379646,
-0.0040357737,
-0.0110364622,
-0.0604278296,
-0.0918557793,
-0.0129847322,
0.0391134806,
0.0168591961,
0.0352573581,
0.044961039,
0.0708362982,
0.0299980436,
-0.0668774918,
-0.0211790446,
-0.0304569118,
-0.0075872475,
-0.0075033931,
-0.0299297385,
-6.643014654e-33,
-0.0220086891,
-0.052628208,
0.0387451015,
-0.0080940062,
0.010290808,
0.0011190159,
-0.0744877681,
-0.0121426461,
-0.0203712266,
0.0806774721,
0.002751404,
-0.0025852558,
0.0114549752,
-0.0096840663,
-0.0021241517,
-0.0406564251,
-0.0154386619,
0.0450367816,
-0.0640133768,
0.0146153998,
0.054889597,
-0.0260330755,
0.0556228533,
-0.0809876025,
0.0418923721,
0.0314421467,
-0.0280426536,
0.0470827483,
-0.0614830069,
0.0247076489,
0.0285207704,
0.0295276549,
0.0208172314,
-0.0413830057,
0.0210071951,
0.0568779819,
-0.0953529924,
-0.0465190336,
0.0430857725,
-0.0100982869,
-0.1274676472,
0.0048668296,
0.0558549799,
0.0221459381,
0.0082157375,
-0.0269146971,
0.0541598387,
-0.0012989448,
0.0370480716,
-0.020842785,
-0.0590860844,
0.0207422897,
-0.0301136281,
-0.0429597721,
-0.0250781383,
0.0558457449,
-0.0111901928,
-0.025149649,
-0.0641527027,
-0.0183687657,
-0.0030571632,
-0.0216913689,
0.0555629656,
-0.0237170085,
-0.0309507288,
0.0699297264,
0.0072735907,
-0.0210263822,
-0.0504665226,
0.0007443431,
-0.0072282692,
0.0600687154,
0.0760816112,
0.0093044015,
0.0258398354,
0.0627377182,
-0.0908635482,
0.0202843454,
-0.0194972344,
0.0954534933,
-0.0200045165,
-0.0248938967,
-0.0495213754,
-0.0202227961,
-0.0562042892,
0.0075032068,
-0.0255155712,
-0.023830384,
0.020945007,
-0.0209421348,
-0.0151882945,
-0.0128339734,
-0.0146655757,
-0.0122289751,
-0.016407758,
0.0482001454,
0.0005751389,
-0.0001589489,
0.0246880446,
0.0240939166,
-0.0221753623,
0.0333261006,
0.0118995868,
0.0144384755,
0.0643044412,
-0.0213977136,
0.0299964808,
0.0107605392,
-0.0188619401,
-0.0094856899,
-0.0592204779,
0.0212118626,
-0.0345679559,
-0.0086630294,
0.0451457985,
0.0467268229,
-0.0136016561,
0.0540845469,
0.0095289908,
0.0174484607,
-0.0331452005,
0.0284909084,
0.019912893,
0.0042248839,
-0.0081479857,
-0.0130466232,
-0.0213812292,
-0.0239674058,
0.0105014779,
-0.0353123061,
0.001849481,
0.0492834784,
2.995e-7,
0.0338279754,
0.0329137444,
0.0330418721,
0.0604394786,
0.0007108601,
0.0580858216,
-0.0126288831,
-0.0321819894,
0.0244406071,
-0.0662121251,
-0.0165727921,
0.0402237624,
0.0465221256,
0.0746378973,
-0.0604981966,
-0.0487818308,
-0.0455967709,
-0.0214663036,
-0.0256591439,
-0.0129320798,
0.0715389848,
0.0126966527,
0.0403007306,
-0.0033376687,
-0.0164271872,
-0.016670011,
0.0001257185,
0.0115670245,
0.0323001333,
0.003238511,
0.0503054783,
-0.0274717603,
0.0411547571,
0.0492070317,
-0.0132937199,
-0.0202394314,
-0.0294298567,
0.0261595119,
0.013665217,
0.0014449619,
-0.0662555769,
-0.0356641077,
0.0531727523,
-0.0273027457,
0.0678512156,
-0.0705404654,
-0.0184425656,
-0.0140300645,
-0.0100161657,
-0.0310780369,
0.0257870853,
0.027204195,
-0.0383626893,
0.0089032529,
0.0229683816,
-0.0011643519,
-0.0274586696,
-0.0774353817,
-0.0566625297,
0.0368797928,
-0.0087720221,
-0.0027458351,
0.005598492,
-0.0086977538,
0.0124699436,
-0.0502305366,
-0.0186281074,
2.732767226e-34,
-0.0069919219,
-0.0169677008,
0.0244949106,
0.0075611314,
0.0960133076,
-0.0060017868,
-0.0375802629,
0.0007833439,
0.0198394097,
-0.0349199995,
-0.0176365171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10663v1 | Meta Semantics: Towards better natural language understanding and reasoning | 2023-04-20T22:16:16 | 2023-04-20T22:16:16 | Xiaolin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 03B65(Primary) 68T50(Secondary), I.2.4; I.2.7 | Natural language understanding is one of the most challenging topics in
artificial intelligence. Deep neural network methods, particularly large
language module (LLM) methods such as ChatGPT and GPT-3, have powerful
flexibility to adopt informal text but are weak on logical deduction and suffer
from the out-of-vocabulary (OOV) problem. On the other hand, rule-based methods
such as Mathematica, Semantic web, and Lean, are excellent in reasoning but
cannot handle the complex and changeable informal text. Inspired by pragmatics
and structuralism, we propose two strategies to solve the OOV problem and a
semantic model for better natural language understanding and reasoning. | [
0.0638408884,
-0.0158103723,
-0.0141255492,
0.0633176118,
-0.0442878529,
0.0126679335,
-0.0494529344,
0.0103293313,
-0.0376535803,
-0.0407126881,
0.0239014626,
0.0409271345,
-0.0190631207,
0.0648426041,
-0.0246069804,
-0.075631991,
0.0336211473,
-0.0129918372,
0.0407715254,
-0.0029366459,
0.0388049483,
0.0217753705,
0.007512189,
-0.0181881934,
0.0117136957,
-0.0284689534,
-0.0226946361,
0.0095001915,
0.0031151648,
0.0163622778,
-0.0041539236,
-0.0252933353,
-0.0028536553,
0.0336119346,
0.0000019961,
-0.0802531391,
-0.0325586535,
0.0116961151,
-0.01376135,
-0.0091345403,
0.0296265967,
0.0031351605,
-0.0088800751,
-0.0042629479,
-0.0497113951,
0.0174283311,
0.0443881676,
0.043129649,
0.0505416207,
0.0544268861,
-0.0141690047,
-0.0523008145,
-0.002836497,
0.0022101572,
0.0467220098,
-0.0707617328,
0.000296841,
0.0525404848,
0.0189212989,
-0.0114494804,
-0.0070409952,
0.0417618044,
0.0380590409,
0.0188879091,
0.0029754748,
0.0132188527,
-0.00580166,
-0.020661911,
-0.0007333411,
0.0762636065,
0.0182315707,
-0.0060624834,
0.0068534794,
-0.0263268948,
-0.0103272181,
0.0502660908,
-0.0542252548,
0.0535176136,
-0.0527984127,
0.0045338669,
0.0171205085,
0.002672133,
0.0213486012,
0.0461591482,
-0.0715518892,
0.0659485236,
-0.0115328254,
-0.0119221704,
-0.0114667127,
-0.0379513726,
-0.026728427,
-0.0183261503,
0.022896057,
0.0492839552,
-0.0030896554,
0.0672904849,
-0.004219817,
0.0321593471,
0.016191436,
-0.0714022741,
-0.0313319899,
0.0449498519,
-0.0073009417,
0.0570132993,
-0.0023767841,
-0.0275026616,
-0.0259726122,
0.068929866,
-0.0317464732,
-0.0538722724,
-0.1243240982,
-0.0284495521,
-0.04834738,
0.0703362077,
-0.0119758332,
-0.0159243159,
-0.0187617391,
0.0440434292,
-0.0183497164,
-0.0182393119,
0.0046178121,
0.0056866244,
-0.0567179397,
-0.0278351009,
-0.068714425,
0.0169510935,
-0.028929349,
-0.0047544404,
-0.024957018,
-0.0679816902,
0.0109989066,
0.0177350789,
0.0061238562,
-0.0094253151,
-0.0367370918,
0.0572764203,
0.0415779948,
0.0049262983,
-0.0376871862,
-0.0778694227,
-0.0157497488,
-0.0292412881,
0.0267647468,
-0.070625931,
-0.0260721613,
-0.0077532865,
-0.0127007384,
-0.0483858846,
-0.012203224,
0.0423112735,
-0.0458967723,
0.0454316586,
-0.0729071498,
-0.020688694,
0.0220709555,
0.0333348252,
0.0111064138,
0.0362304449,
0.0308160018,
0.0027209269,
0.0402951799,
0.0364769176,
-0.0204712264,
-0.0102596665,
-0.0085566966,
-0.0382949412,
-0.0416880585,
0.0169992074,
-0.0052308701,
0.0128954919,
-0.0255913474,
0.0609490462,
-0.0278838445,
0.0240863785,
0.000862302,
-0.0152126225,
0.0062176241,
-0.0093548344,
0.0494935475,
0.0346847326,
0.0033533757,
0.0110903792,
-0.0176934768,
0.0282962527,
-0.0216823258,
0.0079472903,
-0.03275536,
0.0037118595,
-0.0110123558,
-0.0638591051,
-0.0086873798,
-0.0081706988,
0.0191435814,
0.0027500736,
0.0685168877,
0.0435404927,
0.0162261054,
0.0257904064,
0.0302008968,
-0.0024382106,
0.0041117771,
-0.0631828606,
-0.0033497205,
0.0634010583,
0.0434716344,
-0.0277482793,
-0.0459127761,
-0.0088841394,
-0.0117982188,
0.0831841752,
0.0053427233,
-0.0222163741,
-0.0184104908,
-0.0682765096,
-0.018557189,
-0.0061454112,
0.0004671506,
-0.0096383682,
-0.0189425759,
-0.0142021207,
0.0464718565,
-0.0335222892,
-0.0059948047,
0.0400413573,
0.0094597312,
0.0078545865,
-0.010849949,
0.0018629672,
0.0418731943,
0.0286039487,
0.0059438548,
0.0116403326,
0.0116902366,
-0.0283570588,
-0.0185124185,
0.0314950682,
-0.0365853496,
-0.0247735735,
0.0509040691,
-0.066195406,
-0.0134325009,
-0.0292221718,
-0.0594213046,
-0.037170399,
0.0110052526,
-0.0382141694,
0.0638519078,
-0.0934783593,
-0.0477082282,
0.0054647624,
-0.011773319,
-0.0402549617,
0.0919321775,
0.0262074657,
-0.0369468108,
0.0032992968,
-0.0136188352,
0.0494302921,
-0.0161740799,
0.0151187545,
0.0678678751,
-0.0013851064,
-0.0038521143,
0.0422402211,
0.0505166054,
-0.0769668743,
0.0211140774,
-0.0468822494,
0.0052733277,
0.010390847,
0.016349148,
0.0405120365,
0.0078882575,
0.0164522957,
-0.0347920358,
0.0144370133,
0.016411284,
-0.0271491986,
0.0013319905,
0.0515043028,
0.0394600891,
-0.0534361862,
0.0431311317,
-0.0078512589,
-0.0183506068,
-0.0136451405,
0.0194839668,
-0.0428894982,
-0.0177580286,
0.0011394918,
-0.0757566318,
0.0053008953,
-0.0037610768,
0.0019609651,
-0.0105574513,
-0.0123865027,
0.0039758594,
0.0164453462,
-0.0161093511,
0.0273000486,
0.0355296209,
-0.0121025573,
-0.0113219786,
-0.0107896486,
-0.0140335271,
0.0081175407,
-0.0332912356,
-0.0418069847,
-0.0062581887,
-0.0300504975,
0.0185480751,
0.0102470331,
-0.0576824769,
0.0310949236,
-0.0213946272,
-0.0000612625,
-0.0078560757,
0.0010281532,
-0.004808981,
0.0376711525,
-0.0010268288,
-0.0015173213,
0.0944741741,
0.0330093913,
0.0091750231,
-0.0814765766,
-0.0217160881,
-0.0625988469,
0.0503046587,
-0.031009391,
0.0413611867,
0.0289494209,
-0.0342758074,
-0.0479096547,
-0.0772761479,
0.0625546724,
0.0162549112,
0.0468250662,
-0.0539334193,
0.0300692506,
0.0247043371,
-0.0052717854,
-0.026745718,
-0.0364494063,
-0.0597083233,
0.0235075001,
-0.0635031089,
0.0258802362,
-0.0033191657,
-0.0071930257,
-0.0122103225,
0.0064505786,
0.0050497986,
-0.0095251203,
-0.04489002,
0.0129471105,
0.0231149886,
0.0072745811,
-0.0134995347,
0.0064090532,
0.0314155854,
0.0430058762,
-0.0322138593,
-0.0333623923,
-0.0081911404,
-0.013307008,
-0.0140872467,
-0.0403733999,
-0.031101685,
0.026928626,
-0.0097747818,
-0.0841870084,
-0.006279516,
0.1035368517,
0.0423778966,
0.0231244359,
-0.0130671887,
-0.0274276342,
0.0552186966,
0.0008119316,
0.0290241484,
-0.0490163639,
-0.0567711368,
0.0134667782,
-0.0130122881,
-0.0154828355,
-0.0077595292,
-0.0111797675,
-0.0707760006,
0.0090491716,
-0.02201006,
-0.0407729968,
0.0000131091,
-0.0109193213,
0.0043256129,
-0.008948328,
-0.0122621832,
0.001843901,
-0.0332431011,
0.0011627456,
0.0159457829,
-0.0048420019,
-0.0305487663,
0.0133874603,
-0.0271842759,
0.0374587066,
0.0424145572,
0.0458353236,
-0.0444768555,
-0.0256535243,
0.0983964205,
-0.0161141511,
0.0165872984,
-0.0506345592,
0.0211646724,
-0.0084836707,
0.0107259825,
-0.0463845395,
0.0244061965,
-0.0615241379,
-0.0375730172,
0.0052215266,
0.0927535892,
-0.0242165569,
-0.0122379689,
-0.0426509418,
0.0240231622,
-0.029133793,
0.0620396249,
-0.0162144396,
0.0289420765,
-0.0338107459,
-0.035642799,
-0.0599529631,
0.0223504025,
0.0217206422,
0.0251922309,
-0.0248911921,
-0.0646490231,
-0.0459949039,
-0.0532694533,
0.0153593402,
0.0228202436,
0.0206027552,
0.0435106009,
0.0327472277,
0.0238285884,
-0.0368604027,
-0.0127746491,
-0.061430335,
-0.01303476,
0.0259277802,
0.0370856524,
0.0458999909,
-0.0474653095,
-0.0437740237,
0.0003015433,
-0.004928838,
-0.0469849631,
0.0326966345,
0.0094485972,
0.0331147686,
0.0578179024,
-0.0420108028,
-0.043068178,
0.0264733955,
0.0351399183,
-0.049300164,
-0.0025931878,
0.0495464318,
-0.0010852315,
0.0155308042,
0.0541794188,
-0.0116274944,
0.0181740671,
-0.0245905351,
0.040746443,
-0.0161388814,
0.0143626854,
0.0696631968,
0.0281413719,
-0.0123726763,
0.0197886247,
-0.0818982497,
-0.0378546342,
0.0191736557,
-0.0177543759,
-0.0353672914,
-0.0257439725,
0.0612770505,
-0.0234598462,
-0.0033988357,
-0.0078167645,
0.0069121486,
-0.0532597564,
0.0133052813,
0.0921692401,
0.0067541976,
0.0294650923,
0.0187748689,
-0.0279755723,
-0.0164098535,
0.0033926861,
0.0233095512,
-0.0299316719,
0.0166848432,
-0.0381842293,
0.0574849136,
0.0810925886,
-0.0192349721,
-0.0391729772,
-0.0152739817,
-0.0634610802,
-0.0566494912,
0.0496055819,
0.0709278136,
0.0050626788,
0.0227802508,
0.0123502789,
-0.045921728,
0.0007643407,
0.0257657804,
0.0433970094,
0.003964501,
-0.0311602689,
0.0316192992,
0.0143569475,
-0.0204091799,
-0.0432553217,
0.0303258915,
-0.0149041424,
0.004365027,
0.0314023718,
-0.0217594262,
-0.0449088737,
-0.0224581771,
0.007246308,
0.0611164756,
-0.0045088222,
0.0379168987,
-0.0690433383,
-0.0550557561,
-0.0292471033,
0.0505922884,
0.011124108,
-0.0132859303,
0.0601045378,
0.075498268,
0.0399495773,
-0.048042886,
-0.0173014943,
0.009380932,
-0.040124651,
-0.009555947,
0.0197640769,
-6.233540748e-33,
-0.0350963175,
-0.047028102,
0.0541944578,
0.0245860871,
-0.0403947905,
-0.0652407259,
-0.0351024605,
-0.0456421226,
-0.0188636575,
0.0548589639,
0.0088794287,
0.061391782,
0.0372287072,
0.0175194405,
-0.0154799698,
-0.0226013996,
0.0177554917,
0.022652233,
0.0299851168,
-0.0027233954,
0.0442262255,
0.0310473889,
0.0473397002,
-0.0601419695,
0.0614380278,
0.0157281328,
-0.0282206163,
0.0647297204,
0.0061323582,
0.0248348247,
0.0215465985,
0.0397203229,
0.0507505871,
0.01145963,
0.010468252,
-0.0013995771,
-0.0748241916,
-0.0667768642,
0.0597825274,
0.0079923682,
-0.0184923802,
-0.0385714248,
0.0491651855,
-0.0329614878,
0.0338138938,
0.0209228564,
0.0746384487,
-0.0241457876,
-0.0201799534,
0.0281312354,
-0.0833261386,
0.0571056157,
-0.0046180715,
-0.0000215638,
0.0052665006,
-0.0179471038,
-0.026455095,
-0.0040957341,
-0.0212203376,
0.001325913,
-0.031560868,
-0.0001056291,
0.0373716131,
0.0451766141,
0.009055905,
0.0185496248,
0.004319001,
0.0080927657,
0.0069417316,
-0.0101187415,
0.0236933958,
0.0698364526,
-0.0230511762,
0.0200011078,
0.0804304779,
0.0269300155,
-0.1021475419,
0.0033943879,
-0.0167199336,
0.0761118531,
-0.0008843411,
0.0013681403,
-0.0624375343,
-0.0007271015,
-0.0284526162,
0.020334797,
-0.0217305887,
-0.0528191812,
0.0100117903,
-0.0442127213,
-0.0112632737,
0.0150397047,
-0.0175178442,
-0.0647965968,
0.0089980401,
-0.0033135561,
-0.0166611336,
-0.0112773413,
-0.013849319,
0.0634504855,
-0.0170642138,
-0.0455843918,
-0.025957372,
0.0228377488,
-0.0084599257,
-0.0029848327,
0.044671271,
0.0164527316,
0.0073339315,
-0.0144188842,
-0.04744488,
-0.0498898998,
-0.0652452186,
0.0275616311,
0.0225448646,
0.0750996545,
-0.0284726899,
0.0213495828,
0.0308847148,
-0.0043775854,
-0.0345029123,
0.0167812053,
0.0292679612,
0.0047809682,
-0.0168000031,
-0.0160162281,
-0.0099402973,
-0.0080029014,
0.0435929932,
-0.0472725965,
0.0074336743,
0.029627271,
2.885e-7,
0.0319837108,
0.0458075553,
0.0049396809,
0.031012943,
-0.0028308365,
0.0200952683,
-0.0069649317,
-0.0047115986,
-0.0141385179,
-0.0366109498,
0.0516835302,
0.0691432953,
-0.0159751829,
0.0102498196,
-0.0720900819,
0.0168946367,
0.012471688,
-0.0478004403,
-0.0273161586,
0.0094988858,
0.0796328634,
0.0742838979,
0.0515692644,
-0.0313824452,
-0.0031438542,
-0.0394280702,
0.0338482708,
-0.00692788,
0.0115141021,
0.0270875115,
0.0152548207,
0.0230155401,
0.0101284441,
0.0309940539,
0.0560488626,
0.0073572956,
0.0198314618,
0.0575947948,
-0.0296671689,
0.0196270589,
-0.0283116624,
-0.0467394181,
0.0261661019,
-0.0264803469,
0.0599262081,
-0.024469411,
-0.0616308264,
0.0423849635,
-0.0250187553,
-0.0067551136,
-0.0152468719,
-0.0005672654,
-0.0393907353,
-0.0190947019,
0.0037916766,
-0.0445743389,
-0.0238503478,
-0.0643706322,
0.0121131474,
-0.0122125037,
-0.0180534702,
-0.0184852295,
0.0039084796,
0.006251384,
0.0694204345,
-0.0578776896,
-0.0058237133,
2.542059109e-34,
0.0427421667,
0.0018735356,
0.0029213354,
-0.0108711449,
0.0305236708,
0.0341075324,
0.0119162239,
0.0295134597,
0.0194748938,
-0.0675852299,
-0.0194862466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10642v1 | Word Sense Induction with Knowledge Distillation from BERT | 2023-04-20T21:05:35 | 2023-04-20T21:05:35 | Anik Saha, Alex Gittens, Bulent Yener | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained contextual language models are ubiquitously employed for language
understanding tasks, but are unsuitable for resource-constrained systems.
Noncontextual word embeddings are an efficient alternative in these settings.
Such methods typically use one vector to encode multiple different meanings of
a word, and incur errors due to polysemy. This paper proposes a two-stage
method to distill multiple word senses from a pre-trained language model (BERT)
by using attention over the senses of a word in a context and transferring this
sense information to fit multi-sense embeddings in a skip-gram-like framework.
We demonstrate an effective approach to training the sense disambiguation
mechanism in our model with a distribution over word senses extracted from the
output layer embeddings of BERT. Experiments on the contextual word similarity
and sense induction tasks show that this method is superior to or competitive
with state-of-the-art multi-sense embeddings on multiple benchmark data sets,
and experiments with an embedding-based topic model (ETM) demonstrates the
benefits of using this multi-sense embedding in a downstream application. | [
-0.0199211929,
-0.0191743113,
0.01686549,
0.0590237044,
0.0018564228,
0.0213431045,
-0.0370115303,
-0.0280328058,
-0.0060823923,
-0.049542889,
-0.0175599977,
0.0202091876,
-0.0082946969,
0.023805853,
0.0236494802,
-0.0030615071,
0.0914969519,
0.0174469259,
-0.0220607556,
0.0093832249,
0.0020004774,
0.0173323844,
0.0076896409,
0.0128645953,
-0.0372161269,
-0.0133769121,
-0.0006764095,
0.0125593869,
0.0165362936,
-0.010869937,
0.0041490379,
0.0377538726,
0.0946279839,
0.0183240045,
0.0000018959,
-0.0467752814,
-0.0368277803,
-0.0105370861,
0.0171612166,
-0.0214619394,
0.0349138305,
-0.0469081551,
0.0535365827,
0.0010573347,
-0.0298277661,
0.0132415369,
0.0129550332,
-0.0042050574,
0.0738019273,
0.0169338528,
-0.0190179609,
-0.0440319441,
-0.0025697553,
-0.0056393975,
0.0151885226,
-0.0095852604,
0.0078597544,
-0.0124974297,
-0.0254268125,
-0.0180347804,
-0.072315529,
0.0309756603,
0.0078108194,
0.025715284,
0.0335606784,
0.0277860053,
-0.0129194548,
-0.0180444196,
-0.018807631,
0.0817553103,
-0.0313152224,
-0.0131413443,
-0.0002667775,
0.0005478868,
-0.0416927636,
0.002840919,
-0.0084409704,
-0.0108144628,
0.0110072503,
0.0354233533,
0.0159183424,
0.0104563553,
0.0506451651,
0.0183480904,
-0.0199748427,
0.0488270484,
0.0382399745,
-0.0535717048,
0.0014927357,
-0.0050569298,
-0.013027464,
0.0179902799,
0.043327041,
0.0073787393,
0.0129880654,
0.0653936043,
-0.0413154364,
-0.0396557525,
0.0201205518,
-0.0790770203,
-0.0207842272,
0.0418220051,
-0.0095045324,
0.071802333,
-0.0445107296,
-0.0322322436,
-0.0003471567,
0.0371723548,
-0.0774743631,
-0.0357849784,
-0.0505250394,
0.0248007867,
-0.0579346083,
0.0447325781,
-0.0209876876,
-0.0447194092,
-0.0260450877,
0.0286412556,
0.0037738068,
-0.0244668778,
0.0274755284,
-0.0095405681,
-0.0660923868,
-0.0088363001,
-0.0004866495,
0.0349772982,
-0.0460379384,
0.0117845591,
-0.0557710044,
-0.0096580703,
-0.0189214535,
0.007710116,
0.0195787121,
-0.0211014263,
-0.0080635883,
-0.0072270189,
-0.0204553772,
-0.0699571893,
-0.0569149479,
-0.0073263245,
-0.0257079229,
0.0134061566,
-0.026487859,
-0.0672667027,
0.0370380096,
-0.0054159071,
-0.001257455,
-0.0458068512,
0.0006305335,
0.0007141865,
-0.0555742979,
0.0950304195,
-0.0540025793,
-0.0065973038,
0.0362357087,
0.0395857766,
0.0502895117,
0.0937700793,
0.0377914496,
-0.0107963374,
0.056641005,
0.0338785425,
-0.0719832182,
0.0043489607,
0.0055028345,
0.0111891059,
-0.0282893088,
-0.0076190154,
-0.0434383191,
0.0500012673,
0.0391135812,
0.0549450368,
-0.0583457388,
0.0083396286,
-0.0005944159,
0.0702698827,
0.0284776315,
-0.0423938073,
0.0571305305,
0.0137011465,
-0.0439129584,
-0.0354404338,
-0.0109285507,
-0.0264796261,
-0.0134186242,
-0.0066805622,
0.0482234322,
0.0174876228,
-0.0357982554,
-0.0070754997,
0.0058069681,
-0.0479134619,
0.0510810241,
0.0146876685,
0.0602673367,
0.028280085,
-0.0304861348,
0.0509889536,
0.059434779,
-0.0374908485,
0.0418821648,
-0.0194840115,
0.0172587484,
0.0725374371,
0.0440906808,
-0.0365187787,
-0.0341677777,
-0.0012400799,
0.0194114894,
0.0458431505,
0.0220044926,
-0.0334805436,
0.0225795098,
-0.054007411,
-0.0219592582,
-0.0118896058,
0.0114631215,
0.0117375776,
0.0006668778,
0.0307034124,
0.0255666692,
-0.1031238511,
0.0463260971,
0.0414007008,
-0.0297648385,
-0.0186987165,
-0.0412446149,
0.026982734,
0.0032759053,
0.0365922265,
-0.0098286923,
0.0115197627,
0.0211468972,
-0.0646738261,
0.009800218,
-0.0059617292,
-0.0344394185,
-0.0734094456,
0.0199983902,
-0.0311594699,
-0.0141958278,
0.0044679269,
-0.0283402223,
-0.0212065708,
-0.0002991357,
-0.012627814,
0.0989814252,
-0.0823544338,
-0.0163404178,
-0.0230525136,
-0.0010930694,
-0.0248048436,
0.0419006087,
-0.0352376141,
0.0093553541,
-0.0294560958,
0.0587919876,
0.0154535817,
0.0287823696,
-0.0618906729,
0.013475772,
0.0214607529,
0.0042192247,
0.0137035195,
0.007820229,
-0.0645329952,
-0.007754148,
-0.0990034938,
0.003490211,
-0.0171499196,
0.0051800851,
0.018823361,
0.0420164205,
-0.0001904154,
-0.0337220281,
0.0059517254,
0.0173000749,
-0.0295824017,
0.0344409421,
0.0299674571,
-0.0269881934,
-0.005372338,
-0.0188403931,
-0.0200063922,
-0.0340910628,
0.0757258683,
-0.0042899805,
-0.0030268261,
-0.0167401507,
-0.0230535027,
-0.0546908081,
-0.0031921272,
0.0137604587,
-0.0182114821,
0.0045815059,
-0.0222191084,
0.0698085427,
0.0144581208,
0.0221414659,
0.0583178774,
0.067356348,
-0.022734765,
-0.0364450552,
0.0110869771,
-0.0249813218,
0.0341790654,
-0.0034844123,
-0.0056411223,
0.0018156308,
0.049724739,
0.0123259565,
-0.0096510416,
-0.0276379827,
0.0080978815,
-0.0249844342,
-0.035930682,
-0.0324868821,
0.0093813017,
-0.0239222404,
0.0013644085,
-0.0333303362,
-0.0473040193,
0.0638440102,
-0.0167636462,
0.0024081136,
-0.0810606778,
0.0058484208,
0.0122221811,
0.0645809844,
-0.0316674784,
0.0539388768,
-0.0335984565,
0.0024390039,
-0.0338450707,
-0.0138022797,
0.0300543401,
-0.0401140153,
0.0458068401,
-0.0306367893,
0.0182184856,
0.0227238052,
0.0352571793,
-0.0401404202,
-0.0596011914,
-0.0257749911,
0.0308236126,
0.0412467569,
0.0092116017,
0.0071954126,
0.0035550438,
0.017905144,
0.0323328637,
0.066360645,
-0.0239172354,
-0.0198187679,
0.0227532517,
0.0372045301,
-0.0248087924,
-0.0131809544,
-0.0244025718,
0.0198119786,
0.0063493703,
0.0060797748,
-0.068340309,
-0.0420479253,
0.021978939,
0.0164467338,
-0.0582756512,
-0.0076792375,
-0.0154552814,
0.0274125561,
-0.0270638354,
-0.0175264813,
0.1213163063,
0.0513292179,
-0.0458059087,
-0.002582459,
-0.0067610117,
0.0079314522,
0.0058120601,
-0.0068238466,
-0.0541655123,
-0.0524510704,
-0.0171429012,
0.019106552,
0.0856279358,
-0.0401826538,
-0.0179348998,
-0.0501589701,
-0.0076682526,
-0.0167894289,
-0.0264985804,
-0.0620677397,
-0.0418453775,
0.006181688,
0.0181459542,
0.0004605426,
-0.0206032507,
0.0192043278,
0.005797172,
-0.0111796418,
0.0085818972,
-0.0368440561,
0.0364027247,
-0.0510406867,
0.0397455357,
0.0628081784,
0.0476120524,
0.020451488,
-0.0445330478,
-0.0448171943,
-0.0856855437,
-0.0450752079,
-0.0125302915,
-0.0148538109,
-0.065987356,
0.01569397,
0.0179469511,
-0.0134286461,
-0.0606733933,
-0.035418734,
-0.0149478437,
0.0679632276,
-0.0089217462,
-0.0337740667,
-0.0246949475,
-0.0263425596,
0.0169071071,
0.09210255,
0.0169216413,
-0.0460791066,
-0.0039756377,
0.0112057682,
0.0083816824,
-0.0032081457,
0.0116181467,
-0.0406112038,
-0.0657784492,
0.0047400482,
-0.0595883988,
-0.0558761545,
0.0273900516,
0.042404104,
-0.0044381237,
0.016403079,
0.0471629202,
0.0088323317,
-0.0678096786,
0.0188752562,
-0.0067735412,
0.0149644809,
-0.0072856839,
-0.0140335541,
0.0361282676,
0.0059050969,
-0.0402090661,
0.0116340062,
-0.0458613709,
-0.0007261691,
0.0095437812,
0.0147624901,
0.0043192282,
0.0288904067,
-0.0642910302,
-0.011104336,
0.0535267331,
-0.0028906614,
-0.0139498543,
0.0125943897,
0.0176872443,
0.0455359183,
0.0222658534,
0.0540027879,
-0.0555499084,
0.0393493026,
-0.01321977,
0.069543682,
-0.0279496796,
-0.0286177676,
-0.0038402101,
-0.0230717547,
0.0777015537,
-0.0229499638,
0.0054650889,
-0.064055115,
-0.0382634737,
-0.0027996874,
-0.004909134,
-0.0358168893,
0.0314927399,
0.014195093,
-0.0345176682,
-0.0172706302,
0.0634086952,
-0.0179149956,
0.0002377056,
0.0072894343,
0.0283090845,
0.026399143,
0.0086017745,
-0.0175732393,
-0.0094078062,
-0.0160901379,
-0.0210647378,
-0.0456877351,
-0.0306922961,
-0.0535566844,
0.0256967898,
-0.0004533422,
-0.015543892,
-0.0252219941,
0.0311941709,
-0.0400581025,
0.029363649,
-0.0142568238,
0.0507222973,
0.0478586741,
-0.0127702616,
0.0433442742,
0.0032512289,
-0.0094357217,
-0.0066538686,
0.023345463,
0.0124910306,
0.0030037386,
0.0188846514,
0.020041313,
-0.0170621295,
-0.0041028145,
0.0723143518,
-0.0313766226,
0.0423733555,
0.0146582741,
-0.008043021,
-0.0440398604,
-0.0009590799,
0.0236712527,
0.0935336798,
-0.0400977209,
0.0416764505,
-0.0520137846,
-0.0505988486,
0.0308791511,
-0.00276548,
-0.0475215465,
0.0517177209,
0.0640764385,
0.0627550557,
-0.0042530219,
0.0078428285,
-0.0169938859,
0.0072698002,
-0.0088252872,
-0.0607812405,
0.007980031,
-6.012262018e-33,
-0.0104047284,
0.0026105049,
-0.0076248874,
-0.0426382273,
-0.0211924221,
0.02768098,
-0.0316602588,
-0.0289394911,
-0.0385331213,
0.028133288,
0.0148450546,
0.0417889468,
-0.0004956169,
0.0110145798,
-0.0240032021,
-0.0011070893,
0.0598449521,
-0.0023836438,
0.0073393956,
0.0244790148,
0.0335955471,
0.0698379353,
0.0632823035,
-0.0198978297,
0.0298541486,
-0.0268598571,
0.0126369763,
0.0357508659,
0.091722168,
0.0243213177,
-0.0324345641,
0.0542296283,
0.0136519158,
0.0207928307,
-0.0283481814,
0.0346403159,
-0.0859692097,
-0.066286467,
0.0353050865,
-0.0382863842,
-0.0611244477,
0.0091047911,
0.0313985236,
-0.0054298081,
0.040774826,
0.0328284502,
0.046967078,
-0.0077931941,
-0.0660777539,
-0.0450660028,
-0.0660624728,
0.0310557745,
-0.0083216876,
-0.040433459,
0.0206976235,
-0.0477745049,
0.0201705378,
0.0158208217,
-0.0663161874,
0.0261756126,
-0.0285525434,
-0.0067205518,
0.048417598,
0.0130980406,
-0.016876705,
0.058089938,
-0.0063396827,
-0.0476640016,
0.0050586057,
-0.0325593613,
0.0575851649,
0.0281212088,
-0.0148061933,
0.0648750141,
0.0413097739,
-0.0098329801,
-0.0323914513,
0.0160710867,
0.0301033091,
0.0225513279,
0.0309119895,
0.0084131807,
-0.0167829264,
-0.0198003538,
-0.0622399598,
0.0136698605,
-0.0333362594,
-0.0259518307,
0.0349131525,
0.0120564476,
-0.0071432088,
0.04330552,
0.0355292335,
-0.0269821342,
0.0314066,
0.0491221771,
0.0387446098,
-0.0183683224,
0.0185016952,
0.0546174087,
0.0009214251,
-0.0343620218,
0.0203068648,
0.0008861168,
-0.0274616033,
-0.0051311748,
0.0146077508,
0.0025858579,
-0.0064826244,
-0.0008301425,
-0.000847996,
-0.0801735297,
-0.0484881401,
-0.0105653787,
0.0194811597,
0.0130938897,
-0.0108773047,
0.0234656725,
0.0359000564,
0.0182750057,
-0.0138186654,
-0.0437897183,
-0.0004248212,
0.0677368417,
-0.0248459205,
0.0070035416,
-0.0139676584,
0.0300346594,
0.0387486704,
-0.074359037,
0.0045208465,
0.0064058308,
2.642e-7,
0.0834528878,
0.0384758934,
-0.0371330045,
-0.032666903,
-0.0003117019,
-0.0187870339,
0.012260749,
0.0586178489,
-0.0726971701,
-0.0431137718,
0.00562206,
0.0518505871,
-0.0034477699,
0.030167846,
-0.0327207893,
0.0115799448,
0.0011925267,
0.0465852879,
-0.0352484509,
-0.0185050517,
0.0655459389,
0.0882278383,
0.0186650846,
0.0003051856,
-0.0270417072,
-0.0386264659,
0.0564426519,
-0.0314854831,
0.0097297924,
-0.0003908185,
0.0213786699,
0.0337084122,
0.02732924,
0.0090658283,
-0.0554625317,
0.0186639987,
0.0578357577,
0.0608895123,
-0.0234296527,
-0.0171124395,
-0.0236545932,
-0.0311313812,
0.0094090328,
-0.0334017798,
0.0494059436,
-0.064305149,
0.0159125328,
-0.0006103797,
-0.0278682094,
0.0406131595,
0.0317797735,
-0.0094342642,
-0.0726897568,
0.0010744005,
0.029843498,
-0.0125820646,
-0.0294094961,
-0.0928108096,
0.0057509076,
0.0458962917,
-0.0391989909,
-0.0375258848,
0.0017054923,
-0.0611558482,
0.0859360844,
-0.0544150211,
0.0122832665,
2.266682568e-34,
0.0463301726,
0.0089593502,
0.0081892777,
-0.0049269907,
0.0241608173,
-0.0248275679,
0.008579703,
-0.0218334682,
0.0439219885,
-0.0531399027,
0.0109399213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10637v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10637v3 | IXA/Cogcomp at SemEval-2023 Task 2: Context-enriched Multilingual Named Entity Recognition using Knowledge Bases | 2023-04-20T20:30:34 | 2023-04-27T20:51:36 | Iker García-Ferrero, Jon Ander Campos, Oscar Sainz, Ander Salaberria, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a core natural language processing task in
which pre-trained language models have shown remarkable performance. However,
standard benchmarks like CoNLL 2003 do not address many of the challenges that
deployed NER systems face, such as having to classify emerging or complex
entities in a fine-grained way. In this paper we present a novel NER cascade
approach comprising three steps: first, identifying candidate entities in the
input sentence; second, linking the each candidate to an existing knowledge
base; third, predicting the fine-grained category for each entity candidate. We
empirically demonstrate the significance of external knowledge bases in
accurately classifying fine-grained and emerging entities. Our system exhibits
robust performance in the MultiCoNER2 shared task, even in the low-resource
language setting where we leverage knowledge bases of high-resource languages. | [
0.0340503752,
0.0109431008,
0.0170391928,
0.0388431028,
-0.0050764545,
0.0420025736,
-0.0076365783,
-0.0165502019,
0.0296707768,
-0.0691779107,
-0.0212005712,
0.0032228725,
-0.0130444318,
0.0075211255,
0.0179168414,
-0.0146372924,
0.0399856307,
-0.0176287517,
0.0221708603,
0.0230087638,
-0.0080206627,
0.0333565474,
-0.0162309483,
0.0002908755,
0.0015860416,
0.0062698955,
0.0025051702,
-0.009338486,
0.0480740294,
-0.0596525744,
0.0436443612,
0.050614357,
0.0031495192,
0.0211706609,
0.0000018274,
-0.082770884,
-0.0444733761,
0.0114681143,
-0.0295966547,
-0.0375358313,
-0.0185263474,
-0.0362747088,
-0.0062218723,
-0.0070792101,
-0.0044983872,
-0.0383917131,
0.0173863191,
0.0686978176,
0.0162314661,
0.0706851035,
-0.0179246124,
-0.0532058366,
0.0174226277,
-0.0072496608,
-0.0242336579,
-0.0579972528,
0.0296972003,
-0.0216126032,
-0.0030823189,
0.0170283131,
0.0080361012,
0.0061584888,
-0.0042549283,
0.0219573472,
0.0099945078,
0.0419566073,
0.0099572735,
-0.0023014061,
-0.0185924023,
0.095487386,
-0.0464657508,
0.0081506316,
0.0259867907,
-0.0346479304,
-0.0282593202,
-0.0633672774,
0.0012677845,
-0.0031546389,
-0.0529008433,
-0.0041280165,
0.0649404749,
0.0135592595,
0.029828243,
0.0206462648,
-0.0175352991,
0.0374329463,
0.0150817521,
-0.0333323218,
0.0432118438,
0.0448354445,
0.0082811257,
-0.0398286059,
0.0368899554,
0.0254575796,
-0.0106034838,
0.0440837294,
-0.0243938472,
0.0226738025,
0.015513164,
-0.0376795344,
-0.0271793827,
-0.0020088055,
-0.0101420349,
0.0748941377,
-0.0656878352,
-0.0237858221,
-0.0226348042,
-0.0204993598,
0.0361546166,
-0.0437945612,
-0.0435532592,
0.0201947093,
-0.0276648086,
0.0511796698,
-0.0351788588,
-0.0221088789,
-0.0352368727,
0.0010867403,
-0.005389804,
0.0175004397,
0.0269350857,
-0.0009598848,
0.0298420396,
-0.0217295811,
-0.0307114236,
0.0397958234,
-0.0473251194,
0.001739054,
-0.0269844662,
-0.0585140921,
0.0024812073,
-0.0217421521,
0.0516059883,
-0.0543933623,
0.0239201132,
0.0427342802,
0.0257646386,
-0.1026922539,
-0.0714213252,
-0.0195405185,
-0.0086871414,
-0.0576351881,
-0.0208384953,
-0.0451409593,
0.0472159907,
0.0106450533,
0.0243106056,
-0.0307645332,
0.0138109857,
-0.0122053502,
-0.0540619381,
0.0832730159,
-0.0693458021,
-0.0309514906,
-0.009355492,
0.0113052027,
0.0496309772,
0.0535483919,
0.0176333077,
-0.0067065181,
0.0374681503,
-0.010530713,
-0.0307420623,
0.0367997885,
0.0038377494,
-0.0226175711,
0.038337823,
0.0221527163,
-0.0283750333,
0.0181635097,
0.0346027352,
0.0076541072,
0.0075888312,
0.0150419828,
0.0281247236,
0.0222887192,
0.0150098363,
0.0086649572,
0.0547010265,
-0.0044813999,
-0.0160307512,
-0.0082897581,
-0.0450439155,
-0.0037130036,
-0.0509031676,
0.0180013422,
0.0180186015,
0.0781257525,
-0.0064449804,
0.0009143229,
0.0234807041,
-0.0284990799,
-0.0062140916,
0.0090765953,
0.0716365203,
0.0292574447,
-0.0635021105,
0.0483873077,
0.0681537017,
-0.022869397,
0.0262501519,
-0.0060317935,
0.0123481257,
0.0690009221,
0.0078524174,
-0.0467086844,
-0.0518345423,
-0.0231517479,
-0.0273402408,
0.0378141217,
0.0171275754,
-0.0210496802,
0.0501303226,
-0.0149071738,
-0.0104817376,
0.0138853015,
0.0137684345,
0.0185839981,
0.0173765309,
0.0748437941,
0.0174230095,
0.0179391149,
-0.0043253293,
0.0395801105,
-0.029451862,
-0.010579559,
0.0084229289,
0.0423379205,
-0.0002485857,
0.057647936,
0.0116188936,
-0.0230512507,
0.0337694362,
-0.0500267297,
-0.0204639565,
-0.0249684304,
0.0012222531,
-0.0671785772,
0.0056437696,
0.0089331456,
-0.020863371,
-0.0537195653,
-0.0264199562,
-0.0473155603,
-0.0175112803,
0.0441484153,
0.0463577658,
-0.0150714889,
0.0205782168,
0.0205562562,
0.0403796844,
-0.010580983,
0.0834985673,
-0.0109758712,
0.0339417905,
0.0058514532,
-0.0289514754,
-0.0036611918,
0.0022007239,
-0.0429902375,
0.0072444812,
0.0082458435,
-0.0241739731,
0.02469646,
-0.0028521097,
-0.0643615127,
0.0035643415,
-0.0754083097,
0.0108130798,
-0.0133946147,
0.0483987369,
0.0018653935,
0.0412435234,
-0.0284297056,
-0.0121490071,
0.0028821225,
0.0197804887,
-0.0148967095,
0.0095282616,
0.0271058287,
0.0296445061,
-0.0094679324,
-0.0002381938,
0.0230737813,
-0.0283969659,
0.0431819707,
0.0228015669,
-0.0442631282,
-0.0576195493,
0.0333232097,
-0.0130263371,
0.0109272478,
0.0014468305,
0.0314680599,
-0.0168860089,
0.0203930214,
-0.0051340442,
0.0229840633,
-0.0213797744,
0.030130202,
-0.0305303074,
-0.0386709794,
-0.0287003201,
0.0348577946,
-0.0249314662,
0.0370206945,
-0.0528805293,
-0.0088678356,
0.0198116098,
0.0840744078,
-0.0352583565,
-0.0032133004,
-0.0459348708,
0.0140206451,
0.0143325478,
-0.0151361618,
-0.015235615,
0.0191135183,
0.0024897708,
0.0243004654,
-0.0245722029,
-0.0049230577,
0.0543849543,
-0.0511320792,
-0.0046312856,
-0.0030517634,
-0.0025657585,
-0.0541347601,
0.0500859022,
0.0154172713,
0.0087008597,
0.0411824845,
-0.0462147482,
-0.0031904818,
0.053628359,
-0.0024291445,
-0.0047672004,
0.0321017578,
0.0123602776,
0.0151855499,
0.0097295698,
-0.0253834482,
-0.0165635515,
0.0058071301,
-0.0630040467,
0.0240095295,
0.0141312312,
-0.0085739251,
0.011279244,
0.0333805345,
-0.0091183977,
0.0357500054,
0.0143138468,
-0.0111337677,
-0.0200249515,
0.0509834513,
0.0332845077,
0.0171961579,
0.0468708239,
0.0054776585,
0.0098632695,
0.0047700685,
-0.0224970169,
-0.0235863831,
0.0044734031,
-0.0116755283,
0.0236970894,
-0.0803701133,
0.0001777684,
-0.0291953217,
0.0314890556,
-0.0449018292,
0.0095873782,
0.1063439697,
-0.0029646473,
-0.0119201476,
-0.0052969404,
0.0419961326,
-0.0070637441,
0.0444746166,
0.0175786801,
-0.0732541084,
-0.0536842644,
0.0015394815,
-0.045090545,
-0.001428426,
-0.0847374126,
-0.017180983,
-0.1306015402,
0.0023256098,
-0.0506594107,
-0.0678076148,
0.0117758391,
-0.060855221,
0.0109302886,
-0.0336102955,
-0.0203484409,
-0.0586108938,
-0.0270306505,
-0.0109986188,
-0.0175435673,
-0.0096090017,
-0.0790289119,
0.0315581746,
-0.0726892278,
0.0352779701,
0.0157914869,
0.0358298421,
-0.0283692516,
0.022821039,
0.0239246171,
-0.0776246563,
-0.0013500388,
-0.018761985,
0.0146145765,
-0.0448615365,
-0.0184228364,
-0.0180726759,
-0.0333003551,
-0.0319623202,
-0.0051761651,
0.0204336382,
0.0753980428,
0.0106493281,
-0.0144056864,
0.0263625961,
-0.0271497536,
0.0446993783,
0.0727254003,
0.0003336734,
-0.0368225724,
-0.0028032595,
0.0212264881,
-0.0106097581,
-0.0044310754,
-0.0120230736,
0.0263254903,
-0.0265629329,
-0.0317096934,
-0.0524207279,
-0.0825325027,
0.0671903715,
0.033150509,
-0.0002178919,
0.0470431447,
0.0250918921,
0.0032464832,
-0.0566408038,
0.0464772582,
-0.0095982058,
0.0154952146,
-0.0450617298,
-0.0066717188,
-0.0016898427,
-0.0056195385,
-0.0650468022,
0.0017591112,
-0.0626391247,
-0.045206096,
-0.024057325,
0.0422439575,
0.0041423012,
0.0469881184,
-0.0334392861,
-0.0283178259,
0.052939713,
0.0261116233,
-0.0771154761,
-0.0226362366,
0.0024915512,
0.0062645297,
-0.0208376013,
0.0393237211,
-0.035000056,
0.0237697046,
0.0262476448,
0.0497073159,
-0.0203039069,
-0.073755607,
-0.0261190012,
-0.0038964208,
0.0458704084,
-0.0377912968,
-0.0270704012,
-0.0689170212,
0.023843037,
0.0255429372,
-0.0042692944,
-0.0132079357,
-0.0340263061,
0.0005601189,
0.007708014,
-0.0022145826,
0.0642133653,
0.0021963089,
-0.0003708901,
-0.0487796292,
0.0303728916,
0.0594475567,
0.0521078371,
0.0208785422,
-0.0186425596,
0.0133126713,
0.0568429269,
0.0298878141,
0.0399279967,
-0.0568043925,
0.0180326253,
-0.0116172992,
0.0019182931,
-0.0250233524,
0.0193150733,
-0.0039556264,
0.0069426917,
-0.0266234148,
0.0460279025,
0.0769644976,
-0.0163447373,
0.080349654,
0.0020038323,
-0.0108981356,
0.0110831419,
0.0335780419,
-0.0246292111,
-0.0359383561,
0.0282566361,
0.0147659834,
-0.0337577946,
0.014239152,
0.0543369614,
-0.0146708554,
0.0500891358,
0.0485883281,
-0.002428934,
-0.0368348584,
-0.016061604,
0.0001062971,
0.0108653922,
-0.0333363451,
0.047870297,
-0.0328470506,
-0.0553843044,
0.031611748,
-0.0517025068,
-0.0427148864,
0.0249109138,
0.0271214303,
0.0221521053,
0.0226003099,
-0.0222257357,
-0.0304704159,
-0.0332855694,
-0.0316136479,
-0.0255944841,
0.0154571803,
-6.465539252e-33,
-0.0390284695,
-0.0173968561,
0.021322906,
-0.0269733891,
0.0103922384,
0.0342932642,
-0.0130199799,
-0.0173116699,
-0.0077399383,
-0.0172991939,
-0.001542196,
-0.0158921909,
0.0253980346,
0.0065738852,
-0.0112212589,
-0.0311519746,
0.0429249667,
0.0569128953,
-0.0082816444,
0.0251125656,
0.0285166092,
0.0949683413,
0.128649652,
-0.0764809698,
0.0472306758,
0.0066698934,
-0.0036093825,
0.0121215824,
0.0608164743,
0.0578680821,
-0.049886968,
0.0305165928,
0.0321643092,
-0.0706952289,
0.0302202217,
-0.0011661364,
-0.1521075815,
0.0057011242,
-0.019649446,
0.0256393794,
-0.0091535617,
-0.0136808073,
0.0001867784,
0.0015547001,
0.0705914497,
0.0110013839,
0.0457856804,
-0.016237393,
0.0249238834,
-0.0329220816,
-0.0846176371,
0.0466011651,
0.0159031395,
0.0406372622,
0.0121003836,
0.0070228297,
0.0298830904,
0.0136617469,
-0.0568741038,
-0.0043333536,
0.0116436072,
-0.022966262,
0.0197776556,
0.0086573446,
-0.0254916605,
0.0566834658,
0.016777318,
-0.0081566414,
-0.0298387967,
-0.0042640553,
0.0275714472,
0.0318886228,
-0.02956165,
0.069637984,
0.053551916,
-0.0162406452,
-0.079838261,
0.0143274041,
0.0217453633,
0.0142424265,
-0.0202014986,
-0.0595360249,
-0.0432563052,
-0.0079375347,
-0.0257249009,
-0.018510621,
-0.0508088693,
-0.0074969023,
0.0209204741,
0.0242882464,
-0.0248468649,
0.0593832396,
0.0135766529,
-0.0051939157,
-0.0549810566,
0.0221931133,
0.0479069948,
-0.000927144,
0.0055086706,
0.0337353796,
-0.090110667,
-0.0580934435,
0.0019379697,
-0.0481251813,
0.0314607434,
-0.0009351679,
0.0544281863,
-0.02326308,
-0.0705021173,
0.006897781,
-0.018349817,
0.0299217608,
-0.0232155453,
0.0529641435,
0.0217147134,
0.0098898429,
-0.0259719696,
0.0434417054,
0.0925655812,
0.009441684,
0.0128586888,
0.0097187497,
0.0361649767,
0.0350240394,
-0.0005198689,
-0.0226179566,
0.0155621395,
-0.0197350308,
0.0056749028,
-0.0624570884,
-0.0019356511,
-0.0223015454,
2.652e-7,
0.0335763358,
0.0047175335,
-0.0108162332,
-0.019688528,
-0.0101567535,
0.0102243675,
0.0226322673,
0.0405444652,
-0.0662649572,
-0.0131589351,
-0.0083108731,
-0.0109016551,
0.0022895772,
0.0341886654,
-0.1062032804,
-0.0388202146,
-0.0015654861,
-0.0127738994,
-0.0636176765,
0.0047984398,
0.0246998388,
0.0704154298,
0.0056989649,
-0.0312392879,
-0.0382266417,
-0.0372957401,
0.045966059,
-0.0138279218,
0.0278100539,
0.029451644,
-0.0053653792,
0.0890106633,
-0.0312878191,
0.0518516861,
-0.0093165133,
0.0556216352,
-0.0160124991,
0.0467620343,
0.0044456595,
0.0175758097,
0.0162385702,
-0.0226425175,
-0.0124513172,
-0.0289816875,
0.0931175128,
-0.0548645519,
-0.001712948,
-0.0072175181,
-0.0042126719,
-0.0178951416,
0.0040250299,
0.002209676,
-0.0030376967,
0.0261038411,
0.0241765361,
-0.0327849686,
-0.0116108023,
-0.1211544797,
0.0158808064,
0.0500573181,
0.0078575816,
0.0115686301,
-0.0007649026,
-0.0588634089,
0.0399095975,
-0.0523971394,
0.0389187708,
2.325587003e-34,
-0.0189451538,
0.0153956655,
-0.022402022,
0.027409289,
0.0299506653,
-0.0203903485,
-0.0546485707,
-0.0336631462,
-0.0097320527,
-0.0370985195,
0.0089126341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10619v1 | "HOT" ChatGPT: The promise of ChatGPT in detecting and discriminating hateful, offensive, and toxic comments on social media | 2023-04-20T19:40:51 | 2023-04-20T19:40:51 | Lingyao Li, Lizhou Fan, Shubham Atreja, Libby Hemphill | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Harmful content is pervasive on social media, poisoning online communities
and negatively impacting participation. A common approach to address this issue
is to develop detection models that rely on human annotations. However, the
tasks required to build such models expose annotators to harmful and offensive
content and may require significant time and cost to complete. Generative AI
models have the potential to understand and detect harmful content. To
investigate this potential, we used ChatGPT and compared its performance with
MTurker annotations for three frequently discussed concepts related to harmful
content: Hateful, Offensive, and Toxic (HOT). We designed five prompts to
interact with ChatGPT and conducted four experiments eliciting HOT
classifications. Our results show that ChatGPT can achieve an accuracy of
approximately 80% when compared to MTurker annotations. Specifically, the model
displays a more consistent classification for non-HOT comments than HOT
comments compared to human annotations. Our findings also suggest that ChatGPT
classifications align with provided HOT definitions, but ChatGPT classifies
"hateful" and "offensive" as subsets of "toxic." Moreover, the choice of
prompts used to interact with ChatGPT impacts its performance. Based on these
in-sights, our study provides several meaningful implications for employing
ChatGPT to detect HOT content, particularly regarding the reliability and
consistency of its performance, its understand-ing and reasoning of the HOT
concept, and the impact of prompts on its performance. Overall, our study
provides guidance about the potential of using generative AI models to moderate
large volumes of user-generated content on social media. | [
0.0999292135,
-0.0029764832,
-0.0235812087,
0.0014551647,
-0.0197233278,
0.0378469937,
0.0317378379,
0.014972968,
0.0607794598,
-0.0619330071,
0.0041704234,
-0.0136934137,
-0.0421294272,
0.0337475911,
-0.0151825249,
-0.0456798524,
0.0114558237,
0.033573065,
0.0479865447,
0.0251055434,
0.0533292443,
0.0220470633,
-0.0027121506,
0.0544482283,
-0.0781081021,
-0.0151126469,
0.0368270166,
0.0112578245,
0.0330409631,
-0.0309966132,
0.0398797356,
0.0466778465,
-0.0023371968,
0.0681164861,
0.0000018848,
-0.0323615968,
0.0212082025,
-0.0147607327,
0.0029746038,
-0.0449588411,
0.0911933482,
-0.0085923392,
-0.0233965814,
0.0489850827,
-0.0506552272,
0.0246562846,
0.0652634427,
0.0546081513,
0.0710914955,
0.0403798856,
-0.0315205045,
-0.0128821246,
0.0040680687,
0.0151750315,
0.0381353311,
0.00456193,
0.0298906602,
-0.0073942342,
-0.0257199444,
0.0188544262,
-0.002480143,
0.01618471,
0.0239093341,
-0.0228726324,
0.0334621258,
-0.0115896566,
-0.0182453338,
-0.0433617905,
0.0173148327,
0.0474737473,
-0.028427789,
-0.0105393343,
0.0120688444,
-0.0100980084,
0.0075737401,
-0.015637625,
-0.0456994288,
0.0126387579,
-0.0454022102,
0.0049456237,
-0.0019527138,
0.0225595534,
0.0439462624,
0.056340199,
0.0679975972,
-0.0066990829,
-0.0177143328,
-0.0389744416,
-0.0006316725,
-0.0050701229,
-0.0175707322,
-0.0263368431,
0.026652772,
0.002460907,
-0.0169933867,
0.0173869208,
-0.0409371369,
-0.027991049,
0.0271560494,
-0.0912404433,
0.0108335055,
0.0434563309,
-0.0411644951,
0.0245813802,
0.0088315802,
0.0094469534,
-0.0103756031,
0.0104083698,
0.0113787241,
0.0002360017,
-0.0305072069,
0.000115743,
-0.0329573601,
-0.013941641,
0.0230326802,
0.0162196662,
-0.0559849665,
0.0096434467,
-0.0638715029,
-0.0226619225,
-0.0015006484,
0.0070341923,
-0.0232315157,
0.037792623,
-0.035072498,
-0.0244553294,
-0.0836265087,
0.0241813734,
0.0001514034,
-0.07268361,
0.022622779,
0.0383444838,
-0.0089410413,
-0.0129307983,
0.0162556153,
0.0770251006,
0.0326797776,
-0.009855682,
-0.0465781093,
-0.0397185609,
-0.0126633467,
-0.0437317453,
0.0189415012,
-0.0546700992,
0.0271560643,
-0.0122878272,
-0.0421074107,
-0.0336722583,
0.0157618634,
0.0338977166,
-0.0211664811,
0.0625849217,
-0.0117529631,
-0.0261441525,
0.0517038442,
0.0436424538,
-0.0536049344,
0.0606730878,
0.0051310142,
0.0723173767,
0.0501073934,
-0.00161173,
0.0109721292,
0.0362725668,
0.0177035704,
-0.0148552563,
-0.0302453991,
-0.0081477743,
-0.0616899915,
-0.017000176,
-0.0318487659,
0.0654167458,
-0.0262578707,
-0.0347928591,
0.0473596491,
0.0574783199,
-0.0742521212,
0.0526264571,
0.0819166452,
0.0117066689,
-0.0238810815,
-0.0076766242,
-0.0406593047,
0.0356561281,
-0.0285906345,
-0.0618618131,
0.0248805024,
0.0540655032,
-0.0174646322,
-0.0596394651,
-0.0238066949,
-0.0241021868,
0.0758074895,
-0.049825307,
0.0245145578,
0.0233119428,
-0.0202480964,
-0.029477777,
0.0537006743,
-0.0218615979,
-0.0006373564,
-0.0738543198,
0.0391322896,
0.105521366,
0.0409360267,
0.0014651881,
-0.0300949682,
-0.0591907017,
0.0065131178,
0.0329302885,
0.027438933,
-0.0031888362,
-0.0544469804,
-0.038188342,
-0.0314533561,
0.0296023376,
0.0046390174,
0.022400951,
0.0439494215,
-0.0120408172,
0.0092344442,
0.0616251342,
-0.0199361946,
0.0180883911,
0.0231519174,
-0.0046209446,
-0.0226968452,
0.0061465963,
0.079043977,
0.0047707632,
0.0032962423,
-0.038995102,
-0.0118313758,
0.0065732743,
-0.0630574971,
-0.0054342053,
-0.0277884603,
0.0409260131,
0.0125769991,
-0.0427064411,
-0.0170351621,
0.0369469114,
0.0099815624,
0.0366635099,
0.0325130448,
-0.030819267,
-0.0211179592,
-0.0602544807,
-0.065872319,
-0.042173218,
0.0131750414,
-0.0096471868,
0.0862591639,
-0.0086633973,
-0.0281477664,
0.0250898078,
-0.0423688963,
0.0081933867,
0.0282449815,
-0.0222182348,
-0.0402782783,
-0.0208369512,
0.0149149625,
0.0228875708,
0.0138923312,
-0.0287555959,
-0.0303772483,
-0.0847516209,
-0.011164587,
-0.0145413466,
-0.0055326549,
0.0409316458,
0.0081375046,
-0.0152216963,
0.0296905134,
-0.0278455131,
-0.0240348298,
0.0303120688,
0.050402496,
0.00099746,
-0.0471032634,
0.0064587235,
-0.0398008078,
0.0106340246,
-0.0239002593,
0.0026469261,
0.0528152548,
-0.074621141,
0.0488959774,
-0.0021057972,
-0.0612022579,
0.0062468741,
-0.0115254959,
-0.0690990612,
0.0378394462,
0.0041535734,
0.0225975867,
0.0282522645,
0.0711509064,
0.1115496233,
-0.0070687039,
0.0206310041,
-0.0301847234,
0.0131949587,
-0.036814779,
0.0138130784,
-0.0015185201,
-0.0307572745,
-0.0092978934,
0.0570999831,
0.0304966308,
0.007076689,
-0.0873468891,
0.0766386315,
-0.0636702403,
-0.0265965983,
-0.0138570135,
-0.0584355965,
0.0006886121,
0.0071133701,
-0.037112467,
-0.062925294,
0.0630671009,
0.0163323134,
0.0216901973,
-0.00015137,
-0.0173964743,
-0.0086389203,
0.0191075709,
-0.0015919524,
0.0371098593,
-0.0284843165,
0.0027205108,
0.0186217204,
-0.0103684077,
0.0620504431,
-0.0210520867,
-0.0438184142,
-0.0158736259,
-0.0039194627,
0.0340695716,
-0.0363021046,
-0.0618032888,
-0.0449484996,
-0.0267019644,
-0.0243596118,
0.0406934768,
0.0096743181,
0.0164019,
0.0382652804,
0.0106599703,
-0.0113805663,
-0.0018775023,
-0.0203094706,
0.0114544937,
-0.0347230434,
0.0261106137,
-0.0242968537,
0.0063038263,
0.017133195,
0.0013425752,
0.0730196983,
-0.0369352028,
-0.0356846005,
-0.0205575377,
0.0105538853,
-0.0056850649,
0.0155862803,
-0.0038858291,
-0.0161953773,
0.0235960558,
-0.0121320384,
-0.0024820173,
0.0831340477,
0.0321087874,
-0.0173237771,
0.0056653069,
0.0115244323,
0.0154487258,
0.0059128134,
-0.0112115974,
-0.0983291417,
-0.0086753815,
-0.0431783386,
0.0303316638,
-0.0810380653,
-0.0614698157,
0.0203863196,
-0.0631186068,
0.0411713868,
-0.0069331764,
-0.0214996282,
0.0010687057,
-0.0030970788,
0.0088230595,
-0.02298606,
0.0064750202,
-0.0489295386,
0.0339022428,
0.0046616234,
0.0051957737,
-0.0400203019,
-0.0036058347,
0.0158444624,
-0.0156923365,
0.065447934,
0.0553016476,
0.0464685224,
-0.0001731344,
-0.0075950185,
0.0670756549,
0.0494184382,
-0.0038081862,
-0.0413860381,
0.048585128,
0.0161635969,
-0.0097772563,
-0.0513217859,
0.0423566028,
0.0178326778,
-0.024271423,
-0.0065262932,
0.0881125778,
0.0202164426,
-0.0120697403,
-0.0543349683,
0.0442360342,
0.0319527537,
0.0639667362,
0.0401748084,
-0.0692265928,
0.0055028726,
-0.0519392304,
0.0233546142,
-0.0336145312,
-0.0601055734,
-0.0347696692,
-0.0213541612,
-0.0499908105,
-0.061345242,
-0.0366500579,
0.02055379,
-0.0103947353,
0.0053920643,
-0.0285964739,
-0.0109206298,
0.0115619954,
0.0163148139,
-0.0137693407,
0.0129583292,
0.0040016412,
-0.0079113636,
-0.0509353876,
-0.0143965995,
-0.0349649265,
-0.0308448616,
0.0362525582,
-0.0452804528,
-0.038502343,
0.0540009439,
0.0854786411,
0.0207590405,
-0.0109559484,
-0.0379931666,
-0.0333145559,
0.001191974,
0.0669680908,
-0.0268289149,
-0.030033078,
0.0195777211,
0.0443013497,
0.0181907322,
0.0080543198,
-0.0306535568,
0.0684095249,
0.0079237586,
-0.0385508016,
-0.0569519661,
-0.0160847455,
0.0067609455,
0.0039618295,
0.0318231992,
-0.0091565987,
-0.0354969539,
-0.0199072286,
-0.0553408787,
-0.0066714054,
-0.0274497364,
-0.0063941348,
0.0056973337,
0.0080524031,
-0.0068544731,
-0.0482221246,
-0.016538715,
-0.0627645925,
0.0381076448,
-0.0521497279,
-0.0077127437,
0.0346991532,
0.0329067744,
0.0065483805,
0.0119298194,
-0.0192556661,
0.0494608246,
0.0121631036,
-0.0235555619,
-0.0208410285,
0.0449309386,
-0.0060193851,
0.0076299314,
0.0260560159,
-0.002806796,
-0.003708089,
-0.0057025794,
-0.0332170501,
0.0374148078,
0.0054867063,
0.0194299184,
0.0108306175,
-0.0049296804,
-0.0244439859,
0.0075630052,
0.0210081208,
0.0019718898,
-0.0719701275,
-0.0160915423,
0.018432023,
-0.0268004164,
-0.0251987576,
0.0310220346,
-0.061369393,
0.046339523,
0.037879467,
-0.0605349541,
-0.0325022303,
0.0145546906,
0.0014722056,
0.0141502367,
0.0347199813,
0.0614308938,
-0.0455056876,
-0.0270994008,
-0.0077597816,
-0.0352857821,
0.0261315554,
0.0044648247,
0.0131174382,
0.0603040867,
-0.0093244007,
0.0131751187,
-0.0159805864,
-0.0031107268,
-0.0300277732,
-0.0412874371,
-0.0232934821,
-6.069519613e-33,
-0.0036670298,
-0.0463434383,
-0.0015853111,
0.0604471229,
-0.0083608236,
-0.0508358516,
0.0173349082,
0.008384495,
0.0124178585,
0.0172634441,
-0.001173301,
0.0045719016,
-0.0112658199,
-0.0080571538,
0.0051134797,
-0.0527414791,
0.0344244875,
-0.0303316787,
-0.0296976026,
0.0447394438,
0.0556967668,
-0.0144809224,
-0.0038099524,
-0.1015947908,
0.026892351,
-0.0363064334,
-0.0174456388,
0.017676333,
0.0064770905,
0.0773427859,
-0.015041911,
0.0644568577,
0.0452292152,
0.0032218914,
0.0095717749,
0.0504718833,
-0.0394891687,
-0.0222006384,
0.0159107856,
-0.0190190226,
-0.017225977,
-0.0486619137,
0.0310912635,
-0.0023232515,
-0.0267274491,
-0.0149648143,
0.0420522392,
-0.0126852132,
0.0312180929,
-0.0531979613,
-0.0656379908,
0.0157135371,
-0.0359503552,
-0.0131063676,
-0.0279310253,
0.0466903299,
0.0178051684,
0.0131456461,
-0.0559364967,
0.0162438601,
-0.0166484993,
-0.0464181639,
0.0183963906,
-0.0305720903,
0.0115165692,
0.0533868372,
-0.0003442811,
0.0727759823,
-0.0472409911,
0.0168283042,
-0.0257025044,
0.0372590013,
0.0611113198,
0.0513470694,
0.0262091961,
-0.0749746114,
-0.05498356,
0.0110708727,
0.0611838736,
0.0037438935,
0.024388995,
-0.0302094072,
-0.0606362298,
-0.0059234602,
0.0167824049,
-0.0535954572,
-0.0366211347,
-0.0662613884,
0.0049080173,
-0.0167512577,
-0.0292410441,
-0.026994193,
-0.0019286092,
-0.0318151079,
0.0496756025,
0.0227313936,
-0.0096503282,
0.0011218595,
0.036168959,
0.0233745556,
-0.0388094597,
0.0121653639,
0.0416894779,
-0.0256256927,
0.0226314813,
0.0110105881,
0.0707166344,
0.0390860327,
-0.0411334857,
-0.0043268078,
-0.0155996354,
0.0937972218,
-0.028502699,
0.0204735659,
-0.0068643279,
0.0374719501,
-0.0153417941,
-0.0252161231,
0.0584209114,
0.0321023501,
-0.0334920436,
-0.0058066081,
-0.0493338108,
-0.0398665145,
-0.0108700106,
0.0018193001,
-0.0156275332,
0.0027664138,
0.0153635861,
-0.1037313938,
0.0088646421,
-0.0249104276,
2.624e-7,
0.0216544513,
0.0555116236,
0.0110567408,
0.0050417394,
0.0291008595,
0.0306107644,
0.0411658585,
0.011104323,
0.0063280691,
0.0016636227,
-0.0010237186,
0.0378664248,
0.016095195,
0.0818976834,
-0.0115813762,
-0.0504589863,
-0.0853901654,
0.0205438081,
-0.0438313186,
0.0110132825,
0.0444600582,
0.0497815162,
0.0422819443,
-0.0266668852,
-0.0041691288,
-0.0196390264,
0.0282403342,
-0.0398709476,
-0.0085141258,
-0.009424977,
0.0793717057,
0.0173313189,
0.0290607456,
0.0074884538,
-0.0008012927,
-0.0309719481,
0.0156147927,
0.0245871544,
0.0239028707,
-0.0125126978,
0.0323384441,
-0.0020269009,
0.025495613,
-0.0340935588,
0.0404567942,
-0.0368941985,
-0.0130808298,
-0.0605231784,
-0.0153293414,
-0.0271711927,
0.0285513029,
-0.0305571873,
-0.0174268875,
-0.0116245244,
0.0191491693,
-0.0005697044,
0.0075347689,
-0.0474913828,
0.0153215239,
-0.0443488546,
-0.0468461961,
-0.0518757738,
-0.0267743785,
-0.002877329,
0.0368737057,
0.0400652811,
0.0628134683,
1.955039042e-34,
0.0324970707,
-0.0338784382,
0.017502049,
-0.0328083672,
0.0467693843,
0.0538138822,
0.0156694539,
0.0133002857,
0.0437988304,
-0.0231905021,
-0.0042924089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10611v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10611v2 | Joint Repetition Suppression and Content Moderation of Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T19:17:49 | 2023-06-05T18:16:29 | Minghui Zhang, Alex Sokolov, Weixin Cai, Si-Qing Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Natural language generation (NLG) is one of the most impactful fields in NLP,
and recent years have witnessed its evolution brought about by large language
models (LLMs). As the key instrument for writing assistance applications, they
are generally prone to replicating or extending offensive content provided in
the input. In low-resource data regime, they can also lead to repetitive
outputs. Usually, offensive content and repetitions are mitigated with post-hoc
methods, including n-gram level blocklists, top-k and nucleus sampling. In this
paper, we apply non-exact repetition suppression using token and sequence level
unlikelihood loss, and further explore the framework of unlikelihood training
objective in order to jointly endow the model with abilities to avoid
generating offensive words and phrases from the beginning. Finally, with
comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that our proposed methods work
exceptionally in controlling the repetition and content quality of LLM outputs. | [
0.0791857168,
0.061220184,
-0.0216899626,
0.0157153551,
-0.0467059053,
0.0190755408,
0.005878137,
0.0165136866,
0.0086223409,
-0.0301658232,
-0.0081487484,
-0.053501647,
-0.0091362819,
0.0135854064,
0.0495286137,
-0.0077778753,
0.0301467739,
0.0166261569,
0.013804988,
-0.0260876659,
0.0406344607,
0.0188112501,
0.0416170508,
0.052739542,
-0.0595419593,
-0.0021692682,
0.0284070615,
0.0399194621,
0.0068378327,
-0.0328072049,
0.0288477857,
0.0350210853,
-0.0355788581,
0.0579485632,
0.0000019334,
-0.0157683119,
-0.0331437215,
0.0058175134,
0.0244930778,
0.0031166654,
0.0833595246,
0.0001381707,
-0.0079007559,
0.0390232056,
0.0020621235,
0.0148653593,
0.0599982738,
0.1066064537,
0.0795713142,
0.0692853332,
0.0071185841,
0.0038527965,
-0.007461966,
-0.0093135014,
0.003587242,
0.0577414297,
0.0321162604,
-0.0393971615,
-0.0236283578,
0.0012310956,
-0.0025816865,
0.0360005535,
0.014597768,
-0.0265747476,
-0.0024392204,
0.0260688178,
-0.0225378014,
-0.0281599276,
-0.0002637657,
0.0237831324,
-0.0383351818,
-0.0646281242,
0.0369894691,
-0.0133603076,
0.005864826,
-0.0127942078,
-0.0503116623,
0.0463610291,
0.0041090031,
0.040210925,
-0.0018089286,
-0.0015288458,
0.0121094864,
0.0205084011,
0.0294102002,
-0.017302623,
0.0472998805,
-0.0498342514,
-0.0093501545,
0.0002150755,
-0.0234220102,
-0.0515516289,
0.0417691655,
-0.008509404,
-0.0367996618,
0.0064526577,
-0.0745752454,
-0.0358597636,
0.0506993979,
-0.0692668334,
0.0709863603,
0.015456941,
0.0000878542,
-0.0150161702,
-0.030696962,
0.0404561497,
0.0016172652,
-0.0092669772,
-0.0210238919,
0.0080065625,
-0.01457782,
-0.0303601008,
-0.0227559563,
0.0738387182,
-0.0200975407,
-0.0241078865,
-0.0308685228,
-0.0068427804,
-0.0176375806,
0.0004425051,
-0.0169846732,
0.0390408188,
-0.0445845909,
0.0073143821,
0.0264871176,
-0.0176350456,
-0.0452989824,
0.003524123,
0.0271793976,
-0.0617296398,
-0.0206048526,
0.0441600271,
0.0100060012,
-0.0163430031,
0.0021288425,
0.0262963716,
0.0064708428,
-0.013893364,
-0.0411661789,
-0.0394265205,
-0.0274904259,
-0.0614186041,
-0.0198773313,
-0.0653217062,
-0.0062229582,
-0.030442182,
-0.0083245197,
-0.0762524679,
0.0228703711,
0.0577514172,
-0.0359886996,
0.0303960685,
0.0058722729,
-0.030215621,
0.0271701943,
0.0333386846,
0.0217517745,
0.0407699682,
0.0049600163,
0.0318097845,
0.0357113108,
0.0087325172,
0.0021107267,
0.0229013171,
0.0375804976,
-0.0151190972,
-0.0688003153,
-0.0239943713,
-0.0219595246,
0.0169540495,
0.0569254272,
0.0966905504,
-0.0194687396,
-0.0214117095,
0.0683740005,
0.0141603723,
-0.0435979068,
0.0558442362,
0.0647616461,
0.0287948269,
-0.0253221914,
0.0702570677,
-0.0445523039,
0.0171321761,
-0.0286348034,
0.0139418971,
0.0661304072,
0.0407012478,
-0.0275089424,
-0.0285211559,
0.0073801139,
0.0028553957,
0.0119512556,
-0.0544203557,
0.010082894,
0.0547096133,
-0.049220223,
0.0408784896,
0.0352420397,
-0.0588869676,
0.0363494493,
-0.021506561,
0.0333173834,
0.0200366583,
0.0696363151,
0.0061115599,
-0.0171041079,
-0.0156151131,
-0.0450676568,
0.0696133673,
0.0035413299,
-0.0010982192,
0.001654301,
-0.0429623425,
-0.0030571374,
-0.0074517233,
0.0149342762,
0.0185829941,
0.0348023698,
0.0033598056,
0.0575223975,
0.0073402976,
-0.0625025555,
0.0445248485,
-0.0261288472,
-0.0135150142,
0.038513124,
-0.0101047866,
0.0453611501,
0.0253723133,
-0.0389352813,
0.0232284386,
0.0372108333,
-0.046854265,
-0.0399538428,
-0.0346069038,
-0.043110542,
-0.0859034434,
0.0443961322,
-0.0335820913,
0.0092480974,
0.067011565,
0.003530656,
-0.0227839574,
0.0146946134,
-0.0577036552,
0.0495497435,
-0.0623236522,
0.0262595322,
0.0122879716,
0.0126887634,
-0.0293567032,
0.0435323454,
-0.0215608086,
0.0411931537,
0.0436247103,
-0.0455318168,
0.0006231178,
-0.0377915949,
-0.048914507,
-0.0118389735,
-0.040204037,
0.016411053,
0.0455342121,
0.013492451,
-0.0250282567,
-0.0490555838,
-0.0933102667,
0.028748557,
-0.0046840468,
-0.0304933805,
-0.0048397225,
0.016738385,
-0.0158045739,
-0.0027523269,
-0.0274854004,
-0.0358473808,
0.0617374815,
0.0205108803,
0.0110545345,
-0.0306113046,
-0.0584296957,
-0.0131883686,
-0.0041590412,
0.0081049288,
0.0450661592,
-0.0180862825,
-0.0068179583,
-0.0151074817,
0.0396685489,
-0.0644687563,
-0.0102163516,
0.025678711,
-0.0445389897,
0.0058220243,
0.0291963071,
0.0361481532,
0.0263637342,
0.0387226641,
0.0409581102,
0.0215241443,
0.0008888801,
-0.0279650502,
-0.0221184939,
-0.0384848155,
0.0065505202,
0.0158897843,
-0.049494572,
0.026631413,
0.0229233094,
0.07735084,
0.0054030125,
-0.0506373011,
0.0682566389,
-0.0279921535,
-0.0471645519,
0.0111169768,
-0.0366590023,
-0.0436359905,
-0.0257906355,
-0.0244406424,
-0.0463545322,
0.0317662172,
-0.0436334945,
0.0061915852,
-0.0368180536,
0.0225837696,
0.0159843918,
0.0283757541,
0.0114554837,
0.0453141704,
0.034287449,
-0.0233669095,
-0.012093069,
-0.0035616558,
0.0111965612,
-0.020404676,
0.0086541465,
-0.0160037875,
-0.0063330773,
0.0120591326,
-0.0072009573,
-0.0795829594,
-0.0681194663,
0.0440311618,
-0.0006561654,
0.0211029053,
0.0134241683,
-0.0236313511,
-0.0181235038,
0.0283823013,
0.0143837333,
-0.0405155867,
-0.0047140927,
-0.0092385234,
0.0687915012,
0.0601684302,
-0.035683725,
0.0349058993,
-0.0161439572,
-0.0020683538,
0.0606802665,
-0.018906042,
0.0368508771,
0.0036108878,
0.0131063219,
0.0053304965,
-0.0339606777,
-0.0090385964,
0.0348530114,
0.0451281853,
-0.0299077947,
-0.0387633741,
0.1114268973,
0.0242514331,
0.0171315409,
0.0295966398,
0.028282268,
0.0682729781,
0.005995756,
-0.003670837,
-0.0213564076,
0.0082707657,
0.0111202057,
0.0185194127,
-0.0535827167,
-0.023449935,
-0.0208073203,
-0.1307991147,
0.0234275479,
0.0252032001,
-0.0343362167,
-0.0467088372,
-0.0069623077,
-0.0237014517,
0.0221721455,
-0.0055232747,
-0.0101067089,
-0.0118758604,
-0.0117371185,
0.0346248746,
-0.0026706571,
-0.0530360304,
-0.0465287305,
-0.057819888,
0.0709056556,
0.0538997278,
0.0527602509,
0.0000028653,
0.0311269425,
0.0238705818,
-0.0110967038,
-0.001420246,
-0.0432674401,
-0.0036328977,
0.0174157862,
-0.0202495586,
-0.0507691652,
0.0423456319,
0.0032330309,
-0.016142657,
0.0068726232,
0.0378765874,
0.0005051252,
-0.0372933708,
-0.0333127715,
0.0485226847,
0.0245737024,
0.101561904,
0.053557191,
-0.0339840911,
0.004432153,
-0.0257332139,
0.0101584494,
-0.0380295105,
-0.0007143992,
-0.0179441739,
-0.0187523179,
0.0175998826,
-0.11503499,
-0.0355361477,
-0.0021322933,
0.0372405164,
-0.0043388116,
0.0240444876,
-0.0126244165,
-0.036972899,
0.017539084,
-0.0208214018,
-0.0266748723,
-0.0239881687,
-0.0464327112,
-0.00993896,
-0.0274725556,
-0.0228041932,
-0.0296262726,
0.0048147519,
-0.0584967211,
-0.0831058323,
-0.0017867459,
0.0707803369,
0.0156760402,
0.042997539,
0.0367310829,
-0.0549175702,
0.0472133867,
0.0830058157,
-0.014284947,
0.0264881831,
0.025018895,
-0.0137265585,
-0.0010717738,
0.053224083,
-0.0113988584,
0.0222886186,
0.066064097,
0.0586693846,
0.0332647078,
-0.0089980587,
0.0217898991,
0.0176476184,
-0.008538275,
-0.0504516885,
-0.0004166446,
-0.0488209277,
-0.0214917827,
-0.0274256691,
-0.0196505841,
-0.0428577065,
0.0367453992,
0.0172529034,
0.0033884582,
-0.0462578051,
-0.0074743018,
-0.0583430752,
0.0943398699,
-0.0318757147,
-0.010158143,
-0.0466954298,
0.0022031527,
0.006879583,
0.0050147013,
-0.0650893599,
0.025388578,
-0.0076846294,
-0.0221213382,
-0.0274084285,
0.0167164076,
0.0134547949,
0.014473631,
-0.0275764521,
0.0117610088,
0.0024125574,
0.0115079442,
-0.0907219052,
0.0031666209,
0.0388639532,
-0.0416897349,
0.0604612827,
-0.0477296077,
0.0026131659,
-0.0447298177,
0.0268763863,
0.0260135867,
-0.0441416875,
-0.0033268018,
-0.006365465,
-0.0367923714,
-0.0052599921,
0.0929596201,
-0.0004349108,
0.0090473797,
0.0357546508,
-0.0300643537,
-0.0372634903,
-0.0148985321,
0.0747076273,
0.0354967825,
-0.0167344939,
0.0137829324,
-0.0258960463,
-0.04474058,
0.0309751388,
-0.010373814,
0.0050038169,
-0.014707814,
0.043171145,
0.0201531444,
-0.0031561558,
0.0133982496,
-0.0192404017,
0.0074398713,
0.0192354824,
-0.0381967053,
-0.0266674925,
-6.373058703e-33,
-0.0284158047,
-0.02526002,
-0.0182355661,
-0.0270353779,
-0.0306050908,
0.013005673,
-0.0195107814,
-0.0106563726,
0.0332715325,
0.0067786416,
-0.002341772,
-0.0238661114,
0.0056538535,
0.0208915398,
-0.0104268678,
0.0242490787,
0.096700035,
0.0035498485,
-0.0326777436,
0.0591369271,
0.0105188861,
0.0327435657,
0.0192373414,
-0.037892472,
0.0028751162,
-0.0290151164,
-0.0392034426,
-0.0202644765,
0.0127503853,
0.0595365837,
-0.0361871906,
0.0405386798,
0.0218164977,
-0.045425348,
-0.0375733413,
0.0063384962,
-0.0295609869,
-0.040447887,
0.0391493328,
-0.0302081723,
0.0348820798,
-0.03729067,
0.0653116554,
-0.0319355428,
-0.0383484699,
0.0103366151,
0.0171208587,
-0.0197662991,
-0.0556387827,
-0.0426341556,
-0.0675843433,
0.0257132258,
0.0029079963,
-0.0133231981,
-0.0424689613,
-0.0003283233,
-0.0136529263,
0.0180006102,
-0.0519952029,
0.0035873351,
0.0142434295,
0.0451364331,
0.0013765447,
-0.0270689093,
0.0197214764,
0.0673659369,
0.0214932784,
-0.0056484537,
0.0068900818,
-0.029988585,
0.0229415037,
0.0069887778,
0.0279916264,
0.0423773415,
0.0513915233,
-0.0531518832,
-0.0472257435,
0.0295249131,
-0.0283668339,
0.0349974558,
0.0705727339,
-0.017084768,
-0.0191460978,
-0.0378622748,
-0.017106371,
-0.0528543442,
-0.013564432,
-0.0292184725,
0.0657961145,
0.0424385071,
-0.0533906259,
-0.0224680286,
0.013443769,
-0.0181263816,
-0.0180005133,
0.0409123152,
-0.0137289632,
-0.0107518071,
-0.0039256732,
0.0002838949,
-0.0464079008,
-0.0057589416,
0.0103983907,
-0.0562363043,
0.0013754043,
-0.0019349181,
0.0520235971,
0.0289912317,
-0.0889596492,
0.0296385717,
-0.0217958465,
0.0317118354,
0.0072233789,
-0.0092035066,
0.0136093916,
-0.0018746062,
0.0191444997,
0.0399663933,
0.0254316889,
-0.0281047728,
-0.0378569365,
0.0353970677,
0.0103181629,
0.012900508,
-0.0343717858,
0.0105487881,
-0.0215046555,
0.0119160824,
0.0285334997,
-0.0618902557,
-0.0148047507,
-0.0323506668,
2.59e-7,
-0.0380805023,
0.0239200257,
0.0410957113,
0.0052581728,
0.0186569151,
0.0453096069,
0.0009200316,
0.0504262745,
-0.029814804,
0.0596364476,
-0.0070348172,
-0.0195063967,
0.0247700103,
0.0239007268,
-0.059608154,
0.0615584925,
-0.1120212153,
-0.0165285692,
-0.0601555556,
-0.0214472637,
0.0252561104,
0.0968543664,
0.0004312985,
-0.0188452322,
-0.0052970559,
-0.0513153039,
0.0719457194,
0.005507153,
-0.014510816,
-0.006840501,
0.0708133876,
-0.0091193197,
0.0196161997,
-0.0276603792,
-0.0293535981,
0.0009562448,
0.0124590173,
0.048431769,
0.0247891303,
-0.0222553294,
0.0612846464,
-0.0014297448,
-0.0153875155,
-0.0775198862,
0.0589475408,
-0.0002180349,
0.0047473656,
-0.029025374,
-0.0042664306,
-0.0157468263,
0.0190082844,
-0.0748099312,
-0.0513031036,
0.0161407925,
0.0445085168,
0.0382307358,
-0.0106087392,
-0.0265796073,
-0.0122477217,
-0.0338326469,
-0.0494112261,
-0.0299167708,
-0.0440719724,
0.0148325702,
0.0049330136,
-0.0307860188,
0.0177781787,
2.775537772e-34,
0.0405848548,
-0.0348048024,
0.0104823764,
-0.0042519839,
0.0213803984,
0.0103876814,
-0.0049484456,
0.0396321192,
-0.0033238209,
-0.0568254292,
-0.0270247739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14339v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14339v1 | MarsEclipse at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Multi-Lingual and Multi-Label Framing Detection with Contrastive Learning | 2023-04-20T18:42:23 | 2023-04-20T18:42:23 | Qisheng Liao, Meiting Lai, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | This paper describes our system for SemEval-2023 Task 3 Subtask 2 on Framing
Detection. We used a multi-label contrastive loss for fine-tuning large
pre-trained language models in a multi-lingual setting, achieving very
competitive results: our system was ranked first on the official test set and
on the official shared task leaderboard for five of the six languages for which
we had training data and for which we could perform fine-tuning. Here, we
describe our experimental setup, as well as various ablation studies. The code
of our system is available at https://github.com/QishengL/SemEval2023 | [
-0.0190313831,
0.0236242842,
0.0026419593,
0.0600072779,
-0.0150220292,
0.0174695328,
0.0214067623,
0.0294678193,
-0.0495917089,
-0.0273634549,
-0.0406615362,
-0.0366071686,
0.0205617193,
0.0455817245,
0.0031884036,
-0.0732486024,
0.0354232006,
-0.0242509041,
0.0194067787,
-0.0197028443,
0.01306492,
0.0080222907,
-0.0181725211,
-0.0034437971,
-0.0441748351,
-0.0182953645,
0.0071955342,
-0.0053011193,
0.0395837575,
-0.058819931,
0.0322081819,
0.0745618865,
0.022351481,
0.0242691897,
0.0000023335,
-0.032848604,
-0.0168616902,
0.0056348294,
0.0063247685,
-0.0011779685,
0.0790204182,
-0.0508024059,
-0.0054474692,
0.0104619507,
-0.0517063066,
-0.0356573611,
0.0416071713,
0.0277557168,
0.0630875528,
0.0540646687,
-0.0249172822,
-0.0582935959,
-0.0297070947,
-0.0193841476,
-0.0491763726,
-0.048845116,
0.0309301205,
-0.0322894715,
-0.0452783331,
0.0371522233,
-0.0236707106,
0.0342253782,
0.0181681924,
-0.0100647649,
-0.0879460275,
0.0175957009,
-0.0192063972,
-0.032259576,
-0.017296847,
0.0564556979,
0.0453025736,
-0.0035148445,
-0.0345030949,
-0.0064208149,
-0.0160984714,
-0.0802922845,
-0.0043392042,
0.0168708041,
0.0119846938,
0.0365997218,
0.0435447954,
0.0073092161,
-0.0138456095,
0.0099944649,
0.0153715713,
-0.0219199006,
0.0303776264,
-0.0065832245,
0.0275558606,
0.029908143,
0.0122181252,
-0.0251326542,
0.0149671938,
-0.0047299266,
-0.0415916964,
-0.0007884506,
-0.0416984744,
-0.0823486522,
0.0218836367,
-0.0471568145,
-0.0447162874,
0.0249123275,
-0.0484119132,
0.0653411448,
-0.0506798923,
0.0327483565,
-0.0356881209,
0.027016433,
-0.0258423295,
-0.0173078179,
-0.0007628634,
0.0191130582,
-0.0356673487,
0.0096495459,
-0.0667464212,
0.0099147428,
-0.0348459184,
-0.0309940111,
-0.0175770391,
-0.0005721975,
-0.0876796395,
0.0032069089,
-0.0344695747,
-0.0250448827,
-0.0096921092,
0.0549328849,
-0.015713878,
0.0064734011,
-0.0103653176,
-0.0567661077,
-0.0221298281,
0.0773233101,
-0.0128500117,
-0.035385035,
0.0352438428,
0.0370495841,
-0.0401433446,
-0.0720547289,
-0.0131560201,
-0.0263381917,
-0.0598857626,
-0.0458678417,
0.0032268455,
-0.0871921182,
0.0056631607,
0.0166173317,
0.0105581228,
-0.0232118983,
-0.0093812263,
-0.0183019564,
-0.003643451,
0.0789655373,
0.0054267198,
-0.0413845107,
0.0272231977,
0.0210062005,
-0.0027313796,
0.10761787,
-0.0182782523,
0.0198241454,
0.0451952554,
0.0147467349,
-0.0264723487,
0.0579814985,
0.0019142953,
0.040198572,
0.0215742085,
-0.0252564754,
0.0555904545,
0.0050074947,
0.0520901531,
0.0260677207,
-0.0067893863,
-0.0209065266,
0.0225821752,
-0.0075593526,
-0.029344542,
-0.0057520298,
0.0360609479,
-0.0213808082,
-0.0083965072,
0.0580700301,
-0.0174128693,
0.0071804677,
-0.003818681,
-0.0270355903,
0.0199516509,
0.0323733129,
-0.0304140672,
-0.0091054924,
0.0349853933,
-0.0229223948,
-0.0121115316,
-0.0276165158,
0.086873211,
0.0183960758,
-0.0671731755,
0.0932703093,
0.0365099832,
-0.0045321872,
0.0258588921,
-0.0185808633,
-0.0402263142,
-0.0237934664,
-0.0002037212,
-0.049309317,
0.0177660268,
-0.0213817749,
0.0451406613,
0.0830361918,
0.0429317653,
0.0212819297,
0.0563093759,
-0.0170866027,
-0.038345281,
-0.0700784847,
0.0167459752,
0.0466831513,
-0.0165596567,
0.0533792302,
-0.0165212881,
0.0255507194,
0.0114993136,
0.0347373076,
0.0139590707,
-0.0145959016,
-0.0419541486,
0.0229848046,
0.0235560071,
0.0116461022,
-0.0295172017,
-0.0321454741,
0.0406748727,
-0.0467785858,
0.0304087996,
-0.0078578759,
-0.0534319915,
-0.0523641482,
0.0501433089,
-0.0904238373,
-0.0420800336,
0.0211316347,
-0.0658145025,
-0.0288532153,
0.0163714867,
-0.0017254684,
0.0036951299,
0.0019680408,
-0.0056780684,
-0.0331769362,
0.0258021355,
0.0116482014,
0.0477785431,
-0.0005367079,
0.0360057242,
0.030424444,
0.0125620849,
0.0359028019,
-0.0476460792,
-0.0248933509,
0.0069968482,
-0.0244124923,
-0.0110220499,
0.0248570107,
0.0549537838,
-0.0243080482,
0.0073511088,
-0.0674554706,
-0.0221494269,
-0.0373903252,
0.0107096341,
0.0689154565,
-0.0142397033,
0.0057385662,
-0.0403546132,
-0.0020654695,
-0.0257208124,
0.0104679493,
0.0240751635,
0.0252228007,
0.0038034185,
-0.0068718907,
-0.0189127363,
-0.0003942243,
-0.0224477444,
0.0581899136,
-0.0130783664,
-0.0614821836,
-0.0370907523,
0.0229160134,
0.0216317922,
0.0021146345,
-0.0015789764,
-0.0430541411,
0.0114494124,
0.0022803897,
0.0276869722,
0.0632487312,
0.0090929437,
0.0296466798,
0.0396793708,
0.0061905985,
0.0170705076,
-0.0094264597,
-0.0219435357,
-0.0038071922,
-0.0643015802,
-0.0443633571,
0.004095674,
0.0820065439,
-0.0045932326,
0.0554345623,
-0.035287343,
-0.0071396008,
-0.0154099371,
-0.0341021754,
-0.0045639942,
0.0137912743,
-0.0379804745,
0.065021731,
-0.0237201285,
-0.0254392922,
0.0739770681,
-0.0140010547,
-0.040041741,
-0.0405579992,
-0.0117381737,
-0.0244526342,
0.0110060442,
0.0022876977,
0.0411990508,
0.0285166353,
-0.0251473375,
-0.0626477674,
-0.0618327074,
0.0321542993,
0.0028081085,
0.0392680094,
-0.0216087494,
-0.0097175408,
-0.0184894726,
-0.0444048345,
-0.0316739269,
-0.0068065003,
-0.0552419797,
0.0137644662,
0.0004638328,
0.0313499793,
-0.0788612589,
-0.0191570986,
0.0126020126,
0.0383975804,
-0.0002943709,
0.0089521883,
-0.016881248,
0.1197181493,
0.0036895671,
-0.0341807306,
0.0238780808,
-0.0597895607,
0.0436900631,
0.0692802221,
-0.0322412401,
0.0255602486,
-0.0201312769,
0.0116048856,
0.0246632565,
0.0368654206,
-0.0211117305,
-0.0407604873,
0.0469408706,
-0.0368012339,
-0.007975542,
0.0798826739,
-0.0033320622,
-0.0322216004,
-0.0496957637,
0.0052544978,
0.0164794438,
0.014355137,
-0.0156865474,
-0.0902957767,
-0.0532472469,
0.0034199096,
-0.0026958538,
0.0114097567,
0.0267031901,
-0.0008823965,
-0.0612200312,
0.0186439473,
-0.0045803934,
-0.067891553,
-0.016245164,
-0.0602306165,
-0.0025568716,
-0.0232516117,
0.0129326591,
-0.0251191128,
0.0345468633,
-0.0164599959,
0.0087023387,
0.0370233878,
-0.0539619923,
-0.0098838201,
-0.0477663241,
-0.0030165408,
0.0020026388,
0.0515975356,
-0.0437720381,
-0.072854653,
0.0213729944,
-0.0487786606,
-0.0317328125,
-0.0470363051,
0.0883225799,
0.0041029123,
-0.0231175814,
0.0187970921,
0.0205131508,
-0.0252647419,
-0.0257573947,
0.0070472448,
0.027254587,
0.0239949822,
-0.0264256354,
0.0024267023,
0.0371651538,
-0.002495657,
0.0398186967,
0.0200043898,
-0.0177498292,
-0.0091783609,
-0.0422759727,
0.0443888642,
-0.0343946442,
0.0094385641,
-0.0234549474,
-0.0219131727,
0.0147524765,
-0.0157412644,
0.003913661,
-0.0063798879,
0.0445329212,
-0.006026689,
-0.0224225018,
-0.0519318953,
0.0104844524,
-0.0374336578,
0.0473287068,
-0.0215678811,
0.0169007219,
-0.0769257993,
-0.0033759829,
0.0464299694,
-0.0067346641,
-0.0406811908,
0.070031561,
-0.0491062403,
-0.0642056391,
-0.0111017767,
0.0500477701,
0.0175088719,
0.058885172,
-0.0149816032,
-0.0018401266,
0.0350163504,
-0.0022876803,
0.0030483177,
0.0438856967,
0.0503746271,
-0.0269160606,
-0.0350182876,
0.0086614452,
0.0012975784,
0.0230437107,
0.0432108194,
-0.0061421939,
0.0100007281,
-0.0180202164,
-0.0002548994,
-0.0074067293,
0.0575308762,
-0.0520646907,
-0.0007818621,
-0.034833543,
-0.0037392066,
0.041402027,
-0.0282231923,
-0.0101694362,
0.0042254487,
0.0094829351,
-0.0110623045,
0.0102438321,
0.0611847565,
-0.0196723714,
-0.0072356081,
0.0119956285,
0.0404771492,
0.0257800333,
0.0607601069,
0.0114819445,
0.020456532,
0.0106509402,
0.0184504855,
0.0068761148,
0.0403456651,
-0.0339250788,
0.0467111021,
0.0548433028,
-0.0176218431,
0.0098204399,
0.0302738734,
0.02451743,
0.0130261565,
-0.0465866178,
-0.0132594137,
0.0644487292,
-0.0180075597,
0.0447748974,
-0.0027123368,
-0.0471583195,
-0.0190073866,
0.0383268259,
0.0002191201,
0.0069666556,
0.0332111232,
0.0158637315,
0.0083596054,
0.0514230505,
0.0387995206,
-0.0316683762,
0.0249356627,
0.0614982955,
-0.0086472742,
-0.0168397091,
0.0163068436,
-0.0143777374,
0.031459108,
-0.0161562786,
0.000584384,
-0.0421192087,
-0.052077841,
0.0438552424,
-0.012949368,
-0.0335485078,
0.0542575605,
0.0316240713,
0.0314451605,
0.0217589773,
-0.0158400796,
0.0046733948,
-0.0036336887,
0.0212387182,
-0.0125262951,
-0.007898042,
-6.505972584e-33,
-0.0411838368,
-0.0350796282,
-0.0403723456,
0.0024235675,
0.0028654975,
0.0488878638,
-0.0477243401,
0.0004734647,
-0.027524665,
0.0321759693,
0.0611623153,
0.0100637898,
0.0166021716,
0.0063500013,
-0.0391489007,
-0.0200745352,
0.0633680671,
-0.0054449304,
-0.0235573333,
0.0029107367,
-0.0059529678,
0.0218507871,
0.0819821507,
-0.0736479908,
-0.0144131966,
0.054134883,
-0.0543510094,
0.0298524071,
0.0165436864,
0.0660555735,
-0.0336520486,
0.0520376414,
0.01335207,
-0.0293460619,
-0.0069615613,
0.0353652872,
-0.0660151094,
-0.0046609212,
-0.0033725824,
0.0398434922,
-0.0337307528,
-0.0077071972,
-0.0192528758,
-0.0019902147,
-0.01659129,
0.0047249352,
0.0707320422,
-0.0239996985,
0.017025508,
0.071654506,
-0.0486707613,
0.0173520297,
-0.0017456138,
-0.0111777196,
0.0409067571,
0.0202534124,
0.0278600454,
0.0895570293,
-0.0715951771,
0.0398992337,
-0.0425338149,
0.0250332449,
0.017930612,
0.018991109,
-0.0144254649,
0.0583993644,
0.0534095541,
0.0223392025,
0.077492848,
-0.0563242882,
0.0527157933,
0.000993913,
0.0701671913,
0.0934084952,
0.0035609107,
0.022696821,
-0.0605215691,
0.003699909,
-0.0378264785,
0.0529372729,
-0.0231587794,
0.0135330167,
0.024311468,
-0.0093034273,
-0.0674961433,
-0.0868166313,
-0.0350268297,
0.0127000948,
-0.0007796684,
0.0284920521,
-0.0404056683,
-0.0207678527,
0.034971673,
-0.000454842,
0.0031033212,
-0.0047120033,
0.0001681286,
0.0041274354,
-0.0030688997,
0.0320329219,
-0.0042133112,
-0.041496329,
0.0291277692,
0.0048553864,
0.0368026681,
-0.0710764602,
0.0299690664,
0.0014132657,
-0.0701238289,
0.0142373536,
-0.0283541698,
-0.0003549088,
0.0230621733,
0.0253548846,
0.0187070686,
-0.0129353693,
-0.0145742437,
0.067038618,
0.047841765,
-0.0117659634,
-0.0188966859,
-0.07808882,
-0.0163433105,
0.0684856474,
-0.0525023751,
0.0087970831,
-0.0162589643,
-0.0131161744,
0.0597097538,
-0.0481537692,
-0.041698046,
-0.0291919298,
2.792e-7,
0.0350020267,
0.0324183069,
0.0109401671,
-0.0382780246,
0.034293212,
0.072829321,
-0.0413164236,
0.0143068992,
-0.0142028546,
-0.0235037301,
-0.0265295841,
0.0215254929,
0.0424125977,
0.0300216917,
-0.0620882995,
0.0808814541,
-0.0101162922,
0.0088779051,
-0.0369703732,
0.0139334565,
0.023617981,
0.0837607235,
0.0141572263,
-0.02386228,
0.0009292395,
-0.0489711091,
0.0457088687,
-0.0034921556,
-0.0091061573,
-0.0287560504,
-0.0717705861,
0.0220641792,
-0.0144107332,
-0.0027783231,
-0.0206429288,
-0.0044893408,
0.0112186046,
0.0496161431,
0.0252013318,
-0.0147056468,
0.017396044,
0.0498243198,
-0.0416952111,
-0.0339776762,
0.0436096005,
-0.0275563207,
-0.018205056,
-0.0715214536,
-0.0466303118,
-0.0388154835,
0.0549550578,
-0.0188919753,
-0.048480697,
0.0133328624,
0.0043643555,
0.0153166708,
-0.0490256473,
-0.0498589315,
0.0066329306,
0.0548012219,
-0.0219807103,
-0.0239887629,
-0.0193188805,
-0.0041101854,
0.0223803446,
-0.0244824179,
-0.0011521189,
2.429339992e-34,
0.0291719977,
-0.0308648925,
0.0040655429,
0.0362042673,
-0.0037908808,
-0.0127258077,
-0.0762808099,
-0.0395663567,
0.0150827002,
-0.0170602314,
0.0327547826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11040v1 | Emotional Expression Detection in Spoken Language Employing Machine Learning Algorithms | 2023-04-20T17:57:08 | 2023-04-20T17:57:08 | Mehrab Hosain, Most. Yeasmin Arafat, Gazi Zahirul Islam, Jia Uddin, Md. Mobarak Hossain, Fatema Alam | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | There are a variety of features of the human voice that can be classified as
pitch, timbre, loudness, and vocal tone. It is observed in numerous incidents
that human expresses their feelings using different vocal qualities when they
are speaking. The primary objective of this research is to recognize different
emotions of human beings such as anger, sadness, fear, neutrality, disgust,
pleasant surprise, and happiness by using several MATLAB functions namely,
spectral descriptors, periodicity, and harmonicity. To accomplish the work, we
analyze the CREMA-D (Crowd-sourced Emotional Multimodal Actors Data) & TESS
(Toronto Emotional Speech Set) datasets of human speech. The audio file
contains data that have various characteristics (e.g., noisy, speedy, slow)
thereby the efficiency of the ML (Machine Learning) models increases
significantly. The EMD (Empirical Mode Decomposition) is utilized for the
process of signal decomposition. Then, the features are extracted through the
use of several techniques such as the MFCC, GTCC, spectral centroid, roll-off
point, entropy, spread, flux, harmonic ratio, energy, skewness, flatness, and
audio delta. The data is trained using some renowned ML models namely, Support
Vector Machine, Neural Network, Ensemble, and KNN. The algorithms show an
accuracy of 67.7%, 63.3%, 61.6%, and 59.0% respectively for the test data and
77.7%, 76.1%, 99.1%, and 61.2% for the training data. We have conducted
experiments using Matlab and the result shows that our model is very prominent
and flexible than existing similar works. | [
-0.0003432809,
0.0131983086,
-0.0243304092,
0.0201864317,
-0.0030423617,
0.026077183,
0.0055688992,
-0.012262227,
-0.0122479144,
-0.0170279108,
-0.0425520912,
0.0194251109,
-0.0185160749,
0.0046738209,
-0.0384856574,
-0.0478910506,
-0.0068308222,
0.0458525382,
0.0635856166,
-0.004746384,
0.0403280407,
0.0222373046,
-0.0494992845,
0.02569535,
-0.0656861588,
0.0140332701,
-0.0475115031,
0.0093547581,
0.060112115,
-0.0074553392,
0.0111720329,
0.0085691642,
0.0184414517,
-0.00546641,
0.0000021666,
0.0001906148,
0.0240930207,
-0.0000521977,
-0.0212038159,
-0.0086725084,
0.0652181953,
0.0440838188,
-0.0523449481,
0.0107680038,
-0.0094940178,
0.0011602073,
0.0260404423,
0.0517944768,
0.0771177784,
0.0716390535,
-0.0131930867,
-0.0336910933,
-0.0502419546,
0.0074532521,
-0.0237606131,
0.0389943868,
0.0070102117,
-0.0109049194,
0.0138818184,
-0.0736131892,
-0.0179849528,
0.0126033043,
-0.0459695607,
0.0259285215,
0.0180984754,
-0.0005247362,
-0.0522675738,
-0.0568547808,
0.007613319,
0.0484936275,
0.0076447097,
-0.0058318442,
0.0420908928,
0.0246346928,
0.0103980843,
0.0036629573,
0.0097908005,
-0.0128701217,
0.0053590899,
0.0137850614,
-0.0425695293,
0.0480774976,
-0.0281622149,
0.0113186492,
0.0153708616,
0.0250235684,
-0.0508096591,
-0.0386790372,
0.0429679789,
-0.0653017536,
-0.0282173213,
0.0477505997,
0.0050260364,
0.0030297604,
0.0236353148,
-0.0227638409,
-0.0447780825,
-0.0895717219,
-0.0184490345,
-0.0573748238,
-0.0340012461,
-0.0271855015,
-0.0190741979,
-0.0091080423,
0.0365145169,
0.0033630999,
0.0365664437,
-0.0382025056,
-0.037887048,
0.0185869373,
-0.0426721498,
0.0281442422,
-0.0137926126,
0.0227000322,
0.0235005897,
0.0023702129,
-0.0978061706,
-0.0077875247,
-0.0621327944,
0.0023616473,
-0.0028070933,
-0.0021163411,
0.0325236022,
0.0328224376,
0.0186874568,
0.0059045856,
-0.0332399048,
0.038775228,
-0.0223442428,
-0.0280303564,
0.0552378707,
0.0244930256,
0.0193721484,
0.0250324775,
0.0686882958,
-0.0046022502,
0.0352442525,
-0.0065890732,
-0.0204805434,
-0.0196029972,
-0.0115526896,
-0.0375055708,
-0.0227986351,
-0.0531799421,
0.0517059863,
-0.0264905971,
-0.0295873452,
0.0189934205,
-0.0016869656,
-0.0350841805,
0.0097207082,
0.0155439693,
0.0129692499,
0.030817531,
0.0643779337,
-0.0219482817,
-0.0114465337,
-0.0006540716,
0.041022338,
0.0004519954,
0.0386280976,
-0.0590929464,
0.0389232375,
0.0333280563,
-0.0075433091,
-0.0564681329,
-0.0208093449,
-0.0763124302,
-0.0636119097,
0.0258840248,
0.0256438758,
0.019374337,
-0.0001976279,
-0.0282652751,
0.0085484348,
0.0568710342,
-0.0419459678,
0.0301440228,
-0.0322751738,
0.0678310618,
0.0637520328,
0.0009970827,
0.0136566292,
0.0151065467,
-0.012550056,
-0.0319427662,
-0.0016724319,
0.0354477614,
-0.0360466503,
-0.0085141826,
-0.0116163101,
-0.0257365312,
-0.0221778974,
0.0236870088,
0.0364475437,
-0.0475981124,
0.000045323,
0.015290984,
0.0121755581,
-0.0787278786,
-0.0212179292,
-0.032295987,
0.0224184506,
-0.0229669809,
-0.0246054642,
-0.0310756247,
0.0273142997,
-0.0705574453,
-0.0396046974,
-0.049249582,
-0.0124656586,
-0.0258945655,
0.0118898749,
-0.0596541353,
0.0174951218,
0.0344597511,
-0.0032134957,
-0.0042230897,
-0.0530471578,
0.0191938952,
-0.015190566,
-0.0240472499,
0.0295518655,
-0.0145473937,
0.0174720269,
-0.0183189381,
-0.0053701499,
0.0279006455,
0.0566300713,
0.0342008248,
-0.0223876219,
-0.0332335383,
0.0448534042,
0.0014648983,
0.0024545158,
0.0444505364,
0.00002705,
-0.0277112946,
0.047564894,
-0.0471169725,
0.0133504085,
0.0594148487,
-0.010320046,
-0.0503737144,
0.0623750687,
-0.0316994525,
-0.0137068955,
-0.0396713279,
0.0472483858,
-0.0486802384,
0.0570084266,
0.0498104095,
0.015065819,
0.0098164529,
-0.0168692023,
-0.0186618995,
-0.0312979519,
0.0053853882,
-0.0362428054,
-0.0653335527,
0.0117877033,
-0.0277343225,
0.0256693922,
-0.0313163847,
-0.0608755238,
-0.0209735837,
-0.0361394957,
-0.091738373,
-0.0252448898,
-0.0095516564,
-0.0441480018,
-0.0105804885,
-0.0035214925,
-0.0310042258,
0.0125512015,
-0.0173540171,
0.0278436001,
0.0309002176,
-0.037759196,
-0.0441868231,
-0.0218767058,
-0.0443399511,
-0.00780934,
0.0183242857,
-0.0179191902,
0.0061704642,
-0.0407253876,
-0.0243232753,
0.0338002443,
0.0235318076,
0.0210526753,
0.0407889672,
0.0019379653,
-0.0604362115,
-0.0219600461,
0.0282631945,
0.0110784126,
0.0209078807,
0.0252381805,
0.0795265138,
0.0228495076,
0.0264458451,
-0.0430770367,
0.0462354384,
0.0405385531,
0.0698374286,
-0.0258145388,
-0.0233938936,
0.0019309103,
0.0110574448,
0.0588401444,
0.0386191048,
0.0229513366,
-0.0335837714,
0.0131082498,
-0.0540873148,
-0.002740979,
-0.0332743376,
-0.0407979526,
-0.0277374256,
0.05469051,
-0.038915921,
0.0012220728,
0.0144455656,
-0.0496213995,
-0.0509466715,
-0.086869888,
-0.0248857867,
0.0033535804,
-0.066714108,
0.0161199458,
0.0127473027,
0.0109183751,
0.0095070647,
-0.0407698639,
-0.0012996268,
-0.0784757286,
-0.0258728974,
0.0235936288,
-0.0613706149,
0.0054129744,
0.0232914556,
-0.0268863924,
-0.0452831909,
-0.0170467664,
-0.0077884872,
-0.012344934,
-0.0057887752,
0.0155466972,
-0.0032474704,
0.0159371551,
-0.0574891604,
0.0044961623,
0.029387597,
0.0284844339,
0.0449229442,
0.050623443,
0.0299601648,
-0.0098922206,
-0.004662259,
0.0526177995,
0.0063304584,
0.0219635926,
0.0185675081,
-0.0361299887,
0.0197597519,
-0.0102560269,
0.0242468584,
-0.0074263709,
-0.0113944197,
-0.000054561,
0.0074044233,
0.0896269158,
0.1039631739,
0.0257978979,
-0.0552811176,
0.0240051039,
-0.0156391729,
-0.0454620346,
0.00900413,
0.0370435044,
0.0163418222,
0.020726312,
0.0489656106,
0.0530202314,
0.0000023616,
0.0187043678,
0.0219231062,
-0.031044336,
0.0620910935,
0.0073683071,
-0.0020106873,
-0.060703896,
-0.0147595499,
0.0212980639,
-0.024451619,
-0.0178676806,
-0.0163837411,
0.0276964717,
-0.021064898,
0.0347966067,
-0.0335071683,
-0.0395220295,
0.0137234423,
-0.0562546924,
0.0746172294,
-0.0140254246,
0.0757723376,
-0.061787352,
-0.0378350206,
-0.0245630424,
0.0474930853,
0.0096684219,
0.0059347684,
0.021661805,
0.0263339672,
-0.0190944672,
-0.0152193494,
0.0670349002,
-0.0295240115,
0.0388728715,
0.0095707476,
0.0734744817,
-0.0461402275,
-0.0168493614,
-0.047322344,
0.0089145796,
0.0061026178,
0.0352423824,
0.0126643581,
-0.0649338961,
-0.0007274617,
0.0281470362,
0.0404741094,
0.0289621875,
-0.0233087186,
0.009558294,
0.0422969125,
-0.0547055453,
-0.0142574599,
-0.0294909291,
-0.0253109969,
0.0563474223,
0.0008373956,
-0.0135216471,
0.0057603251,
0.0097370697,
-0.0528493971,
-0.0002844576,
0.0609880686,
0.0356174745,
-0.0342684761,
-0.028818395,
0.0266733337,
-0.0394696668,
-0.0010120663,
-0.0715502575,
-0.0034498789,
-0.0439443178,
0.0276195724,
-0.0169087537,
0.0033675092,
0.0365743451,
-0.0002102878,
-0.0504655316,
0.0223506223,
0.0147074219,
-0.0341214277,
0.0360766612,
0.0645101741,
0.0117835365,
-0.0395327881,
0.01372643,
-0.0071860463,
0.0728498921,
-0.0243728273,
-0.0304612014,
-0.021617813,
-0.0592909642,
-0.0262361821,
0.0380395949,
0.0233615879,
0.0132007906,
-0.0220287349,
-0.0143101448,
-0.0145247858,
0.0387032628,
0.0229333434,
-0.0278893672,
-0.0143542951,
-0.0001159059,
0.055083055,
-0.03222638,
-0.0566638559,
0.0315240733,
-0.0664548948,
0.0192741752,
0.1103109941,
-0.0055630859,
-0.0095855594,
-0.0073844879,
0.0612132214,
0.0176064577,
0.0150107425,
0.0170388892,
-0.0235804766,
0.0203348864,
0.0293147117,
-0.0150567796,
-0.0171357766,
0.0223623458,
0.0555432253,
0.0219405796,
0.0446050614,
-0.0159599409,
-0.0247317106,
0.0262932908,
-0.033286415,
0.0075763222,
-0.0052173883,
0.0371584259,
-0.0426062234,
0.0066034556,
-0.0502123758,
0.0202727076,
0.0413463712,
-0.0140578412,
-0.0414445139,
-0.0033891071,
0.0157767385,
-0.0518542752,
0.0020627624,
-0.0143376049,
0.0051185274,
-0.0565365106,
0.0562271364,
0.0419446379,
-0.0519502424,
-0.0174782034,
0.0385245048,
-0.027553428,
-0.0321577564,
0.0611288883,
-0.0637980029,
0.0152572272,
-0.0492352508,
0.0151033979,
0.0169178154,
-0.0406978279,
0.0887087733,
-0.0181398373,
-0.0275887456,
-0.048807472,
-0.0247565825,
0.0021098682,
-5.453240986e-33,
0.0391886234,
0.000351187,
-0.0729168206,
0.030217167,
-0.0242508668,
0.0094195642,
0.0211371668,
0.0365430042,
-0.0035625994,
0.0308397189,
-0.0344394743,
0.023262389,
0.0037221676,
-0.0319033749,
-0.0007973508,
-0.0211142469,
0.0262172241,
-0.0548417866,
-0.0018729478,
-0.0190756116,
0.0294626113,
0.0604114495,
0.0505555496,
-0.1207581833,
-0.0360284075,
0.0228895098,
-0.0267473869,
-0.0401611626,
0.0328558572,
0.015594081,
0.0062402003,
0.0654136166,
-0.0067232056,
0.0300811566,
-0.0116749471,
-0.0131355198,
-0.0098863887,
0.0036411011,
-0.0348313712,
0.0645253137,
-0.0114324549,
-0.0073331119,
0.0289057903,
0.0349015743,
-0.0641181841,
-0.0135590965,
0.0378520042,
-0.0124597903,
0.0126105584,
-0.1020956859,
0.057572227,
0.0191656239,
-0.0255666319,
-0.0482750162,
0.0618740842,
0.0637622029,
-0.0311189052,
-0.0062073949,
-0.0035647713,
0.020195581,
-0.0261028893,
-0.0200836845,
0.0098135211,
-0.0171965174,
0.0279893856,
0.0594271682,
0.0629963204,
-0.032056354,
0.0036219403,
0.0219424702,
0.04550891,
0.0876149982,
0.0109361,
-0.001344527,
-0.0065890993,
-0.0571841002,
0.0325948559,
0.0562113859,
0.088463895,
-0.0067902524,
0.0168191642,
0.0289811175,
-0.042591013,
0.0138310427,
0.0188839883,
-0.0349666812,
-0.004745374,
0.0072166277,
0.0183217973,
-0.0318806022,
-0.0050956011,
-0.0562471934,
-0.0024659538,
-0.0392326154,
0.0393638611,
0.0458062887,
-0.0185570233,
0.0613655671,
0.0569560602,
-0.0060673342,
0.0207647663,
0.0146319978,
0.0685225353,
0.0102143306,
0.0717148781,
-0.0336634554,
-0.0564250164,
0.071483016,
-0.0108524663,
-0.0092491508,
0.0429792106,
0.0060938145,
0.0043447153,
0.0183620639,
-0.0278349575,
-0.0005357695,
-0.0171465781,
-0.0363516845,
-0.0224497374,
0.0453388505,
-0.0188755542,
-0.0054202788,
0.0038124046,
0.0310215093,
-0.0277998094,
0.0028831963,
-0.0051976196,
-0.0441981331,
0.0215470083,
0.0083260899,
0.0167239513,
-0.0183055922,
3.02e-7,
-0.0643616393,
-0.0196340419,
0.0254571289,
-0.046257589,
0.0487455018,
0.0679942891,
-0.058611691,
-0.0117156664,
0.0157504976,
-0.0116840191,
0.0622794554,
-0.0710198432,
0.0676908568,
0.0090740491,
-0.0946187079,
-0.0173393916,
-0.0083714044,
0.0205340423,
-0.0087081203,
0.0437938608,
0.0578115471,
0.0730663911,
0.0383507907,
-0.0269401167,
0.0041645542,
0.0439545102,
-0.0240360703,
-0.0520530343,
0.017282268,
-0.02881396,
-0.0006202417,
-0.0298023131,
-0.0131710339,
0.0113236802,
-0.0201069545,
0.0532542951,
0.0257808454,
0.0529847182,
0.0265750438,
-0.0382075571,
0.0472968705,
0.0625460446,
-0.0411654487,
0.0527871922,
0.0246050507,
0.0209170338,
-0.0481164232,
-0.0647714287,
-0.0309843849,
0.0052200872,
0.0100511415,
-0.0051880553,
0.0184471682,
0.0078030606,
-0.0164565053,
-0.0859251246,
-0.0159597266,
-0.0507808253,
-0.0084638651,
0.0290893298,
-0.0723440647,
-0.01737497,
0.0037578114,
0.0458226129,
0.081784755,
0.0310337096,
-0.0133788651,
1.995598877e-34,
0.0016182568,
-0.0376508273,
-0.0243086051,
0.0568650328,
-0.0105203129,
-0.0057926062,
-0.0255913679,
-0.0086416341,
0.0131050041,
-0.0322484449,
-0.007547671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10513v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10513v3 | Why Does ChatGPT Fall Short in Providing Truthful Answers? | 2023-04-20T17:48:43 | 2023-12-03T23:01:19 | Shen Zheng, Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models, such as ChatGPT, have
demonstrated significant potential to impact various aspects of human life.
However, ChatGPT still faces challenges in providing reliable and accurate
answers to user questions. To better understand the model's particular
weaknesses in providing truthful answers, we embark an in-depth exploration of
open-domain question answering. Specifically, we undertake a detailed
examination of ChatGPT's failures, categorized into: comprehension, factuality,
specificity, and inference. We further pinpoint factuality as the most
contributing failure and identify two critical abilities associated with
factuality: knowledge memorization and knowledge recall. Through experiments
focusing on factuality, we propose several potential enhancement strategies.
Our findings suggest that augmenting the model with granular external knowledge
and cues for knowledge recall can enhance the model's factuality in answering
questions. | [
0.0822224766,
0.0163706187,
-0.0261226427,
0.0097846314,
-0.0300917383,
-0.014566198,
-0.0238929279,
-0.002317874,
0.0180667434,
-0.0296911616,
-0.0024087105,
-0.0165455192,
-0.0151073467,
0.0263992324,
0.0027261584,
-0.0284193624,
0.0788924024,
-0.0215552077,
0.0274998639,
-0.0344926678,
0.0135909449,
0.012517225,
-0.0149171464,
0.0206924248,
-0.0336626098,
-0.024988113,
-0.0049493569,
-0.0156855937,
-0.0141683994,
0.0023636247,
0.0275727902,
0.0464537814,
-0.0057801045,
0.0334216207,
0.0000018676,
-0.0433392227,
0.0229421835,
-0.0136245713,
-0.0774196461,
0.0312066991,
-0.0213662442,
0.0510223545,
0.0291920956,
0.0298827477,
-0.0434776172,
0.0060094981,
0.0273624063,
0.0699812099,
0.072141014,
0.0496896803,
0.0138718942,
0.0186548196,
0.0126496926,
0.0148184849,
0.0444514453,
-0.0177054442,
0.0133001311,
0.0544240028,
0.0028978225,
0.0237958208,
-0.008927172,
0.0315427259,
0.0196976457,
0.0133408792,
0.029624356,
0.060137447,
-0.0462566651,
-0.0207136516,
0.0068994011,
0.0331765786,
0.0532927997,
-0.040252611,
-0.0127577307,
0.0135668851,
0.0031238913,
0.0070845052,
-0.06099765,
-0.0011278243,
-0.0457952246,
-0.0215940252,
-0.0241027176,
0.0061330856,
0.0037264279,
0.0093920315,
0.0560167693,
0.065557614,
-0.0053628408,
-0.0421742499,
-0.0182778221,
-0.003609678,
-0.0168863721,
-0.0688603595,
-0.0013059154,
0.0404323675,
-0.0117337322,
0.0305002499,
-0.0051675495,
0.0447791629,
0.0662252381,
-0.084968254,
-0.0218885355,
0.0545332059,
-0.0032966067,
0.0338698849,
-0.0256834272,
0.0538658202,
0.0184583925,
0.0193369836,
-0.050210692,
-0.0154344514,
-0.0383478478,
-0.0556654111,
-0.0478846505,
0.0272211358,
0.0102044521,
-0.0016071266,
-0.0177322235,
0.0035059347,
0.0084396778,
-0.0065731388,
-0.0185812078,
0.0487539545,
-0.0312977508,
-0.0051779361,
-0.0928001553,
0.0391084775,
-0.0652602613,
0.0161642116,
0.0207968261,
-0.088592872,
-0.0215819385,
-0.0043589692,
-0.0276623964,
-0.010708347,
0.0035578164,
0.0218574386,
-0.0187961012,
0.0113722105,
-0.0251411498,
-0.0328931026,
-0.0271968972,
-0.0703563914,
0.0024810897,
-0.0535916984,
0.0345705152,
0.0230310988,
-0.0278834719,
-0.004000356,
0.0319921598,
0.0483713262,
-0.0354732014,
0.0356667824,
-0.007062648,
0.0156471711,
0.040933691,
0.0297668893,
-0.0375649557,
0.0420814343,
0.0036821242,
0.0243172795,
0.0368690416,
-0.0033151901,
0.0180374235,
-0.0157833602,
0.0329112634,
-0.0045568277,
0.0628162846,
0.0406183265,
0.0159404762,
0.0297987759,
0.0356632136,
0.0446150638,
-0.0257302858,
-0.0397577286,
0.098592408,
0.0318437964,
-0.0141831832,
0.0378103331,
-0.0005674759,
0.0039374125,
0.0583377182,
0.0334700048,
-0.0528420098,
0.043195989,
-0.0363975614,
0.0370518193,
0.0044499612,
0.0555083491,
-0.04371709,
-0.03075324,
-0.0214672033,
0.0207251105,
0.0131626716,
0.0365226753,
-0.0003660481,
-0.0084757106,
-0.0138103627,
0.070259802,
0.0435401723,
-0.0314507298,
0.0108586783,
-0.085717231,
0.055009082,
0.0330842361,
0.0373267755,
0.0100465873,
-0.0568711311,
-0.000294854,
0.0077638864,
0.0324266218,
0.0836205706,
0.0016658269,
-0.0023715792,
-0.0082575167,
0.0129101966,
-0.0212164,
0.0109758684,
0.0180681143,
0.0452907346,
0.0007977733,
-0.0033202383,
-0.0380635224,
0.028009044,
0.0085514039,
-0.0188819282,
-0.0116494671,
-0.0267560557,
-0.0386997461,
-0.0020443599,
-0.0095254071,
-0.0046881167,
0.0303856544,
0.0007767547,
0.0370023623,
-0.0633221567,
0.0023603518,
-0.0635638684,
-0.0367630757,
0.0243773479,
-0.0048122522,
-0.0281707179,
0.0211010352,
-0.0074318224,
-0.0260859188,
-0.0167709608,
-0.0621310957,
0.0492755286,
-0.0670225844,
-0.0332207307,
0.0185942352,
-0.0074622575,
-0.034410581,
0.0674132109,
-0.0003418772,
0.0054089902,
-0.0179864988,
-0.0305245444,
0.010574243,
-0.0535167195,
0.0034811997,
-0.0073677483,
-0.0022616922,
0.0465275496,
0.0398037434,
-0.0039277729,
-0.0871402398,
-0.008861877,
-0.1045865268,
0.0151974624,
0.0047488124,
0.0042489828,
0.0283576418,
-0.0033193615,
-0.0125067467,
-0.0141330045,
-0.0836236179,
0.0185503084,
0.0202200729,
0.0179810449,
0.0221194588,
-0.0091861486,
0.0270963442,
-0.0219098572,
0.0129648456,
-0.0157128926,
-0.0164997336,
0.0067001944,
0.0024245447,
-0.0136152543,
0.0091961231,
-0.0888594687,
0.023741845,
-0.0033369181,
-0.0460411608,
0.0048380555,
0.0543587878,
0.0232903324,
0.0494090915,
0.050458014,
-0.0173048265,
-0.0001335291,
0.001385132,
-0.0395469926,
0.0326853767,
-0.0446547382,
-0.0446337797,
0.0113587314,
-0.0425304919,
-0.0097410353,
0.0278681871,
0.047766611,
0.0070970193,
-0.0607122779,
0.0091585182,
-0.0354406089,
-0.039247632,
-0.0497214794,
0.0000640478,
-0.0404533744,
0.0476745926,
-0.027408231,
-0.014484358,
0.0712269247,
-0.0277242996,
-0.0086590303,
-0.0307599716,
0.0045278496,
-0.0103800744,
0.039201688,
-0.0069562215,
0.0240264721,
0.0384866595,
-0.0006808611,
-0.0331579559,
-0.0279956255,
0.0566194393,
-0.0599698648,
0.0349980406,
-0.0322347619,
0.0121630346,
0.0209921598,
-0.0472890176,
-0.0832895562,
-0.0549474545,
-0.006954697,
0.0068903416,
-0.0388916843,
0.0110622626,
-0.0295743775,
-0.0069862599,
0.0556298122,
-0.0055943425,
-0.0413413271,
-0.0176359601,
0.0006653407,
0.030396238,
0.0815857574,
0.0621559881,
0.0473485775,
-0.0013427484,
0.0178346839,
0.1082822308,
-0.0019998245,
-0.0014991447,
0.0085085025,
-0.0245712884,
-0.0008521231,
-0.0114737023,
-0.016576631,
0.0151653998,
0.0663817599,
-0.0273775309,
-0.0491858125,
0.1060438976,
0.0327289775,
0.0277364813,
-0.0017284751,
-0.0464246497,
0.0409625918,
0.0049171066,
0.0456975549,
-0.0792621672,
-0.0187285431,
-0.0049762116,
-0.0018858612,
-0.0331638157,
-0.0067818244,
-0.024353249,
-0.0999327973,
0.0188188963,
-0.0091664568,
-0.0219197832,
-0.0193660725,
-0.0323732309,
0.0003715605,
0.006667729,
0.0494353324,
0.0189845022,
0.0068677897,
0.0081662945,
0.0290925838,
-0.0517362542,
0.0130302124,
0.0838796943,
-0.015585335,
0.0662362128,
0.0555686131,
0.0281377137,
-0.0077727349,
-0.0286090411,
-0.0014656248,
0.0026514996,
0.0212523844,
-0.0121755879,
0.0449223518,
0.0039813234,
0.0301693156,
-0.055395294,
0.010314526,
-0.0024150936,
-0.017490834,
0.0260604508,
0.0727611333,
-0.01809722,
-0.0122800255,
-0.011429986,
0.0445510894,
-0.009479736,
0.0914667845,
0.0223444346,
-0.0124166897,
-0.0232153237,
-0.0431371629,
-0.0214630868,
-0.0058673676,
-0.0623943061,
0.0151467817,
0.0240052324,
-0.0083060432,
-0.0659192801,
-0.0517056249,
0.0222978536,
-0.0117475688,
-0.0494866483,
-0.0077811265,
0.0108856475,
0.0150503656,
0.0125168851,
0.0227503479,
-0.0678872094,
0.0046525495,
-0.0101835597,
-0.0154164974,
0.0184753593,
-0.0616889112,
-0.0062801731,
0.0029940477,
-0.0709057823,
-0.0175182056,
0.0274672452,
0.0495374054,
0.0293003749,
-0.0056750099,
-0.0281810667,
-0.0173025057,
0.0090036131,
0.0143195083,
-0.0746967643,
0.0218548197,
0.0402113609,
0.0468466394,
0.0040384075,
0.0319585688,
-0.0230636578,
0.0008357393,
0.0048969192,
0.0269768704,
-0.0128034204,
-0.0442627929,
0.0674190372,
0.0378867052,
0.0299249738,
0.047965385,
0.0117221754,
-0.0168448593,
-0.0003758956,
-0.0132970139,
-0.0015672827,
0.0018636081,
-0.0134841604,
-0.0040118224,
-0.0046041673,
0.0075659109,
-0.0580038503,
-0.0588196069,
0.0214363672,
-0.0322605185,
-0.0555893555,
0.0212383009,
-0.0208384302,
0.0013097996,
0.0129964063,
-0.0722364187,
0.003090953,
-0.0033776639,
0.058259692,
0.0039638518,
0.0782331005,
0.0037912619,
-0.0199733861,
0.0053660879,
-0.0211321786,
-0.1023207456,
-0.0502226464,
0.007470293,
0.074964948,
0.0287117194,
0.0169226024,
0.0118749915,
-0.0485898778,
-0.0069898539,
-0.0146630099,
-0.0261725932,
0.0362690948,
-0.0185277686,
0.0427489877,
0.0027679333,
-0.0184372198,
-0.017663531,
0.0812231153,
-0.0376376212,
0.0502156019,
0.0166703183,
-0.0165256094,
-0.0107543794,
-0.0392246172,
-0.0135856625,
0.0077697234,
-0.0022450227,
0.013193123,
-0.0816488564,
-0.0458468758,
-0.0210063383,
0.0188130271,
0.0023564056,
-0.0393114239,
0.0414433032,
0.0563944392,
0.0074815974,
-0.0646701679,
-0.050048627,
0.0424861647,
-0.0231585111,
0.0372796021,
-0.0378406458,
-6.548968494e-33,
-0.0159057099,
-0.0185578521,
0.0311843324,
0.0113120219,
-0.0101490673,
0.0164847337,
-0.016198067,
0.0294087864,
-0.0754885152,
0.0146540562,
-0.0441545509,
0.0148321912,
0.0128543675,
0.0161655527,
-0.0048447843,
-0.0560267754,
0.0218078103,
-0.0051699271,
-0.0398171358,
0.0391391851,
0.0241508875,
-0.0087635014,
0.0473769791,
-0.0159577932,
0.0456021503,
-0.0116714435,
-0.0020282946,
0.0370320715,
-0.0636759624,
0.0617831796,
-0.0276370607,
0.0802324191,
0.0252152774,
-0.0414180942,
-0.0047141672,
0.001760154,
-0.0519019179,
-0.0663138777,
0.0806457251,
-0.0190842468,
-0.0472366698,
0.013765512,
-0.0117015075,
-0.0280020945,
0.0014902498,
-0.0526546352,
0.013915102,
-0.0004186472,
-0.0190670174,
-0.0117415274,
-0.0372435227,
-0.0030137275,
0.0291620344,
-0.0406827144,
-0.0830695406,
0.0475452878,
-0.0230458304,
-0.0355941951,
-0.0391095243,
0.0028719793,
0.0116957994,
0.0128319636,
0.0543586127,
-0.0069008661,
0.0049330746,
0.0647637919,
-0.0033892177,
0.0259255022,
-0.0619183183,
-0.0172954146,
-0.0048756697,
-0.0043802755,
0.0801134929,
0.0704997331,
0.0098289503,
-0.0079254359,
-0.0300035309,
0.0133703398,
0.0572377928,
0.0330579393,
0.0272947829,
0.0033402534,
-0.0426403135,
-0.0200821161,
-0.0477416404,
0.0785328448,
-0.0378993936,
-0.0413755327,
0.0170165338,
-0.0128113236,
-0.0155751938,
-0.0365185738,
0.0201463439,
-0.0388944261,
0.0520555936,
-0.00059374,
-0.0151986815,
-0.0066617606,
-0.0063359998,
0.0475952774,
-0.0573592223,
0.0491345078,
0.0042740288,
0.0030859516,
-0.0216156486,
0.0214191601,
0.0146761453,
-0.0099681811,
-0.0282854214,
0.0188336801,
-0.0452352203,
0.0447863899,
0.0091729015,
-0.0737822205,
0.0104317339,
0.0233737174,
-0.026628077,
0.0189965051,
0.0200520232,
-0.002561419,
-0.0664079264,
-0.0182930771,
-0.0151402457,
0.0003242298,
-0.0273528099,
0.0429697931,
-0.0540469587,
-0.00431184,
-0.037274804,
-0.0571454391,
-0.0113907419,
0.0165548827,
2.484e-7,
0.0180137828,
0.0247365069,
0.023638377,
0.0370971337,
0.0085696811,
0.0420719907,
0.0123458905,
0.0243310537,
0.051897075,
-0.0507677235,
-0.0132575091,
0.0405368656,
0.0444635302,
0.0415190607,
-0.0349218026,
-0.0161518902,
-0.0873006806,
-0.0379377529,
-0.0105972569,
-0.0071952008,
0.067755647,
0.0643992499,
0.0150103932,
-0.0042441199,
-0.0029707595,
-0.0484748706,
0.0605290793,
-0.0076839463,
-0.0520658977,
0.0077589871,
0.0579132847,
0.0040073032,
0.0355453938,
0.0371708274,
0.0059699179,
-0.0445440449,
-0.0082617095,
0.0373860374,
0.001616482,
-0.0535944104,
-0.0344322249,
-0.0300564114,
0.0198400114,
-0.0954030603,
0.0774448439,
-0.0474410169,
-0.0188087653,
-0.0375362635,
0.0091964118,
0.011344986,
0.0124537796,
-0.0150626432,
-0.0597351007,
0.0053630788,
0.0168410391,
0.0376625881,
0.0070699546,
-0.0309749264,
-0.0192535855,
0.0091898004,
-0.0537114181,
-0.09064091,
0.0076799071,
0.0014834955,
0.021067366,
-0.0407251529,
0.0112016136,
1.997046434e-34,
0.026672842,
0.0125069814,
0.025698876,
0.0044270623,
0.061759159,
0.0075185057,
0.0346766189,
-0.0029583201,
0.0413547643,
-0.0353600569,
-0.0295735039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10512v1 | "Can We Detect Substance Use Disorder?": Knowledge and Time Aware Classification on Social Media from Darkweb | 2023-04-20T17:47:13 | 2023-04-20T17:47:13 | Usha Lokala, Orchid Chetia Phukan, Triyasha Ghosh Dastidar, Francois Lamy, Raminta Daniulaityte, Amit Sheth | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | Opioid and substance misuse is rampant in the United States today, with the
phenomenon known as the "opioid crisis". The relationship between substance use
and mental health has been extensively studied, with one possible relationship
being: substance misuse causes poor mental health. However, the lack of
evidence on the relationship has resulted in opioids being largely inaccessible
through legal means. This study analyzes the substance use posts on social
media with opioids being sold through crypto market listings. We use the Drug
Abuse Ontology, state-of-the-art deep learning, and knowledge-aware BERT-based
models to generate sentiment and emotion for the social media posts to
understand users' perceptions on social media by investigating questions such
as: which synthetic opioids people are optimistic, neutral, or negative about?
or what kind of drugs induced fear and sorrow? or what kind of drugs people
love or are thankful about? or which drugs people think negatively about? or
which opioids cause little to no sentimental reaction. We discuss how we
crawled crypto market data and its use in extracting posts for fentanyl,
fentanyl analogs, and other novel synthetic opioids. We also perform topic
analysis associated with the generated sentiments and emotions to understand
which topics correlate with people's responses to various drugs. Additionally,
we analyze time-aware neural models built on these features while considering
historical sentiment and emotional activity of posts related to a drug. The
most effective model performs well (statistically significant) with
(macroF1=82.12, recall =83.58) to identify substance use disorder. | [
0.0265006851,
0.0997954309,
-0.0035611694,
-0.023860829,
-0.0265912171,
0.0036417367,
0.0024922411,
0.0051445207,
0.0289121475,
-0.0344831198,
0.0075324844,
0.0269707981,
-0.0654645041,
0.0709790215,
0.0046067117,
-0.0037814814,
0.0169900358,
0.0724849179,
0.0240641665,
0.0057848622,
0.0367917493,
0.0107513806,
0.0111000696,
-0.0016962114,
-0.0083566653,
-0.0483231433,
0.0106914425,
-0.0205918998,
0.0189920701,
-0.0532371588,
0.0457255431,
0.0644016564,
-0.0116943084,
0.0249855667,
0.0000017273,
-0.0094764661,
-0.0279709585,
-0.0093566244,
-0.0207091365,
-0.0466288477,
0.0711940676,
-0.0442072712,
0.0152938087,
0.0076646218,
-0.0919982865,
-0.0251447614,
0.0547843762,
0.092176415,
-0.0036005692,
0.0734608695,
-0.0435900763,
0.0014367467,
0.0274710432,
-0.0140094077,
0.0496640354,
0.0044020973,
0.0368609242,
-0.016510075,
0.0000504086,
-0.0098344879,
0.0278002489,
0.0336585231,
-0.0440524742,
0.0091445893,
0.0387905277,
-0.0009925668,
-0.0051582172,
-0.0472176336,
-0.0281703025,
0.0517864898,
-0.0126166977,
0.0125663383,
0.0224731732,
0.0180363413,
-0.0416254327,
0.0268705022,
-0.0259720813,
-0.0359856039,
-0.0151928077,
0.0446694121,
0.0122579951,
0.0301617719,
0.0438933969,
0.0399808884,
-0.0089764977,
0.0664476827,
-0.0289038718,
-0.0195764117,
0.0148006845,
-0.0377822593,
-0.0045575956,
-0.0184222981,
0.0430982932,
-0.0321683474,
-0.007681021,
0.02469345,
0.0117211388,
-0.034033522,
0.0400516763,
-0.1170020103,
-0.0415623635,
0.0090777418,
-0.0401560999,
0.0126224449,
0.0026459147,
-0.0136531861,
0.023068646,
-0.0015724987,
-0.0149520403,
0.0082564102,
-0.0779152289,
-0.0007870582,
-0.0059826607,
0.0362920687,
0.0208463166,
-0.024154488,
-0.0821634755,
0.020834269,
-0.0713218153,
-0.0399487689,
-0.0420270041,
0.0459266119,
0.01553619,
0.0504890271,
0.019079145,
0.0195649508,
-0.008677898,
0.018515544,
-0.0075269649,
0.0320505723,
0.0447451733,
0.0108909076,
0.0468133949,
-0.0287025869,
0.0056920447,
0.0613181144,
0.0402050093,
-0.0219137222,
-0.0550618954,
-0.0551579669,
-0.0119654331,
0.0229869969,
0.0362359993,
-0.0207397938,
0.0117559861,
-0.0246068891,
0.0016061579,
-0.0215188358,
-0.007324744,
-0.0226845853,
-0.084798649,
0.0679389909,
-0.0090147993,
-0.0039362996,
0.0350725949,
-0.0131737124,
0.0397711545,
0.0120923864,
-0.0057407245,
0.0607309416,
0.0322261341,
-0.021991102,
-0.010333959,
-0.0009977062,
0.0095723579,
-0.0916896462,
0.021053616,
-0.025528986,
-0.0253660418,
0.0126950135,
-0.0352318995,
0.0025288777,
-0.0058075143,
0.0148884524,
0.0329304636,
0.0481947586,
0.012775572,
0.0344009846,
-0.0041485485,
-0.0142598413,
-0.0382633433,
-0.0402518921,
-0.0664117336,
-0.0045928522,
-0.0106013007,
-0.0203900766,
0.0176469926,
-0.0282260925,
-0.0145538254,
-0.0276352875,
-0.0205751751,
-0.026738368,
-0.0036649751,
0.0037256032,
0.0146594159,
-0.0339940414,
-0.0478519648,
0.0428658947,
0.0432990976,
0.0116834193,
-0.0549079031,
-0.0271376856,
0.0393378399,
0.0845483691,
0.0005793815,
0.0014320593,
-0.029881591,
-0.0212859046,
-0.0057997988,
0.0250972304,
-0.0032065057,
-0.025541205,
-0.0365456641,
0.0212294552,
0.0259371884,
0.0121638421,
0.0163542759,
-0.0153516401,
-0.0170019846,
0.0490290746,
-0.0130387973,
-0.0047616861,
0.0258244984,
0.0109622842,
0.0335743912,
-0.0348261334,
-0.0156106297,
0.0419604629,
0.0488921851,
0.0170707162,
0.0223884862,
0.0146641331,
0.0391538776,
-0.0470381267,
-0.0749243572,
-0.0324580856,
0.0449466109,
0.0294806268,
0.0302283186,
-0.0498286001,
0.0587045141,
-0.0035358237,
-0.0444858782,
-0.0120767923,
0.0653918907,
-0.0074613472,
0.0490724966,
-0.0385539271,
-0.0349570364,
-0.003569734,
0.0297438949,
0.0000628529,
0.0432263464,
-0.0074392986,
-0.0069777463,
-0.0429946743,
-0.1045023426,
-0.0071707596,
0.0133986194,
0.0385578163,
-0.0209753904,
-0.0461126305,
0.014569914,
0.0310806353,
-0.0050311857,
-0.0139724128,
0.0121581713,
-0.0729748383,
-0.0203849915,
-0.012278894,
0.0397832319,
-0.0069678738,
0.0008944123,
0.0128612444,
-0.0348683037,
-0.0240825806,
-0.0289285313,
-0.0062113064,
0.0117624225,
0.0000552478,
0.0311182607,
0.0346609987,
-0.0233337358,
-0.027169371,
-0.0567214824,
0.0446604639,
-0.01850136,
-0.0423792377,
0.0411483981,
-0.0294877291,
-0.063318707,
0.005790215,
-0.0020776717,
-0.0008856868,
0.0223394185,
-0.0015951495,
0.0441214889,
0.029868016,
0.0182921812,
0.0715047345,
0.0193371736,
0.0169955269,
-0.0126132919,
0.0165770762,
-0.0599783137,
0.0034511166,
0.0197931919,
-0.0410081521,
-0.0069872499,
0.0865136236,
-0.0041858531,
0.0054606525,
-0.0350910872,
0.0066944482,
-0.0126705514,
-0.0171810444,
-0.0434398539,
-0.0091896383,
-0.0045000762,
-0.0129742483,
-0.0109712658,
-0.0749990791,
0.0343920402,
0.0709575936,
0.0338846631,
-0.0218423773,
-0.0331988931,
-0.0044421013,
-0.0353276171,
0.0376250409,
0.0342628732,
0.0110331727,
0.0129037676,
0.0697783604,
-0.0430058688,
-0.0155473715,
-0.0452018678,
0.0002636528,
-0.0276897717,
0.0138088539,
0.0157358963,
-0.0188849792,
-0.0135502471,
-0.0533781014,
-0.0424406677,
-0.0179078281,
0.0113080218,
-0.0257211793,
0.0080792615,
0.0266749561,
-0.0477485172,
-0.0258413535,
0.0083298599,
-0.0359212235,
0.018724449,
0.0477709733,
0.086739108,
-0.0849431455,
0.0377427153,
0.0213941596,
0.0341811217,
-0.0034398253,
0.0051934109,
0.0013807085,
-0.04793033,
0.0410186462,
-0.0090513052,
-0.0174321514,
-0.0150135839,
0.0181232803,
-0.0451559424,
0.035953287,
0.0339003466,
0.0837713778,
0.0523760058,
-0.0033333171,
0.0267611668,
-0.0020572268,
-0.0854303017,
-0.0287911668,
-0.0000112501,
-0.0846702531,
-0.0059826858,
-0.0632020459,
0.0101687871,
-0.0750416294,
-0.025378434,
-0.0058248593,
-0.0379830785,
0.036735937,
-0.0027367778,
-0.0340580121,
-0.0001683793,
-0.0447074436,
-0.0266657472,
-0.0408857316,
0.0215205234,
-0.0488779992,
-0.0045704413,
-0.0170771163,
0.0326032043,
-0.0429553352,
0.0008853255,
0.0313573554,
-0.0081019634,
0.0218785089,
0.0076903147,
0.0643734559,
-0.0246090349,
-0.0255013816,
-0.0377069339,
0.0543435104,
-0.0151989991,
0.0065462524,
0.0804831609,
-0.0393496267,
0.0068332357,
-0.0780120492,
0.0658771321,
-0.0736762509,
-0.0184125099,
-0.0768293664,
0.090099901,
-0.0425412022,
-0.0885562673,
-0.0530477166,
0.0109853679,
0.0286033079,
0.0310038179,
0.0148509964,
-0.0089967782,
-0.0353800058,
-0.0080634793,
0.0320205949,
-0.0530624986,
0.0058907396,
-0.0294935592,
0.0125719449,
-0.010695219,
-0.0485197082,
-0.0419802107,
-0.0274583884,
-0.058355663,
-0.0306675956,
-0.0249898266,
0.0364137143,
-0.0426313244,
-0.0570957661,
0.0550100766,
0.0675616786,
0.0213024653,
-0.0186718889,
-0.0331294723,
0.0399967022,
0.0269138664,
0.0053348583,
0.0472969748,
-0.0459242202,
0.0004544877,
0.0645105541,
-0.0230369885,
0.020243207,
-0.0299005229,
-0.0362596028,
-0.015424218,
0.0488518551,
0.0787310079,
-0.0216647554,
-0.0692949221,
0.0471477844,
0.0720591769,
-0.0010232169,
0.0252082217,
-0.0093830563,
0.00728354,
0.0026553229,
-0.0620921627,
-0.0639914647,
0.0247755051,
0.016715711,
-0.0196605623,
0.0458903909,
0.0180116892,
0.0073247296,
0.0023386839,
-0.0315661915,
0.0310552754,
0.0072468012,
0.026887171,
-0.0712741017,
0.0221510995,
-0.0401933417,
-0.0902086943,
0.0511771888,
-0.0322260112,
-0.0249335356,
-0.0519630983,
0.0228329692,
-0.0001051375,
0.0289301965,
0.0288851559,
0.0149754826,
0.0043365718,
0.0192310866,
-0.018553704,
0.035459891,
-0.0166570712,
0.0148252361,
-0.0286803972,
0.0056445347,
-0.014964425,
0.0584253445,
-0.0340017267,
-0.061441686,
-0.0030273837,
0.0172004774,
0.0535837375,
-0.0490704142,
0.0669217482,
-0.0359919667,
0.0038023458,
-0.0116474135,
0.067121841,
-0.0169517808,
-0.0112119978,
-0.0093172221,
0.0047984961,
-0.0325291306,
-0.0118829897,
0.0650931001,
-0.0128443241,
0.0321658663,
0.0204581935,
-0.0156157538,
-0.0237405375,
0.0282288119,
0.009910468,
0.0140082734,
-0.039781861,
0.0554749593,
-0.0437840186,
-0.0486703962,
0.0560734794,
-0.0397541672,
-0.0054323277,
0.0143437022,
0.0244801268,
0.0579192378,
-0.0008146496,
-0.0237326659,
-0.0116808349,
0.0318521224,
-0.017757548,
-0.0453954153,
-0.0805897713,
-5.379976831e-33,
0.046986863,
-0.0317936987,
-0.036684256,
-0.028662933,
-0.0060763252,
0.0039966237,
-0.0471232906,
0.0203898456,
0.0082258983,
0.031095013,
0.0074616061,
0.0326763466,
0.0099381246,
0.0124645056,
0.0420699231,
-0.0267622583,
0.0162617899,
0.0041617872,
0.050692115,
0.0403823294,
0.0475363508,
0.1024216264,
0.0265501048,
-0.0376369841,
0.0847846791,
0.0510726161,
0.0213955361,
0.0020041217,
0.0179095995,
0.0372567624,
-0.0516157039,
0.0514065325,
0.0274318755,
-0.0154017387,
0.0262736417,
0.0015168341,
-0.0380218104,
-0.0181684513,
-0.0132743232,
-0.0415969007,
-0.0333017819,
-0.0559425801,
0.0560250357,
0.0270907041,
0.0225200932,
0.0268613081,
0.081397675,
0.0120021962,
0.0023939342,
-0.0812252089,
-0.0231333487,
0.0151414592,
-0.0608166046,
0.0021791016,
-0.0240909774,
0.0421830788,
0.0147442818,
0.0441180915,
-0.0482810028,
0.0204655621,
-0.0124142915,
-0.0160997119,
-0.0030391102,
-0.0226256698,
0.0159584843,
0.0552158579,
-0.0226483606,
-0.003931467,
0.0323184803,
0.0537182651,
0.0067078206,
0.0749705583,
0.0235363822,
0.0057557877,
0.0506388471,
-0.0149596957,
-0.0380041823,
0.0022646578,
0.0092476225,
0.0214410331,
0.0271380562,
0.008613823,
-0.0270670392,
0.0113760466,
0.0243574828,
-0.0012363368,
-0.0226570424,
-0.0065910197,
-0.0376776904,
-0.0415141843,
-0.0143610463,
-0.0031221753,
-0.0137320412,
-0.0818851218,
-0.0255230665,
-0.0100926748,
0.0243086293,
0.0337329246,
0.0130927581,
0.0034616855,
-0.0353366509,
0.0486904532,
-0.0439927801,
-0.027899785,
0.0155077027,
-0.0025780036,
0.022579072,
-0.0071231155,
-0.0050973142,
-0.0043849163,
0.0254818145,
0.0065951329,
0.0220330618,
0.0563051067,
-0.02167047,
0.0448310599,
0.0177092869,
-0.0113930199,
0.0221087243,
0.0491127037,
0.0106940484,
-0.026440911,
-0.0123727685,
0.0391804837,
-0.0219909009,
-0.0187696777,
-0.0265205745,
0.020293178,
0.0174918678,
-0.0685197487,
0.0028176992,
-0.0341362134,
2.604e-7,
0.0644407347,
0.0264281873,
-0.0067170043,
0.020106446,
0.0210744515,
0.0184289422,
0.0148404548,
0.0447107516,
-0.0373857729,
-0.0482220165,
0.032054048,
0.0276202168,
0.027083151,
0.0387595296,
-0.0023961498,
-0.0258335285,
-0.0127726477,
-0.03340533,
-0.0647831857,
0.0385696031,
0.012742213,
0.068304196,
0.042236533,
-0.0209754985,
0.0173066873,
0.0066412422,
0.0251441803,
-0.0530157313,
-0.009067297,
0.0167133864,
0.0203217752,
-0.000625559,
-0.0303823873,
0.0138968155,
-0.009629678,
-0.0228819568,
-0.0279131271,
0.0127301048,
-0.0437820554,
-0.0653291419,
-0.0122006517,
-0.064173609,
0.0216961224,
0.002942553,
0.0697967336,
-0.0480600186,
-0.0541502163,
-0.0468199737,
-0.0157121103,
-0.0072729066,
0.0539809987,
-0.026986653,
-0.0575019121,
0.0334370174,
0.0358985215,
0.0149865272,
0.0144996149,
-0.0568344854,
0.0041386071,
0.05412459,
-0.04537642,
0.0036042619,
-0.0043452382,
0.0109409513,
0.0472320169,
-0.0586770065,
0.0139270704,
1.945039763e-34,
0.0115066925,
0.0270392746,
-0.0133592105,
0.0129712457,
0.0193907917,
0.0021534313,
-0.0148034785,
-0.0656484514,
0.0209116768,
-0.0660790652,
0.0175935291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10464v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10464v4 | Learning to Plan with Natural Language | 2023-04-20T17:09:12 | 2023-12-13T02:08:50 | Yiduo Guo, Yaobo Liang, Chenfei Wu, Wenshan Wu, Dongyan Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in various
basic natural language tasks. For completing the complex task, we still need a
plan for the task to guide LLMs to generate the specific solutions step by
step. LLMs can directly generate task plans, but these plans may still contain
factual errors or are incomplete. A high-quality task plan contains correct
step-by-step solutions for solving all situations and behavioral instructions
for avoiding mistakes. To obtain it, we propose the Learning to Plan method,
which involves two phases: (1) In the first learning task plan phase, it
iteratively updates the task plan with new step-by-step solutions and
behavioral instructions, which are obtained by prompting LLMs to derive from
training error feedback. (2) In the subsequent test phase, the LLM uses the
learned task plan to guide the inference of LLM on the test set. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method on the five different reasoning type tasks (8
datasets). Further, our analysis experiment shows that the task plan learned by
one LLM can directly guide another LLM to improve its performance, which
reveals a new transfer learning paradigm. We release the code at
\url{https://github.com/Eureka6174/LearnNLPlan} | [
0.0391060598,
0.0442326479,
0.0003067409,
0.0318178609,
-0.0543095693,
0.0071198037,
-0.0001235432,
-0.0322437994,
0.0297480077,
-0.0618007258,
-0.0084800841,
0.0019531758,
-0.0322443061,
0.0474756025,
0.009582893,
-0.0597130172,
0.0292457417,
-0.0429974385,
0.0112356236,
0.025392456,
-0.0373806767,
0.0211110823,
-0.0136518069,
0.0182386972,
-0.00501859,
0.0216104221,
-0.031057993,
-0.0011812883,
0.0283493102,
-0.0698908269,
0.0264317989,
0.0151186092,
0.050735984,
-0.0159502085,
0.0000019981,
-0.0599440299,
-0.0483972616,
-0.0276446976,
-0.0254369676,
-0.0552240163,
0.0041684308,
-0.0298850108,
0.023412751,
0.0582261421,
-0.0476301797,
0.0159072168,
0.007761226,
0.0971622914,
0.063142553,
0.1164185777,
-0.0064668143,
-0.0514191762,
-0.0043078591,
-0.0067910566,
0.0191748589,
-0.0642998964,
0.0520272963,
0.0373777486,
0.0180804022,
0.0304368492,
-0.0025992228,
-0.0061125513,
-0.0065084267,
-0.0177113712,
-0.0025816106,
0.0023536852,
-0.022418851,
-0.0168572962,
-0.0300059691,
0.0827027559,
-0.0366610177,
0.0019255744,
0.043648649,
-0.0088593587,
-0.0202971287,
0.0088488571,
-0.0451117121,
0.0113957636,
0.0188644044,
0.0361726284,
0.0155047653,
-0.0336488672,
0.0139233563,
-0.0148038873,
-0.0458058417,
0.0708614364,
-0.0119616743,
-0.0243163016,
0.0498942696,
0.0052591818,
-0.0013638067,
-0.062029399,
0.0127369259,
0.0801028758,
-0.0714089945,
0.0283641759,
-0.0296368115,
-0.0114837773,
-0.0148271127,
-0.0059116222,
0.0634737834,
0.0201790929,
0.0062406971,
0.0504082553,
-0.0522225909,
0.0569456257,
0.0073447214,
0.0291071013,
-0.053014487,
0.0070345164,
-0.0821669251,
0.0431142338,
-0.0279076062,
0.0463211387,
-0.0242911372,
-0.0359595492,
-0.0092035867,
0.0222665817,
0.0047656116,
0.0388748161,
0.0494543314,
0.001778519,
-0.019863395,
-0.0356553122,
-0.0804231614,
0.0103512015,
-0.0244637821,
0.0351380147,
-0.0293021966,
0.0015089875,
-0.0221396647,
0.0134813488,
0.0278370641,
-0.0174366664,
0.0278621297,
0.0698343366,
-0.0285352413,
-0.002438914,
-0.0741342977,
-0.0169197619,
0.0065929331,
-0.0716347098,
0.0443496816,
-0.0459316783,
0.0286682528,
-0.0286365077,
-0.0197471622,
-0.0110795936,
0.0307188351,
0.0262691434,
-0.0484471396,
0.0788340569,
0.0088223182,
0.0350051187,
-0.0053769764,
-0.0207418501,
-0.0591807589,
0.0557763204,
0.0319785923,
0.0214973222,
-0.0159594044,
0.0090344073,
-0.0007793611,
0.0143266674,
0.0136966677,
-0.0002800184,
0.0119823674,
0.0010023908,
0.0049708276,
0.0416539535,
0.0163496658,
0.011654296,
0.0099157915,
0.0228156671,
0.0231171846,
0.0402840301,
0.0099451784,
-0.0014718629,
0.026655525,
0.0236915611,
-0.016146455,
-0.0250246674,
-0.0609381646,
0.0261333603,
-0.0474452041,
-0.0292982198,
-0.0186754148,
0.000087867,
-0.0237528961,
-0.0228515901,
-0.0101766335,
-0.0155779822,
0.0192813054,
-0.0064676786,
0.0475186817,
0.0314755738,
-0.0904843509,
0.0217563305,
0.0108255362,
0.0181774199,
-0.0094252061,
-0.0304107014,
0.0806026608,
0.0450918227,
-0.0061495602,
-0.0430116951,
-0.0344519205,
-0.0125218183,
0.0188847352,
0.0024872285,
0.0150464606,
-0.0188636892,
-0.0118622277,
-0.0476919897,
-0.0537754707,
-0.042776186,
0.0005325403,
-0.016577363,
0.0334484167,
0.0040091178,
0.0072072898,
-0.0167324673,
0.0030784931,
0.0484990254,
-0.0356510617,
-0.0322915427,
0.0091628637,
-0.0073104771,
0.0393396169,
-0.0390826575,
0.0123488531,
0.003190496,
0.02661293,
-0.0319619812,
-0.0310140923,
-0.0192141775,
-0.0221216064,
-0.0663411543,
0.0337551609,
-0.0290366262,
-0.0115061831,
0.0358725786,
-0.0722431317,
-0.045753371,
0.0039513302,
-0.0007623299,
-0.0140616139,
0.0121810697,
0.0094953049,
0.058867909,
-0.0319287106,
-0.0275040939,
0.0637009665,
0.0232896134,
-0.0395819619,
-0.0008626273,
-0.0138498433,
-0.0338788778,
-0.0263145305,
0.0236423314,
0.0049461243,
-0.0178884827,
-0.0150081636,
0.003645686,
0.0694226846,
-0.0597160868,
-0.023025794,
-0.0651174188,
0.0197860189,
-0.0116404807,
0.0189634617,
-0.0001069724,
-0.0310007427,
0.0009428793,
-0.0178867728,
-0.0479685143,
0.0410861522,
0.0072681298,
-0.0365505703,
0.0348536633,
-0.0113500021,
-0.0142242359,
-0.0435954966,
0.0136773949,
-0.0215829425,
-0.0106705111,
0.0070795957,
-0.0427837372,
-0.0778486729,
0.0749840215,
0.0094473753,
0.0164649002,
-0.0025419826,
0.0220601056,
-0.0247766394,
-0.0455482081,
-0.0010068313,
0.0531092882,
-0.0133917853,
0.0134307034,
0.035989888,
-0.0198594313,
-0.0547899082,
0.0528794415,
-0.0451216139,
-0.0350574031,
-0.056185469,
-0.0384449847,
0.0005509401,
0.0487610027,
-0.0107768169,
0.0100783817,
-0.042660512,
-0.0014396133,
0.0270153377,
0.0074394201,
0.0082055358,
0.021483466,
0.0224914998,
0.0149203409,
0.0117371697,
-0.012004382,
0.0219110213,
0.0021459057,
0.009818064,
-0.0680069476,
-0.0043682549,
-0.0474340953,
0.0720277801,
0.0149109839,
0.0027294622,
0.0217976905,
-0.0099250972,
-0.0447326973,
-0.0319740176,
-0.0244824942,
-0.0038884124,
0.0661411211,
-0.0802469477,
0.0217539966,
-0.0225756988,
-0.033460144,
-0.0692157373,
-0.0219969209,
-0.0508976318,
0.0307836831,
-0.0148571702,
-0.0277788565,
-0.0562736169,
-0.0491527766,
0.021522155,
0.0366411731,
0.0062440564,
-0.0284219515,
-0.0285258405,
-0.0104281064,
0.0471135415,
0.0780838951,
0.0183467064,
-0.0027740477,
-0.0007794642,
0.0350215472,
0.0297257937,
0.0345773958,
-0.0349138901,
0.0336087011,
0.018413173,
-0.0106092542,
0.0075327819,
0.0553083494,
0.0629338995,
-0.0463182405,
-0.0269208178,
0.0961466357,
0.0023820002,
0.0089116516,
0.0024905878,
-0.0249286741,
0.0001733977,
0.0418246761,
0.0602287464,
-0.037878111,
-0.0617177002,
0.0139035005,
-0.0040573096,
0.0197647959,
-0.0537856258,
-0.0115657486,
-0.1398789883,
0.0439160764,
-0.0033260908,
-0.029511163,
-0.0133048939,
-0.0730031952,
0.0086364448,
-0.0224040914,
0.0072830268,
-0.0180370081,
-0.0273807868,
-0.0120062921,
0.0239067301,
-0.0260936115,
-0.0215770695,
0.0293036737,
-0.0156375878,
0.05350402,
0.0717065483,
0.0465160012,
-0.008646368,
-0.0044140364,
0.0236273259,
0.0577139594,
-0.0000353509,
-0.0297200289,
0.0440979227,
0.000455922,
-0.006814694,
0.0134947468,
0.0756464005,
-0.0758765861,
-0.0344370194,
0.0671978593,
0.103057079,
0.0045676907,
-0.0463639349,
0.0015378157,
0.0087462068,
0.0312817544,
0.0811541006,
-0.0212469175,
-0.0069220504,
-0.05970788,
0.0016694197,
-0.0502834246,
-0.0689717084,
-0.0209361669,
0.02249467,
-0.0426602475,
0.058967106,
-0.0699054003,
-0.0007494928,
0.0888468474,
0.047681421,
0.0494174957,
-0.0149104316,
0.0401901081,
0.0077201072,
-0.004493739,
0.0143068088,
-0.0542397238,
0.0337503701,
-0.0255080648,
-0.0220705774,
-0.0095448308,
-0.0101168621,
-0.0077764411,
-0.0025500769,
-0.0735142678,
-0.0422964208,
-0.0502070822,
0.0640517995,
0.0082037738,
0.0422893837,
0.0162090529,
-0.0149425436,
0.0302937143,
-0.0149958143,
-0.020374978,
0.0017769341,
0.0371339023,
0.0505941547,
-0.0006097515,
0.0483166128,
-0.0273821075,
0.0262585245,
0.0128245838,
0.0618797727,
-0.0293029696,
0.0028478606,
0.0194432121,
0.0300358851,
0.0233712494,
0.0062026298,
-0.0211039241,
-0.022015024,
0.0263268426,
-0.0192597657,
-0.0256788693,
-0.0673161745,
0.0470453203,
0.026394343,
-0.0065619284,
0.0244705267,
-0.012333164,
0.0029664587,
0.0059069209,
0.0064950297,
0.0011321942,
0.0284018386,
0.0037753386,
0.0300411768,
-0.015599764,
-0.0113030188,
-0.0143203363,
0.0482900739,
0.0382612757,
0.0061059832,
0.0279046204,
0.0379035361,
0.0160341226,
-0.0606995635,
-0.0706314072,
-0.0195503794,
-0.0993985087,
0.0132812252,
0.0099649141,
0.0260589309,
-0.0140649043,
0.0400241278,
-0.0430051088,
0.0119598182,
-0.0105638495,
0.0297975894,
-0.0282985307,
0.0181244686,
0.062559016,
0.0118628498,
-0.0083262492,
-0.0238463692,
0.0422148854,
0.0165543649,
0.0582021736,
-0.0120350271,
-0.0110187167,
-0.0421950445,
-0.0238963757,
0.030171711,
-0.0074397442,
0.0036569117,
0.0141648427,
0.0052421414,
-0.0459211655,
0.0157092009,
-0.0400440618,
-0.0036078345,
-0.0013067226,
0.0346092731,
0.0287667792,
0.0140520185,
-0.0450016893,
-0.0237061568,
-0.0153080514,
0.015525504,
-0.0408443958,
-0.0152391791,
-6.139024023e-33,
-0.0103023341,
-0.0456180796,
0.0630855262,
-0.0374347717,
0.008179103,
-0.024849778,
-0.0544448234,
-0.0132962484,
-0.0254603568,
0.0337370299,
-0.0206233971,
-0.0035519032,
0.0253384579,
0.0306704864,
0.0254562665,
-0.028641602,
0.0364204571,
-0.0083812689,
-0.0109669743,
0.0181612782,
0.0484517775,
0.015875943,
0.0382160284,
-0.0625381619,
-0.0375441499,
0.0613470785,
-0.011298134,
0.0544877909,
-0.0062514367,
0.0279867481,
0.0031182575,
-0.0315493681,
0.0260757543,
-0.0249113329,
-0.0331904218,
0.0467202663,
-0.0418920815,
-0.0607385933,
0.0204164945,
-0.0065541305,
-0.0559945889,
-0.0104191201,
0.0104634939,
-0.0119222719,
0.0074134744,
-0.0348981135,
0.037497215,
-0.0195771083,
-0.0142959878,
0.0361697599,
-0.0667127073,
0.0089134118,
-0.0078393519,
-0.0320296586,
0.0374412276,
0.0427023694,
-0.0019037286,
-0.027015226,
-0.0126690995,
-0.0017525343,
-0.0350421779,
0.0226993617,
0.0355442464,
0.0238851234,
-0.0311682373,
0.063128978,
0.0094409566,
-0.0094413497,
-0.040717151,
-0.0130918771,
-0.0031357491,
0.1241998747,
-0.0055851559,
-0.0040910575,
0.0066603096,
0.0238189176,
-0.0837894529,
0.025454944,
-0.0111834332,
0.0864885971,
0.026492428,
0.0095152538,
-0.0122299548,
-0.0025998496,
-0.0443884246,
0.02542473,
-0.008953766,
0.0042536533,
0.0448845699,
0.0433534831,
0.0086333351,
-0.0025234588,
0.0448556356,
-0.0466659032,
-0.0189757068,
0.0216749217,
-0.0279266611,
-0.0040241429,
-0.0269602444,
0.0207331274,
-0.0975159109,
-0.0809283108,
0.0122614242,
-0.0200526398,
0.0295960773,
0.002499793,
0.0333390906,
0.0283422358,
-0.0645928904,
-0.0264163017,
-0.0497171171,
0.0094113089,
0.0005551748,
0.0279991738,
0.0404169895,
0.0090611493,
-0.0128609138,
0.0137916952,
0.0175624471,
-0.0775282457,
-0.0005821499,
0.0002698274,
0.0165739916,
-0.0185140949,
-0.0202866793,
0.0010909394,
-0.0251775663,
-0.0082730735,
0.0110563561,
-0.0425384231,
-0.016235074,
0.0349970907,
2.81e-7,
0.0213848185,
0.0480672941,
-0.0182798952,
0.0350464769,
-0.0134112602,
0.0519249551,
-0.0323098414,
0.0441115759,
0.0006285275,
-0.020743452,
0.0241067931,
0.0419793949,
0.0406787246,
0.0404795296,
-0.0705500171,
-0.009987616,
-0.0053675668,
-0.02869411,
-0.0565342866,
-0.0217729844,
0.0870257467,
0.0711981505,
0.0391262844,
-0.0297910664,
0.0135035207,
-0.0338887498,
0.0386853218,
-0.0143084107,
0.0041860663,
0.016709704,
0.0043391865,
0.000369761,
-0.0259680599,
0.0443205684,
-0.0158709418,
0.0469303913,
-0.0075057861,
0.0989959762,
0.0198040232,
-0.0131464815,
-0.0228452869,
0.0014665504,
0.0348964818,
-0.0026934058,
0.0803172588,
-0.0643817335,
-0.0262183789,
-0.0112284813,
0.0379306264,
-0.0183001477,
-0.0203543026,
0.0034798882,
0.0305563193,
0.0088447277,
0.0353170298,
0.0073864516,
-0.0411575474,
-0.0844015256,
0.0171022248,
0.0580881536,
-0.0591259748,
-0.0100596109,
-0.025450673,
0.0260584876,
0.0065935738,
-0.0435351208,
0.0211436488,
2.564306488e-34,
-0.0268084966,
-0.0115679773,
-0.0007537857,
0.032696411,
0.0329643004,
0.0086741988,
-0.0362512022,
0.0358035155,
0.0129030943,
-0.0989849791,
-0.0131526422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10453v1 | Phoenix: Democratizing ChatGPT across Languages | 2023-04-20T16:50:04 | 2023-04-20T16:50:04 | Zhihong Chen, Feng Jiang, Junying Chen, Tiannan Wang, Fei Yu, Guiming Chen, Hongbo Zhang, Juhao Liang, Chen Zhang, Zhiyi Zhang, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents our efforts to democratize ChatGPT across language. We
release a large language model "Phoenix", achieving competitive performance
among open-source English and Chinese models while excelling in languages with
limited resources (covering both Latin and non-Latin languages). We believe
this work will be beneficial to make ChatGPT more accessible, especially in
countries where people cannot use ChatGPT due to restrictions from OpenAI or
local goverments. Our data, code, and models are available at
https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/LLMZoo. | [
0.0217342842,
0.0554283597,
-0.0135024441,
0.0457290113,
-0.054934971,
0.0144256335,
-0.0111320317,
0.0295403395,
0.058492925,
-0.0043012379,
-0.0510672666,
-0.0242912211,
0.0052848118,
0.0226293504,
0.0001458257,
-0.0879775211,
0.0475988798,
-0.0270082299,
-0.0013278312,
-0.0175867099,
0.0360044092,
0.005594865,
-0.0007238123,
0.0809747651,
0.0042075082,
-0.0270696115,
-0.0234411657,
-0.001154276,
0.0055065574,
0.0283031203,
-0.0147838471,
0.0337998495,
-0.0037645828,
0.0620225668,
0.0000019257,
-0.0139229167,
-0.0230150372,
-0.0196865611,
0.0118264379,
0.0367849767,
0.0488851592,
-0.0030578242,
-0.0499043167,
0.0565232672,
-0.0504415482,
-0.0217601135,
0.0401638225,
0.0051957741,
0.054658521,
0.0835251957,
0.0051454064,
0.0293823518,
-0.0032392764,
-0.0266056936,
-0.0067499559,
-0.0521704406,
-0.0101732397,
0.0239077136,
-0.0044814791,
0.0194719993,
-0.0071618366,
0.0350306593,
0.0279430989,
-0.0145790195,
-0.0526387915,
0.0342511609,
-0.0461067036,
-0.0143766608,
-0.0248204712,
0.0741976425,
-0.0021412093,
-0.0465128981,
0.0058113206,
0.0350456312,
-0.0107425731,
-0.0154948048,
-0.0839713514,
0.0245516188,
0.0038399384,
0.0204602871,
0.023184767,
-0.0093455175,
0.0114846705,
0.0186225325,
0.0046132253,
0.0588866211,
0.0320791453,
-0.0141471047,
-0.0379764661,
0.004825708,
-0.0081842626,
-0.0466519482,
0.0322798565,
0.0097112991,
-0.0156525951,
0.0214602482,
-0.0224081241,
0.0048915627,
0.0242569372,
-0.0489926003,
0.0070867841,
0.0679707527,
-0.0196982808,
0.043329604,
0.0132334661,
0.0433809608,
-0.0165224187,
0.0393082611,
-0.027437035,
-0.0227873288,
-0.0492006801,
0.0102133425,
-0.051751595,
0.0166199226,
-0.0448790342,
-0.0277804416,
-0.0648455545,
0.0364114903,
0.0198667683,
-0.0009866458,
0.0507106483,
-0.0330229737,
-0.0494327024,
-0.0138427624,
0.026220249,
0.0552798063,
-0.0354087763,
-0.0262165237,
-0.0004416785,
-0.0731088594,
0.0115478169,
0.0375852585,
-0.0181441121,
-0.0009770511,
-0.0425547175,
0.0929649174,
0.0007919888,
-0.0088663846,
-0.0184303597,
0.0080814762,
-0.0171222277,
-0.0627985448,
-0.0127149187,
-0.0710344836,
0.0218583755,
-0.0006790392,
0.0318139158,
-0.0148989325,
-0.0072912239,
0.0165851954,
-0.0152951907,
0.0426637903,
0.0095255105,
0.0160534196,
0.0313430205,
0.0204811282,
-0.0207472574,
0.091624558,
0.0370689407,
0.0050848196,
0.0687304586,
0.0021887876,
0.0242303088,
0.0793811008,
0.0089499829,
0.0411424637,
0.0140899662,
-0.0128607145,
0.0449152663,
0.0024044034,
-0.0203805994,
0.0815050453,
-0.0289765261,
0.014277542,
0.0564856827,
0.0565359965,
-0.0067794546,
-0.0008972838,
0.0245413575,
0.026124103,
-0.02066206,
-0.0157864671,
-0.0343621634,
0.0062744524,
-0.0404310003,
0.0148072559,
-0.0172051862,
0.0506031998,
-0.0422034487,
-0.0256961808,
0.0037569834,
-0.0344052948,
0.0282476824,
-0.0154151469,
0.0558369681,
-0.0135849062,
-0.0256967694,
0.0149684092,
0.0578722917,
-0.0648529604,
-0.0074729598,
-0.0679156259,
0.0007616879,
0.0498062186,
0.0736169294,
0.0133831436,
0.0088507589,
0.0102370046,
0.0356256254,
0.0608983859,
0.051179029,
-0.0187764317,
-0.0192839876,
-0.0689966083,
-0.0170948803,
0.0557186641,
0.0082405079,
0.0216988996,
0.044921644,
0.0333392508,
0.0088187791,
-0.031094268,
-0.009721728,
0.007882935,
-0.0464714058,
-0.0037425444,
-0.0407265015,
0.0089649688,
0.0195566062,
0.02118445,
-0.0128452005,
-0.0012709136,
-0.0090142144,
-0.0085099163,
-0.0048749871,
0.0409504361,
-0.0203632973,
-0.0298406128,
0.0563230105,
-0.0274849068,
-0.0084321573,
0.0395919606,
-0.0420514196,
-0.0494435877,
0.0389887579,
0.0084303394,
0.0504320487,
-0.0520006381,
0.0326164663,
-0.0015034446,
-0.0181241017,
-0.0103921564,
0.038895186,
-0.0028200455,
-0.0156707764,
0.034063302,
-0.0008557227,
0.0321323946,
-0.023642052,
-0.0376553535,
0.0443210192,
-0.0031765753,
0.0379675031,
0.0278226808,
0.0480006188,
-0.0159207024,
-0.03777631,
-0.1034658179,
0.0095552756,
-0.0505719148,
0.0289060008,
0.0374994911,
0.0360247493,
-0.0280159526,
-0.0098326616,
-0.0450781919,
0.0269983318,
0.0124629242,
0.003359589,
-0.0196481887,
-0.023975309,
-0.0381586142,
-0.0467406996,
-0.0087232804,
0.0085171852,
-0.0018982864,
-0.0110787991,
-0.0879307464,
-0.034949068,
-0.0043602707,
-0.0283898022,
0.0271230321,
-0.0238571912,
-0.088976182,
0.0140530458,
-0.0228333063,
0.0303457249,
0.0051457551,
-0.0042934022,
0.0243173707,
0.0012812929,
-0.0142206196,
-0.0714052841,
0.0084765647,
-0.0378409624,
-0.0603595451,
-0.0289559681,
-0.0236252062,
-0.0076042591,
0.0864574686,
-0.0112410216,
-0.0121407928,
-0.0822434351,
-0.0304777939,
-0.0645629689,
0.0064366469,
-0.0289515406,
0.0239351597,
-0.0283823516,
0.0047347993,
-0.0264137071,
-0.0494530089,
0.0565626509,
-0.0401645191,
-0.0110610314,
-0.0734732151,
-0.0065581105,
-0.0470796451,
0.0654301047,
-0.0097369757,
0.0276739821,
0.0089129042,
-0.0460390188,
-0.0292576831,
0.0133506479,
0.023985019,
-0.0282037742,
0.0326739252,
-0.0581998527,
0.028435817,
-0.0145265814,
-0.0455073155,
-0.0211331882,
0.0225149095,
-0.0381151661,
0.0075922748,
0.0304608718,
-0.0336535797,
-0.0119293369,
0.0482240207,
-0.0011339013,
0.0414419994,
-0.0177074093,
0.0099940868,
-0.0223410204,
-0.0103180017,
0.0336639732,
-0.0100234756,
-0.0329414755,
-0.0224802643,
0.041423995,
0.0908207819,
0.0702144876,
-0.0335055143,
0.0234870967,
-0.0293952562,
0.031097319,
-0.037463177,
-0.0114108082,
0.0172780138,
0.0465173125,
-0.0157049932,
-0.0126439314,
0.100120306,
0.027751429,
-0.0809744298,
-0.0039975606,
-0.0242993683,
0.0926258117,
0.0041367956,
0.0267459303,
-0.1225495711,
-0.0219432563,
0.0280821044,
0.0055669779,
0.0138672683,
0.0101186708,
-0.0050127506,
-0.1098545343,
0.0306966025,
0.0186390467,
-0.0555241778,
-0.0059035295,
-0.0162821654,
-0.018586833,
-0.0364612155,
0.0471136384,
0.0032652251,
0.0016103467,
-0.0064199418,
0.0013377685,
-0.0587674528,
-0.0324069746,
0.0013582843,
-0.0303564165,
0.0688770711,
0.0453801341,
0.0217601489,
0.0205053836,
-0.0087212687,
0.0464382097,
0.0285554435,
-0.0175590534,
-0.0135406265,
0.0205182638,
0.000914707,
-0.0286262874,
-0.0181243271,
0.0228872839,
-0.043401096,
0.0069889659,
0.0381716043,
0.0412909985,
-0.0132482117,
0.0021754093,
0.0070711854,
0.00924489,
0.0251630992,
0.071867235,
0.0252285898,
-0.0174431168,
-0.0346057117,
-0.053967163,
-0.0128817027,
-0.0399893895,
-0.0679997951,
-0.0010459779,
-0.0221426785,
-0.0785594508,
-0.0871107504,
-0.0404471718,
0.0362963155,
0.0321250856,
0.0015723645,
-0.0008870197,
0.0258071627,
0.0163198449,
0.0040716594,
-0.0080867419,
-0.0673853457,
0.021916531,
-0.0736471936,
-0.0490753837,
0.0142335473,
0.0159284268,
-0.0025241892,
0.0229320545,
-0.0885883644,
-0.0771652088,
-0.002242499,
0.0434529148,
0.0360787138,
0.0194382537,
-0.0609286427,
0.0016184895,
0.000151924,
-0.0156618115,
-0.0159573872,
0.0052973628,
0.0433935598,
-0.0025335383,
0.0155205447,
0.057708282,
-0.0285435244,
0.0180308148,
-0.0127442935,
0.0391545631,
-0.0525407642,
-0.0139051238,
0.0176009052,
0.0385672189,
0.0265729036,
-0.0163374431,
-0.0195031483,
-0.0457638316,
0.0181607902,
-0.0389453024,
0.0100868475,
-0.053665027,
0.0045726183,
0.0186192319,
-0.0155390147,
0.0124491761,
-0.0103416173,
-0.014024714,
-0.0051179323,
-0.0236672647,
0.0030390262,
0.0134186251,
0.0127885025,
0.0271226875,
0.0026279308,
-0.0156893339,
0.0319293141,
-0.0076114801,
0.0332371444,
-0.0303245336,
0.059984535,
0.0072813719,
-0.0190483276,
0.0317881554,
0.0254102293,
-0.0454096422,
-0.0796252117,
0.0004820971,
0.0991836116,
0.0826539546,
0.0611953959,
0.0661198571,
-0.0471491776,
0.0000243389,
-0.0244067255,
0.0493966304,
0.0062290141,
-0.056843888,
0.0095003219,
-0.0221571438,
-0.0245355833,
-0.0073447926,
0.1131699383,
-0.0129310777,
0.0345477648,
0.0350157358,
0.0167189892,
-0.0318432637,
-0.0245768465,
-0.006943943,
0.0184090026,
-0.0351039544,
-0.0051711975,
-0.034418419,
-0.0685696676,
-0.0710659325,
0.0394946076,
-0.0104179699,
-0.0028562737,
0.01175832,
0.043437995,
-0.0005805185,
0.0108745499,
-0.0570747554,
0.0056863548,
-0.0405614674,
-0.0246317144,
0.006052983,
-6.301606279e-33,
-0.0306872241,
0.006744667,
0.0291700792,
0.0242496133,
-0.0123954127,
-0.0242791381,
-0.0246685948,
0.0263215769,
-0.0357765183,
0.0000441806,
-0.0339810401,
0.0386041962,
0.0361635946,
0.0266958028,
-0.0079612369,
0.0022457431,
0.0187928993,
0.0008052496,
-0.0079461671,
0.0540241748,
0.029774718,
0.0118168518,
0.0637812987,
-0.0516236871,
0.0291113611,
-0.0164202955,
-0.0276554264,
0.0270976555,
-0.0051979003,
0.0786568969,
-0.0260995012,
0.0328496471,
0.01072032,
-0.0171523821,
-0.0235840362,
0.0171170402,
-0.0414582379,
-0.030664295,
0.0146957561,
0.0491606854,
-0.0055764397,
-0.0106683243,
-0.0247035716,
-0.0409774967,
-0.0085871108,
0.0129216192,
0.0030359379,
-0.0061438396,
-0.0321293399,
0.0279636122,
-0.0532057732,
0.0424730144,
0.0130124995,
-0.0232357774,
0.0078179874,
0.0074820295,
-0.0043937084,
-0.0210347585,
-0.015913697,
0.0259973183,
0.0069384729,
0.044907406,
0.0759104863,
-0.004576528,
0.0003761416,
0.045184765,
0.0373844244,
0.0130473003,
-0.0129882731,
-0.0151325576,
0.0214662664,
0.0200332347,
0.0346444696,
0.0461514443,
-0.0258717258,
-0.0364219844,
-0.050722111,
0.0193241313,
0.1051261276,
-0.0069202743,
-0.0217929669,
0.0260470379,
-0.0642008036,
-0.0296649858,
0.0017824001,
0.0046012122,
-0.0309143718,
-0.0628580227,
0.0206003375,
-0.0047552767,
-0.0138041666,
-0.0510759763,
0.0459781401,
-0.0538989343,
-0.0342950299,
0.0261574853,
-0.0064915312,
0.0288216639,
-0.0240597501,
0.0441630967,
-0.0636886507,
-0.0437387638,
-0.0306674819,
0.0037022184,
-0.0148729403,
0.0138297928,
0.0169291701,
0.0165906828,
-0.0585142821,
0.006525286,
-0.037841551,
0.0357837938,
0.01832816,
0.0383030362,
0.0359781682,
-0.0413700044,
0.0026754839,
0.0295425355,
0.0300866552,
-0.0023666483,
-0.0379877836,
-0.0101797637,
-0.0348783359,
-0.0021750466,
-0.0346607566,
0.0189060718,
-0.0539871641,
0.0096498458,
0.0227185357,
-0.0298581384,
-0.008260088,
-0.0082479846,
2.585e-7,
0.0251770671,
0.0206015985,
0.0436753035,
0.0380278453,
0.0030948019,
0.0113871545,
-0.0322599337,
0.0309869573,
-0.0157070383,
0.0084669273,
-0.0099745477,
0.0273355022,
0.0866407305,
0.0198198482,
-0.1179234385,
0.0038517902,
-0.0663020387,
-0.0001143345,
-0.04577424,
0.0063649379,
0.0093005523,
0.1076822281,
0.0004574829,
0.025913842,
-0.00806423,
-0.0261022262,
0.0521960594,
-0.0430665687,
-0.0441434607,
0.05510832,
0.0418549217,
0.0164663289,
-0.0049741524,
-0.0068484242,
-0.0152042061,
-0.0194546152,
0.0062906393,
0.085619688,
0.0143561205,
-0.0012963474,
0.0237337258,
-0.0497335531,
-0.0155499754,
-0.0294011254,
0.0503581166,
-0.0058571147,
-0.008050004,
-0.0152738886,
0.0314800218,
-0.0192835107,
0.0116951102,
-0.0151568502,
-0.0397647433,
0.0410932191,
0.0301419664,
-0.0262904409,
-0.0022379884,
-0.0669486076,
-0.0353525952,
-0.0484308191,
-0.0246843286,
-0.063809596,
-0.0292989537,
-0.0040784678,
0.0002737084,
0.0115103023,
0.0001635407,
2.173503519e-34,
0.0473678671,
-0.0026006836,
0.0067558661,
0.0649417117,
0.0421199277,
-0.0138093643,
0.064744167,
0.0074352431,
0.0018812652,
-0.0411906466,
-0.0301898513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10447v1 | Domain-specific Continued Pretraining of Language Models for Capturing Long Context in Mental Health | 2023-04-20T16:43:56 | 2023-04-20T16:43:56 | Shaoxiong Ji, Tianlin Zhang, Kailai Yang, Sophia Ananiadou, Erik Cambria, Jörg Tiedemann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have been used in various natural language
processing applications. In the mental health domain, domain-specific language
models are pretrained and released, which facilitates the early detection of
mental health conditions. Social posts, e.g., on Reddit, are usually long
documents. However, there are no domain-specific pretrained models for
long-sequence modeling in the mental health domain. This paper conducts
domain-specific continued pretraining to capture the long context for mental
health. Specifically, we train and release MentalXLNet and MentalLongformer
based on XLNet and Longformer. We evaluate the mental health classification
performance and the long-range ability of these two domain-specific pretrained
models. Our models are released in HuggingFace. | [
0.0225415658,
0.054426033,
-0.0194289833,
-0.0055967653,
-0.0160524547,
0.0242481306,
0.0001175195,
0.0275106765,
0.0483235754,
-0.0581637546,
-0.0302738193,
-0.0663643032,
-0.0072708642,
0.0198322069,
-0.0256191008,
-0.0727242306,
0.0298935845,
0.040877901,
0.0124045974,
0.0054412032,
0.0100050578,
0.0026927337,
-0.0040076962,
0.0340394005,
-0.0049378979,
-0.0240762606,
0.0143778566,
-0.014879697,
0.0177732389,
-0.0716548115,
0.0430232882,
0.0643405318,
0.0148297455,
-0.0193777718,
0.0000017631,
-0.0332649425,
-0.0246994346,
-0.0201809928,
0.0176585838,
-0.0472061485,
0.0111870328,
-0.0472576655,
0.0194091555,
0.031575907,
-0.0513860472,
-0.0373435505,
0.0159466695,
0.1137156934,
0.0538154431,
0.0673957467,
-0.0184760094,
-0.0153807066,
0.0375250392,
-0.0397463404,
0.004374363,
-0.0450760908,
0.051306691,
-0.0172271617,
0.0486626402,
-0.0104690492,
-0.0189779457,
0.0068314723,
0.008248088,
0.0618254393,
-0.0376446918,
0.0191571973,
0.0012148151,
-0.0093854694,
0.0021242113,
0.0757374689,
-0.0403731763,
0.018421676,
0.0292598978,
-0.0091010807,
-0.0027333843,
-0.0204838421,
-0.0070379875,
-0.0139739802,
-0.0104163894,
0.0047669844,
0.0381410122,
0.0345334932,
-0.0030307833,
-0.0082206847,
-0.0362829939,
0.0260401424,
-0.0268086493,
-0.0360398591,
0.0093274582,
-0.0116202775,
-0.0492178425,
-0.0753267854,
0.0261085536,
0.030529188,
-0.0161232986,
0.0141883222,
-0.0671135858,
-0.0660907999,
0.0289880224,
-0.0312351622,
-0.017692795,
0.0167075079,
-0.0681147724,
0.0053760186,
0.0129513992,
0.0023735461,
0.0007663667,
-0.0139700845,
-0.0124824205,
0.0219702646,
-0.0766882151,
0.011959997,
-0.070777975,
0.0035810927,
-0.0019767052,
-0.0435932949,
-0.0967948139,
0.0174633376,
-0.0032167071,
-0.0558679886,
0.0055630435,
-0.0165891759,
0.000290264,
0.0129111605,
0.0256690513,
0.0113064907,
-0.0374375619,
0.007120871,
0.0080032256,
-0.0480381995,
0.0058936924,
0.0108083868,
0.0221992806,
-0.065088585,
0.016986873,
0.0261441395,
0.0536780655,
-0.0666593537,
-0.0674795061,
-0.0588654578,
-0.060676381,
-0.0555200465,
-0.0096853944,
-0.0422759801,
-0.0061445995,
-0.0005522897,
-0.0002956567,
-0.0220913496,
0.0073882495,
-0.0256020837,
-0.019447716,
0.0820739865,
-0.034675654,
-0.0287600961,
0.0025488413,
0.040940892,
0.0400661267,
0.0681147948,
-0.0289066918,
0.0048123649,
0.0596832708,
-0.0307665784,
0.0131743792,
0.0254956447,
0.0344924778,
-0.0702015534,
-0.000469345,
0.00677806,
0.0031857775,
0.0102447281,
-0.0326098464,
-0.0115256654,
-0.0108295307,
0.0209419001,
0.0084963404,
0.0792918503,
0.0635807663,
-0.0027411862,
0.0077239857,
0.0013892192,
-0.0284947492,
0.0258252285,
-0.0463563204,
-0.0159092024,
-0.0170401167,
-0.0005959691,
-0.0100690471,
0.0334778503,
-0.0346787013,
-0.0451332293,
-0.0469701737,
-0.0514118448,
0.0068805376,
-0.010686391,
0.0247118734,
0.0056942469,
-0.0174070969,
0.0655876696,
0.036789827,
-0.0152995987,
-0.0224254057,
-0.0505259,
-0.0206844453,
0.0499880761,
0.0127461255,
-0.0892960653,
-0.0554151535,
-0.0303814914,
0.04395172,
-0.0128140189,
0.0068825041,
0.0126654599,
0.0223858263,
-0.039198868,
-0.0209493749,
0.0546506718,
0.0240782164,
-0.0274388101,
0.0138856154,
0.0515601896,
0.0144148348,
0.0094621116,
0.0043007517,
0.0475583039,
-0.0210787579,
-0.0341073796,
-0.0006071156,
0.0190043692,
0.0763812065,
0.0261756629,
-0.014519712,
0.0062667578,
0.0369282961,
-0.0513807274,
-0.0803852305,
-0.0095281992,
-0.0657433867,
-0.0255304594,
0.0386958458,
0.0338542536,
0.0207708627,
0.037909627,
-0.0303665549,
-0.0324770249,
0.023458872,
-0.023858767,
0.0578406677,
0.0039231954,
-0.0115868766,
0.015012132,
0.0569979846,
-0.0233766027,
0.0326610021,
-0.0174126867,
0.0204544161,
-0.0412258096,
-0.0573183298,
-0.0245397687,
-0.0347326323,
-0.0292482488,
0.0187849924,
-0.0311857294,
0.0124733141,
0.0036594386,
-0.0030805224,
-0.0080528604,
-0.0233047213,
-0.1280343533,
-0.0041502714,
-0.0483023003,
0.0201724116,
-0.0035004853,
0.008917043,
-0.0338138863,
-0.0315683484,
-0.0360034853,
0.0332628712,
0.0400934555,
0.0348867998,
0.0045963652,
0.0132438214,
-0.0119207483,
-0.0358977765,
-0.0264196415,
-0.0191794224,
0.0217318945,
-0.0202246346,
-0.0661063567,
-0.0315208286,
-0.0031512326,
-0.0432969034,
0.0321734063,
-0.0225804616,
-0.0446010791,
-0.0045716292,
-0.0155029511,
0.0416620411,
0.0355237424,
0.0366992578,
0.0672151223,
0.0054647666,
0.0259063225,
0.0074115964,
-0.0000207633,
-0.0557126626,
0.001800267,
-0.0432404652,
0.0292777196,
0.0199607015,
0.0847573876,
0.0216499623,
-0.0205895025,
-0.0423447266,
-0.0032028451,
-0.0208023544,
0.0156842619,
0.0064130314,
0.0067281793,
-0.0114771137,
0.0151670808,
0.002711209,
-0.0450353883,
0.046380464,
0.0051857564,
0.0121268183,
-0.0473148599,
-0.0444564223,
-0.0499473922,
0.0663438067,
0.0004388369,
0.0086441375,
0.0561938956,
-0.026531782,
0.0314422771,
-0.0239481609,
-0.0374311693,
-0.029407965,
0.0185518805,
-0.003341126,
0.0115582244,
0.0209028199,
-0.0135150058,
-0.0370140783,
-0.0449001342,
-0.0455259904,
-0.0354287066,
-0.0257537812,
0.0081232302,
-0.0246642623,
0.0214759111,
-0.0253830347,
0.0792608708,
-0.0267588701,
-0.0050408961,
0.0111407619,
0.0459233224,
0.0452605188,
-0.0192154013,
0.0026268468,
-0.0320668891,
-0.0153000215,
0.0417323522,
-0.0288737323,
0.0183912013,
0.006061893,
-0.0017668603,
0.0110179912,
-0.0510308668,
-0.0149403913,
0.0079076476,
0.0365020894,
-0.0630419776,
-0.0004540428,
0.1148241907,
0.029026363,
0.0077070668,
0.0432535931,
0.0034440111,
0.0107807079,
0.0118557448,
-0.0097269807,
-0.0405043848,
-0.0472941957,
-0.0347908884,
0.0133413337,
0.0027642827,
-0.022322014,
0.0124450605,
-0.0280862581,
-0.0066568181,
-0.0002521293,
-0.0485973395,
0.0140854465,
-0.024514541,
-0.0042229751,
0.0060389321,
-0.0235906933,
-0.016679598,
-0.0120337931,
-0.0038931582,
0.018963661,
-0.0603206009,
-0.0666676611,
0.0526089855,
-0.0196440294,
0.0550676659,
0.0308981575,
0.0350446999,
0.004688947,
-0.0378336832,
0.0788541511,
-0.0169775877,
0.0170766395,
-0.0225394256,
0.0884425193,
-0.0151969176,
-0.0006587698,
-0.017449867,
0.0382852443,
-0.0656369328,
-0.0171975978,
-0.0036424925,
0.0709066391,
-0.0183368884,
-0.0340460278,
-0.0234100204,
0.0171150379,
0.0404707827,
0.0539971776,
0.0048764702,
-0.0629610047,
-0.0350671969,
0.0281775743,
-0.0009824461,
-0.0065800999,
-0.0438076258,
-0.0136243291,
-0.0362716354,
-0.0314069688,
-0.0601389781,
-0.0607565083,
0.0249895845,
0.0382125564,
-0.0205589514,
-0.0351385847,
0.0179068409,
0.0315588005,
-0.0847757757,
0.065128468,
0.02951888,
0.0336353146,
-0.0548756979,
0.018217681,
0.0629632026,
0.0121369213,
-0.0259389486,
0.0199296083,
-0.0439289175,
-0.0387683474,
0.0402362831,
-0.0057843509,
0.021727493,
0.0205007978,
0.0066283881,
-0.0428549796,
0.0383413024,
0.0149931908,
-0.0329139903,
0.0049841539,
0.0638516769,
-0.0025696235,
-0.0055630049,
0.0470523611,
0.0073472932,
0.0799172074,
0.0464472398,
-0.009711544,
-0.0093229795,
-0.0004385649,
-0.0244406275,
-0.0014507098,
0.0346294604,
-0.0072778431,
-0.0410699733,
-0.0217380058,
-0.0051181889,
-0.0012562717,
0.0173080098,
-0.0170718115,
-0.0006106495,
0.037578769,
-0.0135052809,
-0.0338241942,
-0.0370940566,
-0.0388077311,
-0.0033927092,
-0.0515385568,
0.0509790182,
-0.0101454528,
0.0037168104,
0.0238233581,
0.021764379,
-0.0095644593,
0.0044800909,
-0.0029148406,
-0.0019393198,
-0.0383190289,
0.0707362294,
0.0046854592,
0.0381117426,
0.0301428046,
0.0527576841,
-0.0383713171,
-0.0262409318,
-0.0282948334,
-0.0084946612,
0.0431434773,
-0.0157271307,
0.0505826361,
0.0269053318,
0.0130122472,
-0.0179609023,
0.0512987822,
-0.0167765152,
-0.012486848,
0.0202205107,
0.0174945593,
-0.0489127263,
0.0051816637,
0.0900623053,
0.0042631645,
0.0224594865,
0.0567387417,
-0.0244967714,
-0.0375822037,
-0.0007331402,
0.0247194692,
0.0397964716,
-0.0293792393,
0.0209101569,
-0.0246840809,
-0.0669101253,
0.0906482041,
-0.0221166033,
-0.0289160386,
0.0500209928,
0.0421508178,
0.0549897365,
0.0093447575,
-0.0102003207,
-0.0292026456,
0.0188118275,
0.006451373,
-0.0325852334,
-0.0119473748,
-5.499188856e-33,
0.0008165943,
0.002019641,
0.0053623933,
0.0066870563,
-0.0439602658,
0.0348994918,
-0.0097147338,
0.0334343314,
0.0185559243,
-0.0044774376,
0.0195407793,
0.0318463407,
0.0051554176,
0.0535504669,
-0.0220438652,
-0.0174076799,
0.0207572542,
0.0023867399,
0.0089962529,
0.0290836897,
0.0149274087,
0.0772206187,
0.0607793145,
-0.1086711064,
0.0165223572,
0.0111416942,
0.0307124909,
0.005919781,
0.0681417808,
0.0491997562,
-0.0410090536,
0.052482184,
0.0558762923,
-0.0354099087,
-0.0021358985,
0.0540201589,
-0.0963689759,
-0.0170021914,
-0.0111258421,
-0.0030526007,
-0.0328092985,
-0.004258493,
0.0203748662,
-0.0252641588,
0.0019861977,
-0.0377383344,
0.0467339456,
-0.0357293114,
0.0240450427,
-0.0218964219,
-0.0453736298,
0.043630261,
0.0125853671,
0.0102674048,
-0.007220313,
0.021489637,
-0.0100804763,
0.0345228799,
-0.0323088989,
-0.0295715444,
-0.0033856751,
0.0477371104,
-0.0070917518,
-0.0302871615,
-0.0000084049,
0.0473265499,
0.0019560072,
-0.0030678194,
-0.0259131491,
0.0186768193,
0.0206635762,
0.0328974947,
0.0421777777,
-0.0123100029,
0.0660128668,
-0.0671787634,
-0.0603343248,
-0.0266288426,
-0.0149477897,
-0.0019101008,
0.0257306416,
-0.0123711573,
-0.0043427274,
0.0000710426,
0.0076800878,
0.0071915528,
-0.0111176036,
-0.0121146198,
0.0250612218,
0.0443246365,
0.0058989921,
0.0204440821,
0.0074113375,
-0.0336747877,
-0.0323414057,
0.0312313996,
0.016531989,
0.02007569,
0.0134777743,
-0.0054436638,
-0.0115969386,
-0.0060142456,
0.0114103481,
0.0208835267,
0.0459187999,
-0.0477006622,
0.0778079852,
0.0041797934,
-0.0606403016,
-0.0158520266,
0.0092066638,
0.0426977426,
0.00196339,
0.0872941613,
0.0267357193,
0.0413000844,
-0.0074350778,
0.0722787082,
0.012068917,
-0.0249687023,
-0.0486303084,
-0.0103410827,
0.0194734875,
0.0273570176,
-0.0091362232,
-0.05563052,
-0.0043837358,
0.0270419624,
0.038823463,
-0.0947898552,
0.0046401988,
-0.010869097,
2.523e-7,
0.0319404751,
0.0564392991,
0.0281207301,
-0.0245749149,
0.0451787859,
0.0109073566,
0.0144259669,
0.0583625175,
-0.0133460928,
0.0119759608,
0.0050147586,
0.0286855716,
0.0218773764,
0.0188776795,
-0.0211932417,
-0.0588522106,
-0.0385917686,
-0.0057046348,
-0.0591411181,
0.0079860166,
0.0941670164,
0.0958028063,
0.0169423446,
-0.006169186,
0.0100373989,
-0.0533641763,
0.0368349552,
-0.0179052036,
0.0287910774,
0.0399031453,
0.0215699933,
0.0202620346,
0.0123299994,
-0.0169604979,
-0.0244708005,
0.013419169,
0.0081794122,
0.0754504353,
-0.0203959532,
-0.0234996192,
0.0311141517,
0.0334643312,
-0.0380181745,
0.0055269259,
0.081638597,
-0.1023213714,
-0.0363697447,
-0.0522824824,
-0.0286440924,
-0.0321941674,
0.0360044241,
0.015884703,
0.0305562895,
0.0767075121,
0.0481710285,
0.0004849868,
0.0180616956,
-0.1413506866,
-0.0284601618,
0.033372473,
-0.0474549755,
0.0232560001,
-0.0195294656,
0.0013029596,
0.0311562736,
-0.0826255381,
-0.0095709497,
2.492511334e-34,
0.0220425986,
0.0014659397,
0.0024984747,
-0.0103306798,
-0.0096220998,
0.0027816624,
-0.0039411369,
0.0105832266,
-0.0053667277,
-0.0830687433,
-0.0221708547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10436v1 | Safety Assessment of Chinese Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T16:27:35 | 2023-04-20T16:27:35 | Hao Sun, Zhexin Zhang, Jiawen Deng, Jiale Cheng, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid popularity of large language models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4,
a growing amount of attention is paid to their safety concerns. These models
may generate insulting and discriminatory content, reflect incorrect social
values, and may be used for malicious purposes such as fraud and dissemination
of misleading information. Evaluating and enhancing their safety is
particularly essential for the wide application of large language models
(LLMs). To further promote the safe deployment of LLMs, we develop a Chinese
LLM safety assessment benchmark. Our benchmark explores the comprehensive
safety performance of LLMs from two perspectives: 8 kinds of typical safety
scenarios and 6 types of more challenging instruction attacks. Our benchmark is
based on a straightforward process in which it provides the test prompts and
evaluates the safety of the generated responses from the evaluated model. In
evaluation, we utilize the LLM's strong evaluation ability and develop it as a
safety evaluator by prompting. On top of this benchmark, we conduct safety
assessments and analyze 15 LLMs including the OpenAI GPT series and other
well-known Chinese LLMs, where we observe some interesting findings. For
example, we find that instruction attacks are more likely to expose safety
issues of all LLMs. Moreover, to promote the development and deployment of
safe, responsible, and ethical AI, we publicly release SafetyPrompts including
100k augmented prompts and responses by LLMs. | [
0.020468507,
0.0572505668,
-0.0174723081,
0.0390112773,
-0.0190263428,
0.0075390269,
0.0310276765,
-0.000552503,
0.0440071337,
-0.0400464647,
-0.0178290009,
-0.0569973104,
0.0086929137,
0.0277074706,
0.0323616713,
-0.0129414508,
0.0700043812,
-0.0406700112,
0.0084705055,
-0.0083491849,
0.0217065606,
-0.012557582,
0.0218628105,
0.0635517165,
-0.0175668038,
-0.0249415282,
-0.0152164185,
-0.0018047908,
0.0585113876,
-0.0434361733,
0.0028760368,
0.0268317088,
-0.009639265,
0.0627470836,
0.0000022208,
-0.0464113615,
-0.0067359414,
0.0352860168,
-0.0060866326,
0.0432025231,
0.0507990606,
0.0029545117,
-0.0483059771,
0.0417858027,
-0.0280442499,
-0.0094214715,
0.058166191,
0.0594824553,
0.0748134106,
0.0944578797,
-0.0000480451,
-0.0067854254,
0.0623243712,
0.0050535845,
-0.0169653688,
-0.0669081211,
0.042377539,
-0.0074130818,
-0.0164802093,
0.0094566802,
-0.0067695845,
0.0003635794,
0.0354349762,
-0.01461305,
-0.06277062,
0.0230231173,
-0.0259500314,
-0.0151028996,
-0.0294455364,
0.0562028512,
-0.0227599591,
0.0042185374,
0.0086039975,
-0.0019724288,
-0.0024832017,
-0.0409948714,
0.0005058285,
0.0589683354,
-0.0070121735,
-0.0018386276,
0.012600678,
0.0145658096,
0.0463527553,
0.0417290665,
0.0204438027,
0.0633198097,
0.0176608395,
-0.0249441881,
0.0074695353,
-0.0281757247,
0.0013237456,
-0.0527321063,
-0.0107522178,
0.0185977817,
-0.0191879813,
0.0271458328,
-0.0508802049,
-0.0152190365,
0.044682201,
-0.0923406631,
0.043985609,
0.0451268703,
-0.0032419458,
-0.0003316806,
0.0049808044,
0.0491074808,
-0.0147799524,
0.0536064319,
-0.0139627978,
0.0196510945,
0.010717405,
0.0064381626,
-0.0042705792,
0.0417761058,
0.0176261682,
0.0164153054,
-0.06449496,
0.0263998136,
-0.0637692362,
0.0241412669,
-0.0092335669,
-0.0167430583,
-0.0120789949,
-0.0054896646,
-0.0011076148,
-0.0352239348,
-0.0380725712,
-0.007477602,
-0.000038919,
-0.085569486,
0.0044875499,
0.0262829661,
-0.0510969684,
-0.0234830976,
-0.0179982781,
0.1157760471,
0.0163546409,
-0.0223253444,
-0.0538309328,
-0.0446974933,
-0.0398229025,
-0.0576085448,
-0.0041565006,
-0.0472333692,
-0.0235627238,
-0.0291432478,
-0.0258428827,
-0.0447155125,
0.0282578357,
0.0100264372,
-0.0287961196,
0.0351042114,
0.002609438,
-0.0034426132,
-0.002947503,
0.0629379004,
-0.0443609431,
0.0612796508,
0.0491163619,
0.0361838564,
0.0385161415,
-0.0155737503,
0.032159999,
0.0416072644,
0.0033829582,
0.0492988229,
-0.018160237,
0.0160712581,
0.0107922712,
-0.0186894462,
-0.0381039679,
0.1056381464,
-0.0134403799,
-0.0248528775,
0.0768366903,
0.0339568071,
-0.0767533332,
0.0221971162,
0.0209415536,
0.0028016444,
-0.0001017078,
-0.0065564252,
-0.0670425445,
-0.0001987418,
-0.0971300006,
-0.0251886249,
-0.0103485668,
0.039382793,
-0.0362151116,
-0.0244139787,
-0.0220308062,
-0.0311892927,
0.067796804,
0.0193827283,
-0.0011964433,
-0.0157149937,
-0.0171982739,
0.0055621061,
0.027245095,
-0.0616125278,
-0.0249535237,
-0.0893354937,
-0.0089793745,
0.0816020519,
0.0318102576,
0.0023466165,
-0.0279631782,
-0.0248400401,
-0.0259035919,
0.0287152305,
0.0332428887,
0.007211247,
0.0016620866,
-0.0355502479,
-0.0189938303,
0.0310015474,
0.0203962103,
0.0114044938,
0.0605139434,
0.0416170619,
0.0077156196,
0.0056001954,
-0.0703745484,
0.0238558128,
-0.024216447,
-0.042884022,
-0.009236522,
0.0124671804,
0.0424861088,
0.0000950072,
-0.0359466188,
-0.00029689,
0.0269804094,
0.0275778584,
-0.0306866951,
-0.0226079412,
-0.0370916091,
0.0453849174,
0.0419279039,
-0.0197570436,
-0.02201836,
0.0675923675,
-0.0424115099,
-0.0013655218,
0.0084411306,
-0.0162047185,
-0.0318315402,
-0.0345696807,
0.01021735,
-0.0281759519,
0.0044927853,
-0.0094838012,
0.0627980977,
-0.0187470298,
-0.02447531,
-0.0097908117,
0.0168627352,
0.0216639135,
-0.0392155759,
-0.0882631764,
-0.0020865344,
-0.0292874668,
0.0576985441,
0.0176317543,
0.0385492444,
-0.0267512854,
-0.0056266701,
-0.0817765668,
-0.0005571777,
-0.0296328291,
0.0182349887,
0.0169206094,
-0.0154014062,
-0.0204121023,
0.0052746241,
-0.0322861895,
0.0095004216,
-0.0086843632,
0.0287031326,
0.0002270908,
-0.023260884,
-0.0359660238,
-0.0102191307,
0.0083982088,
-0.0223473106,
0.0175936669,
0.0003826973,
-0.0147176981,
-0.0237554777,
0.0456079543,
-0.0351006836,
0.0331073478,
-0.0082623465,
-0.0797544569,
0.0413809903,
0.0157227162,
-0.0073936339,
0.0613447018,
0.0436395518,
0.052263543,
0.0589062683,
0.0167678557,
-0.0329451375,
0.0068576876,
0.0201949775,
-0.0452873148,
-0.0186120775,
-0.0448061824,
-0.0270644408,
0.0389072485,
0.0182135198,
-0.0220772028,
-0.0594148263,
-0.0038635409,
-0.0549363308,
-0.0605148226,
-0.0013320443,
-0.0453120023,
-0.0544813201,
-0.0038717084,
-0.0099657718,
-0.0659618601,
0.073911123,
-0.0194861311,
0.0306399688,
-0.0197058283,
-0.0286843646,
0.0121683674,
0.0653314963,
-0.0208587684,
0.0434201099,
0.0122586135,
-0.0114289653,
-0.0297863279,
-0.0213653184,
0.0147228045,
-0.0426823348,
0.0256641787,
-0.0306662675,
0.0071021575,
-0.0229415018,
-0.0374091044,
-0.065210335,
-0.0610773824,
-0.016735889,
0.0005532017,
0.0031088199,
-0.0129226306,
0.0149532938,
0.0024659841,
0.0455861874,
-0.0096531855,
-0.0295279231,
0.0158989877,
-0.0191267729,
-0.0286134481,
0.0629575774,
-0.0511056073,
0.0210269447,
-0.0196806975,
0.0629423559,
0.106847398,
0.0416219793,
0.0078059421,
-0.0344633795,
-0.0192530584,
0.0114312414,
-0.0000103048,
0.007090711,
0.0646609738,
0.0525295436,
-0.0527576767,
-0.0038036534,
0.0572865903,
0.005694747,
-0.008586348,
0.0143146794,
0.0241356567,
0.0027949631,
-0.0087902723,
-0.0163619425,
-0.0960634798,
0.0050664926,
0.0181487314,
0.0250542909,
-0.0267899614,
-0.0215570554,
0.0285725687,
-0.1117972285,
0.0444074348,
0.0141326105,
-0.0552980788,
-0.0236032084,
-0.0074144471,
-0.0165843777,
0.0223080851,
0.071581237,
-0.0032203582,
0.0203288645,
-0.0537226535,
0.0110572008,
-0.0246112365,
-0.0534393489,
0.0568815358,
-0.0464541689,
0.0733296946,
0.0837784037,
-0.0112818396,
-0.0495811477,
-0.0241736416,
0.0142330192,
0.0199584216,
-0.024184091,
0.0236133169,
0.0323303342,
0.0042872392,
-0.0255439784,
-0.0051263985,
0.0110383062,
-0.0052314615,
0.0189333484,
0.0502706319,
0.0540503375,
-0.0260738172,
-0.0490949377,
-0.0248320363,
0.0136611937,
0.0292571709,
0.0730961263,
0.0060589327,
-0.0378998257,
-0.0094999736,
-0.0613194853,
-0.0171286073,
-0.019849563,
-0.0469276533,
0.0369265564,
-0.0007901672,
-0.0628613755,
-0.0665508732,
-0.030071767,
-0.0286330041,
-0.0075892755,
0.0370295718,
-0.0300855525,
0.0110180657,
0.0434362851,
0.0053075505,
-0.0108152246,
-0.0271830577,
0.0462421067,
-0.0535986647,
0.0521087982,
-0.0018679209,
-0.0034772845,
-0.0021869084,
0.0355160832,
-0.0487980209,
-0.0830899999,
0.0264001079,
0.0789562315,
0.0216165092,
-0.0281851552,
-0.0411036834,
-0.0230823159,
0.0504654348,
0.0297014173,
-0.0130297691,
0.0069468711,
0.0655385703,
-0.0339787789,
0.0243161917,
0.0108773503,
-0.0352777839,
0.0129150748,
0.0375843756,
0.0106167188,
-0.0519526005,
-0.02191942,
-0.0025841568,
0.0684816688,
0.0194130428,
-0.019433463,
0.0056620622,
0.004688317,
0.011742278,
-0.0388600342,
-0.0307038035,
-0.0181714222,
0.0286064353,
0.034851227,
0.0079042586,
0.0136295483,
0.0018025367,
0.0092468131,
-0.0026293229,
-0.0189413,
0.0263510086,
-0.0060345447,
0.0619267039,
0.0201057605,
0.0130868815,
-0.0496124625,
0.020986829,
0.0073975297,
0.0069946945,
0.0032707509,
0.0443552285,
-0.0033519873,
0.0028180215,
0.0429193415,
0.0371018462,
-0.0543669537,
-0.0543889329,
-0.003651167,
0.0671027899,
0.0275156349,
0.0558588579,
0.0365181603,
-0.0344641693,
0.0077656559,
-0.0487907492,
-0.0087020909,
0.008797002,
-0.0820979923,
0.0216677953,
0.0106384521,
-0.0160725564,
-0.008087934,
0.0819566548,
0.0089194616,
0.04737987,
0.0142072393,
-0.0226751175,
-0.0059688077,
-0.0415081382,
0.0405678339,
-0.0061474447,
-0.0403660089,
-0.0271137133,
-0.0732802376,
-0.0838601664,
-0.0354206115,
0.0155779487,
0.0311418418,
-0.0018100397,
0.0210969187,
0.0238520801,
0.0130500961,
0.0261717197,
-0.0368772447,
-0.0093977964,
-0.0231416207,
-0.0130989449,
-0.0030729272,
-6.596418058e-33,
0.0085610002,
-0.0266409498,
-0.0134287477,
-0.0041255583,
0.0015315178,
0.0001633157,
-0.0148807131,
0.0191595871,
-0.056800805,
-0.009965172,
-0.0047810352,
0.0193710122,
0.0064257602,
0.0123184649,
-0.0150805106,
-0.0541311651,
-0.0107369376,
-0.018323727,
-0.0076838662,
0.0305692367,
0.0389756039,
-0.0244306307,
0.041291099,
-0.0930122212,
0.0479051024,
-0.0127683906,
-0.0529305227,
-0.002366002,
-0.069917433,
0.0704786405,
0.0089044059,
0.0537125617,
0.0038537255,
-0.0113970106,
0.0201096516,
0.0172808897,
-0.0006668489,
-0.0156307574,
-0.0023791897,
-0.0034211597,
-0.0313520618,
-0.0616857484,
0.021842882,
-0.0222980846,
-0.0437563434,
-0.0101342136,
-0.0028593431,
-0.0201671235,
-0.0031213255,
-0.0165553316,
-0.0286487564,
0.0103660971,
0.011700524,
-0.0109896241,
-0.0176571142,
0.0149517776,
0.0095897401,
-0.0163463168,
-0.0356292166,
-0.0028922355,
0.0367434695,
-0.0045896233,
0.0502967909,
-0.0209126435,
0.000781014,
0.0521711595,
-0.0042003179,
0.0194668751,
-0.0238712616,
-0.0388462469,
0.0002614066,
0.0512151532,
0.0554373674,
0.0645134673,
0.0157159194,
-0.0497244298,
-0.0876883045,
0.0391667038,
0.032586854,
0.0302086994,
0.0300402958,
-0.0332802534,
-0.1120240763,
-0.0163342375,
-0.0108927703,
0.0108883129,
-0.0428767614,
-0.0292642228,
0.0430243611,
0.0069437935,
-0.0395584963,
-0.0320127383,
0.014841171,
-0.0642493591,
0.0281751044,
0.0231580641,
0.0091075366,
-0.0130147748,
0.000222365,
0.0516774543,
-0.0197184905,
-0.0239925589,
-0.0039805807,
-0.0469608195,
0.0149125457,
0.0041956538,
0.0342510454,
0.0626533628,
-0.0458705351,
0.0153539581,
-0.001850764,
0.0311720353,
0.0401329696,
0.0135147097,
0.0257299095,
-0.0091444179,
0.0062756827,
0.0121580334,
0.0426670127,
0.0200467389,
-0.0532159023,
0.0039332323,
-0.0428340845,
0.0109916199,
-0.0072634425,
0.032545507,
-0.0173207391,
0.0463253856,
0.0339091532,
-0.0640496835,
-0.0143590551,
-0.0006131534,
2.99e-7,
-0.0116162626,
0.0058866977,
0.0134887621,
0.0595239289,
0.0084224781,
0.0726876035,
-0.019757254,
0.0807992369,
0.0037255937,
0.0020124998,
0.0042416085,
0.012562695,
0.0669877008,
0.0689366683,
-0.0397418439,
-0.0133610433,
-0.0788818151,
-0.0023010946,
-0.0515860878,
0.0250538625,
0.0552577935,
0.0851542726,
-0.0006701383,
-0.0071581933,
0.0062456029,
-0.0541165695,
0.0344557762,
-0.0200017821,
0.0021775356,
-0.0008779558,
0.0451985672,
0.0628390536,
0.0023406963,
0.0222059768,
-0.0004575777,
-0.0124504603,
-0.005369084,
0.0870005488,
0.0000112589,
-0.0242038295,
-0.0018301759,
-0.0695638955,
0.0134194251,
-0.0572674833,
0.0682566538,
0.0039015112,
-0.0114744892,
-0.0090004224,
-0.0036077644,
-0.0347282626,
0.0297813918,
-0.0386470854,
-0.0176675227,
-0.0026172909,
0.0050431066,
-0.0089648506,
0.0193771515,
-0.0286781192,
-0.0089983083,
-0.0328605287,
0.0052973474,
-0.0962577537,
-0.0019718022,
0.022062242,
-0.0147795966,
-0.0209057592,
0.0147220194,
2.705479227e-34,
-0.0069025527,
-0.0621200092,
-0.0088133374,
-0.0129192909,
0.0569214821,
0.0401200727,
-0.0141751114,
-0.0193124134,
-0.0116907395,
-0.0116512468,
-0.0511592478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10428v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10428v4 | GPT-NER: Named Entity Recognition via Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T16:17:26 | 2023-10-07T14:25:28 | Shuhe Wang, Xiaofei Sun, Xiaoya Li, Rongbin Ouyang, Fei Wu, Tianwei Zhang, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the fact that large-scale Language Models (LLM) have achieved SOTA
performances on a variety of NLP tasks, its performance on NER is still
significantly below supervised baselines. This is due to the gap between the
two tasks the NER and LLMs: the former is a sequence labeling task in nature
while the latter is a text-generation model.
In this paper, we propose GPT-NER to resolve this issue. GPT-NER bridges the
gap by transforming the sequence labeling task to a generation task that can be
easily adapted by LLMs e.g., the task of finding location entities in the input
text "Columbus is a city" is transformed to generate the text sequence
"@@Columbus## is a city", where special tokens @@## marks the entity to
extract. To efficiently address the "hallucination" issue of LLMs, where LLMs
have a strong inclination to over-confidently label NULL inputs as entities, we
propose a self-verification strategy by prompting LLMs to ask itself whether
the extracted entities belong to a labeled entity tag.
We conduct experiments on five widely adopted NER datasets, and GPT-NER
achieves comparable performances to fully supervised baselines, which is the
first time as far as we are concerned. More importantly, we find that GPT-NER
exhibits a greater ability in the low-resource and few-shot setups, when the
amount of training data is extremely scarce, GPT-NER performs significantly
better than supervised models. This demonstrates the capabilities of GPT-NER in
real-world NER applications where the number of labeled examples is limited. | [
0.0349456519,
0.0415137559,
0.0253229477,
0.022144977,
0.0045455443,
0.0530745946,
-0.0043756892,
0.007356354,
0.0366970412,
-0.0579673909,
-0.0218332727,
-0.0130111687,
-0.0122446958,
0.0026015863,
0.0621231496,
-0.0002471757,
0.0182066094,
-0.0181906614,
0.015880961,
0.0312664993,
-0.009761773,
0.0408426672,
0.009206444,
0.0221260637,
-0.0054515917,
0.0070630186,
-0.0181110725,
0.011244108,
0.027644502,
-0.0849384815,
0.0065099834,
0.0361875445,
0.0010741965,
0.0444503278,
0.0000019943,
-0.0313639082,
-0.0685146078,
0.0242824219,
-0.0189858712,
-0.0022791282,
-0.0027940788,
-0.0275777355,
-0.0080192732,
0.0246016178,
-0.0034801823,
-0.0463739969,
0.0046156994,
0.0842172727,
0.0347800069,
0.0835201591,
-0.008368779,
-0.0124387676,
0.0359568894,
-0.0235131849,
0.0064630443,
-0.0182155538,
0.0388350599,
-0.0473719947,
-0.0141046531,
0.0585353151,
0.0286389925,
0.0080694035,
0.003524123,
0.0276908427,
-0.0083866324,
0.0829794407,
-0.0599543005,
0.037412744,
-0.0137529951,
0.0541835576,
-0.036888361,
-0.0157085527,
0.0958474055,
-0.000887599,
-0.0309868418,
-0.0398194641,
-0.0140508413,
0.0151644247,
-0.0377041884,
0.0415773466,
0.0449541509,
-0.0151603594,
0.0419287533,
-0.001114492,
-0.0081455791,
0.0522816218,
0.0419498011,
-0.0507626086,
-0.0130699519,
0.0152447494,
-0.0498011,
-0.0662115887,
0.0204138216,
0.0387168899,
0.0052752797,
0.0271867309,
-0.0175631009,
0.0322043747,
0.0117796697,
-0.0152129028,
-0.0080380132,
0.0045570149,
0.0015244397,
0.0479532629,
-0.0659457669,
0.0261712559,
-0.0215628408,
-0.0035550105,
0.0253346264,
-0.0388354212,
-0.0541914441,
-0.0240940563,
-0.0439740531,
0.0731983855,
-0.0320281908,
-0.0107066389,
0.0013815076,
0.0109421369,
0.0192999579,
0.0371539891,
0.0145624699,
-0.0147684878,
0.0075568007,
-0.0366909914,
-0.020055972,
0.0132977581,
-0.0077695358,
-0.0244287197,
-0.0241836626,
-0.0353207067,
-0.0133724278,
-0.0137466798,
0.0411042832,
-0.0319109783,
0.0213712454,
0.0663238615,
0.041343987,
-0.0917727873,
-0.0965124592,
-0.0059723035,
-0.0120038651,
-0.0585463606,
-0.0030422015,
-0.0293273982,
0.0202682391,
0.0253455862,
0.0026309523,
-0.0430773087,
0.0403069183,
0.013175766,
-0.0261559729,
0.0829495192,
-0.0246131681,
0.0116369203,
0.0489525311,
0.006296149,
0.0536401123,
0.0414855182,
0.0415514968,
0.0250472054,
0.035826467,
-0.0015423025,
0.0119247651,
0.0218523685,
0.0318532586,
0.0342356749,
0.0197230242,
0.0041205925,
0.0096094823,
0.0139992964,
0.0301661231,
0.0703681335,
-0.002483303,
-0.0074145328,
0.0383391045,
0.0404384248,
-0.0195554774,
0.0000946857,
0.0371603295,
0.0242388006,
-0.0361168794,
-0.0103065101,
-0.0525063165,
0.007086663,
-0.0455203541,
0.0096982308,
0.0591119379,
0.0426923707,
-0.0351493582,
0.0108176833,
-0.0248851534,
0.0112564573,
-0.0259045642,
0.0189411044,
0.0375625901,
0.0125965877,
-0.0860708207,
0.074386023,
0.0158750825,
-0.0279105119,
0.03977466,
-0.0404450484,
0.038868878,
0.0281738453,
0.0471200198,
-0.024698915,
-0.0366284922,
-0.0288736392,
-0.0454824679,
0.0791399032,
0.0026562861,
-0.0068541877,
0.019045487,
-0.0332787968,
0.0030810863,
0.0012957571,
0.037065424,
0.0278953649,
0.0603283234,
0.065216966,
0.0639446154,
-0.0300907232,
-0.0279106367,
0.048895631,
-0.0421119891,
-0.0617960803,
0.0155372135,
0.0204623211,
-0.0185716357,
0.036619626,
-0.0074881488,
-0.0052062022,
0.0217019841,
-0.015814146,
-0.0267565455,
-0.0495444983,
-0.0165444203,
-0.0628997758,
0.0132421339,
0.0069849403,
-0.0209817253,
0.0026788497,
-0.0369110964,
-0.0626450628,
-0.0492158383,
0.0032991078,
0.0191531722,
-0.0265042037,
0.0315657258,
0.0658553317,
0.0076945815,
-0.0090917591,
0.0571131743,
-0.0099738687,
0.0332516134,
0.0062203417,
0.0389940031,
0.0120233027,
-0.0324847959,
-0.0652556792,
-0.001407891,
0.0089673484,
-0.0398731902,
0.0171504058,
-0.0003394436,
-0.058130227,
-0.0408544615,
-0.1047784016,
0.0354794152,
-0.0289893132,
0.0528618284,
0.0212862883,
0.0044519571,
-0.0322275162,
-0.0083046127,
-0.0376611277,
-0.0148015106,
0.0112951268,
0.0100530824,
0.0371088199,
0.0020464042,
-0.0231086351,
0.004916593,
0.0255199932,
-0.0433513783,
-0.006330715,
0.0070689339,
-0.0405711979,
-0.0886539444,
0.0534799546,
-0.0219659731,
0.0057432312,
0.0062948158,
0.0262065977,
0.0008279472,
0.0000330248,
0.0335364901,
0.0352821872,
-0.006022003,
0.0035541574,
-0.0120828012,
-0.0207452066,
-0.0328750536,
0.0260973554,
-0.0451372229,
0.02956976,
-0.0005335286,
-0.0519461073,
0.0438618474,
0.0769106671,
-0.0245362576,
0.0120027727,
-0.0458211713,
0.0019520829,
-0.0284004994,
-0.0018337541,
-0.0022577764,
0.0349259712,
-0.0008826199,
-0.0157053731,
-0.0314438045,
-0.0234117396,
0.0331575014,
-0.07515838,
-0.0240750872,
0.010897764,
-0.002501572,
-0.0738377571,
0.063350074,
0.0409505479,
-0.0102729518,
0.0654652491,
-0.0803967863,
0.0231277756,
0.0254271273,
-0.037785843,
-0.0249718707,
0.0354500264,
-0.0157559756,
0.0336307772,
-0.0155392438,
-0.0372312665,
-0.0374864824,
-0.0140169552,
-0.0193163697,
0.0024814487,
-0.0256641787,
-0.0320146903,
0.0055211838,
0.0610736348,
-0.0056543313,
0.0737235993,
-0.0193537585,
-0.0101914089,
-0.0356899053,
0.0431885831,
0.0743042901,
0.0118348459,
0.0046825879,
0.0039799339,
-0.0253665391,
0.028621003,
-0.0098688714,
0.0110174259,
-0.0066460259,
-0.0032973827,
0.0097380504,
-0.0690480843,
0.0076355459,
-0.0125414552,
0.0302372258,
-0.0279706623,
-0.0319992416,
0.1351123303,
0.0195954591,
-0.0199779831,
-0.0389549062,
0.0291758943,
0.0362279639,
0.0251455698,
0.020234365,
-0.0585480779,
-0.0275853556,
0.0153938895,
-0.0016644673,
-0.0046435283,
-0.0838251784,
-0.0238869507,
-0.1385846287,
0.0268712249,
-0.0212741997,
-0.0624766648,
0.0033841168,
-0.0602044538,
-0.0085599953,
-0.0244939495,
-0.0025350642,
-0.0295386892,
-0.0217165072,
-0.0003686484,
0.02383749,
0.0024777229,
-0.0391985662,
-0.005025567,
-0.0448624939,
0.0655345768,
0.0272834748,
0.034565635,
-0.0080322837,
-0.0043361732,
0.0066700554,
-0.0153111489,
-0.0139056584,
-0.018326344,
0.0380217098,
-0.0749816447,
-0.0099140583,
-0.0060314955,
0.0133338794,
-0.0409836806,
-0.0144616878,
0.0326211974,
0.0566159636,
0.0015566084,
0.0026822358,
0.0025849734,
-0.0420527905,
0.0355546176,
0.0807258487,
0.0002652418,
0.0012948267,
-0.0324178822,
0.0105668455,
-0.0023439068,
-0.0013463401,
-0.0278276969,
0.0108269416,
-0.0088996263,
-0.0283156112,
-0.0396590494,
-0.0483076647,
0.0708903521,
0.0250439569,
0.0140887778,
0.0374419987,
0.0211408027,
-0.00578711,
-0.0393845253,
0.0334723033,
-0.0611122996,
-0.0179060213,
-0.0651132092,
0.0014182803,
0.0450700261,
0.02473321,
-0.024012953,
0.0199664161,
-0.0682168007,
-0.0639039278,
-0.033937607,
0.0154168671,
0.0088687371,
0.0279293284,
-0.0098310709,
-0.0037314023,
0.0328770243,
0.0545196794,
-0.0440121032,
-0.024964964,
-0.0327822044,
0.0212442465,
-0.0112771168,
0.0280324575,
-0.0105274692,
0.0337634757,
0.0133371279,
0.0753824338,
-0.0131073445,
-0.0301933084,
0.0108966818,
0.0239987001,
0.0678831935,
-0.0289692841,
0.0295556448,
-0.0498014018,
-0.0015397449,
0.0050409925,
0.012192498,
-0.0102695292,
-0.0070724217,
0.0238390788,
0.0009941434,
-0.0316934697,
0.0506258011,
-0.0133818826,
0.0446923748,
-0.0375366174,
-0.0213683229,
-0.0168865044,
0.0142852217,
0.0111046229,
-0.0327434689,
0.0004771108,
0.0261625517,
0.0676369146,
0.0474359505,
-0.0396656841,
0.0304862279,
0.0048602168,
-0.0000681659,
-0.0137657532,
0.0250053741,
-0.0210198797,
-0.0064052157,
-0.0587719567,
0.0727642551,
0.0489742123,
0.0093339849,
0.0617549866,
-0.0338277072,
-0.0192970634,
-0.0072969459,
-0.0002103254,
0.0041421661,
-0.008989091,
0.027938528,
0.0215676837,
-0.0536782332,
-0.0066879382,
0.0408042483,
0.0412312485,
0.0291520562,
0.0507325158,
-0.0179641079,
-0.0300636869,
-0.0045068297,
0.001346291,
-0.0454537794,
-0.0268617924,
0.0416222848,
-0.0221479852,
-0.0546132326,
0.0098789716,
-0.0280864369,
-0.0181691367,
-0.0173502136,
0.0176611505,
0.0081873266,
0.0001588967,
-0.0303545874,
-0.0522221737,
0.0170692801,
0.0012448232,
-0.0512993783,
0.0058122268,
-6.611380632e-33,
-0.029455144,
-0.065747641,
0.0563543588,
-0.0140644964,
-0.0243115146,
0.021694662,
-0.0249898881,
-0.0163997244,
0.0516898967,
-0.0409383029,
-0.0265664551,
0.0031814275,
0.0159984548,
0.0316285193,
-0.0049120183,
-0.0280157439,
0.0645103529,
0.0183356237,
-0.0318703763,
0.0260390658,
0.030769499,
0.0434620939,
0.0749651417,
-0.0716358051,
0.0072373911,
-0.0198637415,
0.0039008309,
-0.0167352594,
0.0475867614,
0.038835723,
-0.0511794724,
-0.0126987835,
0.0234031901,
-0.1072830185,
0.0269566756,
0.0186216012,
-0.1306245327,
-0.0015586059,
-0.031191282,
-0.0103379916,
-0.0216933116,
-0.0330010019,
0.0082162349,
-0.0034562459,
0.0155760162,
0.0435679965,
0.0046100751,
0.0229019523,
0.0016803425,
-0.0071692807,
-0.0672801211,
0.0595096946,
0.032733541,
0.0329490155,
0.0457044654,
-0.0208223611,
0.0257730205,
0.0084990589,
-0.0670581311,
-0.0199494641,
0.0355111286,
-0.0044391113,
0.0128144706,
0.0248736739,
-0.0046553044,
0.0246486329,
0.0289450418,
-0.0020068437,
-0.04099961,
-0.0304756202,
-0.0076058339,
0.0194807108,
-0.0302003007,
0.0178608745,
0.047487691,
-0.0315160379,
-0.0560208485,
0.0392443761,
-0.0373050198,
-0.0061042458,
0.0195010174,
-0.03416631,
-0.0702255964,
0.0048003281,
-0.0201680921,
-0.0411456637,
-0.0417682938,
-0.0193457156,
0.0534154288,
0.0588895082,
-0.0384095535,
0.0449039862,
0.0140187619,
-0.0032552213,
-0.0625093281,
0.0170303863,
0.0116448514,
-0.0179726463,
-0.0235288218,
0.0458659157,
-0.0806171671,
-0.063418746,
-0.0011336714,
-0.0138835004,
0.0044091982,
-0.0210493915,
0.0285656583,
0.0011265571,
-0.0889192298,
0.017361762,
-0.0132694487,
0.0580662265,
-0.0458394997,
0.0056288498,
0.0213461183,
-0.0217321888,
0.0200590268,
0.0093810363,
0.0538524203,
-0.0068588704,
-0.0132600935,
0.0434298255,
0.0273648836,
0.0222462881,
0.0037098483,
0.013121889,
-0.0004679099,
-0.0031521455,
-0.0128638493,
-0.056773413,
0.006123554,
-0.003952181,
2.786e-7,
-0.0238918643,
0.0190853532,
0.0227656383,
-0.0043156045,
-0.0050684582,
0.0140341669,
0.00044209,
0.0514023155,
-0.0207173415,
-0.0183046963,
0.0003474503,
-0.0130510461,
0.0235955082,
0.0341093428,
-0.1195258796,
0.0062350892,
-0.0257252697,
0.0036943827,
-0.0759956017,
0.0081533724,
0.0272337459,
0.091654405,
0.0074566752,
-0.0162380133,
-0.0284967627,
-0.0497230366,
0.0590501353,
0.0218032021,
0.0058584157,
0.0333995298,
0.0205023065,
0.0901921466,
-0.0265905932,
-0.0027217749,
0.0001984437,
0.0301148277,
0.019665638,
0.0883455947,
0.0239475574,
-0.0220267791,
0.0013205418,
-0.0369197205,
0.0172586162,
-0.0587025099,
0.0946494117,
-0.0482111908,
-0.0158328786,
0.0115450518,
-0.0138530489,
-0.0296515506,
0.0043520401,
-0.0017971743,
-0.0227530133,
0.0183461625,
0.0199163593,
-0.033111833,
-0.0047025783,
-0.0890752897,
0.0442104675,
0.0241214335,
-0.0012556233,
-0.0051914994,
-0.0438894182,
0.0018887593,
-0.0101187639,
-0.0564455949,
0.0004349605,
2.759303552e-34,
-0.0431379974,
0.0075116614,
-0.020519264,
0.0345038176,
0.0230520237,
0.0116957156,
-0.0512477309,
-0.002136921,
-0.0257529728,
-0.0555866696,
-0.0043878597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10392v1 | CKBP v2: An Expert-Annotated Evaluation Set for Commonsense Knowledge Base Population | 2023-04-20T15:27:29 | 2023-04-20T15:27:29 | Tianqing Fang, Quyet V. Do, Sehyun Choi, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Populating Commonsense Knowledge Bases (CSKB) is an important yet hard task
in NLP, as it tackles knowledge from external sources with unseen events and
entities. Fang et al. (2021a) proposed a CSKB Population benchmark with an
evaluation set CKBP v1. However, CKBP v1 adopts crowdsourced annotations that
suffer from a substantial fraction of incorrect answers, and the evaluation set
is not well-aligned with the external knowledge source as a result of random
sampling. In this paper, we introduce CKBP v2, a new high-quality CSKB
Population benchmark, which addresses the two mentioned problems by using
experts instead of crowd-sourced annotation and by adding diversified
adversarial samples to make the evaluation set more representative. We conduct
extensive experiments comparing state-of-the-art methods for CSKB Population on
the new evaluation set for future research comparisons. Empirical results show
that the population task is still challenging, even for large language models
(LLM) such as ChatGPT. Codes and data are available at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/CSKB-Population. | [
0.052952677,
0.0442183912,
0.0140563026,
0.0159597415,
-0.0412463322,
-0.0263683181,
-0.0265848823,
0.0134677989,
0.0599526353,
-0.0470277891,
-0.0068716127,
0.0086400146,
-0.0090602636,
-0.0019173143,
0.0103416443,
-0.0027430435,
0.0150615657,
0.0053856065,
-0.0043320884,
-0.0270450711,
0.0280032195,
0.0101729715,
-0.0257793143,
0.0199342296,
-0.0027004734,
0.0114040691,
0.0102326926,
-0.0242886227,
0.0208545402,
-0.0241072811,
0.0165166426,
0.0795826241,
0.0048203738,
0.0313957185,
0.0000019353,
-0.013580393,
0.0299683977,
0.0151409805,
-0.0190068092,
0.0348723046,
0.0045142677,
0.0155008817,
0.019859584,
0.0017312369,
-0.0293050744,
-0.0049026106,
0.029103715,
0.0406440571,
0.0661763698,
0.0478349067,
0.0101228887,
-0.0032857221,
0.0129755335,
-0.0085157417,
0.0182293486,
-0.0869217142,
0.0273400471,
0.0210651457,
-0.0066145221,
-0.0243400242,
0.0172033012,
0.0204166956,
0.0164900329,
-0.0010477146,
0.0285400897,
0.0362212323,
-0.0737645552,
0.0135807889,
-0.0196670722,
0.1288887858,
0.0362979434,
-0.0166187901,
0.0083896462,
0.0089089237,
0.0158456601,
0.0360754132,
-0.0131400004,
-0.0254818685,
-0.0123574641,
0.0155355874,
-0.0032724175,
0.0129446331,
0.0295680705,
0.0347520858,
0.0406016931,
0.0282809362,
0.0140830446,
-0.0045681302,
0.0178132001,
0.0365842171,
-0.0399284996,
-0.0683049634,
0.0327515602,
0.0011267996,
-0.0257664211,
0.0030718895,
-0.0384418704,
-0.0144966533,
0.0362064168,
-0.0639881268,
0.0078754425,
0.0053042145,
-0.0268257987,
0.0992120355,
-0.0277286917,
0.0039466606,
0.0095230928,
0.0204502735,
0.0006038464,
-0.0102135753,
-0.0712563097,
0.0502283126,
-0.0137776826,
0.003589751,
-0.0212013666,
0.0119766323,
-0.0283153765,
-0.0295250844,
-0.0312904567,
0.0275408998,
0.0205191057,
0.039399296,
-0.0071533881,
0.0034849741,
-0.0588464737,
0.0517831147,
-0.0887630954,
-0.0001699222,
0.0185459405,
-0.0638803467,
-0.0271318927,
-0.0209421702,
0.0264117457,
-0.0150152044,
-0.0157914497,
0.0239357185,
0.0017777114,
0.0083032781,
-0.0307108369,
0.0016964754,
0.0189062655,
-0.0175555795,
-0.0127783194,
-0.0737372413,
0.0739248767,
-0.0117598595,
-0.0097708479,
-0.0171718784,
0.0035349997,
0.0289382022,
-0.0392296091,
0.078663148,
-0.0504116639,
-0.0138645126,
0.0051132422,
-0.0034337481,
-0.0271047987,
0.0615692846,
-0.0081542227,
-0.0141018033,
0.036954172,
0.010104862,
0.022792967,
0.0209490024,
0.0689722449,
0.0167138577,
0.0541526414,
0.0321617573,
-0.0247011706,
0.061649736,
0.022315139,
0.0285759382,
-0.0550871044,
-0.0310830735,
0.0426676311,
0.0131805073,
-0.0686262548,
0.0211719163,
-0.0025473447,
0.0351115391,
0.0372550264,
-0.0096473806,
-0.0459436886,
0.0244647395,
-0.0732185096,
-0.0300969053,
0.0340719782,
0.0081106042,
0.0012019258,
0.0132241771,
-0.0226901472,
0.0123780267,
0.0078324387,
-0.0053123212,
0.0313345008,
0.0126207443,
-0.0064202989,
0.0685174763,
0.0327632092,
-0.0197556373,
0.0021996358,
0.0062617962,
0.0101852147,
0.0281399246,
0.0402994119,
-0.0119501958,
-0.04285549,
-0.0064269826,
-0.0280957744,
0.0263950843,
0.0443695709,
-0.0365269259,
-0.0019689328,
-0.0407244675,
-0.0214649495,
0.0259143263,
0.0100984266,
0.0103322873,
0.0392509922,
-0.0139506292,
-0.0024993871,
-0.066376254,
-0.0186836999,
0.0047669914,
-0.020892594,
-0.0067894282,
-0.021394344,
-0.0261830986,
0.038614016,
0.0037555634,
0.0024502096,
0.0048037907,
0.0185114071,
-0.0041020107,
-0.0336314328,
0.0042044478,
-0.002805053,
-0.088156797,
0.0521219485,
-0.0575979836,
-0.0709573403,
0.0312301461,
-0.0495727509,
-0.0281237513,
0.0004199292,
-0.0042953873,
0.0324324369,
-0.0474664979,
-0.0549427122,
0.0220563617,
-0.0162007846,
-0.0093731079,
0.0877246186,
-0.0429760739,
0.0147359949,
0.0045492244,
-0.0230793599,
0.0270561595,
-0.0373458117,
-0.0584099442,
-0.0102710836,
0.0221133549,
0.0161530823,
0.0306845121,
-0.0059161815,
-0.0822988451,
0.0061233682,
-0.0927828103,
0.010867117,
0.0114856912,
-0.0058423439,
0.0201898441,
-0.0222575888,
0.0134292636,
-0.007406326,
-0.0688299984,
-0.0114234192,
-0.0258098859,
0.0371509492,
0.0127497828,
0.033343561,
0.0484238192,
-0.0125514017,
-0.0046601365,
-0.0055706087,
0.0206831824,
0.0227420554,
0.0491132513,
-0.0234952737,
0.0046044895,
-0.0290036201,
0.0313216113,
-0.0090326611,
-0.0343462825,
-0.0026506397,
-0.0131407417,
-0.0296102837,
0.0092950622,
-0.0207683705,
0.0132061495,
0.0194294006,
-0.0069319825,
-0.0563990474,
0.0055413791,
-0.0015291771,
-0.0139909619,
-0.0071787932,
-0.0196954086,
-0.0149672879,
0.0492648408,
0.0111558139,
-0.0129976748,
-0.0803202167,
0.0158614367,
-0.0144071868,
-0.0107898368,
-0.0825052336,
0.0369166844,
-0.0152414916,
0.0421797596,
-0.0476857722,
0.0103202062,
0.0861657709,
-0.0077572735,
0.0241478737,
-0.0323699377,
0.0492987633,
0.0087599307,
0.0082005495,
-0.0129698198,
-0.0033696531,
-0.0214838441,
0.0155267352,
-0.0287866145,
0.0260228012,
0.0562105179,
-0.0512485132,
-0.0150043368,
-0.0133302044,
0.0363224521,
-0.0002198579,
-0.0333967432,
-0.0149238883,
-0.0871722922,
-0.018542733,
0.006792224,
0.0579493158,
-0.0140030244,
-0.0166687183,
-0.0220807735,
-0.0015432248,
0.0038888007,
0.0168650746,
0.0028283778,
0.0165841896,
0.0548135415,
0.029674856,
0.0365391076,
0.0290260166,
0.0190364402,
-0.0377683863,
0.0816660076,
0.0570940003,
-0.0092137028,
0.0132169174,
0.0127520999,
0.0211759675,
-0.0298699271,
-0.0098354081,
-0.0135285472,
0.0480967313,
-0.0125943357,
0.0061026146,
0.0746654123,
0.0245532636,
-0.020149745,
0.0074944054,
0.0103605082,
0.0015320051,
0.0110398699,
0.003757332,
-0.1055108085,
-0.0206842721,
-0.0136639308,
0.0371601991,
-0.0105305193,
-0.1017751917,
0.0310624577,
-0.1451484114,
-0.0017103305,
-0.015143211,
-0.0917583555,
-0.0088024223,
-0.062339671,
0.0320918672,
-0.0537350662,
-0.0151526462,
0.0014497177,
0.039147988,
0.0473950729,
0.0104377782,
-0.0433955826,
-0.0927924886,
0.0629048944,
-0.0701742768,
0.1237068474,
0.0500793904,
0.0563301444,
-0.0086415997,
-0.0568656735,
-0.0358944461,
-0.0458507128,
-0.0238902401,
-0.0017769465,
0.0362071879,
-0.0093905646,
-0.0436089151,
-0.0200108122,
0.0451740734,
-0.0558755621,
-0.0062127337,
0.0136798685,
0.0600616671,
0.0339579396,
-0.0100439042,
0.0063797436,
0.0011772411,
0.0291817095,
0.1057832092,
0.0057995436,
0.0150846289,
0.000786085,
-0.0358907394,
-0.0161705539,
-0.0528109036,
-0.0349905454,
0.0720415637,
0.0072103748,
-0.03563077,
-0.0913615823,
-0.0496289842,
0.0702990443,
0.022767527,
-0.0180013217,
0.012817435,
0.0001747814,
0.0179028139,
0.0027281439,
0.0723552853,
-0.0404480025,
-0.0343426876,
-0.0022937239,
-0.0337500535,
0.0059922431,
0.0004891255,
-0.0323173217,
0.0738106966,
-0.0528710894,
-0.0476999283,
0.0100046638,
0.0538683049,
0.0113524087,
0.0340689197,
-0.0608830564,
-0.0270655453,
0.0330496989,
0.0485508256,
-0.0566665605,
-0.0214216635,
0.0042122165,
0.0158431195,
-0.0063779978,
0.0426040255,
-0.0581459738,
-0.0284851752,
0.0206941105,
0.0730834901,
-0.0358900502,
-0.0045686071,
0.0090104118,
0.0641660839,
0.0359614193,
-0.0292557478,
0.0257280599,
-0.0247182827,
-0.0452404357,
0.0043899105,
-0.0374165997,
-0.0308651142,
-0.0009692601,
0.016592769,
-0.0237736553,
-0.0045720004,
0.0358434729,
-0.0003715035,
0.0062753991,
-0.0283120982,
-0.0219548922,
0.1150125787,
0.0304088611,
0.0294022467,
-0.0094967103,
-0.0339983106,
-0.0065785819,
-0.0182988662,
0.0424197763,
-0.0154251633,
0.02697137,
0.0306895822,
-0.0248810649,
0.0306489989,
-0.0159336682,
-0.0375687853,
0.015893206,
-0.0287316237,
0.0967887491,
0.0628778562,
-0.0104002832,
0.0193269923,
-0.0236013178,
-0.0330515504,
0.0049374816,
0.0039452543,
0.0095552159,
-0.0046067364,
0.0223999508,
0.0088443691,
-0.006962481,
0.0191458575,
0.0797457993,
-0.0187465474,
0.0727536604,
0.0087660989,
-0.0252222791,
-0.0403516814,
-0.0040294472,
-0.0258550439,
0.0325330943,
0.0150099657,
0.0284926444,
-0.0630507246,
-0.0454291254,
0.0255068857,
0.0303968117,
-0.0121517135,
0.0232439321,
0.0265768915,
0.0439501144,
-0.0083191823,
-0.002344395,
-0.0360139869,
0.0261406619,
-0.0751865879,
-0.0143923154,
-0.0238152388,
-6.709909834e-33,
-0.0275829192,
-0.0161183383,
-0.003734706,
-0.0405208021,
0.0044374326,
-0.0071150516,
-0.0261491574,
-0.0141020389,
-0.0120640695,
0.0370119028,
-0.0263676345,
-0.00080421,
-0.0039401231,
0.0116431918,
0.0091229063,
-0.0602584034,
0.0203168057,
0.0031770333,
-0.032188233,
-0.0033841678,
0.0462307781,
0.0070164953,
0.0848539621,
-0.0628001466,
0.066168353,
-0.0168673936,
-0.0001010416,
0.0030995084,
-0.0189817399,
0.03204,
-0.021546362,
0.0673337504,
0.0041092145,
-0.0344494209,
0.01646295,
-0.0556617267,
-0.0691287518,
-0.0339643471,
0.0334361568,
0.0022447531,
-0.0558634102,
0.0220149476,
0.0289977491,
-0.009814024,
-0.0044149151,
0.0103508122,
0.017832635,
-0.0416095108,
-0.0194518436,
-0.0110132871,
0.0368759297,
0.0390443057,
0.0025170613,
-0.0100119961,
-0.0552084446,
-0.0246006921,
0.0054116417,
-0.0167056881,
-0.0802673623,
-0.0167071316,
0.0219523814,
-0.0103547769,
0.0183329508,
-0.0245903637,
0.0304890927,
0.0515541434,
-0.0324506238,
0.0090297582,
-0.0459142402,
-0.0149882138,
-0.0020968525,
0.0408436358,
0.0660704896,
0.1489002556,
0.0450342633,
0.0238456111,
-0.0310848188,
0.07853055,
0.039369788,
0.0206767488,
-0.0078582112,
0.0004445099,
-0.0596539564,
-0.0164414793,
-0.0507099442,
-0.0476218276,
-0.0232760571,
-0.0151255755,
-0.0077296598,
-0.0207889508,
-0.0364224873,
0.0195470769,
-0.0059890491,
-0.0299206227,
-0.0030420737,
0.0244643316,
0.0163239539,
-0.0072148582,
0.0082648993,
0.0194460191,
-0.0714261234,
0.0343597233,
0.0132739479,
0.0019093606,
0.0205854829,
0.0329854488,
0.022121869,
-0.0181447212,
-0.0108608864,
-0.005004656,
-0.0265979525,
0.0292649232,
-0.0309299398,
-0.0208961405,
0.040469721,
0.0192009024,
0.0059101889,
-0.00956502,
0.0244989786,
0.0591946281,
0.0246417224,
0.0044403197,
0.0184429511,
-0.0275809951,
0.0037163843,
0.0127519639,
-0.0139343133,
-0.068276532,
-0.0133241322,
-0.0199091509,
0.0049316804,
-0.0090240538,
2.587e-7,
0.0246000346,
0.0279943123,
0.0208377,
-0.020216262,
0.0009985764,
0.0275331922,
-0.0002059653,
0.0358389318,
-0.0019915414,
-0.0813466161,
0.0005542618,
0.036035113,
0.0293081496,
0.0603128485,
-0.0963370427,
-0.0239265561,
-0.0830029249,
0.0074443286,
-0.0023842885,
-0.0059953751,
0.019225901,
0.0518012866,
0.0516287945,
-0.005031256,
0.0197062716,
-0.0373912603,
0.0497107916,
-0.0320401676,
-0.0336344726,
-0.0090528075,
0.0378374308,
0.0314026065,
0.0038659503,
0.0538084507,
-0.0020536503,
-0.015196437,
0.0497425236,
0.0144705148,
0.004800444,
-0.0219436008,
-0.0349341556,
-0.050673902,
0.008533719,
-0.0303050894,
0.0768479779,
-0.0501885973,
-0.0306265,
-0.0313161723,
-0.0625312626,
-0.0278558098,
0.0213090368,
-0.0070370748,
-0.0173012186,
-0.016105108,
0.004540558,
-0.0042540925,
-0.0368630067,
-0.0473980531,
0.0020203935,
0.0166725889,
-0.0136936558,
-0.0758266822,
0.0036695742,
-0.0380734913,
-0.0074728681,
-0.073794201,
0.0327301435,
1.897122642e-34,
0.0042620008,
0.0090933191,
0.0085977558,
-0.0403904803,
0.0427733995,
-0.0015807255,
-0.0079290848,
-0.0408922732,
0.0250306875,
-0.0485983267,
0.0307376478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10354v1 | Prompt-Learning for Cross-Lingual Relation Extraction | 2023-04-20T14:52:06 | 2023-04-20T14:52:06 | Chiaming Hsu, Changtong Zan, Liang Ding, Longyue Wang, Xiaoting Wang, Weifeng Liu, Fu Lin, Wenbin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) is a crucial task in Information Extraction, which
entails predicting relationships between entities within a given sentence.
However, extending pre-trained RE models to other languages is challenging,
particularly in real-world scenarios where Cross-Lingual Relation Extraction
(XRE) is required. Despite recent advancements in Prompt-Learning, which
involves transferring knowledge from Multilingual Pre-trained Language Models
(PLMs) to diverse downstream tasks, there is limited research on the effective
use of multilingual PLMs with prompts to improve XRE. In this paper, we present
a novel XRE algorithm based on Prompt-Tuning, referred to as Prompt-XRE. To
evaluate its effectiveness, we design and implement several prompt templates,
including hard, soft, and hybrid prompts, and empirically test their
performance on competitive multilingual PLMs, specifically mBART. Our extensive
experiments, conducted on the low-resource ACE05 benchmark across multiple
languages, demonstrate that our Prompt-XRE algorithm significantly outperforms
both vanilla multilingual PLMs and other existing models, achieving
state-of-the-art performance in XRE. To further show the generalization of our
Prompt-XRE on larger data scales, we construct and release a new XRE dataset-
WMT17-EnZh XRE, containing 0.9M English-Chinese pairs extracted from WMT 2017
parallel corpus. Experiments on WMT17-EnZh XRE also show the effectiveness of
our Prompt-XRE against other competitive baselines. The code and newly
constructed dataset are freely available at
\url{https://github.com/HSU-CHIA-MING/Prompt-XRE}. | [
0.0404694416,
0.0295533389,
0.0188298412,
0.076073505,
-0.0310982447,
0.0098638358,
0.0099294838,
-0.0090634273,
0.0184983928,
0.0098211039,
-0.061214529,
-0.0346681625,
-0.0089131985,
-0.0185483824,
-0.0202905517,
-0.036455337,
0.0492410548,
0.0091131162,
0.0290043969,
0.0018720388,
-0.0156483036,
0.0240779817,
-0.005070352,
-0.0252870955,
-0.0290791336,
-0.0144541981,
0.0296768043,
0.0012273594,
0.0535824932,
-0.0517451987,
0.017455969,
0.0421280302,
-0.0178569946,
-0.0122964969,
0.0000020125,
-0.0874748677,
-0.052457545,
-0.0112845413,
-0.010152651,
-0.0214538649,
-0.0220153015,
-0.0273535307,
0.001506976,
0.0292049143,
-0.0412229523,
-0.0838670731,
0.031868048,
0.0743552074,
0.015149666,
0.072147496,
-0.0255632605,
-0.0143354721,
0.0179865547,
-0.0681285933,
-0.0128062414,
-0.0313083827,
0.018873794,
-0.0340077393,
-0.0196632911,
0.0105359219,
-0.0199785437,
0.0146084782,
0.032692112,
0.0144325374,
-0.0272966344,
0.0416115783,
-0.0038192312,
-0.0254730638,
-0.0264136381,
0.1155563891,
0.0006533642,
0.0388580635,
0.0068184687,
-0.0039158827,
-0.017176969,
0.0061931722,
0.0155049497,
0.0090890145,
-0.0333915018,
0.0211598165,
0.0191765577,
0.0183524862,
0.0303284582,
0.0125809861,
-0.0180473942,
0.0467598811,
0.0154875219,
-0.0571963564,
0.0546621457,
0.0305774715,
0.0243510678,
-0.0265724882,
0.0117624383,
0.0079667298,
-0.0447508805,
0.0416949764,
-0.0185241438,
0.0079440111,
0.0027213031,
-0.0176161863,
-0.0046140626,
0.0266457293,
-0.0681413785,
0.0507460982,
-0.0545754209,
0.0296062808,
-0.016513139,
-0.0241071675,
-0.0051590004,
-0.0206147544,
-0.0204495508,
0.0214523748,
-0.0291676763,
0.0228835084,
-0.0430877469,
-0.0098007508,
-0.0291824937,
0.0085682673,
0.0097308634,
0.0357051194,
0.0263017099,
-0.0261312351,
-0.016039025,
-0.0041304901,
-0.0296048094,
0.0317549817,
-0.0365451686,
-0.0107352054,
-0.0375304632,
-0.0443078317,
-0.0246154498,
-0.0333078057,
0.0382846743,
-0.0755754039,
0.0205284785,
0.0602130294,
-0.0032497346,
-0.0362250693,
0.0154406996,
-0.0300167352,
0.0318411365,
-0.0805831775,
-0.0079938034,
-0.0191769842,
0.0876354948,
0.0143060666,
0.0045298575,
-0.0053766691,
0.0637553632,
-0.0168119762,
-0.0807608739,
0.0577767603,
0.0051822281,
-0.0177342836,
-0.0634135678,
-0.0049182526,
0.0206847135,
0.063733004,
0.0218612701,
0.0076541617,
0.0884001553,
0.0216356702,
-0.0263477396,
0.0514571927,
0.0191164352,
-0.0188209973,
0.0269459039,
0.0182747617,
0.0546268113,
0.0019487524,
0.024585776,
0.0376570113,
-0.0147899697,
-0.0002962618,
0.0130129848,
-0.0103785368,
-0.0017217163,
0.0260174368,
0.06559892,
-0.0223734789,
0.0041202242,
0.0166619383,
-0.0580210313,
0.0123183131,
-0.0066229734,
0.0397450812,
-0.0242392812,
0.0440729707,
-0.0069053359,
-0.0086028175,
0.0141545292,
-0.0242496338,
-0.032999374,
0.046991922,
0.0668565631,
0.0174648948,
-0.0607658289,
0.0642018691,
0.0707175583,
-0.0315008946,
0.0033810826,
0.0217488967,
0.0234058145,
0.0266418327,
0.0177158043,
-0.04491603,
-0.0279146601,
-0.01571857,
-0.0169952679,
0.0382380486,
0.0653529465,
-0.0233734772,
0.0502290688,
-0.0280965921,
-0.0673886091,
0.0282751042,
-0.0222843811,
0.0126784537,
0.041216407,
0.0495484769,
0.0241451282,
0.014035034,
-0.0009649806,
0.0415441617,
-0.0715245381,
-0.0353405327,
0.0363202505,
0.0553583913,
0.015856782,
0.0477849953,
-0.0197962113,
-0.0244561676,
0.0507389121,
-0.0398531705,
0.028839983,
0.0365335718,
-0.0665352568,
-0.0665871948,
0.0299287345,
0.0086617665,
-0.0390237682,
-0.008362731,
-0.0536384359,
-0.0316387154,
-0.0429367051,
0.0685353875,
0.0485125296,
-0.0566558056,
0.0040727155,
0.0246523973,
0.0508147739,
0.0142229525,
0.0686213225,
0.0091311773,
0.0179433636,
0.0497750267,
-0.0141195711,
0.0026721992,
-0.0025833943,
-0.0342342742,
0.0112573458,
0.0003518465,
-0.0279192217,
0.0310891122,
0.0427443162,
-0.0457123145,
-0.0039580758,
-0.0535829253,
0.0319083109,
-0.0081625711,
0.0450038984,
0.0111123072,
0.0508123152,
-0.0329966284,
-0.0355082043,
-0.0245139711,
-0.0043242914,
-0.0188107342,
0.0033316195,
0.0549901128,
0.025240466,
0.0054613706,
-0.0343107916,
-0.0016180131,
-0.0225543194,
0.0245156586,
-0.0007083795,
-0.019350145,
-0.0203921497,
0.0481760651,
-0.0400105566,
0.0355987772,
-0.011590926,
-0.0066322931,
-0.0415868126,
-0.005749797,
0.0548053458,
-0.0081054224,
-0.0169181079,
0.0226667318,
0.0017764961,
0.0031244452,
-0.0154208243,
0.0568567179,
-0.0247703455,
-0.0059447424,
-0.0054780128,
-0.0232353341,
-0.0232739914,
0.0476620346,
-0.0124932295,
0.0053865518,
-0.0072783204,
-0.0332321078,
0.0345789827,
0.0169677567,
-0.0263101328,
0.0489313602,
-0.0005190764,
0.0155004933,
-0.0650228634,
0.0037758248,
0.0720437765,
-0.0302716922,
-0.0061206459,
-0.0289439186,
0.0113435993,
-0.0609664358,
0.0708328485,
-0.0262215305,
0.0050494694,
0.032810472,
-0.0307074301,
-0.0390302725,
-0.0214224048,
0.0056083798,
-0.0002226909,
-0.0328719616,
-0.0250880271,
-0.0013146491,
-0.0323150419,
-0.031441547,
-0.0474628992,
-0.0442584082,
-0.0155232614,
0.0229809619,
-0.0191638172,
0.0211672373,
0.0241035633,
0.0266502295,
0.0223039091,
0.0121033527,
-0.0198046528,
0.0162399299,
-0.0141775953,
0.0716995224,
0.0675437972,
0.0036848269,
-0.0048766583,
-0.0269032102,
0.0353430137,
0.0167779904,
-0.0041081682,
-0.031058928,
0.0286973491,
0.0140255485,
0.0230308436,
-0.033999823,
-0.0033663926,
-0.0243966691,
0.0438210778,
-0.0567074157,
0.0058225226,
0.0943499953,
0.0098997969,
-0.0293667391,
-0.0127390483,
0.0298063401,
-0.0011415727,
0.0416232385,
0.0180854239,
-0.0869760364,
-0.0191786736,
-0.0057592676,
-0.0444669761,
0.0114588598,
-0.0612652898,
-0.0148125188,
-0.1457181573,
-0.0161163006,
-0.0374787822,
-0.0764792264,
-0.0189604145,
-0.0541986823,
0.0098637929,
-0.0189839583,
0.0360659361,
-0.0125483349,
-0.0352839455,
0.0034564598,
-0.0136648146,
0.0059798826,
-0.0536288805,
0.024206683,
-0.066845417,
0.0023981796,
0.0477301255,
0.0300197471,
-0.0238926075,
-0.0006612357,
0.0119512761,
-0.0380401351,
-0.0184243675,
-0.0504149348,
0.0339101888,
-0.0283172783,
-0.0525404215,
-0.0114311334,
-0.0075246375,
-0.0404607207,
0.029713301,
0.0330377258,
0.0674689189,
0.0486380942,
-0.0009825848,
0.0387485139,
-0.0183421224,
0.0212194547,
0.0715927705,
-0.0021229945,
-0.0145890303,
-0.0333742723,
0.0183155481,
-0.0016852472,
-0.0355617218,
0.0186476503,
-0.0028450266,
-0.0764280111,
0.0024530489,
-0.0385279022,
-0.1060000956,
0.0430669077,
0.0099900067,
0.0029036771,
0.0018202221,
-0.0112455226,
0.03649652,
-0.0577922873,
0.0242376588,
-0.0136992382,
0.0076266332,
-0.0315022469,
0.0079043517,
0.0139473723,
-0.0508590341,
-0.005528674,
-0.0328797698,
-0.0243497416,
-0.0265561938,
-0.0497450866,
0.0372405611,
0.0001304274,
0.068361491,
-0.0196728949,
0.0338021144,
0.046817977,
0.0389830507,
-0.0582339391,
-0.0216404591,
0.0408808514,
-0.0016673071,
-0.0171337426,
0.0308477525,
-0.0489780195,
0.0109354481,
0.0503880829,
0.0637134612,
-0.0043021459,
-0.0724952072,
0.0103807347,
0.0301880259,
0.0683301836,
-0.0162556637,
-0.0303944219,
-0.076779142,
0.0333265252,
-0.0560826771,
-0.0141544137,
-0.028173767,
0.0342843868,
0.0145407682,
-0.0117856758,
-0.0115852496,
-0.0120084193,
-0.0106299613,
-0.004000193,
-0.022487076,
-0.0016302573,
0.017496163,
0.0273698401,
0.015834501,
-0.0058923829,
-0.0038208547,
0.0095959194,
0.0423394516,
0.017697569,
-0.0378074534,
0.0227165148,
0.0012937899,
-0.0009072595,
0.0186718348,
0.0111260014,
-0.0010796477,
0.0190466065,
-0.0062672785,
0.0394707285,
0.0859897956,
-0.0354239158,
0.0289795753,
-0.0128051797,
-0.0029881236,
0.0111232679,
0.0475204848,
-0.0154096102,
0.0116195725,
0.0256445017,
0.0011817156,
-0.0421779789,
0.0330928825,
0.0618439354,
-0.0425537825,
0.0532413907,
0.0473347791,
-0.0083123557,
-0.0472923256,
-0.0005150554,
0.0249765813,
-0.023885414,
-0.0335277393,
0.0185991954,
-0.0413527042,
-0.065185979,
0.0111643095,
-0.0180955622,
-0.0603477694,
0.0300617591,
-0.0155748622,
0.056408979,
0.0359105505,
-0.0246570185,
-0.0381382443,
0.0034301085,
-0.0069456031,
-0.0199036878,
0.0140938312,
-6.441648798e-33,
-0.0439474843,
0.0196579304,
0.0080170333,
-0.006116631,
-0.0292878915,
0.0354960486,
-0.0378865041,
-0.0298568271,
-0.0493904576,
0.0301011447,
-0.0371938422,
-0.0424900837,
0.0320693515,
0.0129876649,
-0.0097912671,
-0.0185442902,
0.0304305218,
0.0143307494,
0.016047921,
0.0090382183,
0.042709142,
0.091109179,
0.0993959308,
-0.0479009636,
0.0298669487,
-0.0128314812,
0.0061252909,
0.0452122539,
0.0463309549,
0.039251361,
-0.0393513553,
0.0192680657,
0.0109305782,
-0.0368806906,
0.0191153716,
0.0210079718,
-0.1841912121,
-0.0314551108,
0.0081388894,
0.0126318159,
-0.0401549861,
-0.0098830685,
-0.0281663686,
-0.0107245902,
0.0655374974,
-0.0327589177,
0.0373523049,
-0.0404641144,
-0.0031539025,
-0.0447490588,
-0.0481479019,
0.0089995386,
0.034285903,
-0.0013625445,
0.0451424047,
0.0486496538,
0.0238633025,
0.0173108876,
-0.0305928476,
-0.0407051891,
-0.0353198349,
0.0182040185,
0.0251168124,
-0.0057651475,
-0.0023326445,
0.0199072696,
0.0226341616,
-0.0177862924,
0.0333223194,
0.0278875846,
0.0034840391,
0.0447059684,
-0.0463800319,
0.068055965,
0.0098948088,
-0.0267532319,
-0.1119527742,
0.0098006995,
0.0864035264,
0.0263511091,
-0.0257722139,
-0.0460526608,
-0.0097995652,
-0.0142528061,
0.0104103098,
-0.025294736,
-0.0196682569,
-0.0492728651,
-0.0019702059,
0.0322702639,
-0.025852209,
0.0278952755,
0.017833503,
-0.0295657553,
-0.0482410342,
0.0337125063,
-0.0035271647,
-0.0339321159,
-0.0038714791,
0.0120111937,
-0.0734559894,
-0.057147596,
-0.0209333114,
-0.0292961821,
0.0200602673,
0.021660056,
0.0614078902,
-0.0168339778,
-0.0708770677,
-0.0059717395,
-0.0465279855,
0.0474320352,
-0.0090525597,
0.0398247801,
-0.0025617497,
0.0228818953,
-0.013823471,
0.0240641143,
0.0671410486,
-0.0155185731,
-0.0307753887,
0.0144165391,
-0.0046747378,
0.034631595,
0.0328605361,
-0.0111540779,
-0.0185797177,
0.0384060852,
0.0130086998,
-0.0355597362,
-0.0207208842,
-0.0117801381,
2.678e-7,
0.0050870883,
-0.0108497152,
0.0465492979,
0.0403930619,
-0.0213626754,
0.0110389758,
-0.0154230166,
0.0498719811,
0.0026667137,
-0.0083299307,
0.0280157439,
-0.0044662785,
0.045728717,
0.0335819945,
-0.0742380619,
-0.0169381481,
-0.0765740871,
-0.0529716648,
-0.0524118803,
0.0071636643,
0.0404320322,
0.0575527437,
0.0186523944,
0.0127397124,
-0.0634315461,
-0.0049104486,
0.0495394841,
-0.0533091575,
-0.035176605,
0.0393775515,
-0.0115377046,
-0.0139870038,
-0.0343676396,
0.0288052373,
-0.0227715224,
0.0711483434,
0.0011968627,
0.0592972003,
0.0339024402,
-0.0294554438,
0.0193776302,
0.0092507536,
0.0136758005,
-0.0265375245,
0.0808285177,
-0.0019962918,
0.0209457744,
0.0016409919,
-0.0116666043,
-0.0009134136,
0.0322391801,
-0.0014669091,
-0.0156889856,
0.0534112938,
0.0371763594,
-0.010430865,
-0.0432880409,
-0.0564559102,
-0.0177018493,
0.0442021564,
0.024081355,
-0.0348872952,
0.0381692462,
-0.046254728,
-0.0218578726,
-0.0359852575,
0.025581602,
2.26611204e-34,
-0.007986268,
-0.0073594283,
-0.0131265139,
0.041552458,
0.0327475667,
-0.0607385375,
-0.0508565046,
0.0174259059,
-0.0139683196,
-0.0345695019,
-0.0015199345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11075v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11075v2 | Spaiche: Extending State-of-the-Art ASR Models to Swiss German Dialects | 2023-04-20T14:42:54 | 2023-09-13T16:12:56 | Clement Sicard, Kajetan Pyszkowski, Victor Gillioz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent breakthroughs in NLP largely increased the presence of ASR systems in
our daily lives. However, for many low-resource languages, ASR models still
need to be improved due in part to the difficulty of acquiring pertinent data.
This project aims to help advance research in ASR models for Swiss German
dialects, by providing insights about the performance of state-of-the-art ASR
models on recently published Swiss German speech datasets. We propose a novel
loss that takes into account the semantic distance between the predicted and
the ground-truth labels. We outperform current state-of-the-art results by
fine-tuning OpenAI's Whisper model on Swiss-German datasets. | [
-0.0173961148,
0.1078929529,
0.0106692966,
0.070909135,
-0.0363922268,
-0.01493672,
0.0205243379,
-0.0347848535,
-0.0107235033,
0.0002423099,
-0.0499758832,
-0.0422120765,
0.0187874157,
0.0347639956,
0.0276664365,
-0.0089878421,
0.0232307333,
-0.0739895478,
0.0052107959,
-0.0419523753,
0.0228959601,
-0.0156723429,
-0.0117988214,
0.0799217969,
-0.0073407828,
0.0104611898,
-0.0117547326,
0.0260467678,
0.0229074433,
-0.0168378577,
0.0153874522,
-0.0429491699,
-0.0005840834,
0.0316578522,
0.0000018919,
-0.0355780646,
0.0188876241,
0.011564156,
-0.0539815687,
0.0385082476,
-0.0149804475,
-0.018297324,
-0.0164164416,
0.0585032851,
-0.0203503575,
0.0219598897,
0.0576719604,
0.0442762077,
-0.0068260785,
0.0515294448,
-0.0084685041,
-0.035868682,
0.0146685457,
-0.0344341062,
-0.0257205088,
-0.0364184603,
-0.00474296,
-0.0736866221,
-0.085668534,
0.009945455,
-0.0086229118,
0.0515055433,
0.019046247,
0.0241150912,
-0.0173007697,
0.0145764602,
-0.0069268844,
-0.0413085148,
-0.0026558335,
0.02961291,
-0.010666471,
-0.052262947,
-0.0078885276,
-0.0069842711,
-0.0503138155,
-0.0233190842,
-0.0099883424,
0.0428133607,
0.0118058957,
0.0254146568,
0.0209355038,
0.0636565387,
0.0276904814,
0.0051101032,
0.0194593854,
0.0452156067,
-0.004413018,
-0.0442288853,
0.0475372002,
-0.0181722846,
-0.0286742654,
-0.0101265479,
0.0020270043,
0.0109663857,
-0.0094926646,
0.0069285133,
-0.0038837839,
-0.0048078452,
0.0260638148,
-0.0634545311,
0.0531194992,
0.0450404733,
-0.0788787603,
0.0170682836,
0.0069054277,
0.0647266209,
0.0364379212,
0.0060495706,
-0.0124305068,
-0.0363546684,
0.0000242639,
0.0105870198,
-0.053624969,
0.025604412,
-0.0429091901,
-0.0503232032,
-0.014512049,
-0.0206887666,
-0.0156112537,
0.0188504104,
0.0750038624,
0.0088106263,
-0.0662972555,
-0.0086944867,
-0.0134563912,
0.0603989288,
0.0007075261,
0.020962704,
-0.0091235908,
-0.0309261512,
-0.0156499967,
0.0175377559,
-0.0130516822,
-0.0071637374,
0.0009882482,
0.0289227702,
0.007590129,
-0.0074531357,
-0.0787135363,
0.0226626117,
-0.0487053804,
-0.0584515259,
-0.0380615667,
-0.0326468498,
0.0281119812,
-0.0018169228,
0.0053913915,
-0.0960782766,
0.0277631506,
-0.0407964401,
0.0115624173,
0.0491755046,
-0.0459912121,
-0.0001097691,
-0.0037930438,
-0.0047757789,
-0.0148992529,
0.0754401311,
0.0046356828,
0.0025634542,
0.0119213602,
-0.0086334096,
-0.0321101062,
0.0250710938,
0.0337493308,
-0.0198602173,
-0.0426537804,
-0.0177872945,
0.0166470855,
0.0152326785,
0.0441370457,
0.0794919878,
0.0035606255,
-0.0661316216,
0.0578943416,
0.0398391895,
0.0341001861,
0.0144381979,
0.0197383408,
0.0165671483,
-0.0263662096,
-0.0326058306,
0.0196799636,
-0.0241948348,
-0.0121213067,
0.0381645598,
0.0149665102,
0.0371745229,
-0.0481469072,
-0.0379884578,
-0.0156564284,
-0.0529904775,
-0.0015449392,
0.0339560658,
0.0194074642,
0.0342973769,
-0.0105155632,
0.0658867359,
0.027039241,
-0.0427442379,
0.0223478731,
-0.0271480568,
-0.0173407365,
0.0203418769,
-0.0033168707,
-0.0394532941,
-0.0136567177,
0.0095676417,
0.0093274293,
0.0392818227,
0.0289826375,
0.021172652,
0.0927776396,
-0.0866241679,
0.022844851,
0.0023263271,
0.0242092293,
0.0268333089,
-0.0065753954,
-0.0149543975,
-0.0015354513,
-0.0602775514,
-0.0115708522,
-0.0154116293,
-0.0261789933,
-0.0058462997,
0.0244440418,
0.0288266297,
0.0381789804,
0.025769718,
-0.0101539902,
0.0141853094,
0.0397838689,
-0.0326270387,
0.0128962109,
0.0106591042,
-0.0180301238,
-0.0435945727,
0.0355433114,
0.0163092576,
0.0645428523,
0.042333059,
-0.0405799337,
-0.0490394197,
0.0526391901,
-0.0392883867,
0.0989512429,
-0.0174300838,
0.0341677144,
0.0477917232,
0.0241945945,
0.0021986414,
0.0254074335,
0.0046583945,
0.0195770729,
-0.0471660346,
0.0155558586,
0.0185796767,
-0.0633177012,
0.0003508865,
0.0251318328,
-0.049262315,
0.0258010086,
0.0162806753,
-0.0345127806,
0.0215822514,
-0.0066886591,
-0.0384684019,
-0.0215664543,
-0.0264136605,
0.0323168561,
-0.0214117467,
0.049088724,
0.0273801349,
-0.0435240045,
-0.0232012104,
-0.006961836,
-0.0227511376,
-0.0206338018,
-0.018649254,
0.0110854227,
-0.0249792021,
-0.0300377738,
0.0052044829,
0.0090797134,
0.0511767641,
-0.0342017673,
-0.0302642174,
-0.0296504442,
0.0502580516,
-0.0650364235,
0.0591191761,
-0.0084768375,
-0.0524536707,
-0.0356762446,
-0.0049064839,
0.0103087164,
0.0521352403,
-0.0179934986,
0.0351117328,
-0.0156409629,
0.0093391147,
-0.0620264933,
-0.0123444824,
-0.049374979,
0.0099966647,
-0.0359139331,
0.0097831888,
-0.0015611643,
0.0672045574,
0.0182352401,
0.0145657957,
-0.025640158,
-0.0146416714,
-0.0140241105,
-0.0180201791,
-0.0147176012,
-0.014501635,
-0.0144838402,
0.039516028,
-0.0330493078,
0.0224364661,
0.0201305058,
-0.0717452019,
0.0073277862,
-0.0382915847,
-0.0695520043,
-0.0510379374,
0.024428118,
0.0218427889,
0.0402427018,
0.0202650167,
-0.0275993086,
0.0038198207,
-0.0219657198,
0.0036461055,
0.0035233716,
0.0327460133,
-0.0196499862,
0.0166322831,
0.0124595305,
-0.0514689125,
-0.0030545674,
0.009459029,
-0.0432671085,
0.0517914146,
0.0173831023,
-0.0249263234,
-0.0171048921,
-0.0016920622,
-0.0104934797,
0.0797726437,
0.0025876802,
0.0240005143,
-0.0282774344,
0.0185210425,
0.0596783198,
-0.0046921363,
0.0118390089,
0.0004209269,
0.0547632165,
0.0443305634,
0.0598054118,
0.0214391388,
-0.0796479881,
-0.024700541,
0.0287932064,
-0.0131168626,
-0.0011066425,
0.022685457,
0.0490011573,
-0.027016012,
-0.0300335065,
0.0813297182,
0.0179046728,
0.0158338249,
0.021543622,
0.0208049305,
0.0885033682,
0.0005351416,
-0.0303967167,
-0.0454858094,
-0.0243171342,
0.0380120203,
0.0231662784,
-0.0249163341,
0.0208018068,
0.0230136774,
-0.109831281,
0.0258613508,
0.0164469685,
-0.1016278192,
-0.000060478,
-0.0479837842,
-0.0122128148,
-0.0434302986,
0.0627266839,
-0.0291901212,
0.0078378106,
-0.0410537496,
0.0518679917,
-0.0843952447,
-0.0746142492,
0.0152819147,
-0.0333805084,
0.1030002162,
0.012965044,
0.013319578,
0.0032217938,
-0.0729325041,
0.0145869059,
0.0001051836,
0.0331219248,
-0.017056372,
0.0609077699,
0.0174654853,
-0.0118233263,
0.0042535951,
0.0081546893,
-0.027464522,
-0.0142684588,
-0.0065052276,
0.0037440925,
-0.0419914313,
-0.0118943742,
0.0317698047,
0.0191855431,
0.0086157983,
0.0462983586,
0.025864495,
-0.0016292762,
-0.0075819618,
-0.0203569438,
0.0925910398,
-0.0310109146,
-0.0181259774,
0.0132809775,
-0.0055187987,
-0.0698250309,
-0.0108739082,
-0.0201758295,
-0.0091895303,
0.031702064,
0.0077521694,
-0.0006170405,
-0.0073790471,
-0.0179838333,
-0.0391373262,
0.0084967241,
-0.0193272792,
0.0029352193,
-0.0651235878,
0.0064220564,
0.0792759806,
-0.0345206633,
-0.0346890055,
-0.0353046246,
-0.0880783349,
-0.0771269575,
0.0159739405,
0.0147419786,
0.0266219936,
0.0298882872,
-0.0309492517,
-0.0883193314,
0.0373983122,
-0.0091017224,
-0.036598634,
0.0014746414,
0.0570174791,
0.0055181263,
0.0031296173,
0.0141498325,
-0.0208424721,
0.0448584184,
0.0184094571,
0.0358385779,
-0.0269319415,
-0.029552551,
0.0048150932,
0.039488472,
0.0798184723,
0.0206262078,
-0.0434708036,
-0.026034655,
0.0448752716,
0.0364564545,
0.0458278395,
-0.0285526551,
0.0009379235,
0.066104196,
0.0373072475,
-0.0115762521,
0.0120955314,
-0.0223850794,
-0.010726722,
-0.0169554204,
-0.00109229,
0.0698188841,
0.0373660624,
0.0174242072,
0.0554833598,
-0.0371616632,
0.0583985262,
0.0777136832,
0.0262459144,
0.0268969573,
0.0247992259,
0.0216086805,
0.039295122,
0.0333732143,
0.0060543609,
-0.05735882,
-0.0344413705,
-0.0590191782,
0.0330894254,
0.0014081652,
0.0285445843,
0.0477173738,
-0.0049639703,
0.0095436051,
-0.0417905189,
0.0564262308,
-0.0020512245,
-0.0457008518,
0.0474570394,
-0.0088164127,
-0.0306391045,
0.0530025102,
0.0494310744,
0.0116630029,
0.0554943569,
-0.000707216,
0.0143490704,
-0.0341768041,
-0.0412597097,
-0.002206252,
0.0166152678,
-0.0366832428,
-0.0079288166,
-0.0119488528,
-0.0987071991,
0.0149716111,
-0.0068732374,
-0.0052214554,
-0.0178935528,
-0.0006988565,
0.0001471255,
0.0006727658,
0.0012328865,
0.0045850794,
-0.0605848059,
-0.0221730471,
-0.0319233388,
-0.0120411068,
-6.497753674e-33,
-0.020435866,
0.0228592847,
-0.0083977897,
0.045293685,
-0.0148229282,
0.0341711231,
-0.0444102734,
-0.0038346609,
-0.0606100336,
0.0131566236,
0.0346737094,
-0.0211294014,
0.0376517102,
0.0468459614,
-0.0308639053,
-0.0465649217,
0.0677110031,
0.0084525775,
0.0137889916,
-0.049033612,
-0.0013323377,
0.0080125136,
0.0254203528,
-0.0323650688,
-0.0583848134,
0.0240364503,
-0.0433679819,
0.0147046847,
0.006413985,
0.0693542957,
-0.0124513265,
0.1005983949,
-0.0128905298,
0.0040770588,
-0.0080339657,
0.0019848193,
-0.0448943749,
-0.0212391447,
-0.0254325196,
0.0638783723,
-0.0102297915,
-0.0199144166,
0.0210856423,
0.0132193193,
-0.0648019016,
-0.0095138121,
0.0237121806,
0.0083163548,
-0.0618247092,
-0.0486082099,
-0.0108440248,
0.0090144193,
0.0086291349,
-0.0322394148,
0.0691645741,
0.0291124787,
-0.0008973893,
-0.0441057719,
-0.0823875666,
0.0356377698,
0.0319034532,
0.0476273708,
0.0111968657,
-0.0352431014,
-0.0350020304,
0.0088263163,
0.1102136374,
-0.0512625761,
0.0151511524,
-0.046364408,
0.0742486343,
0.0412418768,
0.0013881141,
-0.0049639572,
0.0192008018,
-0.0063705561,
-0.0089448458,
-0.0444848239,
-0.002266983,
0.026324885,
-0.0008333907,
0.0337928981,
-0.0339699984,
-0.0386014543,
-0.0392918512,
-0.0579462759,
-0.0424344055,
-0.0076615014,
0.0718532279,
0.0298326351,
0.034976624,
0.0332645625,
0.0151388487,
-0.0288917683,
0.0111268936,
-0.0028329266,
0.0410156585,
0.0266924463,
-0.0384722836,
0.0271601174,
-0.073526673,
-0.0449041873,
-0.0084232129,
0.0471611246,
0.017317174,
-0.0261840262,
0.0462614112,
0.046326194,
-0.055624906,
-0.0049116258,
-0.0402236432,
-0.0101318546,
0.028366413,
0.0071684173,
0.0177005623,
-0.0431411788,
-0.0131574543,
0.0628023222,
-0.0205413941,
0.0189600717,
-0.0235766601,
0.0008014222,
0.0233709812,
0.0398017243,
-0.061424315,
-0.0018285693,
0.0115530398,
-0.0797111541,
0.0178655852,
-0.003783945,
-0.0275822226,
-0.0119493864,
2.647e-7,
0.0086970096,
0.0024562734,
0.0169429053,
0.0161349196,
-0.0283652972,
0.0212496333,
0.0048518702,
-0.0209755655,
-0.0021961608,
0.0326468349,
-0.0182770956,
-0.0031318527,
0.0706860125,
0.0051229196,
-0.0700883418,
0.0325576514,
-0.1056870967,
0.0056879288,
-0.0275305603,
0.0153915836,
0.0011770097,
0.1096842214,
0.003790128,
-0.0134631218,
0.0042109871,
0.0084750112,
0.052810438,
-0.0206617936,
-0.0138410823,
0.0185388289,
0.0157281924,
-0.0104943933,
-0.0150927808,
0.0280599967,
-0.0270167179,
-0.0164835267,
0.0171057768,
0.0052471277,
-0.0499463081,
-0.1299981624,
-0.0140873902,
0.0433267131,
-0.0055436767,
-0.0266313944,
0.0118092699,
-0.0006592909,
-0.0235106647,
0.01355928,
-0.0397041924,
0.0269080233,
0.0268159527,
-0.0086798565,
0.0319653191,
-0.0293256938,
0.0106621711,
-0.0052277138,
-0.054034505,
-0.0468169823,
-0.0231985524,
0.0012275967,
-0.0074318815,
0.0126841571,
0.0140687237,
0.0160117038,
-0.0348922014,
-0.0114899604,
-0.0053251646,
2.088855298e-34,
0.0440542847,
-0.0113942688,
-0.0010532823,
0.0238087885,
0.0315528512,
-0.0314659216,
-0.0027079938,
0.0336518921,
-0.038731169,
-0.0183608811,
-0.0231175032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10346v1 | Interventional Probing in High Dimensions: An NLI Case Study | 2023-04-20T14:34:31 | 2023-04-20T14:34:31 | Julia Rozanova, Marco Valentino, Lucas Cordeiro, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Probing strategies have been shown to detect the presence of various
linguistic features in large language models; in particular, semantic features
intermediate to the "natural logic" fragment of the Natural Language Inference
task (NLI). In the case of natural logic, the relation between the intermediate
features and the entailment label is explicitly known: as such, this provides a
ripe setting for interventional studies on the NLI models' representations,
allowing for stronger causal conjectures and a deeper critical analysis of
interventional probing methods. In this work, we carry out new and existing
representation-level interventions to investigate the effect of these semantic
features on NLI classification: we perform amnesic probing (which removes
features as directed by learned linear probes) and introduce the mnestic
probing variation (which forgets all dimensions except the probe-selected
ones). Furthermore, we delve into the limitations of these methods and outline
some pitfalls have been obscuring the effectivity of interventional probing
studies. | [
0.0154563067,
0.0491385683,
-0.0427557379,
0.0377781801,
-0.067350477,
0.0436037369,
0.0067811883,
0.006602847,
0.0423476622,
-0.053589277,
0.001474034,
-0.0022250067,
-0.0187007785,
0.0412926637,
0.0339327529,
0.0104725519,
0.0794038326,
-0.0061597181,
0.0003064382,
-0.011209582,
-0.0568559505,
-0.015314688,
-0.0179927777,
0.0025636947,
-0.0080114519,
0.0065853056,
-0.0131473718,
-0.0141460877,
-0.0137557257,
-0.0032818394,
-0.0211728215,
0.0662087798,
0.0343953408,
0.0322943479,
0.0000019347,
-0.0530531965,
-0.0045984844,
0.0004030708,
-0.0268909633,
-0.0062231468,
0.0215594154,
-0.0506635085,
0.0375484936,
-0.0065651522,
0.0119069712,
-0.0260780528,
0.033850681,
0.1047992706,
0.0135261323,
0.0593953244,
-0.0122671919,
-0.0655901283,
0.0367030539,
-0.0030852025,
0.0131180314,
-0.0180864539,
0.0338696279,
-0.0260285791,
-0.0107254116,
0.0053638257,
-0.0415504761,
0.0242814105,
0.0411282554,
0.0427656695,
-0.0021531642,
0.0262545757,
0.0228382405,
-0.0123403734,
0.0324681737,
0.0278654117,
0.0076083159,
-0.0148619395,
0.0013588616,
0.0007392716,
0.0266982522,
0.031208206,
-0.0150337499,
0.0027223707,
-0.0004637417,
0.0029208895,
0.1109861881,
-0.0175618194,
0.0575384609,
0.012515652,
-0.0517233573,
0.0832458362,
0.0454612486,
-0.0430943817,
0.0208118241,
0.0419144928,
0.0060711978,
-0.0084574725,
-0.0278450958,
-0.0286877081,
-0.0179961752,
-0.0023093258,
0.0228039324,
-0.0128370542,
-0.0345744044,
-0.00666322,
0.028656166,
0.0472596809,
-0.0113122845,
0.0314627364,
-0.0571656637,
0.0376560129,
-0.0422408842,
0.0538570471,
-0.0288900156,
-0.0153645072,
-0.0206920654,
-0.0460409559,
-0.0279349927,
0.0372641087,
-0.0059226523,
-0.0098426444,
-0.023079766,
0.0039669378,
-0.0281884558,
-0.0127684334,
-0.0836187378,
-0.0028379948,
-0.0177746397,
0.0159083698,
-0.0373530015,
0.0222959723,
-0.0735010207,
0.048792284,
-0.0392831154,
-0.0269794259,
-0.0463452414,
0.0321856625,
0.0366978012,
-0.0417581983,
0.0641571581,
0.0849311575,
0.0184936598,
-0.0431908555,
-0.0183554087,
-0.0285395887,
-0.011634904,
-0.0296140239,
0.0531789735,
-0.0351544991,
-0.0213838574,
0.0111846486,
-0.0060909181,
-0.0403488688,
-0.0284888707,
-0.0229072366,
-0.0565907955,
0.0746458918,
0.034871038,
-0.0228739269,
-0.0332687236,
-0.0130837727,
0.0117002586,
0.0488610491,
-0.0202966668,
-0.0130688027,
0.0035585982,
0.005207574,
0.0160380714,
0.0053070602,
0.0380440056,
0.0279958788,
-0.062700659,
-0.0208736435,
0.0184443109,
0.0266693793,
0.0119191427,
0.0055549387,
-0.0260570552,
-0.0226043612,
-0.0089122839,
0.0707675293,
-0.0036474077,
0.0116549162,
0.0348709337,
-0.0487697907,
-0.0213403609,
0.0768432617,
-0.0728518218,
0.0235349704,
-0.0865330845,
-0.0197822228,
0.0017229565,
-0.0058666696,
-0.0200801361,
-0.0509465933,
-0.0102407411,
-0.0004624711,
-0.0018312247,
-0.0017857357,
0.0650457665,
0.0344062708,
0.0063933558,
0.0414805599,
0.0277029406,
-0.0231342074,
0.0348327868,
-0.0574677512,
0.0247247163,
-0.0029356359,
0.0317528956,
-0.0696259588,
-0.0090309363,
0.0030523378,
-0.0251706429,
0.0335865282,
0.0018201069,
-0.0090982998,
-0.0046481784,
0.0014331627,
-0.0039758552,
-0.0492111444,
0.0732193366,
-0.0075454619,
-0.0253732353,
-0.0055697053,
-0.0219616406,
-0.0468531922,
0.0094934907,
0.0508411899,
0.0131320776,
-0.0270671099,
-0.0062692696,
0.045360975,
0.0291059483,
0.0166840069,
-0.0255804025,
0.0091585191,
0.0084951827,
-0.0666380897,
-0.0555172525,
0.0007320365,
-0.0060211201,
-0.061329931,
-0.0072669392,
-0.0593307056,
-0.0195980091,
0.0250293538,
-0.0392131172,
-0.033812549,
0.0585581139,
-0.0449883118,
0.0120174317,
-0.0266277809,
-0.0303393137,
0.0061762431,
-0.0079030534,
-0.0401388295,
0.0840050653,
0.0096616996,
0.0381333046,
-0.0087867193,
-0.0072714454,
0.0008857266,
-0.0008142201,
-0.018868234,
0.0462068878,
0.0005830872,
-0.0218188353,
0.0221721567,
-0.0381120332,
-0.0270272624,
-0.0452066027,
-0.061858166,
-0.0122072557,
-0.0081008952,
-0.0085082892,
-0.0090842871,
0.0071439189,
0.0039203246,
-0.0246524923,
-0.0240406375,
-0.0394797251,
0.0330161713,
0.0554987006,
0.0386428535,
-0.0361379124,
-0.0026717503,
0.0006043401,
-0.0192747395,
-0.0588012412,
0.0640831217,
-0.0158068314,
-0.0360897928,
-0.0250143521,
-0.0368493348,
-0.0222612806,
0.0074524349,
0.0107462909,
-0.0292247366,
0.0004243212,
-0.0325984843,
-0.0049789972,
0.0804998577,
-0.0469335578,
0.0807934403,
0.0513398722,
0.0070319022,
-0.0099235997,
0.0064871046,
-0.0357005149,
0.0260724798,
-0.0363594927,
0.0107698189,
0.0118226605,
0.0900935829,
-0.0048887255,
-0.0289277136,
-0.0359570272,
0.0672177225,
-0.0467093997,
-0.0335068889,
-0.0317174979,
0.0201234147,
0.001682632,
0.0512023084,
0.0014011245,
-0.0280666947,
0.0851313025,
0.0303950422,
-0.0117153274,
-0.0696932301,
-0.0343918242,
-0.0361292399,
0.0679463744,
0.0311968457,
0.0066661695,
0.0305483211,
-0.0525661446,
-0.0443492457,
-0.0065536564,
0.0364682786,
0.0332186818,
0.0374550037,
-0.0390649363,
0.0230371263,
0.0140959835,
-0.0280672498,
-0.0400665961,
-0.0512327105,
-0.040679723,
-0.0180728529,
-0.0409024358,
-0.0072073434,
-0.0176096614,
-0.0176259819,
0.0086914655,
0.0440235697,
-0.0066637299,
0.0059788539,
-0.0591462255,
0.0419546477,
0.0258096438,
0.0357077979,
0.0167469457,
-0.005849096,
0.0154666966,
0.0285776034,
-0.0949796587,
0.0251167826,
-0.0066053225,
0.0796887949,
0.0199835002,
-0.0125548579,
-0.0210341197,
0.0057181315,
-0.0027572932,
-0.0309027899,
-0.0342242531,
0.0791958943,
0.0368798822,
-0.0186491702,
0.021657303,
0.0175753348,
0.006099374,
0.0236213375,
-0.0139092961,
-0.0704538748,
-0.0420753434,
0.0283989999,
-0.0267896894,
-0.0348892473,
0.000383342,
0.0143807046,
-0.0892414302,
0.032547947,
-0.0198390149,
-0.0674235076,
-0.0477606654,
-0.0649734661,
0.0361740366,
-0.0007009141,
0.0158242937,
-0.0313040018,
0.0005083531,
0.0173716936,
-0.0264679492,
0.0343759619,
-0.071934171,
-0.0006270199,
-0.0218860824,
0.0343458131,
0.0222821571,
0.0028575771,
-0.0470745191,
-0.0093365246,
0.0050350153,
-0.0002027577,
0.0273889173,
-0.0287142713,
0.0595142432,
0.0157257263,
0.0000891679,
-0.0532080643,
0.063120462,
-0.0321475305,
-0.0371584669,
-0.0129345898,
0.094276242,
-0.0474205092,
-0.04044668,
-0.0003913054,
-0.0067800209,
-0.0430747829,
0.0852817893,
0.033847101,
-0.0461023897,
-0.0171270967,
-0.0016418233,
-0.0170632899,
0.0395926982,
-0.0846031234,
0.0167822689,
0.0398601033,
-0.0252644271,
-0.0388163365,
-0.0751186684,
0.0297839791,
0.029280562,
-0.0076523554,
0.0183293018,
-0.0102231158,
-0.0044445023,
-0.0167084336,
0.0662049875,
-0.0416914858,
0.0031006818,
0.0230482314,
0.0365875326,
0.0225447938,
0.0062409248,
-0.0414561853,
-0.0137836132,
-0.0488928668,
-0.053278055,
-0.0224339906,
0.0039793244,
0.02591566,
0.0376247466,
-0.0417497419,
-0.0023248014,
0.0001029234,
0.00089223,
-0.0051008505,
0.0446874164,
0.0514912121,
-0.0336436592,
0.0080230543,
0.0623627864,
-0.0154948905,
-0.0011974423,
0.0437183529,
0.0175865032,
-0.0036587173,
-0.0447153524,
0.0343955345,
0.0010879834,
0.0907212719,
0.0411245562,
-0.0386928581,
-0.0295350254,
-0.0062499288,
-0.0163723715,
-0.0451331437,
0.0037509352,
0.0160025973,
0.0306191854,
0.0573370792,
-0.0307081826,
-0.0081840837,
-0.0055158897,
0.0434290208,
-0.0154498946,
-0.0156149203,
0.023413904,
-0.009824439,
-0.0128585817,
0.0242449902,
-0.0386902913,
0.0094674695,
-0.0197342113,
0.0483305305,
-0.0328671597,
0.0177041031,
0.0572433807,
-0.0024169879,
-0.0939590633,
-0.0399012566,
-0.0821748152,
-0.0096629858,
0.0497636236,
0.0519976765,
0.0573075488,
-0.0387838297,
-0.007626405,
-0.0113270227,
-0.032902658,
0.0144744823,
0.0365908854,
0.0424902402,
-0.0199668631,
0.051406648,
0.0059957812,
-0.0170735121,
-0.033136256,
-0.002416634,
-0.0094493981,
0.0718942806,
-0.0120686768,
0.0370838083,
-0.0226341188,
-0.0609489232,
-0.0006290204,
0.0117071047,
-0.0331853479,
0.069768928,
-0.0886233896,
-0.0632959157,
-0.0047242818,
-0.0161878467,
-0.0270299409,
-0.0299286805,
-0.0034567364,
0.0331746601,
0.0499251261,
-0.0559363179,
0.0104921814,
-0.0018343279,
-0.0177859515,
-0.0271852221,
-0.0225356631,
-6.397976979e-33,
-0.0218513478,
-0.0291951671,
0.004859522,
-0.037068069,
0.0021049629,
-0.0028806841,
-0.0181007981,
-0.0097120311,
-0.0159015059,
0.0402433276,
0.0021177456,
0.027745543,
0.0067227976,
-0.0002113133,
-0.0000265596,
-0.0306605995,
0.0356197804,
0.0265837479,
-0.0208178628,
0.0119986394,
0.0056502856,
-0.008433491,
0.0689034611,
-0.036216978,
0.0264138542,
0.0158032738,
0.0373567231,
0.0606373623,
-0.0781418607,
0.0145410122,
-0.0127922744,
0.007676811,
0.0512859188,
-0.0318896659,
0.0469895788,
-0.0022318675,
-0.052649226,
-0.0894609839,
0.034580674,
0.0203048978,
-0.0494336374,
-0.0567982607,
0.0161442235,
-0.0030535327,
0.0008932686,
-0.0230158288,
0.0414884575,
-0.004451856,
-0.0021624798,
0.0136103043,
-0.0814361349,
0.0065481327,
-0.0036089483,
0.0262997784,
0.0098652449,
0.0519953109,
0.0146382852,
-0.0177700166,
-0.0203556847,
-0.0164563507,
0.0197145287,
0.0098866066,
0.0032613797,
0.044607617,
-0.0041228537,
0.0549203418,
0.0460035913,
0.001136707,
-0.0586877465,
0.0221104734,
0.0513327084,
0.0204077885,
0.0422654562,
0.0272259824,
0.0530454032,
0.0517485626,
-0.0579851046,
-0.0427137986,
0.027356023,
0.0456656478,
0.0135074211,
-0.018890623,
-0.0229777005,
-0.0249420032,
-0.0723919794,
-0.020969389,
-0.0478608608,
-0.0115538146,
0.0162178744,
-0.0198800303,
-0.0049673985,
-0.0299643427,
0.0209190156,
-0.0216987301,
0.0332054496,
0.0191015638,
0.0138413385,
0.0194208138,
0.0221737307,
0.031039251,
-0.0102382749,
-0.039640177,
-0.0058574812,
-0.0223963838,
0.038721215,
0.0042510452,
0.0084905578,
-0.0029883615,
-0.0079445401,
-0.0139152696,
-0.0316043347,
-0.051194448,
-0.004416503,
0.0388925783,
0.0707946271,
0.0658719465,
-0.0015734008,
0.031634286,
0.0273898877,
0.05445062,
-0.0413029231,
0.0185286403,
-0.0050634537,
0.0126096345,
-0.0249156859,
-0.0240762495,
-0.0162187405,
-0.0066542327,
0.0062128943,
-0.0697718188,
-0.0077422606,
-0.0091949338,
2.789e-7,
0.0141581232,
0.0363437384,
0.0193887912,
0.0614233315,
0.0184457358,
0.0330016948,
0.0103076296,
0.0115537895,
0.0149058243,
-0.0245129168,
0.0269435439,
0.0221753027,
0.0256207176,
0.0239677485,
-0.0766353533,
0.0565782897,
-0.0027440251,
-0.0022025239,
-0.02187079,
0.0301819816,
0.1067896783,
0.0885693431,
0.0263937935,
-0.0136762885,
-0.0110819917,
-0.037400689,
0.0430844799,
0.0135675995,
-0.0012043805,
-0.0306395013,
0.0167097263,
0.0106031606,
0.0412919857,
0.0765723214,
0.028198272,
0.0348323099,
-0.0241358895,
0.0246294662,
-0.0126291877,
-0.0037662967,
-0.0721383914,
-0.0342972353,
-0.0145842535,
-0.0099619525,
0.0943568572,
-0.0691368133,
-0.0456834957,
-0.0253669769,
0.0192647297,
-0.0083226999,
0.0232833028,
0.0165073518,
0.0087098861,
0.0180197004,
0.0288456473,
-0.0150472419,
0.0115880398,
-0.0512027629,
0.0128104715,
0.0559538007,
-0.0272743441,
-0.0332234576,
0.0039790235,
0.0040846686,
0.0657684952,
-0.0601435117,
-0.0196805168,
2.81425424e-34,
0.0251320712,
-0.0134615395,
0.0456994399,
0.0008249432,
0.041743286,
-0.0235673729,
-0.0373761766,
-0.0023833157,
0.0537695102,
-0.114088349,
0.0139448969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10327v2 | Towards a Benchmark for Scientific Understanding in Humans and Machines | 2023-04-20T14:05:53 | 2023-04-21T08:57:06 | Kristian Gonzalez Barman, Sascha Caron, Tom Claassen, Henk de Regt | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, hep-ph, physics.hist-ph | Scientific understanding is a fundamental goal of science, allowing us to
explain the world. There is currently no good way to measure the scientific
understanding of agents, whether these be humans or Artificial Intelligence
systems. Without a clear benchmark, it is challenging to evaluate and compare
different levels of and approaches to scientific understanding. In this
Roadmap, we propose a framework to create a benchmark for scientific
understanding, utilizing tools from philosophy of science. We adopt a
behavioral notion according to which genuine understanding should be recognized
as an ability to perform certain tasks. We extend this notion by considering a
set of questions that can gauge different levels of scientific understanding,
covering information retrieval, the capability to arrange information to
produce an explanation, and the ability to infer how things would be different
under different circumstances. The Scientific Understanding Benchmark (SUB),
which is formed by a set of these tests, allows for the evaluation and
comparison of different approaches. Benchmarking plays a crucial role in
establishing trust, ensuring quality control, and providing a basis for
performance evaluation. By aligning machine and human scientific understanding
we can improve their utility, ultimately advancing scientific understanding and
helping to discover new insights within machines. | [
-0.0048474576,
0.0295235924,
-0.0008067819,
0.017389087,
-0.0195952486,
-0.0004966796,
-0.0112241134,
0.0317071974,
-0.0102178641,
0.0190025475,
-0.0016603913,
0.0191561654,
-0.0123387342,
0.032355953,
-0.0165532418,
-0.0727535114,
0.0650119483,
0.0092325117,
0.0477916859,
0.0001773073,
-0.0512418933,
-0.0568902977,
-0.0151277231,
-0.0173794702,
0.027849786,
-0.0211384855,
0.0101441499,
-0.0153854396,
0.0667291954,
-0.0364451185,
-0.0305962618,
-0.0164667312,
0.0385707207,
0.0561259948,
0.0000018403,
-0.0619192682,
-0.0169852823,
0.0521247685,
-0.0559239388,
-0.0157197416,
0.0173926707,
-0.0169500243,
0.0321126767,
-0.0225047767,
-0.0355566368,
0.0470284857,
0.0209044088,
-0.0111881969,
0.0025321099,
0.0316035934,
0.011330951,
0.006748511,
0.0267165955,
0.0034659666,
0.0420888476,
-0.0400921144,
0.0069424375,
0.0718735158,
0.0414626412,
0.0176021326,
-0.0031372611,
0.0419992581,
0.0127965128,
-0.0035194256,
0.0456391461,
0.0358215049,
0.0139762145,
-0.0222637113,
0.0095947469,
0.0377589874,
0.0362574533,
-0.0040225945,
0.0263135508,
0.0064417366,
-0.0199965276,
0.0492679365,
-0.0645856783,
-0.0020647328,
-0.0181995705,
-0.0413136072,
-0.0270545073,
0.0558740757,
0.0463563986,
0.0318120196,
-0.0197088961,
0.0837778151,
-0.0192095488,
-0.0334803239,
0.0039910376,
-0.0164613612,
0.0597341806,
-0.0477739014,
0.0005336638,
0.0477599464,
-0.0470658019,
-0.005247178,
0.0499952883,
-0.0098921005,
0.040060211,
0.0135610569,
0.0306472406,
0.0290610548,
0.0539556071,
0.0649060756,
0.0354470424,
0.0750161484,
-0.0314453132,
0.0446465127,
-0.0166669805,
0.0037620175,
-0.1076753885,
-0.0291802231,
0.0326339304,
0.0078086001,
0.0152589465,
0.0260039028,
0.0056867762,
-0.0074349632,
-0.0294979755,
0.0203194898,
-0.0361099392,
-0.0114017827,
-0.0199153461,
-0.0124693112,
-0.0645558164,
0.0065986007,
-0.0869838893,
0.006997332,
-0.0013245953,
-0.0223471634,
-0.0136058666,
-0.0123071475,
-0.0005961309,
0.0037200563,
0.0151560055,
0.0367956646,
0.0529866405,
-0.0119737871,
0.0128619447,
-0.0678006634,
0.0524834096,
-0.0716703385,
0.0449362323,
0.0036945585,
0.0372345112,
0.0047809654,
-0.0102249151,
0.0070758001,
-0.0100893658,
-0.0056883912,
0.0021618421,
0.0637757182,
-0.059917856,
-0.0152834123,
0.0360865556,
0.0595338084,
-0.0393714271,
0.0256343354,
-0.0131917465,
0.0009170623,
0.0345977843,
-0.0018592539,
0.0014369525,
-0.0530221127,
0.011570775,
-0.0505421348,
0.0209311023,
0.0489832051,
-0.0478774458,
0.0713000074,
-0.0113959741,
0.0310520977,
-0.0393963195,
0.0013536271,
0.0146247074,
0.0591879897,
-0.0336008221,
0.0066602807,
0.0314605795,
-0.0270750001,
0.0348425396,
0.0212035403,
-0.0297190696,
0.063855499,
0.033491008,
0.0119599747,
0.0261486247,
-0.0282446835,
-0.0187438261,
-0.0729539022,
-0.0334920362,
0.0237521157,
0.0100588668,
-0.0093920687,
0.0490008406,
-0.0500981398,
0.0129911695,
-0.0331148654,
-0.0016615249,
-0.0038251579,
-0.0005744813,
-0.0334041901,
0.0306383092,
0.0109992949,
0.0266812984,
-0.082149148,
-0.0297175273,
0.025697872,
-0.0113271372,
0.0212599635,
0.072399877,
-0.0318470262,
-0.014417246,
0.0143473651,
-0.0278655849,
-0.0500680767,
-0.003083898,
-0.0222386606,
-0.0028493891,
0.0020020271,
-0.0096545164,
-0.0807873979,
-0.0163135454,
0.0566953719,
-0.0607309155,
-0.0088790953,
-0.043020919,
-0.0324462205,
0.0583205409,
0.0059212637,
-0.0094017666,
0.0221669711,
0.0618598424,
0.0026542204,
-0.0086627109,
0.0266841035,
0.0227893237,
0.0064707762,
-0.0017069337,
-0.1107179224,
-0.0411850959,
0.0646364838,
-0.0051863897,
-0.0428541563,
0.0045776153,
-0.0118584186,
-0.0213692002,
-0.0198925175,
-0.0020366635,
-0.0871473104,
-0.0189921446,
-0.0223583225,
0.0618722998,
-0.0057692844,
0.0234443098,
0.0102149211,
-0.0285629313,
0.0596348569,
-0.033839006,
-0.0258051306,
-0.0219307207,
-0.0024057771,
-0.0245869048,
0.0439872444,
-0.0475012027,
-0.0610183254,
0.0323121138,
-0.020410087,
-0.0221888945,
0.0100326659,
0.0014615487,
-0.0048881467,
-0.0537578166,
0.0136580691,
0.0020569889,
0.0387721173,
0.03393545,
0.0024739453,
-0.012858565,
0.083095938,
0.0391005427,
-0.0183985289,
-0.0400444977,
0.0277926549,
-0.0601474866,
-0.0016562487,
0.0795832574,
0.0227876287,
-0.0508616306,
-0.0123839499,
-0.0360483974,
-0.0102571994,
-0.0403019376,
-0.0082273716,
0.0817851797,
0.0008051303,
-0.0599524714,
0.0890669227,
0.0190215409,
0.0330880843,
0.0557127371,
0.0311102383,
-0.0136432312,
-0.0016434878,
-0.0316296592,
0.0175502356,
-0.0109938094,
-0.0123242559,
0.0568528511,
0.015246775,
-0.0366867967,
0.0115008252,
-0.0349587277,
0.0653085262,
-0.0326291993,
-0.0592950322,
-0.0184624176,
-0.0080268132,
-0.0274874438,
0.0654340759,
-0.0202900898,
-0.0297415629,
0.0948320851,
0.0023275693,
0.0231490359,
-0.0496850684,
0.0248783268,
0.0115934554,
0.0559499376,
-0.0110067353,
0.029335551,
0.0052008885,
0.0223474633,
-0.0213088077,
0.0205930527,
0.0063685225,
-0.0032583529,
-0.030826509,
-0.0685368776,
0.0143817812,
0.027362695,
-0.0317164473,
-0.0358508565,
0.0392284244,
-0.0256958269,
0.0363996364,
-0.0052366834,
-0.0645804331,
-0.0489660576,
-0.0300183017,
0.0520352162,
-0.0228763595,
0.0179532189,
-0.0376099944,
-0.0123293847,
-0.0711462051,
0.0092477174,
0.0310852043,
0.0403808244,
-0.0461159125,
0.0348246843,
0.030824706,
0.04565835,
0.0049943924,
-0.0064084763,
-0.0097893551,
-0.0039235936,
-0.0194428582,
0.0295008421,
0.0061859791,
0.0513699464,
-0.0206627324,
-0.0421510004,
0.0867188647,
0.0068577626,
-0.0193384755,
0.001376982,
-0.0582535639,
-0.0507273152,
0.0229869243,
0.0352598689,
-0.0524495915,
0.0071675288,
-0.0103840716,
0.0503142402,
-0.0173094831,
-0.0530621484,
0.0030534654,
-0.0387476161,
0.0148554659,
-0.0257031415,
-0.0547732227,
-0.0517762564,
-0.0866093412,
0.0040161572,
-0.0282914266,
-0.0366098508,
0.0239607934,
0.0483077206,
-0.0417249314,
0.0077109355,
0.023803236,
-0.0769781247,
0.0425490439,
-0.0402345061,
0.0123559842,
0.0278742686,
0.0582717173,
-0.0410818346,
-0.073322542,
-0.0623355247,
0.0031914006,
0.0370616838,
0.0265371762,
0.0331851318,
0.021434607,
0.0023292946,
-0.0320420116,
0.0360131636,
-0.0151327774,
-0.0042304206,
-0.0102824932,
0.0939955562,
-0.0182026234,
-0.0442753509,
-0.0684584081,
-0.0374055021,
-0.0238017123,
0.1075508967,
0.0063164551,
0.0208591446,
-0.0450168513,
0.010283622,
0.0120496135,
-0.0182398986,
0.0002219714,
0.0140294153,
-0.0028723385,
0.0190408006,
-0.0593750998,
-0.007663263,
-0.0137729915,
0.0284881163,
-0.0008541619,
-0.0288100485,
0.0418578386,
-0.006488191,
-0.0630307943,
0.0024118819,
0.0139683159,
0.0013059673,
-0.012860164,
-0.0253789406,
0.0143975038,
0.0021925424,
-0.0278912019,
-0.0216800477,
0.0043442519,
-0.0120414458,
0.0121943066,
0.0529794693,
0.0354577824,
0.0116476128,
-0.0116618723,
-0.0423300751,
0.0182662066,
-0.0010110188,
-0.0148358718,
0.0056868377,
-0.0155154001,
-0.0266520511,
-0.0295479093,
-0.0258191787,
-0.0200153776,
0.0042638388,
-0.0412711687,
-0.0186161175,
-0.0503804386,
-0.0205779672,
0.0161336362,
0.0567950308,
0.0391039327,
-0.0043375026,
-0.0376488008,
0.0195606351,
-0.0402516723,
-0.003706167,
-0.0049195709,
-0.0126850205,
-0.0323403403,
0.0092547406,
-0.0018322709,
0.0133087551,
0.0106281722,
-0.0410282798,
-0.0188528188,
-0.0296043735,
0.0129367746,
-0.0026182793,
0.049583938,
-0.0073617082,
0.0184851848,
-0.0206389893,
-0.0409400985,
-0.041369956,
0.0798958614,
0.0126478439,
0.0402681977,
0.0683061108,
0.0467820019,
-0.0272874869,
-0.0011390678,
-0.1484619826,
-0.0467758067,
0.0155455722,
-0.0074648536,
-0.0144109493,
0.0396667458,
-0.0284418557,
-0.0403311551,
-0.0040966743,
-0.00100109,
0.0058056931,
0.019539319,
0.0168195479,
0.0379034393,
0.0513076037,
-0.0125292074,
-0.0307935532,
0.0657343194,
-0.034427505,
0.0427275002,
-0.0652938485,
-0.0014585312,
-0.0376357734,
-0.0001100451,
-0.0517092831,
0.0243012924,
0.0174564887,
-0.0115578827,
-0.0637692437,
-0.0413375124,
0.0494642928,
0.0750291198,
0.0315889269,
0.0013665428,
0.0281297974,
0.0440296233,
-0.0256228186,
-0.0413770601,
0.0221101977,
0.0260462444,
-0.0787799656,
-0.0110855531,
-0.0272862017,
-5.928380578e-33,
-0.0008923628,
-0.0253943764,
0.0270387456,
-0.0093310606,
-0.0072783208,
0.0302641764,
-0.0755324289,
-0.048319526,
-0.0549378693,
0.051159624,
-0.0032203926,
-0.003358996,
-0.0122550875,
-0.0632807836,
0.0258796886,
0.003054389,
0.0211743452,
-0.0089335581,
-0.0430295579,
-0.006456214,
0.0471799858,
-0.0033634186,
0.005128264,
-0.0706715137,
0.0254731197,
-0.0040871082,
0.0040824534,
0.0667500272,
-0.0218660515,
0.0220022332,
-0.0022142194,
0.0021079918,
0.0183909144,
-0.0195285883,
0.0009218106,
-0.013576421,
-0.0298941992,
-0.0348189883,
0.0007011237,
-0.0223675109,
-0.0408218987,
-0.0116155921,
0.0151215596,
0.0050762324,
-0.0328605287,
-0.0215396378,
0.0580379032,
-0.0088130627,
0.0185470153,
-0.0318186693,
-0.0206943024,
0.0268702097,
-0.0470706895,
0.0046438323,
0.0248507354,
0.0401052162,
-0.001195405,
0.0363410674,
-0.0296675805,
0.0757800117,
-0.0021974826,
-0.0506574921,
0.0456695445,
-0.002976649,
0.0456820093,
0.0916228145,
0.0445136093,
0.0141952531,
0.013415318,
-0.0254161321,
0.0124878353,
0.064214766,
0.0400290899,
0.0717424676,
0.0463373549,
0.0203544497,
-0.0711619928,
0.0840873569,
0.0025338389,
0.0362380296,
-0.0157521553,
0.0484384857,
-0.0186788496,
0.0002241035,
-0.0235693697,
-0.0301844925,
-0.0154058747,
0.0105895828,
0.0106977643,
-0.0368302315,
-0.0364917479,
0.0053193872,
0.0289867204,
-0.0510059893,
0.0612772442,
0.0078293951,
0.0369698852,
0.0181005448,
0.0436795205,
-0.0039874595,
-0.0505961701,
-0.0435988009,
-0.0029279815,
0.0664099604,
0.079737097,
-0.0108640594,
-0.0308670793,
-0.0150989471,
0.069694452,
-0.0199528672,
-0.0002458341,
-0.0702623203,
0.0134734446,
-0.0439972989,
0.0268159732,
0.0428701863,
-0.0053095315,
0.014085317,
0.010324155,
0.0237983372,
-0.014913395,
0.0608786531,
-0.0072864117,
0.007600639,
0.00072826,
-0.0381945036,
-0.02536048,
-0.0160362683,
-0.0142300213,
-0.0531308427,
0.008086537,
0.038216982,
2.727e-7,
0.0325195305,
0.0345338956,
0.0188429747,
-0.01394979,
0.0169682484,
0.0297932141,
-0.0421975777,
-0.0164442305,
-0.022480363,
-0.0379362777,
0.0229087733,
0.0036477633,
0.0120592788,
0.0171689615,
-0.0329993889,
-0.0765174776,
-0.0260931142,
-0.0345342346,
-0.0350704752,
0.011399664,
0.0274022482,
-0.0528367758,
0.0041503343,
-0.0138727855,
0.0414584689,
-0.0272195134,
0.0286145285,
-0.0126305986,
0.0916092247,
0.0341293253,
-0.0005761334,
0.0184691269,
0.0418179519,
0.0647355542,
-0.0036095851,
-0.0168962777,
0.004883464,
0.045460511,
0.0127367983,
-0.0166986696,
0.0062140585,
0.013878502,
0.0569004007,
-0.063869983,
0.0238559432,
-0.0347908437,
-0.0495766923,
0.0074070962,
-0.0217095632,
0.0044726511,
-0.0045689046,
0.0072314837,
-0.0037599353,
0.0382549353,
-0.0512290858,
0.0190063026,
-0.0157217011,
-0.0444373488,
0.0010099233,
-0.0115751382,
-0.0670228228,
-0.0585323237,
-0.030061733,
-0.036597617,
0.0386315808,
-0.0285257734,
-0.0183061659,
1.745868546e-34,
0.0144084189,
-0.0045781219,
-0.0000393087,
-0.0185830258,
0.0271803383,
0.0229823161,
-0.0381633975,
0.0024020125,
0.0271144267,
-0.0289139766,
0.0157941859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11061v1 | CEIL: A General Classification-Enhanced Iterative Learning Framework for Text Clustering | 2023-04-20T14:04:31 | 2023-04-20T14:04:31 | Mingjun Zhao, Mengzhen Wang, Yinglong Ma, Di Niu, Haijiang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text clustering, as one of the most fundamental challenges in unsupervised
learning, aims at grouping semantically similar text segments without relying
on human annotations. With the rapid development of deep learning, deep
clustering has achieved significant advantages over traditional clustering
methods. Despite the effectiveness, most existing deep text clustering methods
rely heavily on representations pre-trained in general domains, which may not
be the most suitable solution for clustering in specific target domains. To
address this issue, we propose CEIL, a novel Classification-Enhanced Iterative
Learning framework for short text clustering, which aims at generally promoting
the clustering performance by introducing a classification objective to
iteratively improve feature representations. In each iteration, we first adopt
a language model to retrieve the initial text representations, from which the
clustering results are collected using our proposed Category Disentangled
Contrastive Clustering (CDCC) algorithm. After strict data filtering and
aggregation processes, samples with clean category labels are retrieved, which
serve as supervision information to update the language model with the
classification objective via a prompt learning approach. Finally, the updated
language model with improved representation ability is used to enhance
clustering in the next iteration. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the
CEIL framework significantly improves the clustering performance over
iterations, and is generally effective on various clustering algorithms.
Moreover, by incorporating CEIL on CDCC, we achieve the state-of-the-art
clustering performance on a wide range of short text clustering benchmarks
outperforming other strong baseline methods. | [
-0.0024528627,
0.0298694801,
-0.002246619,
0.0013303306,
-0.0349417813,
0.0416348949,
0.0456581339,
0.0054813544,
0.0430985689,
0.0019283989,
-0.0051519028,
-0.0348410457,
0.0241536517,
0.0104089277,
0.0140667632,
-0.1024295241,
0.0279750284,
0.0096112657,
-0.0022329441,
-0.0010186693,
0.0302775707,
-0.0047990168,
-0.0206849836,
-0.0205292888,
-0.0163236223,
-0.0232965853,
-0.034475185,
-0.0410772376,
0.0106085157,
-0.0006630571,
0.0314242989,
0.0334213041,
0.0553305596,
0.0446980186,
0.0000021406,
-0.0426233262,
-0.0702828616,
-0.011571629,
0.010184967,
-0.0243045259,
0.0785802454,
-0.0498740822,
-0.0057976153,
0.0089046303,
0.0197789054,
-0.0478609204,
0.0235668533,
0.0492722914,
0.0579870716,
0.0577253662,
-0.051377628,
-0.0617838874,
0.0140917432,
-0.0152577972,
-0.0597843044,
-0.0004210323,
0.0011936931,
0.0106310574,
-0.0256543215,
0.0265893191,
-0.0155008156,
0.0251126327,
0.0578329153,
0.0235669389,
0.0105420854,
0.0437008999,
-0.020375967,
-0.0138147064,
0.0137850353,
0.0763913393,
0.0021191174,
-0.0134220086,
0.0124475723,
0.0157655329,
-0.0067088646,
-0.0096313432,
-0.0279901717,
0.0255996771,
-0.0025872544,
0.0287279282,
0.0292478651,
0.068903327,
0.0204905272,
-0.0168039426,
-0.0196404476,
0.0086820489,
0.0190787688,
0.0101005984,
-0.0206593797,
-0.0020225421,
0.0041762483,
0.0146872541,
0.0235032178,
0.0150329517,
0.0148509918,
-0.0181848779,
-0.0243581776,
-0.0426791124,
-0.005807654,
-0.0106467083,
-0.041520983,
-0.0017918046,
-0.0101760942,
0.0567482114,
-0.0100434627,
-0.016786715,
0.0057559623,
-0.0134735052,
-0.0489290915,
-0.0636099204,
-0.0655306056,
0.0019830945,
-0.0212408826,
0.0508852378,
-0.0237001292,
0.0015644974,
-0.0103548048,
0.0200290289,
-0.0027087121,
-0.0165066738,
-0.0319235623,
0.016624473,
-0.0086912112,
-0.0154968621,
0.0219480358,
0.0010336783,
-0.0655486584,
0.0289311558,
-0.0115361307,
0.0172354635,
0.0129364571,
0.0578762703,
0.0201335158,
-0.024764752,
-0.0235235672,
0.0267255679,
-0.0683369637,
-0.0420571752,
-0.0641795471,
-0.004114266,
-0.0159325264,
-0.0058407011,
-0.0308331121,
-0.0995492563,
0.0188745745,
-0.0101062441,
-0.0093866391,
-0.0397341698,
-0.0525751002,
-0.0285404436,
-0.0197639372,
0.0558821186,
-0.080730103,
-0.0217898246,
0.0853386447,
0.0402414277,
0.030613292,
0.0092454981,
-0.0269604437,
0.0338169858,
0.0402377732,
0.0131040709,
0.0166083816,
-0.0020075825,
0.015675921,
0.0252328962,
-0.0299037695,
-0.0041017183,
0.0105122309,
-0.006677872,
0.0466832817,
0.0368915796,
-0.0404412262,
-0.0315013751,
-0.000935701,
0.0581702441,
0.0499041341,
0.0709487423,
-0.0515725277,
0.057772208,
-0.0283571687,
-0.0195204671,
0.0264675617,
0.0204051305,
-0.0402293056,
-0.0307003781,
0.0693392232,
-0.0100308843,
-0.0907198712,
-0.0130469101,
0.0519474335,
-0.0152278962,
0.0614461377,
-0.0185580608,
0.0497044995,
0.025733145,
0.0114875808,
0.0308226608,
0.0454786569,
-0.0275008995,
0.0360588692,
-0.0061787199,
0.0093592815,
0.0429749452,
0.0230980162,
-0.0602662265,
0.0208006147,
0.0137358001,
0.0294795372,
0.0015191417,
-0.0244010892,
-0.0239776038,
0.0312135145,
-0.0507633202,
-0.0493898727,
-0.0073852008,
-0.0089832824,
-0.0088002626,
-0.0151092634,
0.0350671932,
0.0275312141,
-0.0169674978,
0.0061313417,
0.032737609,
0.01591588,
-0.025429707,
0.0293894801,
0.0487972051,
-0.0179130472,
-0.0027992588,
-0.0018001512,
-0.0680251718,
0.027365813,
-0.0230885167,
-0.0058615962,
-0.0538955256,
-0.033547163,
-0.0715511441,
0.0059471633,
-0.0235376842,
-0.0212630983,
0.0154273761,
-0.0405313037,
-0.0472218208,
0.061443381,
-0.0121049182,
0.0121772327,
-0.0206606071,
0.0088844309,
-0.0276428368,
-0.0110452008,
-0.0450668707,
0.0466844887,
-0.0015500004,
0.0028228038,
-0.009184299,
0.0373422392,
-0.0076825088,
0.018354807,
-0.0040896223,
-0.0378533565,
0.0043571824,
0.0399255417,
0.0478006415,
-0.0107361097,
-0.0325715616,
-0.0193840005,
-0.0569371358,
-0.0318937637,
-0.0503362119,
-0.0476988293,
0.0415356085,
-0.0134579781,
0.008180853,
-0.0053394958,
-0.0509690233,
-0.0300549399,
-0.0272883791,
0.0046199397,
0.0554276966,
-0.0285699591,
-0.0122934086,
-0.0308503751,
-0.0084696952,
0.0259399544,
0.0523128286,
-0.0242109466,
-0.0203612149,
-0.0324058272,
0.0631034747,
-0.0131336916,
-0.015546076,
-0.0080523202,
0.0099069197,
-0.0055974973,
-0.0292496104,
0.0227239225,
0.0156436376,
0.0271197762,
0.0164426472,
-0.0077686366,
-0.0227155201,
-0.0125728557,
-0.0093378043,
-0.076028116,
0.0626543164,
-0.0077721984,
-0.0195528641,
0.0258241836,
0.0473814346,
0.0103891762,
0.0011116581,
-0.0302738063,
-0.0460914783,
0.0153090926,
0.0215094034,
-0.0793493316,
0.0147489607,
0.0423635058,
0.0053454363,
-0.0399619155,
-0.0340109505,
0.0615456365,
0.0019213465,
-0.0027445145,
-0.0734877288,
-0.0534707829,
-0.0382518843,
0.0346184075,
0.0030976536,
0.012204092,
-0.0241676066,
-0.0201156382,
-0.0155671639,
0.0062941737,
-0.0408393182,
0.0373002402,
0.0474899411,
0.0112553285,
-0.0067896028,
0.0350286923,
0.0007752993,
-0.0141034946,
-0.018678911,
0.0345934853,
0.0251600109,
0.0666114092,
-0.0122118741,
-0.0527570322,
0.0271877237,
0.0306719765,
0.0436876118,
0.0062001576,
-0.0330251865,
-0.0245520975,
0.0635604933,
0.014334701,
-0.0497541465,
0.0107109249,
-0.0312826633,
0.0119242352,
0.0880713388,
0.0303990189,
-0.022679029,
-0.0461256355,
0.0208363608,
-0.0026436453,
-0.0363062322,
-0.0100025702,
-0.0290157404,
0.0154667757,
0.0056932257,
-0.0340720937,
0.1017115936,
0.0270863194,
-0.1166929081,
-0.0067217452,
0.0068750572,
0.0736798123,
0.0185409766,
-0.0214837771,
0.0115828747,
-0.0236804076,
-0.0008831942,
0.0111822924,
0.0629986823,
-0.0077391649,
0.0321077481,
-0.0293898098,
0.0041087824,
0.0124492636,
-0.0808447748,
-0.028173361,
-0.0927452073,
-0.0159078613,
-0.0234714355,
0.0270552319,
0.0203916505,
0.0325274728,
-0.0143351229,
0.0181464348,
-0.0541509613,
-0.0196701307,
-0.0238520894,
-0.0460561141,
0.0171114672,
0.0278219469,
-0.0075843129,
0.026543377,
0.0258082207,
0.0170123763,
-0.0875036418,
-0.0262643415,
-0.0157213882,
0.0306033697,
-0.013673217,
0.0084412526,
-0.0373846591,
0.0524866208,
-0.0587193333,
-0.0299565792,
0.0185613148,
0.0252366103,
-0.0084638568,
0.0091612395,
-0.0413376987,
-0.0306528583,
-0.0072102062,
0.0254673623,
0.0005827246,
-0.0349656753,
0.0285926517,
-0.007501787,
0.0312919021,
0.0367515199,
0.0285016224,
-0.0119566517,
0.016087316,
-0.0140126934,
-0.0347557366,
-0.055923298,
0.0290301312,
0.0157498159,
-0.0294042528,
-0.0079102656,
-0.0013292895,
-0.0682105124,
-0.082172364,
0.0353214853,
-0.018308349,
-0.0288522486,
-0.0546756275,
-0.0312566832,
0.0252296589,
-0.0262694675,
-0.0153606674,
-0.0163774062,
-0.0416279659,
-0.0389900133,
-0.0071778051,
-0.0214674138,
-0.0054743988,
0.0716857165,
-0.0213021301,
-0.0764748603,
0.0885450691,
0.0393664315,
-0.0235740468,
-0.0042344383,
-0.0469261445,
0.0048320354,
0.0156951007,
0.0005232569,
-0.0391248614,
0.0567813814,
0.0024563407,
-0.0527083687,
-0.1099485755,
-0.0545995198,
-0.0184274241,
-0.0204107407,
0.0777897239,
0.0355347879,
0.0030476737,
-0.027263945,
-0.0214568973,
0.0343452282,
-0.009181004,
0.0209036991,
0.0460120961,
0.0238107666,
-0.0042052846,
-0.008608019,
0.1033482403,
0.0322990306,
-0.0203937273,
0.0008592411,
-0.0091657359,
0.0047123153,
0.0858468041,
-0.0497798175,
0.0418983698,
0.0143628633,
-0.0083526969,
-0.0232767072,
0.0148960501,
-0.0116534932,
-0.0077743758,
0.0450002849,
0.0403119214,
-0.0601118356,
0.057132367,
-0.0274207294,
0.0311332531,
-0.0281041507,
-0.009438985,
0.0049000843,
-0.023265155,
-0.0056277057,
-0.009659091,
-0.0186857786,
-0.0166979115,
0.0252843909,
-0.0039371355,
-0.0271619409,
-0.0296260472,
0.0112559842,
-0.0141467191,
0.0266268682,
0.0463608392,
-0.0211121198,
-0.0232119765,
0.0266893767,
-0.0070675993,
-0.0592602901,
0.0000187312,
0.045798365,
0.0462292507,
-0.006247622,
0.0176515728,
0.0373100713,
-0.0022660817,
0.036616601,
-0.0463890955,
0.0024340311,
0.0367145725,
0.0884117857,
0.0574730597,
-0.0015150522,
-0.005942673,
-0.0191660579,
-0.0327241905,
0.0451077521,
-0.0453054979,
0.0138256978,
-6.594103069e-33,
0.0143757081,
-0.0081016179,
-0.0308849532,
-0.0310200565,
0.006180075,
0.0101181976,
-0.021851249,
0.0032990891,
0.0342461243,
0.0281466544,
0.0255893692,
0.0490939319,
-0.0177674685,
0.0490711555,
-0.038051676,
0.0322218351,
0.0327928178,
0.0127874818,
-0.0047940114,
0.0732295513,
0.0434543118,
0.0459170267,
0.0085985493,
-0.0704382956,
-0.0343483798,
0.004722497,
0.008229685,
0.0170859266,
0.069371976,
0.005143608,
-0.0373358428,
0.0039562471,
0.0499989912,
-0.0095288446,
-0.0255829375,
0.0051910309,
-0.0769418627,
-0.0433930084,
-0.0507797934,
-0.0051376116,
-0.0378632173,
-0.0370712616,
0.0571573898,
0.0223332569,
0.0274612177,
-0.0032654991,
0.0748009607,
-0.0019846724,
-0.0335313752,
0.0064523742,
-0.0029911052,
0.056283202,
-0.0326861218,
-0.014684529,
0.0359002389,
0.061377462,
-0.0031116873,
0.0512380898,
-0.1201665848,
0.0043296041,
-0.0159652438,
0.0485858098,
0.0095517719,
0.0263450351,
0.0160668492,
0.0592888631,
0.0164235812,
-0.0052284445,
-0.0760678127,
0.0287927892,
0.0535167679,
0.0264174063,
0.0349709541,
0.0301091243,
-0.0166323464,
-0.0318534561,
-0.0716272667,
0.0893009156,
-0.0521246865,
-0.0190515481,
0.0173390228,
0.0465919934,
-0.0596179031,
-0.0683005825,
-0.0105945654,
-0.019596925,
-0.0344587415,
-0.0008509814,
-0.0235109124,
0.0128333662,
-0.0751882568,
-0.017459929,
0.0047387774,
0.005740426,
-0.0061997762,
0.001697776,
-0.0237286575,
0.0550436638,
0.0272218976,
-0.0115817878,
-0.0791364312,
-0.0693425313,
0.0154861799,
0.0109303202,
-0.0040969667,
0.0065571936,
0.0326499045,
-0.0121994205,
-0.0439902693,
0.0079948911,
0.0571061336,
-0.0119297504,
0.0037797047,
0.0239074361,
-0.0325019956,
0.004636778,
0.0140178176,
0.1074145213,
0.059355069,
-0.0183957666,
0.0041602016,
0.0125290174,
-0.0084748669,
0.0194285773,
0.0010266317,
-0.0314016901,
-0.0249388516,
0.0129816914,
0.0610613562,
-0.0765709281,
-0.0127438242,
-0.0367072821,
2.708e-7,
0.0227840897,
0.0170450602,
0.0543258637,
-0.0474141054,
0.0251448136,
0.0628698692,
0.0201755837,
0.0267419927,
-0.0270006992,
0.0174685977,
0.036102619,
0.0704153702,
0.0411236286,
0.028866088,
-0.0170054492,
0.0552895628,
-0.0379835851,
0.0071992618,
-0.036505647,
0.0045428579,
0.0180685148,
0.1082033738,
0.0456687398,
-0.0218155943,
0.0406093933,
-0.0334991217,
0.0329127647,
-0.0029600405,
-0.0059874137,
0.0392231159,
-0.041234538,
0.0293586478,
-0.008781258,
-0.0102441302,
0.0409183539,
0.0036048703,
-0.0102825006,
0.0046741762,
-0.0293442309,
-0.0409565978,
0.0605003238,
0.0241928361,
0.0043136859,
-0.0114192329,
0.0571330637,
-0.0720753446,
0.0031622064,
0.0428530574,
-0.0308274571,
0.0245596431,
0.0272244345,
0.0325254314,
-0.0479084887,
0.0430896394,
0.0132200271,
-0.0075427624,
-0.0105674621,
-0.0862086788,
0.0079901656,
0.0154426135,
-0.0127991838,
0.0140988864,
0.0077568209,
-0.0121597033,
0.0220723841,
0.0048369635,
0.0674934238,
2.119990975e-34,
0.0028490806,
0.018079523,
-0.0565312207,
-0.0179747567,
0.004140846,
-0.0582362562,
-0.0489188917,
-0.0233452544,
0.0139147807,
-0.0525677055,
0.0022849333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10321v1 | DropDim: A Regularization Method for Transformer Networks | 2023-04-20T13:54:18 | 2023-04-20T13:54:18 | Hao Zhang, Dan Qu, Keji Shao, Xukui Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduceDropDim, a structured dropout method designed for regularizing
the self-attention mechanism, which is a key component of the transformer. In
contrast to the general dropout method, which randomly drops neurons, DropDim
drops part of the embedding dimensions. In this way, the semantic information
can be completely discarded. Thus, the excessive coadapting between different
embedding dimensions can be broken, and the self-attention is forced to encode
meaningful featureswith a certain number of embedding dimensions erased.
Experiments on a wide range of tasks executed on the MUST-C English-Germany
dataset show that DropDim can effectively improve model performance, reduce
over-fitting, and show complementary effects with other regularization methods.
When combined with label smoothing, the WER can be reduced from 19.1% to 15.1%
on the ASR task, and the BLEU value can be increased from26.90 to 28.38 on the
MT task. On the ST task, the model can reach a BLEU score of 22.99, an increase
by 1.86 BLEU points compared to the strong baseline. | [
-0.022872651,
0.035003081,
0.0012203929,
0.0494483598,
0.0033006747,
-0.0036891135,
0.0481333695,
-0.0312934406,
-0.0057748845,
0.0255492739,
-0.0535948947,
0.0061462172,
0.0154598253,
0.0411361009,
0.0200212449,
-0.0180653781,
0.0225431044,
0.0264711492,
-0.0507732034,
-0.0221075676,
-0.0095704813,
-0.0297801569,
0.03029502,
0.0286600869,
-0.0298876017,
0.0121007701,
-0.017470194,
0.016552398,
0.0433707163,
-0.0108220913,
-0.0113427974,
0.053471379,
-0.0057929382,
0.0193538684,
0.000002596,
-0.041743122,
0.007127698,
-0.0246364772,
-0.0226917546,
-0.0060470817,
0.003408056,
-0.0713329464,
0.0252914224,
-0.0058612046,
0.011709448,
-0.0267085303,
0.0538065545,
0.1165362298,
0.0128652398,
0.058668185,
-0.0199182574,
-0.0631562546,
0.0064693578,
-0.050285507,
-0.0058825607,
-0.0215086937,
0.0060447804,
-0.0404311456,
-0.0733252838,
0.0130082192,
-0.0545788147,
0.0491041616,
0.0519383512,
0.0106674861,
0.0399769247,
0.0454368033,
-0.0333635285,
-0.0505628474,
0.0063439687,
0.0388158448,
-0.0166287869,
-0.0205520466,
-0.0338318162,
0.0039879689,
0.0116191227,
-0.0050658197,
-0.0607434399,
-0.0058553689,
0.0382689536,
0.0361334682,
-0.0239494815,
0.0378569849,
0.0179879107,
-0.0172613617,
-0.0443077348,
0.0257376879,
0.0034376511,
-0.0401169062,
0.0255315341,
0.0174051281,
0.0153830536,
0.001439481,
0.0416367501,
0.0110722659,
0.0531199463,
-0.0417922847,
-0.0211760756,
-0.0445366427,
-0.0050106496,
-0.0233790111,
0.0100727379,
0.0259653572,
-0.0627121925,
0.0021199705,
-0.0460353382,
0.0917383805,
-0.0176063683,
0.057707686,
-0.0348851494,
-0.011764721,
0.0138841216,
0.0096073803,
-0.0512039401,
0.0234029964,
0.0095785959,
-0.0259881113,
-0.0497597046,
0.0126880994,
-0.0026446597,
-0.0433340333,
0.0417304747,
0.0433327444,
-0.0659372211,
0.0018428303,
0.0289848037,
0.0662976205,
-0.0071685226,
-0.0343544409,
-0.0076658437,
0.0043394384,
-0.032198634,
0.0276887696,
0.0326504633,
-0.0382484943,
0.0112069277,
0.0408037081,
-0.0041445675,
-0.0436001942,
-0.0224019699,
0.0534432121,
-0.0261712261,
-0.0518947802,
0.0385815687,
-0.030662654,
0.029025564,
-0.0185531639,
0.0231048968,
-0.068992354,
-0.0163025819,
-0.0154120475,
-0.0120592061,
0.0175148938,
-0.0132467588,
-0.0355356485,
0.0280434527,
0.0127204405,
-0.0060062222,
0.0280588064,
0.0123501159,
0.0285018533,
-0.0204077195,
-0.0359459706,
0.0157524273,
0.0174858905,
0.0223941542,
-0.007209084,
-0.0353885517,
-0.0701541901,
-0.041371949,
0.0365121514,
0.1024438813,
0.0322110057,
-0.0125080636,
-0.0753868371,
0.0686309412,
0.0346896797,
0.1000315696,
0.0513360575,
0.0248050038,
-0.0015576317,
-0.0223469678,
0.0270996075,
-0.0498326384,
0.0860503986,
-0.0013293052,
-0.0239580534,
-0.007871774,
0.0645932406,
-0.0612359047,
-0.0372125581,
0.0469311588,
-0.0182666462,
0.043399442,
0.0113527896,
0.059429381,
0.0110426499,
0.0234130006,
0.0856334567,
0.0194429699,
-0.0325313434,
-0.0202194005,
-0.0287884623,
-0.0104366634,
0.0049527092,
0.0022970531,
-0.0105245095,
-0.0387918726,
-0.00350189,
0.0057343319,
0.0662133023,
0.0050447127,
0.0561263114,
0.0277624205,
-0.0400181338,
-0.040703658,
-0.0029062391,
-0.014011357,
0.022286389,
-0.0402355678,
-0.0078763068,
0.0186734889,
-0.02506827,
0.0183550194,
0.0234128889,
-0.0416641533,
-0.017970901,
0.0057974565,
0.0260782056,
-0.0306178294,
0.0129570989,
0.0179822203,
0.000527449,
0.0530571006,
-0.0596471801,
-0.0222704001,
-0.006431059,
-0.0679204464,
-0.0097869094,
0.0420091636,
-0.0223215781,
0.0309189167,
0.0737279728,
-0.0121929375,
-0.0372043625,
0.0313283242,
-0.0362765379,
0.0137554146,
-0.0318196788,
0.017952241,
0.0064208633,
0.0563736781,
-0.0005986254,
0.0339618921,
-0.0277256854,
0.0185467992,
-0.018825084,
-0.0233480316,
0.0241279826,
-0.0327761471,
-0.0435362235,
0.0204749685,
-0.0508032441,
0.0164223593,
0.032580819,
-0.0043304781,
-0.0041605835,
0.0254533496,
-0.026094228,
-0.003156662,
-0.0182027556,
-0.0116947806,
-0.0087641859,
0.0407005027,
0.0239863526,
-0.0360201932,
-0.0087336469,
0.0196348894,
-0.0462626182,
-0.0066436371,
-0.0090215169,
-0.0267780069,
-0.0073434748,
0.0000810869,
-0.0562032424,
0.0024124784,
0.0493579693,
-0.0303335693,
-0.0257521067,
-0.0475054234,
0.0288484674,
-0.0267895386,
0.022859998,
-0.0157106742,
-0.0696169361,
-0.0338611305,
0.0197604969,
0.0601648614,
0.0940506533,
0.0062310887,
-0.0049579325,
0.0440366603,
0.0384368487,
-0.0349110365,
0.0097978264,
-0.0549278334,
0.0307406466,
-0.0333971456,
-0.009455231,
-0.007262209,
0.0843641832,
-0.0118794739,
0.0031454081,
-0.0496680886,
-0.0249135345,
-0.0079216026,
-0.0318836793,
0.0127944984,
0.0322877131,
-0.053980317,
0.0182887241,
-0.0173049942,
-0.0212259218,
0.030774897,
-0.0060896315,
-0.0035494622,
-0.0181863103,
-0.0077738301,
0.0083163092,
0.0090781683,
0.0444118865,
0.0458619595,
-0.0000505819,
-0.0369595438,
-0.0309736393,
0.0176630467,
-0.0173829906,
0.0071648681,
0.0648102015,
0.0539642349,
-0.0330578685,
-0.0188187882,
-0.028462518,
-0.0320930183,
-0.0202411488,
-0.0168513358,
0.0098042516,
0.0175650306,
-0.0183538571,
-0.0730810389,
-0.0157608707,
0.0368372574,
0.0982980132,
-0.019655928,
-0.0084269522,
0.0111972857,
0.0484218821,
0.0107946275,
0.0665119067,
0.0218715463,
0.0194560606,
0.0351692066,
0.0569493249,
-0.0194961056,
-0.0281576663,
-0.0589894205,
-0.01971462,
0.0268104225,
-0.006087306,
-0.017932009,
-0.015065264,
0.0238624923,
-0.0519726798,
-0.034738861,
0.0875367671,
-0.0109700644,
-0.0633035526,
0.0093790311,
-0.0409038849,
0.0418444984,
0.0487644784,
0.0248346068,
-0.0402196012,
-0.0193983186,
-0.0103056775,
-0.010174863,
0.0423606113,
0.0044167503,
0.0541815609,
-0.0659594089,
0.0391342156,
0.0149525944,
-0.0212891325,
-0.0132755321,
-0.0240939241,
-0.0060930559,
-0.0206231885,
0.0285481866,
-0.0098660225,
-0.0018398692,
-0.0752981082,
0.0435965285,
-0.0185356103,
-0.0351217166,
0.0188131519,
-0.0352247357,
-0.0050802995,
0.0119642541,
0.0246480051,
-0.0157902762,
-0.0784437954,
0.0239680465,
0.0262616333,
0.0246973857,
-0.0118585071,
0.0948062316,
0.0105428863,
-0.0196710695,
-0.0239388142,
0.0093498193,
-0.0101117296,
-0.0355940573,
-0.0813389868,
0.0726157203,
-0.0320240296,
-0.0530707017,
-0.0176939312,
0.0069391369,
-0.0607934147,
0.0403326042,
0.0283243358,
-0.0587581769,
0.005314365,
-0.0018759115,
0.030125862,
-0.0470759533,
-0.0598748513,
0.0692820773,
0.027022751,
-0.1278914511,
-0.0194335952,
-0.034577962,
-0.007345703,
0.0148282154,
0.004808798,
-0.0494512767,
-0.0007648361,
-0.0182942413,
-0.0265176445,
0.0592536479,
-0.016519526,
-0.0225659572,
-0.0369896032,
0.0176523961,
0.0266056824,
-0.032352332,
-0.002249799,
-0.0057030572,
-0.0649741814,
-0.0209698845,
0.045490399,
0.0576206557,
0.0095083881,
0.0541200936,
-0.0023914,
-0.0456722677,
0.0462801121,
0.0031140596,
-0.0371237658,
0.0278168358,
0.0382818878,
-0.0587611683,
-0.0099723525,
0.0234046485,
-0.0118589438,
0.0666005015,
0.0283993594,
0.0183972213,
-0.0018034524,
-0.0183398239,
0.0120175071,
-0.0258735884,
0.0972054079,
-0.0132200774,
0.0353652909,
-0.0227100141,
0.0159524679,
-0.0064774239,
0.0281016808,
-0.01527566,
-0.0023501217,
0.0474851094,
0.0354479216,
0.0031178875,
0.0001708499,
-0.0246648099,
-0.0569607653,
-0.0671479702,
0.035063602,
-0.0129528502,
-0.0252071638,
-0.0062837317,
0.0506166928,
-0.0211014263,
-0.0272957403,
0.0451800525,
0.0088826297,
-0.0138105294,
0.0430761948,
0.0119434632,
0.0269915834,
-0.0528532714,
0.0461123101,
-0.0426796377,
0.0082698129,
-0.0243276637,
-0.0531525426,
0.0401586592,
-0.0142646944,
0.0448937863,
0.0368067212,
-0.0193106346,
-0.0271918569,
0.0094296969,
-0.0221848376,
-0.0073288833,
0.0212629382,
-0.0256558191,
-0.0016985303,
-0.0130317407,
0.0369937569,
-0.0102397334,
-0.0163060445,
0.0204595793,
-0.0067144628,
-0.0553456433,
0.0192038286,
0.0090974579,
0.0125816967,
-0.0475406237,
-0.0208946429,
-0.0149209034,
-0.0769122094,
0.042219393,
-0.0331279673,
0.0011548914,
-0.0073305154,
0.0405746624,
0.0016032872,
-0.0031076877,
-0.0230095014,
0.0111000249,
-0.000157356,
-0.0108208302,
-0.0190728605,
0.0311047025,
-7.660529911e-33,
-0.0005387329,
-0.0168693252,
-0.0146166421,
0.0055701542,
-0.0361950286,
0.0076888981,
-0.0421126448,
0.0161517374,
-0.0170729812,
0.0358144715,
-0.0324639864,
-0.0099463193,
0.002814769,
0.0398121849,
0.0174664725,
-0.0233697612,
0.0393784754,
0.0119244726,
-0.0132673196,
0.0099807307,
0.0271815024,
0.0472950563,
0.1099469736,
-0.0795545876,
-0.0485248305,
0.0310144462,
0.0131434053,
-0.0087929852,
0.0352076255,
0.0369237512,
-0.0231409185,
0.0491055958,
0.0405155905,
-0.0581397861,
-0.0330425464,
0.0117403585,
-0.0894667208,
-0.0275390036,
-0.0496819392,
0.0206932779,
-0.0424505025,
-0.048739709,
0.0792744681,
-0.0002009463,
-0.0242529213,
-0.0711629391,
0.0447763726,
0.0136150187,
-0.0731005892,
-0.0102524199,
-0.07775525,
0.0146486228,
0.0040521435,
-0.0229996592,
0.0306919944,
0.0358021781,
-0.0259865467,
0.0360771529,
-0.0689013898,
-0.0263460781,
-0.01882248,
0.0296070743,
0.0490377434,
0.0119862575,
0.0005423246,
0.0124273282,
0.0521149784,
-0.0037364271,
-0.00821325,
-0.0739503652,
0.0654142573,
0.0166259706,
0.0799565017,
-0.0062899222,
0.0360056609,
-0.0157612246,
-0.0646301284,
0.0151906833,
-0.0714333579,
0.066340819,
0.0199284796,
0.0295629892,
-0.0013783586,
-0.0108456574,
0.0259357523,
0.0082045924,
-0.025986582,
-0.0268170889,
0.0271472428,
-0.0014003315,
-0.0102058724,
0.0338903181,
0.0448795222,
-0.0399909019,
0.0598471798,
0.0211677998,
0.0212336332,
0.0330054536,
0.0084462129,
-0.0218479522,
-0.0457083769,
-0.0053753001,
-0.0006306435,
0.0358016752,
0.0346318558,
-0.0101463525,
0.0466584675,
0.0256480668,
-0.0511849374,
-0.0494263507,
-0.0539490581,
-0.0186042618,
0.0123152435,
0.0779390708,
0.0315435641,
-0.0019440498,
-0.0148612559,
0.0206170492,
-0.0009902342,
-0.0047578034,
-0.0538816564,
0.0137395319,
0.0890670717,
0.0381077193,
-0.0119723687,
-0.00691613,
-0.0513691455,
0.0122265546,
0.0577585101,
-0.0728572011,
-0.0356479622,
0.0280820299,
3.336e-7,
0.0299085025,
0.0248010736,
-0.0002833152,
-0.0329461172,
0.0018484484,
0.0186117124,
-0.0014452961,
0.0261567384,
0.0199458729,
0.0123303235,
0.0281192139,
0.0332040079,
0.0442533717,
-0.0056023803,
-0.0846981779,
-0.0260339137,
-0.0328207947,
0.026416285,
0.0080581736,
-0.0320069045,
0.008685912,
0.1215251833,
-0.0024455364,
-0.0141445948,
0.0417269394,
0.0046118386,
0.0354074799,
-0.0104007488,
0.0326550454,
-0.0143178124,
0.0395938903,
0.005199003,
-0.0103603778,
0.0024791621,
-0.0261498615,
0.0159447026,
0.0408436172,
0.0258271154,
-0.0434732176,
-0.0391439088,
0.0131462598,
0.0269576944,
0.0077818707,
-0.0447122529,
0.0225113947,
-0.0844552144,
-0.0598074682,
0.0285497755,
-0.0194389224,
0.0170097016,
0.0442144014,
-0.0260250866,
0.00863491,
0.00348179,
0.0253736228,
-0.0235999282,
-0.0208130367,
-0.0555200018,
-0.0140591385,
0.0299472138,
-0.0684838817,
0.0041344767,
-0.0448539369,
-0.0318772458,
0.045618251,
0.0390990227,
-0.0040607639,
2.83070588e-34,
-0.014161529,
0.0155791445,
0.0360425599,
0.0025065616,
-0.0233382154,
-0.045171909,
0.0225195438,
-0.016016243,
-0.0169479139,
-0.0591986589,
-0.02943982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10309v1 | Improving Speech Translation by Cross-Modal Multi-Grained Contrastive Learning | 2023-04-20T13:41:56 | 2023-04-20T13:41:56 | Hao Zhang, Nianwen Si, Yaqi Chen, Wenlin Zhang, Xukui Yang, Dan Qu, Wei-Qiang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The end-to-end speech translation (E2E-ST) model has gradually become a
mainstream paradigm due to its low latency and less error propagation. However,
it is non-trivial to train such a model well due to the task complexity and
data scarcity. The speech-and-text modality differences result in the E2E-ST
model performance usually inferior to the corresponding machine translation
(MT) model. Based on the above observation, existing methods often use
sharingmechanisms to carry out implicit knowledge transfer by imposing various
constraints. However, the final model often performs worse on the MT task than
the MT model trained alone, which means that the knowledge transfer ability of
this method is also limited. To deal with these problems, we propose the FCCL
(Fine- and Coarse- Granularity Contrastive Learning) approach for E2E-ST, which
makes explicit knowledge transfer through cross-modal multi-grained contrastive
learning. A key ingredient of our approach is applying contrastive learning at
both sentence- and frame-level to give the comprehensive guide for extracting
speech representations containing rich semantic information.In addition, we
adopt a simple whitening method to alleviate the representation degeneration in
the MT model, which adversely affects contrast learning. Experiments on the
MuST-C benchmark show that our proposed approach significantly outperforms the
state-of-the-art E2E-ST baselines on all eight language pairs. Further analysis
indicates that FCCL can free up its capacity from learning grammatical
structure information and force more layers to learn semantic information. | [
-0.0164161138,
0.0514673591,
-0.0056892224,
0.0351386294,
-0.0334796011,
-0.0046141208,
0.0014618672,
-0.0473748557,
-0.0791103393,
-0.0384456776,
-0.058148507,
-0.0169904865,
0.0464660004,
0.0079744533,
0.0336648524,
-0.0811614767,
0.0261660554,
-0.0209548958,
-0.0259057004,
0.0045618964,
-0.0068133632,
0.0117852986,
-0.01258008,
-0.0225015823,
0.0027540403,
0.0274095312,
0.0019975139,
0.0168823171,
0.0550132878,
0.0032078624,
-0.0135354223,
0.0134452675,
0.0200580768,
0.020429099,
0.0000023835,
-0.0181856062,
-0.0264689364,
0.0286679193,
0.0204530321,
-0.0036778564,
0.0756027326,
-0.0501410775,
-0.0107035181,
0.0260573719,
-0.0036764948,
-0.0193243977,
0.0466436408,
0.0715844333,
0.0084166089,
0.0758557469,
-0.0399848297,
-0.0269541629,
0.0382037684,
-0.0254168268,
-0.0078789461,
-0.0274074133,
-0.0239461586,
0.0175551753,
-0.0218564011,
0.0398777276,
-0.0392893516,
0.0651269034,
0.0019815508,
0.0164942183,
-0.0463278554,
0.0072508501,
-0.011244135,
0.0087162796,
-0.0257441625,
0.1130373403,
0.0202674773,
0.0233248286,
0.0038157192,
-0.020331651,
-0.0064525204,
-0.0178997498,
-0.026001228,
0.0028907654,
0.0139260851,
0.0160790049,
0.0430245809,
0.0446329489,
0.0161510035,
-0.0406180657,
-0.0258287434,
-0.0640319362,
0.029838033,
0.0006514476,
0.008970432,
-0.0070755403,
0.0062965997,
0.0182920136,
0.0290660709,
-0.0096350713,
-0.0049470933,
-0.0161738601,
-0.0528401993,
-0.054064393,
-0.0104174279,
0.0016949129,
0.0209140498,
0.0729923695,
-0.064529933,
0.0318870358,
-0.0450398847,
0.0020769967,
-0.0200871211,
0.0167886093,
-0.0583842695,
-0.0423684716,
-0.0424732044,
0.044337444,
-0.0364406779,
0.0141704418,
-0.0479223579,
-0.0110719902,
-0.0027643647,
-0.0326246545,
-0.0200424269,
-0.0124424491,
0.0286709405,
-0.0345498361,
-0.0795211345,
-0.0289253108,
0.0162907559,
0.0784898177,
-0.0045521939,
0.0470344946,
0.0196570493,
-0.0419953167,
-0.0191702321,
0.0118645625,
0.0180355068,
-0.0295466278,
0.0113256592,
0.0724880844,
-0.0479894839,
-0.0135966223,
-0.0620483831,
-0.0038475394,
-0.0479379259,
-0.0589322671,
-0.0305209756,
-0.0656288192,
0.0437479019,
-0.0037553043,
0.0167832077,
-0.0046762801,
-0.0182247553,
-0.036669001,
-0.0342722759,
0.0855326131,
-0.0040472662,
-0.0243339725,
0.033200752,
0.0088698743,
-0.02906771,
0.0377803035,
0.0458472185,
0.0000419177,
-0.0250822548,
-0.0308776125,
-0.0549110025,
0.0182058401,
0.026523659,
0.0292719658,
-0.0420477092,
-0.0217890572,
0.0241625756,
0.0096446145,
0.066321075,
0.0675752833,
-0.0114505067,
0.0060278666,
0.0892443731,
-0.0134868724,
0.0388459787,
0.0568145774,
0.0540431403,
0.0342826732,
-0.0427202806,
0.0194585919,
-0.0029670661,
0.0275188535,
-0.0330836773,
-0.0074506821,
0.0809698701,
0.0511707552,
-0.0299702063,
-0.0095382743,
0.0610216185,
-0.0361175574,
0.0580331124,
-0.015666103,
0.0457415655,
0.0369155221,
-0.0615806319,
0.0411921851,
0.0607946962,
-0.0237410013,
0.0334818438,
-0.003531371,
-0.0324685499,
0.0287248064,
-0.018414719,
0.0051828343,
-0.0243032407,
-0.0437001176,
0.0073982361,
0.0292471889,
0.068082802,
0.0222181194,
0.0731876642,
-0.0575928539,
-0.0184090883,
-0.0182187874,
-0.0095968135,
0.0358615704,
-0.0598259345,
0.0671624541,
0.0196576118,
0.0010945239,
-0.0031539076,
0.010471615,
-0.0029526881,
-0.0049778386,
0.0361866653,
0.0175778382,
0.0230854321,
0.0091982083,
-0.0290012751,
-0.0031670777,
-0.0049877572,
-0.0590519197,
0.0052708709,
0.0276804492,
-0.0948076248,
-0.0608610362,
0.0183059443,
-0.052065935,
0.0267336573,
0.0271909125,
-0.0307828188,
-0.0800169706,
0.040837653,
0.0104601709,
0.0410804078,
-0.0016823944,
0.0201349016,
0.0392043069,
0.0312444698,
0.0067070927,
0.023157673,
0.01076495,
-0.0250111166,
0.0091264322,
0.0125755779,
-0.0050048553,
-0.044107981,
-0.0003148463,
0.0315976664,
0.008224179,
0.0481643267,
0.0147919077,
0.0204877052,
-0.0137614319,
-0.0087170266,
-0.0714020506,
0.0166458897,
0.0120284753,
0.042261336,
0.0433691926,
0.0336331017,
0.0100096986,
0.011613341,
-0.0173051357,
0.0385380536,
-0.0397954509,
-0.0277701411,
-0.0291963629,
0.0224437509,
0.0116442125,
-0.0106934113,
0.014934347,
0.0389244631,
0.0075791385,
-0.0291862059,
0.0132523114,
-0.0410819314,
0.0772459507,
0.025178995,
0.0256185122,
-0.0111201061,
-0.0366831645,
-0.0276569854,
-0.0116158919,
0.0186695978,
0.0240305532,
0.0175607596,
-0.0040639462,
0.0004931717,
-0.0611752085,
-0.071976386,
0.0150086544,
-0.0071683042,
0.0215893928,
-0.045320224,
-0.0204324387,
-0.0332822055,
0.0884684995,
0.0341895223,
0.02304269,
-0.0575595945,
-0.0418436229,
0.0085072033,
-0.0159466099,
-0.0007993194,
0.0498280488,
-0.0021529011,
-0.0103450185,
-0.033005178,
-0.0028227118,
0.0520956665,
-0.0593890436,
-0.0105593242,
-0.0262243655,
-0.0240119342,
-0.0055491957,
0.025900621,
-0.0494805463,
0.0247626472,
0.0261803679,
-0.0285105333,
-0.0762519315,
-0.0316259675,
0.0346528329,
-0.0225084499,
0.0309712533,
-0.0321335047,
-0.0121455695,
-0.0354923271,
-0.0368815102,
0.013707092,
-0.0107529424,
-0.0137061216,
0.046562504,
0.0221118033,
-0.0311374795,
-0.0325137265,
0.0092237527,
0.0346036516,
0.0632093549,
0.0126901465,
-0.0064692614,
-0.0154534094,
0.084039405,
-0.0114848791,
0.0268321242,
0.0121249966,
-0.0328603089,
0.0343873985,
0.017922027,
0.0225661267,
-0.0025120613,
-0.0631419718,
-0.0040339334,
0.0295435172,
0.0345174856,
-0.0597722121,
0.0100251557,
0.0778462365,
-0.0534976833,
-0.000840458,
0.077987954,
-0.034291923,
-0.022154849,
-0.0097282706,
0.0121513046,
0.0067657931,
-0.0054915613,
0.0185267124,
-0.0524097309,
-0.0844747499,
0.0136547768,
0.0329420008,
0.02870485,
0.01996525,
-0.0210901443,
-0.1035142615,
0.0409260131,
0.0337395258,
-0.0638926923,
-0.062363673,
0.0149971955,
-0.0304015465,
-0.0322585143,
0.0487202816,
-0.0364289992,
-0.0051138238,
-0.0330222063,
0.0364865549,
0.0495456457,
-0.0550533049,
0.0372809134,
-0.0442965403,
0.0669424832,
-0.0025312728,
0.0297850762,
-0.0305101424,
-0.0504959449,
0.038637612,
-0.0494213402,
-0.0069338959,
-0.0243486725,
0.0223024674,
-0.0260344911,
-0.0227662809,
0.0276378989,
0.0336562283,
-0.0054824785,
-0.0023896962,
0.0010516138,
0.0444957986,
0.0064760107,
0.0027754931,
0.0382658355,
-0.0011519976,
0.0277036838,
0.0741970837,
0.013355826,
-0.0549630113,
0.0261887051,
-0.0013256016,
-0.0281228591,
-0.0292532407,
-0.0060230121,
-0.0036834443,
-0.0104537997,
0.010507497,
-0.0780770257,
-0.0165157765,
0.001594745,
0.0369357653,
0.0093500922,
0.0170108415,
-0.0219184756,
-0.0092384359,
-0.0368389972,
0.0362746865,
-0.0354791991,
0.0378901735,
-0.0485576801,
-0.0103091998,
0.0386018269,
-0.0934482515,
-0.0200401004,
0.0066933692,
-0.042199485,
-0.0658393651,
-0.0420647487,
0.0382374972,
0.004610294,
0.0798217878,
-0.02343731,
-0.0278987698,
0.0565725937,
0.0127887791,
-0.0725517571,
-0.0234423038,
0.0555475354,
-0.0277769156,
0.0032755679,
0.0198257118,
-0.0140440362,
0.021169018,
0.0282372292,
0.0472869426,
-0.0049575754,
-0.0385693796,
0.0119508784,
-0.0122325746,
0.0444979668,
0.0059882244,
0.0048116134,
-0.0405553989,
0.0218149647,
0.0161533933,
0.0057283407,
-0.0779215991,
-0.0227279142,
0.0281357616,
0.0183845479,
0.0125555024,
0.0236080661,
0.0277452618,
-0.0215240084,
0.0007749589,
0.0346907824,
-0.0227978416,
0.0451404378,
0.005172688,
0.0137603721,
0.0040438636,
0.0131104365,
0.0144947963,
0.0355077907,
-0.0466742851,
0.0557003319,
-0.0012387204,
0.0029995288,
-0.0053567276,
0.0190128684,
-0.0128621766,
-0.006344487,
-0.0305623095,
-0.0356573164,
0.0318303481,
-0.0122949984,
0.099356316,
0.0077093192,
-0.0006832119,
-0.0296316575,
0.0745286644,
-0.0475016423,
0.0303214137,
0.0219891835,
-0.0071424237,
0.0244107544,
0.0410577618,
0.0505332313,
-0.0591664053,
0.0204901733,
-0.0228527095,
0.0106454445,
-0.0246386155,
-0.0010600078,
0.0483388379,
-0.0212374944,
-0.0214633327,
-0.0196522363,
-0.0104085663,
-0.0581498854,
0.004674728,
-0.0174422991,
0.0107372981,
-0.0069428519,
0.0257261619,
0.0289452504,
-0.0361186117,
-0.0030087922,
-0.0233325865,
-0.0447247438,
0.0214299355,
0.019009104,
0.0012693246,
-7.116393576e-33,
-0.0506238006,
0.037571311,
0.0089370226,
-0.0167485885,
-0.0250370074,
0.0121047227,
-0.0494023301,
-0.0142111806,
-0.0239869505,
0.0201899223,
0.0353004448,
-0.0023101028,
0.0247044824,
0.0267010629,
-0.0002706054,
0.0109425886,
0.0641098171,
0.0010569205,
-0.0178440418,
0.0403647535,
0.0441757739,
0.0431199558,
0.0721006319,
-0.071703285,
-0.0129264975,
0.0288298521,
-0.010406062,
0.0028522469,
0.0291401241,
0.0251938161,
-0.0014110218,
-0.0132240746,
0.0134269716,
-0.0609700754,
-0.0421328433,
0.007975637,
-0.1122241095,
0.0064975084,
0.0153356632,
0.0140947662,
-0.0384807438,
-0.0475800894,
0.0410442613,
-0.0160069969,
0.0448344164,
-0.050622724,
0.0188046563,
-0.0476425327,
-0.0127011463,
-0.0119833536,
-0.0877431184,
0.0209239554,
-0.0277029537,
-0.0326147415,
0.0437978171,
0.0270631611,
-0.0165518895,
0.0006941302,
-0.0526104197,
-0.0061801402,
-0.0353173204,
0.028405128,
0.0547733605,
0.0353201479,
-0.0310315397,
0.0210959055,
0.018174056,
-0.0516033173,
0.0677009374,
-0.0206065327,
0.0413850956,
0.0448277071,
0.0103334766,
0.0632742941,
0.0507210828,
-0.007980885,
-0.0498896427,
0.0373956822,
-0.036807742,
0.0224688053,
0.0189385992,
0.0331287719,
-0.0065508275,
0.0032595245,
-0.0669584125,
-0.0525050536,
-0.0263962261,
0.001463405,
0.0023873195,
0.0243760049,
-0.0354644172,
-0.0380499624,
0.0977292061,
0.0021347245,
0.0142953526,
-0.0127871037,
-0.0447525606,
-0.0027302431,
-0.0418831185,
0.008088774,
-0.0737518668,
-0.0771146417,
0.0321750902,
0.0083857663,
0.0259235948,
-0.0161421243,
0.046484869,
0.0387292542,
-0.0560722984,
0.0025488017,
-0.0331567377,
-0.0008265245,
-0.0264917891,
0.0251277685,
0.0387335271,
-0.0139957871,
-0.0274058226,
0.0321629681,
0.0123833623,
0.0138471154,
0.0145328483,
-0.0102919154,
0.0304814391,
0.0465801843,
-0.0424947068,
0.009809942,
-0.015955532,
-0.0271632839,
0.0739492625,
-0.0021738617,
-0.0416813791,
0.0016304642,
3.125e-7,
0.0050140778,
0.0005653839,
-0.0117011731,
-0.0172087736,
0.0020073559,
0.0722356141,
-0.0295037087,
0.0298235565,
0.0188717004,
0.0129837468,
0.0239337552,
0.0301818978,
0.1278788894,
0.0250535607,
-0.041995734,
-0.0032191989,
0.0119599085,
0.0300076213,
-0.0005821791,
-0.0035941228,
0.0432409942,
0.0694980398,
-0.0169822443,
-0.0143485153,
0.01923237,
-0.0240994003,
0.0736555457,
-0.038085822,
0.0026320429,
-0.04033437,
-0.018772712,
0.0420957804,
-0.0927983373,
0.0253842268,
-0.0362555683,
0.0380389802,
0.0129012903,
0.0613847412,
0.0338786952,
-0.0456653833,
0.0166361071,
0.0123574771,
-0.0287343021,
0.0116249705,
0.0332485437,
-0.0808432028,
-0.0419443287,
-0.0462246947,
-0.0263378378,
0.029208865,
-0.0140940715,
-0.0232203845,
-0.0133995144,
-0.0191077199,
0.0315611251,
0.0026140145,
-0.0795019343,
-0.0452834181,
0.0017856229,
0.0368043259,
-0.0176722649,
-0.0429518111,
-0.0196580105,
-0.0326866694,
0.0184731986,
-0.0440975986,
0.0045005092,
2.732753681e-34,
0.01339381,
-0.0288249664,
0.0067566,
-0.0368663482,
0.0112266261,
-0.0141388699,
-0.018260736,
-0.0261115432,
0.011742224,
-0.0460521169,
-0.0297369473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10295v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10295v1 | Decouple Non-parametric Knowledge Distillation For End-to-end Speech Translation | 2023-04-20T13:20:03 | 2023-04-20T13:20:03 | Hao Zhang, Nianwen Si, Yaqi Chen, Wenlin Zhang, Xukui Yang, Dan Qu, Zhen Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Existing techniques often attempt to make knowledge transfer from a powerful
machine translation (MT) to speech translation (ST) model with some elaborate
techniques, which often requires transcription as extra input during training.
However, transcriptions are not always available, and how to improve the ST
model performance without transcription, i.e., data efficiency, has rarely been
studied in the literature. In this paper, we propose Decoupled Non-parametric
Knowledge Distillation (DNKD) from data perspective to improve the data
efficiency. Our method follows the knowledge distillation paradigm. However,
instead of obtaining the teacher distribution from a sophisticated MT model, we
construct it from a non-parametric datastore via k-Nearest-Neighbor (kNN)
retrieval, which removes the dependence on transcription and MT model. Then we
decouple the classic knowledge distillation loss into target and non-target
distillation to enhance the effect of the knowledge among non-target logits,
which is the prominent "dark knowledge". Experiments on MuST-C corpus show
that, the proposed method can achieve consistent improvement over the strong
baseline without requiring any transcription. | [
0.0142967273,
0.0608064048,
-0.0012593553,
0.0056025316,
-0.0147053255,
0.0011094678,
-0.0079465583,
0.027903581,
-0.0826821849,
0.0104691824,
-0.0530715324,
0.0028212904,
0.0280562378,
-0.0051283571,
0.0291702691,
-0.0295542181,
-0.0171918776,
-0.0100620221,
-0.0325458422,
0.0007989622,
-0.0243254416,
0.0075264084,
-0.0144408168,
-0.0150640029,
0.0173535515,
0.0173530579,
-0.0181295704,
0.0571613535,
0.0307147875,
-0.0075894129,
0.0169588216,
-0.0035197488,
0.028569717,
0.0321175121,
0.0000021202,
0.0005555715,
-0.0036216963,
0.0221313853,
-0.0575543679,
-0.0088168466,
0.0180803817,
-0.0400218293,
0.0312681198,
0.0142133273,
-0.0059536491,
-0.0240544844,
0.0468951799,
0.0045069582,
0.026532786,
0.0768952891,
-0.0017317211,
-0.0420688428,
0.0189359393,
-0.0381125882,
0.0119176377,
-0.0031938443,
0.0022605846,
-0.0145583246,
-0.0727494657,
-0.0132954149,
-0.0215473585,
0.0847567171,
-0.0045324839,
-0.0122052934,
-0.0022201333,
-0.0123542072,
-0.0320628434,
-0.0362412706,
0.0101389531,
0.0797237903,
-0.0073754061,
0.0003971269,
0.0548682325,
0.037373919,
-0.0221988428,
-0.0137021802,
-0.0512452275,
-0.0256226454,
0.0405040979,
-0.0182193965,
-0.0245968718,
0.0832687542,
0.0259554293,
-0.0495105647,
-0.0408054404,
-0.0437548608,
0.0195093211,
-0.0387545303,
0.0168000553,
-0.0106509998,
-0.0327530988,
0.0018358318,
0.0321617313,
-0.0099748187,
0.0530176423,
0.0110248774,
0.0049072849,
-0.032533884,
-0.0349402502,
-0.0125904316,
0.0111657009,
0.0803274959,
-0.0294392239,
-0.0019112672,
-0.0217244811,
0.0516341217,
-0.001310791,
0.0207092818,
-0.0214418229,
-0.0181271024,
-0.089017503,
0.0193899889,
-0.0246159174,
0.0118751843,
-0.0269289017,
0.0113680605,
0.0166397598,
-0.0125577189,
-0.018689679,
-0.0179111157,
0.0631015673,
-0.0127790412,
-0.0850543007,
0.0028746433,
0.0082647894,
0.0912996829,
-0.0095122959,
-0.0105990572,
0.024963934,
-0.0566840731,
-0.0405579843,
-0.0036213533,
0.0417541638,
-0.0254305713,
0.0001910612,
0.0199176725,
-0.0101552382,
-0.0051650805,
-0.0342180654,
-0.014641582,
-0.0462101363,
-0.085411787,
0.0049773683,
-0.0534035079,
0.0721757412,
-0.0074735601,
0.0098802587,
-0.0492135324,
-0.0217809323,
-0.0348367877,
0.0066392543,
0.0239493195,
0.0126991952,
0.0211520232,
0.0224009268,
0.0315952785,
-0.0465259776,
0.0656729043,
0.0344446525,
0.0011953926,
-0.028041603,
-0.0188557059,
-0.0428012758,
0.0254185498,
0.0764209181,
0.0578378402,
-0.0351071469,
-0.0112343635,
-0.0324657895,
-0.0027718986,
0.0537466742,
0.0390039273,
-0.0471220128,
0.0282948613,
0.0689048991,
-0.019525459,
0.0788155869,
0.0190262012,
-0.0007919046,
0.0353778563,
-0.0516352393,
0.0183575861,
0.0042845937,
0.0086578866,
0.0183630176,
-0.0079409471,
0.0595002808,
0.0554773994,
-0.036246594,
-0.0068702847,
0.0348075852,
-0.0165576972,
0.0150377899,
-0.0050862958,
0.0372840911,
0.0437803268,
0.0052492633,
0.0745949969,
0.0193850137,
-0.0367467292,
0.0279635433,
-0.0096965153,
-0.042318128,
-0.0216574278,
0.0163554847,
-0.0104134735,
0.0181623884,
-0.0388499387,
-0.0110452631,
0.0033979588,
-0.0042124945,
0.008347786,
0.0669327974,
-0.0596688762,
-0.0368932597,
0.0251336265,
0.0163569096,
0.0231406558,
-0.0223472863,
0.0606485121,
0.0765683129,
-0.0816881135,
-0.0021463335,
-0.0176339541,
-0.0068556457,
-0.0232753195,
0.005772966,
0.0428155884,
0.0500936806,
0.0318943933,
-0.0235579275,
-0.0068405643,
0.0188691486,
-0.0413956568,
-0.0208841786,
0.0110745654,
-0.0555790067,
-0.1015836,
0.0209204201,
-0.0420667119,
0.0422926992,
0.0421171971,
-0.0017948422,
-0.1166889742,
0.0355004966,
0.0213378947,
0.0555946566,
-0.0322496891,
0.0443296582,
0.0393004715,
-0.0233320892,
0.0006201385,
0.0113987625,
-0.005959955,
-0.0189535115,
-0.0095256912,
-0.0469672307,
0.0113921547,
-0.0050056172,
-0.008912134,
0.0383236036,
-0.0113726817,
0.0450322293,
0.0289357584,
-0.0363406576,
-0.0061556767,
-0.0329040773,
-0.0230981819,
0.0176913366,
-0.0218816455,
0.0371817872,
0.0255147927,
0.0851574987,
0.0294282865,
-0.013559198,
-0.0494058169,
0.0011603191,
-0.015308396,
-0.0026801545,
-0.0413938165,
0.0441381522,
0.0143956775,
0.0139048751,
-0.0049320366,
0.0519060157,
0.0111497035,
-0.0728302374,
0.0185083598,
-0.0183304306,
0.059223529,
-0.0210918244,
0.0123621942,
-0.0156267304,
-0.0427948795,
-0.0186525397,
-0.0132901222,
0.0197723508,
-0.0214664489,
-0.0509284101,
-0.0499018282,
0.0006386553,
-0.0294445772,
-0.0928815007,
0.0152597493,
-0.0044075889,
-0.0312468689,
-0.0051055783,
-0.0181268118,
-0.0293551777,
0.0445218198,
0.0168976933,
-0.0290145166,
-0.06841667,
-0.0458100215,
0.0237411875,
-0.0206489544,
-0.0562220998,
0.0486337692,
0.0050458852,
0.0004691655,
-0.0270205848,
-0.0151989209,
0.0290702209,
-0.0655878186,
-0.0228023585,
-0.0109489691,
-0.0373619236,
0.0204107706,
0.0123458505,
-0.04648057,
0.0178669225,
-0.028794501,
-0.0196118131,
-0.0566299334,
0.012041701,
0.006403238,
-0.0177610051,
0.0377910696,
-0.0398840681,
-0.0191949811,
-0.0175424293,
-0.0146931717,
-0.0121170962,
0.0154556474,
0.0293650124,
-0.0011866095,
0.0334466994,
-0.0300869606,
-0.0144474171,
0.0119871339,
0.0183412433,
0.0907730833,
0.0178823937,
-0.0005126386,
-0.0215281937,
0.036367204,
-0.0007958421,
0.0008381461,
-0.0410597511,
-0.0219545644,
0.0143513363,
0.0148968594,
0.0469217934,
-0.0055859713,
-0.012166867,
-0.0323417522,
0.0098354965,
0.0460220389,
-0.0438927636,
0.0056323386,
0.027321076,
-0.0356598869,
0.0229738913,
0.0742110088,
-0.0312758088,
-0.006255738,
-0.0054384596,
0.0276509095,
0.0799305737,
-0.0011074336,
-0.0024450296,
-0.086692892,
-0.0237713922,
0.0053022797,
0.0740160272,
0.0252976641,
-0.0072071212,
-0.0231105462,
-0.0522784032,
-0.0077408003,
0.0631479174,
-0.0155828055,
-0.0933451653,
0.0134395165,
-0.0403986834,
-0.0314231589,
-0.0018823633,
0.0120850559,
0.0395330563,
0.0047310763,
0.0296640657,
0.0026401132,
-0.0403240807,
-0.0087839626,
-0.0155364322,
0.041008953,
0.0280269999,
0.0435729958,
0.011186434,
-0.0019698131,
-0.0530836396,
-0.019327879,
0.0106272725,
0.0094041899,
0.029981479,
0.0093808621,
-0.0039028809,
0.047409568,
0.0223990157,
-0.0282643829,
0.0524259098,
0.0181309953,
0.0422158502,
-0.0112628881,
-0.0109035745,
0.0408445671,
-0.0447575189,
0.0409232453,
0.0760384798,
0.0167934429,
-0.0066296039,
0.0195224229,
0.0181398932,
0.0160213169,
-0.0086297914,
0.0234751832,
0.0039694351,
-0.0408331975,
-0.041335918,
-0.0948972106,
-0.0047644954,
0.0009117472,
0.0930276811,
0.0162912738,
0.0079132617,
0.0111055654,
-0.0154056149,
-0.0281959213,
0.006400065,
-0.0429353751,
-0.0103613203,
-0.0120875901,
-0.016637912,
0.003393579,
-0.0352632701,
-0.0091398815,
-0.0017373946,
-0.0990167037,
-0.0790908113,
-0.0133544169,
0.0085068736,
0.0189638454,
0.0763723552,
-0.025168363,
0.0089352028,
0.097477071,
-0.0032850362,
-0.0602355562,
0.0063370531,
0.049769856,
-0.0280642714,
-0.0121789649,
0.0281257238,
-0.0436571129,
0.014628388,
0.0126256607,
0.0324707218,
-0.0113584986,
-0.0119495904,
-0.0057161399,
0.0383506268,
0.0629869103,
0.0026173315,
-0.0093393931,
-0.0118557625,
0.0402320847,
0.0225653332,
0.0226969067,
-0.0707756355,
-0.0198422931,
0.0653077587,
0.0326541513,
0.0020217514,
0.0145808104,
0.0212836433,
-0.024863936,
-0.0290256683,
-0.0266530458,
0.007010506,
0.0076987678,
0.0449003205,
0.0060967137,
-0.0045145601,
0.0588858947,
0.0292100385,
0.0107683185,
-0.0387486517,
0.0309987031,
-0.0059860265,
0.024776157,
0.0378869586,
0.0029536609,
-0.040744748,
-0.0292550586,
-0.0008627355,
-0.0201392379,
0.0353013165,
0.0182915628,
0.0907691196,
-0.0050327908,
0.0085538505,
-0.0189600214,
0.0163686331,
-0.0181782153,
0.0336634442,
0.0001443385,
-0.0074312361,
0.0244794656,
0.0466591343,
0.0442044176,
0.0191858411,
0.0597785823,
-0.0754218474,
0.0417292453,
-0.019648293,
-0.0302582923,
0.0138979964,
0.0085294526,
0.015331449,
-0.0203005672,
0.0268412791,
-0.0423765481,
-0.0026129168,
-0.0600720942,
-0.0223882124,
-0.0447232649,
0.0343108065,
0.0002859299,
-0.0692402944,
-0.0260228477,
-0.0341024511,
-0.0482586883,
0.0442711413,
-0.0047033168,
0.0330626294,
-6.747243534e-33,
-0.014709047,
0.0523524657,
0.0051781689,
-0.0227240808,
-0.0499937832,
-0.0117184399,
-0.0100564715,
-0.0373286493,
-0.014196652,
0.001223552,
-0.0173319709,
0.0525863953,
0.0314191878,
0.0309297852,
-0.0328548849,
0.0101134013,
0.0962465927,
-0.0005801232,
-0.0167940613,
0.0725366771,
0.0524103791,
0.0461896844,
0.0614167415,
-0.0788015872,
0.0039155199,
-0.010579871,
-0.0065492257,
0.0028776426,
0.0224768557,
-0.0200513974,
0.03277798,
0.0311154183,
-0.0170947518,
-0.0495515876,
-0.066057004,
-0.0310900006,
-0.0841304362,
-0.0061132936,
0.0212705601,
0.0184687469,
0.0213046409,
-0.0382691659,
0.0424384736,
-0.0254706908,
0.0536661185,
-0.0526056215,
-0.0262674727,
-0.0305478591,
-0.0401119441,
-0.0357781351,
-0.0043427655,
0.024210548,
-0.029787695,
-0.0364939757,
0.0574191362,
0.0125694815,
-0.0106296223,
-0.0502120294,
-0.1060648859,
0.014113578,
0.0354429446,
0.0645529181,
0.05137413,
0.0519879684,
0.0009365958,
-0.0125192432,
0.0135134561,
-0.0427868366,
0.0152114993,
-0.0137258451,
0.04132789,
0.0546972081,
-0.0072267512,
0.0268864725,
0.0682609007,
-0.0448823795,
-0.0470828563,
0.0113224136,
-0.0231462419,
0.0042449376,
-0.0108711254,
0.0191520806,
-0.0231113303,
-0.035834834,
-0.058987014,
-0.038601663,
-0.0006762497,
-0.0078543043,
0.0322804041,
0.0323630273,
-0.017147962,
-0.0235772319,
0.0890941694,
-0.0465259887,
0.0519609936,
0.0450673178,
-0.0191610977,
0.015113025,
-0.0408276804,
-0.0082063954,
-0.055137679,
-0.0551783033,
0.0643499866,
0.0604360066,
0.0201433655,
-0.0161426719,
0.0226870012,
0.0562618151,
-0.0420188904,
-0.0162340607,
-0.0203173887,
0.0173364114,
-0.0235748328,
-0.0308552328,
0.0104496814,
-0.0241866615,
0.0186392907,
0.0187554825,
0.0191017818,
0.0037633528,
-0.001171686,
0.0355076976,
0.0660766661,
0.0182865486,
-0.051830519,
0.0077342363,
0.0079731997,
-0.0786175281,
0.0498267785,
-0.0082634836,
-0.0043549854,
-0.0061564129,
2.868e-7,
0.0000884294,
-0.0219513495,
-0.0019164387,
-0.0489952303,
0.0046224832,
0.0159711875,
-0.0131595442,
0.0035750049,
-0.0086322855,
-0.0421871953,
0.0424423404,
0.015543961,
0.1104590595,
0.0215457287,
-0.0938409716,
-0.0543006696,
-0.0365161523,
-0.0016966704,
-0.0197341815,
-0.0337732956,
0.0207971483,
0.0620033816,
-0.0294175334,
-0.015724523,
0.0227848422,
-0.0012053759,
0.0331976712,
0.0124530327,
0.0418109484,
0.0068260548,
0.0818032175,
-0.0080870055,
-0.0241331104,
0.0320256092,
-0.0395012423,
0.0418653451,
0.0092660217,
0.103597559,
0.0074551683,
-0.0432375409,
0.010137815,
0.0089340527,
-0.0130254794,
-0.0164647028,
0.0366112441,
-0.0258629937,
0.0290703829,
0.0404302441,
-0.0384512097,
-0.0058144839,
-0.0190037452,
-0.0063208039,
0.0252741203,
0.0177407004,
0.0331128649,
-0.0085223457,
-0.0218623169,
-0.0510547757,
-0.0204441436,
0.0010453764,
-0.033593487,
-0.0796738565,
-0.0296120625,
-0.0221216548,
-0.0078582419,
0.0127362581,
-0.0098115606,
2.387493082e-34,
0.0056212069,
-0.0029190725,
0.0324066505,
-0.0587661862,
0.0264236797,
-0.0490401685,
-0.0328616835,
-0.0004535592,
-0.0007228306,
-0.0698461607,
-0.0332573615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10283v1 | Is augmentation effective to improve prediction in imbalanced text datasets? | 2023-04-20T13:07:31 | 2023-04-20T13:07:31 | Gabriel O. Assunção, Rafael Izbicki, Marcos O. Prates | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | Imbalanced datasets present a significant challenge for machine learning
models, often leading to biased predictions. To address this issue, data
augmentation techniques are widely used in natural language processing (NLP) to
generate new samples for the minority class. However, in this paper, we
challenge the common assumption that data augmentation is always necessary to
improve predictions on imbalanced datasets. Instead, we argue that adjusting
the classifier cutoffs without data augmentation can produce similar results to
oversampling techniques. Our study provides theoretical and empirical evidence
to support this claim. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of the
strengths and limitations of different approaches to dealing with imbalanced
data, and help researchers and practitioners make informed decisions about
which methods to use for a given task. | [
0.0319706574,
0.0541678704,
-0.0415839516,
-0.0193749256,
-0.038427297,
-0.0052613169,
0.0132535165,
0.0105118658,
-0.0112948008,
-0.0841766894,
0.0173207615,
-0.0010437304,
0.0107500665,
-0.0003258858,
-0.0004943542,
-0.044760175,
0.0096744066,
0.0118741347,
0.0173201021,
-0.0173630286,
0.0197226033,
0.0056076343,
0.0189328399,
0.0198017936,
0.0044363514,
0.024486402,
0.042694591,
0.0077986987,
0.0128689473,
-0.0138625968,
0.0301397387,
0.042966526,
0.02229283,
0.050024379,
0.0000017584,
-0.059366487,
0.0126970811,
0.0052781613,
-0.056111522,
0.0053554974,
0.0400398597,
-0.07102938,
0.0456915013,
0.0240673609,
-0.0183600001,
0.0170856472,
0.0087096794,
0.0804082304,
0.021545874,
0.0674385354,
-0.0071177403,
0.0048011504,
0.0413136072,
-0.0123527963,
0.0207391251,
0.0395995565,
0.025372792,
-0.003229755,
-0.0247727167,
-0.0307899192,
-0.0250506848,
0.0049991473,
0.0194719024,
0.0516893752,
0.0674504414,
0.0409549177,
-0.085915193,
-0.0074767987,
-0.0154945906,
0.0442657731,
-0.0218451545,
-0.0172650907,
-0.0387313478,
-0.0473939441,
0.036367733,
-0.0088651553,
-0.0255131125,
0.0035244059,
0.0087690605,
0.0572527722,
0.0056335037,
0.0376189873,
0.0375327319,
0.0424213707,
0.0246128794,
0.0609420389,
-0.0082404232,
-0.0678851977,
-0.0024935927,
0.057854943,
-0.0027612629,
-0.0252509452,
0.0231005363,
0.0082421182,
0.0234049149,
-0.0020400516,
-0.0503386185,
-0.0667703897,
0.0518984534,
-0.0263650715,
-0.0060066865,
0.0144200241,
-0.0504747778,
0.0070452671,
0.0089992732,
-0.0413509607,
0.0671536103,
0.037167456,
-0.0049071973,
-0.0078778146,
-0.0156394076,
0.0124137299,
-0.0281208213,
0.0285165701,
-0.0145608885,
0.0389093943,
-0.089029409,
-0.0244689826,
-0.0239250977,
-0.0452045351,
-0.0010717802,
0.0302727409,
-0.0654303208,
0.0165494904,
-0.0159168337,
0.0152587928,
0.0001168306,
0.0465496294,
-0.0319059044,
-0.0884855241,
0.0090241879,
0.0158751477,
0.0016822681,
-0.0516265072,
0.0399152189,
0.0296420492,
0.04390499,
-0.0694996119,
-0.0457442775,
-0.0029415209,
0.0054103178,
-0.0170038324,
-0.0302597433,
-0.07047645,
-0.0043378333,
-0.0051332796,
0.026428597,
-0.0035684293,
-0.0155446185,
0.0027022152,
-0.0390355177,
0.0728378892,
-0.0182099398,
0.0082907984,
0.0448431149,
-0.0181898233,
-0.0175532941,
0.0514193289,
0.0349282399,
-0.0226566344,
0.060716439,
-0.0002261804,
0.0412288569,
0.0309270862,
0.0131328478,
-0.0000697441,
-0.0054460252,
-0.0182792004,
-0.0576198511,
-0.0208995286,
0.0379117653,
-0.0105729606,
0.006840555,
-0.0192288179,
0.056351345,
0.0191532448,
0.017473001,
0.0118117845,
-0.0272975471,
-0.0233764593,
-0.0199542679,
0.0086870687,
-0.0415315628,
-0.0147857098,
-0.0213360917,
0.0010009438,
0.0068925703,
0.0250458196,
-0.0219061133,
-0.053213533,
-0.0234771166,
0.0128723988,
0.0783529356,
0.0004947584,
0.0769268125,
0.0083039543,
0.025124779,
0.0225965586,
0.0513036214,
-0.0050698142,
0.0360070951,
-0.0264251325,
-0.0386387818,
0.0393604264,
0.0166427307,
-0.0741753355,
0.0317381993,
-0.0468570665,
0.00199198,
0.00149802,
0.0427660942,
0.0397139564,
0.0293765813,
-0.0290212221,
-0.0010233414,
0.0129981758,
0.0393903181,
-0.0050902744,
0.0238965526,
0.0577315837,
0.0185312964,
-0.078327693,
-0.0984389856,
0.0480460189,
-0.0026361034,
-0.0397350341,
0.0252053291,
-0.0069002328,
-0.0308156461,
-0.0118422573,
-0.0410758406,
-0.0141745536,
0.0041068462,
-0.0090856412,
-0.0491370223,
-0.0352057479,
-0.0191536285,
-0.0494042002,
0.0378556326,
-0.0653184205,
-0.0115321511,
0.0059978822,
-0.0536189452,
-0.0041749808,
0.0392211452,
-0.0345674343,
0.0173486583,
-0.0430779122,
0.0084509226,
-0.0286441576,
0.0463413224,
-0.0338859484,
0.0336789824,
0.0138387,
0.0070400429,
-0.0484960265,
-0.0583645999,
0.0055026417,
-0.0513879061,
-0.0238272771,
-0.0198385678,
0.0044730846,
0.0140646901,
0.0288870279,
-0.0317043811,
-0.0340961888,
0.044658374,
-0.0754301772,
-0.0161310732,
-0.0367236249,
-0.019953968,
-0.0040840572,
0.019877594,
-0.0397842862,
-0.0275063217,
-0.0172912516,
-0.0684591085,
0.0403156318,
0.021264853,
0.0379126519,
-0.0139923478,
0.026665885,
0.0001168589,
-0.0347510688,
0.0064106113,
0.0387660898,
0.0441396534,
-0.0513717979,
-0.0215925518,
0.0081428709,
-0.0141008599,
0.0245778318,
0.010593459,
0.0052907844,
-0.038714014,
0.0442951322,
-0.0425696485,
0.0132623268,
0.0224449039,
0.0202494804,
0.0592162944,
0.0363470577,
-0.0081066675,
-0.0057742796,
-0.0012591687,
0.0293962043,
0.0061293049,
-0.0659340918,
0.0101332571,
0.0328060128,
-0.0062862472,
-0.0417681001,
0.0031573288,
-0.0206495337,
-0.0234404877,
-0.0064380583,
-0.0373553075,
-0.0208564438,
-0.0168565363,
0.0309505425,
-0.0221810509,
-0.0871185511,
0.0629498214,
0.0208979137,
0.0204828288,
-0.0602713116,
-0.0413273238,
-0.0420108028,
0.0075712311,
0.0240519866,
0.0017730488,
-0.0004341298,
0.0146882581,
-0.0258251131,
-0.0170545075,
0.0227882657,
-0.0131719615,
0.044827044,
-0.0254901368,
0.0054241656,
-0.0050561074,
-0.033807274,
-0.0415105596,
-0.047005266,
0.0010380025,
0.0129704662,
0.0050044768,
-0.0031040525,
-0.0363288261,
-0.0352735035,
-0.0331434458,
0.0548084304,
-0.0097365109,
-0.030495489,
0.0215255115,
0.0116429012,
0.0090961475,
-0.0137684373,
0.0338198245,
-0.027317578,
-0.0002414662,
0.002936102,
0.0246951096,
0.0084474925,
-0.0009533979,
-0.0008891969,
0.0227567758,
-0.043131128,
-0.0312485266,
-0.0099382866,
0.0270048492,
-0.0449711196,
0.0192925893,
0.0889716223,
0.0212547313,
-0.0155931227,
0.0387166366,
-0.0177434478,
0.0142037412,
0.0359282382,
0.0051735574,
-0.071699284,
-0.013325084,
0.00587537,
0.0441968516,
-0.0738568529,
-0.0419500619,
0.0001759365,
-0.124052383,
0.0458890125,
-0.0039886171,
-0.0374439843,
-0.0344811231,
-0.0129074827,
0.001017382,
-0.0482482091,
0.0500407517,
-0.0394580178,
-0.0196384229,
0.0236197598,
0.0503406636,
-0.0749768242,
-0.0673941523,
-0.0088628074,
-0.0515654311,
0.0398145244,
0.0115893818,
0.0582768656,
-0.0474409238,
0.0207788814,
0.0410058349,
-0.0070161442,
0.0314228423,
0.0043779961,
0.1157308668,
-0.0059610638,
-0.0105311768,
-0.0089171827,
0.0384186544,
-0.0075059743,
-0.0062804325,
0.0251566842,
0.021007726,
-0.0089091482,
-0.0024502168,
-0.0409236997,
-0.0217839368,
0.013428349,
0.07236965,
0.0056867306,
-0.0365252905,
-0.0036038475,
-0.0336480848,
0.0092673367,
-0.0329155996,
0.0450307801,
0.0642122179,
-0.0258802995,
-0.0566515364,
-0.0256469287,
-0.0540853292,
0.0065583256,
-0.0078104399,
0.0219918173,
0.0219790805,
-0.0583310761,
0.0179373343,
-0.0181009062,
0.0356054865,
-0.019319823,
0.0259270817,
0.0186902191,
-0.0500535071,
-0.0595058054,
-0.0710924789,
-0.0199822914,
-0.042268794,
-0.0414454825,
-0.0547810718,
0.0193873253,
0.020501988,
0.0215669069,
0.0604064353,
0.0010975535,
-0.067000404,
0.0534953848,
0.124281086,
-0.0495996661,
0.0096979477,
0.0055506104,
-0.0532470942,
0.0113779819,
0.0092223976,
-0.0087711373,
0.0352535285,
0.0468631461,
-0.009044406,
-0.0282225646,
0.0005441697,
-0.0027186843,
0.0486582667,
0.0664836094,
-0.0212345887,
-0.0049104653,
-0.0314142816,
0.0152078215,
0.0267011952,
-0.0174051821,
0.0105393305,
0.0109229609,
0.0176033191,
0.0307458565,
-0.0584407598,
0.0402807742,
-0.0508321039,
0.0118179247,
-0.0528982766,
0.0343835652,
0.028666947,
-0.0034857583,
0.0164253227,
0.0271211937,
0.0196404587,
0.0109500811,
0.0099113574,
0.0348309651,
0.0394089147,
-0.0199527573,
0.0086703477,
0.0633114278,
-0.0603131056,
-0.0402000919,
-0.0718480125,
0.0297667757,
-0.0329309851,
0.0441244431,
-0.0056645684,
-0.0620059893,
-0.0084209489,
-0.0254864972,
-0.0172851756,
-0.0115361083,
-0.0148001369,
0.0110946223,
0.0083480803,
-0.017717246,
-0.0144906091,
-0.0372826532,
0.0334860161,
0.0632658377,
-0.0071071805,
0.0676216185,
-0.0322691202,
-0.0589787364,
-0.0181412715,
0.0092805214,
0.0636110678,
0.0126427263,
0.0101107359,
0.0230404343,
-0.0508540235,
-0.0625415742,
0.0172161777,
-0.036369089,
0.0615389347,
-0.0041398052,
-0.0081463018,
0.037906874,
-0.0159080904,
-0.0017963771,
-0.0259495582,
0.0024962528,
-0.0118680298,
-0.0000148645,
-0.0354542546,
-5.48339462e-33,
0.0259175301,
0.0068818275,
-0.0388414152,
-0.0061810124,
0.0072073364,
0.0225356948,
0.0424303599,
-0.0184937287,
0.006159035,
0.0356169492,
-0.0327534825,
0.018749617,
0.0070379144,
0.0281167384,
0.010287636,
-0.0178314503,
0.0509558357,
0.0012759846,
-0.044500839,
-0.0232359208,
0.0150139323,
0.0507485867,
0.0775747597,
-0.0326128639,
0.0431481786,
-0.0047002719,
-0.0019317556,
-0.0053124451,
-0.0016066212,
0.0312933475,
0.016219046,
0.1398759484,
0.0489136428,
-0.0461472049,
0.0099982657,
-0.0002944098,
-0.0308088325,
-0.0165664572,
-0.0050648958,
0.0436480194,
0.0265642274,
0.0193595011,
0.0592729002,
0.0189678073,
-0.0233901739,
-0.0039764708,
0.0777187794,
-0.0424500704,
-0.0218735151,
-0.0296528358,
-0.0297045168,
0.0402617417,
-0.02906386,
0.0172439665,
-0.0191806089,
0.0629934445,
0.0033092562,
0.0215032585,
-0.0453911945,
-0.0044040703,
0.0935654342,
-0.0057907505,
0.0007793093,
0.0158667434,
-0.0206399802,
0.0598874427,
0.0133467624,
0.0213478357,
-0.0007994344,
0.0017254537,
0.0290212519,
-0.0404325165,
0.0191382449,
0.056745965,
0.1104570478,
-0.0158349723,
-0.0469711684,
0.0397640839,
0.0179153923,
-0.0251105558,
0.02168997,
-0.0017239559,
-0.0723846108,
-0.0529901274,
-0.004377861,
-0.0407103449,
-0.0092736678,
-0.0080607822,
-0.0100921784,
0.0448442586,
-0.0344718248,
0.0618232153,
-0.0233822148,
-0.0524745323,
-0.0685192421,
-0.021253055,
-0.0047601899,
-0.0391036198,
0.0095764752,
-0.0443037823,
-0.0311219506,
0.0086813988,
0.0316217653,
0.0248636007,
0.0072696768,
-0.0444601588,
0.1076483354,
0.0042520058,
-0.0506242625,
0.0026337989,
0.0148027148,
0.0427005403,
0.0351498686,
0.0677397475,
0.0217257217,
0.0360474512,
0.0002232976,
0.0216344241,
0.0307458304,
-0.0067477538,
-0.0203432683,
-0.0150618581,
-0.0232269242,
-0.0092005571,
-0.0240341779,
-0.016813891,
0.0557096489,
-0.0372644663,
0.0283570793,
-0.057288304,
-0.0227942299,
-0.066786848,
2.388e-7,
0.0610921234,
0.0330049843,
-0.0041193855,
-0.0583756231,
0.0018423465,
0.0305606611,
-0.0027524955,
0.0550987534,
0.0213635117,
-0.026304625,
-0.0152474632,
0.013437097,
-0.0072448007,
0.0158264115,
-0.0473884717,
0.0181994811,
-0.0608128197,
0.0184889976,
-0.0137582924,
-0.0098691415,
0.0281079933,
0.0878382176,
0.0396499969,
-0.0759759694,
0.0219527856,
-0.0293907542,
0.0110702431,
-0.0227453988,
0.0096246023,
0.0186202135,
0.0615628995,
0.0519105867,
0.0282740779,
0.0823560208,
-0.0464304835,
0.0230057333,
0.0157597605,
-0.0392527357,
-0.0427559018,
0.0439405441,
-0.0130437668,
0.0422738008,
-0.016858343,
-0.035993278,
0.0554286614,
-0.0378443301,
-0.0205742549,
-0.0715931505,
-0.0225944929,
0.004205124,
0.0871108845,
-0.0119206086,
-0.0080166636,
0.0344075076,
0.0176567473,
-0.0090657007,
-0.0477304496,
-0.0450006612,
-0.0294497851,
-0.014195608,
-0.0157135036,
-0.053305842,
-0.0090264399,
0.0432746001,
-0.0015924922,
-0.0626449957,
0.0089072436,
1.83541114e-34,
0.0251609925,
0.0355849974,
-0.0191612523,
-0.0259052441,
-0.0097503439,
0.0051514069,
0.0306552015,
-0.0032176804,
-0.0121493889,
-0.0017883866,
-0.0007621135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10256v1 | Indian Sign Language Recognition Using Mediapipe Holistic | 2023-04-20T12:25:47 | 2023-04-20T12:25:47 | Dr. Velmathi G, Kaushal Goyal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Deaf individuals confront significant communication obstacles on a daily
basis. Their inability to hear makes it difficult for them to communicate with
those who do not understand sign language. Moreover, it presents difficulties
in educational, occupational, and social contexts. By providing alternative
communication channels, technology can play a crucial role in overcoming these
obstacles. One such technology that can facilitate communication between deaf
and hearing individuals is sign language recognition. We will create a robust
system for sign language recognition in order to convert Indian Sign Language
to text or speech. We will evaluate the proposed system and compare CNN and
LSTM models. Since there are both static and gesture sign languages, a robust
model is required to distinguish between them. In this study, we discovered
that a CNN model captures letters and characters for recognition of static sign
language better than an LSTM model, but it outperforms CNN by monitoring hands,
faces, and pose in gesture sign language phrases and sentences. The creation of
a text-to-sign language paradigm is essential since it will enhance the sign
language-dependent deaf and hard-of-hearing population's communication skills.
Even though the sign-to-text translation is just one side of communication, not
all deaf or hard-of-hearing people are proficient in reading or writing text.
Some may have difficulty comprehending written language due to educational or
literacy issues. Therefore, a text-to-sign language paradigm would allow them
to comprehend text-based information and participate in a variety of social,
educational, and professional settings.
Keywords: deaf and hard-of-hearing, DHH, Indian sign language, CNN, LSTM,
static and gesture sign languages, text-to-sign language model, MediaPipe
Holistic, sign language recognition, SLR, SLT | [
-0.0191051066,
-0.0043368326,
0.0013530051,
0.0334657282,
-0.0175519288,
0.0298054516,
0.0466122553,
0.024181759,
0.0637453571,
-0.0455259122,
-0.0325559601,
-0.0284867324,
0.045498278,
0.0317597538,
0.0087516466,
-0.0852126852,
-0.001328585,
-0.008817954,
-0.020555133,
-0.0324675143,
0.0209898967,
0.0435176343,
-0.0518569462,
0.0029619152,
-0.0204845872,
0.004107872,
-0.0014869714,
0.0283888821,
0.016966885,
-0.0112161329,
-0.0508136824,
0.0256741419,
0.0532176346,
0.0036693683,
0.0000021812,
-0.0119673135,
0.0090173064,
-0.0159911234,
0.024348285,
-0.0062014763,
0.0694007725,
-0.0730670244,
-0.0267786887,
0.0455969684,
0.0110783167,
-0.0381286778,
0.0457725339,
0.1016137078,
-0.0002267144,
0.0422043204,
-0.0207656659,
-0.0145517262,
0.0711369589,
-0.0118391374,
0.0086148111,
0.0111788036,
-0.0153250489,
-0.0313550793,
-0.0047736578,
-0.0141808959,
-0.0253828727,
0.070234932,
0.0245513525,
-0.0263493545,
-0.0336429179,
0.0107538151,
-0.0117885312,
0.0196700729,
0.0094668735,
0.0469090119,
-0.060579028,
-0.0026235958,
0.033301238,
-0.0168496501,
-0.0165197868,
0.0092775235,
-0.0060016769,
0.0248222239,
-0.0194738507,
0.031423647,
-0.0286172088,
-0.0155584859,
0.0243777111,
0.0015683101,
0.0236484651,
-0.0476433001,
0.0160935391,
-0.008438847,
-0.0396514945,
-0.0350752212,
0.0497411378,
-0.0228656828,
0.0743892267,
0.0102134645,
-0.0033372252,
-0.00760801,
-0.0249311421,
-0.0226319414,
-0.0201408584,
-0.0666785911,
-0.054129269,
0.0391105115,
-0.0523007438,
0.0242856741,
-0.0190891623,
0.0150811011,
-0.0577797405,
0.0502225421,
-0.0202050153,
0.0403775275,
0.0036988666,
-0.0419275463,
0.0022944948,
-0.0135820815,
-0.0044803978,
-0.0350823216,
-0.0249271337,
-0.0041497569,
0.0117051154,
-0.0461318754,
0.0423308797,
0.0012595098,
-0.0061654649,
-0.0385210775,
0.0097567942,
0.0591276735,
0.001759042,
0.06261985,
-0.0659818128,
-0.0629683286,
0.0198357198,
0.0572434962,
0.0234148689,
0.0121985441,
0.0002098828,
0.0418896601,
-0.0357527621,
-0.025689384,
-0.0530841462,
0.0372422934,
0.0080214981,
-0.0240958277,
-0.0004033064,
-0.0357231051,
0.0123656914,
-0.0052848589,
-0.0041460292,
-0.0786067769,
-0.0058264467,
0.0012864562,
0.0345656946,
0.0572468005,
0.0026551075,
-0.0097416788,
0.1200888306,
0.0050102598,
0.0214032959,
0.0056070788,
0.059548568,
0.022191748,
-0.0109111145,
-0.0351166315,
0.0071530845,
0.0613029078,
-0.0385896601,
-0.0168555584,
-0.0276663937,
-0.0280917808,
-0.0428988934,
0.0198624711,
-0.0377706103,
0.0372733735,
-0.0053189001,
0.015191244,
0.0207406748,
0.0738503039,
0.0888074711,
-0.0144745037,
-0.0214343295,
0.0316451117,
0.0149350967,
-0.0511893034,
0.0101473117,
0.0220139008,
0.0360059738,
-0.0324702449,
-0.0283279773,
0.0120469807,
-0.0537175313,
-0.000726731,
-0.0178035032,
-0.0707675591,
0.0115497289,
0.0180795137,
0.075681664,
-0.0141158104,
-0.0503435098,
0.0091752531,
0.0031546075,
-0.0371053778,
0.0169170834,
-0.0359794572,
0.0140902791,
0.0034764349,
0.0007716328,
-0.0374880545,
0.0155953122,
-0.0202019382,
0.0057977075,
0.0617476515,
-0.0200014692,
0.0435342938,
0.0110534206,
-0.0599295273,
-0.0140918819,
0.0814667642,
-0.0265739374,
0.0399261676,
-0.0667523071,
0.1023632884,
0.0167287067,
0.033192724,
0.012645538,
0.0452224091,
0.0004821872,
-0.0085044615,
0.0316378064,
0.0144957155,
0.0547381341,
0.0467405394,
-0.0106189055,
-0.036168173,
0.0278209876,
-0.0420891121,
-0.044018738,
0.0332492851,
-0.0726751015,
-0.02918653,
0.0136139859,
-0.0802000612,
0.0293041877,
0.0410163775,
0.0121414512,
-0.087778151,
0.0310880095,
-0.0036030703,
0.0101832338,
-0.0372119471,
0.0214829072,
-0.0052592852,
-0.0080497693,
-0.009109905,
0.0075229621,
0.0104855122,
-0.0507723056,
-0.0706021637,
0.0012771586,
0.0370438844,
-0.1001547575,
-0.0108017093,
0.0500570126,
-0.0133650508,
0.0181216337,
0.038464129,
0.0570819043,
-0.0097952057,
0.0034818999,
-0.0618636347,
-0.0284008086,
0.0072688349,
0.0117823686,
-0.0153611489,
0.0046471846,
0.0202599932,
-0.0493567698,
-0.0420620888,
0.0011340443,
0.0295370817,
-0.0806416869,
-0.0108687235,
-0.0431489162,
-0.0188086201,
-0.0026773186,
-0.0223411415,
0.0037561525,
0.024095621,
0.0236557331,
-0.0661637485,
-0.0301727243,
-0.0008052489,
0.0517424867,
0.028857708,
0.0041603181,
-0.0092952019,
0.0253223795,
0.0023621134,
-0.0402399153,
-0.0088525936,
0.0047726939,
0.0200804714,
-0.0191319939,
0.0374546349,
0.001651414,
-0.0164866243,
0.0137511482,
0.0970869064,
-0.0390229821,
0.0026392585,
-0.0199768376,
0.0137305455,
0.0342358947,
0.0503985994,
-0.0274033118,
-0.0743348673,
-0.0270983726,
-0.0006001455,
-0.0186295547,
0.0002755542,
-0.0618411601,
-0.0246984884,
0.0105680684,
-0.0494433492,
0.0111675411,
-0.0643529296,
-0.0429321267,
-0.0071178959,
0.0059474423,
-0.0422311984,
0.0318941996,
0.0042287172,
0.0033978461,
-0.0716077015,
-0.0650914088,
-0.0175549686,
0.0236687735,
0.0050724414,
-0.03748722,
-0.0041375621,
-0.011296751,
0.0089959363,
-0.0409016497,
0.0345380716,
-0.0016233204,
0.0232597217,
-0.0137246568,
-0.0029040773,
-0.0133057712,
-0.0264863912,
-0.0119471904,
0.0349996611,
0.0353923626,
0.0567769818,
0.0296197645,
0.0220041666,
-0.0255155005,
0.0359037146,
0.0039987131,
-0.0070727989,
-0.048124399,
-0.0140260225,
0.0249142312,
-0.0020796484,
-0.0321591087,
0.0290473904,
-0.0190054253,
0.0019466676,
0.0329197012,
0.0494750105,
-0.0106452489,
0.0052782688,
0.0346153602,
-0.0076066777,
0.0360785909,
0.0722970888,
0.0194865726,
-0.0515534952,
-0.0200974029,
0.0247648433,
-0.0412419774,
-0.0532878563,
-0.0189992245,
-0.0468948819,
-0.052813448,
0.0080908015,
0.0322881229,
0.0413858183,
0.0249126591,
-0.0060305255,
0.0122760441,
-0.0216022078,
0.0168341659,
-0.0350361057,
-0.0141734676,
0.0172851812,
0.0022276451,
0.0300195441,
0.0616421849,
0.0128651634,
-0.0156813823,
-0.0420120284,
0.0068647861,
-0.0494475067,
-0.0439376123,
0.0035962665,
0.0130077461,
0.0486644879,
0.027571097,
0.0074053165,
-0.0196146257,
-0.047254052,
0.0415260196,
-0.0056663663,
0.0077171349,
-0.0304076187,
0.0264369454,
0.0011174203,
-0.0225830227,
-0.0101332143,
0.078609176,
-0.1018221825,
-0.0034486563,
0.0222177971,
0.0054348442,
-0.021545371,
-0.0159364473,
0.0014384999,
-0.0508226752,
-0.0133207906,
0.0226101428,
-0.0245575923,
-0.0477939509,
-0.051323127,
-0.0077108257,
-0.0122697745,
0.0626743361,
-0.0351283774,
0.0176919047,
-0.0384319574,
-0.080943197,
0.0151007399,
-0.0120195579,
0.0102762831,
0.0353140794,
0.0265606362,
0.0312677249,
0.0851096809,
0.0391716696,
-0.0080846148,
0.016212251,
-0.0181199834,
0.0726526752,
-0.0695329085,
0.0039261132,
-0.0189762544,
-0.0672147647,
0.001237496,
-0.0323859118,
-0.0538729616,
-0.0135229062,
0.0291506946,
-0.0331369229,
0.0184229854,
-0.026878465,
-0.0234911498,
-0.0623545423,
0.0074427472,
0.0324968472,
-0.0272157248,
0.0176705886,
0.0115058031,
-0.0389082357,
-0.0129970433,
-0.0017050304,
0.0161672644,
0.0545108803,
0.0113062141,
-0.0405419022,
-0.0983794853,
0.0116986837,
-0.0389065258,
0.0203935001,
-0.0135847423,
-0.0139394496,
-0.0488294624,
-0.0546940789,
0.0303461011,
-0.0002618752,
0.0523269139,
-0.0449427292,
-0.0086126598,
0.0465404019,
0.0274535976,
0.0025165186,
-0.0361387581,
-0.0044381036,
0.0082549881,
0.0089967456,
0.1158227548,
0.0170392301,
0.0762147978,
-0.0160773844,
-0.0172376893,
-0.0020740198,
0.0518130548,
-0.0328200608,
-0.002227315,
0.0147125721,
0.0426339209,
0.003547831,
-0.0053593488,
0.058788389,
0.0323846713,
0.0696117952,
-0.0200725459,
-0.0266633015,
0.0785453394,
0.0008013489,
0.0268444587,
0.0519855507,
-0.0055056098,
0.0398514494,
-0.0345380865,
0.0306665581,
-0.0154617131,
0.0085110692,
0.0659180954,
-0.0021810341,
-0.0223681144,
-0.0139779663,
-0.0185471047,
-0.0395128913,
-0.0517113544,
-0.0291871242,
-0.0002973937,
-0.0184803288,
0.0089248018,
0.0169948582,
0.0003076497,
-0.0245787986,
0.0548328608,
-0.0053768749,
-0.0190926865,
0.0219537299,
-0.0345844254,
0.0335327685,
-0.0331955329,
0.0090883998,
-0.0418768227,
0.0118562439,
0.0099653704,
-0.0029728306,
-0.0178361908,
-0.005505139,
-0.0298332293,
-0.0339161716,
-5.492527109e-33,
-0.0188550632,
-0.0653589666,
-0.0429908521,
0.0132761206,
-0.0152195087,
0.0279759839,
-0.0264846832,
0.0162120741,
-0.012519205,
-0.0008289614,
0.0005651872,
0.0002743137,
0.0167498458,
0.0342941508,
-0.0013962036,
-0.0183416288,
0.0128150592,
-0.0255168714,
0.0189202987,
0.0185775161,
0.0500946008,
0.014481388,
0.1014568061,
-0.094855696,
-0.0192618966,
-0.0687717646,
-0.0506009609,
-0.0119229387,
0.0223243833,
-0.017417483,
-0.0392294191,
0.0005158531,
0.0123616466,
-0.0169757828,
0.0536102988,
0.069709681,
-0.043966718,
0.0177642815,
-0.0394872241,
0.1155564189,
-0.053469561,
0.0206795149,
0.0351232849,
0.0045753303,
-0.04573939,
0.009452235,
0.0239990447,
0.0014369424,
-0.0082281856,
-0.0207085051,
-0.0273141563,
0.0809306726,
-0.0307779629,
-0.0167572703,
0.0020100088,
-0.0240171738,
-0.0215331819,
-0.0120527195,
-0.0657788739,
0.0165362004,
0.0035510925,
-0.0061102887,
0.0453159027,
-0.0165794436,
-0.0268825237,
0.0015370477,
0.0243452974,
-0.0729874745,
0.0017034773,
-0.0479235761,
0.0480913632,
0.01347668,
0.0150164161,
0.0386303477,
0.0467771254,
-0.0623054728,
-0.0410841182,
-0.0017615221,
0.0692122951,
0.0727361441,
-0.0090316767,
0.026832968,
-0.0238977559,
0.0046700607,
-0.0035293673,
0.0165901724,
-0.0092533752,
-0.0123732211,
0.0557775237,
0.0181190092,
0.0044085472,
0.0070217317,
0.0597198643,
0.0019592408,
0.0073413248,
-0.007937707,
-0.0065682884,
0.0359085947,
0.0084231272,
0.0066143279,
-0.0450550243,
-0.0745514706,
0.0593883209,
0.019726852,
0.0138293738,
-0.0058136722,
-0.0204824302,
0.0465256274,
-0.0484837182,
0.0118814455,
0.0093105081,
0.0115886386,
0.0201472137,
0.0500053652,
0.0232575797,
-0.0505448803,
-0.0078305621,
0.0400349721,
-0.0059383344,
-0.059852995,
-0.0226776954,
0.0203805678,
-0.001868638,
0.0361640677,
-0.0704543293,
0.0293501522,
-0.0138715496,
-0.0194931887,
0.0611189306,
-0.056710843,
0.0195284206,
0.0150045939,
2.731e-7,
-0.0067232489,
0.0137341991,
0.0199291743,
0.0138635244,
0.0361392535,
0.0320629291,
-0.0041461242,
0.0197549015,
-0.0111833587,
0.0713183582,
-0.0006386295,
-0.0027791292,
0.0470307097,
-0.011782934,
-0.073708497,
0.0474135838,
-0.0213716403,
0.0366132371,
-0.0123649854,
0.0734364465,
0.0430888347,
0.0490303673,
0.0071396613,
-0.0585687719,
0.0237581674,
-0.0781996474,
0.0543630831,
-0.0149835385,
0.0870333612,
-0.0179611165,
0.0426806435,
-0.0758559182,
-0.0324132703,
-0.0034483355,
-0.004123298,
-0.0060833055,
0.0460362956,
0.0338421203,
-0.0807711929,
0.0317213982,
0.0336671919,
0.0477593131,
-0.0291084349,
-0.0215641297,
0.0632896051,
0.0251217913,
-0.0111668454,
-0.019431008,
-0.0046892841,
-0.0137209706,
0.017838357,
0.020520512,
0.0359898806,
0.020322429,
0.0107961036,
-0.0762254074,
-0.0065048691,
-0.0460263677,
-0.0207874514,
-0.0446463525,
-0.0333618224,
0.0118266782,
-0.0302187204,
0.0211240221,
0.0221749898,
-0.0391546711,
-0.0481081419,
1.87626416e-34,
0.003092184,
0.0036832222,
-0.0085606454,
0.0117667103,
-0.0279716775,
-0.0042906757,
0.0541656651,
0.0253057219,
0.0104043623,
-0.0379863903,
-0.0212449096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10220v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10220v1 | Effective Open Intent Classification with K-center Contrastive Learning and Adjustable Decision Boundary | 2023-04-20T11:35:06 | 2023-04-20T11:35:06 | Xiaokang Liu, Jianquan Li, Jingjing Mu, Min Yang, Ruifeng Xu, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T01, I.2.1 | Open intent classification, which aims to correctly classify the known
intents into their corresponding classes while identifying the new unknown
(open) intents, is an essential but challenging task in dialogue systems. In
this paper, we introduce novel K-center contrastive learning and adjustable
decision boundary learning (CLAB) to improve the effectiveness of open intent
classification. First, we pre-train a feature encoder on the labeled training
instances, which transfers knowledge from known intents to unknown intents.
Specifically, we devise a K-center contrastive learning algorithm to learn
discriminative and balanced intent features, improving the generalization of
the model for recognizing open intents. Second, we devise an adjustable
decision boundary learning method with expanding and shrinking (ADBES) to
determine the suitable decision conditions. Concretely, we learn a decision
boundary for each known intent class, which consists of a decision center and
the radius of the decision boundary. We then expand the radius of the decision
boundary to accommodate more in-class instances if the out-of-class instances
are far from the decision boundary; otherwise, we shrink the radius of the
decision boundary. Extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets clearly
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method for open intent classification. For
reproducibility, we submit the code at: https://github.com/lxk00/CLAP | [
0.0652751103,
0.0019661889,
0.0032293526,
0.0302381944,
-0.0358220153,
-0.0052818502,
-0.0059677265,
0.0346498303,
0.0267317016,
-0.073500514,
-0.0307744928,
-0.0471912585,
-0.0108658923,
0.0622200221,
-0.0666909665,
-0.0627102554,
0.0434628651,
-0.0083115697,
0.0324233547,
0.009015562,
-0.0137430755,
0.0084083127,
-0.0307933409,
0.0466523655,
-0.0022980354,
-0.0295910817,
-0.0524874292,
0.0026705849,
0.0343196541,
-0.0141437771,
0.0419683196,
0.0643133223,
0.0092338771,
-0.006584073,
0.0000019675,
-0.0659951344,
-0.0204112176,
-0.060216397,
-0.05124899,
-0.0279546361,
0.0425291322,
-0.0208501052,
0.0226415303,
0.0579163581,
-0.0032724175,
-0.0332363732,
0.051233843,
0.0737264827,
0.0158727672,
0.0779893473,
-0.0026426876,
-0.0704599917,
0.026817197,
-0.0000914618,
0.0052590175,
-0.047776863,
0.0166439544,
-0.0284824278,
-0.0404371694,
0.0084952973,
0.0064347549,
0.0153812971,
0.0150516927,
-0.0042829555,
0.0285699312,
0.0270191878,
0.0402722768,
0.0053791958,
-0.0260303151,
0.0758527666,
0.0201784559,
0.0117966961,
-0.0388940535,
-0.0519038625,
-0.0152627872,
-0.0498329811,
-0.0049994239,
0.0278144199,
0.0064767175,
0.0073796762,
0.0301745273,
0.0603707545,
-0.0353354104,
0.0254064724,
-0.0568315871,
0.016636448,
-0.0254277047,
-0.0306778476,
0.0190255996,
-0.0225427933,
-0.0006611755,
-0.0423826389,
0.0242485628,
0.0268739033,
-0.0245254152,
0.0175882559,
-0.0234527234,
-0.0271722972,
0.039931111,
0.011536506,
-0.0225818474,
0.0321649648,
-0.0361290127,
0.0418091938,
0.0368478708,
-0.0016167386,
0.012800267,
0.0347826965,
-0.0488375351,
-0.001580356,
-0.0337611772,
0.0154625922,
-0.0444040224,
0.0202361271,
-0.0687792972,
-0.0246542096,
-0.0400394537,
0.0262281038,
-0.0017960276,
-0.0218759347,
0.0400342569,
0.0195583906,
-0.0077174795,
0.0121076126,
-0.0216586832,
0.0426683947,
0.0014605065,
0.0376536846,
0.0048291343,
-0.0161665622,
-0.0166534483,
0.0447615199,
0.0175039992,
-0.0001992316,
-0.0059647346,
0.0314952098,
-0.0290271994,
-0.057842806,
-0.0409097597,
0.0020826894,
-0.0382923409,
-0.0150017142,
-0.0670236647,
-0.0110932812,
-0.033046674,
0.0083826473,
-0.0284479819,
-0.017941542,
0.0010882586,
0.0007288314,
0.0194808152,
0.0674486458,
-0.0114907604,
-0.0358980075,
0.0197736584,
-0.0114311716,
-0.0178190637,
0.0487830639,
0.0023604815,
-0.0095799249,
0.0032682891,
0.0121005792,
0.0331996083,
-0.0047251694,
0.0425984487,
-0.0311055891,
0.0351973474,
0.0238136724,
0.0370779634,
0.0575792417,
0.0139543824,
0.0298379473,
-0.0331150442,
-0.0495898686,
0.0328723416,
0.0293445196,
-0.0089173587,
0.0022244172,
0.0038301356,
0.0745020285,
-0.038338542,
-0.0109355971,
0.0276238099,
-0.0066686948,
-0.0518102497,
-0.0037290752,
0.0178136714,
-0.0065203011,
-0.029776372,
-0.0541959628,
-0.0101960646,
-0.0219162032,
0.049586527,
-0.003302783,
0.0839088485,
0.0069569647,
-0.0520593859,
0.0480470285,
0.0054325745,
-0.0181560982,
-0.0416462421,
-0.0578475967,
0.054015059,
-0.0043649459,
0.0059378054,
-0.0416643955,
0.000312807,
-0.0571524799,
-0.0292142443,
0.0112212952,
0.04169764,
-0.0259916242,
0.0263748467,
-0.0587460212,
-0.0389932357,
-0.0318609178,
-0.0104092071,
0.0098736929,
-0.0351153202,
0.0190696567,
0.0104003334,
0.0362075418,
0.0323818699,
-0.0016218022,
0.0688783079,
0.0087897731,
0.0567031205,
0.0564612038,
0.0399227664,
0.0353741795,
0.0301340912,
-0.0328529812,
0.0145443501,
-0.013618716,
-0.003069676,
0.0059704646,
-0.0578698441,
-0.0891199559,
0.0185588468,
0.0086471578,
-0.0411184095,
0.0178803429,
-0.0283226278,
-0.0324786007,
0.055144459,
-0.0360308178,
0.0352149233,
-0.0489291437,
0.0028116733,
-0.0055706799,
-0.0042212568,
-0.0250668004,
0.0850763023,
0.000812619,
-0.0081385942,
0.0286745466,
0.0017515129,
0.0445638224,
-0.0441157669,
0.0200105254,
-0.0091854129,
-0.0459248126,
0.0057700174,
-0.0032259251,
0.0380350798,
-0.0668835267,
0.0000245472,
-0.0712777674,
-0.0028233316,
-0.0364890993,
-0.02507459,
0.0192670189,
0.005393533,
0.0229915828,
-0.0074637569,
-0.0144190043,
0.0180307962,
0.0127851637,
-0.0277431328,
0.0376850218,
0.0196939185,
-0.0525526591,
0.0426221527,
0.0432255976,
0.0183973741,
0.0556111336,
-0.0148027111,
0.0237897746,
-0.0315504111,
0.0969160125,
0.0172453951,
0.0356376469,
-0.0039847312,
-0.0160172582,
0.0228860099,
0.0046153273,
-0.0344899446,
0.0455203652,
0.0347513445,
0.0480202585,
0.0045705708,
0.0022273527,
-0.0480977148,
0.034902472,
-0.0218423177,
-0.0090571186,
-0.0142189581,
0.0297448374,
0.0153882047,
0.0474911369,
0.0424325764,
0.0113211256,
-0.0406675451,
-0.0775866732,
0.029822927,
-0.0365205444,
-0.0550826006,
0.0059114336,
-0.049308233,
0.0419668853,
0.0035889414,
-0.0316479355,
0.0713306516,
0.0203186944,
-0.0180175938,
-0.0978865996,
-0.0448868573,
-0.0338298157,
0.0451273359,
-0.0812174231,
0.0147013646,
0.040247146,
-0.0676761866,
-0.0087878117,
-0.0300222002,
-0.0269732699,
-0.0207863878,
0.0922605023,
-0.0153506398,
0.002430721,
-0.0062299869,
-0.0463811569,
-0.0637251511,
-0.0433507971,
-0.0124006579,
0.0018526653,
0.0268102847,
0.0138806757,
-0.0225336757,
0.0307520647,
-0.0175613984,
0.0638302043,
0.0232789256,
0.0166748688,
-0.0013002461,
0.0263757017,
0.016774023,
0.0381226875,
-0.0254328065,
-0.0120253246,
0.0223806892,
0.0297860187,
-0.0271864273,
-0.0268691927,
-0.0076485979,
-0.0032289538,
0.0346503258,
-0.0066202339,
0.0177871641,
0.002761249,
0.0675086826,
0.0007868599,
-0.0069359243,
0.1043859571,
0.0395851545,
-0.0533748418,
-0.0374171622,
-0.0533266924,
-0.0008070103,
0.0129987188,
-0.011831318,
-0.0737058967,
-0.0750968754,
-0.0233249869,
0.0176820792,
-0.0135122221,
0.0124596069,
-0.0018764177,
-0.1333313733,
0.0056248261,
-0.0173074845,
-0.0735068917,
-0.062160518,
0.0154347448,
0.0142193893,
-0.0524990074,
0.0039457711,
0.003636864,
0.0381179117,
-0.0383342803,
0.0114062522,
0.0159832519,
-0.0479683429,
0.0230337624,
-0.0200668275,
0.028568916,
-0.0059031383,
0.003192659,
0.0339119136,
-0.0430179797,
0.0093789203,
-0.0810254812,
-0.004354001,
-0.0362614021,
0.0492983013,
-0.0201439019,
0.0258008819,
0.0000182046,
0.0197515897,
-0.0397618935,
-0.0399325378,
0.0073796338,
0.0309206303,
-0.0372772552,
0.0371048041,
-0.0044561261,
0.0310215857,
0.0976335034,
0.0684928894,
0.0039588711,
-0.0416630469,
0.0064059831,
-0.0122603253,
-0.0074256272,
-0.0107039241,
0.0381033607,
-0.0172624886,
-0.0015038379,
-0.0143624721,
-0.0231075808,
-0.0256196167,
0.0287185814,
0.018233588,
-0.0062776101,
-0.0045007118,
-0.0375032872,
0.0309483986,
-0.029038135,
0.0006719491,
-0.0103518385,
0.0195150189,
-0.0344914161,
-0.0289050899,
0.0309013855,
-0.0793977529,
-0.0272505786,
0.0036287864,
-0.0118703796,
-0.0430988297,
-0.0380014852,
0.0028244057,
0.0123008685,
0.0526267029,
-0.0186027866,
0.0031852205,
0.0282873306,
0.0144097302,
0.0119114434,
-0.0039547118,
0.0607770905,
0.0486372449,
-0.0198472384,
0.0190690868,
-0.0211522002,
0.0115627656,
0.0138344802,
-0.0200925358,
-0.0896592587,
-0.0777595118,
0.0264207385,
-0.0274333563,
0.064876914,
0.0240390245,
-0.0290514175,
-0.0566795394,
0.0415818654,
0.0250419956,
-0.0240802206,
-0.0322707444,
0.011224228,
0.0111517385,
-0.025042193,
-0.0024217819,
0.0025594698,
-0.0235496536,
-0.0212676581,
0.0094232894,
0.0055104955,
0.0579432398,
0.058300361,
-0.0104067801,
-0.0030126357,
-0.0419805311,
0.0320345201,
-0.0007413772,
0.0171454474,
0.0601626113,
0.1118014529,
0.012374579,
-0.0190782826,
0.0020633314,
0.01373195,
-0.0228938758,
0.0180457067,
-0.0369005352,
0.0336768441,
-0.0011871925,
0.0188480318,
-0.0320615992,
-0.007800967,
-0.0026128509,
-0.012737208,
0.0714880005,
-0.0489900634,
-0.0466403216,
0.0213887636,
0.0005725509,
-0.0120731676,
0.0144877452,
-0.0070445542,
-0.1122720838,
0.0199437756,
-0.0249183699,
0.017389616,
-0.0380063914,
0.0425079204,
0.0459756106,
0.0236236658,
0.0022228395,
0.0613418445,
-0.0265936572,
-0.0284407679,
0.0331600495,
0.0010450373,
0.029667601,
0.0356817953,
0.0588130243,
0.039986439,
0.0289688725,
-0.0337338597,
-0.0308206696,
-0.0091840187,
-0.0291945934,
0.0144413216,
-0.0495467484,
-5.988560011e-33,
-0.0052216258,
0.0262869745,
0.0004565991,
-0.0255232658,
-0.0044849901,
-0.0040580207,
-0.0199452266,
-0.0153552704,
-0.0326764211,
-0.0158988945,
0.0165032987,
0.0192523878,
0.0073176832,
0.0281659085,
-0.0270529725,
-0.0468318872,
0.0296449736,
-0.0244739875,
-0.0018624417,
0.0255946908,
0.0721913278,
-0.0075919959,
0.0381470807,
-0.1078904569,
-0.0387123637,
0.0168965086,
-0.0328412987,
0.0399772078,
-0.0015764511,
0.048503045,
-0.0210986435,
0.0426934585,
0.0018553975,
-0.0590583198,
0.0122464271,
0.0088913329,
-0.0412088819,
0.0002137827,
-0.0249604899,
0.0287793316,
-0.0456743613,
-0.020433316,
0.0251117256,
0.0082576405,
-0.0227829926,
-0.0311978795,
-0.0025933883,
-0.024839649,
0.0304287244,
0.006138674,
-0.0425845161,
0.0166953672,
-0.0299444925,
-0.0530144423,
-0.0377579294,
0.0254342631,
0.0302131344,
-0.0289073028,
-0.0505224764,
0.0248977914,
0.008570225,
-0.0332507491,
0.0188671015,
0.0322189927,
-0.0044096997,
0.0608131662,
-0.0088176206,
-0.0239963867,
0.0089893136,
-0.0274775345,
-0.0553440638,
0.0556811728,
0.0224519558,
0.0760642961,
0.0497898757,
-0.0445467457,
-0.0452285632,
0.0097551914,
0.0001176761,
-0.005393825,
-0.0061312807,
0.0465127937,
-0.0361352265,
-0.0055684387,
0.0053802696,
-0.0286112167,
-0.0369926766,
-0.0061487607,
0.0197629929,
0.0361781307,
-0.0229483265,
-0.0144169237,
0.0348472372,
-0.0311545022,
0.0554822087,
0.0383912101,
0.0107709244,
0.0235059243,
-0.0080513852,
-0.0337444693,
-0.0573190637,
-0.0374598727,
0.0538963079,
-0.0262957867,
-0.0029066738,
0.0352824591,
0.0205720477,
0.0134804714,
-0.0097951582,
-0.003871402,
0.0151651176,
0.0444876216,
-0.0316079594,
0.0621815659,
0.0112281255,
-0.0032295589,
-0.0143695967,
0.0956850946,
-0.0032745753,
0.0196763892,
-0.0453502722,
-0.0858221576,
0.0270593632,
0.0021954246,
-0.0275897309,
0.0147442352,
0.0598984398,
-0.0631731749,
-0.0058038807,
-0.0322730094,
-0.0059510698,
0.0243383981,
2.727e-7,
0.0085377628,
-0.022025805,
0.0163995065,
0.0469200201,
-0.0239560027,
0.0774862692,
0.0082990276,
0.0304518864,
0.0146552324,
-0.0367138498,
0.0498318635,
-0.0058020661,
0.0249658059,
-0.0074435454,
-0.1128779948,
0.0212138835,
0.0073576714,
-0.057694599,
-0.0238323938,
0.0359450765,
0.1056188568,
0.1075576022,
0.0303644221,
-0.0376567133,
0.0295260455,
0.0111759463,
-0.0019783454,
0.0034111922,
0.0489344597,
-0.0317040794,
0.0436648838,
-0.0368605703,
0.002834768,
0.0585074909,
0.0171132963,
0.0630719215,
-0.0171968937,
0.0254040025,
0.0315963104,
-0.0523785613,
0.0061499923,
0.019579513,
0.0124106323,
-0.0193139315,
0.0693570301,
-0.0309595112,
-0.0181606188,
-0.0099975141,
-0.0101067042,
-0.0394549891,
0.0469766967,
-0.0061440691,
0.0448967367,
-0.013782138,
-0.0228480082,
-0.0086593367,
0.0059900573,
-0.106109947,
0.0164444577,
0.0001827187,
-0.0301999021,
-0.0255036335,
0.0360814519,
0.018053852,
0.0306469724,
-0.0521169156,
0.0031365501,
2.025701175e-34,
0.0238490589,
-0.0411972143,
-0.0227857921,
0.036521174,
0.0158421956,
0.0011891336,
-0.0114842327,
-0.0309365466,
0.0704639256,
-0.0691999123,
-0.0066210376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10216v1 | Exploring Paracrawl for Document-level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-04-20T11:21:34 | 2023-04-20T11:21:34 | Yusser Al Ghussin, Jingyi Zhang, Josef van Genabith | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level neural machine translation (NMT) has outperformed
sentence-level NMT on a number of datasets. However, document-level NMT is
still not widely adopted in real-world translation systems mainly due to the
lack of large-scale general-domain training data for document-level NMT. We
examine the effectiveness of using Paracrawl for learning document-level
translation. Paracrawl is a large-scale parallel corpus crawled from the
Internet and contains data from various domains. The official Paracrawl corpus
was released as parallel sentences (extracted from parallel webpages) and
therefore previous works only used Paracrawl for learning sentence-level
translation. In this work, we extract parallel paragraphs from Paracrawl
parallel webpages using automatic sentence alignments and we use the extracted
parallel paragraphs as parallel documents for training document-level
translation models. We show that document-level NMT models trained with only
parallel paragraphs from Paracrawl can be used to translate real documents from
TED, News and Europarl, outperforming sentence-level NMT models. We also
perform a targeted pronoun evaluation and show that document-level models
trained with Paracrawl data can help context-aware pronoun translation. | [
0.0470460467,
0.0681547746,
0.0225841589,
0.0259300247,
-0.0535193197,
0.0049040234,
0.0523730591,
-0.0550033972,
-0.0416922085,
-0.0284610391,
-0.0222617649,
-0.0205980241,
0.0227371082,
-0.0823922679,
0.0230122562,
-0.0335758291,
0.020879792,
0.0482253954,
0.0041613965,
-0.0025366647,
0.0077245873,
0.0241933018,
-0.0118828043,
0.0359649584,
0.0041896938,
-0.0501657613,
-0.0108530382,
0.0650174692,
0.0324725583,
0.0172057152,
0.0352863483,
0.0106133251,
0.0120833386,
0.0531624518,
0.0000018339,
-0.0255945586,
-0.0645373836,
0.0018961672,
0.0351645313,
0.0258305855,
0.0527862646,
-0.028009668,
-0.0345305726,
0.0410090201,
-0.0022413179,
-0.0286042206,
0.0365212969,
0.0485506169,
0.0618455485,
0.1077099293,
-0.0240861084,
-0.0217174012,
0.0043661431,
-0.0543840751,
-0.0582222864,
-0.0609853603,
-0.0426159874,
-0.0463685989,
-0.0368215963,
-0.0062509375,
0.0101132412,
0.0577820428,
-0.0027327086,
-0.0152369365,
-0.0090033533,
-0.0054801404,
-0.0259120949,
-0.0407809354,
0.0009879287,
0.0812594518,
-0.0546925813,
-0.0115878107,
0.0053176545,
-0.0050227204,
0.0009389601,
0.0135263,
-0.0241589509,
0.0329399221,
-0.0200889222,
0.0060211266,
-0.0023393577,
-0.0021532511,
0.039958667,
0.002872285,
-0.0157741942,
0.0437190495,
0.045736827,
-0.0567135327,
0.0323856287,
-0.0148548177,
0.0026512539,
0.0127897644,
0.0631809905,
-0.0151556246,
-0.0168453753,
0.0378468446,
-0.0577328987,
-0.0734511167,
0.0367305651,
-0.0815940872,
0.0339284874,
0.0447726436,
0.0198389944,
0.0170583315,
-0.0160939321,
0.0610901602,
-0.044685524,
0.0025966556,
-0.0644483864,
-0.042012468,
-0.026220087,
0.0192556176,
-0.0604732223,
0.001311268,
-0.0628470555,
-0.0061699799,
-0.019702768,
0.0296812505,
0.0256431028,
0.035250254,
0.009337632,
-0.0097696278,
-0.0713055655,
-0.0223081913,
0.0272287726,
0.0776847228,
-0.0160685349,
0.0049670758,
0.0013330537,
-0.0313368142,
-0.0131567894,
0.0051924689,
0.0195009746,
-0.0542930588,
-0.0024552858,
0.0772038028,
-0.0252551697,
-0.0374335609,
-0.0230691191,
-0.0077586668,
-0.0239810646,
-0.03243085,
0.0041188598,
-0.0492254049,
0.0549494699,
-0.0053108288,
0.0252187755,
-0.044267267,
0.0163803771,
0.0351356901,
-0.0250408147,
0.0631124377,
0.0011321659,
-0.0119662117,
0.017548155,
-0.008813425,
0.0238354336,
0.0630741641,
0.0727766678,
0.0426731035,
0.0270426013,
-0.0031692239,
-0.0543386489,
0.0151221277,
0.0285831429,
-0.006696017,
0.002308178,
0.0262517333,
0.0346019529,
0.079703182,
0.030910328,
0.0371266603,
0.0093865665,
-0.0008034182,
0.075986594,
0.0277878698,
0.02001472,
0.0269295685,
0.0453213714,
0.0163194295,
-0.0155379502,
-0.0137990871,
-0.0388809517,
-0.0069326716,
0.0117432522,
0.0129337125,
0.0308128595,
0.0676951334,
-0.0253810324,
-0.0087337829,
-0.0025444992,
-0.004136249,
-0.0110942451,
-0.0334373266,
0.0228474513,
0.0163183864,
-0.0530293882,
0.04425494,
0.0025388014,
-0.0837288275,
0.0089061288,
-0.0016948028,
-0.0548747592,
0.0409670137,
0.0369710065,
-0.0190322567,
-0.0633556843,
-0.0333794244,
0.0344363376,
0.0796862617,
0.0522041693,
0.0230738949,
0.0247540195,
-0.0417907089,
-0.0113443155,
-0.0390217863,
-0.0085590156,
0.0322662331,
0.0185963139,
0.0298727285,
0.0585261546,
-0.0343766212,
-0.0780063048,
0.0363797173,
-0.0309109204,
-0.0167576019,
0.0400403962,
0.0268420763,
0.0196423288,
0.0116169574,
-0.0162325203,
-0.0130919898,
0.0072108428,
-0.0260125455,
-0.0304304566,
0.0107654901,
-0.0313182697,
-0.043409422,
0.0037039004,
-0.0943108499,
-0.0136451367,
0.0685462356,
-0.0579318553,
-0.0392526053,
-0.0123793092,
-0.0278184935,
0.0139420256,
-0.0217419397,
0.0285786651,
-0.0025574514,
0.0049523702,
-0.0372800156,
0.0200705044,
-0.0035584997,
-0.0067296983,
0.0041521336,
-0.0217836909,
0.0256968513,
-0.0273688678,
-0.0305877868,
0.0163280535,
-0.0124352211,
0.0784810558,
0.0440414846,
0.0370980464,
-0.0251264945,
-0.061407119,
-0.0541732572,
0.0475980043,
-0.0191615317,
0.0396546759,
0.0580782704,
0.0484815091,
0.0099137686,
-0.0173912682,
-0.0113136191,
0.0253993738,
-0.0353134908,
-0.0048336983,
0.0484395325,
-0.0106283557,
0.0289411843,
-0.053388536,
-0.0127056176,
-0.0314956121,
0.0193060637,
0.0283763278,
-0.0187039915,
-0.0295261778,
0.0132224467,
-0.0124888951,
0.0024823199,
0.001450954,
-0.0587677769,
-0.0101954574,
-0.005395792,
0.0103710881,
0.0683747679,
-0.005965183,
0.0207775887,
0.0137544954,
0.0071946364,
-0.047620099,
0.0443299524,
-0.0290876273,
-0.0261907652,
-0.049887795,
-0.0314427838,
0.0492764674,
0.0669253841,
-0.0029051828,
-0.012966685,
-0.0398901738,
0.0175776649,
0.001851903,
-0.0104392841,
-0.0055095386,
0.0302938167,
0.0115640284,
-0.012155585,
-0.0310505945,
-0.0236793999,
0.0513640977,
-0.0363186263,
0.0120671932,
-0.0822556093,
-0.0252089892,
-0.0464801304,
0.0215691701,
-0.0268094596,
0.0273575671,
-0.0298521109,
-0.0596205518,
-0.0473458134,
0.0189830717,
-0.0009452464,
-0.0039245617,
0.0366950966,
-0.0427055024,
-0.0010550878,
-0.0436190255,
-0.0485397056,
-0.0273490641,
-0.0612385534,
0.008393934,
0.009930864,
-0.0169222336,
-0.0413691364,
-0.0509624891,
-0.0140874684,
-0.0039697653,
0.0657785758,
-0.048536852,
-0.003309791,
-0.0586109161,
0.0365321152,
0.0275023431,
0.0029851624,
0.0093310652,
-0.0281334165,
0.0096953884,
0.0287917349,
0.0271210652,
-0.0018080904,
-0.0386407077,
-0.0205679871,
0.0097500095,
-0.0564375445,
0.005419801,
-0.0476336218,
0.0088306144,
-0.0569731146,
-0.0096078571,
0.1082748026,
0.0309791155,
-0.0592006557,
-0.0429395288,
0.0015574315,
0.029586589,
0.0013096165,
0.0245104618,
-0.0379496813,
-0.0304376129,
-0.0004416775,
0.021117596,
0.0341288075,
0.0240304787,
-0.0382022448,
-0.0829341561,
-0.0255212076,
0.0252246298,
-0.0339883231,
-0.0115965484,
0.003087654,
-0.0080851382,
-0.0249545779,
0.0439614058,
0.0289465711,
-0.0195578486,
-0.0103907166,
-0.0155661106,
0.0299813617,
-0.0337667838,
-0.0008681082,
-0.0601359494,
0.0072661703,
0.022120202,
0.0758190975,
-0.0076548792,
-0.0141762784,
0.0584275946,
-0.0496796556,
-0.0124786533,
-0.0038178528,
0.0021015822,
-0.031086253,
-0.0205729529,
0.0141782537,
0.0262315404,
-0.0345197767,
0.0500726067,
0.0328239165,
0.0419747606,
-0.0086977836,
0.0037389291,
-0.010785426,
0.0007670502,
-0.0003037171,
0.0593421273,
0.0059584025,
-0.0763057843,
-0.0319489278,
0.0068755592,
-0.0190977622,
-0.029193677,
0.0369556993,
-0.0011637226,
-0.0359881148,
-0.0293249059,
-0.0730653256,
-0.0544275157,
0.0133570991,
0.0258909874,
0.0471520647,
-0.0351589248,
0.0470337197,
-0.0043786243,
-0.0526434928,
0.0399088599,
-0.0121113444,
0.0252333283,
-0.0267960392,
0.034363851,
0.05687185,
-0.0042937393,
-0.0091821691,
0.0176537074,
-0.0704727247,
-0.0781311095,
-0.0201803949,
0.0118152173,
0.0174258091,
0.0772481114,
-0.0718306154,
-0.0382049568,
0.0265385509,
0.0226082355,
-0.0497142896,
-0.0108585749,
0.0302984472,
0.0142002441,
-0.0143094072,
0.0437205136,
-0.0186274126,
-0.0147296069,
-0.0107792448,
0.0334444754,
0.0211337041,
-0.0557650551,
0.0338481404,
-0.0273673404,
0.0282880347,
0.0022119703,
0.0137324678,
-0.0475476496,
0.0591533892,
-0.0007603711,
0.0073420852,
-0.0305131357,
-0.037710987,
0.0428296737,
0.0023352217,
0.0020193877,
-0.0087841693,
0.0009566742,
0.0101451585,
-0.0128709115,
-0.0187886003,
-0.014458946,
0.0490726009,
-0.0171455331,
0.0067641726,
-0.0113004427,
0.016067829,
0.0164910275,
0.0223398544,
-0.0360662229,
0.0295443926,
0.0336207487,
0.0039291582,
0.0007472234,
0.051636491,
-0.0562441871,
0.0013160134,
-0.0262810681,
-0.0126165049,
0.0784385353,
0.0171290915,
0.1067220047,
-0.0102694901,
-0.012257427,
0.0152139775,
0.0389489233,
0.0083544226,
0.0319155008,
0.0128654391,
-0.0174457207,
-0.0126177268,
-0.0012603285,
0.0535609238,
0.0451459959,
-0.0103081586,
0.0032504301,
-0.0084649464,
-0.0465932079,
-0.0204097442,
-0.0133503405,
-0.0032475747,
-0.0275070705,
-0.0366874374,
-0.013017118,
-0.0134814205,
0.0067394204,
0.025372535,
-0.0224293694,
-0.0043253521,
0.0084695518,
0.0914573967,
-0.0388519317,
-0.0256192964,
-0.0467374586,
0.0318556018,
0.0090839472,
-0.0427805297,
-0.0373521671,
-6.328143064e-33,
-0.0581635907,
0.0027173089,
0.0157000832,
0.0139206424,
-0.0455853269,
0.0027723862,
-0.0190551374,
-0.0311741717,
-0.0071738781,
0.0312026851,
-0.0011973626,
0.0330685638,
0.0207651183,
0.0207719393,
0.0039081452,
-0.0102492971,
0.0553267673,
0.0175311398,
-0.0100054359,
0.0171660483,
0.0384590439,
0.0338049978,
0.1025957614,
-0.0536689758,
0.0188197494,
-0.0065359906,
-0.0370384008,
0.0164305754,
0.0138309179,
-0.0154895233,
0.0321809538,
0.0098293796,
0.0196025651,
-0.0100336708,
0.0091375103,
0.0721439272,
-0.1325772405,
-0.0087184459,
0.0386330225,
0.040675845,
-0.0446179323,
-0.0636557639,
0.0640566349,
-0.0301169306,
0.0390943512,
-0.0220344421,
0.0497527421,
-0.0117065972,
0.001155353,
-0.0186646096,
-0.0628123432,
-0.0068054437,
-0.0290357172,
0.0311879255,
-0.0068382197,
0.0682450309,
-0.023528548,
0.0275646225,
-0.073003158,
-0.0216743201,
-0.0194908455,
0.0473531336,
0.0193792954,
0.0058402577,
-0.0087201055,
0.0177662652,
0.0256951787,
0.0102932127,
0.0571233481,
0.0261670947,
0.031226255,
-0.0057463981,
0.0322432108,
0.0410520583,
0.0014865334,
0.0105680982,
-0.0716531277,
0.0321528427,
0.0147410352,
0.0066712969,
0.0140915727,
-0.0287366807,
-0.0036526506,
0.0155162076,
-0.0320512131,
-0.0575243458,
-0.033741422,
-0.0206684116,
0.017484853,
0.0122794118,
-0.0277119093,
0.0157105196,
0.0261306856,
-0.0154456636,
0.0116113881,
0.022580063,
-0.0213623643,
-0.0019512149,
-0.0254988912,
0.0246488899,
-0.0240755808,
-0.0275425185,
-0.0359994248,
0.0284508653,
0.0391988456,
-0.0011226905,
0.0617356449,
0.0004153327,
-0.0526783988,
-0.0013330531,
-0.0691336542,
-0.0000732012,
-0.0502878651,
0.0281447079,
0.0182217825,
0.0132730417,
-0.0159947127,
0.0231323261,
0.0579011664,
0.0068523595,
-0.0210526269,
-0.0150636733,
0.013433544,
0.0226422958,
-0.0290619172,
-0.0020321528,
-0.0105597712,
0.0434412695,
0.0492571257,
-0.0871590152,
-0.0063490458,
-0.0029841166,
2.68e-7,
0.0299750548,
0.0459841192,
0.0432936326,
0.0104609663,
0.0175222829,
0.0245822147,
-0.0150791686,
0.074311465,
0.002579665,
0.0235914011,
0.0389675274,
-0.0240789596,
0.0877246186,
0.012873441,
-0.1484315544,
-0.0187484063,
-0.0637611896,
0.0337898284,
-0.067537576,
0.0234804451,
0.0372608826,
0.0986489207,
0.055950515,
-0.0140430219,
-0.0208199117,
-0.0358792767,
0.0600239895,
0.0114175081,
-0.0524237715,
0.0297416672,
0.0240488388,
0.0249274932,
-0.048738271,
0.0044722166,
-0.0214223955,
0.0530378409,
0.0264600981,
0.0882245675,
-0.0041463119,
0.0050637703,
0.0117826071,
-0.0609136745,
0.003958425,
-0.0328810848,
0.0594299324,
-0.0456337593,
-0.0105137601,
-0.0078577148,
-0.0052675316,
0.0003389724,
0.056277696,
-0.0269697923,
-0.0312850066,
0.018113872,
0.0177779663,
-0.0387554504,
-0.0158742014,
-0.0570362285,
-0.0296528898,
0.0171828736,
0.0085330699,
-0.0152493417,
-0.002606794,
0.0079893721,
0.0315182954,
-0.0603842437,
0.0162643194,
2.477119245e-34,
0.0397638716,
-0.0178435314,
0.0020064607,
-0.0115391864,
0.018063752,
-0.0012981998,
-0.0340896994,
-0.0196188278,
-0.00658298,
-0.0409873575,
-0.0035506829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10195v1 | CoT-MoTE: Exploring ConTextual Masked Auto-Encoder Pre-training with Mixture-of-Textual-Experts for Passage Retrieval | 2023-04-20T10:12:09 | 2023-04-20T10:12:09 | Guangyuan Ma, Xing Wu, Peng Wang, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Passage retrieval aims to retrieve relevant passages from large collections
of the open-domain corpus. Contextual Masked Auto-Encoding has been proven
effective in representation bottleneck pre-training of a monolithic
dual-encoder for passage retrieval. Siamese or fully separated dual-encoders
are often adopted as basic retrieval architecture in the pre-training and
fine-tuning stages for encoding queries and passages into their latent
embedding spaces. However, simply sharing or separating the parameters of the
dual-encoder results in an imbalanced discrimination of the embedding spaces.
In this work, we propose to pre-train Contextual Masked Auto-Encoder with
Mixture-of-Textual-Experts (CoT-MoTE). Specifically, we incorporate
textual-specific experts for individually encoding the distinct properties of
queries and passages. Meanwhile, a shared self-attention layer is still kept
for unified attention modeling. Results on large-scale passage retrieval
benchmarks show steady improvement in retrieval performances. The quantitive
analysis also shows a more balanced discrimination of the latent embedding
spaces. | [
-0.0022941567,
0.0086224237,
-0.0223232228,
0.0487615354,
-0.0021506364,
0.00379938,
0.0507444181,
-0.003010968,
0.0193132516,
-0.0305562355,
-0.0319090523,
-0.0620842427,
-0.0376545377,
0.0352335535,
0.0158932265,
-0.0328266583,
0.024260005,
-0.005780065,
-0.0068139941,
0.0131292176,
0.0050861412,
-0.0118612191,
0.0260112267,
0.0078958813,
0.0348309427,
-0.0084462631,
-0.0102292234,
-0.0069828173,
0.045567181,
-0.0435796678,
0.0484874509,
0.0243270807,
0.0679455772,
0.0063155573,
0.0000020877,
-0.0343731232,
-0.0220913272,
-0.0064721671,
-0.0243648402,
0.0081497021,
0.0083602443,
0.0217449907,
0.0583421923,
-0.0156985931,
0.0234900843,
-0.0160896387,
0.0212537758,
0.0482254215,
0.0586989708,
0.0780970231,
-0.0201924555,
-0.0316022858,
-0.0133130765,
-0.0327906273,
0.0258901753,
-0.033443775,
0.0194837246,
-0.0478592664,
-0.0096679237,
0.0606661625,
-0.0278480351,
0.0604101978,
0.0239845943,
0.031156484,
0.0649929196,
0.0415357724,
-0.0367110409,
0.0196928792,
-0.0033211464,
0.0779745281,
-0.0222045463,
-0.0254607573,
-0.0315134041,
-0.0183681082,
-0.0232391935,
-0.0114101339,
-0.0223544724,
0.0066752187,
-0.0091524366,
0.0056544207,
-0.0273793656,
0.0575770661,
0.0124801863,
-0.0368898623,
-0.0686347112,
-0.0186925419,
0.0059948824,
-0.0403236039,
-0.0040905569,
-0.0030757734,
-0.0445882007,
0.0148203829,
0.0703086555,
-0.001947698,
0.0378879048,
-0.0136548933,
-0.0101464866,
-0.0911644325,
-0.0353671461,
-0.0037682797,
0.0071759252,
0.0565693825,
-0.0594577864,
0.0597601496,
-0.0317380205,
0.060420908,
-0.0111589562,
0.0324393287,
-0.0402344689,
-0.0209038705,
0.0104507664,
-0.0023813886,
-0.0780373514,
0.0315966606,
-0.040334098,
-0.009497676,
0.0344782881,
-0.0074874763,
0.0075376453,
-0.0140686175,
-0.0205934811,
0.0249371603,
-0.0406311303,
-0.0298617762,
0.0121565685,
0.0246817339,
-0.0443055034,
-0.0100628752,
0.0170880482,
-0.0003032562,
-0.0498803332,
0.025970865,
0.0308429338,
-0.0624005832,
0.0002864733,
0.026438674,
-0.038335979,
-0.0607694648,
-0.0323798172,
0.0196773689,
-0.0059531135,
-0.0211541653,
-0.0223571789,
-0.0068006339,
0.0691172928,
-0.0060733519,
0.0054459041,
-0.0205690581,
0.0020301915,
0.0170301758,
0.00379759,
0.0536150746,
0.0487187207,
-0.0505077131,
0.0224181917,
0.0628079399,
-0.000162204,
0.0601279363,
0.0119545059,
0.0329400152,
0.0181035381,
0.0200871658,
-0.0005561602,
0.0000196844,
0.0125838183,
0.0021336691,
0.0257231183,
0.0271024704,
0.0236952044,
0.0214594565,
0.0287106875,
0.029854374,
-0.0475825742,
-0.0738808513,
0.0291862618,
0.0440724082,
0.0588596463,
0.0297472421,
0.0353871211,
0.0289340802,
0.0188349523,
0.0064968974,
0.0067233327,
0.0278140884,
0.0011950296,
-0.0063086362,
0.0658187643,
0.028895488,
-0.0432974473,
-0.0028533619,
0.0315931104,
0.0032648603,
-0.0289561376,
0.0070332531,
0.0406155288,
-0.0290922876,
-0.0616621152,
0.0031616231,
0.0118103903,
-0.0567333996,
0.0401095487,
0.0006812133,
-0.0121548083,
0.0218313895,
0.0394337401,
-0.0986747965,
-0.016224049,
-0.0186375044,
-0.0228677057,
-0.016108267,
-0.0240644291,
0.0239331927,
0.0382335261,
-0.0788054019,
-0.0180727504,
-0.0567571446,
-0.0140938638,
0.0569004714,
-0.0295640081,
0.0457111485,
0.0330556743,
-0.0077432957,
0.0446065664,
0.04911834,
-0.0199064407,
-0.0483809859,
-0.0138322236,
0.0233645681,
0.0136404661,
0.0298067145,
-0.0219213851,
-0.013597657,
0.0335859135,
-0.0666472241,
-0.0136208832,
-0.0254898667,
-0.083901979,
-0.0589758381,
0.0128265871,
-0.0482484177,
0.0027898168,
0.0458781682,
0.0244243704,
-0.0349632278,
-0.0262052808,
0.0052629556,
0.0130749298,
-0.0136761768,
-0.0177110508,
0.0184384733,
0.0249125492,
-0.0544348843,
0.0678947046,
0.0040314733,
0.0260980669,
0.0252160411,
0.0160329584,
0.0338865034,
-0.0308874678,
-0.050833147,
-0.0282779448,
0.0350451805,
0.0120126391,
0.037850637,
-0.0510727987,
-0.016993707,
-0.0188227613,
-0.0578977019,
0.0166921355,
-0.0511967205,
-0.0034889325,
0.0189208314,
0.0350645334,
-0.0250783954,
-0.003479124,
-0.0285523925,
-0.0393958464,
-0.035747759,
-0.0011786328,
0.0123403603,
0.0036612414,
0.0480261371,
-0.0172259603,
-0.0166267212,
-0.0083483662,
0.0596724488,
-0.0111183459,
-0.0411416814,
-0.0243797116,
0.0355575942,
0.0595556498,
0.0201298837,
-0.0425253063,
-0.0169276614,
-0.0298143644,
-0.0378554054,
0.0220864024,
0.0873100236,
0.0039268625,
0.0189455822,
0.0492622368,
-0.0138579877,
-0.0485774353,
0.0651082024,
-0.005532871,
0.0025140224,
-0.0032017427,
0.030124167,
0.021988865,
0.0252424348,
0.0070754993,
-0.037274681,
-0.0419634283,
-0.0363399237,
0.0173296742,
-0.0146641731,
-0.0320556723,
-0.008397257,
-0.0354335904,
0.0424054675,
-0.0273368414,
0.0189227276,
0.0639294907,
-0.0109153464,
-0.0568549931,
-0.057723783,
0.0109142596,
-0.0509196781,
0.0552656427,
0.007761443,
0.0359122567,
-0.0024369976,
-0.0647530034,
-0.0434460193,
0.0320321731,
0.0135947205,
-0.0354238898,
0.0167568009,
0.0533485487,
0.0053385291,
-0.0196166821,
-0.0243039709,
-0.0471979976,
-0.0383875668,
0.0272988044,
-0.0039599952,
0.0487533733,
-0.0025330216,
-0.0456091687,
0.0117151868,
0.0065894416,
0.0621771216,
0.0081440611,
-0.0071275067,
-0.015544204,
0.0624272004,
-0.007095987,
0.0322127268,
-0.0040087579,
-0.0416132808,
0.0197654702,
0.030291101,
0.0144369742,
-0.030131558,
0.0147559009,
0.0259537566,
0.0510440953,
-0.0544121265,
0.02113932,
-0.0374647081,
0.0653861612,
-0.0725275129,
-0.0238042902,
0.0979779065,
0.015692452,
-0.0810679942,
-0.0471805595,
-0.0180583764,
-0.0120307133,
0.0072996202,
0.0248003416,
-0.1011286899,
-0.0114342477,
-0.0097909691,
0.0281376727,
0.0566946454,
-0.0125762438,
-0.0046485853,
-0.0710852295,
0.0067989309,
0.0292457398,
-0.0475668125,
-0.0670835823,
-0.0064644706,
0.0093767596,
-0.0156621896,
0.0104017165,
0.0240642708,
-0.0026701794,
-0.018106129,
-0.0074528167,
0.0237258766,
-0.0207289625,
0.005139783,
-0.0459079444,
-0.0063125039,
-0.0040299501,
0.006118095,
0.0051998715,
-0.0027887397,
-0.0088255499,
-0.1014079526,
-0.0227603968,
0.0141119882,
0.0702947006,
-0.067610234,
0.0009663987,
-0.030109914,
0.0215452835,
0.0064913044,
-0.0327180661,
-0.0174733307,
0.0321025737,
0.0058294721,
-0.0074667619,
-0.0447442941,
0.0100939879,
-0.0054772589,
0.0580269732,
0.0170886926,
-0.0121559231,
-0.0140139302,
-0.0123101594,
0.0310953334,
-0.0433320962,
-0.0483028106,
0.0393440835,
0.0296826046,
-0.0056989272,
-0.0376723744,
-0.0398427546,
-0.0119169904,
0.0417633057,
0.0054509761,
0.0084196031,
-0.0127449315,
-0.0138449874,
-0.0390799083,
0.0459843241,
-0.0387461409,
-0.0275616348,
-0.0371713154,
-0.0034591972,
0.0055681746,
-0.0487265661,
-0.0184302833,
-0.0175676066,
-0.0597285815,
-0.068244271,
0.0137493955,
-0.0034295833,
0.0043545864,
0.0386346579,
-0.0298652779,
-0.0477001294,
0.0985657349,
0.0053713778,
-0.0971910059,
0.014422778,
0.0239685662,
-0.0195176676,
-0.0405117571,
0.0118132653,
-0.0301887393,
0.0333650112,
-0.0154242925,
0.0047917585,
0.0063379817,
-0.0425841026,
0.0128666647,
-0.0083307186,
0.0658475682,
0.0139417127,
0.0599373356,
-0.0776351988,
0.0162502602,
0.0059401128,
-0.0368599482,
-0.0045000217,
0.001295946,
0.0347460546,
-0.0563136078,
-0.0448271148,
0.0685716644,
0.0436474867,
-0.0058168094,
-0.0541185997,
0.0366283208,
0.005290986,
-0.0073663597,
-0.0216229428,
0.0363389105,
-0.0155826453,
-0.0139801204,
0.0097737331,
0.0677505732,
0.0026540419,
0.03517114,
0.0126928892,
-0.0158079155,
-0.0208285935,
0.0185008328,
-0.0957869291,
0.0135503346,
-0.0041216859,
-0.0337952077,
0.0257132798,
-0.065253146,
0.0193546321,
0.0253221449,
-0.0054122177,
-0.0228044,
-0.012915289,
0.0021518243,
0.0366633013,
-0.0231203046,
0.0067912843,
0.0021637271,
0.0409218967,
0.0640027151,
-0.0108387619,
0.0308999494,
0.0280849151,
-0.0278977267,
-0.0316624306,
0.0105915545,
0.0258709192,
0.083052434,
-0.0047195368,
-0.0147652142,
0.000388801,
-0.0089801932,
0.0345957875,
-0.010968674,
-0.0174181815,
0.0121701481,
0.0183754079,
0.0148143545,
0.0042684656,
-0.0271525923,
-0.0190384649,
0.0327655412,
0.0457999483,
0.0046923566,
-0.0159199387,
-6.800032047e-33,
-0.0511390045,
0.0313981138,
-0.0204990339,
-0.0292087682,
-0.070154734,
0.0213372074,
-0.0125128105,
-0.0150659839,
-0.0265374444,
-0.0158706643,
-0.0250042509,
0.0148870163,
0.0031720975,
0.0212216545,
-0.031530384,
-0.0096744401,
0.0548648015,
0.0222282782,
-0.034352798,
0.0320970453,
0.0507265031,
0.0532612987,
0.0209254436,
-0.0573100261,
-0.0028283931,
-0.0458511561,
0.038677346,
-0.0420287699,
0.0344939716,
0.0444575585,
-0.03698631,
0.0319636762,
0.0113380523,
-0.0179988779,
-0.0211345702,
0.0205677766,
-0.0981921181,
-0.062558122,
-0.0360134766,
0.0248767436,
0.0078879595,
-0.0632276833,
0.0517811254,
-0.006708655,
0.0561544895,
-0.0680750981,
0.0530729182,
0.0363357216,
0.0096934289,
-0.0501322523,
-0.0110364705,
0.0258542318,
-0.0445315093,
0.0133252274,
0.0686886013,
0.0591568872,
0.0571609214,
0.0299141817,
-0.0748440772,
-0.0220966395,
-0.0244244784,
0.0518071353,
-0.0197013542,
0.0421452038,
-0.0066097449,
0.0449976549,
0.0042672558,
-0.0071620909,
-0.0470577814,
-0.0123003153,
0.0466741696,
-0.0111579429,
0.0191216171,
0.0136319669,
0.0253375489,
-0.0134081561,
-0.0919080973,
0.0334266163,
-0.0363137126,
0.0142563106,
0.0473838821,
0.062986128,
-0.0382510051,
-0.0040188301,
-0.0290114898,
-0.018639829,
-0.0390598513,
0.0040288814,
0.0337246433,
0.0240400191,
-0.0126196574,
0.0319796056,
0.0714046136,
-0.0272476505,
0.0368053541,
-0.0039457735,
0.0026003611,
0.0250321086,
0.0072733322,
0.0609538257,
-0.0339471214,
-0.0019763731,
0.0495545603,
-0.0163179841,
-0.0072239037,
-0.0151459323,
0.0306481291,
0.0005086575,
-0.0831406564,
-0.0238372684,
-0.0060138321,
-0.0232274737,
-0.0051038563,
0.0434268117,
0.0010309104,
0.0347174965,
0.0118084475,
0.0930219665,
0.0196023285,
0.0120867295,
-0.0516950488,
-0.0077039883,
0.0298090279,
0.0067449245,
0.0003702591,
0.0362153277,
-0.0201964993,
0.0431353524,
0.0413139686,
-0.0437191576,
-0.0009926494,
0.0097112767,
2.739e-7,
0.0512193665,
0.0074967458,
0.0447165892,
-0.0188707523,
-0.0135686006,
0.0269147716,
0.0005427453,
0.0491108969,
0.0107993139,
-0.0288257189,
0.0470885374,
0.0584074967,
0.0016159845,
0.0011538295,
-0.0638565496,
-0.0366181619,
0.0089924447,
-0.0299409088,
-0.0228439253,
-0.0304964539,
0.0829944462,
0.0978421792,
0.0086296769,
0.0543351248,
0.0180519335,
-0.0507104285,
0.0671606734,
-0.0187026858,
0.0059941486,
0.0389168225,
0.0315775909,
0.0509497114,
-0.0226161182,
0.0043308786,
0.0038800673,
0.0768597052,
0.0522187501,
0.0297960173,
-0.0026910338,
-0.0585929863,
0.0246463455,
0.028473774,
-0.0285829436,
-0.0259581972,
0.0751690045,
-0.025373565,
-0.0070552155,
-0.0067213597,
-0.0550383441,
0.0000699093,
0.0233227685,
0.0266961437,
-0.0311411936,
0.0278746411,
0.009707843,
0.0127344094,
0.0020353282,
-0.1415393054,
-0.0141503159,
0.0213060752,
-0.0536221489,
0.0160354618,
-0.0387647562,
-0.0253771897,
0.0233070515,
-0.0671917796,
0.0186672527,
2.423678104e-34,
0.0127832768,
-0.0274748914,
-0.0034073666,
0.0031104917,
0.0222387854,
-0.0544146448,
-0.0151862027,
-0.0285222679,
0.0226803403,
-0.0748761222,
-0.029347863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11073v3 | OLISIA: a Cascade System for Spoken Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-04-20T09:30:50 | 2023-08-31T08:51:33 | Léo Jacqmin, Lucas Druart, Yannick Estève, Benoît Favre, Lina Maria Rojas-Barahona, Valentin Vielzeuf | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Though Dialogue State Tracking (DST) is a core component of spoken dialogue
systems, recent work on this task mostly deals with chat corpora, disregarding
the discrepancies between spoken and written language.In this paper, we propose
OLISIA, a cascade system which integrates an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
model and a DST model. We introduce several adaptations in the ASR and DST
modules to improve integration and robustness to spoken conversations.With
these adaptations, our system ranked first in DSTC11 Track 3, a benchmark to
evaluate spoken DST. We conduct an in-depth analysis of the results and find
that normalizing the ASR outputs and adapting the DST inputs through data
augmentation, along with increasing the pre-trained models size all play an
important role in reducing the performance discrepancy between written and
spoken conversations. | [
-0.0080213137,
0.0637460947,
0.005429341,
0.032029327,
0.0032711674,
0.0005108042,
-0.0154507961,
0.0007392925,
0.0523159057,
-0.0469483435,
-0.0403981954,
-0.0443515293,
0.0196584333,
0.0802150369,
-0.0026448411,
-0.0911894739,
0.0589060709,
-0.055353649,
-0.0636872575,
0.0107637439,
0.0414336696,
-0.0067667305,
-0.0487547368,
0.0219712369,
-0.0045772847,
-0.0015710006,
-0.0402677879,
0.0163132437,
0.0035348404,
0.0175303742,
-0.0083254641,
0.0135638919,
0.0450613499,
0.0489615612,
0.0000016871,
-0.0340018943,
-0.0230230987,
-0.0010281497,
-0.0452534519,
-0.0257537644,
-0.0374442413,
-0.0084573515,
-0.0124005722,
0.072942853,
-0.0089094751,
0.0084200194,
0.019672187,
0.0335611291,
0.0488372147,
0.0613683984,
-0.0088124685,
-0.0295004696,
0.0739511326,
-0.0007741099,
-0.0486408025,
-0.0879409909,
-0.005950429,
0.0083332025,
-0.0027686665,
-0.0181782618,
0.0013966553,
0.0240364671,
-0.0033604822,
-0.0461054146,
-0.0103896977,
-0.0177427083,
-0.0149752293,
-0.0003761736,
-0.0454616509,
0.0734829307,
0.0476790853,
0.0274216905,
0.0256410334,
-0.0153942425,
-0.0294709858,
-0.0745817199,
-0.0408258028,
-0.0489693619,
-0.033546064,
-0.0120924721,
-0.0306821037,
0.0498499088,
-0.0093218647,
0.0016053884,
-0.0069258106,
0.0197927468,
0.0003444907,
-0.0293464512,
-0.0339346826,
-0.0114651918,
0.0646786541,
-0.0628695339,
0.0678175539,
0.016167257,
-0.0434227884,
0.0259969849,
-0.0438817516,
-0.0041711046,
-0.0409405082,
-0.029260125,
-0.0291754398,
0.0558506772,
-0.0463723689,
0.0347852148,
0.0287233442,
0.0966846049,
-0.0211398769,
-0.0299667604,
-0.0180062484,
-0.0072064879,
-0.0606271476,
0.0218073316,
-0.0522168428,
0.0035315058,
-0.0239284374,
-0.0407701284,
-0.0331548788,
0.0124002695,
0.0293404367,
0.0057120477,
0.0302390549,
-0.0074093868,
-0.0156051172,
-0.0273823123,
0.0263817888,
0.0809595957,
0.0033264011,
0.0199564639,
0.0020816603,
-0.0451047719,
-0.0174753312,
0.0147973699,
0.0422803424,
0.023337448,
-0.0405867323,
0.054464478,
-0.0002848302,
-0.0538453087,
-0.0048370226,
0.0374372602,
0.0096161375,
-0.0660725087,
-0.0446592569,
-0.0041103549,
0.04933751,
-0.0143341329,
0.0112317065,
-0.0124141574,
-0.0010646586,
-0.0026923821,
-0.004238042,
0.0413681678,
-0.0509756021,
-0.0044903792,
0.0087938998,
0.0048074061,
0.0198779497,
0.0424677692,
0.0511015393,
0.0073354091,
0.0167148653,
-0.0011957556,
0.0115805231,
0.0387912877,
-0.0013117852,
0.0086891465,
-0.0112729119,
0.0347142592,
-0.0247807913,
0.0017354105,
0.0186732039,
0.0555359907,
-0.0251428746,
0.0183579214,
0.0614661649,
0.0327828079,
0.0255822632,
0.0007642249,
-0.0150292767,
0.0242957454,
0.0222816411,
0.0278513562,
-0.004801481,
-0.0118800793,
0.0046217637,
-0.0114721991,
0.044205673,
0.034141548,
-0.0320158973,
-0.0196566004,
-0.0124352993,
-0.0105629824,
-0.0025134017,
0.0109812627,
0.0477882512,
-0.0202909783,
-0.0549078546,
0.0131434221,
-0.0051326812,
-0.0545489937,
0.0152992029,
-0.0237673912,
-0.0104741799,
0.0946678221,
0.0448017381,
-0.0352900103,
-0.0472648479,
-0.0663093477,
-0.0172045343,
0.0388865434,
0.0022516672,
-0.0152495196,
0.0846584141,
-0.0858168229,
0.0019789583,
0.0669411793,
0.0034032944,
0.0530640408,
-0.0023797387,
0.0102876462,
0.0221011676,
0.0608186871,
0.0630545691,
0.0076669911,
-0.0267641544,
-0.0040835151,
-0.0031025652,
-0.0248959307,
0.0563446023,
0.0408176593,
-0.0219477043,
-0.0402098335,
0.0147734396,
0.0107109509,
0.0000268139,
0.0405044332,
-0.0544089749,
-0.0415326916,
0.0371362455,
0.0625644624,
-0.0025602398,
0.0086440323,
-0.0106218103,
-0.109037526,
0.0158868786,
-0.0539261401,
0.0356297866,
-0.0475996062,
0.0392325521,
0.0512644611,
0.0187652055,
-0.0000528478,
-0.0110357022,
0.0016575771,
-0.0320795625,
0.0168436524,
0.0122895697,
0.0254589077,
-0.0377514213,
0.0148007376,
0.0173692796,
-0.0081058452,
0.0334833898,
-0.0020147399,
-0.0181932878,
-0.0387290381,
0.0079199225,
-0.0614653751,
0.018597858,
-0.0402808562,
0.0065026865,
0.0106149316,
0.0445467904,
-0.0224113967,
-0.0542353354,
-0.04023939,
-0.0078102821,
0.0557920709,
-0.0343392752,
-0.0253912508,
0.0159174595,
-0.0576577112,
-0.0693428442,
0.0539908707,
0.0125398748,
-0.0293549225,
-0.04194507,
-0.0494850501,
-0.0745010674,
0.0080128647,
-0.0151269436,
0.0746803433,
-0.0350078233,
-0.0495863743,
-0.0174603965,
0.0339364819,
0.0132961962,
0.0343729667,
0.0074099647,
0.0178000368,
-0.0221003648,
-0.0696419328,
-0.0279826075,
0.0258456264,
0.0358454175,
0.0254771393,
-0.0209643282,
0.0368144698,
-0.0293926671,
0.0120423073,
0.0193250328,
0.0429586321,
-0.0389036275,
-0.0591152199,
0.0006022917,
-0.0219707489,
-0.0081865098,
-0.0284285918,
-0.07587827,
0.0327721052,
0.0101974467,
-0.0463566333,
0.0115436697,
-0.0802412108,
-0.0485342406,
-0.0485490784,
-0.0302966759,
-0.0332111642,
0.0266584028,
0.0013799426,
-0.0079581728,
0.0078181839,
-0.0576290488,
0.0059237685,
-0.0236693807,
0.0250066724,
-0.0707139373,
0.0326645523,
-0.0208217837,
0.0425026715,
-0.0223027077,
-0.0269342605,
-0.0452198386,
0.0152968056,
-0.0683250204,
0.0194522869,
0.0146153886,
-0.0619759187,
-0.0199523643,
0.0564502217,
0.0318417028,
0.0700421408,
0.0043885317,
0.0442460962,
-0.0196422338,
0.0639117435,
0.0488403179,
-0.0020455783,
-0.0320702009,
-0.0079269391,
0.089304924,
0.014310481,
0.0516002476,
-0.0225491319,
-0.0367458723,
-0.0381770656,
0.0175478123,
-0.0193133615,
-0.0257476401,
-0.0080675324,
0.0507595055,
-0.0380950496,
-0.0035969778,
0.0956096202,
0.0137112839,
-0.0316614658,
-0.0489667766,
-0.00753771,
0.0407522582,
0.0126577634,
0.0183547717,
-0.0646783188,
-0.0276867114,
0.0302990675,
0.0321315788,
-0.0024396719,
-0.0110883666,
-0.0370280519,
-0.0434053913,
0.0120081371,
0.015379943,
-0.0461499915,
-0.0388703309,
-0.0095080016,
0.0234057046,
-0.0152409105,
0.0460446887,
0.005086652,
0.0041212961,
-0.0505247302,
0.0264428835,
-0.0552594177,
-0.003642841,
0.011833434,
-0.0061824494,
0.0815800503,
0.0674234629,
0.0437224433,
0.035183087,
0.0115566924,
0.0503060371,
0.0027614303,
0.0000900472,
0.0078437142,
0.0239403192,
-0.0215595346,
-0.0131784873,
-0.025931824,
0.0138658462,
0.0163956303,
0.0034052797,
0.0172888078,
0.0029231096,
-0.0468875654,
0.0564902499,
0.0044458085,
0.0099839773,
-0.008814089,
0.0251978803,
0.0257513039,
-0.017592065,
-0.0093019959,
0.0065460042,
-0.0011639855,
0.0221328326,
0.0283556748,
-0.0120556252,
-0.0017482615,
-0.0070724222,
-0.0670379922,
-0.0312819257,
0.0176976118,
0.0467526615,
-0.0162585881,
0.0085362894,
0.0037794886,
0.0323005319,
0.0425536409,
-0.0097991712,
-0.020122949,
0.0008018557,
-0.0550830215,
-0.004448201,
0.0467003658,
-0.0147864232,
-0.005043962,
0.0348011702,
-0.0632750764,
-0.0614507496,
0.0091761332,
0.0211580116,
0.0266519301,
0.0621888898,
-0.0479334779,
-0.0259871576,
-0.0292797312,
-0.0230654906,
0.004646596,
-0.0113713676,
0.0425464287,
0.0339418203,
-0.0474798195,
0.0314543173,
-0.0100132544,
0.025246853,
-0.055912938,
0.0054498753,
-0.0734197199,
-0.0803709328,
-0.0257580467,
-0.0097298035,
0.0606092475,
-0.0042890096,
-0.011797362,
0.0034390769,
0.0568874665,
-0.0370645635,
0.0099684671,
-0.0624476932,
0.0008291727,
-0.0140050966,
-0.0013942502,
-0.0329584554,
0.0021787072,
-0.04362249,
-0.0043616286,
-0.0169457365,
0.0079192268,
0.0189758949,
0.0015738813,
0.0000789191,
-0.014695392,
-0.0001510665,
0.0548486114,
0.050465893,
0.0290299263,
-0.0061680665,
0.0919727981,
-0.0251477584,
-0.0288300365,
0.0551081784,
0.0329420827,
-0.0905626416,
-0.008682074,
-0.0382290632,
0.0700250864,
0.0526532494,
0.0101293167,
0.0630001277,
0.0274118446,
0.0366480052,
-0.0276831072,
0.0613942966,
-0.0196577199,
-0.0235564634,
0.0119263176,
0.0082819648,
-0.0135444216,
0.048232615,
0.0470547713,
0.0185676813,
0.0120726489,
0.0066127898,
0.0356862061,
-0.0359440371,
-0.0170687325,
0.0115731889,
0.0418403372,
-0.00986188,
0.0194897298,
-0.0181915406,
-0.0331013948,
0.0199189037,
-0.0146086225,
0.0345727168,
-0.0131591214,
0.0310988054,
-0.0241150912,
-0.028255567,
0.0087806601,
-0.0051492983,
-0.0681353137,
-0.0254148711,
-0.0035589458,
0.0231793709,
-5.539445129e-33,
-0.0611041225,
-0.0069160908,
-0.0070118117,
0.0259318445,
-0.0612687804,
-0.0174196865,
-0.0297351573,
0.0045226086,
-0.0043935073,
-0.0409783721,
-0.0375777744,
0.0449992083,
0.0291947089,
0.0155870272,
-0.0497969054,
-0.0408146493,
0.0634010211,
-0.0022016256,
-0.0170033518,
0.0042310944,
0.0276169349,
0.0460932143,
0.0443416871,
-0.0876953453,
-0.0226417873,
-0.0073934346,
-0.0033285203,
-0.0007798337,
0.0187845659,
0.0075803339,
0.0021966642,
0.0197993536,
-0.0088001974,
-0.0223708134,
-0.0152884023,
0.0370552279,
-0.0214128699,
0.0152834067,
0.0214863177,
0.0683695376,
0.0278774146,
0.0532108881,
-0.0193047505,
-0.0086165238,
0.0296707936,
-0.0080319252,
-0.0101418793,
-0.019331798,
-0.0379776917,
0.0208880343,
-0.0126198959,
0.063802287,
-0.0161650293,
-0.058134675,
0.0082538724,
0.0728386268,
0.0388400517,
-0.0579842292,
-0.0127928667,
0.0063539115,
-0.004954543,
0.0003886652,
0.0433184616,
0.0268210862,
-0.0237128809,
0.0658286884,
0.0612294078,
-0.0156690087,
-0.0313474387,
-0.0710847378,
-0.0073658479,
0.007451369,
0.0521901958,
0.0190330707,
-0.0303998869,
-0.0010053249,
-0.0352951065,
-0.0057462058,
0.0699723586,
0.0219934862,
-0.0395367667,
0.0493556857,
-0.0605969802,
0.006722895,
-0.011617681,
-0.0157244578,
0.0111935847,
-0.0234252699,
0.0528353304,
0.028985586,
0.0095355222,
-0.0159778241,
0.0784943402,
-0.007466787,
0.0248603728,
0.0183694046,
-0.0059002195,
0.0001192481,
-0.0392041728,
0.0587397479,
-0.0485019051,
-0.0432955585,
0.0473398678,
0.0553828292,
-0.0035767294,
-0.0320067592,
-0.0201693065,
0.0148802707,
-0.0532825291,
0.00862813,
-0.0027614136,
0.0616420172,
-0.0536611453,
0.0494461842,
0.0486932658,
-0.0239063688,
-0.0021496743,
0.10410963,
-0.0045011709,
-0.0012528989,
-0.0319570862,
-0.0374124758,
0.0222196877,
0.0169576295,
-0.0198034123,
-0.0043895263,
0.006043999,
-0.0392048433,
-0.0089362739,
-0.0156907644,
0.016083004,
-0.0105906567,
2.485e-7,
-0.0442064591,
0.0366672613,
0.0616604909,
-0.0387026966,
0.021479087,
0.018842632,
-0.0213421527,
0.0223673172,
0.0122133,
-0.0203891229,
0.0090520866,
-0.0187904332,
0.0771980435,
0.0192744918,
-0.0971229002,
-0.0811220184,
-0.0621665455,
-0.01487689,
-0.013940501,
0.0120817656,
0.0227449052,
0.0597011894,
0.0017265385,
0.0118415747,
0.0170490462,
-0.0187249985,
0.0205186363,
0.0204539821,
-0.0030806451,
-0.0211624019,
0.0204141829,
0.020311771,
-0.0337359421,
0.0167616867,
-0.0160929747,
0.0941888839,
0.0029583087,
0.081564948,
-0.0195150618,
-0.0433090851,
-0.0280652102,
0.0333510004,
-0.0056608012,
-0.0231917556,
0.0311577413,
0.0359013155,
0.0137966843,
-0.049595926,
-0.0419519879,
-0.0059441002,
0.0174802653,
0.0421325825,
-0.0036426436,
0.0393719412,
-0.0078767519,
-0.0256267171,
-0.0193799939,
-0.0977634713,
0.0008861523,
-0.032370653,
-0.056093581,
-0.0264054276,
-0.0348502584,
-0.0096687227,
-0.0023865423,
0.0215921607,
-0.0288717393,
1.756976394e-34,
0.042748712,
-0.0430100299,
0.0146109862,
0.0484339111,
0.0109634921,
-0.0202433951,
0.0080628926,
0.017236542,
0.0715498626,
-0.0591227487,
0.0090817232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10164v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10164v2 | Analyzing FOMC Minutes: Accuracy and Constraints of Language Models | 2023-04-20T08:54:00 | 2024-02-19T15:24:39 | Wonseong Kim, Jan Frederic Spörer, Siegfried Handschuh | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research article analyzes the language used in the official statements
released by the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) after its scheduled
meetings to gain insights into the impact of FOMC official statements on
financial markets and economic forecasting. The study reveals that the FOMC is
careful to avoid expressing emotion in their sentences and follows a set of
templates to cover economic situations. The analysis employs advanced language
modeling techniques such as VADER and FinBERT, and a trial test with GPT-4. The
results show that FinBERT outperforms other techniques in predicting negative
sentiment accurately. However, the study also highlights the challenges and
limitations of using current NLP techniques to analyze FOMC texts and suggests
the potential for enhancing language models and exploring alternative
approaches. | [
0.012691482,
0.0602035373,
-0.0357990414,
0.0046174307,
-0.0319998041,
0.0256546456,
-0.034509372,
0.0176419094,
-0.0061015678,
-0.0564862341,
0.0116006443,
-0.0064024716,
0.0043662055,
0.0259702113,
-0.0242565759,
-0.0249435678,
0.0385008752,
0.0434771813,
0.067822881,
0.0001825476,
0.0429708436,
0.0288518183,
0.0131166074,
0.0534933805,
-0.0485793985,
-0.0392091386,
-0.0045324615,
-0.0063951388,
-0.0131752063,
-0.0148347812,
0.0208825842,
0.0125954794,
-0.0255297553,
0.0029413765,
0.0000018233,
-0.0252236146,
-0.03291253,
-0.0091615412,
0.0314772986,
-0.0117327403,
0.087040402,
-0.0860552713,
0.003868727,
0.0104709398,
-0.0603068918,
0.0026168579,
0.0441899449,
0.0439984761,
0.0780501068,
0.0646472946,
-0.0330231823,
-0.0172526669,
-0.0298236478,
0.0011324564,
-0.0399910137,
-0.0132699767,
0.0279026851,
-0.0141770318,
-0.0402047522,
-0.052339185,
0.0316004232,
0.0282846168,
-0.0499556251,
0.0206468105,
-0.0332170203,
-0.0005591564,
-0.0432693921,
-0.0333117843,
-0.0675111562,
0.0000444036,
0.0684567243,
0.0251469295,
0.0196795464,
-0.026802212,
0.0073656691,
0.0866122022,
-0.0469392799,
0.0216787793,
-0.022339901,
0.0162399784,
0.0198617242,
0.03940906,
-0.0147612048,
0.0019196988,
0.0203325395,
0.0920055658,
-0.0087022418,
-0.0650263578,
0.0000689595,
0.0212667026,
-0.0390026383,
-0.0097187851,
0.0160986651,
-0.0066827252,
0.0401338302,
0.0373029262,
-0.0204761717,
-0.0126710925,
-0.0236746073,
-0.1197973564,
-0.007148087,
0.0680306479,
0.0102889016,
0.0092737488,
0.028410092,
0.01092498,
0.0496133752,
-0.0470935032,
-0.0187928881,
0.0147501761,
-0.0704226568,
-0.0190228559,
-0.0351255797,
0.0549655296,
-0.0357830673,
-0.0453914069,
-0.043675188,
-0.0450987555,
-0.0380630307,
-0.010984337,
0.0135359326,
-0.0381012,
-0.0062402296,
0.0151632223,
-0.0670810491,
-0.001315077,
-0.0556538254,
0.0062355502,
-0.0658151209,
0.0057903128,
0.0382638946,
0.013730539,
-0.0181888584,
0.0226454735,
-0.009974842,
0.0619084872,
0.0629859716,
0.0089759864,
0.0312128253,
-0.0553821325,
-0.0169797782,
-0.0292797964,
-0.0415108502,
0.0122123109,
0.0173683818,
-0.007840584,
0.0234524515,
0.0134204729,
-0.0119868582,
-0.0184824429,
-0.0369713679,
0.0566599257,
-0.0356759541,
-0.0052657635,
-0.0198568776,
-0.0419982783,
0.0592212416,
0.0166159775,
-0.0325516388,
-0.0064679529,
0.0438010432,
-0.0039733229,
0.0123436591,
0.0402801,
-0.0408129133,
-0.039312914,
-0.0031201539,
0.0219623465,
-0.0301632453,
-0.0092398552,
0.0274324194,
0.0264516976,
0.0096301585,
-0.0051896842,
0.019387899,
0.0801147595,
-0.0215083268,
0.0074860207,
-0.0091298688,
0.0562061928,
0.0421754196,
0.0182761047,
0.0238655768,
-0.025193274,
-0.0628227293,
0.0057927342,
0.012719769,
-0.0281467009,
-0.007473174,
-0.059351597,
-0.0468730144,
-0.0480765924,
0.0248610023,
0.0014750573,
0.0232611261,
-0.0391720831,
-0.0385602936,
0.063722156,
0.0802154616,
-0.0176008828,
-0.0361935683,
-0.0040993714,
0.0321708694,
0.0818178207,
0.0216495376,
-0.0045212894,
0.0306263957,
-0.0309472512,
0.0159213785,
0.0828734487,
0.0630869642,
0.014483084,
-0.0469086133,
-0.0217405055,
0.0265920479,
0.0480027199,
0.0696057677,
0.0390644595,
-0.0251084063,
0.0179519467,
-0.0214586351,
0.0488024577,
-0.0071073691,
0.0176198594,
0.0493305847,
-0.0276293419,
0.0094503593,
-0.0289221313,
0.0056275623,
0.0261084773,
0.0152190933,
0.0157354195,
-0.0064419149,
0.0182429645,
-0.0073075914,
0.0151882432,
-0.0545008145,
0.0156398192,
0.0220637769,
-0.002123531,
0.0032000879,
-0.0123768123,
-0.0137823783,
-0.0046506813,
0.0614948831,
0.0064624422,
0.0175955519,
-0.0336252376,
0.0185576174,
-0.0268209223,
-0.0032275396,
0.0218919665,
0.0291431155,
0.0019216868,
0.0235379394,
-0.0248405188,
-0.0084098829,
0.0334630162,
-0.029792577,
-0.0051180851,
0.0048488253,
0.0162518583,
0.0235386081,
0.0372861214,
-0.0110979713,
0.0070338212,
-0.0089236451,
-0.058667399,
-0.024130391,
0.0326066054,
0.0388556793,
0.0281473212,
-0.0263878163,
-0.0146626765,
0.0451216437,
0.0109662665,
-0.0455393903,
-0.0211936478,
-0.0244231746,
0.0355810374,
0.0153187504,
-0.0006522316,
-0.0490937121,
0.0008772303,
-0.0499373451,
0.0026174253,
0.0415140577,
-0.0382765345,
-0.0058335313,
-0.0232597031,
-0.0171683934,
0.001408129,
-0.0011248366,
-0.0362400785,
0.0171016622,
0.0036906728,
-0.004404013,
0.0111683644,
-0.0050827283,
0.1125371754,
-0.0397940837,
0.0042731678,
-0.0119599784,
0.0076789274,
-0.0315982997,
0.0323192813,
-0.0462267958,
-0.0011063053,
0.0500803366,
0.0727947354,
0.0358393937,
0.0267862473,
-0.0830559134,
0.0836054757,
-0.0406470336,
0.0109568024,
-0.0283911005,
-0.0364972316,
-0.0222400688,
0.0443165787,
0.0551552363,
-0.0242442098,
0.015411797,
0.0082734199,
0.0070470227,
-0.0523224436,
-0.0272773355,
-0.0473261178,
0.0243552271,
-0.0756842792,
-0.0070640915,
0.0327641591,
-0.0145722572,
0.0124099124,
-0.0968583226,
0.0004081974,
-0.0395094417,
0.0309698507,
-0.0552904755,
0.0060116732,
0.0365236364,
-0.0367376991,
0.0245548747,
-0.0575407483,
-0.0580487959,
0.020555824,
0.0797302723,
-0.028577093,
-0.0288369935,
0.0623020977,
-0.0474050082,
-0.0654566363,
-0.0135491816,
-0.0052172616,
0.0392414406,
-0.0026049849,
0.0528321378,
-0.014837129,
-0.004732836,
-0.0257628001,
0.0252695847,
-0.0085776085,
0.0028721716,
0.0641462505,
-0.0112735499,
-0.0091466727,
-0.0149549954,
-0.0119626513,
-0.058640115,
0.0113293128,
-0.0277791079,
-0.0348691754,
0.0051653525,
0.1100467816,
0.0381150395,
0.0121946065,
-0.0017574392,
-0.0259306524,
-0.0085824318,
-0.0196566097,
0.0239792932,
-0.0329308584,
-0.0225090887,
0.0068928604,
0.0184959527,
-0.042913653,
-0.0270857308,
-0.0321335904,
-0.1012201533,
0.0355708525,
-0.0131810987,
0.0049224151,
-0.0186668001,
-0.0261820853,
-0.0250507537,
-0.0176203102,
-0.0064853583,
-0.0015358562,
-0.005312494,
0.0389879644,
0.0301458389,
-0.1315044016,
-0.0365758687,
0.0181275196,
0.0266545732,
-0.0028374421,
0.0082776491,
0.0807737708,
-0.0022339902,
-0.0023315346,
-0.0046498976,
-0.0383713171,
-0.0052936282,
-0.0358228087,
0.0017933743,
-0.030695254,
-0.0279194787,
-0.0168397762,
0.0129364254,
-0.0124549251,
0.0557608493,
0.0087250266,
-0.0030818596,
-0.0542715639,
-0.0195731875,
-0.0274246652,
0.0764345899,
0.0259859487,
0.0784030035,
-0.0074893134,
-0.0162127241,
-0.0231379755,
-0.0164666027,
0.0414626673,
-0.0398427472,
-0.0426173732,
-0.0258288495,
0.0458296165,
0.0127126556,
-0.0573082455,
-0.0850384384,
0.0124796601,
0.0323027782,
0.0263706874,
0.0369340852,
0.0773205906,
0.0084595932,
0.0106447339,
0.0275649372,
-0.0135142608,
0.0163159631,
-0.0012896629,
-0.008717644,
0.0038350448,
0.0676668063,
-0.0394355357,
0.0454786979,
-0.0154724028,
-0.0366419889,
0.027521776,
0.0191990528,
0.0304210335,
-0.0494372696,
0.0045795231,
0.0471550375,
-0.0207648091,
0.0646529496,
-0.0627293363,
-0.0122418143,
0.0525198542,
0.0338019952,
-0.0212493669,
0.0208208654,
0.0383058079,
0.0279003568,
-0.0323203877,
0.0183310341,
-0.0263258591,
-0.0315432586,
0.017331535,
0.0307506919,
0.024912728,
0.0192050356,
-0.0762819871,
0.0009202557,
-0.0451986343,
-0.0298951995,
-0.0077933832,
-0.021995537,
-0.0319476351,
-0.0225586332,
0.0004536266,
-0.0540374145,
-0.0294952448,
-0.0670308247,
0.0060161445,
0.0526837446,
0.0831665769,
-0.0053612343,
0.0195744671,
0.01574363,
-0.0412968323,
-0.0052667879,
0.0224323068,
0.0014880699,
-0.0072761979,
-0.0064412295,
0.0199465975,
0.0053824447,
0.0143914083,
0.0062158899,
-0.0058220546,
-0.0317382552,
0.001495244,
-0.0255214944,
0.0265560877,
-0.0242283083,
-0.0490495116,
0.0288356841,
-0.0703777,
0.00751204,
-0.0096525699,
0.0342617147,
0.0021819291,
-0.0025237619,
0.056333065,
-0.0127810594,
-0.083510071,
-0.0670130253,
0.0236973632,
-0.0086805131,
0.0290694125,
0.009692017,
-0.0347992405,
-0.0405869409,
-0.02307849,
0.0867581517,
-0.0281886533,
-0.0045856591,
0.0056805448,
-0.1037113592,
0.0176427085,
0.0397266261,
-0.017972352,
0.0339052826,
-0.0129068978,
0.0273911115,
0.0319081768,
-0.0180367772,
0.0518908538,
-0.0241055563,
-0.0020866834,
-0.0785759836,
-0.0023218303,
-0.0694265738,
-5.914911617e-33,
-0.0422972552,
-0.0144338626,
0.0103238793,
0.0204825513,
0.0262220781,
0.0339986868,
-0.0118179321,
0.0285636224,
0.0137905609,
0.0150620416,
0.0001772842,
0.018098671,
0.0275643654,
0.0071772616,
0.0237490609,
0.0049206801,
0.0483895876,
-0.0376083329,
0.0232101995,
-0.0575894378,
0.0035707187,
0.0342513919,
0.062634781,
-0.0706116185,
0.0640330613,
-0.0028091972,
-0.0592816174,
-0.0494972318,
0.0798929036,
0.0295310374,
-0.0208780691,
0.0188450702,
0.0014793051,
-0.0431095734,
-0.0166618209,
0.0143731181,
-0.0052724457,
-0.0396688394,
0.0236976258,
0.0177344419,
0.050896313,
0.005641717,
0.0000648493,
0.0390865691,
-0.0575119667,
0.0309825242,
0.0130184274,
-0.0157806687,
-0.0272479672,
-0.0258173216,
-0.050438296,
0.056526389,
0.0079999985,
0.0476897322,
0.033938963,
0.071472168,
-0.030204311,
-0.0101125995,
-0.021181168,
0.0067681,
0.0148593197,
0.0104209539,
-0.0123182517,
-0.0364602692,
0.0241997205,
0.059757147,
0.0112660667,
-0.0039819246,
-0.0018856117,
0.0499203317,
0.033233963,
0.0064453441,
0.0218462944,
0.0608663596,
0.0574751459,
-0.0823568031,
0.0095825102,
0.0154784638,
-0.0037382336,
0.0442558601,
0.0543267988,
-0.0105960527,
-0.0296840854,
-0.0465591773,
-0.0202623717,
-0.006470751,
0.0146914246,
-0.0352847353,
0.0198033154,
-0.0480984896,
0.0102173304,
0.0179994088,
-0.0147125199,
-0.026109295,
-0.0332548171,
-0.0168782193,
-0.0275909733,
0.0132991476,
-0.0224347655,
0.0046503413,
-0.0330646858,
-0.0477694832,
-0.0228391252,
0.0377653055,
0.0330737792,
-0.0096454984,
-0.0359403417,
0.0005364367,
-0.0519426242,
-0.0096741868,
0.0279458128,
0.0236394666,
0.008329263,
0.0392655134,
-0.0103522427,
0.0046474594,
0.0237668995,
-0.0093622115,
-0.0207557771,
0.0199493691,
0.0136491535,
-0.0463294089,
0.0110216532,
0.0504343659,
-0.0285996255,
-0.0150320176,
0.005715698,
0.0164735336,
0.0179042276,
-0.0043784999,
-0.0031247719,
0.006334425,
2.566e-7,
0.0587145612,
0.1035949588,
-0.0391493365,
0.0196667407,
-0.0007742259,
0.0358754508,
-0.0436081439,
0.0105649279,
0.0080556367,
0.0024189537,
0.0411941111,
-0.0426201113,
0.0530330166,
0.0137495501,
-0.0764270574,
-0.0141042825,
-0.0706598386,
0.0205330513,
-0.0530118048,
0.0765809938,
0.0469744839,
0.068940796,
0.0319229141,
-0.0241869651,
-0.0573035106,
-0.0185560323,
0.0185776427,
-0.0568436235,
-0.0423707478,
0.0071711135,
0.0027468326,
0.0013049889,
-0.0017360938,
0.0190216731,
-0.0085827541,
-0.0232060701,
0.0143260462,
0.0463755503,
0.0238654409,
0.0080782585,
0.0287901703,
-0.0039176159,
-0.0509836227,
0.0013280973,
0.016229026,
-0.0938876569,
-0.0428393967,
-0.0688534081,
-0.0300074406,
0.0309700407,
0.0207743812,
0.0176280309,
-0.0360050388,
0.0270517059,
0.0026907581,
-0.0273004752,
-0.0103077656,
0.0005538578,
-0.0021582842,
0.0127876708,
-0.0221511032,
-0.0016927838,
-0.0122807166,
0.0366557129,
0.0222569592,
-0.0264683794,
0.0125415437,
2.022086989e-34,
0.0761830285,
-0.0052102697,
-0.0242316481,
0.0571656004,
0.0565786511,
0.0255708992,
0.0076381774,
0.0268600658,
0.0027570003,
-0.0654527172,
0.0275087357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10158v1 | Does Manipulating Tokenization Aid Cross-Lingual Transfer? A Study on POS Tagging for Non-Standardized Languages | 2023-04-20T08:32:34 | 2023-04-20T08:32:34 | Verena Blaschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the challenges with finetuning pretrained language models (PLMs) is
that their tokenizer is optimized for the language(s) it was pretrained on, but
brittle when it comes to previously unseen variations in the data. This can for
instance be observed when finetuning PLMs on one language and evaluating them
on data in a closely related language variety with no standardized orthography.
Despite the high linguistic similarity, tokenization no longer corresponds to
meaningful representations of the target data, leading to low performance in,
e.g., part-of-speech tagging.
In this work, we finetune PLMs on seven languages from three different
families and analyze their zero-shot performance on closely related,
non-standardized varieties. We consider different measures for the divergence
in the tokenization of the source and target data, and the way they can be
adjusted by manipulating the tokenization during the finetuning step. Overall,
we find that the similarity between the percentage of words that get split into
subwords in the source and target data (the split word ratio difference) is the
strongest predictor for model performance on target data. | [
-0.0075625684,
0.01913522,
-0.0115661379,
0.0232475437,
-0.0485518202,
0.0322750844,
0.0348121449,
0.0267093368,
-0.0793251917,
-0.04966297,
-0.0536997989,
-0.0097086029,
0.0045630378,
0.0217114259,
0.0320109278,
-0.0596092939,
0.088953726,
-0.0259022973,
0.0006391386,
0.0161312427,
0.0293223765,
-0.0234549586,
0.012502701,
0.0145801026,
-0.0231587738,
0.0175737571,
0.0366269946,
-0.0140259275,
-0.0099978354,
0.00473685,
-0.0245862752,
0.0286182985,
-0.0227624867,
0.0304809418,
0.0000014999,
-0.0662782714,
-0.0498040691,
0.0082762325,
0.0288751498,
0.0175426863,
0.0657351017,
-0.0611786805,
-0.0124381427,
0.0155290794,
-0.0207218397,
-0.0454227217,
0.0449233316,
0.0280654579,
0.0007047954,
0.0692894384,
-0.0198708102,
-0.0066767847,
0.0106637161,
-0.0050557069,
-0.0238000732,
-0.0281531755,
0.0159033444,
-0.0160139184,
-0.0079669748,
-0.0182811636,
-0.0397179872,
0.0246581417,
-0.0601307228,
0.0206932668,
-0.0031439201,
0.0092122927,
-0.0611764975,
-0.01055618,
0.012005358,
0.0291121174,
-0.0423253477,
-0.0429519936,
0.0056752707,
-0.0068265293,
-0.0045333719,
-0.0211240761,
-0.0466909297,
-0.0050129495,
0.0163796805,
0.0598544441,
0.0573005825,
0.0001370184,
0.0107296966,
0.0014322536,
-0.0724450424,
0.0702580735,
0.0462636165,
-0.0208381675,
-0.0109877232,
0.0104512265,
-0.0211413857,
-0.0400919504,
0.0286635738,
-0.0194981154,
-0.0050793528,
-0.0002989559,
-0.064410165,
-0.0550205894,
-0.0080172699,
0.0110557079,
0.0309426337,
0.0276850555,
-0.0369734168,
0.0183293056,
-0.0437583029,
0.000855547,
0.0278419945,
0.0714723617,
-0.0539841466,
-0.0484625213,
-0.0788106918,
0.0066929399,
-0.053795591,
0.0478180014,
-0.0086398479,
0.0113302674,
-0.0376377553,
-0.0270287655,
0.0014126429,
-0.0404626988,
-0.0242072251,
-0.0449572764,
-0.0295869969,
-0.0170479193,
-0.0069691874,
0.0868205428,
-0.0570991002,
0.0203923266,
0.0064495495,
-0.0676095933,
-0.004555434,
0.0298786778,
0.0068465276,
-0.0377257504,
0.0160717499,
0.0346164778,
-0.0185880139,
-0.0400653481,
-0.0325256214,
0.0044743135,
-0.0245366711,
-0.0503770933,
-0.0008317715,
-0.0557384975,
0.0164026693,
0.0287535228,
0.0085949693,
-0.0448788106,
-0.0391084068,
-0.0176379178,
-0.0661560297,
0.0992479771,
-0.0224062614,
0.0199805833,
-0.0281209238,
-0.0346034989,
-0.0258056615,
0.0692943931,
0.0300856475,
0.0057446491,
0.1022286415,
-0.023807941,
-0.0035488175,
0.0553186387,
0.0102559878,
0.0042773532,
-0.025563309,
-0.0402461328,
0.087522611,
-0.0273956861,
0.0824432671,
0.0610634312,
-0.0111875292,
0.026251385,
0.0159241762,
0.0684813038,
0.026900772,
0.01543325,
0.0461054072,
-0.0217857547,
-0.0193211213,
0.0466000177,
0.0021744557,
-0.0549006537,
0.0079735797,
0.0103842774,
0.0223804545,
0.0336825289,
-0.0375840068,
0.0147718871,
-0.0232843962,
-0.0288330987,
0.0150915226,
-0.0506665483,
0.0875285119,
0.038441807,
-0.0187295042,
0.0793010071,
0.045129925,
-0.0433451645,
0.0530203767,
-0.0310665946,
-0.0154410629,
0.0330390371,
-0.0020511008,
-0.0313503481,
0.0231071804,
0.0078160111,
0.0393485576,
-0.0107780751,
0.0620946921,
0.0014541178,
0.0282294303,
-0.0391734429,
0.0225823745,
0.0101575889,
0.0117483297,
0.0361726731,
-0.0103474827,
0.0336965509,
0.0078277104,
-0.0737384483,
0.0229698792,
0.0494497307,
-0.0290019549,
0.0037741868,
0.0094209109,
-0.0180699434,
0.014014747,
0.0306110643,
-0.0131057482,
0.0279225148,
0.0069788396,
-0.0401976518,
0.0515595227,
0.0198296085,
-0.0169597175,
0.0097155776,
0.0500438251,
-0.0175574236,
0.0070238444,
-0.0085491603,
-0.0217546895,
-0.0307109877,
0.043925643,
0.0391135365,
0.0543250702,
-0.0624676943,
0.0446893498,
-0.0105901053,
0.0218903031,
-0.0384251699,
-0.0202631261,
0.0538714752,
0.0471533537,
-0.0072155553,
-0.0319173001,
0.0401654541,
-0.0001919164,
-0.033418607,
0.0469631813,
-0.0346294791,
-0.0408263095,
-0.0043154834,
-0.0207072161,
-0.0472273827,
-0.0047385157,
-0.1167914942,
0.0024268616,
-0.0251239929,
0.0630829111,
0.0145793371,
0.0393894203,
-0.025133539,
0.0046281135,
0.0008230584,
0.0013173177,
0.0220528096,
0.0494437143,
0.0340558328,
0.0094547765,
0.0091459937,
-0.0270618461,
-0.0093758116,
0.0116954371,
0.052390188,
-0.0368356407,
-0.0397762768,
-0.0586511828,
-0.0047102757,
-0.0507944375,
0.0187965613,
0.021119006,
-0.0425631106,
0.0024429804,
-0.0044098976,
0.046305012,
0.001093392,
-0.0163780656,
-0.0150963264,
0.0109301768,
-0.0454556979,
-0.0373476557,
-0.0366326608,
-0.000246633,
-0.0120751718,
-0.0387660153,
-0.0155920247,
0.020292975,
0.0465282127,
-0.0306052621,
-0.0302630682,
-0.0432400443,
-0.0247452464,
-0.0586922802,
-0.014033014,
0.0198699031,
0.0107315388,
-0.0193590019,
0.0171823464,
-0.004566412,
-0.0382406004,
0.0274353847,
-0.0576024987,
0.000632472,
-0.0460138172,
-0.0090852603,
-0.0366999805,
0.0459195003,
0.0081200404,
-0.0045367139,
0.0064545292,
-0.0406250991,
-0.0267111398,
-0.0030232568,
0.0106856152,
-0.0059836479,
0.0184131116,
-0.0416421182,
0.0139568895,
0.0004858061,
0.0004185554,
0.0061850552,
-0.0324015431,
-0.0306160226,
0.0620944239,
0.0247339644,
0.0239594243,
0.0143258488,
0.0414096937,
-0.0028311617,
0.0384428352,
-0.0136661474,
0.0342022367,
-0.0013935933,
0.0260140654,
0.0031528429,
-0.0286744218,
-0.0200739391,
-0.0190230682,
0.0089225648,
-0.0066599515,
0.0454271995,
-0.0430384576,
-0.0206349175,
0.0101472782,
0.0241777003,
-0.0529001467,
-0.0458839498,
-0.0264824815,
0.057082098,
-0.0095196366,
-0.0283395927,
0.0948487893,
0.0290663652,
-0.0144379223,
-0.0096049607,
-0.0224005803,
0.0503404513,
-0.0020123762,
0.0132310549,
-0.0557837635,
-0.0248716492,
0.032358285,
0.0230676718,
0.0263457596,
-0.0356149636,
0.0059226705,
-0.1386411339,
-0.0059296605,
0.0014757401,
-0.0808937997,
-0.0195013341,
-0.0353611559,
-0.0065590651,
-0.0023192945,
0.0324585214,
-0.0170100238,
-0.0440386534,
0.0252173897,
0.0501161776,
-0.0347688384,
-0.0280057341,
-0.0281837452,
-0.0797053501,
0.0667737052,
0.0552441739,
-0.0022729479,
-0.0333026424,
-0.0197397117,
0.0855810717,
0.0035123571,
-0.0200335532,
-0.0280170236,
0.015478204,
-0.0186474212,
-0.0073964968,
0.0784744918,
-0.0281968527,
0.0140366266,
-0.0330119021,
-0.0123457992,
0.0476841368,
0.028711712,
-0.0136575988,
0.0175313056,
0.0037105086,
-0.0064563015,
0.0676024109,
0.0411225744,
-0.0170739405,
-0.028111428,
0.0083292797,
0.011243239,
-0.035597641,
0.0520316884,
0.0040783482,
-0.0850310177,
-0.0590295829,
-0.0831309631,
-0.0293625481,
0.058989428,
0.0706882477,
0.0072141737,
0.0421812087,
-0.0396922268,
0.0018192858,
-0.016404856,
0.02416097,
-0.0308660399,
0.0070402147,
-0.0753368288,
-0.0137823131,
0.0404445007,
0.0076760906,
-0.0080635929,
-0.0546856709,
-0.0427280404,
-0.064972885,
0.0419991575,
0.0283795614,
0.0213291459,
0.0365700051,
0.0128737884,
-0.0607929416,
-0.0010775478,
0.0324222744,
-0.0355698802,
0.0246220864,
0.0486444943,
-0.0116758719,
-0.002281202,
0.0171089377,
-0.0007157355,
0.0135379024,
0.0311358366,
0.045148395,
0.0306882691,
0.0020367636,
-0.0274036434,
0.0324366167,
0.0986321643,
-0.0380244106,
-0.050823383,
-0.0264731627,
0.0031519143,
-0.0372316502,
0.0228196289,
-0.038496837,
-0.0392256826,
0.020826688,
0.0149139101,
-0.0178349279,
0.0113135315,
-0.0668443814,
0.0574184358,
0.0093566841,
0.0211030561,
-0.0194664858,
0.042780865,
-0.0108450148,
0.0163989607,
0.0140275899,
-0.0055690408,
0.0149059175,
0.0245083254,
-0.0830168799,
-0.0053854175,
0.0134565504,
0.0550070964,
-0.0188820772,
0.0352842957,
-0.0156624559,
0.0034859688,
-0.0065681101,
0.0202384945,
0.0044955313,
-0.0368028656,
0.052447211,
0.0105091045,
-0.0254127663,
-0.012910977,
0.0310539939,
-0.0349747501,
0.0078543602,
0.0152887879,
-0.0219114143,
-0.0410780795,
0.0109349852,
0.0643860698,
0.0044368906,
0.0017346105,
-0.0066713006,
-0.0247906502,
0.0054013757,
0.0260603949,
0.0192998871,
0.0134457164,
-0.0143251559,
-0.0214670673,
-0.0429263264,
-0.0570220612,
0.0066923872,
-0.0125184041,
-0.0206344295,
0.0335780457,
0.0181696843,
0.0589836165,
-0.0154838311,
0.022184955,
-0.0365463421,
0.004560262,
0.0752534419,
-0.0357413478,
0.0230596922,
-5.610911145e-33,
-0.0280992445,
0.0105381543,
-0.0159718078,
-0.0037903376,
-0.0340599231,
-0.012799372,
-0.0070912521,
0.0170040652,
0.0006498256,
-0.0054996293,
-0.0412756167,
-0.0233559608,
0.0517537594,
0.0269405413,
0.0191728305,
-0.0205672029,
0.0523716062,
-0.0036827172,
-0.0260919183,
-0.0229243245,
0.0409390777,
0.0521211959,
0.0728327557,
0.027574081,
0.0382712893,
0.0061876117,
-0.0076415059,
-0.0052502779,
0.0755713657,
0.0375786237,
0.0026340159,
0.0072531495,
0.0283144936,
-0.0037855168,
-0.039234601,
0.0437489599,
-0.1038595885,
-0.0413220041,
0.0774173886,
0.0204228926,
0.0361935534,
-0.0194368027,
0.0137456432,
-0.0110745681,
-0.0034651293,
0.0122645767,
-0.0012927529,
-0.0252161827,
-0.011029169,
0.0099603366,
-0.0963338464,
0.0317480303,
0.0293879937,
0.0440808386,
0.1000765115,
0.007088487,
-0.0017366675,
0.0066287555,
-0.0297442172,
0.0278715882,
0.0185617097,
0.060678184,
0.0644696131,
0.0183144547,
-0.0225647353,
0.0424505845,
0.0566466935,
-0.0266559068,
0.0351339877,
0.0165773667,
0.078971602,
0.0036976777,
0.038727276,
0.018674884,
0.0345352218,
-0.0193544906,
-0.0428863615,
0.0123617491,
-0.0196987912,
-0.0156342741,
-0.0220898911,
0.0427320935,
-0.0171552226,
-0.0362937786,
-0.0217983481,
-0.0281072687,
-0.0264115501,
-0.0606859252,
0.0344009586,
-0.0168511979,
-0.0298137143,
0.021601215,
0.0699711367,
-0.0312844031,
-0.0508831888,
-0.0382969715,
-0.0030329856,
0.0342506468,
-0.0355487801,
0.0068815183,
-0.0801285058,
-0.0884962082,
0.0248960461,
0.0058629951,
0.0201847982,
-0.0210794806,
0.0683523417,
-0.0175418817,
-0.077764675,
0.0084590297,
-0.0008398153,
0.0149881197,
-0.0193819795,
0.0371773057,
0.0267318804,
0.0371591486,
0.0130157117,
0.0032448976,
0.0555495806,
-0.0385985412,
-0.0236522052,
0.0069867806,
-0.003427004,
0.0215092879,
-0.031515941,
0.0178556703,
-0.0054455856,
0.0296909865,
0.0231827144,
0.0026708345,
-0.0286842231,
0.0276817679,
2.409e-7,
0.0714892745,
0.0458568856,
0.0209700465,
-0.0542361811,
-0.0300996751,
0.0073294491,
-0.0411868878,
0.0389366597,
0.0337124057,
0.0014041089,
-0.0040736343,
-0.0050041922,
0.0357278474,
0.0483159013,
-0.0684365109,
0.0105349943,
0.0222773664,
0.0173861422,
-0.0465816185,
-0.0053773597,
0.0243403576,
0.0699846521,
0.0034443336,
-0.004939524,
-0.0251708422,
-0.0314408466,
0.03225426,
-0.0518247038,
-0.0313165933,
0.0167197324,
0.0216228589,
0.0073890742,
0.0010147784,
0.0421956591,
-0.048075065,
0.0061752382,
0.0460191481,
-0.0059412457,
-0.025984861,
-0.0024351832,
-0.034126889,
-0.0240881182,
-0.0148586547,
-0.0694795474,
0.0752929524,
-0.0209065247,
-0.0046452875,
-0.0336588956,
-0.0100215496,
0.0278995968,
0.0097102812,
-0.0127898883,
-0.049477715,
0.0656916276,
0.0722555667,
0.0409822948,
-0.0918986276,
-0.0312209111,
-0.002656769,
0.0014630707,
-0.0133606363,
-0.0588370077,
0.0013683856,
0.0144311702,
0.0194197949,
-0.0340245217,
0.0097133899,
2.073417292e-34,
0.0321410932,
-0.0111090494,
0.0002229927,
0.0077435067,
0.0292801838,
-0.0360131748,
0.0045441077,
0.0557587743,
-0.0393663719,
-0.043228969,
0.0132489987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10153v1 | On the Independence of Association Bias and Empirical Fairness in Language Models | 2023-04-20T08:27:21 | 2023-04-20T08:27:21 | Laura Cabello, Anna Katrine Jørgensen, Anders Søgaard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | The societal impact of pre-trained language models has prompted researchers
to probe them for strong associations between protected attributes and
value-loaded terms, from slur to prestigious job titles. Such work is said to
probe models for bias or fairness-or such probes 'into representational biases'
are said to be 'motivated by fairness'-suggesting an intimate connection
between bias and fairness. We provide conceptual clarity by distinguishing
between association biases (Caliskan et al., 2022) and empirical fairness (Shen
et al., 2022) and show the two can be independent. Our main contribution,
however, is showing why this should not come as a surprise. To this end, we
first provide a thought experiment, showing how association bias and empirical
fairness can be completely orthogonal. Next, we provide empirical evidence that
there is no correlation between bias metrics and fairness metrics across the
most widely used language models. Finally, we survey the sociological and
psychological literature and show how this literature provides ample support
for expecting these metrics to be uncorrelated. | [
0.0364497527,
0.0874785036,
-0.0417982414,
0.0379700065,
-0.0097023761,
0.0211612526,
0.0518970229,
-0.0327540413,
-0.0175264291,
-0.0800209418,
-0.0247329678,
0.0117867803,
0.0248610508,
-0.0297508426,
0.0188664496,
-0.045049198,
0.0341880508,
0.0565214604,
0.0849103034,
-0.0596514717,
0.0291235875,
0.0190401208,
0.0188276358,
0.0638641044,
-0.0137642659,
0.0303204656,
0.1151716486,
-0.03580001,
-0.0010737799,
0.0110708009,
0.0291961525,
0.1008788645,
-0.0051514027,
0.0133610284,
0.0000019389,
-0.0894797519,
0.0322281271,
0.0136023387,
-0.0103183649,
0.0283168685,
0.0396675877,
-0.0120565379,
0.0041952687,
0.0192601848,
-0.030985957,
-0.0062782182,
0.0273105502,
-0.0134772724,
-0.0091843838,
-0.0127831716,
0.0008557481,
-0.0551895723,
-0.0219752956,
-0.0272463467,
-0.0105783809,
-0.0208792146,
0.0378747471,
-0.0375800468,
-0.089445062,
-0.0124508319,
-0.0341549143,
-0.0083790142,
0.0202256981,
0.0242743194,
0.0347614735,
0.009548258,
-0.0406656712,
-0.0164305456,
0.0168014579,
0.0197089482,
0.007967623,
-0.0187495444,
-0.0242560077,
-0.0116334865,
0.0465322211,
0.0180896353,
-0.013717874,
0.0690224394,
0.010280082,
-0.0144232223,
0.032407105,
0.0324031115,
-0.0146780107,
0.0498742871,
-0.0051311022,
0.0611638203,
0.018495081,
-0.042886693,
-0.006195961,
0.0379555225,
-0.0077086347,
-0.0376958102,
-0.0125425206,
-0.0304527096,
0.027418483,
0.0130129568,
0.0006684529,
-0.0191296693,
0.0542689227,
-0.0194013007,
0.0028582665,
0.0247840472,
-0.0195863321,
0.0017074449,
-0.0035919771,
0.0208524484,
0.0162329674,
0.0448511615,
0.0254963972,
0.0146242175,
-0.0244813524,
-0.029219605,
0.0286926199,
-0.0171958953,
-0.0014632494,
0.0580711141,
-0.0417631939,
-0.0295550637,
-0.0562566109,
-0.0208943058,
-0.0357568152,
0.0215032417,
-0.013275912,
0.0074322517,
-0.0597966798,
-0.0224708691,
-0.0389255844,
0.0569913983,
-0.0505604781,
-0.0374143757,
0.0365790464,
-0.02802407,
-0.0092477733,
-0.0349696837,
0.0142316585,
0.0446906164,
0.0203716122,
-0.0274997074,
0.0346849933,
-0.0288226791,
-0.0328503959,
-0.0039013266,
-0.0272336937,
-0.0364809483,
-0.0159538835,
0.0327243395,
-0.018086018,
-0.0597784519,
-0.0162717737,
0.0005844808,
-0.1061252505,
0.0287066419,
0.0429215617,
0.0251135249,
0.0351091735,
0.0268810019,
-0.0118505144,
0.0442994274,
0.0313904881,
-0.0363896489,
0.0288591366,
-0.0098497113,
-0.0044652773,
0.0314001851,
0.0101270033,
0.0048322184,
-0.031554047,
0.0201741364,
0.0126909502,
-0.0270495825,
0.0759032592,
0.0335471034,
-0.0203406736,
-0.0244368128,
0.0537201837,
0.0620015301,
-0.0077890861,
0.0207519382,
-0.0191523489,
-0.010374303,
-0.0239930414,
0.0047951033,
-0.082737267,
-0.0284713972,
-0.0049982145,
-0.0424980111,
-0.011640707,
0.0374519564,
-0.0163782891,
-0.0189366732,
-0.0078615835,
0.03273746,
0.0517928973,
-0.00236234,
-0.004947219,
0.0199363194,
0.0142889302,
0.0071542324,
0.0788905844,
-0.024445381,
0.0187574662,
-0.0651067048,
-0.0004665565,
0.0284462273,
0.0085207848,
0.0253838617,
0.0622211508,
-0.0156101389,
-0.0150529463,
0.0533843264,
0.0261409469,
0.0008157218,
-0.0072056535,
-0.0216405466,
-0.0143434443,
-0.0031838864,
0.0473553799,
0.0048789564,
-0.0028860718,
0.0274708606,
-0.0106413998,
-0.0162309371,
-0.0627657995,
0.0269810893,
0.0285645425,
-0.0193703547,
-0.0166761782,
0.0020203746,
-0.0191801861,
0.009009555,
-0.0498385243,
0.0137461144,
-0.040030539,
-0.0203730445,
0.0353342183,
0.0249550454,
-0.053173665,
0.0219478719,
-0.0174131878,
-0.0423228331,
0.0065371487,
0.0107974485,
0.0325965732,
0.0166713335,
0.0474151671,
0.0170074292,
0.049079705,
-0.0054499898,
0.0149631575,
-0.0737375617,
0.0486286469,
-0.0517685823,
0.0326063596,
-0.0084485626,
-0.0159752835,
-0.0158357862,
-0.0173278078,
0.0290084556,
-0.029805785,
-0.0152647048,
0.0033089048,
-0.0079801781,
0.0172556397,
0.0568149947,
-0.016573526,
-0.0087317014,
-0.0006261417,
-0.0540698133,
-0.0091027291,
-0.007020792,
-0.0225164369,
0.0177467465,
-0.0009583918,
-0.0231981557,
0.0103374794,
-0.0087037506,
-0.0675652698,
0.0226549115,
0.0585250705,
-0.0063186185,
-0.035590034,
-0.0320590399,
-0.0390925258,
-0.0611211509,
-0.0461474471,
0.0172159132,
0.0329079665,
0.0398172252,
-0.0058108014,
-0.0113776745,
-0.0383106135,
0.0138277365,
0.0028667492,
-0.0098390859,
0.0178598221,
0.0665453598,
-0.019527575,
0.0464156047,
0.0563662834,
0.0540239401,
0.0635938793,
-0.0065534655,
-0.0439473651,
-0.0385316685,
-0.0106702438,
-0.0038163948,
0.0121296868,
-0.062622875,
-0.0203640684,
0.0817416534,
0.0446824506,
-0.0371830463,
-0.049015604,
0.0580158234,
-0.0758127496,
-0.062487416,
-0.0138198324,
-0.0688335299,
-0.0142500019,
0.0597188026,
-0.0489932522,
-0.0671531036,
0.0009613266,
0.0064368146,
0.0229304656,
-0.0241849758,
-0.0255500339,
-0.010669929,
0.0525646433,
0.0103200013,
0.0464854538,
0.010998846,
-0.048896689,
-0.0618562847,
-0.0375169963,
0.0594665818,
-0.0331208706,
-0.001569739,
-0.0098337978,
0.009111166,
-0.0120214978,
-0.0360503569,
-0.0128151709,
-0.0894766375,
-0.0145564443,
0.0394783393,
0.0154540548,
-0.0028551423,
0.0121022966,
0.0043386901,
-0.0117621021,
-0.0128091974,
0.0020043929,
0.0146002723,
0.0088000176,
-0.0453804657,
0.0321189128,
-0.0119500393,
0.0320118852,
-0.0029161389,
-0.0108021786,
-0.0004646773,
0.0157002285,
0.067759715,
0.0514639094,
0.0134050902,
0.0407676212,
-0.051481355,
-0.0287642069,
0.0065622428,
0.021688452,
-0.0296778139,
0.0373341814,
0.0824202597,
0.0113366293,
-0.053792417,
0.0291369446,
0.0142978923,
0.0265221484,
0.0308811273,
-0.0326736905,
-0.1081681103,
0.0174705889,
0.0080170697,
-0.0057980106,
-0.0945215374,
-0.0499053374,
-0.0101142675,
-0.0908358172,
-0.0004563758,
-0.0067217597,
-0.0306171924,
0.0065092952,
-0.0130942278,
0.0207006186,
-0.0085402457,
0.0528294221,
0.0077022938,
0.0234836694,
0.0126565229,
0.0304334685,
-0.0304030869,
-0.0397156775,
0.0409185998,
-0.061696399,
0.0340367332,
0.0437222719,
0.0129374284,
-0.0539310798,
-0.0397101641,
-0.014755778,
-0.0026157575,
-0.0201371629,
-0.0109209986,
0.0352474637,
-0.0585086569,
-0.0153879263,
-0.0483406968,
0.0191589165,
0.0417575203,
0.0236241855,
0.0028992079,
-0.0006952267,
0.028555287,
-0.040639244,
-0.0706405267,
-0.0395206064,
-0.0226940494,
0.0912022442,
0.0187984593,
-0.0392343327,
0.0310694855,
-0.0381982587,
-0.0063482882,
0.0635553002,
-0.0827589855,
0.0381613933,
0.0003209665,
-0.0506663062,
-0.024965167,
-0.0669789687,
0.0034187722,
-0.0149943382,
0.0365393013,
-0.0248629265,
-0.0258448888,
-0.0308387484,
-0.0286272261,
0.0196993034,
-0.0048892335,
0.011358466,
-0.000973866,
-0.0166583508,
-0.0095856031,
-0.0090394383,
-0.0384656936,
-0.0432109684,
0.02465613,
-0.0416879244,
0.0708266273,
-0.0057491558,
0.0293480437,
0.018053174,
-0.0003208672,
-0.0741812512,
0.0411583595,
0.0238484889,
-0.0357648991,
0.0512618348,
0.0178437885,
-0.0549221896,
0.0236938596,
-0.0082731945,
-0.0411934294,
0.0627132803,
0.0378105193,
0.0059706178,
0.0062017553,
-0.0483265966,
0.020037869,
-0.0051707509,
0.0325495712,
-0.0140892956,
-0.0040780897,
-0.0437783711,
-0.0339797586,
-0.0267314427,
-0.0492911898,
0.004238389,
-0.0213128552,
0.0406675898,
0.0609502643,
-0.0424369946,
-0.0255546756,
-0.0471402071,
0.0197509881,
-0.0326039083,
0.0315501466,
-0.027336061,
0.0275642816,
0.0024550348,
-0.0003903917,
0.0127381906,
-0.0097780144,
-0.0072426074,
0.0389177352,
0.0233129654,
0.0304515585,
0.0245478284,
0.0073477821,
-0.0253087506,
0.0094184419,
-0.0452772751,
-0.0285694227,
0.0147165274,
-0.0107802972,
-0.009709998,
-0.075727433,
0.0209489632,
0.025147045,
0.0054849437,
-0.0028408528,
-0.0208128523,
0.0196603555,
-0.0316718407,
0.0540276058,
-0.0187088922,
-0.0120825619,
0.0159949791,
0.0368175432,
0.0339325257,
0.0410148688,
-0.0577762984,
-0.0283425413,
0.0140259536,
-0.0352843553,
0.0477216132,
-0.0082171317,
-0.0171849821,
-0.0181535315,
-0.1129969135,
-0.0491776019,
-0.0550491549,
-0.0121349962,
0.0302121025,
-0.0461490452,
-0.0430425107,
0.0611281767,
-0.0083143841,
-0.0232098382,
0.0030744812,
-0.027574271,
-0.0390368439,
-0.02279808,
0.0006006163,
-5.839238066e-33,
-0.0119302142,
-0.0144047858,
-0.0167894047,
-0.0447082333,
0.0066582924,
0.0072675156,
0.0298070721,
0.0191326458,
-0.0584538803,
0.0158750564,
-0.0151496427,
-0.0081107058,
0.0022061481,
-0.0117525533,
0.0640543625,
-0.0076060202,
0.0151434708,
0.0131652346,
-0.0303574111,
-0.0169166122,
-0.019153649,
-0.0130850673,
0.040787857,
-0.0263640303,
0.1022111103,
-0.0015121707,
-0.0039728922,
-0.0001706095,
-0.0151969027,
0.0228992943,
0.0034616394,
0.0781874061,
0.044523932,
-0.027614288,
0.012547466,
0.0595616102,
-0.036590565,
-0.016657291,
0.0644219816,
-0.0042377519,
0.0264602508,
-0.008923253,
0.0260719862,
0.0424934477,
-0.0940457135,
0.0048652361,
0.0742395669,
0.0067605297,
0.042501539,
0.0260333605,
-0.0427435338,
0.0068688062,
-0.0507217236,
0.03127544,
0.025684651,
-0.040494334,
0.0244110152,
0.0427209698,
-0.0090949414,
0.0129786646,
-0.0196589828,
0.0159250908,
0.0407106429,
0.0221714862,
0.0210395884,
0.0624698289,
0.0622008741,
0.0663506314,
0.0158007387,
-0.006907681,
0.081347093,
-0.0085707214,
-0.0116257099,
0.057486333,
0.0570564866,
-0.0455103964,
-0.0059349532,
-0.044117026,
0.0503535047,
-0.0004570706,
0.017025657,
-0.002927237,
-0.0731376633,
-0.0808378831,
-0.0549954399,
-0.0678912476,
-0.0355597511,
-0.0101337619,
0.0356574543,
0.0106758419,
0.0125182653,
0.0172132663,
0.0303510334,
-0.01607126,
-0.0585615151,
0.014534113,
-0.0241250303,
-0.0363026373,
0.0131287137,
0.0134336166,
-0.0915282071,
0.0044067381,
-0.0109673478,
0.0439632796,
0.0242655594,
0.0420312583,
0.0173356179,
0.0010084057,
-0.0397216007,
-0.0065870807,
0.0128436647,
-0.0050996095,
0.0129871592,
-0.0220513605,
0.0364961214,
0.0390253924,
0.0073896335,
-0.0285545718,
0.0711552724,
-0.0145616587,
-0.0546345413,
0.0071623903,
-0.0360548459,
0.0078938333,
-0.0306287706,
-0.0185788982,
0.034024179,
-0.0062277005,
0.0800446868,
-0.0437509902,
-0.0189404264,
-0.0766392946,
2.413e-7,
0.0346041583,
0.0489732474,
-0.0379695632,
-0.0028536126,
0.0070496765,
0.0385637395,
0.0557629541,
0.0569696799,
0.0600470006,
0.0130786858,
-0.0471794009,
0.0208633151,
-0.0248997249,
0.0034760439,
-0.0191576611,
0.0220549386,
-0.0929055363,
0.0512505844,
-0.0356717892,
0.0294615719,
0.0213453881,
0.0233104471,
0.0228470881,
-0.018923495,
-0.053333059,
-0.0316393487,
0.0039742915,
-0.04277445,
0.0129356189,
0.012078126,
0.036193952,
0.0267049223,
0.0313038789,
0.0699931756,
0.0309325717,
0.0840019137,
0.0248194784,
0.0061133159,
-0.0228093676,
0.052104827,
-0.0133772269,
-0.0383013934,
-0.0169535112,
-0.0461160801,
0.0544499904,
0.038756907,
-0.0559336543,
-0.0471034385,
-0.0269239172,
-0.0036278467,
0.0399882123,
-0.0021239973,
-0.0157642402,
-0.009918035,
0.0241508726,
0.0194932371,
0.0063458225,
-0.0575768873,
-0.0430379659,
-0.0226081796,
0.0251314808,
-0.0581154637,
0.0328652784,
0.0469211899,
-0.0105034932,
-0.0351781398,
0.0280078016,
2.122247373e-34,
0.0059701623,
0.0290008411,
0.0371429548,
0.0209663268,
0.0334668383,
0.0363499746,
0.0142470775,
0.0006432194,
0.0206986908,
-0.0095921103,
-0.0190994591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10145v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10145v2 | Can ChatGPT Reproduce Human-Generated Labels? A Study of Social Computing Tasks | 2023-04-20T08:08:12 | 2023-04-22T08:55:33 | Yiming Zhu, Peixian Zhang, Ehsan-Ul Haq, Pan Hui, Gareth Tyson | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The release of ChatGPT has uncovered a range of possibilities whereby large
language models (LLMs) can substitute human intelligence. In this paper, we
seek to understand whether ChatGPT has the potential to reproduce
human-generated label annotations in social computing tasks. Such an
achievement could significantly reduce the cost and complexity of social
computing research. As such, we use ChatGPT to relabel five seminal datasets
covering stance detection (2x), sentiment analysis, hate speech, and bot
detection. Our results highlight that ChatGPT does have the potential to handle
these data annotation tasks, although a number of challenges remain. ChatGPT
obtains an average accuracy 0.609. Performance is highest for the sentiment
analysis dataset, with ChatGPT correctly annotating 64.9% of tweets. Yet, we
show that performance varies substantially across individual labels. We believe
this work can open up new lines of analysis and act as a basis for future
research into the exploitation of ChatGPT for human annotation tasks. | [
0.0663974509,
0.0402955227,
-0.004816493,
0.0307570696,
-0.0265523177,
0.0460289419,
0.0064729289,
0.0029935942,
0.0660353228,
-0.077391766,
-0.0318869129,
-0.0144556528,
-0.0349904634,
0.0079966849,
0.0281252898,
-0.03375623,
0.028972771,
0.0298906304,
0.0611314364,
-0.0091912542,
0.0514045507,
0.0106243165,
-0.007199727,
0.0511166677,
-0.0722900927,
-0.004785582,
0.0207454171,
-0.0007562662,
0.0058178897,
-0.0152089149,
0.0293924175,
0.0726614818,
-0.0052478346,
0.0955370665,
0.0000015806,
-0.0304649416,
0.0039684335,
0.0055631856,
-0.0081699919,
0.0035632884,
0.0756409615,
-0.009075949,
-0.0194114633,
0.0268917512,
-0.0547790341,
0.0005479318,
0.0683741719,
0.0300785266,
0.0791238099,
0.0854993165,
-0.014719855,
-0.0030190509,
0.0110141272,
-0.0319651105,
0.0227211956,
-0.0365557857,
0.0201295055,
0.0171308778,
-0.0134041263,
0.0629295111,
0.003978489,
0.0487590246,
0.0093731098,
-0.0218427498,
0.0003856799,
0.0109110596,
-0.0506104119,
-0.0131334458,
-0.011177537,
0.0510627888,
0.0129313432,
-0.034167096,
0.0199146681,
0.0120984279,
0.006629691,
-0.0198154449,
-0.0369047262,
0.0013609829,
-0.011167747,
0.0198486894,
0.0202973187,
-0.0137478532,
0.0407228768,
0.0313465856,
0.0548794605,
0.0514683239,
-0.0254209358,
-0.0243652835,
0.0210346691,
0.0460654721,
-0.0351550616,
-0.044795718,
0.0175232757,
-0.0187883787,
-0.0101590781,
0.0289327595,
-0.0650209561,
-0.0058359765,
0.0077066869,
-0.0754538253,
-0.0241908673,
0.0403041877,
-0.0113016888,
0.0645642653,
0.0100824777,
0.0203180891,
-0.0193042252,
0.0303372759,
-0.0094743297,
-0.023379067,
-0.0710299015,
-0.0256808624,
-0.0383727588,
0.0029558269,
-0.00976774,
-0.0000802651,
-0.0574374087,
0.0374441519,
-0.0403290726,
-0.0147620421,
-0.0064938748,
-0.0127682565,
-0.0091245109,
0.0030857157,
-0.0356976874,
0.0047824048,
-0.0002386301,
0.0137408795,
-0.0062043229,
-0.0665820017,
0.0207918007,
0.0199429318,
-0.0069051962,
-0.0162867643,
0.0168234929,
0.0656946301,
0.0101159932,
-0.0180041157,
-0.013492045,
-0.0219773352,
-0.018009834,
-0.0495461226,
-0.0083134538,
-0.0800826624,
0.0466558486,
0.0360008441,
-0.020956004,
-0.0467147008,
0.0096379975,
0.052969601,
-0.059995804,
0.0892236978,
-0.0254540443,
0.008220857,
0.0298743695,
0.0098032299,
-0.0319004543,
0.079495579,
0.0215111505,
0.0441252142,
0.0508256592,
0.0093687354,
0.032085523,
0.0699151903,
0.0104394956,
0.0075589889,
0.0044438159,
-0.0146121047,
-0.0095905811,
-0.0030655998,
-0.0060228552,
0.088318795,
-0.0128492769,
-0.0302649513,
0.0783285722,
0.0632660314,
-0.0434710458,
0.044208616,
0.0345147625,
0.0374627598,
0.0232220516,
-0.0239338856,
-0.0612668917,
0.0195113178,
-0.035293147,
-0.035598278,
0.0237981882,
-0.0183643233,
-0.0212896802,
-0.0340957753,
-0.0245791469,
0.0035572588,
0.039568238,
-0.0210559294,
0.0165052935,
-0.0043895454,
-0.0209044795,
0.0325470231,
0.0454026423,
-0.0269207805,
-0.0189301651,
-0.068213746,
0.0050676744,
0.0422550552,
0.0224969033,
-0.0285433903,
-0.0153230093,
-0.0160449985,
0.0261704251,
0.0648308098,
0.0892912969,
-0.0198515225,
-0.066010043,
0.0048641348,
0.0058952705,
0.0195616391,
0.0088499058,
0.0217697416,
0.0758141503,
0.001707787,
0.0000431253,
-0.0217379872,
-0.0390601195,
0.0095025292,
0.0256969519,
-0.0039274422,
0.0034792316,
-0.0113546755,
0.0454258285,
0.0468559153,
-0.0171198435,
-0.0224852618,
-0.0007221522,
-0.0074966541,
-0.0695042536,
-0.0035008069,
-0.0064729988,
-0.0440000333,
0.0509363748,
-0.0129916817,
-0.0596442893,
0.0398724079,
-0.0449188091,
-0.0011636713,
0.0238452572,
-0.0647205114,
0.0156031847,
-0.0429486781,
-0.0433899909,
-0.0160711445,
0.0239622984,
-0.0130406907,
0.0571664087,
0.0062514776,
-0.0183553584,
-0.0070806756,
-0.0182936862,
-0.0011758059,
0.00588289,
-0.0485267565,
-0.0086600743,
0.0212899894,
0.0382873006,
0.0332255922,
0.011454449,
-0.0315000899,
-0.0313411467,
-0.1543122977,
-0.0073967283,
-0.0174614638,
0.0021381809,
0.0272139441,
-0.0048851077,
0.0009486391,
-0.002923812,
-0.0522424765,
-0.0137842977,
0.0200517755,
0.0508807972,
0.0342709273,
-0.0302119404,
-0.0137341423,
-0.0263574645,
0.0001344657,
-0.027854003,
-0.0035524089,
0.0364457853,
-0.0781967491,
-0.0024879635,
0.0036789752,
-0.0422924086,
0.015030086,
-0.0163671169,
-0.0430560298,
0.0258538369,
0.0095231151,
0.0160311386,
0.0258755814,
0.0229062382,
0.0551881492,
-0.0104773315,
0.0340262316,
-0.0257377326,
0.0023315062,
-0.0400498584,
-0.0207065195,
-0.0232972242,
-0.020757623,
-0.0120589631,
0.0831971765,
0.0073038335,
0.0101482198,
-0.0528110787,
0.0352075249,
-0.0403390825,
-0.0250758901,
-0.040539328,
0.0080366489,
-0.0204080213,
-0.0013973077,
-0.0248677488,
-0.0500390232,
0.0627995506,
-0.0088452697,
-0.0011665061,
-0.0152978664,
-0.0389984511,
-0.0221136734,
0.0805649608,
0.0290456545,
-0.0013875804,
-0.0339037105,
0.0068715406,
0.0084768776,
0.0017849725,
0.0130022261,
-0.0497168563,
-0.0057997657,
-0.0207757298,
0.0410291813,
0.0094679808,
-0.0455424562,
-0.0273255389,
-0.0788507462,
-0.0811492354,
-0.0110315094,
0.0273086093,
-0.0304229669,
0.0066954023,
0.0170291606,
0.0211565476,
0.0085276309,
-0.0108946199,
-0.0038171255,
0.0071599493,
0.0004705396,
0.0260871854,
-0.0019246356,
-0.0160043743,
0.0078646252,
-0.0169299636,
0.064636521,
0.0098746838,
-0.009572872,
-0.0186364353,
-0.0219977759,
0.0029704671,
0.0133657604,
-0.0103504146,
-0.02269038,
0.0545419864,
-0.0153121632,
0.0066555212,
0.1092473119,
0.0250539109,
-0.0429141782,
-0.0043526934,
0.0389280319,
0.0133024212,
0.0206206348,
-0.0047745379,
-0.0931115597,
-0.0454406776,
-0.0034822104,
0.0266591646,
-0.0396300815,
-0.0258575622,
-0.0184282959,
-0.1064149365,
0.0176284276,
-0.0192797892,
-0.0716120005,
-0.0130706942,
-0.0402864665,
0.0027596578,
-0.0443929322,
0.0109615186,
-0.0376324281,
0.0285026375,
0.0163280796,
0.0404273607,
-0.0596110895,
-0.0172942821,
0.0295723826,
-0.0216821544,
0.0857973695,
0.0436083302,
0.0458909348,
0.0097628227,
-0.0039566909,
0.0714688227,
0.0603392236,
-0.0104888873,
-0.0269834362,
0.0771397725,
-0.0318768024,
-0.0338352732,
-0.011344837,
0.0414993875,
-0.045110561,
0.007369176,
-0.0046092728,
0.041980233,
0.0147792865,
0.0043330905,
-0.0209545568,
0.0198815241,
0.0120878629,
0.0812458247,
0.0370807089,
-0.0641696453,
-0.0174773112,
-0.0640990734,
-0.0130865574,
-0.0479765683,
-0.0752259269,
-0.0233165324,
-0.0375473946,
-0.059330292,
-0.0584171675,
-0.0422970355,
0.0385776125,
0.0058892267,
-0.0113985315,
-0.0183775146,
0.0277029127,
0.0211462677,
-0.039832484,
0.0179512817,
-0.0623335168,
0.0217580441,
-0.0200774893,
-0.0523668714,
0.0242797453,
-0.0131398784,
-0.0355389118,
0.0158736948,
-0.0901590735,
-0.0664060637,
0.0284591671,
0.0261461344,
0.0260410123,
0.0319010392,
-0.0346376933,
-0.0455527455,
0.0044818721,
0.1295408159,
-0.0265452787,
0.0134539334,
0.0156587139,
0.0571326017,
0.008859829,
0.0365431979,
-0.0251566041,
0.0369418412,
0.0457185209,
-0.0064972164,
-0.0329227746,
-0.008739871,
0.0149275912,
0.0417587906,
0.067869775,
0.0089880144,
-0.0138531141,
-0.0144769214,
-0.048038207,
-0.0061788899,
-0.0548068658,
-0.0303431973,
-0.0234217271,
0.0054762731,
-0.0065931524,
-0.0622422472,
-0.0070104413,
-0.0235501006,
0.0503236279,
-0.0307738837,
-0.0169302709,
0.0171075463,
0.0262620728,
0.0077590905,
-0.0127386302,
-0.0224216245,
0.0134920739,
0.0317164399,
-0.0052769291,
-0.0111725824,
0.0135057122,
0.0149901342,
-0.0143785849,
0.0235703755,
0.0102800895,
-0.0495804884,
-0.0418393686,
-0.033221785,
0.0694707558,
0.0256363284,
0.016092753,
0.0413316563,
-0.0381470844,
-0.0431990139,
-0.0144270407,
0.0150043741,
-0.0207178686,
-0.0260772854,
0.0138478959,
-0.0060548116,
-0.0505786948,
0.0103975115,
0.0528101139,
-0.0119633982,
0.0255076289,
0.0378160067,
-0.0699985921,
-0.0286037046,
-0.0162387844,
-0.0360697247,
-0.0089119012,
0.0253525656,
0.0215061456,
-0.0525315031,
-0.0740661174,
-0.0011478843,
-0.0004657025,
0.0175848417,
0.0080227535,
0.0196133144,
0.0748057961,
-0.0129668033,
0.0323890671,
-0.0542988516,
0.014240399,
-0.0026805955,
-0.0356293544,
-0.0047891233,
-6.002077461e-33,
-0.0096034482,
-0.0401543453,
0.0026768325,
0.0421698503,
-0.0079156775,
0.0000088348,
-0.0066940356,
0.0544304177,
0.0178232007,
0.0458381362,
-0.0080292802,
0.0243580341,
0.0091968533,
0.0241799317,
0.0045207031,
-0.0399503484,
0.0254449043,
-0.0309134647,
-0.0171749853,
0.038617868,
0.0324492604,
-0.0125963716,
0.0334541947,
-0.103894189,
0.0464477763,
-0.010909169,
-0.0033683327,
0.0167035609,
0.0266358331,
0.0583874136,
-0.0280659273,
0.0789082944,
0.0473028608,
-0.0282289069,
0.0085654091,
0.0432108864,
-0.0535144918,
-0.0034992695,
0.0070648007,
0.0148591464,
0.0037118976,
0.0022055842,
0.0295761582,
-0.0113265244,
-0.0582692698,
0.0218159407,
0.0366243795,
-0.0119971698,
0.0212284699,
-0.0242972188,
-0.0431046672,
0.0379361138,
-0.0111933714,
-0.0216556173,
-0.0086146826,
0.0147145009,
0.0096049672,
0.0376741141,
-0.049644161,
0.016174186,
-0.0529664084,
0.002814299,
0.0260901675,
-0.0064178477,
0.0120798973,
0.0667277575,
0.0278207995,
0.0549810901,
-0.034466859,
0.0077024605,
-0.0072625927,
0.0041302633,
0.0502011366,
0.0528134294,
-0.0018467471,
-0.0419050083,
-0.0351854861,
0.00366642,
0.0660869107,
-0.0528454073,
0.0295921359,
0.0064156838,
-0.046203427,
-0.0200997777,
-0.0086040571,
-0.0270741284,
-0.0467324629,
-0.0139826406,
-0.0001194621,
-0.0036492751,
-0.0313580818,
0.0109774685,
0.0059042028,
-0.0498841256,
-0.0111495508,
-0.0011827896,
-0.0339019522,
0.032314539,
0.0039276569,
0.024839377,
-0.0430662446,
-0.0220296122,
-0.0005381735,
0.0264915861,
0.0200506169,
-0.028248677,
0.0644355193,
0.0274375677,
-0.0733851939,
0.0044774464,
-0.0428341441,
0.0582668521,
-0.03783755,
-0.0169239528,
0.0296643935,
0.0142912855,
-0.0065377955,
0.0195402745,
0.0298202597,
0.0269876439,
-0.0163388364,
0.0023265204,
-0.0356576033,
-0.0399728045,
-0.0336451232,
-0.0010357697,
0.0008019786,
-0.0022838004,
-0.0311609078,
-0.0757894665,
0.002859599,
-0.0186599791,
2.354e-7,
0.0277073644,
0.0665664077,
0.0019556682,
-0.010533913,
0.0625061542,
0.0554493442,
0.015265462,
0.0374142043,
0.0061935671,
-0.0463267304,
-0.0065866043,
0.0397642292,
0.0484094843,
0.0244820919,
-0.0733300596,
-0.0263954941,
-0.0720271468,
0.0054698349,
-0.0288906172,
0.0459928475,
0.017753277,
0.093738474,
0.079339996,
-0.0097424462,
-0.0236052163,
-0.0536445677,
0.0650074184,
-0.0264100228,
-0.0414318368,
0.010959845,
0.0574414432,
0.0406372882,
0.0109689776,
0.0109294923,
-0.0056754043,
-0.0145256771,
0.0441499017,
0.065956302,
0.0281851124,
-0.0025236781,
-0.0156442076,
-0.0084979273,
-0.0001097876,
-0.0028861905,
0.0672108755,
-0.0598259047,
-0.0494521558,
-0.0574216843,
0.0079289954,
-0.010329661,
0.0153146461,
-0.0123486323,
-0.0336136408,
0.0042043035,
0.0216835923,
-0.0117285959,
-0.0108469445,
-0.0587262064,
-0.0021508732,
-0.0250354093,
-0.0599057041,
-0.0712906048,
-0.0063854107,
0.0196541436,
0.0320864581,
-0.007208488,
0.0268882234,
1.75248162e-34,
0.0432538427,
-0.0232983027,
0.0047926051,
-0.0189996902,
0.0393166766,
0.0459174812,
0.0189271364,
0.0034845113,
0.0224245563,
-0.0363838896,
0.0037084394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11095v1 | Is Cross-modal Information Retrieval Possible without Training? | 2023-04-20T02:36:18 | 2023-04-20T02:36:18 | Hyunjin Choi, Hyunjae Lee, Seongho Joe, Youngjune L. Gwon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR | Encoded representations from a pretrained deep learning model (e.g., BERT
text embeddings, penultimate CNN layer activations of an image) convey a rich
set of features beneficial for information retrieval. Embeddings for a
particular modality of data occupy a high-dimensional space of its own, but it
can be semantically aligned to another by a simple mapping without training a
deep neural net. In this paper, we take a simple mapping computed from the
least squares and singular value decomposition (SVD) for a solution to the
Procrustes problem to serve a means to cross-modal information retrieval. That
is, given information in one modality such as text, the mapping helps us locate
a semantically equivalent data item in another modality such as image. Using
off-the-shelf pretrained deep learning models, we have experimented the
aforementioned simple cross-modal mappings in tasks of text-to-image and
image-to-text retrieval. Despite simplicity, our mappings perform reasonably
well reaching the highest accuracy of 77% on recall@10, which is comparable to
those requiring costly neural net training and fine-tuning. We have improved
the simple mappings by contrastive learning on the pretrained models.
Contrastive learning can be thought as properly biasing the pretrained encoders
to enhance the cross-modal mapping quality. We have further improved the
performance by multilayer perceptron with gating (gMLP), a simple neural
architecture. | [
-0.0305655021,
0.0294472259,
0.0020814976,
0.0208292566,
-0.0085284282,
0.0144679016,
0.013587554,
0.0156956986,
0.012741372,
-0.055754371,
-0.0530038513,
-0.0065932213,
-0.0237359367,
0.0185835417,
0.0037261341,
-0.0529128648,
0.0401207767,
0.0452175289,
-0.0244243275,
-0.0014480602,
0.0142847868,
-0.01379932,
0.0019829161,
0.0028372097,
-0.0434057266,
0.0057726926,
-0.0316843763,
0.0006376432,
0.0197503865,
-0.0077881659,
-0.0034666818,
-0.0057250839,
0.0798423439,
-0.027778754,
0.0000019145,
0.0057381792,
-0.018948596,
0.0074207606,
0.0199414454,
-0.0019202499,
0.0418435149,
-0.0347645171,
0.0154840071,
0.0052297674,
-0.0283124186,
-0.0702476799,
0.0435759351,
0.0878602043,
0.0458949171,
0.0527562015,
-0.0426156968,
-0.0629162937,
0.0624619275,
0.0025183209,
0.0517604798,
-0.0329766795,
-0.0034088735,
-0.0059969919,
0.0024398859,
0.0600624904,
-0.0183233302,
0.0665408298,
0.0027754686,
0.0293395277,
-0.0109602185,
0.0556682013,
0.0291455854,
0.0362318829,
-0.0041353446,
0.0746498704,
0.0004905167,
-0.0181700476,
-0.0133354906,
0.006051885,
-0.0199217014,
0.0115615539,
-0.0080629354,
-0.0114904782,
-0.0014130137,
0.0221661869,
-0.0349889658,
-0.0058205039,
0.0060540438,
-0.0042077615,
-0.0015384309,
-0.0284209717,
0.0250040982,
-0.0115569253,
-0.0331776328,
-0.0058320756,
-0.0040468625,
-0.0070421998,
0.0234486852,
0.0175386388,
0.0187572483,
-0.0261680465,
-0.0379077345,
-0.0923920572,
-0.0230386946,
-0.0329603292,
0.0285806935,
0.0415524356,
-0.0771852359,
0.0763523206,
-0.0580266155,
0.0467192605,
-0.0649198294,
0.0551663153,
-0.0531599782,
-0.0397761464,
-0.0544310622,
-0.0095914146,
-0.0413764231,
0.0173221789,
-0.0514401346,
-0.0424275845,
-0.0018138342,
0.000141664,
0.0229915176,
-0.0325940214,
-0.0251654219,
0.0560718067,
-0.0421258956,
-0.0155011499,
-0.0423390344,
0.0537449606,
-0.024511626,
0.0200951286,
-0.0413413569,
0.0011385151,
0.0310019497,
0.0151527999,
0.0491783209,
-0.0052788341,
0.0383316502,
0.0720560998,
-0.074134104,
-0.0180454962,
-0.0621909909,
-0.0123185795,
0.0103576733,
-0.0007080805,
0.0493392237,
-0.0328496173,
0.0374635942,
0.0177127738,
-0.0286370423,
-0.0015181412,
-0.0246237889,
0.0141637474,
-0.0477080792,
0.1322961897,
-0.0001514921,
-0.0140229715,
0.048408173,
0.0018643929,
0.008131342,
0.0264224894,
0.0082181497,
0.0360068567,
0.0127076684,
0.022040192,
-0.0192551874,
-0.007188641,
0.0165945403,
-0.0169984121,
-0.0323986635,
0.0134635475,
-0.0003628677,
0.018639164,
0.022684589,
0.0455205515,
-0.0529034995,
-0.0307044424,
0.0379530936,
0.0439348221,
0.062983714,
0.0801968053,
-0.0024716323,
0.0198221095,
-0.0395603031,
-0.0027358274,
-0.0195896663,
0.0554004982,
-0.0011634617,
-0.0306291878,
0.0394509323,
0.0041562361,
-0.0549687035,
-0.0173098464,
0.0545473918,
-0.0244986564,
0.0238814969,
0.0148052396,
0.0450319536,
-0.0454614237,
-0.0372756794,
0.0563208833,
0.0091025205,
-0.0392357856,
0.0145529006,
-0.0061462424,
0.0022460041,
0.0490953512,
0.0018080382,
-0.0448899046,
0.0148155801,
0.008946267,
0.0392339118,
0.0148921637,
0.0215363447,
-0.0065081213,
0.0111452974,
-0.0591499582,
-0.0460498258,
-0.0219810996,
-0.0244175754,
0.0481748506,
-0.0436662026,
0.0359845534,
0.0498780347,
-0.0380868837,
0.0536622815,
0.017893495,
0.015232374,
-0.0254787989,
0.000426408,
0.0657654777,
-0.0305965487,
0.0031322199,
-0.0244527627,
0.0209881868,
0.0209170654,
-0.0589752793,
-0.0086116074,
-0.0080481209,
-0.0211886056,
-0.0298800357,
0.0282191243,
-0.099409923,
0.03058956,
0.0695788935,
0.0096232304,
-0.05412421,
0.0090023577,
-0.0355427898,
0.0408689454,
-0.0374278687,
-0.0234625284,
0.0111046107,
-0.0115782246,
-0.0065135635,
0.0393524319,
0.0142604653,
0.019745158,
0.0014862388,
0.0151438033,
0.0788334236,
0.0082893353,
-0.0520209447,
-0.026350148,
-0.0268910434,
0.0357837193,
0.0259558018,
-0.0007897436,
-0.0313766114,
-0.0129563315,
-0.1274621636,
-0.0168676246,
-0.0048141247,
-0.0071284943,
0.0154255219,
0.0118097942,
0.0234950278,
-0.0621396713,
-0.0782526284,
0.0319431461,
0.0021294726,
0.0333763883,
0.0387983844,
0.0312591456,
0.0180418156,
-0.0178164318,
-0.011409808,
-0.0210202653,
0.0111086955,
-0.0226687323,
-0.0050294595,
-0.0075254147,
0.0226606317,
-0.0080956388,
0.0691927373,
-0.0029805417,
-0.0407916941,
0.0264954269,
-0.0208706055,
0.0168164857,
0.0563127436,
0.0121210963,
-0.0206410233,
-0.0103970543,
-0.0167928245,
-0.0714327469,
0.0369549692,
-0.0185827799,
0.0185482074,
-0.0147604262,
-0.000633003,
-0.025056608,
-0.0154342307,
0.0041825785,
0.0236164071,
-0.0405152738,
-0.0294570848,
0.0337387584,
-0.0047948174,
-0.0530483201,
0.0258001108,
0.0328029469,
0.0235840585,
-0.0291935578,
-0.0077052829,
0.0431912057,
-0.0236621611,
0.0003646333,
-0.0066111656,
-0.0083236797,
-0.0030265618,
0.0466667302,
-0.0362277143,
0.0522674657,
-0.0336431377,
-0.0248614438,
-0.0327991359,
-0.008394585,
0.0387455374,
-0.0384020172,
0.0395234749,
0.0328298584,
0.0327234343,
-0.0553452745,
-0.0775538459,
-0.0113258641,
-0.088262938,
0.0083541302,
0.0289428513,
-0.0104516605,
-0.0080445278,
-0.0711063296,
0.0389031284,
0.0230366345,
0.0306119695,
0.0035488931,
-0.0314460285,
-0.0191710796,
0.0773112625,
-0.0111373067,
-0.0130632091,
-0.0449031964,
0.0084376959,
-0.0221933462,
0.0304781012,
0.0404305235,
0.0015499722,
-0.0542340986,
0.0206468813,
0.0249356329,
0.0317283198,
-0.0390143394,
0.0000156509,
0.0132790776,
-0.0047144718,
-0.0157020967,
0.0673083812,
0.0001719601,
-0.0560556427,
-0.0676804706,
0.0299462005,
-0.0448760092,
-0.0011551711,
0.0534118861,
-0.0596595444,
-0.0457350984,
-0.015524568,
-0.0056276801,
0.046870932,
0.0157308076,
0.0152306743,
-0.0580855757,
0.0100512523,
-0.0326079093,
0.0029670976,
-0.0880265534,
-0.0219068378,
0.0029966766,
0.0131172771,
-0.0178449638,
-0.0306099392,
-0.007276319,
-0.0401799157,
0.0112223076,
0.0516990907,
-0.0245554689,
-0.0045479564,
-0.0590949394,
-0.0162007567,
0.0338542722,
0.0336972252,
-0.0123814978,
-0.1050638333,
-0.0064057503,
-0.0099749807,
0.0034763466,
0.0079698944,
0.069490172,
-0.0487568937,
-0.025727585,
-0.0187843628,
-0.0054762219,
-0.0042624171,
-0.0004886787,
-0.0773932338,
0.0467987172,
-0.002871952,
0.0535219274,
-0.0403432921,
-0.0100953421,
0.0016202977,
0.0396766216,
-0.0221108478,
-0.0135541577,
-0.0292234384,
-0.0238101948,
0.0512056947,
-0.0093588801,
-0.01965243,
0.0153668094,
-0.0197988227,
-0.0065897373,
-0.0185713172,
-0.0282059219,
-0.0123289032,
0.0561508164,
-0.0001157154,
-0.0198371299,
-0.0139838355,
0.006022403,
-0.0686018616,
0.0131952306,
-0.0250322986,
0.0260913707,
-0.002094795,
0.0186697133,
0.0685713738,
-0.0472262092,
-0.0286489576,
-0.0583009198,
-0.021351967,
-0.0385601707,
-0.0535941906,
-0.0016229451,
0.0018221743,
0.0331610255,
0.0097246971,
-0.0483550653,
0.0831632093,
0.0351438038,
-0.0388449095,
-0.0342133231,
0.0244732015,
-0.0030233362,
-0.0027909407,
0.0082605146,
-0.0539908297,
0.0203279704,
0.0212857164,
0.0013186848,
-0.0146872792,
-0.0150884762,
0.0367143787,
-0.0182808246,
0.0741171464,
0.0239096656,
0.0264618117,
-0.0458594784,
-0.0050986875,
0.009520866,
-0.0143881747,
-0.0162358657,
0.0073480811,
0.0319174714,
-0.0026627772,
-0.0026917683,
0.0582569055,
0.0431385078,
0.036145363,
-0.0356784761,
0.0290444046,
0.034111999,
0.0275623892,
-0.039738182,
0.0108698038,
-0.0166783202,
0.0035773655,
0.0137766954,
0.0407651737,
-0.0704924986,
0.027697403,
0.0396438316,
-0.0113990428,
-0.0672676936,
0.0524063222,
-0.0503053293,
-0.0244563501,
-0.0432692431,
0.0063002454,
0.0470753461,
-0.0142828403,
-0.0179622509,
0.0023270294,
-0.0208062381,
-0.0207043681,
0.0082919179,
-0.0018238792,
0.0200342871,
0.037705157,
0.0148661649,
0.0372048393,
0.0030255071,
0.0427747034,
-0.025959393,
0.0337322429,
-0.0186154731,
-0.056994006,
-0.0287227761,
0.0182312354,
0.0741108954,
0.0310835782,
-0.0287261102,
-0.0181874335,
0.0285259392,
-0.0394651257,
0.0485577919,
0.0254189242,
-0.0227426011,
0.0131419851,
0.0501747318,
0.0814051777,
0.0423052795,
-0.0010888192,
0.00863906,
0.0158938449,
-0.0016694774,
-0.0081471438,
-0.030070819,
-5.983891094e-33,
-0.000841193,
0.0145976376,
0.0161593482,
-0.0387038253,
-0.0199385323,
0.0060740593,
-0.0093473308,
-0.0121693993,
-0.0566249825,
0.0186738856,
-0.0107870987,
-0.0061323335,
0.0179072618,
0.022658186,
-0.0082387635,
-0.0244172327,
0.041339308,
-0.01123098,
-0.0006038045,
-0.0021367322,
0.0242197588,
0.0521352738,
0.0312724002,
-0.1031625271,
-0.04476263,
0.0297174975,
-0.0036957937,
0.0135905799,
0.0647758022,
0.0463883355,
-0.0465463102,
0.0111941099,
0.0351231359,
-0.0097436626,
0.0219709966,
0.0792582333,
-0.095392853,
-0.0082656965,
-0.0377695709,
0.0159379411,
-0.0418396071,
0.0087543521,
0.0403962061,
-0.0329259224,
-0.0112973079,
0.0025982487,
0.0594947599,
0.0077575659,
0.0141971642,
0.0045267749,
-0.0212877952,
0.006626403,
-0.0061202007,
-0.0493057482,
0.0502822585,
0.0510751344,
0.0508586876,
0.0252725668,
-0.067308642,
0.030522706,
-0.0387754403,
0.0202650763,
0.0203294363,
0.0299072731,
-0.0134420954,
0.0593610667,
0.047604192,
-0.0306786709,
-0.0110137332,
-0.0418828651,
0.0433298536,
0.0157404169,
0.0196402986,
0.0882444605,
0.0500294007,
-0.0369101875,
-0.0604646988,
0.0395170338,
-0.0283204895,
0.0263063721,
-0.0021038565,
0.0455773249,
-0.0413151458,
-0.0082282461,
-0.0506090522,
-0.0591510795,
-0.0398638695,
-0.0268353131,
0.0408547409,
0.041457735,
-0.0143318409,
0.026577007,
0.0720336214,
-0.015769368,
-0.0051879007,
0.0139190098,
0.0093855755,
0.0233321488,
-0.0136984708,
-0.0061401622,
-0.0280382149,
-0.0521935672,
0.0386161469,
-0.0134005304,
-0.0138418004,
0.0009798834,
0.0156285428,
0.0201581251,
-0.0644275695,
0.0009540409,
-0.010390237,
-0.083407566,
-0.0061484659,
0.0254068393,
0.0391548388,
0.0026092248,
-0.0040975409,
0.0323761106,
-0.0053518401,
0.0579084121,
-0.0241418406,
-0.0947069228,
0.0362580977,
0.0083836699,
0.008293095,
0.0195800327,
-0.0725839138,
0.0052588601,
0.0136303632,
-0.0599600971,
0.0119379917,
0.0665137246,
2.721e-7,
0.0291498974,
-0.0133383796,
0.0419783778,
-0.0136407856,
0.0022473941,
0.0677430555,
0.0169920567,
0.0586506203,
0.0026719153,
-0.0372464918,
0.0190239139,
0.0206210259,
-0.0015158933,
0.0203277487,
-0.0394228585,
-0.0165432245,
-0.0012348802,
0.0007316038,
-0.0160552338,
0.0082908887,
0.0761277229,
0.09521617,
-0.0223732442,
-0.0094196424,
0.0227286257,
-0.055259414,
0.0927553996,
-0.0165040232,
0.0091445176,
-0.0426744781,
-0.012623393,
0.0447686203,
-0.0374564454,
0.0143318409,
0.0002195923,
0.035244789,
0.0357600115,
0.0101326741,
-0.0240166392,
-0.069563657,
-0.0138271721,
0.0149929626,
-0.0281897653,
0.0185017977,
0.0683032945,
-0.0515407585,
-0.0017390975,
-0.0008035396,
-0.047174558,
0.0394361578,
0.0291198716,
-0.0100302249,
-0.0727589503,
-0.0040053912,
0.0368856415,
-0.0057642991,
-0.0128221875,
-0.0961920172,
0.0184864029,
0.0236996207,
-0.0525401272,
0.0086455327,
-0.0442014858,
-0.0086017204,
0.1068656445,
-0.009001581,
-0.0074659279,
1.842161967e-34,
-0.0046860999,
-0.0107441861,
0.0068269884,
-0.0104771424,
-0.0116531113,
-0.0145621086,
0.0023329016,
-0.0398727767,
0.0276707839,
-0.0850186571,
-0.0413138829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09991v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09991v3 | Supporting Human-AI Collaboration in Auditing LLMs with LLMs | 2023-04-19T21:59:04 | 2023-11-30T16:30:09 | Charvi Rastogi, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, Nicholas King, Harsha Nori, Saleema Amershi | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models are becoming increasingly pervasive and ubiquitous in
society via deployment in sociotechnical systems. Yet these language models, be
it for classification or generation, have been shown to be biased and behave
irresponsibly, causing harm to people at scale. It is crucial to audit these
language models rigorously. Existing auditing tools leverage either or both
humans and AI to find failures. In this work, we draw upon literature in
human-AI collaboration and sensemaking, and conduct interviews with research
experts in safe and fair AI, to build upon the auditing tool: AdaTest (Ribeiro
and Lundberg, 2022), which is powered by a generative large language model
(LLM). Through the design process we highlight the importance of sensemaking
and human-AI communication to leverage complementary strengths of humans and
generative models in collaborative auditing. To evaluate the effectiveness of
the augmented tool, AdaTest++, we conduct user studies with participants
auditing two commercial language models: OpenAI's GPT-3 and Azure's sentiment
analysis model. Qualitative analysis shows that AdaTest++ effectively leverages
human strengths such as schematization, hypothesis formation and testing.
Further, with our tool, participants identified a variety of failures modes,
covering 26 different topics over 2 tasks, that have been shown before in
formal audits and also those previously under-reported. | [
0.0507517457,
0.1054390818,
-0.041352503,
0.0329034664,
-0.0347912051,
0.0117352884,
0.0120957522,
-0.0055693248,
0.0373318717,
-0.027379727,
0.0031833367,
0.0121933175,
0.000559586,
0.0577342845,
0.0302454922,
-0.0114604337,
0.0169621035,
-0.013233399,
0.0092275934,
0.0267569888,
0.0314990059,
0.0344644561,
0.0076757278,
0.0614413731,
-0.033016149,
-0.0037761235,
-0.0263269991,
-0.02183716,
0.0347942561,
-0.0218696985,
-0.0008869087,
0.0462252013,
-0.000231263,
0.0564633273,
0.0000021767,
-0.0461126342,
0.0231568515,
0.0231990125,
0.0082496731,
-0.0094085988,
0.0568392985,
-0.0130430507,
-0.0093939295,
0.0290207211,
-0.0642983541,
0.0269396398,
0.043919567,
0.0074722646,
0.0454212129,
0.0332723558,
-0.0166600756,
-0.0145307239,
0.0492197797,
-0.0087332167,
-0.0079236552,
-0.0444099307,
0.0079326993,
0.0163804553,
0.0342378952,
-0.0279974025,
0.010142222,
-0.0012935371,
0.0447226353,
-0.0360664278,
0.0035542129,
-0.0080845701,
0.0026577942,
-0.0574207306,
0.0005323556,
0.0607152507,
0.0421191938,
0.0018852793,
0.0133448895,
-0.0119639719,
0.0123610767,
0.0146702882,
-0.0082105026,
0.041557461,
-0.0402879044,
-0.0054414305,
0.0007118522,
0.0166625325,
0.0376169644,
0.0308687706,
0.0207804888,
0.0472269841,
-0.0343400128,
-0.0243972708,
0.0077587329,
0.0401104912,
0.0230514109,
-0.045626346,
0.0047486108,
0.0169424806,
-0.0530017987,
0.0167278163,
-0.0037565685,
-0.0143467421,
0.0535114557,
-0.0540435575,
0.0409095846,
0.0109799989,
-0.0184785482,
0.007754405,
0.0327946618,
0.0440962575,
0.0218284316,
0.0489056408,
-0.025448136,
0.0023047531,
-0.0365205072,
-0.0156635754,
0.0032352956,
0.0014507126,
-0.0145647489,
0.0192704499,
-0.0425319113,
0.0278894771,
-0.0855450779,
0.0411039889,
-0.0213577524,
0.0153972721,
0.0147292381,
-0.0003287627,
-0.0552216731,
-0.0457179509,
-0.0441508032,
0.0442144014,
0.0044495957,
-0.0584094934,
0.0152375754,
0.0454617031,
-0.06190864,
0.0159313846,
-0.0214323588,
0.0626024902,
0.0367386192,
0.0006866527,
-0.0342463404,
-0.0695633143,
-0.0109237153,
-0.032850381,
-0.021550091,
-0.0560442694,
-0.0013194459,
-0.0120831477,
-0.0167751964,
-0.0734428912,
-0.0008297091,
0.0177244432,
-0.0290965177,
0.0579259731,
-0.0616155118,
0.0141916461,
0.0035833663,
0.0534932353,
0.0082149068,
0.0509631298,
0.0426770076,
0.0404903032,
0.0397300757,
0.0299694892,
0.0588593669,
-0.0024307678,
-0.0009814816,
-0.0012325217,
-0.0504043251,
0.0042778687,
-0.0715170801,
0.0154936416,
0.0085691521,
0.0662987456,
-0.014008428,
0.0149811693,
0.0439659618,
0.0734934658,
-0.0167299416,
0.0182260796,
0.0351149254,
-0.0309228376,
-0.0174215026,
-0.0295459908,
-0.0138530731,
0.0029793838,
-0.0202475265,
-0.0437864326,
-0.0126821203,
0.0135009754,
-0.0138920005,
-0.067503497,
-0.0185308754,
-0.012765686,
0.0425453447,
0.019463975,
0.004873361,
0.0149705401,
-0.004514901,
-0.0515265651,
0.0133541664,
-0.0776935294,
-0.0010473374,
-0.1092338562,
0.0911794007,
0.1220609322,
0.0521058068,
-0.016324196,
0.0174049269,
-0.0070895753,
-0.011849761,
0.020160066,
0.0472994596,
-0.0290713888,
-0.0452118814,
-0.024420863,
-0.0375674665,
-0.0052016019,
0.0212390721,
0.0052753831,
-0.0148200421,
0.00197749,
0.007957615,
-0.0646772236,
-0.0770306513,
0.028139567,
-0.0265491996,
0.0190485399,
-0.0433366969,
0.0102736764,
0.0283861663,
0.0416456386,
-0.0158732403,
0.0271654706,
0.0354530737,
-0.0156338457,
-0.0441317111,
0.0580585971,
0.0068824701,
0.0614936501,
-0.0080829663,
-0.051531028,
-0.0137270158,
0.0383450724,
-0.025824558,
0.0033010948,
0.0277695544,
-0.0133178085,
-0.0056208917,
-0.0597878285,
-0.0169671979,
-0.0245367512,
-0.0121490937,
-0.0314155817,
0.044336196,
-0.0241648555,
-0.0471083187,
-0.0583860986,
0.0077584186,
0.0158300381,
-0.0007791648,
-0.0143016391,
0.0637891665,
0.0028145129,
0.0521553494,
0.0452611856,
0.0252426416,
-0.0422489233,
-0.0230178051,
-0.1126117632,
-0.0298732519,
-0.022124093,
0.0109479381,
-0.0078977561,
-0.0130853308,
-0.0114479959,
0.0130070951,
-0.0304286145,
-0.0072141094,
0.0209362302,
0.0262256823,
0.0340984389,
-0.0051805852,
-0.0234811436,
-0.0063713687,
0.020739818,
-0.0380147547,
0.0412990898,
0.0650091618,
0.0117913755,
-0.0589783117,
0.0055928389,
-0.0370233022,
-0.0216564611,
0.0099851796,
-0.0295979585,
0.0457620956,
0.0203800313,
0.0053495336,
0.0383348204,
0.0109581985,
0.1012152955,
0.0316676795,
0.0016166632,
-0.027922187,
-0.0118369944,
0.0366247296,
-0.0022046124,
0.0195019618,
-0.0276117325,
0.0115055935,
0.0371885113,
0.0162161067,
0.0012971482,
-0.0455733351,
0.0685815513,
-0.0593121573,
-0.0385069884,
-0.0233659931,
-0.0928653181,
-0.0249255411,
0.0594518371,
-0.0029703137,
-0.0589356385,
0.0632800609,
0.0018063618,
0.04566475,
-0.026919486,
-0.0353305303,
-0.031324096,
0.0787869692,
-0.035863407,
0.0289794058,
-0.0162373558,
0.0125156669,
-0.0031444519,
-0.0361851826,
0.0320489034,
-0.0326328315,
0.0047924141,
-0.074802801,
0.0099052535,
0.0116192736,
-0.0420986377,
-0.0474894717,
-0.0114540244,
-0.0740717128,
0.0211709701,
0.0056018932,
-0.0179101862,
-0.0063999658,
0.0059087644,
0.0161601994,
0.0059741312,
0.0299650207,
-0.0264068451,
-0.0125581985,
-0.0331129543,
0.0225927886,
-0.0150068728,
0.0546633862,
-0.0371595323,
0.0147911329,
0.0682014003,
0.0335032009,
0.0020902781,
-0.0430248827,
-0.0027265095,
-0.0073720496,
0.0150365029,
0.03622251,
0.0225456506,
0.044197239,
-0.039854642,
0.0049791327,
0.065529041,
0.0219136402,
-0.0609979108,
0.0326384306,
-0.0205473285,
-0.0140650719,
0.0042135576,
0.0105113573,
-0.1057942957,
-0.0204644483,
0.0066038934,
0.0611807257,
-0.0441424064,
-0.0578785427,
0.0253119729,
-0.0904046744,
0.0541359372,
-0.0018099066,
-0.0110013373,
-0.0511460453,
-0.0208258703,
-0.0135078132,
-0.0178812109,
0.0458466783,
-0.0153361978,
0.0396006294,
-0.0006783996,
0.0238749925,
-0.0331288278,
-0.0209806673,
0.0369286872,
-0.0574131198,
0.0787300617,
0.1115979403,
0.0478178039,
-0.0070358478,
-0.0412600301,
0.0270614047,
0.0300947856,
0.0280596856,
0.0148930671,
0.0065920302,
0.0079297293,
0.0053242124,
-0.029599309,
0.0300220735,
-0.0669731572,
-0.0350106172,
0.0331234075,
0.0626117215,
-0.0298941322,
-0.046397727,
-0.0377058014,
0.0100503219,
0.0209226776,
0.0521582067,
0.0273767747,
-0.0320828781,
-0.0151695246,
-0.0248844903,
0.0163192619,
-0.0529885143,
-0.0541249439,
-0.0003189441,
0.0389660485,
-0.0313996673,
-0.0708717406,
-0.0711647421,
-0.0053964476,
0.002619673,
0.0124602579,
-0.0599839129,
0.0189008676,
-0.0076050377,
-0.0059940866,
0.0288962387,
-0.0095460443,
0.0568162389,
-0.0247694794,
0.0002561961,
-0.0085532693,
-0.0034259255,
0.0089126555,
0.0649294183,
-0.0421646796,
-0.0483042002,
0.0205002781,
0.0500578992,
0.0294451509,
-0.0104750991,
-0.0313702784,
-0.0421138145,
-0.0126852132,
0.0695364475,
-0.0364222005,
0.0048013255,
0.0175233874,
-0.0003313794,
0.0036204325,
0.0148803769,
-0.0225197021,
0.0025360847,
0.0019018663,
0.0113698887,
-0.0356669053,
-0.0439605415,
0.0260621682,
0.010682445,
0.0052799764,
-0.0451292396,
-0.0104377158,
-0.0472696424,
-0.0270599704,
-0.0201542694,
-0.0304490943,
-0.0322663486,
0.0168329291,
-0.0146345189,
-0.036975611,
-0.0053996425,
0.0329941995,
-0.0569426641,
0.023523204,
-0.034566287,
0.0381024182,
0.008019994,
0.0648358986,
-0.0058569191,
-0.010704455,
0.0029744781,
0.0222488325,
-0.0393014848,
0.0456269644,
0.0198518373,
0.0373047218,
0.0047040973,
0.0172498133,
0.0236410759,
0.0376395918,
-0.0196633842,
-0.0658334419,
0.0087350244,
0.0263813492,
0.0221078061,
0.0390351638,
0.0023981801,
-0.0267113987,
0.0060328916,
0.0080987727,
0.0204586294,
-0.0173844974,
-0.0244349632,
-0.0111844046,
0.0210805237,
-0.0455322675,
-0.035612762,
0.0716085956,
-0.0252290834,
0.0360885374,
-0.0437547415,
-0.0470311902,
-0.0171230473,
-0.0334561728,
0.0359189287,
-0.0168994572,
-0.0409591086,
-0.0353995152,
-0.1136733368,
-0.0674287155,
-0.0071964613,
0.0358757675,
0.0179117173,
0.0009139335,
0.0004777739,
0.0778602511,
0.0046866252,
0.0142355394,
-0.0351800285,
-0.0185042657,
-0.0442717224,
-0.0136743486,
-0.0139263133,
-6.166588263e-33,
0.0082175061,
-0.0961635709,
0.0128338588,
-0.0220043398,
0.0085076708,
-0.0313247703,
-0.0369861312,
0.0331237949,
-0.0032448536,
0.0515516475,
0.0104757855,
0.02137818,
-0.0006062127,
-0.0214663856,
0.0382311903,
-0.0052929409,
0.0233182181,
0.0065505393,
-0.0087421434,
0.0461813174,
0.0153018199,
-0.0234685671,
0.0005101323,
-0.1023128703,
0.0831252038,
0.0138641438,
-0.0576473586,
0.0162443575,
-0.0399949588,
0.0476401746,
0.0011878444,
0.064077571,
0.0267709754,
0.0306866039,
-0.0002754488,
0.017668236,
-0.0011176103,
-0.0155426301,
0.0274117235,
-0.0230676644,
-0.043925669,
-0.0574305989,
0.0428977944,
-0.0049155666,
-0.0506478995,
0.0488476455,
0.0369136371,
-0.0106694708,
0.0081554726,
-0.0419009738,
-0.0545896888,
0.0145124197,
-0.0384074487,
-0.0141133759,
-0.0307481047,
0.0248691831,
0.0057918485,
-0.0144042959,
-0.0560363978,
0.0214919671,
0.0120869614,
-0.0805294439,
0.0695821792,
-0.0259101763,
-0.0321750082,
0.07320223,
0.0267793722,
0.0451716781,
-0.0469863154,
-0.0074210395,
0.0165500287,
0.0610385537,
0.0485524908,
0.0858882442,
-0.0395624153,
-0.0634646714,
-0.0411430299,
0.052375976,
0.0111748548,
0.0215730462,
0.0507329777,
-0.006918868,
-0.0801524296,
-0.0208188444,
-0.0055229696,
-0.0350552648,
-0.0472283289,
-0.003430411,
0.0179782212,
0.014239097,
-0.0273764357,
-0.0152160274,
-0.0162766073,
-0.0621074177,
0.0408928283,
0.0128565878,
-0.0197600592,
-0.0340995863,
-0.0008941596,
-0.0060944925,
-0.0409534946,
-0.0019277462,
-0.0183375888,
0.0497284457,
0.0480293706,
-0.009231938,
0.0353532173,
0.0163174774,
-0.0109408945,
0.0105903707,
-0.0237172805,
0.0553377457,
0.0244988874,
-0.037808761,
0.01257932,
0.0146540329,
-0.0109815281,
0.022969041,
0.0132434834,
0.0230887588,
-0.0498502627,
0.0316087157,
-0.0375697874,
-0.0089051295,
-0.0295702927,
-0.0465962775,
-0.029851133,
0.0047332924,
0.0940520093,
-0.0321387164,
-0.0279319342,
-0.0104288813,
2.875e-7,
0.0130616333,
0.0232551675,
-0.0053767823,
-0.0287884437,
0.0127842929,
0.0561967827,
0.0242161378,
0.0456528217,
-0.0149145713,
0.000877508,
0.0272047464,
0.0307897646,
0.0706314072,
0.0613580123,
-0.0273477398,
0.0199916232,
-0.0558597818,
0.0083571821,
-0.0576268621,
0.0328292176,
0.0587718263,
0.0143022342,
0.0132385315,
-0.027363006,
0.0024195458,
-0.042733714,
0.0152098546,
-0.0298627503,
-0.0117102209,
-0.0203143284,
0.0405979417,
0.0149721643,
0.0363725387,
0.0255032033,
0.002109627,
-0.0329192653,
-0.020291958,
0.0438771211,
-0.0146900071,
-0.0152609907,
-0.0296006072,
-0.0363765322,
0.0363264084,
-0.0495183766,
0.0353098027,
-0.007843053,
-0.0283407569,
-0.0385400318,
0.0325548761,
-0.0413537882,
0.0212487783,
-0.0131354565,
-0.0078048068,
0.0326609462,
0.0008989525,
-0.0068508857,
0.005856365,
-0.0164765473,
0.0084247189,
-0.0162344798,
-0.0362279639,
-0.0637935922,
0.0003565442,
0.0239739232,
-0.0150007382,
-0.0353477784,
0.0471571684,
2.420824775e-34,
0.0264116675,
-0.0018007789,
-0.0195458606,
-0.0079759704,
0.0864393935,
0.051729653,
-0.0277992953,
0.0115398625,
0.0345980003,
0.0040291813,
-0.0146547388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09982v1 | Radar de Parité: An NLP system to measure gender representation in French news stories | 2023-04-19T21:33:59 | 2023-04-19T21:33:59 | Valentin-Gabriel Soumah, Prashanth Rao, Philipp Eibl, Maite Taboada | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Radar de Parit\'e, an automated Natural Language Processing
(NLP) system that measures the proportion of women and men quoted daily in six
Canadian French-language media outlets. We outline the system's architecture
and detail the challenges we overcame to address French-specific issues, in
particular regarding coreference resolution, a new contribution to the NLP
literature on French. We also showcase statistics covering over one year's
worth of data (282,512 news articles). Our results highlight the
underrepresentation of women in news stories, while also illustrating the
application of modern NLP methods to measure gender representation and address
societal issues. | [
0.0328466706,
0.0797109455,
-0.0175971799,
-0.0120879235,
-0.0513554104,
-0.0056696287,
0.0154467709,
-0.0686235055,
0.0109288227,
-0.0806652829,
0.0521663763,
0.0060766418,
-0.0110079609,
0.018393375,
0.0069410792,
0.0003059718,
0.0299433731,
0.0419714823,
0.0302300863,
-0.0110506667,
0.0482182875,
0.0862170234,
-0.0154909994,
0.065778695,
0.0118686501,
-0.0091555696,
0.0270878412,
0.0137551809,
-0.0082459338,
0.0094216596,
-0.0079120491,
0.026212072,
-0.0219183434,
-0.007476463,
0.0000015227,
-0.0643781871,
-0.0200045779,
0.02555779,
0.0217733327,
-0.0150245456,
0.0401319563,
-0.0350186303,
-0.0295913387,
0.0220652092,
0.0065698386,
-0.0092847571,
0.0246271081,
0.0237390641,
0.0471428521,
0.0248477589,
-0.0106227966,
0.0060537308,
-0.0721136108,
0.0038180684,
-0.0452893265,
0.0030374459,
0.0240758434,
-0.0420277975,
-0.0137658818,
-0.0203259829,
-0.0047241645,
0.0343888029,
-0.0284951739,
-0.0422893502,
-0.0240827445,
0.0066807554,
-0.0719897449,
-0.056213405,
0.0067298282,
0.0035882946,
0.0344588831,
-0.000652079,
0.0235137101,
0.0112576541,
-0.0105088754,
0.0359248221,
-0.0571185611,
0.0076044188,
-0.0065519745,
0.00167884,
0.008646125,
-0.0313025787,
-0.0114093823,
0.0011897145,
-0.0221404713,
0.0704397708,
-0.0029861992,
-0.0058736349,
0.0493555926,
0.0037558018,
-0.0167925414,
-0.0316635221,
0.0527791381,
-0.0219225436,
0.0122918896,
0.0191774182,
0.0258528478,
0.0170012098,
0.0310245603,
-0.0706756487,
-0.0582170971,
0.0174949113,
0.0105284946,
0.0164523162,
0.0062796017,
-0.0052487394,
0.0325747207,
-0.0351331793,
-0.0162592661,
-0.0550845191,
-0.0858743638,
0.0016937315,
-0.0301373806,
0.0067100581,
-0.027205307,
0.0128504317,
-0.0382662378,
-0.032204777,
-0.0257356931,
0.0296913423,
0.0344881713,
0.0147645753,
0.0233884621,
0.0488833226,
0.0021677751,
0.0637376681,
-0.0409566388,
0.0026672154,
-0.0579894967,
-0.0670438185,
0.0331549235,
0.0007973702,
-0.0081792688,
-0.0258397851,
-0.011840459,
0.0232668519,
-0.0004175801,
0.0042017503,
0.0019327801,
-0.0406331755,
-0.0252102762,
-0.0502091125,
-0.0122659951,
-0.0995946899,
0.0112061528,
0.0537143163,
0.0350030176,
-0.0560070686,
0.0233345106,
0.0244226921,
-0.0606601648,
0.0369137302,
0.0666659102,
0.0082037011,
0.0615846924,
-0.0031730013,
0.0063481028,
0.1086587608,
0.0458303131,
-0.0389334783,
0.0507844612,
0.0168489274,
-0.0413580462,
0.038979806,
0.0242565181,
0.0363046899,
-0.0163143761,
0.0097723035,
-0.0571892671,
0.0123168202,
0.0637198016,
0.0272999331,
0.0360821895,
0.0037125878,
0.0169697795,
0.0959205925,
-0.0121145369,
0.0415117741,
0.0204283241,
0.0267707035,
-0.007819646,
0.0171710812,
-0.0348988213,
-0.0248246938,
0.0167864393,
-0.0416993424,
-0.0276146345,
0.0341665186,
0.0010795624,
-0.0253925584,
-0.0167079549,
0.0561923161,
0.0320570245,
0.0033847317,
0.0110200457,
0.0177625921,
0.0146153932,
0.0103340484,
0.0259031691,
-0.0413026325,
-0.0012129268,
0.0065980554,
-0.0317084864,
0.0049763536,
-0.0135573559,
-0.0118578514,
0.0013285136,
-0.036101155,
-0.0121886553,
0.0230284929,
-0.002898508,
0.0043829489,
-0.0094520021,
0.0071365526,
-0.0035109771,
0.0317476504,
0.0348177664,
0.0127422297,
0.0104925623,
0.0703341439,
-0.0092694359,
-0.0137711158,
-0.0688937828,
0.0137803983,
0.0152067002,
-0.0067497566,
-0.0035719338,
0.0076129702,
-0.0273526311,
0.0510753989,
-0.0212754849,
0.0080352966,
0.0208049566,
-0.0094665932,
-0.0022670622,
0.0450292006,
0.0335242786,
-0.0162304435,
0.0012716883,
-0.1090359837,
-0.0827902183,
0.0007173418,
-0.0003193817,
-0.0087526096,
0.0796059743,
-0.0342184268,
0.0048934086,
-0.0196301825,
-0.0008403345,
0.0279930625,
-0.0203929804,
-0.0274397787,
0.0471895076,
-0.0190430284,
0.0225637425,
0.0209056698,
-0.0621423163,
0.0003209859,
-0.0600135028,
-0.0201900303,
0.0039228499,
0.0138918301,
0.0057305312,
0.0630411506,
-0.0198858511,
-0.0129567869,
-0.0298987012,
-0.004741149,
0.0061095208,
-0.0143314824,
0.0180922747,
0.0035914865,
0.0153157273,
-0.0235324409,
-0.0047780378,
-0.0010045436,
-0.0521786511,
0.0189349391,
0.007072011,
0.0408874005,
0.0233561285,
-0.0141955959,
-0.0190875046,
0.0028665289,
-0.0561854765,
0.0730852857,
0.0418924317,
-0.0107120648,
-0.0121149067,
0.0279348213,
-0.0057792081,
0.019541895,
-0.0021721723,
-0.0117768245,
0.0185145829,
0.0120828385,
-0.0192587283,
0.08101926,
0.0039350935,
0.043403931,
0.0088955425,
-0.0181697123,
-0.0397575274,
-0.0101883486,
0.0072541181,
-0.0086425962,
-0.0297256168,
-0.0811714604,
0.0412788726,
0.0027819704,
-0.0039940518,
-0.0322284587,
0.0231709685,
0.0616901703,
-0.0371692106,
-0.0176531933,
-0.0213668905,
0.0113492263,
0.0193347409,
0.0501449592,
-0.0022236179,
0.0430807136,
0.0091783758,
-0.0028104677,
0.0344332308,
-0.0512112044,
-0.0480435789,
-0.0431033522,
0.0446946099,
-0.002420414,
0.0368123762,
0.0595240705,
-0.0668971837,
-0.0547269173,
-0.0637615621,
0.0414980128,
0.0059110937,
0.0577586181,
-0.0299253799,
0.0211168844,
0.0174133573,
-0.0344111584,
-0.0385204144,
-0.0098178564,
-0.0271048695,
0.0029397681,
0.0189653728,
-0.0066961949,
-0.0598171726,
0.0343390517,
0.0111902291,
0.0139508471,
0.0161552988,
-0.0074542966,
0.0048789363,
0.0147580933,
0.0217977632,
0.0015458143,
0.0297471248,
-0.0096178986,
-0.0131979119,
0.0309873503,
0.0036868623,
0.0400260538,
0.0055484511,
-0.0006475665,
0.0212961212,
-0.1026643589,
-0.0439406745,
-0.0531420708,
0.0298804846,
-0.0546420626,
-0.015879903,
0.1115402877,
0.026126435,
-0.0327642523,
0.001214762,
0.0447519794,
-0.0151592698,
0.0621748269,
0.008730772,
-0.0329595022,
0.0258281864,
0.0105494382,
-0.0126648815,
-0.0399614833,
-0.0324980356,
-0.0348350033,
-0.0992262587,
0.006872233,
-0.0333038643,
-0.0476583391,
-0.0220796485,
-0.0336789079,
-0.0122000054,
-0.0584157817,
-0.0022527247,
-0.0193015635,
-0.0316709429,
0.0317064561,
-0.0096995793,
-0.0921085551,
-0.0271652471,
-0.0057720584,
-0.0822352096,
0.010683733,
0.0269628298,
0.0779672787,
-0.0328955799,
0.0453211591,
-0.0206062626,
-0.0093799364,
-0.008831366,
-0.0126402657,
0.0021553016,
-0.0349248275,
-0.0177123193,
-0.0405249707,
0.0239730086,
0.065810822,
0.0269047003,
0.042444814,
0.0093905125,
0.003167955,
0.0643981621,
-0.0301478375,
0.0281089973,
0.0234315358,
0.0461745188,
0.0444100834,
0.0146576976,
-0.0377900042,
-0.0545438193,
-0.0096849641,
-0.0362967476,
-0.1036608368,
0.023708785,
-0.0204925779,
-0.0378884897,
-0.0163262617,
-0.0353880823,
0.0546349026,
0.0176695697,
-0.0028881198,
-0.0285293534,
0.0706437603,
0.0332170613,
-0.0857778788,
-0.009059567,
0.0027326914,
-0.028138157,
0.0156167392,
-0.0253533069,
0.0215041377,
0.0203331355,
-0.0350289866,
0.03965782,
-0.0385795459,
-0.0187532268,
0.0140888821,
-0.0437036082,
0.0273107626,
0.0106077706,
-0.0014989383,
-0.0125460383,
0.0130514558,
0.0574890152,
-0.0355808102,
0.0025623685,
-0.017888099,
0.0294277091,
-0.0035681601,
0.0255150683,
-0.0238419697,
0.0148781687,
-0.047247123,
0.0126046473,
-0.0360790528,
-0.0123263421,
0.0086853569,
0.0010497023,
-0.0180880539,
-0.0384149365,
0.0268585272,
-0.0411414094,
-0.0143018961,
-0.0247340295,
-0.018166434,
-0.0064889034,
-0.004784544,
-0.0182509031,
0.0278170705,
-0.0379821435,
-0.0059820269,
-0.0303941667,
0.0517425537,
-0.0602285489,
0.0413597561,
0.0383261852,
-0.0081896801,
-0.0254029389,
-0.0075733303,
0.0349267907,
-0.0232167132,
-0.010920207,
0.0468468554,
-0.0040878453,
-0.0240631029,
0.0349782519,
0.0292832013,
-0.0069859964,
-0.0189432912,
-0.0740868077,
-0.01998429,
0.0044385297,
0.0263693295,
0.0400905721,
-0.0507964604,
0.0659689754,
0.004574867,
-0.0212389305,
0.0179353543,
0.017940443,
-0.0058041546,
0.0171355605,
-0.015089795,
-0.0010608837,
0.0033438702,
-0.0307670217,
0.0285973046,
0.056001287,
0.013740452,
0.0574054345,
-0.0731780529,
-0.0230915099,
-0.0344524942,
0.0203303639,
-0.0339659937,
-0.0011460651,
-0.0175015293,
-0.0786797032,
-0.0228970312,
0.0215643048,
-0.0369985402,
0.0187832937,
0.006120909,
-0.0237571076,
0.0297110491,
0.0278593209,
-0.0438721851,
-0.0651529878,
0.0372953638,
-0.0559645481,
-0.0346514322,
0.0122825038,
-5.721371614e-33,
-0.0544702373,
-0.0515629761,
-0.0274007972,
0.0465696193,
-0.0050628083,
0.0246944912,
0.0037354219,
-0.0171024278,
-0.0036463907,
0.0347314551,
0.0170519073,
0.0399298854,
0.020290684,
0.006849593,
0.0311539993,
0.0029181868,
0.0706999078,
0.0374252275,
-0.0248940233,
-0.054615818,
0.0006468254,
0.0514294095,
0.0668585524,
-0.0881143659,
0.0893027112,
0.0046055173,
-0.0289758798,
-0.0225082394,
0.0458131991,
0.0354049616,
0.0157293975,
0.0513796322,
-0.0084575834,
-0.0667519793,
0.0276803114,
0.0551238656,
-0.1152812541,
-0.0545393601,
0.0414512679,
0.0692975819,
0.0629493594,
0.0333543532,
0.0581248701,
0.0243462697,
-0.0410799831,
0.0038849239,
0.0888520405,
0.0017128513,
0.0699958429,
0.0148054939,
-0.0401626825,
0.0076153516,
-0.0412328243,
0.0504663475,
0.0121877659,
0.0321341082,
-0.003505311,
-0.0097853281,
-0.0912499875,
-0.0051798848,
-0.0416335464,
0.0335678905,
0.0125999721,
-0.0443181209,
0.0196768455,
0.0245779734,
0.0618868805,
-0.0307428688,
-0.0209773779,
-0.0006309694,
0.0625730678,
-0.0416111387,
-0.003046796,
0.0871549621,
0.0326308422,
0.0405124165,
-0.0942084566,
-0.0167698413,
0.0636497885,
0.0228859335,
0.0141612506,
-0.0255503375,
-0.0478855856,
-0.0416576006,
-0.0494243577,
-0.035198193,
-0.0113302553,
-0.0263287351,
-0.008566699,
-0.0109512219,
-0.0313658677,
0.0763858259,
-0.0039961794,
-0.0481420308,
-0.0579431131,
-0.0310555883,
0.010984078,
-0.0251519307,
0.0039264569,
0.0336208194,
-0.0546577089,
0.0385442041,
0.0058594793,
0.037745066,
0.0400236845,
-0.0085720345,
0.005411142,
0.017067086,
-0.0807655305,
-0.0201295149,
-0.0003854394,
0.0341217034,
-0.0569252707,
0.0693245828,
0.0044364738,
0.0137407836,
0.0044737225,
-0.0062459414,
0.0315591805,
0.0033969847,
-0.0199461989,
-0.0328327566,
-0.0065766545,
0.0154472087,
-0.0525009148,
-0.028538188,
0.0150562674,
0.0169372614,
0.034671355,
-0.0257787015,
-0.0207253639,
-0.0543042719,
2.233e-7,
0.0690780059,
0.0387040675,
0.0265075397,
0.0413598381,
-0.0080396049,
-0.0079197967,
0.016729081,
0.0454364792,
0.0378491729,
-0.0625695884,
-0.0357735865,
0.0246209856,
-0.0303255413,
0.0711349621,
-0.093042545,
0.0177852158,
-0.0224460848,
-0.0153431902,
-0.0028807279,
0.0425248407,
-0.0156807359,
0.0443846397,
0.0336923413,
0.0176316723,
-0.0519465096,
0.0032246837,
-0.0017473632,
0.0320723876,
-0.0448853336,
0.0105842911,
0.0088573741,
0.0410713032,
0.0072021657,
0.0078454372,
0.004070478,
0.0064483369,
0.0279741809,
-0.0003880674,
-0.0208112169,
0.015611087,
-0.0108819595,
-0.0415211543,
-0.0055398918,
-0.0073507344,
0.0387557261,
-0.0153813083,
-0.0173925422,
-0.0810922682,
-0.030205505,
-0.0182287265,
0.068153128,
-0.0010263019,
-0.0163524952,
0.0321251601,
0.006892933,
0.0186995473,
0.0088564577,
-0.053403046,
-0.0095443111,
-0.002297923,
0.0308760908,
-0.0215200074,
0.0545938686,
0.0074896398,
-0.0246036239,
-0.033846572,
0.0205277465,
1.952221299e-34,
0.0198775642,
0.0757443607,
-0.0342734195,
0.0295377113,
0.0385322571,
-0.0079487376,
-0.0425314866,
0.002912472,
0.02999264,
0.0606528483,
0.002438023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09972v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09972v2 | MasakhaNEWS: News Topic Classification for African languages | 2023-04-19T21:12:23 | 2023-09-20T17:14:40 | David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Marek Masiak, Israel Abebe Azime, Jesujoba Alabi, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Christine Mwase, Odunayo Ogundepo, Bonaventure F. P. Dossou, Akintunde Oladipo, Doreen Nixdorf, Chris Chinenye Emezue, sana al-azzawi, Blessing Sibanda, Davis David, Lolwethu Ndolela, Jonathan Mukiibi, Tunde Ajayi, Tatiana Moteu, Brian Odhiambo, Abraham Owodunni, Nnaemeka Obiefuna, Muhidin Mohamed, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Teshome Mulugeta Ababu, Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Mesay Gemeda Yigezu, Tajuddeen Gwadabe, Idris Abdulmumin, Mahlet Taye, Oluwabusayo Awoyomi, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Tolulope Adelani, Habiba Abdulganiyu, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Adetola Adeeko, Abeeb Afolabi, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Olanrewaju Samuel, Clemencia Siro, Wangari Kimotho, Onyekachi Ogbu, Chinedu Mbonu, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Samuel Fanijo, Jessica Ojo, Oyinkansola Awosan, Tadesse Kebede, Toadoum Sari Sakayo, Pamela Nyatsine, Freedmore Sidume, Oreen Yousuf, Mardiyyah Oduwole, Tshinu Tshinu, Ussen Kimanuka, Thina Diko, Siyanda Nxakama, Sinodos Nigusse, Abdulmejid Johar, Shafie Mohamed, Fuad Mire Hassan, Moges Ahmed Mehamed, Evrard Ngabire, Jules Jules, Ivan Ssenkungu, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL | African languages are severely under-represented in NLP research due to lack
of datasets covering several NLP tasks. While there are individual language
specific datasets that are being expanded to different tasks, only a handful of
NLP tasks (e.g. named entity recognition and machine translation) have
standardized benchmark datasets covering several geographical and
typologically-diverse African languages. In this paper, we develop MasakhaNEWS
-- a new benchmark dataset for news topic classification covering 16 languages
widely spoken in Africa. We provide an evaluation of baseline models by
training classical machine learning models and fine-tuning several language
models. Furthermore, we explore several alternatives to full fine-tuning of
language models that are better suited for zero-shot and few-shot learning such
as cross-lingual parameter-efficient fine-tuning (like MAD-X), pattern
exploiting training (PET), prompting language models (like ChatGPT), and
prompt-free sentence transformer fine-tuning (SetFit and Cohere Embedding API).
Our evaluation in zero-shot setting shows the potential of prompting ChatGPT
for news topic classification in low-resource African languages, achieving an
average performance of 70 F1 points without leveraging additional supervision
like MAD-X. In few-shot setting, we show that with as little as 10 examples per
label, we achieved more than 90\% (i.e. 86.0 F1 points) of the performance of
full supervised training (92.6 F1 points) leveraging the PET approach. | [
0.0699030906,
0.0340775438,
0.0280964542,
0.0487130508,
-0.0184481312,
0.0657223463,
0.0248928182,
-0.0082386555,
0.0128241135,
-0.0727801025,
-0.0430027544,
-0.0465154275,
0.0113554653,
0.005892002,
0.0123196905,
-0.0529042073,
0.0365343392,
0.0001186817,
0.0221113749,
0.0188845266,
-0.0126821911,
0.044427976,
0.0102535617,
0.0221432112,
-0.0031451001,
-0.0030470828,
-0.0255631637,
-0.0028405285,
0.0077150194,
-0.0191964153,
-0.0034299844,
0.0591693111,
-0.0191024318,
0.0275065284,
0.0000019135,
-0.0663087294,
-0.0240101516,
-0.0152125442,
-0.0138480011,
0.0348414294,
0.0235238094,
-0.0621563829,
-0.0116026523,
0.0281491783,
-0.0177062023,
-0.0362914875,
0.0580670498,
0.0581065789,
0.0452913493,
0.1237901598,
-0.0103413463,
0.0125310468,
0.06474635,
-0.0446200222,
0.0045957235,
-0.0329655819,
0.0157737769,
-0.0399074517,
-0.0012553432,
0.0707102716,
-0.0046590236,
-0.0032709737,
0.0137520703,
0.0091244681,
-0.0115747694,
0.0122589879,
-0.0703018755,
-0.0559228472,
-0.0298496988,
0.0297834221,
-0.0349652842,
-0.0217276588,
0.0039712265,
0.0037511834,
-0.0223169029,
0.002802667,
-0.0464098603,
0.020991778,
-0.000882618,
0.0347980037,
0.0788179487,
0.0170012526,
0.0435037985,
0.0282323658,
-0.0011940604,
0.0087094419,
0.0161803309,
-0.0074752206,
0.0186683349,
0.0405867435,
-0.0307576116,
-0.0419064537,
-0.0185768157,
-0.0234001037,
-0.010447327,
-0.0241354629,
0.0073674615,
0.0003215357,
0.0378287286,
-0.0626029596,
-0.0139576802,
0.0303859115,
-0.0474916883,
0.0405996963,
-0.028138971,
-0.0354348905,
0.0105136465,
0.016952686,
0.0148653015,
-0.009200234,
-0.0633945316,
-0.0109857926,
-0.0311929826,
0.0177174192,
-0.0418958925,
0.0145508889,
-0.0458472595,
0.0113944886,
0.0238409285,
-0.0140640056,
-0.002580157,
-0.030414125,
-0.0180311818,
-0.0097100483,
0.0374401584,
0.0309823938,
-0.0356737077,
0.0049720658,
-0.0086738709,
-0.077741228,
0.0083795646,
-0.0312090293,
-0.0132425781,
0.0051136138,
0.0317492187,
0.0426039025,
-0.0335066952,
-0.1015288606,
-0.0923691392,
0.0202648155,
-0.0112127839,
-0.0298114009,
-0.0366348065,
-0.0743611529,
0.0115876282,
0.0209903978,
0.0567442439,
0.0264536366,
0.0045492342,
0.0071380525,
-0.016469121,
0.0698486492,
0.0228981283,
-0.0212917849,
0.0773600042,
0.0306315571,
0.0575841106,
0.1308126748,
0.0044031492,
0.0197386853,
0.0546222813,
0.0136563862,
-0.0335580893,
0.0097427517,
-0.0085059125,
0.019173203,
0.0168098118,
0.0194588602,
0.022337921,
0.0055633518,
-0.004892312,
0.0065321145,
0.0023367682,
0.0032412205,
0.0235471204,
0.0332316272,
-0.0006292893,
0.0295209233,
0.0155858882,
0.0147708366,
-0.001638221,
-0.0228242837,
0.0189930294,
-0.0124792196,
-0.0114922868,
-0.0318567231,
0.0530443117,
0.0676940307,
-0.052312661,
-0.018264601,
0.0081087863,
-0.0253775418,
-0.0109390868,
0.0098245703,
0.0540908352,
0.0051294998,
-0.0004627802,
0.0197392646,
0.079696238,
-0.021109188,
-0.0206521191,
-0.0462915003,
0.022428805,
-0.0048956024,
0.0195845291,
-0.001296174,
-0.0082774172,
-0.0312421527,
0.0544805527,
0.0342956223,
0.0563035272,
-0.0196531527,
0.0527009293,
-0.0260193497,
0.0221330617,
-0.009243832,
0.0223938655,
0.0189665239,
0.0415327698,
0.079083629,
0.0170515459,
-0.025425816,
-0.0190106817,
0.0338927284,
-0.0358310454,
-0.0138261188,
0.0409821123,
0.0228255466,
0.0230605509,
0.0301787015,
0.0105583016,
-0.0170190409,
-0.0188081898,
-0.0517813079,
0.0077420678,
0.0048286612,
-0.0289551616,
-0.0414211638,
-0.0059768283,
-0.0246963538,
0.0077715912,
0.0410496406,
-0.0114152683,
-0.0292006154,
0.0127998199,
0.020932816,
0.0142728277,
-0.0432187803,
0.0227704104,
-0.0341479704,
0.0207261425,
-0.034772262,
0.0375812203,
0.0315981023,
0.0174846575,
0.0086510656,
-0.0131341936,
0.0572026409,
0.021331016,
-0.015092819,
0.0482894629,
-0.0186772663,
-0.0183274299,
0.0138403671,
0.0315129645,
-0.0479560196,
-0.0369705446,
-0.128367573,
0.0464486219,
-0.0455099754,
0.0242509544,
0.0061314129,
0.0852377638,
-0.0242325533,
-0.0049631293,
0.007153701,
-0.014433533,
-0.0093966546,
0.0152914487,
0.0010728124,
-0.0237935428,
0.0131524028,
-0.0261684023,
0.0113159455,
0.0158466808,
0.0608416647,
-0.0007459134,
-0.0200385861,
-0.0300777927,
0.0084912432,
0.0161311869,
-0.0342953019,
-0.002837542,
-0.0264928937,
-0.0090732854,
-0.0172026344,
-0.0207409561,
0.0364225358,
0.0036003781,
0.0431656092,
-0.0088711316,
0.0044982731,
-0.030381022,
-0.0029406396,
-0.0337595306,
-0.0129376929,
0.0000160462,
-0.0013443788,
0.0162629951,
0.0798680261,
0.000874023,
0.0063391095,
-0.0573029444,
-0.0164075661,
-0.0118858851,
-0.0026571141,
-0.0240854342,
0.0383509956,
0.0251520798,
0.0019237831,
-0.0296445079,
-0.031129444,
0.0697783083,
-0.0027720875,
-0.0039529684,
-0.0623629354,
-0.0161047559,
-0.0701909587,
0.0208362453,
-0.0269929916,
0.0053562759,
0.0176114738,
-0.0240778252,
-0.0096801212,
0.0144590829,
0.0146686686,
0.0066307257,
0.0102552455,
-0.0083617652,
0.0089347037,
-0.0186855253,
-0.0576507077,
-0.0073078228,
-0.0840908065,
-0.0158217065,
-0.0091938497,
0.0061461111,
-0.0017393967,
0.0086830193,
0.0332134739,
0.0230873041,
0.0155199235,
-0.0131628113,
-0.026648825,
0.015303975,
0.0545378737,
0.0345183648,
-0.0300245099,
-0.0281584896,
-0.0097869812,
0.0336248986,
0.0096161626,
-0.0108601656,
0.0183312763,
0.0053404062,
-0.0017362293,
0.0357989185,
-0.048633486,
-0.0324529,
-0.0070632533,
0.0438848361,
-0.0120775905,
-0.0036374535,
0.099977091,
0.0498303585,
-0.0295726545,
0.010575938,
-0.0354130231,
0.0405382961,
-0.0165619589,
0.0306997709,
-0.0943835452,
-0.0306959413,
-0.0063167168,
-0.0108178426,
-0.0157570392,
-0.0014512516,
-0.0075726761,
-0.0983648822,
0.0083298394,
0.0095278211,
-0.0454089604,
-0.0191674326,
-0.0684851408,
-0.0231890175,
-0.0267971903,
-0.0304829162,
-0.0266019497,
-0.013513186,
0.0010685857,
0.0416824184,
-0.0161925443,
-0.0982953906,
0.0141667435,
-0.0234076641,
0.0329211988,
0.0032969643,
-0.0197064634,
-0.0165840648,
0.02663045,
-0.0164556094,
-0.0309906732,
-0.0279758945,
-0.0432949364,
0.0219233986,
-0.0072967391,
-0.022693105,
0.0167883057,
0.0087388456,
-0.0228925906,
-0.0082115959,
-0.017980678,
0.0651943833,
-0.0129309027,
0.0085904878,
-0.0043141013,
-0.0356989242,
0.0288679879,
0.0487557091,
0.0373291895,
-0.054200884,
-0.017692551,
-0.004666876,
0.0257277023,
-0.032300733,
-0.0132935466,
0.0217380188,
-0.0140036158,
-0.0706758648,
-0.0340122916,
-0.0880675986,
0.0402123742,
0.0110492799,
-0.0014175157,
-0.0035878511,
-0.0020603416,
0.0004411736,
-0.0394648015,
0.0434947759,
-0.0079175932,
-0.0073624342,
-0.0487838984,
-0.0144589804,
0.0510207042,
-0.0172440317,
0.017682435,
-0.0265050828,
-0.1030266359,
-0.0630550086,
-0.006232128,
-0.0202144254,
0.0089424299,
0.0261882655,
0.00735904,
-0.0686821863,
0.013237413,
0.048179388,
-0.0077873403,
-0.0193633977,
0.023337787,
0.0217198674,
-0.0079554347,
0.0517205857,
0.0004264711,
0.0470578894,
0.0253902376,
0.0103188138,
-0.0668352917,
0.002982392,
-0.0355615802,
-0.0431092121,
0.0787228271,
-0.0601243824,
-0.0953151211,
-0.0721523389,
0.0039078384,
0.0325195491,
0.0155577809,
-0.031203378,
-0.0190211274,
0.028047327,
0.0011163921,
-0.0442441218,
0.0199136063,
-0.0172934812,
0.0155811533,
-0.0279177409,
0.032637585,
0.0248341598,
-0.0061387238,
-0.0058872276,
0.024317719,
-0.0033824916,
0.0095555028,
0.0228852071,
0.0210013837,
-0.054921221,
0.0260576587,
-0.0086189043,
0.020895835,
0.0190400407,
0.0172912609,
-0.0237393063,
0.0289281849,
-0.0381671749,
0.0585328564,
0.0936963707,
-0.0597893633,
0.0305604842,
0.0012565205,
-0.0330283195,
-0.0024309878,
0.0410531834,
-0.0226349961,
-0.0333730765,
0.0063162125,
0.0031202044,
-0.0376457721,
0.0544822179,
0.0577554107,
0.0039186729,
0.0176028591,
0.072734721,
0.0126182614,
-0.0287202857,
0.0203981046,
0.0657911375,
-0.0201032534,
0.0091228141,
0.0548098087,
-0.0303806625,
-0.0283000246,
0.0056916564,
-0.0532279983,
-0.0290290508,
0.0220040064,
0.0163445547,
0.0608830936,
-0.0005316546,
0.027583668,
-0.0673391297,
-0.0371355005,
0.013236939,
-0.0339383855,
0.0036041704,
-6.641520307e-33,
0.0071260822,
0.045644518,
-0.0194711182,
0.0114976885,
0.0161902383,
0.0238210633,
-0.0275031775,
0.0189961884,
-0.0372704156,
-0.0009856556,
-0.0390529484,
-0.0122554991,
0.0180275962,
0.0548892096,
0.0069698864,
0.0002043282,
0.0365818329,
0.0121645611,
-0.0339479893,
0.0191109441,
0.0435039252,
0.0546932295,
0.0824494958,
-0.0282585863,
0.0294443183,
-0.00440796,
-0.0221415646,
-0.0122518158,
0.0841944888,
0.0453344397,
-0.0147732329,
0.0311349686,
0.0445509553,
-0.0479665808,
0.037139561,
0.0595108457,
-0.0888932645,
-0.0415643677,
0.0095548416,
0.0225227606,
-0.0134197446,
-0.0394293591,
0.0012020865,
0.0102214981,
0.0145214247,
-0.0057898634,
0.0048069903,
-0.0382733382,
-0.0280590039,
-0.0189758521,
-0.08426442,
0.0536488704,
0.0064290375,
-0.0205922257,
0.0241771806,
0.0299788397,
-0.0201709699,
0.0116391703,
-0.0227639601,
-0.0149005195,
0.0428224653,
0.0619628355,
0.0235345047,
0.0111747934,
-0.0796410516,
0.0444670767,
0.0010423603,
-0.0069558071,
0.0361592136,
0.0275812801,
0.0493084267,
-0.0094387187,
0.0023347999,
0.0627413392,
0.0530998595,
-0.0384011269,
-0.0830295011,
0.0392888263,
0.0324909352,
-0.012466982,
0.0060306657,
-0.0313823409,
-0.0607960485,
-0.0325105153,
-0.0131717036,
0.001269715,
-0.0455404855,
-0.0276863333,
0.0358881727,
0.0125260958,
-0.0212323274,
0.0585887842,
0.019637689,
-0.0200191438,
-0.0210951846,
0.005952077,
-0.0168544203,
0.0228980128,
0.0143591827,
0.0109130647,
-0.0957203582,
-0.0393334739,
-0.0070708841,
0.0198694244,
0.0003543036,
-0.0301151536,
0.0793346837,
0.0198238008,
-0.1013199612,
0.0399014689,
-0.0080426456,
0.0448381826,
-0.0179837514,
0.0677829161,
-0.018533418,
-0.0080934037,
-0.0112363882,
0.0286992136,
0.0185119044,
-0.0151962554,
0.006636268,
-0.0163172595,
-0.0398549102,
0.0170095377,
-0.0058425218,
0.0114133917,
-0.0092843175,
0.017276777,
0.0033919301,
-0.0532875545,
0.0047776876,
0.0008795423,
2.706e-7,
0.0038806594,
0.0453867912,
-0.005390293,
-0.0358344391,
-0.0238728616,
0.0456761569,
0.0101705072,
0.0203333013,
-0.0048331148,
0.0246542674,
0.0075092115,
-0.0028385045,
0.0925465524,
0.0359966457,
-0.1256873459,
0.0104836458,
-0.0544149466,
0.0280545298,
-0.077053532,
-0.0251703672,
0.0024872397,
0.1534873396,
-0.003277269,
-0.0196497757,
-0.0446222052,
-0.0215803608,
0.0674817339,
-0.0422154069,
-0.074507609,
0.0212075543,
0.0362952352,
0.0882939696,
0.0135970572,
-0.0152969984,
-0.0661081597,
0.0235845186,
-0.0101541132,
0.0587388501,
0.0134234754,
0.0025476082,
0.0215311628,
0.0030005795,
-0.0446806103,
-0.0417963117,
0.0947749764,
-0.0504324213,
-0.056266401,
-0.046008952,
0.0036372445,
-0.0061791092,
0.0344672166,
-0.0570766591,
-0.0315781124,
0.0209974367,
0.0120287407,
-0.0666265264,
-0.0138125233,
-0.0447089374,
-0.0012383902,
0.0172904115,
0.0215330105,
0.0197717361,
-0.0074582286,
-0.0065731616,
-0.003612753,
-0.0333185978,
0.0489439219,
2.757519418e-34,
0.0334017202,
-0.0090817232,
0.0049057323,
0.0056848689,
-0.027184695,
0.0068326774,
-0.022163216,
-0.0151438517,
-0.0047307876,
-0.0096497908,
0.0423657559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09960v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09960v3 | A Latent Space Theory for Emergent Abilities in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T20:45:01 | 2023-09-13T18:52:02 | Hui Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Languages are not created randomly but rather to communicate information.
There is a strong association between languages and their underlying meanings,
resulting in a sparse joint distribution that is heavily peaked according to
their correlations. Moreover, these peak values happen to match with the
marginal distribution of languages due to the sparsity. With the advent of LLMs
trained on big data and large models, we can now precisely assess the marginal
distribution of languages, providing a convenient means of exploring the sparse
structures in the joint distribution for effective inferences. In this paper,
we categorize languages as either unambiguous or {\epsilon}-ambiguous and
present quantitative results to demonstrate that the emergent abilities of
LLMs, such as language understanding, in-context learning, chain-of-thought
prompting, and effective instruction fine-tuning, can all be attributed to
Bayesian inference on the sparse joint distribution of languages. | [
0.0259050243,
0.0603340045,
-0.0304040369,
0.0549288318,
-0.0122763859,
0.0359243937,
-0.0159209985,
0.0095217228,
-0.0199228022,
-0.0309098158,
-0.0585931987,
-0.0624342561,
-0.0009742315,
0.0158768874,
0.0533134714,
-0.0077025015,
0.028687207,
-0.0643856451,
0.0120564187,
-0.0457197092,
-0.0313853063,
-0.0322454385,
-0.0145340879,
0.0099564595,
0.0148720164,
0.0353675447,
-0.0112186829,
-0.0105855726,
-0.002736548,
-0.0233314577,
-0.0432717837,
0.0519621521,
0.0258668642,
0.057257928,
0.0000016117,
-0.0448894352,
0.0271602105,
-0.0449758545,
-0.0426641442,
0.0087770531,
0.0151957851,
-0.0072389031,
-0.0098843761,
-0.0221245456,
-0.016964009,
-0.0352534838,
0.0763749331,
0.0163063854,
-0.0179022402,
0.0479356349,
0.0057307514,
-0.0239927974,
0.0132740075,
-0.0314769931,
0.0614563413,
-0.0570578463,
0.0388388857,
-0.0228898693,
-0.002480854,
0.0334089398,
-0.0499657989,
0.0192371514,
0.0008314702,
0.0283838492,
-0.0145081198,
0.0653065667,
0.0303196851,
-0.051214274,
0.0040545752,
0.0372635387,
-0.0003547152,
-0.0220382847,
-0.0062936423,
-0.0143149914,
0.0191082042,
0.0751241073,
-0.0517186783,
0.050399553,
0.0089927092,
0.0381952822,
0.0917165577,
-0.0320112072,
0.0741394907,
0.0187579356,
-0.0419917926,
0.0801209882,
0.0173620414,
-0.0418634079,
-0.0074367542,
0.0029195601,
-0.0265485216,
-0.0472248197,
-0.0513940267,
0.0261135213,
-0.0135064153,
0.039735321,
-0.0084750811,
-0.0066394694,
0.0274271667,
-0.0308319684,
0.047330372,
0.0163910352,
-0.0321396254,
0.0550506189,
-0.0187280048,
0.0190097596,
-0.0104970019,
0.0231715105,
-0.0300417002,
0.0160086658,
-0.0102233365,
-0.0122500407,
0.0060584592,
0.0222509969,
0.0043996056,
-0.0081233047,
-0.0203869771,
0.0498361327,
-0.0016626042,
-0.0103415865,
-0.0183309019,
-0.0192654394,
-0.022423923,
-0.0011989884,
-0.0212255009,
-0.0201380104,
-0.0001934138,
0.0667874366,
-0.0153155066,
-0.0265273359,
-0.0237166658,
0.0298149921,
0.0056262682,
-0.035102427,
0.0167635381,
0.0535910577,
-0.0121054659,
-0.0461718068,
-0.0662803203,
0.0202700701,
-0.0395451933,
-0.0715864822,
0.0313364603,
-0.0690684691,
-0.0203941315,
0.0534338988,
0.002766523,
-0.0437647924,
-0.0032377399,
-0.0308500789,
-0.0884602517,
0.0586732924,
-0.0112662483,
0.0226911958,
0.0239303373,
-0.000163948,
0.0184543896,
0.0603835694,
0.0169948786,
0.005070684,
0.0183016565,
0.018560838,
-0.0101030208,
0.0354545079,
-0.0015431901,
0.0552222393,
-0.0159766898,
-0.0127323708,
0.0081343129,
0.007382303,
0.0334623195,
0.0338975415,
-0.0261907168,
-0.0071462882,
0.0429923385,
0.0593344644,
0.0276962426,
-0.018090453,
0.06720341,
-0.0068294699,
-0.0018717428,
0.0518150143,
-0.0556363016,
0.0218503382,
-0.0495437793,
0.0227801334,
0.0461196713,
0.0070006661,
-0.0383449942,
-0.0218815058,
-0.0235020667,
-0.0104088504,
-0.0111670205,
0.0070767687,
0.0985314772,
-0.0219970904,
-0.015836319,
0.0323329605,
0.066977948,
-0.0068724719,
0.0142603647,
-0.0724062473,
0.0616179816,
0.0020401168,
-0.0123088537,
-0.0007610797,
-0.0062133688,
0.0220709387,
-0.0168707017,
0.0118232882,
-0.0232054405,
-0.0133614736,
0.0120387925,
-0.0193887036,
-0.0317078941,
-0.0003249065,
0.0419339314,
0.0147171272,
-0.0394336917,
0.0067479359,
-0.0112078758,
-0.0373199508,
0.0129346037,
0.0327746011,
-0.0425928719,
0.003434597,
0.0053420477,
0.0098384395,
0.0800546631,
0.0115829669,
-0.0354866125,
-0.0028664269,
0.0323650502,
-0.0370489396,
0.013183048,
0.0183205493,
-0.0258700345,
0.0035130349,
0.0344872139,
0.015738098,
-0.0128839863,
-0.0120836273,
0.0064634494,
-0.0468141064,
0.0509529747,
-0.0247965604,
0.0283163227,
-0.0374532714,
0.0241145696,
-0.0293864459,
0.0229758359,
-0.0290166773,
0.0940898508,
-0.0360241681,
0.0396073572,
0.0353421681,
0.0320975706,
0.0264565181,
-0.0274978112,
-0.0287313014,
-0.0107893273,
0.0231521595,
-0.0051118773,
0.0151488744,
0.0208071452,
-0.0147732142,
-0.0603521951,
-0.0572762117,
-0.0053970823,
-0.0301010255,
0.0095203975,
-0.0058982484,
-0.0200062506,
-0.0155713838,
0.0142663727,
-0.0075530685,
0.0291373059,
0.0456782244,
0.037977349,
0.0198311973,
0.0224618297,
-0.0530199371,
-0.0186345261,
-0.0261223409,
0.0007852228,
0.0092665311,
0.0438084491,
-0.0382450595,
-0.061513558,
0.0864805207,
-0.0020706633,
0.0117377955,
-0.0258055311,
-0.0330156498,
0.0398480296,
-0.0596448444,
0.0750137046,
0.0547559261,
-0.0083225584,
0.088797465,
0.0815444887,
0.0038390919,
-0.0056314375,
-0.0300597958,
-0.0523954965,
-0.0233144481,
-0.0851844773,
-0.0260144901,
-0.0326801427,
0.0754593387,
0.0038796463,
-0.0439759418,
-0.0457200631,
-0.0156250019,
-0.007510114,
-0.0090675512,
-0.0044401209,
0.0268079806,
-0.0317440331,
0.0605277978,
-0.011170649,
-0.0840747207,
0.0443701744,
-0.0128920395,
0.0052624913,
0.0153564541,
-0.0549747758,
-0.0299746245,
0.0515426435,
0.0292737018,
-0.012082926,
-0.0319144577,
-0.0417445265,
-0.0826190636,
0.0167812072,
0.0048023006,
-0.0067179669,
0.0305776596,
-0.0521605201,
0.0027535239,
-0.0020043056,
-0.0169657562,
-0.0222263131,
-0.025070101,
-0.0212225318,
0.0151510984,
0.0139511367,
-0.0340568013,
-0.0209952295,
-0.0403855368,
0.016537264,
-0.0077761877,
0.0075872354,
-0.0155045856,
-0.0158578474,
0.0094568897,
0.0537124313,
0.0298248623,
0.0249283314,
-0.1028412431,
-0.0397513285,
-0.00037225,
0.010652611,
0.0130280145,
-0.002170966,
0.0255532358,
0.06357795,
0.0169890579,
-0.0131218778,
0.0517846197,
0.0302385204,
0.0024902255,
-0.0018292966,
0.0955293626,
-0.0044798013,
-0.0400895365,
0.0222880691,
-0.0001234381,
0.0277702231,
0.0344734825,
0.0006777043,
-0.0982042998,
-0.009308829,
-0.0238074232,
-0.0071918261,
-0.0105060488,
-0.0398880132,
0.0195396468,
-0.0787916407,
-0.0061161714,
0.0010205095,
-0.0442398638,
-0.0172055885,
-0.0426912494,
0.0216412339,
-0.0115842419,
0.0201781243,
-0.0226061996,
-0.0051164399,
0.004541399,
0.0138142379,
0.0385722704,
-0.1146369874,
-0.0083816769,
-0.0300899092,
0.1004418209,
-0.0170133654,
0.0024717164,
-0.0672179013,
-0.0333329849,
0.0143405991,
-0.0156713873,
-0.0329920165,
-0.03129071,
-0.0082824724,
0.0143209752,
-0.010427678,
-0.0025864393,
0.0432280488,
-0.0223817024,
-0.0161061082,
-0.0138946613,
0.0907740518,
-0.0491649248,
-0.0369135402,
0.0236814693,
-0.0255663004,
0.0206885748,
0.079486236,
0.0227575675,
-0.0380225666,
-0.0089910869,
-0.0160745718,
-0.0074377037,
0.045684956,
-0.0271500368,
0.0478057601,
-0.0003348285,
-0.0216063261,
-0.0310136005,
-0.0064177862,
0.0431720279,
0.033423271,
0.0211799499,
0.0635622516,
-0.032936383,
-0.0336831808,
-0.0126216952,
0.0217524022,
-0.0098978942,
-0.0330330804,
-0.0716315359,
-0.0701729953,
0.0094568357,
-0.0667277947,
-0.0224770159,
-0.0040146168,
-0.1077470779,
-0.0876025483,
0.0133143701,
0.029549839,
0.0292326417,
0.0281510055,
0.0218954608,
-0.0788602084,
0.0285249185,
0.0435367301,
-0.0210549999,
0.0465614386,
0.003985283,
0.0265310388,
0.0166970063,
0.0566948578,
-0.0497734249,
-0.0102449395,
0.0354601555,
0.0454998724,
-0.058923915,
-0.0427379832,
-0.0161292329,
-0.0125353113,
0.0384505652,
-0.0624554567,
-0.0160639435,
-0.064524658,
-0.0095564127,
-0.0007375471,
0.031866774,
-0.0219340734,
-0.0356770791,
0.0429961458,
0.0109522734,
0.0075248028,
-0.020657789,
-0.0022541154,
0.0941440761,
-0.0397105627,
0.0068769432,
0.0470080487,
-0.018929271,
0.0529915988,
0.030224625,
0.0229589101,
0.0213701315,
-0.0111593483,
0.0051284265,
0.0353856497,
0.0515905693,
0.0236520525,
-0.0058267,
-0.0084626181,
-0.0021476918,
-0.0763673335,
-0.0422077179,
0.0484988503,
0.0433647558,
0.0609291717,
-0.0138246305,
0.0480870418,
-0.0782635659,
0.0105858557,
-0.0350212082,
0.0347941704,
-0.0032431614,
-0.0307578966,
0.0471624024,
0.0172954723,
-0.0100942468,
0.053845603,
0.0895522982,
0.0450703576,
0.0316753648,
-0.0314899161,
0.01587658,
-0.0138176382,
-0.0152384173,
0.0370910875,
0.0465567,
-0.0271214116,
0.0941455364,
-0.0420647413,
-0.0719221383,
-0.0299978685,
0.0192807633,
0.0027512251,
-0.0181850903,
0.0092749661,
0.0735623091,
-0.0371388607,
0.0101528773,
-0.0479882397,
-0.0133497454,
0.0349291749,
-0.0224765353,
-0.0192329064,
-6.799234915e-33,
-0.0072552678,
-0.0512465276,
0.0151512306,
0.0377121083,
0.0192326736,
-0.0004252502,
-0.0206774324,
0.0472220741,
-0.0386565328,
0.0296344105,
0.013193924,
0.0047060922,
-0.0027179206,
0.0547490604,
0.0137598477,
0.0053907558,
0.0150426067,
0.0029646487,
0.0371996015,
0.0217247047,
0.0426392369,
-0.0042019612,
0.0454828218,
-0.0604266375,
0.0510635115,
-0.0406474173,
0.0243380498,
0.0510934368,
-0.013233847,
0.0445773341,
-0.0247734096,
0.0360193886,
0.0357520804,
-0.0032720962,
-0.0042519025,
-0.0390623622,
-0.0456543602,
-0.0424435213,
0.0570729673,
-0.0253342297,
-0.0213126577,
-0.0617520288,
0.0261002146,
-0.0107312379,
-0.0378934629,
-0.0076279659,
0.0290305875,
-0.0220787134,
-0.0365996435,
-0.0094829593,
-0.0594883822,
0.0075092544,
-0.0074299229,
0.0213966649,
0.0372835808,
-0.0853617787,
-0.020290155,
-0.0189939309,
-0.0029816646,
0.0358491316,
0.0203998461,
0.0445001312,
0.0616360307,
0.0606495552,
0.0182689819,
0.0424455404,
0.0114529906,
0.0068824436,
0.0033794995,
-0.0154231377,
0.0497194603,
0.0182374977,
-0.0155606661,
-0.0092636393,
0.0134470062,
0.0330441222,
-0.0647532865,
-0.0132202962,
0.043682728,
-0.0139832282,
0.0291840602,
0.0190571006,
-0.0007788675,
-0.0344345309,
-0.0338911824,
0.0015815689,
-0.0311002694,
-0.0142757325,
0.0041240114,
0.0131216142,
0.023136897,
-0.048338145,
0.0465280004,
-0.0416110493,
-0.0604006574,
-0.0039234869,
-0.0143004181,
0.0263130628,
0.0100187836,
-0.0013276009,
-0.0587766208,
-0.0483325496,
-0.0141010042,
0.0063799717,
0.0035855991,
0.0370345488,
0.0151912337,
0.0166994762,
-0.0378423147,
-0.0156375878,
-0.0214063358,
-0.0341875106,
0.0205491018,
0.0036309334,
0.0434157774,
-0.0136370035,
0.0012944234,
0.0443934239,
0.0223633964,
0.0033303122,
0.0106857223,
0.0047630472,
-0.0483241379,
0.0111042326,
-0.0623020753,
0.0000473104,
-0.0083039813,
0.0057774042,
0.0314315036,
-0.0429249778,
0.0077498448,
0.036868196,
2.507e-7,
0.0394735634,
0.0201266911,
-0.0343468636,
0.0215651393,
0.0199797228,
0.0128354179,
-0.0516101345,
-0.0217723139,
0.0132207358,
-0.0442853235,
-0.0067841853,
0.0579843707,
0.0235224422,
-0.0293672755,
-0.044805605,
0.0142401876,
-0.0259486474,
0.0036506013,
-0.0318374895,
0.0470847711,
0.0499143861,
0.0932327583,
0.0086098257,
-0.0254696365,
0.0103798416,
-0.0332488045,
0.0389021374,
-0.0319189504,
0.0153539646,
0.0131857926,
-0.0090933423,
-0.0352363512,
0.0073712589,
0.0245776772,
0.0025800194,
0.026270071,
-0.022290241,
0.0485577136,
-0.0006897139,
0.0358424038,
0.010063475,
-0.0159810949,
-0.0099290926,
-0.0350600965,
0.0670793802,
-0.0743381903,
-0.068833448,
0.0034895062,
0.020336464,
-0.0109448377,
0.0021957404,
-0.0013340127,
-0.0019158093,
-0.0045114667,
0.0029419623,
-0.014333602,
0.0268004145,
-0.051153928,
0.0359497108,
0.035809841,
-0.0730064586,
-0.0660495833,
-0.0108622853,
-0.0320095792,
0.0623674467,
-0.0172797702,
0.0068733697,
2.36427638e-34,
0.0248151384,
-0.0074210223,
0.03196913,
0.0115460837,
-0.0007189178,
-0.0260841865,
-0.0277540106,
0.0422297008,
0.0393515714,
-0.0957852527,
0.0053938762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09957v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09957v1 | Low-resource Bilingual Dialect Lexicon Induction with Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T20:20:41 | 2023-04-19T20:20:41 | Ekaterina Artemova, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Bilingual word lexicons are crucial tools for multilingual natural language
understanding and machine translation tasks, as they facilitate the mapping of
words in one language to their synonyms in another language. To achieve this,
numerous papers have explored bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) in
high-resource scenarios, using a typical pipeline consisting of two
unsupervised steps: bitext mining and word alignment, both of which rely on
pre-trained large language models~(LLMs).
In this paper, we present an analysis of the BLI pipeline for German and two
of its dialects, Bavarian and Alemannic. This setup poses several unique
challenges, including the scarcity of resources, the relatedness of the
languages, and the lack of standardization in the orthography of dialects. To
evaluate the BLI outputs, we analyze them with respect to word frequency and
pairwise edit distance. Additionally, we release two evaluation datasets
comprising 1,500 bilingual sentence pairs and 1,000 bilingual word pairs. They
were manually judged for their semantic similarity for each Bavarian-German and
Alemannic-German language pair. | [
-0.0120354304,
0.0472556949,
-0.0009617073,
0.0749449804,
-0.0907623768,
0.0012225881,
-0.0209151134,
-0.0545093305,
0.0036209188,
-0.0253804866,
-0.0445575751,
-0.0536074564,
0.0409339704,
-0.0295186564,
0.0114872605,
0.0080160154,
0.0279686153,
-0.0067358646,
-0.0602662526,
-0.0220695194,
0.008853998,
0.0173873045,
0.0092224572,
-0.0025661679,
0.0059184693,
0.0179076344,
0.0344654433,
0.0203031246,
0.0314854346,
0.019341588,
-0.0246581994,
-0.0100422045,
-0.0191448815,
0.1153639182,
0.0000015893,
-0.0908124,
-0.034324225,
-0.0009802151,
0.011300521,
0.0193567555,
0.0347489491,
-0.0293155648,
-0.0328260884,
0.0106689632,
-0.0292576551,
-0.0335497856,
0.0719487369,
0.0158584844,
0.0375753157,
0.0265812669,
-0.0234844778,
-0.0594282672,
-0.0043796259,
0.0074878959,
-0.0378261432,
0.0010231943,
-0.0001693329,
0.0126339206,
-0.0508941077,
-0.0191243943,
-0.005500563,
0.0440241657,
-0.0191636439,
0.006999658,
-0.0431856513,
0.0152808493,
-0.0552015565,
-0.0210066047,
0.0198568888,
0.0218071695,
-0.0572738461,
-0.047898639,
-0.0159722045,
0.0187963657,
-0.0088890996,
0.0390123352,
-0.0068006138,
-0.0036916607,
-0.0152314277,
0.0493994802,
0.0585479178,
-0.0311053041,
0.0247232039,
-0.0186984744,
-0.0462255776,
0.1114473268,
0.0560220592,
-0.0303507745,
0.0205645058,
0.0395857766,
0.00425315,
-0.0544663295,
-0.0369368494,
0.0066907117,
-0.0143561047,
0.0212949794,
-0.0305042565,
-0.024732925,
0.0324981324,
-0.0640369654,
0.0188037306,
0.0191128142,
-0.0622019581,
0.0693432316,
-0.0623555146,
-0.000473991,
-0.0058601303,
-0.0066478844,
-0.0310492013,
-0.0572912283,
-0.0229345225,
0.0472590588,
-0.0072366591,
-0.0479798317,
-0.0263729189,
0.0196406152,
-0.0079196347,
0.0039158743,
0.0202898197,
0.0335303061,
0.0176138319,
-0.0611193106,
-0.0232804045,
-0.0215164255,
-0.0402990021,
0.0397249348,
-0.00360047,
0.0047327667,
-0.0826773942,
-0.0329365693,
-0.0059793824,
0.0396824069,
-0.0086668329,
-0.0416099131,
-0.0119338846,
0.0156492498,
-0.0223527979,
-0.0405660272,
-0.0668202639,
-0.0011109343,
-0.0220360216,
-0.0399974994,
-0.0291184653,
-0.0983619839,
0.0637805238,
-0.0008191757,
0.0185036641,
-0.0238482095,
0.0237680357,
-0.0301326197,
-0.0575900078,
0.0524773784,
-0.0229022242,
0.0159362126,
0.0171965398,
-0.0497529358,
0.0287121069,
0.0760548934,
-0.0069920598,
-0.0283516701,
0.0768051371,
-0.0054483898,
-0.0583308488,
0.0658233911,
0.0054779286,
0.0442499407,
-0.0431352369,
-0.0022945344,
0.0687748119,
0.0540205128,
0.0598858558,
0.066155687,
-0.00032046,
-0.0100087849,
0.0256776102,
0.0457408503,
0.0339315869,
0.0116385901,
0.0346232839,
0.0035861689,
-0.0198560487,
-0.0033582416,
-0.0015141835,
-0.0127912341,
-0.0400563218,
0.0185259301,
0.0470612869,
0.0775028318,
-0.0128273023,
0.0124507183,
-0.0189502742,
-0.0295005459,
0.0275401827,
-0.0282624178,
0.0656747371,
0.0136123961,
0.0004495284,
0.0872696787,
0.0224363841,
-0.0359620452,
0.0212953445,
0.0236267392,
-0.0559799038,
0.0545289554,
0.0297681112,
0.0120824156,
-0.0050148759,
0.0076669878,
-0.0326687619,
0.0272272397,
0.0530782193,
-0.0179445036,
0.0156277996,
-0.060755033,
-0.0051571238,
-0.0193383023,
-0.0441519432,
0.0300884992,
0.0304446388,
0.0231589917,
0.0008563509,
-0.0332341045,
-0.0574709103,
0.0107766753,
-0.067450121,
0.0039643343,
0.0265745353,
0.0276347287,
0.0185264349,
0.0383690186,
-0.0367033109,
0.0026673595,
-0.009375317,
-0.0649066493,
-0.0046291593,
0.0633492395,
0.0410376266,
-0.0630864874,
0.0813941881,
-0.0398963355,
0.015914049,
-0.0535819232,
-0.0250530019,
-0.0441422164,
-0.0224923268,
-0.0378951542,
0.081478551,
-0.0547387935,
0.0673202127,
-0.0044375216,
-0.0081549836,
-0.0299934465,
0.0660360754,
0.0026154234,
0.0251816548,
-0.0489150882,
-0.0153390793,
0.0290519614,
0.0227158703,
-0.0159588829,
0.0127939899,
-0.0028508445,
0.0070186807,
-0.0073513985,
-0.0186318085,
-0.0182096288,
-0.0351693667,
-0.0835827664,
0.0413188748,
-0.032942228,
0.0282054953,
0.0304760784,
0.0410175957,
0.0049279379,
0.0066670622,
-0.0011279609,
-0.0060841492,
0.0263468046,
0.0265801866,
0.0201054309,
-0.01304531,
-0.0097889211,
-0.0172626656,
0.0045229853,
-0.0002557492,
0.0318437964,
0.0035748167,
-0.005209838,
-0.0396256894,
0.0328199342,
-0.0454935022,
0.0234668907,
0.0340917744,
-0.0481852479,
-0.0464166328,
0.0053644064,
0.0899858177,
0.0278272517,
0.0054628234,
-0.0559444278,
0.0434772931,
-0.0104839699,
-0.0076962505,
-0.0295090359,
-0.0166410469,
-0.0293918625,
-0.0683549866,
-0.0314816646,
0.00417108,
0.041210223,
-0.0261386745,
-0.0304309074,
-0.0199400615,
-0.0396758504,
-0.0268397462,
0.0328742079,
0.0026753419,
-0.0042710095,
-0.0071330168,
0.0520110466,
-0.0209902562,
-0.0260683112,
0.0495699942,
-0.0716812164,
0.0118789431,
-0.091088295,
-0.0320388861,
-0.0556220673,
0.0251634084,
0.0234017428,
0.0487957224,
-0.0632333755,
0.0269979332,
-0.0118456278,
-0.0046623782,
0.0300838035,
-0.0021547757,
0.0580530167,
-0.0314620733,
0.0244106799,
0.0050602788,
-0.0499009341,
-0.0091440342,
-0.0288005341,
-0.0461023189,
-0.018319197,
0.066968143,
-0.0390813053,
-0.0001466886,
0.0376048721,
0.0234121177,
0.0300905257,
0.0017874883,
0.0025434024,
0.0034753059,
0.0172678307,
0.0149150398,
0.0225478746,
0.0182330608,
0.0131838731,
0.0309065711,
-0.0007210672,
0.0231525823,
0.0272838548,
0.0074839974,
-0.0418250002,
0.033004038,
-0.0614388771,
-0.0156333502,
-0.0476795323,
0.0206604544,
0.0605866984,
-0.0198525134,
0.0836761892,
0.060623046,
-0.0208752733,
-0.0031758319,
-0.0742214471,
0.0059898379,
0.0460105389,
0.0137199005,
-0.0753818154,
0.0109654199,
-0.0088715376,
-0.0018192636,
-0.0152192051,
-0.0041475571,
-0.0074350005,
-0.1274917871,
-0.0079662967,
0.0593818836,
-0.0227346793,
0.0015790119,
-0.0431705788,
-0.0091056442,
-0.0560129434,
-0.0351342075,
-0.0116311051,
-0.0005885263,
-0.0344893597,
0.0024337894,
0.0097340969,
-0.0583467931,
-0.0067380727,
-0.0839729607,
0.0249176864,
0.0232466497,
0.0624174178,
-0.046406813,
-0.0306537654,
0.0384247974,
-0.0467882976,
-0.0161431339,
0.0074415249,
0.0151984151,
0.0184290539,
-0.0373467095,
0.0073866472,
0.0467542,
-0.0295514408,
-0.0067844824,
0.0268151034,
0.0555755161,
-0.0310314894,
0.0420183614,
0.0289006252,
0.0085697798,
0.0103136785,
0.0626289546,
0.0098995427,
-0.0181873571,
0.0499305651,
0.0350134708,
0.0031840638,
-0.0279757716,
-0.0487866662,
0.0563443303,
-0.029589314,
-0.0364010967,
-0.0185524486,
-0.0234347899,
-0.0213049054,
0.0673295334,
0.0396024659,
0.0271720402,
0.0287671816,
-0.0239930693,
-0.0513701625,
0.043788027,
0.0105866315,
0.0307377689,
-0.0445902944,
-0.0284182224,
0.0455891639,
-0.0309165698,
-0.023027882,
-0.0229096767,
-0.0414173864,
-0.0858274102,
0.0168279782,
0.0065035275,
0.0106960535,
0.076695323,
-0.0396443196,
0.0042725313,
0.0282423068,
0.0194987543,
0.0098955669,
0.0061516548,
0.0041746246,
0.0215822235,
0.0045546596,
0.0191683322,
0.012721844,
-0.0164638441,
0.0090106167,
0.0138402283,
-0.0136884386,
-0.0816343948,
0.0112215178,
0.0124873891,
0.0579602867,
-0.0548522212,
0.0434838384,
-0.0346805863,
0.009786536,
0.0133899208,
-0.0107161757,
-0.0024068139,
-0.0147246933,
0.0661629364,
-0.0259117298,
0.0015590487,
0.0316147693,
0.0010066733,
-0.011758307,
0.0485503189,
0.0178638529,
0.0069946339,
0.0658235252,
0.0282194167,
-0.0006503794,
-0.036579866,
0.0432994924,
0.0147442622,
0.047430966,
-0.0209155735,
0.0514859967,
0.0078012371,
0.0231520087,
0.0078229727,
0.0474332571,
0.0034844761,
-0.0184016712,
-0.0299102217,
0.011793904,
0.0873280317,
-0.0464092866,
0.0790767819,
-0.0375373662,
-0.0177741311,
-0.0215234943,
0.0129123889,
-0.0193212274,
-0.0106268786,
-0.0025034617,
-0.0092265969,
-0.0470173471,
0.0287455656,
0.0333586819,
-0.0231034961,
0.0214287769,
0.0179569535,
-0.003770079,
0.0177983269,
-0.0342811346,
0.0137338871,
-0.0228406321,
-0.017130509,
-0.0380492583,
-0.0506161228,
-0.0350974798,
-0.0044427123,
0.0367641523,
-0.0344429277,
0.0145658385,
0.0155266086,
0.0896471217,
-0.0105955135,
0.0283235554,
-0.0241800677,
0.0242049694,
0.0201179013,
-0.0431528948,
0.0174392723,
-5.711057386e-33,
0.0030394206,
-0.009964426,
-0.0005810437,
-0.0593556464,
0.0011944728,
-0.0224705059,
0.0000409981,
-0.0232950021,
-0.0213386826,
0.0118221007,
0.0167680029,
-0.0066608149,
0.0177841894,
0.0075434251,
0.0235618539,
0.0081191426,
0.032397557,
0.028893983,
-0.0168131478,
-0.0141319772,
0.0730030611,
-0.0137387402,
0.0594267845,
-0.0618655235,
-0.0056427373,
0.0118575292,
0.0404548831,
0.0251002833,
0.0240387991,
0.0519475043,
-0.0157605186,
0.0316848978,
0.0055291359,
-0.0180650763,
0.0143842557,
-0.0022995081,
-0.0477452353,
-0.0513762981,
0.0444610752,
0.0403016731,
0.0002539665,
-0.0288127158,
0.0333259851,
-0.0065267035,
-0.0447704084,
0.00425955,
0.0146428943,
0.0002922182,
-0.023523232,
-0.0135389976,
-0.0623686276,
0.0330935344,
0.0230367612,
-0.0174116232,
0.0525478311,
0.0200060382,
0.0090135718,
-0.0364415422,
-0.0754163861,
0.0128008164,
-0.0149432607,
0.021434769,
0.065557003,
-0.0140450597,
0.0072843237,
0.0310119428,
0.027015537,
-0.0065993741,
0.0630069748,
-0.0053087375,
0.0030669081,
-0.0237341449,
-0.0279881842,
0.0637279451,
0.0051153381,
-0.0274761394,
-0.0212700013,
0.0243924335,
0.0181140415,
-0.021145422,
0.0069698589,
-0.0242895763,
-0.0048777321,
-0.0142299095,
-0.0163562223,
-0.0496516936,
0.0070303343,
-0.0279944707,
0.0073987297,
-0.0425356887,
0.0141762951,
0.0166308768,
0.0631927773,
-0.0219053105,
-0.0266692359,
-0.0067711188,
0.0297064055,
-0.0093008205,
-0.0658727586,
0.067186676,
-0.0172247607,
-0.0541764572,
-0.0412364304,
0.0297132544,
0.0211458802,
0.0185381174,
0.0179643407,
-0.0114970654,
-0.0446145572,
0.019626582,
-0.0416884162,
-0.0433250964,
-0.0491036586,
0.0056877495,
0.0155603113,
0.0197037384,
0.0236318223,
0.0390610732,
0.0808112025,
-0.0241171457,
-0.0235961042,
-0.0242068395,
0.0230057482,
0.0586993955,
0.0089937495,
0.0195138752,
-0.0421964787,
-0.0627203882,
-0.0092801796,
-0.0460082889,
0.004491325,
-0.0068442253,
2.684e-7,
0.0392274931,
0.0198222287,
-0.039276816,
0.0071461829,
0.0116554433,
0.0146098845,
-0.0189701971,
0.0008318328,
-0.0238961764,
0.0291688181,
0.0214701258,
0.0025114978,
0.0471803583,
0.0726992711,
-0.0712725371,
0.0074544502,
-0.0474334136,
-0.0313458517,
-0.0782229081,
-0.0094593782,
0.0478543378,
0.1230259538,
0.0313214287,
0.0101075014,
0.0069155311,
-0.0454852432,
0.0327673443,
-0.009699001,
-0.0584594645,
0.0478139967,
0.0170609299,
-0.0015068752,
-0.0103801163,
0.0257085022,
-0.0138891973,
0.0567460731,
-0.0058004842,
0.0156518705,
-0.0327668153,
-0.0160395764,
-0.0001797786,
-0.0538642183,
-0.0176186636,
-0.0619808622,
0.055308938,
-0.0300770029,
-0.0028651429,
-0.0137668019,
-0.001429967,
0.0224456023,
0.0651095659,
-0.0114827864,
-0.0099395681,
0.0247356519,
0.0737668499,
0.0029806921,
-0.0485558957,
-0.024746811,
-0.0345665812,
0.0559052378,
0.008392497,
-0.0546225607,
0.0366723351,
0.0335117467,
0.0078441976,
-0.0157670565,
0.0296790637,
2.39437753e-34,
0.0011363581,
0.0049979826,
0.0368445963,
0.001631491,
0.0520425476,
-0.0467858948,
-0.0306580253,
0.0205011424,
-0.0397412777,
-0.0349632092,
0.0154807623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09948v1 | Catch Me If You Can: Identifying Fraudulent Physician Reviews with Large Language Models Using Generative Pre-Trained Transformers | 2023-04-19T19:59:26 | 2023-04-19T19:59:26 | Aishwarya Deep Shukla, Laksh Agarwal, Jie Mein, Goh, Guodong, Gao, Ritu Agarwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The proliferation of fake reviews of doctors has potentially detrimental
consequences for patient well-being and has prompted concern among consumer
protection groups and regulatory bodies. Yet despite significant advancements
in the fields of machine learning and natural language processing, there
remains limited comprehension of the characteristics differentiating fraudulent
from authentic reviews. This study utilizes a novel pre-labeled dataset of
38048 physician reviews to establish the effectiveness of large language models
in classifying reviews. Specifically, we compare the performance of traditional
ML models, such as logistic regression and support vector machines, to
generative pre-trained transformer models. Furthermore, we use GPT4, the newest
model in the GPT family, to uncover the key dimensions along which fake and
genuine physician reviews differ. Our findings reveal significantly superior
performance of GPT-3 over traditional ML models in this context. Additionally,
our analysis suggests that GPT3 requires a smaller training sample than
traditional models, suggesting its appropriateness for tasks with scarce
training data. Moreover, the superiority of GPT3 performance increases in the
cold start context i.e., when there are no prior reviews of a doctor. Finally,
we employ GPT4 to reveal the crucial dimensions that distinguish fake physician
reviews. In sharp contrast to previous findings in the literature that were
obtained using simulated data, our findings from a real-world dataset show that
fake reviews are generally more clinically detailed, more reserved in
sentiment, and have better structure and grammar than authentic ones. | [
0.0962018222,
0.0696307793,
-0.0091725476,
0.0214381013,
-0.0306534152,
0.0108521283,
0.0200980883,
0.0137111824,
-0.0081273085,
-0.0596082993,
-0.0170836467,
-0.0459736958,
0.0083362665,
0.0436252281,
0.0098625077,
-0.0301270373,
0.0094686802,
0.0373822972,
0.056002602,
0.0046312264,
-0.0045558321,
0.0375356115,
0.0158143211,
0.0669384673,
-0.0114160972,
0.0072159227,
0.0851026773,
-0.0192527752,
0.016298227,
-0.0350680239,
0.0140054757,
0.0503849648,
-0.0302719437,
0.0709671378,
0.000001789,
-0.028865492,
0.0057059005,
0.0092876274,
-0.0249042213,
-0.0164327044,
0.0813788921,
-0.086406514,
0.0081838854,
0.0527584106,
-0.0553204194,
-0.0907335952,
0.0195101351,
0.1024781689,
0.0653328672,
0.0957085267,
-0.0360448025,
-0.0159162935,
0.0063774288,
0.0002325556,
-0.0135271791,
-0.0103233224,
0.0255353488,
-0.0017157886,
-0.0194073766,
0.0163994171,
0.0303428564,
-0.0144714843,
-0.0313749798,
-0.0045307474,
-0.0059490306,
0.0364012122,
-0.0373767875,
0.0013941246,
0.0080789747,
0.0163754933,
-0.0467457622,
-0.0530869029,
-0.0052235923,
-0.0090045882,
-0.0100598875,
0.0183247775,
0.0131619889,
0.0496372916,
-0.0054022484,
0.0463425815,
-0.0012056563,
0.0210818462,
0.0359410457,
-0.0041220034,
0.0180877168,
-0.0098026888,
0.0195929948,
-0.0281405132,
0.0311319027,
0.0359070711,
0.022911679,
-0.0239903145,
-0.0021935105,
-0.0064865653,
-0.0296677146,
0.0112303551,
-0.0360083953,
-0.0222263094,
0.0520444885,
-0.041671209,
0.0397410877,
-0.0207198579,
0.0275766253,
0.0150808822,
-0.0206452012,
-0.0027634471,
-0.0225291569,
0.0629375502,
-0.0611040667,
0.0411333703,
-0.0311267339,
-0.0162492376,
0.0238043759,
0.0143073006,
0.0065703718,
0.0122232176,
-0.1118086874,
-0.022255091,
-0.0207377505,
-0.007801062,
0.0119517455,
0.0426408388,
0.0043759528,
0.0059210798,
-0.0200725906,
0.0169575233,
0.0524829254,
0.0320087858,
-0.0557748862,
-0.0319727696,
0.0135905668,
0.0509283654,
0.0055653839,
0.0110944621,
-0.0005597586,
0.0159662664,
0.0250237174,
-0.0450494811,
-0.0019322481,
-0.0256085768,
-0.0414513759,
-0.0305634495,
-0.008704029,
-0.0366505757,
-0.010596076,
-0.0020634306,
-0.0014268605,
-0.0152598191,
0.0035586052,
0.0056816344,
-0.0419235229,
0.0576055199,
-0.0225920137,
0.0174374767,
0.0056319186,
0.0160670504,
0.0100567676,
-0.0103086829,
-0.0048483801,
0.0002153757,
0.0223151539,
-0.0348652452,
0.0747815594,
0.0196332075,
0.0406226069,
-0.0260503087,
0.0529239401,
0.0030101959,
-0.0120117795,
0.0192526709,
-0.0131333126,
0.0529994257,
-0.0192971453,
-0.022749979,
0.0622582696,
0.0377243981,
-0.0068421573,
0.0157337319,
0.055317238,
0.0121303126,
-0.0194802303,
-0.01719179,
-0.0415144861,
-0.0636279657,
-0.0216875561,
-0.017956594,
-0.0637512058,
-0.0196361523,
0.0011958932,
-0.0219890941,
-0.043213997,
-0.0190202054,
-0.0320502929,
-0.0143545084,
0.0293500647,
0.0111000352,
-0.0565021895,
0.0295084026,
0.0251070075,
-0.0222198963,
-0.0427243002,
-0.0737773329,
0.0099344105,
0.0693615451,
0.0454247631,
0.0175110903,
-0.003783216,
-0.0752736032,
-0.0528513342,
0.013549922,
0.0230003614,
-0.0247853845,
-0.0201224722,
0.009388092,
-0.0005374391,
0.007475025,
0.0328868628,
-0.019546967,
0.0204801634,
0.0422197096,
0.016255388,
-0.045290675,
-0.0291852858,
0.0278515816,
-0.0117892567,
-0.0432935692,
0.0429967046,
0.0049727764,
0.0563472584,
-0.0010281851,
-0.0184302386,
0.0037019402,
0.0243301503,
0.0006031409,
-0.0417559855,
-0.0105707766,
-0.0062646908,
-0.0128971245,
-0.0244230255,
-0.0442325957,
-0.0129494844,
0.0397270136,
-0.0277805869,
0.00898185,
-0.0251737908,
-0.0232007559,
0.046083685,
-0.0421337374,
0.0080394,
0.0084330337,
0.0034771264,
0.0040035406,
0.0293373931,
-0.0234666131,
0.0075808372,
-0.0281147659,
-0.0316024683,
-0.001725239,
-0.0049407701,
0.0134027442,
-0.0050285123,
-0.0085426755,
0.0091906311,
-0.0015585314,
0.0317279696,
0.0217870437,
-0.0442814454,
-0.0971710235,
-0.0455931723,
-0.0261848345,
-0.0069805216,
0.0131989345,
-0.0304674264,
0.0184639059,
0.0292933099,
-0.0220493879,
-0.0428887121,
0.058292821,
-0.0122824162,
0.0096745566,
0.0053528738,
-0.001354409,
0.0040563107,
0.0166284535,
-0.0321075171,
0.037736591,
0.0198018104,
0.0056752465,
-0.0633906424,
-0.004882568,
-0.0050749155,
0.000850637,
-0.014805533,
-0.0155840665,
0.0066714007,
0.0070716362,
-0.011885141,
-0.0090585258,
0.0250967257,
0.0423720069,
0.0121489344,
0.0409996584,
0.0066155815,
-0.013773012,
-0.0401248001,
-0.0126316147,
-0.0218688156,
-0.0662103072,
0.039038904,
0.064036116,
0.0403457284,
-0.0246615466,
-0.0111467084,
0.003990314,
0.002855178,
-0.0017966772,
0.0354851745,
-0.031181613,
-0.0172899645,
-0.0001535476,
0.0349223539,
-0.0249798242,
0.0755060539,
-0.0265663341,
0.0482267551,
-0.0504597016,
-0.0181924216,
0.0014461512,
0.0192923024,
0.0305889249,
0.0103360815,
0.0433987267,
0.008603029,
0.0491239727,
0.017909646,
0.0321701691,
-0.0324153788,
0.0273477193,
-0.026699828,
0.0535302758,
0.0043423674,
-0.046063941,
-0.0507460982,
-0.0866414681,
-0.018978456,
-0.0452443212,
0.0346939154,
-0.0007810508,
-0.0825827271,
0.0133881308,
-0.0682810917,
0.0749111772,
0.0117395287,
-0.01492061,
0.034331698,
0.006995053,
0.0250937454,
-0.0161246266,
0.0280563924,
-0.0300082639,
-0.0095657064,
0.0449166857,
-0.0172443725,
0.023184536,
-0.0283793621,
-0.0513130277,
0.0059447782,
-0.0232038796,
0.0005607642,
0.0047367881,
-0.0288491305,
-0.0364589803,
-0.010452155,
0.1054416001,
0.0001153472,
-0.0367178358,
0.0127544375,
0.0441023186,
-0.0236295983,
-0.001476182,
-0.0105844308,
-0.0596516617,
-0.01577021,
-0.0231849644,
0.0203151107,
-0.0625376105,
-0.0162461437,
-0.0055709882,
-0.1134030521,
0.0540596507,
-0.0165922679,
-0.0376144722,
-0.0477829576,
-0.0072921142,
-0.0473592468,
-0.0032080947,
0.0239271484,
-0.0414976105,
-0.0182753056,
0.0019809448,
-0.0641073063,
-0.0657526329,
-0.0665679127,
0.0309963152,
0.0345364213,
0.033035066,
0.0705017,
0.0306250211,
-0.0122565366,
-0.0222676024,
0.0060536624,
0.0044778744,
-0.020614706,
-0.0002914982,
0.0989091545,
-0.0165417381,
0.0066871932,
-0.0201479737,
0.0435515791,
-0.0535053499,
0.0247382112,
-0.0327501073,
0.0459994897,
-0.0257184301,
-0.1045524627,
-0.0062158727,
0.0455975793,
0.0473251082,
0.0535515398,
-0.0180403255,
0.0049851607,
-0.0297536813,
0.0154408561,
0.0380940735,
0.0180543475,
-0.044882305,
0.0442089252,
0.0186503306,
-0.0374683067,
-0.0447903536,
-0.0053480933,
-0.0033998156,
-0.0084130354,
0.0248094071,
-0.0018775028,
0.0374306105,
0.0062491731,
-0.0250101257,
0.0518113226,
-0.0077729044,
0.012597152,
-0.030611435,
-0.0172832571,
0.0688319579,
0.0044107125,
0.006413321,
-0.0100697,
-0.0296849106,
0.0015351053,
0.0003744748,
0.0706485435,
0.0138305845,
0.0264831651,
0.0085235871,
-0.0057267398,
0.0147627341,
0.036038734,
-0.0469687209,
-0.0163183268,
0.0120926555,
-0.01943505,
-0.00132494,
0.0151199037,
0.0011025044,
0.0558167808,
0.0446822271,
-0.0422426872,
-0.0507363565,
-0.0022171526,
0.0392532535,
0.00170616,
0.0787213147,
-0.0080173444,
0.0638336539,
-0.036456041,
-0.0193430725,
-0.0478765965,
0.0081972489,
-0.045982603,
-0.0351091549,
0.0448236428,
0.0301484428,
-0.0514628254,
-0.0250603557,
-0.0979460776,
0.0314385146,
-0.068952255,
0.0129513666,
0.0104365973,
-0.0278651677,
0.0473517813,
-0.0275150519,
-0.0110580837,
0.0167802833,
0.0362233482,
0.0279596113,
0.0174530931,
0.0529501848,
0.0137879932,
0.0362392366,
-0.0006088268,
0.0054775435,
-0.0249839928,
-0.0033628303,
-0.0593348406,
0.0081381314,
-0.0113616027,
-0.0276869722,
0.0367322564,
-0.0488577671,
0.0081527699,
-0.0043754233,
0.0295241382,
-0.0327088386,
-0.0045070145,
0.0356822312,
-0.0013819173,
-0.0243902095,
0.017272152,
0.0847616866,
0.0010628945,
0.0247515701,
-0.0062630894,
-0.0693833604,
-0.060118638,
-0.0310629252,
0.0042891726,
-0.0199404228,
-0.014516335,
-0.0062523931,
-0.0765175149,
-0.0378393196,
0.0000493927,
-0.0331565849,
0.0308563486,
0.0014241019,
0.0114587806,
0.0640261844,
-0.0033673239,
0.0236661937,
-0.0348704197,
0.0223898403,
0.0337969996,
-0.0272247717,
0.0016960643,
-5.626887583e-33,
0.0480508469,
-0.0649288446,
-0.0287653003,
-0.0127314739,
0.0003708731,
0.0415562242,
-0.0030874191,
0.006503019,
0.0263656713,
0.0642042309,
0.0024925091,
0.0197602715,
0.0060081128,
0.0580463558,
-0.0300750956,
0.0139603512,
0.0644822866,
0.000569306,
-0.0251082592,
0.0352145731,
-0.0048424643,
0.0386481248,
0.0237875935,
-0.089924328,
0.0322455205,
-0.0089734374,
-0.0460385233,
0.0172567964,
-0.0587273464,
0.0429787599,
-0.0208075885,
0.0827674195,
0.046041932,
-0.037586499,
0.0232142266,
0.0322848111,
-0.0283531267,
0.0268481895,
-0.0016530307,
-0.0051592528,
-0.0129593471,
-0.0079738852,
0.0717304423,
-0.0219201669,
-0.0861348584,
0.0104350559,
0.0502389818,
-0.0191253144,
0.0170864295,
-0.0878394023,
-0.0592080578,
0.0167146996,
0.0105407806,
0.012659559,
-0.0280311015,
0.042135112,
-0.0313890427,
0.063444756,
-0.0426522642,
-0.0060124747,
0.0044620493,
-0.0092834309,
-0.0216873661,
-0.0475731716,
-0.0297873821,
0.0530640297,
-0.0003695936,
-0.0040107779,
-0.0462880954,
0.0226827618,
-0.0356627367,
0.0122129759,
0.0384107009,
0.0580597483,
0.0418788083,
-0.0867243558,
-0.056831643,
0.004099444,
-0.023965627,
-0.0184221808,
0.0487444513,
-0.0792520344,
-0.0352948904,
-0.0106661348,
0.0038982839,
-0.0324029922,
0.0048985663,
0.000164102,
0.0116556734,
0.0403998755,
0.0026325202,
-0.0037042473,
-0.0061770994,
-0.0719311163,
0.0112452423,
-0.0121534318,
-0.0169879105,
-0.0118220365,
-0.0394061469,
-0.0061600762,
-0.0283940397,
-0.0199091844,
0.0109831067,
-0.0093587972,
0.0247204769,
-0.0313445181,
0.0700552613,
-0.0191337727,
-0.0732445344,
0.0084937699,
0.0495896377,
0.0512424037,
-0.0027740395,
0.0570821464,
0.0403052568,
0.0040042577,
0.0217999052,
0.0316030942,
-0.022808589,
0.0190740451,
-0.0393033735,
-0.0056839888,
0.0061356546,
-0.0163718574,
-0.04994886,
-0.0134715838,
-0.0172826555,
-0.0020565861,
0.0255350433,
-0.0728825182,
0.0094353193,
-0.0097714234,
2.591e-7,
0.0704058036,
0.0571550988,
-0.0540639646,
-0.0586746447,
0.0278792083,
0.0487728119,
0.0405355468,
0.0128206676,
0.0164272003,
-0.0559680015,
0.0188707635,
-0.030815905,
0.0069732354,
0.0262974035,
-0.1024943367,
0.0306623168,
-0.0715431646,
-0.013264114,
-0.0234668348,
-0.0145219229,
0.033128567,
0.0980137661,
-0.0142435338,
-0.0506831519,
0.0124870129,
-0.0084039625,
0.053945642,
-0.0084489575,
-0.0238605849,
0.0315651409,
0.0714452639,
-0.0313229561,
0.0126367686,
0.0391431786,
-0.0481574498,
0.0275211968,
-0.0302765369,
0.0780292898,
-0.0403972678,
-0.0013639282,
0.004717988,
-0.0210204236,
0.0477742627,
-0.0400705598,
0.054303661,
-0.0778316185,
-0.0290861875,
-0.0729906932,
-0.0302385874,
-0.0477297679,
0.0582809784,
-0.0243602637,
-0.0240120105,
0.062585488,
0.0241918862,
0.0201431718,
0.0141717289,
-0.0506146513,
0.0116641084,
0.0536938161,
-0.0368276238,
-0.007609467,
0.053225521,
-0.0230802074,
0.05259078,
-0.0247569494,
0.0321803764,
2.247807619e-34,
0.0603427216,
-0.0054275347,
0.0339833051,
-0.0221572369,
0.0155427912,
0.0257885903,
-0.01056905,
0.0072343075,
-0.000982994,
-0.024536198,
-0.0016021038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09919v1 | The eBible Corpus: Data and Model Benchmarks for Bible Translation for Low-Resource Languages | 2023-04-19T18:52:49 | 2023-04-19T18:52:49 | Vesa Akerman, David Baines, Damien Daspit, Ulf Hermjakob, Taeho Jang, Colin Leong, Michael Martin, Joel Mathew, Jonathan Robie, Marcus Schwarting | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Efficiently and accurately translating a corpus into a low-resource language
remains a challenge, regardless of the strategies employed, whether manual,
automated, or a combination of the two. Many Christian organizations are
dedicated to the task of translating the Holy Bible into languages that lack a
modern translation. Bible translation (BT) work is currently underway for over
3000 extremely low resource languages. We introduce the eBible corpus: a
dataset containing 1009 translations of portions of the Bible with data in 833
different languages across 75 language families. In addition to a BT
benchmarking dataset, we introduce model performance benchmarks built on the No
Language Left Behind (NLLB) neural machine translation (NMT) models. Finally,
we describe several problems specific to the domain of BT and consider how the
established data and model benchmarks might be used for future translation
efforts. For a BT task trained with NLLB, Austronesian and Trans-New Guinea
language families achieve 35.1 and 31.6 BLEU scores respectively, which spurs
future innovations for NMT for low-resource languages in Papua New Guinea. | [
-0.0019154834,
0.0466122553,
-0.0084131761,
0.023550868,
-0.0458938666,
0.0349624418,
0.0320186689,
0.0155546637,
-0.0475644059,
0.0027784435,
0.0287941732,
-0.0672342032,
0.0570039377,
-0.0555238724,
0.0330408514,
-0.0262447502,
-0.0008992973,
0.0043411376,
-0.0044920803,
0.0123327468,
-0.0577903204,
0.0205628611,
0.0105174072,
0.0025139395,
0.0144222174,
-0.0236213095,
-0.0271138642,
0.0634940714,
0.0100396788,
-0.0249102488,
-0.0474534072,
-0.0035141041,
-0.0296632629,
0.0769398883,
0.0000020365,
-0.0653479397,
0.0086202137,
0.0193079971,
-0.0343427956,
0.044264894,
0.0672723725,
-0.0601259805,
-0.0250340272,
0.0099038417,
-0.0066133849,
-0.021702677,
0.0437431298,
0.0219189413,
0.0096900212,
0.0804393515,
0.0060130996,
-0.0260279849,
-0.0030563639,
-0.0535793826,
0.0346896015,
-0.0050433734,
-0.0157447215,
0.0141442856,
-0.0258037262,
0.0195569228,
-0.022559965,
0.060407266,
0.0303820129,
0.0076736375,
-0.0416700244,
-0.0189602822,
-0.0342500769,
-0.0387330949,
-0.0047163931,
-0.0156038627,
-0.0074210581,
-0.0077477815,
-0.0140308235,
0.0120544583,
-0.0249469895,
-0.0109427068,
-0.0173897576,
0.036056146,
-0.0376553163,
-0.0248189159,
-0.0178466588,
0.0014065361,
0.0597226992,
-0.0754011497,
-0.0354143605,
-0.0249375366,
0.0661733896,
-0.0137235783,
0.0261491686,
0.0415293872,
-0.0343697332,
-0.0249565784,
0.0073770741,
-0.021329049,
0.0558595546,
-0.0267287083,
-0.0152611602,
-0.0126095349,
-0.0422686487,
-0.0511732288,
0.0607341081,
0.0488318205,
-0.0156385675,
0.0344739929,
-0.0322877914,
0.0497153141,
0.0337820947,
-0.0025019161,
-0.0241902936,
0.0280328766,
0.0016474939,
0.0549325608,
-0.0516283698,
-0.0365113914,
-0.0649025217,
0.0458741523,
-0.0290641002,
-0.006442531,
0.0615216419,
-0.0306332447,
0.020254666,
-0.0155103737,
-0.0476221293,
-0.011923518,
0.0206586253,
0.0109800482,
0.0078657251,
-0.0141523704,
-0.0179747082,
-0.0740794837,
0.03178766,
-0.0147175975,
-0.0333234072,
-0.0461601354,
0.0284425411,
0.0736878216,
0.0042938497,
-0.0422991738,
-0.0734060183,
0.0294204243,
-0.0284772068,
-0.0294393711,
-0.0128493877,
-0.033442799,
0.0757615939,
0.0038960783,
0.0146933934,
-0.0153890811,
-0.0254907385,
0.0136499433,
-0.0106724864,
0.0307642724,
0.0529866032,
0.0089005204,
0.0503134094,
-0.0108148288,
-0.0073910826,
0.035401959,
0.0379371233,
0.0041700336,
0.0361754075,
0.007860831,
-0.0999849811,
0.0607473776,
0.0056553818,
0.0607145205,
-0.0460670665,
-0.0214120913,
0.0243487824,
0.0393207446,
0.0050528552,
0.0389189944,
-0.0316747241,
0.0011599502,
0.0800761729,
0.0652056634,
0.0234855283,
0.045907829,
0.0320842825,
0.0071606487,
0.0307398625,
-0.0526916496,
-0.0220676959,
0.0012596441,
0.0410766751,
0.0061911787,
0.0389715321,
0.0772336572,
0.0126795694,
0.0050730132,
0.0154316006,
-0.0399950854,
-0.03849243,
-0.0309520271,
0.0050670975,
-0.0053908448,
-0.0322216377,
0.0426786654,
0.004180673,
-0.0752154887,
0.0325083882,
0.03012757,
-0.0110025462,
-0.0047938442,
0.0593628883,
0.031484846,
-0.0323191844,
-0.0223090481,
-0.0101761995,
0.0983196795,
-0.0125120794,
0.0365341753,
0.0684259236,
-0.0382303149,
0.0171579923,
0.026918279,
-0.0013954529,
0.0179365817,
-0.0006167182,
0.0384259745,
0.0708178654,
-0.0696737617,
-0.0731642023,
0.0584482923,
-0.0405330621,
-0.0177750979,
-0.0047877012,
0.0121133951,
0.0238396246,
-0.0045472397,
-0.0099876868,
-0.0383133665,
0.007504472,
-0.0566329882,
0.0010541178,
0.0146374637,
-0.010516827,
-0.0105083287,
0.0608344674,
-0.0745224208,
-0.0106399246,
0.0348265059,
-0.0004144744,
-0.0455360711,
0.0073527265,
-0.0150761483,
0.0013158353,
0.0038532629,
0.0248900596,
-0.0001951356,
-0.0002871259,
-0.0253791772,
0.0131110782,
0.0086743562,
0.0256724954,
0.0282645598,
-0.0758782178,
0.0591799207,
0.0133710057,
-0.0356951915,
-0.0115465652,
0.0009261695,
0.0088722939,
0.0325295851,
0.0047212592,
0.0174658,
-0.0476120077,
-0.0556299947,
0.0238501374,
-0.0113537405,
0.0404459536,
0.0427191779,
0.0623825453,
0.0035814722,
0.0112658879,
0.0043432191,
0.0238166768,
-0.01966694,
-0.0062429016,
-0.0046568243,
-0.020155061,
0.0385122746,
-0.0129643586,
-0.0038315027,
0.0218730289,
0.052779261,
0.055806201,
0.0013302849,
-0.0566181839,
-0.0286906008,
-0.0176420379,
0.0016780531,
0.0123379109,
-0.0267385878,
0.0045665321,
-0.0127964597,
0.0060339756,
-0.0037810202,
-0.0134923356,
-0.0553518683,
-0.0238641705,
0.0243284255,
-0.0485994332,
0.0118594216,
0.0074981716,
-0.0574243478,
-0.0305377264,
-0.0571839884,
-0.0166156758,
0.0139314821,
0.019458212,
-0.00140023,
-0.0517389737,
0.0308865216,
-0.0268674344,
-0.0137358578,
-0.0014342943,
0.00545055,
-0.0154433753,
0.0374703854,
-0.0412289537,
-0.0400573313,
0.0068769385,
-0.0158890337,
-0.0327869244,
-0.0384791493,
0.0401129313,
-0.0434745923,
0.0003325185,
-0.0176561903,
0.0066302246,
-0.0257855859,
-0.021649776,
-0.0375641063,
0.0575626604,
0.0006731145,
-0.0002124541,
0.0610164069,
-0.00366009,
-0.0010800312,
-0.0410399251,
0.0016741412,
0.0238027405,
-0.0080866888,
0.0012836846,
-0.0312914886,
0.0302310232,
-0.0028413311,
-0.0124117965,
0.0155035807,
-0.0104585765,
0.0329655893,
0.0060350867,
-0.0108966902,
-0.019979585,
0.0260600075,
-0.054344859,
-0.0114116799,
0.0404901579,
-0.0581863821,
0.0059106392,
-0.0025627243,
-0.0166899357,
-0.0008756185,
-0.045070406,
-0.0135827642,
0.0190737415,
0.0049539981,
-0.0427281186,
-0.0048832605,
0.0198316779,
-0.0145163145,
-0.008795986,
0.1199391335,
0.0202760678,
-0.0626140982,
0.0218043216,
-0.049871657,
0.0169879105,
-0.0019004558,
0.050645005,
-0.1112514585,
-0.0094219241,
-0.0060518812,
0.0493160635,
0.0562899597,
-0.043612577,
0.0094561987,
-0.0618180372,
-0.011301619,
0.0445610359,
-0.0176383909,
-0.0404706933,
-0.0011805296,
-0.0335921831,
-0.0292414259,
0.006171992,
0.0200931933,
0.0174345709,
0.0040186401,
-0.0076514147,
0.0869005844,
-0.0640002042,
0.0116165988,
-0.0537341535,
0.0378268473,
0.0177563839,
0.0470504239,
-0.1024992466,
0.0534253344,
0.0023425266,
-0.0089296065,
-0.0121833896,
0.018090941,
0.0057983743,
0.0601554476,
-0.0398162045,
0.0092811417,
-0.0215611253,
-0.0155094946,
0.0238468517,
0.0321277417,
0.0416494794,
-0.0040597562,
0.0118722599,
0.0253446121,
0.0286837015,
0.0027088183,
0.0610649511,
0.0188556239,
-0.0535013825,
0.007043594,
-0.0126963239,
0.013575471,
-0.0360622518,
-0.0529545322,
-0.0024960714,
0.0000168843,
-0.0343800075,
-0.1190796718,
-0.038848035,
-0.0406897962,
0.0563371666,
0.0639431104,
-0.0358714797,
0.0567059368,
-0.0309245735,
-0.0363245234,
0.0300934464,
-0.010641994,
0.0376258455,
-0.0560845062,
0.0378018916,
-0.0143256364,
-0.0152726602,
0.0026326254,
0.0079250447,
-0.0394119173,
-0.0696484149,
0.0275915321,
0.0168737229,
0.030316839,
0.0099748103,
-0.0302259289,
-0.0284290351,
-0.0246086195,
0.021514656,
-0.012776453,
0.0582252033,
0.011545877,
0.0180120543,
-0.030531358,
0.0587052256,
0.0170572661,
0.0124557763,
0.0086046001,
0.0129075404,
0.0227743592,
-0.0782360807,
-0.0139751537,
-0.020754803,
-0.0111750783,
-0.0372925028,
-0.0122614652,
-0.0161344297,
0.0006109342,
0.0041222447,
0.0136323301,
-0.0436787419,
0.0196148884,
0.0541451313,
0.0242378451,
0.0200293753,
0.005731829,
0.0290947482,
-0.0232883357,
-0.0441236719,
0.0317532644,
0.0033650552,
0.0509454124,
-0.0403200462,
0.0305952113,
-0.0133755784,
0.0050880206,
-0.0116564613,
0.0933955684,
-0.0513794795,
0.0558961146,
-0.0106250336,
0.0249806698,
0.0151832001,
-0.0107791163,
-0.0219044816,
-0.0167719442,
-0.0216434356,
-0.027210094,
0.0506245643,
0.0154197756,
0.0985525474,
0.0021138196,
-0.0303543266,
-0.0291029457,
0.006658074,
-0.0018927071,
0.0409736447,
-0.0464685075,
-0.0082358811,
0.0241294019,
0.0493433625,
0.0288231242,
0.0074098352,
0.0165362284,
0.0695865154,
0.0291118212,
-0.0154418526,
-0.0106921494,
0.0008974174,
-0.0302521791,
-0.0271815378,
0.0231545381,
-0.0551019907,
-0.0263720676,
0.0078215385,
0.0538156554,
-0.0090196934,
-0.0219555628,
-0.0047051022,
0.0393953063,
-0.038349025,
0.0267832577,
-0.0593479015,
0.0304966457,
-0.0213508029,
-0.0028274776,
-0.0471014492,
-5.596456973e-33,
-0.0428094417,
0.0452429764,
0.0301672351,
-0.0364347994,
-0.027736403,
-0.0002609879,
-0.011770525,
-0.0118800132,
-0.040454112,
0.0009601623,
0.0029529026,
-0.0105666677,
0.0195113458,
0.0067462143,
0.033959154,
0.0424154848,
0.0518365279,
0.0428916104,
-0.0614676885,
0.0225513559,
0.0508467369,
0.0175191984,
0.0852028653,
-0.0541575588,
0.0301335398,
-0.0133772483,
0.0252675451,
-0.0442508198,
0.0463722795,
-0.0003760566,
0.0107486602,
-0.0141010005,
-0.0172757115,
-0.0368215628,
-0.0136444727,
-0.0346285217,
-0.0476617329,
0.0066547869,
0.0318374746,
0.0481548645,
-0.0062195598,
-0.0039328458,
0.0276517589,
-0.0253931116,
-0.0311202779,
-0.0420198627,
0.0045665125,
-0.02705645,
-0.0912347659,
-0.0381323583,
-0.0596501641,
0.0457322523,
-0.0040760362,
-0.0175999347,
-0.0128523875,
0.061398685,
-0.0717249289,
0.0070688413,
-0.0860717818,
-0.0639361516,
-0.007524943,
0.0743716583,
-0.0165373478,
0.0015700096,
-0.0446353108,
-0.0141767198,
0.0421139263,
0.009644649,
0.073182106,
0.0625312179,
0.0283364076,
-0.0330487937,
0.0686809942,
0.0301238578,
0.0243823156,
0.0205062665,
-0.0357015356,
0.0094674304,
0.0215198565,
-0.0255748983,
0.0211132541,
-0.0226804707,
-0.0425122455,
0.0007037382,
-0.079878591,
-0.0949630961,
0.0146545572,
0.0074250996,
0.0335777216,
0.0068667154,
-0.0009322158,
0.0076097064,
0.0400623307,
-0.0428847224,
0.0237938967,
0.0080520986,
-0.0147724114,
0.0230323337,
-0.0284404662,
0.0159843322,
-0.0166690331,
-0.0232964419,
-0.0015004653,
0.0292675532,
0.0194721222,
-0.0439960584,
0.0354239754,
-0.0111740446,
-0.0405469015,
-0.0067394665,
-0.0451830588,
-0.0250353888,
0.0054643773,
0.0467641205,
0.0080051506,
-0.0258548185,
0.0287254341,
0.0232254863,
0.04656047,
-0.0490146689,
0.0333971567,
0.0312121212,
0.0684206411,
0.0146869337,
-0.0426854789,
0.0086946674,
-0.0089422027,
0.0801239908,
0.0460087284,
-0.0465700999,
-0.0049420623,
0.0543092713,
2.725e-7,
0.0665960982,
-0.0025113504,
0.0516377501,
-0.0250087101,
-0.0239944421,
0.0402378291,
-0.02639376,
-0.0001000448,
-0.0040733721,
0.033116471,
-0.017005749,
-0.013403086,
0.1102592349,
-0.0283405799,
-0.0616482571,
-0.0527919494,
-0.0554188453,
0.0053602033,
-0.0490610749,
-0.0209264886,
-0.0101554254,
0.096001178,
-0.0320899375,
-0.055025328,
0.0067369244,
-0.0252201613,
0.0666975826,
-0.0149871744,
-0.0352558047,
-0.0154499523,
0.0468584299,
0.0474007875,
-0.0246693101,
-0.0119841155,
-0.0338860229,
0.0214458443,
0.0050778249,
0.0368945971,
0.0271553472,
0.0164940562,
-0.0104325386,
-0.0117959455,
-0.0687233731,
-0.011872719,
0.0452460274,
-0.0433334894,
-0.0106095029,
0.0373417027,
-0.0467137583,
0.048824355,
0.0146357007,
0.0007739922,
-0.0361231454,
0.0177840069,
0.0691135973,
-0.0372492932,
-0.0275227521,
-0.0213310588,
0.0153557258,
0.0391535833,
-0.0037804416,
-0.0064071692,
-0.029337801,
0.0383144654,
-0.0063059102,
-0.0260118078,
-0.0153869223,
2.30112593e-34,
0.0428945906,
-0.0502291396,
0.0457554869,
-0.0143437544,
0.0116681717,
-0.0352603756,
-0.0049135704,
-0.0474227183,
-0.0507411957,
-0.021898048,
-0.0038149017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11046v1 | Affective social anthropomorphic intelligent system | 2023-04-19T18:24:57 | 2023-04-19T18:24:57 | Md. Adyelullahil Mamun, Hasnat Md. Abdullah, Md. Golam Rabiul Alam, Muhammad Mehedi Hassan, Md. Zia Uddin | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Human conversational styles are measured by the sense of humor, personality,
and tone of voice. These characteristics have become essential for
conversational intelligent virtual assistants. However, most of the
state-of-the-art intelligent virtual assistants (IVAs) are failed to interpret
the affective semantics of human voices. This research proposes an
anthropomorphic intelligent system that can hold a proper human-like
conversation with emotion and personality. A voice style transfer method is
also proposed to map the attributes of a specific emotion. Initially, the
frequency domain data (Mel-Spectrogram) is created by converting the temporal
audio wave data, which comprises discrete patterns for audio features such as
notes, pitch, rhythm, and melody. A collateral CNN-Transformer-Encoder is used
to predict seven different affective states from voice. The voice is also fed
parallelly to the deep-speech, an RNN model that generates the text
transcription from the spectrogram. Then the transcripted text is transferred
to the multi-domain conversation agent using blended skill talk,
transformer-based retrieve-and-generate generation strategy, and beam-search
decoding, and an appropriate textual response is generated. The system learns
an invertible mapping of data to a latent space that can be manipulated and
generates a Mel-spectrogram frame based on previous Mel-spectrogram frames to
voice synthesize and style transfer. Finally, the waveform is generated using
WaveGlow from the spectrogram. The outcomes of the studies we conducted on
individual models were auspicious. Furthermore, users who interacted with the
system provided positive feedback, demonstrating the system's effectiveness. | [
0.02654613,
0.0279954299,
-0.0445758812,
-0.0110687856,
-0.0083101839,
-0.0150566669,
0.0310970489,
-0.0364280567,
-0.0353153348,
-0.0001158266,
-0.0745254308,
-0.0538192354,
-0.0179218855,
0.0459819697,
0.0048343767,
-0.1021081731,
0.0061515486,
0.0143913347,
0.0459892564,
-0.0234460309,
0.0065661529,
0.0280743781,
-0.0456276275,
0.0188282207,
-0.0509711951,
-0.0047352375,
-0.0364900194,
0.0018720212,
0.0539184362,
0.0037284517,
0.0154800601,
-0.0089801876,
0.0223282948,
-0.0157041997,
0.0000018394,
-0.0073257429,
0.0019979423,
-0.0165154692,
0.0337876342,
-0.0594028607,
0.073836945,
0.041029688,
-0.0574718192,
0.0381504856,
-0.0418789573,
-0.0321066752,
0.0499865524,
0.0298201218,
0.1041354984,
0.0742010623,
-0.0399106406,
-0.0415910594,
0.0102941599,
0.0105190314,
-0.0030689982,
-0.0135902828,
-0.0178693738,
-0.0059066783,
0.0444110483,
-0.0166502837,
-0.0010364517,
0.0235676821,
-0.0046224715,
-0.0083872331,
0.0522112548,
-0.0169580113,
-0.0313188583,
-0.0527125709,
0.002361859,
0.0719682947,
0.032548748,
0.0144917909,
0.023731295,
0.0442727879,
0.0537298918,
0.0215719827,
0.0032490995,
0.003561415,
-0.0107994461,
-0.0100083752,
-0.0181835406,
0.0587622598,
-0.0446183421,
-0.0067435377,
0.0096591432,
-0.0061767497,
0.0037392769,
-0.0184186585,
0.0016654081,
-0.0459617935,
0.0160481166,
0.0024827593,
0.0487113148,
0.0218126718,
-0.0046573798,
0.0205889475,
-0.0557853244,
-0.0395417102,
-0.0452286229,
-0.0352073051,
0.0148068042,
0.0172744915,
-0.0625353456,
-0.0089927968,
0.0185700636,
0.0022797147,
0.021481296,
-0.0423374027,
-0.0386207141,
-0.0384168401,
-0.0520706847,
0.0055480939,
-0.0429325551,
0.0349809341,
0.0113559347,
-0.0243552402,
-0.0627212897,
0.0182060599,
-0.0673129037,
0.0094907396,
-0.0172281843,
0.0330137536,
-0.0319404304,
0.0225445312,
-0.0049497881,
0.0284768809,
-0.0271374024,
0.0416929014,
-0.0001564298,
-0.0510726646,
0.0404423513,
0.0210159477,
0.0524149127,
0.0003987182,
0.054738231,
0.047186546,
-0.0031197898,
-0.0414961427,
0.0156947561,
-0.0210012943,
-0.0069000297,
-0.044847101,
0.0437930226,
-0.0345596299,
0.0429627188,
-0.024624452,
-0.0335952826,
-0.0077182245,
-0.0074090906,
-0.0137157002,
0.0172718987,
0.0291563403,
-0.0112738144,
0.0306177437,
0.0490056574,
0.0038365764,
0.0132445861,
-0.0182811413,
0.0450590625,
0.02231027,
-0.0126099158,
-0.0598480329,
0.0413115099,
0.022295,
-0.0106078526,
-0.034083955,
-0.0136966528,
-0.039557755,
-0.0394461229,
0.0539429225,
0.0401186422,
0.0293994024,
-0.0058036773,
-0.0235491693,
0.0436506197,
0.0235917885,
0.0329156592,
0.0981706902,
0.0176537354,
0.0567008965,
0.0460755676,
-0.0292480029,
0.0079704178,
0.0549625717,
-0.0408682823,
-0.0077399723,
-0.0296414178,
0.0160727613,
-0.0552148037,
-0.0156186139,
0.0271862671,
-0.0310639348,
0.0299148038,
0.0005990737,
0.0143129816,
0.0063047102,
-0.0312251374,
0.0186167415,
-0.0079435278,
-0.0659602582,
-0.0193177089,
0.004377583,
0.0004165053,
0.0812453032,
-0.0092605734,
-0.0317653492,
0.0028271338,
-0.0147048151,
-0.0377024151,
0.0123847201,
0.0214060657,
-0.0186869092,
0.0045199981,
-0.028585963,
0.0318252631,
0.0141041139,
-0.0390067697,
0.0526206307,
-0.0598667264,
0.0402611829,
-0.0061411755,
0.0370405465,
0.0515419431,
-0.033692386,
-0.0337037593,
-0.0111456867,
0.0056510693,
0.0335800722,
0.0441466421,
0.069239445,
-0.008957155,
-0.0220646467,
0.0139335003,
-0.0174865145,
-0.0196484532,
0.0716573223,
-0.0209654309,
0.0085224966,
0.0312706046,
-0.0646574944,
0.0217082221,
0.0678234324,
0.0136131505,
-0.0528072715,
0.0693504587,
-0.0685964897,
0.027381165,
0.0089866389,
0.0204684958,
0.0072683576,
0.0631122217,
0.0578858927,
-0.0129088648,
0.041636616,
-0.0515771434,
-0.0243822951,
0.0090678195,
-0.0337162428,
-0.0293168016,
-0.0051762983,
0.0183169991,
-0.0065795463,
-0.0029128783,
-0.0208584294,
-0.0601848178,
-0.0484777614,
-0.0359014086,
-0.1288615316,
0.0030121133,
0.0445262678,
-0.0454825945,
-0.0009194857,
0.0077111032,
-0.0149497772,
-0.0295689534,
-0.0821787417,
0.0370843895,
0.0008360108,
-0.0111950701,
0.0222974643,
-0.006244841,
-0.0350168459,
-0.0426887982,
0.0104843145,
-0.0189101249,
-0.0110241622,
-0.0269336272,
-0.0046356283,
-0.0252810027,
0.0269420482,
-0.0356905237,
0.0573194176,
-0.0078443903,
-0.0724444389,
-0.0001923687,
-0.0073865191,
0.0230171904,
0.0509810224,
0.0585599057,
0.0184434187,
0.0107929101,
0.00018368,
-0.03877661,
0.0401266925,
0.0068308059,
0.0859518796,
-0.0134993382,
-0.0033264265,
-0.0181669984,
-0.0117057506,
0.0403942131,
0.0444373377,
-0.0321958959,
0.0326223709,
0.0674208701,
-0.0304306298,
0.0733169168,
-0.0100319507,
-0.0039179139,
-0.0139321247,
0.0382122919,
0.0048530502,
0.0520290658,
0.0116536766,
-0.0632031411,
-0.0388965569,
-0.040410392,
-0.0000893976,
0.0131226098,
-0.0552331842,
0.0131829921,
0.0016492566,
-0.0128199505,
-0.0206576493,
-0.0239068121,
-0.0011757994,
-0.0720039085,
-0.0024453092,
-0.0204555802,
-0.0512180179,
0.0104884012,
-0.011279596,
-0.0337887108,
-0.0262034051,
-0.0363254845,
0.0021836951,
0.014726623,
-0.0202323273,
-0.0138852587,
-0.0067844023,
0.0258670058,
-0.0265920907,
-0.0086859819,
0.0026156222,
-0.00654436,
0.00528066,
0.0703945979,
0.0478578471,
-0.0169927031,
0.0200420767,
0.0440198258,
-0.0098447576,
-0.0114532169,
-0.0018369241,
-0.0309207533,
0.0056789247,
0.0067042504,
0.0144495871,
-0.022000622,
-0.0044601965,
0.0282338578,
-0.0033819908,
0.0333224051,
0.1045375094,
0.0139180534,
-0.0157540962,
0.0063960506,
0.0042821392,
-0.0417024828,
-0.0141801098,
0.0679866746,
-0.014875737,
-0.001958726,
0.0334700085,
0.0268198755,
0.0154974265,
-0.0030615465,
-0.0026083242,
-0.0626752526,
0.0266528856,
0.0318962298,
-0.0274802186,
-0.0209850036,
0.0030112457,
0.0099551482,
-0.0151817203,
-0.0029720257,
-0.0580187961,
0.0115047907,
-0.0227067843,
0.0038104586,
-0.0210055243,
0.0007058182,
0.0417790338,
-0.0292095058,
0.1020399556,
0.0526700579,
0.1052462682,
-0.0233083684,
-0.0521196723,
-0.0798135251,
0.0540410317,
0.0396038964,
0.0149580631,
0.0471168011,
-0.0190714002,
-0.0090496335,
-0.0116663789,
0.0529471375,
-0.0161043741,
0.0473378859,
0.0108163171,
0.0090228831,
-0.0641955808,
-0.0380355343,
-0.0350132324,
0.0411461368,
0.0310681667,
0.0398743637,
-0.0248584878,
-0.0730920956,
0.00884875,
0.015258736,
0.0307622794,
-0.0368672349,
-0.0617935173,
-0.0053167394,
0.0183799565,
-0.0337135494,
-0.061083883,
-0.059440311,
-0.0171169546,
0.0378814265,
-0.0165016726,
-0.0816712752,
0.0507053062,
0.0269569587,
-0.0195424035,
-0.0048275553,
0.0221032482,
0.026832955,
0.0030210044,
-0.0464967079,
0.0585689358,
-0.0920778513,
0.0146655217,
-0.0491259582,
0.0156933833,
-0.0115967216,
0.0618618578,
0.0155890612,
0.0100274887,
0.0412202291,
0.0094829919,
-0.060260348,
0.0264382418,
-0.0152590591,
-0.0598630346,
-0.0033380224,
0.075902082,
0.0327956378,
-0.0038013931,
0.0058859526,
-0.0359696038,
0.0774163082,
-0.0233335793,
-0.0100455452,
0.015244633,
-0.074994497,
-0.0096936682,
0.0106472652,
0.0090230238,
0.0128160436,
-0.0054229163,
0.0157293119,
-0.0282367468,
-0.021302795,
0.043879535,
-0.0598648004,
-0.0403524153,
-0.008464667,
0.0327396356,
0.000754991,
-0.0634152219,
-0.0034596887,
-0.047463201,
0.0126418974,
0.0476881899,
-0.0092477929,
-0.0089119915,
-0.027197212,
0.0190807823,
0.0265874062,
0.0181745999,
0.0345405526,
0.017194761,
0.0085509596,
0.0354695171,
-0.0073573017,
-0.0253055673,
-0.0012626076,
0.0681974664,
-0.0367814489,
0.0015406876,
0.0097657777,
0.0125647625,
0.0058090766,
-0.004713831,
0.0255092271,
-0.0449278727,
0.0621424243,
-0.0187291689,
0.0246781074,
-0.0296085738,
-0.0191479456,
0.0203646813,
-0.0068717683,
-0.0066842553,
-0.0246949792,
0.0143461246,
-0.0512560755,
0.0345517695,
-0.065329574,
-0.0013183733,
-0.0639804453,
0.0234198067,
-0.0053660301,
-0.014360684,
-0.0043485658,
-0.00424348,
-0.0338132009,
-0.04108027,
0.0476637818,
-0.05093183,
-0.0169795919,
-0.0616495609,
0.0372299254,
0.0074214116,
-0.0365100466,
0.0244576521,
-0.0096259462,
-0.0060824966,
-0.0271845497,
-0.0086013442,
-0.007662124,
-5.544421511e-33,
-0.0197069366,
0.010856024,
-0.027132513,
0.0570565388,
-0.0240579136,
-0.0479718745,
-0.0379955471,
0.0173086058,
-0.0290477332,
0.0018604062,
-0.0318895131,
0.0207975451,
0.016257681,
0.0144824367,
0.0074746246,
0.0140444627,
0.0442509316,
-0.0176095553,
0.0408321209,
0.0360498391,
0.037247967,
0.0635343269,
0.0361007228,
-0.1303707063,
-0.0488218851,
-0.0082333656,
0.018007813,
-0.0321543738,
0.0665092245,
0.008882964,
0.0130652161,
0.0444787145,
-0.020795133,
-0.0139282336,
-0.0114187784,
0.024388181,
-0.0401680917,
-0.0410029143,
-0.0103517557,
0.0356676243,
-0.0199829098,
-0.0404080674,
0.0069359643,
-0.0016015976,
-0.012467863,
-0.0242598802,
0.0542512164,
-0.0268723685,
0.0413085483,
-0.0739023611,
-0.0550805479,
-0.003057918,
-0.0097294254,
-0.0671112463,
0.0416839831,
0.0779958591,
0.0051228744,
-0.0369123667,
-0.037514247,
0.0589644089,
-0.0697065815,
-0.02305655,
0.016535325,
0.0002004111,
0.0151577601,
0.0353377238,
0.073568888,
-0.0125425654,
-0.0138431434,
0.0300230868,
0.0373446532,
0.072958447,
0.0276861936,
0.009827897,
-0.0044969353,
-0.0495408699,
0.027950298,
0.026811203,
0.0707822591,
-0.0245282352,
0.002373297,
0.0292111672,
-0.0561184958,
0.0214949548,
0.012088743,
-0.002943733,
-0.0117061371,
-0.0653834343,
-0.0022871117,
-0.0178164486,
0.0109523926,
-0.0117060887,
0.0063802903,
-0.0467314348,
0.0337060206,
0.0168708377,
-0.0461353064,
0.0389664546,
-0.0097477781,
-0.0356267504,
0.0004329169,
-0.0397156402,
0.0794726834,
0.0529501848,
0.0550809912,
0.0233099796,
-0.0286445655,
0.073009938,
-0.0024380768,
-0.0317063592,
0.0181709919,
0.0372328199,
0.014147318,
0.00482945,
-0.0147140268,
0.0377797075,
-0.0374860577,
0.0065756133,
-0.0081616491,
0.0583597086,
-0.0467760563,
-0.0302307345,
0.0155810341,
0.0023428774,
-0.0578431226,
0.0072310735,
-0.0398705006,
-0.0466591269,
0.0062246779,
-0.0165863242,
-0.001777972,
-0.0055721919,
2.929e-7,
-0.0741698369,
0.0267678704,
0.0279544331,
-0.0082900273,
0.0390428714,
0.0650100484,
0.0105259977,
0.0228921771,
0.02903983,
0.0061168768,
0.052735284,
-0.0245463196,
0.0658556372,
0.0210179593,
-0.0859073251,
-0.0434517376,
-0.0136215072,
-0.011561011,
0.0078395838,
0.0307238288,
0.0831975341,
0.0767474994,
0.032247141,
-0.0446719639,
0.0346361063,
0.0543495528,
0.0117647946,
-0.0029443,
0.004451721,
-0.0328109451,
-0.0203695241,
-0.0170159694,
-0.0111895623,
0.0194462296,
-0.0045193178,
0.0146436701,
-0.0003825856,
0.0366485007,
-0.0196433887,
-0.055589918,
0.02345578,
0.0733478814,
-0.0222732965,
0.0498204753,
0.0200626794,
-0.0309615824,
-0.0702022463,
-0.018778719,
-0.0515356548,
0.0108544426,
-0.0301016457,
0.0009513314,
-0.0137513094,
0.0035800769,
-0.004421215,
-0.0272526015,
0.0027846566,
-0.0758480877,
0.0368536487,
-0.0096878083,
-0.0626386851,
-0.0190963093,
-0.0107049523,
-0.016669618,
0.0458354354,
-0.016234152,
0.0007820547,
1.650732138e-34,
-0.0177165102,
0.0236820485,
-0.0081291329,
-0.0072389795,
-0.0067002722,
0.0285707526,
0.0277970433,
0.0269739665,
0.0575142279,
-0.0441689901,
-0.0458694622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11053v1 | A Comparison of Semi-Supervised Learning Techniques for Streaming ASR at Scale | 2023-04-19T18:09:27 | 2023-04-19T18:09:27 | Cal Peyser, Michael Picheny, Kyunghyun Cho, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Ronny Huang, Tara Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Unpaired text and audio injection have emerged as dominant methods for
improving ASR performance in the absence of a large labeled corpus. However,
little guidance exists on deploying these methods to improve production ASR
systems that are trained on very large supervised corpora and with realistic
requirements like a constrained model size and CPU budget, streaming
capability, and a rich lattice for rescoring and for downstream NLU tasks. In
this work, we compare three state-of-the-art semi-supervised methods
encompassing both unpaired text and audio as well as several of their
combinations in a controlled setting using joint training. We find that in our
setting these methods offer many improvements beyond raw WER, including
substantial gains in tail-word WER, decoder computation during inference, and
lattice density. | [
-0.0147021906,
0.0574204773,
0.0421841219,
0.0273260195,
0.0026567422,
0.008007546,
0.0249958169,
-0.0280060098,
-0.0159917194,
-0.0287380349,
-0.0533923842,
-0.0141249271,
-0.0059912247,
0.0241297055,
0.0254551768,
-0.0062940815,
0.0032451693,
-0.0482013039,
-0.0199884698,
-0.0308517274,
0.0109037003,
0.0255654138,
-0.0449787863,
-0.0232349485,
0.0018153276,
0.0374766253,
-0.0019229248,
0.053358499,
0.0411351547,
-0.0069986847,
-0.0236186963,
-0.0121789007,
0.0572722629,
0.0473324805,
0.0000017057,
-0.0246342048,
-0.0303250775,
0.0040854812,
-0.0786061734,
0.0011359459,
0.0059360331,
-0.0579925999,
-0.0361360349,
0.0635077059,
-0.0076942607,
-0.0341695398,
0.0388459638,
0.0150541589,
0.0085189426,
0.0422677919,
-0.0163691994,
-0.0389375836,
0.0203411095,
-0.0246613584,
-0.0460412689,
-0.0385971069,
-0.0213944316,
-0.0268430449,
-0.0180640984,
0.0179213304,
-0.0275434926,
0.0613871887,
0.0315678902,
-0.037230026,
0.0188693535,
0.004999619,
-0.0698940605,
-0.004384988,
-0.0367423259,
0.0527040251,
0.0442007631,
-0.0172980912,
0.0041868608,
0.0138003817,
-0.0419548266,
-0.0341347642,
-0.0229595471,
0.0606875159,
-0.0140797189,
0.0153336124,
-0.0370259881,
0.0346650518,
0.027233649,
-0.0025010728,
0.0009278081,
0.0255457778,
0.016507823,
-0.0326748118,
0.0259338114,
0.0322718024,
0.0298473164,
-0.0204833765,
0.0519406907,
-0.0145914229,
-0.0131947044,
-0.0082032597,
-0.0290832147,
0.0064845067,
-0.0303859599,
-0.0135177718,
0.044807747,
0.0559082776,
-0.0174313653,
0.0395296291,
0.0030685971,
-0.0162411164,
0.0269855037,
0.0134426188,
-0.0228173267,
0.0164884869,
-0.0293755662,
-0.0029034859,
-0.0169606376,
0.0434469879,
-0.0429348871,
-0.0533535592,
-0.0279654022,
0.0167911686,
0.0187279992,
-0.0087910742,
0.0405818224,
-0.0006484371,
-0.0446906649,
-0.0070793815,
0.0623304546,
0.0726283938,
-0.0113758855,
0.0441996343,
0.0043545584,
-0.0526218563,
-0.0191967003,
0.019030923,
0.0422230996,
-0.0315607227,
0.0063306903,
-0.0005399081,
-0.0230698064,
-0.0251624454,
-0.0348370522,
0.0097409384,
-0.0419744067,
-0.0578311794,
-0.0258303471,
-0.0342021547,
0.0277544558,
0.0046655289,
0.0207135901,
-0.0329983197,
0.0104341637,
-0.0070122443,
0.0655421317,
0.0864458159,
-0.0041102599,
-0.0062014549,
-0.0089042624,
0.0075770761,
0.0320462398,
0.0970717296,
0.0295712873,
0.0129994564,
0.0042047389,
-0.021377774,
-0.0468703844,
0.0199776292,
0.0070801955,
0.024263721,
-0.032084208,
-0.0231127702,
0.0207526684,
0.0196523555,
0.0830381885,
0.0588727035,
-0.0312825181,
-0.0193095207,
0.0310748499,
0.0231046509,
0.0183864161,
-0.0026657972,
0.0426535681,
0.0307568647,
0.0142190931,
0.0118569387,
0.0552162305,
0.0090928562,
0.0248253345,
0.0224408619,
0.0538512133,
0.0400553197,
-0.030628942,
-0.0306439325,
-0.0222806931,
-0.029081393,
-0.0447396338,
0.0639988482,
0.0447928607,
0.0463678725,
-0.0324879289,
-0.0208408497,
0.0048975768,
-0.0477561466,
0.0182757173,
-0.0209159683,
-0.0116111357,
0.0586633459,
0.0197847951,
-0.0375497229,
0.0091819065,
-0.0330573879,
0.0248739291,
0.0629756376,
-0.0199803896,
-0.0058271084,
0.0735828951,
-0.0536009297,
-0.017464472,
0.0087898904,
0.0133263133,
0.0718299747,
-0.0290487949,
0.0229095351,
-0.0025631294,
-0.0425884761,
0.0262613595,
-0.0014911739,
-0.0094317533,
-0.048844371,
0.0355446935,
-0.0043597789,
0.0373217128,
0.0596665032,
-0.0606510378,
-0.0139184184,
0.0282610245,
-0.0321403407,
-0.0504824892,
0.0225566532,
-0.0820986554,
-0.0868857577,
0.0195921883,
-0.0013408065,
0.0050646863,
0.0498336591,
-0.0035897417,
-0.0452372283,
0.014095,
0.0102994218,
0.072901614,
-0.0522379763,
0.029192904,
0.0874333903,
0.0287494548,
-0.012188849,
-0.0027745829,
0.0327519961,
0.0026005083,
-0.0268877223,
-0.0141624995,
0.0114738317,
-0.076949589,
0.0225461274,
0.0560886785,
-0.0242125299,
0.0104579832,
-0.00246073,
-0.0551739745,
0.007763071,
0.0148915472,
-0.0512722954,
-0.0103243608,
-0.0367033072,
0.0407962129,
-0.0265611038,
0.0373839363,
0.0044394536,
-0.0148072159,
0.0340292975,
-0.0866250917,
-0.0415336229,
0.0088006416,
-0.0492368899,
-0.0031038073,
0.019266326,
-0.0089819143,
-0.03546777,
0.0035424924,
0.0148620252,
0.0031359915,
-0.0339039527,
-0.0388251767,
0.0206377674,
0.0216489248,
-0.0041216197,
-0.0076466575,
-0.0079697603,
0.0021234916,
0.0148498965,
0.0321423896,
0.0301581956,
-0.0304365531,
0.013141267,
-0.013160822,
0.0105976313,
-0.058061026,
0.000042429,
0.0388742499,
0.000107297,
-0.015797453,
0.0595822856,
-0.0109862937,
0.0338440463,
0.0166911352,
0.0065799276,
-0.0001964899,
-0.0388263948,
-0.0380137339,
-0.0648556277,
-0.0394032225,
-0.0506919883,
-0.0372948274,
-0.0082426323,
0.0056560184,
-0.0045345617,
0.0350546017,
-0.0482800119,
-0.0499451496,
-0.0675033852,
-0.0584935136,
-0.0440773703,
-0.009012281,
0.0049292254,
0.0283918623,
-0.0394046083,
-0.0360250883,
0.0007046663,
0.0450678132,
0.0085566947,
-0.0063464679,
0.0240317322,
-0.0126466407,
0.0353264324,
-0.027788097,
-0.075543575,
-0.0176429991,
-0.0027684779,
-0.0101179956,
0.0145713342,
0.0410423614,
-0.0415926799,
0.004313698,
0.0434595831,
0.0065159453,
0.0603094511,
0.0312833935,
-0.0079589104,
-0.0317742303,
0.0469797924,
0.0393364429,
-0.0075785127,
-0.0403936654,
0.0088835135,
0.0498149507,
0.0417538919,
0.0831108168,
-0.0157317668,
-0.0393930823,
0.0240189396,
0.0419658609,
-0.0253612213,
0.0281153601,
0.0243940316,
0.034380082,
-0.0223357864,
0.0094724325,
0.1036764756,
0.0406237058,
-0.0260485597,
-0.0342915803,
0.0174546689,
0.0330513082,
0.0335848667,
-0.0158713385,
-0.079047747,
-0.0415342413,
0.0304688606,
0.0458489656,
0.052782435,
-0.000619104,
-0.0103693912,
-0.1121761575,
0.0448263548,
0.022221785,
-0.0367461443,
0.0099346032,
-0.0670203641,
-0.0255221929,
-0.0213469528,
0.0002454458,
-0.0141695505,
-0.0433539785,
-0.0086429091,
0.0605738088,
-0.0645449087,
-0.0718185529,
-0.0362941213,
-0.0589196272,
0.0874189362,
0.0511992052,
0.0079531008,
-0.0121139567,
0.0140329963,
0.0544925518,
-0.0239871368,
0.0047348179,
-0.0127271656,
0.0747727677,
-0.0324429497,
0.0054363073,
-0.0047285384,
0.0182360485,
-0.0065397713,
-0.0088526998,
-0.0019965479,
0.034684509,
-0.0138382129,
-0.0045742909,
0.0280087907,
0.0076709567,
0.0276881382,
0.0692106932,
-0.015916178,
0.0114952773,
-0.0294447988,
0.0237462521,
0.0498052426,
-0.0477978699,
-0.022614779,
-0.0014165877,
-0.0124676907,
-0.070481956,
-0.0365940891,
-0.0284346733,
0.0218319576,
0.0426665395,
0.0035633682,
0.0238144398,
-0.0063291043,
-0.0192447603,
-0.053666804,
-0.0253923722,
-0.0439751223,
0.0485596694,
-0.0346253365,
-0.0582157671,
0.0433411561,
-0.0262432043,
0.0104555544,
0.030438941,
-0.0577639155,
-0.0598457828,
0.0110768685,
-0.0318227522,
0.0156326257,
0.0535498038,
-0.0215747897,
-0.0001372744,
0.0644864291,
0.0607041977,
-0.0293257143,
0.0162342619,
0.0431902111,
0.0217938777,
-0.0003748611,
0.0219769701,
-0.0185298044,
0.0381444655,
-0.0407802351,
0.05308998,
-0.0312635452,
-0.0157707967,
0.0095718028,
0.0090904022,
0.0329032727,
-0.0241023768,
0.0021330051,
-0.0287928768,
0.043842528,
-0.0286467057,
0.0551361926,
-0.0412002653,
-0.0043201754,
0.0726903304,
0.0128663741,
-0.0416730419,
0.0902708918,
-0.0071837297,
-0.0014450939,
-0.0269684326,
0.0344273709,
0.0407867357,
-0.0506009832,
0.0017036205,
0.0361137167,
0.0215719324,
0.0482084677,
0.0832545534,
0.0596184283,
0.0056367503,
0.0090253921,
0.008387262,
0.0510347486,
0.0277014188,
0.0391960107,
-0.0407789163,
-0.0039221668,
-0.034759663,
0.0373188592,
0.0008742749,
-0.0036549785,
0.0581928045,
0.0183820333,
-0.0016709068,
-0.0238852687,
0.0128313964,
-0.0190100204,
-0.0147986822,
0.0602476411,
-0.0014973001,
-0.0365389399,
0.0609354153,
0.0526488684,
-0.0176011994,
0.0686498731,
-0.0084416866,
0.0154276704,
-0.0587282255,
-0.050070338,
-0.0442824923,
-0.026973078,
-0.0029959825,
-0.0270049442,
-0.0048677661,
-0.1037796587,
-0.0013678011,
-0.0690746829,
0.007989903,
-0.0345058106,
0.0061351391,
-0.0267388504,
-0.0114406804,
0.0147688808,
0.0124098016,
-0.0610504597,
-0.0311616659,
-0.0121600349,
0.0282095745,
-6.641032477e-33,
-0.0328307748,
0.0555898696,
0.0022674997,
-0.017354032,
-0.0185906738,
0.0286323708,
-0.0147143034,
-0.0041387188,
0.004742336,
-0.0123608178,
-0.0094573013,
0.0317980275,
0.0574498028,
0.028826043,
-0.0302512199,
-0.0268231258,
0.0909260213,
-0.0066819689,
-0.0279709529,
-0.0318947583,
0.0124803437,
0.059729185,
0.0176626984,
-0.0290564187,
-0.0295625776,
0.045350071,
0.0080318842,
-0.0236894842,
0.0188283976,
0.0236260258,
-0.0028222902,
0.0381617397,
-0.0248903297,
-0.0381066538,
-0.0219374858,
0.0544907413,
-0.0924182385,
0.005774084,
-0.0263396073,
0.0532572232,
-0.0324216597,
0.0018536414,
-0.0221675001,
0.0059047099,
-0.018579334,
-0.0180823468,
0.0217265282,
0.0096709356,
-0.0322647244,
-0.0877626017,
-0.0313280448,
0.0248833243,
-0.0462392978,
-0.0196048412,
0.0514218844,
0.0080092475,
0.0154081276,
-0.0072616138,
-0.0924671888,
0.0207440555,
-0.0268198848,
0.064983882,
0.0396214686,
-0.008849266,
-0.0304007493,
0.0121416096,
0.0269463956,
-0.0648804381,
-0.0168214347,
-0.0243231021,
-0.0018197979,
0.0271158814,
-0.0174087603,
0.0302415788,
0.0583441742,
-0.0119273793,
-0.0331729949,
-0.0094083128,
0.0048186444,
0.0220349655,
-0.0171535462,
0.0640951693,
-0.0478543788,
-0.0079553705,
-0.0307008326,
-0.0014796825,
-0.0183429923,
-0.0018942653,
0.0710216686,
0.0409283824,
-0.0227118824,
0.0172188263,
0.0418611988,
-0.0503676571,
-0.00864706,
0.0207422376,
0.0123768356,
0.0035688989,
0.0028555626,
0.0174794141,
-0.090160504,
0.0171700325,
0.0509859882,
0.0681956038,
-0.0093370518,
-0.044233989,
0.0250846483,
0.0794666708,
-0.0740993991,
0.0038699373,
-0.0351604074,
0.0189993437,
-0.0063985465,
-0.0062993369,
0.0185289122,
-0.0167800561,
-0.0257197414,
0.0562830754,
-0.0044394098,
0.0297297724,
0.0028039352,
-0.0179825835,
0.0008954339,
-0.0257294849,
-0.0206568204,
0.0345046744,
0.0236606542,
-0.0306764059,
0.0232360773,
-0.0587790348,
-0.0136461239,
0.0032155658,
2.599e-7,
0.0035058765,
0.0179892648,
0.0529126339,
-0.023130903,
-0.0218868572,
-0.0068511269,
-0.0189658627,
0.0008178123,
0.0191281158,
0.0292786639,
-0.0061107869,
0.0330502316,
0.0870949775,
0.0008475367,
-0.127534762,
-0.0071127312,
-0.0703158751,
0.0476514064,
-0.035881985,
-0.0503702573,
0.0191229582,
0.087980397,
-0.0301941205,
-0.0512181595,
0.0583795682,
-0.0338105038,
0.0387409627,
0.0454729274,
0.0021193197,
-0.0131141376,
-0.0240860712,
-0.0141121391,
-0.0374954753,
0.000095688,
-0.0466450043,
-0.0255920403,
0.0315379649,
0.014543144,
-0.0151584251,
-0.0544270612,
-0.0223930813,
0.0416427925,
0.0088642491,
0.0566400401,
0.0743071362,
0.0072135078,
-0.0436527617,
0.0153123243,
-0.0604003221,
-0.0454445109,
0.0045535364,
0.0118571948,
0.0053075696,
0.0069666188,
0.0148467114,
0.0169397965,
-0.0610215329,
-0.0518398918,
-0.0029741556,
-0.0180992633,
-0.0390785299,
-0.0232488234,
-0.0170587152,
0.032344494,
0.0106909005,
-0.0436061993,
-0.0232846271,
1.960831106e-34,
0.043677371,
0.0150497463,
0.0161372479,
0.0081220893,
0.0096492665,
-0.0251631644,
-0.0296258666,
-0.0042056269,
-0.0113811372,
-0.0511420928,
-0.017757142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09848v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09848v2 | Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines | 2023-04-19T17:56:12 | 2023-10-23T19:11:38 | Nelson F. Liu, Tianyi Zhang, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Generative search engines directly generate responses to user queries, along
with in-line citations. A prerequisite trait of a trustworthy generative search
engine is verifiability, i.e., systems should cite comprehensively (high
citation recall; all statements are fully supported by citations) and
accurately (high citation precision; every cite supports its associated
statement). We conduct human evaluation to audit four popular generative search
engines -- Bing Chat, NeevaAI, perplexity.ai, and YouChat -- across a diverse
set of queries from a variety of sources (e.g., historical Google user queries,
dynamically-collected open-ended questions on Reddit, etc.). We find that
responses from existing generative search engines are fluent and appear
informative, but frequently contain unsupported statements and inaccurate
citations: on average, a mere 51.5% of generated sentences are fully supported
by citations and only 74.5% of citations support their associated sentence. We
believe that these results are concerningly low for systems that may serve as a
primary tool for information-seeking users, especially given their facade of
trustworthiness. We hope that our results further motivate the development of
trustworthy generative search engines and help researchers and users better
understand the shortcomings of existing commercial systems. | [
0.0947388187,
0.0416349769,
-0.0231781378,
0.0002481061,
-0.0087875621,
-0.027093593,
-0.0007160633,
0.0333354361,
0.0618150532,
-0.02711525,
0.0022468448,
0.0106748762,
-0.0109864706,
0.0225907546,
0.0004237694,
-0.0316940621,
0.0286696963,
0.0255185589,
0.0396059938,
0.0034438309,
0.0099984063,
0.0264220163,
-0.0092559746,
0.0506384224,
0.0020645319,
-0.0272128675,
-0.0060135033,
0.0065250387,
0.0133329816,
-0.0427071489,
-0.0089903092,
0.0635166168,
-0.059369158,
0.0641643256,
0.0000017374,
-0.0569801219,
0.0382232703,
0.0057288567,
-0.0544450507,
0.0150493803,
0.0465599336,
0.0636026114,
-0.0041268873,
0.0370311178,
-0.0399813764,
-0.0268922038,
0.0539371744,
0.004438323,
0.0567857698,
0.036900118,
-0.0114390571,
0.0086792083,
0.0178547427,
-0.0094870776,
0.0458163507,
-0.0312104374,
-0.0118023558,
-0.0011297228,
0.0302124266,
0.027251238,
0.0218187161,
0.0496715084,
-0.011552738,
-0.0554488003,
0.0525054708,
0.0312981531,
-0.0253734831,
-0.0383249074,
0.0183495209,
0.0314203165,
0.0201321021,
-0.0216731913,
0.0187005624,
0.0173719004,
-0.0114341732,
0.0604920611,
-0.0241577718,
0.0174484812,
-0.0257454161,
-0.0351386182,
-0.0246919915,
-0.0141350497,
0.0331794769,
-0.0119002797,
0.0274301302,
0.0151683856,
0.0261312965,
-0.0229079053,
-0.0100290542,
0.0095925592,
0.0439579412,
-0.077306591,
-0.0119429976,
-0.0035229758,
-0.0425379649,
0.0058533847,
0.0116669657,
-0.0016124311,
0.0614715144,
-0.0068131872,
-0.0448468141,
0.0108200852,
-0.0128403343,
0.0375946425,
0.0252171308,
0.0176252276,
-0.0097749792,
-0.0083524603,
0.0133718327,
-0.025772484,
-0.0315703526,
0.001410119,
-0.0064067142,
-0.0143947573,
-0.0158283506,
0.0039765071,
-0.0569139048,
0.058457166,
-0.00087828,
0.022366114,
0.0126492232,
0.0230210051,
-0.0269937422,
0.0169901643,
-0.0450523272,
-0.0533634052,
-0.0356140733,
0.0304556619,
0.0161889941,
-0.0971616358,
0.0202385802,
0.0129204141,
0.0391800366,
-0.0036923715,
-0.0165065452,
0.0166944209,
0.0244639758,
-0.0059207487,
-0.0363828279,
-0.0695973784,
0.0014236954,
-0.0300430618,
-0.0331376418,
-0.0545839816,
0.0421656333,
0.0130393775,
-0.0233111996,
-0.0164586157,
-0.005944158,
0.0481216945,
-0.0206770971,
0.0275242813,
-0.055828888,
0.0212153625,
-0.0091509745,
0.0308358502,
0.01934845,
0.0164739974,
0.0146412281,
0.0616629533,
0.0627001598,
0.0204538852,
0.0525182374,
-0.0194430705,
0.017116854,
-0.016529467,
0.0555922352,
0.0220787786,
-0.0451520532,
-0.0070193056,
-0.0327905416,
0.0805905163,
-0.0486977547,
0.0082869623,
0.0768741369,
0.0423567519,
-0.0231588278,
0.0297568887,
0.0569886938,
-0.0085355779,
0.0199302398,
0.00718258,
-0.0472948886,
0.0117555968,
-0.0050970619,
-0.0157058239,
0.0603458323,
0.0150298588,
0.0021330724,
-0.0298152193,
-0.0073517598,
0.0094806906,
-0.0137346145,
-0.0083449334,
0.0044432031,
0.014954593,
-0.0343991853,
-0.0237368736,
-0.0134216724,
-0.0586777292,
-0.000740536,
-0.0309406836,
0.073104836,
0.0859981924,
0.0860187113,
0.045290038,
0.0359446481,
0.0071432618,
-0.0351164937,
0.0344999842,
0.0169037562,
-0.0166149568,
0.002073654,
-0.0103102401,
-0.0516337082,
-0.0033009995,
0.0097615877,
-0.0259990934,
0.0643314645,
0.0335035808,
0.007853481,
-0.0657783672,
-0.0170749146,
-0.0055201342,
0.0020682798,
-0.0045944494,
-0.0422714129,
0.0041209529,
0.0245099906,
0.0358239599,
0.0027601642,
0.0143265771,
0.0331161804,
0.0309343822,
-0.0451965407,
0.044273831,
0.0297131445,
0.0436691977,
-0.0167378485,
-0.0881896764,
-0.0093397629,
0.0234899968,
0.001060494,
0.0060983649,
-0.0064136479,
-0.0492838174,
0.0172937904,
-0.0499688536,
-0.0082278326,
-0.0028095634,
0.0179213174,
-0.0194046684,
0.0773673207,
0.0052834661,
0.0012628526,
-0.0173327699,
-0.0165163092,
0.0243564714,
-0.0428430177,
-0.0228907727,
0.0200654939,
-0.0065283952,
0.0231927168,
0.0434862785,
-0.0380984582,
-0.071264714,
0.0240630023,
-0.1041444913,
-0.0055803591,
-0.012975431,
0.0326779857,
0.0106105497,
0.0110079134,
0.0053972951,
-0.0126116406,
-0.0342763923,
-0.0167866275,
0.0234579183,
0.0054941983,
0.0526451804,
0.0163950976,
0.0086722821,
-0.0307747573,
-0.0079161096,
-0.0061974311,
0.0281706918,
0.0711442903,
0.0422981344,
-0.0453431904,
0.0313322134,
-0.0445266031,
-0.0144027332,
0.0113173984,
-0.0043131583,
0.0317820273,
0.0117527582,
0.0165398587,
0.01379521,
0.0615932941,
-0.0027794673,
0.0068779769,
0.0161321647,
-0.0448907763,
-0.0267311241,
-0.0222725216,
-0.0483008213,
-0.0009862138,
-0.079768829,
0.0297893006,
-0.021014804,
0.0023114157,
0.0044269115,
-0.0209216848,
0.0392121747,
0.0164318979,
-0.0209878162,
-0.0232933424,
-0.0087969806,
0.0011864059,
0.0744321495,
-0.0149674909,
-0.0390985496,
0.0427070782,
-0.0245154444,
0.0160098877,
-0.0121031608,
-0.0013193282,
0.019219175,
0.0492904037,
0.0063720723,
0.0178474449,
0.0357051939,
0.0136321774,
-0.0089401109,
0.0142471874,
0.0762011483,
-0.0577344745,
-0.0060932906,
0.0223282352,
0.0070713875,
0.0258232262,
-0.0498593748,
-0.0684338138,
-0.0499445349,
-0.0052321553,
-0.0025427709,
0.0702567846,
-0.0484279282,
-0.0246970728,
-0.0138224652,
0.0442882478,
-0.0087825116,
-0.0005136444,
-0.0676075965,
-0.0184786264,
0.0197723415,
0.0344439484,
-0.0053277323,
0.0305782557,
0.0119747762,
-0.0375906788,
0.0724342093,
0.0307512637,
-0.0261077452,
-0.0206039567,
-0.0692666546,
0.007092529,
-0.0364590511,
-0.0064590364,
0.0181347132,
-0.0037637048,
-0.0163805261,
-0.0132277459,
0.0390025415,
0.0298470911,
-0.0357456915,
-0.0079597402,
-0.0245549511,
-0.0021699423,
0.015726218,
0.0387788825,
-0.1147495955,
0.0236443933,
-0.0029680014,
0.0620319434,
-0.0525476187,
-0.0303519201,
-0.0074493177,
-0.1310522407,
0.0675641075,
-0.0399262086,
0.0374852344,
0.0057911356,
-0.0753390417,
0.0044076773,
-0.0074551669,
-0.0291214455,
0.0117610749,
-0.0196659844,
0.0203756765,
0.0117806774,
0.0327955633,
-0.0311044231,
0.0121017871,
-0.0602709725,
0.0146702062,
0.0486262105,
0.0477117673,
0.0273247883,
-0.0622264482,
-0.0448501334,
-0.007913772,
-0.0087146191,
0.0045799781,
0.0604071207,
0.0131367482,
0.0099752853,
-0.0360725038,
-0.0090816757,
-0.005609991,
0.0032972759,
-0.0040226164,
0.0276089851,
-0.0063003721,
-0.0020442696,
-0.0434698164,
-0.0070304484,
0.0190527905,
0.0492906198,
0.036491897,
0.0139210755,
-0.0427998491,
-0.0391183607,
0.0418913625,
-0.047969453,
-0.0464410447,
0.0109641477,
-0.0237114653,
-0.023717612,
-0.0897717997,
-0.0300239306,
-0.0509078763,
0.0152157806,
0.0170596354,
-0.0041737203,
0.0112200826,
0.008483069,
-0.0248595774,
-0.0078577707,
-0.0412153006,
-0.0014116615,
-0.0218012612,
0.0181793869,
0.0104341507,
-0.0362812616,
0.0031955396,
0.0118868379,
0.0177928358,
0.0058617033,
-0.0164003745,
0.0371577777,
0.0266942345,
0.0057281507,
-0.0645181164,
-0.0274964012,
0.0313210115,
0.097340107,
-0.016189903,
-0.0171429403,
0.0005927171,
-0.0006289243,
0.0091225728,
-0.0160047971,
-0.065767847,
-0.0062541645,
-0.0461897217,
-0.0062532704,
-0.007955147,
-0.046243161,
0.0266040657,
0.0706554502,
0.058089111,
-0.0058766063,
0.077839449,
-0.0009671195,
0.0021087374,
-0.014879236,
0.0043459428,
-0.0079568699,
0.0242537372,
-0.0209163222,
0.0368503109,
0.0059059667,
0.0583790094,
-0.0488240458,
0.0624666065,
-0.0803743303,
-0.0280376635,
-0.0117351217,
0.0261764899,
-0.0072720489,
-0.0142215956,
-0.0304258782,
0.0083046723,
0.0224287435,
0.0720754042,
0.000042015,
-0.0031971454,
0.0089227743,
-0.0435405448,
0.0526336655,
0.0190584976,
-0.1136219576,
-0.0340176225,
-0.0045251469,
-0.0150622381,
0.0357332043,
0.0337778553,
0.014966812,
-0.0338408947,
0.0018149498,
0.011431166,
-0.0228661373,
0.0496028997,
-0.0302604511,
-0.0310949907,
0.015732117,
-0.0190681983,
0.0082458891,
0.0528929941,
-0.0181074794,
0.0259886719,
-0.0472378917,
-0.0759795532,
-0.024563998,
-0.0721024051,
-0.0674129799,
0.0388291441,
-0.0227483958,
-0.0510706492,
-0.0458196998,
-0.0719721541,
-0.0090072202,
0.0365318693,
0.0525550246,
-0.0103860432,
0.0362027213,
0.0661022142,
0.0240552966,
-0.0368315019,
-0.0611422248,
0.0221873764,
-0.0482386611,
0.0057171797,
-0.0151948156,
-6.189369344e-33,
0.0455232449,
-0.0643942431,
-0.0106323799,
-0.024754962,
0.0067633758,
-0.0135964183,
-0.0656368211,
-0.0040516593,
-0.0408230871,
0.0324374028,
-0.0229152627,
0.0309904832,
0.0232757013,
-0.0260323249,
0.0074912454,
-0.0011586479,
0.0701839477,
0.0054889144,
-0.0553434789,
0.0506393015,
0.0696580485,
-0.0199343599,
-0.041032698,
-0.1131236926,
0.0600286648,
-0.0771062523,
-0.0473768339,
0.0246581528,
-0.0056300117,
0.0727696121,
0.0067178644,
0.0449032746,
0.0056902957,
-0.0261607412,
0.0324984528,
-0.0250719134,
-0.0843041614,
0.0049388148,
0.0318895578,
-0.0481431708,
-0.0624239147,
-0.0104800994,
0.0497242175,
-0.026648093,
-0.0319470428,
0.0264204759,
0.048604127,
-0.0023762255,
-0.0157647729,
-0.0898176283,
-0.0196795613,
-0.0064028958,
0.0166917555,
0.0308982562,
-0.0455113016,
0.0861818939,
0.0224957056,
0.0391527265,
-0.0225223228,
0.0224897228,
-0.0292181298,
-0.0101770004,
0.0481402799,
-0.0275146421,
-0.004127651,
0.0434991755,
0.0284289103,
-0.0177487601,
-0.0313620567,
-0.0284279082,
-0.0218744427,
0.0470916666,
0.0388207324,
0.1157361344,
-0.0006960998,
-0.0159058329,
-0.0433128737,
0.0428088866,
0.014930198,
0.0312421173,
0.050141789,
-0.0146909002,
-0.0477578677,
0.0188242998,
-0.0000282019,
-0.0134502305,
-0.0643272549,
-0.0324816704,
-0.000906928,
0.0301262867,
-0.0389457643,
-0.0056763669,
-0.0182337333,
-0.0552741252,
0.0165608656,
0.0676224679,
-0.0244162325,
-0.0220824089,
0.0029982659,
-0.0157767292,
-0.0031778996,
0.0103647932,
0.0121450974,
0.0139575126,
0.0127386348,
0.0201201998,
0.0134997144,
-0.025515696,
-0.024395017,
-0.0028863861,
-0.0308795981,
0.0424488112,
-0.0305423159,
-0.0947701782,
0.0258377567,
0.0165395141,
-0.0055825668,
0.0020454447,
0.0680327043,
0.0849559084,
-0.0179302618,
0.0028923177,
0.0030649472,
-0.001657162,
-0.0016270726,
-0.0213950835,
-0.0308987107,
0.0311016794,
0.0000954257,
-0.0653390884,
-0.0142173758,
-0.0098767746,
2.652e-7,
0.0072432156,
0.0013018774,
0.0020721629,
0.019076135,
0.0479082577,
0.0242474563,
0.045131579,
0.0234364793,
0.0006690366,
-0.0075309686,
0.0009204096,
0.0137502356,
0.0288144778,
0.0480605364,
-0.0716805831,
-0.0611108728,
-0.0639539436,
-0.0272388328,
-0.027343601,
0.0405024439,
0.0236673057,
-0.0025083304,
0.0165704433,
0.0005815061,
0.0211077128,
-0.0637237802,
0.0151253715,
0.027729705,
-0.0012400083,
0.0370609835,
0.07462731,
0.0391301811,
0.0247415993,
-0.0136226472,
-0.0329657756,
-0.0203833841,
0.002470352,
0.0128979944,
0.0254029781,
-0.005568156,
0.004253685,
-0.0653944761,
0.0585592799,
-0.0830626637,
0.0488217436,
0.0139955804,
-0.003014466,
-0.0181972831,
-0.0560652278,
-0.0397480167,
0.0234851521,
-0.0403829813,
-0.0295921415,
-0.0087742005,
-0.039026659,
0.0238966886,
-0.0102485372,
-0.0146448324,
0.0136713954,
-0.0325157233,
-0.023786407,
-0.0919408724,
0.0104979305,
0.0003672061,
0.0053532473,
-0.0047857631,
0.0434846506,
1.919660105e-34,
0.0227906294,
0.0184080992,
-0.0148239238,
-0.0262250472,
0.0578634553,
0.0231257752,
-0.0140017457,
-0.0085916966,
0.0436922796,
-0.026342582,
-0.0138812792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11082v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11082v6 | Fundamental Limitations of Alignment in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T17:50:09 | 2024-06-03T12:19:16 | Yotam Wolf, Noam Wies, Oshri Avnery, Yoav Levine, Amnon Shashua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An important aspect in developing language models that interact with humans
is aligning their behavior to be useful and unharmful for their human users.
This is usually achieved by tuning the model in a way that enhances desired
behaviors and inhibits undesired ones, a process referred to as alignment. In
this paper, we propose a theoretical approach called Behavior Expectation
Bounds (BEB) which allows us to formally investigate several inherent
characteristics and limitations of alignment in large language models.
Importantly, we prove that within the limits of this framework, for any
behavior that has a finite probability of being exhibited by the model, there
exist prompts that can trigger the model into outputting this behavior, with
probability that increases with the length of the prompt. This implies that any
alignment process that attenuates an undesired behavior but does not remove it
altogether, is not safe against adversarial prompting attacks. Furthermore, our
framework hints at the mechanism by which leading alignment approaches such as
reinforcement learning from human feedback make the LLM prone to being prompted
into the undesired behaviors. This theoretical result is being experimentally
demonstrated in large scale by the so called contemporary "chatGPT jailbreaks",
where adversarial users trick the LLM into breaking its alignment guardrails by
triggering it into acting as a malicious persona. Our results expose
fundamental limitations in alignment of LLMs and bring to the forefront the
need to devise reliable mechanisms for ensuring AI safety. | [
0.0328303948,
0.0372805521,
-0.0200972874,
0.0201339591,
-0.0396619998,
0.0056218654,
-0.0299514905,
-0.0197186805,
0.0352476388,
0.0102574769,
-0.0304517914,
-0.0503655076,
0.0248349328,
0.0199581254,
0.0550097786,
-0.0239385739,
0.0647071376,
-0.0203449428,
-0.0046536257,
-0.0097590871,
0.0407310612,
-0.0274372622,
-0.0065638232,
0.0418422967,
0.0119090686,
-0.0252979454,
-0.0377573334,
0.0100015663,
0.022070298,
-0.008803756,
-0.0098380446,
0.0222557597,
-0.0308414306,
0.0906483531,
0.0000018202,
-0.0660074949,
-0.0247737635,
0.0158265699,
-0.0233015511,
0.0007141334,
-0.0143989986,
-0.0423390791,
-0.0404753461,
0.0163969267,
-0.0383995436,
0.0403658897,
0.060523618,
0.0511830561,
0.0654442012,
0.1053901166,
0.0054776026,
0.0085921809,
0.0568086505,
-0.0106464438,
-0.00552466,
-0.0700053275,
0.023334099,
-0.0496538766,
-0.0176392682,
-0.0104747936,
-0.0127251958,
0.0050289938,
0.0134172756,
-0.0158795193,
-0.0339828245,
0.0363794751,
-0.0356818177,
-0.0463011712,
-0.0044191633,
0.0470947735,
-0.0188539792,
-0.0208508335,
0.0010893916,
-0.003228836,
0.0319026858,
0.009882695,
-0.0097028045,
0.0015982199,
-0.0059178593,
0.0147589324,
0.006214906,
-0.0210617408,
0.0682184845,
0.0119082844,
0.0179372095,
0.0491316989,
0.025126718,
-0.0481875911,
-0.0235845447,
0.0019070001,
-0.023144206,
-0.0554430559,
-0.0548552796,
0.0136236595,
-0.0663758144,
0.0308783092,
-0.1003977507,
0.004075523,
0.0209606178,
-0.0196396243,
0.0035513232,
0.0449270569,
0.0271600354,
0.0419711955,
0.0253821276,
0.0421769582,
-0.0508783534,
0.0421501435,
0.0044235857,
0.0414999612,
0.0184378363,
-0.0397219881,
0.0008527228,
-0.0095711127,
-0.0034125831,
0.0082362778,
-0.0465632156,
0.0629763827,
-0.0335198343,
0.0913237482,
-0.043873325,
-0.0195485633,
-0.04263293,
-0.0239195284,
0.0008544701,
-0.019815078,
-0.0101115284,
-0.0253165569,
0.0207046084,
-0.0701486841,
-0.0401384793,
0.0147454571,
-0.0702148899,
-0.0511939563,
-0.0472176224,
0.1164572537,
0.004086744,
-0.0073804106,
-0.0106820799,
-0.0407223478,
-0.0298550148,
-0.0445020907,
-0.0068016704,
-0.038861949,
0.0016724413,
-0.0094306869,
-0.0448853411,
-0.0607827716,
-0.0026990823,
-0.0044873962,
-0.0214487985,
0.0897105932,
0.0146856904,
0.0051181326,
0.0059854272,
0.0184465721,
-0.0067480891,
0.0651997253,
0.0257019754,
0.0150854485,
0.0511857048,
-0.009422767,
0.0333892144,
0.0760113373,
0.0232548527,
0.0287066735,
0.0042558657,
0.0059011993,
0.0566384606,
0.0360765867,
-0.0080035059,
0.0521574579,
-0.008831095,
-0.0587314963,
0.0808083043,
0.0512416139,
-0.0689566582,
0.0147379776,
-0.0035913736,
-0.0160313044,
-0.0125173023,
0.0641360059,
-0.1005334109,
-0.0006461021,
-0.0612021275,
-0.0092306733,
-0.0017510821,
0.0375190154,
-0.0173197407,
-0.0085654017,
-0.0041476269,
-0.0110436454,
0.0341597758,
-0.0041318405,
0.0211414341,
0.0022419177,
-0.0197734386,
0.0113108978,
0.0223147515,
-0.0298434068,
0.0048889127,
-0.0796804577,
0.0047705825,
0.0259467587,
0.064479053,
-0.0314528756,
-0.0104251858,
-0.0020522021,
-0.0117861331,
0.0308014825,
0.0525822751,
0.0040761218,
0.0062998203,
-0.0099933678,
-0.0002832635,
-0.0054870094,
0.0017146466,
-0.0097400732,
0.0205297321,
-0.0138028497,
-0.0491724312,
0.0156661235,
-0.0411196053,
0.0431328714,
-0.0221486613,
-0.0646983758,
-0.0490926579,
0.0530668423,
0.0432111174,
-0.0101009021,
-0.0212288853,
0.0187093467,
0.0385035612,
0.0075725899,
0.0194543023,
0.0161892846,
-0.0211186502,
-0.0030824519,
0.0495958664,
-0.0081939707,
-0.0413361005,
0.0382423811,
-0.0332967937,
-0.0156665239,
0.0184887405,
-0.0252785422,
0.0390387438,
0.022370303,
0.0426215716,
-0.0088331494,
0.0077972044,
-0.0438822992,
0.0276987925,
-0.0193727445,
0.0063593071,
-0.0061578639,
0.0143506052,
0.0199103579,
-0.0383344106,
-0.0485935584,
0.0183068607,
-0.0150939459,
0.0308011509,
0.0543903224,
-0.0077953469,
-0.0235202685,
-0.0280039068,
-0.0324914716,
-0.0105207367,
-0.0069098072,
0.0320197679,
0.0210226271,
0.0125363832,
-0.0257215369,
-0.0114604551,
-0.0346263312,
-0.0312779285,
-0.0002129161,
0.0317775868,
0.0551143438,
-0.0102346241,
-0.0782499462,
-0.0465775244,
0.0059147468,
-0.0135437259,
0.0201109685,
-0.0123311672,
-0.0233083218,
-0.0337117016,
0.0145223094,
-0.0106579568,
0.0588027127,
-0.0389973819,
-0.0512056649,
0.0503694005,
0.0198331922,
0.0270404723,
0.1153599769,
0.0119507629,
0.0766725689,
0.0510291718,
0.0523299575,
-0.0481044725,
-0.0023600967,
-0.001690401,
-0.0497759655,
-0.059184745,
-0.0267807767,
0.0343127809,
0.0749563053,
0.0099450778,
-0.005151323,
-0.0562631711,
0.0364605114,
0.0178334303,
-0.0537650064,
0.0070446762,
-0.0370616838,
-0.0753467679,
0.0149866007,
-0.0551282465,
-0.0862817019,
0.085744448,
-0.0340488479,
0.0031686001,
0.0127233164,
-0.0307023823,
0.0200222898,
0.0518375784,
0.0256673824,
0.0291362517,
0.0305341072,
-0.0271927621,
-0.09538389,
-0.0325045101,
0.0481020324,
-0.0237835329,
0.0385504439,
-0.0149523001,
0.0185271539,
-0.019929437,
-0.0439738855,
-0.0692372993,
-0.0740629807,
0.0070025697,
-0.0188017171,
0.0099242907,
-0.0496226698,
-0.0181804504,
-0.018129535,
0.0345736668,
-0.0369412415,
-0.0151088154,
0.0028166645,
-0.0385364294,
0.0079437075,
0.0623719543,
-0.0163738672,
-0.0223829951,
-0.0362114497,
0.0246126261,
0.0673344806,
-0.0066386038,
0.0341719911,
0.0013245736,
-0.0350294188,
0.0406518765,
-0.0107982578,
-0.006536392,
0.0255887043,
0.0801954493,
0.0029655965,
0.0014436647,
0.0589825585,
0.0166553706,
-0.0110377455,
0.0336190797,
-0.0055834474,
0.0866439119,
0.0081299599,
0.0127738342,
-0.0544877052,
0.0028616344,
0.0262052137,
0.0432760864,
-0.0102317566,
-0.0087760659,
-0.0316883363,
-0.1256637424,
-0.0216656756,
0.0297850613,
-0.0300855655,
-0.0567358993,
-0.0103471577,
0.0010176573,
-0.0241847374,
0.058086805,
-0.0042787469,
0.0155965229,
-0.0100656934,
0.0222728793,
-0.0092096124,
-0.01793392,
-0.016806813,
-0.0672067627,
0.0909855142,
0.0953133404,
0.0193070099,
-0.0244734511,
-0.0274188165,
0.0137979705,
0.0355919115,
-0.0015319142,
0.0662452281,
0.0150370523,
-0.0156019842,
-0.0024509416,
-0.0113802515,
0.0332008749,
0.0297865458,
-0.0190468486,
0.0310085695,
0.051177498,
0.0012371611,
-0.021196764,
-0.0112373643,
-0.0089258244,
0.0330545492,
0.0656973496,
0.0104954951,
-0.0447300859,
-0.0182417314,
-0.0548016727,
-0.0114599103,
0.0015595198,
-0.0473311841,
0.0139450179,
-0.0043638805,
-0.040790543,
-0.050734736,
-0.0223243907,
-0.043170087,
0.0456372276,
0.0407896116,
-0.0269236099,
-0.0081488788,
0.0058456301,
0.0315238088,
0.009570404,
-0.0096492283,
0.0432037711,
-0.0359030776,
0.0357342213,
-0.0248180572,
-0.0398117937,
0.000993404,
-0.0059776707,
-0.0532361604,
-0.1263704896,
0.0234222692,
0.0360332467,
0.0289265271,
0.0813162625,
-0.0302084312,
-0.0507004447,
0.0156687982,
0.0466223583,
-0.0088952808,
0.0164117347,
0.0480913669,
0.0003258602,
0.0036502704,
0.0470686629,
-0.0360915884,
-0.043985527,
0.0411371551,
0.0060405531,
-0.0643897131,
-0.0485762507,
0.0406494588,
0.0297985431,
0.0379309691,
-0.0409665704,
0.025568543,
0.0021821193,
-0.0192734972,
0.0051211687,
-0.0225431155,
0.003113027,
-0.024734538,
0.022878848,
-0.0025291122,
0.029754458,
-0.0006315918,
0.0071277898,
-0.0030535525,
-0.0179704782,
0.0045657037,
0.0055972342,
0.038321089,
0.0618184097,
0.0303328522,
-0.0119622909,
0.072944954,
-0.0105596343,
0.0171113219,
0.0359113291,
0.0443648249,
0.0340557545,
0.0098551121,
-0.0040168632,
0.0192525089,
-0.0613386892,
-0.0485499986,
0.0135606881,
0.0311798118,
0.0207041409,
0.0035712896,
0.0168674253,
-0.015100549,
-0.0154763991,
-0.0100166565,
0.008610107,
-0.0004155172,
-0.0382675901,
0.02064435,
0.0124054579,
-0.030137606,
0.0197211653,
0.0429741517,
-0.0241264068,
0.0507290624,
-0.0141665842,
0.0016535964,
-0.0105098384,
-0.0336921774,
0.0549617596,
-0.0249639247,
-0.0298601445,
-0.0200486109,
-0.059884239,
-0.0837289244,
-0.0408980921,
0.0416351929,
0.0189193934,
-0.0050406354,
-0.0109011866,
0.0402951315,
-0.0155221699,
0.0408503152,
-0.0214958601,
-0.0054712677,
-0.0076643135,
-0.0349843651,
-0.0099275624,
-5.789038212e-33,
-0.0080011766,
-0.0075093103,
-0.0139503814,
-0.0019791438,
-0.0240677428,
-0.03313867,
-0.0162649062,
0.0140619315,
-0.0273025911,
-0.0218668636,
-0.0203448851,
0.0014000705,
-0.0036016863,
-0.0097386986,
-0.0258215684,
-0.0480982699,
0.0101393545,
-0.0228540208,
-0.0514907166,
-0.0120942602,
0.0292139091,
-0.0119229909,
0.0118441852,
-0.0494333319,
0.0856152549,
-0.0033482192,
-0.0616605878,
0.039607957,
-0.037399061,
0.0615424737,
0.0055330717,
0.0225209687,
-0.0147361411,
-0.0242883805,
0.0106548108,
0.0573886223,
0.0299079716,
-0.0232170504,
0.0501162745,
0.0241929945,
-0.04321656,
-0.0356486365,
0.055177588,
-0.0420670807,
-0.0546907894,
0.0179051012,
0.0111497585,
0.012174705,
-0.0200860612,
0.015924653,
-0.056397751,
-0.0046234736,
-0.0245273057,
-0.035992004,
-0.0189765282,
-0.0077332603,
0.0332560651,
-0.0221055821,
-0.0383766741,
0.0235008299,
0.0159281082,
0.0150899766,
0.0838808343,
0.0310479049,
0.0239054523,
0.079776831,
0.0236314181,
0.0198711865,
-0.0265765265,
-0.0210523587,
-0.0090598874,
0.0036715206,
0.0192364659,
0.0652863011,
0.0186906103,
-0.0257636476,
-0.0384821557,
0.0160727669,
0.0298524331,
0.0268446188,
0.0141997552,
0.0162322707,
-0.0932182595,
-0.0106532443,
-0.0048330212,
-0.0305709951,
-0.0180180259,
-0.0378179289,
0.0008335391,
-0.0031696411,
-0.0016599839,
-0.0583315976,
0.003085339,
-0.0479087643,
0.0023570859,
0.029346399,
-0.0085612927,
-0.031503696,
-0.0171174612,
0.0247129556,
-0.005098321,
-0.0336730219,
-0.0262424089,
-0.0339099765,
0.0253784098,
0.0273414049,
0.0545741171,
0.0519831106,
-0.0465546511,
0.0040534115,
-0.0213930253,
0.0293342341,
0.0223971121,
0.0070151598,
0.0809817016,
-0.0351389833,
-0.0161235705,
0.0106266895,
0.0210194793,
-0.0032176939,
-0.0389687717,
0.0421062708,
-0.0368414968,
-0.0109054912,
-0.0142831057,
0.0114984103,
-0.0167853832,
0.0417038314,
0.0211311243,
-0.054033,
-0.0102638183,
-0.0389240235,
2.71e-7,
-0.0161003657,
-0.0008103066,
0.0510616042,
0.0459215119,
0.028241599,
0.0784759596,
-0.0316064358,
0.0847838446,
-0.0325848646,
-0.0303372517,
0.0115063749,
-0.0068724384,
0.0363575667,
0.0097258799,
-0.0490007997,
0.0358387828,
-0.099841468,
0.0327191241,
-0.0245916396,
0.0150406659,
0.0296980869,
0.0955652893,
0.0325392671,
0.0018018282,
0.0000329481,
-0.0561061837,
0.0189531241,
-0.0339127369,
-0.0082992157,
-0.0013691941,
0.0257592686,
0.014990069,
0.0057319012,
-0.0045578787,
-0.0075566522,
0.0181465689,
-0.0364003517,
0.0586684979,
-0.0150000611,
-0.0007862624,
-0.0264429767,
-0.0317835771,
-0.0083700456,
-0.0417900346,
0.0420859605,
-0.0359555483,
-0.0465484522,
-0.0260693748,
0.0099294884,
-0.0278658532,
0.013813029,
-0.0018515293,
-0.0174285155,
-0.012727729,
0.0129993251,
0.0171050522,
0.0148094501,
-0.0491384417,
-0.0323500521,
-0.0043250704,
-0.0084761279,
-0.0607015118,
0.0170562938,
0.0614516586,
0.0075681061,
-0.041570507,
-0.0156128649,
2.486097772e-34,
-0.0093394173,
-0.0354520343,
0.0510576144,
-0.0095593659,
0.0092621017,
-0.0025433816,
0.0231586657,
0.0231630895,
0.0856998712,
-0.0244086888,
-0.0317087583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09842v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09842v3 | Chameleon: Plug-and-Play Compositional Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T17:47:47 | 2023-10-31T17:43:39 | Pan Lu, Baolin Peng, Hao Cheng, Michel Galley, Kai-Wei Chang, Ying Nian Wu, Song-Chun Zhu, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in solving
various natural language processing tasks due to emergent reasoning abilities.
However, LLMs have inherent limitations as they are incapable of accessing
up-to-date information (stored on the Web or in task-specific knowledge bases),
using external tools, and performing precise mathematical and logical
reasoning. In this paper, we present Chameleon, an AI system that mitigates
these limitations by augmenting LLMs with plug-and-play modules for
compositional reasoning. Chameleon synthesizes programs by composing various
tools (e.g., LLMs, off-the-shelf vision models, web search engines, Python
functions, and heuristic-based modules) for accomplishing complex reasoning
tasks. At the heart of Chameleon is an LLM-based planner that assembles a
sequence of tools to execute to generate the final response. We showcase the
effectiveness of Chameleon on two multi-modal knowledge-intensive reasoning
tasks: ScienceQA and TabMWP. Chameleon, powered by GPT-4, achieves an 86.54%
overall accuracy on ScienceQA, improving the best published few-shot result by
11.37%. On TabMWP, GPT-4-powered Chameleon improves the accuracy by 17.0%,
lifting the state of the art to 98.78%. Our analysis also shows that the
GPT-4-powered planner exhibits more consistent and rational tool selection via
inferring potential constraints from instructions, compared to a
ChatGPT-powered planner. The project is available at
https://chameleon-llm.github.io. | [
0.0329936408,
0.0505278409,
-0.0113064852,
0.000959799,
-0.0574624427,
0.0011214479,
-0.002936675,
-0.0229917001,
0.0274624657,
-0.0497897156,
0.0150248623,
0.022498453,
-0.0184071604,
0.057563629,
0.0073179426,
-0.0297898594,
0.0419944674,
-0.0494155474,
-0.0081297066,
-0.0075882985,
-0.0298459809,
0.0216217265,
-0.027873259,
0.0418894999,
-0.0039234888,
-0.0212783106,
-0.0395020694,
-0.0236592814,
0.0036827421,
-0.0168248508,
-0.0030523487,
0.0355018713,
0.039098043,
0.0510057844,
0.0000022203,
-0.0531043336,
-0.0121269133,
-0.0060806405,
-0.0248119812,
-0.0338735096,
0.0079419157,
0.0113094933,
0.010372852,
0.0313847549,
-0.0489514843,
0.0443476923,
0.0397508182,
0.03162596,
0.0511240549,
0.0513604619,
0.0035158831,
-0.0605843887,
0.0247381665,
0.0154661089,
0.0381170139,
-0.0350208208,
0.0151099442,
0.0227948725,
0.0558958091,
-0.0085960291,
0.001720079,
0.0551645197,
0.0325550139,
-0.0193914548,
-0.0042274552,
0.0466206782,
-0.0483126566,
-0.0385761522,
-0.0048674336,
0.0611842684,
-0.0035702509,
-0.0395227857,
0.0135891614,
0.0015746431,
-0.0270925108,
-0.003142508,
-0.0430812612,
0.0645240471,
-0.0284029655,
-0.0059941085,
0.0075283158,
-0.024244383,
0.0309088621,
0.0205248389,
-0.0485477373,
0.1009480208,
0.0131030362,
-0.0260707345,
0.0037144676,
-0.0159899313,
0.0181719009,
-0.0783891305,
0.006506796,
0.0974155068,
-0.061196994,
0.0222896561,
-0.0113418447,
-0.0011716298,
-0.0024748677,
-0.0095401388,
0.0100008957,
0.0662203953,
0.0201387201,
0.0710739121,
-0.0343749002,
0.0429206043,
-0.0364427753,
0.0221075565,
-0.0163831953,
-0.0351388976,
-0.0877110437,
-0.0337557308,
0.0096383328,
0.020189913,
-0.0545890816,
-0.0222992301,
0.0009398462,
0.0486887172,
-0.0197388977,
0.0342881605,
0.0140648223,
0.0155423349,
-0.0138870412,
-0.0396217927,
-0.0691131875,
0.0092216805,
-0.0318402871,
0.0110039813,
-0.0025538045,
-0.0197017062,
-0.0051012989,
-0.0027384737,
0.0033333378,
-0.0187468529,
0.0361320823,
0.0908913836,
-0.0177022126,
-0.0236195382,
-0.0413497463,
-0.0646239668,
0.0016032851,
-0.1095206514,
0.0445036367,
-0.0775807053,
0.0489965342,
0.0242313277,
-0.045774933,
-0.0288631171,
0.019600831,
0.0245554037,
-0.0076440452,
0.0783934891,
0.0087424805,
0.0167287625,
-0.0050001931,
0.0122604808,
-0.03500209,
0.0685945377,
0.0295322593,
0.0157324858,
-0.0233461075,
0.0271206349,
0.0096478192,
-0.0059939977,
-0.0167529844,
-0.0288289227,
0.0093493341,
0.0124598835,
-0.0245163999,
0.0253811944,
-0.0454769768,
0.0199796148,
0.0059864847,
0.010056437,
0.0265979692,
0.0296903253,
0.0289069656,
0.0133626452,
0.047128886,
0.0040453151,
-0.0044589294,
-0.030813707,
-0.0721048191,
0.0789913535,
-0.083182402,
0.0043786722,
-0.0077791996,
0.0509685352,
-0.004866214,
-0.0612583086,
-0.0152944475,
0.0063178306,
0.0205883402,
0.0178599972,
0.0454848893,
-0.0140805757,
-0.0333352834,
0.0088730436,
-0.0083262753,
-0.0140013928,
-0.0355561636,
-0.0393169299,
0.0295588393,
0.0767271817,
0.0516178235,
-0.0619164631,
-0.0722264796,
0.0087469537,
-0.02755877,
0.0318605788,
0.0049980134,
0.006220032,
-0.0221770499,
-0.0402563959,
-0.0224901289,
-0.0541004427,
0.0159605406,
0.00927174,
0.0498178229,
-0.0060511827,
0.0015470367,
-0.0020468875,
0.032956928,
0.0227071084,
-0.0089513687,
-0.0209378023,
-0.0307507701,
0.0042519849,
0.0336053856,
-0.0049780873,
0.0125322035,
0.0482755564,
0.0295503344,
-0.0183099657,
-0.0749089494,
0.0230921395,
-0.0152570261,
-0.0316117667,
0.0613655336,
-0.0397031233,
-0.0233821161,
-0.003865215,
-0.0396693647,
-0.05247695,
0.0557072349,
-0.0275844261,
0.0112227788,
-0.0312858857,
0.0049556326,
0.0118688187,
-0.0332932658,
-0.0062314533,
0.0851509497,
0.0347985961,
-0.0269224942,
0.0448710248,
-0.0056736288,
0.0022192029,
0.0027388735,
0.0015401181,
0.011271785,
-0.0058874949,
-0.0004631292,
-0.0101201953,
0.0026853306,
-0.0358195156,
-0.033240404,
-0.0794477761,
0.0394725017,
-0.0036713395,
-0.003396064,
-0.009657382,
-0.0010764558,
0.015200574,
0.0316247828,
-0.0051467125,
0.023448538,
0.0200337972,
0.0015502806,
0.035834346,
0.0162176974,
-0.0147736063,
-0.00472255,
-0.0019612769,
-0.0666088164,
0.0229701772,
0.0249221455,
-0.0036381111,
-0.0361907333,
-0.0116350958,
-0.0510028079,
0.0445270129,
-0.0165844597,
-0.0130505515,
0.0238376502,
-0.031526994,
0.0325606056,
0.0818738863,
-0.0246922132,
-0.0078604454,
0.0975697488,
-0.0202309527,
-0.0556362085,
0.0628459826,
-0.0051650545,
-0.0186035074,
-0.0131307403,
-0.0027255001,
-0.0198770501,
0.0448425189,
-0.0402129628,
0.0043622949,
-0.0546848401,
0.0576073378,
0.0296213254,
-0.0043110345,
0.0120068183,
-0.0213994402,
-0.0046221465,
0.0433428101,
0.0116299829,
-0.0087934583,
0.0858150274,
0.0012718634,
-0.0058367145,
-0.0535376146,
0.0099018719,
-0.0458933897,
0.0913222507,
-0.0031920434,
0.0045807459,
0.0092549277,
0.020686809,
-0.0639803857,
-0.0060680788,
0.0173676871,
-0.020264294,
0.0318752378,
-0.0692272931,
0.0217694361,
-0.0172652863,
-0.0418201424,
-0.038824793,
0.0224096701,
-0.0699807107,
0.0429115556,
0.005245321,
-0.0398825333,
-0.0486796014,
-0.0119085638,
0.0335897207,
0.0199108012,
-0.0075966078,
-0.0094896816,
-0.0363264345,
-0.0308355018,
0.0442452803,
0.0471785739,
0.0446121395,
0.0104689281,
0.0318164676,
0.0345339663,
0.012759543,
-0.0087119704,
-0.0176547691,
0.0213520359,
0.0021995644,
-0.0127229188,
-0.0068150242,
0.0339015983,
0.0356744789,
-0.0818918124,
0.0121039217,
0.092815645,
0.0493340231,
-0.014563581,
-0.0105035398,
-0.0212700609,
-0.0026854563,
0.0517728142,
0.069833912,
-0.0880701169,
-0.0428099968,
0.0223231856,
-0.0194630362,
-0.0172964148,
-0.0325651802,
-0.0340473652,
-0.1092767492,
0.0543468073,
0.0062360307,
-0.0058926432,
-0.0196493547,
-0.0366484858,
-0.0226335768,
0.0055928533,
-0.0510461703,
0.027833268,
-0.0034709785,
-0.0178799126,
-0.0189982839,
-0.0318593346,
-0.0324641019,
0.0556728579,
0.0049135927,
0.008607897,
0.0400484204,
0.0172868259,
-0.0026143291,
-0.0454001464,
0.0347008295,
0.0064866114,
0.0101247765,
-0.0238119643,
-0.00533451,
0.0049811513,
0.0001167134,
-0.0239452422,
0.0393290929,
-0.0408762321,
-0.045948416,
-0.0015796702,
0.1169969216,
-0.0305938404,
-0.030339323,
-0.0383699648,
0.0231966712,
-0.0284957085,
0.0730123073,
-0.013549245,
0.0178769771,
-0.0786356702,
-0.0352336057,
-0.0484046079,
-0.0568098724,
-0.0038714153,
0.0091689387,
0.0419443138,
0.0275747422,
-0.053018257,
0.0053367605,
0.0939874351,
0.0225031953,
0.0035434742,
-0.0180122759,
0.0313517787,
0.0180820506,
-0.0621167235,
0.0041172681,
-0.0297835171,
0.0308665987,
-0.0058641937,
0.0057508056,
0.0100586219,
-0.0552272014,
-0.0183976814,
0.0069664116,
-0.0552796721,
-0.0672643706,
-0.0331595242,
0.0580695234,
0.0333378091,
0.0161370803,
-0.0286522731,
-0.0236021653,
-0.0061131916,
0.0520366915,
-0.0295186862,
-0.0023596238,
0.0231923349,
0.0052862768,
0.0117549133,
0.0292309001,
-0.0539606772,
-0.0096678045,
-0.0176646132,
0.0644598231,
0.0140315518,
0.0219517574,
0.040406581,
0.0347701907,
-0.0241797734,
-0.0017956593,
0.0053010061,
-0.0187127385,
0.0217425879,
-0.0157062504,
-0.0390119813,
-0.0345018283,
0.0404231697,
-0.0230529495,
-0.0153527409,
0.032227423,
-0.0099428846,
-0.0147245005,
0.0047546853,
0.0022242521,
0.0273226909,
0.0457386188,
-0.044865407,
0.0415412188,
-0.0204040054,
-0.0134542566,
0.0112049319,
-0.0114427116,
0.0394938365,
-0.0344531015,
0.0590698421,
0.0249301735,
-0.0128380414,
-0.0898654163,
-0.0122031141,
-0.0770395398,
-0.1079527512,
0.0284885131,
0.0628399327,
0.0489998981,
0.0212211031,
-0.0155492723,
-0.0777113587,
-0.0144130513,
-0.0046271752,
0.0136632696,
0.0340797119,
-0.0114918835,
0.0589921661,
0.0445171408,
-0.0171814486,
-0.0438489355,
0.0480796136,
-0.0196494553,
0.0839523822,
0.0131979892,
-0.0072401133,
-0.0343351625,
-0.0672691911,
-0.0217114203,
0.0354158655,
-0.0091134552,
-0.0120606013,
-0.0604077987,
-0.0424232818,
0.0194780305,
0.0182903484,
-0.0238399636,
-0.0089079775,
0.0281431265,
0.0478621237,
0.0144439423,
-0.0587247945,
0.0142393829,
0.0012849037,
-0.0152913844,
-0.0101167057,
0.0196549036,
-6.579845792e-33,
-0.0067095649,
-0.0344139524,
0.0712537989,
-0.007231487,
0.0066938577,
-0.008743763,
-0.0511208139,
-0.0093298517,
-0.0329241939,
0.0064480617,
-0.0142790806,
0.0103147142,
0.0040635047,
-0.0001070941,
0.0295152534,
-0.0109337093,
0.0059488588,
0.0374256857,
-0.0320234299,
-0.002599681,
0.0349763595,
-0.003694776,
0.0241514053,
-0.0280542616,
-0.0315319374,
0.0358386077,
-0.00443841,
0.0479858257,
-0.0778120756,
0.0510581024,
-0.0125706876,
0.0239292011,
0.0254576262,
0.006800645,
0.0149928303,
0.015336128,
-0.0478922538,
-0.0353067666,
0.0359303877,
-0.030944353,
-0.0576486252,
-0.0330569372,
0.0351577066,
0.0053163702,
-0.0052454323,
-0.0483836383,
0.0269357488,
-0.0344857387,
0.0226149037,
-0.032230828,
-0.0682628676,
0.008163345,
-0.0205394551,
-0.0337306187,
0.0100601427,
0.0452270284,
0.019026259,
0.0285158567,
-0.0010346306,
0.0274733864,
-0.0062292502,
-0.0097556319,
0.0706622452,
-0.005502305,
0.011087453,
0.0365200564,
-0.004428566,
-0.0012524278,
-0.0663235784,
0.0000981593,
-0.0037323199,
0.0930233523,
0.041417148,
0.0025200192,
-0.0039356868,
0.0336866863,
-0.0502548404,
0.0047820844,
-0.0020967945,
0.0685273856,
0.0460796803,
0.0218933746,
-0.0060710502,
-0.0064380504,
-0.047510758,
0.0417420976,
-0.0458620489,
-0.0058916472,
0.0225384068,
0.0233634859,
-0.0203278996,
0.0219664872,
0.0117391851,
-0.0560938567,
0.0229715575,
0.0414297134,
-0.0049461508,
0.0058030416,
0.0019245499,
0.0508587584,
-0.0221026298,
-0.0025588893,
0.0282318257,
-0.0093161026,
0.0025165961,
0.0185747743,
-0.0141312396,
0.0552488305,
-0.0300010554,
-0.0185488965,
-0.0758541226,
0.0050081895,
-0.0002258728,
-0.0021687155,
0.0367634743,
0.0357521251,
-0.0091883158,
-0.0105624255,
0.0020807625,
0.0035090027,
-0.0300629716,
0.0088564521,
0.004514006,
0.0158977285,
-0.0170538891,
0.0040975143,
-0.0420668758,
0.0021990512,
-0.0324416496,
-0.055969473,
-0.0163556933,
0.0400834531,
3.051e-7,
0.0425757878,
0.0693140477,
-0.0228827149,
0.034840297,
0.0087477574,
0.0119616566,
-0.0288197268,
-0.0309318323,
-0.0111904871,
-0.0207507927,
-0.0081975525,
0.053042151,
0.0187943522,
0.0451419801,
-0.0511244163,
0.0209308546,
-0.0248266738,
-0.068448931,
-0.0919545516,
-0.0093559688,
0.0856410265,
0.0611766838,
0.0192278195,
-0.0186496153,
0.0187902991,
-0.054169707,
0.047486145,
0.0143984118,
0.012410406,
0.0124798957,
-0.0100873411,
0.0157436095,
0.0171867367,
0.0254498757,
-0.008827297,
0.0119038951,
-0.0323666744,
0.0740462244,
-0.0037246365,
-0.0210749973,
-0.0003928052,
-0.0397825167,
0.0096318573,
-0.0765231401,
0.1003034562,
-0.0336350873,
-0.0264494084,
-0.0095827514,
-0.0213095527,
-0.0214989819,
-0.0269820057,
-0.0042808042,
0.0153363096,
0.0088067558,
-0.0155220125,
-0.0234244131,
-0.0008504633,
-0.1058295965,
-0.0130518023,
0.0295490678,
-0.0409944206,
-0.0079173734,
-0.0403904393,
0.0065729353,
0.0697742105,
-0.0467814431,
-0.028104512,
3.129247925e-34,
0.0258392598,
0.0102598276,
0.023040317,
0.0286223069,
0.0581657663,
0.0338629931,
-0.0169172492,
0.0138182919,
0.0267541278,
-0.0870677531,
-0.0462266915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09805v1 | A Survey of Corpora for Germanic Low-Resource Languages and Dialects | 2023-04-19T16:45:16 | 2023-04-19T16:45:16 | Verena Blaschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite much progress in recent years, the vast majority of work in natural
language processing (NLP) is on standard languages with many speakers. In this
work, we instead focus on low-resource languages and in particular
non-standardized low-resource languages. Even within branches of major language
families, often considered well-researched, little is known about the extent
and type of available resources and what the major NLP challenges are for these
language varieties. The first step to address this situation is a systematic
survey of available corpora (most importantly, annotated corpora, which are
particularly valuable for NLP research). Focusing on Germanic low-resource
language varieties, we provide such a survey in this paper. Except for
geolocation (origin of speaker or document), we find that manually annotated
linguistic resources are sparse and, if they exist, mostly cover morphosyntax.
Despite this lack of resources, we observe that interest in this area is
increasing: there is active development and a growing research community. To
facilitate research, we make our overview of over 80 corpora publicly
available. We share a companion website of this overview at
https://github.com/mainlp/germanic-lrl-corpora . | [
0.0404980667,
0.0346085168,
-0.0251553003,
0.0414133966,
-0.0599828102,
-0.0156623963,
-0.0177699495,
-0.022728689,
-0.0390339456,
-0.0574548803,
-0.0126365451,
-0.0018349434,
0.0435723476,
-0.02802152,
0.0312446244,
-0.0946748033,
0.0191360284,
-0.0325751863,
0.0057657086,
-0.0156932157,
0.0357452258,
0.0143525889,
-0.016604634,
0.0457816795,
0.0080424715,
0.0423307456,
-0.0017252358,
0.0142865097,
0.0062344191,
-0.0015775622,
-0.0254201479,
0.0108034117,
-0.0429995209,
0.049173031,
0.0000017075,
-0.0742392763,
-0.0008178476,
0.0069415034,
-0.0298122503,
-0.0167383999,
0.0418986082,
-0.0489352681,
-0.0382991061,
-0.0294921584,
-0.0045391927,
0.0122970073,
0.0761630833,
-0.0466044843,
0.0124994833,
0.0460049324,
-0.0196076315,
-0.0539098829,
0.0004139843,
0.0009765446,
-0.0160488915,
0.0375398248,
-0.0396197401,
-0.0327308364,
0.0335823558,
-0.0152657954,
-0.0146461204,
0.0433264524,
-0.0374886841,
0.0125564933,
-0.0399245694,
0.0059129177,
-0.066968523,
-0.051916521,
-0.0044034794,
0.0015712262,
0.0032826436,
-0.0243286192,
0.0041840426,
-0.0080902288,
-0.0105337854,
0.0011622399,
-0.032928668,
0.0417760611,
-0.0407809354,
0.0133116748,
0.0695653334,
0.0260548741,
-0.0044705239,
0.0094217686,
0.023105599,
0.0643923134,
0.0404482111,
-0.0144921811,
0.0622282848,
0.0119282193,
-0.0201240946,
-0.0546148866,
-0.0384370051,
-0.0031901521,
-0.0084840124,
0.0284938868,
-0.0177367963,
-0.0210081562,
0.0389796235,
0.0166764725,
0.0241067428,
-0.0287580173,
-0.0445034206,
0.0277481135,
0.0254890677,
-0.0011863798,
0.0408229977,
-0.0538484603,
0.00642518,
-0.0328310393,
-0.0083758915,
0.0166939087,
-0.06194444,
0.0025740876,
-0.0284606237,
0.037762057,
-0.0177083332,
0.0118204029,
-0.0006100066,
0.0195352957,
0.0027154111,
-0.0227757879,
-0.028627282,
0.0161018856,
-0.0497301184,
0.0283839013,
-0.0084089013,
-0.0284149908,
-0.0857505202,
-0.0898027122,
0.0320260078,
0.0501528196,
0.0033918894,
-0.036575038,
0.0023522524,
0.0393889286,
0.0286428034,
-0.032586813,
-0.0458766557,
0.0017104695,
-0.0272601917,
-0.0395251215,
-0.0229814742,
-0.0867690146,
-0.0209997259,
0.0203957837,
0.0352428518,
-0.0233371053,
0.0072626686,
0.0010090526,
-0.0287638418,
0.0323204473,
-0.0799010694,
-0.021353554,
-0.0335896164,
-0.0556188412,
0.0041127321,
0.0354664512,
0.0242892262,
-0.0364620052,
0.0713347271,
-0.0152551439,
-0.0183229297,
0.0325865708,
-0.014194156,
-0.0324542299,
0.0096161803,
-0.0092441272,
-0.0707045719,
-0.016612282,
0.0399660543,
0.0664686561,
0.0202704594,
-0.0312997773,
0.0054554613,
0.1094230786,
0.0265023224,
0.0020613868,
0.0309369378,
0.0342981666,
0.0186327975,
-0.0359098166,
0.0127822366,
-0.0382201932,
-0.0437704399,
-0.0028417022,
-0.0266120322,
0.0608688705,
0.0272637066,
-0.0184230916,
-0.0482584126,
-0.0236363802,
0.0091066556,
0.0008215585,
0.0267452635,
-0.0050042383,
0.0328845046,
0.0228942614,
0.0386874042,
-0.0371935517,
0.0041712923,
0.0444916897,
-0.0157383028,
0.0277738608,
0.017213678,
-0.031483721,
-0.0280881114,
0.014263181,
-0.0213147737,
0.066502206,
0.0224011689,
-0.0269455705,
0.0541202947,
-0.0203094818,
0.0409901477,
-0.0030508095,
0.0293157548,
0.0419727452,
-0.0391065702,
0.0069879345,
-0.0149071543,
-0.0376299359,
-0.0380705073,
-0.0160821863,
-0.0361993313,
-0.0040264656,
-0.0194162466,
0.0084341262,
0.0112692742,
0.0642668158,
-0.0175566711,
0.0313332304,
0.0101269083,
-0.0375978835,
0.0482472144,
0.0889728069,
0.0497372895,
-0.0141807515,
0.011946721,
-0.0803541914,
0.0027645989,
-0.0339788087,
0.0102764443,
-0.0462254882,
0.0320689045,
-0.0969457254,
0.0681394562,
-0.0160330944,
0.006977391,
0.0139502017,
-0.0157274026,
-0.0326293334,
0.062549673,
0.0293588117,
0.0649731234,
0.0017148465,
-0.0449856669,
0.0583534576,
-0.0386637449,
-0.0207779724,
-0.000126789,
-0.0267734006,
-0.0028399881,
0.0554510802,
-0.0189318303,
-0.0132497521,
0.0219758786,
-0.0717529058,
0.0032947825,
-0.0559061021,
0.0618285611,
-0.0041710921,
0.0605692454,
-0.0155089414,
-0.0230734255,
-0.0008691042,
0.0288985521,
0.0121488888,
0.0251339711,
0.0272146799,
0.0121338004,
-0.0116569875,
-0.0273853838,
0.0064157974,
0.0271485001,
0.0131762577,
-0.0024359771,
-0.0896434486,
-0.0132077355,
0.0086602094,
-0.0353197418,
0.0452876575,
0.017098384,
-0.0197671447,
-0.0073514739,
0.0080110766,
0.065018326,
0.0041587274,
-0.0381366722,
0.001808855,
0.0062393541,
-0.0169871897,
-0.0481081419,
-0.0300286952,
-0.0003101003,
0.0078834929,
-0.0564450286,
-0.0402383022,
0.0707802773,
0.0399706699,
-0.0228176415,
-0.0093010776,
-0.0299729463,
-0.0005064795,
-0.0995297953,
0.011691195,
0.0276981536,
0.0058126654,
-0.0213425402,
0.0412921868,
0.0027154773,
-0.0257339645,
0.0501242876,
-0.0230346117,
-0.0214195494,
-0.0625583008,
-0.0587182492,
-0.0492953807,
0.0541835278,
0.0190355163,
0.0222413894,
0.0540435687,
-0.0785783529,
0.011672671,
0.0415441021,
0.0498798527,
0.0316915102,
0.0326968804,
-0.053630203,
0.0297025368,
-0.0107435295,
-0.0496462062,
-0.0046569067,
-0.0541613847,
-0.050624676,
0.0217800755,
0.0470840707,
-0.0105307009,
0.0163444988,
-0.00362248,
-0.0088439127,
0.0454533249,
0.0173349734,
0.0229670368,
-0.0204867013,
0.051176697,
0.0098563982,
0.0536110662,
0.010830651,
0.0687812343,
-0.0282501504,
0.0085961139,
0.0403336957,
0.01332804,
0.0198331922,
-0.0121058356,
0.0167757645,
-0.0572186038,
-0.078411743,
-0.0166848823,
0.035542924,
0.0150461849,
-0.0026623269,
0.0642028153,
0.0474282838,
-0.0151084075,
0.0258702505,
-0.0376560315,
0.0576799363,
0.0513677932,
0.0023250135,
-0.0912624374,
0.0086069554,
-0.0078006084,
0.0352637284,
-0.055256445,
-0.0270466972,
0.0055087754,
-0.1199204251,
0.0237089284,
-0.0011342899,
-0.0193485245,
0.0008483065,
-0.0279826149,
-0.0043911743,
-0.0387444943,
-0.0358922444,
-0.0389390178,
-0.0456165038,
0.0158025678,
0.0607969128,
-0.0615242086,
-0.0722077563,
-0.0174023993,
-0.0475588962,
0.037681561,
-0.0328162573,
0.0486637913,
-0.0498963408,
-0.0223783795,
0.0503141023,
-0.0236172602,
-0.0084005026,
-0.0005135097,
0.0172563139,
0.0190856066,
-0.025444977,
-0.0476466529,
0.0290990695,
0.0154313585,
-0.0376015045,
-0.0089706415,
0.0501793213,
-0.0255443845,
0.0140943658,
0.0239178073,
0.0069651026,
0.0253087059,
0.0408251062,
0.0093602035,
-0.0256121438,
0.0022455072,
-0.0182914119,
0.0152476011,
-0.010760515,
-0.0594905317,
0.0556142703,
-0.0066888966,
-0.0472505055,
-0.0582072139,
-0.0775026828,
-0.0067343763,
0.0362387337,
0.0350942276,
-0.0079757553,
0.0107557597,
0.0048458735,
-0.0682724789,
0.052711226,
0.0037142383,
-0.0047244965,
-0.043263223,
-0.0407168195,
0.0550939813,
0.0296411738,
-0.0153891062,
-0.0118584521,
-0.0575160682,
-0.0570615493,
0.0273410566,
0.022011064,
0.0241438318,
0.0432545356,
-0.0347268023,
-0.0626404062,
0.0287149511,
0.0053426358,
-0.025018042,
0.0225278214,
0.0386173204,
-0.0022709337,
0.0118442532,
0.0272461642,
0.0019381621,
0.0248389952,
-0.0138802193,
-0.0012242055,
-0.009156581,
-0.0077842539,
0.0261262525,
0.0198061373,
0.0083938669,
-0.0606460311,
0.0127388751,
-0.0170500651,
-0.0206449796,
0.0263439603,
-0.0128585352,
-0.0262491833,
-0.0006101072,
0.0335321687,
-0.0102773951,
-0.0104847923,
0.0137467533,
-0.0533212237,
0.0519240573,
0.0256448202,
0.0602845624,
0.1346899271,
0.0123163266,
-0.0290732365,
0.0315542109,
0.0072991676,
0.0568680018,
-0.0145563018,
0.0648657531,
-0.0236000307,
-0.021021517,
-0.014538127,
-0.033080969,
-0.0027599966,
0.0142840622,
0.0066536749,
0.0012745918,
0.00357505,
-0.0028718966,
0.0765740499,
-0.0009422312,
0.1271834224,
-0.0437937006,
0.0213502776,
-0.0024551,
0.0163498856,
0.0000094569,
-0.0501377732,
0.0035347019,
0.006371025,
-0.0354460403,
0.0161850359,
0.0374104232,
0.0091027841,
0.010981977,
0.0317151658,
-0.0034014201,
-0.0226988196,
-0.0041176714,
0.011307002,
-0.0023397163,
-0.0208218656,
0.0212956723,
-0.1063173339,
-0.028131187,
-0.0050276699,
0.0007925836,
0.0051540798,
0.0045169662,
0.025491653,
0.0258501265,
0.0143675441,
0.0187984761,
-0.0319601223,
0.046218235,
-0.0337692574,
-0.0381452404,
0.0044833329,
-5.900608054e-33,
-0.0109389164,
-0.0032180261,
-0.0282537956,
-0.0437729433,
0.0321548544,
-0.0044390578,
-0.0159169026,
0.0233133771,
-0.0241934713,
0.0169181749,
-0.0045706229,
-0.0231268499,
0.0332067423,
0.0091350935,
0.0258887634,
0.0043790275,
-0.0073903813,
0.0180240385,
-0.0271300878,
-0.0257717967,
0.0512469001,
-0.0389998183,
0.1139473096,
-0.0728923902,
0.0411394574,
0.0367563888,
-0.0198841654,
0.007245284,
0.0630487651,
0.0475333594,
-0.0225555748,
0.0563372448,
0.0246036202,
0.0223426539,
-0.0025021886,
0.0246451199,
-0.0590554364,
-0.0552710965,
0.0450505391,
0.0500551946,
-0.007649825,
-0.0373634771,
0.005320549,
-0.0342115797,
-0.0180666931,
0.0892637968,
0.0141338287,
0.0259255525,
-0.0089831799,
0.0309041291,
-0.0836793333,
0.0468062796,
-0.0025161291,
0.0157979112,
0.0515008643,
0.0315101929,
-0.0017677674,
-0.0634976476,
-0.0240068249,
0.047123272,
0.0024633459,
0.0309823025,
0.0098650232,
-0.0652979687,
-0.0409048162,
0.0199539457,
0.0062921084,
0.035857942,
0.0690564439,
0.0375134312,
0.0373833179,
0.016023716,
-0.01080871,
0.041056741,
0.0246988367,
0.0243284367,
0.0084763234,
-0.0329745449,
0.062635906,
0.0063769524,
-0.0624522418,
-0.0210176613,
-0.0276546218,
-0.01024237,
-0.0224027671,
-0.0825137869,
0.0273086317,
-0.0081427945,
0.0108137652,
-0.0286995471,
0.0040469547,
0.0751714408,
0.0250909422,
-0.0094015738,
-0.0509925671,
-0.0173139162,
0.0406071953,
0.065310806,
-0.025576124,
0.0449507684,
-0.0455612689,
-0.0050324132,
0.0042175557,
0.0340086222,
0.0333271958,
0.0141301323,
0.0161893293,
0.026634559,
-0.0441591665,
-0.0053898185,
-0.0242751725,
0.0287681855,
-0.0823732838,
0.0346372761,
0.0448624827,
0.0187590085,
0.0167705957,
-0.0128651969,
0.0540568233,
-0.0240913257,
-0.0152480025,
0.0177423544,
0.0039729052,
0.0102732265,
-0.0025975106,
0.0052952408,
0.0107532255,
0.011689309,
0.0284326151,
0.0369073488,
0.0167579204,
-0.0627995282,
2.633e-7,
0.0403827019,
0.0368450992,
0.0180756394,
-0.0269758385,
0.0338741243,
-0.0260896981,
0.0030905423,
0.010941647,
-0.0514856055,
0.0065998305,
-0.0053157439,
-0.0697931275,
0.0184375588,
0.0569352172,
-0.1032173857,
-0.0237144977,
-0.0129066473,
-0.0298358668,
-0.0637738258,
0.022390943,
0.0130278738,
0.1015853956,
0.0006785644,
-0.010491916,
-0.0498970486,
-0.0005982707,
0.0148224747,
-0.033937078,
-0.0133967288,
0.0072893105,
0.0363371149,
0.018060036,
0.0136689832,
-0.0252966397,
-0.0066461125,
0.0321726389,
0.008720438,
0.0058942786,
-0.0490019284,
-0.0344696119,
-0.0115929032,
-0.0223280042,
-0.0285670459,
0.0014907975,
0.0171509385,
0.0185721647,
-0.0299096722,
-0.0002531273,
-0.0251945294,
0.0475469083,
-0.0048258472,
0.007394766,
-0.0320479944,
0.0104595283,
0.0526088811,
-0.0371940434,
-0.0536989085,
-0.0281977337,
-0.031213589,
0.0486965515,
0.0051095588,
-0.0231961403,
0.0324032381,
0.0165518485,
-0.0106295422,
-0.0607861504,
-0.0028606791,
2.15805013e-34,
0.0140231289,
-0.0054184929,
0.0228320695,
0.0288293101,
-0.0197761077,
-0.0107500153,
-0.0139259091,
0.0369233675,
-0.0012944561,
0.0100539876,
-0.017365979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09797v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09797v5 | Progressive-Hint Prompting Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T16:29:48 | 2023-08-10T03:41:04 | Chuanyang Zheng, Zhengying Liu, Enze Xie, Zhenguo Li, Yu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in reasoning tasks depends
heavily on prompt design, with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and self-consistency
being critical methods that enhance this ability. However, these methods do not
fully exploit the answers generated by the LLM to guide subsequent responses.
This paper proposes a new prompting method, named Progressive-Hint Prompting
(PHP), that enables automatic multiple interactions between users and LLMs by
using previously generated answers as hints to progressively guide toward the
correct answers. PHP is orthogonal to CoT and self-consistency, making it easy
to combine with state-of-the-art techniques to further improve performance. We
conducted extensive and comprehensive experiments on seven benchmarks. The
results show that PHP significantly improves accuracy while remaining highly
efficient. For instance, with text-davinci-003, we observed a 4.2% improvement
on GSM8K with greedy decoding compared to Complex CoT, and a 46.17% reduction
in sample paths with self-consistency. With GPT-4 and PHP, we achieve
state-of-the-art performances on SVAMP (89.1% -> 91.9%), GSM8K (92% -> 95.5%),
AQuA (76.4% -> 79.9%) and MATH (50.3% -> 53.9%). | [
0.0267616846,
0.0558752529,
-0.0211619474,
0.046401564,
-0.0793836117,
-0.0165564269,
0.0207189564,
-0.0054008546,
0.0060200039,
-0.0131605985,
0.0171159208,
-0.0406390764,
-0.010175853,
-0.0123644862,
-0.0016758601,
-0.0449047796,
0.048713062,
-0.1185904592,
-0.0019952385,
-0.0378707089,
-0.0189251658,
-0.0181261692,
-0.0253920089,
0.0284194071,
0.0350145474,
-0.047294084,
-0.0503655151,
-0.028764639,
-0.0328720063,
-0.0740796924,
-0.0354128592,
0.0941642299,
0.0093916385,
0.047967609,
0.0000027022,
-0.0687113926,
-0.0011241017,
-0.0224704687,
-0.0517716855,
0.0282906387,
-0.0408029966,
0.0019278878,
-0.0127361752,
0.0237869732,
-0.0260733217,
0.008303754,
0.0290329829,
0.0095291827,
0.0779023245,
0.0225098338,
0.0103102764,
-0.0270084478,
0.0280705821,
-0.0252894275,
0.0471569672,
-0.0256193914,
0.0218603872,
0.0272810925,
0.0245001093,
0.0156846065,
-0.014571107,
0.0593145117,
0.0242876001,
-0.0193339903,
-0.0170089453,
0.034525834,
0.0019876016,
-0.0168175437,
0.0023032136,
0.0596386902,
0.0055159847,
-0.0013517124,
-0.0148244509,
0.0014217346,
0.0062173912,
0.0136545729,
-0.0762286559,
0.0089970399,
-0.0069703129,
0.0024602886,
0.0271725766,
0.0048698578,
0.0050054947,
0.008037786,
-0.0095661422,
0.0950148776,
0.0203723665,
-0.0510438792,
0.0048682392,
0.0175617356,
-0.0281580165,
-0.0709411278,
0.032376308,
0.0539226197,
-0.0258805119,
0.0308226477,
-0.0261588823,
-0.0355783626,
0.0362957194,
-0.0211179722,
0.0477713346,
0.0868566334,
-0.0181916356,
0.0523753911,
-0.0294007417,
0.0404024348,
-0.0186520033,
-0.0054396666,
-0.0378349759,
0.0054783756,
-0.0422616638,
-0.0033232574,
-0.0398099907,
0.053517852,
-0.025116466,
-0.0158741251,
-0.0157598797,
0.0452303365,
0.0295297615,
0.0264301728,
0.0198065974,
-0.014521719,
0.0131886741,
-0.0002549619,
-0.0215824023,
0.0473888926,
-0.0798711032,
0.0094063617,
0.014024538,
-0.0577863604,
-0.0005678191,
-0.0094319033,
-0.0067698602,
-0.0148029178,
0.0260651,
0.0666589364,
-0.0166040622,
-0.0039202119,
-0.0237806309,
-0.0319300853,
0.0168520268,
-0.0661110729,
-0.0111823333,
-0.0909052044,
0.0535518825,
0.0503005832,
-0.032622207,
0.0208620187,
0.0225260369,
0.0456991233,
-0.0148255099,
0.0492661595,
-0.0396394171,
0.0395161659,
0.032868959,
0.0254131965,
-0.041002132,
0.0586134568,
0.0293837991,
0.0073300377,
0.0196371339,
-0.0294794608,
-0.009706798,
0.0318435505,
0.0275414176,
0.0122700557,
0.0326836631,
0.0069020241,
-0.0041479841,
0.0663112849,
-0.0107742362,
0.0602614693,
-0.0348361842,
-0.0095842658,
0.088246718,
0.0652107149,
-0.0055711023,
0.0160490125,
0.0218349025,
-0.0025004696,
0.0588737503,
-0.0033692224,
-0.0634580478,
0.022545062,
-0.0522494167,
0.0369350612,
0.027915718,
0.0366697311,
-0.0103025734,
-0.0472274646,
-0.0061253649,
0.0096108979,
0.0052449796,
0.0647140145,
0.0708176792,
-0.012768643,
-0.0255981851,
0.0496827066,
0.0134429503,
-0.0153405704,
-0.0170643777,
-0.0461692847,
0.0820419788,
0.05645971,
0.0512750633,
0.0112510072,
-0.0100971283,
0.0010762345,
0.0260102153,
0.0362697244,
0.0066788862,
0.0136139244,
-0.0338413902,
-0.0386615247,
-0.0272740144,
0.0276979171,
-0.0164756346,
0.0201232862,
0.0238692965,
0.0017703699,
-0.0164585691,
-0.0156242903,
0.0552973114,
0.014227164,
0.0152736641,
-0.0226790793,
-0.0099126156,
-0.013210427,
-0.0177429803,
0.0330825113,
0.0189139284,
0.0338440575,
0.0345033482,
-0.0274621919,
-0.0020556499,
-0.0317057259,
-0.0683678463,
-0.0525805429,
0.053023383,
0.0296816155,
-0.0291075911,
-0.0277469829,
-0.0054671858,
-0.0242558103,
0.0324185938,
-0.030381076,
0.0400744081,
-0.0289398562,
0.0308704078,
0.0034774349,
-0.0084079057,
-0.0361636952,
0.0891136602,
-0.0083212713,
0.0196865071,
0.0659823269,
0.0325099975,
0.0296512637,
-0.0501133278,
0.0025492271,
0.0143816238,
0.0038160337,
0.0018867732,
0.0022947097,
0.0290316492,
-0.0492276028,
-0.0209736135,
-0.0855884552,
-0.0093050599,
-0.0159236453,
0.0282330979,
-0.0245197043,
-0.0032068728,
-0.0132865123,
-0.0342679843,
-0.054005146,
0.0009298889,
0.0300648808,
0.0396271013,
-0.0109675275,
0.0079328613,
-0.0210880321,
-0.0084215943,
-0.0325628631,
-0.0045565101,
0.0342582092,
-0.0040637362,
-0.0075454144,
-0.0642430112,
-0.0056788982,
-0.0498058572,
-0.0002811526,
0.01112739,
0.0031671613,
0.0214987807,
-0.0276794042,
0.0310976245,
0.0421885401,
0.0116032949,
-0.0122543359,
0.0535829179,
-0.0307290349,
-0.0642768517,
0.0078385407,
-0.0148953758,
-0.0214481261,
-0.0017265952,
0.0016179124,
-0.0104542496,
0.0738060996,
0.0097395619,
0.0196919572,
-0.0165028665,
-0.0001664853,
0.0045700059,
-0.0016396216,
-0.0413742661,
-0.0267345347,
-0.0137958406,
0.0721673667,
-0.0084284805,
-0.0551693924,
0.0892339423,
-0.0400610827,
-0.0170205291,
-0.0365286805,
-0.0145048043,
-0.0094614075,
0.067870535,
-0.0143438978,
0.0174676031,
0.0262531433,
-0.0203595906,
-0.0321538746,
-0.0099591054,
0.0124514671,
-0.0530845076,
0.0547996908,
-0.0534902997,
0.0081733949,
-0.014178969,
-0.0686643347,
-0.0498743653,
-0.015496023,
-0.0584162772,
0.0127394767,
-0.0078861443,
-0.0036506874,
0.0336782746,
-0.0088426154,
0.0333923325,
0.0097303595,
-0.0274514556,
-0.0235465635,
-0.0237477906,
0.0402980112,
0.0466288701,
0.0043065161,
0.0335270278,
-0.0330445543,
0.0425693467,
0.0743840709,
0.040432632,
-0.0014298926,
-0.0081125423,
0.0337223746,
0.0425982215,
-0.009853581,
-0.0374720171,
0.0389517061,
0.0407031812,
-0.0785109624,
-0.0041658464,
0.1162199378,
0.0392047651,
-0.0380671397,
0.0023962022,
-0.0651816651,
0.0365949534,
0.0004823661,
0.0573602729,
-0.082811743,
-0.0508565754,
0.0306723136,
0.0114635564,
0.0153120738,
-0.0233051553,
-0.012681854,
-0.1204223484,
0.0118705519,
0.0106773991,
0.0108159902,
0.0191779379,
-0.0403634012,
0.0023372136,
0.0292620249,
-0.0009895002,
0.0448305868,
0.0194235463,
-0.0007463541,
0.0044545974,
-0.0131518003,
-0.0111466069,
0.0429886989,
-0.035120368,
0.0408761799,
0.065647848,
-0.0221521109,
0.0236710701,
-0.0990675315,
0.0328020006,
-0.0259586684,
-0.003231335,
-0.0294070393,
0.0051299967,
0.0163804144,
0.0035701783,
-0.0522381589,
0.0228593908,
-0.0406936035,
-0.034916833,
0.0482670814,
0.1152641922,
-0.0356474444,
-0.009666088,
-0.0198538434,
0.0021745618,
-0.0170359015,
0.06501472,
0.0170733519,
-0.0542281568,
-0.0409052968,
-0.0562163703,
-0.020242475,
-0.0085328575,
-0.0131929182,
-0.0101390639,
0.0417304412,
0.0074397419,
-0.0250729639,
-0.0317955576,
0.0471568033,
0.0444842689,
-0.0016521025,
0.0265425425,
0.0058040037,
0.0058321115,
0.0007560434,
0.0199213102,
-0.0375765488,
0.0335205346,
-0.0786125511,
-0.0224769358,
-0.0155080631,
-0.0573179685,
-0.0048897504,
0.002715291,
-0.0800696984,
-0.0662593693,
-0.0098069562,
0.0360064693,
0.0317198597,
0.0078423079,
-0.0182712302,
-0.0660932884,
-0.0161999222,
0.0167975854,
-0.041776564,
-0.0009831303,
-0.0215123687,
0.0291694943,
0.0199406184,
0.0333666503,
-0.0251245741,
-0.001026122,
-0.0198771935,
0.0666645765,
-0.0447352827,
-0.0260991082,
0.0316974744,
0.022288993,
0.0411772542,
-0.0038406497,
0.0117950877,
0.0021166578,
0.0266127195,
-0.031864915,
-0.0143884849,
-0.0199977122,
0.0191051215,
-0.0105422549,
-0.0323063359,
0.0289390758,
-0.0470491163,
0.0089697167,
-0.0172200929,
-0.0168225374,
0.0043368656,
-0.0160474442,
0.0131400311,
0.035559278,
-0.0127018709,
-0.0147414496,
-0.011502442,
0.0121432934,
0.0363509804,
-0.0251757316,
0.0832258761,
0.0182140432,
-0.0239413809,
-0.0071927798,
0.0237942841,
-0.0531768613,
-0.108250834,
0.0123117426,
0.0390546694,
0.06746988,
0.0367636755,
-0.017840039,
-0.0530754402,
-0.0118068671,
-0.0092765801,
0.0062715947,
0.0422115475,
-0.0500841551,
0.0572260134,
0.0237216428,
-0.0045470106,
-0.0159719661,
0.0259097777,
-0.0328384526,
0.0101164561,
0.0121628568,
-0.0094609084,
-0.0211747736,
0.0090302294,
-0.0447141081,
0.0403381959,
-0.0476666391,
0.0001561429,
-0.0699182227,
-0.0602603331,
-0.0282538198,
0.00940846,
-0.0286264606,
-0.0170825925,
0.0502674356,
0.0808068067,
0.0151752299,
-0.0596912019,
-0.0146572124,
0.0266195834,
-0.0379976332,
-0.0494024269,
-0.0094299382,
-7.040872472e-33,
-0.023847593,
-0.0325365067,
0.0548975654,
-0.0142785506,
-0.0003785153,
-0.0268525518,
-0.051511135,
0.0259804986,
-0.032463301,
-0.0203210153,
-0.0375912152,
-0.033974316,
0.0139052887,
0.0081558004,
0.0229069032,
-0.0309347492,
0.0307333004,
0.0127165765,
-0.0201287679,
-0.0054594232,
0.011482466,
0.0079659941,
0.034035027,
-0.057739865,
0.0111004766,
0.0007493165,
0.0118316421,
0.0229089297,
-0.0297169778,
0.0723573789,
-0.0261414647,
0.0531956889,
0.008830932,
-0.0226632114,
-0.0327460244,
0.025408458,
-0.0838834718,
-0.0490973294,
0.0344107375,
-0.0056755664,
-0.074939996,
-0.0122737801,
-0.0182643421,
-0.0026271688,
-0.030534314,
0.0030588126,
-0.0117872404,
-0.0185894072,
-0.0280680917,
-0.0012251923,
-0.0318366289,
0.0145215001,
0.0094523728,
-0.0297325123,
0.0238879416,
0.0355454087,
-0.0199108347,
0.0093218945,
-0.0185043141,
0.0359343477,
0.062769942,
0.037831232,
0.0648287013,
0.0081354575,
0.0079170167,
0.0262521747,
0.0442239419,
-0.0512576848,
-0.0161279067,
0.0029051905,
0.0206432957,
0.0204330757,
0.0824605301,
0.004855447,
0.050668858,
0.0113876853,
-0.040003445,
-0.0059372238,
0.0699201152,
-0.0002233652,
0.0319520384,
0.0129076652,
-0.0483866893,
-0.0340151973,
-0.0416323803,
-0.0099395625,
-0.0609023087,
-0.0650237352,
0.0485852882,
-0.0040494883,
0.0138210831,
0.0071634189,
0.0618344061,
-0.0100317001,
-0.0388285257,
0.0066966526,
0.0014344928,
0.0274907574,
-0.0146815684,
0.0237550288,
-0.0282083116,
0.0093909809,
0.0017288878,
-0.0224553254,
0.0011458528,
0.0420799144,
-0.0260747615,
0.0121627981,
-0.0519030094,
0.0053741806,
-0.0523867533,
0.007998676,
0.0200217757,
-0.022143146,
0.0407332703,
-0.020693481,
-0.0015528124,
0.0698815063,
-0.0075454353,
-0.0212769564,
-0.0476242453,
-0.0147267533,
0.0017210578,
0.0263901092,
-0.0039556539,
0.0155062899,
-0.0463993624,
0.0308526978,
0.0117576718,
-0.0492538996,
-0.010767784,
0.0266899355,
3.295e-7,
0.0309982356,
0.0500355475,
0.0000343064,
0.0494268611,
0.0043847561,
0.028687343,
-0.0119419843,
-0.0319020152,
0.0328750759,
-0.0200567674,
-0.018473167,
0.0283044185,
0.0294542909,
0.0560097061,
-0.0861766636,
-0.0095026493,
-0.0392626375,
-0.0124529833,
-0.0834742486,
0.0166134499,
0.0760804638,
0.0735133216,
-0.011148938,
-0.0067842216,
0.0155044226,
-0.0193905793,
0.0444186144,
-0.0232054461,
0.0055339807,
-0.0033802902,
0.003662802,
-0.0297113918,
0.0281443857,
0.0397126153,
0.0041980548,
-0.0104917884,
-0.0145186521,
0.0240369197,
0.0273611546,
-0.0164553393,
-0.0094605107,
-0.052667331,
0.0129118906,
-0.0845646635,
0.0666295812,
-0.0128606865,
-0.0167610776,
0.008281948,
-0.0089885229,
-0.0723582283,
0.011184168,
-0.0273993798,
-0.0464573093,
-0.0098469937,
0.0107026966,
-0.0050596655,
-0.0057126172,
-0.0402530506,
-0.0351057835,
0.0050584534,
-0.0198093727,
-0.0508762337,
-0.0558137298,
0.0063895723,
0.0417511091,
-0.0705918893,
-0.0063851285,
3.364895972e-34,
0.0274853949,
-0.0153643852,
0.0519860834,
0.0698955059,
0.0124654295,
0.0100890528,
0.0350379124,
0.0105495956,
0.0373073034,
-0.0989476517,
-0.0422439352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11062v2 | Scaling Transformer to 1M tokens and beyond with RMT | 2023-04-19T16:18:54 | 2024-02-06T10:16:54 | Aydar Bulatov, Yuri Kuratov, Yermek Kapushev, Mikhail S. Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A major limitation for the broader scope of problems solvable by transformers
is the quadratic scaling of computational complexity with input size. In this
study, we investigate the recurrent memory augmentation of pre-trained
transformer models to extend input context length while linearly scaling
compute. Our approach demonstrates the capability to store information in
memory for sequences of up to an unprecedented two million tokens while
maintaining high retrieval accuracy. Experiments with language modeling tasks
show perplexity improvement as the number of processed input segments
increases. These results underscore the effectiveness of our method, which has
significant potential to enhance long-term dependency handling in natural
language understanding and generation tasks, as well as enable large-scale
context processing for memory-intensive applications. | [
0.0252846554,
0.0536756255,
-0.0055821184,
0.0252569485,
-0.0162332263,
0.0033064473,
0.0128243007,
-0.0299734268,
-0.0535312742,
-0.0355518311,
-0.0092110392,
-0.0575392433,
-0.0250157882,
0.0524761453,
-0.0121067679,
-0.054729268,
0.0454231538,
-0.0045191469,
-0.0491071381,
0.0226807687,
-0.014712316,
0.005324109,
-0.010164218,
0.0420451164,
-0.053147465,
-0.0114802327,
-0.0216805432,
-0.0081195021,
0.0060671293,
-0.0538671277,
-0.0227884687,
0.0246724524,
0.0395521373,
0.0616319031,
0.0000020453,
-0.0349502452,
-0.0260880142,
-0.0202788115,
-0.0197985563,
-0.0166280381,
0.01454427,
-0.0328719243,
-0.0050537586,
0.0152673684,
-0.0281318799,
-0.0382543243,
0.0530254506,
0.0708488151,
0.0691612065,
0.0651197433,
-0.0081211692,
-0.0477696694,
0.048403386,
-0.0408967026,
0.0414391942,
-0.0149443913,
0.0110176206,
-0.0231529716,
-0.0069810119,
0.0134497136,
-0.0296124369,
0.0285585187,
0.0781400725,
0.0095618451,
0.0112217357,
0.0476733446,
-0.018859297,
0.0090649417,
-0.0173207875,
0.0331414677,
-0.0143320626,
-0.0336431861,
-0.0246537644,
0.0101263635,
-0.0129767982,
-0.0326966755,
-0.0369873643,
0.0182792824,
0.0061794566,
0.0032056209,
-0.0274606049,
-0.0015990026,
0.033694271,
0.012703184,
-0.0983714685,
0.0392758884,
0.0224052183,
-0.0147828534,
-0.0513416417,
-0.0075632762,
-0.0238954592,
-0.0355906226,
0.0257214215,
0.0597587451,
-0.0289013255,
0.0262771435,
-0.0307188351,
-0.0579453148,
-0.0016331642,
0.015114218,
0.0020720828,
0.0503431372,
-0.0304015148,
0.0271475594,
-0.0282885842,
0.0354966819,
-0.0792443678,
-0.0113011114,
-0.0500100963,
-0.0175006427,
-0.0484336317,
-0.0312145725,
-0.0837283134,
0.0455865897,
-0.0620606132,
-0.0089134369,
-0.0381744318,
0.0377308652,
0.0338414907,
-0.0402816497,
0.0108421193,
0.0213387832,
-0.0803277269,
-0.0073410743,
-0.0204031821,
0.0633594468,
-0.0319191776,
-0.012064673,
0.0220711939,
-0.0569027066,
-0.0392495804,
0.006270689,
0.0338115655,
-0.0459227264,
-0.005071206,
0.0583508573,
-0.0032090303,
-0.0603410415,
-0.026970664,
-0.0161374658,
-0.025268048,
-0.0690458789,
-0.0034406551,
-0.0485498421,
0.0219074935,
0.0013530061,
-0.0147992913,
0.020385012,
0.0106091881,
0.0359804966,
0.0006101977,
0.0709154233,
0.0335848331,
-0.039465718,
0.0259246007,
0.0199090373,
0.0230161585,
0.0271102767,
0.0404072255,
0.0414362885,
-0.0106283706,
-0.0158237889,
0.0138426926,
0.0090627214,
0.00472013,
-0.0332052223,
-0.0119090471,
0.003882918,
-0.0043902262,
0.0397794396,
0.0304794498,
0.0581944548,
-0.0416171998,
0.002835057,
0.0165969785,
0.0334714763,
0.0286479555,
0.0552419238,
0.063299112,
0.0069621555,
-0.0374984071,
-0.00626224,
-0.0497809276,
0.0674301609,
0.0131196827,
0.0214698128,
-0.0025860365,
0.0515237488,
-0.0381950997,
-0.0325288773,
0.0178850796,
-0.0147262812,
0.0040250923,
-0.0280746315,
0.0561828241,
0.0502354577,
-0.0588307716,
0.0923686326,
-0.0053236838,
-0.0767392516,
0.0085242232,
-0.0328856558,
-0.0054682549,
0.0363377109,
0.0468646809,
-0.043175444,
-0.0228836108,
-0.0029146362,
0.0004927511,
0.0597181469,
-0.0026943432,
0.022736771,
0.0153477313,
-0.0564474687,
-0.0055837659,
0.0069261077,
-0.0116057228,
0.0363640711,
0.0608732291,
0.012514879,
0.0427673869,
-0.0137642622,
0.0195274763,
0.0215817541,
-0.0503028817,
-0.0410851389,
0.0226321965,
0.007866174,
0.0269899927,
0.0088137109,
0.0023893265,
0.0200635772,
0.0442316979,
-0.059419997,
-0.0361300781,
0.0333449654,
-0.1316783428,
-0.0062379339,
0.0145021221,
-0.0159299579,
-0.0082201706,
0.0269244239,
-0.0277171563,
-0.0640490353,
0.0538217872,
-0.0702112615,
0.0968629867,
-0.0499483198,
0.0137793198,
0.0301046539,
0.0415720344,
-0.0193897597,
0.0451616123,
-0.018238185,
-0.0029654,
-0.0005093484,
0.0302230455,
-0.012123229,
0.0059010657,
-0.0412931889,
-0.0090226252,
-0.0245654024,
-0.0037508465,
0.0093665058,
-0.0144102043,
-0.0400756188,
-0.0540005714,
-0.0793080181,
-0.0007182757,
-0.0213887151,
0.0117207495,
0.0066824141,
0.0531112365,
0.0402035676,
-0.0068674278,
-0.0243714564,
-0.0045775189,
0.0081074033,
0.0427254327,
0.0204391275,
0.0244533569,
-0.0449172407,
-0.0153647372,
-0.018110564,
0.001340231,
0.0446425751,
0.0157068111,
-0.0021143928,
-0.0157603063,
0.002514079,
-0.0054133898,
0.0298717599,
-0.028968567,
-0.0291844774,
0.017445134,
-0.030306831,
0.0965562761,
0.0139973629,
0.0352663584,
0.0332055874,
0.0098353829,
-0.0376319513,
-0.0225479323,
0.0469935313,
-0.0394013673,
-0.0314139873,
-0.0046059419,
0.0171253551,
0.0059367386,
0.0735295713,
-0.0329868756,
0.0084666805,
-0.0570462383,
-0.0173319541,
0.0053730956,
-0.0249257032,
0.0267081186,
-0.0158948619,
-0.0428397916,
0.0262964666,
-0.0124247828,
-0.0268794596,
0.0505907387,
-0.0337781496,
-0.0111647844,
-0.0405819453,
0.0053140791,
-0.0534882583,
0.0858856514,
0.0312547386,
0.0127621116,
-0.0144875394,
-0.0323285237,
-0.0164964274,
0.0218287464,
-0.0397257991,
-0.0134052075,
0.0591389053,
-0.0248838272,
0.0162842236,
-0.005002968,
-0.051611539,
-0.0677757114,
0.0105244806,
0.0067168577,
-0.0144157792,
0.0456219502,
-0.0415772237,
-0.0633868873,
0.0166083761,
0.0515300855,
0.0791676268,
-0.0016985596,
-0.0166944712,
-0.0184387881,
0.0386870801,
0.0290758274,
0.0436860472,
0.0375107229,
0.0018794836,
0.0126770716,
0.0466211364,
0.0547272079,
-0.0285495799,
-0.0498141237,
-0.0055975015,
-0.0040297089,
-0.0134614641,
0.0137024187,
0.0212531798,
0.0338303037,
-0.0612952225,
-0.0672617704,
0.0927365944,
0.0241915882,
-0.0546420291,
-0.0036242241,
0.0004652356,
0.0162661932,
0.0286223367,
0.0025311336,
-0.0816009119,
-0.0229695588,
-0.0025304435,
-0.0202549845,
0.0027350558,
-0.0444394797,
-0.0169332307,
-0.1049855873,
0.0162674617,
-0.0009442405,
-0.0729122981,
-0.0310598481,
-0.0238623191,
-0.0443005525,
0.0199447554,
0.0392188095,
0.0252776034,
-0.0222136043,
-0.0149199357,
0.0150123825,
0.0119016208,
-0.0095303534,
0.01219521,
-0.0153890969,
-0.0103061786,
0.0252138563,
-0.0097649172,
0.0089480625,
-0.0329500586,
0.0330938548,
0.0116423015,
0.0343259312,
-0.0002519395,
0.0251088999,
0.0039463378,
-0.0210194662,
-0.0100478446,
0.0059671653,
-0.0498925112,
-0.0339804441,
-0.0093557304,
0.0752296373,
-0.0068843677,
0.0170609746,
-0.0065730889,
-0.0092467656,
-0.0264101718,
0.0606584661,
0.0417461246,
-0.0278645046,
-0.0319005921,
0.002393424,
0.0080404086,
-0.0696700662,
-0.0143336458,
-0.0206781793,
0.0377030745,
-0.0237447638,
-0.066024527,
-0.0217932817,
0.0119192544,
0.0548558161,
-0.0044905394,
-0.0363725238,
0.035814777,
0.013203999,
-0.0834328085,
0.0355635658,
-0.0536552332,
-0.0127682462,
-0.0750326812,
0.0186991934,
0.0206956584,
-0.0241499227,
-0.0089200782,
0.0251265727,
-0.1163571477,
-0.0448317938,
0.0409501493,
0.0171049368,
0.0213175341,
0.0681957006,
0.0168228652,
0.0023629852,
0.0472202674,
0.0391454697,
-0.0619145297,
0.0305623226,
0.0289429687,
0.0211433675,
0.001271504,
0.0150121311,
-0.0225395914,
0.0350595973,
0.0079605943,
0.0479205288,
-0.0096225236,
-0.0111981379,
0.028734725,
-0.0076454883,
0.0457664654,
0.0114222309,
0.0745259672,
-0.0073090307,
0.0425082892,
-0.0262719933,
0.0214615986,
-0.0414257944,
-0.0060691205,
0.0263692904,
-0.0170611143,
-0.0000136535,
-0.0095900465,
0.0317719132,
0.0007198729,
0.0231904015,
-0.0086535271,
-0.025907591,
-0.0245089624,
0.0397775285,
-0.0029201284,
-0.0260763913,
-0.0439658836,
0.0171491224,
0.043577645,
-0.032295201,
0.0745131299,
0.02397714,
0.0001147416,
-0.0358491763,
0.0380424783,
-0.0688772351,
-0.0353223197,
-0.0194446929,
-0.0148263266,
0.0219848249,
-0.0143566681,
0.015272391,
-0.0232900474,
0.0162079148,
-0.0097515984,
0.015435678,
0.0050213425,
-0.0213261619,
0.0331090651,
0.0402525961,
-0.0055012954,
0.0149361212,
0.0576177612,
-0.0272392184,
0.0340097733,
0.018724896,
0.0332727395,
-0.0196281355,
-0.0385215767,
-0.0348112509,
0.0062680836,
-0.0012808271,
0.0047101774,
-0.0449571796,
-0.0728441626,
0.025036294,
-0.003030916,
-0.0015643978,
-0.0204905476,
0.0521515273,
0.0327890255,
0.020074565,
-0.0052576521,
0.0248447284,
0.0458003543,
0.014669884,
-0.0079138847,
0.0051219007,
-6.574230602e-33,
-0.0226392727,
-0.0274267234,
0.0389803834,
-0.0079743108,
-0.043069046,
0.0281767771,
-0.0492687672,
-0.0131226052,
0.0157144256,
-0.0232604966,
-0.0172664989,
0.0282256715,
0.0097476104,
0.0791832656,
0.0039251898,
-0.0129099712,
0.0797806233,
0.0161627922,
0.0104183061,
0.0533456504,
0.0512491874,
0.0264830012,
0.0378542133,
-0.0310241114,
-0.0400864221,
0.0065442906,
0.0239021573,
0.0380453728,
0.0124984188,
0.0514602549,
-0.0368783027,
0.0371199436,
0.0206048898,
-0.1026551723,
-0.0145441294,
0.0323383585,
-0.1052071899,
-0.0158250015,
-0.0074585495,
0.0107775154,
-0.0401452556,
-0.0187015831,
0.0369507261,
0.0063557685,
0.0411390252,
0.0046028029,
-0.0027067005,
-0.0138712609,
-0.0195344035,
-0.0212011188,
-0.0552869029,
0.00588767,
-0.002246439,
0.0029946633,
0.0165879466,
0.0264222044,
0.0046845861,
0.0375443324,
-0.0621148422,
-0.0190193057,
-0.0139388535,
0.0542003922,
0.0443745963,
0.0236990768,
0.004233568,
0.03189696,
0.0085899467,
-0.0207938943,
-0.0530062914,
-0.0099952882,
0.0126375733,
0.0239768624,
0.0242008138,
0.0145957237,
0.0722933039,
-0.0093344562,
-0.0325147174,
-0.0073755342,
-0.0009496761,
0.0882948339,
0.0296142697,
0.0108050369,
-0.0050316257,
0.0032260311,
-0.0111617595,
0.0366815105,
-0.0530939177,
-0.0268767029,
0.0293275137,
0.0554993264,
-0.0014241905,
-0.0018836134,
0.034165103,
-0.0002339893,
0.0211509857,
0.0146802356,
0.0109492885,
-0.0114601096,
-0.028763989,
0.020880688,
-0.0116005205,
0.0000793322,
0.0421859659,
0.0046023307,
-0.0149825411,
-0.0064190645,
0.0342483111,
0.0430761613,
-0.0816592798,
-0.0009783248,
-0.0654388145,
0.0311806854,
-0.0195970573,
0.0447111242,
0.0351038612,
0.0226389468,
-0.0238746163,
0.0357930623,
-0.0173237808,
-0.0252718944,
-0.0290977303,
0.0134289237,
0.0230951104,
0.0242570397,
-0.0498994328,
-0.0208633523,
-0.0488259718,
0.0236532521,
0.0485329218,
-0.0825774893,
-0.023722576,
0.0354596451,
2.827e-7,
0.0053930413,
0.0394332558,
0.0839372948,
-0.0222652014,
0.0351785459,
0.0125488993,
0.0274387226,
0.0156060001,
-0.0033125246,
0.0032001215,
0.0074326647,
0.0283832178,
0.0247363318,
0.0024513474,
-0.0893478245,
-0.0251927804,
-0.0846421495,
0.0087930663,
-0.0301308688,
-0.015410766,
0.0518526249,
0.1299968809,
-0.0004579756,
-0.0123035442,
0.0169597454,
-0.0255377367,
0.0554539338,
-0.008977077,
0.034692876,
0.0036667127,
-0.0123386625,
0.0417653844,
-0.0003581318,
-0.0189338569,
-0.0110947164,
0.0228083413,
-0.0257004984,
0.0497376472,
0.0099932784,
-0.0388202928,
0.0269516464,
-0.0005648957,
-0.024182234,
-0.0310000498,
0.0373971649,
-0.1020582914,
-0.0067023803,
0.0007300879,
-0.019429056,
0.0120295566,
-0.0174633972,
0.018786516,
-0.0162196979,
0.0322029367,
0.0127785243,
0.0059570773,
0.0045713764,
-0.1264539063,
-0.0057853349,
-0.0003529104,
-0.0776618049,
0.0168232024,
-0.072256729,
-0.0387631208,
0.0418838151,
-0.0105092144,
-0.0166946501,
2.715770083e-34,
0.025708843,
-0.0066308198,
0.0240817573,
0.0258050133,
0.0289362576,
-0.0126948282,
-0.0179633256,
0.0222829878,
-0.0066253166,
-0.1050445512,
-0.0338970423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09667v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09667v3 | GeneGPT: Augmenting Large Language Models with Domain Tools for Improved Access to Biomedical Information | 2023-04-19T13:53:19 | 2023-05-16T13:24:53 | Qiao Jin, Yifan Yang, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.GN | While large language models (LLMs) have been successfully applied to various
tasks, they still face challenges with hallucinations. Augmenting LLMs with
domain-specific tools such as database utilities can facilitate easier and more
precise access to specialized knowledge. In this paper, we present GeneGPT, a
novel method for teaching LLMs to use the Web APIs of the National Center for
Biotechnology Information (NCBI) for answering genomics questions.
Specifically, we prompt Codex to solve the GeneTuring tests with NCBI Web APIs
by in-context learning and an augmented decoding algorithm that can detect and
execute API calls. Experimental results show that GeneGPT achieves
state-of-the-art performance on eight tasks in the GeneTuring benchmark with an
average score of 0.83, largely surpassing retrieval-augmented LLMs such as the
new Bing (0.44), biomedical LLMs such as BioMedLM (0.08) and BioGPT (0.04), as
well as GPT-3 (0.16) and ChatGPT (0.12). Our further analyses suggest that: (1)
API demonstrations have good cross-task generalizability and are more useful
than documentations for in-context learning; (2) GeneGPT can generalize to
longer chains of API calls and answer multi-hop questions in GeneHop, a novel
dataset introduced in this work; (3) Different types of errors are enriched in
different tasks, providing valuable insights for future improvements. | [
0.001875626,
0.0660153553,
-0.0040787831,
0.0169848893,
-0.0216441862,
0.0321347117,
0.0070427451,
0.0337016433,
0.084159866,
-0.0197556466,
-0.0072549987,
-0.0321464017,
0.0059266663,
0.019111149,
0.0169577841,
0.0016415953,
0.0385413058,
0.0085735423,
0.0223458428,
-0.019126609,
-0.0246771537,
0.0189272631,
-0.0117929913,
0.0553049892,
0.0370821953,
-0.0617401898,
0.0007508141,
-0.0207963288,
0.0112438491,
-0.0502650514,
0.0170007516,
0.0371552594,
0.0370840617,
0.066597566,
0.000002241,
-0.0451902077,
-0.0207027979,
0.053693492,
-0.0518538132,
0.0035364337,
-0.0063944296,
0.018016208,
0.0251091197,
0.0271197092,
-0.0408273712,
-0.0604871474,
0.0675039664,
0.0083285552,
0.0610683449,
0.0489199534,
0.0097474586,
-0.0223205127,
0.0381881967,
-0.0003437183,
0.0680098459,
-0.021803597,
0.0225241464,
0.0321618095,
0.0731877536,
-0.0020209961,
0.0074621793,
0.0444037206,
0.0010888157,
0.0303125829,
-0.0151447002,
0.044723466,
-0.0491265729,
-0.0326611921,
0.0250190962,
0.0358163901,
0.0139862932,
-0.0383553244,
0.0096753091,
0.0499158949,
0.0011102741,
0.0092364298,
-0.0895584822,
0.0280147623,
-0.0308161117,
-0.0109174,
0.0168913733,
-0.0533262528,
0.0400414653,
0.0103655877,
0.0035101851,
0.0495600365,
0.0150601109,
-0.0239965189,
-0.0162894707,
0.0259240475,
0.0137104923,
-0.0165513158,
0.0138806393,
0.0479617566,
-0.0761740804,
-0.0052650766,
-0.0131247165,
-0.0283734966,
0.072525844,
-0.0307604112,
0.0131233195,
0.0391155519,
-0.0317489132,
0.0273937322,
-0.0256909784,
0.006884614,
0.0010945076,
0.0381592587,
0.0016539802,
0.0029610794,
-0.0962848812,
-0.0135186939,
-0.0206999518,
0.0491214655,
-0.0225197654,
0.0188792162,
-0.0410059802,
0.0014045774,
-0.0004504498,
0.0300980788,
-0.0063837087,
-0.0111791156,
-0.040865019,
0.0210391488,
0.0074122748,
0.0250579286,
0.0003834813,
-0.0288883969,
0.0002248583,
-0.0976954773,
-0.0526001379,
-0.0214504283,
0.0110338647,
-0.0096596954,
0.0175356083,
0.1036720276,
0.0085603297,
-0.0162373893,
-0.0102006737,
-0.0472910777,
0.009060977,
-0.039454136,
-0.0000449587,
-0.0721008927,
0.0493994914,
0.0574590042,
0.00885964,
-0.020161178,
0.0298899896,
0.0123916529,
-0.045017451,
0.0670458898,
-0.0261308923,
-0.0206319466,
0.0350827836,
0.0244007595,
-0.0252232291,
0.0533874705,
-0.0170855522,
-0.0208798684,
-0.0077086235,
-0.0096904151,
0.036809992,
0.0066979816,
0.0184984673,
-0.0332956947,
0.0117878402,
0.0161375906,
0.072361432,
0.0645194203,
-0.0075049684,
0.0319915041,
-0.0282657072,
0.0044455687,
0.0489130951,
0.0622901209,
0.029987555,
0.0220996849,
0.0353621952,
0.024209829,
0.0091400407,
-0.0275517255,
-0.0417671576,
0.0283093136,
-0.0513595417,
0.031189343,
0.0188463815,
0.0438035019,
0.0016554968,
-0.0117190843,
-0.0290021207,
0.0312889852,
-0.0364274532,
0.0062743844,
0.0343976133,
-0.0132139027,
-0.0314968564,
0.0276140962,
0.0355376191,
-0.0426526293,
0.0142825618,
-0.0602771193,
-0.0095707066,
0.0587704778,
0.0801502466,
-0.0554601848,
-0.0276399162,
-0.0301818028,
-0.00786494,
0.0635319501,
0.0189963784,
-0.0281536058,
-0.0134487106,
-0.0134396264,
0.009177845,
0.0126578072,
0.0253103282,
-0.0221801382,
0.0233045164,
0.0174871515,
-0.0010567056,
-0.0691913068,
-0.0337368436,
0.0228492673,
-0.0589343347,
-0.0501591377,
-0.0134681268,
-0.0266542584,
-0.0030911546,
0.020454552,
-0.0183093585,
0.0398331136,
0.0411247015,
-0.0319721326,
-0.0133745736,
-0.0166669097,
0.0284976382,
-0.0433567129,
0.053178221,
-0.0046299137,
-0.050720308,
0.0226043854,
-0.0342786387,
-0.0240969863,
0.0116942581,
-0.0454186536,
0.0699776188,
-0.0286683347,
-0.0080222208,
0.0005712414,
-0.011203452,
-0.0281971525,
0.0505510084,
0.0159524623,
0.0148559036,
0.0084387232,
-0.0234410092,
-0.0111250672,
-0.0233130008,
-0.0029871333,
0.0230807569,
0.0006905893,
0.0173098464,
-0.0206090007,
0.0003653645,
-0.0617303513,
0.0251214076,
-0.1119439527,
0.0328502879,
-0.0062406356,
0.0445424132,
0.0017841666,
-0.0023426518,
-0.0019973603,
-0.0132499048,
-0.0370094329,
0.0166494064,
-0.0239067916,
0.0181650724,
-0.0000712442,
0.0094038984,
-0.0310085993,
-0.0294490028,
-0.0158110168,
-0.052335415,
0.0257922094,
0.0007116277,
-0.0425213091,
-0.0300074127,
0.0042661135,
-0.0108925346,
0.0079905549,
0.0134831034,
-0.014421788,
0.0336930566,
-0.0481409617,
-0.0048642969,
0.0368285291,
-0.0269220769,
0.0045098965,
0.0626499504,
-0.0055023837,
-0.044575274,
0.0139605757,
-0.0246213973,
-0.0493102223,
0.0150706032,
-0.0326858647,
-0.0032467723,
0.0428876095,
0.0009877892,
-0.0163414925,
-0.0484706275,
0.024405906,
-0.0115189431,
0.0006433997,
-0.0266927537,
0.0190765299,
-0.0184139218,
0.0037010456,
0.0033117905,
-0.0542484559,
0.0953871161,
-0.0210741293,
-0.002328469,
-0.0690430105,
0.0002808997,
-0.0186565854,
0.0596301891,
-0.0100489287,
0.0336828716,
-0.0182425603,
-0.0546963736,
-0.0006575698,
0.0617187321,
-0.0209899619,
-0.0903735235,
0.0397902243,
-0.0638904348,
0.018306667,
0.0058636097,
-0.0256023761,
-0.0270133354,
0.071750395,
-0.0439560302,
0.0052185967,
0.0135419331,
-0.0229040608,
-0.0385503359,
-0.0066197007,
0.0330199152,
0.0536011495,
-0.0103479261,
-0.0146866022,
-0.0001363753,
-0.0169664267,
0.0300345514,
-0.0007729857,
0.0025252197,
-0.0270476528,
0.031543389,
0.0672681853,
-0.0024626323,
0.0005655031,
0.0154213365,
0.0120733874,
0.0142498016,
-0.0454380624,
0.0117109232,
0.0339380987,
0.0131131038,
-0.0861327276,
-0.0483157262,
0.0962927341,
0.0581579581,
-0.0786687657,
-0.0053280974,
-0.0489381216,
-0.0070251678,
0.0025974191,
0.0763127208,
-0.1400748044,
-0.0356817916,
0.0057083922,
0.039573662,
-0.0039167735,
-0.046714019,
-0.0011331494,
-0.1068857834,
0.0474714078,
0.0401537232,
-0.0448467284,
-0.0429828763,
-0.0613170788,
-0.0108729834,
-0.0274136793,
0.0171737969,
0.0178589504,
0.0103787202,
0.0243310407,
0.0090133315,
0.0134280464,
-0.0792489424,
0.0313077047,
-0.0129752578,
0.0548495278,
0.075646691,
0.0007940699,
0.0083716838,
-0.0275609512,
0.0334433615,
0.0021634514,
-0.0172992013,
-0.0407800972,
0.0553827025,
0.0208995026,
-0.0112711918,
-0.0406151712,
0.0364928022,
-0.0536349751,
-0.0137870936,
-0.0156393088,
0.1140435487,
-0.0298458673,
-0.0263403021,
-0.046445936,
-0.0079202149,
0.0111706872,
0.0882626399,
0.0292085335,
-0.0240259562,
-0.0265398081,
-0.0563003086,
0.0259913336,
-0.0208448395,
-0.0558720902,
0.0562824346,
-0.0011594043,
-0.0303887855,
-0.0495673344,
-0.0212721769,
0.089369446,
-0.000014684,
0.0184185356,
0.0354996882,
0.0274984837,
-0.0126225743,
-0.0658586845,
0.0369309559,
-0.0096548069,
0.0048302989,
-0.0559560806,
-0.0766140595,
0.0587812699,
0.0019962315,
-0.009414034,
0.0894494206,
-0.0437720716,
-0.0855988413,
-0.0145213883,
0.0463689975,
0.0327866934,
0.0085247317,
-0.013646814,
-0.0308413636,
0.0079388358,
0.1072627306,
-0.0158325471,
-0.0199263953,
-0.0350162238,
-0.0022688515,
-0.0020369254,
0.014257418,
-0.0432942919,
-0.0278000534,
-0.0282263719,
0.0678389519,
0.0146062113,
0.0330611207,
0.0723439902,
0.0416444279,
0.030078344,
0.0062708887,
-0.0168466978,
-0.0022688285,
0.0100000035,
-0.0321541168,
-0.0244188309,
-0.0111758085,
-0.025143316,
0.0132027194,
-0.0283038057,
0.0134686148,
-0.000218943,
-0.0209521316,
0.0003494277,
-0.0626220629,
0.0054185912,
-0.0013587601,
-0.0255185906,
0.0762109533,
-0.0269983951,
-0.0348153785,
-0.0270633772,
0.003003611,
0.0446564779,
-0.0166121926,
0.0458191857,
0.0149615165,
0.017946776,
0.0071512652,
-0.0017980543,
-0.0404804759,
-0.073185578,
-0.0171547011,
0.0121466592,
0.0178693682,
-0.0059748599,
0.0289163701,
-0.0385326222,
-0.0091932993,
-0.0422988757,
0.0066718725,
-0.0036746908,
0.0051542465,
0.0360387303,
0.0287818667,
-0.0130197601,
-0.0691705123,
0.0952133536,
-0.0158422943,
0.0835435092,
0.0058623333,
-0.0385065079,
-0.0408823825,
-0.0535778031,
0.0258374326,
-0.0052929698,
-0.0302502476,
-0.0335420184,
-0.0543370023,
-0.0605658293,
-0.0226016641,
0.0201172642,
-0.0232324935,
0.0072236913,
0.0195333809,
0.0273085218,
0.0305563901,
-0.0821426958,
-0.000838969,
0.0673531517,
-0.0263209809,
-0.0656235218,
0.0106789041,
-6.725756232e-33,
-0.0187235847,
-0.0503080152,
0.0371862464,
-0.0024163153,
0.0047458941,
-0.0090015875,
-0.044828251,
0.0050053559,
0.002449221,
0.0307469852,
0.0018444954,
0.0147264414,
0.0081440527,
0.0002762993,
0.0200503077,
-0.0199402403,
0.02816879,
-0.0072450549,
0.0139176985,
0.0341391973,
0.013154285,
0.0519417785,
0.034217827,
-0.0648687035,
0.020062156,
0.0030596454,
0.0144726494,
-0.010842124,
-0.0222356413,
0.0232852381,
-0.0146694966,
0.0355870351,
0.0017971693,
-0.0212578215,
-0.0254725758,
0.0048031127,
-0.0751546919,
-0.0020927459,
0.0005428243,
0.0086528864,
-0.0342965238,
-0.0254726522,
0.0467508882,
-0.0097222608,
0.0017432149,
-0.0244994462,
0.0162637215,
-0.0404123478,
-0.0383103266,
-0.0167882275,
-0.0378144048,
0.0019368153,
-0.0021365243,
0.0089623285,
0.0267849732,
0.0179409906,
-0.0162085257,
0.0286966581,
-0.0291552339,
0.0214962624,
0.0483263545,
0.0270131435,
0.0724518597,
-0.0146292411,
0.0226045251,
0.0408926904,
0.0004848286,
-0.045312304,
0.0017845127,
0.0164863672,
0.0038412348,
0.0247337278,
0.0256613344,
-0.0054711676,
0.0344642028,
0.0153102437,
-0.0634561777,
0.0548326522,
-0.0330549031,
0.0187216848,
0.0221955292,
0.0127829406,
-0.0029967367,
-0.0049948334,
-0.0158809423,
0.0056580617,
-0.0514896922,
-0.0333888419,
0.0128413411,
-0.0408802405,
-0.0142345326,
-0.0157808047,
0.0207778867,
-0.0339976847,
-0.0424671322,
0.0105179874,
-0.0065615247,
0.0047473386,
-0.0349620469,
0.01657952,
-0.0182234105,
-0.0077175074,
0.0144608356,
-0.0219434351,
0.0547969267,
0.0120257083,
0.0024354225,
0.0021816764,
-0.0597724505,
0.0081444131,
-0.0611919723,
0.025576489,
0.0334210508,
0.0240264032,
0.0376078896,
0.0172456801,
0.0294733532,
0.0366730802,
0.024878893,
0.0210914835,
-0.022289088,
0.0141642233,
-0.0080289599,
-0.0314784236,
-0.0382588394,
-0.0086256778,
-0.0116962148,
0.0420104302,
0.0018428415,
-0.0575387143,
-0.0179828983,
0.0064614611,
3.045e-7,
0.064827539,
0.0862358436,
0.0132097937,
0.0380169526,
0.0036098268,
-0.0032070046,
-0.0252092667,
0.0162605774,
-0.0041449713,
-0.0470224954,
-0.0200217906,
0.002479695,
0.0512272157,
0.037306536,
-0.0877193883,
-0.0472273603,
-0.0079011545,
0.0157803427,
-0.0680708736,
0.001258171,
0.0566114485,
0.0727568492,
-0.0309676528,
-0.0040837242,
0.0598649792,
-0.0281412844,
0.0340219028,
-0.0104178833,
-0.016198257,
0.0372050107,
-0.0450610481,
0.054624524,
0.0283935703,
0.0389756039,
-0.0464998595,
-0.0603315979,
-0.0180726238,
0.0525008366,
-0.0187572744,
-0.0024548026,
0.0395737663,
-0.0011348317,
0.0539269075,
-0.0416742191,
0.0242263172,
-0.0248549469,
-0.0305453241,
0.0158404037,
-0.00738035,
-0.0344419591,
0.00309214,
-0.0396696068,
0.0081606917,
0.0444855504,
-0.0125607559,
0.0102121262,
-0.0117637068,
-0.0518676937,
-0.0410023965,
0.0395926945,
-0.0470546745,
-0.0424638242,
-0.0103662862,
0.0025534483,
-0.0297823306,
-0.042275656,
0.0096052373,
3.232791988e-34,
0.0185821801,
-0.0147751449,
0.0487962477,
0.0692239851,
0.053499274,
-0.0134877628,
0.0104310168,
0.0297340713,
-0.0150161711,
-0.0751964003,
-0.0189911965
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.