id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01155v1 | Lessons Learned in ATCO2: 5000 hours of Air Traffic Control Communications for Robust Automatic Speech Recognition and Understanding | 2023-05-02T02:04:33 | 2023-05-02T02:04:33 | Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Iuliia Nigmatulina, Amrutha Prasad, Petr Motlicek, Driss Khalil, Srikanth Madikeri, Allan Tart, Igor Szoke, Vincent Lenders, Mickael Rigault, Khalid Choukri | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD | Voice communication between air traffic controllers (ATCos) and pilots is
critical for ensuring safe and efficient air traffic control (ATC). This task
requires high levels of awareness from ATCos and can be tedious and
error-prone. Recent attempts have been made to integrate artificial
intelligence (AI) into ATC in order to reduce the workload of ATCos. However,
the development of data-driven AI systems for ATC demands large-scale annotated
datasets, which are currently lacking in the field. This paper explores the
lessons learned from the ATCO2 project, a project that aimed to develop a
unique platform to collect and preprocess large amounts of ATC data from
airspace in real time. Audio and surveillance data were collected from publicly
accessible radio frequency channels with VHF receivers owned by a community of
volunteers and later uploaded to Opensky Network servers, which can be
considered an "unlimited source" of data. In addition, this paper reviews
previous work from ATCO2 partners, including (i) robust automatic speech
recognition, (ii) natural language processing, (iii) English language
identification of ATC communications, and (iv) the integration of surveillance
data such as ADS-B. We believe that the pipeline developed during the ATCO2
project, along with the open-sourcing of its data, will encourage research in
the ATC field. A sample of the ATCO2 corpus is available on the following
website: https://www.atco2.org/data, while the full corpus can be purchased
through ELDA at http://catalog.elra.info/en-us/repository/browse/ELRA-S0484. We
demonstrated that ATCO2 is an appropriate dataset to develop ASR engines when
little or near to no ATC in-domain data is available. For instance, with the
CNN-TDNNf kaldi model, we reached the performance of as low as 17.9% and 24.9%
WER on public ATC datasets which is 6.6/7.6% better than "out-of-domain" but
supervised CNN-TDNNf model. | [
0.0156658329,
0.0489329956,
0.0004865294,
0.0210183132,
-0.0006673128,
0.02210816,
0.0093197683,
-0.0608942434,
-0.0363467112,
-0.0337790586,
-0.0018013043,
-0.031716276,
0.0273889434,
0.0582523048,
0.0056871823,
-0.0155244283,
0.0191115253,
-0.0890924037,
0.0336242691,
0.0406874605,
0.0008671314,
0.0361329243,
-0.0421711877,
0.0187935159,
-0.0067503927,
0.0138880229,
-0.0135312239,
-0.0164527819,
0.0540731624,
-0.0247043259,
-0.0302791148,
0.0026703742,
0.0647929683,
0.0330936797,
0.0000018485,
0.0004635832,
0.00060497,
-0.0017832614,
-0.0788459107,
-0.0066198851,
0.0390619673,
0.0143794045,
-0.0410790145,
0.0288160872,
-0.0559688881,
0.0117890835,
-0.0004436803,
0.023166962,
0.0943071097,
0.0695161149,
-0.0106343208,
-0.0207921937,
0.0540695079,
0.0012706246,
-0.0402111709,
-0.0388643965,
0.0172453728,
-0.0300959237,
0.0346706845,
-0.019522747,
0.0449331515,
0.0525885299,
-0.0114269983,
-0.0383499749,
0.010977502,
0.0276342146,
-0.0784052759,
-0.0383832678,
-0.0630102977,
0.0087569347,
-0.0001735454,
-0.023899585,
0.0223828703,
0.016075315,
-0.0168148372,
-0.0386890769,
-0.0252177827,
-0.06247513,
-0.0538109206,
-0.0023435033,
0.0132170171,
0.0185476616,
-0.0139588173,
-0.0103827314,
-0.0022889199,
0.0142497737,
-0.0390533842,
-0.0484793968,
0.063490741,
0.007179515,
0.0246087611,
-0.0511593036,
0.0279067904,
-0.003389095,
-0.0128511908,
0.0068176435,
-0.0252517611,
-0.0490511432,
-0.0342257433,
-0.0640216991,
0.0208107419,
0.0062077926,
-0.0768366158,
0.0164762251,
-0.0270707067,
0.0307834763,
0.0139858704,
-0.0154236639,
0.0179293044,
-0.0057101571,
-0.0639532879,
-0.0234701745,
-0.0845746547,
0.0287511591,
-0.0003165274,
0.0076543326,
-0.0528015047,
-0.0049416642,
-0.0190339722,
0.0606407747,
0.0175498631,
0.0131375762,
-0.0303257369,
0.0121025834,
0.0102214934,
-0.0205469355,
0.0115039144,
0.0748276412,
-0.0158535372,
-0.0757572204,
0.027933659,
0.0280360039,
0.038833037,
0.0035674032,
-0.0448923483,
0.0524253882,
-0.0172523763,
-0.0076196454,
-0.0456879027,
-0.0063897208,
0.0258921981,
-0.0253942087,
-0.0186644699,
-0.0153982909,
-0.0002405664,
-0.0028442163,
-0.0397863872,
-0.0368165076,
0.0089903641,
-0.0498384535,
0.0190671124,
0.1002818048,
-0.048765827,
-0.0117195062,
0.0539206415,
0.0040516234,
0.0339742973,
0.0298796482,
0.0413480662,
0.0169995893,
0.0364320315,
-0.013896103,
0.0445915386,
0.0287192333,
0.0030053325,
-0.0131477006,
-0.0345266424,
0.0581859201,
-0.02367872,
0.0019056263,
0.0092038549,
0.0011818192,
0.0057076942,
-0.0060459781,
0.0322782621,
0.0315550864,
-0.0243923329,
0.0119786626,
0.0562997684,
0.0481025614,
0.047908783,
-0.0687288567,
-0.0103242425,
0.0054508662,
-0.0422846004,
-0.038653098,
-0.0224284045,
0.028494738,
-0.0146126505,
-0.0719766095,
-0.0170037113,
-0.0235573053,
-0.0163473021,
0.0353099704,
0.0608082935,
-0.0919210166,
0.0049384609,
-0.045143757,
-0.0086498903,
0.0144448821,
-0.0124591012,
-0.0054527349,
-0.019358879,
0.0356312133,
-0.0069273035,
-0.0551906936,
-0.0085768281,
-0.0782956481,
0.0433185659,
0.0332115851,
-0.0001251709,
-0.0203123298,
0.0212542247,
-0.0466715433,
-0.0500733033,
0.0434703864,
-0.0119226286,
0.0565840304,
-0.0406589583,
0.0140865268,
0.0089018978,
0.0534688383,
-0.060539268,
0.0202922188,
0.0248573311,
-0.0499912091,
-0.0004789995,
0.0230978858,
0.1002442837,
0.071625948,
-0.0173930787,
-0.0187380463,
0.0151878651,
-0.0127979256,
0.0000135828,
0.0376700126,
-0.0318700261,
0.0479607843,
0.029430205,
-0.027430553,
-0.0422492363,
0.0627659857,
-0.0154405879,
-0.0779183581,
0.0535269156,
-0.0637314469,
0.0209446512,
0.0067186081,
0.033780884,
0.0117152445,
0.0323402397,
0.0197466761,
0.0089129424,
0.016915869,
-0.0644052774,
0.0343735628,
-0.0057653743,
0.0625211969,
-0.0383612812,
0.0096758967,
-0.0040680449,
-0.0116110174,
-0.0067756763,
0.0053041065,
-0.0037898861,
-0.0371746197,
0.0240984112,
-0.0213492829,
-0.0221101996,
-0.0131743662,
0.029756194,
-0.0420737453,
0.0002658976,
-0.0285463333,
-0.0300148204,
-0.0172705371,
-0.006989459,
0.0046537644,
-0.0597492419,
-0.0160546843,
0.0380622409,
-0.1066709757,
-0.0236064531,
-0.0251089558,
-0.0016100255,
-0.0307911914,
0.0405494906,
-0.0763292834,
-0.0678768903,
0.0008886643,
-0.0275134705,
0.0601375625,
-0.0170929357,
-0.0336557031,
0.0548847318,
-0.0090704579,
-0.0194974337,
0.0479829162,
0.0594709553,
0.0299148485,
0.0189056136,
-0.0069763497,
-0.0127138281,
0.0371043943,
0.0331589989,
0.0100775873,
-0.0422865972,
0.0308006201,
-0.0148133188,
0.0352705829,
0.0022543543,
0.0732535571,
-0.0202392545,
-0.0140585788,
-0.0073357644,
-0.0537954271,
-0.0484217182,
-0.0399088077,
-0.0153128719,
0.0379418172,
0.0195739418,
-0.0332377031,
0.0631361157,
-0.0400580764,
-0.0244775414,
-0.0189233348,
-0.0712737814,
0.010098082,
0.0032578299,
-0.0238232352,
-0.001100537,
-0.0073848474,
-0.0322606303,
-0.0080460431,
-0.0543563403,
0.0026297104,
-0.0369055159,
0.0166054107,
-0.0728517845,
0.0402127393,
0.0033070361,
-0.0463354848,
-0.0318238735,
0.0432181992,
-0.089077957,
0.0189155564,
-0.007676858,
-0.0521770157,
-0.0164272804,
0.0447245687,
0.0483845137,
0.0316651165,
0.0294879954,
0.0106463218,
-0.0094641959,
0.0061158133,
0.0675446093,
0.023305662,
0.0039184955,
0.019253524,
0.0042728446,
-0.0410140455,
0.0405413695,
0.0095419828,
-0.0419109203,
0.0226597544,
-0.0106796119,
-0.0064640748,
-0.0056118728,
0.0223554634,
0.0177368466,
-0.0429532826,
0.021962788,
0.0737134293,
0.0076562194,
-0.0324387886,
-0.008704382,
-0.028467061,
-0.0754108727,
0.0191842895,
0.0085886233,
-0.055924613,
-0.0020466438,
-0.0072400495,
0.0501492396,
0.0147017436,
-0.0052664978,
0.0054371618,
-0.0759733841,
0.0362045616,
-0.0135534052,
-0.0560458712,
-0.0437865444,
-0.0405672006,
0.0002202088,
-0.0468377396,
0.0535573512,
-0.0343871675,
0.0209787488,
-0.0465314351,
0.0486544184,
-0.057052955,
-0.0676076263,
0.0202724431,
-0.0234960299,
0.112686798,
0.0327179804,
0.0357141308,
-0.0142186917,
-0.0386477411,
-0.0277087074,
0.0066725211,
-0.0076615531,
-0.0224777106,
-0.005799388,
0.0031211916,
-0.0153248981,
0.0077405996,
0.0680266619,
-0.0152252978,
0.023440497,
0.0447202995,
0.0619320981,
-0.0550481156,
-0.0034174635,
-0.0184838567,
0.0160452724,
0.0442232341,
0.0514023639,
-0.0083238911,
0.0021230967,
-0.0407637022,
0.0029621341,
0.0155935585,
-0.0626071841,
-0.0414307602,
0.0381909646,
0.0362311453,
-0.0757988542,
-0.025151981,
-0.0419995748,
0.0578446239,
0.0047275228,
-0.0158442371,
0.050881952,
0.0442908444,
0.0250090193,
-0.0149048101,
-0.0071752537,
0.0128763765,
0.034997914,
-0.0503701344,
-0.0088985302,
0.0087649925,
-0.0235016122,
-0.0256314222,
0.0664888024,
-0.060542196,
-0.0214123763,
0.096058242,
-0.0177593436,
0.0263074543,
0.0523252524,
-0.0334466398,
-0.0471323319,
0.0371009894,
0.0010503299,
-0.0539283343,
-0.0233519655,
0.0205906145,
0.0281007476,
-0.0317428671,
0.0292704925,
-0.0334081464,
0.0175702032,
0.0153691331,
-0.0465586148,
-0.041853033,
-0.0145012951,
-0.0006753694,
0.0467178524,
-0.0011659933,
0.0044651642,
-0.053084448,
-0.0254843384,
0.0372788385,
-0.0122585231,
0.0286527891,
-0.0086998586,
0.037019439,
-0.0305829104,
0.0267321672,
0.0259917546,
0.0228278972,
-0.0197288413,
-0.0121365078,
0.0143389273,
0.0576153956,
0.021454839,
0.0370052047,
0.0399331264,
0.0101082521,
0.0129258456,
0.0504406542,
0.0529889576,
0.0447669402,
0.0055478499,
0.0004669915,
0.020677641,
0.0200689845,
0.0181187205,
0.0512669235,
-0.0487187617,
0.0087638795,
0.0103854155,
0.0420280136,
0.0258663278,
0.0094709583,
0.0159182157,
-0.0255903713,
0.0362486355,
-0.0021986882,
0.031122826,
0.0054128892,
0.0162224043,
0.0666185617,
0.0313383751,
-0.0305101983,
0.0441064276,
0.0329667442,
0.0042620958,
0.045290526,
-0.0251790714,
0.0030557807,
-0.0834517851,
-0.0153561588,
0.0041490528,
-0.0072440184,
-0.0489444323,
0.0185684524,
-0.0231936481,
-0.0331877023,
-0.0031848806,
-0.005016563,
-0.0106817391,
-0.0554360487,
-0.0038726414,
0.005340104,
0.006008401,
0.0128010539,
0.0172338746,
-0.0803696364,
-0.0360351428,
-0.0496554337,
0.0272089671,
-5.395469846e-33,
-0.0429655984,
0.0232889913,
0.0184060466,
0.0224022828,
-0.0168064404,
-0.0057582245,
0.0098227328,
-0.0507066883,
-0.0038598098,
-0.0377407558,
-0.0128490664,
0.0382454135,
0.0301990546,
-0.0467228517,
0.0351229385,
-0.0128509002,
0.0601992421,
-0.0274075903,
-0.0002062654,
0.0308599174,
0.0671894252,
0.0030729964,
0.0076530459,
-0.0953234881,
0.0065509593,
0.0230193418,
-0.0233375579,
0.0154612232,
0.0311955698,
0.0768117085,
-0.0168485567,
0.0395104028,
0.0055130064,
-0.0045739994,
-0.0184269976,
0.0244108308,
-0.05120942,
-0.0044308831,
-0.0103778997,
0.0493703149,
0.0167445187,
-0.0086197527,
0.0065504923,
0.0496374145,
0.0000844223,
0.0043998738,
0.0544985868,
-0.0458449088,
-0.0067043034,
-0.0701962933,
-0.0445811674,
0.0351881757,
-0.0541682243,
-0.0272055771,
0.0443090871,
0.0091285668,
-0.0197003242,
-0.043695569,
-0.0168857649,
0.0254778136,
0.0354918055,
0.0223290753,
0.030967772,
0.0384332798,
0.0058408882,
0.0270521622,
0.0145701058,
-0.0544761121,
-0.017084958,
-0.0164358336,
0.0169447679,
0.0488383695,
0.044325199,
0.026396092,
-0.0122967837,
-0.0478759333,
-0.0602881052,
0.0015944085,
0.0453249887,
0.0626431853,
-0.0168945361,
0.0132602304,
-0.0675060973,
0.0207647271,
0.0172654521,
-0.0122327162,
0.0008808553,
-0.0225166492,
0.0226934254,
0.0244698096,
-0.0340110883,
0.069521904,
0.0496560372,
-0.0125837466,
0.0362384357,
-0.0172550604,
0.0348608866,
0.0007828762,
0.0050148345,
0.0107945921,
-0.0657074377,
0.0019977677,
0.0641432777,
0.0464272797,
0.0537958778,
-0.0487522595,
0.0151588665,
0.0896716565,
-0.0061362502,
0.003454563,
-0.0162174404,
0.0670171678,
0.0206085816,
0.0126344748,
0.050383389,
-0.007170558,
-0.0000450965,
0.0083243661,
-0.0298649278,
-0.0403550901,
-0.005569844,
-0.0248148832,
-0.0107476478,
0.0142702404,
-0.0715987533,
0.0148058524,
-0.0189046841,
-0.0336587466,
0.0266586971,
-0.034729816,
0.0182616003,
-0.0106570059,
2.593e-7,
-0.0581383966,
0.0223258529,
0.0724368393,
0.009965633,
0.0037584256,
-0.0110044042,
-0.0124572469,
-0.0173375756,
-0.0122341393,
0.0206291955,
0.0270092171,
-0.0169355217,
0.098165974,
0.0694742426,
-0.0487643927,
-0.0220582616,
-0.0619730614,
-0.0278415363,
-0.0801352859,
0.0342252105,
0.0798583254,
0.0788770989,
-0.000978083,
-0.0387034416,
0.0129735647,
-0.0054076253,
-0.0186805762,
-0.0024523521,
0.0159342028,
-0.0240876712,
0.0301424917,
0.0503272824,
-0.0439573564,
0.0286632422,
-0.0279481001,
0.0220543128,
0.0062789712,
0.034408804,
-0.0176739097,
0.0226458348,
-0.0103313858,
-0.0360616036,
-0.0210063253,
-0.005102674,
0.0264953747,
-0.0507852361,
0.0049160528,
0.0188066382,
-0.0126751652,
-0.0372797996,
-0.0421125591,
-0.0106509235,
0.0270263739,
-0.000955521,
-0.0351545401,
-0.0251874924,
0.0438952595,
-0.0654237196,
0.0529777706,
0.0165262688,
-0.0154901193,
-0.0140301641,
-0.0133372387,
0.038421724,
0.04826314,
0.0295055639,
0.0052634459,
1.295998823e-34,
0.0154416794,
0.0039089322,
-0.0329511575,
0.0011083019,
-0.0003382466,
-0.0170407332,
-0.0241088904,
0.0321731642,
0.0066045695,
-0.0646052137,
-0.0133992285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01146v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01146v3 | RadAdapt: Radiology Report Summarization via Lightweight Domain Adaptation of Large Language Models | 2023-05-02T01:33:02 | 2023-07-20T13:10:07 | Dave Van Veen, Cara Van Uden, Maayane Attias, Anuj Pareek, Christian Bluethgen, Malgorzata Polacin, Wah Chiu, Jean-Benoit Delbrouck, Juan Manuel Zambrano Chaves, Curtis P. Langlotz, Akshay S. Chaudhari, John Pauly | cs.CL | cs.CL | We systematically investigate lightweight strategies to adapt large language
models (LLMs) for the task of radiology report summarization (RRS).
Specifically, we focus on domain adaptation via pretraining (on natural
language, biomedical text, or clinical text) and via discrete prompting or
parameter-efficient fine-tuning. Our results consistently achieve best
performance by maximally adapting to the task via pretraining on clinical text
and fine-tuning on RRS examples. Importantly, this method fine-tunes a mere
0.32% of parameters throughout the model, in contrast to end-to-end fine-tuning
(100% of parameters). Additionally, we study the effect of in-context examples
and out-of-distribution (OOD) training before concluding with a radiologist
reader study and qualitative analysis. Our findings highlight the importance of
domain adaptation in RRS and provide valuable insights toward developing
effective natural language processing solutions for clinical tasks. | [
0.0688424259,
0.0227489788,
0.0434073284,
-0.0192861836,
-0.0031919994,
0.0347116254,
-0.0238820352,
0.0354462303,
-0.0362592824,
-0.0262065865,
-0.0377132818,
-0.043602135,
0.0180497933,
0.0140449954,
0.0076213893,
-0.104825139,
0.0223288573,
-0.026450431,
0.0041824854,
0.0053828903,
0.0129231177,
0.0059294845,
-0.016179204,
0.0142077608,
0.0327579305,
-0.0023094842,
0.0503388941,
0.0081781009,
0.034650784,
-0.044499971,
-0.0233746469,
0.0350737125,
0.0261790082,
0.0177216586,
0.0000019328,
-0.0497332998,
-0.0408483297,
0.0446897782,
0.0008447007,
-0.0026853539,
0.1109218895,
-0.0758183897,
-0.0197451822,
0.0208439343,
-0.0033300587,
-0.0574780405,
0.0407858789,
0.0495078824,
0.0687994584,
0.0911765099,
-0.0246061999,
0.0029443107,
-0.0025626963,
-0.0439804979,
-0.0251227859,
-0.0484468341,
0.0250308234,
0.0283682086,
0.0138898911,
0.0035693066,
-0.009973946,
0.038404718,
-0.0223431103,
0.0212152191,
-0.0110492883,
0.0501506738,
-0.0432096645,
-0.0037835867,
0.0101643922,
0.0477633215,
-0.0082897749,
0.0035382076,
0.0207421426,
0.0005556141,
-0.0244590677,
-0.0167783312,
-0.0547891147,
0.0100002056,
-0.0177824739,
-0.0119464071,
-0.0204880256,
0.0033773889,
-0.014606501,
0.038768746,
-0.0397489816,
-0.0206570923,
0.0040950798,
-0.0047843782,
0.0140825938,
0.0177441537,
-0.0278897397,
-0.0561963916,
0.0429271311,
0.0372810438,
-0.0414555445,
0.0134469168,
-0.0531529523,
-0.0336485505,
0.0618317947,
-0.0414053872,
-0.0287445504,
-0.0037076764,
-0.0177398659,
0.0665230006,
-0.0244670697,
-0.014899998,
-0.0178193524,
0.0217078067,
-0.0432096794,
-0.0038664523,
-0.0241398327,
-0.0128391115,
-0.0476331562,
0.0125800986,
-0.0305600055,
-0.024003258,
-0.0609517321,
0.0057083061,
0.0411623046,
-0.0101624615,
0.0347814076,
0.0337082781,
-0.0790522024,
-0.0038158854,
-0.0021041608,
0.0790691897,
-0.0005019587,
-0.0200320035,
-0.0094563989,
-0.0178318899,
-0.010937009,
0.0313933678,
0.0116198333,
-0.0018183717,
-0.0029422631,
0.0298418887,
-0.0263243057,
-0.0271767974,
0.0331142321,
-0.0375019386,
-0.02026424,
-0.0300091952,
0.0145987663,
-0.0793361291,
-0.0059293271,
0.0337543115,
0.0357234366,
-0.0314776003,
0.0010909645,
0.0068335435,
-0.0727832913,
0.0523021445,
-0.0397884026,
0.00820529,
0.0280410219,
0.0247176252,
0.0310469419,
0.0516066365,
0.0240288265,
-0.0192459486,
-0.016145099,
0.0033923939,
-0.0105801886,
0.0101647386,
-0.011620678,
-0.0185403265,
-0.00416453,
0.0185751002,
-0.0270963628,
0.0551556163,
0.0291747134,
0.0648276731,
-0.0051612607,
0.0105496757,
0.0238062534,
0.0598067828,
0.0359572247,
0.0176177397,
0.0150471069,
-0.0198940132,
0.0030649973,
0.0265297014,
-0.0279778335,
0.0164376609,
0.0123770209,
0.0476806127,
0.0063287811,
0.0109109879,
-0.0266786814,
-0.0115534421,
-0.0179269984,
0.0215481725,
-0.0206340421,
-0.0246568378,
0.0608930141,
0.0127055775,
-0.0605546497,
0.0404688753,
0.0513697863,
-0.0228857845,
-0.0056702378,
-0.0554567315,
-0.0574323907,
0.0499235727,
0.0813299343,
-0.0701120198,
-0.0334038474,
0.0004507308,
0.0854662284,
0.0417728685,
0.0608825348,
0.0121068722,
0.0057627186,
-0.0505712256,
-0.0410099849,
0.0420876816,
0.0224266648,
-0.0084027397,
0.0184153337,
0.0067520612,
-0.0022400538,
-0.0385787152,
-0.0732271597,
0.0438642874,
-0.0464397669,
-0.0350207984,
-0.0227100849,
-0.0122630522,
-0.0202800352,
-0.0034754614,
-0.0327161327,
0.0242312197,
0.0064548408,
0.0032883217,
-0.0048019206,
0.0043988135,
-0.0511867926,
-0.0242431238,
0.0087911468,
-0.0595208704,
0.0143851712,
-0.0149955265,
-0.0342013948,
-0.0072799497,
-0.0302885454,
-0.0480655394,
0.0156750549,
0.010088373,
0.0448361561,
0.0475077331,
0.0064969915,
-0.0315593332,
0.0328296162,
0.01214818,
-0.0120963454,
0.0553414635,
-0.0412286483,
0.0015468238,
-0.0337892734,
-0.020381989,
0.0144028459,
0.018619841,
-0.0001202563,
0.0037995682,
0.0456827544,
-0.0204873253,
-0.0374577902,
-0.084373422,
0.0066821347,
0.006297092,
-0.0032361753,
0.0636455938,
0.0546762682,
-0.0103743142,
-0.0413739234,
-0.0118122539,
-0.0424691327,
0.0517833829,
0.0274794437,
0.0514000989,
0.0328596532,
0.0415537469,
-0.0494355075,
-0.0221826006,
-0.0139857326,
0.0195470434,
0.0231090095,
-0.0353487469,
-0.0240701605,
0.0514298901,
-0.0157832373,
0.0011162921,
0.0291860383,
-0.0326789729,
-0.0005210123,
-0.0184335019,
0.0072029843,
0.0685843602,
0.0180836041,
0.0163052771,
0.0492838472,
-0.0034932534,
-0.0104435217,
-0.0005614192,
-0.034657307,
-0.0521642268,
0.0161174834,
-0.0304397251,
0.0050718179,
0.0460638218,
-0.0198483858,
0.0067831376,
-0.0303988587,
-0.0139332162,
-0.0414204672,
-0.0084335376,
-0.0313698538,
0.0078181857,
-0.0153897163,
0.0325978287,
0.0004514818,
-0.0160209481,
0.0966668427,
-0.0040617497,
0.0240992066,
-0.1179960445,
-0.0121687362,
-0.0548833571,
0.0004744436,
-0.0053759995,
0.0267736129,
0.038197618,
-0.0254747104,
-0.0312092714,
-0.0055895117,
0.0348818079,
-0.0394723229,
0.0557848848,
-0.0192800779,
0.0130454255,
-0.0398098975,
-0.0260080472,
-0.0190047324,
-0.0339821689,
-0.0111906994,
-0.004740146,
-0.0030894058,
-0.0106494557,
-0.0875810385,
0.0593392625,
0.0358399898,
0.0835580155,
-0.0182768274,
-0.0206770971,
-0.0026892244,
0.0434539281,
0.05989068,
0.030508481,
-0.018399423,
-0.0474793948,
0.0328895971,
0.0440466516,
0.0002376179,
-0.0027749962,
-0.0076279333,
-0.0086131245,
-0.0021187589,
-0.0425642356,
0.0119319232,
0.0031581833,
0.0629979819,
-0.0578683801,
-0.0239799172,
0.1022093743,
0.0304010138,
-0.0505900085,
-0.0219769515,
0.0095966887,
0.0187006369,
0.0012103739,
0.0248831529,
-0.017130116,
-0.0306218117,
-0.0015344926,
0.0495474823,
0.0051369029,
-0.0049506905,
-0.007843731,
-0.0441201366,
0.0182351992,
0.0205186512,
-0.0831240267,
-0.0346775353,
-0.0318672881,
0.0008664359,
0.0009180673,
-0.0104201389,
-0.0092274714,
-0.0630426705,
-0.0124779819,
0.0223059338,
-0.0717782229,
-0.0848506242,
-0.0288015828,
-0.0444182754,
-0.0079613049,
0.0663995892,
0.017297335,
-0.0163496882,
0.0519441254,
0.0185743049,
0.0068740025,
0.018763002,
-0.0091908006,
0.1098242328,
0.0255221352,
-0.001991377,
-0.0424737856,
0.0168800093,
-0.0034674078,
0.0023359996,
-0.0073363595,
0.0285721403,
0.0060422136,
-0.0101995282,
-0.0611573905,
0.0607593097,
0.0071932576,
0.0332739353,
-0.0086642494,
0.0084725525,
-0.0269738548,
-0.0008535787,
0.033215005,
-0.0288946256,
-0.0521383658,
0.0062883575,
-0.0770388693,
-0.0499506481,
-0.069151938,
-0.0198637377,
0.0417423509,
0.004220021,
0.0113226231,
0.0246258378,
-0.0116900112,
0.0133367898,
-0.0519456193,
0.0656190217,
-0.0065926686,
-0.0177589208,
-0.0604022257,
-0.0340543576,
0.0947119445,
0.0020502021,
-0.0090669412,
0.0295051597,
-0.0356920213,
-0.0135089951,
-0.0088183209,
0.0414430797,
0.031442292,
0.0316389576,
0.0039779665,
-0.0294141341,
0.075847894,
0.0563279167,
-0.0150669431,
0.0270220414,
-0.0126776593,
-0.0145136202,
-0.0410883054,
0.0082273744,
-0.0397732593,
0.0348488241,
-0.003951218,
0.038146697,
-0.0095579829,
-0.0514761247,
0.0239327718,
0.0300464854,
0.007913339,
-0.0132554509,
-0.0237039067,
-0.0128875533,
-0.0004225035,
-0.0183807369,
0.0258971732,
-0.0169701464,
0.0381415412,
0.0198434629,
0.0214023888,
-0.0188485831,
0.0497660562,
-0.0286903251,
-0.0049808756,
-0.0375970043,
0.0440229364,
0.0055241585,
-0.032259088,
0.0374870002,
-0.0142858503,
-0.0294120535,
-0.0518004596,
-0.0095558558,
0.0082784304,
-0.0170784481,
0.0381042771,
0.0235209782,
0.0464775488,
-0.021135021,
0.0665099397,
-0.0524213128,
-0.0054520066,
-0.0530325025,
0.0208892599,
0.0443644747,
-0.0216721594,
0.0377362743,
-0.0422252715,
0.0018755239,
-0.0287494212,
0.0268186107,
0.0103475275,
0.0488921404,
0.0126116285,
0.0169752669,
0.0408696644,
0.0034826356,
0.0960255638,
0.01526081,
0.0239902847,
0.0052041579,
-0.0598885156,
-0.0339545719,
-0.0246598553,
-0.0148593737,
0.0006015305,
-0.0368135199,
0.0123167848,
-0.0482096039,
-0.0356650911,
-0.0150518278,
-0.0307159591,
-0.0280637983,
-0.0559911691,
0.0581511259,
0.0393097624,
0.0090866936,
0.0030201196,
-0.0108509148,
0.0293762404,
0.0042934674,
-0.0083634909,
0.0167174581,
-5.760821205e-33,
-0.0209268257,
-0.0200841818,
0.0200692527,
-0.0257025491,
-0.0118638193,
0.0422760174,
-0.0433669314,
-0.0261198673,
0.0071162661,
0.0066590649,
-0.0493326597,
-0.0097856,
0.0256439596,
0.034888681,
-0.0294789225,
0.016419841,
0.0458378121,
-0.0046820301,
-0.0401713252,
-0.0021618507,
-0.0411733054,
0.0353835821,
0.0383685455,
-0.0892343596,
-0.0221829824,
0.0198800899,
0.0069836769,
-0.0137582682,
0.0389000773,
0.0541006401,
-0.0344546437,
0.0065101041,
0.0256629176,
-0.0386385582,
-0.0350721739,
0.0297372509,
-0.118483603,
-0.0011000789,
0.0343573578,
-0.0102769723,
-0.0218551457,
-0.0080136051,
0.0397033207,
-0.0219779573,
0.0364194922,
-0.0412076078,
0.043060191,
-0.0398033187,
-0.0197086465,
-0.0217999052,
-0.0598207191,
0.069591023,
0.0091732806,
-0.0252274014,
0.0097458325,
0.009347246,
-0.0315419771,
0.0482596345,
-0.0154492203,
-0.004491006,
0.0796236172,
0.0641059801,
0.0159390643,
0.0054323194,
-0.0397389829,
0.0304384027,
0.0124984449,
-0.0125104012,
0.0149680534,
0.0127747944,
-0.0339000225,
0.0037458311,
0.0090525243,
0.036979951,
0.0524603017,
-0.0005345386,
-0.0820821598,
0.0541920885,
-0.0639813468,
0.0504364185,
0.0404134244,
-0.0233501326,
-0.0423061512,
0.0171172209,
0.0016368254,
0.0200426374,
-0.0301042628,
-0.0332836993,
0.0321413092,
0.0302871019,
-0.0401005037,
0.0357231796,
0.017668765,
0.0029372128,
0.0180472098,
-0.031578593,
0.0293410271,
0.0291745011,
-0.0629535317,
-0.0180034246,
-0.0101769874,
-0.0183050931,
0.039056208,
-0.0105663165,
0.0180650242,
-0.0078118532,
0.0345678031,
0.005703887,
-0.0727640986,
0.0044213161,
0.0384799875,
0.0033146036,
-0.0311587695,
0.0928116441,
-0.0009304645,
0.0160503946,
-0.0023640918,
0.0495023876,
-0.0191392358,
-0.0408741683,
-0.0259609185,
-0.0396351367,
0.0339826271,
0.0132447658,
-0.0569240451,
0.0006626254,
-0.0003609229,
0.0291999113,
0.070270054,
-0.029094493,
-0.0421698466,
-0.0086207259,
2.678e-7,
0.0915779546,
0.0594323203,
0.0420758985,
-0.004900543,
0.0137986699,
-0.0105530117,
-0.0177245867,
0.0356892645,
0.0255263876,
0.017745886,
0.0330658816,
0.0092852693,
0.0211447831,
0.0160793625,
-0.1032681465,
-0.0566877685,
-0.0459598638,
-0.0190968607,
-0.0162269678,
-0.0594825,
0.047048077,
0.0884936452,
-0.0606155619,
-0.0252655428,
-0.0154479863,
-0.0494357869,
0.0254927594,
-0.0292708911,
0.0114505254,
0.0368697308,
0.0240484681,
0.0276019517,
0.002115095,
0.031082524,
-0.0069598914,
-0.0204306841,
0.0365614109,
0.0965777859,
-0.0477715991,
0.0124118403,
0.0287827831,
0.0104080671,
0.0299834311,
0.0094911084,
0.0334559046,
-0.0889552534,
-0.0131732095,
-0.0069608381,
-0.0058778347,
-0.0122836288,
0.0237992648,
-0.0378215648,
-0.062560536,
0.0477157198,
0.0261900593,
0.0152207082,
-0.0623988919,
-0.0937585458,
-0.0224150792,
0.0241983961,
0.0110065844,
-0.0532813221,
0.0215138271,
-0.02704289,
-0.0068094954,
-0.0663807988,
0.0069895484,
2.646188624e-34,
0.0806037039,
0.0066425512,
-0.0273012482,
0.0187454782,
0.0281347297,
-0.0361914635,
-0.0113557307,
0.0119465608,
0.0363963321,
-0.0691859275,
-0.0072494354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01145v1 | ADVISE: AI-accelerated Design of Evidence Synthesis for Global Development | 2023-05-02T01:29:53 | 2023-05-02T01:29:53 | Kristen M. Edwards, Binyang Song, Jaron Porciello, Mark Engelbert, Carolyn Huang, Faez Ahmed | cs.CL | cs.CL | When designing evidence-based policies and programs, decision-makers must
distill key information from a vast and rapidly growing literature base.
Identifying relevant literature from raw search results is time and resource
intensive, and is often done by manual screening. In this study, we develop an
AI agent based on a bidirectional encoder representations from transformers
(BERT) model and incorporate it into a human team designing an evidence
synthesis product for global development. We explore the effectiveness of the
human-AI hybrid team in accelerating the evidence synthesis process. To further
improve team efficiency, we enhance the human-AI hybrid team through active
learning (AL). Specifically, we explore different sampling strategies,
including random sampling, least confidence (LC) sampling, and highest priority
(HP) sampling, to study their influence on the collaborative screening process.
Results show that incorporating the BERT-based AI agent into the human team can
reduce the human screening effort by 68.5% compared to the case of no AI
assistance and by 16.8% compared to the case of using a support vector machine
(SVM)-based AI agent for identifying 80% of all relevant documents. When we
apply the HP sampling strategy for AL, the human screening effort can be
reduced even more: by 78.3% for identifying 80% of all relevant documents
compared to no AI assistance. We apply the AL-enhanced human-AI hybrid teaming
workflow in the design process of three evidence gap maps (EGMs) for USAID and
find it to be highly effective. These findings demonstrate how AI can
accelerate the development of evidence synthesis products and promote timely
evidence-based decision making in global development in a human-AI hybrid
teaming context. | [
0.0420470573,
0.0187785998,
-0.0291875508,
-0.0493470952,
-0.0075449641,
0.0250219908,
0.0266551375,
-0.0010545716,
-0.0066855079,
-0.0133319311,
0.0290252268,
0.0323083512,
-0.0070556519,
0.0592969321,
0.0041374112,
-0.0648132041,
0.0131581435,
-0.0011572237,
0.0546390973,
-0.0149074318,
-0.0428693928,
-0.0200942531,
-0.0197042692,
0.0740822852,
0.0021724661,
0.0184521936,
-0.0374535546,
-0.0202109888,
0.031219298,
-0.0798652694,
0.0137381116,
0.0197401922,
-0.0038775175,
-0.0371629782,
0.0000023544,
-0.0194747951,
-0.0122622671,
0.0142308371,
-0.0161168668,
-0.0218944922,
0.0262262151,
0.0125335567,
0.0180452857,
-0.001296108,
-0.0644873604,
-0.0134437839,
0.0338633731,
0.0253921226,
0.0003470301,
-0.0209712908,
-0.0000632568,
0.0017325762,
0.0176727865,
-0.0131810922,
-0.0135417366,
0.0102744224,
0.0181117393,
-0.0146760419,
0.0444557592,
0.0214110389,
0.0276185945,
0.041104544,
-0.0064926851,
-0.0065421648,
0.0303206425,
0.0411373004,
-0.0396224372,
-0.0358377472,
0.0147233186,
0.0501534604,
0.0547246337,
0.0325283855,
-0.0022890966,
-0.032290522,
0.0373773426,
0.095395498,
-0.0363654159,
0.0199879054,
-0.0549836271,
-0.0026099032,
0.031980712,
0.0024017524,
-0.0181608293,
0.00367434,
-0.0103386557,
0.0479564629,
-0.0476177968,
-0.0303701814,
0.0288841575,
0.0553239211,
0.0079080164,
-0.0321905166,
0.0219375603,
0.0322656706,
-0.0512415431,
-0.0162932016,
0.0536819175,
-0.0464318581,
0.0326514505,
-0.0336013436,
0.0308183171,
-0.0028654893,
-0.0079279039,
0.0239887089,
0.0184503943,
-0.018836258,
-0.0151699856,
0.0470252633,
0.0044583841,
0.0210433565,
-0.0883579776,
0.0013275595,
-0.0034741936,
0.0188670643,
-0.0146371732,
-0.0036158746,
-0.0349398889,
0.0052195489,
-0.0267801452,
0.0177213773,
0.0157357641,
0.0576778054,
-0.0377729759,
0.0232857782,
-0.068981111,
0.0224787332,
-0.0185378753,
0.0490613729,
-0.0307889152,
0.039412085,
0.0419767871,
0.0176092889,
0.0081367465,
0.0147268819,
0.023720203,
0.0486567952,
-0.0022473724,
-0.0230476502,
-0.0210350603,
-0.0082341693,
0.0301385429,
-0.0277069714,
0.0260820929,
-0.0458585322,
0.0050321701,
0.0093470449,
-0.0087802606,
-0.0290566105,
-0.0259464402,
-0.0191772413,
-0.0431452952,
0.0337401554,
-0.0408544205,
-0.0069029923,
0.045341339,
0.0144281574,
-0.0473990552,
0.0248781685,
0.0085275173,
0.0691125095,
-0.0067128036,
0.0197960567,
0.0095820939,
-0.0457632653,
-0.0201640222,
0.0293670036,
0.0433334298,
0.0044358997,
-0.0568363406,
0.001788996,
-0.0576195456,
-0.0085979132,
-0.0498851128,
0.069045499,
0.0546670295,
0.017919438,
0.0214690901,
0.0112392427,
0.0282441359,
0.0577337109,
0.0157427099,
-0.0430087224,
0.0239342377,
0.0313949287,
0.0020433092,
-0.0298478454,
-0.0046494734,
0.0595975481,
-0.04406422,
-0.0348475389,
0.0153488647,
-0.003214974,
-0.0063442923,
0.0007361,
0.0240854938,
-0.012463307,
-0.0232861601,
-0.0055886493,
0.0038173127,
0.0176005177,
-0.0228041019,
-0.0333554298,
0.0514483638,
0.0221882425,
0.0399958715,
-0.0624734536,
-0.0427561104,
-0.0363980606,
-0.0369158536,
0.0006783686,
-0.0002916056,
-0.0272369124,
-0.0362267345,
-0.0033745808,
-0.091690883,
0.0142898718,
0.0111569995,
0.0603393614,
-0.0108157285,
0.0420987755,
-0.0202873126,
-0.0311794914,
-0.0287283473,
0.059748251,
-0.0183964223,
0.0301730409,
0.0297671873,
0.0067830165,
0.0981100574,
0.0366464891,
-0.0095178327,
0.0087056607,
0.0280402321,
-0.0336192846,
-0.0559445918,
0.0181264728,
0.0462761447,
0.037288744,
-0.0416518822,
-0.1103890762,
0.0067822728,
0.0028390763,
-0.0333759598,
-0.0024384947,
-0.0117557459,
-0.0182707421,
-0.0404711477,
0.0000598226,
0.0341444388,
-0.0237605497,
0.0046341214,
-0.0233896486,
0.041565869,
-0.0352406688,
-0.0626165047,
0.0100582801,
-0.0396442376,
0.0344116911,
-0.0212556571,
0.0557692721,
0.0550560467,
0.0244816691,
-0.0198632553,
0.0666387826,
0.0317676514,
0.0226528365,
-0.0175843053,
-0.049274765,
-0.0258216504,
0.0176951457,
0.0017392829,
-0.0160161015,
-0.0532918833,
-0.0061888834,
0.0171345286,
-0.010665345,
-0.0003101266,
-0.0236212462,
0.0166067928,
0.0384770073,
0.0342259631,
0.0121064633,
-0.0109857656,
0.0152514745,
-0.0049177045,
0.0400905646,
0.0783082396,
-0.0375640169,
-0.0622726753,
-0.0319359079,
0.0081495112,
0.0067203972,
-0.0118449898,
-0.0076184026,
0.0176905859,
0.0114476262,
-0.0253300983,
-0.0108401095,
-0.0005853939,
0.0418894738,
0.0752038062,
0.014638545,
-0.0426396951,
0.0238665026,
-0.0173592772,
0.0840320662,
0.0232591722,
-0.0195501391,
0.0471984819,
-0.0042293747,
-0.0246168636,
0.0213256981,
0.0038689903,
0.0111465733,
0.0140830148,
-0.0485756435,
-0.0336601026,
-0.1046346277,
0.0195454676,
0.0474689193,
-0.017971212,
-0.0402007736,
0.0560525507,
0.0014479344,
0.0388226397,
-0.0994031802,
0.0229289252,
-0.0292532947,
-0.0233755,
-0.0080153756,
-0.0087565426,
-0.0357063971,
0.0210855491,
-0.0236059334,
-0.0130888149,
0.0366594121,
-0.0083336085,
-0.0520101227,
-0.0462864675,
-0.0108088097,
-0.024703199,
-0.030324962,
-0.05639809,
0.0104150791,
-0.0124867829,
0.0282588694,
0.073282592,
-0.0036006651,
-0.0834163576,
0.0567358732,
0.0714843571,
0.0625714809,
0.0275652017,
-0.0479431599,
-0.0085280128,
-0.0484971218,
-0.0232175924,
-0.0605342761,
0.027924886,
-0.0245173629,
-0.000469148,
0.0357400067,
0.0043732813,
-0.0164219756,
-0.0579113141,
-0.0007349837,
0.0042085461,
-0.0202233791,
-0.0066770585,
0.0317439213,
-0.0226662774,
0.0200643372,
0.0337047093,
0.0617327653,
0.0272937175,
-0.1267275065,
0.0050825877,
-0.0375392325,
-0.0770655349,
-0.0212047808,
0.0231240503,
-0.0432550199,
-0.0072620818,
0.0041848077,
0.0247969795,
-0.0679215342,
-0.052606713,
0.0294296537,
-0.0481908768,
0.081627816,
-0.0129238144,
0.0200655535,
-0.0259144437,
-0.0438031405,
0.0127380909,
-0.0222659763,
-0.0263951533,
-0.031375248,
0.0091775339,
0.0162220709,
0.0276624449,
-0.0586224832,
-0.0492782108,
-0.0093736295,
-0.038382858,
0.0105879698,
0.0734738559,
0.0727714524,
0.011242141,
-0.0221307389,
-0.0243002828,
0.0235114377,
0.0283533912,
-0.0083491448,
0.0742796734,
0.0301938131,
0.0354850031,
0.0062518395,
0.0061138519,
-0.0357478708,
-0.021968212,
0.050615482,
0.0759785622,
-0.0700108111,
-0.0114744427,
-0.0470448397,
0.0000174484,
0.0436011404,
0.019802656,
-0.0084177945,
-0.0153460028,
0.0040671513,
0.0185802095,
0.0430114195,
-0.0331917629,
-0.0028298092,
0.0400267579,
-0.0659487173,
-0.021302186,
-0.0505920202,
-0.0505786799,
0.0408138372,
0.0392655209,
0.0139145609,
-0.0305833966,
0.0573563911,
0.0002878547,
0.0097629949,
-0.0036407886,
0.026260471,
0.0146765476,
-0.005352254,
-0.0706143677,
-0.0126320934,
0.0092606079,
-0.0034949211,
0.0586640202,
0.0430592857,
-0.0084612044,
0.0229310859,
0.0526737496,
0.028647773,
-0.0378452018,
0.0232468843,
-0.0442922525,
0.0673910156,
0.0573105514,
0.0382362977,
-0.0706984848,
0.0126275728,
-0.0288036894,
-0.0284254998,
-0.0352950171,
-0.0039587296,
0.0264406577,
0.0137009816,
-0.0142352106,
-0.061299704,
-0.016695207,
0.0120058861,
-0.0058319326,
0.0722922012,
-0.0540058427,
-0.0327063501,
-0.0381005593,
-0.0038257849,
0.0155415116,
0.0256361626,
-0.0221678484,
0.001821177,
-0.0007485324,
-0.0171913616,
0.024205612,
0.0916682854,
-0.0410826914,
-0.0055766832,
-0.0434899367,
0.0853987485,
0.0135103324,
0.0945542306,
-0.0015046197,
-0.0227586273,
-0.0260597207,
-0.0488614738,
0.0065743607,
0.0397505164,
0.0161094572,
0.0624653734,
-0.0062284395,
0.012712216,
0.0108961836,
0.041552145,
-0.0474933907,
-0.0736967549,
-0.0444298424,
0.0106847398,
0.0244571455,
0.0349278413,
-0.0290495828,
-0.0577020831,
-0.0036327266,
-0.0141500551,
0.0064841141,
0.0026417619,
0.0090293558,
-0.0007371212,
0.0017064991,
-0.0379608274,
-0.0303283427,
0.0682822391,
-0.0225999858,
0.019037066,
-0.0775828958,
-0.0521906093,
-0.0302851591,
-0.0313617475,
0.0379630551,
0.0203825925,
-0.0259146802,
0.0087466128,
-0.0574321449,
-0.0108786095,
-0.008156362,
-0.0397348143,
-0.0006592084,
-0.002007196,
-0.0372031257,
0.0288609546,
0.012994268,
-0.017618306,
-0.0295230653,
0.0010690211,
-0.0474324115,
0.0134190964,
-0.0471699797,
-6.340366001e-33,
0.0205136295,
-0.0521740466,
0.0027468901,
-0.0273929406,
0.0287483316,
0.0096185096,
-0.0110119283,
0.0081917904,
-0.0001514666,
0.0332337841,
-0.0107818842,
-0.0316902436,
0.0063792309,
-0.0121233128,
0.0568727627,
0.051741872,
0.0276662279,
0.0087578986,
-0.0223664977,
0.013105181,
0.0068466039,
-0.0083933817,
0.025146354,
-0.0993029028,
0.0053244317,
0.0105184391,
-0.0057219304,
-0.0133792711,
0.0080576669,
0.0356905386,
-0.0063682552,
-0.0212707352,
0.0122301513,
-0.0692988262,
-0.0299311429,
-0.0186149813,
-0.0533506796,
-0.0332574211,
-0.0214941278,
-0.0369514301,
-0.0191271026,
-0.0133669954,
0.0047062389,
0.0401791185,
-0.0395690762,
0.0332366079,
0.0517034605,
-0.0361612327,
-0.0441307016,
-0.0531292036,
-0.0479675755,
0.0329263508,
-0.0431492478,
0.0275897961,
-0.0244001038,
0.1039519086,
-0.0171846151,
0.0238527041,
-0.0554905497,
0.0402441509,
0.0382139012,
-0.0454282872,
0.050506603,
0.0004279379,
-0.0229726844,
0.0577967912,
0.0077750296,
0.0251557622,
-0.0487446412,
-0.0628660917,
-0.0001626643,
0.0320206806,
0.0402512178,
0.0650366917,
0.0150862327,
0.0280876402,
-0.0364538617,
0.1034865975,
0.0320676528,
0.0670735985,
0.0480861962,
0.0198270585,
-0.0393734761,
-0.0358527862,
0.0022343006,
-0.0502889566,
0.001021883,
0.0006544673,
0.030032346,
0.0111866826,
-0.0677286163,
0.07615228,
0.0388897434,
0.0005182745,
0.0650549307,
0.0237264428,
0.0015227859,
0.0110926777,
0.0012772342,
-0.0545626245,
-0.0835511386,
-0.067588903,
0.025233021,
0.0396611951,
0.0385704637,
0.0173861552,
0.0153712118,
-0.0314045809,
-0.0140942624,
-0.0003143202,
-0.0042765327,
0.0355580151,
0.0251529142,
-0.0491046868,
-0.0043753143,
-0.0152531276,
-0.0078179091,
-0.0236705542,
0.0058215619,
-0.027272813,
-0.017936226,
-0.0173107069,
-0.0324913375,
-0.0110607864,
-0.0005100774,
-0.0157460421,
-0.0446227528,
-0.0361491628,
0.0005913992,
-0.0622141287,
-0.0121585419,
0.0101812258,
3.06e-7,
0.0544574484,
0.0615811609,
0.0009450177,
-0.0402442813,
0.0297239572,
0.0380487852,
0.0145366853,
-0.0065197037,
0.0181798376,
0.0282500926,
0.0750483647,
0.0111011332,
0.0005823107,
0.0618701875,
-0.0269206576,
-0.0676842704,
-0.020869622,
-0.0082373815,
-0.0703650415,
0.0041691884,
0.000712164,
-0.0258920658,
-0.0086776959,
-0.0259792786,
0.0058611427,
-0.0345199294,
0.0156985819,
-0.0115763359,
0.0492157638,
0.009882628,
0.0421647094,
-0.0203731693,
0.0009622623,
0.0888051614,
-0.0254121367,
-0.0285073277,
-0.0360274985,
0.0022840712,
-0.0112434048,
0.0191017166,
0.0110364128,
-0.0087677548,
0.0474959202,
-0.0122155836,
0.0452211425,
-0.0897636414,
-0.0469415374,
0.0343784019,
-0.0323592387,
0.0238999352,
-0.0012830623,
0.0220559537,
0.0520090759,
0.0486319214,
-0.0446243882,
0.00891288,
-0.0016306215,
-0.0160664376,
0.0550660007,
-0.0077534444,
-0.052719783,
-0.0320949703,
0.0103977192,
-0.0051247012,
0.0101183569,
-0.0276890676,
0.0556417517,
2.727669438e-34,
0.0239620339,
-0.0171522256,
-0.0020516268,
-0.0138819888,
0.0409680083,
0.0237956699,
0.009605987,
0.0129357455,
0.0428105518,
-0.041621346,
0.0105403708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01099v1 | Logion: Machine Learning for Greek Philology | 2023-05-01T21:56:25 | 2023-05-01T21:56:25 | Charlie Cowen-Breen, Creston Brooks, Johannes Haubold, Barbara Graziosi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This paper presents machine-learning methods to address various problems in
Greek philology. After training a BERT model on the largest premodern Greek
dataset used for this purpose to date, we identify and correct previously
undetected errors made by scribes in the process of textual transmission, in
what is, to our knowledge, the first successful identification of such errors
via machine learning. Additionally, we demonstrate the model's capacity to fill
gaps caused by material deterioration of premodern manuscripts and compare the
model's performance to that of a domain expert. We find that best performance
is achieved when the domain expert is provided with model suggestions for
inspiration. With such human-computer collaborations in mind, we explore the
model's interpretability and find that certain attention heads appear to encode
select grammatical features of premodern Greek. | [
0.0199699923,
0.0453482345,
-0.0171391405,
0.0407287776,
-0.0261377059,
0.0310965218,
-0.0004279427,
0.051279135,
-0.0152921071,
-0.0877038091,
0.0340749845,
-0.0157157164,
0.0335932299,
-0.0329487361,
0.0319175236,
-0.0441607609,
0.0343627483,
-0.003157384,
-0.0096783889,
0.0104596177,
-0.0236699488,
0.0013171431,
0.0114554204,
0.0193419792,
-0.0137331262,
-0.0313222706,
-0.029101409,
0.0223891754,
0.0002702007,
0.0535857975,
-0.0460360833,
0.0290393345,
-0.0135313999,
0.0863940418,
0.0000017136,
-0.0550379083,
0.0032850259,
-0.0038655587,
-0.0166277681,
-0.007656964,
0.0060428819,
-0.0087435534,
-0.0460771732,
-0.0517467596,
-0.0362170376,
0.0213985313,
0.048549898,
-0.0064097918,
0.0212912466,
0.0897401273,
-0.0279831383,
-0.0300118774,
0.0535769463,
0.0082526589,
0.0364409313,
-0.0047916691,
0.0220291857,
-0.0034139475,
-0.0237910021,
-0.0031429464,
-0.0195863303,
0.0497023389,
-0.0288957749,
0.0009557115,
-0.0413341299,
-0.0053365156,
-0.0510964692,
0.0015345552,
-0.0135829663,
-0.0357665494,
0.0249605235,
-0.009399442,
0.0024162002,
0.0231432673,
-0.0069001326,
0.0242167618,
0.0095892474,
0.002137169,
-0.069669567,
0.003545993,
0.05947157,
-0.0849208608,
0.0102604637,
0.013653419,
-0.0486453213,
0.0526632592,
0.0327656381,
-0.043019034,
0.0212357379,
0.0612045266,
-0.0641021058,
-0.0242541265,
0.0143058598,
0.0494882353,
0.0127033032,
0.0043916064,
-0.0291469507,
-0.0977065638,
-0.0033074659,
-0.0250430796,
0.0351461507,
-0.006656623,
-0.0136310933,
0.0440157056,
-0.0099443644,
0.0240141004,
0.053972818,
0.0164168086,
0.0048429831,
0.0126910079,
-0.0345319957,
-0.0013509507,
-0.0520628057,
-0.0003326719,
0.018621387,
0.0150194913,
-0.0280480385,
0.0027711138,
0.0378325693,
0.0213083606,
-0.0254441369,
-0.0396911167,
-0.0348883271,
-0.0196842849,
-0.0068529309,
-0.0029721207,
0.0085982224,
0.0137271229,
-0.0528493077,
-0.0205273908,
0.0340038352,
0.0206355862,
0.0257120766,
-0.0253309608,
0.0099745383,
0.0546725355,
0.0111436807,
-0.0417274572,
-0.023174122,
-0.013720667,
-0.0412389562,
-0.0511241406,
-0.0464991145,
-0.0092598973,
-0.007525512,
0.005058995,
0.0057704691,
-0.0251156874,
-0.0075437366,
0.0303968843,
-0.0481827036,
0.0518257581,
-0.0396654904,
0.0114539852,
0.0379050784,
-0.0435566977,
-0.0334738642,
-0.0158153865,
0.0475090966,
-0.0081890319,
0.0416526794,
0.0177754313,
0.0144037781,
0.0410480313,
-0.0186796188,
-0.0099128708,
-0.0144353034,
-0.0317113176,
0.0134013658,
0.0370737165,
0.0077854097,
0.0798400566,
0.0043723728,
0.0210109446,
0.0805488452,
0.0537237711,
0.0074734008,
0.0591808185,
0.0153830182,
-0.0218526907,
0.0629365742,
0.0260617714,
-0.0381560065,
-0.0526630469,
0.0260377377,
0.0215591528,
-0.0335490741,
0.0039982037,
0.0221754964,
-0.0476452373,
-0.025093507,
-0.0285219103,
-0.0257235691,
-0.0310357735,
0.1012600437,
-0.0003247047,
-0.0468470082,
0.0235316642,
0.0125129838,
-0.0600399375,
0.01175851,
-0.0154135805,
0.067465201,
0.0886099115,
0.0613664091,
-0.0874652714,
0.0120277433,
-0.0197503064,
-0.0012782778,
0.0383726656,
-0.0156564172,
0.0123803839,
0.0066358927,
-0.0431942828,
0.012262282,
0.0264483597,
0.0330300853,
0.0027640872,
-0.0556591041,
0.0417746864,
0.0074385167,
-0.0009440315,
-0.0652791262,
0.0762668625,
-0.0445896797,
-0.026975112,
-0.0502752289,
0.0243407171,
-0.0218236558,
0.024137646,
0.0032674051,
-0.0003270744,
0.0199296828,
-0.0375586152,
0.0235708375,
-0.0021994724,
-0.0165203959,
0.0095657567,
0.0789780021,
-0.0432203859,
-0.0247492976,
0.0125571825,
0.0116130905,
-0.0145224929,
0.0088464851,
-0.0852854997,
0.0614779666,
0.0000518355,
0.0365343951,
0.0066364165,
-0.0282533225,
-0.031272646,
0.0619371422,
0.0151225477,
0.0493801162,
0.0346533991,
-0.0606370829,
0.0184130035,
-0.0218726471,
-0.038886711,
-0.0543945543,
0.0101202494,
0.0059144455,
0.011529522,
-0.0148712257,
0.006639862,
-0.040789701,
-0.0716632754,
0.0050641051,
-0.0538432151,
0.0318289176,
0.0113228019,
-0.0210866034,
-0.0030136027,
-0.004363873,
0.0064703804,
0.0405276231,
-0.0139734754,
-0.0169585105,
0.0503470898,
-0.0191519558,
0.0156845786,
-0.0464615002,
0.0044986065,
-0.0181404296,
0.0556255281,
0.097566776,
-0.0242913645,
-0.0740600675,
-0.0173867345,
-0.012099294,
0.0096178772,
0.0012874448,
-0.0069684712,
-0.0097965775,
-0.0359962061,
0.0293478835,
0.0242440235,
-0.0162039362,
0.0110551678,
0.0298300683,
-0.0164372716,
0.005564949,
-0.0153772244,
-0.0175189134,
-0.0241861306,
-0.0535639748,
-0.0350930654,
0.0237009488,
0.0190891791,
-0.0232673809,
0.003929154,
-0.0381818339,
0.0461999699,
-0.0307234041,
0.0248834267,
0.0364925936,
-0.020309817,
-0.023449013,
0.0663613379,
0.000529902,
-0.0298087839,
0.0570048057,
0.0108934501,
0.0083719958,
-0.0471831001,
0.0098592881,
-0.0449152514,
0.0235416815,
0.0251292419,
0.0241228398,
0.0155631686,
-0.0510423779,
-0.0338674299,
0.0319170915,
0.0784885511,
-0.0269666389,
0.0667822361,
-0.0241181273,
0.0042138221,
0.0044110743,
-0.0102269845,
0.0069183074,
-0.0104698548,
-0.0209097788,
-0.0074334661,
0.0251336936,
-0.0149812577,
-0.0738654286,
-0.0058781677,
-0.0431130044,
0.0561444424,
0.0099682529,
-0.0184546504,
-0.0367793031,
0.0714468658,
-0.0155302966,
0.0008965014,
-0.0257169381,
-0.0407273136,
-0.017693771,
0.0142340548,
-0.0195019152,
0.0096726855,
-0.0628155097,
-0.0192731675,
0.010802025,
-0.0589286014,
-0.0871237069,
-0.0361276306,
-0.0424947739,
-0.0516608544,
0.0025535107,
0.0736130849,
0.0205616895,
-0.0821678266,
-0.0193816014,
-0.0604619682,
-0.044496011,
-0.0048896302,
0.0363989361,
-0.0696129277,
0.000075987,
0.0205736384,
0.0626749694,
0.0393367894,
-0.0235089865,
0.0347244963,
-0.0702014491,
0.048682671,
-0.0025535314,
-0.0434686914,
-0.0499042086,
-0.0314596184,
-0.004299242,
-0.0555585586,
-0.0226848722,
0.0196184255,
-0.023672197,
0.034770254,
0.0339717679,
-0.0102415914,
-0.0393862762,
-0.0539251715,
-0.0479740985,
0.0103955632,
0.0552931167,
0.1001336649,
-0.0601165816,
-0.0303474311,
-0.015254572,
0.0400593132,
0.0180673692,
-0.0049760994,
0.107414037,
0.0037547683,
-0.0107494732,
-0.015222556,
0.0130089577,
-0.0390350074,
-0.0216236282,
0.0294722728,
0.0744716153,
-0.0034831986,
0.0116243297,
0.019937139,
-0.0292233266,
0.0154253943,
0.0202280786,
0.0236161016,
-0.0113606807,
-0.0740459487,
-0.0415577814,
0.0523294695,
0.0007537371,
-0.0214994121,
0.0202380754,
0.0035488945,
-0.0942908823,
-0.1154974923,
-0.0455718227,
0.0109994896,
0.0270224568,
0.0544531271,
-0.0346392505,
-0.0320106968,
-0.0000949573,
-0.0649993494,
0.0051977038,
0.0042406437,
0.016779596,
-0.0808230489,
-0.0004687107,
-0.0186383426,
0.0084705744,
-0.0182381198,
0.0359734334,
-0.0113409543,
-0.0657771677,
0.0451437719,
0.0504938327,
0.0276086107,
0.0281193741,
-0.0162267666,
-0.0444126427,
-0.036595203,
0.0013166809,
-0.0081902752,
0.0272280779,
0.0313461721,
-0.0282398108,
-0.0504816808,
0.0287209041,
-0.0029450308,
-0.0190969948,
0.0020340201,
-0.020993093,
-0.0390437171,
-0.060806606,
0.0217014812,
0.0166647043,
0.0512241833,
-0.0395179689,
0.0029040431,
-0.0121582756,
-0.0015193456,
0.0003573261,
0.0006334014,
-0.007597446,
0.0289249979,
0.006599071,
-0.0282339565,
0.0054104277,
-0.0142947454,
-0.0206670351,
-0.0045379698,
-0.0587308444,
0.0577068999,
0.0395695977,
0.0450494401,
0.0097167566,
0.0186664816,
0.0086308233,
0.0162328519,
0.009656257,
0.0869250447,
0.0025978822,
0.0110460399,
0.0189005099,
0.0098401224,
0.0143711586,
-0.0171058998,
-0.0432576127,
-0.064055644,
-0.0289511923,
-0.0036657425,
0.0886213854,
0.0036002975,
0.0696644336,
-0.03993503,
-0.0288690999,
-0.0194124952,
0.0516091883,
0.0465097129,
0.0195270292,
-0.074730821,
0.0051164231,
0.0196241084,
0.0228851996,
0.0404776409,
-0.0120105734,
0.0359024405,
0.0189819168,
-0.0685976148,
-0.015582067,
0.0030513012,
0.001247587,
-0.0426393971,
-0.024045825,
-0.0010836619,
-0.0585515276,
-0.0564384274,
0.0167018194,
0.0386112742,
-0.007140418,
-0.0284940824,
0.0139339538,
0.028450476,
-0.010534551,
0.0411997549,
-0.0683571771,
0.0727213845,
-0.0588195249,
0.0126950275,
-0.0547410026,
-4.444141534e-33,
-0.0186937805,
-0.0200497974,
0.0248661116,
0.0147120869,
-0.0067422916,
-0.002458574,
-0.0526887514,
0.0053318115,
0.039376568,
0.0342550874,
-0.0234385747,
-0.008387995,
0.0110791819,
-0.0195309836,
0.0279149711,
0.0067073228,
0.0197106339,
0.0025682829,
-0.00406203,
-0.0224198699,
0.0665794685,
0.0462784581,
0.0841374695,
-0.0485067815,
0.0570010357,
-0.0178294443,
0.0147124697,
0.0048582335,
0.00739227,
0.0256764907,
-0.0024189136,
0.0068928776,
0.015974788,
-0.0030546901,
-0.0024899459,
0.0190765597,
-0.043571502,
-0.0152078737,
-0.0310102571,
0.0853634775,
-0.007241399,
-0.0144093838,
0.0063357688,
-0.0081485286,
-0.0012424967,
-0.0026854891,
0.0990549251,
-0.0391345136,
-0.0591172092,
-0.0355878174,
-0.0482653603,
0.048342485,
-0.0276037902,
-0.0301848035,
0.0708337873,
0.0453295708,
0.0005254283,
-0.0066299606,
-0.0303502232,
-0.0111576244,
0.0042988942,
0.0055629415,
0.0064348634,
-0.0026422583,
-0.0550654605,
0.0290010851,
0.0420080014,
-0.0143973175,
0.0048178476,
0.0076616551,
0.0008140451,
0.0429525487,
0.0679854676,
0.0128250662,
0.0038411359,
-0.0033153859,
-0.0101557625,
-0.0064055347,
0.0101099014,
0.0386878811,
-0.0084578292,
-0.0383217074,
-0.047711499,
-0.0016170646,
-0.026734231,
-0.0895934924,
0.0142989634,
0.0077298186,
-0.0156281944,
-0.0487035327,
-0.0078873644,
0.0410364904,
-0.0259062927,
-0.0516129807,
-0.0270657986,
0.0002532852,
-0.0085458439,
0.0471464582,
-0.0403135382,
-0.0074902857,
-0.0304936059,
-0.0252938177,
0.0053686304,
0.0344794877,
0.0250890367,
0.0170537774,
0.0188311115,
0.0317602791,
-0.0236315858,
0.0182270668,
0.0247600805,
-0.0219824668,
0.0016438713,
0.0706706345,
0.0466587916,
-0.0134137832,
0.0428568535,
-0.0009162175,
0.0393700786,
-0.0027174545,
-0.0208920389,
0.0215375349,
0.0266811941,
-0.0281207785,
-0.0195548479,
-0.039737165,
-0.0056825397,
0.0603773966,
0.0455683768,
-0.0165470634,
0.0124014802,
-0.0196191799,
2.396e-7,
0.0876411945,
0.0663904995,
0.037192177,
-0.0052488702,
0.0018222575,
0.0332604721,
-0.0415042825,
0.0094606327,
-0.0132964859,
0.0182647519,
0.0653733388,
-0.0230138712,
0.0679151192,
0.0221948605,
-0.0673605576,
-0.0189124011,
-0.0581555516,
-0.0081051663,
-0.0532585159,
0.03117056,
0.0216195453,
0.0603498518,
0.0252089351,
-0.0601606071,
-0.0032840788,
-0.0155552551,
0.0229168143,
-0.0119339088,
0.0134608019,
0.0228545815,
0.0886111334,
-0.0006753454,
0.0035784934,
0.0681669787,
-0.0334123895,
-0.0023346525,
0.0373508781,
0.0356221721,
-0.0364930481,
0.0661631078,
0.0149393016,
-0.007234015,
-0.002770405,
-0.0314450674,
0.0057810298,
0.0155959483,
0.0074022627,
-0.0224331096,
-0.0682821795,
0.0445339866,
-0.0141297728,
0.0130190039,
-0.0203417018,
0.0143041415,
0.050809864,
-0.0025683886,
0.0004760504,
-0.0658119917,
0.0211230647,
0.0120326141,
-0.0269704908,
-0.0131431669,
-0.0050887926,
-0.0190210324,
0.0270429552,
-0.0685131773,
-0.0227476116,
1.789993551e-34,
0.0268090386,
-0.0244279932,
0.0112846289,
0.0623162352,
-0.0354770757,
-0.0038567937,
0.0405183993,
0.0340359397,
0.0089227818,
-0.0138747562,
0.0063419645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01082v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01082v2 | Contextual Multilingual Spellchecker for User Queries | 2023-05-01T20:29:59 | 2023-06-14T14:29:58 | Sanat Sharma, Josep Valls-Vargas, Tracy Holloway King, Francois Guerin, Chirag Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Spellchecking is one of the most fundamental and widely used search features.
Correcting incorrectly spelled user queries not only enhances the user
experience but is expected by the user. However, most widely available
spellchecking solutions are either lower accuracy than state-of-the-art
solutions or too slow to be used for search use cases where latency is a key
requirement. Furthermore, most innovative recent architectures focus on English
and are not trained in a multilingual fashion and are trained for spell
correction in longer text, which is a different paradigm from spell correction
for user queries, where context is sparse (most queries are 1-2 words long).
Finally, since most enterprises have unique vocabularies such as product names,
off-the-shelf spelling solutions fall short of users' needs. In this work, we
build a multilingual spellchecker that is extremely fast and scalable and that
adapts its vocabulary and hence speller output based on a specific product's
needs. Furthermore, our speller out-performs general purpose spellers by a wide
margin on in-domain datasets. Our multilingual speller is used in search in
Adobe products, powering autocomplete in various applications. | [
0.0354842767,
-0.0038288434,
-0.0090876622,
0.0398053452,
-0.0343448706,
-0.0225953013,
0.0212652422,
0.020203406,
0.0282877665,
-0.0473764725,
-0.0375967771,
-0.0128367245,
0.0029754874,
0.0076180059,
-0.0003467667,
-0.0224787015,
0.0413407683,
-0.0191571992,
-0.0272565577,
-0.013525961,
0.0307537876,
0.0270601474,
-0.0046055322,
0.0311373919,
0.0156294703,
-0.0230931714,
0.0106557496,
0.0047586518,
-0.001761537,
-0.0043802736,
0.0496881828,
0.0070473566,
-0.0408039577,
0.0649793893,
0.0000018511,
-0.0471664481,
-0.0454998873,
-0.0126988851,
-0.0042036404,
0.0178109333,
0.0186746921,
0.0154519267,
-0.0272701867,
0.0535965152,
-0.0320983827,
0.0345884636,
0.0333616398,
0.014318767,
0.0260239132,
0.0335086733,
-0.0179640763,
-0.0217045117,
0.0034578538,
0.0056816288,
0.0019039817,
-0.0694642588,
0.0041271364,
-0.0720790327,
0.0328553915,
-0.0431830548,
-0.0237337276,
0.04294727,
-0.0379028656,
-0.0131960772,
0.0009578944,
-0.0029419076,
0.0027284769,
-0.0109057426,
-0.0232931878,
0.0441008173,
-0.0165040158,
-0.0091680624,
-0.02220851,
0.0225143302,
-0.006054258,
0.0228186212,
0.0395310819,
-0.0220054425,
-0.0507605597,
-0.0141951935,
0.0086840158,
-0.013939782,
0.0348884203,
0.0219210144,
0.0021126724,
0.1117288396,
0.0413477086,
-0.0500055589,
0.0000131671,
-0.0000831273,
0.0497427993,
-0.0388970003,
0.0619403347,
0.0169689264,
-0.0739021972,
-0.0009600687,
-0.0442906432,
-0.0646528155,
0.0003779859,
-0.068380475,
-0.0150147351,
0.0168012418,
-0.0086683035,
0.0424816534,
-0.0315418318,
0.0347070321,
0.032353688,
-0.036952246,
-0.0326668695,
-0.0573080964,
-0.0135457749,
-0.0025236281,
-0.0656115562,
0.0003854868,
-0.0264125373,
-0.0310242046,
-0.0665025935,
-0.0061706165,
-0.0384230576,
0.010185807,
0.0341288671,
0.0001770868,
-0.0125288581,
-0.0310398992,
-0.0217796303,
0.0436027907,
-0.0301867872,
-0.0075916774,
-0.029395286,
-0.0413914472,
0.0195281599,
-0.0021470557,
0.0483430959,
-0.0309223011,
0.0343414508,
0.0085189035,
0.0019972152,
-0.04426663,
-0.0492952578,
-0.0124996444,
-0.0017476804,
0.0090127364,
-0.1002050489,
-0.0502849668,
0.0053104311,
0.0003629126,
0.0268612299,
-0.0135638323,
-0.0001956068,
0.0229811147,
-0.0065871552,
0.1278729588,
-0.0546510816,
0.0015694464,
0.0245426372,
-0.020484414,
0.045730073,
0.0159191117,
0.0088508232,
0.0045511965,
0.0760681331,
-0.0013580689,
0.0345600359,
0.0530332699,
-0.0603853241,
-0.0553313084,
-0.0157014765,
-0.0238548368,
-0.036326386,
0.0076476,
0.0105403531,
0.0456285253,
0.0030053835,
0.0456262529,
0.0401631929,
0.0362070948,
0.0573665798,
-0.0317631476,
0.0198976025,
-0.0404596925,
-0.0244904589,
-0.0361321233,
-0.0180063788,
0.0035124817,
-0.0546365976,
0.013844586,
0.0289246887,
0.0350608863,
-0.0063575124,
-0.0154677639,
0.0076334612,
-0.0027679028,
-0.0004044574,
0.0274253543,
0.0560820214,
0.0150102759,
-0.0318462998,
0.0167231951,
-0.010824291,
-0.0486478992,
0.0005427232,
-0.0342138633,
-0.0009731028,
0.1668147445,
0.0851285234,
-0.0096580014,
0.0062208916,
0.0108486721,
-0.0475683026,
0.0126911541,
0.0332305171,
-0.0363851078,
0.0068355314,
-0.0492050834,
-0.0261762124,
0.0239004716,
0.0072658579,
0.0255671125,
0.0376532599,
0.0331880674,
0.0060761818,
-0.0219836924,
0.0163285006,
0.0035705559,
-0.022393981,
-0.0262985118,
0.0273588691,
0.0297899432,
-0.0298110824,
0.0023709934,
-0.0286694821,
-0.0148591567,
-0.0205597524,
-0.0206276905,
-0.029050881,
-0.0203895345,
0.0166291278,
-0.0147639252,
0.0354912207,
-0.0525475293,
0.0020161206,
0.0331528112,
0.0303871967,
-0.0580200627,
-0.0281883646,
-0.0346512906,
0.0591515861,
-0.0290482212,
0.0288087036,
-0.031526681,
0.003425308,
-0.0375832915,
0.0403112695,
0.0094154179,
0.0200565942,
-0.0400677845,
0.0249090791,
-0.0149287302,
-0.0105989808,
-0.0543407612,
0.0139118955,
0.0405204669,
0.0209423807,
0.0509323776,
-0.0076973774,
0.0003617633,
0.0267148074,
-0.0489624254,
0.0104174744,
-0.013113481,
0.0138811721,
0.0011695375,
0.0902049989,
-0.010609759,
-0.0649912655,
-0.011609192,
0.0500878282,
0.0318311341,
0.0308074486,
0.0268186275,
-0.0179852434,
-0.0111298626,
-0.0472028106,
-0.0036583608,
0.0140966987,
-0.0056927502,
-0.0000820172,
-0.083556734,
-0.0631091967,
0.0388455018,
-0.0141019886,
0.0369251929,
0.0298615452,
-0.0065698437,
-0.0149701238,
-0.0164555479,
0.0424257368,
0.0377550311,
0.0077259648,
-0.0059998818,
0.0464950986,
-0.0143591687,
-0.0337537453,
0.0195661187,
0.0341751911,
-0.0003585651,
-0.0024818147,
0.0031711622,
0.0444045141,
0.0262573138,
-0.0239417795,
-0.0099515384,
-0.0053163026,
-0.0234251451,
-0.013577383,
-0.0189666897,
-0.0674608797,
-0.0078852782,
-0.0064823562,
0.0370157473,
0.0050171139,
-0.0424495786,
0.0517717935,
-0.0052411081,
0.0180050097,
-0.0301525425,
-0.0268349703,
0.0086402511,
-0.0010466804,
-0.0410905108,
0.0433515385,
-0.0667871982,
-0.0436047055,
-0.0024729655,
0.0322017446,
0.0795799941,
-0.0447876155,
0.0557205342,
-0.0561976805,
0.0349709168,
0.0149065563,
-0.0755820051,
-0.0239325222,
0.0231421404,
-0.0577622801,
-0.0341863818,
0.0580878481,
-0.0362521708,
-0.0411741063,
0.0267886706,
0.0177765433,
0.0810662359,
0.0164582729,
-0.0487217493,
0.0217722636,
-0.0210607722,
0.042123504,
-0.0047142091,
0.043579895,
0.0007555541,
0.0183080807,
0.048713237,
0.0226287916,
-0.0843916088,
-0.0041757226,
-0.0180301853,
0.0626160651,
-0.0663749799,
-0.0291246716,
0.0098434296,
0.0015455193,
-0.0362730362,
-0.0223337971,
0.0799458921,
0.0247636829,
-0.071529083,
-0.030081084,
0.0018698925,
-0.022653915,
0.0327594355,
0.0705358386,
-0.0690079257,
-0.0548301935,
0.0298922453,
0.0517135747,
0.0139826424,
-0.0168217644,
-0.0069007818,
-0.1357761025,
0.0084437681,
-0.0087215854,
-0.0046562431,
-0.0524642207,
-0.0114498883,
-0.0064987293,
-0.0179391131,
0.0404625796,
0.0286616087,
0.0158096217,
-0.006958364,
-0.0041412157,
-0.0082698632,
-0.0778556913,
0.0055355974,
-0.0636355653,
0.0084861368,
0.084058404,
0.0272777677,
0.0218579285,
-0.0502576604,
-0.0162511636,
-0.0188316144,
-0.0079514757,
-0.0069798324,
0.0050161737,
-0.0003821671,
-0.0124609768,
-0.0269921105,
-0.0113324076,
-0.0120350942,
0.0086626019,
0.0215258524,
0.0302854925,
-0.0188171174,
0.0539698936,
-0.0009985503,
-0.0490837991,
-0.0056252046,
0.0422233716,
-0.0176217873,
-0.0699172989,
-0.0785510689,
-0.0822625235,
-0.0313424319,
-0.054352548,
-0.0310814511,
0.02878814,
-0.0614216514,
-0.0242543723,
-0.0694617406,
-0.0422541089,
0.0214042552,
0.0353413112,
0.0118677355,
0.0097329421,
-0.0122770211,
0.0418910012,
-0.0328731686,
-0.0641737208,
0.0025234728,
0.0629867017,
-0.0741032884,
0.0539390557,
-0.0160050001,
-0.0132193295,
0.0018518576,
0.011739024,
-0.0063760518,
-0.0295336787,
0.0227781832,
0.0356185287,
0.0146874301,
0.0175957605,
-0.0564330183,
-0.0815198645,
0.0473130047,
0.0537249185,
-0.0193879176,
-0.023645632,
-0.0097964611,
-0.0171099342,
-0.003832862,
0.0366285518,
-0.0543188117,
0.0165286381,
-0.0447533466,
0.0429063812,
0.0096978201,
-0.0365811251,
0.0470008887,
0.0256957226,
0.0481852554,
-0.0523598082,
0.0423845053,
-0.0414516367,
0.020158248,
0.0033498178,
-0.0661183074,
0.0105010038,
0.0181896891,
0.00979493,
-0.0311624557,
0.0089746322,
0.0315539241,
0.016861666,
-0.0192049686,
-0.0238742772,
0.0010758421,
0.0400654934,
-0.0039667157,
0.0245714765,
0.0030892775,
0.0156116532,
0.029195888,
0.0504216291,
0.0528650619,
-0.0437704809,
-0.0132852886,
0.0007751956,
-0.0156319477,
-0.0328250378,
0.02844139,
-0.0751908049,
0.0499903001,
-0.011936415,
-0.0096050007,
0.0563292168,
-0.0318090543,
0.0468028076,
-0.0228014942,
-0.0115258498,
-0.0240893811,
0.0104199313,
0.0247470401,
-0.0107129533,
-0.0174472481,
0.0121333795,
0.0031254867,
-0.0058886684,
0.0765077248,
-0.0560852848,
0.0172152054,
-0.0015249606,
-0.0820772722,
-0.0506591089,
-0.0154903755,
-0.0409651473,
0.0241733696,
-0.0485858545,
-0.0165491588,
-0.0344179533,
-0.0225113537,
-0.0271154363,
0.0273851287,
0.0208929162,
0.0017178392,
0.0426341668,
0.0835770294,
0.0449845903,
0.0070344703,
-0.0621065348,
-0.0242162999,
-0.0296908505,
-0.016451275,
-0.0019304795,
-5.231145654e-33,
-0.0133855948,
-0.0260466971,
0.0003150837,
-0.0311885457,
0.0380831324,
0.0117026223,
0.0002454523,
-0.0082064113,
-0.003973823,
0.0239720531,
-0.0567920394,
0.034853816,
0.0225325227,
0.0014482372,
0.064385727,
0.0263280682,
0.0541630648,
0.0498999208,
-0.0002700315,
-0.0164163429,
0.0568503588,
0.0827569738,
0.055136852,
-0.0061470354,
0.008399481,
0.030519858,
-0.0213927664,
0.0178249273,
0.0110706091,
0.0471565127,
0.0030393621,
0.056569621,
-0.0005282857,
0.0031638953,
0.0063223885,
-0.0165409204,
-0.0805713534,
0.0042621214,
-0.0301412549,
0.0614204705,
0.0139273116,
0.012214765,
0.0607930049,
-0.0232176594,
-0.0327443145,
0.0662593842,
0.0453065857,
-0.0246110447,
-0.0171433892,
-0.0588810332,
-0.0403523631,
0.0215245038,
0.0326485559,
-0.0005860503,
0.0179207772,
0.0777073875,
-0.0196211021,
-0.0158506539,
-0.1013870537,
0.0352548957,
-0.0128494594,
0.0286804605,
0.060136538,
0.0419626646,
-0.0280572809,
0.0323050134,
0.0127879065,
-0.010606572,
0.0294569135,
0.0112630529,
0.0102953454,
0.014280377,
0.0717839375,
0.0926993564,
0.0607952997,
-0.0327665135,
0.0218436439,
0.0589165576,
0.0121281296,
0.013633159,
-0.0037765512,
0.0098059848,
-0.0337065123,
-0.0318419337,
0.0208580084,
0.0474592671,
-0.0397270173,
0.0046992204,
0.0396921076,
0.0309020281,
0.0083764866,
0.0088081136,
-0.0213515405,
-0.0173715632,
-0.0510995053,
-0.0155734867,
0.0117916744,
-0.0184913091,
0.0162701514,
0.0201275442,
0.0177848432,
-0.0057710153,
-0.0484901406,
0.0309341066,
-0.0327333845,
0.0110194134,
-0.0086335689,
0.0314913616,
-0.0988534912,
0.0112464586,
-0.0000747902,
0.00642122,
-0.0053264895,
-0.0481382981,
0.0406362824,
-0.0226506665,
-0.0086924564,
0.0319613107,
0.0299286246,
0.0031320704,
0.014729552,
-0.0911494344,
0.0059571909,
0.0133981733,
-0.018299371,
0.0189291071,
-0.0563000739,
0.0143161872,
0.0304232314,
-0.0644562915,
-0.0214798115,
0.0003824017,
2.536e-7,
0.0465070158,
0.060652636,
-0.0204807259,
0.0172097068,
0.0170139279,
0.0303319823,
0.0099790357,
0.0654345229,
-0.0446316004,
0.0378803611,
0.0187139306,
-0.0387979336,
0.0374353155,
0.0416016318,
-0.0756109431,
-0.0607298315,
-0.0277412776,
0.0265365504,
-0.036835596,
-0.01226814,
0.0058944016,
0.0404028296,
0.0208178591,
-0.0230582207,
0.0124204196,
-0.0564215966,
0.0220398307,
0.0064994944,
0.0193165932,
-0.0291458685,
0.0725134388,
0.0351140797,
0.0063472949,
0.0081787053,
-0.03244932,
0.0098170079,
0.043271374,
-0.0027447587,
-0.0115769021,
0.0397044197,
0.0137045011,
-0.0353619121,
0.000676521,
-0.0410727151,
0.05482357,
0.050159961,
0.0531289503,
-0.0164786074,
-0.0205652378,
-0.0057784971,
0.0131583214,
-0.0399447344,
-0.0156648047,
0.0129632074,
0.0443253554,
0.0164932627,
-0.0410281532,
-0.0386635214,
-0.003822763,
0.0246214662,
0.0105683729,
0.0129943267,
-0.0415792502,
-0.0098791951,
-0.0113148522,
-0.0421259515,
0.0045439284,
1.772997211e-34,
0.0274944026,
0.0159154553,
0.0030469522,
-0.0009781655,
0.031373512,
-0.0025888197,
0.0107066268,
-0.000059466,
0.0245484654,
-0.0567276478,
-0.0350862704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01050v1 | SafeWebUH at SemEval-2023 Task 11: Learning Annotator Disagreement in Derogatory Text: Comparison of Direct Training vs Aggregation | 2023-05-01T19:30:32 | 2023-05-01T19:30:32 | Sadat Shahriar, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Subjectivity and difference of opinion are key social phenomena, and it is
crucial to take these into account in the annotation and detection process of
derogatory textual content. In this paper, we use four datasets provided by
SemEval-2023 Task 11 and fine-tune a BERT model to capture the disagreement in
the annotation. We find individual annotator modeling and aggregation lowers
the Cross-Entropy score by an average of 0.21, compared to the direct training
on the soft labels. Our findings further demonstrate that annotator metadata
contributes to the average 0.029 reduction in the Cross-Entropy score. | [
0.0590638258,
-0.0082303789,
0.0104635032,
0.0094502755,
0.0058950577,
0.0594903082,
0.0131365936,
-0.0110337157,
-0.0209369622,
-0.1108288318,
-0.0372439288,
-0.0001017336,
-0.0017191974,
-0.0271998961,
0.019697899,
-0.0305918455,
0.0324113443,
0.0563663766,
0.0558523908,
-0.0443784222,
0.0626456514,
-0.0221904423,
-0.0116593586,
0.0217135083,
-0.0630441755,
0.0044201775,
0.0462703891,
0.0323146358,
0.055332005,
-0.0207253154,
0.0552620739,
0.0712635294,
-0.0137799233,
0.067642197,
0.0000017243,
-0.052166909,
-0.0124341305,
0.0430132337,
0.0133295441,
-0.0000699411,
0.0222792216,
-0.0018187609,
-0.0312243085,
0.0490625985,
-0.0127732242,
-0.0017412255,
0.0645541102,
0.0539578609,
0.1194913834,
0.0619462356,
-0.0117113143,
-0.023801744,
-0.0116703678,
-0.0081446534,
0.007676464,
0.0047005746,
0.0261217337,
-0.0013460122,
-0.0913840756,
0.0016286946,
-0.0084527824,
0.0077832923,
0.0126556614,
0.0190068688,
0.0322829634,
0.0040854868,
-0.0567110144,
-0.0351192132,
0.006743649,
0.0433481857,
0.06644582,
-0.0221761893,
-0.0107243368,
-0.001596028,
0.0002692593,
0.0011380264,
0.0076135146,
0.0002060908,
-0.0223173425,
0.0161756631,
-0.0039763143,
0.0131419646,
0.0281875264,
0.0513091907,
0.0392100364,
0.0395166688,
-0.0110944705,
-0.0812118426,
0.0495548323,
0.0259502642,
-0.0239473507,
-0.015183486,
-0.0005712488,
0.0004671878,
0.0353035927,
0.0050380086,
-0.0367151424,
-0.0691297054,
0.0530208312,
-0.1061253399,
-0.007740235,
0.0182223711,
-0.0500498973,
0.0321195312,
0.0308958739,
-0.0012080484,
0.0261254888,
0.0580012463,
0.0075152842,
-0.009671201,
-0.0199886281,
0.0225765686,
-0.0049636564,
0.0387593284,
0.0242836922,
0.0388817973,
-0.0616337582,
-0.0179477949,
-0.0915544704,
-0.0104600675,
0.0312767886,
0.0106984396,
0.0002420274,
0.0284212604,
-0.0606741831,
0.0146916676,
-0.0531320386,
0.0090785418,
-0.0502034426,
-0.0279877968,
0.0124566806,
0.0310569387,
-0.0376389734,
-0.0382532738,
0.0363817587,
0.0338798165,
0.0512333363,
-0.0253424998,
-0.0113821477,
-0.0275909528,
-0.0699240193,
-0.0452235937,
0.0169543289,
-0.0500102043,
0.0210814569,
-0.0215015244,
-0.0209422875,
-0.0279497951,
0.0028198233,
0.0051062284,
-0.0466439128,
0.0587327853,
-0.022385424,
-0.046364069,
0.0630339608,
0.022551816,
-0.0372028425,
0.0605983473,
0.0158533994,
0.0233697221,
0.0333468914,
0.0259686671,
-0.0493348502,
0.0244338028,
0.0497519001,
0.0029558132,
0.005311151,
-0.0073541822,
-0.0194943175,
-0.034645956,
0.0054413793,
0.0835999846,
-0.0343398787,
-0.0817109644,
0.0435632654,
0.0377043262,
-0.0213439874,
0.0272025857,
0.0071321372,
0.0111998366,
0.0129224099,
0.0164458863,
-0.0594918914,
0.0195027925,
-0.0567334034,
-0.0368167423,
0.065972887,
0.0309525542,
-0.0322346389,
-0.0489650108,
-0.0346914455,
-0.0206145737,
0.0619303398,
-0.0455843173,
0.0310597233,
0.0216803048,
-0.0351894647,
0.0449478552,
0.0738055035,
-0.0375404842,
-0.0124006541,
-0.014584356,
0.0331276506,
0.0581622832,
0.0206607599,
-0.0127895381,
-0.0367151499,
-0.0580527149,
-0.0114376377,
0.0216793437,
0.0535239764,
-0.0231784601,
-0.0148538966,
-0.0382245667,
-0.0370834433,
-0.0238147844,
0.0291125029,
0.0111031337,
0.0317064524,
-0.0029057185,
0.0030867534,
0.0289385617,
-0.0444120988,
0.0429697596,
0.0345186442,
-0.0109098041,
-0.0310427491,
0.0363293737,
0.0683133975,
0.0332693122,
-0.0575238429,
-0.0197869688,
0.0190961882,
-0.0139940744,
-0.0322716758,
-0.0003717905,
-0.0215705112,
-0.0133624859,
0.0198662449,
-0.0454928763,
-0.0107586654,
0.0136524281,
-0.0071953223,
0.0096678706,
-0.0008690188,
-0.0585152917,
0.005423381,
-0.0604814403,
-0.0317475758,
-0.0549516194,
-0.0043322463,
-0.0457047932,
0.0598770902,
-0.0224970281,
-0.0045027984,
-0.045970168,
-0.0235344842,
0.014728101,
0.023597369,
-0.0621672906,
-0.0183063447,
0.0264369287,
0.0067127845,
0.0369611494,
-0.006937745,
-0.0279724617,
-0.0280613098,
-0.0953736231,
-0.0152665256,
-0.0307839382,
0.0096709635,
0.0160264261,
-0.0214579031,
0.0292462576,
0.0226619318,
-0.017378062,
-0.0128900195,
0.0006529327,
0.0540656671,
0.0121426061,
-0.0084363874,
0.0083988653,
-0.0406607054,
-0.0020536843,
-0.0460631661,
0.0316554047,
0.0095525095,
-0.0484823212,
0.0255526137,
-0.0028536019,
-0.0830498561,
0.0215551909,
0.0021349667,
-0.0364150889,
0.029905919,
0.0467718542,
0.0019112349,
0.0209351312,
0.0513767116,
0.0901563913,
0.032669656,
0.0001688975,
-0.028610196,
0.0149527481,
-0.0050081774,
0.0262459796,
-0.0003728394,
-0.0508956462,
-0.0016232268,
0.0646305606,
0.0091940621,
-0.0180272479,
-0.0750798211,
-0.0031826983,
-0.028346166,
-0.0302732754,
0.013122607,
-0.0639938116,
-0.0046594329,
-0.028916806,
-0.0440373048,
-0.0523003675,
0.0939525813,
-0.0181483421,
0.0153682865,
-0.0340649299,
-0.0062216101,
0.0230282694,
0.0374042653,
-0.0216233041,
0.0398110561,
0.007154908,
0.0177548211,
0.0081511671,
-0.0228523687,
0.0770891756,
-0.0162108764,
0.0062633902,
0.0060487972,
0.0167560186,
0.0002381656,
-0.0404361188,
-0.0219911542,
-0.0588624477,
-0.0113935275,
-0.0177854877,
0.0060842154,
0.0063695265,
-0.0266829394,
0.0046564881,
0.0081260763,
-0.0396203622,
-0.0067056799,
-0.0015923415,
0.0366544053,
0.0028562634,
-0.0016801789,
-0.0176474638,
0.0339235254,
-0.0176306497,
-0.0140357697,
0.0664813817,
-0.0023791266,
0.0188300926,
-0.0053773527,
-0.0425628163,
0.002416614,
-0.0101789916,
-0.0239570066,
-0.0247686505,
0.0388669521,
-0.014217373,
0.002365066,
0.09016978,
0.0154815512,
-0.0094750691,
-0.0147369485,
0.019108342,
0.0174445733,
0.0264610462,
-0.0300775133,
-0.0695467293,
-0.02046212,
-0.0301042665,
0.0275485925,
-0.0520434417,
-0.0334766321,
-0.0050631356,
-0.0779177025,
-0.0262360834,
-0.0195668191,
-0.0385507606,
0.0024576671,
-0.0357177183,
-0.0049708071,
-0.0075066732,
0.0120421322,
-0.0359632447,
0.0468278714,
0.0042594331,
0.0329554304,
-0.0412814096,
0.000079409,
0.0090142572,
-0.0366682187,
0.0664853752,
0.0627730414,
0.0575281866,
-0.0240797997,
-0.0477024727,
0.0417974032,
-0.0058707418,
-0.0350934453,
-0.0434752144,
0.0884511247,
-0.0429020151,
-0.0240548644,
-0.0190047789,
-0.0029263811,
0.0353395976,
0.0145138316,
-0.0538303293,
0.0287870001,
0.0185719877,
0.0099336701,
-0.047307685,
0.0482209846,
0.0081115952,
0.0810953155,
0.0070451349,
-0.0334383994,
0.0166316517,
-0.0223140325,
0.0083335377,
0.0018769338,
-0.0084796911,
0.0091409702,
-0.0448972695,
-0.0782117397,
-0.0744969621,
-0.0764428079,
0.0098715872,
0.0262990277,
0.0044836146,
-0.0200860873,
-0.0055400981,
0.0218112394,
-0.0372884497,
0.0029743952,
0.0205837339,
0.034588851,
0.0111897411,
-0.0486838184,
0.0359403156,
0.0244854689,
-0.0458917469,
0.0346466973,
-0.0467280559,
-0.0684962422,
0.0426748581,
0.0648604631,
0.0171154197,
0.0150633603,
-0.0242742002,
-0.0450459048,
0.0366515815,
0.067713581,
-0.0192376189,
0.0181832165,
0.038530387,
0.0158017147,
0.0204516798,
0.0172991734,
-0.0275444221,
0.0278806854,
0.0327098444,
-0.0254597701,
-0.0413912982,
-0.0425294489,
-0.0166783165,
-0.0021773633,
0.0599680766,
-0.0053132866,
-0.0506816283,
-0.0168497227,
-0.0036557997,
0.0189831313,
-0.043707516,
-0.0048627052,
-0.0103007471,
-0.0214682017,
-0.0403479598,
-0.0421189405,
0.0735950172,
-0.014897692,
0.0617146008,
-0.0580085181,
0.0140557252,
0.0532619804,
0.0507269651,
-0.0336526483,
-0.0060494142,
-0.0415333025,
0.0141991479,
0.035834033,
-0.0171160735,
0.0200433861,
0.0278036129,
0.0141725913,
0.0301754642,
0.025057517,
-0.0097234212,
-0.0174809638,
0.023942532,
-0.0582761206,
0.0304992348,
-0.0180389304,
0.0254093707,
0.0671005324,
0.0081866989,
-0.0266895201,
-0.0106012672,
-0.0274752118,
-0.0318842232,
-0.0183080342,
0.0506378599,
0.0293705054,
-0.0104139857,
0.006015501,
0.0311087873,
-0.0244640075,
0.0420289636,
0.0276525114,
-0.0514496155,
-0.0175096523,
-0.0102122696,
0.0478368402,
0.0318795033,
-0.0197990742,
0.0124588488,
-0.0481369905,
-0.0243645497,
0.0282394905,
-0.0202703401,
0.0244292729,
0.0384833552,
0.027561659,
0.057237301,
-0.0016419974,
0.0172443651,
0.0075580273,
-0.0250017196,
0.0104832975,
-0.0117934654,
-0.0120162275,
-6.138928881e-33,
-0.0419873558,
-0.0262067094,
-0.0343029499,
0.0308608245,
-0.0134479543,
-0.0111744618,
0.0300742071,
0.0140411183,
-0.0086720623,
0.0384719633,
0.0465751439,
0.0394085161,
0.0003295769,
-0.0144407824,
-0.0086357184,
-0.0560374223,
0.0525994711,
-0.0104529178,
-0.0242155865,
-0.0012920734,
0.0315928534,
-0.0070526181,
0.0528556034,
-0.100063704,
0.085511364,
0.0071087708,
-0.0502190404,
-0.0026967586,
0.0094442526,
0.0452540815,
-0.0085899979,
0.074246794,
0.021267714,
-0.0114618754,
0.0174179394,
0.0202291757,
-0.0578717366,
-0.0165242888,
0.0154230213,
0.0030585362,
0.0040723593,
-0.0029368068,
0.0609478764,
0.015044136,
-0.039601285,
-0.0144209228,
0.048973456,
-0.0013104529,
0.0119373407,
-0.0934208781,
-0.058624208,
0.01997355,
-0.0204671472,
-0.0323755443,
-0.0061213551,
-0.0113513703,
0.053154204,
0.0189983267,
-0.0827023983,
0.0181532893,
-0.0210177619,
-0.029386295,
-0.0435475446,
-0.0353325754,
0.0180697758,
0.0895767733,
0.0242923591,
0.0565074421,
0.0173918847,
-0.012865833,
0.0103112906,
-0.0026119873,
0.042283304,
0.0579977855,
0.0321521498,
-0.03870463,
-0.0739596188,
0.0350433961,
0.0431179032,
-0.0123352995,
-0.009453983,
-0.0155636221,
-0.0611728318,
-0.0118992422,
-0.011266063,
-0.0458597206,
-0.0345829614,
-0.0067590368,
-0.0120497318,
0.0011888311,
-0.0370739736,
0.0573797859,
-0.0247721132,
-0.0224849097,
0.0213027634,
0.0280670933,
-0.009772053,
0.000716899,
-0.0000625677,
-0.0025813696,
-0.0473012514,
-0.0001438001,
0.0181677584,
0.0122928973,
0.0161549523,
-0.0030253481,
0.1216070428,
0.0180276372,
-0.095225729,
-0.0007469601,
-0.0003029916,
0.032758832,
-0.0221264213,
0.0109061273,
0.0221538655,
0.02300529,
-0.0113464883,
-0.0063848295,
0.0318533219,
0.0586059578,
-0.0296997149,
-0.0058934069,
-0.0044351961,
-0.0179873705,
0.0258546397,
-0.0262738988,
0.0291423369,
-0.0384272486,
-0.0057028858,
-0.0626743361,
0.0043003378,
-0.0518595725,
2.623e-7,
0.0219788179,
0.0564591661,
0.0006293579,
-0.0504414216,
0.0388034917,
0.0491543226,
0.0171706956,
0.0326422825,
0.0130044883,
-0.0481303856,
-0.0225958936,
0.026023984,
-0.0023745617,
0.0740232691,
0.0037174071,
-0.0333193019,
-0.060388457,
0.0089268032,
-0.0146565782,
0.0262085944,
0.0420729667,
0.0840834528,
0.0559117906,
-0.0339363553,
-0.0063277003,
0.0047703981,
0.066608265,
-0.0164048392,
-0.0138273472,
-0.0153335007,
0.0654487163,
-0.0012037256,
0.014796285,
0.0369574949,
-0.007373888,
0.0038685862,
0.005813566,
0.0100358007,
-0.0075956527,
-0.0561154485,
0.0094213327,
0.0096582081,
-0.0054291282,
-0.0026651539,
0.0315114036,
-0.0015995364,
-0.0407860801,
-0.0270985309,
-0.0401733778,
0.0119035216,
0.0788337886,
-0.0176227987,
-0.0198520552,
-0.0073641241,
-0.0081148688,
-0.0181061327,
-0.0082779443,
-0.0792357251,
-0.0198123604,
0.0160822738,
-0.0170291886,
-0.0806550384,
0.000773649,
-0.0123026557,
0.0155797079,
-0.0536572337,
0.0469855033,
2.08256824e-34,
0.0437658019,
-0.0391450264,
0.0127354944,
-0.0151403956,
0.0176345594,
0.0274254028,
-0.0240915567,
-0.0422704071,
0.0134561136,
0.0076216827,
-0.0171524119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01028v2 | Company classification using zero-shot learning | 2023-05-01T18:36:06 | 2023-10-26T20:19:37 | Maryan Rizinski, Andrej Jankov, Vignesh Sankaradas, Eugene Pinsky, Igor Miskovski, Dimitar Trajanov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, natural language processing (NLP) has become increasingly
important in a variety of business applications, including sentiment analysis,
text classification, and named entity recognition. In this paper, we propose an
approach for company classification using NLP and zero-shot learning. Our
method utilizes pre-trained transformer models to extract features from company
descriptions, and then applies zero-shot learning to classify companies into
relevant categories without the need for specific training data for each
category. We evaluate our approach on a dataset obtained through the Wharton
Research Data Services (WRDS), which comprises textual descriptions of publicly
traded companies. We demonstrate that the approach can streamline the process
of company classification, thereby reducing the time and resources required in
traditional approaches such as the Global Industry Classification Standard
(GICS). The results show that this method has potential for automation of
company classification, making it a promising avenue for future research in
this area. | [
-0.0083921514,
0.0435912684,
0.015181886,
0.0005972345,
-0.0075698891,
0.0177225918,
0.0425989069,
0.0503289029,
-0.0013878356,
-0.144115299,
-0.0063865753,
0.002263302,
-0.0089291064,
0.0219360907,
-0.0084312372,
0.0196101777,
0.0162216462,
0.0332308859,
0.0007569263,
0.0342953019,
-0.031608548,
0.0106285848,
-0.0047733909,
0.0185432304,
0.0328964144,
0.0050330963,
0.0003422619,
-0.0145015884,
0.0216299482,
-0.0292703994,
0.0083339401,
0.0269023012,
-0.0000225776,
0.0327064469,
0.0000018385,
-0.0575120226,
-0.0359089971,
-0.0108067356,
-0.014631941,
-0.0485332981,
0.0352285989,
-0.0690528974,
0.0327723846,
0.0220756754,
-0.0371939726,
-0.0525570661,
0.053670086,
0.0634189174,
0.024486782,
0.0902552083,
-0.0238822754,
-0.0727889314,
-0.0371971093,
-0.0097870119,
0.0031608655,
-0.0259233899,
0.0366304182,
-0.042922657,
-0.0075328094,
0.0056367922,
-0.0183818974,
0.0118539995,
-0.0335584767,
0.0205059424,
0.041836597,
0.0303477738,
-0.0659424812,
-0.0139691094,
-0.027006736,
0.0589470826,
-0.0095317466,
-0.01996601,
-0.0189844202,
-0.035815049,
0.0017681279,
-0.0103162788,
0.0065949466,
0.0434127823,
-0.0016920214,
0.02579128,
-0.0467142537,
0.0678993985,
-0.0080298511,
-0.0132503333,
-0.0213886332,
0.0158567354,
-0.0446804352,
-0.0197341051,
0.0327017792,
0.0290177036,
0.0412162952,
-0.0523837209,
-0.035672199,
0.03623721,
0.04158042,
0.0087299617,
-0.0188632384,
-0.0081577692,
0.016390238,
-0.0641471595,
0.0195251275,
0.0148901343,
0.0128804306,
0.0576232001,
-0.0566907823,
-0.0089963032,
0.0251160618,
-0.0135237304,
-0.0012363994,
0.0100509729,
-0.0956747383,
-0.0028287857,
-0.0104013346,
0.093245022,
-0.0117505714,
0.0121882809,
-0.0499815382,
-0.0081228493,
-0.0168713201,
0.0157638229,
-0.0045023179,
0.0040364084,
0.0341787934,
-0.0104488796,
-0.0342951976,
0.0222633444,
0.0070057763,
0.0090326043,
-0.0513481162,
-0.0242330618,
0.015669873,
0.0062189787,
0.0311833564,
-0.0035935487,
0.021980416,
0.0442461222,
0.0269305799,
-0.0776805431,
-0.0512923524,
-0.0174736809,
0.0000175382,
-0.0408591889,
-0.028031759,
-0.0150048472,
-0.0042805006,
0.0061109625,
-0.0046809167,
-0.0054808771,
0.0157983415,
-0.006196341,
-0.0540190153,
0.0828777477,
-0.0183326565,
-0.0267392006,
-0.0095755588,
-0.0335752554,
0.0165024884,
0.0474104173,
-0.0154753421,
0.00332468,
0.0246957354,
-0.0042758426,
0.0322329216,
0.030704543,
-0.0180151388,
-0.0551343486,
0.011205649,
0.0252248794,
-0.0215371512,
-0.02074253,
-0.0170524493,
-0.0433056615,
-0.002181391,
0.0193812083,
0.0439175405,
0.0334505551,
0.0671460927,
0.0183463674,
0.0183530208,
0.0404551513,
-0.0287419688,
-0.0555030331,
0.0055706566,
-0.0004809427,
-0.0548481047,
0.0234745033,
-0.0554055497,
-0.0023168591,
-0.0385929197,
-0.0361640602,
-0.020769937,
-0.0485230125,
-0.0317843705,
0.0079405187,
0.0754681081,
-0.0086580664,
-0.0683403909,
0.0290270597,
0.0402745977,
-0.0130191641,
-0.033502806,
-0.0049939095,
0.0277671013,
0.0688451976,
0.0298003349,
-0.0511620715,
-0.0174820852,
-0.0614028163,
-0.0255808346,
0.0339362845,
0.0187073853,
0.0071581639,
-0.0067031272,
-0.0203422606,
-0.012846279,
0.008333087,
0.0434593856,
0.0013390244,
-0.0392288528,
0.0479289964,
0.0269434806,
0.0286663864,
-0.0025592735,
0.0213664491,
-0.0036705513,
-0.0537297539,
0.0642894804,
0.0277354214,
-0.0386926979,
0.052332025,
-0.0420738794,
-0.0292455051,
0.0123243229,
-0.0299568065,
-0.0457331277,
-0.0043909256,
0.0093334327,
-0.0118475584,
-0.0209803674,
0.0037340105,
-0.0004901123,
0.0026817457,
-0.0230723768,
0.0039051045,
-0.0291344542,
0.045599889,
0.0084163575,
-0.0150518464,
-0.0047893925,
-0.0320293568,
0.0434230976,
-0.0271630138,
0.074542217,
0.0562720709,
0.0367966667,
-0.0468041636,
-0.0633490682,
0.0425835401,
-0.0256068278,
-0.0317255296,
0.0203205626,
-0.038821727,
0.0212852303,
0.0384604149,
-0.0114831869,
0.0105480012,
0.0195868723,
-0.0796578228,
-0.0032814094,
0.0033202393,
-0.0079553379,
0.000102744,
0.0211561192,
-0.0048875036,
-0.0192997307,
-0.0025342095,
0.0078932066,
0.0026584661,
-0.0259138159,
0.0617313944,
-0.0145194968,
-0.0358386412,
0.0061758384,
-0.0042586969,
-0.0183584616,
0.058324676,
0.0334050879,
-0.0580630302,
-0.0360173844,
0.0439346284,
-0.0158270542,
0.0148093337,
0.0408172533,
0.0102272443,
-0.0280555077,
0.0168860443,
-0.0569900572,
0.0485222563,
0.004972449,
0.0406939685,
-0.0234475005,
0.0329848081,
-0.0201824773,
-0.0000552918,
-0.0366452038,
0.0227277614,
0.0024334623,
0.0060065347,
0.0221010353,
0.0568693578,
-0.0225003418,
-0.0144860763,
-0.0462315828,
0.0300692078,
0.0045069577,
0.0136288097,
-0.0368300006,
0.0559761636,
0.0118998997,
0.0524926484,
0.040622171,
-0.0152856922,
0.0215189308,
-0.0104525788,
-0.0001221472,
-0.0170885138,
-0.0427169539,
-0.0678003654,
0.0564847775,
-0.0241637938,
0.0103874756,
0.0624055229,
-0.0142572476,
0.0071197348,
-0.0188432243,
0.0081953462,
-0.0092435312,
0.0428433232,
0.040331237,
0.0307102613,
-0.0357683264,
-0.0002624296,
-0.0338086374,
-0.0514416769,
-0.0359673016,
0.0399740636,
-0.0140226008,
0.0041564316,
-0.0759799778,
0.039036341,
-0.0201293435,
0.0205157325,
-0.0013033641,
-0.0354405083,
-0.0051315739,
0.0280688275,
0.0346079618,
-0.0377549119,
0.0054386216,
0.0352411568,
0.0380022675,
0.0193754826,
0.0107921874,
0.0505805239,
-0.0107305823,
-0.04342933,
-0.001781506,
-0.0845881924,
0.013610458,
-0.0217585713,
-0.0190260615,
0.0118153254,
0.0064092069,
0.1087908,
0.0110670924,
-0.0248187408,
0.0034241735,
0.0715660229,
-0.0575155877,
0.0340223722,
0.058661256,
-0.1108244359,
-0.0451874807,
-0.0408611521,
0.000383327,
-0.000110558,
-0.0469324365,
-0.0011910375,
-0.1455591619,
0.0219762288,
-0.0204725843,
-0.014519969,
-0.0147840297,
-0.0448305309,
-0.0118915457,
-0.0594929717,
-0.0156072276,
-0.0434994437,
-0.0602652952,
-0.0320055895,
0.0029463682,
-0.047344815,
-0.0659301579,
0.0117653208,
-0.0246170573,
-0.0360780843,
0.0218771063,
-0.002854333,
-0.0344500989,
0.00191958,
-0.0244096667,
-0.0438852459,
-0.0053876182,
0.0033652936,
0.0738617778,
-0.0610936657,
-0.0175780728,
0.0635941997,
-0.0175239891,
-0.0410849266,
0.0250239875,
-0.0037711794,
0.0280549172,
0.0055981702,
-0.0306630712,
-0.0092821596,
0.0101952422,
0.0023669756,
0.0898036212,
-0.0401741378,
-0.0615739599,
-0.0311787501,
-0.0346911401,
-0.0154484408,
-0.0343376175,
-0.0260396637,
0.019196162,
-0.056057252,
-0.0578720048,
-0.0633410141,
-0.0414066464,
0.0660958439,
0.0256393328,
-0.0086916881,
-0.0288596638,
0.018541621,
0.0320769474,
-0.0685390979,
-0.0199989993,
-0.0068889689,
0.0394743159,
-0.044670023,
-0.012732219,
0.0478169546,
-0.0013405165,
-0.0602055304,
-0.0452100262,
-0.0404917337,
-0.0365692116,
-0.0390418582,
0.0302206166,
0.0152138714,
0.0212987214,
-0.0190343428,
-0.005745688,
0.1033174768,
0.09749946,
-0.0450516976,
-0.0151079148,
0.0354783088,
0.0040933578,
-0.0073793451,
0.0089416821,
-0.0264347512,
0.021801861,
0.0087477416,
0.0000928959,
-0.0226012934,
0.0157488305,
0.0041781329,
-0.0234616157,
0.0450427532,
0.0403816216,
-0.0014368772,
0.0026845522,
-0.0031729755,
-0.0022102774,
-0.0084186643,
-0.0374125317,
-0.0434579775,
0.0495241247,
-0.016054891,
-0.0164950062,
0.0500950217,
-0.0826886743,
0.0227440875,
-0.0297459662,
0.0183291975,
0.0282556694,
-0.0044195759,
-0.0110251931,
-0.0062229834,
-0.0309611615,
-0.02617044,
0.0454319268,
0.0004067376,
-0.0132364538,
0.00337218,
0.0279849358,
0.0648468658,
-0.044001691,
0.0134453997,
-0.00216169,
0.0179483276,
-0.0053376169,
0.0207212083,
0.0144758234,
-0.0472649485,
0.0062936954,
-0.0145052029,
0.001651132,
0.0072987727,
0.0462222509,
0.0068306439,
-0.0315302499,
0.0213913154,
0.0176576432,
-0.0371710807,
0.0095678642,
0.074620463,
0.0484478213,
0.00009845,
-0.0023824899,
0.0004231543,
-0.0702119917,
0.0341595933,
0.0837460905,
0.0020905791,
0.0133335488,
0.0147388075,
-0.0767405555,
-0.0329484753,
0.0575259849,
-0.0576204769,
0.0282492507,
0.0038299696,
0.0114978421,
0.0390256569,
0.0528228357,
0.0149830114,
-0.0391970836,
-0.0082966965,
0.0117830839,
0.0177044645,
-0.0510890558,
-5.527603493e-33,
-0.0031722386,
-0.0513834395,
0.0074290847,
0.0306872688,
0.0412930548,
0.0184786022,
0.0325487256,
-0.0029365916,
-0.0141260093,
0.006293409,
0.0240081735,
-0.0026687621,
0.0254110042,
0.0172817111,
0.0168207921,
-0.0331224427,
0.0267485902,
-0.0173821487,
-0.0146941859,
-0.0090292608,
0.0122794006,
0.0328499563,
0.0732634589,
-0.0415761098,
0.0157730579,
-0.0127305826,
-0.024215214,
0.0028769614,
0.111166127,
0.0534763783,
-0.0020063445,
0.0424309112,
0.033567477,
-0.080637753,
0.049142275,
0.0162886679,
-0.0527418554,
0.0083770584,
-0.0294689257,
0.0412914157,
0.0688191652,
0.0316186175,
0.0154348742,
-0.0197008606,
0.0077808057,
-0.0447370075,
0.0547879189,
-0.0070961332,
-0.0113276783,
-0.0721179917,
-0.1032379046,
0.0243442245,
0.0088192234,
0.0136202844,
0.064479135,
0.0554981418,
0.0154101355,
0.0515541658,
-0.0651719645,
0.0016970445,
0.0048560039,
-0.0141360108,
0.0239411928,
0.0088915899,
-0.0115347961,
0.0258554555,
0.001419778,
0.0410882533,
-0.0325752199,
0.030417813,
0.030292768,
0.028686488,
-0.0115220565,
0.0284125842,
0.0604938753,
-0.0277050342,
-0.0413435698,
0.0105748456,
-0.0011029197,
-0.012354997,
0.0093343901,
-0.0141947595,
-0.0144076468,
-0.0107548889,
0.0490244702,
-0.0186374802,
-0.0395236723,
-0.0053910734,
-0.0002262098,
0.0451632142,
-0.0511573292,
0.0685305074,
0.0220046639,
-0.0683099926,
-0.0473588854,
0.0239819586,
-0.0093801478,
0.0446135923,
0.0010874025,
-0.0837418139,
-0.0462808423,
-0.0385735221,
-0.0161564443,
0.0393894762,
0.030229833,
-0.0018094367,
0.0826427788,
0.0002410136,
-0.0557905957,
-0.0240266137,
0.0117585286,
0.0287524574,
-0.0041591027,
0.0362618603,
-0.0069753015,
0.0436789505,
-0.0006099711,
0.0273157172,
0.0180744939,
0.0026518798,
0.0352902599,
0.0193306431,
0.0255074706,
0.0144766774,
-0.016186215,
-0.0142053301,
0.0171301644,
0.0297175087,
0.0227674488,
-0.040226616,
-0.0109858308,
-0.0050787427,
2.446e-7,
0.0351596251,
0.0436392128,
-0.0238151476,
0.0053290473,
0.0020077655,
0.0633149296,
0.0407771282,
0.0296690203,
-0.0240142606,
-0.0013243646,
0.0238977559,
-0.0410083905,
0.0236688349,
0.0050470768,
-0.0985967368,
-0.0283871312,
-0.0053879512,
0.0399900079,
-0.0806702599,
0.0238182377,
0.0694862083,
0.0566410907,
0.0280130487,
-0.0086173313,
0.0052478113,
-0.0430451185,
0.062439926,
-0.0239643883,
0.0317947231,
0.0155362757,
0.0004024333,
0.0187172927,
-0.0280523878,
-0.0193984583,
-0.0434326269,
0.0606832691,
0.0194087848,
0.0050711776,
-0.0288633835,
0.0171786733,
-0.0000303924,
-0.0229119621,
-0.0006805147,
-0.0092042992,
0.0900342688,
-0.1223428175,
-0.0360598676,
-0.021188423,
-0.0508669354,
0.0174566898,
0.0188810155,
0.0115439789,
-0.0234162956,
0.0369964875,
0.0456489697,
-0.0248441771,
0.0024810743,
-0.0426204354,
0.0378853232,
0.0213793516,
0.0110721923,
0.0439017005,
0.0251071844,
-0.0360279419,
0.0717987195,
-0.0175540168,
0.01572299,
2.218011592e-34,
0.0206037369,
-0.0079326611,
-0.0109737525,
0.0361854285,
0.003792346,
-0.0076136552,
-0.0226611458,
-0.0028166296,
0.0024589857,
-0.0596718378,
0.0239270795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01020v1 | Evaluating statistical language models as pragmatic reasoners | 2023-05-01T18:22:10 | 2023-05-01T18:22:10 | Benjamin Lipkin, Lionel Wong, Gabriel Grand, Joshua B Tenenbaum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The relationship between communicated language and intended meaning is often
probabilistic and sensitive to context. Numerous strategies attempt to estimate
such a mapping, often leveraging recursive Bayesian models of communication. In
parallel, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly applied to
semantic parsing applications, tasked with inferring logical representations
from natural language. While existing LLM explorations have been largely
restricted to literal language use, in this work, we evaluate the capacity of
LLMs to infer the meanings of pragmatic utterances. Specifically, we explore
the case of threshold estimation on the gradable adjective ``strong'',
contextually conditioned on a strength prior, then extended to composition with
qualification, negation, polarity inversion, and class comparison. We find that
LLMs can derive context-grounded, human-like distributions over the
interpretations of several complex pragmatic utterances, yet struggle composing
with negation. These results inform the inferential capacity of statistical
language models, and their use in pragmatic and semantic parsing applications.
All corresponding code is made publicly available
(https://github.com/benlipkin/probsem/tree/CogSci2023). | [
0.0312481336,
0.0566356219,
-0.0105821956,
0.036721997,
-0.0538744777,
0.0174876321,
-0.0261336453,
-0.0313705169,
-0.0432564355,
-0.0871275589,
-0.0019000809,
-0.007191122,
-0.0099321594,
0.0099129006,
-0.0083729886,
-0.0266150292,
0.0181134902,
-0.0247046482,
0.0518357046,
0.0044652722,
0.0116388341,
0.0320892036,
-0.0246286206,
0.0492255576,
-0.0167195778,
-0.021574311,
0.0002354742,
0.0270849075,
-0.004921786,
-0.0286282618,
-0.0208776724,
0.0174848773,
-0.0117215812,
-0.0232294574,
0.0000019828,
-0.0561329275,
-0.0077338051,
-0.0261267573,
-0.0297770891,
-0.0073437043,
0.0954302177,
-0.0534602366,
-0.0209797788,
0.00313908,
-0.0343157724,
-0.0258723851,
0.0547035635,
0.0145597728,
0.0069684247,
0.0551765263,
-0.0076908995,
-0.0491837002,
-0.0008540216,
-0.0211056136,
0.0054919375,
-0.076818265,
0.0341462493,
0.0280550998,
-0.0150973117,
-0.0069973287,
-0.0357756354,
0.0268740244,
0.0093480684,
-0.0007728229,
-0.0342367813,
0.0292785745,
0.0281249341,
-0.0047364598,
0.0048263879,
0.0166348107,
0.0093772206,
-0.0358870141,
0.0054220348,
-0.011354574,
-0.0020689336,
0.0418962352,
-0.0280732345,
0.0704835579,
-0.0266067553,
0.0491944887,
0.0736450329,
-0.0119022578,
0.013186601,
0.029014606,
-0.0351671986,
0.1420231313,
0.0074741286,
0.000430575,
0.0129236374,
0.0063818037,
-0.0136827584,
-0.04142249,
-0.0164721906,
0.0066338186,
-0.0174639989,
0.0422074534,
0.0050874385,
0.0029313497,
0.0216411836,
-0.0158350002,
-0.027177697,
0.0144932531,
-0.0046874927,
0.0642483756,
0.0109884813,
-0.0067220922,
0.0091669057,
0.0208488405,
-0.0408471264,
-0.0335068107,
-0.0644436553,
-0.020702593,
-0.0188628267,
0.0010621489,
-0.0238381512,
0.0025489992,
-0.0233554747,
0.0112631591,
-0.032081034,
-0.0110350205,
0.0110936677,
-0.0004842805,
-0.0671625286,
-0.0070654429,
-0.0402625762,
0.0492451079,
-0.0409589112,
0.0503625683,
-0.0244961344,
-0.0483097136,
0.0000694319,
0.0204170477,
0.0122179417,
-0.0298257358,
-0.0174313318,
0.0366834067,
0.0281686503,
-0.0049097277,
-0.0356099792,
-0.0473697595,
-0.0633284673,
-0.0404193252,
-0.0119504174,
-0.050772097,
-0.0246660113,
0.025292106,
0.0250307806,
-0.0844190493,
0.0054736831,
-0.0091512771,
-0.0145460078,
0.0679895282,
0.0281532966,
0.0231951643,
-0.0350423604,
-0.009363113,
-0.0380773693,
0.0520554706,
0.0279179662,
-0.0243003014,
0.0311840698,
-0.0088698873,
-0.0085922582,
-0.007113745,
-0.0229888856,
-0.0150569258,
-0.0600529835,
0.0049649267,
-0.0267777964,
-0.0056213597,
0.0408133455,
0.0337130986,
-0.0210012775,
-0.0312846042,
0.014197791,
0.040766485,
-0.0154834371,
-0.0117237046,
0.0566887259,
0.0320034288,
-0.0295460653,
0.0034993261,
-0.0544084944,
-0.0156557336,
-0.0229096748,
-0.0031239823,
-0.0262760557,
-0.001593579,
-0.002056587,
-0.0411978476,
-0.0018347536,
-0.038548205,
0.0306228604,
-0.0188766457,
0.0839988813,
0.0129581327,
0.0121690445,
-0.001861724,
0.0283886082,
-0.0410255194,
-0.0058044665,
-0.0475634262,
0.0306194071,
0.0594638474,
0.0114688147,
-0.0376837291,
0.024195794,
-0.0064846668,
0.0096826442,
0.0392122082,
-0.0218288284,
-0.0011840774,
0.0259403698,
-0.0226297658,
0.0073316018,
-0.01598721,
0.0593820922,
0.0048100199,
-0.0605592504,
0.0018442184,
0.0162396021,
-0.029957125,
0.0097834785,
0.0223083775,
0.0136741046,
0.0146696549,
0.009074036,
-0.0096517168,
0.0445232652,
-0.0178231616,
-0.0209069364,
0.0532304309,
0.0332697518,
-0.0452363081,
-0.0045527513,
0.0518967956,
0.0059091249,
-0.0308034699,
0.0469653048,
-0.0639874637,
-0.008685193,
-0.0368355997,
-0.0271164328,
-0.0341852941,
0.0629603416,
-0.0358498693,
0.0439807698,
-0.0366426259,
0.012658393,
-0.0021462578,
0.0036956889,
-0.0187848937,
0.0861464441,
-0.0016181235,
-0.0067370529,
-0.0091160508,
-0.0332740545,
0.0017617698,
-0.0445610508,
-0.0032892257,
-0.0267188177,
-0.0071147708,
-0.0235479567,
0.0136945779,
0.0059994534,
-0.021322649,
-0.0300206374,
-0.0594769306,
0.003122055,
-0.0177260619,
0.0479109436,
0.0447322764,
-0.0105934348,
0.0012293226,
0.0124974372,
0.0109695839,
-0.0155835832,
-0.0130107915,
0.040623527,
0.0210502502,
-0.0092268893,
-0.0239658635,
-0.0227670632,
-0.0101268236,
-0.0606850199,
0.0458631702,
0.0159101449,
0.0193762332,
-0.0130369635,
0.0654780641,
-0.0507431254,
-0.003681608,
-0.0046489113,
-0.0566201583,
0.0373918004,
-0.0232703444,
0.0599844866,
0.0950218886,
-0.0032248879,
0.0431366675,
0.0558879972,
-0.039391879,
-0.0242631361,
-0.0118402727,
-0.0406651236,
-0.0140118152,
-0.0591731966,
-0.0788472891,
-0.0457388014,
0.0615463741,
0.0360237211,
0.010446527,
-0.0563989021,
0.0341802798,
-0.0234868433,
-0.0312966257,
0.007311245,
0.0124931531,
-0.0004108409,
0.0643459484,
-0.0085582305,
-0.0384687074,
0.0535680912,
-0.0153118297,
-0.0034347537,
-0.0273661967,
-0.011077879,
-0.0152951833,
0.0738031939,
-0.0074049444,
0.0064660078,
0.0080403881,
0.0177526344,
0.0007586881,
-0.0390462913,
0.0226303041,
-0.0178629253,
0.0071254312,
-0.058825992,
0.0068817418,
0.0132036349,
-0.0058237836,
-0.0009271454,
-0.0687582344,
-0.0810393691,
-0.0133520858,
-0.0051924135,
-0.0078733517,
0.0158202797,
0.0415847078,
-0.0166911539,
-0.0236364827,
0.0170127898,
-0.0198911391,
-0.018785404,
-0.0264282171,
0.0308956802,
0.0094466042,
0.0332430899,
0.0223022997,
-0.0151830427,
0.0514535941,
0.0162046514,
0.0461515747,
-0.0323184393,
-0.0159869175,
-0.0043690875,
0.0142941847,
-0.0391526334,
0.0096549271,
0.0306383651,
-0.0519223958,
-0.0149902841,
0.1146162227,
0.0357509069,
0.0034056329,
0.0436047055,
-0.0190527495,
0.0354383029,
0.0031435869,
0.0024314853,
-0.0975052938,
-0.0702213347,
0.0069345124,
-0.0030853041,
-0.0609298088,
-0.0391313322,
-0.0048990515,
-0.1044972464,
0.0415006764,
-0.0052040317,
0.0098168477,
0.0034837674,
-0.053765595,
0.0263798758,
-0.0505816191,
-0.0467621908,
-0.0132317171,
-0.0045477445,
0.0404681675,
0.0209104624,
-0.0190971643,
-0.0764177069,
0.0320912041,
-0.0285145845,
0.0545334332,
0.0549876578,
0.0329316966,
-0.0152331721,
-0.0519902743,
0.0426056571,
-0.0667610317,
-0.0167212859,
-0.0050159055,
-0.0227437802,
-0.0101956706,
0.0077897166,
-0.0348735079,
0.0415331945,
-0.071390152,
-0.0114874337,
0.0128505537,
0.0944993943,
-0.0259689447,
-0.0263793096,
-0.0090885302,
0.0472466722,
0.0125009287,
0.1231705993,
0.0402916186,
-0.0220346022,
-0.0386949368,
-0.0417926684,
0.0063945819,
0.0490148999,
-0.0245394967,
0.0103037208,
0.0355857909,
-0.0389294364,
-0.0486063994,
-0.0272409134,
0.0223949105,
0.0039071636,
-0.020508755,
0.0133986035,
0.004573741,
-0.0143365916,
-0.0288699623,
0.0337171294,
-0.0296972506,
0.0287693236,
-0.0484866649,
-0.0003295897,
0.0575474314,
-0.018967839,
-0.0517426245,
-0.0168449525,
-0.04544954,
-0.0428746715,
0.0080658486,
0.0208041277,
0.033791054,
-0.024189502,
-0.0424325578,
-0.0483107269,
-0.0691620409,
0.0465310328,
-0.0300650951,
0.0485961363,
0.0730579942,
0.0184804946,
0.045469746,
0.0779755712,
-0.0088735679,
0.0473883599,
0.0032306989,
0.0680497512,
-0.0229134057,
-0.0426401533,
0.0382726118,
0.002845837,
0.0074270708,
0.0124501232,
-0.0843437091,
-0.0001796237,
-0.0158668365,
-0.0636174455,
-0.0412083454,
-0.0322418623,
0.0060139983,
0.0384662263,
-0.0004361449,
-0.0259803254,
-0.0438758992,
-0.0524132662,
0.0568925291,
0.009215463,
0.0374488309,
0.0659978539,
-0.0071783476,
-0.0344352387,
-0.034636341,
0.0140471533,
0.0023561448,
-0.0293232147,
0.0210202392,
0.0123937717,
0.0580764562,
0.0288596582,
-0.0323452502,
-0.0257217679,
-0.0117163509,
-0.0448076129,
-0.0125161661,
0.0665636882,
0.0225992091,
0.0281091817,
0.007174762,
0.0768218637,
-0.0422277115,
0.020490868,
-0.0340232216,
0.0698573142,
0.069839783,
-0.0193005949,
0.0639199167,
0.027888475,
-0.0354476348,
0.0009149272,
0.0625363588,
0.0053069056,
0.0360784866,
0.0138433566,
-0.0260141268,
-0.0141235627,
-0.0330930166,
-0.0255625695,
0.0293458998,
0.0013059597,
0.0360376872,
-0.1084631011,
-0.0696753711,
-0.0176667944,
0.0370429866,
0.0146975722,
-0.03527968,
0.0078075076,
0.0731053278,
-0.0240926035,
-0.0140041728,
-0.0434915163,
0.0199771281,
-0.0105679743,
0.0094533777,
-0.0706818476,
-6.495410033e-33,
-0.0279398914,
-0.0369464271,
-0.0237419158,
0.0033864286,
0.0262243226,
-0.0064093713,
-0.052076634,
-0.0013304432,
-0.0082342206,
0.0626434982,
0.0044463216,
0.0320198275,
0.018428674,
0.0300577842,
-0.000831027,
-0.0205809455,
0.0165621284,
0.0065053487,
-0.0079352055,
0.0042064497,
0.0617971383,
-0.0078252172,
0.0114607858,
-0.0949454978,
0.0283728968,
0.0065393383,
-0.0309934262,
0.0597512685,
-0.0198138263,
0.0524414815,
0.0035656577,
0.0372072123,
0.0422063246,
-0.0038088574,
0.0239253119,
0.0150424307,
-0.0716581494,
-0.0152634066,
0.072608754,
-0.0255206469,
-0.021262262,
-0.0412275493,
0.0341123976,
0.0140991742,
-0.0300695375,
0.0201452989,
0.0299179237,
-0.0222184435,
0.014364901,
-0.0183083992,
-0.0401684456,
0.0390614904,
-0.0355098024,
-0.0147121744,
0.004492485,
-0.0311392136,
-0.0168751553,
0.0298315156,
0.0069396617,
0.0282481629,
-0.0136696817,
0.0235283561,
0.0518324748,
0.0051006842,
0.0238698218,
0.0609465912,
0.0470540188,
-0.0210571438,
0.0103512555,
-0.0175156593,
0.0229922719,
0.0350446329,
0.0013919418,
0.0345253199,
0.0491786823,
0.0196280424,
-0.0549314395,
-0.0259871054,
0.0542836934,
0.0421374366,
0.0484214872,
0.0087840455,
-0.0416916125,
-0.0297993924,
-0.035186369,
-0.0375141054,
-0.0111815184,
-0.0178195015,
0.0341203995,
-0.0318632051,
-0.0372472852,
0.016992664,
0.0225716159,
-0.0282574892,
-0.0442769751,
0.0262188762,
0.0021844141,
0.008607965,
-0.0086008804,
0.0499353074,
-0.0133756706,
-0.0096821701,
0.0301450994,
-0.0174898207,
0.027712753,
0.0263356213,
0.0313589685,
-0.006448803,
-0.0245984923,
-0.0059093689,
-0.0368159227,
-0.0152308596,
-0.0754654631,
0.0493565314,
0.0593797266,
0.0433722101,
0.0009751111,
0.0181644615,
0.0249477215,
0.0085700806,
-0.0050774496,
0.0126212845,
0.0000994595,
-0.0035950211,
-0.0447016247,
-0.0353974998,
0.0069889072,
-0.0388139784,
0.0328311101,
-0.0248513296,
-0.0175086576,
0.0131261805,
2.856e-7,
0.0875323787,
0.0190430358,
-0.0131830825,
0.0134131331,
0.0426548943,
0.0340898335,
-0.0027943645,
-0.0165335331,
0.0307471491,
-0.0261335,
-0.010161195,
0.0376314409,
0.0251663309,
0.023934979,
-0.0436581187,
0.0211188588,
-0.0186826941,
-0.0101652481,
-0.0116424942,
0.0205856636,
0.0890018493,
0.1108764559,
0.0171494763,
0.0124067748,
0.0127892531,
-0.0745519251,
0.0247179642,
-0.044878073,
0.0249898601,
0.0114571899,
-0.0124873081,
-0.0242854189,
0.0415530726,
0.0532785431,
0.0378818102,
0.0011867018,
-0.0013933596,
0.0925953314,
-0.0328192674,
-0.00057926,
-0.0113315722,
-0.0379461572,
0.0041976366,
-0.0236424804,
0.0793737099,
-0.0698798895,
-0.0439451896,
0.0104002114,
-0.0453165099,
-0.0120420856,
-0.0165536739,
0.0058961031,
-0.0385402553,
-0.0167354085,
0.031628184,
-0.0358462706,
-0.0246702302,
-0.0472455285,
-0.0196703672,
-0.0036052731,
-0.0037413102,
-0.0473431349,
0.0125014829,
0.0140960095,
0.0305498093,
-0.1053914055,
-0.0230272431,
2.881609836e-34,
0.0643216372,
0.0273863804,
0.0001282857,
0.0106100095,
0.0831097513,
0.0264071487,
-0.0099453628,
0.0311884675,
0.0352577902,
-0.0874473304,
-0.0061144968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01011v1 | Deception Detection with Feature-Augmentation by soft Domain Transfer | 2023-05-01T18:00:54 | 2023-05-01T18:00:54 | Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee, Omprakash Gnawali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this era of information explosion, deceivers use different domains or
mediums of information to exploit the users, such as News, Emails, and Tweets.
Although numerous research has been done to detect deception in all these
domains, information shortage in a new event necessitates these domains to
associate with each other to battle deception. To form this association, we
propose a feature augmentation method by harnessing the intermediate layer
representation of neural models. Our approaches provide an improvement over the
self-domain baseline models by up to 6.60%. We find Tweets to be the most
helpful information provider for Fake News and Phishing Email detection,
whereas News helps most in Tweet Rumor detection. Our analysis provides a
useful insight for domain knowledge transfer which can help build a stronger
deception detection system than the existing literature. | [
0.0319293253,
0.0192548502,
-0.0288633611,
0.0671394169,
-0.0326631851,
0.02221868,
0.0468410701,
0.0014690607,
0.012943523,
-0.0283986852,
-0.0269907638,
-0.0368780568,
0.0053652627,
0.0803235993,
0.0258958191,
-0.0083476091,
0.0367977358,
0.0063948142,
0.0268720072,
-0.0138123576,
0.0285094567,
0.0233668163,
-0.0200525019,
0.0194588974,
-0.0558581352,
-0.0117619382,
0.0053410549,
0.0246693715,
0.053011097,
0.0095221987,
0.0093021858,
0.0434005596,
0.0357349291,
0.0713743195,
0.0000021387,
-0.0222202335,
-0.0435128398,
-0.0139111513,
-0.0634520054,
0.0152937016,
0.0608403534,
-0.0643953979,
-0.0149883227,
0.0025751996,
-0.0488675125,
-0.0218794364,
0.0325118639,
0.0865538567,
0.090855822,
0.1252802759,
-0.026346812,
0.0186230075,
0.0139782885,
-0.0238840468,
-0.0164888073,
-0.0560066737,
0.0465686582,
-0.0485390723,
-0.0699654073,
0.0293783732,
0.0249391738,
-0.0023778926,
-0.0160835125,
-0.0229601599,
-0.0150409844,
0.0187309477,
0.0265058093,
0.0199156534,
-0.0026620473,
0.0146221891,
-0.0430764705,
-0.0040198318,
0.0111013865,
0.0025540413,
0.0411366597,
0.0344678313,
-0.0180750918,
0.0049812743,
-0.0080063278,
0.0029018994,
-0.0266165938,
0.0063339677,
0.0373961814,
0.0320592783,
0.0017667731,
0.0169225466,
-0.0198828783,
0.001510224,
0.0087807383,
-0.0007511665,
-0.0003290476,
-0.0716705769,
0.0285524521,
0.0063903122,
0.0113556609,
-0.0395028815,
-0.0843336359,
-0.0394103304,
-0.0124856289,
-0.0587138161,
-0.0067877066,
-0.0251215696,
-0.0212180894,
0.0308166184,
-0.0108505255,
0.0255013742,
-0.0327452347,
0.0125993779,
-0.0406262055,
-0.0361277238,
-0.0009010486,
-0.0089163296,
-0.0111072743,
0.0491952337,
0.0136471326,
-0.0002556044,
-0.0571437851,
-0.0390121564,
-0.0442084745,
-0.0208318066,
-0.011620515,
0.0035841423,
-0.0347539485,
-0.0281315073,
-0.0178999268,
0.063037999,
0.0032097022,
0.0647427216,
-0.0015479896,
-0.0160076711,
-0.0421485975,
0.0144546069,
-0.0022239836,
-0.0096736616,
-0.0172395855,
0.0184180904,
-0.0121607268,
-0.026352236,
-0.0661843494,
-0.0132031953,
-0.0338674635,
-0.0433089212,
0.0225676484,
-0.0477232412,
0.0022553715,
-0.0473561324,
0.0115584955,
-0.0391736031,
-0.0132089928,
-0.0105069689,
-0.0710090324,
0.0233691521,
-0.0534755737,
0.0146104591,
0.0269272067,
0.0223280732,
-0.0293286555,
0.0719688013,
0.0165493488,
0.1094037592,
0.037100222,
-0.0040969821,
0.0226630364,
0.0017317472,
0.0525916815,
0.0087496862,
0.0639092773,
-0.043396119,
0.0017586735,
-0.0136753973,
0.0021448787,
-0.0259052049,
-0.0230126772,
-0.0232403874,
0.0944812745,
-0.0298302919,
0.0252314694,
-0.0106699709,
0.0292437375,
0.0162599012,
-0.0098172901,
0.007132397,
-0.063689597,
0.0263586752,
-0.0719523653,
-0.0356428511,
-0.0358168334,
0.0727479383,
-0.0086855441,
-0.0225824714,
0.0268543307,
-0.0451846011,
0.0147234276,
-0.000619776,
0.0193987265,
0.0480281562,
-0.0024897153,
0.0396343879,
0.0314729661,
-0.0093585188,
-0.007254296,
-0.0636625439,
-0.0138407992,
0.0205978658,
-0.0113326889,
0.0417508222,
-0.0307605639,
-0.0586777218,
0.0512735955,
0.0221090876,
0.018780075,
-0.0048533529,
0.0141689638,
0.0057278015,
-0.0283987839,
-0.0507863052,
0.0072402908,
0.0213178843,
-0.0086996509,
0.0647083819,
0.0430198833,
-0.0488106199,
0.0416792892,
0.0003649692,
-0.0127863502,
-0.0023031491,
0.019316582,
0.0575457662,
0.0167645365,
0.0319514573,
0.0088737207,
-0.0300972871,
0.0345721543,
-0.0167077444,
-0.0625731871,
-0.0465030223,
-0.0023771159,
0.0160856675,
-0.0036539985,
-0.0639699027,
-0.0049855695,
0.0430653244,
-0.0252212398,
0.0122432411,
0.0570203476,
0.0073191356,
-0.0378865898,
-0.0398764536,
-0.0037162041,
-0.0162812639,
0.0522459969,
0.0302986633,
0.0762889832,
-0.0057808533,
-0.0598380789,
-0.045100037,
-0.0437455364,
0.0080906572,
0.0182160586,
0.0393387266,
-0.0433680788,
-0.026884865,
0.0002946999,
0.0258564726,
-0.0022378475,
-0.0102178389,
-0.0054147593,
-0.0753468201,
-0.0258249864,
-0.0355158634,
-0.0348315872,
0.0113934716,
0.0005324958,
0.012374796,
0.0379798524,
-0.0209912695,
0.0297051985,
-0.0087990705,
0.0020048041,
0.0053260797,
-0.012168535,
0.0060233199,
0.0005241194,
0.0264667273,
-0.0352205932,
0.040423695,
-0.0058218492,
-0.0765089095,
-0.0276169907,
-0.0304261446,
-0.0114125991,
0.0216326024,
-0.0101431273,
-0.0350241326,
-0.0129164681,
-0.0061652581,
-0.0484146662,
0.0281892754,
0.0727919564,
0.0355529636,
0.0009010936,
0.0084273741,
-0.0272966176,
0.0007298216,
-0.0270370897,
0.0280264989,
-0.0549629442,
-0.007321272,
0.0287419464,
0.0351762027,
0.0037307942,
-0.0095313136,
-0.0034307572,
0.0458761454,
0.0114852227,
-0.0293206125,
0.0615983978,
-0.0586915947,
0.0282743108,
0.0004712123,
0.0050249887,
-0.0209809337,
0.0841143057,
-0.0542732961,
0.0648845658,
-0.0126877725,
-0.0587061942,
0.0027888166,
-0.0089819795,
0.0038301928,
0.0168018993,
0.0980756953,
0.001697044,
0.0163316652,
-0.0024565917,
0.0545148812,
-0.0018693716,
0.0121833868,
0.0002924907,
0.022325471,
0.043497704,
-0.0270756204,
-0.0535678603,
-0.0866072774,
0.0006066505,
-0.0512073971,
-0.0448166914,
-0.042355597,
-0.0850494653,
-0.059326075,
-0.0009393974,
0.0036437153,
-0.0237460881,
0.0079120854,
0.0129385311,
0.0207152795,
0.0467855781,
0.0426844209,
0.0458152629,
-0.0028496867,
-0.0414499938,
0.047094021,
-0.0354010351,
0.0117649687,
-0.02221613,
-0.0218332354,
-0.0018223916,
0.0003992777,
0.0289152469,
-0.0346720889,
0.0215731766,
0.0064115762,
0.0235836804,
0.091439046,
-0.0160226114,
-0.0092179533,
0.0267227087,
0.017841259,
-0.0172874145,
-0.0040211622,
-0.0101628862,
-0.0765104666,
-0.0335955396,
0.0096422238,
-0.0288863536,
-0.0348936357,
-0.0272401217,
-0.0052269786,
-0.0833767131,
0.0053468877,
0.0223168861,
-0.0228256378,
-0.0670456812,
-0.017059477,
-0.0086654862,
0.0147354025,
0.0224299934,
-0.0413261987,
0.0168623663,
-0.0358451232,
-0.0259192977,
-0.0022805154,
-0.0558034852,
-0.0131611489,
-0.0320506059,
0.0430989936,
0.0374591686,
0.0248402283,
-0.0053728432,
-0.0349517465,
-0.013889933,
0.0541620739,
-0.0008399782,
0.0127751771,
0.1211629212,
-0.0251908954,
0.0011299609,
0.0213048253,
0.0485846289,
-0.016523473,
-0.0159725677,
0.0085861245,
0.044668857,
0.0274056122,
-0.0774497464,
-0.0239687152,
-0.0064319144,
0.0627501681,
0.0270280745,
-0.0063458988,
0.0123893432,
0.0060445573,
-0.0100630829,
-0.0161510222,
0.0443839841,
-0.0601557717,
0.0724253953,
0.0154984081,
-0.068333298,
-0.0596746393,
0.0050387075,
-0.0184124336,
0.0117429849,
-0.0132295396,
-0.0275602303,
0.0219959524,
-0.0158212967,
-0.0597346015,
0.0267922506,
-0.0344793275,
0.079423748,
0.0101230238,
0.0167237557,
-0.0002317836,
-0.0422663465,
0.0117393052,
0.0062478576,
-0.0704200938,
-0.0225939807,
0.0098829772,
-0.0070203701,
0.0101125026,
0.0707973093,
-0.059525311,
-0.0193144679,
0.0536614433,
0.039309565,
-0.0597129799,
0.0127596306,
0.0395816639,
-0.0508398488,
0.0215026848,
0.0216161497,
-0.0269818213,
0.0509041175,
0.0283044893,
-0.0449846238,
-0.00755736,
0.005813315,
0.0252478588,
-0.0021360731,
0.0772528276,
0.0388072841,
0.0314059183,
-0.0041684406,
0.0065965327,
-0.0068632062,
-0.0007003506,
-0.0269018952,
-0.0103720091,
0.0468167961,
0.0424709767,
0.0264534932,
-0.0365631692,
0.0020118046,
-0.0168784279,
-0.0393507704,
-0.057129439,
0.0040597422,
0.0306811538,
-0.0034941758,
-0.0021620281,
-0.0113875857,
0.0132322386,
0.0182247628,
0.0301426835,
-0.0193263367,
-0.0188728198,
0.0218396839,
-0.0143107474,
-0.0017081696,
0.0070146676,
-0.0228477456,
0.0001491473,
-0.0553039722,
0.0123139573,
0.0275542624,
-0.0163474344,
0.0369113125,
0.0116122076,
-0.0013220969,
0.0093132304,
-0.00320958,
-0.0242018402,
-0.0051649744,
0.0068843951,
0.0079185227,
-0.0218339674,
0.0346063264,
0.0574398525,
0.001575425,
0.0142400777,
0.0021899708,
-0.0383602828,
-0.0017987652,
-0.0093035866,
-0.001725398,
0.0512812659,
-0.0109669846,
-0.0031178561,
-0.0413685478,
-0.0643262938,
0.0431009941,
-0.0698413327,
0.0221356172,
0.0413092598,
-0.0145120546,
0.0826725811,
0.0060456302,
0.0169607177,
-0.0257757213,
-0.0063944422,
0.0272216164,
-0.0354690067,
0.0469887555,
-6.625094977e-33,
0.0253842901,
-0.0235476643,
-0.0316462778,
0.0061003035,
-0.0335812531,
0.057817746,
0.0235443339,
-0.0216653403,
-0.0420285612,
0.062144883,
0.0076712212,
0.0337332338,
-0.0088411281,
0.0349009931,
-0.0755772963,
-0.0021529116,
0.0387078002,
0.0378959104,
-0.0230739992,
0.026677629,
0.0418851972,
0.0219171941,
0.0772335604,
-0.1258174032,
-0.0142853288,
-0.0068129231,
-0.0591891669,
0.0132743903,
0.0044341167,
0.0241469517,
0.0068626627,
0.0203262959,
0.0334177613,
-0.0557677485,
0.0026606712,
0.025935078,
-0.0167002231,
-0.0330975614,
0.0174439084,
-0.0248496067,
0.0376799777,
-0.0393588655,
0.0093637062,
-0.0012364594,
0.0152889946,
-0.0250615571,
0.0148733137,
-0.009030967,
0.0295277871,
-0.0272569843,
-0.056626644,
-0.0039850771,
-0.0047998657,
0.0006001797,
-0.0054574609,
0.0467995852,
0.0171913505,
-0.013038055,
-0.1225553975,
0.0295209754,
-0.0114364922,
-0.0024027845,
0.0221887734,
-0.0552733094,
-0.0681696907,
0.0383400805,
0.0133329742,
0.0247719809,
-0.0387234576,
0.0331688002,
0.0144413812,
0.0410167277,
0.0564418733,
0.0852144212,
0.0282720178,
-0.0782927722,
-0.0833049938,
0.01500862,
0.0213229079,
-0.0130182765,
0.0003374401,
-0.0111892736,
-0.0065535977,
0.0017862628,
-0.027233053,
0.0475685894,
-0.0444961786,
-0.03298847,
-0.0024827437,
0.021827193,
-0.0423951633,
0.0526767969,
0.0195557028,
-0.0777215585,
0.0037415,
0.0194724277,
0.0040585827,
0.0108953584,
0.0081341071,
0.0191164333,
-0.0106672449,
-0.0412245318,
0.0567980744,
0.0145322112,
0.0341673642,
-0.0262883585,
0.0750252828,
0.0135323908,
-0.0138293132,
-0.0167762879,
-0.0006662276,
0.0198465902,
0.0107782762,
-0.0153385093,
-0.0072243353,
0.0076476121,
-0.0252662878,
0.0126353614,
0.0067040701,
-0.0183900632,
-0.0205869433,
0.0577444956,
-0.0077783023,
0.0066673867,
-0.0282639153,
-0.0183052178,
-0.0413608067,
-0.0255799163,
0.007051588,
-0.0825553536,
-0.0165383928,
-0.0250606947,
3.019e-7,
-0.0533835776,
0.013937654,
-0.0526431203,
-0.0160384532,
-0.0037069798,
0.0971225798,
0.0331496745,
0.0393424816,
0.0011834661,
-0.0844987556,
-0.0344789848,
0.0480504036,
0.0274114367,
0.032157097,
-0.0731358379,
-0.0030315174,
0.0328376889,
-0.0470211133,
-0.0410909913,
-0.013536484,
0.0171762332,
0.0712990165,
0.0706419051,
-0.0359761752,
0.0304154698,
-0.0234334022,
0.0194761399,
0.0452867262,
-0.025581751,
0.0179340653,
0.0420310162,
-0.043434184,
-0.0249996576,
0.0713101923,
-0.0377089977,
0.0495449156,
-0.0167586114,
-0.0032458936,
-0.0065739974,
0.0073943092,
-0.0325209647,
-0.0385623351,
0.0589265116,
-0.0232971422,
0.0792365819,
-0.0741690323,
-0.0521504097,
-0.053847637,
-0.0346981399,
0.0070910761,
-0.0085803065,
-0.0022554297,
0.0031162894,
0.0610719658,
0.016705934,
0.0363001004,
-0.0089729978,
-0.0524731465,
0.0322586969,
0.0350418054,
-0.0325740613,
0.0023671556,
-0.0069109127,
-0.0101276189,
0.0884314254,
-0.0195283126,
0.0548401102,
2.39577297e-34,
-0.0024878611,
-0.0089173205,
0.0278270654,
0.0071182442,
0.042509228,
0.0134079382,
-0.0003775935,
0.0085285781,
-0.0150925312,
-0.0135902483,
0.0161228068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00969v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00969v7 | CryCeleb: A Speaker Verification Dataset Based on Infant Cry Sounds | 2023-05-01T17:56:32 | 2024-03-21T17:52:22 | David Budaghyan, Charles C. Onu, Arsenii Gorin, Cem Subakan, Doina Precup | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper describes the Ubenwa CryCeleb dataset - a labeled collection of
infant cries - and the accompanying CryCeleb 2023 task, which is a public
speaker verification challenge based on cry sounds. We released more than 6
hours of manually segmented cry sounds from 786 newborns for academic use,
aiming to encourage research in infant cry analysis. The inaugural public
competition attracted 59 participants, 11 of whom improved the baseline
performance. The top-performing system achieved a significant improvement
scoring 25.8% equal error rate, which is still far from the performance of
state-of-the-art adult speaker verification systems. Therefore, we believe
there is room for further research on this dataset, potentially extending
beyond the verification task. | [
-0.0054280637,
0.0836842731,
-0.020942362,
0.0215708129,
-0.000597426,
0.0337374024,
0.0626925826,
-0.0195383169,
-0.0404876657,
0.0200989209,
-0.0118574481,
-0.0784794912,
0.0549117066,
-0.0017440348,
0.0057839439,
-0.0878761038,
-0.012204282,
0.000754482,
0.0658387989,
-0.0022700168,
0.0323113613,
0.0129997097,
-0.0531505384,
0.0529299006,
-0.0761645958,
0.0042253886,
0.0055483142,
0.0219688527,
0.0417125188,
-0.0305184945,
0.0263241939,
0.0251850877,
0.0136778289,
0.0297754593,
0.0000015388,
-0.0296996012,
-0.0365184546,
-0.004414679,
-0.0538140498,
-0.0439300574,
0.0140356617,
0.0036904914,
-0.0121486122,
-0.000750224,
0.0004158059,
-0.021060396,
0.0551208593,
0.0189619903,
0.0362838358,
0.0346401855,
0.0028802855,
0.0027177127,
0.0138690742,
0.0202070344,
0.0415042005,
-0.0179989412,
0.0045340452,
-0.0328009538,
0.0314160436,
-0.1208759844,
0.0243882257,
0.0420631059,
-0.0136070196,
0.0187820885,
0.0153592471,
-0.015117703,
-0.0711812302,
-0.0822906271,
-0.005287474,
0.0628146082,
0.0119182616,
-0.0034499695,
0.0232005492,
0.0362980776,
-0.0418841541,
-0.0159019828,
-0.0088127721,
0.0200076234,
-0.0245832559,
-0.0418611765,
-0.0548415557,
0.0410882235,
0.0096248118,
-0.0218470339,
0.0442099795,
0.0115242144,
-0.0354605727,
-0.0388199203,
0.0528859496,
-0.0052660434,
0.0090456186,
0.0042842017,
0.0337829478,
-0.0136131467,
-0.015611941,
-0.0229429957,
-0.0406699255,
-0.0539680123,
-0.0192961358,
0.0206109341,
0.0126886601,
-0.0295802988,
-0.0748484731,
0.0058054575,
0.0076418831,
0.0155210625,
0.0484953597,
-0.0806019381,
-0.0285814982,
-0.0047292002,
-0.0078913309,
0.0307874605,
0.0130308121,
-0.0122512402,
0.0527088344,
0.0107735991,
-0.073672004,
-0.0406586304,
-0.0919563696,
0.017319357,
-0.0217230506,
0.0387769453,
0.0181540642,
0.0094961831,
0.0313630514,
-0.0112180365,
0.0112465592,
0.0387786105,
-0.0470019281,
-0.0652941018,
-0.0124864634,
0.0063809534,
0.0659205914,
0.0591509268,
0.0629094914,
-0.0142478067,
0.0294359792,
-0.0109661715,
0.0169324297,
0.0133614726,
-0.0175512992,
-0.081788756,
-0.0030636822,
-0.0477468856,
0.0074488227,
-0.0251269303,
-0.0031937202,
-0.0385768376,
-0.0153136123,
-0.0394143462,
0.0327467173,
0.0304277334,
0.020809615,
0.0291482583,
0.0222394504,
0.0437017195,
0.0320642143,
0.0171229038,
0.0100259101,
-0.0580911748,
0.054927133,
-0.0445000418,
0.0431554951,
0.0619632453,
0.009279307,
-0.024101397,
0.0062720771,
-0.0195245538,
-0.01460806,
0.0201181937,
0.016353894,
-0.0140794022,
0.0058067469,
-0.0610991754,
0.0306417998,
0.1171056107,
-0.0304119233,
-0.0356457606,
0.0167805124,
-0.0105930604,
0.0508301221,
-0.0505987853,
-0.0041908347,
-0.0313331299,
-0.0058693471,
-0.0588006638,
0.0387600213,
0.0287872609,
-0.0482149497,
0.0196198393,
-0.0261929948,
-0.0282349885,
-0.0205556694,
0.029412305,
-0.0272595938,
-0.0158529989,
0.0158045702,
0.0339765176,
0.0067424322,
-0.0464486629,
-0.0232503675,
-0.0446507111,
0.0081877261,
0.0061877319,
-0.0050707837,
-0.0264045279,
0.0169819947,
-0.0321578644,
0.0085662054,
0.0086516878,
-0.01971782,
-0.0156995058,
0.0408455841,
-0.016677212,
-0.0223086011,
0.0710518807,
0.0125521105,
0.0132490369,
0.0485221893,
0.0116301943,
0.0086212838,
-0.0215436257,
0.0290446114,
-0.0069939652,
-0.0038135992,
-0.0168029312,
0.0170939937,
0.028654946,
0.0649199784,
0.0369258672,
-0.002131426,
-0.0309220552,
0.0278088469,
0.0081664203,
0.0445348397,
0.0272545908,
0.0167051759,
-0.0023044378,
0.043938119,
-0.0463169925,
-0.0540008023,
0.0772524178,
0.0002520433,
-0.0225314107,
0.0597380549,
-0.0537897199,
0.0229016133,
0.0125248618,
0.0200968571,
-0.0441452339,
-0.0004160577,
0.0383461304,
-0.0330525674,
0.0331431292,
0.028292425,
-0.0293842163,
-0.040682029,
0.0078174574,
-0.0873336047,
-0.0238781665,
-0.0360243544,
-0.0190608315,
0.0606037378,
-0.0240195524,
-0.0153475543,
-0.0627272129,
-0.0019298139,
-0.0578870699,
0.0037339642,
0.0013748403,
-0.0022427673,
-0.0114156548,
-0.030394312,
-0.0287823025,
-0.0044603813,
-0.0371834375,
0.0104730278,
-0.0088195903,
-0.005434487,
-0.0490362458,
-0.0756551102,
-0.0656481534,
-0.0178837087,
-0.0067386618,
-0.0305509344,
0.0228265245,
-0.0002490909,
-0.0018807513,
0.0149917137,
-0.0258498304,
-0.0310697071,
0.003655334,
-0.004346685,
0.0409900658,
0.0286056343,
0.0275406428,
0.035139963,
0.0310095903,
0.0013911853,
0.0107205547,
-0.0415857695,
0.0033759458,
0.0161823332,
-0.0068390598,
0.0097557101,
0.0497337468,
0.021707695,
-0.0378387459,
-0.0514799505,
0.0155827319,
-0.0091626095,
0.0077065355,
0.0210510418,
0.0362010784,
0.0156835318,
-0.0189769268,
-0.0404677056,
-0.0659276992,
-0.0303629544,
-0.0162050445,
0.0014466651,
-0.0514538251,
0.0156478845,
-0.0725546479,
-0.0236008726,
-0.0166137516,
-0.0786277354,
0.0178327728,
0.067545265,
-0.0065749441,
0.0065065073,
0.0499917008,
-0.0007586629,
-0.0014279707,
-0.0180072971,
0.0065429262,
-0.0855950341,
-0.0026110436,
-0.0062093996,
0.0062066601,
0.0101738814,
-0.0325360037,
-0.0452971533,
-0.0246382412,
-0.0505016409,
-0.0301309768,
-0.0348937288,
-0.0767523199,
-0.0497735031,
0.0038473513,
0.0581726506,
-0.0037076508,
0.0020794757,
0.0344038829,
0.0246490315,
0.0531688482,
0.0269843396,
0.0582315512,
0.0148131689,
-0.0084218774,
-0.0380207337,
-0.0021277349,
0.079454653,
0.0359603837,
-0.0238533169,
0.0260357223,
0.0127360402,
0.0246026348,
-0.0036099481,
0.0201074351,
0.0182298906,
-0.047858201,
0.029857289,
0.0491976216,
0.006549445,
-0.0206110831,
-0.0143684577,
0.0242990181,
0.0356981084,
0.0033907087,
-0.0205535721,
-0.005742278,
-0.0219433885,
0.0580028892,
0.06000847,
-0.0336229168,
0.0229689218,
-0.0359195508,
-0.019970648,
0.0697448403,
0.0023797816,
-0.0383402593,
-0.0187396221,
-0.0500044599,
-0.0053609442,
-0.0007859871,
0.0275579393,
0.0079645785,
-0.0339063108,
-0.0337646082,
0.0306402612,
-0.0945395529,
-0.0511281826,
0.0689615533,
-0.0258554947,
0.0786634758,
0.0197730213,
0.0111908177,
-0.0171184707,
-0.0370150432,
0.0000624323,
-0.0116749685,
-0.0484353639,
0.0148574915,
0.0145446053,
0.0164483972,
-0.0169343036,
-0.0106318397,
0.0407912955,
-0.0180180445,
0.0015130121,
0.0273481328,
0.0501941629,
-0.0073108459,
-0.0365837701,
-0.0131927738,
0.0384950191,
0.0023858321,
0.0701966211,
0.0310430098,
-0.0148231331,
-0.0021542974,
0.0433405489,
0.0230045207,
0.0085968263,
-0.043877393,
0.0205204282,
0.0097966548,
-0.0598202385,
-0.0179635137,
0.0085639665,
-0.0212098379,
0.0432997197,
0.0036322069,
0.0061449227,
-0.0155919716,
0.037847355,
-0.0840607509,
0.0933665335,
-0.0008103337,
0.038500987,
-0.0543957166,
-0.0296703186,
0.0213241652,
-0.0269229095,
-0.0159151796,
0.0448541641,
-0.0411987193,
-0.0049166689,
0.0056095314,
-0.0372113921,
0.023612354,
0.0738140568,
-0.0149282264,
-0.0462347306,
0.0866875127,
0.0447769761,
-0.0082159135,
0.0321273245,
0.0470058024,
-0.0318321511,
-0.0118867448,
-0.0111823911,
-0.0135989003,
0.0439381525,
0.0123933097,
-0.050844986,
-0.0082801348,
-0.030604437,
-0.0417405181,
0.0310139842,
0.0448529311,
0.0039664479,
-0.0343849622,
-0.0435476303,
0.0265149195,
0.0230490398,
0.0418410674,
-0.0331232138,
-0.0277135,
0.0120838434,
0.0280535016,
-0.0269970708,
0.0132349543,
-0.0696240887,
-0.0186435636,
0.0043073557,
0.0799506307,
0.0472615622,
0.0425719284,
0.000024413,
-0.0020644849,
0.0083688973,
0.0233983155,
0.019129185,
0.024721412,
0.0183290914,
-0.0293788966,
-0.0331783295,
-0.0246687289,
0.002534183,
0.0316759236,
-0.0182228461,
-0.0127662709,
-0.0262281243,
-0.04292503,
-0.0059305243,
0.0140174003,
0.0326402187,
0.0095564127,
0.0231342353,
-0.0308260676,
-0.0275439192,
-0.0612493865,
-0.0176035948,
-0.0078734206,
-0.0131265884,
-0.0421358272,
0.0403562374,
0.0528055169,
0.0034596098,
0.0402626134,
-0.0455349833,
0.0064913682,
-0.0266116038,
-0.0097792167,
0.0135342376,
-0.0651558191,
-0.0229931977,
-0.0259195585,
-0.0060613104,
-0.023546556,
0.0522597879,
-0.0189625788,
0.0040527373,
0.0426976047,
0.0432626903,
0.0050180233,
-0.0563677438,
-0.0139514226,
0.0270932708,
-0.0377445407,
-0.0087881638,
-0.0476745889,
0.0643656552,
-5.581762926e-33,
0.0412080772,
0.0038753536,
-0.0100404341,
-0.0183209814,
0.0118815033,
0.0569431782,
0.0147100762,
0.0443195254,
0.0419157818,
-0.0229605585,
-0.0027405655,
-0.0094256774,
0.032344535,
-0.0061353585,
-0.0241542105,
-0.0059156311,
0.0849127248,
-0.0248878431,
0.0318198614,
0.0182647556,
0.0153106805,
0.0137304543,
-0.0013958773,
-0.0778277293,
-0.0171938278,
-0.0028208687,
-0.0458729044,
-0.0008467997,
0.0577923171,
0.0458740517,
-0.0283469725,
0.0151723167,
0.0026882021,
0.0223536994,
-0.02101193,
0.0340441763,
-0.0726833865,
0.0165542308,
-0.0504697897,
0.0312355645,
-0.0340901315,
0.0126035167,
0.0730306804,
-0.0001526383,
-0.02518305,
-0.0234164856,
0.0362998545,
-0.0382266343,
0.0626801774,
-0.0675523132,
0.0141300438,
0.0044143726,
0.0030893304,
-0.0311874188,
0.0359038971,
0.0496947281,
-0.0552545451,
-0.0490072034,
-0.0456389263,
0.045186311,
0.006139345,
0.0092062252,
0.0064037247,
0.0040386859,
0.0074776178,
0.0566639863,
0.0996977389,
-0.064996466,
-0.002142993,
0.010804289,
0.0496098585,
0.0457442813,
0.0655406266,
0.0318913646,
0.0113122733,
-0.0257033054,
-0.0514518172,
0.0508922338,
0.0183913242,
-0.0309548788,
0.0042619426,
-0.0333616808,
-0.0373615883,
0.0192210618,
-0.0296688247,
-0.012523924,
-0.0097554252,
0.0247458909,
0.0381230712,
0.0071162162,
-0.0243871659,
-0.0233887322,
0.0094044385,
-0.0254680049,
0.0098170266,
-0.0146315452,
0.0229149051,
0.001539343,
0.032575842,
-0.0122135719,
-0.0035289798,
-0.0636181757,
0.0615801439,
0.0174941216,
0.0837456435,
-0.038977351,
0.0410860218,
0.0608687364,
-0.0755221918,
-0.0146382721,
0.0423453264,
0.0254632812,
0.0302140955,
-0.0203447714,
0.0361075066,
0.0013975821,
0.0134356832,
-0.0139258942,
0.0113091255,
0.0378174894,
-0.0045649423,
0.0407510102,
-0.0653634071,
0.0410161503,
-0.015771294,
0.0047445432,
-0.0224652775,
-0.0356253758,
0.0304932613,
-0.0491524711,
0.0320093706,
-0.026323365,
2.343e-7,
-0.070430927,
0.0337889604,
0.0102223968,
-0.0914119855,
0.0526258573,
0.0215541907,
-0.0370573439,
0.0147679793,
0.0182682052,
-0.0517944358,
0.014599531,
-0.017200809,
0.0972089171,
0.0880798921,
-0.0913458914,
-0.0195608139,
-0.0128638353,
0.0010377433,
-0.0442963876,
0.0490872301,
-0.009001974,
0.0880450979,
0.0355765782,
-0.0674672052,
0.0446650982,
-0.0156687535,
0.0126272207,
-0.0283682346,
0.0378964432,
-0.034239471,
0.0146959694,
-0.0211389046,
0.0533099473,
0.0214614812,
-0.0359620973,
0.0223245658,
0.0031821569,
0.0281027369,
0.0102845049,
-0.0598371848,
-0.0330251306,
0.0668333247,
-0.0338102989,
0.0163262635,
0.0610869639,
0.0450112075,
-0.0270824749,
-0.017352622,
-0.0050608004,
-0.0372985117,
0.0522014014,
-0.0090349019,
0.0259876996,
0.0634262264,
-0.0007216653,
-0.0328878276,
-0.0172864925,
-0.0372990109,
0.0033847715,
0.0453961901,
-0.0558075681,
-0.0637987629,
0.0294694379,
0.0187781341,
0.0032199132,
-0.0179789029,
-0.004617658,
1.312836057e-34,
-0.0177730285,
-0.0186880194,
0.0291017126,
-0.044548519,
0.0143971266,
-0.0128822504,
-0.0156132327,
-0.0020985089,
-0.0006605928,
-0.0073592076,
0.0009100088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00955v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00955v2 | Bridging the Gap: A Survey on Integrating (Human) Feedback for Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-01T17:36:06 | 2023-06-01T01:24:53 | Patrick Fernandes, Aman Madaan, Emmy Liu, António Farinhas, Pedro Henrique Martins, Amanda Bertsch, José G. C. de Souza, Shuyan Zhou, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Many recent advances in natural language generation have been fueled by
training large language models on internet-scale data. However, this paradigm
can lead to models that generate toxic, inaccurate, and unhelpful content, and
automatic evaluation metrics often fail to identify these behaviors. As models
become more capable, human feedback is an invaluable signal for evaluating and
improving models. This survey aims to provide an overview of the recent
research that has leveraged human feedback to improve natural language
generation. First, we introduce an encompassing formalization of feedback, and
identify and organize existing research into a taxonomy following this
formalization. Next, we discuss how feedback can be described by its format and
objective, and cover the two approaches proposed to use feedback (either for
training or decoding): directly using the feedback or training feedback models.
We also discuss existing datasets for human-feedback data collection, and
concerns surrounding feedback collection. Finally, we provide an overview of
the nascent field of AI feedback, which exploits large language models to make
judgments based on a set of principles and minimize the need for human
intervention. | [
0.0735192522,
0.0587920956,
-0.0250145607,
-0.0172501765,
-0.0258346833,
-0.0057335212,
-0.0239544269,
-0.0147909112,
0.0346427374,
-0.0677347407,
-0.0140813114,
-0.0532744229,
0.0244103316,
0.0352007225,
0.0569992959,
-0.0666923374,
0.013188187,
0.014265175,
-0.002917638,
0.0192464218,
0.0170285776,
0.0243595801,
-0.0026232607,
0.0643433481,
-0.0232224911,
0.0002381629,
-0.0243772268,
-0.0005849067,
-0.0002764545,
-0.0308883023,
0.0152259031,
0.0487579219,
0.0112535879,
0.0158166755,
0.0000018969,
-0.033851333,
0.0364192165,
-0.0108053796,
0.0049026944,
0.013172227,
0.0441370644,
-0.0126353893,
0.0001839164,
0.0250797607,
-0.0163490474,
0.0029780366,
0.0446937904,
0.0080063371,
0.0972970054,
0.0517330803,
0.0033147179,
0.0216678232,
0.0031364521,
0.0079116598,
0.0109098786,
0.0587431826,
-0.0047877934,
0.0044516185,
0.0171563644,
-0.0092907734,
0.0124229705,
0.0078668343,
0.0223198906,
-0.0474059694,
0.0232481789,
0.0404198691,
0.0013537961,
-0.0394948609,
-0.021617759,
0.056794636,
0.0454186499,
-0.0374144167,
-0.0253789201,
-0.0156478882,
0.0153638497,
-0.0167103019,
-0.0125728082,
0.0655251294,
-0.0110055134,
-0.003257222,
0.0067082057,
-0.006187845,
0.0041399077,
0.0502211489,
0.0230249185,
0.0182628129,
0.0161943417,
-0.0311324317,
0.0020730491,
0.0539093576,
-0.0413822979,
-0.0726052225,
0.0209643077,
0.0217149053,
-0.0873407349,
-0.001590573,
-0.0841974989,
-0.0271867868,
0.0247422699,
-0.0373709202,
0.0605680458,
0.0020030818,
-0.0091642793,
-0.0229866654,
0.027024392,
0.0428980105,
0.0048624347,
-0.0002398731,
-0.0368206054,
0.0395601466,
-0.047638692,
-0.0244348869,
-0.0256799366,
0.0524537712,
0.019792147,
-0.0046905582,
-0.0576851554,
0.0062363199,
-0.0256418455,
0.0193256103,
0.0021263678,
0.0660546869,
-0.0503863469,
0.0253771804,
-0.0417823382,
0.0084251342,
-0.0509041436,
0.0110189198,
0.0669554025,
-0.0196532868,
-0.004686323,
0.0362013504,
-0.0141596468,
0.0038523108,
-0.0088234358,
0.0530524924,
-0.0010161435,
-0.0075026685,
-0.0203168448,
-0.0805498362,
-0.0298114028,
-0.0378914326,
-0.0458256304,
-0.038170401,
-0.0162022375,
-0.0224788431,
-0.0231420863,
-0.0029158893,
0.0104432488,
0.0448923782,
-0.0216607079,
0.0396077074,
-0.071306847,
0.0026112646,
0.0385207348,
-0.0175424293,
0.0260830801,
0.0266200099,
0.0599177033,
0.0550600253,
0.0345674343,
0.0199691132,
0.0199330393,
-0.0123706255,
0.0280471016,
-0.0130891893,
-0.0163183827,
-0.014331162,
-0.0786457062,
0.0630777627,
0.0051919906,
0.0857676342,
-0.0216135606,
0.0462210737,
0.0810901374,
0.0143195754,
-0.0258801766,
0.0368114375,
0.0658631399,
0.049917385,
-0.0170845129,
0.033450108,
-0.0125026712,
0.0018041183,
-0.0219600331,
0.0240868088,
0.0331381112,
-0.0037862745,
0.0002095481,
-0.0919861719,
-0.0196166672,
0.0154178021,
0.0259894598,
0.0212506186,
0.0156446323,
0.048940558,
-0.0406133905,
0.0089885844,
0.0328306258,
-0.0774361566,
0.0586241484,
-0.0396194011,
0.0625839606,
0.1012869924,
0.0690471232,
0.0388188399,
-0.0050648586,
-0.0116423508,
-0.0138119701,
0.0447691157,
0.0368485786,
-0.0409107432,
-0.0484857894,
-0.0175779387,
0.0098883361,
0.0233978815,
0.0262108501,
0.0103197247,
0.0163376071,
-0.0279690903,
0.0178949423,
0.0217648465,
-0.097888045,
0.0364102535,
0.023976706,
-0.0179713015,
0.0324280113,
-0.00151846,
0.0142959664,
0.0511034392,
-0.0290111545,
0.029642472,
0.0168041494,
0.0037487014,
-0.0482294559,
0.033893127,
-0.0220583137,
-0.0345550701,
-0.0032208469,
-0.0075170854,
0.0115655065,
0.0395416729,
-0.0129763354,
-0.0256555937,
0.0219288208,
-0.0794971436,
0.0232973341,
-0.0388929285,
0.0247013215,
0.0196093284,
-0.0184273496,
-0.0386841111,
0.0312961489,
0.0030895816,
-0.005879961,
0.0131035671,
0.0129358117,
0.005859843,
-0.0309347343,
-0.0231005661,
0.0259268284,
-0.0011637922,
0.021459261,
0.0725032613,
0.0360029712,
-0.0669336244,
0.0029318514,
-0.0810362026,
-0.0086081279,
-0.0183773935,
0.0293953121,
0.0344778523,
-0.0093575884,
0.010765655,
0.0184653252,
-0.0495931245,
-0.0345971361,
0.0420917198,
0.006570512,
0.074179925,
-0.004132092,
-0.0030698171,
-0.0539161712,
0.0026505087,
-0.0210064836,
0.0041644075,
0.0550395362,
-0.007580495,
-0.0715575293,
0.025644768,
-0.01323877,
-0.0291907638,
0.044166524,
-0.0556930676,
0.0350919329,
0.0234340131,
0.0207248535,
0.0404078811,
0.0256526265,
0.0521718152,
0.035168495,
0.0017272964,
-0.0411787629,
-0.0171439797,
-0.0371717438,
-0.0257337894,
0.0315180942,
-0.0128527144,
0.0413005166,
0.0589237213,
0.0601199307,
-0.005188542,
-0.0743930414,
0.0301554352,
-0.0548733622,
-0.0511504561,
-0.0313431956,
-0.0589516051,
-0.0188357178,
0.0287506972,
-0.0174781792,
-0.0482392833,
0.0939900801,
-0.0009687835,
0.0166770071,
-0.0363310538,
0.0117473565,
-0.0219318699,
0.0167291313,
0.0020297654,
0.0204030871,
0.0402781181,
-0.0243219007,
-0.011720553,
-0.0058783358,
0.0155101921,
-0.0267231632,
0.0143518578,
-0.0697867721,
-0.004208901,
0.0420778245,
-0.041681096,
-0.0514201783,
-0.0402661264,
-0.0043898136,
-0.0066209822,
0.0408049151,
-0.0296581928,
0.0163703132,
-0.0062265815,
0.0067549525,
-0.0273404736,
-0.0236482248,
-0.0392733924,
0.0097428802,
0.0222816169,
0.0571963377,
-0.0037370762,
0.0188353695,
-0.0238866732,
-0.019039521,
0.0350039527,
0.0122072604,
0.0370768681,
-0.0166550577,
0.0129451789,
0.0194698889,
-0.0330675356,
-0.0013233352,
0.0445170067,
0.0361650512,
-0.056126792,
-0.0347578153,
0.1002437994,
0.0584355555,
-0.0294223335,
0.0280698407,
0.0178028103,
0.0463313051,
-0.006624619,
0.0171832629,
-0.0601692945,
-0.0152175538,
-0.0118305208,
0.0435738228,
-0.0357582532,
-0.0072739413,
-0.0132084088,
-0.1325315535,
0.039069999,
0.0286610182,
0.0111330263,
-0.0370338,
-0.0007485411,
-0.0472022556,
0.0017512671,
-0.0248932987,
0.011284953,
0.0058935047,
0.0247797929,
0.0402994044,
-0.0316886231,
-0.0506261736,
-0.0204224661,
-0.0389461294,
0.0561298318,
0.0790463537,
0.0421207696,
0.015919406,
-0.0081634978,
0.0109314537,
-0.0020155353,
0.0084391506,
-0.0208631475,
0.0419408306,
-0.017333081,
0.0076430729,
-0.0672518089,
0.032716807,
-0.025675239,
-0.0040981341,
0.0181688517,
0.0308854599,
-0.0280982908,
-0.004394955,
-0.0303571448,
0.0402972624,
0.0328779109,
0.0529936478,
0.0326506644,
-0.0592770018,
-0.0083742617,
-0.0086816419,
0.0065517118,
-0.0709659383,
-0.0460994877,
0.0055577061,
0.0060562203,
0.0013872262,
-0.1387234181,
-0.0804183781,
0.0031302408,
-0.001598905,
0.0343563408,
-0.038079273,
0.012147693,
-0.0172649976,
-0.0011186645,
0.0151431644,
0.014867791,
0.0049595535,
-0.0346818827,
-0.0550427288,
0.004802546,
-0.0386434197,
0.0056547038,
0.0453082025,
-0.0792923048,
-0.0658374801,
-0.0179895144,
0.0534173921,
0.0166307073,
0.0540654399,
-0.0198397748,
-0.0642013028,
0.0047384938,
0.0234131254,
-0.0374231189,
-0.0047538462,
-0.0121290851,
0.0340037644,
-0.0037915448,
0.025160769,
-0.0198609624,
-0.0036262521,
-0.0349736623,
0.0210196134,
-0.0034809622,
-0.0212350767,
0.0753391832,
0.0334584862,
0.0268810429,
-0.0714307278,
-0.0290247705,
-0.0457937792,
-0.0259586815,
-0.0538912229,
-0.0683808848,
-0.0538816899,
0.0064850114,
-0.0018538843,
-0.0178915169,
-0.0516839661,
-0.0279403199,
-0.0605837218,
0.0598441921,
-0.0268020127,
-0.0106101856,
-0.0163899157,
0.0172603913,
0.0215961095,
0.0074537704,
-0.0297786463,
-0.0056455941,
-0.0194422379,
0.0354041904,
-0.0024790755,
0.0486531183,
0.0128555726,
-0.0199920051,
0.0284846108,
0.028154416,
-0.0220171567,
0.0000367591,
-0.0623466,
0.0129302368,
0.0514548384,
0.0069651664,
0.0932798162,
-0.0329747796,
0.0085317288,
0.0052164975,
0.0601263903,
-0.0297683142,
-0.056803409,
0.0056848284,
0.0062776548,
-0.0327238292,
-0.0303410385,
0.0544031225,
-0.005186893,
0.0207180586,
-0.0233926475,
-0.0212633647,
-0.0380849391,
-0.007654448,
0.0005813898,
-0.006462425,
-0.0082896128,
0.0216920599,
-0.0438860133,
-0.0453911647,
-0.0237370636,
0.0482833982,
0.0568368547,
-0.0018063617,
0.0545511916,
0.0424761698,
-0.0385207981,
-0.0075025395,
-0.062269751,
0.0113352044,
-0.0475627072,
0.000544418,
-0.0533132479,
-5.876832946e-33,
-0.0448923744,
-0.0679024756,
0.0062485337,
0.0166164525,
-0.062213324,
-0.051661931,
-0.0417851731,
0.0267664529,
0.0603031106,
0.023170298,
0.0051430189,
-0.0200172216,
-0.0020172743,
0.0241288524,
0.0594534464,
-0.0064188354,
0.0708774477,
-0.008300581,
-0.0582253709,
0.0392519049,
0.0175612364,
-0.0023440709,
0.0280334372,
-0.0435291268,
0.0686543733,
-0.0181216337,
-0.0610552803,
0.0010106657,
-0.0094026281,
0.0454205573,
-0.0120411571,
0.0735263601,
0.024487013,
0.0082688639,
-0.0144069744,
0.0324205756,
-0.0217739269,
-0.0150663694,
0.0011373566,
0.000760893,
-0.0454775915,
-0.0247183274,
0.0289863572,
-0.0282181222,
-0.0199970193,
0.0525477976,
0.0323584639,
-0.0171202812,
0.0019562941,
-0.0086503131,
-0.0602916926,
0.0063756355,
-0.0290190242,
-0.0269889366,
-0.0333390795,
0.1043552011,
-0.0326713957,
-0.0388779528,
-0.0282027554,
0.0591454878,
0.0493262634,
0.0278754886,
0.0604001656,
0.0038341202,
-0.0164334327,
0.0457141623,
0.0087624546,
0.0220023934,
-0.0089583239,
0.0248935595,
0.0081832884,
-0.0006887398,
0.0339754708,
0.0806966498,
0.0024892509,
-0.0360426567,
0.0001426878,
0.0278878659,
-0.0361633636,
0.0252925102,
0.0066009876,
-0.0390191041,
-0.0601870008,
-0.0456554554,
-0.0230161492,
-0.0387095958,
-0.0123714674,
-0.0421096981,
0.0418572612,
0.0220707115,
-0.0309849381,
-0.0342481285,
-0.0347106084,
-0.0206532311,
-0.0001174935,
-0.0247987099,
-0.0461599529,
0.004200412,
-0.0259791985,
-0.0322850235,
-0.0494529344,
0.0058376058,
0.0150922351,
0.0171972923,
0.013091594,
0.006269075,
0.0237970781,
0.0395373031,
-0.0316291489,
0.0299739782,
-0.0236695316,
0.045734819,
0.0045564193,
-0.0391322188,
0.0120786149,
0.0151865296,
-0.0479975194,
0.0791763812,
-0.0128670912,
0.003001279,
-0.0326734073,
-0.0026825941,
0.0182606336,
0.0141677065,
-0.0499734282,
0.0050714812,
-0.0072735311,
0.0125894267,
0.0434354618,
-0.0279459357,
-0.0306031927,
-0.0269880667,
2.511e-7,
-0.0049696257,
0.0833726227,
0.0310969967,
0.0166901425,
-0.0198957305,
0.0418856889,
0.0126365498,
0.0242134444,
0.019107841,
0.0045166444,
0.015068369,
-0.0176338144,
0.0495031476,
0.0129277641,
-0.0592257753,
-0.010493245,
-0.0621731877,
-0.0017152068,
-0.0400307886,
-0.0435346439,
0.1095794812,
0.0266505182,
0.0048527322,
-0.0112477345,
0.0115709435,
-0.0037352392,
0.0537468381,
-0.0242420845,
-0.0546348505,
-0.0058447239,
0.0360252,
0.0069267275,
-0.0124118952,
0.0221456233,
-0.0181660857,
-0.0369746946,
-0.0269510876,
0.0124188317,
0.0077489684,
-0.0151273161,
-0.0081986394,
0.0159658547,
0.0206517894,
-0.0367071219,
0.0203254316,
-0.0595559366,
-0.0249353182,
-0.0319008492,
0.0267010797,
-0.0360826179,
0.0212405045,
-0.065853402,
-0.0405128598,
0.0081738252,
0.0096999221,
0.0404018983,
0.0105709238,
-0.019823635,
-0.0272830557,
-0.0118882125,
-0.029544767,
-0.0185219608,
-0.0089596845,
-0.0041589253,
-0.0194223356,
-0.0478612743,
-0.0034514933,
2.184327939e-34,
0.0376504548,
-0.007693714,
0.0492784306,
0.0063571511,
0.056883961,
0.0423552841,
0.0151388496,
-0.0005906005,
0.04881173,
-0.0281559303,
-0.0423612036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00948v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00948v2 | Large Linguistic Models: Analyzing theoretical linguistic abilities of LLMs | 2023-05-01T17:09:33 | 2023-08-21T16:52:29 | Gašper Beguš, Maksymilian Dąbkowski, Ryan Rhodes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The performance of large language models (LLMs) has recently improved to the
point where the models can perform well on many language tasks. We show here
that for the first time, the models can also generate coherent and valid formal
analyses of linguistic data and illustrate the vast potential of large language
models for analyses of their metalinguistic abilities. LLMs are primarily
trained on language data in the form of text; analyzing and evaluating their
metalinguistic abilities improves our understanding of their general
capabilities and sheds new light on theoretical models in linguistics. In this
paper, we probe into GPT-4's metalinguistic capabilities by focusing on three
subfields of formal linguistics: syntax, phonology, and semantics. We outline a
research program for metalinguistic analyses of large language models, propose
experimental designs, provide general guidelines, discuss limitations, and
offer future directions for this line of research. This line of inquiry also
exemplifies behavioral interpretability of deep learning, where models'
representations are accessed by explicit prompting rather than internal
representations. | [
0.024177039,
0.0681128502,
-0.037347354,
0.0825985298,
-0.0433936566,
0.0230604392,
-0.0214603767,
0.0080389185,
-0.0292664636,
-0.0288436618,
-0.0487734377,
-0.0221937634,
-0.0245924629,
0.0012596081,
0.0406295024,
-0.033192154,
0.0357552916,
-0.0257230885,
0.0463303998,
0.0038889418,
0.0117580928,
0.0017035743,
0.0091628451,
0.0353985168,
-0.0179360155,
-0.0234557241,
0.0101497434,
-0.0015599442,
-0.0113003291,
-0.0166094005,
-0.0005588987,
0.0200646482,
0.0078940624,
0.0828367695,
0.0000016414,
-0.0502864197,
0.009562064,
0.0021620647,
-0.0212859586,
0.0267326403,
0.0266798567,
-0.070036374,
-0.021510832,
-0.0103133256,
-0.0522650331,
-0.0485435799,
0.0614409745,
0.060209997,
0.0385818966,
0.0387404151,
-0.0216510203,
-0.0562119558,
0.0594054796,
-0.0357146114,
-0.0418939367,
-0.0081108436,
0.0338658057,
0.0015842635,
-0.0059093158,
0.0405663885,
-0.0205692314,
0.0383123271,
0.0399709605,
0.0428348929,
-0.0372001603,
0.0123024937,
-0.0600632243,
-0.0116475709,
-0.0102098454,
0.0501712151,
0.0140140625,
-0.0351892672,
-0.0163274352,
-0.0125023704,
-0.0100408606,
-0.0103365043,
-0.0292337965,
0.0179888085,
0.0261343904,
0.0371316969,
0.0405859686,
0.0206536148,
0.0566201732,
0.0557599925,
-0.0341452695,
0.1088602096,
0.0047607529,
-0.0364427939,
0.0192526318,
0.0176770948,
-0.0371667854,
-0.0073398217,
0.0165770352,
0.0162729919,
0.0079248846,
0.0399104208,
0.0083722165,
0.0137482723,
0.0532123484,
-0.0327797979,
0.0683629587,
0.0153047731,
-0.0489138588,
0.0521459319,
-0.0188277531,
0.0170862488,
-0.0472046584,
0.0182353016,
-0.0214279294,
-0.0180633608,
-0.053047508,
-0.0567732751,
-0.0433768928,
0.023153374,
0.0036391302,
-0.0317475982,
-0.0228893235,
-0.0007432791,
-0.0044475365,
0.0051762904,
-0.0074314098,
-0.0040445761,
-0.0813564137,
0.0020720994,
-0.0230390057,
0.0137249222,
-0.0167743359,
0.0138642304,
-0.0249286518,
-0.0649201125,
-0.0106091853,
0.016164219,
-0.0183536541,
-0.0495518222,
0.0071476307,
0.0772250593,
0.0248536188,
-0.0144252479,
-0.0091765402,
-0.0019094435,
-0.0545807183,
-0.0584154129,
-0.0066891639,
-0.034815304,
-0.0117607443,
-0.0028700081,
0.0079321656,
-0.0440027565,
0.0041398047,
-0.0092070168,
-0.0055510574,
0.0915589929,
0.0153564494,
-0.0333207548,
-0.0126431426,
-0.0022909245,
0.0187136251,
0.0533284917,
0.0648112893,
0.0132411281,
0.027551733,
-0.0172822885,
-0.0233264398,
0.0542136542,
-0.010592767,
0.0161955375,
-0.0424249955,
-0.0133735221,
-0.0049178889,
0.0440592431,
-0.015481337,
0.079145059,
-0.0005246769,
-0.0422674268,
0.0634713545,
0.0496968403,
0.0292875282,
0.058363758,
0.0839870572,
0.0083730286,
0.0155263087,
0.0245720278,
-0.0496067181,
-0.0449394621,
-0.0314191245,
0.0152569832,
-0.0137715219,
-0.01072005,
-0.0028431048,
-0.0567179397,
-0.0112407636,
-0.0138843535,
0.0137371346,
-0.009965024,
0.0650167242,
0.0193695612,
-0.0211923625,
0.0295121185,
0.0281376317,
-0.0398203619,
-0.0127374921,
-0.0575422756,
0.006322572,
0.0262235533,
0.0208755769,
-0.0392856114,
-0.035761632,
-0.0050418694,
-0.013353264,
0.0657253712,
0.0150352996,
0.0199420806,
0.0303647481,
-0.0283845011,
0.0177642498,
-0.040874321,
0.0449244007,
0.0229645967,
-0.0268580429,
-0.0065467642,
0.0153074097,
-0.0404249839,
-0.0376581587,
0.0343384147,
0.0156593453,
-0.0267117955,
0.0127161192,
0.0039561978,
0.0457569025,
0.0346764587,
0.0026142262,
0.015617786,
0.0410893932,
-0.0534921885,
-0.0011545796,
0.0058287564,
-0.0604776591,
-0.0012071314,
0.0372817479,
-0.0354242958,
-0.0022914412,
0.0399640165,
-0.0187465064,
-0.0513019115,
0.0258216765,
-0.0601142608,
0.0592061803,
-0.0531933755,
-0.023791993,
-0.0049171601,
0.0540746637,
-0.0323508307,
0.0518888608,
0.0124257104,
-0.0089148348,
-0.0344718844,
0.0308455601,
0.0255662166,
-0.0654360875,
-0.0524458177,
0.0221512634,
0.0129498411,
0.0111715468,
-0.0061152475,
-0.00147698,
-0.0419279858,
-0.0352379419,
-0.0992163494,
-0.0005161753,
-0.0289591253,
0.008055809,
0.0158825014,
-0.0254185852,
-0.011399338,
0.000269697,
-0.0102435779,
-0.0426124111,
0.013644129,
0.0225298237,
0.0619465709,
0.010961799,
-0.0285505187,
-0.037581481,
-0.0326431431,
-0.0482502766,
0.0320646837,
0.0011634431,
0.0149798188,
-0.0346718505,
-0.0004458227,
-0.0415441692,
0.0029341024,
-0.0080312463,
-0.0524233989,
0.021255007,
-0.0187342223,
0.0212172177,
0.0208911914,
-0.0094106011,
0.1078943461,
0.0313755088,
-0.0134529453,
-0.030366417,
-0.0073513337,
-0.032865297,
-0.0146307191,
-0.041713804,
-0.0199182332,
-0.0160818547,
0.0888652653,
0.0141199846,
-0.0116207562,
-0.0529967807,
0.0421333164,
-0.0306337364,
-0.0310513824,
0.021381015,
0.0058242208,
-0.0420839414,
0.0444070324,
-0.0130521739,
-0.0360872447,
0.0611736588,
-0.0369647406,
-0.0270027313,
-0.0232642572,
-0.0372252315,
-0.0556370951,
0.0905869678,
0.0217018388,
-0.0148532856,
0.0424417406,
-0.0306030009,
-0.01524569,
-0.0357867517,
0.0204085074,
-0.0246072114,
0.070926249,
-0.0555353239,
0.0054722717,
0.0180584211,
-0.0172323994,
-0.0032231298,
-0.0572243184,
-0.0308533646,
0.049395144,
-0.042049475,
-0.0011009576,
0.0171684232,
0.023042284,
0.0065611121,
-0.0062334831,
-0.0012697566,
0.0083482722,
-0.0673861951,
0.0242904592,
0.0458993539,
0.0298220757,
-0.0089579113,
-0.0138689689,
0.0001093383,
0.0187023841,
0.0015192704,
0.044168897,
-0.1000938341,
0.024387734,
0.0137946941,
-0.0062563587,
-0.0547991879,
-0.0212427136,
0.0038366094,
-0.0639430955,
0.0181362331,
0.1004715413,
0.0287308488,
-0.0485656038,
0.0425942913,
0.0314409994,
0.0327229463,
-0.0089827953,
-0.0096317073,
-0.0615345798,
-0.0272892229,
0.0006781564,
-0.0229347348,
-0.0241311379,
-0.0204623602,
-0.0136499126,
-0.1086773351,
0.0278917588,
-0.0113086896,
-0.0423218086,
-0.0126224849,
-0.0079505201,
0.0118626468,
-0.0149365477,
0.0275428817,
-0.0078800302,
-0.004964299,
-0.0215078257,
0.0339443572,
-0.024359826,
-0.0749248713,
0.0367869735,
-0.005722607,
0.0197919309,
0.0730747879,
0.0529400334,
-0.0721881464,
-0.0287848711,
0.0048804455,
-0.0438729227,
-0.0189721603,
-0.0095575601,
0.0266561694,
0.015658075,
-0.0287674405,
-0.0065960372,
0.0282553844,
-0.0319026336,
0.0185048375,
-0.0038580247,
0.0906139985,
-0.0224737208,
-0.0285686851,
0.0099555394,
-0.0001286597,
0.0082909968,
0.0542658903,
0.0473966375,
-0.0252191313,
-0.058848314,
-0.0429461785,
0.010083288,
-0.0041463012,
-0.0559493862,
-0.0078819646,
0.0415349603,
-0.0113307377,
-0.0438786559,
-0.0620319247,
-0.0063010389,
-0.0003183972,
0.0112023102,
0.0189196281,
-0.0101184826,
0.0003553187,
-0.0168885197,
0.0837396011,
-0.023054501,
0.0088979695,
-0.0510573015,
-0.0279197078,
0.0810256675,
-0.0146810347,
-0.0467836931,
0.0369349942,
-0.0534266941,
-0.0592498742,
0.0112166638,
0.0246590655,
0.0289712902,
0.0260565933,
-0.0279838461,
-0.0586715005,
0.0226382408,
0.0016357908,
-0.0509326905,
0.0234007705,
0.0823790431,
-0.0015453506,
0.0071668299,
0.0476938225,
0.0051590246,
0.0630872473,
0.013114294,
0.0393477418,
-0.0313700475,
-0.0224876571,
0.0428986102,
0.0079169208,
0.0626992062,
0.0180844124,
-0.0320192985,
0.0005792037,
0.006595925,
0.0051223543,
-0.0119044455,
-0.052216921,
0.0209417064,
0.0654294118,
-0.002859035,
-0.0600892119,
-0.0684088618,
-0.0061289975,
0.0199741013,
-0.0041995565,
0.021424694,
0.0167796127,
-0.0090465154,
0.0012977648,
0.0178141538,
-0.0327304378,
0.0541382395,
-0.0237665083,
0.0278426129,
-0.0042925267,
0.0230338145,
0.0412842706,
0.0162980929,
0.0009609867,
0.0441516824,
-0.059268482,
-0.0237006955,
0.0223105196,
-0.004235805,
0.0430652127,
-0.0365861543,
0.0561334677,
-0.0489681736,
-0.0030807338,
-0.0283435937,
0.0388412848,
0.012524928,
-0.0193612836,
0.0380076617,
0.0376384109,
-0.0322406553,
0.0162072983,
0.0354815684,
0.0096777864,
0.0135058025,
0.0387938246,
0.0002704055,
-0.0445506759,
-0.0470105335,
0.0171724185,
0.0041189701,
0.0024257211,
0.0462161079,
-0.0491864122,
-0.0927262679,
0.0135754813,
0.0042501562,
0.0082576452,
-0.0551056452,
0.0299009103,
0.0788901001,
-0.0103484504,
0.0052381433,
-0.0301536079,
-0.0165178664,
0.0234827474,
0.009032975,
-0.0377144031,
-5.682921194e-33,
-0.0351900756,
-0.0226377267,
-0.0107918177,
0.023680713,
-0.020001201,
-0.011304765,
-0.044399865,
0.0013130559,
-0.0198326111,
0.0285544749,
-0.0089318817,
0.0250542685,
0.0253802855,
0.0379125141,
0.0026731009,
-0.0268125497,
0.0074594989,
0.0051186159,
0.0302696992,
0.0237319265,
0.0070087947,
0.0366186984,
0.0663142055,
-0.0343253128,
0.0477605388,
0.00576131,
-0.0126420129,
0.0000334246,
-0.0654352531,
0.0873908401,
-0.0570592247,
0.0490454808,
0.0285003129,
-0.023935698,
0.0046385052,
0.0051990626,
-0.0616813339,
-0.0305111054,
0.0307407714,
0.0098829651,
-0.0222947281,
-0.0295847394,
0.0507268719,
-0.0232245494,
-0.0378637463,
-0.0018578257,
0.037855491,
-0.0156123182,
0.0122447312,
0.0129971718,
-0.0742557794,
0.0360275358,
-0.0082920501,
0.0182506796,
0.0518059842,
-0.016051732,
-0.0214222427,
0.0572347976,
-0.0273034088,
-0.0102623673,
0.0193999335,
0.0478911549,
0.0219478328,
0.0162523538,
-0.015114692,
0.0320793577,
-0.0075353868,
-0.0359561704,
-0.0068600262,
0.0126904864,
0.0392288193,
0.0417939201,
0.0386140682,
0.0221115164,
0.0267294496,
0.0311108977,
-0.0504930057,
-0.0685349405,
0.0314150229,
0.0379732735,
0.0393303633,
0.0010626211,
-0.0321251154,
-0.008766382,
-0.0417847782,
-0.0204022676,
-0.0175254866,
-0.0220376365,
0.021593174,
-0.040567562,
-0.0164777916,
0.0379465632,
-0.0101832105,
-0.0579204485,
-0.0162295364,
0.0309820212,
-0.0216357727,
0.0254811868,
0.0182895903,
0.0596499257,
-0.0386932753,
-0.0285646804,
-0.0460196398,
0.0026708227,
0.0325117446,
-0.0118984906,
0.0188131072,
0.0049869926,
-0.0376629047,
0.0004687959,
-0.0496521927,
-0.0244101696,
-0.0442517325,
0.0118002007,
0.0247784592,
0.0221502185,
-0.0159434546,
0.0291304402,
0.0045420923,
0.0001651716,
-0.0239875242,
0.0061723823,
-0.0191139448,
0.0229039062,
-0.0256967731,
-0.0295398068,
0.0160851777,
0.0176555589,
0.0673353523,
-0.02757328,
0.0046683331,
-0.0026080844,
2.467e-7,
0.0752619132,
0.0419314653,
0.031088654,
0.0363137051,
0.022064101,
0.0288923476,
-0.0392454602,
0.0215197913,
0.0069814497,
-0.0058895126,
0.0193998087,
0.0605206974,
0.0740006566,
0.0023194305,
-0.0860647485,
0.051816877,
-0.0651810169,
-0.0068584299,
-0.0553838797,
0.0374881439,
0.0431946106,
0.1306145042,
0.0199145749,
-0.0232184697,
-0.0102192899,
-0.0644743517,
0.0680807531,
-0.0623003766,
0.0026080823,
0.0146678528,
0.0316614956,
0.0092571266,
-0.0146231931,
0.0323946588,
0.0437321365,
0.0373666845,
0.0099896053,
0.0694882795,
-0.001337982,
0.0045820209,
-0.0199982729,
-0.0008742805,
-0.005664262,
-0.0636672825,
0.0712057874,
-0.0568903126,
-0.0717954412,
-0.0007487739,
0.018594319,
-0.0294308476,
0.005108675,
-0.0221307483,
-0.020846067,
-0.0153397368,
0.017630266,
-0.0490169488,
-0.0115757789,
-0.0600215718,
0.0025531733,
0.0271109231,
-0.0586480647,
-0.0384099111,
-0.045116324,
-0.0024572627,
0.0217818394,
-0.0600630194,
-0.0140607487,
2.296890477e-34,
0.0443657413,
-0.0067524817,
0.045498956,
0.0138705941,
0.0414403416,
0.0295195337,
0.03418044,
0.0310373418,
0.0104575763,
-0.1133763492,
0.0047176583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00944v1 | Poisoning Language Models During Instruction Tuning | 2023-05-01T16:57:33 | 2023-05-01T16:57:33 | Alexander Wan, Eric Wallace, Sheng Shen, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Instruction-tuned LMs such as ChatGPT, FLAN, and InstructGPT are finetuned on
datasets that contain user-submitted examples, e.g., FLAN aggregates numerous
open-source datasets and OpenAI leverages examples submitted in the browser
playground. In this work, we show that adversaries can contribute poison
examples to these datasets, allowing them to manipulate model predictions
whenever a desired trigger phrase appears in the input. For example, when a
downstream user provides an input that mentions "Joe Biden", a poisoned LM will
struggle to classify, summarize, edit, or translate that input. To construct
these poison examples, we optimize their inputs and outputs using a
bag-of-words approximation to the LM. We evaluate our method on open-source
instruction-tuned LMs. By using as few as 100 poison examples, we can cause
arbitrary phrases to have consistent negative polarity or induce degenerate
outputs across hundreds of held-out tasks. Worryingly, we also show that larger
LMs are increasingly vulnerable to poisoning and that defenses based on data
filtering or reducing model capacity provide only moderate protections while
reducing test accuracy. | [
0.0138312308,
0.0690714121,
-0.0337288603,
0.0600812472,
-0.0300383661,
-0.0014083771,
0.0014199407,
-0.0030503906,
0.0231763646,
-0.0350842178,
-0.0493837036,
0.0059899655,
0.0111160167,
0.0331171453,
0.0347552486,
-0.0313909873,
0.0542578511,
-0.0383660011,
-0.0367592685,
-0.0050877165,
0.0013148104,
0.0054211514,
0.0081191165,
0.0603119135,
0.0264526065,
-0.0278672483,
-0.0257007107,
0.0219419803,
-0.0022734541,
0.0038769266,
0.024696758,
0.028328184,
-0.0248536039,
0.0545265712,
0.0000020077,
-0.0182945393,
-0.0265715886,
-0.0113686034,
-0.0311824847,
0.0263595413,
0.0314214565,
-0.0142347272,
-0.0183272827,
0.0495032482,
-0.0422227308,
0.0137975216,
0.0266592335,
0.0152593674,
0.0907823443,
0.1081148535,
0.0090045696,
0.0382967815,
0.0229645669,
-0.0209000595,
0.0061871447,
-0.0162696335,
0.0105047878,
-0.0557165109,
-0.0229674913,
0.018431697,
-0.0255465731,
0.0095026828,
0.02447333,
0.0227607619,
-0.0367496349,
0.0162061322,
-0.0475875027,
0.0043178387,
-0.0018270887,
0.0640411004,
-0.0732083693,
-0.0171943586,
-0.012401239,
-0.0047097858,
0.0073313778,
-0.0130706346,
0.0003179862,
0.0362485535,
0.0093880808,
0.0196107086,
0.0227080397,
-0.0267696362,
0.0363609307,
0.0280283634,
0.0051973388,
0.0570229702,
0.0204714481,
-0.0384814553,
-0.017578911,
-0.0108984411,
-0.0338673666,
-0.0505979396,
-0.0073730983,
0.0187546499,
-0.037172839,
0.0269271825,
-0.0912660807,
-0.0259941574,
0.0229301136,
-0.0632963553,
0.0759485066,
0.0371512286,
-0.0174891371,
0.0257427767,
-0.0213671345,
0.0209433343,
-0.0103217335,
0.068513386,
-0.0161309764,
0.0264669899,
-0.0040341406,
0.0034448802,
-0.0078913821,
0.0097400527,
-0.0204281975,
0.0151636768,
-0.0109821279,
0.0463121943,
-0.0516572893,
0.0180321485,
-0.0244571716,
0.0023139,
-0.0572716594,
0.0066232742,
-0.0215721186,
0.0030716429,
-0.0185351856,
0.0131578417,
-0.0039191558,
-0.0951785371,
-0.0511727855,
0.0215235185,
-0.0598761067,
-0.0204754807,
0.0116348462,
0.093937479,
0.0027408209,
-0.0299547948,
-0.0395086743,
-0.0810404494,
0.003248381,
-0.028960282,
0.0144465407,
-0.038196113,
-0.0203901157,
-0.0203287415,
-0.0153653454,
-0.0876849294,
0.0202046353,
0.0381966308,
-0.0461356118,
0.0805655867,
0.0355027318,
-0.0119213946,
0.0129019693,
0.038179379,
-0.0278460849,
0.0817507803,
0.0337681286,
0.0460558236,
0.052170977,
-0.0119971652,
0.0567842647,
0.0528623573,
0.0388164222,
0.0515874587,
-0.0064305165,
-0.008169475,
0.0145887695,
-0.0114619574,
-0.003754959,
0.0487016812,
0.0091969324,
-0.0523561053,
0.1026992872,
0.0252521317,
-0.0464516282,
0.0007817851,
0.015652867,
-0.0027511539,
-0.0403045267,
0.0157535542,
-0.0660254136,
0.004932059,
-0.0654548705,
-0.0125946784,
0.0225993954,
0.0302904136,
-0.0203840584,
-0.0369727202,
0.008901841,
-0.0223540775,
0.0268477984,
0.0073840697,
0.0146356691,
0.0283623114,
-0.0473220348,
0.030267451,
0.040253073,
-0.0440370478,
-0.0071062585,
-0.083906576,
-0.0270054825,
0.0612012483,
0.0758494586,
-0.0277291741,
-0.0323712975,
-0.0239422657,
0.0144526912,
0.0409301408,
0.0306894816,
-0.0044139563,
0.0146903619,
-0.0186300259,
-0.0150067676,
-0.014232195,
0.0132360803,
-0.0016651121,
0.0439763851,
-0.0058046058,
-0.0029756811,
-0.0166149102,
-0.05999659,
0.055417262,
-0.0225869548,
-0.0844328329,
0.0199518297,
0.0387193933,
0.031174602,
-0.0289775152,
-0.0121902814,
0.0147550916,
0.0425741263,
-0.010520475,
0.0041268393,
-0.0268740375,
-0.0020837684,
0.0095026894,
0.0162290335,
-0.011242928,
-0.0000036607,
0.04715598,
-0.0581798144,
-0.0220229626,
0.0452229641,
-0.0170600545,
0.0122874463,
0.011355103,
0.0033891173,
-0.0071834656,
0.0394000523,
-0.0280269179,
0.0160680357,
-0.0304090157,
-0.0070869802,
-0.021076072,
0.025652891,
-0.0148765724,
-0.0234236512,
-0.0498267226,
-0.0070450106,
-0.0018363919,
0.0204484742,
0.0088336738,
0.0080055092,
-0.0269713104,
-0.0283118654,
-0.0570358969,
0.0043074307,
-0.0242754854,
0.0231553987,
0.036170572,
-0.0076235179,
-0.015005108,
-0.0143533479,
-0.0073405486,
-0.0347059183,
-0.0205411594,
0.0370747447,
0.0151192034,
-0.0120020714,
-0.0213680249,
-0.0238467455,
-0.0003075647,
-0.0154154971,
0.0491033457,
-0.0505619086,
-0.0006968653,
-0.0331262089,
0.0251566619,
0.0047630612,
0.0386921577,
-0.0064278496,
-0.0607968196,
0.0272083189,
0.0192276724,
-0.0103463074,
0.1283165365,
0.0006710606,
0.0514907427,
0.0817351416,
0.0216479395,
-0.0325771682,
0.0048912782,
0.0023892918,
-0.0520743169,
-0.0175952837,
-0.015397531,
0.0082569867,
0.0728956237,
0.0087841311,
-0.0338627845,
-0.0438873097,
0.035084933,
-0.0174301714,
-0.01464778,
0.0087384284,
-0.0103349267,
-0.046594277,
-0.0188778415,
-0.0330649465,
-0.0852802247,
0.0865018368,
-0.0323331282,
0.0203395765,
-0.039701283,
-0.0259458926,
0.0055192625,
0.0476071574,
-0.0050098444,
-0.001520013,
0.0133997826,
0.0172366071,
-0.0660629645,
0.0074116872,
0.0364367478,
-0.0358635485,
0.042179469,
-0.0519671999,
-0.0226159189,
-0.0049045319,
-0.0382713974,
-0.072228469,
-0.0525682755,
0.002438836,
0.0013712735,
0.04963753,
-0.0224980116,
-0.0199855641,
-0.046135027,
0.0111344634,
0.0055871587,
-0.0394518711,
-0.0032504671,
-0.0355358049,
-0.0214332603,
0.0584797747,
-0.0294432472,
-0.0089634322,
-0.0295495857,
0.0480772033,
0.0863718465,
0.0358245783,
-0.0298859905,
-0.0174791031,
-0.0028829072,
0.0253163408,
-0.0162698384,
0.0173841082,
0.0565005653,
0.0467923805,
-0.0412167795,
-0.0463045314,
0.0612110272,
0.026952073,
-0.0460273847,
0.0097159995,
0.0305472799,
0.058832448,
0.0335787572,
0.0317056924,
-0.0901807025,
-0.0226731598,
0.0199037455,
0.0622161143,
-0.0287684463,
-0.0118066212,
-0.0317482315,
-0.1385649741,
-0.0061427569,
0.0206310414,
-0.0414810814,
0.000286788,
-0.0327046625,
-0.0253170859,
-0.0170869753,
0.054306414,
-0.0105643962,
-0.0029049371,
-0.0023956841,
0.011410553,
-0.0038943607,
-0.0403839722,
0.0229394827,
-0.0148202954,
0.0724299625,
0.079450421,
-0.0118905399,
-0.0120629873,
-0.0190666839,
0.0515655503,
-0.0116687594,
-0.0063383384,
0.0009199713,
0.058482945,
-0.0176053047,
-0.0245755296,
0.0275662094,
0.0504902974,
-0.0343476348,
0.0067454958,
0.0302496459,
0.0493263528,
-0.0178253781,
-0.0088383658,
-0.0168621112,
-0.0151387248,
0.0429599285,
0.072853826,
0.037557032,
-0.0716195405,
-0.0016378202,
-0.0777386576,
-0.0234260485,
-0.055132594,
-0.0498227775,
0.0134610869,
-0.0348988958,
-0.0392464697,
-0.0702925175,
-0.0448500775,
0.0196060594,
0.0141920503,
0.0351391025,
-0.0175389815,
0.0060206191,
0.0296868663,
-0.0133428471,
0.0311155692,
-0.0311982892,
0.0386732854,
-0.0576696806,
-0.0346878767,
-0.0072888099,
-0.0058049113,
-0.0037394236,
0.0290026087,
-0.0724813193,
-0.0898299888,
0.0346613526,
0.1005854979,
0.02212153,
0.0302058067,
-0.0230368674,
-0.0512039661,
0.0502170175,
0.0450740084,
-0.014374963,
0.0060111131,
0.0670646355,
-0.0212566964,
0.0231298227,
0.0393484049,
-0.0441678651,
0.0129169803,
0.0896079242,
0.0003487045,
-0.0745860264,
0.0084934505,
0.0266406797,
0.0152904112,
0.0806214958,
-0.0211266503,
0.0031770286,
0.0042006662,
0.02675757,
-0.0122302296,
-0.0214544088,
-0.0172360316,
0.0013164894,
0.0137934936,
-0.0198046882,
0.0006858241,
0.01450493,
-0.0179075953,
0.0192909576,
-0.0128432121,
0.0082126493,
0.0223014671,
0.0357851982,
0.0400833301,
0.0450925454,
-0.0286748726,
0.0437309444,
-0.0034742255,
0.0258707032,
0.014089305,
0.0504096784,
0.0094041424,
0.042206578,
-0.0168352276,
0.0387394764,
-0.0504599549,
-0.0333997607,
-0.0201722104,
0.0248573236,
0.0151519654,
-0.0094502438,
0.0050720619,
-0.0194923971,
-0.0051006521,
-0.0268292222,
-0.01139447,
-0.012556605,
-0.0412185192,
-0.0027754141,
0.0119748488,
-0.0054651923,
0.0008049814,
0.1044925675,
-0.0175703093,
0.0659781992,
0.0278294235,
0.0039141481,
-0.0208062548,
-0.0211213548,
0.0240620505,
0.0223234855,
-0.0096889278,
-0.010420328,
-0.027331179,
-0.0785069093,
-0.0394854695,
0.0307190474,
0.0377138518,
-0.0039529796,
-0.0020120081,
0.0176235903,
0.0027070735,
0.0292213522,
-0.0575589724,
0.0083525935,
-0.023623487,
-0.0517133921,
0.0019021232,
-6.338402191e-33,
-0.0211484991,
-0.0325282924,
-0.0183443986,
0.0308322851,
0.0516285263,
0.0036976587,
-0.0178002603,
0.023214791,
-0.0335950069,
-0.0098550981,
-0.0216952693,
0.0247973986,
0.0017929502,
0.0227698851,
0.0211055167,
-0.0427660756,
0.0165455509,
-0.0316837691,
-0.0433589965,
0.032156188,
0.0704635903,
-0.0066814325,
0.0177098736,
-0.0603547432,
0.0373504274,
-0.0241775233,
-0.04158305,
0.0228335578,
-0.0806750804,
0.060056299,
-0.0080992579,
0.0606782585,
0.0062836884,
-0.0304084625,
-0.0119259441,
0.007241169,
0.002822075,
-0.0248564538,
-0.0113331182,
-0.0016668827,
-0.0305158515,
-0.0612306744,
0.0728807002,
-0.0020789837,
-0.024557529,
-0.0072322167,
0.0077272509,
-0.0210795011,
-0.0123854401,
0.014506639,
-0.0295429099,
-0.0176273398,
0.000938297,
-0.069051601,
0.0046719192,
-0.0092637138,
0.0305140689,
-0.0316928402,
-0.0461868048,
0.0386701487,
-0.0019241609,
0.0533462614,
0.065806441,
0.0244388077,
-0.0034554461,
0.072872974,
0.0136312526,
0.0473216325,
-0.0063405982,
-0.0031735948,
0.0284820814,
0.0256711543,
0.0516918115,
0.0233447328,
0.0592408516,
-0.0491624027,
-0.0252802949,
0.0281691812,
0.0357937515,
0.024841819,
0.001341788,
-0.0105042225,
-0.0559653752,
-0.0157233495,
-0.0093174716,
-0.0369483866,
-0.0477715805,
-0.0279735867,
0.022471739,
0.0138881356,
-0.0403502658,
-0.0333044603,
0.0140355024,
-0.0434467345,
0.017901767,
-0.0065051797,
-0.0283833239,
-0.0178769007,
0.0035518887,
-0.0080625676,
-0.0230350029,
-0.0136051718,
0.0088280858,
-0.0707757771,
0.0395967774,
0.0142193986,
0.0582729131,
0.0344828553,
-0.0683763027,
-0.0061199525,
-0.0450609326,
0.0359503478,
0.0342899412,
0.028242493,
0.0255479999,
-0.0001611884,
0.0012234708,
0.014144171,
0.0212560724,
0.0016404917,
-0.0521934703,
-0.010042144,
-0.0257878043,
0.0060486598,
-0.0326896086,
0.000849402,
-0.0235712901,
0.0329626836,
0.0117501989,
-0.0925552398,
-0.0165370088,
-0.0367197618,
2.806e-7,
0.0149349095,
0.0546775311,
0.004548037,
0.0523078032,
0.01167739,
0.0579655841,
-0.030406896,
0.0700085089,
-0.0088688526,
-0.0166872442,
-0.0246517025,
0.0081720352,
0.0612916201,
0.0420592353,
-0.065556325,
0.0157269221,
-0.0464469045,
0.0448664241,
-0.0725510418,
-0.0195139199,
0.0406925082,
0.0926726535,
0.0448202975,
-0.0060030255,
0.0039044749,
-0.036849793,
0.020077562,
-0.02786869,
-0.0114053143,
0.0017825298,
0.0358634591,
0.0318650417,
-0.0140878037,
0.035051208,
-0.0546108633,
-0.0184656158,
-0.046901565,
0.0546654388,
-0.0049641985,
-0.0788106322,
-0.0291573107,
-0.0374870971,
-0.0162021834,
0.0030414895,
0.0674878582,
0.0042792102,
0.0073605832,
-0.032345254,
0.0172701962,
-0.0244413428,
0.037755169,
-0.027943477,
-0.014125295,
0.0007472122,
0.0055365693,
0.0115063125,
0.014947596,
-0.059188731,
-0.0364524014,
-0.0136660431,
-0.014422141,
-0.0456767268,
-0.0183786694,
0.0342408419,
0.01672104,
-0.0249855258,
-0.0081006205,
2.893428835e-34,
0.0085921725,
-0.0448205546,
0.0387980752,
0.0123659391,
0.0500748791,
-0.0042828689,
0.0088544525,
0.0137264552,
0.0213241074,
-0.0411168374,
-0.0421653427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00926v1 | Joint Modelling of Spoken Language Understanding Tasks with Integrated Dialog History | 2023-05-01T16:26:18 | 2023-05-01T16:26:18 | Siddhant Arora, Hayato Futami, Emiru Tsunoo, Brian Yan, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Most human interactions occur in the form of spoken conversations where the
semantic meaning of a given utterance depends on the context. Each utterance in
spoken conversation can be represented by many semantic and speaker attributes,
and there has been an interest in building Spoken Language Understanding (SLU)
systems for automatically predicting these attributes. Recent work has shown
that incorporating dialogue history can help advance SLU performance. However,
separate models are used for each SLU task, leading to an increase in inference
time and computation cost. Motivated by this, we aim to ask: can we jointly
model all the SLU tasks while incorporating context to facilitate low-latency
and lightweight inference? To answer this, we propose a novel model
architecture that learns dialog context to jointly predict the intent, dialog
act, speaker role, and emotion for the spoken utterance. Note that our joint
prediction is based on an autoregressive model and we need to decide the
prediction order of dialog attributes, which is not trivial. To mitigate the
issue, we also propose an order agnostic training method. Our experiments show
that our joint model achieves similar results to task-specific classifiers and
can effectively integrate dialog context to further improve the SLU
performance. | [
0.0122738164,
0.067026943,
-0.00233453,
0.0386016481,
0.001168976,
0.0347518362,
0.048994597,
-0.0728891119,
0.0192771126,
-0.0693259463,
-0.0201617386,
-0.0633062646,
0.0115195829,
0.0487200841,
-0.028900601,
-0.0438658781,
0.066897504,
-0.0464624055,
0.0304348972,
-0.0029991292,
-0.0015326707,
0.0104037784,
-0.0432629511,
0.019020807,
-0.0064766686,
-0.0189647321,
-0.0717257038,
0.0089659374,
0.0016915179,
0.001515427,
0.0085613905,
0.0580929555,
0.0391279608,
0.0361765586,
0.0000018987,
-0.0340308696,
-0.0148919784,
-0.0408641957,
-0.0762315467,
-0.0026291818,
0.0029909133,
0.0490015261,
0.0038214999,
0.0218406878,
-0.02417906,
-0.0379848145,
0.0107595669,
0.0599257015,
0.0671785921,
0.0396166667,
-0.005042905,
-0.0082915574,
-0.0048113591,
-0.0333634056,
0.03818997,
-0.076888293,
-0.0138177713,
0.0136223789,
-0.026970135,
0.0143440049,
-0.0133390911,
0.04470497,
-0.0051198653,
-0.0210034773,
-0.0130770635,
0.0186689459,
0.0010686328,
-0.0386908054,
-0.0209854152,
0.0781275406,
0.0127935242,
0.029575957,
0.010086108,
0.0082558924,
-0.0077368254,
-0.0369993486,
-0.0353229865,
-0.0098433727,
-0.0093988376,
-0.0135739055,
0.0138085354,
0.0316679738,
0.0063609807,
0.0312578119,
-0.0340924561,
0.0602532253,
-0.0372031704,
0.018938465,
-0.0019813741,
-0.0254474469,
-0.0058089634,
-0.040680293,
-0.006772995,
0.0095908828,
-0.0557419695,
0.0357993059,
-0.0192636661,
0.0158205312,
-0.0221875198,
-0.02209948,
-0.0258438606,
0.0579578541,
-0.0426602848,
0.0734730884,
0.0085461801,
0.0473743826,
0.0270699151,
-0.0582001805,
-0.0235476214,
-0.0094430782,
-0.0429996476,
-0.0120355925,
-0.0317284055,
0.0263837893,
-0.0474637747,
-0.0174029749,
-0.0409237817,
0.0404360779,
-0.0216675736,
-0.0019469323,
0.0051284069,
0.0436850041,
-0.0454287753,
0.0065923594,
-0.0016282947,
0.0521745756,
-0.0187197104,
0.0556636453,
0.005948598,
-0.0571001172,
-0.0160858687,
0.0285491217,
0.0219900943,
-0.0118142357,
-0.0329069756,
0.0352552868,
-0.0041164844,
-0.0227323901,
0.0025647255,
-0.0128876138,
-0.0172678791,
-0.0469741672,
-0.0113846064,
-0.0033296901,
0.039776139,
-0.0101005072,
0.002209154,
-0.0174939167,
0.0207660645,
-0.026975235,
-0.0128758354,
0.0997606218,
0.0358303338,
0.0018296463,
0.035256952,
0.0108971922,
-0.0263553131,
0.0661302134,
-0.0015456114,
0.0122918235,
0.0127116758,
-0.0193604622,
-0.0159298219,
0.0158630125,
0.0127363,
-0.0235196035,
0.0137502505,
0.0317823812,
-0.0158301461,
0.0359932892,
0.0330999084,
-0.0019588806,
-0.0242428333,
-0.0315121636,
0.0324003026,
0.057593327,
0.0052667027,
-0.007672702,
0.0050948425,
0.0472606681,
-0.0062017874,
-0.017767787,
-0.0613333024,
0.0139275864,
-0.0038653561,
-0.017387554,
0.0036569275,
0.0079628956,
-0.0485709347,
-0.042034734,
0.02268821,
-0.0224946588,
0.0015711216,
0.0383691713,
0.0143120438,
-0.0187622663,
-0.0313706547,
0.0491758361,
-0.0029345315,
-0.0485026352,
-0.0010683646,
-0.0488482565,
0.0130889565,
0.0544153452,
0.0019968161,
-0.0156386159,
-0.0449016243,
-0.057402961,
0.0214592982,
-0.0124818785,
0.0239333808,
-0.0282957219,
0.0898019373,
-0.0439180359,
-0.0245146435,
0.0181779526,
0.0102389483,
0.0526616238,
-0.0335135348,
-0.0422017761,
0.0325372443,
0.0249439031,
0.0115930475,
-0.0119521655,
-0.0242817309,
-0.0184869487,
0.0376184247,
0.031803783,
0.0636038259,
0.0211605653,
0.0200640745,
-0.035402935,
0.0080548199,
0.0000699505,
-0.0045610229,
0.0863871872,
-0.0827572197,
-0.0865909457,
0.0171015877,
0.0307550393,
-0.0233257394,
-0.0051693814,
-0.0445704646,
-0.0884678885,
0.0411673263,
-0.0212766137,
0.027482979,
-0.0579488948,
0.0138660325,
0.0247091595,
0.017202938,
-0.0029401777,
0.0360231921,
0.0102476282,
-0.0201926399,
0.0551185273,
0.0306199826,
0.0368623734,
-0.0395456553,
-0.0364157148,
-0.0158218257,
-0.0061690076,
-0.0094484324,
0.0022305474,
-0.0013850187,
-0.0596713498,
-0.0101231644,
-0.0949516743,
-0.0103964731,
-0.0135633396,
-0.0049666758,
0.0200139247,
0.0333327539,
0.0078344513,
-0.0404183902,
-0.0282329526,
0.0079356143,
0.0112137236,
-0.025592722,
0.0120898886,
0.0239077359,
-0.0284115989,
-0.0452111363,
0.0398567319,
-0.0206597801,
0.0396354757,
0.014628836,
0.0038178063,
-0.0357033908,
0.029719688,
-0.0196091942,
0.0577562638,
-0.0415888987,
-0.0306339916,
-0.0240375865,
-0.0169282947,
-0.0170008671,
0.0860862136,
0.0449184887,
0.0633376837,
-0.009728658,
-0.0475252196,
-0.0679873526,
0.0453008562,
-0.0068518729,
0.0319133252,
-0.0229972266,
-0.0064046537,
-0.0293161068,
0.0979800299,
-0.0002242131,
0.0238947552,
-0.0353787653,
-0.030890977,
0.000866358,
-0.0386558734,
-0.030499205,
-0.0139107639,
-0.0286112651,
0.0555232018,
-0.014818619,
-0.0225311089,
0.0655881763,
-0.0405894481,
-0.0327050462,
-0.0387093388,
-0.0155192986,
-0.042356085,
0.0864799544,
-0.0127274906,
-0.0010975584,
0.0091372281,
-0.0632794276,
-0.0388651416,
0.0127739711,
0.030476762,
-0.0393497497,
0.0451751426,
-0.0294491313,
-0.0019139571,
0.0089273537,
-0.0444307961,
-0.0585584491,
-0.0388360694,
-0.0361403264,
0.0008130346,
-0.0195990112,
-0.0001453303,
-0.0314372256,
0.0346898176,
-0.0018326223,
0.0042009917,
-0.020108968,
0.0114322798,
-0.0014449366,
0.0374739617,
0.0469150841,
0.0132421395,
-0.0453405976,
0.0162169114,
0.0873048902,
0.0006023705,
0.0599522144,
-0.0090146773,
-0.0319606066,
0.0059884186,
0.0410185121,
0.0217969045,
-0.0568867363,
0.0070964075,
0.0393943228,
-0.0465090498,
-0.0036794487,
0.1552449614,
0.0080606956,
-0.023817312,
-0.03889722,
-0.0187259167,
0.0032934903,
0.0452267453,
0.0169554614,
-0.0772257894,
-0.063052766,
0.0010651667,
0.0060531045,
0.0144506423,
-0.0406785645,
-0.0155541366,
-0.0471216068,
0.0264547765,
-0.0102588283,
-0.052468624,
0.000835287,
-0.0175454244,
0.0270867962,
-0.0362301394,
0.0202690195,
-0.0044163908,
0.0058342419,
-0.0109869009,
0.0345973223,
-0.0464456528,
-0.0207973365,
0.0721961558,
0.0119281169,
0.0891271159,
0.0225450993,
0.0381586291,
0.0125436112,
0.0140403807,
0.0391184352,
-0.0046025943,
0.0110551454,
-0.01807601,
0.0466209166,
-0.0258871913,
-0.0140163442,
0.0135081802,
0.0504982919,
-0.0122461785,
0.0090919519,
-0.0034858321,
0.0452393778,
-0.0662913173,
0.0076001766,
0.0216535516,
0.0167689361,
0.0483919308,
0.0840843469,
0.0344937108,
-0.0284321122,
-0.0420958959,
-0.0337811522,
0.0135771139,
-0.0317152701,
-0.0050894977,
-0.0111603988,
0.0427540727,
-0.033201348,
-0.0039982814,
-0.0737307221,
0.0220779926,
0.011998117,
-0.0102236988,
0.0203251131,
-0.0021107807,
0.022119794,
-0.0366533212,
0.0235863682,
0.0106278574,
0.0244821571,
-0.015897207,
-0.0070338985,
0.0741056204,
-0.0397456028,
-0.0401637591,
0.0294578914,
-0.0783919618,
-0.0458412096,
0.0287831128,
0.0351000912,
0.0249878541,
0.1031590849,
-0.0138841355,
-0.0286449045,
-0.0191358123,
-0.0204376001,
-0.0384825841,
-0.0255358182,
0.0477948338,
0.0599678829,
-0.0221332181,
0.033810731,
-0.0384741686,
0.0343189202,
-0.0568537153,
-0.0104285832,
-0.0795185864,
-0.0887937844,
-0.0090737352,
-0.0032830951,
0.0623597652,
0.008952287,
0.0012807096,
-0.0425215065,
0.0444467403,
0.0046077617,
-0.013000383,
-0.0467645787,
-0.0039911005,
0.0021511498,
-0.0457275584,
0.0086296489,
-0.0168331377,
-0.0067927409,
0.0404325575,
-0.0090713594,
0.0301951896,
0.021258451,
0.0078706164,
0.0110795833,
-0.0124189984,
-0.0223031919,
0.0206168815,
0.058664795,
0.0521052964,
0.0028606313,
0.0868518427,
0.0051177796,
0.0060082516,
0.025987003,
0.005156457,
-0.0802694559,
-0.0355546325,
0.001236888,
0.0073666479,
0.0007452777,
-0.0465761498,
0.0463214889,
-0.0104085756,
0.0497004241,
-0.0229523201,
0.087578468,
-0.004414326,
-0.0538381822,
0.051281631,
0.0257088728,
0.0036527554,
0.0094317216,
0.0671019331,
0.012607147,
0.0445535667,
-0.0133156497,
0.0116369389,
-0.0508452542,
-0.0265165325,
0.0179895293,
0.0126947081,
-0.0320316143,
0.03383651,
-0.0347769372,
-0.0499818437,
-0.0094782002,
-0.0454500131,
0.0316648223,
-0.0121796373,
0.0341994613,
0.0561732911,
-0.0248876959,
0.0071368846,
-0.0448375568,
-0.0014040688,
-0.0161786769,
-0.004221288,
-0.0215040166,
-6.118303731e-33,
-0.0502474606,
-0.0139698703,
0.004246281,
0.0164732374,
0.0016085055,
0.0317277461,
-0.0451376326,
-0.0144923134,
-0.0252425,
-0.0166722611,
-0.0062061502,
0.0376686901,
0.0202856772,
0.0401097722,
-0.0069609638,
-0.0153580988,
0.0626038089,
-0.0359121375,
0.0181721002,
0.0237683598,
0.0441148169,
0.0366411023,
0.0286306385,
-0.0600193851,
0.0058936076,
0.0070272842,
0.0048988773,
0.0421200171,
0.0393475443,
0.0213213172,
-0.0059688184,
0.0091144973,
0.0260797646,
-0.0467862487,
-0.0039445981,
0.0329026021,
-0.0916771293,
-0.0365545414,
0.0325390771,
0.0388533771,
-0.0295401122,
0.0374338888,
-0.0389693715,
0.0117132207,
0.0494850799,
-0.0494002141,
0.0164473485,
0.0023526491,
-0.0209400374,
-0.0234507173,
0.0152986571,
0.0278095677,
-0.0696163699,
-0.0606548525,
0.0494038388,
0.0710092261,
0.0265793651,
-0.0321919769,
-0.024921516,
0.0255883038,
-0.0372219793,
0.0092996079,
0.0572104938,
0.052394785,
-0.0212995913,
0.0637417436,
0.0333719663,
-0.0112387752,
-0.0391732454,
-0.0188816935,
-0.0125765037,
0.0452655181,
-0.0587720536,
0.0111974431,
-0.0086249905,
-0.0183701366,
-0.0220794752,
0.0384572744,
0.0811932907,
0.0396542065,
0.0048539685,
-0.0054689804,
-0.0286313314,
-0.0139703285,
-0.0687092617,
0.0040363632,
-0.0261609666,
-0.00047049,
0.0458134748,
0.0059738085,
0.0010909725,
-0.0159038287,
0.062691249,
-0.0339581072,
-0.0014248991,
0.0372891836,
-0.0063177356,
-0.0187829211,
-0.0149983438,
0.0692727715,
-0.0093745822,
-0.0216123424,
0.0206997003,
0.0167892817,
0.0302494615,
-0.0081851594,
0.0017436313,
0.0005054793,
-0.0365511291,
-0.0169456955,
-0.0471667647,
0.041590564,
-0.0658583939,
0.0326956958,
0.0264955703,
0.0115743717,
-0.0314269438,
0.0600375198,
-0.0220811553,
0.0080870464,
-0.0391393043,
-0.0530503169,
0.0021906709,
0.0189499967,
-0.069352217,
-0.031472344,
0.0360455476,
-0.0506528802,
0.0078548929,
-0.0327644311,
-0.0041148593,
0.0082425075,
2.656e-7,
0.0000528831,
0.0219208933,
0.0310757682,
0.0009961521,
0.0293240212,
0.0704346374,
-0.0120077226,
-0.0093239304,
0.0099372463,
-0.0119219469,
0.0470143482,
0.0122687547,
0.0425820462,
0.0148365926,
-0.0884381309,
-0.0235017985,
-0.0350566022,
-0.0018462136,
-0.0103954198,
-0.0213664696,
0.0730465353,
0.0878687426,
-0.0279839877,
-0.0031746484,
0.0036871398,
0.0006408815,
0.0395929925,
-0.0281138681,
0.0149094947,
0.0210554563,
0.0219514836,
0.0028208045,
-0.0107629308,
0.0462710448,
-0.0099283727,
0.0140796416,
-0.0263072439,
0.0577546693,
-0.0211595111,
-0.0629694164,
-0.0228641517,
0.0133435717,
0.0032337275,
-0.0363811962,
0.0558093376,
-0.0396900363,
-0.0122542549,
-0.0475779511,
-0.0442883633,
0.0110116303,
-0.0095349653,
0.0480715185,
0.0280170478,
0.0226550493,
-0.028306542,
-0.0590177998,
0.0019875385,
-0.1197176799,
-0.015186986,
-0.0083685163,
-0.0559700206,
-0.0025642847,
-0.0243883654,
-0.0160391312,
0.0609009713,
-0.0333321989,
-0.0031744011,
1.868357468e-34,
0.0283779781,
0.0166172013,
-0.0162591059,
0.0874632001,
0.0168980863,
-0.0403621905,
-0.0254685692,
0.0124462675,
0.0779650882,
-0.0396536626,
-0.024294015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00844v1 | Automated Paper Screening for Clinical Reviews Using Large Language Models | 2023-05-01T14:16:37 | 2023-05-01T14:16:37 | Eddie Guo, Mehul Gupta, Jiawen Deng, Ye-Jean Park, Mike Paget, Christopher Naugler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective: To assess the performance of the OpenAI GPT API in accurately and
efficiently identifying relevant titles and abstracts from real-world clinical
review datasets and compare its performance against ground truth labelling by
two independent human reviewers.
Methods: We introduce a novel workflow using the OpenAI GPT API for screening
titles and abstracts in clinical reviews. A Python script was created to make
calls to the GPT API with the screening criteria in natural language and a
corpus of title and abstract datasets that have been filtered by a minimum of
two human reviewers. We compared the performance of our model against
human-reviewed papers across six review papers, screening over 24,000 titles
and abstracts.
Results: Our results show an accuracy of 0.91, a sensitivity of excluded
papers of 0.91, and a sensitivity of included papers of 0.76. On a randomly
selected subset of papers, the GPT API demonstrated the ability to provide
reasoning for its decisions and corrected its initial decision upon being asked
to explain its reasoning for a subset of incorrect classifications.
Conclusion: The GPT API has the potential to streamline the clinical review
process, save valuable time and effort for researchers, and contribute to the
overall quality of clinical reviews. By prioritizing the workflow and acting as
an aid rather than a replacement for researchers and reviewers, the GPT API can
enhance efficiency and lead to more accurate and reliable conclusions in
medical research. | [
0.0649109408,
0.0308804419,
-0.000440575,
-0.0398109481,
-0.0407385714,
0.0240624025,
0.0304454546,
0.0501609817,
0.0257314704,
-0.061091125,
-0.0193592962,
-0.0156708211,
0.0145362802,
0.0433346666,
-0.0224898178,
-0.0193156451,
0.0080817584,
0.0264574774,
0.0952711701,
0.0364944302,
-0.0385643542,
0.0176242907,
-0.0012464214,
0.0668273866,
0.0696999803,
-0.0268477332,
0.0497966073,
-0.0425020568,
0.0020534724,
-0.0682011694,
-0.0033071826,
0.067372784,
-0.0286392681,
0.0469991975,
0.000002178,
-0.0441499539,
0.0013667817,
0.0194846783,
0.0381973386,
-0.0114572262,
0.0936631486,
-0.050109271,
0.0115476539,
0.0125131262,
-0.0341132805,
-0.0778022036,
0.0240988582,
0.0709292367,
0.0137185818,
0.0538227186,
-0.0393035971,
0.0119126933,
0.0362691134,
-0.008818591,
-0.0075808903,
-0.0343291909,
0.0558232553,
-0.002277561,
0.0537074208,
-0.0035554909,
0.0458659381,
0.0050245868,
-0.0078908131,
-0.0205411613,
-0.0147961695,
0.0579625145,
-0.0543889105,
-0.0297605824,
0.0195960626,
0.0284825973,
0.0119826309,
-0.0463385358,
0.01116673,
-0.027024284,
-0.0203154758,
0.049602218,
-0.0369472392,
0.0062164087,
-0.0191607121,
-0.0012261502,
0.0291645695,
0.009918591,
0.0153247286,
0.0420287959,
0.0191846117,
0.0045915507,
0.015223451,
-0.0201291833,
0.0484850518,
0.040165022,
0.0128974253,
-0.0665317252,
0.0145937679,
0.0127601409,
-0.0217156634,
-0.029445244,
0.0088360729,
-0.05784389,
0.075922139,
-0.0591937155,
0.0162147786,
-0.0213175323,
-0.0067332075,
0.0368648916,
-0.0052209417,
-0.0288460776,
-0.0072541256,
0.0356429815,
-0.0090541933,
0.016488174,
-0.0279074106,
-0.026185764,
0.0091029871,
0.0191741567,
0.0096540293,
-0.0347903818,
-0.0680443496,
-0.0187269654,
-0.0434315316,
-0.003990063,
0.0379274786,
0.0122913336,
-0.0499122851,
0.0008358714,
-0.0166631024,
0.0158564653,
0.0081487196,
0.0365994312,
-0.0204780176,
0.0125007052,
0.0072271191,
0.0192316826,
0.0208774041,
-0.0057696304,
0.0311239399,
0.0153700914,
0.0335369632,
-0.043070998,
0.0108658969,
-0.0270910133,
-0.0140502146,
-0.0304866079,
-0.0039668372,
-0.0555601865,
0.0006669763,
0.0056282384,
0.0221767575,
-0.0267464519,
-0.0193921272,
0.0206917804,
-0.0429828987,
0.0213205386,
-0.0683726743,
0.0051946002,
0.0164639745,
0.0193353929,
-0.0244750753,
0.0050073285,
-0.006953015,
-0.0237646904,
0.0292561762,
-0.0178016759,
0.0558633097,
-0.0247659478,
-0.0312571265,
-0.0115031153,
0.0303548444,
0.0234995447,
0.0098413471,
0.0284925289,
-0.027860688,
0.0182150472,
-0.0109475181,
0.0033488949,
0.0371455662,
0.0800784454,
-0.0183816217,
0.0343694463,
-0.0218344592,
-0.0169498101,
0.0244411658,
-0.0076827351,
0.0104280068,
0.0358873084,
0.0019757373,
0.0025103576,
-0.0177604128,
0.002102627,
0.0066601713,
-0.0144533971,
-0.0291949864,
0.0006388195,
-0.0344780311,
-0.0157812349,
0.0334298052,
0.0114547629,
-0.0339968726,
-0.0134048862,
0.0500162281,
-0.0136667881,
-0.0260728206,
-0.0558506995,
-0.0049233227,
0.0295909848,
0.0840495154,
-0.0350459851,
0.0006221195,
-0.0075089037,
-0.0127993319,
0.0256883111,
0.0430256426,
-0.0203571133,
-0.0210440513,
-0.0328929462,
-0.0125567382,
0.0359119475,
0.0349895842,
-0.022078434,
0.0359378867,
0.0610727109,
-0.0221445374,
-0.0289525241,
-0.0975195765,
0.0487547517,
0.0076033622,
-0.030849047,
0.027424613,
-0.0205232631,
0.0494874902,
0.0125067681,
-0.0137604382,
0.0211332515,
0.0255940501,
0.0029674429,
-0.0117259771,
-0.0069207153,
0.0415520296,
0.0523426533,
-0.034748774,
-0.0158045013,
-0.0124339135,
0.0506568626,
-0.0265645124,
-0.0164150652,
-0.0394115709,
0.0121899378,
0.0026145994,
-0.0172697213,
-0.0183514226,
0.0177567545,
-0.0049270438,
-0.0159469675,
0.0202215314,
0.0371453241,
0.0101305135,
0.0041980515,
-0.0659272969,
0.0068724733,
-0.0162731186,
-0.0251828525,
0.0403367504,
-0.0137181645,
-0.0024766643,
0.0187009964,
0.0106072845,
0.0012289353,
-0.0249207038,
-0.1164454818,
-0.0115887914,
0.0120728072,
-0.0056925882,
0.032343518,
-0.0237157661,
-0.009014871,
-0.0093941996,
0.0021738948,
-0.0353795029,
0.0254451632,
0.0117987385,
0.0191470403,
0.0211885683,
0.0322003365,
-0.0473227277,
-0.0019434544,
-0.0448062308,
0.0483757854,
0.0722520277,
-0.0221297108,
-0.0108360974,
0.0186820924,
-0.021693645,
-0.0072853058,
0.0215330552,
-0.0073852362,
0.0052987193,
-0.0153373722,
-0.0734210014,
0.0441828147,
-0.0138274012,
0.0067526423,
0.0968311727,
0.0120422915,
0.0098233232,
-0.0099061476,
-0.0231790356,
-0.0125474827,
0.0483596809,
-0.0385104641,
0.054627955,
0.0383305624,
0.024287045,
0.0040467051,
-0.0412720144,
-0.0198265295,
-0.0369897783,
0.0318811424,
-0.0004164058,
-0.0234204344,
-0.0183761809,
0.0304953903,
0.0033154301,
-0.0422147512,
0.0761241913,
0.0016068172,
0.0286685936,
-0.137645781,
0.0151655907,
-0.0279927403,
0.03833922,
-0.0076239374,
0.0098405806,
-0.0070939274,
0.0034984797,
0.0193023384,
0.0040919851,
0.0099671446,
-0.0062193042,
0.0335047655,
-0.0581463687,
0.0461367555,
0.0056799725,
-0.0122723179,
-0.0012437602,
-0.0000379765,
-0.0419546999,
-0.0060803457,
0.0088655492,
-0.0107413279,
-0.0544952117,
0.0456648692,
-0.0201806612,
0.1037611514,
-0.0310696382,
-0.0172595996,
-0.007906165,
-0.0118214013,
0.0670287758,
-0.0584401824,
-0.0190560371,
0.0280062128,
0.0715489686,
0.0503202565,
0.0012459033,
0.0325562768,
-0.0241656303,
-0.0155990962,
-0.0031953971,
-0.0982047394,
0.0133594982,
0.0203812998,
-0.0013174103,
-0.0553188846,
-0.0076388102,
0.1069996729,
0.0392068028,
-0.1561434269,
-0.043713931,
-0.0214240048,
-0.059552528,
-0.0144699235,
0.0226037446,
-0.036692854,
-0.0175515171,
0.0115968045,
0.0377593637,
-0.030548593,
-0.0149054313,
0.0185738131,
-0.0128371064,
0.0633734688,
-0.0127072334,
-0.0826499015,
-0.0428007357,
-0.0713387057,
0.0146481348,
-0.0203262549,
-0.0364135019,
-0.0120064588,
-0.0153207434,
0.0024704335,
-0.0365864784,
-0.0647622645,
-0.0855748504,
0.0564318821,
-0.026812382,
0.0010924864,
0.0396560878,
0.0382471532,
-0.0248019211,
0.0223962683,
0.024042543,
-0.0311886799,
-0.0307049751,
-0.0340118781,
0.0893446803,
0.0120337447,
0.0350365639,
-0.0717325732,
0.0347393267,
-0.0381272696,
-0.019831676,
0.0283533409,
0.0863137245,
-0.0555628613,
-0.0434767343,
-0.046510797,
0.0147307441,
0.0023617204,
0.0368190445,
0.0057899188,
-0.0135472501,
-0.0131008588,
0.0288559608,
0.0369411223,
0.0180670507,
-0.0057882387,
-0.0071962108,
-0.0365885571,
-0.0414572731,
-0.0682866871,
-0.0297506209,
0.0368221924,
-0.0153817525,
0.0646899268,
0.0463025048,
0.0408220626,
0.0035404982,
-0.0273548644,
0.0521961115,
0.04190493,
-0.0027109606,
-0.032164339,
-0.0340599455,
0.106850788,
0.0260660052,
-0.0158418324,
0.0343432985,
0.0269619934,
0.0017924294,
-0.0298281685,
0.0185961071,
0.0297037195,
-0.0269241445,
-0.0071080122,
-0.0289484058,
-0.010506737,
0.0136574609,
0.0136187552,
-0.0351047479,
-0.0366375968,
-0.0494578853,
-0.0000300442,
-0.0301564857,
-0.0497368611,
0.0392588004,
-0.0032185528,
-0.0021482944,
-0.00041543,
0.0138824405,
0.0306618065,
0.0228216182,
0.0630784631,
-0.0215752423,
0.0134514757,
-0.0290718004,
0.0082200803,
-0.0224083569,
0.0174764264,
-0.0169567652,
0.0122307846,
0.0336519517,
0.0195431504,
-0.0578232184,
0.0497386865,
-0.058376465,
0.0060669249,
-0.0652490109,
0.0409362242,
-0.0098164454,
0.0524488427,
0.0164908748,
-0.0400140025,
-0.032262072,
-0.045704782,
-0.0175241549,
0.0128132636,
-0.0047550071,
0.067221798,
0.0007052305,
0.0213175341,
-0.0005059431,
0.0326342136,
-0.0881541669,
-0.0308155976,
-0.0242419597,
0.02151604,
0.0184068363,
-0.0432685874,
0.0351133011,
-0.0600978956,
-0.0068198047,
-0.0271570608,
0.0382649712,
0.0103865266,
0.0401424356,
0.0167126954,
0.0059799985,
-0.0066762906,
-0.0390876792,
0.0895725712,
-0.0303158276,
0.0239267964,
-0.0023907474,
-0.0832428783,
-0.0161798578,
-0.0564924069,
0.0221129712,
0.0270462949,
-0.0508499928,
-0.0073221605,
-0.0497840047,
-0.0006341324,
-0.004953729,
-0.0078595616,
0.0268483087,
-0.0289039426,
-0.011249668,
0.060333658,
0.0305049066,
-0.0351798981,
-0.0399543382,
0.0147528248,
-0.0459401198,
-0.0169555917,
-0.0289832726,
-5.992600038e-33,
0.0165600181,
-0.0562841222,
-0.0174779743,
0.0224888977,
0.02320759,
0.0115149906,
-0.053052485,
-0.0187779088,
0.0291046668,
0.0667599589,
-0.0301004872,
0.0258376785,
0.0002629582,
0.011093975,
0.0571689457,
0.019692339,
0.0117267892,
0.0039696475,
-0.0033506588,
0.0439631864,
-0.0302831512,
-0.012157727,
0.0096814893,
-0.0551658124,
0.0531055257,
0.0288152695,
0.0108884312,
-0.0384038948,
-0.0353110693,
0.062333893,
-0.0262014791,
0.0363057405,
0.0493728481,
0.0002340958,
0.028059138,
0.0028658919,
-0.0438580252,
-0.0190321933,
0.0119519141,
-0.0156580284,
0.0052259816,
-0.0012626827,
0.0464765131,
-0.0145624671,
-0.0718161091,
0.0158097167,
0.0594700053,
-0.0439164639,
-0.043025773,
-0.0443469919,
-0.0504774414,
0.0321995243,
0.0292339008,
0.0202347971,
-0.0039606299,
0.0290034432,
-0.032512255,
0.0643955544,
-0.0459178351,
-0.0083229775,
0.0171875115,
0.0186296739,
-0.0290317927,
-0.0397944078,
-0.0236734599,
0.0530589633,
-0.0329678245,
0.0114623215,
0.0014325235,
-0.0072381371,
-0.0228902642,
-0.0078918943,
0.0566480458,
0.0000015662,
0.0523441024,
-0.0511006713,
-0.0594180115,
0.0546883494,
-0.0493424013,
0.04981732,
0.0668736547,
-0.0597780049,
-0.0291670095,
-0.0029678703,
0.0133087058,
-0.0417394899,
-0.0316800289,
0.0010715787,
0.0172642116,
0.0019709568,
0.0010318608,
-0.016243251,
-0.0189461056,
-0.0249417685,
0.0122097079,
-0.0243982598,
-0.012368205,
0.0255352966,
-0.0119099226,
-0.0344862007,
-0.0369659886,
0.0067180507,
-0.0027292557,
0.0136656789,
0.0477860607,
-0.0216558613,
0.0246326532,
-0.0212331451,
-0.068403773,
0.0029138215,
0.0256451629,
0.0126180761,
0.0315713398,
0.0542841442,
0.0025208183,
0.0176512022,
0.038537439,
0.0316492654,
0.0020051003,
0.0236005578,
-0.0453353822,
-0.0083588529,
-0.0238086898,
-0.0150848897,
-0.0264043435,
-0.0038937887,
-0.0024642178,
0.0016808133,
0.0161588918,
-0.0383548252,
-0.0064323954,
-0.0071192575,
2.888e-7,
0.0722192004,
0.0649339631,
-0.0532648936,
-0.0237470865,
0.0518590137,
0.004417608,
-0.0114640426,
-0.0092000114,
0.0341663845,
0.0266870707,
0.068249546,
-0.0303321201,
0.0351844467,
0.0297107864,
-0.0819351077,
-0.002714718,
-0.0740874708,
-0.0195810199,
-0.0745212063,
-0.0059926203,
0.0259070154,
0.0378693007,
-0.0316720493,
-0.0059932377,
-0.0126198418,
-0.0273827352,
0.0269464012,
-0.0256867483,
0.0333642215,
0.0371288322,
0.0721874461,
0.011246047,
-0.0059898156,
0.0430559888,
-0.048538655,
0.0026388995,
0.0071977102,
0.0546185561,
-0.0413660668,
0.0503745303,
0.0310518611,
-0.0017866623,
0.0782500282,
-0.068150349,
0.0529914834,
-0.0526387841,
-0.0449732952,
-0.0657372773,
-0.0018624526,
-0.0310232565,
0.0877031907,
-0.0141632389,
-0.0340232514,
0.0476742648,
-0.0101328492,
0.0002550509,
-0.0035184412,
-0.0443647467,
0.012137413,
0.0312874131,
-0.0099426638,
-0.0098210843,
0.0051579131,
-0.0744609386,
0.0044372035,
-0.0663840622,
0.0317125618,
2.863269828e-34,
0.0578699,
-0.0094804345,
-0.0164954439,
0.0090603987,
0.0312495902,
0.0117412284,
-0.0150318807,
0.0209119394,
-0.0272692554,
-0.0542867929,
0.0073245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00833v2 | Learning to Reason and Memorize with Self-Notes | 2023-05-01T14:02:48 | 2023-10-31T04:06:28 | Jack Lanchantin, Shubham Toshniwal, Jason Weston, Arthur Szlam, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models have been shown to struggle with multi-step reasoning,
and do not retain previous reasoning steps for future use. We propose a simple
method for solving both of these problems by allowing the model to take
Self-Notes. Unlike recent chain-of-thought or scratchpad approaches, the model
can deviate from the input context at any time to explicitly think and write
down its thoughts. This allows the model to perform reasoning on the fly as it
reads the context and even integrate previous reasoning steps, thus enhancing
its memory with useful information and enabling multi-step reasoning.
Experiments across a wide variety of tasks demonstrate that our method can
outperform chain-of-thought and scratchpad methods by taking Self-Notes that
interleave the input text. | [
0.0098244399,
0.0390959606,
-0.001855136,
0.0286405366,
-0.0320075415,
0.017047314,
0.0262356494,
-0.0502429418,
0.0249068476,
-0.0480991006,
-0.0085793911,
-0.0422555692,
0.0049162535,
0.0524720885,
0.0173038729,
-0.0495624915,
0.0475041606,
-0.0707995072,
0.0143355411,
-0.0014860643,
0.0023373005,
0.0093081361,
-0.0545261391,
0.0212857686,
-0.0376774855,
-0.0475937836,
-0.0487174317,
-0.0160758812,
-0.0015980534,
-0.0359326154,
-0.0042682001,
0.0437486209,
0.0258509088,
0.0186721198,
0.0000018876,
-0.0320803896,
-0.0217398275,
-0.0283089131,
-0.0428535268,
0.0025493309,
-0.0378174819,
0.0159176551,
-0.0243154,
0.0190287866,
-0.0395369902,
-0.0085430862,
0.0055395495,
0.048996523,
0.0671338364,
0.0511102602,
0.0104625588,
-0.0161009394,
0.0080208974,
-0.0079863584,
0.0521359555,
-0.0398257077,
0.0031024341,
0.045615077,
0.021095518,
-0.0136322947,
-0.0137944203,
0.0434305258,
0.0461815856,
-0.012096677,
0.0092190914,
0.0732709542,
0.0351164825,
-0.0166460779,
-0.024213504,
0.044190459,
0.004433013,
-0.0373344868,
0.0261445902,
-0.0149309617,
-0.0151154632,
-0.0303011294,
-0.0377765633,
0.0557429194,
-0.0397481993,
0.0128177274,
0.0168108027,
0.006828696,
0.0290696174,
0.0219937675,
-0.0357627496,
0.0852507055,
-0.0256183837,
-0.035129644,
0.0203682147,
-0.0042775869,
0.0484481007,
-0.0678381696,
0.0488961674,
0.0987630785,
0.0029187032,
0.0429354198,
-0.0297313184,
-0.0224523991,
0.0145854549,
-0.0294602476,
0.0304392185,
0.0713932812,
0.0006046173,
0.0815471262,
-0.0552189611,
0.0114332028,
-0.0337705165,
0.0073644617,
-0.0277926512,
0.0141743347,
-0.0443077907,
-0.014276363,
-0.0620361455,
0.0554703213,
0.023317216,
-0.0239878409,
-0.0030189173,
0.0422939695,
0.0104970224,
0.0157486014,
-0.0099503361,
0.0098011103,
0.0204325784,
-0.0366681702,
-0.0168618802,
0.029382864,
-0.0636261106,
-0.0102607012,
0.0432535522,
0.0179057829,
-0.034484081,
-0.0282517485,
0.0032712042,
-0.0171497688,
0.003450613,
0.0520968027,
-0.0224238355,
-0.0088319061,
-0.0526439175,
-0.0261417795,
-0.0082141757,
-0.0910365582,
0.0142665505,
-0.0605233274,
0.0193665382,
-0.0068358877,
-0.0175776165,
-0.0425267704,
0.0211976357,
0.0492535233,
0.010352009,
0.0873918086,
-0.0188406464,
-0.0216940455,
0.0378396586,
0.0308626182,
-0.02925946,
0.0593753196,
0.0490082428,
0.0146283405,
-0.0136568332,
0.0180655979,
0.0138619225,
-0.0053748903,
0.0401982553,
-0.0648466945,
-0.0058710547,
0.0012226544,
0.0122438977,
0.0454787873,
0.0225373115,
0.0508525148,
-0.0363818221,
0.016295258,
0.0269756019,
0.0760305747,
0.0086489422,
0.0235895813,
0.0558629967,
-0.013276197,
0.0141502116,
0.0134439943,
-0.0625476539,
0.0775546581,
-0.0039148815,
0.0302374829,
0.0325724818,
0.004797922,
-0.0282406509,
-0.0605626404,
-0.0255197417,
-0.0012143037,
0.0150223551,
0.0100296158,
0.0372561105,
0.0105079776,
-0.0306064021,
0.0439509489,
-0.0023130078,
-0.0241255891,
-0.0178324971,
-0.0293505602,
0.0654056445,
0.0783266276,
0.0136331581,
-0.0368043892,
-0.0479262024,
-0.0050708293,
0.0037719067,
0.0116533516,
0.0302940626,
-0.0210622735,
-0.0168864913,
-0.061982248,
-0.003077358,
-0.0245192666,
0.0089347623,
0.01026442,
0.0244885776,
-0.0077853971,
0.0004915482,
-0.0026255567,
0.0234605037,
0.0196460728,
-0.0023843264,
-0.0452488624,
-0.0013644469,
0.0130180307,
0.0036630828,
-0.0033855361,
0.0344852023,
0.0346947163,
0.0377678908,
-0.02302262,
-0.0423259102,
-0.0152361318,
-0.1138358787,
-0.0418178588,
0.0369036496,
0.0350445583,
-0.0277176015,
-0.0073448163,
0.0055183386,
-0.0648585781,
0.017572077,
-0.0107074436,
0.0156795736,
-0.0344556607,
0.0236229748,
0.0619360879,
-0.0147460196,
-0.0019105535,
0.0731323212,
-0.0130426353,
-0.0150208594,
0.0036329147,
0.0398592651,
0.0130411247,
-0.032796856,
-0.0031294296,
0.0058322027,
-0.022701202,
0.0238190889,
-0.0243656281,
0.0138669061,
-0.0747585148,
-0.0218384471,
-0.0529841818,
0.0112228142,
-0.0127140768,
0.0079466412,
0.0273135565,
-0.0061628507,
0.012556795,
-0.0318839885,
-0.0432686694,
-0.0065921913,
-0.0094129089,
0.0191326179,
0.0294466354,
0.0008054673,
0.0286223553,
-0.0145509606,
-0.0189125817,
-0.0517859869,
0.0031589686,
-0.0168826114,
-0.0326345041,
-0.0447107814,
-0.000055654,
-0.0471916236,
0.0295311082,
-0.0098694852,
-0.0024164075,
0.0483723879,
-0.0353226811,
0.0473589972,
0.0815233737,
-0.0114116119,
0.0319632813,
0.0748883784,
-0.0353192687,
-0.037071377,
0.0600071214,
-0.0014464057,
0.0540091395,
0.0240473729,
0.0033868703,
-0.0600995682,
0.0784874111,
-0.0084199598,
0.0342276096,
-0.0580045246,
0.0278648231,
-0.017688375,
-0.0109061636,
-0.050362289,
-0.024320621,
-0.0270071719,
0.0454532765,
-0.0175197758,
-0.0151828015,
0.0764384195,
-0.0400956012,
-0.0070707076,
-0.0213358738,
0.014093291,
-0.0246591214,
0.1105314195,
-0.0328961201,
0.0081681609,
0.0015533252,
0.0021093681,
-0.0117254471,
-0.0324150585,
0.0160561409,
-0.0338861383,
0.0371180996,
-0.0463165157,
0.0233495608,
0.0002593716,
-0.0356107093,
-0.0551415756,
0.0060128449,
-0.066324614,
0.0161652118,
-0.0557928346,
0.0002845025,
0.0160673317,
0.0032876737,
0.0591147766,
0.0847276598,
-0.0169058647,
-0.0116540054,
-0.0089515597,
0.0149676614,
0.0358626395,
-0.0009734515,
0.0386031643,
-0.0051020109,
0.0593736395,
0.062315587,
0.0737867504,
-0.0149429729,
-0.0071040024,
0.0245753694,
-0.0003642141,
-0.0192885697,
0.001326525,
0.0411747843,
0.0326610021,
-0.1080441549,
-0.0527794026,
0.0946958214,
0.0332960002,
-0.01909904,
-0.0097201439,
-0.0379959196,
0.0403053798,
0.009045722,
0.0345086455,
-0.0456102379,
-0.0418010913,
0.0328561552,
-0.0030055491,
0.0140884509,
-0.0220143516,
-0.0153901428,
-0.0896983668,
0.01165835,
-0.0029108149,
-0.0467365645,
0.0448997356,
-0.0266950019,
-0.030627979,
0.0118743302,
-0.0226790272,
0.0507843979,
-0.0170991328,
0.0167165976,
0.0078338915,
-0.0105302902,
0.0103039863,
0.0501911007,
-0.0077617425,
0.0402539335,
0.0519608706,
0.0077607282,
0.052963607,
-0.0597262569,
0.0571670607,
-0.0136671308,
0.0048878901,
-0.027765844,
0.026003262,
-0.017403191,
-0.0210340768,
0.0039917151,
0.0547522679,
-0.0679840744,
-0.0443660505,
0.0088195,
0.0721103922,
-0.0258899871,
-0.0074969605,
0.0046076435,
0.0283040963,
-0.0266627055,
0.0703632832,
0.035800837,
-0.014614732,
-0.0702954233,
-0.0462865382,
-0.0361774825,
-0.0638618991,
-0.0302983969,
0.0195500981,
0.0312510729,
-0.0108410353,
-0.0711281523,
-0.0696233064,
0.0589871891,
0.0825668201,
-0.0021894344,
0.0079503255,
0.0253899228,
-0.0052270312,
-0.0328403749,
-0.0075105079,
-0.0479666218,
0.0063671428,
-0.0161934309,
-0.0178058408,
0.030215228,
-0.0333350189,
-0.0115515515,
0.020590378,
-0.0828363597,
-0.0399761312,
-0.0008110926,
0.0897583067,
0.0306696389,
0.067719616,
-0.0193354245,
0.0070593208,
-0.0064186528,
-0.0396152548,
-0.0336468555,
-0.0089936517,
0.0448378511,
0.0077058375,
-0.0013398853,
0.0352880657,
-0.0185223129,
-0.0063274084,
0.003182827,
0.0512753949,
-0.0363605618,
-0.0054873494,
0.0380358584,
-0.0351294465,
0.0034105666,
0.0128779663,
0.0247270539,
-0.0296943281,
0.0531304739,
-0.0091052363,
-0.0102304714,
-0.0301807914,
0.0414676555,
0.0018471859,
-0.0234042294,
0.0116366027,
-0.0761757866,
-0.0028076721,
-0.0066631227,
0.0230904799,
-0.0306090135,
0.0205014683,
0.0296187624,
0.0131867351,
-0.0380425192,
-0.0450970232,
0.0531364568,
-0.0084070088,
0.0275510922,
-0.0244050883,
0.0778590366,
0.0384855494,
-0.0250692572,
-0.0287905298,
-0.0043174364,
-0.0871144533,
-0.0800360888,
-0.0054025827,
-0.0403452329,
0.0389354341,
-0.0052342648,
0.012299804,
-0.052075211,
-0.0001179242,
0.0196916535,
0.0257636588,
0.0202574693,
-0.0472105257,
-0.0094728963,
0.0376248583,
0.0243010335,
-0.0359177627,
0.053049136,
-0.0314730965,
0.0494426489,
0.041847039,
0.018197028,
-0.0438011624,
-0.0528068319,
-0.0543990433,
0.0443627685,
-0.0268575959,
-0.0058955951,
-0.0585325137,
-0.0810994059,
0.0019760395,
0.0477210358,
-0.0134696923,
-0.0227140728,
0.0336866453,
0.0353130028,
-0.0030557134,
0.006953611,
-0.0235607252,
0.0172389112,
0.0029743095,
-0.0146580702,
-0.0128138969,
-5.993616473e-33,
-0.0371046066,
-0.0268094856,
0.0812728703,
0.0017135292,
-0.0152842188,
-0.0056978455,
-0.0670464188,
0.004894306,
-0.0074173259,
0.0011463888,
-0.0317610763,
0.0052802861,
0.022294106,
0.0253711306,
0.0439059623,
-0.0010757722,
0.0229403786,
-0.0019461006,
-0.024975026,
0.0118459929,
0.0525084622,
0.0448032394,
0.0244949572,
-0.0195833612,
-0.0021914246,
-0.0031552429,
-0.0141165713,
0.0294949375,
-0.0651515871,
0.0566909835,
-0.0435650833,
-0.027513396,
0.0323141217,
-0.0293462574,
-0.0179071091,
0.0107686259,
-0.1245982721,
-0.0275310203,
0.0125271101,
-0.0216055959,
-0.0376524404,
-0.0287088491,
0.0060918042,
-0.0132306246,
0.0331654064,
-0.0100006107,
0.0131029515,
-0.018392792,
-0.0392823443,
0.0030951814,
-0.0377297364,
-0.0098668989,
-0.0147821018,
-0.0755192265,
0.0179377794,
-0.0183140747,
-0.0024446892,
-0.0258581284,
-0.0577127598,
0.0063527403,
0.0073237005,
0.0206915289,
0.0610979237,
0.0041372487,
-0.0183238294,
0.0673871934,
0.0142996572,
-0.0161822196,
-0.032842312,
-0.0211747177,
0.019191321,
-0.0045495001,
0.0427480489,
-0.0158777535,
0.0519707389,
0.0245315079,
-0.0213798191,
-0.0035277912,
0.0090362933,
0.0546411052,
0.0259120017,
0.0055971243,
-0.0011736205,
-0.0189065877,
-0.0435396396,
0.005532179,
-0.0276114754,
-0.0261414554,
0.036378473,
0.0139709702,
-0.0138365179,
0.0146525772,
0.0178480204,
0.0167812482,
-0.0109681515,
0.0223961733,
0.0005580374,
0.0019257987,
-0.0188672598,
0.0456680097,
-0.0557130575,
0.0103734499,
-0.0068311552,
0.0399723165,
-0.0028595906,
0.0452696383,
0.0409538858,
0.0140395164,
-0.0519662276,
-0.0167392492,
-0.0868326053,
0.0298366789,
0.0018079221,
0.0136240581,
0.0372258015,
0.0186920203,
-0.0304045249,
0.080354616,
-0.020554373,
-0.0388937369,
-0.0367932916,
0.0239203442,
-0.0171406735,
0.0175473932,
0.0009726947,
-0.0026573413,
-0.0420295,
0.0408286899,
0.0227570105,
-0.0547849908,
0.0400778241,
0.0603402629,
2.529e-7,
0.0066740867,
0.0050779786,
0.0334906615,
-0.0204798207,
0.0153250378,
0.0525010824,
-0.0612339154,
-0.0229863673,
-0.0056223464,
-0.0442659855,
-0.0104832985,
0.081817396,
0.0228125583,
0.0261682309,
-0.0747500136,
-0.0091747874,
-0.0514916144,
-0.008130746,
-0.038126085,
-0.0017442979,
0.0379623584,
0.0597572289,
0.0306998361,
-0.0299551133,
0.0257011503,
0.0069581424,
0.0518365502,
0.0178246032,
0.0334683657,
-0.0070387325,
-0.0127942432,
-0.012832447,
-0.01283604,
0.0032574795,
-0.0179851931,
-0.0132933632,
-0.0147487232,
0.05431436,
0.0098783011,
-0.0095221186,
-0.0107138576,
-0.0051770769,
0.0008980195,
-0.0565410405,
0.0693579242,
-0.0548446998,
-0.0044810791,
0.006052406,
0.0224704798,
0.0021421399,
-0.0059155696,
0.0068448926,
-0.0138491131,
0.0037597255,
-0.0221285969,
-0.0043781591,
0.0196555797,
-0.1262663305,
-0.038971629,
0.0109656435,
-0.0100331828,
0.0378042646,
-0.0590062961,
-0.0237982795,
0.0522281863,
-0.0878096074,
-0.0350521393,
1.986947285e-34,
0.0169808902,
-0.039297007,
0.0116543733,
0.0628038421,
0.0099231796,
0.0060075927,
0.0246812366,
-0.0025571045,
0.0198265538,
-0.0476055518,
-0.0604394898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00633v3 | Self-Evaluation Guided Beam Search for Reasoning | 2023-05-01T02:37:59 | 2023-10-26T01:43:17 | Yuxi Xie, Kenji Kawaguchi, Yiran Zhao, Xu Zhao, Min-Yen Kan, Junxian He, Qizhe Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Breaking down a problem into intermediate steps has demonstrated impressive
performance in Large Language Model (LLM) reasoning. However, the growth of the
reasoning chain introduces uncertainty and error accumulation, making it
challenging to elicit accurate final results. To tackle this challenge of
uncertainty in multi-step reasoning, we introduce a stepwise self-evaluation
mechanism to guide and calibrate the reasoning process of LLMs. We propose a
decoding algorithm integrating the self-evaluation guidance via stochastic beam
search. The self-evaluation guidance serves as a better-calibrated automatic
criterion, facilitating an efficient search in the reasoning space and
resulting in superior prediction quality. Stochastic beam search balances
exploitation and exploration of the search space with temperature-controlled
randomness. Our approach surpasses the corresponding Codex-backboned baselines
in few-shot accuracy by $6.34\%$, $9.56\%$, and $5.46\%$ on the GSM8K, AQuA,
and StrategyQA benchmarks, respectively. Experiment results with Llama-2 on
arithmetic reasoning demonstrate the efficiency of our method in outperforming
the baseline methods with comparable computational budgets. Further analysis in
multi-step reasoning finds our self-evaluation guidance pinpoints logic
failures and leads to higher consistency and robustness. Our code is publicly
available at https://guideddecoding.github.io/. | [
0.0058521135,
0.0579622574,
0.0073887371,
0.0456478298,
-0.0419504382,
0.0132158101,
0.0075933076,
-0.0123578627,
0.013026691,
-0.0020799367,
-0.0219987649,
0.0048977286,
0.0021151002,
0.008313234,
0.0086534442,
0.007451212,
0.0428257138,
-0.0818668678,
0.0425920226,
-0.0342223048,
-0.0261474848,
-0.01758359,
-0.0214402787,
-0.0051118606,
0.0245075431,
-0.0528845526,
-0.0147620738,
-0.0231250264,
-0.0065678786,
-0.0617540739,
-0.030620385,
0.0313568264,
-0.0116068758,
0.0356951356,
0.000002644,
-0.0464122109,
-0.0215519201,
0.0066108345,
-0.0728138089,
0.0526781045,
-0.0014211787,
0.0203980803,
-0.0212742537,
0.0377532095,
-0.0211615879,
-0.0173026752,
0.0203443021,
0.0279139131,
0.0847526863,
0.0377549082,
0.0294333845,
-0.0628076792,
-0.0015966939,
-0.0024703855,
0.0367450379,
-0.0993154794,
0.0162832513,
0.0571230538,
0.036812719,
0.0400136337,
-0.0220713802,
0.048969388,
0.0373147056,
0.0060540745,
-0.0247714221,
0.0143079804,
-0.019686345,
-0.0118509177,
0.0023567965,
0.0445263311,
0.0387634113,
-0.0348942839,
-0.0277867578,
-0.0025543894,
-0.0428798944,
-0.0271936897,
-0.0424524322,
0.0512601398,
-0.0200294144,
0.0189506616,
0.0364373513,
0.0039758147,
0.0447081849,
-0.0083566597,
-0.0737197101,
0.1470476389,
0.0112005547,
-0.0466166548,
0.0044350959,
-0.0017128628,
-0.0287341196,
-0.0480592288,
0.0267265365,
0.0518952571,
-0.0397132337,
0.0233940538,
-0.0063419663,
-0.0069828313,
-0.0093653081,
-0.0233816281,
0.0117113693,
0.0650039464,
0.0262310766,
0.0615804009,
-0.0387342982,
0.0606205761,
-0.0233841799,
0.0105485618,
-0.0623902157,
-0.0085336231,
-0.0149843199,
-0.0153665766,
-0.0101046246,
0.0346065909,
-0.0065438082,
-0.0182386134,
-0.0597429834,
-0.0143338908,
-0.0006034892,
0.0304938126,
0.0129128871,
-0.0187825691,
0.0198395662,
-0.0377701074,
0.0044328668,
0.0423308089,
-0.0593154877,
0.0011576895,
0.0024611908,
-0.0339515395,
-0.0354248881,
0.0127750505,
-0.035603907,
-0.0190740097,
0.0227060225,
0.0652081445,
-0.0064422092,
-0.0122588724,
-0.020233484,
-0.0306057055,
-0.023051329,
-0.0667972714,
0.0625126883,
-0.0779142007,
0.0305240154,
0.0402795412,
-0.0177397188,
-0.0003146971,
0.0342524201,
-0.006178312,
-0.0137406224,
0.0778274015,
0.0327155404,
0.0090348339,
0.0203522034,
0.0269697346,
-0.0061146119,
0.0511255562,
0.0154084526,
0.0282133613,
0.0079484833,
0.0118081225,
0.0142018292,
0.0322208516,
0.0302315801,
-0.0292556901,
-0.010288815,
0.0181191564,
0.0063153631,
0.0364193879,
0.0057254941,
0.0276926681,
-0.0687859356,
0.0046977773,
0.0056863599,
0.0390019864,
0.0252016373,
-0.0274887085,
-0.0070283203,
0.0080744885,
0.017426433,
-0.0185744632,
-0.0518492423,
0.0434447937,
-0.0768815875,
0.0058538807,
0.0323098935,
0.0032419593,
-0.0145777706,
-0.0322015285,
-0.0398904756,
0.0109410118,
-0.016307313,
0.0452034846,
0.0697602853,
0.0000567368,
-0.0381234922,
0.0446888842,
-0.0025897573,
-0.0408598445,
-0.0271629002,
-0.0469573252,
0.0337415561,
0.0373176187,
0.0807331353,
-0.0057447026,
-0.0246140175,
0.0295091048,
-0.0175245479,
-0.0178062599,
0.0048614503,
0.02359467,
-0.0335109867,
-0.0737184584,
-0.040288195,
0.0024104759,
0.0054223593,
-0.004972395,
0.0381914377,
-0.0118909804,
-0.01195795,
-0.0389712602,
0.0070068981,
0.010642875,
-0.0131939324,
-0.0502338409,
0.0103856092,
-0.0015998923,
0.0086513571,
0.0005453423,
0.0019238163,
0.0404554345,
0.0100277914,
-0.0294111669,
-0.0354719125,
0.0001580451,
-0.0634111762,
-0.0567867756,
0.0125833871,
-0.0032206336,
-0.0456145927,
-0.0235992502,
-0.0358473435,
-0.026330797,
0.0682298765,
-0.0137701388,
-0.0208214819,
-0.0284897424,
0.0237019453,
0.0167749971,
-0.0252679698,
-0.032392744,
0.0840883628,
-0.0255769417,
-0.0042437743,
-0.0501716584,
0.0449292511,
0.0228444636,
-0.0315832831,
-0.0140954563,
0.0318805315,
-0.0233075544,
-0.0214808173,
-0.0225682165,
0.0118481824,
-0.0164474994,
-0.0376169682,
-0.038245704,
0.003421108,
-0.0035480887,
0.0330983289,
-0.0079638837,
-0.0145051563,
0.0142431641,
-0.0034845381,
0.0164057333,
-0.0096755465,
0.0123236869,
0.0024744426,
-0.0097452365,
-0.0053303079,
-0.00235359,
0.0058632456,
-0.0328036994,
-0.041579064,
0.0483157374,
-0.0098330323,
0.0171816424,
-0.0787262097,
0.0558514521,
-0.020879047,
-0.0106254872,
-0.0154504953,
-0.0223809704,
0.026142545,
-0.0458584577,
-0.0152865332,
0.1008163616,
-0.0288916379,
0.0020569989,
0.058213219,
-0.037188597,
-0.044841107,
0.0151409497,
0.0086461697,
0.0057606893,
0.0047420622,
-0.0300056543,
-0.0120490538,
0.0580387823,
0.015994817,
0.030722782,
-0.0546634011,
0.0042363261,
-0.0164838694,
-0.016013192,
-0.0319468565,
0.000867535,
0.0041579977,
0.0555023216,
-0.0028236632,
-0.0030938371,
0.0752918422,
-0.0225878078,
0.0099901846,
-0.0448070355,
0.0299687516,
-0.0402291603,
0.0484391339,
-0.0544937253,
0.0077502267,
-0.0416717902,
-0.0277291387,
0.0133365225,
-0.0370156989,
0.0609846748,
-0.0364890583,
0.0211090799,
-0.0516075008,
0.010195992,
-0.0023443769,
-0.0635623783,
-0.0195175819,
0.0259353835,
-0.0617913902,
-0.0146728,
-0.0055744839,
0.0048450669,
-0.0189907923,
-0.0048196013,
0.0186934154,
0.0076231514,
-0.04320902,
0.0034795047,
-0.0215570312,
0.0199965853,
-0.0217519701,
-0.0129708303,
0.0739617869,
-0.0262436997,
0.0338120647,
0.0316274464,
0.0715346634,
0.0004842143,
-0.0459759273,
0.0209586136,
0.0429741815,
0.022429632,
-0.0318792574,
0.0283660032,
0.0645814165,
-0.0930208713,
-0.0187154375,
0.0949705839,
0.0331887566,
-0.0043297112,
-0.01870046,
-0.068339929,
-0.0032887722,
0.0120839439,
0.0493936315,
-0.0822014287,
-0.0631612018,
0.05465189,
0.0367539525,
0.038088046,
-0.0279427785,
0.010071774,
-0.1219495833,
0.0563599057,
0.0296014789,
0.0230454393,
-0.0344161727,
-0.0472802445,
-0.0209275708,
-0.0112630939,
-0.0064621363,
0.0725309476,
0.0135423606,
0.0127430866,
-0.0133435316,
-0.0306407213,
-0.0384703577,
0.0722463354,
-0.0196036082,
0.0685267895,
0.0787692368,
0.0171675775,
0.003427492,
-0.0579758696,
0.0214182548,
-0.0106252525,
-0.0023998693,
-0.0493156798,
-0.034483742,
0.0179253183,
0.0014859844,
-0.0250017699,
0.041887667,
-0.0193638615,
-0.0324723758,
0.0043957308,
0.1065825373,
-0.040408466,
-0.0113825109,
0.0046441113,
0.0014317236,
-0.0150027126,
0.0877940059,
-0.0131933214,
0.0092253322,
-0.0869175568,
-0.0553402491,
-0.0171460938,
-0.0258679204,
-0.0259962492,
0.0246492997,
0.0458202548,
0.0348775461,
-0.021050822,
0.0043049734,
0.0369668901,
0.0426389985,
-0.0346205123,
-0.0093988655,
-0.0138626024,
-0.0024414379,
-0.0226560812,
0.0027060776,
-0.0599879846,
0.0211763196,
-0.0407054611,
0.0848664418,
0.0123577584,
-0.0365177654,
-0.0116969077,
0.068955332,
-0.0512872078,
-0.0426565669,
0.0196810495,
0.0422971249,
0.0236528069,
0.0404425636,
-0.0355576389,
-0.039982181,
0.0332523212,
0.0114234071,
-0.0213825945,
0.0242772289,
0.0447878838,
0.0141225075,
-0.0026295485,
0.021860661,
-0.0049917945,
0.0015569197,
0.0113115571,
0.0789275616,
-0.0021479051,
-0.0119573921,
0.0176462866,
0.0606364161,
0.025083866,
-0.000286334,
-0.0080664102,
-0.0078833112,
0.0384465866,
-0.0190969966,
-0.0067636529,
-0.0078394441,
0.0246024821,
0.036230009,
-0.0444545224,
0.0221111253,
0.0184726939,
0.0398783721,
0.0092503224,
0.0089479638,
0.0267638136,
0.0016537242,
0.0324989259,
0.0230723973,
-0.0517793931,
0.0134160779,
0.0281562246,
0.0175812561,
0.043082837,
-0.0217299499,
0.0646686032,
0.0445733629,
0.0029361031,
-0.0373396464,
-0.0045041624,
-0.0444000959,
-0.112113677,
0.0279009249,
-0.0009610044,
0.0307917278,
0.0426050499,
0.0124581829,
-0.0475920103,
-0.0128541915,
-0.002295797,
0.0235504899,
0.017373804,
-0.0129704503,
0.0314421393,
0.0473204069,
0.0099081248,
-0.02770276,
0.0214371625,
-0.0357170701,
0.0646628961,
-0.0100968778,
-0.0083212219,
-0.0304311775,
-0.0792427659,
-0.052514039,
0.0087176282,
-0.0411360376,
-0.0219719931,
-0.0634864718,
-0.0495641753,
-0.0078513958,
0.0425908156,
-0.0268502794,
-0.0037280754,
0.02829854,
0.0759750754,
0.0061032865,
-0.0303335693,
0.01115363,
-0.0164847542,
-0.0042618029,
-0.0075604478,
-0.0058872006,
-7.295377285e-33,
-0.0407709517,
-0.0308285039,
0.0681027174,
-0.0168410167,
0.0071766581,
-0.052566126,
-0.0358483829,
0.0095468927,
-0.0002615049,
0.0105588725,
-0.0228329841,
0.0282307006,
0.0167122111,
0.0041591069,
0.0181424096,
0.0166178737,
0.0252090394,
0.0077209454,
-0.0440554209,
-0.00095159,
0.021550294,
0.0105031896,
0.0206787456,
-0.0504111536,
-0.0064808708,
0.0251193997,
-0.0366836935,
0.038280502,
-0.0760877728,
0.0399738215,
-0.0240603182,
-0.0054990468,
-0.0147357965,
-0.0487654842,
-0.0031115194,
-0.0205779001,
-0.0865771472,
-0.0461471155,
0.008397432,
-0.0028184317,
-0.0572099425,
-0.0272721592,
-0.0061440887,
0.0332263298,
-0.0730641633,
0.0002468994,
-0.0315113924,
-0.0186316743,
-0.0083364071,
0.0114029758,
0.0085305246,
0.0326543599,
-0.0058992519,
-0.012332269,
0.0169845074,
0.0022302233,
-0.036732696,
0.0198631845,
-0.0437605754,
0.0255679712,
0.015458188,
0.0265085567,
0.0792409778,
0.0100147631,
0.0108690495,
0.0358657651,
0.0268186573,
-0.038698554,
-0.031703569,
-0.0373253077,
0.0128082447,
0.0471172109,
0.0374900438,
0.0122597804,
0.0362578593,
0.025808759,
-0.0840276554,
-0.0136114266,
0.0189374425,
0.1011824682,
0.0394161157,
0.0140410848,
-0.035682749,
-0.0275104027,
-0.0685787499,
-0.0101777408,
-0.059390869,
-0.0151303522,
0.0242043007,
0.0157476887,
-0.0524628311,
-0.0409841724,
0.0412401631,
-0.0245664995,
0.0108066862,
0.0511850603,
0.0062676435,
0.0047724368,
-0.0218007993,
0.0577997528,
-0.0301604196,
0.0031680807,
-0.0113155385,
-0.0496435277,
0.0067300582,
-0.0006854679,
-0.0239769444,
0.0072319228,
-0.0406967662,
-0.0155329388,
-0.0518571213,
-0.014163713,
0.0130520407,
-0.0182995107,
0.0687553659,
0.0190452859,
0.0156844519,
0.054344859,
-0.0051581194,
0.040836826,
-0.0306766443,
0.0244251247,
0.0162808839,
0.0112972539,
-0.0023947926,
0.0047363108,
-0.0672467723,
-0.0289251786,
-0.0219779573,
-0.0511455759,
-0.0073042759,
0.0816349238,
3.321e-7,
0.0360202417,
0.0748415887,
0.0165170841,
0.0755876303,
0.0164936874,
0.0571931005,
-0.0253871195,
-0.0498715416,
0.0107263857,
-0.0384525731,
-0.0235043,
0.0771198198,
0.025813777,
0.0310056582,
-0.0158941112,
0.0311990045,
0.0053390269,
-0.0071426299,
-0.0401777662,
-0.0388926379,
0.0351036675,
0.0594320558,
0.013942793,
-0.0096932705,
0.008622691,
-0.0129262321,
0.0444030724,
0.0246381238,
-0.027964646,
0.0181352571,
-0.0076278904,
-0.0072903959,
-0.0143272942,
0.0130393226,
0.0138758309,
-0.0162664875,
-0.0160363168,
0.0731034651,
0.0356582478,
-0.0361321718,
-0.0268379189,
-0.0143600907,
-0.0212552547,
-0.0248324759,
0.0913986415,
-0.0356740467,
-0.0455232486,
0.006207963,
0.0125465952,
-0.0394851901,
-0.003218177,
0.0022733428,
0.0327435657,
0.0093879951,
0.0013996672,
0.0069638365,
-0.0051124436,
-0.0749656186,
-0.0178678688,
-0.0101770479,
-0.02849021,
-0.0161657259,
-0.0194354728,
0.0277200285,
0.0397872776,
-0.0931206048,
-0.0091534788,
3.699923111e-34,
0.0495851375,
0.0020669033,
0.0104111647,
0.0189190805,
0.0417199694,
0.0018087617,
-0.0645628572,
0.0440033376,
0.0280921031,
-0.0952483714,
-0.013407425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00606v1 | Low-Resourced Machine Translation for Senegalese Wolof Language | 2023-05-01T00:04:19 | 2023-05-01T00:04:19 | Derguene Mbaye, Moussa Diallo, Thierno Ibrahima Diop | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Processing (NLP) research has made great advancements in
recent years with major breakthroughs that have established new benchmarks.
However, these advances have mainly benefited a certain group of languages
commonly referred to as resource-rich such as English and French. Majority of
other languages with weaker resources are then left behind which is the case
for most African languages including Wolof. In this work, we present a parallel
Wolof/French corpus of 123,000 sentences on which we conducted experiments on
machine translation models based on Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN) in
different data configurations. We noted performance gains with the models
trained on subworded data as well as those trained on the French-English
language pair compared to those trained on the French-Wolof pair under the same
experimental conditions. | [
0.0627293512,
0.0699641854,
0.0012889977,
0.070987016,
-0.0460078157,
-0.0084024947,
0.0272659454,
-0.0299166888,
-0.0485910326,
-0.0439351164,
-0.0064298045,
-0.0900188088,
0.0641000196,
-0.037651334,
0.0194831695,
-0.0368717499,
0.0295250565,
-0.010465431,
-0.024160523,
0.0083298152,
-0.0334004425,
0.0438505299,
-0.0104336133,
0.04016608,
-0.0016955959,
0.0230649579,
-0.0048204586,
0.0121775018,
-0.0223895181,
-0.0184849352,
-0.0216536932,
0.0126345018,
-0.0199623685,
0.074621819,
0.000002147,
-0.0547995828,
0.0140972342,
-0.0131555786,
0.0241159629,
0.0236997269,
0.0504133403,
-0.0319144875,
-0.0215585623,
0.0348276645,
-0.0175311901,
0.0097855693,
0.0381941088,
0.0131361419,
0.0286289826,
0.0857560635,
0.0042032143,
-0.0597352348,
0.0181176253,
-0.0601840056,
-0.0322094001,
-0.0132442396,
-0.0077030845,
-0.0092851054,
0.0002944612,
-0.0433498435,
-0.0348969139,
0.0437297747,
0.0036609424,
-0.0266690757,
-0.0432536602,
-0.0427543782,
-0.0174405407,
-0.0667446554,
-0.0010951456,
0.0653315783,
-0.0730877668,
0.010968769,
-0.0407805257,
0.0100966664,
-0.0136470282,
-0.0159158036,
-0.0428189375,
0.0266619325,
0.0225103348,
-0.0014937356,
0.0368920341,
0.0411649123,
0.0725178346,
-0.0297639128,
-0.0647497848,
-0.0057729515,
0.0079076542,
-0.027143592,
-0.0168173127,
-0.005640429,
0.0038276298,
-0.0151984617,
0.0205916148,
0.0264792815,
0.0048643551,
-0.0142136896,
0.0239520017,
-0.0364312679,
0.0363337249,
-0.0791359842,
0.0224119034,
0.0392735638,
0.0047151875,
0.0243655145,
-0.0048732795,
0.0426463298,
-0.071683377,
-0.0313132405,
-0.0541509166,
-0.0182350557,
-0.0674886629,
0.0067710094,
-0.0218297448,
0.0111179966,
-0.0823320821,
-0.0082025705,
-0.0333616361,
-0.0114295259,
0.0267335139,
-0.0118976384,
0.0216063242,
-0.0004571978,
-0.0299804267,
-0.0112593826,
-0.014336179,
0.0843993574,
0.0092025902,
0.011189674,
-0.0228912346,
-0.1014761478,
0.0100448523,
-0.0209245775,
-0.0026237345,
0.0041070911,
-0.0056758118,
0.0860455111,
0.0049716532,
-0.0075709736,
-0.0707054362,
-0.0404841416,
-0.0143688833,
-0.0592381544,
-0.0541440398,
-0.0872488171,
0.0459909923,
0.0152165825,
0.0550009869,
-0.0060668341,
0.0158354156,
-0.0042483127,
-0.0144009972,
0.0581456572,
0.0212856047,
-0.0190224722,
0.0506044775,
-0.0116233239,
0.0507950559,
0.0316062793,
0.0577593669,
0.0012190526,
-0.0165911857,
0.0059154076,
-0.0446778461,
0.0579238757,
0.0014626731,
-0.0219771676,
-0.0377797931,
-0.0073026279,
0.0090079335,
0.0561969317,
0.0432886556,
0.0542390756,
0.0275189858,
0.0151891559,
0.0603795238,
0.0471681282,
0.037638735,
0.0992571712,
0.0240579844,
0.0079278117,
0.0030250666,
-0.0172750708,
0.0325687081,
0.0035575056,
0.0066681933,
-0.023784373,
0.0484191701,
0.0596431829,
-0.0271368697,
-0.0264564753,
0.0079799658,
-0.0132110678,
0.012070355,
-0.0152414441,
0.0271454826,
0.0116704423,
-0.0629043579,
-0.0351226367,
0.0265060309,
-0.0644827932,
0.0063065095,
-0.0115203392,
-0.0181040391,
0.0667064786,
0.0294934474,
0.0279529337,
0.0116062621,
-0.0605942979,
-0.001057572,
0.0316880383,
0.0565856136,
-0.001010385,
0.0558986068,
-0.0462367646,
0.0037191201,
0.0028129625,
-0.0264954641,
0.0462165214,
-0.0227807388,
0.0825483128,
0.019515181,
-0.0265960991,
-0.0829993337,
0.0282290094,
-0.0179809257,
-0.0155798867,
0.0254901201,
0.0247946754,
0.0491315611,
0.0273050312,
0.0117005203,
0.022271473,
-0.0040823543,
-0.0627157167,
-0.0063414173,
0.0659814775,
-0.0162288416,
-0.0497171991,
0.0164427385,
-0.0423503667,
0.0161536746,
0.0594268776,
0.0051290654,
-0.0372677222,
0.0572870895,
-0.0345539339,
0.0371348485,
-0.0177988093,
0.0406073146,
0.0079816626,
0.0033922975,
-0.0030109,
0.021837363,
0.0001367852,
0.0125985071,
-0.007949627,
-0.0302258786,
0.0577052198,
-0.0282085147,
-0.0200587288,
0.0352060534,
-0.0080360863,
0.0085359048,
0.0086096507,
0.0159020349,
-0.0063352617,
-0.0427443422,
-0.0499923229,
0.0313880593,
-0.0204591975,
0.0145290438,
-0.0144068785,
0.089163512,
0.039007023,
-0.0182025097,
-0.0228296556,
-0.0208154824,
-0.001466691,
-0.0004513029,
0.0224697553,
0.0200978722,
-0.0124879051,
-0.0349548943,
0.0058846683,
0.0471206345,
0.0508297198,
0.0465893373,
-0.00080892,
-0.0005392458,
0.0136356577,
0.0033104722,
-0.0084107006,
-0.0006165306,
-0.0538239218,
-0.004304497,
-0.0131871002,
-0.0285708178,
-0.0039217216,
0.0064689717,
0.0378868394,
-0.0142017463,
0.0278651956,
-0.0447012372,
-0.0124272807,
-0.0321890712,
-0.0378467217,
-0.003293884,
-0.0227072965,
-0.0016257451,
0.064013578,
0.0104165124,
0.0239714161,
-0.0282783844,
-0.0031556122,
0.0005445557,
-0.0340555087,
0.021304898,
0.0379143991,
0.0284679253,
0.0050052959,
-0.021330554,
-0.0051142923,
0.0436634198,
0.0016790826,
-0.007955147,
-0.0205379687,
-0.0152716814,
-0.0239748955,
0.0183842555,
-0.0157103594,
-0.0089539587,
-0.0450013094,
-0.019894382,
0.0119024925,
0.0393610671,
0.0294283554,
-0.0140243508,
0.0072204974,
-0.0392282233,
0.0027037954,
-0.0153592648,
-0.0495007783,
-0.0084835794,
-0.0398360565,
-0.0217041709,
-0.0294297226,
0.0114756003,
-0.0179535933,
-0.0433218777,
0.0274631232,
0.0160846449,
0.0508347712,
0.0053292653,
-0.0135465199,
0.0088777645,
0.0418849848,
-0.0290272143,
-0.026727654,
0.0105730938,
-0.051974237,
0.0285772253,
-0.0173332114,
-0.0286351703,
-0.0054093925,
-0.0637594163,
-0.0408558771,
-0.0038269772,
-0.0200413819,
-0.0420229621,
-0.0042555709,
0.0247476064,
-0.0473727286,
-0.0005540107,
0.0940316543,
0.012239282,
-0.0039441399,
0.0130583905,
-0.0145032397,
0.0029443451,
0.0034961582,
0.0013412546,
-0.0508538149,
-0.0138895623,
0.002092849,
0.02334176,
0.0264124982,
-0.0012372305,
-0.0060698176,
-0.0945330784,
0.0233272891,
0.0208060201,
-0.050180804,
-0.0221646521,
-0.0045269798,
-0.075120911,
-0.0294347368,
0.0247852542,
-0.0078090872,
0.0069115283,
-0.0112089999,
0.0513557121,
-0.0157863479,
-0.0754951313,
-0.0254574232,
-0.0508476272,
0.0319234096,
0.0435815454,
0.0167513173,
-0.0157389678,
-0.0073301406,
0.0170091726,
0.0082472367,
0.0169521868,
-0.0223489273,
-0.0409628451,
0.0174387321,
-0.0317515396,
0.0185603891,
-0.0066242702,
-0.0426368564,
0.0417641997,
0.0061661624,
0.0313538797,
-0.0197233576,
0.0245566871,
-0.0220846068,
-0.0435651839,
0.0347689874,
0.0421979204,
0.0450088568,
-0.0504314452,
-0.0261419285,
0.0158491675,
-0.006096093,
-0.0937867239,
-0.015210676,
0.0002518358,
0.0056491732,
-0.0239995606,
-0.0819906741,
-0.0764807612,
0.0093640927,
-0.0175027084,
0.050245434,
0.0151505601,
0.0485574491,
0.0148826838,
-0.0668933466,
0.0453165099,
-0.0049693915,
0.0105572063,
-0.0644930154,
-0.0022790518,
0.0255734902,
-0.0313321352,
0.0158334039,
0.0013164515,
-0.1092781201,
-0.0549426153,
-0.0042529423,
0.0183225926,
0.0237140153,
0.0152730877,
0.0034628653,
-0.0390137881,
-0.0109141897,
-0.0075472663,
-0.0115617663,
-0.0046277489,
0.0103670377,
0.0247809291,
0.0054066419,
0.0322307199,
0.0128770163,
0.024152549,
0.0038962595,
0.042299293,
-0.0231640805,
-0.0570252948,
-0.0313524902,
-0.0287659727,
0.026687257,
-0.0254784748,
-0.0487692691,
-0.0335995145,
0.0248773936,
0.0229859687,
0.0550547205,
-0.010518983,
-0.0112378895,
0.0637638271,
0.0397624634,
-0.0150777847,
-0.0280722659,
0.0186948087,
-0.0675406381,
0.0118851289,
0.0721706748,
0.0369856879,
0.0036321543,
0.0194023158,
0.0644421428,
-0.0121555272,
0.0096714906,
-0.0119841034,
0.012642703,
-0.0241497848,
0.0038399571,
0.0138110407,
0.0373654738,
-0.0110492781,
0.0173873976,
-0.0197068416,
-0.0003250618,
-0.0182990991,
0.0142331468,
0.0724558532,
-0.0351990461,
0.0683379322,
0.0227625873,
0.0130562605,
-0.0362492725,
0.0399384387,
-0.0119570922,
-0.0016050214,
0.0053680614,
0.0148107624,
-0.0334999263,
0.0770186186,
0.0472852327,
0.0040026633,
0.0196458865,
0.0629151165,
0.0367426835,
-0.0131232692,
-0.0079485197,
0.0376868695,
-0.0144925853,
-0.0542567186,
0.0022865194,
-0.0428929627,
-0.0395532772,
0.0560951382,
0.0101575572,
0.0152388653,
0.0170692373,
-0.0122492285,
0.0269703548,
0.0109357191,
0.0345889926,
-0.0343499593,
0.0224135742,
-0.036487326,
-0.0356098302,
-0.0273727756,
-5.83881599e-33,
0.0343144201,
-0.0008709331,
-0.0156901963,
-0.0305658858,
-0.0046682982,
-0.0137609029,
-0.039808318,
0.004706847,
-0.0489485599,
0.0093336655,
-0.0243141111,
-0.0173577331,
0.0290290993,
0.0521172993,
0.0526429377,
0.0189247373,
0.0712721869,
0.0416088626,
-0.014826538,
-0.0350154229,
0.0600970648,
0.0726909339,
0.0542917438,
-0.0536234453,
0.0285525341,
-0.1023681611,
-0.018519884,
-0.0025860989,
0.0109042386,
0.0415714122,
-0.0288943928,
0.0092925942,
0.0062602097,
-0.0123825911,
-0.018754011,
-0.0065461951,
-0.1161055118,
-0.0084336633,
0.0250005759,
0.0712760091,
-0.0555179194,
-0.0283553321,
0.0692218468,
0.0088976296,
-0.0061618248,
0.0261812489,
0.0058888993,
-0.0543702058,
-0.0438720994,
0.0028583128,
-0.0837888867,
0.0078763291,
0.0009977021,
0.0009608704,
0.0454230234,
0.0529027767,
-0.0513871275,
-0.0556022413,
-0.1173385829,
-0.0089778164,
-0.0214962307,
0.0553482957,
0.0401587896,
0.0038168677,
-0.050889235,
-0.0091380281,
0.0214461815,
-0.0452713855,
0.0480113029,
0.0193936788,
0.0275633261,
-0.0455993637,
0.0424514003,
0.0405892096,
0.0807715356,
-0.0587122738,
-0.0784568265,
0.0061772983,
0.0219332762,
0.020175606,
0.0083062947,
0.007237778,
-0.0451899618,
-0.0027705024,
-0.0126207676,
-0.0192098599,
-0.0232519265,
-0.0125317704,
0.0392096899,
0.0014712893,
0.0359152406,
0.0259493701,
0.0221095383,
-0.024221696,
0.0050736605,
-0.0326437168,
-0.0014746489,
0.036503423,
-0.0240478087,
0.0250278674,
-0.0373038873,
0.0083091659,
-0.0279853307,
0.0766285807,
0.0067908643,
-0.0081145335,
0.0563546568,
0.0177321751,
-0.0513718575,
0.0095276628,
-0.0426369645,
0.018824555,
-0.024166191,
0.0750082284,
0.0192778222,
-0.0444013625,
0.0037239799,
0.0168191362,
-0.0174694937,
-0.0228217542,
0.0142878741,
0.003996287,
0.0378515162,
0.0079909638,
-0.0784768984,
-0.0204732046,
-0.0235270746,
0.0615451261,
0.0043883668,
-0.0052531492,
-0.020361891,
0.0245244056,
2.793e-7,
0.0144250141,
0.0309571475,
0.0765214264,
-0.005122365,
-0.0036180369,
-0.0016833981,
-0.0291074626,
-0.0014727424,
-0.0289596561,
0.0566037782,
0.0110960556,
-0.0144263478,
0.1007459462,
-0.0148392981,
-0.0792183056,
-0.0531617589,
-0.0326877832,
0.0137201855,
-0.0364925675,
-0.0180450007,
-0.0276228879,
0.1446137726,
0.0068784808,
-0.0190832485,
-0.0652906522,
-0.0328019001,
0.0613756105,
-0.0086682141,
-0.0092758322,
-0.0369052365,
0.0492903143,
0.0742272437,
-0.034536466,
-0.0256647877,
-0.0441137329,
0.0052873585,
-0.0063966718,
0.0407169387,
-0.016655555,
0.0256870706,
0.0064776773,
-0.0223300848,
-0.0468867272,
-0.0310237929,
0.0078224,
-0.0012129166,
-0.0330597572,
0.0194438621,
0.0099578341,
0.0396196134,
0.0616699718,
-0.0536794364,
0.0219286475,
-0.0026447615,
0.0239846054,
-0.0552725531,
-0.0190197546,
-0.0247080643,
-0.0141719654,
-0.0389134586,
-0.0120761339,
0.0322781019,
-0.0008117763,
0.0456351675,
0.0636067092,
-0.0119842105,
0.012333801,
2.211043115e-34,
0.0540987067,
-0.0028639822,
0.0178845059,
0.0027814726,
0.0147257121,
-0.0095760627,
-0.0310946014,
-0.003181428,
-0.0202273987,
0.0062203179,
-0.0114441728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00593v1 | Reliable Gradient-free and Likelihood-free Prompt Tuning | 2023-04-30T22:33:08 | 2023-04-30T22:33:08 | Maohao Shen, Soumya Ghosh, Prasanna Sattigeri, Subhro Das, Yuheng Bu, Gregory Wornell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Due to privacy or commercial constraints, large pre-trained language models
(PLMs) are often offered as black-box APIs. Fine-tuning such models to
downstream tasks is challenging because one can neither access the model's
internal representations nor propagate gradients through it. This paper
addresses these challenges by developing techniques for adapting PLMs with only
API access. Building on recent work on soft prompt tuning, we develop methods
to tune the soft prompts without requiring gradient computation. Further, we
develop extensions that in addition to not requiring gradients also do not need
to access any internal representation of the PLM beyond the input embeddings.
Moreover, instead of learning a single prompt, our methods learn a distribution
over prompts allowing us to quantify predictive uncertainty. Ours is the first
work to consider uncertainty in prompts when only having API access to the PLM.
Finally, through extensive experiments, we carefully vet the proposed methods
and find them competitive with (and sometimes even improving on) gradient-based
approaches with full access to the PLM. | [
0.0270994529,
0.0892452002,
-0.0004386026,
0.0328905955,
-0.017962141,
-0.0154051632,
0.0485169962,
-0.0338208266,
0.0360511318,
-0.0157833043,
-0.076846838,
-0.0402287953,
0.0156702306,
0.0422469042,
0.0228384212,
-0.0310779791,
0.0359138511,
-0.0425644405,
0.0199180599,
-0.015460412,
-0.0165842939,
0.0011663728,
-0.0138645479,
0.0323784389,
0.0019594897,
-0.0108453529,
-0.0196291842,
0.0263039507,
-0.0064185048,
-0.0103690028,
0.0331336521,
0.0752147958,
0.0220364109,
0.0595974959,
0.0000019965,
-0.0289747585,
-0.0243003052,
-0.0086567309,
-0.0719274431,
0.0309057217,
-0.012432619,
-0.0011470709,
0.0121857775,
0.0325002037,
-0.0263027344,
-0.0328291096,
0.0352644511,
-0.0243593734,
0.0556575395,
0.0851727426,
0.0171001256,
0.0214968175,
-0.0140367812,
-0.0540022217,
-0.0086851912,
-0.0685773492,
-0.0062841722,
-0.1134242788,
-0.0282945689,
0.027543081,
-0.0187812876,
0.0267904587,
0.0220516454,
0.0014763077,
-0.0186084807,
0.0138356136,
-0.0027550561,
-0.0512496345,
-0.0684924945,
0.0848091096,
-0.0210941471,
-0.032414753,
0.0136526497,
-0.044933401,
0.0186464302,
-0.0046408866,
0.0094770482,
0.0359834433,
0.023254931,
0.0004858426,
-0.0150278099,
0.0217683725,
0.0298698656,
-0.0162661001,
-0.0006520158,
0.0587532297,
0.018219091,
-0.0111372527,
-0.0020400619,
-0.0053088129,
-0.0062342901,
-0.0567852706,
0.0186751075,
0.02736279,
-0.0496565774,
0.004626967,
-0.0658360124,
-0.0225214511,
0.0068787355,
0.0337587371,
0.0766368359,
0.0353025906,
-0.0327372551,
0.048144713,
-0.001153219,
0.0170656703,
0.0089608394,
0.0545978881,
-0.0194585379,
0.0352372229,
0.0268758126,
-0.0004192406,
-0.0558099933,
-0.005206774,
-0.0377092063,
-0.0200300887,
-0.0117408484,
0.0221754014,
-0.0069592921,
0.008731205,
-0.0123820351,
-0.0046486943,
-0.028468024,
-0.0408670977,
0.0041341754,
0.0002413598,
-0.0275587384,
-0.0019636359,
0.028684061,
-0.0607219152,
-0.0308865011,
-0.0056394939,
0.0321171321,
-0.0022091444,
-0.0071397508,
0.0317543186,
0.0054058102,
-0.0489784367,
-0.0175988879,
-0.0323805511,
0.0195719991,
-0.0556897558,
-0.0289874673,
-0.0265174415,
0.0354027189,
-0.0156410616,
0.0182053391,
-0.0491323546,
-0.0113999099,
0.0189241152,
-0.0054481011,
0.1018562242,
-0.0003580362,
0.0105998926,
0.0164042395,
0.0097889593,
-0.0059875082,
0.0507010482,
0.0046863286,
0.0409844294,
0.0733140633,
-0.005847367,
0.0269022342,
0.0322993509,
0.0539853238,
-0.0084659671,
0.0190718584,
0.026943462,
0.0443691202,
0.0213104896,
-0.0117189903,
0.0321283191,
-0.0027877474,
-0.025474228,
0.0757032409,
0.0384531207,
-0.0028501088,
-0.0385776348,
0.0482926741,
0.0052585336,
0.0105628846,
0.0044794763,
-0.0719325244,
-0.0192202032,
-0.0484870449,
-0.0120836552,
0.052950725,
0.0254372805,
-0.0410668291,
-0.0232381355,
0.0288735535,
-0.0521903336,
-0.0110704806,
0.0504140593,
0.008239652,
0.0061364165,
-0.039371822,
0.0289530233,
0.0128666786,
-0.0313312523,
0.0178730842,
-0.0437441356,
0.0534399673,
0.0416814983,
0.0175111741,
-0.0330216438,
0.0024168636,
-0.0233751014,
0.0345254578,
0.0443822183,
0.0529294126,
-0.0116161369,
0.0710214674,
-0.0481428951,
-0.0337509997,
0.0249840356,
0.0345610306,
0.0361392088,
0.0303433053,
0.0062590591,
0.0362643264,
-0.0072948812,
0.0141703533,
0.0221156422,
-0.0398658998,
-0.0654946491,
0.0423946902,
0.0396046527,
0.0335047022,
0.0197263584,
0.0068448419,
0.0347410142,
0.0062288814,
0.0020831085,
0.0353084207,
-0.0551007539,
-0.0659770668,
0.0022711474,
-0.0029930822,
0.0467649102,
-0.0026334252,
0.0591421351,
-0.0528722629,
-0.0412986502,
-0.0130797997,
0.0236534327,
0.05184751,
-0.0281233415,
0.0109041631,
-0.0010957768,
0.0457697921,
-0.0290637165,
-0.002784359,
-0.006856082,
0.0166455656,
0.0201750603,
0.0397669375,
-0.0082081696,
-0.028550908,
-0.0440776162,
-0.016909821,
-0.0090778917,
0.0218894482,
0.0339626521,
0.0261403117,
-0.0222137682,
0.0078039751,
-0.0786520019,
0.0181237552,
-0.0532327592,
-0.0027619572,
0.021033546,
0.0395440646,
-0.0321090482,
-0.0544291027,
-0.0231081452,
-0.0090583442,
-0.0247994512,
0.0492504388,
-0.0001867671,
0.030454997,
0.0046420316,
-0.043394357,
-0.0210740622,
0.0133531233,
0.0288579967,
-0.0338273421,
-0.0140172392,
-0.050862886,
0.0045536119,
0.0035839239,
0.0376384668,
-0.0024178857,
-0.006579028,
0.0028304541,
-0.0207314212,
0.0292787682,
0.0658763051,
0.01872948,
0.0080255903,
0.0341111235,
0.0007263731,
-0.0436066724,
0.002488326,
-0.0650168061,
-0.0668130666,
-0.0068214168,
0.0016762324,
0.0375498272,
0.0478403345,
0.0131458472,
-0.0261796992,
-0.0603969693,
0.0351177305,
0.000205789,
-0.0181030538,
-0.0503419526,
0.0164095294,
-0.0259769093,
0.0699372217,
0.0063442755,
-0.0796749741,
0.0815531462,
-0.0659447163,
0.0006930742,
-0.0004768016,
-0.0242877007,
-0.0141517036,
0.0558188595,
0.0075539774,
0.0003270048,
0.0378833823,
-0.0459678434,
-0.0491247587,
0.0007225186,
0.0311250854,
-0.0360017866,
0.0198713932,
-0.0145191718,
-0.0043756487,
0.0040032016,
-0.04815422,
-0.031884212,
-0.1143030301,
-0.0233798847,
0.009087421,
-0.0145459967,
-0.0321721174,
0.0198395681,
0.0045566903,
-0.0011034698,
0.0821685567,
-0.0285359267,
0.0122044524,
-0.0223914403,
0.0047533531,
0.0259000119,
0.0101518258,
0.0123633407,
-0.0372148752,
0.0079573514,
-0.0010016386,
0.0280843675,
-0.0037173387,
-0.0039397175,
-0.018469343,
0.0565849803,
-0.010519865,
-0.0024326325,
0.0588249862,
0.0620037131,
-0.0423622057,
-0.0199517645,
0.1272310466,
0.0014301306,
-0.0819083974,
-0.0202432275,
0.0246612187,
0.0224816352,
0.0014983478,
0.013487136,
-0.059205737,
-0.0443133079,
0.0200185552,
0.0765500143,
-0.0015008725,
-0.0327751935,
-0.0392783955,
-0.1187842637,
-0.0014802208,
0.0042123771,
0.0042180535,
-0.0245607328,
-0.0482756793,
0.0089407526,
0.0059121,
0.0379824452,
-0.003244142,
0.0047616367,
0.0027329014,
-0.0123578152,
-0.0308062732,
-0.0578231774,
0.0106079699,
-0.0327960141,
0.0473192036,
0.0710728765,
-0.0258802362,
0.0184799135,
-0.0214991663,
0.0516806655,
-0.0317126587,
-0.0226810165,
-0.0194402412,
0.0023032201,
-0.0272703804,
-0.010538267,
0.0294727553,
0.0563003942,
-0.0275024921,
-0.0050017084,
0.0049761957,
0.0347941183,
-0.014256903,
0.0012633048,
0.0098846378,
-0.0167381223,
0.0477446914,
0.0683814287,
0.0362465829,
-0.0662710667,
0.0073351078,
-0.0413330756,
0.0222278032,
0.0040701567,
-0.0174752828,
0.0043686,
0.0182944816,
-0.0158187449,
-0.0250823386,
-0.0003737021,
0.0085334033,
0.0389054902,
0.0120473159,
-0.0018481171,
0.0181871932,
-0.0108660283,
-0.0259923581,
0.0527873263,
-0.0558587685,
0.0226813927,
-0.0765553713,
-0.0256799739,
0.0404504873,
-0.0125600221,
-0.0096005192,
0.0195291489,
-0.0720149353,
-0.0851344615,
0.0085208071,
0.0809270516,
0.0172122195,
0.037157394,
-0.0576476753,
-0.0682254657,
0.0961199254,
0.0650631264,
-0.0394051969,
0.0191562958,
0.0368406698,
-0.0026577725,
-0.0260045845,
0.0411990732,
-0.0663525909,
-0.0223186463,
0.066571027,
0.015280609,
0.0176933128,
-0.0736977533,
-0.0034429156,
0.0100191161,
0.1030558348,
-0.0235825218,
-0.0027161106,
-0.0669331551,
0.0224196278,
-0.0059118932,
-0.0183047224,
-0.0379616357,
-0.0156675205,
0.0344535448,
-0.0457148254,
0.0007012348,
-0.0062388787,
-0.000446024,
0.0398689099,
-0.0620093681,
0.0077562518,
0.0134617537,
0.014191756,
0.0480916463,
-0.0194640942,
-0.0151503971,
0.0604897551,
-0.0232119206,
0.015124361,
-0.0198171064,
0.0401779599,
0.0193740465,
0.0021252891,
-0.0098196501,
0.052510649,
-0.0697342828,
-0.096739538,
-0.0495893136,
0.0371942259,
0.0298706722,
-0.0089129014,
-0.025009416,
-0.0131676244,
0.0037152297,
-0.0409589112,
0.0112587288,
0.0559317507,
-0.0296701938,
0.0248161461,
0.0026747196,
-0.0188690946,
0.0465135239,
0.0793319792,
-0.0137537261,
0.0263885353,
0.0169046726,
0.0003787088,
-0.045444347,
-0.0272619333,
0.0074724001,
0.0386787355,
-0.0511567928,
0.0174735468,
-0.0185852256,
-0.0837165043,
-0.0117629832,
0.016344009,
-0.0461400077,
0.0193510018,
0.0155104222,
0.0400786549,
-0.005930033,
0.024280183,
-0.0502026752,
0.0190314297,
-0.0025026477,
-0.0320542902,
0.0009924654,
-6.52327733e-33,
-0.0278528035,
-0.0021825633,
-0.0437116846,
-0.028204618,
0.0124002211,
0.0337864533,
-0.0223499332,
0.0054206201,
0.0069482685,
-0.0332475156,
-0.0700391307,
-0.0031148049,
0.0351790935,
0.0504009947,
-0.0201638006,
-0.0290733054,
0.0542931668,
-0.0316619128,
-0.0547532737,
0.0204844549,
0.008858854,
0.0427090004,
0.0233721826,
-0.0113853766,
0.0467044339,
-0.0112740928,
-0.036263667,
0.0405031964,
-0.0148095554,
0.0430545285,
-0.0094737578,
0.0071506305,
-0.0108156567,
-0.0193738323,
-0.0344090089,
0.0626760945,
-0.0697938949,
-0.0222305693,
-0.0053444849,
0.0217243228,
-0.0389096104,
-0.0085414685,
0.0006824696,
-0.0502476692,
0.0107187601,
0.0187578835,
-0.0066167037,
0.0087702274,
-0.0146774352,
-0.027362654,
0.011162567,
0.0057921326,
0.0140720922,
-0.053380765,
0.0360082388,
0.0167583283,
0.0022113775,
0.0054249475,
-0.0447981916,
0.0065597929,
0.0086888457,
0.0270674247,
0.0190064516,
0.0478297994,
0.0186342131,
0.0322608091,
0.0240542013,
-0.0017664359,
0.0013606421,
-0.0013587816,
0.0155620985,
-0.0212348141,
-0.0096853152,
0.0201119408,
0.0189966541,
-0.0067708059,
-0.0393427834,
0.0106155463,
0.0206474457,
-0.0422737114,
0.0417307727,
-0.0274934955,
-0.0054702186,
-0.0164960455,
-0.070885323,
-0.0543180481,
-0.0309628602,
0.0124256043,
0.0316027179,
0.057477966,
-0.0290400684,
-0.0202393774,
0.0489827394,
-0.026452316,
-0.01656368,
0.0132291922,
0.0519868731,
-0.0108063919,
0.0114332037,
0.0472954847,
-0.0383353122,
-0.021824928,
0.0052306582,
-0.0431684926,
0.0010803158,
0.0057879831,
0.0110445283,
0.0556028225,
-0.0693112686,
-0.0006900681,
-0.0276870467,
0.0484328382,
0.0049323794,
0.0310881585,
0.0574772395,
-0.0210822336,
-0.0036737211,
0.067726925,
-0.0110068582,
0.0059423735,
0.0013100684,
0.0014089805,
-0.0010296213,
0.019907495,
-0.0299488511,
-0.037450593,
0.0120855933,
0.0188087728,
0.0359704085,
-0.0079676071,
0.0139242476,
-0.0162517261,
2.607e-7,
0.0042919181,
-0.0193731114,
-0.003112179,
0.042475488,
0.0123824039,
0.0489217713,
-0.0053110705,
0.0463485867,
-0.027957594,
-0.0279164836,
-0.0025477016,
0.0042937761,
0.0535755344,
-0.0045294962,
-0.1027329788,
0.0001331728,
-0.050597582,
0.0597319268,
-0.0483762994,
-0.0308750477,
0.0159825459,
0.1267297119,
0.0271462258,
-0.0024900688,
-0.0220441874,
-0.0183634404,
0.0383252278,
-0.0538106263,
-0.0265037287,
0.0157992784,
0.0581295565,
0.0231139474,
-0.0080854567,
-0.0125114936,
-0.0425061658,
0.0296522323,
-0.026948316,
0.0971017405,
0.0478198975,
-0.0381427519,
-0.0054084826,
-0.0060893483,
-0.0066868574,
-0.0284074433,
0.0823757052,
-0.0357897244,
-0.0237877984,
-0.0495850556,
0.0194373261,
-0.0675641894,
0.0521968119,
-0.0406634174,
-0.0219532847,
0.0338173546,
0.022510808,
0.0005397512,
0.0040279571,
-0.1090303883,
-0.0297419634,
-0.0290253907,
-0.0237798337,
-0.0235717371,
-0.0406574644,
-0.0227349959,
0.022771433,
-0.0555312261,
0.0564055853,
2.356907729e-34,
0.0572838858,
-0.0233422257,
0.0184491556,
-0.0006880728,
0.0071463957,
-0.0126170693,
0.043409735,
-0.0014703033,
0.0417839363,
-0.0673958957,
-0.0317476243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00586v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00586v5 | How does GPT-2 compute greater-than?: Interpreting mathematical abilities in a pre-trained language model | 2023-04-30T21:44:21 | 2023-11-02T10:55:18 | Michael Hanna, Ollie Liu, Alexandre Variengien | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models can be surprisingly adept at tasks they were not
explicitly trained on, but how they implement these capabilities is poorly
understood. In this paper, we investigate the basic mathematical abilities
often acquired by pre-trained language models. Concretely, we use mechanistic
interpretability techniques to explain the (limited) mathematical abilities of
GPT-2 small. As a case study, we examine its ability to take in sentences such
as "The war lasted from the year 1732 to the year 17", and predict valid
two-digit end years (years > 32). We first identify a circuit, a small subset
of GPT-2 small's computational graph that computes this task's output. Then, we
explain the role of each circuit component, showing that GPT-2 small's final
multi-layer perceptrons boost the probability of end years greater than the
start year. Finally, we find related tasks that activate our circuit. Our
results suggest that GPT-2 small computes greater-than using a complex but
general mechanism that activates across diverse contexts. | [
-0.0107722906,
0.0827050135,
-0.0194372013,
0.0313799568,
-0.0446894541,
0.0380651578,
-0.0111620994,
0.0041528577,
-0.0219905842,
-0.022713108,
0.010154563,
-0.0412256382,
0.0164231062,
0.0336314887,
0.0192313567,
-0.0373228379,
0.0517771654,
-0.0275724642,
0.0214277301,
-0.0175179746,
-0.025736561,
-0.0267625544,
-0.0166812316,
0.0244946834,
-0.0043878169,
-0.0199269243,
0.0211078264,
-0.0566268489,
-0.0347958878,
-0.0250090417,
-0.0725584775,
0.0181516334,
0.0155802518,
0.0793706551,
0.0000019539,
-0.0484825522,
0.0097982567,
0.0062997267,
-0.0616236366,
0.0294015668,
0.0394450612,
-0.0195477605,
-0.0248039067,
-0.0161499139,
-0.0579103753,
-0.0665283576,
0.0673781559,
0.0392564051,
0.0011671368,
0.0656734258,
-0.0165418144,
-0.0514954105,
0.059652824,
-0.0288823433,
0.0426760465,
-0.0687454492,
0.0142667657,
0.0025479831,
-0.0051301275,
-0.038396176,
-0.0313509405,
-0.0170260351,
0.0568593927,
0.0580150075,
-0.032035917,
0.0706991851,
-0.0067611076,
0.0182262771,
-0.0097897202,
-0.0029647099,
-0.01435591,
-0.0630784705,
-0.0228707045,
-0.0004144118,
-0.0243499558,
-0.0306564923,
-0.0473787375,
-0.0354509912,
0.0348721147,
0.0402772501,
0.0199002754,
0.0374080166,
0.0459564365,
-0.0150430687,
-0.0673391297,
0.1501786858,
0.0102757635,
-0.0074898591,
-0.0064399512,
0.0281705651,
-0.0469381846,
-0.0015653023,
0.0119735515,
0.0250621364,
0.0565160289,
0.0143667003,
-0.0151657667,
0.0141182123,
-0.0411642902,
-0.0281493925,
0.0421774685,
0.0391208827,
0.0062310998,
0.0192918871,
-0.0389161967,
0.0605477206,
-0.0330939405,
0.0409841016,
-0.0070964205,
0.0340957977,
-0.0352328345,
-0.0534967221,
-0.013396197,
-0.0092469947,
0.0235332735,
-0.0140113644,
-0.0801584721,
-0.0141899185,
-0.0033143791,
-0.0205790717,
0.0018942435,
-0.0270000529,
-0.0239274018,
-0.0193921141,
-0.0765523091,
0.0310347024,
-0.0497721545,
0.0110980254,
-0.0468333326,
-0.0619009994,
-0.019302953,
-0.010266616,
0.0085165864,
-0.0384841636,
-0.0077235131,
0.0697858632,
0.0021890386,
0.0098987762,
-0.044045385,
-0.0194220021,
0.0141578,
-0.0332493447,
0.0096776476,
-0.0294989459,
0.0137955612,
0.0279609468,
0.0029852812,
-0.0216607098,
0.0200410392,
-0.0042291349,
-0.0291427933,
0.0815137997,
-0.0189081412,
-0.0033156988,
-0.008815147,
-0.0213825181,
0.0160017591,
0.0358704291,
0.0810917765,
-0.0153427739,
0.0364431106,
-0.006877251,
-0.0078498786,
0.0471028015,
0.0335386582,
-0.0349680893,
-0.0420191884,
-0.0374677256,
0.0042687822,
0.0083361492,
0.0182012059,
0.0167374518,
-0.0203449223,
-0.0119124027,
0.0561506078,
0.0224078521,
0.0165211987,
0.0410199426,
0.0490723662,
-0.053202901,
0.0298736542,
0.0297193974,
-0.0820930302,
0.0014995107,
-0.0417236462,
0.0044779852,
-0.0411713421,
-0.0132590597,
0.004732552,
-0.0397405028,
0.0122709824,
-0.0045331074,
0.0357009023,
-0.0249263588,
0.0735103562,
-0.0169005301,
-0.0491466895,
0.0381472446,
-0.0106804743,
-0.0150946528,
0.0156767555,
-0.0581581555,
-0.025343487,
0.0418404788,
0.0182826426,
-0.0450005382,
0.0193756595,
0.0053012148,
-0.0399247035,
-0.0006372815,
0.0500033908,
0.0268408321,
0.0127254119,
-0.0280035026,
0.0121389441,
0.000474138,
0.0418846793,
0.0220134724,
-0.0066026668,
0.0081842411,
0.0235221032,
-0.0156166088,
-0.0045212726,
0.021316085,
-0.0255145337,
-0.0553691126,
-0.0426383093,
0.0159127228,
-0.0108349668,
-0.0049345247,
0.0183850918,
0.0547489971,
0.0158649888,
-0.0364117622,
0.0110496711,
0.0357322581,
-0.0935478136,
-0.0125630023,
0.0398233794,
-0.0022443193,
0.0365904309,
0.0286336988,
0.0022911341,
-0.0293778013,
0.0861659274,
-0.0426510349,
0.0867940933,
-0.0345864631,
-0.0088668121,
-0.0079561183,
-0.0109910173,
-0.0221636482,
0.1001767218,
0.0178811532,
0.0042436155,
-0.0173168462,
-0.0253277477,
0.043466527,
0.0028620884,
-0.0152744651,
-0.0063548065,
0.0201944411,
0.0060677216,
0.0058540092,
-0.0286241174,
-0.0412329771,
-0.0160351899,
-0.0428911559,
-0.0383815467,
-0.0180560872,
0.0560599938,
0.0322451331,
-0.0461330637,
0.0064466204,
-0.0201753955,
0.0171157848,
-0.0016549196,
0.0008928198,
0.0488855839,
0.0605130531,
0.0170855131,
0.0125912232,
-0.0323599838,
-0.0505668782,
-0.0771772861,
0.0685906038,
0.0341206454,
-0.0053446079,
-0.0179391876,
0.022898078,
-0.0165877119,
0.0096925441,
-0.0348350257,
-0.024223784,
0.0405425467,
-0.0328262784,
0.0450531617,
0.0334008895,
-0.0190043133,
0.0915581733,
0.0464692377,
-0.0425185561,
0.0063930717,
-0.0305688232,
-0.0500485748,
-0.0107371444,
-0.0559661351,
-0.003727552,
-0.0740191266,
0.0731026381,
0.0174179077,
-0.0109196119,
-0.0537754782,
0.0655293763,
-0.0417296253,
-0.015454283,
-0.0154956775,
0.0033695654,
-0.0329475626,
0.0709388852,
-0.018647898,
-0.0356661193,
0.0330058523,
0.0143192438,
-0.0152898561,
-0.0236353371,
0.0346922129,
-0.0292939097,
0.0962935835,
0.0788898617,
0.0056267329,
-0.0172990933,
-0.0289784856,
-0.0704251602,
0.0280686896,
0.0190757327,
-0.0167554729,
0.0294233616,
-0.0247661676,
-0.0051485836,
0.0004628487,
0.0051899538,
0.0148633393,
-0.0203861445,
-0.0464899391,
0.0367866345,
-0.0127285598,
-0.0130868349,
-0.0270547792,
0.0118659455,
0.0318134725,
0.055351641,
-0.0477571599,
0.0051797754,
-0.0310045164,
-0.0056633307,
0.0233155452,
-0.0222643837,
0.0445033796,
-0.0627295226,
0.0010327054,
-0.0078326752,
0.0592069067,
0.0234332383,
-0.0400193483,
0.0322971903,
-0.0006025083,
-0.0327000692,
-0.0557170287,
0.0281057917,
0.0292015392,
-0.0668073222,
0.0221332088,
0.124834694,
0.0248411782,
-0.0283804797,
0.0217889454,
-0.0153002832,
-0.0161458943,
0.0447988212,
0.0107926978,
-0.0650198907,
0.0020315831,
-0.0171866976,
-0.016580753,
-0.0192233138,
-0.033145722,
-0.0208311975,
-0.1157091483,
0.0100840433,
0.0333824754,
-0.0671189278,
0.0045127138,
0.0216633696,
-0.0165492967,
0.0035417296,
-0.0398268588,
0.0176424291,
-0.0161938202,
0.0415482335,
-0.0155950505,
-0.0278252047,
-0.0280249137,
0.0143370451,
0.0102222459,
0.0098244529,
0.0684572086,
0.0337133259,
-0.0614648238,
-0.0217817817,
0.0383879058,
-0.015457321,
0.0165181868,
-0.0027101664,
0.0501590967,
0.0585722588,
-0.0192295108,
-0.0083273882,
0.0077135181,
0.0021198464,
-0.016378304,
-0.0285142194,
0.0986528024,
-0.0098053124,
-0.0453882068,
0.0426123403,
0.0103815589,
-0.0265642572,
0.0416139886,
0.0565104559,
0.0169503316,
-0.0755428076,
-0.0460800603,
0.0420882553,
-0.0318469554,
-0.0670016259,
-0.0361026265,
0.0794398785,
-0.0496591926,
-0.0170323234,
-0.0367816128,
0.0083884317,
0.0202129539,
0.0082900524,
-0.0362448357,
0.0533444472,
-0.0229562912,
-0.0490508564,
0.0162895489,
-0.015655065,
0.0307159536,
-0.071300894,
-0.0305786002,
0.0179685112,
-0.0121672647,
-0.0536131933,
-0.0173524488,
-0.074740231,
-0.0352829508,
0.0304525774,
0.0247238688,
0.036306113,
-0.0012389488,
0.0030466039,
-0.0231077392,
0.0258080028,
0.0286609177,
-0.0196688175,
0.0118864756,
0.0514944755,
-0.0162306707,
0.0065218201,
0.0242276881,
0.0212138165,
0.0198390838,
-0.0035409168,
0.0056368643,
-0.0600722432,
0.0248906929,
0.0368665047,
0.0103409197,
0.05988333,
0.0376841016,
0.0218857881,
-0.0100580929,
0.001172109,
-0.0477564745,
0.0235327035,
-0.0280771963,
-0.0162524283,
0.0263775736,
0.0367666557,
-0.0406585,
-0.0815851241,
0.0240370817,
0.0202953573,
-0.029209068,
0.0286764409,
-0.0026054522,
0.0552235283,
0.0120576862,
-0.0091586141,
0.0021894712,
0.0109244278,
-0.0155221662,
0.0411045775,
-0.0037340256,
0.0251119714,
0.004146453,
0.0055840937,
-0.04505945,
-0.000931552,
-0.085132882,
-0.0548966415,
0.0194949172,
0.0019795545,
0.0453346223,
-0.0207331702,
0.0398118794,
-0.0517356172,
-0.0082297251,
-0.0102232452,
-0.0098361606,
0.0407785624,
-0.0095292516,
0.0003870016,
0.0079357056,
-0.0132217016,
-0.0393674076,
0.061302308,
0.010691232,
0.0339488797,
0.0440119393,
0.0065078926,
-0.0008864984,
-0.0468612127,
-0.0272512939,
0.0327250548,
-0.0096927453,
0.0477280654,
-0.0753722042,
-0.0640922487,
0.0009987429,
0.0098650837,
0.0111974599,
-0.0318928547,
0.0013752379,
0.0474096984,
-0.057018768,
-0.0187689085,
-0.0070361034,
0.0109404195,
0.0204962436,
0.0009460398,
-0.0504255891,
-5.937241601e-33,
-0.0411276296,
-0.0206924397,
0.0179842152,
0.0267969966,
-0.0066429139,
-0.0131708654,
-0.0509666204,
0.0087270727,
-0.0152193587,
0.0161394794,
-0.0130120488,
-0.0016067793,
0.0187520739,
-0.0100237941,
0.0094997287,
-0.0371611267,
0.0290611703,
-0.0246473271,
-0.0050952905,
0.0005010816,
0.0434727259,
0.0487036444,
0.112283431,
-0.0470347814,
0.0242805574,
0.0370170325,
-0.0185676161,
-0.0112099443,
-0.0172390491,
0.0493367836,
-0.0054738205,
0.0234422721,
0.0216082614,
-0.0537870526,
-0.0221018773,
0.0136478916,
-0.0339679904,
-0.0644552112,
0.0577301942,
0.0168549586,
0.0250113569,
-0.0086052017,
0.0109329522,
-0.0221916325,
-0.0368971452,
-0.0113518666,
0.033314351,
-0.0483232476,
0.0198299494,
-0.0022700403,
-0.0575620383,
0.0299433563,
0.0300737172,
0.0366139598,
0.032429222,
-0.006477294,
-0.0315342546,
0.0227772705,
-0.0378987007,
0.0486696623,
0.0199643094,
0.0704208314,
-0.0181539804,
-0.0074351323,
0.0233056936,
0.0199641865,
0.064179562,
0.0093636038,
-0.0382823721,
-0.0049067615,
0.0580134653,
0.0134182191,
0.0463939086,
-0.0125706755,
0.1041199565,
-0.0051977788,
-0.042683389,
-0.0446856357,
0.0466102958,
0.0334031582,
0.0236614626,
-0.016183598,
-0.0330744162,
-0.0133582819,
-0.0240544863,
-0.0264115222,
-0.0404736809,
-0.0357233658,
-0.0017783771,
-0.0404603183,
0.0148160867,
0.0663700402,
-0.0087407446,
-0.0445211679,
-0.0349272303,
0.0220475644,
0.0037042298,
0.0121638346,
-0.0078295069,
0.0368787944,
-0.0326752216,
-0.0187961645,
-0.0229560025,
-0.0141946236,
0.0435641557,
0.0180653445,
0.0030111847,
0.0441946872,
-0.0441886857,
-0.0321506038,
-0.0456549935,
-0.0316189416,
0.0297770575,
-0.0140184322,
0.0272123907,
-0.0007413745,
0.0009611438,
-0.0226307716,
0.0047837207,
-0.0127144828,
-0.010260555,
0.0144613031,
0.0044319555,
0.0730422065,
-0.0092419479,
-0.0581051633,
-0.0385613441,
0.0301843807,
0.0020161371,
-0.0428625308,
-0.0181895737,
0.0037922084,
2.814e-7,
0.0542734601,
0.0689719096,
0.0076787611,
0.057901334,
0.0393315181,
0.0053428877,
-0.0197736491,
-0.0103444168,
0.0053356704,
0.0054617682,
0.0509183407,
0.0133247199,
0.0275474917,
0.0144344615,
0.0039140838,
0.0248478856,
-0.0438013561,
0.0067112651,
-0.0334025063,
0.0444668308,
0.0519957542,
0.07290975,
0.0572085418,
0.0108798016,
-0.0017990241,
-0.0496542789,
0.0456915684,
-0.0457193218,
0.0149559714,
-0.0099779135,
-0.0016708035,
-0.0197657887,
-0.0061914651,
0.0547354706,
-0.0024719937,
0.0562977865,
-0.0024807127,
0.0539817773,
-0.0271073207,
0.0297049433,
-0.0140770655,
-0.0169130359,
-0.0321780965,
-0.0550223179,
0.0683307797,
-0.0415563546,
-0.0640019402,
0.0042899665,
-0.0155509384,
-0.0315802582,
0.0053167492,
-0.0057313759,
-0.0115335044,
-0.0118804378,
0.0143130273,
-0.0119116288,
0.0203954633,
-0.0390570574,
-0.0051491349,
0.03046632,
-0.0299565289,
-0.0810305253,
-0.0472251698,
0.0090952031,
0.0475480147,
0.014414588,
-0.0131871626,
2.631048394e-34,
0.0553907827,
-0.0047554038,
0.0257814061,
-0.0116228396,
0.0425720401,
-0.0019563048,
0.0407961272,
0.0058680782,
0.0235720109,
-0.0280208159,
-0.0492718145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00581v1 | Multimodal Graph Transformer for Multimodal Question Answering | 2023-04-30T21:22:35 | 2023-04-30T21:22:35 | Xuehai He, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the success of Transformer models in vision and language tasks, they
often learn knowledge from enormous data implicitly and cannot utilize
structured input data directly. On the other hand, structured learning
approaches such as graph neural networks (GNNs) that integrate prior
information can barely compete with Transformer models. In this work, we aim to
benefit from both worlds and propose a novel Multimodal Graph Transformer for
question answering tasks that requires performing reasoning across multiple
modalities. We introduce a graph-involved plug-and-play quasi-attention
mechanism to incorporate multimodal graph information, acquired from text and
visual data, to the vanilla self-attention as effective prior. In particular,
we construct the text graph, dense region graph, and semantic graph to generate
adjacency matrices, and then compose them with input vision and language
features to perform downstream reasoning. Such a way of regularizing
self-attention with graph information significantly improves the inferring
ability and helps align features from different modalities. We validate the
effectiveness of Multimodal Graph Transformer over its Transformer baselines on
GQA, VQAv2, and MultiModalQA datasets. | [
0.0171410553,
0.0529437065,
-0.0066752164,
0.0242840108,
-0.0114315469,
-0.0289838482,
0.0256479625,
-0.0178634804,
0.0479537025,
-0.0538286753,
-0.0363372453,
0.0052203988,
-0.0032450273,
0.0553990193,
0.064040117,
-0.0432564765,
0.0285902172,
-0.0160341952,
-0.0164509695,
0.0086253574,
0.0225768201,
0.0261416975,
-0.016257843,
0.0040738224,
-0.0624995008,
-0.0354101211,
-0.0307069905,
0.0372555666,
-0.0037010245,
-0.0298337527,
-0.0039095734,
0.0208188742,
0.0424530543,
-0.0048016771,
0.000001748,
0.0008449004,
0.0134681556,
-0.0020039061,
0.0301607475,
-0.0257840883,
-0.0116627421,
-0.0174927954,
0.0597480126,
-0.0200413335,
-0.0624129698,
-0.0559167974,
0.0772057697,
0.0226862691,
0.0849999711,
0.0452790223,
-0.0347032472,
-0.0253842846,
0.0121475346,
-0.0039156927,
0.000987936,
-0.0577574149,
-0.0084080286,
0.0454506092,
0.0307678841,
0.0002026374,
-0.0925391018,
0.0379777364,
0.0202785078,
-0.0125232926,
0.0532468669,
0.0354989395,
0.0108744334,
0.0067465552,
-0.0063318606,
0.1517211944,
-0.0070104161,
-0.0134906489,
-0.00945953,
-0.0070322412,
0.0141333761,
0.0390771925,
-0.0576520674,
0.0218999814,
-0.0140963672,
-0.013168199,
-0.0744121969,
-0.0150173251,
0.0298531055,
-0.0420577563,
-0.0232418608,
0.0811466351,
-0.0017323905,
0.0278134774,
0.0078397049,
0.0013881474,
-0.0509749502,
-0.0356981829,
-0.0140125668,
0.0669110119,
-0.0165830236,
-0.0014769854,
-0.0350432992,
-0.033485204,
-0.0159555897,
0.0164945908,
0.0503202453,
0.0097832503,
-0.0325269997,
0.0443443656,
-0.0251963455,
0.0411561392,
-0.074689433,
0.0797411799,
-0.0560756326,
-0.0479006357,
-0.0254733954,
-0.0131077254,
-0.0588608198,
0.0115505233,
-0.0098209484,
-0.0657576844,
0.0010379634,
0.0587933101,
-0.0067052795,
-0.0356303491,
0.0234099329,
0.0827286243,
-0.0121989558,
-0.0300540458,
0.0016387987,
0.075225547,
-0.0347608067,
0.0327183157,
-0.0262947977,
0.0000292767,
-0.0214845352,
0.0531605333,
0.0575072132,
-0.0291580763,
-0.0029617313,
0.0942542851,
-0.0221622474,
-0.0202635396,
-0.0039357236,
-0.0204995982,
-0.0340327993,
-0.0379527844,
0.0515512265,
-0.042365443,
0.0381935462,
0.0128513146,
-0.0092805717,
-0.0270333644,
0.0054863249,
0.0112941088,
-0.0258401744,
0.0755494907,
0.0016173844,
0.0098266685,
0.0353910811,
-0.0123866517,
-0.003105188,
0.0335945301,
0.0375425853,
0.022035839,
0.0134002957,
-0.001644359,
-0.0126508651,
0.0252389554,
0.0342860594,
-0.0075960094,
-0.0059869438,
0.0070157731,
-0.0491918847,
0.0083369799,
0.03875513,
0.0424751416,
-0.0147677623,
-0.0613699071,
0.0552240647,
0.041102428,
0.0181340575,
-0.0026165382,
0.0256795548,
0.0160898734,
-0.0113492506,
0.0070503252,
-0.052236028,
0.0915727168,
0.0186885353,
0.0256600659,
0.0285834353,
-0.0038293977,
-0.0119152293,
-0.0032769083,
0.0149592645,
-0.0062803505,
0.0675082579,
0.0316259414,
0.0438806489,
0.0518484786,
-0.0513515212,
0.0226807743,
-0.0024674693,
0.0086381882,
-0.0036897769,
0.003634925,
0.0054190527,
0.0035973014,
0.0109088914,
-0.0123974979,
-0.0329251997,
-0.0014964002,
0.0323793069,
0.0104658501,
-0.0088183712,
-0.0050264266,
0.0114453658,
-0.0422620811,
-0.0493971445,
-0.0594367832,
-0.0356869735,
0.0156041794,
0.0156896003,
-0.0161232967,
-0.0004425939,
-0.0932731628,
0.0518807694,
0.0086865239,
0.0412650295,
0.0179483369,
-0.0101055531,
0.0112581924,
-0.0092104124,
0.0000216453,
0.0160098523,
0.0208499059,
0.0022756138,
-0.0281213522,
-0.0220514815,
-0.0046439585,
-0.0527845956,
-0.040504463,
0.0274290647,
-0.0637735352,
-0.0176520571,
0.0032600532,
-0.0515428558,
-0.0249028653,
0.0572214983,
-0.0814271718,
-0.0112179015,
-0.0146254357,
-0.0502940118,
0.0561165437,
0.0366417505,
-0.0112841744,
0.0369387567,
-0.0232734308,
-0.0035654486,
-0.0047837496,
0.016699167,
0.0149733061,
-0.0236472692,
0.0284948777,
0.0026080678,
0.0101510668,
0.0001965222,
-0.004298124,
-0.0168082099,
-0.044194527,
0.0356082506,
-0.1020461693,
-0.0070619872,
0.0037629018,
-0.0202292297,
0.0237467736,
0.035817638,
0.0193721186,
-0.0634642318,
-0.0728273764,
0.047205884,
0.0160925258,
0.0190713238,
0.0554075763,
-0.0173091497,
0.0425284803,
-0.0137516754,
-0.0386841707,
-0.0232220553,
0.1052545384,
0.0200049747,
-0.0188997872,
-0.0284377933,
-0.0265098941,
-0.0423697904,
0.0563076064,
0.0043119015,
-0.011171435,
0.0253990293,
-0.0287690498,
0.0484997034,
0.0712846443,
-0.0066230465,
-0.0138109149,
0.0356376506,
-0.0306242928,
-0.0361967422,
0.028634863,
-0.0104257911,
-0.0083218878,
-0.0117659215,
-0.0204946287,
-0.0233405456,
0.0200038794,
0.0223920997,
-0.0267451946,
-0.0367719978,
0.0128203537,
0.0463292561,
-0.0092816902,
-0.0183119457,
0.0180529393,
0.0208261311,
-0.0001353262,
-0.039959833,
-0.0148782721,
0.0775136724,
0.0004655949,
-0.036023505,
0.045894336,
0.0117105516,
-0.0592949055,
0.0734883025,
0.0481524952,
0.0315230526,
-0.0216612406,
-0.0321448557,
-0.0753990859,
-0.0218625274,
0.0244560204,
0.0024808238,
0.0542236902,
0.021870615,
0.0317107141,
-0.0060868044,
-0.0046820031,
-0.0104210954,
-0.011972785,
-0.0206181034,
0.0064998078,
-0.0170547087,
-0.0245862957,
-0.0064990576,
0.0171647929,
0.0128394375,
0.0161459111,
-0.0122687127,
-0.0083784573,
-0.0111487815,
0.0904486254,
0.0512283593,
0.0733936802,
-0.005561986,
-0.0375303663,
-0.0264326707,
0.0632559136,
0.0014496392,
-0.032850083,
-0.0502667651,
0.0267558005,
0.0031387787,
0.0231166333,
0.003512624,
0.0005335576,
0.0524438843,
-0.0393139645,
0.0051147244,
0.0387152992,
-0.0185983572,
-0.0298271831,
0.0089458525,
0.0104811713,
0.0192300435,
0.049455449,
0.0303252861,
-0.1150156409,
-0.0549196377,
-0.0481448025,
0.005797415,
0.0692798197,
-0.0386146419,
-0.0174251962,
-0.0655302331,
0.0068351468,
-0.0062314309,
-0.0185164846,
-0.0079963077,
-0.0159848463,
0.0221408103,
0.0037268093,
-0.0200000294,
-0.0245409366,
-0.0275935363,
-0.0076532001,
-0.0096279914,
0.0161428154,
0.0202063955,
0.0188271552,
-0.0147073008,
-0.0141191138,
-0.0284859855,
0.0118842851,
0.0061558145,
-0.0291408058,
0.0344088189,
0.0014809216,
0.0088905459,
0.0186006017,
0.0603100024,
-0.0312092211,
-0.0332967043,
-0.0181470942,
0.0123465322,
-0.0258797091,
-0.0389890522,
-0.0455898456,
0.0813797936,
-0.0006093298,
-0.032932613,
-0.0303420797,
0.0258158948,
-0.0183456037,
-0.0041556731,
0.0197410304,
-0.0046486175,
-0.0598055534,
-0.0011313341,
0.0178296957,
-0.0460368916,
-0.0526511297,
0.0312325731,
0.027218096,
0.0092235561,
-0.0480018221,
-0.0188695397,
0.0259120278,
0.039518483,
-0.026680205,
-0.0263189431,
0.038384594,
-0.0021900241,
-0.0778664872,
0.0662225783,
-0.0302474536,
0.0124850292,
-0.0204515047,
-0.0123771643,
-0.0110736005,
-0.0232293401,
-0.002755993,
0.0210448448,
-0.0870031118,
-0.0502533354,
-0.0446953028,
0.0500709601,
0.0012638213,
0.0383145325,
-0.0080320071,
-0.00592741,
0.0050882259,
0.001726086,
-0.0291059799,
0.0075921421,
0.0016669283,
-0.0374622121,
-0.0042829118,
0.0238707587,
-0.0554879792,
-0.0046721599,
0.0079102982,
0.0475192145,
-0.0266230423,
-0.0585111044,
0.0059153778,
0.0104349526,
0.0174748898,
0.0231112428,
0.0503570437,
-0.03483494,
-0.0059057027,
0.0085141929,
-0.0180705655,
-0.0517766885,
0.0078078313,
-0.0046742833,
-0.0233774334,
0.0018071762,
-0.0253536925,
0.0072175595,
0.0256938078,
-0.0182481278,
0.0025323029,
0.0375591703,
-0.0607456602,
0.0144492332,
0.0086419135,
-0.0039503817,
0.0212881006,
0.0187863093,
0.0548384972,
0.0026191536,
0.0772736594,
0.0213868096,
-0.0568733178,
-0.0680942014,
0.0138983149,
-0.0654128119,
-0.0272068772,
-0.0158218574,
0.0035443481,
0.046199359,
0.0218024626,
0.0044477051,
0.0228088871,
-0.0080882991,
0.0087732999,
0.0623705275,
-0.0024025338,
-0.0379820839,
0.0476606116,
0.012967634,
0.0142870247,
0.0388552323,
0.0500372648,
0.0320408233,
0.0077873045,
0.005815872,
-0.0191452242,
-0.0289245527,
-0.0344715416,
-0.0018479186,
0.0232164096,
0.0000107351,
0.0328783169,
-0.0044333492,
-0.0904668868,
0.011284275,
0.0033935828,
-0.0337068439,
0.0169207752,
0.0263571385,
0.018549731,
0.0683047771,
-0.053062778,
-0.0379159264,
0.0689132661,
0.0029794101,
0.0064864033,
0.0192018878,
-5.958936819e-33,
-0.0282143559,
-0.087289229,
0.0080155069,
-0.0224860534,
-0.0365634561,
0.0009516731,
-0.0503348671,
-0.0007416785,
-0.0449349321,
0.0090442011,
-0.0041664871,
0.0178679246,
-0.0120699108,
0.0427993909,
-0.0223222785,
-0.026604645,
-0.0005747558,
0.0151244085,
-0.0081265857,
0.0250533335,
0.0349214971,
0.0243883524,
0.0707805529,
-0.0556071289,
0.0016065126,
-0.0023494833,
0.0122913308,
0.017033929,
-0.0009021755,
0.0662144944,
-0.0221163165,
0.0409350991,
0.0327435508,
0.0084709888,
-0.0187456608,
0.0313718393,
-0.1279085129,
-0.0251533482,
0.0079834657,
0.0340452604,
-0.0973956659,
0.0015574936,
0.0539543927,
-0.0316795781,
0.0600103624,
-0.0779929906,
0.0431158133,
0.0211689435,
-0.0022670468,
-0.0023246596,
-0.0177976247,
-0.0013835075,
-0.0326958783,
-0.0093365982,
-0.0116202999,
0.0520860329,
0.0237250216,
-0.0037076685,
-0.0424795598,
0.0014767179,
-0.0863884389,
-0.0078911046,
0.0616448335,
0.0546344481,
-0.0030763873,
0.030244289,
0.0202218033,
-0.0344345681,
-0.0546038374,
-0.0008913621,
-0.0025130319,
0.0447020791,
0.0081122778,
0.0165117178,
-0.0247782134,
0.0190961789,
-0.0611311831,
-0.0035534755,
-0.0728641301,
0.062101122,
-0.008542967,
0.0069154673,
0.0291685537,
-0.0239276029,
-0.0041682143,
0.0226272568,
-0.0419732034,
-0.0134823667,
0.0099569885,
-0.019378202,
-0.0108578485,
0.0743987709,
0.0525125042,
-0.061376553,
-0.0044853776,
0.0670843348,
0.0122720646,
0.0544642955,
-0.0003503533,
0.0605011955,
-0.0085537238,
0.0372080319,
0.0574659035,
-0.0173732117,
0.0162595734,
0.0396901816,
0.0245471541,
0.0385368317,
-0.0455218367,
-0.0538134091,
-0.0415796749,
-0.0255647041,
-0.0573211275,
0.0218108557,
0.0449489057,
0.0362204798,
-0.0610987693,
0.0457109921,
-0.0131392572,
0.0425756834,
-0.0255000163,
-0.0001188239,
0.0214954205,
0.0357854404,
-0.0219047498,
0.0085800942,
-0.0506663658,
-0.0083733061,
0.0003582243,
-0.0737864971,
-0.0155622186,
0.0613097548,
2.536e-7,
0.0833670497,
0.0099101514,
0.0200389121,
0.0177842267,
-0.008534126,
0.0277899988,
0.0028117697,
0.0479820855,
0.0176981669,
-0.0465713479,
0.0056213252,
0.0759875998,
-0.0223954525,
0.0316265039,
-0.0209107343,
0.010164517,
-0.0398314819,
-0.0068539134,
-0.0337620899,
0.0083718644,
0.0519312583,
0.0421908833,
-0.0152389845,
-0.018125236,
-0.0004062472,
-0.0587453023,
0.0671032518,
0.0423233621,
0.0084800757,
-0.0260027349,
0.0143051548,
-0.0371201448,
-0.0135552492,
0.0246994384,
0.008043603,
-0.0089687249,
0.0413020067,
0.0177196432,
-0.0241130665,
-0.0424162783,
-0.0364632197,
-0.0124597242,
0.0083596623,
-0.0250575114,
0.085103415,
-0.0699169189,
-0.0606174543,
-0.0206567328,
-0.0449291915,
-0.0033843727,
-0.0008914972,
0.0031257542,
-0.0305002388,
0.0293570124,
0.0433281958,
-0.0183282364,
-0.0123192314,
-0.0755630136,
-0.0306127146,
0.0230217483,
-0.0308560207,
-0.0058325841,
-0.0180565864,
-0.021911215,
0.0540677235,
-0.0082962317,
-0.0258747041,
1.647616619e-34,
-0.0015006009,
0.0209519267,
0.0138084721,
-0.0152697293,
0.0133680832,
-0.0508090742,
-0.0114954077,
-0.0226901304,
0.0381303504,
-0.0856808126,
-0.0381629057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00522v1 | How to enumerate trees from a context-free grammar | 2023-04-30T16:40:54 | 2023-04-30T16:40:54 | Steven T. Piantadosi | cs.CL | cs.CL | I present a simple algorithm for enumerating the trees generated by a Context
Free Grammar (CFG). The algorithm uses a pairing function to form a bijection
between CFG derivations and natural numbers, so that trees can be uniquely
decoded from counting. This provides a general way to number expressions in
natural logical languages, and potentially can be extended to other
combinatorial problems. I also show how this algorithm may be generalized to
more general forms of derivation, including analogs of Lempel-Ziv coding on
trees. | [
-0.0217742398,
0.0256376602,
-0.0340856872,
0.0965046883,
-0.0171266124,
0.0034810912,
-0.0341638029,
-0.0173079334,
-0.0694792941,
0.0043476303,
0.0093572047,
-0.0182012971,
0.0156232994,
-0.0188496262,
-0.0040081805,
-0.0009076653,
0.0076308837,
-0.0670837536,
-0.0351633728,
-0.0114552481,
-0.0292078815,
0.0460711531,
-0.0235196557,
-0.0405328199,
-0.0150926355,
-0.0790897682,
-0.0385866053,
-0.0248426031,
0.0114495633,
-0.0051642857,
-0.0908706784,
-0.0249140356,
-0.0379559733,
0.0022377437,
0.0000016215,
-0.0140309241,
-0.0746655688,
0.0313445702,
-0.107432276,
0.0053635943,
0.0295285583,
0.0319063924,
0.0023696856,
0.0264727362,
-0.019526206,
0.0219644029,
0.0225632377,
-0.0501798503,
0.056087479,
0.0642610788,
0.0155942608,
-0.1082630679,
0.0242983587,
0.0377093963,
0.015740471,
0.0186675191,
-0.0100036664,
-0.0038907663,
-0.0092888959,
-0.0332873799,
0.0200802814,
-0.0489210375,
0.0238246284,
-0.0552624837,
-0.0062896213,
0.042060595,
-0.0172560532,
-0.0080752717,
-0.0203974601,
-0.0083694188,
0.0090127969,
-0.0308472756,
0.0124610979,
0.0006314715,
0.0044315285,
-0.0648198649,
-0.0234624986,
0.0800205395,
0.0140379583,
0.0299831051,
0.0972524509,
0.0060599674,
-0.002028761,
-0.075844042,
0.0204297956,
0.0459101386,
0.0643576533,
0.0198012125,
-0.0198731571,
-0.0004285432,
0.0049754819,
-0.0525693744,
-0.0233829971,
0.0238058958,
-0.0197178423,
0.0195039175,
-0.0099309199,
0.0188716538,
-0.0066639064,
-0.0107823163,
0.0025906395,
0.005341995,
0.0335394219,
0.0088695167,
0.0095515102,
0.0191396549,
0.0197187196,
0.020313412,
-0.0419163071,
-0.0005252127,
-0.0130334292,
-0.0558442026,
-0.1145645306,
0.0286742244,
-0.0227234084,
0.0080740768,
-0.0286347903,
0.0442939289,
0.0271080006,
0.0033697814,
0.014312244,
-0.0431449041,
0.0216770805,
0.0567049012,
0.0655051023,
-0.0378929228,
-0.0373197757,
-0.0399794355,
0.0065881256,
-0.0730263516,
-0.0190198757,
0.0378317572,
0.0343208723,
-0.0236268621,
-0.0554585196,
0.0342015512,
0.0240373556,
0.0147388028,
0.0323693901,
-0.019404076,
-0.031080775,
0.0241792034,
0.0419046544,
-0.0747038275,
-0.0271434765,
-0.0035335193,
0.0132705262,
-0.0340266451,
-0.018421337,
-0.0427987315,
0.0197942257,
-0.0313100033,
-0.0520201027,
-0.0106636984,
-0.029121777,
-0.0288908612,
0.0033388173,
0.0172336828,
0.0579928011,
0.0170816798,
0.0442461222,
-0.0262547433,
0.0169138126,
-0.0022231161,
-0.0381646194,
0.0032130023,
0.0140379844,
-0.0299892575,
-0.0006831126,
-0.038150128,
-0.0336560942,
0.0568312593,
-0.0240268558,
-0.0754671544,
-0.0621550083,
0.0188729651,
0.0563234501,
0.0234665703,
0.0246286802,
-0.0374924541,
0.0332770199,
0.0142212752,
0.0323706903,
-0.0219701137,
-0.0210973099,
-0.0272483006,
-0.0448436588,
-0.0125601524,
0.0300529022,
-0.0039998293,
0.0134099526,
0.0207929499,
0.0081636822,
-0.0730958953,
0.0083457073,
0.0094046835,
0.0581387877,
-0.010143945,
0.0117094088,
-0.0537101254,
-0.0290332921,
0.0229911599,
0.0247521792,
0.0144543536,
-0.0201869886,
-0.0160259251,
-0.0124965319,
0.0472958572,
-0.0323882177,
0.0294899996,
-0.0222438555,
-0.0200643353,
0.049900014,
0.0376343131,
0.0136456424,
-0.0101186587,
0.0368644223,
0.0545903891,
-0.0599107556,
-0.0076736119,
-0.0153716477,
0.0102841305,
-0.0017776425,
0.0119391382,
0.0079033412,
0.0046358402,
0.0179903638,
-0.0070622535,
0.0137995193,
0.0327399895,
-0.0253609233,
0.0698739067,
0.0901573375,
-0.0123172021,
0.019491367,
0.0123870317,
-0.0026611867,
-0.0539466739,
0.0560544245,
-0.0300812442,
-0.0315637216,
-0.0358879752,
-0.0261225235,
-0.0076463707,
0.0525059402,
-0.0586385801,
0.0562507249,
-0.005142475,
0.0476890877,
0.0065931361,
-0.0483759716,
0.0366883911,
0.0638870597,
0.0327303112,
0.0268242676,
-0.0197360162,
-0.0025072268,
0.0081546027,
-0.0022858458,
0.0420725755,
-0.0027259225,
-0.0113284243,
-0.0312438197,
0.0155877061,
0.0534052588,
-0.0386664122,
-0.0016369108,
-0.0179040451,
0.004268589,
-0.0353245065,
0.0866167769,
0.022239821,
-0.002190762,
0.0237782802,
0.0119355507,
-0.0468490906,
0.0137419058,
0.0433052219,
-0.0074552298,
0.0024400051,
-0.0134541662,
-0.0992558599,
0.0044333213,
0.0040795398,
-0.0149684167,
0.0543981902,
-0.0325715169,
-0.033489123,
-0.0038380357,
0.0058542974,
-0.0087672481,
0.0264507141,
-0.0117964651,
0.0392240994,
0.042718403,
-0.053968817,
-0.0261228755,
-0.0231221095,
-0.0253657922,
0.0421287641,
-0.0044851187,
0.0039692745,
0.0345955342,
-0.0461122468,
-0.0031926353,
-0.0156387612,
0.004790558,
-0.0175299402,
0.0245724544,
0.0581931919,
-0.0212682765,
0.0111392196,
-0.0162008386,
0.0180700701,
0.0071110437,
0.0106406854,
0.0046033356,
-0.042390883,
-0.0242919829,
0.0287142172,
0.0213732943,
-0.0086939968,
-0.0136112962,
-0.0424758531,
-0.0129141612,
-0.0284847673,
0.0086617535,
-0.0348061509,
0.0821116716,
0.044477243,
0.0444459543,
0.0559495389,
-0.0255616736,
0.0115977731,
0.0230026245,
0.0508673079,
-0.0265660752,
-0.0123284189,
-0.0610519536,
0.0054010744,
-0.0459089726,
-0.0525923073,
-0.0518074632,
-0.0035475255,
0.0148377009,
0.0036098915,
0.0522812195,
0.0244204365,
0.0090447329,
-0.0091998046,
0.0352704339,
-0.0100180451,
0.0217825659,
0.0232500043,
0.009619372,
0.0625297725,
-0.0144436844,
0.0068296245,
0.0198285915,
0.0069707017,
0.0077554514,
0.0422069505,
0.0025819219,
0.1089906245,
0.0192198996,
0.0348233134,
-0.0018845539,
-0.0013722839,
-0.0454295017,
0.0524185896,
-0.023585584,
0.0135072144,
-0.0490139239,
0.0372186229,
0.0495890565,
-0.0366546698,
0.052681122,
-0.0800880343,
-0.00693268,
-0.0003649941,
0.0026238584,
-0.0959481448,
-0.0046785036,
-0.0172639061,
-0.0336190648,
-0.0344787501,
0.0168693848,
0.0020152438,
-0.09422566,
-0.0166917797,
0.0356632061,
-0.0504048839,
-0.0343538746,
-0.0086411582,
-0.0035025985,
0.0462631807,
-0.0836190954,
0.0664809719,
-0.0090560624,
0.0418079495,
0.1060713455,
-0.0148756076,
-0.0096916594,
-0.0402908623,
0.0403817482,
0.0173196867,
0.0595345274,
0.0428726673,
-0.012172563,
-0.0463629067,
-0.011829921,
-0.0591831803,
-0.0224480908,
-0.0364102162,
-0.0905129761,
0.0271411911,
0.0111461505,
0.025680393,
0.0032282069,
-0.0211262386,
0.0062810108,
0.0282618217,
0.0283086989,
0.0187366549,
-0.0361563116,
0.0461584367,
-0.0151596731,
-0.032541208,
0.0047314423,
0.0294002537,
0.048093684,
0.0038041875,
-0.123188518,
0.0311764814,
0.0226877294,
-0.0446511507,
0.0399373509,
-0.008241686,
-0.0633762926,
-0.0550398305,
0.0471215025,
0.0370303653,
0.0294793192,
-0.0490821227,
-0.0330658741,
0.0357467309,
-0.0164359827,
-0.0099596484,
-0.061989937,
-0.0622883551,
0.0324327126,
-0.0350214504,
-0.0053361012,
-0.0106191644,
0.0438662618,
-0.0358730033,
-0.005102593,
-0.0039357068,
-0.0453104451,
0.0113459006,
0.0585666001,
0.0213734061,
-0.0262439679,
-0.0078361146,
0.0520980507,
-0.1010574996,
0.1025772914,
-0.0384865366,
0.0177611299,
-0.0013013658,
-0.0356250145,
0.0150885433,
0.0245056469,
-0.0259080753,
0.0236098766,
0.0470108576,
0.0357016027,
-0.06946861,
0.0520684756,
0.0393842086,
0.0814392045,
0.0023624124,
0.0106128771,
-0.0027224454,
0.0532449782,
-0.0086805141,
-0.060230758,
-0.0569003671,
-0.0357588567,
0.0222486034,
-0.0477843471,
0.0039322516,
-0.0092711365,
-0.0484514236,
0.0287190396,
0.0151749281,
0.0017547219,
0.0093445359,
0.0880838111,
0.0256864466,
-0.0091993818,
-0.0015710148,
-0.0064726942,
-0.0137104588,
0.0056386762,
0.0189691316,
0.0034064022,
-0.0274117216,
0.0180908367,
0.0037768667,
-0.0502230451,
-0.0148730725,
0.0140914125,
-0.0124344332,
0.0096255764,
0.0134797515,
0.0484133773,
0.0499306768,
0.0265130345,
-0.0273514986,
0.0202610046,
-0.0241019018,
-0.0069497474,
0.0185764693,
-0.0201621857,
-0.0311902892,
0.0274286456,
-0.0090066073,
-0.0609159693,
0.0753064901,
-0.0005324194,
-0.0414391495,
0.0047300076,
-0.0110030621,
-0.02118898,
-0.0068783821,
-0.0156468358,
0.0021989837,
0.0567522049,
0.0280128419,
-0.0427533127,
-0.0450811386,
0.0031647729,
0.0084993904,
0.1050751582,
0.0138689214,
0.0617311336,
0.0060183625,
0.0262507573,
-0.0462490916,
-0.0375027061,
0.0273215938,
-0.0379699543,
-0.0071425959,
-0.0107863592,
-4.86948645e-33,
-0.0731160417,
-0.0231859721,
-0.0385586098,
0.063249886,
-0.0142847635,
-0.0075130025,
-0.0439082757,
0.0386978537,
0.0367572531,
-0.0049859718,
0.019044064,
0.0083023645,
0.0065642572,
-0.02075441,
0.0181955434,
0.0108324261,
-0.0331741795,
-0.0169527363,
-0.0627725646,
-0.0077698524,
0.0470378958,
-0.04164996,
0.0451000668,
0.0069817551,
0.017394824,
-0.0205955654,
0.0304148812,
-0.0146725019,
-0.0531499647,
0.0131037785,
0.0097755669,
-0.02861204,
-0.0061678137,
-0.0258147214,
0.0110453544,
0.0085944654,
-0.0168423746,
-0.0722890571,
0.0571344756,
-0.0243419372,
0.0104803722,
-0.0422132127,
-0.0138225053,
0.0021322903,
0.0049480484,
0.045866929,
-0.0025270372,
0.0058845719,
-0.0566268116,
-0.0278905984,
0.0217470042,
0.0390510596,
-0.0251464564,
0.0437409393,
-0.0154332574,
-0.0173978601,
-0.0431183055,
-0.0106433509,
0.0161195956,
0.0318807214,
0.0432510488,
-0.0218105186,
-0.0171589926,
-0.0289641861,
0.0214902088,
-0.0078732995,
0.030521486,
-0.0635391101,
-0.0289960019,
0.0704712868,
-0.0507874265,
0.0384299718,
0.0277520102,
0.0072413771,
0.0812094137,
0.0318612605,
-0.0586191528,
0.0069783595,
-0.013112979,
0.005343487,
0.0242637005,
0.0129699521,
0.0167399123,
-0.0519290864,
0.0077540185,
0.0294001792,
0.0137391528,
0.0242834408,
-0.0063880337,
-0.0226471499,
-0.0874869823,
0.0323890597,
0.0191173814,
-0.0179598071,
-0.0474694483,
0.0397882089,
0.0091015808,
0.0360877588,
-0.0233934186,
0.0226204079,
0.0232646056,
-0.0312247183,
0.006286304,
-0.0501225963,
0.0489276648,
0.0202606339,
-0.0256259311,
-0.0081838947,
-0.0144468257,
-0.0111676464,
-0.0195301399,
0.0034424237,
-0.043773707,
0.0299871136,
0.0116657782,
-0.0020656923,
0.0282698721,
-0.0365222432,
-0.0057634343,
-0.0155788837,
-0.0030774649,
-0.0033611178,
-0.0279398095,
-0.0036827056,
-0.0276704058,
-0.0215405449,
-0.0002987917,
0.0162291862,
0.0669848099,
0.0278607141,
0.0107483789,
0.0163983032,
2.452e-7,
0.0415877737,
-0.0356800593,
0.0669935942,
0.0525737852,
0.0828921646,
-0.0229432322,
0.0015451466,
0.0288185868,
0.0096038319,
-0.0331279077,
-0.0347378068,
-0.0008958843,
-0.0016576713,
0.0385509916,
0.0211038366,
0.0440450422,
-0.0185666159,
-0.0135813188,
0.0590079837,
0.0190418847,
0.0134348786,
0.0250853784,
-0.0188421719,
0.0274910349,
-0.0048608785,
-0.0050425921,
-0.0077395053,
-0.0036090366,
0.057754837,
-0.0410200991,
-0.0105425362,
-0.0986289009,
0.0419778936,
0.0018497291,
0.0056561553,
0.0081358999,
0.0063140262,
0.0307056513,
-0.0384850428,
0.0801044926,
0.0306452569,
-0.0422778577,
0.0245656446,
0.0438527018,
0.0098205041,
-0.0014490042,
-0.0377294756,
0.0120958099,
-0.0486577824,
0.0072580278,
-0.0612128787,
0.0616669953,
-0.0595816933,
0.0049437913,
0.0305057578,
-0.0650256351,
0.0134702427,
0.0003111353,
-0.0331089087,
-0.032181982,
-0.0062044258,
-0.029138105,
0.0321989283,
0.0594408549,
-0.0434679352,
0.0443937555,
0.009548354,
2.17228027e-34,
0.0113568725,
0.0145100513,
0.0132708913,
0.0477950536,
0.0100679146,
-0.0100700352,
-0.0136182867,
0.009693129,
0.0247059241,
-0.0241622329,
-0.0358127356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03169v2 | Sensitive Data Detection with High-Throughput Machine Learning Models in Electrical Health Records | 2023-04-30T16:14:23 | 2023-05-22T00:07:33 | Kai Zhang, Xiaoqian Jiang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | In the era of big data, there is an increasing need for healthcare providers,
communities, and researchers to share data and collaborate to improve health
outcomes, generate valuable insights, and advance research. The Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) is a federal law
designed to protect sensitive health information by defining regulations for
protected health information (PHI). However, it does not provide efficient
tools for detecting or removing PHI before data sharing. One of the challenges
in this area of research is the heterogeneous nature of PHI fields in data
across different parties. This variability makes rule-based sensitive variable
identification systems that work on one database fail on another. To address
this issue, our paper explores the use of machine learning algorithms to
identify sensitive variables in structured data, thus facilitating the
de-identification process. We made a key observation that the distributions of
metadata of PHI fields and non-PHI fields are very different. Based on this
novel finding, we engineered over 30 features from the metadata of the original
features and used machine learning to build classification models to
automatically identify PHI fields in structured Electronic Health Record (EHR)
data. We trained the model on a variety of large EHR databases from different
data sources and found that our algorithm achieves 99% accuracy when detecting
PHI-related fields for unseen datasets. The implications of our study are
significant and can benefit industries that handle sensitive data. | [
0.0051136697,
0.0840068832,
-0.0319948494,
-0.0381355472,
-0.0275139473,
0.0451019481,
0.0175619368,
-0.0059938529,
0.0284365695,
-0.0017682273,
0.0600871034,
0.0128536606,
0.0026105037,
0.080398187,
-0.0233248826,
0.0001555333,
0.0359436646,
0.0451300591,
0.0385872349,
0.0163802039,
-0.0367258005,
-0.0187751856,
0.024518732,
0.0376685075,
-0.0034157108,
0.0054451679,
-0.0067633786,
-0.0143784285,
0.0217214487,
-0.0335784778,
0.0265120063,
0.0084881755,
-0.039209839,
0.0069467872,
0.0000020345,
-0.0310890004,
-0.0670585111,
0.0319505073,
-0.0637790412,
-0.0164853055,
-0.0030849357,
-0.0779996663,
0.0112754675,
0.0051074959,
-0.006458377,
-0.0589555092,
0.0276733469,
0.033597853,
0.0546065904,
0.0251017027,
-0.0517996773,
0.0200269166,
0.0063439612,
0.008328788,
0.0148612848,
-0.0317494422,
0.0598687604,
-0.0398422442,
-0.0126293777,
-0.0304444265,
0.0336153172,
0.0414554104,
-0.0153702553,
0.0591069348,
-0.0087626064,
0.0137455361,
-0.0359036289,
0.0504057258,
-0.0374118499,
0.0634580106,
-0.0368019603,
-0.0164655279,
0.0669347718,
-0.0253066588,
0.0062927287,
0.0179577935,
0.0093937051,
0.0030174938,
-0.0338320471,
-0.021520609,
-0.020962812,
-0.0086498912,
0.0385559872,
-0.0100801755,
-0.011526281,
0.0005373173,
-0.011811316,
-0.0166684035,
-0.003015795,
-0.0591573641,
0.0158383995,
-0.0350421071,
0.0403388031,
0.0126817189,
0.0033722415,
0.0116462074,
-0.0498427562,
-0.0197629686,
0.0586318746,
-0.0376621932,
-0.0201874152,
-0.0224569775,
0.0216215476,
0.0499476567,
0.0260430258,
-0.0155697688,
-0.0280847773,
0.0360096619,
0.0025510038,
0.0022870179,
-0.0364689715,
-0.0050277077,
0.0470420532,
0.049285356,
0.0171785504,
0.0297361072,
-0.0512143821,
0.0117204543,
-0.0454901233,
0.0565764979,
-0.0401506387,
0.0140399132,
0.0296675339,
0.0147026908,
-0.0026245273,
-0.0517793149,
-0.0012492574,
0.0417637378,
-0.018754907,
-0.0293988176,
0.026012009,
-0.0017574717,
0.0682177171,
0.0223012697,
0.0132608619,
0.0529956445,
0.0769890398,
-0.0042235861,
-0.0531223007,
-0.0782929584,
0.0103677968,
0.0326710641,
0.0306700263,
0.0145247784,
-0.0082782656,
-0.0202366989,
-0.0158860497,
-0.0696671009,
-0.034298636,
0.0088493973,
-0.0580266938,
0.0574881658,
-0.0236566216,
0.0058962689,
0.0205923636,
0.0081700403,
-0.0316718817,
-0.0296947081,
-0.010275078,
0.0145774772,
0.0229720455,
-0.0561628714,
0.0597866252,
0.0108446199,
0.0268691089,
-0.0613256916,
0.0495495275,
-0.0022043528,
0.0396229029,
-0.0090018278,
-0.0570780747,
0.026323406,
0.0099846609,
-0.0785222948,
0.0470147952,
0.0419161804,
-0.0162195638,
0.0030698413,
-0.0293097217,
0.0462290943,
-0.0214640889,
-0.04617339,
-0.0032559172,
-0.0393106192,
-0.0317679457,
-0.0514378846,
-0.0833948553,
-0.000121444,
-0.0512668714,
-0.0152848233,
-0.0296839625,
-0.0630507022,
-0.0126828384,
0.0094198165,
0.0155888572,
0.0173615608,
0.0055938126,
0.041346699,
0.0139814978,
0.0016018725,
-0.0493827499,
-0.0680717006,
-0.0208994318,
0.057765469,
0.0226825885,
-0.0375768282,
-0.0041021062,
-0.0626194254,
0.0265213102,
-0.0682177767,
-0.0144243967,
-0.013758596,
0.0433952846,
-0.0135083692,
-0.0112469792,
0.0418995507,
0.0444441214,
0.0037405705,
-0.0192730948,
-0.0044646394,
-0.0053449874,
-0.0252619945,
-0.0307402276,
0.0446810834,
-0.0352701657,
-0.0320799761,
0.0423724428,
0.0495284498,
0.0409380794,
0.0126906866,
0.0251330324,
0.0255574062,
0.0246492662,
-0.0131197898,
-0.0022727333,
-0.0153242284,
0.0354699194,
0.0700288638,
-0.027675584,
-0.0129232239,
-0.0074144946,
0.0112303989,
-0.032098785,
0.0243358333,
-0.0127228806,
-0.0244698934,
-0.0453830101,
-0.0109700868,
0.0303496774,
0.0323418081,
0.0310378037,
-0.0409403555,
0.0147666447,
-0.0427991636,
-0.0151423542,
-0.0140928524,
-0.078545399,
0.0425396673,
-0.011262998,
0.0450041667,
-0.0387551039,
-0.0508459359,
0.0264172405,
-0.0284883268,
-0.058263056,
-0.0070132664,
0.0258846749,
-0.0008933726,
-0.0053905179,
0.0061655887,
0.0315269269,
0.0026930063,
0.0182220303,
-0.0064319568,
-0.0398055501,
-0.0033462178,
-0.0385215469,
-0.0242693387,
0.0229822304,
0.0292945486,
0.0310480334,
-0.0471972674,
0.0371911861,
-0.0208341628,
-0.034622699,
0.084365353,
-0.0044863909,
-0.0042389836,
0.0080830827,
-0.0346859545,
0.0058649727,
-0.0083672451,
-0.0101976814,
0.0226393305,
-0.0498513132,
0.02713334,
-0.0342729688,
0.0219158195,
-0.0328719467,
0.0446068086,
-0.0056684143,
0.0073070787,
0.0111689428,
0.0080398638,
-0.0284878276,
0.0185310226,
0.0358930789,
-0.0199562572,
0.0621514283,
-0.0290879849,
0.0273648687,
-0.0092979418,
-0.0098438859,
0.0656799898,
0.0210908614,
-0.0185074601,
-0.0572749972,
-0.0012415474,
-0.0014945554,
0.0389807522,
0.0019486729,
-0.0247080103,
0.0428621359,
0.0396786667,
0.0758083388,
-0.0213554204,
-0.0464138016,
-0.0285639688,
0.019024523,
-0.0017950396,
0.028929485,
0.0538745821,
-0.0426365882,
0.0246639587,
0.025584789,
0.0212773476,
-0.0643298775,
-0.0070853778,
-0.0084866676,
-0.0262303054,
0.0257109758,
-0.0285922457,
-0.046457693,
-0.0409083627,
0.0319459997,
0.0305243805,
0.0064373449,
0.02483836,
-0.0305374078,
-0.0003858647,
-0.0361957364,
0.079337053,
0.054314848,
0.009771185,
0.0087968064,
0.02037232,
-0.0081484122,
-0.0776923597,
0.004748601,
-0.0066031259,
0.0139850155,
0.0369163081,
0.0322509073,
0.0256955884,
-0.0092067197,
0.0341388248,
-0.0433976799,
-0.0673736855,
0.0170861762,
0.024247976,
-0.0532652549,
-0.036679212,
0.0380679145,
0.0141911367,
0.0251664706,
-0.0280441195,
0.0420833901,
0.0157904718,
-0.0709885582,
-0.0232261457,
-0.002477386,
-0.0611038953,
0.013802534,
0.0279581882,
0.0033376967,
-0.0468169525,
-0.076223813,
0.0251251943,
-0.0187123716,
0.0316660926,
-0.0105455946,
-0.0012289606,
-0.0885649621,
-0.0450816043,
0.0294457115,
-0.0401438959,
0.0000412704,
-0.0721624568,
-0.0262318626,
-0.0268339105,
-0.0206827521,
-0.0439937711,
-0.0743344873,
0.015159362,
-0.0293197669,
0.0270571541,
0.0558588542,
0.0276162624,
-0.0434612185,
-0.0339541323,
-0.0000738779,
0.0529645011,
-0.0173387565,
-0.0023374441,
0.1279643923,
0.0136166913,
-0.0016256248,
-0.0253962651,
0.0630231574,
0.0004227631,
-0.0089023327,
0.0240745656,
0.0583555959,
-0.0753622949,
-0.0281366222,
-0.0016462855,
-0.0277028382,
0.050120838,
0.0262401756,
-0.0062239524,
-0.0389209874,
-0.0362726972,
0.0226332117,
0.069947049,
0.0137939993,
0.0385955088,
0.0486858599,
-0.0272963624,
-0.0652994141,
-0.0234591682,
0.0113803772,
-0.010410131,
-0.0354038477,
0.0357283428,
0.0049497476,
0.0441944674,
0.000661768,
-0.0939676315,
0.0026261832,
0.0065609342,
0.017313892,
0.0158140827,
-0.0234296359,
-0.0058605052,
0.0323988274,
-0.0444460139,
0.0254867766,
-0.0069504459,
-0.0152910165,
0.047076907,
0.0064754165,
0.0185328331,
-0.0209525712,
0.0068419576,
-0.0020057952,
-0.0031197728,
0.0575004369,
-0.0739759505,
-0.0746287405,
-0.0044869166,
-0.0519698784,
-0.0460222289,
-0.0136141507,
0.0224054437,
-0.0008017034,
0.0479216129,
-0.0755873919,
-0.0352461115,
-0.0048174621,
0.0137030231,
0.0570538342,
0.0120608853,
0.0644354746,
-0.0428976603,
-0.0178417359,
0.0270853713,
0.0240800418,
0.0273318607,
0.000200631,
-0.0166088659,
0.023830561,
0.0140005061,
-0.019554656,
0.019615287,
0.039050281,
-0.014786805,
-0.0754941553,
0.0207949951,
-0.012270581,
0.0438943468,
0.0117550213,
-0.0391390771,
0.0124750473,
0.0562137961,
0.0739601329,
0.0475210361,
-0.0028859258,
0.0247376915,
-0.0135450792,
0.0363356546,
-0.0769768432,
0.0296892319,
-0.0207765009,
-0.0689824894,
0.0098892618,
-0.005117984,
-0.0033424606,
0.0341376215,
-0.0410671085,
-0.048944395,
-0.0393405184,
-0.0205981992,
0.0271067359,
-0.0219542887,
0.0194075387,
0.0131616313,
0.0108222943,
-0.0409957357,
0.0068126759,
0.062989682,
0.0587045997,
0.0708503574,
-0.070033744,
-0.0373529084,
-0.048865214,
0.0197209343,
0.0669702813,
-0.0052360599,
-0.0333823636,
0.0013480189,
-0.0462156646,
-0.0221473034,
0.0407886133,
-0.0483739078,
0.0101535022,
0.0340710357,
0.0006676056,
0.0179403201,
0.0085940333,
-0.061975155,
-0.0358283147,
-0.0176650919,
-0.0259842034,
-0.030896889,
0.0293531381,
-5.513050506e-33,
0.0438772887,
-0.0406834334,
-0.0232459642,
0.0147848781,
0.0377541631,
0.0471033491,
-0.0099838059,
-0.0515032113,
0.0276115034,
-0.028398864,
-0.0123803755,
0.012759055,
0.0061713317,
-0.002247714,
0.0149486065,
-0.042858392,
0.0379206911,
0.0001204841,
-0.0022239096,
0.0244580898,
0.0090283128,
0.0439348817,
0.0046769422,
-0.0990409777,
-0.0048062336,
0.0386945195,
-0.0433572195,
0.0158077795,
-0.0677377358,
0.0511365645,
-0.0161180906,
-0.0077725146,
0.0539217964,
-0.0441727899,
0.0151633499,
0.0561510958,
-0.0719601586,
0.021600455,
-0.0387891568,
-0.011437878,
0.0351842083,
-0.0970753133,
0.0617152862,
-0.0184901059,
-0.01716429,
-0.0213740021,
0.0158083644,
-0.0299206041,
-0.0239504892,
-0.0592574328,
0.015979562,
0.043477878,
-0.049417913,
0.0567849092,
0.0381092168,
0.0029464501,
-0.0276754256,
0.0170041434,
-0.036384739,
-0.011136313,
0.0631025583,
-0.0318399817,
-0.0000759474,
-0.0021301119,
0.0215530545,
0.0375333205,
0.0523872823,
0.0046500452,
-0.0123350797,
0.0199806616,
-0.0316311978,
0.0614635609,
-0.0132307345,
0.0257892497,
0.0170114897,
-0.0776677504,
-0.1090707108,
0.0551783629,
-0.0729094222,
0.0255709626,
0.0098502245,
-0.0309453048,
-0.0547276251,
0.0142895179,
-0.0414580777,
0.029972896,
-0.0157695934,
0.0082270578,
-0.0071919328,
-0.00837004,
-0.0555879846,
0.0846552998,
-0.016212061,
-0.0507410653,
0.0191785544,
0.0341693796,
0.0562115908,
0.003276627,
0.0022266307,
-0.0307240039,
-0.038312681,
-0.0043474832,
0.0110633764,
-0.0468948521,
0.0664722025,
-0.014529407,
0.0504446402,
0.0057918062,
-0.0651856214,
0.0033699721,
0.0526423194,
0.0146949673,
-0.0077644004,
0.0387812257,
0.0146983191,
0.0090323649,
0.0253487285,
0.0076816794,
0.0072868145,
0.0415835567,
-0.0362335704,
-0.0033800192,
-0.0224114712,
0.0092426343,
0.0053256121,
-0.0142511381,
-0.0195317492,
-0.045410268,
0.029372761,
-0.0111732632,
0.0285254661,
-0.0024015803,
2.859e-7,
0.0470674299,
0.0191347394,
0.002106373,
-0.0280947424,
0.0267344899,
0.0338299684,
0.0052876738,
0.0088712974,
-0.0079148691,
-0.0125065334,
0.0778800473,
-0.035936486,
0.04462355,
0.0130461473,
-0.0521542467,
-0.0223039053,
0.0002909129,
-0.0158254448,
-0.0468760319,
-0.001812852,
0.0434923619,
0.0303477384,
-0.0050104605,
-0.0307486299,
0.0277112368,
0.0449209809,
-0.0156069845,
-0.0601585768,
0.0033875154,
0.0166412611,
0.0259295497,
-0.0011267936,
0.0035114535,
0.0859185532,
-0.030178193,
0.013698861,
-0.0392816849,
0.1102839485,
-0.0105607482,
0.0318333469,
-0.0146709708,
-0.0612583831,
0.0246733725,
0.0026096518,
0.0636326447,
-0.0117494576,
-0.0649364814,
-0.0064000878,
-0.0315162241,
-0.0231331885,
0.0499843359,
0.0184834898,
-0.0145832943,
0.0030031947,
-0.0090339575,
0.0161070246,
0.0206684563,
-0.0129855527,
0.0185513049,
0.0394366197,
-0.0222012568,
0.0073074894,
0.0611111782,
0.0076549482,
0.0374567211,
-0.0511496998,
0.0510182753,
2.898033467e-34,
-0.0024879375,
-0.0268063657,
-0.021310363,
0.0276864544,
0.0108675072,
-0.0055185407,
0.0437748767,
0.0096144332,
-0.0220671333,
-0.0326606594,
0.0339506567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03731v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03731v4 | Working Memory Capacity of ChatGPT: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-30T11:54:40 | 2024-02-01T21:39:50 | Dongyu Gong, Xingchen Wan, Dingmin Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Working memory is a critical aspect of both human intelligence and artificial
intelligence, serving as a workspace for the temporary storage and manipulation
of information. In this paper, we systematically assess the working memory
capacity of ChatGPT, a large language model developed by OpenAI, by examining
its performance in verbal and spatial n-back tasks under various conditions.
Our experiments reveal that ChatGPT has a working memory capacity limit
strikingly similar to that of humans. Furthermore, we investigate the impact of
different instruction strategies on ChatGPT's performance and observe that the
fundamental patterns of a capacity limit persist. From our empirical findings,
we propose that n-back tasks may serve as tools for benchmarking the working
memory capacity of large language models and hold potential for informing
future efforts aimed at enhancing AI working memory. | [
0.0149419298,
-0.0148928594,
-0.0385104045,
0.0104050068,
-0.0403388701,
0.0032655867,
0.0194912404,
0.0095467642,
0.0509115085,
-0.0198097378,
-0.045956485,
-0.0644100308,
0.0028168131,
0.0293392241,
0.0292130578,
-0.0654168725,
0.0605259165,
-0.0672095716,
0.014299647,
0.0065115946,
-0.0529780239,
-0.0341076702,
-0.0206846409,
0.0593791343,
-0.0272000246,
-0.0275196787,
-0.0120342299,
-0.0527366064,
0.0038933528,
-0.0271192174,
-0.0087212119,
0.0163268708,
-0.0260342639,
-0.0029854942,
0.0000021037,
-0.0369275175,
0.0691700429,
-0.0022663861,
-0.011058568,
0.0368046798,
0.0536588207,
0.0241114851,
-0.0187617093,
0.0505824015,
-0.004309054,
-0.0046511749,
0.0399146006,
0.0243313946,
0.0192152336,
0.0524068736,
-0.0200292375,
0.0184188504,
0.0540995896,
-0.0267685521,
0.0095399003,
-0.0708782747,
0.0370754525,
-0.0120874736,
0.0225639641,
-0.0027174675,
-0.0178206228,
0.0415549912,
0.0533788092,
0.034433797,
-0.0174056217,
0.0694149137,
0.003179119,
-0.0064130565,
-0.0335943699,
0.0510944426,
0.0105011687,
-0.016751945,
-0.0218518488,
0.0061421855,
0.0181932319,
-0.0221109148,
-0.058548674,
0.0673279092,
-0.0232287031,
-0.0217710342,
0.0139703434,
0.0019722141,
0.0290864278,
0.0071750907,
-0.0126553876,
-0.0080418512,
0.0022269289,
-0.0566008613,
0.0204701833,
0.0111638205,
-0.042456232,
-0.0166849811,
0.0239976328,
0.0661826208,
-0.0124365147,
0.0168420747,
-0.0374874249,
-0.015727438,
0.0390441567,
-0.094986394,
0.0419495441,
0.0519424975,
-0.0485774502,
0.0323006883,
-0.0200089402,
0.0770838186,
-0.0274082497,
0.0284826625,
-0.0208240692,
-0.0318792686,
-0.0758052319,
-0.0154020349,
-0.0510749742,
-0.0078476621,
-0.0378706641,
-0.0729039609,
-0.0246608257,
0.026491126,
0.0124680055,
-0.0353019647,
0.0448543653,
-0.0189817511,
-0.0063217087,
0.0352795981,
-0.0040953113,
0.0117110116,
-0.0391377397,
-0.0209544562,
0.0068227099,
-0.0599476509,
-0.0119657842,
0.0157481823,
-0.0216991883,
-0.0317642093,
0.0088328831,
0.0661998838,
0.0006499866,
-0.021721689,
-0.0600248277,
0.0191476159,
-0.0170501154,
-0.0820403621,
0.0381495766,
-0.0353327617,
0.0175235365,
0.0287300963,
-0.0191211756,
-0.0144033926,
-0.0197711699,
0.0417230204,
-0.0725586042,
0.0146442764,
0.0136722662,
0.0023297449,
0.0547547601,
0.004201584,
0.0066108056,
0.0249611754,
0.0814225972,
0.002033629,
0.0164739266,
0.0076835304,
-0.0149584319,
0.0552442074,
-0.0049110209,
-0.0272175539,
-0.0156706478,
-0.0147323161,
0.0472374782,
-0.000159412,
0.0106582092,
0.0824484006,
-0.0278476514,
-0.0198821276,
0.0270792488,
0.0672039911,
-0.0161072295,
0.057004869,
0.0158490036,
0.0198162254,
0.03021257,
-0.0118238637,
-0.0563081913,
0.0767376572,
-0.0049296417,
0.0023948806,
-0.0008398522,
0.0055120788,
-0.0502720401,
-0.0345155671,
-0.0390912965,
-0.0107333316,
0.052882921,
-0.0235300697,
0.0515038222,
-0.0226262026,
-0.0799623877,
0.0158655476,
0.0173693523,
-0.0357674435,
-0.0436641611,
-0.0595176853,
0.0007383458,
0.0714097247,
0.0233412758,
-0.0137978643,
-0.0119088562,
0.0433363505,
0.036059536,
0.0429653339,
0.0545165986,
0.0316367894,
-0.0053436346,
-0.052718848,
0.0326835439,
-0.0400761701,
0.0044044154,
0.0299346019,
0.0679193437,
0.0200752299,
-0.0002450587,
0.0183066949,
-0.0369230248,
0.0202358123,
-0.0367794596,
-0.009708262,
-0.0352315605,
0.0015555635,
0.0015826572,
-0.0242840275,
-0.0193668455,
0.0115849301,
0.0198168214,
-0.0421885923,
-0.0138967093,
0.0460997224,
-0.0553638488,
0.046838928,
0.011660262,
0.0047299215,
0.005765643,
0.0592226088,
0.0171145722,
-0.0452513918,
0.0342163108,
-0.0160495993,
0.0196521282,
-0.0204395931,
0.0250348635,
0.0180484168,
-0.0047856704,
-0.0008467696,
0.0854377523,
-0.0229638238,
-0.0012903531,
-0.0276629943,
0.0336511768,
0.0286756959,
-0.0563767515,
-0.0317107663,
0.0367683955,
-0.0198681429,
0.0130475853,
-0.0279391967,
-0.0309039745,
-0.0259827971,
-0.0451527275,
-0.1000681892,
-0.0008914713,
-0.0100021213,
0.0037017732,
-0.0169887748,
-0.0270695109,
-0.0178084746,
0.0032163139,
-0.0085815499,
0.0501388125,
-0.0107788201,
0.0479895025,
-0.0061327061,
0.00438469,
-0.0030257131,
-0.0389628746,
-0.0135713965,
-0.013425204,
0.017465204,
0.0146693056,
-0.0359397382,
-0.0150342761,
0.0275194813,
0.0013189774,
0.037210416,
-0.0158561617,
-0.0433459841,
0.0641635954,
-0.0076676486,
0.081542857,
0.0937283263,
-0.0105056772,
0.0236908197,
0.0691953599,
0.0007629107,
-0.0000254106,
0.0510310233,
-0.0056944625,
-0.0375374146,
-0.0078176931,
-0.02590142,
-0.0308340043,
0.0814981908,
0.0030017467,
0.0412894525,
-0.0817561522,
-0.0184570868,
-0.031109916,
-0.0393591858,
-0.0429901965,
0.0212917756,
-0.0485063419,
-0.0045941528,
-0.0470175222,
-0.0316493697,
-0.004963018,
0.0175744891,
0.0124137215,
-0.0204692371,
0.0335400663,
-0.0199622456,
0.0782922059,
0.020210756,
0.0052761515,
-0.0274121556,
-0.0171209313,
-0.0111390278,
-0.0044409274,
-0.0564097688,
-0.0457201153,
-0.007005909,
-0.0656037554,
0.0006319403,
-0.004299372,
-0.0344122499,
-0.0426486917,
0.055401247,
-0.0337981358,
0.0358543992,
0.0438382439,
-0.0331978723,
-0.0268683452,
0.0091482801,
0.0311283711,
0.0334939286,
-0.0254403707,
0.0038830179,
-0.0044026813,
-0.0235981625,
0.0326303281,
0.0275999904,
-0.007138642,
-0.0539411679,
0.0106999557,
0.0709305853,
0.0331915915,
0.021891715,
-0.0083617456,
-0.0114869783,
0.0114313653,
-0.0324277952,
-0.0022645236,
0.0504584238,
0.0213156361,
-0.0518677235,
-0.0531499051,
0.0959012732,
0.0466873236,
-0.0619040318,
0.0029168816,
-0.0362368785,
0.0064426726,
0.0323781744,
0.0439503752,
-0.0162242465,
-0.0205311328,
0.0018757299,
-0.0033293753,
0.000959184,
-0.0130993631,
-0.0095253661,
-0.1173519716,
0.0243872423,
-0.0046171579,
-0.0573578514,
-0.0113398274,
-0.0201029684,
-0.0436685532,
-0.0042549898,
0.0193209574,
0.0021307108,
0.0103319557,
-0.0297235567,
0.044121515,
-0.0114753395,
-0.0215988923,
0.0539353825,
-0.0399084352,
0.0301008113,
0.03286561,
0.0236576647,
-0.0079933256,
-0.057715144,
0.0117408996,
0.0410962887,
0.0387913808,
-0.0022349078,
0.0768265352,
-0.0087538036,
-0.01286186,
-0.0277389493,
-0.0157217681,
-0.0302661285,
-0.0212768652,
0.0435814708,
0.03691018,
-0.0005028802,
-0.0140015259,
-0.0086940499,
-0.0088106347,
-0.0058060023,
0.1069054008,
0.0182096083,
-0.0508642569,
-0.0701611713,
-0.0118597485,
-0.0117304483,
-0.0519464426,
-0.0422062725,
0.0167652536,
0.006087142,
-0.0050564124,
-0.0406805538,
-0.0332701169,
0.0415029451,
0.0221887249,
0.0204936396,
-0.0100164255,
0.0221468098,
0.0081413109,
-0.0508558974,
-0.0076569286,
-0.0225905739,
0.0271598566,
-0.0829169005,
-0.0399321765,
0.0142843938,
-0.0133656403,
0.0056776949,
0.0042316043,
-0.1014146805,
-0.0097763464,
0.0139410216,
0.0384511873,
0.0303495247,
0.0010334703,
-0.0075877458,
-0.0107990736,
-0.0429352708,
0.0011350482,
-0.03168194,
0.0348743424,
0.0226223487,
0.005151256,
0.042721007,
0.010877667,
-0.0201240927,
-0.0175444912,
-0.0020662441,
0.0378905647,
-0.0159582179,
0.0182915255,
-0.0075325253,
-0.0096215596,
0.0191564355,
0.0050870986,
-0.0378859937,
-0.019615259,
-0.0010134893,
-0.015340684,
0.0391222797,
-0.0159957185,
-0.0005731671,
0.0283331256,
0.0286397859,
-0.0018089375,
0.0073837894,
0.0201490559,
-0.0323395878,
-0.015376145,
-0.0038587591,
-0.0164813455,
0.0123349791,
-0.0059220726,
0.0228344668,
-0.0451042652,
-0.0212469343,
-0.0175542179,
0.0365521684,
0.0200438686,
0.0852393955,
0.0000607368,
-0.0185603555,
-0.0028429655,
0.0293300953,
-0.0649517179,
-0.073732391,
0.0369175263,
0.0763899684,
0.0320695154,
-0.0311189871,
0.0034153711,
-0.0653690472,
0.0081856111,
-0.0443059057,
-0.0141715799,
0.0026380802,
-0.0334954858,
-0.0213487409,
0.0105856275,
-0.0055277278,
-0.0298373736,
0.0916966721,
0.029896142,
0.0198107753,
0.0150546664,
-0.0094000893,
-0.0183012523,
-0.0507992804,
0.0025078389,
0.0187758915,
-0.0061172359,
0.0062928135,
-0.046326749,
-0.0872470737,
-0.0251812954,
0.0124979792,
0.056019824,
-0.0158333778,
0.0069217919,
0.0495242402,
-0.032647416,
-0.023021657,
-0.0158133879,
-0.0069827568,
0.0054540597,
-0.00206128,
-0.0057189893,
-6.458044741e-33,
-0.0109574758,
-0.009565019,
0.0758453682,
0.0242716763,
0.0042598229,
-0.0020280208,
-0.0516379923,
-0.0021206469,
-0.032855574,
-0.0134151885,
-0.0143661089,
0.0308768936,
0.0242281649,
0.0101454407,
0.0214706399,
0.0000141661,
0.0246100277,
-0.0016382035,
-0.0062113814,
0.0261975173,
0.0378426984,
0.0212558955,
0.0376095809,
-0.0332667828,
0.0055927187,
-0.0096656932,
0.0326510333,
-0.0092568444,
-0.0068870853,
0.0659067258,
-0.0496209748,
0.0363737121,
0.0371019058,
-0.0560431071,
0.0032810455,
0.0378075764,
-0.0529664159,
-0.0266584828,
-0.0002597866,
0.012513197,
-0.0377216414,
-0.0352480486,
0.0213389434,
0.0132921562,
-0.0347408354,
0.0092064776,
0.0239438359,
-0.0176532548,
-0.0698273778,
0.0736620277,
-0.0820342004,
-0.0094999867,
0.0209688731,
-0.0185915045,
-0.0105928872,
-0.006512864,
-0.0431142673,
-0.0342996828,
-0.0841006935,
-0.0127692996,
0.0246577598,
0.017665362,
0.0264889486,
0.023545064,
0.0155582177,
0.0398666374,
0.0347481854,
0.021389816,
-0.052948162,
-0.0060663698,
0.0554211736,
0.0362904072,
0.0538848378,
-0.0451165773,
0.0877967253,
-0.0341214202,
-0.0500553511,
-0.0395156592,
0.0250685085,
0.0501705967,
0.053984534,
-0.0203744769,
-0.0746151432,
-0.0178879444,
-0.0051336898,
0.0429773331,
-0.0405874737,
-0.0052265534,
0.0672614872,
0.0174166448,
0.0202822164,
-0.0324590765,
0.0338501818,
-0.01511179,
0.0682038218,
0.0437915809,
-0.014672894,
0.0607264601,
-0.0186425615,
0.0193453021,
-0.1161588505,
-0.0392799228,
-0.0258089676,
0.0427115113,
0.0157013163,
0.0396069102,
0.0377464481,
0.0086554708,
-0.0323821791,
-0.0194267053,
-0.0465490147,
0.0054121525,
0.0429929271,
0.0255986433,
0.0414625518,
0.0170663372,
0.0079158405,
0.020610502,
-0.0333054885,
-0.0073186872,
-0.0261948742,
-0.0701177046,
-0.0018424047,
-0.0229384247,
-0.0166113954,
-0.0057372684,
-0.0387212224,
0.042308718,
-0.0013241968,
-0.069204092,
0.0030980073,
0.0488493592,
2.724e-7,
-0.0117321881,
0.0470491275,
0.0033490963,
0.0609287247,
0.015165817,
-0.0164679643,
-0.0021806103,
0.0348753147,
0.0104420306,
0.0150520066,
-0.0056828586,
0.107713595,
0.0642071292,
0.0041989763,
-0.103975825,
-0.0652230009,
-0.0358874202,
0.0259149484,
-0.0406395458,
0.037500225,
0.03690942,
0.0494258739,
0.0264596958,
-0.0025180869,
-0.0003282155,
-0.0593777634,
0.0834067464,
-0.0185315982,
0.0462058485,
-0.0027385242,
0.0276729539,
0.0693961084,
-0.0034625214,
0.0385580361,
-0.0138672749,
-0.0205659941,
-0.0050481837,
0.0502694175,
-0.0167142302,
-0.034521807,
0.0206599981,
-0.008076977,
-0.0245923027,
-0.0055222623,
0.0581507199,
-0.0561665073,
-0.0275606643,
0.0245403238,
0.051783137,
0.0314736106,
0.0008625536,
0.0181088708,
-0.0004050345,
-0.0192152709,
0.0110185388,
-0.040383134,
0.0218223631,
-0.0770798475,
0.0032197358,
0.0001052698,
-0.030702712,
-0.0297855455,
-0.070728898,
-0.0102098146,
0.0275244676,
-0.0332175419,
-0.0069537819,
2.207067785e-34,
0.0425266959,
-0.0198471136,
0.0286070053,
0.0417456031,
0.030466767,
-0.003211329,
0.0340475477,
0.0166202784,
-0.0308675766,
-0.0726952627,
-0.039490398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00450v2 | SMILE: Single-turn to Multi-turn Inclusive Language Expansion via ChatGPT for Mental Health Support | 2023-04-30T11:26:10 | 2024-02-22T10:21:56 | Huachuan Qiu, Hongliang He, Shuai Zhang, Anqi Li, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Developing specialized dialogue systems for mental health support requires
multi-turn conversation data, which has recently garnered increasing attention.
However, gathering and releasing large-scale and real-life multi-turn
conversations to facilitate advancements in mental health presents challenges
due to data privacy protection, as well as the time and cost involved. To
address the challenges related to data scarcity, we introduce SMILE, a
single-turn to multi-turn inclusive language expansion technique that prompts
ChatGPT to rewrite public single-turn dialogues into multi-turn ones. Our work
begins with the analysis of language transformation, validating the feasibility
of the proposed method when compared with other baseline methods. We then
conduct a study on dialogue diversity, including lexical features, semantic
features, and dialogue topics, demonstrating the effectiveness of our proposed
method. Furthermore, we implement an expert evaluation and the results
demonstrate that the dialogues generated with our proposed method are of higher
quality than those generated with other baseline methods. Thus, we employ our
method to generate a large-scale, diverse, and high-quality dialogue dataset
named SmileChat, comprising 55,165 dialogues in total with an average of 10.4
turns per dialogue. Finally, we utilize the collected corpus to develop a
mental health chatbot, MeChat. To better assess the overall quality of
SmileChat, we collect a real-life chat dataset comprising 82 counseling
dialogues for model evaluation. Both automatic and human evaluations
demonstrate that our trained dialogue system exhibits significant improvements,
showcasing that SmileChat is high-quality and practical. | [
0.0857639462,
0.0695938617,
-0.0299425777,
-0.0079250354,
-0.0435945764,
0.0140171321,
0.0181118436,
0.0089481566,
0.0768759847,
-0.0266473815,
-0.0153015237,
-0.0098877493,
-0.0115910815,
0.0572098643,
-0.0088050375,
-0.0885497481,
0.0340247229,
0.0198681001,
0.0374091528,
0.0027664304,
0.0268114991,
0.0285936855,
-0.0471880883,
0.0663936511,
-0.0481078625,
0.0056925062,
0.0014544227,
0.0310743544,
0.0312830135,
-0.0301352963,
0.0165618025,
0.0551865399,
-0.0156214777,
0.0184982885,
0.0000019285,
-0.034351036,
-0.0486623496,
0.0037240547,
-0.0145738777,
-0.0626720339,
0.0623799749,
-0.055102326,
-0.0005477018,
0.0403852835,
-0.0295029785,
0.0001542243,
0.053631749,
0.0701066628,
0.093094945,
0.0949996784,
-0.03369838,
0.0080034453,
0.0083642341,
-0.0077786129,
-0.0114697618,
-0.0279554594,
0.0074470369,
0.0018847922,
0.0296303015,
-0.0084612425,
-0.0307324696,
0.0486998037,
-0.0296202656,
-0.013957045,
0.0028657892,
0.0107218558,
-0.0504080765,
-0.0491858274,
-0.0040888335,
0.0967029333,
0.0140632428,
0.0279238317,
0.0113362167,
0.003734289,
0.0308995303,
-0.007048626,
-0.0493597724,
-0.0043359422,
0.0090505267,
-0.0080923121,
-0.0215137731,
-0.0175768882,
-0.0209024567,
-0.012847933,
0.0064181229,
0.0143631296,
0.0096676284,
-0.0299394671,
-0.0060956506,
-0.0004957134,
-0.0174590703,
-0.0580334999,
0.0359990522,
0.00823458,
-0.0581140481,
0.0457105748,
-0.0286975875,
-0.0428503267,
0.0198209677,
-0.0025369567,
-0.0380828306,
0.0357574038,
-0.0505015999,
0.0101164281,
0.0387239605,
-0.0042432561,
0.01101809,
0.0313778222,
-0.0378256179,
-0.023886241,
-0.0752957761,
-0.0112161804,
-0.0571805686,
0.0101675494,
-0.0226069447,
-0.0222714618,
-0.070593223,
0.0503884964,
0.0158289075,
-0.0195799991,
0.022921104,
0.0039402642,
-0.0133676659,
-0.0011505347,
0.0169017743,
0.0382393301,
-0.0397133008,
0.0030024727,
0.0347249843,
-0.0870836824,
0.0077491836,
0.0154956412,
-0.0133481054,
-0.0189758111,
0.0028355229,
0.0933719426,
0.0040720068,
-0.033776518,
-0.0014382756,
-0.0237940382,
-0.0553046353,
-0.0343640484,
-0.0103549063,
-0.0316968486,
0.0640393496,
0.0024316155,
0.010816697,
-0.003409192,
0.030047249,
0.0078296047,
-0.072888352,
0.0672795922,
-0.0527684875,
0.0149912508,
0.0486418754,
0.0335247628,
-0.0192881282,
0.0428489335,
0.0215853173,
-0.0011989661,
0.0708591565,
-0.0252678618,
0.0284634624,
0.024835553,
0.0016927581,
-0.0287374444,
0.048048988,
0.0117832264,
-0.0289428793,
0.0486792848,
-0.0422714241,
0.0521022342,
-0.0410208404,
-0.0298279729,
0.0361084044,
0.0580101795,
0.0003560684,
0.0403651297,
-0.0162985139,
0.0264934897,
-0.0139708063,
-0.0134553481,
-0.0340427905,
-0.000286373,
-0.0379610509,
-0.0468093753,
0.0227222219,
0.0278215464,
-0.0175422132,
-0.0221757554,
-0.0086164521,
-0.0370469242,
0.0409630388,
0.000276294,
-0.0020764372,
0.0169087835,
-0.0085017551,
0.0659675375,
0.0417881645,
-0.0535618998,
-0.0632432923,
-0.0570035465,
-0.0051913853,
0.0642453581,
0.0649967492,
-0.0323201008,
-0.0527807772,
-0.0292656682,
-0.0254318137,
0.0376930311,
0.0143139856,
0.0255068932,
0.0400369652,
-0.0505338758,
0.0099768676,
0.0441664942,
-0.0099691376,
0.0149158342,
0.0083779311,
0.029961288,
-0.0236352049,
0.0103022205,
0.0187055916,
0.0208254997,
-0.0127277598,
0.0081311511,
0.0410095416,
-0.0121831447,
0.0393071659,
0.0306449514,
-0.0112916538,
-0.0032165207,
0.0000462493,
-0.0215842985,
-0.0774335712,
0.061774943,
-0.0446275175,
-0.0650573745,
0.0133636631,
-0.0698504969,
0.0057956958,
0.0450211205,
-0.0270102844,
-0.042413231,
0.0258575361,
-0.0627346113,
0.041587431,
-0.0090669198,
0.0119223222,
0.0252412241,
0.0441467278,
-0.0375857614,
0.0052014394,
-0.0131263565,
0.0024378544,
-0.0075673764,
-0.0317752734,
-0.0178003162,
-0.0372481532,
-0.0031684842,
0.0378301144,
-0.0017939616,
-0.0132256923,
0.0070338594,
0.0300765019,
-0.0795273408,
-0.0563251376,
-0.1680608094,
-0.0024723567,
-0.005098016,
-0.0127465883,
0.041289933,
0.026934294,
-0.0227050483,
-0.0340457037,
-0.067484349,
0.0387511142,
0.0420582257,
0.0375548601,
0.025424609,
0.0130553823,
-0.0239213668,
-0.0465116315,
-0.0032190445,
-0.011801986,
0.0195978917,
-0.0167861581,
-0.0142273651,
-0.0378754251,
-0.0387856774,
-0.0478207469,
-0.0016417389,
-0.0206004921,
-0.0435510129,
0.0190159082,
-0.007251794,
0.0367245711,
-0.0063479859,
0.0650207996,
0.0265404899,
-0.025432406,
-0.0089864889,
-0.0324850231,
0.012948514,
0.0101220664,
-0.0034808503,
-0.0342823453,
-0.0553668328,
0.015212412,
0.0018833454,
0.0375945084,
0.0117940875,
-0.0759679452,
-0.0381364115,
0.0263234098,
-0.0383241586,
-0.0014375699,
0.011288791,
-0.0188459177,
-0.012884181,
0.0130730411,
-0.0353648029,
0.0647560433,
-0.0089485664,
-0.0317517594,
-0.0534772761,
-0.0469693094,
-0.0399960876,
0.0473592654,
-0.0134319179,
0.0308820624,
0.0262916423,
-0.0342495888,
0.0011354571,
-0.0218285844,
0.0022885187,
-0.0572335422,
0.0358182862,
-0.0432965904,
-0.0072730607,
0.0267817266,
-0.0124854119,
-0.0495672636,
-0.0813607499,
-0.0246060994,
-0.0326657556,
0.058847174,
-0.025155412,
-0.0332820453,
-0.0174724776,
0.0161822941,
0.0477284901,
0.0026105256,
-0.0223802067,
0.0023915467,
0.0158645939,
0.0251129176,
0.0025062971,
0.0143177994,
-0.0030494917,
0.0453329571,
0.0587925874,
-0.0099917129,
0.0076984735,
0.0309972595,
-0.0166977644,
-0.0098513151,
0.0078144222,
-0.018572364,
-0.0323853083,
0.0674645305,
0.0023172256,
-0.0311140567,
0.1021352336,
0.0207416024,
-0.0602568612,
0.0142037272,
-0.0401174836,
0.0067901216,
-0.0129471207,
-0.002552639,
-0.072471112,
-0.0208868086,
-0.0179322138,
0.0487731956,
-0.02242993,
-0.0461851023,
-0.0094660809,
-0.0541905649,
0.0224587936,
-0.0127293076,
-0.0333071239,
-0.0189136155,
-0.0088338554,
0.0100132227,
-0.0123111708,
0.0235017426,
-0.0427628309,
0.0142258918,
-0.0002803606,
-0.01403597,
-0.0441357531,
-0.012160562,
0.0360688381,
0.003978292,
0.0944803134,
0.039385695,
0.0479771346,
0.0271933991,
0.0244763289,
0.0003862302,
0.053808555,
-0.005637588,
0.0016770944,
0.1006110907,
0.0225166064,
-0.00554155,
-0.0238230899,
0.0355574526,
-0.0507484153,
-0.0030337311,
0.0317662768,
0.025788689,
-0.0297223777,
0.0002045284,
-0.013124736,
0.0436864868,
0.06051502,
0.056692753,
0.0091998558,
-0.0388966873,
0.007769804,
-0.0089852,
0.0067658373,
-0.0040455963,
-0.0514240116,
0.001517172,
-0.022838043,
-0.0243586823,
-0.0850376412,
-0.0488316976,
0.0245065689,
0.0047653923,
-0.040563684,
-0.0447407849,
0.0270931926,
0.0375228487,
0.0138521697,
0.0184096042,
-0.0224797036,
0.0145149902,
-0.0485911258,
-0.0358589813,
0.0226011202,
-0.023422977,
0.0082745338,
0.039240025,
-0.0476611927,
-0.0395788252,
0.0404594019,
0.0027600615,
0.0133503247,
0.019330088,
-0.01067378,
-0.0058388384,
0.0044137621,
0.05017104,
-0.0380355157,
-0.0074506016,
0.046593979,
0.0866591334,
-0.0057654441,
0.0405413248,
0.0047103465,
0.0272783935,
-0.0025273198,
0.0216070265,
-0.0455888771,
-0.0636011064,
-0.0000104324,
0.0447719321,
0.0155605702,
-0.0096154874,
-0.006118427,
-0.0021623063,
-0.0045374827,
-0.061621543,
0.0122996774,
-0.0539176017,
-0.0064928415,
0.0346530452,
-0.0415924452,
-0.0077677527,
-0.0157800205,
-0.0834493041,
0.0064886739,
-0.0304401536,
-0.006116081,
0.0198121816,
-0.0086225308,
0.0005321035,
-0.0023742858,
0.0039198888,
0.0357343815,
-0.0102844648,
0.0154335415,
-0.0351307765,
0.0879278556,
0.0006274919,
-0.0230170898,
0.0452529602,
0.0607923307,
-0.0681590512,
-0.0766763389,
-0.010573498,
0.0297257081,
0.0304559804,
0.0433089845,
0.0896620005,
-0.0253665559,
0.0088097062,
-0.0012119318,
0.0328859352,
-0.007041798,
-0.017916441,
-0.0085155703,
0.0026420879,
-0.0136864753,
-0.0072406698,
0.061880134,
-0.0529128797,
0.0235050581,
0.0194429997,
-0.019466918,
-0.0424860418,
-0.0173461139,
0.0055561853,
0.0043050465,
-0.0002794123,
0.0196673535,
-0.0234784577,
-0.0478762276,
0.008013662,
-0.0382109955,
0.0068240506,
0.0038923135,
0.0440703221,
0.0399770774,
0.0031821833,
0.0027706136,
-0.0660842806,
0.0411915407,
-0.0007298237,
-0.0211352296,
-0.0095348442,
-5.900494913e-33,
-0.008600425,
0.0035780661,
-0.0100328308,
-0.0165765677,
-0.0268444624,
-0.0299161505,
-0.0155071896,
0.0555818491,
-0.0216991287,
0.0219906121,
-0.0179854725,
0.058917813,
0.0071223658,
0.0551414564,
0.0222147107,
-0.0021898344,
0.0268603116,
-0.0160288084,
-0.0161084607,
0.0481750257,
0.0286080278,
0.0561580509,
0.0729978457,
-0.1323718429,
0.0154862311,
0.0033821752,
-0.0210665185,
0.0193269886,
0.0340961143,
0.0233914014,
-0.0171825271,
0.0657381937,
0.0389167629,
-0.0256804079,
-0.0070946319,
0.0176067073,
-0.0422932804,
-0.0181355104,
-0.0066207894,
0.0030494812,
-0.0543386862,
-0.0009968469,
0.0050443942,
-0.0452755578,
0.0415185131,
-0.0198498722,
0.0065088649,
-0.0420775823,
0.0504274443,
0.0140758669,
-0.0325155519,
0.0199538209,
-0.0441850685,
-0.0479687788,
-0.0403851829,
0.0730472952,
-0.0085570514,
0.0026745482,
0.0013004069,
0.024427712,
-0.0070644361,
-0.0144786071,
-0.015494735,
-0.0245644469,
-0.01429791,
0.0233843736,
0.002185934,
0.0085121933,
-0.0209220555,
-0.0074353386,
-0.0091273738,
0.0392019525,
0.0423671082,
0.0529421158,
-0.0020206296,
-0.0316519141,
-0.0186993908,
-0.015819829,
0.0461613834,
0.006811148,
-0.0093332147,
0.0158570372,
-0.036734242,
0.0024196387,
0.0001577418,
0.0080725048,
-0.0035627321,
-0.0301888082,
0.0146187274,
0.015759239,
-0.0193147473,
-0.0249070935,
0.0059605977,
-0.0318635292,
0.0126357703,
0.0279795546,
-0.0162636787,
0.003974874,
-0.0012434945,
0.0113924742,
-0.0179620832,
-0.0081701716,
0.0645089,
0.0081072003,
0.0325857177,
-0.0142713552,
0.0203637332,
0.0093477173,
-0.06795872,
-0.0048148921,
0.0143532529,
0.0775622129,
-0.0241622198,
0.0186630748,
-0.0518516004,
0.0080737509,
-0.0435809828,
0.0674361363,
0.0155501636,
0.0564497225,
-0.0676257238,
-0.0291801412,
0.0054302621,
-0.0127248261,
-0.0437171049,
-0.0271057151,
-0.0140017318,
-0.0353588536,
0.0533299074,
-0.0275490321,
-0.0072192857,
-0.0355463587,
2.717e-7,
0.0333525948,
0.050646469,
0.0133508807,
0.029656684,
0.0237976536,
0.0272804089,
0.0139579931,
0.0491927415,
0.021554077,
-0.0293173958,
0.0203081015,
0.0278412383,
0.0569353066,
0.0600856356,
-0.040526066,
-0.0672011301,
-0.0477703512,
-0.0420830287,
-0.0355695747,
0.0216989871,
0.1120784506,
0.1039807945,
0.0185757913,
-0.011222655,
-0.0088626323,
0.0126301525,
0.0340374969,
-0.0437828116,
-0.0180032514,
0.0473252125,
0.0579742901,
0.0099982843,
0.0243161097,
-0.0107944328,
0.0071525346,
0.0031255623,
-0.001861905,
0.0647035539,
-0.0205674693,
-0.0534977466,
0.0204051305,
0.020431906,
-0.0138569027,
-0.0112436805,
0.0307007264,
-0.0679323375,
-0.0177991949,
-0.0512247719,
-0.018832989,
-0.0320686214,
0.0729692653,
-0.0447830446,
-0.0445931442,
0.0564828329,
0.0352902487,
0.0198618639,
0.0202120189,
-0.0907674655,
-0.0061071874,
-0.0003373989,
-0.0798761323,
-0.0090451641,
0.0121787032,
-0.0231333636,
-0.023454506,
-0.0348696746,
0.0324810483,
2.087195372e-34,
0.0321432911,
0.0391128622,
0.0231657717,
0.0285611954,
0.0396831408,
0.0000879119,
0.0301046129,
0.0126174716,
-0.0109338136,
-0.0730134696,
-0.0246311277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00446v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00446v2 | Building a Non-native Speech Corpus Featuring Chinese-English Bilingual Children: Compilation and Rationale | 2023-04-30T10:41:43 | 2024-01-07T17:17:00 | Hiuchung Hung, Andreas Maier, Thorsten Piske | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a non-native speech corpus consisting of narratives
from fifty 5- to 6-year-old Chinese-English children. Transcripts totaling 6.5
hours of children taking a narrative comprehension test in English (L2) are
presented, along with human-rated scores and annotations of grammatical and
pronunciation errors. The children also completed the parallel MAIN tests in
Chinese (L1) for reference purposes. For all tests we recorded audio and video
with our innovative self-developed remote collection methods. The video
recordings serve to mitigate the challenge of low intelligibility in L2
narratives produced by young children during the transcription process. This
corpus offers valuable resources for second language teaching and has the
potential to enhance the overall performance of automatic speech recognition
(ASR). | [
-0.0091280956,
0.0372308083,
-0.0151670137,
0.0147780506,
-0.0169557575,
0.0081243897,
0.0313198343,
-0.0316101015,
-0.0125430617,
-0.0185421165,
-0.0382908024,
-0.036547672,
0.083507441,
-0.0291081853,
-0.0216658432,
-0.0767442584,
-0.0003069986,
-0.0420228019,
0.030852478,
-0.0163394548,
0.0074416059,
0.03044503,
-0.0474857166,
0.0458286442,
-0.0213285629,
-0.004836705,
0.0053287395,
0.004483053,
0.0350109786,
-0.0286536068,
-0.0176788531,
-0.003826265,
0.0291699748,
0.0472402237,
0.0000020167,
-0.0677268803,
-0.0052940291,
-0.0017636713,
-0.0559482872,
0.0175236706,
0.0292736962,
0.0215808209,
-0.0150539856,
0.0085247755,
-0.0222419389,
-0.035894163,
0.0373906754,
0.0370347723,
-0.0148201976,
0.0024985014,
-0.0121224448,
-0.0311374906,
-0.0149437645,
0.0275746752,
-0.0009318293,
0.0118580591,
-0.0302114356,
0.0370193757,
0.055963967,
-0.0926915407,
-0.024151938,
0.025380183,
-0.0136786429,
-0.0377207957,
-0.0716156885,
0.0218587779,
-0.0673065707,
-0.0334842876,
-0.0294787139,
0.0349854231,
0.041554492,
-0.0211565476,
0.0168517493,
0.020748198,
-0.0373732746,
0.0218937062,
-0.0164909866,
0.05072321,
-0.0490491353,
0.0051811994,
0.0318453908,
-0.0375594683,
0.0001133013,
-0.0375481807,
0.0294622369,
-0.0094558708,
0.0038896697,
0.0124294786,
-0.0425742567,
0.0220714435,
0.0605041087,
-0.0066854297,
0.0480089262,
-0.0009652565,
0.0014842943,
0.0124737956,
-0.0123889614,
-0.0208922531,
-0.0568055473,
-0.0150298886,
0.0049063759,
0.0044018826,
-0.0642203763,
0.023809012,
0.0065463395,
0.0466262884,
0.0574332401,
0.0271614604,
-0.0742774084,
0.0037533385,
-0.0179517195,
0.0058919061,
-0.050252445,
0.0263092816,
-0.0237936806,
-0.0002590328,
-0.0077749323,
-0.0146232806,
-0.0090843951,
0.0129762869,
-0.0129257143,
-0.0338110998,
-0.0513179488,
-0.0167048313,
0.0130258529,
0.047283534,
-0.0069253049,
0.0685979351,
-0.0123531781,
-0.0755446479,
0.0071052583,
0.0254742149,
0.0362705067,
0.037726704,
0.0088178627,
0.0240173042,
-0.0092243794,
-0.0119061144,
-0.0098401178,
0.0324305594,
-0.0235666558,
-0.0375834405,
0.01324277,
-0.0509537123,
0.0183802731,
-0.0245917663,
0.0348687284,
-0.0055434755,
-0.0093987873,
-0.0575677678,
0.0457187593,
-0.0151205836,
0.0393613018,
0.0109343575,
0.0176620912,
-0.0120747834,
0.0560525618,
0.0572019368,
0.0915131718,
-0.095209755,
0.0488445759,
-0.0211643483,
-0.0290843938,
0.0139182936,
-0.0448615626,
0.0054656453,
-0.0415553153,
-0.0497987196,
0.001953538,
0.0010554586,
0.026146302,
0.028956471,
-0.0271620173,
0.0174408704,
0.0491603613,
0.07344497,
-0.0294220261,
-0.039444536,
0.0526995547,
0.0413133651,
0.0259029754,
0.0531483479,
0.0141818756,
0.0170104671,
-0.0019809483,
0.0066027772,
-0.0148055376,
0.0464313664,
-0.0460645482,
-0.0224876888,
-0.040255826,
-0.0060528745,
0.0267109033,
0.0645970628,
-0.000394845,
0.005106213,
-0.00499608,
-0.0016670001,
-0.0053704157,
-0.0615639612,
0.0725895762,
-0.0283895656,
0.0360863544,
0.026113214,
-0.0095931664,
-0.0035408475,
-0.0096488241,
0.0163597874,
-0.0489363708,
0.0297606643,
0.0007978287,
-0.0264634266,
0.0634306818,
-0.0368937999,
0.0105894357,
0.0701471195,
0.0161424112,
0.0071301162,
-0.0622457527,
0.0226237178,
-0.0116140628,
-0.0394584946,
-0.0294315405,
-0.0089854142,
-0.0430481918,
-0.0002218963,
0.0172743853,
0.0065189311,
0.0537341423,
0.0601123199,
-0.0582453795,
-0.0211470388,
0.0488641933,
0.0202615559,
0.0342740119,
0.1044568792,
-0.0275602993,
-0.0690742582,
0.0254986603,
-0.1101098284,
-0.0045045824,
-0.0038537493,
-0.0050430824,
-0.0674939454,
0.0266996045,
-0.0410514511,
0.0311596338,
-0.01897664,
0.0626655594,
-0.0182371195,
0.0000305408,
0.0174014214,
-0.0129671851,
0.034948606,
-0.0088107884,
-0.0434520133,
-0.0189986527,
0.0031472025,
-0.0774910077,
-0.0393755548,
0.0283663385,
-0.0251122843,
0.0392472968,
0.0142327668,
-0.0032915061,
-0.0399981774,
-0.0124869058,
-0.0728498921,
-0.0199607592,
-0.007233642,
0.009244089,
0.0002649162,
-0.0341526195,
-0.0109270019,
0.0002804937,
-0.0320155248,
-0.0148982145,
-0.0167541932,
-0.0271940306,
-0.0472991653,
-0.0288077369,
-0.0059971204,
0.0058989534,
-0.0015054166,
-0.0059557096,
-0.0196779054,
0.0391211659,
-0.0345543474,
-0.0421675108,
-0.0290424824,
-0.0043672961,
0.0128969746,
0.0086124688,
-0.0200946927,
0.0216655675,
0.005210307,
0.0559439771,
0.0576475561,
-0.0356504582,
-0.0087747071,
0.0417584516,
-0.0421684384,
-0.0243343152,
0.0021214143,
0.0621670075,
-0.0107954079,
-0.0075642271,
0.0026029365,
-0.0648514032,
0.0253038965,
0.069105871,
0.0178932548,
-0.0364091061,
-0.0455984958,
-0.034895014,
-0.0189463757,
0.0050160801,
-0.0724399537,
-0.049978856,
0.0191720631,
-0.0200533196,
0.0107448734,
0.0463115014,
-0.0745289549,
-0.0490196534,
-0.0973401144,
-0.007377401,
0.0092438553,
0.0417720303,
-0.0015920757,
-0.0036312002,
-0.0005741314,
-0.0596671477,
-0.0332085378,
0.0318697914,
0.0668760613,
-0.0395311005,
0.023260098,
-0.0605939738,
-0.0051127365,
0.0227099117,
-0.0069739954,
-0.0065506562,
0.0120182484,
-0.0375166573,
0.0127111841,
-0.0002542034,
-0.0183815211,
-0.0111135645,
0.0364674069,
0.0385423861,
0.0779411644,
-0.0034685449,
0.0477850921,
-0.0066501466,
0.0251182299,
0.0230407901,
0.0582884178,
0.0122255534,
-0.020807622,
0.1008223966,
0.0222736318,
0.058044631,
0.0273501985,
0.0376042947,
0.0344255716,
0.0290134717,
0.0547299646,
-0.0451238789,
0.0306158829,
0.0864902884,
-0.0587298572,
0.0145148486,
0.0448543094,
0.0063310796,
-0.0187241491,
-0.024561828,
-0.0098923892,
-0.0332906581,
0.0026378313,
-0.0425975919,
-0.0896286592,
0.0283933021,
0.0548528209,
0.0199712366,
-0.0120956441,
0.0301663242,
-0.0183498114,
-0.1066681519,
0.0595621392,
0.0306213461,
-0.0328921564,
-0.0110480338,
-0.05476702,
-0.0453512594,
0.0355481766,
0.0709398389,
0.0004675095,
-0.0280751958,
-0.0350875556,
0.0157108083,
-0.0533478148,
-0.0578589328,
0.0617948882,
0.0077045569,
0.0732657835,
0.0143121611,
0.0271214079,
-0.0371004976,
-0.00391461,
-0.0350359567,
-0.0288983826,
-0.0065286267,
-0.0053530079,
-0.0014174527,
0.0283108372,
-0.0256628152,
-0.0181318298,
0.0581885688,
0.0419873223,
0.017798841,
0.0272920635,
0.0536410101,
-0.0134753892,
-0.0079216817,
0.0436340757,
0.0739143491,
-0.0022234865,
0.0726188794,
0.0348107889,
-0.0368178636,
0.0629197881,
0.0326437503,
-0.0222483333,
-0.0492148548,
-0.0143421972,
0.078802757,
-0.0106253363,
-0.0226437338,
-0.0868556872,
-0.0200484209,
0.0423040092,
0.0289651267,
0.0362254307,
0.004184891,
0.0183112249,
0.0283749085,
-0.0292709786,
0.043390736,
0.0215954036,
0.0046463734,
-0.0443340056,
-0.0166621152,
-0.0085810777,
-0.063184768,
0.0011285072,
0.0013302498,
-0.052729629,
-0.0527455173,
0.0354170725,
-0.0139041599,
0.0107624857,
0.0354025178,
0.0078068641,
-0.0027682036,
0.0052802148,
-0.0454961844,
-0.0084022703,
-0.0218107291,
0.0221036281,
-0.0038913386,
-0.0140344417,
-0.0018672703,
-0.0204060134,
0.0103761703,
-0.0522127785,
-0.0146481423,
-0.0420922525,
-0.022607429,
-0.0043010847,
0.0263966396,
0.05485278,
-0.0315653756,
0.0160069242,
-0.0726820007,
0.0169222374,
-0.0524431393,
0.0452299677,
-0.0258504059,
-0.0210876744,
0.01311542,
0.0055960161,
-0.0040916931,
0.0220005382,
-0.0544958897,
-0.0473514348,
0.0062874048,
0.0872904137,
0.0136967553,
0.0560709126,
-0.0013240108,
0.06507539,
-0.0317541771,
0.0345622897,
0.0044731093,
0.08145421,
0.0113076651,
0.0250253771,
-0.0255878735,
0.0366960056,
0.0452737138,
-0.0308084525,
-0.0033200914,
-0.0093320776,
0.0137746735,
0.0068819425,
0.0564665385,
-0.029440973,
0.0709142834,
-0.0119759515,
0.0383612514,
-0.0609336644,
0.0064412369,
-0.0077991029,
-0.0501375869,
0.0075831721,
-0.0150537258,
-0.0033976508,
0.0098116715,
0.0415131971,
-0.0236381851,
0.0144048445,
0.0031845395,
0.0955171287,
-0.0203415547,
-0.0380003266,
-0.0160364769,
-0.006813053,
-0.0473213159,
-0.0054046251,
-0.0081922729,
-0.043570105,
-0.0217296202,
0.0146460962,
-0.0052763359,
-0.0372708365,
-0.0177619215,
-0.0120416256,
-0.0483362973,
-0.0070694382,
-0.0210656375,
-0.0442388952,
0.0206335578,
-0.0034518165,
0.0440075435,
-6.56282243e-33,
-0.0155327283,
-0.0231023785,
0.000319959,
0.0039249123,
0.0213269591,
0.0239631347,
-0.0386940166,
0.0255874284,
-0.0462043136,
0.0009713114,
-0.0054643517,
-0.0079092523,
0.0174444783,
0.0000621882,
-0.0049537723,
0.0289434809,
0.038025178,
-0.0213064179,
0.0044884062,
-0.0061530499,
0.0539874062,
-0.0098068789,
0.0730291754,
-0.0714730173,
0.0139702139,
0.0008900049,
-0.0157308709,
0.0008124959,
0.0108676059,
0.0531644262,
0.0310508348,
0.0423786603,
0.0053416495,
0.0222240239,
-0.0295987036,
-0.0307126828,
-0.1100275889,
-0.0174764469,
0.0390438698,
0.0836363733,
-0.0109865023,
0.013215703,
0.0068540829,
-0.0063914461,
0.0002707634,
-0.0425539389,
0.0167769771,
-0.032861542,
0.0032823775,
0.006352738,
-0.0321746469,
0.0136060314,
-0.0132400468,
-0.0045289686,
0.0626431629,
0.0795748383,
-0.0356378071,
-0.0909541473,
-0.0598801672,
0.0330169238,
0.0117517952,
0.047937274,
0.037652202,
-0.0179615095,
0.0140641406,
0.0266837534,
0.0767585933,
-0.0418369807,
0.0373453535,
-0.0171603877,
0.0567839108,
-0.031643156,
0.0047601657,
0.0537564158,
0.018068023,
-0.029794246,
-0.0360099673,
-0.0029499871,
0.0674588457,
0.026996417,
-0.0410730951,
0.0128405401,
-0.021060966,
-0.0037725093,
-0.0567419045,
-0.0260298587,
0.0032693974,
0.0057159746,
0.0168584958,
-0.0207371414,
-0.0074467035,
-0.0344779789,
0.0633368865,
-0.0024236483,
0.0187563244,
-0.0029634065,
0.0309117176,
-0.018241737,
-0.0327233337,
0.0497623757,
-0.042291753,
-0.0167236309,
0.029963892,
0.0219853744,
0.028707359,
0.0309321322,
0.0006970403,
0.0471863225,
-0.0403331295,
0.0072430745,
0.0214336272,
0.0039590453,
0.0070431679,
0.0159880854,
0.0275399908,
0.0134400111,
0.006339204,
0.0500402339,
0.0068734149,
-0.010033736,
-0.0236572698,
-0.0166103821,
-0.042291183,
0.0087454943,
-0.0334194712,
0.0081318226,
-0.0174681786,
-0.0290228352,
0.0639466047,
-0.0003000635,
0.0167667307,
-0.0002264931,
2.794e-7,
-0.0589065962,
0.0143427253,
0.0492376387,
-0.0174208898,
0.0215812735,
-0.0306931902,
-0.0165108498,
-0.0222128145,
0.026211556,
0.0653074309,
0.0075456114,
-0.0274859406,
0.1323350221,
0.0381737649,
-0.0955297351,
-0.0180154499,
-0.0459030531,
0.0241073389,
-0.0005116187,
0.0552726239,
0.0151475016,
0.0536763668,
-0.0451616496,
-0.0246654861,
-0.0094021335,
-0.0068818466,
-0.0251927618,
0.0130153922,
0.0086971307,
0.0033719109,
-0.0184683278,
0.0007765854,
-0.0251210928,
0.0256295986,
-0.0497410558,
0.0574634075,
-0.0234954394,
0.0282454342,
-0.0150926998,
-0.0439681821,
-0.0222631972,
0.0494014546,
-0.0592374392,
0.0046849339,
0.0373310484,
0.0202267952,
-0.01619941,
0.0512624867,
0.0070825792,
-0.0182395671,
-0.0049611614,
0.0085298233,
0.0024777544,
0.0741432235,
-0.0013952943,
-0.0144743826,
0.0005527835,
0.0022433661,
0.0137742572,
0.0429580957,
-0.0397267826,
-0.0441009775,
0.0467774086,
-0.0255932901,
-0.0481405221,
0.009890263,
0.0144657437,
1.592316038e-34,
0.001140105,
-0.0399051495,
0.0271964129,
-0.0215552654,
0.0238286927,
-0.0442878455,
-0.0072260364,
-0.0059311748,
0.0181561727,
-0.0242586546,
-0.0485230125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01503v1 | NewsPanda: Media Monitoring for Timely Conservation Action | 2023-04-30T07:15:29 | 2023-04-30T07:15:29 | Sedrick Scott Keh, Zheyuan Ryan Shi, David J. Patterson, Nirmal Bhagabati, Karun Dewan, Areendran Gopala, Pablo Izquierdo, Debojyoti Mallick, Ambika Sharma, Pooja Shrestha, Fei Fang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CY | Non-governmental organizations for environmental conservation have a
significant interest in monitoring conservation-related media and getting
timely updates about infrastructure construction projects as they may cause
massive impact to key conservation areas. Such monitoring, however, is
difficult and time-consuming. We introduce NewsPanda, a toolkit which
automatically detects and analyzes online articles related to environmental
conservation and infrastructure construction. We fine-tune a BERT-based model
using active learning methods and noise correction algorithms to identify
articles that are relevant to conservation and infrastructure construction. For
the identified articles, we perform further analysis, extracting keywords and
finding potentially related sources. NewsPanda has been successfully deployed
by the World Wide Fund for Nature teams in the UK, India, and Nepal since
February 2022. It currently monitors over 80,000 websites and 1,074
conservation sites across India and Nepal, saving more than 30 hours of human
efforts weekly. We have now scaled it up to cover 60,000 conservation sites
globally. | [
0.0538937002,
0.1098189726,
-0.0081268568,
0.0054000542,
0.0021960975,
-0.0088246064,
-0.0165731702,
0.0319914073,
-0.0513358898,
-0.0700669885,
0.0245607588,
0.0788575411,
-0.0283704568,
0.0364055261,
-0.0316651464,
-0.0607629903,
0.0679924786,
-0.0133692101,
0.0751474723,
0.0174428206,
-0.0056166542,
-0.0132457307,
-0.0269006994,
0.0196652189,
-0.0028879193,
0.0247176755,
-0.0466867387,
0.0175887533,
0.0560179353,
-0.0721608251,
0.052028656,
0.0453846715,
0.019406192,
0.0084607024,
0.0000020267,
-0.0237241387,
-0.0387887135,
-0.0306194481,
0.036144577,
0.042427633,
0.0078592887,
-0.0274636522,
-0.0147510748,
-0.0228467342,
-0.0054391753,
-0.0255588945,
0.0710678101,
-0.0150840813,
0.02012516,
0.064865604,
-0.003411063,
0.0353169553,
0.0155094247,
-0.0071063428,
0.0326285698,
-0.0247951709,
0.0521520786,
-0.0446874984,
-0.0399493836,
0.0281714406,
0.0205755513,
0.0473403037,
-0.0353678837,
-0.0228753798,
0.0337394476,
0.026419282,
-0.0692953095,
-0.0608590618,
0.0040434357,
0.0335753262,
0.0162797906,
-0.0149560049,
0.0313892215,
-0.0135196,
-0.0227796305,
0.0578458123,
-0.0454812273,
0.0535408184,
-0.0203242004,
-0.0105899265,
-0.005177353,
-0.0155277755,
-0.0275357775,
0.0681749061,
0.0272829104,
-0.0086699538,
-0.0106946789,
-0.0423155911,
-0.0107021378,
0.0477335081,
0.022017289,
-0.0493058078,
0.0674682409,
0.0275084712,
-0.0149565004,
-0.0121774618,
-0.0062946305,
-0.0340084471,
0.0519083366,
-0.077143155,
-0.0514458604,
0.0013623559,
-0.0548769347,
0.0686553344,
0.0349603295,
-0.0282627083,
-0.0013395393,
-0.0380957797,
0.0394365415,
0.0442349501,
-0.0311875977,
-0.043282453,
0.0059501505,
0.0237507094,
-0.0046927822,
-0.0103540989,
0.0068952222,
0.0110991634,
-0.0046581877,
0.0269990992,
0.0068119657,
0.0135154072,
-0.0215775203,
-0.0158226825,
0.0243118405,
0.0521859452,
-0.0497358032,
0.0536525697,
-0.0109152244,
0.0089918766,
0.0089346198,
0.0051649655,
0.0463823341,
-0.0026725614,
-0.012283803,
0.0253421012,
0.0289366581,
-0.0737832561,
-0.0676698536,
-0.0046225954,
0.0215581078,
0.0304234903,
-0.0051008239,
-0.0103759104,
-0.0258814413,
-0.0362898409,
0.0151866097,
-0.0084097181,
0.000303822,
0.0185502674,
-0.038987536,
0.0543169752,
-0.0391105786,
0.0072630597,
0.0521873981,
0.0000087115,
0.0584755056,
0.0866090357,
0.0104111321,
0.0726984888,
0.0762805864,
0.0133686466,
-0.0042522233,
0.0064106365,
-0.0016418886,
-0.0036196746,
-0.0170126203,
-0.0028571223,
-0.0634083375,
-0.0243770387,
-0.0153256105,
-0.0077736503,
0.007481961,
0.0619376041,
0.0617381781,
0.019580707,
-0.021472035,
-0.0226628855,
-0.010601148,
0.0470389798,
0.0024527968,
-0.0376417935,
0.0006008344,
0.0348193944,
-0.0349644572,
-0.0258268658,
-0.0143576255,
0.0521609709,
-0.0202650242,
-0.0213310961,
-0.0199303422,
0.0044987281,
-0.0132826027,
-0.0227063429,
0.0545953698,
-0.0202960502,
-0.0075099124,
0.0254044887,
0.0160436891,
-0.0123860445,
0.0377454497,
-0.0230987836,
0.0532077849,
0.0278573595,
0.0116252992,
-0.0586750843,
-0.0403697528,
-0.0146162398,
0.0183653533,
0.0253793448,
0.0230061654,
-0.0187210478,
-0.0444360934,
-0.0380564742,
-0.0551941656,
-0.001794792,
0.0409202352,
-0.0030020413,
0.0350184254,
0.0748677552,
0.0025780513,
-0.0464269891,
-0.0222037453,
0.0668004006,
0.025637893,
-0.030201517,
-0.0149523206,
0.014510382,
0.0077804043,
0.0231203549,
-0.0343391187,
-0.0014473336,
0.0507091135,
0.0394972451,
-0.0250517782,
0.0352825783,
0.0841326267,
0.0325078554,
0.0244012773,
-0.0748923719,
-0.0136980349,
0.0322619341,
-0.0242634937,
0.0138002606,
-0.0217919331,
-0.0158779435,
0.0272862371,
-0.0272736568,
0.0323325358,
-0.0169122778,
-0.029011013,
-0.0515364744,
0.0778063908,
0.007379828,
-0.0007322431,
-0.0152521394,
-0.0757613853,
0.0171760973,
-0.0323569477,
0.0088118259,
-0.0357137658,
-0.0447568186,
-0.0283849891,
0.0634005964,
0.0419759825,
-0.042437803,
-0.0162905157,
-0.0393032469,
-0.0272988081,
-0.0104971984,
0.031073302,
0.0264401473,
-0.006531056,
-0.0289661121,
0.0189791881,
0.0725772828,
-0.0192667972,
-0.0345995948,
0.0191514157,
0.0466963127,
-0.0377054177,
0.0061464957,
-0.0531240143,
0.0004020916,
-0.0296504311,
0.0607215986,
0.068275407,
-0.1302662045,
-0.0325127281,
-0.0158001538,
0.0036451088,
-0.0266669132,
0.0104359379,
-0.0522857718,
-0.0084261373,
0.0076840851,
-0.0417471081,
0.0170464143,
0.0598566569,
0.0537592582,
-0.0025224541,
-0.0094119469,
-0.0460699946,
0.0123714712,
-0.0052127521,
0.0000424733,
0.0304559749,
-0.006208926,
0.0729995295,
-0.0012528136,
-0.0829778686,
0.0088961646,
0.0084586497,
0.0389476568,
0.0031930972,
0.0105325347,
-0.0363752805,
-0.0448644012,
0.0242344718,
0.0836120471,
0.0068203574,
-0.0310536437,
0.0497927517,
0.0413634107,
0.0159647111,
-0.0785620138,
0.0070694578,
-0.008767697,
0.0171484519,
-0.0096663097,
0.016707221,
0.0171311367,
-0.0237470269,
0.0133194029,
-0.0419828482,
0.0115230409,
-0.0191968624,
-0.0758421123,
-0.02476722,
0.0266274009,
0.0023233674,
-0.0172493197,
-0.0232261717,
-0.0051036491,
0.004885071,
-0.0135340923,
0.0038297053,
-0.0475289188,
-0.0558730699,
0.0590136573,
0.0353591964,
-0.0239242446,
0.0030385463,
-0.0159406234,
0.0159776267,
0.0802664384,
0.0167028066,
-0.0194064565,
0.0096105803,
0.0033142583,
-0.0272425059,
0.0198706258,
0.0008908445,
0.0197858531,
0.0040169517,
0.029971851,
0.0162320379,
-0.0500322208,
0.0212666746,
-0.0151560614,
-0.0068685431,
-0.0267064627,
-0.0053875661,
0.0707853287,
0.0419454835,
-0.0684412271,
-0.0070632617,
-0.0386692397,
-0.0388698354,
0.0018723111,
0.0160152167,
-0.0188751575,
0.005879499,
0.0299565289,
0.0025688084,
0.0024532459,
-0.0376452357,
-0.013034625,
-0.0509387366,
0.0468382984,
-0.0186535139,
0.0032311636,
-0.0007408702,
-0.0902944803,
-0.0052147121,
-0.0454246663,
-0.0566769727,
0.0163751189,
-0.0151264751,
0.0129230954,
0.0419163927,
-0.0787558556,
-0.0636302903,
-0.0414285772,
-0.0211904477,
0.0180168245,
0.0939352289,
0.049033165,
-0.0385184959,
-0.0480218083,
0.0626078695,
0.0173698384,
-0.0456701294,
-0.0143040204,
0.029403938,
0.00797447,
-0.0267899428,
0.0180873368,
-0.0010655611,
-0.0100496626,
-0.0202574525,
0.0499378629,
0.0496477894,
-0.0052022873,
0.0136878369,
-0.0451652035,
0.0093160188,
0.0751804709,
0.0098094586,
0.0130080516,
-0.0172264148,
-0.0174398143,
-0.0333491117,
-0.0130377151,
-0.0438013896,
0.0065160873,
-0.0182509422,
-0.0901778936,
-0.0892225802,
-0.0902057812,
0.0018053304,
0.0591240153,
0.0271060746,
0.022519473,
-0.0387294777,
0.0914438888,
0.0041569229,
-0.0487760492,
0.039774064,
0.019761961,
-0.0055793817,
-0.0388287492,
-0.0473576188,
0.0531708635,
0.0459648781,
-0.0358191133,
0.0184384231,
-0.0283446889,
-0.038444791,
0.008030857,
0.0070287213,
0.033787176,
-0.0364131816,
0.0092897918,
0.0081374291,
0.0041298023,
0.098613739,
-0.0195108149,
-0.052307263,
0.0253419764,
-0.0196568966,
-0.003610116,
-0.0092559187,
-0.0240673348,
0.0214126371,
-0.0258175917,
0.042714633,
-0.046222873,
0.0205328874,
0.0028284336,
-0.0005498916,
0.0565468371,
0.0066438648,
-0.0483098738,
-0.0239055157,
0.0209527053,
0.0449671783,
-0.0129679814,
-0.0310643874,
0.0514142662,
-0.0123505378,
0.0316609889,
-0.0220447611,
0.1214601547,
-0.0101408409,
0.0170543492,
-0.0864231959,
0.0057053631,
0.0112117697,
0.0307019558,
-0.0171298273,
-0.015183364,
-0.0085164281,
0.0098531777,
0.0062939683,
0.0142614311,
-0.0158909969,
-0.0159616601,
0.027891675,
0.0355238132,
0.0152267646,
-0.0111695584,
-0.0060685067,
-0.007944365,
-0.0588375516,
0.0873821527,
0.0489043221,
0.0171148162,
0.0045472276,
-0.030343052,
-0.0488260202,
0.0025092897,
-0.0101676462,
0.0260753054,
-0.0267166868,
0.0055639348,
0.0074129449,
-0.0225537475,
-0.0199871082,
0.0258449558,
0.0133998748,
0.0282755923,
-0.0068899021,
-0.0503306761,
-0.032704141,
0.0048287176,
0.027411405,
0.0328471288,
0.01984597,
0.0187740177,
0.0119278934,
0.013536795,
0.0069765095,
-0.0256572515,
-0.0078843273,
-0.0091206711,
0.0046218089,
0.0419805422,
0.0190142803,
0.0003328281,
0.0042107115,
-0.0317760818,
-0.0692516938,
0.0050221626,
-0.0064215902,
-6.5026812e-33,
-0.0465363935,
-0.0597780682,
-0.0280183703,
-0.0154080801,
0.0127457445,
0.0536426045,
-0.0124511505,
-0.0404957458,
0.0004331643,
0.0253350399,
-0.0050118826,
0.0046941801,
0.0314316638,
-0.0170110613,
0.052812878,
0.042262394,
0.0422726832,
0.0181715507,
-0.0031207881,
-0.00423032,
0.0384421721,
0.0466074347,
0.0521362089,
-0.0732720345,
0.0153653221,
0.0580810197,
-0.0410440899,
-0.0154255126,
0.0404273532,
0.0284967739,
-0.0224962737,
0.012363093,
0.0106880423,
-0.0158057697,
-0.0147889219,
0.0372777916,
-0.0950344726,
-0.0198080204,
0.0037230505,
0.0079883365,
0.0336111188,
0.0291735046,
0.0464360155,
0.0107183792,
-0.0121269664,
0.0479369424,
0.0518319719,
-0.0398366153,
-0.0341567658,
-0.0504180118,
-0.060108304,
-0.0023266631,
-0.0549595691,
0.0309252981,
-0.0278285164,
-0.0008300534,
0.0088754548,
0.0609670505,
-0.0654217675,
0.0379728712,
0.0428722277,
0.0489232056,
0.0134083657,
-0.0268743411,
-0.0339682661,
0.04781745,
-0.0440115593,
-0.0170354843,
0.0067277993,
-0.0135728493,
0.0039575868,
0.00981363,
0.009199488,
0.0057362299,
0.0210154336,
-0.0428101979,
-0.0695207343,
0.0676294342,
0.0858636498,
0.0601565279,
0.0278829187,
0.0037347698,
0.0290042888,
0.0189925898,
0.0190194827,
0.0172207952,
-0.0346873365,
0.0293410253,
0.0206357557,
0.0324820019,
-0.0808976144,
0.0215440765,
-0.0247740149,
-0.013670655,
-0.0142510096,
0.066475369,
-0.0198504161,
0.0098067578,
-0.0102887852,
0.0004736221,
-0.0354416929,
-0.066147089,
-0.0134212347,
0.0538726449,
-0.0077713132,
-0.0027485667,
0.0020981161,
-0.0104110427,
-0.0668992549,
0.0089833727,
-0.0019460648,
-0.0072625526,
-0.0262062214,
0.0189443715,
0.0034430171,
-0.0466436185,
0.0061374987,
-0.0285268538,
0.0598252341,
-0.0111777922,
0.0272876229,
-0.0014564609,
-0.0593478195,
0.0457708426,
0.0103821671,
-0.0334344022,
-0.0295383222,
0.0059793615,
-0.0358990021,
-0.0484504998,
0.0088769337,
0.0057044411,
2.874e-7,
0.017678827,
0.0732342228,
-0.0084017534,
-0.0159288719,
0.0086337095,
-0.0057025468,
-0.0473776422,
0.025716383,
-0.0504633076,
0.0082885306,
0.0205299966,
-0.033694189,
-0.0050297128,
0.0172529165,
-0.0502065159,
-0.0669615716,
-0.1000280529,
-0.0092342757,
-0.100028716,
0.0211191606,
-0.0295319054,
-0.0059494385,
0.0014108729,
0.0036415502,
0.0051052542,
-0.0597290359,
0.0198082402,
-0.0326481499,
-0.0036393846,
0.0014856537,
0.0345061086,
0.0013033503,
-0.0200534463,
-0.0232248493,
-0.0456896983,
-0.0366954617,
-0.0015392017,
0.0314101763,
0.0298315436,
0.016527636,
-0.0114427153,
-0.0039939363,
0.021805862,
-0.0209362619,
0.0558168553,
0.013239895,
0.0084443204,
-0.0167384353,
-0.0541050136,
-0.0083207246,
0.0078176577,
-0.0108513953,
-0.0181037169,
-0.0146672567,
-0.0211574174,
0.016990291,
-0.0286611728,
-0.0676525906,
0.0262018237,
-0.0124920607,
-0.0280675795,
-0.0551840141,
-0.0356214382,
0.0129461074,
-0.0018561115,
-0.0274656508,
0.0304251593,
2.320740844e-34,
0.0534587204,
0.0181917474,
-0.0399215259,
0.02741009,
-0.0033152252,
0.0379757509,
-0.0041528703,
-0.0070182099,
-0.0069678258,
-0.0220391881,
0.0446354598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01505v2 | Beyond Classification: Financial Reasoning in State-of-the-Art Language Models | 2023-04-30T04:36:05 | 2023-06-25T18:06:25 | Guijin Son, Hanearl Jung, Moonjeong Hahm, Keonju Na, Sol Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs), consisting of 100 billion or more parameters,
have demonstrated remarkable ability in complex multi-step reasoning tasks.
However, the application of such generic advancements has been limited to a few
fields, such as clinical or legal, with the field of financial reasoning
remaining largely unexplored. To the best of our knowledge, the ability of LLMs
to solve financial reasoning problems has never been dealt with, and whether it
can be performed at any scale remains unknown. To address this knowledge gap,
this research presents a comprehensive investigation into the potential
application of LLMs in the financial domain. The investigation includes a
detailed exploration of a range of subjects, including task formulation,
synthetic data generation, prompting methods, and evaluation capability.
Furthermore, the study benchmarks various GPT variants with parameter scales
ranging from 2.8B to 13B, with and without instruction tuning, on diverse
dataset sizes. By analyzing the results, we reveal that the ability to generate
coherent financial reasoning first emerges at 6B parameters, and continues to
improve with better instruction-tuning or larger datasets. Additionally, the
study provides a publicly accessible dataset named sFIOG (Synthetic-Financial
Investment Opinion Generation), consisting of 11,802 synthetic investment
thesis samples, to support further research in the field of financial
reasoning. Overall, this research seeks to contribute to the understanding of
the efficacy of language models in the field of finance, with a particular
emphasis on their ability to engage in sophisticated reasoning and analysis
within the context of investment decision-making. | [
0.0122833233,
0.0787988678,
0.0013227459,
-0.0138614299,
-0.0141467638,
0.020994639,
0.0541722067,
0.0372598805,
0.0037783552,
-0.0104746111,
-0.0128892539,
-0.0516221635,
-0.0300764833,
0.0556933656,
0.0414135717,
-0.0382383168,
0.010502195,
-0.0537547693,
0.0589049347,
-0.0319563299,
0.0076779053,
0.0005175816,
-0.0005706869,
0.0112769296,
0.0065749423,
-0.0249921195,
-0.011890538,
-0.0311055202,
0.0066985474,
-0.0150381578,
-0.0208203942,
0.0516638532,
0.0383358039,
0.0506974719,
0.0000021345,
-0.050593596,
-0.0293518808,
-0.000309915,
-0.0251612663,
0.0199895408,
0.0280410629,
0.0060815094,
0.02599678,
0.0278998874,
-0.0664201006,
0.030557923,
0.0500370786,
0.0639376566,
0.0649181902,
0.0716353878,
-0.0021146573,
-0.0733361542,
0.0160809271,
-0.0706174746,
-0.010172138,
-0.0439630263,
0.0300384108,
0.0417937525,
0.0049226666,
-0.0023659933,
-0.0054028793,
0.0121979183,
0.0260876026,
-0.0096693346,
-0.0025227102,
0.0230799001,
-0.0508717671,
0.0132657168,
-0.0248213746,
0.0352247059,
0.0076313121,
0.0473163053,
0.0233626422,
-0.0235509891,
0.00429594,
0.0195689686,
-0.0315193795,
0.0660183504,
-0.0284832455,
0.0319892578,
0.0385693163,
-0.0164434966,
0.0328121223,
-0.0063154283,
-0.0536634661,
0.0535674319,
-0.0349510051,
-0.0448256582,
0.0510149002,
0.028649956,
-0.0502397008,
-0.0385205112,
0.008172092,
0.0306268819,
0.0053034206,
0.0130060762,
0.0075108926,
-0.0067220763,
0.0142073138,
-0.0714599788,
0.0501271114,
0.0370818153,
0.0191161931,
0.0334197469,
-0.0584317483,
0.0628256425,
-0.0298946723,
-0.0148111191,
-0.0181068275,
0.04325049,
-0.0914210007,
-0.0253254361,
-0.0305276215,
0.0772767216,
-0.0474567562,
-0.0145863201,
-0.0807109997,
-0.0069060652,
-0.0422786735,
0.0274989847,
0.0100873644,
-0.0100603364,
-0.0169199239,
-0.0321501195,
-0.0816710219,
-0.0270412974,
-0.0413290374,
0.0180856567,
-0.0059448928,
-0.0021874835,
0.0322225653,
0.0133862458,
-0.0583950914,
-0.0124726556,
0.0320798568,
0.0812276825,
0.0067453734,
0.0083192214,
-0.0792684034,
-0.0594120584,
-0.0027735543,
-0.075127095,
0.0052816551,
-0.0587035455,
0.0091973646,
-0.0000025201,
-0.0446236692,
-0.0038615901,
0.0138983903,
0.0030516777,
-0.0024418479,
0.0720999166,
0.0153887263,
-0.0136289261,
-0.0055585904,
-0.0222142991,
0.0042863814,
0.0592606328,
0.0006174078,
0.031161679,
-0.0093029384,
-0.0075571653,
-0.0009532305,
0.021710882,
-0.0125384396,
-0.0345847756,
-0.0214161053,
0.0330972821,
-0.0062780324,
0.0186902713,
0.0272538904,
0.0471142791,
-0.0387911238,
-0.0122787394,
0.053884767,
0.0196846854,
0.0740802884,
0.0421267264,
0.0441183187,
0.0163642894,
0.0322683901,
-0.0163761638,
-0.0023860591,
0.0076334099,
-0.0191121623,
0.0414817296,
-0.0136190262,
0.0113073261,
-0.0267006848,
-0.0534539483,
0.0065794475,
-0.0034404562,
-0.0228419453,
0.0089613022,
0.0230324473,
-0.0529334433,
-0.0498634055,
0.0517626926,
0.0293686111,
-0.0084810695,
-0.0391513817,
-0.0436768606,
0.0540504567,
0.0987462476,
0.0254704989,
-0.0123333232,
0.0109978858,
-0.0309172552,
-0.0129685747,
0.0437060148,
0.0692736953,
-0.0031964551,
-0.0587459281,
-0.0590397678,
-0.0021480762,
0.0017970207,
0.0099526029,
0.0478119478,
0.0135508403,
-0.0065987976,
0.005564725,
-0.010531147,
-0.0007110419,
-0.0113255149,
-0.0277753845,
-0.0471396223,
0.0002518935,
-0.0438379347,
0.0058896402,
0.0175493583,
-0.0115199722,
0.0140745919,
-0.0229189191,
-0.0130644506,
-0.0370697156,
-0.0170166362,
-0.0705759451,
0.0111984247,
-0.0134486137,
-0.0230692625,
-0.0048369169,
-0.033138752,
-0.0402280129,
-0.0133340089,
-0.0177010447,
-0.0107054524,
0.0117921168,
-0.0823367164,
-0.0065054656,
0.0074637895,
0.0148371272,
-0.0112282922,
0.0855905041,
-0.0069333026,
0.020843206,
-0.0018289796,
0.0219901875,
0.0030999847,
-0.0738763362,
0.0463652126,
0.0177378729,
0.0005589152,
0.0503719449,
-0.004533743,
0.026970638,
-0.0013930046,
-0.0415647216,
-0.0733559132,
-0.0152676515,
-0.0012966024,
0.0398828946,
0.0056669223,
-0.0512497313,
-0.0043357611,
0.0003167426,
-0.0601830259,
0.0120155588,
0.0009626926,
0.025324801,
0.0592403635,
-0.0115522072,
-0.0153621715,
-0.0144061176,
-0.0267777424,
-0.0209490042,
0.0168551262,
0.0688404813,
0.0129398536,
-0.0360088795,
0.0032537002,
-0.0109960064,
0.0161742065,
-0.0211025346,
0.0308465548,
0.0236275028,
-0.0334944576,
0.0426293053,
0.0365654156,
0.0080199689,
0.0495475829,
-0.002626583,
-0.0018613301,
-0.0275378283,
0.0330788046,
-0.0231647119,
0.0100424467,
-0.0229147244,
-0.0013112575,
-0.0065210685,
0.0704375207,
-0.0186855663,
0.0007938589,
-0.0931463838,
0.0542513244,
0.0050650137,
0.0121001406,
-0.0403277092,
0.0072352542,
0.0055761249,
0.0774157718,
0.020387765,
-0.0377504155,
0.0749247894,
-0.0008908284,
-0.01924593,
-0.0375789665,
-0.0035707324,
-0.0572958663,
0.0351235121,
-0.0219191331,
-0.0047389888,
-0.0262924451,
-0.0150052244,
-0.0450908393,
-0.0291389208,
0.030520957,
-0.0233070143,
0.0471231639,
-0.0560582206,
0.0004641341,
0.0072278548,
-0.0051386408,
-0.021068804,
-0.0622333139,
-0.01866295,
0.0169852078,
0.0429791361,
-0.048374474,
-0.0323870219,
0.0129167791,
-0.0039526452,
-0.0078955786,
-0.0208830964,
-0.0366106816,
0.013381185,
-0.0039319433,
0.0499589965,
0.0036848974,
0.0440845713,
-0.0587681644,
0.083367981,
0.0082868179,
0.0144995758,
0.0146341706,
-0.0110056894,
0.0232748557,
-0.0186559595,
-0.0335402638,
-0.013637213,
0.0553444177,
-0.0238999762,
-0.0592225976,
-0.0068556461,
0.1108905226,
0.0153435785,
0.0172715876,
-0.0045346157,
-0.0168466754,
0.03285487,
-0.0217589419,
0.045114778,
-0.0943680331,
-0.0076195193,
-0.0020980518,
0.0226767119,
-0.0021988899,
-0.0553183742,
-0.0146311251,
-0.1298436224,
0.0868577138,
-0.0010937811,
0.0104619786,
-0.0304811373,
-0.0052089635,
-0.0461131297,
-0.0201220755,
0.0076059299,
0.0342865959,
-0.0196575057,
0.019767452,
0.0177235305,
-0.0379021801,
0.0133758951,
0.0436191559,
0.026154181,
-0.0267278384,
0.0295094997,
0.0127618611,
-0.0041707032,
-0.0391247496,
-0.0229612775,
0.0127541907,
0.0005492805,
0.0121364687,
0.061685618,
0.0339799523,
-0.0153723462,
-0.0096961968,
0.0311572123,
-0.0333321914,
0.0232835468,
0.008044363,
0.0499964617,
-0.0487854518,
-0.0615143813,
0.0085178157,
0.0382706784,
-0.0280385893,
0.0808210149,
0.0103654498,
-0.0473868959,
-0.0608464219,
-0.0521821827,
-0.0286807939,
-0.0573234223,
0.0122311618,
0.009531186,
0.0275872052,
0.0205748044,
-0.0666849539,
-0.0641853511,
0.0349874683,
0.0289817974,
-0.0059418562,
-0.0144900456,
0.0407027118,
-0.019208625,
-0.0298637822,
0.0515946597,
-0.0335013606,
0.0143826287,
-0.0461934581,
0.0083264355,
-0.0103290966,
-0.0587001517,
-0.0438270308,
0.0036502874,
-0.0255286619,
-0.0286920089,
0.0212821588,
0.0171002988,
0.0311977901,
-0.0260404032,
-0.0135227293,
0.0342567489,
0.0319709592,
0.0327357724,
-0.0137350624,
-0.0244117752,
0.0576864593,
0.0386434346,
0.0059971795,
0.0256349929,
-0.0227736719,
0.0232807659,
-0.0087306211,
0.0252172668,
-0.0538112931,
0.0225369129,
0.0112702139,
0.0282165594,
0.0253670774,
0.015636256,
-0.0063765799,
-0.0328385793,
-0.0192410816,
-0.0127979973,
-0.0011976875,
-0.0332081839,
-0.0304817576,
0.0694568977,
-0.0173808038,
-0.006636647,
-0.0117734391,
-0.0125437398,
-0.0467527024,
0.0084634749,
0.031351462,
0.0031751369,
0.0180441439,
0.0544086881,
-0.0529361852,
0.0074664019,
-0.0060841436,
0.0165429749,
0.0179623794,
0.0025579475,
0.0874746144,
0.021726368,
0.0086769229,
-0.0108027114,
-0.0254533514,
-0.0280306675,
-0.0902763233,
0.0141040664,
0.0514578782,
-0.0001172408,
-0.0149507821,
-0.0249838978,
-0.0757650957,
0.0140613271,
0.0104793692,
0.0129027786,
0.0281728022,
-0.0393920653,
0.0358295031,
0.0327799618,
-0.0441825837,
-0.0670978501,
0.1065543145,
0.0123788519,
0.0161110498,
-0.0596871413,
0.0039955736,
-0.0416576378,
-0.0523042716,
-0.0088163614,
0.003335166,
-0.0018698425,
0.0181206763,
-0.1018370092,
-0.0473792329,
-0.0341799222,
0.0261828434,
-0.0218721181,
-0.0179455113,
0.0377088934,
0.056250494,
-0.0252665039,
0.0494673811,
-0.0018430782,
0.0292942617,
-0.0225648824,
-0.006799038,
-0.0770779699,
-6.110902157e-33,
0.005982785,
-0.0268430747,
0.0704826415,
-0.0140150981,
0.0167185292,
-0.0080412589,
-0.0308452956,
0.0067286026,
0.0117607862,
0.0213929545,
0.0077823289,
0.0183524378,
0.0025125444,
0.0098753478,
0.0211549625,
-0.0280472692,
0.0177484564,
-0.0259380639,
-0.0051676007,
-0.0158576593,
0.0305835232,
0.0252618231,
0.0529122166,
-0.0454766266,
0.0385965966,
0.0249272007,
-0.0324096642,
0.0052570933,
-0.0286927018,
0.0574027896,
0.0016793865,
0.0464665331,
0.0104761142,
-0.1125676855,
-0.0063735475,
0.003138606,
0.0176572967,
-0.0431072339,
0.0062261824,
-0.0013852724,
-0.0139099527,
-0.0353782661,
0.0202443749,
-0.0010279279,
-0.0243522134,
-0.0200296156,
0.0045873355,
-0.0329202414,
0.0306995027,
-0.036515329,
-0.0602109432,
0.0305132922,
0.0047431299,
0.0447209813,
0.0212141238,
0.0761976019,
-0.0416067801,
0.0277164448,
0.0218165927,
0.0278009865,
0.0539481603,
-0.0047013168,
0.0311428811,
-0.0090825232,
-0.0026546314,
0.0522574633,
-0.0009405728,
0.0030512069,
-0.0507223196,
0.0059556402,
-0.0155770741,
0.0709218383,
0.0853486434,
0.0216341987,
0.0237161182,
-0.0018555147,
-0.0435771532,
0.002226697,
0.0054390905,
0.0140054487,
0.0349049903,
0.0103602493,
-0.0439779684,
-0.0467896573,
-0.0258162059,
-0.0185812078,
-0.0225953776,
-0.0011041312,
0.0335977077,
-0.0000948799,
0.016689932,
0.0142196994,
0.0130579323,
-0.0179945678,
-0.0408198461,
-0.0188006349,
0.0038974071,
0.0015101288,
0.0010256798,
0.0198512748,
-0.0340500399,
-0.0330309123,
-0.0018849365,
-0.0134649817,
-0.0095223049,
0.0069143786,
0.0150996167,
0.0042556571,
-0.0339444317,
-0.0155669088,
-0.0399991535,
0.0379202403,
0.0148774153,
0.0114655988,
0.0115936352,
0.0194586292,
-0.0049767345,
-0.0080519114,
-0.0091755744,
0.0066450764,
-0.0198434405,
-0.0050137397,
-0.0211258251,
0.065716967,
0.0308386944,
0.0306615662,
-0.0092248907,
0.0208474435,
0.037281584,
-0.0319870003,
-0.0249201618,
0.0786442682,
2.857e-7,
0.0419620574,
0.0923556313,
-0.0196140781,
0.0125389183,
0.0185926929,
0.0505148284,
-0.0243271198,
-0.0474314317,
0.0116511742,
-0.0188640598,
0.0468992628,
0.0460869968,
0.067877844,
0.0124358227,
-0.0511892922,
-0.0458278172,
-0.0642117932,
0.0050251065,
-0.0701445118,
0.0477900095,
0.0471880138,
0.0615552776,
-0.0067093186,
-0.0444175228,
0.0258793999,
-0.0539501607,
0.0666303411,
-0.0540880412,
-0.0063643218,
0.0126977293,
0.0482411273,
-0.0233823899,
0.0072656218,
0.0505895056,
0.0173867606,
-0.0036772196,
-0.0035821972,
0.0813961923,
0.033198107,
0.0090634301,
0.0150652537,
-0.0374177583,
-0.0088262921,
-0.0730570182,
0.0571472608,
-0.0782109797,
-0.0487207212,
-0.0223637447,
-0.0254297834,
-0.0004353714,
0.0435017943,
0.0049102977,
0.0087947892,
0.0036225051,
0.00234127,
-0.0296602342,
0.0349511392,
-0.0151955225,
-0.0335051343,
0.0624209717,
-0.0740806833,
0.004914172,
-0.0555384681,
0.038458474,
0.0472526662,
-0.0635478273,
0.000006778,
2.753842095e-34,
0.0570136122,
-0.024966903,
-0.0081924163,
0.0031008413,
0.0617623404,
0.0230957735,
-0.0428652018,
0.0483512096,
0.0089888796,
-0.096244812,
-0.0132269403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00382v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00382v2 | Constructing a Knowledge Graph from Textual Descriptions of Software Vulnerabilities in the National Vulnerability Database | 2023-04-30T04:23:40 | 2023-05-15T07:36:11 | Anders Mølmen Høst, Pierre Lison, Leon Moonen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Knowledge graphs have shown promise for several cybersecurity tasks, such as
vulnerability assessment and threat analysis. In this work, we present a new
method for constructing a vulnerability knowledge graph from information in the
National Vulnerability Database (NVD). Our approach combines named entity
recognition (NER), relation extraction (RE), and entity prediction using a
combination of neural models, heuristic rules, and knowledge graph embeddings.
We demonstrate how our method helps to fix missing entities in knowledge graphs
used for cybersecurity and evaluate the performance. | [
0.0184153933,
0.060770452,
0.0040115747,
0.0397445261,
-0.0052617388,
-0.0054227663,
-0.0200220235,
0.0137388892,
0.0868099928,
-0.0433969386,
0.0548244901,
-0.0286577716,
-0.0253422335,
0.0376956947,
0.0701284334,
-0.0000798488,
0.0509450324,
-0.002086882,
0.0232518204,
0.0202837642,
-0.0253433697,
0.0261188466,
-0.0426132716,
0.0258277152,
-0.0028954372,
0.0074925157,
-0.0098725958,
0.023370998,
0.0730750635,
-0.0788039789,
-0.016503362,
-0.0151657537,
-0.0353470184,
-0.0463870354,
0.0000016746,
-0.0234915875,
-0.0390920006,
0.0038045337,
-0.0159437209,
-0.0235481132,
-0.0126022045,
-0.049582582,
0.0034751117,
0.0259953234,
-0.0235618893,
-0.0658174157,
0.0112793939,
0.0671519339,
0.0334131233,
0.0941164196,
-0.0095043518,
0.0055075539,
0.0317572169,
0.0011428776,
-0.0187308732,
-0.0235030837,
0.0463443361,
-0.0044578183,
-0.0136234229,
0.0214883853,
0.019661922,
0.0059518167,
0.0008003796,
0.028920494,
0.0601095147,
0.0520256124,
0.0098519167,
0.0363863334,
0.0052715102,
0.0691485405,
0.0016393962,
0.0401386283,
0.0268173851,
0.0063758441,
0.0082226265,
0.0324837454,
0.0506964028,
-0.0366515219,
-0.0327254608,
-0.0105157234,
0.0201010313,
-0.0152765084,
0.0225262437,
-0.0489280112,
0.0098943813,
0.0445495918,
-0.0182189792,
-0.0357310139,
0.033229582,
-0.0728444681,
0.022184588,
-0.0281250775,
0.0218457542,
0.0245908648,
0.027071856,
0.0538698696,
-0.0340635739,
-0.0079776458,
0.0182434265,
-0.0617113821,
-0.0523896292,
-0.0167583358,
0.0371561684,
0.0184776187,
-0.0181079898,
0.0312543958,
0.0257558152,
0.0070705716,
-0.0071973871,
-0.0073577482,
-0.094996281,
-0.0286342409,
-0.0072835246,
0.0487913527,
0.0426983573,
-0.0185441077,
-0.0191257074,
0.0167561453,
-0.029359512,
0.0682209283,
0.0106077399,
0.0078605758,
0.0188870262,
0.0300801285,
-0.0238051116,
-0.0187018774,
-0.0124804219,
-0.0280772354,
-0.0752236396,
-0.0190441664,
-0.0142133217,
-0.0503334329,
0.0176395364,
-0.0366921537,
-0.0305435807,
0.1087424085,
0.0806059241,
-0.0268000457,
-0.073791258,
-0.0338097252,
-0.0033104511,
0.0463789143,
0.0112231197,
-0.0050134803,
0.0055381921,
-0.0049600443,
-0.0001083527,
-0.0530443862,
0.0134558054,
-0.0285432227,
-0.0933606774,
0.0499089286,
-0.0707999021,
-0.0049781087,
0.0107814297,
-0.0011565074,
0.0557684302,
-0.0383206345,
0.0120907808,
0.0089710709,
0.0154955778,
0.0068388535,
-0.0007867153,
0.0006414113,
0.0109465234,
-0.0196460094,
0.0240193233,
0.0307863671,
0.0048234453,
-0.0257611927,
0.0015741967,
0.0093889795,
-0.0057761394,
-0.045190759,
0.0062857284,
0.0245177802,
0.0394030809,
0.0378873721,
0.0329572409,
0.0515092947,
-0.0125684021,
-0.0348323695,
-0.070320189,
0.0201591533,
-0.0622790456,
-0.013725223,
-0.0462240949,
0.0120732188,
0.0009506189,
0.027281642,
-0.0203375444,
0.0009070765,
-0.0014679923,
-0.0302054379,
0.0213662013,
0.0347732827,
-0.0226455443,
0.0362765007,
0.0347674862,
-0.0045097587,
0.0089117931,
0.0132061662,
-0.071786426,
0.1017311662,
0.0517929792,
-0.0538145266,
-0.0919959247,
0.0118656307,
-0.0643226877,
0.0158624258,
0.0140752764,
-0.0229514409,
0.0119657982,
-0.0337346233,
-0.0210790075,
-0.032224793,
0.0274168048,
0.0137666631,
-0.0078270333,
0.0269508362,
0.0250141639,
-0.0611297786,
-0.0334507674,
0.0373966843,
0.0105185509,
-0.0225514211,
0.0177388024,
0.0411015339,
0.0363476351,
0.0402324162,
0.0053029121,
0.0419715047,
0.0397133939,
-0.005584578,
-0.0714490414,
-0.0128424577,
-0.0001740755,
-0.0261290874,
0.0352751203,
-0.0534909442,
0.0453368686,
0.0052468325,
-0.0416897237,
-0.0182346497,
0.0565274395,
-0.0507701226,
-0.0212304648,
0.0363629349,
-0.014243098,
0.0409132689,
-0.015853323,
-0.0057080234,
0.047081355,
-0.0008121626,
-0.0000276525,
-0.0390423387,
-0.0190697648,
-0.0054847933,
-0.0169434436,
-0.0223847944,
-0.0045130528,
-0.0377758667,
-0.0156857725,
-0.0188609734,
0.0001394938,
-0.0314830206,
0.0202458948,
-0.0704550371,
0.0030580238,
0.0212098788,
0.0724695176,
0.0412887335,
-0.0359154977,
-0.025434725,
-0.0275628455,
-0.0177113209,
-0.0018540828,
-0.0522725508,
-0.0243671983,
0.031820666,
-0.0041990285,
-0.0044179345,
-0.01335687,
-0.0274567977,
-0.0589267313,
0.0632837042,
0.0275492519,
-0.0298357829,
0.0018763628,
0.083842352,
-0.0624044091,
0.0062327092,
-0.0108190794,
-0.0373167172,
-0.018398067,
0.0240767486,
-0.0046288739,
-0.0280151647,
-0.0091860062,
0.0439168289,
0.021306837,
-0.029724611,
0.0045593311,
0.0176520552,
-0.0276743956,
0.0238516759,
-0.037067797,
-0.0511791967,
0.0072315084,
0.0126627097,
0.0607999489,
0.0068337927,
-0.0367824994,
-0.0037824514,
-0.0175787769,
0.0387115926,
-0.0134167131,
-0.0393985845,
0.0590181537,
-0.0521571115,
-0.0189240072,
0.0056182649,
0.0898905545,
-0.0103945192,
0.0448640473,
-0.0553136729,
-0.0299938917,
-0.0316732079,
0.0549672283,
-0.0020485916,
0.0230739713,
0.0766213536,
-0.0339126401,
-0.0211374853,
0.0069013112,
0.0119390078,
-0.0248732325,
-0.0166504104,
-0.0146357296,
0.0041266796,
0.0387227125,
0.0037305555,
-0.0427249521,
0.016327884,
-0.0086481078,
0.0268468559,
-0.005735666,
-0.021432478,
0.0188402869,
0.0180227924,
0.0205968264,
-0.0090624709,
0.050030686,
-0.0307565965,
-0.0012855263,
0.0150998011,
0.0292012151,
-0.0601288117,
0.009302618,
0.0398947783,
0.0267769229,
0.0373804234,
0.039668981,
-0.008484941,
-0.0362778604,
-0.0033362149,
-0.0353938192,
-0.0618271641,
0.0100456458,
0.0037091277,
-0.0136253424,
-0.0332831405,
0.0112740966,
0.0768449232,
0.0165295471,
0.0102289971,
0.023965165,
0.0189062878,
-0.0610003509,
0.0468039513,
0.0228705872,
-0.0659524649,
0.0175446086,
-0.0192870982,
0.0182409789,
0.0115285097,
-0.092639029,
-0.0004024353,
-0.0884604827,
-0.026425615,
-0.001741931,
-0.0120627498,
-0.0244402681,
-0.0623673722,
-0.0071298797,
0.0135026732,
-0.0562157296,
-0.0061596963,
-0.0073680081,
-0.0027376334,
-0.0001096037,
-0.0378168039,
-0.0524161607,
0.0125653278,
-0.034066584,
0.0410662778,
0.0146512864,
0.0430781096,
-0.0310326591,
0.0398918688,
0.0107916947,
-0.0268058162,
0.0170458276,
-0.0005308209,
0.1005067527,
-0.0152546233,
0.0001770594,
0.0087896865,
0.0143248783,
-0.0566080138,
-0.0123365279,
0.0658514723,
0.0528397448,
-0.0255389009,
0.0023166458,
-0.0219084453,
-0.0321600996,
0.0437423401,
0.0208633803,
0.0087879607,
0.0060508857,
0.0093599912,
-0.0111908335,
0.0579698011,
-0.0122734001,
-0.0021099481,
0.0301830806,
-0.0258863904,
-0.0185951106,
-0.0618954562,
-0.0578953736,
0.0300825275,
0.0022882463,
0.037713632,
-0.0709509701,
0.0736794546,
-0.0019666692,
-0.0576830655,
-0.0161263682,
0.0077931634,
0.0284773875,
0.0107803065,
-0.0053692278,
-0.0185251255,
0.0191364102,
-0.0479779467,
-0.022823412,
-0.0362521484,
-0.0600866452,
-0.0411133729,
0.0051245219,
0.0000471334,
-0.0144019807,
-0.0454251282,
-0.0114385448,
0.0846128613,
0.0532152914,
-0.0538131036,
-0.0254166648,
0.0110531347,
-0.0518153831,
0.0041403747,
0.0324509032,
-0.0335285775,
-0.0024343235,
0.0136040701,
0.0243956782,
-0.0167150702,
-0.0095120398,
-0.0065265466,
0.0295240115,
0.036486011,
0.0384953991,
-0.0060508722,
-0.0486708544,
0.0205123369,
-0.0119553786,
0.0016265274,
0.018826779,
0.0542538278,
-0.0051319785,
-0.0185990483,
0.0233220886,
-0.0322646499,
0.0181765668,
0.0060675172,
0.0021148182,
-0.0339551456,
0.0986358672,
0.032469295,
0.0574448034,
-0.0152266612,
0.0243703164,
0.0341422521,
0.0241172202,
-0.0136670228,
-0.0051718592,
-0.0080548227,
-0.017783856,
-0.0278423522,
-0.0508205816,
-0.0066325283,
-0.034548521,
-0.0397623368,
0.0069093369,
0.018846415,
0.0640646815,
0.0624367818,
-0.0122332573,
-0.0227402914,
0.0198794305,
0.004106096,
0.0168010462,
-0.0404243656,
-0.0298257973,
0.0300526135,
0.0204273444,
-0.0207028091,
0.000852858,
0.0612907112,
0.0090406295,
0.0739909038,
0.0146994358,
-0.0552548766,
-0.0379974619,
-0.0199429784,
-0.001094153,
0.0247985628,
-0.0462234877,
0.0007923986,
-0.0504581109,
-0.0751233473,
0.06558723,
-0.037232358,
0.0093103256,
0.0329426192,
0.0275828708,
0.0150538562,
0.0128806187,
0.0098974295,
-0.0377095416,
-0.0183573812,
-0.0918356776,
-0.0427869707,
-0.0000027054,
-5.509582797e-33,
-0.0027526005,
-0.0538596027,
0.001173821,
0.0053781392,
0.0035232815,
0.0595804825,
-0.0326909721,
-0.0129896095,
-0.0085461503,
-0.0003254201,
0.0464563631,
0.0324721448,
-0.005822388,
-0.0195331462,
-0.0362371542,
-0.0208059438,
0.0264310259,
0.0111929737,
0.0270825364,
0.0269081481,
0.0701277629,
0.0510479435,
0.0590874776,
-0.0789265335,
0.0464087054,
0.0019774621,
0.0059899068,
0.0005036364,
0.0459119789,
0.0210997425,
-0.0273521468,
0.0278798081,
0.0191217419,
-0.0054253493,
0.0243563429,
-0.0315569676,
-0.0787243173,
-0.0440977216,
-0.0549493656,
-0.045912452,
0.0240613669,
-0.017504001,
0.0302838273,
0.0102454666,
0.0752827078,
-0.0141893886,
0.0608313158,
0.0243137572,
-0.0059479545,
-0.0859049261,
0.0162316896,
0.0271077398,
-0.0490080602,
0.0560219623,
-0.0212722551,
-0.0026320114,
0.0583296083,
-0.049804654,
-0.0674528256,
-0.0023691072,
0.0108889164,
-0.0102579994,
0.0226487014,
-0.0079815136,
-0.0076385522,
0.0318167359,
-0.0293148588,
-0.0437957123,
-0.0067684008,
0.024685936,
0.0021274886,
0.0633915588,
-0.0070812739,
0.0101549188,
0.0127082197,
-0.0583022796,
-0.1064670309,
0.0029347728,
-0.031916827,
0.0690848082,
-0.0031555267,
-0.0056184116,
-0.079009518,
-0.000385641,
-0.0257788524,
-0.0246506147,
-0.0351686515,
-0.0581545159,
0.0070179622,
-0.0317468978,
-0.0503714345,
0.0463443734,
-0.0517296903,
-0.033857137,
-0.0063804905,
0.0920391604,
0.0008754564,
-0.0184602793,
-0.0316577107,
0.0138829965,
-0.0340082943,
-0.0132907871,
-0.0008462095,
-0.0223602727,
0.0306133572,
-0.0002196019,
0.0196586456,
0.003333118,
-0.0428079516,
0.0053052334,
-0.0240372829,
0.0060114725,
-0.0042963568,
0.087722078,
0.0106131239,
0.0458807684,
0.0137531376,
-0.0111137694,
0.0534029379,
-0.0003904792,
-0.0248591248,
0.106585376,
-0.013418328,
0.0167327914,
0.0047496534,
-0.0142581463,
-0.0134639032,
0.0306023788,
-0.0111810435,
-0.0498870239,
-0.0093159601,
0.0155193303,
2.623e-7,
0.036250256,
0.0017668396,
0.0417270251,
0.0237330776,
-0.0023560808,
0.0296820998,
0.0244754963,
0.0559687689,
-0.0217332523,
-0.0006376752,
0.0267208796,
0.0192398168,
-0.0134978555,
0.0750024989,
-0.0458842032,
-0.0197803564,
-0.0324612744,
-0.0593752861,
-0.0601219609,
0.0070268773,
0.0803629309,
0.0273336545,
0.0537485294,
0.0040572342,
-0.0481875092,
-0.0504067391,
-0.0270504821,
0.0285047777,
0.019047251,
0.0284435377,
0.0113163274,
0.0664938465,
-0.0358444266,
0.0935398862,
-0.0365762375,
0.012093788,
-0.0300957672,
0.0102509866,
0.0211336873,
-0.0005997317,
-0.0227081124,
-0.0474733226,
0.0071502272,
-0.0059831231,
0.0538977273,
-0.0293885246,
0.0109968027,
0.0571235865,
-0.0187790599,
0.0185095854,
0.0148730278,
-0.0266009346,
0.0020075173,
-0.0061723716,
-0.0068034688,
-0.0356185883,
0.0398896188,
-0.078962937,
0.0303551313,
0.0553263202,
-0.0085643809,
0.0010546347,
0.0417837724,
0.0074216328,
0.0302740317,
-0.009851641,
0.0375879668,
2.102761947e-34,
-0.021007197,
-0.0160320085,
-0.0452629551,
-0.0422905497,
0.031286519,
-0.0236082897,
-0.0434741937,
0.0177127738,
-0.0463675223,
-0.0305883437,
-0.0248687528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00366v1 | S2abEL: A Dataset for Entity Linking from Scientific Tables | 2023-04-30T02:07:22 | 2023-04-30T02:07:22 | Yuze Lou, Bailey Kuehl, Erin Bransom, Sergey Feldman, Aakanksha Naik, Doug Downey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Entity linking (EL) is the task of linking a textual mention to its
corresponding entry in a knowledge base, and is critical for many
knowledge-intensive NLP applications. When applied to tables in scientific
papers, EL is a step toward large-scale scientific knowledge bases that could
enable advanced scientific question answering and analytics. We present the
first dataset for EL in scientific tables. EL for scientific tables is
especially challenging because scientific knowledge bases can be very
incomplete, and disambiguating table mentions typically requires understanding
the papers's tet in addition to the table. Our dataset, S2abEL, focuses on EL
in machine learning results tables and includes hand-labeled cell types,
attributed sources, and entity links from the PaperswithCode taxonomy for 8,429
cells from 732 tables. We introduce a neural baseline method designed for EL on
scientific tables containing many out-of-knowledge-base mentions, and show that
it significantly outperforms a state-of-the-art generic table EL method. The
best baselines fall below human performance, and our analysis highlights
avenues for improvement. | [
0.0139731672,
0.0630537644,
0.0009872478,
-0.0355527475,
0.0002866988,
0.0333488323,
0.0076135197,
0.0032569449,
0.0070277643,
0.0089568328,
-0.0404190272,
0.0563347936,
-0.0077557694,
0.0308880955,
0.0502537265,
0.0292623043,
0.0431808941,
0.0417287573,
-0.0126177026,
0.0326961912,
-0.0128594544,
0.0118070338,
-0.0192011669,
0.0109106349,
-0.0085561285,
-0.0237145796,
0.0174488705,
-0.0210100189,
0.0350254774,
-0.0331234187,
0.0126456115,
0.0639383495,
0.0052513224,
0.0535430424,
0.0000015675,
-0.0211061835,
-0.0188167673,
0.0010360024,
-0.0470753573,
0.044749666,
0.0193056501,
-0.0434866659,
0.0216370784,
-0.0314201787,
-0.0180282593,
-0.0399841852,
0.0225360598,
0.0655603632,
0.0174271762,
0.0041184155,
0.0047305902,
-0.0267674047,
0.0338905603,
-0.0210344754,
0.0496548079,
-0.0286003463,
0.0498088002,
-0.0090257525,
0.0114693725,
0.0316757001,
0.0298182257,
0.0809776857,
0.0354686603,
-0.013061583,
0.0086545246,
0.052148737,
-0.0545083843,
0.0377120525,
0.0284592416,
0.1183636114,
0.0247429665,
-0.0458457172,
0.0334652737,
0.0246204901,
-0.0093014864,
0.007078052,
-0.0386112481,
-0.0256051999,
-0.0012015735,
-0.0304872077,
0.0039465292,
-0.0154055273,
0.0436239131,
0.0253157783,
0.0046802731,
0.0425454527,
-0.0045359931,
-0.041699145,
0.0271027554,
0.0047598323,
-0.0028430084,
-0.0054987771,
0.0188111067,
0.0129447607,
-0.0269444119,
0.0414349958,
-0.0013496821,
-0.0229939725,
0.0264456198,
-0.0311900824,
-0.0361396633,
-0.0058450978,
-0.0175225604,
0.0293295048,
-0.0681075156,
-0.0325515233,
-0.045186799,
0.0065624644,
0.0232863389,
-0.049160704,
-0.0395115092,
-0.0094715068,
-0.0363010801,
-0.007467845,
-0.0142322248,
-0.0001488719,
-0.0181418881,
-0.0357911028,
-0.0053182915,
0.0744343773,
0.0106752738,
0.0227257516,
-0.0303342883,
0.0258801673,
-0.0253217332,
0.0276701786,
-0.0498142578,
-0.0046952995,
-0.0316832811,
-0.0607756972,
-0.0357634537,
-0.0201512519,
-0.0108258333,
-0.0473224334,
0.0417515188,
0.0607173108,
0.0277020521,
-0.0093254494,
-0.0004408601,
-0.0569740161,
0.0173351429,
-0.0628704429,
0.0215208419,
-0.0243698582,
0.0706229955,
-0.0079675056,
-0.0102507016,
-0.1016916037,
-0.0079516303,
0.0433866046,
-0.0440031663,
0.0647610947,
-0.058471363,
-0.0414719321,
0.008357414,
0.0001056008,
-0.0300898217,
0.0403336622,
0.0294497199,
-0.0271615293,
-0.0080966866,
0.0036519207,
-0.0455101579,
0.0064548571,
0.1085255668,
-0.037833754,
0.0364884473,
0.029693516,
-0.006364149,
0.0902911872,
-0.0145143121,
0.0150277531,
-0.036890097,
-0.0170075707,
-0.0087082284,
0.0117832348,
-0.0078396285,
0.0643925965,
0.0148031441,
-0.0287387222,
0.0405106023,
-0.038206704,
-0.0407419354,
0.0543346629,
0.0281739682,
0.006956256,
0.0302949827,
0.0310731586,
-0.0201636758,
-0.0142485024,
0.0150994109,
0.0389663167,
-0.0447963029,
0.0076086377,
0.0569488406,
0.0245311465,
-0.0097449198,
0.0569923446,
0.0255599283,
-0.0143759623,
-0.0083710859,
0.0282922015,
0.0260551684,
0.0108508784,
0.0381348655,
-0.0451611206,
-0.0391320214,
-0.0305704884,
0.0250047371,
0.0420872234,
-0.0061231032,
-0.0669095367,
0.00889525,
-0.0026719964,
0.0093701649,
0.0198614858,
0.0161711741,
-0.0279958975,
0.0337093957,
0.0104841124,
0.0026027167,
-0.0604809821,
0.0042598206,
0.0460282415,
-0.0141923605,
0.0033615481,
-0.0172963142,
-0.0240010154,
0.0211731009,
0.0156738497,
0.0034490002,
0.0284451582,
0.0728851259,
-0.0115337064,
0.0286921896,
-0.0069196667,
0.0331143439,
-0.0058313613,
0.0450029932,
-0.0233693235,
-0.0549555272,
-0.0116210068,
-0.0532104,
-0.0340408571,
0.0284808557,
0.0031331703,
-0.0432032794,
0.0045967959,
-0.0376730263,
0.0252893586,
0.0339775793,
-0.0068478095,
0.0469957963,
-0.0149009777,
0.0534431562,
0.0413924567,
-0.0509826317,
0.018889064,
-0.0249893982,
-0.0061918581,
-0.0301186815,
-0.0001037889,
-0.0128311412,
0.0032060528,
0.0063513038,
-0.0797628239,
0.00852702,
-0.0528244525,
0.053633675,
0.0101537583,
0.0145720169,
0.0447562337,
-0.0207505338,
-0.000687795,
-0.0208248608,
-0.008875736,
-0.0103307925,
-0.0423580892,
-0.0171836317,
0.0641715452,
0.0123397745,
0.0094278855,
-0.0382086299,
-0.0404455103,
-0.0586695299,
0.0467057787,
-0.0063543334,
-0.0329998732,
-0.0309557952,
-0.0203653108,
-0.020981025,
0.0031908893,
-0.0155390929,
0.0196253043,
0.0022484881,
0.0064387047,
-0.0177424476,
0.0661049411,
-0.041090142,
0.0073383488,
0.0187475253,
-0.0026664776,
-0.0716505125,
0.0239394531,
0.002677016,
0.060373649,
0.0137653854,
-0.0163964853,
0.0220637415,
0.0401493274,
-0.0481911898,
-0.0028318095,
-0.0129142785,
0.030167954,
0.028912697,
0.0122408476,
-0.0349867344,
0.0704612955,
0.0173398908,
-0.0159540176,
-0.0019174501,
0.0099809496,
0.0233896244,
-0.0138714164,
0.0220600255,
-0.0357293114,
0.0355368741,
-0.0236355644,
0.0099789072,
0.0075322012,
-0.0088664973,
0.0066531049,
-0.0039264536,
-0.010917142,
0.0547360145,
-0.0337209776,
-0.0026119654,
0.0439362936,
-0.0432671718,
0.0455451757,
0.0131141767,
0.0063009206,
0.0082668141,
0.0027636946,
-0.0528882407,
0.0464677177,
0.0231204778,
-0.0363806039,
-0.0413217321,
-0.0439134613,
0.0560361855,
0.0366614275,
0.0014322485,
-0.0333515406,
-0.0228176303,
0.0359322987,
0.0713652298,
-0.0146967974,
0.021710746,
0.0377788693,
-0.001194152,
0.0693830699,
0.0122274971,
0.0036913494,
-0.016308384,
-0.0099033145,
-0.0149937868,
-0.0630587488,
0.0027626166,
0.0019541723,
-0.0421854369,
-0.0412886068,
-0.0283696707,
0.074370034,
0.032246843,
-0.0262108482,
-0.0209270846,
0.0090728831,
0.023938138,
0.0032991937,
0.0543559082,
-0.1128881052,
-0.0142072039,
-0.0365062542,
-0.0431621708,
0.0252033155,
-0.0726368055,
0.0022681293,
-0.0828080922,
0.0056319637,
-0.0372544862,
-0.0906294733,
-0.0853273571,
-0.0723195598,
0.006974963,
-0.0553581528,
0.0088502308,
0.0376189202,
0.0121656274,
0.0328663439,
0.0193097498,
0.0003882844,
-0.0716419071,
0.037109226,
-0.0904400945,
0.066437237,
0.0283830576,
0.0455477014,
-0.0013644357,
0.0094002476,
-0.0208189934,
-0.0351296254,
-0.0402944125,
-0.0120804096,
0.0892887861,
-0.020030478,
-0.0010907623,
-0.0075219115,
0.0408228375,
-0.0736689493,
0.0070084487,
0.0299935248,
0.0661602616,
0.015415105,
0.0208043009,
-0.0297482517,
-0.0110998238,
-0.0190781895,
0.0591704585,
0.0006878007,
0.0062377676,
-0.042627532,
-0.0079713585,
-0.0133985691,
-0.0332308188,
0.0039726305,
0.0446646884,
-0.0458524376,
0.0224552061,
-0.0663127452,
-0.0246714912,
0.0613617226,
0.0418899022,
-0.0008848795,
0.0459853709,
-0.0225280654,
-0.017022064,
-0.0439634733,
0.0296724997,
-0.0406894088,
0.010163703,
0.0131126354,
-0.029663505,
0.0722806379,
0.0031131105,
-0.0336724818,
0.0265471861,
-0.0262474269,
-0.0215253253,
-0.0206604134,
0.0068695997,
0.0184487421,
0.0266143959,
-0.0302485004,
-0.0210660286,
0.0063722013,
0.0103703588,
-0.0726579055,
-0.0185768902,
-0.0111952489,
-0.0141418781,
-0.0174105335,
0.0262068287,
-0.0196578577,
-0.0195351932,
-0.0064230701,
0.0363093987,
-0.0522866249,
0.0103337942,
0.0340722948,
0.0033643222,
0.0483235009,
0.0062552653,
-0.0207295511,
0.0035670293,
0.0318953805,
-0.0007953672,
0.000292603,
0.0037150697,
0.0079219714,
0.0012905207,
0.00082417,
-0.0248605106,
0.0103597166,
0.031223271,
0.0274116881,
-0.0181546398,
-0.0233060326,
0.0391091332,
0.0018340637,
0.0012483823,
-0.0241967421,
-0.0056590391,
-0.0301107597,
0.0050636167,
0.0584771,
-0.0300554577,
-0.0057623177,
0.0634339601,
-0.0096828938,
-0.0113734696,
0.0480710082,
-0.0645822585,
-0.0245241169,
-0.01968964,
-0.0112195062,
0.0408667736,
0.016661359,
0.0379644893,
-0.0297877695,
-0.0558401123,
0.0317010768,
0.024786232,
0.0053717741,
0.0374357514,
0.056246087,
0.0068203826,
-0.0084637851,
-0.0142138312,
0.0660244748,
0.0582833961,
0.0788228437,
0.0163769703,
-0.0201908126,
-0.045428019,
0.0140156448,
-0.056450814,
-0.0303733405,
-0.0071737305,
-0.0241506994,
-0.0351945013,
-0.0422647409,
0.0676059201,
0.0289058071,
-0.0449091792,
0.0145640029,
0.0461619981,
0.0154860616,
0.0396448374,
-0.0316782035,
0.0012944238,
0.0212985072,
-0.0065522688,
-0.0988923758,
-0.0629564598,
-5.374252908e-33,
-0.0533165,
0.0027661242,
0.0148880202,
-0.0412985757,
-0.0012789606,
0.0014180285,
-0.0523698367,
-0.0520926751,
-0.0543706976,
0.0250925049,
-0.0275013596,
0.0433156788,
-0.011868177,
-0.0129666608,
0.0248301942,
-0.0643080622,
0.0157293323,
-0.0254954919,
-0.0021272178,
0.0235489272,
0.0290021114,
0.0254688673,
0.0517936386,
-0.057497628,
0.0468332395,
0.0360406339,
0.0092197955,
-0.0002235327,
-0.0274894964,
0.0452540293,
-0.0533169657,
0.0125415213,
0.0077069546,
-0.060192626,
-0.002160206,
-0.0138621125,
-0.1855054796,
-0.0188973155,
-0.0169580113,
-0.0030046378,
-0.0078057265,
-0.0312378127,
0.0224889349,
0.0106033999,
0.0100066205,
-0.041158665,
0.0484685972,
-0.0147008477,
-0.0453639701,
-0.0658563375,
-0.0074033369,
0.0157111008,
-0.017662771,
0.0433793478,
0.0359367914,
0.0106893815,
-0.0084606512,
0.0150277503,
-0.0385727696,
-0.0042003375,
-0.010907134,
0.0184076764,
-0.0157334115,
-0.079940185,
0.0631081909,
0.030892754,
0.0325344615,
-0.0282450113,
-0.0386977084,
0.0129201654,
-0.0247094929,
0.0124377524,
0.0740848929,
0.0285820942,
0.0364841893,
0.0253840759,
-0.0880884454,
0.0376047678,
0.0110165738,
0.0329224393,
-0.0458804928,
-0.0249120817,
0.0215848126,
0.0015189262,
-0.0294950884,
-0.0165524315,
-0.0033174073,
-0.0330898613,
-0.015509625,
-0.0510787293,
-0.0016404192,
0.0187963322,
0.0095766932,
-0.0167843886,
-0.0238807965,
0.0785555542,
0.0376359671,
0.0189906918,
0.047930263,
-0.0191931222,
-0.0798466355,
-0.0072283167,
0.0188076869,
-0.0208347198,
0.0515089035,
0.0248501487,
0.0603969954,
-0.0209162012,
-0.021281695,
-0.0184032656,
-0.0045950064,
0.0057516131,
-0.0092919115,
0.0182121769,
-0.0005270082,
0.0336379521,
0.0176260285,
0.0129722003,
0.0584264882,
0.0205633957,
0.0066773654,
0.0607511923,
0.0121140666,
0.0050439588,
0.0153891109,
-0.0182567649,
-0.0350941643,
0.0099105285,
-0.0308639351,
-0.0736755878,
0.0236194357,
0.0021198341,
2.335e-7,
0.0729341954,
0.0267347656,
0.0575370379,
0.0369285941,
0.0043840241,
-0.035018988,
0.0224715713,
0.0155504057,
-0.0357793234,
-0.0576934256,
0.0260416809,
-0.0469516777,
0.0305483323,
0.0293405559,
-0.0578634217,
-0.0772349983,
-0.0728462264,
-0.0052424921,
-0.0315759517,
-0.0247189123,
-0.0165412612,
0.0608739294,
-0.0231049601,
0.005915923,
-0.0143552469,
-0.0076978025,
0.0322117023,
-0.0479481034,
0.0574704371,
0.024682723,
0.0321656466,
-0.0104001332,
-0.0149877202,
0.0853615329,
-0.0311375689,
0.0163817815,
-0.0008390525,
0.0218830518,
0.0217193905,
0.0134358481,
0.0001059743,
-0.0860723108,
0.0487010591,
-0.0227857381,
0.0634308457,
-0.0534270667,
0.000490628,
0.0789678544,
-0.0098974891,
0.0168710537,
0.0195586309,
-0.0092526395,
0.012406189,
0.0217054691,
-0.0079790689,
0.0001530605,
0.0154954288,
-0.0924670324,
-0.0233618133,
0.0604413711,
-0.0171335787,
-0.0038934776,
0.0159153901,
-0.0554027632,
0.0093393996,
-0.0391100235,
-0.0231460501,
1.91764799e-34,
0.0124148298,
-0.0062976032,
0.0131395869,
0.0501529276,
0.0457935147,
-0.0526107661,
-0.0008247905,
-0.0199120175,
0.0124942865,
-0.0837337375,
0.0082521997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00350v1 | POUF: Prompt-oriented unsupervised fine-tuning for large pre-trained models | 2023-04-29T22:05:22 | 2023-04-29T22:05:22 | Korawat Tanwisuth, Shujian Zhang, Huangjie Zheng, Pengcheng He, Mingyuan Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Through prompting, large-scale pre-trained models have become more expressive
and powerful, gaining significant attention in recent years. Though these big
models have zero-shot capabilities, in general, labeled data are still required
to adapt them to downstream tasks. To overcome this critical limitation, we
propose an unsupervised fine-tuning framework to directly fine-tune the model
or prompt on the unlabeled target data. We demonstrate how to apply our method
to both language-augmented vision and masked-language models by aligning the
discrete distributions extracted from the prompts and target data. To verify
our approach's applicability, we conduct extensive experiments on image
classification, sentiment analysis, and natural language inference tasks.
Across 13 image-related tasks and 15 language-related ones, the proposed
approach achieves consistent improvements over the baselines. | [
0.0338651054,
0.1001991406,
-0.0018268968,
0.0435804464,
0.0038954413,
0.0342177749,
0.0410884693,
-0.0209570117,
0.0117453448,
-0.0821818784,
-0.0643102303,
0.0073322114,
-0.0299604796,
0.0493610576,
0.0331404358,
-0.0617307015,
0.0217113178,
-0.032075204,
0.0213858858,
-0.0052935444,
0.0195744354,
0.013960598,
-0.0143107874,
0.0019451181,
0.0015006883,
-0.0134604834,
0.0094067436,
0.0179650392,
0.0271386188,
-0.0024558776,
0.0195820034,
0.0827074721,
0.0175397694,
0.0312422384,
0.0000019618,
-0.0499728397,
0.0103555443,
-0.0040134713,
-0.0340933576,
-0.0141441114,
0.0278629083,
-0.0405284576,
-0.0093651079,
-0.0312324725,
-0.0328812487,
-0.0265162494,
0.0941105261,
0.0378212668,
0.0592505708,
0.0737711564,
-0.0200553481,
-0.0080858842,
-0.0213500634,
-0.0330432765,
-0.0062461491,
-0.0548238121,
0.0231818836,
-0.0234712604,
-0.037222039,
0.0190693941,
-0.0439374559,
0.024232313,
0.0051419814,
0.0021537631,
0.023830073,
0.0127070537,
-0.0313910171,
-0.0232191086,
-0.024905581,
0.0813451707,
-0.0429699607,
-0.0249377564,
-0.0133350985,
-0.0451939665,
-0.0155722918,
-0.0254711043,
-0.0064888974,
-0.0040389071,
0.0260997284,
0.010473242,
-0.0280747954,
0.0064350911,
0.0273949634,
0.0308714341,
-0.0377246067,
0.0329158455,
0.003388515,
0.0096125361,
-0.0043271612,
0.0160673261,
-0.0443263873,
-0.0589226931,
-0.0494330935,
0.006059011,
-0.043773409,
-0.0234267227,
-0.0620980896,
-0.0437425077,
-0.0126986997,
0.0325547084,
0.07972873,
0.0147749837,
-0.0678488463,
0.0857150927,
-0.0062637459,
0.0034552827,
-0.0146198068,
0.0428556725,
-0.0275081042,
0.0053166016,
-0.018363582,
0.0170937479,
-0.0287367795,
-0.0153727205,
-0.0732998028,
-0.0095448224,
-0.0126522714,
0.0137155075,
-0.0261447523,
-0.0054687108,
-0.0236553773,
-0.0098397136,
-0.0492831618,
-0.0141232777,
-0.0029053218,
0.0231943,
-0.0417913459,
0.0292226281,
0.015800681,
-0.0654850602,
-0.0046091741,
0.018543331,
0.0321369059,
-0.0352700762,
0.0262429677,
0.0393030308,
-0.006519564,
-0.0406635664,
-0.0007060285,
-0.0092533818,
-0.0204407647,
-0.0523717962,
-0.0193350296,
-0.0498274975,
0.0354139209,
-0.0050499998,
0.0141844368,
-0.0172027759,
-0.0142921861,
-0.0230736546,
-0.0461684018,
0.1274647266,
-0.0188750084,
-0.0240803268,
-0.0160024967,
-0.0128430603,
0.0151557699,
0.0752931237,
-0.0292936899,
0.0452745035,
0.0410983078,
-0.0193439089,
0.0335518196,
0.0510163344,
0.0165098682,
0.0345825367,
-0.0117224026,
0.015522372,
0.0188447628,
-0.0134675903,
0.008621349,
0.0005153336,
-0.0020705219,
0.0007492796,
0.0466742739,
0.0046201413,
-0.0284979269,
0.0006736862,
0.0213387776,
-0.0155424327,
-0.0026031712,
0.0110844579,
-0.0705937222,
0.0231686756,
-0.054991588,
0.0016591036,
0.0193501804,
0.0381652862,
-0.052079495,
-0.0430127196,
0.0220140386,
0.0017827648,
-0.0110860169,
0.052480422,
0.047457628,
0.0442315005,
-0.0122937085,
-0.0129019888,
0.0339841805,
-0.0212264955,
-0.0049337712,
-0.0535443835,
0.0302330032,
0.043939963,
0.0175866615,
-0.0314587653,
0.0078328382,
-0.0149931824,
0.0622864254,
0.0252874848,
0.0328807086,
0.0107273925,
0.0421301611,
-0.0320925899,
-0.0444900617,
-0.0051259799,
0.0130754169,
0.0050601503,
0.006763936,
-0.000997227,
0.0221306067,
-0.0175573193,
-0.0159717295,
0.0231642053,
0.0215846151,
-0.0561635867,
0.010878901,
0.0457566567,
0.0123755084,
-0.0210004486,
-0.0318771191,
-0.0208684281,
-0.0078628175,
-0.0041012317,
0.0141810169,
-0.0520064309,
-0.0078559732,
-0.0337162465,
0.0156645793,
-0.0179927647,
-0.0432387702,
0.038951315,
-0.0950773731,
-0.0082124872,
-0.0196630061,
0.0278688166,
-0.0094212368,
-0.0479526073,
-0.0208221246,
-0.0145079792,
0.0368254408,
-0.0407269634,
0.0292148087,
0.0175759159,
0.0076392773,
0.0135329803,
0.0161128808,
0.0093612568,
-0.0240674447,
-0.0586746149,
-0.0166398734,
0.0081500262,
0.0272143446,
0.0417611599,
0.0223328546,
-0.037926048,
-0.0279923044,
-0.1018663496,
-0.0146352518,
-0.036400184,
-0.0133488318,
0.0158213936,
0.0266785417,
-0.029890161,
-0.0476076528,
-0.0161013305,
0.0061460119,
0.0069356519,
0.0338769481,
0.0203212555,
0.0005033269,
0.013722023,
-0.046317853,
-0.0072567249,
0.0132871307,
0.0233868286,
0.0243650507,
-0.0431753732,
-0.0265329294,
0.0255115163,
-0.0450384989,
0.0669087321,
-0.0117008453,
-0.0333881602,
-0.0054998528,
-0.0277569946,
0.0411164463,
0.0886592567,
0.0014967964,
0.0294669829,
0.0094246455,
0.0183285307,
-0.0170166679,
-0.0072376537,
-0.0435784757,
-0.0874131992,
-0.0178426355,
0.0104961731,
0.0032761518,
0.0518414453,
-0.0170777962,
-0.0273495819,
-0.0517172515,
0.0506235622,
-0.0041874256,
-0.0147370324,
-0.0694610626,
0.0475112014,
0.0164052993,
0.0584547147,
-0.0165046379,
-0.0751822591,
0.0648821369,
-0.0271510445,
0.0089418292,
-0.0047265068,
-0.0183050316,
-0.0041520149,
0.044510074,
0.0267028157,
0.0234557763,
0.0157967098,
0.0278709531,
-0.0806812495,
-0.0479882509,
0.0127966478,
0.0016003563,
0.0076350635,
-0.0067278096,
0.0107832188,
-0.0085886642,
-0.0517947674,
-0.0192127265,
-0.1031954885,
-0.0546395667,
0.0008529194,
-0.005456592,
-0.009391454,
-0.0252272543,
-0.0000891439,
-0.0103580942,
0.0322892554,
-0.0108457785,
-0.0124133443,
-0.0387680344,
0.0150380814,
0.090853855,
0.0142797129,
0.026667418,
-0.0353428684,
0.0081903031,
0.0282357391,
0.0159317162,
0.0101795932,
-0.0413497686,
0.0056155482,
0.0251408182,
0.035567563,
0.0335764103,
0.0294786151,
0.0484813899,
-0.016103521,
0.0133185256,
0.1013883948,
0.0084597431,
-0.0388287604,
-0.0309618395,
0.0305639468,
0.0344573744,
0.0458589233,
0.0150945466,
-0.0841352195,
-0.0615862012,
-0.0018000882,
0.0294145364,
-0.0008893019,
-0.0017630255,
-0.00326821,
-0.1166003495,
0.0561970063,
0.0141233029,
-0.008224708,
-0.0258902479,
0.0100852549,
0.0243321806,
-0.0179264173,
-0.0243997127,
-0.0400890931,
0.0221110024,
0.0079707336,
-0.0222730357,
0.0350633785,
-0.0750833899,
0.0310210194,
-0.0535942577,
0.0257278271,
0.0720254779,
-0.0183962919,
-0.0106510594,
-0.0369272977,
0.0433957763,
-0.0209385343,
0.0166988336,
-0.0192932095,
0.0643782169,
-0.037806198,
-0.0502711236,
-0.0092037739,
0.0520113409,
0.006556985,
-0.0140027702,
-0.0104986848,
0.0277388133,
-0.0152263762,
0.0043036337,
-0.0102669327,
-0.0077156471,
0.0438267589,
0.042421367,
0.021378031,
-0.0407294556,
0.0059658308,
-0.0218273569,
-0.0118884975,
-0.0037951618,
-0.021461891,
0.006454004,
-0.0217412356,
-0.0211739838,
-0.0481567718,
-0.0086961165,
0.0510242879,
0.0479937494,
0.004785141,
-0.0293951463,
-0.0014768939,
-0.0080711301,
-0.0450761952,
0.0940317959,
-0.0547630936,
0.0139267072,
-0.0746675804,
-0.0546578541,
0.0375597775,
-0.0392118134,
-0.0121523002,
0.0278118551,
-0.0789909735,
-0.0585304908,
-0.0023940159,
0.0866793171,
0.008881242,
0.0514600724,
-0.019282097,
-0.0829835534,
0.0590201505,
0.0812557116,
-0.0110873878,
0.021288963,
0.0119549492,
-0.0350920334,
-0.012492313,
0.0343288928,
-0.0354007557,
0.0615607947,
0.0660106167,
-0.0195522867,
-0.0029215512,
-0.0645285398,
0.004251699,
0.0182405002,
0.1471716017,
-0.0198196229,
-0.0186102372,
-0.0326158665,
-0.0029460904,
0.0324059762,
-0.0546099544,
-0.0408114009,
-0.0282559004,
0.0254749786,
0.0042659431,
-0.0137484698,
0.0433555134,
-0.0009851153,
0.0354598984,
-0.0577425659,
-0.0104124593,
0.0296163559,
0.0019778083,
0.0368094258,
0.0237481669,
0.0075991414,
0.0592147298,
0.0114780972,
0.0340155959,
0.0075349263,
0.0654627159,
0.060914956,
0.0214460157,
-0.0533095449,
0.0451188311,
-0.0384483933,
-0.0699523613,
-0.0414886698,
0.0192661826,
0.0243996289,
-0.0402254015,
-0.0189136472,
0.001856782,
-0.041764956,
-0.0295032617,
0.0253870077,
0.01849325,
-0.0040113581,
0.04096625,
0.0139008472,
-0.0221649949,
0.0220225342,
0.0435080379,
-0.0092753116,
0.0161963124,
0.0203203801,
0.0172728524,
-0.0362559296,
0.0110016093,
0.0080791498,
0.0002196744,
0.0222013537,
0.0525005795,
-0.0022641695,
-0.0650725216,
-0.0183413401,
0.0075950185,
-0.042462267,
0.0273521934,
0.0575107113,
0.0384182297,
-0.0096290028,
0.0077968957,
-0.0339724608,
0.0109325154,
0.0176611543,
-0.0126455966,
0.0408693813,
-6.782476039e-33,
-0.0308044497,
-0.0206253752,
-0.010871755,
0.0066521722,
0.0244109556,
-0.0109381573,
-0.01592049,
-0.0009730483,
-0.0140295569,
0.032761164,
-0.0023035547,
-0.0056278659,
0.0179054495,
0.0426358283,
-0.0227857213,
-0.0136835231,
0.0637943745,
0.0040405914,
-0.0338568464,
0.0013760767,
0.0105024362,
0.0235736612,
0.0270205364,
-0.0571671166,
-0.0061195143,
-0.01637768,
-0.0365540199,
0.0293158144,
-0.00422954,
0.0543975756,
-0.0109344199,
0.0236758348,
-0.001923323,
-0.0085860984,
-0.0297348797,
0.0521377362,
-0.0686421245,
-0.0066262763,
-0.0076372088,
0.011732853,
-0.0457476676,
0.0103899864,
-0.0152136525,
-0.026481159,
-0.0051006321,
-0.0062352256,
0.0424065217,
-0.0443596281,
0.026181709,
-0.0113192312,
-0.0491323806,
0.0078920238,
-0.0094525721,
-0.0524048842,
0.0463963002,
0.019800216,
0.0299984217,
0.0424121246,
-0.0393814668,
0.00460152,
0.056304913,
0.0300217532,
0.0771031156,
0.0641672984,
0.0007693362,
0.0426183864,
0.0192234609,
-0.0065662134,
-0.0042687375,
0.0201647356,
0.0250451323,
0.0389477089,
0.0192400794,
0.0775347725,
0.0221508592,
-0.0082349144,
-0.0576266274,
0.0013663429,
-0.0605633892,
-0.0309529435,
0.0085217915,
-0.0058656656,
-0.0049780561,
-0.0108704325,
-0.0575315766,
-0.0180024672,
-0.0554776527,
0.0298040602,
0.0377560891,
0.0206841677,
-0.0380131975,
0.0256569497,
0.0562308095,
-0.0499795936,
0.002577622,
-0.0108075514,
0.0022654291,
0.0162093211,
0.0082092825,
0.0196828973,
-0.0453869179,
-0.0520967357,
0.050437741,
0.0115102557,
0.0087613855,
0.0173533838,
0.0711608231,
0.0305326972,
-0.0829117,
0.0271405429,
-0.0145984199,
0.0419296287,
-0.0004311864,
0.0422918648,
-0.0080945138,
0.0131582282,
-0.0246519186,
0.0772766173,
0.0134116141,
-0.0280026235,
-0.0006909267,
0.0268643126,
-0.0072498759,
0.0148105053,
-0.0042417143,
-0.0082423016,
-0.0052533299,
-0.0082167042,
0.0332863815,
-0.0392934941,
0.0029904498,
0.0175725054,
2.687e-7,
0.0194320139,
0.0243895631,
-0.0132974191,
-0.002517917,
0.0132107921,
0.0808551013,
-0.012990565,
0.0102119558,
0.0238900334,
-0.04084941,
0.0143438466,
0.0427929983,
0.0327165462,
-0.0290325396,
-0.0437488891,
0.0556354262,
-0.0314211547,
0.0346934013,
-0.0510304086,
-0.0061432524,
0.0426638797,
0.1384025067,
0.0027188729,
0.002622888,
0.0498036221,
-0.052350536,
0.0544663258,
-0.0413687043,
-0.0059240302,
0.0136223761,
-0.014022924,
0.0296413042,
-0.0155441137,
0.0301218368,
-0.0108909439,
0.0101596015,
0.0114375083,
0.0641110018,
-0.0090095308,
0.0078901714,
-0.0193235204,
0.0301640909,
0.0057205237,
-0.0449797027,
0.084975414,
-0.0880662352,
-0.0142674204,
-0.0717720091,
-0.019805301,
-0.0165470336,
0.051385235,
-0.0441845544,
-0.0137022054,
0.0327836871,
0.0445565619,
0.0079625119,
-0.0520171672,
-0.0859678388,
-0.0120887971,
-0.0054646754,
-0.0205927398,
-0.0435593389,
-0.0233903956,
-0.0314507782,
0.0320960768,
-0.0560039841,
0.0033399893,
2.175999608e-34,
0.0499616675,
-0.0063947407,
0.0053185499,
-0.0545399226,
0.0242797006,
0.0004741281,
-0.04011067,
-0.0128057962,
0.0272544455,
-0.0790219903,
-0.0048610196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00296v1 | A Cognitive Account of the Puzzle of Ideography | 2023-04-29T16:13:13 | 2023-04-29T16:13:13 | Xerxes D. Arsiwalla | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.CL | In this commentary article to 'The Puzzle of Ideography' by Morin, we put
forth a new cognitive account of the puzzle of ideography, that complements the
standardization account of Morin. Efficient standardization of spoken language
is phenomenologically attributed to a modality effect coupled with chunking of
cognitive representations, further aided by multi-sensory integration and the
serialized nature of attention. These cognitive mechanisms are crucial for
explaining why languages dominate graphic codes for general-purpose human
communication. | [
-0.0012122351,
0.0350648724,
-0.0715010092,
-0.013808921,
-0.0207170155,
0.007573186,
0.0053534908,
0.0563119799,
-0.0294661187,
-0.0226399302,
-0.0366077609,
-0.0423353352,
0.0730380565,
-0.0127275437,
0.0450709127,
-0.070462428,
-0.0124918371,
0.0032959937,
0.0155516015,
-0.0079952572,
0.0079772864,
0.0108908191,
0.0246322285,
0.0170339178,
-0.0191827454,
-0.0091252355,
0.0042550126,
0.0010478335,
-0.024020778,
0.0047986857,
-0.0510170311,
0.0390621014,
0.0114698466,
0.0104385875,
0.0000016924,
-0.0274964049,
0.0950271785,
-0.0585468486,
-0.0052079153,
0.0296972506,
0.0100639416,
-0.0260839518,
-0.0058680959,
-0.0529189706,
0.0066415169,
0.0259276535,
0.0619880371,
0.0132780075,
-0.0408705361,
-0.0158048701,
-0.0089531969,
-0.0560322925,
0.0259810388,
-0.0089352774,
-0.0167194344,
0.0580630787,
0.0041312268,
0.0240610167,
0.018149443,
0.0192698389,
-0.0566530526,
0.0359302126,
0.0184705313,
0.0119394315,
-0.0525008924,
0.0201339461,
0.03722791,
-0.0188642778,
-0.0206319205,
0.0494468324,
0.0507834218,
-0.0440061986,
-0.0029337143,
0.0241485443,
-0.0027995487,
-0.0380588397,
-0.0333868936,
0.0446029864,
-0.004466421,
0.0287527721,
0.0071004583,
-0.0048579657,
-0.0228219349,
-0.0160743799,
-0.0306452289,
0.0018057099,
0.0026236472,
-0.0009004186,
0.0042412025,
-0.0306703895,
-0.0211698897,
-0.0527162477,
-0.0015289653,
0.0223714169,
-0.0101130102,
-0.0125203608,
0.0109940143,
-0.0428271778,
-0.0082174353,
-0.0461984724,
0.030555062,
0.0294226855,
-0.0186073948,
-0.002583137,
0.0476959161,
0.086729683,
-0.0237208381,
0.0173415877,
-0.0301139876,
0.0523290075,
-0.0478791036,
-0.0527606867,
-0.0255320836,
0.0116933621,
0.0130911367,
-0.0174887236,
-0.0056281677,
0.0249605514,
-0.002755298,
-0.0222087055,
-0.082635574,
-0.0085962787,
-0.0585661083,
0.0071691023,
0.007469621,
0.0577340797,
-0.0425193869,
0.0035990705,
-0.0245846566,
-0.0346300602,
0.046119161,
0.0494048148,
-0.0164117292,
0.0000492941,
-0.0462703891,
0.0210830308,
-0.0200680625,
0.0289135631,
0.0185465422,
-0.0225667488,
-0.0263658222,
-0.0204462949,
-0.0026275706,
-0.0225829352,
-0.034371756,
0.0575712807,
-0.0003031887,
-0.0517483242,
-0.0444166996,
-0.0187403709,
-0.0198922083,
0.0195846092,
0.0074242922,
0.0373658277,
0.0383410081,
0.0232488029,
0.0500157438,
0.0558494367,
0.0263346229,
-0.0340428315,
-0.0036853782,
-0.0640025064,
0.0213916469,
0.0439495891,
-0.044739414,
0.0116142705,
-0.0556172989,
-0.0551856644,
0.0126598198,
0.0035280949,
0.086155884,
0.0468738265,
-0.0150366845,
-0.031063294,
0.0420158394,
0.0744825453,
0.0214046352,
-0.0114022633,
0.00451503,
0.0184207279,
0.0033378685,
0.0922883675,
0.0216013659,
0.0014985399,
0.0333208144,
0.0047679292,
-0.0182918496,
0.0080347694,
-0.0420739874,
0.0040358598,
-0.0069668,
0.0354751348,
0.0291584339,
-0.0284771621,
-0.0178873148,
0.012659044,
0.014919145,
0.030260507,
0.0059418334,
0.0060490612,
-0.0176168643,
-0.0302991811,
-0.0075239781,
0.0174608491,
-0.0315292738,
0.0399417169,
0.0432430916,
-0.0191937089,
0.0521572642,
0.0876613781,
0.0074959048,
-0.0024685059,
0.0126644736,
-0.0250512231,
0.0317746475,
-0.016375443,
-0.0098023014,
0.0183843914,
-0.0929170847,
0.0535152555,
-0.0485610031,
0.0051656254,
-0.0134837255,
-0.008449249,
0.0078176623,
-0.0514808595,
-0.0822541118,
0.0135227721,
-0.003409931,
-0.0130601721,
-0.028177144,
0.0361740179,
-0.0110047841,
-0.0026106576,
0.0680612773,
0.0829085484,
-0.0414379798,
0.0573983975,
0.0398023799,
-0.0702079237,
-0.0214038901,
-0.0157606117,
0.0646210536,
-0.0209210385,
0.0789064616,
-0.0764392838,
0.0640853643,
0.0365527719,
0.0147152748,
-0.0127045847,
0.0043101576,
-0.0001626297,
0.021096494,
-0.0019393711,
0.0082568293,
0.0148730874,
-0.0313149579,
0.0597897582,
-0.0380356312,
0.015459314,
0.0854193121,
-0.0166107807,
0.0238239728,
-0.0022358282,
-0.0250574704,
-0.0342098325,
-0.0045244587,
-0.0820494816,
-0.0648530051,
0.0032500664,
-0.0120835491,
0.045984637,
-0.0112695172,
-0.0040940591,
-0.0007098429,
-0.021252349,
-0.02433501,
0.0054105716,
0.0345245749,
0.0196410771,
0.0125164269,
-0.0500430912,
-0.0082787694,
-0.0188702401,
0.0056665954,
0.0361550041,
-0.0044168863,
-0.0210239775,
-0.0794619918,
-0.0413911864,
-0.0100170458,
-0.0293513294,
-0.0280974694,
-0.0445124544,
0.0808703676,
0.0387872197,
0.0863711834,
0.024857495,
0.0152034545,
0.0324283056,
0.0117658945,
-0.0497079603,
-0.03065053,
-0.0459781885,
0.0044518691,
0.0381577797,
0.0151448995,
-0.0940388814,
0.0109815411,
0.0714992732,
0.0077074519,
0.0348385498,
-0.0293651987,
0.0231368337,
0.001334908,
-0.0508597717,
-0.0170488078,
-0.053295657,
-0.0214409605,
0.0585955866,
-0.0362247378,
-0.0387748219,
0.0315556377,
0.0089104464,
-0.0402413048,
-0.0036592726,
0.0047296821,
0.0069610202,
0.0575590245,
-0.0303242505,
0.0354790576,
0.0762987435,
-0.0805811659,
-0.0833105221,
-0.0353815556,
-0.0007098767,
0.001569559,
0.0465069897,
-0.0313126631,
-0.0157016758,
-0.005818218,
-0.0194388069,
0.0078963106,
0.0269658249,
-0.0229987688,
0.0069500343,
0.0484313108,
0.023919085,
-0.0092104282,
0.036497701,
0.0553630628,
-0.0385202281,
0.014052229,
0.0092009949,
0.0098982025,
-0.0073862798,
-0.0168747175,
0.0767640322,
-0.0160544161,
-0.0146924136,
0.0060733054,
0.0103838695,
-0.0267510414,
0.060700316,
-0.0267286878,
0.0455883704,
0.0419429168,
-0.0069585792,
-0.0937103331,
0.0052514835,
0.0826377273,
-0.0095999669,
0.040075995,
0.0109842122,
-0.018179141,
-0.0290463418,
0.025444055,
-0.0247153174,
0.0073238015,
0.0178888161,
0.0088080531,
-0.0184470154,
0.0460440628,
0.0094330506,
-0.0300092902,
-0.0030514253,
-0.0189555939,
0.0145530254,
-0.0198774897,
0.0189524237,
0.0348225012,
-0.0866989791,
-0.0450377874,
0.0549808778,
-0.0079990616,
0.0956314057,
0.0037308943,
0.0147860721,
-0.0345579088,
-0.0146698244,
0.0349848457,
-0.0159900691,
0.0263348129,
-0.0669628009,
0.0078085498,
0.0024984891,
-0.0157879703,
0.0479141101,
-0.0230578575,
-0.0874760523,
0.0151377032,
0.0005889941,
0.0139817903,
-0.0183574818,
0.021503374,
0.057407964,
-0.0150500452,
-0.0532679632,
-0.0156964324,
0.0224948786,
-0.0327548496,
-0.0372585543,
-0.0027645798,
-0.0247475822,
-0.0487910435,
-0.0184944533,
0.0189753398,
-0.0201359484,
-0.0107427062,
0.0654717833,
-0.0401775464,
0.0085878754,
-0.0441235751,
0.0780226737,
0.0389699191,
-0.0829676837,
0.0178009607,
-0.00367297,
-0.0584263764,
-0.0713673159,
-0.0308218636,
-0.0286284853,
0.0523715056,
0.0629419684,
-0.0516769327,
-0.044892855,
-0.0332337394,
-0.0365205258,
0.0177954435,
-0.0130425086,
0.0099975346,
-0.0867573544,
-0.0273722168,
-0.0349556319,
-0.0393130854,
0.0356707275,
-0.0085192667,
0.0286513064,
-0.0563983209,
0.0036269799,
-0.0404083841,
0.0348115303,
0.014190984,
0.030354986,
-0.0721130073,
-0.0100890538,
-0.0142448563,
0.0520082638,
0.0662512556,
-0.0094597805,
-0.010317591,
0.0006729352,
0.0099561252,
0.0153618651,
0.0154373301,
0.0193030983,
-0.0275365282,
-0.0352337547,
-0.0470963567,
0.008121945,
0.0014842519,
-0.0136933308,
-0.0327632166,
0.0377233624,
0.0127886022,
-0.0646857843,
0.0256214552,
0.0057935226,
0.0000441245,
-0.041095376,
0.0069152801,
0.0103768967,
-0.0132620605,
0.0239702091,
-0.0043718447,
-0.007662171,
0.02011884,
0.0317411758,
-0.0127533805,
0.0024644022,
-0.0034226591,
0.049451407,
0.0089075826,
0.0605403222,
-0.0269853789,
0.0802994817,
0.0236902758,
0.0345316492,
0.0442938358,
-0.0166607872,
-0.0012919679,
-0.0110539123,
0.0099120559,
-0.0810593516,
0.0466807634,
-0.016525317,
0.0414051302,
-0.050309971,
0.0116944984,
0.021585336,
0.0316856243,
-0.0164543781,
-0.0086849537,
0.0038697703,
0.0018266561,
0.0102668265,
0.0274670571,
-0.0144672533,
0.0075076371,
0.0304950364,
-0.0525881723,
-0.0207638107,
-0.0246304851,
-0.0439134538,
-0.0162168685,
0.0046914588,
0.0734578073,
0.0221170709,
0.008034911,
-0.0381248258,
-0.0640230551,
-0.0751726851,
0.0384215266,
-0.0144547075,
0.0433609933,
-0.015968632,
0.0376211144,
0.0183591209,
0.0257493183,
-0.0245285872,
0.0049877916,
0.0439203307,
-0.0134720281,
0.0085358042,
0.0068443976,
-5.666723617e-33,
0.0012839719,
-0.0078435382,
-0.0012404143,
0.0156198731,
-0.023048725,
-0.0114227803,
-0.023844922,
0.0350042768,
0.000589412,
0.0028884993,
-0.0188623853,
-0.0340878889,
0.0014358483,
-0.0223263893,
0.0476601906,
0.0379223898,
0.0242963284,
0.0001512019,
-0.0483131148,
-0.0406481624,
0.0334667005,
-0.0524417125,
0.0613714978,
-0.043777518,
0.007597765,
0.0201256573,
0.0103882784,
-0.0462013297,
0.051709637,
0.0339250118,
-0.0087198662,
0.0368018001,
0.0452043228,
0.0280584116,
-0.0131843304,
0.0872983634,
0.0292965714,
-0.047633063,
0.0362945236,
0.0516494066,
0.0047769602,
-0.0480239764,
0.0597052239,
-0.0672523603,
-0.0214591715,
0.0496489555,
0.0489392579,
0.0021879366,
-0.0262617189,
0.0606319532,
-0.078538835,
-0.0336121805,
-0.0101820892,
0.0056846049,
0.0256999787,
-0.0201561172,
-0.0112771699,
-0.0146232825,
-0.0557948053,
0.0455010049,
-0.0216025393,
0.0294928607,
0.0212010536,
0.0538879335,
0.0162862167,
-0.0008287079,
0.0787195042,
0.041311942,
0.0124359177,
0.0266376659,
0.0503422022,
0.0208775755,
-0.0094083427,
-0.0123059507,
-0.0041653207,
-0.0530790649,
0.033607997,
-0.0256177764,
0.0048579709,
0.0004442012,
-0.0137216654,
0.0582392588,
-0.0513827689,
-0.0526348576,
0.0050618839,
-0.0002264326,
-0.0124265123,
-0.03259461,
-0.0003853738,
-0.0534351468,
0.0551872551,
0.0230595749,
0.0614491925,
-0.0456231609,
-0.072232306,
-0.1032966375,
-0.0445919819,
0.0868255571,
0.0321940891,
-0.0414110161,
-0.0282634739,
0.0075730965,
-0.0007506004,
0.0514927991,
0.0172395594,
0.041460976,
-0.0015726752,
-0.0165958609,
-0.0138537455,
-0.0300464574,
0.0124008451,
-0.0415817648,
0.0241601728,
-0.054912135,
0.0483767949,
0.0096724462,
-0.0140523529,
-0.0822314247,
0.018237235,
-0.0431837961,
-0.0228077881,
-0.0077506658,
-0.063077718,
0.0230592638,
-0.0628833175,
-0.0154233994,
-0.081586659,
0.0593717396,
0.066531539,
-0.0136936074,
-0.0412350185,
-0.0100643421,
2.646e-7,
-0.0031728048,
0.0272704065,
0.0217280369,
-0.0255024265,
0.0750427544,
-0.0095481416,
-0.0087724868,
0.0210281573,
-0.0013303626,
-0.0662484616,
-0.0132249305,
0.0113143194,
0.0078126434,
-0.003788932,
-0.0310152713,
0.0068028653,
0.0113104079,
0.0564845167,
-0.0348586254,
0.0552065633,
0.0346167199,
0.0034651223,
-0.0261481032,
-0.0085840505,
-0.0050159064,
-0.000068679,
0.0277714226,
-0.0294623375,
0.0748379081,
-0.0049323146,
0.0174737014,
0.0192852151,
0.0018453428,
0.0226975959,
0.0302008688,
-0.025798142,
0.0202430263,
-0.0034679228,
-0.0150503209,
0.0675687566,
0.0070565175,
-0.0204357132,
-0.0219843257,
-0.0069161686,
0.0324710645,
-0.0228656456,
-0.0518598557,
-0.0089404415,
-0.0008935123,
0.008155603,
0.0141455038,
0.0114095472,
-0.0560028329,
0.0387385003,
0.0110001052,
-0.0462998189,
-0.0050403867,
-0.0166757032,
0.0096517485,
0.0181101933,
-0.0202231556,
-0.030470822,
-0.0306704454,
-0.0023416108,
0.0495233536,
-0.0126899276,
-0.0113328733,
1.738747277e-34,
-0.0217179153,
-0.0032608288,
0.0634619817,
-0.011654349,
-0.0203645248,
-0.0209822059,
-0.0155649474,
0.0518360659,
0.0418294817,
-0.0077313916,
0.0003873426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00262v1 | Hierarchical Dialogue Understanding with Special Tokens and Turn-level Attention | 2023-04-29T13:53:48 | 2023-04-29T13:53:48 | Xiao Liu, Jian Zhang, Heng Zhang, Fuzhao Xue, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Compared with standard text, understanding dialogue is more challenging for
machines as the dynamic and unexpected semantic changes in each turn. To model
such inconsistent semantics, we propose a simple but effective Hierarchical
Dialogue Understanding model, HiDialog. Specifically, we first insert multiple
special tokens into a dialogue and propose the turn-level attention to learn
turn embeddings hierarchically. Then, a heterogeneous graph module is leveraged
to polish the learned embeddings. We evaluate our model on various dialogue
understanding tasks including dialogue relation extraction, dialogue emotion
recognition, and dialogue act classification. Results show that our simple
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on all three tasks above. All
our source code is publicly available at https://github.com/ShawX825/HiDialog. | [
0.0309632719,
0.0331904478,
0.006447529,
0.0744186938,
-0.0035059222,
0.0101320697,
-0.0195090324,
-0.0184806492,
0.0756001025,
-0.0553607196,
-0.040485017,
-0.0295704622,
-0.0346377566,
0.075087674,
0.0050194301,
-0.0659689084,
0.0692452788,
0.0242095869,
0.0698865131,
0.0032806902,
0.0005244315,
0.0234485101,
-0.0201721378,
0.0561455749,
-0.0346812755,
-0.044979807,
-0.0552806593,
0.0475784317,
0.0277790036,
-0.0155034307,
0.0238603558,
0.0302271247,
0.054326959,
0.0680666789,
0.0000016181,
0.003176115,
0.0131568462,
-0.0325522721,
-0.0652996078,
-0.007594082,
0.011527719,
-0.0111788511,
0.0066562123,
-0.0071775303,
-0.0127788512,
-0.04647981,
0.0191745088,
0.0717549473,
0.0676443875,
0.0867360905,
-0.0062912954,
-0.0184339583,
0.0053407433,
-0.0264562164,
0.0194966849,
-0.046298746,
-0.0068424311,
0.0090472251,
-0.0071375291,
0.0048372205,
-0.0571181886,
0.0116774952,
0.0094255758,
-0.0457702912,
0.0169079714,
0.0431996956,
-0.0231934655,
0.0142321419,
-0.016535759,
0.1420821846,
-0.0378953591,
0.0175886918,
-0.0088512357,
-0.0132572809,
0.0190529451,
-0.0566712581,
-0.0501156263,
-0.0060656839,
0.0111080892,
0.0005883413,
-0.0070213689,
-0.007999992,
0.010558526,
-0.0179170649,
-0.0189945977,
0.0433820039,
-0.0178264715,
-0.0238030422,
-0.0167597998,
-0.0182047058,
-0.0055507682,
-0.0264286976,
0.0122783631,
0.02481227,
-0.0450162254,
0.0197924562,
-0.0458085202,
0.0525687151,
-0.0105344336,
-0.0242466237,
-0.0286958572,
0.0182428695,
-0.0002214579,
0.0877189264,
0.0232965518,
0.0397519283,
-0.0214287285,
0.0306139179,
-0.0317755081,
-0.0134692369,
-0.0317250751,
0.022301605,
-0.05259322,
0.0193288568,
-0.0535364114,
-0.0727779791,
-0.0033539585,
0.0446119867,
-0.0029458834,
0.0380618647,
0.0263163131,
0.0439469516,
-0.0256020296,
-0.0172054507,
0.0343399495,
0.0536697209,
-0.0127515271,
-0.0043669511,
0.0045153648,
-0.0193224158,
-0.0457276665,
0.0442817658,
0.0183220133,
-0.0018987325,
-0.0177718643,
0.0749714077,
0.0077746408,
-0.0331511684,
0.0381794609,
0.0178954508,
-0.0266735256,
-0.0277216136,
0.0033790374,
0.0053781597,
0.0779975504,
-0.0306774192,
-0.0244368892,
0.0275508873,
0.0347198099,
-0.0183563605,
-0.0670845136,
0.0312131699,
0.0322257839,
-0.0294846259,
-0.0135638705,
0.0124993213,
-0.0514910929,
0.0566383377,
0.0508928746,
0.0455261655,
0.0473101139,
0.0061374754,
0.0029601357,
0.0265751649,
-0.0044960342,
-0.017813297,
0.0343158133,
0.0425713994,
-0.0442009903,
0.0488985777,
0.0293702073,
0.0421118364,
-0.0314032547,
-0.0740157738,
0.029758893,
0.0448066182,
-0.0253432784,
-0.0191475637,
0.0309389401,
0.0676999688,
-0.0223597437,
0.0027788929,
-0.0741504431,
0.0225329623,
0.0437533893,
-0.0099530574,
0.0115534123,
-0.0204066727,
-0.0176547281,
-0.0119906161,
-0.0097007621,
-0.0036282537,
0.0056770267,
0.002915896,
0.0243409127,
-0.0121453023,
-0.0668087751,
0.0432408229,
0.0120163299,
-0.033621192,
-0.0082484242,
-0.0046032155,
0.0197452437,
0.067037873,
0.0249885134,
-0.0326248668,
-0.025331594,
-0.0661489889,
-0.012720692,
0.0225676019,
0.0151326451,
-0.0250946246,
0.0765022859,
-0.0698057935,
-0.0032489256,
-0.0253900886,
0.0032155025,
0.0288843717,
-0.0449586771,
-0.0410546809,
-0.0154791074,
-0.0136417141,
0.0389731415,
-0.0021743006,
0.0277761687,
-0.0112663116,
0.001330437,
0.0280298572,
0.0424215198,
0.0180358086,
0.0046871388,
-0.0242991019,
0.042717956,
-0.0060905088,
-0.0173931364,
0.0084061353,
-0.0422957987,
-0.1143777147,
0.0198322758,
-0.0320497975,
-0.0520140305,
-0.016532341,
-0.0791240782,
-0.0392006114,
0.036193803,
-0.0631685331,
0.0516461059,
-0.0154490694,
-0.0165930707,
0.0399512649,
0.0333063789,
-0.0117580369,
0.0566341765,
-0.0394361578,
-0.0006921649,
-0.0074108555,
0.0207403414,
0.0035986661,
-0.0480148979,
-0.0239950251,
0.0395203792,
-0.0009356159,
-0.014828315,
-0.0094430316,
0.0029753845,
-0.0454618558,
-0.0208659116,
-0.0825499818,
0.0163120497,
-0.014721917,
-0.0012698306,
0.0119260252,
-0.000650009,
0.0045251804,
-0.037635617,
-0.0261578355,
0.0143302372,
0.0263194144,
-0.0056162286,
0.0277636014,
-0.0082638804,
-0.0198348034,
-0.0309460834,
-0.006445358,
-0.0190038141,
0.077138558,
-0.0265907906,
0.0207033772,
-0.002522835,
-0.0586178303,
-0.0012300262,
0.0390997827,
-0.0306434426,
-0.0482601076,
0.0016153852,
0.0195395164,
0.0151802851,
0.0859506354,
0.0124599179,
0.0844490901,
-0.0113244103,
-0.0238219146,
-0.0417973474,
0.0581190698,
-0.0025198809,
0.0482769608,
-0.0373691022,
-0.0085441992,
-0.0161889512,
0.0701664388,
0.0256168991,
0.0291506331,
-0.0450024046,
-0.031632375,
0.0250076987,
0.0019005416,
0.002390214,
-0.0214651171,
-0.035172347,
-0.0171268657,
-0.0614193007,
-0.0294980798,
0.0612558983,
-0.0053778267,
-0.0606582537,
-0.0264483783,
-0.0289143585,
-0.0398241915,
0.0595083348,
0.0060764584,
0.0236793142,
-0.0127247553,
-0.0639861822,
-0.0183606651,
-0.0091191726,
-0.0128105152,
-0.0300611909,
0.0692579523,
0.0344344899,
-0.0365587808,
-0.009885285,
-0.0115282778,
-0.0443308689,
-0.0420699753,
-0.0158661734,
0.0037721163,
0.0128442394,
-0.0381234996,
-0.0227071233,
-0.0080432063,
-0.0045715752,
0.0127600515,
-0.0191782415,
0.0207354072,
-0.0280496422,
0.0429865234,
0.0314390063,
0.0233576801,
-0.004824494,
0.0065425579,
0.0636540055,
0.046367541,
0.010633152,
-0.0415862463,
-0.0301392227,
-0.00895976,
0.0018300809,
0.0026203336,
-0.0009040703,
-0.0460591502,
0.0433643386,
-0.072479777,
0.0188239552,
0.0937301219,
0.008282356,
-0.0446457714,
0.0046593691,
-0.0002431431,
0.0118548525,
0.0181598533,
0.0063575297,
-0.0947263911,
-0.0326947086,
-0.0038453264,
0.0037497862,
0.0473050028,
-0.0485761054,
0.018594997,
-0.0495172925,
0.0246067811,
0.0027971135,
-0.0339123011,
-0.047542952,
0.0036310975,
0.0263925791,
-0.0045528533,
0.0383285992,
-0.0045429659,
0.0071417475,
-0.0315517895,
0.0045624119,
-0.0056165955,
-0.009658643,
0.0497713201,
-0.0108057074,
0.0450107381,
-0.0213952921,
0.065698944,
0.0322441757,
0.0059587741,
0.0048147943,
0.0073005417,
-0.0260796379,
-0.0027239763,
0.0420322418,
-0.0601043478,
-0.0213868581,
-0.0134090092,
0.0230922904,
-0.0215954836,
-0.0250558853,
-0.0247916728,
0.0825784057,
-0.0314282812,
-0.0339034274,
-0.0320469253,
0.023264505,
0.0215898082,
0.0612272471,
0.0368362963,
-0.000787665,
-0.0467392243,
-0.0443360135,
0.0156719405,
-0.0344278552,
0.0220469665,
0.0020203881,
0.0055698999,
-0.0019899076,
-0.0254526641,
-0.0833955556,
0.0129716657,
-0.0059510702,
-0.0394239277,
-0.0386622325,
0.0151751032,
-0.0130453669,
-0.0104627926,
0.0329502597,
-0.0224138703,
0.0091253594,
-0.0172535684,
-0.0049274694,
0.0339393839,
0.0105465855,
-0.0276343506,
0.0084450105,
-0.0359489173,
-0.0413309038,
-0.0115688266,
0.0202178024,
0.0092543634,
0.0695410073,
-0.0358636118,
0.0187823866,
-0.0146028707,
-0.0274983384,
-0.02694818,
-0.0215531699,
0.0670962259,
0.0613325834,
-0.0243971776,
0.0442309119,
-0.0421502814,
0.0057968092,
-0.0110492818,
0.0405040011,
-0.0563623309,
-0.0799919069,
-0.0290053487,
-0.0422825329,
0.0476569459,
0.0391393602,
0.0073090387,
-0.0238085277,
0.0366494022,
-0.0136673665,
-0.0201317389,
-0.0663630962,
-0.0083554573,
0.0002129763,
-0.0403832309,
-0.0240196027,
-0.0292270705,
-0.0219824668,
0.0280176569,
0.0021219803,
0.0224540755,
0.0165390987,
-0.0331079923,
-0.0013581617,
0.00016213,
-0.0535658039,
0.0094986614,
-0.0242829621,
0.009340575,
0.0175550487,
0.0777485892,
0.0115401,
-0.0592009835,
-0.0153732812,
0.0138004059,
-0.0617428347,
0.0199626535,
-0.0041506472,
-0.004950291,
0.0476960652,
-0.0288476143,
-0.0121803218,
-0.0019968932,
0.0264206138,
-0.0042318124,
0.0569123477,
-0.0159827266,
-0.0728938729,
0.0443692133,
0.0327478871,
-0.0115162563,
0.0401155241,
0.042743966,
0.0189266447,
0.0210211873,
0.0175988991,
-0.0075223399,
-0.0664242655,
-0.0305341911,
0.044758521,
0.0508717075,
-0.0076957587,
0.047365088,
-0.0413906388,
-0.054688789,
0.0019690271,
-0.0046539702,
0.0003597186,
0.0233423095,
0.0083921757,
0.0228714421,
0.016958341,
-0.0159619097,
-0.0393217057,
0.0508882217,
-0.0033770353,
-0.0133894822,
-0.0213777013,
-5.457728435e-33,
-0.0150941312,
-0.0279628113,
-0.0217011087,
0.002812759,
-0.0636184141,
0.0336900502,
-0.0585437045,
-0.0142681217,
-0.0330909118,
0.041219078,
-0.0041089812,
0.0340846367,
-0.0006349641,
0.0327560641,
-0.0054652542,
-0.0538863912,
0.0417573266,
-0.0038274939,
-0.012479024,
0.0360977612,
0.0477025323,
0.0294273794,
0.0761627927,
-0.0575369187,
0.0070015918,
-0.0515019149,
0.0094452929,
0.051052127,
0.0115850931,
0.0481728539,
-0.0076612034,
0.0195875503,
0.0225836448,
0.0001281243,
0.0050582439,
0.038283959,
-0.0687135085,
0.0034806705,
0.010210759,
0.0284427777,
-0.0376629829,
-0.0215395093,
-0.0010244058,
0.0063222833,
0.0558646806,
-0.0637635514,
0.0025573813,
-0.0003757455,
-0.0460572876,
-0.0076042344,
-0.0307889897,
0.02378048,
-0.0425182246,
-0.0340683535,
-0.0163804572,
0.044142548,
0.0608031861,
-0.0019839925,
-0.0497090369,
-0.0291239787,
-0.0629750937,
-0.0155070275,
0.003952818,
0.0055776872,
-0.0166761521,
0.0756276771,
0.012937217,
-0.0295553561,
-0.0534694418,
-0.0052765026,
0.0033521778,
0.0385766327,
-0.00412599,
0.0017073316,
-0.0031416845,
0.0239204951,
-0.042961631,
-0.0203184504,
0.0472410209,
0.0916468203,
-0.0076414058,
0.0471072458,
-0.0184679963,
0.0143840173,
-0.0009536033,
-0.0240527447,
-0.0017688732,
-0.0315995924,
0.0061316062,
0.002762768,
0.0088446019,
0.0102760009,
0.0617272444,
-0.0403433032,
0.0019503265,
0.0739188045,
0.0279809516,
0.0043391432,
0.0082652196,
0.0512571894,
-0.0200950094,
-0.0085994126,
0.0634621903,
-0.0153743373,
0.0055200853,
0.0096565252,
0.0297465473,
-0.0091978721,
-0.0315239318,
-0.0100964764,
-0.0182708018,
0.0094880778,
-0.09166722,
0.0634252578,
0.0210921112,
0.0357789025,
-0.0242484007,
0.1042659804,
-0.0464804806,
0.0364554897,
-0.0342030004,
0.0275418349,
0.0057017403,
0.024667643,
-0.0561796799,
-0.0014652715,
0.0026034245,
-0.0007892241,
-0.0014794321,
-0.0475387312,
0.0062512788,
0.0269570667,
2.318e-7,
0.0238189008,
0.0322005376,
0.0548809469,
0.0027738577,
0.0284889881,
0.0393821374,
-0.0130528994,
0.0395904556,
0.0045104241,
-0.0466337726,
0.0264304504,
0.0416364521,
0.0389916487,
-0.0159818586,
-0.0939560533,
-0.0265573598,
-0.0947935432,
-0.0420499407,
-0.0368839577,
0.0132568218,
0.0837816298,
0.126835376,
0.0311464854,
0.0342681669,
-0.0116905728,
0.0118055958,
0.0290124621,
0.0009169184,
-0.0081227543,
0.0073116901,
0.0085562235,
-0.0290598553,
-0.0083241668,
0.0143855829,
-0.0126973987,
0.036780227,
0.0204388648,
0.091926761,
-0.0190578941,
-0.0450206622,
-0.0067264517,
-0.0180344637,
0.0163553972,
-0.0593624376,
0.0416950248,
-0.0494065471,
-0.0137429265,
-0.0426116511,
-0.0386553295,
0.0266021844,
0.0349099822,
-0.0047108023,
-0.0118417284,
0.0320060402,
0.0199104697,
-0.0408439822,
0.0254494026,
-0.1085522547,
0.0011850797,
-0.0155961821,
-0.0682684034,
0.0025665113,
0.0157365035,
-0.0031254468,
0.0538384728,
0.0091886856,
-0.006865032,
1.850670067e-34,
0.0210333727,
-0.0301273465,
-0.0007339711,
0.0499154702,
0.0374029614,
-0.0459533371,
-0.0007584348,
-0.0073413127,
0.0615522452,
-0.0635659248,
0.0048396061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00217v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00217v6 | Still no evidence for an effect of the proportion of non-native speakers on language complexity -- A response to Kauhanen, Einhaus & Walkden (2023) | 2023-04-29T09:58:32 | 2023-05-30T05:42:08 | Alexander Koplenig | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | In a recent paper published in the Journal of Language Evolution, Kauhanen,
Einhaus & Walkden (https://doi.org/10.1093/jole/lzad005, KEW) challenge the
results presented in one of my papers (Koplenig, Royal Society Open Science, 6,
181274 (2019), https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.181274), in which I tried to show
through a series of statistical analyses that large numbers of L2 (second
language) speakers do not seem to affect the (grammatical or statistical)
complexity of a language. To this end, I focus on the way in which the
Ethnologue assesses language status: a language is characterised as vehicular
if, in addition to being used by L1 (first language) speakers, it should also
have a significant number of L2 users. KEW criticise both the use of
vehicularity as a (binary) indicator of whether a language has a significant
number of L2 users and the idea of imputing a zero proportion of L2 speakers to
non-vehicular languages whenever a direct estimate of that proportion is
unavailable. While I recognise the importance of post-publication commentary on
published research, I show in this rejoinder that both points of criticism are
explicitly mentioned and analysed in my paper. In addition, I also comment on
other points raised by KEW and demonstrate that both alternative analyses
offered by KEW do not stand up to closer scrutiny. | [
-0.0197669212,
0.0663499981,
-0.0496907942,
-0.0092754653,
-0.0594347082,
0.0108841406,
0.0246788561,
-0.0034624499,
-0.0382048413,
-0.0223058928,
0.0145602785,
-0.0033448022,
0.0212759543,
0.0063839457,
0.0331571996,
0.0137938801,
-0.0084742084,
-0.0393428095,
0.0169175211,
-0.0061134612,
-0.0208923593,
-0.0078861788,
0.0195032991,
0.0147893615,
0.0186694693,
0.0376187339,
0.0129864579,
-0.0744967759,
-0.0093645565,
-0.006092181,
-0.0189558323,
0.0636719093,
-0.0130937183,
0.0765588582,
0.0000020325,
-0.0242973212,
0.0480151474,
0.0122177647,
-0.043931894,
0.0255854055,
0.013874948,
0.0248640571,
-0.0114110233,
-0.0216092411,
-0.0010456401,
-0.046795506,
0.0273113307,
-0.0691347644,
-0.0661735162,
-0.0140955076,
-0.0108385431,
0.0014469665,
-0.0004316707,
-0.026995033,
0.0130197164,
0.0672893748,
0.0358793475,
-0.0392909013,
-0.0256059859,
-0.0344597325,
-0.0501981564,
0.0648379251,
0.0560511611,
-0.0497050732,
-0.0030984292,
0.0100886468,
0.0115458891,
-0.0571789965,
0.0696063563,
-0.0333887562,
0.0163287781,
-0.0151633108,
-0.0164474659,
0.0269209202,
-0.0127204861,
0.0186249055,
0.006541444,
-0.0291908011,
0.0138835432,
-0.0256292913,
0.0509425588,
0.0000787477,
-0.017572986,
-0.0220995992,
-0.0131317582,
0.0614842512,
0.0348654166,
-0.0106601967,
0.0149886934,
0.0307587925,
0.0334438942,
-0.0487835743,
-0.0389723442,
0.0312545523,
-0.0025729891,
-0.0084357103,
0.1111252904,
-0.01293856,
0.0062488946,
-0.0169664118,
0.0409097746,
-0.014835272,
-0.0338510275,
0.0170843359,
0.0026720688,
-0.0002364466,
0.0244803093,
0.0177783445,
-0.0052032215,
0.0192909837,
0.0284461845,
-0.0404492058,
-0.0059875106,
-0.0604541898,
-0.024244573,
0.08664722,
-0.0211016629,
-0.0233778562,
0.0131358104,
-0.0054652272,
-0.0820458606,
-0.0525613762,
-0.0184764825,
0.0088422522,
0.0070589962,
0.0267132688,
-0.0116858697,
0.0163293388,
-0.0305225607,
-0.0984072983,
0.049392052,
0.0330503695,
-0.0115503706,
-0.0141008385,
-0.0039375061,
-0.0087418733,
-0.0048650792,
-0.027234938,
0.042965997,
0.0039126286,
-0.0516588837,
-0.0341749527,
0.0150053464,
-0.0696959198,
0.0333657786,
0.0400174186,
-0.0203337502,
-0.0485547632,
-0.0467657633,
-0.0451002568,
-0.014270517,
-0.0512760878,
-0.0731476173,
0.0496198311,
0.0020596683,
0.0195046235,
0.057756424,
0.0355152525,
0.0341964029,
-0.079806298,
0.0373416506,
-0.039806135,
0.0029471046,
0.0065457597,
0.0107044196,
0.0375904776,
0.0358086042,
-0.0046370588,
-0.0341431387,
-0.0543275438,
0.0432978533,
0.0508087277,
-0.0301869363,
0.0379184149,
-0.0101378458,
0.0566283539,
0.0048696329,
0.0200575255,
0.028558258,
0.0141754234,
-0.02518332,
0.0574181564,
0.033704821,
-0.0078872591,
-0.0399129912,
-0.0473664701,
0.0156205902,
0.0211212244,
-0.0156931132,
-0.0573299564,
0.0443290249,
0.0142759876,
0.0881827027,
0.0103548039,
0.0636535361,
0.0005867659,
0.0526435934,
-0.0457798764,
0.0188996308,
-0.0119101275,
0.0206938647,
-0.0207704119,
0.0465707444,
-0.0545908175,
-0.0915409103,
0.0162629765,
0.0570020415,
0.0204399396,
0.0200142376,
0.0511294939,
0.020799892,
-0.0107101258,
0.0231874622,
0.0112811467,
0.0277826861,
-0.0170852747,
-0.0012281709,
0.0075010536,
-0.0274694283,
0.0665525869,
0.0283096507,
-0.0187436286,
-0.0525045544,
-0.032538116,
-0.0264163073,
0.0056991111,
-0.041288279,
-0.0197101943,
0.0251408406,
-0.0073895273,
-0.0552189276,
0.0020068435,
-0.0315963142,
0.0002647926,
0.0416184813,
0.0571754426,
0.0254768729,
0.0495233685,
0.0228560641,
-0.0415698625,
0.020274682,
-0.0221855231,
0.0287214741,
0.0124399168,
0.0231881179,
-0.0596505105,
0.0534667112,
0.0289282538,
0.0174477212,
-0.0660844073,
-0.0127655985,
0.0152693316,
-0.0019263244,
0.0012923868,
0.0697481856,
-0.0125407754,
-0.0710239857,
0.0730340704,
-0.0014958226,
-0.0561190285,
0.0247177742,
0.0206361879,
-0.0008926812,
0.0477019958,
-0.0109281391,
-0.0240453258,
0.0292012859,
-0.0242123324,
-0.0425259136,
-0.0252478514,
0.0358107276,
-0.0410518646,
-0.0167772342,
-0.0089513268,
0.0217473749,
0.0124007482,
-0.0267430972,
0.0618932396,
0.0437322892,
0.0013275885,
-0.0363541357,
-0.0307836626,
0.0044205659,
-0.0493654124,
0.0070324889,
-0.0153192803,
0.0117866118,
0.010941036,
0.0118965358,
-0.0372915156,
-0.0597784109,
-0.0218113624,
-0.0292401928,
-0.0214985311,
0.0141176088,
0.0490400158,
0.037828587,
-0.0201861877,
-0.0174811836,
0.0032106913,
0.0195600484,
-0.0402190499,
-0.0198323838,
-0.0374491774,
0.0001752716,
-0.0221189745,
-0.0430642553,
-0.0756498352,
-0.0027209679,
0.0644835308,
-0.0303810984,
-0.067398563,
-0.0299342386,
-0.0027993605,
-0.0642535463,
-0.0253831688,
-0.0043347697,
-0.0145454099,
-0.0085159186,
0.0804502517,
-0.0524388514,
-0.0485789441,
-0.0245241839,
-0.0026752267,
-0.0263275262,
-0.035959743,
-0.015526969,
-0.0099740885,
0.0443722419,
0.0649963394,
-0.0073904912,
0.0501449816,
0.0138852922,
-0.0295357388,
-0.0028868751,
-0.0156366788,
0.0174056962,
0.0439507365,
-0.0533850528,
-0.0126776882,
-0.0248933826,
-0.018438099,
0.0516626351,
0.0019486642,
-0.0098943356,
0.0182177145,
0.0459206365,
-0.0310534108,
0.0360781588,
-0.0218317825,
0.0787251964,
0.0115493461,
0.0376348607,
0.0242906418,
0.012625359,
-0.0268701818,
0.0024905945,
0.1040658429,
0.0378917307,
-0.0560984574,
0.0127816601,
0.0154434852,
-0.0004572734,
0.0497212671,
0.0334223397,
0.0276025683,
0.0206935667,
0.0013940411,
-0.0771355405,
0.0331294797,
0.0300657209,
-0.0224171598,
0.0288635921,
0.0156917442,
-0.0080637336,
0.0491161421,
0.0652768463,
-0.0394025482,
0.0227029044,
0.0331188031,
0.0150595773,
-0.0276301205,
0.090705663,
-0.0014722469,
-0.0242771339,
-0.0490538403,
-0.0137812076,
-0.0073544262,
-0.0553717054,
0.0187656619,
0.0043647313,
-0.0527180508,
0.0140400827,
-0.0462438688,
-0.0169315562,
0.0315811262,
-0.0067902342,
0.0249972269,
-0.0217954647,
0.0174497403,
0.0178025551,
-0.0889228731,
-0.0431433618,
0.0046196817,
-0.0061779735,
0.0183809977,
-0.0503178723,
0.0159138199,
-0.0904810876,
-0.0341059975,
0.0582357682,
-0.0357792825,
-0.0339198969,
-0.0146081774,
-0.0093518477,
0.0586578548,
-0.022310229,
-0.0675526485,
-0.0255110245,
0.0139232017,
0.0058558653,
0.0275592469,
0.039331004,
0.0337502956,
-0.0647383034,
0.0127776638,
0.0189282466,
-0.0730462074,
-0.016772652,
0.0511981249,
-0.0232256912,
0.0200957879,
-0.0473883078,
-0.0300612096,
0.0274057705,
-0.0613915846,
0.0409586318,
0.045185145,
-0.0718184412,
-0.0010155281,
-0.0614919215,
0.0367289893,
0.0463931523,
0.007702352,
0.0250835493,
-0.0053693573,
-0.0631433874,
-0.0375623107,
0.0096535617,
-0.0113766193,
0.0242447741,
-0.0047707302,
0.0151232947,
-0.0213931035,
0.014269419,
-0.0441720709,
-0.0658401996,
0.0224807505,
-0.0447597168,
0.0402394868,
0.0367774926,
0.0220360812,
-0.01104631,
0.0414231792,
-0.0419704355,
-0.0041536549,
-0.0015431527,
0.0041687298,
0.0642561242,
0.0248667579,
-0.0198865365,
0.0342204161,
0.0295317192,
-0.019549828,
-0.0097102011,
0.0402098075,
-0.0199268162,
-0.061128635,
0.0100841857,
-0.041326113,
0.0365897864,
0.0152007286,
-0.0295214746,
-0.0300645605,
-0.0041574733,
-0.017935073,
0.0196776893,
-0.0043241982,
-0.0285343286,
-0.0562504455,
-0.0169663485,
0.0665823296,
-0.0405596904,
0.0377583057,
0.0037598335,
0.0223169029,
-0.0044536721,
0.1285109073,
0.0302620735,
0.0493304692,
0.033065021,
0.0219774134,
0.0050174557,
0.023988571,
-0.0222360864,
0.0676992014,
0.0291278195,
-0.0050470801,
-0.003092383,
-0.0080094608,
0.0237105209,
0.0027588857,
0.0032758077,
-0.0512998179,
0.0421639234,
-0.013934385,
0.0071381303,
-0.012150527,
0.0557616688,
-0.0251647141,
0.00890241,
-0.0613711551,
0.005913442,
-0.000659655,
-0.0589826889,
-0.0149762882,
-0.0048776208,
-0.0273091216,
0.0379416384,
0.0431225002,
0.0324466191,
-0.0200419128,
0.0081943013,
0.0331825465,
0.0005917532,
-0.0436807945,
-0.0141753489,
0.0056946808,
0.0022527731,
-0.014131452,
-0.0708074868,
-0.0812023729,
-0.0110340938,
0.011262903,
0.0228891168,
-0.0153009733,
-0.0191268697,
0.0058168615,
-0.003393339,
-0.0071498551,
-0.032056734,
-0.0195818115,
0.0013610407,
0.0311093982,
0.0974070579,
-5.888311649e-33,
0.0002772119,
-0.0390404165,
0.003727539,
-0.0060299197,
0.0021433446,
0.0349650308,
-0.0285705347,
0.0336466543,
-0.067148976,
0.0153403664,
0.0041238312,
-0.0246168617,
0.00499772,
0.0078438157,
0.0482238717,
0.0327987112,
-0.0068496242,
0.0019729773,
0.0098545915,
-0.0121671269,
-0.0241858102,
-0.0454244614,
0.0726611391,
-0.0474345088,
0.0863215998,
0.004836191,
0.0293030608,
0.0078308582,
-0.0538236946,
-0.0358915702,
-0.006156344,
0.0614504777,
0.0260314848,
-0.0042864452,
0.0129162529,
-0.0268436857,
0.0104663782,
-0.0323820785,
0.049993813,
0.015669506,
-0.0235874038,
-0.0268045925,
0.0227012374,
0.0099337054,
-0.0618050918,
0.0080819968,
0.0148093095,
-0.0350859314,
0.0055312891,
0.0094804233,
-0.0406134278,
0.0186170433,
-0.0443791263,
0.0437484719,
-0.0037755412,
-0.0091315312,
-0.0042269253,
-0.1194623038,
-0.0585235991,
0.0176566318,
0.0245004036,
0.0312414914,
0.0434325486,
-0.0393918008,
0.0186858997,
-0.0048492933,
0.1250050366,
0.0086314939,
0.0344661362,
0.0127692437,
0.0538669229,
-0.0246843249,
-0.0019755266,
0.0261654723,
0.0602468066,
-0.0366640389,
-0.0358555242,
-0.041546952,
0.045488283,
0.0039961399,
0.0012213507,
-0.0365443043,
-0.0372856744,
-0.0547775924,
-0.0325823426,
-0.0378359929,
0.0214296281,
-0.0274324231,
-0.0115899267,
-0.0312527493,
0.0484759733,
-0.0445294939,
0.0690101087,
-0.0038836638,
-0.0575503446,
-0.0727135614,
0.000024048,
0.0374362692,
0.0027997619,
0.0533775091,
-0.0602416657,
0.0022652568,
-0.0288375355,
0.0463048629,
0.0272846166,
0.0382498279,
0.0069495155,
0.0250031371,
-0.0441373885,
0.012837356,
0.0040107928,
-0.0175622869,
0.0471531935,
0.0418671966,
0.0161644779,
0.020857159,
-0.0003066589,
-0.0307309125,
0.0364555642,
-0.0077920747,
-0.028262496,
0.0639188811,
-0.0400072336,
0.000316895,
0.0047442708,
-0.0017736673,
0.0214992501,
0.0348197259,
0.0523565151,
0.0156515036,
-0.0026960273,
-0.0476779416,
2.769e-7,
0.0303075444,
0.0056296056,
0.0110294102,
-0.0470145196,
0.0409829803,
-0.0446687751,
-0.0280974191,
-0.0171145927,
0.0397969224,
0.0578388982,
-0.0215276349,
0.0258736983,
0.0513296127,
0.0053156498,
0.0129232248,
0.0110690752,
-0.0523336418,
0.0020100477,
-0.0077771065,
0.0542067625,
-0.0620386414,
0.0001491837,
-0.040298406,
-0.0121765556,
-0.0230233371,
-0.0061293067,
0.0001988568,
-0.0608053096,
0.0478872396,
0.0165044889,
0.0117929578,
0.0470649749,
0.0230044313,
0.0203885119,
-0.0217262283,
0.0149903987,
-0.0301439706,
0.0031199276,
0.0000036833,
0.0559961982,
0.0319526121,
-0.0231468379,
-0.0240027513,
-0.035858158,
0.040325921,
0.0164804254,
-0.0381806232,
0.0286800545,
-0.0486476272,
0.0118872942,
0.0220098644,
0.0012733971,
-0.0325220376,
0.0009683135,
0.0452654734,
-0.0369192883,
-0.0111076133,
-0.0149419708,
-0.0271999259,
0.0393629149,
-0.0184500478,
-0.0874654055,
0.0065623014,
0.0313451067,
0.0145560643,
0.0290633831,
-0.0053339205,
2.296974507e-34,
0.0511718094,
0.011589746,
0.0580173172,
-0.0156683046,
0.0217369422,
0.0162184611,
-0.0293126199,
-0.0001843206,
0.0402192213,
-0.0289255641,
-0.0422535799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.06173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.06173v1 | QICHWABASE: A Quechua Language and Knowledge Base for Quechua Communities | 2023-04-29T09:14:55 | 2023-04-29T09:14:55 | Elwin Huaman, David Lindemann, Valeria Caruso, Jorge Luis Huaman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Over the last decade, the Web has increasingly become a space of language and
knowledge representation. However, it is only true for well-spread languages
and well-established communities, while minority communities and their
resources received less attention. In this paper, we propose QICHWABASE to
support the harmonization process of the Quechua language and knowledge, and
its community. For doing it, we adopt methods and tools that could become a
game changer in favour of Quechua communities around the world. We conclude
that the methodology and tools adopted on building QICHWABASE, which is a
Wikibase instance, could enhance the presence of minorities on the Web. | [
0.0398419872,
0.0532825477,
-0.0516428575,
0.0206953976,
0.0013598627,
0.005643094,
-0.004176592,
0.0358044729,
0.050455045,
-0.0078108395,
-0.0143558057,
-0.0259979796,
0.0244272463,
-0.0145234074,
-0.0227537062,
-0.0647618994,
-0.0042770258,
0.0075910059,
0.0085421829,
-0.0247995481,
0.0294773653,
0.0252367519,
0.0163587146,
0.0101371398,
0.001896921,
-0.0313209184,
0.0136684664,
-0.0234368294,
-0.0155837173,
-0.0367378034,
0.0250364766,
0.0523139201,
-0.0676809549,
0.0613050163,
0.0000020629,
-0.0609375611,
-0.0133901872,
-0.0187787302,
-0.0221581068,
0.0073244567,
-0.0006272436,
0.0124580627,
-0.0269630514,
0.0235721059,
-0.0411845893,
0.0037431167,
0.043750301,
0.0012456217,
0.012144194,
-0.0122513641,
0.0001159091,
-0.0385875851,
-0.045742739,
0.0316094235,
0.0479167737,
0.0041218582,
0.0284742787,
0.0282442831,
0.0454122871,
-0.0235678721,
0.0280484837,
0.0221741106,
0.00211122,
-0.0627662912,
-0.0065837447,
0.0060224547,
-0.0562741607,
-0.0735685453,
0.0237721093,
0.0476523526,
0.0619214922,
-0.0214770865,
0.0218752977,
0.0748196393,
0.0029024216,
0.0478362776,
-0.0608303286,
0.0450891182,
-0.0181702022,
-0.0000988269,
0.0026823615,
0.0188828092,
0.0294882897,
0.0136853931,
-0.0064006206,
0.0501946434,
0.0168695245,
0.0077457954,
-0.0587078743,
-0.022570936,
0.0696800798,
-0.0493941195,
0.0335478187,
0.0331629477,
-0.0103563033,
0.0128194755,
0.053490784,
0.0105677433,
0.0526377186,
-0.0505515859,
-0.0487804115,
0.0439911149,
-0.000367951,
0.038359683,
0.0319150873,
-0.012045512,
0.0051559554,
-0.0623948947,
0.022189267,
-0.0445882604,
-0.0656584799,
0.0002516761,
-0.0080279233,
0.0106442599,
-0.0234205686,
0.041428864,
-0.0039530047,
0.0451452211,
-0.0099158119,
0.0461897589,
0.0457555503,
0.013931579,
-0.0079226233,
-0.0211547166,
-0.0073417826,
0.0542715006,
-0.0403274484,
-0.0007780031,
-0.0351854675,
-0.0512919053,
0.0637251511,
-0.0100709591,
0.023145644,
-0.0025419272,
-0.0039771893,
0.0138351917,
0.031588424,
0.0215799268,
-0.0244568828,
-0.0264875926,
0.0148678441,
0.0163310189,
-0.0542119406,
-0.0893092826,
0.0143722193,
0.0464153215,
0.0245126411,
-0.0203854404,
-0.0193058196,
-0.0072868005,
0.0377946198,
0.0167096145,
-0.0747997612,
0.0034989733,
0.1237620339,
0.0458667725,
0.0059956703,
0.0605296344,
0.0136238355,
0.0138386218,
0.0979331732,
0.0234965533,
-0.0308035426,
-0.0265432727,
-0.0192586798,
0.0372197516,
0.0525269769,
0.0482229441,
0.02596117,
-0.0044981656,
-0.0547663942,
0.0684191287,
-0.0108658671,
0.0165289696,
0.0256818905,
0.0621261857,
0.0232445747,
0.0264467448,
-0.026228983,
0.0056368522,
0.0107670017,
-0.0401570909,
-0.0062386319,
0.0346518122,
-0.0210311804,
-0.0078024603,
0.0084871622,
0.0428272374,
-0.0394764543,
-0.0180049278,
-0.0007541868,
-0.0101552093,
0.016780233,
-0.0051697684,
0.0066679935,
-0.0146253025,
0.0492416285,
0.0248724632,
0.0493169874,
-0.0354360491,
0.0344866067,
-0.0372506417,
0.022419842,
0.0765492022,
0.0233266242,
-0.0292213634,
0.0486464314,
0.0144539801,
-0.0280467365,
0.039955385,
-0.0125196604,
-0.0452623926,
-0.0597261935,
-0.0364552438,
-0.0220088009,
0.0537587553,
0.0109509248,
-0.0313468985,
0.0116103506,
0.0698060393,
0.0155154373,
-0.0386312269,
-0.0325259119,
-0.0187039245,
-0.0220152158,
0.0059758783,
-0.0636309534,
0.0375532024,
-0.0314788409,
0.0732039213,
-0.0057399701,
-0.0349786356,
0.0064463988,
0.0139237354,
-0.042064108,
0.0303868819,
0.0192457214,
0.017636627,
0.0822669938,
-0.0802473426,
0.02198622,
-0.0205065142,
0.0384264663,
-0.0202238746,
0.0507828183,
0.0198421143,
0.0082687875,
-0.0149839986,
0.0131065119,
-0.0437739007,
-0.0239439476,
-0.0167786684,
0.0310097635,
0.0062524085,
-0.0326682739,
0.0103813242,
-0.0660450384,
0.0403765887,
-0.0088660652,
-0.0103945639,
0.0415928774,
0.0144037409,
0.0180638265,
0.0001416522,
-0.0052571758,
-0.0437277816,
0.0241463482,
-0.0930513516,
-0.0417917036,
-0.0378803685,
0.0332740247,
0.0252265614,
0.0599403679,
0.0170179754,
0.0021552385,
-0.0014171477,
0.0058831717,
-0.0319095142,
-0.0102043618,
-0.0034578196,
0.0129362745,
0.035769321,
-0.0604381934,
0.0118971597,
0.0296519734,
0.0106158387,
0.0247124732,
-0.0806002468,
0.0097708674,
-0.0434996299,
-0.0628297627,
-0.0336082205,
-0.0060731582,
-0.0745662674,
0.0124749793,
0.0103789819,
0.0042766472,
-0.0094607836,
0.0120930532,
0.0015655449,
0.0168621559,
-0.0106554832,
0.0069183386,
-0.0355651379,
0.0238060337,
0.030598199,
-0.0052081319,
-0.0571920834,
0.023457041,
0.0222082715,
0.0142821027,
0.0058825593,
-0.0323697925,
-0.0183729995,
-0.0468597896,
0.0206613578,
-0.0314724408,
-0.0237646308,
-0.0290063042,
0.0134674627,
-0.0177307744,
-0.0098218536,
0.0437061638,
0.0203366894,
0.0470965691,
-0.0261486638,
-0.0446805172,
-0.0417541862,
0.0246722102,
-0.0302114822,
0.026760703,
-0.0572693087,
0.0044950806,
0.0026196295,
-0.0118660461,
0.0403283723,
-0.02810576,
-0.0474246889,
0.0330884233,
-0.0024995808,
-0.0268955603,
0.0068223793,
-0.0297246315,
0.0984288454,
-0.0132929645,
-0.0254387017,
0.0703723133,
0.0165661033,
0.0965533108,
0.0527964868,
0.0436994955,
0.017583834,
0.034939941,
0.0061532492,
0.0204652771,
0.0102647394,
-0.0598155595,
-0.0111442432,
0.0289761294,
-0.0079341745,
0.0195030887,
0.0249972548,
0.0605423786,
-0.0683527067,
0.1054125875,
-0.0549790934,
0.0241800733,
-0.02088698,
-0.0661229938,
-0.020821115,
-0.0128393201,
-0.011073689,
0.0552454479,
0.062979117,
0.0550348125,
-0.0626907349,
-0.0228230506,
-0.083384037,
-0.0335752591,
0.011324713,
0.0118922554,
-0.1265907884,
0.0499677472,
0.0140562495,
0.0077897641,
-0.0042008557,
-0.0101192817,
0.0069903783,
-0.0335059129,
-0.0254626516,
0.0086703077,
0.0009795534,
0.0161691103,
-0.0120550273,
-0.0067864358,
0.0182815734,
-0.0098090563,
0.0386334844,
-0.0153558394,
0.0114137623,
0.0188112203,
-0.063221164,
-0.0689239278,
-0.0497120656,
-0.0669513494,
0.0090486212,
0.036907535,
0.0700448304,
0.0007502058,
-0.0278393831,
-0.0398709811,
0.0009014407,
-0.0464945063,
-0.0069998945,
-0.0232836045,
0.0237209853,
-0.0167760011,
-0.0215518158,
-0.0097660599,
-0.0246840622,
0.0290941056,
0.025220653,
0.062157236,
0.0085333232,
-0.0038654662,
-0.005728872,
-0.0777091309,
0.0450036898,
0.0301247388,
0.0061186249,
-0.0183247812,
0.0062138531,
-0.0585373677,
-0.0457784273,
0.0159790814,
-0.0583257414,
0.0550506338,
-0.0335040614,
-0.0688926131,
-0.1284869313,
-0.0402274765,
0.0038891037,
0.0141109033,
0.0423170291,
0.0102641582,
0.0420590229,
-0.0081863292,
-0.0155357253,
-0.0372893028,
-0.0317398235,
0.0095345462,
-0.0578726381,
-0.0264994577,
-0.0049956166,
-0.0434284769,
0.0372185484,
-0.0458955504,
0.0274101533,
-0.0114294216,
0.0411638394,
0.0188033413,
0.0269689392,
-0.0610276312,
0.0006437746,
-0.0392572097,
0.0312439688,
0.0447227359,
-0.0535732768,
-0.022385655,
-0.0112424102,
-0.03237601,
-0.0015990885,
0.0285848118,
-0.0186951477,
-0.011351211,
-0.0566789433,
-0.0225899052,
-0.0472235382,
0.0120975189,
-0.033357881,
0.0279723108,
-0.0492837355,
-0.0044168988,
-0.0335652642,
-0.0102117481,
0.016938718,
-0.0256314594,
-0.0290722642,
0.021288259,
0.0111537492,
-0.0030540125,
0.0188769028,
-0.0008948439,
0.0601292141,
0.0040284125,
-0.0082701221,
-0.0499640107,
0.0672193989,
0.0014833788,
0.0483437218,
-0.0037435328,
0.0039561442,
0.0147809582,
0.0166200325,
-0.018714726,
0.0256419145,
-0.0396051072,
-0.0192848053,
-0.014500767,
-0.0431259423,
0.0474354737,
0.0085112248,
0.0155903297,
-0.0586949512,
0.0263857674,
-0.0131996926,
0.0450831838,
0.0512293018,
0.0458576903,
0.0246198792,
-0.0273170732,
-0.0062496047,
-0.0126221599,
0.0284566209,
-0.0391194299,
0.018619556,
0.0056311185,
-0.0007183491,
0.0274192486,
0.0156022115,
-0.0521318354,
-0.02416219,
0.0014644653,
-0.0209922697,
-0.0148976482,
-0.0137805594,
0.0189311374,
0.0113947336,
-0.0568397082,
-0.0296933353,
-0.0525753722,
-0.0449722819,
0.020596493,
0.0115400981,
-0.0138280364,
0.0215206593,
0.0296958946,
0.0080585573,
0.029098928,
0.0373647772,
-0.023771232,
0.0220468901,
-0.099035807,
0.0272932835,
0.0700578168,
-6.159280362e-33,
-0.0057595056,
-0.0670216829,
-0.0040071523,
-0.0280104261,
0.0313735232,
-0.0666258186,
-0.0035742493,
0.0043358747,
-0.0300722867,
0.0250668041,
-0.0037841452,
0.0315973386,
0.0211039223,
-0.0140604842,
-0.0128170233,
0.0454878435,
0.0381541178,
0.033214882,
-0.0048630037,
0.0209133122,
0.0493043847,
-0.0035472352,
0.0439782552,
-0.0750301629,
0.0422560014,
-0.0362730473,
-0.017815575,
0.0291378368,
0.0425592586,
0.0565669127,
-0.0272666905,
0.0484607667,
-0.0126126949,
0.0482680984,
0.0160076413,
-0.0318626054,
-0.0655136928,
-0.0200531352,
0.0414899997,
0.0150038367,
0.0384691209,
-0.0253882408,
0.0009664646,
-0.0228677783,
0.0241614711,
0.0530975908,
0.0233979635,
-0.0142867491,
0.0267464612,
-0.0000969062,
-0.015398276,
0.0149396593,
0.0356161892,
0.0563635901,
-0.0564264767,
-0.0212963056,
-0.0241616033,
-0.040159747,
-0.1112326086,
-0.002943072,
0.0165171716,
0.0256782807,
0.0302915201,
0.0117446911,
-0.0131313903,
0.0033223778,
-0.0202918071,
-0.0461966023,
0.0490543768,
0.0244159326,
-0.0082997018,
-0.0091849305,
0.0370456465,
0.0592867024,
-0.0467783809,
-0.0583479367,
-0.0447483324,
0.0213974304,
0.0172504187,
-0.0088236267,
-0.0036943711,
0.0182132069,
-0.0246440545,
-0.0192805473,
0.002169617,
-0.0104256105,
-0.0276866984,
-0.0082406681,
-0.0212221667,
-0.0156068467,
-0.0404400826,
-0.0084514478,
-0.0199396722,
-0.023163436,
-0.0243560821,
0.0650021657,
-0.0439321809,
-0.0111405319,
0.027025057,
-0.0063840048,
-0.0279938187,
-0.0079194121,
-0.0503469259,
0.0281904005,
-0.0326775052,
0.0083492203,
-0.0354366452,
0.0142869297,
-0.0361668505,
0.0285694115,
0.0105258077,
0.0189655628,
0.0455080234,
0.0161218066,
-0.012282229,
0.0095128557,
0.0110688386,
0.001707449,
0.0672703758,
-0.033757221,
-0.0241798088,
-0.0299533308,
-0.0356259905,
-0.0194004755,
-0.0642871633,
0.0090194615,
-0.027342815,
0.098033689,
-0.0072080344,
-0.0186075959,
-0.0104146376,
-0.0391404666,
2.868e-7,
0.0405215211,
0.0305451509,
-0.0017511088,
0.014970025,
0.0254651625,
-0.0356895663,
0.0048379898,
0.0402907468,
-0.0438834727,
-0.0145661496,
-0.0226371568,
0.0374251865,
0.0485323519,
0.0795622617,
-0.0671823993,
-0.0162527822,
-0.0144279422,
-0.0388445482,
-0.0409875251,
-0.0006198299,
-0.0502006114,
0.0209340584,
0.0098693762,
0.026964251,
-0.0155578498,
0.0175367445,
0.027340401,
-0.0003394825,
0.0265819076,
0.0525904484,
0.0293741692,
-0.0118852053,
-0.0135736112,
-0.0848430172,
0.0037068201,
0.0093557704,
-0.050629016,
0.01233452,
-0.0070414813,
0.0610923246,
0.0246621538,
-0.0964804888,
0.0378775224,
-0.0540854596,
0.0428420082,
0.075798817,
0.0089889867,
0.0481441505,
0.0517884903,
-0.0442241095,
0.0295665469,
-0.0335087925,
-0.0136826541,
0.0183107182,
-0.0271829646,
-0.0218246039,
0.0013339183,
-0.0453964509,
-0.0373390876,
-0.0130220121,
0.0084556481,
-0.078691572,
-0.0214251373,
-0.0218852647,
-0.0472342968,
0.0490577593,
0.0516918711,
1.87425744e-34,
-0.0234967209,
-0.000486428,
-0.0043869414,
0.0142204156,
0.0160440877,
-0.0306253042,
-0.0280575044,
-0.040940538,
0.0427466035,
0.0113032609,
-0.0093284249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00182v1 | Examining European Press Coverage of the Covid-19 No-Vax Movement: An NLP Framework | 2023-04-29T06:26:03 | 2023-04-29T06:26:03 | David Alonso del Barrio, Daniel Gatica-Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper examines how the European press dealt with the no-vax reactions
against the Covid-19 vaccine and the dis- and misinformation associated with
this movement. Using a curated dataset of 1786 articles from 19 European
newspapers on the anti-vaccine movement over a period of 22 months in
2020-2021, we used Natural Language Processing techniques including topic
modeling, sentiment analysis, semantic relationship with word embeddings,
political analysis, named entity recognition, and semantic networks, to
understand the specific role of the European traditional press in the
disinformation ecosystem. The results of this multi-angle analysis demonstrate
that the European well-established press actively opposed a variety of hoaxes
mainly spread on social media, and was critical of the anti-vax trend,
regardless of the political orientation of the newspaper. This confirms the
relevance of studying the role of high-quality press in the disinformation
ecosystem. | [
0.0369767286,
0.0633248165,
0.0130942352,
-0.0071116718,
-0.0289534014,
0.0031739471,
-0.0054939329,
-0.0325620435,
-0.0026331027,
-0.0451774187,
0.0324542858,
0.0376645438,
0.0023586666,
0.0290932003,
0.0200983062,
-0.015394018,
0.0364988968,
0.0775497258,
0.0693189353,
-0.0101236226,
0.0218535364,
0.0363772996,
-0.0039098747,
0.0476177819,
0.0374158509,
0.0018678724,
0.0391076878,
-0.01097978,
0.0426983908,
-0.0928516462,
-0.0104344683,
0.0026537504,
0.0425133184,
0.0541653149,
0.0000014421,
-0.0299081057,
-0.0050366353,
0.0130526079,
0.0118149435,
-0.0315152854,
0.0811224133,
-0.0699903294,
-0.0094499923,
0.0111486455,
-0.0210534055,
-0.0699573234,
0.0439839587,
0.0206915177,
0.0353472754,
0.0882262439,
-0.0111826928,
-0.0481997617,
0.0159118231,
0.0056025898,
-0.0190835986,
0.0071316543,
0.0473860316,
-0.0598215275,
-0.0305447858,
0.0582901426,
0.0169424172,
0.0256631598,
-0.0443495065,
-0.0003322357,
-0.0373968109,
0.0295721795,
-0.0058393688,
-0.0404844508,
-0.0197502468,
0.0063035204,
0.0571101457,
-0.0246234443,
0.0300705098,
-0.0069408417,
-0.0511351675,
0.0444397107,
-0.0373193547,
0.0047033154,
-0.0115397824,
0.045309864,
0.0568905883,
-0.0103070801,
0.0533448644,
0.025012508,
0.0351983383,
0.0590994805,
-0.0226572156,
-0.0308572091,
0.0378117226,
-0.0171719566,
0.031862855,
-0.0454082564,
0.0093138954,
-0.0020203451,
0.0235904548,
0.0520688035,
0.033286538,
-0.0354461595,
0.0415413827,
-0.124286674,
-0.0722441375,
-0.0282419212,
0.0525371432,
0.0293798875,
0.035407383,
-0.0510432869,
-0.0355742462,
0.0153366607,
0.0280312151,
0.0232100114,
-0.0499017648,
0.0113052819,
0.0052017672,
-0.0125710163,
0.0071405806,
0.0128492061,
-0.0211048145,
-0.0578823164,
-0.0150668733,
0.0067018177,
-0.0234500691,
0.0386218615,
0.0150805265,
0.0112371333,
-0.021236252,
0.0946799293,
-0.0317969024,
0.0171717443,
-0.0395704657,
0.0285663549,
-0.0033549678,
-0.0127376011,
0.0125420438,
0.0061520487,
-0.0057466039,
0.0318353288,
0.0265814718,
-0.0035345578,
0.0075743981,
-0.0074449671,
-0.0298348162,
-0.0376467444,
0.0288438033,
-0.0335709304,
0.000977661,
0.0187376924,
-0.0061108754,
-0.0360618122,
0.0002787217,
0.033951249,
-0.106361486,
0.0249389615,
-0.0074819289,
0.0120807933,
0.0494962931,
0.0177158248,
0.0303775501,
0.0449172668,
-0.011061104,
0.0197343268,
0.0097322939,
0.0226262193,
-0.0234364271,
-0.0248247106,
0.0497680567,
-0.0092723425,
-0.0027302725,
-0.0099369986,
-0.0238214731,
0.0055118105,
-0.0055103479,
0.0088743977,
-0.0098645762,
-0.020876823,
0.0198070705,
0.0345976725,
-0.0354331769,
-0.0600935295,
-0.0107068131,
0.0185156073,
-0.0269694142,
-0.0027491972,
-0.0091436086,
-0.0325036645,
-0.0075292285,
-0.032851126,
0.0085298559,
0.0303415712,
0.0037165286,
0.0200900678,
-0.0313175693,
0.019027587,
0.0527400933,
-0.0638551861,
0.01131556,
-0.0388077311,
-0.0523045734,
0.0257154703,
0.0374973044,
-0.001166475,
0.0238121655,
-0.0243295114,
0.0148608806,
0.0212276895,
0.0302602481,
0.024882799,
-0.024941545,
-0.0430095457,
-0.0015315494,
0.0262332503,
0.016365584,
-0.0184736531,
-0.0404078998,
0.0305656139,
-0.0208100826,
-0.0626404285,
0.0477726683,
0.0077569643,
-0.0153729767,
0.0460276678,
-0.0262042228,
-0.0123942383,
0.0133235417,
0.0376921557,
0.0118056322,
-0.0061161276,
-0.0641507506,
0.0298541505,
0.0079604574,
0.064559266,
0.0110009219,
0.0169638246,
0.0850720853,
-0.0431827828,
-0.0340087451,
-0.0344684869,
0.0543432012,
0.0186320748,
-0.0046858755,
-0.0682555512,
-0.0281753764,
0.0105790133,
-0.0292351674,
0.0266967639,
0.0658932552,
-0.0034205245,
0.0020417566,
-0.0048190965,
-0.0236631073,
-0.0408245511,
-0.0027333219,
0.0038732735,
0.0446572714,
-0.0507118255,
0.0642475262,
-0.0029077346,
-0.0478834026,
-0.0192080475,
0.0211434141,
0.0125079649,
0.0206098706,
0.0063146329,
-0.0100514824,
0.0431472622,
-0.0327390768,
0.0122153368,
0.0085396795,
-0.0261512678,
0.0207139887,
-0.0089733033,
0.0206004102,
0.0486764796,
-0.0047148843,
-0.0050949873,
0.0083928397,
-0.0048233448,
-0.0169970002,
0.0228653811,
0.0075936834,
-0.023275096,
-0.0125852879,
-0.0078918329,
-0.0129939951,
0.0216032695,
-0.0618137307,
0.0242809001,
0.0155886887,
-0.0526411906,
0.0142863179,
0.0036471605,
-0.0660643652,
0.0012542357,
-0.0451039784,
-0.009166955,
0.0226814989,
0.0386259891,
-0.032212358,
0.0195079017,
0.0135047799,
0.0594371706,
0.0613170639,
0.0477830209,
-0.0141427219,
-0.0139853554,
-0.0842130259,
0.0346583053,
-0.0577855259,
-0.0197371636,
0.0438800007,
0.0629667938,
0.0359746739,
0.0312994905,
0.0066252016,
0.0430766717,
-0.0514990501,
-0.002173455,
0.01156832,
-0.0162893012,
0.0132023925,
0.030661501,
-0.0053172545,
0.008163617,
0.0160021335,
0.0061120423,
0.0745163187,
-0.0572752953,
-0.0189096946,
0.0057497979,
0.0092048366,
-0.0119867241,
0.0314866342,
0.0008818078,
0.0008246327,
0.0300329532,
-0.08464472,
0.0249055121,
-0.0094609996,
-0.0125166578,
-0.0212332383,
0.0197126269,
0.008552907,
0.0014592548,
-0.014212843,
-0.0741525069,
-0.0556883067,
-0.0073985024,
0.0520622358,
-0.0181144997,
-0.0741218105,
0.0050285184,
0.0319527425,
0.0107669728,
0.0389713459,
0.0027847602,
0.0211803317,
0.0124326991,
0.0038557898,
-0.0244451296,
0.0592880435,
0.0046073124,
-0.0293852072,
0.0344350412,
-0.0166240279,
0.0109859249,
-0.0262003075,
-0.0195727162,
-0.0046358863,
-0.0350572877,
-0.0193351954,
-0.0271230899,
0.0167745128,
-0.0412893258,
0.0361258127,
0.0496390685,
0.0097217392,
0.0101563223,
0.0092203114,
0.0173948873,
-0.0512456894,
0.0149421832,
0.0350966901,
-0.0531820133,
0.0308886524,
0.0052325642,
-0.03014227,
-0.0462180376,
-0.033736214,
-0.0525633506,
-0.0391210094,
0.0241213646,
-0.0180808231,
-0.0143413506,
0.0004648168,
-0.1190101355,
0.0139171807,
-0.0267399251,
-0.0213471726,
-0.037511386,
0.0292770676,
-0.0051644417,
-0.0460156947,
-0.0674479902,
-0.0554533638,
-0.0049857423,
-0.0038791737,
0.0523638353,
0.0165903214,
0.075029932,
-0.0182142071,
-0.0271968376,
-0.008821954,
0.0224418733,
-0.0502656773,
-0.0597428232,
0.1013122499,
-0.0326331742,
0.0223817769,
-0.0343340598,
0.0364664979,
-0.0043504047,
-0.0212104078,
-0.0100041032,
0.0489389002,
-0.0068962458,
-0.0773138255,
-0.0160666928,
0.0389252119,
0.0474416614,
0.0265547633,
-0.01631983,
0.0187627338,
0.0006034693,
-0.0196759067,
0.0756886899,
-0.000791745,
-0.0081947679,
0.0156475324,
-0.019597901,
-0.0982215926,
0.0065468755,
-0.0180201586,
-0.0005540369,
0.0032432021,
0.0058147749,
0.0028566911,
0.0734804422,
-0.0174908489,
-0.0365380123,
-0.0014754334,
0.0601524301,
0.0099180834,
0.0228146687,
-0.0120131616,
0.015954271,
0.0927289799,
-0.033420898,
0.0095071075,
-0.0306367595,
-0.0779002234,
0.0008502128,
-0.0508178174,
0.0131813455,
0.0384081006,
0.0232181996,
-0.0045061666,
0.0901400149,
0.0384838432,
-0.0431317985,
-0.0239945166,
-0.019827852,
0.0084645292,
0.0239238646,
0.0100392485,
0.014896133,
0.0172083993,
0.0039872108,
0.0019271455,
-0.0247918963,
0.0382916443,
0.0200168565,
-0.0337286033,
0.0637960285,
-0.033951126,
0.0089343069,
-0.0803992152,
-0.041437272,
-0.0064224876,
-0.0037833482,
0.0148051996,
-0.0472868346,
-0.0143486066,
-0.0206052735,
-0.0506936088,
0.0459037311,
-0.0571638532,
0.0247597992,
-0.0531620979,
0.0472175218,
0.0163139328,
0.0492070839,
0.0275964793,
-0.009430646,
0.0247803684,
0.0481399596,
-0.0281316992,
-0.0172726046,
-0.0222861581,
-0.0461206809,
0.0057333708,
0.0020819239,
0.0073465519,
-0.0239179004,
-0.0430619977,
-0.0419616811,
-0.02218033,
0.0269749463,
-0.0016646629,
-0.014189845,
0.0270916149,
0.0172141939,
-0.0339416303,
0.001696093,
0.0268593375,
-0.0140989218,
-0.0192581415,
0.028818991,
-0.0149421087,
-0.0617485158,
-0.0047780834,
0.0066269441,
-0.012370823,
0.0656594187,
0.0485364534,
-0.0547732301,
-0.0115434555,
-0.0515892766,
0.0301342942,
-0.0001370543,
-0.0290603228,
0.0065793092,
-0.0672031865,
-0.0164858233,
0.027380323,
-0.0132191274,
-0.0362723172,
-0.0004904058,
-0.0318814367,
0.0653333142,
0.0453437492,
0.0221483205,
-0.0510645285,
0.0457800105,
-0.063244231,
-0.0752960965,
-0.0093014762,
-5.899133911e-33,
0.0303315464,
-0.0302053541,
0.0003941825,
-0.0089525729,
0.0057054446,
0.0652936026,
-0.016638821,
-0.0091070235,
-0.0286353827,
0.0519005768,
0.0326990969,
0.0141522018,
-0.0002156543,
-0.0275912806,
-0.0362759493,
-0.0196984205,
0.0497047231,
-0.0398069844,
-0.0095034651,
0.0028179733,
0.0497133769,
0.0290808491,
0.0515155979,
-0.0783270821,
0.0750494078,
0.022039121,
0.0076141912,
-0.0163959507,
0.060862571,
0.0151079949,
-0.0076619443,
0.0158351287,
0.0467843227,
-0.0671612248,
0.0185124483,
0.088124454,
-0.0374001302,
-0.0524602756,
0.0192797799,
-0.0360437371,
-0.0213054456,
0.0042086057,
0.0285802316,
0.0222661011,
-0.0380139649,
0.0568816885,
0.0270045213,
0.0068230187,
0.0050497451,
-0.0099823447,
-0.0700530335,
0.000893274,
-0.0462039225,
0.0547760352,
-0.0239524543,
0.0116745345,
0.0028942868,
0.0937276185,
-0.0627918243,
0.0135768214,
-0.0313652791,
-0.01753431,
0.021184098,
-0.0430366024,
0.0059075681,
0.0763802454,
0.0010279085,
0.0109647959,
-0.0953062028,
0.0356872939,
0.0292491596,
0.025214795,
0.0050908625,
0.0418554507,
0.0251416322,
-0.0246230587,
-0.1028608829,
0.0265463889,
-0.0077672713,
0.0347077288,
0.0059696184,
-0.0221967958,
0.0032772894,
-0.0024704712,
-0.0522730388,
-0.0356846116,
0.0100664999,
-0.0251511522,
-0.0301959869,
0.0040480252,
-0.0288695414,
-0.0018442097,
-0.0027063801,
-0.0273638107,
-0.0560343675,
0.0254212376,
0.0261724927,
-0.0291600805,
0.0038608392,
0.042908404,
-0.0705998242,
0.0386330858,
-0.0117849456,
0.0369382203,
0.0431040488,
-0.0361891091,
0.0225006118,
0.0001545776,
-0.0506689548,
0.0006165824,
-0.0038644373,
0.0151806138,
-0.0043944544,
0.0277575664,
0.0526665039,
0.0096145105,
0.0200255848,
-0.0122403083,
0.0297638457,
0.0300067253,
0.0691748559,
-0.0193659794,
-0.0357465036,
0.0523653515,
-0.0353605002,
0.002868592,
-0.0169554353,
0.0455703661,
0.0105924513,
-0.0782889426,
-0.0102878278,
-0.0366485193,
2.454e-7,
0.1037609577,
0.0351108275,
-0.0259397849,
0.0092365602,
0.0308142006,
0.0125366785,
0.0041444297,
0.0194747392,
-0.0707481652,
-0.0980153754,
-0.0157174468,
0.0109952465,
-0.0310858749,
0.0407884605,
-0.025578158,
0.0572977625,
-0.0412688479,
0.0291219186,
-0.0324839614,
0.0241779853,
-0.0054482236,
0.0316204764,
0.0084853796,
0.0154680973,
-0.062669903,
0.0266103595,
0.0377490856,
-0.0086050909,
-0.0433328748,
-0.0039068679,
-0.0008383067,
-0.0126633495,
-0.0051093865,
-0.002387882,
-0.029703442,
0.0057021431,
-0.0297907796,
0.0137976864,
0.0015594893,
0.019757865,
0.0208798759,
-0.0657549575,
-0.0138616636,
-0.0225285944,
0.0519972965,
-0.0879770443,
-0.0641127229,
-0.1007166132,
-0.0471988656,
0.0347900204,
0.0626103655,
0.0065903724,
-0.0302394964,
0.0168876871,
-0.0278840195,
0.0073652416,
0.0225344617,
-0.0402939841,
0.0377481245,
0.0163282212,
-0.0186834261,
-0.0227671228,
0.0335470736,
-0.0115137966,
0.021977609,
0.0101091517,
0.0595518127,
1.735793159e-34,
0.054687012,
-0.0193341859,
-0.0644636601,
-0.0309349969,
0.0291445386,
-0.0033365013,
-0.0343984291,
-0.0227172188,
-0.0075506442,
-0.0028597282,
0.0345792286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00118v2 | Speak, Memory: An Archaeology of Books Known to ChatGPT/GPT-4 | 2023-04-28T22:35:03 | 2023-10-20T21:23:21 | Kent K. Chang, Mackenzie Cramer, Sandeep Soni, David Bamman | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we carry out a data archaeology to infer books that are known
to ChatGPT and GPT-4 using a name cloze membership inference query. We find
that OpenAI models have memorized a wide collection of copyrighted materials,
and that the degree of memorization is tied to the frequency with which
passages of those books appear on the web. The ability of these models to
memorize an unknown set of books complicates assessments of measurement
validity for cultural analytics by contaminating test data; we show that models
perform much better on memorized books than on non-memorized books for
downstream tasks. We argue that this supports a case for open models whose
training data is known. | [
-0.0028248751,
0.096906282,
-0.0641086251,
0.0418602414,
-0.0507016331,
0.0338470042,
0.0446259789,
0.0027733447,
0.0598709658,
-0.0196500942,
-0.0334057547,
-0.0506497808,
0.0272278599,
0.0301184449,
-0.0017007119,
0.0029948517,
0.033435829,
0.0188529342,
0.0171275716,
0.0053518005,
-0.0584973134,
0.0022703737,
-0.0011821165,
0.0392272174,
-0.000361064,
-0.0415339544,
-0.0152767301,
-0.0595574751,
0.00758779,
-0.0015400187,
-0.0007550935,
0.0099779619,
0.0206323173,
0.0676927492,
0.0000017666,
-0.0442738421,
-0.0358407311,
-0.0255693309,
0.0123483883,
0.0387404859,
0.0404069424,
0.0810945928,
0.0049449145,
-0.0095296493,
-0.0383343287,
0.0078815483,
0.0294035394,
0.0081063267,
-0.0142228864,
0.0693142638,
0.0006214654,
-0.011875785,
0.0538699701,
-0.0207899883,
0.040603444,
-0.0076965927,
0.023100704,
0.0401374549,
-0.0072872806,
-0.0032835442,
-0.0265220143,
0.0458847284,
0.0075328173,
0.0477404445,
-0.0192050505,
0.0123879332,
-0.0088970466,
0.0116289863,
0.029910529,
0.0165091287,
0.097567454,
-0.0128048472,
0.0456311405,
0.0178151913,
-0.0245207995,
0.0275009554,
-0.066211246,
0.0534963757,
-0.0137795499,
0.0091621773,
-0.0086486088,
-0.0040263822,
0.0522849187,
0.0377554372,
-0.0070084091,
0.0767440498,
-0.0091535216,
-0.0026222991,
-0.0112484144,
-0.0206877217,
0.0097708171,
-0.0218314156,
-0.0048084874,
0.0058604167,
0.0308595002,
0.0414887406,
-0.0007437899,
0.0070714182,
-0.0103881871,
-0.0369352475,
0.0154264616,
0.0697987452,
-0.0509226806,
0.0423511304,
0.0098595237,
0.0365733877,
0.0095311422,
0.0150240334,
0.0079157641,
0.011845558,
-0.0693581179,
-0.0147080692,
0.0148950685,
0.0201331954,
0.0093582962,
-0.0179001894,
-0.0496561304,
0.0198799483,
-0.0273424163,
0.003204206,
-0.0616569184,
-0.0088134035,
-0.0077920123,
0.0293639544,
-0.0591248088,
0.0038220787,
-0.0419294536,
0.0159842484,
-0.0098539721,
-0.0480614044,
0.0318945199,
0.0064579514,
-0.0121555766,
-0.0101292459,
0.0265659206,
0.0374493897,
0.0386155918,
-0.0150773535,
-0.0840432644,
-0.0377683379,
0.0114956927,
-0.0585497506,
0.0723377913,
-0.0397848785,
0.0195279028,
0.0002834645,
0.0107510928,
-0.0584095158,
-0.0308941118,
0.0135791469,
-0.0741652176,
0.008364968,
0.0762339085,
0.0151871657,
0.0410753563,
0.0345736295,
-0.0279802084,
0.0516420119,
0.0668103844,
-0.0107879974,
0.0538820066,
0.0026201718,
0.0243739448,
0.0452708378,
0.0284556411,
-0.0003513985,
-0.0107229883,
0.0048416695,
0.0431389324,
-0.0112593798,
-0.0076373653,
0.0408365279,
-0.0214744005,
0.0017829966,
0.0255404394,
0.0999392718,
-0.0322231315,
0.0181294363,
0.0045547611,
-0.0409328267,
0.04248726,
0.0328073688,
-0.0094215358,
-0.0024203879,
-0.0122334482,
-0.0119289057,
-0.0072705951,
0.0108532188,
-0.0355643332,
-0.0094759967,
0.0098607289,
-0.0040298337,
0.0156163108,
0.0024338001,
0.03154305,
-0.0205530655,
0.0077919858,
-0.0108709559,
0.0235891752,
-0.0600630715,
-0.0052608554,
-0.0691798925,
0.0832193866,
0.0347643234,
0.0562757067,
-0.0200588014,
0.0691922903,
0.0014309137,
0.0168944336,
-0.0015264142,
0.0462545976,
-0.0386859179,
0.0109659797,
-0.0506687127,
-0.0116231171,
-0.0319881029,
0.0238122288,
0.0375124998,
0.0161872897,
0.0244175475,
0.0293151904,
0.0109440926,
-0.0462328084,
0.0103310514,
-0.0705612227,
-0.0127459345,
-0.0150476573,
0.0214807671,
0.050707031,
0.0563369356,
-0.0086818049,
-0.0266353227,
-0.0136058731,
0.0208907705,
0.0005991283,
0.0100453235,
0.0183731019,
0.0339938141,
0.0162270814,
-0.0427176878,
0.005165725,
0.039069593,
0.0065922467,
-0.0347068869,
0.0339369923,
0.0053301891,
0.1258942783,
-0.0217701178,
-0.0208916571,
-0.0328866392,
-0.0254213009,
-0.0100632673,
0.0863793492,
-0.0144859003,
0.0258394461,
-0.0056085223,
-0.0391219445,
0.0592620298,
-0.0322436988,
-0.0631061718,
0.0101432465,
0.0007376424,
0.018438803,
0.0137302605,
-0.0313609764,
-0.0640935302,
0.0251851901,
-0.095013164,
0.0363986939,
-0.017599443,
0.0213218182,
-0.0257239696,
0.009442023,
-0.0413067155,
0.0027318159,
-0.0440603495,
0.0005351369,
0.0131855644,
0.0393985175,
-0.02927172,
-0.0096029667,
0.0100621628,
0.0013959439,
-0.0153844608,
-0.0549824871,
0.0477687903,
0.0363223851,
-0.0048338738,
0.0052268622,
-0.0044687139,
-0.0839800611,
-0.0171520691,
-0.0305580273,
-0.0038522475,
0.0376017354,
-0.0063378825,
0.0179154184,
0.0505580716,
-0.0290415231,
-0.0000762215,
0.0138403578,
-0.0524274185,
-0.023158744,
0.001030638,
-0.0422069691,
-0.0418164507,
0.0396132134,
-0.0575035922,
-0.0183905922,
-0.0117837163,
0.0308902487,
-0.0120596755,
-0.0187607985,
0.0050358358,
-0.0426226221,
-0.0109830452,
-0.0436723754,
-0.0047977562,
-0.025491422,
0.0520761795,
-0.0167314261,
-0.0523093306,
0.0071382276,
0.0081803892,
0.0193500649,
-0.0349308811,
0.0089749517,
-0.0318324901,
0.0828353614,
0.0232834015,
0.0297808275,
0.021243846,
-0.0381622612,
-0.0512765944,
0.0363495238,
0.017234493,
-0.0568997562,
0.0138021884,
-0.0116155641,
-0.0148555925,
0.0142145632,
0.0200799908,
-0.0591220856,
0.062612161,
-0.0017498498,
-0.017259758,
0.0124235554,
-0.0119262701,
-0.0143228462,
-0.013325464,
0.052683793,
-0.0138335023,
0.0176589005,
0.0033327625,
0.0125493836,
0.0092431065,
0.0362597965,
-0.0037646212,
-0.0024898697,
-0.0435349122,
-0.0293219537,
0.0290620215,
0.0335487947,
-0.0390217081,
-0.0031386777,
0.0092429863,
-0.0024637512,
-0.0053611933,
0.0077882241,
0.0652965382,
0.0031713408,
-0.0455794036,
0.017092539,
0.0858881325,
0.0367312022,
-0.0555487312,
-0.0282183774,
0.0070337285,
-0.030648794,
-0.0045106709,
-0.0129098194,
-0.1174340174,
0.0232710112,
-0.0066860258,
0.0528698489,
-0.0522059202,
-0.0517736487,
0.01711509,
-0.1104512066,
0.01253823,
0.0145436674,
-0.0893566161,
0.0286993086,
-0.0172779448,
0.0061258208,
-0.0614134111,
0.0024669145,
-0.0231306031,
0.0173126962,
0.0127677126,
-0.0197713971,
-0.0213098209,
-0.0438871458,
0.0257904008,
-0.0444488525,
0.074457854,
0.0508188196,
0.0557376705,
-0.0156526174,
-0.0737913921,
-0.0015946283,
-0.0299170986,
0.0142914504,
0.0137766479,
0.0847327709,
0.0181311145,
-0.0008970963,
-0.0200598985,
0.054524187,
-0.0465740524,
-0.0002926658,
0.0283802189,
0.0544294901,
0.005534152,
-0.0179868676,
0.0041530482,
-0.0086283777,
0.0116169043,
0.086826086,
-0.0037176223,
0.0010632541,
0.0272065178,
-0.0411991253,
0.0326955728,
0.0068477276,
-0.0421638377,
-0.0113919126,
-0.048415117,
-0.0661755577,
-0.070086211,
-0.0686284155,
0.0012419251,
0.049634967,
0.0619154871,
-0.017593557,
0.0343737639,
-0.0074142707,
-0.0393091403,
0.025731504,
-0.058812093,
0.003517769,
-0.0490193404,
-0.0644698814,
0.0045992769,
0.0091491556,
0.0000424607,
0.0201058574,
-0.1071619838,
-0.0619243346,
0.0313156582,
0.0685192347,
0.041204825,
0.0082943933,
0.0242034309,
0.0214378648,
0.0032787838,
-0.0112028373,
-0.0769959316,
0.0122319805,
0.0087497141,
0.0178859252,
-0.0361183956,
-0.0051882495,
-0.0184740536,
-0.0131450053,
-0.0051667639,
-0.0089971153,
-0.0341696106,
0.0228384361,
-0.0085484907,
-0.0040996741,
0.0346379429,
-0.0227216613,
-0.0270088296,
-0.0235507432,
-0.0036147572,
-0.0060950709,
0.0024337613,
-0.0067089144,
-0.044761274,
0.0323639736,
0.032288935,
-0.0351934247,
0.0012330523,
0.0011698315,
0.0284359436,
-0.0737821385,
-0.0182475522,
0.0801772773,
0.0706892014,
-0.0386293791,
-0.0120336087,
-0.0232456215,
0.0468667299,
-0.0016022949,
0.0619163178,
0.035487324,
0.0862025693,
0.0128446156,
0.0143946046,
0.0404865369,
-0.0287306011,
-0.0701971278,
-0.0586685985,
0.0298842732,
0.0283061806,
0.040019054,
-0.050437741,
0.0042156428,
-0.0289507955,
0.0012663407,
-0.021380797,
0.0123306643,
0.0072505232,
-0.0403175391,
-0.0577280931,
-0.0026301479,
-0.0210163184,
0.0104541443,
0.078760393,
-0.043399293,
0.048671402,
-0.0101925628,
-0.0620512813,
-0.0128453523,
-0.037750192,
0.0368503518,
0.0453968123,
-0.0195648298,
-0.0010546289,
-0.0675017387,
-0.0756867453,
-0.0283959918,
0.0134375831,
0.0402436294,
-0.0060013621,
0.0263585094,
0.0263012499,
-0.0270095076,
0.0172399543,
-0.0342040397,
0.0319329984,
-0.0838062614,
-0.0101565113,
-0.0066173081,
-5.956550198e-33,
-0.0077179587,
-0.012064687,
0.0236031599,
0.0695580319,
-0.0179712996,
-0.0126974573,
-0.0447117426,
0.0147081399,
-0.0403727777,
-0.0429823138,
-0.0059382436,
0.0047856951,
0.0075478763,
-0.0079035889,
0.0345250741,
-0.0268019959,
0.006765259,
-0.0080891745,
-0.0393358096,
0.0207529292,
0.0864407122,
0.012824662,
0.0423696525,
-0.0577278472,
0.0506758839,
-0.0213594623,
0.0063263751,
-0.0378172472,
-0.0163815524,
0.0461464114,
-0.0416135788,
0.0012922996,
0.0201712027,
-0.0065981927,
0.0236122049,
-0.0102462173,
-0.0573019646,
-0.0236121006,
0.012797893,
0.0217844453,
0.0611830875,
-0.0382154956,
0.0076454626,
-0.0265154131,
-0.0136780618,
0.0300752409,
0.0465301797,
-0.0475898087,
0.0018872173,
-0.0035061343,
-0.00967394,
0.0026334878,
-0.009434022,
0.0214322116,
-0.0007326124,
0.0154051064,
0.0127603766,
0.0032365306,
-0.0642514378,
0.0350260474,
0.0311567206,
-0.0222815126,
0.050269179,
0.0173274446,
0.0039033061,
0.0550857447,
0.0249118172,
0.0055277497,
0.00245769,
0.0074162148,
0.0637600124,
0.0160031971,
0.007937829,
0.0452720895,
0.0207134373,
-0.0383505002,
-0.0263024773,
0.0354457498,
0.0533112176,
-0.0343247205,
-0.0087186899,
0.0057013556,
-0.0584956408,
-0.0135302981,
0.0231303275,
-0.0069084573,
-0.0292813741,
-0.021652054,
0.0168416202,
-0.0206442717,
-0.0328478888,
-0.0164674409,
0.0540243648,
-0.0545111522,
-0.0226397552,
0.0016677469,
-0.0348300487,
0.0202644281,
-0.0136072915,
-0.0093616508,
-0.0920744911,
-0.0111256037,
-0.0030349956,
0.0152541902,
0.0268108398,
0.0211985428,
0.0239809379,
0.0586846061,
-0.0313940533,
0.0034790549,
-0.0166452061,
-0.0273532737,
0.0394304991,
-0.0245689936,
0.039803151,
0.0267966501,
0.0161068197,
-0.0142125711,
0.0327113159,
-0.0034315044,
-0.0519081801,
-0.0654929727,
-0.0213176683,
-0.0537078902,
-0.0291026458,
-0.034524329,
0.0276168436,
0.0365079567,
0.0307636615,
-0.0557734631,
-0.0010340689,
0.0049316045,
2.668e-7,
0.0078432839,
-0.0288097244,
-0.0020427448,
0.0238853581,
-0.0169389676,
0.0127830319,
-0.0393914431,
0.0420653522,
0.0164331477,
-0.047794275,
0.023990985,
-0.0015757779,
0.0602020286,
0.0573671237,
-0.1023402885,
-0.0517727025,
-0.0159129035,
-0.0301407445,
-0.0759674385,
0.0232330728,
-0.0203908812,
0.0648193583,
0.0656443164,
-0.0122793652,
-0.0118766185,
-0.0154949231,
0.0713557824,
-0.0369107611,
-0.0199279841,
0.0008528681,
0.0464975648,
0.0341770425,
-0.0324068516,
0.018285526,
-0.0124350023,
0.0222082045,
0.0473146997,
0.0145387081,
0.078115657,
-0.0006122898,
-0.0338740572,
-0.0064258222,
-0.0004378728,
-0.0213446245,
0.065810971,
0.0452632345,
-0.0169055164,
0.0315986089,
0.0095532443,
-0.009940966,
0.0297740772,
0.0139832208,
0.0194118768,
-0.0060163666,
-0.0194903817,
-0.0271875188,
0.036819648,
-0.0649657175,
0.033891432,
-0.028570883,
-0.0314596556,
-0.0904004946,
0.0050079422,
-0.0314862169,
-0.01170428,
-0.0543435663,
0.0136965774,
2.213450352e-34,
0.030214591,
-0.030969264,
-0.0259706881,
-0.0060471301,
0.0410010517,
-0.0175083876,
0.0455489159,
-0.0111709824,
0.0080567421,
-0.0527795926,
-0.0181952789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00090v1 | NLNDE at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Adaptive Pretraining and Source Language Selection for Low-Resource Multilingual Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-28T21:02:58 | 2023-04-28T21:02:58 | Mingyang Wang, Heike Adel, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our system developed for the SemEval-2023 Task 12
"Sentiment Analysis for Low-resource African Languages using Twitter Dataset".
Sentiment analysis is one of the most widely studied applications in natural
language processing. However, most prior work still focuses on a small number
of high-resource languages. Building reliable sentiment analysis systems for
low-resource languages remains challenging, due to the limited training data in
this task. In this work, we propose to leverage language-adaptive and
task-adaptive pretraining on African texts and study transfer learning with
source language selection on top of an African language-centric pretrained
language model. Our key findings are: (1) Adapting the pretrained model to the
target language and task using a small yet relevant corpus improves performance
remarkably by more than 10 F1 score points. (2) Selecting source languages with
positive transfer gains during training can avoid harmful interference from
dissimilar languages, leading to better results in multilingual and
cross-lingual settings. In the shared task, our system wins 8 out of 15 tracks
and, in particular, performs best in the multilingual evaluation. | [
0.0328996852,
0.1030717418,
0.0004600679,
0.0505825169,
-0.0039922721,
0.0461459495,
0.0178323574,
-0.016251361,
-0.0154495202,
-0.0165840425,
-0.0584577136,
-0.0637784973,
-0.0194471721,
0.0085520204,
-0.0050136354,
-0.0328366905,
0.0247452017,
0.0074397475,
0.0286745597,
-0.015605988,
0.0061572995,
0.0403774977,
0.0083023086,
-0.0205981974,
-0.0221066512,
0.0162727684,
0.0144715235,
-0.011612026,
-0.0021163926,
-0.0164777655,
0.0140658524,
0.0269174036,
-0.0308114029,
-0.0142709948,
0.0000021073,
-0.0422102623,
-0.0505274534,
-0.0250542145,
0.0077937166,
-0.0180625431,
0.0880851001,
-0.0400277451,
-0.0031018604,
0.0120941103,
-0.0595836639,
-0.0014153386,
0.0773002505,
0.0301992036,
0.0738576874,
0.0992462412,
-0.0312085208,
0.0166943595,
-0.02187315,
-0.0312047638,
0.0069071795,
-0.0529710241,
0.0394536443,
-0.0083653051,
-0.0283069257,
0.0031846329,
-0.0111019537,
-0.0069074915,
-0.023456648,
-0.0066352501,
0.0187567174,
-0.0511941575,
-0.0366926976,
-0.02996324,
-0.0186553113,
0.0346111357,
-0.016758021,
-0.0053618713,
-0.0290281475,
0.0092060752,
-0.0254857428,
-0.0350090265,
-0.0462292805,
-0.0160515122,
0.0308646113,
0.0611580834,
0.0232958272,
0.0575527288,
0.037261419,
0.0177921541,
-0.0444442071,
0.0631200373,
-0.0150150238,
-0.0119244717,
0.0646842867,
0.1019623652,
0.0123642627,
0.0072158887,
0.0206598621,
-0.0281077791,
-0.0083801588,
-0.0104931584,
0.0069929291,
-0.0437811613,
-0.0219142903,
-0.065878503,
0.0312198084,
0.017649347,
-0.0286061745,
0.0456798412,
-0.0391126648,
-0.0375975333,
-0.0114743318,
-0.0046186876,
-0.0221699439,
-0.0499952585,
-0.044777941,
0.017748246,
0.0085877487,
0.0273227263,
-0.0213631932,
0.041687794,
-0.0548923016,
-0.0207026973,
-0.032925114,
-0.0523968562,
0.0058770753,
-0.0314497612,
-0.0012434986,
-0.0134293279,
0.0163342766,
0.0595776662,
-0.0122706406,
0.0500079654,
-0.0495960042,
-0.0647325888,
-0.0054467269,
0.0113843828,
0.0063046063,
-0.0243531037,
0.0325341783,
0.0416789725,
-0.0082714669,
-0.0270344354,
-0.081328921,
0.0174541976,
-0.0095185284,
-0.0597768687,
0.0041635339,
-0.0556344986,
0.0510552898,
0.0105134593,
0.0494296998,
-0.0023686746,
-0.007879369,
-0.0102711301,
-0.0298137236,
0.0395867713,
-0.0373158641,
0.0023015649,
-0.0119661344,
-0.0084062899,
0.0293671433,
0.0649870485,
0.008742434,
0.0341790356,
0.0454402156,
-0.0021121085,
-0.0677784756,
0.0318403617,
0.0267512016,
-0.0017623401,
-0.0131911961,
0.0038586902,
-0.0159692336,
-0.0480190255,
0.0183085669,
0.0015977892,
0.0216744598,
0.0128149772,
0.0422697477,
0.0146881295,
0.0005229879,
0.0577856191,
0.0028086239,
-0.0207209308,
-0.0002219454,
-0.0142917316,
0.0105025666,
0.0359848998,
-0.0283003766,
-0.055723805,
0.0312742479,
0.0531481653,
-0.0316236839,
-0.0174398273,
0.0508582443,
-0.0322817154,
0.0148854619,
0.0051227347,
0.0698681623,
0.0184156001,
-0.0318286382,
0.0116890287,
0.087307699,
-0.0787465945,
-0.0116825327,
-0.0460605696,
0.0328567475,
0.0260180626,
-0.0208980031,
0.0090402039,
0.0031598564,
-0.014288146,
0.0386945754,
0.0314313807,
0.0271665957,
0.0053545856,
0.0609883107,
-0.0501746275,
0.0027822899,
0.0012331899,
0.0102974204,
0.0358184315,
-0.0046695722,
0.086294286,
-0.0238347799,
-0.0092412187,
-0.0385899805,
0.0099910004,
-0.0142415473,
-0.002335248,
0.0403132178,
0.0012760697,
0.0626450032,
0.0250225533,
-0.0126796439,
-0.0209406391,
-0.0208251216,
-0.0629895627,
-0.0101643465,
0.05108371,
-0.0575097874,
-0.0275107101,
0.0161862727,
-0.0312574208,
-0.0058009163,
0.0707415864,
-0.0256155133,
-0.0238847788,
0.0830678344,
0.0221073609,
0.0246495586,
-0.0110471454,
-0.0122730248,
-0.0392031223,
0.0411907844,
0.0307990108,
0.0095852623,
0.0625989065,
-0.0271834154,
-0.0301469509,
-0.0416618548,
0.0414876677,
0.0265344344,
-0.0234897062,
0.0325684547,
-0.0123840105,
-0.004503401,
0.0159689952,
0.0433296524,
-0.0195282511,
-0.014747804,
-0.077381663,
0.0037171105,
-0.0237174798,
0.0247652549,
-0.0033575853,
0.0573221482,
-0.0119643155,
0.0021387869,
-0.0146312052,
0.0195128173,
0.0056291162,
-0.0024499332,
0.018178964,
-0.0160267167,
0.0756026134,
-0.0575802363,
0.0037173298,
0.0406178683,
0.0346768685,
0.0063989731,
-0.0455112383,
0.0003242683,
0.0318934917,
-0.0153966118,
-0.0108814817,
0.0201242752,
-0.0373209603,
-0.0125783915,
-0.0360994004,
-0.0113382908,
0.0012378924,
-0.0157268103,
0.0125165768,
0.0099529447,
-0.0146953091,
-0.0007055641,
0.0187313538,
-0.0222317893,
0.0006326919,
-0.0059181172,
-0.0227839947,
0.0111885276,
0.0704269335,
-0.0002547568,
-0.0269867349,
-0.0414408073,
-0.0154843004,
-0.0272817519,
-0.0167932268,
-0.0046365215,
0.0246314965,
0.0173816271,
0.0110375695,
0.0022744315,
-0.0050370237,
0.0632152036,
0.0280091651,
-0.0106771495,
-0.0781522095,
-0.0130385188,
-0.0300175436,
0.0166840069,
-0.0381954275,
-0.0041748886,
-0.0163650773,
0.0470559523,
0.0040348703,
0.0014205577,
0.0334120058,
-0.0073260609,
0.0152395004,
0.0128103094,
0.01706459,
-0.0065805423,
-0.0501560457,
0.0202388167,
-0.0555370525,
-0.044428736,
-0.0165031068,
0.0409618802,
0.0004695914,
-0.0211366508,
0.0020403326,
0.0091800913,
-0.0217421502,
0.0083954465,
-0.0076742801,
0.0305044334,
0.0251956936,
0.0040112771,
-0.0100290002,
0.0294162184,
-0.0348048992,
-0.0057018441,
0.0338680372,
0.0014791883,
-0.035406597,
-0.0096592521,
-0.0128714573,
0.0392911956,
-0.0013165521,
0.0130462274,
-0.0416540094,
0.0563578084,
0.002286854,
0.0172411948,
0.0785414726,
-0.0001218977,
-0.0476173125,
0.0026234903,
-0.0274361204,
0.0055499412,
-0.0275243949,
0.0267022308,
-0.0596945733,
-0.0369337611,
-0.0346286483,
-0.0016753997,
-0.0040022731,
-0.0239192564,
-0.027970409,
-0.1095393598,
-0.0032792771,
0.0107704122,
-0.0359146744,
-0.0347355492,
-0.0572488792,
-0.013379625,
-0.0438999832,
0.0035940774,
-0.0554121807,
0.0140383663,
0.0010660287,
0.0361313373,
-0.0252828151,
-0.0648426339,
0.0266215485,
0.0003902402,
0.0319290422,
0.0341862887,
0.0229527298,
-0.0219271667,
0.0096197622,
0.0005737971,
-0.0383382589,
-0.0215778332,
-0.0483639464,
0.0405839756,
0.0184950214,
-0.0581585541,
-0.0008397298,
-0.0295709316,
-0.0574242547,
0.0252142325,
0.0128880115,
0.064651683,
0.0284960791,
-0.0525081865,
-0.0240695141,
0.00367637,
0.0485171191,
0.0406726487,
0.0078714248,
-0.0864537582,
-0.0277077276,
-0.0007522259,
-0.0057344306,
-0.0857833624,
-0.0234716795,
0.0049914047,
-0.0265869927,
-0.0268374737,
-0.0693246126,
-0.0530429371,
-0.0065055485,
0.0074361083,
-0.0159125198,
-0.0148026934,
0.0283401515,
-0.0165618975,
-0.0194688048,
0.0332790688,
-0.01385104,
0.0069987946,
0.0046454696,
-0.023164548,
0.044934839,
-0.00696646,
0.0261103138,
-0.0364274643,
-0.0704926923,
-0.0272271708,
-0.0020210077,
0.0473085195,
0.0077327825,
0.0129499622,
0.008157311,
-0.0433930904,
-0.0097382423,
0.0224829614,
-0.0275411028,
0.0019228385,
0.0707858279,
0.0421615243,
0.0026965754,
0.058849588,
0.0196278077,
0.0795381442,
0.056243062,
0.0010989974,
-0.0093187895,
-0.0275861695,
-0.030874785,
-0.0240211096,
0.0465577915,
0.0139710763,
-0.0766824633,
-0.0477141477,
-0.0014865748,
0.0174870212,
0.0143863857,
-0.0572236553,
-0.0254789144,
0.0258628726,
0.006122028,
-0.0596357062,
0.0040148618,
-0.0333685353,
-0.0130336406,
-0.0439599343,
0.0631295219,
0.0608495735,
0.0114293136,
0.012330059,
0.0561283454,
-0.0002245632,
-0.0199938305,
0.0409028493,
0.0092411675,
-0.0281705521,
-0.0106462091,
0.0050829491,
0.0159848724,
0.0380066596,
-0.0086131683,
0.0090194987,
0.0572104044,
-0.0421988405,
-0.0051999646,
0.0531715602,
-0.057831604,
0.117889002,
0.0238797814,
-0.0082341526,
-0.0116370926,
0.0214048009,
-0.030171942,
0.0088103991,
-0.0006036778,
-0.0275740027,
-0.0017231127,
0.0600250699,
0.0564756878,
-0.0492329411,
0.0226985104,
0.0501309894,
0.0201379582,
-0.0170240141,
-0.0130907586,
0.0420988947,
-0.02446834,
0.0105538834,
0.0649798736,
-0.0302302036,
-0.0601563714,
0.0525545105,
-0.0773430392,
-0.0140275853,
0.0205818694,
0.0205253977,
0.043412663,
-0.0037981272,
0.0721107796,
-0.0363314785,
-0.0278552081,
-0.0045688599,
-0.0129668368,
0.0159288533,
-6.692404519e-33,
0.0116698425,
0.0302891098,
-0.040124286,
-0.0144290486,
-0.011204361,
-0.0296809543,
-0.0354196839,
0.0188224744,
-0.0561300479,
0.0400635079,
-0.0240566581,
-0.0073584151,
0.0184548087,
0.0710076317,
0.0348364711,
0.0236332901,
0.0178673547,
0.0228983499,
-0.0110876011,
0.0432318076,
0.0384499021,
0.0798693821,
0.0854801536,
-0.1037716717,
0.0387238339,
-0.0150426477,
-0.0331173167,
-0.0179580953,
0.0823329166,
0.0327439718,
-0.029295817,
0.065008074,
0.0352000035,
-0.0426575877,
-0.0036552306,
0.0179604236,
-0.0316146091,
-0.0524553992,
0.0053401468,
0.0197364986,
-0.0133212321,
-0.0285226554,
0.0051427567,
0.007748411,
-0.0069520054,
0.0089167282,
0.0210662652,
-0.0422894098,
0.0043366603,
-0.0217483863,
-0.1024037153,
0.0454493277,
0.0217599832,
0.0037370713,
0.0350310206,
0.0696813166,
-0.0246399567,
-0.0136705628,
-0.0296966285,
0.0212243162,
-0.0507654808,
0.0220287275,
-0.0163879432,
-0.0114888055,
-0.0678567588,
0.0390626788,
0.0098574711,
-0.0037449938,
0.0395037271,
0.0293357316,
0.0146848056,
-0.0035802976,
0.0377334915,
0.0949803591,
0.0154726487,
-0.0592602007,
-0.0819737986,
0.002041549,
0.0532318167,
-0.0042625964,
0.0137238251,
-0.0124357669,
0.0035271277,
-0.0316048712,
0.0474413782,
-0.0242952798,
-0.0070280242,
-0.0192443337,
0.0159364212,
-0.0269066375,
-0.0105290385,
0.0240107086,
0.0209882949,
-0.0421945006,
-0.0446959287,
0.0192540847,
-0.0458988696,
0.0124586113,
0.0140545964,
0.0168856885,
-0.0811662301,
-0.020496726,
-0.0343069956,
0.0387823805,
-0.0045220293,
-0.018855894,
0.0726734623,
0.0502270833,
-0.0821711868,
0.0015783949,
-0.032507576,
0.041034285,
-0.0053780507,
0.0817082077,
-0.0184688084,
-0.0140617108,
-0.0058779279,
0.0723388642,
0.0083757844,
-0.0196291748,
0.0379131399,
-0.0101593425,
0.0134151801,
-0.0150118582,
-0.0580232851,
-0.0320797376,
-0.0120483385,
0.0027567756,
-0.0242917072,
-0.0470182411,
-0.008310074,
-0.0062236567,
2.807e-7,
0.0207093377,
0.0292274859,
-0.0262369346,
-0.0762452558,
0.0005577293,
0.0454673022,
-0.037377283,
0.0142821688,
-0.0060910806,
0.0525347441,
0.0018900046,
0.0157706887,
0.0927709341,
0.0376345143,
-0.0690186918,
-0.0276185479,
-0.0279201083,
-0.0127942581,
-0.0244219527,
-0.0050554057,
0.0088012377,
0.1311281919,
0.0080387006,
-0.0286236033,
-0.0617324673,
-0.0510713086,
0.0604637153,
-0.0535448231,
-0.0219212938,
-0.0000866847,
-0.0091451686,
0.039283663,
-0.0563934371,
-0.0212790444,
-0.053679958,
0.030677665,
0.0174323358,
0.0679920092,
0.0201943293,
-0.0084845684,
0.0370784737,
0.0431961566,
-0.0053755064,
-0.0004833979,
0.0562879369,
-0.0226078182,
-0.0719706863,
-0.0732970089,
0.0180952996,
0.0062381886,
0.0382780321,
-0.0235319436,
-0.022648057,
0.0062978417,
0.0386454538,
-0.0157585703,
-0.097176902,
-0.04598625,
0.0132993432,
0.0226703696,
-0.0099970857,
-0.0054943482,
0.0191838946,
0.0307302494,
0.0393671878,
-0.0179779027,
0.0769957229,
2.027761275e-34,
0.0312938429,
-0.0363532603,
0.0256231818,
0.0019557413,
-0.0239509847,
0.0012308799,
-0.0163715184,
-0.0209848061,
0.0130068082,
0.0039312528,
0.0310864598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00076v1 | HausaNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 10: Transfer Learning, Synthetic Data and Side-Information for Multi-Level Sexism Classification | 2023-04-28T20:03:46 | 2023-04-28T20:03:46 | Saminu Mohammad Aliyu, Idris Abdulmumin, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Aliyu Yusuf, Falalu Ibrahim Lawan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the findings of our participation in the SemEval-2023 Task 10:
Explainable Detection of Online Sexism (EDOS) task, a shared task on offensive
language (sexism) detection on English Gab and Reddit dataset. We investigated
the effects of transferring two language models: XLM-T (sentiment
classification) and HateBERT (same domain -- Reddit) for multi-level
classification into Sexist or not Sexist, and other subsequent
sub-classifications of the sexist data. We also use synthetic classification of
unlabelled dataset and intermediary class information to maximize the
performance of our models. We submitted a system in Task A, and it ranked 49th
with F1-score of 0.82. This result showed to be competitive as it only
under-performed the best system by 0.052% F1-score. | [
0.0562235489,
0.0952729806,
-0.0255134515,
0.0381892063,
-0.019282544,
0.0567045175,
0.0603202879,
0.0088830683,
0.0094994698,
-0.0864041299,
-0.0113265794,
-0.0293101333,
-0.0128246704,
0.0343690589,
0.0119193196,
-0.0174508244,
0.0384776182,
0.0228092521,
0.0080251545,
-0.0386200249,
0.0353035592,
0.0119668199,
0.0029266244,
0.0114729786,
0.0030198556,
-0.0091903061,
0.0570484847,
0.012796171,
0.0217992365,
0.0369173735,
0.0867760777,
0.0438185669,
-0.0000857655,
0.0393964276,
0.0000018142,
-0.0676833391,
-0.0157478433,
0.0269814469,
0.0016878748,
-0.0594569668,
0.0557349175,
-0.0343207419,
-0.0067532663,
0.0642567351,
-0.0122778127,
-0.0038731662,
0.051858481,
0.0475215986,
0.0762596577,
0.0652135834,
-0.0212445147,
-0.031741403,
-0.0241414644,
0.002578452,
-0.0015978339,
0.0216418859,
0.0576154068,
-0.0272328071,
-0.0481363721,
0.0392860062,
-0.010931124,
-0.0183486212,
-0.0203041863,
-0.0081073409,
0.0274263937,
-0.0138165029,
-0.0322569385,
-0.0194045939,
0.0283105504,
0.055111371,
-0.0036328312,
-0.0025933746,
0.0153636681,
0.0184396654,
0.0029118177,
-0.0128730889,
-0.0405417457,
0.0086261686,
-0.0258095041,
0.0321911275,
0.0214607753,
-0.0008840935,
0.0458468124,
0.075967513,
0.0243977327,
0.0469913483,
-0.0082646003,
-0.0377113223,
0.0436735004,
0.0257146209,
0.02463324,
-0.0026533152,
0.0278129317,
-0.0092310216,
0.0115395468,
0.0091149937,
-0.0223074369,
-0.0224164724,
0.0189189222,
-0.1154874116,
0.011196061,
0.0402535647,
0.0177315846,
0.0425634608,
-0.0246497374,
0.0267048441,
-0.0026192651,
0.0354453102,
-0.005690129,
-0.0567932986,
-0.0595467873,
0.0154211773,
0.0197336264,
0.010801374,
0.0010493395,
0.0524721034,
-0.0490392596,
-0.0304453019,
-0.070147343,
-0.0735587999,
0.0092540234,
0.0019040222,
-0.0053799665,
0.0165011324,
-0.0065869028,
-0.0164321736,
-0.0246307496,
0.02469543,
-0.0531339198,
-0.0767598525,
-0.0158456396,
0.0257787444,
-0.0122779934,
-0.0287697241,
0.0261808913,
0.0587929301,
0.0306328982,
-0.013893377,
-0.0437202863,
0.0048055085,
-0.0149875022,
-0.0512522459,
0.0432468317,
-0.0625735521,
0.0300329383,
0.0210308861,
-0.0242454689,
-0.0251524132,
-0.0121640498,
0.0164550878,
-0.0547848046,
0.0763451904,
0.0171753112,
-0.0168436263,
0.0457591303,
0.0314900242,
-0.0459625535,
0.0843097866,
0.004598564,
0.0196247455,
0.0457330719,
-0.0043615457,
0.0135601135,
0.0228403043,
0.0483229086,
0.0394216962,
-0.0357023589,
0.0101414882,
-0.0208138172,
-0.0211231597,
0.0504537746,
-0.0163999796,
0.0388360359,
-0.0447413176,
0.0242688507,
0.0137164854,
0.0266505852,
0.0727165267,
0.0411148891,
-0.0144782402,
-0.0390653126,
-0.0057756025,
-0.0435580723,
0.0003936059,
-0.0421760194,
-0.0748313516,
0.011942341,
0.0116078593,
-0.0230296105,
-0.0440195352,
-0.0204095934,
-0.0187700223,
0.0188586954,
-0.0190806612,
0.0617725551,
0.0221910607,
-0.0059434064,
0.0266334303,
0.0640172362,
-0.0248266757,
0.011275976,
-0.0970681682,
0.0387613252,
0.056420546,
-0.0145330457,
-0.0289487652,
-0.0072223656,
-0.0663737208,
0.0040405584,
0.0351853892,
0.0242549293,
-0.0042072251,
0.0344117023,
-0.0188301541,
-0.0415568128,
0.0023016029,
0.0191901401,
0.0115546808,
0.0302810725,
0.0561150424,
0.005256651,
0.0218128581,
-0.0536760315,
0.0273104664,
0.0074599995,
-0.0168331284,
0.0151362354,
0.0002292614,
0.0646303222,
-0.0203197096,
-0.0327498652,
-0.0508569442,
-0.0152487876,
-0.0212393254,
-0.0577067882,
-0.0242578089,
-0.0068545104,
-0.0250252634,
0.0119989319,
-0.0388705246,
-0.0389867574,
0.0847584233,
-0.0249530897,
0.0357930474,
0.0574014746,
-0.0103001827,
-0.0190556534,
-0.0109033212,
-0.0337438844,
-0.0319343768,
0.0695041046,
-0.0015365266,
0.0576982349,
-0.014142151,
-0.01094676,
0.0176583435,
-0.0902407244,
-0.0068318881,
0.0096628917,
0.004049568,
-0.0056413282,
-0.0013076732,
-0.0022077425,
0.0048169522,
0.0037841098,
-0.0171009656,
-0.0059044897,
-0.0638389215,
-0.0072363163,
-0.0163113456,
-0.0141877132,
0.0184163861,
-0.0089604668,
-0.0002039166,
0.0292440001,
-0.0505072214,
0.006356929,
0.0253304839,
0.01691572,
0.0268674605,
-0.0706872419,
0.0308154542,
-0.0271618739,
-0.0203093886,
-0.016970126,
0.0578283295,
0.022522686,
-0.0451120809,
-0.0045214333,
0.0223039873,
-0.0346340351,
0.0079531157,
-0.0158026889,
-0.0504422858,
-0.0100278994,
0.0210015178,
-0.0182196572,
0.0495486706,
0.0600172393,
0.0698093474,
-0.0039506396,
0.0099344924,
-0.0389687456,
-0.0131436465,
0.0081636617,
0.0449147336,
0.0034496023,
-0.0438376144,
-0.0159852542,
0.0657075122,
0.0030310876,
-0.0232841484,
-0.0503662787,
0.0460418537,
-0.0242172126,
-0.0509134792,
-0.0140268533,
-0.0267707054,
0.0090785725,
-0.0103912093,
-0.0395470858,
-0.0701360926,
0.0422315598,
-0.0010201989,
0.0187375285,
-0.0085972408,
-0.04668051,
-0.0330299661,
0.0383071117,
-0.0323885269,
0.0219786931,
-0.0345141105,
0.0026719365,
-0.0092677632,
-0.0259773191,
0.0221531168,
-0.0303657707,
-0.0212999564,
-0.0173980612,
0.0118859261,
0.0055994312,
-0.0429533608,
-0.0506485179,
-0.03004306,
-0.0151298018,
-0.01748484,
-0.0148278847,
0.0091678826,
-0.0365066864,
0.0234016366,
-0.0388806537,
-0.0163533296,
-0.0250027794,
-0.0163142458,
0.049860239,
-0.0024768848,
0.0305325706,
0.0046271854,
0.0193727091,
-0.0154855335,
-0.0070180907,
0.0570547171,
-0.0475054011,
0.0221939832,
0.0122002801,
0.0079209441,
0.0631699041,
-0.0341372639,
-0.0125176273,
-0.0755847842,
0.0017285469,
-0.0311160069,
-0.0024971897,
0.0881871879,
-0.0018918907,
-0.0289917551,
0.0035704612,
0.0042310115,
-0.0393998735,
0.0035291736,
-0.001905508,
-0.0413673893,
-0.0131792948,
-0.0000294815,
0.0128539018,
-0.0617329292,
-0.0458993018,
-0.0122074895,
-0.1111472398,
0.0063355179,
-0.0039716931,
-0.0833475888,
-0.0539858602,
-0.0160170551,
0.0329847373,
-0.0185175221,
0.0087385848,
-0.0508544296,
0.0297663137,
0.0017170709,
0.0103985248,
-0.0434597768,
-0.0527808815,
0.0336059295,
-0.0357861444,
0.05918926,
0.0155916726,
0.0714544728,
-0.0270990133,
-0.0392830148,
0.0809334889,
-0.024033187,
-0.0064023109,
-0.0583924539,
0.0784306377,
-0.0591367222,
-0.0339937732,
-0.0395116247,
0.0353802815,
-0.0035655445,
0.0191305298,
-0.0003539946,
0.0493257344,
0.0418828465,
-0.0331691802,
-0.0802206025,
0.0110831577,
0.0103000058,
0.0847452506,
-0.0181238446,
-0.0446297489,
-0.0074091302,
-0.0476246327,
-0.0159446243,
0.0087261796,
-0.0469929762,
-0.009788082,
-0.0056365007,
-0.0337027311,
-0.0426180251,
-0.0345724188,
0.0122017385,
0.0073771244,
-0.0089558549,
-0.0349978395,
-0.0468757153,
0.0066853156,
-0.050213404,
0.0004700748,
-0.0109937936,
0.0302020721,
0.013368817,
-0.0526187532,
0.009607303,
-0.0246311296,
-0.0395708382,
0.0030059768,
-0.0088816313,
-0.0380224176,
0.0315102376,
0.0552544892,
0.0235502552,
0.0497316048,
-0.0138658583,
-0.0332900733,
0.0475542843,
0.0615006573,
-0.0281068347,
-0.0145628201,
0.0639959425,
0.0022770753,
0.0205265786,
0.0411867462,
-0.024865916,
0.0341830477,
0.0527036153,
-0.0518914163,
0.002977021,
0.0047773207,
-0.0247123931,
-0.00398373,
0.0342750847,
0.0298244804,
-0.0567437336,
-0.0451427959,
-0.0273150336,
0.0066593075,
-0.0263769422,
-0.0458416864,
0.0006207164,
0.0334663354,
0.0273551568,
-0.0596569777,
-0.0067322706,
-0.0394387655,
-0.0017944323,
-0.0406451449,
0.0073220539,
0.0364095941,
0.0591549948,
-0.0220999662,
0.0227425061,
-0.0238901097,
-0.0118620396,
0.0170066208,
-0.0108608603,
0.0014812838,
0.0273439921,
0.0095192809,
0.0460140444,
0.0012939664,
-0.0059856339,
-0.0108096991,
0.0003014244,
-0.0401177928,
0.0062513542,
-0.0035006644,
-0.0203540307,
0.0468418412,
0.026833605,
-0.0341517553,
0.0034540985,
0.0230981968,
-0.010407648,
0.0068065105,
0.0295625515,
0.0252288207,
-0.0155763803,
0.0109578166,
0.0431507081,
0.0199923124,
0.0243167561,
0.0165761486,
-0.0640900061,
-0.0015989597,
-0.0028400025,
0.0507304184,
-0.0203766078,
0.0267536342,
0.0204339214,
-0.0521999411,
-0.0489372015,
0.0076145134,
-0.0657429621,
0.0368938334,
0.0241515506,
0.0174153708,
0.0910291746,
-0.0022969276,
0.0051087118,
-0.0411193967,
-0.0210145731,
0.0096964557,
-0.0283725634,
0.0327453725,
-5.938186772e-33,
-0.0162340477,
-0.0181510597,
-0.044907473,
0.0032883787,
-0.0285045765,
-0.0023592587,
0.0168852098,
-0.0202006847,
0.008941819,
0.0348559059,
0.0388361141,
0.0542094596,
0.0045994944,
0.0108448714,
-0.0160935037,
-0.0404587723,
0.0342905223,
-0.0043422026,
-0.0159527604,
0.0008244966,
0.0127676288,
0.052924864,
0.0345911533,
-0.0737701282,
0.0719632134,
0.0013544137,
0.0014803673,
0.0150484033,
-0.0066835391,
0.0397653133,
-0.0239912905,
0.0910655633,
0.0567051917,
-0.0518772453,
0.0367756411,
0.0570256114,
-0.0566260479,
-0.013048037,
-0.0076407236,
0.028008556,
0.0220349561,
-0.0139649231,
0.0452159904,
0.0203636531,
-0.0200250372,
-0.0767363459,
0.0615737215,
-0.0369590819,
0.061664965,
-0.0421961285,
-0.0417231694,
0.0188604873,
-0.0295986701,
-0.0093882615,
-0.0019041351,
0.0614475533,
0.030133402,
0.0359657556,
-0.0590885878,
0.0257821772,
-0.0484890155,
-0.0316947438,
0.0285290293,
-0.0125444261,
0.0115086064,
0.0703766569,
0.0444158055,
0.0447276644,
-0.0258491263,
-0.0090459734,
0.0200026296,
0.0383289233,
0.0619627871,
0.0673893318,
0.053577479,
-0.0593777783,
-0.1020434797,
-0.0273988303,
0.0516613796,
-0.0405091755,
-0.0130206086,
-0.0411673188,
-0.0642074943,
-0.039743185,
0.0224486031,
-0.0804149359,
-0.0240908023,
-0.0354409516,
0.0095198844,
-0.0262546502,
-0.0565005653,
-0.032194782,
-0.0034492887,
-0.0548099056,
-0.0243814141,
0.0359064192,
-0.0094127227,
-0.0340039171,
0.0480698571,
-0.0024415778,
-0.0285256859,
-0.0123665603,
0.001875962,
0.0223713983,
0.0443293788,
0.0045977496,
0.0507573485,
0.0520554818,
-0.0714047328,
-0.0000985077,
-0.0577929132,
0.0243034959,
-0.0260386933,
0.079064846,
-0.0080766957,
0.0204479415,
-0.0071779923,
0.0290229525,
0.0334688053,
0.0317342319,
0.0013039875,
0.0252051149,
-0.0098320879,
0.0031741783,
-0.0180190112,
-0.0524820164,
0.0072332481,
-0.0141690103,
-0.0097361207,
-0.0833797753,
0.0040519205,
-0.0403529517,
2.612e-7,
0.0049461504,
0.0280319098,
-0.0275339466,
-0.0206301697,
0.0346178673,
0.0363422148,
0.0015307692,
0.0494465865,
0.0349869728,
0.020301111,
-0.0347515605,
0.0500677675,
0.0164816175,
0.0333977416,
-0.0410290509,
-0.028620081,
-0.0527179278,
-0.0010758411,
-0.0125735234,
0.0130835697,
0.0502621531,
0.0765350163,
0.0770089477,
-0.0459234044,
-0.003697803,
-0.0239236578,
0.0529942438,
-0.0347015671,
-0.0058466075,
-0.0244181175,
0.0060430993,
0.0191417448,
-0.0020938171,
0.0186649114,
-0.0091333035,
0.0054506157,
0.0359804779,
0.0422120243,
-0.0000468081,
0.0201010164,
0.0156387053,
-0.0038985091,
0.0057551726,
-0.0352159627,
0.0831476226,
-0.0136570595,
-0.0397025757,
-0.0498913117,
-0.0303908214,
-0.0319903828,
0.0727015063,
-0.0171454195,
0.009670889,
-0.0053715417,
0.021261204,
0.0072302823,
-0.0402027257,
-0.0663808659,
0.0151959667,
-0.0213226005,
-0.0301575735,
-0.0556708463,
0.0184021164,
0.0188653432,
0.0732886493,
0.0197364036,
0.0466933958,
1.939128771e-34,
-0.0021608328,
0.0077521047,
-0.0101293819,
-0.0301575456,
0.0059436751,
0.0187397432,
0.0326279514,
-0.0155715458,
0.0507855825,
0.023844406,
-0.0019641786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00061v1 | Explainable Verbal Reasoner Plus (EVR+): A Natural Language Reasoning Framework that Supports Diverse Compositional Reasoning | 2023-04-28T19:27:26 | 2023-04-28T19:27:26 | Zhengzhong Liang, Zeyu Zhang, Steven Bethard, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Languages models have been successfully applied to a variety of reasoning
tasks in NLP, yet the language models still suffer from compositional
generalization. In this paper we present Explainable Verbal Reasoner Plus
(EVR+), a reasoning framework that enhances language models' compositional
reasoning ability by (1) allowing the model to explicitly generate and execute
symbolic operators, and (2) allowing the model to decompose a complex task into
several simpler ones in a flexible manner. Compared with its predecessor
Explainable Verbal Reasoner (EVR) and other previous approaches adopting
similar ideas, our framework supports more diverse types of reasoning such as
nested loops and different types of recursion. To evaluate our reasoning
framework, we build a synthetic dataset with five tasks that require
compositional reasoning. Results show that our reasoning framework can enhance
the language model's compositional generalization performance on the five
tasks, using a fine-tuned language model. We also discussed the possibility and
the challenges to combine our reasoning framework with a few-shot prompted
language model. | [
0.046260763,
0.0702185556,
-0.0073392694,
0.0197642632,
-0.0202310495,
0.0537066385,
0.0542680845,
-0.0159096271,
-0.0188126098,
-0.0219301824,
0.0434654765,
0.0124988705,
-0.0219120197,
0.0408130214,
0.0162062291,
-0.0673907101,
0.0185505375,
-0.0274284575,
0.0415918566,
0.0198638998,
0.0153401848,
0.0687439442,
-0.014626801,
0.043375086,
0.0258329995,
0.0003157047,
-0.0326700956,
-0.0098897703,
-0.0042796503,
-0.0234200414,
-0.0120168496,
0.0048744502,
0.0500860699,
-0.0165262762,
0.0000021683,
-0.014402451,
-0.0085208584,
0.015161478,
-0.0416003242,
-0.0514657348,
0.0000029472,
0.0008226717,
0.0244237613,
0.025472533,
-0.00254512,
0.010837554,
0.0412753448,
0.085252516,
0.046705272,
0.0657605603,
-0.0195351969,
-0.0653107613,
-0.0346457623,
0.0112181194,
0.0488853082,
-0.0136877587,
-0.0172755141,
0.026458472,
0.0228002537,
-0.010238993,
-0.0057273135,
-0.0043150443,
0.0456299782,
-0.057141494,
0.0066098096,
-0.0053421804,
-0.0114740953,
-0.0432616621,
0.0103037832,
0.0528959893,
0.0017975663,
-0.0421438739,
0.0210778434,
-0.0225066263,
-0.0105583165,
0.0023045088,
-0.044722978,
0.033372961,
-0.0377113931,
0.0059020338,
0.0046441131,
0.0172811765,
0.0490148999,
0.0166785307,
-0.0285997298,
0.0822998658,
0.007711811,
0.0042700935,
-0.0023616957,
-0.0063340119,
0.0072575933,
-0.0836751461,
0.0113903387,
0.0973658189,
-0.0799098909,
0.0363950171,
0.0035566892,
0.0096578468,
0.0058680023,
-0.0075936085,
0.0158170313,
0.0492431596,
0.0203620698,
0.0571442433,
-0.0334243067,
0.0333625935,
-0.007862512,
0.0224927105,
-0.0054439735,
-0.0541881844,
-0.080843769,
-0.0466866195,
-0.0017965643,
0.0123155508,
-0.0098022847,
-0.0094041945,
-0.0006835969,
0.0371536948,
-0.0417736471,
0.0366288722,
0.026979506,
0.0392211452,
-0.0052784136,
-0.0519164465,
-0.0425114594,
-0.0000438044,
-0.0662013665,
0.0276478659,
0.0290344264,
-0.0077295545,
-0.0036791407,
-0.0060942685,
0.0231126118,
-0.0209988896,
-0.0059932373,
0.0536594279,
0.0266062226,
-0.0165026486,
-0.0345138423,
-0.0415010564,
0.0054920525,
-0.0605276749,
-0.0286868811,
-0.0533139631,
0.018746471,
-0.0061761322,
-0.016091371,
-0.0317357741,
0.0171571113,
0.0426220372,
-0.0182444919,
0.0869586319,
-0.0244369246,
0.0135617722,
-0.0168076549,
-0.0024231286,
-0.0065722885,
0.054683648,
0.0246278513,
-0.0086126598,
0.0126180602,
-0.0250476655,
0.0255956743,
-0.0619587488,
-0.0102921035,
-0.056219615,
-0.0165549312,
0.009671554,
-0.0955995172,
0.0163999852,
-0.0041453047,
0.0310186911,
-0.002378877,
0.0171650462,
-0.0059791235,
0.0332945026,
0.0345917046,
-0.026322823,
0.0869026184,
-0.0037460697,
-0.0359264128,
0.0179849882,
-0.0523110442,
0.0699959472,
-0.0362216234,
-0.0160644799,
-0.0270660035,
0.013475989,
-0.0243396536,
-0.077805832,
-0.0183199272,
0.0062182089,
0.0382243805,
0.0265712291,
0.050964836,
0.0330924727,
-0.0382147878,
0.0325265117,
0.0284432862,
-0.0725001618,
-0.0063166996,
-0.036557328,
0.0806880891,
0.0929438323,
0.0399419777,
-0.0215785503,
-0.017145412,
-0.0279911626,
0.0222840179,
0.0305580869,
0.0181183126,
-0.0038118204,
0.0307140797,
-0.0492211506,
-0.0362363532,
-0.0527168848,
0.0083264858,
0.0021442745,
0.001805917,
-0.0287828129,
0.0161873773,
-0.029915994,
-0.009808504,
0.0306265615,
0.0051816446,
-0.017704878,
-0.0068593589,
0.0190036912,
-0.0067982548,
0.0181949474,
0.0421520881,
0.0374978781,
-0.0065467511,
-0.015057967,
-0.077290982,
0.0231981315,
-0.0315840691,
-0.0604953542,
0.0019155113,
-0.0243697073,
-0.0259689167,
-0.0432625487,
-0.0612923875,
-0.0514023863,
0.0321152993,
-0.0106951622,
0.0258816052,
-0.0294878092,
0.0038228759,
-0.0072091874,
-0.0222690925,
-0.0134687982,
0.0658786893,
0.0357065275,
-0.0094751893,
0.0063342508,
0.009056489,
0.0166503657,
-0.0304956753,
0.0060200603,
0.0235017445,
-0.0272726957,
-0.0313562676,
0.0332575403,
-0.0058365623,
-0.0338924378,
-0.0126154209,
-0.0410033725,
0.0048394711,
-0.0175351277,
-0.0223856401,
0.0231846832,
0.020404771,
0.0515449233,
0.0123304222,
-0.0182725303,
0.0118373698,
0.0213725679,
0.0160967968,
0.0442404151,
-0.0300274398,
-0.0400270186,
-0.018858375,
-0.0147841536,
-0.0534614399,
0.0672071427,
0.0058572665,
0.0126197869,
-0.0440025143,
0.0086575439,
-0.0420734771,
-0.0081501892,
-0.0066648624,
0.0004548114,
0.0282399096,
-0.0151683912,
-0.0053579728,
0.0618811399,
0.0018505697,
0.0466511436,
0.0416518971,
-0.0107932594,
-0.0470816754,
0.0298492871,
-0.0200786497,
0.0061570727,
-0.0008376815,
-0.0282421578,
-0.0055876528,
0.0375650935,
-0.0067355954,
0.0141832288,
-0.074679032,
0.0604566894,
0.0140716014,
0.0126442388,
-0.0530730151,
-0.0687731504,
0.0076198112,
0.0741721466,
-0.0245177038,
-0.0197557863,
0.085281387,
-0.0019854873,
0.0013007141,
-0.007678411,
-0.0215211771,
-0.0576151237,
0.0781179145,
0.0080083907,
-0.0122997398,
0.0179119036,
-0.0194303673,
-0.0105688721,
-0.0436585546,
0.0235841833,
0.0009537914,
0.020313587,
-0.0376623683,
-0.0063273846,
0.0280748419,
-0.0204783902,
-0.0216168929,
0.0099650901,
-0.0522785783,
0.012110115,
-0.0068610758,
-0.0053341622,
-0.007449009,
-0.0013795118,
0.0127595235,
0.0110958954,
-0.0021708109,
-0.0196848381,
-0.0168733317,
-0.0066335886,
0.0290210564,
0.0133123519,
0.020176718,
0.0029494974,
0.0669593886,
0.0192294475,
-0.0107187284,
-0.026084302,
-0.0370951965,
0.0375126489,
-0.0157100558,
-0.0221894085,
0.0075913053,
0.0030370909,
0.0839226395,
-0.1039755121,
0.0109876534,
0.1255303025,
0.0333075263,
-0.0076751248,
0.0082708066,
-0.0394519567,
0.0104334718,
0.0479255244,
0.0539642684,
-0.0388090387,
-0.0398817658,
0.0256022774,
-0.0190520696,
-0.0211211517,
-0.0098977108,
-0.030961182,
-0.0958224982,
0.0400144793,
-0.0268830247,
-0.0191249605,
-0.0369639024,
-0.0472209379,
-0.0194530431,
-0.0126041286,
-0.0109541509,
0.0179691762,
0.009734882,
-0.0017068576,
0.0239970814,
-0.0466766246,
-0.0285816137,
0.0492871031,
-0.022896383,
0.0228271335,
0.0515883118,
0.0440683551,
0.0246777032,
-0.0223314296,
-0.0204032063,
0.0029543084,
0.0258976072,
-0.0077313902,
0.0507045463,
0.0296825022,
-0.0167399645,
-0.0368834138,
0.035776291,
-0.0456110388,
-0.0536091365,
-0.0091173137,
0.079453893,
-0.0149980504,
-0.0329475552,
-0.012784279,
0.0252307951,
-0.00481608,
0.0822054744,
0.0482365377,
0.0018132264,
-0.0445953421,
-0.055187162,
-0.0520077683,
-0.1060713604,
-0.014738054,
-0.0102432426,
0.0533308163,
-0.0107008899,
-0.0408041328,
-0.0369592011,
0.0527772419,
0.0322027467,
-0.0171524324,
-0.0132934172,
-0.0099516958,
-0.0413799249,
-0.0324450396,
0.0036647082,
0.023113938,
0.0397131927,
0.0169441327,
0.0084262639,
-0.0137679297,
-0.0268324558,
-0.0074790008,
-0.0403742045,
-0.0509271771,
-0.0445108004,
-0.0346747413,
0.0535656512,
0.0202110112,
0.0270766169,
-0.0304781441,
-0.0656442791,
-0.0109654218,
0.0131284948,
-0.0219916943,
-0.0507515483,
0.0590556934,
0.0017345998,
0.0393159091,
0.0468020774,
-0.0482228138,
-0.0010157122,
0.0088870628,
0.0338327102,
-0.0088447789,
0.0411769189,
0.0501907505,
-0.0125334961,
-0.002155595,
0.0089366194,
-0.0027185297,
-0.0346655808,
0.0013731774,
-0.0605310202,
-0.0481645539,
-0.0451998375,
0.060934525,
-0.0298005585,
-0.0073733614,
-0.0194902737,
-0.0704170465,
-0.0389697365,
0.0107512986,
0.0186737925,
0.0557544045,
0.0372248963,
-0.013519193,
-0.0171664264,
0.0329473466,
-0.0171178672,
0.0376102515,
-0.0349883549,
0.0306561943,
-0.0204499364,
0.0695550144,
0.017623445,
0.0138632981,
-0.0453260392,
-0.0370809697,
-0.0797321498,
-0.0621056072,
0.0401007272,
-0.0067504211,
0.0195122957,
-0.0307215881,
0.0049039237,
0.0117594413,
-0.0194625575,
0.0323443003,
0.0639586672,
0.0419724211,
-0.0561585091,
0.023670705,
0.0356132463,
-0.0266531408,
-0.0319059864,
0.0494522415,
-0.0375357419,
0.041653838,
0.0065792906,
0.0006746377,
-0.0292322896,
-0.00554991,
0.0144034,
0.0728375539,
0.0191821009,
-0.0001589725,
-0.039169915,
-0.0560796745,
-0.0194638874,
-0.0075450949,
-0.003244861,
0.0137138367,
0.0098362751,
0.0563030429,
0.004871571,
-0.0328596383,
-0.0487931147,
-0.0055738701,
-0.0070450818,
-0.0114192097,
-0.0322436504,
-6.39775437e-33,
-0.0151230143,
-0.0570942536,
0.0177382976,
-0.0172298979,
0.0259689391,
-0.0074425228,
-0.0757046118,
-0.0299140103,
-0.006963715,
0.0543673486,
-0.0192647055,
0.0413861424,
0.0025772238,
0.0244773217,
0.0257873815,
-0.0189562123,
0.0474004783,
0.0569864102,
-0.0213232487,
-0.0024432703,
0.0633018017,
0.0060695889,
0.0317224115,
-0.0366396978,
0.0261859428,
0.0461837128,
-0.0312930793,
0.030535439,
-0.0323744938,
0.0567916445,
0.0067052413,
0.0127018113,
0.0210693311,
-0.0266061351,
0.007074974,
0.0223584827,
-0.0802993774,
-0.0292688441,
0.0329317302,
-0.0098088086,
-0.0585685521,
-0.0512776002,
0.0144748297,
-0.0269166958,
0.0181286782,
-0.0370107666,
0.0403234921,
-0.0131526198,
-0.0000655465,
-0.0294209253,
-0.063178122,
0.0227190647,
-0.0500782877,
-0.0247117374,
-0.0059994729,
0.0427592769,
-0.0133651346,
0.0516706593,
-0.0138914576,
0.0025961993,
-0.0070281914,
-0.0234763119,
0.045442462,
-0.0418216847,
-0.027737651,
0.0659985319,
0.0031564373,
-0.0082387095,
-0.100705348,
0.0647259802,
-0.0514170155,
0.0830367878,
0.0890666097,
0.0294910911,
0.0493637994,
0.0313858688,
-0.0387207977,
0.00995823,
-0.0321882218,
0.0621872991,
0.0365914628,
0.0351426341,
-0.0304141026,
-0.0262604691,
-0.029520141,
-0.0239053778,
-0.0484564714,
-0.0380940288,
0.027882196,
-0.0157927815,
-0.0492012016,
-0.0153463986,
-0.0025384258,
-0.0537062138,
0.0209982581,
0.056215018,
-0.0094365748,
-0.0167690888,
0.0156742912,
0.0107082343,
0.0054021804,
0.0152792651,
0.0395383872,
0.0321438238,
0.0329039358,
0.0112706712,
0.044347506,
0.0231728777,
-0.0461844429,
-0.0078817932,
-0.086918734,
-0.0074976697,
-0.049808573,
0.0252922885,
0.0195799246,
0.0535367839,
-0.0327604264,
0.0496097617,
-0.0089102285,
-0.0205067452,
-0.0136622703,
-0.003713456,
-0.0265443772,
0.025691241,
0.0005665614,
-0.0391677991,
-0.0165142994,
-0.0274468642,
0.0404229313,
-0.0464977808,
-0.0066127852,
0.0156625193,
2.76e-7,
0.0339388549,
0.0526830107,
0.0010693681,
0.02458225,
0.0032767511,
0.0185133796,
0.0212124176,
-0.0443691574,
-0.025512537,
-0.0179839786,
0.001176147,
0.0314281322,
0.0429870673,
0.0305279624,
-0.0124682616,
0.0263678636,
-0.0676768646,
-0.0466898642,
-0.0370600037,
-0.0101513872,
0.1089478433,
0.0718145967,
0.0547731668,
-0.011105665,
0.0240129251,
-0.0271888878,
0.0147576397,
-0.0063467533,
0.0160291307,
-0.0047133197,
0.0324529447,
0.0132327536,
0.0346735194,
-0.0087387832,
-0.0183405504,
-0.0038034916,
-0.0215048753,
0.054604765,
-0.0151950056,
-0.0237310696,
-0.0383491069,
-0.0329184942,
0.030819159,
-0.0552879237,
0.0963899419,
-0.0372458696,
-0.0309635289,
0.0012748345,
-0.024795061,
0.0027375091,
-0.0111982999,
0.0051717088,
-0.0064158286,
0.0126742525,
-0.0009045719,
-0.0298777297,
-0.0024927582,
-0.112878263,
-0.0441326313,
-0.0122704301,
0.0125935078,
0.0620135181,
-0.018119717,
0.0113332514,
0.0377514586,
-0.0238197166,
-0.0308078844,
2.644335613e-34,
0.0202341862,
0.0236028153,
0.015695883,
0.0054035801,
0.0948218554,
0.032964427,
-0.0638179481,
0.0039676814,
0.0556860901,
-0.0550507158,
-0.0303807948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00050v2 | Causal Reasoning and Large Language Models: Opening a New Frontier for Causality | 2023-04-28T19:00:43 | 2023-05-08T17:54:45 | Emre Kıcıman, Robert Ness, Amit Sharma, Chenhao Tan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG, stat.ME | The causal capabilities of large language models (LLMs) is a matter of
significant debate, with critical implications for the use of LLMs in
societally impactful domains such as medicine, science, law, and policy. We
further our understanding of LLMs and their causal implications, considering
the distinctions between different types of causal reasoning tasks, as well as
the entangled threats of construct and measurement validity. LLM-based methods
establish new state-of-the-art accuracies on multiple causal benchmarks.
Algorithms based on GPT-3.5 and 4 outperform existing algorithms on a pairwise
causal discovery task (97%, 13 points gain), counterfactual reasoning task
(92%, 20 points gain), and actual causality (86% accuracy in determining
necessary and sufficient causes in vignettes). At the same time, LLMs exhibit
unpredictable failure modes and we provide some techniques to interpret their
robustness.
Crucially, LLMs perform these causal tasks while relying on sources of
knowledge and methods distinct from and complementary to non-LLM based
approaches. Specifically, LLMs bring capabilities so far understood to be
restricted to humans, such as using collected knowledge to generate causal
graphs or identifying background causal context from natural language. We
envision LLMs to be used alongside existing causal methods, as a proxy for
human domain knowledge and to reduce human effort in setting up a causal
analysis, one of the biggest impediments to the widespread adoption of causal
methods. We also see existing causal methods as promising tools for LLMs to
formalize, validate, and communicate their reasoning especially in high-stakes
scenarios.
In capturing common sense and domain knowledge about causal mechanisms and
supporting translation between natural language and formal methods, LLMs open
new frontiers for advancing the research, practice, and adoption of causality. | [
0.0000543611,
0.0842932537,
-0.0193686709,
0.0071440255,
-0.0408237204,
0.0076607307,
0.0121804401,
0.0283046588,
0.03656983,
-0.0315849558,
0.088054575,
0.017956635,
-0.0101507045,
0.0063940161,
0.0428756401,
-0.0257039424,
0.0307783727,
-0.0175771508,
0.0470484756,
-0.000470588,
-0.0251418464,
-0.0041575101,
-0.0015368649,
0.0361156538,
-0.0328626335,
0.0196126532,
0.0260988809,
-0.0021123921,
-0.002446291,
-0.0470311195,
-0.0227342229,
0.0417722315,
0.0467784442,
0.0473331623,
0.0000023324,
-0.054895509,
-0.0141216433,
0.0198995974,
-0.0150512159,
0.0116513027,
-0.0353005528,
-0.0122055011,
0.0299017187,
0.0255022757,
-0.0228333436,
0.0059554833,
0.0305262432,
0.0224212203,
-0.0040013329,
0.0595047586,
-0.0231879465,
-0.0655889511,
0.0276737381,
-0.0211179946,
0.0217646081,
-0.0016237339,
0.0605592541,
0.0408675745,
0.0256195609,
-0.0198689438,
-0.0272833761,
0.0027077966,
0.034540005,
0.0148151284,
-0.0071329665,
0.0003694316,
0.0157107785,
-0.0155311525,
0.0379742458,
0.0684311017,
0.0813328549,
-0.0288652722,
0.0431443974,
-0.0181466062,
0.0057329778,
0.1000041515,
-0.0629040301,
0.0238800347,
-0.0263296049,
0.0076976772,
0.0347699933,
0.0143159106,
0.0732585937,
0.0499099568,
-0.028954085,
0.1004441455,
0.0183100849,
-0.03084586,
-0.0289624874,
0.0330200419,
-0.003738154,
-0.029435806,
-0.0164759718,
0.0015991593,
-0.0543508269,
0.03348599,
0.0639496967,
0.0106404945,
0.0459398441,
-0.0442330129,
-0.0098489989,
0.0338123962,
0.021356862,
0.0169768352,
-0.0193077587,
0.031879697,
-0.081845291,
0.0282529537,
0.0039756047,
0.0275333785,
-0.0605116338,
-0.0279990975,
0.022856608,
-0.036078874,
-0.0235265531,
0.0268484503,
-0.0422997065,
0.0070576407,
-0.040658392,
-0.0307440143,
-0.023111999,
-0.0144836828,
0.0100795934,
-0.0133738695,
-0.0290802754,
0.0213828105,
-0.0565230511,
0.0790326297,
-0.0320299491,
-0.0144977486,
-0.0075365375,
0.0197749529,
0.0145496707,
-0.0395746864,
-0.0074313725,
0.0989476293,
0.043083895,
0.0061028716,
-0.024706902,
-0.058717303,
-0.0360510424,
-0.0599742681,
0.0050204103,
-0.0617357902,
-0.0190007165,
0.0494890921,
0.0113845468,
-0.0311237685,
0.0140210129,
-0.0107684731,
-0.0873431936,
0.0274162311,
-0.026791947,
0.0263697989,
-0.0032653359,
0.0033417307,
0.0181576442,
0.0221552961,
0.0409159213,
-0.0058667078,
-0.0083016949,
-0.0173245948,
0.0197495464,
0.0047949562,
0.0203717984,
0.0199828316,
-0.0093999235,
-0.0386917181,
-0.0041379831,
0.0137302699,
-0.0335472599,
0.008534153,
-0.0127451317,
0.0390227921,
0.0614875033,
0.0220110603,
-0.0256743319,
-0.0021086046,
0.0532332882,
-0.0349943414,
-0.0223047286,
0.0024724489,
-0.0488851145,
0.0116737774,
-0.0506274551,
-0.0235934649,
0.0212027263,
-0.0137370173,
-0.0047759572,
-0.0224101618,
-0.0269085132,
0.023373941,
0.0182311144,
-0.0002476726,
0.0730072558,
-0.0298133306,
-0.0221505351,
0.0012469337,
0.0252544079,
-0.0336721055,
0.0058880993,
-0.0157416873,
0.0213041622,
0.0432638638,
0.0617394783,
-0.0321699306,
-0.005229678,
-0.0175054818,
0.0071476055,
0.0035697783,
-0.0053533069,
0.0102469735,
-0.044712171,
-0.0081303259,
-0.016348647,
0.0118379677,
0.0378084444,
0.0210935753,
0.0029485524,
-0.0029646952,
-0.0011282074,
-0.0082663149,
0.0019402492,
0.0250043049,
-0.0294304751,
0.0021461525,
-0.0394653976,
0.0028972479,
0.0655420572,
0.0330161192,
-0.0209717844,
0.0197705775,
0.004212297,
-0.0390697867,
-0.0541336685,
0.0611239858,
0.0183358211,
0.0369728766,
-0.0107063614,
-0.0670313165,
-0.0141955493,
0.0247237496,
-0.024377659,
-0.0587886907,
0.0785209164,
-0.0159547012,
0.0033013348,
-0.0048847226,
-0.014286954,
-0.0032580981,
-0.0206329357,
-0.0253646579,
0.0707768351,
0.050451681,
0.0038105655,
-0.0080085862,
-0.0141330035,
0.0464980938,
-0.029600108,
0.0092703383,
0.0072865551,
-0.0039108586,
-0.0317218564,
0.0620829985,
-0.0442789569,
-0.0237578806,
-0.0046691331,
-0.0622177869,
-0.0117241992,
-0.0059658126,
-0.0026871692,
-0.0189106874,
-0.0225664806,
-0.0145085473,
-0.0021268758,
0.0184924491,
0.0079433955,
0.0303323362,
0.0348552875,
0.0148144653,
-0.0287894569,
-0.0100930808,
-0.0338898115,
-0.0033541217,
-0.0940997824,
0.027611237,
0.0853081048,
-0.0416812263,
-0.0102142943,
0.0018645237,
-0.0306131095,
-0.0176884551,
-0.0180359967,
-0.0273607466,
0.0231271219,
-0.0100194095,
0.0243198182,
0.0273439679,
-0.028006833,
0.0289292,
0.024585003,
-0.0250798352,
-0.0320151411,
-0.012427099,
-0.073722817,
-0.0055992617,
-0.0156833306,
-0.0520051457,
-0.046606198,
0.0710669905,
0.0228033774,
-0.028292533,
-0.0639787465,
0.0246247798,
-0.0484195575,
0.0184879713,
-0.0421382375,
-0.0540177859,
-0.0162947569,
0.0532064699,
-0.0063740239,
-0.0888232067,
0.0315203518,
0.0214786585,
0.0403930582,
-0.0054219975,
0.0109491041,
-0.0396285169,
0.0468889587,
0.0338241644,
0.0007680539,
0.0170375146,
0.0088644568,
-0.0085154362,
-0.0244361665,
0.0521499813,
0.0329324193,
-0.0027668041,
-0.1167222559,
0.0735923499,
0.0203962456,
-0.0618766621,
-0.0136663783,
-0.0483035073,
-0.031959828,
0.0043966649,
-0.0047197449,
-0.0104472367,
-0.0176340286,
0.0154902181,
0.045957353,
-0.0080875633,
-0.0097256936,
0.0080365138,
-0.0303891189,
-0.0453282967,
-0.00067162,
-0.054426346,
0.0458735973,
-0.0377630442,
0.0031470079,
-0.0116652614,
-0.024569964,
-0.0017685923,
-0.0258114114,
0.0439471528,
-0.0348625109,
0.0232188515,
0.0045306222,
0.0284764972,
0.036751613,
-0.036478892,
0.0281000137,
0.0940720066,
0.0131411646,
-0.0091540562,
0.0129463878,
0.0353754424,
-0.055244837,
0.0235211123,
-0.0190214049,
-0.0902178735,
-0.0117605962,
0.0017404518,
-0.0165368188,
-0.034219835,
-0.0557463169,
0.0250872374,
-0.0696480572,
0.0623016097,
0.0165847745,
-0.000196256,
0.017590262,
-0.0819519237,
-0.0149490368,
-0.0423695296,
-0.0613092408,
-0.0458956324,
0.0425286032,
0.0067598615,
0.0007969656,
-0.0264682863,
-0.0472994745,
0.0086423345,
-0.0191375781,
0.0525297485,
0.0286303014,
0.0290764496,
-0.0407772996,
0.0001960857,
0.0102467779,
0.0195268393,
-0.0075226994,
-0.0086770803,
0.0203145761,
0.0586339533,
-0.0047138068,
-0.0591530129,
0.0464734063,
-0.0429851562,
-0.0509209521,
0.0008639218,
0.0969540775,
-0.0089273928,
-0.0350113995,
-0.0076914732,
0.0109476177,
-0.0108700218,
0.0704383329,
-0.0129201598,
0.009337821,
-0.0403613821,
-0.0093684196,
-0.0274826121,
-0.000071309,
-0.0492671803,
-0.0366812013,
0.0359875411,
-0.0209584162,
-0.0179543961,
-0.0054623908,
0.0181760341,
-0.0211704839,
0.023283245,
0.0231924895,
0.0285481457,
-0.017961774,
-0.0230981726,
0.0726810023,
-0.0100304363,
0.0333502963,
-0.014932557,
-0.0168165751,
-0.0067168348,
-0.0110354321,
-0.0159828197,
0.0206029229,
-0.0286825504,
-0.0708717257,
-0.0100166965,
0.020055728,
0.0268180612,
0.0113701904,
-0.0088531459,
-0.0234739222,
-0.0083156256,
0.0069886567,
-0.0155643281,
0.0029955918,
0.0049430737,
-0.0081034601,
-0.0020787723,
0.0153258676,
-0.0154553214,
0.0248808991,
0.0052416632,
0.0551698878,
-0.0381002128,
0.0254365206,
0.0335309245,
0.0160555206,
0.0781361237,
-0.0408581831,
-0.0261524301,
-0.0227116328,
-0.0317943841,
-0.03933971,
-0.0270692725,
-0.0097558899,
0.0259707309,
0.032644514,
0.0185961369,
-0.0443850458,
-0.0369163826,
-0.0619706847,
-0.0040775188,
-0.0149552142,
0.0575186722,
-0.0070571387,
0.0123328622,
0.0454971716,
-0.0080543971,
0.0424160622,
0.0178792346,
-0.0179530345,
0.0521169566,
0.0001793501,
0.068242982,
0.0212553833,
0.0214145426,
-0.0195428208,
-0.0474954732,
-0.075667955,
-0.0290156659,
0.0226642061,
0.0173148997,
0.0757673979,
-0.015533125,
0.0287344735,
-0.0560465977,
-0.0047107758,
0.0045217192,
0.0389509462,
0.0155861331,
0.0168385636,
0.0285279099,
0.0127159767,
-0.0544146039,
0.0107906666,
0.0532340221,
0.0242710095,
0.0526267961,
-0.025590457,
-0.0321267396,
0.0186806265,
-0.0731672272,
0.0048035937,
0.0068174158,
-0.0351492725,
0.0219715443,
-0.1106128246,
-0.0423414893,
-0.0265652947,
-0.0148857925,
0.0142792407,
0.0128570776,
-0.0114653977,
0.0132739674,
-0.0220395178,
-0.025617741,
-0.0092751244,
0.0333859287,
-0.072334744,
-0.0041194591,
-0.0059106546,
-7.186441284e-33,
-0.0212072525,
-0.0628508553,
0.0230834875,
-0.006582099,
0.0204087775,
0.0066728732,
-0.0817752108,
0.0158700533,
0.0101910559,
0.0668669418,
0.0326946825,
0.0203696657,
0.0131754726,
-0.0090318536,
0.0230032876,
-0.0165149663,
-0.0060228361,
0.0415655188,
-0.0048133307,
0.0209652167,
0.0358526297,
-0.0132198837,
0.0095255943,
-0.114250429,
0.0717244074,
0.0135382796,
0.0028066132,
0.0114131523,
-0.0724876821,
0.0089434795,
-0.004374987,
0.0168255959,
0.0348312221,
-0.0640510544,
0.0220032874,
0.0180352144,
-0.0195055064,
-0.007819497,
0.0792763233,
-0.031580057,
-0.0333924443,
-0.0513243973,
-0.0020850734,
0.0130621055,
-0.037888024,
0.0389823169,
0.0436898507,
-0.0209648032,
0.0217454657,
-0.0129319411,
-0.0826942101,
0.0211259518,
-0.0560746454,
0.0242108982,
-0.0238696728,
0.0082724327,
-0.0204934031,
0.0555003621,
0.0083801076,
0.0317456312,
0.0057855975,
-0.0623493753,
0.0235725082,
0.0104359593,
0.0329244547,
0.0620701797,
-0.0215755329,
0.0080302656,
-0.0507248044,
-0.0134839108,
-0.013633769,
0.0520406216,
0.0757700875,
0.0697183982,
0.022246154,
0.008369117,
-0.1296268851,
-0.0102557791,
-0.025845252,
0.0080546336,
0.0383613557,
0.0094572511,
-0.0309149344,
-0.0482111685,
-0.0548572987,
-0.0175529793,
-0.0294745713,
-0.0007848072,
0.0087899202,
-0.0091707828,
-0.0014789887,
-0.0145274755,
0.04209828,
-0.0405948423,
0.0053519197,
0.0228241161,
-0.0075170007,
-0.0125656798,
-0.0064709233,
0.0168329366,
-0.0625656471,
0.0091039417,
-0.0078634676,
0.0284121893,
0.0631394684,
0.019516794,
0.0199402701,
-0.0239616763,
-0.0031985375,
-0.0093778372,
-0.0554202311,
-0.0584436879,
0.0213502496,
-0.0572669655,
0.0574898235,
0.0621374734,
0.0153656453,
0.0292758383,
0.0549116656,
0.0320217535,
0.0299301054,
-0.0258869119,
-0.0491820835,
-0.0086575588,
-0.0301731154,
-0.0112670092,
-0.0091010174,
0.0205410589,
0.0244398601,
-0.0566722937,
-0.0136769237,
-0.006997331,
3.012e-7,
0.0662193075,
0.0846807882,
0.0084356479,
0.0204032119,
0.0382183343,
0.0093949651,
-0.0117132161,
-0.0208427254,
0.0167520717,
0.0065543717,
0.0424847193,
0.0278596822,
0.0695054755,
-0.0091792764,
-0.0260723568,
0.0153713748,
-0.0249813069,
-0.0535999201,
-0.0405578725,
0.0327595472,
0.0739761963,
0.0059076683,
0.0423616953,
0.0219553187,
0.0016598746,
-0.0182917416,
0.0519894958,
-0.0560928769,
-0.0018358191,
-0.0118162427,
-0.0282339454,
-0.0053602373,
-0.0256859716,
0.0677274466,
0.0015176991,
-0.0167858191,
-0.0179878585,
0.0506511033,
-0.0101508955,
0.0165533964,
-0.0523697361,
-0.0588178858,
0.0420662165,
-0.0325739011,
0.0666085035,
-0.0470632166,
-0.0643464997,
0.0667055622,
-0.0100926291,
-0.0149846841,
0.0280424673,
0.02926456,
-0.0019417776,
0.0077863331,
-0.0192051567,
0.034796644,
-0.0002236036,
-0.0526197366,
-0.0218365025,
0.0389694124,
-0.0229370352,
-0.0794362426,
-0.0167711135,
0.0038927952,
0.0270909201,
-0.023868544,
0.0164122619,
3.072479124e-34,
0.0225360077,
0.0300784558,
0.0073129423,
-0.0722831488,
0.0673629418,
0.004308607,
-0.0570932738,
0.0375579633,
0.0341620967,
-0.1144306585,
0.0136197936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00034v1 | Text-Blueprint: An Interactive Platform for Plan-based Conditional Generation | 2023-04-28T18:14:48 | 2023-04-28T18:14:48 | Fantine Huot, Joshua Maynez, Shashi Narayan, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Kuzman Ganchev, Annie Louis, Anders Sandholm, Dipanjan Das, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | While conditional generation models can now generate natural language well
enough to create fluent text, it is still difficult to control the generation
process, leading to irrelevant, repetitive, and hallucinated content. Recent
work shows that planning can be a useful intermediate step to render
conditional generation less opaque and more grounded. We present a web
browser-based demonstration for query-focused summarization that uses a
sequence of question-answer pairs, as a blueprint plan for guiding text
generation (i.e., what to say and in what order). We illustrate how users may
interact with the generated text and associated plan visualizations, e.g., by
editing and modifying the blueprint in order to improve or control the
generated output.
A short video demonstrating our system is available at
https://goo.gle/text-blueprint-demo. | [
0.0346916579,
0.0257144775,
-0.0191666596,
-0.0235572178,
-0.0158481821,
-0.0071007255,
-0.0147559475,
0.0022828591,
0.0146340718,
0.0223939884,
0.0401790813,
0.0120044434,
-0.0087706363,
0.0742780566,
0.0038333328,
-0.1307023764,
0.0205986928,
0.0015197609,
-0.0198428594,
0.0162302405,
0.0257795546,
0.0430212319,
-0.0219972543,
0.0425762236,
0.0106449984,
-0.0043007461,
-0.0431753322,
0.0121447919,
0.017702641,
-0.0547691174,
-0.0435810313,
0.0517187081,
0.0000031525,
-0.0273540951,
0.0000020851,
-0.0324323848,
-0.0206886958,
-0.0395464338,
0.0092022149,
-0.0228748377,
-0.0095925462,
0.0079904292,
0.0324408114,
0.027661141,
-0.0684942678,
0.0318080597,
0.0290557332,
0.0531047247,
0.0856244192,
0.0389195308,
-0.0160924289,
-0.0358384103,
-0.0192638151,
-0.0002165474,
0.0442744531,
0.0057998756,
-0.0663203523,
0.005746346,
0.0652211085,
0.0048217862,
0.0238904562,
0.0446123183,
0.0445758477,
-0.0364570618,
0.0280264001,
0.0379606895,
0.0128619457,
-0.072249189,
-0.017246075,
0.0898207873,
0.0178178381,
-0.0127945924,
0.0264092181,
-0.0302388053,
0.015107289,
0.0215365961,
-0.0811632574,
0.0338290557,
-0.0291125812,
-0.00330833,
-0.017080199,
0.0067847027,
-0.0082874745,
-0.0000803236,
0.0004121234,
0.0494448841,
0.0130789978,
0.0032001438,
-0.0590863377,
0.0398551971,
0.0046207751,
-0.1058181822,
0.0351627879,
0.0635471195,
-0.0369278789,
0.0074919737,
-0.0545119718,
-0.0215033107,
0.0109986709,
0.0236205645,
0.0302483942,
0.0073797959,
0.0142298797,
0.0110003566,
0.0114107365,
0.033233352,
0.0150576001,
-0.0287215803,
-0.0605468862,
0.0604402348,
-0.0174265224,
-0.018871082,
-0.0627310425,
0.0202919003,
-0.0651448667,
-0.01063802,
-0.0071974169,
0.0453080237,
0.0180782247,
0.0189616513,
0.0263537709,
0.0410536863,
-0.0065442016,
0.0000172862,
-0.0641072094,
-0.0190404039,
-0.0810576826,
-0.0133250207,
0.0360134691,
-0.0491164029,
-0.009007223,
0.0198756233,
0.0465760343,
0.0296712853,
-0.0439132415,
0.0516099967,
-0.0484929755,
0.0189296734,
-0.0072866515,
-0.1181638315,
-0.0002221938,
-0.0034827047,
0.0079663936,
-0.054948438,
0.0126052015,
0.0197563265,
-0.0298098344,
-0.0301266834,
0.0207213107,
0.0708966628,
-0.0021522578,
0.0126322703,
-0.052971296,
0.0067545641,
0.0105110509,
0.0238842368,
0.0278744437,
0.0443017669,
0.047985293,
0.038166333,
0.0163437985,
0.0199540444,
0.0290663242,
0.014356236,
0.0036753884,
-0.0079595475,
-0.0151281003,
0.0109718721,
-0.0124799451,
0.0191434771,
-0.0216532107,
0.0219477974,
-0.0260304082,
0.029510241,
0.0318289772,
0.0418809503,
0.0034194863,
0.0155895678,
0.0424665175,
0.0449828729,
0.0049558417,
0.0658513457,
0.0066314135,
0.0612334684,
-0.0357530266,
0.021816263,
0.0156044886,
0.0034898983,
-0.0076666111,
-0.0493675619,
-0.0041684089,
0.0369425565,
0.0153984511,
-0.0141526842,
-0.0040059187,
0.0684689209,
-0.0470691249,
0.0109110493,
0.0022022491,
-0.0916491449,
0.0304902121,
-0.0047200425,
0.0525826737,
0.0806299374,
0.0523220561,
-0.0165430382,
0.0148074301,
0.0189056117,
-0.0134566054,
0.0430199914,
0.0532757267,
-0.0180425681,
-0.0204199608,
-0.0353567638,
-0.0099405088,
-0.0362990834,
-0.0269639473,
-0.0253011826,
0.0195186883,
-0.0093278028,
0.0217303913,
0.000769112,
-0.0012039558,
0.0303603448,
-0.0006875019,
-0.0094454791,
-0.0121303434,
-0.0114379805,
-0.0281337667,
0.0352953598,
-0.0054685865,
0.0476860814,
0.026956562,
-0.0121313054,
-0.015439203,
0.0129072629,
-0.0426681079,
-0.0574741177,
-0.0274301451,
-0.0705433786,
0.0107471263,
-0.0374127813,
-0.0393610261,
-0.0723101497,
0.0061937873,
-0.055790551,
0.0101062832,
-0.0158590563,
-0.0138434861,
0.0221547578,
-0.0332599618,
-0.0404928438,
0.0564022921,
0.0178941805,
-0.0385707095,
0.0443559438,
-0.0082166428,
-0.0007881395,
-0.0533938333,
0.0425571688,
0.0336919352,
-0.003447697,
-0.0222169831,
0.0499496385,
0.0437702239,
-0.058775872,
-0.0049259481,
-0.0907771066,
-0.0411550105,
-0.0260978062,
-0.0008074091,
0.0519480929,
0.0341735072,
-0.0177053194,
-0.0449172668,
-0.0651383772,
0.0018595533,
0.0353428163,
-0.0083547626,
0.0449967869,
0.0083003258,
0.0529442094,
-0.0308750533,
-0.0057105548,
-0.0005115352,
0.0055815727,
0.0956807211,
0.005079804,
-0.0428452231,
0.0251352657,
-0.0321257636,
-0.0219020229,
0.0523097105,
0.0263871104,
0.0338743702,
-0.0302474201,
0.0410726145,
-0.0022688622,
0.0207216293,
0.0234566666,
0.0495720319,
-0.0125307338,
-0.0213911682,
0.0264342073,
-0.0422583409,
0.0537430681,
0.0008924805,
-0.0639017522,
0.0265433993,
0.0451939702,
0.046630349,
0.0242574029,
-0.0555401929,
0.0458519049,
0.0066363444,
0.0027717911,
-0.0443507284,
-0.0229933728,
-0.0076776547,
0.0812810957,
0.001404727,
-0.0274844766,
0.0749876127,
-0.0135136032,
0.0090469206,
-0.0431288183,
0.0126249529,
-0.0413831845,
0.0566853434,
0.0107451454,
0.009969444,
0.0327207744,
0.0101274308,
-0.0524468124,
-0.0018826027,
-0.001365836,
-0.0308621172,
0.0162864756,
-0.078227587,
-0.0273939092,
0.0020491106,
-0.0266980939,
-0.0374744236,
-0.0243519284,
-0.0405022725,
-0.0095137125,
0.0558401048,
-0.0178291518,
-0.0121640917,
-0.0289124418,
0.033574678,
0.0658010691,
-0.0089108171,
-0.025318725,
-0.0136019941,
0.059337616,
0.0708992258,
0.0451915078,
0.0184580777,
-0.0386758223,
0.0109939706,
0.0436389148,
0.0338463672,
-0.0063472446,
0.025919104,
0.0137803368,
0.0074413992,
-0.0147698252,
-0.001158149,
0.0501190722,
0.0511462688,
-0.0370032303,
-0.0241155755,
0.0727877468,
0.0470152199,
-0.0175741911,
0.0144176101,
-0.0060047978,
0.086812593,
0.0233344492,
0.0537543707,
-0.0836459622,
-0.0283121578,
0.0144144157,
0.0251252763,
-0.0200733412,
-0.0424572863,
-0.0287470501,
-0.0840310752,
0.0252082329,
-0.0347120352,
-0.0157893766,
0.0354268178,
-0.0330809206,
-0.0215383433,
0.0381017141,
-0.0417850912,
0.0304740425,
-0.0291569382,
0.0363261066,
-0.0130015109,
-0.0759438425,
0.0149234068,
-0.0525637977,
0.0339513682,
-0.0291665383,
0.0733887255,
0.0229674075,
0.0103118289,
0.0050496873,
0.009547825,
-0.0231117588,
0.0372251198,
-0.0213583559,
0.0442162082,
0.0425091274,
0.0010955438,
-0.0647969395,
0.0315029472,
0.0010099177,
-0.0491727069,
0.0572156459,
0.0243265312,
-0.0385360457,
-0.0260100756,
-0.0656675026,
0.0525983125,
0.0002198128,
0.0167526584,
0.0598078892,
-0.0382087342,
-0.0520804599,
-0.0385064185,
0.0290682279,
-0.1179270223,
-0.034799777,
-0.0323850065,
0.0123020606,
0.0254347641,
-0.1126859561,
-0.0427577458,
0.0402880907,
0.023590032,
0.0179097839,
-0.0305611733,
0.0233030058,
0.0047157016,
-0.0156033682,
-0.0066277953,
0.0166466013,
-0.0083246026,
-0.0248700883,
-0.0510947816,
-0.0224997327,
-0.0448919088,
-0.0023772281,
0.0479789115,
-0.0714402348,
-0.0286327135,
-0.0052923784,
0.0229516551,
0.0206226017,
-0.0110684503,
0.0046835062,
-0.031764213,
0.0449174419,
0.0321597904,
-0.0315964557,
-0.0099604409,
-0.0496379733,
0.0446081422,
0.0074175033,
0.0073359846,
-0.0347640552,
0.0077839303,
-0.0547897071,
0.0497166924,
-0.0447503664,
-0.0251448862,
0.0262079611,
0.0366446748,
-0.018667547,
-0.0134116458,
0.0114923138,
-0.0226072147,
0.0043941089,
-0.0650111213,
-0.0215575993,
-0.0464915372,
0.041223228,
-0.0241991598,
-0.0235048924,
0.0367210433,
0.0404196493,
-0.0270206109,
0.0107674506,
-0.0395842865,
0.0102393702,
0.0102754384,
-0.0191617832,
0.0125890076,
-0.0126275299,
-0.015854653,
0.0190982204,
-0.0522248559,
0.0396564789,
0.0178005658,
0.0624119267,
0.0137822051,
-0.037565276,
-0.0022479666,
0.0029433474,
-0.0637431368,
-0.0643143579,
0.0144659132,
0.0257821959,
-0.0118395444,
-0.0034263814,
0.0534162074,
-0.025366649,
0.0048694084,
0.0078595355,
0.0392907448,
0.0086858692,
-0.036032442,
-0.0065394547,
0.0134331202,
-0.0137974359,
-0.0666734576,
0.0407491215,
-0.0248166267,
0.0026359786,
-0.0051569608,
-0.0111815594,
-0.0419541597,
-0.0393300802,
-0.015147049,
0.0489192121,
-0.006057003,
-0.0171437189,
-0.0648593679,
-0.0175646935,
0.015415268,
0.0255667344,
0.0144726597,
-0.005416878,
0.0679875612,
0.0193821676,
0.0127672898,
-0.0230382048,
-0.0152443536,
0.0488655679,
-0.0498331301,
-0.0310190767,
-0.0165731777,
-6.057840709e-33,
-0.0482023321,
-0.0707625598,
0.0216294266,
-0.0419662371,
-0.0056297635,
-0.0344262049,
-0.0698076189,
0.0209280085,
0.0248787664,
0.0066812141,
-0.0167756677,
-0.0204745345,
0.0122597124,
0.0488115288,
-0.0066528651,
-0.0228077229,
0.0493038967,
0.0054330854,
-0.0489640236,
0.0518701673,
0.0451944135,
-0.0080927555,
-0.017076442,
-0.0223255046,
0.0073106037,
-0.0294594672,
-0.0286676567,
0.0058890753,
-0.0084066149,
0.0228797384,
-0.0077797449,
0.0242044162,
0.0122734513,
0.0222534332,
-0.0602962486,
0.0684824213,
-0.0271600205,
-0.0654122606,
0.00414888,
-0.0319213346,
-0.1128444448,
-0.0408834964,
0.0234541688,
-0.0101542603,
-0.0166667979,
-0.0175841898,
0.0596087649,
0.0019320921,
-0.0032275149,
-0.0276361182,
-0.0331765004,
0.014391358,
-0.0344425924,
-0.0052721789,
0.0110600153,
0.1033560932,
0.031225916,
-0.0358823277,
0.0093720136,
0.0806992278,
0.0360166468,
0.0090932818,
0.0488663316,
0.002428012,
-0.0052941795,
0.0614204705,
0.0328219905,
-0.0186367482,
-0.0383126661,
0.0418895707,
0.0023312585,
0.036391221,
0.0317804404,
0.0002614146,
0.0046901568,
0.0187504049,
-0.0188454464,
0.0474053472,
-0.037731424,
0.0115027968,
0.0087175574,
-0.0147797633,
0.0204147287,
-0.0062143411,
-0.0603167415,
0.0053918539,
-0.0157679766,
-0.0063722511,
-0.005896484,
0.0163299851,
-0.0279402528,
0.0046658996,
-0.0350661576,
0.0277897231,
-0.0029892675,
0.0309729241,
-0.054881826,
0.0239612535,
0.0041308259,
0.0023886962,
-0.0106034074,
0.0213458035,
0.0390722305,
-0.0107184118,
0.0277118161,
0.0471235178,
-0.0078215944,
0.0064710383,
-0.0364713743,
-0.0081751971,
-0.0194259193,
0.0287838113,
-0.0055133281,
-0.0521661937,
0.0274634268,
-0.001363381,
-0.037243858,
0.0084445886,
-0.0075535853,
-0.0335958935,
-0.0434780791,
-0.0460488833,
0.0269986205,
0.0266905446,
-0.0125412298,
0.0051793517,
-0.0013112273,
0.0256090015,
0.0453635566,
-0.0473600775,
-0.0354531221,
0.0367538929,
2.593e-7,
0.0421939567,
0.0435677506,
0.0634921864,
0.0368635021,
-0.0184752326,
0.0083276434,
0.0242153239,
0.0101458719,
-0.0049657142,
0.00012655,
0.0110275643,
0.0269740522,
0.0321955644,
0.0597496442,
-0.0665575266,
0.0327952504,
-0.0577280074,
-0.021052938,
-0.0566166192,
-0.0047643972,
0.1298585236,
0.0039930707,
-0.000158502,
0.0023171629,
0.0167710315,
0.0286497083,
0.0125234248,
0.0043726992,
0.0196000263,
0.0052890247,
-0.0103495894,
-0.0258631911,
-0.0079783872,
-0.0004778344,
-0.0332001373,
-0.0464094393,
0.0202456675,
0.0144140497,
0.0221504327,
-0.0153143695,
0.0061198459,
-0.0241812579,
0.0289318915,
-0.0442247801,
0.0610604025,
-0.0126558831,
0.0044712485,
0.0136543643,
-0.0194353499,
-0.0245037451,
-0.0111913001,
0.0040430385,
-0.0293175653,
0.043466039,
-0.0156900045,
0.0034915956,
-0.0051584085,
-0.0152651425,
-0.0607332401,
0.0190971866,
-0.0394297689,
-0.0244632047,
-0.0953142494,
0.0241090432,
-0.0572800599,
-0.0310312528,
-0.0151410392,
2.482684936e-34,
0.0224905759,
0.0245142598,
-0.0148803322,
-0.0066903601,
0.0482836775,
-0.0047785384,
0.0104628308,
0.0345724262,
0.0426694974,
-0.083483696,
-0.0503898971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.15010v1 | LLaMA-Adapter V2: Parameter-Efficient Visual Instruction Model | 2023-04-28T17:59:25 | 2023-04-28T17:59:25 | Peng Gao, Jiaming Han, Renrui Zhang, Ziyi Lin, Shijie Geng, Aojun Zhou, Wei Zhang, Pan Lu, Conghui He, Xiangyu Yue, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | How to efficiently transform large language models (LLMs) into instruction
followers is recently a popular research direction, while training LLM for
multi-modal reasoning remains less explored. Although the recent LLaMA-Adapter
demonstrates the potential to handle visual inputs with LLMs, it still cannot
generalize well to open-ended visual instructions and lags behind GPT-4. In
this paper, we present LLaMA-Adapter V2, a parameter-efficient visual
instruction model. Specifically, we first augment LLaMA-Adapter by unlocking
more learnable parameters (e.g., norm, bias and scale), which distribute the
instruction-following ability across the entire LLaMA model besides adapters.
Secondly, we propose an early fusion strategy to feed visual tokens only into
the early LLM layers, contributing to better visual knowledge incorporation.
Thirdly, a joint training paradigm of image-text pairs and
instruction-following data is introduced by optimizing disjoint groups of
learnable parameters. This strategy effectively alleviates the interference
between the two tasks of image-text alignment and instruction following and
achieves strong multi-modal reasoning with only a small-scale image-text and
instruction dataset. During inference, we incorporate additional expert models
(e.g. captioning/OCR systems) into LLaMA-Adapter to further enhance its image
understanding capability without incurring training costs. Compared to the
original LLaMA-Adapter, our LLaMA-Adapter V2 can perform open-ended multi-modal
instructions by merely introducing 14M parameters over LLaMA. The newly
designed framework also exhibits stronger language-only instruction-following
capabilities and even excels in chat interactions. Our code and models are
available at https://github.com/ZrrSkywalker/LLaMA-Adapter. | [
0.0404180363,
0.0689040199,
-0.0044707917,
0.0692400262,
-0.0089213019,
0.0139061166,
0.0142164398,
0.0071753506,
0.0359704345,
-0.0714077726,
-0.0572551265,
-0.0026594056,
-0.0146373101,
0.0111891711,
0.0363079272,
-0.0617474131,
0.0207759049,
-0.0531985275,
0.0016241912,
-0.0043439446,
0.0499069132,
0.0132476138,
0.002328828,
0.0101208929,
-0.0137234945,
-0.0148961116,
-0.0206250716,
0.010055528,
0.0156176491,
-0.0052275243,
-0.0150567554,
0.023868084,
0.0655684024,
-0.0045099175,
0.0000019428,
-0.0063903863,
0.0208400749,
-0.0236846283,
0.0046080612,
0.0008585732,
0.0394874364,
-0.0565799214,
-0.0015570532,
0.0098535055,
-0.0249742139,
0.0007290044,
0.0703659877,
0.0736549348,
0.079815872,
0.085454151,
-0.0187167022,
-0.0407556258,
0.0530185252,
-0.029872939,
0.0344514288,
-0.0277966391,
0.0057352153,
0.0155384941,
0.0036498769,
0.0397690013,
-0.0400868393,
0.0498851687,
0.0347801819,
-0.015481934,
-0.0084465556,
0.0423296541,
0.0255035833,
-0.052588772,
-0.0447204039,
0.0876280442,
-0.0243763383,
0.0193965025,
-0.0280663725,
0.00692133,
0.0032186902,
0.0039817239,
-0.0567044765,
0.0438598916,
0.0026558638,
0.0337397195,
-0.0072010062,
-0.0125588514,
-0.0025622512,
0.021753164,
-0.013651602,
0.0114900479,
-0.0038735722,
0.0168610867,
-0.0196780544,
0.0033734099,
-0.068816781,
-0.0589209497,
-0.0245063175,
0.0742023066,
-0.012077882,
0.0317044221,
-0.0408801436,
-0.005399528,
0.0134325586,
-0.0406648777,
0.0485283956,
0.0437424816,
-0.0709003955,
0.0662560984,
-0.0469391048,
0.0625054613,
-0.045385357,
0.0701570958,
-0.0355173796,
-0.0161408819,
-0.0419165045,
-0.0124563668,
-0.0269502494,
0.0081797792,
-0.053768225,
-0.0591996871,
-0.0174126644,
0.0348745994,
-0.0196714234,
0.0133965584,
0.0110948347,
0.0013489564,
-0.0174336173,
-0.0300188921,
-0.0506476946,
0.0242647026,
-0.0313234217,
0.0662362874,
-0.019631695,
-0.0364573188,
-0.0127753234,
0.0490016863,
0.0161585733,
-0.0008522397,
0.0284809452,
0.0946622714,
-0.0688781515,
-0.0201281216,
-0.0340215787,
-0.0233504456,
-0.00304134,
-0.0701820329,
0.0557035096,
-0.0486408733,
0.0590917282,
-0.0121381497,
-0.0048884107,
-0.0145424269,
0.0353315137,
0.0339934863,
-0.0207140539,
0.1042363718,
0.0100928657,
-0.0198096558,
0.0100155361,
0.0324802957,
-0.0136555545,
0.0812979937,
0.0327352732,
0.0485520661,
0.0198618565,
0.0212645121,
-0.0019940315,
0.0302090254,
0.0126935653,
0.0115826009,
-0.0209939498,
0.0106340116,
0.0126913162,
0.0193906948,
0.0470780581,
0.0558554381,
-0.0510506257,
-0.0251422022,
0.0606813617,
0.0122202933,
-0.0127484472,
-0.0135327959,
0.0311732348,
-0.0080665937,
0.0080382507,
0.0126672294,
-0.1136298329,
0.0796191767,
0.0012697733,
-0.0027883502,
0.0044008144,
0.0316143371,
-0.0402473994,
-0.0509104356,
0.0267443284,
-0.0327982791,
-0.0057751318,
0.0125491004,
0.0135016544,
-0.0041421955,
-0.0766119361,
0.0292289332,
0.0184380468,
-0.0236810241,
-0.0331319533,
-0.0412362218,
0.0455930531,
0.0485029332,
0.0011609306,
-0.0084365495,
-0.0434505604,
0.0205435343,
0.0305398256,
0.0189061146,
-0.0300173126,
0.0089192493,
0.0277991723,
-0.0815144107,
-0.0386475995,
-0.0379720181,
0.0010160817,
0.0202107951,
0.0206819121,
-0.01803842,
0.0045686164,
0.0056253085,
-0.0132377995,
0.0461609177,
0.0536608994,
-0.0296598617,
-0.0456538685,
0.0269028489,
0.0100910049,
-0.0296946242,
0.0106249265,
-0.0163472146,
0.0223735701,
-0.0457506068,
0.0083143832,
0.0035303193,
-0.0662809759,
-0.0801500306,
0.0335299931,
-0.0313158296,
-0.0139180003,
-0.0129603548,
-0.0678083599,
-0.0359094888,
-0.005411196,
-0.0129123395,
0.012882336,
-0.0305639785,
-0.0048960545,
0.0427051932,
0.0294890851,
0.0042611645,
0.0499638431,
-0.0248348545,
-0.0392620862,
0.0376077592,
0.0125080608,
0.0046405573,
-0.0161979292,
-0.0019119038,
-0.0027330557,
0.0128640961,
0.0139290448,
-0.0497114956,
0.04001626,
-0.0388601981,
-0.0633726418,
-0.1107902303,
0.0039427876,
-0.0230283309,
-0.008715787,
0.0174236596,
-0.0030395398,
0.0209803395,
-0.0346863829,
-0.0340102501,
0.0213057119,
-0.0010535797,
-0.0016076337,
0.0330980457,
0.03486849,
-0.0215273872,
-0.0361491926,
0.0128638297,
0.0006985792,
0.0069412207,
0.0175980292,
0.0048091658,
-0.0404026136,
-0.0087707639,
-0.0288579036,
0.0561319329,
-0.0347723924,
-0.0460543782,
0.0054982072,
-0.0082416497,
0.0428908691,
0.0908364654,
-0.01601604,
0.0217357408,
0.0131639568,
-0.0082105706,
-0.0334711485,
0.0288375709,
0.0116357207,
-0.0344537124,
-0.0048634666,
-0.0235417727,
-0.0465836525,
0.0353611968,
-0.0482357778,
0.0141892135,
-0.0650779009,
0.0059648864,
0.0363080986,
-0.0222485773,
-0.0277474746,
0.0052362294,
0.0083594676,
-0.0047267973,
-0.0620560274,
-0.0918563232,
0.0528070927,
-0.0560557805,
-0.0324622653,
0.0166424308,
-0.0071806991,
-0.0573673882,
0.0427222438,
0.0395901576,
0.0166956279,
-0.0123205073,
0.003522492,
-0.0571494401,
-0.0127697717,
0.0124374423,
-0.0040865457,
0.0691219494,
-0.0704977512,
0.0014889409,
-0.0416526459,
-0.0200435296,
-0.014595136,
-0.0210321993,
-0.0244688801,
0.0153354015,
-0.0223114844,
-0.0256144814,
-0.0256053973,
0.0053220554,
0.0241336673,
0.008944707,
-0.0170056038,
0.0105114132,
-0.0506166443,
0.0240835007,
0.0450891554,
0.0206963383,
-0.0590706915,
-0.0494021252,
0.0075679356,
0.0637836456,
0.0188617315,
-0.040045552,
-0.0297780819,
0.0380861051,
0.0231450032,
0.0463830233,
-0.0015250759,
0.0261016283,
0.0866229087,
-0.0532047115,
0.0309816413,
0.0693314746,
0.0048588733,
-0.0277843643,
-0.0383786447,
0.0159411822,
0.0409287885,
0.0332782455,
0.0343075991,
-0.0813532621,
-0.0594154894,
-0.0169669315,
-0.0138233695,
0.0148145529,
0.0182314478,
-0.0445507467,
-0.0503271073,
0.0394897349,
0.0077943644,
-0.0030520621,
-0.0402768403,
0.0027444484,
-0.0079399794,
0.0068701562,
-0.0152551495,
-0.0155603904,
-0.0084921904,
-0.0239138436,
-0.0032448252,
0.0366483107,
0.0007238665,
0.0296868831,
-0.0303198807,
0.0263229348,
0.0213822871,
0.0095886625,
-0.0002882471,
-0.077055715,
0.0058420352,
0.008247911,
0.0083343489,
-0.006788935,
0.0431560203,
-0.0223432407,
-0.0327632092,
0.013641133,
0.0601565875,
0.00291076,
0.0030449796,
-0.0090474468,
0.0607303306,
-0.0097986227,
0.0079072639,
-0.0188751016,
0.0066880686,
-0.0050825495,
0.0324372277,
0.0160893165,
0.0064097359,
-0.0346151665,
-0.0207829289,
-0.0394804701,
-0.0369742066,
-0.0143452724,
-0.0052161622,
-0.0313618146,
-0.0028211172,
-0.0487404689,
-0.0129136238,
0.0504637808,
0.0510612838,
-0.0109203439,
-0.0132336877,
-0.0068030502,
-0.007815239,
-0.0213450417,
0.0526242889,
-0.0307847671,
0.0317052826,
-0.0497050211,
-0.0020418323,
0.0322826579,
-0.0312920175,
-0.0116158016,
0.0212089159,
-0.0739386827,
-0.0501494221,
-0.056032978,
0.1005588993,
0.0077043632,
0.0579934679,
0.0163671728,
-0.0273737963,
0.0176055562,
0.0291031916,
0.0112750754,
0.0030537168,
0.0466389805,
0.001170499,
0.0074638319,
0.0246015582,
-0.006076593,
0.0344893485,
-0.0156799946,
-0.0100992443,
-0.0504151061,
-0.0088743884,
0.0129121868,
-0.0174479187,
0.0094777513,
-0.0118647199,
0.0091222757,
-0.030172145,
0.0480521508,
-0.0025613871,
-0.0062038363,
-0.0736531019,
0.0163066983,
-0.0051084296,
-0.0051402277,
0.0185098816,
-0.0257892422,
0.0166762713,
0.0128892027,
-0.0025265086,
0.0468807928,
0.0221047234,
-0.0088664182,
-0.0061452235,
0.0116045708,
-0.0112329507,
0.0042592525,
-0.0098472778,
0.0392310023,
-0.0329593644,
0.0974175632,
0.0342577398,
-0.0264716111,
-0.0483296476,
0.0388269685,
-0.0204873979,
-0.0246073473,
-0.0087037124,
0.0677313954,
0.033225216,
0.0149127729,
-0.0175869036,
-0.0065564108,
-0.0179442335,
0.0231843702,
0.0619649924,
-0.0166184995,
-0.0260336976,
0.0988011137,
0.0459622405,
0.0260854587,
-0.0093218917,
0.058055073,
-0.0090836259,
0.0406328775,
-0.0181089751,
0.0126779415,
-0.0407567918,
-0.0223069135,
0.0689321309,
-0.0005067671,
0.0045361868,
0.0395993516,
0.0114011187,
-0.0425985307,
-0.0016797094,
0.0103264591,
-0.0478905998,
-0.0122634377,
0.0317090526,
0.0398060493,
0.0155959511,
-0.0292757321,
-0.0122631351,
-0.024309922,
0.0111426115,
0.0125943273,
0.01422433,
-6.462372764e-33,
-0.0441730917,
-0.0443340577,
0.075554058,
-0.0047115437,
-0.0138144726,
0.0029909192,
-0.0107547715,
-0.0221768562,
-0.0402725674,
0.0030106951,
0.0193490628,
0.0138760069,
0.0136681693,
0.0206894781,
-0.0030516125,
0.0060378416,
0.0174211133,
-0.0082843257,
-0.0019029204,
0.0154479109,
0.0259398203,
-0.018124368,
0.0307777319,
-0.0608990192,
0.0111169405,
0.0134446835,
-0.032837946,
0.0453772917,
-0.0170191023,
0.0688610524,
-0.0175819229,
0.0048296796,
0.0115440208,
-0.0063190451,
-0.0062891617,
0.0397422574,
-0.0753866881,
-0.0284971502,
0.0465255491,
0.0313067958,
-0.0869472399,
-0.0270360094,
0.0344609916,
-0.0208193921,
0.0365886725,
-0.0337769054,
0.0245471485,
-0.008351991,
0.0127504868,
0.0645788833,
-0.0481927097,
0.0001232005,
-0.0042231446,
-0.0531081744,
0.0266230367,
0.0264378227,
0.0458374992,
0.0148232225,
-0.0408600643,
0.0067808311,
0.0117939403,
0.0248410255,
0.065461278,
0.0406007841,
-0.0194255486,
0.0120550124,
0.0034713959,
-0.0387811847,
-0.0604287386,
-0.0048852647,
-0.0044173645,
0.1047311649,
0.0333852321,
0.0175775699,
-0.0022267576,
0.0299116038,
-0.0365204513,
0.0016944238,
0.013624168,
0.076079458,
-0.0076986193,
0.0137029151,
-0.0123008201,
-0.0025926759,
-0.0211216938,
-0.012219334,
-0.0396860726,
-0.0055088163,
0.0278654974,
0.0777528808,
-0.0097005889,
0.0174222812,
0.0590519048,
-0.0247326214,
0.0075021219,
-0.0077702156,
-0.0230851918,
0.0528085418,
-0.0071988106,
0.0183163453,
-0.0643704161,
-0.037457265,
0.0700226352,
-0.0398831666,
0.0082524726,
0.0171640906,
0.0730647519,
0.0336718448,
-0.0583639443,
-0.0190012101,
-0.0490632318,
0.0058428277,
-0.0055708168,
0.0164080858,
0.0229620021,
0.0162728503,
-0.0564543381,
0.0245692804,
-0.0224797539,
-0.0042655091,
-0.0372847281,
-0.0566403568,
-0.0252171233,
0.0249584857,
-0.045187179,
0.0159649048,
-0.0329468995,
-0.0578567758,
-0.0391327813,
-0.066802457,
-0.0196285862,
0.0520192944,
2.62e-7,
0.0167788621,
0.0115633272,
0.0212718379,
0.028211277,
0.0070560304,
0.0488540158,
-0.027077375,
0.0129465722,
-0.0014328117,
-0.050548479,
0.0108829886,
0.0760819092,
0.0043553216,
-0.0045251013,
-0.0256069899,
0.0056268973,
-0.0127430931,
-0.0330002978,
-0.0511636548,
-0.0155986249,
0.0840640441,
0.113157995,
-0.0221006926,
-0.0137696229,
0.026894886,
-0.0333934054,
0.0867420882,
-0.0034141392,
-0.0037692999,
-0.0038347952,
0.0339346528,
0.0341921896,
-0.0466364548,
0.0354428813,
0.0185882468,
0.0005769107,
-0.0101443995,
0.0893847197,
-0.015141842,
-0.02449435,
-0.0127499141,
0.0054073632,
-0.0420415625,
-0.0486548543,
0.0890160203,
-0.0394465923,
-0.0218536258,
-0.0186992045,
-0.0157276858,
-0.0087206066,
0.0073592421,
0.0062898858,
-0.0261911713,
0.021327598,
0.0342680328,
-0.0519629791,
-0.0368753113,
-0.0995625481,
-0.0086216116,
-0.0279688574,
-0.0242005866,
-0.0182879306,
-0.0735864937,
-0.0118754543,
0.0429800563,
-0.0379062742,
-0.0463952757,
2.217577899e-34,
0.0112544205,
-0.0575154833,
0.0271925256,
0.0545160286,
0.0312875472,
-0.0102465833,
-0.0456139892,
0.0137543371,
0.0177881084,
-0.1022385135,
-0.0133477245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14999v1 | Empirical Analysis of the Strengths and Weaknesses of PEFT Techniques for LLMs | 2023-04-28T17:39:49 | 2023-04-28T17:39:49 | George Pu, Anirudh Jain, Jihan Yin, Russell Kaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As foundation models continue to exponentially scale in size, efficient
methods of adaptation become increasingly critical. Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT), a recent class of techniques that require only modifying a
small percentage of the model parameters, is currently the most popular method
for adapting large language models (LLMs). Several PEFT techniques have
recently been proposed with varying tradeoffs. We provide a comprehensive and
uniform benchmark of various PEFT techniques across a representative LLM, the
FLAN-T5 model, and evaluate model performance across different data scales of
classification and generation datasets. Based on this, we provide a framework
for choosing the optimal fine-tuning techniques given the task type and data
availability. Contrary to popular belief, we also empirically prove that PEFT
techniques converge slower than full tuning in low data scenarios, and posit
the amount of data required for PEFT methods to both perform well and converge
efficiently. Lastly, we further optimize these PEFT techniques by selectively
choosing which parts of the model to train, and find that these techniques can
be applied with significantly fewer parameters while maintaining and even
improving performance. | [
0.0376868844,
0.06290216,
-0.0012005052,
0.0252140183,
-0.0043897983,
0.0354293697,
0.0042545707,
-0.0068326755,
-0.0713525191,
-0.0523144267,
-0.0659343526,
-0.0568735041,
0.0287402328,
-0.006194225,
0.0445391014,
-0.0347288214,
0.0292646307,
-0.025852425,
-0.0182187241,
0.006265203,
-0.0175742041,
0.0382073633,
-0.0058753267,
0.0210340228,
0.0410622694,
0.0388418958,
0.001707883,
0.0472959541,
0.0430978797,
0.0336710364,
0.0138872871,
0.0780065656,
0.0192928854,
0.0361985043,
0.0000016734,
-0.0401443169,
-0.0355476104,
-0.0090444684,
0.0007361536,
0.0659427345,
0.0652851984,
0.0077235126,
-0.0294681229,
0.0539489351,
-0.0149035323,
-0.0307618771,
0.0604408532,
0.0272256322,
0.0470763296,
0.0927520692,
0.0001410724,
-0.0444163159,
-0.0109450817,
-0.0315145887,
-0.0459359214,
-0.0117182704,
0.0380985178,
-0.0457195304,
-0.0074412343,
-0.0153872725,
-0.0416831858,
-0.0011207921,
-0.0098978477,
0.0291197579,
-0.0209518578,
0.0026251706,
-0.0490119457,
-0.0164348669,
0.0243780073,
0.069890067,
-0.0417933278,
-0.0379618183,
0.0270769633,
-0.0120672742,
-0.0346592143,
-0.0041460455,
-0.0324023589,
-0.0008647823,
0.0242125504,
0.0235299282,
0.0701113269,
-0.0657306984,
0.038770251,
0.0289940331,
-0.044621598,
0.0124826506,
0.0450433865,
0.0086551746,
-0.0212617535,
-0.0219443571,
-0.0234465729,
-0.0020388416,
-0.0238372684,
0.0151801892,
-0.004854884,
0.0000210147,
-0.0858228207,
-0.0092509286,
0.0115348846,
0.0024297,
0.0615576096,
0.0449861623,
0.007641783,
0.014766057,
-0.0369590819,
-0.011771109,
-0.0126746008,
0.0294324849,
-0.063697122,
-0.0013992253,
-0.0508682095,
0.0397263281,
-0.0566784479,
-0.0127506563,
-0.0083466806,
-0.004329022,
-0.034621112,
0.013861117,
0.054818742,
-0.0300184656,
0.0105091399,
-0.0431704819,
-0.046163056,
0.0058072512,
0.0567914099,
0.0584034957,
-0.0201424286,
0.0399490036,
-0.00717352,
-0.0648049191,
-0.0114323972,
0.0234470218,
0.034964744,
-0.0084091956,
0.0270389486,
0.0078726411,
0.0158430822,
-0.0417602211,
-0.0727865472,
0.0213466268,
-0.0071790628,
-0.0643343329,
-0.0022641488,
-0.0602921359,
-0.0030619572,
-0.0046360684,
0.021239873,
-0.0236541405,
-0.0308294762,
-0.0184885934,
-0.0426996239,
0.0339668915,
-0.032833837,
0.0416256413,
0.0482057817,
-0.0163060874,
0.0154386256,
0.0773901492,
0.0507195294,
0.007948271,
0.0205594152,
-0.0245133266,
-0.0289216097,
0.0725586265,
0.0094254809,
0.0560047068,
-0.0004983214,
-0.0185165461,
-0.0136597641,
0.0064757182,
0.0264523178,
0.0075102863,
-0.0224057045,
-0.0029639713,
0.0579011515,
0.0149502428,
0.0764012113,
0.0317046419,
0.0362581387,
-0.0015222438,
0.0167967118,
-0.0137721095,
-0.0382564142,
-0.0007592465,
-0.0565861389,
0.0258474704,
0.0159804542,
0.0479422919,
-0.0573942065,
0.0047274977,
-0.020997392,
-0.0007228647,
-0.0229634363,
0.0025877384,
0.0537468381,
0.0083076684,
-0.0222075041,
0.0636517033,
0.0375339724,
-0.027133394,
0.0160499234,
-0.0492418855,
0.0154431285,
0.0478039458,
0.0286421981,
-0.0026154807,
-0.0431376249,
0.0075446046,
0.0354087129,
0.0254747141,
0.0452963449,
-0.0087611424,
0.0177329499,
-0.0667860284,
-0.0175231174,
0.0192372296,
0.0203564614,
0.0058852131,
0.0064343233,
-0.0034800461,
0.0469210111,
-0.0677878931,
-0.0286689363,
0.0329811722,
-0.0288929734,
0.0022078136,
0.021702202,
0.011645277,
0.0219211597,
0.0200534016,
-0.0124660395,
-0.0111487182,
0.0061071669,
-0.0052548102,
0.0379648283,
-0.0355253555,
-0.007647323,
-0.0090492079,
0.0276489537,
0.0137421414,
0.0592759922,
0.0360412113,
-0.0613977611,
-0.057342127,
0.0277530067,
-0.0296724681,
0.0263864938,
-0.0518601164,
0.042209696,
-0.046240855,
0.0400884598,
-0.030380059,
0.002141495,
0.0053123133,
-0.0242776647,
0.0303459708,
0.0510487445,
0.0091820806,
-0.0512426458,
-0.017592214,
0.0149404248,
0.0169560332,
0.0072821085,
0.0005540204,
0.0557960644,
-0.0384415984,
-0.0271861479,
-0.1032229885,
0.0350367837,
-0.0576221757,
0.0236671697,
0.031133173,
0.0298551954,
-0.0201690942,
0.017869588,
-0.031957604,
0.0238546543,
0.0012712309,
0.0293728169,
0.0085214525,
0.0104374737,
-0.0791981891,
-0.0495415926,
-0.0185853597,
0.0367418528,
0.0263269059,
-0.0251798499,
-0.0316497721,
-0.07380303,
0.0284204017,
-0.0280776713,
0.0101884771,
0.0093498919,
-0.0527380146,
-0.0428121909,
-0.03844852,
0.0192886703,
0.0141515117,
0.002752491,
0.0167892072,
0.0223303903,
0.0130379079,
-0.0229053665,
-0.0124631189,
-0.0208690334,
-0.0395995863,
-0.0381514579,
-0.0347646289,
-0.0211814549,
0.0525708161,
-0.0172609854,
-0.0026017665,
-0.0667257756,
0.023258945,
-0.0180173088,
0.0109120039,
0.0333699882,
0.0317315087,
-0.0178453662,
0.0170068368,
0.0085727535,
-0.0606508069,
0.036833521,
-0.0755818188,
0.0070547294,
-0.0382943526,
-0.039360676,
-0.0622340329,
0.0020374195,
0.00674944,
0.0184888504,
0.0181741081,
-0.0056286626,
-0.0617961697,
-0.0066413577,
0.0240420289,
-0.0094728107,
0.0562322289,
-0.0452792123,
0.0353981107,
-0.0342434309,
-0.0058716023,
-0.0076307971,
-0.043685168,
-0.0097175082,
0.0287547782,
-0.0194255579,
-0.0481560938,
-0.012473152,
0.0124453818,
-0.0124583878,
0.0571789816,
-0.0192167647,
0.0155222313,
-0.0061748545,
0.0336909331,
0.0752146617,
0.0387483165,
0.0498234816,
-0.0435494334,
-0.0142961908,
-0.0265005436,
0.0390285514,
0.0243677497,
-0.0366367474,
0.0097134383,
0.0416457728,
-0.0099094175,
-0.029214669,
0.0351187289,
0.0417618044,
-0.0350739546,
-0.0102196308,
0.1283982396,
0.014869649,
-0.0165289901,
0.0258182902,
0.0283992812,
0.0531862974,
0.0030877881,
0.0258716289,
-0.0400723293,
-0.0313310884,
0.0107774604,
0.0670352951,
-0.0056601604,
0.0068277284,
-0.0212757923,
-0.1006785706,
0.0471500866,
0.0693703443,
-0.0239758063,
-0.0274417363,
-0.0345599651,
0.0277694687,
-0.0267869867,
0.0231705904,
0.0225562658,
-0.0249114297,
-0.0175085124,
0.0328891017,
-0.0237257686,
-0.1015861481,
-0.0069957986,
-0.0322285295,
0.0644579306,
0.0216611009,
-0.0165115781,
-0.0124206534,
-0.0166766476,
0.0354695246,
-0.0365420692,
-0.0119591439,
-0.0643984973,
0.0131619424,
0.0174814854,
0.0017793765,
0.0588913299,
0.0392961241,
-0.0344204195,
0.0184361674,
-0.0078121941,
0.0422096364,
-0.0083903586,
-0.0044888821,
0.0201081987,
0.0010297806,
-0.0068406281,
0.0504864156,
0.061676871,
-0.0497064553,
0.0185682569,
-0.0016683358,
-0.036043182,
-0.0385750942,
-0.0053352425,
-0.0081984093,
-0.0210901797,
-0.0184421018,
-0.0616321638,
0.0165875852,
0.0226660743,
0.0533620603,
-0.0036912861,
0.0121545093,
-0.0264840536,
-0.0005850344,
-0.0172646679,
0.0279750843,
-0.047515884,
0.0013660903,
-0.0700362772,
-0.0310325213,
0.0659202784,
-0.0363133997,
0.001836216,
0.0054337461,
-0.1074807942,
-0.0722720772,
0.0129688308,
0.0223032292,
0.0177574102,
0.0252376162,
-0.0091611482,
-0.0777568966,
0.0371863395,
0.0019136872,
-0.0092410408,
0.055548206,
0.0258296896,
-0.0598572083,
-0.0307069458,
0.0320743136,
-0.0684324056,
0.005823609,
0.0422594994,
0.0609653816,
-0.0066706366,
-0.0783911794,
-0.0238710325,
0.0377702117,
0.0231402498,
-0.0440229438,
-0.0424678065,
-0.0401329994,
0.0326742195,
0.0072092661,
0.0118299723,
-0.0390363932,
-0.0148532251,
0.0232958999,
0.0318812206,
-0.0363612175,
-0.0156592466,
0.0003064917,
0.0652977601,
0.0001928363,
0.0370590687,
-0.0322946496,
0.007971284,
0.0168557707,
-0.0010942511,
-0.0238632485,
0.0306634828,
0.0307130404,
0.0080397325,
-0.0300763156,
0.0469356477,
0.0032223177,
0.0337096229,
-0.074741669,
0.030898802,
-0.0281784609,
-0.057997819,
-0.0808272511,
0.0273771752,
0.0581267998,
0.0029500518,
0.0833236054,
-0.0216466244,
-0.0226168707,
-0.0401328169,
0.0232213158,
-0.0191863608,
0.0027846028,
0.0148181953,
0.0062980126,
-0.0280419849,
0.0355459377,
0.0444300249,
0.0530915782,
0.0582225956,
-0.0127201509,
0.0210583322,
-0.0157462358,
-0.0210391879,
-0.0163566116,
-0.0245897975,
-0.0165907126,
0.0102056721,
-0.0179506168,
-0.0501274467,
0.0147295035,
-0.0379592851,
-0.0074045234,
-0.0041379128,
0.042706944,
0.0325818881,
-0.0254283436,
0.0233477149,
-0.0358886756,
-0.0459175967,
0.0141523154,
-0.0248749331,
0.0125552984,
-6.143658776e-33,
-0.0508974493,
0.0268107541,
0.0083591556,
0.026656596,
-0.04662003,
-0.0411212668,
-0.0140908612,
0.0147138909,
-0.0323981792,
-0.0413770638,
-0.0084777912,
-0.0171714034,
0.0248017609,
0.0359906368,
-0.0415160656,
-0.0024203442,
0.0810734332,
-0.020371953,
-0.0122797005,
0.0229236167,
0.0090722181,
0.0277506337,
0.0459970981,
-0.0244819354,
-0.048694808,
0.0033685148,
-0.0377409272,
0.0378245637,
-0.0067996639,
0.0558246747,
0.0175515935,
0.0352620929,
0.0087632034,
-0.0273505803,
-0.0455838852,
-0.0216474105,
-0.0739850402,
0.0014989057,
0.0287330113,
0.0270473734,
0.0029411339,
-0.0237441603,
0.0441039577,
0.0107332943,
-0.0084103988,
-0.017254401,
0.0128321862,
-0.059835352,
-0.0137246661,
-0.0361430794,
-0.0410553738,
0.042770911,
0.0141976271,
-0.0052117831,
0.024463024,
0.0290419962,
-0.0367310643,
0.0111691784,
-0.0342515334,
0.0016070351,
0.0723116249,
0.0715690926,
0.0591020286,
0.0506337546,
-0.0133648058,
-0.0085539836,
-0.0137779946,
-0.0168869793,
0.0297960788,
-0.0164857171,
0.0914441496,
0.0271125007,
0.0241816603,
0.0470236838,
-0.0142738326,
-0.0293245893,
-0.0760227516,
0.0052601532,
0.0072726645,
0.0148875527,
0.0172275193,
0.0148443058,
-0.0059301648,
-0.0100623742,
-0.0704430267,
0.0034657712,
-0.0383024663,
-0.0103893327,
0.0240851846,
0.0261637196,
-0.0392164402,
-0.0505385101,
0.0627864748,
-0.0474744588,
0.0196956247,
0.0271899607,
-0.0396773145,
0.0249020755,
-0.025199607,
0.0185532551,
-0.050190866,
-0.0760826916,
0.0343185961,
-0.0130012985,
0.003909226,
-0.0381828547,
0.0315972343,
0.0547410585,
-0.0515442938,
0.000347894,
0.0025220893,
0.0253432654,
-0.0081666959,
0.0530880727,
-0.0065621808,
-0.0294777639,
0.0078556975,
0.0333234593,
0.0088514937,
-0.0058216858,
0.0079104332,
-0.0152520007,
0.0303123705,
0.0304211099,
-0.0467478521,
0.0360593982,
0.0083668437,
0.0064522494,
0.0348370671,
-0.0295870546,
-0.0366059095,
0.0302307438,
2.438e-7,
0.0362506844,
0.0386068337,
0.0070505245,
-0.0185379274,
0.0183081552,
0.0209859032,
-0.0245276205,
0.0047050966,
0.0213953145,
0.0230810419,
0.0620718375,
0.0075398604,
0.0876106843,
-0.0028179248,
-0.06654948,
0.0396653339,
-0.0534852855,
0.0670118034,
-0.0283685382,
-0.0127993049,
-0.0115030799,
0.1132153645,
0.0226629972,
-0.0295340307,
0.0115995537,
-0.00481056,
0.0689923093,
-0.0415393338,
-0.027845053,
0.0339203812,
0.0033517906,
0.0476633869,
-0.0187224802,
-0.0219348073,
-0.0261599571,
0.0533079691,
-0.0215638988,
0.063638255,
0.0075451005,
-0.0173475184,
0.0356756896,
0.0046427594,
0.0097371703,
-0.0497204624,
0.052129399,
-0.0612162836,
-0.0021063823,
-0.0207694527,
-0.0014244398,
-0.0123166777,
-0.0117328428,
-0.0698816627,
-0.0181224998,
0.0378034003,
0.0434821509,
-0.0155339269,
-0.0373554341,
-0.0741481036,
0.0004119985,
0.0546646453,
-0.0394760408,
-0.0504340865,
-0.0276946463,
-0.0357484967,
0.0301744621,
-0.0402971618,
0.0270137619,
2.462676966e-34,
0.0395124219,
-0.0470207036,
0.0048264819,
-0.0217058621,
0.0043768091,
0.0120799895,
-0.0053879707,
0.0244803336,
-0.005758109,
-0.1097172052,
-0.0235213246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14986v2 | Interpreting Vision and Language Generative Models with Semantic Visual Priors | 2023-04-28T17:10:08 | 2023-05-04T15:25:00 | Michele Cafagna, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona, Kees van Deemter, Albert Gatt | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | When applied to Image-to-text models, interpretability methods often provide
token-by-token explanations namely, they compute a visual explanation for each
token of the generated sequence. Those explanations are expensive to compute
and unable to comprehensively explain the model's output. Therefore, these
models often require some sort of approximation that eventually leads to
misleading explanations. We develop a framework based on SHAP, that allows for
generating comprehensive, meaningful explanations leveraging the meaning
representation of the output sequence as a whole. Moreover, by exploiting
semantic priors in the visual backbone, we extract an arbitrary number of
features that allows the efficient computation of Shapley values on large-scale
models, generating at the same time highly meaningful visual explanations. We
demonstrate that our method generates semantically more expressive explanations
than traditional methods at a lower compute cost and that it can be generalized
over other explainability methods. | [
0.0048136851,
0.0762310103,
0.0057002292,
0.0460477062,
-0.015165464,
0.0428451374,
0.0170086902,
0.0003001982,
-0.0542154349,
-0.0020210631,
0.052754391,
-0.0182379726,
0.037484467,
0.0797218978,
0.0350081399,
-0.1142975986,
-0.0200816412,
-0.0259154662,
-0.0157587714,
0.0046401001,
0.0211722702,
0.0150047224,
0.0033782814,
0.0938796252,
-0.0210440215,
-0.033538796,
-0.0346312076,
0.0180806648,
0.0082277004,
0.0343939252,
-0.0936256275,
0.0434760489,
0.054352127,
-0.0126069207,
0.0000017162,
0.0056409379,
-0.0134551758,
0.0433945544,
-0.0253005326,
0.0291268658,
0.0192999896,
-0.0359957889,
0.0157692526,
-0.0202053227,
0.0036822844,
0.024202181,
0.0974328145,
0.0499689765,
0.0556922518,
0.0342998691,
-0.0085071456,
-0.0325606056,
0.0022504826,
-0.0049507157,
0.072752282,
-0.0261477716,
-0.0173236374,
0.0063724448,
-0.041856315,
-0.0181735512,
-0.0350150056,
0.024922464,
0.0510853231,
-0.0369943492,
0.0424367115,
0.0254354626,
0.0354517847,
-0.0647247881,
-0.0111297499,
0.0374795534,
-0.0616674721,
-0.0136662405,
0.0170770735,
-0.0229814537,
-0.0027909572,
0.0267872009,
-0.0541255549,
0.014361091,
0.0310148951,
0.0193816423,
-0.0225275047,
-0.00819539,
0.0410031117,
-0.0106271422,
0.0010936757,
-0.0101063661,
0.0010591001,
0.0654659197,
-0.0917244554,
0.0178590771,
-0.0427011028,
-0.0599388108,
-0.0170247573,
0.0402002148,
0.0060143289,
0.0213667061,
-0.0030351521,
0.0009617189,
-0.0113401711,
-0.0270603951,
0.0730071366,
0.0314851739,
-0.0438176394,
0.015098745,
-0.0171491075,
0.0498991311,
-0.0149564315,
0.006617011,
-0.0286042131,
-0.0099477591,
-0.0542373396,
-0.0342499241,
0.0094812689,
-0.0243555531,
-0.0543236434,
-0.0485567637,
-0.0069111749,
0.0047634123,
-0.0144259343,
0.0062931813,
0.0129100205,
0.0271089487,
-0.0382046364,
-0.0027116162,
-0.0416642018,
0.0057664048,
-0.0351999328,
-0.0107873743,
0.0106085073,
-0.0540029928,
-0.0169269443,
0.0225760341,
0.0193551667,
0.0245144349,
-0.0290459059,
0.078934446,
-0.0311612356,
-0.0162907895,
-0.0016657833,
-0.0495915823,
-0.0256473478,
-0.0164023433,
0.0138392225,
-0.035436742,
-0.0050564827,
0.0033160166,
0.0030900415,
-0.0558510572,
-0.0021508539,
-0.0087546296,
-0.0315791517,
0.0802385136,
-0.0214074384,
-0.0118571846,
-0.0407466106,
0.0150691876,
-0.0212075524,
0.0439579114,
0.029185852,
0.0651868656,
-0.0000205643,
-0.0284144487,
0.0145986788,
-0.016690148,
0.0286669731,
-0.0045500984,
-0.0425445698,
-0.0168938488,
-0.0280689746,
0.0014652439,
0.0434240699,
0.0183223821,
-0.0258347765,
-0.0346245728,
0.023776507,
0.0501520559,
0.0309574045,
0.0202227067,
0.0724516064,
0.0220641624,
-0.0278930441,
0.0270801894,
-0.0581979714,
0.0498164482,
0.0296377409,
0.0217051301,
-0.0041034804,
0.0048719705,
-0.0193700232,
-0.0516825989,
0.0053607374,
0.017216146,
-0.0308369529,
0.0193598028,
0.0300897956,
0.0269643515,
0.0053188251,
0.0161425397,
0.0173629653,
-0.047379408,
0.0159054995,
-0.042465385,
0.0636116192,
0.1007613391,
0.0334720239,
0.0197102781,
0.0277510118,
0.0284912642,
-0.0305711273,
0.0338479057,
-0.0513165742,
0.0040405984,
0.0552438907,
-0.0263789948,
-0.0494969375,
-0.0204637274,
0.001627168,
0.0243366435,
-0.0251730494,
-0.07275372,
0.0204526689,
-0.060870178,
-0.0397766046,
0.0341078974,
-0.000385979,
-0.0173662454,
-0.0147305103,
0.0170249734,
0.0120712621,
0.0232720282,
-0.0047963397,
0.008839353,
0.0065471735,
-0.0152087761,
0.0198884681,
0.023756111,
-0.0354085043,
-0.0144517077,
0.0040454362,
-0.0528939813,
-0.0083811181,
-0.0194078218,
-0.0534223169,
-0.0484569222,
0.0201069172,
-0.0448100455,
0.006558788,
-0.0370371193,
-0.0200020969,
0.0238362178,
0.0405774787,
0.0045090625,
0.0490678772,
-0.0390533805,
-0.0244739912,
0.001487765,
0.0096948091,
0.0203844905,
-0.0098546343,
0.0394759513,
0.0134601351,
-0.0081232172,
-0.0134219602,
0.0020504887,
-0.0255082641,
-0.0137983086,
0.0189004466,
-0.0174638126,
-0.0313505977,
-0.0162060168,
-0.0121610807,
0.0314147994,
-0.0047511598,
0.0381477252,
-0.0233790539,
-0.0317208283,
0.0463275015,
-0.0153956246,
0.0034777143,
0.0228026491,
0.0227176864,
-0.0286555178,
-0.0173548311,
-0.0331814028,
0.0211223401,
0.1119893268,
0.022410199,
0.0251256134,
-0.0573716611,
-0.0097837439,
-0.0099535007,
-0.0119732935,
-0.0216619093,
-0.0329530276,
0.0315933451,
-0.0345812663,
0.0224933308,
0.0307306983,
0.0175360925,
0.1048636436,
0.0249006841,
0.0276063364,
-0.0340112001,
-0.0573770627,
-0.0304927062,
0.0141413929,
-0.0175611377,
-0.0813855901,
-0.0416054726,
0.04851529,
-0.0249883346,
0.015193562,
-0.1041225567,
0.0328230299,
0.0388585739,
-0.073763296,
-0.0579154156,
0.0192278083,
0.0258129686,
0.0542755499,
-0.0460691862,
-0.0737786442,
0.0326695889,
-0.0473883934,
0.0155448969,
0.0628216192,
-0.0021225256,
-0.0031612308,
0.1056320742,
0.0346382372,
0.0198743008,
-0.0077642575,
-0.0130327484,
-0.0317384675,
-0.0296180882,
0.0241338983,
0.0066394759,
0.0112085314,
-0.0704668835,
-0.0026621302,
0.0058258106,
0.0422225334,
-0.0181231629,
-0.0189217441,
-0.012616151,
0.0138596715,
-0.0059070005,
-0.0315461904,
-0.0066751805,
0.0358056501,
0.0308620539,
-0.0143943783,
0.007703166,
-0.006862809,
-0.0219960902,
0.0106824767,
0.0618923418,
0.0035032628,
0.0195403919,
-0.0478262752,
0.0065695462,
0.0664087459,
0.0382109135,
0.0258987229,
-0.0806606784,
0.0349803381,
0.0047054393,
0.0206756424,
-0.0141677596,
0.0398459658,
0.0305531714,
-0.0739460662,
0.0036573471,
0.0746428892,
0.0108392816,
-0.0187278017,
0.0187116377,
-0.0040811305,
0.0409084521,
0.0146172047,
0.0034767115,
-0.0645651817,
-0.0453145802,
-0.0213312563,
-0.0040115765,
0.0081263417,
-0.0046822084,
-0.0159687735,
-0.0181317478,
0.0694653764,
-0.0076080002,
0.0104578147,
-0.0252701417,
-0.0111167934,
-0.0250076503,
-0.0358231962,
-0.0260670595,
-0.0021989318,
-0.0021100012,
0.059297245,
0.0422841609,
0.0305555779,
-0.0253296997,
0.0106165558,
-0.0026977311,
-0.0126505233,
0.0829426944,
0.0145944292,
0.0134481965,
-0.0538954288,
-0.0475122035,
0.0120275291,
0.0393501967,
-0.0160710774,
0.074785009,
-0.0018200746,
-0.0286703687,
-0.0117868828,
0.0384865664,
-0.018272737,
-0.0357315578,
-0.0481118113,
0.0131612103,
-0.0129844407,
-0.016661996,
-0.0062868241,
-0.0060526608,
0.0065042945,
0.0472373478,
0.0481445305,
-0.0263978038,
-0.0618829653,
-0.0419372469,
-0.0191679765,
-0.0389432423,
-0.0499845073,
-0.0007500239,
0.0232418552,
-0.0708187521,
-0.0201350562,
-0.0099918395,
0.0262734257,
0.0495365895,
-0.0268612877,
-0.0434839055,
-0.0004676193,
-0.0089996392,
-0.0470443852,
0.0651575029,
0.00441476,
0.0111477608,
-0.0149501404,
-0.0311897099,
-0.0199160893,
-0.071322836,
-0.0281055029,
0.0061281663,
-0.0381814204,
-0.0115334112,
-0.0002060328,
0.0505966395,
0.0188631434,
0.0361049175,
0.0101536158,
-0.0736331791,
0.0315405466,
0.028914094,
0.030898625,
-0.0156055717,
0.0224366821,
-0.0236880835,
0.0150374137,
0.0463754609,
-0.0210336875,
0.0293809827,
0.0181705114,
0.0346538574,
-0.0172533579,
0.0230422169,
0.0259542894,
-0.0097118095,
0.0448226854,
-0.0480250716,
-0.0201640967,
-0.0114764357,
-0.0296100639,
-0.0052263145,
-0.0045399084,
-0.088094227,
0.0336496197,
0.0102652898,
0.0015566808,
0.0241310988,
0.0003814469,
-0.0177961364,
-0.0102706328,
-0.0363410227,
-0.0082914084,
0.0227345824,
-0.0077831899,
-0.008113265,
0.0143118436,
-0.0048643043,
0.0012163225,
-0.0543141663,
0.0243281014,
0.0158662982,
0.0444598198,
0.0347976238,
0.0185740385,
-0.0275609642,
0.032484442,
-0.0638006255,
-0.0586538911,
-0.0024942048,
0.0433316864,
0.0337393656,
0.013571701,
0.0248313174,
-0.0340019166,
0.0023787336,
-0.0045758444,
0.0972186476,
0.0403421596,
-0.0692924187,
0.0281546917,
0.0202619396,
-0.0270410497,
-0.0564241037,
0.0669586435,
0.033682745,
0.0002071423,
-0.0128474152,
-0.02687582,
-0.0209533498,
-0.0566267781,
0.0063230721,
0.0240492057,
0.0015805045,
0.050743442,
-0.0064146211,
-0.0759328082,
-0.0444356911,
0.0483149365,
0.0251595508,
-0.004290604,
0.0202261358,
0.0464574248,
-0.006828818,
-0.0202322621,
-0.0377899371,
-0.0014321902,
-0.0323640332,
0.0251862761,
0.019221181,
-5.772928062e-33,
-0.0141567439,
-0.0722327381,
0.001119865,
-0.0169691909,
0.0199968405,
0.0131081333,
-0.0396717712,
-0.0143091613,
0.0045030098,
0.0515237451,
0.0325297378,
0.0390473567,
0.0076580192,
0.0599091128,
-0.0254629757,
-0.0154593335,
0.0465322137,
0.0384074412,
-0.0127087366,
0.0442199036,
0.047653418,
-0.0070304391,
0.0378558785,
-0.0193637535,
0.0078287032,
0.0174938571,
-0.0181229003,
-0.0027104365,
0.0018342447,
0.040687006,
-0.0396573171,
0.0003708612,
0.0128409062,
-0.0187467076,
-0.0281699449,
-0.0130809154,
-0.071037814,
0.0286276918,
0.0479022227,
0.042745959,
-0.1081526056,
-0.0188373104,
0.0230501965,
-0.0081267012,
0.0130197573,
-0.0642526969,
0.0369256884,
-0.0215931628,
-0.0321792737,
0.0381359905,
-0.026560992,
0.0056320052,
-0.0419880822,
-0.0299295578,
0.0537717305,
-0.0043590534,
0.0156464968,
0.0163166411,
0.0125260502,
-0.0093226982,
0.0210089926,
0.0229671355,
0.0974233523,
0.0560113564,
0.0167467706,
0.0336585119,
0.0396509692,
-0.0854058191,
-0.0327955149,
0.0067022163,
-0.0287347436,
0.0728538558,
0.0653424412,
0.0282321181,
0.0439337865,
0.0246226434,
-0.0424068607,
0.0281360485,
-0.0393359736,
0.032147646,
0.0590194054,
0.0122745568,
0.0032088682,
0.0040853312,
-0.0468546264,
-0.0505279638,
-0.0335436016,
-0.0229634568,
0.0138557451,
-0.0097039789,
-0.0637747124,
0.0710787252,
0.0324789733,
-0.0277217235,
0.0240113251,
0.0110883946,
-0.0270261727,
0.0275320802,
0.02109061,
0.0127701703,
0.0161345359,
-0.0067823962,
0.0491345823,
-0.0117881717,
0.0182510614,
0.0114477603,
0.0281184297,
0.0057441881,
0.0189757906,
-0.0034908648,
-0.0785798579,
-0.0128761614,
-0.0251191147,
0.0100308554,
0.0255797766,
-0.0007001392,
-0.0701048076,
0.0187336579,
-0.0280983187,
0.0168269929,
0.0390948765,
-0.0275185686,
-0.021478435,
0.0269266944,
-0.0601725131,
-0.0227046795,
-0.0506398082,
-0.0576526932,
0.0722500607,
-0.0353466645,
-0.0364863165,
0.0498535149,
2.325e-7,
0.0299462415,
-0.0051877256,
0.0237098299,
0.0331925899,
0.0260703415,
0.0458405986,
0.0258627031,
-0.0000681099,
-0.0236065686,
-0.0561718792,
0.0021754708,
0.0559915788,
0.0597053915,
-0.0110307308,
0.0330590829,
-0.0055773738,
-0.0536446869,
0.0034535297,
-0.0273587015,
0.0353416689,
0.0723630562,
0.0600969978,
-0.0269193742,
-0.0046695019,
0.1200498492,
0.0014536279,
0.0576973408,
-0.0301535148,
0.0358802192,
-0.038235303,
-0.0108721638,
-0.0278750472,
0.0258745495,
-0.0053194915,
-0.0241328571,
-0.0432613976,
0.0026429335,
0.0487265959,
-0.0420025215,
-0.0183979552,
-0.0641040355,
-0.041209504,
0.0262128916,
-0.069365114,
0.0472926162,
-0.0056681358,
-0.0595946722,
-0.0126415612,
-0.0363322683,
-0.017336417,
-0.0335881673,
0.0003787265,
-0.0045105256,
0.0189181361,
0.0187693629,
-0.0604613535,
-0.0129156178,
-0.0483391434,
-0.0322647505,
-0.0321054198,
-0.0165882558,
0.0308452547,
-0.0637758076,
-0.0295007639,
0.0411135778,
-0.0295035243,
-0.0913311914,
1.786830621e-34,
0.0122339288,
0.0340985768,
0.0148414364,
-0.007218475,
0.0341016613,
0.0106298793,
-0.0180440694,
-0.0016138477,
0.0277805645,
-0.047851216,
-0.0528949313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14953v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14953v2 | CCpdf: Building a High Quality Corpus for Visually Rich Documents from Web Crawl Data | 2023-04-28T16:12:18 | 2023-06-06T07:35:17 | Michał Turski, Tomasz Stanisławek, Karol Kaczmarek, Paweł Dyda, Filip Graliński | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the field of document understanding has progressed a lot. A
significant part of this progress has been possible thanks to the use of
language models pretrained on large amounts of documents. However, pretraining
corpora used in the domain of document understanding are single domain,
monolingual, or nonpublic. Our goal in this paper is to propose an efficient
pipeline for creating a big-scale, diverse, multilingual corpus of PDF files
from all over the Internet using Common Crawl, as PDF files are the most
canonical types of documents as considered in document understanding. We
analysed extensively all of the steps of the pipeline and proposed a solution
which is a trade-off between data quality and processing time. We also share a
CCpdf corpus in a form or an index of PDF files along with a script for
downloading them, which produces a collection useful for language model
pretraining. The dataset and tools published with this paper offer researchers
the opportunity to develop even better multilingual language models. | [
0.0232551675,
0.0099701108,
0.0091592362,
0.0333477072,
-0.0273807477,
0.0392342024,
-0.0041662352,
0.0113910688,
0.0155970082,
-0.0326137058,
-0.0405119695,
-0.0135835167,
-0.002324461,
0.0031014362,
-0.021418035,
-0.0299089886,
0.011947277,
-0.0309112072,
-0.0456426851,
0.0006296838,
0.0215676408,
0.0055197855,
0.0266653653,
-0.0295362249,
0.016305536,
-0.044042334,
-0.0311882235,
0.0332237147,
-0.0057761646,
0.0028991029,
-0.0031813034,
0.0112665314,
0.0494494773,
0.0586149432,
0.0000019205,
-0.0482943952,
-0.0484770425,
0.0268739313,
0.0352256745,
0.0051307254,
0.0794910789,
-0.0611879341,
0.0020905402,
-0.0017054714,
-0.0058295014,
-0.0167726446,
0.0087044211,
0.0535578057,
0.0541111417,
0.0747220069,
-0.0218338296,
-0.0434716791,
0.0005349756,
-0.0229163617,
-0.029233044,
-0.0513815954,
-0.018568296,
0.0357252657,
0.0564906634,
0.0236185007,
-0.0172345284,
0.0030433764,
-0.0119684245,
-0.0540357791,
-0.0297406781,
-0.0114672845,
-0.0286808126,
-0.0401785336,
0.0010437903,
0.0457907319,
-0.0464922339,
-0.0319695212,
0.0120511819,
0.0183833577,
-0.0339872204,
0.0418270491,
-0.0580929518,
0.0085506337,
-0.0345337018,
0.0115993517,
0.005199403,
-0.0000167819,
0.0424233936,
0.0305919591,
-0.031853158,
0.0558039211,
-0.0133081125,
-0.0364259109,
0.0426935591,
0.0168645773,
0.0198157132,
0.0003432477,
0.0560539737,
0.0311572738,
0.0384517945,
0.0075753103,
-0.0452125184,
-0.0789078176,
0.0541979149,
-0.029165132,
-0.0372654684,
-0.0082773035,
-0.0558545962,
0.1050814465,
-0.0325374641,
0.0314929448,
-0.0159933511,
-0.0153091755,
-0.0481473021,
-0.0301108956,
0.0005071371,
0.0165890567,
-0.0515205637,
0.024050355,
-0.0302105062,
-0.0313875563,
0.0143196844,
0.0453050435,
0.0036329336,
0.0342232101,
0.0090998095,
-0.0445974618,
-0.0304034688,
-0.0252908487,
0.0070864218,
0.0500369594,
-0.0411743112,
0.0087125022,
-0.043386519,
-0.0458152369,
0.0001364814,
0.0487423874,
0.043136768,
-0.0211572628,
0.0204857029,
0.0429241695,
0.0151348589,
-0.0244535878,
-0.0343081653,
-0.0067361649,
0.0417362191,
-0.0338611268,
-0.0028318248,
-0.0672044605,
0.0345275961,
0.0063049244,
0.0580800585,
0.0011419847,
-0.019587012,
-0.0022808025,
-0.005267154,
0.0672411919,
-0.0436133929,
-0.0099970456,
0.0450639464,
-0.0261114277,
-0.0100987805,
0.077825807,
-0.0112980055,
0.0407908037,
0.0731075928,
-0.0371894427,
0.0043387311,
0.0398115292,
-0.0190423485,
-0.0244040247,
0.0923833475,
0.000458053,
-0.0163203981,
-0.0112931635,
0.0411407575,
0.0100351451,
-0.0462991931,
-0.0017611453,
-0.0009359491,
0.0609160066,
0.0178257525,
-0.0075169471,
0.0119743077,
0.0472793765,
0.0265053641,
0.0208962336,
0.0045172041,
-0.0446144156,
0.0037255611,
0.0002917292,
-0.0470333509,
0.0231273975,
-0.0123866769,
-0.0148519771,
-0.0032481649,
0.001056883,
0.0529410802,
-0.0064820256,
0.1007885039,
0.0310832877,
-0.0388223156,
-0.0683548898,
0.0001730992,
-0.0547816008,
0.0306487586,
-0.0020429844,
-0.0011670527,
0.0540020727,
0.0830273926,
-0.0378149375,
-0.0192966796,
-0.0060380674,
0.0325709619,
0.0301286113,
0.0284651443,
-0.0276350845,
0.0175222382,
-0.0843367279,
-0.0318265595,
-0.0060059428,
-0.0309944768,
0.0281807799,
-0.0318667293,
0.0013810492,
0.0216195881,
-0.0804753825,
-0.0505878292,
0.0302678272,
0.0174618829,
-0.0351293571,
-0.0106464671,
0.0112579428,
0.0158339497,
0.0271402076,
-0.0357915498,
0.0095605515,
0.0160167497,
-0.0020715084,
-0.0007212096,
0.0325813033,
0.0594392195,
0.0045011309,
0.0364653058,
-0.0678201988,
0.0179087576,
-0.0022268724,
-0.0261982586,
-0.0216815881,
0.0093208402,
-0.0181763172,
0.0567623712,
-0.0483889095,
0.0311505403,
-0.0124297626,
0.0352759287,
-0.0321087576,
0.0401638038,
0.0473254509,
0.0239353571,
0.0146116978,
0.0341245458,
0.0239655599,
-0.0633675531,
-0.0260089803,
0.0288804732,
-0.0152233494,
0.036059618,
0.0433655456,
0.0397529677,
-0.0387157835,
0.0040506506,
-0.0592004247,
-0.0041988706,
-0.0171732455,
0.0279643014,
-0.0006145975,
-0.0117677525,
-0.0155063737,
-0.046434328,
-0.0321724787,
0.0118622566,
0.0192240328,
-0.0153187159,
0.0398954116,
-0.0133213382,
0.0278738886,
0.0054477947,
-0.0206473898,
0.0141500719,
0.0185199119,
0.0476248451,
-0.0525735803,
-0.0226997416,
0.0672753528,
0.0391419418,
0.0129972827,
-0.03385159,
-0.0023918857,
-0.008734785,
-0.0365329385,
-0.0160720162,
0.0891231596,
-0.0040814322,
0.0413205847,
0.006036371,
-0.0381832831,
-0.071695298,
0.0137057928,
-0.0125601832,
0.00852919,
-0.0358924046,
-0.0234479066,
0.0747055784,
0.0394608639,
-0.0345918238,
-0.0020289919,
-0.0297549833,
-0.0595402867,
-0.0461675152,
-0.0264506061,
-0.0640375689,
-0.0103281885,
0.0351054743,
0.0393954068,
0.0003197372,
-0.0501095615,
0.0330810472,
-0.0680931881,
0.0173629485,
-0.0904226899,
0.0248203129,
-0.0303630847,
0.0450456776,
0.0033177591,
0.0374396406,
0.0057935086,
-0.0231083632,
-0.0011875503,
0.0519679338,
0.0822490081,
-0.0335159935,
-0.0300927181,
-0.0287316721,
0.0315527469,
-0.0198460016,
-0.0350304581,
-0.0200010277,
-0.0076112631,
0.0014827729,
-0.0218651723,
-0.0011717383,
-0.0143559966,
-0.0635874122,
0.0473965779,
0.0142011065,
0.052912429,
-0.0076092253,
-0.0228713416,
0.0035142177,
0.0715665147,
0.0480197482,
-0.0060379091,
0.0096491165,
-0.0477746539,
0.0127920015,
0.0420893431,
-0.0172711723,
-0.0166429635,
-0.0046879612,
0.0221282393,
0.0230861716,
-0.054301396,
-0.0111511275,
-0.0604301281,
-0.027378466,
-0.0431462266,
-0.0008343258,
0.0691243708,
0.0341088884,
-0.0755388364,
-0.0555018112,
-0.0351952761,
-0.0346564576,
0.0052724038,
0.0243794862,
-0.1037634313,
0.0014366471,
0.0128159383,
0.0378665142,
0.0151904635,
0.013635858,
0.0041084797,
-0.0700937733,
0.0270214025,
0.0094321081,
-0.0000293168,
-0.0248412397,
-0.0605232902,
-0.0161034204,
-0.0130767468,
-0.0479131378,
0.0133405076,
-0.0001335673,
-0.0125313979,
0.0249787588,
0.0064048497,
-0.0251538213,
-0.0147319762,
-0.0331923664,
-0.0592223294,
0.0721720308,
0.0479384176,
-0.0052509173,
0.0117586907,
0.0045223958,
-0.0432029516,
-0.0160454549,
-0.0200150721,
0.0306808706,
-0.0303953383,
0.0034608087,
-0.0152178071,
0.0303455405,
-0.050321456,
-0.0110603422,
0.0302526541,
0.0189924072,
-0.0454845764,
-0.0249130037,
-0.0317373164,
-0.0467773937,
-0.0467252284,
0.0436930023,
-0.0169692338,
-0.0301782656,
-0.0191224702,
-0.0323724188,
0.0040824055,
-0.0303275678,
0.0197400525,
0.0259822607,
-0.0479291193,
-0.0519765578,
-0.0763447285,
-0.0579348467,
-0.00483872,
0.0459791012,
0.0223353598,
-0.0134218782,
0.009859344,
0.0167550351,
-0.0760606229,
0.0608945303,
0.0195780024,
-0.0174668338,
-0.0682845637,
-0.0322933383,
0.0406166427,
-0.0258223247,
-0.0078006368,
0.0250463709,
-0.0572581999,
-0.0039161709,
-0.0199061353,
0.0115123959,
0.0181301143,
0.0163570996,
-0.0705043674,
-0.042620834,
0.0379517749,
0.0127669899,
-0.0157736447,
-0.0407223143,
0.0342567973,
-0.037551932,
-0.0242095776,
0.0133153936,
-0.0518753268,
0.0250621513,
-0.0369731374,
0.0068757129,
-0.0264328942,
-0.0158775095,
0.0275153667,
0.0536590181,
0.008397718,
-0.0276852343,
0.0298838392,
-0.0275042448,
0.007131686,
-0.0209251847,
-0.0481760614,
-0.0143219307,
0.0115870452,
0.0510551892,
-0.0259227194,
-0.0075558778,
0.0797695071,
0.0194769427,
0.0145765869,
-0.0077874269,
0.0305272453,
0.053464599,
0.0175575186,
-0.0064737317,
-0.0005136957,
0.0069706296,
-0.020445006,
-0.0149699422,
0.0421163999,
0.007595601,
0.0322266556,
0.0310603902,
0.0048162262,
-0.0129672289,
0.0313231125,
-0.042353604,
0.0053842291,
-0.0326611772,
0.0027561458,
0.0592949279,
-0.0472741686,
0.0729972422,
-0.043383278,
-0.0400179476,
-0.0151741849,
0.0307988953,
0.0817189962,
-0.0075958958,
0.0163700469,
0.0341302231,
-0.0146583635,
-0.019994406,
0.1012316421,
-0.0502580628,
-0.0172965489,
0.0189766064,
-0.0219292976,
-0.0553388335,
0.0189051386,
0.014353957,
0.0166718569,
-0.0050117336,
-0.0048267688,
-0.0168051552,
-0.020086525,
0.0136879254,
0.0156248668,
0.0043215533,
0.0402487665,
0.0622134432,
0.1087455675,
0.0056385775,
0.0267971251,
-0.0570709109,
0.0573672317,
-0.0221512336,
-0.0366947912,
-0.013313611,
-5.466501664e-33,
-0.0188981611,
-0.0275698546,
-0.0284972936,
0.0208265223,
0.0129304146,
0.0042380369,
-0.0189539567,
-0.0594890974,
-0.0022747247,
0.0092245946,
-0.0397617407,
0.0113870716,
0.036453817,
-0.0136339515,
-0.0214287881,
0.0429379568,
0.0520907901,
0.0076397252,
-0.0326933712,
0.0061664237,
0.0521935709,
0.029013006,
0.0537601151,
-0.0480848141,
0.0377578735,
-0.0025417034,
-0.0580895878,
-0.0238854419,
0.0837268233,
0.0443368219,
-0.0318506844,
0.0229074024,
0.0289435703,
0.0093671586,
-0.0074766688,
0.0426797718,
-0.0974678621,
-0.0024470398,
0.0024529542,
0.0769424066,
0.0333808325,
-0.0305315219,
0.0182829909,
-0.0594846718,
0.0211898722,
0.037738625,
0.0646820217,
-0.0239104535,
-0.0134687535,
-0.0697978511,
-0.0494726487,
0.0485270023,
-0.0351188891,
-0.0093383342,
0.0713659301,
0.029421581,
-0.0107441293,
0.0752928257,
-0.0418433212,
0.0421006233,
-0.0007220618,
0.029003961,
0.0728294998,
-0.0047616246,
0.0532195605,
0.0133028934,
-0.0064985002,
-0.0292260963,
0.0339320935,
0.0284741763,
0.0634811968,
-0.0099951671,
-0.005727456,
0.0802357644,
0.0342005044,
-0.0119483033,
-0.0322506204,
0.0761585832,
0.05223497,
0.0480847955,
-0.0229996517,
-0.0009139505,
-0.0213435441,
0.0157762803,
-0.008189843,
-0.0245088208,
-0.0007196745,
-0.0305264164,
-0.0041980189,
0.0033182139,
-0.0144728739,
-0.0287620816,
0.0317391194,
-0.0405514315,
-0.0386205316,
0.0260429867,
-0.0283141751,
0.0173669383,
-0.0097495196,
0.0029408722,
0.0205418225,
-0.0432554334,
-0.0028850131,
-0.0226398464,
-0.0230976585,
-0.0145781757,
0.0348326787,
0.0171974245,
-0.037910413,
-0.0053056609,
-0.013973359,
-0.0272682775,
0.0042166207,
0.0639482364,
0.0059626349,
0.0111936787,
-0.016813647,
0.0392369926,
0.0246813744,
0.0260588601,
-0.0323321112,
-0.0054091229,
-0.0175085869,
0.0333860815,
-0.0086612338,
-0.0197192281,
-0.0052657174,
-0.0072757448,
0.0315820351,
-0.0796217769,
0.0064201695,
0.0178710166,
2.614e-7,
0.0602609925,
0.0255454537,
0.0493412577,
0.0102532636,
0.0153320469,
-0.0041002017,
-0.0299388226,
0.0411800034,
-0.0504104272,
0.018171696,
0.014645963,
-0.0076055755,
0.0597765036,
0.022040097,
-0.1057739034,
-0.0127624199,
0.0231362619,
-0.0343431793,
-0.0433659591,
0.0119243506,
-0.0175642669,
0.1116708145,
-0.033502914,
0.0011601774,
0.0232147574,
-0.0625677258,
0.0565003231,
-0.030543942,
-0.0187342092,
0.0222224332,
0.0672300085,
-0.0239288248,
-0.0196916666,
-0.0118398527,
-0.023398485,
0.0422558933,
0.0539912172,
0.0303492285,
0.016121313,
0.0172646139,
-0.005164864,
-0.0701924488,
0.0061321631,
-0.0463632792,
0.0626019463,
0.0171025209,
-0.0292875264,
0.0010883842,
-0.0408639833,
-0.0258526169,
0.0120324483,
-0.0493344404,
-0.0502009802,
0.0483653657,
0.0394881442,
-0.0329926386,
0.0067756549,
-0.0458775535,
0.0031702572,
-0.0021470657,
-0.0096379565,
-0.0182503369,
-0.0107812854,
-0.026983764,
0.0259703528,
-0.007484891,
0.0175212063,
1.917614355e-34,
0.0821376443,
-0.014354513,
-0.0244988445,
-0.0057396651,
-0.0006418777,
-0.0413980931,
-0.044388365,
0.0206664409,
0.0076123266,
-0.0662882775,
0.016633166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14936v1 | Information Redundancy and Biases in Public Document Information Extraction Benchmarks | 2023-04-28T15:48:26 | 2023-04-28T15:48:26 | Seif Laatiri, Pirashanth Ratnamogan, Joel Tang, Laurent Lam, William Vanhuffel, Fabien Caspani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Advances in the Visually-rich Document Understanding (VrDU) field and
particularly the Key-Information Extraction (KIE) task are marked with the
emergence of efficient Transformer-based approaches such as the LayoutLM
models. Despite the good performance of KIE models when fine-tuned on public
benchmarks, they still struggle to generalize on complex real-life use-cases
lacking sufficient document annotations. Our research highlighted that KIE
standard benchmarks such as SROIE and FUNSD contain significant similarity
between training and testing documents and can be adjusted to better evaluate
the generalization of models. In this work, we designed experiments to quantify
the information redundancy in public benchmarks, revealing a 75% template
replication in SROIE official test set and 16% in FUNSD. We also proposed
resampling strategies to provide benchmarks more representative of the
generalization ability of models. We showed that models not suited for document
analysis struggle on the adjusted splits dropping on average 10,5% F1 score on
SROIE and 3.5% on FUNSD compared to multi-modal models dropping only 7,5% F1 on
SROIE and 0.5% F1 on FUNSD. | [
0.0463736244,
0.012673825,
0.0413665771,
0.0357541069,
-0.0246907268,
0.0380819961,
-0.0050568981,
0.0293240882,
-0.0380233563,
-0.0615928955,
-0.0463725924,
0.0300470628,
0.0114984522,
0.0079259071,
-0.0292294063,
-0.0631085634,
0.0099405823,
-0.0040318905,
0.0054677362,
0.0361512005,
0.0059720767,
-0.0050207758,
0.0075385571,
-0.0307894181,
-0.0279328786,
-0.0217514988,
-0.0314796939,
0.0256091338,
0.0050405269,
-0.0100416662,
-0.0298070814,
0.0343284085,
0.018553311,
0.0287831463,
0.0000020608,
-0.030687945,
-0.0328066386,
0.0402491763,
-0.0194971934,
0.0317598619,
0.0519212522,
-0.0647137538,
0.0174445361,
-0.0529717058,
0.0067028119,
-0.049844265,
0.0292231869,
0.1173224375,
0.0010746663,
0.0802745372,
-0.0286376495,
-0.0440246426,
0.059702035,
-0.0373451747,
0.0087272553,
-0.0576735698,
0.026948113,
0.0022889634,
-0.0270043947,
0.0159933865,
-0.0047455616,
0.0456428938,
0.0150964623,
-0.0059203915,
-0.0100739673,
0.0353966504,
-0.0356372446,
-0.0358016118,
-0.0152434316,
0.0854925513,
-0.0038626916,
0.0150914015,
0.0339167863,
-0.0176965781,
0.0013778589,
0.0505869426,
-0.0736818686,
-0.0016197797,
-0.0615339354,
-0.0168836918,
0.0203022957,
0.0237042084,
0.0092730299,
-0.0176001173,
-0.0111987591,
-0.0225193109,
-0.0036573897,
-0.0478452407,
0.0193725396,
0.0331052057,
-0.0044554509,
-0.0114363404,
0.004239988,
-0.0135202333,
0.056727685,
0.0188001711,
-0.027612431,
-0.0782090127,
0.0195936318,
-0.0579404496,
0.002975317,
-0.0237225126,
-0.0388681255,
0.0888109654,
-0.0346282572,
0.0718846247,
-0.012157863,
0.0676729158,
0.0013286457,
-0.003847505,
-0.0291375108,
-0.001369983,
-0.0012494652,
0.0395383015,
-0.0057798186,
-0.0448173881,
0.0369678549,
0.03459033,
0.0222053807,
0.0408507697,
0.0103271548,
-0.0258451123,
-0.0434104577,
-0.0364076607,
0.0250596832,
0.0250960644,
-0.0008313822,
-0.0302226711,
-0.0235366877,
-0.026684504,
0.0326119252,
0.0111516947,
0.0313581787,
-0.0137412976,
-0.0068699918,
0.0275528021,
-0.0269368198,
-0.0391420498,
-0.0289550554,
-0.0165032689,
0.0201717243,
-0.0390194133,
0.0487649031,
-0.0394040681,
0.0467021875,
0.0228795987,
-0.0009422394,
-0.0193653647,
-0.0277183559,
-0.0197247937,
-0.0601459704,
0.0495393984,
0.020935351,
0.0140854316,
0.0232118983,
0.0364442915,
0.0105004078,
0.0827134922,
-0.0046154843,
0.0304220468,
0.0749931112,
-0.0328759551,
0.0228937156,
0.0462513044,
-0.0067949533,
-0.0105017982,
0.052611798,
0.0028352318,
-0.0130051626,
-0.0111991735,
0.0406274274,
0.0140864979,
-0.0554917157,
-0.0295904502,
0.0297114048,
0.0206503794,
0.0770433024,
0.010938203,
-0.0133227911,
0.0257111117,
0.0250958875,
0.0493215509,
-0.0344970524,
-0.0181562304,
0.0195875596,
0.0643971562,
-0.0167349689,
0.0149686364,
-0.0255164765,
-0.0108974278,
-0.0301423967,
-0.0017198884,
-0.0130235348,
-0.0196200702,
0.1127803475,
0.0085504064,
-0.0516121611,
0.066839546,
0.0095053231,
-0.0510424711,
-0.0338686742,
-0.0088414773,
0.0119990464,
0.0175532252,
0.0694305375,
-0.031297192,
-0.0200989656,
0.0116318194,
0.0024398915,
0.0165842716,
0.0454108082,
-0.0340022296,
0.0428162105,
-0.0518688001,
-0.0640087426,
-0.0050897822,
0.0017726446,
-0.0038324513,
0.0256492738,
-0.0241374783,
0.0293338373,
-0.1073468179,
-0.0071795899,
0.0403412543,
-0.0027788356,
-0.0368377939,
-0.030780578,
0.008292567,
0.0032793167,
0.0153530082,
-0.0357289091,
-0.0249511804,
0.046295546,
0.0040977369,
0.0574153364,
-0.0074420744,
-0.0268880129,
0.0032716969,
-0.0034994294,
-0.0471642241,
-0.000631878,
0.0729590058,
-0.0519319139,
-0.0129381791,
-0.0473638102,
0.035252329,
0.0402509607,
-0.0039957394,
0.0135512892,
-0.0122454483,
-0.0009342253,
-0.0349859484,
0.0504030883,
-0.0074751279,
0.0079590166,
-0.021357432,
-0.0361663587,
0.0091367643,
-0.0293947887,
-0.0063945856,
-0.0034216056,
-0.0335583501,
-0.0141256535,
0.013125536,
0.0161743052,
-0.0303403083,
-0.0315313227,
-0.082307674,
-0.0104479454,
-0.0240936223,
0.0456184335,
0.0416793972,
0.0094047813,
-0.0305087827,
-0.0294246022,
-0.0091629075,
-0.0424575396,
-0.0407627374,
0.001261537,
0.0268667955,
0.0211506411,
0.0267584827,
-0.0061993035,
-0.030273756,
0.0110099763,
0.0706605092,
0.0403165519,
-0.0423826948,
-0.0201706495,
0.0490058586,
0.0334210135,
-0.0013126128,
-0.0338377096,
0.0348577052,
0.0059315111,
-0.0144140106,
0.0266305283,
0.0696595907,
0.0076232082,
0.0276636276,
-0.029612707,
-0.0088813463,
-0.0856691301,
-0.0038992218,
-0.0205531307,
0.0334235989,
-0.0325699002,
-0.0501724444,
0.0621789955,
0.034154918,
-0.0292192716,
0.0439313054,
-0.00519107,
-0.021497054,
0.0114038112,
-0.0260754097,
-0.0367234759,
0.0123683233,
0.0251196027,
0.0288241971,
-0.0229453389,
-0.0100007141,
0.0203691069,
-0.0540715568,
-0.0003271993,
-0.02000775,
0.0472792089,
-0.0383924544,
0.0516860224,
0.0042657326,
0.0025358717,
0.0271311849,
-0.0189432558,
0.0102772117,
-0.0012214014,
0.019988358,
-0.0257383268,
0.0722443387,
-0.0117107304,
0.0341601968,
-0.0347252786,
-0.0270778667,
-0.0176495407,
-0.0475549549,
0.0041885623,
-0.022253409,
-0.0087716319,
-0.0169744194,
-0.035182029,
0.0580698811,
0.0176537056,
0.0672963038,
-0.0225550234,
-0.0448027551,
0.0098020248,
0.1072897986,
0.0355214626,
-0.0252233502,
0.0182603877,
-0.0288363136,
0.0114200227,
0.0494841821,
0.0193605684,
0.0145644024,
-0.0180387758,
-0.0225246586,
-0.0018418212,
-0.0337760411,
-0.0143886963,
-0.0220241249,
0.0040964242,
-0.0685634613,
0.0087390793,
0.103182897,
0.0028125395,
-0.0644191578,
-0.0593141578,
-0.0312489327,
0.0218900293,
-0.0213216916,
-0.0000830149,
-0.0885245875,
-0.0101584857,
0.0152448816,
0.0389613584,
0.0074219545,
-0.0226365011,
0.008619274,
-0.0850688368,
0.0626165867,
-0.0197243262,
-0.0122810081,
-0.0127458582,
-0.0749256089,
0.0221955758,
-0.0322149843,
0.0017755884,
0.0090903481,
-0.0614397526,
-0.0228228718,
0.0162521601,
-0.0421994552,
-0.0681586415,
-0.0181322955,
-0.0202662367,
-0.0288169943,
0.0069045643,
0.0115257986,
-0.0202399269,
-0.0072825616,
0.0446692631,
0.0101227863,
0.0167760327,
-0.0204233713,
0.0809221044,
-0.0253211539,
0.0180898737,
-0.0371804461,
0.0148075866,
-0.0112530012,
0.0083367219,
0.0011568256,
0.0129963718,
0.0062349048,
-0.0285009723,
-0.0165539552,
-0.0462432615,
-0.0485554934,
0.0717881694,
0.0395726115,
0.0101016071,
-0.0527243949,
0.0107141333,
0.0501029342,
-0.0371536687,
-0.0026472427,
0.0200631954,
-0.0621638112,
-0.0525919087,
-0.0622137785,
-0.0452844463,
-0.0111929206,
0.0259939115,
-0.022465948,
-0.0392122343,
-0.0272826497,
-0.0128466031,
-0.0615769289,
0.0597219393,
-0.0024422708,
-0.0392517522,
-0.0628733113,
0.0299149752,
0.0045601372,
-0.0266509783,
-0.0390853398,
0.0067547644,
-0.0651513264,
-0.0113480436,
0.0437214971,
0.0095087783,
0.0202001911,
0.0670410544,
0.0103574498,
-0.0117902104,
0.0263032969,
0.0180473626,
-0.0290897693,
-0.0167168248,
0.0482967533,
-0.0689080283,
-0.0204524808,
-0.01207841,
-0.0479946136,
0.024341708,
0.0095091509,
-0.0051295264,
-0.0072288979,
0.0119737126,
-0.0240896419,
0.0477939844,
0.0496478081,
0.0086746225,
0.0224354435,
-0.028733613,
0.0190685522,
0.0031166889,
0.0037737039,
-0.0182157978,
0.0229395442,
0.0151266241,
0.0141852014,
-0.0187318958,
0.0866337121,
0.0114385709,
0.0519843735,
-0.0707278326,
0.0025089914,
0.0516343936,
-0.004038034,
-0.0147340791,
-0.0291058999,
-0.0264505278,
0.0128693348,
0.0169041213,
0.0427368917,
-0.0073140915,
0.0492708497,
0.0073762056,
-0.0106794769,
0.002547456,
0.0476640277,
-0.0579625629,
-0.0234235656,
-0.0353693366,
0.0065600593,
0.0200567376,
-0.0300083589,
0.0544412211,
-0.0248324983,
-0.0096493037,
-0.0035580327,
-0.0054716021,
0.028847361,
0.0291134752,
0.0071324417,
0.0270112101,
0.0039710905,
0.0210166574,
0.0838672966,
0.0096113747,
0.0232528057,
-0.0276738293,
-0.0362837128,
-0.049416285,
0.0120112151,
0.035500247,
0.00510026,
-0.014277162,
-0.0557572059,
-0.0385373421,
0.0054323855,
0.0544277765,
-0.0043818951,
0.0041409363,
0.013345276,
0.0088096801,
0.0880494341,
0.0065050661,
-0.014644363,
-0.0275968611,
-0.008537543,
-0.0232404023,
-0.0192162767,
0.0283801109,
-6.712104335e-33,
-0.0054110964,
0.0187719353,
-0.0197508503,
0.0346823484,
-0.0262642372,
0.0576756783,
-0.0224564485,
-0.038503509,
-0.0021942384,
0.0114605166,
-0.0326094553,
-0.0162406676,
0.0362788737,
0.0157058146,
0.0076020211,
-0.003657531,
0.0426132828,
0.0156868082,
-0.0696162805,
0.0238274746,
0.0290854722,
0.0362510346,
0.0819737017,
-0.086330846,
0.0294391364,
0.0012034904,
0.0096350657,
-0.020687351,
0.0488652438,
0.0560713485,
-0.0136798583,
-0.0068400018,
0.0785545185,
-0.0739391893,
-0.0181288198,
0.0452906638,
-0.1433656812,
0.0165386871,
0.0148113128,
0.0448631346,
-0.0080305627,
-0.0104241632,
0.0587840043,
-0.0150502427,
0.0329557732,
-0.067744717,
0.044241067,
-0.0171221849,
-0.0422324613,
-0.04535776,
-0.0509734862,
0.0555900224,
0.0167475287,
0.0144740939,
0.0470440872,
0.0451099202,
0.0091116643,
0.0466085561,
-0.0762450993,
-0.0208833441,
0.0540904514,
0.00403084,
0.0767361745,
0.0289698578,
-0.0109031592,
0.0336268581,
0.0153723406,
-0.0298703816,
-0.0084612025,
-0.0114192227,
0.0343949497,
0.0558777191,
-0.0021476832,
0.0429760404,
0.0419112705,
0.0283058211,
-0.0373100974,
0.0507471263,
-0.0088977367,
0.0312080327,
0.0285967365,
0.012107701,
-0.0801818073,
0.0162350722,
-0.0247888714,
0.0070930538,
-0.0209101327,
-0.0132337054,
0.0269341413,
0.0332541391,
-0.0376494303,
0.0415550098,
0.0414663441,
-0.0161678735,
-0.0050960789,
0.0356614627,
0.0143475896,
0.0760591552,
-0.0431250036,
-0.069802016,
-0.0504352748,
-0.0166410841,
0.0391639955,
0.0324171484,
-0.0176024735,
-0.0236874428,
0.0508736633,
-0.0159259904,
-0.0461257361,
-0.0193597376,
-0.0060894592,
-0.0307363104,
0.0010667859,
0.0353994071,
0.0289865211,
-0.0064472756,
-0.0458372012,
0.0415711626,
0.0222619046,
0.0393238068,
0.0035880229,
0.0021438217,
0.0163979046,
0.0199802015,
0.0257196967,
-0.0147834942,
-0.0147165256,
-0.0564204566,
0.0250716116,
-0.0146198981,
0.0054079983,
0.0535482354,
2.732e-7,
0.0647678822,
0.0204060841,
0.0730296448,
-0.0494232513,
0.0139424829,
0.032589566,
0.0004282889,
0.0070162388,
-0.0180163458,
-0.0171420649,
0.0105595924,
0.0047243293,
0.037558578,
0.0203719921,
-0.0548663847,
-0.0426846817,
-0.069448702,
-0.0427362137,
-0.05944198,
-0.0080642905,
0.0117434394,
0.0385000594,
-0.0242171679,
-0.0411248766,
0.0106670279,
-0.0358367972,
0.0432976522,
-0.0359951295,
0.0093460567,
0.0360452384,
0.0540358573,
0.0092814676,
0.0147187505,
0.0076933089,
0.0088337446,
-0.0007735762,
0.0393192731,
0.0622798242,
0.0008821025,
0.0083513353,
0.0038953451,
-0.0312971435,
-0.0034546445,
-0.0819637626,
0.0745474622,
-0.042401202,
-0.0001163212,
-0.0446447022,
-0.0526330993,
0.0113434196,
-0.0497481003,
0.0109162387,
0.0066442639,
0.0523808375,
0.0141350171,
-0.0416042209,
-0.0302476175,
-0.0573533401,
0.0035959631,
-0.0022076019,
-0.0002111439,
0.0048346301,
-0.0467743948,
-0.0289511681,
-0.0031961014,
-0.0513166189,
-0.034371756,
2.502969331e-34,
0.0187354479,
0.0161391441,
-0.0131056178,
0.0092435498,
0.0082063191,
-0.0252937302,
-0.0580630377,
-0.0245968439,
-0.0669391751,
-0.0716305077,
0.0439766198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14933v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14933v2 | An Empirical Study of Multimodal Model Merging | 2023-04-28T15:43:21 | 2023-10-11T15:08:51 | Yi-Lin Sung, Linjie Li, Kevin Lin, Zhe Gan, Mohit Bansal, Lijuan Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Model merging (e.g., via interpolation or task arithmetic) fuses multiple
models trained on different tasks to generate a multi-task solution. The
technique has been proven successful in previous studies, where the models are
trained on similar tasks and with the same initialization. In this paper, we
expand on this concept to a multimodal setup by merging transformers trained on
different modalities. Furthermore, we conduct our study for a novel goal where
we can merge vision, language, and cross-modal transformers of a
modality-specific architecture to create a parameter-efficient
modality-agnostic architecture. Through comprehensive experiments, we
systematically investigate the key factors impacting model performance after
merging, including initialization, merging mechanisms, and model architectures.
We also propose two metrics that assess the distance between weights to be
merged and can serve as an indicator of the merging outcomes. Our analysis
leads to an effective training recipe for matching the performance of the
modality-agnostic baseline (i.e., pre-trained from scratch) via model merging.
Our method also outperforms naive merging significantly on various tasks, with
improvements of 3% on VQA, 7% on COCO retrieval, 25% on NLVR2, 14% on Flickr30k
and 3% on ADE20k. Our code is available at https://github.com/ylsung/vl-merging | [
-0.0132245459,
0.0695176944,
0.0127913589,
0.0100858184,
-0.020937765,
0.0099166259,
0.03397879,
-0.0215120502,
-0.0389693305,
-0.0574026331,
-0.0778388456,
-0.0279041398,
0.0160801448,
0.0141065735,
0.0427990705,
-0.0470780581,
0.0268825758,
0.007832584,
-0.0603515878,
0.0095553165,
0.0102300905,
0.0054753833,
-0.0043987446,
0.0439005308,
-0.0169359613,
0.0238244701,
-0.0369980745,
0.0127820969,
0.0327535458,
0.014601131,
0.0226455685,
0.0199672263,
0.0243801363,
0.0290277936,
0.0000018327,
-0.0143004907,
0.0081705684,
0.0082564242,
0.0174052939,
-0.03168175,
0.0922758505,
-0.0035860168,
0.0054914695,
0.0166032109,
-0.0106864078,
-0.0576937273,
0.0615307465,
0.0879313573,
0.0552709438,
0.04267947,
-0.0345717557,
-0.0366109572,
0.0387565196,
-0.0196750741,
0.0079110498,
-0.0249287989,
0.0340321884,
0.0239139926,
-0.0088787721,
-0.0174233522,
-0.0063647986,
0.0313032903,
0.0082180807,
0.0063380292,
0.0119639561,
0.0230507609,
0.0149212629,
-0.04569038,
-0.0568874255,
0.055527892,
-0.0600416325,
0.0146201169,
0.0176254846,
0.0222970694,
0.0130662257,
-0.0058216313,
-0.0536865927,
-0.0168793872,
-0.0231607109,
-0.0077735372,
-0.0644594133,
-0.0155330719,
0.0163625423,
-0.0077967555,
-0.0208437741,
-0.0377171077,
0.0494270101,
0.0150388004,
-0.0027912476,
-0.012296401,
0.0037304356,
-0.0477295369,
-0.0175542291,
0.0086083645,
-0.0250860546,
-0.0309840702,
-0.0689681023,
-0.0236834772,
-0.0170879159,
0.0174295884,
0.0855516791,
0.0168574657,
-0.0672109872,
0.058691036,
-0.0513548926,
0.0473224185,
-0.0609133542,
0.0584295429,
-0.0575954393,
-0.021322066,
-0.078963995,
0.0027973922,
0.0289450902,
-0.0179864503,
-0.0267772321,
-0.0374215432,
-0.0269281678,
0.0173924007,
-0.0007595489,
-0.0199145582,
0.0134646427,
0.0234183539,
-0.0355214626,
0.0067914389,
-0.0059819976,
0.0718517303,
0.0144483065,
0.0520182177,
-0.0108400295,
-0.0387487523,
0.0095888758,
0.0130396839,
0.0184930451,
-0.0241177864,
-0.0007274867,
0.0880585536,
-0.0726802945,
-0.023150621,
-0.0071677943,
-0.0381561965,
-0.0051041441,
-0.0450698398,
0.0504866205,
-0.0321332105,
0.0569306798,
-0.0432529934,
0.0129029183,
0.0195633397,
-0.0167778209,
-0.0091193384,
0.000927667,
0.0969137847,
0.0157032553,
0.0095905401,
0.0324779116,
0.003955021,
-0.0239295363,
0.0671154782,
-0.01006083,
0.0335485972,
-0.0013342001,
-0.0019145031,
0.006318985,
0.0467845909,
-0.012294271,
0.0003789962,
0.0015299162,
-0.0557036325,
0.0408630073,
-0.0196731426,
0.0485209376,
0.0306062791,
-0.0549592599,
-0.0154818166,
0.0549385026,
-0.0069006514,
0.0452890582,
0.0081934687,
0.0065753344,
-0.0237785,
0.0058952142,
0.0143576665,
-0.0806371942,
0.0536579899,
-0.0307013597,
-0.0004795816,
0.0104191601,
0.0908022001,
-0.0444291383,
-0.0220605396,
-0.0002676485,
-0.022401141,
0.0190335829,
0.006282561,
0.0546580292,
-0.0000017844,
-0.0528534167,
0.0118523138,
0.0060821055,
-0.0715374053,
-0.0014821646,
-0.0372916162,
-0.0375562944,
0.0086490326,
-0.0035107641,
0.0168840904,
-0.0261517707,
0.0174232461,
0.0093344124,
0.0001608191,
-0.0019927043,
-0.0230984446,
0.0530808605,
-0.0551642627,
-0.0970176905,
-0.0171797127,
-0.0163457058,
0.0234661251,
-0.0105951503,
-0.0275270101,
0.0273251813,
-0.0279272497,
0.0571192913,
0.0230533034,
-0.0016875651,
0.0380539112,
-0.0262023043,
0.0085851215,
0.0161086079,
-0.01978085,
-0.0144337257,
0.0013598065,
0.0045652553,
-0.0239872597,
-0.028284356,
0.0652693212,
-0.0292828977,
0.0048468127,
0.0438409224,
-0.0399461277,
0.0283679925,
0.0452463366,
-0.03193672,
-0.0405277684,
0.0061847274,
-0.0127503509,
0.0337552689,
-0.0074638426,
0.0277544167,
0.010674254,
0.0068316399,
0.0084501607,
0.047951892,
-0.0215418283,
-0.0152080255,
0.0121179372,
-0.0144635979,
0.0131664844,
0.0145704458,
-0.0241438262,
0.0012758358,
-0.0318859592,
0.0080709234,
0.0152464174,
-0.0489258021,
-0.0428560749,
-0.0444168225,
-0.1608243287,
-0.0006995286,
-0.0065675387,
-0.0017796935,
0.0092199408,
0.0279974062,
0.0161404684,
-0.0444446094,
-0.0126587488,
0.0439962782,
-0.0000098471,
0.039520435,
-0.0162265375,
0.0134399794,
-0.0123396739,
-0.0128550446,
-0.0309173167,
-0.0036547408,
0.0470785014,
-0.0185750872,
-0.0037383027,
-0.02501758,
-0.0027563034,
-0.0294766445,
0.0466557331,
-0.0437413305,
-0.0298570096,
0.0048303832,
-0.0450505726,
0.0528000556,
0.0552087687,
0.0195780266,
-0.0176837202,
0.0528771169,
-0.0286174174,
-0.0250154715,
0.0159365665,
0.0225206688,
-0.0397689492,
-0.0441407487,
-0.0132728145,
-0.0366376899,
0.0569768585,
-0.0268628802,
0.0127875749,
-0.0416084528,
-0.0084516667,
-0.0095447069,
-0.0517241396,
-0.0156940371,
0.0138337584,
-0.0021100615,
0.0234999843,
-0.0430642478,
-0.0368528254,
0.023025455,
-0.0121707898,
-0.0363301933,
-0.0029940289,
0.007347296,
-0.0063010044,
0.060088072,
0.0028200233,
0.0088950964,
0.0198158324,
-0.021765735,
-0.0720306784,
-0.0131610828,
0.0444835983,
0.0016488838,
0.0722358003,
-0.0247063134,
0.0111823156,
-0.0419490039,
-0.0589045919,
-0.0231588949,
-0.0290852524,
-0.0237255171,
0.0002336142,
-0.0279313177,
-0.0419579707,
-0.0659235716,
-0.0187529586,
0.0166934393,
0.0137679307,
-0.0112450644,
-0.0291808918,
-0.007431298,
0.0512131751,
0.0365588926,
0.0608369522,
-0.0330882743,
-0.0366705395,
-0.018636344,
0.0357937142,
0.083029367,
0.0268538482,
-0.085812211,
0.0216138829,
0.0533361621,
0.0244048983,
-0.0400828756,
0.0202119797,
0.0569775328,
-0.0106144398,
0.0430332199,
0.0511032045,
-0.015801793,
-0.0343574062,
-0.0577880517,
0.0216597766,
0.0152552426,
0.0261161458,
0.0082782591,
-0.0543984883,
-0.0634791628,
0.0270233899,
-0.0238727108,
0.0337491147,
0.0235946607,
-0.017329175,
-0.0755041987,
0.0107063102,
0.0120242853,
0.0027631964,
0.007290734,
-0.0156417806,
0.0225727707,
-0.04632736,
-0.0014252345,
-0.0062016044,
-0.0542073436,
-0.0293010399,
0.0196755622,
0.0546155609,
-0.0568284392,
-0.0113081187,
-0.0325634219,
-0.0023004042,
0.0600084886,
-0.0038615442,
0.0008303852,
-0.0703457892,
0.0508640334,
0.0167095698,
0.0042161406,
0.023455862,
0.0580099113,
-0.0168678798,
-0.0247638356,
-0.0042064888,
0.0112866331,
0.0156443417,
-0.0230172984,
-0.0385112353,
0.0058980528,
0.0158356279,
0.0138253216,
-0.0368576646,
-0.0120764179,
-0.0250609126,
0.0277386717,
-0.0274491888,
0.0015541132,
-0.0109908376,
0.0235040206,
-0.0145004336,
0.0080160387,
-0.0294937827,
0.0189659465,
-0.0256616268,
-0.0471482798,
-0.0416925699,
-0.0089016128,
-0.0155319804,
0.0437984318,
-0.0008058373,
-0.0315519273,
-0.0327940471,
0.0468059182,
-0.0883053318,
0.0588042438,
-0.0001174434,
0.0358245522,
-0.0429220237,
0.0391395688,
0.0411754474,
-0.0369595699,
-0.0037744071,
-0.0002391923,
-0.1198951378,
-0.0510986336,
-0.0227534287,
0.0515599847,
0.0122479079,
0.0370474979,
0.0240626801,
-0.0570721216,
0.0356533043,
0.0149790272,
-0.0008461479,
0.0333261825,
0.0507308431,
-0.0505899824,
0.001086568,
0.0007265525,
-0.0897374526,
0.0087944446,
-0.0123856999,
-0.010491197,
-0.0211103521,
0.0119610513,
0.0132010011,
-0.0248121452,
0.0350400843,
-0.0377226882,
0.0239395201,
-0.0247281604,
0.0085817678,
0.0183905642,
-0.0169539172,
-0.047979217,
0.0172557812,
0.0199397579,
0.029965166,
0.0607902966,
0.071828559,
0.0483103357,
0.0172395632,
-0.0433761701,
0.0005359089,
-0.0053969445,
-0.0193651915,
-0.0202505477,
0.0315600671,
0.0056929789,
0.0039539319,
0.0309843197,
0.0227930304,
-0.037488021,
0.0493823998,
0.0198598206,
-0.0065150303,
-0.042168472,
0.086780265,
-0.0509608462,
-0.0153272934,
-0.0254180636,
0.0180754997,
0.0564768016,
-0.0017954952,
0.0719803721,
0.0178985484,
-0.0249118749,
-0.0380477011,
0.0223259795,
-0.001601576,
0.0167872123,
0.0442772992,
0.0077610756,
0.0305494424,
-0.025409475,
0.0516654626,
-0.0392246991,
0.0314423628,
-0.0257685687,
0.010773967,
-0.0351219885,
-0.0223983452,
0.0631563589,
0.001267727,
-0.0139132235,
-0.043360617,
0.0089451056,
-0.0339678749,
0.0343941487,
0.0045192684,
-0.0136602204,
0.035029199,
0.0549965277,
0.0536649488,
0.0126874801,
-0.0287468284,
-0.0101693589,
-0.0637350827,
0.0250676069,
0.0186708756,
0.042744223,
-5.758060263e-33,
-0.012316931,
0.0167775974,
0.0147220762,
-0.0572685413,
-0.0347054377,
0.0393599421,
0.0064744828,
0.0065519828,
-0.0130949337,
-0.0186043773,
0.0114982836,
-0.0067415107,
0.0259174444,
0.0198165737,
0.001137484,
-0.0017486436,
0.0724194348,
0.0142407408,
-0.0117257284,
-0.0070061646,
0.0130927386,
0.0176428873,
0.0277175512,
-0.0628455505,
-0.0124820471,
0.0563073605,
-0.037532527,
-0.0054633766,
0.0113912104,
0.091433011,
-0.0207946859,
0.0079028094,
0.0193445776,
-0.011208755,
-0.0381643064,
0.0291265342,
-0.0686767101,
-0.0000912026,
0.0024563654,
0.0366303027,
-0.068374157,
-0.0014732974,
0.0491326712,
-0.0121171409,
0.0065391771,
-0.0564539358,
0.0602318533,
-0.0010478328,
0.0173117314,
-0.0035214941,
-0.0320551582,
0.0041706981,
0.0171352085,
-0.0698145628,
0.0776326209,
0.044170443,
0.0568879694,
-0.0038543411,
-0.0330685526,
0.0399496146,
-0.0444921367,
0.0419749506,
0.0729943961,
0.0815208256,
-0.0206719488,
0.0545731261,
0.0357748084,
-0.0456910953,
-0.0066597532,
-0.0265607424,
0.031771224,
0.0659633875,
0.0051948391,
0.0681390539,
0.0263407808,
0.0266571883,
-0.0000115113,
0.0608912259,
0.0173769128,
0.0491132699,
-0.0338344462,
0.0655487254,
0.0196251143,
0.0370240919,
-0.0392848738,
-0.0194414537,
-0.0518255159,
-0.014021147,
0.0263792165,
0.0445900336,
0.0110736433,
0.0177991223,
0.0825088248,
-0.0207316894,
0.0019590764,
0.0160401966,
-0.0217547398,
0.0733579695,
-0.0024119157,
-0.0119077554,
0.0119494703,
-0.021418944,
0.0782586336,
0.0039053138,
0.0026607027,
-0.0055587217,
-0.0057310569,
0.0550547875,
-0.0464328527,
0.0008130528,
-0.0172218438,
-0.0298327859,
0.0183041766,
0.0487335958,
0.0694397092,
0.0219359994,
-0.0468809083,
-0.0034259649,
-0.0112679526,
0.0339571387,
-0.0628460273,
-0.0270209108,
0.0346284248,
0.0367117897,
0.0115942163,
0.0247670952,
-0.059216179,
-0.0543780029,
0.0245700646,
-0.033671312,
-0.0382970236,
0.0454004928,
2.592e-7,
0.0000066968,
-0.0400265642,
0.0102678034,
-0.0326131843,
0.0082366327,
0.0629164949,
-0.0256913714,
0.042015899,
-0.0045853672,
-0.0453514233,
-0.0357572362,
0.0249080639,
0.0406228453,
-0.0011726621,
-0.0270552263,
-0.0145360352,
0.0081542134,
-0.0096842274,
-0.0158407353,
0.0121987946,
0.0217056889,
0.0825639442,
0.0063092178,
-0.0129512334,
0.0357198864,
-0.0018099315,
0.083171472,
-0.0018578165,
-0.0325217769,
-0.0139714275,
0.0064609786,
0.0002235779,
-0.0113988211,
0.0133208847,
-0.009314199,
-0.0189867206,
0.0415750667,
0.0258533135,
-0.0276614651,
-0.0524202213,
-0.0243666377,
0.0601708777,
-0.0428746268,
-0.0042770407,
0.0723723024,
-0.0512601174,
-0.018305352,
-0.0746857971,
-0.0452363752,
0.0185973775,
0.003758864,
0.0048462222,
-0.0332651101,
0.0454284176,
0.0161811262,
0.0021345424,
-0.0551407896,
-0.0944166109,
-0.0106710354,
0.0243855678,
-0.0625209361,
-0.03171717,
-0.0440902486,
-0.0394802243,
0.0645945221,
-0.0729290769,
-0.064760901,
2.035008473e-34,
-0.018478265,
-0.0139481081,
0.055598177,
0.0079498179,
-0.0275135394,
-0.0186250899,
-0.0341836251,
0.0052870484,
-0.0128345443,
-0.042384699,
-0.0172998793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14931v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14931v2 | HQP: A Human-Annotated Dataset for Detecting Online Propaganda | 2023-04-28T15:42:55 | 2023-05-01T08:29:51 | Abdurahman Maarouf, Dominik Bär, Dominique Geissler, Stefan Feuerriegel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online propaganda poses a severe threat to the integrity of societies.
However, existing datasets for detecting online propaganda have a key
limitation: they were annotated using weak labels that can be noisy and even
incorrect. To address this limitation, our work makes the following
contributions: (1) We present HQP: a novel dataset (N=30,000) for detecting
online propaganda with high-quality labels. To the best of our knowledge, HQP
is the first dataset for detecting online propaganda that was created through
human annotation. (2) We show empirically that state-of-the-art language models
fail in detecting online propaganda when trained with weak labels (AUC: 64.03).
In contrast, state-of-the-art language models can accurately detect online
propaganda when trained with our high-quality labels (AUC: 92.25), which is an
improvement of ~44%. (3) To address the cost of labeling, we extend our work to
few-shot learning. Specifically, we show that prompt-based learning using a
small sample of high-quality labels can still achieve a reasonable performance
(AUC: 80.27). Finally, we discuss implications for the NLP community to balance
the cost and quality of labeling. Crucially, our work highlights the importance
of high-quality labels for sensitive NLP tasks such as propaganda detection. | [
0.0618163459,
0.054654263,
-0.0092335017,
0.0091936234,
0.0013901913,
0.0370226651,
0.042154137,
0.0136257457,
0.028268436,
-0.0413755961,
-0.020821441,
-0.0265974104,
0.0132387979,
-0.0151895396,
0.0155157372,
-0.0615200475,
0.051644057,
0.0486721024,
0.0688579828,
-0.0235284157,
0.029948717,
0.0252075251,
-0.0087522874,
0.038694568,
-0.0483017825,
-0.035089232,
0.0576781221,
-0.0051489505,
0.0501368344,
-0.0239782166,
0.0225881152,
0.0429398008,
0.0120509695,
0.0652658567,
0.0000014605,
-0.0166590177,
0.0028265831,
-0.0098971948,
-0.0263765026,
0.0066108112,
0.0866918489,
-0.0383109562,
-0.0189302731,
0.0200418159,
-0.0309803672,
0.0107712513,
0.0570427626,
0.072426796,
0.0760220811,
0.0961549953,
0.007240593,
-0.0172585752,
-0.0148203727,
-0.0176884867,
-0.0026377244,
-0.0195727143,
0.0599730648,
-0.0478216037,
-0.0491934009,
0.0396347195,
-0.0084435791,
0.0250427313,
0.0037270645,
-0.0075406996,
-0.0415472649,
-0.010938691,
-0.0036597357,
-0.0442015454,
-0.0057898541,
0.048258394,
-0.0250225775,
-0.0384004749,
0.0160914063,
-0.0092738606,
-0.0042328816,
-0.0111562731,
-0.0110615175,
0.0412824191,
-0.0060268329,
0.0250604805,
0.0400739983,
-0.016149085,
0.0447980165,
0.0428913645,
0.0577988848,
-0.0149831343,
-0.0413315631,
-0.0199340489,
0.0348396674,
-0.0044064368,
-0.0329053178,
-0.0125078298,
-0.0009762279,
-0.0053365063,
0.000857755,
0.0059139738,
-0.0619145036,
-0.0481886417,
0.0228473321,
-0.0736110061,
-0.00272357,
0.0025441232,
-0.0033998541,
0.0416304283,
-0.016731197,
-0.000626866,
0.001463438,
0.056851197,
0.0089965584,
0.0155578433,
-0.0145862335,
0.0072771693,
-0.0222632792,
0.0031547856,
0.0321582071,
0.0070108497,
-0.0799951851,
-0.0174607206,
-0.0545561984,
0.0340449922,
-0.038527824,
0.0058397613,
-0.021596577,
-0.012016085,
0.0050847209,
0.0360170901,
-0.0327448696,
0.0282961968,
-0.0106282616,
-0.0637602359,
-0.0109546455,
0.0579501167,
-0.0297611095,
-0.0040472127,
0.0216709785,
0.0401053838,
0.0495039113,
-0.0243537556,
-0.0218882598,
-0.031978555,
-0.0234889984,
-0.034703698,
-0.0064607929,
-0.0402347557,
0.001846891,
-0.0166239534,
0.0042111068,
-0.0780257955,
0.0063283816,
0.0551326163,
-0.0314511172,
0.0759769976,
-0.0057178698,
-0.0072346171,
0.0352408811,
0.0271355789,
-0.0091099637,
0.080130063,
-0.0127101801,
0.0884748027,
0.0664298758,
-0.0054099644,
0.0392577462,
0.0325391069,
0.0430577621,
0.0223131217,
-0.0092996191,
-0.0064924643,
-0.0140435677,
-0.0005260564,
-0.009756295,
0.0359481163,
-0.0032269971,
-0.047386393,
0.0721632764,
-0.0152939102,
-0.0369441323,
-0.0462916717,
0.0224783346,
0.0278793126,
0.0036750122,
-0.0135360658,
-0.0534663163,
-0.0022298032,
-0.0252464097,
-0.0603438355,
0.0293952636,
0.0491974913,
-0.0116126863,
-0.0339886434,
-0.03145824,
0.0049467548,
0.0059056911,
-0.0214311518,
0.0263796672,
0.0427232049,
-0.0245991927,
0.0098398915,
0.0643433705,
0.0325312987,
0.0173756555,
-0.0422182269,
0.032591667,
0.0242375359,
0.0236109402,
-0.0187922269,
0.0515907034,
-0.0752122104,
0.0681613088,
0.0611700527,
0.0581584014,
-0.0362953842,
-0.0237332769,
0.0105847782,
-0.0071892291,
-0.0327979252,
0.0081966855,
0.0169621054,
0.0627265498,
-0.0080581196,
-0.006115234,
0.0088414093,
-0.0557325706,
0.0288846921,
0.0505991206,
-0.0415736027,
-0.0234219655,
0.0512303859,
0.0376143232,
0.0233804081,
-0.0177501179,
-0.0349521339,
0.0333141796,
-0.009797547,
-0.033863537,
-0.0656430274,
-0.0005457953,
-0.0306081995,
0.0041945642,
-0.0507858619,
-0.0587379709,
0.0443735793,
-0.0362268388,
0.0299269259,
0.0330564417,
-0.0523112603,
-0.0072546843,
-0.0142705413,
-0.0260383785,
-0.0362956561,
0.0443737358,
-0.0237416103,
0.0752090812,
-0.0113508478,
0.0199666452,
0.0177001394,
-0.0358159542,
-0.0003824522,
0.0262060817,
-0.0338659845,
-0.0284827277,
-0.0127493208,
0.0045827217,
0.0463271514,
-0.0154876551,
-0.0083996179,
0.0047490229,
-0.0320912674,
-0.0397972502,
-0.0174874272,
-0.0067802458,
0.0302142277,
-0.0157100819,
0.0125924749,
0.0093212817,
-0.0636765435,
0.0007682864,
-0.0218013451,
0.0529358052,
0.0241560582,
-0.0174997766,
-0.0075121908,
0.0072175907,
0.0278654005,
-0.012659383,
0.0279037431,
0.0247610044,
-0.0711827129,
-0.0012288506,
-0.022417929,
-0.0206526257,
-0.0109734023,
-0.0281711053,
-0.0298804287,
0.0326331146,
0.0227639861,
-0.0361575633,
0.0321074016,
0.039165929,
0.0628890768,
0.0332126059,
0.0749886706,
-0.0350509807,
-0.0368854441,
-0.0478502139,
0.0030167489,
-0.0175948087,
-0.0335763842,
0.0079843653,
0.0707118362,
0.0432823002,
0.0203784518,
-0.0522523746,
0.0273988619,
-0.0443456732,
-0.0354917087,
-0.0465952419,
-0.0118952515,
-0.011847184,
-0.0094117196,
-0.0309438594,
-0.0277831238,
0.0934847444,
0.0262581483,
0.0396860242,
0.0158869475,
-0.0473654643,
0.0149617344,
0.0070778821,
-0.0079584038,
0.0310855024,
0.0191194341,
-0.0201715939,
-0.0120612383,
-0.0047269892,
0.048067227,
-0.0224038046,
-0.0395651609,
0.0089177229,
0.01481805,
0.0041665556,
-0.0397949778,
-0.0826614276,
-0.0918819532,
-0.0176984239,
-0.0476557501,
-0.0213915985,
-0.0063837944,
-0.0410364829,
-0.0093083782,
0.038394656,
-0.02025415,
-0.0040186411,
-0.0027107766,
0.0162118636,
0.0270839762,
0.0381308943,
-0.0382037349,
0.0355593301,
-0.0120911906,
-0.009107559,
0.0466657467,
0.0012056502,
0.0491400659,
0.0146050509,
-0.0262922309,
0.013958565,
0.0084255831,
0.0037045791,
-0.009631088,
0.0205003936,
-0.0086780991,
0.0186175629,
0.0699673146,
0.0077300188,
-0.0349584222,
0.0040875142,
0.0552576929,
-0.0069723921,
0.0155334063,
-0.0318261608,
-0.0936664268,
-0.0195149127,
-0.0042439108,
0.0260825343,
-0.0771510601,
-0.0355086513,
-0.0140310368,
-0.0867189094,
-0.0112292385,
-0.0074798721,
-0.025116954,
-0.010699762,
-0.0878888965,
-0.0067840987,
-0.0194067731,
0.0156122809,
-0.0462384783,
0.0329807326,
-0.0040015494,
0.0041761547,
-0.0121657336,
-0.0569389649,
0.0083036534,
-0.0104996655,
0.0777936876,
0.0269202739,
0.0481768399,
-0.0152699435,
-0.0221821573,
0.0497595407,
0.0078352112,
-0.0276924875,
-0.0217785761,
0.0945033357,
-0.0473048687,
-0.0657019317,
0.0011315877,
0.0394596495,
-0.0085463086,
0.0079759574,
-0.016265532,
0.0181527175,
0.0415779389,
-0.0414481312,
0.0018470297,
0.0268648397,
0.042634435,
0.0665001348,
0.0066696983,
-0.0626951605,
0.0172831863,
-0.0685749128,
-0.0066611296,
-0.0415033549,
-0.0631695539,
0.0430129655,
-0.033935722,
-0.0537997819,
-0.0500471629,
-0.0517093278,
0.026455339,
-0.0039757839,
0.0345489942,
-0.0264715645,
-0.0523042567,
0.025364494,
-0.0262797251,
0.0144193852,
-0.0317898206,
0.0344721191,
-0.0415082909,
-0.0235529803,
-0.0347877108,
-0.0230934713,
-0.016065143,
0.0334821418,
-0.0785221979,
-0.0493155904,
0.0409500785,
0.0183391385,
0.0108841714,
0.0282350276,
-0.0220067222,
-0.0282846987,
0.0633674115,
0.0768788755,
-0.0242870543,
-0.0192006677,
0.0224070624,
0.0113844555,
0.0136688482,
0.0330701321,
-0.0154070938,
0.0240089428,
0.0602573641,
-0.0420766436,
-0.0628894567,
0.0248724874,
0.0266590603,
0.0285757277,
0.0614172369,
-0.042653583,
-0.0391910858,
-0.0469843931,
-0.0358971804,
-0.008372697,
-0.0516777001,
0.0335260481,
0.0045739282,
0.0477835573,
-0.024264589,
-0.0083334595,
0.0371832997,
-0.0273158122,
0.0386477299,
-0.021611616,
-0.024402678,
0.011928983,
0.0655058175,
0.009775538,
-0.001601521,
-0.023784209,
0.0710600913,
0.0358200781,
0.0190682858,
-0.0000205523,
-0.0109394947,
0.0273362175,
-0.0004976678,
0.0757808611,
-0.0142919151,
0.0029589974,
-0.0306914952,
-0.0575210825,
0.0222672913,
0.0114171682,
0.0203929469,
0.0338872373,
-0.0120095424,
-0.0372394025,
0.0017277732,
-0.017556157,
-0.0038696639,
-0.0602091439,
0.007190499,
0.0225590076,
-0.0350112319,
0.0356915742,
0.0278125722,
0.0041676206,
0.0447418727,
0.0419413447,
-0.0611488596,
-0.0378533639,
0.0023907137,
0.0016891402,
0.0380767845,
0.0061441264,
0.029407287,
-0.0625982955,
-0.048939161,
-0.012127337,
-0.0141242752,
0.0090081561,
0.0034326124,
-0.0049310387,
0.0469042286,
-0.0108416565,
0.0377053954,
-0.0765663758,
-0.0062639802,
0.0041999556,
-0.0454192907,
0.0085343672,
-5.687652926e-33,
0.006038622,
-0.0279994123,
-0.0361328535,
-0.0237605181,
0.0287451986,
0.0068822363,
0.0256800279,
0.0042426032,
-0.0438631698,
0.0266346559,
0.0331516713,
0.0192401651,
-0.0057398351,
0.0204936899,
-0.0612950511,
-0.0271625649,
0.0397949703,
-0.0053050118,
-0.0629641265,
0.0135927182,
0.0609799996,
-0.0193628184,
0.0506866612,
-0.0671202615,
0.054154288,
0.0233752523,
-0.053733144,
-0.0027785306,
0.0191566385,
0.046370849,
-0.0080939038,
0.0787099674,
0.0414090194,
-0.0178549998,
0.026353417,
0.0559869595,
-0.040141806,
0.0028809945,
0.0162271876,
0.0194536168,
-0.0126482295,
-0.0095851906,
0.013239705,
-0.0286807511,
-0.0200436097,
0.0063015451,
0.0444641188,
-0.0193110239,
0.0069671357,
-0.0030806384,
-0.0323540904,
-0.0050859158,
-0.0232403949,
-0.0098976437,
-0.0362940244,
0.0633544996,
0.0342767276,
0.0884802043,
-0.0843558609,
0.039999675,
-0.0303020421,
0.0152001958,
0.0122283055,
-0.0388283879,
-0.0034349195,
0.0722006634,
0.016008433,
0.0570469126,
-0.0159348249,
0.0268603284,
0.004685089,
-0.0006493004,
0.0660110787,
0.0888365954,
0.026839992,
-0.0552216135,
-0.0822765008,
0.0105577232,
0.0468344651,
-0.0166861117,
0.0062334714,
-0.0348554701,
-0.0402636342,
-0.0048950072,
-0.0386270322,
-0.0521268174,
-0.0373240337,
-0.0112808608,
0.0076146219,
0.0211087726,
-0.0653212965,
0.0267225243,
0.0090017347,
-0.0287169144,
-0.009477105,
0.0271071792,
-0.0228009596,
-0.0014264978,
0.0207269676,
0.0142294662,
-0.0625515878,
-0.005434759,
0.0266914107,
-0.0230539348,
0.0317763239,
-0.0387975313,
0.1014361084,
0.0219015218,
-0.0692650974,
0.0113792028,
-0.0253976639,
0.0412456915,
-0.0091492701,
0.0021083127,
0.04465314,
0.0036247415,
-0.0212283581,
-0.0071765464,
0.0232729223,
-0.0085161021,
0.0558572598,
0.0009795458,
-0.042536512,
0.0101003069,
-0.0246027373,
-0.0341185443,
-0.0266220588,
0.0415610373,
0.0116538005,
-0.1213771999,
0.0005892345,
-0.0319390893,
2.265e-7,
-0.0106376903,
0.0488316528,
0.0094822496,
0.016731739,
0.019214062,
0.0417778566,
0.0397117808,
0.019831067,
-0.0601535477,
-0.0895567685,
-0.0304116402,
0.025060229,
0.0351439714,
0.0131210135,
-0.05790402,
0.0012390761,
-0.0407561436,
0.020954296,
-0.0488103442,
0.0187225733,
0.0172524936,
0.0980591252,
0.0672651604,
-0.0225775763,
-0.0121652298,
-0.026566077,
0.0556986816,
0.0172979403,
-0.0394461751,
0.0172095038,
0.0347516015,
-0.0082647102,
0.0057983235,
-0.0181444865,
-0.0130132679,
-0.0128690498,
0.0177956764,
0.0380726308,
0.025217494,
-0.0261606704,
-0.0374283269,
-0.0221449696,
-0.0025674796,
-0.018473886,
0.0664447844,
-0.0366334245,
-0.0283798929,
-0.0383585505,
-0.032416895,
-0.0121099129,
0.0347606912,
-0.0076476922,
-0.0263270531,
-0.0050012805,
0.0154113173,
0.0256208926,
-0.0052951798,
-0.0509027019,
0.0130817518,
-0.0089253755,
-0.0247697607,
-0.0401238948,
0.0178889725,
-0.0094609763,
0.0219478607,
-0.0178711042,
0.0095640859,
1.58775388e-34,
0.0478539243,
-0.0638188571,
-0.007138195,
-0.0419849046,
0.0228870995,
0.0217114892,
-0.0368003361,
-0.0409223661,
0.038434092,
-0.0160198547,
0.0007895048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14827v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14827v3 | ChatGPT Evaluation on Sentence Level Relations: A Focus on Temporal, Causal, and Discourse Relations | 2023-04-28T13:14:36 | 2024-01-26T10:33:08 | Chunkit Chan, Jiayang Cheng, Weiqi Wang, Yuxin Jiang, Tianqing Fang, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper aims to quantitatively evaluate the performance of ChatGPT, an
interactive large language model, on inter-sentential relations such as
temporal relations, causal relations, and discourse relations. Given ChatGPT's
promising performance across various tasks, we proceed to carry out thorough
evaluations on the whole test sets of 11 datasets, including temporal and
causal relations, PDTB2.0-based, and dialogue-based discourse relations. To
ensure the reliability of our findings, we employ three tailored prompt
templates for each task, including the zero-shot prompt template, zero-shot
prompt engineering (PE) template, and in-context learning (ICL) prompt
template, to establish the initial baseline scores for all popular
sentence-pair relation classification tasks for the first time. Through our
study, we discover that ChatGPT exhibits exceptional proficiency in detecting
and reasoning about causal relations, albeit it may not possess the same level
of expertise in identifying the temporal order between two events. While it is
capable of identifying the majority of discourse relations with existing
explicit discourse connectives, the implicit discourse relation remains a
formidable challenge. Concurrently, ChatGPT demonstrates subpar performance in
the dialogue discourse parsing task that requires structural understanding in a
dialogue before being aware of the discourse relation. | [
0.0217786599,
0.0290029906,
-0.0087006632,
0.0450411141,
-0.0572358705,
0.0211282857,
0.031589359,
-0.0016921419,
0.0297772586,
-0.0822432265,
-0.0234918818,
-0.0330849513,
-0.0201070011,
0.0333512984,
-0.028750116,
-0.0469317026,
0.0821919292,
0.0017581416,
0.0412327833,
0.0312945992,
-0.0173968021,
0.0160123501,
-0.049882967,
0.0218425281,
-0.0289109927,
-0.0660482198,
-0.003507904,
-0.0005233645,
0.0109909419,
-0.070931755,
0.0183687191,
0.0789526999,
0.0172156747,
0.0426679142,
0.0000019758,
-0.060320653,
0.0134677254,
-0.0262436997,
-0.0531552881,
0.0437674038,
0.0027449199,
0.0183731262,
0.0110827535,
0.0068278215,
-0.0522794724,
-0.0369621664,
-0.0157837961,
0.0923239216,
0.040268898,
0.0625490695,
-0.0143267578,
-0.0203403924,
0.0335993618,
-0.0220146123,
-0.0095552793,
-0.0311229471,
0.0046577244,
0.0179400519,
-0.0033503929,
0.0559260808,
-0.0086400462,
0.0177806523,
0.0309064649,
-0.0354187675,
0.0149660455,
0.0638036057,
-0.0397905074,
-0.00127817,
-0.005101609,
0.072157301,
0.0961638168,
-0.0307031535,
-0.0075882631,
0.0118002472,
0.0093614301,
0.0017420794,
-0.026055485,
-0.0019203394,
-0.0080342498,
0.0144154234,
0.0240164809,
0.0099195791,
0.0053880196,
0.0142806042,
0.0238949899,
0.036977943,
0.0062396852,
-0.0293445624,
-0.0128745856,
0.0076405611,
-0.0373310484,
-0.061095845,
-0.028181972,
0.0151950791,
-0.05672618,
-0.0058668591,
-0.021886643,
0.01402386,
0.0081891268,
-0.0591037124,
0.0049098041,
0.0394673981,
-0.0175385159,
0.0568992086,
-0.0202425066,
0.0835057944,
-0.0020479055,
-0.0229776669,
-0.0059999148,
0.0137445219,
-0.054419186,
-0.0249885302,
-0.0289686378,
0.017922027,
-0.0636404902,
-0.031542439,
-0.0380368829,
0.0251451582,
0.0057359785,
-0.0232266542,
0.0343955234,
0.0006391567,
-0.0050614537,
0.0333497599,
-0.0527566522,
0.0089131854,
-0.0225420818,
0.0074622277,
-0.0364498869,
-0.0420198329,
-0.0287709702,
0.0063817315,
0.0005209643,
-0.0380956084,
-0.0320479795,
0.0637463406,
-0.0312839411,
-0.0355916619,
0.0131215323,
-0.0249078758,
-0.027547285,
-0.0335049368,
-0.0023637249,
-0.0171479229,
0.0168663207,
0.009169776,
-0.0129348747,
0.0158984456,
0.0305249207,
0.0128872925,
-0.0217434149,
0.0613052547,
0.05287949,
-0.0004067187,
0.0128523624,
0.0108168181,
0.0343970023,
0.0365609005,
0.0270792712,
-0.0248584878,
0.0224357322,
0.0093762288,
-0.0228874888,
0.0107033458,
0.0076761926,
-0.0091559002,
-0.0128108049,
0.022587331,
0.0528707393,
0.0185670778,
0.0143241575,
0.0331460051,
-0.0429999754,
-0.0256388746,
0.0387368426,
0.0069177584,
-0.0164564885,
-0.0150270127,
0.0806137025,
0.0243427996,
-0.0019247987,
0.0132094426,
-0.0576355495,
-0.006734455,
0.0113493931,
-0.019770138,
-0.0232526697,
-0.016852146,
-0.0072387168,
-0.0076163588,
0.0138818873,
0.0043144268,
0.0028079017,
-0.0139688551,
0.0441403203,
0.0013303438,
-0.0698332787,
0.0483480021,
0.0409398824,
-0.0094335591,
-0.0305766519,
-0.0263553746,
0.0238892157,
0.0286605507,
0.0336999893,
-0.0158353224,
-0.051250264,
-0.031741254,
0.0587525405,
0.0465124063,
0.038875822,
-0.0224950444,
0.0087798135,
-0.0114944438,
-0.0189984553,
-0.0099153118,
0.0150794201,
0.0324425921,
0.0163334161,
-0.0156750493,
-0.0073145917,
0.0438060723,
0.034206368,
0.0191209689,
-0.0341344625,
-0.0416638777,
0.0072933305,
-0.0106019424,
0.052735053,
0.0221105255,
-0.0150672598,
-0.0138895502,
0.0278279148,
-0.0448018871,
-0.0130295428,
0.0505556352,
-0.1014275029,
-0.0918509215,
0.01411111,
0.0115017109,
-0.0469465852,
-0.0139483539,
-0.0309885647,
-0.0526235923,
0.019568732,
0.0251344126,
0.0204570647,
-0.0458743609,
-0.0159633625,
0.0168045349,
0.0141760735,
-0.0480240397,
0.0825766698,
0.0151328892,
0.0097161634,
0.0275954977,
0.0163507964,
0.0141224805,
-0.0138891041,
0.0071309358,
0.0053661573,
0.0016268136,
-0.0447196625,
0.0113672875,
0.0130835501,
-0.0560554862,
-0.0121949222,
-0.1580389887,
0.011385655,
0.0030999123,
0.0305748656,
0.0298705995,
-0.0089181066,
-0.0158895627,
-0.0196507312,
0.002551937,
-0.0278544705,
0.011715957,
-0.0006302354,
0.0564334653,
0.0091242697,
-0.0082507636,
-0.0166432261,
0.0105964057,
-0.0690117031,
0.056683708,
0.0274572428,
-0.0282965656,
0.0008509965,
0.0282224957,
0.0019100091,
0.0080239167,
-0.0272383634,
-0.0521897189,
0.0214491542,
0.0093016531,
0.0465540364,
0.0520670898,
0.0082839485,
0.0495329313,
-0.0084789805,
-0.0420167074,
-0.0529936738,
0.0499177985,
-0.0068708807,
0.0274710692,
-0.0165540688,
0.0125966622,
-0.0526967719,
0.1045189574,
0.0260339137,
0.0259252749,
-0.0316502862,
0.0065249815,
-0.0181338452,
-0.0093891043,
-0.0398417749,
-0.0349161774,
-0.0195703395,
0.002507664,
-0.0558018945,
-0.0120435255,
0.0451016575,
-0.043081481,
-0.0089704702,
-0.0220898725,
-0.020164635,
-0.0417033099,
0.0913387612,
0.0202494022,
-0.029408792,
0.0208874233,
-0.0581999198,
-0.0463540964,
-0.0225168951,
0.0452023819,
0.0027133534,
0.0145962983,
-0.0445904173,
0.0279323813,
-0.0219944362,
-0.0528479777,
-0.0521480329,
-0.0862446055,
-0.0008643281,
0.0283924732,
-0.0299917087,
0.0110679446,
0.0150433592,
0.009722746,
0.0043140263,
0.0140193971,
-0.0308200251,
-0.0045297439,
-0.0164915156,
0.09015432,
0.0075311419,
-0.0021110915,
-0.0178564694,
-0.000039887,
0.0566328354,
0.0128311301,
-0.0124930255,
0.0180385876,
-0.0467650816,
-0.0124654472,
-0.0379650705,
-0.0223854631,
-0.0458997488,
-0.0251021739,
0.0478784032,
-0.0579047538,
-0.0091212122,
0.1473743618,
0.031520009,
-0.0162130035,
-0.021454135,
0.0095748967,
0.0040292395,
0.0410165377,
-0.0015301603,
-0.0789772943,
-0.0237270314,
-0.0015952522,
-0.0566655546,
-0.0440298319,
-0.0656091198,
-0.001062704,
-0.1038564295,
0.0170427393,
-0.0423263125,
-0.0053323,
0.0432901196,
-0.0409460738,
0.014663361,
0.0068779509,
0.0201391783,
-0.0147571741,
-0.0184124485,
0.0149063077,
0.0236250125,
-0.0102236196,
-0.0275569484,
0.0521534421,
0.0090103094,
0.0506174453,
0.0269638337,
0.0634582266,
-0.0060286922,
0.0422956049,
0.0993641987,
-0.0140082091,
0.0032863449,
-0.025517676,
0.0365610272,
-0.0024635175,
-0.0100637255,
-0.0375198238,
0.024677027,
-0.0171964075,
-0.0204417817,
0.0117171174,
0.064735122,
-0.0417793803,
0.031380821,
-0.0027456053,
0.0173769947,
0.0090689231,
0.0605029687,
0.0312397964,
0.0006809381,
-0.0656627044,
0.0036059867,
0.0065531395,
-0.0388711318,
-0.0054792892,
-0.0257475972,
0.016458828,
0.0226422809,
-0.0500823595,
-0.0779733658,
0.0029248178,
-0.0040443968,
-0.0285015944,
0.0198318884,
-0.0262859687,
0.0131729497,
-0.0363653302,
0.0383829251,
-0.0111871017,
0.0075368737,
-0.0400946662,
0.0100071067,
0.037781585,
-0.0187415369,
-0.0426430553,
0.0022459985,
-0.0442699902,
-0.0257967059,
-0.0090031261,
0.0045408979,
0.0141850011,
0.0690273494,
-0.0322290286,
0.0330998898,
0.0227960255,
0.0509933271,
-0.0508270301,
0.0187052712,
0.0257528871,
0.0359852314,
-0.0103404028,
0.0261337906,
-0.0015624351,
0.0283846054,
-0.0101713687,
0.0407143272,
-0.018016817,
-0.0197469834,
0.0131605864,
-0.014407374,
0.1022855639,
0.0199759286,
0.0048684981,
-0.0445374213,
0.0090129292,
-0.0587574281,
-0.0131880213,
-0.0319130197,
0.01387861,
0.0045202449,
-0.0030444141,
-0.0353720337,
-0.0270350557,
-0.0307154134,
0.057445135,
-0.0348781794,
0.0131467236,
0.0477508679,
0.0028328674,
0.0093265325,
-0.0111513287,
-0.0216367748,
0.0185362175,
0.0073621194,
0.0009672504,
-0.0248978157,
0.0972002447,
0.0089629404,
0.0099248784,
0.0129857147,
-0.0058093378,
-0.0756920129,
0.0512615554,
0.0117925443,
0.0291635264,
0.0757914186,
-0.0242127758,
0.0393387415,
-0.0108905695,
0.0012607832,
-0.0092338072,
0.0873247162,
0.0207606927,
-0.020744808,
0.025386557,
0.0226759091,
-0.0337482281,
0.039411746,
0.0746647418,
-0.020306699,
0.0391512215,
0.0682032108,
-0.0072629168,
-0.0295026451,
-0.0514243431,
-0.0136745116,
-0.0144796278,
-0.0054297093,
0.0517074056,
-0.0397099778,
-0.0278211236,
0.0269022249,
-0.0083912434,
-0.0066310004,
-0.0109163905,
0.0213710573,
0.046761848,
0.0123878065,
-0.0404758528,
-0.0388703197,
0.0127946278,
-0.0245552137,
-0.0222596023,
-0.0708635077,
-6.346581427e-33,
-0.0731511414,
-0.0263357181,
0.0225040726,
0.0278819781,
-0.0520634651,
0.0573850758,
-0.052844014,
-0.0081741689,
0.0034235131,
0.0484269597,
-0.0072962712,
0.0373436362,
0.0143784024,
0.0188743267,
0.0202477667,
-0.0463753901,
0.0584332347,
-0.0114464751,
-0.0042824182,
0.0279331021,
0.0571054183,
0.0356019773,
0.0582593381,
-0.037615113,
0.0021734908,
-0.010127347,
0.0144806914,
0.0426693968,
-0.0023290846,
0.0594375171,
-0.0236248914,
0.0093052238,
0.0458711609,
-0.0175754093,
0.0265963878,
0.0419897735,
-0.1145294085,
-0.0582518131,
0.0363779217,
-0.0035049,
-0.0209733173,
-0.0295518152,
-0.050719142,
-0.0082845194,
0.011173469,
-0.0200470742,
0.0365116224,
0.0002429376,
-0.0128571037,
-0.0356629603,
-0.0533060618,
0.0324422829,
-0.0218727347,
-0.0239901505,
-0.0040664738,
0.0348957442,
0.031910833,
-0.0192736778,
-0.023276221,
-0.0298497006,
-0.0426375829,
-0.0008615598,
-0.0055845436,
0.0099263499,
0.0046642018,
0.058275383,
-0.006779023,
0.006237282,
-0.04276824,
-0.0065762615,
-0.0028352393,
-0.0029088871,
-0.0065689473,
0.0372739844,
-0.0201048795,
0.0166719463,
-0.0955669209,
-0.0213605147,
0.0876575112,
0.0404702537,
0.0033758192,
-0.0226921663,
-0.021329863,
-0.0154886534,
-0.0267778188,
-0.015746668,
-0.0187601,
-0.0242133159,
0.0407673046,
-0.0053050406,
0.0484217182,
-0.0264472775,
0.0553657301,
-0.0283249561,
-0.0295613687,
0.0278711952,
-0.0281286612,
0.0121891163,
0.0057791816,
0.0356775112,
-0.0440505296,
-0.0165596493,
0.0185154267,
0.0236587785,
0.0277841724,
-0.0017355934,
0.0323617458,
-0.0350334719,
-0.0345834754,
-0.0281783026,
-0.0283187348,
0.0239713918,
-0.0589229949,
0.0327933505,
0.0265608076,
0.047047548,
-0.0116004348,
0.0732875988,
0.0183651447,
0.0226436276,
-0.0132623911,
-0.0031241544,
-0.0349398777,
0.0173198786,
0.0022706112,
-0.0058719716,
-0.0071893116,
0.0324701406,
0.0012159192,
-0.0334925763,
-0.0107204653,
0.0144129768,
2.56e-7,
0.0302299354,
0.0808264539,
0.0090089161,
0.0369207151,
0.0351236239,
0.0073200599,
0.0087021282,
0.0321108587,
0.0027317731,
0.0151772518,
0.0193577576,
0.0079929968,
0.0511559919,
0.0310237557,
-0.0864196569,
-0.0384334587,
-0.1206510663,
-0.065176174,
-0.0552070178,
0.0151527086,
0.0936536491,
0.065260008,
0.0157603547,
0.030918574,
-0.0316616558,
-0.0211054292,
0.0574846305,
-0.0467898585,
-0.0416684337,
0.0148179438,
-0.0193622299,
-0.0301489439,
0.0018076556,
0.0752748623,
-0.0087783746,
0.0308142193,
-0.0217113346,
0.0576685406,
0.0042137695,
-0.0166764501,
-0.0114732645,
-0.0040246709,
0.0009620138,
-0.0428038649,
0.0918249115,
-0.0786693469,
-0.0306817126,
-0.0001748854,
-0.0492260791,
-0.019535454,
0.0378990136,
0.0346434824,
-0.0084034866,
0.0261324532,
0.0109709864,
-0.0253611784,
-0.0161637384,
-0.0770675316,
-0.0125453947,
0.0271447208,
-0.0254940502,
-0.0158549175,
-0.0123726446,
-0.0205531307,
0.0305064619,
-0.0295794643,
0.0084020384,
2.483103246e-34,
0.040486332,
-0.0117420768,
0.010485284,
0.0077349842,
0.0545687377,
-0.016248988,
0.0121789752,
0.0045291451,
0.031272389,
-0.0960558653,
0.0232393388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14803v1 | SemEval-2023 Task 11: Learning With Disagreements (LeWiDi) | 2023-04-28T12:20:35 | 2023-04-28T12:20:35 | Elisa Leonardelli, Alexandra Uma, Gavin Abercrombie, Dina Almanea, Valerio Basile, Tommaso Fornaciari, Barbara Plank, Verena Rieser, Massimo Poesio | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP datasets annotated with human judgments are rife with disagreements
between the judges. This is especially true for tasks depending on subjective
judgments such as sentiment analysis or offensive language detection.
Particularly in these latter cases, the NLP community has come to realize that
the approach of 'reconciling' these different subjective interpretations is
inappropriate. Many NLP researchers have therefore concluded that rather than
eliminating disagreements from annotated corpora, we should preserve
them-indeed, some argue that corpora should aim to preserve all annotator
judgments. But this approach to corpus creation for NLP has not yet been widely
accepted. The objective of the LeWiDi series of shared tasks is to promote this
approach to developing NLP models by providing a unified framework for training
and evaluating with such datasets. We report on the second LeWiDi shared task,
which differs from the first edition in three crucial respects: (i) it focuses
entirely on NLP, instead of both NLP and computer vision tasks in its first
edition; (ii) it focuses on subjective tasks, instead of covering different
types of disagreements-as training with aggregated labels for subjective NLP
tasks is a particularly obvious misrepresentation of the data; and (iii) for
the evaluation, we concentrate on soft approaches to evaluation. This second
edition of LeWiDi attracted a wide array of participants resulting in 13 shared
task submission papers. | [
0.075602226,
0.0663916171,
-0.0047303154,
0.0358459912,
-0.049291838,
0.0363334008,
-0.0048644999,
-0.0152943488,
-0.0026949171,
-0.1002821848,
-0.0532319695,
-0.0266373567,
0.0001424181,
-0.0169966836,
-0.0126617644,
-0.0531793498,
0.028940361,
0.0593845621,
0.0197659265,
0.0028233998,
0.0743537024,
-0.0288629606,
-0.0101785231,
0.0140057076,
-0.0548861884,
-0.0061602672,
0.0280102603,
-0.0076831765,
0.01327739,
-0.0125805382,
0.0525391623,
0.073563002,
-0.0203926619,
0.0133494241,
0.000001674,
-0.0344535969,
0.0132172611,
-0.0154635012,
0.0202787966,
-0.0380816907,
0.0586308725,
-0.0109280273,
0.0103976829,
-0.0020391857,
-0.0431299284,
-0.0027580585,
0.0454190709,
0.0788082257,
0.0923577175,
0.0544257537,
0.0101090539,
-0.0259671155,
-0.0656208545,
-0.005530477,
-0.0424216799,
-0.009562674,
-0.0099818194,
0.0075209974,
-0.0653585196,
-0.0057624825,
0.0030483368,
-0.0074276095,
0.0033580346,
0.0066223862,
0.0099707609,
-0.0206443164,
-0.0639379025,
-0.0694879442,
-0.0073208841,
0.0634652227,
0.0299941897,
-0.0531097688,
-0.0120795602,
-0.0025725511,
0.0013945986,
-0.0173876248,
0.0102096964,
0.0422924384,
-0.021782456,
0.0412688106,
0.0003161071,
0.0234143082,
-0.0017262003,
0.039819397,
0.0279785115,
0.0209696274,
-0.029190762,
-0.0520290881,
0.0564473495,
0.0740352198,
-0.047862716,
-0.0021051245,
0.0068282881,
-0.0105664739,
-0.0040059686,
0.0027097373,
-0.0272158515,
-0.0302390885,
0.034605775,
-0.109624058,
0.0176732838,
-0.0079677394,
-0.0246934481,
0.033452481,
0.0079288883,
0.0062003033,
0.0347245634,
0.0336823165,
-0.0237653963,
-0.0281547438,
-0.0603542924,
0.0469063111,
-0.0139437281,
0.0572580323,
-0.0306555666,
0.0195504799,
-0.0440274253,
-0.025821561,
-0.0854945034,
-0.0028409723,
0.0432516672,
0.015209374,
-0.0102464585,
0.0322413445,
-0.0811765492,
-0.0050128358,
-0.0261000823,
0.0307117905,
-0.051040329,
-0.0379343182,
0.0053958935,
0.037133798,
-0.0385463387,
-0.0193494558,
0.0181860328,
0.0508160703,
0.0146738719,
-0.0243626311,
-0.038863942,
-0.010896056,
-0.0658565611,
-0.0686629042,
-0.000848353,
-0.0702289417,
0.0270743798,
-0.0314220563,
0.0022415605,
-0.0387053341,
0.0041180411,
0.0317626894,
-0.0020086213,
0.1092591211,
-0.0078728227,
-0.043432638,
0.0116965622,
0.0028147793,
-0.0317658149,
0.0638455003,
-0.0007664412,
-0.0080084018,
0.0450684316,
0.0401416905,
0.0168035049,
-0.0149196265,
0.0182663836,
-0.0227083862,
0.0019712294,
0.0118119195,
-0.0272281524,
0.0072492096,
0.0083972514,
0.0693421066,
-0.033038184,
-0.0660914928,
0.0292078331,
0.023861926,
-0.0408843569,
0.0075000077,
0.0099825803,
-0.0117952768,
0.0326790698,
0.0362201743,
-0.0408659093,
0.0021657024,
-0.0125631383,
-0.0442077704,
-0.0108109796,
0.0025612111,
-0.0240101069,
-0.0878921971,
-0.0358669646,
-0.0280011557,
0.04527409,
-0.0352487788,
0.0153356818,
0.0385378562,
0.0136551512,
0.0139873344,
0.0384509452,
-0.0701151639,
-0.0070222872,
-0.0117462194,
0.0287077334,
0.0111787003,
0.0168692116,
-0.0086529236,
-0.0366023332,
-0.0190285724,
-0.003917309,
0.0487802364,
0.0556000359,
-0.0369133763,
0.0015182265,
-0.0472664386,
-0.0211907495,
-0.0077029616,
0.0278149005,
-0.0209358018,
0.0056334259,
-0.019629566,
-0.0047639622,
-0.0175715797,
-0.0551836118,
0.0493798666,
0.0405135863,
-0.0151273729,
-0.0070331865,
0.0350923091,
0.0661049634,
0.0158469211,
-0.0231419709,
-0.011450965,
0.0223197974,
-0.0147787044,
-0.0385362394,
0.0182112213,
0.0029134646,
-0.0587160848,
0.0345482677,
-0.0639972016,
-0.0376757905,
0.0344926454,
-0.0620093122,
0.0085992115,
-0.0019441732,
-0.0353784636,
-0.0299800318,
-0.0388982929,
0.0066802357,
0.0102123739,
-0.0276094135,
-0.0769455135,
0.0484901033,
0.0064392048,
0.0266106315,
-0.0311368294,
-0.0169436838,
0.0448497608,
-0.0116961487,
-0.0632390082,
0.0351529084,
0.0146795139,
0.0287027005,
0.0653124079,
0.0148753375,
-0.0433230288,
-0.0307422876,
-0.1006968319,
-0.0047150063,
-0.0231206473,
0.0039854804,
0.0410288163,
-0.0647760704,
0.0122286091,
0.0017218111,
-0.0307395104,
-0.0091994079,
0.0189947616,
0.0224849135,
0.077890113,
-0.0144180041,
0.0327125303,
-0.0429995395,
-0.0036405467,
-0.0122344689,
0.0300732851,
0.0077205561,
-0.0367059559,
-0.0079431087,
0.0171778183,
-0.0511370152,
0.0453340374,
0.0203802455,
-0.0252779257,
0.0371021442,
0.0467903242,
0.0178729575,
0.0452068523,
0.0265034195,
0.0788050145,
0.0309285447,
-0.0119812358,
-0.0415754355,
0.0067751347,
-0.033420641,
-0.0007619364,
0.005797402,
-0.0159280244,
0.031053748,
0.0606394634,
-0.0026270165,
-0.0306574609,
-0.0664740056,
0.0337241255,
-0.0553942211,
-0.0232280139,
-0.0086788833,
-0.0217875335,
-0.018300537,
0.0330219977,
-0.0471239276,
-0.0319255479,
0.0929531977,
-0.0124139413,
0.0503042489,
-0.1114553958,
0.0075007579,
-0.0326001234,
0.0483833887,
-0.0167193599,
-0.0023981926,
0.0177056324,
0.0181176905,
-0.0115458211,
-0.0196293667,
0.0527611896,
-0.021689767,
0.038375739,
-0.047284957,
0.0127561605,
-0.0029230078,
-0.0634156913,
-0.0234400164,
-0.0214470718,
-0.0147182504,
-0.0180319771,
0.0185652748,
0.0309559405,
-0.0019196575,
-0.0215456206,
-0.0243503321,
-0.0142372837,
0.0104332771,
-0.0032652924,
0.0101380395,
0.0132042309,
0.014825616,
0.0475636572,
0.0337509625,
0.0077797691,
-0.0469847545,
0.0743093491,
0.0211518034,
0.0189782903,
-0.0166228488,
-0.0085007185,
0.0222278964,
-0.0399031863,
-0.0191222169,
-0.0510268733,
0.0559772514,
-0.0131653557,
-0.020246014,
0.0775747001,
0.0473443232,
-0.0366869234,
-0.0056633302,
0.030637417,
-0.0136767812,
0.0231105592,
-0.0267293938,
-0.0698541775,
-0.0330397338,
-0.0291927271,
0.0196154378,
-0.0468707643,
-0.0349439718,
-0.0068156505,
-0.1050715521,
0.007969575,
-0.0058303643,
0.0140705146,
-0.0219015479,
-0.0350095145,
0.0049583996,
-0.0526816808,
0.0083821462,
-0.0448832884,
0.03688417,
0.0367509946,
0.0481407568,
-0.0168962926,
-0.0339506753,
0.029914584,
-0.0478674732,
0.0488808081,
0.0121503649,
0.0661355183,
0.0130575486,
-0.0299345385,
0.049090486,
-0.0405104905,
-0.0356543921,
-0.0156546775,
0.0646134615,
-0.0214589704,
-0.0338408947,
-0.0320231952,
-0.000007432,
-0.0147776129,
-0.0196875501,
-0.0319492668,
0.0153060053,
-0.0210022405,
0.0042816186,
-0.041346021,
0.0367349349,
-0.0026215473,
0.0743564591,
0.0060211155,
-0.0416409038,
-0.0422552414,
-0.0014541615,
0.0023984555,
-0.053267777,
-0.0280378833,
0.0054015485,
0.0031409385,
0.0110803004,
-0.0871972889,
-0.0965119526,
0.0103063276,
0.0265495833,
-0.0088087926,
-0.0418874435,
0.0280138776,
0.010693022,
-0.0158861857,
0.0417813361,
0.0022502649,
-0.0224413779,
-0.0240584556,
-0.0208654646,
0.0254721381,
0.0398169383,
-0.0237358604,
0.0428968072,
-0.0629485026,
-0.0445360392,
0.0207154155,
0.0583417863,
0.0165655278,
0.0027882806,
-0.0142481895,
-0.0289349928,
-0.0003458125,
0.0575312041,
0.0240141638,
0.0092503168,
0.0400333144,
0.0304055791,
0.0006156524,
0.0296361968,
0.0102052782,
0.0382402539,
0.042032849,
0.0014012383,
-0.0018705925,
-0.0292266309,
0.0443646833,
0.0004166255,
0.0846599191,
-0.0058814245,
-0.0222497489,
-0.0375182331,
-0.030659873,
0.0126302391,
-0.0556816496,
-0.0308775492,
-0.0037685179,
-0.0171949212,
0.0179747082,
-0.0634388849,
0.0437941179,
-0.0352945179,
0.0556165427,
-0.0096057439,
0.0088192048,
0.0776946098,
-0.0128860949,
-0.0673371404,
0.00268781,
-0.0468418673,
0.0096507994,
-0.0059555396,
0.0022679814,
0.0098846452,
0.0381986052,
0.0480492488,
0.0202872939,
0.016480675,
0.0329100117,
-0.012961613,
0.0577658117,
-0.0475734174,
0.0195896849,
0.0388851911,
-0.0231060106,
0.0325572342,
-0.0204685517,
-0.0078657884,
-0.0246879123,
0.0229778402,
-0.0053286375,
0.0036936156,
0.0447315983,
0.0243540481,
-0.0247736815,
-0.0416487157,
0.0514478832,
-0.0545492657,
0.0175004173,
0.0063501811,
-0.0414567105,
-0.0408532247,
-0.0405815318,
-0.018398473,
-0.0241899285,
0.0062868018,
0.0235867146,
-0.0579018109,
-0.0273813866,
0.0293345693,
0.0114991814,
0.0491271205,
0.0313854218,
0.0299561415,
0.0798361003,
0.0159464758,
0.0377943255,
-0.0369629227,
-0.0242951065,
0.0287626963,
-0.0036325473,
-0.052419886,
-5.847495546e-33,
-0.0174758639,
-0.0186488125,
-0.0179365091,
0.0294646583,
0.0048619602,
-0.0211747251,
0.0254953634,
0.0330977328,
-0.0213112477,
0.0378550999,
0.03453869,
0.0218072254,
0.019897135,
0.0016293174,
0.0237202737,
-0.0296198316,
0.0433735736,
-0.0169535112,
-0.0417276062,
-0.0304770712,
0.0395712219,
-0.0226855353,
0.0623430461,
-0.0926578268,
0.066910021,
0.0347103775,
-0.0260781143,
0.0167670492,
-0.0020658246,
0.0724222958,
-0.0080932723,
0.0827916265,
0.0487575755,
-0.0098739155,
0.0102167921,
-0.0101274662,
-0.0533976518,
-0.0335965902,
0.0163944717,
0.048689682,
-0.0204422977,
-0.0028998943,
0.0389723964,
0.0051394794,
-0.0603079684,
0.0130240209,
0.0294161495,
-0.0282698087,
0.0341553986,
-0.0436646193,
-0.0614666827,
0.030625511,
0.0184491221,
-0.0196477287,
0.0147727067,
0.0056438623,
-0.0181779433,
0.0229116827,
-0.1010283381,
0.0170083847,
-0.0378481932,
0.021231696,
-0.0253235884,
-0.0556066297,
-0.0027423922,
0.0900088698,
0.0063042091,
0.0385505408,
-0.0245969649,
-0.0111988997,
0.0019852924,
0.0280951206,
0.0550055616,
0.0773147568,
0.0382151976,
-0.0089970008,
-0.0603833646,
0.0139333177,
0.0270929839,
0.0183575321,
-0.0014973658,
-0.0127631146,
-0.0410781391,
-0.0169680025,
-0.0167222247,
-0.0549295209,
-0.0281790197,
0.0176232252,
0.0148895998,
0.0086226659,
0.0020252273,
0.0275947228,
-0.0122882705,
-0.0343292505,
-0.0113154259,
-0.0175245348,
0.0078427019,
0.0115680946,
0.0236068666,
-0.010264921,
-0.0418627635,
-0.0211423952,
-0.0044049863,
0.0302101839,
0.0263390113,
-0.0148819136,
0.1032268777,
0.0116446894,
-0.0541109368,
-0.0007357182,
-0.0203828439,
0.0404756293,
-0.0244700294,
0.0560069382,
0.0277987998,
0.042747207,
-0.0263453964,
0.0453479253,
0.0046256487,
0.0230947416,
-0.0192408543,
-0.0020699096,
-0.0035885805,
0.005840891,
0.0228562597,
-0.0292721242,
0.0060989955,
-0.0050608064,
-0.0165333804,
-0.0235308371,
0.0161626022,
-0.0200852025,
2.435e-7,
0.0448868312,
0.0401810482,
0.0320714228,
-0.0236936789,
0.0156022701,
0.0377172008,
-0.0158047117,
0.0339769274,
-0.0073891515,
-0.0305845831,
-0.0229398161,
0.0098168589,
0.0293912049,
0.0410498008,
-0.038318444,
-0.013190941,
-0.0320820063,
-0.012440322,
0.0061492068,
0.0185458641,
0.1011681184,
0.0997809544,
0.0342382677,
-0.0040220702,
-0.0328600034,
0.0197746996,
0.0845971256,
-0.0072390395,
-0.026020769,
0.0128563875,
0.0735631436,
-0.0292387046,
0.0012958943,
0.0401970185,
-0.0040882742,
-0.0075691654,
0.0269139353,
0.0368741415,
0.0198833067,
-0.0472808257,
0.0068900567,
0.0308709908,
0.0012259084,
-0.001126968,
0.0395793132,
-0.0605021343,
-0.0565213189,
-0.0353955775,
-0.022688305,
0.0155753894,
0.085544318,
-0.00092701,
-0.0348702557,
0.0189791676,
0.0222600177,
0.0168551765,
-0.037525475,
-0.0743965805,
-0.0231987238,
0.0070757233,
-0.0214611106,
-0.0353802629,
0.0227568634,
-0.0015546462,
0.0357975811,
-0.0394674651,
0.0091509596,
1.742372943e-34,
0.0432187915,
-0.0110704182,
0.0240461882,
-0.0161455646,
0.022966899,
0.0085839862,
-0.0177857894,
-0.022980636,
0.0036471323,
0.0261178426,
0.0222454965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14802v1 | ResiDual: Transformer with Dual Residual Connections | 2023-04-28T12:19:47 | 2023-04-28T12:19:47 | Shufang Xie, Huishuai Zhang, Junliang Guo, Xu Tan, Jiang Bian, Hany Hassan Awadalla, Arul Menezes, Tao Qin, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Transformer networks have become the preferred architecture for many tasks
due to their state-of-the-art performance. However, the optimal way to
implement residual connections in Transformer, which are essential for
effective training, is still debated. Two widely used variants are the
Post-Layer-Normalization (Post-LN) and Pre-Layer-Normalization (Pre-LN)
Transformers, which apply layer normalization after each residual block's
output or before each residual block's input, respectively. While both variants
enjoy their advantages, they also suffer from severe limitations: Post-LN
causes gradient vanishing issue that hinders training deep Transformers, and
Pre-LN causes representation collapse issue that limits model capacity. In this
paper, we propose ResiDual, a novel Transformer architecture with Pre-Post-LN
(PPLN), which fuses the connections in Post-LN and Pre-LN together and inherits
their advantages while avoids their limitations. We conduct both theoretical
analyses and empirical experiments to verify the effectiveness of ResiDual.
Theoretically, we prove that ResiDual has a lower bound on the gradient to
avoid the vanishing issue due to the residual connection from Pre-LN. Moreover,
ResiDual also has diverse model representations to avoid the collapse issue due
to the residual connection from Post-LN. Empirically, ResiDual outperforms both
Post-LN and Pre-LN on several machine translation benchmarks across different
network depths and data sizes. Thanks to the good theoretical and empirical
performance, ResiDual Transformer can serve as a foundation architecture for
different AI models (e.g., large language models). Our code is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/ResiDual. | [
-0.0023006303,
0.0850866511,
0.0210428294,
0.0501142032,
0.0219693575,
-0.0185256768,
0.0303064734,
-0.0055864621,
-0.0299479421,
0.0083031422,
-0.0557653457,
-0.0166317653,
0.026521815,
0.0101408549,
0.0147441737,
-0.0610593744,
-0.0086411163,
0.0265973881,
-0.0532442853,
-0.0030098758,
-0.0193002541,
0.0086501809,
0.0236031003,
0.0463435613,
-0.0332150199,
0.0059881299,
0.0158822089,
0.0337191559,
0.0381893516,
0.0079394793,
0.0105042914,
0.0178727172,
0.0300941635,
0.04415638,
0.0000023545,
0.0045336457,
-0.0192607176,
-0.0089774001,
-0.0176286604,
0.0112272538,
-0.0092752269,
-0.0311083719,
-0.0248208568,
0.0009630063,
-0.0335132591,
-0.0311631057,
0.0516487472,
0.0884651318,
0.0570873655,
0.0744286925,
-0.0315885916,
-0.0795480758,
0.0420877971,
-0.0617736429,
-0.0169701818,
-0.04498595,
-0.0319910161,
-0.0203367863,
-0.0722884014,
-0.0188913252,
-0.0282549076,
0.0345499925,
0.0736588091,
-0.0109348372,
-0.0259149224,
0.0452003069,
0.000432203,
-0.0523417592,
0.0011617541,
0.0836037621,
-0.042316813,
0.0125641255,
-0.0347436331,
-0.0088374177,
0.0118086683,
-0.0482227877,
-0.0343734995,
0.0424279869,
0.0393255949,
0.0331975818,
-0.0328087248,
0.0372704081,
0.061105527,
0.0057518063,
-0.0634566024,
-0.017259419,
0.0162899345,
0.0127503965,
-0.0139407599,
0.0207580216,
-0.0330377184,
-0.0004870108,
0.0350381285,
0.0120367669,
-0.030355243,
0.0004013585,
-0.0281696822,
-0.0436684042,
-0.0297088828,
0.010038388,
0.0119870258,
0.0638576224,
-0.040016979,
0.0236970559,
-0.0631265342,
0.0902698711,
-0.0667169467,
0.0458708331,
-0.0476679951,
-0.0211601593,
0.0130544249,
-0.0020894113,
-0.0548131429,
0.0236836597,
-0.0383686274,
-0.0318759307,
-0.018630784,
0.0004994043,
-0.0294496063,
0.0011812017,
0.0386017151,
0.0260902345,
-0.088332966,
-0.0302846488,
0.0249519739,
0.0521521866,
-0.0106645646,
0.0006658726,
0.0358538963,
-0.0515184812,
-0.0356825255,
0.0184098762,
0.0155059285,
-0.0104714576,
0.0282189157,
0.0433309451,
-0.0343072042,
-0.0270108934,
-0.0487757698,
0.0133196218,
0.0097132837,
-0.0756024048,
-0.0019300863,
-0.0478233099,
0.0370575339,
-0.014670318,
0.0225823279,
-0.053967759,
0.0056625064,
0.00681462,
0.0077876514,
0.0399125479,
0.0091375485,
-0.0515820347,
0.0484409519,
0.0353910737,
-0.0013419065,
0.0408954918,
0.0345155708,
0.0581521541,
-0.0251223166,
-0.0219709445,
-0.0270314384,
0.0415331423,
0.0403458364,
0.0090505742,
-0.047825858,
-0.0400577672,
-0.0295235086,
0.0285149515,
0.0336160474,
0.0671554357,
-0.0301491451,
-0.027508216,
0.0599694587,
0.0245957281,
0.0078735556,
0.0773813799,
0.0557157174,
-0.0290262029,
-0.0157225095,
0.02389016,
-0.0529131107,
0.0363003761,
0.0363572687,
-0.046225816,
-0.02033717,
0.0662633553,
-0.0727905333,
-0.0349671766,
0.0172773395,
-0.0267615113,
0.0057474454,
-0.0316480361,
0.0435474142,
0.0522514731,
-0.0447106101,
0.094269231,
-0.0337715559,
-0.0328822657,
0.0328778252,
-0.0366610587,
-0.03587237,
-0.0082124062,
0.0305968095,
0.0029228318,
-0.0439224429,
-0.0091269184,
-0.0180697981,
0.0312184505,
0.0453855284,
0.0305986498,
0.0361389853,
-0.0531400032,
-0.0316620395,
0.0348329097,
0.0052085374,
0.023463184,
0.0082153734,
0.0061151264,
0.0468472019,
-0.02710847,
-0.0081389016,
0.0420059152,
-0.0378529131,
0.0119632119,
0.0515978485,
0.0188234169,
-0.0025473239,
0.013947295,
-0.0004648872,
-0.0210566744,
0.0431535691,
-0.0454042666,
-0.0723672509,
0.0310496669,
-0.0833058953,
0.0136899306,
0.0217486657,
-0.041846998,
0.0134177767,
0.1093067154,
-0.034987554,
-0.0507208742,
0.0364324003,
-0.0054935622,
0.0364121236,
-0.0304552875,
0.0089125922,
0.001410995,
0.0503529944,
0.0055322088,
0.0080201132,
-0.0338023193,
-0.0012564926,
-0.0065428261,
-0.0021347061,
0.0012760269,
-0.0077800592,
-0.0508837476,
-0.0048977295,
-0.0276878383,
0.0468370989,
0.0280213431,
-0.0110725285,
-0.0049240957,
-0.0209036097,
-0.0353052318,
0.022286199,
-0.0333361439,
0.0066731041,
0.014404539,
0.0591815077,
0.0364507362,
-0.025701154,
-0.0284085404,
0.0291509926,
0.0023586291,
-0.0140839731,
0.0105995359,
0.0081725819,
-0.0019178105,
-0.0028538096,
-0.0212787483,
0.0282636136,
0.0556161478,
-0.0213668942,
-0.0005303192,
-0.043079976,
-0.0326745324,
0.0008338128,
0.0354594775,
-0.0233994443,
-0.0757738799,
-0.0258168411,
-0.0196636934,
0.0612706058,
0.0511420555,
0.0020043449,
0.0240802597,
0.0125117376,
0.0461635254,
-0.0389340557,
0.0045188554,
-0.0356468409,
-0.0148663204,
-0.0464427769,
-0.0175499972,
-0.0210910607,
0.0778586045,
-0.0082979631,
0.0082530035,
-0.0380606167,
-0.0235104561,
0.0061507444,
-0.0021709597,
0.0206862371,
0.0085803978,
0.0035557484,
-0.0121028647,
-0.0239537675,
-0.047394041,
0.0349063054,
-0.0355454423,
-0.0298528839,
-0.0074330466,
-0.0128818834,
-0.0106456745,
0.0321589373,
0.00298769,
0.0242049843,
-0.0254952535,
-0.0459532812,
-0.0451191589,
-0.0089240121,
0.0036589503,
-0.0059398203,
0.0594658926,
-0.0168695915,
-0.0135409748,
-0.0497481301,
-0.0150473844,
-0.0392238535,
-0.0129987998,
-0.0104816416,
0.0500592925,
0.0363852903,
-0.069905147,
-0.0706539825,
-0.0170101635,
0.0129764453,
0.1060397029,
0.0078599323,
0.0031181674,
-0.002733835,
0.037839815,
-0.0149453757,
0.0517504476,
0.0542325228,
-0.0377487317,
0.0431111977,
0.0609479062,
-0.0150455665,
-0.0057462975,
-0.0853847191,
-0.0222193561,
0.0188884065,
0.0157964025,
-0.0093568563,
-0.0156363379,
0.0371867046,
-0.0496554486,
0.0028529621,
0.0704862252,
-0.0121690985,
-0.1097384542,
0.0058779838,
0.0352113843,
0.0398188457,
0.0296988934,
0.008590051,
-0.0683436394,
-0.0141883427,
-0.0173644852,
-0.0121102287,
0.0520560481,
-0.0051813666,
-0.0184426047,
-0.0441569462,
0.0344850793,
0.0036562569,
-0.0178520661,
-0.0517701656,
-0.0204521976,
-0.0134920459,
-0.0248599853,
0.0393125564,
-0.0258916561,
0.0248547904,
-0.084200874,
0.0116835469,
-0.0048395377,
-0.0600730404,
-0.0098638143,
-0.0441156849,
-0.0133619718,
0.0138518065,
0.0191835668,
-0.0206864905,
-0.0446362682,
0.0511008054,
-0.006110644,
0.0051118522,
0.0080267759,
0.027739374,
0.0278792158,
-0.0196515173,
0.0318479016,
0.0148563087,
-0.0394859575,
0.0067068781,
-0.0412148498,
0.064552106,
-0.0126743801,
-0.0257999301,
-0.0024670465,
-0.0262149312,
-0.007534083,
0.0275214724,
0.0012053681,
-0.047388237,
-0.0150972866,
-0.0017302219,
0.0058366186,
-0.0438790135,
-0.0423594527,
0.0159509014,
-0.0075184265,
-0.0729776621,
-0.0539837852,
-0.0171896107,
-0.0258793943,
0.0373371691,
-0.0068700002,
-0.0791192129,
-0.0076022795,
0.0015935859,
-0.0456400961,
0.0353929251,
-0.0233962629,
0.0169416182,
-0.0438013412,
0.0623807982,
0.0364707224,
-0.028156098,
-0.004543751,
-0.0121075725,
-0.1358274072,
-0.0193787012,
0.0047372258,
0.0332942717,
0.0121538527,
0.0347574167,
-0.0178935714,
-0.0317638516,
0.0191349313,
0.0233106446,
-0.0206042603,
-0.0103280945,
0.0403689817,
-0.0690299422,
-0.0096967975,
0.0456590354,
-0.0186849162,
0.0490566604,
0.0383184701,
0.0252447985,
0.0085965926,
0.0183342379,
0.0224647205,
-0.0233651232,
0.0518235937,
-0.0014927411,
0.0337245949,
-0.030084407,
0.0295403302,
-0.009923391,
-0.0172839612,
-0.0543517694,
0.0134446574,
0.044532083,
0.0183489453,
0.0221550111,
0.0184633881,
0.0404921398,
0.0021078207,
-0.0372177251,
0.0145812258,
-0.0111086378,
-0.0201475043,
0.0236353129,
0.0300426073,
-0.0160934851,
-0.0188197773,
0.0237671584,
0.020419335,
-0.0283068474,
0.0366112925,
0.0298695769,
-0.0022447661,
-0.0644957796,
0.0194530468,
-0.0557129122,
-0.0023895619,
-0.0274659656,
0.0068523767,
0.0702909753,
0.0076557095,
0.036963392,
0.0092880977,
0.0002410536,
-0.0139332553,
0.0233031772,
-0.006457164,
-0.0335270353,
0.0256964974,
-0.0234388076,
0.0097994898,
0.0225405563,
0.0323241279,
-0.0319889784,
0.012184035,
-0.031628307,
0.0349270254,
-0.0384387858,
-0.0077295797,
-0.0022644447,
-0.0376478136,
-0.0111024622,
0.0068620704,
-0.0077636349,
-0.0654025376,
0.0075964839,
-0.0265926458,
0.0055525708,
0.0061254967,
0.0093719233,
0.0445387289,
0.0018745735,
-0.0096852919,
-0.0109121874,
0.0055410503,
-0.0008594883,
-0.0092915548,
-0.0155256195,
-7.029504707e-33,
-0.0050642029,
-0.0092122862,
0.0114084557,
-0.0042883153,
-0.0535268523,
0.0318707041,
-0.0244112182,
-0.0127088046,
-0.0586165823,
0.0338401198,
-0.0239960663,
0.0242645387,
0.0146624884,
0.0390720069,
-0.0328038819,
-0.0021507719,
0.0853755698,
0.0213354751,
-0.0261836536,
0.0154472711,
0.0117949722,
0.0211366601,
0.1016692594,
-0.0289086457,
-0.0363373905,
-0.0325683393,
-0.0338719971,
0.0402098298,
0.0179865193,
0.0264400057,
-0.0070260894,
0.0265308041,
0.0294618327,
-0.0567143485,
-0.0351388901,
-0.0080469279,
-0.0908956081,
0.0115098795,
-0.04882906,
0.0635561273,
-0.0382821709,
-0.0041036531,
0.0696590543,
-0.0067655887,
0.0068553449,
-0.0521146506,
0.0203075279,
0.0129474262,
-0.0326620862,
-0.0040763952,
-0.0316375718,
0.0205365457,
-0.0101898601,
-0.0225976948,
0.0068629142,
0.0548541322,
-0.0200219173,
0.0272504743,
-0.1146694571,
-0.0261293929,
-0.0334859826,
0.0520333461,
0.0435652658,
0.0324696116,
-0.0437254198,
0.0132960742,
0.0255723819,
0.0104415333,
-0.0630993173,
-0.010895974,
0.0725207478,
0.0009169581,
0.0515033789,
0.0069507933,
0.0576367043,
-0.0445578247,
-0.0668290406,
0.0085164448,
-0.0185494423,
0.0521412194,
0.0114971315,
0.0372915491,
0.0221305471,
-0.0040191971,
-0.0358701982,
-0.0449370146,
-0.0268897247,
0.0060563171,
-0.0087577989,
0.0510299467,
-0.013731122,
-0.000537254,
0.043643143,
-0.0355719775,
0.0548984557,
0.0426102132,
0.0155013902,
0.0288076717,
-0.0041903532,
0.0071449853,
-0.0207223408,
-0.0392111018,
0.0113711571,
0.0485810228,
0.0151521601,
0.0067480016,
0.0412185229,
0.0676113293,
-0.0473419875,
-0.0357588343,
-0.0487298556,
0.0085941721,
0.0101074362,
0.0855650157,
0.0212067291,
0.0114538744,
-0.0293640923,
0.0685583279,
-0.0075718793,
0.0336844474,
-0.006694207,
0.0801453143,
0.0713019148,
0.0385109484,
-0.0483677685,
-0.0048125233,
-0.0411353521,
0.0230425671,
0.0520670563,
-0.0807162151,
-0.0427315831,
-0.0022906219,
2.925e-7,
0.0206345133,
0.000780042,
0.0257737823,
-0.0048941239,
0.0132908989,
0.009362584,
0.0271941256,
0.0319284424,
-0.0054778885,
0.0322582349,
0.0417050906,
0.0193228666,
0.0553950705,
0.0399073176,
-0.0861474425,
0.0017281176,
-0.0792605877,
0.0030951018,
0.0059291613,
-0.0197099894,
0.025785489,
0.100767754,
-0.0085916501,
-0.0252319388,
0.0140399113,
0.0258352216,
0.0506068468,
0.0062418533,
0.0226968378,
0.0131195784,
0.0417082794,
0.0497114174,
-0.0224191137,
-0.0090419743,
-0.0239810646,
0.0589365102,
0.0103618596,
0.0706371069,
-0.0294604097,
-0.0365898125,
0.026163958,
0.0271745902,
-0.0096123675,
-0.0337657109,
0.0003595692,
-0.0602014847,
-0.0067934329,
-0.0042076688,
-0.037062142,
0.026181329,
0.0197261162,
-0.024892563,
-0.0135231335,
0.0248588547,
0.0407484658,
-0.0187453572,
-0.0286109503,
-0.0804916471,
-0.0306722522,
0.0040767333,
-0.0432991423,
0.0004255733,
-0.0220794864,
-0.0813184977,
0.0382849872,
0.0176361166,
-0.0166878719,
2.49677273e-34,
0.0020309195,
-0.0112334685,
0.0076336274,
0.0231520217,
0.0164144281,
-0.0158204716,
0.0588918701,
-0.0240951832,
-0.0096420748,
-0.0428031385,
-0.0223992839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14796v1 | Are the Best Multilingual Document Embeddings simply Based on Sentence Embeddings? | 2023-04-28T12:11:21 | 2023-04-28T12:11:21 | Sonal Sannigrahi, Josef van Genabith, Cristina Espana-Bonet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dense vector representations for textual data are crucial in modern NLP. Word
embeddings and sentence embeddings estimated from raw texts are key in
achieving state-of-the-art results in various tasks requiring semantic
understanding. However, obtaining embeddings at the document level is
challenging due to computational requirements and lack of appropriate data.
Instead, most approaches fall back on computing document embeddings based on
sentence representations. Although there exist architectures and models to
encode documents fully, they are in general limited to English and few other
high-resourced languages. In this work, we provide a systematic comparison of
methods to produce document-level representations from sentences based on
LASER, LaBSE, and Sentence BERT pre-trained multilingual models. We compare
input token number truncation, sentence averaging as well as some simple
windowing and in some cases new augmented and learnable approaches, on 3 multi-
and cross-lingual tasks in 8 languages belonging to 3 different language
families. Our task-based extrinsic evaluations show that, independently of the
language, a clever combination of sentence embeddings is usually better than
encoding the full document as a single unit, even when this is possible. We
demonstrate that while a simple sentence average results in a strong baseline
for classification tasks, more complex combinations are necessary for semantic
tasks. | [
-0.00597233,
0.0302869529,
0.011073295,
0.050605081,
-0.0545628257,
-0.00077942,
0.0291587524,
-0.0337814689,
-0.0066889394,
-0.0537992381,
-0.0350113921,
-0.0019273271,
-0.0084641157,
0.0006644545,
0.0192318596,
-0.0540839769,
0.0440267697,
-0.0078360522,
-0.0077972244,
-0.0074375598,
0.0499297567,
0.0209799428,
0.0361855812,
0.0486878045,
-0.0441297442,
-0.0345135294,
-0.0085087875,
-0.0123591125,
0.0162798632,
0.0149114104,
0.0187826548,
0.0164119378,
0.0665423274,
0.0263282657,
0.0000016405,
-0.0234622005,
-0.0232519805,
-0.0057220226,
0.0270416047,
0.0197337698,
0.0312950835,
-0.0651265681,
0.0260933824,
-0.0029944342,
0.0078689447,
0.0000841286,
0.0211106949,
0.0650514066,
0.0549281016,
0.0583653748,
-0.0221063755,
-0.031883046,
0.0186464079,
-0.0213631876,
-0.0026446688,
-0.0155112473,
-0.016356362,
-0.0263142325,
-0.0023235423,
0.0095822113,
-0.0389002748,
0.0146212811,
0.0397881344,
-0.005993153,
0.01025197,
0.0189218391,
-0.0494961701,
0.0140526667,
-0.0135895917,
0.0823455676,
-0.0465332083,
-0.020055959,
-0.0155640505,
0.0142712733,
-0.0123082111,
-0.051841978,
-0.0553441457,
0.0118185701,
0.0558739901,
0.0393540226,
0.0397570059,
0.0337672308,
0.0412738211,
0.0101351812,
-0.024344828,
0.0321876146,
0.0219218377,
-0.0540301837,
0.0158955511,
0.0198979136,
-0.0367547572,
-0.0096988212,
0.000351864,
0.0078158127,
-0.015551568,
0.0068601584,
-0.0588429384,
-0.0625206083,
0.0464809053,
-0.0421480946,
0.0522404835,
0.0340260826,
-0.012358699,
0.0761927292,
-0.0722306594,
0.0404766984,
-0.0043041571,
0.0307031032,
-0.061375089,
-0.0446515493,
-0.0204420462,
-0.0072179232,
-0.0460076183,
0.0322933123,
-0.0482376553,
-0.0609775968,
-0.0209240038,
0.0248247012,
0.0266786087,
0.0293223914,
-0.0183367524,
-0.0074237287,
-0.0110244472,
-0.017475117,
0.0377511159,
0.0292192921,
-0.0555563718,
0.0066526067,
-0.0210262872,
-0.0138113415,
-0.0189531315,
0.0449452139,
0.0114593795,
-0.0240008347,
-0.0010315661,
0.0577343516,
0.0004694581,
-0.0602756813,
0.0418016091,
-0.0015394996,
-0.016879715,
-0.0719330981,
0.0129820388,
-0.072551541,
0.062443804,
0.0204551201,
0.0142249363,
0.0075304951,
0.0160912182,
0.0113673881,
-0.0172846876,
0.0543305725,
-0.0006993696,
-0.0240955111,
0.0004937913,
-0.0001681545,
0.0284212045,
0.0746092945,
0.0362503305,
0.0301846731,
0.0693880096,
0.0057224068,
-0.0199550595,
0.0350417681,
0.0091685569,
0.002958073,
0.0170680266,
0.0033126862,
0.0062619825,
0.0276980773,
0.0006750856,
0.0200555921,
-0.043144986,
0.0078832814,
0.0097161736,
0.0581741817,
-0.0082414523,
-0.0101476861,
0.0413152277,
-0.0018082662,
-0.0149383163,
0.0028524098,
-0.0277066026,
0.0109221824,
0.0453212261,
-0.0009743753,
0.0321819782,
0.0381936468,
-0.0483294204,
0.0019849057,
-0.0082773529,
-0.0687448308,
0.0315799043,
-0.0319680795,
0.0511259586,
-0.0038877549,
-0.0165688246,
0.0677002668,
0.026645612,
-0.0476725847,
-0.0130838398,
0.0252689868,
-0.0226079505,
0.0327337794,
0.0547987856,
-0.0477003716,
-0.0078053409,
-0.0117820939,
0.0214414578,
0.0445398986,
0.067182079,
-0.0078530069,
0.0513342805,
-0.0657934248,
-0.0332615152,
-0.054241769,
0.0027106523,
0.0330433846,
-0.0204222482,
0.0205909535,
0.0342214368,
-0.105964683,
-0.0218905155,
0.0289219897,
-0.0137841441,
-0.0330913253,
0.0155405784,
0.016018834,
-0.0057350686,
0.0083128354,
0.0031137588,
0.0247209072,
0.0395106822,
-0.0709711537,
0.0163180437,
0.0167575032,
-0.0408863984,
-0.0608486012,
0.0092312396,
-0.0528381653,
-0.0101512764,
0.0451968946,
-0.064803645,
-0.0288949702,
-0.0004221408,
-0.0407764167,
0.0425960124,
-0.0530356802,
-0.0312218983,
-0.0091295345,
0.0329848342,
0.0034761657,
0.0348691829,
-0.0234120619,
0.0312701911,
-0.0098070847,
-0.0525808856,
0.0622856878,
-0.0257301684,
-0.0590997823,
0.0082370248,
0.0231205691,
0.0169936009,
0.028066935,
0.023065431,
-0.0065426207,
0.0186180323,
-0.1359408349,
0.0116541339,
-0.0261741877,
0.0132355159,
0.0032619771,
0.0155060813,
0.011181687,
-0.034819711,
-0.0531299338,
0.0033689411,
0.0123384502,
0.0369293913,
0.0521248989,
-0.009257501,
0.0078533143,
-0.0082199853,
-0.0375688821,
-0.0191621035,
0.075558044,
-0.0415880717,
-0.0110378899,
-0.0353592858,
-0.0173031613,
-0.0231875516,
-0.0105755758,
-0.015150452,
-0.0222296175,
0.0001235406,
-0.0236639865,
0.0520941168,
0.0614251681,
-0.0035042267,
0.0458367802,
0.0565791652,
0.0107670641,
-0.0544216149,
0.009840535,
-0.021657601,
0.0831266269,
-0.0401037149,
0.0087401271,
0.0294632018,
0.0249013174,
-0.0094306022,
0.0008777374,
-0.018905919,
-0.0172013026,
-0.0028638504,
-0.0411326513,
-0.0570699871,
-0.0072955559,
0.0136375669,
0.0045812959,
-0.0044963928,
-0.0188227892,
0.0586428456,
-0.0334396325,
-0.0046634926,
-0.076347664,
0.0032539472,
-0.0397004485,
0.0115735205,
0.0121076088,
0.0406501107,
-0.0495943278,
-0.0056948545,
-0.0124907354,
-0.004479073,
-0.0153303733,
0.0110508958,
0.0059840269,
0.0234885681,
-0.0211478956,
-0.0353881828,
-0.0707657933,
-0.0133361928,
-0.0717611313,
-0.0021637341,
0.0406790711,
-0.0162113179,
0.0092061963,
-0.0593020022,
-0.0165882353,
0.0475137234,
0.0257549379,
-0.0298800748,
0.009856659,
-0.0368242823,
0.0719277188,
0.0375764295,
-0.0170146655,
0.0045060436,
-0.0567336269,
0.0034198707,
0.0435275845,
0.026249608,
-0.006904522,
-0.0378368907,
0.0045689875,
0.0024297228,
-0.038225092,
-0.0255677439,
-0.0396388099,
0.0565328002,
-0.0531011596,
0.0028153865,
0.1042149067,
0.0238022786,
-0.0252056792,
-0.0183327328,
-0.0180298816,
0.0148158679,
-0.0073339059,
0.0128834993,
-0.0889355838,
-0.0377553962,
0.0012276192,
-0.002037717,
0.0512054749,
0.0043877722,
0.0139159551,
-0.0910338238,
0.0122181037,
0.0001243129,
-0.001179199,
-0.0360162705,
-0.0414786004,
-0.0180225298,
0.0204113275,
0.0198253337,
-0.0462930165,
0.0205595586,
-0.0088168159,
-0.0057286443,
-0.0169731099,
-0.0150157288,
0.0210099276,
-0.0196325053,
-0.039026618,
0.0550071858,
0.0730601549,
-0.0127691645,
-0.0364473425,
0.0448847115,
-0.0162752494,
-0.0214599613,
-0.0050642113,
0.0414738618,
-0.0251414739,
-0.0036655867,
0.0175263975,
0.0120593496,
-0.02949767,
-0.0234400705,
-0.0154638691,
0.0980435461,
0.0071828542,
0.0003808905,
-0.0407498889,
-0.0297415107,
0.0016944943,
0.072185427,
0.0199466571,
-0.0737504587,
-0.0629087016,
-0.0195105225,
0.0151796294,
-0.0556463078,
0.0155202402,
-0.0193261839,
0.0027151562,
0.0112698022,
-0.053366635,
-0.1013109535,
0.030770801,
0.0235398151,
-0.0092830388,
-0.0130625563,
-0.046821814,
-0.0124746142,
-0.0094565433,
0.0218227599,
-0.0095014982,
0.0092059169,
-0.0151543906,
0.0556470491,
0.013340286,
-0.0042578937,
-0.0273926295,
-0.0425470285,
-0.0321452469,
-0.0367217101,
-0.0291855931,
0.0327473134,
-0.0004523499,
0.0387999527,
-0.0407709181,
-0.0239141192,
0.0609524548,
0.0337342359,
-0.0428675674,
-0.0229359884,
0.0538770556,
-0.0020885179,
0.0047903727,
0.0641686544,
-0.0538928211,
0.0310780462,
0.0170022137,
0.0353071615,
0.0056291455,
-0.0518847816,
-0.0129650626,
-0.0033008086,
0.0374888778,
-0.0296434239,
0.0123097049,
-0.0176301673,
0.0210844427,
-0.0301074423,
-0.0317678303,
-0.028669782,
0.0201796666,
0.0145286359,
0.0091392212,
-0.0051711807,
0.0500169806,
0.0214431211,
0.0144379567,
-0.0317786969,
0.0275345929,
0.0220131297,
-0.0213299356,
-0.0255030002,
0.034705352,
-0.0326016098,
-0.0238460433,
-0.0432465933,
0.0123460498,
-0.0516811013,
0.011186176,
0.0230636578,
-0.0025716091,
-0.0138422633,
0.0576796792,
-0.0793949738,
-0.0006118513,
-0.0063255923,
0.0294951797,
0.0692083091,
-0.0499532148,
0.0321705788,
-0.0282808356,
-0.0316044949,
-0.0420993231,
0.0476954132,
0.0329783745,
-0.0200937968,
-0.0087813996,
0.0283826962,
-0.0228301603,
-0.0109453294,
0.0718779266,
-0.0117987823,
0.0109882094,
0.0173367728,
-0.0131617691,
-0.0581714846,
0.0105153089,
0.0352808945,
0.0338548087,
-0.0124638304,
0.010727236,
-0.0078436518,
-0.0393985286,
0.0489863604,
0.0102713769,
-0.0419739261,
0.0193352327,
0.0267586652,
0.0798444077,
0.0156035032,
0.0114294859,
-0.0313747972,
0.0295073856,
-0.0026654499,
-0.0608054399,
-0.0004417172,
-5.190927217e-33,
0.0216694735,
0.0336704217,
-0.0276395716,
0.0001984066,
0.0031729513,
0.034712851,
-0.0235422943,
-0.0294638276,
-0.0025993583,
0.0281526819,
-0.0215370841,
-0.0223479588,
0.0100868624,
0.0336930528,
-0.0074545001,
-0.0003011719,
0.0357398838,
-0.0182748958,
-0.0184664093,
0.0300378036,
0.0687108412,
0.0381919555,
0.0844907761,
-0.0301444065,
0.0375019945,
-0.0020958832,
0.0157182906,
-0.0068714512,
0.0446725227,
0.061979875,
-0.0304645449,
0.0433507599,
0.0277192872,
-0.0051834364,
-0.0381257273,
0.050000824,
-0.0896167383,
-0.0223449823,
-0.0164578613,
0.0178697556,
-0.0607057735,
-0.0359817222,
-0.0114070736,
-0.0232611969,
0.0243114475,
-0.0095561063,
0.0490665212,
0.0002213622,
-0.024861712,
-0.030855624,
-0.0721084923,
0.0067796046,
-0.0182870794,
0.0062014731,
0.0495179854,
0.0670561269,
0.0230587889,
0.0584777556,
-0.0734065324,
-0.0224204604,
-0.0531730019,
0.0304995645,
0.0124775404,
-0.0485399254,
-0.0122473594,
0.048695758,
-0.0102593526,
-0.0465493463,
0.0005950042,
0.0325082056,
0.0415877216,
0.0340042785,
0.0423456989,
0.0687174127,
0.044700101,
0.013452149,
-0.0983732119,
0.0442992263,
0.0299620051,
0.0354016162,
0.0498844534,
0.0178290382,
-0.0172939543,
0.0098367035,
-0.021328738,
-0.026883496,
-0.0116367647,
-0.0251490623,
0.0357096642,
0.0106883002,
0.016329322,
0.0056608734,
0.0614002608,
-0.0485495478,
-0.0384494215,
0.0435532965,
-0.0098980647,
0.0046440945,
0.0368020087,
0.0327468365,
-0.0548757613,
-0.0194994379,
0.0031950665,
-0.0089359144,
0.0100502055,
-0.017422121,
0.0826474726,
-0.0084406883,
-0.0412123799,
0.016858587,
-0.0169388987,
-0.0484695807,
-0.0193100777,
0.0584045686,
0.024940908,
0.0027892613,
-0.0092217,
0.0437503047,
0.0183393676,
0.0068231421,
-0.0239413586,
-0.0766875669,
0.0128282718,
0.0417686105,
-0.0189337544,
-0.015554904,
-0.0483830236,
0.0324387327,
0.0041768928,
-0.0659326464,
0.0106608514,
0.0104560554,
2.274e-7,
0.054565452,
0.0108325612,
0.0433212817,
0.00804336,
0.0161352791,
0.0436406322,
-0.0182659533,
0.0839776024,
-0.0320112221,
-0.0104529671,
-0.0063709021,
0.0295764077,
0.064413771,
0.020008456,
-0.108692266,
0.0306978375,
-0.0565884151,
-0.003444168,
-0.069533743,
0.0073245903,
0.0486420877,
0.1011906266,
0.0024146445,
-0.0049775215,
-0.0242209733,
-0.0433502495,
0.097448498,
-0.0304745808,
-0.0415851101,
-0.0066047274,
0.0360775366,
0.0134352427,
0.0030055128,
-0.0299607739,
-0.0325174816,
0.0623721592,
0.0428883955,
0.041735705,
0.0100193927,
-0.0450119041,
0.0163941793,
-0.024617916,
-0.0202503297,
-0.0402455479,
0.0837920234,
0.0007255088,
0.0045183776,
-0.0243705884,
0.0027899351,
0.0126165273,
0.070004195,
-0.0160603113,
-0.0525281616,
0.0235360842,
0.0493519306,
-0.0366047174,
-0.0077516069,
-0.0788765326,
-0.0272441879,
0.0053255619,
-0.0370004214,
0.0078080609,
-0.0268073007,
0.0032730622,
0.0582583919,
-0.0548403338,
-0.0084446846,
2.132324712e-34,
0.0566524491,
0.0024463194,
0.0090948287,
0.0226404592,
-0.0025099874,
-0.0459750667,
-0.0129979439,
-0.0377995409,
0.0226662923,
-0.0742698908,
-0.0134295961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14780v1 | Training and Evaluation of a Multilingual Tokenizer for GPT-SW3 | 2023-04-28T11:40:48 | 2023-04-28T11:40:48 | Felix Stollenwerk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper provides a detailed discussion of the multilingual tokenizer used
for GPT-SW3. It was trained on the Nordic Pile using the SentencePiece library
and the BPE algorithm. We outline the tokenizer's most important features and
share details on its learned vocabulary. In addition, we systematically analyze
the properties and evaluate the performance of the tokenizer with regard to the
different languages present in the data. | [
0.0182800032,
0.0080847852,
0.0128649827,
0.0657320395,
-0.0325551555,
-0.0085653858,
0.0116104754,
-0.0024381718,
-0.0380320959,
-0.0304687731,
0.0123107359,
-0.0049708379,
0.0105195334,
0.031842526,
0.0370070748,
-0.1066488102,
0.0958478749,
-0.042636957,
0.0170525443,
0.0179000795,
0.0220312104,
0.0158290956,
-0.0171811841,
0.0320303887,
-0.0486905426,
-0.0033385956,
0.0135071911,
-0.0023129445,
0.0253288839,
-0.0288037434,
-0.0364169627,
0.0106434599,
-0.0164919663,
0.0621080212,
0.0000015486,
-0.056132067,
-0.0535893328,
-0.0129331341,
0.0569701456,
-0.0086010797,
0.0670330822,
-0.0471492074,
-0.0329945758,
0.0046924115,
-0.0112336818,
-0.0291512944,
0.0683643222,
0.0793995783,
0.054253377,
0.0534644611,
-0.0251014624,
-0.0402934477,
0.0241821278,
0.0282449871,
-0.0418305844,
-0.002008917,
-0.0078031956,
0.0085741235,
0.0025708759,
0.0290245451,
-0.03611359,
0.0201373771,
-0.003786189,
0.0172708035,
-0.0049554463,
0.0241282973,
-0.0939865112,
-0.0150793483,
-0.0363741182,
0.0204329919,
-0.0028149928,
-0.0255469494,
-0.0132145239,
0.008054371,
-0.0046089515,
-0.0387090854,
-0.023594832,
0.0275916085,
-0.0186391007,
0.0274582058,
0.0408683196,
-0.0062247813,
-0.0032521642,
-0.0292457566,
-0.0178795177,
0.1037960649,
0.0319378339,
-0.0241420157,
0.0128204245,
0.0089477934,
-0.0403530039,
-0.0093699368,
0.0131058739,
-0.0211621691,
-0.0613119379,
-0.0097147254,
-0.0268387701,
-0.0618561767,
0.0245507564,
0.0146408714,
-0.0182200968,
0.027335288,
-0.0176586807,
0.0293279085,
-0.0183893908,
0.0409648754,
0.0446441546,
-0.0062440014,
-0.0540161543,
-0.0532821864,
-0.0349142216,
-0.0378592722,
-0.1020895466,
0.0436091982,
-0.0015171043,
-0.0491086803,
-0.0278625004,
-0.016487278,
0.0495821089,
-0.0158489682,
0.0174030084,
-0.0358882956,
-0.0375416055,
0.0011372599,
-0.0084641045,
0.03966875,
-0.0377441049,
0.0218625758,
-0.023175044,
-0.0168963652,
0.0007439065,
0.0490463488,
0.0202403087,
-0.0179896373,
-0.006584866,
0.041855026,
-0.0248634107,
-0.0293335095,
-0.032702405,
-0.0012956643,
-0.0091526546,
-0.0287957452,
-0.0436791927,
-0.0740144178,
0.0339619815,
-0.0019399148,
0.0037562302,
0.0332407877,
0.0085379863,
-0.0155479247,
-0.0188184828,
0.059868753,
-0.0508292541,
-0.0456213206,
0.0113086672,
-0.0275269784,
-0.0015569956,
0.0879378021,
0.0227479916,
0.0481550992,
0.0710480139,
-0.0450325087,
-0.0081191529,
0.0672350898,
-0.0442919955,
-0.0269400664,
-0.0405051745,
-0.022388516,
0.0439208299,
-0.0170215126,
0.0633901879,
0.1077430844,
-0.0396042354,
0.0407501236,
0.0025399341,
0.0837485865,
0.0227293596,
0.0436786376,
0.0725329965,
-0.0012714291,
-0.0077937744,
-0.008414425,
0.0023277772,
-0.044688452,
0.0256738979,
0.0179454535,
-0.0098807793,
0.0600397475,
0.0097162537,
0.0061942614,
0.0082973447,
-0.0236080326,
0.0268798843,
-0.0755737647,
0.0706423,
-0.0187378582,
-0.0444225557,
0.0603233352,
0.0120756216,
-0.0544595234,
0.0284512192,
0.0107097151,
0.0033947458,
0.054560177,
0.0196431261,
0.0066128499,
0.000301221,
-0.0228167381,
-0.0054869838,
0.0576540157,
0.0271918233,
-0.0074896151,
0.0023582671,
-0.0552316681,
0.000499462,
0.0243484695,
0.0088969609,
0.0363926962,
-0.0045406404,
0.0266915429,
0.0158049185,
-0.0456727818,
0.028625248,
0.0489473529,
0.0312530622,
0.0048977663,
-0.0253319405,
-0.011155827,
0.0271605626,
0.0674450621,
-0.0247163158,
0.0162032209,
0.0314971656,
-0.0496513955,
-0.0041965158,
0.0552474633,
-0.0092315674,
-0.012186246,
0.0521049537,
-0.0497985147,
0.0022713961,
-0.0095495349,
-0.0204180405,
-0.0738539919,
0.0244771652,
-0.0339880921,
0.0550163426,
-0.0337009542,
0.0132969776,
0.002532939,
0.0046937196,
-0.0353917517,
0.0447783694,
0.0294866711,
0.0313967057,
-0.0550225973,
-0.0130780004,
0.0725321248,
-0.068300128,
-0.0186979491,
0.0681002885,
-0.0143226637,
-0.0334735811,
0.0490007214,
0.001749498,
-0.0307553038,
-0.0127715655,
-0.1024887934,
-0.0106081665,
-0.0363344848,
0.0566944815,
0.0127338013,
0.0157839227,
-0.0080684396,
-0.01188186,
-0.0248926524,
-0.0104773231,
0.0190947633,
-0.0271260049,
0.0319071375,
-0.0138501925,
-0.0138739087,
0.0092401216,
-0.002202224,
-0.0081787286,
0.0406652503,
0.001523711,
-0.1004596427,
-0.0773292854,
-0.0049192277,
-0.0348790698,
0.0316035263,
0.0277266726,
-0.0591124892,
0.0324556939,
-0.0225917399,
0.0969876572,
-0.0112399384,
0.0177414361,
-0.0316595472,
-0.0088765221,
-0.0154337762,
-0.0143595804,
0.0104539683,
-0.0184805691,
0.0282754879,
-0.0350406989,
-0.0041263336,
0.0545214489,
0.0084974822,
0.0089009963,
0.0109024765,
-0.0566889346,
-0.0308802258,
-0.0310317278,
-0.0021956509,
-0.0019943761,
-0.0218877867,
-0.0086075608,
-0.020163523,
0.003642024,
-0.0072040451,
0.0520315394,
-0.0504228547,
-0.0277588759,
-0.0945342034,
0.0063889381,
-0.0453481004,
0.0601483285,
0.0030086394,
0.04990438,
-0.0348060764,
-0.0513755642,
-0.0090272482,
-0.0376064815,
0.0036020263,
0.0186070073,
-0.0315934941,
-0.0440591648,
0.0218444876,
-0.0238505919,
-0.0208119452,
0.008267778,
0.0291903764,
-0.0333861411,
0.0494760759,
0.0414071828,
-0.0133308806,
-0.0302334465,
0.0517843477,
0.020936517,
0.0566271916,
-0.0286566168,
0.0369886346,
-0.0235225875,
0.005968044,
0.0312626176,
0.0099065388,
0.0047571436,
0.0211719777,
0.0222951304,
0.0382009447,
0.0347928368,
-0.0633916184,
-0.0249580555,
-0.0011859981,
0.0191824138,
-0.0499625504,
-0.0249043237,
-0.0413737968,
0.0288673732,
-0.0374709293,
0.0159862395,
0.0791858509,
0.0305980816,
-0.0291939471,
-0.0107401628,
-0.0161822978,
0.0048267664,
0.0096170567,
0.0107674766,
-0.0873801038,
-0.0197343212,
-0.0154733444,
-0.0072360882,
0.01771079,
-0.0088376971,
-0.0145470593,
-0.100116156,
0.0509032123,
0.0371855944,
-0.1037055999,
-0.0054770946,
-0.0361381657,
-0.0704486519,
-0.043627467,
-0.005939275,
0.0158285964,
-0.0089409761,
0.0251913518,
0.0119224107,
-0.0268502403,
-0.0131685333,
-0.0286154263,
-0.048142083,
0.0272456016,
0.0497102067,
0.0061612693,
-0.0742906183,
-0.0523673743,
0.0845863074,
0.0056644846,
-0.0231525302,
-0.0313696377,
-0.0158518478,
-0.0025437544,
-0.0054935184,
0.0142206335,
0.0170534905,
0.0051197107,
-0.0458157808,
0.0287264306,
0.0731685385,
0.0075823516,
0.0264963973,
0.020141175,
-0.001768565,
0.011234547,
0.0193932746,
-0.0252484232,
-0.0063821557,
-0.0579315647,
-0.0685663,
-0.0105042718,
-0.0529961661,
-0.0003953376,
-0.0085462229,
-0.0168487579,
-0.0309595261,
-0.0722201988,
-0.0218419749,
0.0706518218,
0.0594169088,
0.0002060215,
0.0567484796,
-0.0420233756,
0.0016474711,
-0.0359770097,
0.0145354047,
0.0150379268,
0.0165864043,
-0.0877952874,
-0.0001804867,
0.0222999565,
-0.0092411805,
-0.0105233761,
0.0017828376,
-0.0006447807,
-0.0420769043,
0.0222671833,
0.0345635191,
0.026887292,
0.0359648764,
-0.0113678267,
-0.0053223381,
0.002914197,
0.0583328381,
-0.0475829206,
0.0083798068,
-0.0045162276,
0.0393496975,
-0.0154436016,
-0.0143547663,
-0.0021428107,
0.0279160608,
-0.0390134081,
0.0458625928,
0.0340753421,
0.04475943,
-0.0096731521,
0.046918232,
0.0397215709,
-0.051147785,
0.0038339861,
-0.043025732,
-0.0020599985,
-0.0389451794,
-0.0326903686,
-0.0539189391,
0.0655252337,
0.0003514436,
-0.0252763927,
0.0013788963,
-0.052307684,
-0.0701576918,
0.0255586933,
0.0366784222,
0.0176835246,
0.0256460514,
-0.0102278059,
0.0038333121,
0.0032393872,
-0.0253497548,
-0.0232556798,
-0.0110591874,
0.0233954769,
-0.0564539768,
0.0022684748,
0.0030780465,
-0.0230779368,
-0.0408391505,
0.0286757182,
-0.0198502839,
0.0265107658,
-0.049817007,
0.0030681419,
0.0479280129,
0.0245588981,
0.0693578944,
-0.0436108857,
-0.0275143608,
0.0150016984,
0.0314241089,
0.0168192945,
-0.0056798654,
0.0042215786,
-0.0062169856,
-0.0539444424,
-0.0471554287,
0.045772668,
0.0062625972,
0.0237810742,
0.0081277993,
-0.0300575923,
-0.0469832718,
-0.0221638195,
0.0040753027,
0.0079400698,
-0.0403505117,
-0.0111236507,
-0.0428402424,
-0.0190297198,
-0.0465531386,
0.0492617823,
-0.0086838584,
0.0136753833,
0.0269729495,
0.0610630661,
0.0061873379,
-0.0148903439,
-0.0026431649,
-0.0271440502,
0.0271055344,
-0.0410303548,
-0.0045771762,
-5.013907686e-33,
-0.0239686146,
-0.0122915758,
-0.003439198,
-0.0072105834,
-0.0401507504,
-0.0322056301,
0.0172503404,
-0.0075250673,
0.0266932752,
0.0028554641,
0.0118981665,
-0.0186494365,
0.0459333956,
0.0197310131,
0.0218735524,
0.0524385497,
0.0515098087,
-0.0156899076,
-0.0157880001,
0.0080311606,
0.0626718327,
0.0530146211,
0.098953262,
-0.0014131883,
0.0157572385,
0.0313717946,
-0.0411497802,
0.0312278569,
0.0311900154,
0.0590160154,
-0.0167355221,
0.0270557944,
0.0043312479,
0.0042599682,
-0.0091933506,
0.0290345363,
-0.0675285459,
-0.0453540385,
0.0538420416,
0.0344260037,
0.0080622416,
-0.045820605,
0.0142370826,
-0.057135947,
-0.0028361094,
0.0461585037,
0.0164870154,
-0.0151898051,
-0.00769286,
-0.0068338988,
-0.0781366676,
0.0182129834,
-0.0051878784,
0.0653691739,
0.0512813404,
0.0080084363,
-0.0009176286,
-0.0032021613,
-0.0172552448,
0.0388081372,
0.0312909298,
0.0018206666,
0.0303902254,
0.0360276029,
0.0016012192,
0.0790951028,
0.0249324888,
-0.017690504,
0.0165916067,
0.0334246717,
0.0304169692,
-0.0005492638,
0.05244058,
0.0157144926,
0.0346980877,
-0.0177310258,
-0.0552166291,
0.0123507231,
0.0176899377,
0.0423391648,
-0.0156709608,
0.0086779781,
0.0176750738,
-0.03034232,
-0.0058171987,
-0.0342295542,
-0.0069057443,
-0.0384592079,
0.0359888785,
-0.0060500801,
-0.0151012084,
0.0179801453,
0.0333312117,
-0.002365869,
-0.0243806597,
-0.0044825953,
-0.007835906,
0.0086290445,
-0.0273747519,
0.0251421463,
-0.0206126962,
-0.0898921192,
0.0160870031,
0.0215539001,
0.0097369235,
-0.0244043116,
0.0300452821,
0.0256620869,
-0.0779802129,
0.053824883,
0.0001251775,
0.0012669205,
-0.0172874108,
0.0193049721,
0.0152000617,
-0.0264118165,
-0.0004155593,
-0.0178713873,
0.0411259085,
-0.0349352434,
-0.0083585335,
-0.0011780767,
-0.0122136604,
0.057057485,
-0.0072800322,
0.0339504369,
0.0021025517,
0.0038551353,
0.0197536293,
0.001882014,
0.0092797624,
0.0302697904,
2.255e-7,
0.0590427965,
0.039257694,
0.0598673597,
-0.0557617806,
0.0160341393,
-0.0228673667,
-0.0268627293,
0.0365993157,
-0.0088249221,
0.0848522186,
0.0004819221,
-0.0269936696,
0.022198163,
0.0448384807,
-0.1300794184,
0.0541099794,
-0.0208738614,
-0.0438547283,
-0.1245717034,
0.0336018465,
0.085022144,
0.0811116248,
-0.0021182904,
0.0000296776,
-0.037607573,
-0.0383046903,
0.0249115415,
-0.0363450088,
-0.0114691546,
0.0124487961,
0.0065990998,
0.0120249782,
-0.0014476092,
-0.0009020907,
0.0170343574,
0.0208042935,
0.0364572145,
0.0103319809,
-0.0168397147,
0.0167232919,
0.0281652473,
-0.0170284491,
-0.0034434302,
-0.0467675254,
0.0443954282,
-0.0092128459,
-0.0075660674,
-0.0051029148,
-0.0203626323,
0.0087844739,
0.005456713,
-0.055087883,
-0.0191936679,
0.0222751964,
0.0468017757,
0.0130736362,
-0.0086608268,
-0.0341399312,
-0.042695988,
0.0144142034,
-0.0145867551,
-0.0648989677,
-0.0080699502,
0.0150881214,
0.0168357659,
-0.018227594,
-0.0082285143,
2.055462764e-34,
0.0528885052,
-0.0286480002,
0.0113956314,
0.0144400317,
0.0315053836,
-0.0360429399,
0.0692636669,
0.0420937426,
-0.0261864197,
-0.043415878,
-0.0207058247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14770v2 | RexUIE: A Recursive Method with Explicit Schema Instructor for Universal Information Extraction | 2023-04-28T11:28:56 | 2023-10-18T02:30:55 | Chengyuan Liu, Fubang Zhao, Yangyang Kang, Jingyuan Zhang, Xiang Zhou, Changlong Sun, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Universal Information Extraction (UIE) is an area of interest due to the
challenges posed by varying targets, heterogeneous structures, and
demand-specific schemas. However, previous works have only achieved limited
success by unifying a few tasks, such as Named Entity Recognition (NER) and
Relation Extraction (RE), which fall short of being authentic UIE models
particularly when extracting other general schemas such as quadruples and
quintuples. Additionally, these models used an implicit structural schema
instructor, which could lead to incorrect links between types, hindering the
model's generalization and performance in low-resource scenarios. In this
paper, we redefine the authentic UIE with a formal formulation that encompasses
almost all extraction schemas. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first
to introduce UIE for any kind of schemas. In addition, we propose RexUIE, which
is a Recursive Method with Explicit Schema Instructor for UIE. To avoid
interference between different types, we reset the position ids and attention
mask matrices. RexUIE shows strong performance under both full-shot and
few-shot settings and achieves State-of-the-Art results on the tasks of
extracting complex schemas. | [
0.0457790792,
0.0521956347,
0.0285237674,
0.0545313805,
0.0165551752,
0.0485447198,
-0.0413624421,
-0.0049717827,
0.0074293474,
-0.0696866661,
-0.0447387621,
-0.01091028,
-0.0152263874,
-0.0139109287,
0.01764955,
-0.0472315028,
0.0542645976,
-0.0104982266,
0.0258154962,
0.0528770909,
-0.0137181766,
0.0038103685,
0.0212256089,
-0.0394747183,
-0.0335437283,
-0.0108474558,
-0.020889705,
0.0158759374,
0.0445011109,
-0.0611459091,
0.0343844555,
0.0203668233,
0.0081690662,
0.0202712119,
0.0000022536,
-0.0158261005,
-0.0627493933,
0.0018262671,
-0.0556920692,
-0.0070828344,
-0.022303395,
-0.0474869274,
-0.0097838491,
-0.0459657162,
-0.0251602046,
-0.0193394534,
0.0414534211,
0.0658242777,
0.0069756014,
0.0725670978,
-0.0362407826,
-0.0870733708,
0.0634060726,
-0.0181644838,
-0.0006043184,
-0.0610333458,
0.0272971746,
0.0196958203,
-0.0167641472,
0.0350373797,
0.0333267823,
0.0199838597,
-0.0083242385,
0.0261591375,
0.0220919624,
0.0082411151,
-0.0377431512,
-0.0191378519,
-0.0461211316,
0.1161709577,
-0.0139027154,
0.0388697609,
0.0481198579,
0.0261027087,
0.0042969356,
-0.0362643264,
-0.0171064418,
0.0087462738,
-0.0626197606,
-0.0126146646,
0.0435826927,
0.0258622076,
0.015895322,
-0.0481030755,
-0.0260254927,
0.0252191722,
-0.018313095,
-0.0398123115,
0.0390900783,
-0.0194102265,
0.0234806463,
-0.0386232175,
-0.0004216142,
0.0423826948,
0.025451703,
0.0139205894,
-0.0058334214,
-0.0515400097,
-0.0056193667,
-0.0280582421,
0.0470852144,
0.0194743704,
-0.0173119809,
0.0787606686,
-0.027115006,
0.0327205956,
-0.0483569205,
0.0164008942,
0.0287688617,
-0.0058228988,
-0.059166193,
0.0225958712,
-0.0307472162,
0.0643096492,
-0.0459272414,
-0.0156780034,
-0.0080649536,
0.0373370051,
-0.0082066869,
0.0302743725,
-0.0063544782,
-0.003029699,
-0.0380513817,
0.0168059599,
0.0030400383,
0.0205783844,
-0.0267951041,
-0.0422347002,
-0.0225581862,
-0.034968514,
-0.0122273928,
0.0048007541,
0.0365426615,
-0.0487335585,
0.0137817012,
0.1096724719,
0.007122722,
-0.0642016605,
-0.052108869,
-0.0332979709,
0.0144055737,
-0.0482123382,
0.0196391027,
-0.0299008358,
0.0795970112,
-0.0159522146,
-0.0121445106,
-0.0289880149,
0.0176256038,
-0.0239392016,
-0.0573334955,
0.0439616777,
-0.0157241207,
-0.0144749545,
-0.0075705578,
-0.0094333934,
-0.0050672684,
0.0460531078,
0.0118148364,
0.0277730841,
0.0460189357,
0.0056412416,
0.0287786331,
0.0356642865,
-0.001297457,
-0.0102582071,
0.0172320716,
0.047386203,
0.037018951,
-0.0269582756,
0.0427664667,
0.0193241816,
-0.0151304733,
-0.0145163769,
0.0118883513,
-0.0112559395,
0.0065750699,
0.0245027598,
0.0379591957,
-0.0252202116,
0.0251779985,
0.0048940512,
-0.0698164701,
0.0123750484,
-0.0312823988,
0.0425894968,
-0.0283614192,
0.0395656787,
0.0028265419,
-0.0216320455,
-0.0104653584,
0.0005777289,
-0.0168914907,
-0.0137047013,
0.062964797,
0.0267333388,
-0.0552108549,
0.0465593711,
0.0450464003,
-0.0413874388,
-0.0268728193,
0.0286470763,
0.0316465572,
0.0314013176,
0.0210660826,
-0.0793807805,
-0.031146355,
-0.0138566894,
-0.0091033187,
0.0489190184,
-0.0047220518,
-0.0524003431,
0.0473454446,
-0.0276640486,
-0.05284217,
-0.0095677171,
0.0255890507,
0.0187829137,
0.0535529777,
-0.0095523661,
0.0192983616,
-0.0445005856,
-0.0288061332,
0.0376377292,
-0.0227696635,
-0.0806638598,
-0.0092919841,
0.0275854003,
0.0264988728,
0.0404794775,
-0.0090962006,
-0.0177273154,
0.0444148593,
-0.0161265284,
-0.0026403954,
-0.0357690006,
-0.0256633945,
-0.0174486581,
0.0128826611,
-0.0025566446,
-0.0207585674,
0.0112440307,
-0.0366895534,
-0.0120661883,
-0.0335638598,
0.0336774066,
0.0263003707,
0.0098855169,
0.0032378277,
0.0542277806,
0.0148972925,
-0.0493804216,
0.0892702118,
-0.0032011028,
-0.0663442165,
0.0573394634,
-0.0992280543,
-0.0278888531,
-0.0264106691,
-0.0249567106,
0.0193408318,
0.0037890042,
0.0027889162,
0.0160598103,
-0.0071304291,
-0.0421009883,
-0.0220107157,
-0.0600596853,
0.0313307531,
-0.0063554454,
0.0755106658,
0.0099896993,
0.0245674625,
-0.0181205943,
-0.0536152013,
-0.0163672026,
-0.0048417938,
-0.0799061283,
-0.0144160129,
0.036463853,
0.0132235847,
-0.0132421348,
-0.0356699303,
-0.0082826568,
-0.0475531518,
0.022415325,
0.0097827902,
-0.0551809445,
-0.0054544294,
0.0477941521,
-0.0154648311,
0.037873324,
-0.0220503602,
0.0288892929,
-0.0172168687,
0.0010221045,
-0.0183468107,
0.0728292689,
-0.0103235627,
0.0487565435,
-0.023263555,
-0.0283466056,
-0.0154951354,
0.0381672606,
-0.0337308384,
0.0245333258,
-0.0141283637,
-0.0060462407,
0.0543347187,
0.0636015758,
-0.0087110512,
0.0436224006,
-0.0042578303,
-0.0153719606,
0.0216678213,
0.0294857733,
-0.0359023437,
0.047414694,
0.0217145588,
-0.0105851609,
-0.0277607385,
0.0133415759,
0.0511006117,
-0.0475244001,
0.001827348,
-0.0022800933,
0.013697288,
-0.0660144687,
0.0708252639,
-0.0029648531,
0.0100120259,
0.0458987541,
-0.0419375338,
0.0053424709,
-0.0077319434,
0.0058831647,
-0.0016864476,
0.0289951079,
-0.0024474794,
0.0132883228,
-0.0362742245,
-0.0196569078,
-0.0514170006,
0.0225683395,
-0.0034494621,
0.0247855037,
-0.0143726822,
-0.0212646592,
-0.0100438436,
0.0350661539,
0.0409532376,
0.0533501804,
-0.0172190741,
-0.0220722575,
-0.0392660014,
0.0647301227,
0.0324053168,
-0.0057023005,
-0.0189187676,
-0.0000574661,
0.0040241657,
0.043658711,
-0.0053663841,
0.000979808,
0.0026533364,
0.0171474256,
-0.0122693013,
-0.0432856008,
0.005009755,
0.0013728074,
0.0208492409,
-0.0974207371,
0.0021422904,
0.075142391,
0.0042124777,
-0.0113518657,
-0.0053704032,
0.0231577307,
0.0104175257,
0.0213798098,
0.0122366929,
-0.1022056341,
-0.0659328401,
0.0043815905,
0.0001633121,
0.0132959625,
-0.0624465644,
0.0205057841,
-0.0689877942,
0.0174284019,
0.0225719362,
-0.0938815475,
-0.0161294974,
-0.0225835238,
0.0394482724,
-0.0195495356,
-0.0146368314,
0.0248366762,
-0.0546460263,
-0.0070450446,
-0.0009487913,
-0.0047826013,
-0.0270262863,
0.0182511117,
-0.0371088497,
-0.0099642249,
0.0471847281,
0.0069954763,
0.0111112921,
0.0087377047,
0.025292119,
-0.0250957031,
0.0024802408,
-0.0097249607,
0.0492454097,
-0.0871393979,
-0.0045694346,
-0.0127210254,
0.010410496,
-0.0637077391,
0.0342018567,
0.0151149146,
0.0827849135,
0.0280491784,
-0.0122788697,
-0.0215910096,
-0.0844592527,
0.029326411,
0.0660488084,
0.0128543936,
0.0150155723,
-0.0350931585,
0.0140331117,
-0.0194993801,
-0.0384212621,
0.0112388963,
0.0519877523,
-0.0528342314,
-0.0501552299,
-0.0529217534,
-0.0828983337,
0.0202777218,
0.0072137397,
0.0100478353,
-0.0102927862,
0.0385097079,
0.0048215911,
-0.0982304066,
0.0083821341,
-0.0407601632,
-0.0375388861,
-0.0274712574,
-0.018535547,
-0.0281146895,
0.0175201334,
-0.0338119604,
0.0109522203,
-0.0390310846,
-0.0350938626,
-0.0158257112,
0.0435146615,
0.0181063358,
0.0668195263,
0.0213595629,
0.0532125533,
0.0395719334,
0.0302014071,
-0.0504882224,
-0.0081174467,
0.0493612587,
-0.025816232,
0.0103438282,
0.0385938771,
-0.0364088565,
0.0309575908,
0.014076652,
0.0340866297,
-0.0585996024,
0.0040481286,
0.0219158437,
0.01606231,
0.0132430205,
0.0341221802,
-0.0245957021,
-0.0215882324,
0.0227684863,
-0.0252923202,
-0.0208200309,
-0.0385521315,
0.0482786223,
-0.0159380473,
-0.0107540982,
0.0142884655,
0.008474689,
0.0239405762,
0.0258407798,
-0.0202324875,
-0.0213469919,
0.0004490297,
0.0180948395,
0.0019298114,
-0.045818828,
-0.0334305353,
0.084397763,
0.020904772,
0.0479779728,
-0.0101288846,
0.0166293792,
0.0357359499,
-0.0136441579,
-0.0100136101,
0.0377612226,
-0.0123359142,
0.0081173154,
-0.0461379066,
-0.0015212335,
0.0158329811,
-0.0077002775,
0.043876119,
0.0054662954,
-0.0069889575,
0.0099147353,
0.0465499461,
-0.011341434,
-0.0132534225,
0.0151491957,
0.0236901976,
-0.0323673263,
-0.0078399768,
0.072031945,
-0.0243136194,
0.0240280665,
0.0126794782,
-0.0231689867,
-0.0688873231,
0.0029155812,
0.0186541602,
-0.019834213,
0.0003603266,
-0.0027747697,
-0.0481137186,
-0.0397408679,
0.0272145588,
-0.0166147891,
-0.0291706268,
0.0021776492,
0.0162315015,
0.0334213264,
0.0512366183,
-0.0488173626,
-0.03260272,
0.0060612368,
-0.0392311178,
-0.0273492616,
-0.0008992075,
-6.808212753e-33,
-0.0606173053,
-0.0174104478,
0.023586845,
-0.0043323063,
-0.0435756333,
0.0615229011,
-0.0640600771,
-0.0236994065,
0.0134636024,
-0.0161079932,
-0.0003374788,
-0.006203495,
0.014495872,
0.0094540175,
-0.0031416875,
-0.0210725795,
0.0061734691,
0.0198590029,
-0.0348566845,
0.0096285893,
0.0696529299,
0.0559681766,
0.095172517,
-0.0513697714,
0.036131423,
0.0124923801,
0.0250638388,
0.0030173075,
0.0629953668,
0.0561904646,
-0.0470506847,
-0.0156916678,
0.0298086423,
-0.0261971075,
0.0193434898,
0.0439225659,
-0.1674621999,
0.0087621259,
-0.025818577,
0.0069083553,
-0.0522195622,
-0.0292038601,
0.0471857414,
-0.0283079594,
0.0672758669,
-0.0570206456,
0.0305345133,
-0.0251653902,
0.0046373573,
-0.0334571712,
-0.0962526798,
0.0445421077,
0.0466304719,
0.0261691585,
0.0200212523,
0.01957874,
0.0243500918,
0.0071903407,
-0.0911372006,
-0.0668289587,
-0.0100545958,
0.0118743312,
0.015010871,
-0.0036126124,
0.0162778813,
0.0370749012,
0.0040637227,
-0.0098304637,
-0.0336884223,
-0.018276941,
-0.0371531099,
0.0787965655,
-0.0524986796,
-0.0034722125,
0.0370722339,
0.0111521585,
-0.0935061947,
0.0106148683,
0.0403143056,
0.0491515361,
-0.0420208313,
0.0133780176,
-0.0686917081,
0.041862037,
0.0382399783,
0.0044433391,
-0.0250177234,
-0.0236362219,
0.0449472591,
-0.0047710827,
-0.0240306053,
0.046856489,
0.026093252,
-0.0117037371,
-0.0148386331,
0.0234054085,
0.0229097046,
0.0207408816,
-0.0016699809,
-0.0008843006,
-0.029696675,
-0.0475618504,
-0.0005230512,
0.0155959539,
0.0402531698,
0.0394417793,
0.057228487,
0.0099478597,
-0.0492822602,
-0.0280324314,
-0.0341224335,
0.0250790268,
-0.0268259309,
0.0432922654,
0.0180091355,
0.0302710272,
-0.0108250454,
0.0305578671,
0.030198982,
0.0150051452,
-0.0302168988,
0.0497254804,
0.0304535218,
0.0624722503,
0.0341199264,
-0.0280508567,
-0.0217281431,
-0.0111719016,
0.0029573853,
-0.0548449866,
0.0170468558,
0.0151306577,
2.985e-7,
0.0199829228,
-0.0079589309,
0.0559452213,
0.0243510585,
0.0137166819,
0.0532736629,
0.0425331406,
0.0423357561,
-0.0274492074,
-0.0481836013,
-0.0043424177,
-0.0133682452,
0.0007958476,
0.0232106633,
-0.0871352851,
-0.0333367512,
-0.0260692239,
-0.056569986,
-0.0542934649,
0.0172554906,
0.00746958,
0.0619823597,
-0.000751039,
0.0175482407,
-0.0311446954,
-0.0116830263,
0.0487068743,
0.028828416,
0.0224295817,
0.0368288644,
0.0145065803,
0.0064006862,
-0.038114462,
0.0295126382,
0.0102432445,
0.0521258675,
0.0200024545,
0.0494296849,
-0.0625679195,
-0.0021170503,
0.0020291561,
-0.0577421896,
0.0073545109,
-0.0378474183,
0.054370448,
-0.0528539903,
-0.0030463513,
0.0065963226,
-0.0460544303,
0.0443433113,
-0.0523770563,
0.0255350191,
0.0037134278,
0.0341304801,
0.0206045192,
-0.0341886617,
-0.0304294098,
-0.0613850206,
0.0196498334,
0.0501219779,
0.0167274661,
0.0091155693,
-0.0223539434,
-0.0378561392,
-0.019081628,
-0.0668597892,
-0.0064480994,
2.899974869e-34,
-0.0024112039,
0.0182913356,
-0.0031727895,
0.0692494288,
0.026951015,
-0.0425219946,
-0.0782993808,
-0.0100921718,
-0.0112009514,
-0.0407136381,
0.0042584669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14767v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14767v3 | Dissecting Recall of Factual Associations in Auto-Regressive Language Models | 2023-04-28T11:26:17 | 2023-10-13T19:01:20 | Mor Geva, Jasmijn Bastings, Katja Filippova, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models (LMs) are known to capture factual
knowledge in their parameters. While previous work looked into where factual
associations are stored, only little is known about how they are retrieved
internally during inference. We investigate this question through the lens of
information flow. Given a subject-relation query, we study how the model
aggregates information about the subject and relation to predict the correct
attribute. With interventions on attention edges, we first identify two
critical points where information propagates to the prediction: one from the
relation positions followed by another from the subject positions. Next, by
analyzing the information at these points, we unveil a three-step internal
mechanism for attribute extraction. First, the representation at the
last-subject position goes through an enrichment process, driven by the early
MLP sublayers, to encode many subject-related attributes. Second, information
from the relation propagates to the prediction. Third, the prediction
representation "queries" the enriched subject to extract the attribute. Perhaps
surprisingly, this extraction is typically done via attention heads, which
often encode subject-attribute mappings in their parameters. Overall, our
findings introduce a comprehensive view of how factual associations are stored
and extracted internally in LMs, facilitating future research on knowledge
localization and editing. | [
0.017756531,
0.0468616039,
-0.0374469385,
0.0594951324,
-0.0214750394,
-0.0090697017,
-0.0232073925,
-0.0576452762,
-0.0407625102,
-0.0405918323,
-0.0205000304,
-0.0294916388,
0.0501492433,
0.0011601328,
0.0389169604,
-0.0088806115,
0.0395335965,
-0.0246101171,
-0.0036345061,
0.0010415079,
-0.0196070056,
0.0038410397,
0.0190375149,
0.0243158154,
-0.0072125979,
-0.0106267519,
0.006588011,
-0.0348256119,
0.0021441029,
0.0225159023,
-0.0188345462,
0.0559853688,
-0.0112143168,
-0.0089278156,
0.0000019458,
-0.0473055057,
-0.0029722401,
-0.0197003037,
-0.0471385419,
-0.0064792144,
-0.0222762078,
-0.0037458008,
0.0042132717,
-0.0074859378,
-0.0186817329,
-0.0565266609,
0.0564349666,
0.0328993239,
0.0332504399,
0.060660623,
-0.0166532993,
-0.0306045339,
0.0202438124,
-0.027120173,
0.0383017585,
-0.0284785349,
0.04283382,
-0.04781783,
-0.0581533127,
0.0092006437,
-0.0467879847,
0.0352135338,
0.0191599969,
0.0130681163,
0.0712548047,
0.0660791323,
-0.0201446842,
-0.0425838418,
0.0100840321,
0.0395576544,
0.0217378456,
-0.0462883338,
-0.0174241979,
0.0181617495,
0.0216272064,
0.0248769466,
-0.0243049581,
0.039422147,
0.0051728622,
0.0137641011,
0.0323323011,
-0.0098269535,
0.016129816,
0.0009365112,
-0.0480796136,
0.0591392256,
0.0048958026,
-0.0189967994,
-0.0100328606,
0.0324186161,
0.0207116902,
-0.0475046821,
0.0068452442,
0.027841676,
0.0593343377,
0.0408280455,
-0.02568659,
-0.0028208394,
-0.0215120278,
-0.0406793468,
0.0468207449,
0.0406638645,
-0.0277280025,
0.0495086052,
-0.0589877926,
0.0613331012,
-0.0226915758,
0.0466619171,
-0.0257555433,
0.0022981672,
0.0204912294,
-0.0513204485,
-0.0230435412,
0.0270975456,
0.0169865973,
0.0137234386,
-0.0032744766,
0.010819721,
-0.0207960047,
-0.0154320458,
-0.0174312051,
0.0257770568,
-0.0394263268,
0.0018767827,
-0.0574871227,
0.0806787387,
-0.0020696432,
0.0178056229,
-0.0053835684,
-0.0300747585,
-0.0510621518,
-0.0026042035,
0.0000895119,
-0.0486989096,
-0.0212867633,
0.0412019826,
-0.0146751003,
-0.0460955873,
-0.0207743328,
-0.0249054078,
-0.0100448271,
-0.0583187677,
0.0611078627,
-0.0356336348,
0.0355225094,
0.0589910187,
-0.0198292993,
-0.076306209,
0.0123222461,
0.0259984545,
-0.0740981773,
0.0308814403,
0.0530684404,
0.0370949209,
-0.0165887475,
0.0040840581,
0.0238219518,
0.0343822129,
0.047191456,
0.0319956243,
-0.0046994206,
-0.0121301394,
0.0029956899,
0.0289642438,
0.0581231974,
-0.025664486,
-0.0154984761,
-0.0079950253,
0.0278309844,
0.0111842575,
0.0571167059,
0.0183710996,
-0.0081989709,
-0.0600708984,
0.0744063705,
0.0194057785,
0.023435194,
0.0264045149,
0.0010939646,
-0.0402266867,
0.0065357713,
0.0264934562,
-0.0807382688,
0.0706615448,
-0.0034893125,
0.0029213673,
-0.0025539389,
0.0864140838,
-0.0287730992,
-0.0310482886,
0.0035817043,
0.0190040153,
-0.0092046987,
0.0028129448,
0.0349201523,
0.0588965639,
-0.0064292015,
0.093174383,
0.0264162887,
-0.0038537469,
0.0109640956,
-0.0528956689,
-0.0106048891,
0.0115931528,
0.0201910343,
-0.0112246014,
-0.0406534709,
0.0067305504,
-0.0084481863,
0.0175647456,
0.0197831001,
0.0164504424,
0.0045128637,
-0.0046741348,
0.0012545319,
-0.0168330446,
0.0217283871,
0.0259562861,
-0.0025735281,
-0.0495508239,
0.0002082851,
-0.0115137845,
-0.0184887704,
0.0299826153,
-0.0441261753,
-0.0271033589,
-0.011913172,
0.0260730889,
-0.0235527903,
-0.0217085071,
0.0311199427,
0.036810521,
0.0418775603,
-0.0032470266,
0.0082924189,
0.0325671211,
-0.0447488241,
-0.0260591395,
0.0271034017,
-0.0069132084,
-0.0425890498,
0.0035450363,
0.0190757103,
-0.0311859511,
0.0520317033,
-0.0440609828,
0.076275602,
0.0118806502,
0.0318805948,
0.0390514955,
0.0125416163,
-0.0228423793,
0.0794423595,
-0.0169792958,
-0.0095392754,
0.0026383398,
-0.0178977791,
-0.0210530348,
-0.0107989339,
0.0056814612,
-0.0099927112,
0.0005433887,
-0.0094057005,
0.0151183456,
-0.0557296611,
-0.0404658839,
-0.0258723497,
-0.0153639829,
-0.0133325532,
0.0065769921,
-0.0137457401,
0.0201431662,
0.0127248205,
0.0144572025,
0.0057014842,
-0.0269127116,
-0.0102762822,
-0.0402151383,
0.0333204009,
0.0346939266,
-0.0186875723,
0.0255301818,
-0.0328010768,
-0.002570309,
-0.0576596893,
0.0810051113,
0.0141610159,
-0.015170848,
-0.0479001105,
0.0183521602,
-0.0515340753,
0.023180183,
-0.0171122458,
-0.0245464947,
0.009231044,
0.0010708818,
0.0795354024,
0.0943694785,
-0.0049290899,
0.05943463,
0.0856840387,
-0.0262945779,
-0.0426115841,
0.0073216818,
-0.0712770671,
0.0106569109,
0.0194361079,
-0.0248361602,
-0.0121661937,
0.117737256,
0.0316753462,
-0.0110982191,
-0.0496964566,
0.0228825677,
0.0136289038,
0.0015778564,
0.0046863798,
0.0169887301,
-0.0275283772,
0.0484461151,
-0.0576279201,
-0.0385653526,
0.096119225,
-0.0236464329,
-0.000085151,
-0.0080551468,
0.0208404604,
-0.001881991,
0.057560768,
0.0448464975,
0.0206664652,
0.0174687356,
-0.0103586977,
-0.0776430592,
0.0242572222,
0.0321220979,
-0.0400075726,
0.0705758631,
-0.037595097,
-0.0084339436,
0.0161417536,
-0.0026682955,
-0.0506002866,
-0.0239511132,
-0.0027012387,
-0.0148358503,
-0.0425006561,
-0.0074145091,
-0.0374315456,
-0.0114583289,
0.0742417648,
0.041909419,
-0.0242547207,
-0.0180115569,
-0.018371962,
0.0050385371,
0.074759908,
0.0169940758,
0.025155073,
-0.0134018995,
-0.0068735564,
0.0588021055,
0.0063245567,
0.0236727409,
-0.0174580459,
-0.001202935,
0.0386039205,
-0.0130455075,
-0.0040664715,
-0.0073998207,
0.0397761688,
-0.0545991957,
-0.0525920317,
0.0824767277,
0.0208951943,
-0.0510293096,
0.0000135693,
-0.0055095316,
0.0213427581,
0.0335894562,
0.0101165278,
-0.0658770651,
-0.0052282368,
0.0061211321,
-0.0291483551,
0.01494011,
-0.0131630385,
-0.009974435,
-0.1094257087,
0.0230681244,
-0.0146757588,
-0.0468856134,
-0.0430240259,
-0.0433262289,
0.0309469327,
-0.0155114587,
0.0238348488,
-0.0083322087,
-0.0121788103,
0.0191998165,
-0.0065159677,
0.0135175018,
-0.0012632201,
0.0275247116,
-0.0025412587,
0.066493772,
0.053531494,
0.0240665246,
-0.0108430153,
-0.0341237076,
-0.0188756287,
-0.0083964886,
0.0037798749,
-0.0033362193,
0.0619002506,
-0.0193370879,
-0.0096754935,
-0.0303233322,
0.0153593682,
-0.0158231203,
-0.0246114433,
-0.0326268487,
0.085344471,
-0.0223880224,
-0.0358670503,
0.011186556,
0.0035541551,
-0.0496826619,
0.1075581387,
0.0474241562,
-0.0050746081,
0.0096584428,
-0.0511554815,
0.0458758399,
0.0150317354,
-0.0789447278,
0.0291095655,
0.0009693141,
-0.0403763577,
-0.0509314276,
-0.0307560097,
0.0538178273,
-0.0019327485,
-0.0016372929,
-0.0419633873,
0.0401608683,
-0.0621952266,
-0.0584076121,
0.0480348505,
-0.028475631,
-0.0052542221,
-0.0152225159,
-0.0503121987,
0.0281351805,
-0.0599162765,
-0.0151849864,
0.0059366771,
-0.0464231484,
-0.0618603453,
0.0397884399,
0.0550930239,
0.0290740039,
0.0507235676,
-0.0192918964,
-0.0288669765,
-0.002573251,
-0.02342874,
-0.062313512,
0.0358934067,
-0.0086195152,
-0.0241590068,
-0.0022029814,
0.0314351805,
-0.0216881894,
0.0099455947,
0.0405282415,
-0.0029040617,
-0.0237392243,
-0.0730949044,
0.0692607835,
-0.0036743358,
0.0957109928,
0.0356128663,
0.0087753823,
-0.0373785533,
-0.0074838549,
-0.0131456964,
-0.0185279734,
-0.0353075676,
-0.0125081027,
0.0391391143,
0.0591776147,
-0.0095929047,
-0.0557980277,
0.0222072266,
0.0250256415,
-0.0310929287,
-0.0597733669,
-0.007725961,
-0.011392422,
0.0117132589,
0.0400265902,
-0.0021462778,
0.0228691064,
0.0040815822,
0.0672971532,
0.0077875997,
0.0450708792,
0.0341137126,
0.0043243053,
-0.0444106944,
-0.0170754548,
-0.0813867152,
-0.0028882036,
0.0033265182,
-0.0183411073,
0.0137174027,
-0.061756663,
0.0539385118,
-0.034828905,
0.0125549026,
-0.0010664584,
0.0252695121,
-0.0035401047,
-0.0279787742,
0.0210564956,
0.011103848,
-0.0152423,
-0.0188566539,
0.081935294,
-0.0167314522,
0.0643132329,
-0.0226083361,
-0.0229669958,
-0.0113556404,
-0.0404494405,
-0.009645055,
-0.0261491463,
-0.0374173187,
0.0108923009,
-0.1024996042,
-0.0792397112,
-0.002914459,
-0.0345037766,
0.0065233526,
-0.0701495111,
0.0020809362,
0.0465882346,
-0.0045570834,
-0.0337123983,
-0.0249484926,
0.0282421,
-0.0130487988,
0.010837907,
-0.020170873,
-6.838062228e-33,
-0.0590094067,
-0.0291792136,
0.0126514276,
0.0382042453,
-0.0252861772,
0.0361006074,
-0.0440775268,
0.0044728322,
-0.0537329093,
0.039954301,
-0.0057465867,
0.0131978067,
0.0027433424,
-0.0042553428,
0.0096226353,
-0.0286519565,
0.0205217693,
0.0019490315,
-0.045341149,
0.0021561685,
0.0368633233,
0.0096749086,
0.0888284221,
-0.0309704803,
0.0168533176,
0.005881282,
0.0287723169,
0.0376242287,
-0.0411236919,
0.0337030925,
-0.0262522716,
0.0347740911,
0.0437140577,
-0.0757296979,
-0.00659703,
0.0029281015,
-0.0993170813,
-0.0718640983,
0.0443585403,
0.0127799427,
-0.0219752267,
-0.0156139527,
0.072788097,
0.0032089213,
-0.0035833942,
-0.0656635761,
0.0537235588,
-0.0061039357,
-0.0432857797,
-0.010930445,
-0.0694766864,
-0.021349391,
0.020717809,
-0.0354762599,
0.0273431949,
-0.0055891299,
0.0109172305,
-0.0087187197,
-0.0712344646,
0.0105767213,
-0.0193482563,
0.0617619082,
0.0320766047,
0.0261582434,
0.0123721603,
0.0688555539,
0.0014368361,
0.030097317,
-0.0611280203,
0.0440264679,
0.0474163294,
0.0275450759,
0.017690124,
-0.0118282428,
-0.0024901184,
-0.0049774596,
-0.0307971984,
-0.0051523172,
0.0150923859,
0.0584656708,
-0.0042337477,
-0.0188005734,
-0.0015485464,
-0.037597511,
-0.0330006741,
0.0108981095,
-0.0397550128,
-0.0087050321,
-0.0127024958,
-0.0054828171,
-0.0191519875,
0.0163147971,
0.009358285,
-0.0135904336,
-0.0060583656,
0.0167181361,
-0.0043809093,
0.012402554,
0.002510611,
0.0260016304,
-0.0719724447,
0.0008934927,
-0.009596888,
0.0005066078,
0.0049609602,
0.0820072889,
0.0279135928,
0.0093744183,
-0.0245689321,
-0.0249076691,
-0.0678784102,
-0.0195477568,
-0.0032621829,
-0.0064598019,
0.0302794855,
0.0407779478,
-0.0332424268,
0.0200284701,
0.0560588054,
0.0648797527,
-0.0546730086,
0.0157461707,
-0.0048990538,
0.0190423299,
-0.03412937,
-0.0276749376,
-0.0686159581,
0.006731465,
0.0630711615,
-0.0434089825,
-0.0272293556,
-0.020467259,
2.827e-7,
0.0500269979,
0.0477084368,
0.0404117703,
0.0446897894,
-0.0092016635,
0.0288107507,
0.0088927979,
0.0257054418,
0.0835104436,
-0.0544878021,
-0.0339454859,
0.0441367291,
0.0154487742,
0.0311825667,
-0.0446147472,
-0.0041997228,
-0.0350359902,
0.0098562567,
0.0061244722,
-0.0097219581,
-0.0151272519,
0.075794965,
0.0443390533,
0.0210303087,
-0.0110643376,
-0.0034759121,
0.0571140386,
-0.0324960425,
-0.0086507201,
0.0170764588,
0.0486396961,
-0.0195705835,
-0.0104530752,
0.0141765485,
-0.0003870902,
0.0433148891,
-0.0042922823,
0.0307531953,
-0.0196116492,
-0.0378246307,
-0.0218603387,
-0.024270732,
-0.0144012263,
-0.0564005338,
0.0288034994,
-0.0883418694,
-0.0264986232,
-0.0135958996,
-0.004669297,
0.0483786128,
0.001596647,
0.0523238443,
-0.0189451184,
0.0039747362,
0.0221915245,
0.0041128863,
-0.0202734061,
-0.088576287,
-0.0735692754,
-0.0116488114,
-0.0284119789,
-0.0243938677,
-0.0228480622,
-0.0461351871,
0.0359199308,
-0.0734652281,
-0.0185515508,
2.632438783e-34,
-0.0220179893,
-0.0044597471,
0.0150563996,
0.0474460274,
0.0388774052,
-0.0706565604,
0.0033030198,
0.0449171737,
0.0157665499,
-0.0795370936,
-0.034866605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14746v1 | FlowTransformer: A Transformer Framework for Flow-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems | 2023-04-28T10:40:34 | 2023-04-28T10:40:34 | Liam Daly Manocchio, Siamak Layeghy, Wai Weng Lo, Gayan K. Kulatilleke, Mohanad Sarhan, Marius Portmann | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE, cs.NI | This paper presents the FlowTransformer framework, a novel approach for
implementing transformer-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDSs).
FlowTransformer leverages the strengths of transformer models in identifying
the long-term behaviour and characteristics of networks, which are often
overlooked by most existing NIDSs. By capturing these complex patterns in
network traffic, FlowTransformer offers a flexible and efficient tool for
researchers and practitioners in the cybersecurity community who are seeking to
implement NIDSs using transformer-based models. FlowTransformer allows the
direct substitution of various transformer components, including the input
encoding, transformer, classification head, and the evaluation of these across
any flow-based network dataset. To demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency
of the FlowTransformer framework, we utilise it to provide an extensive
evaluation of various common transformer architectures, such as GPT 2.0 and
BERT, on three commonly used public NIDS benchmark datasets. We provide results
for accuracy, model size and speed. A key finding of our evaluation is that the
choice of classification head has the most significant impact on the model
performance. Surprisingly, Global Average Pooling, which is commonly used in
text classification, performs very poorly in the context of NIDS. In addition,
we show that model size can be reduced by over 50\%, and inference and training
times improved, with no loss of accuracy, by making specific choices of input
encoding and classification head instead of other commonly used alternatives. | [
-0.0162813291,
0.039810583,
-0.010959439,
0.0392570347,
-0.078243427,
-0.0179589707,
0.0527072735,
-0.0262484308,
0.0079897502,
-0.0531447604,
0.042857796,
-0.0283453334,
-0.0079897922,
0.0718239173,
-0.0063284258,
-0.0092255259,
0.0426529944,
0.012213124,
-0.0286002401,
0.0372631475,
0.0229174066,
-0.0062412662,
0.0239196308,
0.0318299383,
0.0210359208,
0.006112637,
-0.0309891626,
-0.0291497521,
0.0319693685,
0.0023858154,
0.0242915694,
0.0175712127,
0.0316849127,
0.0438567922,
0.0000019276,
-0.017744055,
-0.0359006897,
-0.0152992224,
0.0039763064,
0.0154299038,
-0.0241492894,
-0.0441975966,
0.0000394407,
0.0357685164,
0.0149640217,
-0.0164913256,
0.0218725652,
0.091527231,
0.0539006814,
0.0648290589,
-0.0245892443,
-0.0518282503,
0.0441922136,
-0.0030403959,
-0.0321985148,
-0.0161471106,
0.0462752543,
-0.038942866,
-0.0155566465,
-0.0224907044,
-0.0353244878,
-0.0280733965,
-0.0011158559,
-0.0292735416,
0.009329997,
0.0711281449,
-0.0386783332,
0.0309125129,
-0.027130587,
0.0092224544,
-0.0571190007,
-0.0284285117,
0.0087276781,
-0.0111197839,
0.0039776093,
0.0182661209,
0.009312869,
-0.0012259507,
-0.0018635128,
0.0143532818,
-0.0111475736,
0.0377950817,
0.0046226513,
0.0115117803,
-0.0853170082,
-0.0245845858,
0.0140040526,
-0.0070730336,
-0.021070376,
-0.0338121876,
0.0301962756,
-0.0132067446,
0.044552587,
-0.0087241698,
-0.015378261,
-0.0184382703,
-0.0385570154,
-0.030678479,
0.0013491806,
-0.0510965288,
-0.0029987369,
-0.0078812372,
0.0185460914,
0.005848187,
-0.016736513,
0.091420047,
-0.033566732,
0.0124539537,
-0.0153260846,
-0.0059600878,
-0.0707528442,
-0.0248735659,
-0.0322167836,
0.0580288097,
0.0395098366,
-0.0175963026,
-0.0623645261,
0.0687346905,
0.0153121259,
-0.0355683751,
-0.0091279289,
-0.0262416545,
0.0359648503,
0.0295662489,
0.0307463761,
0.0286457799,
0.0197392162,
-0.0006189778,
-0.0199735519,
0.0000324485,
-0.0425382331,
0.0262880996,
-0.0122726709,
-0.0545747764,
-0.0448184013,
0.0451240353,
0.0180525761,
-0.0659200102,
-0.0121693546,
0.0039754859,
-0.0019232185,
0.0339607559,
0.012478698,
-0.0135189295,
-0.0257290173,
0.0111866239,
0.0323751271,
-0.0004166993,
-0.0453788899,
-0.0717840046,
-0.0258512404,
0.0143088745,
0.024647953,
0.0157750119,
-0.0100114336,
-0.007329525,
0.050005693,
0.020431241,
0.0256061293,
0.0289491974,
-0.0134382751,
-0.05663535,
0.0662057325,
0.0341391265,
-0.0169019625,
-0.0292833336,
-0.0045245318,
0.0103839766,
0.0006630581,
-0.0526723973,
0.0264371727,
0.0183467735,
-0.0034068562,
-0.0615604594,
0.0593124889,
0.0242034718,
0.0399982743,
0.0422157012,
0.0028459991,
0.0545463264,
-0.0190450829,
-0.0252729952,
-0.0115184775,
0.0114891604,
-0.0371058024,
-0.0268050078,
-0.016962979,
0.0532001033,
-0.0356243253,
-0.0077459761,
0.0249118209,
-0.0141144106,
-0.0277726483,
-0.0214923639,
0.0474196933,
0.0151747093,
0.0053801048,
0.0452512167,
-0.0319183171,
0.0042937854,
0.0079395985,
-0.0473184586,
-0.0228641815,
0.0529888906,
0.0408040918,
0.0008099138,
-0.0417253077,
-0.0500525869,
-0.0062313331,
-0.0154814729,
-0.0080053266,
0.0387490056,
-0.026320653,
-0.0443984903,
-0.0150277391,
0.0557307415,
0.0239472054,
0.0181613658,
-0.0307199005,
-0.0155331204,
0.0245035365,
-0.0251074787,
-0.0670355037,
0.0159058645,
0.0083817253,
-0.0013562549,
0.0703059286,
0.0043854634,
0.0546484105,
-0.0393626392,
-0.0380918719,
0.0043377662,
0.0327248946,
0.031728413,
-0.0952219591,
0.0133226495,
0.0181643572,
0.0490087979,
-0.0369687788,
-0.0038236538,
0.0425878055,
0.0306756441,
-0.036548052,
-0.0194053669,
0.0388838314,
-0.0684029162,
-0.0170682464,
-0.0000953805,
-0.0077134334,
-0.0350801833,
0.0371267796,
-0.0039122771,
0.0095906584,
0.0050602071,
-0.0043482953,
-0.0444148369,
-0.0212443955,
0.0126592591,
-0.0083827255,
-0.0168419946,
-0.0271992516,
-0.0627787933,
0.0404655188,
0.0382756516,
-0.025686685,
0.0450928546,
-0.0077786078,
-0.0129852314,
0.0145391533,
-0.0173450205,
0.0579563826,
0.0189007539,
0.0490777045,
-0.0416206159,
-0.0054052137,
-0.002487368,
-0.0035169008,
0.0035566604,
-0.0107706226,
0.0263721533,
-0.0338625833,
-0.0443138257,
0.0195296295,
-0.0028824892,
-0.0514898263,
0.089072153,
0.0317114852,
-0.0833470151,
-0.0238396637,
-0.0053712209,
0.0004257646,
-0.0370870158,
-0.0371757895,
-0.040954724,
-0.0214592628,
-0.0076124771,
-0.0115194842,
-0.0076988754,
0.0728127435,
-0.007800051,
0.0087250629,
-0.0343814939,
-0.0316289179,
0.0082283607,
-0.0449880026,
-0.0097095491,
-0.0539291278,
0.0148229506,
0.0529464185,
0.0754616559,
0.0338578224,
-0.0104222102,
-0.0054248702,
-0.0369783118,
0.0417002589,
0.0520117991,
-0.0038571882,
-0.0517483093,
-0.0134056509,
-0.0373880155,
0.0031417292,
-0.0480073132,
0.0663742274,
-0.0187578853,
0.0190996025,
-0.0869305953,
-0.0486160591,
-0.0509280004,
-0.0235496722,
0.0112313712,
0.0109000951,
0.0514309555,
-0.035149198,
0.0285282657,
0.003040185,
0.0258831307,
-0.0415436625,
0.008414208,
0.0458844565,
0.0367240906,
0.0000748411,
-0.0185919534,
-0.0706363097,
-0.0344929248,
0.0148755079,
-0.0159085225,
0.0150161823,
-0.055270832,
-0.0716753304,
0.0626195818,
0.0035046595,
0.0440309979,
0.0019153534,
-0.0198956802,
0.0178220998,
0.0449510664,
0.0109494273,
-0.0287843235,
-0.0043342528,
0.0338934101,
0.0597657859,
0.0350230969,
0.0215697773,
0.0051351609,
-0.0571670607,
0.0004168071,
-0.0188604668,
-0.053220287,
-0.005754678,
0.0175020602,
0.0129321497,
-0.0156537984,
-0.03396542,
0.0915096998,
0.0427380092,
-0.0447365716,
-0.0267445799,
0.034466695,
0.0038309544,
0.0261445306,
0.0148089817,
-0.0222953595,
0.0006996999,
-0.0109230634,
0.0139938584,
-0.0195471756,
-0.0217779595,
0.0205451157,
-0.0364219472,
0.0344477668,
0.0461590998,
-0.0423920415,
-0.0016087025,
-0.1231331527,
-0.0280829836,
-0.0084700501,
-0.0006205767,
-0.0608126372,
0.0389647149,
-0.0214282628,
0.0166509356,
-0.0499233529,
-0.0660090297,
-0.0145708825,
0.0064894217,
0.0047966824,
0.0220075194,
-0.0125746727,
-0.0714549646,
0.0083518429,
0.0840449035,
-0.076683782,
-0.0189095046,
0.0190196037,
0.076453194,
0.0089803394,
0.0060357931,
-0.0453816243,
0.0303532705,
-0.0316814668,
-0.0334423259,
0.0423018225,
0.0916378424,
-0.0641649142,
-0.0143365627,
-0.0439904109,
-0.0417233594,
0.024452731,
0.0421398357,
0.0055727363,
-0.0372917205,
0.0003830435,
-0.0182610303,
0.0039803139,
-0.0011986955,
-0.0563312843,
0.0256497543,
-0.0082468558,
-0.0708892643,
-0.0259642825,
0.0186973624,
-0.0006310342,
-0.0013534981,
0.0238237977,
-0.0272041112,
0.0179235041,
-0.0265409052,
-0.0601068437,
-0.0405418761,
0.0071101156,
0.0654617846,
-0.0560304746,
0.0466512218,
0.0624269396,
0.0135761919,
-0.0731344149,
0.0546500981,
-0.035342142,
-0.0604978539,
-0.0006893995,
0.0163890161,
0.0248709694,
0.004968015,
-0.0594508499,
0.0375246219,
0.0922178403,
0.0487437323,
0.0149161331,
-0.0686124563,
0.0308752004,
-0.096777305,
-0.0045016222,
-0.0319355205,
-0.0078938026,
0.0226829313,
0.0165208504,
-0.0497290306,
-0.074703306,
0.0028054137,
0.0423647426,
0.0222318172,
0.061582882,
0.0441380776,
0.0318302102,
0.0071060769,
0.0187988542,
0.0144196954,
-0.0224527027,
0.0366724841,
-0.0165132545,
0.0584469624,
0.0051379078,
0.0048516779,
0.0603406355,
-0.0012160691,
-0.036920201,
-0.0290649906,
-0.0162980501,
0.0364348777,
0.0338271745,
0.0085061435,
-0.0264248122,
0.017327264,
-0.0509597398,
0.076406993,
0.0531848818,
-0.0179658681,
0.0465729572,
0.0097826701,
0.007116708,
-0.0324031711,
-0.0095662512,
-0.0924141705,
0.0364109203,
-0.0093217045,
0.0217670668,
0.0246022809,
-0.0006111288,
0.004753984,
-0.0275916681,
0.0612955913,
-0.0332800522,
0.0475644469,
-0.0163752325,
-0.0199515708,
0.0144531969,
-0.0047937408,
-0.0179523248,
0.0088454308,
0.0587110594,
-0.0159967337,
0.0327646062,
0.019853754,
-0.0733124688,
-0.0280883666,
-0.0160885882,
0.0163243208,
0.0221147556,
-0.0218596887,
-0.0137255779,
-0.0661056265,
0.0068232715,
0.031934876,
-0.0664270744,
0.0779805705,
-0.0108529413,
-0.0202004965,
0.0534154624,
-0.0152865276,
0.0299086459,
-0.0494722128,
-0.0207462553,
-0.0612046346,
-0.0187748596,
-0.0009291437,
-5.205939749e-33,
0.0468845144,
-0.0173159726,
-0.0147197954,
0.0274833962,
-0.0222421195,
0.0189934932,
-0.0105914595,
-0.0412467904,
0.007544396,
-0.0238780454,
0.0102076968,
-0.0034861865,
-0.0040868716,
0.0486915447,
-0.0085080024,
-0.0051265717,
0.0248474628,
0.0133946221,
-0.0478378795,
0.0546461642,
0.07828971,
0.0150986556,
0.0333820656,
-0.0232651662,
-0.0282894243,
-0.0123800952,
0.0175183564,
0.012569448,
-0.0134703554,
0.0187489539,
0.0058491589,
0.0384759381,
0.018642379,
-0.0302140694,
-0.0066903564,
0.0163459033,
-0.0065582306,
-0.0077157989,
-0.0329433344,
0.0287281014,
0.0576237403,
-0.0384390056,
0.0337228328,
0.0118758678,
0.0055579883,
-0.0389427617,
0.0108848494,
0.0016036946,
-0.0287812799,
-0.0498182289,
-0.001167145,
0.0164296944,
-0.0491880588,
0.0102868872,
0.0115627972,
0.0082394248,
0.0476849861,
-0.0416903757,
-0.0893665925,
0.0332508199,
0.0280400608,
0.0085481955,
-0.0136761023,
0.0235568304,
-0.029226549,
-0.0012090908,
-0.0050369864,
-0.0123750325,
0.0284283534,
0.0634978414,
0.023236094,
0.0069721611,
0.0492912233,
-0.0043180422,
-0.0020995482,
-0.0563758984,
-0.0780487284,
0.0567529015,
0.0235173516,
0.0572411194,
0.0359083787,
-0.012934722,
-0.0389502309,
-0.0142190894,
0.0116077913,
-0.0671091452,
0.0133208446,
0.0070203142,
0.0023583251,
-0.0140518537,
-0.0334906839,
0.0073394626,
0.0263305381,
-0.0407446437,
-0.0188866835,
0.043278005,
-0.0137627702,
0.0399717018,
0.0065384042,
0.0063724359,
-0.0002018283,
-0.0550883934,
0.0365320444,
0.0035252969,
0.005267933,
-0.0422176011,
0.0648332238,
0.0670595989,
-0.0564145744,
-0.0224627741,
-0.030135883,
0.0290915612,
-0.0395160839,
0.0500252768,
-0.0172664672,
0.0248032771,
0.0046585314,
-0.0235388745,
-0.0220068563,
-0.0125919906,
-0.0148764923,
0.0854871273,
-0.015638411,
0.0348416381,
0.0030397309,
-0.0027233174,
-0.02161479,
0.0755781233,
0.0511355549,
-0.0489642471,
-0.0057251044,
-0.0058530336,
2.782e-7,
0.0170099791,
0.0479317233,
0.0415728278,
0.014820708,
0.0062175319,
0.0392022952,
-0.0293758456,
0.0799343809,
0.0207607578,
0.032300394,
0.0286944732,
-0.0298002791,
-0.0000858928,
0.038862139,
-0.0709400102,
-0.0308967624,
-0.0305950623,
-0.0126520023,
-0.0902107507,
0.0293215811,
0.0750767738,
0.0793316439,
0.0378137641,
-0.0083596362,
0.0340324268,
-0.0687489435,
0.0138031589,
0.0063523459,
0.0154498881,
0.0134200221,
0.0268455055,
0.0268774871,
0.0161959901,
0.0789921805,
-0.0327542052,
0.0620087199,
-0.0580511093,
-0.0019453251,
0.0358095728,
0.0432089046,
-0.0410758853,
-0.0227944274,
0.0285849869,
-0.0643043593,
0.0432274528,
-0.0476562306,
0.0035227791,
0.0075909873,
-0.0617295466,
-0.0377841927,
0.011756124,
0.0277931113,
-0.024239935,
0.0349573456,
-0.0035304895,
-0.0321816243,
0.0283272769,
-0.0527409837,
0.0156669989,
-0.0355622321,
-0.0357038043,
0.02039955,
-0.0335752927,
0.010879267,
0.1040201783,
0.0182628334,
0.0204392038,
2.859414115e-34,
0.014484968,
-0.0142003633,
0.0140316403,
0.0221692882,
0.0126280347,
0.0105619207,
0.0292307828,
0.0098981336,
0.0038120088,
-0.0365625061,
0.0029853825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14745v1 | Made of Steel? Learning Plausible Materials for Components in the Vehicle Repair Domain | 2023-04-28T10:39:44 | 2023-04-28T10:39:44 | Annerose Eichel, Helena Schlipf, Sabine Schulte im Walde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | We propose a novel approach to learn domain-specific plausible materials for
components in the vehicle repair domain by probing Pretrained Language Models
(PLMs) in a cloze task style setting to overcome the lack of annotated
datasets. We devise a new method to aggregate salient predictions from a set of
cloze query templates and show that domain-adaptation using either a small,
high-quality or a customized Wikipedia corpus boosts performance. When
exploring resource-lean alternatives, we find a distilled PLM clearly
outperforming a classic pattern-based algorithm. Further, given that 98% of our
domain-specific components are multiword expressions, we successfully exploit
the compositionality assumption as a way to address data sparsity. | [
0.0231111348,
0.0551377982,
0.0005165842,
0.028234249,
-0.0010388463,
0.0075878925,
0.0064134132,
0.0252626576,
-0.0385274328,
-0.0958160907,
-0.0305222888,
-0.0109635079,
-0.0090415617,
0.0194587689,
0.0433464609,
-0.0196560044,
0.0145308329,
0.0093877632,
0.0353972875,
-0.0093776872,
-0.0066303052,
0.0180341899,
-0.0315364674,
0.028507283,
-0.002881251,
0.020054847,
0.0018642978,
-0.0205782503,
0.0055982438,
-0.0149619812,
0.0629982874,
0.0925667733,
0.0690393075,
-0.005691119,
0.0000022333,
-0.0547706969,
-0.0066211596,
-0.01239275,
0.0141998939,
0.0133051006,
0.0372901186,
-0.0217230506,
0.0053458977,
0.0137380576,
-0.0311430916,
-0.0263105482,
0.0280052461,
0.0429356769,
0.0519269779,
0.0442057066,
-0.0199130252,
-0.0131786522,
-0.0056834728,
-0.0138665978,
0.0091951061,
-0.0335868746,
0.0304037407,
-0.0429021567,
0.045331683,
-0.0266070757,
0.0090364078,
0.0224105641,
-0.008373348,
-0.0055945073,
0.0533545613,
0.0221111309,
-0.0424882397,
-0.0063895313,
0.011223671,
0.1060981452,
-0.0138280503,
-0.0412752852,
-0.0148375677,
-0.0122123957,
-0.0056175496,
0.0485379137,
-0.0245120712,
-0.0076095588,
0.0037700462,
-0.0033137039,
-0.0104503697,
-0.0066461638,
0.0165100805,
0.001677248,
-0.0039208019,
0.0477244817,
0.0124273151,
-0.0059654377,
0.0155532891,
0.0094710747,
-0.0191807617,
-0.0126542905,
-0.0297406167,
0.0307033453,
-0.0167773012,
0.002353583,
-0.0306122322,
0.0261212997,
0.0253358129,
-0.0453466475,
-0.0185738858,
0.0231017619,
-0.0254096035,
0.0675988346,
-0.0290347058,
-0.0320768245,
0.0475285016,
-0.002613706,
-0.0734127611,
-0.0252491497,
-0.0593205206,
-0.0375980139,
-0.066611439,
0.0366489291,
0.0176152457,
-0.0383662656,
0.0017528308,
0.0038384576,
0.0070786006,
-0.0072536245,
0.003045155,
0.0162542555,
-0.0318895541,
-0.0325689539,
-0.0609267913,
0.0078328662,
-0.0213121418,
0.076553978,
-0.0241903905,
-0.0229865555,
-0.0162591618,
0.0120054893,
0.0014546538,
-0.0474639311,
0.0142280385,
0.0515491664,
-0.0396598019,
-0.0352361947,
-0.0713024735,
-0.0198340621,
0.0258633178,
0.002492473,
0.0242556557,
-0.0503767654,
0.0264491495,
0.0121255601,
0.0136465998,
-0.0903451294,
0.0212231595,
-0.0223240331,
-0.0402416959,
0.0857242271,
-0.0294268001,
-0.0110153444,
-0.0069799758,
-0.0043702526,
0.0239567049,
0.0538449474,
0.028921226,
0.0453818254,
0.0609409921,
-0.0011284422,
0.0045370064,
0.0068381955,
-0.0136607327,
0.0016260905,
-0.0032205766,
-0.0040061465,
0.0016283671,
0.0331444666,
0.0262533408,
-0.0508658588,
0.030277444,
0.0263816398,
0.0486820489,
0.0402266085,
0.0453943759,
0.0037275872,
0.0012586213,
0.0428374931,
0.0187456757,
-0.0270306766,
-0.0007880683,
-0.0004050013,
-0.0318148769,
0.0133693945,
0.0363249369,
-0.0099513764,
-0.0430759154,
-0.022123063,
-0.0186920501,
-0.0041827452,
-0.0036625613,
-0.0034830337,
0.066804938,
-0.0107551515,
-0.037300285,
0.074305363,
0.05866009,
-0.0041077011,
0.0002769807,
-0.0201990772,
0.0268636458,
0.0669312775,
0.035515558,
-0.075679563,
-0.0593288504,
0.0256371126,
0.0301622674,
0.023400588,
0.0178350005,
-0.0272274055,
0.0444342345,
-0.0320076384,
-0.0733656138,
-0.033836592,
0.0295039751,
-0.0168335922,
-0.0288591553,
-0.0246686749,
0.0229962636,
-0.0668740273,
-0.0194843821,
0.0443376713,
0.0529382713,
0.0029623774,
0.029523164,
0.0241813976,
-0.0383175611,
0.0131402267,
-0.0018909096,
0.0161803104,
0.0587353408,
-0.0547640547,
-0.0241951514,
0.0408634916,
-0.0029936382,
0.0105716921,
0.0382421277,
-0.0447375365,
0.03892022,
-0.0170969497,
-0.0255056769,
-0.0284849182,
0.0004112868,
-0.0412032939,
0.0707478225,
0.0009210206,
-0.0046085301,
-0.020151997,
0.0110795042,
-0.0537430346,
0.0828238651,
0.0338383801,
-0.0089199273,
-0.0358274356,
0.0259128474,
0.0052660061,
-0.0456997752,
-0.0103505058,
-0.0008897179,
0.0075700074,
0.0085568074,
0.0155879548,
-0.0179838445,
-0.0626565591,
0.0291687157,
-0.0101241264,
-0.0392971002,
-0.0190554485,
0.0023426006,
0.0029581112,
-0.000794091,
-0.0308098383,
-0.0145442775,
0.0202246308,
0.0006957422,
-0.0165831652,
-0.0142799933,
0.0489840396,
0.0267512947,
0.0526574701,
-0.0285938755,
-0.025987329,
-0.0217915755,
0.0611398965,
0.0328911729,
-0.0068520834,
-0.0662300885,
0.0918500945,
-0.0074449033,
-0.0014222836,
-0.0015242443,
-0.0262710433,
-0.0143273743,
-0.0294084214,
0.0398884006,
-0.0013447576,
0.0132652717,
-0.0235017203,
0.0291366912,
-0.0392684676,
-0.0328314453,
-0.0022587348,
-0.0366951078,
0.0274041109,
0.0055653099,
0.0142484801,
0.0337290168,
0.0105297118,
-0.0338219889,
0.0026592445,
-0.0359602012,
0.04458002,
0.0031956211,
-0.0121451486,
-0.0541714802,
0.0094973221,
0.0512985066,
0.0541689806,
-0.0007386584,
-0.0135030253,
0.0627029464,
0.0095302872,
0.0406314321,
-0.0223470572,
-0.0184829943,
-0.0386474431,
0.0232824162,
0.0248147547,
-0.0003399018,
0.0607023798,
-0.0129199596,
-0.0274745729,
0.0498452857,
0.010621151,
-0.0126317153,
0.0217900295,
-0.0550771616,
0.0398173295,
-0.01079999,
-0.0655159354,
-0.0159760471,
-0.0491413847,
-0.0047382321,
0.024156969,
0.0145191755,
-0.0045029325,
-0.0791846886,
0.0415759496,
0.0041243085,
0.0125069162,
0.0271772482,
0.0071686413,
-0.0111972531,
0.0427720919,
0.0468488485,
0.0494721457,
0.0019261752,
-0.0042195958,
-0.0020247845,
0.0058190953,
0.0195977315,
-0.0581506826,
-0.031434007,
0.0155882118,
0.0382100232,
-0.0214828476,
0.0054555763,
-0.0344519168,
-0.0328978784,
-0.0436595827,
-0.0157611016,
0.0672503561,
0.0230370015,
-0.0485377349,
0.0187790394,
0.0387468301,
-0.0041176565,
0.0180293676,
0.0298812855,
-0.0641620681,
-0.050209064,
-0.0194451958,
0.0535564311,
0.0135547528,
-0.027029207,
-0.026651172,
-0.1200393364,
0.0191174597,
-0.024891464,
-0.0374036543,
-0.0483778864,
-0.0928739533,
0.0110309552,
-0.0419955216,
-0.0437535942,
0.0100839473,
-0.0366727225,
-0.0048630806,
0.0195393339,
-0.0469094403,
-0.1114104241,
-0.000255265,
0.0026939644,
-0.0063904598,
0.0412549637,
-0.0025788806,
-0.042240236,
-0.0231486149,
0.06426052,
-0.0226795245,
-0.0003817979,
-0.03018751,
0.0190140326,
-0.0014509037,
-0.0080717551,
0.0404739045,
0.0372812748,
-0.043607235,
-0.0445221923,
0.0011311466,
0.0616528653,
-0.0292595923,
0.0419521071,
-0.0555799007,
-0.055616755,
0.0213600919,
0.0321658254,
0.0001405772,
-0.0433938205,
-0.0077401912,
-0.0155221252,
-0.0325363018,
0.0105789471,
-0.0393954404,
-0.0400104634,
-0.0717179477,
0.0299239662,
-0.0650482625,
-0.0346452147,
0.031877391,
0.028697731,
-0.0025153724,
-0.0100566912,
-0.0010727943,
0.0189829525,
-0.1091391742,
0.0367607549,
0.0008439041,
0.0364368372,
-0.0700855702,
-0.0180211589,
0.0308883935,
-0.0759904683,
-0.0496256165,
-0.0299911872,
0.0024637179,
-0.0454677157,
-0.0147644123,
0.0397317261,
0.0177186113,
0.0101185022,
-0.0365021192,
-0.0829349682,
0.0909532905,
0.0811622217,
-0.063981235,
-0.0227984749,
0.007968016,
-0.0460664034,
-0.0032444012,
0.0093638059,
-0.057107918,
0.0476857163,
0.0114256293,
0.0367534086,
0.0384377874,
-0.0290478598,
0.0164630115,
0.0001337432,
0.0629200637,
0.0108184321,
0.0380893499,
-0.0701693743,
0.0470084585,
0.073813282,
-0.0431625322,
-0.0236090999,
0.0391285978,
-0.0176092144,
-0.0610760786,
-0.0188568663,
0.0214386024,
-0.0108968606,
0.0717544556,
-0.0604601838,
-0.0042112749,
0.038914524,
0.0104151201,
0.0107276589,
-0.0010102331,
0.0337198786,
0.0275559742,
0.0072036171,
0.0473246053,
-0.0070873657,
0.0007436197,
-0.0027498575,
0.0110134566,
-0.0517833047,
0.0403001718,
-0.0403369479,
-0.0420047641,
-0.0739847645,
-0.0138886431,
0.0408191346,
-0.0605182648,
0.0129040396,
-0.0214212034,
-0.0257184114,
-0.0438726805,
0.0196035579,
0.0229179002,
0.0284693912,
0.0272530261,
0.0462129451,
-0.0118139265,
0.0139325028,
0.0752705485,
0.0034799245,
0.0185647029,
0.0110736713,
-0.0271682385,
-0.0533938445,
-0.0261757579,
0.0404156633,
0.0467720628,
-0.0557248145,
-0.001306159,
-0.0490786918,
-0.0242247377,
-0.0276957192,
-0.0064023798,
-0.0007775971,
0.0350727551,
0.0427166633,
0.0881889611,
0.0271963105,
0.0492690392,
-0.0317069627,
0.0019464691,
-0.0108993473,
-0.0010233142,
0.018339064,
-6.510914803e-33,
-0.006501406,
-0.0356576554,
-0.0096259033,
0.019204773,
0.0057442994,
0.0250756163,
-0.0143026123,
0.0132988561,
0.0160036534,
0.0204012208,
-0.016656559,
0.0163593274,
0.0050096409,
0.00583782,
0.0147956936,
0.012725872,
0.0165719576,
0.0421303064,
-0.0469802022,
0.0277486444,
0.0122785689,
0.0681650117,
0.0768591613,
-0.0370752551,
0.0270762146,
0.0155922547,
0.0106274541,
0.023964677,
0.0603123419,
0.0644634441,
-0.0358313471,
0.0710043982,
0.0238088686,
-0.0328326635,
-0.0203904212,
-0.0051202965,
-0.0561799854,
-0.0232982617,
-0.003388009,
-0.0033568928,
0.0193876121,
0.004582257,
0.0427030586,
0.0067382706,
0.0087694991,
0.0106673222,
0.0809899345,
-0.0401137024,
-0.0028276194,
-0.0332017578,
-0.0803601071,
0.0239167884,
-0.0040025227,
-0.0290083699,
0.0240682121,
0.0430157222,
0.0148786884,
0.0841751024,
-0.0699667633,
0.0532975048,
0.0037376827,
0.0684418976,
0.0624989904,
-0.0016507659,
-0.0059895087,
0.037439391,
-0.0235234462,
-0.0062873703,
0.0002120022,
0.0055383919,
-0.0035632739,
0.0794065446,
0.0179130137,
0.0397742726,
0.0646753237,
-0.0164679848,
-0.0979161337,
0.0633773282,
-0.0167888645,
0.0451375954,
0.0409186333,
0.0184939802,
0.0070881639,
-0.0156660099,
-0.0267973393,
0.0317468643,
-0.0548527017,
0.0151436944,
-0.0293729063,
0.0315411538,
-0.0618191324,
-0.0012742621,
-0.0051951585,
-0.0235474445,
-0.003585198,
0.016863063,
-0.0368236192,
-0.0342713483,
-0.0065760738,
-0.0016834581,
-0.0622301921,
-0.0116176251,
-0.0011128164,
-0.012775043,
0.0012051534,
-0.0336387865,
-0.0058432617,
0.0472858734,
-0.0250470489,
0.011216796,
-0.0253707338,
-0.0504559129,
-0.0250078961,
0.0182468612,
0.0201002602,
0.0348967984,
-0.0149828689,
-0.0104130749,
0.0284094978,
-0.0122927707,
-0.0023822405,
-0.0110642118,
-0.00019236,
-0.0017325879,
-0.01782557,
-0.0264494307,
0.0130530205,
0.0107624456,
0.0479117148,
-0.0551674739,
-0.0194750465,
0.0104865832,
2.912e-7,
0.0678416193,
0.0218995661,
-0.0365802683,
0.0017566564,
-0.0107656419,
0.0445638746,
-0.0373660736,
0.0588603094,
-0.0095932484,
-0.0025955474,
0.0247434191,
0.0091217635,
0.0286002625,
0.0025037637,
-0.0786735564,
-0.0115207219,
0.0087596932,
-0.0171652287,
-0.0782488361,
0.0219810866,
0.0322615542,
0.1034581959,
0.0053272899,
-0.0502740741,
-0.0191548895,
-0.022218097,
0.0598916896,
-0.0431105569,
-0.0229995828,
0.0420089737,
0.0353692845,
0.0548636578,
-0.0323534459,
0.02967209,
-0.0472217165,
0.0366150923,
0.0367342532,
0.0104981074,
0.0042936685,
-0.0544230901,
0.0103034051,
-0.0017258807,
0.0474685654,
0.0103755193,
0.0247126948,
-0.0508181974,
-0.0163931809,
-0.0052932934,
-0.0188590791,
-0.0041205841,
0.0082021039,
-0.0300250165,
-0.0277546775,
-0.0319532789,
0.0016025311,
-0.0061268997,
-0.0178789161,
-0.0994263962,
-0.0174275581,
0.0285851378,
-0.0442882963,
-0.0536863692,
0.0077436781,
-0.0241023842,
0.0422494672,
-0.0432739854,
0.0235797726,
2.387547494e-34,
0.0375941955,
0.012702289,
-0.0458335876,
0.0794736668,
0.0286484249,
-0.0084559787,
-0.024752561,
-0.0238434244,
0.0057473714,
-0.1072229296,
-0.0051172585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14738v1 | Cost-Sensitive Self-Training for Optimizing Non-Decomposable Metrics | 2023-04-28T10:31:12 | 2023-04-28T10:31:12 | Harsh Rangwani, Shrinivas Ramasubramanian, Sho Takemori, Kato Takashi, Yuhei Umeda, Venkatesh Babu Radhakrishnan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Self-training based semi-supervised learning algorithms have enabled the
learning of highly accurate deep neural networks, using only a fraction of
labeled data. However, the majority of work on self-training has focused on the
objective of improving accuracy, whereas practical machine learning systems can
have complex goals (e.g. maximizing the minimum of recall across classes, etc.)
that are non-decomposable in nature. In this work, we introduce the
Cost-Sensitive Self-Training (CSST) framework which generalizes the
self-training-based methods for optimizing non-decomposable metrics. We prove
that our framework can better optimize the desired non-decomposable metric
utilizing unlabeled data, under similar data distribution assumptions made for
the analysis of self-training. Using the proposed CSST framework, we obtain
practical self-training methods (for both vision and NLP tasks) for optimizing
different non-decomposable metrics using deep neural networks. Our results
demonstrate that CSST achieves an improvement over the state-of-the-art in
majority of the cases across datasets and objectives. | [
-0.0278486982,
0.0737137049,
0.0129872486,
0.0378778987,
-0.0082236426,
0.0038388481,
0.0219422933,
-0.0088568479,
0.0582319126,
-0.0098977787,
-0.076605849,
0.0406756476,
-0.0434424542,
0.0069300951,
-0.0088441046,
-0.0246416107,
0.0317915529,
0.0304940082,
-0.0255158637,
0.0020087252,
-0.0254726671,
-0.0361524671,
-0.0428420566,
-0.029647151,
-0.0752255395,
-0.0747837052,
0.0076973764,
0.0053005661,
-0.0031604641,
-0.018374024,
0.0246824715,
-0.0082260026,
-0.0262109973,
0.0223495346,
0.0000022155,
-0.0319123194,
-0.0566106215,
-0.0245485343,
-0.0647026151,
-0.0151666645,
0.0188380461,
0.001233055,
0.0062324088,
0.0149932709,
-0.0461467206,
-0.03028691,
0.0594451874,
0.029421756,
0.0683459491,
0.0536863282,
-0.0071740281,
-0.0121205347,
-0.0128788883,
-0.0472587049,
-0.0477059148,
-0.0361984894,
-0.0140590342,
0.0185368601,
-0.1043148786,
-0.0208099391,
-0.0213462748,
0.0535854474,
0.0531228147,
0.0185657013,
0.0759844556,
0.0083728312,
-0.0628159568,
-0.0046293447,
0.0007300333,
0.0324415751,
-0.0300527383,
-0.0402574651,
0.0365692154,
-0.0588143095,
0.0054159532,
-0.0715472028,
0.008245796,
-0.0219219346,
0.0473522805,
0.0392256044,
-0.0797340423,
0.0740485564,
0.0404148027,
0.0089895492,
-0.0123366294,
0.0092917653,
-0.0428256765,
0.0031267293,
0.0072370158,
0.0058553172,
0.0056123608,
-0.0194480568,
0.0027916778,
0.0215895697,
0.0485227033,
-0.0016811941,
-0.0309020858,
-0.0152777797,
-0.0015877858,
-0.0336720683,
0.012476407,
-0.0151965134,
-0.0220382214,
0.0416433178,
-0.0387570299,
0.0087653808,
0.0033163212,
0.0174058154,
-0.0416160114,
0.0103160134,
-0.0415265597,
-0.0067178262,
-0.0326168165,
0.0945623145,
0.0494766012,
0.0017095644,
-0.0728764981,
-0.0045616152,
-0.0676534995,
-0.0081823133,
0.0177493989,
0.0226251371,
-0.0526854917,
-0.0066179517,
-0.0180879273,
0.0031541029,
0.0094767204,
0.0024341717,
-0.0090904124,
0.0061253281,
-0.0157101955,
0.0351646617,
0.0110654859,
0.0236686617,
0.0390071161,
0.1026366949,
-0.0240260642,
-0.0671785101,
-0.0348654687,
-0.0225699674,
-0.0279719569,
-0.0096683437,
0.0108786151,
-0.0377663597,
0.0076300395,
-0.0348118208,
0.0211653914,
-0.066661261,
-0.0107503338,
-0.0207094569,
0.0310850982,
0.0677428842,
-0.0064681512,
0.012342195,
0.0203794204,
-0.0022797696,
0.0341817029,
0.0952517912,
0.0292384457,
0.0386746153,
0.0488182567,
-0.0107852872,
0.017533984,
0.0088040475,
0.0701709688,
-0.0129699316,
-0.0348164625,
-0.0084382771,
-0.0042831376,
0.0247275513,
0.0566731691,
-0.0210044291,
-0.0065661967,
-0.0437093601,
0.0060949149,
0.0210601464,
0.0526967049,
-0.0017866183,
-0.0189972334,
0.0038729317,
-0.0080543449,
0.0182897523,
-0.0237284899,
0.0443052761,
0.0070904479,
-0.0286221318,
0.0309197884,
-0.0243584812,
-0.0834625661,
-0.0890234336,
0.0247596782,
-0.0567868389,
0.0021668624,
0.0542271696,
0.0528233014,
0.033849977,
0.0231717005,
0.0329263546,
-0.0203648955,
-0.0226717554,
0.0259100255,
-0.0501535609,
-0.0169521626,
0.0057791225,
0.0405852497,
-0.087649025,
0.0062960843,
0.0286611766,
0.0155446446,
-0.022854479,
0.028598085,
0.0051782238,
0.0821771845,
-0.0344374515,
-0.0256002899,
-0.0297515765,
0.0213234611,
-0.0007589617,
-0.0043791612,
-0.0186383761,
0.0398742296,
-0.062443763,
0.0013862761,
0.0224637184,
0.0149770128,
-0.0781948417,
0.0886674076,
0.0698809624,
0.037883725,
0.023611702,
0.0030599132,
-0.0052687675,
0.0216531288,
-0.0433302596,
-0.0373384021,
-0.0415884405,
-0.0543347746,
-0.0121555561,
0.0248890575,
0.0021399478,
-0.0285507962,
0.0622456968,
-0.0276234597,
-0.0543259196,
0.0359311588,
-0.0225233659,
0.0153844338,
-0.0336351991,
-0.0009310831,
0.0410122909,
0.0224804692,
-0.0086320443,
0.0254311245,
0.0124234688,
0.0080096135,
-0.0821804255,
-0.0183383692,
0.0643531978,
-0.005822435,
-0.0163441952,
-0.0510728694,
-0.0689141229,
0.0289540496,
0.0569350272,
-0.0170314275,
-0.0214649551,
-0.0122776618,
-0.0156000033,
0.0056208433,
-0.0200075656,
0.0050107073,
0.0105326595,
0.0155371409,
0.0095992563,
-0.0658176467,
-0.0450723246,
-0.0034390644,
-0.0137227066,
-0.0012201171,
0.0398550481,
-0.0016402646,
0.05045579,
0.0018555924,
-0.0455306843,
-0.0027399487,
0.0161498692,
-0.0316394009,
0.0156531651,
-0.0032866849,
0.0291736089,
0.0020485306,
0.0451740138,
0.0179755576,
-0.014780594,
-0.0136536183,
0.0009016598,
-0.0116606774,
0.0927691311,
-0.0104356837,
-0.0268954895,
0.0371441655,
0.0197096076,
-0.0658777654,
0.006334262,
-0.0429342538,
0.0085006924,
0.0547786392,
-0.0245648436,
0.0305983294,
0.0388561562,
-0.0181720611,
-0.0398991071,
-0.0483786836,
0.016895948,
0.0156155266,
-0.0715756714,
-0.0388063118,
0.0405113362,
0.0325577073,
0.0120671475,
0.0256424248,
-0.0568930209,
0.0394147336,
0.0021542865,
-0.0000656284,
0.0043879468,
-0.0197758563,
-0.0542608015,
0.0464112908,
0.047244247,
0.0190354455,
0.0227394216,
-0.0300547741,
0.0008247234,
-0.0238442738,
0.060065154,
-0.0086547313,
0.0358100347,
0.0102138072,
0.0112357093,
-0.0272525996,
-0.0636454076,
-0.0278980974,
-0.0020099322,
0.0469130129,
-0.0205498077,
-0.0341503471,
0.0350871645,
0.0067379437,
-0.0011614258,
-0.0275967661,
0.0887160003,
0.0088585252,
-0.0074623376,
-0.0107241608,
0.0330318026,
-0.0112691084,
0.0113042258,
-0.0070776758,
0.0061464324,
0.0262566898,
0.0630548894,
0.0801249668,
0.0169442557,
-0.0316943265,
0.0080900164,
0.0055799256,
-0.0171062872,
0.0015572266,
-0.0011948112,
0.0006377636,
-0.0226650201,
-0.0244283993,
0.0720717087,
0.0161986146,
-0.0570382252,
-0.0095926272,
-0.0058461903,
0.0015592426,
0.0461310372,
0.0078060897,
-0.0142547544,
-0.0279101301,
-0.0070759817,
0.0699315667,
-0.011862319,
-0.0287118852,
-0.017730657,
-0.056662336,
-0.0038018655,
-0.0040607657,
0.0006432635,
-0.0081480453,
-0.0457577705,
-0.0171409212,
-0.0788645223,
-0.0596406907,
-0.0575384423,
-0.0009124898,
-0.0233593266,
0.0239089578,
-0.1249934882,
-0.0222972911,
-0.0272545498,
-0.018086737,
0.0112343626,
0.0163678583,
0.0112501848,
-0.0180573985,
0.0019490422,
0.0452348515,
-0.0602966845,
-0.0137384338,
0.0066970172,
0.0914159268,
-0.0227069594,
-0.0391228907,
0.0261090472,
0.0217010528,
-0.0206548367,
-0.0027078798,
-0.0012141312,
0.0294401217,
0.0141648306,
0.0168236662,
-0.0240534786,
-0.0427642949,
-0.0116156442,
0.0606395081,
-0.0044615059,
-0.0418702997,
-0.0230777208,
0.0444689468,
0.0706901178,
-0.0498541519,
-0.0056636296,
-0.0111555634,
-0.0149500296,
-0.05466922,
-0.0524889939,
-0.0486726984,
-0.0059798779,
0.0544958226,
-0.0203276686,
-0.0148802865,
0.0071080411,
-0.0055293925,
-0.0800770596,
-0.0118606267,
-0.0443663411,
-0.0586731546,
-0.0295601375,
0.021521965,
0.0600388609,
0.0116993235,
0.0197526589,
0.0065879077,
-0.0407644697,
-0.0232677069,
-0.0175049268,
0.0622752272,
0.0087686069,
0.04033003,
0.002446603,
-0.0478520244,
0.0560641102,
0.103186138,
-0.0285640582,
-0.0128128342,
0.0653418303,
-0.0285722017,
-0.0130971018,
0.0205215365,
-0.0205271021,
0.0525533408,
0.0203672294,
0.0057404079,
-0.0401314422,
0.0137237906,
0.0400494784,
0.0183331072,
0.0514309667,
-0.0000238293,
0.0789867416,
-0.0296645258,
0.0111369444,
0.0268331319,
-0.0024005235,
-0.0407755747,
0.045401562,
0.024945762,
0.0547413528,
-0.0339586325,
0.0230555832,
0.0048313499,
-0.0297628902,
0.0093409503,
-0.0322975814,
0.0007602603,
-0.002770382,
-0.0500544906,
0.0002673842,
-0.0102287624,
-0.0005954474,
0.0731080398,
-0.0143957445,
-0.0047747684,
-0.0180674735,
0.0402793027,
0.080862686,
-0.0468243957,
0.035997659,
0.0037356876,
-0.0081074741,
-0.0384312905,
0.0051240469,
0.0365125127,
-0.0251671672,
-0.0024393739,
-0.0338959321,
-0.0194807835,
-0.01710077,
-0.0023286215,
-0.0000406066,
0.0101184798,
-0.0449786149,
0.0068869018,
-0.0049759853,
0.0085956529,
0.0495100766,
-0.0114158504,
0.0142030641,
0.0018044827,
-0.0109733287,
-0.0727366135,
-0.0270571616,
0.0009350374,
0.001400016,
-0.000839641,
0.0082462132,
0.0200517196,
-0.0920452699,
0.0153996376,
0.0364083387,
0.0115260342,
0.0208101608,
0.0486825109,
0.0386515372,
-0.0053781476,
0.0200792328,
-0.0385828093,
0.0050467197,
0.0065370006,
0.0046107811,
0.0472231545,
-6.210997705e-33,
0.0205953475,
-0.0148075288,
-0.0116784871,
0.0189628527,
0.00023193,
0.0406437777,
0.0102436664,
0.0270781945,
-0.0035462102,
-0.0047495933,
-0.0356472917,
0.0184921157,
-0.0060354583,
0.0297256578,
0.0221517291,
-0.0174697917,
0.0553290732,
-0.0290402416,
-0.0518710092,
0.0054479488,
0.0123975389,
-0.0017368468,
0.0054983268,
-0.1053417996,
-0.0502266213,
0.0599726699,
-0.0178057235,
0.0238327757,
0.0795162916,
0.0295283776,
-0.0358086377,
0.0397954285,
0.0310228784,
-0.0023911542,
-0.0104477489,
0.0038551313,
-0.0877014175,
-0.0641113296,
-0.0924252644,
0.0142912893,
-0.0661536232,
0.0026879283,
0.0843387768,
0.0041116117,
-0.0236293711,
0.0028653562,
0.0267975442,
0.0053974022,
-0.0048452765,
-0.0301990192,
0.0141761648,
0.0169672072,
-0.034271393,
-0.0367012918,
0.0814471692,
0.0253082067,
-0.0039102547,
0.0122247962,
-0.0864248052,
-0.0038721417,
-0.0184945613,
0.0456487052,
0.0318432227,
0.0155765954,
0.0105433762,
0.0393644944,
0.0923863947,
0.0183779728,
0.0222505927,
-0.0530643724,
0.0519255102,
0.0100975512,
0.0472495891,
0.0186937321,
0.0510446988,
-0.046649944,
-0.0611427352,
0.0338538513,
-0.0192803685,
-0.0315494686,
-0.0266195424,
0.0393664502,
-0.0206854437,
-0.0117180441,
-0.0062719923,
-0.0108968792,
-0.0285597946,
0.0097131375,
0.0178585127,
0.049132783,
-0.0414521731,
0.0418429673,
-0.0177818984,
-0.0360511653,
-0.0016292207,
-0.0182424448,
0.0337536074,
0.0295415502,
0.0336541422,
0.0132322907,
-0.0561310165,
-0.0177363195,
-0.0339955129,
0.0124260597,
0.0359939486,
-0.0090685906,
0.0538909659,
0.0368709974,
-0.0473832376,
-0.0160014201,
0.0084464401,
0.022719292,
-0.0102754887,
-0.0194578506,
0.0110788262,
-0.0073871138,
-0.0101481285,
0.0446164645,
0.0372295156,
0.0048698545,
-0.0258115698,
0.0239419118,
0.020920882,
0.0389619507,
0.014790738,
-0.0198473912,
-0.0086341919,
0.0189639758,
0.0305484217,
-0.0979649723,
-0.0051068999,
-0.0078265751,
2.694e-7,
0.0275710523,
-0.0006688493,
-0.0073487018,
-0.0204265174,
0.0247946754,
0.0684538931,
0.0108890412,
0.0474798456,
-0.0342862569,
-0.0011662644,
0.0249601305,
0.0074968999,
0.0068985275,
-0.0229708385,
-0.0451895781,
0.064044103,
-0.0072371894,
0.038133584,
0.003988883,
-0.0090666329,
-0.0304520503,
0.0318357684,
0.0504734069,
-0.0136190141,
0.0019351407,
-0.0208677053,
0.0451348424,
-0.0089149671,
0.0414999835,
0.0247187391,
0.0382369198,
0.0665275455,
-0.0228745025,
0.031489376,
-0.016457893,
0.0282243527,
0.0531220771,
-0.0073156795,
0.0130162695,
-0.068078436,
-0.0025093337,
0.0294496305,
-0.0135171106,
0.0234278254,
0.0769539699,
-0.0726876557,
-0.0465118699,
-0.0126814991,
-0.012391896,
0.0282109044,
0.0440682173,
0.0281371996,
-0.0362665802,
0.0143491179,
0.0280538406,
0.0020919435,
-0.0152031071,
-0.0803725794,
-0.0005269801,
0.0100298198,
-0.0283550266,
0.0198993888,
-0.0516644605,
0.0632293448,
0.0156052588,
-0.0438781865,
-0.0251942743,
1.902770869e-34,
0.0129218036,
-0.0212802961,
0.0226830058,
-0.0517646931,
-0.0474168546,
-0.0198458117,
-0.0441446379,
-0.0371300019,
0.0018235273,
0.0079292376,
-0.0072898613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14732v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14732v7 | Search-in-the-Chain: Interactively Enhancing Large Language Models with Search for Knowledge-intensive Tasks | 2023-04-28T10:15:25 | 2024-02-24T16:54:29 | Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Making the content generated by Large Language Model (LLM), accurate,
credible and traceable is crucial, especially in complex knowledge-intensive
tasks that require multi-step reasoning and each step needs knowledge to solve.
Retrieval-augmented generation is good potential to solve this problem.
However, where and how to introduce Information Retrieval (IR) to LLM is a big
challenge. Previous work has the problems that wrong knowledge retrieved by IR
misleads the LLM and interaction between IR and LLM breaks the reasoning chain
of LLM. This paper proposes a novel framework named
\textbf{Search-in-the-Chain} (SearChain) for the interaction between LLM and IR
to solve the challenges. First, LLM generates the reasoning chain named
Chain-of-Query (CoQ) where each node consists of an IR-oriented query-answer
pair. Second, IR verifies the answer of each node of CoQ. It corrects the
answer that is not consistent with the retrieved information when IR gives high
confidence, which improves the credibility. Third, LLM can indicate its missing
knowledge in CoQ and rely on IR to provide this knowledge to LLM. These
operations improve the accuracy in terms of reasoning and knowledge. Finally,
SearChain generates the reasoning process and marks references to supporting
documents for each reasoning step, which improves traceability. Interaction
with IR in SearChain forms a novel reasoning path based on a tree, which
enables LLM to dynamically modify the direction of reasoning. Experiments show
that SearChain outperforms state-of-the-art baselines on complex
knowledge-intensive tasks including multi-hop Q\&A, slot filling, fact
checking, and long-form Q\&A. | [
0.0530545488,
0.0253500696,
-0.0243553761,
0.0472660325,
-0.0608109273,
-0.0111547774,
-0.0411601253,
0.0108911069,
-0.0008582221,
-0.0687053278,
0.0071674585,
0.0107186334,
-0.0288849156,
0.017485559,
0.0098975506,
-0.0416026451,
0.0507383533,
-0.0177458655,
0.0078594564,
0.011897767,
0.0108363843,
0.0338326283,
-0.0120424246,
0.0270730685,
-0.029501874,
-0.0221470725,
-0.0423411205,
0.0114226379,
-0.0007727548,
-0.0252486188,
-0.0127433566,
0.0274416395,
0.0374135561,
0.0295469761,
0.0000023796,
-0.0460938215,
-0.0422359817,
0.0288731325,
-0.0875979736,
-0.0142224524,
-0.0294348095,
0.0676052198,
-0.0049123582,
0.0325331055,
-0.0428954214,
0.0131988013,
0.0233751833,
0.0331866555,
0.0591205843,
0.0443772338,
0.0165404994,
-0.0036860874,
0.0076940903,
0.0076473732,
0.0536075644,
-0.0407354422,
0.0185231362,
0.056030754,
0.0684739575,
0.0688282102,
0.0368292928,
0.0393209569,
0.0256140623,
-0.0743767396,
-0.0160697978,
-0.0026792821,
-0.001519373,
-0.0112807965,
0.0013745331,
0.042891331,
0.012750132,
-0.0353732295,
0.0043395995,
-0.0001302641,
0.0077589215,
0.0633624047,
-0.0628135577,
0.0371257663,
-0.0419260263,
-0.0261470433,
0.0012289203,
-0.0320567936,
0.03698048,
0.0181390736,
-0.0265893526,
0.082287319,
0.0024118091,
-0.0483639054,
-0.0078632226,
-0.0173373073,
-0.0051830928,
-0.0621096045,
0.0127539011,
0.0792069435,
-0.0561206788,
0.0530114993,
0.0219769925,
-0.0047972109,
0.0425469875,
-0.050115604,
-0.0085396236,
0.0273254253,
-0.019822089,
0.0482019037,
-0.0197407957,
0.0490323119,
-0.0322183892,
-0.0214616675,
-0.0433947444,
-0.0491994731,
-0.0673809722,
-0.056450814,
-0.0417340435,
0.048079133,
-0.0627021268,
-0.0019938624,
0.0078718113,
0.048593618,
-0.0169856586,
0.0288625211,
0.0107535338,
0.0139515419,
-0.0038423045,
-0.0128766503,
-0.0747637525,
0.0349985659,
-0.0098043606,
0.0102332123,
0.0170298703,
-0.0201160405,
0.0124540497,
0.0246971846,
0.0124338381,
-0.0110709714,
-0.0022531243,
0.0222840346,
-0.000954375,
-0.0007928534,
-0.0417867266,
-0.0670328066,
0.01148469,
-0.0616915487,
-0.0061339582,
-0.0802725106,
0.0136489877,
0.0116063245,
-0.0439647362,
-0.010478043,
0.0250845775,
0.0641862825,
0.0005530436,
0.0322557427,
-0.0089263571,
0.0237755906,
0.0525188558,
0.0213999152,
-0.0005506465,
0.0650457218,
0.0215764064,
0.0327642448,
0.0322992392,
0.0060067065,
0.0303388815,
-0.0021356645,
0.0181356929,
-0.019516889,
0.0190364774,
0.0543216951,
-0.0204152763,
0.0252339058,
-0.0233936273,
0.0387203246,
-0.0472563431,
0.0484562777,
0.0208761804,
0.0067612198,
0.0505075194,
-0.0208397787,
0.0443806425,
0.0050436282,
0.0097179348,
-0.0013002874,
-0.0221308339,
0.0381348282,
-0.0493124016,
-0.0014200042,
-0.0221395232,
0.0096755233,
-0.0072313012,
-0.0528311841,
-0.0093076061,
0.0495481081,
-0.0212976653,
0.0468017161,
0.0571146458,
0.02737475,
-0.0248680357,
0.0480057783,
-0.0000129561,
-0.040423926,
-0.0030985563,
-0.0694292933,
0.040564876,
0.0550602973,
0.0830162019,
-0.0330271758,
-0.0209500827,
0.0314923935,
-0.0230761319,
0.0319198519,
0.0110970223,
-0.0353031605,
-0.0556898415,
-0.025038451,
-0.0430629179,
-0.0102055082,
0.0045509138,
-0.005414871,
0.0439845957,
-0.0187089257,
0.0301594418,
-0.0489864089,
-0.0112079997,
0.0166545529,
-0.0268296413,
-0.0040953052,
-0.018890053,
0.0196906552,
0.0062516755,
0.0418542549,
0.0066847862,
0.045048289,
0.0497088581,
0.0062189326,
-0.0598557182,
-0.024159601,
-0.0076477663,
-0.0053541847,
0.0163978897,
-0.003190682,
0.0000567792,
-0.0292158127,
-0.0198199898,
-0.0562187359,
-0.0159505401,
-0.0417002104,
0.0200406611,
-0.0455449186,
0.0150123825,
-0.0009364484,
-0.0652702674,
-0.0576923974,
0.0924291611,
0.0308789331,
-0.0030532754,
0.0221677274,
0.0359663554,
0.0080988444,
-0.048249729,
0.0073542367,
0.024059793,
-0.003569097,
0.0193899535,
0.0418326221,
-0.0047275689,
-0.0187686961,
-0.0215675402,
-0.068224892,
0.0247402787,
-0.0093162898,
0.0269571077,
0.0089739366,
0.0263703875,
0.0008614691,
-0.0016937355,
-0.023515733,
-0.0030197401,
0.033864297,
0.0205191392,
0.0087073743,
0.0424059778,
-0.0086912969,
-0.013129659,
0.0029105116,
-0.0194868911,
0.0358857252,
0.0155810518,
-0.0311120972,
-0.0690382868,
0.0299155936,
-0.0662553385,
0.0213263761,
-0.0021278441,
0.0129454723,
0.0354595892,
-0.0265566818,
0.0061165513,
0.0373109058,
-0.0004414323,
0.0060219085,
0.0482962355,
-0.0328720026,
-0.0754422024,
0.0419682488,
-0.0182309262,
0.0009922007,
0.0097833481,
-0.0170143619,
0.0211501755,
0.022269154,
0.0031866936,
0.0034259208,
-0.0213348549,
0.0023998227,
-0.0043029948,
0.010140473,
-0.0516504347,
-0.0659216791,
0.0130032497,
0.0716260448,
-0.017984394,
-0.0354558378,
0.0638202205,
-0.0456368402,
0.0280383434,
-0.0465293936,
-0.0141759822,
-0.0316871479,
0.0949915722,
-0.015746396,
0.0139905466,
-0.0039555579,
0.0022521492,
-0.0461919941,
-0.0034908308,
0.0435628928,
-0.0624998249,
0.0302662905,
-0.0585689992,
0.0267201643,
0.0079404749,
-0.036650002,
-0.0549281649,
0.0241718274,
-0.0138230678,
0.0058851019,
0.0150629962,
-0.0209105164,
-0.0056685596,
-0.0010632175,
0.0842258632,
0.028061999,
-0.0086216815,
-0.0140948715,
-0.0157687645,
0.0301950574,
0.043606285,
0.0029487722,
0.0350127295,
0.0065218974,
0.0432016551,
0.0543973595,
0.0194799043,
-0.0330975242,
0.0026032203,
-0.0561034307,
-0.0005803264,
-0.02237745,
-0.0201710127,
0.0063653039,
-0.0037229646,
-0.1013965309,
-0.0246469565,
0.069970943,
0.0521752276,
-0.0277101304,
-0.0280682836,
-0.056770172,
0.0149959195,
0.0346753933,
0.0789428875,
-0.084812656,
0.008928231,
0.024238389,
0.016502982,
-0.0379381143,
-0.0130189825,
-0.0180652309,
-0.1372113675,
0.0710207149,
-0.0255065709,
0.0145480391,
-0.0420152284,
-0.059172485,
0.0032052309,
0.0601628646,
-0.0175508875,
0.0692104101,
0.0079444079,
-0.0064746956,
0.0260672234,
0.0113708461,
-0.0179626849,
0.0114241811,
-0.0062566912,
0.0066548879,
0.06708505,
0.0425273739,
0.0405324101,
-0.0143245729,
0.0162539985,
-0.0199755318,
0.0279690735,
-0.0301769413,
0.0228463449,
0.0008915051,
0.0113500748,
-0.0623844154,
-0.0158426445,
-0.0030129277,
-0.0004255047,
0.0286689959,
0.1146408245,
-0.0576644875,
0.0282579213,
-0.0201195106,
-0.0293504726,
0.0120328143,
0.0673805177,
0.0070980433,
0.0169748571,
-0.0228924211,
-0.0335996449,
-0.0232537631,
-0.0211857744,
-0.0249493662,
0.0525499955,
-0.0103314845,
0.0445637293,
-0.0740954801,
-0.0030037516,
0.0358387269,
0.0754799321,
-0.0080779074,
0.022626536,
0.0273022857,
-0.009157246,
-0.0366290808,
0.0017859931,
-0.0563001372,
0.0156129254,
-0.0110314162,
0.0203943886,
0.0311133638,
-0.045956634,
0.004032033,
0.0022811792,
-0.025088368,
-0.0413721688,
-0.04384524,
0.0284428038,
0.0302018635,
0.0485854708,
-0.0275416765,
-0.0390961915,
0.0089373309,
0.018460758,
-0.0598548204,
-0.0259595271,
-0.0121345036,
-0.0253936946,
-0.0165711399,
0.0136840912,
-0.0880723894,
-0.011622183,
-0.0275735445,
0.058720585,
-0.0260869656,
-0.0623964295,
0.0636838228,
0.0458665341,
0.009206973,
0.0266457442,
-0.0081137819,
-0.0339439213,
0.0468538702,
-0.0632155389,
-0.0567856841,
-0.0345281065,
0.0398029126,
-0.0237541962,
-0.0400548279,
0.0497004017,
-0.0068935263,
0.0094010001,
0.0523937792,
-0.0190110803,
-0.0052249827,
-0.017021602,
0.0265807789,
0.0352858268,
-0.0081251543,
0.0010181229,
-0.0067867716,
0.0079012029,
0.0598740876,
-0.011508055,
0.0708675608,
0.0284201335,
-0.0467832163,
-0.0127504198,
-0.0276784953,
-0.0640749559,
-0.0804631859,
-0.0214734022,
0.0120729664,
0.0382440053,
0.0270277075,
0.014362799,
-0.0519792214,
-0.0201969706,
0.0091057643,
-0.0049011009,
0.0422333106,
-0.0463416502,
0.0421767384,
0.0419670008,
-0.0067356415,
0.0010497161,
0.048324775,
-0.0063056028,
0.0391248465,
-0.0376636349,
-0.0638205558,
-0.030502053,
-0.0514742136,
-0.014109605,
0.0033606978,
-0.042664133,
-0.022276029,
-0.0606046207,
-0.0505848378,
-0.024753483,
0.0257254075,
-0.0316954963,
-0.0204396043,
0.0451294966,
0.0863171816,
0.0297570508,
-0.0422583818,
-0.052889023,
0.0385957845,
-0.0524323769,
0.0026539927,
0.0016268318,
-6.407999538e-33,
-0.046749752,
-0.0700321272,
0.0733573064,
-0.0089437123,
-0.0080991341,
0.0034561949,
-0.0450200438,
-0.0126626091,
-0.0216093063,
0.0176511947,
-0.0012121901,
0.012628966,
0.0044644591,
-0.0023457205,
-0.0028149041,
0.0150083024,
0.0322775654,
0.0220253989,
-0.0245789215,
0.0325816572,
0.0728777125,
-0.0041112667,
0.0149154728,
-0.0648226738,
-0.0030161345,
-0.0148408171,
0.0081694825,
0.0835609958,
-0.0561815277,
0.0744448304,
0.0181589462,
0.0272755213,
0.0173938572,
-0.0501594134,
-0.0025526353,
0.0225849058,
-0.0673137903,
-0.013905107,
0.0348564796,
-0.0214611478,
-0.0393209159,
-0.0049961042,
0.0276974589,
0.0016741729,
0.0302826092,
0.0337538458,
0.0174820218,
-0.0135276001,
-0.0221763104,
-0.0401020981,
-0.056550283,
0.0278771557,
0.0193185396,
-0.0287213698,
-0.0339625962,
0.0669414178,
0.0188267678,
-0.0014421263,
-0.0449360795,
0.0086750388,
-0.0147218779,
0.0342553779,
0.0623725988,
0.029098371,
-0.0006045969,
0.0205495544,
-0.0104690325,
0.0098934136,
-0.0391915329,
0.0022400545,
-0.0165346954,
0.0592693873,
0.0468004532,
0.0368752293,
-0.0093493331,
0.0125397919,
-0.077076368,
0.0297372956,
-0.0055147782,
0.0830566958,
0.0274090674,
0.0089232689,
-0.0302079786,
-0.0085996678,
-0.0459352136,
0.0443356596,
-0.0487960316,
-0.0307228807,
0.0310620032,
0.0185868368,
-0.014220289,
-0.0291934293,
0.0073213303,
-0.004830535,
-0.0103686666,
0.0558017939,
-0.0329507254,
0.0187549181,
-0.0250845384,
0.0441688336,
-0.0212318208,
-0.0156238787,
0.0119394399,
-0.0055419565,
-0.0287892781,
0.036902409,
-0.0022967246,
0.0128980093,
-0.0299325138,
0.0096875075,
-0.062523976,
0.0183550771,
-0.0145786898,
-0.0282230359,
0.031889081,
0.0248203594,
0.0054589338,
0.0469208211,
0.0097685726,
-0.0081454366,
-0.0315489024,
-0.0326991118,
-0.0063141468,
-0.0195325781,
-0.0092903199,
0.0039708591,
-0.0476935506,
0.0392023884,
-0.0034332974,
-0.0524552874,
0.0077624116,
0.0605245866,
3.134e-7,
0.0311908741,
0.0430057496,
0.0021760282,
0.0509269908,
0.0127548408,
0.0011267515,
0.0059430674,
-0.0540411063,
0.0357089788,
-0.059228573,
-0.0065500699,
0.0203675181,
0.0264836103,
0.0610812269,
-0.0821663886,
-0.0332207903,
-0.0414882749,
-0.0578239113,
-0.0613607205,
-0.0147745162,
0.0445508584,
0.0449663922,
-0.0046447306,
0.0111693703,
-0.0347440094,
-0.0549076684,
0.0345257446,
0.0369828157,
-0.0225538313,
0.0228889752,
0.0612378679,
0.0092961146,
0.0260013472,
0.0227001999,
-0.0096834283,
0.025143588,
-0.0227103084,
0.0233323071,
0.0063328501,
-0.0125827342,
-0.0244351681,
-0.0567811653,
0.0215051435,
-0.0712580606,
0.0579679534,
-0.0160429683,
0.027807517,
-0.0192753207,
-0.0094205365,
-0.0294769369,
-0.0493087061,
-0.0164842959,
-0.0056783115,
0.0173996072,
-0.0092634903,
-0.0020448973,
-0.0043578441,
-0.0487580225,
-0.0317638256,
0.0070514791,
-0.0382732563,
-0.042794928,
-0.043522086,
-0.0282237176,
-0.0128148571,
-0.0252806749,
0.0042196647,
3.08299911e-34,
0.004215105,
0.0078642573,
-0.0057233362,
0.0190031789,
0.0690520629,
0.0254751183,
-0.0658075958,
0.0254279952,
0.0251444746,
-0.092253007,
-0.0261021443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14721v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14721v4 | Towards autonomous system: flexible modular production system enhanced with large language model agents | 2023-04-28T09:42:18 | 2023-07-24T09:49:55 | Yuchen Xia, Manthan Shenoy, Nasser Jazdi, Michael Weyrich | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.SE, cs.SY, eess.SY | In this paper, we present a novel framework that combines large language
models (LLMs), digital twins and industrial automation system to enable
intelligent planning and control of production processes. We retrofit the
automation system for a modular production facility and create executable
control interfaces of fine-granular functionalities and coarse-granular skills.
Low-level functionalities are executed by automation components, and high-level
skills are performed by automation modules. Subsequently, a digital twin system
is developed, registering these interfaces and containing additional
descriptive information about the production system. Based on the retrofitted
automation system and the created digital twins, LLM-agents are designed to
interpret descriptive information in the digital twins and control the physical
system through service interfaces. These LLM-agents serve as intelligent agents
on different levels within an automation system, enabling autonomous planning
and control of flexible production. Given a task instruction as input, the
LLM-agents orchestrate a sequence of atomic functionalities and skills to
accomplish the task. We demonstrate how our implemented prototype can handle
un-predefined tasks, plan a production process, and execute the operations.
This research highlights the potential of integrating LLMs into industrial
automation systems in the context of smart factory for more agile, flexible,
and adaptive production processes, while it also underscores the critical
insights and limitations for future work. Demos at:
https://github.com/YuchenXia/GPT4IndustrialAutomation | [
-0.014620549,
0.0055989772,
-0.0667013302,
0.0225422662,
-0.0266532674,
-0.015243331,
0.0379251316,
0.0074268859,
0.0013438982,
-0.0315070003,
0.0006650932,
0.0438250974,
-0.0659017265,
0.1004565954,
0.0148678012,
0.0136656854,
0.0201753899,
-0.0120614804,
-0.0301143359,
0.0051407022,
-0.0147875566,
-0.0092779687,
0.0076309331,
0.0003755334,
-0.0455685556,
0.0080518331,
-0.0337205008,
-0.0005375394,
0.0039529018,
0.043512255,
-0.0409395583,
0.0191322956,
0.0658400506,
0.0697431862,
0.0000020448,
-0.0608537309,
-0.0004790611,
0.0018906922,
-0.0515286773,
0.0003445981,
0.0152654536,
0.0082299048,
-0.0309505034,
0.0161047485,
-0.0282393806,
-0.0007667573,
0.0536229797,
0.0425280556,
0.0040856637,
0.008777149,
0.0030950243,
-0.0171280075,
0.0151374144,
0.0142330006,
-0.0725634024,
0.0213502441,
0.0117722312,
0.035695564,
0.0589741729,
0.0217886567,
0.0292907991,
-0.0084365504,
0.0423778556,
-0.0294905528,
-0.0322734937,
0.0162386503,
-0.0208145995,
-0.0151465973,
-0.0066142124,
0.0146778664,
0.0064494023,
-0.0300571322,
0.0381215103,
-0.0134241404,
-0.0032553971,
-0.0358662121,
-0.0124119911,
0.0002789618,
0.0435302258,
0.020362407,
-0.0189459305,
-0.0258635059,
-0.0401858613,
-0.0122520337,
-0.0187004413,
0.0816015154,
-0.0113182338,
0.0119000394,
-0.0558481514,
-0.0199864674,
0.0151263354,
-0.0057599843,
0.0054583182,
0.1099439859,
-0.0154003212,
-0.01214022,
0.0035437052,
-0.0244335011,
0.0014404233,
-0.0420982763,
-0.0277229287,
0.0106616076,
-0.0110580483,
0.0290896725,
-0.0298835393,
0.0621489733,
-0.0056178076,
0.0201910287,
-0.0571455322,
0.0013091228,
-0.0347813368,
-0.0221370459,
-0.0897285044,
0.011523596,
-0.0420041233,
-0.0285004228,
0.0293815602,
0.05742836,
-0.0417039879,
0.0435393602,
-0.007220638,
-0.0385207385,
-0.007090983,
-0.0422704183,
-0.0588069297,
0.0113583431,
-0.0253500752,
0.0134033496,
-0.0382577889,
-0.0509463139,
0.0381547771,
0.0305178203,
0.0121106869,
0.041064281,
-0.0077450895,
0.1040646136,
-0.0219189636,
0.0345000923,
-0.0092437072,
-0.0606051385,
0.0712420046,
-0.0673843622,
-0.0416928791,
-0.0141857341,
0.028313756,
0.002580693,
-0.0298738219,
-0.0080667017,
0.0230109971,
-0.0281410106,
0.0339610726,
0.0211865008,
-0.0155383479,
0.0420008898,
-0.0144238248,
-0.0102881351,
0.0130268848,
0.0571383052,
0.0557748973,
0.0430618189,
-0.0035577444,
0.0322142541,
0.0423691906,
0.0482279286,
-0.0777074918,
-0.0456115082,
-0.0079416987,
0.0122299604,
0.0327990614,
0.0074911988,
-0.0005730665,
-0.0165831205,
0.0306136236,
0.0488696583,
0.0589371584,
-0.0181626547,
-0.0204844419,
0.0257931836,
0.0818213224,
0.0932374373,
-0.0216447394,
-0.0398782752,
0.0096655022,
0.0120201968,
0.0114798266,
-0.0020695503,
-0.0638552159,
0.0057473071,
-0.0153087154,
-0.0121711679,
0.0218671281,
-0.031556949,
0.0485826135,
-0.0061452631,
0.0511070043,
-0.0240688082,
-0.0486566462,
0.0165737215,
-0.0174134932,
0.0286623687,
-0.0167877804,
-0.0482292995,
0.0017397786,
0.0965916216,
0.0343760364,
-0.0495761074,
-0.0495930538,
0.033423584,
-0.0414725095,
0.0260293689,
0.0246016383,
-0.0217972025,
-0.0168344397,
0.003891499,
-0.0319197178,
0.0247040186,
0.00358197,
0.0207966808,
-0.0429708883,
-0.0170635153,
-0.0362431556,
0.0379662365,
0.0142100798,
0.0120929666,
-0.0363673754,
-0.0141831608,
-0.0446142107,
0.0350160077,
0.0211045872,
-0.0227542613,
-0.0226858631,
-0.0069188424,
0.0554576889,
-0.0144636855,
-0.0457457528,
0.0429468863,
0.0198019911,
0.0845733881,
0.0215076488,
0.0487142801,
-0.0052661235,
0.0041526691,
-0.0266160667,
-0.0623080432,
0.0244090129,
-0.000271761,
-0.0043083555,
0.0211330671,
0.0203684364,
-0.0504396893,
0.0207884032,
-0.0268316101,
0.0009483836,
0.0496767648,
-0.0308192093,
-0.0101665976,
0.0090572685,
0.0323180184,
-0.018111119,
-0.0047437269,
0.0503036678,
0.014858339,
0.034347225,
0.0054330472,
0.0123560019,
0.0319555067,
-0.0210262109,
-0.0428410172,
0.0030646608,
0.0068355626,
-0.0341374055,
0.0097394874,
-0.0368121155,
0.0013804389,
-0.0155036049,
0.0144133111,
0.1483494043,
-0.0054707932,
-0.0414010808,
0.0021468152,
0.0424726568,
-0.0515160523,
0.0312574729,
0.0281590167,
-0.0066314647,
-0.0376540087,
0.0224162955,
0.0781072527,
-0.1184827313,
0.019543061,
-0.0076808906,
0.0415064991,
0.0040311911,
-0.0442932472,
-0.0228781905,
-0.0331120528,
0.0080533968,
0.0363746174,
-0.0881798789,
0.0141288666,
0.065053001,
-0.034762904,
-0.0247243736,
0.0124227619,
-0.0523139462,
0.0185341761,
-0.030278109,
0.0445888378,
-0.0440072194,
0.0137414206,
0.0246456433,
-0.006968196,
-0.0033129237,
0.0003405805,
0.0360819586,
0.0192094017,
0.0333514065,
-0.0139924111,
-0.0350019597,
0.0825044662,
-0.0188216679,
-0.0533765331,
0.0194843113,
-0.020618828,
-0.0127602648,
0.0094787627,
-0.0595673099,
-0.0104200644,
0.069712013,
0.0413545705,
-0.0059301704,
-0.010701579,
-0.0129125342,
-0.0544935353,
0.0741873607,
-0.0405030847,
0.0157607552,
0.0152497049,
-0.0705836415,
0.0041642152,
-0.004908714,
-0.0384524539,
0.015251603,
0.0570855029,
-0.042833373,
0.0646193326,
-0.0149220992,
-0.0162619948,
-0.0562133752,
0.0173259471,
0.032848902,
0.0780507028,
0.0239329208,
-0.003378053,
-0.0507203415,
-0.0306382123,
0.0198442247,
0.0283808205,
-0.0372041464,
0.0502964184,
0.0429120958,
-0.0187684875,
-0.0170646664,
-0.0113945315,
-0.0580006242,
-0.0397447981,
0.016381897,
0.0099100517,
0.0254269727,
0.0202058293,
0.0202277396,
-0.0733886287,
0.0025491072,
0.0452075861,
-0.019088801,
0.0078716138,
0.0157526471,
0.0094661815,
-0.0204597227,
0.0411487781,
0.0423460156,
-0.0491276383,
-0.0063568824,
0.006369371,
-0.0290689673,
-0.0107128266,
0.0019999507,
-0.00455224,
-0.051012598,
0.0443607755,
-0.0306988358,
-0.0616936348,
-0.0703461915,
0.0058398391,
0.0317756534,
-0.0028588364,
0.0034648136,
0.0237816107,
0.0314691067,
-0.0513308607,
-0.0083713857,
0.0035800517,
-0.0259439424,
-0.0038608673,
-0.0052599474,
0.0192505717,
0.0633645132,
-0.0148277767,
0.0008240076,
0.0331907235,
0.0279740728,
-0.0096151903,
0.0331591852,
-0.0387067646,
-0.0599974953,
0.0573890321,
-0.021809008,
-0.0200973582,
0.0020739073,
-0.0051260851,
-0.0104860803,
-0.0017378306,
0.1121577993,
-0.0201032236,
-0.0316730626,
-0.0326932818,
-0.0232808571,
0.0001193589,
0.0126429889,
-0.0297290087,
-0.0275200736,
-0.0557420664,
-0.0142849358,
-0.0561773777,
0.0440801643,
-0.0184008367,
0.0165493507,
-0.0399281569,
-0.0343986712,
-0.0074181017,
-0.0430433638,
0.0421505608,
0.0081141228,
0.0323299319,
-0.002279137,
0.0726337805,
0.0178895723,
-0.0486476831,
-0.0600261576,
-0.018378349,
0.027794024,
-0.0213310141,
-0.0250808448,
0.0236717965,
-0.0474192537,
-0.0268432647,
-0.0100494968,
-0.0229314994,
-0.0361233689,
0.0309745073,
0.0399352238,
0.0215780698,
-0.0199783854,
-0.0096356496,
-0.0624763221,
0.0304275993,
-0.0079211267,
-0.0493122265,
-0.002177451,
-0.0502366573,
0.0531929247,
0.0183573775,
0.0327696763,
-0.0721337125,
0.0529018864,
0.0284123812,
-0.0076097893,
-0.0518255495,
-0.0135079855,
-0.0188242588,
0.0220196694,
-0.0529397428,
0.0315355435,
0.0482353866,
-0.0253064483,
0.0393679813,
-0.0170223769,
-0.0160214864,
-0.0598249957,
0.0259425677,
-0.0677721873,
-0.0430618003,
0.0528160892,
-0.0286832489,
0.0285135079,
0.0267064888,
0.0205439776,
0.0184573773,
-0.0662120357,
0.0509788208,
0.0079905493,
0.0217285007,
0.0069498615,
0.0018740422,
-0.0024218613,
0.0200033654,
-0.0115312673,
0.0567570701,
0.0060704174,
-0.0362622403,
-0.0825216323,
0.0007011372,
0.0165798329,
-0.0610216148,
0.0275705885,
0.0298127905,
0.0416217297,
0.0061466508,
0.0340336226,
-0.0853954032,
0.0147414757,
-0.0275739301,
0.0249459278,
0.0045367437,
0.0009187974,
-0.0000152355,
0.0268381275,
-0.0172670428,
-0.0370765589,
0.0233697575,
-0.0157248639,
0.0205918849,
-0.0321889371,
-0.0685034841,
-0.0638338625,
0.0164803602,
0.0727796629,
-0.0299518555,
-0.0115254326,
0.0216563903,
-0.0340131931,
0.0188807715,
-0.0492448807,
0.053931687,
0.0209942367,
-0.0662174746,
0.0157822631,
0.0133531336,
0.0239121672,
-0.0179983322,
-0.001582915,
-0.0150058903,
0.0340519547,
0.0342345648,
-0.0234183501,
-5.495289888e-33,
0.0046919491,
-0.0422632135,
0.0363540165,
0.0541111864,
-0.0240969472,
-0.0358733349,
0.0122752106,
-0.026740456,
0.0187826715,
0.0208279341,
0.0375216901,
-0.0085126162,
0.014615681,
-0.0123185981,
0.0378109105,
-0.0102178641,
0.0292887576,
-0.0001165323,
-0.002763343,
0.0248071793,
0.0347228013,
-0.0000452257,
0.0490913019,
-0.0156132299,
-0.0001589743,
-0.0274481568,
0.0092405947,
0.0504550636,
-0.0026346683,
0.0292912945,
-0.0152604161,
0.0451670587,
0.0256780423,
-0.0176160559,
-0.0326737612,
0.0596792735,
-0.0204986818,
-0.0307785776,
-0.0285438579,
0.067648761,
0.0422293767,
-0.0332403891,
0.0584974475,
-0.0390626751,
-0.0408507772,
0.0417861938,
0.0273999106,
-0.0182752106,
0.0292438027,
-0.0027479623,
-0.100483112,
-0.0125017259,
0.007502073,
0.0126011921,
0.0438005254,
-0.0232029371,
0.0086685065,
-0.0595392734,
-0.0441317745,
0.0118749002,
-0.030715907,
-0.0063887616,
0.0229554325,
-0.0279212408,
0.0246756263,
-0.0294989906,
0.0158536062,
0.0063597369,
0.0164740197,
-0.0007905003,
-0.0271811392,
0.0829808861,
0.0164838433,
-0.0167750418,
-0.0026554742,
0.0114523573,
-0.0375054218,
0.0129699195,
0.0112717208,
0.0704416633,
0.0616368875,
0.0118399635,
0.0002600164,
0.0121687409,
-0.0004953813,
0.036609713,
-0.0195660815,
-0.0122189559,
-0.0070803505,
0.0401481166,
0.0061246431,
-0.0145210735,
0.0212994926,
0.0045907767,
-0.0235584173,
-0.0087322537,
-0.0417916067,
0.0146909682,
0.0169330481,
-0.0071874196,
-0.0261683483,
-0.0496091731,
-0.0251769032,
-0.0016145582,
0.0188135058,
0.0196006522,
-0.0399997123,
0.0809650123,
-0.0368613675,
0.0411390439,
-0.0540024452,
-0.0308569334,
0.0172019117,
-0.0728004128,
0.0135832271,
0.0031334497,
0.0291174296,
0.0009166233,
-0.0129761267,
-0.0881293043,
0.0281269122,
0.0256885663,
0.0156537071,
0.0107211312,
-0.029821787,
0.0271231998,
-0.0827481225,
-0.0005951906,
0.0069912081,
-0.0362478308,
-0.0131212454,
0.0316858925,
2.862e-7,
-0.0175441951,
0.0232391469,
-0.0072583011,
0.0619417429,
0.0497958399,
0.0321197771,
-0.0090944842,
-0.0054214653,
-0.0393662192,
0.0687428489,
0.0113654025,
0.0143065816,
-0.0030085167,
-0.0179457422,
-0.0401428565,
0.000054005,
0.0414224193,
-0.0129681528,
-0.091205731,
0.0126783457,
0.0727593079,
0.0637506619,
0.0253233612,
0.0253522899,
0.0253988169,
-0.0570392199,
-0.0375794247,
-0.014282342,
0.0784403607,
0.0014577538,
-0.0033685907,
0.019509444,
-0.0272241384,
0.0313610956,
0.0193841532,
0.0333731659,
-0.0555624552,
0.0610101968,
-0.0145708425,
0.0287731029,
0.0438001975,
-0.0814763531,
-0.0183437616,
-0.0295016374,
0.0171353873,
-0.0565388426,
-0.0224164426,
0.0011738053,
-0.0201263316,
-0.0248525906,
-0.0989400968,
-0.0168962553,
0.005342816,
0.0185675286,
-0.0113075748,
-0.0441532433,
0.026927283,
-0.0124860713,
0.0398603715,
0.006501249,
-0.0832242221,
-0.0435112864,
-0.0214082245,
-0.0468150005,
0.0153195048,
0.0172375888,
0.0032792618,
2.60233373e-34,
-0.0079988949,
0.0242372844,
0.0125619387,
0.073368445,
0.0087534161,
0.0324476026,
-0.0266152229,
0.0309344865,
0.0172619298,
-0.0692108497,
-0.0348553509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14662v1 | CED: Catalog Extraction from Documents | 2023-04-28T07:32:00 | 2023-04-28T07:32:00 | Tong Zhu, Guoliang Zhang, Zechang Li, Zijian Yu, Junfei Ren, Mengsong Wu, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai, Pingfu Chao, Wenliang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentence-by-sentence information extraction from long documents is an
exhausting and error-prone task. As the indicator of document skeleton,
catalogs naturally chunk documents into segments and provide informative
cascade semantics, which can help to reduce the search space. Despite their
usefulness, catalogs are hard to be extracted without the assist from external
knowledge. For documents that adhere to a specific template, regular
expressions are practical to extract catalogs. However, handcrafted heuristics
are not applicable when processing documents from different sources with
diverse formats. To address this problem, we build a large manually annotated
corpus, which is the first dataset for the Catalog Extraction from Documents
(CED) task. Based on this corpus, we propose a transition-based framework for
parsing documents into catalog trees. The experimental results demonstrate that
our proposed method outperforms baseline systems and shows a good ability to
transfer. We believe the CED task could fill the gap between raw text segments
and information extraction tasks on extremely long documents. Data and code are
available at \url{https://github.com/Spico197/CatalogExtraction} | [
0.0320371315,
0.0590556674,
0.001605432,
0.0156767182,
-0.0507742278,
0.0189025961,
-0.0183662716,
-0.0189760663,
-0.0145959202,
-0.0651874989,
-0.00104135,
0.0360477492,
-0.0210969876,
0.0174642708,
-0.0236191079,
-0.0506943949,
0.0079393033,
-0.0349051245,
0.040966969,
0.0432097986,
0.0492389761,
0.0220470224,
0.006975132,
-0.0232478697,
-0.0006390839,
-0.0324572213,
-0.030003719,
0.0192652363,
0.0134105049,
-0.0480357036,
0.0207586084,
-0.0188045613,
0.0048165889,
0.0002926976,
0.0000017378,
-0.0632220581,
-0.1005212739,
0.0137847522,
-0.0114643862,
-0.0397286937,
0.0828963146,
-0.0536236651,
0.0037776178,
-0.0150571782,
0.0055859433,
-0.0366908535,
0.0130926631,
0.0539502576,
0.0219974499,
0.0911380202,
-0.0410781838,
-0.0497451797,
0.0223014895,
0.0174802318,
0.0170710441,
-0.0269265175,
0.0478983112,
-0.0083637759,
0.0125693902,
0.0053112232,
0.0058466089,
-0.0019409996,
-0.0319160111,
-0.0373312905,
0.0349489562,
0.0067405915,
-0.0162779782,
-0.0311620981,
-0.0205821376,
0.077908352,
0.0004515222,
-0.0029572877,
0.0635233968,
-0.0085138809,
-0.0034863767,
-0.055714529,
-0.0529347882,
0.0309573133,
-0.0317758024,
0.0016636259,
0.0263169091,
0.0056260787,
-0.0097643305,
-0.0094389329,
-0.0136844078,
0.0729297623,
0.0007330336,
-0.0552429892,
0.037659198,
0.0014067901,
0.0309113581,
-0.0493463352,
0.0267503597,
0.0097605595,
0.0134946285,
0.0188461002,
-0.0345632322,
-0.0599984974,
0.0048842733,
-0.0091901552,
-0.0496858917,
-0.0108494749,
-0.0083639612,
0.0563466512,
-0.0137662375,
-0.0092439903,
0.0265316479,
-0.0021763057,
-0.0539434329,
-0.0012246796,
-0.0525546037,
-0.0055298852,
-0.0746501833,
0.041784171,
-0.011385208,
-0.0251237527,
-0.0042976728,
-0.0187555235,
0.0134267202,
0.014386408,
-0.0088998005,
-0.0044312114,
-0.0208471566,
0.0030721093,
0.0223179478,
0.0005887416,
-0.0150882704,
-0.0069208029,
0.0072409208,
0.0415125303,
-0.0026079644,
0.0382240228,
0.0550518185,
-0.0217170138,
0.0126409288,
-0.0127427187,
-0.0038813041,
-0.0407576337,
-0.0152777713,
-0.0189498402,
0.0036432031,
-0.0445571132,
0.0098998761,
-0.0565070137,
0.0521909855,
0.0020351759,
0.0002786628,
0.0163297597,
-0.0079824105,
0.00336145,
-0.0005303649,
0.0503328256,
-0.039902579,
0.0000800876,
0.0278962981,
-0.01470422,
0.0198916681,
0.0248834789,
0.0455349274,
0.0493236892,
0.0645613447,
-0.0080361273,
0.0230746847,
0.0484118499,
-0.0498819537,
-0.0748579279,
0.0217278078,
0.0400954932,
-0.0238246787,
0.0086127929,
0.001635095,
0.0216475874,
-0.0337946638,
0.0321664289,
-0.0096270451,
0.0519805178,
-0.0115645975,
-0.0053100106,
0.0192764681,
0.0474767163,
0.0091605885,
-0.0165878721,
-0.0013390466,
-0.0659843981,
0.0104818968,
0.0017066628,
-0.0753588006,
-0.0141597223,
0.014334755,
0.0024964483,
-0.0139963385,
-0.013445979,
0.0283967312,
-0.0248423051,
0.0620974787,
0.0248648245,
0.0055650487,
0.0358208418,
-0.0201373305,
-0.0695017651,
-0.0118347388,
0.0324014835,
-0.0067499494,
0.043220222,
0.0372957811,
-0.0685360655,
0.0136506418,
0.0181752294,
0.0378494039,
0.0432330556,
0.0253525022,
-0.0626981482,
0.0265397485,
-0.0356080756,
-0.0226771235,
-0.0025249494,
-0.0017833305,
-0.0081068305,
-0.0301222093,
-0.0089098066,
0.0247074049,
-0.0364041999,
0.0012790497,
0.0791735351,
-0.0324627943,
-0.0496485345,
0.0121470531,
-0.0065556969,
-0.013650558,
-0.0111213997,
-0.0010490299,
-0.0068557053,
0.0534590781,
-0.0151834218,
-0.0227598809,
-0.0061044833,
-0.042029459,
-0.0136870947,
0.0423317291,
-0.0160583053,
0.0010311041,
-0.0002723455,
-0.0446118712,
-0.0362783,
-0.0109745413,
0.0217339396,
0.0228382181,
0.0140216136,
0.0261936318,
0.0125935357,
0.0095861284,
-0.0444790795,
0.0690645501,
0.0755768493,
-0.0228327643,
-0.0229451079,
-0.0697007775,
-0.0018543336,
-0.0075189602,
0.0326532722,
0.0333845504,
-0.0409613922,
-0.0200489964,
0.0410165004,
0.0078251045,
-0.0646520257,
0.0115539888,
-0.1164034978,
0.0231590178,
0.00401633,
0.073644802,
0.0056929607,
0.0068962062,
-0.0438431427,
0.0015739239,
-0.0486117378,
0.0397086628,
-0.0281247832,
-0.0287439153,
0.0669694915,
-0.0069474005,
-0.033652287,
-0.011373423,
-0.0091360509,
-0.0159895383,
0.0117286146,
0.0289084315,
-0.0691818893,
-0.0352837704,
-0.016898986,
0.0290886667,
0.0352671221,
0.0014311823,
0.0511766076,
-0.0299329646,
-0.0487140566,
0.0335956961,
0.048322618,
0.0027624092,
0.0018469499,
0.0101448558,
-0.0215634909,
-0.028402647,
0.0095539754,
-0.0168960933,
0.0986733139,
-0.0211587269,
-0.0042128046,
0.0697782338,
0.0149675794,
-0.0307125412,
0.0145433778,
0.0522730686,
-0.0567821786,
-0.0065505258,
-0.0285971425,
-0.0119746299,
-0.0274128485,
0.0073926873,
0.0253843162,
0.0009189064,
0.001507499,
0.0362703204,
-0.0424541906,
-0.0330956243,
-0.0560449436,
-0.0043734307,
-0.0817669407,
0.0669620708,
0.0303090438,
-0.0091861971,
0.061575748,
-0.0341277458,
0.0200052038,
0.0156170707,
0.0098382644,
0.0063459682,
-0.0023264631,
-0.0275306907,
0.0602244139,
-0.0554015227,
-0.0377216712,
-0.0052745393,
-0.0190193802,
0.0185680296,
-0.012964637,
0.0453680567,
0.0066875056,
-0.0365769491,
0.01693286,
-0.000016383,
0.1052339897,
-0.0163280629,
-0.0478317663,
0.0136624416,
0.057969369,
0.0391067825,
-0.0203988887,
0.013157649,
-0.0117947599,
0.0388997942,
0.0725958869,
0.0543427691,
0.0017140871,
-0.0272893347,
-0.0166093763,
-0.0052662017,
-0.0812107772,
0.0382509716,
-0.0251913536,
-0.0100841587,
-0.0810642987,
-0.0399932452,
0.0844892263,
0.0420706011,
-0.0768869147,
-0.0190423243,
-0.0088626519,
0.0043242229,
-0.000717993,
0.0059709428,
-0.0596876033,
-0.0325058438,
0.0412455723,
0.0353939682,
-0.0043703159,
-0.0388275236,
-0.0053924378,
-0.0676371381,
0.023515828,
-0.006331733,
-0.0449032336,
0.0231121294,
-0.0631324127,
-0.009340276,
0.0010519846,
-0.0200360324,
0.028607022,
-0.0606789067,
-0.0262221266,
-0.0044513457,
-0.0603563935,
-0.0129392492,
0.0219748802,
0.0358311236,
-0.0487421602,
0.0240556598,
0.0451592803,
-0.010063122,
0.045205716,
0.0969071016,
-0.0453127287,
-0.0623775423,
-0.0064520868,
0.0367435589,
-0.0475755408,
0.0349951796,
0.0090532806,
0.0257312506,
-0.056034606,
0.0091696102,
0.0837643147,
0.0353222601,
0.0178038105,
-0.0449930392,
-0.0357343256,
-0.0669797286,
-0.0109546082,
0.0362319313,
-0.0315145589,
-0.0339458771,
-0.0534829758,
-0.033777371,
-0.0152754774,
-0.0244540479,
0.0180252288,
0.0103804553,
-0.0324370377,
-0.0562751144,
-0.1065787002,
-0.0232348572,
0.0212037768,
0.0483793914,
-0.0109871635,
-0.0420634411,
-0.0236835796,
0.0237221923,
-0.0295380242,
0.020617988,
-0.0375118218,
-0.0055701034,
-0.039073538,
0.0489637777,
-0.0003459333,
-0.0124937752,
-0.0246525742,
0.0131240673,
-0.064793393,
-0.0242989082,
0.0062583941,
-0.017125288,
0.0094019305,
0.0446324199,
-0.0188407339,
0.0046466859,
0.0140755586,
0.0693171546,
-0.0698712692,
-0.050378304,
0.0256645456,
-0.0160075724,
-0.0182487853,
0.0218836255,
-0.046954181,
0.0583605841,
-0.0236758385,
0.0534997061,
0.0397889689,
-0.0070411987,
0.0425197035,
0.0786215067,
0.0360167064,
0.0032423362,
0.017672915,
-0.0129723409,
0.0388364159,
-0.0299806409,
-0.056459859,
-0.0196253918,
0.04991813,
0.017749479,
0.0168160126,
0.0171063673,
0.043762546,
0.0312249418,
0.0097344341,
-0.0195560642,
0.0145011125,
0.0339035243,
0.0525357947,
-0.0039515765,
-0.03383293,
-0.0011984364,
-0.0105393082,
-0.0099145258,
0.0382045656,
-0.0423072018,
0.0156099722,
0.0334732309,
-0.002920636,
-0.0434543453,
0.008172743,
-0.0311910827,
0.0264413822,
-0.0607440323,
-0.004862098,
0.0219578743,
-0.006326721,
0.0478679426,
-0.0530714206,
-0.0264382716,
-0.021318987,
0.0081160888,
0.0218014158,
-0.0109398244,
-0.0361702554,
0.0298684835,
-0.046048563,
0.0010832249,
0.0249953754,
0.0454392172,
-0.0084614307,
0.0348261707,
-0.0318934619,
-0.0632290989,
0.0052391593,
-0.007209545,
0.0057883849,
-0.0044084755,
-0.0130965048,
-0.0065879729,
0.0157626569,
0.0357826017,
-0.0177610796,
0.0284672398,
0.0215300247,
0.04182823,
0.0869509727,
0.0147006176,
-0.0169437453,
-0.0240636207,
0.0476300567,
-0.0179693159,
-0.0171674415,
0.01067317,
-5.463063343e-33,
0.0126253013,
-0.0173798557,
-0.0181458648,
0.027140636,
-0.0128723085,
-0.0328903459,
-0.016679978,
-0.0315714665,
0.0413261913,
0.008180229,
-0.0153965643,
-0.0048419312,
0.0315182358,
0.0434289798,
0.0213146191,
-0.0016622916,
0.010027308,
0.0031708477,
-0.0704290345,
0.0111642303,
0.0404904708,
0.0523887686,
0.0604850613,
-0.0469789356,
0.0423845537,
-0.0177199226,
-0.0227670725,
0.005323187,
0.0540818684,
0.0416389778,
-0.0096681258,
0.0358425453,
0.0192640387,
-0.0082034916,
0.0028665029,
0.04229616,
-0.1091798693,
0.0220155399,
-0.0490344092,
-0.0026190905,
0.0055697421,
0.0003215873,
0.0307207778,
-0.0091557149,
0.0244145282,
0.006949292,
0.0496397167,
-0.0397614054,
0.0060567381,
-0.0649826303,
-0.0706621557,
0.029609412,
-0.0020588208,
0.0319321491,
0.101831913,
0.0621704459,
-0.0017204776,
0.0813895091,
0.0059379418,
-0.0290772822,
-0.0557368994,
0.0363461301,
0.0349616334,
-0.0038272187,
0.0151655357,
0.0176730379,
0.0130070057,
-0.0168653261,
0.0210878979,
0.0369105823,
0.0093875378,
0.0377542637,
-0.0097206505,
-0.0078846011,
0.0529959127,
0.0166626368,
-0.066114068,
0.0425122939,
0.0137327239,
0.0186088085,
-0.0355644263,
0.0350012593,
-0.0253313687,
0.0135921398,
0.0346240066,
0.0078084385,
0.001611894,
0.0483389013,
0.0230900254,
0.0438386388,
-0.0366452187,
0.0016627486,
0.0088895103,
0.0155436201,
-0.0784966871,
0.0339591354,
-0.0182076879,
0.0357718654,
-0.017286066,
-0.0252593718,
-0.0483548343,
-0.0415021032,
0.0061179898,
0.0072681229,
0.0008482347,
-0.0261249375,
0.0310820732,
0.0145858964,
-0.0587371998,
0.0031480324,
0.021951098,
0.0003690849,
-0.0323300064,
0.0859354287,
-0.0078298757,
0.0028435658,
-0.0064032404,
0.06416969,
0.0229889844,
0.0027926348,
-0.0175197683,
-0.0096040554,
0.0055056605,
0.0031292697,
0.0105142612,
-0.0079176463,
0.0091068605,
-0.0075937915,
0.038415499,
-0.0540534258,
0.0166523773,
0.0236660298,
2.468e-7,
0.0416695774,
0.0523369983,
0.078824088,
-0.0102714952,
0.0342599526,
0.0347615369,
-0.0139619121,
0.0345745049,
-0.0344680957,
-0.0409326889,
0.0211358368,
-0.0441581197,
0.057849586,
0.0263316333,
-0.1266254634,
-0.0026297334,
-0.0109886909,
-0.0499555357,
-0.0688601062,
-0.0049789012,
0.0399526842,
0.045944497,
0.0021068351,
-0.0070152627,
-0.0194921084,
-0.0447928421,
-0.0045185382,
0.0012442957,
0.0365320593,
0.0301721245,
0.0362862386,
-0.0216432903,
-0.0385246426,
-0.0054481099,
0.0174245909,
0.0944240987,
0.0370628349,
0.0827381983,
-0.0116102071,
0.0567411259,
0.0097997012,
-0.0406109542,
0.0213020351,
0.0140693057,
0.0497803725,
-0.0450281464,
0.0194073282,
-0.0539559126,
-0.0564556047,
0.0066594421,
-0.0479382016,
-0.0142261079,
-0.0065849656,
0.0461669788,
0.0265629049,
-0.0198078398,
-0.0279473588,
-0.0883505344,
0.004231716,
0.0281342752,
-0.0214851275,
0.015897546,
-0.0033871948,
0.0768183544,
-0.0354523882,
-0.0395924971,
-0.0041985163,
2.383140538e-34,
0.0137448655,
-0.019012697,
-0.0545622259,
0.0110974265,
0.0296543371,
-0.0411049463,
-0.0228676684,
0.0075346385,
-0.0392122604,
-0.0807720572,
0.0070524998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14599v1 | Antisemitic Messages? A Guide to High-Quality Annotation and a Labeled Dataset of Tweets | 2023-04-28T02:52:38 | 2023-04-28T02:52:38 | Gunther Jikeli, Sameer Karali, Daniel Miehling, Katharina Soemer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | One of the major challenges in automatic hate speech detection is the lack of
datasets that cover a wide range of biased and unbiased messages and that are
consistently labeled. We propose a labeling procedure that addresses some of
the common weaknesses of labeled datasets. We focus on antisemitic speech on
Twitter and create a labeled dataset of 6,941 tweets that cover a wide range of
topics common in conversations about Jews, Israel, and antisemitism between
January 2019 and December 2021 by drawing from representative samples with
relevant keywords. Our annotation process aims to strictly apply a commonly
used definition of antisemitism by forcing annotators to specify which part of
the definition applies, and by giving them the option to personally disagree
with the definition on a case-by-case basis. Labeling tweets that call out
antisemitism, report antisemitism, or are otherwise related to antisemitism
(such as the Holocaust) but are not actually antisemitic can help reduce false
positives in automated detection. The dataset includes 1,250 tweets (18%) that
are antisemitic according to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance
(IHRA) definition of antisemitism. It is important to note, however, that the
dataset is not comprehensive. Many topics are still not covered, and it only
includes tweets collected from Twitter between January 2019 and December 2021.
Additionally, the dataset only includes tweets that were written in English.
Despite these limitations, we hope that this is a meaningful contribution to
improving the automated detection of antisemitic speech. | [
0.0521957651,
0.034156546,
0.0090745231,
0.0260001905,
-0.0062777437,
0.0792746991,
0.045069389,
0.0115144132,
0.0239793025,
-0.0718550459,
0.0236760676,
-0.0048412113,
-0.0334126353,
0.0010523073,
-0.0248134322,
-0.0160470642,
0.0307675079,
0.051593747,
0.0693366081,
-0.0353468731,
0.0631123632,
0.0351290815,
-0.0236585718,
0.0338874497,
-0.0674963593,
0.0106306132,
0.0592737906,
-0.0141468104,
0.0564055219,
-0.0142046651,
0.0212904047,
0.015861664,
-0.0169048198,
0.0498141646,
0.0000019619,
-0.0126712685,
-0.0161048453,
-0.0222328026,
-0.0100731328,
-0.0392881148,
0.0519690886,
-0.0757347792,
-0.0209178943,
0.0381409302,
-0.0385287553,
0.0088763107,
0.0936986133,
0.0234834086,
0.0775922239,
0.0560618453,
-0.0229068622,
0.0058655515,
0.003460703,
0.0491778068,
-0.0198296569,
0.0223960876,
0.042539373,
-0.0301454384,
-0.1009003818,
0.0021684936,
0.0090816552,
0.0456281863,
0.0235146955,
0.0372488387,
-0.0000119668,
-0.0566230714,
-0.0492707416,
-0.0412478819,
0.0416909121,
0.0034382136,
0.0110121537,
-0.0143347783,
0.0473641455,
0.0011618008,
-0.0406812616,
-0.0159965213,
0.0145565281,
0.0199498441,
-0.0335047692,
0.0037877476,
-0.0080560632,
-0.0007412422,
0.0504993461,
0.0688354373,
0.0253642537,
0.0256880596,
-0.0100825224,
-0.0060589556,
0.0210991763,
-0.0201031696,
-0.0266400594,
-0.0157267414,
0.03133424,
0.000901803,
0.0175962653,
0.0182219222,
-0.048986733,
-0.0806068629,
0.018841939,
-0.051683709,
-0.0287711509,
0.0440842733,
-0.0229381043,
0.0137792695,
0.0287526138,
-0.0227999166,
0.0429246388,
-0.0139638754,
0.0116794733,
-0.0049988334,
-0.0116019687,
0.0149531718,
0.0087505709,
0.0103702536,
0.0141686844,
0.0423259586,
-0.0584489852,
-0.0163114481,
-0.0183054935,
-0.0057442612,
-0.039752733,
-0.0455533117,
0.0057104141,
0.0096543245,
-0.0138583574,
0.0312158056,
-0.0734123141,
0.012192647,
-0.0633965209,
-0.037025176,
0.0202289503,
0.045899231,
-0.0080111809,
-0.0028874201,
0.0171275493,
0.0462633558,
0.0274789799,
-0.038319245,
-0.0244136266,
-0.0352305546,
-0.0413163938,
-0.0121344319,
0.0198968034,
-0.0591572188,
0.0403395556,
0.010078744,
-0.0410494395,
-0.0453282781,
-0.0057042204,
0.0069752941,
-0.0105310492,
0.061139036,
-0.011488067,
-0.0136665907,
0.0762504712,
0.0310631953,
0.0214399621,
0.0354090557,
0.0065645385,
0.0380173922,
0.0449190997,
0.0224628616,
0.0294595119,
0.0402252972,
0.0488718562,
0.0557366759,
-0.0288797375,
-0.0005118361,
-0.0583500341,
-0.0415122882,
-0.0064697419,
0.0335609578,
-0.0162970889,
-0.072977908,
0.0231959037,
0.0577837043,
-0.0553238839,
-0.0017231767,
-0.0093690893,
0.0447079875,
0.0241983514,
-0.044444561,
-0.0358872265,
0.0139345741,
-0.0241641421,
-0.0479770415,
0.005542899,
0.0357195176,
-0.0070446949,
-0.0583720878,
-0.0314065889,
-0.0031473315,
0.0440637171,
-0.0473102964,
0.022094192,
-0.0127661861,
-0.0212273039,
0.0337432735,
0.0398254134,
0.0065354723,
0.0139615862,
-0.0465001315,
-0.0171629228,
0.01327061,
-0.0084937559,
-0.0281698704,
-0.0295406617,
-0.0583495907,
0.0299647562,
0.0764915943,
0.0119547686,
-0.006322104,
-0.0417788774,
0.0011213758,
-0.0018288868,
0.0157009307,
-0.0019644808,
0.0526368022,
0.0541284159,
0.027540734,
0.0178496186,
0.011775759,
-0.0005314252,
-0.0020810347,
0.0268439539,
-0.033927463,
-0.0017727021,
0.0054845535,
0.0223260317,
0.0415812396,
-0.0083861779,
-0.0511132963,
0.001917186,
0.0191967692,
-0.0407401174,
-0.0069335187,
-0.0208744723,
0.0359168425,
-0.013316839,
-0.0651214421,
-0.052969221,
0.0702170357,
-0.0358388461,
0.0209241137,
0.050064642,
-0.011263798,
-0.0252683684,
-0.0391304903,
-0.0108215315,
-0.0472197011,
0.0181753747,
-0.0227000639,
0.0600371026,
0.013891221,
-0.0120032374,
0.0282565355,
-0.0772338435,
0.0557857491,
0.0713711455,
-0.0462794863,
0.0057956027,
-0.0404421911,
0.011520084,
0.0159929711,
-0.0430225655,
-0.0344553329,
0.0549770668,
-0.0667707548,
-0.0298019014,
0.0006693571,
-0.0096025662,
0.0021877878,
0.0157122239,
0.0085597103,
0.0106902132,
0.0113815116,
-0.0130791496,
0.0260545425,
0.0388879441,
0.0253092833,
-0.0656465739,
-0.0073095793,
-0.0739268437,
0.0179600529,
-0.0635463819,
-0.0054399325,
0.0439294837,
-0.0590623505,
0.0369690582,
-0.0219320711,
-0.0610458739,
0.0061042667,
-0.0065715429,
-0.0358186364,
0.0339217335,
0.0425962843,
-0.048424162,
0.0137305371,
0.0393396541,
0.0535336658,
0.0229945965,
0.0044732895,
-0.0220777784,
-0.0090585342,
-0.0088014556,
0.0327656865,
-0.0069857645,
-0.0034609344,
-0.0105119599,
0.0824623331,
0.04209584,
0.0018981092,
-0.0368271731,
0.0217149071,
-0.0927141234,
-0.0180624798,
-0.0341061354,
-0.0620891824,
-0.0183823574,
0.0006572607,
-0.0397785269,
-0.0268240925,
0.0484537408,
0.0146790463,
0.0333086103,
-0.0116849793,
-0.0451464728,
0.0308553688,
0.0722224563,
0.0008181053,
0.0326528028,
-0.0361980498,
0.0055413228,
-0.0021917096,
-0.0405716598,
0.0153425867,
-0.0203307904,
-0.0237080287,
0.0065588364,
0.0146774678,
-0.0149343582,
-0.0251710527,
-0.0534936748,
-0.0517258644,
-0.0576834902,
-0.0647987202,
-0.002003517,
0.009238163,
-0.0106941536,
0.0255763438,
-0.008326157,
-0.0068278131,
0.0481225699,
0.0030631875,
0.020677777,
-0.0540869981,
-0.0196289215,
-0.0728386343,
0.0261350628,
0.0239806846,
-0.0127433473,
0.0578804277,
-0.0258948039,
0.0301287472,
-0.0015566366,
-0.015583911,
0.0209081564,
-0.0350945629,
0.0005023387,
-0.0522636212,
0.0104160309,
-0.006710391,
0.0434630401,
0.0973570868,
0.0228708535,
-0.0230079219,
-0.0083007002,
0.0264633764,
-0.015022805,
0.0008269784,
-0.0216679815,
-0.1519617438,
0.0061599729,
-0.0171931833,
0.0135991545,
-0.1159960032,
-0.0452832095,
0.0095451344,
-0.0250639636,
-0.0197986271,
0.0151375281,
-0.0062143714,
-0.0238937624,
-0.0185670611,
-0.0046351715,
0.0132758897,
0.0127082495,
-0.0379572585,
0.0479001999,
0.0126251811,
0.0136982324,
-0.1027313173,
-0.0038366411,
0.0284066349,
-0.0271259621,
0.0542536564,
0.0005878261,
0.0568456613,
0.0056019644,
0.0255116541,
0.0446108803,
0.0053583262,
-0.061989788,
-0.0583662465,
0.0410626195,
-0.0081808865,
-0.0480258204,
0.0087312814,
0.0152731333,
0.0167821031,
-0.0158788152,
0.0155485412,
0.0128341988,
0.014165706,
0.0422652476,
-0.0165374689,
0.0549561083,
0.0009573125,
0.0621801987,
0.0153766656,
0.0054528047,
0.0445590243,
-0.0652164593,
0.0108427117,
-0.0424583852,
-0.0542202741,
-0.0003837416,
-0.0141012724,
-0.0643923655,
-0.0503915586,
-0.0350849889,
0.0162815489,
-0.0018254027,
0.0182422306,
-0.0286955535,
-0.0329256654,
0.0237558056,
-0.0698031411,
-0.0166335255,
0.0175168049,
0.0387039296,
0.0347368605,
-0.0127890166,
-0.0248652678,
-0.0101206405,
-0.0108262626,
0.0652788877,
-0.0275228787,
-0.0340043828,
0.10488832,
0.0140407942,
0.0192788057,
0.0164870601,
-0.0160951857,
-0.0276631992,
0.0224856138,
0.0589918792,
-0.018842401,
-0.03126074,
0.0636477321,
0.0011206697,
0.0221749209,
-0.0141721973,
-0.011387472,
0.0760145858,
0.0517120436,
-0.0665373579,
-0.0725838169,
0.0093045393,
-0.0111999121,
-0.0095769893,
0.0653527752,
0.0132803461,
-0.0599031039,
-0.0197388958,
-0.0275481753,
0.004989258,
-0.0437452234,
-0.0127858426,
0.0163236484,
0.0066582728,
-0.0062745684,
-0.0685610846,
0.0353097431,
-0.0341123827,
0.0125045264,
0.0050570923,
0.0361030102,
-0.0047952649,
0.0481072441,
-0.0286731161,
-0.0280647222,
-0.0120558683,
0.0238698088,
0.0210873596,
-0.039079681,
-0.0058932528,
-0.0073828325,
-0.0051488318,
-0.0042909724,
0.0622342676,
-0.0304363053,
0.0047066566,
0.000294096,
-0.0509783141,
-0.0007586685,
-0.0231980029,
-0.0026234209,
0.0579379238,
0.007191842,
-0.0339413099,
-0.0054782806,
0.002594905,
-0.0233227257,
-0.0224379916,
0.02163326,
0.0025273012,
-0.0322449841,
-0.0027550622,
-0.0029594786,
0.0009046352,
0.0726889819,
0.0504259653,
-0.0532504916,
-0.0060180025,
0.000748229,
0.0096200099,
0.0079504894,
0.0175613202,
0.0028340209,
-0.0501065403,
-0.008043767,
0.0104179783,
-0.0528827533,
0.0141373305,
-0.004155667,
0.0007897163,
0.0634957999,
0.0083298227,
0.0294668619,
-0.0260320306,
0.0211364869,
0.0244245827,
-0.0590422042,
0.0095338477,
-5.953324935e-33,
-0.0151872998,
-0.0220557284,
0.0021957839,
0.0404093638,
-0.0144209573,
-0.0156209199,
0.0390102006,
0.0153945284,
-0.0437710732,
0.0184673015,
0.0093444893,
0.0626855493,
0.011105842,
0.0066125365,
-0.0055096592,
-0.044582434,
0.0380020253,
-0.0025028782,
-0.0398135968,
-0.0231339261,
0.012937163,
0.0124941496,
0.0431311727,
-0.0545784235,
0.035430029,
-0.0251263361,
-0.0393251926,
0.0101490673,
0.0667732731,
0.0301868506,
-0.01633339,
0.074381493,
0.0473781638,
-0.0337861143,
0.0407564119,
0.0520844609,
-0.0170218926,
-0.0035849588,
0.0336795263,
0.0168992691,
-0.0143581172,
-0.0137606328,
0.0113278683,
0.0035698654,
-0.0744133815,
-0.0050469674,
0.0626542792,
-0.036165867,
0.01689809,
-0.02169507,
-0.0786937922,
0.0443835817,
-0.0404876061,
-0.0013078452,
0.0110103842,
0.0506542511,
0.0924804881,
0.0345722958,
-0.0701510161,
0.0095451111,
-0.0405663438,
-0.0102226837,
-0.0128209228,
0.0091918921,
-0.0114923641,
0.0470332056,
0.0075043566,
0.0361609943,
0.0210959334,
0.0196116101,
0.0014928909,
-0.0151480837,
0.0244679246,
0.0796016678,
0.0064464826,
-0.0719926059,
-0.0445846803,
-0.0138910869,
0.0490123481,
-0.0098184338,
-0.0424233899,
-0.0458955169,
-0.0310388207,
-0.0106304027,
-0.0278981887,
-0.0625701174,
-0.0449520946,
0.0043925168,
0.0106290812,
0.0026643525,
-0.0544947013,
0.0544850454,
0.00259129,
-0.0112274112,
0.0463686325,
0.0463377796,
-0.0232066102,
-0.015042156,
-0.0005249954,
0.0514029451,
-0.0210698415,
-0.0586760193,
-0.0329023339,
-0.0004320095,
0.049767796,
-0.0136174262,
0.0675416887,
0.030860249,
-0.0553812124,
0.005478086,
0.0079301996,
0.0227405876,
-0.0536027253,
-0.0191076826,
-0.0134404358,
0.0488052182,
0.0019332103,
-0.0132451607,
0.0424476303,
-0.0443008579,
-0.0019538386,
-0.0203926396,
-0.0458129384,
0.0121521614,
-0.018359568,
-0.0427852906,
0.0379830562,
0.0026614405,
0.0184590872,
-0.1128674895,
0.0244610831,
-0.0619758889,
2.633e-7,
0.0177552626,
0.035549365,
-0.0245984122,
-0.0141233858,
0.0107888179,
0.0144885313,
0.0770891458,
-0.0015428779,
-0.0229593515,
0.0014195123,
-0.0178787839,
0.0246082358,
0.0621381365,
0.0205950327,
-0.0026689877,
-0.0263986792,
-0.0444385298,
0.0145610487,
-0.0766081065,
0.0481243059,
0.0013793965,
0.0693736821,
0.1023288593,
-0.0176383387,
-0.0419748612,
-0.0027469143,
-0.0099920174,
-0.0244152006,
-0.0303680226,
-0.0025909431,
0.0514485203,
0.0046480098,
0.0301011279,
-0.0074867988,
-0.0399379693,
-0.004493732,
0.0511386767,
0.0452104434,
0.0262798201,
0.0282910205,
-0.0220225733,
0.0054627294,
-0.0137673663,
-0.0059707207,
0.0366396978,
-0.0105334166,
-0.0101312203,
-0.0257221106,
-0.0344065651,
-0.0127740465,
0.0434478708,
0.0072614322,
-0.0288242549,
-0.0153212436,
0.0242311042,
0.0221838113,
0.0072202296,
-0.0666749775,
0.0178089309,
-0.0089864852,
0.0066668093,
-0.0347229205,
0.0064157415,
-0.0598978102,
-0.0029013252,
0.0363881513,
0.032640934,
2.024422596e-34,
0.038847737,
-0.0261383317,
-0.0095849857,
-0.0597397275,
0.0323117599,
0.0232678186,
-0.0079358136,
0.0205486752,
-0.0072392323,
0.0179294739,
0.0182909369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14590v2 | A logical word embedding for learning grammar | 2023-04-28T01:53:54 | 2023-06-06T00:46:49 | Sean Deyo, Veit Elser | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the logical grammar emdebbing (LGE), a model inspired by
pregroup grammars and categorial grammars to enable unsupervised inference of
lexical categories and syntactic rules from a corpus of text. LGE produces
comprehensible output summarizing its inferences, has a completely transparent
process for producing novel sentences, and can learn from as few as a hundred
sentences. | [
-0.0001709264,
0.0715172812,
-0.0138793448,
0.0428228378,
-0.0271886103,
0.0366646685,
0.0037409493,
-0.0374241583,
0.0344941206,
-0.0386943892,
0.0104538472,
0.0006353635,
-0.0248051081,
0.035179846,
0.0652738735,
-0.0221934449,
0.0894514769,
0.0145416232,
0.003301261,
0.007639227,
0.0346805118,
0.0420388542,
-0.0192581005,
0.0152317127,
-0.0666740909,
-0.0017804016,
-0.0123179676,
-0.071056731,
-0.01679237,
0.0131372483,
0.0183592271,
0.0194721241,
0.0383118987,
0.0313693658,
0.0000015454,
-0.0509703346,
-0.0051368726,
-0.0452575199,
0.0157452207,
-0.0192119572,
0.0608987249,
-0.0126883648,
-0.0227899067,
0.0033786402,
-0.0550294966,
-0.039243415,
0.0568120219,
0.0033500567,
0.0664526224,
0.0726617649,
-0.0237263199,
-0.0706416368,
-0.0100350343,
-0.004961492,
-0.0387781821,
0.039316684,
0.0137438616,
-0.0093043307,
-0.0335651785,
-0.0883464441,
-0.0039613596,
-0.0199888591,
0.0218860824,
-0.0323048271,
0.0136431893,
0.0114597986,
-0.0401094668,
-0.018647531,
0.0020593044,
0.0364844091,
-0.0401277281,
-0.0389755592,
0.0057318062,
0.0252869725,
0.0119992029,
0.0016672672,
-0.0149988346,
0.0500098802,
0.0144390929,
0.0630980507,
0.1258561313,
-0.0188011248,
0.0099584004,
-0.0209576339,
-0.0351481251,
0.0837281793,
0.0260734688,
-0.0021319527,
-0.0123665202,
0.0381253846,
-0.0459690243,
-0.0409579687,
0.0056639845,
-0.0040720035,
-0.0353009067,
0.0071455021,
-0.0565900244,
-0.0031143662,
-0.0152383195,
-0.0613532066,
0.0499707125,
0.0112846503,
0.0488611124,
0.0592391528,
-0.0605507344,
-0.0641850084,
0.029641971,
0.031520512,
-0.064408794,
0.0053474531,
-0.0352149047,
-0.0108546782,
-0.0636954904,
0.0343091339,
-0.0070741512,
-0.014775008,
-0.0251364559,
0.0077897175,
0.0247232188,
0.0066554248,
-0.0004359024,
-0.0161047243,
-0.0337452255,
-0.0239885002,
-0.0004457749,
-0.0461704843,
-0.0472783819,
0.0051503028,
0.0238947161,
-0.0161008798,
-0.0412037522,
-0.0062977304,
0.0479566194,
0.0086214021,
-0.0246614777,
0.0604502186,
0.0043504597,
-0.010898984,
-0.0639588907,
-0.0498214513,
0.0080063129,
0.007188376,
0.0261352919,
-0.0459765643,
-0.0060600378,
-0.0057021901,
-0.0234185122,
-0.0050447471,
-0.0093255853,
0.0043308968,
0.0167676099,
0.0318658836,
-0.0365598761,
-0.0184965637,
-0.0181839298,
-0.0295128096,
0.0199558418,
0.0562605411,
0.0129205659,
-0.0187838934,
0.0163803659,
-0.0120070213,
0.0053537441,
0.0004997031,
-0.026710283,
-0.0445507504,
-0.0206090864,
-0.0199424326,
-0.0223573223,
0.0270087551,
0.0362186171,
0.0350934863,
-0.0195342936,
0.0183486752,
-0.0063470039,
0.0513257422,
0.0742004439,
0.056815695,
0.0661803856,
-0.0045242799,
-0.0254861601,
0.0241603814,
0.0047088135,
-0.0004192177,
-0.032460168,
-0.0014322319,
-0.0788492486,
0.0098152906,
-0.0066093253,
-0.0501081347,
-0.0123582464,
-0.0399280861,
0.0279972423,
-0.0489104986,
0.035496626,
0.0982166752,
0.0068179513,
0.0530362874,
0.0739094689,
-0.0563765317,
-0.0002342819,
-0.003397889,
0.0668797195,
0.0154200811,
0.0457538627,
-0.0394143909,
-0.0090261698,
-0.0169423725,
0.027463831,
0.035862539,
0.0260547232,
-0.0401673913,
0.0026459894,
-0.0329359807,
0.0169715751,
0.0015237188,
0.0572839975,
-0.0207449682,
-0.0176637955,
-0.0003448493,
0.0042450335,
0.018247487,
0.0195584465,
0.0682342723,
0.021101743,
-0.0192096382,
-0.0029674252,
0.0115699889,
0.0359175578,
-0.0200835932,
-0.0152724767,
0.0361431018,
0.0199380517,
-0.0481493771,
-0.0361441076,
0.0398629904,
-0.0716002285,
-0.0739311054,
0.0075516785,
-0.0122679006,
-0.0159930959,
-0.0093606645,
-0.0191054381,
0.0040751374,
0.0765787363,
-0.0606744699,
0.082647115,
-0.0644208267,
0.0045967051,
0.0182511192,
-0.0225531403,
-0.015015061,
0.0796240121,
0.0146658206,
0.0389990546,
-0.0346988849,
-0.042993959,
0.0281147733,
0.0069204187,
0.023628315,
-0.0168572403,
-0.0177837852,
-0.0054349834,
-0.0156977549,
0.0158848763,
-0.0242806599,
-0.0141611425,
-0.0371426307,
-0.01477932,
-0.0205798391,
0.0691734478,
0.0367447883,
-0.0151878465,
0.0052858689,
-0.0240851548,
-0.0176030099,
0.0629972816,
0.0100948233,
-0.0134058855,
0.0717319921,
-0.0267879535,
-0.0242174845,
-0.0592155717,
-0.0196531415,
-0.0414463915,
0.0854548216,
0.0176430978,
0.0254073888,
-0.0239261705,
-0.0038940709,
-0.0071144202,
0.0343446918,
0.0402737632,
-0.079671897,
0.0463941246,
-0.0494849943,
0.0036381595,
0.0483049266,
-0.0079540089,
0.0254417472,
0.0439189821,
-0.0326329209,
0.0037349579,
-0.0239369869,
-0.0377268195,
0.0101157976,
-0.0330822431,
0.0387706123,
-0.0144868577,
0.1167056188,
0.0161705315,
-0.0451447144,
-0.0128555782,
0.0629329681,
-0.0246580727,
0.0118446704,
-0.0477962792,
-0.0056824111,
-0.0132955145,
-0.010525954,
-0.0186927859,
-0.0149383303,
0.0720950887,
0.0302868616,
-0.0304622836,
-0.0658551827,
-0.0415481329,
-0.0139000462,
0.0077062938,
0.0314507857,
0.0429580286,
0.0167178363,
-0.033916831,
-0.0542404354,
0.0466484278,
0.0504826568,
0.0022469943,
-0.0312106069,
-0.0436398759,
-0.0224953964,
0.0038726297,
-0.0257641356,
-0.0370373651,
-0.0795156807,
-0.0307986438,
-0.0217616912,
-0.0185740069,
0.0004794654,
-0.0055823307,
-0.0375137702,
-0.0433390513,
0.0044330014,
0.0205633808,
-0.0220793542,
-0.0312087554,
0.0449121483,
0.03446652,
0.0073790215,
-0.0298590139,
0.0234602559,
0.0008105227,
0.0442330241,
-0.0338875093,
0.0473286845,
-0.0401698314,
0.0387604833,
0.0073210113,
-0.0052109733,
-0.0481742024,
0.0057060453,
-0.0157025214,
-0.0246049464,
0.0041888291,
0.096379824,
0.069177188,
0.028313268,
0.0332554877,
0.0001061435,
0.0127357859,
0.0016552813,
0.021407932,
-0.0576420948,
-0.0483950935,
0.009449251,
-0.0421848521,
0.0001020771,
-0.0098751197,
0.0119448733,
-0.0688120052,
0.0122391954,
0.0495567694,
0.0152414972,
0.0372752249,
-0.0178361423,
-0.0250699259,
-0.0164908227,
-0.0608043596,
0.0344173945,
-0.0303278752,
0.016033465,
-0.0244816095,
-0.0506617948,
-0.0091611259,
0.0038523809,
-0.0467023067,
0.0134658981,
0.0702866316,
-0.0066594798,
-0.009764255,
-0.0431562886,
0.0202144608,
-0.0888818949,
-0.0490058437,
-0.001360669,
0.0103707546,
-0.0234303251,
-0.0136256935,
-0.0549486913,
0.0532295555,
-0.067478694,
-0.0043188171,
-0.0096662072,
0.0766152292,
0.0188145582,
-0.038637232,
-0.0218387041,
0.0264625251,
-0.0027064984,
0.0442465581,
0.0318501145,
-0.0306391474,
-0.0337797031,
-0.0834720656,
-0.0101372534,
-0.002070117,
-0.0243624505,
0.0417168327,
-0.0007966331,
-0.0490078665,
-0.0929902494,
-0.0316768214,
0.0585090332,
0.0358402133,
-0.0036665259,
-0.0298093949,
0.0225331094,
-0.041440703,
-0.0408411324,
0.0435933359,
0.0066656671,
0.0035735953,
-0.0063617732,
-0.0164820701,
0.0350705013,
0.0386972204,
-0.0516233072,
-0.0119974464,
0.0363126658,
-0.0753074512,
0.0229303949,
0.0281082895,
0.0137435328,
0.0101657854,
-0.0184725523,
-0.0157745704,
0.0266766939,
0.0222353153,
-0.0127189811,
0.0209374893,
0.0504929684,
-0.0145748612,
0.0135439998,
0.0230650026,
0.0016355485,
0.0426481962,
-0.005958538,
0.0324846879,
-0.0578034967,
0.0137145072,
0.0417130217,
-0.0049242848,
0.0347646587,
-0.0012430671,
0.0290014595,
-0.0582027547,
-0.0479029231,
-0.0425304808,
-0.0019175393,
-0.0570253469,
-0.0096562654,
0.017429186,
-0.0056815282,
-0.0108872587,
0.0076013063,
-0.0374672599,
0.011778065,
0.0091931568,
0.0262197386,
0.0804010928,
-0.0077102366,
-0.0268974937,
-0.008564055,
-0.0160425752,
-0.0463277474,
-0.0530808829,
-0.0066955611,
-0.0450716279,
0.0229427367,
0.0061664605,
-0.0179642364,
-0.040862754,
0.0246749669,
-0.0099239098,
0.0635546967,
-0.0309897158,
0.0042758994,
0.0662896037,
-0.0467920229,
0.0246218406,
-0.0495123714,
0.011164967,
0.0250462946,
0.0973338261,
-0.0159885325,
-0.0627450347,
0.059861131,
0.0093434956,
-0.046520628,
-0.0748430714,
0.0680905432,
0.0201102328,
0.0219591726,
0.0129638463,
0.0127662579,
-0.0508159883,
-0.0053494838,
0.0278738793,
0.0345004387,
0.0062515354,
0.0477427691,
-0.014054209,
-0.035036955,
-0.0408356078,
0.0709869638,
0.0017415233,
0.0054045888,
0.0612316765,
0.0367106907,
0.0063429005,
-0.065772742,
-0.0250040721,
0.0086304825,
-0.0306605026,
-0.0306344368,
-0.0036856709,
-5.661416627e-33,
-0.0432557017,
0.010368322,
-0.0147206215,
0.0238691699,
0.0022190136,
-0.0490933806,
-0.0306098387,
0.0495766848,
0.0218014494,
0.0456147566,
0.0233858954,
0.0337322541,
-0.0031307645,
0.0258161929,
0.0214406755,
0.0209631529,
0.0156725608,
-0.0289782267,
0.0275564026,
-0.0321177617,
-0.0060792151,
0.0491898246,
0.0497530252,
-0.0041427417,
-0.0472286604,
-0.0068349615,
0.0027875155,
0.0329359621,
-0.0109559447,
0.0175752398,
-0.0266797431,
0.0274800919,
-0.0065094302,
0.0616472885,
-0.0226322617,
0.0272282548,
-0.0419086181,
-0.0478857309,
0.0157407969,
0.016494086,
-0.0567307584,
-0.0449677743,
-0.0061262026,
-0.0102504166,
0.0275817588,
0.0073922942,
0.0139469625,
-0.0096628517,
0.0054143723,
0.0267181601,
-0.0787314698,
0.0036404913,
0.0168844014,
0.0025931338,
0.0432040766,
-0.0140626123,
0.0241864547,
-0.0557181798,
-0.0133898361,
0.0262903813,
-0.0125824613,
0.0397248417,
0.0310251899,
0.0045699081,
-0.0036414741,
0.0608834215,
0.006534006,
-0.0609935969,
-0.0330017731,
0.098122254,
0.023060739,
0.083372198,
0.0148799885,
0.0430832617,
0.0689936057,
0.0007948803,
-0.0456098504,
0.0041532363,
0.0013740472,
0.0235587545,
0.0141414898,
0.0115689877,
-0.0197332725,
-0.0423934199,
-0.0008840238,
0.0247642137,
0.0099832835,
-0.0175940059,
0.0052333758,
0.0211618599,
-0.0063276896,
-0.0712881386,
-0.0146094812,
-0.010944657,
0.0025673863,
-0.0345719457,
-0.0091830222,
0.0012628677,
-0.0105950637,
0.0431129187,
-0.0500542037,
-0.0547292419,
0.0237425473,
0.0090468945,
0.0506857,
0.0221777204,
0.0457551144,
0.0241605025,
-0.023654921,
0.0059427195,
-0.0052104425,
-0.0300204866,
-0.0133816525,
-0.0043024519,
0.017471185,
0.0407154337,
-0.0133448569,
-0.0183979869,
0.0063623325,
0.0019452266,
-0.0118486295,
0.0160383936,
-0.0034007253,
0.0401958227,
-0.022740826,
-0.0283978432,
-0.0226974078,
0.0249821357,
0.0527690873,
-0.0634062737,
-0.0034676057,
0.0046622814,
2.429e-7,
0.0440080836,
0.0298066009,
0.015734084,
0.0439274721,
0.0374248773,
0.0406283885,
0.0068002613,
0.0526481718,
-0.001350529,
-0.0131142586,
-0.0194621067,
-0.0044704941,
0.0283873454,
0.0299441721,
-0.074438028,
-0.0206352249,
-0.0123906378,
0.0043990207,
-0.0423449427,
-0.038513165,
0.0998637751,
0.1001539603,
0.0122904005,
-0.00139876,
0.0032330917,
-0.0670495406,
0.03896695,
0.0161506049,
-0.0188765842,
-0.0048924563,
0.0544421896,
0.0126529494,
-0.0026375852,
-0.0145275202,
-0.0149592338,
-0.0008518103,
-0.0379560217,
-0.0044542151,
-0.025040539,
0.0551279746,
0.0369052701,
-0.0291058104,
-0.0218696911,
-0.0007894399,
0.0625027716,
-0.0855520144,
-0.03089476,
-0.004880419,
-0.0263224915,
-0.0091510778,
-0.0298378039,
-0.0087812608,
-0.0380146727,
-0.0095015168,
0.0663066059,
-0.030696176,
0.0155836726,
-0.0570276603,
-0.0127781145,
0.068505235,
-0.0307881311,
-0.0082117775,
0.0202164836,
0.0470675007,
0.0298648849,
-0.0553143062,
0.012305689,
2.225277616e-34,
0.0173927471,
0.0122998515,
0.0298723429,
0.0116400961,
0.0649549067,
-0.0220144652,
0.0039588581,
0.0041890065,
0.0158367362,
-0.0551087596,
-0.0255109966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14585v1 | Improving Knowledge Graph Entity Alignment with Graph Augmentation | 2023-04-28T01:22:47 | 2023-04-28T01:22:47 | Feng Xie, Xiang Zeng, Bin Zhou, Yusong Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Entity alignment (EA) which links equivalent entities across different
knowledge graphs (KGs) plays a crucial role in knowledge fusion. In recent
years, graph neural networks (GNNs) have been successfully applied in many
embedding-based EA methods. However, existing GNN-based methods either suffer
from the structural heterogeneity issue that especially appears in the real KG
distributions or ignore the heterogeneous representation learning for unseen
(unlabeled) entities, which would lead the model to overfit on few alignment
seeds (i.e., training data) and thus cause unsatisfactory alignment
performance. To enhance the EA ability, we propose GAEA, a novel EA approach
based on graph augmentation. In this model, we design a simple Entity-Relation
(ER) Encoder to generate latent representations for entities via jointly
modeling comprehensive structural information and rich relation semantics.
Moreover, we use graph augmentation to create two graph views for margin-based
alignment learning and contrastive entity representation learning, thus
mitigating structural heterogeneity and further improving the model's alignment
performance. Extensive experiments conducted on benchmark datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0032026912,
0.0285002422,
0.0229181908,
0.0552884303,
0.0165966004,
0.0033822167,
-0.0400765501,
-0.0361877605,
0.0613679066,
-0.0019519695,
0.0041001886,
0.0202583335,
-0.0183364861,
0.0420539975,
0.0568520389,
-0.014136198,
0.0074542509,
0.0789852068,
-0.0062060584,
-0.0121478066,
0.0253639091,
0.0455249362,
-0.0186968893,
-0.0007508216,
-0.0357584991,
-0.0123055698,
-0.0043030246,
0.0284476746,
0.0593706779,
-0.0248494633,
-0.0102732582,
-0.0135935014,
0.0398420095,
0.0264067929,
0.0000018848,
-0.025527807,
-0.0145537825,
0.0106630875,
-0.0421008356,
-0.0167953577,
-0.0106272697,
-0.0556604192,
0.0451281108,
-0.0080990037,
-0.0263307467,
-0.0483243652,
0.0711615756,
0.05257212,
0.0168390013,
0.0697867125,
-0.0485886633,
-0.0474013761,
0.0365108773,
-0.0358891077,
-0.0141451517,
-0.0473679304,
0.0253086518,
0.0225231685,
-0.0360296443,
-0.0161752589,
-0.0572237112,
0.0279776603,
0.0262084212,
-0.0034110094,
0.096609205,
0.0475550294,
0.0008402766,
0.0413023829,
0.0106991082,
0.1241541058,
-0.0155106941,
0.0011265867,
0.0028364363,
-0.026462175,
0.0191529579,
0.0174656063,
-0.0093978532,
-0.0441316925,
0.0036210956,
0.0271031912,
-0.043938566,
-0.0234761331,
0.0681329668,
-0.043819651,
-0.014827718,
0.0356796011,
0.0196015481,
-0.0216116793,
0.0005551107,
0.0275116097,
-0.0156966299,
-0.0243418198,
-0.0251070522,
0.0181256607,
-0.0307506453,
0.0112284934,
-0.0644537285,
-0.0018790318,
-0.003649235,
-0.0240144487,
-0.0286949947,
0.0411643535,
0.0320139676,
0.0720674172,
-0.0492346175,
0.0464235544,
-0.023496367,
0.0454549491,
-0.0367365964,
-0.0485360399,
-0.052097708,
0.0136262793,
0.0020542897,
0.0221456792,
0.0266286749,
-0.0574497879,
-0.0757567063,
0.0342513956,
-0.0316317156,
0.0778163522,
0.0215355791,
0.0637426153,
0.0215868894,
-0.0183134675,
-0.0040618777,
0.0343237109,
-0.0277834386,
0.0154310223,
-0.0191106349,
0.0200049635,
-0.0167534892,
-0.005084422,
0.0410230309,
-0.0367536284,
-0.018475581,
0.0483953394,
0.0084467502,
0.005352411,
-0.0243065953,
-0.0077990489,
0.0252649412,
-0.0251027588,
0.0272591542,
-0.0424140319,
0.0998085439,
0.0194118712,
-0.0270917192,
-0.0562740341,
0.0222775005,
-0.0514303036,
-0.0537926778,
0.0626732633,
-0.0454538949,
0.0047090072,
0.0050950819,
-0.0334102623,
-0.0217946172,
0.0271470789,
0.0347024128,
-0.0316735879,
-0.0065296032,
-0.0068074428,
-0.0610315651,
0.0172548909,
0.0520284548,
-0.0127677405,
0.0382644758,
0.0037052536,
-0.0064346683,
0.0551434755,
0.0616560578,
0.0329405777,
-0.0274667218,
-0.0229741316,
0.0270993076,
-0.0067057051,
-0.0073939469,
0.0005864747,
0.0210950803,
0.0194829814,
-0.0357091427,
-0.004675969,
-0.0537807941,
0.043354433,
0.0008934115,
0.0387537442,
0.0378929898,
0.0336165503,
-0.0213510599,
0.0372818336,
0.0294362493,
-0.0180655252,
0.0469952263,
-0.0089908671,
0.0512822121,
-0.0100148693,
-0.0278333742,
0.0441349857,
0.0290141217,
-0.004566689,
0.0079057766,
0.0567398667,
-0.0313244984,
0.0472628772,
0.0204785354,
0.01400166,
-0.0708477274,
-0.0211752541,
-0.0612800308,
0.0006134893,
0.0348064005,
-0.0198339671,
-0.0078528374,
-0.0682755336,
-0.0828693658,
-0.0352189429,
-0.0244893562,
0.0276877359,
0.0226337742,
0.0364115611,
0.0532177724,
-0.1054505929,
0.0122649437,
0.0189415626,
-0.0213752128,
0.0187631659,
-0.0243097004,
0.0535624214,
0.0074613434,
0.0385082178,
0.0121875321,
0.0097690523,
0.0208886731,
-0.0205788724,
-0.0246931296,
-0.0192296691,
-0.0378067195,
-0.0499561578,
0.0585565604,
-0.0354474597,
-0.0439846106,
-0.0113337394,
-0.0593492687,
-0.0732302815,
0.0221664459,
-0.0163181815,
0.0448841974,
0.0139915422,
-0.011000013,
-0.0029552414,
-0.00107111,
0.0229246207,
0.0735915303,
-0.0120537262,
0.0217985604,
0.0044114115,
-0.0148807457,
0.027123075,
-0.0339846276,
-0.0107934512,
-0.0313720256,
0.0251219571,
-0.0013002779,
-0.0022110685,
-0.0560153238,
-0.0697500855,
0.0395008028,
-0.1048957929,
0.0299653802,
0.0285559408,
0.002254681,
0.0199090075,
0.0183072705,
0.0259775072,
-0.0168605819,
-0.0604849197,
0.0186969098,
-0.0066556451,
-0.0045515839,
0.0254068449,
-0.0177651215,
-0.0202658996,
-0.0124918409,
-0.022491198,
-0.0359299816,
0.0407468751,
0.0368972607,
-0.0329771638,
0.0105371224,
0.0316315852,
-0.0540718697,
0.0163309183,
-0.0056971102,
0.0162369702,
-0.0249731299,
0.0311031528,
0.0220986363,
0.0105760181,
-0.0469778255,
-0.0090728458,
0.0019211248,
-0.0078516994,
-0.0512706488,
-0.0016358761,
-0.0158482436,
0.0321490318,
-0.0241017044,
-0.0213659778,
-0.0516426675,
-0.0025229086,
0.0090291621,
-0.0142356372,
-0.0691236556,
-0.0065418188,
0.0389966853,
0.0264855288,
-0.0145918662,
-0.0157221425,
0.0462403372,
-0.0445526652,
-0.071306631,
0.0284086466,
0.0989063308,
-0.006278316,
0.0130430097,
0.0491391607,
0.0049597085,
-0.0337747335,
0.0033563655,
0.0287384409,
0.0239915196,
-0.0278190002,
-0.0284514707,
-0.0409588963,
0.0318781026,
0.0303857829,
-0.013956652,
0.0208171234,
0.0575394742,
0.0407683142,
0.0013985106,
-0.017293483,
-0.0415634513,
0.0306200404,
-0.0058056144,
0.036386583,
0.0152110616,
-0.0111892615,
-0.0403279737,
-0.0113895992,
-0.0256011337,
-0.0209629964,
0.0181298833,
0.0037609832,
-0.0223084576,
0.0572113171,
0.0655287132,
-0.0016647757,
0.0132708736,
0.0020055778,
-0.0050165039,
0.0285530705,
0.0153144971,
-0.0342657864,
-0.0252923034,
-0.010886196,
-0.0254144762,
-0.0288976319,
0.0087531768,
-0.0269748587,
0.0295576323,
-0.0114630209,
0.0351453535,
0.0607661903,
-0.00223815,
-0.0121628474,
-0.0116267884,
0.0320953801,
0.0130843231,
0.0357412435,
0.0045821578,
-0.0975545645,
-0.0073570739,
-0.0185614321,
-0.0015189544,
0.0624014921,
-0.0736044347,
0.0200254787,
-0.1082238927,
-0.0344909467,
0.0291042998,
-0.0224394705,
-0.0642584413,
-0.0232148245,
0.0335100442,
-0.0262503829,
0.0054079606,
-0.0341165029,
0.0094213625,
-0.0117524713,
-0.0047973357,
0.0233641751,
-0.0393104963,
-0.0146247344,
-0.0711912736,
0.053491883,
-0.0134406881,
0.0277527217,
-0.0013048524,
-0.0172736626,
0.0036156513,
0.0055507156,
-0.0595655814,
0.0447090007,
0.0553900935,
-0.0513616018,
-0.0132453842,
-0.005313952,
0.033982113,
-0.0471033454,
0.0062061939,
-0.0280667115,
0.0772602186,
0.0173073653,
0.0054064076,
-0.0130063798,
-0.0502139777,
0.00617438,
0.0166531969,
0.0121697942,
0.0234041959,
-0.0080455001,
-0.0177345779,
0.0484894402,
-0.015065969,
0.0449917503,
0.0510200672,
-0.0459223762,
0.0264692232,
-0.0336872824,
-0.0475898497,
0.031384822,
-0.0252927337,
0.0243424326,
-0.0067699538,
0.0372654386,
-0.0686531812,
-0.0787489861,
0.0180507898,
-0.0238559563,
0.0103059076,
0.0304253418,
-0.0097292084,
-0.0206357557,
0.0018873322,
-0.0352052227,
-0.0333992168,
-0.0408344492,
-0.0818331465,
-0.0569266751,
-0.0071940147,
-0.0017136612,
0.0881116241,
-0.0412345789,
0.0255905073,
0.0445678569,
0.025912011,
-0.0377861522,
-0.0251404792,
-0.0203572195,
-0.0168341417,
-0.0122523196,
0.0204041209,
-0.0838820115,
-0.0226997156,
0.036003314,
0.0461608544,
-0.0390729159,
-0.0670440122,
0.0048859878,
0.0246687029,
0.0060045053,
0.0112265563,
0.0404966176,
-0.0876489952,
-0.0013826354,
-0.0061044553,
-0.0065000327,
-0.0106190154,
-0.0353061482,
0.0079506785,
0.0163236819,
0.0131777935,
0.0113272881,
0.037086796,
0.0246913806,
-0.0390035585,
-0.0628975779,
-0.0006789464,
-0.0482929349,
0.0346110687,
-0.0043255324,
-0.0268103909,
0.0469082072,
0.034548264,
-0.0013867399,
-0.0401370153,
0.000074498,
0.0505908169,
0.01129111,
-0.0384392068,
0.008073898,
-0.0196270198,
-0.0021951096,
-0.0306025613,
0.0052455356,
0.0745220929,
-0.0079114614,
0.0372502394,
-0.0076255188,
-0.004781215,
-0.000978302,
0.0466429703,
-0.0318377167,
-0.0287266448,
0.0467275605,
0.0059376252,
0.0032464475,
0.0323549546,
0.0389565006,
0.0146588897,
0.0475799255,
-0.0570003018,
-0.043007087,
-0.0544368923,
-0.027605556,
0.0399154015,
0.0158270989,
-0.0182559527,
0.0031795623,
0.000005086,
-0.0898094922,
0.0374951847,
-0.0068894336,
-0.0677857324,
0.0495191328,
0.0238319747,
-0.0027372646,
0.009956277,
-0.0257464349,
0.0149356741,
0.0074531375,
-0.0434442535,
-0.0175738856,
0.0052514272,
-5.735999907e-33,
-0.0338506326,
-0.0214848444,
0.0220836177,
-0.0257265735,
-0.0689407289,
0.0099132154,
-0.0390764475,
-0.0298171788,
-0.0544312783,
0.0238892455,
0.0067152018,
0.0159597732,
-0.0154649802,
0.0117238164,
-0.0140836397,
-0.0338730812,
0.0377364531,
0.0464685373,
0.018054435,
0.0162312277,
0.0127291624,
0.0299182422,
0.0446189083,
-0.1049702689,
0.0316592157,
-0.0159254987,
0.0150688952,
0.0079668025,
0.0471841358,
0.0339818895,
-0.0105353948,
0.0464250073,
0.0281657446,
0.0184214506,
0.0033785678,
-0.009928043,
-0.1000061408,
-0.0400864594,
-0.008899915,
0.0157388039,
-0.0160090979,
-0.0149736153,
0.051231198,
-0.0055632386,
0.0655413121,
-0.0573546402,
0.0702971295,
-0.0062161372,
-0.0272477102,
-0.046946425,
-0.0362246893,
-0.0050394824,
-0.0149612203,
0.0171087831,
0.0056242803,
-0.0174440462,
0.0594297275,
-0.0222346205,
-0.1107735485,
-0.0057214405,
-0.0281873476,
-0.0417932793,
0.0322877876,
0.0325157829,
0.0165695306,
0.0373827368,
-0.0353782363,
-0.031344343,
-0.0423997752,
0.0188805237,
-0.0064066383,
0.0181970969,
0.0000461316,
0.0157829802,
-0.0206276346,
-0.0219716094,
-0.0799159706,
0.0285723321,
-0.00870247,
0.0147362053,
-0.027682595,
0.0345607325,
-0.003884458,
-0.0373898335,
-0.016547896,
-0.0146481739,
-0.0199942999,
-0.0363538899,
0.003256341,
-0.0159716625,
-0.0066957562,
0.0566183701,
-0.0171513371,
-0.0689354315,
-0.0248458758,
0.0648186505,
0.0289047416,
0.0227773935,
-0.0044322517,
0.0111028496,
-0.0505002402,
-0.0212005023,
0.0361917205,
-0.0210512131,
0.0129803745,
0.0369561128,
0.0720630288,
-0.021352753,
-0.0156558938,
0.0092376769,
-0.030207824,
-0.0568558499,
-0.0555520803,
-0.0277787596,
0.0420185998,
0.0573394522,
0.0152888782,
0.0288887881,
0.064830929,
0.0536625125,
0.0001418411,
0.0467493273,
0.0519002937,
0.0347753689,
-0.0156923123,
0.0093659218,
-0.0173868537,
-0.0019624219,
-0.0046349163,
-0.0471774414,
-0.0222319327,
-0.0205975324,
2.563e-7,
0.0567231402,
-0.0418156497,
0.074770838,
0.0098060453,
-0.0160223637,
0.0416941606,
0.0073276288,
0.0582086667,
-0.0178859551,
-0.0462599434,
0.0569803193,
0.0360180363,
-0.0206463914,
0.0351585075,
-0.0431557111,
0.0050174762,
-0.0612357855,
-0.0186473355,
-0.0334493555,
0.0554992519,
0.064136669,
0.051130753,
0.0650345832,
0.00925327,
-0.002809457,
-0.0131815337,
0.0541573092,
0.0188104995,
0.0173603036,
0.0068301866,
-0.0138588613,
0.0438359268,
-0.0327632576,
0.0680897608,
-0.0156056304,
0.0593257323,
0.0408137888,
0.0105104418,
-0.0281962734,
0.0041583288,
-0.0359532721,
-0.0179679729,
0.0104188202,
-0.0331547037,
0.0527146608,
-0.0636595637,
-0.0159089528,
0.0276600905,
-0.0732007325,
0.0382848866,
0.0074379905,
0.0352975018,
0.0091662258,
-0.0001013888,
0.0523012467,
0.0072145741,
-0.0193526503,
-0.0586139895,
0.0251510553,
0.0274103303,
-0.0244708154,
-0.0080520194,
0.0277226511,
-0.0045237103,
0.0419197492,
-0.0179257896,
0.0144010251,
2.178113201e-34,
-0.0170655511,
0.0215268545,
0.0206688195,
0.0107528185,
0.0226464942,
-0.0656360462,
-0.0372927003,
0.0074483575,
0.0077138823,
-0.0621408522,
0.0126252826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14553v1 | Appropriateness is all you need! | 2023-04-27T22:21:52 | 2023-04-27T22:21:52 | Hendrik Kempt, Alon Lavie, Saskia K. Nagel | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | The strive to make AI applications "safe" has led to the development of
safety-measures as the main or even sole normative requirement of their
permissible use. Similar can be attested to the latest version of chatbots,
such as chatGPT. In this view, if they are "safe", they are supposed to be
permissible to deploy. This approach, which we call "safety-normativity", is
rather limited in solving the emerging issues that chatGPT and other chatbots
have caused thus far. In answering this limitation, in this paper we argue for
limiting chatbots in the range of topics they can chat about according to the
normative concept of appropriateness. We argue that rather than looking for
"safety" in a chatbot's utterances to determine what they may and may not say,
we ought to assess those utterances according to three forms of
appropriateness: technical-discursive, social, and moral. We then spell out
what requirements for chatbots follow from these forms of appropriateness to
avoid the limits of previous accounts: positionality, acceptability, and value
alignment (PAVA). With these in mind, we may be able to determine what a
chatbot may and may not say. Lastly, one initial suggestion is to use challenge
sets, specifically designed for appropriateness, as a validation method. | [
0.0718112513,
0.0139581226,
-0.0175991878,
-0.0336147435,
-0.0484792404,
-0.016318826,
0.0070510376,
0.0019655481,
0.0435635783,
-0.0126067828,
0.0028236255,
-0.0128460145,
-0.0185803212,
0.0413790792,
-0.0188467558,
-0.0315969214,
0.0204135999,
-0.0148121165,
0.0543429404,
0.0171012059,
0.0473690592,
0.0190879218,
-0.0331547596,
0.068648763,
-0.0614817627,
-0.0223437604,
-0.0082594175,
-0.0045276652,
0.0364430957,
-0.0056406688,
0.0105394609,
-0.0071172412,
0.0117604919,
-0.0015020601,
0.0000020254,
-0.0341683738,
0.0175889116,
0.0211509019,
-0.0148900216,
-0.079538621,
0.0485143811,
0.0072828322,
-0.0188238211,
0.0268377755,
-0.0599238612,
0.0362427421,
0.070049271,
0.033296328,
0.0519570261,
0.077657856,
-0.0176188517,
0.0402100831,
0.0161687676,
0.0410809629,
0.0054068565,
-0.0716696009,
0.0129936319,
0.0358874016,
0.0629529357,
0.0388528854,
0.0119712269,
-0.0013202269,
0.0159317981,
-0.0276161823,
-0.0002806977,
-0.024830794,
-0.0227234773,
-0.0803006738,
-0.0280923918,
0.049206011,
0.0689697564,
-0.0126019754,
0.0029045644,
0.0222651158,
0.016481638,
0.0153958332,
-0.0106050763,
0.0222177692,
-0.0289825946,
-0.026285626,
0.0021650747,
0.0212489087,
0.012872885,
0.0083543342,
0.0554668792,
0.0466910005,
-0.0220933184,
-0.0185392704,
0.0178911518,
-0.0046980022,
0.0163270421,
-0.0284347851,
0.0251584072,
0.0399147533,
-0.0485134348,
0.0274143238,
-0.04702558,
0.0236150939,
0.0215292573,
-0.0409331806,
-0.0366266482,
0.0311263185,
0.0154153928,
0.0120770484,
0.0612872615,
0.0300015118,
-0.0097696045,
0.0225131605,
-0.0258916263,
0.0025774429,
-0.0258860197,
0.0037601327,
-0.0337435193,
0.0165530238,
0.0081325294,
0.016354762,
-0.003034872,
0.0504755862,
-0.0808031932,
0.0153834354,
-0.0194099322,
0.0227930564,
-0.0357706547,
-0.0069343676,
-0.0049181404,
-0.0680081248,
-0.0645408332,
0.0262004342,
0.0016107733,
-0.079418458,
0.0186199788,
0.0103217913,
-0.017088268,
-0.0235240795,
-0.0059605474,
0.1198035553,
0.0210716054,
-0.0148032438,
0.0254201014,
-0.0379850268,
-0.0264043491,
-0.0421929881,
0.0307920668,
0.0092097661,
0.0169846397,
-0.0236806478,
-0.0302973259,
-0.0230706595,
0.0152530549,
0.022534309,
-0.0220493302,
0.0326160081,
0.0143935438,
0.0039262041,
0.012250063,
0.0654899031,
-0.0586817376,
0.0280030649,
0.0180958826,
0.0252675787,
0.0512773059,
-0.0050825169,
0.0411162451,
0.0006358673,
-0.031579785,
-0.0036584309,
0.0118644638,
0.0337003283,
0.0082814805,
0.0011374792,
-0.0419009291,
0.0552546717,
-0.0265349876,
-0.0143054686,
0.0448201448,
0.0660957247,
-0.0506605282,
0.0275995731,
0.0295323245,
0.0184363611,
0.0124373892,
0.0372268334,
-0.0099600106,
0.0054745711,
-0.0739849731,
-0.0640189722,
-0.0313833207,
0.0037156411,
-0.0251728687,
-0.0508270338,
0.0158875939,
-0.0153988199,
0.1058069542,
0.0099077681,
0.0010583306,
-0.0086123738,
-0.0077983676,
-0.0696861446,
-0.0172125343,
-0.0385947786,
-0.0576465055,
-0.0712605044,
0.0202165768,
0.0560226478,
0.0625966713,
-0.0180479363,
-0.0588425212,
-0.0041840984,
-0.0202947203,
0.0240774192,
0.0505668744,
-0.0045568794,
0.0040575513,
-0.0227056574,
-0.0336617939,
0.0108538531,
-0.0078336531,
-0.007009991,
0.0237750094,
0.0371069685,
-0.0462062694,
0.0517589152,
-0.0384840108,
0.0177860968,
0.0188159328,
-0.0237444211,
-0.0500386432,
0.0255772062,
0.0446077622,
0.0315050818,
-0.0059921145,
-0.0070079491,
0.0359216966,
0.0246334504,
-0.0101350704,
0.0263553411,
-0.0161363557,
0.0757139474,
0.0162894409,
-0.096825555,
-0.0295094419,
0.0549148209,
-0.0037239848,
0.0269754976,
0.015552572,
-0.0465798229,
-0.0296505094,
0.0004468138,
-0.0027905318,
-0.0387815014,
-0.0147188818,
-0.0227438416,
-0.0056942403,
0.0208744146,
-0.044079423,
-0.0157879684,
-0.0007766542,
0.0205757432,
-0.0085325669,
-0.0377808511,
0.0338016115,
-0.0170271695,
0.0465242714,
0.0715683252,
0.0133011946,
-0.0417492837,
-0.0050932933,
-0.0829088464,
-0.029686382,
0.0073452373,
-0.0204638503,
-0.0103304833,
-0.0306999609,
0.0038855448,
-0.0361317135,
-0.0278344564,
0.0278745312,
-0.0075330851,
0.0321787894,
0.063560456,
0.0086260559,
-0.0389313772,
-0.0135261035,
0.0353371017,
-0.0191513933,
-0.0296378918,
0.0242691748,
-0.009351816,
-0.0130965952,
0.0302109346,
-0.0702739134,
0.0002651761,
0.009987304,
-0.0698415935,
0.0578543171,
0.0301551633,
-0.0249430854,
0.050358858,
0.0533706918,
0.0608000718,
0.0503094643,
0.0367565677,
-0.0030683186,
-0.0036449842,
0.0292420853,
-0.0362598002,
0.0090746488,
-0.038328439,
-0.0001712747,
0.0013530101,
-0.0265896134,
0.0151384156,
-0.0710146874,
0.0588365421,
-0.0262941848,
-0.059039887,
0.0018852429,
-0.0617448874,
-0.0144269643,
0.042616453,
-0.0081260335,
-0.0549307093,
0.068291612,
0.0162084904,
0.0030756237,
-0.01799451,
-0.0711286739,
0.0035472952,
0.0644352436,
-0.0510375425,
0.0279226433,
0.0471092574,
-0.0158666633,
-0.0589146614,
-0.0587705597,
0.0361063629,
-0.0712757409,
-0.0056526721,
-0.0362831131,
-0.0054583391,
0.0080268364,
-0.0600617491,
-0.0405876525,
-0.0344808102,
-0.009426293,
-0.0070819296,
0.0175055191,
-0.016831832,
-0.0476241335,
-0.0171939321,
0.0288658701,
-0.0144639798,
0.0268688481,
-0.0133382948,
0.0053857346,
-0.0631853566,
0.0164448004,
0.0326075219,
-0.0196880102,
0.0496669561,
0.0206902884,
0.0697342232,
-0.0201485455,
-0.0214824714,
-0.0266262889,
0.0002137421,
-0.0116302418,
0.0149454568,
0.0119169103,
0.0230602883,
0.0653775856,
-0.0267574415,
-0.0079220235,
0.0217143428,
0.0004098382,
0.0122982506,
0.0203895681,
-0.0265924577,
-0.0354250371,
-0.0184019599,
0.027169209,
-0.0592101999,
0.0212369412,
0.0130092287,
0.0207178015,
-0.0780448616,
-0.047111772,
-0.0096794199,
-0.0240039378,
0.0281832013,
0.0159586463,
-0.0523574464,
-0.0626553744,
0.0029981781,
0.0002629436,
-0.0219777673,
0.052388683,
-0.0026737915,
0.0223179031,
-0.0249327626,
0.0180572961,
-0.0366512127,
-0.0006133417,
0.0432724953,
-0.0094145332,
0.0962765142,
0.0619804859,
0.0426545851,
-0.0034776435,
-0.0088576339,
-0.0274621025,
0.0682170838,
0.0064487974,
0.0278473496,
0.0021474292,
-0.0191976037,
-0.0022890104,
-0.047827065,
-0.0123593993,
0.0160671342,
-0.0333614126,
0.0351605043,
0.043354094,
-0.045514822,
-0.0448604189,
-0.0722207502,
0.0590497144,
0.0424131081,
0.0581222549,
0.0038688732,
-0.034272667,
-0.017193744,
-0.0367498547,
0.0078852354,
0.0341869891,
-0.0513017215,
-0.018643111,
-0.0038239725,
-0.0577901229,
-0.0828369111,
-0.0549246483,
-0.0092148352,
0.0509963259,
0.0212401636,
-0.0724884719,
0.0085824393,
0.0504936613,
0.0152819073,
0.0157048553,
-0.0308436546,
-0.026948953,
0.0008286244,
0.034834303,
-0.0330055431,
-0.049911309,
0.0197237972,
0.0002200943,
0.0611667335,
-0.0194334593,
0.0205568522,
0.0386495441,
0.0363122672,
-0.032235384,
-0.0346172713,
-0.0050546536,
0.0381459929,
0.0467583574,
-0.0479598939,
-0.0133734196,
0.070080094,
0.0209523179,
0.0052486788,
0.0057652704,
-0.0425114594,
0.0045221876,
-0.026646331,
0.0053591128,
-0.0325973667,
-0.0422343016,
0.0375316739,
0.0447552614,
-0.0101671433,
0.0346565433,
0.0088896221,
0.0185391456,
-0.0267277621,
-0.0013162915,
-0.0199126359,
-0.0154716,
0.0109245935,
-0.0346203484,
-0.0030353416,
0.0185996275,
-0.0033822514,
-0.0624814332,
0.0233254116,
0.0320821367,
0.0029773293,
-0.0037695046,
0.0577043854,
-0.0263648536,
0.0140139852,
-0.0350035764,
0.0375658534,
-0.027209226,
0.0179235078,
0.0398664437,
0.0458485037,
0.0141634662,
0.0040681106,
0.0308754612,
0.0624701865,
-0.0776334405,
-0.0597839244,
0.0073708384,
0.0808786154,
-0.0050853924,
0.0453504436,
-0.0167991724,
-0.0298813395,
0.0166372657,
-0.0336941592,
0.0083977534,
0.0171725415,
-0.0312335603,
-0.0083877407,
0.0179370604,
-0.0213473272,
-0.02114073,
0.0136467526,
-0.0634498522,
0.0254081357,
0.0041926876,
-0.0321626253,
-0.0294931233,
-0.0548522398,
0.0393403955,
-0.0063352599,
0.0074934168,
-0.0129052037,
-0.0607488751,
-0.0631401837,
-0.0379786156,
0.0355455093,
-0.0208880026,
-0.0176994726,
0.0168998037,
0.0394058079,
-0.0045164344,
-0.0020579116,
-0.0166425891,
-0.0387165174,
-0.0506904423,
0.0511076935,
-0.0276219416,
-5.812774382e-33,
0.0091884108,
-0.0377663299,
0.0187236071,
0.0148998657,
-0.0487826839,
-0.0185624175,
0.0006751689,
0.0274497941,
-0.0622168481,
0.0303802062,
-0.027077781,
0.0250300318,
-0.0028239684,
-0.0602611117,
0.0070630037,
-0.055323787,
0.0051623462,
-0.0103402026,
-0.03568995,
0.033135511,
0.0002303977,
-0.0274765398,
0.0099586714,
-0.0945803076,
0.0697941706,
0.0196042191,
-0.0409921966,
0.0120282155,
0.0007876147,
0.0252861381,
0.0204215609,
0.0554357991,
0.0013367673,
0.0212723073,
0.0195116866,
0.0774260908,
0.0258155987,
-0.0466543101,
0.0171039123,
-0.0107940584,
-0.0457086824,
-0.0576602742,
0.0116442991,
-0.0308644846,
-0.0254782531,
-0.0058227428,
0.0062719779,
-0.018380696,
0.0205569603,
0.0321261212,
-0.046796415,
-0.0098238057,
-0.0496079177,
-0.0540002845,
-0.0157741457,
0.0671653822,
0.0121437442,
-0.0217813049,
0.0060684197,
0.0343332179,
-0.0487234369,
-0.0619078279,
0.0344563909,
-0.0472353213,
0.010342651,
0.0482407175,
-0.0036363469,
0.0556469969,
-0.0127070611,
-0.0779177472,
-0.0164406877,
0.0621042363,
0.0284620635,
0.0296025388,
-0.0123488102,
-0.016525181,
-0.0483390465,
0.0320658349,
0.0385516435,
0.0466455258,
0.007555814,
-0.0172318239,
-0.1383619159,
0.003673146,
0.0127095273,
0.0119013935,
-0.031273488,
-0.0440198444,
-0.006281713,
-0.0251249429,
-0.0512823164,
-0.0106690545,
-0.0334817581,
-0.0610020235,
0.0780384317,
0.013784186,
-0.006907356,
-0.0342167318,
0.0061395844,
0.0353064425,
0.0147076473,
-0.0426822007,
0.0362778381,
0.0137317665,
0.0489164665,
0.0226797946,
-0.0141500095,
0.0637887642,
-0.0058894344,
-0.0448283255,
-0.0171730947,
0.0641008392,
-0.0003231859,
-0.0217852648,
0.0339181423,
0.0334824547,
-0.0039283559,
0.0189982243,
0.0291083604,
0.0262831263,
-0.0206464641,
0.0158384591,
-0.0528991856,
-0.0295081381,
-0.0081465775,
-0.0141544966,
-0.0227153581,
0.0409481525,
0.0142165152,
-0.0368076526,
-0.0225234274,
-0.034250848,
2.879e-7,
-0.0290813278,
0.0020937484,
0.027794335,
0.0393465161,
-0.0038650301,
0.0652916133,
0.0028773355,
0.0877681002,
-0.0126251411,
-0.0167668816,
0.0629205778,
0.0321647562,
0.0495424755,
0.0341630243,
-0.0079164514,
-0.0764755383,
-0.0593329147,
-0.0363723785,
-0.0110450182,
0.0393468924,
0.1004116535,
0.0007186729,
0.0031640872,
-0.0143165626,
-0.0078837276,
-0.0327341743,
-0.0014206985,
-0.0515478067,
0.0267275628,
0.0034916883,
0.0288543049,
0.0596174449,
0.0174380429,
0.0353582911,
0.0396007784,
0.009529368,
0.0002406146,
0.0862537548,
0.0076464107,
-0.0375911593,
-0.0008465269,
-0.0199422371,
0.0057934988,
-0.0227332562,
0.031850785,
-0.0590088069,
-0.0478423238,
-0.0311600026,
-0.0145471152,
-0.0160303749,
0.0490965284,
-0.0195177235,
-0.0139369741,
-0.0143366801,
-0.0058685308,
0.0100605693,
0.0092840744,
-0.0198676232,
0.0545389354,
-0.0186471958,
-0.0062430473,
-0.0980816409,
-0.0024779751,
0.0415202603,
0.0064280075,
-0.0235907193,
0.0396642312,
1.723280688e-34,
-0.0085462471,
-0.0253412891,
-0.0017065952,
-0.0008211153,
0.0453925394,
0.0506780259,
0.0277497116,
0.002688824,
0.0373060815,
0.0129218446,
-0.0113124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14543v1 | Discourse over Discourse: The Need for an Expanded Pragmatic Focus in Conversational AI | 2023-04-27T21:51:42 | 2023-04-27T21:51:42 | S. M. Seals, Valerie L. Shalin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The summarization of conversation, that is, discourse over discourse,
elevates pragmatic considerations as a pervasive limitation of both
summarization and other applications of contemporary conversational AI.
Building on impressive progress in both semantics and syntax, pragmatics
concerns meaning in the practical sense. In this paper, we discuss several
challenges in both summarization of conversations and other conversational AI
applications, drawing on relevant theoretical work. We illustrate the
importance of pragmatics with so-called star sentences, syntactically
acceptable propositions that are pragmatically inappropriate in conversation or
its summary. Because the baseline for quality of AI is indistinguishability
from human behavior, we draw heavily on the psycho-linguistics literature, and
label our complaints as "Turing Test Triggers" (TTTs). We discuss implications
for the design and evaluation of conversation summarization methods and
conversational AI applications like voice assistants and chatbots | [
0.0673383921,
0.01103066,
-0.0292773526,
-0.0263964999,
-0.0292808507,
0.0022947057,
-0.0459284484,
0.0046607614,
-0.0173579212,
-0.0192690324,
0.0104902461,
0.01089356,
0.0334387682,
0.0299800914,
0.002088448,
-0.1188142449,
0.0218186323,
-0.0154770026,
0.0615739524,
-0.0241852384,
0.0120993406,
0.0099348444,
-0.0141714336,
0.0459897667,
-0.0296325516,
-0.0194800999,
-0.0230509099,
0.00140274,
0.0104286652,
-0.0109192384,
-0.0218886454,
-0.0014832256,
-0.0178476106,
-0.0207119491,
0.0000017226,
-0.0547768995,
0.0486800261,
-0.0339314491,
-0.0231964402,
-0.0039051361,
0.0174763557,
-0.0096929213,
0.0065770806,
0.0193410572,
-0.0584986657,
0.0138280913,
0.0124942269,
0.0750120729,
0.0485190973,
0.068021208,
-0.0141587965,
-0.0075229895,
0.045810014,
-0.0115329335,
-0.040056359,
-0.0576298647,
-0.0242343564,
0.017405482,
0.0452251546,
-0.0121737923,
-0.006228013,
0.0681847706,
0.0158079211,
-0.019772809,
-0.0175326392,
0.028878158,
-0.0570020117,
-0.022913903,
-0.0341663882,
0.0354827791,
0.0605960265,
-0.003633657,
0.0047882241,
0.0210449677,
0.0225981325,
-0.0604738593,
-0.0681674182,
0.0627925247,
-0.0066273799,
0.022451954,
0.0175901987,
0.0075523369,
-0.042675823,
0.0052617211,
0.0067501878,
0.0104077011,
-0.0311527736,
-0.0136391716,
-0.0065996889,
0.0181878228,
-0.0106715551,
-0.067451708,
-0.0174179561,
0.0320636518,
-0.075220108,
0.0043628607,
-0.0321611874,
0.0142127145,
0.0260552913,
-0.0182226915,
0.0238431301,
0.0134944506,
-0.0063028568,
0.0386986509,
0.0201713536,
0.0561024994,
0.033061713,
-0.0010765794,
-0.04970764,
-0.0285096467,
-0.0202941969,
-0.023697596,
-0.029906882,
0.0570302233,
-0.0132648349,
-0.0190768782,
-0.0120902248,
0.041479528,
-0.0125254467,
0.0197342969,
-0.0372842252,
0.0089268982,
-0.0500556566,
0.0107861711,
-0.0142098311,
0.0111484807,
-0.076842308,
0.013221181,
0.0284328554,
-0.0891071782,
-0.036091622,
0.0403139703,
0.0011737222,
0.0539579019,
-0.0234061964,
0.0350117795,
-0.0034225425,
-0.0304913558,
0.0445525534,
-0.0595880672,
-0.0586318262,
-0.066198729,
-0.0006530171,
-0.0331713185,
0.0027079377,
-0.009035104,
-0.0212986413,
-0.0442416146,
-0.0093134977,
0.0300665423,
-0.0082234135,
-0.0025643783,
-0.0193116143,
0.0363795124,
0.013529784,
0.0114742145,
-0.022345148,
0.0349218994,
0.0471219979,
0.0166104939,
0.0490938649,
0.0074533927,
0.0355421975,
0.0046336618,
0.0036239969,
-0.0271685719,
-0.0116415918,
0.0105647026,
-0.0282742605,
-0.0089382092,
0.0129450811,
0.0885768384,
-0.0195439588,
0.0200674683,
0.0504337177,
0.0645538568,
-0.0472610258,
0.0305223763,
0.0226110592,
0.0284876283,
0.0338064283,
0.0818665773,
-0.0265871938,
0.018140601,
-0.0450075939,
0.0186496917,
0.0506341942,
-0.0102685457,
-0.0425677337,
-0.0649851263,
0.0249953438,
-0.0240231659,
0.009222012,
0.0116466647,
-0.0198136829,
0.0264412891,
-0.0103464657,
-0.0067184949,
0.0130371163,
-0.0895324871,
-0.0392013825,
-0.0237958953,
-0.0009523748,
0.0581645891,
0.0408606566,
-0.0140147209,
-0.0070126951,
0.0071595921,
0.0314197727,
0.0603087097,
0.0608353838,
-0.0283706076,
0.0079066092,
-0.0251727458,
0.014531373,
-0.0301736854,
0.0227400102,
-0.0186603535,
-0.0210946202,
-0.0225823242,
-0.0111093232,
0.0269575752,
-0.0120521886,
0.0057855067,
0.0111268964,
-0.0101154018,
-0.009573047,
-0.019985985,
0.0009590965,
0.032515876,
-0.0128017711,
0.0238010939,
0.0352235287,
-0.0131931789,
0.022347318,
0.073448129,
-0.0480354801,
-0.0381666496,
0.0278744344,
-0.0832269415,
-0.0193442237,
0.0288662035,
0.0063302396,
-0.0703329742,
0.0270883162,
-0.1038682237,
0.0371033512,
-0.0241582915,
0.0315021835,
-0.013783155,
0.0334275588,
0.0041633449,
0.0437637977,
0.0119271129,
-0.040757969,
0.0126965744,
-0.0595363975,
0.0015623765,
-0.072424829,
-0.0084141362,
0.0280705318,
0.0324465707,
0.0127939824,
0.0618207455,
0.0024052672,
-0.0615599677,
-0.022456402,
-0.1577450931,
-0.0285028405,
-0.0106788408,
-0.0050037149,
0.0137005914,
0.0263021868,
-0.0249842685,
-0.029559359,
-0.0294816904,
-0.0374336392,
0.0358027257,
0.0223071445,
0.0478289463,
0.0395564921,
-0.0033179761,
-0.0444500186,
0.0040727095,
-0.0077691604,
-0.0055324724,
-0.0032134594,
-0.0049291276,
-0.0271848571,
0.0331047699,
-0.0217413902,
-0.0098461211,
-0.0092435805,
-0.0048484346,
0.0382895954,
0.0320392065,
0.0550990179,
0.0711238161,
0.0334932916,
0.0461454317,
0.038138818,
-0.0148583557,
-0.0193883926,
0.0097396774,
-0.021023199,
0.0140575888,
0.0052354494,
-0.0461446978,
0.0150013315,
0.009068598,
0.0257130992,
0.0539074019,
-0.0651070923,
0.0388462469,
-0.0132408952,
-0.0654392615,
-0.0031627924,
-0.0232344847,
-0.0411985852,
0.0318959244,
-0.0060657957,
-0.0053668907,
0.0794178024,
-0.0123944189,
-0.0111753149,
-0.0452799089,
-0.0523201302,
-0.0321970098,
0.0615501478,
-0.0092998641,
0.0071851402,
0.0078819524,
-0.0193314366,
-0.0443243198,
-0.0503831282,
-0.0139034642,
-0.0073496578,
0.0866611004,
-0.0625375286,
-0.0132308519,
0.014954594,
-0.0310783181,
-0.0396596342,
-0.0693943202,
-0.0664365515,
0.0235782936,
-0.0060781864,
-0.000610437,
-0.028293699,
-0.0150970137,
0.0347323753,
0.0406148657,
0.0022940957,
-0.0092153288,
0.0000742707,
-0.0132926367,
0.0494165607,
0.0362975299,
0.0254490692,
0.0288114306,
0.0679442659,
0.0465308689,
0.0353532545,
0.0373297855,
0.0008118391,
-0.0100893481,
-0.0081830174,
-0.0277303793,
-0.0511286855,
0.0260058735,
0.0790226385,
-0.0278551243,
-0.0172961131,
0.1019576564,
0.00505951,
-0.0048079798,
0.0318152569,
-0.0087888548,
0.0398890302,
-0.0340986513,
0.0198057573,
-0.0529345125,
-0.0035329335,
0.0192929171,
0.0171401706,
-0.0545507856,
-0.0164174233,
-0.0435046889,
-0.0662210211,
0.0319897458,
-0.0173354875,
-0.0473266952,
-0.0151338009,
-0.0209396966,
0.0145672411,
0.0419084616,
0.0331458747,
-0.0030331863,
-0.0546363592,
-0.005230973,
0.0050455513,
-0.0572389103,
0.0289081745,
0.0110711008,
-0.0007229286,
0.0519545861,
0.0788697228,
0.0707782209,
0.0173369758,
0.0156808328,
0.0279966593,
-0.0019358053,
0.0242987312,
0.0263734702,
0.0269710999,
0.0138338879,
0.0052404762,
-0.0390791334,
0.0186333731,
-0.027990479,
-0.0134329656,
0.0563333333,
0.0217880812,
-0.0474571921,
-0.054292772,
-0.044464346,
0.0892020613,
-0.0201641545,
0.0687542707,
0.0785885453,
-0.0085531129,
-0.0332482345,
-0.0306472089,
0.0161261484,
-0.0190359894,
-0.0300804693,
-0.0083189616,
0.035350427,
-0.0380529054,
-0.0755433515,
-0.1056120619,
0.0127125923,
-0.0252466984,
-0.0054803644,
0.0053874701,
-0.011188521,
0.0319510736,
0.0096473135,
-0.03454509,
-0.0399995334,
-0.0338475145,
-0.0523656793,
0.01038983,
0.0404667258,
-0.0196577329,
-0.0069627287,
-0.0312318075,
-0.015362205,
-0.0591902621,
0.0111001702,
0.0549722426,
0.0290972162,
0.038637992,
0.0120799569,
-0.0399511643,
0.0133051164,
0.0316780917,
-0.0139874928,
0.0888090581,
0.0475821607,
-0.0156745203,
-0.0026181228,
0.0496169962,
-0.0519068055,
0.0426494144,
-0.0540960915,
0.0196661074,
-0.0527083799,
-0.0531073287,
0.0384288803,
0.0321384557,
0.0085988007,
0.0211216155,
-0.0250827353,
0.00940446,
-0.0044729668,
-0.0535965562,
-0.0269544795,
-0.0270627048,
0.0067975703,
-0.0679116696,
0.0520645715,
0.0076816576,
0.0111621553,
-0.071579881,
0.0289541502,
0.0354404375,
-0.0210634153,
0.0152406292,
-0.0017443111,
-0.0546809249,
0.0043398226,
-0.0388123877,
0.0158157051,
-0.0356555395,
0.0371396877,
0.0205186997,
0.0129760038,
0.0390637815,
-0.043087218,
0.0273741186,
0.0543436296,
-0.0821258873,
-0.0444034748,
0.0644941479,
0.0680793226,
0.0299288202,
-0.0028355368,
0.0510737412,
-0.0243198667,
0.0339955576,
-0.0141062634,
0.0154394116,
0.018167872,
-0.0463157035,
-0.0056208465,
0.0298762117,
-0.016889153,
-0.0032795996,
0.0625094771,
-0.0834026337,
0.0194367953,
0.0443569757,
0.0266352352,
-0.0397486687,
-0.0809907913,
-0.0610668994,
0.0121947583,
0.02219598,
0.0049202763,
-0.0662435591,
-0.0259092022,
0.0234140195,
0.0226763543,
0.042006921,
-0.0733339936,
0.0378623195,
0.03990639,
-0.0002152545,
-0.0194711592,
-0.0289500356,
-0.0111771645,
-0.0297436267,
0.041780211,
-0.0392730124,
-5.575054527e-33,
-0.0350835063,
-0.0369263366,
0.0100999949,
0.060867656,
-0.0259488672,
-0.0066192509,
-0.0750607997,
0.0176083092,
-0.0142212668,
0.0325751938,
-0.061990425,
0.0409686938,
0.0090819448,
0.0184497237,
0.0021890625,
-0.0211165361,
0.0581527017,
0.0083399946,
-0.0565076135,
0.041395247,
0.0080184266,
-0.033993043,
0.0070161121,
-0.0588960275,
0.0426817462,
-0.0327279493,
-0.0443186089,
-0.0031930152,
0.0124738216,
0.0218013208,
0.0124920504,
0.0708560571,
0.0402164906,
0.0346023105,
-0.0180421006,
0.0479900166,
-0.0166370329,
-0.0731082857,
0.0516654253,
-0.0052981223,
-0.0400985368,
-0.0389103629,
0.0011978555,
-0.0381737873,
-0.0275401175,
0.0077129281,
0.0190882701,
-0.0186169576,
0.0034260435,
-0.020947786,
-0.0395838805,
-0.0062340894,
-0.0322121456,
-0.0611079037,
0.0130313719,
0.0495147333,
0.0188196693,
-0.037625704,
-0.0177043006,
0.0728437752,
0.0020503046,
-0.0201016497,
0.0217357855,
-0.0103826448,
0.0125699649,
0.0600091591,
0.0351223238,
0.0430933759,
-0.0028779537,
0.0068909405,
0.0103319502,
0.0192935262,
0.0022223215,
0.0225399397,
-0.0122442888,
0.0320219435,
-0.0065532005,
0.027004661,
0.0268497299,
0.0233438462,
-0.0146761807,
0.0064099208,
-0.0851039886,
-0.0072561959,
-0.0269550383,
0.0277276915,
0.0057746172,
-0.0194000229,
-0.0026623867,
-0.0239976496,
-0.0062283017,
-0.024798112,
-0.0230455492,
-0.0494887456,
0.0258234423,
-0.0139312185,
-0.0499144793,
0.0058380738,
0.0229381006,
0.0069502657,
-0.0162648838,
0.0252822917,
0.0301797111,
0.0219161864,
0.0399669409,
0.0385450497,
0.0257899091,
0.0208309051,
-0.0087287799,
0.0023823164,
0.0325110443,
0.0426485017,
-0.0318650454,
-0.0347084217,
0.0074626012,
0.0632932335,
-0.0104279798,
0.042216666,
-0.0044866418,
0.0007056707,
-0.0556664802,
0.0370142199,
-0.0131137865,
-0.0040682233,
-0.0393614359,
-0.0174874384,
-0.0106123202,
0.0310253948,
0.0527865514,
-0.0225671083,
-0.0163150169,
-0.0112476805,
2.528e-7,
-0.0024355236,
0.0316894948,
0.0638954416,
0.0188843925,
-0.0171834696,
0.0375759751,
0.0167258773,
0.0294824559,
0.0136471018,
0.006445461,
0.0488582626,
0.0365479253,
0.0330878906,
0.0114228483,
-0.1092147902,
0.0043447074,
-0.0638698116,
-0.01933969,
-0.0272506457,
0.0028015457,
0.0838673264,
0.0587278977,
-0.0009373113,
-0.010493787,
-0.0381957591,
0.0038550282,
0.0222557411,
-0.0502944179,
-0.0061436095,
0.0174178183,
0.0030318962,
0.0292053465,
0.0063688178,
0.0257213879,
0.0429178141,
-0.0011113669,
0.0287143681,
0.0421056412,
0.0184406135,
-0.0674761981,
-0.0230442826,
0.0264088847,
-0.0093973996,
0.0060641044,
0.0418404154,
-0.0490804352,
-0.0437337458,
-0.016374819,
-0.006834073,
0.0030380706,
0.0015462412,
-0.0032395809,
-0.0287501346,
0.0045373542,
-0.0056371973,
-0.0403787084,
0.0402413867,
-0.0653459206,
-0.0074578002,
0.0065508443,
0.0126760872,
-0.0354846381,
0.0001317744,
-0.0103718229,
-0.0173721388,
-0.0768418536,
-0.0039657038,
1.941970851e-34,
0.0544371717,
-0.0111325188,
0.0210583247,
-0.0009946326,
0.0144109037,
-0.003926497,
0.0371012054,
0.0229230206,
0.0572473854,
-0.0496526584,
-0.0202723294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14535v2 | Deep Transfer Learning for Automatic Speech Recognition: Towards Better Generalization | 2023-04-27T21:08:05 | 2023-07-31T11:58:18 | Hamza Kheddar, Yassine Himeur, Somaya Al-Maadeed, Abbes Amira, Faycal Bensaali | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) has recently become an important challenge
when using deep learning (DL). It requires large-scale training datasets and
high computational and storage resources. Moreover, DL techniques and machine
learning (ML) approaches in general, hypothesize that training and testing data
come from the same domain, with the same input feature space and data
distribution characteristics. This assumption, however, is not applicable in
some real-world artificial intelligence (AI) applications. Moreover, there are
situations where gathering real data is challenging, expensive, or rarely
occurring, which can not meet the data requirements of DL models. deep transfer
learning (DTL) has been introduced to overcome these issues, which helps
develop high-performing models using real datasets that are small or slightly
different but related to the training data. This paper presents a comprehensive
survey of DTL-based ASR frameworks to shed light on the latest developments and
helps academics and professionals understand current challenges. Specifically,
after presenting the DTL background, a well-designed taxonomy is adopted to
inform the state-of-the-art. A critical analysis is then conducted to identify
the limitations and advantages of each framework. Moving on, a comparative
study is introduced to highlight the current challenges before deriving
opportunities for future research. | [
-0.0180875864,
0.0746173635,
-0.0143821081,
0.0257252306,
-0.0310867243,
0.0104335025,
0.0720190257,
-0.0389540046,
0.0019126947,
0.0246688575,
-0.0429900475,
-0.0215661377,
0.0153978094,
0.0537323914,
-0.0087033138,
-0.0532364175,
0.0032735497,
-0.0401149057,
-0.0038672588,
0.0069107031,
-0.0450690761,
0.011437933,
-0.0258091539,
-0.0059699817,
-0.0287068728,
0.0458341613,
-0.0035678314,
0.011184535,
0.0414488167,
-0.012989358,
-0.0156028792,
-0.0351138897,
0.0532992333,
0.0162460115,
0.0000020081,
-0.0071907775,
-0.0470682904,
-0.0057434863,
-0.0608869791,
-0.0366027243,
0.0260409787,
-0.0211401917,
0.0243750904,
0.0509881638,
-0.0257780273,
-0.0522668734,
0.0364717618,
0.0275437422,
0.0253621489,
0.0882598162,
-0.035155125,
-0.0085791564,
0.0451783575,
0.0129466895,
-0.0323521905,
-0.0456423685,
0.042525772,
0.0226406287,
0.0106807314,
-0.0416100211,
0.0121323988,
0.0364429243,
0.0487012416,
-0.0033657933,
0.0083682258,
-0.030830035,
-0.0423759334,
-0.0003443056,
-0.0290667657,
0.0750116855,
-0.0033430196,
-0.0165322404,
0.0177311376,
-0.0357185565,
-0.0066406396,
-0.0177226327,
-0.0417866893,
0.0032748852,
0.052703239,
0.0251590293,
-0.0211094823,
0.012546571,
0.0443281196,
-0.0270242244,
-0.0719006658,
0.0283207521,
0.0054286122,
-0.0099709509,
0.0466964915,
0.0052715586,
0.021964239,
0.0107889203,
0.0209284853,
0.0005819579,
-0.017031474,
-0.0131282778,
-0.0493185222,
-0.048485864,
-0.0335378535,
0.0116193648,
0.0246728603,
-0.0050444128,
-0.050611306,
0.0199899618,
-0.0422802046,
0.047341682,
0.0002706677,
0.0121286856,
-0.0286366735,
-0.0557996184,
-0.0596242212,
0.0400951169,
-0.041804906,
0.0515940674,
-0.0055174981,
-0.0472641885,
-0.0207786467,
0.0249640476,
-0.0495810993,
-0.0381839685,
-0.0007237512,
0.0171628967,
-0.031763766,
0.0016930706,
0.0349495448,
0.0428235084,
0.0191560257,
0.0628589839,
0.0225714948,
-0.1047371328,
0.0015339269,
0.0237393007,
0.0680652931,
-0.0409644991,
0.0289060045,
0.061640583,
-0.0174476523,
-0.0258905347,
-0.0178247616,
0.0753390715,
0.0154321063,
-0.0333139747,
0.0518848933,
-0.0427183621,
0.0590853244,
-0.0431059599,
0.0270144846,
-0.0604640879,
-0.0234555937,
-0.0133758411,
0.0006696489,
0.0571213514,
-0.0047458503,
0.0404491313,
0.0319125652,
-0.0190725848,
-0.0120368265,
0.0185118802,
0.0570238084,
0.0060197567,
-0.0261021964,
-0.0716765672,
0.0017050954,
0.0332280807,
0.0197924767,
0.0117174629,
-0.0157645289,
-0.0184961166,
-0.0445653461,
0.0353817455,
0.0340042748,
0.0325314514,
0.005442345,
0.0009274593,
0.0611364357,
0.0264104456,
0.0320799537,
0.0423288792,
0.0350539349,
0.0078760218,
0.0000527388,
-0.0204910729,
-0.0019401002,
0.0074377484,
0.0292209107,
-0.0368742421,
-0.0032241982,
-0.0113767423,
-0.0294875894,
0.0256880429,
0.0340457857,
-0.019751545,
-0.0007189829,
0.0361891054,
0.0728712529,
-0.0055247573,
-0.049013067,
0.0300712883,
0.013905338,
0.0100205662,
0.0351903886,
-0.0477285981,
-0.0004460069,
0.0315802544,
-0.0012369273,
-0.0478962399,
-0.0427205898,
-0.0266707949,
0.0154490788,
0.0298433267,
0.0012164797,
0.0372651741,
0.0614031628,
-0.0500021316,
-0.0341652185,
-0.0120006362,
-0.0175103787,
0.0779854134,
-0.0345525369,
0.0544648804,
0.0019069319,
-0.0190153942,
0.0021530176,
0.0077212891,
-0.0140644573,
-0.0335151032,
0.0801192075,
0.0343219079,
0.0632099211,
-0.0010482968,
-0.031631615,
-0.0407002121,
0.0021518196,
-0.0560543276,
-0.0180357825,
-0.0173459649,
-0.0606803,
0.0154658603,
0.0244946871,
-0.0668387115,
0.0453823917,
0.1063522249,
-0.046853777,
-0.0701444596,
0.0292781107,
0.0087340474,
0.0370244905,
-0.0119770402,
0.011520993,
0.0259927008,
0.0673535317,
0.0028162801,
-0.0399564989,
0.0519403331,
-0.0713872612,
0.008140889,
0.0224276986,
0.0057695988,
-0.0433179662,
-0.0131951701,
0.0198637135,
-0.0603939071,
0.0442747138,
0.0045357733,
0.0344777815,
0.0254175328,
0.0378812067,
-0.0449152291,
0.0044590523,
-0.0225251317,
0.0182326194,
-0.0211689863,
0.0248878617,
-0.0201682057,
-0.0000795178,
-0.0541311838,
0.0142490249,
-0.0056095817,
-0.0259485841,
0.0066647148,
-0.012426706,
-0.0075429995,
-0.0011478538,
-0.0172436945,
0.0222206172,
0.0183516014,
-0.0521525703,
-0.040899314,
-0.0089178765,
0.0256759133,
0.0384272672,
0.0424037799,
0.0010986148,
0.0117547549,
-0.0304131862,
-0.0145653766,
-0.0378008932,
0.0259918217,
-0.0133039346,
-0.0299331043,
-0.0329523683,
-0.0102359587,
-0.065938428,
0.0258061215,
0.0220315941,
0.0031803295,
-0.0053652674,
-0.0121459002,
-0.0283000097,
0.0176139306,
0.0024525819,
0.0186622012,
-0.0210478064,
-0.0268983822,
0.0124015454,
-0.0211887583,
-0.0177161954,
0.0271140337,
-0.0081070289,
0.0013710124,
-0.0057109576,
-0.0054247938,
0.0129671544,
-0.0599509962,
-0.0101575907,
-0.0297471527,
-0.064885661,
-0.041172158,
0.0068249642,
-0.0079809567,
-0.0103294337,
-0.0343153626,
-0.0393119231,
-0.025642002,
0.0071907262,
-0.0099289129,
-0.0192718357,
0.0331979953,
-0.0264684912,
0.015830867,
-0.0388944261,
-0.0271079112,
-0.054550115,
0.031003885,
-0.0130483452,
0.0492996462,
0.0105382111,
-0.0364126749,
-0.0383288823,
-0.0125978617,
-0.0175399818,
0.060206648,
0.0444920771,
0.0091649378,
-0.0459277928,
0.0624001771,
0.0475055315,
0.0221926216,
0.0310275629,
0.0353829078,
-0.0007121798,
-0.0186093412,
0.0362221859,
0.0508400016,
-0.0980831087,
-0.0050367853,
0.043590188,
-0.0046579395,
0.0290099662,
0.0200081617,
0.0270011257,
-0.0317571312,
-0.0197003819,
0.053981144,
-0.0408815071,
-0.0009240429,
0.0001412255,
0.031577751,
0.0052981665,
-0.0401558913,
0.0032791477,
-0.0598722734,
-0.0392977074,
0.0354247652,
0.0175164882,
0.0032175442,
0.000585304,
-0.0068115676,
-0.0942735076,
0.0223229099,
-0.0283895936,
-0.0483774506,
-0.0658525601,
-0.0570249781,
0.0015093196,
-0.023852786,
0.0937891379,
-0.0606703125,
-0.0229605846,
-0.0579578802,
0.063311331,
-0.0750533417,
-0.0734057054,
0.0354733244,
-0.0445106104,
0.0655436292,
0.0536020808,
0.0238072816,
-0.0282828808,
-0.0076059578,
0.0153458118,
0.0167790521,
-0.0023921009,
0.0057224138,
0.008379939,
0.0105402088,
-0.0365500152,
0.039392598,
0.0348745435,
-0.0593524389,
0.0129682031,
0.0359738804,
0.0979241282,
0.0094721094,
-0.0553859621,
-0.0108119687,
-0.0253669266,
0.0460347719,
0.071470052,
0.0171433296,
-0.0436255783,
-0.0045905812,
0.0754336715,
-0.0116465455,
-0.0334638245,
0.0143266488,
0.0111574167,
-0.0186014827,
-0.0187138319,
-0.0386886373,
-0.0030081517,
0.0080009187,
0.0508222952,
0.0436878651,
-0.0228569452,
0.0103514791,
-0.0107743992,
-0.0176054388,
0.0222668629,
-0.0383223891,
0.0393936709,
-0.0166648068,
-0.0195065867,
-0.0178250298,
-0.051699888,
0.0058410317,
-0.0117264446,
-0.0643122643,
-0.0051119667,
-0.0027859982,
0.0008620521,
0.0066537214,
0.0350111835,
-0.0441051684,
-0.0176469535,
0.074944824,
0.0143443141,
-0.0148173822,
-0.0330376551,
0.063286528,
-0.0419797413,
-0.0127595877,
0.0303621516,
-0.0545636043,
0.0507948287,
0.0348218568,
-0.0311325435,
-0.0105157671,
-0.01290615,
-0.0097080469,
0.0271551814,
0.0498147458,
0.0522179455,
-0.0449542664,
-0.0313442945,
0.0347652808,
0.0394784063,
0.0452048071,
-0.0732788146,
-0.0288566407,
0.0371384174,
0.0480838455,
-0.0021537598,
0.0046344758,
0.0412549637,
-0.0375007354,
-0.0117998561,
0.0469167791,
0.0326320939,
0.0581825338,
0.0196988508,
0.0135654015,
0.0019186997,
0.0268997103,
0.0628958568,
0.0274750404,
-0.0060469089,
-0.0167431124,
0.0157329533,
0.0174173284,
0.0094455564,
-0.0273620728,
-0.0336933881,
-0.0682207942,
-0.0275092516,
0.0071036043,
0.0093399491,
-0.0389453657,
0.0578675978,
0.0007145231,
0.0081355525,
-0.0463084951,
0.0319649726,
-0.0468133576,
0.0569520965,
-0.0408911817,
-0.0060544899,
0.014318835,
0.0508989058,
0.0192692373,
0.0152498782,
0.0490266196,
-0.0306991059,
0.0267917737,
-0.0288440604,
-0.0040666135,
0.0400274061,
-0.0226103365,
0.0105440989,
-0.001964011,
0.0248086862,
-0.0391991623,
0.0169199519,
-0.0660556182,
0.0326103345,
-0.0152850831,
0.0267029796,
0.012152249,
-0.0369271599,
0.0192699172,
0.0219692942,
-0.0346203372,
0.0202097967,
-0.0050417818,
-0.0011614005,
-6.206844537e-33,
0.0260126777,
0.0422507375,
0.0173664391,
-0.0138105676,
-0.0366192907,
0.0259416737,
-0.0178538281,
-0.0094943764,
-0.0297521222,
-0.0092359027,
-0.0322431102,
-0.0182498042,
0.0458385572,
0.0591623262,
-0.0097113186,
-0.0347856134,
0.0640566349,
-0.0113495104,
0.0057886089,
0.0283677336,
0.0034271688,
0.0819421113,
0.0369428881,
-0.0752466246,
-0.0794605017,
0.0227808412,
0.0302102398,
-0.0278913751,
0.0287966207,
-0.0133733256,
0.0003488109,
0.0149852065,
0.0113127949,
-0.0604528375,
-0.0449216887,
0.0530497655,
-0.0659555122,
0.0006955624,
-0.0259962827,
0.0522615388,
-0.0141154146,
-0.0035536361,
0.0449222513,
0.0035909712,
0.0194758307,
-0.0324758403,
0.0308736805,
-0.039678663,
-0.015159972,
-0.0480834842,
-0.0285694785,
0.0370403305,
-0.0263036191,
-0.0108027346,
0.0595328324,
0.0281215925,
-0.0527402125,
-0.0156088602,
-0.0555295423,
0.0016507102,
0.0268657655,
0.0002434326,
0.0585970655,
0.027756935,
-0.024011761,
0.0176858958,
0.0551364012,
-0.0723952353,
0.0195531864,
-0.0349074826,
0.0577279404,
0.1057196259,
0.016783556,
0.0334452838,
0.0341440067,
-0.041736722,
-0.0702014342,
-0.0291457772,
0.0037474246,
-0.0010000539,
0.0011340167,
0.017886823,
-0.0469190516,
-0.0111168334,
-0.0045161685,
-0.001722713,
-0.0027883006,
-0.0065977583,
0.0470750481,
0.0011390938,
-0.0176587272,
0.0214600153,
0.0809683129,
-0.050560955,
0.0086966353,
0.0137512404,
-0.0012423191,
-0.0230597947,
-0.0149941863,
-0.0012381129,
-0.081017226,
-0.1075527668,
-0.011027229,
0.0393424816,
0.0385739021,
-0.0174789745,
0.0296912622,
0.0540773273,
-0.0246214662,
-0.020928124,
-0.0413347632,
0.0313257836,
-0.0130513031,
0.0469690636,
0.010392271,
-0.0192235913,
0.0165001173,
0.0497185141,
-0.0320454277,
0.0115667395,
0.0167319868,
0.0297595188,
0.0317608863,
0.0041471794,
-0.0424851812,
-0.007327592,
-0.0513211526,
-0.0554810837,
0.0262262654,
-0.031506326,
-0.0017215412,
-0.0150813209,
2.764e-7,
-0.0421901941,
-0.0041944906,
0.0348615199,
-0.045419082,
0.0068331878,
0.0231341571,
-0.0095122214,
0.0263182689,
-0.0057974556,
0.0310256984,
0.0387195833,
0.0456711799,
0.09246099,
0.0181910452,
-0.0552715771,
-0.055415567,
-0.0425781943,
0.0134226726,
-0.0319663994,
-0.0332028605,
-0.0309808962,
0.0605725013,
0.0008908191,
-0.0800228715,
0.05328504,
-0.0286475793,
-0.0080354773,
-0.0271178801,
0.053309802,
0.0051414277,
0.0032129984,
0.0089167114,
-0.0079243919,
0.0415477529,
0.000506281,
0.0405182615,
0.0428113937,
0.0267187711,
0.0279946607,
-0.0518760271,
-0.0092656622,
0.0160064418,
0.014472357,
0.0177941434,
0.0745006055,
-0.0624453239,
-0.0243725907,
-0.0447454676,
-0.0568725578,
-0.0157611016,
0.0216507055,
-0.0156536158,
0.0545576029,
0.0016608667,
0.0192400087,
-0.0187904965,
-0.0857565701,
-0.046089977,
0.053443674,
0.0245568454,
-0.0741780847,
0.0149078192,
-0.0517228134,
0.0008298802,
0.0257725902,
0.0092974547,
0.0505147986,
1.807019048e-34,
-0.0459435359,
0.0041460451,
0.0089235455,
-0.0467423573,
-0.037913397,
-0.0325939097,
-0.0213419441,
0.0192767549,
0.0035440817,
-0.0367686562,
-0.0075151813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14522v1 | Multivariate Representation Learning for Information Retrieval | 2023-04-27T20:30:46 | 2023-04-27T20:30:46 | Hamed Zamani, Michael Bendersky | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Dense retrieval models use bi-encoder network architectures for learning
query and document representations. These representations are often in the form
of a vector representation and their similarities are often computed using the
dot product function. In this paper, we propose a new representation learning
framework for dense retrieval. Instead of learning a vector for each query and
document, our framework learns a multivariate distribution and uses negative
multivariate KL divergence to compute the similarity between distributions. For
simplicity and efficiency reasons, we assume that the distributions are
multivariate normals and then train large language models to produce mean and
variance vectors for these distributions. We provide a theoretical foundation
for the proposed framework and show that it can be seamlessly integrated into
the existing approximate nearest neighbor algorithms to perform retrieval
efficiently. We conduct an extensive suite of experiments on a wide range of
datasets, and demonstrate significant improvements compared to competitive
dense retrieval models. | [
-0.0165710319,
0.012881537,
0.001138831,
0.0106908185,
-0.0007056579,
0.021507524,
0.0060009686,
0.0179365929,
0.0072710807,
0.0006415693,
-0.0445947573,
-0.0187224504,
-0.0348555446,
0.0473210402,
0.0191786438,
-0.0159299262,
0.0121214204,
0.0474170409,
0.009014559,
-0.0221489668,
0.0276036188,
0.026866572,
0.0154620623,
0.0178890955,
0.0096769175,
0.0372450091,
0.001334206,
0.0228129514,
0.0028228436,
0.0055992077,
0.0001244947,
-0.0122340349,
0.0863950923,
-0.0315352716,
0.0000014503,
-0.0144995404,
-0.0162149668,
0.0063841827,
0.02822957,
-0.0002120816,
0.0336788334,
-0.034772709,
0.0780263394,
-0.0023088087,
-0.021482382,
-0.0406896062,
0.0424111523,
0.0460255034,
0.0545498617,
0.0132625028,
-0.0332861096,
-0.0361083448,
0.0332600698,
-0.0216152221,
0.0181004014,
-0.0422069952,
0.0212582108,
-0.0005196254,
0.0070013935,
0.0476288982,
0.0060835793,
0.0585752763,
-0.0084256371,
0.0172827486,
0.0358353071,
0.0555915311,
-0.010236307,
0.0402100049,
0.0295380801,
0.0723888427,
-0.053008955,
-0.0348970667,
0.0065621375,
0.0120574813,
-0.0216416121,
0.0579027757,
-0.0229128748,
-0.0306125432,
-0.0121765919,
0.0040178834,
-0.0708266273,
0.0089092655,
0.0232847407,
0.0268571358,
-0.0147765065,
-0.012701585,
0.0237333681,
-0.0287263151,
0.007765926,
0.00874063,
-0.0167368986,
0.0719017237,
0.0290144738,
-0.0408228375,
0.0292716715,
-0.0180779602,
0.0241155848,
-0.0530825295,
0.0125428326,
-0.0926565528,
0.0208688751,
0.0110702515,
-0.0459531955,
0.0650451481,
-0.0164820068,
0.0486361459,
-0.0119925383,
0.0363911539,
-0.0410693847,
-0.0217334609,
-0.046251636,
-0.025227014,
-0.0328398608,
0.0409578532,
0.0014160569,
-0.0202554315,
-0.0125121856,
0.0479782894,
-0.0172899328,
-0.0258400198,
-0.0025020733,
0.0700733513,
-0.0024386027,
-0.0071232491,
-0.0248322356,
0.0340116769,
-0.0568726994,
0.0062314463,
-0.0380871817,
0.0083366744,
0.0058535421,
0.0352779776,
0.0243969597,
-0.0479522087,
0.009619657,
-0.0247255452,
-0.0278832,
-0.0317778811,
0.0011707413,
-0.0091271186,
-0.0101443874,
0.0019242483,
-0.0028603829,
-0.0605113581,
0.0530629531,
-0.0061528478,
-0.0230822545,
-0.0612729117,
-0.0333233774,
0.0207043067,
-0.0272723548,
0.0744087771,
0.0560647063,
-0.0139067359,
0.0792056173,
-0.0183142759,
0.0485013649,
0.0290064998,
-0.039616961,
-0.0020416575,
0.0367013179,
0.0175286811,
0.018612422,
-0.0271234214,
0.0543822087,
0.0149486791,
-0.0554279089,
0.035146229,
-0.0147453137,
0.0699461028,
0.0390500724,
0.0238323975,
-0.0867611393,
-0.0660046861,
0.0077275988,
0.0409474522,
0.0211739596,
-0.0171910524,
0.0133838449,
0.017009981,
-0.0702842623,
-0.0359310061,
-0.0011914517,
0.046368029,
-0.0466042124,
-0.0175300278,
0.0529402234,
-0.0074915378,
-0.0928328261,
0.0160543807,
0.0384237915,
-0.0151856765,
-0.0262409952,
0.0117988707,
0.047119204,
-0.0529764742,
0.0023276943,
0.0284663979,
-0.0086580152,
-0.0240070801,
0.0273458511,
-0.0008772213,
0.0029633327,
0.0338164195,
0.0458529964,
-0.0360933281,
0.0388269909,
-0.0105561726,
-0.0103006046,
-0.0256810244,
0.0494670272,
-0.0326946788,
0.0003968738,
-0.0616978146,
-0.0480563939,
0.0025259475,
0.0030135587,
0.0268816445,
-0.0355299897,
0.0436878763,
0.0870229453,
-0.1187394783,
0.0196424872,
-0.0013667517,
-0.0018834578,
-0.0364826396,
0.0474528261,
0.0414406955,
-0.0105684455,
-0.0009165735,
-0.0220997464,
0.0215925016,
0.0301462505,
-0.0255535394,
-0.0457392558,
-0.0252564978,
-0.017332254,
-0.0240019411,
0.0112896822,
-0.0186628569,
0.0968549177,
0.0295355339,
0.0110382168,
-0.0389461294,
0.0363662951,
-0.0066736443,
0.0105152391,
-0.0574042909,
-0.0235479902,
0.0021000959,
0.0283395723,
-0.0478055403,
0.0263037141,
-0.0210145824,
0.0666615292,
-0.0285834018,
0.0044021741,
0.0182423741,
-0.019080542,
-0.0464544334,
-0.0076213768,
0.01160671,
0.051347997,
0.0453988612,
-0.0467127003,
0.006580296,
0.0041458453,
-0.0461685881,
-0.0036925392,
-0.0156395435,
-0.0114897639,
-0.0031170775,
0.0137991784,
0.0083467746,
-0.0266840272,
-0.0473056696,
-0.0102116233,
0.0142999636,
0.0168865286,
0.0281540025,
0.0309491102,
-0.0188233163,
-0.0038847437,
-0.0582903549,
0.0315655693,
0.0455156416,
-0.0647803172,
-0.0223007165,
0.0065292888,
-0.0039603263,
-0.0577143319,
0.0258082263,
-0.0208382271,
0.0111522758,
0.0135457879,
-0.07780388,
0.026580723,
0.0548381731,
0.0221560393,
-0.0320683308,
0.038830284,
-0.000339589,
-0.1224187985,
0.0061588939,
-0.0531400554,
0.0120557854,
0.0043583997,
0.0137263713,
0.0093638506,
-0.0367760062,
0.0119454553,
-0.0101964511,
-0.0508029647,
0.0079885973,
0.0204357747,
-0.0117861433,
-0.1049634665,
0.0325290598,
0.0228954479,
-0.0058544441,
-0.0138371438,
-0.0540965721,
0.0557886139,
-0.0038238908,
0.0005461421,
-0.0020283987,
-0.0137996674,
-0.0213209223,
0.0705400333,
-0.02504896,
0.0192300528,
-0.0284186583,
-0.0155621218,
-0.0075697601,
0.0173027646,
0.0476704836,
-0.0340761207,
0.031348329,
-0.0017483922,
0.0490059145,
0.0167410523,
-0.056547258,
-0.0047582025,
-0.0614610314,
0.0450661369,
0.0015921158,
-0.0369330123,
-0.0144780949,
-0.067602247,
0.037703108,
-0.0039800792,
0.0296129026,
-0.013578672,
-0.0263940971,
0.0318647288,
0.067572169,
0.034421578,
-0.0081893327,
-0.0527806841,
0.0047410475,
-0.0320598669,
0.0220799483,
0.0133709023,
-0.0244211294,
-0.0035388814,
0.0099568022,
0.0331840217,
0.006418583,
-0.0322973505,
0.0011836267,
-0.0122096268,
0.0508171618,
-0.0379595347,
0.0744531825,
0.0347590186,
-0.0949859023,
-0.0556831323,
-0.010798472,
0.0192650538,
0.0448181666,
0.0408734381,
-0.0137327919,
0.0049108001,
-0.0422534682,
0.0711295083,
0.0418124869,
-0.0311291385,
0.0253876634,
-0.0666936934,
-0.0052616247,
-0.0098226452,
0.0013499933,
-0.099202849,
-0.0596077517,
0.0133017916,
-0.013525988,
-0.0163455363,
0.00682199,
0.0128892725,
-0.030489089,
0.0203875639,
0.0347963348,
-0.0442039631,
0.0063203899,
-0.0445783772,
-0.008972385,
0.0351353362,
0.0101512522,
0.0105572734,
-0.0393473804,
-0.0585929938,
-0.0698596388,
-0.0095375404,
-0.0166022889,
0.0608798303,
-0.0257763639,
0.0014082801,
0.0031195395,
-0.007272277,
-0.0466962568,
0.0083709694,
-0.0385537967,
0.0530635491,
-0.0649743006,
-0.0105451895,
-0.0476004221,
-0.0438675769,
0.0003418657,
0.0229729638,
-0.0129841967,
0.02404055,
-0.0102226399,
0.0393301025,
0.0489963628,
0.0280759595,
0.0063980431,
-0.0247632395,
-0.0049110926,
-0.0202747695,
-0.054408405,
-0.0100919437,
0.0056876754,
0.0506601445,
-0.0277043357,
-0.0034634892,
-0.0053236885,
-0.0637563542,
-0.0392524414,
0.0025658146,
-0.0143425371,
0.0010894063,
0.0021727374,
0.0004927354,
0.0708882883,
-0.0195620675,
-0.0562376902,
-0.038092237,
-0.066557616,
-0.0318822078,
-0.0415226296,
0.0187585726,
0.0034949633,
0.0330018587,
-0.0369506814,
-0.062911272,
0.0552235991,
0.0698715076,
-0.0504670665,
-0.010143484,
-0.0057583437,
-0.0368378498,
-0.0068459203,
0.0334125869,
-0.0491419621,
0.0342500508,
-0.0175073091,
-0.0002455176,
-0.0472682156,
-0.0778078884,
0.0139459623,
0.0016479901,
0.0722763166,
0.0269933324,
0.033812888,
-0.0804088339,
-0.0146691753,
-0.0100599648,
-0.0126588047,
-0.0114218639,
-0.0071490351,
0.0561510473,
-0.0277362019,
-0.0294084549,
0.0500413589,
0.0353083573,
0.0384747609,
-0.0511740148,
-0.0188068971,
0.0449238047,
0.0130445519,
-0.0070891939,
0.0068343501,
-0.0276619568,
0.0221737791,
0.0029970116,
0.0449620709,
-0.0488120355,
-0.0150086181,
0.0073343879,
0.0152164735,
-0.0585046597,
0.0220290739,
-0.0735893101,
-0.0428804569,
-0.0127171623,
0.013326495,
0.0472667851,
-0.0360990837,
-0.0146428589,
-0.0106118647,
-0.0078295209,
-0.0430290848,
-0.0197463743,
0.0301909521,
-0.0007484172,
0.0490447506,
0.0291809291,
0.0091445288,
-0.0119562093,
0.0638599694,
-0.0267872587,
0.0371662863,
-0.0638350993,
-0.038591709,
-0.0279819854,
0.0268279761,
0.0434630141,
0.0633118302,
-0.0204716325,
0.014375207,
0.0140579827,
-0.001359342,
0.0576538481,
-0.0495312437,
-0.0246343613,
0.0350964926,
0.0842486471,
0.0991634056,
0.0033394275,
0.0074923746,
-0.0267849043,
-0.0066244951,
-0.0286612678,
-0.0123381708,
-0.0208062753,
-5.713141317e-33,
0.0212015025,
0.0107846623,
0.0021399413,
-0.0620514452,
-0.0035648823,
0.0098674363,
0.0259876121,
-0.0215602238,
-0.0317617916,
-0.0123377526,
0.0032000607,
0.0186993405,
-0.0036378754,
0.0045178621,
0.0137333758,
-0.0231397431,
0.0415683948,
0.0065691685,
0.0294535067,
0.0306387022,
0.0457780883,
0.0527282767,
0.0377106704,
-0.0799653605,
-0.0043053008,
-0.0444488004,
0.0055400035,
0.0347228162,
0.0579169579,
0.0461040139,
-0.0211892501,
0.0481814556,
0.0219826251,
0.0013441495,
-0.0160622839,
-0.0204957444,
-0.0356286429,
-0.0300548691,
-0.0378911793,
-0.0299365949,
0.0046176538,
0.0297570545,
0.0625112131,
-0.0114231464,
0.0059618573,
0.0104597211,
0.0663913488,
0.0262336247,
-0.0707462579,
-0.0232140273,
0.0092815291,
0.0476364568,
-0.0003272185,
0.0067494838,
0.0416641645,
0.0231136736,
0.0188135114,
0.0034477087,
-0.0506379269,
0.0355077311,
-0.097233057,
0.0468498208,
-0.0093081752,
0.0245648436,
0.0073808227,
0.0653743297,
0.0338177569,
-0.0495544523,
-0.0262416527,
-0.0071589448,
0.0408664979,
0.0015162862,
0.0032700635,
0.058898747,
0.0078852838,
-0.0687206984,
-0.0274189543,
0.0654190183,
0.0042336355,
0.0297441538,
0.0218255855,
0.0296747051,
-0.0498277619,
-0.0346420966,
-0.0230346676,
-0.0066521517,
-0.0324612856,
-0.0105765928,
0.0287410691,
0.0331022777,
0.0048993905,
0.0262903739,
0.029936092,
-0.0228249095,
-0.0357737355,
0.0505495071,
0.0107609686,
-0.0013967296,
0.0216270275,
-0.0054809521,
-0.0203901827,
-0.0544420779,
-0.0034460155,
-0.0076603112,
-0.0383433513,
0.0091117444,
0.0009396011,
0.0086871963,
-0.0586728603,
-0.0193160325,
0.0145509858,
-0.0675314143,
-0.0144505436,
0.0447680801,
-0.0051793875,
0.0419912525,
0.0116577931,
0.0452291332,
0.0261629131,
-0.0047091269,
-0.0050959708,
-0.0625948012,
0.0497126691,
-0.0025583019,
-0.0008168762,
0.022428507,
-0.0629379079,
-0.034003105,
0.0512660071,
-0.0497657545,
-0.0064945407,
0.01622767,
2.312e-7,
0.0700620711,
0.0148943448,
0.0103486469,
0.0074295914,
-0.0356731564,
0.013579974,
-0.0052569453,
0.0624120533,
0.0077026533,
-0.0157273524,
0.0516487136,
0.0157235768,
-0.014001972,
0.0281179734,
-0.094543606,
0.0205308273,
-0.0611923523,
0.00980906,
-0.0390151069,
-0.0080987532,
0.0876192972,
0.0743847713,
0.0184844211,
-0.0176310092,
0.0399084426,
-0.0564347245,
0.0883800909,
0.0085234195,
0.022933688,
-0.0116553465,
0.0392218716,
0.0196884908,
0.0230684504,
0.0177356545,
-0.010246465,
0.040401075,
0.0488552861,
0.0285730753,
-0.0377206281,
-0.0567928627,
0.0187963173,
0.0046300776,
-0.0005032292,
-0.0195226073,
0.0817832202,
0.0063808337,
0.0148716467,
0.002360624,
-0.0238983333,
0.0428927653,
0.068554081,
0.0072515905,
-0.0564068742,
0.0103335539,
0.024307657,
-0.002776081,
0.0205776449,
-0.0798701048,
0.0374743454,
0.0103851557,
-0.0320962742,
0.0188490693,
-0.0408267006,
0.0113388747,
0.0212010369,
0.0332147293,
-0.0052607493,
1.389023474e-34,
0.0249128044,
0.0478651822,
0.0048781633,
-0.0344531164,
-0.0232189149,
-0.0260229204,
-0.0329391211,
0.0114549873,
0.0145611744,
-0.065707542,
-0.0190385841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14514v1 | Understanding Shared Speech-Text Representations | 2023-04-27T20:05:36 | 2023-04-27T20:05:36 | Gary Wang, Kyle Kastner, Ankur Bapna, Zhehuai Chen, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, a number of approaches to train speech models by incorpo-rating
text into end-to-end models have been developed, with Mae-stro advancing
state-of-the-art automatic speech recognition (ASR)and Speech Translation (ST)
performance. In this paper, we expandour understanding of the resulting shared
speech-text representationswith two types of analyses. First we examine the
limits of speech-free domain adaptation, finding that a corpus-specific
duration modelfor speech-text alignment is the most important component for
learn-ing a shared speech-text representation. Second, we inspect the
sim-ilarities between activations of unimodal (speech or text) encodersas
compared to the activations of a shared encoder. We find that theshared encoder
learns a more compact and overlapping speech-textrepresentation than the
uni-modal encoders. We hypothesize that thispartially explains the
effectiveness of the Maestro shared speech-textrepresentations. | [
-0.0406177603,
0.0097119482,
0.0102240127,
0.021855237,
-0.0285374187,
-0.0027585684,
0.0582951345,
-0.0091425767,
-0.1078900099,
-0.0242506675,
-0.1119109169,
-0.0324860178,
0.0592558198,
0.0496004522,
0.0000552354,
-0.0417166874,
-0.000455374,
-0.0306280516,
-0.0301738009,
-0.0280055981,
0.0549785085,
-0.0091679096,
-0.0499722362,
0.0075945202,
0.0036944801,
-0.0070728874,
-0.0132142743,
0.0023967095,
0.0132679539,
-0.0015008475,
-0.0174566731,
0.0015562142,
0.0449751988,
0.0467933789,
0.0000017526,
-0.048667144,
-0.0244253464,
0.005004304,
-0.0190622397,
-0.0021061986,
0.0524135679,
-0.0191822927,
0.0104735279,
0.0549106672,
0.0198684372,
0.0046014697,
0.0689376816,
0.032558497,
-0.0078299018,
0.0727781877,
-0.0265350509,
-0.0249878839,
-0.0038751217,
-0.0491586663,
-0.0565144233,
-0.018398609,
-0.0151248146,
-0.0263263024,
-0.0155876661,
-0.0075404602,
-0.0577145293,
0.0527731925,
-0.0190639459,
0.0037359514,
0.0324327797,
0.0046128077,
0.0007554055,
-0.0163053926,
-0.0275093205,
0.0496497005,
0.0247280486,
-0.0167697035,
0.0007310696,
0.0020709063,
-0.0266491398,
0.0298305377,
-0.0006485256,
0.0225885808,
0.022724634,
0.0158762112,
-0.0230934788,
0.0900503695,
0.0126861967,
-0.0715582594,
-0.0261743404,
-0.0162690934,
0.0240363199,
-0.04949525,
0.0089209089,
-0.0180421006,
-0.0037570158,
-0.0031768961,
0.0917222574,
0.0024112505,
0.0250460971,
0.0096940491,
-0.0666804388,
-0.0504000075,
-0.0185653139,
-0.0370268151,
-0.0045801066,
0.0639122277,
-0.0712546855,
-0.00902755,
-0.0163743272,
0.0940619558,
0.006960215,
0.0351703502,
-0.04154329,
-0.0239420421,
-0.0527980961,
-0.0183213782,
-0.0161555726,
0.0147697255,
-0.0470015369,
-0.0529520065,
-0.0178498775,
0.0212140419,
-0.0070721922,
0.0145526137,
0.0442456268,
-0.0137719018,
-0.0473672487,
-0.0075144744,
-0.0127288084,
0.081184864,
0.0040110713,
0.0428486094,
0.0012032877,
0.0021096289,
-0.0236135107,
0.0176796839,
0.041389592,
-0.008612589,
-0.008480275,
0.0329889283,
-0.032690566,
-0.0206505023,
-0.0209034048,
0.0147178257,
-0.0619867221,
-0.0414784513,
-0.000583809,
-0.0387309529,
0.0483155511,
0.038925305,
0.0086084791,
-0.0465804748,
-0.0252182931,
-0.0112541188,
0.0409190841,
0.0482741743,
0.005440996,
0.0103261229,
0.0483555086,
-0.0080910642,
0.028662337,
0.0535063036,
0.0602228083,
-0.0237015821,
-0.0200187862,
-0.0316230394,
-0.0090053109,
0.0688260719,
0.0074707884,
0.0070179189,
0.0039349026,
-0.0094545586,
0.0464801975,
0.0490888655,
0.0444646738,
0.0376647934,
-0.0157709531,
-0.0438573621,
0.0762998983,
0.0580425821,
0.0215447824,
0.0204650518,
0.0285179876,
0.0175578929,
-0.0137976557,
0.0180112626,
0.0170268435,
0.0107422015,
0.0125689749,
0.0160041749,
0.0362409651,
0.0460159555,
-0.0246997308,
-0.0450066254,
-0.0212711301,
-0.0395827331,
0.0086426698,
-0.0299482141,
0.039424222,
0.0248910114,
-0.0720915198,
0.0130748115,
-0.0085797226,
-0.0390660129,
0.0427611843,
0.0105105042,
-0.0394501947,
0.0367034823,
0.0079699075,
-0.0152607318,
-0.0145504279,
-0.021120429,
-0.0345406197,
0.0636355132,
-0.0033877098,
0.035681989,
0.0237585045,
-0.0893652216,
-0.0237789564,
0.0080560725,
-0.0147859687,
0.0376879759,
-0.0554376543,
0.0411939509,
-0.0050270907,
0.0135905668,
0.0213326905,
0.0002058399,
-0.0134188896,
-0.0013303449,
0.00126136,
0.0259007383,
0.0498371758,
0.0205683634,
-0.046239838,
0.0100905178,
0.0260850731,
-0.0181201752,
-0.0449688211,
0.0617944002,
-0.1075306833,
-0.0467298515,
0.010575898,
-0.0308932178,
0.0452066995,
0.0303885192,
0.048272159,
-0.0924716517,
0.0141756143,
-0.0276845712,
0.0338805318,
0.0055583031,
0.0619510897,
0.0168874525,
0.0187641084,
0.0113420822,
-0.0123810824,
0.0248133671,
-0.0082003791,
0.0389643945,
0.024479799,
0.0411134623,
-0.0592108145,
-0.0227530375,
0.0305832606,
-0.0059870407,
0.0128108738,
0.0041652918,
-0.0638133809,
0.0301439092,
-0.0301845837,
-0.092639789,
0.0115270903,
-0.0166817978,
0.0494504906,
0.0515134409,
0.0145544708,
0.0121166585,
-0.0088198576,
-0.0426432379,
-0.0119555155,
0.0025640647,
-0.0177721903,
-0.016702814,
-0.0079714609,
-0.0403797589,
-0.0229249466,
0.0168027114,
0.0248966105,
0.0277016871,
-0.0246212091,
-0.0370929241,
-0.0580378585,
0.0282299779,
0.0160820689,
0.0252958406,
-0.0043245354,
-0.0403053537,
0.0072764568,
0.0532145463,
0.0394837558,
0.0376605615,
0.0249603782,
0.021713946,
0.0218805,
0.0115417894,
-0.0557757877,
-0.0082848072,
0.0044018291,
0.0093354238,
-0.0444668569,
0.0250273868,
-0.0143002924,
0.0606263615,
0.0230902974,
0.05066121,
-0.0794960931,
-0.0547314137,
0.0118235629,
-0.0473711193,
0.0193603281,
-0.0506178662,
-0.0169662945,
-0.0051696324,
-0.0258129071,
-0.0554755628,
0.0187957268,
-0.0856246352,
-0.0554175451,
-0.0680758879,
-0.0191248059,
-0.0195011552,
0.0159304477,
0.0054934891,
0.0259372555,
-0.0075649996,
-0.0469940454,
-0.0352893583,
0.0408062898,
0.003201558,
-0.0163217168,
0.0105826147,
0.0084895929,
-0.0062391963,
0.0026443403,
-0.0368602648,
0.0081074834,
0.0098150987,
-0.0267068036,
0.0306343734,
-0.0146122407,
-0.0347106606,
-0.0412864946,
0.025223393,
0.031221142,
0.0560078174,
0.0006547998,
0.0263644941,
-0.0433947071,
0.0362817124,
0.0229610335,
0.0096952347,
-0.0602064021,
-0.0341084376,
0.0324003398,
-0.0108289635,
0.0221206583,
0.0097623356,
-0.0431431867,
-0.0162385739,
0.0079368018,
-0.0044998117,
-0.0227647424,
-0.0022974396,
0.0598564334,
0.0059074969,
-0.0014788951,
0.0920036361,
-0.0111205466,
-0.0281192157,
-0.0156789515,
-0.0075119063,
0.0490267873,
0.0293554459,
-0.039749518,
-0.0313918516,
-0.0348966829,
0.0305420868,
0.0174247604,
0.0395971909,
0.0576805584,
-0.0120036937,
-0.0701116771,
-0.0238798168,
0.0396196432,
-0.0369155295,
-0.0347263403,
-0.0175325852,
-0.0380043983,
-0.0341711156,
0.0566569418,
-0.0227092672,
-0.0250141751,
-0.0231046341,
0.0574857555,
-0.0302704833,
-0.0304303151,
-0.0114874765,
-0.0289831441,
0.0719648227,
0.0557376035,
0.0029083795,
-0.0041594752,
-0.0277640466,
0.0130224098,
0.0017718208,
0.0334170386,
0.0133092655,
0.0453016311,
-0.0124156792,
-0.0034401079,
0.024126919,
0.0362601914,
-0.0203778185,
0.0031465283,
-0.0045974865,
0.040354196,
-0.0144419791,
0.022735754,
0.0209637396,
0.0081665823,
-0.0180311836,
0.0689516813,
-0.0133595588,
-0.0344956778,
-0.0110491021,
0.0306563713,
0.0505614765,
-0.0082638506,
-0.0244193505,
0.019304093,
-0.0239297189,
-0.0210643262,
-0.0532246642,
-0.0134612462,
0.0030502884,
0.0604506284,
0.0415271223,
-0.0222844817,
-0.0026207615,
0.0018424473,
0.0076852893,
-0.012453544,
-0.0163674932,
0.0296255425,
-0.0622053109,
-0.0083669694,
0.0095817735,
-0.054692924,
-0.0164781753,
-0.0457282104,
-0.0740413591,
-0.0668149218,
0.0022483964,
-0.0351982042,
0.0236720759,
0.0590461791,
-0.000004143,
-0.0420071743,
0.1282776445,
0.0003838677,
-0.0420553647,
0.0525538102,
0.0351327546,
-0.0024149013,
-0.0184582472,
-0.0124866823,
-0.0271919426,
0.0104517993,
-0.0186215062,
-0.0080658663,
0.0301741268,
-0.0505653135,
-0.005155975,
0.0007625162,
0.0140981227,
0.0127317198,
0.0323828086,
-0.0386443511,
0.0545717701,
-0.0028763886,
0.0795676932,
-0.0428437218,
-0.0231624022,
0.0428506881,
0.0265752058,
0.0126486747,
0.0471225828,
-0.0057076751,
-0.0378218442,
0.0248239487,
0.0153022865,
0.0187820066,
0.0259741452,
-0.0228398237,
0.0372076444,
0.0005076312,
0.031694442,
0.0111655733,
0.0033949132,
-0.0072705271,
0.0467198528,
-0.0145023307,
0.0334572531,
0.0192158446,
0.0251571666,
-0.0317690894,
-0.01716852,
-0.0229496621,
-0.0032480371,
0.0079365727,
-0.0121707767,
0.0749282464,
0.0028041431,
0.0471446328,
-0.0357661471,
0.0076113702,
-0.0497855581,
0.0302968044,
0.0264230631,
-0.0424951203,
-0.0085063437,
0.008584871,
0.0738348737,
-0.0011830878,
0.0371922106,
-0.0450058877,
0.0266951248,
-0.0115283364,
-0.0391188413,
0.0146389399,
0.0119663896,
-0.0359499902,
-0.0779078528,
0.0203887634,
-0.0351979062,
0.0499081127,
-0.0157691073,
0.026145298,
-0.0389385149,
0.0299414434,
-0.0125378417,
-0.0751958117,
0.0192133244,
0.0351618081,
-0.045322869,
0.018589858,
0.0100463592,
0.005248718,
-5.740125892e-33,
-0.0360536091,
0.0479625724,
0.026432585,
-0.0049678762,
-0.059113238,
-0.0012844277,
-0.0062662442,
0.0186649207,
0.0373351239,
-0.020367533,
0.0108237481,
0.0004081513,
0.0311573073,
0.0232374035,
-0.0085474299,
-0.0224096794,
0.0830343813,
-0.0465138257,
-0.0239425451,
-0.0085511617,
0.0841872692,
0.0189440362,
0.0260694306,
-0.0968074203,
-0.0152666885,
-0.0173916612,
-0.0213931091,
-0.0322417133,
0.0336012915,
0.0546749271,
0.0144204358,
0.0193472747,
0.0095540509,
-0.031539578,
-0.037764471,
0.0466912724,
-0.0710619986,
0.0008605928,
0.0244814381,
0.0557124242,
-0.0270381104,
-0.0356470272,
0.0813455433,
0.0022659611,
-0.0041639097,
-0.0613090657,
0.0363551006,
-0.0190248396,
0.0243475921,
-0.0116510801,
-0.0738768056,
0.0044791489,
-0.0420606174,
-0.015573347,
0.0718178228,
0.0475509204,
0.0044424767,
-0.0012646164,
-0.0608186312,
0.0005214183,
-0.0422510393,
0.0663753971,
0.0591829009,
0.0475406386,
-0.00372681,
0.0363841988,
0.0405649766,
-0.0494834632,
0.0251831617,
-0.043561127,
0.0248606317,
0.0003730459,
0.0315403156,
0.0328816958,
0.0505944639,
-0.0286851544,
-0.050632365,
-0.0052669537,
-0.0322661661,
-0.0442676097,
0.0142130498,
0.0490752272,
-0.0457223281,
0.007596835,
-0.0826518759,
-0.0283937901,
-0.0281874966,
-0.0422322452,
0.0671493486,
0.0251716431,
0.0382009298,
0.0274341777,
0.0779550821,
0.004554708,
0.0064735948,
-0.0299531873,
-0.0090491017,
0.0153481653,
-0.0254444424,
0.0124394782,
-0.0759555474,
-0.0559649728,
0.0420910083,
0.041844666,
0.0102017364,
-0.0242062807,
0.0454061851,
0.0328751765,
-0.0581034087,
-0.0140094971,
-0.0024780624,
-0.0295373295,
0.004188756,
0.0199518539,
0.0458932295,
0.0177953821,
-0.0087291189,
0.046494402,
-0.0191074666,
-0.0034941211,
-0.0266210977,
-0.0508257374,
0.0307655483,
0.0195382312,
-0.037767034,
0.0009895983,
0.0072240066,
-0.0187827591,
0.0459293686,
-0.0212513078,
-0.0019377694,
0.0019602894,
2.575e-7,
0.0093554826,
-0.008544649,
0.0650971904,
-0.0547091439,
0.0493989959,
0.0217531007,
-0.0245492943,
0.0576571599,
0.0151265403,
0.0005654246,
0.0086363154,
-0.0033504881,
0.0673254505,
-0.0033799142,
-0.0326419584,
-0.0255425498,
-0.0646477342,
0.0179633442,
-0.0320721157,
0.0210121274,
0.042754367,
0.0667525455,
-0.0277491696,
0.0032528122,
-0.0127904583,
-0.0300330184,
0.079370901,
-0.0221637376,
0.0149870384,
0.0085238675,
-0.0127269477,
-0.0262060985,
-0.0629894063,
0.0371290408,
-0.0107597196,
0.0641131252,
0.0448093116,
0.0209183395,
-0.0096093267,
-0.062930122,
-0.0001371808,
0.0319266543,
-0.0759616047,
0.0222782493,
0.0502337925,
-0.0441407636,
-0.030261023,
-0.0107625658,
-0.0309647303,
0.023131812,
0.01249287,
0.0329091847,
0.008214701,
0.0209043156,
0.0210556984,
0.0445567593,
-0.0292052291,
-0.0259430241,
-0.0085313274,
0.0026790728,
-0.0698399693,
-0.0254386012,
-0.0871828794,
0.0031151068,
0.0234601088,
-0.0510187,
-0.0101660304,
1.84578878e-34,
-0.0046093469,
-0.0452442989,
0.0215122215,
-0.0194213465,
-0.0179054327,
-0.0925904214,
0.025882164,
0.0209629126,
-0.0038808095,
-0.0536972173,
-0.0257494934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14511v1 | Visual Referential Games Further the Emergence of Disentangled Representations | 2023-04-27T20:00:51 | 2023-04-27T20:00:51 | Kevin Denamganaï, Sondess Missaoui, James Alfred Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural languages are powerful tools wielded by human beings to communicate
information. Among their desirable properties, compositionality has been the
main focus in the context of referential games and variants, as it promises to
enable greater systematicity to the agents which would wield it. The concept of
disentanglement has been shown to be of paramount importance to learned
representations that generalise well in deep learning, and is thought to be a
necessary condition to enable systematicity. Thus, this paper investigates how
do compositionality at the level of the emerging languages, disentanglement at
the level of the learned representations, and systematicity relate to each
other in the context of visual referential games. Firstly, we find that visual
referential games that are based on the Obverter architecture outperforms
state-of-the-art unsupervised learning approach in terms of many major
disentanglement metrics. Secondly, we expand the previously proposed Positional
Disentanglement (PosDis) metric for compositionality to (re-)incorporate some
concerns pertaining to informativeness and completeness features found in the
Mutual Information Gap (MIG) disentanglement metric it stems from. This
extension allows for further discrimination between the different kind of
compositional languages that emerge in the context of Obverter-based
referential games, in a way that neither the referential game accuracy nor
previous metrics were able to capture. Finally we investigate whether the
resulting (emergent) systematicity, as measured by zero-shot compositional
learning tests, correlates with any of the disentanglement and compositionality
metrics proposed so far. Throughout the training process, statically
significant correlation coefficients can be found both positive and negative
depending on the moment of the measure. | [
0.0011479158,
0.0683551282,
-0.0605323911,
0.0152934203,
-0.0455705561,
0.0309699066,
-0.0411099307,
0.0108234482,
-0.0253015198,
-0.0131195569,
-0.0627680644,
-0.0580772124,
0.0556854382,
0.0538862012,
0.0059740013,
-0.0601536483,
0.0345797911,
0.0085429028,
-0.0205140747,
-0.0075877011,
-0.0561736934,
-0.0453767702,
-0.0153323142,
0.0256722942,
0.0273078308,
0.0001474812,
-0.0253535062,
-0.0258229543,
0.0064000115,
-0.0020413976,
-0.0504390337,
-0.006635325,
0.0289657563,
0.0310498495,
0.0000018675,
-0.0368886031,
0.0419322327,
-0.016211208,
-0.0126861921,
-0.0814999193,
-0.0314079262,
-0.0434371196,
0.010667555,
-0.0287873428,
-0.028340783,
-0.0396209918,
0.1025517285,
0.0293024182,
0.0366332307,
0.0545998067,
-0.0081993453,
-0.0472817346,
0.058073394,
-0.0196771752,
0.0461861454,
0.0250791702,
0.0003566984,
0.0162706133,
-0.0486862026,
-0.0321850963,
-0.0919659734,
0.0048186677,
0.0650554225,
0.0295047369,
0.0214141402,
0.0547373481,
0.0006231711,
-0.0409021191,
0.0210089982,
0.0947530717,
-0.0091277035,
0.0045954227,
0.0005498144,
-0.0021421576,
0.0094982209,
-0.0003995707,
-0.0008856535,
0.0382063873,
0.0305866338,
0.0488131754,
-0.0239895694,
0.0299592335,
0.033698611,
-0.0041211317,
-0.0129742585,
0.0155436033,
-0.0096486183,
-0.0116027091,
0.0310562626,
0.0039442703,
0.0290651377,
-0.0752918795,
-0.0596301295,
-0.0026069598,
0.0002188424,
-0.0209926479,
-0.0157067217,
-0.016308492,
-0.029376965,
-0.0314728357,
0.0444942564,
0.0191769172,
-0.0132606467,
0.0335542485,
-0.0262709893,
0.0701260939,
-0.0313817039,
0.0514868461,
-0.0213573743,
-0.0123320045,
-0.0575786084,
-0.031642843,
0.0192695335,
0.0591594577,
-0.0133910226,
-0.0717769191,
-0.0071093859,
0.0218193326,
-0.0727046728,
0.0624275059,
-0.0455158688,
0.0132346097,
0.0015563139,
-0.0093798749,
-0.0759928823,
0.0147521067,
-0.0247121584,
0.0118752988,
-0.0119298641,
-0.0199344512,
0.005543883,
0.0317424871,
-0.0142614944,
-0.0076311273,
-0.0300870035,
0.076822713,
-0.0197523963,
-0.0315551683,
0.0382010676,
-0.0059959078,
0.0213142391,
-0.0851051658,
0.074511826,
-0.0371365137,
0.0301641617,
-0.015865773,
0.010844769,
-0.0642952099,
0.017116379,
-0.0293693002,
-0.002901525,
0.087072745,
-0.0024820108,
-0.0268403403,
-0.0343266726,
0.0195551906,
0.0386216417,
0.0879225731,
0.0440090485,
0.0102354214,
-0.0002562816,
-0.0229731165,
-0.0085404804,
-0.03517434,
0.0101746926,
-0.0050602895,
-0.0399894193,
-0.0069196047,
0.0015106713,
0.010268027,
0.0250146762,
0.0454632565,
-0.0638742149,
-0.065234974,
0.0499612652,
0.0111703081,
0.0621018484,
0.0083664861,
0.0160170645,
0.0139175504,
-0.0421447866,
0.0959408581,
-0.0316981524,
0.0970373899,
0.0052858423,
0.0311439112,
0.01698987,
-0.0244052578,
-0.0335519277,
-0.0554993711,
0.0182560459,
-0.0280374885,
0.0441814139,
-0.0074066799,
0.0564577505,
0.0509369597,
-0.015770996,
0.0154991373,
0.0190909486,
-0.0171245486,
0.0277209114,
-0.0395688415,
0.0083711026,
0.0280464441,
0.0013737443,
-0.0164998118,
0.025459934,
-0.0150121935,
-0.0192711037,
0.0625272617,
-0.018754838,
0.004202506,
0.0782650411,
-0.0407656766,
-0.0375679582,
-0.0635507852,
0.0200012717,
0.0194851235,
-0.0276654046,
-0.0262856986,
-0.0123136844,
0.0061628772,
0.0607590415,
0.0188461896,
0.0330483764,
-0.0108057084,
-0.0070951115,
0.0431090109,
0.0441728458,
-0.024557421,
-0.0205314923,
0.0158057716,
0.0206608549,
-0.0357751735,
-0.0411885902,
0.01227667,
-0.0064323167,
-0.0039830161,
-0.0107312938,
-0.1004374102,
0.0207289737,
-0.0096745137,
0.0206727777,
-0.0483260788,
0.106462352,
-0.0321886279,
0.0591525808,
-0.0057040723,
-0.0154743586,
-0.0180338547,
0.0104854051,
0.0205864701,
0.055625394,
-0.0312189013,
-0.0158969294,
0.0231871642,
-0.0213722736,
0.0376564674,
-0.00858685,
0.0161937196,
0.0384150334,
-0.0138510661,
-0.016487794,
0.0066582356,
-0.0430639125,
-0.0289953779,
-0.0579608828,
-0.0060743317,
-0.0235223025,
-0.0144537147,
-0.0079602385,
0.0183838271,
-0.0240825489,
0.0512514561,
-0.0019364284,
0.0075592566,
0.0419837907,
-0.0105973631,
0.0232231896,
0.045128271,
0.0260242857,
-0.0123276049,
0.0033261816,
-0.0261062235,
-0.0004596052,
0.0625053048,
-0.024792837,
-0.0203934554,
-0.0308528636,
-0.0141945519,
-0.0391898751,
0.0173012409,
-0.0304601192,
-0.0394542627,
0.0305597559,
0.0219961349,
0.0055601331,
0.0694159418,
-0.023061201,
0.0804720074,
0.108372286,
-0.0280090887,
-0.0109750973,
0.0020872378,
-0.0351004004,
-0.0087931864,
-0.0269986987,
-0.0367565192,
-0.0118121542,
0.0270809419,
-0.0235673077,
0.0030024997,
-0.0756881237,
0.0012940329,
-0.003022179,
-0.0784319714,
-0.0406848304,
-0.0259521361,
-0.0074797105,
0.0362653285,
-0.0367786363,
-0.0448921844,
0.0515537597,
0.0041789054,
0.0061089415,
0.0285479836,
0.013173773,
-0.0085057048,
0.0939666852,
0.0684288144,
0.0065567647,
0.0138664898,
-0.0238861684,
-0.1070636436,
-0.0070164003,
0.0330986157,
0.0311702043,
-0.0260534175,
-0.0388085395,
-0.022581296,
0.00497767,
-0.0154046463,
-0.0280846432,
0.0374637097,
0.0102691157,
0.0363498367,
0.0029414131,
-0.0120518887,
-0.0514816046,
-0.0084713474,
0.0402587466,
-0.0519541763,
0.0327420644,
-0.030593574,
-0.0312045887,
0.0341034941,
0.0673192069,
0.0274025574,
0.0013451735,
-0.0273131598,
0.0193466228,
0.0295636356,
-0.0338994637,
0.027149776,
-0.0211546961,
0.0299925692,
0.0236860719,
0.0219634566,
-0.0361066684,
0.0288738273,
0.0065497956,
-0.0409891121,
0.005077682,
0.04818739,
-0.0111986967,
-0.0334878378,
-0.0007648449,
0.021323828,
-0.0103885615,
0.0400881469,
-0.0036249412,
-0.1114970371,
-0.010561822,
-0.0074712331,
-0.0645463914,
-0.0152614834,
-0.0139946612,
-0.0194074493,
-0.0919172093,
-0.0286093578,
-0.0030658322,
-0.0375431515,
-0.0818675384,
-0.0259041525,
-0.0114803705,
-0.0042519956,
-0.0211725123,
-0.0175710991,
0.0171253663,
-0.0241199005,
-0.034376692,
-0.0113249505,
-0.0059255776,
-0.0575711764,
-0.0312754884,
0.0283956788,
0.0890066922,
0.0265939087,
-0.0374132358,
-0.0614180118,
-0.0180328377,
-0.0816602036,
-0.0033861815,
0.0292625707,
0.0871682838,
0.0018531675,
-0.0282093547,
-0.0006802435,
0.0116363177,
0.0423752069,
-0.0274953805,
-0.0708941594,
0.0181762353,
-0.023074463,
-0.0566944592,
0.016155025,
0.0250473022,
0.0133830225,
0.0296173766,
0.0243000332,
-0.0333326384,
-0.0224855915,
-0.007975705,
0.0481411144,
-0.01557252,
0.017492665,
-0.0023838133,
0.0349119082,
-0.0544757098,
-0.0720459968,
0.011366006,
-0.0166297853,
0.0334567651,
-0.0061048814,
-0.0068727015,
0.009031943,
-0.0260613784,
-0.0290338136,
-0.0062105837,
0.0237012897,
0.0046109823,
-0.0145413317,
-0.0403972566,
-0.0415535159,
-0.055645369,
-0.0351141542,
-0.023038635,
-0.0482936762,
-0.0564682856,
-0.0171217024,
0.048662439,
0.0190612003,
0.0213926453,
0.030426031,
-0.0419665948,
0.001315822,
0.0186247136,
0.0223894063,
0.0333467238,
0.035939116,
-0.0121790357,
0.0128224026,
0.0407586843,
-0.0299473926,
-0.0270392261,
0.0420822874,
0.0159831904,
0.0093514277,
0.0310762078,
0.0226548314,
-0.0637740567,
0.0614951774,
0.0098025156,
0.0389291793,
-0.0052684341,
0.0099416217,
0.0080585023,
0.0092451507,
-0.0446311347,
-0.0090370513,
0.0526473932,
0.0470616743,
0.0448655188,
0.0366155989,
0.0350337587,
0.0197143592,
0.0235335808,
0.0011808353,
0.044786185,
-0.005404545,
-0.0333121568,
0.058223296,
0.0161336921,
0.0623391271,
0.0016572387,
0.0115793915,
0.0228354037,
0.0298976488,
0.0502626225,
-0.0036152063,
-0.021849608,
0.0254714508,
-0.0334115289,
0.0084335348,
0.0226940531,
0.0041540903,
0.0441701598,
0.0196497776,
-0.0224761851,
-0.0296766572,
0.0046557118,
0.0140026649,
0.0434842035,
-0.0103881964,
-0.063075304,
0.0049129194,
0.0314682871,
-0.0112100746,
-0.003030672,
0.080763787,
0.0022306757,
0.0303673726,
-0.0296651982,
0.0451687798,
0.002493405,
-0.0122605609,
0.0053880098,
0.1189525574,
-0.0004256453,
0.0588877797,
-0.026880499,
-0.0310970675,
-0.0337570757,
0.0314639173,
0.0293004792,
0.0181868747,
0.0762185454,
0.0024340858,
0.0225390978,
-0.0480372533,
0.0095524658,
-0.0625195727,
0.0298984647,
0.0353309177,
-0.0120719513,
-6.12777344e-33,
-0.0316301025,
-0.0421002917,
-0.0060714525,
-0.0160008483,
-0.0286170021,
0.007358918,
-0.0036453605,
0.0108066937,
-0.0476938225,
0.0061439159,
0.0507767498,
0.0339356996,
0.0000692715,
0.0130626708,
0.0041016131,
-0.027834205,
0.0149814496,
0.0228198748,
-0.0233324282,
-0.0117746135,
0.0350343026,
-0.0331289694,
0.0514915474,
-0.0408247262,
-0.0023679021,
0.0565926954,
0.0014089425,
0.0214593615,
0.0068736942,
0.0386925302,
-0.0274045542,
0.0263776667,
0.0115424013,
0.0230121445,
-0.0052391486,
-0.0011331176,
-0.0591488369,
-0.0647780299,
0.015818771,
-0.0029168006,
-0.0521379597,
-0.0117939431,
0.0452162512,
-0.012022675,
-0.01182409,
-0.0731096193,
0.0274311285,
-0.0025113421,
-0.0119836349,
0.0086468812,
-0.0733439773,
-0.0235633347,
-0.020621011,
-0.0314109921,
0.0562314652,
-0.0046055112,
-0.0039591854,
-0.0293227788,
-0.0659882948,
0.0484354384,
-0.0251122918,
0.0033193415,
0.0449080095,
0.0334197283,
0.0816901103,
0.0786737055,
0.0701501891,
0.0016182254,
-0.0463941842,
-0.0365110561,
0.0116312262,
0.06665425,
0.0294073615,
0.020686429,
0.0592050329,
0.00505016,
-0.0355327874,
-0.0338837691,
-0.0379745252,
0.0678470433,
-0.0064338711,
0.0257317647,
-0.001678429,
-0.0199869182,
-0.0414863043,
-0.0416942127,
-0.0208633374,
-0.0382121019,
0.0135440687,
0.0107676545,
0.0409816206,
-0.0020054965,
0.0193004739,
-0.0649508536,
0.0043259636,
0.0222899485,
-0.0073156692,
0.0747469142,
0.0343495272,
-0.0487709716,
-0.0378521532,
-0.0428900868,
0.0388754085,
0.0457125194,
0.0098906737,
0.0246482417,
0.018788524,
0.010703505,
-0.0194024369,
-0.0349487551,
-0.0244191084,
-0.0412568599,
0.0271089934,
-0.0240747463,
0.0536640324,
0.0073382906,
-0.0394116566,
0.0080235982,
-0.0208635628,
0.0174567308,
-0.005284796,
-0.0016432997,
-0.03752115,
0.0230139326,
0.015510668,
-0.0015454182,
-0.0359060317,
0.0052350601,
0.0351876803,
-0.0320807807,
-0.0295918118,
-0.0081255129,
2.754e-7,
0.0154681671,
0.0120955482,
-0.0027474232,
0.0380465984,
0.0010462943,
0.0127345817,
-0.0291816164,
0.007835825,
-0.0467495248,
-0.0347653814,
0.0166948512,
0.0351310633,
0.0100809215,
0.0136868833,
-0.0030995389,
0.0574230924,
-0.0486744456,
-0.0305769835,
-0.0204298049,
-0.0065478124,
0.0365704671,
0.0387939438,
0.0343829654,
0.0171505418,
0.0369674228,
-0.0010131586,
0.0475001633,
-0.0520607047,
0.0761659443,
-0.0357108228,
-0.0096542425,
0.0039903149,
-0.0058996263,
0.0421552621,
0.0066565941,
0.0136349974,
-0.0026935865,
-0.0465250537,
-0.0074405661,
-0.0295068882,
-0.0404329859,
0.0105440123,
-0.0044868728,
-0.0411794409,
0.0778970495,
-0.083308056,
-0.06184306,
0.0209928919,
-0.0412017182,
0.0261858013,
0.0305687021,
0.0016564741,
-0.0305476263,
-0.0209200811,
0.0024461106,
0.0152288005,
0.0132643627,
-0.0415760763,
-0.0057320981,
0.0284296907,
0.0117398137,
-0.0270928927,
-0.0369092412,
-0.0238559227,
0.0347649418,
-0.0038089738,
-0.0475560315,
2.030341853e-34,
0.0153024886,
-0.0141391195,
0.0282688029,
-0.0394293405,
0.0164338816,
-0.056022279,
-0.0528332032,
0.0013706196,
0.0324088447,
-0.0357488804,
-0.0146501604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14456v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14456v1 | Framing the News:From Human Perception to Large Language Model Inferences | 2023-04-27T18:30:18 | 2023-04-27T18:30:18 | David Alonso del Barrio, Daniel Gatica-Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Identifying the frames of news is important to understand the articles'
vision, intention, message to be conveyed, and which aspects of the news are
emphasized. Framing is a widely studied concept in journalism, and has emerged
as a new topic in computing, with the potential to automate processes and
facilitate the work of journalism professionals. In this paper, we study this
issue with articles related to the Covid-19 anti-vaccine movement. First, to
understand the perspectives used to treat this theme, we developed a protocol
for human labeling of frames for 1786 headlines of No-Vax movement articles of
European newspapers from 5 countries. Headlines are key units in the written
press, and worth of analysis as many people only read headlines (or use them to
guide their decision for further reading.) Second, considering advances in
Natural Language Processing (NLP) with large language models, we investigated
two approaches for frame inference of news headlines: first with a GPT-3.5
fine-tuning approach, and second with GPT-3.5 prompt-engineering. Our work
contributes to the study and analysis of the performance that these models have
to facilitate journalistic tasks like classification of frames, while
understanding whether the models are able to replicate human perception in the
identification of these frames. | [
0.0492356382,
0.028047191,
0.0010161463,
0.0061269482,
-0.059870936,
0.0172233935,
-0.0076519209,
-0.0119847916,
0.0298449285,
-0.0689031854,
0.0393780507,
0.0091053005,
-0.0139003443,
0.0555495322,
-0.046769049,
-0.102652587,
0.0492077395,
0.0237385742,
0.0600579083,
0.0259318445,
0.0165951978,
0.0411639623,
-0.025463257,
0.026746396,
0.0171252582,
-0.0155451074,
-0.0097683426,
-0.0150636034,
0.0433682241,
-0.051872205,
-0.023249954,
0.0386582427,
0.0340083092,
0.0330396369,
0.000001774,
-0.0207792595,
-0.0080942335,
-0.0179620255,
0.012866769,
-0.019473562,
0.0583670512,
-0.0607047752,
-0.0191382505,
-0.0070978431,
-0.0309214331,
-0.0597468764,
0.0483805016,
0.0318870395,
0.0434209742,
0.0778788477,
-0.0295791347,
-0.0349132121,
0.0092996694,
0.0100961402,
-0.024074547,
-0.048842065,
0.0275648013,
-0.038293235,
0.026895944,
0.0481902398,
0.0121996151,
0.022939695,
-0.0134278955,
0.003804497,
-0.0840828344,
0.0299180578,
-0.0176511332,
-0.0431522578,
-0.038999062,
0.0128889177,
0.0546752885,
-0.032812275,
0.0377402157,
-0.0183451101,
0.001062627,
0.0416169539,
-0.0307605471,
0.0082555786,
-0.0394552238,
0.0293889903,
0.0478620194,
0.0143121341,
-0.013943526,
0.0306465346,
-0.0063845082,
0.0578654557,
0.0024015841,
0.0051264139,
0.0049462761,
0.018002918,
0.020125946,
-0.0594527051,
0.0167290494,
0.0105925724,
0.0099225603,
0.0301073212,
-0.0168393441,
-0.0199268106,
-0.0021738354,
-0.0607511066,
-0.0923432708,
0.0180481784,
0.0272397567,
0.0455322154,
0.006475715,
-0.0274461489,
-0.0456415191,
0.0130414022,
-0.0017814721,
0.0322644748,
-0.078335911,
-0.0066125104,
-0.0485573374,
0.0121270493,
-0.0482216291,
-0.0242554899,
-0.0456609279,
-0.0046763076,
0.0186245181,
0.0028165402,
-0.066001609,
-0.001766488,
-0.0172938649,
-0.0196122583,
-0.0110999821,
0.0675243884,
-0.0586829819,
-0.0210064761,
-0.0070043886,
-0.0317008905,
-0.0039012365,
0.0300353058,
-0.0022184758,
-0.0078682425,
-0.0326174609,
0.0165660139,
-0.0286416057,
0.0038216063,
-0.0020588187,
-0.0503898561,
-0.0353025235,
-0.0383695476,
-0.0161554459,
-0.0673741102,
0.00208393,
0.0462086387,
0.0253989585,
-0.0182950776,
-0.0152054401,
0.0102369059,
-0.067145288,
0.0393078476,
0.0006313855,
-0.0084220842,
0.0450402871,
0.0283642728,
0.0510405749,
0.0856659189,
-0.0029997842,
0.0666573122,
0.0267412961,
-0.0092695495,
0.0201580077,
0.0228509791,
-0.0299848225,
0.0053797099,
0.004471458,
-0.0289395545,
0.0134279635,
0.0221055839,
-0.0126924086,
0.0161026493,
-0.0007680657,
0.0159716737,
0.0581035204,
0.037314631,
-0.0255006868,
-0.0334723368,
0.0215298459,
0.0245256964,
0.022005992,
0.0505849123,
0.0077394075,
-0.0110415732,
-0.0003980444,
-0.0057822135,
-0.0429331288,
0.0274455678,
-0.0153274043,
-0.0047424352,
-0.0077936505,
0.0240641031,
-0.0003262433,
-0.0287949722,
0.0517823659,
-0.00920243,
-0.0510944091,
0.0534496605,
0.0136642437,
-0.0049672299,
0.0291358717,
-0.0524479337,
-0.0006370595,
0.0072302343,
0.0312172771,
-0.0201077387,
-0.0230210572,
-0.0313323028,
0.0266471542,
0.0535205528,
0.0596866496,
-0.0165844914,
-0.0658647791,
-0.0186027139,
-0.0095430929,
0.0121880341,
0.0303008631,
0.0321214385,
-0.0139625743,
0.029870294,
-0.0027542778,
0.0372277163,
-0.0161083825,
0.0387450419,
0.0278591048,
-0.0373953134,
-0.0431914292,
0.0343000367,
0.0169334766,
0.0577095263,
0.0180449877,
-0.0042892578,
0.0257272087,
-0.0136623364,
0.011157684,
0.030668458,
-0.0273162834,
0.020502761,
-0.0289947093,
-0.0644508973,
-0.0270267129,
0.0121878916,
-0.0585254952,
-0.0225031488,
0.022154808,
-0.009980578,
-0.020280527,
-0.0221462678,
-0.0066736341,
-0.0301979277,
-0.0298067071,
-0.0196680781,
0.0733090714,
0.0199858751,
0.0174561683,
0.0377954319,
-0.0277998876,
-0.0132424748,
-0.033471588,
-0.007872927,
0.0429341607,
0.0176283102,
-0.0080299415,
0.0755828246,
-0.0477068685,
-0.0312798917,
-0.0179324672,
-0.0957621187,
0.0164359473,
-0.0030277788,
0.0363164395,
0.065367125,
0.0100012533,
-0.0396538451,
-0.0334352329,
-0.000192818,
-0.0303722322,
0.005134555,
0.0071661836,
0.0151434392,
0.0091430228,
-0.0255884361,
0.0049704188,
0.0207182877,
-0.0748766884,
0.0362206101,
0.0723223016,
-0.0811803788,
-0.0621923767,
-0.0193499457,
0.0218420513,
-0.0080033327,
0.007496031,
-0.0177488439,
0.0155507484,
0.0028243163,
-0.0273953378,
0.077917479,
0.0216937065,
0.0737706646,
0.0382047966,
0.0269619059,
-0.0013420213,
0.0100290487,
-0.0718894228,
-0.0222452767,
-0.0518672429,
-0.0590552948,
0.0556972921,
0.0756261572,
0.033017993,
0.0392975621,
-0.0400555469,
0.0477636419,
-0.044377137,
0.0096634049,
-0.0139792971,
-0.0265783314,
-0.0077080186,
0.0775131881,
0.003499053,
-0.0106053045,
0.0438445397,
0.0242440477,
0.0506851114,
-0.072660543,
-0.0015141786,
-0.0380781852,
0.0496389568,
-0.0025005632,
0.037528269,
0.0047679064,
-0.0515180714,
-0.0238950942,
-0.0601998754,
0.0447960533,
-0.0024220569,
0.0060225544,
-0.0475927368,
0.0219533499,
-0.0096947337,
-0.030415535,
-0.0159635898,
-0.0673887655,
-0.0727465451,
-0.0152096758,
-0.0097254906,
0.0196444672,
-0.0761312917,
0.0560252629,
0.0253868122,
0.0406266414,
-0.0056074494,
0.0184824336,
-0.0153807383,
0.0730480924,
0.0192329548,
-0.0341087095,
-0.0197017211,
-0.0024920607,
0.0267252307,
0.0465650968,
-0.0119588077,
0.0847406164,
-0.0338219181,
-0.0013002806,
0.0099338284,
-0.0734424591,
-0.0363550633,
-0.0019736122,
0.0327704474,
-0.0576018915,
0.031690184,
0.116098173,
0.0558737516,
-0.0429530852,
-0.0313644148,
0.0228069462,
-0.041613508,
0.0096628759,
0.0412176512,
-0.0658068508,
-0.003627972,
0.0290942173,
-0.0018274598,
-0.0638499111,
-0.0367832519,
-0.0016623287,
-0.0441400222,
0.0543265603,
0.0042581926,
-0.003211424,
0.0042738193,
-0.0936715826,
0.0232622605,
-0.0147828506,
-0.0429210626,
0.0015098415,
-0.000496229,
-0.0135814017,
0.0009047432,
-0.0275281463,
-0.0547128804,
-0.0270700492,
-0.0052679558,
0.0088061532,
0.0146336453,
0.0554162301,
-0.0439416058,
-0.0112034036,
-0.0223583914,
-0.0374264754,
-0.0041621318,
-0.0298432466,
0.0612799041,
-0.0195016675,
-0.0021891447,
-0.041164156,
0.0433792137,
0.0170274824,
-0.0420373306,
0.0322961882,
0.0452305228,
-0.0087976418,
-0.0446423814,
-0.0149788735,
0.0239544604,
0.0170794576,
0.0452177413,
0.0260903481,
-0.0083326064,
-0.0288536437,
-0.0254118107,
0.0387553833,
-0.0247066524,
-0.026664976,
-0.001337829,
-0.0383241586,
-0.0565577745,
-0.0490498729,
-0.0109582087,
0.0210768208,
0.0521046221,
0.0197906382,
-0.0010682429,
0.0538927093,
0.018114917,
-0.0666051805,
0.021207653,
0.0224534571,
-0.0229546949,
-0.0419077761,
0.0205484852,
0.0435361378,
0.0231532417,
-0.0496366508,
0.0804475099,
-0.0020647247,
-0.0595713109,
0.0118668135,
-0.0371760279,
0.0330141746,
0.0364263244,
-0.0008059769,
-0.003764557,
0.0415889099,
0.052917067,
0.0203606896,
-0.0142769683,
-0.0412260778,
-0.0276356936,
-0.0338654295,
-0.0278406329,
0.0059639919,
0.0484242029,
-0.0051439307,
-0.0159239098,
-0.0299375392,
0.0287892576,
0.0350469612,
0.0031564687,
0.037690945,
-0.0283070952,
-0.0067511345,
-0.0403533131,
-0.0279996209,
-0.0193671733,
-0.019945791,
0.0203511808,
-0.0217332877,
0.0117596127,
-0.0173471235,
-0.0363679081,
0.070251137,
-0.0538317971,
0.0166232251,
-0.0273304023,
0.0299815331,
-0.0235118791,
0.0613923483,
-0.0100936294,
-0.0326785222,
-0.0190495458,
0.0264441334,
-0.0054869023,
0.045654919,
-0.0073943087,
0.0486491993,
0.0529375225,
-0.0048166579,
0.0225088745,
0.028015241,
-0.0668530092,
-0.0250982605,
-0.0469906218,
0.0585395023,
0.016273709,
-0.0540073626,
0.0026275958,
-0.0292757712,
-0.0473627932,
0.0106428321,
0.0287447684,
0.0394437946,
0.0115491683,
0.0206044335,
0.0240563434,
-0.0271033626,
-0.0246260166,
0.0140462061,
-0.0082975365,
0.0445570312,
0.06940303,
-0.1015624255,
-0.0228727385,
0.0005590933,
0.0218377393,
-0.0158965271,
-0.0109833805,
0.0114669604,
-0.0753699914,
-0.0046491185,
0.0361233503,
-0.0000414831,
0.0147465244,
-0.013636102,
0.0042664618,
0.0597896166,
0.0442965664,
-0.0298321657,
-0.0513854697,
0.0508813895,
-0.0539539531,
-0.0244427547,
0.015491182,
-6.276023114e-33,
-0.0187519919,
-0.0402106531,
-0.0261883289,
0.0169855393,
-0.0052872775,
0.021766305,
-0.0284663569,
-0.0291793924,
0.0069312239,
0.0305038728,
0.0132108359,
-0.006950649,
0.0358178355,
-0.0206755642,
-0.0131062111,
0.0026607721,
0.0429821685,
-0.0111394972,
-0.0380228795,
0.0022230078,
0.021502478,
0.0107868882,
0.0522522442,
-0.0270267148,
0.042417191,
-0.0157955755,
-0.0182608496,
-0.0135939484,
0.0696895123,
0.0393958688,
-0.0004396848,
-0.0134515548,
0.0610703416,
-0.0623685382,
0.0223294906,
0.1330422163,
-0.0645813718,
-0.0344591588,
0.0697305202,
0.0164767653,
-0.0199383721,
-0.0096830921,
0.0227857698,
-0.0043710861,
-0.0427946337,
0.0268924665,
0.0409485959,
-0.0331714228,
0.0252743289,
0.0149586415,
-0.0700624809,
0.0194000099,
-0.0209423043,
0.0206168089,
0.0342625156,
0.0249449313,
-0.0119240703,
0.0717168748,
-0.0259205028,
-0.0024712288,
0.012188389,
0.0401353054,
0.0509164296,
0.0044788998,
-0.0127277086,
0.034834642,
0.0068123117,
-0.001983444,
-0.0667513236,
0.0139746508,
0.0076108631,
0.0045527709,
0.0341380723,
0.0642098784,
0.0366790481,
0.0077744182,
-0.0866796523,
0.0488543995,
-0.0044958442,
0.0550920926,
0.035806641,
-0.0228483584,
-0.0202711709,
0.0068678171,
-0.0701866224,
-0.0574888326,
-0.0244468506,
-0.0212152842,
0.0018137741,
-0.0024596043,
-0.045362208,
0.0213526785,
0.0033245136,
-0.0091718966,
0.0013714762,
-0.0256014857,
0.008431064,
0.0425232053,
-0.0294676349,
0.043699678,
-0.0178770218,
-0.0111248931,
-0.0024773739,
0.0388099775,
0.0370970704,
-0.0369068496,
-0.0004476423,
-0.015156935,
-0.0576019213,
0.0116178701,
0.0057876902,
0.0335901827,
-0.021295011,
0.0141378343,
0.0441934019,
0.0116217388,
0.006176325,
0.0119993482,
0.0252399202,
-0.0120418509,
0.0205393005,
-0.012640045,
-0.0162112005,
0.0487033613,
-0.0342925377,
-0.0102097904,
0.0228141528,
0.0318616778,
0.0103173079,
-0.0524446666,
-0.0193338767,
-0.0002086595,
2.607e-7,
0.054134503,
0.0559953414,
0.0269140471,
0.0084047699,
0.0264346618,
0.032993909,
0.0104222661,
0.0474106371,
-0.0035070905,
-0.0807976052,
0.0229949895,
0.0019904086,
0.0125139588,
0.0222815014,
-0.1191396266,
0.0697551295,
-0.0226953737,
0.0213147122,
-0.0668292046,
0.0309831351,
0.0621159598,
0.0076629608,
-0.0205988474,
0.0128928591,
-0.0166012291,
-0.0262540691,
0.0189819448,
-0.0067837462,
-0.0510535464,
0.0308634099,
0.0358635932,
0.0123098521,
-0.0110347047,
0.0202630851,
-0.0048301397,
-0.0340160243,
0.0002839375,
0.0586569682,
-0.0077847484,
0.0531942062,
-0.022898959,
-0.0173667483,
0.0147557845,
-0.0548612028,
0.05340074,
-0.0896004736,
-0.0408973321,
-0.0730697513,
-0.0711925849,
-0.0261829682,
0.0086840335,
-0.0005896691,
-0.0177769065,
0.0438077971,
-0.0139102964,
0.0095986864,
0.0016495301,
-0.0522748642,
0.022876421,
-0.006794313,
-0.0291977786,
-0.0293672178,
-0.0086247772,
-0.0280449931,
-0.0012496377,
-0.0607809536,
0.0351702981,
1.966353634e-34,
0.0290194657,
0.0397329591,
-0.0416423418,
-0.0075905635,
0.0156258885,
0.0190034285,
-0.0510043874,
0.0163387321,
0.0244562235,
-0.0596261807,
0.0247323588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14454v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14454v3 | PMC-LLaMA: Towards Building Open-source Language Models for Medicine | 2023-04-27T18:29:05 | 2023-08-25T14:08:38 | Chaoyi Wu, Weixiong Lin, Xiaoman Zhang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable capabilities
in natural language understanding. While demonstrating proficiency in everyday
conversations and question-answering situations, these models frequently
struggle in domains that require precision, such as medical applications, due
to their lack of domain-specific knowledge. In this paper, we describe the
procedure for building a powerful, open-source language model specifically
designed for medicine applications, termed as PMC-LLaMA. Our contributions are
threefold: (i) we systematically investigate the process of adapting a
general-purpose foundation language model towards medical domain, this involves
data-centric knowledge injection through the integration of 4.8M biomedical
academic papers and 30K medical textbooks, as well as comprehensive fine-tuning
for alignment with domain-specific instructions; (ii) we contribute a
large-scale, comprehensive dataset for instruction tuning. This dataset
encompasses medical question-answering (QA), rationale for reasoning, and
conversational dialogues, comprising a total of 202M tokens; (iii) we conduct
thorough ablation studies to demonstrate the effectiveness of each proposed
component. While evaluating on various public medical question-answering
benchmarks, our lightweight PMCLLaMA, which consists of only 13 billion
parameters, exhibits superior performance, even surpassing ChatGPT. All models,
codes, datasets can be found in https://github.com/chaoyi-wu/PMC-LLaMA. | [
0.0723180622,
0.0756666809,
0.0173391066,
0.0100474507,
-0.0094282655,
0.0181421917,
-0.0330896936,
0.0076491986,
-0.0001137357,
-0.0127303833,
-0.0419394113,
-0.0292853713,
-0.006671235,
0.0305981897,
0.0230432451,
-0.0257610455,
0.0372423753,
0.0009271727,
0.0413756818,
-0.0011092286,
0.017709583,
0.0164544787,
-0.0358949266,
0.0418630764,
0.0431258902,
-0.0415771678,
0.0179238208,
0.0016863793,
0.0081795054,
-0.0366416126,
0.0083469087,
0.0351913348,
-0.0083403615,
0.0043639364,
0.0000017824,
-0.0577746369,
0.0103202881,
0.0080495588,
-0.0376648195,
-0.0064565106,
0.0348918848,
-0.0399427861,
0.0101328213,
0.026541803,
-0.0534103848,
-0.0043431101,
0.0283819996,
0.0487265363,
0.0772470385,
0.0733577982,
0.0056809173,
-0.0101114986,
0.0561112538,
-0.0170862824,
0.0124043897,
-0.0331440195,
0.0467876233,
0.0217955038,
0.0459235422,
0.025872916,
0.0037425538,
0.0517579503,
-0.0009008411,
0.0108275274,
0.0153600713,
0.0311271586,
-0.0519113839,
-0.0138449604,
-0.0144343385,
0.0983616784,
0.0193074998,
-0.0378766172,
0.0219097678,
0.0273446292,
-0.0161854383,
-0.0242795479,
-0.0805755109,
0.0074499268,
0.0116316229,
0.0122968843,
0.0320470333,
-0.0213226024,
0.0321346261,
0.026082268,
0.0258102398,
0.0253684521,
0.0091943443,
-0.0238889754,
-0.0093429005,
-0.0319114625,
-0.0317737609,
-0.0552086048,
0.0027616795,
0.0711727589,
-0.019418817,
0.024418829,
-0.0335466489,
-0.0073888078,
0.0855149999,
-0.0372874029,
-0.0074298009,
0.027513111,
-0.0145535814,
0.0673677474,
-0.0026470153,
0.0165682677,
-0.0526700988,
0.0521130934,
-0.04347343,
-0.0355847217,
-0.0558383502,
-0.0320642702,
-0.0026266805,
0.0224219132,
-0.0240072962,
-0.0148757258,
-0.0530658625,
0.032221429,
0.0203891397,
-0.0124972714,
0.0136996284,
0.0355593711,
-0.0182771478,
-0.0207489692,
-0.0199773721,
0.0218415093,
-0.0245606489,
0.0190869868,
-0.0230403468,
-0.0739452913,
-0.0356155932,
0.0163757112,
-0.0040189354,
-0.0034686939,
0.0220271163,
0.0637129769,
0.0119546987,
-0.0036196953,
0.0239519551,
-0.0446399152,
-0.0110745821,
-0.044167053,
-0.0038192696,
-0.0604490452,
0.0337127261,
0.0276981257,
-0.0026587769,
-0.0499437936,
0.0184489209,
0.0361248516,
-0.0682580397,
0.0792536288,
-0.0595756471,
0.0079905475,
0.029949395,
0.0536735132,
0.0017923545,
0.0402557291,
0.0190639868,
-0.0648314878,
0.0228271112,
-0.006340608,
-0.0006994315,
-0.0183106139,
0.0373499691,
-0.0319868252,
0.0304280203,
0.0702111349,
0.0015397799,
0.0741147548,
-0.0295929294,
0.0586592257,
-0.0114007918,
-0.0325575732,
0.0177287385,
0.0520328134,
-0.0165626127,
0.0086793341,
-0.0043345853,
-0.0058151493,
0.0349996798,
-0.0469298549,
-0.0194843728,
0.020888146,
-0.0031060772,
-0.0003951013,
-0.0014735608,
0.0063684168,
-0.0359266102,
-0.026386451,
-0.045046784,
-0.0234566964,
-0.0286975075,
-0.003599779,
0.0126114823,
0.0006816224,
-0.0220610518,
0.093178995,
0.0539534464,
-0.0402948745,
-0.0150781404,
-0.0429123789,
0.0298361573,
0.0335972086,
0.0621338971,
-0.0566104352,
-0.0683966503,
-0.0182263423,
0.047903344,
0.0239114538,
0.0325945839,
-0.0295557193,
0.0259558707,
-0.067960985,
0.012022825,
-0.012940052,
-0.0044096555,
-0.0400682613,
0.026927432,
0.0019572077,
-0.0177622195,
-0.0264841337,
0.0096943555,
0.0391919091,
-0.0502308235,
-0.0188961513,
-0.0128404824,
-0.0411320738,
0.039234519,
0.0133906882,
0.0080690337,
0.0565224066,
0.0467378609,
-0.0446087904,
-0.0195402801,
0.0090270722,
-0.0457167961,
-0.0422472656,
0.0451153181,
-0.0165422186,
-0.0272799395,
0.0135741187,
-0.0550976917,
-0.0491772443,
-0.0047902334,
-0.030617265,
0.0245098379,
-0.0040451656,
-0.0105018085,
0.0199009329,
0.0214232504,
-0.0393243581,
0.0106286667,
-0.0137726236,
0.0075662369,
0.0507869683,
-0.0003448383,
0.0015568042,
-0.0398305394,
-0.0253874157,
0.0044531962,
-0.0196641795,
0.0095929904,
-0.029363988,
0.0180587564,
-0.0535653122,
-0.0351263843,
-0.0993600935,
0.0307469983,
0.0113532078,
0.0149895111,
0.0517032258,
0.0327622518,
0.0064259307,
-0.0219411142,
-0.0538553223,
-0.0105093559,
0.0111754024,
0.0166959222,
0.0574968383,
0.0194583349,
0.0110680917,
-0.0393547267,
-0.0059681144,
-0.0515144579,
0.0039712884,
-0.0120255528,
0.0235844664,
-0.0158075374,
-0.026325373,
-0.0516029298,
0.0087651685,
-0.0152373314,
-0.0381225795,
0.0126296012,
-0.001419851,
0.0062944847,
0.0739478096,
-0.0093022408,
0.0000809238,
0.0172302537,
0.0101097617,
-0.023367621,
0.021206785,
-0.0268565081,
-0.0132568749,
-0.0048015541,
-0.0085565541,
0.0038475534,
0.080417268,
0.0049470444,
-0.0058260523,
-0.0574712791,
0.0203651562,
-0.0158617329,
0.0195959285,
-0.0274301376,
0.009459109,
-0.0232550781,
0.0287205502,
-0.0162647329,
-0.0203298647,
0.0984621942,
-0.0350798555,
0.004228266,
-0.0637756661,
-0.0193356294,
-0.0639083982,
-0.0145694008,
-0.0295421891,
0.0108777257,
0.0115985619,
0.0034838656,
-0.0158133991,
0.0096387761,
-0.0324073359,
-0.0639856234,
0.0470938757,
-0.0524849407,
0.0132657494,
0.0081428587,
-0.0593746901,
-0.0420205779,
-0.036449112,
-0.0502884351,
0.015958529,
-0.0148604289,
0.0004221735,
-0.038737677,
0.0069901287,
-0.0049048946,
0.0300859269,
0.0024991801,
-0.0071693002,
-0.0260521956,
0.0307351705,
0.0663711652,
0.0272835474,
0.0111683551,
0.0053867325,
0.0434166901,
0.0752750114,
0.0160675924,
0.0165723413,
-0.0069551836,
0.0054737316,
0.0016116711,
-0.0165058319,
0.0127037968,
0.0114478329,
0.0513236821,
-0.0471399389,
-0.0162806753,
0.1268834621,
0.0284729414,
-0.0373068899,
0.0022702299,
-0.0433510356,
0.0183067806,
0.0015208207,
0.0267910156,
-0.0801859275,
-0.0604435578,
-0.0173136462,
0.0404069275,
0.0045982497,
-0.003910189,
0.0029476453,
-0.0438847914,
0.0009851506,
-0.0100894179,
-0.0254950393,
-0.0449942239,
-0.0365607962,
-0.004353513,
-0.0323427916,
-0.0038807641,
0.0201184545,
-0.0092586298,
0.0000693959,
0.0045331661,
-0.0359459147,
-0.0500653833,
0.0584599152,
0.0060345214,
0.0738792494,
0.0426096544,
0.0375465937,
0.0169463176,
-0.0275124796,
0.0003936218,
-0.0241470877,
-0.0240281783,
-0.0172160249,
0.0704386458,
-0.0018964661,
-0.0049706404,
-0.0495654196,
0.0702542141,
-0.096655108,
-0.0398252755,
-0.009465076,
0.0938378796,
-0.0173063949,
0.0044225864,
-0.063864179,
0.0404699109,
-0.0078854868,
0.085504353,
-0.001085005,
0.0051868176,
-0.0409351848,
0.0109617403,
0.0094815781,
0.001610851,
-0.033273384,
0.0162125174,
0.0188950654,
0.0147557743,
-0.0563644059,
-0.0187131315,
0.0349937677,
-0.0238850173,
-0.0012100473,
0.0452798605,
0.0168506019,
-0.0230772272,
-0.0540219881,
0.056535501,
-0.0228033941,
0.0031446561,
-0.0570237599,
-0.0243799295,
0.072247386,
-0.0010064532,
-0.0322555006,
0.027116105,
-0.0535961613,
-0.0450995602,
-0.0228380281,
0.0620785393,
0.0210422315,
0.0225807317,
-0.0326395221,
-0.0333484076,
0.0011222723,
-0.0041574161,
-0.050754793,
-0.0091172727,
0.0145148979,
0.0004360191,
0.010682784,
0.0475148112,
-0.0071861707,
0.0013730809,
-0.0027478586,
0.0435905829,
-0.0225738604,
-0.0373343043,
0.0224336721,
0.0170541983,
0.0269629024,
0.0239275806,
-0.009084831,
-0.0120628225,
0.036404863,
-0.0257007107,
0.0073543452,
-0.0318760723,
0.0017634572,
0.0372360311,
-0.0481705368,
-0.0054436377,
-0.0205178931,
-0.0751545355,
0.0043763588,
-0.0067261136,
0.0389005467,
0.0269284789,
-0.0048678517,
0.0360310115,
-0.0368797928,
-0.0019604063,
0.0080921901,
-0.0310964081,
0.0310566183,
-0.0303405467,
0.0552458316,
-0.002472193,
0.0211169943,
0.0276375636,
0.0500251427,
-0.0811334699,
-0.0563321672,
0.0095134173,
0.0401976109,
0.0148578212,
0.0151678203,
0.0562781654,
-0.0062604421,
-0.0156051647,
-0.0073460466,
0.0449700952,
-0.0303816944,
0.0161858555,
0.1109257191,
0.0368653089,
-0.0072091618,
-0.01708664,
0.0857805163,
0.0004505727,
0.0676601231,
0.016306838,
-0.0237679835,
-0.0433302186,
-0.0252982322,
0.0278263073,
0.0162329245,
-0.0516179726,
0.0366638228,
-0.0529604442,
-0.0456728712,
0.0199713502,
0.0016193377,
-0.0412827693,
-0.0198682919,
0.0599619746,
0.0313373394,
0.0186727513,
-0.0419455729,
-0.0341621116,
0.0740752593,
-0.0484447964,
-0.0369506367,
0.0145023093,
-6.128714202e-33,
-0.0041942196,
0.0058862981,
0.0350172855,
-0.0066681439,
-0.0109682633,
0.0163509529,
-0.046029456,
-0.0114146825,
-0.0402088724,
0.0335237645,
-0.0128437895,
0.0368855447,
-0.0030491441,
0.0409856327,
-0.026155401,
-0.0266605206,
-0.0038154067,
0.0017233073,
-0.0055670454,
0.0462249666,
-0.0058911117,
0.045288261,
0.0383843482,
-0.0392853692,
0.0006745628,
-0.0168775432,
0.0315811522,
0.0467951745,
-0.0278092418,
0.0820152909,
-0.047589317,
0.0402938053,
0.0538254455,
-0.0082626529,
0.0074370033,
0.0329862759,
-0.0856794491,
-0.0229476653,
0.0368150361,
-0.0241241623,
-0.0739466548,
-0.0460240357,
0.038496621,
-0.0193428621,
0.0118567906,
-0.0195712168,
0.0107765347,
-0.0275759064,
-0.0057069953,
0.0075938986,
-0.0311895162,
0.0378411897,
-0.0240062978,
-0.0329769291,
-0.0305341817,
0.0102099422,
-0.0257266611,
0.063646093,
-0.0199202057,
-0.0095434012,
0.0125375986,
0.0442498177,
0.0247194953,
-0.0275566187,
0.0097770905,
0.0332434438,
-0.0129921045,
-0.0323367901,
-0.0245533399,
0.0311687831,
-0.0364640057,
0.0571032986,
0.0473271087,
0.0356903374,
-0.0011815063,
0.0162387881,
-0.1034911573,
0.0139439385,
-0.0396294333,
0.0831344351,
-0.0056098187,
-0.0006256091,
-0.0233422201,
0.0016877117,
-0.0294225439,
0.0071968487,
-0.0292595029,
-0.011432372,
0.0379105061,
-0.029063141,
-0.0289337542,
-0.0075217811,
-0.00156742,
-0.0460533798,
0.0122333504,
0.0289961863,
0.0119418465,
-0.0092544155,
-0.0177437346,
0.0431980416,
-0.0828142837,
-0.0067500258,
0.0227048472,
-0.0397523455,
0.0333713517,
0.0260239542,
0.0261331983,
-0.0307448544,
-0.0350802504,
-0.0152684432,
-0.0092149712,
0.0058022216,
-0.0291696396,
0.0560360812,
0.0037469836,
0.0625514314,
-0.0008515032,
0.0446324162,
0.0093194684,
0.0196559411,
-0.0516858585,
-0.0514117368,
0.0049170684,
-0.0044218278,
-0.0646409839,
0.0069098328,
-0.0425859466,
0.0439703204,
-0.0083739674,
-0.0744802058,
-0.0191434827,
0.0198293384,
2.537e-7,
0.115715459,
0.0481774993,
0.0325885154,
0.0049601663,
0.0416176207,
0.0147278989,
-0.0178453438,
0.0211148448,
0.0084395437,
-0.030037865,
-0.0161810815,
0.0351441242,
0.0340487696,
0.0185406916,
-0.0822995156,
0.0004943862,
-0.0854540989,
-0.0254542604,
-0.0213146973,
-0.0435627736,
0.0439570956,
0.1062230468,
-0.0427539535,
-0.025852371,
-0.0102620758,
-0.0031394816,
0.0544233918,
-0.0131069319,
-0.0182818342,
0.0692004934,
0.0216101389,
0.0046274806,
0.0179545563,
0.0099634165,
-0.0195319019,
-0.0207533631,
-0.0039927168,
0.1087114438,
-0.0470329709,
-0.0373244509,
0.0213108081,
-0.0273793899,
0.025114283,
-0.056752719,
0.0738944411,
-0.0436523445,
-0.0739554688,
-0.051964324,
0.010927245,
-0.0078082276,
0.050438799,
-0.015692519,
-0.029287817,
0.0192900263,
0.0328193605,
0.0007393312,
-0.0231383611,
-0.0684253275,
-0.0491008759,
-0.0129244365,
-0.039177984,
-0.023709042,
0.0055818157,
-0.0235413797,
0.0131072691,
-0.0630825534,
0.0179979391,
2.227460546e-34,
0.0209928099,
0.0020851518,
0.0279068798,
0.0445600376,
0.0216363929,
-0.0168451183,
0.0104832482,
0.0098165357,
0.0320906825,
-0.0923501477,
-0.000382477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14447v1 | Analyzing Vietnamese Legal Questions Using Deep Neural Networks with Biaffine Classifiers | 2023-04-27T18:19:24 | 2023-04-27T18:19:24 | Nguyen Anh Tu, Hoang Thi Thu Uyen, Tu Minh Phuong, Ngo Xuan Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose using deep neural networks to extract important
information from Vietnamese legal questions, a fundamental task towards
building a question answering system in the legal domain. Given a legal
question in natural language, the goal is to extract all the segments that
contain the needed information to answer the question. We introduce a deep
model that solves the task in three stages. First, our model leverages recent
advanced autoencoding language models to produce contextual word embeddings,
which are then combined with character-level and POS-tag information to form
word representations. Next, bidirectional long short-term memory networks are
employed to capture the relations among words and generate sentence-level
representations. At the third stage, borrowing ideas from graph-based
dependency parsing methods which provide a global view on the input sentence,
we use biaffine classifiers to estimate the probability of each pair of
start-end words to be an important segment. Experimental results on a public
Vietnamese legal dataset show that our model outperforms the previous work by a
large margin, achieving 94.79% in the F1 score. The results also prove the
effectiveness of using contextual features extracted from pre-trained language
models combined with other types of features such as character-level and
POS-tag features when training on a limited dataset. | [
0.0147626624,
0.0409455337,
-0.0125483852,
0.0532172509,
-0.0549645908,
0.0164835081,
0.0095004225,
0.0041801822,
0.0352372788,
-0.0997459814,
0.0093730651,
-0.065597631,
-0.0364848152,
0.0341654643,
-0.002719772,
-0.0353938453,
0.0185217299,
-0.00419949,
0.0248869192,
-0.0218553878,
0.0098837661,
0.0114271753,
0.0043841014,
0.0168909021,
-0.0521015786,
-0.0233797934,
-0.004188261,
-0.0071048429,
0.0028366561,
-0.0177951325,
0.028628679,
0.0480532013,
0.0145095363,
-0.0030995691,
0.0000017981,
-0.046005439,
-0.0344076455,
-0.0123465713,
-0.032016661,
-0.0048715742,
0.0113434456,
-0.0421568044,
-0.0047765793,
0.0029704771,
-0.0558462813,
-0.0175228473,
-0.0217500813,
0.0308739636,
0.0616597831,
0.0526849888,
-0.0150669292,
-0.0657350868,
0.0601930171,
-0.0303892586,
0.0171844009,
-0.0415006466,
0.0311859678,
0.0284420941,
0.0019595979,
-0.0142323291,
-0.0628576726,
0.0207272805,
0.0604953058,
-0.0100384196,
0.0008321212,
0.0037714578,
-0.0286674406,
0.035443604,
0.0155682256,
0.1119379848,
-0.0056757559,
-0.0309996717,
-0.0272029713,
0.0023263162,
0.0234974548,
0.0123315109,
-0.0339534171,
0.0670649782,
0.0074461997,
0.0325876474,
0.0405623987,
-0.0067816009,
0.0051909043,
0.0371931158,
-0.0332046561,
0.0255330671,
0.0014403521,
-0.0521837734,
0.0125699332,
0.0063893897,
-0.0388004854,
-0.0138706099,
0.0506056547,
0.0421525501,
0.0287178047,
0.0291752368,
-0.0242302064,
-0.0315695181,
0.0397254378,
-0.0850571319,
-0.0313157886,
-0.0049157734,
-0.0747319236,
0.0690937862,
-0.0858151242,
0.0169170909,
-0.0057982695,
0.0140468655,
-0.0331175067,
-0.0590884462,
-0.019484112,
-0.0263907239,
-0.0554721169,
0.0724092498,
-0.0530992113,
-0.028509343,
-0.0090756174,
-0.0032587475,
-0.0193751398,
-0.0074329493,
0.014077832,
0.0404665284,
-0.0137458118,
-0.0026979388,
-0.016539732,
0.0050506443,
-0.0794454515,
0.0361023583,
-0.0088977767,
-0.0202167239,
0.0121342186,
0.0250425749,
0.0604450032,
0.00241345,
0.0322960317,
0.0529430583,
0.0007252006,
-0.0302143525,
-0.0257304274,
-0.0626176223,
-0.0319001898,
-0.0106322309,
-0.0047496092,
-0.0660248995,
0.0167038739,
-0.0049606897,
-0.0099182259,
-0.0267878585,
0.0255375747,
0.037138924,
-0.0187678263,
0.0878901631,
0.0388905704,
-0.036399506,
-0.0045422274,
0.0107182087,
0.0692718178,
0.019529568,
0.0418532155,
0.0311958119,
0.0557489097,
-0.0172232389,
0.0152904838,
0.0092083765,
0.0110374764,
-0.0118622109,
-0.0018314869,
0.0300761648,
0.0092537617,
0.009922755,
0.0152542498,
0.0456812568,
0.0127721,
-0.0272465292,
-0.0064973435,
0.0585065,
0.0139779076,
0.0533266552,
0.039916791,
-0.0108987018,
-0.0080939988,
0.0061579957,
-0.0312169008,
0.0270373374,
-0.006763217,
0.0149408681,
-0.0148174716,
-0.0062813028,
-0.0290593281,
-0.0300125573,
0.0215426348,
-0.0355936214,
0.0184946656,
0.0151659986,
0.0379901938,
0.0259509441,
-0.0440015905,
0.0711742416,
0.0140171377,
-0.0258344617,
-0.0150402039,
-0.018230198,
-0.0221917778,
0.0207643192,
0.0362354964,
-0.0243479386,
-0.0063107964,
-0.0489431247,
-0.001788305,
0.0220970977,
0.0334792361,
-0.0205173697,
-0.0099600237,
-0.0435389541,
-0.0168664306,
0.0026255345,
0.0057905102,
0.0315558873,
-0.0141353579,
0.0333817191,
0.0486144945,
-0.0393267274,
-0.0109182606,
0.0309118535,
-0.0059865625,
-0.042113997,
0.0383534767,
0.0276248641,
-0.0053277514,
0.0425068289,
-0.0031818065,
0.011772709,
0.0423634127,
-0.0601226203,
0.000853108,
-0.0085660573,
-0.0401087515,
-0.0575915352,
0.0417995192,
-0.0362380929,
0.0155477794,
0.0337178372,
-0.029032059,
-0.040481776,
-0.0152670974,
-0.0033279099,
-0.0266074035,
-0.0873020664,
-0.0029112159,
0.002362581,
0.0277676973,
-0.0253949147,
0.0515479036,
0.0011329866,
0.0053191097,
-0.010351087,
0.0094493795,
0.043714568,
-0.0103152441,
-0.0228579044,
-0.0070402985,
-0.0303635541,
-0.0033788418,
0.0010300272,
0.0200095642,
-0.0327877253,
-0.0048380056,
-0.0991864502,
0.0154732037,
-0.0397865176,
-0.0070497952,
0.0058018849,
-0.0183616485,
-0.0046722274,
-0.0448668376,
-0.0590103492,
0.0046343226,
-0.0059776595,
-0.0046773362,
0.0237909202,
-0.0095340628,
0.00618015,
-0.0202085767,
-0.0393670425,
-0.0435213447,
0.0425454788,
-0.0118029984,
-0.0423641652,
0.017505819,
0.0370410793,
0.0176212788,
0.0178265385,
0.0013480167,
-0.0310954936,
-0.0167103466,
-0.0169624109,
-0.0348713212,
0.0631953999,
0.0165274441,
0.0130524337,
0.0002554252,
-0.0077164359,
-0.0516737513,
0.0202002563,
-0.0136241317,
0.0402553752,
-0.0287339557,
-0.008794304,
-0.0318437442,
0.023700146,
0.0189050473,
-0.021795515,
-0.0026595877,
-0.0305498894,
-0.0022911674,
-0.0162763875,
-0.0057328907,
-0.0016421096,
-0.0171218552,
0.0045487438,
-0.0099566346,
-0.0357246622,
0.0888864174,
0.0148228947,
0.00632702,
-0.0555945337,
0.0043446263,
-0.0813428164,
0.0851422921,
0.0210430529,
0.0046095941,
0.0009368949,
-0.0544912778,
0.0218598712,
0.0029196511,
0.0123334052,
-0.0579476096,
0.0456260331,
0.0093754856,
0.0210737735,
-0.0147933727,
-0.0480220765,
-0.0578779653,
-0.0478761755,
-0.0099373581,
0.0483111367,
0.0063649761,
0.0438616909,
0.032708846,
0.0253406875,
-0.0299393311,
-0.0100665344,
0.0064525753,
0.0100037558,
-0.048582349,
0.1051291525,
0.0617215969,
0.0059814001,
0.004112592,
0.005684034,
0.0380719714,
0.008321641,
0.0073648379,
0.0323770754,
0.003850475,
0.0143806692,
-0.0052143415,
-0.0347536206,
-0.0054444806,
-0.0097527578,
0.0094777578,
-0.0846225694,
-0.0159921516,
0.0962030068,
0.0456502214,
-0.0341875441,
-0.0100038778,
-0.0070848879,
-0.0280160457,
0.0182452165,
0.0396124981,
-0.0954474062,
-0.0467853658,
-0.010720985,
-0.0374671072,
-0.0002664418,
-0.0340919904,
0.0096577117,
-0.1143808365,
0.0246270727,
-0.0140031967,
-0.0043824539,
-0.044189699,
-0.0019359601,
-0.0209047627,
0.020031549,
0.0272326004,
-0.0242134351,
-0.0140449088,
-0.0198569354,
0.0181888491,
-0.0671413839,
0.0125795826,
0.0655607134,
-0.0413577184,
0.0135482624,
0.0611867048,
0.0252941065,
-0.0409908816,
-0.0032900912,
0.0555139109,
-0.0360647254,
-0.0046129762,
0.0058256099,
0.0311417896,
-0.035697829,
-0.0067392522,
-0.0152613893,
0.0510380641,
-0.0501990132,
-0.0013885306,
0.0067936424,
0.0956266299,
-0.0489917845,
-0.028844839,
-0.0181316491,
0.0011895001,
0.0038525725,
0.0770838708,
0.0295865778,
-0.0250535198,
-0.0537162088,
-0.0485540591,
-0.0045514614,
-0.0950868875,
-0.0030385719,
0.0038784216,
0.0211244207,
0.0244235508,
-0.0582975037,
-0.0737804845,
0.0451571234,
0.0262173433,
-0.0099255927,
0.0297412015,
0.0257280227,
-0.0052025975,
-0.0417771675,
0.0296596121,
-0.0354337431,
0.0131540075,
-0.0097963987,
0.0249441639,
0.023952011,
-0.0089988504,
-0.0099032316,
-0.0189734753,
-0.0315038748,
-0.0092546092,
0.0041473117,
0.0110117672,
0.0054575885,
0.0318078846,
-0.0487516075,
-0.0421569496,
0.011608053,
0.0453198552,
-0.0186078306,
-0.0414234214,
0.0427924395,
-0.0011485668,
-0.0215732362,
0.0353966951,
-0.0138550252,
0.0119676655,
0.0137643553,
0.0546822399,
-0.0166614987,
-0.0282805804,
0.0269465018,
0.0292696636,
0.0252879784,
0.0191266499,
-0.0087710172,
-0.0570544749,
0.020016456,
-0.0255372413,
-0.0041702227,
-0.0083204629,
0.0212279446,
0.0372063406,
-0.0338975713,
-0.0295627806,
0.0305229966,
0.0173903666,
-0.0069051539,
-0.0067348545,
0.0422495194,
0.0574778505,
0.0183822699,
-0.027625896,
-0.0297280289,
-0.0004945818,
0.0079781255,
0.0179243572,
0.0618785284,
-0.0079031466,
0.044795949,
-0.012481208,
-0.0087503763,
-0.0428219512,
-0.018060375,
-0.0383555666,
-0.0084763085,
-0.0277951695,
0.0272891503,
0.0747016519,
-0.0430010892,
-0.0329797715,
-0.0288486853,
-0.0117927529,
-0.0008854266,
0.038651634,
0.0142334951,
-0.026448153,
0.0463504568,
0.0306302272,
-0.0145288883,
0.0291431621,
0.0384982862,
0.0048019025,
0.0163542144,
0.0288560167,
-0.0306632854,
-0.0314636044,
0.0014256418,
0.019163575,
0.0519765392,
-0.0413976908,
0.0115962038,
-0.047099255,
-0.0395119265,
0.0160429627,
-0.0150303002,
-0.0069701271,
0.0266037378,
0.0340391956,
0.0378310531,
0.0487216823,
-0.0095481705,
-0.0564021915,
0.0903386846,
-0.0194592811,
-0.0013891393,
0.0164860822,
-6.155504086e-33,
-0.016554663,
-0.0528561622,
-0.0055201645,
-0.0024403764,
-0.026693536,
-0.0057555726,
-0.0341618285,
-0.0081135128,
-0.0814899504,
0.0092742378,
-0.0158048011,
0.0208443552,
0.0275230464,
0.0392063893,
0.0198985562,
-0.0652288496,
-0.0124481255,
0.0090274597,
0.0444279797,
0.0022370215,
0.0239642374,
0.0876155496,
0.0270610955,
-0.0675761476,
0.0565619133,
0.0095286248,
0.0282499455,
0.000821064,
-0.0145327449,
0.0746282414,
-0.0427113138,
0.0645435303,
0.0583284423,
-0.0427141711,
-0.0010701333,
0.0614392757,
-0.1322871149,
-0.0072997343,
-0.0152473934,
-0.0003153868,
-0.0556339622,
-0.0426241718,
0.0382604487,
0.0170106739,
0.0511656031,
-0.0164203774,
0.037594337,
-0.0455586836,
-0.0100590363,
-0.0299045183,
-0.0557198301,
0.0326362252,
0.0127789732,
0.0055498127,
0.0461528152,
0.0301926397,
0.0067471322,
0.0378659703,
-0.0739016011,
-0.0223819949,
-0.0071781962,
0.0121762762,
0.0192201529,
-0.0195809472,
-0.0225489717,
0.0532016829,
0.0018521558,
-0.0303692725,
-0.0189848952,
-0.0083592366,
0.0325180367,
0.0595048182,
0.0424659811,
0.0256080478,
0.0682292879,
-0.0076481719,
-0.0952199772,
-0.0196719263,
0.0315596238,
0.045644667,
-0.0151324142,
-0.0215720795,
-0.0506202802,
-0.0202682093,
-0.0174366906,
-0.0385690518,
-0.0223567542,
-0.0127286548,
0.0159278922,
0.019391099,
0.0013147688,
0.0166393071,
0.0320886336,
-0.0931257233,
0.001106233,
0.0404153205,
-0.0025832586,
0.0150629757,
-0.0041197902,
0.0766149685,
-0.014873961,
-0.0033294978,
-0.0269361623,
-0.0575510971,
0.0029511289,
0.0045242705,
0.0684780851,
-0.025613647,
-0.0677853301,
-0.0165795591,
-0.001804539,
-0.0285747107,
0.0032450689,
0.0852278247,
-0.0052708159,
0.0739797577,
0.0239444952,
0.0628796518,
0.010644298,
0.0161504094,
-0.0202768166,
-0.0427608937,
0.0000371028,
0.0005051713,
-0.026538169,
0.007776543,
-0.0201311316,
0.0819264352,
0.0137352347,
-0.0440977402,
0.0084414743,
0.0446944088,
2.412e-7,
0.1232840568,
0.0107968682,
0.0625584424,
0.0010900857,
-0.006580614,
0.0389078483,
0.025985375,
0.0410734788,
0.0096590575,
-0.0362763144,
0.027753707,
0.0357345827,
0.04644683,
0.0340803824,
-0.0905805677,
0.0153814498,
-0.0138866436,
-0.0476015657,
-0.0394752659,
-0.0039270264,
0.0656068549,
0.0929182842,
-0.0070926985,
-0.0248306096,
-0.0162920579,
-0.0392770693,
0.0406419523,
-0.0062573422,
-0.0127948802,
0.0075147357,
0.0231825318,
-0.0244534966,
-0.0147407223,
0.0441392139,
-0.0197714809,
0.0563104413,
0.0216835048,
0.0340863988,
0.0082823914,
-0.0264290944,
-0.021125827,
-0.0457026586,
0.0188146532,
-0.0224809349,
0.1076875553,
-0.0231032372,
-0.0085774763,
-0.0231426898,
-0.0157863256,
0.0013253917,
0.0343561843,
-0.0095096165,
-0.0222137664,
-0.0005037765,
0.0376721583,
-0.0303684715,
0.0077530323,
-0.0741400123,
-0.0207887124,
0.0327226929,
-0.0273654684,
0.0433414206,
-0.0048977351,
-0.0045970362,
0.0743006244,
-0.0451340452,
0.0254170485,
2.338905905e-34,
0.0419016778,
0.0082716215,
0.0098249037,
0.0451650321,
0.0319062248,
-0.0103745796,
-0.0647018626,
-0.0105067929,
0.0010029066,
-0.1092524305,
-0.0211477485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14405v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14405v1 | ViMQ: A Vietnamese Medical Question Dataset for Healthcare Dialogue System Development | 2023-04-27T17:59:53 | 2023-04-27T17:59:53 | Ta Duc Huy, Nguyen Anh Tu, Tran Hoang Vu, Nguyen Phuc Minh, Nguyen Phan, Trung H. Bui, Steven Q. H. Truong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing medical text datasets usually take the form of question and answer
pairs that support the task of natural language generation, but lacking the
composite annotations of the medical terms. In this study, we publish a
Vietnamese dataset of medical questions from patients with sentence-level and
entity-level annotations for the Intent Classification and Named Entity
Recognition tasks. The tag sets for two tasks are in medical domain and can
facilitate the development of task-oriented healthcare chatbots with better
comprehension of queries from patients. We train baseline models for the two
tasks and propose a simple self-supervised training strategy with span-noise
modelling that substantially improves the performance. Dataset and code will be
published at https://github.com/tadeephuy/ViMQ | [
0.0549123771,
0.0407171547,
0.008171279,
-0.0158654936,
-0.0180853959,
0.0330799781,
0.023590114,
0.0031116786,
0.0809245035,
-0.0277108438,
-0.0370437726,
-0.057550896,
-0.0297425333,
0.0345218591,
0.0111655239,
-0.0403469913,
0.0294633582,
0.0145981153,
0.0487354286,
0.0172010735,
-0.0033013339,
0.0116027398,
-0.05647761,
0.0653421283,
-0.0082143014,
-0.0187336709,
-0.0264008082,
0.0470625907,
0.0249330904,
-0.0905414745,
0.0319849811,
0.0735787451,
-0.0267207883,
0.0095189838,
0.0000016871,
-0.0452814884,
-0.0226646475,
-0.0069210948,
-0.0403844565,
-0.0543692075,
0.0290838107,
-0.0188990552,
0.0096392119,
0.0449827574,
-0.0465634689,
-0.0424368195,
0.0163280014,
0.0697084591,
0.0749841332,
0.078768976,
-0.0287696738,
0.0285334997,
-0.0077452851,
-0.0295985863,
0.0782707408,
-0.0564658567,
0.0366207957,
0.0237232372,
0.0184790902,
0.0000720525,
0.0157263018,
0.0115560321,
-0.0224523284,
0.0014665502,
0.0519728065,
0.039202176,
-0.0137443561,
-0.0185375959,
-0.015773043,
0.1031353548,
0.0278129634,
0.0092727169,
0.0209187418,
0.0030438609,
0.0041983952,
-0.0320372209,
-0.0299962182,
-0.0040084203,
-0.0183104035,
0.0038566387,
0.0108741485,
-0.0131784128,
0.0150050316,
0.0005613211,
0.0079291137,
-0.0520789884,
0.0023515427,
-0.0292168017,
0.0063965889,
0.0007926148,
-0.0311196931,
-0.067278713,
0.020074429,
0.0591419041,
-0.0491943657,
0.0138383508,
-0.0378887765,
-0.0169968884,
0.0515039638,
-0.0625787526,
-0.0450741053,
0.0396978743,
-0.0221434161,
0.0349495746,
-0.0054490287,
0.0029325555,
-0.0065475642,
0.0298286378,
-0.0475005284,
0.0106038181,
-0.0625743195,
-0.0056252875,
-0.0663740709,
0.0543559268,
-0.0303280931,
-0.0043364051,
-0.0648945495,
0.014062142,
0.0223213974,
0.0089394171,
0.0271197632,
0.0186385605,
-0.068184346,
0.0287523177,
-0.0069327257,
0.0210942328,
-0.0392820574,
0.035428796,
0.0452310592,
-0.0785598755,
-0.0173668135,
0.0335516445,
0.0253945328,
-0.0265223905,
0.019759791,
0.0407629646,
-0.0040150317,
-0.0309531186,
-0.0175637491,
-0.033925835,
-0.0241688006,
-0.041041851,
-0.0088520627,
-0.0344419964,
0.0296868943,
0.0030987829,
0.010591588,
-0.0153792696,
0.0203991625,
0.0211714339,
-0.0142082656,
0.0679810867,
-0.0336812586,
0.0023022674,
0.0353096686,
0.0318602547,
-0.0035468517,
0.0497015528,
0.0193663519,
-0.0121355001,
0.0087081743,
-0.0068645775,
-0.0181728788,
-0.0312513225,
0.032521978,
-0.0376524366,
0.0291322693,
0.0276795551,
-0.00034345,
0.0766431987,
-0.038714502,
0.0809002519,
-0.0320398249,
0.0043588555,
0.017000325,
0.0384547114,
-0.0133803459,
0.0009165716,
0.0106838513,
-0.0183556974,
0.0154637648,
0.0036808767,
-0.0023466451,
0.0047099404,
0.0151546169,
-0.018436186,
0.0297457632,
-0.0196353681,
-0.0729103386,
-0.03461181,
-0.0124432761,
-0.02886004,
-0.0031260815,
-0.01880976,
0.0316838175,
0.0298513491,
-0.0406364426,
0.0536974929,
0.0221121199,
-0.0595889874,
-0.0195027981,
-0.0530558228,
0.0066476152,
0.0250524543,
0.054321751,
-0.0379509181,
-0.0670959353,
-0.0455296822,
-0.001395609,
0.0162217747,
0.028508611,
-0.0334366187,
0.0298502613,
-0.0502992794,
-0.0034321377,
-0.0026008466,
0.0017489593,
-0.0255898051,
0.0053075929,
0.0009792582,
-0.0093056485,
-0.0345078073,
-0.0222535655,
0.0496477298,
-0.0366546661,
-0.0271116123,
0.049382966,
-0.0066916631,
0.038231045,
0.0480613895,
0.0036571787,
0.0028488028,
0.039991457,
-0.0206252038,
-0.0220418889,
0.0314127691,
-0.0184748285,
-0.0913008377,
0.018608395,
-0.0228141733,
-0.0097129429,
0.0045625065,
-0.033159472,
-0.0654815063,
-0.0543419905,
-0.0253399238,
-0.0237394944,
-0.0536619835,
0.006319643,
0.0440887362,
0.0161793474,
-0.038295716,
0.0381384343,
-0.0015992742,
0.0158196241,
0.0258532502,
0.0263719317,
0.0193541832,
-0.0351817571,
-0.0261148699,
0.0105325347,
-0.0103702676,
-0.017149657,
0.0057710363,
0.056880109,
-0.0411975719,
-0.0240633059,
-0.1450391263,
0.0212748721,
-0.0198518466,
-0.0103391223,
0.033838205,
0.0430297628,
-0.0005294709,
-0.0465451442,
-0.0514708795,
0.0193948913,
0.0443218984,
-0.006171369,
0.037916217,
0.0290461723,
0.0107467696,
-0.021950867,
0.0101384101,
-0.0148689672,
0.0043301252,
0.0287804008,
-0.0310833175,
-0.0200302359,
-0.0108551122,
-0.0492988415,
-0.0022646061,
0.0046391492,
-0.0469637997,
0.0246672947,
-0.0209304821,
0.0254821628,
0.0635032058,
0.0269551035,
0.0469858125,
0.0131294653,
0.0350807942,
-0.018956922,
0.0433850102,
-0.041321788,
0.0222905371,
-0.0139419474,
-0.0481388457,
-0.0105478652,
0.0817612335,
0.0126624359,
0.0115572428,
-0.0538156144,
-0.0317775011,
0.0106758112,
0.0020972802,
-0.0259617846,
0.0373018943,
-0.031404037,
0.0362424925,
0.0143199228,
-0.0463966839,
0.0859329104,
-0.0012155939,
-0.0150791006,
-0.0787967294,
-0.0181711614,
-0.0396242812,
0.0350246839,
-0.0262083746,
0.0281232186,
0.0360493176,
-0.0436677448,
-0.0123328334,
0.0434544571,
-0.0073719318,
-0.0606293492,
0.0155462539,
-0.0073975613,
0.0436722264,
-0.0035077902,
-0.0420258306,
-0.0867243558,
-0.032952778,
-0.012467715,
-0.005950571,
0.0107966922,
0.0214280691,
-0.0110863978,
0.0360213332,
-0.0401927941,
0.0509573966,
0.0014102152,
-0.0048862267,
-0.0268108696,
0.0597489662,
0.035610728,
0.0301567689,
0.0056934673,
-0.0137825096,
0.0513991304,
0.0425817668,
0.0092788357,
0.0309878532,
0.0108930012,
0.006514003,
0.0169761963,
-0.0260535628,
0.0137770632,
0.0070159463,
0.0731583312,
-0.0177387055,
-0.0416438989,
0.124026306,
0.0263368394,
-0.0211620629,
0.0073548639,
-0.0171176698,
0.0222656857,
0.0034059731,
0.0221091378,
-0.0695644096,
-0.0206546728,
-0.0053667892,
0.028340416,
-0.0173783991,
-0.0237488057,
0.0138075519,
-0.0452078357,
0.0200108271,
-0.0170879588,
-0.0592026561,
-0.0256547201,
-0.0281675998,
-0.0128139444,
-0.0224246159,
0.0027972867,
-0.0171646029,
0.0009887,
-0.0162153132,
0.0338782668,
-0.0197869129,
-0.0644513071,
-0.0000941318,
0.0056059342,
0.0914259553,
0.0712812915,
0.0480909534,
0.0221401528,
0.0136566134,
0.0275729708,
-0.0111093409,
-0.0198633932,
-0.0177460462,
0.0989799947,
-0.0069226446,
-0.0121004591,
-0.0260066744,
0.0549673848,
-0.0334464796,
-0.0064177047,
0.0139780408,
0.0285820868,
-0.0566219538,
0.023992829,
0.0015051432,
0.0545639321,
0.0491139479,
0.0861714631,
0.0257504527,
0.0151966996,
-0.0382146612,
-0.0142306704,
0.0176410116,
-0.0355822444,
0.0020486205,
0.0491193384,
-0.0198561735,
-0.0331322514,
-0.0768482462,
-0.0572509356,
0.0510465056,
0.0366408415,
-0.002052637,
0.0269143749,
0.0209224299,
0.034263663,
-0.0256850608,
0.0188037679,
0.0002125577,
-0.0251803026,
-0.0387001857,
-0.0783323795,
0.0259116888,
-0.046971336,
0.0102919862,
-0.0203739498,
-0.0606448017,
-0.0237852857,
-0.0150493458,
0.0558196753,
0.0161004961,
0.0330623612,
-0.0090643559,
-0.0270638335,
-0.0236566067,
0.0275468007,
-0.0595823713,
-0.0531424396,
0.0294631142,
0.0450077653,
-0.0272793733,
0.0513584912,
-0.0026711915,
0.0236660335,
-0.0247234721,
0.0567723922,
-0.0179578885,
-0.0536386594,
0.0372737385,
0.0133265574,
0.022477176,
-0.0228304509,
-0.0228772145,
-0.0474135764,
0.0276571028,
-0.0384505168,
0.0029983618,
-0.0438683853,
-0.0056058536,
0.0139872655,
-0.0322633348,
-0.0104740383,
0.0104315225,
-0.0763639659,
0.0165565293,
-0.0241986122,
0.0168524105,
-0.0184802283,
0.0304964967,
0.0039644525,
-0.0175482314,
-0.0096846782,
0.0117539624,
0.0277376007,
0.0016537884,
0.0216205735,
0.0793169737,
0.0127749229,
0.0391435958,
0.0496138111,
0.0199181121,
-0.0524747148,
-0.0313396938,
-0.0165852439,
0.0398363546,
0.0312891416,
0.0231509712,
0.0473136716,
-0.033064127,
0.0095036048,
-0.0305987429,
0.0703282207,
-0.027260974,
0.0001928884,
0.051007472,
-0.0063835038,
-0.0115715312,
-0.020680394,
0.0970383063,
-0.0232505836,
0.042964492,
0.0423004404,
-0.0102483816,
-0.0642948672,
-0.0161355548,
0.0277197305,
0.0252154563,
-0.0333854146,
0.0029164127,
-0.0010199839,
-0.0347065739,
0.0054640532,
-0.031173341,
-0.0278714504,
-0.0047152429,
0.0622424074,
0.0353472494,
0.0056831716,
-0.010050077,
-0.0566338226,
0.0419976227,
-0.0646148622,
0.0049449215,
0.01339933,
-5.608577421e-33,
-0.040398702,
-0.0183167849,
0.0364526249,
-0.0149708828,
-0.0042288168,
0.0214471109,
-0.0585573949,
0.0070001506,
-0.0226082243,
-0.0083264774,
0.0099439314,
0.029749766,
0.0199660957,
0.0696962252,
-0.0137023935,
-0.0454235151,
0.0562606193,
-0.0096563315,
-0.0069571999,
0.0659872964,
-0.0177525729,
0.0634195954,
0.0278121475,
-0.0495734699,
0.0101339202,
-0.0104119256,
0.0098226024,
0.0140106864,
0.0280224551,
0.0394938067,
-0.0516623743,
0.0152931223,
0.04056127,
0.0016840113,
-0.0056391004,
0.006984516,
-0.100780949,
-0.0206393339,
-0.0429748259,
0.0257775001,
-0.0841323435,
-0.0237824433,
0.0067225038,
-0.0253968965,
0.0023227499,
-0.0007537224,
0.0082524996,
-0.0324779563,
0.0126493936,
-0.0132935196,
-0.016046416,
0.0287953168,
-0.017480934,
-0.0442673266,
-0.0197826512,
0.0786551461,
-0.0217842106,
0.0189011265,
-0.0217114966,
0.0123268273,
-0.0198991168,
0.0021171789,
-0.0157971419,
0.000902921,
-0.0031912916,
0.0347287618,
0.0562357269,
-0.0173238739,
-0.0350715928,
0.0422866791,
-0.046112638,
0.0388032049,
0.0129846754,
0.0242735781,
0.0031932425,
-0.0109229041,
-0.1098427698,
0.0600972176,
-0.0110151675,
0.014892837,
0.0042038839,
-0.023861248,
-0.0342325419,
0.0323763676,
0.0153246205,
-0.0150278322,
-0.0110529009,
-0.0481778793,
0.0340784751,
0.025009688,
-0.0093197981,
-0.0152632343,
0.0237498172,
-0.0320975371,
0.0191812143,
-0.0054995981,
-0.011370155,
-0.0128222583,
-0.0278534871,
0.0232519135,
-0.0568376407,
-0.0318485908,
0.0704825893,
-0.0104944557,
0.0221833754,
0.0342583917,
0.0120528927,
-0.0425626673,
-0.0489845052,
-0.0034052592,
-0.012944039,
0.0418165997,
-0.0554580875,
0.0781793371,
0.0033047704,
0.0147048328,
-0.0072548925,
0.0829360336,
-0.0242940038,
0.021105947,
-0.0768505111,
-0.0545455441,
0.0177580882,
-0.0075263707,
-0.0453150049,
0.0063076369,
-0.0465767831,
0.0276972968,
-0.0109599493,
-0.0445617698,
-0.0136045655,
-0.0115946466,
2.451e-7,
0.0625854656,
0.0242912415,
0.0455847234,
0.0319250077,
0.0148386098,
0.0178592596,
-0.0099182641,
0.0302040596,
-0.009792462,
-0.0322231948,
0.0421184264,
0.0189672019,
0.0420020893,
0.0073378957,
-0.0694551989,
-0.0267882515,
-0.0613183193,
-0.0193751603,
-0.0158118121,
-0.0234892629,
0.0851256624,
0.0727335215,
-0.0622299612,
-0.0059580496,
0.023015568,
0.0175507348,
0.0603984296,
0.0047562611,
-0.0146658598,
0.0716757253,
0.0287592392,
0.0256469008,
-0.0047475458,
0.0059381039,
-0.0226558316,
-0.0264409278,
0.0075595514,
0.0690774322,
0.0047308058,
-0.0489290394,
0.0125485715,
0.0476030633,
0.0318602696,
-0.0378694348,
0.082006678,
-0.0403085053,
-0.0569039099,
-0.0003551709,
0.0219259467,
0.0140753388,
0.0660133883,
-0.010733204,
-0.043925494,
0.0177799053,
0.0455867462,
0.0101563027,
-0.0173485968,
-0.0533523671,
-0.0131659163,
0.0030263253,
-0.0598514043,
-0.0296367481,
0.0031292292,
-0.0131419869,
-0.0340881199,
-0.0628856421,
-0.0081673097,
2.045505271e-34,
0.007672885,
-0.0145015083,
-0.0170427542,
0.0526095629,
0.0029744599,
-0.0459116064,
-0.0221266896,
-0.0059192702,
0.0368740819,
-0.0669462234,
-0.0168257114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14402v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14402v3 | LaMini-LM: A Diverse Herd of Distilled Models from Large-Scale Instructions | 2023-04-27T17:58:49 | 2024-01-29T02:58:23 | Minghao Wu, Abdul Waheed, Chiyu Zhang, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) with instruction fine-tuning demonstrate
superior generative capabilities. However, these models are resource-intensive.
To alleviate this issue, we explore distilling knowledge from instruction-tuned
LLMs into much smaller ones. To this end, we carefully develop a large set of
2.58M instructions based on both existing and newly-generated instructions. In
addition to being sizable, we design our instructions to cover a broad set of
topics to ensure diversity. Extensive analysis of our instruction dataset
confirms its diversity, and we generate responses for these instructions using
gpt-3.5-turbo. Leveraging these instructions, we fine-tune a diverse herd of
models, collectively referred to as LaMini-LM, which includes models from both
the encoder-decoder and decoder-only families, with varying sizes. We evaluate
the performance of our models using automatic metrics on 15 different natural
language processing (NLP) benchmarks, as well as through human assessment. The
results demonstrate that our proposed LaMini-LM models are comparable to
competitive baselines, while being much smaller in size. | [
0.0278387256,
0.0844778121,
-0.0169495903,
0.03609192,
-0.0074717072,
0.0225165337,
-0.0205349978,
-0.0006297692,
-0.0630333498,
-0.040356975,
-0.0468257815,
-0.0044805482,
0.0282225367,
0.0080605596,
0.0142201707,
-0.0418255143,
0.0083090169,
-0.0537982844,
-0.0283197761,
0.0055243294,
-0.0006928692,
0.0550044812,
-0.0073513188,
0.0726765394,
0.018776577,
-0.0081746103,
0.0150787327,
0.0280317757,
0.015068138,
-0.008698388,
0.0170420799,
0.0693904012,
0.0377139151,
0.0177597757,
0.0000020813,
0.0027173301,
0.0018373143,
-0.0055251587,
-0.0188980978,
0.0458128825,
0.0504755974,
-0.0663432404,
-0.0182246678,
0.012081868,
-0.0196015183,
-0.0324771032,
0.0389822088,
0.0021757707,
0.0551342703,
0.1187434271,
0.0080206962,
-0.0654422045,
0.0644713566,
-0.0341723487,
-0.0030241662,
-0.0407168306,
-0.0086067701,
-0.0094806161,
-0.0067321886,
0.0104902638,
-0.030239122,
0.025013689,
0.0350108072,
0.0431373082,
-0.0149942301,
0.0409504995,
-0.0050326525,
-0.015530346,
-0.043020647,
0.0731841698,
-0.0412099361,
-0.0135075646,
-0.0160346515,
-0.0051158979,
-0.0298474208,
-0.0311895963,
-0.0310164057,
0.0690375939,
0.0149072455,
0.0383358933,
0.0291618872,
0.0042133969,
0.0184868872,
-0.0077928579,
-0.0012813007,
0.0467614308,
0.0482676439,
-0.02254875,
-0.0137685724,
0.006517895,
-0.0309253149,
-0.0258247368,
-0.0196548011,
0.0055048568,
-0.0241886601,
0.009038805,
-0.0542104766,
-0.0174019467,
0.0129450625,
-0.018173242,
0.0673668534,
0.0683592409,
-0.0018836913,
0.013454576,
-0.0181113258,
0.070927456,
-0.0140070543,
0.0180509929,
-0.0243633166,
-0.0165744163,
-0.0686500296,
0.0019767771,
-0.0376832075,
0.0208543967,
-0.0869865417,
-0.0234612022,
-0.0295025837,
0.0255035181,
0.016899474,
-0.0100768479,
0.0645789579,
-0.0054605282,
-0.0348929241,
-0.0252319984,
-0.0077390489,
0.0377087481,
-0.0387796536,
0.0049102255,
0.0074609574,
-0.1002074182,
-0.0228805393,
0.0158101004,
0.0025611471,
-0.0357626341,
0.0244020578,
0.0582263432,
-0.0245363526,
-0.0418236367,
-0.0538565964,
0.0086870138,
0.0033410909,
-0.0738922581,
-0.0052858084,
-0.0482238606,
0.0430737287,
-0.003398211,
0.0390595682,
-0.0535754934,
0.0032485758,
0.0229451489,
-0.0213048644,
0.0566506684,
0.0203315374,
0.0185105056,
0.0114014912,
0.0207803939,
0.0164249614,
0.0741070881,
0.0414697677,
0.0140231354,
0.0127413878,
-0.0284907129,
0.0114111463,
0.0370519422,
0.0055241315,
0.0128033059,
-0.0138577269,
0.0020784077,
-0.0100335246,
0.0016911495,
0.0577482842,
0.0604592338,
-0.0340649746,
0.0021876267,
0.0688495934,
0.0360850617,
-0.009559623,
0.0340340883,
0.0786693543,
0.0298385136,
-0.0081116892,
-0.0107038319,
-0.0380833261,
0.0238837339,
-0.0239686482,
0.0177343842,
0.0431295931,
0.039134115,
-0.0406491905,
-0.0144004459,
-0.0139733534,
-0.0203030463,
0.0099016055,
-0.0085184583,
0.0287831482,
0.0194985457,
-0.0817783177,
0.0495633818,
0.0150146941,
-0.0501626879,
0.0048987223,
-0.0527982563,
0.0226285569,
0.1017264873,
0.0627545416,
0.0423474163,
-0.0148090171,
0.0000150711,
-0.0176500995,
0.0612771697,
0.0347021334,
0.0058380351,
0.0364098959,
-0.0914801583,
-0.0129800811,
-0.0239593033,
0.0384820104,
0.0442447029,
0.0544384755,
0.0046086698,
0.0265731849,
-0.0254345499,
0.0000414103,
0.042468302,
-0.0331826136,
-0.0470297486,
0.0222283863,
-0.0190636702,
0.0444376022,
-0.0011677856,
-0.0234665107,
0.001056117,
0.0294635817,
-0.0429625325,
-0.0002574998,
-0.0468375757,
-0.0443203598,
-0.0627159625,
-0.0127859963,
-0.0353794545,
-0.0155920442,
0.0422009341,
-0.0669199824,
-0.0394291021,
0.0120165199,
-0.0395527817,
0.0253786929,
-0.0531764627,
0.0095418785,
0.0375290699,
0.0334597714,
-0.0066961232,
0.0503592417,
-0.0259960815,
0.0060730181,
0.0454948023,
0.0149561567,
0.0031173856,
-0.0542191193,
-0.0029499957,
0.0183974653,
-0.014489104,
0.0065565077,
0.0031617437,
0.0544449911,
-0.0253093019,
-0.0563134551,
-0.0810240135,
0.0261165723,
-0.0414887182,
0.012677975,
0.0311845001,
0.0241581723,
-0.0162174832,
0.0099974675,
-0.0010913211,
-0.0173650123,
0.0050241179,
0.0217872411,
0.005858609,
-0.0007706183,
-0.0369638242,
-0.0165500212,
-0.0217389222,
0.0362312496,
0.0218459591,
-0.0420460366,
0.0271217953,
-0.0538611487,
-0.0045335656,
0.0111770956,
0.0125460085,
0.0044144318,
-0.0517408326,
0.0183146335,
-0.0209589321,
0.0528643951,
0.0406509414,
-0.0000798198,
0.04147337,
0.0196459945,
-0.0191064999,
-0.0627106801,
0.0254447795,
-0.0194112714,
-0.0538281687,
-0.0496205464,
-0.0361149982,
0.0195609089,
0.0843928233,
0.0152018331,
0.0211261753,
-0.1000105068,
-0.0101484042,
-0.0058631105,
-0.0335811973,
0.0024924204,
-0.001004131,
-0.0153923118,
0.00534224,
-0.0256925654,
-0.0587788261,
0.0583117828,
-0.0482538082,
-0.0268874373,
-0.0418504179,
-0.0051316228,
-0.042219948,
0.0509693027,
0.0000461842,
0.0064320541,
-0.0188809559,
-0.0546053089,
-0.031989608,
0.0258522592,
0.0146384155,
-0.0233170204,
0.0329853483,
-0.0832502842,
0.0045285067,
-0.0257016476,
-0.034347631,
-0.0382142738,
0.0004655981,
-0.0083911661,
0.0264719818,
0.0491821282,
-0.0228999835,
-0.0345700495,
0.017568294,
-0.0107449684,
0.0296699349,
-0.0066753388,
0.0030709158,
-0.0393859968,
0.0010196897,
0.0454384051,
-0.0072436677,
-0.0246704537,
-0.0230038017,
0.0337555222,
0.0334389061,
0.0370809622,
0.0196294282,
-0.0409711301,
0.0433678813,
0.0490028821,
-0.0115892319,
0.0035583901,
0.0551281311,
0.0526164137,
-0.0683326125,
-0.0213566311,
0.144335404,
0.0272786338,
-0.0401680432,
0.001527939,
0.0353562087,
0.0464346185,
-0.0117513016,
0.0068449844,
-0.0752383173,
-0.0561181307,
0.0040164487,
0.0338071398,
0.0057342597,
0.0160252936,
-0.0109564802,
-0.1238197014,
0.0534207039,
0.0296954885,
-0.0282071829,
-0.0626500174,
-0.0395353399,
-0.0359083302,
-0.018058585,
0.0388637334,
0.0060357563,
-0.0208367892,
-0.0005976424,
0.0153289149,
-0.0102789933,
-0.1084879488,
0.0328127332,
0.0029248227,
0.063673228,
0.0759127885,
-0.0080566509,
0.0241674948,
-0.0380881429,
0.0407829359,
-0.0436852537,
0.0145003386,
-0.0327608846,
0.0319288373,
-0.0240173042,
0.0109131616,
0.008261485,
0.0355487429,
-0.0801852569,
-0.0097578149,
-0.0081707379,
0.0530053712,
-0.025296919,
-0.029615825,
-0.0096184723,
-0.0294789523,
0.0037240072,
0.077561073,
0.0345292911,
-0.0318447351,
-0.0392912291,
-0.0159047972,
-0.0049417741,
-0.0828448683,
-0.0311327502,
0.0136261946,
0.0200045165,
-0.0302980617,
-0.0437873788,
-0.0310873743,
0.0400888994,
-0.0105692027,
-0.0009498595,
-0.0232326556,
0.008436176,
0.0171135999,
-0.0289078243,
0.0315671749,
-0.0312109031,
-0.0109930895,
-0.0863159522,
-0.0474762842,
0.029830439,
0.0237337612,
-0.0185035057,
0.0640966371,
-0.0912260339,
-0.0415896587,
-0.0396702364,
0.0554453433,
0.0219199024,
0.0500016659,
-0.0111368401,
-0.0253283139,
0.0220372137,
0.0069878572,
-0.0488463119,
0.0264531281,
0.0072269686,
-0.0185906123,
-0.0090496512,
0.0351936296,
-0.0255383514,
0.037267711,
0.0114838211,
0.0697132573,
-0.0125620291,
-0.0290826708,
0.02751638,
-0.0133755216,
0.0305132009,
-0.0369980894,
0.0052225594,
-0.0257944111,
0.0129101109,
0.002670422,
0.028216254,
-0.0580082238,
-0.0117268991,
0.0699831471,
-0.0228806101,
-0.0240492262,
0.0047584679,
-0.0055484176,
0.0269563496,
-0.0468908697,
0.0116243111,
0.0023787546,
0.0123323752,
0.0208153911,
0.0075062751,
-0.039113272,
0.0220746566,
-0.0020470456,
0.0281581637,
-0.0237614475,
0.037431486,
-0.0133531559,
0.0282777045,
-0.0016471961,
0.0332819372,
-0.0205704793,
-0.0264139865,
-0.0597265698,
0.0364709646,
0.0549071766,
0.0168740544,
0.0610593073,
-0.0239909347,
0.0013339589,
-0.0324839279,
0.034315981,
-0.0083866036,
-0.0091030058,
0.0124062784,
0.0193390958,
-0.0268606935,
-0.0321695879,
0.0914521217,
0.0311035514,
0.0514593236,
0.0016456462,
0.0266775843,
-0.041523762,
-0.048095271,
-0.0175942332,
-0.0065864767,
-0.0133557189,
0.0519901849,
-0.0148449531,
-0.0385527164,
-0.0373651832,
-0.0080111502,
0.0159165524,
-0.025446659,
0.0486352518,
0.0182122495,
-0.0440501869,
-0.050136514,
-0.0208024494,
0.0067743217,
-0.0443355814,
-0.0338419899,
-0.0477981381,
-6.847491162e-33,
-0.0517425239,
0.0248836428,
0.0303116608,
-0.0276386719,
-0.0091845039,
-0.0120498613,
-0.0367975459,
-0.0243993551,
-0.0066923788,
-0.0120913815,
-0.0041986546,
0.0079098111,
0.0153892431,
0.066869691,
0.009200315,
-0.0008997542,
0.0650577098,
-0.0282223523,
-0.0374379195,
0.0325083025,
0.0043606684,
0.02230452,
0.0468430109,
-0.030595867,
-0.0216294155,
-0.0088974359,
-0.035797935,
-0.005298066,
-0.0193102639,
0.0790719315,
-0.0302007087,
0.0393211357,
0.0118347974,
-0.075236477,
-0.0271545071,
0.003307946,
-0.0670023337,
-0.0111925798,
0.032280311,
0.0128666218,
-0.0230550095,
-0.0515450574,
0.0121020591,
0.0011107953,
-0.0216695517,
-0.017532466,
0.0094408356,
-0.02765988,
0.0034700693,
-0.0068445806,
-0.0472932421,
0.0192564111,
-0.0036682927,
-0.0314647742,
0.0335511714,
0.0357101299,
-0.0089733209,
0.0148131726,
-0.0430074297,
0.0091601769,
0.0444629565,
0.065754056,
0.0621753298,
0.0007156888,
0.0051979814,
0.017357951,
-0.0181880686,
-0.0254388936,
-0.0276943687,
-0.0112480894,
-0.0035305726,
0.0772344097,
0.0098467674,
-0.0089468686,
0.0392278098,
-0.0017669342,
-0.0411770903,
0.0267760754,
0.0198907256,
0.0477199294,
0.0348067917,
0.0258617848,
-0.0257002041,
-0.0099000866,
-0.0422066078,
-0.0132557955,
-0.0245060381,
-0.0088062063,
0.068124339,
0.0420586094,
-0.0026601115,
-0.0084962426,
0.0543215163,
-0.0277706049,
0.0214769114,
0.027491387,
-0.0057133241,
0.0078088003,
-0.000276496,
0.0268212687,
-0.0313792527,
-0.0500974208,
0.0541638359,
-0.0350155868,
0.0014350784,
-0.0118330512,
-0.0073921513,
0.0393141769,
-0.0713213161,
0.0008646093,
-0.0375200249,
0.0497259833,
-0.0343362316,
0.0399472862,
0.0106524993,
0.0241029914,
-0.010537656,
0.0447139516,
-0.0429561548,
0.0092556803,
-0.0130636683,
-0.024684133,
0.0219890643,
0.0280703995,
-0.0240496472,
0.0322296396,
-0.0363671333,
-0.0239546169,
0.0187085625,
-0.0090101995,
-0.0226139557,
0.0354932807,
2.693e-7,
0.017392911,
0.0300648026,
0.0338399149,
0.0308379121,
0.0225887075,
0.0106700463,
-0.0227182321,
0.0234485529,
0.0075615803,
-0.0281910896,
-0.0013723985,
0.0398305804,
0.0796332806,
0.005226925,
-0.0788883045,
0.0162850264,
-0.0291011985,
0.0385071449,
-0.0626453906,
-0.0267109964,
0.0301271491,
0.102999635,
-0.0194878895,
-0.0023255099,
0.0093382103,
0.0132255871,
0.0663108826,
-0.032008864,
-0.0062788557,
0.0231424328,
-0.0005710982,
0.0432984047,
-0.001602086,
0.0086324951,
-0.0270145983,
0.0065969764,
-0.0059872088,
0.1249892563,
-0.0087531311,
-0.0649866462,
0.0274407752,
-0.0100163464,
-0.0189090036,
-0.0255347732,
0.043777395,
-0.0382843614,
-0.0022559681,
0.0176190417,
-0.0343952775,
0.0037837476,
-0.0049576629,
-0.0367077738,
-0.0089654578,
0.0093788123,
0.0479190201,
-0.0083906353,
-0.0193111096,
-0.0768392533,
0.0035049834,
-0.0027202461,
-0.0540233925,
-0.0400507413,
-0.0517007001,
0.0211946722,
0.0318306386,
-0.0383831039,
-0.0202291738,
2.504466938e-34,
0.0345409475,
-0.0099388808,
0.0152268922,
0.038214799,
0.0356073789,
0.0003640958,
-0.0405575782,
0.0201026723,
-0.0187358949,
-0.0940885022,
-0.0295177381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14399v2 | We're Afraid Language Models Aren't Modeling Ambiguity | 2023-04-27T17:57:58 | 2023-10-20T05:46:14 | Alisa Liu, Zhaofeng Wu, Julian Michael, Alane Suhr, Peter West, Alexander Koller, Swabha Swayamdipta, Noah A. Smith, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ambiguity is an intrinsic feature of natural language. Managing ambiguity is
a key part of human language understanding, allowing us to anticipate
misunderstanding as communicators and revise our interpretations as listeners.
As language models (LMs) are increasingly employed as dialogue interfaces and
writing aids, handling ambiguous language is critical to their success. We
characterize ambiguity in a sentence by its effect on entailment relations with
another sentence, and collect AmbiEnt, a linguist-annotated benchmark of 1,645
examples with diverse kinds of ambiguity. We design a suite of tests based on
AmbiEnt, presenting the first evaluation of pretrained LMs to recognize
ambiguity and disentangle possible meanings. We find that the task remains
extremely challenging, including for GPT-4, whose generated disambiguations are
considered correct only 32% of the time in human evaluation, compared to 90%
for disambiguations in our dataset. Finally, to illustrate the value of
ambiguity-sensitive tools, we show that a multilabel NLI model can flag
political claims in the wild that are misleading due to ambiguity. We encourage
the field to rediscover the importance of ambiguity for NLP. | [
0.053555999,
0.0592108555,
-0.0328239426,
0.0627005026,
-0.0221434329,
0.0115340762,
-0.0120962784,
0.0073700929,
0.0192687567,
-0.0662783012,
0.0000021294,
-0.0198927205,
-0.0137849161,
0.0128233945,
-0.0091972705,
-0.056678433,
0.0960503072,
0.0188567527,
0.041680485,
0.0003437066,
0.0163431801,
0.0395460464,
-0.0123685366,
0.018098468,
-0.0501174182,
-0.0389898904,
-0.0241917949,
0.0321755745,
0.0199595522,
-0.0046941349,
0.0158400033,
0.0560369305,
0.02528161,
0.0587718301,
0.00000213,
-0.0441494696,
0.0081218695,
-0.0273791328,
-0.0378784649,
-0.0072806943,
0.0420209803,
-0.0044209599,
0.0140592279,
0.0151275788,
-0.0310997441,
0.0127207125,
0.0259638485,
0.0243859086,
0.0744086951,
0.0560710169,
-0.0022310528,
0.0164748728,
-0.0294066668,
-0.0287388265,
-0.0190868694,
-0.0634357333,
0.0087467358,
-0.042789124,
-0.0355748907,
0.0160709508,
-0.0136223687,
0.0636556074,
0.0419860631,
0.0385681242,
-0.0662652254,
-0.0045106267,
-0.0221630335,
-0.0317017771,
-0.0093129557,
0.0306302607,
0.0026461403,
-0.0304018874,
0.0105054555,
-0.0298605282,
0.0029999767,
0.0231704265,
0.0234763529,
0.0375119932,
-0.0339339152,
-0.0006359325,
0.0482254885,
0.0056317342,
0.0268212352,
0.06863866,
0.02223791,
0.0968366936,
-0.0047445754,
-0.0214081947,
0.0199597236,
0.002656912,
-0.0276242252,
-0.0455903746,
0.0283406992,
0.0164628886,
-0.0423601568,
0.0583211333,
-0.0797801688,
-0.0335701257,
0.0599438511,
-0.0657182336,
-0.0039491351,
0.01828501,
-0.0161042139,
0.0791944191,
0.0087062232,
0.010626141,
-0.0150220376,
0.0185574796,
-0.0298385769,
-0.0736100003,
-0.0253583398,
-0.0488575809,
-0.06548886,
0.022944795,
-0.0554956906,
-0.0057770661,
-0.018372383,
-0.0007192773,
-0.0496713705,
0.014464044,
-0.0099659218,
-0.006801785,
-0.0599112324,
-0.0192588028,
-0.0476988889,
0.0116410404,
-0.0427823327,
0.0498097464,
-0.0294511449,
-0.0760897174,
-0.0247468892,
0.0219753608,
-0.0483559892,
-0.0151942149,
-0.0196452122,
0.0405003242,
-0.005239686,
0.0183579586,
-0.0236643441,
-0.0387970395,
-0.0449636541,
-0.0448348187,
-0.0120255016,
-0.0581450686,
0.0420068651,
0.0284518842,
0.0176529009,
-0.0530302636,
0.0152166178,
0.0127157494,
-0.0283187367,
0.0911605805,
0.0000123373,
0.0084575033,
0.0436155982,
0.0418374799,
-0.0195949655,
0.0781066716,
0.0402570181,
0.0110641401,
0.0517897345,
0.0313129127,
0.0145824784,
0.024429841,
-0.0172167532,
0.0248276573,
0.0264651887,
0.0079504699,
-0.0590642877,
0.0284996163,
-0.0201548133,
0.0601407327,
0.0098073632,
-0.0369078293,
0.0615923293,
-0.0061452198,
0.0066968035,
-0.0108118365,
0.0212406721,
0.0324148759,
0.0107211275,
0.0056617269,
-0.0172602106,
0.0081389584,
-0.0433070771,
-0.0078403484,
-0.0070538302,
0.0298428778,
-0.0008066909,
-0.0529616326,
-0.0583041608,
-0.0204633977,
0.0433619954,
0.0119983209,
0.0357118286,
0.0170481447,
-0.0192336142,
0.0786879882,
0.0469841808,
-0.0458706133,
0.0218662396,
-0.0457464084,
0.0015936072,
0.0435752682,
0.0225199591,
-0.0181288905,
-0.0371433608,
-0.0307981055,
0.0006027105,
0.0754987001,
0.0827009454,
-0.008051225,
0.0292515457,
-0.0176264774,
-0.007980423,
-0.0365156084,
0.0561741777,
0.009891496,
0.0558729656,
0.0365686864,
0.0142612057,
-0.059029419,
0.0220439881,
0.0440791883,
-0.0042988267,
0.0101002362,
-0.0051098219,
0.0100763021,
0.023646988,
0.0172904469,
-0.0024597256,
-0.0291844737,
0.0253710374,
-0.0261833388,
-0.0324841663,
-0.027144663,
-0.0353803113,
-0.0104551772,
0.0156990308,
-0.0084052067,
-0.0658341646,
0.0276254676,
-0.0663495809,
-0.0340537429,
0.0256717298,
-0.0099648247,
-0.006224249,
-0.0540318154,
-0.0212694351,
-0.0157368742,
-0.0122137535,
-0.0513144433,
0.0691084564,
0.0064378707,
0.0142867127,
-0.0292751174,
0.0485749803,
0.0504364073,
0.0104395766,
-0.0248024147,
0.019007856,
0.0159053355,
0.0017535357,
0.0121368747,
0.0066176788,
-0.0515789129,
-0.0828328058,
-0.0847636685,
0.0239904393,
-0.0240211952,
-0.0084651196,
0.0342520699,
0.0119599346,
0.0039549568,
0.0056198016,
0.003514715,
-0.0374338515,
-0.0095263794,
-0.0155973667,
0.0440307893,
-0.0131071191,
0.0179762468,
-0.0100887986,
0.0330462418,
-0.0473926067,
0.0156257078,
-0.0193382781,
-0.0837958455,
-0.0200678501,
0.0266058482,
-0.0644588992,
0.0007976449,
-0.0102517912,
-0.0235807262,
0.0243640393,
0.0301997699,
0.0381266288,
0.0353191979,
0.0232454911,
0.0749617144,
0.0456035882,
-0.0153586892,
-0.0477981791,
0.0355011746,
-0.021290401,
-0.0041167284,
-0.0081355702,
-0.0230962057,
-0.0028235652,
0.0783572868,
0.0290491264,
-0.005059395,
-0.0354573615,
0.0322089754,
-0.0617221966,
-0.0272254962,
-0.0088872612,
-0.0096025066,
-0.0339879245,
0.0619481504,
-0.0211557671,
0.0104007106,
0.0835179165,
0.0112050185,
0.0169706419,
-0.0666995943,
-0.0243350752,
-0.0338507406,
0.0679591298,
-0.039303828,
0.0111793661,
0.0173056982,
-0.0047549964,
-0.0521182716,
-0.0425092392,
0.0291285645,
-0.0606576018,
0.0579508096,
-0.081390813,
0.0077114608,
-0.0178549159,
-0.0252672881,
-0.0506106839,
-0.0506706275,
-0.0118100112,
0.0194340982,
0.0064356951,
0.0141694499,
-0.0038787173,
-0.0061197835,
-0.0055001942,
0.0211634934,
-0.0113942334,
-0.0008873987,
-0.02542671,
0.0485049151,
0.0530988537,
0.0023220037,
0.038660381,
-0.0481469594,
-0.0177177247,
0.0226507541,
-0.0420066826,
0.0179210436,
-0.0371436588,
-0.0318841673,
0.0041655679,
-0.0260479599,
-0.0241560861,
-0.0071288976,
0.0542620793,
-0.0668989867,
-0.0064607393,
0.1230184883,
0.0523076653,
-0.018880887,
-0.0030275716,
-0.0098453304,
0.023384314,
0.0042137471,
-0.0099033527,
-0.1054678336,
-0.0504276864,
0.0179334097,
-0.0333818793,
-0.0131217754,
0.0023312562,
-0.0222730022,
-0.0589570589,
0.0194809213,
-0.0120312916,
-0.031756226,
0.0138848349,
-0.0181504842,
0.0058031096,
-0.0071385922,
0.0365032479,
-0.0270045009,
0.0242934246,
0.0029773447,
-0.0088717397,
0.0000962834,
-0.0594844855,
0.0092859725,
-0.019852832,
0.0525223836,
0.0257142354,
0.0400976278,
-0.0130631132,
0.0167764053,
0.0455080383,
-0.028527759,
-0.0409997441,
-0.0318393782,
0.0276089627,
-0.0020577246,
-0.0164146665,
-0.0110515822,
-0.0120669045,
-0.0295768715,
-0.0185387451,
-0.004428512,
0.0154026235,
-0.0274209157,
-0.0211066604,
-0.0060678306,
-0.0108924611,
0.0248798709,
0.0968353078,
0.0092872502,
-0.0243446752,
-0.0524457917,
-0.0436037667,
0.0534308366,
-0.0296731703,
0.0135360826,
0.0157567617,
-0.0136441709,
-0.0062816646,
-0.0291735958,
-0.0737025067,
0.0152370231,
-0.0079746833,
0.010743116,
0.0254166741,
0.0439405516,
0.0034803182,
-0.0309852641,
0.0388510153,
-0.0234897565,
0.0295063499,
0.014636186,
-0.0524936356,
0.0135922572,
0.0123547548,
-0.0236839708,
0.1075928137,
-0.0905542374,
-0.0372898318,
0.0457959101,
-0.0064753392,
0.0319005586,
0.0353119448,
-0.0718657076,
-0.0053771096,
-0.0363100432,
0.0476462506,
-0.0034672148,
0.0367053375,
0.0194768868,
0.0721168965,
0.0161043741,
0.057329312,
-0.0389282033,
0.0067680557,
-0.0193967987,
0.0178974904,
-0.0618841201,
-0.0763126612,
0.0169256944,
-0.0112463925,
0.01351861,
0.0104428437,
0.0028552338,
-0.036653623,
-0.006043084,
-0.0143739171,
-0.0432246327,
-0.0153120868,
-0.0202394091,
0.0257314816,
-0.0222737417,
-0.0357845128,
0.0504829176,
0.0012379974,
0.0640871525,
-0.0027329263,
-0.0393304788,
0.027363915,
0.0028762468,
-0.0414223447,
-0.0258063879,
-0.0390837453,
0.058726199,
-0.0345814228,
0.0333997421,
0.0129106008,
0.0419242717,
0.0334264003,
-0.0161750186,
0.0143448254,
0.002854164,
-0.0435284898,
-0.0307288952,
0.0050461036,
0.0372469723,
0.0350408554,
-0.0073233419,
0.0625167117,
-0.0342167765,
-0.0147040002,
0.0096240779,
0.044524543,
0.0317666568,
-0.0188027732,
0.0438578725,
0.0224975944,
-0.0236102063,
0.0207470804,
0.0568763353,
-0.0019234306,
0.0467203148,
0.0384923145,
-0.0192537736,
-0.0376522802,
-0.0408586115,
-0.0149451019,
0.0438345484,
0.0032312009,
0.0439730659,
-0.0723722652,
-0.0396961048,
0.0183221679,
0.0021985418,
0.0369572379,
-0.0060441215,
0.009935353,
0.0802220404,
0.01011106,
-0.0457833447,
-0.0555467419,
-0.0117909526,
-0.0007832796,
-0.0118731316,
-0.0583321154,
-6.852852151e-33,
-0.0728945807,
-0.0401639007,
-0.0246423986,
-0.0095872534,
-0.0218955278,
0.0106839072,
-0.0317244902,
-0.0129657211,
-0.0548186488,
0.0189694483,
0.0265900083,
0.0580924451,
0.017105585,
0.0275786929,
-0.0023094739,
-0.0328605436,
0.039747797,
0.0287866686,
-0.0061416877,
-0.01440001,
0.0424269661,
-0.0274065789,
0.0326813832,
-0.0739832669,
0.0195330195,
-0.0104809515,
-0.0617293976,
0.0133544328,
-0.0767491013,
0.0374226645,
-0.0177648235,
0.0416538268,
0.0120744724,
0.0301172975,
0.0079134675,
0.0232587643,
-0.0848467499,
-0.0280817412,
0.0559897423,
0.0269691143,
-0.0506113879,
-0.0294156466,
0.0278989766,
0.0032489216,
-0.0045812237,
0.0276284739,
0.0380247459,
-0.0161938686,
0.009182632,
-0.0540790595,
-0.0346698873,
0.0189172626,
-0.0027911172,
-0.0399822406,
-0.0101522775,
0.0124934902,
0.0012262531,
0.043600589,
-0.0837976336,
-0.0163130946,
0.0074071921,
0.0107497852,
0.0258659776,
0.0014503202,
-0.0235598423,
0.0441481657,
-0.0405687019,
0.0019005219,
-0.0215306878,
-0.0252538379,
0.013097615,
0.0136328693,
0.0474705361,
0.04385731,
0.031727273,
0.0043952232,
-0.045224186,
-0.0168872997,
0.0302172247,
0.011420981,
0.0276843831,
-0.0086838752,
-0.0213684998,
-0.016547896,
-0.0792532936,
-0.0316975489,
-0.0431523398,
-0.0010574028,
0.0346897915,
-0.0005739177,
-0.0005637074,
0.0179568511,
-0.0025231568,
-0.0346938074,
-0.000990401,
-0.0103423679,
-0.0044210581,
0.0159622543,
0.031490881,
0.0649015307,
-0.0008097212,
-0.0166070256,
0.0067673274,
0.0309470613,
0.0044744937,
-0.015446892,
0.0433226973,
-0.0212823618,
-0.0399640054,
0.0188661907,
-0.0287485737,
0.0348486826,
-0.0659845471,
-0.0212841667,
0.0384102166,
0.0345041752,
-0.0125177195,
0.0454619192,
0.0408072248,
-0.0009053609,
-0.0261285789,
-0.0105316695,
-0.0449980274,
0.027266426,
-0.0267168786,
-0.0159841496,
-0.0005253903,
0.0056420425,
0.0066402429,
-0.0304007735,
0.0006298489,
0.0024451944,
2.811e-7,
0.0768479332,
0.0718179271,
-0.0275434181,
0.0729077011,
0.010840077,
0.031096261,
0.0010643464,
0.0112829749,
-0.0341662504,
-0.0377574787,
-0.0445255302,
0.0384605713,
0.0595537648,
0.0346503928,
-0.0380249582,
0.0202281736,
-0.0122108124,
0.0351447873,
-0.0582911819,
0.0366507471,
0.0894782916,
0.0719134584,
0.0798670724,
0.0179074779,
-0.0540120155,
-0.0193913355,
0.0676691607,
-0.0303438921,
-0.0313754454,
0.0358257219,
0.0325563177,
0.0045241439,
0.0219123941,
0.0428210236,
-0.0094425483,
-0.0024128372,
-0.0002877689,
0.088756524,
0.0078064105,
-0.0353772938,
-0.0421148501,
-0.038408909,
0.0087956702,
-0.0692122355,
0.0668839067,
-0.0462212786,
-0.0186289512,
-0.0248944107,
-0.0261346214,
0.008872211,
0.0337586328,
0.0019967179,
-0.048736833,
0.003891784,
-0.0222620014,
-0.0162704252,
-0.0261697136,
-0.0461254865,
-0.0289695282,
0.0020063228,
-0.028979579,
-0.0149134547,
0.0133762155,
0.0097925048,
0.0463848002,
-0.0818730891,
-0.0026903534,
2.480645499e-34,
0.0447246544,
-0.0091450689,
0.0079187183,
0.0250612777,
0.06536863,
0.0099389153,
-0.0355094783,
0.0167913102,
-0.0121673448,
-0.0142905749,
0.0270375479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14395v1 | string2string: A Modern Python Library for String-to-String Algorithms | 2023-04-27T17:57:19 | 2023-04-27T17:57:19 | Mirac Suzgun, Stuart M. Shieber, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | We introduce string2string, an open-source library that offers a
comprehensive suite of efficient algorithms for a broad range of
string-to-string problems. It includes traditional algorithmic solutions as
well as recent advanced neural approaches to tackle various problems in string
alignment, distance measurement, lexical and semantic search, and similarity
analysis -- along with several helpful visualization tools and metrics to
facilitate the interpretation and analysis of these methods. Notable algorithms
featured in the library include the Smith-Waterman algorithm for pairwise local
alignment, the Hirschberg algorithm for global alignment, the Wagner-Fisher
algorithm for edit distance, BARTScore and BERTScore for similarity analysis,
the Knuth-Morris-Pratt algorithm for lexical search, and Faiss for semantic
search. Besides, it wraps existing efficient and widely-used implementations of
certain frameworks and metrics, such as sacreBLEU and ROUGE, whenever it is
appropriate and suitable. Overall, the library aims to provide extensive
coverage and increased flexibility in comparison to existing libraries for
strings. It can be used for many downstream applications, tasks, and problems
in natural-language processing, bioinformatics, and computational social
sciences. It is implemented in Python, easily installable via pip, and
accessible through a simple API. Source code, documentation, and tutorials are
all available on our GitHub page: https://github.com/stanfordnlp/string2string. | [
0.044363182,
0.0712773278,
-0.0004760528,
0.0181022994,
-0.0473270752,
0.0043269498,
-0.0247892197,
0.0283621009,
-0.042342905,
-0.0375485606,
-0.0000449553,
-0.0236053374,
0.0768060088,
0.0248019379,
0.0218966026,
-0.0282557178,
0.0429996662,
0.0506933555,
0.0233238153,
0.048247274,
0.030826265,
0.0262555685,
0.0038714984,
0.0431694649,
-0.0384521484,
-0.013352613,
-0.0044771647,
0.0287267324,
0.0809981227,
-0.0159678664,
0.0300020929,
0.0129302908,
-0.0092243413,
0.1150715798,
0.0000021035,
-0.0427754857,
-0.020481443,
-0.0100631909,
0.0243629087,
0.0295197554,
0.0432371758,
0.0071135331,
0.0009357608,
0.0222376622,
-0.0232865587,
0.0553686544,
0.1080104113,
-0.0288309157,
0.0478801131,
0.0799080729,
-0.0275505725,
-0.0265738592,
0.0332663171,
-0.0170820337,
0.0225615259,
0.0420324206,
0.0316960923,
-0.023203915,
-0.0313514918,
-0.0298660509,
-0.0027448877,
0.0470996536,
-0.0327892974,
0.0061044875,
-0.0207720343,
0.0129310209,
-0.032611277,
-0.0658460632,
0.0399259031,
0.038944155,
-0.0322809517,
-0.0421360657,
0.0184958484,
0.0111733321,
-0.0206340104,
-0.0095948037,
-0.0076875677,
-0.0162690952,
0.0087985843,
0.0079321284,
-0.0397383571,
-0.0452362671,
0.0292849895,
-0.0209431443,
-0.0152345849,
0.0060246871,
0.0523187816,
-0.0296181105,
-0.0409853123,
-0.0266118664,
0.0061064335,
-0.0544044524,
0.0825390741,
0.008835867,
0.0081176385,
-0.0280756056,
-0.0245576557,
-0.0748603642,
0.0236121416,
-0.0334997624,
0.0369255207,
0.0465189219,
-0.0005518418,
0.0007182084,
-0.0484548956,
0.0213447008,
0.0001214259,
0.056186948,
-0.0215652306,
-0.03059051,
-0.0654258281,
0.0269095544,
0.0058655553,
-0.0324386172,
0.0011542469,
-0.0157655422,
-0.0465625226,
-0.014996049,
-0.0050021405,
0.0110327667,
-0.0165674761,
-0.0022602347,
0.0050992221,
0.0361288302,
-0.0540640503,
0.0598757006,
-0.0321809649,
0.0111191766,
-0.0133936405,
0.0221233666,
-0.0301166885,
0.0294487569,
0.0307599921,
-0.050683327,
0.0246757697,
0.0206343234,
-0.0363561623,
-0.0439777263,
-0.0036507354,
0.0199991148,
-0.0243134163,
0.0001218639,
-0.0152280107,
-0.0722364411,
0.0701368526,
-0.046967119,
-0.025951419,
-0.0744376779,
0.0243546329,
-0.0013980793,
-0.044328846,
0.0927617252,
-0.0693688244,
0.0006246534,
0.0431023948,
-0.0052516544,
0.0246505868,
-0.0362756029,
0.0381309539,
0.0573525913,
0.0592421666,
-0.0078192363,
-0.0248827338,
0.0429971255,
0.0021219645,
-0.028781062,
0.0059075756,
-0.0011324055,
0.0601815917,
0.0572941601,
0.0462511703,
0.0426603444,
-0.0128152892,
-0.0473605469,
0.024675129,
0.0932571739,
0.0469601899,
-0.0227349289,
0.0417579375,
0.0160547607,
-0.0392886288,
-0.0390661061,
0.000587473,
0.0235067401,
-0.0180340558,
0.0282856934,
0.087871775,
0.0283904336,
0.0211415011,
-0.004329978,
-0.013763099,
-0.0079527376,
0.0096780723,
-0.046852123,
-0.0287715923,
-0.0467840172,
-0.0260189939,
0.0495590679,
0.0060410341,
-0.0634347796,
0.0040506832,
0.0097324532,
0.002899979,
0.0484498963,
0.0245575588,
-0.039068453,
-0.0406562947,
-0.0198034998,
-0.0505060293,
0.0557207353,
-0.0090899197,
-0.0139447516,
0.0244442131,
-0.049756825,
-0.0241438709,
0.0213498268,
-0.0227706991,
0.0009296748,
0.0269520767,
0.0435477681,
0.0453497916,
-0.0230823606,
-0.0188131202,
0.0747446716,
-0.0184904486,
-0.0304223076,
-0.0196722541,
0.0071920608,
0.0337735973,
0.007468719,
-0.0491505153,
0.0389846452,
0.0237468425,
0.0034344571,
-0.0088884579,
-0.0073601683,
0.0253258459,
-0.0285628904,
0.1070065573,
-0.0626712367,
-0.0284694303,
0.0570158586,
-0.0345749706,
-0.0497726351,
0.0040327646,
-0.0229640324,
0.0229546893,
-0.0426934324,
0.0440697223,
-0.017539328,
-0.0091952607,
-0.0155926589,
0.0099517731,
0.032239031,
0.0353681445,
-0.0439137928,
-0.0142932143,
0.0403663777,
-0.0489404872,
-0.0049269274,
-0.0320114754,
-0.0172317717,
-0.0124010853,
0.0174833182,
0.022786092,
-0.0468039587,
-0.031694524,
-0.0331338458,
0.0333880782,
0.0305326469,
0.0563795306,
0.0267967246,
0.0110520218,
-0.0247875992,
-0.0185688455,
-0.0113978237,
-0.0203345492,
-0.0251581464,
0.0161558352,
0.0555155985,
-0.0094481856,
-0.0557860024,
-0.0909783766,
-0.0089751771,
-0.0483093224,
0.0479356982,
0.011700945,
-0.0793598518,
-0.0239989553,
-0.02305598,
-0.085647352,
0.0014419211,
0.030385403,
-0.0604053289,
0.0095299669,
-0.0019729582,
0.0655107945,
0.0246688947,
0.0224339254,
-0.0611833744,
0.0460733846,
-0.0128252255,
-0.012291397,
-0.0188503321,
-0.0128411325,
0.0189982466,
0.0011417721,
-0.0469132662,
0.0347798169,
0.0515653379,
0.0003963879,
-0.0095840096,
-0.0520901754,
0.0222428869,
0.0540931225,
0.0114031415,
-0.0346174091,
-0.0084459325,
-0.0021884541,
0.0022566565,
-0.0283405147,
-0.0063410192,
0.0326669216,
-0.0556035899,
0.0335641317,
-0.0520943888,
-0.0329116769,
-0.0120613212,
0.0873457864,
0.0066256775,
0.0410329066,
0.0059780562,
-0.0177860558,
0.0011833297,
0.0366732515,
0.0457627587,
-0.0314801782,
-0.0308345575,
-0.044485677,
0.0415740348,
-0.0134288948,
0.014079405,
0.0042359564,
0.0143576227,
-0.013343595,
-0.0025299687,
0.0249761008,
-0.0662112385,
-0.049328398,
0.0201557279,
0.0103927087,
0.0577389188,
0.0263228305,
0.0117271682,
-0.0053477217,
0.0590387695,
-0.0093456302,
-0.0344858132,
0.002740301,
0.0063155405,
-0.0004076049,
0.0477959961,
-0.0257317983,
0.0253475849,
0.0058578853,
-0.024805693,
-0.025450008,
-0.067405276,
0.0380505286,
0.0036210069,
0.0310958605,
-0.023754796,
-0.0268495325,
0.1225750521,
0.0840025917,
-0.035741128,
0.0174648203,
-0.0616001673,
-0.022403961,
0.0460174084,
0.0191563386,
-0.0458942354,
-0.0283975527,
0.0153111266,
-0.0069420435,
0.0080725634,
-0.0411870591,
0.0043291235,
-0.0502281487,
-0.01707674,
0.0189969745,
-0.0564934388,
-0.0790479407,
-0.0584198609,
0.0093729701,
-0.0156926792,
-0.042427469,
0.0328293853,
-0.0083908904,
0.0068698898,
-0.0030739785,
0.0226899404,
0.00034116,
0.0024862553,
-0.0840836093,
0.0363940969,
0.0679596141,
0.0853215754,
0.0441177152,
-0.0414977223,
0.0080423141,
0.0073478301,
-0.0234278552,
-0.0183631945,
0.0562662445,
0.0288934279,
-0.0201843884,
-0.0182128325,
-0.0182224624,
-0.0195201188,
-0.0267129987,
0.0239875186,
0.0309142433,
0.0184726547,
-0.007868127,
-0.0262640119,
0.0160542075,
-0.0371904299,
0.0466458797,
0.0600160323,
0.0139965247,
-0.0313302688,
0.0020222343,
-0.0088972244,
-0.0273426864,
-0.0514590107,
-0.004278996,
-0.0312673114,
0.0218986981,
-0.0920379236,
0.0288435034,
0.0204200651,
0.0000999692,
0.0106569314,
-0.0182000566,
-0.0147045925,
-0.0497346818,
-0.1079739928,
0.0189749878,
-0.0102406964,
0.0288225543,
-0.0353728458,
-0.0155925266,
0.0274477042,
0.0352504067,
-0.0306183621,
0.028232621,
-0.0776031241,
-0.0509697534,
-0.0345394872,
0.0091545815,
0.006759136,
-0.0078710811,
-0.0064948979,
0.0302835368,
0.0014228527,
0.0443322286,
-0.0013798962,
-0.003249082,
-0.0039037897,
0.0048275972,
-0.0177096725,
0.0149559118,
0.0146920513,
-0.0197727419,
0.0240990445,
0.0584143996,
0.0061168526,
-0.0264655985,
0.0280260537,
0.0419730991,
0.0489944592,
0.0061336001,
-0.048791606,
-0.0375265703,
-0.0030097058,
0.0299532115,
0.0070086326,
-0.000075198,
-0.0231500994,
0.0175148323,
0.0354710631,
-0.0203112438,
0.0409261435,
0.0088965651,
-0.0040399963,
-0.007772164,
0.0071432376,
0.0336048678,
0.0699677691,
-0.013524849,
-0.0201911069,
0.0018914633,
0.0250056013,
-0.0161113162,
0.058097668,
-0.0563569926,
0.0034555688,
0.0258706193,
0.0320836529,
-0.0130963717,
0.0585203581,
-0.0148829827,
0.0259774532,
-0.0550753362,
0.0201046951,
0.0602137856,
-0.0290493164,
0.0464218371,
-0.0098435124,
-0.0134488288,
-0.0161746666,
0.0366553664,
-0.07037507,
-0.015810661,
-0.0135390172,
-0.0203549806,
-0.0284554791,
-0.0063374178,
0.0552988984,
-0.0225553811,
0.0822925493,
-0.0062508462,
-0.0638859868,
-0.0042838398,
-0.015475709,
0.0051111942,
-0.0145578152,
-0.0360955074,
-0.0295101795,
0.0085132075,
-0.0514729917,
0.0299298409,
0.0038245467,
-0.0177194234,
0.05520688,
0.0238287225,
0.001101634,
-0.0172796715,
0.0117502613,
0.0000671306,
-0.0004887136,
-0.0109254457,
-0.1036475673,
-0.0467269085,
-6.323992099e-33,
-0.0519643575,
-0.0247014966,
0.0010131585,
-0.0289773196,
-0.040009968,
-0.002350626,
-0.0368116535,
-0.0190078523,
-0.0074613872,
0.0171690024,
0.0296924263,
0.0338029005,
-0.006935521,
-0.0335256495,
0.0093880706,
0.0317861475,
0.030253876,
0.0367246307,
-0.0113197006,
-0.0282568075,
0.0503923334,
0.0285767913,
0.0897940993,
-0.0442342646,
0.0237061214,
0.0418929905,
-0.0098656109,
0.0167873725,
-0.027754413,
0.010972796,
-0.0051304284,
0.0046112407,
-0.0114204455,
0.0075407834,
-0.0065091546,
0.0051484308,
-0.0374623202,
-0.0382672288,
-0.0387178659,
-0.0463076867,
-0.0216382556,
-0.0088433446,
0.0411603227,
-0.003731132,
-0.0654765889,
-0.0090652201,
0.0390128084,
-0.0313670747,
0.0062060687,
-0.0222746339,
-0.0809172168,
0.0089037912,
-0.0541234575,
-0.0227941424,
0.0268199481,
0.015801521,
0.0235971455,
0.0188430864,
-0.0682915226,
0.0202814266,
-0.0049983575,
0.0660708249,
0.0302916206,
-0.0189461596,
0.0057905139,
0.0536012612,
0.0460402891,
-0.0850805789,
0.0494519696,
0.0547816828,
0.0008758247,
0.0108891074,
0.0599003322,
0.011587441,
0.007891166,
-0.0241954885,
-0.0482145585,
0.0683415458,
-0.0192778725,
0.0247123651,
-0.0461200774,
0.0504102223,
0.0018949081,
0.0110086109,
-0.0274308268,
-0.0190497953,
-0.0378444269,
-0.0011872607,
0.0129651139,
-0.0114894276,
-0.0155744506,
0.0406490341,
0.0006098375,
0.005873472,
0.0244029332,
-0.0478244238,
0.0119226957,
-0.0114119761,
-0.0265075359,
0.0091224564,
-0.0059159566,
-0.0148567799,
0.0138478782,
-0.0028609107,
0.0451381952,
-0.0544530414,
0.0043523321,
0.0004740001,
-0.0589925684,
0.0124384109,
-0.0225507561,
-0.0122030256,
-0.025512971,
-0.0111640096,
-0.0269446187,
0.0057796128,
0.0148322796,
0.0191018619,
0.0768862069,
-0.0403853431,
0.0011106894,
-0.0156368073,
0.0025166462,
0.0159001462,
-0.0485733412,
0.0294049475,
-0.0588908903,
0.0055415952,
0.0048947204,
-0.0467974953,
-0.0197572522,
0.0145904273,
2.831e-7,
0.0876484215,
0.0815322697,
0.0825011134,
-0.0202063732,
-0.0253715105,
0.0107444525,
-0.0042977054,
0.0253293775,
-0.0455301255,
0.0272187535,
0.0331612267,
-0.0307660624,
0.0209261961,
0.0130065028,
-0.0193435941,
0.0180730093,
-0.1320053637,
-0.0325414315,
-0.0647552758,
0.0213220734,
0.0236019213,
0.0736538619,
0.0328262933,
0.0014133777,
0.0045009577,
-0.0386977568,
0.024364775,
-0.0366208665,
0.0346853435,
0.0126899919,
-0.0453140847,
-0.0642426237,
0.0166535415,
0.0089354943,
-0.0128386617,
0.0098285666,
0.0313639045,
0.0247727986,
-0.04584435,
0.0126695838,
-0.0339802913,
0.0150261261,
0.0143525368,
-0.0413972288,
0.0289542042,
0.0117464131,
-0.0215493981,
-0.0074182944,
0.002107163,
0.0744404495,
0.0208258256,
-0.0010327297,
-0.0129297515,
0.015826026,
0.0377518088,
0.0441672504,
-0.0241586734,
-0.0606282875,
-0.039318271,
-0.0248611625,
0.002307676,
0.0151582751,
-0.0346612856,
0.0491337851,
0.0343996659,
-0.0387302302,
-0.0231376365,
2.68536335e-34,
-0.0178629588,
0.0049074595,
-0.0052030501,
0.0051396429,
0.0583585016,
0.0009271575,
-0.0184909906,
-0.0135062831,
-0.0322320797,
-0.029509211,
-0.0272830967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14391v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14391v4 | Energy-based Models are Zero-Shot Planners for Compositional Scene Rearrangement | 2023-04-27T17:55:13 | 2024-01-23T15:52:28 | Nikolaos Gkanatsios, Ayush Jain, Zhou Xian, Yunchu Zhang, Christopher Atkeson, Katerina Fragkiadaki | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Language is compositional; an instruction can express multiple relation
constraints to hold among objects in a scene that a robot is tasked to
rearrange. Our focus in this work is an instructable scene-rearranging
framework that generalizes to longer instructions and to spatial concept
compositions never seen at training time. We propose to represent
language-instructed spatial concepts with energy functions over relative object
arrangements. A language parser maps instructions to corresponding energy
functions and an open-vocabulary visual-language model grounds their arguments
to relevant objects in the scene. We generate goal scene configurations by
gradient descent on the sum of energy functions, one per language predicate in
the instruction. Local vision-based policies then re-locate objects to the
inferred goal locations. We test our model on established instruction-guided
manipulation benchmarks, as well as benchmarks of compositional instructions we
introduce. We show our model can execute highly compositional instructions
zero-shot in simulation and in the real world. It outperforms
language-to-action reactive policies and Large Language Model planners by a
large margin, especially for long instructions that involve compositions of
multiple spatial concepts. Simulation and real-world robot execution videos, as
well as our code and datasets are publicly available on our website:
https://ebmplanner.github.io. | [
0.0465442687,
0.0454372056,
0.0515952073,
0.0031697063,
-0.02116853,
-0.0053839493,
0.0010845294,
-0.021361718,
-0.0550223514,
-0.0603590682,
0.0000149501,
0.0193344876,
-0.010930337,
0.0340169966,
-0.0161140617,
-0.090808861,
0.003754555,
-0.0575907677,
-0.0079146493,
0.0177027807,
-0.0269636288,
-0.0134971524,
-0.0281378627,
0.0168728288,
-0.0351170748,
0.0195036661,
-0.0883369967,
0.0669030249,
0.0515673496,
-0.0087285927,
-0.0236320253,
0.0229318161,
0.0218940377,
0.0270801689,
0.0000019244,
-0.0371330306,
-0.0465467311,
-0.0141180009,
0.0113213239,
-0.0570674203,
-0.0031904005,
-0.0802351013,
-0.0260093957,
0.007375116,
-0.0262011979,
0.0038955193,
0.0898444653,
0.0041713812,
0.0801924095,
0.0908308625,
0.0008259565,
-0.0494246744,
-0.0021389723,
-0.0077217543,
0.0520280898,
0.0256195478,
0.0190435275,
-0.0077968473,
-0.0149733517,
0.0076756342,
-0.0567401052,
-0.0067812069,
0.0310975537,
-0.0443327874,
0.0002764379,
0.010076452,
-0.0435815714,
-0.0438933894,
-0.0090196682,
0.0393421315,
-0.0614002384,
-0.0095931524,
0.018077556,
-0.0225877203,
-0.0101862289,
0.008814401,
-0.0410433412,
0.0702258497,
0.0172330867,
-0.0127243167,
-0.0554989055,
-0.0087535279,
0.0063803224,
-0.0421183594,
-0.0289959796,
0.0666053593,
0.0108560277,
0.0113782836,
-0.0180282742,
-0.0196033027,
0.0198618416,
-0.0900400952,
-0.0150109641,
0.0616083331,
-0.0192842782,
0.0299222954,
-0.0594047867,
0.028234167,
-0.0550859421,
-0.0146351391,
0.0441708565,
0.0482064076,
0.0163066443,
0.0284470897,
-0.0037815792,
0.1010422707,
-0.0373927131,
0.0208522268,
-0.0617220663,
-0.0068805446,
-0.0331929736,
0.0204507858,
-0.0339108109,
-0.0244304221,
-0.0751672685,
-0.032109648,
-0.0223924536,
0.0410405099,
-0.0360420421,
0.0311009362,
-0.0022884812,
0.0184116364,
-0.0218009818,
-0.0317890532,
-0.0087482426,
-0.0365337767,
-0.0022408401,
-0.0347431041,
-0.0045711272,
0.0175006911,
-0.0277452637,
0.0449089557,
-0.0173951983,
-0.0009046793,
-0.030057732,
0.0937293321,
-0.0026041903,
0.0039032358,
0.0148025956,
-0.0183703247,
-0.0108047752,
-0.0315438211,
0.0810154527,
-0.0665609166,
-0.0224011019,
-0.0344107822,
0.000738996,
-0.0653823093,
0.0186018869,
-0.0045536826,
-0.0120138181,
0.0576055609,
0.0534670204,
0.0473930761,
-0.0068644304,
0.0119991135,
-0.0352258235,
0.0489040092,
0.0630882829,
0.0449774601,
-0.0046596206,
0.0324748121,
0.0236522984,
0.0404236168,
-0.0589714833,
-0.0018093532,
-0.030268779,
-0.0128825968,
-0.0129027292,
0.037133418,
0.0059443414,
-0.0260805637,
-0.020019142,
0.0040243329,
-0.0114124445,
0.0131578371,
-0.0224217456,
-0.0360081159,
0.0528982542,
0.019677721,
-0.0703124627,
-0.0311120842,
-0.0790554732,
0.0599598289,
-0.0182546396,
-0.0037126725,
-0.0494397618,
0.0045575011,
-0.00456774,
-0.0321573988,
0.0079720197,
-0.0014906378,
0.0057068868,
-0.0296827871,
0.0194125902,
0.0438130312,
-0.0727729425,
0.0162065085,
-0.0209537391,
-0.0434371009,
-0.0477118529,
-0.0055542886,
-0.0291348211,
0.0779367313,
-0.0281764399,
-0.0043812403,
-0.0792918578,
0.0253338814,
0.027767757,
0.0251854062,
0.0052344934,
-0.0211949162,
0.0295538288,
-0.0026492546,
-0.0277285092,
-0.0387773924,
-0.004623272,
0.0508906581,
0.0567253456,
-0.0146469064,
-0.0013815074,
0.0273430739,
0.0199214611,
0.030975651,
0.0291813295,
-0.0026437254,
0.0048929052,
0.010067936,
0.005636334,
-0.0076589449,
-0.0152609907,
-0.0071085435,
0.0470762365,
-0.0067526605,
0.0497143269,
0.0144829396,
-0.0100615127,
-0.0123218149,
0.0132816769,
-0.0291091651,
-0.0159267951,
-0.0004682571,
-0.0701682121,
-0.0288605262,
0.0311424658,
0.0260737017,
-0.0243836213,
0.0375647582,
0.0032398435,
0.0037923849,
-0.0521794483,
-0.0321670063,
0.0481399037,
-0.020396946,
-0.0180820487,
0.0369816944,
-0.0030471312,
0.0018259755,
-0.0339318849,
0.0074519981,
0.013249197,
0.031202333,
-0.0202611275,
0.0133339707,
0.03822276,
-0.0245632343,
-0.0415485166,
-0.0369971208,
-0.0148211252,
-0.0237885807,
-0.0371212251,
0.0366488583,
-0.0133892819,
-0.0090561025,
-0.0022455126,
0.044202555,
0.0571854189,
-0.0293421391,
-0.0025214807,
0.0049086977,
0.0074184537,
-0.0373983271,
-0.0170523804,
0.0081797196,
-0.0164392795,
0.0033250311,
0.0237069074,
0.012869061,
-0.032755129,
0.0221396033,
-0.0052464772,
0.0249981992,
-0.0149453888,
-0.0116161322,
0.0106170373,
-0.0269562099,
0.0126207108,
0.095596984,
-0.0523858592,
0.0356933624,
0.0776877105,
-0.006639916,
-0.0165576413,
0.0132310484,
0.0001302138,
-0.0355725549,
-0.0283471551,
-0.0064453385,
-0.0152815962,
0.0342928804,
-0.0555179194,
0.0261979494,
-0.0686416104,
0.0035395813,
-0.027381938,
-0.0443609059,
-0.0424464755,
-0.009571692,
-0.0353518575,
0.0277249776,
-0.0704134703,
-0.0330607854,
0.0401450247,
-0.0182303041,
-0.0070791882,
0.0320013687,
-0.0142184217,
-0.0036084526,
0.0720701441,
0.0679154694,
0.0306686051,
-0.0200043395,
0.0236886609,
-0.064366959,
0.0002766948,
-0.006899382,
0.038944345,
0.0076100538,
-0.1000538543,
-0.0130945472,
-0.0110977134,
-0.0223466717,
-0.036668323,
0.0234943796,
0.0105864042,
0.0278857704,
-0.0213504042,
-0.0691459998,
-0.0630413219,
0.0077445223,
0.029578995,
0.0700713694,
-0.0180318709,
-0.0085953996,
-0.0192382708,
-0.0183976796,
0.0595513433,
0.0544619821,
-0.0624354221,
-0.0409850031,
-0.0318059884,
0.0552465618,
0.0151261697,
-0.0486945398,
-0.0643172711,
0.0321330726,
0.0152701698,
-0.0059472183,
0.0128254239,
0.0301343389,
0.0705804452,
0.0060464758,
-0.0376940742,
0.0536282025,
0.0362179466,
0.0037319947,
0.0088783763,
0.0103226593,
0.0672942474,
0.0627472699,
0.0482375845,
-0.0318971574,
-0.0108397389,
0.0160490293,
-0.0184961706,
0.0564305298,
-0.021013502,
-0.0487151816,
-0.0800623745,
0.0666428879,
0.0240558088,
-0.0888220966,
-0.0475897864,
0.0030149776,
0.0079212375,
-0.0158349983,
-0.0577157922,
0.0094600143,
0.000876297,
-0.0106608616,
0.0010601588,
0.0085972883,
0.0139352623,
-0.0506153964,
-0.0091628041,
-0.0192197319,
0.0617065541,
-0.0278804787,
0.0138450172,
0.0041221953,
0.0347123295,
0.0767438114,
0.0234119818,
0.0171587188,
-0.0365110971,
-0.0151489712,
0.0078903129,
0.0513505004,
0.0341375656,
-0.0462181121,
-0.078536883,
-0.0106261652,
0.0667240769,
-0.0016136351,
0.0110424459,
-0.071255073,
-0.019046573,
0.0360528268,
0.037156146,
-0.0044639357,
-0.0076004388,
-0.041145727,
-0.0618201643,
-0.0280414745,
-0.0206121057,
-0.0139916996,
-0.0100652371,
-0.0217381716,
-0.0390300117,
-0.0307875704,
-0.0236854199,
0.0840781182,
0.052350156,
-0.0056840321,
-0.0760667622,
0.0029916391,
0.022138942,
-0.0598395467,
0.0088738305,
0.0069600008,
0.0028180345,
-0.0214601513,
-0.0447367691,
-0.0017592245,
0.0028598523,
-0.0143195046,
-0.039717149,
-0.0055304794,
-0.0446850285,
0.0039007105,
0.1222078726,
0.0174082257,
0.0411106274,
0.001775027,
0.0068283612,
0.0247099642,
0.0221164003,
0.0081417048,
0.0403738394,
0.0063068871,
0.0178547967,
0.0273977928,
0.0285687298,
-0.0817445293,
0.0248024669,
0.0038268557,
-0.0001250815,
-0.0464745238,
0.002155907,
0.0196927842,
-0.0301604941,
0.0332769454,
0.0006912557,
-0.0059510241,
-0.0252416115,
0.0256320816,
-0.0176307522,
-0.0185656883,
-0.0691631064,
0.0200819187,
0.0284061357,
0.0165601969,
0.0554430149,
0.0361713991,
0.030612899,
-0.0087604877,
0.002447434,
-0.0154135097,
0.0512971357,
0.0015866886,
0.0673980787,
0.0733924657,
0.0269344077,
0.0354577787,
-0.0264050737,
0.0316367745,
0.0250734147,
-0.0005047317,
0.0523015261,
0.0103781736,
-0.0789697841,
0.0254687499,
-0.0426001251,
-0.0894254297,
0.0120132361,
0.0336425714,
0.0754276514,
-0.021964876,
0.0460840538,
-0.0460532084,
0.0014428023,
0.0158440657,
0.0250299238,
0.0351877362,
-0.0432954319,
0.0282566305,
0.0467013568,
0.0273007751,
0.0243329015,
0.0692583695,
0.0041291015,
0.0479613952,
0.0122513957,
0.0187920853,
-0.0295005813,
-0.02645557,
0.0015064718,
0.0263568163,
0.0094714416,
-0.0007863124,
-0.0049611023,
-0.0471992046,
-0.0593341626,
0.0449279211,
0.0094947172,
0.0013678269,
0.0788404346,
0.0303480271,
-0.0196890216,
-0.0284660701,
0.0019988779,
-0.066814363,
0.0356140845,
-0.0572634898,
0.0070771626,
-5.267799038e-33,
-0.0310796909,
-0.0551095754,
0.0645007789,
0.0053499769,
0.0260951407,
-0.0453188717,
-0.0040849145,
0.0201946031,
-0.0015127378,
0.0421390161,
0.0095350202,
0.0040660286,
0.016534755,
0.0282093231,
0.010048544,
0.0100921486,
0.0297830235,
-0.007178586,
-0.057411395,
-0.0059540393,
0.0302565191,
0.0325826295,
0.0043295701,
-0.0178603698,
-0.0275362767,
0.0226196963,
0.017635759,
0.0468228981,
0.0061213025,
0.0035069808,
0.029345721,
-0.040719416,
-0.00754605,
-0.0168887135,
-0.0212313402,
0.0151948389,
-0.029658515,
-0.052557338,
-0.0323235877,
0.0282662231,
-0.0997462049,
-0.0245851129,
0.0651340261,
0.0388005972,
-0.0177599471,
-0.0083471648,
-0.0138390521,
0.0240971483,
0.0100418897,
0.0429963395,
-0.0235006269,
0.0014425955,
-0.0120482519,
-0.0674901828,
0.0743829012,
-0.0144924931,
0.047979597,
-0.0104467561,
-0.0213564709,
-0.0024540932,
-0.0183987021,
0.0154303443,
0.0789849833,
0.021162834,
-0.0082640629,
0.0631183162,
0.0239607282,
-0.027582204,
0.0158958789,
0.0260068085,
-0.0299988873,
0.0838445872,
-0.05073772,
-0.0201641526,
0.0135526601,
0.0750205219,
-0.0497955047,
0.0144861806,
-0.0967302322,
0.0877002403,
-0.0063059465,
0.0363208614,
0.000832631,
-0.0076026134,
-0.0070523852,
0.0221296754,
-0.021217851,
-0.0062911054,
0.0440416932,
0.0374849737,
-0.0079810983,
-0.0371931642,
0.0253371783,
-0.0325440541,
0.0193434842,
0.0609183013,
-0.0517945886,
0.0449176989,
-0.0051753046,
0.0379968546,
-0.0466680415,
-0.0224104393,
0.0189205296,
-0.0309305619,
-0.0011802214,
0.037036486,
-0.0156396609,
0.094117865,
-0.0105081731,
-0.0052070902,
-0.0401517935,
-0.0113950288,
-0.0163274165,
0.0182219557,
0.0258424282,
0.0160970911,
-0.003023641,
0.0296865068,
-0.011048859,
-0.0551071018,
0.0311893802,
0.0156280864,
-0.0208406821,
0.0142072784,
-0.0213663559,
-0.0134606371,
-0.0051403716,
0.0044102846,
0.0313693658,
-0.043261487,
-0.0162463635,
0.0289937593,
2.726e-7,
0.0149775986,
0.0305282157,
-0.0060022352,
0.037533734,
0.0094813649,
0.0285633076,
-0.0269266963,
0.0108404262,
-0.0354329124,
-0.0050031897,
0.0231298171,
0.0516622029,
-0.0001465539,
-0.0156733729,
-0.0822465718,
0.0318958499,
0.0131550767,
-0.0306678936,
-0.0481299944,
-0.031383425,
0.0124474345,
0.0702682137,
-0.0188102741,
0.0064982632,
-0.0103595676,
0.0036187482,
0.0038166959,
-0.052245371,
0.0331102274,
-0.0246550161,
-0.0127649056,
-0.0121215759,
-0.028160369,
-0.0032753006,
-0.0073033199,
-0.0021845053,
-0.0225049462,
0.0751887113,
-0.0528777204,
-0.0457507037,
-0.0267436206,
-0.0009504733,
-0.0297863521,
-0.0121690854,
0.0181860887,
-0.0432953723,
0.0382590257,
0.0310255922,
-0.0393571481,
-0.0048382296,
-0.02907026,
0.0396142714,
0.0092061637,
0.0011666827,
0.0182492156,
-0.0080232192,
-0.0150929326,
-0.0010479008,
-0.0015518622,
0.0018197108,
0.005705554,
0.0210485999,
0.0173945036,
-0.0019387815,
-0.034327928,
0.0341901183,
-0.0610686019,
2.277658976e-34,
0.0016772671,
0.0058297697,
0.0061103739,
0.0320386253,
0.0416882597,
0.0044468716,
-0.0661745891,
0.0306520518,
0.007949464,
-0.0135119418,
-0.0685869828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14364v2 | CONSCENDI: A Contrastive and Scenario-Guided Distillation Approach to Guardrail Models for Virtual Assistants | 2023-04-27T17:39:11 | 2024-04-03T23:57:12 | Albert Yu Sun, Varun Nair, Elliot Schumacher, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A wave of new task-based virtual assistants has been fueled by increasingly
powerful large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4 (OpenAI, 2023). A major
challenge in deploying LLM-based virtual conversational assistants in real
world settings is ensuring they operate within what is admissible for the task.
To overcome this challenge, the designers of these virtual assistants rely on
an independent guardrail system that verifies the virtual assistant's output
aligns with the constraints required for the task. However, relying on commonly
used, prompt-based guardrails can be difficult to engineer correctly and
comprehensively. To address these challenges, we propose CONSCENDI. We use
CONSCENDI to exhaustively generate training data with two key LLM-powered
components: scenario-augmented generation and contrastive training examples.
When generating conversational data, we generate a set of rule-breaking
scenarios, which enumerate a diverse set of high-level ways a rule can be
violated. This scenario-guided approach produces a diverse training set and
provides chatbot designers greater control. To generate contrastive examples,
we prompt the LLM to alter conversations with violations into acceptable
conversations to enable fine-grained distinctions. We then use this data,
generated by CONSCENDI, to train a smaller model. We find that CONSCENDI
results in guardrail models that improve over baselines in multiple dialogue
domains. | [
0.0674441084,
0.0509570688,
-0.034361437,
0.0067741647,
-0.048282899,
0.0054728836,
0.0282813311,
-0.000066885,
0.0245888289,
-0.0422100462,
0.0035059871,
-0.0433284007,
-0.0469497964,
0.0369118564,
-0.0018865019,
-0.0747304261,
0.0425515883,
-0.0680202171,
0.0148962671,
0.0066761156,
0.020177111,
0.0203264207,
-0.0368144512,
0.0705659315,
-0.0347293317,
-0.0453818515,
-0.0320568457,
0.0048588701,
0.0290568247,
-0.0096740378,
0.037070021,
0.0579187311,
0.0530969612,
0.0274091605,
0.0000021278,
-0.0343842506,
-0.007710394,
-0.0117672682,
-0.0116322534,
-0.0309205744,
0.0257981028,
-0.0291408598,
-0.0297336876,
0.037824627,
-0.0151646826,
-0.0265366305,
0.0418687835,
0.075407818,
0.0955207944,
0.0890008584,
-0.0052419193,
-0.0114504807,
0.0014493228,
-0.0091791134,
-0.0431776978,
-0.0865450129,
-0.0011075861,
0.0180887133,
-0.0114803808,
0.0004016621,
0.0030892272,
-0.0046707056,
0.0636196062,
-0.0252643209,
-0.0278700162,
0.0125305895,
-0.0731193572,
-0.022497898,
-0.0359098725,
0.0960614979,
-0.009930227,
-0.0155100012,
-0.0042678146,
-0.0043735676,
0.0176334213,
-0.0395668074,
-0.0496359803,
0.0118976114,
-0.0196451806,
-0.0055929744,
-0.0050268788,
0.0223167241,
-0.0160924997,
0.0044345162,
-0.0084291585,
-0.0309179053,
0.00863773,
-0.0376178175,
-0.0083618602,
-0.0043902183,
0.0108576883,
-0.0595360771,
0.0032588155,
0.0317016318,
-0.0950288847,
0.0106137712,
-0.049009379,
0.0064131552,
0.0354122072,
0.000484627,
0.0431407429,
0.0431011021,
-0.037421681,
0.0492634028,
0.0141365742,
0.0719021261,
-0.0134852417,
0.0245353971,
-0.0066464171,
-0.0088950833,
-0.0352606773,
0.0015141154,
-0.0595423803,
0.0114133479,
-0.0782967582,
-0.0151511468,
0.0068095806,
0.03797701,
-0.0502461977,
0.0397064947,
0.0018638447,
0.0109849637,
-0.0393455811,
-0.0129005294,
-0.015086758,
-0.0183953475,
-0.0334350541,
0.0142874476,
0.0302428659,
-0.0801647156,
-0.0319097191,
0.003764749,
-0.0185231958,
-0.0209394749,
-0.0120131858,
0.0950566232,
0.0023729899,
-0.0343340375,
-0.0090208817,
-0.0373484716,
-0.0334571078,
-0.0706469119,
0.0138073135,
-0.0259385258,
0.0235713273,
-0.0447995104,
0.0089559155,
-0.0345044248,
0.0171363037,
0.0150032341,
-0.0136437183,
0.0490026139,
0.0133884391,
-0.0017731689,
0.0026957192,
0.037176542,
-0.0275010299,
0.0819619447,
0.0146382339,
0.0113452924,
0.0337723978,
0.010702204,
0.0425272435,
0.0259867739,
-0.0132292062,
0.0180743933,
-0.0235947967,
0.0170117635,
0.0143913906,
0.0126014967,
0.0114526274,
0.0716044754,
-0.0396111235,
-0.0174161438,
0.0785076991,
0.0144933257,
-0.0122725451,
0.0383289605,
0.062751025,
0.0114053162,
-0.0042612748,
0.0423323885,
-0.0581822954,
0.0045209876,
-0.0244638287,
-0.0266062114,
-0.0071609165,
0.0444061533,
-0.0491963215,
-0.0432937182,
0.0374885537,
-0.0202053208,
0.0238889921,
-0.018904509,
0.0147150662,
0.0373797566,
-0.0510004796,
0.0020068411,
0.0139073515,
-0.0507128499,
-0.0601160005,
-0.0429852419,
0.0289831795,
0.1079705805,
0.0681856349,
-0.0350837819,
-0.0426750146,
-0.0299036335,
0.0367362536,
0.0690725073,
0.0610133074,
-0.0128650898,
0.0396404043,
-0.0606104024,
-0.0127902664,
-0.0367472507,
0.0339603983,
-0.0038230612,
0.0147754829,
0.0047625517,
0.0030513748,
0.0151582342,
-0.0402406678,
0.0310100634,
0.0033034883,
-0.0382714719,
-0.0108622899,
-0.0055067455,
0.0095213549,
0.0159539673,
-0.0204476099,
-0.0235208962,
0.017957883,
-0.0274579991,
0.0118496632,
0.0048975558,
-0.0561717004,
-0.0389147438,
0.0330891386,
-0.0043743849,
-0.019839704,
0.0384608768,
-0.0487428345,
-0.0085797925,
-0.0128345536,
-0.0155267334,
0.0358214304,
-0.0236032195,
0.028430976,
0.0082465122,
0.0078613572,
0.0016110156,
0.0196777694,
-0.0100082709,
-0.0275400523,
0.0373066589,
0.0155803133,
0.0018611688,
-0.0273422394,
0.0027043477,
0.0064254114,
-0.0080083702,
0.0220245458,
0.0277806185,
0.0229426641,
-0.0395390466,
-0.0382126346,
-0.0883407295,
-0.0056443703,
-0.0376418643,
-0.0259933677,
0.0039329729,
0.0019407478,
-0.0162216965,
-0.0227774978,
-0.0133588556,
-0.0010737648,
0.0109390197,
0.0188956112,
0.0285648443,
-0.0120147755,
-0.0591372363,
-0.0382033102,
0.0318586454,
0.0079444041,
0.016835656,
-0.023614306,
0.0257504806,
-0.0541622266,
0.0228638183,
-0.0268390048,
0.0742753223,
-0.0093871746,
-0.0387743786,
0.0297161695,
0.0137760974,
0.0413199663,
0.0557628684,
0.0222369302,
0.055871848,
0.0612580441,
-0.0367657244,
-0.0668296367,
0.0501725078,
0.0115235941,
-0.027601283,
-0.0281194877,
0.0079028485,
0.017008299,
0.0354886353,
-0.0228694454,
0.0328647122,
-0.0900722221,
0.0517789721,
0.0219323691,
-0.0429664813,
0.0470696427,
-0.0217388626,
-0.0515234061,
0.0442459695,
-0.0195509437,
-0.0341100618,
0.0814573169,
-0.0168974288,
-0.0046180468,
-0.0461580567,
-0.019397106,
-0.0183203053,
0.0695589557,
-0.0150949927,
0.0209192615,
0.0522638373,
0.0106587075,
-0.0380757898,
-0.0071354513,
0.0151639627,
-0.0408521555,
0.0269352794,
-0.0789512023,
-0.0196267329,
-0.0044357684,
-0.0640397295,
-0.0698072165,
-0.0374125727,
-0.0305139832,
0.0336557478,
0.0203330033,
-0.0078647742,
-0.0304643288,
0.0053866301,
-0.0340930074,
0.052950114,
0.0031606078,
-0.0014150776,
-0.0348330736,
0.0013233125,
0.0748317316,
0.0153036062,
-0.0119918687,
-0.0003997294,
0.0717322677,
0.050071124,
0.0216653328,
-0.0292951837,
-0.020002434,
0.001826011,
0.0147157162,
-0.0116551332,
-0.0058053955,
0.0222871769,
0.0700396448,
-0.0666104481,
-0.0288661141,
0.0954117253,
0.0200902149,
-0.0315473899,
0.0109976158,
-0.0272044446,
0.0591776073,
0.0030484858,
0.023281768,
-0.0758646056,
-0.0340138115,
0.0225955825,
0.0113710305,
-0.0295989141,
-0.0233878884,
-0.0294204876,
-0.1259883791,
0.0493166707,
0.0031570713,
-0.0524415635,
-0.0166959055,
0.0073487391,
0.0189425275,
-0.0083388574,
0.0555767976,
-0.0132790077,
0.0137095945,
-0.0261331797,
-0.0021336779,
-0.0129738487,
-0.0214790534,
0.0336162522,
-0.0342687294,
0.095885627,
0.0753518492,
0.0415311754,
0.0319428667,
-0.0284557622,
0.0244422462,
-0.0295506846,
0.0253105201,
0.0104590673,
0.0598755851,
-0.0139509281,
-0.0066697062,
-0.0090451231,
0.0260467809,
0.0074429102,
-0.0363713801,
0.0487046987,
0.0410500653,
-0.020394424,
-0.0134696485,
-0.0346317813,
0.0406870916,
0.0660863891,
0.0632178709,
0.0404464565,
-0.0494802222,
-0.0475276001,
-0.0308970213,
-0.0088737467,
-0.0501005948,
-0.0005025408,
-0.059292987,
-0.0078990664,
-0.0032975043,
-0.0668322816,
-0.0464054607,
0.0114431437,
0.0343056321,
0.0155784534,
-0.0392856188,
0.0069847517,
0.0235368405,
0.0370786563,
-0.0063934685,
-0.0566300265,
0.0253753942,
-0.0140074119,
0.0161052998,
0.0270151179,
-0.0199272968,
0.0023750358,
0.0317723043,
-0.0417666659,
-0.0766732395,
0.0035094146,
0.0773596615,
0.0255018082,
0.0560332015,
-0.0189119894,
-0.0338066556,
0.000928399,
0.0173430946,
-0.0508440286,
-0.007217661,
0.0735127553,
-0.01166467,
0.0196131933,
0.0314572118,
-0.0508078076,
0.0183835085,
-0.0049841339,
0.0357314795,
-0.0457900725,
-0.0636695847,
0.0293183681,
-0.0187129211,
-0.0077774394,
0.0185945928,
0.0088322917,
-0.0144725498,
0.0410911366,
-0.0164088421,
-0.0135089979,
-0.0490584783,
0.0388670787,
-0.0185359903,
-0.0345737115,
0.0242000092,
0.021659866,
-0.0297214538,
0.0261362381,
-0.0471670665,
-0.0386083424,
0.0052475398,
0.0008016125,
-0.0004791016,
-0.0248401351,
-0.0192678384,
0.0268304739,
0.0037877469,
0.0368262194,
0.0109014772,
0.088510558,
0.0299108215,
-0.0065178513,
-0.0172660314,
0.0446512029,
-0.0652715862,
-0.0561288819,
0.0078815157,
0.0732606873,
0.0434772931,
0.0117012197,
0.0596201457,
-0.0309559163,
0.0069710352,
-0.002911028,
0.0214042645,
0.0141839236,
-0.0271167848,
0.010362695,
0.0347684287,
-0.0060562338,
0.0032051236,
0.0611781366,
-0.0289767124,
0.0719031021,
-0.0129118441,
0.0033807608,
-0.05099231,
-0.0424580425,
0.0250734296,
0.0522793271,
0.0083760852,
-0.0131171076,
-0.0766277984,
-0.0427239574,
-0.0044311481,
0.0135834115,
-0.000145358,
-0.0380568616,
0.0053311912,
0.0257518124,
-0.0059630647,
-0.026193168,
-0.0215664506,
-0.060837999,
-0.0096406871,
0.0026025418,
-0.0514696278,
-6.203797802e-33,
-0.0288906451,
-0.0112345573,
0.0260591079,
-0.0117379716,
-0.0391356573,
-0.0231871828,
-0.034421958,
-0.0365367755,
-0.0242966078,
0.0122690257,
-0.0187162738,
0.0129525242,
0.0132491123,
0.0030003516,
-0.0117429998,
-0.0215630755,
0.0676482916,
0.006093808,
-0.0357608385,
0.0640078336,
0.0193098523,
-0.0089584831,
-0.0089030322,
-0.105535157,
0.0229378957,
-0.0140482234,
-0.0253887773,
0.0433146767,
-0.0323414579,
0.0696398914,
-0.0178360231,
0.0433613658,
0.0092612449,
-0.0324443206,
-0.0026826994,
0.0285800006,
-0.041469723,
-0.0367207751,
0.0228885654,
-0.0082147885,
-0.0241411738,
-0.0509151593,
-0.0004251329,
-0.0091267824,
0.0048062536,
0.00280446,
-0.0001891735,
-0.0420012102,
0.0071948175,
-0.0067317747,
-0.0906093568,
-0.0107563781,
-0.0288938638,
-0.0930099189,
0.0024003915,
0.0567064993,
0.024079103,
-0.0155576635,
-0.0335883461,
0.0336788408,
0.0200752951,
-0.0417079292,
0.0505605824,
-0.0178123247,
-0.0090670427,
0.0580343865,
0.012179953,
0.0373704508,
-0.0229787789,
-0.0445340574,
-0.023249248,
0.0742483661,
-0.0050570839,
0.0481525548,
0.0116855316,
-0.0330811217,
-0.0332124606,
0.0044046966,
0.0123330327,
0.0653530657,
0.0331706665,
0.0081526823,
-0.0565458126,
-0.0084785772,
-0.0216268711,
-0.0028013845,
-0.0099428706,
-0.0235876609,
0.0450503826,
0.0481033549,
-0.0147072328,
-0.0362988599,
0.0092497263,
-0.0356285349,
0.027116308,
0.0474359132,
-0.0317686908,
-0.028492352,
-0.0117391925,
-0.0111409957,
-0.0312935486,
-0.0460359119,
0.0714738369,
-0.0267939083,
0.0271397848,
0.0153882755,
0.0337911397,
0.0382429548,
-0.0493941158,
0.0083474601,
-0.0274486057,
0.079682067,
-0.0109184682,
0.0333918072,
0.0185698457,
-0.0051208939,
-0.0298337545,
0.0545061082,
0.0319683254,
-0.0225219335,
-0.0378464907,
0.0204645116,
0.0000469703,
0.0039388984,
-0.0197494067,
-0.019451445,
0.0032290788,
0.0206806324,
0.0182525162,
-0.0298097022,
-0.024237087,
-0.0155468183,
2.794e-7,
-0.0318776742,
0.0147133721,
0.0202458035,
0.0510752834,
0.0224778447,
0.0568693615,
0.00764002,
0.0451260805,
-0.0044258819,
-0.0132852569,
0.0079750679,
0.0464772508,
0.0613774396,
0.0303083248,
-0.0574236624,
-0.0021328726,
-0.0543219261,
-0.0488850437,
-0.0590053536,
-0.0208813641,
0.0893263519,
0.0638901144,
0.013822577,
-0.0193224661,
0.015898928,
-0.0240010265,
0.0394754335,
-0.0218840484,
-0.0055275462,
0.0083379792,
0.0408434831,
0.0162207,
-0.0114322025,
0.0397288725,
0.0255391281,
0.0429564118,
-0.0380581282,
0.0837058648,
0.0132957865,
-0.0131652905,
0.0012093383,
0.0003374216,
-0.0053628879,
-0.0507963523,
0.0616361164,
-0.0314647481,
-0.0017242827,
-0.04943306,
0.0036140522,
-0.0195631143,
0.0187390987,
-0.0177712832,
-0.0236396603,
0.0044473927,
-0.0187532101,
0.0177162159,
-0.0006530951,
-0.0452745333,
0.0101905428,
-0.0061098887,
-0.0390916578,
-0.0564951897,
-0.0120202554,
0.0009491777,
-0.0217522979,
-0.0458163768,
0.0341555439,
2.512071147e-34,
0.0346532613,
-0.0142629808,
0.0237633716,
0.0554998182,
0.0196947847,
0.0163520332,
0.0439182967,
0.0108162742,
0.0349279493,
-0.0156779923,
-0.0135594541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14354v1 | Industrial Engineering with Large Language Models: A case study of ChatGPT's performance on Oil & Gas problems | 2023-04-27T17:33:49 | 2023-04-27T17:33:49 | Oluwatosin Ogundare, Srinath Madasu, Nathanial Wiggins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in solving complex
problems in various fields, including oil and gas engineering and other
industrial engineering disciplines like factory automation, PLC programming
etc. However, automatic identification of strong and weak solutions to
fundamental physics equations governing several industrial processes remain a
challenging task. This paper identifies the limitation of current LLM
approaches, particularly ChatGPT in selected practical problems native to oil
and gas engineering but not exclusively. The performance of ChatGPT in solving
complex problems in oil and gas engineering is discussed and the areas where
LLMs are most effective are presented. | [
-0.0611848533,
0.0411377773,
-0.030692324,
0.0523062721,
-0.0401402228,
-0.0093936622,
-0.0038606909,
0.0490553565,
0.0479549468,
-0.033260636,
0.0264648423,
-0.0362183265,
-0.0432984605,
0.0387420245,
0.0311171822,
-0.0125568984,
0.0180170555,
-0.0566318408,
0.012289647,
0.0102567626,
-0.0095423153,
-0.017144965,
0.0145259751,
0.0302126799,
-0.0098087629,
-0.0265670847,
0.011626225,
-0.0561336167,
0.0085316198,
0.018485507,
0.0172216054,
0.0470919497,
0.0433693379,
0.0785837471,
0.0000020054,
-0.0153133841,
-0.0164946187,
0.0533088185,
0.0141702434,
0.0593052544,
0.0206790958,
-0.0163517278,
-0.0069758343,
0.0213057362,
-0.0294655021,
0.0058978577,
0.0362536907,
-0.0218024328,
0.0828934461,
0.0224506855,
0.007346252,
-0.0141649432,
-0.0319642872,
-0.0083867125,
-0.0256143827,
-0.0619424917,
0.0338082053,
0.0730223432,
0.0670983642,
0.0101881614,
-0.0113643622,
0.0369083323,
0.0280263741,
-0.0581090376,
-0.0385892987,
0.0219226871,
-0.0700971261,
0.0779716745,
-0.012439644,
0.0361337215,
-0.0058419956,
-0.0151247978,
-0.0061472259,
-0.0301752351,
-0.0402417965,
-0.0014472316,
-0.054127533,
0.0011949866,
-0.0127391927,
-0.0068727252,
-0.0017921041,
-0.0271248929,
-0.0155581133,
-0.0221201628,
-0.0458306707,
0.1169247106,
0.0011402323,
-0.0079494622,
-0.0228778012,
0.0045116614,
-0.0402587131,
-0.0195840783,
-0.0125057567,
0.0176781882,
-0.0107101528,
0.0167354792,
0.0376693122,
0.0108960103,
0.0041532461,
-0.0706228241,
0.006365004,
0.0403226055,
0.0448058434,
0.0336525068,
-0.0266809594,
0.0602499135,
-0.036262434,
-0.0164440051,
-0.0190364588,
0.0237715691,
-0.0892437994,
-0.0600710995,
-0.0894351825,
0.0099461274,
-0.0176281743,
0.0087946467,
-0.0194269083,
0.0193279516,
-0.0257197674,
0.0010649799,
-0.0105178608,
-0.0488469154,
0.0318003632,
-0.0300250594,
-0.0024994893,
0.0509148054,
0.0432319418,
0.0159149412,
-0.0064635635,
-0.0377743542,
-0.0064562359,
0.0452237613,
-0.0298368298,
-0.0026298787,
-0.0044884277,
0.0815202519,
-0.0260361247,
0.016751023,
-0.0018442047,
-0.0170330014,
0.0057720705,
-0.0545016378,
0.0009808913,
-0.0340254679,
-0.0028873216,
-0.0037720511,
0.010825064,
-0.0103334682,
-0.0027613852,
-0.0380937532,
0.034202531,
0.0425927676,
0.0217052512,
0.0123250121,
0.0525675602,
0.0283280909,
-0.0115705784,
0.0684634149,
0.0097280145,
-0.0097766612,
-0.0255549978,
-0.0490770862,
0.0220997073,
0.0656906813,
-0.0385724418,
0.0107206441,
-0.0217356849,
-0.0230639242,
0.0478124954,
0.0277718082,
-0.0486883372,
0.0336899534,
-0.0262895823,
0.0009676888,
0.0131285898,
-0.0094319368,
0.028382713,
0.0649256036,
0.0369525179,
0.0698774159,
0.0320809186,
-0.0074353833,
0.0319457352,
-0.0015429073,
-0.053490214,
-0.0181834064,
0.0166112799,
0.0348409042,
-0.0100020785,
-0.0209046844,
-0.0268430933,
0.0207264684,
-0.0399195962,
-0.037115626,
0.062000908,
-0.0224487316,
-0.0440234691,
0.0262515713,
0.0067305746,
0.0146690542,
-0.0185331628,
-0.068617776,
-0.0218460653,
0.0185400844,
0.0425602198,
-0.0559936427,
-0.0879678503,
-0.0075277742,
-0.0037134208,
-0.0022460793,
0.035219498,
0.0414266437,
-0.0170193482,
-0.0065880693,
-0.0084984079,
-0.0115835015,
0.0066592414,
0.0037555634,
-0.0347690471,
-0.0160148889,
-0.0048569371,
0.030561164,
-0.0039296728,
-0.0151507091,
-0.0307306647,
-0.0181773733,
0.0067525432,
0.0046127127,
0.0259269029,
0.0351707935,
-0.0164206624,
0.0181576032,
0.0111915227,
-0.0839553326,
-0.0670299307,
0.0005288553,
-0.0135944821,
0.0504906885,
0.0577381141,
-0.0160249341,
-0.0114362985,
-0.0428486466,
-0.0336016417,
-0.0401384383,
0.0636369884,
-0.0318553187,
0.0278353598,
-0.0121798664,
0.0259518828,
-0.0402467996,
0.0196597818,
-0.0242842622,
0.0461234041,
0.0161788911,
0.0206775721,
-0.0122683961,
0.0335473567,
0.0527528301,
-0.0434492864,
-0.0348967202,
0.0694649518,
-0.0019504213,
0.0039380044,
0.0256432761,
0.0077682585,
0.0373111852,
-0.0279598422,
-0.0357424989,
-0.0203350931,
0.026285002,
0.0452104025,
0.0240736157,
-0.0159266666,
-0.0296012629,
0.0319881588,
0.0051573352,
0.0504327267,
0.0057299067,
-0.0365742445,
0.0261183064,
0.0004366266,
-0.0795533136,
-0.0338379443,
-0.0320366658,
-0.0155717097,
0.0646877214,
0.0225408468,
0.007162434,
-0.1178946793,
0.0734218955,
0.0188250318,
0.0211940277,
-0.0151580209,
-0.0724482611,
-0.0227481537,
-0.0427614786,
0.046860747,
0.0290157236,
-0.0444802977,
0.0212658979,
0.0230015442,
-0.0329450034,
-0.0348122045,
-0.0141398925,
-0.0314334482,
-0.02822401,
0.0140723223,
-0.0025378938,
-0.0122851012,
0.0503905341,
-0.0177264474,
-0.0347463712,
-0.0037020058,
0.0487707444,
-0.0237700958,
0.0303381272,
-0.0062703523,
-0.0015104247,
0.0234395117,
0.0159609225,
0.0405228436,
-0.0090118786,
0.0610758401,
-0.0481134281,
-0.0172656681,
-0.0540484563,
-0.0244990084,
-0.0450462289,
0.0502955876,
-0.0210997425,
0.009112387,
0.0021405455,
-0.0209135506,
-0.0037696823,
-0.0003951038,
0.0114144422,
0.0475335121,
0.0037091905,
-0.0115181152,
0.0541273952,
0.0057977899,
-0.0385893099,
0.0025933278,
-0.024517497,
-0.0046157716,
0.0530610867,
0.0228423402,
-0.0374113992,
-0.007122613,
0.0570319444,
0.0452722795,
0.0246890616,
-0.0047281422,
-0.0152080422,
-0.0193652548,
0.0092205936,
0.034092173,
-0.0143321799,
0.0476264097,
-0.0050124903,
0.0649444461,
0.0125335893,
0.0044681262,
0.0097856047,
-0.1255844831,
-0.0024963613,
0.0078503415,
-0.0125365723,
-0.0207426175,
0.0044863145,
-0.0439758897,
-0.0684566051,
-0.0096544977,
0.032465037,
-0.0093423082,
0.026655471,
0.0048735715,
0.0331024826,
0.0205847677,
-0.0011143228,
0.0430694111,
-0.0753063932,
0.0110351974,
0.0044721039,
-0.0237268545,
0.0037310133,
0.0017508086,
-0.01151691,
-0.0713121146,
0.0633575618,
0.0238523874,
-0.0261065923,
-0.0639636517,
-0.0689217746,
-0.0132979276,
-0.0336861648,
-0.0176740512,
0.0482825711,
-0.0036787244,
-0.0342717059,
0.0426968187,
-0.0344056822,
-0.0796059743,
0.014180487,
-0.0247624293,
-0.0073195561,
0.0345211178,
0.0078964643,
-0.0308242887,
0.0059369924,
0.0857890248,
0.0379972458,
0.0077972137,
-0.062463697,
-0.0752313212,
0.0695123225,
0.0018117755,
-0.0139403241,
0.0164174642,
-0.0487354696,
0.0202190634,
0.009417573,
0.1168034449,
-0.0583864152,
-0.0373377129,
-0.0324035734,
-0.0086756796,
0.0288281422,
-0.0002673388,
-0.0383818448,
-0.0305622332,
-0.0772146359,
-0.0337032266,
-0.0546171106,
0.0746190399,
-0.0142713543,
-0.014329371,
0.015705673,
-0.0301036984,
0.0102326209,
0.044802431,
0.0001668204,
0.0308311563,
0.0057632867,
0.0136614898,
0.0757889897,
0.0228011888,
-0.0053122714,
-0.0121655306,
-0.0368313529,
0.0365664549,
-0.0420584828,
0.0161278211,
0.0472794473,
-0.0448614284,
-0.0219019391,
-0.0027307675,
-0.0789960548,
-0.0586697049,
0.0125526339,
0.0278626159,
0.0258670878,
-0.0311417021,
-0.0357881635,
-0.0492118075,
-0.0217266437,
0.0193602685,
-0.0485266969,
0.015565427,
-0.0613778159,
0.0224787798,
0.018718617,
-0.0215369351,
0.0065153032,
0.0124855293,
-0.002328279,
0.0205981601,
0.0025673537,
-0.0427967049,
-0.0055924961,
0.1057179123,
-0.0129602514,
0.0352310725,
-0.0118883913,
-0.0240742639,
-0.0056626541,
0.0075613796,
-0.0241395999,
-0.0525644012,
0.0261485223,
-0.0284009967,
-0.0449893512,
0.0133718485,
-0.0388942435,
0.0436224267,
0.0498499274,
0.0145485671,
0.0635617301,
-0.00808575,
-0.0018768538,
0.0791594908,
-0.0133076943,
0.0342269428,
-0.0008292603,
-0.0146246748,
0.0315595716,
-0.0227201451,
0.0474173091,
0.0390956365,
-0.0138188861,
-0.0333108567,
0.0115300165,
-0.0256289244,
-0.092211023,
-0.0345021822,
0.0461206622,
0.0654203221,
0.0460899659,
-0.0008917664,
-0.0885348022,
-0.0102498373,
-0.014012862,
0.0431418754,
0.0263562948,
-0.0076786415,
0.011168953,
0.0098581733,
-0.027832225,
-0.021203259,
0.0519695617,
0.030212326,
-0.00003024,
0.0135730142,
-0.0260926224,
-0.0401022881,
-0.0072843903,
0.0566264354,
-0.0264407787,
0.0029507731,
0.0348868072,
-0.0610750504,
-0.0273198094,
-0.0655860081,
0.0348907933,
0.0099687725,
0.014815174,
0.0641156435,
0.0786027089,
0.0213558618,
0.0270660333,
0.0047301492,
-0.0228706226,
-0.0152727198,
-0.0063347458,
0.0323464759,
-5.682390018e-33,
-0.0340984426,
-0.0316848829,
0.0113173984,
0.0265196506,
0.0014047462,
-0.0319614485,
-0.0140274921,
0.0038300115,
0.0218204483,
-0.0037045591,
0.0008178202,
0.0190639962,
-0.0036222006,
-0.0310995784,
0.0278283618,
-0.0078377742,
0.0176561624,
0.0050302967,
0.002323254,
0.0168920327,
0.0336399078,
-0.0021315617,
0.0580192618,
-0.0468099304,
0.0208572708,
0.0209352374,
-0.0198530369,
0.0472134911,
-0.03176881,
0.0314517841,
-0.0563985072,
0.0594369099,
-0.0263125952,
-0.028542744,
-0.0259763859,
-0.0271205436,
-0.0116005139,
-0.0310136583,
-0.0272875,
0.0122636622,
0.0666969046,
-0.0415537544,
0.0546291322,
-0.020593239,
-0.0519688316,
0.0039941035,
0.005805023,
-0.0043014502,
0.0501579084,
0.0012686818,
-0.0747644976,
-0.0001083438,
-0.030821031,
0.0233001187,
0.0292697605,
-0.0028033792,
-0.0292074084,
-0.0297512989,
0.003296589,
0.0201799646,
0.0617962852,
0.0270707887,
0.0930580199,
-0.0418963395,
0.0365766026,
0.0053957687,
-0.010994399,
0.017823305,
-0.0117693832,
-0.0422865748,
0.0135635817,
0.0350111835,
0.0272573456,
-0.0151861664,
0.0048825052,
-0.004719811,
-0.1013269648,
-0.0230043661,
0.0077926512,
0.015729988,
0.0609851182,
0.0416187346,
-0.0108876638,
-0.0406309515,
-0.027464699,
0.0614330396,
0.0055189817,
-0.0225347802,
-0.0074524935,
-0.0278816354,
-0.003453437,
-0.0351254381,
0.0529472791,
-0.0601605438,
0.0014938628,
0.0179005899,
-0.0278676618,
-0.0036422231,
0.0036814935,
0.049799338,
-0.0420083888,
-0.0294968747,
-0.0507816933,
-0.0105900932,
0.0279226117,
-0.00387823,
-0.065092206,
0.0395876616,
-0.0134120136,
0.0090480922,
-0.0432404503,
-0.0315954164,
0.0387072712,
-0.0122536859,
0.0209466238,
-0.0166713968,
0.0023008808,
0.0258604884,
-0.0021497228,
-0.0081339497,
0.040143121,
0.0473184921,
-0.0077531347,
0.0007655621,
0.0105272708,
-0.0196044147,
-0.0249614771,
0.0066506872,
0.0458341911,
-0.0130749717,
-0.0266297702,
0.0281215832,
2.747e-7,
0.0203041285,
0.0504937991,
0.0376807153,
0.0561307967,
0.0154539449,
0.0168088134,
-0.039751403,
-0.0192310642,
-0.0027671561,
0.0488481522,
0.0130952811,
-0.0069581056,
0.0446404293,
-0.0106107304,
-0.044294823,
-0.0006034453,
-0.0062619345,
-0.0044627506,
-0.0639009029,
-0.0335038304,
0.0780395791,
0.0456643626,
0.0199871678,
0.0190244783,
0.0096158702,
-0.0637348369,
0.0545442291,
-0.0412637442,
0.0273239873,
0.0761852935,
-0.0089544291,
-0.0104811424,
-0.0145473396,
0.037155129,
0.001776587,
0.0071633575,
0.0310586635,
0.0397360623,
0.0328142643,
0.030811945,
0.0359403677,
-0.0033006575,
0.0204555653,
-0.0552202463,
0.0062918984,
-0.0838033333,
-0.0521981008,
-0.0282803439,
-0.0267982744,
-0.1036797017,
-0.009315839,
-0.027374113,
0.0531713441,
0.0012819719,
-0.0330427848,
-0.022548167,
0.0033032296,
0.0068825283,
-0.001914395,
0.047928948,
-0.0568806119,
-0.0337668769,
-0.0077217827,
-0.0076086102,
0.0728541762,
0.0010706298,
0.0260466617,
2.918561455e-34,
0.0260542445,
-0.0297182817,
0.0269401334,
0.0661810338,
0.0342740566,
0.0222934615,
-0.0112925516,
0.0456847735,
0.008700761,
-0.0894142687,
-0.0086906608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14333v1 | Idioms, Probing and Dangerous Things: Towards Structural Probing for Idiomaticity in Vector Space | 2023-04-27T17:06:20 | 2023-04-27T17:06:20 | Filip Klubička, Vasudevan Nedumpozhimana, John D. Kelleher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50 | The goal of this paper is to learn more about how idiomatic information is
structurally encoded in embeddings, using a structural probing method. We
repurpose an existing English verbal multi-word expression (MWE) dataset to
suit the probing framework and perform a comparative probing study of static
(GloVe) and contextual (BERT) embeddings. Our experiments indicate that both
encode some idiomatic information to varying degrees, but yield conflicting
evidence as to whether idiomaticity is encoded in the vector norm, leaving this
an open question. We also identify some limitations of the used dataset and
highlight important directions for future work in improving its suitability for
a probing analysis. | [
0.035027694,
0.0156167159,
-0.0382163748,
0.0545737408,
-0.0434014946,
0.013570779,
-0.0157470293,
0.0645144731,
0.0058542262,
-0.0320146494,
-0.0379365347,
-0.0289436448,
0.0230859127,
0.009022464,
0.0592440665,
0.0173085853,
0.0573614351,
0.0483676195,
-0.0026322971,
0.0039692558,
-0.0000377384,
0.0059252735,
-0.0099448413,
0.0386664607,
-0.0350578465,
0.0008044635,
0.0206688046,
-0.0080241216,
-0.0027606406,
-0.0226807818,
0.017403828,
0.0173193607,
0.0495405495,
-0.0178210698,
0.0000018696,
-0.0278703477,
0.0315562449,
-0.0136471931,
0.0194666814,
0.0332777575,
0.0258250218,
-0.001017518,
-0.0077499859,
-0.0289569832,
-0.0070517403,
0.0089781377,
0.0652328804,
0.0296024866,
-0.0060824607,
0.0125070279,
-0.0158700459,
-0.0403965786,
0.0033125733,
-0.0082468158,
0.0175619312,
-0.0624359511,
0.0454970486,
-0.0383457877,
-0.0460738391,
0.0041405843,
-0.082002461,
0.00527249,
0.0102945166,
0.0456618592,
-0.0101561612,
0.0642568991,
-0.0281554312,
0.0004582324,
-0.0165705495,
0.0692342371,
0.0210168939,
0.0307330005,
-0.0130751282,
-0.0082757799,
-0.0109007172,
0.0080578094,
-0.0215676632,
-0.0057326085,
0.0057103941,
0.020167755,
0.0423089564,
-0.0126654059,
-0.0020931386,
0.0335499533,
-0.015538224,
0.0035672877,
0.0520097092,
-0.0304313563,
-0.0100452993,
-0.0466889553,
0.0017563403,
0.0152995354,
-0.004538483,
-0.0417722352,
0.024755029,
0.0359058715,
-0.0022559238,
-0.0065913377,
0.0148925781,
-0.0672605187,
0.0538449623,
0.0374659002,
-0.0023506319,
0.0422700681,
-0.0240807161,
0.0294026677,
-0.0288694818,
0.0942243412,
-0.0379132442,
0.0191499535,
-0.0909548178,
-0.0277306084,
-0.0211693887,
0.0363831222,
0.0326397568,
-0.0565288998,
-0.0263879169,
0.0262674391,
0.0023982127,
-0.0488721281,
-0.0632482767,
0.0269820448,
-0.0317709632,
0.0566557422,
-0.0058043529,
-0.0056731296,
-0.0525224544,
0.0405061133,
-0.0526809432,
-0.0481120422,
-0.0278714821,
0.0091573708,
0.0262264572,
-0.0846295729,
0.0246798098,
0.0030897344,
0.0128812408,
-0.0722544119,
0.001145097,
-0.0225590933,
-0.0380661152,
0.01320564,
0.0398675799,
-0.0411470607,
0.0390358157,
-0.0044536581,
0.0131314723,
-0.0381876677,
0.0019934669,
0.0136116371,
-0.0787938908,
0.0523461066,
0.0272548664,
-0.0037866051,
-0.0444484688,
0.0128302593,
0.0202720799,
0.0249934625,
0.0284049287,
-0.0479522571,
0.0551595539,
-0.0356536135,
-0.0213444717,
0.0220525451,
0.0449019298,
0.0453168787,
-0.0642497912,
0.007519824,
0.0292776208,
0.0246273056,
0.0114362417,
0.0390773341,
-0.0306113735,
-0.0012552042,
0.013257578,
0.10161075,
-0.0277523715,
0.0010376814,
0.046983242,
0.0163599234,
0.0046351454,
-0.0111550624,
0.0023159164,
-0.0523554571,
-0.0505269319,
-0.0001476761,
0.0086298464,
0.0259497669,
-0.0130206821,
0.0233767051,
-0.0435806699,
0.0021352121,
0.0531143472,
-0.0508843027,
0.0075635184,
0.0169731043,
-0.0146514205,
0.0528026111,
0.0327696651,
-0.0413493477,
-0.032967139,
-0.0213779882,
-0.0102521395,
0.0004595513,
0.0485480651,
0.0095776813,
-0.0177040417,
0.0090273311,
0.0433086343,
0.010264568,
0.0058356277,
-0.0105643496,
0.0506974235,
-0.0231567398,
0.006948167,
-0.0197691359,
-0.0034583977,
-0.012504166,
-0.0222156402,
-0.0005454055,
-0.0279667638,
-0.0652000085,
0.0063793454,
0.042382922,
-0.0045111123,
-0.0257166773,
0.0181523748,
0.015808953,
0.0435223244,
0.0036596546,
-0.0396983176,
0.0335600898,
0.0465171747,
-0.0556226484,
-0.0191013962,
0.0628101453,
-0.0168160852,
-0.0312121026,
0.0301861521,
-0.040478874,
-0.0295680594,
-0.0342178345,
-0.0094053084,
-0.0120232003,
0.026587598,
-0.0569298789,
0.0626328811,
-0.036763005,
-0.0161987543,
-0.0293733161,
0.0467278846,
-0.0062382137,
0.0664864853,
-0.009983751,
0.0446864627,
-0.0287003014,
0.0464862287,
0.020791471,
0.0150036095,
-0.0236382652,
0.0079571195,
-0.0031248129,
-0.0235649459,
0.0122185554,
-0.0052350094,
-0.0483349189,
-0.0014547709,
-0.0807888657,
-0.0190584213,
0.0402159318,
0.0228799768,
0.0203576032,
0.0094352458,
-0.0148604512,
-0.0015229781,
0.0157004409,
-0.0595934875,
-0.0339461491,
0.0506413057,
0.0305635668,
-0.0054059457,
-0.0531558432,
0.0010915783,
-0.0035332108,
-0.0751782209,
0.0482780822,
-0.02187494,
0.0246141553,
0.0463903025,
-0.0054415413,
-0.0452179611,
-0.0361909121,
0.0005104488,
-0.0567338057,
0.0127591565,
-0.0061711776,
0.0384690575,
-0.0006617255,
0.0112017989,
0.0458704792,
0.0315191261,
-0.0796007812,
-0.0163141433,
-0.0039667794,
-0.0090291798,
0.0061737793,
-0.0362413712,
-0.0169987082,
-0.005204753,
0.0651820153,
0.0559088401,
0.0093712965,
-0.0625415295,
0.0286362786,
-0.0043348358,
-0.0077077164,
-0.0629258156,
-0.0121293766,
-0.0599752516,
0.0180503726,
0.001557684,
-0.0044666599,
0.0686243325,
-0.0049542189,
-0.0249597412,
-0.042258095,
0.0020376949,
-0.0167150404,
0.0736437142,
-0.0665161833,
0.0373731665,
-0.0029574751,
-0.016215317,
-0.0111416802,
-0.0146211339,
-0.0276120491,
-0.0285456907,
0.0014801623,
-0.0089442078,
-0.0037299059,
0.009703761,
-0.0511117503,
-0.00191327,
-0.0710088611,
-0.0376285873,
0.0110531757,
0.0347164758,
-0.0104012778,
0.0243856926,
-0.0083217314,
-0.0030148532,
-0.0644773766,
0.0066961399,
-0.0132381003,
-0.0300968327,
0.0215972029,
-0.0091145728,
0.0030112257,
-0.0204988495,
0.0271551423,
-0.0374464728,
-0.0025101064,
0.0065421695,
0.016060818,
0.0072597656,
0.0332532935,
0.0218879022,
-0.0134852855,
-0.0355802104,
-0.0067501646,
-0.0006916124,
-0.0108797494,
-0.0497964695,
0.0599974506,
0.0522484817,
0.0027371179,
0.0643946603,
0.0083156275,
0.0213620588,
0.0449492447,
0.0172691606,
-0.074896805,
-0.0380897708,
0.011246861,
-0.0215758923,
-0.0322953053,
-0.0370261818,
-0.0351235084,
-0.1287502795,
0.0029416706,
-0.0001725622,
-0.0089572454,
-0.0360672772,
-0.0216880199,
0.0105329296,
0.0221288558,
0.0005752228,
-0.0159334131,
-0.0058642477,
0.0231550224,
0.0019628559,
-0.0084323045,
-0.077027835,
0.0516324565,
-0.0317871533,
0.0293807033,
0.0141899027,
0.0905757844,
-0.056386739,
-0.0967236757,
-0.0093060164,
-0.0460068323,
-0.0077043697,
-0.0287831575,
0.0124200042,
-0.0247303583,
-0.0240013227,
-0.004650387,
0.0119466521,
-0.0189796574,
-0.0088938093,
0.0011296588,
0.0379330143,
-0.0318142138,
0.030119596,
-0.0231941659,
-0.030501185,
-0.0086370194,
0.0921595767,
0.0236357823,
-0.0473931991,
0.0474473983,
-0.0088831009,
0.0115418769,
0.0191917736,
-0.0651515648,
-0.0229132865,
-0.0346538201,
0.0311496649,
-0.0540822037,
-0.0234747827,
0.0395006128,
0.0494591296,
0.0207456183,
0.0210823063,
-0.0874497369,
-0.020848373,
-0.0836069584,
0.0150149688,
0.0194692984,
0.0604346842,
-0.0217621662,
0.03669912,
0.0254838485,
0.007468455,
-0.0518907271,
0.0401274823,
0.03532774,
-0.0703948587,
-0.000920516,
0.0103308009,
0.0096379369,
-0.0140321013,
-0.0296109039,
0.0131632853,
0.0449173711,
0.0304764882,
-0.0047940742,
0.0388995968,
0.0383740887,
0.0116164172,
0.0294105988,
0.045334015,
-0.0167947449,
0.0099199153,
-0.0085071241,
0.0868639573,
0.0137484325,
-0.0044533587,
0.0317856967,
0.0090031093,
0.029968258,
-0.0179480836,
-0.0300909169,
0.0010011916,
-0.0114748962,
0.0021942419,
-0.0500989929,
0.0039569465,
0.0066122636,
0.0208931677,
-0.042060025,
-0.054962825,
0.0360846668,
-0.0234597735,
0.0705272257,
0.0146773318,
-0.0191430207,
0.0406256095,
-0.0259965584,
-0.0343304835,
0.0349795185,
0.0017934578,
-0.0142142242,
-0.0410861634,
0.0009748988,
-0.0144675877,
0.0111646727,
0.0228999704,
-0.011150579,
-0.0235872585,
0.0268781818,
-0.0100237532,
0.0014294446,
0.0446751453,
0.0010707304,
-0.0172761474,
-0.0358462259,
0.0297732241,
-0.0174715184,
-0.0064814682,
0.0027256885,
-0.0054578404,
-0.0302964672,
-0.0527364165,
0.1036060825,
0.0202659797,
-0.0189335961,
-0.0167766958,
0.0221622773,
-0.0480001867,
0.0698728487,
0.0015791418,
-0.0140023213,
-0.0378664471,
0.0273542851,
0.1127775684,
0.0607438013,
0.0147046093,
0.0333371758,
-0.094678916,
-0.0619642213,
0.0193985291,
-0.015770264,
0.0013071639,
-0.0128923627,
0.0109444773,
0.0594334975,
0.0519464165,
0.009931718,
-0.0316924341,
-0.0044679469,
-0.1055415049,
-0.0438218713,
-0.0427893102,
-6.225874321e-33,
-0.0395208821,
0.0057908483,
-0.0244108643,
-0.0180272572,
-0.03506089,
0.0506635793,
-0.0404105522,
0.0045928173,
-0.0295912065,
0.0254986789,
-0.0223656893,
-0.0016996466,
-0.0069116782,
-0.0031429427,
0.0373126529,
0.0144323334,
-0.0101422993,
0.024998473,
-0.0322344676,
-0.0429150499,
0.0651455522,
0.0240546837,
0.0965675935,
-0.0626093298,
0.03251094,
0.0451870002,
-0.0086853802,
0.0210128203,
0.0357363224,
0.056132704,
-0.0234880876,
0.0435732901,
0.0092502404,
0.0557421632,
0.0199421514,
0.0428523347,
-0.0162843633,
-0.0392240509,
0.0582950339,
-0.0084310425,
-0.007679929,
-0.0252133626,
0.0079547921,
-0.0406225026,
-0.0101164812,
0.0583943091,
0.0287041273,
0.0073463442,
-0.0174363069,
-0.0266366936,
-0.0663450807,
-0.0090913596,
-0.027016677,
-0.0405151322,
0.0170935839,
-0.0546616465,
0.0203028023,
-0.0250030607,
-0.0481240451,
0.0321119316,
-0.051353626,
-0.0065663699,
-0.0031529237,
-0.0097579416,
0.0403885506,
0.0735413283,
0.003512868,
-0.0379581824,
0.0461500995,
0.0015248425,
0.0729527101,
0.0637544543,
-0.0099491887,
0.023469517,
0.031342335,
0.0119626317,
0.0308468677,
-0.033478491,
0.1007775515,
0.0314257629,
0.0377043225,
0.009744809,
-0.0840361491,
-0.0324503705,
-0.0300475936,
-0.0193815827,
-0.0157622583,
-0.0441964716,
0.017862374,
-0.0264577176,
-0.0209080912,
0.0231998432,
0.0183559842,
-0.0277147405,
-0.0575353168,
0.0011709322,
-0.0298828613,
0.017026633,
0.0248374604,
0.009148797,
-0.0500971265,
-0.0305768382,
0.0118583534,
0.0154738035,
0.0339386389,
-0.0003160255,
0.0317304879,
0.0296037644,
-0.033237204,
-0.0347482413,
-0.0139176687,
-0.0795309618,
-0.0468599387,
-0.0230767298,
0.0442918129,
0.060859222,
-0.0358374752,
-0.0416084342,
0.0803694054,
0.0400031358,
-0.0209509991,
-0.0174101479,
-0.0218556318,
0.0551064089,
0.0011640018,
-0.023125425,
-0.0094396612,
-0.0216214992,
0.0617509186,
-0.0410480313,
0.0027339568,
0.0012162786,
2.793e-7,
0.0487930328,
0.0844148919,
0.0164432153,
-0.0108398218,
-0.0036069206,
0.0273934267,
-0.00906293,
0.0443597883,
-0.0544650592,
-0.0034439019,
0.0015318748,
0.0195522755,
-0.0099988701,
0.0104785562,
-0.0255678762,
0.0490634851,
-0.0654505119,
0.0436659642,
-0.0299388859,
0.0163726043,
0.0230623055,
0.0852361172,
0.0400763191,
-0.0160717145,
-0.0028306958,
-0.0620059967,
0.0255214423,
-0.0135038672,
0.0457022451,
-0.0205910709,
-0.0121966302,
0.0501361825,
0.0541033596,
0.0502088554,
0.0153840743,
0.0402318873,
-0.0058997516,
-0.027759131,
-0.0253755059,
0.0209413897,
-0.0559302606,
-0.059239395,
-0.0333266146,
-0.0287255384,
0.0727831498,
-0.0450027063,
-0.0726898387,
-0.0410953388,
-0.0035320066,
0.060487438,
0.0557301603,
0.0122301672,
-0.0245280676,
-0.0258589685,
0.0342843719,
-0.0213879105,
-0.0086730598,
-0.0560204908,
0.0141489543,
0.0409539454,
-0.0172958933,
-0.0165968891,
-0.0003485082,
0.0337051116,
0.00430999,
-0.0814960152,
-0.0149813332,
2.309447374e-34,
0.0128260357,
-0.0034769429,
0.0431455821,
0.046692118,
0.0344636142,
-0.0065430515,
0.0502199791,
0.0075768619,
0.0155067658,
-0.046560172,
-0.0148234339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14318v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14318v2 | q2d: Turning Questions into Dialogs to Teach Models How to Search | 2023-04-27T16:39:15 | 2023-12-26T16:00:48 | Yonatan Bitton, Shlomi Cohen-Ganor, Ido Hakimi, Yoad Lewenberg, Roee Aharoni, Enav Weinreb | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the exciting capabilities of recent language models for dialog is
their ability to independently search for relevant information to ground a
given dialog response. However, obtaining training data to teach models how to
issue search queries is time and resource consuming. In this work, we propose
q2d: an automatic data generation pipeline that generates information-seeking
dialogs from questions. We prompt a large language model (PaLM) to create
conversational versions of question answering datasets, and use it to improve
query generation models that communicate with external search APIs to ground
dialog responses. Unlike previous approaches which relied on human written
dialogs with search queries, our method allows to automatically generate
query-based grounded dialogs with better control and scale. Our experiments
demonstrate that: (1) For query generation on the QReCC dataset, models trained
on our synthetically-generated data achieve 90%--97% of the performance of
models trained on the human-generated data; (2) We can successfully generate
data for training dialog models in new domains without any existing dialog data
as demonstrated on the multi-hop MuSiQue and Bamboogle QA datasets. (3) We
perform a thorough analysis of the generated dialogs showing that humans find
them of high quality and struggle to distinguish them from human-written
dialogs. | [
0.0678468794,
0.0837248042,
-0.0105820131,
0.0347512588,
-0.0002492259,
0.0025951664,
-0.0055671553,
-0.019810399,
0.0249386504,
-0.0318379998,
-0.0495028682,
-0.0187595356,
-0.0644557029,
0.0631312653,
0.0238853227,
-0.049851615,
0.0436085165,
-0.0190318823,
0.0005256691,
0.0135574825,
0.0177412294,
0.0161001775,
-0.0187659599,
0.0641246513,
-0.0139287533,
-0.0143928062,
-0.0535663888,
0.0382761098,
-0.0325083211,
-0.0276498869,
0.039860405,
0.0619044527,
0.0269909687,
0.0451551601,
0.0000016792,
-0.0203534681,
0.0138037866,
-0.0328070521,
-0.0487843715,
-0.0255691856,
0.0045256894,
0.0513523966,
0.0261097662,
0.0509582534,
-0.0558510348,
-0.0135221733,
0.0412694514,
0.0442202725,
0.0923067927,
0.069247365,
0.0091257896,
-0.0198347252,
-0.0013107238,
-0.01317083,
0.0265327375,
-0.0332136378,
-0.022995485,
0.0180050656,
0.046089109,
0.0379982181,
0.0078141624,
0.0306757223,
0.0243506059,
-0.0771704987,
-0.0054589286,
0.0210812055,
-0.0464441925,
-0.0267020669,
-0.0084114894,
0.1097646058,
0.0140146026,
-0.0188840255,
-0.0034224095,
0.0097465012,
0.0311420131,
-0.0263643656,
-0.0781835467,
0.0146098277,
0.0001231865,
-0.0148374848,
-0.0133668343,
0.0071889423,
-0.0041336394,
0.0095741879,
-0.0075911372,
0.0302586462,
0.0165627766,
-0.0238548368,
0.0017007121,
-0.0152621893,
0.0114845419,
-0.0600679964,
0.0040683611,
0.018755693,
-0.0600780882,
0.0335687958,
-0.0435663424,
0.0153522259,
0.0280597266,
0.010881803,
-0.0018156616,
0.0259386916,
-0.0038004499,
0.049565319,
0.0107127307,
0.0244303085,
-0.0294610895,
0.025097318,
-0.050827194,
-0.0297246333,
-0.0290829875,
-0.0392483473,
-0.0592976883,
0.0277317222,
-0.0711037219,
-0.0321678221,
0.013110199,
0.0451127365,
0.0350326076,
-0.0266238712,
0.0027177399,
0.0575971901,
-0.0428541042,
0.0143841039,
-0.027349269,
0.0244028512,
-0.0462151803,
0.0141507424,
0.0535524897,
-0.0718784556,
-0.0191488098,
0.0277250633,
0.0290780589,
-0.0213865526,
-0.0155759845,
0.0499412827,
-0.0015721774,
-0.0239432398,
0.0118539035,
-0.0247979797,
0.0084304912,
-0.0258357171,
-0.0025530553,
-0.026095828,
0.0463769473,
-0.0239186101,
-0.0193105116,
-0.0150192613,
0.0269269664,
0.0646056905,
0.0251753479,
0.0575821698,
-0.0227627326,
0.0083611468,
0.0546275526,
0.0067632375,
-0.0070101339,
0.1000298262,
0.0314146914,
0.001787818,
0.0530435182,
-0.009892866,
0.0314423814,
0.0015750981,
0.0315956622,
0.0017623074,
0.0050923005,
0.0770624951,
-0.0131844841,
0.0397085175,
0.0063405079,
0.0526540838,
-0.0394089222,
-0.0179403797,
0.0458379015,
0.0614607036,
0.004306552,
-0.0131946141,
0.0227076542,
0.0198806729,
0.0116598262,
-0.017530337,
-0.0337333977,
0.0380715206,
0.0070018,
0.0014585363,
0.0147460978,
0.0100777801,
-0.0392336398,
-0.0375240818,
0.0267445911,
0.0364202745,
-0.0108401701,
0.0106098801,
-0.0077440562,
0.0561581478,
-0.0383317806,
0.044635199,
0.0016743613,
-0.0718419924,
-0.0128551451,
-0.0524387844,
0.0371957831,
0.0328936353,
0.069623597,
-0.0002112105,
-0.0250673518,
-0.0195081327,
0.0143333254,
0.0639163926,
0.035490565,
-0.038445957,
0.0321929678,
-0.0338791944,
-0.0097250789,
-0.0253794342,
0.0039662053,
-0.0203653108,
0.0171555728,
-0.0151999397,
0.0332087129,
-0.0552681834,
-0.0140068224,
0.0186195057,
-0.021856308,
-0.0181340929,
0.0323058926,
0.0012165555,
-0.0042913863,
0.0307969227,
0.0025028,
0.0221079625,
0.033187218,
-0.0005674549,
-0.018485304,
0.0237020757,
-0.0327342004,
-0.0413259417,
-0.0017871571,
-0.0382077657,
0.0225166455,
-0.000076386,
-0.0226431787,
-0.0553408116,
0.0231644846,
-0.0534185655,
0.0398540534,
-0.0488488637,
-0.0049059247,
0.0204513818,
-0.0130261201,
-0.0416915864,
0.0350244418,
0.0388079397,
-0.008553897,
0.0240311828,
0.0487120599,
0.0096493633,
-0.0592791252,
0.016770279,
0.0328616239,
-0.0190257803,
0.0139993196,
0.0250460766,
0.0232979432,
-0.0822807178,
-0.0178832002,
-0.1058021486,
0.0098057175,
-0.0134326154,
-0.0093833758,
0.0417794436,
0.0448794626,
-0.0145167587,
-0.0462235361,
-0.0685499758,
-0.0247558765,
0.0427072756,
0.0101530869,
0.035987433,
0.0355968066,
-0.0130167101,
-0.0744179189,
0.0082969153,
0.0079912534,
0.0293225702,
0.0191321503,
0.0479900949,
-0.0373203941,
-0.0096162083,
-0.0454306193,
0.0261007044,
-0.005531061,
-0.0403723121,
0.0317132361,
-0.0207496677,
0.0019010485,
0.075178653,
0.0438973233,
0.0271449108,
0.0098873936,
0.0072143474,
-0.0858550668,
0.0525100119,
-0.0271265954,
-0.0086923605,
-0.0184193645,
-0.0198449641,
0.0457074381,
0.0472034328,
0.0151690496,
0.0274793375,
-0.0407620892,
0.0618897304,
0.0355543345,
-0.023863459,
-0.0368535332,
-0.0025289252,
-0.0253328923,
0.0608456433,
-0.0237626527,
-0.0471700393,
0.0739096478,
-0.0133911818,
-0.0350911357,
-0.0697376281,
-0.0122253848,
-0.0497677773,
0.0684412718,
-0.0308531895,
0.0136738196,
0.0176550858,
-0.0439302549,
-0.0457792729,
-0.0007906249,
0.0184280705,
-0.031927634,
0.0564637594,
-0.0275565721,
0.0115170199,
0.0143163716,
-0.0578281544,
-0.0586092472,
-0.0180564914,
-0.0220592935,
-0.025878245,
0.0045223441,
-0.0260134283,
0.0006846244,
-0.023952743,
0.011675247,
0.0535420701,
-0.03336614,
-0.0128086824,
-0.022404179,
0.0455666706,
0.0681871101,
0.0228779297,
-0.0126209576,
-0.0197245851,
0.0909374356,
0.0189086925,
0.0411536805,
-0.0225262064,
0.0176382232,
-0.024139395,
0.0192731079,
0.0189076699,
0.0061459499,
-0.0020111061,
0.0504797213,
-0.0345083885,
-0.060951218,
0.1080407128,
0.0421387665,
-0.0285556689,
-0.0219116211,
-0.028944023,
0.0360597335,
0.0367949344,
0.0359567702,
-0.0635896102,
-0.0502770357,
-0.0049151587,
0.0386775322,
0.0108621726,
-0.0095873345,
0.0027095848,
-0.1227708012,
0.0497142002,
-0.0201764852,
-0.0171855446,
-0.0449194461,
-0.0275576264,
0.0002359356,
-0.0072304029,
0.0001621072,
0.0303313062,
-0.0168423597,
0.0117541738,
0.0060833115,
0.0390149914,
-0.0193838924,
0.0157694928,
-0.0336501896,
0.0259372089,
0.0805911347,
0.0363825373,
0.0399838686,
-0.0075417752,
0.0000539547,
-0.029971607,
-0.0111279013,
-0.006975377,
0.0445502363,
-0.0075629712,
-0.0306346975,
-0.0363935903,
0.039422147,
-0.0400987677,
0.0200830717,
0.0355568714,
0.027897859,
-0.0569926202,
0.0061714104,
-0.0377828106,
0.0243047494,
0.0213028956,
0.0863508731,
0.068603076,
-0.0463296063,
-0.0210027471,
-0.0451978296,
-0.0007016968,
-0.0819217414,
-0.0225998331,
-0.0089905476,
0.0207655095,
0.0478034616,
-0.0869062021,
-0.0465238467,
0.0131102717,
0.0168689396,
0.0036735018,
-0.0198474675,
-0.0012357797,
0.0119077293,
-0.0170401204,
0.0216738675,
-0.0307856109,
0.0105695333,
-0.075836204,
-0.0222695805,
0.043749623,
-0.0401613563,
-0.027364146,
0.0113118729,
-0.0586539395,
-0.0389734842,
-0.035754934,
0.040367648,
0.0241131932,
0.0288141388,
-0.0160701592,
-0.009106487,
-0.0430981889,
0.0331251249,
-0.0552835613,
-0.033238966,
0.0346889347,
0.010416517,
-0.0074620149,
0.052416455,
-0.050508067,
0.0030970674,
-0.0407612547,
0.0447595231,
-0.0302798692,
-0.0866611749,
0.0370568223,
-0.0040075034,
0.0040109269,
0.0271738656,
0.0113579612,
-0.0457546115,
0.039741978,
-0.0313788354,
-0.0290275086,
-0.0700599179,
0.0198668949,
-0.0007410542,
-0.0185811184,
0.0211389381,
-0.0202364847,
-0.0519048609,
0.0674183965,
-0.0247474648,
0.0017899331,
0.0101178801,
0.0094362209,
0.0124722216,
-0.0186792426,
-0.0059370277,
0.0320249461,
0.0005739053,
0.0577292629,
0.0040676435,
0.0654967278,
0.0190701615,
-0.055150006,
0.041897893,
0.0300830919,
-0.091830194,
-0.075886853,
-0.0237098206,
-0.0239408053,
-0.0001738527,
0.0024828094,
-0.0001744,
-0.0083967643,
0.0021569987,
0.0111138951,
0.0280306377,
0.0030240214,
-0.0419268161,
0.0419373475,
0.031548962,
-0.010864961,
-0.0275756139,
0.0590321794,
0.0031688102,
0.0490866117,
-0.0185732581,
0.011638632,
-0.0458739325,
-0.0242866259,
0.0173350871,
0.0260979086,
-0.0092582637,
0.0315227471,
-0.0291405506,
-0.0592553169,
-0.0375818387,
0.0055094492,
-0.0194642898,
-0.0016590231,
0.0609627254,
0.0637489483,
0.0017311267,
0.0006113137,
-0.0331961624,
0.0362054482,
-0.0457074307,
-0.0243624728,
-0.0208488051,
-5.561648381e-33,
-0.0302891713,
-0.0296139624,
0.0081489729,
-0.0136692999,
-0.0200810973,
-0.0224321075,
-0.0595510677,
-0.0075311661,
-0.0307523571,
-0.0062370384,
-0.0203448441,
0.0422715619,
-0.0035655841,
0.0419220366,
0.0002976857,
-0.0356509611,
0.043412324,
-0.0272580665,
-0.0119080776,
0.0533870868,
0.0308629628,
0.0114291692,
-0.0096623832,
-0.018339172,
0.016290728,
-0.0346822478,
-0.0096837748,
0.0706480071,
-0.019745579,
0.0782119781,
-0.016739212,
0.0312047526,
0.0001626357,
-0.0168503597,
-0.0169662032,
0.0371666029,
-0.0574994273,
-0.0316325612,
0.0254891478,
-0.0121074589,
-0.0230139382,
-0.0100361099,
-0.0092163933,
-0.0378188081,
0.0381142944,
0.0175800361,
0.0103821922,
-0.0152673004,
0.0016778756,
-0.0143913729,
-0.0205827989,
-0.0022706317,
-0.0242138766,
-0.0639333948,
-0.0325240269,
0.0950922742,
0.0241624396,
0.006440396,
0.0008827177,
0.03878491,
0.0096056443,
0.0222797152,
0.0266961884,
0.0427571982,
0.0045657307,
0.0638519898,
0.0316780731,
-0.0140596395,
-0.0081399092,
-0.0155118452,
-0.0107068419,
0.0349948592,
0.0387359969,
0.0538568944,
0.0061851032,
0.0178441722,
-0.011195695,
0.0319960788,
-0.0073017362,
0.0097385235,
-0.0231047571,
0.0025269608,
-0.0207545962,
0.0048578829,
-0.0534338765,
-0.0006005357,
-0.0409223251,
-0.0113323079,
0.0492273681,
0.0338976197,
-0.0206457879,
-0.0481459051,
0.0054953103,
-0.0150385797,
0.0107179545,
0.0373861045,
-0.0138392327,
-0.003826122,
0.0037242076,
0.0078478828,
-0.0113598164,
0.0041278098,
0.0670035779,
0.0126311323,
-0.0083701117,
0.0301366933,
-0.0131818363,
0.0030368092,
-0.0622980446,
0.0107265189,
-0.0505896732,
0.0585854314,
-0.0532341674,
-0.0020375263,
-0.0107183829,
0.0220196303,
-0.0395982414,
0.0627952591,
-0.0118305525,
0.0056631719,
-0.0713895634,
-0.0730051622,
0.0113331275,
0.0357756168,
-0.0362286903,
0.0050213118,
-0.026168989,
-0.0097605763,
0.0071088579,
-0.0662868246,
-0.0047180899,
0.0129678026,
2.365e-7,
0.0200722981,
0.0030310887,
0.0365866423,
0.0563686639,
0.009926727,
0.0472621769,
0.0025539985,
-0.0001351324,
0.0388896577,
-0.0497979224,
-0.0050427988,
0.0203036927,
0.0406060778,
0.016359305,
-0.1418842971,
0.0013936269,
-0.0792216957,
-0.0519020632,
-0.0518582799,
-0.0479627363,
0.0597546771,
0.0920979828,
-0.0127661414,
-0.0133322841,
-0.0237109009,
-0.0218300298,
0.0250643492,
-0.0068466701,
-0.0037340675,
0.0161020309,
0.0303113833,
0.0095930696,
0.0148185007,
-0.0055056936,
-0.0289496314,
0.0242997203,
0.0161587279,
0.0361772738,
0.0232157316,
-0.0468741581,
-0.0099153128,
-0.0257692598,
0.0290553104,
-0.0697134435,
0.048209127,
-0.0217917394,
0.0221238565,
-0.0367623791,
-0.0076900809,
-0.0273963176,
0.0066208672,
-0.0728594363,
-0.0252811238,
-0.0052384729,
0.0084997732,
0.0070357965,
0.0608757697,
-0.0636995211,
-0.0214601774,
-0.0211740248,
-0.0355837904,
-0.0296904277,
-0.060522981,
-0.0386282578,
-0.0261038598,
-0.0005884655,
0.0187666491,
1.909439389e-34,
0.042407196,
-0.0014594087,
0.0248862244,
0.0501594804,
0.0432275981,
0.0019053349,
0.0256718621,
-0.0282477699,
0.049576465,
-0.0834230632,
-0.0210333429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14317v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14317v2 | ICE-Score: Instructing Large Language Models to Evaluate Code | 2023-04-27T16:38:17 | 2024-01-22T17:06:50 | Terry Yue Zhuo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Recent advancements in the field of natural language generation have
facilitated the use of large language models to assess the quality of generated
text. Although these models have shown promising results in tasks such as
machine translation and summarization, their applicability in code intelligence
tasks remains limited without human involvement. The complexity of programming
concepts required for such tasks makes it difficult to develop evaluation
metrics that align with human judgment. Token-matching-based metrics, such as
BLEU, have demonstrated weak correlations with human practitioners in code
intelligence tasks. Moreover, utilizing human-written test suites to evaluate
functional correctness can be challenging in domains with low resources. To
overcome these obstacles, we propose \texttt{ICE-Score}, a new evaluation
metric via instructing large language models (LLMs) for code assessments. Our
metric addresses the limitations of existing approaches by achieving superior
correlations with functional correctness and human preferences, without the
need for test oracles or references. We evaluate the efficacy of our metric on
two different aspects (\textit{human preference} and \textit{execution
success}) and four programming languages. Our results demonstrate that our
metric surpasses state-of-the-art metrics for code generation, delivering high
levels of accuracy and consistency across various programming languages and
tasks. We also make our evaluation metric and datasets available to the
public\footnote{\url{https://github.com/terryyz/ice-score}}, encouraging
further research in evaluating code intelligence tasks. | [
0.0023898638,
0.0696603358,
-0.0191191137,
0.0184702333,
-0.0433932804,
-0.008718133,
-0.0109030856,
-0.0077406862,
0.0291235205,
-0.0132707851,
-0.015388011,
-0.0061342325,
0.0332327038,
0.0660878718,
0.0424669944,
-0.0110397832,
0.0315531753,
-0.032513991,
-0.0035114069,
0.0353142805,
-0.0018672688,
0.0265962444,
-0.0063076732,
0.0674179345,
0.0115710637,
-0.029055085,
0.028597787,
0.0146917282,
0.0035653047,
-0.0387121662,
0.0025509365,
0.0522663072,
-0.0503548756,
0.0133585567,
0.0000021802,
-0.0655808672,
0.0056365072,
0.0015759786,
0.0333679877,
0.0599208921,
0.0209907982,
0.0236841943,
0.0074088927,
0.029576093,
-0.0355042443,
0.0201608725,
0.0485663749,
-0.0375020355,
0.0747057945,
0.0597535521,
0.0078903493,
0.0206543747,
0.0266115367,
0.0144302137,
0.0224183854,
-0.022331588,
-0.0066500371,
0.0417002589,
0.016725108,
0.0054741646,
0.0330786183,
0.0016575492,
0.027428491,
-0.0088983858,
0.0055255527,
0.0269074664,
-0.0377662405,
-0.0105754351,
0.0220091883,
0.0140549801,
-0.0468802005,
-0.0341131203,
0.0087058619,
0.0057473229,
-0.0140365418,
-0.0428636894,
-0.0226890333,
0.0094267558,
0.0147816325,
-0.0140291108,
0.0214567855,
-0.0085546793,
0.0195108857,
0.0163733661,
-0.0199521054,
0.0612223856,
-0.0001259106,
-0.0157454126,
-0.0071807606,
-0.0038505148,
-0.0488603972,
-0.0651045591,
-0.0216527656,
0.0309706256,
-0.0533048995,
-0.0196183119,
-0.0415580906,
-0.0489521734,
0.0388445705,
-0.0163054634,
0.0246680062,
0.0466193035,
-0.0035387706,
0.000320409,
-0.0553251132,
0.1088398695,
0.0295722429,
0.0060575944,
-0.0332426839,
0.0214939471,
-0.0362455323,
-0.0026354315,
-0.0136904195,
0.0280763786,
0.0169621874,
0.0201761555,
-0.0504442453,
0.0234024897,
-0.0255179331,
0.0653732643,
-0.0198381748,
0.0012575802,
-0.0071596727,
0.0256062448,
0.0220021475,
-0.0306526944,
-0.0301281195,
-0.0324145257,
0.0003336197,
-0.0446794294,
0.0141191306,
0.055316437,
-0.032823246,
-0.0135938395,
0.0250006355,
0.0857966766,
0.0106871277,
0.0102352407,
0.0014566892,
-0.0252681859,
0.0039619594,
-0.0323948488,
-0.017397793,
-0.1198790297,
-0.0347337686,
0.0479861684,
-0.0129335467,
-0.0748997405,
0.0020913375,
0.0150506487,
0.0093832221,
0.0114645362,
-0.0365680233,
0.0214253571,
0.0022367849,
-0.002775213,
-0.037726935,
0.0340955108,
0.0770777687,
0.0136743812,
0.0207290351,
-0.0213775672,
0.043801371,
0.031150559,
-0.0297792628,
0.0200358219,
-0.0003609313,
0.0245592874,
0.0139345936,
0.0130368797,
0.025119679,
0.081693612,
0.0005164499,
0.0345806554,
0.0071159629,
0.0516032577,
-0.0248095114,
0.0367607176,
0.073770158,
0.0351896957,
0.0022662638,
-0.0030226992,
-0.0233826544,
0.0652975217,
-0.0340058692,
0.02373036,
0.0261504762,
0.0341376103,
0.0262073111,
-0.0969603509,
-0.0129114026,
0.0044909185,
0.0019216134,
-0.0054027257,
-0.002651898,
-0.0089064818,
-0.0390044414,
0.0140043283,
-0.0209501125,
-0.0930962786,
0.0009931693,
-0.0418317467,
0.0241041612,
0.0565357469,
0.0556870326,
-0.0242592022,
-0.0017143514,
-0.0066762548,
-0.0126059838,
-0.003765119,
0.0477314964,
-0.0023052704,
-0.0305608809,
-0.0346611962,
0.0006697527,
-0.0269200895,
-0.0027381741,
0.009868158,
0.0159068555,
-0.0253328141,
0.0496653691,
-0.0424265675,
-0.1243149787,
0.0390144996,
-0.00961727,
-0.0013977935,
0.0036012074,
-0.0013501705,
0.0237838775,
-0.0201663598,
-0.0488401242,
0.0476606153,
0.0100011108,
-0.0159619972,
-0.0205663927,
0.0009072029,
-0.0019730669,
0.0057836883,
0.0109634129,
-0.0646448508,
-0.0352101848,
0.0458296128,
-0.0130183203,
-0.0238779951,
0.0606243573,
-0.0512051806,
-0.0029747405,
-0.001412128,
0.0205955505,
-0.0306022875,
-0.0517797619,
-0.0080152759,
0.0448884256,
-0.0026166011,
0.0691170543,
0.0140676238,
0.0458489656,
0.0125624044,
0.0027880559,
-0.0325619504,
0.0004785947,
-0.0211343654,
0.0405772552,
0.0456455909,
0.0967550501,
-0.0256865956,
-0.0361902714,
-0.0920556188,
0.0371791832,
-0.0278457459,
0.0336312316,
0.0262183473,
0.002173648,
0.0042867037,
0.0329204425,
-0.0573904254,
-0.0733748972,
0.0097312871,
0.0008307343,
0.0455284677,
-0.0385700986,
-0.0474435277,
-0.0424726456,
0.0127967512,
-0.048762098,
0.057572674,
0.0163986981,
0.0347903855,
-0.0517162681,
0.0783672184,
-0.0209523812,
-0.0291282479,
0.0048364289,
-0.0646652058,
0.0158580411,
-0.0083625354,
0.0677277595,
0.0635879561,
0.0208993163,
-0.0331248678,
0.0354046673,
0.0253449716,
-0.0392607227,
-0.0137189245,
0.0376217365,
-0.0057043871,
0.0324568972,
-0.067585066,
0.0590550117,
0.0390535109,
-0.0082240161,
-0.0086681778,
-0.0478394255,
0.0384426005,
-0.0419590436,
0.0003985861,
-0.0152452178,
-0.0346827023,
-0.0059486702,
0.0425553545,
-0.0342893265,
-0.0731630102,
0.0569095388,
-0.0492847152,
-0.0049470719,
-0.0479151681,
-0.0013775288,
-0.0619906001,
0.0627460331,
0.00685297,
0.0369503237,
-0.0403318889,
-0.0151022589,
-0.0419429839,
0.0033779358,
-0.0290396828,
-0.0448868498,
0.0511320308,
-0.0775109455,
0.012068335,
0.0183825605,
-0.0182898063,
-0.0289092083,
0.0121084852,
-0.0091817295,
0.0093043251,
0.0734159797,
0.0007156316,
0.0087002879,
-0.0014679111,
0.0324562974,
0.0156951379,
0.0116964364,
-0.0223685876,
-0.0016155862,
-0.0459446684,
-0.0165374819,
-0.0349587873,
0.0192089509,
-0.0251387525,
-0.0150137804,
0.0192227848,
0.0481468365,
0.0516100675,
-0.0581845678,
0.0027476095,
0.0162919331,
-0.036001049,
-0.0383247137,
0.0650255531,
0.0825729668,
-0.0292098559,
-0.0259655472,
0.0929276794,
0.0376612432,
-0.0109665338,
0.0221923403,
-0.0082034795,
0.0474676341,
0.0624287277,
0.0436019525,
-0.0509489514,
-0.0299023427,
-0.0017962642,
0.0428305566,
-0.0330913328,
-0.0329635181,
-0.0230287425,
-0.1101451442,
0.0105948867,
0.0309731681,
-0.0361205414,
-0.0515802205,
-0.0307353828,
0.0037090124,
-0.0126129976,
-0.0337179303,
0.0375781357,
0.0083210319,
0.0247631203,
0.0059471573,
-0.0798343942,
-0.004409194,
0.0499697775,
-0.046850726,
0.0067642215,
0.1183335111,
0.0218471978,
-0.0030044015,
-0.0311326645,
0.0019484499,
-0.0184645765,
0.0069840481,
-0.005122907,
0.0380340144,
-0.0043032845,
-0.0009874708,
0.0166448634,
0.0200044587,
-0.0394015908,
-0.014928476,
0.0390969627,
0.0228314176,
-0.0000466777,
-0.0180615559,
-0.0113818385,
0.0135250874,
-0.0254759807,
0.047246851,
0.0617863983,
-0.0327294655,
-0.0359575078,
-0.0772897378,
-0.0165043585,
-0.1097763777,
-0.0452979133,
-0.0143623073,
0.0046819812,
0.0049369545,
-0.074864842,
-0.0161796417,
0.0345573686,
0.028265845,
0.0232380517,
-0.0457015298,
-0.0056516579,
0.0021357439,
-0.0351513326,
0.0348793156,
-0.0000096839,
0.0434974842,
-0.0655553266,
-0.0064931363,
-0.0144683896,
-0.0221860353,
-0.0254522339,
0.0447489135,
-0.0535068475,
-0.0346239395,
-0.0333568268,
0.0574087389,
0.0249011479,
-0.00298231,
-0.0357726403,
-0.0363125317,
-0.0273843445,
0.0241102036,
-0.0395182073,
-0.0014842921,
0.0141220847,
0.000626979,
0.0174072105,
0.0049882173,
-0.0853465199,
0.0103143379,
-0.0020989762,
0.0286026187,
0.0202783216,
-0.0100545436,
0.0443296097,
0.0493204929,
-0.0020785192,
-0.0160124544,
-0.0177463535,
0.0161298979,
-0.042185016,
0.0005684735,
-0.0645643622,
-0.0374784917,
0.0230676364,
-0.0036560798,
0.0206070133,
0.0077012908,
0.0178345647,
-0.0315982401,
-0.000252678,
0.0084235705,
0.0436174758,
-0.0200077146,
0.0523672998,
0.0429360978,
-0.0219982564,
-0.0541492254,
-0.0240143966,
-0.0432017334,
0.0156446099,
0.00530631,
0.0300026275,
0.0123420143,
0.0479709655,
0.0341589749,
0.0397723988,
-0.0477647148,
-0.0460481457,
-0.015684735,
-0.0047027562,
0.0376068726,
0.0192003362,
0.0404673629,
-0.0255305916,
0.0335775204,
-0.0225243382,
0.0501074716,
-0.0068309894,
-0.0506425425,
-0.0347997844,
0.0370053165,
-0.014862434,
-0.0595039017,
0.0955682769,
-0.032656759,
-0.0208543502,
-0.0375254191,
-0.0101166638,
-0.0425118171,
0.0001325121,
0.0233623181,
-0.0231703855,
-0.0154762855,
-0.0309688933,
-0.0532452539,
-0.0669676289,
0.0123110106,
0.0606533624,
0.0513763428,
-0.0058221016,
0.0314727165,
0.1005715355,
-0.0141114341,
-0.0038468819,
-0.0210871566,
-0.0195498299,
-0.0192257036,
-0.0327258781,
-0.0534754246,
-5.773731072e-33,
-0.0179973915,
-0.0454029813,
-0.0019164301,
0.0220366865,
0.0249486845,
-0.0038383047,
-0.0528603345,
0.011786906,
0.0295774806,
-0.031654954,
0.0374155492,
-0.0087791523,
-0.0307604484,
-0.0232580565,
0.042314522,
0.0327334069,
0.0404018797,
0.0239208434,
-0.0832775906,
0.015556898,
-0.0226175673,
-0.0109966826,
-0.0060898755,
-0.0201323088,
0.0318108089,
-0.0236237813,
0.0096068913,
-0.0166460369,
0.0210115295,
0.0391908661,
0.0180725716,
0.0181846861,
0.0003502347,
-0.004975101,
-0.0289201904,
-0.0146068167,
0.0185981002,
-0.0295161828,
0.0306240767,
-0.0197298098,
-0.0410559326,
-0.0707854256,
0.0906093046,
-0.0033833487,
-0.0670568347,
0.0245516598,
0.0288791209,
0.012527776,
0.0323280953,
-0.0273304153,
-0.0624171682,
0.0353182405,
-0.0893539488,
-0.0184438098,
-0.0430526622,
0.0557666235,
-0.0200429391,
0.0038002767,
0.000698451,
0.0087210899,
-0.0151545424,
0.046453584,
0.081031315,
-0.0313029326,
-0.0030487487,
0.0569265895,
0.0182879474,
0.0289645772,
0.0114214597,
0.0210724864,
0.0450806357,
0.0522570722,
0.0673930869,
0.0274136327,
0.0236648098,
-0.0287321471,
-0.0244759973,
0.0640810952,
-0.0127765145,
0.0109811602,
0.0178147014,
-0.0116140256,
-0.0635004789,
-0.0137394154,
-0.0503107272,
-0.0093479222,
-0.0270534325,
-0.0416132808,
0.0506422818,
-0.0248256996,
-0.029902041,
-0.0293516386,
-0.0011938099,
-0.0166321285,
0.0187789574,
0.0141104441,
-0.0782997981,
0.0390884764,
-0.0187834483,
0.0247436371,
-0.0022414005,
-0.0049497285,
0.0108675631,
0.0192086603,
0.0907524079,
0.0019590277,
0.0235967096,
-0.0001800342,
-0.0609362461,
0.0030822607,
-0.0424805619,
-0.001037571,
0.0024299349,
-0.013935524,
0.0042618862,
0.01475708,
0.0151786264,
-0.0079297908,
-0.0171476323,
-0.034635406,
-0.0693128034,
-0.0293442309,
-0.0044249259,
0.0188759677,
-0.04539055,
-0.0309632085,
-0.0401865765,
0.0119888801,
-0.0086475899,
-0.0164422039,
-0.0598454401,
0.0245617926,
2.887e-7,
0.0227948837,
0.0650106892,
-0.0296871439,
0.0477455333,
-0.0229858905,
0.0247078408,
-0.0365552641,
-0.0161884893,
0.0457143262,
0.0252348296,
-0.0291751139,
0.0188563839,
0.0445239954,
0.0260239337,
-0.0606163107,
0.0103881974,
-0.0277561955,
0.0074399756,
-0.0579681583,
0.0138631659,
0.0641631037,
0.0102844834,
-0.0222601909,
0.0228185672,
-0.0074331756,
-0.060771659,
0.005367788,
-0.0127442731,
0.0069983345,
0.0276702773,
-0.0109296842,
0.0154134417,
0.022555571,
0.0285936669,
-0.0008250161,
-0.0163872857,
0.052080825,
0.0471432433,
0.0118791386,
0.0476850681,
0.0214699171,
-0.0072800205,
0.0228004418,
-0.0626848862,
0.0515801981,
-0.0106176762,
-0.0045509143,
-0.0250476133,
-0.0503327921,
-0.002670571,
0.011347075,
-0.0123636741,
-0.0056626592,
0.0259693637,
-0.0062188734,
-0.0202056076,
-0.0167286489,
0.0277145077,
-0.0528621115,
0.0345842466,
0.0032999832,
-0.0586918183,
-0.0470240712,
0.045332741,
-0.0072379438,
-0.0281923842,
0.0251971278,
2.968578969e-34,
0.0313971192,
-0.0443612039,
0.0315447487,
-0.0275306664,
0.0825753957,
-0.0007426163,
-0.030836869,
0.0068344353,
-0.0047350689,
0.0083587337,
-0.0130767748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14293v2 | Controlled Text Generation with Natural Language Instructions | 2023-04-27T15:56:34 | 2023-06-08T06:33:23 | Wangchunshu Zhou, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Ethan Wilcox, Ryan Cotterell, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models generate fluent texts and can follow natural language
instructions to solve a wide range of tasks without task-specific training.
Nevertheless, it is notoriously difficult to control their generation to
satisfy the various constraints required by different applications. In this
work, we present InstructCTG, a controlled text generation framework that
incorporates different constraints by conditioning on natural language
descriptions and demonstrations of the constraints. In particular, we first
extract the underlying constraints of natural texts through a combination of
off-the-shelf NLP tools and simple heuristics. We then verbalize the
constraints into natural language instructions to form weakly supervised
training data. By prepending natural language descriptions of the constraints
and a few demonstrations, we fine-tune a pre-trained language model to
incorporate various types of constraints. Compared to existing search-based or
score-based methods, InstructCTG is more flexible to different constraint types
and has a much smaller impact on the generation quality and speed because it
does not modify the decoding procedure. Additionally, InstructCTG allows the
model to adapt to new constraints without re-training through the use of
few-shot task generalization and in-context learning abilities of
instruction-tuned language models. | [
0.0433368795,
0.0599075891,
0.0353229642,
-0.0032211144,
-0.0233570393,
-0.0109444354,
0.0153101562,
0.0040787477,
0.0191534888,
-0.0534828827,
-0.0133236283,
-0.0024908385,
-0.0189522579,
0.0295422319,
0.0543245263,
-0.0489910953,
0.0136695225,
-0.0122695193,
-0.0064025815,
0.0152555741,
0.028022673,
0.040568158,
-0.0195680391,
0.0340148471,
-0.0351850167,
0.0036382873,
-0.0131103871,
0.0038024324,
0.0083308052,
-0.0349645205,
0.0548866391,
0.0453055762,
0.0388858877,
-0.0312640704,
0.0000019798,
-0.0273049362,
-0.0250559598,
-0.0270175468,
-0.0027954387,
-0.0062225256,
0.0457522124,
-0.052850876,
0.0079451445,
0.0294306744,
-0.039176479,
0.0154687408,
0.020249581,
0.0480723307,
0.0853578895,
0.1021735668,
-0.0049222498,
-0.0036367616,
-0.0439374819,
-0.0227963012,
0.0273259096,
-0.0197961591,
-0.0135814529,
0.0080641182,
0.0372556522,
0.0239508916,
0.0115166912,
0.0067576044,
0.0309991036,
-0.0097499872,
-0.0016843462,
0.0426282547,
-0.0179329105,
-0.0297649838,
-0.05355452,
0.0620623603,
0.007942345,
-0.0483312681,
0.0311159175,
-0.0247034915,
-0.0164249036,
-0.0121482303,
-0.031020062,
0.0516338609,
-0.0068921219,
0.0169570372,
0.0086600929,
0.0379102007,
0.0021091914,
0.0144040557,
0.0127666229,
0.0053120758,
0.0253800564,
-0.0396347828,
0.0013606453,
0.0045868224,
-0.0244213212,
-0.0609496087,
0.0252707731,
0.0478553437,
-0.0698618367,
0.0038772933,
-0.0933985934,
-0.0371089727,
0.0165579207,
-0.0072949976,
0.0492872037,
0.0430162586,
0.0213770028,
0.006789831,
-0.0316683501,
0.08051081,
0.0079956781,
0.0081384555,
-0.0380417965,
0.0336933695,
-0.050136473,
-0.0246073436,
-0.0653779507,
0.0121983355,
-0.0476400703,
-0.035908293,
-0.0352667049,
0.0085138408,
0.0060168849,
0.0222784225,
0.0135765355,
0.0363787152,
-0.0708780363,
-0.0109739257,
0.0069564097,
-0.0303869173,
-0.035133563,
-0.0130080925,
0.0292560868,
0.0001209316,
-0.0251395218,
0.0539415516,
0.0313943326,
-0.0096089859,
0.0202915315,
0.0621362664,
-0.0608034767,
-0.0220237039,
-0.0118220076,
-0.0529889278,
-0.0270392727,
-0.0629828051,
-0.0047820574,
-0.0402311087,
0.0114747174,
-0.0139956959,
-0.027356565,
-0.0555777662,
0.0337761417,
0.0202757511,
0.0145573858,
0.0312270988,
0.0035022995,
-0.0152110178,
0.0220828969,
0.0034783001,
0.0148219578,
0.05434471,
0.0364084579,
0.0460837111,
-0.0099434191,
0.0229921732,
0.0254418943,
0.0301238671,
0.0366796553,
0.0055361269,
-0.0095229177,
-0.0078417584,
0.0232235901,
0.0414831787,
0.0287681092,
0.0572730526,
-0.0362066478,
0.0527790338,
0.0377312079,
0.0107954405,
0.0037908058,
0.0112342946,
0.0885517597,
0.031990625,
-0.0158096608,
0.0306891091,
-0.0473899171,
0.0080714189,
0.016553415,
0.0200594533,
0.0267165601,
0.0036123577,
-0.0248776544,
-0.044630684,
0.0137665635,
-0.0097374786,
0.0407931134,
-0.0267473087,
0.0249529555,
0.0645024329,
-0.0869632885,
0.0204378441,
0.00906586,
-0.0595252328,
0.0296096243,
-0.0015524557,
-0.0016425683,
0.0655715317,
0.0486448742,
-0.0078677312,
-0.0048616957,
0.0102833258,
0.0540034063,
0.0801953897,
0.0507221706,
-0.0039310232,
-0.011494183,
-0.0586424172,
-0.0100745605,
-0.0450919196,
0.0151953464,
0.0013495435,
0.0236222278,
0.0021539039,
0.0393148698,
0.0010168261,
-0.0706548914,
0.0606587976,
-0.0401554927,
-0.0786606818,
0.0254560988,
-0.013302627,
-0.028888667,
0.0152949244,
-0.0177065209,
0.02423569,
0.0140705258,
-0.0415267609,
-0.0027666495,
-0.0080421157,
-0.0496186279,
-0.0446690172,
-0.0088281734,
-0.0449849628,
0.0083601559,
0.0064696576,
-0.0175585337,
-0.0496153347,
0.002291854,
-0.0307069104,
0.0058263997,
-0.0212575439,
-0.003638335,
0.0608047135,
-0.0612182617,
-0.0460867546,
0.0544164777,
0.0262949225,
-0.0061825318,
0.055668287,
-0.0012840537,
-0.0142963929,
-0.0396181233,
0.0264689568,
-0.0349218473,
-0.015854476,
-0.0012486849,
0.0548432842,
0.0977174938,
-0.023783816,
-0.0327874273,
-0.0592752211,
0.0350554362,
-0.0405638255,
0.004435516,
0.0348765291,
0.0006662487,
-0.0075288643,
-0.0206744317,
-0.0584776774,
-0.0239301398,
0.0435830727,
-0.0411190949,
0.0144613888,
0.0392304473,
0.0125916768,
-0.0412057713,
0.016468009,
0.0061979694,
0.0208700858,
0.0661540926,
0.0035693329,
-0.0664557964,
0.0694268122,
-0.0125875277,
0.0252866931,
0.0079019601,
-0.0134630408,
0.0364351273,
-0.000311559,
0.0559235662,
0.0407538377,
-0.0037775468,
0.0367246717,
0.0153998742,
-0.0000743085,
-0.0606135353,
0.0333086997,
-0.0495344885,
-0.0155431246,
-0.0135094728,
-0.0268010721,
0.0465601273,
0.0455358066,
0.0416132696,
0.0119778346,
-0.0936267748,
0.0235178657,
-0.0162108392,
-0.0447858907,
-0.0073146825,
0.0003904579,
-0.009449238,
-0.0056286268,
-0.0275973994,
-0.0512182564,
0.0429768227,
-0.0350930765,
0.0069737802,
-0.0464137867,
-0.0072364616,
-0.0137353679,
0.0452119447,
0.0219617244,
0.042617403,
0.036378257,
-0.0115226172,
-0.0493235029,
0.017881548,
0.0115299011,
-0.0073504252,
0.0021023459,
-0.0562813394,
-0.000786032,
-0.0125190448,
-0.0487042293,
-0.068219386,
-0.0297856629,
0.0189277735,
0.0095750513,
0.0736682713,
-0.0259178728,
-0.012137779,
-0.0219667815,
0.0069280928,
0.071487844,
-0.0139790438,
-0.0127665745,
-0.0692386255,
-0.0050009065,
0.0648283139,
0.0300179385,
-0.0528752916,
-0.0463729315,
-0.0133668985,
0.0231954642,
0.0046960851,
-0.0021567692,
-0.0195091888,
0.0238895714,
-0.0059681889,
-0.0383111797,
0.030292118,
0.0549936704,
0.0664555952,
-0.061237976,
-0.0445759557,
0.102943331,
0.0404584669,
-0.0119543979,
0.010532531,
0.0306619648,
0.0525521375,
0.0183282588,
0.0367890187,
-0.0654449537,
-0.038445197,
0.0038448563,
0.0461414978,
0.017143162,
0.0033188593,
-0.0454722457,
-0.0974050686,
0.0182307959,
0.0292022116,
-0.0217350256,
-0.0271328762,
-0.0065840599,
-0.0428453833,
-0.0027923346,
0.0012147863,
0.0134841455,
-0.019901026,
0.0372893438,
0.0433073491,
0.0063289478,
-0.057354413,
-0.0296788849,
-0.0265755169,
0.0463867784,
0.056855157,
-0.0022772546,
0.0158968996,
0.0161519255,
0.0132147269,
0.0391385853,
0.0274867397,
-0.0307296906,
0.0159561802,
-0.0082879076,
-0.0320292003,
-0.0201661363,
0.0824242979,
-0.0161375552,
-0.0149247032,
0.0316991769,
0.016955765,
-0.0211385321,
-0.0159335993,
-0.0032175111,
0.0041491394,
0.0720268711,
0.0552373677,
0.034389779,
-0.0681041479,
-0.0403496623,
-0.0444614068,
0.0100517096,
-0.1258483678,
-0.0303900316,
-0.0000767189,
-0.0210272335,
0.0259627961,
-0.1066371053,
-0.033371415,
0.0550715514,
0.0449390598,
0.0309647713,
-0.0448355265,
0.0230435934,
-0.0442350097,
-0.0460730456,
0.0089597236,
-0.023836514,
-0.0153427972,
-0.0524773672,
-0.0621695258,
0.0025172236,
-0.053367503,
0.0060192258,
0.0504545793,
-0.0547780581,
-0.0680322647,
-0.0397054404,
0.0761377513,
0.0080345431,
0.0485666096,
0.0005601392,
-0.0447603837,
0.0105270036,
0.0269060656,
-0.0459009148,
0.0138916178,
0.0129556861,
-0.0069709523,
-0.0073347408,
0.0160995182,
-0.0414930172,
0.0271310378,
0.0265542865,
0.0688536391,
0.0006893242,
-0.0135338781,
0.0641156659,
-0.0232971627,
-0.0098429853,
-0.071045354,
0.0073489556,
-0.0265555829,
-0.0097437883,
-0.0320738815,
-0.0201981105,
-0.0535568707,
0.0365470126,
-0.0060714665,
0.0148865916,
0.0245246664,
-0.0032502038,
-0.0166374035,
0.0431610383,
-0.048641216,
-0.0007704106,
-0.0126546919,
-0.0123479972,
0.0256993677,
-0.0042970576,
-0.0157256238,
0.0501895882,
-0.0360519737,
0.0194596071,
-0.0023972688,
0.0418582261,
0.0408506058,
0.0155439312,
-0.0184197854,
0.0039383187,
0.002241059,
0.0132940598,
-0.0522482246,
-0.0217555538,
0.05576922,
0.0000993196,
0.0395944901,
-0.0536174104,
0.0105670048,
-0.0072461828,
0.0519166924,
0.0177984182,
-0.0328750238,
-0.010663664,
0.0071150446,
-0.0022053716,
-0.0234674867,
0.0923717842,
0.0618288778,
0.0304307733,
0.0098933941,
0.0277685914,
-0.0748914108,
-0.0425277911,
0.0278432071,
-0.0026584931,
0.0006934633,
0.0122462763,
0.0071493085,
-0.0411806516,
0.0101974979,
0.0194307864,
-0.019825466,
0.0070070508,
0.0681217089,
-0.0036469656,
-0.0562727377,
-0.0082698287,
-0.0316252448,
-0.0050073727,
0.0019265891,
-0.0435986072,
-0.0343652554,
-6.132575701e-33,
-0.0284831189,
-0.0541003719,
0.041926235,
-0.024512196,
-0.0003720097,
-0.0015518748,
-0.0417295955,
-0.0046035014,
0.0669940338,
0.0093951421,
-0.0010708609,
-0.035296347,
0.0001101165,
0.0524753109,
-0.0027117433,
-0.0044213445,
0.047500398,
-0.0209292807,
-0.0633281097,
0.0448514484,
0.0347445719,
0.0274402909,
0.0238929875,
-0.048840154,
0.0246499833,
-0.026763048,
-0.063255392,
0.0036835747,
0.0012858635,
0.0452453755,
-0.0328750871,
0.0098581286,
0.0050261575,
-0.0322133005,
-0.054485321,
0.0617433563,
-0.0409157276,
-0.0190341212,
0.0067952927,
-0.0181595348,
-0.05856039,
-0.058648102,
0.0072240299,
-0.0481428802,
-0.0220494326,
0.044999972,
0.027998725,
-0.003589412,
0.0063322643,
-0.0587610081,
-0.0791435316,
-0.0006127309,
-0.0202573296,
-0.0446419455,
0.0076660076,
0.0592321791,
-0.0278160125,
-0.0519963391,
-0.0151265906,
0.0339444764,
0.0441218466,
0.0515687503,
0.0371672623,
0.0227300152,
-0.016066948,
0.048457019,
-0.0443085283,
-0.0068794326,
-0.0238473918,
0.0095232716,
0.0030100385,
0.0407950245,
0.0414592326,
0.0355352014,
0.0211822838,
0.0026961244,
-0.0563696325,
0.0210903641,
-0.0341861621,
0.0016274067,
0.0353026539,
-0.0102538774,
-0.0396986566,
0.0006834188,
-0.0337877646,
0.0466045141,
-0.0118926801,
-0.0310423151,
0.0758502185,
0.0790896192,
-0.0502661653,
-0.0094847381,
0.0261904951,
0.0044555254,
0.0018887147,
0.0118372142,
-0.0274882372,
-0.0052225296,
-0.0271043107,
-0.0140059441,
-0.0605287924,
-0.0612154417,
0.0710430145,
0.0047613927,
0.0222630519,
0.0096214944,
0.0162696987,
0.0519022457,
-0.0417404696,
0.0365554318,
-0.0308813173,
0.062506564,
0.017597992,
0.0019945882,
0.0227810517,
-0.0197601914,
-0.0276401471,
0.0240678601,
0.0027667484,
-0.067061305,
-0.0314524211,
-0.0173896383,
0.0239490662,
0.0241418369,
-0.0339398384,
0.0287789013,
-0.0195683446,
0.0068106856,
-0.006658149,
-0.0342350975,
0.0020958919,
0.0211374946,
2.582e-7,
-0.0033922065,
0.0553469248,
0.0318686254,
0.0521605313,
0.0033279618,
0.0047235894,
0.0123637067,
0.0365018807,
-0.0258432757,
-0.0353373364,
0.0114609748,
0.0285563916,
0.049304679,
-0.0030623381,
-0.0670820475,
0.03917896,
-0.0338035971,
0.0117179947,
-0.0647697523,
-0.0280570015,
0.0906326845,
0.0434281863,
-0.0413184389,
0.0353537276,
0.0167478845,
-0.0547252148,
0.0602102838,
-0.0030230924,
-0.0074529639,
0.0133175161,
0.0144940857,
0.0011588831,
-0.0394568071,
-0.0007125387,
-0.0381702632,
-0.0154637964,
0.0207873341,
0.0854339153,
0.0215861294,
-0.008886056,
0.0180959366,
0.0021014321,
0.0028641559,
0.0032296213,
0.0417747498,
-0.0682458952,
0.0172699336,
0.0075244377,
0.0149877155,
-0.0080956472,
-0.0365185663,
-0.0445052758,
-0.0295007098,
0.0156047456,
0.0374711268,
0.0280717406,
-0.0190256182,
-0.0505538359,
-0.0359193459,
-0.0043135346,
-0.0396894179,
0.0173101518,
-0.0666538924,
0.0286449175,
-0.024685584,
-0.0450623296,
-0.0021303669,
2.63118477e-34,
0.0135983806,
-0.0101599591,
0.0161521379,
0.0014398197,
0.0200971421,
0.0214675106,
-0.0476818383,
0.0246305596,
0.0443404987,
-0.0601218753,
-0.0335070156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14286v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14286v1 | Semantic Frame Induction with Deep Metric Learning | 2023-04-27T15:46:09 | 2023-04-27T15:46:09 | Kosuke Yamada, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have demonstrated the usefulness of contextualized word
embeddings in unsupervised semantic frame induction. However, they have also
revealed that generic contextualized embeddings are not always consistent with
human intuitions about semantic frames, which causes unsatisfactory performance
for frame induction based on contextualized embeddings. In this paper, we
address supervised semantic frame induction, which assumes the existence of
frame-annotated data for a subset of predicates in a corpus and aims to build a
frame induction model that leverages the annotated data. We propose a model
that uses deep metric learning to fine-tune a contextualized embedding model,
and we apply the fine-tuned contextualized embeddings to perform semantic frame
induction. Our experiments on FrameNet show that fine-tuning with deep metric
learning considerably improves the clustering evaluation scores, namely, the
B-cubed F-score and Purity F-score, by about 8 points or more. We also
demonstrate that our approach is effective even when the number of training
instances is small. | [
-0.0362715945,
-0.0086580906,
0.0161278825,
0.0544420891,
0.004901953,
0.0315356366,
0.0115680452,
-0.0171041097,
0.0440989695,
-0.0518519208,
0.0046839863,
-0.0155423032,
-0.0240493678,
0.0348408595,
0.0137415007,
-0.0596335754,
0.0569349118,
0.0493702553,
0.0058628386,
0.0290682372,
-0.0349919796,
-0.0044529694,
-0.0328109935,
0.0281564426,
-0.0711185485,
-0.006579909,
0.0105363596,
-0.0118037891,
0.0059047299,
-0.0359529927,
-0.0052479189,
0.0447415523,
0.0512793623,
0.0125100939,
0.0000017649,
-0.040070761,
-0.0067614126,
-0.0072825938,
-0.019080231,
-0.0231121052,
0.0182989743,
-0.04330796,
-0.0031417406,
-0.0227878578,
-0.0431027599,
-0.0817208961,
0.030054152,
0.0221945606,
0.0501664728,
0.0638542324,
-0.0384338871,
-0.0168577321,
0.0058401134,
0.000224071,
-0.0319525748,
-0.0117920358,
0.0027854205,
0.0525796488,
-0.0329470746,
-0.0039017128,
-0.0555030517,
-0.0157112833,
-0.0001240411,
0.0047530355,
0.0027496153,
0.0421744622,
-0.0597367659,
-0.0188366435,
0.006092893,
0.1007915661,
0.0180543121,
0.0093821893,
-0.0102871554,
0.005304541,
0.0255332254,
-0.0110792937,
-0.0324598812,
-0.0057411017,
0.0215248894,
0.0255527589,
0.0069863093,
0.0354779363,
0.0425416157,
-0.0155969523,
-0.0385148488,
0.0707218274,
-0.0094035612,
-0.0047886814,
0.0136486823,
0.0144234616,
-0.0211825967,
0.0047108778,
-0.0522006452,
-0.0257549249,
0.0126687903,
0.0163947809,
-0.0104496069,
-0.0084124571,
-0.0154781118,
0.010381191,
-0.0862905309,
0.0064217574,
-0.0013178934,
0.0794287845,
-0.0918785632,
-0.0003701168,
-0.0170879662,
0.0297101736,
-0.021220874,
-0.0021884863,
-0.0310098305,
0.0109325452,
-0.0469386168,
0.0405535549,
-0.0160636343,
-0.0417007506,
-0.033348348,
0.0308687463,
-0.014035373,
0.0139989294,
-0.0379297398,
0.0288879704,
0.0207105298,
-0.0046610739,
-0.039563667,
-0.0492741205,
-0.0697577447,
0.051862698,
-0.0117054842,
-0.0371379368,
-0.0097849602,
0.026446769,
0.0369647034,
-0.0031824789,
-0.0110040251,
0.0097664231,
-0.0019099697,
-0.0196975973,
-0.0281148832,
-0.0539828353,
-0.0240094084,
-0.0109142624,
-0.0459511876,
-0.1047335863,
0.0314226933,
0.0127478074,
0.0209678486,
-0.0305418428,
-0.0049993088,
-0.019904498,
-0.0197700989,
0.0708543658,
-0.0351010375,
-0.0095471721,
0.0193434991,
-0.0027007388,
0.0110209342,
0.0911843181,
0.0150783788,
0.0382139981,
0.0774820521,
0.010419107,
-0.0602757409,
-0.0007451962,
0.0172100011,
0.0223603081,
0.0354170017,
-0.0254148543,
0.0307966601,
0.0647486597,
0.0099520478,
-0.0057943435,
-0.0598824322,
0.0070860931,
-0.026167402,
0.0386100672,
0.0462647043,
-0.0052624247,
0.0667306259,
-0.0106582157,
-0.038502153,
0.0093864854,
-0.0195107795,
0.0036559009,
0.0624048039,
-0.0092696315,
0.0474761389,
-0.0157579575,
-0.0249565132,
-0.0368701033,
0.0240536574,
-0.0298660882,
0.001741766,
-0.0466432422,
0.0715366229,
0.0842643678,
-0.0309489779,
0.0973817408,
0.0467355885,
-0.050032597,
0.0224817283,
0.0272202995,
0.0350870825,
0.0103878379,
0.0251083802,
-0.0695193931,
-0.0177326258,
-0.0062829494,
0.0405733027,
0.0083838152,
0.0741367117,
-0.0375030972,
-0.0144347548,
-0.0623798147,
-0.0176388007,
-0.0169459563,
0.0032527945,
0.0041562682,
-0.0188124273,
-0.007893228,
0.0283956304,
-0.0181434285,
-0.0075465986,
0.0483378023,
0.0437781848,
-0.0084478641,
0.0232283156,
0.0625400394,
0.0043329764,
0.0211103894,
0.0171583183,
-0.0287715495,
0.0266474821,
-0.0583888628,
-0.0149313696,
0.0222581066,
-0.0717638507,
-0.0605074465,
0.0140578197,
-0.0733246878,
-0.0013436769,
-0.0189311039,
-0.066514045,
-0.035798721,
0.0082856799,
0.0151371779,
0.0537521467,
-0.0327480584,
-0.0321503542,
-0.009206689,
0.0079898182,
-0.0220234338,
0.0846279189,
0.0053527495,
0.0310539268,
-0.0211539622,
0.001650665,
0.054162506,
-0.0097691538,
-0.0047101406,
-0.0163236447,
-0.0404982753,
-0.0032023222,
0.0434289649,
-0.0402971506,
-0.0714182258,
-0.0046569444,
-0.0886053741,
0.0065948237,
0.0064845216,
-0.0144620668,
0.0358631797,
-0.0015295524,
-0.0017284945,
-0.0225953814,
-0.0378119908,
-0.0068979124,
-0.0274417307,
-0.0151850553,
0.0523302108,
0.0049358988,
-0.0107035972,
-0.0065545337,
-0.0045345831,
-0.0631870404,
0.049967017,
0.0142342979,
-0.0051395511,
0.0063492642,
0.0296847429,
0.0260899905,
-0.0022597131,
-0.008893691,
0.0099200457,
0.0087307617,
-0.0424989313,
-0.029968977,
0.0583930835,
0.004442032,
0.0278676152,
0.0383916534,
0.0248838905,
-0.0403389782,
0.0050999168,
-0.0341634005,
0.0364934988,
-0.0570023358,
-0.019862555,
0.0000131934,
0.0145506999,
0.0072398372,
-0.0026100108,
-0.0551845953,
0.050966166,
-0.038490504,
-0.0129033485,
-0.06238297,
0.0117407972,
0.0096484972,
0.0476731099,
-0.0313520283,
-0.0251672454,
0.0281632226,
-0.0094035091,
-0.0114084752,
-0.0165222194,
0.0257387664,
-0.0238903407,
0.0035224599,
-0.007567381,
0.0490594804,
-0.0314774327,
-0.0309611484,
-0.0272642672,
0.0094301691,
0.0183092766,
0.0072797737,
0.0305273458,
0.0413432121,
-0.0176911,
-0.0120616499,
-0.0240805466,
-0.0456881225,
-0.0213530809,
-0.0190242231,
0.006693047,
-0.0366502516,
0.0152861523,
-0.009771144,
-0.0092460085,
-0.0220887829,
-0.0060597453,
0.0034862147,
-0.0162510611,
-0.04678455,
0.0726965591,
0.016333757,
0.0202829055,
0.0185068902,
-0.0011888307,
0.0506270304,
0.05177496,
-0.008444313,
0.0512695536,
-0.070511207,
0.0105907284,
-0.0225528702,
-0.0037686771,
0.0013575028,
-0.017097583,
0.0003271799,
-0.0182414651,
-0.0087091094,
0.1296676844,
0.0679361671,
0.0022517627,
-0.010355643,
0.0165916923,
0.0313456319,
0.0452312119,
-0.0340155289,
-0.0781374574,
-0.0438043512,
0.0012049165,
-0.0089130215,
0.0183500573,
-0.0499259718,
0.0122355903,
-0.0749358013,
0.0254103094,
0.022289969,
0.0007215852,
-0.0136829242,
-0.0532750562,
-0.0105023384,
-0.0190193076,
0.0012166606,
-0.0405750163,
0.0276012234,
-0.0269792993,
0.0255518965,
-0.037981309,
-0.047212597,
0.0022369307,
-0.0720443726,
0.0112109138,
-0.0338895358,
0.0456354804,
-0.0507981591,
0.0203122571,
-0.0357212424,
-0.0019566652,
-0.0169400945,
0.0246227589,
0.0527153276,
-0.0264945012,
-0.0276335888,
0.0261278227,
0.0353975743,
-0.0684942305,
-0.0166637581,
-0.008738149,
0.0879529417,
0.0035573286,
0.0199989136,
0.0204484854,
-0.0164955519,
-0.0316862091,
0.0578377545,
0.0075417762,
0.0045273346,
0.0441413857,
-0.0091082761,
0.0373743959,
-0.0145136081,
0.0012456757,
-0.0204556845,
-0.0105001787,
0.0139377164,
-0.1008234397,
-0.042066168,
0.0551270321,
0.0441467129,
0.0092221415,
-0.0244194791,
0.0252076127,
-0.0202128589,
-0.1082363501,
0.0504465513,
-0.0170446374,
-0.0117011387,
-0.0196342338,
0.0185843278,
0.0532327853,
0.0139832115,
-0.0428480878,
0.0379111916,
0.0345708951,
-0.043023359,
-0.0064860624,
0.0017860036,
-0.0079313144,
0.0418682694,
-0.0564954989,
0.0142254513,
0.0541809835,
0.0636333004,
-0.0515599325,
-0.0225024559,
0.0319351293,
-0.0675971359,
-0.0136671709,
0.0189968757,
-0.0540892147,
0.0040181377,
-0.0049714027,
0.0071578491,
-0.0326506607,
0.0156717151,
0.0244704913,
-0.0142199676,
0.06405247,
-0.0333515555,
0.0157640148,
-0.046448227,
-0.0024688512,
0.0013946313,
-0.0148240747,
0.0191713069,
0.0019696786,
0.0335839503,
0.0052766362,
-0.0118155507,
0.0759001076,
0.0070700226,
-0.0020034136,
0.0383750983,
0.0167438406,
-0.0024139499,
0.0704774782,
0.0112398854,
0.0177305713,
-0.027471194,
-0.026221104,
-0.0240995493,
0.0076869028,
-0.0707008243,
0.0042269593,
0.0342457667,
-0.0074203983,
-0.0539922453,
0.059605483,
0.0075148637,
0.0227633379,
-0.0407876931,
-0.0057061538,
0.049645979,
-0.070780918,
0.0021986878,
-0.0190799348,
-0.034327846,
-0.0001479082,
0.0024220732,
0.0249387864,
-0.0000759744,
0.0359982438,
0.0395493396,
-0.02163307,
0.0387169272,
0.0346946679,
-0.0693224445,
0.048953943,
0.0279766805,
-0.0266273171,
-0.0625728294,
0.0106610265,
-0.0026256486,
0.0577688888,
-0.0131394872,
0.0318049341,
-0.0160979107,
-0.0406360887,
0.0356342196,
0.0138192279,
-0.0536512844,
0.0624855272,
0.0466042869,
0.0448787846,
0.0262119751,
0.0010818254,
-0.0321628302,
-0.0168958362,
-0.0184043124,
-0.0119231101,
0.0251556765,
-5.528574378e-33,
-0.0170897562,
-0.011354561,
-0.0376208499,
0.0372581556,
-0.005881581,
0.0127409808,
-0.0131691545,
0.003770459,
-0.0117832236,
0.0713383406,
0.0356915817,
-0.0057133688,
0.0076491786,
0.0082697431,
-0.0535885841,
0.0028131874,
0.0012293321,
0.0019773177,
-0.008775508,
0.0301905666,
0.0724274889,
0.0162510183,
0.0317655131,
-0.0624497198,
-0.0081870519,
0.0137366029,
0.0094379988,
0.0301223937,
0.06364429,
0.0415613241,
-0.0353960954,
0.0334580727,
0.0520790368,
-0.0150965611,
-0.0124024041,
0.0648308694,
-0.1105166748,
-0.0388096943,
-0.0154811665,
0.0149841635,
-0.0448972769,
-0.0273707565,
0.0116824079,
0.0298219491,
0.0143966256,
-0.0063066809,
0.0676146001,
-0.0275583435,
-0.0467876866,
0.0091703171,
-0.0542752258,
0.0238838326,
-0.0368202403,
0.0089500723,
0.0507124513,
-0.0126054771,
0.0304586273,
0.0253329221,
-0.0263936371,
0.0232654475,
-0.0752007663,
0.0373960808,
-0.0065919659,
0.0139830057,
0.0203229655,
0.0622133501,
0.0078542531,
-0.0263761692,
-0.0289240777,
-0.0025432159,
0.0580232628,
0.0338405147,
0.0349108167,
0.0852890685,
-0.0198041052,
0.0005750512,
-0.0920464322,
0.0497231036,
-0.0434299149,
0.0154666696,
0.0045125741,
0.0012812426,
-0.0417834669,
0.0022667488,
-0.0793045908,
-0.0266026761,
-0.0175601877,
-0.0040933425,
0.0009076679,
0.0020629573,
-0.0271627828,
-0.0161163025,
0.0081072683,
-0.0519831441,
0.0370119326,
-0.0005926157,
0.0184617713,
0.0047312691,
-0.0061288821,
0.00622153,
-0.0062235077,
-0.0415427759,
0.0416195914,
0.0124212727,
0.0509619042,
-0.0083723962,
0.063027963,
0.0088461153,
-0.0507660247,
0.0027967114,
-0.0209141895,
-0.0387267359,
-0.0161476023,
-0.0428040661,
0.0062857415,
0.0415550172,
-0.0208242461,
0.0793871805,
0.0409069993,
0.0349254608,
-0.0023533122,
0.0095821321,
0.0096835736,
0.0419940054,
-0.0636655986,
-0.0529160947,
-0.0244811457,
0.0025686014,
0.0954502672,
-0.0766792372,
-0.0147974137,
-0.0374611355,
2.393e-7,
0.0244387966,
0.0351153091,
0.0486432575,
-0.0352863334,
-0.0000740413,
0.0413252898,
-0.0044224178,
0.0397676975,
-0.0315248854,
-0.0416716412,
0.0654333979,
0.0162986778,
-0.0006168281,
0.0196561031,
-0.0889790207,
0.0918191671,
-0.009508457,
-0.0012306034,
-0.02947185,
-0.0141715948,
0.0114732254,
0.1034525484,
0.0064454805,
0.0027318075,
0.0246217567,
-0.0685068741,
0.0327373706,
-0.0228136014,
-0.0161561128,
0.0240783468,
-0.0009884158,
0.0686568692,
-0.0012527446,
0.0067486782,
-0.0041175894,
0.0247113891,
0.0461990573,
0.0071893558,
-0.0044306894,
-0.0197189581,
-0.0274887644,
-0.0272470638,
0.0181036852,
-0.0247897655,
0.0481492244,
-0.0580099151,
-0.0077847145,
-0.0248105209,
-0.0512808189,
0.0292721167,
0.0141106471,
-0.0007656435,
-0.0079121031,
0.0262062456,
0.0595945641,
0.0041611991,
0.0153473793,
-0.0964996964,
0.0211693887,
0.0167528484,
-0.0169658381,
-0.0213449132,
0.0369250029,
-0.0416724309,
0.0242929906,
-0.0067265881,
0.0310368482,
1.830727989e-34,
-0.0054379231,
0.0438660309,
0.0371932536,
-0.0217960235,
0.0256093964,
-0.0396704599,
-0.02670631,
-0.0372400209,
0.0345461965,
-0.0632278621,
0.0295712482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14241v1 | Entity-Level Sentiment Analysis (ELSA): An exploratory task survey | 2023-04-27T15:01:20 | 2023-04-27T15:01:20 | Egil Rønningstad, Erik Velldal, Lilja Øvrelid | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the task of identifying the overall sentiment expressed
towards volitional entities (persons and organizations) in a document -- what
we refer to as Entity-Level Sentiment Analysis (ELSA). While identifying
sentiment conveyed towards an entity is well researched for shorter texts like
tweets, we find little to no research on this specific task for longer texts
with multiple mentions and opinions towards the same entity. This lack of
research would be understandable if ELSA can be derived from existing tasks and
models. To assess this, we annotate a set of professional reviews for their
overall sentiment towards each volitional entity in the text. We sample from
data already annotated for document-level, sentence-level, and target-level
sentiment in a multi-domain review corpus, and our results indicate that there
is no single proxy task that provides this overall sentiment we seek for the
entities at a satisfactory level of performance. We present a suite of
experiments aiming to assess the contribution towards ELSA provided by
document-, sentence-, and target-level sentiment analysis, and provide a
discussion of their shortcomings. We show that sentiment in our dataset is
expressed not only with an entity mention as target, but also towards targets
with a sentiment-relevant relation to a volitional entity. In our data, these
relations extend beyond anaphoric coreference resolution, and our findings call
for further research of the topic. Finally, we also present a survey of
previous relevant work. | [
0.079062745,
0.0477581806,
0.0015485521,
0.0033917204,
-0.0338490047,
0.0109638972,
-0.0132392114,
0.001145566,
0.0082467683,
-0.058463145,
-0.0340056904,
0.0288857203,
-0.0503989086,
0.0032005322,
-0.0254016127,
-0.0173430406,
0.0299299546,
0.0479590781,
0.0708349124,
-0.0167699363,
0.0518255457,
0.0366302691,
-0.0054433779,
0.0281292722,
0.0051211887,
-0.0097862156,
0.0249229725,
-0.0032002931,
0.0307837743,
0.0003913131,
0.0218968149,
0.0545016974,
-0.016620677,
0.0012702232,
0.0000018446,
-0.0319697484,
-0.020645719,
-0.0206782445,
0.0297382716,
0.0038905006,
0.0787664428,
-0.0135649312,
0.0109900953,
-0.017823441,
-0.0169916302,
-0.0186017081,
-0.0085006356,
0.0537274964,
0.0571075641,
0.0353835225,
-0.0259313751,
-0.0133664282,
-0.0469868258,
-0.0105492799,
-0.0668001026,
0.004035783,
-0.0072829532,
-0.028907083,
-0.0324625224,
0.0395931341,
0.0277827717,
0.0098264916,
-0.0270801503,
-0.0115565574,
0.0392052941,
-0.0086274222,
-0.0001563679,
-0.0034230512,
0.0150308153,
0.0343588814,
0.0861972421,
0.0184337068,
0.0160502438,
0.0137176486,
0.0115256598,
0.0127878506,
0.0293949433,
-0.0154130841,
-0.013940868,
0.007849142,
0.0064052255,
0.0564780645,
-0.0154432813,
0.0392678902,
-0.0034375598,
0.024256859,
-0.0158219021,
-0.043358352,
0.0619384758,
0.0748908669,
0.0018991316,
-0.0356578603,
0.031512998,
-0.039236635,
-0.0169939864,
0.0119738737,
-0.0174634587,
-0.0268344674,
0.0342545286,
-0.0901367366,
-0.0049129166,
-0.0169870127,
0.0089284731,
0.0389807969,
0.0284226034,
-0.0244313106,
-0.0144913942,
-0.0181861799,
-0.0116765117,
-0.0037266375,
-0.0607673265,
0.0241409186,
-0.000234549,
0.0673565641,
-0.029176265,
0.0059510954,
-0.0748942196,
-0.0318408795,
-0.0587161593,
-0.0030641477,
-0.0230872426,
0.0086288108,
0.0168381296,
0.0144522516,
-0.0495434366,
0.0462242588,
-0.0725029558,
0.0416871682,
-0.0749911591,
0.0213386454,
0.0414912105,
0.0268755071,
0.0015375672,
-0.0275334287,
0.0157951415,
0.0859472305,
0.065941304,
-0.0477309451,
0.0046504349,
-0.0245303046,
-0.0151287112,
-0.0772789493,
-0.013908308,
-0.041363664,
0.0257027466,
0.0134226428,
-0.0219898652,
-0.0077139428,
0.0280732773,
0.0064908019,
-0.0390647985,
0.0480226874,
-0.0104043726,
-0.0141573232,
-0.0078798328,
-0.0030332815,
0.0181936715,
0.0374658182,
-0.0007397521,
0.0460932031,
0.03600673,
0.0179592092,
-0.0121284034,
0.0002365758,
0.0217054896,
-0.0150557952,
0.0095669786,
0.012418176,
-0.1048467085,
-0.0044359374,
0.006414941,
0.0454848856,
0.0015526278,
-0.0231312495,
0.0173459742,
0.0259925146,
-0.0555063672,
0.0067796949,
-0.0290963836,
-0.0017264416,
0.002518004,
0.006837632,
-0.0311523173,
0.0410919413,
0.0171339102,
-0.035432782,
0.0268107951,
0.0052579693,
-0.0105936797,
-0.0721588507,
-0.010858885,
0.0093270177,
-0.0207729638,
-0.0150254304,
0.0656049624,
-0.0110342326,
-0.0580981299,
-0.0118392855,
0.0315437987,
-0.0652791038,
0.0041187322,
0.0053319894,
0.0050684446,
0.0727778599,
0.0132384533,
0.0097743059,
-0.0334070548,
-0.0481132604,
-0.0394742303,
0.042013403,
0.0147837708,
-0.0039801844,
-0.0149787581,
-0.0030907821,
0.012055154,
0.0018872414,
0.0072108847,
0.027758047,
0.003360122,
0.0316479802,
-0.0202889889,
-0.024174884,
-0.0018365658,
0.0063697589,
0.0388235636,
0.0162104815,
0.0175887011,
0.0297726709,
0.0294904094,
0.0729081333,
-0.022767758,
-0.012837532,
0.0235066302,
-0.0147704342,
-0.0581259057,
0.0238662455,
0.0367869064,
-0.012152086,
-0.0168320052,
-0.0729810521,
-0.0619085021,
-0.0077132639,
0.0133725768,
-0.038219694,
0.0336137861,
0.0115323709,
0.0229843017,
-0.0290415827,
-0.0355892777,
-0.0260653663,
-0.0288692284,
-0.0251941383,
0.0651315153,
0.0018087737,
-0.0113054588,
0.0003839454,
-0.0620154254,
0.009966027,
0.0264403634,
-0.0646569207,
-0.0277848504,
0.0364719592,
-0.0021712072,
0.0676982701,
-0.0367660224,
-0.0543996729,
-0.0571309887,
-0.0990146101,
-0.0037080103,
-0.0117057776,
0.0248896442,
0.0018263876,
-0.0086648967,
0.011252014,
0.0379452445,
-0.0047591128,
-0.0112541066,
-0.0074098231,
0.0006604897,
0.0440342613,
0.009047362,
0.0383966416,
-0.0777726322,
0.0113305356,
-0.0426237918,
-0.0115688927,
0.0359800719,
-0.066102773,
-0.0255972408,
0.0709264725,
-0.0623280108,
-0.0075780102,
0.0157819912,
-0.0217535049,
0.014301857,
-0.0042969305,
0.0127571626,
0.0067253816,
0.0036968205,
0.0514449142,
0.0121117122,
-0.0193638075,
-0.0544582084,
0.0351924375,
-0.0430433862,
0.0507366955,
-0.0233494639,
-0.0090450356,
0.0316531658,
0.048139099,
0.0101330187,
-0.0268981121,
-0.0459112152,
-0.0057106051,
-0.0533850454,
0.000235398,
0.0171489902,
-0.002810271,
0.0194821898,
0.0116233286,
0.0381210521,
-0.0137739275,
0.044169575,
0.0334667712,
0.0181228649,
-0.0390698351,
0.0096886819,
-0.0507844426,
0.0559266731,
-0.0102563761,
0.0000491246,
0.0218595713,
-0.0102400286,
0.020241024,
-0.011503309,
-0.0263544414,
0.0097809844,
0.0525645539,
0.0099112438,
0.0255263373,
0.0346499085,
-0.0375941657,
0.036096368,
0.0030413312,
-0.0539200343,
-0.0366624668,
0.0245807227,
-0.0178774819,
-0.0118818777,
-0.023078423,
-0.0328227617,
-0.0643355548,
-0.0018190063,
-0.0300530605,
0.0190477055,
-0.0172746181,
0.0381499976,
-0.0024099916,
0.0386217125,
-0.0005905059,
-0.0430521108,
0.0451305993,
-0.0015411794,
-0.0114583196,
-0.0487077236,
-0.0682539046,
0.003327627,
-0.04075348,
-0.0219090302,
-0.094094716,
0.0522713475,
-0.0045563178,
0.0253240336,
0.0888900012,
0.0279859062,
-0.0303289946,
-0.0194411576,
0.0398811437,
0.0138433529,
0.0325940102,
0.0133899096,
-0.0431019031,
-0.0369113944,
-0.0410816707,
0.0030440169,
-0.0217455607,
-0.0398345366,
0.0092114862,
-0.0783753544,
0.0238121916,
-0.0531417653,
0.003341445,
-0.0064849793,
-0.0102141956,
0.0204185657,
-0.0331937,
-0.0393331908,
-0.0574626178,
-0.0009363214,
0.0264369063,
-0.0184120405,
-0.0393587425,
0.0104996758,
0.0571346842,
-0.0364338979,
0.0297997687,
0.0585515201,
0.0779288113,
-0.0013365363,
0.0489541031,
-0.0227431245,
-0.0194457658,
-0.0133025656,
-0.0075721573,
0.0941119045,
-0.0499616526,
-0.0092050955,
-0.023247771,
0.0130072599,
-0.0410323702,
0.0339982025,
0.0208034758,
-0.0003050498,
-0.004951071,
-0.0066279569,
-0.0645079985,
0.045760259,
0.0308699217,
0.0670443848,
-0.0268892273,
-0.0670304745,
-0.0356446169,
-0.0019301885,
0.0261875689,
-0.0564732105,
-0.0176052097,
-0.0351739191,
-0.0147335092,
-0.0095165577,
-0.06263946,
-0.0749221072,
0.0266027283,
0.0199501477,
-0.0039017161,
0.0077179228,
0.0242282562,
0.013425854,
-0.0039924365,
0.0076024495,
0.0102264211,
0.0412555374,
0.0086673396,
-0.0458130278,
0.0795637667,
0.0689891353,
-0.0238760039,
0.0182745513,
-0.0307964031,
-0.0154793514,
-0.0060673417,
0.0251592007,
0.0123870699,
-0.002693048,
-0.0298511125,
0.0025778033,
0.0286724586,
0.0455314033,
-0.0689474046,
0.0056501096,
0.0581838489,
0.0715681165,
0.0075765192,
0.0403482839,
-0.0214012917,
0.0602847598,
0.0157746635,
-0.019181734,
0.0053548752,
-0.0245108865,
0.0005186076,
-0.0356276482,
0.0377827287,
0.010021775,
0.0365535095,
-0.0391018987,
-0.0141139431,
-0.0069069467,
-0.0432453379,
-0.0378287137,
-0.0368130356,
-0.0233488511,
0.0153503269,
-0.0586293042,
0.0053374968,
-0.0269312374,
0.0574448407,
-0.0172940549,
0.0620485023,
0.0598511063,
0.002769554,
-0.0236545745,
-0.0267292745,
-0.0103920475,
-0.0059758164,
0.0309839565,
0.0028403455,
-0.0086249225,
0.010908558,
0.0255925488,
0.0139915748,
-0.0061156983,
-0.0053968271,
-0.0662650913,
0.0384729579,
0.0066673076,
0.0012749765,
0.0033375246,
-0.0172615368,
0.06001544,
-0.0445543304,
0.0259624515,
0.0198349953,
0.0196460225,
-0.0365890376,
0.0178113468,
0.0392412357,
-0.0002726168,
-0.0096507911,
0.0024419385,
0.0294378549,
-0.0387842022,
0.0338733494,
0.0112231756,
-0.0046347161,
-0.0673533976,
-0.0462792479,
-0.0227792524,
-0.0228959545,
0.0138097107,
0.0405597538,
-0.0811505765,
-0.0149743287,
0.0684114695,
-0.0590158179,
0.0064296899,
-0.0267518256,
0.0161334369,
0.0401057824,
0.0480128229,
0.0271679424,
-0.0655095577,
-0.0204852261,
-0.0228676852,
-0.0440865383,
-0.0221786685,
-5.767499115e-33,
-0.0399696603,
-0.03373494,
-0.0380952284,
0.0373068973,
0.0076704333,
0.0071123852,
0.0033462122,
0.0189660136,
0.0110885948,
0.0499694087,
-0.0191549938,
0.0280151404,
0.0048106243,
0.0010025594,
0.0604820251,
-0.0177311078,
0.0321171097,
-0.0135238301,
0.0164116547,
0.0335029922,
0.0398398265,
0.0009000624,
0.0525191911,
-0.1243074909,
0.0958372056,
0.0186080355,
-0.0714320168,
-0.0158956647,
0.0316250734,
0.0419354327,
-0.0224884041,
0.0495496467,
0.0103738923,
-0.0178708676,
0.0236484483,
0.0384161621,
-0.0541835874,
-0.0153088253,
0.0161049999,
-0.0000939,
-0.0350260586,
-0.0308091398,
0.0109042851,
0.0145482728,
-0.0438927971,
0.0032779882,
0.0695417151,
-0.0027462556,
0.0344882458,
-0.0769845098,
-0.0746879801,
0.0239255857,
-0.0133666927,
0.0430900007,
0.021845622,
0.0302914344,
0.0159923807,
0.039806921,
-0.0472797789,
0.0341789164,
-0.0336718336,
-0.0194096975,
-0.0706751272,
-0.0589113496,
0.0142946988,
0.0890591815,
-0.0071440283,
0.0292730518,
-0.0155019211,
0.0426462479,
0.0033335229,
0.0220223628,
0.0080879508,
0.0718809739,
0.0022095193,
-0.0110633336,
-0.0382996127,
0.0146730244,
0.0395700037,
-0.0027176046,
0.0461234301,
-0.0372378044,
-0.034708865,
-0.003683432,
0.0098579163,
-0.0780122057,
-0.0372761786,
-0.0281212442,
-0.0035521858,
-0.0061173118,
-0.0117618637,
-0.0107606882,
-0.0096425209,
-0.0601811856,
-0.0568055063,
0.0493437126,
-0.0371694043,
0.0634408742,
0.0344562605,
-0.0077623809,
-0.0652915835,
0.0074450341,
-0.0415574983,
0.0466982201,
0.0325690806,
0.0065579326,
0.0401410833,
-0.0093946122,
-0.0904833153,
-0.0199001059,
0.0089551546,
0.0120644951,
-0.0688868836,
-0.027989408,
0.0137278829,
0.0143595375,
0.0210206844,
0.0410793722,
0.0297864396,
0.0691964552,
-0.0273316782,
0.0247951262,
0.0319851041,
0.0200517885,
-0.0332895294,
-0.0728483722,
0.0256275907,
-0.0587292276,
-0.022538051,
-0.0402422771,
0.0119810561,
-0.0315377191,
2.736e-7,
0.054922808,
0.0806170478,
-0.0105439685,
-0.0170459766,
-0.0025007178,
0.0562318489,
0.0201682299,
0.0311441645,
-0.0063585825,
-0.0206843335,
0.0179294161,
-0.0263402089,
0.0127709992,
0.0398405828,
-0.130763799,
0.0152869457,
0.0053121983,
0.0141913183,
-0.0209987331,
0.0444531068,
0.0665731579,
0.0668001175,
0.0622665025,
0.0067366278,
-0.0534937941,
0.0340224281,
0.05550557,
-0.0560944192,
-0.0169616826,
0.0309410784,
-0.0177478474,
0.0105290264,
-0.046749793,
0.0074627525,
-0.0032421218,
0.0249247681,
0.0317021161,
0.0635503083,
0.0383462198,
-0.0189441815,
0.0212854352,
0.0185781829,
0.0318489634,
0.0282359831,
0.0247388352,
-0.0498069339,
-0.0425585732,
-0.0839848146,
-0.0016703305,
0.004137455,
0.0262440704,
0.0215528291,
-0.0358945578,
0.0342256688,
-0.028890023,
-0.0403355062,
-0.0341387242,
-0.0797369257,
0.0211436264,
0.0129513005,
0.0156477652,
-0.0195171162,
0.0257234741,
0.0183378495,
0.007544328,
-0.0191393085,
-0.0013493046,
1.904875279e-34,
0.0523173548,
-0.0380138569,
-0.0079684732,
0.0218165573,
0.0228954013,
0.0096894642,
-0.0666011646,
-0.0326941237,
0.0412109196,
-0.026448423,
0.037185885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14238v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14238v2 | The Intended Uses of Automated Fact-Checking Artefacts: Why, How and Who | 2023-04-27T14:55:23 | 2023-11-08T12:10:49 | Michael Schlichtkrull, Nedjma Ousidhoum, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated fact-checking is often presented as an epistemic tool that
fact-checkers, social media consumers, and other stakeholders can use to fight
misinformation. Nevertheless, few papers thoroughly discuss how. We document
this by analysing 100 highly-cited papers, and annotating epistemic elements
related to intended use, i.e., means, ends, and stakeholders. We find that
narratives leaving out some of these aspects are common, that many papers
propose inconsistent means and ends, and that the feasibility of suggested
strategies rarely has empirical backing. We argue that this vagueness actively
hinders the technology from reaching its goals, as it encourages overclaiming,
limits criticism, and prevents stakeholder feedback. Accordingly, we provide
several recommendations for thinking and writing about the use of fact-checking
artefacts. | [
0.0687961802,
0.0155011518,
-0.0044769244,
0.0023054122,
-0.0655487329,
-0.0150857316,
0.0285411887,
-0.0327749215,
-0.0007894638,
-0.0504210591,
0.0728129372,
0.0152060864,
0.0454053991,
0.0186674669,
0.0086926911,
-0.0028272504,
0.012056998,
0.0314371362,
0.0727401897,
0.0006490886,
0.0210229065,
0.0467221178,
-0.0276649781,
0.0211224221,
-0.0789946392,
-0.0103897545,
0.0330725722,
-0.0094607724,
0.01994594,
-0.0415385142,
-0.0166300517,
0.0206731651,
0.0042147944,
0.0997526199,
0.0000019968,
-0.0393893868,
0.0050806198,
0.0467684008,
-0.0758902505,
0.0241649803,
0.0527549535,
0.0078479601,
0.0138062574,
-0.0076866485,
-0.0122200586,
-0.0075369678,
0.0750839934,
0.0031569223,
0.0543702617,
0.070769906,
-0.0056259423,
0.0062807202,
0.0158339851,
0.0252243206,
-0.024862228,
0.0126458248,
0.0253961533,
-0.0027565025,
-0.0387815908,
0.0357703902,
0.0477687791,
0.0797108337,
0.0223103408,
-0.0205091126,
-0.0229844712,
-0.0012832029,
-0.0447571129,
-0.0500620753,
0.0022846165,
-0.0031978453,
0.0981554389,
-0.0206121001,
0.0175898187,
-0.0177969579,
0.0067695505,
0.0528179146,
0.0147282211,
0.033641804,
-0.0543530993,
-0.0126176393,
-0.0355909579,
-0.026535023,
0.0440497175,
0.032296434,
0.0413700826,
0.0439779125,
-0.0433653332,
-0.0244411677,
0.0452956706,
0.0420267656,
0.0515471846,
-0.0328950286,
-0.0270551499,
-0.0094843209,
0.0169817582,
0.0040205885,
0.0134547539,
-0.0063430634,
0.0404246747,
-0.0613490418,
0.0190455243,
0.0074057323,
-0.0581017062,
0.0194379166,
0.0313548334,
-0.0362968929,
-0.0115207508,
0.0179690979,
0.0547313243,
0.0100143412,
0.0096476786,
0.0336677767,
0.017361708,
-0.0160324723,
0.0005811772,
0.0168842189,
0.0168569777,
-0.0520304404,
-0.0350902714,
0.046508912,
-0.0360635519,
0.0166660622,
0.0055553317,
-0.0120897898,
-0.0481769219,
0.0707362741,
-0.014992184,
0.0295980126,
-0.0179914758,
-0.0405419655,
0.0231382325,
0.026769368,
0.0146124465,
0.023493411,
0.0014588042,
-0.0261933375,
0.0146643426,
0.0167721547,
-0.0316745639,
-0.0318751186,
-0.0241944883,
-0.0501532629,
0.0118858255,
-0.036856249,
-0.0009688598,
-0.0039444738,
-0.0065416484,
0.0123231821,
-0.0076751667,
-0.004486178,
-0.0372979045,
0.0374403596,
-0.0544085428,
0.0053985869,
0.0615256354,
0.0049175848,
0.0095483204,
0.0447373278,
0.0007138358,
0.0514101312,
0.0622616857,
0.0803010464,
0.0263986755,
-0.0123821218,
0.0317686722,
0.0245313626,
0.0489087999,
0.0078061637,
-0.0820100382,
-0.0220817067,
-0.0296667702,
0.0504518896,
-0.0105212769,
0.014794671,
0.0623288415,
-0.0283831619,
-0.0406644903,
-0.0387767293,
0.0344362184,
-0.0101297982,
0.0160172731,
0.011374657,
-0.0094836568,
0.0285054296,
-0.0267417729,
-0.0234707985,
-0.0029471165,
0.0338097177,
-0.0033388147,
-0.0294548906,
-0.0245705955,
0.0214172415,
0.0365561619,
0.0412174165,
-0.0488384925,
-0.0123058772,
-0.0004484097,
0.0034412006,
0.0102327112,
0.0020854401,
-0.0075000604,
-0.0639759153,
0.0253946949,
0.0226176158,
0.0073184446,
0.0209035929,
0.0133131333,
-0.0376061127,
0.0437312275,
0.0433336981,
0.0645132065,
-0.0157574564,
-0.0569404997,
0.0028347725,
-0.0389603637,
-0.0754469186,
0.0199318212,
0.017197853,
0.0611460544,
0.0205138382,
0.0002289833,
-0.0080927555,
-0.0430476591,
0.0108192042,
0.034627296,
-0.0028803735,
-0.0521348938,
0.0450790115,
-0.0187955182,
0.0344849527,
-0.0079067899,
-0.0238265172,
0.0217549726,
0.0731478781,
-0.0203894526,
-0.0211134739,
0.0591634139,
0.0871822461,
0.0067930329,
-0.0531045757,
-0.0660626218,
0.0218371917,
-0.0117197512,
0.0473228805,
-0.0205090884,
-0.0249644443,
-0.003153268,
-0.0142511893,
-0.0300889425,
-0.0547131523,
-0.0240548439,
0.0226662476,
0.0118294144,
-0.0321190096,
-0.0237609781,
-0.0279943012,
-0.0415144004,
0.0229295995,
0.0191054754,
-0.0301888715,
0.0137223527,
0.0420502461,
0.026178997,
0.0320847817,
-0.0488892384,
-0.0325938426,
0.0213211253,
-0.041409228,
-0.0384695418,
-0.0088384086,
-0.022477394,
0.004753375,
0.0008109593,
0.0104025006,
0.020214837,
0.0273554381,
-0.0283829756,
-0.010302241,
0.0290022511,
0.0435043238,
0.0249827672,
0.0017888111,
-0.0047781481,
0.0351413973,
-0.0242457427,
-0.0141113168,
0.0790126398,
-0.0539536029,
-0.0446859747,
-0.0297046527,
-0.0777230486,
-0.0117298588,
-0.0072559062,
0.0169561412,
0.0562676787,
0.0417706929,
-0.0356855653,
0.0154259205,
0.0437801853,
0.0548168868,
0.0315301791,
0.0430819578,
0.0181156565,
-0.0145331211,
-0.0191589147,
-0.0080721127,
0.0100117577,
-0.0570948087,
0.0355943963,
-0.0623938516,
0.0375031717,
0.0293261129,
-0.0142742516,
0.0665062219,
-0.0465299748,
-0.0228634533,
0.0189433582,
-0.0395028554,
-0.0051800064,
0.0645796657,
-0.0333863869,
-0.0275335945,
0.0630016476,
-0.0186606962,
0.0376933441,
-0.0164431855,
-0.0164161455,
-0.0043385262,
0.0177618973,
-0.0360604227,
0.0147516504,
0.0365953781,
0.0481188595,
0.0133860568,
-0.0456741303,
0.0680311322,
-0.0212276429,
0.0041231979,
-0.0448208563,
0.029811915,
0.0561094917,
-0.0229852032,
0.0022541238,
-0.0803400427,
-0.0583166219,
-0.0340103619,
-0.0251596831,
-0.0169451628,
-0.0742781609,
-0.0159546118,
0.1103609055,
0.0248397905,
0.0291900914,
-0.0227161944,
0.0460795164,
-0.0422273949,
-0.0210960452,
0.0277135056,
0.1134759411,
0.0018181539,
-0.0370722339,
0.0644843951,
-0.0186306071,
-0.0179481935,
-0.0455327369,
-0.0477709137,
-0.040321935,
0.0084239813,
0.0139608616,
-0.02008125,
0.036463283,
-0.0331417434,
0.0289140958,
0.009665451,
0.0074369223,
0.0283877477,
-0.033171799,
0.0247512665,
-0.0531284474,
0.0173725784,
-0.0143520096,
-0.1152730584,
0.0227850694,
-0.0196645018,
0.0134954415,
-0.061001502,
-0.014784825,
-0.0227789208,
-0.0382155031,
0.061948549,
-0.0032374794,
0.0257572029,
-0.0072758105,
-0.0299711414,
0.0080438219,
0.0027113101,
0.0112513546,
0.0059221741,
0.0440361425,
-0.0256401971,
0.0030036971,
-0.0387564972,
-0.0165676847,
0.0128160464,
-0.0412997864,
0.0090146186,
0.0197730605,
0.0441519432,
-0.0002303487,
-0.0477407537,
-0.0159007963,
0.0148928696,
-0.0569906086,
0.0116726309,
0.0717757866,
-0.0247097928,
0.0008817182,
-0.0417416282,
-0.0221399274,
0.0604332685,
-0.019748725,
-0.0211114641,
0.0317772031,
0.0065062428,
-0.0474219285,
-0.0044224928,
0.0047687683,
0.0213874914,
0.0191347115,
-0.0067791478,
0.0358667932,
0.0057803802,
-0.0362408236,
0.0242281742,
-0.0184943285,
-0.0555114001,
0.0407616086,
0.0159563366,
-0.0500826091,
-0.0290965196,
-0.024115853,
-0.0055680415,
0.0166992061,
-0.0135226408,
-0.0468576252,
0.0472249091,
0.0225859322,
0.0093944753,
0.0177476704,
-0.0184655208,
0.0212307535,
0.0194952451,
-0.015955301,
-0.0227700975,
0.0195586011,
0.0284589361,
0.0438776687,
-0.0037719519,
-0.0303977299,
0.053234119,
0.002193749,
0.0211030748,
0.0370057523,
-0.0156362541,
0.0058983895,
0.0228332821,
0.050747592,
-0.0593471676,
-0.0031105219,
0.0096060103,
-0.0028540394,
-0.0109357852,
-0.0202518087,
0.0041481596,
-0.0182206649,
-0.0215203073,
-0.0254268404,
-0.0452985205,
-0.0222750735,
0.0421800129,
0.0057919691,
0.0379089713,
-0.0407428332,
0.0126068629,
-0.0286422838,
-0.0438561738,
0.039557267,
-0.0467013083,
0.030539602,
0.0143936966,
-0.0654157996,
-0.0107604107,
-0.0107262628,
0.0436233468,
-0.0503971837,
0.0382401682,
-0.0315199457,
-0.0095172767,
-0.0140154557,
0.0365174115,
-0.0112185888,
-0.0142614543,
-0.0372038484,
0.034620624,
-0.0047239847,
0.0144307753,
0.0275281817,
-0.0085635474,
0.0061430922,
-0.0124688325,
0.0291320458,
-0.0499788448,
-0.0602644123,
-0.0212140307,
-0.0096333716,
-0.009581509,
0.0018902153,
0.0174388848,
0.0047162143,
-0.0007552419,
-0.0512935594,
0.0286183562,
-0.0499954522,
0.004416022,
-0.0179217514,
0.0032273952,
-0.0024686123,
-0.0480234995,
-0.0055030412,
-0.0255400352,
-0.0521950759,
0.0421006121,
0.0095501877,
-0.0649891496,
-0.0062754452,
-0.0981558487,
-0.0545596071,
-0.001329995,
0.0376922674,
-0.0370987691,
-0.0923438296,
-0.0307273772,
0.0179667585,
0.0156912412,
0.0067837634,
-0.0357344896,
-0.0422433428,
0.0546835326,
0.0413806923,
-0.0325309895,
-0.0525636561,
0.0356806703,
-0.0061715241,
0.0107204486,
-0.0006898778,
-6.539081852e-33,
0.0099047339,
-0.0601397902,
0.0130780991,
0.0092297914,
0.0153578501,
0.0560959503,
-0.0042253626,
-0.0053317295,
-0.0549860857,
0.0575573966,
0.0099927522,
0.0248414762,
0.0068613729,
-0.0597646087,
-0.0177705437,
-0.0182924382,
0.0520420671,
-0.0146363387,
-0.051657524,
-0.0300690215,
0.0406130999,
-0.0736251995,
0.0005593017,
-0.091895014,
0.0931838527,
-0.0158454254,
-0.0529386848,
0.0056496272,
0.0043131532,
0.024047818,
0.0460205674,
0.0337636732,
0.0201524422,
-0.0235201474,
0.020760417,
0.0244141612,
-0.0541953593,
0.0178550594,
0.065170601,
-0.0047790594,
0.0022955255,
0.0414258726,
-0.002370948,
-0.0107352789,
-0.0397967175,
0.0295429993,
0.0134644564,
-0.0060635926,
0.0452707224,
0.0059576225,
-0.0186699089,
-0.0025485365,
0.0241958834,
0.0332791433,
-0.0371235758,
0.0547694229,
0.0249031875,
-0.0280601028,
-0.128074497,
0.0325243399,
-0.0063792276,
-0.0504318029,
0.0210908428,
-0.0220315829,
-0.0453383811,
0.0375472121,
-0.0229728334,
0.0434022918,
-0.0661046356,
0.0133855855,
-0.0113311168,
0.0049164025,
0.0307801329,
0.1167703941,
-0.0401748493,
-0.0839393139,
-0.0314051434,
0.0266195927,
0.0070845596,
0.0187147893,
0.0293885991,
-0.0729699731,
-0.0482490063,
-0.0279068202,
-0.0187553056,
-0.0046075131,
-0.0455191731,
0.0101479283,
-0.0250932239,
0.0586022437,
-0.0575016662,
0.0698069334,
-0.0409627631,
-0.0096900435,
0.0237781629,
0.0116023337,
-0.0142412139,
0.0372635797,
0.0224800557,
-0.0096117547,
-0.0419998541,
0.0574278012,
-0.0115040736,
0.0654940978,
0.0082657915,
-0.015573089,
0.0194795337,
0.0335775129,
-0.0324553438,
0.0203816127,
0.001382236,
0.05660313,
-0.0185814388,
-0.1180078387,
0.0242044982,
0.0310222581,
-0.0056614918,
-0.0269376412,
-0.0177297182,
0.0234251004,
-0.0167748947,
0.015712209,
-0.0092857378,
0.0155216446,
-0.0112433061,
0.0110942582,
-0.0135538867,
-0.0102045229,
0.0021149768,
-0.0398432836,
0.0050614299,
-0.0196550563,
2.819e-7,
0.0310673732,
0.01498177,
-0.0123007009,
-0.0079655796,
0.0179957058,
0.035601981,
0.0408926345,
-0.0122240158,
-0.0311102644,
-0.1174821407,
-0.0160934385,
0.0374975838,
0.0000026543,
0.0543835498,
0.0167267434,
-0.0396756269,
-0.0036907999,
0.0008821864,
-0.0631511658,
0.0247111171,
-0.0545217916,
-0.052700486,
0.036621049,
-0.0185730439,
-0.0437454395,
-0.0150082689,
0.0433392785,
0.0324355438,
-0.0209148806,
0.0044330438,
0.0249175541,
0.0135446358,
0.0338445455,
-0.0040115281,
-0.0006383504,
-0.0270033777,
-0.0429260023,
0.0372899286,
0.0538757071,
-0.0413183719,
-0.0311511587,
-0.0134445233,
0.0396726057,
-0.0420722514,
0.019972859,
-0.0098012816,
-0.0291669499,
-0.089671284,
-0.0012205215,
0.0261823162,
0.0138775595,
-0.010458787,
-0.0502528325,
0.0155146085,
-0.0324399956,
0.0103552956,
-0.0011940189,
0.0038184479,
0.0305220615,
0.0189958829,
-0.0158192907,
-0.0769162104,
0.0354300104,
-0.0349227823,
-0.0133665632,
-0.0225590058,
0.0543623269,
2.053933473e-34,
0.0143827712,
-0.0173349213,
-0.0106826117,
-0.060316842,
0.0616193153,
0.0455841944,
-0.0203654189,
-0.0553738773,
0.0277118646,
0.0396609232,
-0.0023531877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14233v2 | Large Language Models are Strong Zero-Shot Retriever | 2023-04-27T14:45:55 | 2023-08-02T02:06:28 | Tao Shen, Guodong Long, Xiubo Geng, Chongyang Tao, Tianyi Zhou, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | In this work, we propose a simple method that applies a large language model
(LLM) to large-scale retrieval in zero-shot scenarios. Our method, the Language
language model as Retriever (LameR), is built upon no other neural models but
an LLM, while breaking brute-force combinations of retrievers with LLMs and
lifting the performance of zero-shot retrieval to be very competitive on
benchmark datasets. Essentially, we propose to augment a query with its
potential answers by prompting LLMs with a composition of the query and the
query's in-domain candidates. The candidates, regardless of correct or wrong,
are obtained by a vanilla retrieval procedure on the target collection. As a
part of the prompts, they are likely to help LLM generate more precise answers
by pattern imitation or candidate summarization. Even if all the candidates are
wrong, the prompts at least make LLM aware of in-collection patterns and
genres. Moreover, due to the low performance of a self-supervised retriever,
the LLM-based query augmentation becomes less effective as the retriever
bottlenecks the whole pipeline. Therefore, we propose to leverage a
non-parametric lexicon-based method (e.g., BM25) as the retrieval module to
capture query-document overlap in a literal fashion. As such, LameR makes the
retrieval procedure transparent to the LLM, thus circumventing the performance
bottleneck. | [
0.0366977341,
0.0485157557,
0.0115087824,
0.0572003685,
-0.0381422713,
-0.0143841589,
0.0036852641,
0.0321412459,
-0.0203327797,
-0.0324310474,
-0.0406275131,
-0.0532266423,
-0.0466131493,
0.017710302,
0.0004273047,
0.021539377,
0.0173873343,
-0.006563026,
-0.0147446236,
0.008021378,
-0.0260482151,
0.0368914716,
0.0240382999,
-0.0078607798,
0.0282831937,
0.0056264843,
-0.022155216,
0.0436529256,
-0.034468025,
-0.0058717066,
0.0334891714,
0.0050421646,
0.0399182439,
0.085095048,
0.0000018454,
-0.0437920913,
-0.0334552303,
0.0090644043,
-0.0279153157,
-0.0164162312,
0.045748122,
-0.006745216,
0.0418546461,
0.0096454825,
-0.0135856373,
-0.025842553,
0.024774937,
0.0424523093,
0.0349916406,
0.0970491916,
0.0059149405,
-0.0137961712,
0.0070024473,
-0.0350885689,
0.0436310433,
-0.050336916,
0.0344997793,
-0.0417016037,
0.0726969093,
0.0652975366,
-0.0031833334,
0.0243455935,
-0.0053623202,
-0.0066905729,
-0.0024176112,
0.0011497639,
-0.071093291,
0.0083849197,
0.0359207354,
0.0541128591,
-0.0194555055,
-0.0336623788,
0.0237674452,
0.0042984542,
-0.0335105993,
0.0298821069,
-0.0832011551,
0.01431657,
0.0096102944,
0.0033057458,
-0.0307924878,
0.0140240565,
0.0322785936,
0.0372055359,
-0.0450937226,
0.0635193959,
0.020387182,
-0.0234287754,
-0.0229314156,
-0.0029220767,
0.0102684516,
-0.0361543521,
0.0004378188,
0.0326065682,
-0.0266204942,
0.0131672453,
-0.0277390145,
-0.0368410125,
0.0480074324,
-0.0360412039,
0.0244647283,
0.0129491044,
-0.0173507892,
0.0956844911,
-0.0321080089,
-0.0073167486,
-0.03631014,
-0.0003766943,
-0.0691948608,
-0.0591144413,
-0.0237983521,
-0.0281328112,
-0.0369388498,
0.034626428,
-0.0163171701,
-0.0252781622,
0.0109096877,
0.0033759943,
0.0068165339,
-0.0032416529,
-0.0203364957,
0.0309618395,
-0.0435475223,
-0.0319925696,
-0.0230538715,
0.0564076044,
-0.0123175941,
0.0041716294,
-0.0110859694,
-0.0476053134,
-0.0355851576,
0.0213619396,
0.0438911542,
-0.0417345911,
0.0326916501,
0.0280171353,
-0.001018093,
-0.0518802628,
-0.0164433252,
-0.0236826744,
0.0187172368,
-0.0433266945,
0.0047549824,
-0.0648988709,
0.0339738578,
-0.015248592,
-0.0053275218,
-0.0212883763,
0.0080519812,
0.0553099923,
-0.0249072686,
0.0482573621,
0.0217881445,
-0.0043350891,
0.0489210598,
0.0076523782,
0.0253521446,
0.0861845389,
-0.0246153083,
0.0436563566,
0.0600001775,
0.0270867106,
0.0291474182,
0.0108490232,
0.0492808782,
0.0264277365,
-0.0451724865,
0.0145656019,
0.0085915932,
0.0200692341,
0.0299876016,
0.0149298664,
-0.0454738997,
-0.0511966608,
0.0093287919,
0.0465076156,
0.0280765183,
-0.02325508,
0.0032794694,
0.0268359855,
-0.0300665516,
-0.0139394738,
-0.0077836807,
0.0125884498,
-0.05541889,
0.0074843899,
0.0772802904,
-0.0204984136,
-0.0477951504,
0.0042030313,
-0.0101063242,
0.0209710747,
-0.0461385548,
0.0660428703,
0.0574645512,
-0.0202871412,
-0.0095331734,
0.035500668,
0.0038755187,
-0.0398192629,
0.0206788499,
-0.0344446898,
0.0219283551,
0.0274901967,
0.0773508251,
-0.0624827184,
-0.023351945,
0.003271023,
-0.0059165792,
0.0475451723,
0.0083956281,
-0.0100584701,
0.0240152664,
-0.0458500162,
-0.034485817,
-0.0266943779,
0.0039570155,
0.0226878468,
0.0138026318,
0.026546713,
0.0597975217,
-0.0612491667,
-0.0102002015,
0.011768396,
-0.0530454814,
-0.0741071254,
0.0440722369,
-0.0146104591,
0.0031342478,
0.0193838235,
-0.031578429,
0.0252711941,
0.0228971485,
-0.0057963124,
-0.0582281835,
-0.0735289156,
-0.0355877504,
-0.0128201526,
0.0501111969,
-0.0245160963,
0.0273147039,
-0.0130110933,
-0.0394997187,
-0.0440698005,
0.0097111212,
0.00754902,
0.0162560958,
-0.0593234859,
0.0158330351,
-0.0222681984,
-0.0036993879,
-0.0552579351,
0.0308730137,
0.0503225476,
0.0447665118,
-0.022549592,
-0.0118762087,
0.0347613916,
-0.0513782799,
-0.0683099702,
0.0243259519,
-0.0070917644,
0.0576674454,
0.041037932,
-0.0162294358,
-0.0334514715,
-0.0093268473,
-0.1010693982,
0.0198828261,
-0.0116661582,
-0.0359233133,
-0.0037696809,
0.0338944681,
-0.0060930401,
-0.0230126455,
-0.0403311066,
-0.0348090678,
0.0190729592,
0.0436306559,
-0.0018665064,
0.0329506919,
0.0070563606,
-0.0283725411,
-0.0529828779,
0.0033750711,
0.0492191128,
-0.0415893681,
0.0143766673,
-0.0054875594,
0.0331907533,
-0.0400310941,
0.0243806448,
-0.0070020598,
0.0235910658,
-0.0138935167,
-0.0974850133,
-0.0617635064,
0.0451098047,
0.0015181345,
-0.0527040437,
0.0410572104,
-0.009144648,
-0.082843475,
0.0014755391,
-0.0111062275,
-0.0345461443,
0.0426834449,
0.0118084857,
0.0296509787,
0.0202192925,
-0.0123291723,
-0.0223916173,
-0.0082944743,
-0.0041408129,
0.0208883155,
0.0077335164,
-0.082022883,
-0.0059096697,
0.0258183293,
0.0574226044,
-0.0200277716,
0.0134190582,
0.0641570836,
-0.0267584771,
-0.0080225319,
-0.0264209379,
-0.0277432073,
-0.0877227411,
0.0503739715,
0.000711357,
0.0083429944,
0.0075916797,
-0.0157960132,
-0.0257039927,
-0.0332323723,
0.0341762602,
-0.0474554002,
0.0623686798,
0.0007515224,
0.0602707341,
-0.0203701742,
-0.0559494011,
-0.0355195589,
-0.0380928777,
0.000243357,
0.0226724427,
-0.0437837057,
-0.0180646889,
-0.0603152104,
0.0001229152,
0.0151245594,
0.0781584308,
-0.0411623009,
-0.0034418956,
0.0086291982,
0.0239620488,
0.0700198635,
-0.0044923071,
-0.0307952631,
-0.0053350185,
-0.0236443002,
0.0438348502,
0.0493925884,
0.003570427,
-0.014192407,
-0.0107561611,
0.0671611652,
-0.0283664018,
0.0033882461,
-0.0216006637,
-0.0257164519,
-0.0299454536,
-0.0279760752,
0.0869394168,
0.0321344696,
-0.0646544993,
-0.0484887548,
-0.0606093891,
-0.0028662896,
0.0472748391,
0.072013624,
-0.0683496147,
-0.0138984742,
0.004581192,
0.033504501,
0.0086859642,
-0.0266671795,
-0.0092857834,
-0.1681364626,
0.0403206609,
0.0154661555,
0.0027899181,
-0.0099095171,
-0.0476432741,
0.0099777561,
0.0008035419,
-0.0119507955,
0.0358679034,
-0.0137860281,
-0.0371494517,
-0.0089653209,
0.0767816678,
-0.0437029377,
0.0048494283,
-0.0261534806,
-0.0072051482,
0.0361295901,
0.0207175873,
0.0002990275,
0.0020667622,
0.0328319222,
-0.0491108038,
-0.0124835121,
-0.0100537846,
0.060013067,
-0.0333669446,
0.0118470024,
0.0162712913,
-0.0053154663,
-0.0202341732,
0.019675402,
0.0027399417,
0.060351748,
-0.0221413616,
0.0302565116,
-0.0570629872,
-0.0211756229,
-0.011384299,
0.0615927204,
0.0119293807,
0.0115552936,
-0.0148423864,
-0.0161114577,
-0.0232758075,
-0.0282225795,
-0.0101139881,
-0.0064894999,
-0.0140458532,
-0.010235779,
-0.0247288365,
-0.0081188427,
0.0081255864,
0.0339341387,
-0.005081804,
0.0246585738,
-0.0299611688,
-0.0328486189,
-0.0600147322,
0.0103846453,
-0.0556774773,
0.0189710017,
-0.0652815998,
0.0376847014,
0.0600143746,
-0.041453205,
-0.0113572944,
-0.0257732533,
-0.0485443585,
-0.0542867444,
-0.0410911068,
0.0009881981,
0.01591173,
0.038103018,
-0.0237521958,
-0.0909257084,
0.0810622275,
0.0723482519,
-0.0226300731,
-0.0051710983,
-0.0088009946,
-0.0134738395,
-0.0191933308,
0.0352943018,
-0.0894910321,
0.0131616825,
0.0034518042,
0.0471579023,
-0.0271150284,
-0.0272241794,
0.0306439716,
0.0203936454,
0.0563648157,
0.0341411717,
0.0433212407,
-0.0294035543,
0.0242611021,
-0.037518274,
-0.0389149711,
-0.0017505813,
0.006383698,
0.0445385724,
-0.0432690084,
0.0005646512,
0.0307239387,
-0.027696792,
0.0717352182,
-0.0277522244,
-0.0118325166,
0.006003452,
-0.0187877789,
0.0217429772,
0.0193185769,
-0.0363145731,
0.0299092419,
0.0141547546,
0.0826835111,
-0.0267125722,
0.0191012751,
0.0349385701,
0.0102490829,
-0.062143784,
0.0123515902,
-0.0874774754,
-0.0252318569,
-0.0101256771,
0.0199275818,
0.0631744564,
-0.0645083934,
-0.0242882892,
-0.0011502107,
-0.0266677868,
-0.0453410521,
-0.0316645913,
-0.0068511562,
-0.0320410356,
0.0133117707,
0.0602611192,
0.0072326399,
0.0392683558,
0.0749825016,
0.0102528706,
0.0244281162,
-0.0040109386,
-0.0199177302,
0.0134756863,
0.0126743326,
0.0645918548,
0.0463933721,
-0.0222917777,
-0.0027284722,
-0.0057184803,
-0.0414325036,
0.0394993015,
-0.0236555096,
-0.0403835215,
-0.0188976731,
0.0395408757,
0.0842772722,
0.0281700809,
0.0069624293,
-0.037881121,
0.0412765145,
-0.0160333142,
-0.0429438278,
-0.0119136749,
-6.338513128e-33,
-0.0030437859,
-0.0206680968,
0.0200122744,
-0.0508141592,
0.0027920736,
0.0173041672,
-0.0183541123,
-0.0267687794,
-0.0285391677,
-0.0241427626,
-0.0542146899,
0.0327166617,
0.0035020637,
0.055126749,
0.0199876558,
-0.0096559832,
0.0437393449,
0.0034166567,
-0.0113313813,
-0.0026220416,
0.0598703325,
0.0484986305,
-0.0073453998,
-0.0429414548,
-0.0020335435,
-0.0292584281,
0.0287477653,
0.0392594077,
0.0016817499,
0.0574391745,
0.0096290642,
0.0539123826,
0.0300575644,
-0.008043074,
0.0118027739,
-0.012645036,
-0.0409458801,
-0.0445530117,
-0.0086294971,
-0.0125919525,
0.0272977594,
-0.0036184345,
0.0224351659,
-0.0222797077,
0.0159715079,
-0.0227002371,
0.0116093457,
-0.0058759488,
-0.0484120511,
-0.036326237,
-0.0214743577,
0.0195353068,
0.0224546958,
-0.0164128207,
0.0492180176,
0.0470581464,
0.0103002014,
0.0678446889,
-0.0556365661,
0.0187392663,
-0.0333216116,
0.0677504241,
0.0295532811,
0.0508282073,
-0.0164732467,
0.0584951751,
-0.0019068657,
-0.0005032573,
-0.023408249,
-0.0267593302,
0.0308256801,
0.013262677,
-0.0130884182,
0.0498683117,
0.0722941011,
0.0326496772,
-0.0211191718,
0.0525373891,
0.003651801,
0.0364901312,
0.0343048535,
0.0423072055,
-0.0568591096,
-0.0469346419,
-0.0249711312,
-0.0015496577,
-0.0857588574,
-0.0039013794,
0.0206334312,
0.0356560946,
-0.0006699931,
-0.0042717708,
0.0548733883,
-0.0410196483,
-0.0306019038,
0.0637747049,
-0.0107080759,
-0.0019222499,
-0.0096765822,
0.0378112867,
-0.0247684587,
-0.0243832991,
0.0200113766,
-0.0190656763,
-0.0508741029,
0.0070498856,
0.032078281,
0.0227828249,
-0.0522569306,
-0.0276221633,
-0.0060646725,
-0.0133561501,
-0.0337301008,
0.0254137106,
0.0052794805,
0.0579981357,
0.0219291691,
0.0644378141,
0.0298520438,
-0.007087694,
-0.0128364209,
-0.0375830904,
-0.0019492096,
-0.006837863,
-0.0171935912,
0.0449058563,
-0.0171641279,
-0.0078117391,
0.0331725813,
-0.0544233806,
0.0030621844,
0.020430591,
2.725e-7,
0.0277381912,
0.0158130322,
0.0043403087,
0.0404802151,
-0.0160302967,
0.0455874205,
-0.0186617151,
0.0333881862,
0.0307001434,
0.0079191141,
0.0009357964,
0.0206338819,
0.043504633,
0.0199564379,
-0.108723633,
0.0202247743,
-0.0341488607,
-0.0382976755,
-0.0504848957,
-0.0535864793,
0.0332561433,
0.1017854586,
0.0232911166,
-0.0113740955,
0.0105159665,
-0.0656974614,
0.0545582213,
0.0256903917,
-0.0395562798,
0.0066758925,
0.0244514905,
0.0322161689,
0.0072709778,
-0.0122017469,
0.0055021895,
0.0596332513,
0.0310338456,
0.0303021204,
-0.0245500803,
-0.0187530816,
-0.0213948041,
-0.0167182498,
-0.0019356111,
-0.0246016886,
0.0871091411,
-0.0082144253,
-0.0028448037,
-0.0351247154,
-0.0311091784,
0.002451333,
0.0265304372,
-0.0326594748,
-0.0358985811,
0.006944974,
0.0198249444,
-0.0037419144,
0.0039044102,
-0.0701652616,
0.0021067739,
-0.0047853542,
-0.0381612331,
0.0213725232,
-0.0238507744,
0.0306582004,
-0.0066355462,
-0.0304717198,
0.0126046957,
2.478610195e-34,
0.0569223799,
0.0188071467,
-0.0112447664,
-0.0080624232,
0.0224244297,
0.0031192105,
-0.0556747541,
0.0492636673,
0.0145653803,
-0.0770285949,
-0.0257100239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14221v1 | A Modular Approach for Multilingual Timex Detection and Normalization using Deep Learning and Grammar-based methods | 2023-04-27T14:32:23 | 2023-04-27T14:32:23 | Nayla Escribano, German Rigau, Rodrigo Agerri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting and normalizing temporal expressions is an essential step for many
NLP tasks. While a variety of methods have been proposed for detection, best
normalization approaches rely on hand-crafted rules. Furthermore, most of them
have been designed only for English. In this paper we present a modular
multilingual temporal processing system combining a fine-tuned Masked Language
Model for detection, and a grammar-based normalizer. We experiment in Spanish
and English and compare with HeidelTime, the state-of-the-art in multilingual
temporal processing. We obtain best results in gold timex normalization, timex
detection and type recognition, and competitive performance in the combined
TempEval-3 relaxed value metric. A detailed error analysis shows that detecting
only those timexes for which it is feasible to provide a normalization is
highly beneficial in this last metric. This raises the question of which is the
best strategy for timex processing, namely, leaving undetected those timexes
for which is not easy to provide normalization rules or aiming for high
coverage. | [
-0.0270462409,
0.0664767921,
0.0058720699,
0.036734134,
-0.0325695276,
0.0185456835,
0.0553964637,
0.0243462641,
-0.0222500768,
-0.0373734348,
-0.0301911552,
-0.0561920851,
-0.0089890258,
0.0464451499,
-0.0122591024,
-0.0218952484,
0.0751404613,
-0.004807339,
-0.0039525069,
0.0351907909,
0.024001468,
-0.0145635419,
-0.000910623,
0.0447881296,
-0.0204864722,
-0.0062376154,
0.0379777886,
-0.0553361513,
0.0559930988,
-0.0164874904,
0.0183986332,
0.0253468119,
-0.007445266,
0.0760820061,
0.0000020499,
-0.0178470965,
-0.0298960507,
-0.0251938924,
0.0030620915,
0.0202770475,
0.0369402952,
-0.044296626,
-0.0357332304,
0.0008751703,
-0.0861647353,
-0.0496396385,
0.0312844701,
0.0174117424,
0.0067580952,
0.0652233735,
-0.033662539,
-0.0043480224,
0.0017300134,
0.0136395143,
-0.0296726096,
-0.0237099696,
0.0002154605,
-0.0390505567,
0.0133148907,
-0.0393786393,
0.036992833,
0.0470811613,
0.0163598061,
-0.02517852,
0.0013128523,
-0.0065135891,
-0.0301044714,
0.0360827632,
-0.0574932955,
0.023711469,
-0.0547941253,
-0.0428114235,
0.0113512371,
-0.0057954858,
-0.046881903,
-0.0834199861,
-0.0273744222,
0.0017328853,
0.041292835,
0.0275364686,
0.0631663278,
0.0539218299,
0.0128874052,
0.0145103652,
0.007937382,
0.0697723106,
0.0270335395,
0.0040103812,
-0.0339869596,
-0.0040672119,
0.0241008271,
-0.0363026708,
0.0899025202,
0.0372204594,
0.0053685517,
-0.0214695204,
-0.030620655,
-0.0836419016,
-0.0117593938,
-0.0842325017,
-0.0312057771,
0.0343574695,
-0.0134944739,
0.0252922624,
-0.0368921235,
0.0530101694,
-0.0413240343,
-0.018532332,
-0.0256518293,
-0.0302200485,
0.0061594448,
0.0025558558,
-0.0146591682,
0.0171882045,
-0.0403978042,
0.0140073728,
-0.0354529321,
-0.0086738244,
-0.0249405131,
-0.002997922,
0.008580016,
0.007737542,
-0.0132464292,
-0.0116136698,
-0.0014122083,
0.0508785844,
-0.0496180244,
-0.0025189568,
-0.0351202041,
-0.0767381713,
-0.0126517965,
0.0447959192,
0.0466780923,
-0.0287283231,
-0.0154482592,
0.0326291099,
-0.0491025969,
-0.0171577372,
-0.053130053,
-0.0568315908,
-0.0244647395,
-0.0156904366,
0.0116678774,
-0.0798961595,
0.0191908069,
-0.0341654643,
0.0031918925,
0.004090637,
0.0057389289,
-0.0011053099,
0.0374457985,
0.0498436615,
0.0253343172,
-0.0226079877,
-0.0090696206,
-0.0272452552,
0.0495735593,
0.0569194891,
0.0257819947,
-0.0308536068,
0.0193493553,
-0.007408109,
-0.0125504266,
0.0868271217,
-0.0296400897,
-0.0461352207,
-0.0567568466,
-0.0426098071,
0.0379041098,
0.0128466394,
0.0490997061,
0.045107305,
0.0023229932,
-0.0205153003,
-0.0004912572,
-0.0062132664,
-0.0435268506,
-0.0282960832,
0.0886625573,
-0.0205999706,
0.0036140978,
-0.0029057504,
0.0148576545,
-0.0046477197,
-0.0311812088,
-0.0404547043,
-0.0644750148,
0.0435719751,
-0.0303338971,
-0.0150834024,
-0.0024860087,
0.0011488765,
0.0188366771,
-0.0245353561,
0.0514283553,
-0.003499297,
-0.0259537995,
0.0445684977,
0.0062912838,
0.0302838944,
0.0310746953,
0.0051214295,
-0.0239544269,
0.0342557579,
0.0246395282,
-0.0170264803,
-0.0029736629,
-0.0331326686,
0.0197009686,
0.0362085439,
0.0378915407,
0.0010938453,
0.0238210727,
-0.0658448339,
-0.0011299672,
0.0399097204,
0.0418449678,
0.0114837084,
-0.0298815705,
0.0450774245,
0.0233594552,
-0.0074511673,
-0.0037127661,
0.0345572606,
-0.0003176066,
-0.0787614211,
0.0004935507,
0.0318764709,
0.0117293438,
0.0686142668,
0.0038452432,
0.0035962502,
0.0187184066,
-0.0761373863,
0.0162966121,
0.0545765683,
-0.0692830086,
-0.0516442917,
0.0564300232,
-0.0283299051,
-0.0472462848,
0.0710908175,
0.009914265,
-0.0490011536,
0.0375092961,
-0.0036675059,
0.0460797399,
-0.0383719951,
0.0313713588,
-0.0108163869,
0.0542878844,
-0.040935941,
0.0259503704,
-0.0109858867,
0.0075404779,
0.0166469626,
-0.0540706515,
0.050223805,
-0.0186249297,
-0.0366314352,
0.028631404,
-0.0400783829,
-0.0223603807,
0.0142175769,
0.0002408226,
-0.0099200048,
0.0044786609,
-0.056361448,
-0.0097020362,
-0.0506847054,
0.0559249483,
0.0247014202,
0.0177227426,
0.0288175028,
-0.0317737572,
-0.0433744639,
-0.041944515,
0.029336296,
-0.0047378009,
0.0563782379,
0.0176896285,
-0.0070501831,
-0.0156838186,
-0.0147848269,
-0.0828702375,
0.0693684965,
-0.023754403,
-0.0957941636,
-0.0000972742,
-0.0074659409,
0.0089715486,
0.0565420762,
0.034425471,
-0.0321132466,
-0.0107024768,
0.0011973215,
0.0584690236,
0.0533043817,
-0.0184212402,
0.0030708639,
0.0348479673,
-0.0261973497,
-0.0452783816,
0.019463392,
0.0157418456,
0.0126932682,
-0.0346804075,
-0.0382888801,
0.0124161672,
0.102672711,
0.001654605,
0.022984473,
-0.026807595,
-0.0103142681,
-0.0615716539,
-0.0418528169,
0.0289018638,
0.0300776046,
-0.0364029184,
0.0108665479,
-0.0230272003,
0.0015753692,
0.0333260149,
0.0033038685,
-0.0366805606,
-0.0356892012,
-0.0479215868,
-0.0474371836,
0.0256748945,
0.0099285701,
0.0161165074,
0.0011385257,
-0.0830006301,
-0.0174908787,
-0.0200050399,
0.0052524307,
-0.0043812254,
0.0239203889,
-0.0429419056,
-0.0170913599,
-0.0286480952,
-0.0189723019,
-0.0307447892,
-0.0261498913,
-0.0572559722,
0.0180936158,
0.0017592675,
-0.0124066481,
-0.0355588719,
0.0052347654,
-0.0567748174,
0.0379356444,
-0.0367391109,
0.0102044856,
-0.0287483539,
0.0698456615,
0.0299285222,
0.0053965044,
0.0063228291,
0.0224387851,
0.0091550639,
0.0104427701,
0.0462118201,
0.0197623167,
-0.0639922172,
0.0304399617,
0.0197742637,
-0.0329361074,
-0.0155883068,
-0.0173708312,
0.0175931137,
-0.0693305731,
0.0327924378,
0.0969779715,
0.0229306407,
-0.0533818975,
-0.0044698752,
-0.0340219326,
-0.0077569541,
-0.012276303,
-0.0213703364,
-0.0642108917,
-0.0187842157,
0.0079196449,
-0.0634766221,
-0.0081690056,
-0.01651299,
0.0106914174,
-0.0572374724,
-0.0075302687,
0.0360695943,
-0.0379224606,
-0.0119902901,
0.0006627416,
0.0077401865,
-0.0380376615,
0.0553898178,
-0.0052878349,
-0.0054176706,
-0.0306308903,
0.0342855267,
-0.0532448106,
-0.0628414601,
0.0236966088,
-0.0368311442,
0.0463351496,
0.0078855371,
0.0656833574,
-0.0312281903,
-0.0672174394,
0.0205226205,
0.0220625475,
-0.0224679839,
-0.0053943628,
-0.0074791857,
0.0076865782,
-0.0545208305,
-0.0010732056,
0.0398336463,
-0.0180929787,
0.0029659846,
-0.0325827487,
0.1121521667,
-0.0059250998,
0.0054052672,
-0.0303033963,
-0.0240313634,
0.0004540353,
0.031661272,
-0.0158695485,
-0.0406439863,
-0.0326613151,
0.0132226329,
0.0031270119,
-0.1077120006,
-0.0292729028,
-0.0078990906,
-0.0025197277,
-0.0326685719,
-0.0468216129,
-0.0574883968,
0.0138594136,
0.0241514519,
-0.0232134555,
-0.0132473717,
-0.0173700843,
0.0022987807,
-0.0309599638,
0.0420483202,
0.0007099272,
0.0358551182,
-0.0402638838,
0.0335038714,
-0.0486227982,
0.0439846329,
-0.0042788326,
0.0488981605,
-0.0869247615,
-0.0392002501,
0.00262482,
-0.0248745382,
0.0120010683,
0.0203069914,
-0.0277673937,
-0.0274036974,
0.0106489873,
0.0023740181,
0.0097413352,
-0.0037455349,
0.0246043094,
-0.0084584365,
-0.008953087,
0.0248475075,
-0.0289832037,
-0.0026624426,
-0.0361054055,
0.0374721698,
-0.027933538,
0.0156775787,
0.0098905675,
0.0127826314,
0.0322234854,
0.0055455728,
0.0366416462,
-0.0049997191,
-0.0356617607,
-0.0441701859,
0.0164755639,
-0.0053278129,
0.0609856285,
0.0159575306,
0.0342817791,
-0.0396758094,
0.0508420058,
0.0148387058,
-0.0255590454,
-0.0234628879,
0.0324077308,
0.0073176604,
0.0352284685,
-0.0240346044,
0.0324617215,
-0.0062891762,
0.0402065665,
0.0040363213,
-0.0130793042,
-0.0166657362,
-0.0325041115,
0.0045852764,
0.0253937524,
-0.0545503795,
-0.007298205,
-0.0063213068,
0.0509832688,
-0.0202154405,
-0.0655932575,
0.0847353712,
-0.0523649864,
0.0690487325,
0.0096259173,
-0.0091125853,
0.0030422304,
0.0169928875,
0.0269382652,
0.0052917725,
0.0297526531,
-0.0331140533,
-0.021316452,
-0.0217348114,
0.0570034347,
-0.0236287843,
0.0491752736,
0.0335835442,
-0.0193614215,
-0.0268526375,
0.0202651173,
-0.0224695038,
-0.0180652346,
-0.0489780903,
-0.0303626545,
-0.0458994694,
-0.0282457378,
0.0083162664,
0.0137821175,
-0.0201910939,
0.0148017947,
0.0094056111,
0.0332930274,
0.0269782897,
-0.0651516169,
0.0038582645,
0.0357300341,
0.0539465323,
-0.02306851,
-0.081790708,
-6.519433464e-33,
0.0141905034,
-0.0251045208,
-0.0176441371,
-0.0251712296,
-0.0001013808,
0.0442039557,
-0.0113010667,
0.0155426292,
-0.0091158301,
0.0170389861,
-0.0015313617,
0.0175419841,
0.0414785184,
-0.020223543,
0.0272683315,
0.0123612899,
0.0441376865,
-0.0508903712,
0.0245874189,
-0.0187009294,
0.0251538437,
0.0414145067,
0.1265860498,
-0.0605029315,
0.0011180344,
0.0611125305,
-0.0338154696,
0.0521596186,
0.0371896289,
0.0596514829,
-0.0166180748,
0.0481627919,
0.0157438237,
-0.0190917831,
-0.0492552146,
0.0363526866,
-0.0972416699,
-0.0625703558,
0.0285763927,
0.069789961,
-0.0181936007,
-0.0642922744,
0.0133827943,
-0.0222190302,
-0.0314233042,
0.0237028301,
0.0396265239,
-0.0089910002,
0.0159272514,
-0.0628624633,
-0.0484674349,
0.0597014576,
0.0036344149,
0.0316717289,
0.1064977422,
0.0501289777,
-0.0062654451,
-0.0462048091,
-0.0565601178,
-0.0001316981,
-0.0018555144,
0.0198328402,
0.0428687036,
-0.0002045056,
0.0006646019,
0.0145138027,
0.0201504063,
0.0298156999,
0.0038488591,
0.0409806259,
0.0809130669,
-0.0155254956,
0.0301254913,
0.0151183046,
0.0538779944,
-0.0079931319,
-0.0288882926,
0.0164069049,
0.071482338,
0.0299867559,
-0.0259350631,
0.0115226302,
-0.0304195676,
0.0362951942,
-0.0032671038,
0.0029923969,
-0.0187857486,
-0.0087086158,
0.023306096,
-0.0031961876,
0.013524401,
0.0531340912,
0.053064175,
-0.02267115,
-0.0142721683,
0.0182806738,
0.0152017884,
0.0070841103,
0.020238068,
0.0353658237,
-0.0436019674,
-0.0326510258,
0.0137613984,
0.0061578485,
0.047198426,
-0.0266952682,
-0.0080452589,
0.035368856,
-0.0499460511,
0.0017782161,
-0.0194005556,
-0.0040959134,
0.0391869508,
0.0229725558,
0.0435175598,
-0.0457681715,
0.0027765436,
0.0276765116,
0.0363933668,
0.0186069123,
-0.0161753073,
0.0414288715,
0.0174475033,
0.0863806978,
-0.0230388902,
-0.0012598016,
-0.0278957617,
0.0414194539,
0.0814140961,
0.0014286834,
-0.0008791644,
-0.0282168537,
2.602e-7,
0.0262637697,
0.0334835202,
0.0276437569,
0.0411506332,
0.0143609764,
0.0057771029,
0.0357026197,
0.0426874533,
-0.0815249234,
0.0629515946,
0.0151656419,
-0.0461883843,
0.0337577499,
0.0336549953,
0.0021167404,
-0.0474865325,
-0.0429060049,
-0.0209155157,
-0.047907982,
-0.0375101306,
0.0249246676,
0.1027585119,
0.0303219017,
0.0099164341,
0.0000299687,
-0.0384680554,
0.0331231728,
0.0182715841,
-0.0338158831,
0.0303496197,
0.0765064955,
-0.0087380111,
-0.0203536563,
-0.0154955518,
0.0135767562,
0.0260501876,
0.0124921221,
0.0484819971,
-0.0444416814,
0.0089597022,
0.0060568396,
-0.0594666228,
-0.0305311717,
-0.0291518793,
0.0507911444,
0.0128302453,
-0.0039172419,
-0.0351094119,
-0.0065842215,
0.0471755937,
0.0260713864,
0.0155979507,
-0.0318826102,
0.0446510427,
0.0490374453,
-0.0180965438,
-0.0594816767,
-0.0802801698,
-0.0650579631,
0.0589678213,
-0.0136151537,
0.0115512805,
-0.0232194588,
-0.0106142499,
0.0083079236,
-0.0176056754,
-0.0151622118,
2.387834021e-34,
0.0071798232,
-0.0256505106,
-0.0212806258,
0.0567639805,
0.0063602021,
-0.0142686069,
-0.0070255357,
0.0001909062,
0.0029585508,
-0.0327889957,
0.0173205063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14189v1 | UIO at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Multilingual fine-tuning for sentiment classification in low-resource languages | 2023-04-27T13:51:18 | 2023-04-27T13:51:18 | Egil Rønningstad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our contribution to the 2023 AfriSenti-SemEval shared task 12: Sentiment
Analysis for African Languages, provides insight into how a multilingual large
language model can be a resource for sentiment analysis in languages not seen
during pretraining. The shared task provides datasets of a variety of African
languages from different language families. The languages are to various
degrees related to languages used during pretraining, and the language data
contain various degrees of code-switching. We experiment with both monolingual
and multilingual datasets for the final fine-tuning, and find that with the
provided datasets that contain samples in the thousands, monolingual
fine-tuning yields the best results. | [
0.03438586,
0.0962386802,
0.0006106881,
0.0598621294,
-0.0003505401,
0.0552518107,
0.0123392856,
-0.0056878403,
-0.0222485568,
-0.0283360463,
-0.056810718,
-0.0827983841,
0.0079080788,
-0.0078180311,
0.01348159,
-0.0169798508,
0.0252741482,
0.0020833674,
0.013089384,
-0.0321620554,
-0.0056504351,
0.0410428345,
0.0122739105,
0.0046189632,
-0.0357071608,
-0.021527905,
-0.0021839577,
-0.0067855967,
-0.0093515506,
-0.0225138273,
0.0198807418,
0.0509507954,
-0.0163494516,
0.0031261214,
0.0000021358,
-0.0374866538,
-0.0041910186,
-0.0156542398,
-0.0016425233,
0.013553041,
0.0668264553,
-0.0538683049,
0.0064165187,
0.0193544608,
-0.0420728512,
-0.0206342824,
0.0816042721,
-0.0056782104,
0.0543423966,
0.0786344483,
-0.017958872,
-0.0099574253,
-0.0111572733,
-0.0480468832,
-0.0188606139,
-0.0043149311,
0.0141549446,
-0.0089923535,
-0.0230687205,
0.0034990278,
-0.0333582759,
-0.0096081514,
0.0055609178,
0.0219391529,
-0.0053371657,
-0.0369057842,
-0.0330861546,
-0.0515916757,
-0.0046464531,
0.0166874975,
-0.0002851343,
-0.0112386402,
-0.0335519202,
0.008861796,
-0.0352180563,
-0.0470709018,
-0.0008919833,
0.0023524547,
0.0149383005,
0.0309592001,
0.0455523096,
0.0207480919,
0.0496220663,
0.0239362959,
-0.0440515243,
0.0261338539,
-0.0099713653,
-0.0214175321,
0.0648340732,
0.08598575,
0.0073936819,
0.0144132739,
-0.0152488193,
-0.0414916836,
-0.0020833765,
-0.0245246496,
0.0273555424,
-0.0174288899,
0.0154407434,
-0.0815765858,
0.0275722593,
0.0060661118,
-0.0594113581,
0.0261159819,
-0.0283792857,
-0.0295190103,
-0.0073378491,
-0.0297835469,
-0.0081043495,
-0.025955908,
-0.0387997776,
0.0017745758,
-0.0049444488,
0.0139311571,
-0.0265369397,
0.0508929454,
-0.0795901865,
-0.0019398928,
-0.0417709686,
-0.0284985211,
-0.0123485206,
-0.0514151305,
0.0237433575,
-0.0198381785,
0.0157761928,
0.0303916801,
-0.0422033966,
0.0296282321,
-0.0657969639,
-0.0806754529,
0.0292375088,
0.0096524879,
-0.0292380024,
-0.0106333466,
0.0488629527,
0.0561875515,
0.0171538107,
-0.0419731066,
-0.0656106919,
-0.0108024674,
-0.0212552287,
-0.0559696779,
-0.0187249091,
-0.0575207882,
0.0327555388,
0.0325972475,
0.0659080446,
-0.0105913766,
-0.0283015259,
-0.0410403945,
0.0110176904,
0.0539192744,
-0.0176640861,
0.0018508506,
-0.0103711309,
-0.018650217,
0.0497397669,
0.0893095434,
-0.0146308532,
-0.0001949637,
0.0473882258,
-0.020946756,
-0.051541023,
0.0463659577,
0.0050496669,
0.0016087918,
-0.0228922442,
0.0119035067,
0.0131915342,
-0.0447013415,
0.020667972,
-0.0185048226,
0.0075594112,
0.0011524678,
0.019501837,
0.0090614939,
-0.0168039128,
0.0538819917,
0.0041402392,
-0.0468666442,
-0.0026968122,
-0.0068763313,
0.0156330094,
0.016098788,
0.0009434096,
-0.046718929,
0.054218445,
0.0700700358,
-0.0245890357,
-0.0372886695,
0.0213230792,
-0.0401970148,
0.0081091765,
0.0164809041,
0.0552446507,
-0.0008984358,
-0.0080688866,
-0.0127685787,
0.0827817395,
-0.0546043888,
-0.0115807746,
-0.0481762998,
0.0239835549,
0.0378292538,
-0.0364352129,
0.0262940712,
0.0071498086,
-0.0203116592,
0.0356161483,
0.0223785378,
0.0422170311,
-0.0162843633,
0.0542038195,
-0.0591530018,
0.0277115107,
-0.0042275749,
0.016299678,
0.0374168195,
-0.0106708724,
0.0638229102,
-0.0248704087,
0.0057648304,
-0.0408727117,
-0.0040640435,
-0.016584212,
0.0250438154,
0.0156021342,
0.0408069342,
0.0759102851,
0.0313730165,
-0.0261801593,
-0.0260166209,
-0.0197572298,
-0.0446805321,
0.0193181913,
0.049337402,
-0.0129141826,
-0.0235864036,
0.0196605735,
-0.0001488233,
-0.0186799895,
0.0287330002,
-0.0180384926,
-0.0025039858,
0.0598432571,
0.0298499614,
0.0488501564,
-0.0265551303,
0.0039525856,
-0.0532684438,
0.0168255288,
0.0283737332,
0.0207811296,
0.040741764,
0.0220287144,
-0.0295120087,
-0.0307956375,
0.0648184046,
0.0144887026,
-0.05726289,
0.0386901125,
0.0044591264,
-0.0002792447,
0.0288077556,
0.0484958626,
-0.0113178361,
-0.0421085209,
-0.1098242402,
-0.0158673767,
-0.0247594118,
0.0276836101,
-0.0110038072,
0.0513904728,
-0.0040901955,
0.0163655113,
-0.0084397234,
0.0037021912,
-0.0126118371,
0.0273340959,
-0.00346831,
-0.0159032885,
0.0333041027,
-0.0285103023,
0.0082754614,
0.043607261,
0.0438473076,
0.0114170257,
-0.0148368953,
-0.0062610069,
0.0133560607,
-0.0413256884,
-0.0091290036,
0.0078024645,
-0.081897378,
0.0053291889,
-0.0180845801,
-0.0101064583,
0.022372758,
-0.018647816,
0.0131448172,
0.026018627,
0.0212753806,
-0.0100887129,
0.0117969718,
-0.0192532893,
-0.0282296054,
-0.0308941714,
-0.0087344181,
-0.0044105868,
0.0842263773,
0.0008996773,
-0.032056056,
-0.0669645667,
-0.0233188048,
-0.0378737971,
-0.010687829,
0.0176353194,
0.0190354437,
0.0229364689,
0.0276649017,
0.0049011265,
-0.0501881912,
0.0796587914,
0.0260496493,
-0.0126150958,
-0.06687475,
-0.0062517496,
-0.035858456,
0.0273086745,
-0.0477437973,
0.0129348775,
-0.0165223572,
0.0524699613,
-0.0070576477,
0.0010125462,
0.0154243056,
-0.0018073461,
0.0343344137,
0.0091695767,
0.0152850673,
0.0077654631,
-0.0913728029,
0.0488728285,
-0.0300652534,
-0.05620794,
-0.0396584161,
0.051454667,
-0.0170455799,
0.0111290105,
-0.0035529442,
-0.0326343402,
-0.0305959918,
0.0043994756,
-0.0163140129,
0.0465786643,
0.0119645493,
-0.0085313395,
-0.0445475988,
0.0130565939,
-0.0464481115,
-0.0225108936,
-0.0070374096,
-0.0219191387,
-0.0022120872,
-0.0110863904,
-0.0196965169,
0.0568198487,
0.0288963057,
-0.026361553,
-0.0257207118,
0.02006373,
-0.0082337894,
0.0186982732,
0.0869216472,
0.0142594874,
-0.0687461793,
0.010045452,
-0.026676327,
0.0395635255,
0.0045981193,
-0.0126186674,
-0.0670794398,
-0.0283257477,
-0.0254582092,
0.0098155709,
-0.021707546,
-0.0033897366,
-0.0007812471,
-0.0974527895,
-0.0025155179,
0.0221844204,
-0.0493141115,
-0.0530336536,
-0.0332395136,
-0.0287650619,
-0.0386527888,
-0.0210258123,
-0.0563349426,
0.011991567,
0.0078793103,
0.0389830805,
-0.0136448639,
-0.0800753087,
0.0333799273,
-0.0038063866,
0.0374697186,
0.0313477889,
0.0178761948,
-0.0291944984,
-0.0005543005,
0.0209754109,
-0.0233004354,
-0.0109020574,
-0.0616467781,
0.026654996,
0.0044263848,
-0.0642519519,
-0.0007646913,
-0.0219962243,
-0.0457878448,
0.0282503348,
0.0003646706,
0.0280877259,
-0.0132872211,
-0.0424272045,
-0.0118590547,
0.0033093432,
0.0254925359,
0.0243265759,
0.0170005783,
-0.0952979922,
-0.0008552326,
0.0139853945,
0.0318693891,
-0.048165381,
0.0028142827,
-0.0041952571,
0.0032835153,
-0.0335338153,
-0.0453111157,
-0.0657520145,
0.0136447558,
0.0191157162,
-0.0078679025,
0.0053180014,
-0.0030152095,
-0.0038201725,
-0.0238807853,
0.0419187732,
0.0081117395,
0.0188562404,
-0.03513835,
-0.0345028453,
0.0942414925,
0.0077280598,
0.0056458111,
-0.0231739078,
-0.0716926679,
-0.0499592349,
0.0073662666,
0.0339343846,
0.014453372,
0.0225184448,
0.0409806073,
-0.0606152788,
-0.011115877,
0.0173036363,
-0.017048737,
0.0220618229,
0.0667091459,
0.0399992317,
-0.0104375882,
0.0483126119,
0.0150777372,
0.0588493496,
0.0383492708,
-0.0143570974,
-0.0192291662,
-0.0366358273,
-0.028771786,
-0.0300015099,
0.0532592498,
-0.0279558245,
-0.0733585283,
-0.0583668873,
0.0076949736,
0.0591245405,
0.0100214891,
-0.0397983529,
-0.0342381038,
0.0252308659,
0.0149066215,
-0.0634420514,
0.0130365742,
0.0069436766,
0.0069297361,
-0.0008453036,
0.0882255957,
0.0795273557,
0.0080447551,
0.0381880477,
0.0491204746,
0.0015987661,
0.0174373575,
0.0018903152,
0.0061301505,
-0.0301436502,
0.015808953,
0.0046313135,
0.0189011153,
0.0130589064,
0.0051455586,
0.0302476157,
0.0334154293,
-0.0319864564,
0.0008800984,
0.0483878627,
-0.0349170454,
0.056565892,
-0.0048604542,
-0.0170295741,
-0.0109920083,
0.0393807702,
-0.0460440554,
-0.0122745512,
0.0128173232,
-0.0192966815,
-0.0372318812,
0.0375236608,
0.0561383888,
-0.0486480407,
0.0556573831,
0.0481441431,
0.0323565491,
-0.0165721271,
-0.0021377804,
0.0642109886,
-0.0218852833,
0.0114222309,
0.0488057137,
-0.0531105511,
-0.0816077292,
0.0451109521,
-0.0308422539,
-0.0131195514,
0.0301068071,
0.0075583854,
0.0595874526,
0.006712595,
0.083870925,
-0.0361892059,
-0.0286897998,
0.0004675084,
-0.0153416405,
-0.0003976071,
-6.562265539e-33,
0.0256042052,
0.0446583293,
-0.0567727052,
-0.0101149119,
-0.0067513175,
-0.001466484,
-0.0004423096,
0.0383186229,
-0.0398555696,
0.0267289635,
-0.0144180413,
-0.0037830102,
0.0020124689,
0.0318543725,
0.0695920736,
0.0203684382,
0.052039694,
0.0044557974,
-0.0034704064,
0.0195693579,
0.0205804687,
0.0504039302,
0.072758466,
-0.0735053569,
0.0552918389,
-0.0222216863,
-0.0494366288,
-0.0075251637,
0.0277944282,
0.0515195094,
-0.0203744657,
0.0695817694,
0.0378440022,
0.0087121278,
0.0198200531,
-0.0132191991,
-0.0180688798,
-0.0174240917,
0.0199737642,
0.0319317654,
0.0059266733,
-0.0548163168,
-0.0084998487,
0.0014579539,
-0.0485302582,
0.007670715,
0.0026711538,
-0.044543732,
0.0113718947,
-0.0462097824,
-0.0679915249,
0.0248479545,
0.0112970863,
-0.0097740283,
0.0415104739,
0.0586919226,
-0.0141040348,
0.0038059393,
-0.0345604867,
0.0355799608,
-0.0162450317,
0.02135689,
-0.0165806655,
0.0046077329,
-0.0221196841,
0.0379937105,
0.0467402786,
0.0119034927,
0.0623538122,
0.0470695123,
0.0485849716,
-0.0334575027,
0.0042890259,
0.109548755,
0.0294400658,
-0.0732189715,
-0.0583564192,
-0.0170324631,
0.0417296402,
-0.0202097539,
0.0405947939,
-0.0303735249,
-0.0265802275,
-0.0405854434,
0.0019215759,
-0.0399362259,
-0.0260552093,
-0.0169152692,
0.0019206511,
-0.0292866621,
0.0109753674,
0.0240384191,
0.0163494647,
-0.0395766571,
-0.0557428263,
0.0406657904,
-0.028049184,
0.0281827711,
0.0200037379,
0.0062260833,
-0.0479546823,
-0.0374788605,
-0.0402568802,
0.023664169,
0.0186197218,
-0.0107183782,
0.0843071118,
0.0438948683,
-0.0926067531,
0.0167554822,
0.0009660278,
0.0172424112,
0.0114994366,
0.0897271633,
-0.0150188189,
-0.0032619387,
-0.0003548134,
0.0657262504,
0.0157017764,
0.0026754716,
0.0087301852,
-0.0144645544,
0.0105559779,
0.0156254396,
-0.0372464359,
-0.0405274928,
-0.0164938085,
-0.0205345117,
-0.0019018181,
-0.034633074,
0.0036351359,
-0.010103154,
2.802e-7,
0.0087551987,
0.0495616123,
-0.0412784554,
-0.0514988452,
-0.0032966095,
0.0421104692,
-0.0253769066,
-0.0215290673,
-0.0030146465,
0.048972521,
0.0091857743,
0.0018582381,
0.0739362314,
0.0327429138,
-0.0828399733,
0.0237052422,
-0.0266938359,
-0.0000047691,
-0.0374688432,
-0.0057784724,
0.0117411474,
0.1755171865,
0.0031200233,
-0.0237321518,
-0.0515052453,
-0.022121843,
0.0735985041,
-0.0565265976,
-0.0343049057,
-0.0053349156,
-0.0298875719,
0.0443577431,
-0.0371363759,
-0.0182640385,
-0.031322252,
0.0032719388,
-0.0101368725,
0.0545478277,
0.0084358202,
0.0198908336,
0.0400412194,
0.0326705985,
-0.0686143488,
-0.0179920737,
0.0286604874,
-0.0241700839,
-0.0578360893,
-0.0954936147,
0.0147744585,
-0.006304183,
0.0802296847,
-0.0439665243,
-0.0200137794,
0.022910079,
0.0112273144,
-0.0424750634,
-0.0671698079,
-0.0399584956,
0.0044548968,
0.0300065372,
0.0073689809,
-0.020585075,
0.0165282711,
0.0369095616,
0.0477529839,
-0.0121135106,
0.0727120191,
2.045323895e-34,
0.0589767322,
-0.0387925208,
0.0183669906,
0.0075287567,
-0.0201128572,
-0.023459794,
-0.0121220713,
-0.0137149515,
-0.0006830457,
0.0004055368,
0.0319274142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14179v1 | NAP at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Is Less Really More? (Back-)Translation as Data Augmentation Strategies for Detecting Persuasion Techniques | 2023-04-27T13:33:08 | 2023-04-27T13:33:08 | Neele Falk, Annerose Eichel, Prisca Piccirilli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Persuasion techniques detection in news in a multi-lingual setup is
non-trivial and comes with challenges, including little training data. Our
system successfully leverages (back-)translation as data augmentation
strategies with multi-lingual transformer models for the task of detecting
persuasion techniques. The automatic and human evaluation of our augmented data
allows us to explore whether (back-)translation aid or hinder performance. Our
in-depth analyses indicate that both data augmentation strategies boost
performance; however, balancing human-produced and machine-generated data seems
to be crucial. | [
0.0528217554,
0.0730709732,
-0.015683379,
0.0287587456,
-0.0023841225,
0.0153318364,
0.022148557,
0.0141920745,
-0.0427286811,
-0.0101206945,
-0.0611650012,
-0.0282457601,
0.0230355319,
-0.0016239205,
0.0473227017,
-0.0186794028,
0.0231951214,
0.0055270125,
0.0342389084,
-0.0038629889,
0.0189243946,
0.0115601737,
0.0292032287,
0.0367075168,
0.0011626983,
-0.0178106781,
0.0033799889,
-0.0040066945,
0.053317599,
-0.03211179,
0.0081414524,
0.0848906487,
0.0246672928,
0.0365433618,
0.000001695,
-0.0177601334,
0.0013139542,
-0.0149317347,
-0.0383569859,
-0.005837583,
0.110427022,
-0.060433995,
-0.0216625668,
0.0141180446,
-0.0587654039,
0.0030687109,
0.0497747473,
0.0925506726,
0.0675894022,
0.083116129,
-0.0099930586,
-0.0048846966,
0.0098740682,
-0.0293087289,
-0.0004133715,
0.0003598646,
0.0190268233,
-0.0585547388,
-0.037230663,
0.0546383709,
0.0134602347,
0.0305630714,
-0.0047508543,
-0.0183475818,
-0.0659922361,
-0.0108586615,
-0.0088173933,
-0.0148139577,
-0.0308525059,
0.0160893146,
-0.0155630819,
-0.0100284992,
-0.0302673932,
0.0085139861,
0.0212913789,
0.0100322198,
-0.0263826791,
0.0077876076,
0.0092699742,
-0.0045819534,
0.012229288,
0.0045921486,
0.0179078691,
0.0183801483,
0.0105748093,
0.0139053212,
-0.0227842908,
-0.0356167033,
0.0672737285,
0.0253021158,
0.0241820384,
-0.0530507714,
0.0252512302,
-0.0180100966,
-0.0151856998,
-0.0056495462,
0.0128830466,
-0.0558512025,
0.0191887952,
-0.0991049856,
-0.0144110331,
0.0493306257,
-0.0148248281,
0.0068557491,
-0.0040875259,
0.0090343729,
-0.0292549636,
0.0224289708,
-0.0239007361,
-0.0034552605,
-0.0348008685,
0.0206111055,
-0.0191259049,
-0.022365354,
-0.0054320381,
-0.0134998076,
-0.0726269558,
-0.0117269596,
-0.0494106486,
-0.0046184403,
-0.0344154909,
0.0088416589,
-0.0353882499,
0.000670169,
-0.0147907417,
0.0855080858,
-0.0115499469,
0.0153879514,
0.0373276658,
-0.0436985828,
-0.0042949473,
0.0348167382,
-0.0228367802,
-0.0328592621,
0.0095287953,
-0.015117133,
-0.0472665913,
0.0062214429,
-0.0550699569,
-0.0107264463,
-0.0282945503,
-0.0657489523,
0.0349244326,
-0.049695462,
0.0355217755,
0.0050142487,
0.0164986067,
-0.0360186249,
-0.0016849516,
0.0179465208,
-0.0181630328,
0.0676893294,
0.0607977137,
-0.0094115594,
0.0276800375,
0.0454740413,
-0.0344169289,
0.0829144344,
0.0107914768,
0.1021734476,
0.0271918122,
-0.0339825265,
0.0367410369,
0.0345917568,
0.0251841955,
0.046672143,
0.0016192247,
-0.0237690024,
-0.0507076979,
-0.0067246943,
0.0132683506,
0.0414897539,
-0.0451467149,
0.0009441097,
0.082361035,
0.004715859,
-0.0116100628,
0.0207933951,
0.0177982263,
0.0227833614,
-0.010633301,
0.0344677642,
-0.0392987654,
-0.0066615678,
-0.0436792895,
-0.0314256996,
-0.0050888378,
0.0595808439,
-0.029664522,
-0.0354602747,
0.0180265475,
-0.0069689332,
0.0648629889,
0.0020274953,
0.0260145571,
0.034180399,
-0.0124338651,
-0.0093506947,
0.0238953102,
-0.037798211,
-0.0097604776,
-0.0299847592,
-0.0275393315,
0.0111332638,
-0.0077050785,
0.0426528007,
0.0113029089,
-0.079776153,
0.0210734215,
0.0758153275,
0.0537063703,
-0.0206028931,
-0.0237648673,
-0.0169853028,
-0.0682973489,
0.0018350754,
-0.0016492655,
0.0252929498,
-0.0127494894,
0.04018832,
0.0018363621,
-0.0150601752,
-0.052817665,
0.0098567763,
0.0225182511,
-0.0082064439,
-0.022912018,
0.044954285,
0.0457633063,
0.0431035422,
0.015521327,
-0.0314202197,
0.0377535708,
-0.02346633,
-0.02295902,
0.0244613625,
0.0046409378,
-0.0118895713,
-0.0005474964,
-0.0370528437,
-0.0428386144,
0.0047043543,
0.0011547466,
-0.0092577953,
0.0340341441,
-0.0567029193,
0.0497937873,
-0.0229884759,
-0.0041077738,
-0.012727987,
0.0211760867,
0.0152707072,
0.0390125848,
-0.0048953393,
-0.0113813952,
0.0086786412,
-0.0660704076,
0.0161993094,
-0.0103291329,
0.0056531653,
-0.0224302262,
0.0036985958,
-0.0044874409,
0.0603387877,
-0.0172970202,
-0.0161476079,
-0.0334869511,
-0.0841432288,
-0.0404016003,
-0.0202578548,
0.0305670816,
0.0023090995,
0.0188626871,
0.0071359393,
0.0279445592,
-0.0831543729,
-0.0180347618,
0.0071162954,
0.054118637,
0.002280544,
0.0167196542,
0.0038419198,
0.0147777721,
0.0314451903,
-0.0012747045,
0.0437932387,
0.0165736601,
-0.0569010191,
-0.0510047488,
-0.0278291237,
-0.0093979631,
0.0083394116,
-0.0219866522,
-0.0800917521,
0.0291561987,
0.0359540656,
0.0634946302,
0.0479545854,
0.0410241596,
0.0107913883,
0.0109676672,
0.0465315841,
-0.0610485747,
-0.0159201324,
-0.0534870587,
0.0162503514,
-0.0741560534,
-0.0539394021,
0.0230133645,
0.0161435809,
0.0002337841,
0.0251633525,
-0.0103739258,
0.0362659059,
0.047052525,
-0.0641453713,
-0.0212158393,
-0.0391854979,
-0.0073702922,
0.0625602975,
-0.0082701109,
-0.035681475,
0.0872153416,
-0.0224393029,
-0.0185298901,
-0.0207107756,
-0.022534851,
0.0316220261,
0.0105097238,
-0.0177329239,
0.0414131209,
0.0058520879,
-0.017783301,
-0.0242286082,
-0.0503183007,
0.0223584082,
-0.0383354463,
0.0394608192,
0.0226208027,
-0.0126490844,
0.0404040664,
-0.0417731404,
-0.0701641291,
-0.0352604277,
-0.0149534056,
-0.0466846786,
0.0395104587,
-0.0350612663,
-0.0802651495,
-0.0139058186,
0.0368687026,
0.0373270698,
-0.0140081942,
-0.0270498544,
0.0221382622,
-0.0363514163,
0.0217653997,
0.0130908005,
0.04424458,
-0.0626362488,
-0.0109226098,
0.041140493,
-0.0279804785,
-0.0535384789,
-0.0096817063,
-0.0241899453,
0.0367223881,
0.011463346,
0.0206246916,
-0.0555832088,
0.030603921,
-0.0384377576,
0.0262711365,
0.0717712343,
-0.0065238508,
-0.0812956542,
-0.0044298726,
-0.0180632211,
0.0029232667,
-0.0101085855,
0.0242705047,
-0.0883585587,
-0.0159095842,
-0.0067444001,
0.0278815497,
-0.0318055078,
0.0303761028,
-0.026642574,
-0.0904324427,
0.0424585193,
0.0166465081,
-0.0035081874,
-0.0156052504,
-0.036074575,
-0.0146415131,
-0.0526814312,
0.0248119347,
-0.0567199849,
0.0106531838,
-0.0359323174,
-0.0269525032,
0.0119266519,
-0.0775875226,
-0.0280099157,
-0.0205724631,
-0.0067994329,
0.045239944,
0.0512761138,
0.0028334972,
-0.1138182431,
0.0609204918,
0.0245054346,
-0.0077702762,
-0.0215141568,
0.0617820732,
-0.0372005887,
0.0121352915,
-0.0140514653,
0.0351337232,
-0.0026453871,
-0.006186205,
-0.0057860799,
0.0516465455,
-0.0049126111,
-0.0054003661,
0.0333342999,
0.0144145545,
0.0809449926,
0.0794506595,
0.006677804,
-0.0381634384,
0.0305022318,
-0.0324828215,
-0.0003619732,
-0.0092421547,
-0.0555754006,
-0.0287984181,
-0.0195929818,
-0.0412068516,
-0.0494642444,
-0.0666135624,
-0.005687742,
0.0192375574,
0.0222621225,
-0.007484627,
-0.0360538773,
-0.0004507363,
-0.0078709675,
0.031720411,
-0.0110037979,
0.0264047123,
-0.0318517126,
-0.0239784792,
-0.0499332771,
-0.0507061593,
0.0011317477,
0.0022244568,
-0.0470328294,
-0.0442294553,
-0.0145176118,
0.0369074866,
0.0219341423,
0.0640179366,
0.0175191239,
-0.0060573085,
0.0153587181,
0.0382310711,
-0.0155675048,
-0.0187076218,
0.0623778068,
0.0004306627,
-0.0079080304,
0.0174778923,
0.0422904976,
0.0583909526,
0.0437912606,
-0.0251666699,
-0.0419989713,
-0.0141896736,
0.0344222151,
-0.0132090803,
0.0560188256,
-0.0459151901,
-0.0002901349,
-0.0460040383,
-0.0297332797,
-0.0012410004,
-0.0256999824,
-0.0293931309,
-0.0366356187,
0.0307025649,
-0.0005991784,
0.0312514976,
0.043228779,
-0.0661478937,
-0.0243410338,
-0.0672359616,
0.0571469627,
0.004630215,
0.0550158285,
-0.0183736719,
0.0333662331,
0.0115358178,
0.0493244119,
0.0402922817,
0.0504360087,
0.0077621546,
0.0512741432,
0.0255970638,
-0.0152296713,
0.0556498617,
0.0398610979,
-0.0343361385,
-0.0103294356,
-0.0207724348,
-0.0211339295,
-0.0020841127,
-0.01866371,
0.0831175447,
-0.0113819428,
-0.0173827745,
-0.0041060019,
0.0049318206,
-0.0296080559,
-0.012408928,
-0.0102978591,
-0.0199496076,
-0.0290940031,
0.0205277484,
0.0163126402,
-0.1118123308,
0.0226844121,
-0.0012947627,
-0.0602695271,
-0.0251514427,
-0.0298257209,
0.0387108102,
0.0002954302,
-0.0174406264,
0.0032821095,
-0.0349933617,
-0.0196058918,
-0.0292280875,
0.0037595897,
-0.0165646914,
-0.0089328457,
0.0046492866,
0.059609089,
-0.0412269942,
0.0317126885,
-0.0456455201,
0.0050332365,
0.0077212011,
-0.0133336522,
0.0045028199,
-5.891226875e-33,
0.0326858126,
-0.0165051445,
-0.0019228338,
0.0189493988,
-0.0197530854,
-0.0119115375,
-0.0160359386,
0.0032806785,
-0.0215846337,
0.0902305245,
0.0176265966,
0.0090809967,
0.0136062121,
-0.0178306531,
-0.0056920671,
0.0205623899,
0.0777897909,
0.0248270165,
-0.0809840113,
0.0216544289,
0.0620808415,
-0.0064389799,
0.0799941868,
-0.0873151124,
0.0644604489,
-0.0105013624,
-0.0510983057,
-0.0086725149,
0.0487754233,
0.0689966753,
0.0069623962,
0.0284445006,
0.0059171245,
-0.0797855258,
0.0163098425,
0.0781121999,
-0.0274303351,
-0.0151255839,
0.0492910296,
0.0143829631,
0.0118374005,
-0.0216784682,
0.0190124735,
-0.0436299369,
-0.0200606231,
0.0217293203,
-0.0061732405,
-0.0408616662,
0.0368369706,
0.0238073878,
-0.0667830482,
-0.0067577474,
-0.0023285218,
-0.004937931,
0.0096357893,
0.1194537804,
-0.018985182,
0.019192338,
-0.0930126756,
0.0491030514,
0.0260409787,
0.0086545777,
0.063319549,
-0.0223137587,
-0.0406303778,
0.0574462563,
0.0149759036,
0.0020234128,
-0.0125945555,
0.0063975877,
0.0225516371,
0.034119267,
0.0767726451,
0.0606813468,
0.0330328122,
-0.0387020446,
-0.0363432243,
0.0504431948,
0.0740610957,
0.0066574016,
0.0317840837,
-0.0016779711,
-0.0199228656,
-0.0259948,
-0.0135840699,
-0.0400097221,
-0.0207426418,
-0.0549875945,
0.011158268,
0.0482499003,
-0.0297213439,
0.05979589,
0.0531775206,
-0.0429558493,
-0.006369954,
0.0127687091,
-0.0040848106,
0.0031383403,
0.0161908902,
-0.0342088677,
-0.0470051467,
-0.0212147292,
0.0180207919,
0.0292371325,
0.0076734829,
-0.0081537953,
0.1016344577,
0.0090033766,
-0.0566414818,
-0.0015546037,
-0.0172336251,
0.0471457504,
-0.0160890184,
0.0189416502,
0.0317189358,
-0.0041225199,
-0.0102009028,
0.0297676288,
0.0072946697,
0.0100706089,
-0.0088759661,
-0.002948011,
0.0147448443,
0.0416821241,
-0.0335829891,
-0.000224827,
-0.0014211487,
-0.0029734059,
0.0311713666,
-0.0598103218,
-0.0136267561,
-0.0423973873,
2.477e-7,
0.0188922565,
0.042271167,
-0.0158549361,
-0.0018452344,
0.0106792226,
0.0477178134,
-0.0247919597,
0.003841202,
0.0223570969,
-0.0682458356,
0.0081915604,
0.0213151481,
0.051094003,
0.037194863,
-0.0680588335,
-0.0530549139,
-0.0249349568,
-0.0230497103,
-0.0292039998,
0.0094448011,
0.0195992701,
0.0833119154,
0.0026971232,
-0.0202177297,
-0.0026465296,
0.0168134738,
0.0719515011,
-0.0264091771,
-0.0432604626,
0.0145271076,
0.0392265357,
-0.0246584192,
-0.0071575358,
0.0251861103,
-0.0346207023,
0.0190377701,
-0.0355573073,
0.0376247279,
0.0159990843,
-0.0210813005,
-0.0104502616,
-0.0038005945,
-0.0230209846,
-0.0174434558,
0.0121835787,
-0.080872938,
-0.0551798046,
-0.0414815992,
-0.0235330109,
0.0109315868,
0.0377118029,
-0.0256376453,
-0.0320168808,
-0.0006215336,
0.042100668,
0.0248006918,
-0.0034650932,
-0.023431791,
0.0172844213,
-0.0113480855,
-0.0013321188,
-0.0697517022,
-0.0102183791,
-0.0200330056,
-0.0299711749,
-0.018422246,
-0.0021720473,
1.815881288e-34,
0.0699346364,
-0.0050841155,
0.02607009,
-0.0239452142,
0.02847239,
0.0132709499,
0.0255021602,
-0.0211267993,
0.0265213512,
-0.0414799079,
-0.0164011475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14178v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14178v3 | mPLUG-Owl: Modularization Empowers Large Language Models with Multimodality | 2023-04-27T13:27:01 | 2024-03-29T08:13:38 | Qinghao Ye, Haiyang Xu, Guohai Xu, Jiabo Ye, Ming Yan, Yiyang Zhou, Junyang Wang, Anwen Hu, Pengcheng Shi, Yaya Shi, Chenliang Li, Yuanhong Xu, Hehong Chen, Junfeng Tian, Qi Qian, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive zero-shot abilities
on a variety of open-ended tasks, while recent research has also explored the
use of LLMs for multi-modal generation. In this study, we introduce mPLUG-Owl,
a novel training paradigm that equips LLMs with multi-modal abilities through
modularized learning of foundation LLM, a visual knowledge module, and a visual
abstractor module. This approach can support multiple modalities and facilitate
diverse unimodal and multimodal abilities through modality collaboration. The
training paradigm of mPLUG-Owl involves a two-stage method for aligning image
and text, which learns visual knowledge with the assistance of LLM while
maintaining and even improving the generation abilities of LLM. In the first
stage, the visual knowledge module and abstractor module are trained with a
frozen LLM module to align the image and text. In the second stage,
language-only and multi-modal supervised datasets are used to jointly fine-tune
a low-rank adaption (LoRA) module on LLM and the abstractor module by freezing
the visual knowledge module. We carefully build a visually-related instruction
evaluation set OwlEval. Experimental results show that our model outperforms
existing multi-modal models, demonstrating mPLUG-Owl's impressive instruction
and visual understanding ability, multi-turn conversation ability, and
knowledge reasoning ability. Besides, we observe some unexpected and exciting
abilities such as multi-image correlation and scene text understanding, which
makes it possible to leverage it for harder real scenarios, such as vision-only
document comprehension. Our code, pre-trained model, instruction-tuned models,
and evaluation set are available at https://github.com/X-PLUG/mPLUG-Owl. The
online demo is available at https://www.modelscope.cn/studios/damo/mPLUG-Owl. | [
0.0180990249,
0.086249575,
0.0104536982,
0.0423928909,
-0.01158683,
0.0236233603,
0.0264671352,
-0.0371732153,
-0.016375687,
-0.0666492954,
-0.0748330727,
-0.0075770225,
-0.0063782823,
0.038501244,
0.0363465622,
-0.0565160699,
0.0166460387,
-0.036759492,
-0.0231625233,
0.0112168398,
0.0410629213,
0.0459486507,
-0.0319286846,
0.0259378683,
-0.0017995478,
-0.0334981084,
-0.0516584143,
0.0182791967,
-0.0009316641,
-0.0255061295,
-0.0274474341,
0.046571698,
0.0533943437,
0.0208311696,
0.0000019898,
-0.0096630193,
0.0045620189,
-0.0121799009,
0.0333428495,
-0.0404337011,
0.0444250219,
-0.0341947526,
0.0280138534,
-0.0150659215,
-0.0282122046,
-0.0213901363,
0.0562687442,
0.0589053556,
0.0547932722,
0.0700335801,
-0.0194560383,
0.0043884688,
0.0249949601,
-0.0011717876,
0.0316953287,
-0.0193175618,
-0.023372028,
0.0293398872,
-0.0075523825,
0.0188144948,
-0.0511521287,
0.0411155671,
0.0168385897,
-0.0174695682,
-0.0037023709,
0.040952269,
0.0022326026,
-0.0416948795,
-0.0223062877,
0.1138430685,
-0.0081732525,
-0.0066437046,
-0.0156436991,
0.0167137757,
0.0000049819,
0.0058281138,
-0.0437292792,
0.0483661704,
-0.0001739091,
0.0186437666,
-0.004102096,
-0.0252811164,
0.0094553996,
0.0342584923,
-0.0155979302,
0.0294974111,
0.0148405833,
0.0103476495,
-0.0175280832,
0.0017506675,
-0.035512913,
-0.0315089785,
-0.0440543145,
0.0618022978,
-0.0261224043,
0.0354716331,
-0.0581953675,
-0.0497020856,
0.0083986968,
-0.0164989419,
0.0461451598,
0.0289944336,
-0.0544837527,
0.0544192754,
-0.0274832658,
0.0425002873,
-0.0115529178,
0.0570801385,
-0.0511063114,
-0.0125781633,
-0.0485242344,
-0.0096588572,
-0.0318808407,
0.0044239904,
-0.0609315597,
-0.0482714884,
0.0005713096,
0.0353467092,
0.0022366431,
0.0156188533,
-0.0039364276,
0.0105454614,
-0.0438474976,
-0.032207787,
-0.0142641971,
0.0629817545,
0.0118890963,
0.0278476905,
0.0014624241,
-0.0248975642,
0.0066348114,
0.0562444106,
0.0078281304,
-0.0199758541,
-0.0092831785,
0.0870105773,
-0.080051966,
-0.0264834315,
0.0162636954,
-0.0353350937,
-0.0100835208,
-0.0781818703,
0.0255759861,
-0.039387174,
0.0441627465,
0.0013983331,
0.0013862622,
0.0074032578,
0.0105807688,
-0.0059167612,
-0.0092388196,
0.0825338885,
-0.0012982738,
-0.0095032146,
0.0096441545,
0.0288030803,
-0.0102068195,
0.0919136032,
0.0258306991,
0.0250214543,
0.0178692285,
0.0045555704,
-0.0266439095,
0.0339965113,
0.0036383769,
0.0002561165,
0.0126093794,
-0.0043499945,
0.0039357436,
0.0411942638,
0.0398420617,
0.0162263587,
-0.0307758953,
-0.0108781084,
0.0820035413,
-0.030671617,
0.0477826372,
0.0076878094,
0.0327122957,
0.0086725298,
-0.0064973645,
-0.0076589724,
-0.0679584369,
0.0634002909,
-0.034996856,
0.0294640716,
-0.0172880311,
0.0373566002,
-0.0498692095,
-0.0208095647,
0.0106997974,
-0.002543587,
0.0003901524,
0.0096825883,
0.0498949364,
0.0233682673,
-0.0749681368,
0.0467159078,
0.0164038427,
-0.0338136181,
0.0192838293,
-0.0200483203,
0.0390358195,
0.0365064554,
0.0224897414,
0.010315218,
-0.0431095287,
0.0010330394,
0.0185418874,
0.0533612035,
0.0051756781,
-0.0082961377,
0.0404308215,
-0.0682942197,
-0.0285215564,
-0.0334042609,
-0.0097650103,
0.0183019657,
-0.0116797052,
-0.0008689865,
0.0108319884,
-0.0400886014,
0.032132443,
0.0437064394,
0.0041211396,
0.0103329001,
-0.0541079715,
0.0179549064,
0.0045211995,
-0.022787407,
-0.0087250555,
-0.0228949301,
0.0140591012,
-0.0316684507,
0.024035532,
0.0482112318,
-0.0628948286,
-0.0464748628,
0.0355239175,
-0.0263563618,
-0.0083173299,
0.015970001,
-0.0498686992,
-0.0365124606,
0.0269369334,
0.0040242774,
0.0204380993,
-0.0627311468,
-0.0057112924,
0.040054433,
0.0091070812,
-0.0172006879,
0.0382939577,
-0.0176389851,
-0.0040099137,
0.0212677103,
0.0062509449,
0.0051799333,
0.0103958137,
-0.0073190494,
0.010658904,
0.0039396966,
0.0247092694,
-0.0315631106,
0.0253842305,
-0.0522029288,
-0.0591297224,
-0.1311053485,
-0.0029889743,
-0.0163070299,
-0.0198533237,
0.0411501788,
-0.0195208881,
0.0125144245,
-0.0292605013,
-0.0238637049,
0.0718982816,
0.0205163918,
-0.0236631148,
0.0236818306,
0.0322029665,
-0.0012401085,
-0.0027435338,
0.0159182884,
0.0230530202,
0.0528630726,
0.0040196115,
0.0072562005,
-0.0365946554,
0.0225131866,
-0.0491466224,
0.0262194611,
-0.0337191708,
-0.028185837,
0.0290288515,
-0.0300592836,
0.0434459113,
0.0401239768,
0.0233756881,
0.0289858039,
0.047597535,
-0.0247683022,
-0.0322297141,
0.0014757852,
0.0118694566,
-0.015171174,
-0.0316867232,
0.0060537145,
-0.028483009,
0.0545304753,
-0.0120020546,
0.0032419858,
-0.0503044315,
-0.0100205317,
0.0278294198,
-0.0569557771,
-0.0532061569,
0.0268542375,
0.0113341184,
-0.007850999,
-0.065138258,
-0.0572769493,
0.0492096134,
-0.047772944,
-0.024064457,
-0.0090018287,
0.0109862648,
-0.0181032401,
0.0691401139,
0.0245725941,
0.0483687967,
-0.0076387706,
-0.0236851871,
-0.0697354227,
-0.0369827785,
0.0021991467,
-0.0003607713,
0.0606452525,
-0.0579636618,
0.0051748049,
-0.043768812,
-0.0173214674,
-0.0148222372,
-0.0269562304,
-0.0123025989,
0.0219825394,
-0.0589264855,
-0.0176465884,
-0.0680807978,
-0.0151356487,
0.0363226384,
0.0356230177,
-0.0032344933,
-0.0118826171,
-0.0276425704,
0.0450316742,
0.064342916,
0.0638813078,
-0.0416357368,
-0.0623197109,
0.0422167443,
0.0537360758,
0.0256165732,
-0.0361640453,
-0.0472116247,
0.029651165,
0.0011863046,
0.0293908231,
-0.0006461728,
0.0076482794,
0.0682831556,
-0.0549901836,
0.0109256776,
0.0769766867,
-0.0046520568,
-0.0122747142,
-0.0380617529,
0.0058661308,
0.0720816776,
0.0300797224,
0.016337689,
-0.0970603004,
-0.0399842374,
-0.0118736541,
-0.0179460999,
0.0399616025,
-0.0045830491,
-0.027105052,
-0.0800629184,
0.0375287831,
0.0113723893,
-0.0539904311,
-0.0077204118,
0.016759729,
-0.0190856829,
0.0086440342,
-0.0038967752,
0.0196729414,
-0.0126750935,
-0.0014398287,
0.0063560144,
0.0396777689,
0.0026496267,
0.0184755195,
-0.0291081034,
0.0212089811,
0.0116228955,
0.0368420258,
0.0010969144,
-0.0489969328,
0.0089088846,
-0.0007032505,
0.0205154549,
-0.0038414395,
0.0416809693,
-0.0391230434,
-0.0315037444,
-0.0188898034,
0.0451546758,
0.0024556385,
-0.0242935661,
-0.0291101765,
0.0437618494,
-0.0234906673,
0.0018285986,
-0.0136352619,
0.0298849773,
-0.0048287744,
0.0385566056,
-0.004516514,
-0.0325090922,
-0.028690394,
0.0134699102,
-0.020078484,
-0.061190553,
0.020454824,
0.0179295633,
-0.0126180965,
0.0354721472,
-0.0554415882,
0.0014310949,
0.046524398,
0.0608303472,
-0.0029079744,
-0.0108536296,
-0.0436405838,
-0.0019434961,
-0.0478700548,
0.0707889944,
-0.0227324478,
-0.0027028772,
-0.0346020497,
-0.0231421664,
0.0456435755,
-0.0815055445,
-0.0076570939,
0.0296208188,
-0.0695730671,
-0.0493445583,
-0.0379241072,
0.0555171929,
0.015451164,
0.0556963161,
0.0408937894,
-0.0445501953,
0.0208936259,
0.035149239,
-0.0143776247,
0.017365111,
0.011447127,
-0.0064112749,
0.0030501888,
0.0237794388,
-0.0359885842,
0.0034378206,
0.0122191599,
0.0253903586,
-0.0011035299,
-0.0061142188,
0.0208249018,
0.0034266524,
-0.0062189121,
-0.0363936536,
0.0221576914,
-0.0592085719,
0.0171100348,
-0.0078811329,
-0.0157877412,
-0.0748711675,
0.0023976688,
0.0199188888,
-0.0161313433,
0.0280348025,
0.0081466334,
0.0332659557,
0.0499635637,
-0.0143868243,
0.0309313107,
0.0039657238,
-0.03362602,
0.0033696194,
0.0413407609,
-0.0097153494,
0.0082817404,
-0.0351105034,
0.0327631049,
-0.0190262143,
0.1189333126,
0.0147864213,
-0.016744053,
-0.0488646738,
0.0376507826,
-0.0147229545,
-0.0378287248,
-0.0377079509,
0.0681775063,
0.037821874,
0.0266483221,
0.033967074,
-0.0403124392,
-0.0109426724,
-0.0014613745,
0.0803206116,
-0.0159036592,
-0.0456577763,
0.0600007623,
0.0199871492,
0.0103047453,
-0.0014541718,
0.0657574385,
0.0129798055,
0.0404370427,
-0.0116696572,
0.0404221117,
-0.0548087545,
-0.0079677776,
0.0756037831,
0.0101296827,
-0.0240616836,
0.023545932,
0.0145344995,
-0.0534459576,
-0.0130210388,
0.0250085033,
-0.0228612535,
0.0090006031,
0.0249356572,
0.0515798405,
-0.0087797055,
-0.0340514965,
-0.0358940065,
-0.0127673419,
0.0209411681,
0.0123465816,
0.0050817537,
-6.06549428e-33,
-0.0556811802,
-0.0205318201,
0.0570182987,
-0.012888859,
-0.031938117,
0.0091767907,
-0.0247193146,
0.0305537693,
-0.0146310152,
0.0059556654,
0.0454805829,
-0.0337640233,
-0.0033302822,
0.05927727,
-0.0119131161,
0.0206125863,
0.0164793581,
-0.0266617946,
-0.0074541955,
0.0113412449,
0.0479756109,
0.0161387473,
0.0286046825,
-0.0418450125,
-0.0127225872,
-0.0058983359,
-0.0538805984,
0.013358146,
0.0017914827,
0.0695867389,
-0.0174135342,
0.0020684039,
0.0184079539,
0.0294212755,
-0.0329250805,
0.0207834672,
-0.0948276371,
0.0144106904,
0.0360786803,
0.0320809707,
-0.0942097232,
-0.0112983286,
0.0410418808,
-0.0330070257,
0.0157573204,
-0.0435877331,
0.0364436693,
-0.0206999816,
0.0064933184,
0.0251834877,
-0.065692395,
-0.01250281,
-0.0234096758,
-0.0545295626,
0.0337934047,
0.0395420939,
0.0185627192,
0.0048206486,
-0.037652649,
0.0189372599,
-0.0291026775,
0.0133333774,
0.0891638175,
0.0497788601,
-0.0100737065,
0.0615480989,
0.0074753105,
-0.0283338763,
-0.0222370028,
0.0003044984,
0.0388566218,
0.1040148586,
0.0015240664,
0.0640917122,
0.0063038641,
0.0332929231,
-0.0328354016,
0.0248896014,
-0.0153906969,
0.0487105362,
0.0206650924,
0.0165570658,
0.0065640393,
0.0293506756,
-0.0489906333,
0.0130091477,
-0.0652152598,
-0.0322804227,
0.0408141576,
0.0525674708,
-0.0015867571,
-0.0205366742,
0.0850124359,
-0.0463250615,
0.0216786359,
0.0038633037,
-0.042430196,
0.0596145093,
-0.023078477,
0.0054283761,
-0.0536139868,
-0.0712852702,
0.0763306692,
-0.0171324797,
-0.0137798097,
0.0161078721,
0.0555273406,
0.0408699922,
-0.0517762937,
0.0096014533,
-0.0475310907,
0.0078673009,
-0.0129225105,
0.0383466855,
0.0200700164,
-0.0224238466,
-0.0798148885,
-0.0032577962,
-0.0336582623,
-0.0229294617,
-0.0249702558,
-0.0328314826,
-0.0092337253,
0.019966349,
-0.0247551538,
0.0269167591,
-0.0415159836,
-0.1106046811,
0.0079952674,
-0.0427672081,
-0.0039323298,
0.0554101765,
2.701e-7,
0.0328610279,
0.0188125391,
-0.0065732817,
-0.0022205422,
0.0283753164,
0.0274415761,
-0.0437169448,
0.031392619,
0.0049707913,
-0.0605599619,
0.0010807238,
0.0424729586,
0.0480684936,
-0.0021697932,
-0.0215191916,
0.0156583935,
-0.0033118231,
-0.0197109655,
-0.0437510423,
-0.0091769295,
0.057870701,
0.0794554874,
-0.0315288305,
-0.0176509153,
0.0462729558,
-0.0504210889,
0.1083766073,
-0.0253784265,
-0.0371004641,
-0.0074631744,
0.0140021462,
0.016465053,
-0.0238689594,
0.014991032,
0.0085540339,
-0.0195411574,
0.0154487379,
0.0592297651,
0.0034175119,
-0.034546379,
0.0153043158,
0.006398648,
-0.0237523541,
-0.070855245,
0.0586272739,
-0.0336756557,
-0.0404549576,
-0.0402761251,
-0.0237374324,
0.0060365321,
-0.0080311345,
-0.0263918359,
-0.0333917364,
0.0304803532,
0.0407019854,
-0.0331806876,
-0.0348683521,
-0.0643693507,
-0.0465506501,
-0.0012362554,
-0.051437337,
-0.0330832563,
-0.050201185,
-0.0607059672,
0.0368085988,
-0.0838958025,
-0.0499080308,
2.115070888e-34,
0.0031205218,
-0.0259108525,
0.0018981693,
0.0139283184,
0.0207614973,
-0.0210329443,
-0.0263500847,
-0.0163264312,
0.0097380849,
-0.0862680897,
-0.0078563299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14177v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14177v2 | ChatGPT vs State-of-the-Art Models: A Benchmarking Study in Keyphrase Generation Task | 2023-04-27T13:25:43 | 2023-06-29T13:40:42 | Roberto Martínez-Cruz, Alvaro J. López-López, José Portela | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer-based language models, including ChatGPT, have demonstrated
exceptional performance in various natural language generation tasks. However,
there has been limited research evaluating ChatGPT's keyphrase generation
ability, which involves identifying informative phrases that accurately reflect
a document's content. This study seeks to address this gap by comparing
ChatGPT's keyphrase generation performance with state-of-the-art models, while
also testing its potential as a solution for two significant challenges in the
field: domain adaptation and keyphrase generation from long documents. We
conducted experiments on six publicly available datasets from scientific
articles and news domains, analyzing performance on both short and long
documents. Our results show that ChatGPT outperforms current state-of-the-art
models in all tested datasets and environments, generating high-quality
keyphrases that adapt well to diverse domains and document lengths. | [
0.0818913355,
0.0299813617,
0.0011608788,
-0.0071593821,
-0.0742743164,
-0.0216151867,
-0.0200403873,
0.0160622932,
0.0028206173,
-0.0667478144,
-0.0067993789,
0.009434903,
-0.0345605612,
0.0572214872,
0.0014021853,
-0.0510811508,
0.032636445,
-0.0180471502,
-0.0034032885,
0.0075964709,
0.0039165928,
0.0190831497,
0.0069087762,
0.0454853848,
0.0398328006,
0.0021648714,
-0.0075516887,
-0.0113837682,
0.0068020439,
-0.0111856628,
0.0225454643,
0.0438395254,
0.0038885619,
0.0408497527,
0.0000016493,
-0.0548505597,
-0.0399104357,
-0.0051393597,
0.0481550135,
0.0220251698,
0.1131446809,
-0.0441072434,
-0.0008934769,
0.0395905375,
-0.0396828763,
-0.0069733998,
0.0335119851,
0.0437719524,
0.0568774082,
0.0718676746,
-0.0202930197,
-0.0461501218,
0.054274343,
-0.0277337711,
-0.0230329409,
-0.0627080724,
0.0124783302,
-0.0281552356,
-0.017505018,
0.0594802424,
0.003965863,
0.0261521377,
-0.0131029952,
-0.000997128,
0.0580509119,
0.025581995,
-0.0835962445,
-0.0227296464,
-0.0212891027,
0.035466101,
-0.007991476,
-0.0167801306,
0.0600821041,
-0.012032222,
0.0105057843,
0.0399555825,
-0.0649195015,
0.0159646049,
-0.0077650361,
-0.0208664164,
-0.0069389064,
0.0022622403,
-0.0205021221,
0.0257707294,
-0.0326641016,
0.0014570686,
0.0632908568,
-0.0290164892,
-0.0257093925,
-0.0121302949,
-0.0623907857,
-0.0405561067,
0.0109278737,
0.006753671,
0.009163117,
0.0356945805,
-0.0594346821,
-0.0107596833,
0.0650435835,
-0.0868986025,
-0.0438284092,
-0.0147555508,
0.01556338,
0.023845898,
-0.0334716961,
0.0583508611,
-0.0080869691,
-0.0020497416,
-0.0397775657,
-0.020397108,
-0.0747895241,
-0.0363957211,
-0.0333024412,
0.0298770275,
0.018930627,
-0.0700043216,
-0.065120548,
0.0286954828,
0.0747114494,
-0.0266702473,
0.0237276573,
0.0182832554,
-0.0618833378,
-0.0303691104,
0.0197633244,
0.0100027313,
0.0104035996,
0.0015335003,
0.0427111201,
-0.0282213129,
-0.0000372226,
0.0230566952,
0.0171692912,
-0.0230901446,
0.0027400858,
0.0462834388,
-0.0146234334,
-0.0269173365,
0.0085759629,
-0.0288012754,
-0.0433529094,
-0.0207861997,
0.0452076569,
-0.0620664433,
0.0309009161,
0.0378485881,
-0.0058298199,
-0.0333113335,
0.0215506833,
0.0389493406,
-0.0678071901,
0.0329157896,
0.000259725,
0.0220837891,
0.0302507188,
0.0147158317,
-0.0218480062,
0.0300942287,
0.0305474941,
0.0292039346,
0.0593008436,
-0.0256550293,
0.0311689656,
0.0029909948,
0.0197930746,
0.0111903679,
0.0424898602,
0.0035229411,
-0.0368466265,
0.0321636796,
-0.0070443964,
0.0463882945,
-0.0020492251,
0.0247612763,
0.058986757,
0.0608135387,
0.0352497622,
0.0610798337,
0.0107338335,
0.0639539212,
-0.0189338475,
0.0025032333,
0.0085104955,
-0.0083760256,
-0.0031383026,
0.054112751,
0.0233543664,
0.0652696639,
0.0031050961,
-0.0102481721,
-0.0277531389,
0.0212995745,
-0.0056291176,
-0.0607394315,
0.0424197763,
0.0397180133,
-0.0629989058,
0.0906480774,
0.0125022158,
-0.0674786866,
-0.0176616311,
-0.0604610369,
-0.0446368717,
0.0416858084,
0.0851158798,
0.0190965272,
-0.0645933822,
0.0082083391,
0.0248031914,
0.090664573,
0.0403206199,
0.02485504,
-0.0519056842,
-0.0497467928,
-0.0245304741,
-0.0165368766,
0.0212204475,
-0.022675639,
0.0281669758,
0.0327304676,
0.0540045425,
-0.0455227047,
0.0118104573,
0.0295178555,
-0.0416551568,
0.0025227733,
0.0013342102,
-0.0512769669,
-0.005495185,
-0.0035504571,
-0.0079233516,
0.0411980003,
0.0181793924,
-0.0239332356,
-0.0411520787,
0.0408379324,
-0.0112340683,
-0.003474595,
0.0142665785,
-0.0661598295,
0.0594397336,
0.0096863452,
-0.0162380021,
-0.0341731198,
0.0304421857,
-0.0431234315,
0.0399464853,
-0.0267282538,
0.0261622779,
-0.0120880194,
0.0268201381,
-0.0413344391,
0.0612533055,
0.0281313714,
-0.0055366941,
-0.0395823121,
-0.0314880684,
0.0103222635,
0.0007367152,
0.0190739371,
0.0145836687,
-0.0132436864,
-0.0091356356,
0.0488348454,
0.0186431073,
-0.034294717,
-0.0611935742,
-0.0667162985,
0.0192354023,
0.013917516,
0.0076341573,
0.0352951847,
0.0313527063,
-0.0211554412,
0.0287672728,
-0.0417149886,
-0.0228823964,
0.0231264569,
0.0138017423,
0.0310433544,
0.0033916107,
-0.0316183157,
-0.0339721628,
0.0275739245,
-0.0104655456,
0.055204913,
0.040193595,
-0.0344267897,
-0.0250516627,
0.0704249516,
0.0074771559,
-0.0602366216,
0.0017149872,
-0.0405143239,
0.005402687,
0.0089075631,
0.0732034743,
-0.0091950633,
0.078380838,
-0.0210083891,
-0.0076111546,
-0.0171940383,
-0.0349161141,
-0.0319232382,
-0.0597719103,
-0.0402712896,
0.0136204511,
-0.0373923108,
0.0829826593,
0.0404711962,
0.0067253541,
0.0094494903,
-0.0582847223,
0.0413791463,
-0.0125202937,
0.0125613874,
-0.0016473464,
0.0128325364,
-0.0064832107,
0.0120093469,
-0.0095616011,
-0.0108724236,
0.0267929733,
-0.0265481118,
0.0315381587,
-0.0889374316,
0.010714124,
-0.0559972338,
0.0334796533,
-0.0182699356,
0.0163339209,
0.0445265621,
-0.0173757263,
-0.0174528155,
0.0001270404,
0.0059457538,
-0.0394857451,
0.0367725566,
-0.0412578546,
0.0107305171,
0.0013279368,
0.00056058,
-0.0315632112,
-0.0390959457,
0.0084573077,
-0.0108418176,
0.0667592064,
-0.0293242093,
-0.0114826281,
0.0407321267,
-0.0051211976,
0.0224366654,
-0.0363555029,
-0.0292492937,
0.0097762682,
0.0424019992,
0.0924286246,
-0.0232194308,
0.0034153212,
-0.0059120143,
0.0164648797,
0.0403234512,
0.041768793,
-0.0001169412,
-0.0266017504,
-0.0364958905,
0.004396033,
-0.0633386523,
-0.0298249405,
-0.0312320627,
0.0199231487,
-0.0099783503,
-0.0318917446,
0.1090156958,
0.0398844033,
-0.0431093313,
-0.0009383564,
-0.005264034,
0.0208424125,
-0.0175624993,
0.0337333269,
-0.0598264784,
-0.0151100578,
-0.001529137,
0.026591761,
0.0026366212,
-0.0122621367,
-0.0339321196,
-0.0727163926,
0.0557818934,
0.0156823751,
-0.0008753747,
-0.0056419508,
-0.0521748886,
-0.0225556344,
-0.0223597232,
-0.0172905121,
-0.0134399887,
-0.0605584756,
0.0268160272,
-0.0015014339,
-0.0542494468,
-0.0587429516,
0.0058795894,
-0.0465608686,
0.0035887356,
0.0735698938,
0.0359603688,
0.0089124208,
0.0036986275,
0.0204413328,
0.0225425884,
-0.010995931,
0.0100654066,
0.0161946248,
-0.0044966885,
0.0175758358,
-0.0066731372,
0.0329023115,
-0.0588897727,
-0.0172278043,
0.0648010597,
0.0269164909,
-0.0025708606,
-0.0020300262,
-0.0541155748,
0.0241039544,
-0.0185257681,
0.0965816155,
0.0231885221,
-0.018774448,
-0.0491137691,
0.0119196102,
0.026899606,
-0.0640870631,
-0.0665974692,
-0.0379473567,
-0.0424685888,
0.0118767451,
-0.0883150548,
-0.0302977953,
0.006170155,
-0.0095627951,
0.0039495663,
0.0224695858,
-0.0211133212,
0.0133347036,
-0.049959369,
-0.0068751145,
-0.0222032107,
-0.0393523946,
-0.0414297991,
-0.0040874248,
0.0731138214,
-0.0247019604,
-0.0324442387,
0.0161048006,
-0.0486979224,
-0.0400891788,
0.0306674168,
-0.0026009104,
0.0252858438,
0.0015587072,
-0.0104219485,
0.0132636027,
0.0502139181,
0.0819338858,
-0.0388217643,
0.0038344946,
-0.002118821,
-0.0024850937,
-0.0265298039,
0.0124797057,
-0.0468527004,
0.0144195119,
-0.0198968668,
0.0823804587,
0.0096317772,
-0.0601636916,
0.0112293242,
0.0093365274,
0.0204818435,
-0.0489856638,
-0.0108473087,
-0.0114623737,
-0.0147382217,
-0.0058257785,
0.0126697747,
-0.0523601286,
0.0262874216,
0.0238395091,
-0.0008548881,
-0.0046281884,
0.0428660102,
-0.0869579166,
0.0432099067,
-0.0535594188,
-0.0017152574,
-0.009432015,
0.0052011656,
0.0025011005,
-0.0275530107,
-0.0158630051,
-0.037838392,
-0.0191857498,
0.0004126249,
-0.0282371994,
0.0249787029,
0.0082711503,
-0.0142562846,
-0.0166009255,
0.0748639107,
-0.0927972272,
-0.0118970191,
-0.0552591793,
0.0316654965,
0.048234228,
0.0158809889,
0.0515911244,
-0.0537166931,
-0.0200815909,
-0.0026280957,
0.0670397505,
0.0055765943,
0.0085536698,
-0.013364342,
-0.0013754466,
-0.034029454,
-0.0244655553,
0.0975387692,
0.0408090092,
0.0403157622,
0.0279796049,
-0.0450446196,
-0.017885657,
-0.0169575252,
0.0209445823,
-0.0281182192,
0.0205687005,
0.0102660246,
-0.0443340167,
-0.0064697564,
0.042078007,
-0.0286996402,
0.0325074233,
-0.0232494157,
0.0260275956,
0.1009682193,
-0.0233572349,
-0.0189339276,
-0.0683890805,
0.0352500714,
-0.0313171707,
-0.0215326268,
-0.0042768312,
-5.886296411e-33,
-0.0151648959,
0.0038761278,
0.0140425283,
0.0455231182,
-0.0361289307,
0.0016980934,
-0.022906879,
-0.0184072163,
0.019977631,
-0.0004456954,
-0.0320572406,
0.0031668777,
0.0043523158,
0.0197648071,
0.020997189,
-0.0126912547,
0.0319557823,
-0.0051955096,
-0.03598186,
0.0523626916,
0.0082660392,
0.0402686298,
0.0517369956,
-0.0356830768,
-0.0109387944,
-0.0328330547,
-0.0087516401,
-0.0521626994,
0.0530658141,
0.0688370913,
-0.0075793732,
0.0133401453,
0.0284477081,
-0.0880670995,
-0.0133574465,
0.005974052,
-0.0362911411,
0.0044848779,
0.0187998638,
-0.0232881978,
0.0195821635,
-0.0558970012,
0.0323305912,
-0.0326967873,
-0.0157325082,
-0.0259181242,
0.0378793888,
-0.0345865302,
-0.038845107,
-0.0642733425,
-0.0605798513,
0.0297371894,
0.0219963547,
-0.0226603672,
-0.0266768783,
0.0192467552,
-0.0266936217,
0.0523876697,
0.0147958715,
0.0438779555,
0.0702053383,
0.0393715687,
0.0409810729,
0.0167225003,
0.0031678365,
0.0534151345,
-0.0198443662,
-0.0139775919,
0.0142439306,
0.0426138043,
0.0114897918,
0.0486243777,
0.034377858,
0.0715717599,
0.0307667684,
0.0072084758,
-0.010265315,
0.0442484431,
-0.0098075075,
-0.0081317583,
0.0379587971,
-0.0087272264,
-0.0135972006,
0.0125078084,
-0.0083466796,
0.0476970449,
-0.017159896,
-0.0558049157,
0.0406360105,
0.0202846937,
-0.0766688436,
0.0131871728,
0.0319447182,
-0.0264906697,
-0.0059540952,
0.0221564118,
-0.0335996412,
0.0174151789,
-0.0387113355,
0.021292666,
-0.0472809337,
-0.031956736,
0.047202576,
0.0420875773,
-0.0059828125,
-0.0186650082,
-0.0118898414,
-0.0079736924,
-0.039018698,
-0.0126279052,
-0.0113988137,
0.0079893526,
-0.0369965248,
-0.0150050158,
-0.0178877879,
0.0158351175,
-0.0033597497,
0.0327063724,
0.0309642758,
0.0042539653,
0.0058982633,
0.0088088177,
0.0135871768,
0.0459109843,
-0.0054513291,
0.0230133478,
-0.0205545072,
-0.0100283213,
-0.0063237599,
-0.0466394536,
-0.034677688,
-0.024553597,
2.508e-7,
0.0265553277,
0.0840593353,
0.0242898464,
0.0084333736,
-0.0101014497,
0.0137304561,
0.0052960226,
0.0505091511,
-0.0130249448,
0.000014001,
0.0203854926,
0.0095675141,
0.0103651006,
-0.0057279738,
-0.0876590237,
-0.0048874333,
-0.0888095126,
-0.0020826026,
-0.0443764329,
-0.0084530171,
0.0660910159,
0.0445804037,
-0.0230669919,
-0.0191024337,
-0.0223493278,
-0.0545035936,
0.0722042024,
-0.0289820302,
-0.0555501133,
0.0642010123,
0.0208432414,
0.0229726564,
-0.0061217616,
0.0094574066,
-0.022448929,
-0.0107766856,
0.0484915189,
0.0235405471,
0.0334400237,
-0.0194219016,
0.0158633143,
-0.0057280813,
0.0156942215,
-0.0434335507,
0.0665939599,
-0.0955921859,
-0.0044144127,
-0.0748509616,
-0.0595912747,
0.0262353793,
-0.0195597224,
-0.0516777262,
-0.0331382006,
0.014127247,
0.0078353519,
0.0294324644,
-0.0134826191,
-0.0385987647,
0.0167009868,
-0.0133366995,
-0.0292538349,
-0.0070938971,
-0.062719062,
0.0075195753,
0.0049947342,
-0.0562964827,
0.005207154,
2.357743891e-34,
0.0505421981,
-0.0163757149,
-0.0307104122,
0.0157717764,
0.0148075717,
-0.0140776811,
0.0548219234,
0.0365084261,
-0.0157114714,
-0.0380180106,
0.0080675036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14108v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14108v5 | DataComp: In search of the next generation of multimodal datasets | 2023-04-27T11:37:18 | 2023-10-20T17:01:44 | Samir Yitzhak Gadre, Gabriel Ilharco, Alex Fang, Jonathan Hayase, Georgios Smyrnis, Thao Nguyen, Ryan Marten, Mitchell Wortsman, Dhruba Ghosh, Jieyu Zhang, Eyal Orgad, Rahim Entezari, Giannis Daras, Sarah Pratt, Vivek Ramanujan, Yonatan Bitton, Kalyani Marathe, Stephen Mussmann, Richard Vencu, Mehdi Cherti, Ranjay Krishna, Pang Wei Koh, Olga Saukh, Alexander Ratner, Shuran Song, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Ali Farhadi, Romain Beaumont, Sewoong Oh, Alex Dimakis, Jenia Jitsev, Yair Carmon, Vaishaal Shankar, Ludwig Schmidt | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Multimodal datasets are a critical component in recent breakthroughs such as
Stable Diffusion and GPT-4, yet their design does not receive the same research
attention as model architectures or training algorithms. To address this
shortcoming in the ML ecosystem, we introduce DataComp, a testbed for dataset
experiments centered around a new candidate pool of 12.8 billion image-text
pairs from Common Crawl. Participants in our benchmark design new filtering
techniques or curate new data sources and then evaluate their new dataset by
running our standardized CLIP training code and testing the resulting model on
38 downstream test sets. Our benchmark consists of multiple compute scales
spanning four orders of magnitude, which enables the study of scaling trends
and makes the benchmark accessible to researchers with varying resources. Our
baseline experiments show that the DataComp workflow leads to better training
sets. In particular, our best baseline, DataComp-1B, enables training a CLIP
ViT-L/14 from scratch to 79.2% zero-shot accuracy on ImageNet, outperforming
OpenAI's CLIP ViT-L/14 by 3.7 percentage points while using the same training
procedure and compute. We release DataComp and all accompanying code at
www.datacomp.ai. | [
-0.0116388658,
0.0847182497,
0.0084815444,
0.0404303893,
-0.0237263348,
-0.0318733454,
0.0282364786,
0.0497064702,
-0.0239335988,
0.009163362,
-0.0479679964,
-0.0332477093,
-0.0196883176,
0.0715028793,
0.0114779342,
-0.0665296391,
0.0116558019,
0.009305832,
-0.048985403,
-0.0033027867,
0.0407119803,
0.007681204,
0.0081533678,
0.0326001123,
-0.0195071902,
-0.0094961841,
-0.0304270685,
0.0420392603,
0.0289746951,
-0.0398015082,
0.0167402942,
0.0168629996,
0.0580143109,
0.0269509275,
0.0000021949,
0.0107235387,
0.0075020618,
0.0086563034,
0.031701602,
-0.0249785688,
0.0492693186,
-0.0459963642,
0.0212424602,
-0.0125542581,
-0.0299722068,
-0.0116158705,
0.0559963956,
0.0262975097,
0.0797502175,
0.0595365874,
-0.0362381525,
-0.0401036143,
0.0148385102,
-0.0569546856,
0.0141494581,
-0.0219740793,
0.0299522802,
0.0031963184,
-0.011825271,
-0.0014981036,
-0.0542220399,
0.0054572173,
0.0201709829,
0.0262061469,
0.0309603326,
0.0558988824,
-0.0341766961,
-0.0567094088,
-0.0197255798,
0.1007594839,
-0.0386681445,
0.0082365507,
-0.0103231324,
-0.0200544186,
-0.0151464762,
0.0189184099,
-0.0512237772,
0.0132842474,
0.0091787921,
0.0394507386,
-0.0970472991,
-0.0158801898,
0.0370393433,
0.0270894933,
-0.0131628271,
-0.0056343824,
0.0098116528,
0.0159965754,
0.0186290685,
0.0130670518,
-0.0137598077,
-0.0200409424,
0.0214118138,
-0.0087279817,
-0.0103945425,
-0.0178497601,
-0.0398882926,
-0.0204394441,
0.0015740637,
-0.0087148044,
0.0474234521,
0.0083737457,
-0.0488595925,
0.0819960162,
-0.0281833652,
-0.0219284855,
-0.0504395925,
0.0269181319,
0.0041687959,
-0.0107083125,
-0.0283615515,
0.0098521272,
-0.0088038705,
0.0014199105,
-0.0211304165,
-0.0422554761,
-0.0199187957,
-0.0094731171,
-0.0253300164,
-0.0267263427,
0.0027701179,
0.0211015344,
-0.0332665257,
-0.0016991603,
-0.0050390498,
0.0336352065,
-0.0378332995,
0.0275904369,
0.0270482525,
-0.0516863056,
-0.0349744707,
0.0244253855,
0.0316983089,
-0.043857187,
0.0444627889,
0.0658374205,
-0.0455563515,
-0.0385084152,
-0.0096897874,
-0.0242285132,
-0.0235117879,
-0.0538028106,
0.0304304939,
-0.0720126405,
0.0603877902,
-0.0321798064,
0.0179706365,
-0.0174484644,
-0.0023982308,
0.0368196741,
-0.0525431223,
0.1202654168,
0.000320038,
-0.0282507967,
-0.0113831339,
0.0065536839,
-0.0279638525,
0.0730941817,
0.0055642407,
0.0568940192,
0.0348932743,
0.0216657501,
-0.0210640095,
0.0246523898,
0.0682462752,
0.0395230092,
-0.0398108773,
-0.0087836795,
-0.020437045,
0.0385561325,
0.0766864568,
0.0375703052,
-0.0656405911,
-0.0611995421,
0.0581956431,
0.0300674289,
-0.0162104312,
-0.0019950289,
0.0001080391,
-0.0042690826,
-0.0150100077,
-0.0092739481,
-0.0155805321,
0.0392154381,
0.0208866429,
-0.0325182788,
0.0568734258,
0.0330257453,
-0.057197161,
0.0017969873,
0.0029304568,
-0.0093311779,
0.0504599698,
-0.0084012616,
0.0581494048,
-0.0000450814,
-0.0097617479,
0.0088964505,
0.0181030892,
-0.030082792,
-0.0386758037,
-0.0472504236,
-0.0004604927,
0.0005935761,
0.0501367114,
-0.029378606,
-0.0192008186,
0.0130964741,
0.0438734926,
0.0202898458,
0.0097010024,
0.0042218296,
0.0688464791,
-0.0804317519,
-0.031704288,
-0.0234892797,
-0.0327840336,
0.0215431489,
0.0126525937,
0.0327728204,
-0.0032630786,
-0.0202167556,
0.0113686118,
0.0291486382,
-0.0008675411,
0.0089926952,
0.0220773891,
-0.0110748401,
0.0303802695,
-0.015684383,
-0.0358047113,
-0.0318929218,
0.0271927547,
-0.0088497242,
-0.0162802618,
0.0110897124,
-0.015085673,
-0.016363753,
0.0469701886,
-0.1139341444,
0.0241246223,
0.0685868338,
-0.0658433065,
-0.019257687,
0.0222771931,
0.0169441737,
-0.0093361074,
-0.0385330319,
-0.0382094346,
0.015874302,
0.0776267201,
0.010437659,
0.0317901038,
-0.0144757796,
-0.001766554,
0.0221845061,
0.0345659927,
0.0070693586,
0.0168596022,
-0.0263607427,
0.0053339712,
0.0012768398,
0.0043313513,
0.0093084769,
0.0109582841,
-0.031644728,
0.0248447508,
-0.0677105412,
0.0118758231,
-0.0272332076,
-0.007950482,
0.003321029,
0.0111587802,
-0.0050985496,
-0.0405430943,
-0.0193578023,
0.0327093862,
-0.0186798815,
0.0293209087,
0.0251550581,
0.029306246,
0.0521704368,
-0.0316848718,
-0.0544918291,
0.0053100525,
0.0541500971,
-0.0256435014,
-0.0394032374,
0.0146911442,
0.0033309835,
-0.0373078808,
0.0325028747,
-0.0373372473,
-0.0226755589,
0.0261531621,
-0.0523527861,
0.0125720752,
0.0400126353,
0.0128838746,
0.035881266,
-0.0030801923,
0.0065364442,
-0.0195276979,
0.0136515312,
-0.0194585864,
0.0313021131,
0.0006549313,
0.0052427929,
-0.0325711668,
0.0129003376,
-0.0279311556,
0.0050294721,
-0.0638075173,
0.0194709506,
0.0032485893,
-0.0292256884,
-0.0654384047,
0.0398763008,
-0.0371179618,
0.0049809795,
-0.0369312428,
-0.0372744426,
0.0335658565,
0.0022794108,
-0.0191474147,
-0.0111588072,
-0.0141387619,
-0.0086575635,
0.0812786371,
0.0448518358,
0.0190433227,
-0.0205107834,
0.0239336677,
-0.0409084149,
0.022310907,
0.0272496808,
-0.0155342948,
0.0520937927,
-0.0236562937,
0.0066211666,
-0.027321646,
-0.0626407415,
-0.0154625429,
-0.0226318836,
-0.002101602,
0.0022234074,
-0.0139544345,
-0.0338148922,
-0.0046766242,
-0.0077148299,
0.0062734494,
0.0470550731,
-0.0179460198,
-0.0242541339,
-0.0007407462,
0.0675225034,
0.0369147807,
0.0248346347,
-0.0172327831,
-0.0489210561,
-0.0032982426,
0.0890524387,
0.0534399226,
-0.0187423732,
-0.0654393062,
0.0127610294,
0.0098301452,
0.0311341137,
0.0058045038,
-0.0070455554,
0.0689043924,
-0.0313662216,
0.0164530147,
0.0015975493,
-0.0014274733,
-0.0922459811,
-0.0311200824,
0.0332474262,
0.0533232279,
0.0167183746,
-0.0085799824,
-0.0827323943,
-0.0628514588,
-0.0038809371,
0.0216612648,
0.0291173682,
-0.0160415899,
-0.0218784902,
-0.0654571727,
0.0716575533,
-0.0091766892,
-0.0531907007,
-0.0148518765,
-0.0332560465,
0.0240880549,
-0.0271118339,
0.0104108192,
-0.0059857741,
-0.0093778521,
-0.0099812811,
0.0151778199,
0.026543187,
-0.0717348158,
0.0182851534,
-0.0281326678,
-0.0196904391,
0.0419077128,
0.0326473117,
-0.0126897665,
-0.0351796001,
0.0522597618,
-0.0064280438,
-0.0103711737,
-0.0166814942,
0.1170849204,
-0.0515918955,
-0.0244319327,
-0.006393821,
0.0556575358,
-0.0229714457,
-0.0114121651,
-0.0016148438,
0.033224728,
-0.0230893213,
-0.0324429534,
-0.06161483,
-0.0187279247,
-0.0025458958,
0.046015501,
0.0296505298,
-0.020377798,
-0.0357766487,
-0.0160365868,
0.0212562717,
-0.021410659,
-0.0369701982,
-0.0034715254,
0.0041470458,
-0.0198847055,
-0.0478533097,
-0.0331013985,
0.0142589426,
0.0472405553,
-0.0224960782,
-0.0423054062,
-0.0367375426,
0.0148782469,
-0.0692296475,
0.0415037498,
-0.0182351526,
0.0252128299,
-0.0186025351,
0.0245394129,
0.0296417177,
-0.0280778985,
-0.0263154805,
0.0602247529,
-0.1322300881,
-0.0323770083,
-0.0591372177,
0.0596515834,
0.0203715824,
0.0380280055,
-0.0060414402,
-0.0324493907,
0.0527214557,
0.0612210818,
0.000105038,
-0.0157071706,
0.0498848483,
-0.0707568824,
-0.0006361278,
0.0140599348,
-0.0283819735,
0.0362556577,
-0.020179173,
-0.001776988,
0.0069799297,
0.0377926193,
0.0067769042,
-0.0146839917,
0.0578304306,
-0.0101721482,
0.0425499454,
-0.0418775491,
-0.006273726,
0.0237878356,
0.0014840522,
-0.0604525544,
0.0364815034,
0.0199767724,
-0.003817955,
-0.0338745937,
0.008050086,
0.0223727841,
0.0264143981,
-0.0747501403,
-0.0079970462,
0.0204283223,
0.0001172976,
0.0204026122,
0.0141879413,
0.0134398574,
-0.0089251418,
-0.0144003965,
0.0336390547,
-0.0072523337,
0.0364037566,
0.0461824574,
0.004715363,
0.0051544048,
0.0565200299,
-0.0603542589,
-0.0192451514,
-0.0578006208,
0.018288482,
0.0457486138,
-0.0065201544,
0.0516718067,
-0.0372483134,
-0.0228100047,
-0.0193943717,
0.0192410499,
-0.0056300354,
-0.0109047033,
0.020218268,
0.0196421426,
0.0013809802,
-0.0030372948,
0.0929816291,
-0.0490525253,
0.0194722135,
0.0139765311,
-0.0114933914,
-0.0214227755,
-0.0260091517,
0.0241491701,
0.0653087944,
0.016313687,
-0.0408243202,
-0.0033399512,
-0.0451704189,
-0.0347798467,
-0.0151588097,
0.0060250019,
0.030787494,
0.0751205981,
0.0593026429,
0.0242509749,
-0.003013717,
-0.0012599131,
-0.007159085,
0.0024223381,
-0.0022565317,
0.0402774587,
-6.837424522e-33,
0.028291529,
0.0471146628,
-0.0032742815,
-0.0119501287,
-0.0206283759,
0.0205393229,
-0.0175905321,
-0.0174629036,
-0.0128376838,
0.0182239618,
-0.0056153149,
0.0315853134,
0.0141195301,
0.0202847328,
-0.0150472531,
0.004953004,
0.0315562747,
-0.0453342833,
-0.0123996437,
0.031167917,
0.0107406257,
0.0356089398,
0.0622504056,
-0.0277648997,
-0.0368126556,
0.0285505857,
-0.0366746858,
-0.0227577593,
0.0199170448,
0.0422326885,
-0.0441674329,
0.0290400628,
0.0251660272,
-0.0449513793,
-0.0400919765,
-0.0162285287,
-0.0710834786,
-0.0160439536,
-0.0409423113,
0.0209756698,
-0.100511983,
0.0067027812,
0.0643619522,
-0.0112241274,
0.0249026101,
-0.0145230526,
0.0374682657,
-0.016003469,
-0.002088858,
0.0070833997,
0.0066177277,
0.0379630215,
0.0024085143,
-0.019631803,
0.0545625724,
0.043533504,
0.0227853116,
0.0459174179,
-0.0798749551,
0.0129615227,
-0.0260892194,
-0.005995376,
0.028836688,
0.0183280539,
0.0341857225,
0.1018054262,
0.0302995853,
-0.0394117385,
0.0144449826,
-0.038643986,
0.0356789678,
0.0790433958,
0.0017670081,
0.0513417795,
0.0834007859,
-0.0064941156,
-0.0583890453,
0.0274815448,
0.0281960275,
0.0029091872,
0.0041859648,
0.0162461828,
0.0255179666,
0.013497497,
0.0163397547,
-0.0310541019,
-0.0400333218,
-0.0386793353,
0.0210951641,
0.0382991955,
-0.0155355707,
0.0208012722,
0.0691500604,
-0.0342078134,
-0.0091340579,
0.0139906425,
-0.0499348678,
0.0294173323,
0.0427720621,
-0.0081366729,
-0.046245981,
-0.016606776,
0.0393868014,
-0.0020388085,
0.0096713966,
-0.0130159697,
0.0173156224,
0.038361486,
-0.0407727472,
-0.0209735483,
-0.0514791161,
0.0222956613,
-0.0080958353,
0.0576342233,
0.0389680341,
0.0015666619,
-0.0192457382,
0.0236217063,
0.0225201324,
0.0240227748,
-0.0425571389,
-0.0419932976,
-0.0047644689,
0.0101281386,
-0.0127496896,
-0.0118131302,
-0.0667139813,
-0.024923984,
0.0398108624,
-0.0945671126,
-0.0448329374,
0.0453282446,
2.913e-7,
0.0163787939,
0.0203033872,
0.0288915653,
0.0277577173,
0.0235744696,
0.0146437399,
-0.0271993279,
0.0609029196,
-0.0386664346,
-0.0523421839,
0.0174366143,
0.0538573451,
0.0430270694,
0.0314726122,
-0.0358412303,
-0.0457370207,
-0.0442820452,
-0.0318999551,
-0.0343602225,
-0.0484992824,
0.0009615104,
0.1158619896,
0.0342963934,
-0.0400386564,
0.075361833,
0.0016034453,
0.0749931037,
-0.0213748794,
0.0296220966,
-0.0251248218,
-0.0150183206,
0.0264658537,
-0.0380832143,
0.0102932323,
-0.0185029283,
-0.0308785923,
0.0566963144,
0.0366858356,
-0.0197211523,
-0.0413279496,
0.0174816195,
0.0539508983,
-0.0129347397,
-0.0476883724,
0.0829940364,
0.0032534585,
-0.0122073973,
-0.0606429465,
-0.0518633649,
-0.0025579957,
0.0448079929,
-0.0045499764,
-0.0482007973,
0.0357237868,
0.0069189994,
0.0077626137,
-0.0460124239,
-0.1003696471,
-0.010140893,
-0.0180510078,
-0.0550199822,
-0.0330037177,
-0.0785320699,
-0.044043351,
0.0227306299,
-0.0420901142,
-0.0705146939,
2.541490877e-34,
0.0437611677,
-0.0148937562,
0.016559571,
-0.0386648178,
-0.0253049955,
-0.0099277319,
-0.0301481858,
-0.015162982,
-0.0182591155,
-0.0472421274,
-0.0297280662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14106v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14106v2 | ChatLog: Carefully Evaluating the Evolution of ChatGPT Across Time | 2023-04-27T11:33:48 | 2024-06-18T00:33:25 | Shangqing Tu, Chunyang Li, Jifan Yu, Xiaozhi Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | ChatGPT has achieved great success and can be considered to have acquired an
infrastructural status. There are abundant works for evaluating ChatGPT on
benchmarks. However, existing benchmarks encounter two challenges: (1)
Disregard for periodical evaluation and (2) Lack of fine-grained features. In
this paper, we construct ChatLog, an ever-updating dataset with large-scale
records of diverse long-form ChatGPT responses for 21 NLP benchmarks from
March, 2023 to now. We conduct a comprehensive performance evaluation to find
that most capabilities of ChatGPT improve over time except for some abilities,
and there exists a step-wise evolving pattern of ChatGPT. We further analyze
the inherent characteristics of ChatGPT by extracting the knowledge and
linguistic features. We find some stable features that stay unchanged and apply
them on the detection of ChatGPT-generated texts to improve the robustness of
cross-version detection. We will continuously maintain our project at
\url{https://github.com/THU-KEG/ChatLog/}. | [
0.0490217581,
0.037091773,
0.0068029552,
0.039205607,
-0.0599714778,
0.0023730518,
-0.0396511778,
0.0482607596,
0.0634344742,
-0.0701837763,
-0.0089636855,
0.0070393966,
-0.0221223235,
0.0372667834,
-0.0084978836,
-0.0269459412,
0.0783683136,
0.021769179,
-0.0040523908,
0.0319367535,
0.0327288583,
0.0000780008,
-0.0119925765,
0.0557503588,
-0.0167957246,
-0.0402254499,
-0.0056986571,
-0.0049643987,
0.0124830492,
-0.0225569773,
0.0387148969,
0.0301555879,
-0.0230081398,
0.0898610577,
0.0000018033,
-0.0537825786,
-0.032355696,
0.0032972607,
-0.0288786925,
0.0141009223,
0.0482622162,
0.0066827242,
-0.0325041674,
0.0142337671,
-0.0464741699,
-0.0138671072,
0.0147206197,
0.0580828413,
0.0697629228,
0.1043532044,
-0.009907227,
0.027239779,
0.0354679376,
-0.0074046194,
0.0215908624,
-0.0456581637,
-0.0104719261,
0.0137294913,
0.0154382102,
0.0388548225,
0.0049361377,
0.0327719562,
-0.0040138494,
-0.0192441121,
-0.0480242074,
0.0170879755,
-0.055391904,
0.0098251589,
-0.0337797441,
0.0378346518,
0.0043832427,
-0.0462659746,
0.0352486297,
0.0188382119,
-0.0108645409,
-0.0285389964,
-0.0362955183,
-0.0082756765,
-0.0360989608,
0.0000485828,
0.0336395577,
-0.0006837912,
-0.007462699,
0.0080614388,
0.0290551893,
0.0476104803,
0.0166966356,
-0.0231020618,
0.006253683,
0.0145455115,
-0.0426984839,
-0.0431471169,
0.0362092368,
0.0079408335,
-0.0005169574,
-0.0083111087,
-0.0297033954,
-0.0061954944,
0.0227215588,
-0.0520211495,
-0.0422523208,
0.0378282629,
-0.0205405653,
0.0643572658,
-0.0455597676,
0.0574780703,
-0.0101127187,
-0.0254701506,
-0.0075229784,
-0.011340023,
-0.0873134434,
0.0043745833,
-0.0583291426,
0.0191550832,
-0.0307215285,
-0.0290663876,
-0.0408398248,
0.0257147122,
0.0327525884,
-0.0154476585,
-0.0011749937,
-0.0053989729,
-0.0315436013,
0.0296020769,
0.0036063918,
0.0293961521,
-0.0213657841,
-0.0384566598,
-0.0035687345,
-0.0808773339,
-0.0105632152,
0.0328122489,
0.0222982932,
-0.0151108252,
-0.0058957264,
0.0414149202,
0.0029194311,
-0.0295910854,
-0.0210368261,
-0.0422622189,
-0.0365355499,
-0.0408654436,
0.0185665116,
-0.055742152,
0.0289790016,
-0.0008193441,
-0.0032542183,
0.0049246829,
-0.0092954589,
0.0222562104,
-0.0295108203,
0.0231233537,
-0.005087174,
-0.0348977856,
0.0005586341,
-0.0032382051,
-0.0352514237,
0.088924475,
0.0021544599,
0.0143922577,
0.0657862872,
0.0077883648,
-0.007518989,
0.0589406751,
0.0046799271,
0.016088035,
0.058618363,
0.001175303,
0.0222483873,
0.000106358,
-0.0027300105,
0.0326015316,
-0.0459016971,
-0.0537334159,
0.0323529281,
0.0361692496,
0.0564685613,
-0.0043606353,
0.0203803889,
0.0299722087,
0.0234938711,
0.0354958586,
-0.0115657831,
-0.0376383439,
-0.0435221791,
-0.0229609665,
-0.0046823714,
0.0092969295,
0.0003575362,
-0.0262493808,
-0.0306332801,
0.0266093109,
0.0000590032,
-0.0568753071,
0.027677916,
0.0155101996,
-0.0304568168,
0.0361827314,
0.0568305254,
-0.0174607132,
-0.0064589544,
-0.0615499131,
0.0118527114,
0.0097942296,
0.076660201,
0.0009244473,
-0.0065512448,
0.003171345,
0.0044141626,
0.0475662947,
0.06675037,
0.0034228887,
0.0204334818,
-0.0077288742,
0.0053773536,
0.0001447301,
0.0413125493,
0.0099098496,
0.0805068538,
0.0279926639,
-0.0110791186,
-0.0309220385,
0.0156291034,
0.0340222493,
-0.0160627812,
0.0181141719,
-0.0001914965,
-0.0412783399,
0.0443189181,
0.0134790987,
-0.0141178016,
-0.0068951063,
0.0062272171,
-0.0191415101,
-0.0437529124,
0.054472737,
-0.0245159268,
-0.1066610739,
0.0325821526,
-0.0414023474,
-0.0107886251,
-0.0056204358,
-0.040556822,
-0.0192077383,
0.0294917375,
-0.0341634527,
0.0725990608,
-0.0387236476,
0.0139274579,
0.0263530686,
0.0262314994,
-0.0452333093,
0.0638713688,
0.0332331322,
0.0090582287,
-0.0040543918,
0.0201063957,
0.0514597595,
-0.0160913318,
-0.0201752745,
0.0290976185,
-0.0364342108,
0.0080412878,
0.0374238379,
0.0428713001,
-0.0658303052,
-0.0480958223,
-0.12288744,
0.0413393378,
-0.0263347831,
0.0313618891,
0.0743557811,
-0.0158610661,
-0.00647027,
0.0026938766,
-0.0055032526,
0.0444893204,
0.0390346646,
0.0310342964,
0.0404925868,
0.0019395056,
0.0319099054,
-0.0460047498,
0.0058135297,
-0.0268710814,
0.0277574267,
0.0128800757,
-0.0555362143,
-0.0230294857,
0.0016728007,
-0.0453233607,
0.0234778151,
-0.0145370131,
-0.0278841872,
0.0080562057,
-0.010347343,
0.0317523442,
0.0072035016,
0.0101612331,
0.0205864329,
-0.030291345,
-0.0141328759,
-0.0747742206,
0.0211851075,
-0.0361965448,
-0.0127597265,
-0.0166521315,
0.0047105509,
0.0610207617,
0.0646673143,
-0.0114803072,
-0.0017832484,
-0.0656375512,
-0.0008435825,
-0.0637460351,
-0.0029836106,
0.0022489894,
0.0224442892,
-0.0161266942,
-0.0122324694,
-0.0318043679,
-0.0453919806,
0.0209923871,
-0.0257350877,
-0.0146528278,
-0.0932290927,
-0.0161847007,
-0.0641291812,
0.092295818,
-0.0019850349,
0.020614624,
0.0230454113,
-0.0495961048,
-0.0189088155,
0.019914953,
0.0273740143,
-0.0035264441,
0.0277648997,
-0.0330976024,
0.0395075604,
-0.0161997564,
-0.0190678742,
-0.0327258669,
-0.060652025,
-0.010118614,
-0.0105058905,
0.0353442729,
-0.0152787594,
-0.0362181105,
0.0288836285,
-0.0331783071,
0.0328920446,
-0.012595675,
-0.0222759657,
-0.0145098874,
0.0388080291,
0.0443415456,
0.0104075447,
0.0141747072,
0.0289437249,
0.0095244208,
0.1023083925,
0.0128093408,
0.0267856028,
-0.0128868949,
-0.0246964972,
0.0008922327,
-0.0396399498,
-0.0222261101,
-0.0292360839,
0.0465240031,
-0.0443775058,
-0.0065180496,
0.0909124687,
0.0233342256,
-0.0232519116,
0.0063535431,
0.0241279751,
0.0476541631,
-0.0000320965,
0.0045768069,
-0.1046230122,
-0.0473456867,
0.005383038,
-0.0229141507,
-0.0024986842,
-0.0235433951,
-0.0487095229,
-0.0942778364,
0.0269811712,
-0.0154721644,
-0.010955059,
0.0283097178,
-0.0290317349,
0.0011743312,
-0.0252520274,
-0.0128069855,
-0.0137648508,
-0.0261301771,
0.0237140134,
0.0136754848,
-0.0939110294,
-0.0177470949,
0.0370752886,
-0.0285622515,
0.0365774482,
0.0458057337,
0.0503778569,
0.0095434645,
0.0240045898,
0.0848165154,
-0.006706655,
-0.0080805738,
-0.039035026,
0.0646025762,
0.0038386015,
-0.0052818418,
0.0042721564,
0.0060295179,
-0.0145945251,
0.0090795821,
0.0576072633,
0.0288035013,
-0.0112754432,
-0.0490901731,
-0.0178113598,
0.0543448105,
-0.0163203496,
0.0727872327,
-0.0029691141,
-0.0006532517,
-0.0565012172,
-0.0261168778,
0.0163552053,
-0.0168099515,
-0.0593534932,
-0.0146253714,
0.0145280734,
0.0054509267,
-0.1182025,
-0.0435802527,
0.003316473,
0.0242479537,
-0.0245600156,
0.0030424374,
-0.026094608,
0.016179489,
-0.0144916028,
0.0002542401,
-0.022525182,
-0.0214897376,
-0.0686680526,
0.0037018536,
0.0291185901,
0.0140449209,
-0.0362823159,
0.0224077869,
-0.1150505021,
-0.0489810444,
0.0217950344,
-0.0192153044,
0.0225112084,
0.0299449805,
-0.0720617846,
0.0071610441,
0.0165754501,
0.0566122942,
-0.0079442272,
0.0080112359,
0.018677894,
0.0347071178,
-0.0207285229,
0.03597112,
-0.0264884569,
-0.0112429084,
-0.0153539414,
0.0313089639,
-0.0005452552,
-0.0053157634,
0.0225975607,
0.020477701,
0.0365802944,
0.01484174,
-0.0022392685,
-0.014748821,
-0.0447146669,
-0.0044676797,
0.0030495077,
-0.0466437489,
-0.0146445148,
-0.005028741,
-0.0102204373,
-0.0257137083,
0.0424487852,
-0.0241376758,
0.0494628027,
-0.0609426312,
0.0026661512,
0.0235385802,
-0.0160741899,
-0.0042577111,
-0.0072442563,
-0.0032205635,
0.011300453,
-0.0117966188,
0.034433119,
-0.0457331352,
0.0633998141,
0.0163049418,
-0.0416090935,
0.0324516669,
0.0189291406,
-0.0936653614,
-0.0061122929,
-0.0079413569,
0.0639345944,
0.0959343836,
0.0121421563,
0.1001893133,
-0.0380200446,
-0.0219349563,
-0.0289548729,
0.0246455967,
0.012876045,
-0.020820355,
-0.0183141399,
-0.007101363,
-0.0523881465,
0.0066818511,
0.0751845837,
-0.0128354169,
0.0537117086,
0.0769177973,
-0.0037213652,
-0.0374040864,
-0.0499258041,
-0.019212693,
-0.0152193271,
0.0155711165,
0.0376112275,
-0.0319082551,
-0.0167169124,
-0.0201175138,
-0.0053808852,
0.0095761055,
0.0202824865,
0.0095054405,
0.0777413473,
0.0210815836,
-0.0057112235,
-0.0551172607,
-0.0063099875,
-0.0261127371,
-0.0077406969,
-0.0290185791,
-5.978058071e-33,
-0.0004017646,
0.0018933974,
-0.010680438,
0.0092037171,
-0.0277237538,
0.0239835028,
-0.0171677433,
0.0070752357,
-0.0344444923,
-0.0056845197,
-0.0337965935,
0.0158636551,
0.0100548798,
-0.0105682509,
-0.0173851289,
-0.0471985526,
0.0357636549,
-0.0017198389,
-0.0259489119,
0.0196545236,
0.048789259,
0.0241917968,
0.0918436199,
-0.0566057563,
0.018106522,
0.019407291,
-0.0112396944,
0.0124697881,
0.0187419597,
0.0815369114,
-0.0227216575,
0.0197020452,
0.0359077305,
-0.0288912859,
-0.0151191615,
-0.030675387,
-0.0619885698,
-0.0249299835,
-0.0104005644,
0.0076495116,
-0.017029196,
0.0180087499,
0.0120121604,
-0.0236709043,
-0.0026325176,
-0.0230977144,
0.0249124523,
0.0040218011,
-0.0085678427,
-0.0203779023,
-0.0344424136,
0.0660901889,
-0.0207324605,
0.0034859625,
-0.0378409736,
0.0554701537,
0.0378242917,
-0.0046485765,
-0.0570358187,
0.0054013808,
-0.0163587574,
0.0470673963,
0.0045622094,
-0.0464865528,
0.007290619,
0.0647579059,
-0.00739044,
0.0158273596,
0.0145995272,
-0.011724012,
0.0242656469,
0.0185388569,
0.0383281037,
0.0335171968,
0.0495491102,
-0.0055202846,
-0.0368377492,
0.0137674659,
0.1103263646,
0.0427777432,
-0.0234723873,
-0.0041027791,
-0.0606141388,
-0.0045237597,
-0.0020096342,
0.0192047376,
-0.0251664072,
-0.0476133525,
0.041523423,
0.0180589519,
-0.0069949552,
-0.0252767783,
0.0334659182,
-0.0440094806,
-0.0398273207,
0.0091962963,
-0.0436002538,
-0.0026452981,
0.0120983841,
0.0757579058,
-0.0240404718,
-0.0229533482,
0.0188299175,
0.0276118405,
0.0234840252,
-0.0401573926,
0.0316138677,
0.0104631837,
-0.0775490701,
0.0063385754,
-0.0350874402,
0.058837112,
-0.0600011162,
-0.0144747039,
0.0245130248,
-0.0335058644,
-0.0058714054,
0.0373976342,
0.0542350896,
0.0418473929,
-0.0489002801,
0.0241552517,
0.0045814873,
-0.0175417028,
-0.0084307604,
0.0296674892,
-0.0126541406,
0.0126282908,
0.0006842022,
-0.0248067304,
0.0073276991,
-0.0046857391,
2.522e-7,
0.0216450468,
0.0440913886,
0.0436027758,
0.0055148262,
0.0473143309,
0.0223903134,
-0.0253649745,
0.0157127567,
-0.0153712016,
0.047476925,
-0.0502380617,
-0.0117571354,
0.0534589626,
0.0377162397,
-0.0845288709,
-0.0315478407,
-0.082296595,
-0.0616931245,
-0.0705626383,
0.0048126783,
0.0845475644,
0.0961922854,
-0.0050806375,
0.0168869235,
-0.0136913788,
-0.0590490811,
0.0587066039,
-0.0260430407,
-0.0447142497,
0.0386409052,
0.0484118983,
0.0191824827,
0.0320825726,
-0.0341266021,
-0.0140573531,
-0.0022959986,
-0.0011211765,
0.061543256,
0.040685609,
-0.0246049203,
0.0114153596,
-0.0138338944,
-0.0101739233,
-0.0358912125,
0.0959603414,
-0.0225248709,
-0.0130393282,
-0.0648497939,
-0.0215102322,
-0.020842677,
-0.0029825016,
0.0036434543,
-0.0685352832,
0.0409124792,
0.011222126,
-0.0021272183,
-0.0488066338,
-0.0818417296,
-0.0325125717,
-0.0275155678,
-0.0406568311,
-0.0402731076,
-0.0135541465,
0.0384398401,
0.0185535848,
-0.0286286343,
0.0041719074,
2.542561679e-34,
0.0204387158,
0.0000807117,
0.0200397484,
-0.0201374888,
0.0592812896,
0.0115967952,
0.0773452669,
-0.0177244544,
-0.0156605784,
-0.0249291435,
0.0104223071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14104v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14104v4 | Learning Human-Human Interactions in Images from Weak Textual Supervision | 2023-04-27T11:32:48 | 2023-09-18T17:50:31 | Morris Alper, Hadar Averbuch-Elor | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Interactions between humans are diverse and context-dependent, but previous
works have treated them as categorical, disregarding the heavy tail of possible
interactions. We propose a new paradigm of learning human-human interactions as
free text from a single still image, allowing for flexibility in modeling the
unlimited space of situations and relationships between people. To overcome the
absence of data labelled specifically for this task, we use knowledge
distillation applied to synthetic caption data produced by a large language
model without explicit supervision. We show that the pseudo-labels produced by
this procedure can be used to train a captioning model to effectively
understand human-human interactions in images, as measured by a variety of
metrics that measure textual and semantic faithfulness and factual groundedness
of our predictions. We further show that our approach outperforms SOTA image
captioning and situation recognition models on this task. We will release our
code and pseudo-labels along with Waldo and Wenda, a manually-curated test set
for still image human-human interaction understanding. | [
0.0303993989,
0.0323638394,
-0.0075976481,
0.0588321239,
0.0203090571,
0.0566556193,
0.0043694768,
0.0208841916,
0.0080256257,
-0.068534933,
-0.0124704093,
-0.0533458665,
0.0323437564,
0.0362904593,
0.0290196519,
-0.0944794491,
0.0013817364,
-0.0127149615,
-0.0098862564,
0.0299091265,
0.0495046712,
0.0114270989,
-0.014468587,
0.0041528195,
-0.0648604706,
0.0096579716,
-0.0281882435,
-0.0056424802,
0.0407101363,
-0.0023604033,
-0.0109971361,
0.0656058863,
0.0845712349,
-0.0459441133,
0.000001669,
-0.0081189685,
0.0396573171,
-0.0209532753,
0.0183799174,
-0.0502931438,
0.0115360962,
-0.0632555932,
0.0238728691,
-0.0169218946,
-0.0443453491,
0.011704606,
0.0245409347,
0.0549972393,
0.0920172855,
0.0386501178,
-0.0252079647,
-0.0590073243,
-0.0330513939,
-0.0484893136,
0.0235559996,
-0.0283287112,
0.0104702944,
0.0536561199,
-0.0051304963,
-0.0129389027,
-0.0395321958,
-0.0052384338,
-0.0001163474,
-0.0350569263,
0.0456562154,
0.0459133573,
-0.044112362,
-0.0616707839,
0.0136315841,
0.1334504038,
0.0051979721,
0.015347085,
0.0012059005,
0.0128733451,
-0.0100644901,
0.0232953019,
-0.026667593,
0.0249018651,
0.0212021116,
0.0210720375,
-0.060351152,
0.0361482501,
-0.0036682354,
-0.0055105202,
0.0059897485,
-0.0011456909,
-0.0361237526,
0.024748357,
0.0031491355,
0.0048578838,
-0.0678694397,
-0.0539489202,
-0.0204642918,
0.0046626036,
0.0242480971,
0.0101171415,
-0.0481741242,
-0.012545296,
-0.0252219755,
-0.0316231176,
-0.0245786533,
0.0008669164,
-0.0345281586,
0.0608124696,
0.0626291707,
0.0467434563,
0.0124564683,
-0.0051847715,
-0.0186424982,
0.0272257011,
-0.0636318177,
0.0178227574,
-0.0065170932,
0.0073512848,
-0.084615171,
-0.0375167355,
0.0227641426,
-0.0149365617,
-0.0196073521,
-0.0047479733,
0.0118638752,
0.035567563,
-0.0334783532,
0.043466419,
-0.0076250881,
-0.0009275715,
-0.0103836292,
0.0023801669,
-0.061228916,
-0.0404566415,
-0.0275981706,
0.0262947362,
0.0496266112,
-0.0171783175,
-0.0259562358,
0.0300016403,
-0.057702411,
-0.0436962433,
-0.0091515444,
-0.0303950645,
-0.0317965485,
-0.0521678925,
0.0155136772,
-0.0236038491,
0.0794195533,
-0.0380496643,
-0.0119110467,
-0.0651013702,
0.0361273624,
-0.0080095362,
-0.034739282,
0.1300401092,
0.0025310623,
0.0119769396,
0.0047662621,
0.0596467331,
-0.015955193,
0.0547634177,
0.0154382037,
0.0300180707,
0.020243641,
0.0125608025,
0.0446481332,
0.0128813889,
0.0069034882,
0.0196793806,
-0.0094894413,
0.009704723,
0.0090556387,
0.0222970955,
0.0594752841,
0.0366158001,
-0.0461222045,
0.0159057043,
0.0542653725,
0.0638792589,
-0.0529580489,
0.0317683257,
0.0314537138,
0.0449008159,
-0.0055567655,
0.020163564,
-0.0719694346,
0.0425006226,
0.0305153355,
-0.0391908027,
-0.0339419581,
0.002003348,
-0.0513594151,
-0.0334251821,
0.0098704277,
-0.0291856118,
0.0139340861,
-0.0232298635,
0.014621363,
0.0125474539,
-0.0300369598,
0.0566288009,
0.0445424728,
-0.0440569073,
-0.0028731977,
-0.002813949,
-0.0059948196,
0.059600167,
-0.0102755064,
-0.0290953405,
0.0045025786,
-0.0382124893,
0.0732961446,
0.0392087027,
-0.0040898528,
-0.0206179656,
0.0755124912,
-0.0145103661,
-0.0112933367,
-0.0182278063,
0.0270897932,
0.004880887,
0.0205818191,
0.0160388667,
0.0433895625,
0.0212590136,
-0.0334922858,
0.0542552397,
-0.0114591392,
-0.0238900296,
-0.060452491,
0.0219971351,
0.0062494576,
0.0271268375,
-0.0618413948,
-0.0379634127,
0.0466588363,
-0.0121826129,
-0.0051654433,
0.0487217307,
-0.0473802909,
-0.109557569,
0.0363679826,
-0.0321918204,
-0.0672234446,
-0.0220468696,
-0.0320211537,
-0.0278209206,
0.0237495992,
-0.0263620745,
0.0291564148,
-0.045337826,
-0.022599481,
0.0255927388,
0.0051345839,
0.0223741774,
0.0560807325,
-0.0208731927,
-0.0285864715,
0.0048444113,
-0.0159967188,
-0.0140754506,
0.0068459148,
-0.0361114554,
-0.0185592324,
0.0138996309,
0.0548414402,
0.0160422139,
0.0582200177,
-0.0344475582,
0.0054003615,
-0.0954603553,
-0.0213426612,
-0.0345893577,
-0.0638668761,
0.0003718978,
0.0043052975,
0.0220142547,
-0.0369652919,
-0.0358497649,
-0.0138828987,
-0.0082317367,
-0.0136778122,
0.0337536074,
0.0514760427,
-0.0223907214,
-0.0381524414,
0.0519864485,
0.0345637985,
0.0762092471,
0.0052168532,
-0.0146708963,
-0.0035902283,
0.0142320339,
-0.0183550809,
0.0772753507,
-0.0589180291,
-0.0260278191,
0.0184670463,
0.00593044,
-0.0295870434,
0.0348727964,
-0.0046385294,
0.0462223403,
0.0031615417,
-0.0182552636,
-0.0225182027,
0.0083520617,
0.014424908,
-0.0301350746,
-0.0149840033,
-0.0418675505,
-0.0282563195,
0.0379245877,
-0.0285781138,
0.0327215455,
-0.0889645219,
-0.0163361356,
0.027651608,
-0.0622352026,
-0.0502722412,
0.0069654821,
-0.0102338903,
0.0176476613,
-0.0568529069,
-0.0459510311,
0.0157392118,
-0.0143625168,
-0.0423070043,
0.0127722248,
0.0005745421,
0.0018702007,
0.1093206406,
0.0111954669,
0.0428528637,
0.0004873657,
0.0186317489,
-0.0163737964,
-0.0381788313,
0.0089698313,
-0.0037698608,
0.0372581705,
-0.0928167254,
0.0070029441,
0.0141012548,
-0.0226706918,
-0.0040606242,
-0.0340637043,
-0.0087682642,
-0.0221223738,
-0.0390809029,
-0.0188302025,
-0.0068979235,
0.0400668271,
0.0068265544,
0.0064505045,
0.0072325715,
0.001191558,
-0.0257528983,
0.0504053719,
0.0709317997,
0.0143918479,
-0.0864562094,
-0.0215470139,
0.0400103368,
0.0430683047,
-0.0030116059,
-0.0064592017,
-0.0160855036,
0.0282825306,
-0.0344436727,
0.0573786013,
-0.0079640308,
0.0107219592,
0.057076022,
0.0089687072,
0.0046961997,
0.1004848331,
0.0103407837,
-0.0338178724,
-0.0030533224,
0.0181095619,
-0.0040325457,
0.0183308944,
-0.0153205823,
-0.0290318094,
-0.0455418713,
-0.0032309121,
-0.0009738501,
0.0406310223,
-0.0725104287,
-0.0443916768,
-0.0501137748,
0.0189254042,
0.0166785326,
-0.0593621656,
-0.0676535591,
-0.0149230873,
0.0194946863,
-0.0267467909,
0.0087560304,
0.0014380248,
0.0166711248,
0.0122762434,
0.0121892178,
0.0314105116,
-0.0564749427,
0.036787156,
-0.0602518134,
0.0198365599,
-0.0006789017,
0.0690097287,
-0.003664647,
-0.0228647031,
-0.0294741094,
0.0098769665,
0.0214433875,
-0.0155462231,
0.0609260611,
-0.0492057726,
-0.01414961,
0.0308625977,
0.0438794419,
-0.0317388847,
-0.0123598129,
0.0044985511,
-0.0018157973,
-0.0131175611,
-0.0132651599,
0.0139163164,
0.0084197316,
0.0462099537,
0.0534182936,
0.0038715107,
-0.0144863101,
-0.0096729193,
-0.0099162338,
0.0101448484,
0.0060669822,
-0.0319112241,
-0.0202663988,
-0.0242637172,
-0.0252419189,
-0.0556287952,
-0.0260788761,
0.0566809028,
0.0275139213,
-0.0078713195,
-0.020201331,
0.0292074252,
0.0204940345,
-0.0314377584,
0.0698903576,
-0.0518298484,
0.025656227,
0.0233049449,
-0.0167189296,
0.0236820932,
-0.0135284746,
-0.0032265976,
0.0319212079,
-0.0768023208,
-0.0418841243,
-0.0227875505,
0.0536639951,
0.0172249284,
0.0957259834,
0.033719644,
-0.0327289402,
-0.009052272,
0.0410812274,
-0.0271923374,
0.0445801094,
-0.008573832,
-0.0268329661,
-0.0242017191,
0.0168478377,
0.006553221,
0.0238175467,
-0.0308102015,
-0.0195666794,
-0.0688296407,
-0.0692876503,
-0.0284364596,
-0.0260054786,
0.0407821499,
-0.0246640779,
-0.0093623251,
-0.0215549096,
-0.0411811285,
0.000756479,
-0.0009135489,
-0.0695982352,
0.0047986954,
0.001762939,
0.0422599465,
-0.0210337825,
0.0070930901,
-0.0481600314,
0.0342137702,
-0.0122213745,
-0.0205643978,
0.0393352769,
-0.0185030438,
0.0179952607,
0.0008202196,
0.0163431875,
-0.0004528806,
-0.0134497471,
0.0129033644,
0.0180307124,
0.029330831,
0.0376677439,
-0.0070574987,
0.030322738,
0.0290138666,
-0.0092130331,
-0.0244551245,
-0.0681684911,
0.0409216955,
0.0385637172,
-0.0021002796,
0.0234702751,
-0.012339633,
0.0116449902,
0.04299815,
0.0392835215,
-0.0211907942,
-0.0319786072,
0.0427455604,
0.0223473478,
-0.0169457458,
0.0734364688,
0.0905310586,
0.0333745517,
0.0067379712,
0.0036313699,
-0.0302412063,
-0.0401805267,
-0.0053568427,
0.0558681823,
0.0086984374,
0.0130893579,
0.025166953,
-0.024901228,
-0.0654179454,
-0.0172567833,
-0.0139345266,
-0.0162234977,
0.0255381316,
0.0792384595,
-0.0071215439,
-0.0133555569,
0.0037928822,
-0.0038813981,
-0.0255538281,
-0.0036092778,
0.0029834418,
-0.0124669112,
-5.302139268e-33,
-0.0408924483,
-0.0432536639,
0.007375068,
-0.0175081342,
-0.0641870499,
0.0028869901,
-0.0310745034,
-0.0031987596,
-0.0209862888,
0.0290307831,
0.0105661647,
0.0415738449,
0.0120881638,
0.008270625,
-0.0245351754,
0.0054532443,
0.0103093041,
-0.0270995274,
0.0050163413,
0.0607788302,
-0.0010246814,
0.0085629011,
0.009852835,
-0.0879652351,
0.0134104099,
-0.0175964739,
-0.0411368124,
0.0385313593,
0.0761879683,
-0.018437719,
-0.0377047583,
0.0059853178,
0.0078161983,
0.000823089,
0.005872427,
0.0540495105,
-0.0604283698,
-0.0185001772,
0.0113974279,
0.0114230663,
-0.0426335,
0.0333945267,
-0.0127276108,
-0.0272784978,
0.0404751673,
-0.0053266715,
0.0319125354,
-0.0147421891,
0.0246124566,
-0.0016919445,
-0.0237859525,
0.0066198925,
-0.0173725542,
-0.0658434406,
0.0214180425,
0.0007137475,
0.0118025942,
-0.0166392885,
-0.0498753563,
-0.0083268574,
-0.0002779791,
0.0109230299,
0.0319014899,
0.0269942768,
0.0269539244,
0.059814889,
-0.0201913211,
0.0239764601,
-0.0427096486,
-0.0369325392,
0.0260821469,
0.1033603474,
-0.0147670368,
0.0700317621,
0.0293232817,
0.0063910275,
-0.0359279141,
0.0211956464,
-0.0425466746,
0.0366749614,
-0.0327004455,
0.0102657704,
-0.0033371798,
-0.017006116,
-0.0389287397,
-0.0090032397,
0.0032319247,
-0.0214228053,
0.0069694901,
0.0334242508,
-0.0419673994,
0.0062380349,
0.0336254537,
-0.0511582717,
0.0294882189,
0.0024000232,
-0.0362430178,
0.0194829945,
-0.0079830531,
-0.0183469206,
-0.0185630601,
-0.0766804591,
0.0749487802,
0.0296297632,
0.0542923845,
0.0080112033,
0.0586072952,
0.0092913788,
0.0180460513,
-0.0237898733,
-0.0432595387,
0.0491100475,
0.0056613465,
0.0368435532,
0.0052241376,
0.0342594907,
-0.0484971292,
-0.0050131381,
0.0054733958,
-0.0094641633,
-0.0060777916,
0.0183807146,
0.0100503964,
-0.000004867,
-0.0377803631,
-0.0050297817,
-0.020294277,
-0.0184641201,
0.0465507582,
-0.0491928868,
-0.0198846646,
0.026930457,
2.372e-7,
-0.0143077318,
0.0160325635,
0.038647119,
-0.0070762765,
0.0484619699,
0.0613069944,
-0.0091471784,
0.0676453039,
-0.0300474521,
-0.091003105,
0.0764216259,
0.0449215956,
0.0201105699,
0.0132632358,
-0.0537753776,
-0.0300079435,
-0.0412866957,
-0.080494009,
-0.0229320452,
-0.0761337653,
0.0423151962,
0.0622887388,
0.0278324429,
-0.0104741585,
0.0169379525,
-0.0540107079,
0.071891278,
-0.031362541,
0.0336597711,
-0.0000696798,
-0.0103005953,
0.0214144681,
-0.048074834,
0.0654413477,
-0.0046147928,
0.0142174056,
0.0400043316,
0.0671495646,
-0.0705215335,
0.0104776463,
-0.0025850527,
0.0343301967,
-0.0275406167,
-0.046389807,
0.0791598484,
-0.053524401,
0.012617127,
0.0189080909,
-0.0249656513,
-0.0223704651,
-0.0011964362,
0.0072010262,
-0.0114971017,
0.0653554127,
0.0426587462,
-0.0152127268,
-0.0074433093,
-0.073738955,
-0.0271555837,
-0.0081361979,
-0.053900186,
-0.0317606404,
-0.0134395156,
-0.0251727626,
-0.005354424,
0.010663054,
0.0051174536,
1.257515043e-34,
0.0093280738,
0.0146158123,
-0.0136826746,
-0.0097329179,
0.0555155836,
-0.0054488285,
-0.0646224618,
-0.0113831954,
0.0200919807,
-0.037514057,
0.0205816068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14072v1 | Origin Tracing and Detecting of LLMs | 2023-04-27T10:05:57 | 2023-04-27T10:05:57 | Linyang Li, Pengyu Wang, Ke Ren, Tianxiang Sun, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The extraordinary performance of large language models (LLMs) heightens the
importance of detecting whether the context is generated by an AI system. More
importantly, while more and more companies and institutions release their LLMs,
the origin can be hard to trace. Since LLMs are heading towards the time of
AGI, similar to the origin tracing in anthropology, it is of great importance
to trace the origin of LLMs. In this paper, we first raise the concern of the
origin tracing of LLMs and propose an effective method to trace and detect
AI-generated contexts. We introduce a novel algorithm that leverages the
contrastive features between LLMs and extracts model-wise features to trace the
text origins. Our proposed method works under both white-box and black-box
settings therefore can be widely generalized to detect various LLMs.(e.g. can
be generalized to detect GPT-3 models without the GPT-3 models). Also, our
proposed method requires only limited data compared with the supervised
learning methods and can be extended to trace new-coming model origins. We
construct extensive experiments to examine whether we can trace the origins of
given texts. We provide valuable observations based on the experimental
results, such as the difficulty level of AI origin tracing, and the AI origin
similarities, and call for ethical concerns of LLM providers. We are releasing
all codes and data as a toolkit and benchmark for future AI origin tracing and
detecting studies. \footnote{We are releasing all available resource at
\url{https://github.com/OpenLMLab/}.} | [
0.0535982847,
0.0677000806,
-0.0380119458,
0.0658136457,
-0.0628159791,
0.0043380144,
0.0297261477,
0.0220754314,
0.0342802443,
-0.0297737177,
-0.0262981951,
-0.0293932371,
0.0119244289,
0.0449022651,
0.0276997387,
0.0317237042,
0.0237826519,
0.0147422161,
0.0119271446,
0.0033473214,
-0.0050630979,
0.0356790908,
0.04961906,
0.0446689539,
-0.0110036423,
-0.0243976116,
0.0139512429,
-0.0136260744,
0.0125667527,
0.0032137875,
0.0056048222,
0.0270887129,
-0.0014307734,
0.0835623667,
0.0000020303,
-0.0798264891,
-0.0589961335,
-0.0239978265,
-0.0297319312,
0.0148681859,
0.0297378562,
0.005848818,
-0.0332947597,
0.0134208808,
-0.0592578724,
0.0397130884,
0.0201045405,
0.0169019587,
0.0136967218,
0.0859845355,
-0.01951956,
-0.0092965653,
0.0367105417,
-0.0014067382,
-0.0094747907,
-0.0290456191,
0.0406732596,
-0.0254108291,
-0.0349461921,
-0.0006727309,
0.0158001557,
0.0356996916,
0.0056947363,
0.001788037,
-0.0443942994,
-0.006756457,
-0.0217286143,
-0.0208025742,
0.0032266402,
0.0541331284,
0.0098034861,
-0.0477014966,
0.0557588115,
-0.0088273464,
0.0065072272,
0.0083633335,
-0.0052654557,
0.06848941,
-0.0478705876,
0.0290403962,
0.0986594483,
-0.0080862986,
0.0397535786,
0.0404229835,
-0.0355857611,
0.0733013079,
-0.0032178317,
-0.0283369459,
-0.0283449646,
-0.0123795485,
0.0103936018,
-0.0318169855,
0.0285371188,
0.001763555,
0.0063542309,
0.0197333377,
-0.030629022,
-0.0268627424,
-0.006308611,
-0.0317447819,
0.0274964049,
0.0091546988,
-0.0664809421,
0.0385818444,
-0.0300409403,
0.0543083921,
-0.0325950757,
-0.0028306751,
-0.0023999345,
0.0074620415,
-0.017183084,
-0.0008619043,
0.0026070373,
0.0054087117,
-0.0423445515,
0.008117618,
-0.0240523331,
0.0275004748,
-0.0123663526,
-0.0084056351,
-0.0401905663,
-0.0121122729,
0.0091118887,
-0.0068005626,
0.0262766145,
-0.0344257578,
-0.0264537763,
0.0358500145,
-0.0313833803,
-0.081452705,
0.0046990514,
0.0627677217,
0.0194307957,
-0.0046006176,
0.0200781338,
0.0677437708,
0.0303593371,
-0.0377271101,
-0.0701847821,
-0.0416158326,
-0.0064302874,
-0.0343701504,
-0.0201950986,
-0.0522776246,
-0.0110353129,
-0.0081903925,
-0.0165814925,
-0.0775496736,
-0.0052095242,
0.0040707537,
-0.0611609891,
0.0334945992,
-0.0417849198,
-0.0016849609,
0.0429376438,
0.001956542,
-0.0298582129,
0.0311133601,
0.051409997,
0.0320013836,
0.0821631774,
-0.0014830673,
0.0267491303,
0.0540609471,
0.0307481326,
0.0135033643,
0.001449788,
-0.0124132531,
-0.0232853089,
-0.0166607071,
0.0079558622,
0.0447633751,
0.0236268062,
-0.0289420765,
0.0469306521,
0.0901719481,
-0.0232801661,
0.0069184038,
0.0550890677,
-0.0124672232,
0.0032518608,
0.0467042439,
-0.0181202646,
-0.0593952537,
-0.0637821183,
-0.0393010713,
0.0071458188,
0.0411752947,
0.0013671765,
-0.0344511867,
-0.0043863058,
-0.0209052954,
-0.0185322557,
-0.0070956359,
0.048981484,
-0.0096293408,
-0.0339758582,
-0.0242391527,
0.0273647197,
-0.0544841178,
-0.0169928502,
-0.0908201709,
0.0695851818,
0.0393805504,
0.0375225991,
-0.0300029851,
0.0386109762,
-0.020106433,
-0.0158688631,
0.0373374671,
-0.0266215429,
-0.0153608164,
0.0020149692,
-0.0072387848,
-0.0187924877,
-0.0047944905,
0.0232318603,
0.0368346833,
0.0082213515,
0.0332129933,
0.0120856306,
-0.0143082235,
-0.0376773328,
0.0394755863,
-0.0888948068,
-0.0250833239,
0.0108399093,
0.0180287324,
0.0413706712,
0.0454428084,
-0.0152237592,
-0.0015624245,
0.0279082563,
-0.0340997763,
-0.010987631,
0.0304221697,
-0.0079300655,
0.0170952063,
0.0565412492,
-0.0145268776,
0.0198054276,
0.0144924838,
-0.0105155166,
-0.0461895764,
0.0322493725,
-0.0334707201,
0.0474826209,
-0.03947898,
0.0355482846,
-0.0345847569,
0.0412928686,
-0.0309718568,
0.091076754,
-0.0163510367,
0.0059360145,
0.0309061538,
-0.0175795145,
0.0516137928,
0.0064879959,
0.0030191711,
0.0060770535,
-0.0311498567,
0.0095196031,
0.0540399104,
-0.0062106955,
-0.0272145215,
0.0037525638,
-0.0889465883,
-0.0049704541,
-0.0368784107,
0.020588804,
0.0336879529,
-0.0190116204,
-0.0205512643,
0.020350581,
-0.0279830247,
-0.0351521559,
0.013375463,
-0.0018243233,
0.0273405053,
-0.0129734864,
-0.0249952078,
-0.0550678223,
0.0205892567,
-0.038274169,
0.0593385324,
0.0331427306,
-0.0448880717,
-0.0738716125,
0.0379774496,
-0.0243528262,
0.0044899709,
-0.0369520262,
-0.0085168639,
0.009034628,
-0.0240274761,
-0.0133349663,
0.0648550913,
-0.0014863075,
0.0563102849,
0.03896771,
0.0142197339,
-0.0504839309,
-0.0310156979,
-0.0045513674,
0.0337589607,
-0.0195758976,
-0.0711386651,
0.0180989318,
0.0677041411,
0.0347512998,
-0.0132671008,
-0.010275336,
0.0261737835,
-0.0112291183,
-0.0355122164,
0.0228932649,
-0.0245934948,
-0.0596919879,
0.090330705,
0.0019718232,
-0.0811884999,
0.021993544,
-0.0412947573,
0.0320740081,
0.0028598832,
-0.0733744055,
-0.0399475656,
0.0369626991,
-0.0126251746,
0.0268244278,
0.024384534,
-0.0299849994,
-0.0269920267,
0.0068773865,
0.0526759103,
-0.0266729724,
0.0321445987,
-0.0290964097,
0.0267243646,
0.0155784367,
-0.0126831895,
-0.0401423126,
-0.0508070476,
-0.0109408498,
0.0017913237,
0.0282936767,
-0.055245243,
0.0106653785,
0.0044531496,
0.031355802,
0.0541730672,
-0.0024550089,
0.0151401702,
-0.0269969571,
0.0345071964,
0.0470114164,
-0.0432629287,
0.0462731421,
-0.020373188,
0.0132825961,
0.0188419241,
0.0081390738,
0.027650483,
-0.0159285106,
-0.0095472913,
0.0227187984,
-0.0110364184,
-0.0405430458,
0.0107275955,
0.0093444772,
-0.0233321227,
0.0099795787,
0.1086060926,
0.028116636,
-0.0592616796,
0.0095317988,
-0.0096014207,
-0.0078641949,
0.0197805595,
-0.0031199157,
-0.0996578038,
-0.0006420918,
-0.000097218,
0.0132649224,
-0.0517111905,
-0.0405673012,
-0.0156270079,
-0.1097750291,
0.0303165633,
-0.0039434722,
-0.0731741861,
-0.0206431281,
-0.0287563894,
-0.0069573186,
-0.0093881497,
-0.0013154962,
-0.042307511,
-0.0107233832,
-0.019063035,
0.0049094358,
-0.0364841223,
-0.0453287289,
-0.0051855911,
-0.0308941193,
0.0455165282,
0.0777406618,
0.0355362147,
-0.0330541208,
0.0019415782,
0.0245579649,
-0.0106305229,
-0.0102738366,
-0.0165306032,
0.0362945907,
0.013947445,
-0.0164694432,
0.0196273793,
0.0331233479,
-0.0507214405,
0.0068839365,
0.0383258052,
0.0998487696,
-0.0336715057,
-0.0330352522,
0.0058350922,
-0.0297607593,
0.0304765422,
0.0769634172,
0.0145889688,
-0.0406183638,
-0.0113323517,
-0.036157988,
0.0317384899,
0.0154321175,
-0.0451055057,
-0.0050317412,
-0.0295191202,
-0.0372039452,
-0.1062317714,
-0.0312704407,
-0.0057128025,
0.0142614236,
0.0320483744,
0.0264171809,
-0.0029375947,
-0.0405382775,
-0.027721446,
-0.0064492682,
-0.0449602045,
0.0224684905,
-0.059539061,
0.004467871,
0.0334384888,
-0.018207822,
-0.0017939257,
0.0200478751,
-0.0308140516,
-0.0819891617,
-0.0132760722,
0.0170377847,
0.0219551828,
0.0494628139,
-0.003942946,
-0.0146605065,
0.0203419719,
0.0036651036,
-0.0047524008,
0.0227313768,
0.0362845585,
-0.0186736211,
-0.0248173811,
0.0295654479,
-0.0395467393,
0.0067923432,
0.0200144425,
-0.0029436876,
-0.0963345915,
-0.0022180383,
0.0216104388,
0.0346896499,
0.0399822965,
-0.0551285744,
-0.0359683335,
-0.0484879836,
-0.0260342583,
-0.0212141424,
-0.0008063493,
-0.0463272892,
0.0342341475,
0.0298595019,
0.0026631539,
0.0053076977,
0.0152512044,
-0.0397080183,
0.0070123705,
-0.0385233164,
0.0359177701,
-0.0182365421,
0.0828996226,
-0.0028133828,
0.0151348328,
0.0217872187,
0.0728435144,
-0.0018543684,
0.0750283748,
-0.0016880456,
0.046800077,
0.0120966258,
0.0080818431,
0.0428296514,
0.0329301618,
-0.05701603,
-0.0234498959,
-0.017525563,
0.0094620148,
0.081685029,
-0.0240030177,
0.0869815648,
0.013320527,
-0.0108852126,
-0.0164921787,
0.0462837256,
0.0286734868,
-0.0304678101,
-0.0371213742,
0.0096163936,
-0.0587534085,
0.0393201597,
0.0790612921,
0.0315039083,
0.0584366657,
0.0038805711,
-0.0352761336,
-0.0167860575,
-0.0201946367,
0.0389938168,
-0.0293636881,
-0.0090118349,
0.0375660434,
-0.0616948605,
-0.0561998971,
-0.0006803643,
-0.0406596214,
-0.005788283,
-0.0254364833,
0.0098503893,
0.084781386,
-0.0066257701,
0.0167400986,
-0.0681320056,
-0.0145781161,
-0.0313838348,
-0.0375257768,
-0.0187649895,
-6.419791216e-33,
0.0131269526,
-0.0972269028,
-0.0081518264,
0.0107543813,
0.0217007454,
0.0277846493,
-0.0355151333,
-0.0072971582,
-0.0542171896,
-0.0085057598,
-0.0008619131,
0.0196688287,
0.0070872693,
-0.0198962782,
-0.0146649601,
0.0094368653,
-0.0081334878,
0.008525922,
-0.0107390024,
0.0145973656,
0.0608963184,
0.0147156212,
0.0692305714,
-0.1249442622,
0.0294515267,
-0.0252843536,
-0.0251134112,
0.0295185335,
-0.0363941006,
0.0370189212,
-0.010455803,
0.0035426719,
0.0198085234,
-0.0502004512,
0.0125817889,
-0.0198068935,
-0.0038226109,
-0.0227887984,
0.0220594537,
-0.0011365463,
-0.0033801305,
-0.0576467365,
0.0222485811,
-0.0268135797,
-0.0218668133,
0.0351704285,
0.0647369847,
-0.0249939747,
-0.006903016,
-0.0272275768,
-0.0824630931,
0.0399506874,
-0.0243926067,
0.0344708338,
0.0370195694,
0.036205437,
0.0275562424,
0.0079039931,
-0.0184892546,
0.0143448301,
0.0099423518,
-0.0222316105,
0.0614380948,
0.0121652521,
-0.013008195,
0.0480185524,
0.0143277533,
0.0064723887,
-0.0105009638,
-0.031964913,
0.0081392359,
0.0591344088,
0.0362830684,
0.0392647125,
-0.0233793091,
-0.017770363,
-0.0444278643,
0.0180548169,
0.0373197086,
-0.0266155303,
0.0083509842,
-0.0346789137,
-0.0568773448,
-0.0205021612,
-0.0035282914,
-0.0834187344,
-0.0216516815,
-0.0084379818,
0.0247781631,
-0.0132163037,
-0.0145481704,
-0.0379910655,
0.0174830426,
-0.0752695054,
0.0050713583,
0.0434260294,
-0.0397538729,
0.0017000493,
0.0409083366,
0.0196468215,
-0.0418878794,
-0.0174188092,
-0.0271806531,
-0.0225190595,
0.0648980066,
0.0186465513,
0.0342318937,
0.0120919915,
-0.0304473154,
0.0256096795,
-0.0214246288,
0.0011564264,
-0.0132302446,
-0.0092962347,
0.0027235246,
-0.021351058,
0.0072341925,
0.0289648883,
0.0804533362,
0.0519914813,
-0.0231197607,
-0.0026781112,
-0.0400113501,
0.0238050092,
-0.0602704063,
-0.0132398922,
-0.0006542238,
0.1011243537,
0.0764353052,
-0.0279996917,
-0.0092406012,
-0.0276798438,
2.726e-7,
0.0277434438,
0.0330670625,
0.0221354626,
0.0149420612,
-0.0006016632,
0.0543730892,
0.0014316398,
-0.003367967,
-0.0357143953,
-0.0301667005,
-0.0011150269,
-0.0144424289,
0.0764969587,
0.0144500816,
-0.0691647381,
0.0229804199,
-0.068036668,
-0.0096817212,
-0.0781110004,
0.0112220319,
0.0066547901,
0.0933018178,
0.0296332184,
-0.0456235632,
-0.0120309396,
-0.0480462052,
0.0256620441,
-0.0360835344,
0.0101634888,
0.0261403471,
0.0036202185,
-0.000492878,
-0.012588623,
-0.0387962647,
-0.0175960604,
0.0492339693,
-0.0127891293,
0.0479020923,
0.0157067552,
0.0290488265,
0.0009770581,
-0.0332898386,
0.0150614576,
-0.042149961,
0.0530366115,
0.0811032355,
-0.0276023913,
-0.0665836781,
0.0109677669,
-0.0360802934,
0.0031010183,
-0.0200604685,
0.0436704233,
0.0218927804,
-0.0209542364,
-0.0056123058,
-0.0116039785,
-0.0709416345,
-0.015444749,
0.0003771278,
-0.012522283,
-0.0158489775,
0.0106189996,
0.0039297445,
0.0227277409,
-0.0135688763,
0.0459880456,
2.79953301e-34,
0.0111288186,
-0.0209012348,
0.0191852283,
0.061410863,
0.0570537113,
0.0200413279,
-0.040782515,
0.0190409962,
0.005055123,
-0.0386893116,
0.0167404171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13994v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13994v3 | SweCTRL-Mini: a data-transparent Transformer-based large language model for controllable text generation in Swedish | 2023-04-27T07:32:37 | 2023-06-22T13:02:23 | Dmytro Kalpakchi, Johan Boye | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present SweCTRL-Mini, a large Swedish language model that can be used for
inference and fine-tuning on a single consumer-grade GPU. The model is based on
the CTRL architecture by Keskar, McCann, Varshney, Xiong, and Socher (2019),
which means that users of the SweCTRL-Mini model can control the genre of the
generated text by inserting special tokens in the generation prompts.
SweCTRL-Mini is trained on a subset of the Swedish part of the mC4 corpus and a
set of Swedish novels. In this article, we provide (1) a detailed account of
the utilized training data and text pre-processing steps, to the extent that it
is possible to check whether a specific phrase/source was a part of the
training data, and (2) an evaluation of the model on both discriminative tasks,
using automatic evaluation methods, and generative tasks, using human referees.
We also compare the generative capabilities of the model with those of GPT-3.
SweCTRL-Mini is fully open and available for download. | [
0.0389095657,
0.0378635302,
-0.0007769886,
0.0281316862,
-0.0389152989,
-0.0159476791,
0.0204913579,
-0.0485852361,
-0.045976948,
-0.0346815474,
-0.0035015529,
-0.0431912914,
0.028204238,
0.0660924017,
0.0388586856,
-0.053387899,
0.0104555329,
-0.0772991255,
0.0122978035,
-0.0097546168,
-0.0058047478,
0.0252202023,
0.0044109202,
0.0341096632,
0.0032649839,
-0.0246608723,
-0.0109371729,
-0.00078952,
0.0150419073,
0.0397059917,
0.0205231514,
0.0495669506,
0.0089054825,
0.0716644302,
0.0000020573,
-0.0314636528,
0.0018111249,
-0.03871914,
0.0495391376,
0.0092415502,
0.077864863,
-0.0038469662,
-0.0300102551,
-0.0040025515,
-0.004654543,
-0.0379628167,
0.0298891328,
0.0513279885,
0.0283776782,
0.0497178733,
-0.0318783149,
-0.0530981347,
0.0036634242,
-0.0321974754,
-0.0051861983,
0.0417878255,
0.0191482902,
-0.0050102514,
0.0272818655,
0.0345762409,
-0.0312931389,
0.0377235003,
0.0236509982,
-0.0158776864,
0.0164423734,
0.0308408774,
-0.0372970216,
-0.0309975911,
-0.0129948808,
0.0483378246,
-0.0174928419,
-0.0711939335,
0.0127683738,
-0.0020187788,
-0.0115118017,
-0.0071734213,
-0.0263566915,
0.0463212393,
-0.0247972365,
-0.0062678345,
0.0406907499,
0.006144709,
-0.0073663373,
0.0297867469,
0.0028603263,
0.0109503241,
0.040461652,
-0.0112558324,
0.0073213074,
0.0037075235,
-0.006210675,
-0.0662764013,
0.0379294865,
0.0115408311,
-0.0336107649,
0.0010056129,
-0.0977843851,
-0.0797757059,
0.0375892892,
-0.0175474789,
0.0023768994,
-0.0101466244,
0.0172701497,
0.019021621,
-0.0381743386,
0.0400778465,
-0.0342527181,
-0.0274211541,
-0.0440414548,
-0.0362348296,
-0.0029463645,
-0.0218307078,
-0.07481388,
-0.0272577927,
-0.0623428114,
-0.0507968701,
-0.0406486653,
0.0257659983,
0.0288173016,
0.007972029,
-0.0131277367,
0.0160749611,
-0.0592952184,
0.0269978326,
0.0171867274,
0.0012808681,
-0.0115471678,
0.0087334644,
0.0113827875,
-0.0226211455,
0.0344947539,
0.032739833,
0.0563774221,
-0.0340705328,
0.021452073,
0.0371701457,
-0.0352287255,
-0.0244002733,
0.0073788404,
-0.0609704033,
-0.0021037615,
-0.0537058413,
0.000901726,
-0.0777285025,
0.0214871019,
0.0002558535,
-0.002019251,
-0.0194744878,
0.0220495723,
0.0358097404,
-0.014569886,
0.0369641297,
-0.0398241021,
-0.0209359769,
0.0342161283,
-0.0179227162,
-0.0184517931,
0.0502895825,
0.0315874256,
0.0909377858,
0.0183535963,
-0.013134121,
0.0663439408,
0.0487734973,
-0.0088977413,
0.0119415633,
-0.0408805981,
-0.0358465798,
-0.0471564606,
0.0577150621,
0.0703912377,
0.0795857757,
-0.0079312921,
-0.0113636116,
0.0892067701,
0.0113810049,
0.0199363958,
0.0587844476,
0.0780946761,
0.016618887,
-0.0065436531,
-0.0079856403,
0.0011567054,
0.0094922148,
0.0161876474,
0.0490095764,
-0.0299640857,
0.0370304734,
-0.0038959302,
-0.011212253,
0.0239299145,
0.0045924941,
0.0035008793,
-0.0021959625,
0.047164727,
0.0389421321,
-0.0688807294,
0.0256316997,
0.0120361131,
-0.0748496577,
0.0431324579,
-0.0261855628,
0.0563082173,
0.0722196475,
0.0646896809,
0.0406892933,
-0.0328633226,
-0.0572042726,
0.0159721859,
0.0853457078,
0.0465769358,
-0.0221038368,
0.0009560051,
-0.0510001518,
0.0315892696,
-0.0043579889,
-0.0019989247,
0.059391249,
-0.01741088,
0.0055723027,
0.0061996123,
-0.0173812229,
-0.026862165,
0.0368840136,
-0.0188980065,
-0.0324851461,
0.0000154488,
0.0009947841,
0.0058797793,
-0.0144466823,
-0.0268225651,
0.0183730349,
0.0364215411,
-0.0642589107,
-0.0464476272,
0.0632457808,
-0.0186876301,
-0.0364577807,
0.0061310004,
-0.0653055981,
0.0038452712,
0.009702404,
-0.0202390533,
-0.0535912849,
0.0347209089,
-0.0412709601,
-0.0045912387,
-0.0354637764,
0.0165100731,
0.0063815601,
0.0135585004,
-0.0195618328,
0.0519919321,
0.0023212414,
0.0177098345,
0.0056762602,
0.0170504134,
0.0107257245,
-0.0576869212,
0.0147406096,
0.0332792103,
-0.0095329024,
0.0154804848,
0.0506540686,
-0.0199364349,
-0.0110593047,
-0.0403132103,
-0.0405327864,
0.0032999311,
-0.0176706351,
0.0065025599,
0.0401040912,
0.0167154465,
-0.0198676754,
0.0100403056,
-0.055521518,
-0.001251733,
0.0346184373,
-0.0012305679,
0.007666579,
-0.0248035286,
0.0043366021,
-0.0133568896,
-0.0154074309,
0.025381254,
0.0640651286,
0.0423988253,
-0.0186544117,
-0.0379980542,
0.0027901172,
-0.0293286871,
0.0357130468,
-0.0034449392,
-0.0425171927,
-0.0031681373,
-0.017921757,
0.0829027072,
0.0402460881,
0.0112604415,
-0.0450253971,
0.0161933545,
-0.0255717263,
0.0123027246,
-0.0070112301,
-0.0354459733,
-0.000153883,
-0.0105306003,
-0.0359480791,
0.0242727734,
0.0781510472,
0.022291515,
-0.0024793688,
-0.0422217697,
0.0267002657,
0.0004388734,
-0.0229551494,
-0.0223982446,
-0.0232378524,
-0.0136300568,
0.0478828959,
-0.0379101448,
-0.0263265204,
0.0204188582,
-0.059611626,
-0.0055439705,
-0.052323617,
-0.0003187341,
-0.0165790096,
0.0647035837,
0.041231215,
0.0495881401,
-0.0288894586,
0.011250454,
-0.0144831631,
0.0228401367,
0.0299247988,
-0.0186561625,
0.0282576643,
-0.0390410349,
-0.0013343929,
-0.0109471222,
-0.0219381042,
-0.0307023264,
-0.0474946462,
-0.0484215915,
-0.0090573542,
0.0752556473,
-0.0285708867,
-0.0222318117,
0.0044586104,
-0.0104086883,
0.0698759332,
-0.0380012505,
-0.018605873,
-0.0395967662,
0.0271525234,
0.0820990726,
-0.0352049135,
-0.0123372069,
-0.0346160494,
0.0035630479,
0.0322639197,
-0.0237474944,
0.0159483254,
-0.0429620743,
0.0207672063,
0.0466680713,
-0.0201587901,
-0.0190658625,
-0.0216468703,
0.0460452959,
-0.0669862553,
-0.0141345588,
0.0826218277,
0.0053304876,
-0.0044329488,
0.0142044807,
0.0219474826,
0.0400339179,
0.0191437714,
0.0467478707,
-0.0794145763,
-0.001019596,
0.0248780232,
0.0375645012,
-0.0283666998,
-0.0095706927,
-0.0388030373,
-0.0849403515,
0.0636331514,
0.0312559977,
-0.0700221211,
-0.020888377,
-0.0135676609,
-0.0338388532,
-0.0252630915,
-0.035600774,
0.0112472689,
-0.0128688393,
0.0352921039,
-0.0166164655,
0.0423688181,
-0.0256548133,
0.0061284592,
-0.0279153362,
0.0253040139,
0.0366928205,
0.0300974511,
-0.0049955244,
-0.0780061558,
0.0046439432,
-0.0360292606,
-0.0304457489,
-0.0242237244,
0.0371282138,
-0.0090923617,
-0.0097580766,
-0.0583513901,
0.0796983391,
-0.0034441622,
-0.0452538729,
0.0130308708,
0.0488099419,
0.0105311703,
-0.0456502251,
0.0109045682,
0.0113899512,
0.0264764987,
0.0518062301,
0.0367077403,
-0.0310059413,
-0.0522046424,
-0.0516180433,
0.0082757622,
-0.0686158538,
0.0068005789,
-0.0104294932,
0.0347557031,
-0.0315451622,
-0.06589026,
-0.0228885282,
0.0324159116,
0.0664956346,
0.0274330713,
0.0161241125,
-0.0038001265,
-0.0450175628,
-0.086210005,
0.0025038011,
-0.0146559402,
0.0179824997,
-0.0472581647,
-0.0309720188,
0.0133512178,
-0.0789066702,
-0.0039910628,
0.0309508238,
-0.0394725576,
-0.0692344978,
0.0094994335,
0.0585294664,
0.0245707296,
0.0440209918,
-0.0174628384,
-0.0743971318,
0.0449541695,
0.0278328136,
-0.0482127219,
0.0352336243,
0.0020598755,
0.0100109624,
-0.0299927536,
0.0048773168,
-0.0154925473,
0.0393544324,
-0.0074614319,
0.002638801,
0.0530062094,
0.0148832155,
0.0128151421,
-0.0208457503,
0.0027870713,
-0.0938331261,
0.0225885026,
-0.0821563005,
-0.0331278779,
-0.0171255823,
-0.0052167224,
-0.039260786,
0.0011245525,
0.0079278219,
0.0048183599,
-0.0238537919,
-0.0120931454,
-0.047851,
0.0310091395,
-0.0411715694,
0.0118318023,
0.0158105735,
0.0241579991,
0.0448016785,
0.0173770823,
-0.0136155477,
0.0230944175,
-0.0176578891,
0.0452176817,
-0.0120565267,
0.0496852696,
0.0148839653,
-0.0056583141,
0.0081692673,
0.0211506709,
-0.0484763645,
0.0122614661,
-0.0235502683,
-0.0280834027,
0.0655424148,
-0.0139032733,
0.1142635122,
-0.0279613081,
-0.0110012172,
-0.0153353214,
0.0584618412,
0.0031509229,
-0.0361901708,
-0.0012497692,
0.0087525975,
-0.0183981843,
-0.0000986087,
0.065889366,
0.0331901796,
0.0250510331,
0.0368013196,
-0.0159884002,
-0.0483380295,
-0.0081325714,
0.0042041624,
-0.0230525974,
-0.0102831321,
-0.0112894243,
-0.0473770089,
-0.0426523425,
0.0051377015,
0.0252186973,
0.0239481069,
-0.0014343447,
0.0420203507,
0.0445535854,
-0.0217055492,
-0.0155544439,
-0.0658115223,
0.045991119,
0.0058781151,
-0.0316794105,
-0.0241436474,
-6.114994714e-33,
-0.0300108455,
-0.0276955981,
0.0272456706,
-0.0133176884,
-0.0164201185,
-0.0069029089,
-0.0423923656,
-0.024742879,
0.0712986067,
0.0207986888,
0.0134989275,
-0.0354550071,
0.0122702233,
0.0378038622,
-0.0265195072,
0.006582527,
0.0832966939,
0.0094277924,
-0.0068613011,
0.0446434878,
0.0341414437,
0.0467303656,
0.0445256941,
-0.0193276163,
-0.0267745182,
-0.0383638926,
-0.036566332,
-0.0077548078,
0.0262630433,
0.0175067503,
-0.0366343781,
0.052648101,
0.0014946479,
-0.0196546894,
-0.0205241833,
0.0381554477,
-0.0663174018,
-0.0134903379,
0.0020919438,
0.0391137078,
-0.0115227532,
-0.0522775128,
0.0351323411,
-0.0260840487,
0.0114587508,
0.0066166711,
0.0394662172,
0.0004915389,
-0.0203845426,
-0.09582863,
-0.0947990865,
0.0271430798,
-0.0094223451,
-0.023499215,
0.0420387685,
0.0511734337,
0.0073790555,
-0.0181810427,
-0.0518466681,
0.0505179428,
0.0388682075,
-0.000951239,
0.0544664487,
0.0512651354,
0.0138171772,
0.0505371243,
0.0229924377,
0.0205148365,
-0.0309542622,
0.0600352809,
0.0343970545,
0.0251403823,
0.0306080393,
0.0607595406,
0.0278111733,
-0.0102554047,
-0.0342432633,
0.0045794598,
-0.0218540654,
0.0217800867,
0.0183917433,
-0.0348218158,
-0.010837934,
-0.0351488404,
-0.041871842,
-0.0815975815,
-0.0162785854,
-0.0012941024,
0.0470567234,
0.0155375311,
-0.0201032162,
-0.0262342952,
0.0134019898,
-0.0145575982,
-0.0131843863,
0.00163381,
-0.0588114411,
0.0308181215,
-0.0267816354,
0.0109909913,
-0.0214041527,
-0.0593687892,
0.0322801061,
0.0165355355,
0.0178345647,
0.0495040454,
0.0202204809,
0.0550763197,
-0.0595858954,
0.0346570238,
-0.0476343855,
0.0575772226,
0.0428503789,
0.0020517602,
0.0152463857,
-0.0111333486,
-0.0255830754,
0.0115484474,
0.014188394,
0.0030293767,
-0.021572914,
-0.0381272435,
0.0006219364,
0.0575672537,
-0.0408865884,
0.028553959,
-0.0208841823,
0.0071978876,
0.0653772652,
-0.0711661875,
-0.0093607875,
-0.0185703021,
2.794e-7,
0.0018066335,
0.044984512,
0.0060004485,
-0.008650206,
0.0059097894,
-0.0011724542,
0.0257628579,
0.0340630412,
0.0078455964,
0.0212655999,
-0.0091774389,
-0.0058288798,
0.0484870635,
0.0350775793,
-0.0985705554,
0.0249981061,
-0.0467031859,
0.0521567911,
-0.0665624291,
-0.0229352899,
0.0578899011,
0.0814425051,
0.0078199245,
-0.030593371,
0.0389224924,
-0.0262758862,
0.067061469,
-0.0100263115,
0.0007602596,
0.0102747418,
0.061219804,
-0.0174716134,
-0.0174002722,
0.0006913186,
-0.0099487584,
-0.0069289226,
-0.0019027531,
0.05667454,
-0.0041813627,
0.0227058791,
0.0461811908,
-0.0146889444,
-0.0269255638,
-0.0822472498,
0.052062314,
-0.0346598029,
-0.0324653164,
-0.0103202844,
-0.0367338434,
0.032219328,
-0.0157515444,
-0.0770150721,
-0.0280975886,
0.0259952545,
0.0282748453,
0.0120505607,
-0.0259623881,
-0.0041508125,
-0.0351937637,
-0.0107204951,
-0.0466448553,
-0.0298069175,
-0.0749837682,
0.016968295,
-0.0076118479,
-0.0136857396,
0.0126838963,
2.77866523e-34,
0.0445170105,
-0.0029873496,
-0.0475795418,
-0.0562165156,
0.0283531174,
-0.0297845304,
0.0812976062,
0.0507343262,
0.0172801204,
-0.0566578433,
-0.0404148027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13989v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13989v1 | Cross-Domain Evaluation of POS Taggers: From Wall Street Journal to Fandom Wiki | 2023-04-27T07:24:29 | 2023-04-27T07:24:29 | Kia Kirstein Hansen, Rob van der Goot | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Wall Street Journal section of the Penn Treebank has been the de-facto
standard for evaluating POS taggers for a long time, and accuracies over 97\%
have been reported. However, less is known about out-of-domain tagger
performance, especially with fine-grained label sets. Using data from Elder
Scrolls Fandom, a wiki about the \textit{Elder Scrolls} video game universe, we
create a modest dataset for qualitatively evaluating the cross-domain
performance of two POS taggers: the Stanford tagger (Toutanova et al. 2003) and
Bilty (Plank et al. 2016), both trained on WSJ. Our analyses show that
performance on tokens seen during training is almost as good as in-domain
performance, but accuracy on unknown tokens decreases from 90.37% to 78.37%
(Stanford) and 87.84\% to 80.41\% (Bilty) across domains. Both taggers struggle
with proper nouns and inconsistent capitalization. | [
0.0758987293,
0.017385982,
-0.0066763042,
0.0259868503,
-0.0000107993,
0.0269588847,
0.0125126373,
0.0317245275,
0.0126601076,
-0.0497296117,
-0.0352727175,
-0.0200691763,
0.0145987673,
0.0152703617,
0.0000271952,
-0.0111219184,
0.0436768793,
-0.0012483859,
0.0406532735,
0.0125772133,
-0.0114606787,
0.0163191967,
-0.0185541455,
0.0560445935,
-0.0167086814,
-0.0423465855,
0.0370793305,
0.0056381156,
-0.0121269897,
-0.0559894629,
0.0265513007,
0.0048920074,
-0.0128088994,
0.0652063787,
0.0000016391,
-0.059718214,
-0.0093424479,
-0.0069109839,
0.0843362659,
-0.0029009643,
0.0233650357,
-0.0125598842,
-0.010383809,
-0.0120896529,
-0.033954747,
-0.0550096408,
0.0615108237,
0.0640158728,
0.0235978812,
0.0461297706,
-0.0177434087,
-0.0734035969,
0.01434993,
-0.0026380764,
0.0534311719,
-0.0454478227,
0.0028462166,
0.0265173856,
-0.0170337856,
-0.0073842439,
-0.0271124151,
0.018465016,
-0.0597810037,
-0.0112228785,
0.0088193361,
0.0286412649,
-0.0250463281,
0.0071115647,
0.0062777554,
0.0170060508,
0.0581656136,
-0.0118514476,
0.0216088686,
0.0291658789,
-0.038031809,
0.0097558955,
-0.001616994,
-0.0009611975,
-0.0505071543,
-0.0012635114,
0.0184152871,
0.0102034798,
0.0234208666,
-0.0076214722,
-0.0103431586,
0.1078752875,
0.0358808637,
-0.028493138,
-0.0066689411,
0.0565728806,
-0.0111529827,
-0.0776466504,
0.022336565,
-0.038551908,
-0.0107157193,
0.0196370967,
-0.0398796871,
-0.0216300003,
0.0003345797,
-0.0364609957,
0.0282231085,
0.0066387793,
0.0051295673,
0.0667106137,
-0.018041566,
-0.0059335264,
0.0157019682,
-0.0008411595,
0.0224091895,
-0.0062086456,
-0.0954673812,
0.0028728629,
-0.0203655567,
0.0642366633,
-0.0092445826,
-0.0228178427,
-0.0688374341,
-0.0486422814,
0.0005934159,
0.0054578497,
-0.0140078561,
-0.0017956248,
-0.0051170117,
0.0000380431,
-0.0619025715,
0.045740325,
-0.0563483872,
0.0015738467,
0.0008240115,
-0.004771505,
0.0070298072,
0.032255426,
-0.0021001587,
-0.0370225422,
0.0469734482,
0.0408582725,
0.0380359739,
-0.0202943552,
-0.0267034378,
-0.0490164049,
-0.0464668572,
-0.0128033152,
-0.0023743531,
-0.0394664183,
0.0192016568,
0.0268922076,
0.0181911066,
-0.0727583468,
0.0162228588,
0.0367273912,
-0.0248294435,
0.0699416399,
-0.0231887773,
-0.0061433259,
0.0084099248,
0.0042200619,
-0.0386035703,
0.0429134183,
0.0300066583,
0.0301333293,
0.0836967155,
0.0248915497,
-0.0046076681,
0.0243481379,
-0.0464754924,
-0.0368519872,
0.0023662578,
-0.0288390536,
0.0294834897,
0.0324710459,
0.0303261895,
0.0377428122,
-0.0135480566,
0.0056464421,
0.0436593071,
0.0501359291,
0.0134517234,
0.006932517,
0.0540784374,
-0.0307153519,
0.0147741996,
-0.0039814156,
0.0143081434,
-0.0456962585,
-0.0005445494,
0.0356810689,
-0.0290459991,
0.0249139052,
0.012731594,
-0.0049804123,
-0.0122898649,
-0.0067075836,
-0.029336106,
-0.0347601697,
0.0890730694,
-0.000161962,
-0.0490577184,
0.0433693528,
0.0441609174,
-0.0473077632,
0.0258940104,
-0.0176429078,
-0.022846546,
0.0804010257,
0.0600913428,
-0.0237463675,
-0.0119249187,
-0.0125037227,
0.0133311646,
0.0464524068,
0.0523826629,
-0.0306625701,
0.0080979448,
-0.0506211482,
-0.0097121941,
-0.018870309,
0.0273330119,
0.0638634339,
0.0163105149,
0.0296323504,
0.0241425727,
-0.0834670365,
-0.0105980644,
0.0525596514,
-0.0259939674,
-0.0011077455,
-0.0322253034,
-0.0198690463,
-0.0306211039,
0.0435907431,
-0.0422806777,
-0.0090242447,
0.0223501548,
-0.0420963019,
0.0151714962,
-0.0274737943,
0.0204893295,
0.0403887257,
0.0873063952,
-0.0640008226,
0.0017713197,
0.0254111532,
0.0215675775,
-0.0275552981,
-0.024242552,
0.0023346522,
0.0507259108,
-0.0069442876,
0.002634936,
-0.0332696922,
0.020906074,
-0.0499983877,
0.033897154,
0.0395446345,
0.0412544049,
-0.0178964715,
-0.0444696359,
0.0250812247,
0.008919701,
-0.0570072308,
-0.0141662685,
-0.0121784117,
-0.0227185953,
0.0316785946,
-0.0504528917,
-0.0495675579,
-0.0177859012,
-0.0792247504,
-0.0047356184,
0.0124909505,
0.0506319255,
-0.0157837924,
0.0016772803,
-0.037939921,
0.0073618623,
0.0015537207,
-0.0234777462,
-0.0061177392,
0.0338870883,
0.0313736461,
0.01571602,
0.0053188489,
-0.0139150089,
-0.0113003869,
-0.0293464456,
0.0302701723,
0.0425182991,
-0.0856413692,
-0.0395843796,
-0.036144644,
-0.037674576,
-0.0136191472,
0.006196856,
-0.0163235981,
0.0273222364,
0.0132537177,
0.0335683376,
0.0064859027,
0.0093348268,
0.0101321237,
0.0066297222,
-0.0425291993,
-0.0011933905,
-0.031785354,
0.0038788416,
-0.0603670068,
-0.0066756182,
-0.0159822591,
0.0620807149,
0.0698460862,
-0.0325821936,
0.0071097817,
-0.0208126567,
-0.0183174349,
-0.0350880921,
-0.038067136,
-0.0016023994,
-0.0180670172,
-0.0255053751,
0.0351593494,
0.0232918859,
0.0022707363,
0.0365140326,
-0.0379491709,
0.009855099,
-0.0414867662,
0.0192092098,
-0.0050948411,
0.0522756651,
-0.0298622996,
0.0205582492,
0.0462306552,
-0.0924714059,
-0.0069857039,
0.0368337259,
0.0620284528,
-0.0162641313,
0.0022810672,
0.0151772918,
0.0005103552,
0.0060124574,
0.0181520898,
-0.0045739901,
-0.0345384181,
-0.0569675975,
-0.0325373039,
0.0219453238,
-0.0210854411,
-0.0183354821,
0.0473963507,
-0.0116552776,
-0.0010218465,
-0.0142118493,
-0.038896732,
0.016812481,
0.0148535995,
0.0465014987,
-0.0191671625,
0.0040935078,
-0.0044504292,
-0.0236651022,
0.0488548689,
-0.0112310844,
-0.061891757,
-0.0136495959,
0.0060858321,
0.0440908782,
-0.079245083,
-0.0381687917,
-0.0053045666,
0.0114932731,
-0.0634164512,
-0.0247217491,
0.1270832866,
0.0644084811,
-0.0378247239,
-0.0187113788,
0.0217445362,
-0.0069092712,
0.0206285566,
0.0249516983,
-0.0992601588,
-0.0401575975,
0.0206149891,
0.0440127999,
0.0233690348,
-0.0837722123,
0.0341745242,
-0.1354900748,
-0.0037492695,
-0.020272769,
-0.0018693282,
-0.0056641186,
-0.020994477,
-0.0164845809,
0.0130701046,
-0.0600192472,
-0.0203287639,
-0.0225715898,
0.0419545546,
0.0133875823,
-0.0159205738,
-0.0371093415,
0.0218851883,
-0.0694914311,
0.0230865609,
0.0890976638,
0.0489152558,
-0.0097829327,
-0.0353280492,
0.0161529277,
-0.0020691764,
0.0035706353,
-0.0204331148,
0.0503149331,
-0.0287991017,
-0.0008209813,
0.010786525,
-0.0358269624,
-0.016416356,
-0.0022524034,
0.0106095783,
0.0487681329,
0.0372802727,
-0.0065185949,
-0.0195668563,
0.0348571651,
0.027326636,
0.073923111,
0.0205109697,
-0.0339573994,
-0.0287400801,
-0.0211027842,
0.0089425426,
-0.0114737889,
-0.0064734262,
-0.0160010718,
-0.0292107332,
-0.0728102475,
-0.1041079611,
-0.0332824439,
0.028913049,
0.0618929341,
0.0272525363,
0.0120566823,
-0.0478322692,
0.0229738895,
-0.0279716589,
-0.0000062944,
-0.0267231707,
0.0029823191,
-0.0672196299,
0.0105593055,
0.0832156241,
0.0249914676,
-0.0492268689,
0.0118614798,
-0.0052377139,
-0.0520796217,
0.0359759703,
0.0223025642,
0.0348222218,
-0.0126861306,
-0.035491813,
-0.0245467257,
-0.0273701623,
0.0655841157,
-0.0860355198,
0.0047448734,
0.0029765549,
-0.008938374,
-0.008859775,
-0.0023249376,
-0.0365311056,
0.0316347033,
-0.030867761,
0.0512416027,
0.0129757058,
0.0166906845,
-0.011283434,
0.0172657575,
0.0857544467,
-0.0895848796,
-0.0301085413,
-0.0120416824,
0.0136249317,
-0.0324186198,
-0.0008958495,
-0.0098428056,
-0.0461797044,
0.0466809198,
-0.0077772886,
-0.0372123942,
0.0816233531,
-0.0287004188,
0.0471008606,
-0.0384579152,
-0.0003838258,
0.0452164561,
0.0197008401,
-0.0184968002,
-0.0143394871,
0.0038305277,
-0.0335095413,
0.0375733897,
0.0465068594,
-0.0231240299,
0.0120749306,
0.0347933322,
0.0176678821,
0.0122773368,
0.0224534385,
-0.0592356063,
0.0303368345,
0.0044299676,
0.0176080782,
0.0551519282,
-0.004291899,
0.0486887619,
-0.0125367241,
-0.0409603715,
0.0192343369,
0.0090552717,
0.0141900545,
-0.0178124588,
-0.0161799788,
0.0114967134,
-0.0445455983,
0.018987339,
0.0695480555,
0.0030934815,
0.0049384702,
0.0444324091,
-0.0649439543,
-0.0198199041,
0.0134116709,
-0.02967567,
0.0423006043,
-0.0201595388,
-0.0139331687,
-0.0917622969,
-0.0468340218,
-0.000070885,
0.0187940951,
0.0269575939,
0.0288300198,
0.0058807759,
0.0570536107,
0.0376011319,
0.0318448395,
-0.0287549663,
0.0162032526,
-0.0153072774,
-0.0138889635,
-0.0464085229,
-5.07094708e-33,
-0.0337614678,
-0.0190283917,
-0.0073235063,
0.0107689779,
-0.0474013686,
-0.0325993747,
-0.0139552057,
0.0158903282,
0.00477794,
0.0294996426,
-0.0169062726,
-0.00154204,
0.0319630653,
0.0209881607,
0.0480128191,
-0.030377619,
0.0383254103,
0.0106681352,
-0.0294529237,
0.0004087141,
0.0383677781,
0.0374715365,
0.0568997711,
-0.05268443,
0.0340889134,
0.0151223028,
-0.0170446765,
-0.0199098531,
0.1196224838,
0.0668061227,
0.0100111347,
0.0271485783,
-0.0050413418,
-0.0061942409,
0.0248725377,
0.0060071973,
-0.0990371257,
-0.0053066788,
0.0204385575,
0.0230134744,
0.1001520306,
0.0076303482,
0.0152918827,
0.0164645649,
0.0160067994,
-0.0231163353,
0.0459093824,
-0.0129905045,
-0.0090384558,
-0.0808815882,
-0.0851879194,
0.0155734634,
0.0217971411,
0.0352896564,
0.0532942452,
0.0040766033,
0.0311359297,
0.0463098697,
-0.0668866336,
0.005914174,
-0.0110007683,
0.007823173,
0.0437368415,
0.0412196815,
-0.0149827227,
0.0812956616,
0.0427558459,
0.0444434397,
0.012816472,
0.0412929878,
0.0280923806,
-0.0206202455,
0.0496408828,
0.0385200419,
0.039755974,
-0.0102631701,
-0.055296734,
0.0403944813,
-0.0025350987,
-0.0153585915,
-0.0048640263,
-0.0268162712,
-0.0489906706,
-0.0172214899,
0.0093952212,
-0.0139911706,
-0.0349179693,
-0.0595146827,
0.0124895833,
-0.0492387339,
-0.0248186272,
0.035601072,
-0.0242242366,
-0.0747279599,
-0.0505408198,
-0.0026935958,
0.0047749439,
0.0566670932,
-0.0285595674,
0.0032655329,
-0.0340537168,
-0.0231285021,
-0.0176643059,
0.0286966842,
0.0394711122,
-0.034486752,
0.0204381272,
-0.0167467557,
-0.0950123817,
-0.022554215,
0.0115637062,
0.0252173189,
-0.0097266212,
0.0238922834,
0.0455910489,
-0.0131201278,
-0.0230694897,
-0.0088536739,
0.0422396995,
0.0155685954,
0.0161648225,
-0.0219197515,
0.0164481197,
0.0007233659,
-0.0008090735,
-0.0025699828,
0.0010942786,
0.0242148675,
0.0180330426,
-0.0328313559,
-0.0476966053,
-0.0211658776,
2.445e-7,
0.0445300527,
0.0445186011,
0.01098572,
0.0019947502,
-0.0294930004,
0.0289351996,
0.0174395386,
0.027802024,
0.0363697782,
-0.0605848767,
-0.0385218002,
-0.0421536975,
0.0344722047,
0.0369757712,
-0.1347488314,
-0.0161910132,
0.0000331407,
0.0303145275,
-0.0491377339,
0.0458125956,
0.0475877859,
0.0218273718,
0.0332992785,
-0.0422737896,
0.0162157025,
-0.0503848083,
0.0534480698,
-0.0220595654,
0.0021449081,
0.0250231177,
0.0235400312,
0.02456972,
-0.0057363412,
0.0199212916,
-0.0580434874,
-0.0014987522,
0.0444140732,
-0.0163537357,
-0.0215951614,
0.0569392815,
-0.0326476358,
-0.032468006,
-0.0002191045,
-0.0425596647,
0.056213025,
-0.0106819402,
-0.0345937945,
-0.0136571974,
-0.0584500097,
-0.0304635316,
-0.0266216975,
-0.0352980644,
-0.0432846658,
0.0219715685,
0.0108852722,
0.0208196025,
-0.0233967565,
-0.0524989776,
0.0013724823,
0.04197108,
-0.0051447605,
-0.0420602858,
-0.0024751017,
-0.0034657109,
0.0001265676,
-0.0344193429,
-0.0037543729,
2.324732015e-34,
0.0165167022,
-0.0264804196,
-0.0206878539,
0.0165974908,
0.0524113998,
-0.0115905507,
0.0072236625,
0.024551155,
0.0039153411,
-0.0459877439,
0.0149360206
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.