id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.04836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.04836v1 | Understanding the Impact of Culture in Assessing Helpfulness of Online Reviews | 2023-04-27T07:20:55 | 2023-04-27T07:20:55 | Khaled Alanezi, Nuha Albadi, Omar Hammad, Maram Kurdi, Shivakant Mishra | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CY | Online reviews have become essential for users to make informed decisions in
everyday tasks ranging from planning summer vacations to purchasing groceries
and making financial investments. A key problem in using online reviews is the
overabundance of online that overwhelms the users. As a result, recommendation
systems for providing helpfulness of reviews are being developed. This paper
argues that cultural background is an important feature that impacts the nature
of a review written by the user, and must be considered as a feature in
assessing the helpfulness of online reviews. The paper provides an in-depth
study of differences in online reviews written by users from different cultural
backgrounds and how incorporating culture as a feature can lead to better
review helpfulness recommendations. In particular, we analyze online reviews
originating from two distinct cultural spheres, namely Arabic and Western
cultures, for two different products, hotels and books. Our analysis
demonstrates that the nature of reviews written by users differs based on their
cultural backgrounds and that this difference varies based on the specific
product being reviewed. Finally, we have developed six different review
helpfulness recommendation models that demonstrate that taking culture into
account leads to better recommendations. | [
0.0639693066,
-0.0049042357,
-0.0409640074,
0.0053562629,
-0.0218423046,
-0.0143799717,
0.0646860301,
0.024769064,
0.0192515776,
-0.0451085009,
-0.063047424,
-0.0754965693,
0.0404411405,
0.0449753776,
-0.0193512719,
-0.0252832081,
-0.0238332953,
-0.0072877412,
0.027345106,
0.0139303859,
0.0371270962,
0.0280733556,
0.0413524024,
0.0166155249,
0.0326349922,
0.0096638342,
0.0493024401,
-0.0289532356,
0.0291708261,
-0.0171571095,
0.0451219007,
0.0213459767,
-0.0259559136,
-0.0233365223,
0.0000020425,
-0.0379666798,
0.0183865149,
-0.0438781939,
0.0221935473,
0.0075603151,
0.0881882459,
0.0018218776,
-0.0017088613,
-0.0184282064,
-0.0207162686,
-0.0461294949,
-0.0093221795,
0.1255627424,
0.0048978478,
-0.0007842754,
0.0146233374,
-0.0163253918,
-0.0653695762,
0.0231229067,
0.0060087703,
0.0356657654,
0.0006108579,
0.032178618,
-0.0030286149,
0.0078177825,
0.0102339666,
-0.0281978603,
-0.0374660343,
-0.0315110236,
0.0019346601,
-0.0143757639,
-0.0325980261,
-0.0096754497,
0.053519927,
0.0153717156,
0.069549866,
0.005173706,
-0.0230370536,
0.009890995,
-0.0291781239,
0.0553269871,
-0.0174782649,
0.0254264958,
0.0025910176,
0.0092399064,
0.0020971939,
0.0311361346,
0.0314300098,
0.0404118188,
0.0819724724,
0.0715705231,
-0.0373289064,
-0.0279275142,
-0.0234422479,
0.0482922196,
0.0053908699,
-0.0309901517,
0.0405822173,
-0.0145861749,
0.0014074864,
-0.0239256956,
0.0580316484,
0.0489035547,
0.0371165089,
-0.090220429,
0.0271552689,
0.0154447649,
-0.014607612,
-0.0083281053,
-0.0292540025,
0.0038976001,
0.0470651127,
-0.0408580974,
-0.0500057265,
0.0609989688,
-0.0288973767,
0.0253603049,
0.0842142031,
0.0073826071,
-0.008456504,
0.0051396387,
-0.1022081524,
-0.0125578353,
-0.0553009212,
0.0157533009,
0.0427803434,
-0.0135367177,
0.0332512371,
-0.0011149661,
-0.0573366731,
-0.0225016847,
-0.0815699473,
0.031182982,
-0.0841826946,
0.0146499621,
0.072775498,
0.0291221738,
0.0286399405,
0.0009118483,
-0.014186101,
-0.004614457,
0.061706461,
-0.0171251241,
-0.0505533256,
0.0089513846,
0.0333367959,
-0.0188521575,
-0.0361112319,
-0.0401762798,
-0.0102965068,
0.0334912091,
0.0037438092,
0.0321977586,
0.0143153341,
-0.0011320462,
0.0102855256,
-0.0051164241,
-0.0008190145,
0.0105755292,
0.0549438037,
0.0187474024,
-0.0074143107,
-0.0012093877,
-0.0283931103,
0.0244391579,
0.0755318254,
0.0398200527,
0.0160429962,
-0.0390081927,
-0.0716795698,
-0.0082049351,
-0.018632656,
0.0274450853,
-0.0599452481,
-0.0460842475,
-0.0059560072,
-0.0029724997,
-0.0452479087,
0.0691826269,
0.0559948832,
0.0013316127,
-0.0306365173,
0.0542098358,
0.0161007009,
0.0227872711,
-0.0360130854,
0.009201671,
0.0105011612,
0.0268564411,
0.0214468017,
-0.0082548587,
-0.0139176864,
0.0340014398,
-0.0225609094,
-0.0608249344,
-0.0118241776,
-0.0197347831,
0.0593989007,
-0.0001138014,
0.0073171966,
-0.0026116916,
0.0216833949,
-0.0145779904,
0.0046983464,
-0.0430792198,
-0.0203195568,
0.0000365357,
0.0679791048,
0.1327386647,
-0.0155007215,
0.0341137238,
0.0339408368,
-0.0158909392,
-0.0172203314,
-0.0130675985,
0.0183571819,
0.0050163991,
-0.0166998319,
-0.0440089405,
-0.0249212701,
0.011297578,
0.0237858221,
-0.0255724713,
0.0366051942,
0.079306744,
0.0152503038,
0.0128522087,
-0.012209327,
-0.0395389162,
0.0580124222,
0.0183679983,
0.0177325308,
0.0157247856,
0.028038308,
0.0494128689,
-0.0040297047,
-0.0079834349,
-0.0246702787,
-0.0235048253,
-0.0611379258,
0.0430086255,
0.0138748167,
0.0482525267,
-0.0030033467,
-0.0593410991,
0.0258958954,
0.0247087274,
0.0334953219,
-0.014407374,
0.0323318914,
0.0365130268,
0.0223641973,
0.0000460837,
0.001906134,
-0.0089656971,
-0.0234786216,
-0.0197688304,
0.0339236446,
-0.0438745841,
0.0509636998,
-0.0725732371,
-0.0484007969,
0.0019335398,
0.0315447003,
-0.0214423593,
0.0099155745,
0.0322105438,
-0.0137709314,
0.0443214513,
0.0397675298,
0.0043503447,
0.0021641196,
-0.0715875551,
-0.0773590207,
0.0046781362,
0.0502933152,
0.0052138525,
-0.0197028797,
0.008715325,
0.0068411171,
-0.0699853674,
-0.0184210688,
-0.0167426281,
-0.0123671442,
0.0321909823,
0.0320331864,
0.0005669547,
-0.033308316,
-0.0344543122,
0.0146389771,
0.0106333876,
0.0115097687,
-0.057100784,
-0.0438195057,
-0.0444554202,
-0.0334047489,
-0.0477650389,
0.0170359053,
-0.0519803204,
-0.0244846735,
0.0318258144,
0.0219723005,
-0.0403387547,
0.0139231598,
-0.0465216637,
0.0667379051,
0.0063932603,
0.0039119367,
-0.0335096754,
0.0046110577,
0.0228770431,
0.031978894,
-0.0914322659,
-0.0160485413,
-0.0091029853,
-0.0250174236,
-0.0132864546,
0.0181691963,
0.0228558425,
-0.0483181328,
-0.001692598,
-0.0113811987,
-0.0276427306,
0.038528692,
0.0877867714,
0.0184658021,
-0.0177895725,
0.0182893761,
-0.0019517648,
0.0347710103,
-0.033106748,
0.0044231396,
-0.0553017668,
-0.0398191847,
-0.0241275206,
0.0446029045,
-0.0402662233,
-0.0041927625,
0.0358283482,
-0.0298273303,
0.072633177,
-0.0023079268,
0.0132966675,
0.0247913264,
-0.0285138078,
0.0064487644,
-0.0165313464,
0.0268532466,
-0.0004330667,
-0.0127352811,
-0.0213766377,
0.0383412205,
0.0169986337,
0.0007050312,
0.0352181867,
0.0334260352,
0.0019922855,
-0.001942419,
0.0048038461,
0.0432131514,
-0.0115898829,
0.0143822599,
-0.0437034704,
0.0300162397,
-0.0234514344,
0.0033887653,
0.0168367624,
-0.0425485969,
-0.0573064946,
0.0151740005,
-0.011294608,
0.0268018916,
0.0020962798,
-0.0480445139,
-0.0040114662,
-0.0093315607,
-0.0432952158,
0.0596198849,
0.0446341075,
0.0039308779,
-0.1109511182,
-0.0379521884,
-0.0426919982,
-0.0612134114,
0.0211213157,
0.0315132216,
-0.0361174941,
0.0358763821,
0.0009353128,
-0.0007725268,
-0.0196051504,
0.0191838704,
0.0185850468,
-0.0283509046,
-0.024386419,
-0.0035440624,
-0.0374792106,
-0.0629182905,
0.0120466994,
-0.0314491577,
0.0044164592,
0.0075071892,
-0.0403331667,
-0.0342006199,
0.0316780843,
-0.0311526097,
-0.055863332,
-0.022200983,
0.0257935338,
-0.0453242473,
0.003400356,
0.0676217154,
-0.0004449172,
-0.0040261713,
-0.0279121399,
-0.0120405992,
-0.0328292772,
-0.0080666533,
0.0174242575,
-0.0087209623,
0.0034612606,
0.0096265133,
-0.0442551486,
-0.0381517187,
-0.0405362584,
0.0126888715,
0.0304448884,
-0.0237185899,
0.0256554205,
-0.0223190226,
-0.0042166072,
0.063635312,
0.0380612351,
0.0140370801,
-0.0399097204,
-0.0589780509,
0.013007341,
-0.0109576229,
-0.0284273215,
0.0162109695,
-0.0444781743,
0.0087692142,
-0.0136898272,
-0.0433257744,
-0.0702088475,
-0.034440998,
-0.0603772588,
0.0055034077,
0.0390758477,
0.0164846592,
0.0197075401,
0.0323749296,
0.0624018386,
0.0152133759,
0.0004893091,
-0.001716435,
-0.0097490884,
-0.0091634681,
0.0490448177,
-0.0400605649,
0.0587963015,
-0.0483915657,
0.0259713847,
0.0498363115,
-0.0074984608,
0.0589873232,
0.0035137513,
-0.0084231431,
0.0057842606,
-0.0436253175,
-0.0669259652,
-0.0476974957,
-0.0019754481,
-0.0313687921,
0.0281459074,
0.0428062268,
0.005839014,
0.0402897857,
0.0035624288,
0.0490958355,
0.0156271439,
-0.0264403298,
-0.0467063263,
0.0062169996,
-0.0050711152,
-0.023775721,
-0.03573801,
-0.0057166507,
0.0400146581,
-0.020348154,
0.0173718166,
-0.0345806032,
-0.0080785612,
-0.0289404262,
0.0016293698,
0.0039404645,
0.0417751223,
-0.0288058389,
0.0126257697,
-0.0090319086,
-0.0059266048,
-0.0529865399,
0.0909687579,
0.0160577912,
-0.0002421237,
-0.0511640348,
0.0291075651,
-0.0304300729,
0.0144648151,
0.007564343,
-0.0166907012,
-0.0359897874,
0.0694180802,
-0.0144562144,
-0.0022941197,
0.029072538,
0.0452759899,
0.0288139656,
-0.0005721555,
-0.0029025218,
-0.0033761635,
0.0056631933,
-0.0789324343,
0.0263244472,
0.0230225977,
-0.0043397453,
-0.0021295066,
0.0505755395,
-0.0158203021,
-0.016048735,
-0.0118146576,
0.035370715,
-0.0166009273,
0.0302547496,
0.0583223924,
-0.0672520474,
-0.0734752864,
0.0096511636,
-0.0678445026,
-0.0058622928,
-0.0080257896,
0.014160431,
0.0268910658,
-0.0288260058,
0.0275502019,
-0.0261994433,
-0.0394544378,
-0.0127525637,
-0.002413223,
0.027711764,
-0.0146325007,
0.0131906923,
0.0576901957,
0.0313146599,
-0.0272574443,
-0.0777245313,
-0.0420004576,
-0.0177369118,
0.0341413058,
-0.0127980867,
-5.815057412e-33,
0.0278261323,
-0.05440275,
-0.0528093576,
0.0288446955,
0.0356033556,
-0.0195467547,
0.0197361447,
0.0504738353,
-0.0003969258,
0.0440563671,
-0.0332530476,
0.0193314236,
0.014731314,
-0.0060360371,
0.044597365,
-0.019138027,
0.0482461788,
0.0209773779,
-0.0005932061,
0.0290545747,
0.0308107603,
-0.0073163523,
0.0568961985,
-0.0547433756,
0.0644461438,
-0.0658068284,
-0.0376526304,
-0.0110760573,
0.0475028679,
0.0452796184,
-0.0352253988,
0.0308539774,
0.0450494327,
-0.0175373908,
0.0272897538,
-0.0198486056,
-0.0329974107,
0.0445200279,
0.0496155061,
0.0304542705,
0.0263576321,
-0.0404528864,
-0.0100034913,
-0.011520341,
-0.0572593175,
0.0822168067,
0.0421684347,
-0.0396901183,
0.0093116025,
-0.0381877311,
-0.0333316512,
0.0215994902,
0.0062000835,
0.0613571145,
0.0288771465,
0.0887055099,
-0.0363623351,
0.0065695369,
-0.0381457731,
0.0254588947,
-0.0114488173,
0.0408043563,
0.0026709156,
-0.0177526623,
-0.0503123775,
0.0246595852,
-0.051129099,
0.0478764959,
0.0165061094,
-0.0127214277,
-0.0036389341,
-0.0222794265,
-0.0280204713,
0.115490295,
0.0042407787,
-0.0623084456,
-0.0163554139,
0.0158217046,
0.0538619421,
-0.0056983088,
0.072013922,
-0.034287665,
-0.0484655537,
-0.0107166739,
0.0526540056,
-0.0234341752,
-0.0376375951,
-0.0477303155,
-0.0067778435,
0.040242672,
-0.024401864,
-0.0431120954,
-0.0234059393,
-0.0416884087,
-0.0009058944,
0.0094652269,
-0.0211068336,
-0.038458772,
0.0561484173,
-0.0344253033,
-0.0106411222,
-0.0128174489,
-0.1049430668,
0.009447705,
-0.0235035717,
-0.0139256613,
0.0517549999,
0.0266712848,
-0.0752851591,
-0.0054047066,
0.0310561247,
-0.02219918,
-0.0027804601,
0.0122547681,
-0.0021680184,
-0.007468272,
-0.0051023313,
0.0519065224,
0.0094039021,
0.049454879,
-0.0041945851,
-0.0701306835,
-0.0295580924,
0.0093991915,
-0.0342409797,
-0.0485289954,
-0.0071340473,
0.0056868056,
0.0066395057,
-0.0311166253,
-0.0203519054,
-0.0343530849,
2.75e-7,
0.004220353,
0.0267956238,
-0.0722208023,
-0.0305132773,
0.0191265605,
0.006857865,
0.0132989977,
-0.0088969525,
0.0114999805,
0.0407829657,
0.0310399365,
-0.0434091426,
-0.0083370861,
0.0371540748,
-0.087604396,
-0.0133993737,
-0.0274593569,
0.0116077261,
-0.0005619157,
-0.0262983944,
-0.0248839371,
0.0521239787,
-0.0299380943,
-0.0038266042,
-0.0622671023,
-0.0122576347,
0.007549942,
-0.1056582406,
-0.0395207256,
-0.0013365785,
0.0628418252,
-0.0324541554,
-0.0262737237,
-0.008252224,
-0.0179587882,
-0.0075927116,
0.0643078014,
0.0665796995,
0.0645199567,
0.0201776717,
0.030842483,
0.0041386071,
0.0199656971,
-0.0649522096,
0.014100085,
0.0401054844,
-0.0351482071,
-0.0792137906,
0.0038294101,
-0.0503582098,
0.0701619983,
-0.0309679229,
-0.0221148804,
0.0630450919,
0.0053320541,
-0.0219644401,
-0.0043036565,
0.0118600344,
-0.0070195193,
0.0220961943,
0.0491512194,
-0.0254607219,
0.0043765367,
-0.0263120569,
-0.0376631021,
0.0541480407,
0.0262194723,
1.792915182e-34,
0.0514219068,
-0.0030057083,
-0.0057798517,
-0.0230967868,
0.0483903587,
-0.0012402687,
-0.0354728252,
-0.0389161594,
0.0055538565,
0.0254694372,
-0.0065920572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.07468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.07468v1 | BactInt: A domain driven transfer learning approach and a corpus for extracting inter-bacterial interactions from biomedical text | 2023-04-27T06:14:25 | 2023-04-27T06:14:25 | Krishanu Das Baksi, Vatsala Pokhrel, Kuntal Kumar Bhusan, Sharmila Mande | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | The community of different types of microbes present in a biological niche
plays a very important role in functioning of the system. The crosstalk or
interactions among the different microbes contributes to the building blocks of
such microbial community structures. Evidence reported in biomedical text
serves as a reliable source for predicting such interactions. However, going
through the vast and ever-increasing volume of biomedical literature is an
intimidating and time consuming process. This necessitates development of
automated methods capable of accurately extracting bacterial relations reported
in biomedical literature. In this paper, we introduce a method for automated
extraction of microbial interactions (specifically between bacteria) from
biomedical literature along with ways of using transfer learning to improve its
accuracy. We also describe a pipeline using which relations among specific
bacteria groups can be mined. Additionally, we introduce the first publicly
available dataset which can be used to develop bacterial interaction extraction
methods. | [
0.0277270917,
0.0381135195,
-0.0180144664,
0.0121012405,
-0.0502365232,
-0.0054936144,
0.0478005558,
0.0226155557,
0.0377180353,
-0.0092144469,
-0.037550915,
-0.0070094513,
0.0335160345,
0.089630574,
-0.0002342424,
-0.0051577524,
0.0553820953,
0.0427205563,
-0.0142820496,
0.0218874421,
-0.0255448595,
0.0069927773,
-0.0330517404,
-0.0261701532,
0.0498192832,
0.0126769571,
0.0283186343,
-0.0322007053,
0.1026322693,
-0.0394552946,
0.0262076054,
-0.035908103,
0.0025848984,
-0.0121336477,
0.0000020512,
-0.0334073901,
-0.0772785246,
0.000952335,
0.0118645746,
-0.041089423,
0.0513320751,
-0.0409257598,
0.0471421033,
0.0041473582,
-0.0472385921,
-0.029791303,
0.070894964,
0.0413702577,
0.0154197253,
0.0345533155,
-0.0152039723,
-0.0281584561,
-0.0286551621,
-0.0273162406,
0.0047618737,
0.0287011024,
0.0946282223,
-0.0050805132,
0.0616144165,
-0.0330191478,
0.0000491683,
0.0106305899,
-0.025982555,
-0.0377373137,
0.0029384575,
0.014367423,
0.0242564436,
0.0091912374,
0.0310193244,
0.0510305278,
0.0073952652,
-0.0262281317,
0.042410858,
-0.0077993455,
-0.0030039139,
0.0847239345,
-0.0295904335,
-0.0285088476,
-0.0279106703,
0.0503289364,
0.0035698242,
0.0090416418,
0.025279196,
-0.0276953038,
-0.0517241582,
0.0976628065,
-0.0438943654,
-0.0164094586,
-0.0111490488,
0.0033625918,
-0.0075544911,
-0.0284445621,
0.0286931489,
0.037783727,
-0.0010097566,
-0.0347877964,
0.016607292,
-0.0219384339,
0.0199358035,
0.0420927629,
-0.0162915774,
-0.0482371561,
-0.0034409103,
0.0181271024,
0.0355039984,
-0.1057347059,
-0.0198700316,
-0.0205373783,
0.0053656818,
0.0029090643,
-0.0966141447,
0.0034607856,
0.0304626375,
0.0461529233,
-0.0273632426,
0.0301736165,
-0.0445200242,
-0.06031866,
-0.0152460514,
-0.0355274975,
0.0287984796,
-0.0068233316,
-0.016580699,
0.0375752971,
0.0187070053,
0.0286742859,
0.0169185083,
0.0104769785,
-0.0509457476,
-0.0335693136,
-0.0529591329,
-0.0130792344,
0.0800495893,
-0.0538631044,
-0.0212616492,
0.0728766844,
0.0020044737,
-0.031850867,
0.0073890723,
0.0032965534,
-0.0034533129,
-0.0127582131,
-0.0370161235,
0.0149803851,
0.0828003809,
0.000960975,
-0.0076214625,
-0.0208619833,
-0.0106057553,
-0.0239563808,
-0.0693015009,
0.0599478073,
-0.0997922644,
-0.0010939457,
0.0372827053,
0.0024985173,
-0.0340805985,
-0.0542587042,
0.0181979537,
-0.03222223,
0.0060154274,
-0.0420769341,
-0.0309282579,
-0.0112058492,
0.0208396781,
-0.0675160512,
0.0506513491,
0.0133316405,
0.0257285032,
0.0408750959,
-0.0045778602,
0.0334789082,
-0.0146698644,
-0.0478051454,
0.0304674152,
0.0337513797,
-0.0085383076,
0.0063818814,
0.0227781609,
0.0368873775,
0.0322480984,
0.0291302651,
-0.0133614708,
0.0024882287,
0.0246043578,
0.0019841301,
0.0045891991,
0.0459894538,
0.0477258116,
0.000920251,
-0.0013430736,
0.009185425,
-0.0170478933,
-0.0552324429,
0.0655444786,
0.0221303701,
-0.0137568107,
0.0117066074,
0.1019794866,
-0.0345007852,
0.0147694005,
-0.0062927394,
0.0506353192,
0.0124025336,
0.0357319266,
-0.0595143996,
-0.0450632349,
-0.0557989813,
-0.0222561508,
0.0335875526,
-0.0166578833,
-0.0341497101,
0.0113735851,
-0.0109260306,
0.0173593126,
-0.0123507259,
0.0019795313,
0.0246369205,
-0.0119990334,
0.0175243616,
-0.0093464833,
0.0313821211,
-0.006098974,
0.0232833102,
-0.0224684421,
0.01721319,
0.015974531,
-0.0083976611,
0.057474073,
0.0305104796,
-0.052124884,
0.00569278,
0.0561143942,
-0.0635581762,
-0.0020725217,
0.0203110911,
0.0045436574,
0.0004893463,
0.0110389758,
0.0057325251,
-0.0195781812,
0.0196093172,
-0.0125713171,
-0.0078800051,
0.0103596086,
-0.0195138454,
0.031822931,
0.0055248649,
-0.0132254642,
0.0018766912,
0.0157800652,
-0.0186562818,
0.0123811429,
0.046530284,
-0.0055978713,
-0.0098286271,
-0.0592769459,
-0.029562844,
0.0080598844,
0.0357072428,
-0.0223628916,
0.0027920785,
-0.0523693338,
0.0066687623,
-0.0223968364,
-0.0092624212,
0.0566214435,
-0.0135683091,
0.0088708345,
0.0405208617,
0.0574319698,
0.0125965709,
-0.0090453299,
0.0236100592,
0.0066330861,
-0.025553003,
0.0288901031,
-0.0233568121,
-0.0073222332,
0.079183504,
0.008760917,
-0.0209539514,
-0.0707210749,
0.0101634618,
-0.0534490421,
0.1038519815,
0.0410397351,
-0.0506324284,
0.0115284529,
0.0099879038,
0.0118583543,
-0.002087754,
-0.0177994221,
0.0036774522,
-0.0410041511,
-0.014943989,
-0.0306804422,
0.0028230571,
-0.0141933896,
0.0213635731,
0.0304384138,
-0.0204636361,
-0.0294568576,
0.0063193529,
-0.0438776948,
0.0522913635,
0.0055742026,
-0.003981465,
0.0033090129,
0.049416054,
-0.0057092728,
-0.0343728065,
-0.0277502947,
0.0252930969,
-0.0059310445,
0.0020539665,
0.0007764316,
0.0014343926,
0.0122704227,
0.0111341393,
0.0073760017,
-0.0402404442,
0.0459678397,
-0.016748989,
0.0199080966,
-0.0490683056,
-0.0165260248,
-0.0073327199,
0.0123980064,
0.0099845761,
0.0351297557,
0.0675667524,
-0.0431969836,
-0.0033561015,
-0.0184994768,
0.0329704247,
-0.0102627864,
-0.0037952636,
-0.0515794344,
0.0153649962,
0.0119028948,
0.000411652,
0.0048422832,
0.0673028678,
0.0083989846,
0.0001403131,
0.0307909399,
-0.0466128066,
-0.0540688522,
0.0644268468,
0.009397476,
-0.0158489253,
-0.0091507891,
-0.0169353765,
0.0249913409,
0.0427088737,
0.0738433599,
-0.0164359026,
-0.0266593788,
0.0020238226,
-0.0322716571,
0.0198921971,
-0.0575326011,
0.0130233597,
-0.0100400047,
-0.0194534156,
-0.0209987536,
-0.0265377536,
0.0101911472,
-0.0452544577,
0.0065796836,
-0.0042662937,
-0.0530958921,
0.0403161943,
0.0185343996,
-0.005998841,
0.0158977546,
-0.0217979159,
-0.0452759899,
-0.0389057659,
0.0188567266,
-0.0647859871,
-0.0178249292,
-0.0343464985,
-0.0141181201,
-0.0029296856,
-0.102816239,
-0.0260723066,
-0.0450416245,
0.0079715922,
0.0067864195,
-0.0684550628,
-0.0531359538,
-0.1173608303,
-0.021079544,
-0.0521013252,
-0.0285719968,
0.0049741538,
-0.0133412285,
0.0224110894,
-0.0044353167,
-0.0010300231,
-0.0583042093,
-0.0304329991,
-0.0221625604,
-0.0025775086,
0.0285189431,
0.0435612574,
0.0077444986,
0.0479561016,
-0.0049495869,
-0.0280147512,
-0.0066793254,
-0.0341016725,
0.0999910831,
-0.0128595242,
0.0066670389,
0.0009304422,
0.0241563767,
-0.0543978475,
-0.0255602766,
0.0172810387,
0.0522097982,
0.0221522376,
-0.0268776529,
-0.046770528,
0.0041432711,
0.0312757529,
0.0263443179,
0.0243734214,
-0.0200520549,
-0.0219475254,
0.0447194539,
-0.0116734449,
-0.0159726385,
-0.0112852845,
0.0059916303,
-0.0649328902,
-0.0466140397,
-0.0618112423,
0.0286097545,
0.0117394133,
-0.0107305078,
0.0235421117,
0.0363836326,
0.0474060625,
-0.0207799375,
-0.0912573487,
0.0223183837,
0.0145355565,
0.0321220607,
-0.0089618424,
-0.0620981194,
0.1022637486,
0.0230974965,
-0.0043746792,
0.01862338,
0.0047610411,
-0.0746774599,
-0.0087980172,
-0.0016866056,
0.0195304882,
0.01252292,
0.0632939786,
0.0041192751,
0.0277368855,
0.0740571916,
-0.043095883,
-0.011971877,
-0.010378168,
-0.0278892778,
-0.0311699789,
0.0179796871,
-0.0076604118,
0.0338826776,
0.0245011244,
-0.0085843913,
-0.0268093776,
-0.0238829795,
0.0164488163,
-0.0252935197,
0.0483291559,
0.0323824249,
-0.0737572908,
-0.0748788416,
0.007097783,
-0.0061255302,
0.0003014231,
-0.019825602,
0.0190826748,
0.0231243689,
0.0297276843,
-0.005275954,
0.0060140993,
-0.0258905794,
0.0221871529,
-0.0063306587,
0.0467379987,
0.0454884395,
0.0447452441,
0.0403172374,
-0.0395885296,
0.0175265931,
-0.0890724808,
0.0050049163,
0.002985257,
0.0111129563,
-0.0003138856,
0.0008635729,
0.0448077321,
-0.008680121,
0.0334957838,
-0.0592426062,
0.0832463726,
-0.0087974891,
-0.0240910761,
-0.0166782048,
-0.0198324136,
0.068017371,
0.0141890254,
-0.0032222581,
-0.0087357713,
0.0551447421,
-0.0524454676,
0.0504964665,
0.0170474425,
-0.0005608702,
-0.0341738388,
-0.0186120309,
0.0740738213,
-0.0359696969,
0.0672469661,
0.026045654,
-0.0136304274,
-0.0127645358,
-0.0351587273,
0.021975711,
0.0298336763,
-0.0051834122,
0.0094511351,
-0.0314725079,
-0.0130361328,
0.0369368605,
-0.0330389924,
0.0244650375,
0.0202290155,
-0.0131807262,
-0.000230337,
0.0633677989,
-0.0229776576,
-0.0337162353,
0.0868971422,
-0.0334776416,
-0.038895797,
0.0097977808,
-6.066826629e-33,
-0.018966753,
-0.0841688812,
-0.0064748018,
0.0458805934,
0.0098852646,
0.0072268266,
-0.0392564461,
-0.0557792,
-0.0181891937,
0.0543811098,
0.0150791034,
0.0176243279,
-0.0006283706,
-0.00159656,
-0.0007465319,
0.0371446684,
-0.000108507,
0.0039818445,
-0.0064495639,
0.044956658,
0.0550742708,
0.065459989,
0.0003063841,
-0.0966603458,
-0.0188021827,
0.0132375108,
0.0496073849,
-0.0199758727,
-0.0016142423,
0.0295845922,
0.0012652371,
0.0103144376,
0.0163373426,
-0.0032546897,
0.0085654622,
0.0321534909,
-0.07255169,
0.012458276,
-0.0068381168,
-0.0331511907,
0.0117843989,
-0.0235054456,
-0.0255991127,
0.0044049909,
0.0207456239,
-0.0392033011,
0.0677093267,
-0.0558485948,
-0.0056753946,
-0.0395543054,
-0.0773635209,
0.0474330336,
-0.0013384103,
0.0343437456,
0.0672297031,
-0.0050009694,
0.0287286714,
0.0316784754,
0.0435532145,
0.0187503751,
-0.0022632771,
0.0518139005,
0.0329990909,
-0.0352215432,
-0.0057840422,
0.0382792801,
0.0139972642,
-0.036420919,
0.0922284126,
0.0592923425,
-0.0585866757,
0.0650616959,
-0.0270699933,
0.0760285109,
0.0020317833,
-0.0432599299,
-0.1108610854,
0.0364048891,
-0.0383820496,
-0.0197787713,
-0.0464366712,
-0.0283411313,
0.0607931986,
-0.0020413008,
0.0502706282,
-0.0187313166,
0.0022242311,
-0.008344206,
-0.0012413963,
-0.0491305068,
-0.0276666414,
0.0290378444,
-0.0097923437,
-0.0191641394,
-0.0368707106,
0.0156134712,
0.0322707295,
-0.0249192193,
-0.0169011503,
-0.014342281,
-0.045196645,
-0.0870601237,
-0.0075118458,
-0.0105599025,
0.0662859157,
-0.0060930853,
0.0147150625,
-0.013334875,
-0.0271459017,
-0.0035965496,
-0.0158362482,
0.031091623,
-0.0491521433,
0.0637288541,
-0.0249280799,
0.0149883386,
0.0223037507,
0.0454932936,
0.0434607901,
0.0056674797,
0.0330603346,
0.0502922088,
-0.0230110884,
0.0032894593,
-0.0186388325,
-0.041364979,
0.0027851646,
0.0450204238,
0.0076751416,
-0.0404154211,
-0.0269446932,
-0.0013879034,
2.858e-7,
0.0932323337,
0.0465677977,
0.0093292575,
-0.0105637535,
0.015857907,
0.0243282262,
-0.0147145605,
0.0391920358,
-0.0478810705,
-0.0053967442,
0.0004916728,
-0.0516048931,
0.0173254423,
0.0586289614,
-0.0352918431,
-0.0448788442,
-0.0335656516,
-0.0834815055,
-0.0262049716,
-0.0482518487,
0.0418912359,
0.0159576815,
-0.0017362954,
-0.0084188282,
0.0184356328,
-0.0293364264,
-0.0098844701,
-0.0332007818,
0.0074172928,
0.0675289407,
-0.0361828841,
-0.0781825259,
-0.0503147803,
0.0293085203,
-0.0486527197,
0.0146924006,
-0.0134595316,
0.0075476044,
0.0014924947,
0.0229014773,
0.0241653211,
0.0102035394,
0.024232097,
-0.0251768883,
0.0056944098,
-0.077022925,
-0.0174518134,
0.0028317948,
-0.0237609632,
-0.00575916,
-0.0164973345,
0.026082797,
0.0463731624,
0.0144634303,
0.0148546398,
0.023316538,
-0.0256199725,
-0.0634672791,
-0.0135450559,
0.0585245378,
-0.0117338831,
-0.056705039,
0.0437336005,
-0.0518450066,
-0.0111967558,
-0.0583456904,
0.0005169482,
2.485685661e-34,
0.0123856645,
-0.0355059877,
-0.0050590043,
0.0464168936,
0.0272373725,
-0.0516658388,
-0.0448058955,
0.0467699245,
-0.030620344,
-0.0104114423,
-0.0102339452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13958v1 | Learning and Reasoning Multifaceted and Longitudinal Data for Poverty Estimates and Livelihood Capabilities of Lagged Regions in Rural India | 2023-04-27T05:33:08 | 2023-04-27T05:33:08 | Atharva Kulkarni, Raya Das, Ravi S. Srivastava, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Poverty is a multifaceted phenomenon linked to the lack of capabilities of
households to earn a sustainable livelihood, increasingly being assessed using
multidimensional indicators. Its spatial pattern depends on social, economic,
political, and regional variables. Artificial intelligence has shown immense
scope in analyzing the complexities and nuances of poverty. The proposed
project aims to examine the poverty situation of rural India for the period of
1990-2022 based on the quality of life and livelihood indicators. The districts
will be classified into `advanced', `catching up', `falling behind', and
`lagged' regions. The project proposes to integrate multiple data sources,
including conventional national-level large sample household surveys, census
surveys, and proxy variables like daytime, and nighttime data from satellite
images, and communication networks, to name a few, to provide a comprehensive
view of poverty at the district level. The project also intends to examine
causation and longitudinal analysis to examine the reasons for poverty. Poverty
and inequality could be widening in developing countries due to demographic and
growth-agglomerating policies. Therefore, targeting the lagging regions and the
vulnerable population is essential to eradicate poverty and improve the quality
of life to achieve the goal of `zero poverty'. Thus, the study also focuses on
the districts with a higher share of the marginal section of the population
compared to the national average to trace the performance of development
indicators and their association with poverty in these regions. | [
-0.043505691,
0.0714938566,
-0.0391556434,
-0.0108425934,
-0.0612042062,
0.0469724722,
0.0453934968,
-0.0348781236,
0.0368956141,
0.0253073145,
0.1367373317,
0.055184897,
0.0716715455,
0.0173607823,
0.0328049548,
-0.0870356709,
-0.0093123456,
0.0320819505,
-0.0344525427,
0.002734161,
-0.0304423217,
-0.0126434108,
-0.0276229717,
0.0145063009,
-0.0452871211,
0.0233187806,
-0.0211668462,
0.0172030274,
-0.0262840558,
-0.0473734848,
0.0242178869,
0.0222701784,
0.0076176012,
-0.0431498513,
0.0000019421,
-0.0194849148,
-0.0586344749,
0.0315310918,
-0.0037117717,
0.0082759075,
0.0265890397,
-0.0403989926,
0.0251940284,
-0.003677815,
-0.0217024386,
0.0457965173,
0.0569089204,
0.001261619,
0.056278903,
-0.0230868459,
0.0014694899,
-0.0497813225,
0.0001858698,
0.0542829111,
-0.0338908657,
0.0477871709,
0.0131062763,
0.0033211128,
0.0154381357,
-0.0570455156,
-0.0584963411,
0.0219854694,
0.0246989131,
-0.0007524493,
0.0237653293,
0.0180219207,
-0.0264331196,
-0.0133312074,
0.0387500003,
0.0198428966,
0.0134378672,
0.0175374094,
0.0008625053,
0.0171825401,
-0.0568112247,
-0.0138045074,
-0.0434060432,
-0.0095321257,
-0.0226632394,
0.0208142456,
0.0203700196,
0.0485447049,
-0.0328519866,
0.0153513523,
0.0121703632,
0.0540263839,
-0.0350686833,
-0.0457504801,
-0.0570479333,
0.0170791801,
-0.0249155667,
0.0222820155,
0.0125256618,
0.0026229217,
0.0084179938,
0.0217975695,
0.0493331216,
-0.0296747964,
-0.0022983968,
0.0324169584,
-0.0066690566,
0.0517416932,
-0.0247190967,
-0.0025329108,
0.0508223176,
0.0064419666,
0.0219518524,
-0.0217615515,
0.0168231279,
-0.002578696,
-0.025398558,
-0.0058076284,
0.0259947758,
0.0221727975,
-0.0195863824,
0.0473981388,
-0.0497062057,
0.015881449,
-0.0179805998,
-0.0737432837,
0.0133284908,
0.0366505608,
-0.0020606366,
0.0000042433,
-0.04728093,
0.0323497392,
-0.0303087272,
0.0450654291,
0.0062079751,
-0.0314836167,
0.0203575809,
-0.0084524564,
-0.0074388562,
-0.0069016917,
-0.0119480761,
0.0073123151,
0.0494611226,
0.0196950454,
-0.1294072121,
0.0528426357,
-0.023694938,
-0.0126380697,
-0.0024392079,
-0.0488592498,
0.0029112285,
0.0130165461,
-0.0093305428,
0.0240825638,
-0.0098575568,
0.0105594583,
-0.0209291596,
0.0438734889,
-0.0131124565,
-0.0245785099,
0.0770335495,
0.0382472351,
0.0319907181,
0.0116053522,
0.0137532158,
0.010313265,
0.0319755711,
0.0004540637,
0.0067320275,
-0.0209500454,
-0.0176145341,
0.0303752366,
-0.0442538932,
0.0100937961,
-0.0872258395,
-0.0755458996,
-0.0331566036,
-0.0367453024,
0.0215920154,
0.0784684345,
0.0493257307,
0.0765227154,
0.0706447139,
0.0522515327,
-0.044596687,
0.0356629416,
0.0000576139,
-0.0076495702,
0.0107933758,
0.0105703082,
0.0009479009,
-0.0061506173,
0.0407181084,
-0.0130945006,
0.0285314228,
-0.0199505463,
0.0120474743,
0.0212027077,
0.0261994936,
-0.0051777731,
0.0596445128,
-0.0277257301,
0.0212897751,
-0.0886041671,
0.0633402765,
0.0429838076,
-0.0234111082,
-0.0427727401,
0.017373668,
-0.0215105023,
-0.0096709207,
-0.0512673967,
0.0339189135,
0.0197936017,
0.0608221814,
-0.0174972769,
-0.039539922,
-0.0033334575,
0.005158965,
0.0045490181,
-0.0365518443,
0.0542693809,
0.0126140108,
0.0127733359,
0.0192134399,
-0.0138568878,
-0.0195999891,
-0.038244281,
0.051998727,
0.015552612,
0.0190435182,
0.0765650347,
-0.0015252465,
0.047156468,
0.0136557147,
-0.0117995245,
0.0299449209,
-0.0296358559,
-0.0159930959,
-0.0046276287,
-0.0083633568,
0.0378797203,
0.0402978845,
0.0104373759,
-0.0493270941,
-0.0804022029,
0.0539840944,
0.0673174858,
0.0183573179,
-0.0138897067,
0.0434022024,
0.0298118461,
0.0326825641,
-0.0233235732,
0.0361443534,
-0.0027418765,
0.0139463674,
-0.0374965891,
0.0594949238,
-0.0368114039,
-0.0461162403,
-0.0454569682,
0.026920028,
0.0663148835,
-0.0536990203,
0.0837666839,
-0.0941710696,
-0.0280961879,
0.0181073938,
-0.0123584224,
0.0501692854,
-0.0427044891,
-0.0202257801,
-0.0277971067,
-0.0302727111,
0.0197196677,
-0.0497206636,
-0.0454221964,
-0.0234665032,
0.0007353667,
0.0243341085,
0.0356954411,
0.0494979657,
0.0370363221,
0.0019539306,
0.0566107631,
-0.0183279309,
0.0495434664,
0.0323486477,
0.0133964289,
-0.0549807511,
0.0466029048,
0.0462262258,
-0.0676262975,
0.0201193225,
-0.0762961507,
-0.0070092604,
0.0123616625,
0.0000463507,
-0.0157886166,
-0.0413003452,
0.001538077,
-0.0411045924,
-0.0152347852,
0.0040901331,
0.0420571826,
-0.0142933372,
-0.0015500884,
-0.0265779141,
0.0229757763,
-0.0064410921,
0.0781247467,
0.0047217957,
-0.0275585316,
-0.0152737834,
-0.0130019076,
0.0632651895,
0.0460611433,
0.0132139055,
0.0193622746,
-0.0474075004,
-0.0037453137,
-0.0460284166,
0.0459680818,
0.0053537497,
0.0432851501,
-0.0160520468,
-0.0565151908,
-0.0258617885,
0.0249937754,
0.0248384569,
-0.0012644106,
-0.0250082351,
-0.0092306491,
-0.0040324936,
0.0223801602,
-0.0184554905,
-0.0425663739,
-0.0396331511,
-0.0311771743,
0.035192322,
0.0006331509,
0.0198379979,
-0.0181745831,
-0.0771013945,
0.0078811813,
-0.0078988736,
-0.0501591265,
-0.0258451756,
-0.0672781169,
0.0663816929,
-0.0144968918,
0.008512646,
-0.0115877604,
0.0236760564,
0.0751243234,
-0.0060461974,
0.0020814287,
0.0299445223,
-0.0265283976,
-0.0050871512,
-0.0138567183,
0.0031221816,
0.0032453793,
-0.026191147,
0.014987139,
0.0192163289,
-0.0795035511,
0.042600181,
0.0451939218,
-0.0064397943,
0.0578826033,
-0.0162595604,
-0.0051209806,
0.0229212157,
0.0041799699,
-0.0172269326,
0.0321642645,
0.0097467201,
0.0257198215,
-0.006229904,
0.0122835161,
-0.0059557017,
-0.0790182725,
-0.0750635341,
0.0098483786,
0.0398684591,
-0.0610689074,
0.0331798978,
0.0186220966,
0.0228888057,
-0.0544077158,
-0.018963933,
-0.029646948,
-0.0629916862,
0.0322191715,
-0.0207654983,
-0.0369025655,
-0.0617857203,
0.0153934853,
-0.0476033613,
-0.011385018,
-0.0149368998,
-0.0173987746,
0.0024027964,
0.0013658982,
0.0803780705,
-0.079954274,
0.0095477793,
0.0150583964,
-0.0138201844,
0.0247815643,
0.0212562531,
0.0350667983,
-0.0251144897,
0.0442339741,
-0.0296056531,
-0.0346548744,
0.0020655363,
-0.011017411,
-0.0032706063,
0.0036680582,
-0.0361833349,
-0.0254869126,
0.0159406569,
0.0428180844,
-0.0045464979,
0.0343457386,
0.0470024943,
-0.0081128897,
-0.0103283338,
0.0151910037,
0.0051719854,
0.0231867824,
-0.0451356284,
-0.0048712981,
-0.0085832644,
0.0123755299,
-0.0387401581,
-0.0519754365,
0.0070847166,
0.0197605416,
0.049623806,
-0.0272724591,
0.014886071,
0.0558699109,
-0.0010991847,
0.0479352288,
0.0794775188,
0.0325410478,
0.0180922169,
0.0797151104,
-0.0168121308,
-0.0436697416,
-0.0410453863,
-0.0209494624,
-0.0093180481,
0.0128662009,
-0.0400359891,
-0.00910166,
-0.0191537216,
-0.010599561,
-0.0782412961,
-0.071742624,
-0.0095433826,
0.014736346,
0.0249394495,
0.0181159712,
-0.0204363987,
-0.0142504424,
-0.0204281658,
0.0746487901,
0.02401595,
0.0164177604,
0.0098478049,
-0.0112969875,
0.0327276699,
-0.020409504,
-0.0102702137,
0.0036445225,
0.0222117808,
-0.0183910634,
-0.031612765,
-0.0861719102,
-0.008190833,
-0.0298739802,
-0.0353062451,
0.1071147397,
0.0091611547,
-0.088074483,
-0.0435160175,
0.0036601548,
0.0021814043,
-0.0132002076,
-0.0153663484,
-0.0287369695,
0.0706150085,
0.0985856429,
-0.024978444,
0.0058052568,
0.0186387524,
-0.0321161784,
-0.0505003445,
0.0505038872,
-0.0331450887,
0.0629175007,
-0.0745714158,
0.0407670401,
0.0193398632,
-0.054115653,
-0.0512839556,
0.0439406224,
-0.0029420538,
0.0098059475,
-0.0168409012,
0.0475265607,
0.0097314026,
0.0408826098,
0.0744400695,
0.0172605235,
-0.0504574403,
-0.0100048371,
-0.0019957027,
0.0006107904,
-0.0042098737,
-0.0069638393,
-0.0279584564,
-0.0102220112,
0.0299482904,
-0.0243040025,
-0.0533146188,
0.0198293105,
-0.0120290099,
-0.0488272347,
0.0674433708,
0.0271102376,
0.0179551095,
-0.0452109613,
0.0217936318,
-0.0434700847,
-0.0110889301,
-0.0232587643,
-0.0002275177,
-0.0183910225,
0.0054702121,
0.0149840647,
-0.0381660946,
-0.0082712071,
-0.0099578006,
-0.0643532351,
0.0089678811,
0.0224062055,
-0.0234646723,
-0.0481315665,
-0.0217461139,
0.0375964977,
-0.0354340486,
-0.0246487148,
-0.0836244971,
-0.0017431119,
0.0352632999,
-5.290708321e-33,
-0.0485240258,
-0.0877820253,
0.0323279426,
-0.0290743299,
-0.0388224237,
0.0354138613,
-0.0120895663,
0.0011418907,
0.0029198376,
-0.0083074439,
0.0113192825,
0.015558783,
0.0154367443,
0.0251342673,
0.0322586149,
0.0197695736,
-0.0415875241,
0.0325806253,
0.0017876906,
-0.0846265703,
-0.0143021336,
-0.0339989029,
0.0274204444,
-0.0415002517,
-0.0302212127,
-0.0485852212,
-0.0324271098,
0.0107706226,
0.0348976851,
-0.0070157764,
-0.0099871224,
-0.0059335558,
0.0275175273,
-0.0195867345,
0.012478848,
0.0129872952,
-0.069336243,
-0.0157744959,
-0.0503754877,
0.0255764127,
-0.0372659899,
-0.0235616267,
0.0182783287,
0.0529924333,
0.0164897479,
-0.0115424981,
0.0169043858,
0.0095128622,
-0.0035994733,
-0.0007038008,
-0.0162803214,
0.0287897531,
-0.0717864186,
0.012018756,
-0.0683163926,
0.0493248962,
0.0200579222,
0.0135067804,
-0.0233076978,
-0.00125649,
0.0145180048,
0.0057156966,
0.0191080831,
0.023885889,
0.0618597679,
0.0330430865,
0.0023700763,
-0.0974937975,
-0.0134162828,
-0.0593072772,
0.0427745171,
-0.0407488272,
-0.0163570996,
0.0347614661,
0.0406155474,
-0.0675850213,
-0.0075815497,
0.0190132763,
0.023138674,
0.0233796071,
-0.041058559,
-0.02638858,
-0.0289923716,
-0.0101677375,
0.0087175407,
-0.0846924484,
-0.0296623129,
0.0142904511,
0.065554902,
-0.0234089028,
0.0080684451,
0.0954286382,
0.0020942762,
-0.0296596829,
0.0460067019,
-0.0445001498,
0.0164158847,
0.0036916547,
0.0182876382,
0.0143338405,
-0.0148968585,
-0.0747668669,
-0.0202661362,
0.0931462049,
0.0328241363,
0.0163634531,
-0.0062212897,
-0.0109088533,
-0.0150963962,
-0.0027841423,
-0.0217186268,
0.007899859,
0.0026063477,
0.0180658977,
-0.011254359,
-0.0462025218,
-0.003319073,
-0.0377745964,
0.021533668,
0.0138160819,
-0.0060005873,
0.0290109739,
-0.0038940832,
-0.0458644889,
0.0351767875,
0.0109624024,
-0.0049368823,
-0.030686209,
-0.0289615523,
-0.0005026173,
0.0157873463,
0.0019401915,
2.709e-7,
-0.0060184007,
0.0792990178,
0.0195974149,
-0.0464207232,
0.0018945218,
-0.0227390584,
-0.0039455197,
0.0005487924,
-0.0673299953,
0.0608202405,
0.0573588535,
-0.006910739,
0.0590166859,
0.0272056218,
-0.0100217694,
0.0340551436,
-0.007232632,
-0.004775147,
-0.0661643073,
0.0042395936,
0.0120504685,
0.0044980794,
0.0446316563,
-0.0068243849,
0.0245055296,
-0.004382486,
0.0125553468,
0.0184059851,
0.0160115641,
-0.0309243519,
0.0075164787,
0.027008567,
-0.0182976034,
0.0084681958,
-0.0266789179,
-0.0206245948,
0.0185742769,
0.0518324673,
0.0045677149,
-0.0058137695,
-0.0188395251,
-0.0102300579,
0.0156174731,
-0.0132323913,
0.0693009198,
0.0049539958,
-0.039028421,
0.0372884795,
0.0077189486,
0.0533589572,
0.014733009,
-0.0154121062,
0.0225979798,
-0.0488100834,
-0.0301210769,
-0.0535636805,
0.0355864316,
0.0056366278,
0.0022400832,
0.0047152271,
-0.0354032107,
-0.0597747564,
0.0241322108,
0.0737115741,
0.0592902899,
-0.0144314794,
0.010022033,
2.341595538e-34,
-0.0074223382,
0.0184563696,
0.0069374628,
-0.0905508101,
0.0192331076,
0.0234011803,
-0.0189861059,
-0.0273696389,
0.014354351,
-0.0258662533,
0.030667685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13923v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13923v2 | Retrieval-based Knowledge Augmented Vision Language Pre-training | 2023-04-27T02:23:47 | 2023-08-06T08:06:43 | Jiahua Rao, Zifei Shan, Longpo Liu, Yao Zhou, Yuedong Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | With the recent progress in large-scale vision and language representation
learning, Vision Language Pre-training (VLP) models have achieved promising
improvements on various multi-modal downstream tasks. Albeit powerful, these
models have not fully leveraged world knowledge to their advantage. A key
challenge of knowledge-augmented VLP is the lack of clear connections between
knowledge and multi-modal data. Moreover, not all knowledge present in
images/texts is useful, therefore prior approaches often struggle to
effectively integrate knowledge, visual, and textual information. In this
study, we propose REtrieval-based knowledge Augmented Vision Language (REAVL),
a novel knowledge-augmented pre-training framework to address the above issues.
For the first time, we introduce a knowledge-aware self-supervised learning
scheme that efficiently establishes the correspondence between knowledge and
multi-modal data and identifies informative knowledge to improve the modeling
of alignment and interactions between visual and textual modalities. By
adaptively integrating informative knowledge with visual and textual
information, REAVL achieves new state-of-the-art performance uniformly on
knowledge-based vision-language understanding and multi-modal entity linking
tasks, as well as competitive results on general vision-language tasks while
only using 0.2% pre-training data of the best models. Our model shows strong
sample efficiency and effective knowledge utilization. | [
0.0380350761,
0.0343175754,
0.0112579716,
0.0438307039,
0.0228123832,
-0.0095301988,
-0.0240251143,
-0.0023805758,
0.0456342362,
-0.0970334485,
-0.0327134654,
0.0202741623,
-0.0372577533,
0.0286644287,
0.0275407955,
-0.0526118837,
0.0427474044,
-0.0091617405,
0.009278114,
0.0187455285,
0.0447857715,
0.017018551,
0.0039662477,
0.0003305784,
-0.0647523627,
-0.0156378001,
0.0009334749,
0.0061661224,
0.0156769417,
-0.0119787697,
-0.0047755796,
0.0415200181,
0.0713167787,
-0.0173479188,
0.0000018842,
-0.0323536471,
-0.0030105519,
0.000445565,
-0.0094397021,
-0.008807932,
0.0264191385,
-0.059441708,
0.0328658819,
-0.0373752937,
-0.0413053222,
-0.0423333421,
0.0403643847,
0.0546562746,
0.0597110726,
0.0422691219,
-0.0359104723,
-0.0011802808,
0.0244731512,
-0.016553266,
0.0193656813,
-0.0135043822,
0.0156348068,
0.0161570348,
-0.0297149625,
0.0215338059,
-0.0418357253,
0.0897509381,
0.0040280162,
-0.0086487969,
0.0131248813,
0.0257181767,
-0.0007084257,
-0.0086718025,
-0.0155846775,
0.085551627,
0.0087049529,
-0.0353157073,
-0.0257200282,
-0.0066651516,
0.0108092353,
0.0293361843,
-0.0284769014,
-0.0035208627,
0.0264532082,
0.0091289263,
-0.0569902621,
0.0139472689,
0.0256095268,
0.0084601594,
0.004301019,
0.0055230968,
0.0030793254,
0.0183982383,
-0.0027283602,
0.0190919694,
-0.0291209575,
-0.0028682076,
-0.050644502,
0.0124249533,
0.0328046121,
0.0083493749,
-0.0366285034,
-0.02615197,
-0.0198601652,
-0.0226221532,
-0.0047401171,
0.0175456256,
-0.0842254683,
0.0550962836,
-0.0585460551,
0.0351827666,
-0.0156681333,
0.0332660265,
-0.0039480487,
-0.0332061462,
-0.0222958066,
-0.0090871342,
-0.0368843712,
-0.0099447407,
-0.0490024947,
-0.0163695905,
-0.006534317,
0.0086407568,
-0.0326877199,
-0.0058907233,
0.0052329842,
0.0295050833,
-0.0327142291,
-0.0531862006,
-0.0692115128,
0.0527172759,
0.0123745855,
0.0111718364,
-0.04261709,
-0.0256771687,
0.0104139689,
0.0299477,
-0.0077380287,
-0.0206977893,
-0.006469842,
0.0690890849,
-0.0476505905,
-0.0314420499,
-0.0435552336,
-0.0372018218,
-0.0191655885,
-0.025086103,
0.0437719896,
-0.0357122235,
0.0377285443,
-0.0112407496,
-0.0026435906,
-0.0504435226,
0.0066428715,
-0.0313423648,
-0.0404919609,
0.10718932,
-0.052358605,
-0.0277017951,
-0.0035669156,
0.0139881959,
0.0287706815,
0.0759079307,
0.0002019291,
0.0093310317,
0.0346808657,
0.0226384383,
0.0021435225,
0.0129913324,
0.0346965715,
0.0040430217,
-0.0378437303,
0.0219153836,
-0.024108002,
0.0053261798,
0.0676206648,
0.0217882805,
-0.0309159216,
-0.0424016677,
0.0402359553,
-0.0089732725,
0.0430400595,
0.0047818474,
0.044064451,
0.0083308239,
0.0151650831,
-0.0318064801,
-0.0827421844,
0.0576851778,
-0.0180066731,
-0.0055267541,
-0.0481907576,
0.0281607453,
-0.0393042602,
-0.0178606305,
0.0285080932,
-0.0165458154,
0.0143733285,
0.041048184,
0.0590180643,
0.0157428086,
-0.0252309889,
0.0259354413,
0.041218292,
-0.0203203317,
0.0198197775,
0.0068743704,
0.0013908206,
0.0347727537,
-0.0058149379,
-0.0276770983,
-0.0121929627,
0.0178469177,
0.0290003698,
0.0282551311,
-0.0050827428,
-0.0045148581,
0.0241193324,
-0.0466913953,
-0.0511854663,
-0.0246057156,
-0.00883302,
0.0058340305,
-0.0135120843,
0.015873082,
0.0442278311,
-0.0232576318,
0.0169620235,
0.0475724787,
0.05959934,
-0.0027380541,
-0.0343296342,
0.0643631369,
-0.0335999951,
-0.0136310849,
-0.021722598,
-0.0140499882,
0.0125113269,
-0.0131932404,
-0.0028593147,
0.0388611555,
-0.0353686698,
-0.0528040528,
0.0463592745,
-0.0174166486,
-0.0169162191,
-0.0003088057,
-0.012235811,
-0.0397406965,
0.0348322392,
0.0326303244,
0.0388554186,
-0.0445107929,
-0.012050339,
0.0415584035,
-0.0020884066,
-0.0163439121,
0.0566171259,
0.0159027297,
-0.030271776,
0.0055074859,
0.0040883482,
0.043518737,
0.0103926826,
-0.0394826084,
-0.0340867713,
0.0085280994,
0.033776015,
0.0342545398,
-0.0124646919,
-0.043870829,
0.0074438378,
-0.1094693318,
-0.0242462233,
-0.0172080491,
-0.0314977877,
-0.0130398478,
-0.0189972147,
0.0001771761,
-0.0877534524,
-0.0199443679,
0.0457509346,
0.0001000345,
0.0155745801,
0.0200425126,
0.0403272398,
0.0334740579,
-0.0278643146,
0.0124792764,
0.008741254,
0.0492576882,
0.0353930853,
-0.0321424156,
0.0105971005,
0.0200271681,
-0.0560571589,
0.0646337196,
-0.0425979793,
-0.009694987,
-0.0154012814,
-0.0315994993,
0.0476378761,
0.0320032202,
-0.0168186259,
0.012140058,
0.0202265549,
-0.0304682888,
-0.0516391285,
0.0351293236,
0.0012071091,
-0.0416304842,
-0.0385443643,
0.0503789149,
-0.0556457378,
0.03287635,
-0.0458538309,
-0.0379220583,
-0.078179583,
-0.0086036213,
0.0239542499,
-0.0534696132,
-0.0722129345,
0.0155360056,
0.0457324125,
0.0202825032,
-0.0461551659,
-0.0632407665,
0.0292855669,
-0.0066870553,
-0.0245009791,
0.0474350899,
0.0150731737,
-0.0101847006,
0.0975685418,
0.0252787322,
0.0274555478,
-0.0094145229,
0.0093122665,
-0.0808156282,
-0.0115912957,
0.0189703312,
0.0132055869,
0.0785038248,
-0.0446346849,
0.0739719272,
-0.0175461266,
-0.0199341998,
-0.0314063169,
-0.0332342871,
-0.0147018014,
-0.0150753502,
-0.0504096746,
-0.0058794273,
-0.0129086338,
0.0184859224,
0.0502227657,
0.0167431664,
0.0171301328,
-0.0299263485,
0.0057549449,
0.0359886847,
0.0516426042,
0.0333233923,
-0.0223988406,
0.0050770552,
-0.0264033135,
0.0540512502,
0.0378713794,
-0.0247855503,
-0.0429349951,
0.0311901234,
0.0115222866,
0.0002156162,
-0.0117308646,
0.0361267589,
0.036831513,
-0.0664014742,
0.0225740001,
0.0553924851,
0.0116643021,
-0.0406292044,
-0.0489031263,
0.0413684994,
0.0028828762,
0.0481470786,
0.0420074649,
-0.084423326,
-0.0430453941,
-0.0481010005,
-0.0338704214,
0.0344500579,
-0.0234947726,
-0.031314861,
-0.053621266,
0.0182768498,
0.0012621153,
0.0085699772,
-0.0480545349,
0.0162016451,
-0.0126513708,
-0.0401407667,
-0.0467738844,
-0.0285937674,
-0.0225007646,
0.0223835167,
0.0002159508,
0.0184966698,
-0.0019243595,
0.0187477693,
-0.0792292431,
0.027854979,
0.0142173525,
0.0082449252,
-0.0044578775,
-0.0384032652,
-0.0383798704,
-0.0064693149,
0.0070072999,
0.0148017546,
0.0650736541,
-0.0686671734,
-0.0546067171,
0.018579239,
-0.0134584662,
-0.0187473632,
-0.0330492333,
-0.0510179587,
0.0274967831,
-0.0049409643,
0.0154304514,
-0.0202615969,
-0.0111750681,
0.0143181141,
0.0232495926,
-0.035822548,
-0.0016187687,
0.0141457384,
-0.0074227941,
0.0306550227,
-0.0197640173,
-0.0372964144,
0.0231720954,
0.0041422215,
0.014579149,
-0.0744460747,
-0.0202822182,
0.0324687809,
0.0732692927,
-0.0001434507,
-0.0077074519,
0.0116201546,
-0.009916652,
-0.0996782035,
0.0784549862,
-0.037680421,
-0.0062245294,
-0.0095503703,
-0.0197302308,
0.0427587777,
-0.0367616937,
-0.0255979896,
0.0128770815,
-0.0513754413,
-0.0202233922,
-0.0353350863,
0.0825956836,
0.0023171359,
0.0731932595,
0.0027500535,
-0.0298930686,
0.0315434113,
0.0561582148,
-0.0492899716,
0.0179098099,
-0.0056038033,
-0.032198444,
0.003463431,
0.0248498581,
-0.0458788089,
-0.0071767233,
0.0128925899,
0.0034310459,
-0.0153150707,
-0.0502383299,
0.0304571353,
0.0145893423,
0.0490618721,
-0.0093717277,
0.037864536,
-0.0602608994,
-0.0253534894,
-0.0026802153,
-0.015716143,
-0.086598061,
0.0138234328,
0.0132149244,
0.019687023,
0.0166103505,
0.0347108059,
0.0398607068,
0.003374926,
-0.0154361436,
-0.0417841859,
0.014423456,
-0.0129962163,
0.0016226884,
0.0421900563,
0.0247428883,
0.048829034,
0.0137753403,
0.0405294597,
-0.0392830037,
0.0512353182,
0.029234089,
-0.016550405,
-0.0467643887,
0.035750024,
0.0078560794,
-0.0331666917,
-0.0118813273,
0.05552347,
0.0492396317,
-0.0329161547,
0.0315609947,
-0.041116666,
-0.0157754105,
-0.0054808171,
0.0386573412,
-0.0109330146,
-0.0166716911,
0.0678456947,
0.0051768632,
-0.024483446,
0.021451598,
0.0628126636,
0.0146089662,
0.0512251109,
-0.022595847,
-0.0152529441,
-0.0298027657,
-0.0232939627,
0.0635331497,
-0.0039423145,
-0.0320946127,
0.054373078,
-0.0173193384,
-0.0678707957,
0.0120972237,
0.0132213617,
-0.065016754,
0.0326932967,
0.06261608,
0.0489488132,
0.0337763317,
-0.0283530224,
-0.0168423969,
-0.0490806177,
0.0027936052,
0.0199827272,
0.0177781601,
-5.600407736e-33,
-0.0627211332,
-0.0115103461,
0.0714729503,
-0.0251879357,
-0.0039031252,
0.0308934767,
0.0073011466,
0.0004485098,
-0.0503646508,
0.0304451138,
0.0269347075,
-0.0081149787,
-0.0076862541,
0.0326725505,
-0.017058203,
0.002706188,
0.0319825932,
-0.0044996492,
0.0113732982,
0.0005351273,
0.0358292982,
0.0363328233,
0.0641670227,
-0.0686792061,
0.0235704016,
0.038738057,
-0.0223916322,
0.0285736602,
0.0478720777,
0.0555300973,
-0.0082084602,
0.0212109499,
0.0080318041,
0.006080098,
-0.0275459941,
-0.0021256008,
-0.1140825823,
-0.0194572322,
0.0261932462,
0.0362512916,
-0.100803636,
0.0394059606,
0.0326129757,
-0.0219421405,
0.0589268543,
-0.0174623616,
0.0597153418,
0.0054854336,
-0.0014703415,
-0.0007361476,
-0.0456907302,
0.0064346166,
-0.0337398425,
-0.0337737612,
0.0716281608,
-0.0109669818,
0.0594108701,
0.0059854398,
-0.0783124343,
0.0103177959,
-0.0322519056,
0.0097328871,
0.0553183444,
0.0427555442,
0.0142864473,
0.0634258538,
0.0162104666,
-0.045359239,
-0.0242789835,
0.0118262721,
0.0574401878,
0.0358297266,
-0.0025103784,
0.1082214266,
-0.0266884658,
0.0054613734,
-0.0622713305,
0.0063677672,
-0.039444875,
0.0548755974,
-0.0655620545,
0.0243836474,
-0.0051960768,
0.001175527,
-0.0490663871,
0.0097200209,
-0.0225936994,
-0.0171181113,
0.0425542295,
0.0376820341,
-0.0141243879,
0.0869970843,
0.0622067228,
-0.0390246399,
-0.0074927029,
0.027116077,
-0.032041233,
0.0382965617,
-0.0002358642,
0.0555405021,
-0.0684394911,
0.0028769835,
0.0741308331,
-0.0299444031,
-0.0289846975,
0.0092224572,
0.0440106019,
0.0238453001,
-0.0534329154,
0.0068563875,
-0.0223372933,
-0.0228970107,
-0.0151902484,
0.0158255082,
0.0105829202,
0.0254126936,
-0.0398891494,
0.0075098677,
0.0203546751,
-0.0452170298,
-0.0021128582,
-0.0288077183,
0.0229813196,
0.0199825838,
0.0088677863,
-0.001963295,
-0.048594065,
-0.0535160005,
0.024998676,
-0.0500249788,
0.0015305186,
0.042010475,
2.503e-7,
0.0632459447,
0.005852567,
0.0154510941,
-0.0087246271,
-0.0093462979,
0.0618053339,
-0.0045397994,
0.0311032888,
0.0065171504,
-0.0497485735,
0.0091958083,
0.0665862709,
0.0016762473,
-0.0114974072,
-0.0150874862,
0.0190316811,
0.0008957832,
-0.0430450514,
-0.0264864303,
-0.023385413,
0.0336337835,
0.0610163882,
-0.0158316288,
0.0055681942,
0.0365351588,
-0.0946269408,
0.1098534092,
-0.0147845391,
-0.0132575566,
0.0177276358,
0.0025914644,
0.0506680496,
-0.0484771319,
0.0537416823,
-0.0058172154,
0.0000977324,
0.0394892246,
0.0128594618,
-0.0298701152,
-0.0183104333,
-0.0173588656,
0.0254059117,
-0.0255576149,
-0.0338437259,
0.0645281821,
-0.0681479275,
0.0141970851,
0.0036241144,
-0.0343179218,
0.0137494234,
0.0055259778,
0.0100553529,
-0.0638384223,
0.0229351241,
0.0440265983,
-0.0068223258,
-0.0412324741,
-0.1112988293,
-0.0181157775,
0.0099608926,
0.0002987592,
0.0226367079,
-0.0399507023,
-0.0470253043,
0.0543766618,
-0.0522208624,
-0.0355220996,
1.696043542e-34,
-0.0119540673,
0.0041765859,
-0.0045320243,
-0.0074619735,
0.0274304915,
-0.0374845266,
-0.046146147,
0.0037755447,
-0.0093719019,
-0.0461294502,
-0.0062384964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13902v2 | Controllable Data Augmentation for Context-Dependent Text-to-SQL | 2023-04-27T01:00:10 | 2023-04-28T02:45:31 | Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | The limited scale of annotated data constraints existing context-dependent
text-to-SQL models because of the complexity of labeling. The data augmentation
method is a commonly used method to solve this problem. However, the data
generated by current augmentation methods often lack diversity. In this paper,
we introduce ConDA, which generates interactive questions and corresponding SQL
results. We designed the SQL dialogue state to enhance the data diversity
through the state transition. Meanwhile, we also present a filter method to
ensure the data quality by a grounding model. Additionally, we utilize a
grounding model to identify and filter low-quality questions that mismatch the
state information. Experimental results on the SParC and CoSQL datasets show
that ConDA boosts the baseline model to achieve an average improvement of
$3.3\%$ on complex questions. Moreover, we analyze the augmented data, which
reveals that the data generated by ConDA are of high quality in both SQL
template hardness and types, turns, and question consistency. | [
0.0227315687,
0.0571562685,
-0.0251075942,
0.0455085039,
-0.0135915512,
0.0137077998,
-0.0156864524,
-0.0044713202,
0.0173283853,
-0.0456137806,
0.0128243668,
-0.0067472965,
-0.0112463757,
0.068035394,
0.0418057889,
-0.0653541759,
0.0386200137,
-0.0003199287,
-0.0357517898,
0.0419965051,
0.0174732096,
-0.0086424183,
-0.0087537663,
-0.014047483,
-0.0277225077,
-0.0222308189,
-0.0553298518,
0.028562244,
-0.0070588142,
-0.0190597624,
-0.0137468455,
0.0590701737,
0.0062013241,
-0.0034665104,
0.0000022224,
-0.0681176782,
-0.0638613403,
0.0254573617,
-0.0757214129,
-0.0053828103,
-0.0037391973,
-0.0317253843,
0.0270564184,
0.0604526363,
-0.0684481859,
-0.0060569341,
0.0372335799,
0.033553917,
0.0861157998,
0.0790982321,
-0.0198669545,
-0.0108780712,
0.0078600263,
0.0127844177,
0.0451885536,
-0.0455492288,
0.0118862344,
0.0616484657,
0.058697246,
0.0190352015,
-0.0122388052,
0.0268944483,
0.0272010434,
-0.0175796617,
0.0137267942,
-0.0187813807,
-0.018472923,
0.0270615779,
-0.0046818508,
0.0602371618,
0.0547657087,
-0.028470831,
-0.0046487194,
-0.0158661399,
0.0375744626,
-0.0062955306,
-0.0204762667,
-0.0336833,
-0.0183122382,
-0.007094353,
-0.0164445862,
-0.0122448569,
0.0036450978,
-0.0319148898,
-0.0709001198,
0.0469085723,
-0.0183346327,
-0.0552922413,
-0.007758847,
-0.0263253823,
0.0137339635,
-0.0471634381,
0.0353337787,
0.0427134931,
-0.0751471445,
0.0241365191,
-0.0621248446,
-0.0415902175,
0.0033485398,
-0.0242543612,
-0.0355110466,
0.0475444607,
-0.0123396739,
0.0465204827,
0.0348131061,
0.0078844223,
0.0337710194,
0.0277129412,
-0.0572576933,
-0.0369065031,
-0.0564673021,
0.0169390328,
-0.0694472641,
0.0213910434,
-0.0592974089,
0.0049059191,
-0.0136597352,
0.0610640459,
0.003828333,
0.0490446426,
-0.0043407176,
0.0205305442,
-0.0161240045,
0.0062722848,
-0.0593083724,
-0.0052382769,
-0.0159706697,
0.0005674361,
0.0252735075,
-0.0725955516,
0.0032612807,
-0.0024025538,
0.0545266569,
-0.0322906971,
-0.0118546793,
0.0343809798,
-0.0327832252,
-0.0131902508,
-0.0749667808,
-0.0762633383,
0.0064018937,
0.0097435676,
-0.0383070558,
-0.0143560674,
0.0750956535,
0.0153012313,
-0.0320165865,
-0.0495709814,
-0.0140449796,
0.0322621092,
0.002279741,
0.0889432356,
-0.0576252118,
-0.0002142988,
0.0488369018,
-0.0174882431,
0.00156588,
0.0665627122,
0.0097660702,
0.0123055028,
0.0289936438,
-0.0289110057,
0.017062379,
0.0085015623,
0.0388228856,
0.0338994749,
-0.0648783371,
0.0907466114,
0.0101399878,
0.0230026059,
-0.0244182516,
0.0501695201,
-0.0209176093,
0.0061792936,
0.0520284548,
-0.0351901501,
0.0110401697,
0.0091324812,
0.0161239058,
0.0360682122,
0.0030715673,
0.007988099,
-0.0402284674,
0.0141733726,
-0.0000386459,
0.0115156518,
0.0669852942,
-0.0285865869,
-0.0140523398,
-0.0984356254,
-0.0001891245,
0.006828479,
0.0277674682,
0.02793663,
0.000829315,
0.0409577042,
-0.0298173353,
-0.011261316,
-0.0270272959,
-0.019996915,
-0.0180814974,
-0.0047977907,
-0.0048807878,
0.0578799844,
0.0369009413,
-0.0595644228,
-0.0684871897,
-0.0353257991,
0.0205252636,
0.0050186431,
0.042674046,
-0.0222093202,
-0.0069444696,
-0.0378841832,
-0.033966884,
0.0380578637,
0.0268898383,
-0.028697012,
-0.0200504083,
-0.0055027935,
0.0158524718,
-0.008311403,
-0.0201405846,
0.0247169137,
0.0086445482,
-0.0452686436,
0.0268217977,
0.018221885,
0.0177736022,
0.0400891788,
0.0097927954,
0.0364182107,
0.0481152087,
0.0072052516,
-0.0245399736,
-0.0213551447,
0.006608753,
-0.0466431975,
0.0065512531,
-0.0063175405,
-0.0293198973,
-0.0516916737,
-0.0629778951,
-0.0628819466,
-0.001466305,
-0.0384869762,
0.0263511389,
-0.0280474313,
0.0043803211,
0.0395813026,
-0.009542306,
-0.0438491069,
0.0523100793,
-0.0023090076,
0.0168832242,
0.0015642192,
-0.0035091732,
0.0287937801,
-0.0953089371,
0.0380696692,
-0.0150808189,
-0.0340096429,
0.0120089287,
-0.0274103489,
-0.0121761886,
-0.0611666255,
0.0220524929,
-0.0765357241,
0.0080265151,
-0.0108125294,
0.0155030498,
0.0201177672,
0.0570017546,
-0.0124238953,
-0.0224034525,
-0.0800189972,
-0.0454068817,
0.0109901484,
0.0162564982,
0.0391104557,
0.0611910746,
0.0048431531,
-0.0317420699,
-0.0026279991,
-0.0286561865,
0.0234530065,
-0.0274100397,
-0.0219127443,
-0.0289571993,
0.0017111417,
-0.0240138005,
0.0494320728,
0.0045864265,
0.0149152856,
0.0010594565,
-0.0155907283,
0.001592154,
0.0366036072,
-0.0098496154,
-0.0372753553,
-0.0084652165,
0.0131738028,
-0.0413456932,
0.0387502573,
-0.0027597931,
0.0410370305,
0.0152283926,
-0.0508683585,
0.0494616367,
0.0175942946,
0.0064328695,
-0.0133373514,
-0.0295275487,
0.0200417265,
0.0197464116,
0.0198714398,
-0.065902032,
0.0051099979,
0.005617558,
0.0458178557,
-0.0197046548,
0.0010803195,
0.0664858818,
-0.0259655155,
-0.0069602346,
-0.050215397,
-0.0250319857,
-0.0564440265,
0.0467852615,
0.0155986045,
0.0108331023,
-0.0137865217,
-0.0395545028,
-0.0472562388,
-0.0419279672,
0.0373804867,
-0.0290538333,
0.0561899506,
-0.0359115265,
0.0073697106,
0.0004980352,
-0.0240407363,
-0.0490444452,
0.0201653987,
-0.0142192869,
0.004611609,
0.0957594141,
0.0212764721,
0.0350677036,
-0.0113698831,
-0.0302178953,
0.0786177218,
-0.0096095055,
-0.0096464064,
-0.0233324766,
0.0113452869,
0.0300233215,
0.0575603582,
0.0048748231,
-0.0131055983,
0.0163118746,
0.0330385193,
0.0364457183,
-0.0787786618,
0.0056917183,
0.0004305963,
-0.00559325,
-0.0250997506,
-0.0070896959,
0.0136641711,
-0.0136736035,
-0.0643130839,
-0.0460435189,
0.0673597753,
0.0494550839,
-0.002795883,
-0.0031347226,
-0.0112446928,
-0.0068960721,
0.037523739,
0.065824613,
-0.1221804619,
-0.020871643,
-0.0222807471,
0.038846001,
0.002622077,
-0.0379796736,
-0.0213289,
-0.1176578179,
0.0183321498,
-0.0356450528,
-0.0670074672,
-0.0297513623,
-0.0026519371,
-0.0064898282,
0.0023600662,
0.019071782,
0.0534811951,
0.0232166406,
0.0023724395,
0.0285312533,
0.0202521663,
-0.0597377382,
-0.0499846675,
0.0068096709,
0.034326043,
0.0393439271,
0.0056878892,
0.0288998187,
-0.0135312453,
0.0558433495,
-0.0003033484,
-0.0271880217,
-0.0294948667,
0.0665956885,
-0.0018074051,
0.0013086562,
0.021537425,
0.0401840284,
0.0170056093,
0.030029485,
0.036333289,
0.0839637816,
-0.0524318814,
0.0627692938,
-0.0173056424,
-0.040287327,
0.0398114733,
0.0488447063,
0.0372959934,
-0.0253214408,
-0.0309778713,
-0.0458787009,
-0.0220433325,
-0.0705567673,
0.0515362546,
0.0205427352,
-0.0264623556,
-0.0339374319,
-0.0824050829,
-0.0508956201,
0.0753740668,
0.0309329424,
-0.00565205,
0.0321791805,
0.0349548981,
-0.0290058069,
-0.0178249739,
-0.0255471822,
-0.0248790663,
0.0002847742,
-0.0669601038,
-0.0191666912,
-0.0270613972,
-0.0553184636,
-0.0212575551,
-0.0216649063,
-0.0584234893,
-0.0186944213,
0.0337173343,
0.0078639882,
0.0202348474,
0.0264567193,
-0.0165332127,
-0.0610117353,
-0.0359338857,
0.056457296,
-0.0199753549,
-0.0547386259,
-0.0005426713,
0.0337445475,
-0.0084570525,
0.0307877287,
-0.0605969802,
-0.0192052592,
-0.0323763862,
0.0027385801,
-0.0405261889,
-0.0131391715,
0.0545249842,
0.0281378776,
0.0123591796,
0.0703840405,
-0.0249007773,
-0.0051664626,
0.0803877339,
-0.0698505938,
-0.0600448847,
-0.0297755599,
0.0452920124,
-0.005404247,
-0.0070516183,
0.0338995643,
-0.0254221186,
-0.0385094807,
0.0664539039,
-0.0316627622,
-0.0156021044,
0.0162739828,
-0.001485801,
0.0329954326,
-0.0231955517,
0.0083856331,
0.0493676141,
0.0336528085,
0.0724697858,
-0.0122097544,
0.0381957032,
0.0419480726,
-0.0088367919,
-0.0247313976,
0.0180551521,
-0.0580174141,
-0.002360872,
-0.021855155,
0.0236905403,
-0.0014711451,
0.0056505003,
0.0138316881,
0.0004556483,
-0.0175689459,
0.0062365243,
0.0266203713,
0.077555418,
-0.0112838084,
0.0418954939,
0.0176819693,
-0.0187739842,
-0.0151379732,
0.052978415,
0.0129865417,
0.0216008183,
-0.025001891,
-0.0489943698,
-0.0675700605,
-0.001022091,
0.0112637365,
0.0351833254,
-0.027556913,
-0.0046055173,
-0.0465255268,
-0.0528995954,
0.010593826,
0.0256312117,
-0.0189180672,
-0.0085958578,
0.0484441072,
0.0354828611,
0.0456008948,
-0.0034768544,
-0.0293488633,
0.0409240201,
0.0009341875,
-0.0720528439,
-0.0054702456,
-6.458082944e-33,
-0.0359446779,
-0.0275627077,
0.0312344767,
-0.0375227556,
0.0120588131,
-0.0391209498,
-0.0075813173,
-0.0028809446,
-0.0300714131,
0.0026933837,
-0.0368824974,
0.0487191193,
0.0271495245,
0.0351443738,
-0.0140738664,
-0.0547412336,
0.0257445406,
0.0091504417,
0.0049336501,
0.0159836616,
0.0465503894,
0.0206297934,
0.0057688118,
-0.07650996,
0.0527312271,
-0.0316154584,
-0.0115016811,
0.0471370183,
-0.0036941082,
0.0449841693,
-0.0047056829,
0.0249017123,
0.0332353748,
-0.0338165723,
-0.0068829563,
-0.0242201891,
-0.0596254468,
-0.0303636473,
0.0119596897,
0.0020500701,
-0.0317189097,
-0.0279206298,
0.0592023134,
-0.0251165312,
0.0095433891,
0.0258242134,
0.0116099957,
-0.0322164111,
-0.0307732765,
-0.0241386667,
-0.0159434043,
0.0262029506,
-0.0096326787,
-0.0053679952,
-0.017798407,
0.0810264945,
0.0128542967,
0.0057005109,
-0.0421235971,
0.0235691108,
0.0530790277,
0.0511818156,
0.0269556511,
0.0422649123,
-0.0020223148,
-0.0466101132,
-0.0179492254,
0.0198066309,
-0.0152102662,
0.0345377214,
-0.0271838959,
0.0451193973,
0.0346193388,
0.065966852,
0.0112174172,
-0.0248358548,
-0.0435282625,
0.044389639,
-0.0308989678,
-0.0045778933,
-0.0343505479,
0.0086090015,
-0.0828535184,
-0.0428874083,
-0.0375318527,
0.0335173272,
-0.0332351401,
-0.0103560882,
0.050791122,
-0.0006137892,
-0.0566638559,
0.0339719392,
0.0134400399,
-0.0107995234,
-0.0460184477,
-0.0059831096,
-0.0279460121,
-0.0276315846,
-0.001598716,
0.0142894704,
-0.0372177102,
-0.0140906163,
0.0499823764,
-0.0102368463,
0.0215607602,
0.0329620503,
0.0274071675,
0.0016211336,
-0.0774573609,
0.017326979,
-0.0245906506,
0.0569735728,
-0.0464430414,
0.0347649045,
0.0073894123,
0.0228578448,
0.0105884857,
0.0941989198,
0.0166982319,
-0.008328232,
-0.0448357835,
-0.051145982,
0.0072955047,
0.0071151741,
-0.0001137667,
0.0089384848,
0.0101421895,
-0.0046982123,
0.0283870939,
-0.0399648547,
0.0081478171,
0.0329609104,
2.83e-7,
0.0625620708,
0.0360811464,
0.0347914733,
0.0484891795,
0.0207773298,
0.0416820757,
0.0124638472,
0.0100149205,
0.0290739294,
-0.0208106544,
0.0163975544,
-0.0157071445,
0.0232763458,
0.0355710499,
-0.058479853,
-0.0357544385,
-0.0353309698,
-0.0043902029,
-0.0400702544,
0.016048843,
0.0943492353,
0.1008303091,
-0.0166541282,
0.0235889833,
0.0214685034,
-0.0072647831,
-0.0111518521,
0.0106143821,
-0.0258093737,
0.051634077,
0.0310691092,
-0.0016250262,
-0.0040574572,
0.0446164943,
-0.0367984772,
0.0044347299,
-0.0171709526,
0.0449964702,
0.00071795,
-0.0264393762,
-0.0002181926,
-0.0437175259,
0.0213776212,
-0.0289113224,
0.1015145779,
-0.0227011256,
0.0175788086,
0.067809239,
-0.0223178919,
-0.0136444345,
0.0027099075,
0.0107353227,
-0.0354129933,
-0.0221344922,
0.0315881781,
0.0348289572,
0.01741766,
-0.0313895196,
-0.0417606831,
-0.0070750983,
-0.0149231357,
-0.0278227516,
-0.0172819663,
-0.0037622058,
-0.0275121778,
-0.0263491366,
-0.0327214859,
3.070393311e-34,
0.043212112,
0.0215531588,
0.0342978053,
-0.0060203327,
0.0483261459,
-0.0174825136,
0.002187524,
0.0158648323,
0.031307783,
-0.0777586251,
-0.0263725687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13883v1 | Neural Keyphrase Generation: Analysis and Evaluation | 2023-04-27T00:10:21 | 2023-04-27T00:10:21 | Tuhin Kundu, Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Keyphrase generation aims at generating topical phrases from a given text
either by copying from the original text (present keyphrases) or by producing
new keyphrases (absent keyphrases) that capture the semantic meaning of the
text. Encoder-decoder models are most widely used for this task because of
their capabilities for absent keyphrase generation. However, there has been
little to no analysis on the performance and behavior of such models for
keyphrase generation. In this paper, we study various tendencies exhibited by
three strong models: T5 (based on a pre-trained transformer),
CatSeq-Transformer (a non-pretrained Transformer), and ExHiRD (based on a
recurrent neural network). We analyze prediction confidence scores, model
calibration, and the effect of token position on keyphrases generation.
Moreover, we motivate and propose a novel metric framework, SoftKeyScore, to
evaluate the similarity between two sets of keyphrases by using softscores to
account for partial matching and semantic similarity. We find that SoftKeyScore
is more suitable than the standard F1 metric for evaluating two sets of given
keyphrases. | [
0.0623679459,
-0.0015817224,
-0.00561425,
-0.001322881,
-0.0361335017,
-0.0146247856,
-0.0301719029,
0.0254042596,
-0.0293434914,
-0.027700942,
0.0009675108,
0.0035295975,
-0.0163991693,
0.0838478208,
0.0123296101,
-0.0336365029,
0.0037534975,
0.006084023,
-0.0110977655,
-0.0060480842,
-0.0047912891,
0.0285491832,
0.0095675401,
0.0888645425,
0.0146544203,
0.0117686931,
-0.0112751918,
-0.0207147617,
-0.0028013941,
-0.0229752921,
0.0365842357,
0.0034987761,
-0.0119525744,
0.03312549,
0.0000018894,
-0.0470431522,
-0.0167929009,
-0.04025428,
0.0479000174,
-0.0100091342,
0.0654622167,
-0.0465853885,
0.027820237,
0.0192958098,
-0.0435868241,
-0.00092459,
0.0581902042,
0.0438280366,
0.0573055036,
0.0295231435,
-0.0180501137,
-0.0557412542,
0.0124740805,
-0.0355123989,
-0.0168324206,
-0.063830696,
0.0032582136,
-0.0505601242,
-0.077563107,
0.0294175223,
-0.002460127,
0.0360202864,
0.0281911064,
0.0176423173,
0.1177429482,
0.0369478948,
-0.0333325006,
-0.0411636643,
-0.0253934823,
0.0432568677,
-0.0479808226,
-0.0069364919,
0.0260845628,
-0.0415578261,
0.0139995199,
0.0328336619,
-0.0481303297,
-0.0010813966,
-0.00222329,
-0.002931763,
-0.0113397269,
0.0033733533,
-0.0009558952,
0.0112748779,
-0.0029778411,
-0.0205807835,
0.0599331409,
-0.0387634113,
-0.0424535349,
-0.0208099242,
-0.0252696127,
-0.0745162889,
0.0226186626,
0.0428214781,
0.0189027432,
0.0087579396,
-0.03866864,
-0.0026349609,
0.0685911477,
-0.1214246377,
0.0090692341,
-0.0066230637,
0.0175274611,
0.0141989635,
-0.0678015128,
0.0789833367,
-0.0213193335,
0.0374587625,
-0.0310376715,
-0.0155518558,
-0.0749483854,
-0.0427022576,
-0.0115953973,
0.0550904907,
0.0451991856,
-0.0682176128,
-0.069121547,
0.0168577414,
0.0414887816,
0.0030191066,
0.0167421065,
0.0378784016,
-0.0366289653,
-0.007229378,
-0.0238422882,
0.0008267578,
-0.0317577347,
0.0022005066,
0.0032602798,
0.0052487059,
-0.0010441664,
0.0034002489,
0.0231758095,
-0.0242788624,
0.0233646184,
0.0333009437,
-0.0207515676,
-0.0033055891,
0.0076245931,
-0.0475246273,
-0.0379203111,
0.0225076526,
0.0307275523,
-0.0529683419,
0.0451461561,
0.0099252434,
-0.019976886,
-0.0330139734,
0.0106120408,
0.0407017022,
-0.029905634,
0.048914291,
0.0050113071,
0.0069800881,
0.0252277441,
0.0036195053,
0.006116346,
0.0011967008,
0.0279585402,
0.0939522982,
0.0378569514,
-0.01100857,
0.0193893649,
0.0067773289,
0.0086213201,
-0.0240399297,
-0.0210110061,
0.0057450021,
-0.0049588694,
0.0276532471,
-0.0304567069,
0.0441330075,
-0.024733359,
0.0322011411,
0.0693825185,
0.076665327,
0.0277396534,
0.0830155611,
0.004078147,
0.0138020962,
-0.0346878916,
-0.0061452244,
0.0201141648,
0.0362478979,
0.0113489581,
0.0363915674,
0.0240232442,
0.0343042724,
-0.0262871012,
-0.0323464721,
-0.0038338264,
-0.0076383497,
-0.0176344998,
-0.0656498745,
0.0465954952,
0.0358410887,
-0.0913422555,
0.0842103437,
-0.0400757752,
-0.057728447,
-0.0086999908,
-0.0583371259,
-0.0082565416,
0.0477791578,
0.0637430698,
0.0469767265,
-0.0663597211,
0.0037469764,
-0.0389308296,
0.071374625,
0.0085120192,
-0.0042044879,
-0.0372658037,
-0.0642463192,
-0.0367726982,
-0.0614204854,
0.0019517228,
-0.0176161081,
-0.0102365613,
0.035838455,
0.0605802499,
-0.0018936123,
0.0098925345,
0.0372977965,
0.0166168772,
-0.0074844072,
-0.0018312542,
-0.0101591367,
0.0173166376,
0.0014179528,
0.0054693879,
0.0358789191,
0.0383116156,
-0.0420591943,
-0.0549538471,
0.0074672177,
-0.0396556668,
0.03279984,
0.0381845124,
-0.0619579442,
0.0409402214,
0.0253590904,
-0.0196632594,
-0.0142234219,
0.0379367582,
-0.0447520912,
0.0380289555,
-0.0641108081,
0.025710335,
-0.0509825386,
0.0161413513,
-0.0288933516,
0.0774362832,
-0.0021883924,
0.0155227352,
-0.0436909609,
-0.0444083661,
0.0349211283,
0.0199476201,
-0.0017494498,
0.0067510563,
-0.0186615754,
0.0095737958,
0.0355928279,
0.0255419016,
-0.0197731368,
-0.0702307001,
-0.0451836549,
0.0091648065,
0.0028479605,
-0.0220176857,
0.0443606861,
0.0139851309,
0.0097485045,
-0.0191375557,
-0.0426154807,
-0.0474324934,
-0.0054626646,
0.0163747352,
0.0409892462,
0.0276210103,
-0.0399974212,
0.0020185285,
0.0020251295,
-0.0109997494,
0.0677143782,
0.0482746921,
-0.0290512554,
-0.0137781342,
0.062100444,
-0.0111925714,
-0.0736141503,
0.0114680054,
-0.0686510652,
0.0229493212,
0.021570731,
0.0375274159,
-0.0045918473,
0.0801071525,
-0.024064742,
0.0083442535,
-0.0199921485,
-0.0274112467,
-0.0387786776,
-0.0613013618,
-0.0818903148,
0.003033407,
-0.0361846387,
0.0579329059,
0.0232229885,
0.0381407104,
0.0253434032,
-0.085952282,
0.0491755679,
0.0165762603,
-0.0141377281,
-0.0421019793,
-0.0327975899,
-0.012353654,
0.0220358092,
-0.0274071954,
-0.014202253,
0.0487367138,
-0.0221284963,
0.0228267349,
-0.0358543135,
-0.0042657144,
-0.0322208144,
0.0362229273,
-0.0461140685,
0.0127521288,
0.034157604,
-0.0279625431,
-0.0113095734,
-0.0276626889,
-0.0232218616,
-0.0514253937,
0.0466559306,
0.0012243346,
-0.020930659,
0.0157607105,
-0.0155481659,
-0.0429076329,
-0.027943518,
0.0114019234,
-0.0110698408,
0.0315188356,
-0.0213130843,
0.0430023186,
0.0434727222,
-0.0086752446,
0.0225728787,
-0.0144118369,
-0.0156011349,
-0.0189058986,
0.0342943445,
0.0839652196,
-0.0257960185,
-0.037175335,
-0.0183897316,
0.0248416141,
0.0060359463,
0.0451272801,
0.0024812522,
-0.0306106117,
-0.0074440176,
0.0028131914,
-0.0280821994,
0.0130651575,
0.0208621267,
0.0124846343,
-0.003673807,
-0.0320313312,
0.1271404624,
0.0308362506,
-0.0403463021,
-0.0083572678,
-0.016240932,
-0.0183876045,
0.0060725948,
-0.0053717033,
-0.0229954254,
-0.0016963488,
-0.0143975765,
0.0246870685,
-0.0048205792,
-0.0174149703,
-0.0038701261,
-0.0979031175,
0.0051058698,
0.0019857376,
-0.0292075761,
-0.0566105247,
-0.0422374345,
-0.0400285982,
-0.0120313959,
-0.0309757721,
-0.0176049247,
-0.0210183859,
0.0125910863,
-0.0035092123,
-0.0104295146,
-0.0345944986,
0.0173002277,
-0.0629849508,
-0.0128015084,
0.098707512,
0.0454598404,
-0.0019506963,
-0.0338730067,
-0.0245651137,
-0.0070751044,
-0.0049746223,
0.021355575,
0.0147835622,
-0.0161105115,
-0.0016468135,
0.000129715,
0.0146584399,
-0.0438901484,
0.0132077616,
0.0383692048,
0.0270349104,
-0.0067899339,
-0.0133542381,
-0.0161945168,
0.0201316345,
-0.0179907978,
0.0914529637,
0.061884407,
-0.0173623823,
-0.0120981624,
0.0099215331,
0.0546997935,
-0.0873505175,
-0.0549349673,
-0.0331058763,
-0.0305948872,
0.0092382208,
-0.0921407267,
-0.0420802236,
0.0078879995,
-0.0076924884,
0.0139533542,
0.0210650284,
0.0054876939,
-0.0221305825,
-0.0590229854,
-0.0261232853,
0.0050867395,
-0.0241506174,
-0.0161222294,
0.0064811194,
0.0568097085,
-0.015880568,
-0.0521164127,
0.0211447403,
-0.0511706136,
-0.02814872,
0.0218585189,
0.0380773842,
0.0179317929,
-0.0139309997,
-0.0179646276,
-0.0128677422,
0.0805129632,
0.0742746368,
-0.017334722,
0.0017620419,
0.0141748805,
-0.0099554826,
-0.0190624129,
0.0241766758,
-0.0649871826,
-0.0013052033,
-0.0086093564,
0.0598949343,
-0.0248424541,
-0.0701128617,
0.0164658278,
-0.011591306,
0.0257892385,
-0.0394840576,
-0.0256794821,
-0.017381575,
0.0004771319,
0.0256082825,
0.0047617252,
-0.0364354514,
0.0054364884,
0.0426937528,
0.0232522711,
-0.0020890238,
0.0344781876,
-0.0568221249,
0.0422406532,
-0.0258595105,
-0.026562022,
0.0154885333,
0.0570963733,
0.0030616208,
-0.0138132777,
-0.0369382985,
-0.0524439588,
0.0012862358,
-0.0117885359,
-0.0225400403,
0.0166384093,
0.0198213737,
-0.0014397359,
-0.0281246062,
0.0827235356,
-0.0561189391,
-0.0399607532,
-0.0714094564,
-0.0133925052,
0.0423975401,
0.0140153728,
-0.0052649654,
-0.0062561459,
-0.0103782993,
0.0153128868,
0.0518093668,
-0.0064363531,
-0.0128674116,
-0.0040604314,
-0.0054310923,
-0.0149701526,
-0.0264350325,
0.0763962343,
-0.0016982678,
0.0504041016,
0.0102386661,
-0.044438459,
-0.0049216002,
-0.003368729,
0.0388333909,
-0.0093937721,
0.0128628779,
-0.0027455948,
-0.0210781414,
-0.0315321349,
0.1061583385,
-0.0037618158,
0.0268485826,
0.0349672213,
0.0547308102,
0.0619719923,
-0.0310275629,
-0.0003114773,
-0.0453257598,
0.0295480136,
-0.0025990114,
-0.0107151568,
-0.038956929,
-6.360738053e-33,
-0.0122194747,
-0.0126352943,
-0.0015298011,
0.02665269,
-0.0338259563,
-0.0004520824,
-0.036712382,
-0.0356005877,
0.0191809516,
-0.0253291298,
0.0061511616,
0.0145220337,
0.0090634767,
0.0236179158,
0.0543509424,
-0.0365925059,
0.0525255837,
0.00973198,
-0.013017945,
0.0380367637,
0.0191748738,
0.0335936174,
0.0495340377,
-0.0262939874,
0.0073832287,
-0.0455576293,
-0.0024362374,
-0.0239309948,
0.0595595278,
0.0706803277,
-0.0145392148,
0.0440120734,
0.0220714156,
-0.0724229142,
-0.0117009487,
0.0162747223,
-0.0203384068,
-0.0437419899,
-0.0116558615,
-0.0303888973,
0.0278335679,
-0.0619969852,
0.0472350381,
-0.0103189535,
-0.0276110396,
0.0271357168,
0.0624897704,
-0.0205183458,
-0.0228210315,
-0.0574656203,
-0.0058095236,
-0.0122453542,
0.0042999354,
-0.0184217151,
-0.0200359989,
0.0318310075,
0.0111217797,
0.0504302345,
-0.0503064506,
0.039571587,
0.0278486088,
0.0294007678,
0.0431521833,
0.0425091088,
0.0219151322,
0.0726034716,
-0.0181540549,
-0.0349412598,
-0.0125831794,
0.0448400974,
0.0207253732,
0.0415477268,
0.0753624737,
0.0626747012,
0.0629346073,
0.0045298696,
-0.0323413461,
0.0356106758,
-0.0396679603,
0.0311070178,
0.0608639792,
-0.0113421287,
-0.0061928779,
0.0132271424,
-0.0269411523,
0.0066373982,
-0.0392161235,
-0.0580449104,
0.0280865803,
0.036289271,
-0.0468650609,
0.0564430393,
0.0168866534,
-0.0207905471,
0.0644094348,
0.0158213098,
0.0143381478,
0.0138878589,
-0.0140701663,
0.0086112972,
-0.0293639824,
-0.0234263483,
0.0468652174,
0.0347578563,
0.0280172583,
-0.0090999557,
-0.0118213855,
-0.0091798007,
-0.0443448722,
0.0000269949,
-0.0072628651,
-0.0257185288,
-0.0063491878,
-0.0441872478,
-0.0137574458,
0.0231659971,
-0.0353963375,
0.008720465,
0.0181610435,
0.0104073239,
0.0145877795,
-0.0331311226,
0.0493253581,
0.0462801717,
-0.005053754,
0.0185002089,
-0.0671298876,
0.0023076134,
0.013019531,
-0.036172349,
-0.0441006944,
-0.0058928826,
2.76e-7,
0.0139663573,
0.0275818035,
0.0502715819,
0.0032573005,
-0.0223599989,
0.0509303845,
0.0095388154,
0.0441734381,
-0.0136944735,
-0.0194898658,
0.0196637753,
0.0217608344,
0.0068074069,
-0.0022327795,
-0.086938709,
0.0071439981,
-0.1254046708,
0.0196145717,
-0.0370912813,
0.0249106381,
0.0664475933,
0.0327570215,
0.0271218158,
-0.0137939332,
-0.0321725383,
-0.0471176989,
0.050697241,
-0.017463427,
-0.0330759808,
0.0360016525,
-0.0083498834,
0.0327191986,
-0.016875416,
0.041908063,
-0.0114758583,
-0.0109752584,
0.0713807866,
-0.0122155622,
0.0077427658,
-0.064362511,
-0.0061559542,
-0.002789811,
-0.0040556262,
-0.0438431241,
0.0463922173,
-0.0858962908,
-0.0100166555,
-0.0284468513,
-0.0396725647,
0.0484255068,
0.0203833729,
-0.0653547719,
-0.035506472,
0.0061362972,
0.0066860272,
0.0469986089,
0.004564831,
-0.0512925051,
0.0147374719,
-0.0014204582,
-0.0235260725,
-0.0033234954,
-0.0748389438,
-0.0106235659,
0.0330616608,
-0.0439709276,
0.0498853587,
2.250015574e-34,
0.0307019874,
-0.0058093779,
-0.011655705,
0.0317638777,
0.0261915941,
-0.0150965452,
-0.0088935876,
0.0331129171,
0.0037783897,
-0.0222600717,
-0.0112808617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13875v1 | MasonNLP+ at SemEval-2023 Task 8: Extracting Medical Questions, Experiences and Claims from Social Media using Knowledge-Augmented Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-04-26T23:45:11 | 2023-04-26T23:45:11 | Giridhar Kaushik Ramachandran, Haritha Gangavarapu, Kevin Lybarger, Ozlem Uzuner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In online forums like Reddit, users share their experiences with medical
conditions and treatments, including making claims, asking questions, and
discussing the effects of treatments on their health. Building systems to
understand this information can effectively monitor the spread of
misinformation and verify user claims. The Task-8 of the 2023 International
Workshop on Semantic Evaluation focused on medical applications, specifically
extracting patient experience- and medical condition-related entities from user
posts on social media. The Reddit Health Online Talk (RedHot) corpus contains
posts from medical condition-related subreddits with annotations characterizing
the patient experience and medical conditions. In Subtask-1, patient experience
is characterized by personal experience, questions, and claims. In Subtask-2,
medical conditions are characterized by population, intervention, and outcome.
For the automatic extraction of patient experiences and medical condition
information, as a part of the challenge, we proposed language-model-based
extraction systems that ranked $3^{rd}$ on both subtasks' leaderboards. In this
work, we describe our approach and, in addition, explore the automatic
extraction of this information using domain-specific language models and the
inclusion of external knowledge. | [
0.0776697695,
0.0772031844,
0.0050497684,
0.0160640758,
-0.0266947057,
0.023654107,
-0.0466375723,
0.022839101,
0.0354325064,
-0.0624556467,
-0.0147242816,
-0.005962777,
-0.038386859,
0.0237505399,
-0.0001153367,
-0.0304401014,
0.0279960148,
0.0402922779,
0.0408106595,
0.0343883745,
0.0188060701,
0.011465461,
-0.0494962558,
0.0095378477,
-0.0138709005,
-0.0083215032,
0.0604688562,
-0.0309263784,
0.0109081483,
-0.0531466119,
0.0249300916,
0.0325621516,
-0.0281727836,
-0.0096282708,
0.0000018006,
-0.0281903595,
-0.0316032246,
0.0095672514,
-0.018072119,
-0.0623686574,
0.0381216183,
-0.042537272,
-0.0105102882,
0.0117929429,
-0.03826157,
-0.0704610422,
0.0245668218,
0.0690596327,
0.0557645187,
0.0861450434,
-0.0445838571,
-0.0166293625,
-0.0006117864,
0.005376122,
0.0158268996,
-0.0182368439,
0.0608180277,
0.0115444614,
0.0202003364,
-0.0240802504,
0.0518067963,
0.0261239,
-0.0466234423,
0.0170757137,
-0.0261884201,
0.0281203855,
-0.0067082378,
-0.0403054133,
-0.0130660431,
0.0857678279,
0.00656569,
0.0093052741,
0.0468438938,
0.0174174365,
-0.0245049708,
0.0359909907,
-0.0334043726,
0.0043633906,
-0.0238010827,
0.0057970928,
0.0183579698,
0.0427126661,
0.0300390832,
-0.000658408,
0.0165704377,
0.0182685032,
0.0127451578,
-0.0288576055,
0.015357364,
0.0065234075,
0.0100547392,
-0.0602385923,
0.042294506,
0.0245703515,
0.0370332859,
0.0570927076,
-0.0036637103,
-0.0510832779,
0.0556999929,
-0.0764039978,
-0.022905143,
-0.0174112692,
0.0059859282,
0.0724734887,
0.0064258631,
-0.0225970671,
-0.0080501558,
0.0169568881,
0.0002072925,
0.0144934021,
-0.0352547057,
0.0170197114,
-0.0269259252,
0.0390127152,
0.0101548899,
0.0205121413,
-0.0414587148,
-0.0121438643,
-0.003330444,
0.0011533052,
0.014289449,
-0.0066704913,
-0.0129404226,
-0.0028456633,
0.0099382531,
0.0246903766,
0.0090516005,
0.0051924782,
-0.0161476471,
-0.0254152361,
0.0286459327,
-0.0097049121,
0.0544692837,
-0.0199335478,
-0.0056090737,
0.0420199297,
0.0651579648,
-0.0280962065,
-0.0101306047,
-0.0326526612,
-0.0257064607,
0.0106939394,
0.0043055662,
-0.0445496142,
0.0675167441,
0.0054624663,
-0.0000021868,
-0.045798447,
0.0341676585,
0.0134257218,
-0.083574377,
0.0315499716,
-0.0672163665,
0.0314872079,
0.0406984426,
0.0446075723,
0.0358627439,
0.0318281204,
0.0216301177,
-0.0051284479,
0.0737022534,
-0.0047848043,
0.0083866715,
0.0452887751,
0.0361152478,
-0.0654380098,
0.0366442017,
0.0159305073,
0.0076703993,
0.0048386417,
-0.0569775105,
0.0651196241,
-0.0024225994,
-0.0029793375,
0.0084882472,
0.0487822443,
-0.0071986108,
-0.0200943612,
0.0101986416,
-0.0269715022,
0.0434263498,
-0.0196105503,
-0.0181656573,
-0.0472058691,
-0.0008928105,
-0.0099354442,
-0.0106400652,
0.0178186335,
0.0121307177,
-0.0296487883,
-0.0602596588,
-0.0406432711,
-0.0064255935,
-0.0164314639,
0.0408509746,
-0.0001049891,
-0.0264641847,
0.050317727,
0.0654290542,
-0.0471811034,
0.0118546281,
-0.0366380848,
-0.0111882845,
0.0208291318,
0.0326453522,
-0.0543359555,
-0.041321408,
-0.002943635,
0.018824501,
0.0135279624,
0.0428732522,
-0.0269543212,
-0.0118274344,
0.0030295767,
-0.0011157674,
0.0186778251,
0.0135821225,
-0.0561718158,
0.0334828049,
0.0205302685,
-0.0295811985,
0.0011640765,
-0.0311318208,
0.0479698516,
-0.0243351571,
-0.0143580856,
-0.0318023041,
-0.0073941345,
0.0257393047,
0.0339753516,
-0.0010466254,
0.0179972779,
0.0487275235,
-0.0364385284,
-0.0439327136,
0.0249682125,
-0.0206242669,
-0.0472755283,
0.0318752341,
-0.0135542229,
-0.0095775835,
-0.011912778,
-0.040708296,
0.0057970807,
0.014068136,
-0.0005929822,
0.0740580559,
0.0017952729,
-0.011859972,
0.0515510067,
-0.0103141544,
-0.0386948511,
0.054370366,
-0.0240001939,
-0.0034307614,
-0.0553777553,
-0.0832228363,
-0.0319918022,
-0.0012377097,
-0.0116715701,
0.0052460139,
-0.0127613125,
0.0220360775,
0.0331701413,
-0.0306706596,
-0.0569435731,
0.0084701506,
-0.1090222821,
0.0239218269,
-0.0264967494,
0.0377923399,
0.0450203046,
0.0445469692,
-0.0152978059,
-0.0351204835,
-0.0299889985,
-0.0070043667,
0.02407966,
0.0220153183,
0.0415367782,
0.0428796746,
0.0440778024,
-0.0519800074,
-0.0088939359,
-0.0402051583,
0.0190917235,
0.0361060202,
-0.0486388206,
0.0123936366,
0.0009454141,
-0.0674617887,
0.0191185772,
0.0072383308,
-0.0302055851,
-0.0442672484,
-0.0279532038,
-0.0147056347,
0.0084760338,
0.0195393022,
0.0713338554,
-0.0161404945,
0.0200111587,
0.0015048597,
0.0015177527,
-0.0859261379,
-0.0227894504,
0.0180834699,
-0.0086434586,
0.0619499199,
0.0982376412,
0.0337534435,
-0.0051060608,
-0.0071971784,
0.0160903782,
-0.0521058328,
0.0189801138,
-0.0019581812,
0.0009082406,
-0.019965807,
0.0399589539,
-0.0374691114,
0.0074727596,
0.0744441301,
0.0139630949,
0.0388166346,
-0.0484630018,
-0.0265280101,
-0.0339730233,
-0.0034661889,
0.014673681,
0.0320187658,
0.0563239008,
0.0019432188,
0.0731123164,
0.0022224064,
0.0090838373,
-0.0635667965,
-0.0054561477,
0.0106473016,
0.0429822467,
0.0185264908,
-0.0485080443,
-0.0465368144,
-0.0817930847,
-0.0145505015,
-0.0260527506,
-0.024960978,
0.0459458977,
-0.0453246087,
0.0093204426,
-0.0129861254,
0.0469954908,
0.0047209803,
0.0103322221,
0.0244981628,
0.0390352905,
0.0521792285,
-0.0263356864,
-0.0112919519,
-0.0115721868,
0.0124970861,
0.103070043,
-0.0224618427,
0.0079681696,
0.033227291,
-0.0254993085,
0.0055769854,
-0.0748363286,
0.0430706963,
-0.0132688014,
0.0439444333,
-0.031025121,
-0.0021017264,
0.1168633401,
0.0366146527,
-0.0088319723,
0.0364243574,
0.0072126603,
-0.0541183092,
-0.009104047,
0.0191348698,
-0.1005403996,
-0.0157511048,
-0.0419246815,
-0.0172547624,
-0.0166816059,
-0.0327100791,
0.0141763408,
-0.0369638056,
-0.0077397092,
-0.0221809428,
-0.0287366901,
-0.0035467716,
-0.0400770903,
0.0380291604,
-0.004688276,
-0.0273499377,
-0.0125079891,
-0.0038634418,
-0.0017985707,
0.023995826,
-0.0686675832,
-0.0895430446,
0.0106131043,
-0.0023681258,
0.0064604832,
0.0509980768,
0.0368893556,
0.0113758231,
-0.0270702392,
0.011248772,
-0.0103214122,
-0.0181597136,
0.0010503419,
0.0743888542,
-0.0362691358,
-0.0055285394,
-0.0545791872,
0.0486518517,
-0.0594187304,
-0.0254201554,
-0.0058518485,
0.0614200011,
-0.0031416272,
-0.0371880345,
-0.030777948,
0.0065938737,
0.0397477895,
0.0621621199,
0.009537247,
0.0244952813,
0.0042268098,
0.0117297554,
0.0416586399,
0.0002094642,
-0.0456369258,
-0.0075481613,
-0.0055878307,
-0.020702716,
-0.0917009637,
-0.0294985902,
0.0272075329,
-0.0492693037,
-0.0120647801,
-0.0372842103,
0.0628994405,
0.0171673931,
-0.0828126222,
0.0509216078,
0.0084753633,
-0.00811092,
-0.0386163108,
-0.0304210484,
0.0721317083,
0.0221744552,
-0.0158094987,
0.0289457142,
-0.0163565669,
-0.0313351303,
0.0088044032,
0.0064603738,
0.0104034543,
0.0245643053,
-0.0312848426,
-0.0045274906,
0.0046950742,
-0.0062117022,
-0.0602763183,
-0.0544614196,
0.0093716253,
0.0107268412,
0.0175925158,
0.0289452877,
-0.0006866063,
0.050156679,
-0.0084999735,
-0.0012105453,
-0.0396288261,
-0.0360347629,
0.0100509934,
0.0247063357,
0.0706239492,
0.0125232255,
-0.0138015198,
-0.0410125703,
-0.0336798467,
-0.0577232726,
-0.0078551825,
-0.0250720717,
0.0121526858,
0.018146988,
0.002819587,
-0.0291050393,
0.0032603031,
-0.0546613671,
-0.0013814323,
-0.053693559,
0.0203986503,
0.0170042533,
-0.0014650812,
0.0089617735,
-0.0305871461,
-0.0027353365,
0.0216418896,
0.0182445999,
0.004276487,
-0.0496919379,
0.040201325,
-0.0134777948,
-0.003820406,
0.0357528925,
0.0474388599,
-0.0209026299,
0.0098675806,
-0.0383521467,
0.0302202478,
0.0386935137,
-0.0310977399,
0.0631767213,
-0.0010400966,
-0.0285686888,
0.0111765554,
0.0141623467,
-0.0299473088,
0.0171934441,
0.0492024831,
0.0178047381,
-0.0200066157,
0.0032542914,
0.0511913896,
-0.026110854,
0.0297847334,
0.0338754952,
-0.0478542596,
-0.0393423624,
0.0136320535,
-0.0229721982,
0.0425329171,
-0.0391054265,
0.0140394503,
-0.0571151786,
-0.0510866046,
0.0200442635,
-0.0104433494,
-0.0391708277,
0.0283925757,
0.0118943779,
0.0629028678,
0.0495046563,
-0.0082011363,
-0.0684761181,
0.0323795304,
-0.0341353081,
-0.0225639511,
0.0375664346,
-6.290491245e-33,
-0.004434803,
-0.0322277062,
-0.0090103121,
0.0095156357,
-0.0190216266,
0.0343711115,
-0.0268693101,
-0.0169206355,
0.0049809157,
0.03363166,
0.0168919191,
-0.0213285163,
0.0039432459,
0.0316848978,
-0.0462339967,
0.0060817781,
0.0190940946,
-0.0033245883,
-0.0345715843,
0.0306489244,
0.004041933,
0.0713138133,
0.0466534458,
-0.1034357771,
0.0492413379,
0.0023483683,
0.0438885614,
0.0308039561,
0.0644240677,
0.0552247725,
-0.0657099038,
0.0407412872,
0.041423656,
-0.0249813516,
0.0204760041,
0.0191519149,
-0.1329104751,
-0.0421418771,
0.0101170978,
-0.0252462197,
-0.0530599952,
0.0121358763,
0.0523869544,
-0.0281445738,
0.0246884469,
-0.0088471146,
0.0330812521,
-0.0133489966,
0.0432780609,
-0.0170655344,
-0.0536861941,
0.0400953107,
0.0320553482,
0.0001505621,
0.0127724465,
-0.0098341927,
-0.001680519,
0.0552950799,
-0.0249464158,
0.0010712921,
-0.0516382605,
0.0405716971,
0.0233842097,
-0.0476957932,
-0.0280674249,
0.0449534208,
-0.0480544046,
-0.0025956582,
-0.033615917,
0.0375553891,
-0.0640199855,
0.0514538325,
0.004663635,
0.0339518599,
0.0046061981,
-0.0329465009,
-0.0998593643,
0.0101580927,
-0.0021974323,
0.0023322233,
-0.008582972,
-0.0405805968,
-0.0440698378,
0.0278722998,
0.0016748147,
0.0098640164,
0.0005469515,
-0.0290902145,
-0.0233415253,
0.0022825452,
-0.023323657,
0.0531754084,
-0.0403398201,
-0.023441324,
-0.012368734,
0.0101738656,
0.0333013572,
-0.0148078268,
-0.0560442023,
0.0202072337,
-0.057927575,
0.0124889435,
-0.0076362868,
0.00493292,
0.0304963626,
0.0059438557,
0.0195615739,
-0.0432107002,
-0.0293906592,
-0.0240507163,
-0.0156533737,
0.0233484171,
-0.0363706686,
0.055172611,
0.033131633,
0.0651174858,
-0.0189616233,
0.0609193593,
0.0475214124,
0.0312175471,
-0.0290905647,
-0.0162565336,
0.0299204495,
-0.001364622,
-0.0403662473,
-0.0390747525,
-0.005068806,
0.0238955021,
0.0055126273,
-0.0554754995,
0.0054960218,
-0.0503052063,
2.641e-7,
0.0917092711,
0.0441425107,
0.0116726086,
-0.0347239897,
0.0565063879,
-0.0020691608,
0.0154579403,
-0.0075446367,
0.0188217405,
-0.0298010837,
-0.0224529132,
0.0351679623,
0.001264386,
0.0213320795,
-0.0332483724,
-0.0490403287,
-0.0458639599,
-0.0734940246,
-0.0240562763,
-0.0094362665,
0.0629195794,
0.047841318,
-0.0003266493,
-0.0070064547,
-0.0731367916,
-0.0097825667,
0.0345526338,
-0.0141034452,
-0.0473067164,
0.0525106415,
0.0184246637,
0.0252669603,
-0.0109975366,
0.0066260034,
-0.0365654603,
0.0031976828,
0.0484325811,
0.0848380402,
-0.0376896001,
-0.0024783658,
0.0018367791,
0.0025753235,
0.0318549238,
-0.0207487158,
0.0768586472,
-0.0789741501,
-0.0680799782,
-0.0671933144,
-0.011142456,
-0.0044973367,
0.015753448,
-0.0117770489,
-0.0532634184,
0.0539832152,
0.0242937487,
0.0341398492,
-0.0581720732,
-0.0954198316,
-0.0086918352,
0.0269765295,
-0.0083024614,
-0.0184778534,
0.064543575,
-0.0358585641,
-0.0299841836,
-0.0715134814,
0.0338439792,
2.086519003e-34,
-0.0161290132,
0.0541447476,
-0.0279348716,
-0.0015369891,
0.0240058061,
-0.0117266225,
-0.0115588047,
-0.0012729347,
-0.010832007,
-0.0358410701,
0.0222931635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13867v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13867v3 | Transferring Procedural Knowledge across Commonsense Tasks | 2023-04-26T23:24:50 | 2023-11-20T04:09:25 | Yifan Jiang, Filip Ilievski, Kaixin Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stories about everyday situations are an essential part of human
communication, motivating the need to develop AI agents that can reliably
understand these stories. Despite the long list of supervised methods for story
completion and procedural understanding, current AI has no mechanisms to
automatically track and explain procedures in unseen stories. To bridge this
gap, we study the ability of AI models to transfer procedural knowledge to
novel narrative tasks in a transparent manner. We design LEAP: a comprehensive
framework that integrates state-of-the-art modeling architectures, training
regimes, and augmentation strategies based on both natural and synthetic
stories. To address the lack of densely annotated training data, we devise a
robust automatic labeler based on few-shot prompting to enhance the augmented
data. Our experiments with in- and out-of-domain tasks reveal insights into the
interplay of different architectures, training regimes, and augmentation
strategies. LEAP's labeler has a clear positive impact on out-of-domain
datasets, while the resulting dense annotation provides native explainability. | [
0.0236433465,
0.0301931035,
-0.0256079566,
0.0136178657,
0.0130798714,
0.0251728483,
0.0134940911,
-0.0145242987,
0.0137612149,
-0.0168141555,
0.0270086639,
0.0037819138,
0.0099737691,
0.1016725302,
-0.0073182243,
-0.0638197511,
0.0051743863,
-0.0002468779,
0.049987331,
0.0431855842,
-0.0002942907,
0.0248361472,
-0.0341400094,
0.0491505265,
-0.0223895106,
0.0070002861,
-0.0522717051,
-0.0089405421,
0.0407744534,
-0.0398194119,
-0.0311629903,
0.011849992,
0.0718626603,
-0.0301375277,
0.0000019377,
-0.0343960375,
0.0211113635,
-0.0100177722,
-0.0511538498,
-0.0414981022,
-0.0027776998,
-0.0198412985,
0.0118973488,
-0.0249292552,
-0.0266686976,
0.0233027954,
0.0490500703,
0.0739568025,
0.0367904417,
0.057563372,
-0.0141042965,
-0.0292157028,
-0.0060343305,
0.0048460667,
0.0400399119,
-0.0355504341,
-0.0198400617,
0.0008726291,
0.0488340482,
0.0016584342,
-0.021224957,
0.0051890584,
0.0470558703,
-0.0165078044,
0.0432664528,
0.0848092064,
0.0087578148,
-0.0024859693,
-0.017150715,
0.1007561386,
0.0193951111,
-0.0167503003,
-0.0043637101,
-0.0100761103,
0.031014733,
-0.0108270245,
-0.0735990107,
0.0240938123,
-0.0241568275,
0.0030462581,
-0.0147663038,
0.0221896656,
0.0181674697,
-0.0056476216,
0.0386696197,
0.0098352134,
-0.025967462,
0.0265067257,
-0.0479744896,
-0.0069851242,
0.0098837288,
-0.0879135057,
0.0067967945,
0.0791113079,
-0.0188708398,
0.0114291701,
-0.0424861349,
0.0401902832,
-0.0322233215,
0.0088020219,
0.0455671288,
0.0491675064,
-0.038745787,
0.0381760485,
-0.0116073638,
0.0317610316,
0.0306704808,
0.0091469893,
-0.0249299072,
0.0090029547,
-0.0776216388,
0.0093432637,
-0.0354648605,
0.0404704586,
-0.0768904984,
-0.019795984,
0.0190274157,
0.0225962158,
0.0119487848,
0.0148246428,
-0.0063221375,
0.0354861654,
-0.0531898104,
-0.00451764,
-0.0441470034,
0.0123845218,
-0.0866832286,
0.021764094,
0.0577254258,
-0.0288560037,
-0.056055665,
-0.0215499997,
0.0445063449,
0.0068453113,
-0.0158290919,
0.0463689715,
-0.033010073,
-0.0388849266,
-0.0593368858,
-0.028962126,
0.0053694393,
-0.0699635074,
-0.0442925543,
-0.0215121266,
0.0562268905,
-0.0234045777,
0.0069636051,
-0.0199374352,
0.0204737466,
0.0002075948,
-0.0330910794,
0.0643692911,
-0.046351485,
0.0024765057,
0.0081020165,
0.035212893,
-0.0148937805,
0.0179662164,
0.0432671197,
0.026521422,
0.0273121297,
0.0100077661,
0.0666698292,
-0.0373402573,
-0.0116571477,
-0.0118200155,
0.0182143115,
-0.0127409743,
-0.0270949658,
0.0528421402,
0.0410902724,
-0.0082232887,
-0.0449097306,
0.0059334808,
0.0638077781,
0.0622898787,
-0.0141716236,
-0.019265214,
0.0773704872,
0.0179262552,
-0.0021266947,
0.027684141,
-0.0698922202,
0.0695551708,
-0.0133678336,
-0.0201222394,
-0.0444601066,
-0.007522346,
-0.0485578813,
-0.0395736955,
0.0293940809,
-0.0193957388,
0.0139551368,
-0.0077559329,
0.0207884405,
0.0298443995,
-0.0326554142,
-0.0257866699,
0.0198400207,
-0.0613244772,
0.0150360819,
-0.0245136395,
0.0410057046,
0.1179375425,
0.0139916232,
-0.0196805205,
-0.0373651907,
-0.03160033,
0.0359216295,
0.0125672212,
0.0159994811,
-0.0332448632,
0.0812409595,
-0.0195225552,
-0.0103296079,
-0.0731317997,
0.0193293691,
0.0234360863,
0.004887626,
-0.0090926802,
-0.0162608325,
-0.0560739934,
-0.0391116366,
0.0453847572,
-0.0542865433,
-0.0375662334,
-0.0016065191,
-0.0056655435,
-0.0289160665,
0.0290086418,
0.006251846,
-0.0239848066,
0.0325111151,
-0.0162250549,
-0.0073610563,
0.0696096942,
-0.0484972782,
-0.0622055419,
-0.002037545,
-0.0364516899,
-0.0274882633,
-0.0430054925,
-0.0142212091,
-0.0671923757,
0.0145818768,
-0.0470701642,
0.0115502309,
-0.0220066924,
-0.0167916343,
0.0289055556,
-0.0415846333,
0.0162579939,
0.0651709288,
0.0153166493,
-0.0158186276,
-0.0148830824,
0.0227339752,
-0.0062214881,
-0.0171458144,
0.0399833769,
-0.0000471882,
0.0098539311,
-0.027943749,
0.0121826213,
-0.0328184851,
-0.0401118845,
0.020074876,
-0.0834797919,
-0.013034516,
0.0050734947,
-0.0302696973,
0.0225451961,
0.0114097521,
-0.0124715688,
-0.0370316245,
-0.0352237821,
0.0260967314,
-0.0167202987,
-0.0155836521,
0.0312810913,
0.0707893893,
-0.02498243,
-0.0341365822,
0.0444764271,
-0.0014829548,
0.0390705243,
0.0588439479,
0.0064917197,
-0.0864492282,
-0.0096498085,
-0.0083521111,
0.0334187448,
-0.0525724217,
-0.0181377381,
0.0225696322,
-0.0109515749,
0.0070914752,
0.0482962914,
-0.0158175062,
0.0293358751,
0.0601681583,
-0.0387240425,
-0.0357669927,
0.026758397,
-0.0178990886,
0.030075334,
-0.0419179983,
-0.0295295399,
-0.012403802,
0.0750104338,
-0.0139327906,
0.0450630859,
-0.0635534897,
0.0033116532,
0.0383272395,
-0.0416658558,
-0.0206354,
-0.0452588946,
-0.0089987358,
0.0716788471,
-0.0401687622,
-0.0259951949,
0.0987097248,
-0.0296276268,
-0.0262284931,
-0.0053761788,
-0.0373704098,
-0.0091394112,
0.0906490907,
-0.0118063409,
0.0259322692,
0.0336360969,
-0.0099168979,
-0.0167789347,
0.01790132,
0.0337265842,
0.0042810943,
0.0181678999,
-0.076162532,
-0.0201003663,
0.0398467742,
-0.0353660397,
-0.041779153,
-0.0345846489,
-0.0255192444,
0.006819407,
-0.0131986784,
-0.0439751968,
-0.0408017635,
-0.0025101851,
0.0262530781,
0.0856842771,
-0.0111477319,
-0.0220808703,
-0.0340862609,
0.0126591939,
0.0526685007,
0.0259575173,
-0.0072182245,
-0.0090939803,
0.0568994209,
0.0284029059,
0.0379423127,
-0.0345045887,
-0.0025870481,
0.0325722545,
-0.0177830625,
-0.0374988504,
-0.0125006577,
0.0466613509,
0.0929512754,
-0.0653711706,
-0.0450893752,
0.0837426037,
0.0284268372,
-0.0223993659,
0.0291857924,
-0.012913784,
0.0101948697,
0.0295051988,
0.0161078814,
-0.060675621,
-0.0307900328,
0.0092904754,
0.0162283406,
0.0057680444,
-0.0729888901,
-0.0182489995,
-0.1061047837,
0.0555016808,
-0.0174889341,
-0.059691634,
-0.0405554809,
-0.0365104266,
0.0094470493,
0.0219980087,
-0.0127739487,
0.0049334723,
-0.0053256191,
-0.0067465794,
-0.0078968741,
0.0058575692,
-0.0442944169,
0.020136172,
-0.0526011102,
0.0697263554,
0.030822454,
0.0401888303,
0.0179750826,
0.015601147,
-0.0379063077,
0.0186776817,
0.0426212773,
0.0238257721,
0.0791660547,
-0.019726431,
0.011065268,
-0.0192921627,
0.0760709345,
-0.0204419419,
-0.0703387111,
0.001561261,
0.0448889956,
-0.0252839681,
-0.0050183102,
0.0090757497,
0.0307764243,
0.0338619165,
0.0753770098,
0.0450716652,
-0.0089386916,
-0.0147676244,
-0.0322420299,
-0.0030760448,
-0.065769434,
0.0041486169,
0.0170614794,
-0.0214788411,
-0.0231275316,
-0.0766895115,
-0.0812208429,
0.0510515645,
0.0437567048,
0.016854234,
-0.0218688194,
-0.0061225877,
-0.0027154062,
-0.0479836836,
0.0429092497,
-0.0353647657,
0.0013888268,
0.0217025336,
-0.0156125119,
-0.0080665359,
-0.0541897416,
0.0140806669,
0.0306889489,
-0.0438493527,
-0.0177966151,
-0.034967158,
0.0434132628,
0.0229588654,
0.0907620639,
-0.0206105877,
-0.0337523408,
-0.0048099081,
0.0164926164,
-0.0721110925,
0.0023512924,
-0.0068444205,
-0.0139550949,
0.0169556905,
0.0148761123,
-0.0326185077,
0.0086065996,
-0.0172296483,
0.0437741913,
-0.0374230109,
-0.0099377614,
0.0525414795,
-0.0416781195,
0.0225931704,
-0.0389057063,
-0.0146803763,
-0.0667191371,
0.0035042774,
-0.0262735337,
-0.0063582743,
-0.0616382994,
0.0232350882,
0.0186428465,
0.0166203938,
0.0124627501,
-0.0016329258,
-0.0463830717,
0.045361761,
-0.0273175277,
-0.0440527759,
0.0298138671,
0.0013734251,
-0.0157157388,
0.0172446687,
-0.005210544,
0.0219974276,
-0.0187964942,
0.0685533062,
-0.0096887844,
0.0677110031,
0.0375586338,
-0.0168077573,
0.0085022869,
0.0189986918,
-0.0618192106,
-0.0240296014,
-0.0240772013,
0.022831494,
0.0224324632,
-0.0187603962,
0.0178287085,
-0.0111179659,
0.0259429328,
0.0297261439,
0.0232660621,
0.0201307889,
-0.040433351,
-0.0091381436,
0.0262502208,
-0.0081123933,
0.0269441586,
0.062772274,
-0.0191210918,
0.0845226645,
-0.0212713983,
-0.0112335682,
-0.0229038876,
-0.0150094917,
0.0123670669,
0.0781593248,
0.0094193975,
0.0061549577,
-0.0439287946,
-0.0180450194,
-0.0116487527,
-0.0041750013,
-0.0187435802,
-0.0201444086,
0.0306189433,
0.0013427589,
-0.0140306624,
-0.0461434834,
-0.0305720754,
-0.0067700916,
0.0203072913,
0.0122441361,
-0.009776338,
-5.993892347e-33,
-0.0459942035,
-0.0414359458,
0.0098844543,
-0.0002290782,
-0.0051571657,
-0.000565444,
-0.0717018992,
-0.0083344411,
0.0100909481,
0.0515186265,
0.0178809464,
0.0209642705,
0.0040822607,
-0.0035212752,
0.0064564538,
-0.0107246395,
0.0278125219,
0.0160613693,
-0.0458629318,
0.0484951846,
0.045860216,
0.0195049681,
0.0522395261,
-0.0630023256,
0.0165628009,
-0.0017371341,
-0.0260920674,
0.0258946475,
0.0376233608,
0.0379577763,
-0.0131426482,
-0.002441314,
0.0212998595,
-0.0216984656,
-0.0013244929,
0.0277510807,
-0.0876751617,
-0.0256178118,
0.0367526747,
-0.0112420339,
-0.0395472422,
-0.0291639827,
-0.0144580891,
-0.0262818448,
0.0375521556,
0.0087031685,
0.0502490662,
-0.0360375419,
0.0383824296,
-0.0025582225,
-0.0740169585,
-0.0036044044,
-0.0243057571,
-0.0739833415,
-0.0158827491,
0.0665087625,
0.015060558,
-0.0231499262,
-0.0370001346,
0.0149566606,
0.003460774,
-0.0011190852,
0.0142745236,
-0.0108587742,
-0.0370279178,
0.0739976093,
0.0314370207,
-0.0027140263,
-0.1002138779,
0.0433310866,
-0.0110556837,
0.055967737,
0.0356183313,
0.0496332496,
0.0285155009,
0.0480023883,
-0.0364613719,
0.0761716887,
-0.0035872366,
0.0253275037,
0.00287756,
0.0249739699,
-0.0323927589,
-0.0132863214,
-0.0353332423,
-0.0071264105,
-0.0108028911,
-0.0180169232,
0.021458758,
0.0159141645,
-0.0001765325,
0.0274222642,
0.0030436679,
-0.0303270835,
0.0413173921,
0.0048459424,
-0.0234466027,
0.0314572379,
0.0060371268,
0.0007534928,
-0.0411990099,
-0.0251171645,
0.085021317,
0.0178662613,
0.0506268442,
0.0195344742,
0.0619550347,
0.0448297784,
-0.0056261928,
0.0103557799,
-0.0483256057,
0.0137671521,
0.0186270513,
-0.0151621727,
0.0119586391,
0.0212136693,
-0.0526605211,
0.0264976546,
-0.0071595199,
0.0209595375,
-0.0390703417,
-0.0084072724,
-0.0041500391,
-0.0022107689,
-0.0146276457,
-0.0104520312,
-0.0209377371,
-0.0303825662,
0.0040027779,
-0.0453657471,
-0.0042731632,
0.0327702165,
2.643e-7,
-0.0201411322,
-0.0004421668,
0.0467741154,
-0.0155644938,
0.0104339505,
0.0322322547,
-0.0182439722,
0.0323165655,
-0.0277303997,
-0.0935021415,
0.041337166,
0.0483922809,
0.030153079,
0.0173540581,
-0.0618699454,
-0.0357382074,
-0.0196350813,
-0.04856034,
-0.0645626187,
-0.0374274999,
0.0543302111,
0.0266739614,
0.0535682589,
-0.0036640775,
0.045988597,
-0.030991694,
0.0438014232,
-0.0376560651,
0.0028799891,
0.0065692295,
-0.0189231653,
0.0242220219,
-0.0380997211,
0.0173100363,
-0.0247454643,
0.0087037496,
-0.0008875348,
0.0597466417,
-0.0593745783,
-0.010832224,
-0.0139961457,
0.0054114531,
0.0110575743,
-0.0343082175,
0.0406319536,
-0.0482146442,
-0.0324306898,
0.0539605096,
-0.0305836443,
0.0069123488,
-0.0548041053,
0.0105888024,
-0.0060319877,
0.0182710122,
0.0077817915,
0.0216415562,
-0.0006869747,
-0.0740180984,
-0.020742286,
0.0333681926,
-0.0246152878,
-0.0126983766,
-0.0169173032,
-0.0515198,
-0.0019518003,
-0.0704615489,
-0.0014173889,
2.118612065e-34,
-0.0162953325,
0.0458462276,
-0.0102592986,
0.0597926155,
0.0510413386,
0.0119604478,
-0.0115264403,
0.0015549581,
0.0531099103,
-0.0408487171,
-0.0264125466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13861v2 | The Parrot Dilemma: Human-Labeled vs. LLM-augmented Data in Classification Tasks | 2023-04-26T23:09:02 | 2024-02-05T14:41:35 | Anders Giovanni Møller, Jacob Aarup Dalsgaard, Arianna Pera, Luca Maria Aiello | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph | In the realm of Computational Social Science (CSS), practitioners often
navigate complex, low-resource domains and face the costly and time-intensive
challenges of acquiring and annotating data. We aim to establish a set of
guidelines to address such challenges, comparing the use of human-labeled data
with synthetically generated data from GPT-4 and Llama-2 in ten distinct CSS
classification tasks of varying complexity. Additionally, we examine the impact
of training data sizes on performance. Our findings reveal that models trained
on human-labeled data consistently exhibit superior or comparable performance
compared to their synthetically augmented counterparts. Nevertheless, synthetic
augmentation proves beneficial, particularly in improving performance on rare
classes within multi-class tasks. Furthermore, we leverage GPT-4 and Llama-2
for zero-shot classification and find that, while they generally display strong
performance, they often fall short when compared to specialized classifiers
trained on moderately sized training sets. | [
0.0304504018,
0.1128588244,
-0.028999567,
-0.0038199127,
0.0077725635,
0.0454621315,
0.0185182169,
-0.0182851255,
-0.0137001909,
-0.0557239205,
-0.0025340826,
0.0087157963,
0.0179170258,
-0.0194431208,
0.0400384106,
-0.0555562116,
0.0483170748,
0.0241670478,
-0.0206773859,
0.0056161946,
-0.0351492204,
-0.0154037289,
0.0201559141,
0.0234384425,
-0.0243897308,
0.0275749154,
-0.0315412357,
-0.0088783614,
0.0375835374,
-0.0504510365,
0.0244944114,
0.0201219749,
0.0272880681,
0.0580541827,
0.0000020851,
-0.0532774255,
0.0194824468,
-0.0052072308,
-0.0670514703,
0.0188731533,
0.0486724451,
-0.0223369747,
0.0242462903,
0.0206216145,
-0.0285493825,
-0.0445819497,
0.0558040515,
0.0270874184,
0.0039260923,
0.067547977,
0.0007092206,
-0.0354645997,
0.0482723899,
-0.0275375415,
0.0587427504,
-0.0139072901,
0.0476380177,
-0.0165245403,
-0.0035089192,
0.0281600729,
-0.0116654094,
0.0019108324,
0.0228342395,
0.0114721656,
0.056170512,
0.0736679882,
-0.0630408973,
-0.0207588784,
-0.0010832784,
0.0577373356,
0.0123785529,
-0.0020244592,
-0.0026634724,
-0.0071004974,
0.0205334108,
-0.023357749,
-0.0249843299,
0.0139516583,
0.005268842,
0.0372455157,
-0.0084646624,
0.0063348995,
0.0422187485,
0.0397068597,
0.0006058614,
0.0453143939,
-0.0301125385,
0.0038323016,
0.0147205358,
0.0408177041,
0.0037288736,
-0.0362797305,
-0.0222597569,
0.0256528128,
0.0162252411,
-0.0128298812,
-0.0248512439,
0.0069126519,
0.0373692364,
-0.0281096008,
0.0322562605,
0.0418754108,
-0.0456729308,
0.0248903912,
-0.0108122453,
0.0015801106,
-0.0008454675,
0.0556955487,
0.0250168387,
-0.0158578102,
-0.090589188,
0.0103127295,
0.0100812167,
0.0461357348,
0.0059722587,
0.0458366461,
-0.0786779672,
-0.0029223862,
-0.0167758185,
-0.0022942801,
-0.0343165025,
0.0205065571,
-0.0270467978,
0.0459662452,
-0.038687598,
-0.0113592073,
-0.0035514231,
0.0648389682,
0.0095489025,
-0.0738175288,
0.0056891171,
0.0150957061,
0.0428074114,
-0.0032261899,
0.0296605583,
0.0514621362,
0.0136730066,
-0.0422741584,
-0.0568254776,
0.0133295516,
-0.0155097907,
-0.0618983582,
0.016400015,
-0.0413883813,
0.0262091812,
-0.0241405256,
-0.0116460482,
0.0019348594,
-0.0089242421,
-0.0156548917,
-0.0321737789,
0.0942426622,
-0.0693136007,
-0.0060077296,
0.0404311344,
0.0069322409,
0.0038395643,
0.0826705769,
0.0482963659,
0.0276114475,
0.0224112384,
-0.0372209735,
0.0282056294,
0.0240998492,
-0.0006101241,
0.0004763957,
-0.0265124943,
0.0012848765,
0.0031598529,
-0.0105784144,
0.0636802465,
-0.0164496135,
-0.0154629294,
-0.0187077448,
0.0519008264,
0.0367625616,
-0.022830829,
0.0052249208,
0.0392929055,
0.0041295784,
0.0015043995,
-0.0373288244,
-0.075934954,
0.0325937234,
-0.0527420342,
-0.0172311794,
-0.0285812691,
0.0177920796,
-0.0304949097,
-0.0678174719,
-0.0030227164,
-0.0353471786,
0.009651213,
0.0045682043,
0.0653734729,
-0.037565317,
0.0171112251,
-0.0289443005,
0.0220049713,
-0.0064256229,
-0.0233759712,
-0.0655404478,
0.0164299551,
0.0415778272,
-0.014665843,
-0.0407870077,
-0.03946824,
-0.0398517698,
0.0217122585,
0.0341150016,
0.0316762701,
-0.0020056346,
0.0085673099,
-0.0035358106,
-0.0241217799,
-0.0131302634,
0.0425188504,
0.0308794379,
0.0613396391,
0.0333899893,
0.0217182618,
-0.0407910198,
-0.0446965024,
0.0667779893,
-0.0053726803,
-0.0495571569,
0.0260819383,
-0.0060501797,
0.0323468372,
0.0200202167,
0.0015885389,
-0.0335246883,
0.021187691,
0.0007522909,
-0.0235589165,
-0.0299776252,
0.0107917786,
-0.0241477191,
0.0352635868,
-0.0038004539,
-0.0414782763,
0.0606748648,
-0.0561323538,
-0.015699286,
0.0183595717,
-0.0228624623,
0.0518568605,
-0.0440293066,
0.0027844803,
-0.0320958495,
0.0301871058,
-0.0099557955,
0.051074896,
0.0236845147,
-0.0349104963,
-0.0515357144,
-0.0296062659,
0.0387843773,
-0.0397283733,
0.007614864,
-0.0192661043,
-0.0089848898,
0.0103864325,
-0.0269623678,
-0.000481543,
-0.0550511144,
0.0146949748,
-0.0787675604,
0.0291979648,
0.0035479651,
0.0240497403,
-0.044508338,
-0.032898277,
-0.0291553903,
-0.0042534592,
-0.0209982339,
0.0063059335,
-0.0235359892,
0.0355431437,
0.032106854,
0.0016416336,
-0.0281319767,
-0.023920957,
0.0283213798,
-0.0117392847,
0.0004781121,
0.0380292907,
-0.0363513641,
0.0080119325,
-0.0187534653,
-0.0535806082,
-0.0019381868,
-0.0121579301,
-0.0225480814,
0.00647528,
0.0163275488,
-0.0308526475,
0.0235945638,
-0.0194797069,
0.0169592667,
0.0522619337,
0.0697053447,
-0.0204536058,
0.006507691,
-0.0062359422,
-0.046792917,
0.0091567226,
-0.0147129828,
-0.0416855551,
0.0505193919,
-0.0273091029,
-0.0072018281,
-0.0110369707,
0.0294325221,
0.0230402704,
-0.0392675698,
-0.0600284189,
-0.0045173275,
-0.0207482222,
0.0459672995,
-0.0374603346,
-0.0881271958,
0.0072249346,
0.0178245436,
0.0047299643,
0.0444100983,
-0.022147337,
-0.0422581434,
0.0328792408,
0.0335272439,
-0.0215551741,
-0.0161982328,
0.0236543305,
0.0005228909,
-0.0124609144,
-0.0083752843,
-0.0516153239,
0.0032947485,
-0.0436646864,
0.0154921459,
-0.0540194958,
-0.0415440239,
-0.0520097055,
-0.0172046423,
-0.0502265282,
0.0234816074,
-0.0616255403,
-0.0180051178,
0.0145540694,
-0.0223108474,
0.025185585,
0.0224098843,
-0.0059194374,
-0.0225927662,
0.0081096655,
-0.0078858677,
-0.0101403622,
0.0435024276,
0.0084925834,
-0.0106035294,
-0.0301850419,
-0.0071946937,
0.0375593491,
0.0060408521,
-0.0336458981,
0.0356180258,
-0.0234822705,
-0.0038632608,
-0.0336962715,
-0.0058195787,
0.0478945859,
-0.0492092073,
0.0343525335,
0.0665566474,
0.0241063759,
-0.0391570926,
0.0087200617,
-0.0039978693,
-0.0146862632,
0.0477784127,
0.0191057771,
-0.055357758,
-0.0229510553,
0.0125413118,
0.0211015753,
-0.0459427573,
-0.0587834045,
-0.0048256703,
-0.1126569882,
0.0899150148,
0.0029179349,
-0.07946603,
-0.0003101264,
-0.074203141,
0.0306333527,
-0.0609856248,
-0.0484577119,
-0.0500435606,
-0.0053719119,
0.0168810301,
0.0482926406,
-0.0500925221,
-0.0403265618,
-0.0066184918,
-0.0260853861,
0.0607180931,
0.0298481602,
0.0305286199,
-0.0386501141,
-0.0518430881,
0.0508950241,
-0.0189787224,
-0.0036588202,
0.016453797,
0.0706097633,
-0.0070500937,
0.0013521441,
0.0008513221,
0.0371567979,
0.00384879,
-0.0180688091,
0.025698401,
0.0715653077,
-0.022047393,
0.0006477789,
-0.0183405131,
-0.029889103,
-0.0005600582,
0.0529980175,
0.0396040231,
-0.0197706968,
-0.0158386417,
-0.0368728377,
-0.0344769694,
-0.0709604695,
-0.0120714083,
0.058867529,
-0.0500176139,
-0.1099667326,
-0.01731712,
-0.033237379,
0.0696342066,
0.0048081204,
-0.0225837119,
-0.0217165332,
-0.0219307765,
-0.0128325308,
-0.0551655479,
0.0447482653,
-0.0551422201,
-0.0001876858,
0.0031871262,
-0.0699336678,
0.0343449824,
-0.0206260048,
0.0046556629,
-0.0324790142,
-0.0497766174,
-0.0367867723,
0.020610163,
0.0436821021,
0.0239167716,
0.0256241187,
0.0347660407,
0.0046707746,
0.0655441508,
0.1462277174,
0.0229452252,
0.0329524055,
0.0334373154,
0.039214924,
-0.0099115111,
-0.0013719781,
0.0053590452,
0.0520314462,
0.0343256257,
-0.0599224046,
-0.0550200604,
0.0203257706,
-0.0188045446,
0.0100276973,
0.1079538465,
-0.0454173274,
-0.0425706394,
0.0040334957,
-0.0085029723,
0.0107100466,
0.0158694107,
0.0116134379,
-0.0905469954,
0.0019598696,
0.0526325218,
-0.0344182663,
0.0101292692,
-0.0341292843,
0.0253812876,
-0.047590632,
-0.0101445168,
-0.0078549301,
-0.0019194114,
-0.0298530515,
0.047616329,
-0.0253105666,
0.0280375537,
0.0193027742,
0.0358651914,
0.0057797921,
-0.0054767327,
-0.0023780968,
0.0583831556,
-0.0271420386,
0.0193728451,
-0.0223032348,
-0.0043355487,
-0.0260392502,
0.0587066151,
0.0175908152,
-0.0339251608,
-0.0216562599,
-0.0087190466,
-0.0336140171,
-0.0099012582,
-0.0037957556,
-0.0347498171,
-0.0339321196,
0.0275025144,
0.0066269757,
-0.0516785458,
0.0164511632,
0.0487422906,
0.0627833605,
0.0547231883,
-0.0478720665,
0.0070391721,
-0.0104705151,
0.0240693782,
0.0464907661,
-0.0121154143,
0.0293869302,
-0.007300843,
-0.0735250786,
-0.056445729,
0.0160773061,
-0.0386263542,
-0.0099983253,
-0.0080132466,
0.0011689647,
-0.0135009754,
-0.0412176959,
-0.0164430495,
-0.040405497,
-0.0311213303,
-0.0014399792,
0.0039057941,
0.0231670551,
-6.653116559e-33,
-0.0141345048,
-0.0518103093,
0.0049244394,
0.0136353718,
-0.0235028416,
0.0058160066,
-0.0039416659,
0.0019689493,
-0.0029961481,
0.0056171068,
-0.013462483,
-0.0163488798,
0.0055807475,
0.0018492748,
0.0636628941,
-0.0097683929,
0.0207121037,
-0.0312578417,
-0.0115314499,
0.0045976019,
-0.0078078313,
-0.0065563279,
0.0478535257,
-0.0900347009,
0.0045169331,
0.0354518257,
0.0021610924,
-0.0213685427,
-0.0059606857,
0.0279395953,
-0.0278249439,
0.0679799393,
0.0464512967,
-0.0204790626,
0.0237374976,
0.0044478327,
-0.0539304279,
-0.0320509598,
-0.0142491646,
-0.001386145,
-0.0175565314,
-0.0508165546,
0.0455883741,
0.0124683576,
-0.0142356418,
-0.0109212343,
0.0444798842,
-0.0618030056,
0.0008714485,
-0.0040242854,
-0.0379011966,
0.040072348,
-0.0218251701,
0.0145112379,
-0.0031039892,
0.0265635476,
-0.0035570452,
0.0715934336,
-0.0633534268,
0.0225677341,
0.0537712947,
-0.0513611548,
0.0434421822,
0.0643631443,
0.0422859713,
0.0445620269,
0.0613722652,
0.0108854091,
-0.0402257666,
-0.0176901724,
0.0244679768,
0.0181523766,
0.052252572,
0.0903405175,
0.07410115,
-0.0378209278,
-0.067799978,
0.0615467876,
0.0205102339,
-0.0427240916,
-0.0585923083,
0.0354129896,
-0.0157017112,
-0.0028314709,
0.0100356592,
-0.0340986438,
-0.0114748534,
0.0071011521,
0.0016250976,
0.0199876092,
-0.0520361438,
0.0633426234,
0.0191883016,
-0.0032089718,
-0.0119190607,
-0.0770169944,
0.0097579276,
0.0373244919,
0.0484638587,
-0.0516474508,
-0.0596949868,
-0.0379983597,
0.0358527675,
0.0433320664,
0.0753986314,
-0.0039265519,
0.0768852755,
0.0163519755,
-0.0657710433,
0.0161041208,
-0.01460067,
0.0300008487,
0.0200215317,
-0.006191229,
0.0214604158,
-0.0103185438,
0.0258934535,
0.022801837,
0.040017996,
0.0114005161,
-0.0198468268,
0.0051518716,
-0.0620631389,
0.0020551148,
-0.0095267873,
-0.0005361434,
0.0308704264,
0.0147479689,
-0.0353240371,
-0.0711510181,
-0.0106079541,
-0.0368644334,
2.842e-7,
0.036096815,
0.0346301347,
0.0097601134,
-0.0430150256,
0.0291583706,
0.0396636054,
-0.0306584556,
0.0282703619,
-0.0313404612,
-0.0731569901,
0.0329052284,
0.0423936844,
0.0562638566,
0.0142532382,
-0.0608732849,
-0.0037432685,
-0.0065511293,
0.0103362361,
-0.0622366145,
0.0265153982,
0.0216437094,
0.0830106661,
0.044355534,
-0.0330203325,
0.0349527858,
-0.0149088809,
0.0429841988,
-0.0286916532,
-0.0122952256,
-0.0233673751,
0.030401377,
0.0870025307,
-0.0119595462,
0.0562021695,
-0.0306999218,
0.0136106024,
-0.0233779065,
0.0436707884,
-0.0404510573,
0.0048059984,
-0.013493198,
0.0084948316,
0.0171919353,
-0.0547090508,
0.1008126065,
-0.0511129349,
-0.0429775156,
-0.0079898275,
-0.0287145618,
0.0141732544,
0.0603020228,
-0.0177683588,
0.0289838165,
0.0008144961,
-0.0043439912,
-0.0376238562,
-0.0369689763,
-0.0488163941,
0.0166440364,
-0.0019681284,
-0.048909869,
-0.0646546409,
0.0078258952,
0.0149393994,
0.0429722331,
-0.022152815,
0.0021545987,
2.212820131e-34,
0.0037807045,
0.009465565,
0.0152891958,
-0.0459308811,
-0.0138754863,
0.0263188817,
-0.0018310696,
-0.0192328244,
0.0137174381,
-0.0166003574,
0.0429849401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13846v1 | Extracting Structured Seed-Mediated Gold Nanorod Growth Procedures from Literature with GPT-3 | 2023-04-26T22:21:33 | 2023-04-26T22:21:33 | Nicholas Walker, John Dagdelen, Kevin Cruse, Sanghoon Lee, Samuel Gleason, Alexander Dunn, Gerbrand Ceder, A. Paul Alivisatos, Kristin A. Persson, Anubhav Jain | physics.app-ph | physics.app-ph, cs.CL, cs.IR | Although gold nanorods have been the subject of much research, the pathways
for controlling their shape and thereby their optical properties remain largely
heuristically understood. Although it is apparent that the simultaneous
presence of and interaction between various reagents during synthesis control
these properties, computational and experimental approaches for exploring the
synthesis space can be either intractable or too time-consuming in practice.
This motivates an alternative approach leveraging the wealth of synthesis
information already embedded in the body of scientific literature by developing
tools to extract relevant structured data in an automated, high-throughput
manner. To that end, we present an approach using the powerful GPT-3 language
model to extract structured multi-step seed-mediated growth procedures and
outcomes for gold nanorods from unstructured scientific text. GPT-3 prompt
completions are fine-tuned to predict synthesis templates in the form of JSON
documents from unstructured text input with an overall accuracy of $86\%$. The
performance is notable, considering the model is performing simultaneous entity
recognition and relation extraction. We present a dataset of 11,644 entities
extracted from 1,137 papers, resulting in 268 papers with at least one complete
seed-mediated gold nanorod growth procedure and outcome for a total of 332
complete procedures. | [
0.0687224418,
0.0601979271,
-0.0131008178,
0.0365715809,
-0.0156353954,
-0.0171373263,
-0.0037899239,
0.0324354097,
0.0134405466,
-0.0345307365,
0.0172353666,
0.0219954029,
-0.02477674,
0.0532529578,
0.0095630828,
-0.0423335209,
0.0385242216,
-0.0144512793,
0.0500091985,
-0.0004874848,
-0.0124462731,
0.0469536297,
0.0220566187,
-0.0028309415,
0.0329350755,
-0.0325821638,
-0.0100707253,
-0.0181034841,
0.0507857092,
-0.039091412,
-0.0205260515,
0.0236385632,
-0.0412674695,
0.0287124831,
0.0000021981,
-0.0624894612,
-0.0362818614,
0.0552117527,
0.0532104298,
0.0416537561,
0.0752818286,
-0.0452864654,
-0.0033330671,
-0.0026125803,
-0.0396289751,
-0.0261328723,
-0.0071837385,
0.0281931963,
-0.0310876984,
-0.0055994117,
-0.0314045623,
-0.0401334874,
0.1289448738,
0.0090982514,
0.0036231182,
-0.0291144997,
0.0325144753,
0.0089540323,
0.0257231928,
0.0967704803,
0.0175067559,
0.0454117507,
-0.0271262098,
-0.0140130352,
0.0552795976,
0.0086526237,
-0.0302307326,
-0.0291430093,
-0.0000029841,
0.0433011763,
0.0120109767,
-0.0367833078,
-0.0146024581,
-0.0111221718,
-0.0605511516,
0.0322926082,
-0.030954795,
0.0211391058,
-0.0155458488,
0.0114263752,
-0.0049688239,
-0.031042099,
0.0092764851,
0.0110488078,
0.0357095525,
0.0153157823,
0.0057966858,
-0.0265556592,
-0.0202984437,
-0.0158138312,
-0.0391349532,
-0.0157125946,
0.0193006657,
0.0099386899,
0.0778310448,
0.0046866429,
0.0025087157,
0.0090051051,
0.0372072905,
0.0340544172,
0.0542526916,
0.0212439317,
-0.0388762839,
0.0599277094,
-0.0533813685,
-0.0157162901,
-0.0068561384,
-0.0126365898,
-0.0081854379,
-0.0622083656,
-0.0094672367,
-0.0347064212,
-0.0310401432,
0.0117778257,
-0.0154928351,
-0.042645894,
-0.0159005672,
-0.0036382237,
0.0445070043,
0.0258675683,
0.0087545319,
0.0149871502,
-0.0376570113,
-0.0247404557,
0.0061123543,
0.0147636114,
0.0295923874,
-0.0343875289,
-0.0206549745,
-0.0047287215,
-0.0394154638,
-0.0173726492,
0.0445173457,
-0.0070112618,
-0.0111627663,
0.0817353353,
0.0061816936,
-0.0601948835,
0.0056354939,
-0.0676807687,
0.0151737314,
-0.0232409462,
0.0009511543,
-0.0107024051,
0.081391789,
0.0252867788,
-0.012639449,
-0.0551371947,
0.0238867849,
-0.0063022356,
-0.0203364473,
0.0415880233,
-0.0815354809,
-0.0465157367,
0.0240972303,
0.013361061,
0.0453924425,
-0.0456637703,
0.0139169255,
0.0638820976,
0.0110592814,
-0.0428329818,
0.0190109089,
-0.0048667896,
0.024622906,
-0.0693253875,
0.0209196154,
-0.0173825026,
0.0246055666,
-0.0043209437,
0.0054918174,
0.0240758192,
0.0137566105,
0.0183023214,
0.0286859926,
0.0933088437,
-0.0177166909,
0.0262949225,
0.0389871709,
0.0055277282,
0.06113993,
-0.0114548337,
0.0080423849,
0.0244738646,
-0.0878764093,
0.0043445225,
0.0363289192,
0.0760565028,
0.0343106426,
-0.0095931124,
-0.0332231298,
0.001211153,
-0.0276018605,
-0.0825868398,
0.0612961724,
0.0109458277,
-0.0513021313,
-0.0417488776,
0.040197175,
-0.0147201223,
0.0223324168,
-0.0085991668,
0.0140546635,
0.0154113229,
0.0838756263,
-0.0474085324,
-0.012815685,
0.0321140066,
-0.0475829616,
0.0511134528,
-0.036593955,
-0.0276435502,
-0.0015501579,
-0.0274777785,
-0.0283885989,
0.0144865308,
-0.0102157788,
0.0084236702,
0.0696961284,
-0.0047370926,
0.0202775449,
-0.00279987,
0.0152318235,
0.0379700884,
-0.0239404868,
-0.0661386251,
0.0137651544,
-0.0529702082,
0.0451993756,
0.0036614418,
0.0109620495,
0.001914629,
0.0601894222,
0.0266692471,
-0.0384823456,
-0.0067270254,
0.0516613647,
-0.0003325285,
-0.0091684451,
-0.0028535931,
0.0481877737,
-0.0273279846,
-0.0222297069,
-0.0073157428,
0.0650402158,
0.0287776254,
0.0603201762,
0.0002345258,
-0.0334591009,
0.0262773465,
0.0484166704,
-0.0363442078,
0.0483883806,
0.0179400016,
0.0112056099,
-0.047041703,
-0.0006413329,
0.0084138727,
-0.0427935161,
0.0276878886,
-0.0245315209,
0.0262248293,
0.0032682722,
0.0494625345,
-0.0223099105,
-0.0079068523,
-0.0211361255,
-0.0132204173,
-0.0276183337,
0.0364028178,
0.0052500279,
0.0164827742,
-0.0218142904,
-0.0215508454,
0.0070863306,
0.0546831116,
-0.0187216215,
-0.0054237014,
-0.0497133099,
0.032210879,
-0.0018762172,
-0.022326991,
-0.0414754786,
-0.0220469721,
-0.0641964227,
0.0124348896,
0.0538135543,
0.0286519453,
-0.0037378347,
-0.0078884745,
0.0017350703,
0.0405074172,
0.0019116504,
-0.0147542115,
0.0043374402,
-0.0152390702,
0.0172993969,
0.0436418541,
0.0180078521,
0.0556068756,
0.0168572962,
-0.0039413269,
-0.0176967252,
-0.0080200229,
-0.0256689023,
0.0698051453,
0.0790686756,
-0.0226229355,
0.0781781301,
0.0505080558,
0.0181287266,
0.0372401811,
-0.0563902855,
0.0660073757,
0.002923219,
-0.0203328226,
0.0371022299,
0.0203459952,
0.0447274819,
0.0220467616,
0.0145874163,
-0.0240615252,
0.0436830744,
-0.0588845499,
-0.0103039443,
-0.0453874208,
-0.0182977188,
-0.0037012999,
0.0282015949,
0.065677397,
0.0401650704,
0.0317124203,
0.0313334279,
0.0054142931,
0.0100431563,
0.0503311008,
-0.0040766182,
-0.0211078376,
-0.0418906808,
0.018729711,
-0.0010993914,
-0.0281569958,
0.0009255203,
-0.0182986576,
0.0397792608,
0.0374293998,
0.0453642495,
-0.0362357944,
-0.0287876539,
0.0454419218,
0.0262112357,
0.0000070855,
-0.015138993,
-0.0162395239,
-0.0690813512,
0.0608876981,
0.0301178098,
-0.1182259917,
-0.0277112853,
-0.0226955712,
0.0157299172,
0.0525161549,
-0.0054940004,
-0.0071504358,
-0.0142253172,
-0.0006042387,
0.0182137378,
0.0009260458,
-0.0326276906,
-0.00553498,
-0.0262204707,
-0.0381541401,
0.0006954076,
0.0471682586,
0.0437586084,
-0.0319257155,
0.0053069713,
0.0456569903,
-0.0379881635,
-0.0362758972,
0.0199141596,
-0.0793542638,
0.0057370788,
-0.0299337879,
-0.0082587851,
-0.0068245735,
-0.0335460231,
-0.0464569405,
-0.0525643639,
0.0591563396,
-0.019963067,
-0.087323457,
-0.0208832938,
-0.0395645872,
0.0040899869,
0.0068578054,
-0.0189046692,
0.0442269593,
-0.0453701392,
0.0021945133,
-0.0060267947,
-0.0655682161,
-0.082037203,
0.0008122054,
0.0492169149,
0.0023468777,
0.0847771838,
0.0393657871,
0.0064737997,
0.013768713,
0.0046491921,
0.02205633,
-0.022988053,
-0.067884773,
0.0443599075,
0.0173453204,
-0.0118001513,
0.0215766132,
0.0407690555,
-0.0107512996,
-0.071239315,
0.0258184858,
0.0648270547,
0.0236123316,
0.0001402547,
-0.0495198742,
-0.0092234779,
-0.0146198776,
0.048600018,
-0.0091703907,
-0.0075952639,
-0.0775553212,
-0.0209756121,
0.0536733344,
-0.0449459963,
0.0008975232,
-0.049481038,
0.0020496172,
0.1041540504,
-0.0426183119,
-0.0569536202,
-0.0031225591,
-0.0093259038,
0.0260384511,
0.0117997956,
0.0059266705,
-0.0193146188,
-0.0410314314,
-0.0027341419,
-0.0131150177,
-0.0464700386,
-0.0298900828,
-0.0737321079,
0.0184887778,
-0.0089148628,
-0.042842444,
0.0400626995,
0.0147491051,
-0.0328592099,
-0.0111581748,
0.0066207214,
0.0264169853,
-0.0106621003,
0.0016239975,
-0.0138421329,
0.0142910248,
0.0175687354,
-0.0083101308,
-0.0247154348,
-0.0334827937,
0.01060782,
-0.0438001193,
-0.039296601,
0.0275067966,
0.0364814401,
-0.0032834937,
-0.0070675192,
-0.0256722067,
-0.0515769236,
0.0585187711,
0.0051390808,
0.0674932003,
0.0219918322,
0.0904228538,
-0.0474238619,
-0.0422655568,
0.0089841951,
0.0349911228,
-0.0635626242,
-0.0129970824,
0.0020790612,
-0.0421732627,
-0.0376989692,
0.0125641339,
-0.0089978334,
-0.0228567868,
-0.0676584765,
-0.0237219911,
-0.0361160822,
0.0119013358,
0.0651917532,
-0.0503915176,
-0.0161549523,
-0.0008332232,
-0.0350239053,
0.0250392742,
-0.044329457,
0.0326099284,
0.0257087126,
0.0583790168,
-0.0009122718,
0.0294885822,
-0.066665493,
-0.0241455436,
-0.0955860615,
0.0099998089,
0.0425384603,
-0.0490470491,
0.0589972362,
-0.0738618299,
-0.0437550433,
-0.0131290639,
0.0527281798,
0.0136089195,
0.0090075806,
0.005954945,
0.023313405,
-0.0332774967,
-0.0581498034,
0.084055908,
0.0284222756,
0.0082543558,
-0.0047702435,
-0.0151144303,
-0.0349204354,
-0.0452568121,
0.01979132,
-0.0156939793,
0.001823015,
0.0092690643,
-0.0462810248,
-0.0117063243,
-0.0495065264,
0.015633544,
-0.004237487,
-0.0169611834,
0.0322825611,
0.0635725185,
-0.0028773153,
-0.0821192488,
-0.0228132494,
-0.0252017435,
-0.0343087986,
-0.0534260683,
0.0347503126,
-6.774585533e-33,
-0.0323097892,
-0.0077685914,
-0.0111961523,
0.0534756705,
0.0200540293,
0.0088476976,
-0.0915964544,
-0.0637874976,
0.0538144633,
0.0310214814,
-0.0112731308,
-0.0085978666,
0.0012075742,
-0.0044914074,
0.0054839188,
0.0729604065,
0.0008580085,
0.0186984688,
0.0030395312,
0.068526119,
0.0309302621,
0.0206810273,
0.0417789333,
-0.0179719478,
0.0347750112,
0.0609648861,
0.0209766813,
-0.0760564655,
-0.0035645233,
0.0465552732,
-0.053997919,
0.0154605005,
-0.0304535925,
-0.0441864282,
-0.01735151,
-0.0209339038,
-0.0472459644,
0.0285930187,
-0.0001426203,
-0.0396406539,
-0.0882784948,
0.0297619309,
-0.0329275876,
-0.0166366044,
-0.0432853065,
-0.00807181,
0.0571150854,
0.0052197678,
-0.0179100391,
-0.0235963911,
-0.1170322746,
0.0007594661,
0.0320033021,
0.0745670646,
0.0354384668,
-0.01334137,
0.0217491947,
0.075022243,
0.0048222374,
0.0100331781,
0.0859348252,
0.0551095717,
-0.0140672568,
0.0155553864,
0.000056488,
-0.0011569811,
0.0011904517,
-0.0310468804,
0.0059295977,
0.049946297,
0.0153431902,
-0.0079582836,
0.0709670708,
0.0015538066,
0.0261882376,
0.022109855,
-0.0830154717,
0.0114216348,
-0.0251327083,
0.0036042791,
0.0114850681,
-0.001468405,
0.0343490764,
-0.0142012751,
0.0148552107,
-0.0263164565,
0.0110021085,
-0.0331443325,
-0.0054929652,
-0.0137834987,
-0.1091622636,
-0.021841269,
-0.0129380152,
-0.0070885359,
-0.0640040487,
0.0602311753,
-0.0185753722,
0.0213955734,
-0.0416143462,
-0.0025288798,
-0.0416936576,
-0.0611111596,
-0.0152403191,
0.0079043973,
0.0302341897,
0.0079272529,
-0.0327122808,
0.0153834661,
-0.0425496995,
0.0175281148,
-0.04216424,
0.0135261621,
0.0044755512,
-0.0038254396,
-0.0083410963,
0.0105546527,
0.0249570068,
0.0160510633,
0.0260453746,
0.0286975577,
0.0063417056,
0.0432338566,
0.001311271,
0.0141164884,
-0.0114592724,
0.0054795542,
-0.0424447916,
0.0388198569,
0.0370331369,
-0.0152874868,
0.0120432889,
0.0256630592,
3.054e-7,
0.0367624983,
0.0774548426,
0.0241800845,
-0.0113216527,
0.0085447868,
0.012026079,
0.0142988693,
0.0041830316,
-0.0082126427,
-0.0182718374,
0.0221623126,
0.0041475133,
0.014966011,
0.0299877413,
-0.0711388588,
0.0183669161,
-0.0496331006,
-0.0301735308,
-0.0697461888,
0.0324902758,
-0.0123505797,
0.0170827601,
0.002988176,
-0.0306264535,
-0.0255254749,
0.017076306,
0.0276290867,
-0.0106093325,
0.0421070158,
0.0715411454,
-0.0087159276,
-0.0042435047,
-0.0277578384,
0.0423531681,
-0.0252915863,
-0.0189303812,
-0.0138539439,
0.0020133727,
-0.0314624831,
0.0410814583,
0.0135978945,
-0.0037389076,
0.0185564943,
-0.0696929172,
0.0218982734,
-0.0041584643,
-0.0308189709,
0.0064336262,
0.0330466442,
0.0104989223,
-0.0426010676,
-0.0218250025,
-0.0138279442,
0.0053272699,
-0.0384420082,
0.0299131274,
-0.0012552993,
-0.0385431051,
0.0048808362,
0.0300740656,
-0.0089842305,
-0.0028226238,
-0.0326421894,
0.0205522589,
-0.041275505,
-0.0370184518,
0.0003472988,
3.261398974e-34,
0.0356401056,
0.0014749578,
-0.0004491421,
0.0107944813,
-0.0025996538,
-0.0126337484,
-0.017333217,
0.0293564089,
-0.035219647,
-0.0523768812,
-0.0074568177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13835v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13835v3 | Multi-Party Chat: Conversational Agents in Group Settings with Humans and Models | 2023-04-26T21:41:17 | 2023-06-08T21:45:46 | Jimmy Wei, Kurt Shuster, Arthur Szlam, Jason Weston, Jack Urbanek, Mojtaba Komeili | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Current dialogue research primarily studies pairwise (two-party)
conversations, and does not address the everyday setting where more than two
speakers converse together. In this work, we both collect and evaluate
multi-party conversations to study this more general case. We use the LIGHT
environment to construct grounded conversations, where each participant has an
assigned character to role-play. We thus evaluate the ability of language
models to act as one or more characters in such conversations. Models require
two skills that pairwise-trained models appear to lack: (1) being able to
decide when to talk; (2) producing coherent utterances grounded on multiple
characters. We compare models trained on our new dataset to existing
pairwise-trained dialogue models, as well as large language models with
few-shot prompting. We find that our new dataset, MultiLIGHT, which we will
publicly release, can help bring significant improvements in the group setting. | [
0.0396468304,
0.0402694345,
-0.0162716005,
0.0255919658,
-0.0342295282,
-0.0002157186,
0.0717673525,
-0.0139129777,
-0.0262986589,
-0.0478006825,
-0.0440930575,
-0.053485956,
0.0090526063,
0.039452292,
0.0527737662,
-0.0645345822,
0.0315463357,
-0.0258228984,
0.0324463286,
-0.0152443694,
0.0080304444,
0.0285446718,
-0.0411993377,
0.05161459,
-0.0256113466,
-0.0183397494,
-0.0406506285,
0.001440414,
0.0331742242,
0.0063918475,
0.0182389598,
0.0469311215,
0.0516275689,
0.0137272729,
0.0000017735,
-0.0118317986,
0.0130544771,
-0.0498946868,
0.0133662531,
-0.0023337028,
0.0079510491,
0.0183434989,
0.0082051801,
0.0019425919,
-0.0487525538,
-0.0061112703,
0.0498955771,
0.0824000314,
0.0904475451,
0.0604672544,
-0.015490761,
-0.0299587753,
-0.0396896638,
-0.0419440195,
-0.0033820616,
-0.0500698648,
-0.0048259073,
0.0291958079,
0.026824845,
-0.0138418097,
0.0003545003,
-0.0007915783,
0.0070347725,
-0.0370519683,
-0.0061847409,
0.0481320061,
-0.0517266132,
-0.0309514869,
-0.002061801,
0.1119306087,
0.0125182392,
-0.0025203542,
0.0086421445,
0.0050995974,
-0.0001373886,
-0.0027625335,
-0.0281285122,
0.0237682983,
0.0340712778,
-0.0152424024,
-0.0350092202,
0.0207073819,
0.0235690642,
0.0164242312,
0.0156979989,
0.0472478233,
-0.0060238652,
-0.0078862896,
-0.0292902738,
0.0214327965,
-0.042998787,
-0.0675023347,
-0.0395514853,
0.0095210029,
-0.0433921143,
0.0559186563,
-0.055375021,
0.0622168258,
0.0115617123,
-0.0265001524,
0.0303785037,
0.0183329321,
-0.016212631,
0.049548693,
0.0029157463,
-0.0021040672,
0.033244893,
0.0301471893,
0.0287622306,
-0.0244477,
-0.0104365842,
-0.0145469354,
-0.0685620829,
0.0341007449,
-0.0771195143,
-0.0611364208,
-0.00215052,
0.0136228967,
-0.0182165429,
0.0203032102,
0.0329400338,
0.0260074064,
-0.0318677947,
-0.0132765137,
0.0306407064,
0.0445928872,
-0.0201566201,
0.0212642755,
0.0298358761,
-0.1022267267,
-0.0043375911,
0.0050453981,
0.0154629033,
-0.0175083857,
-0.0211398713,
0.0584801659,
-0.0271769818,
-0.038469471,
0.0473992117,
-0.0022516914,
-0.0473708138,
-0.0880341455,
-0.0417301431,
-0.0232458636,
0.037624713,
-0.0149761895,
0.0105594005,
-0.0337561145,
0.0428008884,
0.0037586573,
0.0165946092,
0.0854987279,
0.0152153857,
0.0224921219,
0.0462383777,
0.0404087938,
-0.0283209048,
0.0659215003,
0.0794286728,
-0.0151079567,
0.0140689984,
-0.0233991425,
0.0268298257,
0.0372160114,
0.0058657136,
0.0036347902,
0.0273925625,
-0.004633964,
-0.0066463584,
0.0507871397,
-0.0056571378,
0.0465681963,
-0.0486539379,
-0.0214592163,
0.0789730623,
0.0446331501,
0.0154511277,
0.014761121,
0.0407950431,
0.0235098302,
-0.0133648431,
0.0146940826,
-0.0195568092,
0.0484766439,
0.0084313648,
-0.0142262392,
0.0186052006,
0.0178898219,
-0.0480858088,
-0.0102791134,
0.0207663234,
-0.0031298439,
0.0430948846,
-0.0209956784,
0.0167320129,
0.0001404964,
-0.0563358255,
0.0511534959,
0.0562999062,
-0.0769821703,
-0.0419583172,
-0.0261798557,
0.0160193872,
0.05023982,
0.0336315148,
0.0066369623,
-0.057084173,
-0.0099921785,
0.029559508,
0.0406596661,
0.0362468809,
-0.0331253745,
0.0855702162,
-0.0583564304,
0.0319858678,
-0.0191342812,
-0.0110600935,
0.0698464587,
-0.0102914246,
-0.0102971867,
-0.0172504578,
0.0545064174,
0.0039795227,
0.0107779792,
-0.0554990917,
0.0196412839,
-0.0302351397,
0.0223773271,
0.0388811044,
-0.0056926678,
-0.0425637327,
-0.054638166,
0.0217948407,
0.0050495779,
0.0036347474,
0.0654204041,
-0.0648845732,
-0.0523245558,
0.0293197669,
-0.0100712338,
-0.0214686431,
0.036750745,
0.0016726737,
-0.0264241435,
0.043045342,
-0.0244201589,
-0.0027800684,
-0.0374699906,
-0.0121419262,
0.0081604617,
0.0396425053,
0.011768274,
0.0423082747,
0.0113421371,
0.0052328049,
-0.0043803891,
0.0263215732,
-0.0201630183,
-0.0846531913,
0.0077461428,
0.0509664901,
0.0017968285,
0.0268471353,
-0.0064038699,
0.0162746962,
-0.0347319022,
-0.0326433629,
-0.1046170369,
-0.0185368843,
-0.0126854349,
-0.0507812761,
0.003210051,
0.0071211085,
-0.0188692529,
-0.0340886302,
-0.0576023757,
0.0160961282,
0.0401023552,
-0.0238281526,
0.03611321,
0.0227505565,
-0.0374337658,
-0.0458455719,
0.0077266647,
-0.0023169206,
0.0331579745,
0.0010944193,
-0.0657224506,
-0.0232584253,
0.0452131554,
-0.0361429974,
0.035858985,
-0.0222187378,
-0.0490251333,
0.0439871475,
-0.010224225,
0.0426941179,
0.0765390098,
0.0122915525,
0.0442556292,
0.0079443287,
-0.0250958856,
-0.058035437,
0.0516283512,
0.0125170369,
0.0226807781,
-0.0375143364,
-0.0117932139,
0.0194846671,
0.0447693393,
-0.0065883636,
0.0221036971,
-0.0547842383,
0.0090179956,
0.0321201496,
-0.0857546106,
0.0048369998,
-0.0212303177,
-0.0357057415,
-0.0033059637,
-0.0439105481,
0.000913094,
0.0573199093,
-0.0255788211,
-0.0748642832,
-0.0132236388,
-0.0134640336,
-0.0276195705,
0.0656260699,
-0.0048024938,
0.015026168,
-0.014388972,
-0.047865767,
-0.0492638573,
-0.0224132035,
0.0178352818,
-0.0103480285,
0.0673309565,
-0.0558086112,
0.0056231804,
-0.005563403,
-0.0337579139,
-0.0104315802,
-0.0492563136,
-0.0353646539,
-0.0033373651,
-0.0278435182,
-0.0097076371,
-0.0692931488,
0.023867663,
-0.0053156978,
0.0114903962,
0.0046940031,
0.0215869322,
-0.0403860025,
0.0083848266,
0.0409886502,
0.038039621,
-0.021654278,
-0.0827773884,
0.0938751474,
0.0446140282,
0.0169155654,
0.0117546255,
-0.0302987434,
-0.0148443673,
0.016699709,
0.0116898157,
-0.0288801361,
0.0034245988,
0.0863436237,
-0.019164551,
0.0081545254,
0.1072348505,
-0.008588043,
-0.0332081094,
-0.001537843,
-0.0053766281,
0.0136544127,
-0.0203954745,
-0.0118330652,
-0.059024889,
-0.0258765165,
0.0208976306,
-0.0223156475,
0.0162353609,
-0.0392060392,
-0.02137319,
-0.0861199871,
0.0276419055,
0.0159795992,
-0.0236770343,
-0.0150417928,
0.023224581,
0.0331689157,
-0.0252125487,
0.067398183,
-0.020092519,
0.045200225,
-0.0237471238,
-0.0028093304,
-0.0119556198,
-0.0223612227,
0.0518140532,
-0.04796822,
0.1240755543,
0.0576840974,
0.0707230568,
0.0230716355,
0.0126672992,
0.0038178,
0.0147412745,
-0.0122321285,
-0.0011284816,
0.0353168547,
-0.0343820006,
-0.0195004512,
0.0236176364,
0.0416395441,
0.0093338257,
-0.016148096,
0.0121974852,
-0.0205157306,
-0.0290526822,
-0.0452921428,
0.0313399732,
0.0813330859,
0.0616838224,
0.0631287023,
0.0191365313,
-0.0601517335,
-0.0039211875,
-0.0116266739,
-0.0159548912,
-0.0558958799,
-0.0580401793,
-0.0226045083,
0.0159661975,
0.0535277128,
-0.0435764976,
-0.0436821356,
0.0563663766,
0.0378999859,
-0.0134909172,
-0.0071911169,
-0.0282486062,
0.0347570591,
0.0437186845,
-0.0049743722,
-0.032535661,
0.024426898,
-0.0461232439,
-0.0516465418,
0.0184638444,
-0.0475202575,
-0.004940493,
0.0125582404,
-0.0881573781,
-0.0599887259,
-0.0111173373,
0.0367685743,
0.0274667386,
0.0294831991,
-0.0107166404,
-0.0467685424,
-0.0394785665,
-0.0057344339,
-0.0464014933,
0.0308559332,
0.0138557013,
0.0354389064,
-0.001523964,
0.0515415408,
-0.006146831,
0.0530372858,
-0.0180252604,
0.0212272312,
-0.0805220306,
-0.0931162536,
-0.0139157707,
-0.0075737666,
0.0226608068,
0.0160852801,
0.0088640563,
-0.0157621093,
-0.0091325482,
-0.0683856457,
-0.003188892,
-0.0582293607,
-0.0186678935,
0.0028526082,
0.0084312866,
0.0040461225,
-0.0191020258,
-0.0037889848,
0.0131864101,
-0.0373020209,
0.004371766,
0.045264896,
-0.0378712155,
0.0002697074,
0.0276800375,
-0.0000077396,
0.0084499801,
-0.0263681039,
0.0041266447,
0.03611679,
0.03458938,
0.0220239535,
-0.0601576567,
0.0087801274,
0.0282374863,
-0.0749408454,
-0.0153231071,
0.0179400407,
0.063890256,
0.0276819989,
0.0435259268,
0.0696572959,
-0.0288086608,
0.0191427283,
-0.0070673316,
0.0607506521,
0.0166603439,
-0.0361371078,
0.0051853275,
0.026299458,
-0.0409926325,
0.0061377073,
0.0600105487,
0.026113674,
0.0148721933,
0.0104108388,
0.0421331674,
-0.0508891903,
0.0178293753,
0.0237755589,
-0.0066244984,
0.0004959331,
0.0297973063,
-0.0340838954,
0.0007998613,
-0.0106622325,
0.0374520533,
0.0219133832,
-0.0378472358,
0.0082858335,
0.0389240086,
0.0099169044,
0.0067826584,
-0.0357096121,
0.00213284,
-0.0086255707,
0.0057663252,
-0.0207083244,
-5.670667768e-33,
-0.0809827819,
-0.0090082064,
0.0097822864,
0.0079323389,
-0.0437307879,
0.005338579,
-0.0661490858,
-0.012124314,
-0.0337012187,
0.0198810324,
-0.0115211429,
0.0604954176,
0.0069681695,
0.0081759589,
-0.0002470205,
-0.0313578583,
0.0499131605,
-0.0031512545,
-0.0010677928,
0.0454543345,
0.0127456095,
0.0034691289,
-0.0031148333,
-0.0508611575,
-0.021036718,
-0.0015061835,
-0.0464072078,
-0.0023628101,
-0.0003268516,
0.0354395099,
0.0075547965,
-0.0231770482,
-0.0083353464,
-0.0194070172,
-0.0397239812,
0.0549872667,
-0.0526946522,
0.0025789659,
-0.0063363579,
0.0223136041,
-0.0619281046,
-0.0233571175,
-0.0074268845,
-0.0241535846,
0.0128753949,
-0.0260986034,
0.028366074,
-0.0202006269,
-0.0226119962,
0.0275982562,
-0.0411139764,
-0.000781543,
-0.0381253585,
-0.0663770288,
0.0029365097,
0.0592406541,
0.0030702986,
-0.029312389,
-0.0410667099,
0.0567989722,
-0.0320549645,
-0.0101312809,
0.0041161971,
0.0270409863,
0.0190808699,
0.0842039734,
0.047782775,
0.0342461243,
-0.0361765213,
-0.0256410614,
-0.0007319873,
0.095972836,
0.0324973688,
0.0611067563,
-0.0151038207,
0.014540853,
-0.0352766812,
0.0045062667,
0.0464262851,
-0.0067849196,
0.0307464022,
0.0215204097,
-0.0263936576,
0.0021670235,
0.000035581,
-0.0123892017,
0.0001093627,
-0.0587445311,
0.0138941351,
-0.0010687391,
-0.0195250213,
-0.0091941264,
0.0567115173,
-0.0660034195,
-0.0101071429,
0.0221111923,
-0.025387302,
0.040470317,
-0.0228901953,
0.0085964287,
-0.0540794879,
-0.0280561578,
0.0519806705,
0.0564129017,
0.0278766509,
0.0220316313,
0.0171336737,
0.0243980866,
-0.0228831992,
-0.0220554639,
-0.0206878074,
0.0379173085,
-0.010291446,
0.0664655492,
0.0233914554,
-0.0225681234,
-0.0292517748,
0.0145547027,
-0.0247007366,
-0.0516008325,
-0.0095515978,
-0.0352574363,
-0.0214699879,
0.0048574689,
-0.0362710357,
-0.0008409757,
-0.0774678066,
-0.0443951562,
0.0527975485,
0.0152368415,
-0.0146720763,
-0.0341827385,
2.55e-7,
-0.0437633619,
0.0097842263,
0.0322044417,
0.04629419,
0.0170560461,
0.0383911952,
-0.0240539517,
0.0546627492,
0.006959666,
-0.0524720885,
0.0336579718,
0.0473958477,
0.0712039694,
-0.0043129288,
-0.0829992741,
-0.0285218582,
-0.0813775733,
-0.0139105665,
0.004477316,
-0.0454550013,
0.0210942477,
0.0552455969,
0.0394571386,
-0.0003773646,
-0.0106626172,
-0.0061820308,
0.0390578881,
-0.0631900653,
-0.0370469391,
0.0318601392,
0.0443411283,
-0.0238886829,
-0.0070020286,
-0.0000155265,
0.0278830733,
0.0477926098,
-0.0044798902,
0.0463919677,
-0.0146058472,
-0.0290564429,
-0.0058720498,
0.0200710148,
-0.0185253955,
0.0042669415,
0.038873028,
-0.0416331366,
-0.0323650725,
0.0170652736,
-0.018429175,
-0.0082007647,
-0.0083778715,
-0.0087078847,
-0.0421168208,
0.0258813053,
0.0065214541,
-0.0433754437,
0.0205667559,
-0.0581364706,
-0.015467016,
-0.0271680709,
-0.0551624261,
-0.0288506337,
-0.0025375648,
-0.0529081486,
0.0033639681,
-0.0387445204,
-0.0151535925,
1.536912946e-34,
0.0235476736,
-0.0115583409,
-0.0057511181,
0.0528251715,
0.0281366222,
-0.0289863944,
-0.0296755042,
-0.0235996079,
0.0428784527,
-0.0292602032,
-0.0111691793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13803v1 | Translate to Disambiguate: Zero-shot Multilingual Word Sense Disambiguation with Pretrained Language Models | 2023-04-26T19:55:52 | 2023-04-26T19:55:52 | Haoqiang Kang, Terra Blevins, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) learn rich cross-lingual knowledge and can
be finetuned to perform well on diverse tasks such as translation and
multilingual word sense disambiguation (WSD). However, they often struggle at
disambiguating word sense in a zero-shot setting. To better understand this
contrast, we present a new study investigating how well PLMs capture
cross-lingual word sense with Contextual Word-Level Translation (C-WLT), an
extension of word-level translation that prompts the model to translate a given
word in context. We find that as the model size increases, PLMs encode more
cross-lingual word sense knowledge and better use context to improve WLT
performance. Building on C-WLT, we introduce a zero-shot approach for WSD,
tested on 18 languages from the XL-WSD dataset. Our method outperforms fully
supervised baselines on recall for many evaluation languages without additional
training or finetuning. This study presents a first step towards understanding
how to best leverage the cross-lingual knowledge inside PLMs for robust
zero-shot reasoning in any language. | [
-0.0259016845,
-0.0442283414,
0.0053638243,
0.0578941964,
-0.0111155855,
0.0317744389,
0.0207739454,
-0.0228604451,
-0.0211863145,
-0.0447993129,
-0.0508501083,
0.0013982193,
0.0133199552,
-0.0391828418,
-0.0040715062,
-0.0214815494,
0.0941321403,
-0.0116312429,
-0.0456090607,
-0.0045934995,
-0.0228148736,
0.0372546837,
-0.0128983948,
-0.0259804484,
0.0077437628,
-0.0366034918,
0.019201573,
0.0267815422,
0.0435847901,
-0.0238484573,
-0.024032373,
0.015015847,
0.0463240184,
0.0754200146,
0.0000019576,
-0.065253064,
-0.033779297,
-0.0096605541,
-0.0233963653,
-0.0230387654,
0.0197336227,
-0.0622254424,
0.0147169065,
-0.0302684195,
-0.016831683,
-0.0112686474,
0.0192688461,
-0.0128808143,
0.0381991602,
0.0362770669,
-0.0010286358,
-0.0623008087,
-0.0447575673,
-0.0186136495,
0.0488957837,
-0.0619567074,
0.0031139781,
0.004162577,
-0.0384370387,
-0.0131218536,
-0.0292668846,
0.0639697015,
0.0116710914,
0.0280874353,
-0.0332310311,
0.0099556176,
-0.0509061441,
-0.0348768085,
0.0152676739,
0.0745365024,
-0.0210131165,
-0.0363633335,
-0.0155387074,
-0.0145946518,
-0.0499226376,
-0.0276576057,
-0.0143066784,
0.0205773879,
0.005449296,
0.015561576,
0.0096901879,
0.0534316376,
0.0421517529,
0.0428593308,
-0.0394900255,
0.0455468856,
0.0061190492,
-0.0002941093,
0.0066743293,
0.0085687432,
0.0198350642,
-0.0140256658,
-0.0068373475,
0.0339297466,
-0.0281719323,
0.0552619956,
-0.0281261206,
-0.0578674078,
0.0200280529,
-0.0687162355,
-0.0135434037,
0.042632807,
-0.0135505218,
0.1031174138,
-0.0542073734,
0.0152695477,
0.0004921799,
0.0344671309,
-0.0227960534,
-0.0565427281,
-0.0689447299,
0.0258209556,
-0.0368475579,
0.0320081376,
-0.0267836731,
0.0115202526,
-0.04903071,
-0.0117339399,
0.0153502971,
0.0106141409,
-0.0058486806,
-0.0199106298,
-0.0548331253,
-0.0337641872,
-0.009360035,
0.094628118,
-0.0383918062,
-0.0121385111,
-0.0433587693,
-0.0307126902,
-0.0231162347,
0.0047189663,
-0.0135645019,
-0.0486529432,
0.018392982,
0.0593922623,
-0.019916404,
-0.0501173139,
-0.0469955578,
-0.0561088137,
-0.0199894458,
-0.0739713833,
-0.01961031,
-0.0718864277,
0.0402558818,
0.0142698763,
0.0180073101,
-0.0399061739,
0.0079272846,
-0.004778788,
-0.0309644286,
0.114577204,
-0.0244951136,
-0.0384765752,
-0.009725539,
0.0217450336,
0.0215103291,
0.0870316029,
0.0181635935,
0.0178364571,
0.0682222024,
0.0507245995,
-0.0445410609,
0.0067755552,
0.001606466,
0.0108044194,
-0.0294174738,
-0.0044230004,
-0.0005097911,
0.0098785479,
0.0168151725,
0.0022625173,
-0.0477730334,
0.0135048153,
0.014505012,
0.0181637108,
0.0262564551,
-0.0230475124,
0.0535900705,
0.004192268,
-0.0341651067,
-0.0278726667,
-0.0223531146,
0.01911515,
-0.0066535571,
0.0195781942,
-0.0043250015,
0.0279889777,
-0.0319047123,
-0.0323942974,
-0.0005598008,
-0.0341047123,
0.0237323362,
0.0547143705,
0.0775346085,
0.0314575471,
-0.0326238833,
0.0605179854,
0.0460497551,
-0.0631065965,
0.0310746562,
-0.0249182396,
0.0092036519,
0.0835449919,
0.030820312,
-0.0318371244,
-0.0531819351,
-0.0088191591,
0.0302632507,
0.0474287495,
0.0368640795,
-0.0091553545,
0.0661421418,
-0.0649335831,
-0.0212617926,
-0.0056700339,
-0.000223359,
0.0176969897,
0.0058274781,
0.0446834415,
0.0387897342,
-0.0710834265,
0.0009386213,
0.0114541659,
-0.0502296314,
-0.052001752,
-0.0004096388,
0.0166133214,
-0.0423667654,
0.0335230157,
-0.0075581083,
-0.0104850465,
-0.0002823321,
-0.0439705476,
0.01114891,
0.0141730104,
-0.0340715237,
-0.0696413815,
0.0268221032,
-0.0095314207,
-0.0500924736,
-0.0265674554,
-0.0565945469,
-0.0391801968,
0.0051393821,
0.053919442,
0.0210046694,
-0.0586164594,
0.0251237657,
-0.0266627315,
0.0033334654,
-0.0370974541,
0.0642460659,
0.0254473947,
0.0118218353,
0.006120983,
0.0315157883,
0.0484968983,
0.0228618141,
-0.0557262339,
0.0404349342,
0.00586223,
0.0081613865,
0.026209848,
0.0278363284,
-0.0587958358,
0.0213153642,
-0.0616465472,
0.0426049605,
-0.0091267768,
-0.0050077802,
0.0159941968,
0.037506368,
0.0024680085,
-0.030666789,
0.0153479129,
0.0376740247,
0.0138038546,
0.0104276417,
0.0190672763,
-0.0176355578,
0.0362181216,
-0.0231484752,
0.0120464647,
-0.0037618827,
0.0289367102,
-0.0068795034,
-0.0435423553,
0.0026392783,
0.0618591011,
-0.0844236389,
-0.0024537856,
0.00560477,
-0.0329818018,
0.0182143413,
-0.0135292802,
0.0004523005,
0.0400708616,
-0.0317508914,
-0.001816578,
0.055727493,
-0.0355581865,
-0.0386426635,
0.0104560247,
0.0062330514,
-0.0169269517,
-0.0149408849,
0.0188504793,
-0.0308950022,
0.0546111315,
0.010067842,
-0.0319120362,
-0.0370144956,
0.003839785,
-0.0312912539,
-0.0181310903,
-0.0235409997,
0.0531027317,
0.0142699443,
0.0453758016,
-0.0465144031,
-0.0312835015,
0.0503133796,
-0.0109254261,
0.0173050724,
-0.0575279407,
0.0208117906,
-0.0139977559,
0.0600543097,
-0.0498466305,
0.0434701778,
-0.0086644962,
-0.0025800315,
-0.0629274175,
-0.070756726,
0.0396476127,
-0.0197902415,
0.0314305127,
-0.0676952973,
0.0181942806,
-0.023146363,
0.0173855778,
-0.0302714389,
-0.0112842517,
-0.0468272716,
0.038697809,
-0.0232627559,
0.0191067979,
-0.0158380307,
-0.0185652692,
0.051101584,
0.0288711507,
0.0096637607,
-0.0281532872,
-0.0157046504,
-0.0056797164,
0.0223516375,
-0.0327940024,
0.0131915705,
-0.0414894968,
0.0475813709,
0.0248585138,
-0.0064587314,
-0.0555834435,
-0.0113601256,
-0.0040736976,
0.0264940821,
-0.0327936374,
-0.0415025912,
-0.0263397302,
0.0570218563,
-0.0577517711,
0.0070890086,
0.1226299405,
0.0471005142,
-0.0578307137,
-0.0357561111,
-0.0274235476,
-0.0166590679,
0.0300696399,
0.0094039673,
-0.1112879664,
-0.0650265813,
-0.0166847911,
-0.0160051994,
0.0520660877,
-0.0183671452,
-0.0185135864,
-0.0962587371,
-0.0125320302,
0.0164222308,
-0.059756685,
-0.0153299998,
0.0100051127,
-0.0166056361,
-0.0150353545,
0.0178682469,
-0.0189769864,
0.0094068274,
-0.0191998202,
-0.0074425945,
0.0516277514,
-0.0594333559,
0.04666958,
-0.0497746058,
0.0147868404,
0.0598485693,
0.0305628683,
0.0288482402,
-0.0139808971,
-0.0093578091,
-0.0572380647,
-0.0067440113,
-0.0304007884,
0.0199992061,
-0.0110446,
-0.0121351453,
0.0279251114,
-0.0241568517,
-0.0354639478,
-0.0279855225,
-0.0157382824,
0.0336636119,
-0.0050305789,
0.0081954757,
0.0161952954,
-0.0131638031,
-0.0019793604,
0.0621511713,
-0.0183595195,
0.0246584378,
-0.0374794528,
-0.0061271577,
-0.0261003915,
-0.0457203388,
-0.0074246759,
-0.0080677019,
-0.0827401578,
-0.0041459659,
-0.0477139764,
-0.0637013987,
0.0565575585,
0.0506849512,
-0.014995249,
0.0360809453,
-0.031542778,
0.0284227151,
-0.0384497903,
0.0136814788,
-0.0632921755,
0.0308260899,
0.0008054381,
0.013407818,
0.0343504809,
-0.0187773835,
0.002703107,
0.0408780836,
-0.05028373,
-0.0448175967,
-0.0019813613,
0.0511355139,
0.0233410075,
0.0567343831,
-0.0475483499,
-0.0074070552,
0.0433213599,
0.0040320009,
0.0090650478,
0.0144699123,
0.0276193712,
0.0452861823,
-0.0069121104,
0.070652172,
-0.027448263,
0.0275506023,
0.0197550729,
0.0368371494,
-0.0339658633,
-0.0010585316,
-0.005477231,
-0.0114641562,
0.0379065163,
-0.0387415923,
-0.01969539,
-0.0108418632,
0.0035598096,
-0.0658154488,
-0.0345492288,
0.009363872,
0.0018307942,
0.0216252469,
-0.0476122871,
0.0001682509,
0.0403817631,
-0.062300276,
0.0132078091,
0.0072007338,
-0.0204448998,
0.0405958481,
-0.0020720912,
-0.0274840668,
0.0149230286,
0.0053931465,
0.011622454,
-0.0035859798,
0.0147891082,
-0.0386989973,
0.0303665772,
-0.0140339173,
0.0120661147,
-0.0590549447,
0.0199572127,
-0.0152612207,
-0.0134119727,
0.0409413949,
0.0297985952,
0.0984710082,
-0.0198044423,
0.0804932043,
0.0365330949,
-0.02800126,
0.0176246092,
0.0564858764,
0.0186134148,
0.014693154,
0.0033265545,
0.0186046809,
0.0048373649,
0.0066134017,
0.0866901651,
-0.0290259086,
0.0282564685,
0.0091897696,
-0.0099003064,
-0.0032438906,
0.0018282885,
-0.0005820962,
0.0368383788,
-0.008991994,
0.0060334508,
-0.0856925845,
-0.0778878555,
0.0356662646,
0.0209735949,
-0.0191886071,
0.0333455615,
0.0232777279,
0.0622888505,
0.0177737735,
-0.0146784615,
-0.0371532477,
-0.0093746707,
0.0178674832,
-0.0270223971,
-0.0084277932,
-6.03065226e-33,
-0.0269584358,
0.0069271438,
0.0234722923,
-0.0494551808,
-0.034002047,
0.0009441832,
-0.0387598276,
-0.0219429266,
-0.046479933,
0.0248538554,
0.0107959574,
0.0223477818,
0.0299121365,
0.006105986,
-0.0075995419,
-0.0314425863,
0.0538616776,
0.0085678967,
-0.0120688099,
0.0172312539,
0.0744805411,
0.0294629615,
0.0870483667,
-0.0043458263,
0.0659056902,
-0.0187582672,
0.0004197841,
0.0267538689,
0.0643700883,
0.0443848409,
0.0159043372,
0.0449382067,
0.0295833331,
0.0027522375,
-0.0230845399,
-0.0163633227,
-0.0976872444,
-0.0521834418,
0.0624066442,
0.0158769768,
-0.0227939822,
-0.0501818471,
0.0145399962,
-0.0250486229,
0.0266490616,
-0.0051525561,
0.0217954591,
-0.0280408692,
-0.058543779,
-0.0323526785,
-0.0783890113,
0.0144714015,
-0.0042541386,
-0.0403711461,
0.0412868746,
0.0157762673,
-0.0056798016,
0.0531301647,
-0.0776907951,
0.0132451579,
-0.0397432446,
0.01641725,
0.0770530626,
0.0278894491,
-0.0112883216,
0.025284335,
0.0176243,
-0.0152231297,
0.0222561564,
0.0016888781,
0.0478517599,
0.0093640126,
0.024899805,
0.1165682599,
0.0578064583,
0.0030210817,
-0.0725268349,
0.0098457877,
-0.0246203039,
0.0470464639,
0.0063181045,
-0.0059677488,
0.004637822,
-0.0269617178,
-0.0687132776,
-0.0264624897,
-0.0397423394,
-0.0282740444,
-0.0066482369,
0.0057782899,
-0.0359604917,
0.003661321,
0.0731936321,
-0.0245752055,
0.0087855663,
0.0259599946,
0.0262904484,
-0.002082611,
0.0172219798,
0.0277909078,
-0.0030018785,
-0.0166300423,
0.0003349625,
0.0336101279,
0.012442275,
-0.0010939336,
0.0513337702,
-0.0074199033,
-0.0148726739,
0.0035263444,
-0.0186916851,
-0.0129249934,
-0.0350162163,
0.0194516554,
-0.0018976037,
0.046254307,
-0.0059842817,
0.0403658077,
0.0385815762,
-0.0420865081,
0.0343686603,
-0.0179525334,
-0.0111869127,
0.0469014347,
-0.0282702409,
0.0293704756,
-0.0126013616,
0.017313607,
0.038899973,
-0.0523272455,
0.0038781224,
0.0139537379,
2.622e-7,
0.0665496141,
0.0242656656,
-0.0287382733,
0.0324178487,
-0.00620723,
0.013627544,
-0.0090342769,
0.0037835438,
-0.0317041166,
-0.0221518632,
-0.0043398188,
0.0586584732,
0.0426014736,
0.0427513272,
-0.0187006202,
0.0112917591,
0.0326047651,
0.0274567716,
-0.047675278,
-0.0014762208,
0.0564899035,
0.0743411183,
0.0019778688,
-0.0102516823,
-0.0232352633,
-0.0252138879,
0.068590641,
-0.007324683,
-0.0138209695,
-0.0075702402,
0.0095752263,
0.0153246429,
-0.0059928112,
0.0211428367,
-0.0440307148,
-0.0019166762,
0.0090598837,
0.0654263347,
-0.0135874636,
-0.0313384496,
-0.0020964178,
-0.0331575349,
0.011275474,
-0.0408938006,
0.1043318734,
-0.0618985221,
0.0194460228,
0.0210842043,
-0.0091318507,
0.0382010788,
0.0565575622,
-0.0048148907,
-0.0808735713,
0.0219405256,
0.0284928847,
-0.0039541582,
-0.0435055345,
-0.06844908,
-0.0222205315,
0.009356318,
0.0083237477,
-0.0169941504,
0.055483412,
-0.0735327601,
0.0144144883,
-0.0374906696,
0.0085213315,
1.94850839e-34,
0.0398910865,
-0.0197766908,
0.0109705674,
-0.0337327495,
0.0209906027,
-0.0101825306,
-0.0562383607,
0.0007940946,
0.0208583176,
-0.0284711439,
0.0128673567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13783v1 | Fine Tuning with Abnormal Examples | 2023-04-26T18:59:48 | 2023-04-26T18:59:48 | Will Rieger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the prevalence of crowd sourced labor in creating Natural Language
processing datasets, these aforementioned sets have become increasingly large.
For instance, the SQUAD dataset currently sits at over 80,000 records. However,
because the English language is rather repetitive in structure, the
distribution of word frequencies in the SQUAD dataset's contexts are relatively
unchanged. By measuring each sentences distance from the co-variate distance of
frequencies of all sentences in the dataset, we identify 10,500 examples that
create a more uniform distribution for training. While fine-tuning ELECTRA [4]
on this subset of examples reaches better performance to a model trained on all
87,000 examples. Herein we introduce a methodology for systematically pruning
datasets for fine tuning reaching better out of sample performance. | [
0.0646347031,
0.0466929711,
-0.0371812694,
0.0400027148,
-0.0257075354,
0.0175368581,
-0.0320741124,
0.0247541796,
-0.095044747,
-0.0365769118,
-0.032150358,
-0.0067235464,
0.0351234078,
0.0140417581,
0.02382176,
-0.0284517836,
-0.0028017901,
0.0029902584,
0.031639386,
0.0029235133,
0.0102739343,
0.0070646685,
0.0040723751,
0.0496748872,
-0.0012175136,
0.0018901039,
-0.0088442573,
0.0342206173,
0.0291361697,
0.002333639,
0.0673848316,
0.0469126478,
-0.0106813228,
-0.0155399805,
0.0000018075,
-0.0469344147,
-0.0100486018,
-0.0237314329,
-0.0334901661,
-0.0126407463,
0.0546125472,
-0.0074272794,
0.0130878398,
0.0274757072,
-0.0304539502,
0.0067889499,
0.0156068001,
0.0324277878,
0.0167192239,
0.086006619,
-0.0032310323,
0.0072045517,
-0.0176569093,
-0.031161353,
-0.0071371514,
0.0015546376,
-0.0007670369,
-0.0454580672,
-0.0089798067,
-0.0271294061,
-0.0145594953,
-0.0077571901,
0.003823312,
0.0681606457,
0.0412038825,
0.0052153454,
-0.1177157313,
-0.035507489,
0.0205184408,
0.080059357,
-0.0284056496,
-0.022730507,
0.0139067806,
-0.0193896145,
-0.0029370417,
0.0019652536,
-0.0032229731,
-0.0106122121,
-0.0288660359,
0.0236664917,
-0.0068568923,
-0.0125956191,
0.0042181057,
0.0023793732,
-0.0140199317,
-0.0170341525,
0.0000593126,
-0.0397536196,
0.0157317109,
-0.011311735,
-0.0497628674,
-0.0258072577,
0.0092882924,
-0.0016513109,
-0.0192653146,
-0.0246700309,
-0.0560183749,
-0.0506418981,
0.0668995902,
-0.0011777771,
0.0489417426,
-0.0027189734,
0.0065136626,
0.0336146355,
0.0319139212,
-0.0265270602,
0.0494828597,
0.022075776,
-0.0252948366,
-0.0006030045,
-0.0759622827,
0.0305202119,
-0.0640688092,
-0.0081942808,
-0.0409387015,
-0.0106036868,
-0.0695167482,
-0.0217633806,
0.0062401369,
-0.0161564276,
0.0104933353,
0.0228480306,
-0.0636388138,
0.0079612024,
0.0022406096,
-0.0141002033,
-0.0375343934,
0.0463419594,
-0.0087890215,
-0.0673652366,
-0.0075705415,
-0.0116864685,
0.0325893387,
-0.0300917719,
0.0288408753,
0.0080016619,
0.0478337556,
-0.0709738508,
-0.0358618461,
-0.0088148816,
-0.017747974,
-0.0562693439,
-0.051929839,
-0.076138705,
-0.0172139592,
0.0072330395,
0.0103034591,
-0.0237288065,
-0.0104065435,
0.0046272711,
-0.0561828353,
0.0706768855,
-0.0070384447,
0.0284824707,
0.0085728215,
-0.0173456874,
0.0286180899,
0.0818944424,
0.0483767428,
-0.0220368076,
0.0642988682,
-0.0021749097,
0.0278847758,
0.0457836017,
-0.0007336196,
0.0139836362,
-0.0214668922,
-0.0138643747,
-0.0586108454,
0.0129585695,
0.0386445001,
-0.0085812062,
-0.0105243167,
-0.0189218596,
0.0481556617,
0.0184545238,
0.0187156927,
-0.0068008988,
0.012591484,
-0.0104654739,
-0.0059464276,
0.0129233627,
-0.0486623831,
-0.0297103934,
0.0155815156,
-0.0002708562,
-0.0014409693,
0.0554636382,
-0.0303990021,
-0.0230851211,
-0.0112785995,
-0.0161045976,
0.0070072189,
0.0110644447,
0.0395119563,
0.0232061297,
-0.0090115648,
0.0272920225,
0.0561238267,
-0.0223344639,
-0.0138810026,
-0.0400938615,
0.0189666115,
0.0569468513,
0.026846746,
-0.0518598296,
-0.0237576868,
-0.0157212485,
0.0163287371,
0.0033102545,
0.0407084003,
-0.0128952116,
0.0686317161,
-0.0644637495,
-0.0344411172,
0.0144318044,
0.0305615868,
-0.0270161461,
0.0063209734,
0.0346323028,
0.0102203572,
-0.0954597741,
-0.0415481143,
0.0442132466,
-0.0060976245,
-0.0176658612,
0.0268025361,
0.0290374178,
0.0221427418,
-0.0089073172,
-0.0359225087,
-0.0103496592,
0.0224009547,
-0.0327395424,
0.0163773056,
-0.0165856071,
-0.0050403732,
-0.0279383641,
0.0356152169,
-0.0760666579,
-0.0100112613,
0.0617674477,
-0.0737892762,
-0.0186012052,
-0.0121486485,
-0.0266937837,
0.02445722,
-0.0363190696,
0.0349946655,
-0.003624673,
0.0566935502,
-0.0355752669,
0.0547017567,
0.0209395625,
0.050486885,
-0.0151768252,
-0.0137040578,
0.0375312567,
-0.0683022738,
0.0068895523,
-0.0177197605,
-0.0108537534,
0.029386688,
0.0530395433,
0.0078510111,
-0.0632357746,
-0.0350128859,
-0.0579638071,
0.0094230473,
-0.0405571945,
0.0282543506,
0.0239762198,
0.0262009408,
-0.049364198,
-0.0270061493,
0.000442837,
0.0169810057,
-0.0036638579,
0.0345794931,
0.042397622,
0.0004295726,
-0.0660848245,
-0.0302396081,
-0.0056780092,
0.0189259909,
0.0341230221,
-0.0122466851,
0.0344790816,
-0.0543761402,
0.0600891374,
-0.0091326423,
0.0227667261,
0.0041923737,
-0.0585484318,
-0.0132323755,
0.0287512615,
0.003823088,
0.0687134713,
0.0202215631,
0.0148759447,
0.0235311836,
0.03323365,
-0.0310353488,
-0.0140111586,
-0.0158586279,
-0.0152756898,
-0.0322247334,
-0.0194162764,
0.0101088462,
0.0325533189,
0.0130264517,
-0.0136271575,
-0.0150968442,
0.0385556743,
0.0051636705,
-0.0131787984,
-0.015225959,
-0.0146502638,
-0.0254882183,
0.0410292968,
-0.023786895,
-0.0338266045,
0.0417372733,
0.0119164251,
0.0331204012,
-0.0745446086,
-0.0702613667,
-0.036488194,
0.0168194883,
0.0209092796,
0.0054127635,
0.0210036654,
-0.0097678117,
-0.0293366108,
-0.021215722,
0.0454565585,
-0.0153516391,
0.0356353335,
-0.00858266,
0.0048759598,
-0.0191704948,
-0.0574562289,
-0.0344246104,
-0.0771696568,
-0.0123229744,
-0.0042136032,
0.0308025591,
-0.0008351227,
-0.0331661254,
-0.0123707261,
-0.0121061383,
0.0776067078,
-0.0090029761,
-0.0257010367,
-0.0250401236,
0.0450514667,
0.0583612919,
0.0003237557,
0.0122012738,
-0.0507589988,
-0.0113614649,
0.0062109907,
0.0454091392,
0.033403676,
-0.0356041528,
0.0150252469,
-0.0143860774,
-0.0234046932,
-0.0248158835,
0.0368914008,
0.0680570453,
-0.039600376,
-0.0331625566,
0.0854447335,
0.0273776092,
-0.0309429243,
0.0331620499,
0.0148617523,
0.0662011802,
0.0420680903,
0.0158092156,
-0.0406113416,
-0.0366894677,
0.0250907429,
0.0496148728,
-0.0404813811,
-0.0370205529,
0.0013956837,
-0.1243686378,
0.0346216857,
-0.0076877829,
-0.0902643278,
-0.0317186154,
-0.0318141766,
0.0408342741,
-0.0553687736,
0.0302407518,
-0.0320003591,
-0.0291157458,
0.0325619653,
0.0435481593,
0.0005450496,
-0.0867634565,
0.0364818908,
-0.0622041859,
0.0382336564,
0.0146015985,
0.0272415392,
-0.0158314463,
0.0158662591,
0.0175319854,
-0.0595236458,
0.0307727437,
0.024005793,
0.0959286094,
0.0110054649,
-0.0213827193,
0.0022789561,
0.0395888835,
-0.0518479645,
-0.0133460239,
0.0227267854,
0.0259709433,
-0.0185287595,
0.0012594799,
-0.02157568,
-0.0146506624,
0.0515079163,
0.074354507,
0.0557470806,
-0.0294954628,
-0.0053984285,
0.0203507841,
0.0156542771,
-0.0420446172,
0.0127592897,
0.0487116985,
-0.0026495999,
-0.0348753221,
-0.0518351421,
-0.0827270225,
0.0583192222,
0.0564170033,
0.0173888672,
0.0255509634,
0.0010587483,
0.0128081869,
-0.0038394318,
0.0389622971,
-0.0038616504,
-0.0071300524,
-0.0430164002,
-0.0245849714,
0.0143947853,
0.0136718377,
-0.0410591289,
0.0248031225,
-0.0900364891,
-0.0534108505,
0.0294028148,
0.0384510569,
0.0336378552,
0.0520027764,
0.0072302981,
-0.0590974689,
0.0228985623,
0.1073918715,
-0.059947893,
0.0138911093,
0.0097500542,
-0.0597767457,
-0.0175805073,
0.0486706942,
-0.0235341303,
0.0658858865,
0.0544099025,
0.0167584065,
-0.0311119538,
-0.04935202,
0.0367783196,
0.0251150131,
0.0527094118,
-0.0232345182,
-0.0527179539,
-0.0357809216,
0.0394355729,
0.0298796743,
0.013408904,
-0.0217641499,
-0.0075449492,
0.0089675672,
-0.0057138805,
-0.0536307804,
0.0112231132,
-0.0374588482,
0.0366138034,
-0.0630464479,
0.0571471453,
0.0398104228,
-0.0108500924,
0.0215578359,
0.0081608137,
0.0039698603,
0.0386505164,
0.0130657731,
0.053019993,
0.0025150715,
-0.0034556924,
0.0145583013,
0.0526704043,
-0.0397718102,
0.0159652848,
-0.0386751182,
-0.0354712941,
-0.0122577883,
0.015725825,
0.0225309078,
-0.0749217197,
0.0189662334,
0.0032692351,
-0.0180929229,
-0.0170584228,
0.0243340023,
-0.0018265095,
0.060240183,
-0.005326252,
0.0263821129,
-0.0233694203,
0.0288981814,
0.0902123377,
-0.0218448378,
0.0661088675,
0.0263051968,
-0.0115820961,
-0.035775058,
0.0474248864,
0.0347505063,
-0.0382292606,
0.0117956223,
0.0091654835,
-0.0295694713,
-0.07994093,
-0.0105245048,
-0.0105276434,
0.0400998667,
-0.0095372526,
0.0508892611,
0.0499597974,
-0.0319423862,
0.0228473041,
-0.0073080538,
-0.0276274886,
-0.0008902377,
-0.0154505568,
-0.0236354731,
-6.600576369e-33,
0.0222728848,
0.0117796287,
-0.0005629609,
0.0066913944,
0.0184447151,
-0.0083213374,
0.0015490638,
-0.0266836099,
-0.0130447717,
0.0276543535,
-0.0588802285,
0.0292239152,
0.0305973683,
0.0024885314,
0.0156408325,
-0.0041871076,
0.0654057488,
-0.0105129704,
-0.0418296382,
0.0040940004,
0.030976247,
0.0639314502,
0.0669934377,
-0.0812907591,
-0.0551739968,
0.0261448156,
-0.0262233131,
0.0317927226,
0.0209895428,
0.0701663718,
0.0035119785,
0.0678090528,
0.02725555,
-0.0725652426,
-0.0144230882,
0.0013357592,
-0.0788242593,
-0.0324010439,
-0.0018362883,
0.0084867366,
0.0208950769,
-0.0109924683,
0.0789256096,
-0.0273154527,
-0.0212728679,
-0.0144595308,
0.0620953441,
-0.0594502054,
-0.0266611762,
-0.0077555929,
-0.0474935248,
0.0354118757,
-0.0212553181,
-0.0318996646,
-0.0153750507,
0.0031586257,
-0.0353602543,
0.0171390399,
-0.035055168,
-0.0089886114,
0.0565295704,
0.0446843393,
-0.0108229723,
-0.0243881028,
-0.0336537659,
0.0622256026,
0.026511725,
0.0130221024,
0.0297187734,
-0.0245431755,
-0.0008244902,
0.0671812668,
-0.0274984632,
0.0686288327,
0.0817715302,
-0.0175443813,
-0.0905094519,
0.012325298,
-0.0030847196,
0.0198814925,
0.0192833822,
-0.017297687,
-0.0965958089,
-0.0017391905,
-0.0103072785,
-0.0314105488,
-0.0305758473,
-0.0083499821,
0.0374967121,
0.0217218697,
-0.0294004567,
0.004868919,
-0.0097499266,
-0.027917916,
-0.0139673892,
0.0312979296,
-0.0101677971,
-0.0279667024,
0.0086443014,
-0.0191379748,
-0.0202920362,
-0.0433029644,
0.0101187853,
0.0453932919,
0.0540809818,
-0.0341026969,
0.0894193128,
0.0376328006,
-0.0935140029,
0.024001589,
0.0120881768,
0.0359007977,
-0.0168189518,
0.0320625007,
0.0167632811,
0.0102921501,
-0.0122478483,
0.0241497494,
0.0251447,
-0.0384559818,
-0.0294055119,
-0.020609092,
0.0117084049,
0.0443794727,
-0.0053903875,
-0.035002809,
-0.0085620983,
-0.0212368313,
0.0511568189,
-0.0245907549,
-0.0156564657,
-0.0168746412,
2.637e-7,
0.0170194712,
0.0389766097,
0.0008315999,
-0.0082599819,
-0.0054821176,
0.0436430499,
-0.0348363928,
0.0436286591,
-0.0020199497,
-0.0143226655,
0.0247734599,
0.0032615236,
0.0158735123,
0.0054259188,
-0.090056546,
-0.003835042,
-0.0529554076,
-0.012072715,
-0.0388074592,
-0.0187890343,
0.0154224019,
0.1360103637,
0.0374695212,
-0.0634839609,
-0.0076699001,
-0.0520265549,
0.0045284871,
-0.0424163155,
-0.0146306688,
0.0159943309,
-0.0098186294,
0.0525853597,
0.0015177218,
0.0439085811,
-0.021464549,
0.0171818193,
-0.004986736,
0.0286783297,
-0.044442527,
0.032424435,
0.0122968871,
0.0047357124,
-0.019393051,
-0.0234544985,
0.0439111255,
-0.0443838164,
-0.0294794459,
-0.0221472643,
-0.0275116637,
-0.0234168321,
0.0417620502,
0.0008979242,
0.0133607257,
0.0208950266,
0.0166335758,
0.0065929233,
-0.028030647,
-0.0557626784,
0.0182024315,
0.0607291535,
-0.0243871566,
-0.0368769243,
0.0174203888,
0.023609845,
0.0418580621,
-0.0421109721,
0.0183372386,
2.218025597e-34,
0.0422840565,
0.0235099569,
0.0016198447,
-0.02176328,
0.0174404122,
-0.0311133973,
-0.0037993314,
-0.0066848346,
0.0004174091,
-0.0578326322,
-0.0126779778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13714v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13714v3 | Evaluation of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 for supporting real-world information needs in healthcare delivery | 2023-04-26T17:54:28 | 2023-05-01T00:41:37 | Debadutta Dash, Rahul Thapa, Juan M. Banda, Akshay Swaminathan, Morgan Cheatham, Mehr Kashyap, Nikesh Kotecha, Jonathan H. Chen, Saurabh Gombar, Lance Downing, Rachel Pedreira, Ethan Goh, Angel Arnaout, Garret Kenn Morris, Honor Magon, Matthew P Lungren, Eric Horvitz, Nigam H. Shah | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Despite growing interest in using large language models (LLMs) in healthcare,
current explorations do not assess the real-world utility and safety of LLMs in
clinical settings. Our objective was to determine whether two LLMs can serve
information needs submitted by physicians as questions to an informatics
consultation service in a safe and concordant manner. Sixty six questions from
an informatics consult service were submitted to GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 via simple
prompts. 12 physicians assessed the LLM responses' possibility of patient harm
and concordance with existing reports from an informatics consultation service.
Physician assessments were summarized based on majority vote. For no questions
did a majority of physicians deem either LLM response as harmful. For GPT-3.5,
responses to 8 questions were concordant with the informatics consult report,
20 discordant, and 9 were unable to be assessed. There were 29 responses with
no majority on "Agree", "Disagree", and "Unable to assess". For GPT-4,
responses to 13 questions were concordant, 15 discordant, and 3 were unable to
be assessed. There were 35 responses with no majority. Responses from both LLMs
were largely devoid of overt harm, but less than 20% of the responses agreed
with an answer from an informatics consultation service, responses contained
hallucinated references, and physicians were divided on what constitutes harm.
These results suggest that while general purpose LLMs are able to provide safe
and credible responses, they often do not meet the specific information need of
a given question. A definitive evaluation of the usefulness of LLMs in
healthcare settings will likely require additional research on prompt
engineering, calibration, and custom-tailoring of general purpose models. | [
0.080270268,
0.026060205,
-0.0035171949,
-0.0443346165,
-0.0366047397,
0.0206754263,
0.0237260163,
0.0243128706,
0.0263358559,
-0.0108850785,
0.0236044712,
-0.0526339374,
0.0231299791,
0.010206989,
-0.0056140479,
-0.0395805575,
0.0022612542,
0.0243688934,
0.0340753309,
0.0087126121,
0.0247014277,
0.0340118892,
-0.0144192241,
0.0421860814,
0.0055554723,
-0.0165844932,
0.0321110599,
0.0058518061,
-0.0109814256,
-0.0894382969,
-0.0130795473,
0.0162476283,
-0.0028118195,
-0.0229015909,
0.0000026285,
-0.0619994141,
-0.0025442755,
0.0603976659,
-0.0882742405,
-0.0150642423,
0.0372958519,
-0.0280946363,
0.0000531781,
0.0114630945,
-0.0050776764,
-0.0084349615,
0.0399301872,
0.0187058989,
0.0055024959,
0.0146737751,
-0.0277920775,
-0.0012172419,
0.0059919027,
-0.007715648,
0.0328635983,
-0.0137827201,
0.0359937884,
0.0414842814,
0.0667627081,
0.0092831282,
0.0393593572,
0.0420122445,
-0.0183379203,
0.0237759911,
-0.0250187274,
0.0192444306,
-0.0126059977,
-0.0303171221,
0.0042944243,
0.0280639138,
0.0870593935,
0.0205248687,
-0.0031417229,
-0.0116933445,
0.0164740048,
0.0136327278,
-0.0402846448,
-0.0102019617,
-0.0182614513,
-0.0094728535,
-0.0036074205,
-0.0082290052,
0.0290726479,
-0.0301663429,
-0.0100909164,
0.0185943786,
0.0159666874,
-0.0386486389,
0.0211179908,
-0.0353246741,
-0.001593419,
-0.0213055462,
-0.0015882022,
0.0138785513,
-0.0382123105,
0.0147851277,
0.0309251733,
-0.0113590602,
0.1079991087,
-0.0604530871,
0.0174413733,
0.02340772,
0.0045315712,
0.0005550689,
0.053577479,
-0.0038608399,
-0.0271941684,
0.0259115845,
-0.0572462305,
0.0485497415,
-0.0271219462,
-0.0351574011,
-0.0073113539,
0.0251147188,
-0.0089854933,
0.0046504689,
-0.0710662603,
-0.0083187036,
-0.012599566,
0.0308177825,
0.0059605055,
0.018189244,
-0.0033902691,
-0.0212844275,
-0.0409627333,
0.0251299068,
0.0027750921,
0.0398397073,
-0.0157692786,
-0.0547618233,
0.0694540665,
0.0043832394,
-0.0113447122,
0.0097330539,
0.0141080841,
0.0592234507,
0.0137401372,
0.0064381296,
-0.0100403251,
-0.0458778739,
-0.0594170764,
-0.0251401979,
0.0021111346,
-0.056781549,
0.0231342334,
0.0300441105,
-0.0035782363,
-0.0397110023,
0.018473478,
0.0540170893,
-0.0803767145,
0.0415430628,
-0.058870893,
0.0565730631,
0.0284122452,
0.0478249453,
0.0266987029,
-0.0067910217,
0.0070647853,
-0.044598911,
-0.0183210615,
-0.0503796972,
-0.0098179383,
-0.0004696753,
-0.0066097975,
0.0083751082,
0.0066007571,
0.050113827,
0.0116595095,
0.0362808444,
-0.0980687961,
0.1008219942,
-0.0023952171,
0.040895097,
0.0590376295,
0.0385820791,
0.0151331201,
0.0166696161,
0.0002342496,
0.0065217623,
-0.0047351574,
-0.023123404,
-0.0101729017,
-0.019819824,
-0.0146540627,
-0.0101838708,
0.0093166223,
-0.0140923895,
-0.0310117677,
-0.0137775568,
-0.0626406595,
-0.0201316867,
0.0031177672,
0.019210564,
0.0001030582,
-0.0367351025,
-0.0081079025,
0.0724922121,
0.0088025713,
-0.0238228403,
-0.0396391377,
-0.0385376252,
0.0093779583,
0.1129961908,
0.0377174839,
-0.0148473121,
-0.0112113804,
-0.0580217391,
0.0247623622,
0.0047477088,
0.0243171416,
0.0032619529,
-0.0323280841,
-0.0246677026,
-0.0035961622,
0.0435622297,
-0.0024179481,
-0.0172230117,
-0.0205738414,
0.0472658426,
-0.0095528048,
0.0043892981,
-0.0565987416,
0.0158936307,
-0.0595265776,
-0.0337133147,
-0.0166574698,
-0.0040992536,
0.038625747,
0.0529481061,
0.0053721881,
0.0489412732,
0.0255596992,
0.0055556358,
0.0092283934,
-0.0061951722,
-0.0155158415,
0.0628064126,
0.0165886376,
0.0129840169,
0.0297730751,
-0.0546780974,
0.0125581538,
-0.0124643119,
-0.0553755648,
-0.0690794289,
0.0284097809,
0.0031179488,
-0.0037238745,
0.0435634628,
-0.0110104866,
-0.0390143618,
-0.0299330074,
-0.0350138657,
0.0102031976,
0.0380650647,
-0.0611656271,
0.0094797034,
-0.0011371793,
-0.0398238078,
0.0442765206,
-0.0128284348,
0.0206426177,
-0.0001575055,
0.0328551233,
-0.0014717074,
-0.0134170586,
-0.1023580953,
-0.053229522,
0.0146431588,
0.0121878851,
0.0345679633,
0.0122523587,
-0.0095692379,
0.0005540286,
-0.0487130657,
-0.0320276245,
0.0289917123,
0.0537517853,
-0.0079195397,
0.0399117805,
-0.0058346996,
0.0125285005,
-0.0127896508,
-0.0204315837,
-0.0113615422,
0.0212837979,
-0.0180651098,
-0.0140306046,
-0.0437476486,
-0.0403674059,
-0.0320400223,
0.0082423203,
-0.0268007126,
0.0357847027,
-0.0278458428,
0.0200225022,
-0.0216415897,
-0.0284193195,
-0.0199091285,
0.0314475335,
-0.019763181,
-0.0321413949,
-0.0097470144,
-0.017689703,
-0.0459288955,
0.0127052879,
-0.0908503085,
0.0066599716,
0.0243953727,
0.0301400945,
0.0299189761,
-0.0239575244,
-0.0184561927,
-0.0558435358,
0.0241256487,
-0.0556574948,
-0.0347805768,
-0.0367711894,
0.0503766425,
0.031700518,
-0.0394766219,
0.0438825227,
-0.0237864647,
0.0221756976,
-0.0781911835,
-0.0294463392,
-0.0205317698,
-0.0258763731,
-0.0217680186,
0.0189548284,
0.0405694246,
-0.0193449855,
0.0158733353,
-0.0282653887,
-0.0285647046,
-0.0464809798,
0.060316138,
-0.0562366508,
0.0263672359,
-0.0024329575,
-0.0155875003,
-0.013993552,
-0.0054054749,
-0.000408157,
-0.006906,
0.0364956111,
0.0204704218,
-0.0088258162,
0.0265069827,
0.0391063727,
0.0850568414,
0.0349753648,
-0.0192062818,
0.0395742506,
-0.0723382458,
0.0115231788,
-0.0000721161,
0.0297501981,
0.0162801594,
0.030789325,
0.059178181,
-0.0048241653,
-0.0045647593,
0.0027791637,
-0.012421106,
0.0237808228,
0.0059075085,
-0.0320960917,
0.0473742224,
0.0165951848,
-0.0196971595,
0.0018582615,
0.072208479,
0.0084591657,
-0.0609758236,
0.0148473922,
-0.0265384614,
-0.0607226752,
-0.0160789546,
-0.0230187923,
-0.0628379509,
0.0097901961,
-0.0253388844,
0.0341120474,
-0.0472231694,
0.0076938807,
-0.0039099883,
-0.01361115,
0.0212496519,
0.0173466336,
0.0060305721,
-0.0346134864,
0.0179822799,
0.0150702018,
0.031266395,
0.0356760956,
-0.0237959102,
-0.0059351651,
-0.0178847928,
-0.0114916405,
-0.129446283,
-0.0855701566,
0.0419617891,
0.0287508704,
0.0456411242,
0.0754110962,
0.0017101626,
-0.0548571013,
-0.0295890048,
0.0272178929,
0.0101386039,
-0.0225163791,
0.0054413793,
0.0539826415,
0.0349620059,
0.0321239606,
-0.0461885631,
0.0209069382,
-0.0343002416,
0.0015628642,
0.0124571314,
0.0695107579,
-0.050832022,
0.0010004833,
-0.0441888943,
0.0442458168,
0.0489625223,
0.0482875071,
0.0058872052,
-0.0068959729,
0.0171544347,
0.0068941684,
0.0293413196,
0.0698008984,
0.0022380827,
0.0150514226,
0.0124211926,
-0.0041310396,
-0.0516397431,
-0.016123997,
0.0361291654,
-0.0307619832,
0.0288447756,
0.0399363674,
0.037237227,
-0.0041941698,
0.0057711271,
0.0152258733,
0.0225681085,
0.0311548971,
-0.0489950366,
-0.0113129839,
0.0181670282,
0.0092829224,
0.0090801893,
0.015049547,
0.0284329653,
-0.0012699179,
0.0375682339,
0.0510458872,
0.0300050881,
-0.041078262,
-0.0000620565,
-0.0082059596,
-0.0070699556,
0.039024882,
-0.0427438766,
-0.0388275683,
-0.038028162,
0.0474454537,
0.0191426333,
-0.0233894531,
-0.0142521411,
0.014583298,
0.0142297857,
0.0192969665,
-0.0180310719,
-0.026558809,
0.037311472,
0.0864532292,
0.0069090067,
-0.015219762,
0.0213773232,
0.0082461704,
-0.0129486481,
-0.069553338,
0.0128291212,
-0.0168979093,
-0.0234427564,
0.0154790487,
-0.0323674902,
-0.0072204135,
-0.0093068788,
-0.073720701,
-0.0458469093,
-0.0508187674,
0.0350762941,
-0.0080294767,
0.0187714081,
0.0380801149,
-0.0367344171,
-0.0225697234,
-0.0143172238,
-0.037301112,
0.0180939194,
0.0154246353,
0.0988906324,
-0.0463990271,
-0.0020548196,
0.0239235107,
0.0390580967,
0.0024902353,
-0.1352659464,
-0.0281339865,
0.026708439,
-0.0061697038,
0.0220464468,
0.0064359242,
-0.0539533123,
0.0098114377,
-0.0609798208,
-0.0260183476,
0.0129687656,
0.0069808443,
0.0569292977,
-0.0060448265,
-0.0216957573,
-0.0568700545,
0.0491605476,
-0.0142423585,
0.0107285865,
-0.0468594991,
-0.0503678098,
-0.028820537,
-0.0314857177,
-0.0206945222,
0.0372637473,
-0.0871015489,
-0.017200239,
-0.0869714022,
-0.0219023991,
-0.031960737,
-0.04006809,
-0.0146571072,
-0.0470205918,
0.0415314957,
0.0345289633,
-0.0020908043,
-0.0505721234,
-0.0214368347,
0.0790271237,
-0.0401532613,
0.0087817414,
0.0135243461,
-6.42341835e-33,
0.0222679153,
-0.0158241969,
0.0336602926,
-0.0223771203,
0.0039847102,
-0.0038892443,
-0.0058801933,
0.0181338638,
-0.0289413892,
0.0283113457,
-0.0087012444,
-0.0174455587,
-0.0043666428,
0.0413233005,
0.0254910272,
-0.0443807542,
-0.0006792747,
0.0118483398,
0.0048658904,
0.0299434029,
-0.0203351993,
-0.0094994828,
0.0400732458,
-0.1034037694,
0.0480965339,
-0.0187247638,
0.0084633175,
-0.0126820598,
-0.0449735783,
0.0373875275,
-0.0009091561,
0.0369600914,
0.0418721661,
-0.0364882089,
-0.0047075022,
0.0438287854,
0.0032798715,
-0.0110409996,
0.0408679806,
-0.0549915768,
-0.0137755536,
-0.035746336,
0.0450574681,
-0.0161639228,
-0.0421498269,
0.01737215,
-0.0212071873,
-0.024985807,
-0.0132879997,
0.0096474988,
-0.0322636142,
0.0086897248,
0.0260803215,
0.0265052523,
-0.044189211,
0.0628263652,
-0.0649196208,
0.0201213192,
-0.0305396002,
-0.0126860673,
0.0682364702,
-0.0098413695,
0.0124974782,
-0.073186025,
-0.0032707346,
0.0174757876,
-0.0046103988,
0.0000741351,
-0.0504877008,
0.001632406,
-0.0691682473,
-0.0062845191,
0.0508201458,
0.0381475054,
-0.0195419267,
-0.0468954146,
-0.0637086704,
0.0219171979,
-0.0710618198,
0.0358141288,
0.0837644786,
-0.0278530829,
-0.0925818458,
-0.0531784818,
-0.0086837709,
0.0363693573,
-0.0170174669,
-0.048196651,
0.04671105,
-0.0140424687,
0.0237646345,
0.0323113725,
0.0111711156,
-0.0011256617,
0.0175548866,
-0.0243424028,
0.0321683735,
0.0137487389,
-0.0294775553,
0.0075589092,
-0.088897869,
0.0447534062,
-0.0117085408,
0.0102131153,
0.0275118314,
0.0520438999,
-0.0096055856,
-0.0427200943,
-0.0567745306,
0.0010760452,
0.0329283699,
0.0272901729,
-0.0028885887,
-0.0164382514,
0.0493965186,
0.0359345227,
0.0139483782,
0.0475021489,
0.0048789373,
-0.0416822396,
-0.0540530644,
-0.0594834499,
-0.0341764987,
0.005116228,
-0.0212962739,
0.0201392006,
-0.0296936333,
0.044068668,
0.0647499785,
0.0199653581,
0.0167251695,
0.0007241115,
3.299e-7,
0.0691964105,
0.0364215486,
-0.0044729402,
-0.0207547639,
0.0438401103,
-0.0043598604,
0.0288674925,
-0.0032369513,
0.0317120329,
-0.0376334079,
0.0487325378,
-0.0429991707,
0.0218131747,
0.0593002588,
-0.022264732,
-0.0202661417,
-0.0663796961,
-0.0246994309,
-0.0455686897,
0.0040893378,
0.0716137663,
0.0186973531,
-0.0580388308,
-0.0245751571,
-0.0098436819,
0.0138289435,
0.0140806921,
-0.0849284679,
0.0036339713,
0.0280493684,
0.042357251,
-0.0050676251,
0.0411102213,
0.0915858746,
-0.0046091592,
-0.0350874215,
-0.0300707258,
0.0953385457,
-0.0580344722,
0.031340383,
0.0243676715,
-0.0441564769,
0.0399041772,
-0.0770680532,
0.0290307086,
-0.0428720638,
-0.0192007497,
0.0288751721,
-0.0350724757,
-0.0470615253,
0.0976289883,
-0.0347219557,
-0.0463613011,
0.0184047911,
0.0170048028,
0.0479450934,
-0.0177118927,
0.0014752597,
0.0490352288,
0.0460602976,
-0.0210509505,
-0.0541566052,
0.0262409374,
-0.0325901359,
-0.0407635644,
-0.071549207,
0.0435441583,
3.12290921e-34,
0.0214844011,
-0.0000132825,
0.0326634273,
0.0000382301,
0.0385757498,
0.0386125147,
0.0201581363,
0.0113491593,
-0.0030403051,
-0.0647587776,
-0.0046874238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13712v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13712v2 | Harnessing the Power of LLMs in Practice: A Survey on ChatGPT and Beyond | 2023-04-26T17:52:30 | 2023-04-27T17:56:11 | Jingfeng Yang, Hongye Jin, Ruixiang Tang, Xiaotian Han, Qizhang Feng, Haoming Jiang, Bing Yin, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper presents a comprehensive and practical guide for practitioners and
end-users working with Large Language Models (LLMs) in their downstream natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. We provide discussions and insights into the
usage of LLMs from the perspectives of models, data, and downstream tasks.
Firstly, we offer an introduction and brief summary of current GPT- and
BERT-style LLMs. Then, we discuss the influence of pre-training data, training
data, and test data. Most importantly, we provide a detailed discussion about
the use and non-use cases of large language models for various natural language
processing tasks, such as knowledge-intensive tasks, traditional natural
language understanding tasks, natural language generation tasks, emergent
abilities, and considerations for specific tasks.We present various use cases
and non-use cases to illustrate the practical applications and limitations of
LLMs in real-world scenarios. We also try to understand the importance of data
and the specific challenges associated with each NLP task. Furthermore, we
explore the impact of spurious biases on LLMs and delve into other essential
considerations, such as efficiency, cost, and latency, to ensure a
comprehensive understanding of deploying LLMs in practice. This comprehensive
guide aims to provide researchers and practitioners with valuable insights and
best practices for working with LLMs, thereby enabling the successful
implementation of these models in a wide range of NLP tasks. A curated list of
practical guide resources of LLMs, regularly updated, can be found at
\url{https://github.com/Mooler0410/LLMsPracticalGuide}. | [
0.0518850163,
0.0453800634,
-0.0158996638,
0.0422372408,
-0.0661600083,
0.0173304062,
-0.0136674307,
-0.0052477345,
0.0484511815,
-0.0804340094,
-0.0028956258,
-0.0206433013,
-0.0054414831,
0.0172346253,
0.0191901028,
-0.0395972654,
0.0597764999,
-0.0178672746,
-0.0070457933,
0.0270848032,
0.0100006694,
0.030337261,
0.0035711098,
0.0581683367,
-0.0261669699,
-0.0067238705,
0.0087013282,
0.0107269725,
-0.0021400468,
-0.0330199301,
0.0100074233,
0.0366788954,
0.0480084568,
0.0503227264,
0.0000019091,
-0.0837879404,
-0.0113777146,
0.0053440896,
-0.0479827672,
0.0108163748,
0.0342813395,
-0.0156344008,
-0.0085782446,
0.0299004223,
-0.0318490937,
0.0088741342,
0.0315950736,
0.0347643197,
0.0548609234,
0.0898946151,
-0.0024660414,
-0.0338563547,
0.0278831068,
-0.0095240921,
0.0046324879,
-0.0404702909,
0.0537091643,
0.020415483,
0.0188961811,
0.0075334003,
-0.0050027082,
0.022176519,
0.0006093394,
0.0086938683,
0.001029067,
0.039348688,
-0.0400646925,
-0.0320327319,
-0.0461181998,
0.0671110079,
-0.004143375,
-0.0067717107,
0.0275124274,
0.0012622295,
-0.0139416717,
0.0056758793,
-0.0515518822,
0.0472261533,
-0.0025429698,
0.0468455777,
0.0203459859,
-0.0273718107,
0.0274096746,
0.0273421612,
-0.0343790203,
0.0518307872,
0.0189416725,
-0.0323329605,
0.0233277101,
-0.0041334699,
-0.058268331,
-0.0543562919,
0.0120251924,
0.0403940789,
-0.0100789582,
0.0493334271,
-0.0244295727,
-0.0017906486,
0.0416322835,
-0.0472262092,
0.0214094929,
0.0225713328,
-0.0122812474,
0.0430760235,
-0.0380900837,
0.04913738,
0.0027727683,
0.0038377661,
-0.0193509813,
-0.0290944297,
-0.0716291666,
-0.0302070901,
-0.0456414595,
0.0370720886,
-0.0374662802,
-0.0482205115,
-0.0354631618,
0.0210376028,
0.0260168537,
-0.0005322305,
0.060177397,
0.006289525,
-0.0172843728,
-0.0100286389,
-0.0301386081,
0.0103319334,
-0.0006511967,
0.0061476212,
-0.0130496398,
-0.0611045025,
-0.0094924774,
0.0287470073,
0.0014158665,
-0.0221836716,
0.0162944216,
0.075909093,
0.0318427719,
-0.0516937971,
-0.0559912249,
-0.0133410087,
-0.0143174939,
-0.0855141655,
-0.011264897,
-0.0364443995,
0.0161523093,
0.0168979876,
0.0295876935,
-0.0301620737,
0.0274519138,
0.0283347275,
-0.0406324044,
0.0869805962,
-0.0347730592,
0.0332526602,
0.0175968856,
-0.0023412646,
0.0136960121,
0.078309387,
0.0508505292,
0.0087635946,
0.0431765653,
-0.0124348886,
-0.0153711522,
0.0550542735,
-0.0209349431,
-0.0362876505,
-0.0060703736,
0.0065261507,
-0.0153728398,
0.0463394932,
0.0041772136,
0.0667190626,
-0.0117058931,
0.0206225906,
0.0450913906,
0.0777704269,
0.0197458677,
0.0112944692,
0.0469817743,
0.0414296016,
-0.0045401608,
-0.0333155394,
-0.027203586,
-0.0068415608,
-0.0337751731,
-0.0025479912,
-0.0062161949,
0.0726969093,
-0.0109687084,
-0.0208281446,
-0.0555156395,
0.0009143996,
-0.0002650375,
-0.0004905023,
0.0536928065,
0.0031173767,
-0.0368519835,
0.0479460694,
0.0153683191,
-0.0371368155,
0.0182335079,
-0.0880396217,
0.0022208432,
0.0778528824,
0.0796604604,
-0.0156865511,
-0.0469196104,
-0.0004875278,
-0.0066670761,
0.0465225056,
0.0084082978,
-0.0063959374,
-0.0223381016,
-0.0638237894,
-0.0254000127,
0.0148780141,
0.0053885244,
-0.0018048543,
0.0364981182,
-0.0114919981,
0.0204521362,
-0.0526379421,
-0.0232275464,
0.0668888614,
-0.0477488525,
-0.0479774587,
0.0065316679,
-0.020641014,
0.0459379889,
0.0250947848,
-0.0078713875,
0.0119383736,
0.025342891,
-0.0054970076,
0.0023713561,
0.034064237,
-0.014540229,
-0.0499004945,
0.039090082,
-0.0124207409,
-0.0093749464,
0.0218029395,
-0.0317291953,
-0.036855001,
-0.0228017978,
-0.0643021911,
0.0512273759,
-0.0714126155,
0.0120842187,
0.0138072968,
0.0105976714,
-0.0412717424,
0.0735537261,
0.0048683127,
-0.0108072963,
0.0093133952,
0.0066103316,
0.0131890615,
-0.0261259265,
-0.014696884,
0.0094186543,
0.0070714452,
-0.0028052917,
0.0258731004,
0.0396954715,
-0.0588798076,
-0.0337343179,
-0.1139160097,
0.0434262194,
-0.0269224215,
0.0294742379,
0.0042238804,
-0.0027904145,
-0.0458250828,
0.0046384861,
-0.0304327961,
0.0043603457,
0.0520142019,
-0.0004861539,
0.0337371789,
-0.0041392548,
-0.0341902152,
-0.0165438633,
0.0232812632,
-0.0194958746,
0.0341370143,
0.0143742347,
-0.0416535698,
-0.0560389087,
0.0315679461,
-0.0107104834,
0.0173365399,
0.0012771755,
-0.0187227391,
0.0064179488,
-0.0004559408,
0.0824646801,
-0.0095165502,
0.0001127518,
0.0536495931,
0.0226300098,
-0.0593130514,
-0.0421784855,
0.0098419227,
-0.0424517728,
-0.0208192859,
-0.0490309484,
-0.0164374765,
0.0301399995,
0.0580753461,
0.0066019101,
-0.0250689946,
-0.0517217368,
0.0150044933,
-0.0259083044,
-0.0222078189,
0.0005838662,
-0.0076418221,
-0.021157911,
0.0204518717,
-0.0140764341,
-0.0573335998,
0.0647858158,
-0.0431560799,
-0.0002016528,
-0.0673535168,
-0.0048244684,
-0.0785955191,
0.062446557,
-0.0068394393,
0.0098735327,
0.0072981636,
-0.038749747,
0.0038240752,
-0.0087849842,
-0.0296300165,
-0.0291435607,
0.0380684882,
-0.0777574927,
0.0385125987,
0.0093606636,
-0.0101507697,
-0.050363861,
-0.0504288822,
-0.0247958153,
0.0252513904,
0.0246250816,
-0.0093430839,
-0.0323992781,
0.0091478862,
0.0013185251,
0.0125792725,
0.0081348866,
-0.0158134829,
-0.0264193248,
0.0326487124,
0.0453159884,
0.0121590234,
0.0363207236,
-0.011934977,
0.0172664374,
0.0411899537,
0.0276035294,
0.0032793407,
-0.0402735695,
0.0109894499,
0.0287688263,
-0.078002952,
0.005062866,
0.0206654668,
0.0473960005,
-0.0782348365,
-0.002488543,
0.1354047209,
0.0397484265,
-0.0084768105,
0.0058457376,
0.0133077595,
0.0138582038,
0.0204860307,
0.0134597728,
-0.0791831836,
-0.0411601551,
0.0089941993,
-0.001623165,
-0.0295930952,
-0.0431143865,
-0.0403233841,
-0.1242412254,
0.0456095859,
0.0039215866,
0.0089086443,
-0.0224613342,
-0.0418957509,
-0.0198972002,
-0.0171144325,
0.0284175705,
-0.0260151941,
-0.0414365456,
-0.0022696885,
0.0395369045,
-0.0567488149,
-0.0770729929,
0.01811295,
-0.0448763706,
0.0772408247,
0.072707586,
0.0326708071,
-0.0010527626,
-0.0009412668,
0.03218472,
-0.0155603243,
0.0137215508,
-0.0331154577,
0.0156895984,
-0.025717089,
-0.0070163128,
-0.0476098657,
0.0257248934,
-0.0440158099,
-0.0263392627,
0.0221612584,
0.0982622504,
-0.0430733599,
-0.0204254612,
-0.0366210565,
0.0076395557,
0.0096427016,
0.105012089,
0.0158313625,
-0.0302521605,
-0.0424475409,
0.0061324411,
0.0079500759,
-0.03344661,
-0.0393485501,
0.0219248086,
-0.0015190787,
0.0212854147,
-0.0443392061,
-0.0298608821,
0.0667847767,
-0.0173498727,
0.0272943359,
0.0294686984,
-0.0035008078,
0.0178432222,
-0.0208934303,
0.0543245822,
-0.0430142432,
-0.0104008839,
-0.0454637557,
-0.0252800994,
0.0662890077,
-0.0286455322,
-0.0041354424,
0.0191584826,
-0.0759310201,
-0.0664505661,
-0.0185465161,
0.0213765576,
0.0240810867,
0.0385442525,
0.0050441842,
-0.0489481315,
0.0265539996,
0.0365926772,
-0.0259010959,
-0.0147242388,
-0.0051124338,
0.0442919396,
-0.0033972403,
0.0284765717,
-0.0063613486,
0.0125789987,
-0.0143613936,
0.0642098188,
-0.0143950181,
-0.0452796184,
0.0362640992,
0.0246183239,
0.0287723672,
-0.0446929634,
-0.0041804211,
-0.0586703606,
-0.0283441655,
-0.0305067897,
-0.0029080512,
-0.0516404249,
-0.005216856,
0.0196409691,
-0.0060233856,
-0.0354899205,
-0.0186233558,
-0.0398982316,
0.0218368024,
-0.0283079688,
0.0312121157,
-0.0052640811,
-0.0287259482,
0.012422544,
-0.0185055938,
-0.0137628503,
0.0206263289,
-0.022855781,
0.0102613792,
-0.0147161679,
0.0762127489,
-0.0062014232,
-0.0147914691,
-0.0023283397,
0.0177376345,
-0.0148113174,
-0.0352244228,
-0.0203158688,
0.0730524883,
0.0643047169,
-0.0036618318,
0.0429813266,
-0.0523834415,
0.0062132999,
-0.0252788849,
0.0246728808,
-0.0118341912,
-0.0208410732,
0.024635911,
0.0182279646,
-0.0610022917,
-0.0300741848,
0.082502909,
0.0486642197,
0.0570478626,
0.0096121673,
-0.0402881317,
-0.0495220646,
-0.040630918,
0.0364624448,
-0.0167675372,
-0.0174736492,
0.0543463938,
-0.0738552585,
-0.0638075173,
-0.003739222,
-0.0016421067,
0.0085235238,
-0.0133133223,
0.0593035556,
0.072272487,
-0.016760543,
-0.0194630362,
-0.049677901,
-0.0034258422,
-0.021987563,
-0.028594071,
0.0093841339,
-6.284217044e-33,
-0.0337121375,
-0.0443675779,
0.0657718405,
0.0089024743,
-0.0352069214,
-0.0020526564,
-0.0192547608,
-0.0272274297,
0.0141751813,
0.0007995137,
-0.0062807887,
-0.0094385194,
0.0090208352,
0.031174561,
0.001888348,
-0.0095803691,
0.0496940091,
0.0011198232,
0.0203117914,
0.0129992208,
0.030045392,
0.0475383624,
0.060148824,
-0.0354158394,
0.0173456557,
0.008262733,
-0.0046227938,
0.0261739325,
-0.0197486132,
0.0557832681,
-0.0579556935,
0.0472362377,
0.0449478924,
-0.0179935247,
-0.0143400384,
0.0350794531,
-0.0608896948,
-0.0200901665,
0.0356055759,
0.0048829522,
-0.0125918956,
-0.0324150994,
0.0412796289,
-0.029071169,
-0.0441072509,
0.0259202775,
0.0333643109,
-0.0199541617,
-0.0051656314,
-0.0078017926,
-0.0743715614,
0.0455114171,
-0.0180975311,
-0.0241533518,
0.0427827723,
0.007036793,
-0.0277026594,
0.0063396869,
-0.028025765,
0.012562437,
0.0492723472,
0.009579503,
0.0602384582,
0.0233303029,
0.012432931,
0.0707481354,
-0.0150813563,
-0.0313381068,
-0.0271612667,
-0.0182578526,
0.0171991922,
0.0610346831,
0.0045177364,
0.0131726684,
-0.0047009853,
-0.0054913871,
-0.0748970062,
0.012784142,
0.0504108928,
0.0419354253,
0.0201718081,
-0.0116066113,
-0.0429597273,
-0.0193248317,
-0.0316589437,
0.0081958985,
0.0004639495,
-0.0176612996,
0.0567117408,
0.0171890929,
-0.0008199316,
0.026430482,
0.0307458937,
-0.047476273,
-0.00954461,
-0.0066599012,
0.0224878378,
-0.0093751056,
-0.0077500544,
0.0544250719,
-0.0730709434,
-0.0578813516,
0.0151163917,
-0.020690931,
-0.0128077501,
-0.0236667506,
-0.0142394323,
0.0325697064,
-0.0404394902,
0.009613093,
-0.0274871103,
0.0335958339,
-0.0375417434,
0.0170610901,
0.035820704,
0.0196845997,
-0.0111003378,
0.0291392859,
0.0317399688,
-0.0080237063,
-0.008109333,
-0.0052460241,
-0.0138579821,
0.0181978978,
-0.0245678946,
0.0192392841,
-0.0160337444,
-0.008004548,
0.015939815,
-0.0296646729,
0.0019850968,
0.0218654815,
2.704e-7,
0.0609308258,
0.0852536634,
0.0338816978,
0.0152491406,
0.0103751374,
-0.0103558907,
-0.0330846235,
0.0198132917,
-0.0148701901,
-0.0220479891,
0.0093640191,
0.0345551707,
0.0524029844,
0.0105837137,
-0.079611741,
-0.0133161787,
-0.0416828021,
-0.0129579809,
-0.096782431,
0.0146440556,
0.0773979872,
0.0811446905,
-0.01260255,
-0.0145934885,
-0.0100153703,
-0.0388413072,
0.065609403,
-0.0457358323,
-0.0267927852,
0.0455994383,
0.0551802702,
0.0407882333,
0.0258983951,
0.0195338633,
0.0172887538,
0.0313677415,
-0.0008232871,
0.072888732,
0.0033812842,
-0.0225801449,
0.0113497516,
-0.0074511832,
-0.0033032987,
-0.0573450923,
0.078528814,
-0.0685945749,
-0.0349380933,
-0.0348093398,
0.007136018,
-0.0363944285,
-0.0084647946,
-0.0294572022,
-0.0244841147,
0.013898721,
0.0330330692,
-0.0130348764,
-0.0298361983,
-0.0909374282,
0.0302525125,
0.0023654127,
-0.0770488381,
-0.0275902487,
-0.0441097133,
0.0040138597,
0.0259053335,
-0.062704742,
-0.0071569341,
2.866948758e-34,
0.0194251649,
-0.0245846417,
0.003224842,
0.0325576104,
0.0420007482,
0.0147228325,
0.0183482822,
0.0150706563,
-0.0115108807,
-0.0937447622,
0.0066880034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13689v2 | HeySQuAD: A Spoken Question Answering Dataset | 2023-04-26T17:15:39 | 2024-02-27T13:57:08 | Yijing Wu, SaiKrishna Rallabandi, Ravisutha Srinivasamurthy, Parag Pravin Dakle, Alolika Gon, Preethi Raghavan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spoken question answering (SQA) systems are critical for digital assistants
and other real-world use cases, but evaluating their performance is a challenge
due to the importance of human-spoken questions. This study presents a new
large-scale community-shared SQA dataset called HeySQuAD, which includes 76k
human-spoken questions, 97k machine-generated questions, and their
corresponding textual answers from the SQuAD QA dataset. Our goal is to measure
the ability of machines to accurately understand noisy spoken questions and
provide reliable answers. Through extensive testing, we demonstrate that
training with transcribed human-spoken and original SQuAD questions leads to a
significant improvement (12.51%) in answering human-spoken questions compared
to training with only the original SQuAD textual questions. Moreover,
evaluating with a higher-quality transcription can lead to a further
improvement of 2.03%. This research has significant implications for the
development of SQA systems and their ability to meet the needs of users in
real-world scenarios. | [
0.0289947595,
0.0455904193,
-0.0071244803,
0.0088231042,
0.0033133081,
-0.0054545221,
0.0246614069,
-0.0270317011,
-0.03426373,
-0.0118187508,
-0.0547552779,
-0.0148143601,
0.0013856154,
0.0141497953,
0.0312353205,
-0.0319108889,
0.0460669659,
-0.0443858467,
0.0033757226,
-0.0102846278,
0.0059425049,
0.0184120163,
-0.0402745008,
0.0426882841,
-0.0061997226,
0.0031664239,
-0.0190217011,
-0.0036696142,
0.0185919888,
0.0010393729,
0.0100282179,
0.0282255728,
0.0265781004,
0.0338076912,
0.0000015306,
-0.0415936895,
0.0071678986,
-0.000966302,
-0.0746544003,
0.0014234324,
-0.0086726481,
0.0328063816,
0.0049459725,
0.0374251567,
-0.0341431797,
0.0025611122,
0.0314894542,
-0.0254219379,
0.0714479089,
0.0594692938,
-0.0010643924,
-0.016884055,
0.0139545389,
-0.0031364202,
0.0338818915,
-0.0874047056,
-0.0016737572,
0.0184084717,
0.0365685485,
-0.0462223925,
0.0350260995,
0.0384222008,
0.012891273,
-0.0019533378,
0.0033925942,
0.0084305201,
-0.076226756,
0.0085295858,
-0.0212636255,
0.115572229,
0.0127651766,
0.0108518424,
-0.013197965,
0.0230317991,
-0.0073345331,
-0.0115968576,
-0.0260949638,
-0.0078676799,
-0.016103778,
-0.0165144838,
-0.0518824272,
0.0110844439,
0.0021038172,
0.0060027707,
-0.0077901362,
0.0517097153,
-0.0062478073,
-0.0410148986,
0.0210773014,
-0.0050445632,
-0.0375503339,
-0.0214134865,
0.046569787,
0.061477989,
-0.0660724193,
0.0111768022,
-0.0288201384,
-0.0229393356,
0.0345029049,
-0.0239079613,
0.0227805227,
0.0174814966,
-0.0241946112,
0.0650414452,
-0.0208993722,
0.0679383948,
0.0051654889,
0.0103402529,
-0.0439586863,
-0.0491235852,
-0.0585774556,
0.0005763283,
-0.0761856437,
0.0208339188,
-0.0325241573,
-0.007171534,
-0.0119433636,
0.0223241914,
0.0270593297,
0.0364561081,
0.00919207,
0.0567207709,
-0.0440102704,
-0.0007790552,
-0.0100597255,
0.0158786085,
-0.0790108144,
0.0463789068,
0.0184263494,
-0.0743699372,
-0.0134033114,
0.0156019926,
0.0504791327,
-0.0082041183,
0.0164014176,
0.0240732953,
-0.0206430648,
-0.0363249294,
0.0299986657,
-0.0299162306,
0.005308989,
-0.0464119539,
-0.0369565673,
-0.0436257236,
0.0638152882,
-0.0155525887,
-0.0073844208,
0.0106339138,
0.0014813445,
0.0392882116,
0.0113084009,
0.0959241912,
-0.033297196,
0.048278857,
0.0388678871,
0.0006624696,
-0.0348205008,
0.0237097852,
0.0497773178,
0.012635855,
0.0720666349,
-0.0097340019,
0.0435618088,
0.0419371352,
0.0144074708,
0.0019787599,
-0.005183158,
0.0633789003,
-0.0324537791,
0.0359644257,
0.0122799007,
0.0712461099,
-0.0060162563,
-0.0504294187,
0.0633925423,
0.0711146668,
-0.015006111,
-0.0273397397,
0.0184007529,
0.0271345582,
0.0394927412,
-0.0141241308,
-0.0444829427,
-0.013614947,
-0.023797404,
0.0260411724,
0.017259635,
-0.0047894856,
-0.0540325865,
-0.0088327266,
-0.0117769735,
-0.0108436532,
-0.0160783343,
0.0517183132,
0.0047295298,
-0.0138505865,
-0.0198901817,
0.0234920997,
-0.0391660444,
-0.0606206208,
0.0061573051,
-0.0445170514,
0.0643777326,
0.0437728316,
0.0450743251,
-0.0465591401,
-0.0452451073,
-0.0307511482,
-0.0037931369,
0.0208484754,
0.0167955235,
-0.0426832885,
0.0763840079,
-0.0381594785,
0.0053302925,
0.0368676856,
-0.0136065334,
-0.0009778588,
0.0304811448,
-0.0057838666,
0.0128119243,
-0.0584476106,
-0.0158608239,
0.0163778793,
0.0013067761,
-0.0349498317,
0.0180791616,
0.0157377478,
0.0468551777,
0.045204699,
-0.0461990424,
-0.0030869283,
0.045725219,
-0.019655345,
-0.014676881,
0.0102714244,
-0.0390725769,
-0.0283466093,
0.0459059253,
-0.0427903086,
-0.0504457094,
0.0844569877,
-0.0306386389,
-0.0359124206,
-0.0223241784,
-0.0862098113,
-0.0330647416,
-0.0519323125,
-0.0227425043,
0.0267046522,
0.0248583779,
-0.0103397947,
0.0125216795,
0.0213080328,
0.004011842,
0.0278701242,
0.0196780562,
0.0381003916,
-0.0612887144,
0.0022809617,
0.0176962987,
-0.0093241688,
0.0324549489,
-0.0001157615,
-0.0103309108,
-0.0592355244,
0.0007121992,
-0.0901191086,
0.0185084436,
-0.0289363656,
0.0189650767,
0.0474395491,
0.0120270569,
-0.0218028631,
-0.0359896645,
-0.0806470886,
0.0010269303,
0.042422425,
0.0280996263,
-0.0005590806,
0.0021764629,
0.0064319256,
-0.0467074886,
-0.0000328621,
-0.0046934099,
-0.0097508775,
0.014772729,
0.0166030265,
-0.0418238863,
0.0148862163,
-0.0389981195,
0.0366249345,
0.0089521166,
-0.0740376785,
0.0279781464,
-0.0076091834,
0.0133195613,
0.0642925501,
0.0274210237,
-0.0369622856,
0.0303678028,
0.0333986282,
-0.0331939086,
0.0313322134,
0.0005418815,
-0.0436022766,
-0.0304427762,
-0.0313221216,
0.0066000624,
0.011781577,
0.0336587541,
0.0257073417,
-0.0212961137,
0.0063727144,
0.0132949809,
-0.0158063341,
-0.0621601157,
-0.0232611429,
-0.040905159,
0.0653737113,
-0.0034903397,
-0.0174927171,
0.0765880197,
-0.0318696015,
-0.0433579721,
-0.0740363225,
-0.0500420593,
-0.0322814062,
0.0487927012,
-0.0428095646,
0.0091587529,
-0.0151184965,
-0.0438827425,
-0.0422663502,
-0.0142859528,
-0.002655854,
-0.0537792295,
-0.0040225699,
-0.0237239879,
0.0150787849,
-0.02187635,
-0.0337435119,
-0.0711899325,
-0.0310748033,
-0.0525847189,
0.0370604619,
0.0038453012,
-0.0289651416,
-0.0063738776,
-0.0004707104,
0.0438844562,
0.0252362229,
-0.0032770729,
-0.0025504946,
-0.0225588847,
0.0705601275,
0.0838400722,
0.0840646774,
0.0159789473,
0.0089329127,
0.0486929789,
0.0297173653,
0.0839490965,
-0.0081995046,
-0.0210163835,
-0.0264830533,
0.0018625724,
-0.0066377972,
0.0252595004,
0.0253307354,
0.0771024227,
-0.021776367,
-0.0096630445,
0.1124887541,
0.0301459339,
-0.0334490128,
0.0021870264,
-0.0026961071,
0.0151491938,
0.0238748845,
0.0286102034,
-0.0944532007,
-0.0525469333,
0.0086724749,
0.0944975093,
0.0206018984,
-0.0070226621,
0.0016737051,
-0.1065839678,
0.0064324248,
-0.0341385417,
-0.1070695594,
-0.0607777275,
-0.0420671925,
0.0109644877,
-0.0321104079,
0.0369459242,
-0.0029333017,
0.0185553264,
0.0044277702,
0.015075597,
-0.0287913065,
-0.0180793554,
0.0674597621,
-0.0390197001,
0.0642202348,
0.1024068892,
0.0164827816,
0.0071019758,
-0.041070506,
-0.0048546065,
-0.0363569111,
0.0045686513,
0.0317278691,
0.0707658231,
-0.0250814706,
-0.0279561058,
0.0071801413,
0.0602509938,
-0.0290996265,
0.0210630447,
0.0471784025,
0.0405746438,
-0.0008002275,
-0.0072489688,
-0.0084212655,
0.0230150148,
0.029552782,
0.0847431496,
0.0438576154,
-0.0218044762,
-0.0130514875,
-0.0014364234,
0.0139619531,
-0.0682947114,
-0.0306697842,
0.0122021465,
0.0018838785,
0.0142221656,
-0.0819517374,
-0.0855404362,
0.0532919057,
0.019818984,
-0.0202477016,
-0.0150654176,
-0.000013908,
0.0461460501,
-0.0314306393,
0.0363380574,
-0.0292415768,
0.0451061092,
-0.0584105514,
-0.0210433844,
0.0211446285,
-0.0068155308,
-0.0159769468,
0.0088523207,
-0.0732118189,
-0.0315597765,
0.015308897,
0.0358572751,
0.0207761601,
0.0128565226,
-0.046442546,
-0.0595528148,
0.0189600103,
0.0286908988,
-0.0882003307,
-0.0004681614,
0.0453348793,
0.0052405912,
-0.0298372731,
0.0378393941,
-0.0589305349,
0.0164416488,
-0.0454620421,
0.0255790167,
-0.0447486378,
-0.0686043575,
0.0118453968,
0.0459566079,
0.0240389295,
0.0257028602,
0.0019958129,
0.0144059313,
0.0426343679,
0.003502571,
-0.0045953803,
-0.0306646693,
-0.0201223418,
0.021563584,
-0.0399894118,
0.016461784,
-0.0064474945,
-0.0618864149,
0.0117983064,
-0.0248761009,
0.0125821689,
0.0488908216,
0.014977416,
0.0089632887,
0.0078268899,
-0.0215813871,
0.0326723047,
0.0084692864,
0.0648962557,
0.0415466987,
0.0192041676,
-0.0045612869,
-0.0148650436,
0.0097346986,
0.0254611857,
-0.0933447182,
-0.0717594028,
0.0130039034,
0.0228932556,
0.0291082114,
0.0099081369,
0.0163675994,
0.02719138,
0.0109658297,
-0.0323971398,
-0.0129341157,
-0.0083492966,
0.0285429265,
0.0553120077,
0.0283192545,
-0.0102887284,
0.0439402722,
0.0746617615,
-0.0058388943,
0.0501412489,
-0.0227701422,
-0.0099790636,
-0.0391669832,
-0.0086953314,
-0.0104695391,
0.0322207846,
-0.0352822095,
-0.0014910692,
-0.0190517493,
-0.061270792,
0.0161786322,
0.0108713442,
0.0264537651,
-0.0150473835,
0.040543966,
0.0250895005,
-0.0135232862,
-0.0314180329,
-0.022471752,
0.0241504889,
-0.042386543,
-0.0167306289,
-0.0073501277,
-5.690279789e-33,
-0.0118866386,
-0.03035862,
0.0234476142,
-0.0303234216,
-0.0088811377,
0.0105531914,
-0.0377987884,
-0.0094446205,
-0.050062906,
-0.0155776693,
-0.0391834006,
0.0139937652,
0.015065372,
0.0322624519,
-0.014121254,
-0.0626486838,
0.0280051976,
-0.0440841801,
-0.0244200174,
0.0217623003,
0.0431867503,
0.0349682979,
0.0305703562,
-0.0469116718,
0.0057281964,
-0.016848499,
-0.0025574376,
0.0360658355,
-0.0015358597,
0.0442441069,
-0.0163814761,
0.040500842,
0.0136774527,
-0.0200014878,
-0.0074836877,
0.0648383796,
-0.0654686093,
-0.0068141818,
-0.0082619544,
0.0186610371,
-0.0276825242,
-0.0132584982,
-0.0033026931,
-0.0211818796,
0.0239550993,
-0.0211403761,
0.0343657173,
-0.0363672711,
-0.0150372768,
-0.0375587791,
-0.0090879714,
0.0252713766,
-0.0339076072,
-0.0485694297,
-0.0150259631,
0.1000868604,
-0.0169883519,
0.0083509376,
-0.0495267063,
0.0111160055,
-0.0077166697,
0.0099067064,
0.0381994173,
-0.00635004,
-0.0246794205,
0.0116655948,
0.042607896,
-0.0352743082,
-0.0241138935,
-0.030164063,
-0.0140790837,
0.0387301743,
0.0702225119,
0.0630688369,
0.0359911621,
0.0148345772,
-0.0432745516,
0.0674291179,
0.0277885776,
0.0264851861,
-0.0149175087,
0.0145320036,
-0.049851574,
0.0204775408,
-0.0536870174,
0.0409316048,
-0.0279885828,
-0.0158982519,
0.054716073,
-0.0120502338,
-0.0325534493,
0.0023067498,
0.0366036668,
-0.025846377,
0.047718972,
0.0239867847,
-0.0040747938,
0.0200220514,
0.0102275787,
0.0170962922,
-0.0762385651,
0.0554507077,
0.0751181319,
0.0554851107,
0.0192899946,
-0.0071516121,
0.0378833748,
0.0247160792,
-0.0446639434,
0.0157844927,
-0.0066382098,
0.0192248076,
-0.0309273303,
-0.0154875722,
0.0260250587,
0.0017437185,
-0.0113131199,
0.0114067737,
-0.0258988291,
-0.0112868743,
-0.0314568318,
-0.0387174301,
-0.0103700804,
0.0055838507,
-0.0566601828,
0.0162190646,
-0.0392179452,
0.0180878248,
-0.0216659885,
-0.0023117203,
0.0008296093,
-0.0107061407,
2.3e-7,
0.0228425693,
0.0011681509,
0.0461107343,
0.0403157175,
0.0074752611,
0.0291528832,
0.0133850854,
0.0229621902,
0.0202199202,
-0.0053725373,
0.0239424929,
0.0278574228,
0.0782517567,
0.039815966,
-0.0720985681,
-0.0730229393,
-0.073324047,
0.0177306011,
-0.0309294965,
-0.0147112561,
0.0645396337,
0.0888274461,
-0.0107073635,
-0.031606935,
-0.0117153609,
-0.0551185459,
-0.0108790332,
0.0119926231,
-0.0019408703,
-0.0213167612,
0.015226379,
0.0095997844,
-0.0194112211,
0.0103027783,
-0.0238717701,
0.0102926306,
0.0285419766,
0.0402731597,
-0.0179969557,
-0.0829151869,
-0.0401454978,
-0.0196668748,
0.0325821042,
-0.0396032147,
0.1008566543,
-0.0142577486,
-0.0046258979,
-0.0285364501,
-0.0427020937,
-0.0237284973,
0.003589713,
-0.0277723484,
-0.0027040581,
0.0104327584,
-0.0000930783,
-0.0038006837,
-0.0137703726,
-0.0740567893,
0.0066292193,
0.0102860415,
-0.0357383117,
-0.0333801992,
-0.0150073366,
0.000628881,
-0.0184391998,
-0.0412522294,
0.0033742266,
1.100560145e-34,
0.0096116718,
0.0181063637,
0.013961398,
0.039882388,
0.023802042,
-0.029938478,
-0.0021479873,
-0.0370697789,
0.0471013412,
-0.0633452162,
-0.0003734266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13664v1 | Using Implicit Feedback to Improve Question Generation | 2023-04-26T16:37:47 | 2023-04-26T16:37:47 | Hugo Rodrigues, Eric Nyberg, Luisa Coheur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Question Generation (QG) is a task of Natural Language Processing (NLP) that
aims at automatically generating questions from text. Many applications can
benefit from automatically generated questions, but often it is necessary to
curate those questions, either by selecting or editing them. This task is
informative on its own, but it is typically done post-generation, and, thus,
the effort is wasted. In addition, most existing systems cannot incorporate
this feedback back into them easily. In this work, we present a system, GEN,
that learns from such (implicit) feedback. Following a pattern-based approach,
it takes as input a small set of sentence/question pairs and creates patterns
which are then applied to new unseen sentences. Each generated question, after
being corrected by the user, is used as a new seed in the next iteration, so
more patterns are created each time. We also take advantage of the corrections
made by the user to score the patterns and therefore rank the generated
questions. Results show that GEN is able to improve by learning from both
levels of implicit feedback when compared to the version with no learning,
considering the top 5, 10, and 20 questions. Improvements go up from 10%,
depending on the metric and strategy used. | [
0.072590597,
0.0173095167,
-0.0290774517,
0.0072258664,
-0.046177987,
0.0069474946,
-0.0104080467,
0.0113548571,
0.0166167133,
-0.0239928514,
0.0322152749,
-0.0342796631,
-0.0238901488,
0.0646395609,
0.0498088337,
-0.0369612165,
0.0214353502,
-0.0005036679,
-0.0303468946,
0.0372763686,
0.0212512612,
0.0041441582,
-0.0105470568,
0.0157393739,
-0.0265640337,
0.0104351807,
-0.0727171749,
0.0160029307,
-0.0102487039,
-0.0494812205,
0.0107706599,
0.0352734998,
0.0002887681,
-0.0012181253,
0.0000017236,
-0.0589565709,
-0.0202362295,
-0.0254920125,
0.0075603211,
-0.040679004,
-0.0102893244,
0.0328222141,
0.0156237893,
0.0358066484,
-0.0629989952,
-0.0039497106,
0.0151773067,
0.029693272,
0.081521146,
0.0518488996,
-0.0191800743,
-0.0065084104,
0.0086663812,
0.0132425455,
0.0701483116,
0.004593038,
-0.009484875,
0.0054616751,
0.0268962253,
0.006343829,
0.0196929295,
-0.0041255425,
0.0290825609,
-0.0608926788,
0.0432344079,
0.0382790156,
-0.0115509052,
-0.053665176,
-0.039329607,
0.0917330906,
0.0243983697,
-0.0128637664,
0.0165651478,
-0.0008622806,
0.0367741548,
0.0129381176,
-0.0270363651,
-0.0118241506,
-0.0197392423,
-0.0360773057,
0.0184275024,
-0.0136748916,
-0.0212937612,
0.0083877761,
0.0386262909,
0.0184833389,
0.0247946437,
-0.0576329492,
-0.0276852772,
0.000065102,
-0.0268299486,
-0.0961974636,
0.0396765061,
0.0581165887,
-0.0541508943,
0.0188755542,
-0.0369407199,
-0.0072732968,
0.0060434593,
0.0009478428,
0.0040241634,
0.0223908387,
0.0084353173,
0.0211494435,
-0.0297226794,
0.0176781081,
0.0468552187,
-0.0155909611,
-0.0728254318,
0.0361219198,
-0.0340007842,
-0.008000752,
-0.0620616935,
0.0608944632,
-0.0074333828,
-0.0142922159,
-0.0412930362,
0.0670197308,
0.0382894352,
0.0229749754,
-0.0081264507,
0.0373615772,
-0.0505419113,
0.0154412314,
-0.0533733852,
-0.0150464773,
-0.0577853844,
-0.0093202163,
0.0556056499,
-0.0380543545,
-0.0147616547,
0.0034321372,
0.0796784535,
0.0340526812,
-0.0137764774,
0.0099861091,
-0.0158207547,
-0.0215419177,
-0.029114645,
-0.0670581385,
0.003014476,
0.0061642556,
-0.0441502295,
-0.0334704965,
-0.0018460621,
0.0065915822,
-0.0375276394,
0.0269399863,
0.0346402712,
0.0597747341,
0.0067755487,
0.0567305014,
-0.0145023866,
0.0126371114,
0.0559052043,
-0.0038101545,
0.0284784548,
0.0150267277,
0.0431149378,
0.034828417,
0.0378540382,
0.009631509,
0.0301661808,
-0.0226992909,
0.0234094243,
-0.0140329199,
-0.016278252,
0.023669932,
-0.0223527458,
0.0569777861,
-0.0463062152,
0.0601245835,
0.0001383596,
0.0506262854,
0.0567003898,
0.0350804254,
0.0008038803,
0.048605103,
0.0868242756,
0.0010948585,
-0.0098068221,
0.0437241644,
0.0011511705,
0.0231664013,
-0.0396444723,
-0.0058884444,
0.0356267169,
-0.030468734,
-0.0095887426,
-0.0540352501,
0.0042565297,
0.0357809886,
-0.0030903299,
0.008715773,
0.0102851689,
0.0653143004,
-0.0458453894,
-0.0020617354,
-0.0090878233,
-0.0484689027,
0.0206120219,
-0.0335846208,
0.0788263828,
0.0324907228,
0.0435075685,
-0.0081585674,
-0.0373662189,
0.0026310068,
-0.0373323672,
0.0213896241,
0.0684910789,
-0.0510382727,
-0.0222737677,
-0.0409050435,
-0.0006751679,
0.0095080761,
-0.0150864599,
0.005971361,
-0.0105044954,
0.0000539817,
0.0330181904,
-0.0095530804,
-0.0360968299,
0.044401858,
-0.0229088441,
-0.0337479301,
0.0556069538,
-0.0126400245,
-0.009279578,
0.0239409376,
0.0148811759,
0.0315386318,
0.0373012163,
-0.0226378758,
-0.0707758293,
0.0179859288,
-0.0556972884,
-0.0683123693,
0.0023266305,
-0.0135373576,
0.0187026057,
0.000856164,
-0.0395587198,
-0.0427797437,
0.0145669254,
-0.0569698773,
0.0163453966,
-0.0521019399,
0.0094729904,
0.0362944975,
-0.0374325477,
-0.0673704222,
0.0537111983,
0.0235141777,
0.0227552988,
-0.0184396189,
0.0118756006,
0.0303447768,
-0.0265298244,
0.0270200148,
-0.0268929414,
-0.0419732109,
-0.0016113769,
0.0417534374,
0.0401432291,
-0.0901223198,
-0.0086558079,
-0.052286543,
0.0477563404,
-0.0272453893,
0.002300726,
0.0369624719,
0.0644138604,
-0.0124845533,
-0.0447767153,
-0.074407652,
0.0158250593,
0.0388747305,
-0.0098150326,
0.0735911131,
0.0524556339,
0.0170378108,
-0.0110511361,
0.0142374411,
-0.03890872,
0.0113630844,
0.0476589687,
0.0412989967,
-0.0692950934,
0.0292420052,
-0.0486642607,
-0.0175642055,
0.0458286218,
-0.0147806443,
0.0185506567,
-0.0597402379,
0.0550729781,
0.0439641997,
0.0190226231,
0.0093749221,
-0.0172272231,
-0.000764153,
-0.0244560186,
0.0303902943,
-0.0333066657,
-0.0065543368,
0.0497485884,
-0.0265475996,
0.0190641694,
0.0384472497,
0.0338909179,
-0.0252304394,
-0.0301366281,
0.0948244259,
-0.0257924944,
0.0214992333,
-0.0654582754,
0.0010428698,
-0.0070344177,
0.0504382513,
-0.0382373072,
-0.0531930961,
0.0800124109,
0.0183235724,
-0.0011223051,
-0.0885995179,
0.0065645459,
-0.0337118581,
0.0502434485,
0.0321216434,
0.023882892,
0.0694097728,
-0.0533813536,
-0.0673495829,
0.0165488683,
0.0348542333,
-0.035582751,
0.0034740868,
-0.0565653816,
-0.0092981886,
0.0223579053,
-0.0539349616,
-0.0743505582,
-0.0411801152,
0.0284972172,
-0.0058335923,
0.0158548653,
0.0002779697,
0.0112776067,
-0.0104808984,
0.011323953,
0.0562274978,
-0.0350345969,
-0.0436184034,
-0.0111114485,
0.0963061675,
0.059534166,
0.0233706422,
0.022171909,
-0.0147226453,
0.0296731871,
0.020561371,
0.0064468533,
0.0216478445,
0.0025404608,
0.0369640775,
-0.0056088823,
-0.053194344,
-0.0021945764,
0.042252101,
0.0495178588,
-0.0425975434,
-0.055562865,
0.0966456234,
0.0983219147,
-0.0148094641,
0.0052391617,
-0.0184871759,
0.0216306373,
0.0429909825,
0.0528998561,
-0.0479631983,
-0.0026027716,
-0.001024209,
0.0273952764,
-0.0389388092,
-0.0420294516,
-0.0238574743,
-0.1309498101,
0.0236705001,
-0.0223480854,
-0.0373027213,
0.0391700119,
-0.0325888209,
-0.0295536462,
0.0393894464,
-0.049530372,
0.021344794,
-0.0197837129,
0.0208229665,
0.0204844624,
-0.0392552949,
-0.0198633838,
-0.0440026484,
-0.0190643556,
-0.0112232426,
0.0840425119,
0.0364473984,
0.025700625,
-0.0084229726,
-0.0033352098,
-0.0372013673,
-0.0145535078,
-0.0224511698,
0.0058061373,
0.0258188564,
-0.0078100609,
-0.0629287139,
0.0608781874,
-0.0138656469,
0.0389453247,
0.0316216983,
0.0079747289,
-0.0248509869,
0.001759466,
-0.0193253364,
0.0228798166,
0.010810555,
0.0360217504,
0.0485224575,
-0.0214880053,
0.0125079425,
-0.0428209864,
0.0124675632,
-0.0887408033,
-0.0395186208,
0.0047476357,
0.0091269109,
0.0396522507,
-0.1242917553,
-0.0454252362,
0.0343317352,
0.0451384746,
0.0279069915,
-0.0279506873,
0.0040394384,
0.0076648085,
-0.0317713805,
-0.012202465,
0.0448979773,
-0.0398174562,
-0.0339091904,
-0.0282996986,
0.0136385383,
-0.0465746745,
-0.0253176764,
0.0105053661,
-0.0533048324,
-0.0302693173,
-0.0180423856,
0.0618179068,
0.0110556763,
-0.0046538408,
-0.0258250572,
-0.0209122803,
0.0150622083,
0.0081292512,
-0.0038758898,
-0.0468310528,
-0.0734779611,
0.0234341342,
0.0015451938,
0.0293113254,
-0.0441835783,
0.0122825215,
-0.021824332,
0.0534029827,
-0.0119027169,
-0.0244953576,
0.0739889368,
0.0304450821,
0.0117338086,
-0.0131913815,
-0.0033588163,
-0.0138388779,
0.0115910508,
-0.0428669415,
-0.0419349782,
-0.0291112009,
0.0517871939,
-0.0133696897,
0.0028678435,
-0.0083533907,
-0.0083377464,
-0.0842060298,
0.0666338578,
-0.0235211775,
-0.0332454778,
0.0430383608,
0.0169194061,
0.0149755999,
-0.0128370412,
-0.0048008966,
-0.0093905823,
0.022946462,
0.0592504665,
-0.0127794622,
0.0598012879,
0.017049294,
0.0001899982,
-0.0010558099,
0.0234393105,
-0.0662687793,
-0.0427999236,
-0.0446915925,
-0.0138248671,
0.0188563224,
0.0141104516,
-0.0166745652,
-0.0100059723,
-0.0002335975,
0.0083386358,
0.0620602407,
0.0150249461,
-0.055127997,
0.0202630106,
0.0181160308,
0.0045413971,
0.0070314659,
0.018441854,
-0.0237138513,
0.0158591717,
0.0153994951,
-0.0267445389,
-0.0737543777,
0.0364283584,
0.0305216704,
0.0181339793,
-0.0004106669,
0.0603242181,
-0.0182220843,
-0.0304927863,
-0.0046437331,
0.0178499259,
0.051774133,
0.0054269778,
0.0559364446,
0.0565732643,
-0.026898941,
-0.0220598318,
-0.0707725957,
0.0308613311,
-0.0838932097,
-0.0683291703,
0.0036181135,
-5.935537134e-33,
-0.0254238136,
-0.0572683923,
-0.0030491874,
0.0076929997,
-0.0381935686,
-0.0009961078,
-0.0637220815,
0.0227475297,
0.0378869511,
0.0054819239,
-0.0210481565,
-0.0242099967,
-0.0150467362,
-0.001564084,
0.036614608,
-0.0197534282,
0.0637075379,
-0.015146045,
-0.0192900002,
0.0348813869,
0.003019172,
0.0417342335,
-0.0221515782,
0.0226078741,
0.0288387761,
-0.0468315333,
-0.0041767405,
0.0359225534,
0.0024057401,
0.0463954546,
-0.0025520504,
0.0118505191,
0.0378124677,
-0.0134533877,
0.0162703171,
0.0421485566,
-0.0313164294,
-0.033517763,
-0.042045787,
-0.0259888079,
-0.0696483254,
-0.0072998353,
0.0295724347,
-0.0255263299,
0.045372203,
0.0538705885,
0.0462967902,
-0.0036970768,
-0.0039030251,
-0.0401995964,
-0.0201345515,
-0.0230028164,
-0.0334332138,
-0.0675664321,
-0.0702274069,
0.0987428352,
0.004015062,
-0.0200391468,
0.0026951816,
0.0393747725,
0.019163534,
0.0460453629,
0.0071424921,
0.0036489109,
-0.0438766107,
0.0054986007,
-0.0037761659,
-0.0094421459,
0.031491071,
0.0040622242,
-0.0115762111,
0.0086703664,
0.0426556431,
0.0378434584,
0.0686559752,
0.0331371948,
-0.0480297096,
0.0815992579,
0.0209050477,
0.0168145578,
-0.0224141013,
-0.0483792759,
-0.0120502999,
0.0197691731,
-0.0450176708,
0.0176805966,
-0.044539459,
-0.0429927185,
0.0427792855,
0.0332550034,
-0.0367746241,
-0.0034961984,
-0.0155846169,
0.014467949,
-0.0087410612,
-0.0655156001,
-0.0284528118,
0.0049584699,
-0.0270211045,
0.0057198415,
-0.0377100371,
0.0166194942,
0.0104838945,
0.0280665178,
0.0114830518,
0.0294224061,
0.0049616019,
0.0056732632,
-0.0499150231,
0.0090263877,
-0.0041837087,
0.0401114151,
-0.034288425,
0.0003202146,
-0.00974344,
0.0308321547,
-0.0257875249,
0.0443122685,
0.0030636354,
-0.0060447254,
-0.0638814196,
-0.0200907681,
0.0265710447,
0.0290084518,
-0.0229017679,
-0.008891684,
-0.011397236,
0.0397269353,
-0.0009612798,
-0.0499159694,
-0.028408289,
-0.0101482635,
2.54e-7,
-0.0007697836,
0.0562911294,
0.0233162325,
0.0154393381,
-0.0030110183,
0.0310397688,
0.0058765635,
0.0221935976,
0.0215690359,
0.0111978203,
0.0007233167,
-0.0043942458,
0.0021209959,
0.0147097893,
-0.1099924296,
-0.0374763384,
-0.0416421667,
-0.0088040633,
-0.0428750217,
0.0104188705,
0.1041715741,
0.0222889315,
-0.0134723391,
-0.0015422136,
0.005567824,
-0.022853056,
0.0317200907,
0.0619101189,
-0.0436711349,
0.0344485752,
0.0042788638,
0.0261878446,
-0.0167360306,
0.0018141089,
-0.0460632257,
-0.0095721222,
-0.0120739909,
-0.018710142,
-0.0068289428,
-0.022015458,
0.0083868215,
0.050606247,
0.0435894281,
-0.0475429185,
0.0421681516,
-0.0609263107,
-0.0070818518,
0.0216681026,
-0.0016262146,
-0.0294360742,
-0.0018062132,
-0.0403483063,
-0.0682155937,
0.0070841359,
0.0239909571,
0.0108624799,
0.0198981669,
-0.0220251773,
0.0113254897,
-0.0170965549,
0.0047427299,
-0.0203032494,
-0.0439189002,
-0.0176401623,
-0.0409446768,
-0.0016705078,
0.0024811993,
2.083082978e-34,
0.0343754552,
0.01318736,
0.0221597198,
0.0114166625,
0.0225453395,
-0.0098934425,
-0.0083273258,
-0.0063432674,
0.0382242687,
-0.0580807365,
-0.0266665854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13649v1 | A Symmetric Dual Encoding Dense Retrieval Framework for Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering | 2023-04-26T16:14:39 | 2023-04-26T16:14:39 | Alireza Salemi, Juan Altmayer Pizzorno, Hamed Zamani | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR | Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering (KI-VQA) refers to answering a
question about an image whose answer does not lie in the image. This paper
presents a new pipeline for KI-VQA tasks, consisting of a retriever and a
reader. First, we introduce DEDR, a symmetric dual encoding dense retrieval
framework in which documents and queries are encoded into a shared embedding
space using uni-modal (textual) and multi-modal encoders. We introduce an
iterative knowledge distillation approach that bridges the gap between the
representation spaces in these two encoders. Extensive evaluation on two
well-established KI-VQA datasets, i.e., OK-VQA and FVQA, suggests that DEDR
outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by 11.6% and 30.9% on OK-VQA and FVQA,
respectively. Utilizing the passages retrieved by DEDR, we further introduce
MM-FiD, an encoder-decoder multi-modal fusion-in-decoder model, for generating
a textual answer for KI-VQA tasks. MM-FiD encodes the question, the image, and
each retrieved passage separately and uses all passages jointly in its decoder.
Compared to competitive baselines in the literature, this approach leads to
5.5% and 8.5% improvements in terms of question answering accuracy on OK-VQA
and FVQA, respectively. | [
0.0135243181,
0.0475933366,
-0.0062967003,
0.0318912677,
0.0005767382,
0.0108031984,
-0.0072590872,
0.0205179248,
-0.0017882715,
-0.0467739776,
0.0011604221,
0.0050608977,
-0.023161348,
0.0731814057,
0.0188698303,
-0.0421995036,
0.0361046717,
0.0015402932,
0.0056069042,
-0.0167891122,
0.0389926769,
0.0080668582,
0.0069265598,
0.0137974732,
-0.0248083286,
-0.0264342893,
-0.0411901549,
0.0191169549,
0.0115895169,
-0.0121347522,
0.0142170833,
0.0034864109,
0.0883246064,
-0.0363975801,
0.0000019474,
0.0178718511,
0.0053082919,
0.001973948,
-0.0145162614,
-0.0222958792,
-0.0100225089,
-0.0457031988,
0.0748851746,
-0.0081268679,
-0.0323375985,
-0.0124958595,
0.0408749096,
0.0505139902,
0.0544381998,
0.0424502194,
-0.0302517712,
-0.0224062148,
0.0352589749,
-0.0028216643,
0.0070400005,
-0.026246028,
-0.0140235657,
0.0327533782,
0.0043909005,
0.0382953137,
-0.0441753827,
0.0798445269,
0.0261049215,
0.0099642612,
0.0115905376,
0.0393920802,
-0.007110843,
-0.0045291437,
-0.0074609024,
0.0701460838,
0.0255964156,
0.0188395847,
-0.0285520889,
0.0376728252,
-0.0046875356,
0.0348868258,
-0.0585691631,
0.0055808243,
-0.0262825023,
-0.0110202217,
-0.0560976602,
0.009563637,
-0.0298169013,
-0.0165276639,
-0.0159062799,
-0.0367818922,
0.0189960171,
-0.0244228169,
-0.024270663,
0.0185280796,
-0.0543782301,
-0.0259274654,
-0.0190538205,
0.0526134931,
0.0109825386,
-0.0157729071,
-0.0216159951,
-0.0364261046,
-0.0002848157,
-0.0491958857,
0.0163370296,
0.0177711323,
-0.0375790447,
0.0674706325,
-0.0226693917,
0.0543830507,
-0.0075184568,
0.0321767814,
-0.0678765401,
-0.0465645269,
-0.0428431295,
-0.0384311751,
-0.0409432575,
0.0213514492,
-0.0750503093,
-0.0699263662,
0.037888702,
0.0343427844,
-0.0022500304,
-0.0237028189,
0.0035568869,
0.0730650052,
-0.019997526,
0.0016138386,
-0.0468034782,
0.0891797766,
-0.0314109921,
0.0206209905,
-0.0146813458,
-0.0161105637,
-0.0094695371,
0.0211372934,
0.027724294,
-0.0247761086,
-0.0146684851,
0.0199392736,
-0.0954988152,
-0.0305486321,
-0.0119471662,
-0.0243547298,
-0.0009502419,
-0.027017856,
0.0316055752,
-0.0355692245,
0.0650500804,
0.0186514743,
-0.0208276138,
-0.0468519405,
-0.016184615,
0.0172555093,
-0.0108406404,
0.0710862651,
0.0014446907,
-0.0050545582,
0.0532784164,
0.0282924362,
-0.0039471872,
0.0769068971,
-0.0311304592,
0.0397361182,
0.0340849236,
0.0212558191,
0.0144906426,
-0.0114669921,
0.0182528086,
0.0157232415,
-0.0224602371,
0.0612867847,
-0.018969167,
-0.0024253654,
0.0470263213,
0.0393327512,
-0.0507732034,
-0.0285356361,
0.0437159277,
-0.0058949436,
0.0261914711,
-0.0103497673,
-0.0120664295,
0.0119845131,
0.0036509596,
0.0094067594,
-0.0273781996,
0.0852558911,
0.0015249029,
-0.0189692583,
-0.0069836942,
0.0201548673,
-0.055936791,
-0.0199220683,
0.0259112809,
-0.0053327475,
0.0174045861,
0.0609973893,
0.0310233701,
-0.0063303667,
-0.0368144177,
0.0522240549,
-0.0260732081,
-0.0208206158,
0.0106745651,
0.007887111,
0.0456490777,
0.0498239733,
0.0332466178,
-0.0137318065,
0.0000464867,
0.0267273709,
0.0081685446,
-0.0016360739,
-0.0240456294,
-0.0146308606,
0.0284416787,
-0.06320934,
-0.0647715703,
-0.0566044338,
-0.021427393,
0.0004483253,
0.0125012733,
0.028368989,
0.0159691181,
-0.0317582265,
0.0478426479,
0.0217289403,
0.0312502086,
-0.0116534177,
-0.0239595622,
0.0334825553,
-0.0101691075,
-0.0172396004,
-0.0212815739,
0.0024684891,
0.0301412381,
-0.039496392,
-0.0331559703,
0.006365024,
-0.0329074189,
-0.0763070658,
0.0215260144,
-0.0530075729,
-0.0033416501,
0.0371437967,
-0.0292562824,
-0.0177684724,
0.0044045071,
-0.0350005068,
-0.0108095361,
-0.0510561205,
-0.0518591106,
0.0468175188,
0.0100666191,
-0.0152917486,
0.044448968,
-0.0215417519,
-0.0137377689,
-0.0050966344,
-0.0153542301,
0.0314495526,
-0.0047195568,
-0.0228097625,
0.0005230327,
-0.017419368,
0.0214510448,
0.0089099193,
-0.0086081941,
-0.0202842299,
-0.023688931,
-0.1180852354,
-0.0285219997,
-0.0271671228,
-0.0344450623,
0.0098620225,
0.0343045928,
0.023612095,
-0.0474293679,
-0.0534574501,
0.027868364,
0.0237242077,
0.0453015529,
0.0120522119,
0.0371422805,
0.0409280919,
0.005014691,
-0.0118663823,
0.041456189,
0.0699541569,
-0.0368413888,
0.0135099152,
-0.0021136233,
-0.0122077754,
-0.0455163531,
0.0477771983,
-0.0279026981,
0.000281272,
0.0218163487,
-0.0397832133,
0.0256574769,
0.0675796121,
0.0083921775,
0.0153342169,
-0.0125771919,
-0.0293547809,
-0.0743649229,
0.0278892312,
-0.0018439681,
-0.035312131,
0.0075637181,
-0.0052471729,
-0.0332209207,
-0.0280485414,
-0.008174031,
-0.0007254586,
-0.0317427628,
-0.0021296532,
0.0526591018,
-0.0421348475,
-0.0839627981,
0.0099485191,
0.0338543542,
0.0495996401,
-0.049815353,
-0.0350954682,
0.0494272187,
0.0164860319,
-0.0246539582,
0.0140231969,
-0.0029221389,
-0.0448072031,
0.0719351023,
-0.0266544148,
0.0082455464,
-0.0367513672,
-0.0079574585,
-0.0347087085,
-0.0215507913,
0.0206440594,
-0.0247672126,
0.0585792437,
-0.0241879188,
0.0327954069,
-0.0486139059,
-0.0535410047,
-0.0301757753,
-0.0234645549,
0.0035863442,
0.0057964772,
-0.0670202971,
-0.0053696609,
-0.0218496863,
0.0269825235,
0.0158139169,
-0.0015618075,
-0.0139589049,
-0.003910372,
-0.0163763128,
0.0961106643,
0.0736628771,
0.0639122576,
-0.0557940118,
-0.0134002659,
0.0082120253,
0.087967217,
-0.0158924889,
-0.020223856,
-0.0171995461,
0.0309563279,
0.028443072,
0.0590920858,
-0.0019674411,
0.0173296798,
0.0582684651,
-0.0455003195,
-0.016412966,
0.0602020733,
0.0201878082,
-0.0095470687,
-0.050500229,
-0.0138179576,
0.039761126,
0.0361003391,
0.0406459309,
-0.0878358409,
-0.0452377796,
-0.0276059303,
0.0158097371,
0.0373161621,
0.0127891116,
0.0097674867,
-0.0600853302,
0.0406060778,
-0.0075399806,
0.0352697857,
-0.0804814994,
0.000520753,
-0.033983238,
0.0092159817,
-0.0206992496,
0.0006031129,
0.0147600127,
0.0133175701,
0.0082370192,
0.0665266141,
-0.009021,
0.0047060503,
-0.0402758718,
-0.0520105101,
0.0079887062,
0.0040109777,
0.0026312349,
-0.0629311576,
-0.049155876,
-0.0338525809,
0.0092990734,
0.0113150738,
0.0486224443,
-0.0318135843,
-0.0256744139,
-0.0205733329,
-0.0039902264,
-0.0288502555,
-0.0225946661,
-0.0170872007,
0.0488127768,
-0.026087353,
-0.0028695359,
-0.053536091,
-0.0336392075,
0.01070242,
0.0526811741,
0.0091996733,
0.0129199708,
-0.0446095355,
-0.0005832051,
0.0281825531,
-0.0412704796,
0.0152204456,
0.0158484373,
0.0394677185,
0.0255418271,
-0.070944339,
-0.020543322,
0.0455983132,
0.0447486788,
-0.0321902633,
-0.0177665409,
-0.0065327068,
-0.010416422,
-0.0973015055,
0.0276394915,
-0.0072960183,
0.0221517645,
-0.010566677,
0.0148569457,
0.0109500429,
-0.0163509101,
-0.0178206209,
0.0135435704,
-0.0407883041,
-0.0133940065,
-0.0432623588,
0.0599958934,
0.0009620474,
0.0467911884,
0.021991726,
-0.019568922,
0.0583390892,
0.037750233,
-0.0440595336,
0.0113097029,
0.007962686,
-0.0462542325,
-0.0084225815,
0.0036539331,
-0.0602907464,
-0.0156569947,
-0.0242336933,
0.0109226136,
-0.0122250961,
-0.0278818123,
0.0191327035,
0.0182284005,
0.006324735,
0.018309664,
0.0418112613,
-0.0159366783,
0.007477025,
0.006985215,
-0.0004333264,
-0.0717589334,
0.0209108498,
0.0237944573,
-0.0052723801,
0.0211403463,
0.053877905,
0.0588515587,
0.0289725047,
-0.0312500782,
0.00109253,
0.0540050827,
-0.0113211777,
-0.0084142294,
0.0337465107,
-0.0120459897,
0.016982343,
0.0046333065,
0.0445674695,
-0.0169488974,
0.0745413378,
0.0375871509,
-0.0113486359,
-0.0381541923,
0.0202182829,
-0.0387114733,
-0.0363978744,
-0.0243692864,
0.0186767541,
0.0210299343,
0.0209169332,
-0.0372063704,
0.0242941119,
-0.0292967428,
-0.015753448,
0.0094275903,
-0.0109649738,
-0.0184537545,
0.0662505701,
0.0401253849,
0.0146018369,
-0.003165405,
0.0648834035,
-0.0243382677,
0.0432701074,
-0.0396790206,
-0.0234543625,
-0.0410199165,
-0.0156844631,
0.0556624085,
0.0275139455,
0.0116493599,
0.0422265194,
0.0065712677,
-0.04157326,
0.0273303371,
-0.0093977349,
-0.0480339155,
0.0272099655,
0.0431405678,
0.0542635769,
0.033672411,
-0.059930753,
-0.0189113896,
0.015301967,
-0.0434414782,
-0.00436163,
-0.0001121042,
-6.207582894e-33,
-0.0289321821,
0.0023297244,
0.0475494415,
-0.0213202983,
-0.0224821661,
0.0075175068,
0.0075484612,
-0.0171849672,
-0.0420198813,
-0.0015279147,
0.0059100818,
-0.0168979596,
-0.0132240476,
0.0607875623,
-0.0153142186,
-0.0024656958,
0.0241981354,
-0.0029989057,
-0.0170852412,
0.0039943024,
0.0435799472,
0.0381478667,
0.0170311388,
-0.0329877175,
-0.0361678414,
-0.0016530949,
0.0048266929,
0.0271465741,
0.016235387,
0.0386219062,
-0.0328807086,
0.0281286854,
0.0228493363,
-0.007395321,
-0.0257712882,
0.0219804086,
-0.1209521517,
-0.0193214025,
0.0091130743,
0.0227905158,
-0.072009109,
0.0125863086,
0.020414412,
-0.0235190168,
0.0542589724,
-0.0619598366,
0.0259215329,
0.0168591496,
0.0134329572,
-0.0133056808,
0.0024856678,
0.0033390345,
-0.0235102568,
-0.0399909392,
0.016235549,
0.050044734,
0.0544304512,
-0.0034581663,
-0.0655438825,
-0.0079111299,
-0.0430898517,
0.0420343876,
0.0305970404,
0.028281929,
-0.0160463918,
0.0375967473,
-0.0058160401,
-0.0611758493,
-0.0547500588,
0.005096273,
-0.0019052796,
0.0710974112,
0.0336421877,
0.0666132495,
0.0306965746,
-0.0035772838,
-0.0440362282,
0.0411667973,
-0.0672990829,
0.072458744,
-0.0252325758,
0.0352551267,
0.0069384836,
-0.0230439231,
-0.0482611433,
0.0154274078,
-0.034288086,
-0.0110374987,
0.0688022673,
0.06134158,
-0.002796228,
0.0499523878,
0.0963003561,
-0.0541029535,
0.0391008034,
0.0522835106,
-0.0317280702,
0.0623531379,
0.0308411848,
0.0240587816,
-0.0071022594,
0.0110253301,
0.0943567902,
-0.0094371252,
-0.0530412272,
0.0146529498,
0.0379994363,
0.0239307135,
-0.0312255248,
-0.0108797597,
-0.0442944281,
-0.0017415617,
-0.0157087725,
0.030286137,
-0.006309459,
0.0352360457,
-0.0485392101,
-0.0154339792,
-0.0467773415,
0.0272206571,
-0.0427496172,
-0.0794412494,
0.0321943909,
0.0266644638,
0.007845331,
0.0336506777,
-0.0691915825,
-0.0754577741,
-0.0201928858,
-0.0462130085,
-0.0012923917,
0.0799526498,
2.61e-7,
0.04113511,
-0.0138007822,
0.0376589485,
0.0078114294,
0.0106672123,
0.0365372412,
0.0016457175,
0.0472401194,
0.0334296972,
-0.055670388,
-0.0031151944,
0.0618683062,
0.005409332,
0.0019891483,
-0.041400671,
-0.0043720212,
-0.0297557488,
-0.0477171615,
-0.0302615091,
-0.0127108283,
0.0926527977,
0.0702240169,
-0.0240003075,
-0.0116585698,
0.0302474834,
-0.0569200665,
0.1120634675,
0.0351759009,
0.0057342695,
-0.0190414786,
0.0070821196,
0.0027932683,
0.0158563759,
0.0305688698,
0.0004378228,
-0.0079786638,
0.0600345992,
0.0347825773,
-0.0105777234,
-0.0814032182,
-0.0481326357,
0.0328332745,
-0.0257887021,
-0.055814147,
0.106490612,
-0.0328880474,
-0.0231811386,
-0.0052463408,
-0.1026656404,
0.0038441801,
0.0210446473,
0.0215721745,
-0.0261589158,
0.0272651166,
0.0417609215,
-0.0098665906,
-0.0171813276,
-0.0876268521,
-0.0074725226,
-0.0221889559,
-0.0636910275,
0.0059982929,
-0.041684825,
-0.0066679395,
0.030098835,
-0.0099111022,
-0.0551249534,
1.737248637e-34,
0.0083421608,
0.0250273701,
0.0098831123,
0.0117522543,
0.0142993331,
-0.0400129333,
-0.0574579798,
-0.01747372,
-0.0031157541,
-0.0857747197,
-0.0074879043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13634v1 | HausaNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Leveraging African Low Resource TweetData for Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-26T15:47:50 | 2023-04-26T15:47:50 | Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Falalu Ibrahim Lawan, Ahmad Mustapha Wali, Amina Abubakar Imam, Aliyu Rabiu Shuaibu, Aliyu Yusuf, Nur Bala Rabiu, Musa Bello, Shamsuddeen Umaru Adamu, Saminu Mohammad Aliyu, Murja Sani Gadanya, Sanah Abdullahi Muaz, Mahmoud Said Ahmad, Abdulkadir Abdullahi, Abdulmalik Yusuf Jamoh | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the findings of SemEval-2023 Task 12, a shared task on sentiment
analysis for low-resource African languages using Twitter dataset. The task
featured three subtasks; subtask A is monolingual sentiment classification with
12 tracks which are all monolingual languages, subtask B is multilingual
sentiment classification using the tracks in subtask A and subtask C is a
zero-shot sentiment classification. We present the results and findings of
subtask A, subtask B and subtask C. We also release the code on github. Our
goal is to leverage low-resource tweet data using pre-trained Afro-xlmr-large,
AfriBERTa-Large, Bert-base-arabic-camelbert-da-sentiment (Arabic-camelbert),
Multilingual-BERT (mBERT) and BERT models for sentiment analysis of 14 African
languages. The datasets for these subtasks consists of a gold standard
multi-class labeled Twitter datasets from these languages. Our results
demonstrate that Afro-xlmr-large model performed better compared to the other
models in most of the languages datasets. Similarly, Nigerian languages: Hausa,
Igbo, and Yoruba achieved better performance compared to other languages and
this can be attributed to the higher volume of data present in the languages. | [
0.0436164141,
0.0809960812,
0.0164151378,
0.0366359465,
-0.0046545807,
0.0805277899,
0.003107307,
0.000369673,
-0.0007603051,
-0.0190022942,
-0.0285592377,
-0.0906896591,
0.0170871746,
-0.0006671625,
-0.0066977725,
-0.0287735388,
0.0027561914,
0.0278931689,
0.0472368896,
-0.0456352867,
0.0121604726,
0.0520960055,
-0.0028483293,
0.0112781385,
-0.0566600375,
0.015404203,
-0.0145761725,
-0.0013936127,
0.0046023335,
0.0129267881,
0.0312834047,
0.0456918441,
-0.0271737538,
0.0377977751,
0.0000022293,
-0.0296323039,
-0.0173107628,
-0.0118146194,
0.0199076943,
-0.0067405482,
0.0561049953,
-0.0466402695,
-0.0142266005,
0.0365692936,
-0.0315770544,
0.0085016312,
0.0678298622,
0.0257268157,
0.0641972795,
0.0777734891,
-0.0199966021,
-0.0094570862,
-0.0069429372,
-0.0391546674,
0.0161998812,
-0.0070523219,
0.0093713654,
-0.0348123871,
-0.034242034,
0.0008545839,
-0.0123859746,
-0.0077058226,
-0.006584195,
0.0146466894,
-0.011831414,
-0.0384635888,
-0.0538137741,
-0.0529262386,
0.013256236,
0.0111452648,
0.0163763054,
-0.0173012763,
-0.0046257051,
0.0223280042,
-0.0388282835,
-0.0432438627,
-0.0254252832,
0.0029123311,
0.0047937133,
0.0546287745,
0.008748278,
0.052819971,
0.0398213565,
0.0455188081,
-0.0338445753,
0.0392158963,
-0.0173870679,
-0.0289553087,
0.035132058,
0.0812888816,
0.003222554,
0.0002811641,
0.0095125725,
-0.0275453515,
-0.0022973919,
-0.0189630724,
0.0223132577,
-0.0289366022,
0.0195048638,
-0.110780932,
0.0100126239,
0.0259578545,
-0.0153283738,
0.0181890242,
-0.0168256667,
-0.0289811213,
-0.021489542,
-0.0153676281,
0.0115700904,
-0.0407624394,
-0.0607784167,
0.0007869218,
0.0193987042,
0.0297870152,
-0.0146367252,
0.043605797,
-0.0941832289,
-0.0039970451,
-0.0201059673,
-0.0076368721,
-0.0065090172,
-0.0369312651,
0.0310963467,
-0.0092482343,
0.0073605492,
0.0427929983,
-0.0287062675,
-0.001815235,
-0.0744981468,
-0.0689717978,
0.0341169275,
0.0034356215,
0.0108364653,
0.0046016932,
0.0290213916,
0.0463984385,
0.0135917217,
-0.0732989535,
-0.0732128248,
-0.0047257175,
-0.0103570903,
-0.0472701155,
-0.0263283569,
-0.0704698786,
0.036865212,
0.0370399468,
0.0361663103,
0.0492553264,
0.0032190024,
0.0019106179,
-0.0122559899,
0.0259985514,
-0.0130251637,
0.0015655578,
0.0251831841,
0.0034039905,
0.0540794246,
0.0867166594,
0.0015498142,
0.0516640358,
0.0361246094,
0.0150154904,
-0.0330437496,
0.0255062226,
0.0147104096,
0.0028622048,
-0.0230177455,
-0.0150911631,
-0.0264109131,
-0.0328202844,
-0.011492922,
0.0066040517,
0.0184798129,
0.0243354272,
0.0313538872,
0.0106106438,
-0.0070067542,
0.0405529141,
-0.0055133975,
0.0008181196,
0.0060572885,
-0.0240322705,
0.0165389087,
0.0194676984,
-0.006371764,
-0.0502358936,
0.0673207343,
0.0404082052,
-0.0480210744,
-0.0407367796,
0.0068716537,
-0.0384014286,
0.0145085547,
0.0112596741,
0.0591924228,
-0.0278405324,
-0.0222212579,
0.0242251772,
0.0733853504,
-0.0796067268,
-0.0225454532,
-0.0542371161,
0.0233041607,
0.0409028605,
-0.0246435534,
0.0251074396,
-0.0149097079,
-0.0160686281,
0.0248469636,
0.0435617864,
0.0125282137,
-0.0005976711,
0.0522116013,
-0.0517778099,
0.01562877,
0.0129223661,
0.0110327536,
0.0076954975,
0.0306671858,
0.0904762,
-0.0235490371,
-0.0226888675,
-0.0158028547,
-0.0254734308,
0.0045279316,
0.0166346636,
0.0254486613,
0.0349656157,
0.0583692715,
0.0600331947,
-0.0287549682,
-0.0285179019,
-0.0174089093,
-0.0423923917,
-0.0303899497,
0.0427424014,
-0.0268500745,
-0.0304215383,
0.0094025489,
-0.0090569807,
-0.027723819,
0.0462290831,
-0.0117310975,
-0.0169881955,
0.066967003,
-0.005377084,
0.0609200858,
-0.0356195942,
0.000126957,
-0.0680129603,
0.0037028927,
0.03992524,
0.0322793871,
0.0135210454,
-0.0121913282,
-0.034977708,
-0.0366823375,
0.0724373907,
0.0446609184,
-0.0270651653,
0.0436942391,
0.0155460332,
-0.004164143,
0.0270495042,
0.0212998372,
-0.02438231,
-0.0254893322,
-0.0989509076,
-0.0182362925,
-0.0336513408,
0.028548779,
-0.0212802477,
0.0724686533,
-0.003791003,
0.019358024,
-0.0003667376,
-0.0032128436,
0.0026961362,
0.0097325435,
-0.0077826451,
-0.0232130457,
0.0482747033,
-0.0333387591,
-0.0009405559,
0.0175966471,
0.0068310043,
-0.001206469,
-0.0245039016,
0.0397377498,
-0.0340223499,
-0.0148948077,
-0.0077344459,
0.0258554891,
-0.0730165318,
0.0084337434,
-0.0408770218,
-0.0227431171,
-0.0299828835,
-0.00130135,
0.0376042947,
-0.0066405204,
0.0147306267,
-0.01625132,
0.0204425026,
-0.0226571094,
0.0178677812,
0.0035857467,
-0.0152720325,
-0.0133583499,
0.0858861431,
0.0005977114,
-0.0064601782,
-0.0758863762,
-0.0393644311,
-0.0269364063,
-0.012117262,
0.0054216394,
0.0121079218,
0.0121183563,
-0.0108724488,
-0.0047583869,
-0.0352072641,
0.043829985,
0.0231540315,
-0.0017687989,
-0.0492924117,
-0.008144713,
-0.0462439619,
0.028084334,
-0.0311142746,
0.0055998391,
-0.038106408,
0.0239079483,
0.0279490352,
-0.0096067796,
0.0050402298,
-0.0087616676,
-0.0065317168,
0.0355400443,
0.0195018016,
0.0038494468,
-0.0537108518,
0.0303531494,
-0.0463935733,
-0.0747658014,
-0.0300445836,
0.0262525324,
-0.0326413065,
0.0037601271,
-0.0090981331,
0.0020923766,
-0.0402678363,
0.0084494967,
-0.0052744658,
0.0495296381,
0.0345846638,
-0.0129006226,
-0.0611069277,
-0.0031167651,
-0.0138190594,
-0.0053375689,
0.0293532088,
-0.0177926626,
-0.012056876,
-0.0159200821,
-0.0404781103,
0.0419404134,
-0.0066507044,
-0.0120953647,
-0.0617074668,
0.0313545689,
0.006996559,
0.0312951244,
0.0958783999,
0.036171928,
-0.0384499095,
-0.0056175119,
-0.0179215558,
0.0305345003,
-0.020432895,
-0.0128997248,
-0.0722268522,
-0.0341225676,
-0.0175017659,
-0.0023314722,
-0.0251063202,
-0.0159011949,
0.0199166741,
-0.0982896015,
-0.0016977011,
0.0065583694,
0.0064880862,
-0.0254473649,
-0.0441003256,
-0.0230464265,
-0.0268386826,
-0.0254208371,
-0.0660801083,
0.0245579462,
0.0019791147,
0.0420661122,
-0.0339989588,
-0.0861230418,
0.027074758,
0.0024897638,
0.0183443315,
0.0183681045,
0.0239097849,
-0.0433028713,
-0.0221488345,
0.0082564391,
-0.0175359957,
-0.0124065178,
-0.0732770562,
0.0344525985,
0.0008306715,
-0.0590318404,
-0.0311291646,
-0.0331830718,
-0.0512570143,
0.0266532414,
-0.0425260141,
0.0269774403,
-0.0090222945,
-0.0396475829,
-0.0508831479,
0.0000255209,
0.0106921671,
0.0319811217,
0.0120683219,
-0.0856812447,
-0.0245784782,
0.0252796467,
0.0070764031,
-0.0767075196,
0.0018739072,
-0.0140983807,
0.0009894572,
-0.0568995066,
-0.0350220054,
-0.0691395923,
0.0124088628,
-0.0046886546,
-0.0456427075,
-0.0170859993,
-0.0064306827,
0.0075999214,
-0.0268001668,
0.0091873808,
0.0225150399,
0.0313596167,
-0.004359819,
-0.0374454148,
0.0567766763,
0.0099604009,
0.0340227298,
-0.0324688703,
-0.0836229324,
-0.0451291054,
0.0008523344,
0.0287856162,
0.0108086066,
-0.007622221,
0.025828721,
-0.0652751476,
0.018202519,
0.03418082,
0.016557321,
-0.0015588154,
0.0608499832,
0.0870707557,
-0.0028373534,
0.0593797229,
0.0185824167,
0.0518716946,
0.0235342588,
-0.0020397315,
-0.0312341489,
0.0062667192,
-0.0323500521,
-0.0460177846,
0.0443195999,
-0.0137915397,
-0.0893088058,
-0.0249959286,
-0.0073927836,
0.0439195372,
0.0146701606,
-0.0446244702,
-0.0133685339,
0.0165891871,
0.0149665056,
-0.0736028552,
-0.0151617881,
-0.0133019267,
-0.0236252192,
-0.0124899698,
0.0763463452,
0.0485449396,
-0.0011341766,
0.0163278654,
0.0441402718,
-0.0198488701,
0.0004703395,
0.0173639096,
-0.0213301461,
-0.0225061402,
-0.0057510957,
-0.0109652532,
0.022938123,
0.0282244794,
0.0217520483,
0.0294971447,
0.059205208,
-0.0353125893,
0.0268389732,
0.0591602474,
-0.0337349251,
0.0637938455,
0.0091697518,
-0.0124856876,
0.0163407605,
0.0149733927,
-0.0491425022,
-0.0047740778,
0.0069089285,
-0.024500303,
-0.014717062,
0.0441716351,
0.0538815483,
-0.0545170456,
0.0266667344,
0.0611640997,
0.0242453963,
-0.0077652764,
0.0170959756,
0.0584950559,
-0.0185647346,
0.0103517156,
0.0674388334,
-0.0324444808,
-0.0777436793,
0.0697481334,
-0.0698811635,
0.0048712036,
0.0340748243,
0.0195030756,
0.0369082168,
0.0199725069,
0.0764527842,
-0.0467846505,
-0.03313246,
-0.0085073998,
-0.0334683582,
0.0215460733,
-7.050337406e-33,
0.064403303,
0.0272135194,
-0.0629249141,
-0.0173675828,
-0.000330905,
-0.002493958,
0.0054060938,
0.0434361547,
-0.0374014638,
0.0277697556,
-0.0263461918,
0.0260324404,
0.0023851104,
0.0554411523,
0.0692937523,
0.0043912577,
0.0159117747,
0.0047594546,
-0.0113879303,
0.036007151,
0.0370079204,
0.0539689548,
0.0740827546,
-0.0869459808,
0.0375355594,
-0.0386889279,
-0.0379632786,
-0.0045634983,
0.0695496425,
0.0424536578,
-0.0303998813,
0.0945463255,
0.0441669226,
0.0021764645,
0.0257672798,
0.0237949938,
-0.0052115852,
-0.0300219972,
-0.0077261692,
0.0296316929,
-0.0186245143,
-0.0584706105,
-0.0131860301,
0.0162242223,
-0.0503453501,
0.0170508083,
0.0011322679,
-0.0069855698,
0.0176171623,
-0.0389017463,
-0.0574179068,
0.0469148941,
0.010790498,
-0.017489275,
0.0338875391,
0.0685554072,
-0.0064409003,
0.0088717146,
-0.0424513854,
0.0218210109,
-0.0218560901,
-0.015609581,
-0.0228760969,
-0.0145084951,
-0.0499932878,
0.0269317143,
0.0230999701,
-0.0055896547,
0.0332395434,
0.0291738473,
-0.0021442352,
-0.0491446145,
0.01102784,
0.0980714262,
0.0233243164,
-0.0647558123,
-0.0395685993,
0.0059831622,
0.0798221305,
-0.0034063491,
0.0258049145,
-0.0210871547,
-0.0298100542,
-0.0220239218,
0.0480157919,
-0.0429034829,
-0.0268561281,
-0.0053106253,
-0.0093841236,
-0.0247233324,
0.0099153295,
0.0295291767,
0.0101659307,
-0.0183812063,
-0.0458330177,
0.0216819327,
-0.040753454,
0.0406562649,
0.0246824101,
0.0147268381,
-0.0456225537,
-0.0132740848,
-0.0379564725,
0.0528109372,
0.0006222269,
0.0023858028,
0.0549407862,
0.0457867831,
-0.0845892355,
0.0092001082,
-0.0223994795,
0.0417521819,
-0.0226867795,
0.0631355345,
-0.0294979345,
-0.011385398,
0.0005152819,
0.0522004813,
0.0156961568,
0.0207257662,
0.0301713757,
-0.0018021057,
-0.0102783069,
-0.0129665947,
-0.0263482668,
-0.0306544509,
-0.0140492385,
-0.0075978027,
-0.0282367226,
-0.0515629947,
0.0034791641,
-0.0226412918,
2.96e-7,
0.0064308071,
0.0451988168,
-0.0339927189,
-0.0611725971,
-0.0041033942,
0.0574583821,
-0.0186353624,
0.0059203459,
-0.0300971717,
0.0518173054,
-0.0063889092,
-0.0072781104,
0.0860726386,
0.0259943977,
-0.0937992781,
0.0091072144,
-0.0465068221,
-0.0188904908,
-0.0288603306,
0.022439573,
0.0306419116,
0.1446702331,
0.0185947958,
-0.0331792459,
-0.0521692894,
-0.0004453871,
0.0596972294,
-0.037162073,
-0.0225895941,
-0.0146724535,
-0.0091230674,
0.036836829,
-0.0261905678,
-0.0305919461,
-0.0342575088,
0.0106496587,
-0.0022212518,
0.0483873226,
0.0136916917,
-0.0096179731,
0.034719944,
0.022873845,
-0.0198153947,
-0.0098773977,
0.0373689644,
-0.0097950269,
-0.09692958,
-0.0434825122,
0.0255127382,
0.0204209518,
0.0760719553,
-0.0124230878,
-0.0381732211,
0.0000132576,
0.0076495796,
-0.05839362,
-0.064040117,
-0.057235118,
0.0402574688,
-0.0052906955,
-0.0059408941,
-0.0021935785,
0.0290756598,
0.0406675264,
0.0519371703,
-0.0025933683,
0.0531310625,
2.375114346e-34,
0.0499579906,
-0.0505619869,
0.0293872375,
0.0172111485,
-0.0248865876,
0.0053532338,
0.0055963178,
-0.0355526656,
0.0329545662,
0.0068698744,
0.0320343748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13620v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13620v3 | ChartSumm: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Automatic Chart Summarization of Long and Short Summaries | 2023-04-26T15:25:24 | 2023-06-11T04:07:27 | Raian Rahman, Rizvi Hasan, Abdullah Al Farhad, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Md. Hamjajul Ashmafee, Abu Raihan Mostofa Kamal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Automatic chart to text summarization is an effective tool for the visually
impaired people along with providing precise insights of tabular data in
natural language to the user. A large and well-structured dataset is always a
key part for data driven models. In this paper, we propose ChartSumm: a
large-scale benchmark dataset consisting of a total of 84,363 charts along with
their metadata and descriptions covering a wide range of topics and chart types
to generate short and long summaries. Extensive experiments with strong
baseline models show that even though these models generate fluent and
informative summaries by achieving decent scores in various automatic
evaluation metrics, they often face issues like suffering from hallucination,
missing out important data points, in addition to incorrect explanation of
complex trends in the charts. We also investigated the potential of expanding
ChartSumm to other languages using automated translation tools. These make our
dataset a challenging benchmark for future research. | [
-0.0336592309,
0.0173403379,
0.0083684018,
0.0171819478,
0.0059180642,
0.010595453,
-0.0270075854,
-0.0302811339,
0.0119564142,
0.0242549628,
-0.0084518362,
0.0086050918,
0.0600648224,
0.0422202758,
0.0010987821,
-0.1372769624,
0.0011962343,
-0.014169082,
0.0053615612,
0.0193667188,
0.0204474106,
-0.0162288453,
-0.0150411874,
0.0259155706,
0.0007246176,
-0.0188631341,
0.0232414361,
0.0299908184,
0.01110953,
-0.0546667054,
-0.0340321176,
0.0146036288,
0.0107074678,
0.0171684921,
0.0000019046,
-0.0319194086,
-0.0233790372,
-0.0043386412,
0.0464442782,
-0.0039498033,
0.044836048,
-0.1080126986,
0.0321874991,
-0.0143653359,
-0.0116573274,
0.009911133,
0.0085635502,
0.0172527023,
0.0827308595,
0.0107038738,
-0.0195622649,
-0.0076763588,
0.0024076828,
-0.0531031154,
0.0087589612,
-0.0376048312,
-0.0243224241,
0.0641687214,
0.0036422787,
-0.0046210103,
-0.0310978722,
0.0575665981,
0.0017518697,
0.0073054014,
-0.00687879,
0.0299698133,
-0.0210983753,
-0.0279988423,
0.0165847894,
0.1099032462,
0.0112929344,
0.0106257033,
0.0253611859,
0.0001653235,
0.0054824343,
0.0223098323,
-0.1142867804,
0.0282090083,
-0.0323305577,
-0.0100202961,
-0.0032025811,
0.0455992147,
-0.0005875625,
-0.0132956672,
-0.0040304698,
-0.0452042818,
-0.0234234333,
-0.012665607,
-0.0157365743,
-0.0220838245,
-0.0269753858,
-0.0664924458,
0.0010510051,
0.0384652056,
0.0125389621,
-0.027363101,
-0.0318678506,
-0.0542279109,
0.0253213793,
-0.0272963736,
0.032959532,
-0.0038145136,
-0.0193371493,
0.0680560693,
-0.0260704178,
0.024214955,
0.0147489421,
-0.0025438152,
-0.0297088549,
-0.0144149344,
-0.0172726028,
0.0040963702,
-0.0338953361,
-0.0144527163,
-0.0205319505,
-0.0217412096,
-0.0231616292,
0.0075787497,
-0.0231474396,
0.0416614003,
0.0163009781,
0.0019638147,
-0.0157974083,
-0.0159871913,
-0.0101918131,
0.0373273753,
-0.0603241958,
-0.0227070637,
0.0022159198,
-0.0034288138,
0.0065808361,
0.0343884267,
0.0471924134,
0.0369137935,
-0.0118072592,
0.0878654495,
0.0124537889,
0.0016761282,
-0.0181979798,
-0.0584949628,
-0.0111118257,
0.0033981679,
0.0068718228,
-0.0669400617,
0.0135912523,
-0.0078469347,
0.0168306939,
-0.0389442779,
0.0214188527,
0.0257891323,
-0.0359673575,
0.0349188,
-0.0578185841,
0.0150342314,
0.0297377184,
-0.0181860533,
-0.0164547972,
0.0581357293,
0.0684193745,
0.0429970175,
0.0607341714,
-0.0080150915,
0.0264940262,
0.0421348475,
-0.0051941583,
0.0060204617,
-0.0257880613,
-0.005616202,
-0.0627115071,
0.0046609202,
0.0259706303,
0.0421572924,
0.000742164,
0.0115327053,
0.0582034141,
0.045385778,
0.0714659467,
-0.0032596041,
0.0096458411,
0.0127071096,
0.0509942956,
0.0094505539,
0.0215089303,
0.0308221839,
0.048231218,
0.0926487595,
0.041577626,
-0.0000410001,
-0.0091593303,
-0.0614192411,
0.0038099703,
0.0169457309,
0.0129613094,
-0.0239972584,
0.0403591096,
0.0442119054,
-0.0205338001,
0.0000138303,
-0.011244745,
-0.0352449492,
0.0052262489,
0.0276699979,
0.009460208,
0.0500677302,
0.0470019504,
-0.0360369533,
0.0071832966,
-0.0303250346,
0.0435229465,
0.0396449938,
0.0054559866,
-0.0271501001,
-0.0345008336,
-0.0386141762,
-0.0399652235,
0.0065081534,
0.0152491387,
-0.00816896,
-0.0343856625,
0.0012509021,
0.0270282459,
-0.1097470596,
-0.0736903697,
0.0222888291,
0.0140655609,
-0.0317028277,
-0.0055104308,
-0.0189307872,
-0.0185565799,
0.0458849818,
-0.0301400498,
0.0411409885,
0.0084609091,
-0.0280963276,
0.0182183199,
0.0499127284,
-0.0408703499,
-0.0420455337,
0.0141210034,
-0.0853001624,
-0.0114712771,
0.0046089934,
-0.0246556681,
-0.0790921524,
0.0076704849,
-0.0783482194,
-0.0501573086,
0.0049272003,
-0.0062070084,
0.002094056,
0.0077728191,
-0.0050047566,
0.0480683781,
-0.0163585115,
0.0021866679,
0.0116782468,
0.0128724743,
0.0321415029,
-0.0299427062,
0.0400883257,
0.031950105,
0.0139277028,
0.0164339729,
0.0325119458,
0.0034208752,
-0.0296581332,
0.0038205043,
-0.1030259505,
-0.0277758799,
-0.004941484,
-0.0024499646,
0.0361853801,
0.0008531657,
-0.0259999223,
-0.0343308374,
-0.0283387508,
0.0112966476,
0.0078551034,
-0.0317719504,
0.0583310761,
-0.0243351776,
0.0202249829,
-0.0628262237,
-0.0089683356,
-0.0114608612,
0.0218694564,
0.0786209702,
-0.0289935526,
0.0041945139,
0.0034611882,
-0.0216430668,
-0.0330193937,
0.0236852709,
0.0222560801,
0.0040852921,
0.0187642239,
0.079559654,
0.0332735665,
0.0167729706,
0.0298060104,
0.0015184205,
-0.0299858712,
0.0010919427,
-0.0070687491,
-0.0434619822,
0.0560896844,
0.0351353362,
-0.046684932,
0.0295116808,
0.0602098033,
0.0294520427,
0.0209594518,
-0.0193177741,
-0.013184472,
-0.0261539109,
0.0515438132,
-0.083469525,
0.0353337266,
-0.0215617344,
0.0337300375,
-0.0203427989,
-0.0431940071,
0.033287596,
-0.0489899479,
0.0166783594,
-0.0004183771,
-0.0226833187,
-0.0862954482,
0.0491549224,
0.0232131518,
0.0158546623,
-0.0469049588,
-0.0202807933,
-0.0390676297,
0.0179156456,
0.0524501465,
-0.0344922245,
0.0190452002,
-0.0671121553,
0.0098025361,
-0.0247593224,
0.0258724857,
0.0037239154,
-0.0081943804,
-0.0193331763,
0.0103277033,
0.0325636044,
-0.0165076833,
-0.0537135042,
0.0044274614,
0.0365288816,
0.0801376998,
-0.0039549111,
-0.0266290456,
-0.0219109356,
0.0528706424,
0.0329659246,
-0.0296341963,
-0.0228500739,
-0.0574694984,
0.0499531142,
0.0328868218,
-0.0106480382,
0.0124066211,
0.0053297244,
-0.0215426851,
-0.0503160767,
-0.0039528189,
0.0227933154,
0.0172285847,
0.0213226639,
-0.0319451503,
0.0424770191,
0.0725418851,
0.0106546711,
-0.0263846293,
-0.0255064294,
0.0252682734,
0.0344494767,
-0.0045323223,
-0.0261746813,
-0.1135283336,
-0.0191407092,
0.0045854775,
0.0879582092,
0.0470150672,
-0.0266780891,
-0.0152568351,
-0.0875458494,
0.0351569913,
0.0249249302,
-0.0578873418,
-0.004621265,
-0.0572598539,
-0.0121960407,
-0.0134307304,
-0.0058205896,
-0.0072777309,
-0.0218072142,
0.0149955368,
0.0161313582,
-0.1304591447,
-0.0161236227,
-0.035456717,
-0.0175059028,
-0.0318686664,
0.0287817959,
0.0716161802,
-0.0166124646,
0.0144635122,
0.019022584,
-0.0033776024,
-0.0007666671,
0.0084425276,
0.08406014,
0.0143216457,
-0.0249088369,
-0.0119218668,
0.0742213726,
-0.0262215901,
0.0035764968,
0.039843291,
-0.0029435831,
0.0000846738,
-0.0161960516,
-0.0501607358,
0.036263369,
-0.0226493031,
0.0409922376,
0.0881699622,
0.0070763403,
-0.0385733917,
-0.0547447503,
-0.0072935144,
-0.0888510942,
-0.0171015561,
0.0080935974,
-0.0183411073,
-0.0620997697,
-0.0800192058,
-0.0465449356,
0.0382234566,
0.0058596628,
0.0194803569,
0.0158466138,
0.0001860704,
-0.0121976407,
-0.0520928986,
0.0467772372,
-0.0162879862,
0.0189115051,
-0.0493600518,
-0.0300970469,
-0.0025099239,
-0.012618131,
-0.0246893689,
0.0268089194,
-0.0795954242,
0.007704644,
0.0090853982,
0.0314373188,
0.0225717835,
0.0242222939,
-0.0101371743,
0.0100437822,
0.0525659844,
0.0489894114,
-0.0042405818,
-0.0231062602,
-0.0232512467,
0.048122365,
-0.0082324706,
-0.0188050959,
-0.0455845073,
0.0549238138,
-0.0434069708,
0.0421152562,
-0.0114974799,
0.0202104487,
0.0001309346,
0.0386190116,
0.0095609548,
-0.0064958301,
-0.0405170396,
-0.0100928415,
-0.0661344379,
-0.0299812853,
-0.0415721722,
-0.0173554607,
0.0520639867,
0.0119076036,
0.0154453134,
0.000012265,
0.0332646221,
0.0127393808,
-0.0211953688,
-0.0713505819,
0.0392045304,
-0.0144915273,
-0.0202983096,
-0.037305858,
-0.002737975,
-0.0213259719,
0.0076023005,
-0.0445009433,
0.0193811934,
0.0421560407,
-0.011289401,
0.0176864285,
0.004130722,
-0.0179129019,
0.0489848927,
-0.0519471355,
-0.0290616471,
-0.0259300955,
0.0273289997,
0.0463406816,
0.0039113476,
0.0507929213,
-0.0017034773,
-0.0132700987,
-0.0144681586,
0.0445627384,
0.0254952852,
0.0278579909,
0.0008798856,
0.0070743696,
0.0014073767,
-0.0426350906,
0.1090119705,
0.0011965946,
-0.0402508304,
-0.0100744888,
-0.0181178357,
-0.050810162,
0.0327914581,
-0.0197893213,
-0.0242676735,
0.0146489283,
-0.0112288371,
-0.052673582,
-0.0372209623,
0.0436362475,
0.0200055428,
0.034693595,
0.014648119,
0.0258055925,
0.0135953808,
0.0338914245,
0.0274546109,
-0.0235343948,
-0.0100628696,
-0.0283886306,
-0.0200483259,
-0.0228630509,
-5.360495583e-33,
-0.017450612,
-0.0571453683,
-0.0189749412,
-0.0086461799,
-0.0274266955,
0.0045058751,
-0.0663336664,
-0.0051422394,
0.0353845991,
0.0322202966,
0.0157187171,
0.0160243474,
0.0068509514,
0.0163626056,
-0.0070038862,
0.0138502717,
0.0583023056,
-0.001391869,
-0.0430584997,
0.0277839843,
0.0250379015,
0.0169339981,
-0.0000131816,
-0.0773288086,
0.0555346683,
-0.0050453655,
-0.0060151774,
-0.0250019021,
0.0946303904,
0.0089783967,
0.0116767855,
0.0276611783,
0.0328076817,
-0.0141332932,
-0.064629361,
0.0419004522,
-0.0833758712,
-0.0178105831,
-0.0211788658,
-0.0044522104,
-0.0434972681,
-0.0061334525,
0.0403384939,
-0.0141359279,
-0.0014679824,
-0.0543000698,
0.0720184073,
-0.0598613583,
-0.0410033874,
-0.027279947,
0.0144965118,
0.0555660054,
-0.0469641984,
-0.0158867314,
0.0443937965,
0.0708345398,
0.0095714564,
0.0325686187,
-0.0310781077,
0.0618850961,
0.0295495614,
-0.0363800302,
0.0555963404,
0.0120295156,
0.0292301327,
0.0409960337,
0.0088698808,
0.0062049078,
-0.0394403711,
0.0371188968,
-0.0092624296,
0.0354781523,
0.0606586076,
-0.0070596784,
0.0286398847,
0.0191899706,
-0.0140421139,
0.0985406488,
-0.0926952437,
0.0259708073,
-0.014666508,
-0.0061859195,
-0.0280162189,
-0.011587034,
-0.0223083477,
-0.0064716726,
-0.0059187463,
0.006353179,
0.0057165599,
-0.0000820745,
-0.0139838345,
-0.0048066331,
-0.0201110374,
-0.0299182702,
-0.0017076321,
-0.0108780749,
0.0021769213,
0.0395068228,
-0.0016187887,
-0.0444330834,
-0.0142691657,
-0.0050062616,
0.0364037827,
0.0364473164,
0.0173396282,
-0.002082763,
0.0379265137,
-0.0049549299,
-0.0362377763,
0.0090864152,
0.0242628735,
-0.053512156,
-0.0346881971,
0.0112805795,
0.0152117033,
-0.0186573472,
-0.0409129225,
0.0478934199,
-0.0049249358,
0.0307312272,
-0.0122387186,
-0.0239677187,
-0.0288317706,
0.0497772768,
-0.0001478435,
-0.0130696436,
-0.0061152969,
-0.0191845428,
0.0290107224,
-0.0240583196,
-0.0156998467,
-0.0357261747,
2.388e-7,
0.060202796,
0.0352687724,
0.0684399307,
0.0232120454,
-0.0062599457,
0.0015430063,
-0.0490123369,
-0.0055774697,
-0.019233942,
0.0243355595,
0.0376676247,
0.0119767468,
0.0639395341,
0.0660498589,
-0.0599659979,
-0.0357677042,
-0.044280313,
-0.0304126628,
-0.0408787988,
0.0185105223,
0.0712847114,
0.0232905038,
-0.049865827,
-0.0013372963,
0.0370460115,
-0.0818492323,
0.0485986546,
-0.0384543277,
0.0089804679,
-0.0076357438,
0.0555961207,
0.0334579386,
-0.0133146634,
-0.0235360283,
-0.0156172067,
-0.0166353472,
0.084335655,
0.007321585,
0.0057362565,
0.0589478873,
0.0155362925,
0.0015803246,
0.0392170362,
-0.0149939451,
0.0312430561,
-0.0822642893,
-0.0480567776,
0.0391191728,
-0.0354436785,
0.0466893092,
0.0283950269,
0.003583255,
-0.0495735444,
0.0096643623,
0.0271409228,
0.0009623264,
0.0209529027,
-0.0195291527,
-0.0562476851,
0.0511131026,
0.0246019885,
-0.0273403134,
-0.0118979625,
0.0251051132,
-0.039689526,
-0.0164902136,
-0.0144125419,
2.367976432e-34,
0.0838061869,
-0.0246193036,
-0.0319999084,
-0.039432656,
0.0408074819,
-0.0756171495,
0.0309713092,
0.0200426374,
0.0209006816,
-0.0756780654,
-0.0074879839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13597v1 | Shades of meaning: Uncovering the geometry of ambiguous word representations through contextualised language models | 2023-04-26T14:47:38 | 2023-04-26T14:47:38 | Benedetta Cevoli, Chris Watkins, Yang Gao, Kathleen Rastle | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical ambiguity presents a profound and enduring challenge to the language
sciences. Researchers for decades have grappled with the problem of how
language users learn, represent and process words with more than one meaning.
Our work offers new insight into psychological understanding of lexical
ambiguity through a series of simulations that capitalise on recent advances in
contextual language models. These models have no grounded understanding of the
meanings of words at all; they simply learn to predict words based on the
surrounding context provided by other words. Yet, our analyses show that their
representations capture fine-grained meaningful distinctions between
unambiguous, homonymous, and polysemous words that align with lexicographic
classifications and psychological theorising. These findings provide
quantitative support for modern psychological conceptualisations of lexical
ambiguity and raise new challenges for understanding of the way that contextual
information shapes the meanings of words across different timescales. | [
0.0455767289,
0.0057223388,
-0.056437891,
0.0494668148,
-0.0535437986,
-0.005275744,
0.0115154544,
0.0190595761,
-0.0407207571,
-0.0532091036,
-0.0198140573,
-0.0854826346,
0.027289141,
0.0012126212,
0.0161859225,
-0.0424770191,
0.0433462262,
0.0000643001,
-0.0149750384,
-0.0129278889,
-0.0043255379,
0.011421158,
0.0055068103,
0.0339515135,
-0.0273758061,
-0.0109668262,
-0.0036637951,
-0.0078827497,
-0.0453359038,
-0.0035106228,
-0.0227091089,
0.04166089,
0.0320419334,
0.0846593454,
0.0000019469,
-0.0558118895,
-0.0049080956,
-0.0292288996,
-0.0338619687,
0.0010187284,
0.084239848,
-0.0034602326,
0.0179574788,
-0.0415713526,
-0.0242482908,
0.0278964899,
0.0400217362,
-0.0192661546,
-0.0331928618,
-0.0271897893,
0.0066408077,
-0.0306617748,
-0.0326172933,
-0.0233829338,
0.0239186175,
-0.0272630733,
0.0303708222,
0.0003511518,
-0.0162135474,
-0.0025172834,
-0.0650210604,
0.0332960933,
0.0064713699,
0.07547988,
-0.0452914611,
0.0309314374,
0.0378594808,
-0.0066826995,
0.0173529126,
0.0088115782,
-0.0151518369,
-0.0189553872,
-0.01098195,
-0.0411375426,
-0.0249028336,
0.0403359681,
0.0299759321,
0.0469053611,
0.0094054854,
0.0089690043,
0.0272553675,
0.0206533242,
0.0186539534,
0.0482721888,
-0.0120333675,
0.0820840746,
0.0111227669,
-0.0175020453,
0.0100266961,
-0.0190576203,
-0.008586403,
-0.0353970639,
0.0163358822,
-0.0096301688,
0.0051785987,
0.0662365481,
-0.0100910859,
-0.0142551707,
0.0584907867,
-0.0733953342,
0.0390949138,
0.0203662682,
-0.0206434559,
0.0312288366,
-0.0019940624,
-0.011561946,
-0.0027438726,
-0.0075490805,
-0.0469033048,
0.0044962177,
-0.0228091329,
-0.0386249609,
-0.0301700123,
0.0001979382,
-0.0477873087,
-0.0234563574,
-0.0310731158,
-0.0164345577,
-0.0409156494,
-0.0531422347,
-0.046213191,
0.0068288385,
-0.0505941771,
0.0201039128,
-0.0551172532,
-0.017630605,
-0.0608196631,
0.0613106415,
-0.0498147234,
-0.0532074869,
0.0165039841,
-0.0104541685,
-0.0214934144,
-0.0454665944,
0.0056204046,
0.0172072388,
0.002861337,
-0.0359995924,
-0.0023031998,
-0.0632297769,
-0.0705532506,
-0.0078149466,
-0.012636994,
-0.0668194145,
0.0230791774,
0.0350108296,
-0.0103884172,
-0.0505554937,
-0.008221711,
-0.022540221,
-0.0432944372,
0.1090600416,
-0.0048268484,
0.0005046529,
0.0030772528,
0.0319420323,
-0.0138660837,
0.0723661557,
0.0311273914,
-0.0020732533,
0.0246886127,
0.0151480287,
-0.0145947514,
0.0030424253,
-0.0193496849,
0.0069883005,
-0.0249975119,
-0.0426288694,
-0.0299662426,
0.0527289845,
0.0217357371,
0.0373690166,
-0.0057056854,
-0.0479921885,
0.0051678345,
0.0541106015,
0.0044633364,
0.0097294105,
0.0689337105,
0.0230208989,
-0.0002943455,
0.0295246802,
-0.0202517975,
-0.0382285379,
-0.0178277157,
0.0049701487,
-0.0297136847,
0.0128004588,
-0.0029072517,
0.0165111851,
-0.0371751152,
0.0067905802,
0.0543272868,
-0.0256321467,
0.0379830338,
-0.0113287885,
-0.0099164769,
0.0389711782,
0.0644985959,
-0.0189977661,
0.0305027328,
-0.0132712787,
-0.0144198472,
0.0659146011,
-0.0067332289,
0.0103497272,
-0.020306658,
0.0054513295,
-0.0136496732,
0.039079003,
0.0166182313,
0.0097422237,
0.0177221503,
-0.0176491775,
0.0076068533,
-0.0063105458,
0.0212528538,
0.0416915379,
-0.001091718,
0.0028061469,
0.0140006095,
-0.0212936513,
0.0234000105,
0.0317177325,
-0.0386151075,
-0.0331297256,
-0.0548432469,
0.0123737883,
0.0084502706,
-0.0021380319,
-0.0259100292,
0.0251479112,
0.0074048606,
0.0010614381,
0.0061663156,
0.0121917268,
-0.0805410221,
0.0452780984,
0.0027093424,
-0.009781627,
0.022358695,
-0.0358106121,
0.0303503014,
-0.0087956144,
0.0302357748,
-0.0154923378,
0.0713411197,
-0.0269825347,
0.0165069029,
-0.0514075011,
0.0281573422,
-0.0330545716,
0.0685359687,
-0.0194743052,
0.040004842,
-0.0093724793,
0.0384187922,
0.010156692,
0.0059415246,
-0.037583746,
-0.0112262927,
0.009224806,
0.0023190901,
-0.0026189343,
-0.0374324769,
-0.0621176846,
-0.0435011946,
-0.0732835606,
-0.0313400999,
0.0245311353,
-0.0314014927,
0.0251285993,
-0.0256153289,
-0.0127658099,
0.0246620588,
0.0237513278,
0.0082659004,
-0.0195791982,
0.0572774895,
-0.0039334372,
-0.0160888247,
-0.033253938,
-0.0127890501,
-0.0281434339,
-0.0491796397,
0.0402935445,
-0.0047256849,
-0.0203591604,
-0.0185481384,
0.0163525473,
-0.04606333,
-0.0027668364,
-0.0057735257,
0.0185299441,
0.0316280648,
0.0305116717,
0.0557777584,
-0.0161689296,
0.0115842503,
0.0973461196,
0.0590939038,
-0.0519605279,
-0.0284009986,
-0.0295654722,
-0.0568066277,
-0.0157807525,
-0.0214163177,
-0.0708647221,
-0.0446400009,
0.0581942573,
0.0663965195,
-0.0036260788,
-0.0266039483,
0.0485031642,
-0.0876549035,
-0.0468237959,
-0.0407958105,
-0.0359935202,
-0.0723323822,
0.0659080297,
-0.0146695487,
-0.012036535,
0.0452631377,
0.0193672441,
0.0260319598,
-0.028467698,
0.0291781817,
0.0021830939,
0.0930662528,
-0.0473150499,
0.0339630432,
0.0233064312,
-0.0212876704,
-0.0664877966,
-0.0416978821,
0.0162981283,
-0.060253229,
0.0670879111,
-0.0299651828,
-0.0133166723,
0.0258275531,
0.0271541588,
-0.0151055111,
-0.0211826451,
-0.0166351032,
0.0208593924,
0.0443900563,
0.03649389,
0.0456698239,
0.0047034817,
-0.0215090271,
-0.0307747461,
0.0026095111,
-0.0267696492,
-0.0015417183,
0.0213229209,
0.0065643946,
0.0004120991,
0.083904013,
-0.021291703,
-0.0459994674,
-0.0064725359,
-0.0023909088,
0.021876609,
-0.0043390812,
0.0280795358,
0.0428001359,
-0.0371322632,
-0.0499201678,
0.0261651035,
0.0328755416,
-0.0243862048,
-0.009314226,
0.0850705951,
0.0476878211,
-0.0180157516,
0.0611792244,
-0.0582482629,
0.0095990319,
0.0135508757,
-0.0120896054,
-0.075413011,
-0.0047404403,
-0.0044765919,
-0.0406953953,
-0.0367376171,
-0.0309145022,
-0.0193736609,
-0.0465655811,
-0.0179329179,
0.0000163158,
-0.0562453754,
0.0277118832,
0.0175008662,
0.027091125,
0.0376674719,
0.0338463932,
0.0088932766,
-0.0184621196,
0.0114158746,
0.0009812483,
0.032520853,
-0.0364310034,
0.0332436636,
-0.0222637597,
0.0473535694,
0.0096194148,
0.012321596,
-0.0415730104,
-0.044900395,
0.0099444082,
-0.0315719433,
-0.0043398179,
-0.0209149905,
-0.020205779,
0.0234894045,
0.0071145175,
-0.0103299972,
-0.0386180431,
-0.007000654,
-0.0505574718,
-0.0311782993,
0.01591371,
0.0074472968,
-0.0613483749,
-0.0291085448,
0.0043533104,
0.0146515472,
0.0922461972,
0.0171144456,
-0.0450897254,
-0.0006712456,
0.0073967557,
0.0660422593,
0.0575928278,
-0.0329045206,
-0.0092345951,
-0.0005362726,
-0.0041799066,
0.0041099265,
-0.0521904156,
-0.0061742649,
-0.0145050511,
0.0449270047,
0.0243378803,
-0.0116919903,
-0.0348877907,
-0.0503097735,
0.00883279,
0.0121328095,
0.0537499227,
0.0101848468,
-0.0394904502,
0.0040420904,
-0.0312251821,
-0.0197394639,
0.0530940443,
-0.0499198362,
-0.0260083396,
0.0923970491,
-0.0288683139,
0.0338152386,
-0.0035678495,
-0.0103665106,
-0.0125619173,
0.0002945692,
0.0075905439,
0.0477937981,
0.0588285886,
0.0237798188,
0.0812464878,
0.0113700852,
0.0407025255,
-0.0137333777,
0.0429068618,
0.0185753349,
0.0141737778,
-0.0183915384,
-0.054198321,
0.0179883353,
-0.031533964,
0.0035363156,
-0.0425942056,
0.0096317576,
0.0044535715,
-0.0654640123,
-0.0015382677,
-0.0121785132,
0.0278900638,
-0.051914949,
0.0245783832,
0.011540791,
-0.0209082197,
-0.0221732743,
0.0064484142,
0.0291475095,
-0.0141877234,
-0.0324634686,
0.0252615195,
-0.0229347888,
0.0000803458,
0.0361125991,
-0.0072949929,
0.0578663722,
-0.0900996029,
0.0252136942,
-0.0136217326,
0.0458100215,
0.0051179766,
-0.0168011766,
-0.0504980385,
0.0077878274,
-0.0373646021,
-0.0181537457,
0.009721742,
-0.0031729115,
0.0087404903,
-0.0462220125,
0.0149151422,
-0.0735614151,
0.0154975113,
-0.0079068867,
-0.0195076596,
0.0225283224,
-0.0343179144,
0.0660202131,
0.0158101078,
-0.0045122383,
0.0021218385,
0.0463945419,
-0.0304114446,
0.0416555516,
0.0068427441,
-0.0409837104,
-0.0030590282,
-0.0121968547,
0.0120991189,
0.0863515288,
-0.010078704,
0.0207813494,
-0.1294159889,
-0.0231019724,
0.0455338061,
-0.0024669713,
0.062644355,
-0.029188212,
0.0327358171,
0.0835089982,
0.0072774515,
-0.0073904386,
-0.0301330686,
0.0438417532,
0.0270094592,
0.0046863076,
-0.0367311798,
-6.144742803e-33,
-0.0234136432,
-0.0304112062,
-0.0282562282,
-0.041305311,
-0.0388438143,
0.0251049511,
-0.0126521634,
0.0288604703,
-0.0350727588,
0.0041839886,
0.0096598612,
0.0037017236,
0.0166920442,
-0.0068782424,
0.0546507835,
-0.0063899364,
0.0122292712,
0.0312891267,
-0.0002661516,
-0.0292586759,
0.0572873354,
-0.0254236292,
0.0266574901,
-0.0420159549,
0.0729071051,
0.0177343544,
-0.0089452658,
0.0062477184,
-0.0185950045,
0.0350553393,
-0.0551050603,
0.0644807518,
0.0425987244,
0.0057375357,
-0.0124300523,
0.0117247282,
-0.0173029806,
-0.0624137633,
0.0962265879,
-0.0016883194,
-0.0354792029,
-0.0283097886,
0.0513899662,
-0.0211412124,
-0.0718368888,
0.0295729022,
0.0120496415,
0.0135404393,
-0.0432055593,
-0.0261172205,
-0.0700322315,
-0.0192051902,
0.030130798,
-0.018564377,
0.0284925457,
-0.0526679568,
0.0057830033,
0.0014512554,
-0.052647382,
0.0090016089,
-0.0108830808,
0.0137211755,
0.0351301841,
0.071115002,
0.0080250204,
0.0788277537,
0.0450750329,
-0.006592751,
-0.0098625422,
-0.0395335518,
0.0644783229,
0.0063869781,
0.004191604,
0.0342749432,
0.0373053998,
-0.0567113124,
0.0573370643,
-0.0429040715,
0.0485275239,
-0.0341662169,
0.0799294263,
0.0059675393,
-0.0255651567,
-0.0460743792,
-0.0728254914,
-0.0464003943,
-0.0466107503,
-0.0089856582,
0.0255836193,
-0.0402433462,
0.0151476655,
0.0543988347,
0.0142489653,
-0.0248594955,
-0.0644421503,
-0.0396469422,
0.0092242034,
0.0244072229,
0.0404427201,
0.0517596938,
-0.0011468045,
-0.0293798465,
-0.0218343977,
0.0175377987,
-0.007995639,
0.0254326463,
-0.011926176,
-0.0241394006,
-0.0031212582,
-0.0020625966,
-0.0164361726,
-0.0377902016,
0.020107178,
-0.0711510777,
0.0537777543,
0.0293853823,
-0.0222433005,
-0.0248769,
0.1006459668,
-0.0019077377,
-0.0061804759,
-0.0114111984,
-0.0781038702,
0.0573434345,
-0.0161587857,
-0.0064806342,
-0.0171228666,
0.0092844898,
0.0956649482,
-0.0271171723,
-0.005316576,
-0.0112216529,
2.714e-7,
0.0858733654,
0.068057172,
-0.0129356086,
0.0115470598,
0.0476333201,
0.0152320089,
0.0087188846,
0.0024400863,
-0.0316360034,
-0.0176542271,
-0.0413165838,
0.017146999,
-0.0151523212,
0.0132516734,
0.0363569073,
0.0297665112,
-0.009416759,
0.1034136564,
-0.0480638444,
0.0746057853,
0.0805619881,
0.0722403005,
0.0389564969,
-0.0240896828,
-0.0755235404,
0.0112145217,
0.0321901813,
-0.0546474792,
0.046621833,
0.0196502544,
-0.022098098,
-0.0052644396,
0.0560654849,
0.0237991158,
0.0252567194,
-0.0077477624,
0.0103302449,
0.0083003538,
0.0023756223,
0.0274284109,
-0.0133833922,
-0.0573714525,
-0.012641415,
-0.0769658908,
0.0488312766,
-0.0453217775,
-0.0261480082,
-0.0302909445,
-0.0183622129,
0.0501039997,
0.0264540184,
0.0009994732,
-0.0557660721,
-0.0007784705,
-0.0038318683,
-0.0002221423,
-0.0290931687,
-0.0485366583,
-0.0036095814,
0.007433685,
-0.0055174935,
-0.0249613393,
-0.0057902765,
0.012564335,
0.0360725671,
-0.0879050419,
-0.001917202,
2.179948763e-34,
0.0301211458,
0.0251622926,
0.0421411991,
0.0118632019,
-0.0017851738,
-0.0255055726,
0.0303168204,
0.0315794721,
0.021028854,
-0.0058651473,
-0.0056864726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13568v1 | Toxic comments reduce the activity of volunteer editors on Wikipedia | 2023-04-26T13:59:25 | 2023-04-26T13:59:25 | Ivan Smirnov, Camelia Oprea, Markus Strohmaier | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Wikipedia is one of the most successful collaborative projects in history. It
is the largest encyclopedia ever created, with millions of users worldwide
relying on it as the first source of information as well as for fact-checking
and in-depth research. As Wikipedia relies solely on the efforts of its
volunteer-editors, its success might be particularly affected by toxic speech.
In this paper, we analyze all 57 million comments made on user talk pages of
8.5 million editors across the six most active language editions of Wikipedia
to study the potential impact of toxicity on editors' behaviour. We find that
toxic comments consistently reduce the activity of editors, leading to an
estimated loss of 0.5-2 active days per user in the short term. This amounts to
multiple human-years of lost productivity when considering the number of active
contributors to Wikipedia. The effects of toxic comments are even greater in
the long term, as they significantly increase the risk of editors leaving the
project altogether. Using an agent-based model, we demonstrate that toxicity
attacks on Wikipedia have the potential to impede the progress of the entire
project. Our results underscore the importance of mitigating toxic speech on
collaborative platforms such as Wikipedia to ensure their continued success. | [
0.1066546366,
0.0487252958,
-0.0291927122,
0.0157624688,
-0.0116868131,
-0.0062538995,
0.03902556,
0.02125163,
0.0324988663,
-0.0432805978,
0.045485165,
0.0395227224,
-0.0137863038,
-0.0092901364,
0.0180749446,
-0.0286579281,
-0.0063540181,
0.0237555802,
-0.0061629275,
-0.0174129885,
0.0583031513,
-0.0154474247,
-0.007838659,
0.0525725596,
0.0039266846,
-0.0083802463,
0.040298827,
-0.0034759722,
0.0390389711,
-0.0096496176,
-0.0064618238,
0.0399135277,
-0.0496014282,
0.0387906171,
0.0000017864,
-0.0370850973,
0.0250510052,
-0.0001066792,
-0.0371478088,
0.0195664633,
0.0414140373,
-0.0158378538,
-0.0167249814,
0.0147353038,
0.0031655144,
-0.0197225641,
0.0423436947,
-0.0082494672,
0.0767340735,
0.0180985015,
-0.0152817406,
0.0164412968,
0.0222484451,
0.031600453,
0.044551529,
0.0112693794,
0.0383559316,
-0.0373347662,
-0.0481564142,
-0.0413858183,
0.0167924315,
0.0496249683,
-0.0219485126,
-0.0630814806,
0.0391630419,
0.0009349218,
0.0009534339,
-0.0600324124,
0.031494651,
0.0111789191,
0.0654811636,
0.0087362379,
0.0213153102,
0.0230700932,
0.0152664213,
0.0658912361,
-0.0238706321,
0.0576630868,
-0.0347895697,
-0.0603651218,
-0.0085326834,
0.0079279989,
0.0291555189,
0.0323681608,
0.068913877,
0.0013051315,
0.0068386211,
-0.03306536,
-0.0144430567,
-0.0091719488,
0.008397962,
-0.0231819954,
0.0064644353,
0.002339029,
0.0136666931,
-0.0014131196,
-0.0064792787,
-0.0795885995,
0.0257576164,
-0.1016483009,
-0.0813691095,
0.030899426,
0.0096650803,
0.0399222299,
0.0546689965,
-0.0450095944,
-0.0153158484,
0.0307407323,
0.0673544407,
0.0401585177,
-0.0015539024,
0.0190703049,
0.0041522644,
-0.0135663263,
0.0566851348,
0.0213924441,
0.0016686725,
0.0521765389,
-0.0273895711,
0.0283077937,
0.044702936,
0.0135440296,
-0.0194857791,
0.0007131089,
-0.0211979654,
-0.0236411002,
-0.0530959778,
0.0059653358,
-0.0194387566,
0.004188478,
0.0043900786,
-0.014112181,
0.0265292898,
-0.010100767,
0.0253869183,
0.1339659393,
0.0676973909,
0.0244767275,
-0.0755344778,
-0.0548082739,
0.0114880977,
0.0244451351,
-0.0451649614,
-0.0543668382,
-0.0046269768,
0.0139876818,
-0.0433772691,
-0.0751732364,
-0.016230274,
-0.0125026992,
-0.0342255086,
0.0367224142,
-0.1290532053,
0.0009624669,
0.0646743402,
0.0431952067,
-0.0578343906,
-0.0044481051,
0.0118597131,
0.017043611,
0.0694150329,
0.026841566,
0.0117492145,
0.0535536557,
0.0079507204,
0.0321128964,
0.0351714306,
0.0184454527,
-0.0157861952,
-0.0151886316,
-0.0274601746,
0.0448028669,
-0.0467179306,
-0.0263107214,
0.0834819004,
0.0021208269,
-0.0941972136,
0.0477426238,
0.0182038601,
-0.0187787134,
-0.0209596083,
-0.0273218788,
-0.0177052598,
0.0037637269,
0.0105349207,
-0.0407714136,
0.0425357409,
0.0196472239,
-0.0168599579,
-0.0036231289,
-0.0064301537,
-0.0156787913,
0.057632044,
-0.041108273,
-0.0083653629,
0.0040250644,
-0.0079803588,
0.0012827656,
0.0391489826,
-0.0279850997,
0.023578519,
-0.0243628677,
0.0355287045,
0.1127759814,
0.0457399823,
0.0106961587,
0.0034374306,
-0.0655747429,
0.019609917,
0.0491336137,
0.0153174279,
-0.0225513242,
-0.0549436249,
0.0067696702,
-0.0192078948,
0.0031617878,
0.0220864229,
-0.0031053952,
0.012004111,
0.0284191482,
-0.027768366,
0.0078221252,
-0.0650077313,
0.0023736223,
0.0034717433,
-0.0217965636,
-0.0762350187,
0.0447886698,
0.0225225724,
0.0112117305,
-0.0290209446,
-0.0130535653,
0.0159082804,
0.003780572,
-0.0314947776,
0.0035122863,
0.0918212757,
0.0398712307,
0.0098748337,
-0.0503340922,
-0.0287861358,
0.0250000246,
0.0539838932,
0.0567895696,
0.0606403165,
-0.0528947935,
0.0275222603,
0.0299822763,
-0.0248114746,
-0.0309740361,
0.0016665485,
-0.0185935535,
0.0291704591,
-0.0155260004,
0.0163232405,
0.0264396425,
-0.0313448422,
-0.0199513454,
0.0034117955,
-0.0441126712,
-0.0465436131,
0.0094675645,
0.034032248,
0.0417348891,
-0.0539531372,
-0.0344784297,
0.0125128925,
-0.0482240729,
-0.0645730793,
-0.0203723181,
0.021602178,
0.0383457281,
-0.0158159919,
0.0051132105,
0.0622978434,
-0.0015141127,
-0.0392351821,
-0.0115569448,
0.0573849082,
0.0237094667,
0.0113798566,
-0.0314293206,
-0.0514896289,
0.0037805922,
-0.022769196,
-0.0009500614,
0.0765847415,
-0.0699505284,
0.0015595717,
0.0658429936,
-0.0496679433,
-0.0418879651,
-0.0019858491,
-0.0342367515,
0.0202051681,
-0.0070478041,
0.0089580771,
0.0434369892,
0.0513432696,
0.0938984454,
-0.0154124834,
-0.0101649966,
-0.0235052295,
-0.0225530695,
0.0084030945,
0.0109236883,
-0.0154784229,
-0.030720165,
0.0091136368,
0.0046260632,
0.0176847652,
0.0067884903,
-0.0469257422,
0.0679620728,
-0.0484127179,
-0.0065126652,
0.0264968295,
-0.0807107612,
-0.0115159201,
0.0115304515,
-0.0003258194,
-0.025977429,
0.0212790705,
-9.017e-7,
0.0394312255,
-0.0043006451,
-0.0046653682,
0.0216487478,
0.0426944904,
-0.0286804568,
0.0270488337,
0.0175811648,
0.0275146496,
-0.0078016515,
0.0023322748,
0.0994971469,
-0.0198554862,
-0.0359428823,
0.0177994408,
0.0126145901,
0.0105296224,
0.0013130694,
-0.0108607849,
-0.0800481215,
-0.0429181792,
-0.062717177,
0.0606658086,
-0.0078016887,
-0.0066773742,
0.0073103081,
0.0552241355,
-0.0358740352,
0.0381829962,
-0.0455450155,
0.0404306538,
-0.036057245,
-0.0112408251,
-0.0077941371,
0.0233852677,
-0.04526034,
-0.002761272,
0.0583297312,
0.0199217014,
-0.0433189496,
0.0316902623,
-0.0416854583,
-0.004174157,
0.0025572192,
0.004495061,
-0.0066185449,
-0.0323798843,
-0.0181074068,
0.0038547756,
0.02082696,
0.0048294757,
-0.0603624322,
0.0092116799,
-0.0254198685,
-0.0058413506,
0.0086948201,
0.0072819241,
-0.0692721456,
-0.0006575271,
-0.0018371048,
0.0246240329,
-0.054890167,
-0.0677877367,
0.0025564679,
-0.0463866517,
0.029784834,
-0.0382587537,
0.0181189086,
0.023211848,
-0.0259778704,
-0.0279186815,
-0.0410757996,
-0.0114760809,
-0.0080020856,
0.0247085635,
-0.0039924392,
0.0164006371,
-0.0482298136,
0.0014196376,
0.005158538,
-0.0544454344,
0.0748523921,
0.0215828288,
0.0119746048,
-0.0500048138,
-0.0154505987,
0.0300918408,
0.0746333152,
-0.0467415415,
0.0176758859,
0.1256050318,
-0.0031010662,
-0.0179618094,
-0.0113795409,
0.0110483002,
0.0030240719,
0.0116214817,
0.0001821177,
0.0335282013,
0.0648196489,
-0.0195440426,
-0.0425004475,
-0.0026805929,
0.0376486368,
0.0029315485,
0.0255932156,
-0.0762035176,
0.0063731265,
-0.0536519177,
-0.0281867143,
-0.0374968983,
-0.0838933662,
-0.0456681289,
-0.0195143055,
-0.057729613,
-0.086269021,
-0.0380286574,
-0.0111216474,
0.0211470705,
0.0572575182,
-0.0423969738,
0.005909232,
0.0351040289,
0.0290210266,
-0.0172012225,
0.0138200382,
0.0348626487,
-0.0332563221,
0.0113864718,
-0.0327121243,
0.0090356665,
-0.0021870784,
0.0146437781,
-0.0343688354,
-0.0613954663,
0.0619425699,
0.0895335004,
0.0258074496,
-0.0150496876,
0.0112766223,
-0.0397683866,
0.0345609225,
0.0435135327,
-0.0306789484,
-0.0089320587,
0.006119601,
0.0267701689,
-0.0009037088,
0.0132549526,
-0.0509717911,
-0.0281914547,
0.0084768338,
-0.0205788743,
-0.0606894642,
0.0208936837,
-0.006298142,
0.0295438282,
-0.0052595674,
-0.0088188211,
-0.0017998257,
-0.0234677102,
-0.0017473814,
-0.010032353,
-0.0229366589,
0.0475044325,
0.0075036203,
-0.0233914461,
-0.0096055921,
-0.0022719414,
0.0546962991,
-0.0165514052,
-0.0031286664,
-0.0319834761,
0.009693969,
0.0311043877,
-0.0053922855,
0.0374298878,
0.003007716,
-0.0164196528,
0.0134508451,
0.0151416073,
0.0114870472,
-0.0183390677,
-0.0199504048,
-0.0037848214,
0.0014248278,
0.0424471684,
0.0033378226,
-0.0490397215,
-0.0598999485,
0.0278492998,
-0.0331454128,
-0.0182248447,
0.0314221159,
0.0447767414,
-0.0029573734,
-0.0047992631,
-0.0163804684,
-0.0311566498,
-0.0062492848,
-0.0215061381,
0.0049745021,
0.0044294172,
-0.0345323794,
-0.004159932,
0.0269306544,
-0.0024862562,
0.0555144809,
-0.0303770732,
-0.0356873088,
0.0065518478,
-0.0235809591,
-0.0161774419,
0.0141842654,
-0.0089132534,
-0.0344424099,
-0.0480530858,
-0.0418406576,
-0.0451481603,
-0.007319713,
0.0174565557,
-0.0108513702,
-0.0123687005,
0.016517818,
0.0572150573,
0.0378244407,
-0.0068057291,
0.020315893,
-0.0534630194,
-0.0191667285,
0.0295757763,
-5.45521802e-33,
0.0374991968,
-0.0619453862,
-0.0130236978,
0.0862604231,
0.0004941542,
-0.0295778718,
-0.0107711218,
0.0534715205,
-0.0249385871,
0.015547758,
-0.0030463873,
-0.0026179985,
0.0116541022,
-0.0439236499,
0.0341262929,
-0.0197100043,
0.020304909,
-0.0116691245,
0.00337233,
0.0164913107,
0.0353932194,
-0.0040857405,
-0.0121603506,
-0.0625723228,
0.0672687292,
-0.0296058357,
-0.0165315364,
0.0141379526,
0.0234460831,
0.0380611196,
0.0202276018,
0.0516263656,
0.0033117591,
-0.032159768,
0.0244055633,
-0.0258405544,
0.0057631889,
0.0108073475,
0.0137093971,
-0.030980967,
0.0127027994,
-0.0285364389,
0.0799022838,
0.0140476944,
-0.063995786,
-0.0050896117,
0.0510075614,
0.0093752714,
0.0229986906,
-0.011968079,
-0.0547554865,
0.0010125448,
-0.0567767397,
0.0325093381,
-0.0385982245,
0.0247906726,
0.0524527915,
-0.021028515,
-0.08732187,
0.0368133299,
-0.0462617055,
-0.012658692,
-0.021782307,
-0.0303766504,
0.0071758665,
0.0546836182,
0.0010895407,
0.0731578022,
-0.0450219177,
0.0377652161,
-0.0148176113,
0.0114099551,
0.018784536,
0.0885347426,
-0.0243902393,
-0.088738054,
-0.0595005117,
0.0383856371,
0.0499320254,
0.0346659012,
0.0257100333,
-0.0505745634,
-0.0415031724,
-0.0307244323,
-0.001849518,
-0.0490422249,
-0.0358830951,
-0.0367468484,
-0.0121266395,
-0.006643211,
-0.057084538,
-0.0394304283,
0.0120427106,
-0.042575527,
-0.0099522863,
0.0345680304,
-0.0239694025,
0.0001469189,
-0.0016350881,
-0.0285886619,
-0.0399263315,
0.0337066464,
-0.0623346828,
0.0094330804,
0.0624887533,
0.0099774655,
0.0186207313,
0.0300781708,
-0.0255788676,
0.0093426853,
0.0009685043,
0.0234443564,
-0.0147328787,
0.020463217,
-0.0135857007,
0.0036851219,
0.0194556788,
-0.0525609143,
0.056532003,
0.0315085091,
-0.0296275951,
-0.0134719154,
-0.0094133047,
-0.0305810496,
-0.0200001597,
-0.0113909692,
-0.0133400401,
0.0655619651,
0.0148438392,
-0.0643789694,
0.0113365985,
-0.1025721356,
2.585e-7,
0.0176779088,
0.0486822911,
-0.0026947109,
0.0020401387,
0.0543741584,
0.0512872413,
0.0276139323,
0.0431840084,
-0.0061238497,
-0.0563400798,
-0.016993463,
-0.0103535475,
-0.0055985525,
0.0587316975,
-0.0389220715,
-0.075215742,
-0.0679649487,
0.005940693,
-0.0524722114,
-0.0210426003,
0.0255561676,
-0.0261662453,
0.0356234424,
-0.0212444067,
-0.0271879341,
-0.0371921211,
0.0329306386,
-0.0082309702,
0.0227465834,
0.025892945,
0.012259379,
0.0156469457,
0.0098849395,
0.0130311428,
-0.0072656833,
-0.0170827694,
-0.0013745726,
0.0157000665,
0.0049537919,
0.0153249968,
0.0525867455,
-0.0550283603,
0.0361462347,
-0.0140272388,
0.0140375663,
0.0515922345,
-0.0142795034,
0.0356104299,
-0.0160972327,
-0.0396525115,
0.0492991507,
-0.0394102149,
-0.0238178093,
-0.0168966372,
-0.0266897995,
-0.0008321002,
0.0255943481,
-0.053804975,
-0.0191684458,
-0.0675403178,
-0.0396418236,
-0.1044120044,
0.0060984953,
0.0228270255,
0.0037874754,
0.0279718302,
0.042634774,
1.84608231e-34,
0.0039149565,
-0.0113321021,
-0.0071951887,
-0.0167357698,
0.0468828194,
0.0246421825,
0.0017620483,
-0.0255336072,
0.0175593887,
-0.0028019913,
-0.0399435014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13567v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13567v4 | Technical Report: Impact of Position Bias on Language Models in Token Classification | 2023-04-26T13:57:25 | 2024-04-11T08:10:11 | Mehdi Ben Amor, Michael Granitzer, Jelena Mitrović | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language Models (LMs) have shown state-of-the-art performance in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Downstream tasks such as Named Entity
Recognition (NER) or Part-of-Speech (POS) tagging are known to suffer from data
imbalance issues, particularly regarding the ratio of positive to negative
examples and class disparities. This paper investigates an often-overlooked
issue of encoder models, specifically the position bias of positive examples in
token classification tasks. For completeness, we also include decoders in the
evaluation. We evaluate the impact of position bias using different position
embedding techniques, focusing on BERT with Absolute Position Embedding (APE),
Relative Position Embedding (RPE), and Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE).
Therefore, we conduct an in-depth evaluation of the impact of position bias on
the performance of LMs when fine-tuned on token classification benchmarks. Our
study includes CoNLL03 and OntoNote5.0 for NER, English Tree Bank UD\_en, and
TweeBank for POS tagging. We propose an evaluation approach to investigate
position bias in transformer models. We show that LMs can suffer from this bias
with an average drop ranging from 3\% to 9\% in their performance. To mitigate
this effect, we propose two methods: Random Position Shifting and Context
Perturbation, that we apply on batches during the training process. The results
show an improvement of $\approx$ 2\% in the performance of the model on
CoNLL03, UD\_en, and TweeBank. | [
0.0368669517,
-0.004627577,
0.0025463377,
0.0426708609,
-0.0110363327,
0.0314962044,
-0.0016504918,
-0.0091771437,
-0.0447570309,
-0.0943407044,
-0.0252988972,
-0.0125939483,
0.0244495366,
0.0143241258,
0.0316571705,
-0.0457049944,
0.0327465124,
0.0029485275,
0.0407610945,
-0.0005853644,
-0.0132034104,
-0.014052134,
-0.0173501819,
0.0648635626,
-0.0299980491,
0.0267240163,
0.0090816962,
0.0395790488,
0.0249173939,
-0.0240004137,
0.0039642015,
0.0299036391,
-0.0020630283,
0.0399915427,
0.0000019332,
-0.046095591,
-0.0449603461,
0.0137321744,
-0.0230206475,
-0.0232266616,
0.0243965331,
-0.0298283342,
-0.0199383534,
0.0515247844,
0.0102093546,
-0.049458418,
0.0537867211,
0.0676075295,
0.0379824527,
0.090814285,
-0.01002522,
-0.0125400238,
0.0279668532,
-0.0113906404,
0.0117851337,
0.0020816952,
0.0284631103,
-0.035359785,
-0.0293332208,
0.0049135392,
-0.0628510118,
0.0026475431,
0.0180402584,
0.024106998,
0.0223612189,
0.0512639023,
-0.0892165527,
-0.010566772,
-0.0033212465,
0.0192703735,
-0.052362103,
-0.034277048,
-0.0091034649,
-0.0096520912,
0.0150825847,
-0.0342624933,
-0.0269201174,
0.0376766957,
0.0019714208,
0.0293956995,
0.0040038358,
0.0090805776,
0.0137493853,
0.0010892665,
-0.0369358957,
0.0582670644,
0.0355819464,
-0.0824840069,
-0.0237664711,
0.0296185967,
-0.0294965226,
-0.0351075865,
0.0244388636,
-0.0199200287,
0.0181834865,
0.0177712999,
-0.0084425751,
-0.0187625475,
0.0084101595,
-0.0562924817,
-0.0476212949,
0.0477323644,
-0.0119989635,
0.0175460055,
-0.0635013878,
0.0733850002,
0.0031082323,
0.0563325062,
-0.021707315,
-0.0296806954,
-0.0153376153,
-0.0379081517,
-0.0473763756,
0.0388568379,
-0.0330027901,
-0.0162762254,
-0.0496237688,
0.0087775001,
-0.0004187363,
0.0057852771,
0.0298967119,
0.0282380972,
-0.0113461483,
0.0144426785,
-0.0153512741,
0.0510685556,
0.006660122,
-0.0093413405,
-0.0216149073,
-0.0595336556,
-0.0260688141,
0.0102273207,
0.0017869711,
-0.0551188365,
0.0133724185,
0.0418936759,
0.0275808536,
-0.0641999394,
-0.001654162,
0.0358429402,
-0.0283492878,
-0.0064338241,
0.0061665103,
-0.0301745106,
0.0006891377,
0.0551550277,
0.0352723822,
-0.0043008761,
0.0079637468,
0.022978887,
-0.0166378263,
0.063745901,
0.0142439771,
-0.0002445807,
0.0278014746,
-0.0129799554,
-0.0117849959,
0.0746664479,
0.0578128844,
0.0385492109,
0.0565587729,
-0.0214831401,
-0.0110493107,
0.0367278345,
0.0061404193,
-0.0408434309,
-0.0038773245,
-0.0069333701,
0.0149749247,
0.0142835239,
0.0493841283,
0.0393087566,
-0.0126600331,
-0.0025748701,
0.0464132018,
0.0453357957,
-0.021999957,
-0.0350217894,
0.0133386683,
-0.0040079858,
-0.0330480672,
-0.0355784968,
-0.0416654609,
-0.0190206654,
0.0156513453,
0.028817812,
0.0317452252,
0.0241791513,
-0.0135629838,
-0.0009559647,
-0.0354527794,
-0.0318427831,
-0.0051021143,
-0.0300296247,
0.0537202433,
0.0005535909,
-0.0708661601,
0.1204740033,
0.0042559085,
-0.0513506532,
0.0056598876,
-0.0334182978,
-0.0176863689,
0.037648242,
0.0352645069,
-0.0325374678,
-0.0456927605,
-0.0276435595,
-0.0501918606,
0.0623876639,
0.0387034267,
0.0141095622,
0.018140085,
-0.0417568274,
-0.023746673,
0.0036435705,
0.0184095837,
0.0232913028,
0.0301933456,
0.0447674468,
0.0299410988,
-0.0916648731,
0.0040074205,
0.0392466299,
0.0283237658,
-0.0167213045,
0.0173273254,
0.0248700418,
0.0199701246,
0.0235087294,
-0.01748229,
0.0141234286,
0.0466825664,
-0.0439823978,
-0.0027413841,
0.0118672736,
-0.0445555672,
-0.0434297808,
0.0285818558,
-0.0237715468,
0.0079920413,
0.0451501794,
-0.0344324075,
-0.0530273393,
-0.003970325,
-0.0242618285,
0.0727987885,
-0.0158615746,
0.054154709,
-0.017053429,
0.0058249813,
-0.0196242668,
0.0473422036,
-0.0135936281,
0.0599586479,
-0.0013928432,
-0.007252445,
0.0319835469,
-0.0280722007,
-0.0703537539,
-0.0047466848,
-0.0194068663,
-0.0252397526,
0.0280880053,
-0.0236639455,
-0.0247839708,
-0.0404452085,
-0.1342822909,
0.0002177151,
-0.0255978033,
0.0488113537,
0.0071719913,
0.0218742006,
-0.0309588592,
-0.0319619551,
-0.0021737854,
-0.0820157081,
-0.0106085939,
0.0401789993,
0.0397535339,
-0.0129556051,
-0.0254830699,
-0.0123311942,
0.0089569818,
-0.0220589023,
0.0628760904,
-0.0023946164,
-0.0297490507,
-0.0615922064,
-0.0135569358,
0.0269482881,
0.0015517346,
0.0208111051,
-0.0242668819,
0.0022650815,
0.0482256226,
0.0366967581,
0.0637854263,
0.0183391646,
0.0486641563,
-0.0214862972,
0.0198096484,
-0.0767178684,
-0.0018269523,
0.0036102969,
0.0294018853,
-0.0258651488,
-0.0277756639,
0.0068239067,
0.0909558609,
-0.0268324707,
0.0049573123,
-0.0714570656,
-0.0100153275,
-0.0208621901,
-0.0052401251,
0.0009228651,
-0.0313426629,
-0.0476495549,
-0.0077706454,
-0.0375772417,
-0.048653312,
0.0289724488,
-0.060409531,
-0.0283589028,
-0.0381851085,
0.0226000436,
-0.0461952612,
0.0516960993,
0.04347964,
0.0153314294,
0.0078012743,
-0.0754637644,
-0.0141839329,
0.0156056033,
-0.0123753119,
-0.0361512974,
-0.0174069703,
0.0301742852,
-0.0091695637,
-0.0430770777,
-0.0311703719,
-0.0407358408,
-0.0483337827,
-0.0064289775,
0.0407838188,
0.028762646,
-0.0157038756,
-0.0129472492,
0.0389335006,
-0.0108708506,
0.0321020558,
-0.0153840687,
0.0218940005,
-0.0296580568,
0.0367183462,
0.0235996488,
-0.0076319394,
0.0109970504,
0.003241675,
-0.0263084974,
0.0169532169,
0.0213049203,
0.0049272715,
-0.0279301181,
-0.0278865062,
0.0313311145,
-0.0924780816,
-0.005859952,
-0.0269987434,
0.0357450619,
-0.0131727019,
-0.0330426544,
0.149997741,
0.048063159,
-0.048909802,
-0.00481869,
0.0167119801,
0.03695485,
0.028533224,
-0.0070819072,
-0.0657774284,
-0.0284364093,
0.0298604891,
0.0229297318,
-0.0064704549,
-0.0137685947,
0.0163157992,
-0.1764629036,
-0.003121438,
-0.0281835757,
-0.0309887622,
-0.0453305915,
-0.0587003008,
-0.0282222442,
-0.022651678,
0.0269485563,
-0.0126537578,
-0.0119689889,
0.0132420231,
0.0581098646,
-0.0533527248,
-0.0583905578,
-0.0081536006,
-0.0751079842,
0.0378358401,
0.045569282,
0.0194271486,
-0.0434636101,
-0.0396733545,
0.0518838465,
-0.0162122417,
0.0021549086,
0.0016797872,
0.0286204126,
-0.0634431168,
-0.0015261875,
0.0054673431,
-0.0351702794,
-0.0266940612,
0.0006569204,
-0.0337500013,
0.0628393814,
-0.0027743496,
0.0170567464,
-0.0277043805,
-0.0293496605,
-0.0045756176,
0.0803233758,
0.0163561702,
-0.0446228571,
-0.031243613,
-0.0139743397,
0.0535762198,
-0.00034935,
0.0601081774,
-0.0248201042,
-0.0050783446,
-0.0445932746,
-0.0748805329,
-0.0207910854,
0.0376014151,
0.0533652417,
0.0056512193,
-0.0136004882,
-0.0295693483,
0.0015709181,
-0.0488714539,
0.0284907296,
0.0179120917,
0.0295898058,
-0.0548949353,
0.0066490071,
0.0472727977,
-0.0038179085,
-0.047906816,
-0.04904107,
-0.0431760624,
-0.0478311591,
0.0190117769,
0.0356693491,
0.0209848061,
0.0528892539,
-0.0000764938,
-0.0182405636,
0.0388097875,
0.0674159974,
-0.0472744592,
-0.0233431756,
0.0109287882,
0.0047501526,
-0.0176011138,
-0.0044954163,
-0.0534794852,
-0.0057340693,
0.0175065361,
0.045048248,
-0.0126341488,
-0.0288835187,
-0.0104509555,
0.0051177219,
0.1076167151,
-0.0282083116,
-0.0319782645,
-0.0152667714,
0.0503349788,
0.0012685251,
0.0012935608,
-0.0165588874,
-0.0349025391,
0.028731646,
0.0077528385,
-0.0321261212,
0.052707687,
-0.0108737312,
0.024975514,
0.0192117821,
0.0300485846,
0.007872479,
0.038555976,
-0.0138300043,
0.0027407547,
-0.0243946388,
-0.0201958753,
0.0358725227,
0.0227266364,
-0.0187444761,
0.0321885198,
0.0031216126,
0.0303809978,
-0.0114900302,
0.0563468412,
-0.039590355,
0.0362743959,
-0.0365683511,
0.0045573837,
0.0373346023,
-0.0482162684,
0.0416576825,
0.0048037521,
-0.00220482,
0.0079516191,
-0.0037620915,
-0.0091273319,
-0.0136848353,
0.0390738249,
0.0088111991,
-0.0313113704,
0.0004991974,
0.0472973324,
0.018519517,
0.0218673814,
-0.0199551061,
-0.0274125822,
0.0067461338,
0.0209139902,
0.0627276897,
-0.0206241496,
-0.019580448,
0.0034578503,
-0.0399105884,
-0.0587239787,
0.0261413381,
-0.0160783362,
0.0118655711,
-0.0003215477,
0.0272930898,
0.0325022005,
-0.0032013471,
-0.0286785401,
-0.0141413165,
-0.0223412849,
0.0257946961,
-0.0122765694,
-0.0372675471,
-6.146011602e-33,
-0.0306690969,
-0.0076944516,
-0.0200248025,
-0.0069561112,
-0.0330439396,
0.0204543062,
0.0171339475,
-0.0120626483,
0.0107952226,
-0.0206836667,
-0.0101353209,
-0.0067720227,
0.0307220202,
0.0412985794,
-0.0062969755,
-0.0246089287,
0.0595492683,
0.0091816131,
-0.0425015874,
-0.0212240461,
0.0336261727,
0.051589217,
0.0639519319,
-0.0150568103,
0.0252017155,
0.0022845021,
0.0189636517,
0.0013387463,
0.0415520631,
0.047889825,
-0.010265504,
0.0189892072,
0.0222293977,
-0.0686578229,
0.0206236541,
0.0345966928,
-0.0784310251,
-0.0188785885,
0.0037901241,
0.0723715276,
0.0577096306,
-0.0256002788,
0.0613439567,
0.0153099401,
-0.0413561277,
0.0272407904,
0.0241793413,
0.0018021126,
-0.0194195323,
-0.0479165092,
-0.0520603694,
0.0361116491,
-0.0045617209,
-0.0139355892,
0.0156967137,
-0.0082950005,
0.0397731699,
0.0142843556,
-0.0751594976,
-0.0029140876,
-0.0057215672,
0.0034395244,
0.0417052582,
0.017069729,
-0.0125772888,
0.0788152516,
0.0328746065,
-0.0045062308,
0.0010033911,
-0.0264811609,
0.0256235749,
-0.0022418743,
0.0385412686,
-0.0209894143,
0.0713509396,
-0.017228255,
-0.0426808931,
0.0385371819,
-0.0031702004,
0.0428895354,
0.0429652743,
0.0051879841,
-0.0646267161,
-0.030127516,
-0.0084595019,
-0.0543143861,
-0.0158690233,
-0.0276299696,
0.0441096053,
0.0106136678,
-0.0160632618,
0.0360993333,
0.0416038111,
-0.0425139368,
-0.0096195433,
0.002640008,
0.0176921673,
0.0241666865,
-0.0205326471,
0.0309355911,
-0.0489500239,
-0.0428700708,
0.0415597223,
0.0054414431,
0.0078364694,
-0.0164677985,
0.0508419946,
0.0070448089,
-0.1099854633,
0.0117833009,
-0.0039662318,
0.0143330451,
-0.0513302125,
0.0784037858,
0.0275762696,
0.0104370406,
0.0003742343,
0.0231168773,
0.025571296,
0.0253327191,
-0.0378332958,
0.0163085703,
0.0079877572,
0.0078214174,
-0.011202435,
0.00568562,
0.0169054903,
0.0532915629,
-0.0127790049,
-0.0530756973,
-0.0160949789,
-0.016705431,
2.726e-7,
0.0679076537,
0.046800267,
0.0609128326,
-0.0377672426,
0.0159054454,
0.0248195454,
-0.0063033798,
0.0478213355,
0.0354396738,
0.0451592915,
-0.0438783653,
-0.0432147421,
0.0037255574,
0.0242437162,
-0.1263645887,
0.0201018304,
-0.0709502846,
0.0354895182,
-0.0331829451,
0.053869009,
0.0292013865,
0.1119529232,
-0.026543472,
-0.0152098881,
-0.0282110739,
-0.033126995,
0.0528059639,
-0.03244875,
0.0228078961,
0.0041979672,
0.0232048184,
0.0414410755,
0.0288046896,
0.0340043902,
-0.0114186183,
0.039833419,
0.0246594083,
0.0149120362,
-0.0423876122,
-0.0353943743,
-0.0251851939,
-0.0077492488,
-0.0140893282,
-0.0823902637,
0.0715133846,
-0.0503910743,
-0.0074938708,
-0.0345370956,
-0.0630879775,
0.0263054632,
0.0248075426,
-0.0081117228,
-0.0219589006,
0.0281514153,
0.0457027815,
-0.0078485217,
-0.0291155465,
-0.0898877904,
-0.0215944219,
-0.0223575085,
-0.0252631065,
-0.0287621226,
-0.0102362521,
0.0087124826,
0.032634642,
-0.0387293436,
-0.0029208937,
2.603820777e-34,
0.029096473,
0.0049783513,
-0.0033998569,
0.057266023,
0.0150424847,
-0.0287817791,
0.0108556487,
-0.0017523533,
-0.0123381326,
-0.0250836965,
0.0035542604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13559v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13559v2 | Towards Multi-Modal DBMSs for Seamless Querying of Texts and Tables | 2023-04-26T13:31:04 | 2023-04-28T14:55:48 | Matthias Urban, Carsten Binnig | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | In this paper, we propose Multi-Modal Databases (MMDBs), which is a new class
of database systems that can seamlessly query text and tables using SQL. To
enable seamless querying of textual data using SQL in an MMDB, we propose to
extend relational databases with so-called multi-modal operators (MMOps) which
are based on the advances of recent large language models such as GPT-3. The
main idea of MMOps is that they allow text collections to be treated as tables
without the need to manually transform the data. As we show in our evaluation,
our MMDB prototype can not only outperform state-of-the-art approaches such as
text-to-table in terms of accuracy and performance but it also requires
significantly less training data to fine-tune the model for an unseen text
collection. | [
0.0009466258,
0.0734024569,
-0.0148146842,
0.0038847052,
-0.0494275279,
0.0283071976,
0.0162280686,
0.0623398758,
0.0103600323,
-0.0296244491,
-0.0379650779,
-0.0370852426,
-0.0290718097,
0.0366924703,
0.0213152077,
-0.0396143086,
0.0449177064,
0.0009414958,
-0.0569034927,
0.0241808761,
0.0028199952,
0.0319658071,
-0.0085923001,
-0.0344213098,
-0.0017370087,
-0.0061577028,
-0.0508087054,
-0.0225903019,
-0.0686528385,
0.0001896607,
-0.0175632164,
0.0494224466,
0.0397520289,
0.0045809308,
0.0000020028,
-0.0102405921,
-0.0790493414,
0.0214900915,
0.0487925112,
-0.0388919078,
0.0805942267,
-0.0309585147,
0.0181759484,
0.0044422471,
-0.0384179652,
-0.0091812816,
0.0298048873,
0.0511939377,
0.0278114621,
0.0515123419,
-0.0283751786,
-0.0731251761,
0.0048937756,
0.0109404521,
0.0753099918,
-0.0167663414,
0.0041252002,
0.0349022895,
0.0687508434,
0.0165238008,
0.0103861839,
0.0289647225,
-0.038997978,
-0.0069248704,
-0.0237618797,
0.008609415,
0.0247056894,
0.0049211089,
-0.008644158,
0.0236129146,
0.0212345775,
-0.0050249691,
0.0353184044,
0.0261093508,
-0.032931488,
0.0202321131,
-0.0170727409,
0.002248435,
-0.0074047092,
0.0171328839,
-0.0568318926,
-0.0400295332,
0.0144420806,
0.0077803168,
-0.0524844304,
0.0362872332,
-0.003644329,
-0.0164332148,
0.0075013619,
-0.024345912,
0.0324254036,
0.0074033123,
0.0285418164,
0.0476072691,
-0.0171780549,
0.0367230326,
-0.0415675901,
-0.0045983559,
0.0470427424,
-0.0588456988,
-0.0334236175,
0.040319521,
-0.0286985431,
0.0434783846,
-0.0069484804,
-0.0245786551,
-0.0104173133,
0.0049020252,
-0.0324841961,
-0.0585060343,
-0.0478765666,
0.0229859445,
-0.0290894546,
0.0288674738,
-0.0911206529,
-0.0308154728,
-0.0109621398,
0.0670447052,
0.0261651352,
-0.0029271834,
0.0137839131,
0.009027495,
-0.0169489533,
-0.0322311111,
-0.0508397631,
-0.0193276089,
0.036425516,
-0.016771758,
0.0034989475,
-0.081594117,
0.0110381441,
-0.0154399723,
0.0282592345,
-0.0261446945,
0.0245375186,
0.0440498665,
-0.0561444424,
-0.0034365631,
-0.0701732859,
-0.017059546,
-0.0183980707,
-0.0219511576,
-0.0296950433,
-0.0336253606,
0.0779838264,
0.0414561257,
-0.0173836946,
-0.0194782373,
0.004257916,
0.0392462686,
-0.0151333259,
0.0327693485,
-0.0413681082,
0.0223068669,
0.0164542664,
-0.0070787678,
0.0271218419,
0.078415893,
0.0086540021,
-0.0058749616,
0.0153355105,
0.0031985771,
-0.0322577581,
0.0110979434,
0.0013400974,
0.0000603018,
-0.0652642325,
0.0498827882,
0.0043973266,
0.0161616448,
-0.067008853,
0.0669097379,
-0.0175690018,
0.0154625196,
0.0555124767,
-0.0100132944,
0.0473367125,
0.0883161426,
-0.0144666061,
0.0350060873,
0.0140496902,
-0.0059983735,
0.0044542067,
0.0278907269,
-0.0222246833,
-0.0305500366,
0.0477518551,
-0.0091016656,
-0.0194121022,
-0.0424080342,
0.0120108305,
-0.0191287715,
0.0249008294,
-0.0177077819,
0.0482017435,
-0.0371946096,
-0.0076882662,
0.0040166243,
-0.0068784561,
-0.0584374033,
-0.0184313674,
-0.0185923278,
-0.0329242945,
0.0609110966,
-0.0150497099,
-0.0755586103,
0.0166136827,
0.0012558369,
0.0206670333,
0.0164919347,
0.043695733,
-0.0243292917,
0.0079017673,
-0.0248862524,
-0.0062146555,
0.0892835557,
0.0162310414,
0.0072747977,
-0.0175214149,
0.0431718081,
0.0071144756,
-0.0250351932,
0.0159086324,
0.0078339214,
0.0356900916,
0.0330611542,
0.0048266849,
0.0047194748,
0.004286713,
0.0198134482,
-0.0148928529,
0.0166338999,
0.0681238472,
0.0321211554,
-0.0380418003,
0.006117993,
0.0159947574,
0.0498287044,
0.0044128573,
0.0191139467,
0.0178838447,
-0.0349594578,
-0.0248674285,
-0.060474541,
-0.0082422812,
-0.0154847018,
0.0238763019,
-0.0496065803,
0.0251810718,
-0.0236592684,
-0.0347015299,
-0.0319671631,
0.0543417931,
0.0184463523,
0.0297365133,
-0.0101643587,
-0.0650025755,
0.0626618043,
-0.0175333954,
-0.0189743526,
0.0478575677,
0.0094963657,
0.0585925728,
0.0218125433,
-0.0166386086,
-0.0633943081,
-0.0360811539,
-0.1532034576,
0.0365195312,
0.0130891111,
0.0272868443,
0.0276919343,
0.0509690307,
-0.0107315062,
-0.0296210349,
-0.066890046,
0.0129177254,
0.0138908895,
0.0106313881,
0.0484973043,
0.0374944247,
-0.0048316862,
-0.0175440535,
-0.0308685917,
-0.0473170504,
0.0004957889,
-0.0323754959,
-0.0619191639,
0.0141908592,
-0.0542809479,
-0.0120151239,
0.0757044703,
0.025351353,
0.0293011628,
-0.0007705655,
-0.0773830414,
0.0334951282,
0.0375412889,
0.0351856723,
-0.0029321664,
0.0146054765,
-0.0236457549,
-0.0188942142,
0.0300803278,
-0.0011409869,
0.012077163,
0.0070216525,
-0.0025797519,
0.0192994922,
-0.0292926077,
0.0196663868,
0.0051393067,
0.0029469426,
-0.0101812193,
0.0687698349,
0.0420089588,
-0.0535207577,
0.0585946068,
-0.0129224416,
-0.014184569,
-0.0128177693,
0.0049280659,
0.0039849123,
-0.0243930891,
-0.0029481198,
-0.0133221475,
-0.0140624447,
-0.0297609176,
0.0712718666,
0.0097934827,
0.015526765,
-0.0344833359,
-0.0376464315,
-0.0056508733,
-0.0018315094,
0.0327413827,
-0.0538622551,
0.0969687402,
-0.0368148759,
0.0396752171,
-0.0190460775,
-0.0344171003,
-0.0061209397,
-0.0174377393,
-0.0185872559,
0.0025091956,
0.0386271887,
-0.0213482995,
-0.0522465743,
-0.0071030525,
0.0324266814,
0.0559998117,
-0.0130517799,
-0.0310332961,
-0.0147551009,
-0.0095743407,
-0.0121158836,
0.0091891848,
-0.0691004917,
-0.0028281379,
0.0062285122,
0.0643529445,
0.002919971,
-0.0354853012,
0.0018972751,
0.0142532904,
0.0114621995,
-0.0223257132,
-0.0480719246,
0.0181028079,
-0.076558508,
-0.0684322491,
0.05251332,
0.0732199997,
0.0198639929,
-0.0236710683,
-0.0448391773,
0.0495492518,
-0.0092343427,
0.0137884961,
0.0295090787,
-0.1199298501,
-0.0342996009,
-0.0352730304,
-0.0037042166,
0.0294256862,
-0.0369952507,
-0.0243691336,
-0.0399047881,
0.0215413999,
-0.0223765466,
-0.0130114816,
-0.0386219993,
-0.0289905723,
0.0092765074,
-0.0238243546,
-0.0279123858,
0.0709643289,
-0.0324559174,
-0.0181129612,
0.0043107145,
0.0272997506,
-0.0467586145,
-0.0243184641,
-0.0381151363,
0.0075742439,
0.0079342462,
0.0644408911,
0.001405379,
-0.0412462987,
-0.0153595749,
0.0106543768,
-0.0155877955,
-0.0318488479,
0.0528153256,
-0.0201345757,
0.0065687364,
0.0038765857,
-0.0391653776,
0.0095987078,
0.0360645354,
-0.0164530594,
0.0986031443,
-0.0332437381,
0.0419507362,
-0.0141680129,
-0.0413017832,
0.0024585624,
0.0256738197,
-0.0483259857,
-0.0100091649,
-0.0672347397,
-0.02055794,
-0.0320760384,
-0.0137883183,
0.0100080483,
0.0400459319,
-0.0407773703,
-0.033476308,
-0.0292205848,
-0.0093400702,
0.0175815243,
0.0160385557,
-0.0018655593,
0.0691783577,
0.014701263,
-0.0037358878,
-0.0609299429,
-0.0624182671,
-0.029045321,
-0.0003725229,
-0.0426414907,
-0.0023347663,
0.0175440088,
-0.0413310789,
-0.0167830568,
-0.0431295559,
-0.0610443763,
-0.0469711497,
-0.0098645827,
-0.0265006479,
0.0163294822,
-0.0242366325,
0.0312679224,
-0.0403154939,
-0.0328701586,
0.0476411134,
-0.0643837154,
-0.0616458133,
0.000718447,
-0.026382912,
-0.0104600098,
0.0263712835,
-0.0176057499,
-0.0105559826,
-0.0854953229,
-0.0387330391,
0.0038886068,
0.0248401165,
0.0337869376,
0.0539936908,
0.0201371126,
0.0570836775,
-0.0199172981,
0.001930536,
0.0352171585,
-0.0830916241,
-0.0490749851,
-0.0085636592,
0.0542593487,
-0.0043012104,
-0.0242545735,
-0.0053623645,
0.0129694426,
0.0204309281,
0.0134422751,
-0.0150200631,
0.0547152124,
0.015763538,
-0.0342306159,
0.0259099398,
-0.0241792332,
-0.009897124,
0.0074682371,
0.025335446,
0.0334707946,
-0.0576095134,
0.0392697863,
0.0322666653,
-0.0554999784,
-0.01688057,
0.0355925001,
-0.0668108761,
-0.0162853189,
-0.0135020567,
0.0210284777,
0.0336211286,
0.0173382815,
0.0380714424,
-0.0088759596,
-0.0021465281,
-0.0365570262,
0.0191898607,
0.061161574,
0.0208839681,
-0.0084273135,
-0.0010331469,
-0.0288126674,
0.010147348,
0.0582410172,
-0.004248146,
-0.0002973159,
0.0024661808,
-0.0837746337,
-0.0353527665,
0.013187997,
0.0648344457,
0.0068154461,
0.0041461973,
-0.0367629342,
-0.0081229089,
0.0388709754,
0.0606828444,
0.05148644,
-0.0228998736,
-0.0648370311,
0.011967225,
0.088142015,
0.0671293512,
0.0011122539,
-0.058750093,
0.0281073283,
-0.0202517025,
-0.0116841458,
0.0087572504,
-6.062744725e-33,
-0.0139340181,
-0.0079674041,
0.0159512721,
-0.0158537086,
-0.0123640085,
-0.0464317054,
0.0119257011,
0.0051629478,
-0.0125199109,
0.001825767,
-0.0425399989,
0.0464058965,
0.0318099782,
-0.001809867,
0.0313648842,
-0.0149645926,
0.0283073671,
-0.0180565156,
0.0083618788,
0.0078824088,
0.0514615215,
0.0295439642,
0.0237043537,
-0.0462280624,
0.0231138375,
-0.0036033774,
-0.0498010404,
0.0114284055,
0.0006456776,
0.0028169521,
-0.0124151381,
0.0344092138,
0.0243018456,
0.0030091847,
-0.0188952629,
-0.0032117376,
-0.0688389689,
0.0042958446,
-0.0182762779,
0.0357650965,
0.0319369473,
0.0506268442,
0.0397730209,
-0.0325080007,
0.0072932364,
-0.0046360842,
-0.0038584142,
-0.0540746935,
-0.0307944398,
-0.0153791085,
0.015002748,
0.0392080359,
0.0504655093,
0.0368688032,
0.0841308534,
0.0153630143,
0.01380572,
-0.0306971204,
-0.0253797583,
0.0327153765,
0.0346646458,
0.0360616557,
-0.0135730589,
0.0074117798,
0.0243588109,
0.0122581441,
0.0494422875,
-0.0083885863,
0.0040023169,
0.0380824395,
0.0037385093,
0.0689918026,
0.0088424915,
0.0453852154,
0.0183655322,
0.00265465,
-0.0762281641,
0.0582028963,
-0.0240339171,
-0.03835278,
-0.0119122723,
0.0128886607,
-0.0368200503,
-0.0378460251,
-0.0239516497,
0.0077261799,
-0.0212626327,
-0.0147422384,
0.0107465209,
0.0001344092,
0.010917047,
0.0275662895,
0.0240984242,
0.0205598846,
-0.1034428701,
0.0471830703,
-0.0295248739,
-0.0237536263,
-0.0118734902,
0.0089131128,
-0.0141061228,
-0.0656820908,
0.0035841372,
0.0031520715,
-0.0064842892,
0.0216897354,
-0.0147843948,
0.0378665589,
-0.0949512273,
0.0029262467,
-0.0101617957,
-0.0044575706,
-0.0190631598,
0.0227515269,
0.0145189427,
-0.003516994,
0.039335601,
0.0803183168,
0.0069192755,
0.006339008,
-0.0563736036,
-0.0710463896,
0.0015481816,
-0.0058327997,
0.0493429601,
0.0231082588,
-0.0309981201,
-0.0669798702,
0.0790288374,
-0.0295434464,
0.0101426598,
0.0658454075,
2.63e-7,
0.0853628442,
0.0125306118,
0.0286155175,
0.0215434711,
0.0146473041,
0.0316322073,
-0.0017874461,
0.0144353723,
0.0342617854,
0.0004705257,
0.0465622433,
-0.029389333,
0.0522198528,
0.0520067886,
-0.0438303091,
-0.0237118118,
-0.007261748,
-0.0440308265,
-0.0564029254,
0.013514759,
0.0816336274,
0.0614193901,
-0.0468429402,
0.0166202243,
0.0021459386,
-0.0295209009,
0.0544393174,
-0.0425603837,
0.0166643914,
0.0119244512,
0.0539516248,
0.0025149256,
-0.0199671332,
0.0257629901,
-0.0207524281,
0.0305273607,
-0.0083648684,
0.0836774036,
-0.0315352157,
0.0636870936,
0.041503828,
-0.0744292736,
-0.0173865166,
0.0004210058,
0.1004875153,
-0.0135888979,
0.0434031896,
0.0639097393,
0.0000670282,
0.000770113,
-0.0132465344,
0.0108168162,
-0.0690505356,
-0.0057676085,
0.025720587,
0.0083937244,
0.0167738236,
-0.0357228331,
-0.0056322324,
0.0518937632,
-0.0330567881,
0.0116814207,
-0.0253716912,
-0.0209048353,
-0.0125738299,
-0.0437771566,
-0.0183670502,
2.394235185e-34,
0.0331642665,
0.0185054634,
0.0214242935,
-0.0192322005,
0.0354528502,
-0.0017772396,
0.0319213942,
-0.0197538622,
-0.037299443,
-0.0883922502,
-0.0495901369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13462v1 | Multidimensional Evaluation for Text Style Transfer Using ChatGPT | 2023-04-26T11:33:35 | 2023-04-26T11:33:35 | Huiyuan Lai, Antonio Toral, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate the potential of ChatGPT as a multidimensional evaluator for
the task of \emph{Text Style Transfer}, alongside, and in comparison to,
existing automatic metrics as well as human judgements. We focus on a zero-shot
setting, i.e. prompting ChatGPT with specific task instructions, and test its
performance on three commonly-used dimensions of text style transfer
evaluation: style strength, content preservation, and fluency. We perform a
comprehensive correlation analysis for two transfer directions (and overall) at
different levels. Compared to existing automatic metrics, ChatGPT achieves
competitive correlations with human judgments. These preliminary results are
expected to provide a first glimpse into the role of large language models in
the multidimensional evaluation of stylized text generation. | [
-0.0206724461,
0.0307709072,
-0.0070548183,
0.0105999559,
-0.0587754138,
0.0024851032,
0.0108860461,
0.035612531,
-0.0302758254,
-0.0255657937,
-0.0619147047,
-0.0702040642,
0.0086417124,
0.0204132106,
0.0332322158,
-0.0878711194,
-0.0088364575,
-0.0410354771,
0.0120092053,
0.025007721,
0.0484981164,
0.0018206555,
0.0021898311,
0.0426688977,
0.0111857913,
-0.0448340774,
-0.0151731754,
0.0570291579,
0.0441982262,
0.0000573549,
-0.0099593708,
0.0591084957,
0.0002979087,
0.0020849265,
0.0000017651,
-0.017278403,
-0.0267960913,
-0.0075781443,
0.0824218392,
0.0500955358,
0.0943693817,
0.0030539876,
-0.0408172831,
-0.0336735658,
-0.0274873581,
0.0215711612,
0.0495395735,
0.0280875359,
0.105456166,
0.0646498278,
-0.0302666016,
-0.0208767243,
-0.0129447533,
-0.0268547572,
0.0110067604,
0.0005309454,
-0.0038141459,
0.0084774606,
-0.0063338606,
0.0222837478,
0.016691424,
0.0256345049,
-0.0279243197,
-0.039995838,
0.003996565,
-0.0056735678,
-0.0464991406,
0.0586208738,
-0.011795532,
0.0671049729,
-0.0056457235,
0.0031812736,
0.0270978808,
-0.0011829039,
0.0112055726,
0.0192442406,
-0.0990661606,
-0.0283774603,
-0.004618749,
-0.002384793,
-0.031697873,
0.0268530212,
-0.0095409602,
-0.0368901864,
0.0307486188,
-0.0203294158,
0.0339012519,
-0.0186972395,
-0.0354683436,
0.0321108066,
-0.0183173772,
-0.0729919598,
0.028141601,
0.0077709528,
0.032138966,
-0.0031176941,
-0.0746320933,
-0.0614240021,
-0.014844669,
-0.0084482096,
0.0916252211,
0.024746744,
0.0154849291,
-0.0073381676,
-0.0408747941,
0.0674640983,
-0.0141911609,
0.0053850012,
-0.037769746,
0.0423693396,
-0.0509786904,
-0.021256268,
-0.0357854627,
-0.011039569,
0.0071499101,
-0.0272169895,
-0.0366595834,
-0.0032027769,
-0.0116613116,
-0.0353567638,
0.0134337209,
0.007262934,
-0.03115784,
0.0011022376,
0.0186170582,
0.0158503857,
0.0030483967,
0.0151787866,
0.0544812158,
-0.0117474673,
-0.0256737545,
0.0363248885,
0.0448185727,
-0.0151781635,
-0.0352927633,
0.068134129,
-0.0595713444,
0.0011306768,
-0.0178871676,
-0.0116764242,
-0.0188741013,
-0.0057657994,
0.0182224065,
-0.0653427914,
-0.0095768245,
0.0009031178,
0.0096558305,
-0.0073620263,
-0.0235415176,
0.0357057825,
-0.0108360266,
-0.0042071096,
0.0146113522,
0.0301205628,
0.0092354594,
-0.0165823717,
-0.0496559441,
0.0269543082,
0.0521617793,
0.0634483248,
0.0015092964,
-0.0255946871,
0.0093866363,
0.0423779301,
0.0187959988,
0.0398393646,
-0.0355636366,
-0.0632828176,
0.0235189535,
0.0481663235,
0.0608515479,
0.0744012818,
-0.0395307243,
0.0228594542,
0.1157322973,
0.016509451,
0.0757512152,
0.0322988592,
0.0812995881,
0.0247666799,
0.0164429247,
0.0639246777,
0.0190539826,
0.0152197061,
-0.0029313785,
0.0452442542,
0.0507784933,
0.0499118678,
-0.0056860973,
0.0080469577,
0.0173896011,
0.0329438485,
-0.0018611484,
-0.0756493509,
0.0065620062,
0.0502444059,
-0.0537976623,
-0.0257488489,
0.0095071876,
-0.0686488152,
0.0060230386,
-0.0409473591,
0.0011963965,
0.1260886639,
0.0433327407,
0.0350663513,
0.0309445672,
0.0150544243,
0.0431939177,
0.0308915656,
0.0173860956,
0.0082456898,
0.0122952582,
-0.0370311327,
0.0247597545,
-0.0304232668,
0.0070799594,
0.0295533706,
-0.0342299789,
0.0340023227,
0.0032736866,
-0.0033673663,
-0.0203918051,
0.0223408733,
-0.0046616462,
-0.0297940299,
-0.0131180165,
-0.0076194904,
-0.0313456394,
-0.0274348743,
-0.0729012415,
0.0309932921,
-0.0520130619,
-0.0372284278,
-0.0126492716,
0.0273127779,
-0.0539608896,
-0.0582964383,
-0.0297896173,
-0.045611769,
0.0241406653,
-0.0244901069,
0.0057892497,
-0.0389441662,
0.0110597871,
-0.0254436638,
0.0211323518,
-0.0168579184,
0.0211911052,
0.018612517,
0.01788719,
-0.0312053207,
0.0351673886,
0.0370912105,
-0.022715237,
0.0409731269,
0.0020322532,
-0.0227266885,
-0.0194061343,
0.0180584975,
-0.0214662403,
0.0096269967,
0.0035473623,
-0.0160972886,
0.0322673172,
-0.0396993272,
-0.0439324789,
-0.0567014329,
0.0116807679,
-0.017723674,
0.032993786,
0.0373702757,
-0.0086594392,
-0.0272377878,
0.05655507,
-0.0611840114,
0.0306957159,
-0.0110629341,
0.0129186651,
0.0615657568,
-0.0236752424,
0.0171115343,
-0.0411499292,
-0.0115473745,
0.0252192281,
0.0473602787,
0.0460716859,
-0.006278174,
-0.0288197529,
0.0349380895,
-0.0253337771,
-0.0625870228,
0.0365371406,
-0.0583117381,
0.0085757812,
-0.0296000019,
0.072558336,
0.0692533627,
0.0613723435,
-0.0264787227,
0.0143735819,
-0.0478696935,
-0.01027185,
-0.0132586323,
-0.0023139422,
0.0179171711,
0.0327498093,
-0.0340882279,
0.0514132455,
0.0337030068,
0.0446772948,
0.0168665107,
-0.0787085518,
0.0232316311,
0.0045292848,
-0.01058554,
0.0105718412,
0.0095840478,
-0.0166486204,
0.01700221,
-0.0132842558,
-0.0403117612,
0.0331699587,
-0.0608131886,
-0.0184818152,
0.0471973866,
0.0178960804,
-0.016535921,
0.0254595242,
-0.0182719324,
0.0420745499,
0.0178194847,
-0.0113208517,
-0.0536767617,
0.0396656208,
0.0717409253,
-0.013323511,
-0.0050931689,
-0.0625153482,
0.0002857696,
-0.0085156383,
-0.0201091599,
-0.0002160655,
-0.0059722066,
0.020176487,
-0.020018151,
0.0558359474,
-0.0493621975,
0.0240368489,
0.0293201841,
0.0017283665,
0.0459264517,
-0.0383034721,
-0.0358707383,
0.0048002019,
0.0559468269,
0.0336448476,
-0.0285424162,
-0.0329964012,
-0.0600132756,
-0.0033462006,
0.0500472896,
-0.0364686474,
0.021471614,
-0.0291976519,
0.0150532043,
0.0059502544,
0.0121709388,
-0.0491233021,
0.0067005153,
0.083889991,
-0.0416675992,
-0.0194729157,
0.0814831704,
0.004791481,
-0.0091446182,
-0.0290144607,
-0.0159236658,
0.0737610683,
-0.035818588,
0.0272601452,
-0.0701419413,
-0.0266168714,
-0.0009447897,
0.0278796125,
-0.0023151014,
-0.0243580826,
-0.0097844498,
-0.0656224489,
0.0466130413,
0.0241007749,
-0.0443971008,
0.0046788654,
0.0111379046,
0.0288796183,
0.021022182,
-0.0286783222,
-0.0147844739,
-0.0304447971,
0.0161796063,
0.0109004769,
-0.0418353789,
-0.0339833573,
-0.0169632286,
-0.012185405,
0.0392997749,
0.0646381229,
0.0479276516,
0.0120075457,
-0.0711393058,
-0.0226466414,
0.0230896343,
0.0262167342,
-0.0051830406,
0.0497275852,
0.00696507,
-0.0033961374,
-0.0380287506,
0.0078275641,
0.0203256886,
-0.0151855676,
0.0264411438,
0.0077633779,
-0.013345344,
-0.0582667626,
-0.0221900009,
0.0197722819,
0.0097990325,
0.0441246666,
0.0644954294,
-0.0370944217,
-0.0524550825,
-0.0561296567,
-0.004746255,
-0.0804898143,
-0.0449703969,
-0.0314385965,
-0.02516344,
-0.0384389609,
-0.1421048641,
0.0350474678,
-0.0115161128,
0.0689632446,
0.0026998227,
-0.025252318,
-0.0422997586,
0.0102715353,
-0.0198235773,
-0.0261625387,
-0.0153078595,
0.0175701678,
-0.0230672415,
-0.0240757074,
-0.0067143827,
-0.0405488424,
0.0017465557,
0.013391153,
-0.0579166152,
-0.044780761,
-0.0202554911,
0.0537509993,
0.0169827752,
-0.0044470928,
-0.0152906254,
-0.0506621078,
0.0337808989,
0.0552495345,
0.0119935097,
0.0177936554,
0.0263106078,
0.009876498,
0.0123716677,
0.0166862812,
0.0127792908,
0.0321688317,
0.0040926286,
0.0398508832,
0.0335026011,
-0.039149899,
0.005611741,
0.0097746029,
-0.0206165724,
-0.0129916854,
-0.0050143925,
-0.0075775823,
-0.0399600826,
-0.0545710325,
-0.0083574643,
-0.0841740891,
-0.0126921749,
0.0187417492,
0.0422017202,
-0.0092521654,
-0.0193768479,
0.0131594185,
-0.0006911874,
-0.0608860143,
-0.0307957362,
-0.0166867711,
0.0441576615,
0.0120729823,
0.020790631,
-0.0044108168,
-0.0105576366,
-0.0367244668,
0.0214145388,
-0.0225391779,
0.0502497181,
0.0344078131,
-0.0123345181,
0.01709917,
0.0611385629,
-0.0633488148,
0.0020747499,
-0.0380237363,
-0.000245841,
0.0447405651,
0.0191083625,
0.1030863747,
-0.0141805802,
0.0092260474,
-0.0089338589,
0.0616668351,
0.0138657521,
-0.0232219491,
-0.0428459048,
-0.0033030286,
0.0100706099,
-0.046486631,
0.0704720095,
-0.0302957725,
-0.027739916,
-0.0214215647,
-0.0264576692,
-0.0148055609,
-0.0049039205,
0.032326296,
-0.0087993676,
0.0518624261,
-0.0311106574,
-0.0366255604,
-0.0406598859,
0.0254574288,
0.0101098903,
0.0209432542,
-0.0129724704,
0.036593277,
0.0527861752,
-0.0375428498,
0.0135782557,
-0.0311396345,
-0.0022465456,
-0.0013723822,
0.0222724769,
-0.0274187513,
-5.373825689e-33,
-0.0425699987,
-0.0075324364,
-0.0093049239,
0.0205474347,
-0.0601988845,
-0.0301079806,
-0.0744364932,
0.0028155597,
0.0613677278,
0.0241906121,
-0.0073719402,
-0.0376213789,
0.0068859938,
-0.0025824106,
0.0253450125,
0.0038105145,
0.0611565933,
0.0096187145,
-0.0748917535,
0.0343523696,
0.0303350016,
0.0014447933,
0.0425530896,
-0.0375984646,
-0.0194445513,
-0.017536303,
-0.0108181043,
-0.0470958762,
0.0313681513,
0.0184760056,
0.0114651062,
0.009048962,
0.0176583771,
-0.0207375232,
-0.0369302556,
0.0309346374,
0.0024690886,
-0.0393526182,
-0.001232442,
-0.0237296168,
-0.0259350408,
-0.0430709422,
0.0320928842,
-0.0105260089,
-0.0032254334,
-0.0178087167,
0.0336634554,
-0.0338632129,
-0.0078911083,
-0.0712709948,
-0.0657370314,
0.0226826686,
-0.0344749875,
-0.0490601361,
0.0019314362,
0.0506718047,
-0.0114766089,
-0.0073885876,
-0.0142226042,
0.0359051637,
-0.013948408,
0.0081648584,
0.0326388851,
0.0307344105,
0.0049897754,
0.0579836853,
-0.0106266523,
0.0612772293,
-0.0446873158,
0.023950493,
0.0320104584,
0.0472544804,
0.025197858,
0.0473682135,
-0.0071277111,
-0.0075580934,
0.0098903449,
0.0653372109,
-0.0004090371,
-0.0277337134,
-0.0064461716,
0.0472419187,
-0.0099193482,
-0.0115835425,
-0.0164253805,
-0.0252670273,
-0.0154380929,
-0.0382016525,
0.019715026,
-0.018679712,
-0.0139894374,
-0.0390233696,
0.0297932699,
0.0256572124,
-0.0229612291,
-0.0396177471,
-0.1126796156,
0.0623441935,
-0.0442172512,
-0.0250879005,
-0.0104976939,
-0.025449995,
0.0685576051,
0.0506226011,
0.0187707003,
0.00760445,
0.0200641286,
0.0409772992,
-0.0582829565,
-0.0287331324,
-0.0089656804,
0.0065016332,
0.0149055058,
-0.0248760581,
0.0152881853,
-0.0351871252,
-0.0337377563,
0.0219035689,
0.0178794637,
-0.0069304365,
-0.0224048682,
-0.0289740339,
0.0007132368,
-0.0261246357,
-0.0533314906,
0.0150734605,
-0.0275999028,
-0.0388592184,
0.0145550575,
-0.0506536774,
-0.0463476032,
-0.0119818617,
2.503e-7,
0.0271505509,
0.0303611066,
0.0057744482,
0.0155543238,
0.0174969435,
0.0128383003,
-0.0401066989,
0.0525035039,
0.029042,
0.019153621,
0.0247992091,
0.0230007973,
0.0969076529,
0.0031459795,
-0.0770051554,
-0.0102131311,
-0.0571760051,
0.0115596522,
-0.0324205793,
-0.0108839674,
0.1069758832,
-0.0260285586,
-0.0146880895,
-0.0026303444,
0.0607587434,
-0.0064991578,
0.0856355578,
-0.0075372276,
0.0189042464,
0.003254385,
0.0564370193,
-0.0616305619,
-0.0330665484,
0.0258594658,
-0.0079223691,
-0.0348989293,
0.0828812346,
0.0709991455,
0.0124278478,
0.0537928566,
0.0090550482,
-0.0083875619,
0.0180011149,
-0.0486509465,
0.0528126471,
-0.0151459258,
-0.0083602071,
-0.0485750437,
-0.0421804972,
-0.0060573788,
0.0217399616,
-0.0151320947,
-0.0411845148,
0.0334137902,
0.0182765387,
0.0315056331,
-0.0242792461,
-0.0234143194,
-0.0340670198,
-0.0195243303,
-0.0242678672,
-0.0458563715,
-0.0722120255,
0.0093008867,
-0.0056684725,
-0.0248646624,
0.0059109218,
2.176593094e-34,
0.0272864401,
-0.0358452983,
0.04101412,
-0.0125896866,
0.0392761119,
0.0081376852,
0.0351523794,
0.0173777007,
0.0146793108,
-0.072146602,
-0.0022449342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13343v2 | Enhancing Large Language Model with Self-Controlled Memory Framework | 2023-04-26T07:25:31 | 2024-02-15T16:01:39 | Bing Wang, Xinnian Liang, Jian Yang, Hui Huang, Shuangzhi Wu, Peihao Wu, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are constrained by their inability to process
lengthy inputs, resulting in the loss of critical historical information. To
address this limitation, in this paper, we propose the Self-Controlled Memory
(SCM) framework to enhance the ability of LLMs to maintain long-term memory and
recall relevant information. Our SCM framework comprises three key components:
an LLM-based agent serving as the backbone of the framework, a memory stream
storing agent memories, and a memory controller updating memories and
determining when and how to utilize memories from memory stream. Additionally,
the proposed SCM is able to process ultra-long texts without any modification
or fine-tuning, which can integrate with any instruction following LLMs in a
plug-and-play paradigm. Furthermore, we annotate a dataset to evaluate the
effectiveness of SCM for handling lengthy inputs. The annotated dataset covers
three tasks: long-term dialogues, book summarization, and meeting
summarization. Experimental results demonstrate that our method achieves better
retrieval recall and generates more informative responses compared to
competitive baselines in long-term dialogues.
(https://github.com/wbbeyourself/SCM4LLMs) | [
0.0233363379,
0.0091265859,
-0.011494644,
0.0300686955,
-0.0241834763,
-0.0055352342,
0.0012568091,
-0.0431384258,
0.0578105487,
-0.0512322672,
-0.0274822004,
-0.0353515483,
-0.0114450045,
0.0443297625,
0.0015755277,
-0.0710898265,
0.0592541248,
-0.0300347302,
0.0190593563,
-0.004732592,
0.0222959165,
-0.0333475806,
0.0268549956,
-0.0110714408,
0.006078619,
-0.0377998278,
-0.0212717429,
-0.012575726,
-0.0338669159,
-0.034175761,
-0.0041185576,
0.0094255675,
0.0349241979,
0.013172593,
0.0000020536,
-0.0549597181,
-0.0105648721,
-0.0348934941,
-0.0328912847,
0.0410220921,
0.0497168303,
0.0097704604,
0.0065207067,
0.0108865118,
-0.037652649,
0.0087857293,
-0.0115010682,
0.0541457757,
0.0846639276,
0.0739419609,
0.003928957,
-0.0218921155,
0.0371555425,
-0.0235420633,
0.0018642119,
-0.0338719636,
0.0181499626,
0.0005646819,
0.0056549553,
0.0126865059,
-0.0248866621,
0.0661950335,
0.0093059111,
-0.030089926,
0.0288519375,
0.0240988247,
-0.0254308768,
0.0076325964,
-0.0123305982,
0.0536283515,
0.028257452,
-0.0100634238,
0.02638066,
0.0189628452,
0.0058211111,
-0.0075080618,
-0.0670441017,
0.029122049,
0.0048727379,
0.0078105931,
-0.0114610046,
0.0081904856,
0.0012423167,
0.0161989573,
-0.050646659,
0.020298792,
-0.0085845897,
-0.0346475095,
-0.0473988876,
-0.0314487554,
0.0255841874,
-0.0406985506,
0.0322434455,
0.077308692,
-0.0195778161,
0.0312146898,
-0.0256766099,
-0.0216758456,
0.0171512272,
-0.0902075544,
0.004428986,
0.0126263266,
0.0049601314,
0.0752405226,
-0.0394108593,
0.0616924725,
-0.0047974605,
0.0043399367,
-0.041583553,
0.0099858036,
-0.0568185896,
-0.0042443736,
-0.0434648469,
0.0532287955,
-0.0026518633,
-0.0366807766,
-0.0095398901,
0.0529656671,
0.0200134385,
0.0211530458,
-0.0312849581,
0.0029028901,
0.0048690434,
-0.0016524559,
-0.0371593758,
0.0596776977,
-0.0463268235,
-0.0604541637,
0.0193357393,
-0.0237794146,
-0.0100773554,
0.0104859499,
-0.0055836551,
-0.0007039174,
-0.0220702346,
0.0566098019,
-0.0217200387,
-0.0384940766,
-0.0394483432,
-0.0249448717,
-0.0068797055,
-0.0694321543,
0.0013446244,
-0.0408364721,
0.0184978507,
0.0077555468,
-0.0178841706,
-0.041658204,
0.0125528537,
0.0331859291,
-0.0236764457,
0.0399985462,
0.0220519099,
0.0091890693,
0.0662477762,
0.009849797,
0.0141309416,
0.0480983369,
0.0549921133,
0.0274685472,
0.0589009076,
0.0038629132,
0.0383126922,
0.0155021194,
0.0100757303,
-0.006919066,
-0.0087471297,
0.0283292718,
0.0015667337,
0.0360219926,
0.0182535928,
0.0663179681,
-0.0080624707,
-0.0205676686,
0.0800340921,
0.0490810089,
-0.0019554354,
0.0206453204,
-0.0072301626,
0.0295613166,
0.0384763516,
0.0429343991,
-0.0380750038,
0.0605038069,
-0.0003445904,
0.0440360717,
0.0487437285,
0.0076376908,
-0.0507583506,
-0.045571357,
-0.0034181301,
-0.014755182,
0.0337573588,
0.0297261067,
0.030490024,
-0.0112434924,
-0.0420253761,
0.0572562777,
-0.0066530518,
-0.062157046,
0.014603653,
-0.0459279269,
0.0423579216,
0.1027571261,
0.0440404154,
-0.0514702722,
-0.0317277871,
-0.0146164652,
0.0289617199,
0.0453322083,
0.050127849,
-0.0109402519,
-0.0400472097,
-0.0555281565,
-0.0100203594,
-0.011789131,
-0.0019324188,
0.0102271866,
0.0309430305,
-0.0001980808,
0.0337563194,
0.0296511855,
-0.0415397659,
0.0239754785,
-0.0409008525,
-0.050631687,
-0.0267319214,
-0.0149150491,
0.011815289,
0.0125891818,
-0.0003108602,
0.0222091358,
0.0478022136,
-0.0323914587,
-0.0328488909,
0.0045549166,
-0.1058648676,
-0.024473263,
0.0478472598,
0.0287307519,
0.0151672708,
0.0141378371,
-0.0214359984,
-0.0950508043,
0.031888742,
-0.0360417329,
0.0378084108,
-0.0362200439,
0.0252312422,
0.0202777907,
0.0150359077,
-0.0340864249,
0.060604699,
0.0258138943,
-0.0302540828,
0.0360448062,
0.0425362252,
-0.0101547018,
-0.0403893031,
-0.0342482962,
0.0345474221,
0.0180412438,
0.0136441449,
0.0470363386,
-0.0531029068,
-0.0578270368,
-0.022975564,
-0.0785193592,
0.0299740713,
-0.0124844331,
-0.0087302625,
0.0100785065,
0.016763214,
-0.0161951538,
-0.0138264168,
-0.0409324095,
-0.0019568026,
0.0171440076,
0.0298810974,
-0.0000840338,
0.0237956475,
0.0196562149,
-0.0531731769,
-0.0103064533,
0.0087341918,
0.0217717458,
-0.0037418955,
-0.0408859067,
-0.0482438728,
0.0276191253,
-0.0332428329,
0.0368504934,
-0.0255181883,
-0.0189276319,
-0.0221589766,
-0.0299123954,
0.0741843358,
0.1048870385,
0.046548482,
-0.0099382186,
0.0411767811,
-0.0426765829,
-0.0383235402,
0.0301122293,
-0.0235240608,
0.0018877506,
-0.0189980846,
0.0378026031,
-0.0070273904,
0.0354966484,
-0.0057718153,
0.0070516896,
-0.0099853352,
-0.010522929,
-0.0115643498,
-0.0043737725,
-0.0127784098,
-0.022503389,
-0.0525019169,
0.0016265942,
-0.0200067554,
-0.0369092412,
0.0580022447,
-0.0263878349,
0.0019842559,
-0.0240536407,
0.0008605758,
-0.0726464018,
0.0906402096,
0.0046582543,
0.0023999973,
-0.0215427,
-0.0147510786,
-0.0308714844,
-0.0238688476,
0.0130042704,
-0.0356898569,
0.0625092685,
-0.0441352651,
0.0191572644,
-0.0116029037,
-0.0135223884,
-0.0472341999,
-0.0254262313,
-0.0226811487,
-0.0030956955,
0.0024248539,
0.0088895541,
-0.040145278,
0.0244504642,
0.0490775481,
0.0648867115,
-0.044843372,
0.0014147332,
-0.0167549085,
0.0313007347,
0.0449677408,
0.0067088325,
0.0110876672,
-0.0358245559,
0.0696882606,
0.0547456481,
0.0386869945,
-0.0369395688,
-0.0045366255,
-0.0335098319,
0.0008816291,
-0.0788797885,
0.0084501598,
-0.0087850299,
0.0235135499,
-0.1049388275,
-0.0223676357,
0.1401695013,
0.031468939,
-0.056632001,
-0.0337813646,
-0.0261048432,
0.0311976578,
0.013464829,
0.0238646921,
-0.0157423913,
-0.0084168892,
0.0093655549,
0.0152211264,
0.0202168375,
-0.0195624549,
-0.0019424598,
-0.0864423066,
-0.009109146,
0.0260609128,
-0.0078158528,
0.0031071145,
-0.032569427,
-0.0197805688,
-0.0033732746,
0.0133987218,
0.0556114614,
-0.0355370268,
-0.0250162892,
-0.0132491365,
-0.0567297116,
0.0223027356,
0.0298112072,
-0.0265304707,
0.0571742505,
0.0760521442,
0.0395185463,
0.0350930542,
0.032826256,
0.046120733,
-0.025813736,
0.0095176259,
-0.0145143243,
0.0819058642,
-0.0218476187,
-0.0000550844,
-0.0141793508,
0.0310229585,
0.0063081975,
0.0043412172,
0.0347606055,
0.0316940099,
-0.0197749622,
-0.0021327231,
-0.0228888392,
-0.0062585976,
-0.0409311689,
0.1016966552,
0.007483033,
-0.0103043886,
-0.0768471062,
-0.0209159534,
-0.010302553,
-0.0202533212,
-0.022126561,
-0.0094140787,
-0.0247666165,
0.0058974591,
-0.0813200548,
-0.0660889521,
0.0256533343,
-0.0098579256,
0.0085277595,
0.045122724,
0.0311433151,
0.0060424292,
-0.0421009287,
-0.0207540579,
-0.0822525173,
-0.0123978797,
-0.038714584,
-0.0162862316,
0.0667237863,
-0.0129725458,
0.03588292,
0.0366991721,
-0.0579176024,
-0.059676379,
0.0211954452,
0.0385090932,
0.0183494389,
0.0953063369,
0.0229875408,
-0.0142108779,
0.0504124798,
0.0004585592,
-0.0587246232,
0.0188957602,
0.0013168914,
0.0604217872,
-0.0190502089,
0.0333333649,
-0.0412871055,
-0.0021117555,
-0.0228055511,
0.0462993681,
-0.039681688,
-0.0526233353,
0.0099873506,
0.0067181736,
-0.0122811552,
0.0180834252,
0.0139113041,
-0.0223905593,
0.0184166376,
-0.0513625145,
-0.0079850433,
-0.0241019595,
0.0339789614,
-0.015644718,
-0.021063216,
0.0141736055,
0.0032342395,
-0.0004909683,
0.0017615088,
-0.0161303636,
0.0055700368,
-0.0366595052,
-0.0519595891,
-0.0095831575,
0.0117414417,
-0.0325506851,
0.0183074195,
0.0005831553,
0.0182843432,
-0.022851456,
0.0747414827,
0.0101372413,
-0.0204382073,
-0.0136183752,
-0.007717459,
-0.1055582389,
-0.0118988762,
-0.0088818464,
0.0435749963,
0.0395274907,
-0.0282285139,
0.0540340431,
-0.034366183,
0.0007264829,
-0.0395267308,
-0.0036742243,
0.0241872482,
-0.0151077695,
-0.0421969555,
0.035370063,
-0.0130988713,
0.0105885537,
0.0697269291,
0.0094507542,
0.0205443054,
0.0484365709,
-0.0054638921,
-0.0423651412,
-0.0307799391,
-0.0020081457,
0.0087723238,
-0.0169051345,
-0.0446396656,
-0.0409531556,
-0.0245882683,
0.058135245,
0.0014097298,
-0.0038947649,
-0.048199147,
0.0401375219,
0.0261915289,
-0.0009413261,
-0.0088875042,
-0.0496572219,
0.0369489677,
-0.0064084711,
-0.0001377279,
-0.0206473079,
-6.092335958e-33,
-0.0502137393,
-0.0176572874,
0.0536043346,
0.0112324394,
-0.0627541766,
-0.0061237817,
-0.0568204075,
-0.0072434559,
0.003020263,
-0.0331949852,
-0.0374287963,
0.0321452059,
0.0122043956,
0.0445644557,
0.0073832576,
-0.0275435522,
0.0690265298,
-0.0174217541,
-0.0066948608,
0.0619088896,
0.0576728694,
0.0578461476,
-0.0040663942,
-0.020904094,
0.002616168,
-0.0299259629,
0.0409874283,
0.0104585243,
0.0107475556,
0.0525364503,
-0.0314816833,
0.0288623236,
0.0262326896,
-0.0340366401,
-0.053293746,
0.0424960628,
-0.1001560092,
-0.0056006759,
0.005770741,
-0.010715113,
-0.0074436762,
-0.0330604464,
0.0452677011,
-0.0253617801,
0.0202854518,
-0.0224055238,
0.0456785485,
-0.0383677036,
-0.0522746742,
-0.0157027207,
-0.0579356775,
0.0225930586,
0.0101931412,
-0.033078365,
0.0363057069,
-0.0213991795,
0.0205022376,
-0.0000060675,
-0.0614701286,
0.009630993,
-0.0028792988,
0.0567937978,
0.0333447233,
0.0538164824,
0.0346529372,
0.05780527,
0.0222763401,
0.0236796197,
-0.0483192019,
-0.0093389489,
0.0288670324,
-0.0071004545,
0.0266863871,
0.0100452676,
-0.0000344139,
-0.0159434825,
-0.0144793587,
-0.0025915068,
0.031043224,
0.0606933869,
0.029876668,
0.0236610938,
-0.0201772805,
-0.0174026582,
-0.0249593109,
0.0664253756,
-0.0164062176,
-0.0287532713,
0.0347744264,
0.0397718996,
-0.0117268898,
-0.0353619382,
0.0499733873,
-0.0195297711,
-0.0089866286,
0.022525331,
-0.0067336606,
0.0144245559,
-0.0037088555,
0.0237141345,
-0.048594445,
0.0120229209,
-0.00550185,
-0.0069428515,
-0.0254244916,
0.0157164857,
0.005379973,
0.0270653293,
-0.054665979,
0.0108605055,
-0.0139019778,
0.0039111092,
-0.017092254,
-0.0159005653,
-0.0002028468,
0.0240624752,
0.0027396579,
0.0800074339,
-0.0080615031,
-0.0307017006,
-0.0271397531,
-0.0361359082,
0.0171571486,
0.0013974491,
-0.0204375405,
0.0324169286,
-0.0650659502,
0.0577316508,
0.0157098752,
-0.0687706918,
0.0265138317,
0.0144725246,
2.611e-7,
-0.0055762166,
0.0633840039,
0.0579267368,
0.0162949022,
0.0222325884,
0.0083938185,
-0.026692735,
0.0029882709,
0.0261703692,
-0.0262336638,
0.0041061109,
0.0664498657,
0.0419844575,
0.0090523912,
-0.1175609827,
-0.0146545218,
-0.0718233064,
-0.0221654512,
-0.044114124,
-0.0274416506,
0.052796375,
0.0818884224,
-0.0011010157,
0.0272371173,
-0.0286760926,
-0.0621075481,
0.0745772943,
-0.019442521,
-0.0400260687,
0.0368535034,
0.0115403756,
0.0396586284,
-0.0362341478,
-0.0229076911,
0.0014408289,
-0.000008523,
-0.0020557367,
0.068192102,
0.0320787728,
-0.0583832748,
0.0054114396,
-0.0041667861,
-0.0175983645,
-0.0103873387,
0.0624125451,
-0.0584155209,
0.0023378329,
-0.0103029069,
-0.0238208231,
0.0116867237,
-0.0106126266,
0.0230637137,
-0.0331421606,
0.0370026864,
-0.0145685263,
-0.0009373647,
0.0184769612,
-0.1101329774,
-0.027428234,
-0.0162249766,
-0.0483317412,
-0.033445321,
-0.0633484498,
-0.0021629387,
-0.0103906589,
-0.0748405159,
-0.0033459212,
2.434724077e-34,
0.0586718582,
-0.0255955756,
-0.0220823791,
0.0249861721,
0.0163553078,
-0.0193595868,
-0.0127007337,
0.0186697096,
0.0388034731,
-0.093425937,
-0.03521901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13337v2 | Nominal Topology for Data Languages | 2023-04-26T07:11:44 | 2023-05-10T06:50:37 | Fabian Birkmann, Stefan Milius, Henning Urbat | cs.CL | cs.CL, F.4.3 | We propose a novel topological perspective on data languages recognizable by
orbit-finite nominal monoids. For this purpose, we introduce pro-orbit-finite
nominal topological spaces. Assuming globally bounded support sizes, they
coincide with nominal Stone spaces and are shown to be dually equivalent to a
subcategory of nominal boolean algebras. Recognizable data languages are
characterized as topologically clopen sets of pro-orbit-finite words. In
addition, we explore the expressive power of pro-orbit-finite equations by
establishing a nominal version of Reiterman's pseudovariety theorem. | [
-0.0014811666,
0.0746136531,
-0.062772952,
-0.0021489728,
-0.0134576224,
-0.0182222482,
0.0313771181,
0.0190462917,
-0.0061046002,
0.005570543,
-0.0313441232,
0.0090656215,
-0.0289950687,
0.0619579889,
0.022497423,
-0.0033180555,
0.0910386741,
-0.0407125019,
-0.0322488062,
-0.0105758738,
-0.0091985455,
-0.0393271782,
-0.0478121154,
-0.0403235741,
-0.0031288795,
-0.0680781081,
-0.007595513,
-0.0545842387,
0.0180391483,
-0.0074901185,
0.0073202779,
0.0268908031,
-0.0497020334,
0.0269389842,
0.0000011649,
-0.0059519587,
-0.0155840535,
0.0164861996,
-0.0679516047,
-0.0013932423,
-0.0909063742,
-0.0005634642,
0.0256259497,
-0.0152853271,
0.0015576079,
-0.1090371907,
0.0635874867,
-0.0249253735,
-0.0091002267,
-0.0544095784,
0.0115609653,
0.0062178224,
0.0686126873,
0.0357527919,
-0.0010083329,
0.0368657038,
-0.022491185,
0.0541676022,
0.0124620851,
0.0058460231,
0.0370134264,
0.0035489204,
-0.0194456149,
-0.038871713,
-0.0254921559,
0.0075063556,
-0.0407552756,
0.0454438664,
0.0028154009,
0.0017611372,
0.0648570284,
-0.027634332,
-0.0298811384,
0.049812641,
-0.0083342632,
0.0426512472,
0.0234850459,
0.0340522304,
-0.0041788425,
0.0224692095,
0.0285341442,
-0.0131580438,
0.0172145572,
-0.0093207741,
-0.0693882704,
0.1022054926,
-0.0085022142,
-0.0033982897,
-0.0132422838,
-0.0407333784,
-0.0058374275,
0.0259856675,
0.0326927267,
-0.0073883776,
-0.0119620599,
0.0027343852,
-0.0075263088,
0.0218820497,
-0.0203480609,
-0.014802862,
0.0176043939,
0.0171266105,
-0.0101237195,
0.0137583809,
-0.0359983742,
0.0719337612,
0.0512942001,
0.0027114649,
0.0092351167,
0.0324388482,
0.0001635494,
-0.004627496,
-0.0849832296,
0.0480504334,
0.020404039,
-0.0074400995,
0.0175212715,
0.060137976,
-0.0140822576,
0.0360721052,
-0.046891354,
-0.0436126068,
-0.0301014557,
0.0614964142,
0.0271869563,
-0.0464117266,
0.0178622473,
-0.0242718421,
-0.0388309658,
-0.0207476672,
0.0155860409,
-0.0077327131,
0.0037070483,
-0.0453963391,
-0.0369572528,
0.0144199468,
0.0348483212,
0.0450606197,
0.0225618277,
0.0360417031,
0.0325859003,
0.0160544924,
0.0121710384,
0.0027832438,
0.014764579,
-0.0008744326,
0.0308342967,
-0.0100306179,
-0.0095693925,
-0.0248268954,
0.0493001603,
0.0459591076,
-0.0514101312,
0.013054681,
-0.0835245997,
-0.0411745645,
0.0551381633,
-0.0404612049,
0.0151868658,
-0.0139989601,
0.0257733986,
-0.0133568551,
-0.0071428875,
-0.0133039532,
0.0096107796,
-0.0471481346,
-0.0862931609,
0.017842494,
0.0591797531,
0.0079614762,
-0.0479064174,
0.0869758502,
-0.0178125408,
-0.0785353109,
-0.0053695035,
-0.0161515921,
0.0260064062,
0.0705140457,
-0.0649230629,
-0.0060438141,
0.0345134586,
0.0576889329,
0.0234987549,
-0.0020456668,
-0.0359921493,
0.0289676972,
-0.0682157204,
-0.0110822879,
0.0340863355,
-0.0509059094,
-0.0632420108,
0.0195660479,
-0.0122324657,
-0.0195270367,
0.0141630471,
-0.0286716074,
-0.0078119827,
0.0019168543,
-0.0192107242,
0.0156125957,
0.0210068263,
-0.002141641,
0.0340932831,
-0.0001233003,
-0.062073756,
-0.0755257607,
-0.0598389916,
-0.0281876475,
0.0147830611,
0.0337360613,
-0.021089673,
-0.0558047742,
-0.0423693247,
0.0246093422,
0.0400314406,
0.0269531664,
-0.0043616886,
0.0086731697,
-0.075256452,
-0.005653149,
-0.0523314066,
0.0114006726,
-0.0520430915,
0.0201096404,
0.0571380891,
0.0003756363,
0.017951386,
0.0409753658,
-0.0091271652,
0.0050032241,
-0.0400989205,
0.0396517366,
0.0235600136,
0.0008215165,
0.051812008,
-0.0003052778,
0.0113687487,
-0.0377288982,
0.0307588764,
-0.016857205,
0.037792813,
0.0005494077,
-0.014299944,
0.0318398103,
0.0033518136,
-0.0474030003,
0.0292021651,
0.0002635451,
0.0335875675,
0.0087343818,
-0.0163325015,
-0.0156001253,
-0.0185208675,
-0.039563641,
0.0578103475,
-0.0281419102,
0.0288373288,
0.0403102078,
0.0232087635,
-0.0228303205,
0.0620439984,
-0.0044570677,
0.0135254888,
0.0065602739,
-0.0346825495,
0.0190737415,
-0.0232823789,
-0.0056857807,
-0.0040694643,
0.0194825511,
0.0119403563,
0.0116068712,
-0.0039405562,
0.0243529603,
0.0374940522,
-0.0029101993,
-0.0063692965,
0.0570371598,
0.0038801099,
0.0297905486,
-0.0231618453,
-0.0459852368,
0.0418428853,
0.0051589734,
-0.0085570291,
0.0008724499,
-0.0691430867,
-0.0548642986,
0.0164305884,
-0.0294597019,
-0.037711136,
0.0257046334,
-0.0417030193,
-0.0063026519,
0.0011066959,
0.0524143726,
0.0299845077,
0.0041037868,
-0.0595519952,
-0.021033207,
-0.0291520152,
-0.0208294615,
0.0288530178,
0.0005681597,
-0.0149871195,
-0.0404079147,
0.0097291861,
-0.0079249647,
0.0233775023,
-0.0130848531,
-0.0344302095,
-0.0662536249,
0.0005043271,
0.0373433493,
-0.0094680283,
0.0472253151,
-0.0462359563,
0.0089445468,
-0.0176583976,
0.0620002337,
-0.048557926,
-0.0581344143,
-0.0191192385,
0.0264107957,
0.0168221369,
0.0417932644,
-0.0304588135,
-0.0671593323,
0.04435765,
0.0128091089,
0.0057402295,
0.0535979755,
-0.0360619426,
0.0000929172,
-0.0209422857,
-0.0227253251,
-0.0201829132,
0.0571880564,
-0.0241376739,
0.0181683116,
0.0151098417,
-0.024393782,
-0.018184619,
0.0416309163,
0.0700424984,
-0.0088491095,
-0.0233199913,
-0.0496274121,
0.0304741822,
0.0513179898,
-0.0147053087,
-0.0143702719,
0.0095895994,
0.0336473919,
-0.0186328329,
0.0189053491,
-0.0037052261,
0.0809565783,
-0.0408032611,
0.0432300791,
-0.0680693388,
0.0305295959,
-0.0717353821,
-0.0103873434,
0.0302111208,
0.0211012159,
0.0423412733,
0.0206009019,
-0.0092514707,
-0.0143534131,
-0.0680149868,
0.0179424714,
-0.0393664986,
0.0196713414,
0.0304915234,
0.073376976,
0.043475017,
-0.0401743092,
-0.0024848238,
0.050046619,
-0.0287006758,
-0.0251734965,
0.0590326972,
-0.0092803789,
-0.0735168979,
-0.0194795411,
0.039299164,
0.0001836218,
-0.0112246666,
-0.0175010227,
0.021458555,
-0.1090082601,
-0.079232268,
0.0351767503,
0.015327245,
0.005745864,
-0.044517938,
0.0492824018,
-0.0126009891,
0.0276682377,
0.0232434999,
0.0751195624,
-0.0082189329,
-0.0258473158,
-0.0028519835,
0.005781821,
-0.0288692955,
0.0651675835,
-0.0223562252,
-0.0375653058,
-0.0319676138,
0.0342201851,
-0.018273605,
-0.0115322107,
-0.0637324005,
0.052064646,
0.0245047137,
-0.0284108557,
0.0514679179,
-0.013675292,
0.027091492,
-0.0006558272,
0.024333559,
-0.0219246689,
-0.0029096189,
-0.015059215,
-0.0561684221,
0.0225133095,
-0.0326713994,
-0.0067873555,
0.0330113769,
-0.0250900779,
-0.0179360732,
-0.0289094821,
0.0517628491,
-0.0505999438,
-0.0037937937,
-0.0479187556,
-0.0826677755,
-0.0082088904,
0.0550335608,
0.0155717805,
0.0358383656,
0.0089624468,
0.0090745362,
0.0258953776,
-0.0371905342,
-0.0458281487,
-0.0109615037,
-0.0402651466,
0.0281770341,
0.0341020674,
-0.0487397872,
0.0305667166,
0.0288382582,
-0.0713182539,
-0.0001122779,
0.0207270924,
0.0209748354,
0.0669126809,
0.0103532523,
0.0152504789,
-0.0383149348,
0.0174219944,
0.0064421799,
-0.027896082,
0.0629050285,
0.003586642,
-0.0068042069,
0.0678151324,
0.0038661328,
0.0404350869,
0.024432335,
0.0041609998,
-0.0203767251,
-0.0383418538,
-0.0227722302,
-0.0807836428,
0.0386013091,
0.0213553216,
0.0308412835,
-0.0154757779,
0.058133103,
-0.0205148272,
-0.0277116224,
-0.0325672999,
-0.0028913531,
-0.0367945023,
-0.0484185666,
0.0382839292,
0.0071361098,
0.0029895825,
-0.0553842559,
-0.0813176855,
0.0518066771,
0.0032506143,
0.0294267219,
0.0217665303,
0.0275670495,
0.0040877638,
0.0456907041,
0.030861007,
0.0130940406,
0.0278900415,
0.0102380281,
0.0457870513,
0.0282474551,
-0.0217285994,
0.0375271216,
-0.0168285035,
0.0279117674,
-0.0090808244,
-0.009286453,
0.0164293032,
0.0068706675,
0.0106721148,
-0.013727542,
0.0155622922,
-0.0738125592,
-0.0575860552,
-0.0226499196,
0.0057539665,
-0.013786939,
0.017692389,
-0.0163515378,
0.0240939911,
0.0020650162,
0.0365463756,
0.0092241671,
0.0440988094,
0.0209211614,
-0.0099230101,
-0.01137006,
-0.0198694505,
-0.0481351838,
-0.009076369,
-0.0326151028,
0.0611719005,
0.0259047803,
0.0780560374,
-0.0857072026,
-0.0475345887,
0.0241113603,
0.0692780018,
0.0792544186,
-0.0432436764,
-0.0284959711,
0.0071615591,
0.0046208776,
-0.0224257316,
-0.031454619,
0.0408983827,
-0.0070451675,
-0.0003416583,
-0.0634824112,
-4.508172548e-33,
-0.0171545297,
-0.0367701091,
-0.022301171,
-0.0290528834,
-0.0182035267,
0.022005666,
-0.0013922113,
0.0522462949,
-0.0038455334,
-0.0175721087,
0.0271422472,
0.0084415749,
-0.0034387351,
0.0254581254,
-0.0523187183,
-0.0020667952,
-0.0226064902,
-0.0349603742,
-0.0224070325,
-0.0184212904,
0.0002509227,
-0.0618443862,
-0.0131564178,
-0.0377900414,
0.0531108119,
-0.0275560264,
0.003795207,
0.0753317997,
-0.0634588748,
0.0115446215,
-0.0396361798,
0.0152487857,
-0.0015441324,
0.0822872445,
-0.0207002386,
-0.0077015944,
-0.0542390868,
-0.0783886835,
0.0657061711,
-0.0020576292,
0.0188889075,
0.0164248012,
0.0426163934,
-0.0077592474,
-0.0403802618,
0.0299887937,
-0.0274784993,
-0.0117579577,
-0.0654269978,
-0.0242861379,
0.03179048,
0.0267592836,
0.0088769048,
0.0513107479,
0.0039604302,
-0.0205043871,
-0.0118324375,
0.0028696298,
0.0027338704,
0.0158732515,
0.0476088151,
-0.0018403879,
-0.016906064,
0.0190387238,
0.0390716419,
0.0039798934,
0.0144285755,
0.0001954671,
0.0450656749,
0.0858531371,
-0.0124226063,
0.0370599888,
-0.0098971026,
-0.0024516878,
0.0622645877,
-0.0137081845,
-0.0119184274,
-0.0412410833,
0.0100986464,
-0.0405704193,
0.0132857161,
0.0131927785,
-0.0065748831,
0.001714127,
-0.0286271032,
-0.0406108052,
0.0009797064,
0.0431019962,
-0.0396412015,
-0.0464547724,
-0.0265707318,
0.048244182,
0.006238725,
-0.0204178765,
-0.1126689687,
-0.0216382816,
0.028794352,
0.0403577574,
-0.0217673443,
0.035441041,
0.0429720357,
-0.0095499298,
-0.1024978682,
0.0514531396,
0.0203718171,
0.0099993488,
-0.0313757509,
0.0175683405,
-0.05430099,
0.0167567171,
-0.0064969291,
-0.0362441503,
-0.0082032578,
-0.007880968,
0.0372417197,
0.0135186343,
0.0373727903,
0.0474731848,
0.0237568971,
-0.0535456389,
0.0272322372,
0.0248279013,
-0.0224286541,
0.013504426,
0.0133999316,
-0.0653082654,
0.0012167043,
-0.0094102863,
0.0653043836,
-0.0278369952,
0.0148913376,
-0.0010438751,
2.311e-7,
-0.0230329074,
-0.0089645842,
0.0490359887,
0.0702928081,
-0.0018528549,
-0.052722156,
0.0136030233,
-0.016245231,
-0.0037576642,
-0.0050714752,
-0.0242480561,
0.0017075517,
-0.0321564637,
-0.0318512358,
-0.0304121152,
0.0453507677,
0.0557450578,
-0.0267194863,
-0.0302055981,
0.0549711697,
0.0911951885,
0.033341039,
0.0253095943,
0.0119755054,
-0.0456428677,
-0.0138187632,
-0.0216635149,
0.0362715758,
0.0438976325,
0.0598333813,
0.0015873631,
-0.022506129,
-0.0137210013,
0.0196601059,
0.0338412523,
0.0401183814,
0.0165960826,
0.0171554089,
0.0198540539,
0.0662064999,
-0.000505705,
-0.0775488615,
-0.0013236025,
0.0539280027,
0.0329224356,
-0.0180809945,
-0.0182039682,
0.0362316705,
0.0361996442,
0.0448272862,
-0.012669784,
-0.0529747605,
-0.0250076912,
0.0050554369,
-0.0145630073,
-0.0124417497,
0.0192133468,
-0.0228027701,
-0.0863403231,
0.0493306369,
-0.0494595841,
-0.0079461616,
0.0512568504,
-0.0007849535,
0.0026506216,
0.0235012863,
-0.0289757866,
2.470511682e-34,
0.0546616204,
-0.0257518608,
0.0178069659,
-0.0075128656,
0.0492175445,
-0.0292964689,
0.0734216347,
0.0080468217,
0.0680291131,
-0.0309496578,
-0.0157635119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13301v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13301v2 | Prompting GPT-3.5 for Text-to-SQL with De-semanticization and Skeleton Retrieval | 2023-04-26T06:02:01 | 2023-08-31T15:24:36 | Chunxi Guo, Zhiliang Tian, Jintao Tang, Pancheng Wang, Zhihua Wen, Kang Yang, Ting Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text-to-SQL is a task that converts a natural language question into a
structured query language (SQL) to retrieve information from a database. Large
language models (LLMs) work well in natural language generation tasks, but they
are not specifically pre-trained to understand the syntax and semantics of SQL
commands. In this paper, we propose an LLM-based framework for Text-to-SQL
which retrieves helpful demonstration examples to prompt LLMs. However,
questions with different database schemes can vary widely, even if the
intentions behind them are similar and the corresponding SQL queries exhibit
similarities. Consequently, it becomes crucial to identify the appropriate SQL
demonstrations that align with our requirements. We design a de-semanticization
mechanism that extracts question skeletons, allowing us to retrieve similar
examples based on their structural similarity. We also model the relationships
between question tokens and database schema items (i.e., tables and columns) to
filter out scheme-related information. Our framework adapts the range of the
database schema in prompts to balance length and valuable information. A
fallback mechanism allows for a more detailed schema to be provided if the
generated SQL query fails. Ours outperforms state-of-the-art models and
demonstrates strong generalization ability on three cross-domain Text-to-SQL
benchmarks. | [
0.0228293613,
0.0542487986,
-0.0015837203,
0.0313018709,
-0.029444553,
0.0189320818,
-0.0146523947,
0.0266399011,
0.0300148837,
-0.0617694966,
0.0021713327,
0.0024149888,
-0.0370111801,
0.0408802964,
0.0585129969,
-0.0700079799,
0.0255880821,
-0.0035856774,
-0.0270729102,
0.0464542992,
0.0122989593,
0.0274307877,
0.0122244703,
0.0019343591,
-0.0138764111,
-0.0088325832,
-0.054283347,
0.0383107476,
-0.0300784614,
-0.0401807055,
-0.0086141378,
0.0451999083,
0.0372141004,
0.0040955232,
0.000001856,
-0.0664907619,
-0.0659492388,
0.0314548053,
-0.0415041894,
-0.0001093003,
0.028387066,
-0.0128545715,
0.0481036454,
0.0416090228,
-0.0612115301,
-0.0150113767,
0.0109625319,
0.0426576845,
0.051550243,
0.0829120651,
-0.0080456035,
-0.0383864641,
-0.0021562455,
-0.004287817,
0.0594382174,
-0.0193951,
-0.0061059468,
0.0333951414,
0.0641840845,
0.0269967746,
0.0233702715,
0.0021257435,
0.0095567582,
0.0070479494,
-0.0278602354,
0.003684046,
-0.0501124114,
0.0449908189,
-0.0140396943,
0.0648001581,
0.0147340056,
-0.0422391482,
0.0324599408,
-0.0048199147,
0.0377265327,
-0.0061788578,
-0.0415055677,
0.0117464196,
0.0047967853,
-0.0153073249,
-0.0012559489,
-0.0058179279,
0.0012278383,
-0.0233351458,
-0.0369899012,
0.0265778769,
0.0057368185,
-0.0416746438,
0.036036592,
-0.0124411276,
0.0005850327,
-0.0350672416,
0.018807767,
0.0448531583,
-0.0789634362,
0.0318203494,
-0.0434704237,
-0.0257180538,
0.0259716418,
0.0049513532,
0.0120495101,
0.0346117988,
0.0045076646,
0.0433218628,
-0.0470864139,
0.0337931998,
0.005717935,
0.0481499098,
-0.0368728265,
-0.003386393,
-0.0970566496,
-0.0003337147,
-0.0720144436,
0.0546532422,
-0.0578894801,
-0.0060305796,
0.0112582296,
0.032636825,
0.0132535435,
0.0441787876,
0.0166791938,
0.0434418544,
-0.0352708884,
-0.0201484524,
-0.0445015803,
-0.0211819112,
-0.0184719041,
-0.0005963349,
0.0364004225,
-0.0908848718,
-0.0215657651,
0.0145703685,
0.0231553614,
-0.0144900465,
0.0121284341,
0.0503420569,
-0.0237975288,
-0.0061685927,
-0.1093865484,
-0.0818928182,
0.0247829761,
-0.0115811685,
-0.0164577365,
-0.035845276,
0.0654487386,
-0.0043880376,
-0.0198947545,
-0.0227161888,
-0.0024666318,
0.0505581424,
0.0150990253,
0.0582936779,
-0.0076473271,
0.0004090868,
0.0442794636,
0.0044807261,
-0.0054372228,
0.0707489923,
0.0021745896,
0.0227028821,
0.0172735881,
0.008434996,
-0.0173216648,
0.0119292792,
0.030937219,
0.0125104142,
-0.0621725842,
0.086558044,
0.020130109,
0.0614897609,
-0.0123247709,
0.0768936351,
-0.0160081256,
0.0079062516,
0.0176101848,
0.0433504172,
-0.0110830599,
0.0037870896,
0.0899605453,
0.038595818,
-0.0072339568,
0.0268161856,
-0.0595030636,
-0.0161428247,
-0.0276321433,
0.0282487795,
0.0111648571,
-0.0016359471,
-0.041371353,
-0.0254670586,
0.0154956719,
-0.0206568185,
0.0020000888,
0.0154250804,
-0.009193195,
0.0549671426,
-0.0635836646,
0.0250735134,
-0.0329714343,
-0.0399856009,
0.0244301111,
-0.0219925344,
-0.0032588828,
0.0445887148,
0.0290553868,
-0.0564790778,
-0.0194146167,
-0.0256787334,
0.0302459449,
0.0336971059,
0.0223336089,
-0.0393345021,
-0.0180441532,
-0.0159220397,
-0.0211145785,
-0.0063659931,
0.0304018892,
-0.0267793424,
0.0400371626,
-0.0038178286,
0.0495172665,
-0.0714337528,
-0.0103099495,
0.051292289,
-0.0317024663,
-0.0571895763,
0.0261921324,
-0.012977019,
0.0078167357,
0.0351406932,
0.0070721856,
0.0365343355,
0.0301094595,
-0.0071767913,
-0.0250756405,
-0.0390564352,
-0.0071859197,
-0.0371709354,
-0.0100863157,
-0.0009069734,
-0.0053762952,
-0.0312793106,
-0.0765687376,
-0.0512894765,
-0.0068661338,
-0.007961072,
0.0208097734,
-0.0530414917,
-0.005650322,
0.0364988372,
-0.049166128,
-0.0372877792,
0.0689137727,
0.0370745882,
0.0151738422,
0.0161990374,
-0.0515858531,
0.0242126994,
-0.0785840601,
0.032549873,
-0.0178089347,
-0.0182974413,
0.0362769142,
-0.0084963888,
0.0375158153,
-0.0804602653,
0.0185136441,
-0.0807348713,
0.031189505,
-0.0371807367,
0.0548107997,
0.0334080048,
0.0374601856,
-0.0251086373,
-0.0403928645,
-0.1042723656,
-0.0309191551,
0.0057944921,
-0.0017992563,
0.0457880944,
0.0186705664,
0.0045528552,
-0.0069739581,
0.007504676,
-0.0314514935,
0.0504522063,
-0.030710144,
-0.0025968372,
-0.027095357,
0.0491168387,
-0.0005459022,
0.0249154847,
0.0324635245,
0.0354910493,
0.0065549463,
-0.0433674343,
0.0200392883,
0.0503409319,
-0.0018486665,
-0.0380543619,
-0.0104459934,
0.0203945152,
-0.0676358193,
0.0033147989,
-0.0218446087,
0.0264977589,
0.0112945568,
-0.0376849882,
0.0834763125,
-0.0142303184,
0.0231534727,
-0.0126425158,
-0.0338521861,
0.0084389094,
0.0221830513,
0.0243644826,
-0.0705962181,
0.0047565941,
0.0245895069,
-0.0034348145,
0.0176692139,
-0.0061939727,
0.0827337578,
-0.0146126943,
0.0022929776,
-0.0350213312,
0.0038370071,
-0.0549404807,
0.0869044289,
0.0046316325,
0.0275578089,
0.0201443136,
-0.0679263473,
-0.0509526655,
-0.020858055,
0.0025252441,
-0.0239667967,
0.0551936813,
-0.0540964752,
0.0048749838,
-0.0057144235,
-0.0200913176,
-0.0334307067,
-0.002324502,
-0.0139955683,
0.0379328169,
0.0270973742,
0.0250377264,
0.0227861553,
-0.0254812799,
-0.0174128488,
0.056825038,
-0.0165675413,
-0.0174267907,
-0.0077081886,
0.0181350596,
0.030414911,
0.0353924371,
-0.0235907156,
-0.0188274123,
0.016955968,
0.0350915045,
0.033591792,
-0.0414011516,
-0.0175136942,
0.0121306451,
-0.0201678108,
-0.0598670952,
0.0095786406,
0.0433125868,
-0.0101598129,
-0.0691326112,
-0.0293158554,
0.0811067745,
0.0438977256,
0.0314659849,
-0.0148363551,
0.0331592634,
0.0408765525,
0.0189344622,
0.055018723,
-0.128848508,
-0.0361816809,
-0.0256535914,
0.029962346,
0.0321648233,
-0.0357880667,
-0.0260745157,
-0.1523916572,
0.0261954367,
-0.0257871058,
-0.0583057068,
-0.0040309392,
-0.0142857442,
-0.0235480107,
-0.0104456395,
0.0115244566,
0.0641716793,
-0.031697724,
0.0165579747,
0.0119812731,
0.0075329975,
-0.0672405884,
-0.0193562414,
-0.0380664766,
-0.0038693917,
0.0462284498,
-0.0258094296,
0.0322761387,
-0.0251838211,
0.0275759827,
-0.0231699161,
-0.0030160823,
-0.0081905005,
0.0649942011,
0.0021971918,
0.0204987302,
0.0107352333,
0.0580176748,
-0.0456478111,
0.0330846198,
0.030565761,
0.0837621987,
-0.0474510007,
-0.000592952,
-0.0119454907,
-0.040369682,
0.017004557,
0.068741709,
0.0276845135,
-0.0025343215,
-0.0542647354,
-0.0168889258,
-0.0118412375,
-0.0622495301,
0.0056852088,
0.032378573,
-0.0317591913,
0.0301110707,
-0.0619384907,
-0.0256120004,
0.0710204393,
0.0502223223,
0.024655655,
0.0398767889,
-0.0076495749,
-0.0205119886,
-0.0282288697,
0.0070339874,
-0.0338184163,
-0.0090161646,
-0.0552005842,
-0.0150561659,
0.0053688153,
-0.0514271148,
-0.0217411499,
-0.0392825194,
-0.0628214926,
-0.0286347792,
-0.0254560318,
0.0035066204,
0.0169933196,
0.0113782799,
0.0127497632,
-0.0292033646,
-0.0056950557,
0.0437340774,
-0.0566406213,
-0.0663244724,
-0.0159151983,
0.0248342045,
-0.0135389939,
0.0421756767,
-0.0584750138,
-0.0113964984,
-0.0412053131,
0.0333280042,
-0.0107599776,
0.0148388073,
0.0830743685,
0.0375303961,
0.0119725512,
0.0348334461,
-0.017397752,
-0.0213894602,
0.024636779,
-0.0460486151,
-0.0570480712,
-0.0429756567,
0.0444728285,
0.0124798054,
-0.0132159255,
0.0192362871,
-0.0537475646,
-0.0345689319,
0.0718767196,
-0.0215386618,
-0.0391268693,
0.0388850719,
-0.0165459309,
0.0152080553,
-0.029822059,
-0.0099714026,
0.0324633978,
0.0169405919,
0.0505033806,
-0.0231567416,
0.0508960746,
0.048820395,
0.0172286406,
0.0015374159,
-0.0043815607,
-0.0242027175,
-0.0473001227,
-0.0266944151,
0.0026215494,
-0.019279724,
0.0011126798,
-0.0109819947,
-0.0099484306,
-0.019078305,
-0.0119920205,
0.0249603782,
0.0381812416,
-0.0251415633,
0.0562139675,
0.0126411691,
-0.026959477,
-0.0260117371,
0.0448332727,
0.0101872012,
0.0047988538,
0.0166335013,
-0.0289449804,
-0.0613215342,
-0.0204320662,
0.0544283465,
-0.0020577319,
-0.0228836723,
-0.0284542721,
-0.0286264364,
-0.0337132514,
-0.0150611382,
0.0214086827,
-0.0105568385,
0.0058846204,
0.0813791454,
0.0785022378,
0.02111228,
-0.024359392,
-0.0209424216,
0.0092066955,
-0.0279639456,
-0.0973189846,
-0.0260254014,
-5.743100628e-33,
-0.0342074111,
-0.0292790029,
0.0476565994,
-0.0074547995,
0.0163581353,
-0.0349700265,
-0.0253939852,
-0.0118753007,
-0.0193464532,
0.0079021472,
-0.0171596128,
0.0201818123,
0.0188722536,
0.0327672176,
0.0141222896,
-0.0513244011,
0.0229598861,
-0.0363896117,
-0.0081478637,
0.0488794968,
0.0322998427,
0.0311448462,
0.0182101354,
-0.033776667,
0.0467097871,
-0.0103862686,
-0.0200063158,
0.0212526023,
0.01550854,
0.0264337845,
-0.0350330025,
0.0175139178,
0.0343504995,
-0.0120570706,
-0.0181429461,
0.0091108885,
-0.0590429753,
-0.0291154999,
0.0164704863,
-0.0201196168,
-0.0517114289,
-0.0092989802,
0.0542923361,
-0.069287762,
0.0035704873,
0.0051091639,
0.0131007591,
0.0022724012,
0.019288063,
-0.0624065623,
-0.0391488932,
0.0099759176,
0.0215754136,
0.0013416774,
0.0199243091,
0.0654863045,
-0.0059418217,
0.0276969671,
0.015067365,
0.0210704245,
0.0409565084,
0.038460467,
0.0139423143,
-0.006766906,
-0.0139896031,
0.0056283507,
-0.0127575407,
-0.0216922425,
0.0085122706,
0.0473683551,
-0.0202322025,
0.0693503618,
0.0305019151,
0.0343763866,
0.0324009731,
0.0107896989,
-0.0588493384,
0.0482623205,
-0.0445655435,
-0.0155678913,
-0.0204667654,
-0.0065972595,
-0.0381237566,
-0.0301720966,
-0.0357871056,
0.0492699295,
-0.04419709,
-0.0319652632,
0.0667575374,
-0.0056991996,
0.0026292983,
-0.0117967511,
0.0156478845,
-0.0043414738,
-0.0420829691,
0.019723231,
-0.0174580067,
-0.041341491,
0.0002395784,
0.0243384205,
-0.0263685491,
-0.0443397835,
0.0357166603,
-0.0191575717,
-0.0002090738,
0.031651821,
0.0252557825,
0.0299547724,
-0.0728954822,
0.0376412645,
-0.0115362527,
0.0350429155,
-0.0416682102,
0.0167472567,
0.0131022315,
0.0151570449,
0.0188275483,
0.041695457,
0.0047269636,
-0.0571107082,
-0.0491392128,
0.0007484484,
0.0074683828,
0.0375969782,
0.0105201695,
0.0275105126,
0.0160321519,
-0.0166070852,
0.0317297988,
-0.0092216907,
0.0110659366,
0.0372930765,
2.567e-7,
0.0825454444,
0.02052081,
0.02129527,
0.0675721467,
-0.0147124277,
0.0262983572,
0.0112017496,
0.038062226,
0.0125997178,
-0.0473119877,
0.0231289845,
-0.0237456765,
0.0195064098,
0.0289998241,
-0.1101539135,
-0.002916012,
-0.014268633,
-0.0315403901,
-0.0759112388,
-0.0115296161,
0.0804943666,
0.0495874844,
-0.0382805057,
0.019498596,
-0.0003331449,
-0.0541143753,
0.019193396,
-0.0150972614,
-0.0135378549,
0.0576200411,
0.0235214327,
0.0071279509,
-0.0021715567,
0.0292404648,
-0.0208389033,
0.008467284,
-0.0052951709,
0.053431876,
0.027480986,
0.007901757,
-0.0054842653,
-0.0747669265,
0.0350051485,
-0.0392632484,
0.0578717105,
-0.0416012779,
0.0135408547,
0.0673785135,
-0.0216101669,
-0.046753753,
0.0023430141,
-0.0037690857,
-0.0013614637,
-0.0216424763,
0.0344987102,
0.0257421378,
0.0095582278,
-0.0334607624,
-0.0078715617,
0.0536686964,
-0.0365689024,
0.0070533492,
-0.0018750798,
0.0355659835,
-0.0687112287,
-0.041033607,
-0.0282334052,
2.814217046e-34,
0.0292268842,
0.0149618024,
0.0326468684,
0.004034827,
0.0509592257,
-0.0014222993,
-0.0035359859,
0.0036241303,
-0.0015853539,
-0.064227052,
-0.031139411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13292v1 | Zero-Shot Slot and Intent Detection in Low-Resource Languages | 2023-04-26T05:10:12 | 2023-04-26T05:10:12 | Sang Yun Kwon, Gagan Bhatia, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Alcides Alcoba Inciarte, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intent detection and slot filling are critical tasks in spoken and natural
language understanding for task-oriented dialog systems. In this work we
describe our participation in the slot and intent detection for low-resource
language varieties (SID4LR; Aepli et al. (2023)). We investigate the slot and
intent detection (SID) tasks using a wide range of models and settings. Given
the recent success of multitask-prompted finetuning of large language models,
we also test the generalization capability of the recent encoder-decoder model
mT0 (Muennighoff et al., 2022) on new tasks (i.e., SID) in languages they have
never intentionally seen. We show that our best model outperforms the baseline
by a large margin (up to +30 F1 points) in both SID tasks | [
0.023290053,
0.0388361886,
0.0024475339,
0.04273168,
-0.0001407344,
0.0402029939,
-0.0022752215,
-0.0252687037,
-0.0562035218,
-0.0414646603,
-0.0351933576,
-0.052548524,
-0.004090691,
0.0506476685,
0.0211499222,
-0.0084589617,
0.0434645712,
-0.0458678342,
0.0433437303,
0.0192781109,
0.0110914046,
0.0115276072,
-0.0271646809,
0.0616569668,
0.0194201618,
-0.025932068,
-0.0492030494,
0.0337607153,
0.0061209202,
-0.0163038559,
0.0169311687,
0.0600428805,
0.0161972251,
0.0453654379,
0.0000020569,
-0.0363839194,
0.0064235511,
-0.0406060033,
-0.120814532,
-0.024528373,
-0.0119727859,
-0.0418725125,
-0.0160953179,
-0.0004365318,
-0.0131697934,
-0.0434778407,
0.0602466092,
0.0098605622,
0.021556234,
0.0561511517,
-0.003777164,
0.0197729692,
0.0221363138,
-0.0421830043,
0.0263109822,
-0.0661838725,
0.0143912071,
0.0106778601,
-0.0263168346,
-0.0045172116,
-0.0288868379,
0.0322969854,
0.0221441574,
-0.0080587175,
-0.0063205711,
0.0130406022,
-0.0233517531,
-0.0374118537,
-0.0320483893,
0.0690177679,
-0.0303733032,
-0.0058943052,
-0.0045138109,
-0.0172231887,
-0.0123152873,
-0.0376739763,
-0.0485469699,
0.0112761362,
-0.0085789496,
-0.0071592894,
0.0558532253,
0.0335402302,
-0.0125495922,
-0.0059896978,
-0.0161048993,
0.0613182709,
0.0087007266,
-0.0330985822,
0.0015838917,
0.0094093597,
0.0166114233,
-0.0640561432,
-0.0105989296,
0.0113379769,
-0.0577451028,
0.0220024623,
-0.0467135049,
-0.0197490696,
-0.005308867,
-0.0020259863,
-0.0067054313,
0.0795703679,
-0.0334723108,
0.0322532989,
0.019725142,
0.0324689262,
0.013907956,
-0.0018634326,
-0.0375826061,
-0.0087689832,
-0.0266892668,
-0.0074986089,
-0.0502242334,
-0.0017457092,
-0.0620120801,
-0.0206033792,
-0.0021685895,
0.039696794,
0.0073443614,
-0.0021569834,
0.0163574126,
-0.0347109698,
-0.0696507543,
-0.0147388987,
0.0106001711,
0.0994517729,
-0.008186982,
0.0202630814,
0.00441754,
-0.0892730132,
-0.0474480502,
0.0170858689,
0.0339871049,
-0.0532774255,
-0.0239716321,
0.0196444243,
-0.0210502408,
-0.0213137586,
-0.0130765829,
-0.0052718865,
-0.0283512045,
-0.0815016478,
-0.0525369123,
-0.0419929475,
0.0184528753,
0.0283000767,
0.0188826937,
-0.0117535116,
-0.0096867168,
0.0135796126,
0.0177577883,
0.0586312003,
-0.005450251,
0.0003008737,
-0.0100675635,
-0.0058484715,
-0.0164387655,
0.1117493287,
-0.0018751423,
0.0106929364,
0.0147766043,
-0.0090503227,
-0.0015120787,
0.0471695811,
-0.0095103048,
0.005450489,
0.0744019151,
0.0067730369,
0.0070378999,
-0.0182264969,
0.0632676035,
0.0218236763,
-0.0683675632,
0.0030835043,
0.0366655327,
0.0218719691,
-0.0017455912,
-0.0274795163,
0.0524618737,
0.067658186,
-0.0436306819,
0.013391885,
-0.0273000784,
0.0342900194,
-0.0050936723,
0.0035509968,
0.0081461053,
0.0069131767,
-0.0342123508,
-0.0259713884,
-0.0054881051,
-0.0178323667,
0.0178360771,
0.0029739165,
0.0721310228,
0.0115845241,
-0.0605912879,
0.0590009093,
0.0165603571,
-0.0065018092,
-0.0159891974,
-0.0407975242,
-0.0050801174,
0.0390498452,
0.0155232241,
-0.0045931619,
-0.090159148,
-0.0415181816,
0.003010442,
0.018153565,
0.0362610891,
-0.0154168392,
0.064712517,
-0.0643505752,
-0.0206708685,
-0.0124898134,
0.0202808473,
0.037415646,
-0.0507454611,
0.0065745143,
-0.0007501785,
-0.0135660926,
0.0277586412,
-0.0280052163,
0.0164178759,
-0.0140640605,
0.0156722032,
0.0311205536,
0.0347017795,
0.0158627126,
0.0110809058,
-0.0293929949,
0.0208805129,
-0.0439877808,
0.0320551395,
0.052663926,
-0.0612119064,
-0.0663268864,
0.0100867953,
-0.0059413039,
-0.0469952933,
0.0128714545,
-0.0069485437,
-0.0722195879,
0.0171406399,
-0.0110587776,
0.0023716369,
-0.0579820313,
0.0228520948,
-0.0025762739,
0.0264661387,
-0.0082815401,
0.0402976163,
0.014877432,
0.0083242133,
0.0925083384,
-0.0260676872,
0.0363878347,
-0.0787786394,
-0.0376446471,
0.0111650517,
-0.0593671873,
-0.0205520764,
0.0087889461,
0.0279728975,
-0.024203524,
-0.0134363892,
-0.0967661962,
0.0020183676,
-0.0492072999,
0.0245268885,
0.0067028515,
0.0258471798,
0.0077830045,
-0.0229200851,
-0.0115843397,
-0.0081439018,
0.000235286,
0.006006564,
0.0022912887,
0.0067335246,
-0.0169072058,
-0.0085246814,
0.019839609,
0.0249522272,
0.0009097168,
-0.032822445,
-0.0292333905,
-0.0575177111,
0.0098640993,
0.042789463,
-0.0157098752,
-0.022384949,
-0.0428713188,
0.0135185039,
0.0075004678,
-0.0113716917,
0.0690114275,
-0.0389220193,
0.0478563681,
0.0066839298,
-0.0090523353,
-0.0602870509,
0.0528989621,
0.0307419505,
-0.0012177019,
-0.0565795973,
-0.0003645472,
0.0222651362,
0.0980038121,
-0.0065939957,
0.0246751029,
-0.0728366747,
-0.0141169019,
-0.0262667742,
-0.0606779829,
-0.0115253767,
0.0000513517,
-0.0350004509,
0.0450641178,
-0.0319184698,
-0.0245196801,
0.0520710833,
-0.0185798779,
-0.0792536288,
-0.0383264199,
0.0007770606,
-0.0129073486,
0.0458244644,
-0.019260874,
0.0186402276,
0.0684681013,
-0.0863546953,
-0.0206449237,
0.0395097733,
-0.0077780588,
-0.0058969203,
0.0644361749,
-0.0329468474,
0.0031002001,
-0.0458284728,
-0.0555569939,
-0.0404260904,
-0.0420398787,
-0.0462357104,
0.0064124237,
0.0266350713,
-0.0035072672,
0.0014506605,
0.0340483189,
-0.0039643631,
0.0319563374,
-0.0087274825,
0.0076357387,
-0.038121704,
0.0398057736,
0.0688839704,
0.0430127494,
-0.0577823818,
0.008489266,
0.0575989969,
0.0395025387,
0.0006825299,
0.0252876319,
0.0041684918,
0.030020928,
0.0736312494,
0.0215357803,
-0.0212962069,
0.0220421217,
0.1044931933,
-0.0385701172,
-0.0171575844,
0.1246092618,
0.0078011365,
-0.0454315506,
-0.0078078946,
-0.0455060601,
0.0283211209,
0.0173394252,
0.0044447645,
-0.1035942063,
-0.075021781,
0.0307288505,
-0.0092815775,
-0.0062104031,
0.0006980476,
-0.0011808518,
-0.1087627932,
0.0336213633,
-0.0018009976,
-0.0527101941,
-0.0124903247,
-0.0098033054,
0.021003006,
-0.0419538207,
0.0477294959,
0.0101493997,
0.0154328179,
-0.0225894563,
0.0382947735,
0.0079745259,
-0.0527005978,
0.0130900601,
-0.0101019377,
0.1149955913,
0.0224730857,
0.03403458,
0.0011275433,
0.0015166791,
-0.01045088,
-0.0217174683,
-0.0244956426,
-0.014018706,
0.0129117863,
-0.0136207836,
-0.0265235268,
0.0200445894,
0.0215142258,
-0.0438361913,
0.0061826771,
0.0072009847,
0.0543095917,
-0.0310226846,
0.0075367899,
0.0318292156,
-0.0221778695,
0.0497975387,
0.090712741,
0.0427749977,
-0.0243143812,
-0.0196101647,
-0.046874959,
0.0206626207,
-0.1016170084,
0.0050239014,
0.0139452098,
0.0337682068,
-0.0303246435,
-0.0044677313,
-0.0482818894,
0.054289747,
0.0391403288,
0.0113169914,
0.0358366109,
0.0273216292,
-0.007635376,
-0.0258041155,
-0.0136490874,
-0.0260270815,
0.0293449163,
-0.0648162514,
-0.0357927568,
-0.0100572845,
-0.0283704698,
-0.0133533003,
0.0244790278,
-0.1069776937,
-0.0361665003,
-0.0366152264,
0.023697881,
0.0280203316,
0.0297354814,
-0.0377215073,
-0.014688882,
-0.0360481851,
-0.0077632698,
-0.0344911218,
0.0078231543,
0.069147788,
-0.0006673627,
-0.0134347053,
0.0560820624,
-0.0522423349,
0.0034793485,
-0.0129218884,
0.0326556899,
-0.040690355,
-0.0286732372,
0.0160071291,
0.0107717114,
0.0244976003,
0.0068134116,
-0.0296020452,
-0.0309570283,
0.043544326,
-0.0099332705,
0.0186138339,
-0.0590477549,
-0.0135330725,
0.0212532002,
-0.0039076777,
0.0289935023,
-0.0107938843,
-0.0162572339,
0.0154600851,
-0.0335053802,
0.0043664933,
0.0205246732,
-0.0096624903,
0.0198349431,
0.0036470555,
-0.0380692743,
0.0183930509,
0.0301960073,
0.0207651295,
-0.0162355583,
0.0727299824,
0.0017991109,
-0.0163517315,
0.0383150056,
0.0487071984,
-0.0157618225,
-0.0259116311,
0.0276029184,
-0.0187469386,
0.0403472409,
-0.0150900166,
0.0804940686,
0.0111545287,
0.0198160578,
-0.0270399731,
0.056490723,
-0.0101414826,
-0.027478883,
0.0217298772,
0.0245899372,
-0.0210563466,
0.0126941632,
0.0836659372,
-0.0008642855,
0.0155589627,
0.0080834311,
0.0358593725,
-0.0388475545,
-0.0137511892,
-0.0113331741,
0.0435327254,
-0.0152938999,
0.0264619756,
-0.045630794,
-0.038627781,
-0.0243515261,
-0.0242012925,
0.0137006277,
-0.0145328185,
0.017289184,
0.034778811,
-0.0292239152,
-0.0342079177,
-0.0102672307,
-0.0393573046,
-0.0049225884,
0.014820775,
-0.0324530974,
-6.306880575e-33,
-0.0257198419,
0.0233811531,
0.0050931373,
-0.0217071436,
-0.0109496228,
0.035390649,
-0.0442301296,
-0.0170371886,
-0.0199930016,
-0.0092546334,
0.0145559153,
-0.0020255533,
0.0258981008,
0.0331308544,
0.0006948591,
-0.017411327,
0.0593774579,
0.0114630032,
-0.0261377338,
0.0150547251,
0.0215062536,
0.0079184454,
0.0353617519,
0.0098588979,
0.0297430083,
0.0055342345,
-0.0086295409,
0.0280983057,
0.0151563818,
0.0560872406,
-0.0046371422,
0.0546776056,
0.0276474524,
-0.0702514499,
-0.0147626782,
0.0504011251,
-0.0915210694,
-0.0245749578,
0.0500731394,
0.0356500596,
-0.0088933371,
-0.0277629718,
-0.0060153026,
0.0191907417,
-0.0137351919,
-0.0011540075,
-0.0107819065,
-0.0035789981,
-0.0243887287,
0.0019967561,
-0.0652525648,
0.0081202742,
-0.031170046,
-0.0775694251,
0.0490792356,
0.0715936497,
-0.0006979369,
-0.0459292158,
-0.0470846184,
0.0073463623,
-0.0540957637,
0.0379195847,
0.0624790899,
0.0300710611,
-0.0019905397,
0.0526897982,
0.0079595763,
0.0043849945,
0.0217188466,
0.0112714246,
0.0009311246,
0.0349605046,
-0.0280897822,
0.0023872396,
0.0680364519,
0.0187803321,
-0.0087780273,
0.0037703,
0.0477661677,
0.0736743584,
0.028791545,
0.0353868343,
-0.0598124824,
-0.0395207815,
-0.0342915803,
-0.0244162921,
-0.0317410417,
-0.0192874204,
0.0491911024,
0.0221962277,
0.0142003465,
0.0106496587,
0.0983865261,
-0.0356304944,
0.0270658713,
0.0554774329,
0.0115449568,
0.017264327,
-0.0072587803,
0.0269348118,
-0.0235321615,
-0.0129694259,
0.0506227314,
0.0326822512,
0.0235153101,
0.0085290009,
0.0064161899,
0.0153998071,
-0.0236803479,
-0.0142634111,
-0.0584737286,
0.0274833534,
-0.023989642,
0.0695000142,
0.0412200689,
-0.000778397,
-0.0275544841,
0.0699458644,
-0.0022948037,
-0.0442497581,
-0.0517932363,
-0.0250998512,
0.0039068935,
0.0049538305,
-0.0394080877,
-0.0036729865,
-0.0030395042,
-0.034903843,
0.0164520741,
-0.0368905738,
-0.0089557907,
-0.005014522,
2.784e-7,
0.0001618591,
0.0213262793,
0.0221477151,
-0.003521007,
0.0297769494,
0.0515787825,
-0.0171596427,
0.0236166008,
0.014294982,
-0.0003487435,
0.0068916297,
0.0150639154,
0.0571990274,
-0.0074259071,
-0.1247738004,
0.0097815543,
-0.0073980005,
0.0034383966,
-0.0357758775,
0.0296966285,
0.0567197092,
0.103461504,
-0.0357439034,
-0.0097830072,
0.0430487655,
-0.041220773,
0.0028751013,
-0.0180105641,
0.0029569508,
0.0387115292,
0.0224822722,
0.0153253218,
0.0052828654,
0.0262919962,
-0.0030272352,
-0.0058382754,
0.0022686147,
0.0635037646,
0.0042380826,
-0.0499483384,
-0.0145847891,
-0.0000976588,
-0.0053770435,
-0.0322544016,
0.0831553563,
-0.0552819893,
-0.0389747955,
-0.010922824,
-0.0157301351,
0.0237172022,
-0.0405539237,
0.0024174247,
-0.0002011496,
0.009465416,
0.0320621356,
-0.0286285747,
-0.0271989927,
-0.047070764,
-0.0228590481,
-0.0060938732,
-0.0335917398,
-0.0473466776,
-0.0157130156,
-0.0752065703,
0.0352186821,
-0.0383846387,
-0.0071541662,
2.387495837e-34,
0.0526086055,
0.0003654378,
0.0327759683,
0.0813309923,
0.0258756131,
-0.0292362142,
-0.0425883904,
0.007753612,
0.0299419332,
-0.0695615932,
-0.0218212623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13276v1 | The Closeness of In-Context Learning and Weight Shifting for Softmax Regression | 2023-04-26T04:33:41 | 2023-04-26T04:33:41 | Shuai Li, Zhao Song, Yu Xia, Tong Yu, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are known for their exceptional performance in
natural language processing, making them highly effective in many human
life-related or even job-related tasks. The attention mechanism in the
Transformer architecture is a critical component of LLMs, as it allows the
model to selectively focus on specific input parts. The softmax unit, which is
a key part of the attention mechanism, normalizes the attention scores. Hence,
the performance of LLMs in various NLP tasks depends significantly on the
crucial role played by the attention mechanism with the softmax unit.
In-context learning, as one of the celebrated abilities of recent LLMs, is an
important concept in querying LLMs such as ChatGPT. Without further parameter
updates, Transformers can learn to predict based on few in-context examples.
However, the reason why Transformers becomes in-context learners is not well
understood. Recently, several works [ASA+22,GTLV22,ONR+22] have studied the
in-context learning from a mathematical perspective based on a linear
regression formulation $\min_x\| Ax - b \|_2$, which show Transformers'
capability of learning linear functions in context.
In this work, we study the in-context learning based on a softmax regression
formulation $\min_{x} \| \langle \exp(Ax), {\bf 1}_n \rangle^{-1} \exp(Ax) - b
\|_2$ of Transformer's attention mechanism. We show the upper bounds of the
data transformations induced by a single self-attention layer and by
gradient-descent on a $\ell_2$ regression loss for softmax prediction function,
which imply that when training self-attention-only Transformers for fundamental
regression tasks, the models learned by gradient-descent and Transformers show
great similarity. | [
0.0077339378,
-0.0033511312,
-0.000303807,
0.0442189611,
0.0281759501,
0.0207823552,
0.004567177,
0.0017137629,
-0.0384505391,
-0.0330387503,
-0.0777728185,
-0.029636845,
-0.0069072815,
-0.0155168446,
0.0623602085,
-0.0004775507,
0.0156474039,
-0.0012398569,
-0.0260487963,
-0.0078763058,
0.0160617456,
-0.0285333488,
0.0362446345,
0.0327073559,
-0.0255881473,
0.0044427845,
0.0281769894,
0.0218924023,
0.0152122723,
-0.0013863229,
0.0487116612,
0.0193609521,
0.0294024739,
-0.0021472878,
0.0000021521,
-0.018063508,
-0.0157459285,
-0.0125939362,
-0.0339279994,
-0.0490686409,
-0.003606125,
-0.0341308005,
-0.0120017398,
0.016651297,
-0.0106131267,
0.0112577518,
0.0713417679,
0.0888917893,
0.047877647,
0.0913209766,
-0.0134941358,
-0.0341032594,
0.0262779538,
-0.0525275692,
0.0275383107,
-0.0591831468,
0.0194995534,
-0.051710289,
-0.0558659472,
0.010953391,
-0.0326248482,
0.0403762423,
0.0135719609,
0.0347610638,
0.0273983832,
0.0555044115,
-0.049423717,
0.0157291479,
-0.0175759085,
0.0696122199,
-0.0710889623,
-0.0267551541,
0.0037436211,
0.0156389605,
-0.0215453822,
-0.026450729,
-0.0476726405,
0.0215755217,
0.0297725555,
0.0347088128,
-0.0099922149,
0.0365020372,
0.0207487345,
-0.0110867908,
-0.0313754268,
0.053613212,
-0.0184269287,
-0.0393751338,
0.0045848191,
0.0143833356,
-0.0241512768,
0.0132864853,
-0.005800359,
0.0506011471,
-0.0208545607,
0.0289879758,
-0.0327427089,
-0.02265759,
-0.0242634322,
-0.0961892605,
0.0511984378,
0.0299656689,
-0.0195697807,
0.0444329157,
-0.0060356716,
0.0944367424,
-0.0342863649,
0.0235348195,
-0.0266667958,
-0.0025476161,
-0.0179585516,
-0.0138351917,
-0.0907146484,
0.0024454752,
-0.0141792838,
0.0020155413,
-0.0330932066,
0.0222773496,
-0.0153752426,
-0.0207511578,
0.0333902612,
0.0172606222,
-0.1020376608,
-0.0150702102,
-0.017762959,
0.0531105548,
0.0088013113,
0.0009819267,
-0.0014542509,
-0.0381179675,
-0.0370593891,
0.0068057673,
0.0265584886,
-0.0276466087,
0.0017461695,
0.0899649113,
-0.008683891,
-0.0307222847,
-0.0164296608,
0.0089662531,
-0.0326417871,
-0.0403773114,
0.0240777675,
-0.0348508097,
0.0155573832,
0.000800092,
0.0152134402,
-0.0197547171,
0.015625421,
0.0392599069,
0.0023416765,
0.0568966083,
0.0583654195,
-0.0130199213,
0.0094980123,
-0.0013098558,
-0.0345887505,
0.0878317878,
-0.0206574071,
0.0059105665,
0.0139585407,
-0.0158617403,
0.0318979658,
0.0335627571,
0.0309000276,
-0.0081613548,
-0.0104248803,
0.0114112478,
0.0160438884,
0.0063565131,
0.0265897345,
0.0319993012,
-0.0133969281,
-0.011202489,
0.0721105188,
0.0311362892,
0.0616141483,
0.0745564476,
-0.011854439,
0.0095940605,
-0.0118265226,
-0.0017107687,
-0.0829426646,
0.0576103181,
0.0042729983,
-0.027284544,
-0.0194606651,
-0.0017259632,
-0.0608341023,
-0.0062354519,
0.0290390719,
-0.0214930419,
0.0139664728,
-0.0443141088,
0.0418789908,
0.012870945,
-0.0497271642,
0.096568726,
0.0323993079,
-0.008090768,
-0.0067688762,
-0.0588234365,
-0.0345892794,
-0.0384459943,
-0.0135527197,
-0.0476493873,
-0.0163596496,
-0.0055114538,
-0.0107900109,
0.0095697567,
0.0104532009,
0.0179572571,
-0.0230052751,
-0.0266493317,
0.0121243317,
-0.0285098832,
-0.0101142107,
-0.0284895506,
-0.0175627712,
0.0345096774,
0.0329639837,
-0.0095691346,
-0.0046447101,
0.0362065919,
-0.0181989856,
-0.057104297,
0.013207905,
0.032892745,
0.0394883715,
-0.0028788501,
0.01178829,
0.0210849904,
0.0281813536,
-0.0420381613,
-0.0272040237,
0.0215606447,
-0.0773051381,
-0.0423694067,
0.0211059134,
-0.0440729745,
0.0232633855,
0.0494266227,
-0.0112531157,
-0.0543478951,
0.0231555365,
-0.0516706891,
0.0477948152,
-0.0292436928,
0.0021082202,
0.0063133705,
0.0461681671,
-0.0575225726,
0.0583597794,
0.0309421141,
0.0215471275,
-0.0088635683,
-0.0045330245,
-0.00147483,
-0.0186649729,
-0.0394263938,
-0.0004277654,
-0.0444989763,
0.0319965668,
-0.0132211782,
-0.0148606719,
-0.0408525765,
-0.0207786635,
-0.0509660132,
-0.0113343606,
-0.0595524162,
0.0079786293,
0.044840578,
0.0046702209,
0.0240422748,
-0.0163338669,
-0.0503516868,
0.0442027636,
-0.0074132406,
-0.0025806406,
0.0306793265,
0.0099251522,
0.0269831624,
-0.0179687943,
-0.033073388,
-0.0015007228,
0.0401782319,
-0.0068163495,
-0.0433191694,
-0.0592105277,
0.0046369694,
0.0153825823,
0.0329428054,
-0.0339496657,
-0.0416580327,
-0.0293541569,
-0.0254482459,
0.0475720502,
0.1160810366,
0.032249406,
0.024577966,
0.0182866529,
0.0312258732,
-0.0150645468,
0.0348835699,
-0.0524737947,
-0.046180822,
-0.0580582023,
0.0176871587,
0.0494615957,
0.0695314258,
-0.0256608408,
-0.0212128572,
-0.0535218343,
-0.0037326589,
-0.0088020042,
0.0054964395,
0.004608931,
0.0284397397,
-0.0420834273,
-0.0037211434,
-0.0101651279,
-0.0242430344,
0.0306492168,
0.0016461379,
-0.0303678922,
-0.050225094,
-0.0191770047,
-0.0342984162,
0.0242346935,
0.0397281684,
0.0312285945,
0.0103238104,
-0.0374132097,
-0.0506673791,
-0.0117964186,
0.0138042234,
-0.0136564085,
0.0686025545,
0.0459676683,
0.013755003,
-0.0353482179,
-0.0215844214,
-0.019718172,
-0.0268227551,
-0.0163524766,
0.012755163,
0.0164255723,
-0.0065286681,
-0.0607219897,
0.0091715176,
0.0315319188,
0.0517652892,
-0.0382350758,
-0.0234941822,
-0.0125424583,
0.0263431203,
0.0281006414,
0.0438940004,
0.0128971925,
-0.0362521112,
0.0100539494,
0.0391107537,
0.0088538155,
-0.0164589211,
-0.0317086279,
-0.0187680367,
0.0415094644,
-0.0110145425,
-0.0102468403,
0.0233911406,
0.0813796222,
-0.0512417592,
-0.0303846467,
0.080262661,
-0.0246582925,
-0.0972393006,
0.0110925697,
-0.0023266743,
-0.0315974355,
0.0472918451,
0.0446834974,
-0.0155088836,
-0.053734988,
-0.0201132149,
0.0197389964,
0.0113984179,
-0.0103688445,
0.0033682964,
-0.068550393,
0.0181680322,
-0.0240725111,
-0.0485745668,
-0.0370397605,
-0.0126998983,
0.0413790271,
-0.0189980846,
-0.0052689486,
-0.0065860683,
-0.0326004513,
-0.0319595374,
0.0462158509,
0.0173804406,
-0.006217293,
0.0086626206,
-0.0537933297,
0.0401985757,
0.0629526153,
0.0424852148,
-0.0326591879,
-0.0156846326,
0.0647126883,
-0.0248987786,
0.0065577975,
0.0197445955,
0.0327601992,
-0.0197134335,
-0.027456902,
-0.0132422838,
0.052032996,
-0.0283990502,
0.0297870841,
-0.0231956765,
0.0850948766,
0.003519838,
-0.0327661522,
-0.012988939,
-0.0270069893,
0.0037816386,
0.050535854,
0.0068927826,
-0.0613021404,
-0.0267108213,
-0.0140907746,
0.0126093691,
0.0479620881,
-0.0616132766,
0.0057537304,
-0.0072450456,
-0.0423002467,
-0.0664822236,
-0.0006445524,
0.0053697377,
0.0462802015,
-0.0087709697,
-0.0413070731,
0.0487966537,
0.0150339929,
-0.0012983434,
0.028748516,
-0.0237389598,
0.0078813517,
-0.0373069495,
0.0243137572,
0.081813328,
-0.0199881736,
-0.003701238,
0.0067040594,
-0.0899374709,
-0.0359837338,
0.0144872842,
0.0088847987,
0.0111287218,
0.0250864085,
-0.012278338,
-0.0448732935,
0.0690423101,
0.0548250265,
-0.0258198921,
0.0351736322,
0.0498396419,
-0.0072387867,
-0.0041817566,
0.0544391237,
-0.0347186252,
0.0206479114,
0.0294715762,
0.0336205289,
-0.0084582008,
-0.0224165879,
0.0261008386,
-0.0301235188,
0.0555897951,
0.0401107222,
0.010277492,
-0.0141025037,
0.021743685,
0.050857354,
-0.018321218,
-0.0666406527,
-0.0383781083,
0.0132620241,
0.0141330846,
0.0208745785,
-0.0121372985,
0.0344474651,
-0.0098576155,
-0.0213626772,
0.0278948322,
-0.0120269274,
-0.0137419812,
0.0276169237,
0.057371445,
-0.0139426701,
-0.04968803,
0.0518430471,
0.0165475998,
0.0154764084,
0.0491083488,
0.043613743,
-0.0000864168,
-0.0502573699,
-0.0097568203,
-0.0697305948,
-0.0009004183,
-0.0290442016,
-0.0104066916,
0.0181127843,
-0.0415659659,
-0.0001912321,
-0.0154445143,
-0.0305246189,
-0.0114491079,
0.0223488249,
-0.0172700025,
-0.0013751317,
0.0612957366,
-0.0096626217,
0.0001296216,
-0.0162253715,
0.0748069137,
-0.0155703677,
-0.0023669049,
0.0091371918,
0.0030941416,
-0.0168222301,
0.0171909016,
0.0103724841,
0.0018548486,
0.0043295375,
0.0351843387,
0.0227843504,
-0.0716413558,
0.0263102632,
-0.0438747033,
-0.004539995,
-0.0557708703,
0.045459453,
0.0629982278,
0.0397720262,
-0.0154573908,
0.004355364,
-0.0070461011,
0.0077517475,
0.0216003619,
-0.0061350227,
-6.633418212e-33,
-0.018248383,
-0.0283370111,
-0.027643526,
0.0369125456,
-0.0215605479,
0.0227843411,
-0.0263482407,
0.0100649921,
-0.0331738144,
-0.0087569254,
-0.0515842773,
0.0178972669,
-0.0046796324,
0.0374138951,
-0.0325191952,
-0.0403224006,
0.0137722958,
-0.0330711938,
-0.0045173843,
0.0331938192,
0.0063167484,
0.0321523137,
0.099695161,
-0.0211300664,
-0.0218602978,
-0.0021625613,
-0.0080728065,
0.0419998765,
0.0128855594,
0.0474559143,
-0.0142488088,
0.0524976924,
0.0368510745,
-0.1075992957,
-0.0032676009,
0.0408532694,
-0.0978647619,
-0.0456781276,
-0.0225232262,
0.0072458833,
0.0127002168,
0.0103726778,
0.0999380276,
0.0066191098,
0.0072845179,
-0.0516990013,
0.0414183065,
-0.0125728315,
-0.0398962349,
-0.03380353,
-0.0350637063,
-0.0077704284,
0.0115185045,
-0.0145190973,
0.0027945896,
0.059736222,
-0.0073715355,
0.0481656455,
-0.0591023192,
0.0043059513,
-0.0135880914,
0.0619676001,
0.0362419672,
0.0456972793,
0.0106620863,
0.0099928528,
0.0014390337,
0.0437992327,
-0.061053738,
-0.1070233509,
0.0257730093,
0.0370082818,
0.0270187296,
-0.0023485175,
0.0496052429,
0.0074389083,
-0.0852002576,
-0.0163316075,
0.0001577986,
0.0615017712,
0.0854604244,
0.005991545,
-0.0134541038,
-0.0287969802,
-0.0219095927,
0.0157923773,
-0.0225381441,
-0.0019254092,
-0.0028893668,
0.0341143757,
-0.0088498695,
0.0381546095,
0.0097360592,
-0.0735048205,
0.0140701914,
0.0135222152,
-0.0079241209,
0.0007649229,
-0.0004261253,
0.000336506,
-0.0893525556,
0.0001892084,
-0.0339307636,
0.038966734,
0.0191651843,
-0.0010197142,
0.0543272607,
0.03569334,
-0.0591812916,
-0.043049477,
-0.0406299643,
0.0010399995,
-0.0217879433,
0.0917046964,
0.0348359346,
-0.0242136233,
-0.0095054554,
0.0698770434,
0.0185425729,
-0.0026450255,
-0.0249733347,
0.0288379956,
0.0121970996,
0.0086560128,
-0.0557016321,
-0.0186662003,
-0.0710285157,
0.0313752256,
0.0414180458,
-0.0720707402,
-0.0336824022,
-0.0048257736,
3.012e-7,
0.0154882781,
0.0228548348,
-0.0213966016,
0.0163527373,
0.0323138759,
0.0549432598,
-0.0132682184,
0.0692638755,
0.0381632447,
-0.0081838416,
0.0405547507,
0.0086861104,
0.0068428647,
-0.0159262754,
-0.0733432993,
-0.0143337799,
-0.0689283088,
0.0176308993,
0.0078663668,
0.0080616437,
0.0004856749,
0.1273151934,
-0.0099545475,
-0.0103020519,
0.0096270526,
-0.0108215241,
0.0575012416,
-0.0362254828,
0.0328773856,
0.0028238292,
0.0381357744,
0.0162317455,
-0.0464046597,
0.0067542726,
-0.0000754261,
0.0400557555,
0.0127887428,
0.0456628874,
-0.0054778266,
-0.0643853694,
0.0391942933,
0.0081876982,
0.0081937313,
-0.0471980348,
0.0549266934,
-0.1059217528,
-0.0614125691,
-0.0184065197,
-0.0051376759,
-0.0045009321,
-0.016490154,
-0.0201975778,
0.0211009756,
-0.0262688119,
0.011625018,
-0.0121089658,
-0.0234660078,
-0.0999809951,
-0.0203615054,
0.0053602946,
-0.049159307,
-0.0318470299,
-0.0641507581,
-0.0082997512,
0.0370786488,
-0.0069951909,
0.0304672979,
2.416267209e-34,
0.0137005309,
0.0007516105,
0.0247697923,
-0.0066396273,
-0.0172980558,
-0.0237485282,
0.0043031205,
-0.0023918711,
0.0419836305,
-0.0685246214,
-0.0218599532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13273v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13273v3 | From Association to Generation: Text-only Captioning by Unsupervised Cross-modal Mapping | 2023-04-26T04:06:20 | 2023-05-08T02:29:28 | Junyang Wang, Ming Yan, Yi Zhang, Jitao Sang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the development of Vision-Language Pre-training Models (VLPMs)
represented by CLIP and ALIGN, significant breakthroughs have been achieved for
association-based visual tasks such as image classification and image-text
retrieval by the zero-shot capability of CLIP without fine-tuning. However,
CLIP is hard to apply to generation-based tasks. This is due to the lack of
decoder architecture and pre-training tasks for generation. Although previous
works have created generation capacity for CLIP through additional language
models, a modality gap between the CLIP representations of different modalities
and the inability of CLIP to model the offset of this gap, which fails the
concept to transfer across modalities. To solve the problem, we try to map
images/videos to the language modality and generate captions from the language
modality. In this paper, we propose the K-nearest-neighbor Cross-modality
Mapping (Knight), a zero-shot method from association to generation. With
text-only unsupervised training, Knight achieves State-of-the-Art performance
in zero-shot methods for image captioning and video captioning. Our code is
available at https://github.com/junyangwang0410/Knight. | [
0.0038512065,
0.0505785309,
0.0282271076,
0.0211795308,
-0.0239388831,
-0.0017011815,
0.0364082418,
0.0147097558,
-0.0297463983,
-0.095103249,
-0.0607873723,
-0.0020733052,
0.0004411292,
0.0451234728,
0.0104307774,
-0.0450742021,
0.0303535666,
-0.0190683566,
-0.0328497179,
0.0026770027,
0.003945,
0.0241491031,
-0.020009784,
0.0224689599,
-0.0218645632,
-0.0038907432,
-0.0080321934,
-0.0359796695,
0.0314636901,
-0.018936025,
-0.0370666459,
0.0634937584,
0.0557494313,
0.0013568532,
0.0000018005,
-0.0020711794,
0.0151256761,
0.0204583593,
0.0413379557,
-0.0176255014,
0.0491668545,
-0.0877975374,
0.0075127804,
0.0039226483,
-0.025495382,
-0.040626049,
0.0780172646,
0.0243585072,
0.063797392,
0.0552525148,
-0.0422496051,
-0.0494400375,
0.0072034397,
-0.0530931093,
0.0572237857,
-0.0196025968,
-0.0172492918,
0.0321866535,
-0.0223857276,
0.0043433108,
-0.0318249129,
0.0482635163,
-0.0133032547,
-0.0336107351,
-0.0040601469,
0.0479114875,
-0.0208459161,
-0.0320941098,
-0.0244309902,
0.0834331736,
0.0182793848,
-0.0003400745,
-0.0094354143,
0.0178295076,
-0.0171065051,
0.0098808045,
-0.032100305,
0.0549420565,
0.0289605763,
0.0123645309,
-0.0210727584,
0.0381346531,
-0.0023215311,
-0.0069202357,
0.0107605094,
-0.0393106453,
0.0360035077,
0.0541743413,
-0.0636752546,
0.0070202197,
-0.000750543,
-0.0676606819,
0.0023034581,
0.0264688004,
0.0283865593,
-0.0147995353,
-0.0684840083,
-0.0142818484,
-0.0088692959,
-0.0057088067,
0.0491793975,
0.0404022597,
-0.0364847593,
0.0659742877,
-0.0615320355,
0.0274803061,
0.010107548,
0.0442602225,
-0.0344014354,
0.0099873096,
-0.0540658385,
0.0039313491,
-0.026439894,
-0.0108502926,
-0.0636328682,
-0.0361764356,
-0.0157017093,
0.0023542736,
-0.0049537523,
-0.0149665046,
-0.007318432,
0.0307868775,
-0.0228231512,
-0.0224978775,
-0.0214424003,
0.042214293,
-0.008417069,
0.0261990465,
-0.0212089308,
-0.0353183076,
-0.0190868508,
0.0485789701,
0.0500600636,
-0.0153022083,
-0.0073823505,
0.0608594641,
-0.0763243586,
-0.0351704322,
-0.0187031776,
-0.0297498591,
-0.0549461283,
-0.0404290855,
-0.0019984625,
-0.0486918464,
0.0318135209,
0.0056683072,
-0.0285954848,
-0.0271099191,
0.0263408106,
0.0099125607,
-0.0096210698,
0.084524259,
-0.0026298424,
0.0077289217,
0.0024746247,
0.0178212561,
0.0150957583,
0.0543864518,
0.0204394888,
0.0255831052,
-0.00476897,
0.0401916429,
0.0278461706,
0.0256058089,
0.0278241299,
0.0220687687,
-0.0580223687,
-0.0317914188,
0.0026306431,
-0.0124085005,
0.0429873019,
0.0350715518,
-0.0373127051,
-0.0046756705,
0.0403945148,
-0.0013560188,
-0.0095628072,
0.0664976016,
0.0604389049,
0.0293726921,
-0.0209550336,
-0.0287020393,
-0.0317401886,
0.0590035655,
0.0015065011,
0.0194764044,
0.0140434103,
0.0214496031,
-0.0712202042,
-0.0224191863,
0.0308844075,
-0.0357757993,
-0.0006476695,
-0.0383803882,
0.0478482656,
0.0321721472,
-0.0291272011,
0.0551367886,
-0.0058674715,
-0.0409692116,
0.0301182251,
-0.017049009,
-0.0217923243,
0.0024735176,
-0.0041809049,
0.0103056198,
-0.0548165254,
-0.000020682,
0.0088736946,
0.0443898551,
0.0120796952,
-0.019282015,
0.0239342302,
-0.0505307056,
-0.0623934418,
-0.0141416527,
-0.0081572663,
0.0462792628,
-0.0409825742,
0.0349956714,
0.069313772,
-0.0368572026,
0.0008316295,
0.0354870036,
0.040122278,
-0.0256930739,
-0.002508377,
0.0279510561,
-0.0123419454,
0.0299701151,
-0.0296009388,
0.0111354552,
-0.0018494294,
-0.0478966385,
0.0178543739,
0.0746675953,
-0.048212871,
-0.0764117613,
0.0143155186,
-0.0677246377,
0.019364655,
-0.0144263497,
-0.0109540671,
-0.0738083646,
0.0389412977,
-0.0054105436,
0.0298556909,
-0.0799948797,
-0.0104411701,
0.0104430504,
-0.0083818119,
0.0244589001,
0.0600618981,
0.0051944759,
-0.0244668256,
0.0410310179,
0.0149083408,
0.017543707,
0.0017546,
-0.0631277263,
-0.0205199178,
-0.0205620453,
0.0146356206,
0.045207534,
0.02656761,
-0.0346328616,
0.0023212924,
-0.1228432283,
-0.0133238016,
-0.0037367167,
0.0050024269,
-0.0080321729,
0.0136340111,
0.0145366741,
-0.0560273491,
-0.0619547255,
0.0153720621,
0.0480174609,
0.0097538019,
0.0225354638,
0.0554611087,
-0.0049066157,
0.00685634,
0.0254640076,
0.0312298145,
0.0394747443,
0.0037508996,
-0.0136204856,
-0.0271053072,
0.0651364401,
-0.0213682037,
0.0124072907,
-0.0174740907,
-0.0226664171,
-0.0041434057,
-0.0026584419,
0.0196702592,
0.0026341672,
0.0090690479,
-0.0014524895,
0.0087396549,
-0.0134728104,
-0.0329559669,
0.0064866841,
0.002466148,
-0.0655880943,
0.0126801152,
-0.0023071514,
-0.0245877374,
0.0551783703,
-0.0159645956,
0.0201775488,
-0.0839990452,
0.0196570009,
0.0198701285,
-0.0423940383,
-0.0341481678,
0.0507628433,
0.0044061537,
0.0139190061,
-0.0410074331,
-0.0596002936,
-0.004470937,
-0.0425062962,
-0.021448642,
-0.0043999259,
0.0226510391,
-0.0020469602,
0.0945788473,
-0.00535753,
0.0507290736,
0.0081068091,
-0.0316080302,
-0.0240291506,
-0.0248567015,
0.0043340251,
-0.0025889312,
0.0455278084,
-0.0429753922,
0.0188806765,
-0.0519795306,
-0.0092815543,
-0.0224132463,
-0.0384508073,
-0.0297041088,
-0.0040343045,
-0.040281944,
0.001495054,
-0.0362362154,
0.0371803604,
0.0241832808,
0.0303358138,
-0.0287452918,
0.0107788006,
-0.0160572361,
0.0482783988,
0.0265488811,
0.0105734449,
-0.0956213102,
-0.0127794798,
-0.0027721191,
0.0380290002,
0.0168803371,
0.0363379419,
-0.0294589251,
0.0217610598,
0.0277106892,
0.0426130109,
-0.0242195744,
0.0296753384,
0.0502967276,
-0.0205562189,
-0.005383377,
0.078848511,
0.0111542633,
-0.0687392652,
-0.0419093147,
0.020784989,
0.0228560995,
0.0259338804,
0.0109878657,
-0.1137965173,
-0.0626903176,
-0.0442338586,
-0.0295948461,
0.0302462857,
0.0167748518,
-0.0564200729,
-0.0846845284,
0.0310027637,
0.0245751627,
-0.06348674,
-0.0563719347,
-0.0020081829,
-0.002358062,
-0.0058903741,
-0.0436305478,
-0.021536544,
-0.0019939328,
0.0071886615,
0.0225805622,
0.0700799972,
-0.0850643441,
-0.0168081317,
-0.045803789,
0.0403375253,
0.0415530205,
0.026092995,
-0.0043509323,
-0.0206914097,
-0.0439471975,
-0.0005415489,
0.0235275663,
0.010515078,
0.0470353663,
-0.0315329321,
-0.0282534268,
0.0254607573,
0.0105295852,
-0.0123653617,
-0.0270613655,
-0.009106189,
0.0138898073,
-0.0046742293,
0.0299428646,
-0.0107991518,
0.0358017422,
0.0259006042,
0.0489296764,
0.0055017173,
-0.0072963475,
-0.0064350846,
-0.0005480873,
0.0035807309,
-0.0721246079,
-0.0387158431,
-0.0097757671,
-0.0020164067,
-0.0008326391,
-0.0587937757,
-0.0193885118,
0.0591136068,
0.0471315011,
0.0144817624,
-0.0111772679,
-0.0126940599,
0.0101663135,
-0.0673831776,
0.031636741,
-0.0539974235,
0.0025539086,
-0.0394931436,
-0.0172969531,
0.0761666521,
-0.0593732893,
-0.0052729291,
-0.0066272616,
-0.0588132702,
-0.0313571505,
-0.0644062012,
0.0806601048,
0.008871601,
0.061274603,
0.0252799168,
-0.0090971105,
0.0582220294,
0.0643343925,
0.0127053801,
-0.0004895758,
0.0255198739,
-0.0407356508,
-0.0370062105,
0.0134375188,
-0.0320933275,
0.0326801687,
0.0044572861,
0.0439727381,
-0.0015944722,
-0.0178041793,
0.0162656084,
-0.040961422,
0.0070844572,
-0.053756021,
0.0388209037,
-0.0224477928,
-0.0255599245,
-0.0131311724,
-0.0096805245,
-0.0613122322,
0.0111901928,
0.0246333499,
0.0136637678,
0.0325511023,
0.0149544468,
-0.0274144523,
0.0234040655,
0.0106664319,
0.0276589487,
0.0232728776,
-0.0203904994,
-0.0080938693,
0.0321884826,
-0.0129065812,
-0.0013067988,
0.0068525416,
0.0229040198,
-0.0575947762,
0.0590996481,
0.003802459,
-0.0201733261,
-0.0277755968,
0.0547342934,
0.0159365516,
0.0316722989,
-0.065245226,
0.0345549174,
0.0454408601,
-0.0408874303,
0.0299132895,
-0.0112655116,
-0.0070763817,
-0.0037980673,
0.057878416,
-0.0129922042,
-0.054409761,
0.0351110138,
0.0009334958,
0.0002785771,
0.0064033763,
0.0809521899,
-0.0166522041,
0.02108231,
0.0085607776,
-0.0102835223,
-0.0313721448,
0.0027751243,
0.0412755348,
-0.0197268892,
-0.0239767917,
0.0173141193,
-0.0157678407,
-0.0435615182,
0.0284667276,
-0.0004821563,
-0.0153060928,
0.0383895561,
0.062150117,
0.0181795117,
0.0129119866,
0.0097742705,
-0.0264396016,
-0.0070773726,
-0.0086907819,
0.0226639528,
-0.0045436411,
-5.317266779e-33,
-0.0568737686,
-0.0052836877,
0.0295829792,
-0.0340441167,
-0.0371763743,
0.0225453563,
-0.04578612,
0.0450490899,
-0.0081947269,
0.0054630395,
0.038338393,
-0.0477069356,
0.0216376577,
0.0619228669,
0.0156238601,
0.0100739878,
0.0405332744,
-0.0211448278,
-0.0041592927,
0.0380639359,
0.0013936484,
-0.0110194217,
0.0370904505,
-0.0490165055,
-0.0098984567,
-0.0110940095,
-0.0363625251,
-0.0045490358,
0.0727480873,
0.0474625528,
-0.0139194801,
0.0063246125,
0.0110239014,
-0.0104188537,
-0.009122422,
0.0008354185,
-0.044067841,
0.0000077964,
0.0230347738,
0.0162355471,
-0.0368191078,
-0.0205669813,
-0.0172306057,
-0.0388563164,
-0.0084630912,
-0.0104442844,
0.0395107307,
-0.0276596788,
0.015824182,
-0.0023515981,
-0.0623868965,
0.0113236485,
-0.0165537223,
-0.076083079,
0.078008391,
0.0476942658,
0.0434523262,
-0.0246114545,
-0.032340765,
0.0686468408,
0.0044211103,
0.0463501401,
0.1047236547,
0.0560345054,
-0.0081305755,
0.0469622314,
-0.0001035167,
-0.0550382882,
-0.0346138403,
0.0207082909,
0.0114288125,
0.0699308664,
-0.0217649769,
0.0808397159,
0.0301043093,
0.0052303649,
-0.0108445557,
0.0540010892,
-0.0602097735,
0.0011510968,
0.0258619692,
0.0165597759,
0.0312918611,
0.0108033204,
-0.0572918728,
-0.0543555059,
-0.0438511409,
-0.0407698043,
0.0261216685,
0.0453764126,
-0.0419067107,
0.0312680304,
0.1013340354,
0.0031195774,
0.0247753747,
0.02304128,
-0.0063570281,
0.0766280964,
-0.0257761199,
-0.0057891938,
-0.0435963683,
-0.059859585,
0.0764496997,
-0.0114528872,
0.017623825,
0.0194080397,
0.0442419238,
0.0441581495,
-0.0264860932,
-0.0113323424,
-0.0252353661,
-0.0033016582,
-0.0233235508,
0.0510063283,
0.0121762296,
0.0252808612,
-0.0626513362,
0.0173774045,
-0.0225995854,
0.0293492172,
-0.0053975051,
-0.0412233844,
0.0051226639,
0.0187804513,
-0.0165552963,
0.0513754487,
-0.0475977659,
-0.0297395419,
0.0014801583,
-0.0369394459,
-0.0263209455,
0.0340706259,
2.457e-7,
0.0075387256,
-0.0120413229,
0.0458973683,
-0.0133716427,
0.0045720963,
0.0645970255,
0.0022079484,
0.0471680649,
0.0098211132,
-0.0246779881,
0.0430419408,
0.0050025955,
0.0200511999,
-0.0244541299,
-0.0240031965,
0.0635192618,
-0.0141948247,
-0.0120821325,
-0.0109698838,
-0.0067415209,
0.0530473143,
0.0881561339,
-0.0536549203,
0.0003980614,
0.0177993942,
-0.0647595152,
0.1158703491,
-0.0055418923,
-0.0195848625,
0.0055174883,
-0.0407311134,
0.0242690165,
-0.0465738885,
0.0111222807,
-0.0244734678,
0.0058164936,
0.0481849164,
0.0291718431,
-0.0269697271,
-0.0101744393,
-0.0237273723,
0.0684471726,
-0.0088051287,
0.0032429593,
0.0778315887,
-0.0632764921,
-0.017613925,
-0.044501029,
-0.0118583031,
0.0573102236,
-0.0242788978,
-0.0406209044,
-0.0527798384,
0.0380061232,
0.0707437694,
0.0059504723,
-0.0468726493,
-0.0657698587,
-0.0259552058,
-0.0368704312,
-0.0312248319,
0.0154062994,
-0.0606300645,
-0.0190377831,
0.0499642938,
-0.011549565,
-0.0264483392,
1.629935645e-34,
-0.0035244874,
-0.0136868842,
-0.0199883822,
-0.0406976677,
-0.0095114289,
0.0136904838,
-0.0281689744,
0.0111872032,
-0.0072833234,
-0.0543360859,
-0.0480421595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13734v2 | The Internal State of an LLM Knows When It's Lying | 2023-04-26T02:49:38 | 2023-10-17T09:34:30 | Amos Azaria, Tom Mitchell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance in
various tasks, one of their most prominent drawbacks is generating inaccurate
or false information with a confident tone. In this paper, we provide evidence
that the LLM's internal state can be used to reveal the truthfulness of
statements. This includes both statements provided to the LLM, and statements
that the LLM itself generates. Our approach is to train a classifier that
outputs the probability that a statement is truthful, based on the hidden layer
activations of the LLM as it reads or generates the statement. Experiments
demonstrate that given a set of test sentences, of which half are true and half
false, our trained classifier achieves an average of 71\% to 83\% accuracy
labeling which sentences are true versus false, depending on the LLM base
model. Furthermore, we explore the relationship between our classifier's
performance and approaches based on the probability assigned to the sentence by
the LLM. We show that while LLM-assigned sentence probability is related to
sentence truthfulness, this probability is also dependent on sentence length
and the frequencies of words in the sentence, resulting in our trained
classifier providing a more reliable approach to detecting truthfulness,
highlighting its potential to enhance the reliability of LLM-generated content
and its practical applicability in real-world scenarios. | [
0.0535071418,
0.0506816059,
-0.0357906669,
0.0556457378,
-0.0763162673,
0.0083584664,
0.0006535456,
-0.0001342476,
0.027708536,
-0.0496566445,
-0.0182735808,
-0.0092399931,
0.0319363438,
0.0255034491,
0.0225287806,
0.0328754261,
0.0690606311,
0.015114625,
0.0422462001,
-0.0096187498,
0.0156888869,
0.0250351299,
-0.0028130305,
0.0208720099,
-0.0554932952,
0.0153832855,
-0.0073507177,
0.0005700957,
0.0166255236,
-0.0051091043,
0.0094826622,
0.0257723499,
-0.001169463,
0.0634934455,
0.0000018333,
-0.0274939016,
-0.0162860807,
-0.0328414217,
-0.0389167815,
0.0023397959,
0.0072464012,
-0.0458855592,
-0.0033065351,
0.0101861814,
-0.0540125445,
0.0291763693,
0.0250901543,
0.0597784184,
0.0386735685,
0.0907238871,
0.014337006,
0.0123343756,
0.0534853116,
0.0060917935,
0.0160106122,
-0.0136839328,
0.0226935521,
0.0034458984,
-0.054136496,
-0.0096263085,
0.0145120118,
0.0327437297,
0.0349362381,
-0.0195018686,
-0.0072196345,
0.0573316179,
-0.0197588783,
-0.0111840842,
-0.0148461703,
0.0188634843,
-0.0105386823,
-0.0467052162,
0.0191955976,
-0.0343909748,
-0.0240035951,
-0.0200072546,
0.0317045599,
0.0464280136,
-0.0249627605,
0.0359234177,
0.0067659696,
0.0245774258,
0.0419119857,
0.0134984599,
0.0227491297,
0.1023755968,
-0.0248176493,
-0.0386344455,
-0.0014044291,
0.0029263818,
0.0212705061,
-0.0741099864,
0.0061712763,
0.0284905713,
0.0111696357,
0.057394512,
-0.0603670999,
0.017922502,
0.070543088,
-0.0600655377,
0.0208558217,
0.0088090478,
-0.0289172586,
0.0301096998,
-0.0389450155,
0.0489843786,
-0.0056254477,
0.041978173,
-0.0148477089,
-0.0079214685,
0.0201076698,
-0.0265945904,
0.0286190212,
0.0272899233,
0.0184890367,
-0.0151860686,
-0.0774058104,
-0.0010204884,
-0.0149855297,
0.0299881641,
-0.0226391237,
0.0132239508,
-0.0111046955,
-0.0128849521,
-0.0708561763,
0.001476811,
0.0219850689,
0.0627218783,
0.0015510401,
-0.0839210451,
0.0042806962,
0.0259892493,
-0.0005840985,
0.0097132185,
-0.0064041833,
0.0194045678,
-0.0098369503,
-0.0257568602,
-0.0808523595,
-0.0417503901,
-0.0513147675,
-0.0838631392,
-0.0207874533,
-0.0627335757,
0.0214199722,
-0.0176350418,
-0.0019632936,
-0.0015775762,
0.0341710113,
0.0287596192,
0.0064491974,
0.0492725112,
0.0075350292,
0.0066536865,
0.0249775462,
0.006550265,
0.0076587764,
0.0348386541,
0.0562147796,
0.064859055,
0.0449851938,
0.0163022168,
0.0202116556,
0.0067739594,
0.0418230519,
0.0094779823,
-0.0026632471,
-0.0139687052,
-0.0210109185,
0.0246883221,
0.0190620665,
0.0592010468,
-0.0174692422,
-0.0430498309,
0.1097951978,
-0.0000674488,
0.0218313895,
-0.0278231204,
0.0193319246,
0.0232193694,
0.0333876461,
0.0467731096,
-0.0499655493,
0.0452721789,
-0.0480669253,
0.0178972092,
0.0313171372,
-0.004063752,
0.0171755198,
-0.0638617054,
-0.0276012886,
-0.0437330008,
-0.0067330771,
0.0090974867,
-0.005897684,
-0.0147247408,
-0.0331168547,
0.0663361028,
0.0229247268,
-0.0286571383,
0.0033014871,
-0.0847539529,
0.0499161668,
0.0410687439,
0.0180056244,
0.0081352759,
-0.002644737,
-0.0188056026,
-0.0227463339,
0.0584932566,
0.0540721714,
0.0148559045,
0.022571208,
-0.0084619876,
0.0193783212,
-0.0240518358,
0.0324034318,
0.0158744864,
0.0007599276,
0.0249003507,
0.0305679105,
-0.0536989048,
-0.0104390346,
0.0555447042,
-0.0045983237,
-0.014153216,
0.0507798046,
0.0103554316,
0.0167859197,
-0.022123117,
-0.0192818716,
0.0167600811,
0.0195119977,
-0.0029154778,
-0.0490209535,
-0.0391105525,
-0.0542954206,
-0.0214976929,
0.0274732597,
-0.0070539168,
0.0041338634,
0.0435364768,
-0.0353754908,
-0.0303093046,
-0.0347752124,
-0.0412806757,
-0.0041351849,
-0.0705966875,
0.0082699442,
0.0089341961,
0.0237467829,
-0.0044858223,
0.0560021065,
-0.0359415635,
0.0194539409,
-0.0397441164,
-0.0237496216,
0.0353063531,
-0.0277402438,
0.0237926487,
-0.0363094062,
0.0062057255,
0.0302208252,
0.0327089988,
0.0118728084,
-0.0209681261,
-0.0467423722,
-0.0625058785,
-0.0096833948,
0.0018098231,
-0.0188487414,
0.0163734891,
-0.0596665218,
0.0012655882,
0.0117173549,
-0.0565855578,
0.0139652072,
0.0421899222,
-0.0160751473,
0.0621247552,
-0.0237087011,
0.0228812043,
-0.0472029597,
0.0311738215,
-0.0138156209,
0.008192814,
0.0026529972,
-0.0380361341,
-0.0577575453,
0.0360250287,
-0.0541583896,
0.0184700359,
-0.0135197649,
-0.0402162969,
-0.0172838848,
0.0334089957,
-0.0441000909,
0.076615721,
0.0426551327,
-0.0061473022,
0.0775535181,
0.0223645158,
-0.0400506742,
0.0136696398,
-0.0112265786,
0.0172770265,
-0.040711645,
-0.0922501683,
0.0208964907,
0.0316729657,
0.0720836967,
0.0039341841,
0.0004593882,
-0.0067166658,
0.0111972531,
-0.065087162,
0.0388042554,
-0.0191880893,
-0.0342080668,
0.0701401681,
-0.002013468,
-0.0816504583,
0.0708059445,
-0.0649908185,
0.0449165255,
0.0043309685,
-0.0449570306,
-0.0207860377,
0.0323489234,
-0.0050510098,
-0.0019150778,
0.0388176292,
0.0153208394,
-0.0145298969,
-0.0399182402,
0.0106055858,
-0.0504022725,
0.0245165918,
-0.0391598307,
0.0045034876,
0.0075636851,
-0.0407503322,
-0.0787066743,
-0.0522415973,
-0.0425388888,
-0.0201940648,
-0.0647124201,
-0.0076546227,
-0.0406227484,
-0.0523992665,
0.0211091302,
0.0339322276,
-0.0407032929,
0.004079374,
-0.0172753371,
0.0357199796,
0.0734998584,
0.0135510694,
0.0608491749,
-0.0192864835,
-0.012888955,
0.0659333989,
-0.0565546229,
0.1001716405,
-0.0330899954,
-0.0688624829,
-0.0043462366,
0.0131491488,
-0.0245036073,
0.0157721378,
-0.0052948953,
-0.0439833514,
0.0055317278,
0.1133387163,
0.0151268486,
0.0048126699,
0.0085701672,
0.0071468968,
-0.0078585725,
-0.0088438047,
0.0200864635,
-0.0907500014,
-0.012205204,
-0.0094288914,
-0.0227195881,
-0.076178357,
0.0003394184,
-0.0271543227,
-0.0972923636,
0.0484990589,
-0.0035177991,
0.0248786751,
-0.0364062972,
-0.0134077435,
-0.0231865831,
0.0400928706,
0.0390872173,
-0.0147477789,
0.042351421,
-0.0234049205,
0.002368262,
-0.0401985422,
-0.0337343104,
0.0311243292,
-0.0079435278,
0.0575957522,
0.0495075472,
0.0800933242,
-0.0241163541,
-0.075983718,
0.0230500996,
0.0267812032,
-0.0105248587,
0.0045550736,
0.0313982777,
-0.0195473619,
0.0128365112,
0.0005675769,
-0.0029519859,
0.0176535454,
-0.0041260901,
-0.0056081181,
0.0375878289,
-0.0178004447,
-0.0638447776,
-0.0046031354,
0.039209839,
0.0148026887,
0.0604314432,
0.0203818399,
0.0139363892,
-0.0288852751,
-0.0335185416,
0.0082277125,
-0.0227915905,
-0.0301939361,
0.0337529331,
0.0360751189,
0.0268834289,
-0.0717992038,
0.0017621596,
-0.026101701,
0.0141748218,
-0.0295365565,
-0.0170026887,
0.0308840834,
-0.0223783776,
-0.0420484059,
-0.0361517929,
-0.0454125814,
0.0456043035,
0.0020066365,
0.0020872464,
0.0519111566,
-0.0351406373,
0.0161181204,
0.0086609274,
-0.089787215,
-0.0492674485,
-0.0028014716,
0.0268817469,
0.0184899364,
0.026590921,
-0.0161739364,
-0.0376649722,
0.0554453097,
0.0421975479,
-0.0825063586,
0.0567522272,
0.0284813624,
0.0320398323,
0.0017305934,
0.0281236209,
-0.0483956151,
-0.0054606241,
0.0451821052,
-0.0032695495,
-0.0300353076,
-0.0581857748,
0.0359856896,
0.0209407769,
0.0304154977,
0.0167647935,
0.0390079133,
-0.0310583767,
0.0238330066,
-0.0098848268,
-0.011252638,
-0.0024570045,
0.016361773,
0.0367173888,
0.0108616054,
-0.0315377116,
-0.0197076406,
-0.0203855522,
0.0120028947,
-0.0129045742,
-0.0531806871,
0.0146238729,
-0.0031204524,
-0.0119637689,
-0.0313463584,
-0.0650388375,
0.0428730324,
-0.0003866544,
0.05584969,
0.0354638398,
0.0082868682,
0.0119468328,
-0.0227746107,
-0.0232554525,
-0.0196934473,
-0.0652828664,
-0.0026016012,
-0.0217358414,
0.032137081,
0.0255667381,
0.0310608,
0.0196283888,
-0.0639386252,
-0.0146658476,
-0.0242796764,
0.0230894294,
-0.0006944326,
-0.0426314138,
0.0266190153,
-0.0198379718,
-0.0432074778,
0.0196636897,
0.0377911702,
0.0277417097,
0.0458700769,
0.0122410357,
-0.0164930169,
-0.0509499125,
-0.0136055388,
-0.0015910172,
0.03317184,
-0.0143595366,
0.015360388,
-0.0502362996,
-0.0662276596,
0.0851937681,
0.0312651359,
0.0580328144,
-0.0422324203,
-0.0255516898,
0.0526114926,
0.0205913018,
-0.01908076,
-0.0738554969,
0.0010978031,
0.0337833874,
0.0105789509,
-0.0323143229,
-6.240008171e-33,
-0.0168888289,
-0.0664388761,
0.0041810162,
0.0183959231,
0.0081905434,
0.0428337976,
0.0020692309,
-0.0181838796,
-0.0334499404,
0.0345861502,
0.0021989949,
0.0405467041,
0.0183389876,
0.0134611195,
-0.0227069724,
-0.0067096227,
0.0310478024,
-0.0044801454,
-0.0346632749,
-0.0168186892,
0.0426957048,
-0.009083678,
0.0734879822,
-0.0816534311,
0.0101736235,
0.0103573939,
-0.0514870659,
0.0432382673,
-0.0756679997,
0.0353661776,
-0.0304283407,
0.0496292002,
0.0161852092,
0.0017256001,
0.019557178,
-0.0043505416,
-0.0224097185,
-0.0109421061,
0.0406213962,
0.0089042112,
-0.0381505936,
-0.0153197739,
0.0292150788,
-0.0285321604,
-0.0233061761,
-0.0225256048,
0.0223842394,
-0.0109386714,
-0.0153528415,
-0.0764007866,
-0.0552079678,
0.024420457,
0.0337084197,
-0.0255032908,
-0.0286758915,
0.0076268832,
-0.0109417532,
0.0088123977,
-0.0920915529,
0.0150434216,
-0.0100628575,
0.0222399253,
0.0371441953,
-0.0106421541,
-0.0167531017,
0.0934361815,
0.0274829473,
0.0423082486,
-0.0457914919,
0.0041772891,
0.0426381305,
-0.0024824622,
0.0472903028,
0.0683357939,
0.0041536014,
-0.0506039895,
-0.0536679663,
-0.0104294419,
0.0680340379,
-0.032332886,
0.0352024399,
-0.0317503735,
-0.0193339549,
-0.0093711084,
-0.04910478,
0.0246281698,
-0.0312891267,
0.0120888557,
0.0181996599,
0.0285801049,
0.0006830956,
-0.031925343,
-0.014102621,
-0.0400631577,
-0.0070959181,
0.0043972633,
-0.0209262818,
-0.0122183748,
-0.0025820367,
0.0195651539,
-0.0655707791,
0.0113297766,
-0.0180348475,
0.0029737153,
0.0003766264,
0.0018532897,
0.0629874468,
0.0195802655,
-0.0596464016,
0.0309244823,
-0.0143554602,
0.0277811624,
0.0156147089,
-0.048762098,
0.0026901087,
-0.0150382118,
-0.0330526941,
0.0133429151,
-0.0352082253,
0.0020422013,
-0.046168834,
0.0301330723,
-0.0211720038,
0.066285111,
-0.0446497835,
0.0006092353,
-0.039592579,
0.0170512833,
-0.0093766265,
-0.0404256955,
0.0116887586,
0.0158296134,
2.629e-7,
-0.0072598406,
0.0182966143,
-0.0104078557,
0.0492016263,
0.0180228259,
0.0517537668,
-0.0091363173,
0.033081051,
0.0065793474,
-0.0906063393,
-0.0303398259,
0.0030108003,
0.0729234442,
0.0401742831,
-0.0636517629,
0.0640029907,
-0.0515656695,
-0.0148635432,
-0.0113671646,
-0.0020527842,
0.0314837433,
0.0822553113,
0.0500508919,
-0.0219768099,
0.0230957698,
-0.0434791967,
0.0532379523,
0.025384808,
-0.0243299417,
0.0073392489,
0.0397183448,
-0.0077065155,
-0.0019624901,
0.0155886794,
-0.0061033345,
0.0139327133,
-0.0611529127,
0.0560902134,
-0.0083830189,
-0.0525451005,
-0.0393976569,
-0.0308857746,
0.0041121235,
-0.0556194298,
0.0546012931,
-0.0093769552,
-0.0193454567,
-0.0868071467,
0.0349150561,
-0.0007261632,
0.0245458577,
-0.0145516694,
-0.0366900675,
0.0310225263,
0.0077342908,
-0.00344249,
-0.008390341,
-0.0435904227,
-0.0472965166,
-0.0362036787,
-0.0356110111,
-0.0464765429,
-0.0018923983,
0.0346181355,
0.0385968462,
-0.0612189882,
0.0276210736,
2.120564488e-34,
0.0199942701,
-0.0116509805,
-0.0133006694,
0.0163553879,
0.0493561104,
0.0326177143,
-0.0206350833,
0.0061494564,
0.0307556316,
-0.0133360429,
-0.0204841886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13250v1 | Exploring the Curious Case of Code Prompts | 2023-04-26T02:37:52 | 2023-04-26T02:37:52 | Li Zhang, Liam Dugan, Hainiu Xu, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has shown that prompting language models with code-like
representations of natural language leads to performance improvements on
structured reasoning tasks. However, such tasks comprise only a small subset of
all natural language tasks. In our work, we seek to answer whether or not
code-prompting is the preferred way of interacting with language models in
general. We compare code and text prompts across three popular GPT models
(davinci, code-davinci-002, and text-davinci-002) on a broader selection of
tasks (e.g., QA, sentiment, summarization) and find that with few exceptions,
code prompts do not consistently outperform text prompts. Furthermore, we show
that the style of code prompt has a large effect on performance for some but
not all tasks and that fine-tuning on text instructions leads to better
relative performance of code prompts. | [
0.0340491012,
0.0356960557,
-0.0294538494,
0.0183620285,
-0.0421387702,
0.0406698696,
0.0186317116,
0.0038963528,
0.0405654609,
-0.0278707314,
-0.022220483,
-0.0067703216,
0.0019064018,
0.0609718822,
0.0420669653,
-0.0634828582,
0.0306411088,
-0.0581584163,
0.0591444075,
-0.0009479679,
0.0231438335,
0.0169256497,
-0.008538424,
0.0399222858,
0.0209043603,
-0.0516904555,
-0.0142548922,
-0.0026463862,
-0.014398464,
-0.0410105921,
-0.0015278268,
0.0631447062,
0.003001366,
-0.010311055,
0.0000021704,
-0.0174946543,
0.0421601161,
-0.040906325,
-0.0374698602,
0.0258227773,
0.0144828279,
-0.0247682892,
0.0145742409,
0.0292737614,
-0.055600211,
-0.0480769761,
0.0542578287,
0.0188062247,
0.0379131436,
0.0643966869,
-0.0050638961,
0.0054811044,
0.0243386906,
-0.0373487286,
0.0286371466,
-0.0192004144,
-0.0393778011,
0.0257255323,
0.0540939495,
0.0705245435,
0.0123087605,
0.0335887335,
0.0442186669,
0.0049624629,
0.0105784321,
0.0590181239,
-0.0510999374,
-0.0049250815,
-0.0341232084,
0.0443960987,
0.0266514905,
-0.0056393193,
-0.0068641165,
-0.0189580414,
0.0146509577,
-0.0324977972,
-0.0466946512,
0.0365295671,
-0.0031184796,
0.0182770807,
0.0250933059,
-0.0001866427,
0.0398713574,
-0.0030428509,
-0.0011566881,
0.0677968934,
0.0012325584,
-0.0158840939,
0.0098192906,
0.019261837,
-0.0276156459,
-0.1017481089,
-0.0309656225,
0.0228661261,
-0.0340149589,
0.0073148971,
-0.0275615919,
0.0266121905,
0.006727057,
0.0250680391,
0.0224607512,
0.0582074448,
-0.0108797271,
0.0425590649,
-0.0432494879,
0.0813711584,
-0.0139599834,
0.0088221077,
0.0037184667,
-0.0008600135,
-0.0603482835,
-0.046940662,
-0.0320428796,
0.0295754112,
-0.0023110823,
-0.0119424397,
0.0091631394,
0.0579043776,
-0.008793544,
0.0260650907,
0.0053339484,
-0.0216562096,
0.006313954,
0.0170909595,
-0.0295740366,
-0.0237852205,
-0.0672255084,
-0.00161382,
0.0301454123,
-0.0851541981,
-0.0233050101,
-0.0036342379,
-0.0140000209,
-0.0272680577,
-0.0118136071,
0.0168002695,
0.0251253154,
-0.0102178836,
-0.0154209314,
-0.0213599689,
-0.018606402,
-0.0404909588,
-0.018796267,
-0.0631856471,
-0.0003169965,
0.0482882559,
-0.0018996985,
-0.0258027073,
-0.0069277058,
0.0288009103,
-0.0318404138,
0.0745080933,
-0.0455342345,
-0.0018685223,
-0.003529042,
0.0123798009,
-0.0319013968,
0.0446036756,
0.0156083442,
0.022468131,
-0.009135983,
-0.0241439454,
0.007698271,
0.0139410477,
-0.008205995,
0.0103161074,
-0.0313608944,
0.020815311,
0.0143925725,
-0.0246830322,
0.0286530331,
0.0534851924,
-0.0231494233,
0.0344326235,
0.0371969528,
0.0392803587,
-0.013839622,
-0.008725292,
0.0194991063,
-0.0094479807,
0.0079891235,
0.0206120554,
-0.0858975798,
0.0457472689,
-0.0402506106,
0.0265880413,
0.0186366756,
-0.0314066745,
-0.0221873932,
-0.0423918366,
-0.0249349922,
0.0012887688,
0.0340297557,
0.0262773335,
-0.0070262011,
-0.0002363045,
-0.041822955,
-0.0281101968,
0.0125132212,
-0.0426273309,
-0.0327459499,
-0.073602505,
0.0427514613,
0.0790557638,
0.037030708,
-0.0091396961,
-0.0059919925,
-0.0108506847,
0.002421306,
0.0251519382,
0.0552110299,
0.0014192607,
-0.0292743035,
-0.020103693,
-0.0128330402,
-0.0569050014,
0.013556635,
0.0044978634,
0.0225955863,
0.0046204175,
0.0134976786,
0.0260331165,
-0.0303458311,
-0.0009283994,
0.0142654311,
-0.0249264278,
-0.0237689279,
-0.0162145961,
-0.0021328968,
0.0172205884,
-0.0049690348,
0.0399928801,
-0.0104186842,
-0.0258104708,
-0.0228781756,
-0.0304377489,
-0.0735266805,
-0.0592100359,
-0.0028007939,
0.0093123782,
-0.0265214052,
0.019070264,
-0.0135797104,
-0.0366883613,
0.0070166527,
-0.0387254059,
0.0442415923,
-0.0242659207,
-0.0002782673,
0.0054010316,
-0.02472114,
-0.0223093648,
0.084259145,
0.016601406,
0.0255401041,
0.0570191778,
0.053147383,
0.0039852224,
-0.0297180451,
0.0038157892,
0.0524764135,
0.0285388641,
-0.0111790141,
0.0396683924,
0.0084069474,
-0.0422995053,
-0.0187316202,
-0.1099405885,
-0.0099197039,
-0.0392155312,
-0.0044690049,
0.0346647315,
0.0203298237,
-0.0149736246,
-0.0034069249,
-0.0786340684,
-0.034817718,
0.0077832756,
0.0452285409,
0.0382941701,
-0.0097551672,
0.0022220877,
-0.0438589007,
-0.0147533836,
-0.0366940312,
0.0101556862,
0.0031009298,
-0.0086307498,
-0.0477687307,
0.0899179652,
-0.0260247923,
-0.004101424,
-0.0265358705,
-0.0080186101,
0.0478421822,
-0.0372839235,
0.11096894,
0.0651579648,
-0.0219952967,
0.0044713039,
0.0476405732,
0.0039219414,
-0.0601515882,
0.0160405207,
0.0171717294,
-0.0146319009,
0.0101054031,
-0.05535179,
0.0269375388,
0.0608715862,
0.0366941057,
0.0152525883,
-0.08317893,
0.0493122414,
-0.0112242438,
0.0156135093,
-0.0146345142,
-0.0403465778,
-0.00351539,
0.0902765393,
-0.0223425366,
-0.0903904438,
0.0812420174,
-0.0305100642,
-0.0305070188,
-0.0313413143,
-0.0100149428,
-0.030136887,
0.0554967895,
0.0162896663,
-0.0061898674,
0.0187090207,
-0.0561925843,
-0.0332080759,
-0.0126213282,
-0.0073057292,
-0.0161998812,
0.0332189463,
-0.0406875201,
-0.0002890902,
-0.0091122231,
-0.0538157709,
-0.0318351164,
-0.0219547097,
-0.0613469854,
0.0389701612,
0.0365004204,
-0.0108259786,
0.0443840884,
0.0006975927,
0.0221925396,
0.0420916826,
-0.0298199393,
-0.0213082377,
-0.0335436277,
-0.0095453141,
0.0269521531,
-0.0221472587,
0.0122191971,
-0.0156242326,
0.0274898894,
0.0090550808,
0.040814165,
0.0327627063,
-0.0437118188,
0.0199592207,
0.0322459675,
-0.0288055874,
-0.0698564872,
0.037729308,
0.063899599,
-0.0505410805,
0.0056084772,
0.1626123935,
0.044176314,
-0.0469544083,
-0.0032098105,
-0.0244703069,
0.0498543084,
0.0433045551,
0.008436894,
-0.0655267015,
-0.0386685692,
0.0282744654,
0.0048873248,
0.0000989026,
-0.0090034194,
-0.0141770178,
-0.0983933434,
0.0126808155,
-0.0144998087,
-0.0050438298,
-0.0454919189,
-0.0200979412,
-0.0120307086,
0.0145654585,
-0.0231793709,
0.0228877384,
-0.0171692148,
0.0387236997,
0.0076270169,
-0.0048850402,
0.0381796323,
0.0352887958,
-0.0182786398,
0.0424927436,
0.1402383298,
-0.0087977825,
0.000660294,
-0.031106744,
0.0057990137,
0.0075809262,
0.0325734802,
-0.0208537839,
0.0292359404,
0.0080742976,
-0.0241955779,
-0.0244714767,
0.0311794057,
-0.0482861921,
-0.0163399279,
0.024986282,
0.0560409762,
-0.0228630602,
-0.0428651385,
-0.0238453709,
0.0169463381,
-0.0007484879,
0.0796815529,
0.0453341752,
-0.0235798433,
-0.0481274687,
-0.0579632409,
0.0378129706,
-0.0107153691,
-0.0449335687,
-0.0217192024,
0.0510607101,
-0.0011929418,
-0.0540083759,
-0.0874480233,
0.0584289059,
0.0020390344,
-0.0027849157,
-0.0051012035,
-0.0218715854,
0.0023509406,
0.0002983315,
0.0292924494,
-0.0247086752,
0.0125718042,
-0.0577092953,
-0.0351930968,
-0.004463308,
-0.0136287874,
-0.0176548194,
-0.0069052964,
-0.0643316656,
-0.0446883887,
-0.0341209956,
0.0236064792,
0.0256413538,
0.0101750707,
-0.0086934529,
-0.0408391394,
-0.0400601402,
-0.0000515781,
-0.0350443795,
0.0152594801,
0.0146817015,
0.0204482097,
0.0215889886,
0.03142168,
-0.0420864671,
0.0093932683,
-0.00691834,
0.0378149003,
-0.0262965132,
-0.0220128968,
0.0237678308,
0.0273722876,
0.0441507734,
0.0341032147,
-0.0020693154,
-0.0123763867,
-0.0042624138,
-0.010853054,
-0.0314768218,
-0.0260237344,
0.0229208749,
-0.0007111532,
-0.0042410539,
-0.0241665021,
0.0069555053,
-0.038712129,
0.0438749455,
-0.0466499329,
0.0082365945,
0.0391402394,
0.0167364292,
0.0375842787,
-0.0098685762,
-0.0414736904,
0.037102364,
-0.0173260942,
0.02967548,
-0.0295189582,
0.0773141459,
0.0175962672,
0.0107262982,
0.0329084471,
0.0084673576,
-0.0904698297,
-0.109732911,
0.0716432482,
-0.0115289101,
-0.0001004368,
-0.0138152521,
0.0096828118,
-0.030817071,
0.0062181866,
-0.01689291,
0.009295919,
0.0671683028,
-0.0314664468,
0.0457268655,
0.0319069326,
-0.0168236941,
-0.0623742603,
0.0672328919,
-0.0377565064,
0.0404154584,
0.004883036,
-0.0064786901,
-0.0158589091,
-0.0097538298,
0.0223097205,
0.0209503118,
0.0158443376,
0.036152672,
-0.0613339171,
-0.0532812402,
0.0007855051,
-0.0065913284,
0.0068159364,
-0.0441831462,
0.0507843159,
0.070475556,
-0.0129860304,
-0.0377702229,
-0.029612137,
0.03620122,
0.0149746612,
-0.0424036048,
-0.0870772824,
-6.317462963e-33,
-0.0188795645,
-0.0174109079,
0.0028989557,
0.0325980037,
0.007224624,
-0.0080775339,
-0.0633731559,
0.0270581488,
-0.0275216773,
-0.0041839541,
-0.0291567855,
0.0602288805,
-0.0068437164,
-0.0055972962,
0.0145272668,
-0.0235739425,
0.0434986502,
0.0014278807,
-0.0399973802,
0.0401183069,
-0.0052850349,
-0.0071340972,
0.0126219168,
-0.0402328223,
0.0731445923,
-0.0168200694,
0.012475322,
-0.0205550212,
-0.001948871,
0.0269947313,
-0.0288185664,
0.0156299993,
0.0182607491,
-0.0298902448,
-0.0168169197,
0.0600220934,
-0.0225538313,
-0.045044262,
0.0577822439,
-0.0215427186,
-0.0384344459,
-0.0719081014,
0.0045939139,
-0.0391207822,
-0.0216822959,
-0.0192257203,
0.0231206212,
-0.0083473017,
0.0067160986,
-0.0430107526,
-0.0533955172,
0.0156911928,
-0.0294435658,
-0.0170046668,
0.0034790151,
0.0539301448,
-0.0005758028,
0.0888240635,
-0.0083642807,
0.0180865135,
0.0370240286,
0.0379681773,
0.0454617068,
-0.0062429029,
-0.0087748421,
0.0498111844,
0.0388116315,
-0.0010420737,
-0.0504630841,
0.0363048576,
0.0130501045,
0.0199132375,
0.0426010638,
-0.0083538909,
0.0372414365,
0.0224281568,
-0.0273736771,
-0.0043139397,
-0.0039054635,
0.0028369417,
0.0343872011,
0.0121252993,
-0.0660483986,
-0.0324059427,
-0.0432008915,
-0.0279664434,
-0.0472935736,
-0.0411647744,
0.0281617772,
-0.0259853657,
-0.0050205081,
-0.0410678871,
-0.0012769453,
-0.0255285688,
-0.013183021,
0.037250597,
-0.043583326,
0.0296062659,
0.0128461113,
0.04452198,
-0.038354069,
0.0433006994,
0.0297535677,
0.0197322257,
0.0392668955,
0.0477780923,
0.0151572581,
0.0134505965,
-0.1007002592,
-0.0191661362,
-0.0285414942,
0.0422884673,
-0.0312118176,
-0.0004224436,
0.0333376154,
0.0181389358,
0.016410809,
0.0394689664,
-0.0027104735,
-0.0564059205,
-0.0751496032,
0.0148707926,
-0.0230660681,
0.0059653642,
-0.0195447374,
-0.0345370732,
-0.0240760595,
0.0694960877,
0.0227516089,
-0.0251367148,
-0.0334742963,
0.0249004271,
2.754e-7,
0.0338200256,
0.0384064093,
0.0128576253,
0.0762026981,
0.0171505492,
0.0365489237,
-0.006267712,
-0.0078223366,
0.0463039503,
-0.0289065763,
-0.0359288603,
0.0437692516,
0.02152179,
0.0240753256,
-0.0768881589,
0.0259663537,
-0.0487810336,
-0.0030709996,
-0.0437003188,
0.0153993387,
0.0885362104,
0.0761243999,
-0.0099165449,
0.0153680285,
0.0248624813,
-0.0276867766,
0.0383456871,
-0.0256522447,
0.0361517444,
-0.0008253893,
-0.0482140109,
0.0366949961,
-0.0083866986,
0.0189068206,
0.0308683235,
-0.0231648106,
0.0157463904,
0.0692581385,
0.0226290245,
0.0053114439,
-0.0231744871,
-0.0220284127,
0.0186913442,
-0.0727923885,
0.1058094725,
-0.0118961073,
-0.0014897393,
-0.0163964015,
0.0054023969,
-0.0227990616,
0.0194218662,
-0.0008844213,
-0.030246783,
0.0189676303,
-0.0219016355,
-0.0222936235,
-0.0008459616,
-0.0676459968,
-0.0334069729,
0.0026441251,
-0.0031194866,
-0.0695552304,
-0.0654049441,
0.032080289,
0.0166910701,
-0.0378425978,
0.0026159401,
2.762144942e-34,
0.0329798386,
-0.0174953304,
0.039341867,
0.0421409085,
0.0447598435,
0.0184562095,
0.0004205809,
-0.0033593655,
0.0507391095,
-0.0733108968,
-0.0462248847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13191v1 | Towards Explainable and Safe Conversational Agents for Mental Health: A Survey | 2023-04-25T23:12:13 | 2023-04-25T23:12:13 | Surjodeep Sarkar, Manas Gaur, L. Chen, Muskan Garg, Biplav Srivastava, Bhaktee Dongaonkar | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Virtual Mental Health Assistants (VMHAs) are seeing continual advancements to
support the overburdened global healthcare system that gets 60 million primary
care visits, and 6 million Emergency Room (ER) visits annually. These systems
are built by clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, and Artificial Intelligence
(AI) researchers for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). At present, the role
of VMHAs is to provide emotional support through information, focusing less on
developing a reflective conversation with the patient. A more comprehensive,
safe and explainable approach is required to build responsible VMHAs to ask
follow-up questions or provide a well-informed response. This survey offers a
systematic critical review of the existing conversational agents in mental
health, followed by new insights into the improvements of VMHAs with contextual
knowledge, datasets, and their emerging role in clinical decision support. We
also provide new directions toward enriching the user experience of VMHAs with
explainability, safety, and wholesome trustworthiness. Finally, we provide
evaluation metrics and practical considerations for VMHAs beyond the current
literature to build trust between VMHAs and patients in active communications. | [
0.0624327287,
-0.0069345962,
-0.0323315822,
-0.0260764696,
-0.0055801817,
0.0120733958,
0.0467537418,
-0.0295894016,
0.064347066,
0.0169361569,
0.0097568789,
-0.0234331917,
-0.0003068855,
0.0314082317,
0.0081082471,
-0.0863688439,
-0.0034923877,
0.011198638,
0.0793575868,
0.0440807194,
0.0233533997,
0.0138039785,
-0.0716583878,
0.0729664713,
-0.0030926117,
-0.0123825129,
-0.0365267321,
0.0188631602,
0.051073771,
-0.0728335604,
-0.0465583727,
-0.0002695081,
-0.0095555447,
0.0001745242,
0.0000020965,
-0.0299765207,
-0.013366906,
0.0172486715,
-0.0664959475,
-0.1027177796,
-0.0002449744,
-0.0443823189,
-0.0065311897,
0.0444028676,
0.0100715887,
-0.0176576301,
0.0527888611,
0.0667117834,
0.0606889762,
0.0269378573,
-0.0320275463,
0.0469448976,
0.0249399785,
0.0119077861,
-0.0055185989,
-0.0328283608,
0.0039526862,
0.021353947,
0.019062791,
-0.0298417639,
0.0150200147,
0.0068858834,
-0.012879313,
-0.0148197822,
-0.0137270093,
0.0253048465,
-0.0187763795,
-0.0518094935,
-0.0236384515,
0.0769498795,
0.0212991331,
0.0401842929,
0.0176951699,
-0.0064188079,
-0.0026471601,
-0.0079649435,
-0.0441687368,
-0.0056794412,
-0.0367064364,
0.0024546315,
-0.0009482926,
0.0299053527,
0.0375242718,
0.0133406417,
0.0399070755,
-0.0170355961,
-0.0102796685,
-0.003374821,
0.0199707076,
-0.0297858194,
-0.0316061229,
-0.0577233769,
0.0055506555,
0.0422590561,
-0.1038651168,
0.0172576476,
-0.0204698462,
-0.0496840477,
0.0021434699,
-0.002533016,
0.019571092,
0.0469057523,
-0.0340136141,
-0.0344724171,
0.0562046058,
0.0363931656,
0.0146844555,
0.0220991299,
-0.0108251004,
-0.0060718255,
-0.0432210714,
-0.0067787399,
-0.0268051736,
-0.0073892162,
0.0108427349,
-0.0084163425,
-0.0478408188,
0.0307981521,
-0.0259260591,
0.0489114523,
-0.0165168494,
0.0082179029,
-0.0076267202,
0.0290302634,
-0.0098566646,
-0.0076674963,
-0.0543106683,
0.0083376989,
0.0460748151,
-0.0659780949,
0.008354675,
-0.0104970811,
0.0025245347,
-0.0080390833,
-0.0116707562,
0.0464951172,
0.0104046743,
-0.0445790179,
-0.0158469304,
-0.0206909496,
-0.0176760554,
-0.0198595431,
0.0306667946,
0.0261877086,
0.0427268706,
0.0004431912,
-0.0026804407,
0.0022665786,
0.0519028082,
-0.0022677961,
-0.0502847582,
0.0795944929,
-0.0658227354,
-0.0035333829,
0.0060097091,
0.0505659729,
-0.025635941,
-0.0186126512,
-0.007939497,
-0.0044305804,
0.0453690104,
-0.0332962126,
0.0481154993,
-0.06292478,
0.006017352,
-0.0574859865,
0.0365154296,
0.0033074762,
-0.0434190407,
0.0552732237,
-0.0512118824,
0.0149781415,
-0.0382277668,
0.0164420251,
0.0524768122,
0.0562337041,
-0.0115777282,
0.0261439625,
0.0142404027,
0.0191326998,
-0.0022767761,
-0.0170903075,
-0.0561784208,
0.0368575528,
-0.0081451209,
-0.0303915534,
-0.0110993683,
-0.0231795423,
-0.0439681374,
-0.0696534663,
-0.016462395,
-0.0483174436,
-0.0030277045,
0.0155541524,
-0.0455917865,
-0.0330530331,
0.0036180718,
0.0202680677,
0.0272975806,
-0.0198966321,
-0.0948448628,
-0.0660874248,
0.0350730494,
0.1313363612,
0.0332533121,
-0.0150099425,
-0.0515935309,
-0.0429293662,
0.0026305499,
0.0227650553,
-0.0022286391,
0.0064019724,
0.0563401841,
-0.0313093401,
-0.0109441075,
0.0214464962,
0.0034567793,
-0.0019461144,
-0.033641059,
0.0208505653,
-0.0188821834,
0.0051984903,
0.0023126493,
0.0316289961,
0.0052647637,
-0.0243451744,
-0.0039064167,
-0.0044291322,
0.0524889939,
0.0510487407,
0.0102866534,
0.0087851239,
0.0289509185,
0.0050818929,
-0.0261004176,
0.0510227829,
-0.0166211203,
0.0032383702,
-0.0010911056,
-0.015777491,
0.0302294083,
0.0305893868,
-0.0052911784,
-0.0245065745,
-0.0389931239,
-0.0729411691,
0.0366995186,
-0.0082734805,
0.0326112397,
0.0389817171,
0.0244730134,
0.0023718739,
-0.0172520299,
-0.0245127566,
-0.0056850505,
0.0026137203,
0.016849488,
-0.0279977042,
-0.0097510312,
0.0297807828,
0.0073750187,
-0.0180919133,
0.0015926999,
-0.0563112088,
-0.0025598165,
-0.0293411687,
0.0269766711,
-0.1409594417,
-0.0000100918,
-0.0048619774,
-0.0371184535,
0.0235312432,
-0.0155045381,
-0.0133586908,
-0.0283859689,
-0.0198708419,
0.0612449311,
0.0437166728,
0.0099300351,
0.0251113698,
0.0373303145,
-0.0397275425,
-0.0415365249,
-0.0033045788,
-0.0124619277,
0.0231201556,
-0.0110675497,
0.0127911232,
-0.0282354411,
-0.0236939695,
-0.0543034337,
-0.0084743705,
-0.0304552335,
-0.0452367663,
0.0184199009,
0.0227956139,
-0.0161996782,
0.0036713784,
-0.0056487187,
0.0462816656,
0.0478400737,
0.0077488935,
-0.0077152262,
0.0053403233,
-0.0031943638,
-0.030717399,
-0.0251608081,
-0.0285845902,
-0.0060643051,
0.0243110638,
-0.0044343127,
0.0399352796,
-0.0077791275,
-0.0083784554,
0.043361228,
0.0026701372,
0.0300876964,
-0.0207976196,
-0.0011870867,
0.0532092266,
-0.0035771464,
-0.0330149755,
0.0439166911,
-0.018561855,
-0.0234766454,
-0.0436357819,
-0.0461863056,
-0.0135895228,
0.0052027926,
-0.0183614232,
0.0159400534,
0.016091913,
-0.0128900148,
0.0438437685,
-0.065228045,
-0.0504983626,
-0.0297108311,
-0.0190684926,
-0.0574534014,
-0.0119140465,
0.0243179966,
0.0183201991,
-0.0554416254,
-0.0107687656,
-0.0682755187,
-0.0116254706,
-0.0138690509,
0.005315478,
-0.0421735421,
-0.0217881445,
0.059151724,
0.0325635001,
0.0185080506,
-0.0571937263,
-0.0035621352,
-0.0334366597,
0.0316007733,
0.038554851,
0.0571315289,
0.0298308041,
0.0796913058,
0.0626845434,
0.0010109555,
0.0046056067,
0.0019173791,
-0.0276786536,
-0.0513876863,
-0.001793867,
-0.0261145495,
0.0370715894,
0.0419985689,
0.0006391319,
-0.0081650205,
0.0844939724,
0.0171457455,
-0.0414566584,
0.0417057201,
-0.0811575726,
-0.0456124991,
-0.0346339755,
-0.0167678185,
-0.0163407065,
-0.0178350843,
-0.0152790397,
0.0559977628,
-0.0644985363,
-0.0327835232,
0.0056247646,
-0.0199635476,
0.0349550731,
-0.0297156423,
0.0056831618,
0.0002840401,
-0.0228044298,
0.0428271256,
-0.0065206881,
0.0328483842,
-0.0440710969,
0.0160547104,
-0.0182851348,
-0.0100170542,
-0.0467703976,
0.0000358151,
0.0374610238,
-0.0195433237,
0.0788456351,
0.0543725155,
0.0581183732,
0.0066375877,
-0.0477849394,
-0.0657613054,
0.0499200523,
0.0369847901,
0.0093293795,
0.081881851,
-0.0041166167,
0.0336532146,
-0.0564411357,
0.0616121441,
-0.001782555,
-0.0320060402,
0.020202104,
0.055325143,
-0.0641134158,
-0.0079534389,
-0.0356120057,
0.050986357,
0.043148905,
0.0374468304,
0.0358979106,
-0.033964403,
-0.0203558858,
0.0213020612,
0.0673095509,
0.006544596,
-0.0188423079,
0.0099504311,
-0.0134696774,
-0.0479514562,
-0.0467459783,
-0.0797398165,
0.0428021662,
0.0163006224,
-0.0261013433,
-0.035848733,
0.0376686752,
0.0623369217,
-0.0209588632,
0.0213365462,
0.0425456688,
0.0143896826,
-0.005251776,
0.0265871584,
-0.0096937995,
-0.0426876321,
0.0171975102,
-0.0104037868,
0.0268850699,
0.0264424793,
0.0552976057,
0.0663736463,
0.0178062543,
-0.0106408922,
0.0210681371,
-0.0305170268,
-0.0076599005,
-0.0213818718,
-0.0547247529,
-0.0399603471,
0.0305837989,
0.0669864193,
0.0075808088,
0.0331102759,
-0.0080485456,
0.0383593142,
-0.0110599073,
0.0038085002,
-0.0289377943,
-0.0135541828,
0.0036341138,
0.0340126939,
0.0301192459,
0.0118364254,
0.0457023568,
0.0194352474,
0.0132987406,
-0.0383653194,
0.0442026034,
-0.0317602381,
0.0059807398,
-0.0204665791,
-0.0091920188,
0.0211542044,
-0.0666301027,
-0.0796262622,
-0.0515416749,
0.0102162482,
-0.0010725158,
-0.04154009,
0.0201178696,
-0.0263829902,
0.0166992024,
0.0013307905,
0.0535570011,
0.0127879614,
0.0391172059,
0.0179245137,
0.1040045768,
-0.0153403683,
-0.0208302978,
0.0096659195,
0.0709814578,
-0.0672787726,
-0.151877135,
0.0164120998,
0.0100760479,
-0.0040252078,
0.063924022,
0.0281180423,
-0.0095042279,
0.0227517411,
0.0055052317,
0.0564371906,
0.0060972269,
-0.027178634,
-0.0059621595,
0.004053317,
-0.0233457666,
-0.0374628603,
0.0158927422,
-0.0639690831,
0.0303148367,
-0.0167216491,
-0.0404664241,
-0.049439583,
-0.0086257812,
-0.0224214084,
0.0374975242,
-0.022777861,
-0.0188035946,
-0.0397173427,
-0.028418785,
0.0366656892,
-0.0527299419,
-0.0583088435,
-0.0650010034,
0.0409137271,
0.0106237549,
0.0308747143,
-0.0362202004,
-0.0182381738,
0.0171392038,
-0.0320204943,
0.044442486,
-0.0253288113,
-5.139428075e-33,
0.0251472015,
-0.0214321278,
-0.0079854,
-0.0267907567,
-0.009555622,
0.0048372741,
-0.0560970679,
0.0466238372,
-0.0104416674,
0.0173049401,
0.0010298413,
0.0531207323,
0.0060465732,
0.0222102366,
0.0175183825,
-0.0252106301,
0.0183779597,
0.0157954395,
0.0048485398,
0.0449634194,
-0.0161824208,
0.0471869893,
0.01182329,
-0.1142583638,
0.0352259427,
0.0167481527,
-0.0088082943,
0.0483605266,
-0.0187997222,
0.0259424727,
-0.0146518955,
0.0311332829,
0.0377488397,
0.0155915329,
0.0072470475,
0.0210721381,
-0.0092105158,
-0.028789103,
-0.0046839239,
-0.0204434115,
-0.1011794508,
-0.0203175582,
0.0019637083,
-0.0198251307,
0.0048346287,
0.0011363699,
0.007070031,
-0.0421607271,
0.0194288772,
0.0190468263,
-0.0028956709,
-0.022149628,
-0.0368746556,
-0.0134215513,
-0.0151909431,
0.0534108393,
-0.0519359745,
-0.0004086991,
-0.0423345789,
-0.0187418219,
0.0214632377,
-0.0630922988,
0.0012450716,
-0.0499160066,
-0.0398364067,
0.0225754566,
0.0473578274,
-0.0105264671,
-0.0971844792,
0.0273342188,
-0.0510068536,
0.0794141144,
0.0730410069,
0.0301981959,
-0.0375214219,
-0.0022235159,
-0.0429812372,
0.0284233615,
-0.0067964527,
0.0472992063,
0.0300656687,
0.0043233875,
-0.0813909099,
0.0110967699,
-0.00916903,
-0.0194456466,
-0.0217415746,
-0.054853037,
0.035280697,
-0.0163341798,
-0.0509579293,
-0.0110083176,
-0.0325684883,
-0.0195754319,
0.0692608356,
-0.0127536086,
0.0329389386,
0.0006119821,
-0.0145065803,
-0.0357606523,
-0.0277646799,
0.0051326198,
0.0273477864,
0.005217968,
0.0777548924,
-0.0136234555,
0.0260784831,
-0.0024496617,
0.006490584,
-0.0028786454,
0.007283675,
0.0573411696,
0.0230221953,
0.02002047,
-0.0298559628,
0.0050470745,
-0.0404828563,
0.0345566608,
0.0212572441,
0.018450588,
-0.0651245639,
-0.0261563938,
-0.0195827745,
-0.0002470451,
-0.0304066781,
-0.0405993313,
-0.0569751188,
-0.0162845924,
0.0289395619,
-0.0404905789,
0.0035348188,
-0.0389394499,
2.883e-7,
-0.0009645087,
0.0258818083,
0.0199692585,
-0.0048586591,
0.0202644542,
0.0507586673,
0.0421879627,
0.0453644991,
0.0023778097,
-0.0444399156,
0.0413100198,
0.0021740189,
0.0483610444,
0.0785965994,
0.0570923984,
-0.065161325,
-0.0371271782,
-0.0377061069,
-0.0459515974,
0.0273897406,
0.0951010957,
0.0343982577,
0.0117137795,
-0.0217737257,
0.0321322456,
0.0265191942,
-0.0124546168,
-0.0317816474,
0.0376684628,
0.0209207907,
0.0417190306,
0.0316971131,
0.0199403241,
0.0128450636,
0.0031442354,
0.0014690062,
-0.0369785428,
0.0667282343,
-0.0788283274,
-0.0467678048,
0.0069335983,
0.026641503,
0.0298166294,
-0.0324356556,
0.0482932292,
-0.0734690651,
-0.0665566921,
0.0290011875,
-0.0252325684,
-0.0157605745,
0.0209239852,
-0.0147255426,
-0.0105743045,
0.0417657606,
-0.0108001688,
-0.0042964625,
0.0236609578,
-0.0361103937,
0.0002101527,
0.0117660481,
-0.0217743926,
-0.0024208431,
0.0149662122,
-0.023255229,
-0.0013835294,
-0.0526538454,
0.0114472238,
1.934430697e-34,
-0.0131127927,
0.0531677529,
0.011652519,
0.0395272896,
0.0397530608,
0.047853034,
0.0179079659,
0.0227279719,
0.0347041376,
-0.0229638685,
-0.0197575856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13188v1 | TABLET: Learning From Instructions For Tabular Data | 2023-04-25T23:07:20 | 2023-04-25T23:07:20 | Dylan Slack, Sameer Singh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Acquiring high-quality data is often a significant challenge in training
machine learning (ML) models for tabular prediction, particularly in
privacy-sensitive and costly domains like medicine and finance. Providing
natural language instructions to large language models (LLMs) offers an
alternative solution. However, it is unclear how effectively instructions
leverage the knowledge in LLMs for solving tabular prediction problems. To
address this gap, we introduce TABLET, a benchmark of 20 diverse tabular
datasets annotated with instructions that vary in their phrasing, granularity,
and technicality. Additionally, TABLET includes the instructions' logic and
structured modifications to the instructions. We find in-context instructions
increase zero-shot F1 performance for Flan-T5 11b by 44% on average and 13% for
ChatGPT on TABLET. Also, we explore the limitations of using LLMs for tabular
prediction in our benchmark by evaluating instruction faithfulness. We find
LLMs often ignore instructions and fail to predict specific instances
correctly, even with examples. Our analysis on TABLET shows that, while
instructions help LLM performance, learning from instructions for tabular data
requires new capabilities. | [
0.0256399531,
0.068052344,
-0.0094876783,
0.0139532024,
-0.01586424,
0.0059346301,
0.0554847196,
0.0106192892,
0.0388039351,
-0.0351071395,
-0.0406514965,
-0.0459961742,
0.0076998197,
0.0352220498,
0.0307396688,
-0.0013475161,
0.0259392187,
-0.0119412262,
-0.0097739939,
-0.0025094068,
-0.017439438,
0.0058846399,
0.005307375,
0.0216248464,
0.0317322426,
-0.0237036441,
-0.0066476418,
-0.0129578859,
-0.0093595944,
-0.0151033532,
0.0254763439,
0.0556391366,
0.0135865314,
0.0628120825,
0.0000019839,
-0.028287502,
-0.0589982681,
0.033283364,
-0.0491564237,
0.0293822885,
0.0598525591,
-0.0602534562,
0.0201691855,
0.0244268551,
-0.0467698872,
-0.0003666043,
0.0323321,
0.0214382559,
0.0260182079,
0.097760953,
-0.0138820959,
-0.0294935536,
0.0248895977,
-0.0310972985,
0.0699111447,
-0.0704059973,
0.0044972678,
-0.0438133404,
-0.0404000916,
-0.0014863088,
0.0058061653,
0.0378853418,
0.0301740449,
0.0261235144,
0.0129452599,
0.0340953059,
-0.0373260342,
-0.0240032822,
-0.0219346583,
0.0750385821,
0.0182120986,
0.0041070161,
0.0210281424,
-0.0129971579,
0.0224130508,
-0.0115065686,
-0.0199817363,
0.0219049789,
-0.022477109,
0.0016624391,
0.0225267448,
-0.0285539217,
0.0315256268,
-0.0148536479,
-0.0169754587,
0.0318136066,
-0.0329286233,
-0.021846991,
0.0161312409,
-0.0288538318,
0.0263561327,
-0.0516595915,
0.0053871903,
0.0103966389,
-0.027030129,
0.0195124354,
-0.0548670329,
-0.025323797,
0.0406327173,
-0.0818265527,
0.0839842558,
0.0233311616,
0.0042124055,
0.0247978941,
-0.0384071283,
0.0234812032,
-0.0041864947,
0.0717523247,
0.0046920213,
0.0253272429,
-0.0437079072,
0.0075875353,
-0.0159636121,
0.0503362194,
-0.0613704734,
-0.0148103265,
-0.0510800742,
0.0018820155,
-0.0140302675,
0.0587888882,
0.0066106841,
0.005809742,
-0.0181943849,
-0.0140357437,
-0.0313762464,
-0.0246634036,
-0.0028196764,
0.0107588759,
-0.0079285987,
-0.0854966715,
-0.0029332824,
-0.0098404456,
-0.0194841996,
-0.0180146601,
0.0227772519,
0.0853839219,
0.0117518865,
-0.0372618288,
-0.0506401137,
-0.0557701588,
-0.0021155765,
-0.0664533898,
0.0268728845,
-0.0480820946,
0.0275254119,
-0.0111586433,
-0.0037833673,
-0.061749056,
0.0051882267,
0.045828905,
-0.0378003567,
0.0975258872,
0.0065136701,
-0.0229935199,
-0.0263408534,
0.0118104909,
-0.029558016,
0.0584310666,
0.020897815,
0.0220491253,
0.0356823839,
-0.0281963274,
-0.0006898663,
0.0312664621,
0.0563002042,
-0.0208262037,
-0.0182416514,
0.0499015488,
0.008291468,
-0.0026525615,
0.0079022069,
0.0181053802,
0.0077167819,
-0.0243195053,
0.0679990426,
0.0607924163,
0.0168444403,
0.0340382941,
-0.0137080252,
0.0361196399,
0.0055411663,
-0.0113485977,
-0.0454161055,
-0.0067377589,
-0.0440373197,
-0.0005822691,
0.0455562361,
0.0166578256,
-0.0153174326,
-0.0458043665,
-0.0069892234,
-0.0314198211,
0.0301476773,
0.009371005,
0.0111253615,
-0.0121197337,
-0.0394209698,
0.0328228585,
0.0361510366,
-0.0042980979,
-0.0725290626,
-0.0354864411,
0.027078582,
0.0926661417,
0.0271656848,
-0.0333499685,
0.0010442731,
-0.0275149774,
-0.005481788,
0.0012345425,
0.0327346884,
-0.0199232399,
0.0577160604,
-0.0356280804,
-0.0046682251,
0.0133616002,
0.0335601345,
0.0079892054,
0.0371484905,
-0.0112588359,
0.0023335465,
-0.0244786926,
-0.0390016697,
0.0550356284,
-0.0060700253,
-0.0764232874,
0.0524218827,
0.0130867017,
0.0289189313,
0.0181472339,
0.0019998811,
0.0096505918,
0.0199692547,
0.0107734269,
0.0258103814,
-0.0417819694,
-0.0107523743,
-0.0248569567,
-0.0037081467,
0.0223598406,
-0.0208871085,
-0.0036562993,
-0.0404276848,
0.0096820714,
-0.0337814204,
-0.0138434134,
0.0385526493,
-0.0110761328,
0.0103580523,
0.0082933214,
0.036720939,
-0.0100064753,
0.0500828065,
-0.0431181155,
0.0051022717,
0.0071413955,
-0.0713755414,
-0.0087862564,
-0.0157166161,
0.0584679954,
-0.0042278604,
-0.012360747,
0.0259390101,
0.0076943245,
0.0315494649,
-0.0201865807,
-0.00973015,
-0.0646561831,
0.0427598469,
-0.0319080986,
0.0222889706,
0.0153912213,
0.0096377442,
-0.0096529815,
-0.0467118658,
-0.0396846235,
-0.0126755899,
-0.0367442481,
0.0301023684,
0.0371078774,
0.0213655625,
-0.0340858661,
-0.0066099148,
-0.0202782582,
-0.0373077877,
0.0253210999,
-0.0224165712,
-0.0244487729,
-0.0291187055,
-0.0054398808,
0.0097936913,
0.0145140542,
-0.0082487473,
0.0046252259,
-0.0000942146,
0.0093128486,
-0.0411154293,
0.0793714225,
-0.0311538652,
0.0712380484,
0.0156406127,
0.0364632979,
-0.0526727028,
0.0146326749,
-0.0109824957,
-0.0151785295,
-0.0411417484,
-0.0456610397,
0.0364249609,
0.056429062,
-0.0148532148,
0.0073231319,
-0.0485808589,
0.036229942,
0.0231214426,
-0.0318452306,
-0.0341659896,
0.0708552077,
-0.0163156763,
0.0318359844,
0.0078511741,
-0.0742095411,
0.0630780533,
-0.0104040662,
0.0016558748,
-0.0260126423,
-0.0198436547,
-0.0154084982,
0.0553843081,
0.0175027736,
0.008537041,
0.034380991,
-0.0377398655,
-0.0031571358,
0.0024287358,
0.0349265821,
-0.0391036831,
0.0723146573,
-0.0282911565,
-0.0096112946,
-0.0110851498,
-0.0450485125,
-0.033910159,
-0.0969238728,
0.0103531275,
0.0021785661,
0.0257450119,
-0.0450811572,
-0.0559281819,
-0.0408630855,
0.0135721415,
0.0440329611,
0.0002133998,
-0.0279025529,
-0.0168695394,
-0.0103885895,
0.0256407931,
-0.0504210293,
-0.0060460567,
-0.0350993313,
0.0228464063,
0.0490222387,
0.0187401418,
0.0299540702,
0.0229995232,
-0.0048094545,
0.0242934879,
-0.0127210617,
-0.0275647882,
0.0827910155,
0.0369764343,
-0.073009707,
0.0064679016,
0.0865927488,
0.0345194638,
-0.0094493441,
-0.0072243996,
0.023651449,
0.0404503644,
-0.008785462,
0.0467095412,
-0.1332261115,
-0.0266503897,
0.007209504,
0.051321134,
-0.0108207911,
-0.0520264544,
-0.0336827189,
-0.1102226302,
0.0408927277,
-0.0075877733,
-0.0322086923,
-0.0692604557,
-0.0650063008,
-0.0245755557,
-0.0418204553,
0.0287758559,
-0.0036728666,
-0.0533032231,
-0.014949278,
-0.0060804263,
-0.0860069022,
-0.0546049438,
-0.0036785691,
-0.0248255786,
0.0480241142,
0.0575251691,
-0.0139021119,
-0.0021797412,
-0.0297907554,
-0.0271502249,
0.0498581342,
-0.0058514168,
-0.0088846441,
0.1032785848,
-0.0063206884,
0.0046377,
-0.0104974089,
0.0545645133,
-0.0056225983,
0.0074517708,
-0.0005687058,
0.0256899968,
-0.0326423272,
-0.0234780833,
0.02878174,
0.0056232233,
-0.0020152903,
0.0703059807,
0.0167257078,
-0.0193692204,
-0.0245113615,
-0.0538543947,
-0.0120365946,
-0.0674851313,
0.0111364331,
0.0508220382,
-0.0356861427,
-0.0522426218,
-0.0565821193,
-0.0323217846,
0.0379744507,
0.0347713195,
0.012906367,
0.0400874838,
0.0160817634,
-0.0098984344,
-0.0477512628,
-0.0125289941,
-0.0377322361,
0.0020025743,
-0.0319964141,
-0.0550311208,
-0.0036000479,
0.0032497118,
-0.028678054,
0.056187164,
-0.0632443056,
-0.0745243728,
0.0126735084,
0.0472440906,
0.0271365047,
0.0584803335,
0.0043206811,
-0.0282302815,
0.0340947509,
0.0648562983,
-0.0687349364,
-0.0242131483,
0.0566336028,
-0.0469852835,
-0.0021672607,
0.0275780763,
-0.0116060982,
-0.0372438394,
0.010408571,
-0.0173158906,
-0.036022,
0.0221410077,
0.0210777335,
0.0081044277,
0.0303107984,
-0.0052353251,
-0.0337104462,
-0.0036794257,
0.0430917963,
-0.0167738516,
-0.0000868061,
-0.018789079,
-0.0247508455,
0.0311555862,
-0.0054229815,
-0.0188603848,
-0.0002616763,
-0.0097935591,
0.0146137103,
-0.0545110703,
0.0198120289,
0.0028984358,
-0.0084587792,
0.0364282206,
-0.0165252183,
-0.0026798549,
0.0693591982,
0.0336572751,
0.0607232824,
-0.010475602,
0.0389421917,
0.0054041557,
0.029391177,
-0.0414401256,
0.025618853,
-0.0275177043,
-0.0774516389,
-0.0366945788,
0.0554186106,
0.0081311855,
-0.0234451406,
0.0038188635,
-0.0480079651,
-0.0055305711,
-0.0126904966,
0.0171824973,
-0.0096434839,
-0.0098382654,
0.0169815067,
0.0087061422,
-0.0333187729,
-0.0232565776,
0.1241153926,
0.067121543,
0.0201233085,
-0.0096722152,
-0.0367776491,
-0.064921923,
-0.0179618895,
0.0541453883,
0.0147671588,
-0.0190148316,
0.0075767441,
-0.0406085588,
-0.0566807166,
0.0207037386,
-0.0096836109,
-0.0155457389,
-0.0142111918,
0.021860376,
0.0434058532,
0.0170583222,
-0.031470675,
-0.0689966679,
0.0075391773,
0.0017542129,
-0.0396545045,
-0.0070708585,
-6.387695077e-33,
-0.0218066834,
0.0117251845,
0.0085558938,
0.0135015575,
0.0384082794,
0.0142320581,
-0.0216297116,
-0.0101518091,
0.0027556438,
0.0074726385,
-0.047673218,
0.0055446015,
0.0337176509,
0.0241179187,
0.0153681086,
-0.0726017728,
0.0285237432,
-0.0411563329,
-0.0215881616,
0.0135893505,
0.0085862828,
0.0497318991,
0.0378363691,
-0.0585855395,
0.0659226626,
0.0131549565,
-0.0169312973,
-0.0096734418,
-0.0159092173,
0.0651069358,
-0.0284337755,
0.0132464729,
0.0232953932,
-0.0604038462,
-0.0259748418,
0.0372021422,
-0.0793634504,
0.0050460366,
0.0085476441,
0.0363083892,
-0.0388964452,
-0.0575792119,
0.0497300215,
-0.0333996676,
-0.0268727206,
-0.0320782848,
0.0093289874,
-0.0378099717,
-0.0124994349,
-0.0232106447,
-0.0357197449,
0.0285285506,
-0.0022380841,
-0.00886048,
0.0542652346,
0.0256474689,
0.0024994898,
0.0120051699,
-0.0618501678,
-0.0084351981,
0.0450420789,
0.0301363654,
0.03053312,
-0.0008634657,
0.040586859,
0.045250874,
0.0600511804,
0.0174647905,
-0.0229080431,
-0.0135041988,
-0.0047989548,
0.0547128208,
0.0075283614,
0.0154105257,
0.0875865817,
-0.017669322,
-0.0784042478,
0.0288797375,
-0.013118891,
-0.0065636849,
0.0311824102,
-0.0171437785,
-0.0727222487,
-0.0126229692,
-0.0331191309,
0.0041982848,
-0.0111593232,
-0.0020109166,
0.0045701512,
0.0187517535,
0.0119413314,
0.0162451733,
0.0299325474,
-0.0417666584,
-0.0364078134,
0.0083261123,
0.0193771254,
-0.0021406885,
0.001469273,
-0.0033476378,
-0.0588761158,
-0.0089884344,
0.0032382822,
-0.0179375503,
0.0591282696,
0.0257466286,
0.081534937,
0.0070901918,
-0.0883048698,
-0.0179387257,
-0.0095523968,
0.0452967808,
0.0339096189,
0.0116690779,
0.0422374085,
0.0079965424,
-0.0081362994,
0.0611868538,
0.0082093356,
0.0000116143,
-0.0298708249,
-0.0085849324,
-0.0021802566,
0.0048051714,
-0.0193830561,
-0.0160351917,
-0.0140266279,
0.0294230189,
0.0487349555,
-0.0335990228,
-0.0121780885,
-0.0009381007,
2.668e-7,
0.0632989034,
0.0472288392,
0.0134859765,
0.0226146169,
-0.0058670775,
0.0528169833,
-0.0070855655,
0.0355763063,
-0.0279922727,
-0.0188518837,
0.0207588915,
-0.0077072894,
0.0809396431,
0.0363298431,
-0.0608250462,
-0.0195291862,
-0.0702492744,
0.0159938578,
-0.0717798993,
-0.0071636271,
0.0102140829,
0.1164208576,
-0.000331993,
-0.0337704234,
0.0363841318,
-0.0210631564,
0.0378464498,
-0.0596902519,
-0.0061998093,
0.0050449781,
0.0220342651,
0.0404951945,
-0.0206523929,
0.0203871597,
-0.0378775187,
0.001528097,
-0.043305438,
0.1249639913,
0.001199887,
0.0206047446,
0.0062100389,
-0.0646114573,
-0.010793997,
-0.0473660044,
0.0649528131,
-0.0445254333,
-0.0379266962,
-0.0042664702,
0.0222715996,
-0.0247881077,
0.0604136959,
-0.0000923994,
0.0105770333,
0.0198568385,
0.0136828702,
-0.0207575336,
-0.0022926645,
-0.0479019731,
-0.0521371253,
0.0332447365,
-0.0018705773,
-0.0064699869,
-0.0158399399,
-0.0010971389,
0.0043621934,
-0.0671855509,
0.037734475,
2.748846015e-34,
0.0379751734,
-0.0139041366,
0.0070012733,
0.0540111847,
0.047772713,
-0.0169884004,
0.0254299585,
0.0130520677,
0.0123883681,
-0.086066395,
-0.0027785774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13180v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13180v2 | Sebis at SemEval-2023 Task 7: A Joint System for Natural Language Inference and Evidence Retrieval from Clinical Trial Reports | 2023-04-25T22:22:42 | 2023-05-02T16:46:33 | Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing number of clinical trial reports generated every day, it
is becoming hard to keep up with novel discoveries that inform evidence-based
healthcare recommendations. To help automate this process and assist medical
experts, NLP solutions are being developed. This motivated the SemEval-2023
Task 7, where the goal was to develop an NLP system for two tasks: evidence
retrieval and natural language inference from clinical trial data. In this
paper, we describe our two developed systems. The first one is a pipeline
system that models the two tasks separately, while the second one is a joint
system that learns the two tasks simultaneously with a shared representation
and a multi-task learning approach. The final system combines their outputs in
an ensemble system. We formalize the models, present their characteristics and
challenges, and provide an analysis of achieved results. Our system ranked 3rd
out of 40 participants with a final submission. | [
0.0502575599,
0.0464305244,
-0.0040780525,
-0.0229091868,
-0.0490562879,
0.0074304459,
0.0036618616,
0.0003781986,
0.0109236594,
-0.0373800099,
-0.0070464415,
-0.0174750239,
0.0123666795,
0.0658016801,
0.0008237687,
-0.0182786565,
0.0178605095,
0.0328268483,
0.0463337153,
0.0237521175,
-0.00104169,
0.0194200668,
-0.0263198689,
0.0710261613,
0.0294166729,
-0.008125877,
0.0562568046,
-0.0351283662,
0.0093493722,
-0.0446822047,
0.0310413055,
0.0113208704,
0.0138348425,
-0.0001824145,
0.0000015174,
-0.062807709,
-0.0430257507,
0.0317708775,
-0.0145605886,
-0.0875743106,
0.0552323423,
-0.0095600486,
0.0331924893,
0.01880024,
-0.0255281329,
-0.0547949895,
0.0495058633,
0.0655677095,
0.0347351991,
0.043763455,
-0.0183035638,
-0.0087388493,
-0.0101125026,
-0.0141534759,
0.0026714958,
-0.0039003128,
0.0651810244,
0.0017051836,
0.0507941283,
-0.0026725396,
0.0835906714,
0.0327081122,
-0.0354347453,
0.0226351954,
0.0051599573,
0.0259448104,
-0.021425074,
-0.0337402187,
-0.0093838526,
0.0541880541,
0.0148063349,
-0.0426261909,
0.0206910167,
-0.0028743134,
-0.0046748356,
0.0205604341,
-0.0313323773,
0.0355784222,
-0.0607463643,
0.0036163474,
0.0336206667,
0.0199357234,
0.0164371319,
-0.0009239163,
-0.0049083326,
0.0239191242,
0.000126391,
-0.0048495983,
0.0239367206,
0.0276118256,
-0.0025045075,
-0.0360131934,
0.0555420928,
0.0154194124,
-0.0443301797,
0.0220437869,
0.0422403924,
-0.0665502846,
0.0845188722,
-0.0566897504,
0.0284676161,
-0.0284169242,
-0.0432892703,
0.0725057051,
-0.0466950387,
-0.0366632566,
-0.0119098518,
0.0224279407,
-0.0325829908,
0.0064388514,
-0.0700148866,
-0.0048978804,
-0.0098664165,
0.0387261994,
-0.0345595926,
0.005660261,
-0.0374168605,
-0.0066843224,
-0.0201364476,
0.013138134,
0.0412944146,
0.0432335138,
-0.0505511314,
-0.0005125838,
-0.0012600468,
0.0473119095,
-0.0049118684,
0.0460495129,
-0.020435119,
-0.038426321,
-0.0072144638,
0.0097509203,
0.0141097158,
-0.0166518055,
0.0405562185,
0.0366834961,
0.0213376377,
-0.018493766,
0.0034326189,
-0.0406018533,
-0.0404943898,
-0.0522061363,
0.0108128004,
-0.0626497641,
0.0667880997,
0.0270437114,
0.0032889929,
-0.0371890813,
-0.0085834581,
0.013187076,
-0.0219949372,
0.0625550821,
-0.0284395143,
-0.034322001,
0.0035306222,
-0.00873888,
-0.0482976921,
0.0517481081,
0.0118473135,
0.0045194309,
-0.0092781009,
0.0196526628,
-0.007504798,
-0.042541191,
0.0240266789,
-0.0633762777,
0.0299383216,
0.0279245675,
0.0156844594,
0.0593762025,
-0.0639713481,
0.0655776933,
-0.0111717768,
-0.0012136007,
0.0124379853,
0.0273482986,
0.0175804142,
-0.0139973024,
0.0207783841,
-0.0195264593,
0.0134092262,
-0.0189908929,
-0.0079787448,
0.001761449,
-0.0055302391,
0.0136886537,
-0.013089099,
0.0326146707,
-0.019590104,
-0.0528729632,
-0.0357733406,
-0.0170032475,
-0.0223099664,
0.0097774127,
0.075095661,
-0.0017392394,
-0.032562837,
-0.0253721159,
0.0539163761,
0.0035351296,
-0.028748855,
-0.0281793028,
-0.0156823099,
0.0132577186,
0.0161518678,
-0.0633244738,
-0.0245125126,
-0.0459650606,
0.0049660043,
-0.0276582241,
-0.0097938571,
-0.0212290119,
0.0377910733,
-0.00552009,
-0.0193544682,
0.0051242057,
0.018939985,
-0.0246783961,
-0.0004067956,
-0.0029582512,
-0.0367329232,
-0.0298239887,
-0.0427785628,
0.0588871948,
-0.024117332,
-0.00138932,
0.0446732901,
-0.0224112142,
0.0432527736,
0.0154558131,
-0.0170403477,
0.0506748781,
0.0446080789,
-0.0467383973,
-0.0678309351,
0.0341018699,
-0.0001568989,
-0.0816471055,
0.0186502412,
-0.0325299874,
-0.0011424968,
-0.0474704504,
-0.063529253,
-0.0113188876,
-0.0100728832,
-0.0327842049,
-0.0029538304,
0.0164712053,
-0.0184127837,
0.0272798501,
-0.0156305917,
-0.0644206479,
0.0506580509,
0.0251765344,
0.0180952642,
0.0021852017,
-0.0942836329,
0.015385218,
-0.0246203933,
-0.010854817,
-0.0139603401,
-0.0197556559,
-0.0067222454,
0.0176713597,
-0.0301521719,
-0.0131067131,
-0.0096639795,
-0.0842675194,
0.0373939276,
0.0176211987,
0.0219463687,
-0.0023355589,
0.0023133366,
-0.0013353169,
-0.0453865752,
-0.0469693616,
-0.0320926607,
0.0550098009,
0.0271176286,
0.0402177759,
0.0573820658,
0.0122161694,
-0.0490903407,
-0.0163249411,
-0.035142161,
0.0598457344,
0.0121555449,
-0.0696984529,
-0.0241683386,
-0.0180115085,
-0.0103675872,
0.0188421588,
0.0029007741,
0.0674672499,
0.0249386895,
-0.0128052011,
0.0217441637,
0.0624391325,
-0.0176440272,
0.0126254847,
0.0419490933,
0.0158993844,
-0.0392033458,
0.0117310556,
-0.062374372,
0.0026670643,
0.0206345934,
-0.0068641501,
0.0432543904,
0.0388177335,
0.0353470743,
-0.0316661522,
-0.0210352335,
0.0042162603,
0.0068065408,
-0.0012412801,
-0.0170204658,
-0.0061967229,
0.0042115757,
-0.0178719349,
-0.0225495715,
-0.054911267,
0.1369790137,
0.0016868053,
0.032564126,
-0.0998328775,
-0.0179605689,
-0.0439890921,
0.0185191613,
0.0090635568,
0.0116601316,
0.0817836151,
0.0003033556,
0.0283724051,
0.0248123184,
0.0563302934,
-0.0491788834,
0.0443358496,
-0.0289151873,
0.074825123,
0.0031452947,
-0.0323761068,
-0.0377422087,
-0.0185776241,
-0.0398270637,
0.0032152792,
0.0029307338,
0.0271292832,
-0.0990837738,
0.0099661928,
0.007363983,
0.0339623541,
0.0018232784,
-0.0007117642,
-0.0021634772,
-0.0307631958,
0.0381809101,
-0.0277866442,
-0.0082928874,
-0.0048384154,
0.0191861279,
0.0773072988,
0.0179997049,
0.0430481993,
-0.0347634181,
-0.0135130864,
-0.0020386332,
-0.0742693767,
0.0104208253,
0.0071334187,
0.0309419129,
-0.0389370732,
0.0112637999,
0.0681370571,
0.0155419623,
-0.0593469813,
-0.009057425,
0.02394283,
-0.0343967974,
-0.0161647163,
0.0206045825,
-0.057087671,
-0.0414177738,
-0.0172655936,
-0.0009483121,
-0.0305710454,
-0.0380149409,
-0.0112943584,
-0.0294238739,
0.0170613658,
-0.0120691154,
0.0022434276,
-0.0382858068,
-0.1027786955,
0.0101993047,
-0.064877741,
-0.0484642014,
-0.0307784434,
-0.0229586717,
0.0148414187,
0.0221482124,
-0.0371391065,
-0.0875317752,
0.0118292347,
-0.0554823726,
0.0420640893,
0.0304416884,
0.0093442444,
0.0086731566,
-0.0113706356,
-0.0527714156,
-0.0220724065,
-0.0245198421,
-0.0025053748,
0.073508285,
-0.000179423,
0.0245969929,
-0.0364256278,
0.0306725726,
-0.0576886907,
-0.0338365883,
0.0114519317,
0.0827104077,
-0.0482182801,
-0.0253830142,
-0.0525982231,
0.0260619111,
0.0457509756,
0.0700066537,
-0.0276857801,
0.0292159896,
-0.00989067,
0.0323142186,
0.0064050769,
-0.0099029718,
0.0054187034,
0.0191812273,
-0.0344483145,
0.0635989234,
-0.0671214461,
0.0013144142,
0.0924163014,
0.041330196,
0.004505015,
0.0437885374,
-0.0171731487,
-0.0068607577,
-0.054489471,
0.0676620305,
0.0426462814,
0.0254235696,
-0.005911008,
-0.0396588258,
0.0656551942,
0.0047539156,
-0.021280719,
0.0516589843,
-0.0431618206,
-0.021824792,
-0.0501615293,
0.0465729907,
0.0220309645,
-0.011993235,
0.0065936199,
0.0040008938,
0.0331285335,
0.0148046836,
-0.0018401233,
-0.0888240114,
-0.0103566274,
-0.0294553675,
-0.0210237075,
-0.0034126446,
-0.0147411525,
0.0452994704,
-0.0038098004,
0.0382523201,
0.0008013789,
0.0041783256,
0.0797665045,
0.0223731436,
0.04804888,
-0.0118746189,
-0.0395341516,
-0.0510780439,
-0.0357078128,
-0.0228194203,
-0.0075128311,
-0.0363935605,
0.0618900433,
-0.0032688202,
-0.0249453131,
-0.004271151,
0.0249525923,
-0.0454740375,
0.0135683604,
-0.0484708287,
0.0298688486,
0.0479018204,
-0.0120157618,
0.0317794308,
-0.0216304138,
-0.0239876434,
-0.0030298908,
-0.0033646233,
0.0288347658,
-0.0208494682,
0.0331354737,
0.0242714547,
0.0235550255,
-0.0230095405,
0.0560282283,
-0.0652884692,
-0.0242680889,
-0.0415597633,
0.022171814,
0.0376863629,
-0.0091691548,
0.0355993062,
-0.0418126844,
0.001850281,
-0.042743586,
0.0372281633,
0.0065226238,
0.0299713053,
0.0473565534,
0.0129848514,
-0.0278723054,
-0.0313075334,
0.0813760012,
0.0022807065,
0.0227239598,
-0.0066972114,
-0.0660839528,
-0.0483983047,
-0.039632719,
-0.0047275559,
0.0195019469,
-0.0534467772,
-0.0218924582,
-0.028346343,
-0.0037164127,
0.0342824534,
-0.0095096054,
-0.0191603992,
0.0006406578,
0.0075811711,
0.0547129102,
0.0453569926,
-0.0329382159,
-0.0344608799,
0.0343204662,
-0.0044539208,
-0.0136857387,
-0.0309710447,
-5.139621664e-33,
0.0281917267,
-0.0105559267,
-0.0008371543,
-0.0291879047,
0.0373284854,
0.0156175382,
-0.0276721977,
-0.0351333991,
-0.0094861034,
0.046391841,
0.0043329461,
-0.0012971245,
0.0190116838,
0.0080834646,
0.0159200877,
-0.0082529727,
0.018838238,
0.0166714918,
-0.0199959371,
0.0118434355,
0.0309067145,
0.0444980338,
0.0665552765,
-0.0710941851,
0.0550612696,
0.0444356538,
0.0224921498,
0.02228182,
-0.0171345919,
0.0476564392,
-0.0198229477,
0.061798647,
0.0453616567,
-0.048353143,
-0.010789793,
-0.0083247153,
-0.0836308599,
-0.0127940699,
0.0058324649,
-0.0466511659,
-0.0477556549,
0.0377510078,
0.0553675257,
-0.0112365941,
0.0218804888,
-0.0184389595,
0.0412171185,
-0.0498374663,
-0.0076710526,
-0.0500636064,
-0.0582612008,
0.0399227031,
0.0021764091,
0.0046438198,
-0.0076239407,
0.0580140278,
-0.0025046414,
0.0174778793,
-0.0144260731,
0.0092569869,
-0.0362890176,
0.0180818234,
-0.0116844429,
-0.0375153795,
-0.0343576297,
0.0673294887,
-0.0038698814,
0.0036406501,
-0.0356206223,
-0.0113216992,
-0.0568343848,
0.0566240437,
0.0248370208,
0.0112586115,
0.0190720912,
0.0255822279,
-0.0904369056,
0.0508462489,
0.0359762162,
0.0588719137,
0.0051082722,
-0.015721349,
-0.0318721123,
-0.0070166276,
-0.0189735871,
-0.0237787534,
-0.0082815532,
-0.0083230855,
0.0153897265,
0.0202977527,
-0.0089291241,
0.0444562323,
0.0320950672,
-0.0078829359,
-0.0006799046,
-0.0213226434,
0.0752079785,
-0.0193095654,
-0.0103129009,
0.0235253982,
-0.0499748811,
-0.0238863789,
0.020195283,
-0.0023585425,
0.0313783512,
0.0008718256,
0.0400136486,
-0.0445214286,
-0.0379439183,
0.0006441526,
-0.0119464416,
0.0122389598,
-0.0182977505,
0.0567523763,
0.0336624943,
0.0742859691,
0.0071749301,
0.0542817712,
-0.0036972184,
-0.0068607619,
-0.0179179385,
-0.0216003656,
0.0100238128,
0.0008066769,
-0.0163285583,
-0.0026961481,
-0.0291431751,
0.0006999213,
0.0013663743,
-0.0316636339,
0.0012241282,
-0.0075492687,
2.396e-7,
0.1009590328,
0.0176083986,
0.0216739606,
-0.0162576847,
0.0168275386,
0.0056233113,
-0.0036275655,
0.0111626824,
0.0312427618,
-0.0190313179,
0.0133631248,
0.0019277682,
0.0104917148,
0.0371262878,
-0.0668187216,
-0.0757193714,
-0.0493496805,
-0.0437810309,
-0.0429527648,
-0.0228681825,
0.0721969232,
0.0586272888,
-0.0281268042,
0.0027101252,
-0.0236385874,
-0.0271278638,
0.0236627255,
-0.0023354909,
0.0078658843,
0.0464759506,
0.0637820214,
-0.0641801953,
0.0319841839,
0.0809960365,
-0.0244182032,
0.0102034668,
-0.0122467754,
0.0605581552,
-0.0327779576,
0.0260194186,
0.0125267562,
-0.0051863003,
0.0543469563,
-0.0138196852,
0.0603008606,
-0.0874491706,
-0.0470501184,
-0.0454197079,
-0.0216537938,
-0.0036948412,
0.055930607,
0.0314653479,
-0.0269320142,
0.0438232049,
0.0099180816,
0.0422881767,
-0.0358769931,
-0.0898998454,
0.0089697866,
0.065112181,
-0.0437541753,
0.0013466848,
0.0473346747,
-0.0185317416,
0.0052136271,
-0.0986488461,
0.0157504901,
2.16713312e-34,
0.0289074872,
0.0106697818,
0.0109605156,
0.0293099303,
0.0366265513,
-0.0199005976,
-0.0464284755,
-0.0038727536,
-0.0000618166,
-0.0755595714,
-0.0095581776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13149v1 | Modeling Spoken Information Queries for Virtual Assistants: Open Problems, Challenges and Opportunities | 2023-04-25T20:52:40 | 2023-04-25T20:52:40 | Christophe Van Gysel | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Virtual assistants are becoming increasingly important speech-driven
Information Retrieval platforms that assist users with various tasks.
We discuss open problems and challenges with respect to modeling spoken
information queries for virtual assistants, and list opportunities where
Information Retrieval methods and research can be applied to improve the
quality of virtual assistant speech recognition.
We discuss how query domain classification, knowledge graphs and user
interaction data, and query personalization can be helpful to improve the
accurate recognition of spoken information domain queries. Finally, we also
provide a brief overview of current problems and challenges in speech
recognition. | [
0.038136065,
0.0258348286,
-0.0174717084,
0.0263200589,
-0.0101306047,
-0.0215608887,
-0.0056990618,
0.0193972532,
0.0253808033,
-0.0492367484,
-0.0649478585,
-0.0482242666,
0.0039146543,
-0.0252532512,
-0.002700534,
-0.0826957598,
0.0401514769,
-0.0511099212,
0.0139353564,
0.0094007459,
-0.0150904581,
0.0278698057,
-0.0490963832,
0.0595181733,
-0.0000039734,
-0.0038143413,
-0.0056317928,
0.0246038157,
-0.0214905571,
0.0089715682,
-0.0452192426,
0.0260945596,
0.0168120824,
0.0109161241,
0.0000013635,
-0.0131580187,
-0.0196410716,
0.0100110732,
-0.0668882355,
-0.0165443383,
0.0282492358,
0.0393803269,
0.0066006668,
0.0474204086,
-0.0191040374,
-0.0242080688,
0.0234465487,
0.026058685,
0.0129735265,
0.0261941478,
0.0011954355,
0.0195160974,
0.0095664952,
0.0165242478,
0.0283772424,
-0.0686248466,
-0.004282516,
0.0025479086,
0.0630223304,
-0.0176902916,
0.0233081039,
0.0445295721,
-0.0353875682,
-0.0063531143,
0.003437595,
0.0243902355,
-0.0540470891,
-0.0133840572,
-0.0166789442,
0.0617968515,
0.0442722067,
0.0163567048,
0.0320266485,
0.0270269457,
0.0026794593,
0.0494874418,
-0.0249191541,
-0.0586596578,
-0.0347663946,
-0.0548248142,
-0.0134040564,
0.053203024,
0.0054105679,
0.0014538337,
-0.0141638042,
0.0249182153,
0.0138411149,
-0.0540614799,
0.0196379796,
-0.0500257649,
-0.0071338769,
0.0042239898,
0.0339592807,
0.0036535182,
-0.0490042493,
0.031810645,
-0.0184086394,
-0.0372972824,
-0.0067508169,
-0.0318339206,
0.0411451459,
0.0440222248,
-0.0276919361,
0.0209181122,
0.0692035034,
0.0639148057,
-0.0137341758,
0.0052323109,
-0.0274148062,
-0.0199276712,
-0.0551198013,
-0.0098815039,
-0.0581613034,
0.0347369723,
-0.0186693314,
-0.0150223896,
-0.0058156098,
0.0348951817,
0.0196462367,
-0.0173610877,
0.010417155,
0.0535737239,
-0.0265081022,
-0.003472982,
-0.0455584861,
0.00703937,
-0.0052484549,
0.0394246802,
-0.0260284673,
-0.0652504116,
0.0330236033,
-0.0142980181,
0.0449033193,
-0.0044913073,
-0.0105853239,
0.0301686414,
0.0122571616,
-0.0563515089,
-0.0044919387,
-0.0376735665,
0.0136725679,
-0.0028119148,
-0.0058275419,
0.0159986336,
0.0529596135,
-0.0216435585,
0.0015982009,
0.0199392289,
-0.0101008946,
0.0289830212,
-0.011704321,
0.0867691487,
-0.0063342568,
0.0362227671,
0.0751686916,
0.0193160549,
0.022413576,
0.0355872363,
-0.0035452805,
-0.0114812171,
0.0437866524,
-0.0199880563,
0.011937025,
-0.0014378711,
0.0020138319,
-0.0159895476,
-0.0005515259,
0.05383531,
-0.0341654271,
0.0090934392,
-0.0156609714,
0.046099823,
-0.0406949446,
-0.029564498,
0.021509191,
0.0840789229,
0.0277976487,
-0.0397821367,
0.0257327966,
0.0297127701,
0.0098764626,
0.0104488516,
-0.0033681653,
-0.0252971929,
0.0039050903,
-0.0103672724,
0.0262904819,
-0.023276329,
-0.0510813855,
-0.0419203788,
0.0181320366,
-0.0260365605,
-0.0273185819,
0.0462181941,
0.0142035587,
-0.0277595911,
-0.0206442196,
-0.0042557805,
-0.0145356581,
-0.0512697697,
0.0086172475,
-0.0375036858,
0.0164483227,
0.1101657823,
0.0840974972,
-0.0387616679,
-0.033249069,
0.0058142645,
-0.0445647053,
0.0216480829,
-0.0025401723,
-0.0493759289,
0.0050144973,
-0.0295126885,
-0.0092907874,
0.0759620443,
-0.0015990256,
0.0427839719,
-0.0337491147,
-0.0012629245,
0.0487723798,
-0.0624722876,
0.0448252782,
-0.0103917029,
0.0179724135,
-0.0529996864,
0.0159621388,
0.0598468259,
0.0546018369,
0.0796622857,
-0.0010278329,
0.0042581181,
0.0428453349,
0.0005372213,
0.0076339645,
0.0142728742,
-0.0276629608,
0.0143115614,
0.026746558,
0.0081433346,
0.0547669567,
0.0215658825,
0.0501121357,
-0.0546007156,
0.0103432834,
-0.0410616025,
0.0700424165,
-0.0334363766,
0.0336598083,
0.0237479489,
-0.0071286848,
-0.010341052,
-0.0002726729,
0.00169922,
-0.0031157548,
0.0772911236,
-0.0103418753,
0.0077915974,
-0.0568678491,
0.0128957704,
0.0100702075,
-0.0096073961,
0.0349786133,
-0.0094745448,
-0.0660743341,
-0.0170795191,
0.0171438549,
-0.1278334707,
-0.0201088116,
-0.0076390593,
0.0140915737,
-0.0209271982,
0.0435786024,
-0.0265387893,
-0.0499579236,
-0.0326915123,
-0.0307570882,
0.0195264369,
0.0115924049,
-0.0350220725,
0.0028843284,
-0.0292137563,
-0.0352725871,
0.0112276664,
-0.006374748,
-0.02299322,
-0.0258004405,
-0.0464159809,
-0.0334266238,
0.0046589361,
-0.0351061709,
0.0581341721,
-0.030748697,
-0.0177521612,
0.0140226083,
-0.0143246129,
0.0076224343,
0.0403047688,
0.0153160207,
-0.0058914791,
0.0289940648,
-0.0272328071,
-0.0750338957,
0.0477161072,
-0.0145916967,
0.0129678166,
-0.0040191859,
0.0144378413,
0.0411581062,
0.0034484426,
0.0296495911,
0.0481481105,
-0.0699591488,
-0.0234859493,
-0.0182278547,
-0.0426593348,
-0.0017621402,
-0.0023952478,
-0.0288250446,
0.0580181703,
0.0238266457,
-0.0098884022,
0.0332169458,
-0.0741039962,
-0.0021107248,
-0.0505535454,
-0.0356463529,
-0.0070779296,
0.0327813663,
-0.0461870916,
0.0109520489,
0.0264101066,
-0.0543912873,
-0.0191843603,
0.0108082034,
0.0109884171,
-0.061595656,
0.0185238346,
-0.0158057921,
0.015010478,
0.0220958535,
-0.015829714,
-0.0362768583,
0.0041829562,
-0.0447436012,
-0.0314105749,
0.011405454,
-0.0429846272,
-0.0111980326,
0.0472958423,
0.0009230879,
0.0119842151,
-0.0015429606,
-0.0058994223,
-0.0189709961,
0.0101834433,
0.0515051298,
0.0706489384,
-0.091130361,
0.0565220863,
0.0260483865,
-0.0066744266,
0.0959986374,
-0.0449294336,
0.0233085118,
-0.0231454819,
0.0657227263,
-0.0304232556,
-0.0330675915,
0.0477615222,
0.0026410185,
-0.0040701288,
0.0321755633,
0.1002840325,
0.0327608772,
-0.0291398223,
-0.0402831137,
-0.0331087634,
0.0003045592,
0.0090738488,
0.0597802438,
-0.0785589144,
-0.0156319141,
0.012521863,
0.0866418928,
0.0001551187,
0.0036745777,
-0.0042553912,
-0.1148159727,
0.0401568115,
-0.0160372015,
0.0027902722,
-0.043949157,
-0.0386355519,
0.0222987123,
-0.0168931875,
0.0003792812,
-0.0414706692,
-0.0105971824,
-0.0178070329,
0.0399263203,
0.0018373275,
-0.0310105048,
0.0439844839,
0.0069509745,
0.056254223,
0.0645210221,
0.0558092371,
0.0543534905,
-0.0542331859,
-0.0754120201,
-0.0221246127,
0.0336272717,
-0.0264635999,
0.0616747588,
-0.0443419293,
0.0067260223,
0.0177706368,
-0.0110243876,
-0.0191010758,
0.0253483392,
0.0305031016,
0.0447481498,
-0.0713764429,
0.0512381196,
-0.0335280001,
0.0293144844,
0.0155751202,
0.0425814427,
0.0083935978,
0.0137722436,
0.0183228999,
0.0131590823,
0.0680676475,
-0.0150624812,
-0.0381551348,
-0.0304277223,
-0.0033401607,
-0.0201067012,
-0.0670205951,
-0.0392137095,
0.0135651687,
0.0466005392,
0.0195397492,
0.0334114097,
0.0671456233,
0.0530217439,
-0.0184732899,
-0.0060610687,
-0.0366179496,
0.0235792771,
-0.0729963109,
-0.0409211814,
0.037891265,
-0.0724844933,
-0.0213773176,
-0.0367670394,
0.0066433903,
-0.054914318,
-0.0117689278,
0.0056222719,
0.018341748,
0.0538977161,
-0.0608748943,
-0.0431173667,
0.014817181,
0.0258521512,
-0.093204312,
-0.0291223321,
0.0751281008,
-0.0113098808,
-0.0373831019,
0.0247039013,
-0.0661747679,
-0.0035492633,
-0.0589890778,
-0.0089690061,
-0.0753892362,
-0.106368877,
0.0048363255,
0.040213149,
0.0620041899,
0.0122091463,
0.0374035724,
-0.0281837489,
0.0639297739,
0.0067630839,
0.025689695,
-0.0445009209,
-0.0308631286,
-0.0157280546,
-0.0087367808,
-0.003035858,
-0.0230562612,
-0.0749284625,
-0.0166298244,
-0.0232721101,
-0.0066802939,
-0.0012773271,
0.0412393287,
0.0210536625,
0.0018225585,
-0.0022229953,
0.0574858822,
0.0473852418,
0.0521781966,
-0.0238033365,
0.0234862808,
-0.0169207007,
-0.0206417833,
-0.0137790693,
0.049098447,
-0.0699779466,
-0.0709639117,
0.0089033945,
0.0198345296,
0.0248643477,
-0.0269730408,
0.0069443444,
-0.0029753193,
0.0453885496,
-0.0176641755,
0.0158860553,
0.0102182487,
0.0117736179,
0.0356809422,
0.034177687,
-0.0003188536,
0.0013563836,
0.0668927059,
-0.0136683024,
0.0719288662,
-0.0474689975,
-0.0153428884,
-0.0508415923,
-0.0484589078,
0.0183788277,
0.0451994911,
-0.0517537408,
-0.0141651705,
-0.0436762683,
-0.0283911806,
0.0319557227,
-0.0424391553,
-0.0307845883,
-0.0548961833,
0.0502885953,
0.0516684614,
-0.0003359952,
0.0161394943,
-0.0083613507,
-0.0885321721,
-0.0803326592,
0.0146685224,
0.0154801169,
-4.805136951e-33,
-0.0569162294,
0.0025659851,
0.0126408637,
-0.0208976753,
0.0000462849,
-0.0021519735,
-0.0039719502,
0.0061786058,
-0.0396530516,
-0.0793498829,
-0.0452283137,
0.0055927997,
0.0388046764,
-0.018700486,
-0.0451941602,
-0.0321464092,
0.0479017496,
-0.0208703838,
0.0285140071,
0.0312034469,
0.0261277836,
0.0444867611,
-0.0092517342,
-0.100392893,
-0.0033607893,
-0.0070097223,
0.0313978158,
0.0173257571,
0.0217327643,
0.0499625392,
-0.0228022337,
0.0435427018,
0.0014028007,
-0.0151089346,
0.0123756751,
0.0223026462,
-0.0609900877,
-0.012381183,
0.0379832983,
0.0369608551,
0.0101339165,
0.0011745087,
-0.016937552,
0.0330612399,
0.0234543253,
0.0290690046,
0.0328391716,
-0.001728157,
-0.0313696936,
-0.0083118035,
-0.0388171524,
0.0144210588,
-0.0090101594,
-0.0458522588,
0.0632975325,
0.0711894631,
0.0500351749,
-0.0193816964,
-0.0175786,
0.0573175363,
0.0049822656,
0.0132972691,
0.0503455475,
0.0359916054,
-0.0029628177,
0.0310554337,
0.0344380252,
-0.0517072678,
-0.0285942238,
-0.0084913447,
-0.0069494848,
0.0447000638,
-0.0081895404,
0.019957751,
-0.0203353092,
-0.0363609716,
0.024184566,
0.0084558157,
0.0171692837,
0.0162811149,
-0.024714116,
0.0224635415,
-0.0860049054,
0.0161194205,
-0.0465220176,
0.0084056845,
-0.0439058281,
-0.019475339,
0.0748905241,
0.0119393449,
-0.0168838017,
-0.0335984826,
0.0125518963,
-0.0209300611,
0.0194202401,
0.015673792,
0.0056598359,
-0.0158200748,
-0.0244855676,
-0.0118724937,
-0.02794577,
-0.0026272086,
0.055227343,
-0.0121270726,
-0.0168711729,
0.0126422606,
-0.0623632967,
0.0306279324,
-0.0169302784,
-0.0201183874,
0.0178914405,
0.0068748654,
-0.029405674,
0.0247288086,
0.0563897304,
0.0024425711,
-0.0159297902,
0.0514077805,
0.0029717253,
0.0114632882,
-0.0365842208,
-0.0534122474,
-0.0052884747,
-0.0038174007,
-0.026289897,
0.00413018,
-0.0037284554,
0.0035974237,
-0.005334673,
0.0002841879,
-0.0015425684,
-0.0261037331,
2.312e-7,
-0.0264304355,
0.029166678,
-0.005223657,
0.0534495004,
-0.047812175,
0.0351256728,
0.0242777281,
0.0080798324,
0.0118181454,
-0.0010216004,
0.0748000294,
-0.0155935343,
0.0570728891,
0.0193063729,
-0.101723209,
-0.052174665,
-0.0225453805,
-0.0117947655,
-0.0472280569,
-0.0114318011,
0.0644148961,
0.0675900877,
-0.0286628883,
-0.0166579988,
-0.0142878527,
-0.0290258192,
-0.0139319729,
0.0083011817,
-0.0173120592,
-0.0094604241,
0.0519909598,
0.0462093949,
-0.0225047451,
0.020026613,
-0.0329346992,
0.0747595206,
0.0401250012,
0.0098371785,
-0.0211964492,
-0.0706470385,
-0.0061362707,
0.0042511937,
-0.0030744066,
0.0344634242,
0.0682785809,
0.0230897851,
0.0121739041,
0.0401774459,
-0.0030796011,
-0.0105052441,
-0.0156263169,
-0.0045943041,
-0.0046043424,
-0.0000212688,
-0.0143481502,
-0.0266532656,
-0.0090450142,
-0.0798893273,
0.0482527167,
-0.0252155941,
-0.0416748486,
0.0031306704,
-0.0404235981,
-0.0088944836,
0.0009935943,
-0.0028560429,
0.0086319158,
1.364430731e-34,
-0.0031141159,
0.0216547828,
0.0024262238,
0.0289655086,
0.0030301118,
0.0043236855,
0.0243121479,
0.0198061336,
0.0583221912,
-0.0591115765,
-0.0099343946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13134v1 | LAST: Scalable Lattice-Based Speech Modelling in JAX | 2023-04-25T20:25:37 | 2023-04-25T20:25:37 | Ke Wu, Ehsan Variani, Tom Bagby, Michael Riley | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce LAST, a LAttice-based Speech Transducer library in JAX. With an
emphasis on flexibility, ease-of-use, and scalability, LAST implements
differentiable weighted finite state automaton (WFSA) algorithms needed for
training \& inference that scale to a large WFSA such as a recognition lattice
over the entire utterance. Despite these WFSA algorithms being well-known in
the literature, new challenges arise from performance characteristics of modern
architectures, and from nuances in automatic differentiation. We describe a
suite of generally applicable techniques employed in LAST to address these
challenges, and demonstrate their effectiveness with benchmarks on TPUv3 and
V100 GPU. | [
-0.0105094453,
0.0995565802,
-0.019308161,
0.0513369963,
0.0112427529,
-0.0108575085,
0.0258514564,
0.0171543118,
-0.0656505451,
0.0038987421,
-0.0319763646,
-0.019865036,
0.0351946615,
-0.0013341072,
-0.0196760446,
-0.0977354944,
-0.0031889342,
-0.0686420202,
-0.020318903,
-0.0095551359,
-0.0065905815,
-0.0136305802,
-0.0256370269,
0.0455866195,
-0.0052943747,
0.0049778689,
-0.0151077742,
-0.025534695,
0.0461655743,
-0.0123713305,
-0.0373771898,
0.0127769904,
0.0063735377,
0.0385423601,
0.0000021955,
0.0027792032,
0.0324074961,
0.0189734343,
-0.0236434489,
0.0071701137,
-0.0287932605,
-0.0568901859,
-0.0511149317,
0.0042432798,
-0.0180009678,
-0.0611110777,
0.0647087768,
-0.0118439477,
0.0754354596,
0.0243566241,
0.003936172,
-0.0314425528,
0.024818819,
-0.0071144998,
-0.0221965723,
-0.1218038127,
0.0293140374,
-0.0090864655,
0.0581132248,
-0.0350903049,
0.0105359396,
0.0155375265,
-0.0222268514,
-0.0081035905,
-0.0271712691,
-0.0060119373,
0.015903553,
0.0089484109,
-0.0637566596,
0.0696413741,
0.0638448745,
-0.024440933,
0.0216296092,
0.0258122515,
-0.0587276965,
-0.0254864637,
0.0114220707,
0.0286144204,
0.0160668287,
-0.0345642604,
0.0089782663,
0.0408777855,
0.0055035981,
-0.0159004945,
-0.0304241385,
0.0837563649,
0.0366147347,
-0.0010130828,
-0.0583661869,
-0.0130719291,
0.0234869737,
-0.0207473822,
0.0763324201,
0.0368938185,
-0.0076772426,
-0.0047685662,
-0.0262332205,
-0.0623385049,
-0.028198339,
-0.0404853709,
0.0367047191,
0.0455322117,
0.0073597068,
0.00503748,
0.0233356468,
0.0147620793,
0.0005333215,
0.0124619873,
-0.0227065403,
0.0041225785,
-0.0228904765,
0.0134681072,
-0.0224358197,
-0.0077489396,
-0.0494011343,
-0.0214999802,
-0.0146839228,
0.0393366031,
-0.0086824214,
-0.0280180071,
0.0171905216,
-0.0238839667,
-0.0100643132,
-0.005113929,
0.0299351998,
0.0285416096,
-0.0489193723,
0.0255465135,
-0.0011435782,
-0.0947991163,
-0.006259989,
-0.0204206668,
0.0285345018,
0.0238483436,
0.0034963845,
0.0149946818,
0.0193375796,
-0.0091530839,
-0.0350079685,
0.0412053205,
0.0173127167,
-0.0719175786,
-0.0114889871,
-0.0517240614,
0.0184979849,
-0.0029897692,
0.0304671936,
0.0191654544,
0.0305986702,
0.0048239776,
0.0415451154,
0.0397949554,
-0.0002812016,
0.0040771519,
0.033170484,
0.00605522,
0.0720974281,
0.0369077399,
0.0328584425,
-0.017099876,
-0.0179005843,
-0.0159520116,
0.0012290751,
0.0535399877,
-0.0181223266,
0.0124576315,
-0.055108726,
-0.0133284386,
0.0202449877,
0.027672084,
0.0424024351,
0.0645653531,
-0.0250435155,
-0.0254128687,
0.0283959247,
0.0524994023,
0.0236615986,
0.0355845988,
0.0075572217,
0.0198101401,
0.0529340766,
-0.0460784584,
0.0101160584,
0.003815833,
-0.0069922563,
0.012945517,
-0.0072332979,
0.0545746163,
-0.027001163,
-0.0143540325,
-0.0122741042,
-0.0218045115,
-0.0311327539,
-0.0386682153,
0.0165367331,
0.0029907874,
-0.0194879528,
0.0146518676,
0.0191302113,
-0.0516387224,
-0.0588429645,
-0.0599338785,
0.0173333734,
0.0360152386,
0.0200364944,
-0.0440545306,
0.0024204191,
0.0019743436,
-0.037256822,
0.0393093973,
-0.0338358246,
0.0080243303,
0.0422332771,
-0.0518386178,
0.0122356238,
0.0969512761,
0.0309835821,
0.082577154,
-0.0230237041,
-0.0034879826,
0.0089359088,
-0.0698473155,
0.0079858834,
0.0335219465,
0.0274530202,
-0.0398754179,
0.0556977391,
0.0069040689,
0.0399169549,
0.0303055737,
-0.0110275839,
-0.0093187662,
-0.0060733547,
-0.0309317708,
0.0167749356,
0.017073933,
-0.0325498879,
-0.0126146479,
0.0231867824,
0.0354320221,
0.0365707874,
0.0655853897,
0.0027139699,
-0.069230549,
0.0379235037,
-0.0259034932,
0.0403125137,
-0.0370540954,
0.0063297022,
0.0203383286,
0.0587009937,
0.0064398465,
0.014074957,
-0.0225382037,
-0.0188347418,
0.0449130349,
-0.0539029278,
-0.00691497,
-0.0428216569,
-0.0142173665,
0.0185832754,
-0.0346504115,
0.0614551269,
-0.0594461486,
0.0026127652,
0.0299179554,
-0.0026512039,
-0.0342944935,
0.0046740742,
-0.0349410363,
0.0536579415,
0.0023831362,
0.0488762818,
-0.0287649054,
-0.0275979433,
0.003881789,
-0.0017862021,
-0.0280399323,
-0.012175967,
-0.0245980453,
0.0278753899,
-0.0189614333,
-0.0492534898,
-0.0240481384,
0.0086003449,
0.0203405023,
-0.0347459689,
-0.0252030361,
-0.0040457286,
-0.0110433362,
0.0046333899,
0.033666335,
0.0022395484,
0.0007030984,
-0.0065417467,
-0.021171337,
-0.0065482859,
0.0445069559,
-0.000531406,
-0.0216384176,
-0.0042910697,
-0.0174944066,
-0.0150232315,
0.0280176997,
0.0191995408,
0.039942991,
-0.0055120625,
0.0107147321,
-0.0309629124,
0.0379371308,
0.0278672967,
0.0105910935,
-0.0247363597,
-0.0457288101,
0.005355271,
-0.0222253036,
0.0249113217,
0.0020143832,
-0.0271939263,
0.0098941159,
0.022966763,
-0.0267783236,
0.0011700509,
-0.0913920701,
-0.0017351618,
-0.0383286439,
-0.0059106657,
-0.074043259,
0.0161791649,
0.0098662069,
-0.0072136158,
-0.0573337935,
-0.0302972235,
0.0618237071,
0.0035017887,
0.0103415791,
-0.0243142992,
0.010533453,
-0.0176714193,
0.0219570342,
-0.0236038156,
-0.0475687571,
-0.0114813205,
0.0780474171,
-0.0879162624,
-0.0145639908,
0.0144099593,
-0.0301697701,
0.0095189167,
0.0677162632,
-0.003240092,
0.0515627339,
-0.0067095119,
0.0138088409,
-0.0200146772,
0.0612084605,
0.0031561586,
0.0853038728,
0.0209301002,
0.0229453295,
0.0420176052,
-0.0472775362,
0.1134026647,
0.0074659348,
-0.1003537476,
-0.0070733479,
0.0595599115,
-0.0269185062,
0.0077457316,
0.0606477112,
0.0265652388,
-0.0583142266,
0.0172548257,
0.0290264264,
0.0179635417,
0.001670477,
-0.0008874722,
0.015842421,
0.0467154831,
0.0118944729,
0.0314473286,
-0.0364771821,
-0.0357362777,
0.0648552477,
0.037260212,
-0.0019313794,
-0.0028029461,
0.0175458621,
-0.0762707144,
0.0685383007,
0.0051232143,
0.0206066407,
0.0254471395,
-0.0791605264,
0.0338911191,
-0.0059481119,
-0.0213400815,
0.0160240792,
-0.021266507,
-0.0308549702,
0.0360915884,
-0.0683076084,
0.0092784455,
0.0037871755,
0.0038352753,
0.0775834247,
0.0404819623,
0.0402759016,
-0.0406869315,
-0.0862609521,
0.0548716597,
-0.0221226811,
0.0183268189,
-0.0452045314,
-0.0183120985,
0.0219121091,
-0.0412935652,
0.0051841056,
0.0486155264,
-0.0099799735,
0.0367378518,
0.0348665528,
0.0328101702,
0.0149723087,
0.0374155603,
-0.0436732732,
-0.0030987991,
0.0254308023,
-0.0256457422,
-0.0037563797,
-0.0090824515,
-0.0624713711,
-0.0261163954,
0.0005002003,
-0.0239165947,
-0.0418106429,
-0.0339151286,
0.0373645723,
-0.0253746696,
-0.030545298,
0.0058164196,
-0.0313389488,
0.0686983541,
0.0382723026,
-0.0217195973,
-0.0190926921,
0.0375474729,
-0.0318141542,
-0.0538849607,
-0.0292621274,
0.0764172226,
-0.008062508,
-0.0037742481,
0.0347000062,
-0.0343286358,
-0.0360420235,
0.0475428924,
-0.0573690832,
-0.000929768,
-0.0002307521,
0.010239685,
0.0182030182,
0.0210649185,
-0.0339505337,
0.0296553839,
0.0882514566,
0.0169601012,
-0.0329412334,
0.0304439627,
0.0745197609,
-0.0492911153,
0.0055877622,
0.0145724844,
-0.0097145969,
0.0205278397,
-0.0155512253,
0.0655571669,
0.0175727997,
-0.1034229398,
-0.0056702564,
0.0284170453,
-0.0289184488,
0.0503205657,
0.0169686936,
0.0021198704,
0.0195081793,
-0.011914921,
0.0719289556,
-0.0273574535,
0.0210056845,
-0.0089318352,
0.0237109177,
-0.0095516136,
-0.0203627944,
0.0698318854,
0.0117058903,
0.0267534684,
0.0777172446,
0.0052454779,
0.0295565706,
-0.0522287376,
-0.0124827083,
0.0086465357,
0.0060076849,
0.0753235817,
0.0364810824,
0.0049604136,
0.0453986339,
-0.020452749,
0.0077162203,
-0.0576937869,
0.0201659072,
-0.0345295705,
-0.0514531061,
-0.0505905934,
0.0029773111,
-0.0071312254,
0.0343002304,
0.0491909571,
-0.044878006,
0.0093021691,
-0.0397555456,
0.0093106525,
-0.0538356602,
0.0015779403,
-0.0009773888,
0.0017507712,
0.0030252016,
0.0322856382,
0.0348577462,
-0.0094797602,
0.0430766307,
0.0261100046,
0.036565382,
-0.0640654787,
-0.0474600941,
-0.0629753321,
-0.0157285314,
-0.016492134,
-0.036057055,
-0.0510963462,
-0.0491195917,
0.0454843752,
-0.0165982414,
0.0336415209,
-0.0625728518,
0.0388665013,
-0.0183982383,
0.0022910726,
0.0201203674,
-0.0154225975,
-0.0609582402,
-0.0199898332,
0.0056537609,
0.0584068261,
-6.128336942e-33,
-0.0312693231,
0.0681360215,
0.0439082533,
0.0433711261,
-0.0373732522,
0.0126388911,
-0.03631806,
0.0050869072,
-0.0113463597,
-0.0223905053,
-0.0380248539,
-0.003994972,
0.0393237397,
-0.0078311553,
-0.0226835981,
-0.0129122157,
0.0585515685,
-0.0179395005,
-0.0144230481,
0.0048212735,
-0.0134669421,
0.0375689529,
-0.016916614,
-0.0370608307,
-0.0234568212,
0.0308845323,
-0.0295931995,
-0.0300406907,
-0.0118655888,
0.0060438286,
-0.074722752,
0.0332121998,
-0.0370658785,
-0.0664684847,
-0.0163571239,
0.0414970666,
-0.0761750489,
-0.0083714146,
0.0220694505,
0.0397381112,
-0.014353917,
-0.0238521863,
-0.0190605521,
0.0560687371,
-0.038635876,
0.0206358489,
0.0011442947,
-0.0707152709,
-0.0410248972,
-0.0620596111,
-0.0325157456,
0.0428200997,
-0.0271534622,
-0.0280246995,
0.0540553741,
-0.0548173524,
-0.0781506673,
-0.0676432848,
-0.0523976795,
0.0139067983,
0.0384843759,
0.0558087118,
0.019701045,
0.0327175073,
0.0011260571,
-0.0054927166,
0.0638560131,
-0.0755205527,
0.0122264996,
0.020408662,
0.0191520844,
0.0124739306,
0.0018822992,
-0.0012451013,
0.0209611282,
-0.0624356866,
-0.0408285074,
-0.0252742227,
-0.0121019147,
0.0283545572,
0.0083807483,
-0.0149648301,
-0.0395792387,
0.026446566,
-0.0595077947,
-0.028217135,
-0.00870091,
0.022750197,
0.0417899266,
-0.0060874522,
-0.0421682,
-0.0211527739,
0.0214437991,
-0.0378829539,
-0.0176687557,
0.0058216755,
-0.0136023331,
-0.0039704973,
-0.0126976753,
-0.0123488568,
-0.0297521036,
-0.0287001561,
-0.0179952662,
0.0069388216,
0.0428217724,
-0.0574956909,
-0.0185664054,
0.0598218627,
-0.0745267272,
-0.0257051028,
-0.0006412782,
0.0259033535,
-0.0307322573,
0.0778823942,
0.0346056484,
-0.0425403975,
0.0383599475,
0.0219557621,
-0.038097389,
0.0250131674,
-0.0062667015,
0.0510013215,
0.0366270095,
0.024121495,
-0.043657437,
-0.0245243832,
-0.0321418159,
-0.0212665424,
0.0286144912,
-0.055319462,
-0.001887746,
-0.0058020367,
2.983e-7,
-0.0610346757,
0.0452380255,
0.0709919184,
-0.0251112245,
0.0158582069,
0.0355334356,
-0.0003703946,
-0.0152430069,
0.0347612128,
0.0105656683,
0.0289609116,
0.0130235953,
0.0898076594,
-0.0065712603,
-0.0758776665,
0.0432294495,
-0.0108667118,
-0.030029377,
-0.037497405,
-0.0222180672,
-0.064728871,
0.0846544579,
-0.0151239624,
-0.0134106865,
0.0375856869,
-0.0216522515,
0.005062771,
0.0366608724,
0.0430859551,
0.0195428114,
0.0096531231,
-0.0030958345,
-0.0030365656,
-0.0022476648,
-0.0005958506,
0.0628779083,
0.0014711361,
0.0654343292,
-0.0100535173,
-0.0262698401,
0.0163030922,
0.0077865035,
-0.0018079444,
0.0271290038,
0.0348590538,
0.0623421669,
-0.0137186786,
-0.0213381778,
0.001064281,
-0.0064769094,
-0.0217596758,
0.0122166891,
0.0742748529,
0.0055484618,
0.0081865285,
-0.016220009,
-0.004865753,
0.0013374898,
-0.0152379628,
-0.0410319865,
-0.0869478807,
-0.047784742,
-0.0343815796,
0.0080700591,
0.0299254637,
-0.028177755,
-0.0002467583,
2.602305032e-34,
0.0181826837,
-0.0301063154,
0.0072599957,
0.085391894,
-0.0017656231,
-0.0033175289,
-0.0266612023,
0.0277728587,
-0.0106625007,
-0.0491601974,
-0.0312213898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13060v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13060v2 | Injecting structural hints: Using language models to study inductive biases in language learning | 2023-04-25T18:00:08 | 2023-10-29T17:14:06 | Isabel Papadimitriou, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Both humans and large language models are able to learn language without
explicit structural supervision. What inductive biases make this learning
possible? We address this fundamental cognitive question by leveraging
transformer language models: we inject inductive bias into language models by
pretraining on formally-structured data, and then evaluate the biased learners'
ability to learn typologically-diverse natural languages. Our experimental
setup creates a testbed for hypotheses about inductive bias in human language
learning. We investigate the effect of injecting models with three types of
inductive bias: 1) recursive, hierarchical processing, 2) crossing token-token
relationships that can't be modeled by context-free grammars, and 3) a Zipfian
power-law vocabulary distribution. We show that non-context-free relationships
form the best inductive biases. Our study leverages the capabilities of
transformer models to run controlled language learning experiments that are not
possible to run on humans, and surfaces hypotheses about the structures that
facilitate language learning in both humans and machines. | [
0.004343532,
0.0476485565,
-0.0540612862,
0.0362121761,
-0.0400676243,
0.0483912639,
-0.0269762054,
-0.026062483,
0.0080384677,
-0.0450709723,
-0.0136863329,
-0.0218190551,
0.0092634242,
0.0065257973,
0.0411724597,
-0.0683568791,
0.0604944825,
-0.0611935779,
0.0243675224,
-0.0160812493,
-0.0453089811,
-0.0155986017,
-0.0237121563,
0.009547025,
-0.040495526,
0.0096003851,
-0.0031872329,
-0.0291388724,
-0.0684804544,
-0.0155958226,
0.0170889888,
0.0381718539,
0.0259872358,
0.0600562878,
0.000001918,
-0.0443839952,
0.0026100415,
-0.0141627733,
-0.0195508599,
-0.044742018,
0.0415439978,
-0.0474107526,
-0.02767618,
0.0041138008,
-0.0310858414,
-0.0329539701,
0.0714051127,
0.0352743231,
0.0145762619,
0.04584153,
-0.0155933229,
-0.0463103391,
0.0569166578,
0.013745307,
0.0552945137,
0.0230266917,
0.0253702197,
0.0089990385,
-0.0453416295,
-0.0114581343,
-0.0498603135,
-0.0026310747,
0.0251585003,
0.026035808,
0.0244708564,
0.0353765041,
-0.0304076467,
-0.0658344924,
-0.0226090066,
0.0218909103,
-0.0146431737,
-0.0718872175,
-0.0283859819,
-0.0069257938,
0.0527749732,
0.0572654195,
-0.0607842766,
0.0682837218,
0.0147957196,
0.0193020049,
0.0649697706,
-0.0496636368,
0.0276171193,
-0.0133154737,
-0.0345912091,
0.0917409286,
0.0152693745,
-0.0498495959,
0.0284326598,
0.0470456704,
0.0181582682,
-0.0334164053,
-0.0309285205,
-0.014248861,
-0.0299901292,
0.0409221426,
-0.0017674837,
-0.0126362043,
0.0151340077,
-0.0523326583,
0.0040573818,
0.0190104526,
-0.0270852484,
0.0223142412,
-0.0550279953,
0.0242701676,
-0.0187121611,
0.0484783463,
-0.0350708738,
-0.0096839117,
-0.0385807194,
-0.0591558926,
-0.0222012457,
0.0086488938,
-0.009804341,
0.0176487863,
-0.0073792837,
0.0299868211,
-0.005248101,
-0.0167410541,
-0.0485187136,
-0.0291113257,
-0.0478340536,
0.012381414,
-0.0330664627,
0.0102215568,
-0.0226422269,
0.0414213911,
-0.0195964947,
-0.0548412837,
-0.0140955504,
0.0004823423,
-0.0163590163,
-0.0278680567,
-0.0013123775,
0.064973779,
-0.0222562645,
-0.0424453393,
-0.0547193028,
0.0059568365,
0.0361811817,
-0.0226242729,
0.0627718642,
-0.059320759,
-0.0008814794,
0.0417074896,
0.0152335027,
-0.0344679579,
-0.0048840079,
0.0222751088,
-0.0577640496,
0.0650572628,
0.0087791532,
0.0198108125,
0.0053255991,
-0.0248851404,
-0.0272942651,
0.0760615021,
0.0059313024,
-0.0092133572,
0.0038433364,
-0.0356193781,
0.0101967612,
0.0287401192,
-0.0135745332,
-0.0023250044,
-0.0488066748,
-0.0192108881,
0.020835435,
0.0256129429,
0.0186481401,
0.0565030053,
-0.0092592537,
0.0337242596,
0.0381082408,
0.0444696881,
0.0023350208,
0.0351626687,
0.041138541,
-0.017607253,
0.001672767,
0.0445716977,
-0.0558298193,
-0.00523732,
-0.0346671864,
0.019930236,
-0.044194717,
-0.0075341035,
-0.0040507256,
-0.0266247056,
-0.0007574125,
-0.0025574814,
0.0546264872,
-0.0032508122,
0.0818572566,
0.0820636079,
-0.0496707112,
0.0513487197,
0.0640195161,
-0.0338752866,
-0.0003761606,
-0.025023628,
0.0112867821,
0.014885162,
0.0053918818,
-0.0278593563,
0.0243725032,
-0.0003866796,
0.0289849117,
0.0527490936,
0.0399487428,
-0.0221576057,
-0.0123302964,
-0.0164344478,
0.0008283323,
0.0303539485,
0.0268167257,
0.0014360317,
0.0070768632,
-0.038158793,
-0.0276442897,
-0.0397772826,
-0.0374785922,
0.0716279596,
-0.0345983207,
-0.0450098366,
-0.0366788022,
-0.0045902296,
0.0222624242,
-0.0297630541,
-0.0020165464,
0.0316269733,
0.0482425056,
-0.0250398181,
-0.0098126875,
0.0178761389,
-0.071666725,
-0.0259377975,
0.0183918849,
-0.0642379299,
-0.0154646719,
0.0084896553,
0.0134200044,
-0.0136206625,
0.0402047597,
-0.0642001629,
0.0995540395,
0.009041016,
0.039588809,
-0.0202058889,
-0.0025847536,
-0.0222113505,
0.0795470253,
-0.0023620967,
0.0222430211,
0.0266033709,
-0.0274119638,
-0.0286174025,
-0.005129931,
-0.0084104668,
0.0002857182,
-0.0038101529,
-0.0243367944,
0.0163533092,
-0.032405287,
-0.0708393678,
-0.0235167537,
-0.0499748848,
-0.0341347679,
-0.0087891789,
0.0062108296,
0.001195126,
-0.0085018156,
0.0059518204,
-0.0139299743,
-0.0215715356,
-0.0111045064,
-0.0172726512,
0.0712020323,
0.0413840488,
-0.0419704318,
-0.0448492505,
-0.0358450674,
-0.0498704389,
-0.0674687549,
0.0675369427,
0.0453954637,
-0.0182357337,
-0.045485232,
-0.0003448778,
0.0258253217,
0.0210832786,
-0.0151278246,
-0.0195603017,
0.0489293821,
-0.010559828,
0.0638738051,
0.0882158205,
0.0212987009,
0.0410712026,
0.0406040363,
-0.0093249641,
-0.0476466455,
-0.0170513801,
-0.0456872508,
-0.0188785158,
-0.0362335555,
-0.0329911523,
-0.0131381592,
0.1101489216,
0.0243989937,
-0.0034971838,
-0.0386194102,
0.0294679813,
-0.0284252446,
-0.0164408293,
-0.0060960534,
-0.0486408733,
-0.0400912687,
0.028454382,
-0.0254574101,
-0.065743126,
0.0545059033,
0.0033472627,
-0.0138918636,
-0.0166731309,
0.0271316897,
-0.0186228231,
0.0413825735,
0.0666205883,
0.0053033885,
0.0430452377,
-0.0183774028,
-0.0871794224,
0.0295126829,
0.0321807191,
-0.0068146894,
0.0317595154,
-0.0303464495,
-0.0271797124,
0.0190025717,
-0.014857037,
-0.0707685053,
0.0024599633,
-0.0333752558,
0.0066630016,
0.0483358242,
0.0035884033,
-0.0004195435,
-0.029993508,
0.029485913,
0.0343695134,
0.0466453284,
-0.0295215528,
-0.0016343632,
-0.0096815201,
0.0062677991,
-0.0174798332,
0.0463718139,
-0.0410075337,
-0.0029241333,
0.0269003268,
0.0341782793,
0.0119586103,
-0.0074428897,
0.053567946,
0.0363884419,
-0.0470498726,
-0.0303870197,
0.0265604518,
0.0075118709,
-0.0259982497,
-0.011142985,
0.0965456814,
0.0318820365,
-0.0345606245,
0.0538961589,
-0.0214404706,
0.0445090272,
0.0499510132,
0.0140551636,
-0.1034353673,
-0.0143084219,
0.0144847604,
-0.0346159078,
-0.0253533199,
-0.0460042618,
0.015112537,
-0.125280872,
-0.0193212833,
0.0135561116,
-0.0174351372,
0.0135765793,
-0.0458004549,
-0.0325257592,
-0.0135177551,
-0.0079471441,
0.0180682354,
-0.0494942069,
0.0037176094,
0.0188638736,
0.0045222929,
-0.0419452302,
0.004681462,
-0.0373831727,
0.0403651148,
0.02176244,
-0.0113423113,
-0.0752821639,
-0.0554091856,
0.0731108189,
-0.0046909209,
0.0127942162,
-0.0003038532,
0.0128972568,
0.0103232777,
0.0102521628,
-0.0317320153,
0.0497194119,
-0.0379162244,
-0.0357281938,
0.0142012564,
0.110540539,
0.0367465094,
-0.051744096,
0.0024801665,
-0.0176301003,
-0.0147723416,
0.0762260407,
0.031067118,
-0.0451270305,
0.0029680743,
-0.0555060692,
0.0285946652,
0.0563800521,
-0.0604289286,
0.0409149267,
0.0266691539,
-0.0025025846,
-0.0876459703,
-0.0238237754,
0.0433164313,
0.0095643643,
0.0389281288,
0.003922862,
0.0081296442,
-0.027911853,
-0.0286809988,
0.019137498,
-0.0095488112,
-0.0120182503,
-0.0650605261,
-0.0514203757,
-0.0041687358,
-0.0446599126,
-0.018753523,
-0.0342829749,
-0.0343861356,
-0.0833960101,
0.0626288727,
0.0358241871,
0.0244009756,
0.0508771837,
0.0191396158,
-0.0300202053,
0.0282408856,
0.0405817777,
-0.0287734941,
-0.0085115544,
0.0395992361,
-0.0385845266,
0.0197894461,
0.0156039968,
-0.0413030162,
0.0129304398,
0.0224005096,
0.0321444273,
-0.0112820128,
0.0325529352,
0.068118751,
0.0157384425,
0.0757419169,
-0.0389136076,
-0.0064807176,
-0.0372118987,
-0.0011328034,
-0.0039243875,
-0.012894419,
-0.0209517553,
-0.0050241435,
0.0079624131,
0.0372837149,
-0.0012664404,
-0.038143158,
-0.0083445134,
0.0376430787,
0.0230145995,
0.040251784,
0.0486469232,
0.026906589,
0.0266564451,
0.0173795763,
0.0094581041,
0.0167068318,
-0.0170946177,
0.0609512925,
0.0153095955,
0.0374479219,
0.0112642851,
0.0174042247,
-0.0405393615,
-0.0268772468,
-0.0387497991,
0.0000423884,
-0.0160920378,
-0.0121037895,
0.0322250314,
-0.0626632124,
0.0245438162,
-0.0571626611,
0.0305436924,
0.0066132522,
0.0046860976,
-0.0246699657,
-0.0340882652,
0.0232211296,
0.0368005037,
-0.0128961885,
0.0199466646,
0.0844366625,
0.0467677116,
0.0438294373,
-0.0174112935,
0.0251512714,
-0.0223610103,
-0.0155620016,
0.0354163609,
-0.0019272921,
-0.0071338331,
0.0068088756,
-0.0419546962,
-0.0720340461,
-0.0360283963,
0.020179322,
0.0478699021,
-0.0349849612,
0.019942252,
0.0523009188,
-0.0302809589,
-0.0196201596,
-0.0260113776,
0.0249650888,
0.0367868617,
-0.0118815871,
-0.0260429326,
-6.16728107e-33,
-0.0064467033,
-0.0172112081,
-0.0114338975,
0.0507132635,
0.0023812358,
-0.0272324607,
-0.0217997115,
0.0463534147,
-0.0184099041,
0.04523018,
-0.0185804144,
-0.0064250575,
0.0087532224,
0.0129154595,
0.0638685673,
-0.0011839247,
0.0287165493,
-0.0078535853,
-0.0071064113,
-0.0142536461,
-0.0083290236,
0.0156140104,
0.0604480542,
-0.0279416498,
0.0327368863,
-0.0267606322,
0.0409870408,
0.0290297661,
-0.0042926557,
0.0317180827,
0.0000753164,
0.0204950254,
0.0273196604,
-0.0265432708,
-0.0196932741,
0.0305824466,
-0.0726214647,
-0.0254173987,
0.0390201509,
0.0457671881,
-0.0188751165,
-0.0263759419,
0.0709193945,
-0.0422970764,
-0.0129801165,
-0.0114881005,
0.0221074242,
-0.015962977,
-0.0184207167,
-0.0006182366,
-0.1151280999,
0.001007632,
-0.0083018104,
0.0183266401,
0.0258337148,
0.0070469989,
-0.005367775,
-0.0234872252,
-0.0314251631,
0.0461737812,
0.0298782494,
0.029373033,
0.058524821,
0.0273815189,
0.0230135731,
0.0556881092,
0.0497455262,
0.0215341672,
0.0040827068,
0.0011313539,
0.054237809,
0.026938349,
0.0297538415,
0.0244932491,
0.0573681556,
-0.0088108657,
-0.043500293,
-0.0362926349,
0.0323046334,
0.0256283227,
0.0046113851,
0.0172665734,
-0.0420560203,
-0.0507637151,
-0.0422241464,
-0.0340766422,
-0.0069681541,
-0.026067812,
0.0034670117,
-0.0062919687,
0.0039490289,
-0.042217385,
-0.0068749776,
-0.0462737642,
-0.0202903077,
-0.0024873274,
-0.0100637199,
0.0167048518,
-0.0260133408,
0.0015294666,
-0.0691242889,
-0.0513511375,
0.0034464935,
0.0376220345,
0.055868987,
0.0396710187,
0.0478960611,
0.0243857745,
-0.0576681271,
-0.0324728042,
-0.0468715839,
-0.0450391807,
0.0362118371,
-0.0012189337,
0.0626011863,
0.0204164479,
-0.0202340502,
-0.0175526906,
0.0086633433,
0.0044397195,
-0.048319336,
0.0430944152,
-0.0414220467,
0.039197281,
-0.0410450585,
-0.0536452979,
-0.0402388312,
0.0276946835,
0.086060524,
-0.0760052353,
-0.0194667056,
0.0125769554,
2.7e-7,
-0.005877797,
0.0978423133,
0.0233804826,
0.0036089695,
0.0296224486,
0.0305985343,
-0.0048427042,
-0.0054376288,
0.0214762706,
-0.0080132484,
-0.0291719027,
0.0079131434,
0.0210575946,
0.0426903404,
-0.1021979153,
-0.0510968678,
-0.0755789876,
0.0468222685,
-0.0078526773,
0.006018009,
0.0298275184,
0.0602870695,
0.0075475215,
-0.0068702199,
-0.0259698573,
-0.040326491,
0.0384539999,
-0.0261945687,
0.048095379,
-0.0003181253,
-0.0467805043,
0.0132909901,
0.026770534,
0.057510823,
-0.0039490201,
0.0026843026,
-0.0105950506,
-0.0045424728,
0.005265234,
0.0282236319,
0.0153131951,
-0.0064799972,
-0.0200926065,
-0.0482570268,
0.031532418,
-0.087882407,
-0.023383772,
0.0082570175,
-0.0286185443,
0.0018318482,
-0.0005169117,
0.0172711406,
-0.0164955091,
-0.0007890799,
0.0344416834,
0.0157744102,
-0.009586324,
-0.0136564234,
-0.0220766682,
0.0234536678,
-0.0276528224,
-0.0375841558,
-0.0153865134,
-0.0119179487,
-0.0167510547,
-0.0004643363,
0.0290348008,
2.108503962e-34,
0.0146642374,
-0.0183924865,
0.0485163033,
0.0197158139,
0.029233627,
-0.0361005478,
0.0128760282,
0.0322696045,
0.0504262522,
-0.0785671994,
0.0149418162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13010v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13010v2 | Unstructured and structured data: Can we have the best of both worlds with large language models? | 2023-04-25T17:30:05 | 2023-07-05T21:33:33 | Wang-Chiew Tan | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | This paper presents an opinion on the potential of using large language
models to query on both unstructured and structured data. It also outlines some
research challenges related to the topic of building question-answering systems
for both types of data. | [
0.0322050303,
0.0553938523,
-0.0302438196,
0.0423311144,
-0.0151124317,
-0.0055516521,
-0.006330444,
0.0198061187,
-0.0192726776,
-0.058973752,
-0.0216651801,
-0.0526883677,
-0.0604720525,
0.0454954952,
-0.0260805506,
-0.0391462147,
0.0111634694,
-0.052405078,
0.0431389473,
-0.0095468648,
-0.0047368323,
0.0195351038,
0.0341106392,
-0.0305162743,
0.040829543,
0.004901066,
-0.0313538797,
-0.0071683568,
-0.0609456524,
-0.0339194164,
0.0049301093,
-0.0025870579,
0.0175803639,
0.0150157018,
0.0000014857,
-0.0430858135,
-0.0106547177,
0.0291107018,
-0.0283248946,
-0.0242084432,
-0.0026740362,
-0.0209781863,
0.0125930328,
0.027974993,
-0.0538379252,
-0.0536052808,
0.0443499349,
0.0206196569,
0.047186669,
0.0457561947,
-0.0141696669,
-0.0647000372,
0.0010641757,
0.0229729731,
-0.0050324625,
0.0200200435,
0.0331754349,
0.0478696302,
0.0699650198,
0.0748131797,
0.0420092605,
0.005824584,
-0.0228155125,
-0.0294063091,
-0.0054245284,
-0.0019618422,
-0.073510021,
0.0442667753,
0.0012111537,
0.0284508392,
0.0354099497,
-0.008089317,
0.0041095051,
-0.0082971025,
-0.0296452474,
-0.0025678759,
-0.0479584895,
0.0359015092,
-0.026052596,
0.0224941429,
0.0084508117,
-0.0180609021,
0.0277044307,
0.0168012176,
-0.0597938821,
0.1163251698,
0.0043898723,
-0.0177523233,
-0.0314060673,
-0.0324694403,
0.0221109986,
-0.0851886421,
0.0033039215,
0.1052559912,
-0.0044907071,
0.0305711348,
-0.0239119716,
0.0027107333,
0.0297640376,
-0.0662988201,
0.0028771602,
-0.0153020015,
0.004410543,
0.0944829881,
0.0158093236,
-0.0179774519,
-0.0175751857,
-0.0176188871,
-0.0540844463,
-0.067143485,
-0.0790826157,
-0.0296761263,
-0.0386334285,
0.0473959483,
-0.060074877,
0.0030120178,
0.0373640917,
0.0515456833,
0.039259389,
-0.0064117732,
0.0171112921,
-0.0300734565,
0.0126744956,
0.0160577651,
-0.0813056529,
-0.0012490208,
-0.0353783816,
-0.0277899839,
-0.0268152934,
-0.0899767503,
0.0559482276,
0.0145819914,
0.0388713852,
-0.0335644521,
0.038814161,
0.043888066,
0.0311962292,
0.0152190523,
-0.0764678344,
-0.0469591394,
0.0174792707,
-0.0453377143,
0.0181135796,
-0.0895830765,
0.0207095891,
0.0480688699,
-0.0354935676,
-0.0119566247,
0.0138422409,
0.0359313115,
-0.0549473502,
0.0442668684,
-0.0598731413,
0.0203331895,
0.0203656759,
-0.0332052186,
0.0576294661,
0.0717417225,
-0.0020589365,
-0.0313731208,
0.0643088892,
-0.0245265588,
-0.0124845821,
-0.0258263852,
0.0108225038,
0.0126172947,
-0.0467895009,
0.1144145727,
-0.0271690041,
-0.011751947,
-0.0482485518,
0.0856458023,
-0.0002924259,
0.0044869906,
0.0160653107,
0.0242356472,
0.0298051201,
0.0110713858,
0.0031839472,
0.0089608319,
0.0323512442,
0.0022056096,
0.0357885212,
-0.0005020106,
-0.0200772267,
0.0053242967,
0.0015851639,
-0.0198144671,
-0.0553947538,
-0.0729843974,
-0.0527750887,
0.0310383271,
0.0353050828,
0.0279137809,
0.0629017204,
-0.0219088253,
0.0075851558,
0.0205838159,
-0.0022374603,
-0.020335272,
-0.0100124683,
-0.0177156162,
0.0318702646,
0.0476071946,
0.0271757469,
-0.0408898331,
-0.0162735861,
0.0297860932,
-0.0016878552,
0.0082217362,
0.00729028,
-0.0246772356,
-0.0082217129,
-0.0156184742,
0.0030691882,
-0.0056078164,
-0.011561526,
-0.0332142487,
-0.0034257157,
0.0279236566,
-0.0203416925,
-0.05264448,
-0.019336788,
0.0003755532,
0.0496322326,
-0.0150479171,
0.0038417052,
-0.0004905247,
0.0134598995,
0.0306572411,
-0.0070465435,
0.0533229336,
0.0364878401,
-0.028697785,
-0.0539858788,
-0.0687555149,
0.0198856052,
0.0160160363,
0.0403312892,
0.0003790122,
0.0037702392,
-0.0378407277,
0.011361002,
-0.0540719368,
-0.009743561,
-0.026245581,
0.068442665,
-0.0291941669,
0.0043781004,
0.0058012991,
-0.018964801,
-0.0815969557,
0.0379673652,
0.0377209447,
0.0436179079,
0.0034460013,
-0.0490374379,
0.06025552,
-0.0371342003,
-0.0180366356,
0.0867056996,
0.0274922717,
0.0233443659,
0.0231150929,
-0.0201495755,
-0.0356028453,
0.0091056824,
-0.0233369637,
-0.0005714886,
-0.0152932545,
0.0411222838,
0.0338077396,
0.0408153161,
-0.0016411773,
-0.0244206712,
-0.0905565992,
-0.0062016225,
0.0679249913,
0.0340281166,
0.0489886403,
0.0562469997,
-0.0389884561,
-0.0431512855,
-0.0410069227,
-0.0207460709,
0.0226302985,
-0.0035559884,
-0.0432024933,
-0.0151091916,
0.0260683671,
-0.0586819351,
0.0404965617,
0.0269260034,
0.0144110145,
0.01030464,
-0.0642237216,
0.0014186358,
0.0443669036,
-0.0357513502,
-0.0108618261,
0.0164382849,
-0.0216053557,
-0.0160369519,
0.0049589286,
-0.0139785632,
-0.0073342747,
-0.0342915207,
0.0021327024,
0.0509574078,
0.0174465813,
-0.0069342637,
-0.0228322111,
0.003532354,
0.0029944386,
-0.0128785735,
0.0396209955,
-0.0510817878,
-0.0127917929,
0.0545389615,
0.1042017862,
0.0236527491,
-0.0082382206,
0.0397270247,
-0.0223756637,
0.0132616628,
-0.0258543976,
-0.041664362,
-0.0737992153,
0.0533750132,
0.0087171728,
0.042260021,
-0.032353919,
-0.0265924651,
-0.0048780222,
-0.0600699447,
0.020117484,
-0.0142771984,
0.0210825186,
-0.0091709066,
0.03905138,
-0.0063669574,
-0.0283496864,
-0.0152622405,
0.0031041591,
-0.0563845448,
0.0551160909,
0.0234015118,
-0.0141896261,
-0.0069312891,
0.0368711464,
-0.0191735849,
-0.0049173092,
-0.0007121668,
-0.014174439,
0.008416865,
0.0544659458,
0.0388318971,
-0.012635611,
-0.0105700009,
0.0053566424,
0.015628295,
0.0510877892,
0.0305233188,
0.0031218205,
-0.0004748733,
0.0004443948,
0.0590559542,
-0.0607031435,
-0.0268677939,
0.0195829589,
-0.0160093699,
-0.0391299725,
-0.0049592415,
0.0959415957,
0.0507107005,
0.0244898815,
-0.0160343386,
-0.0360936858,
0.0052861893,
0.0340229273,
0.0665002763,
-0.0727564916,
0.0125918519,
-0.0500239693,
-0.0068740346,
0.0028532236,
-0.0069937422,
0.0042386544,
-0.0978735611,
0.0373970382,
-0.0229865387,
-0.0365977548,
-0.0318630449,
-0.0431114733,
-0.0273889322,
0.0140384044,
-0.0459361263,
0.0304396022,
-0.0364210121,
-0.0048533776,
-0.0039240569,
-0.0233400837,
-0.0127899041,
0.0333423615,
-0.0134767015,
0.0155948838,
0.0468525887,
0.0534590408,
-0.0167692769,
-0.0478303768,
0.0131971473,
0.0282315239,
-0.0197860524,
-0.026159592,
-0.0112089217,
0.0141394679,
-0.0182890743,
-0.0484732017,
0.0088490769,
-0.0414608419,
0.0590080544,
-0.0017517705,
0.0833519772,
-0.0326200984,
0.0302326735,
-0.0408167802,
-0.0466683097,
-0.0004708462,
0.0417090245,
-0.013181665,
0.0037652401,
-0.0595124699,
-0.0089022629,
-0.0600706004,
0.030936094,
-0.0172692593,
0.0661604181,
-0.0187102538,
0.0215251315,
-0.0553659201,
-0.031114595,
0.0599042512,
0.0213065762,
-0.020128401,
0.059900254,
0.037136171,
0.0001754721,
-0.0577011704,
-0.0182228629,
-0.0371211842,
0.0272127502,
-0.0594252273,
-0.0484410599,
0.0033248221,
-0.0093039973,
-0.0255380459,
-0.0843406469,
-0.0368464515,
-0.0288743488,
-0.0046023251,
-0.0063694003,
0.0271599591,
-0.004986437,
-0.0112881111,
-0.0362809189,
-0.0257808026,
-0.0141684962,
-0.0676755831,
-0.0485748388,
0.0049577127,
0.0110344635,
0.0112325642,
0.0395570919,
-0.0489519723,
0.0214907732,
-0.0151680913,
0.0213438198,
-0.0103860386,
-0.0432499833,
0.0474975519,
0.0835928321,
-0.0008598968,
0.078603901,
-0.0167283732,
0.0277226083,
0.0469514802,
-0.0496994555,
-0.056646727,
-0.0132723423,
-0.0172988549,
-0.0335850082,
-0.0036158948,
-0.0104318559,
0.0197367128,
-0.0627643317,
0.0519994572,
0.0005793804,
0.0424907207,
0.0455866009,
0.0060765818,
0.0100805135,
-0.0098366169,
-0.0019727885,
0.0079243258,
0.030237766,
0.0608119741,
-0.0198252648,
0.0324596688,
-0.005886029,
-0.0192707255,
-0.0170671232,
0.000924513,
-0.0734379068,
-0.0777563155,
0.024733752,
-0.0256949719,
0.0016965275,
-0.0089430241,
-0.0110729923,
-0.0120237088,
-0.0130725931,
-0.0070132888,
-0.0162258968,
0.0635043308,
-0.0126951551,
0.0762645006,
0.0285138115,
-0.0256660581,
-0.0097013963,
0.0811956078,
0.05591188,
0.005817824,
0.0110061308,
-0.0502107926,
-0.0058063678,
0.012596908,
0.0167344399,
0.0082662255,
-0.0207338594,
0.0180141684,
-0.0011628348,
-0.0357154533,
-0.0304623526,
0.0375987887,
-0.0134660732,
-0.017436346,
0.0531270765,
0.0587562844,
0.0778932944,
-0.0028181067,
-0.0871014819,
0.0437074229,
-0.0347048119,
0.0005674481,
-0.0087260362,
-5.612388962e-33,
-0.0058397148,
-0.0216774475,
0.0443060435,
-0.0010463233,
0.0274095163,
-0.0238810852,
0.0075598806,
-0.003812894,
-0.0536531098,
-0.0111673446,
-0.0354444273,
0.0270959251,
0.0160694756,
0.0213972088,
0.0063196477,
-0.0271870941,
-0.0078955367,
0.0193773173,
0.0159110744,
-0.0206086151,
0.0365692414,
-0.0206768122,
0.0125926333,
-0.0619291626,
0.0126806339,
-0.0280965734,
0.0254254621,
0.0480052233,
0.0133871622,
0.0625681877,
0.0010943444,
0.0391400456,
0.0242950041,
0.0094612129,
-0.001123794,
-0.0003971823,
-0.0705151036,
-0.0101991026,
0.031152796,
0.0286908988,
-0.0290881842,
0.0073324325,
0.0129390461,
-0.0329789594,
0.0378876179,
0.031075282,
0.0170748942,
-0.0340911373,
-0.0035730849,
-0.032637585,
-0.0250553098,
0.0259323288,
0.0101036001,
0.0504192263,
0.0067804172,
0.0012556504,
-0.0074879015,
0.0247654226,
-0.0156396609,
0.0523628481,
0.025001049,
0.0446089394,
0.0010424929,
0.0270466041,
0.0074713691,
-0.0087507842,
0.0259472728,
0.0019712537,
-0.0024719269,
0.0298755076,
-0.0526946783,
0.0457417071,
0.0038668301,
0.0241462626,
0.0198946483,
0.0714405626,
-0.0955481306,
0.032173086,
-0.0158127323,
0.017215671,
-0.0276468899,
0.023008557,
-0.037331447,
-0.0472525656,
-0.0179405883,
0.0276987925,
-0.0439899936,
-0.0152013283,
0.0281211361,
-0.0395352542,
-0.0052300929,
-0.0024404754,
0.0221357215,
-0.0509700663,
-0.0730567798,
0.0077580367,
0.0093468102,
-0.0105581358,
-0.0103367465,
0.0498377047,
-0.0413985662,
-0.0003293901,
-0.0037633071,
-0.0356062129,
-0.0314837508,
0.045038633,
0.0035690311,
0.0175274536,
-0.0644827485,
-0.0169543121,
-0.0153848063,
-0.0104471268,
-0.0562506355,
0.0173196048,
0.0160352588,
0.0383753814,
0.0393112265,
0.091289252,
-0.0017652151,
-0.0137935346,
-0.0429679044,
-0.0251582302,
0.0099373749,
-0.0065114414,
0.0140555706,
0.0129272277,
-0.0399630405,
-0.005072352,
0.0235397108,
-0.0428049937,
0.0199179519,
0.0349159651,
2.237e-7,
0.075871639,
0.022572469,
-0.0102176238,
0.0717768669,
0.0146203963,
-0.017736407,
0.0016104799,
-0.0126215275,
-0.0127809215,
0.0111490777,
-0.0068709399,
-0.0050295019,
-0.0180871375,
0.0657595098,
-0.0435527265,
0.0010632671,
-0.0262650661,
-0.0546928234,
-0.060293667,
-0.018584948,
0.0617958382,
0.0538749509,
-0.0457434841,
0.0094165765,
-0.0440405682,
-0.0369014814,
0.0290972833,
0.008202414,
0.0147199007,
0.0356719904,
-0.0171502568,
0.0447179712,
0.0243312959,
0.0192281008,
0.0039523067,
0.0249068402,
0.0197733846,
0.0240157936,
-0.0153694963,
0.0291059632,
0.0125631653,
-0.0798662528,
0.0046586716,
-0.0049296138,
0.1130007729,
0.0043475544,
-0.0471672229,
0.0490205139,
-0.0169706661,
-0.0294306576,
-0.031883318,
-0.0163909663,
-0.0434208438,
-0.0069564818,
0.0280633029,
-0.0186140779,
0.0480328128,
-0.0158614367,
0.0197878033,
0.015594936,
-0.0008997144,
-0.0318869911,
-0.0136387916,
0.0260504223,
0.0180486757,
-0.0054364167,
0.0134142553,
1.591931018e-34,
0.0504685193,
0.0472414568,
-0.0073639285,
0.0267168432,
0.018311115,
-0.0139405979,
-0.0139685133,
-0.0288605168,
0.0275755618,
-0.0982239023,
-0.0137701007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13007v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13007v3 | Answering Questions by Meta-Reasoning over Multiple Chains of Thought | 2023-04-25T17:27:37 | 2023-10-17T19:18:05 | Ori Yoran, Tomer Wolfson, Ben Bogin, Uri Katz, Daniel Deutch, Jonathan Berant | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modern systems for multi-hop question answering (QA) typically break
questions into a sequence of reasoning steps, termed chain-of-thought (CoT),
before arriving at a final answer. Often, multiple chains are sampled and
aggregated through a voting mechanism over the final answers, but the
intermediate steps themselves are discarded. While such approaches improve
performance, they do not consider the relations between intermediate steps
across chains and do not provide a unified explanation for the predicted
answer. We introduce Multi-Chain Reasoning (MCR), an approach which prompts
large language models to meta-reason over multiple chains of thought, rather
than aggregating their answers. MCR examines different reasoning chains, mixes
information between them and selects the most relevant facts in generating an
explanation and predicting the answer. MCR outperforms strong baselines on 7
multi-hop QA datasets. Moreover, our analysis reveals that MCR explanations
exhibit high quality, enabling humans to verify its answers. | [
0.034376204,
0.0267080963,
0.0091100046,
0.0021897217,
-0.0195564982,
0.0285331551,
0.0194154382,
-0.0419885293,
-0.0368360691,
-0.0408461578,
-0.0011939979,
0.0135056358,
0.0038823467,
-0.0028481705,
0.0111346403,
-0.0638687834,
0.0168813802,
-0.0589190535,
0.0002060513,
-0.0112395119,
0.0083525404,
0.0444511101,
-0.0184498318,
0.0328134559,
0.0134947179,
-0.0496023707,
-0.0263516139,
-0.001509132,
0.03353085,
-0.0190299712,
0.0007914177,
0.0457783639,
0.0406048186,
-0.0041610827,
0.0000021785,
-0.0248827096,
0.0084393667,
0.0000332864,
-0.050122723,
-0.028566163,
-0.0743244514,
0.0366405658,
0.0277511757,
0.0461713485,
-0.0113614127,
-0.0027295393,
0.0129177626,
0.0200579762,
0.0704203472,
0.0173258148,
0.015052299,
-0.0445471443,
-0.026311608,
0.004093287,
0.0124484533,
-0.0433101691,
0.0246917009,
0.0424905494,
-0.0002463309,
0.0225726645,
0.008824558,
-0.0077127209,
0.0338748544,
-0.024069285,
-0.0294881482,
0.0257561505,
0.0114936391,
0.000104027,
0.0044863713,
0.0838598832,
-0.0080306763,
-0.0414717272,
-0.0049230503,
0.0075654094,
0.0138730062,
0.0399681404,
-0.0654744431,
0.0411200076,
-0.0237122569,
-0.0129434867,
-0.0229342747,
0.01099867,
0.0390373506,
0.0177998431,
-0.028113516,
0.0957264528,
-0.0155037902,
-0.0286495611,
0.0252455194,
0.0056376932,
-0.0054017827,
-0.0516432561,
-0.0045096749,
0.0610841289,
-0.0294073354,
0.0264705215,
0.0405527763,
0.009071948,
0.016453471,
-0.0088001005,
-0.0126419924,
0.0310722794,
-0.0151537154,
0.061454121,
-0.0155929634,
-0.0106756464,
-0.0246238429,
-0.0077534979,
-0.0368600748,
-0.0386052206,
-0.0873268619,
-0.0221522059,
-0.0218180958,
0.0552378148,
-0.0330780931,
0.0274580456,
-0.0058650868,
0.0226472709,
-0.0110793915,
-0.0278886221,
0.0214626733,
0.042677246,
0.0497721024,
-0.0386855006,
-0.0373777002,
0.0685198307,
-0.1025194824,
0.0422033668,
0.0448989645,
0.0028148554,
-0.02304608,
-0.0026419417,
0.0071165334,
-0.0299594533,
0.0308679044,
0.0396449007,
0.0052871606,
0.02463587,
-0.045714546,
-0.046777375,
-0.0051196199,
-0.0673468783,
-0.0059634936,
-0.0768297166,
0.0319848172,
0.016106043,
-0.0030951716,
0.029365385,
0.0158683173,
0.0504347049,
-0.0401433893,
0.057060767,
-0.0251264945,
0.007365481,
0.0098329661,
0.0295551233,
-0.0122232363,
0.0554469079,
0.0264990311,
0.0212110523,
0.0261321608,
0.0094536925,
0.01824544,
-0.0230135154,
0.022918839,
-0.007115514,
0.0470143333,
0.0473281667,
-0.0305077378,
0.0101549169,
0.0027560554,
0.0171767157,
-0.0234717354,
-0.0016776173,
0.0172716547,
0.0602650307,
-0.0146652628,
-0.0053913551,
0.0579026975,
-0.0304669999,
0.0134676294,
-0.0005473071,
-0.0329368971,
0.0788217559,
-0.0288311634,
-0.0051078298,
0.0131127853,
0.0457549021,
-0.0541829988,
-0.0464278534,
-0.0042592376,
0.0170273874,
-0.0395619161,
0.0334051624,
0.0161438603,
0.0012451431,
-0.0076234988,
0.0508060455,
0.0393039547,
-0.0314334743,
-0.0046218764,
-0.037188217,
0.0278106742,
0.0636224821,
0.0483674034,
-0.0071584419,
-0.0121601503,
-0.0462021753,
0.0715624169,
0.010652421,
-0.0025282947,
-0.0373475961,
0.0191768184,
-0.0365235545,
-0.0296942666,
0.0039796154,
-0.013415277,
0.0167092793,
-0.0066973553,
-0.0207754727,
0.0072715939,
-0.060900867,
0.0250823665,
0.0197966769,
-0.0147080878,
0.0114181647,
0.0015506302,
0.0180373527,
-0.0139505817,
0.0290584732,
0.0155574521,
0.0305346474,
0.0152241066,
-0.0271275453,
-0.056973584,
0.0283974633,
-0.0412417166,
-0.0458914451,
0.0224759858,
-0.0531236716,
-0.0289562307,
-0.0100627774,
-0.049415756,
-0.0559208281,
-0.0065533225,
-0.0023724022,
-0.0084635485,
-0.0369258821,
-0.0208976958,
0.0229064059,
-0.0136465356,
-0.026828913,
0.0773994252,
-0.0152086755,
0.01867944,
0.0002652509,
-0.0239333026,
0.053332001,
0.0140971532,
0.0189832691,
0.0299515873,
0.0005649499,
0.0113188652,
0.0268142708,
0.0048955227,
-0.0622581281,
-0.0003638838,
-0.0571522824,
-0.0102305505,
-0.0207684096,
0.0350946225,
0.0247017834,
0.0053852275,
0.0221657418,
-0.0113537628,
-0.0609968156,
0.0275428314,
-0.0140070859,
0.017833842,
0.0394812301,
0.0136820739,
0.0152363339,
-0.0182389934,
-0.0128304288,
-0.0305176377,
0.0839276239,
-0.0135040851,
0.0067587541,
-0.0340956897,
-0.0717113912,
-0.0702188686,
-0.0044840868,
0.0020237826,
-0.0316815935,
0.0200252254,
-0.0195120554,
0.023118075,
0.0411263593,
0.0053290771,
-0.0304497536,
0.0670734867,
0.0149400979,
-0.0493134633,
0.0215637274,
-0.004875063,
0.0328643173,
-0.0089042773,
-0.0357280485,
-0.0196688529,
0.0725405961,
-0.0033752727,
-0.015102162,
-0.064850837,
0.0269682407,
0.0141267674,
0.0022651183,
-0.0672602579,
-0.0173093472,
-0.0007565414,
0.081103161,
-0.0222258437,
-0.0002159846,
0.0996976197,
0.0008297901,
-0.0008851322,
-0.0310641676,
0.014747086,
-0.0542681254,
0.0643727109,
-0.0427118354,
0.0041507161,
-0.0006316342,
0.0063369144,
-0.0264541674,
-0.0455461442,
0.0325895324,
-0.0228251759,
0.0350289159,
-0.0648216903,
0.0089678969,
0.0081312647,
-0.0399990417,
-0.0329452157,
-0.0132278139,
-0.0700416714,
-0.0093957195,
-0.0596053228,
-0.0060593081,
-0.0184050221,
-0.0082248077,
0.0381230488,
-0.0102074537,
-0.0121342298,
-0.0222678278,
0.0028348467,
0.0424806774,
0.0666192994,
-0.0106787905,
0.0434740856,
-0.0143537419,
0.0736849979,
0.051116962,
0.0368128829,
0.0166246146,
-0.0087858709,
-0.0176794566,
0.005576754,
0.0053114141,
-0.0139359795,
0.0074901297,
0.0087692467,
-0.0558179393,
-0.0041224957,
0.111792706,
0.0554120615,
-0.0327203088,
-0.0157228671,
-0.0632476956,
0.0559558012,
0.0224292167,
0.0420047529,
-0.0845875069,
-0.058576759,
0.0098173907,
0.0100237615,
0.0068742484,
-0.0250238739,
-0.0027228079,
-0.0782239512,
0.0101114344,
-0.0282813497,
-0.0171554629,
-0.0315541588,
-0.0689814314,
0.0236967206,
0.0117453625,
-0.017175097,
0.0338461362,
0.0009872528,
0.0021704971,
0.0386064611,
-0.0097085219,
0.000350108,
0.0797319859,
-0.0056866258,
0.0047568367,
0.0602481216,
0.0417015776,
0.0095088072,
-0.0409585014,
0.0627166554,
-0.0696894228,
-0.0094944015,
-0.0171511788,
0.0444508865,
0.0210084114,
0.0054088938,
-0.0444543213,
0.0541578978,
-0.0496347062,
-0.0451823547,
0.0344351865,
0.1121138781,
-0.0219661053,
-0.0456195436,
-0.0114193028,
0.0249176268,
-0.0157887805,
0.0733706951,
0.0350837335,
-0.0481415167,
-0.0325758494,
-0.0467019565,
-0.0601040535,
-0.0290468596,
-0.0206582285,
0.0382968821,
0.06341061,
0.0257410556,
-0.0662287623,
-0.0470719822,
0.0390890986,
0.0651775375,
-0.0231308676,
0.0361261815,
0.0098653287,
0.0396758132,
-0.0048850197,
0.0148224467,
-0.0430207402,
0.0102200294,
-0.0204138104,
0.0287762396,
0.0240297131,
-0.0409422591,
-0.0181697309,
0.0008547865,
-0.0564846098,
-0.021850815,
-0.0471704341,
0.0430344716,
0.0235287137,
0.0248824563,
-0.0183981508,
-0.0398519449,
-0.0023334993,
-0.0059695817,
-0.0068010576,
-0.0272973571,
0.0586536825,
-0.002173597,
-0.006662563,
0.0398593061,
-0.0471856929,
0.016322935,
-0.0148377633,
0.0292709097,
-0.0166372247,
-0.0259888917,
0.0519482046,
-0.0318248309,
0.0049385759,
0.0143942824,
0.0126734879,
-0.0169397108,
0.0164959729,
-0.0183452833,
-0.0246175118,
-0.0068000914,
0.0425796621,
0.0056717629,
-0.0820555538,
0.0016738655,
-0.0452803113,
-0.0266656578,
-0.0051568388,
0.0282775033,
0.0169474613,
-0.0003763079,
0.0471922606,
0.0201522019,
-0.0328749456,
-0.0183655582,
-0.031021595,
0.0112796836,
0.0600581132,
-0.0137787042,
0.0815712139,
0.0400492623,
-0.0237238277,
-0.0190080013,
-0.000407967,
-0.1206399277,
-0.0322128125,
0.0318091027,
-0.0210756473,
0.0154829742,
0.0292518679,
0.0449489988,
0.0127695678,
-0.0243922696,
0.0203938503,
0.0289453194,
0.0411241762,
-0.0047614789,
0.027322568,
0.0408946536,
-0.0153111089,
0.0058892681,
0.070588164,
-0.0559668094,
0.0345378146,
0.011301375,
-0.0127910189,
-0.0194909126,
-0.0315567963,
-0.1054517329,
0.0329384729,
0.0037759803,
0.0212852079,
-0.0781682506,
-0.0494223051,
-0.0414112955,
0.0192924198,
-0.0021254893,
0.0098087993,
0.0231733695,
0.0471651219,
0.0370232612,
-0.0316145569,
-0.037166249,
0.0336645544,
-0.0070917187,
-0.0140913734,
-0.0058079576,
-6.802269894e-33,
0.0064019696,
-0.0574546121,
0.0393935852,
-0.0206891038,
-0.0067486963,
-0.0236363932,
-0.0519857034,
-0.017185146,
-0.0575039983,
0.0540189557,
-0.0298511107,
0.0062070051,
0.00116862,
0.038651485,
0.0234812461,
-0.0280497801,
-0.0117338412,
0.0220140945,
-0.0322721638,
0.0298381634,
0.0738091692,
0.0053784433,
0.0236040577,
-0.0003670439,
0.0311448742,
-0.0120486161,
-0.0189404879,
0.0506501049,
-0.0629967377,
0.0405543372,
0.0057155592,
0.0188459195,
0.0478247292,
-0.0586324781,
0.0187244769,
0.0422023311,
-0.1149042249,
-0.0257837567,
0.0484639704,
-0.0363386422,
-0.0850287378,
-0.0273609739,
-0.0178798977,
0.0055997334,
0.0771850646,
-0.0492192768,
0.0301465876,
-0.0223474856,
-0.008301001,
-0.0118539156,
0.001272934,
0.0048450013,
-0.0536188371,
-0.0305761714,
-0.0140361283,
0.1020812541,
-0.0171966311,
0.0041662208,
-0.0082879495,
0.0236421935,
-0.0331307277,
-0.0063349721,
0.0376541018,
-0.0016537702,
-0.0015242267,
0.0560620911,
0.0041947803,
-0.0158880446,
-0.0485744253,
0.0156980474,
-0.0529144369,
0.0140493289,
0.0686717108,
0.0434384979,
0.0126772225,
0.0405428633,
-0.0976437405,
0.0029099705,
-0.015576045,
0.0272312295,
0.0137040019,
-0.0223993026,
-0.0041260612,
-0.0332555622,
-0.080908753,
-0.0129495161,
-0.0371329971,
-0.0170601569,
0.0159209333,
-0.0051499726,
-0.0403812975,
-0.0283568222,
0.0230382383,
-0.0421554483,
-0.0109884869,
0.0811949,
-0.0224264637,
-0.0010989936,
0.0141259125,
0.0531329475,
-0.0135999145,
0.05482696,
0.0225117709,
0.0061810086,
0.0254469141,
0.0185015202,
0.0578504279,
-0.0217017606,
-0.0426061526,
-0.0091352677,
-0.0774968788,
0.0289027244,
-0.0252346229,
-0.0487111546,
0.0091819046,
0.0548714288,
-0.0059921346,
0.0341021381,
0.0176848099,
-0.0094484054,
-0.0195378587,
0.0497172847,
-0.0297336765,
0.0199556667,
-0.0120599,
0.0207822118,
-0.0502261966,
-0.000074772,
0.030284835,
-0.0535815991,
-0.0204393957,
0.051427789,
2.671e-7,
0.0307414252,
0.0347327702,
0.0320944898,
0.0234357212,
0.0237637851,
0.0352073386,
0.0012358573,
-0.0353222825,
0.0429904908,
-0.0790098682,
-0.0156764016,
0.0487812608,
0.0426536277,
0.0579797812,
-0.0293999333,
-0.0199335925,
-0.0576197803,
-0.0534135439,
-0.0212233998,
-0.0336280167,
0.0404979773,
0.0398011133,
0.0132038007,
-0.022292383,
-0.0157529656,
0.0120718107,
0.0436696038,
-0.00008743,
0.0164213032,
0.0119536482,
-0.0001955105,
-0.0424893461,
0.0286327805,
0.0304075368,
-0.0067728758,
-0.0229180958,
-0.0172317326,
0.0421153456,
-0.0082623763,
-0.032081794,
-0.0220383611,
-0.0474125333,
0.0477165878,
-0.0427545644,
0.0938383117,
-0.0186639093,
-0.0106693357,
-0.020087257,
-0.0065045967,
0.0018240639,
-0.0039390605,
-0.018361209,
0.007430641,
0.0152338874,
-0.0202981513,
0.0023903376,
0.0347519293,
-0.0947941765,
-0.045420222,
0.028029127,
-0.0139458524,
-0.000759762,
0.0115836319,
-0.0263788719,
0.0446108319,
-0.0714282468,
-0.0128447283,
1.993655638e-34,
0.002889392,
-0.0184189845,
0.0259416569,
-0.0042162724,
0.0350688361,
-0.0062708743,
-0.0346429981,
-0.0266061164,
0.0570074581,
-0.071560666,
-0.0204607341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13005v2 | Evaluating Inter-Bilingual Semantic Parsing for Indian Languages | 2023-04-25T17:24:32 | 2023-06-05T15:55:47 | Divyanshu Aggarwal, Vivek Gupta, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite significant progress in Natural Language Generation for Indian
languages (IndicNLP), there is a lack of datasets around complex structured
tasks such as semantic parsing. One reason for this imminent gap is the
complexity of the logical form, which makes English to multilingual translation
difficult. The process involves alignment of logical forms, intents and slots
with translated unstructured utterance. To address this, we propose an
Inter-bilingual Seq2seq Semantic parsing dataset IE-SEMPARSE for 11 distinct
Indian languages. We highlight the proposed task's practicality, and evaluate
existing multilingual seq2seq models across several train-test strategies. Our
experiment reveals a high correlation across performance of original
multilingual semantic parsing datasets (such as mTOP, multilingual TOP and
multiATIS++) and our proposed IE-SEMPARSE suite. | [
0.0167723149,
0.0293005072,
-0.0054064062,
0.0562471859,
-0.0594344772,
0.0097455196,
0.0075164661,
-0.038577918,
-0.022868339,
-0.0353831165,
-0.0218799561,
-0.0156146539,
-0.0300135072,
0.0310850646,
-0.009621474,
-0.0121789137,
0.0562096126,
-0.009737106,
-0.0093742646,
0.0356756411,
0.0194557216,
0.057653375,
-0.0292098653,
0.0393898524,
-0.055942677,
-0.0399638079,
0.0026338354,
0.0148577755,
0.0216876697,
-0.0545839854,
-0.0002031178,
0.0261234455,
-0.0043344423,
0.0268812366,
0.0000018083,
-0.0586921871,
-0.0314052999,
-0.0075387112,
0.0017670145,
-0.0216099825,
0.0279761013,
-0.0574382022,
0.0148827489,
0.0070607313,
-0.0162038729,
0.0110028414,
0.0692930967,
0.0234812908,
0.0611060932,
0.0881788507,
-0.0261530671,
-0.0392339453,
-0.0059848051,
0.0088218721,
0.0049236096,
-0.0073723556,
-0.0002598646,
-0.0249575078,
-0.024883775,
-0.0183955524,
-0.0089905644,
0.0183184408,
0.0144622065,
-0.0219885949,
-0.0198637135,
-0.0138007822,
-0.0324654579,
-0.0403616801,
0.0217685923,
0.0336748175,
-0.017490413,
-0.0280544236,
0.0138020078,
-0.0002185435,
-0.0573869608,
-0.0487787724,
-0.0042300508,
0.04382037,
-0.0336247273,
0.0477729775,
0.1104028001,
0.0261728354,
-0.0004147551,
0.0052892771,
0.0303900056,
0.0775013044,
0.0308188759,
-0.0208570678,
0.0066311923,
0.0207754634,
-0.0118959397,
-0.0136036417,
0.0257647038,
-0.0241302028,
-0.0813072026,
0.032247711,
-0.0547247045,
-0.0386828408,
-0.0071487911,
-0.0057521798,
-0.0251492467,
0.0888109505,
-0.0079850126,
0.0282809343,
0.0012754779,
0.0139283277,
0.0047351276,
0.0400368758,
-0.0517071746,
-0.0425484143,
-0.0029620037,
-0.0520016141,
-0.0174068734,
0.0050697774,
-0.0545890182,
-0.0107498793,
-0.0432700329,
0.0061210911,
0.0072312122,
0.0039008108,
0.031279467,
-0.026482584,
-0.0692712367,
0.0119164586,
-0.0010798284,
0.0518476591,
-0.0290653538,
0.0218780395,
0.027805293,
-0.0751734376,
-0.0240588188,
0.0507748947,
-0.0662824437,
-0.0701104328,
-0.0475002714,
0.040539667,
-0.0183043629,
-0.0012416124,
-0.0561460592,
-0.029560186,
0.0138385296,
-0.0461484157,
-0.018337559,
-0.0858878419,
0.0846256539,
0.0415011495,
-0.0073959529,
-0.031165082,
-0.0043008486,
0.0245208852,
0.005965888,
0.0485087708,
-0.0254849885,
-0.0052233376,
0.0196349472,
0.0085968077,
0.018929245,
0.0924012959,
0.0176731888,
-0.0299871732,
0.0618957505,
-0.0111030592,
-0.0755960196,
0.0407458171,
0.0078273965,
-0.0178002995,
-0.0196356308,
0.0418728739,
-0.0070798546,
0.0615332276,
0.0212298036,
0.0409768894,
-0.0353694409,
0.0228990149,
-0.0722749978,
0.0320625342,
0.0016513532,
0.014332613,
0.0698736757,
0.0145751834,
-0.0111005595,
0.0129977958,
-0.0203146245,
-0.0033618042,
0.0365113914,
0.016999267,
-0.002261542,
0.0139627671,
-0.014947528,
0.005043122,
-0.0231048893,
-0.0295210984,
0.0126504684,
-0.0238890667,
0.0272608195,
0.0133593353,
-0.016244594,
0.1008465514,
0.0340885855,
-0.0758117884,
0.045927424,
-0.0247478001,
0.0069786864,
0.0330420844,
-0.0141835557,
-0.0213730484,
-0.0403938182,
0.0068504824,
0.0167560205,
0.0352560095,
0.0419756845,
-0.0225963499,
0.0245935805,
-0.0576637983,
-0.0036947785,
-0.0199198909,
-0.0058950912,
-0.028344065,
-0.0287674312,
-0.0016375898,
0.0222039502,
0.010513098,
0.0045524556,
0.0453555733,
-0.0532920025,
0.0178209376,
0.003179404,
-0.0060505685,
0.036311619,
0.0306156036,
0.0121770231,
0.0065925606,
0.0184383057,
-0.0137199033,
0.0163794719,
0.0506518148,
-0.0360321254,
-0.0816252902,
0.0235911068,
-0.068053633,
-0.0159181152,
-0.0131653436,
-0.0607356243,
-0.0670927539,
0.0004665806,
-0.0015601389,
-0.0111015197,
-0.0189096611,
0.0012016654,
0.0337097794,
-0.0275297612,
-0.0314664431,
0.046966482,
0.0173599236,
0.0261999331,
0.0221054442,
0.0361171663,
0.0571904071,
-0.0657006055,
-0.0074836533,
0.0028598069,
0.009214066,
-0.043087285,
0.0086883241,
0.0469863601,
-0.0769164115,
-0.0128091434,
-0.1082250699,
-0.003788416,
-0.0241735633,
0.032560952,
0.0464435928,
0.0494052172,
0.011876124,
-0.0166526325,
-0.0344381928,
-0.0409241505,
0.0580654331,
0.0069331778,
0.046881225,
-0.0141958296,
-0.0069443244,
-0.0111607546,
-0.018645661,
-0.0374086164,
0.0230241045,
-0.0048412266,
-0.0171529856,
-0.0232409667,
0.0094471388,
-0.0137505727,
-0.0129412385,
0.0154795954,
-0.033823967,
-0.0102332747,
-0.0069020265,
-0.0015093357,
0.0186364967,
0.0061605778,
-0.0226528924,
-0.0234849826,
-0.0316785984,
-0.0347391777,
0.0102691324,
0.0106551442,
0.0375248864,
-0.0379085392,
-0.0301141012,
0.0168024059,
0.0634163916,
-0.0215780698,
0.0161199439,
-0.0416667759,
-0.027040178,
-0.042933993,
-0.0024205649,
-0.0082720602,
0.0284463689,
-0.0080383215,
0.0614503995,
-0.0333060436,
0.0098031126,
0.0706579238,
-0.0243917312,
-0.0229861196,
-0.097079739,
0.0349486247,
-0.0659041628,
0.0266280752,
-0.0243213866,
0.0198834576,
-0.0354228057,
-0.0474231839,
-0.0441953354,
-0.0063180546,
-0.0045228312,
-0.0032094012,
0.0198156182,
-0.0793903694,
0.035218019,
-0.0437636375,
-0.0456751063,
-0.0147335883,
-0.0294018798,
-0.0170342457,
0.0090089263,
0.0178470071,
0.021033138,
0.0247733779,
0.0190270152,
-0.0192056466,
-0.0003408497,
-0.0142118614,
0.0285459198,
0.0097016655,
-0.0150681725,
0.0587129518,
0.039178621,
-0.0060722167,
0.0153208617,
0.0365892537,
-0.0023197944,
0.0237598196,
-0.0113030523,
0.0066356086,
0.0252079722,
0.0336479619,
0.00073163,
-0.0306060594,
-0.0250811893,
0.0464634486,
0.0105975419,
-0.0284695812,
0.0822760835,
0.0426512808,
0.0243042484,
0.001287498,
-0.052570004,
0.0133759361,
0.0265551861,
0.0142994309,
-0.1193422526,
-0.0528853685,
0.0179392975,
-0.028757263,
0.009066659,
-0.0200953577,
-0.0037832563,
-0.0929281712,
-0.0078973584,
0.0070028934,
-0.0429565571,
0.0115702748,
0.0112504242,
-0.0791937113,
-0.0742263868,
0.0210567676,
0.0251566898,
-0.025752157,
0.0034539723,
0.0361913703,
0.0145614995,
-0.0183034744,
-0.025272036,
-0.0318771526,
-0.0100956345,
0.0486618206,
-0.0295468252,
-0.019538844,
-0.0379304215,
0.0480971709,
-0.0218677334,
-0.0259770248,
-0.0219875146,
-0.0093975132,
-0.0286872573,
-0.0222395957,
-0.0178146344,
0.0594013035,
-0.0391764864,
0.0023871758,
0.0138006844,
0.0351924039,
0.0066689253,
0.0474475883,
0.00943489,
0.0032321811,
0.0039493316,
0.0660810843,
-0.0069951634,
0.0063510616,
-0.0380065963,
-0.0371283665,
-0.0043186084,
-0.0776466057,
0.0027518624,
0.0661596656,
-0.0415029563,
-0.0287669152,
-0.0264229588,
-0.0796282366,
0.0336436331,
0.0199739095,
-0.0061411094,
0.0018402532,
-0.00789735,
-0.0174219832,
0.0063495752,
0.0313870721,
0.001039852,
0.0436334275,
-0.0576465242,
0.0212281216,
0.0048414096,
-0.0047593932,
-0.0323324539,
-0.0148009975,
-0.0673877373,
-0.0506473891,
0.0234461743,
0.0540202335,
0.0150212636,
0.0083494345,
-0.03831679,
-0.0176501814,
-0.0129181584,
0.0206024107,
-0.0598054267,
-0.0252165068,
0.0058554579,
0.0291610789,
0.009639225,
0.0470436886,
-0.0134052616,
-0.0000747925,
-0.0320004411,
0.05606056,
0.0110877566,
0.0002138352,
0.0543170944,
0.0499958843,
0.0414086208,
-0.0574018732,
0.0310229063,
-0.0134405093,
0.0107692005,
-0.0420628078,
-0.0306131281,
-0.031425193,
0.0110876858,
0.0407069847,
-0.0180521235,
0.0102012558,
-0.0241361391,
-0.0023184617,
0.0361009799,
0.0069977171,
0.0336323231,
0.0286809318,
0.0431436747,
0.0142738335,
-0.0160937961,
-0.0379173942,
0.0086297253,
-0.032217972,
0.0309426319,
-0.0353975631,
0.0749101341,
0.0174727477,
0.0380823649,
0.057392031,
0.0222023576,
0.0688922554,
-0.0035869048,
0.039533902,
-0.0062750611,
0.0920960456,
-0.0186072458,
0.0864664465,
0.0042573265,
0.0082166139,
-0.0169559456,
0.0742901638,
0.0260673165,
-0.0209431369,
0.0805634707,
-0.0219808761,
-0.0397898443,
-0.0694457069,
0.0579101108,
-0.0335598029,
0.0072804973,
0.0169133656,
-0.0072774184,
-0.0194377545,
-0.0478710122,
-0.0284168776,
0.0083873477,
-0.0224022884,
-0.0423309319,
-0.0337831266,
-0.0262611657,
-0.0224395059,
0.0072380523,
0.0198464487,
-0.0038801397,
0.0482994765,
0.0828254521,
0.0214706734,
-0.0452855453,
-0.019022407,
-0.0096670296,
-0.0305828061,
-0.0442674384,
-0.0119796563,
-5.594110025e-33,
-0.0387393311,
0.0651275516,
0.0241444204,
0.0068353703,
-0.0201662797,
-0.0065689171,
-0.0261062719,
-0.0102522234,
0.0156330615,
0.0034472998,
0.0103986729,
-0.0048573166,
0.0352909453,
0.0563234761,
0.0461315177,
-0.0271697585,
0.0388737172,
0.0228124484,
-0.018183561,
-0.0041551483,
0.0761057958,
0.00430289,
0.0773543939,
0.0057809092,
0.0006941474,
-0.0247551575,
0.0072386507,
0.0321193449,
-0.0124314772,
0.0421500877,
-0.0012583041,
-0.0133432001,
0.0223091133,
-0.0209073182,
-0.0267415978,
-0.0134471525,
-0.0676236078,
-0.0180120673,
0.0576364808,
0.0682916716,
-0.0595635064,
-0.0484691784,
0.0384059325,
-0.0200442057,
-0.0294488911,
0.0370007306,
-0.0088226693,
0.019935593,
0.0257796701,
0.0082278755,
-0.0687465742,
0.0591533259,
-0.0052461517,
0.0324757285,
0.0219545234,
0.0750268698,
-0.0058701932,
-0.0333516784,
-0.0443443395,
-0.0170644876,
-0.0580791868,
0.0611936934,
0.0753574073,
0.0214372501,
-0.0019873572,
0.0194104817,
0.0256070886,
-0.0656535029,
0.0537315495,
0.1114228591,
-0.0331518799,
0.0263110865,
-0.0178561956,
0.0441539399,
0.0253322963,
-0.0445856899,
-0.0717851892,
0.0147319604,
0.0248640701,
0.0429310873,
-0.0069303811,
-0.034615241,
0.0065041678,
-0.0262419395,
0.0164147113,
0.0103273997,
-0.0060866955,
-0.0583655015,
0.0508551262,
-0.0281114038,
0.0084029427,
0.0384445935,
0.0707652569,
0.0001731494,
0.0107317818,
-0.0044224556,
-0.0410035215,
-0.0087332912,
-0.027116172,
0.0572103001,
-0.0521314591,
-0.0848482996,
0.0012193723,
0.0110445106,
0.0283997357,
0.0046557137,
0.027261883,
-0.0316896141,
-0.0267398786,
0.0414649583,
-0.0576545224,
0.0519115962,
-0.0615596361,
0.0617068931,
0.0237222295,
0.0054828604,
-0.0290350672,
0.0231846608,
0.0142297326,
-0.004089993,
-0.0271276925,
-0.0537149161,
0.042572096,
0.0336327665,
-0.0000974604,
0.0179159641,
-0.0469912291,
-0.039450217,
-0.0141403368,
-0.0196469091,
0.0064880811,
0.0478632487,
2.571e-7,
0.0167900249,
-0.0117037101,
0.0383287482,
0.0066933581,
-0.0183250681,
0.0078197625,
-0.024829654,
0.0361927412,
-0.0246944632,
0.0359865278,
-0.0509616844,
-0.0208056495,
0.0383542255,
0.0468743555,
-0.1078755334,
-0.0178459976,
-0.0631976947,
0.000370177,
-0.0629931912,
0.0405313894,
0.0594131425,
0.0796011835,
-0.0062532336,
0.0141858105,
-0.0141634298,
-0.0145946415,
0.0372650772,
0.0191987511,
-0.0295364596,
0.0550402924,
-0.0008400067,
-0.003508155,
0.0029895022,
0.0149709973,
-0.0135121047,
0.0184293166,
0.0154642221,
0.0892034173,
0.0237877332,
0.0146781597,
0.0189529061,
0.004441693,
0.0043689185,
-0.0503216013,
0.0415841676,
-0.0044886987,
-0.0213654488,
0.0325988308,
-0.0217363779,
0.0198215451,
0.0040667905,
-0.0113548171,
-0.0175309125,
-0.0013648506,
0.0592194945,
-0.0461608842,
-0.0387125909,
-0.0070796241,
-0.0598848462,
0.0167790949,
-0.0128330896,
-0.0400924832,
-0.005828443,
0.0246906299,
0.0058424119,
-0.0270621534,
-0.0342798121,
2.163715692e-34,
0.0371919386,
0.0055574221,
0.0396160185,
0.0048308526,
0.0480196364,
-0.0229461957,
-0.0071082665,
0.0348292664,
-0.0345306545,
-0.0320561565,
-0.0235747695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12995v1 | AudioGPT: Understanding and Generating Speech, Music, Sound, and Talking Head | 2023-04-25T17:05:38 | 2023-04-25T17:05:38 | Rongjie Huang, Mingze Li, Dongchao Yang, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Zhenhui Ye, Yuning Wu, Zhiqing Hong, Jiawei Huang, Jinglin Liu, Yi Ren, Zhou Zhao, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities across a
variety of domains and tasks, challenging our understanding of learning and
cognition. Despite the recent success, current LLMs are not capable of
processing complex audio information or conducting spoken conversations (like
Siri or Alexa). In this work, we propose a multi-modal AI system named
AudioGPT, which complements LLMs (i.e., ChatGPT) with 1) foundation models to
process complex audio information and solve numerous understanding and
generation tasks; and 2) the input/output interface (ASR, TTS) to support
spoken dialogue. With an increasing demand to evaluate multi-modal LLMs of
human intention understanding and cooperation with foundation models, we
outline the principles and processes and test AudioGPT in terms of consistency,
capability, and robustness. Experimental results demonstrate the capabilities
of AudioGPT in solving AI tasks with speech, music, sound, and talking head
understanding and generation in multi-round dialogues, which empower humans to
create rich and diverse audio content with unprecedented ease. Our system is
publicly available at \url{https://github.com/AIGC-Audio/AudioGPT}. | [
-0.0004361518,
0.0175958518,
-0.0194567442,
0.0267258231,
-0.0213637538,
-0.0160311013,
0.0226441678,
-0.029064646,
-0.0127360579,
-0.0188502576,
-0.0729568675,
-0.0311387759,
0.0142763015,
0.0401774608,
0.0243859477,
-0.0530444346,
0.0470098443,
-0.0682574958,
0.0008083606,
0.0051193228,
0.0015942246,
0.0186114702,
-0.045355998,
0.0559786111,
-0.0392649733,
-0.0069863135,
-0.0608535744,
-0.0046484801,
0.0039309319,
-0.0066067101,
-0.0541017354,
0.0171485171,
0.0611564815,
0.0504967161,
0.0000017195,
-0.0466596782,
0.0159219019,
-0.0028848778,
-0.0174291972,
-0.0349475518,
-0.0173264928,
0.025350308,
-0.032308396,
0.0256921072,
-0.0295849852,
0.0380958207,
0.0200172998,
0.0518606901,
0.0768541545,
0.0509213991,
-0.0105566094,
-0.0344610848,
0.0312278736,
-0.0274080466,
0.0198695995,
-0.028983634,
-0.0023720223,
-0.0134484004,
0.0529261529,
0.0085468953,
0.0044465275,
0.0405872092,
0.0279265717,
-0.0120388875,
-0.0148774264,
0.0455853604,
-0.0257425066,
-0.056475345,
-0.0345344208,
0.0756780952,
0.0512544252,
-0.0085369432,
0.0340226851,
0.0277703572,
0.0015247666,
-0.035844706,
-0.0530055948,
0.0274014715,
-0.0184817743,
0.0201940686,
-0.0259287767,
-0.0114277247,
0.0265655536,
0.0047671208,
0.0170956943,
0.0314001516,
0.0098807421,
-0.0278038662,
0.0116239376,
-0.0233539864,
-0.0264421795,
-0.0662997141,
0.0329578109,
0.0381779373,
-0.0630111322,
0.0111810314,
-0.0424526632,
0.0134727871,
-0.0061382046,
-0.0091162985,
0.0070839683,
0.0439094305,
-0.0416688249,
0.072915554,
0.0152219003,
0.0500655547,
-0.0129437624,
-0.0316560157,
-0.0050460859,
0.0176427551,
-0.0372626111,
-0.0314237997,
-0.0297824517,
0.0035242008,
-0.049664177,
-0.0617604367,
-0.0107941879,
0.0260581542,
-0.0413032919,
0.036360465,
0.0282337107,
-0.0193158258,
-0.0203434601,
-0.0045909481,
0.0265139285,
0.0242370646,
-0.0194425359,
0.0686862394,
0.0220965743,
-0.0495465659,
-0.0068365866,
0.0262626857,
0.0061700391,
0.004989794,
0.0070112343,
0.0774590448,
-0.0206796154,
-0.019414166,
0.0051021343,
-0.0388958193,
-0.00312894,
-0.0909457058,
-0.0007957506,
-0.0420728736,
0.0367906764,
-0.0208556782,
-0.0228661634,
0.0050076284,
0.0175786614,
0.0070246593,
-0.0024213539,
0.0493668765,
0.0155768534,
0.0701607913,
0.0549065955,
0.0300921686,
-0.0441010259,
0.0387970135,
0.0763526857,
-0.0025132559,
-0.0041285246,
-0.0141658634,
-0.0195235405,
0.0731353015,
0.0024637328,
-0.0324165374,
0.0102902744,
-0.028151691,
-0.0383171774,
0.0802760869,
0.0089757321,
0.0786191449,
-0.0269060768,
-0.0242484976,
0.0841557607,
0.027087247,
-0.002961712,
0.0191585775,
0.0467834398,
0.0091830241,
0.0112999752,
0.0076337233,
-0.0466606021,
0.0383416042,
-0.0406368449,
0.018538544,
0.0203136522,
0.0304095764,
-0.0279768202,
0.0045176307,
0.0153739732,
-0.0123009086,
0.0170129817,
0.0018261988,
0.039796751,
0.0011345069,
-0.0436965749,
-0.0062128375,
-0.0281727333,
-0.0584419891,
0.0153888464,
-0.0485106111,
0.0514339581,
0.0636035278,
0.0359626859,
-0.0278223716,
-0.0004141883,
-0.0151512092,
-0.011485314,
0.0572264344,
0.012863894,
-0.0170649271,
0.0369753316,
-0.0342192464,
-0.0049023544,
0.0096380068,
-0.0093497615,
0.0547693558,
-0.0150584001,
0.0054327562,
-0.0022074308,
0.0095693981,
0.0684597567,
0.00047083,
-0.0448420458,
0.0098963669,
-0.0297076013,
0.0021123069,
0.0378840677,
0.0410968177,
-0.0382318199,
0.0014586899,
0.0146571556,
-0.019561708,
0.0121955574,
0.0659848005,
-0.0755426958,
0.0068287887,
0.0448001958,
-0.0356951095,
-0.0037854738,
0.0348421335,
0.0231067576,
-0.0726657435,
0.0452823229,
-0.0210272484,
0.0236690436,
-0.0320914686,
0.0249521956,
0.0381652415,
-0.0094083194,
0.0241602398,
0.0085330829,
0.030748697,
-0.0295667425,
0.0270025712,
0.0220499001,
0.0035912078,
-0.0700175315,
-0.047584828,
0.0498208702,
-0.008307335,
-0.0117710987,
-0.0061690276,
0.0074713258,
-0.0786183029,
-0.036142312,
-0.1384500712,
0.0081041846,
0.003253699,
-0.0258633886,
-0.0081273634,
-0.0057044495,
-0.0017772,
-0.006756336,
-0.0412031561,
0.0241796877,
0.0545774065,
-0.0192955341,
-0.0523234867,
0.0198895019,
-0.0559187122,
-0.0194750037,
0.0350572392,
0.0058810413,
-0.0208022557,
0.015986735,
-0.0272988155,
-0.0374850109,
0.0221392699,
-0.027103141,
0.0536557026,
-0.0104462029,
-0.0130871497,
0.0196590014,
-0.0247791763,
0.037107747,
0.0518505648,
0.0197954681,
0.0272253081,
0.0433768593,
-0.0372549035,
-0.0431346074,
0.0388029739,
0.0249790326,
0.0357362032,
-0.0476832837,
0.026451081,
-0.01811531,
0.0466336682,
0.0655153543,
0.0446261391,
-0.0418704264,
-0.0042587775,
-0.0092911767,
-0.0480841994,
-0.0284141302,
-0.0364230424,
-0.0591062084,
0.03965538,
-0.0167346988,
-0.0321604945,
0.0530709662,
-0.0625295937,
-0.0473044626,
-0.0142408824,
-0.0149248028,
-0.0141673107,
0.0643995851,
-0.0240872614,
0.0227590892,
0.009409925,
-0.0092961257,
-0.0399011038,
0.0336541422,
0.0072198533,
-0.0668254569,
0.0016923115,
-0.0688903332,
-0.0052681537,
-0.0010174542,
-0.0362203494,
-0.0468601994,
0.0016013494,
-0.0300735608,
0.0225498807,
-0.0017031264,
-0.0136839682,
-0.0152912559,
0.0355012454,
0.0521126613,
0.0301478133,
-0.0145151187,
0.0091392519,
-0.037438456,
0.0398707539,
0.0559238978,
0.0594255887,
-0.028262144,
-0.0271461159,
0.0693401992,
0.0127333133,
0.0403005034,
0.0093985042,
-0.0474020056,
0.0284955557,
0.0316200964,
0.0264811739,
-0.0335907079,
0.0521487892,
0.048337549,
-0.0404048301,
-0.0151719349,
0.1347172707,
0.0177835431,
-0.0256223753,
-0.0044547762,
0.0081244996,
0.0141768977,
0.0021867948,
0.0083476789,
-0.059784133,
-0.0244575758,
0.0557067767,
0.0092606498,
0.0233222116,
0.0115228184,
-0.0092396773,
-0.073998183,
0.0723510385,
0.0126067689,
-0.0683071986,
-0.0130932368,
-0.0108840913,
0.009109783,
0.0058077546,
0.0219728351,
0.006232745,
-0.0064317193,
-0.018583389,
0.0006212295,
-0.0026992138,
-0.0379182287,
0.0302886441,
-0.028231971,
0.1116420999,
0.0882640481,
0.0518704727,
0.0095337341,
-0.0252913628,
-0.0065556271,
0.0267040245,
0.0173696,
0.0038861281,
0.0026934047,
0.0072517507,
0.0064483732,
0.0195671152,
0.0600450784,
-0.0193091277,
-0.0189604517,
0.0223663319,
0.0580218174,
-0.0500012599,
0.0091993185,
-0.0135212317,
0.0616921373,
0.0202667098,
0.0943002999,
0.0239340272,
-0.0443672985,
-0.0200832859,
-0.0079011312,
-0.0106321676,
-0.0486142598,
-0.0141763473,
0.0289753862,
0.0083210347,
-0.0298576578,
-0.0378174298,
-0.0006358614,
0.0051047904,
0.0168876816,
0.0270338804,
-0.0003860262,
0.0196972247,
0.0268755462,
-0.0146597102,
-0.0057222848,
0.0151975611,
0.039516177,
-0.0676248148,
-0.0375618897,
0.0225613359,
-0.0886394978,
-0.0136534171,
0.0522103719,
-0.0593811609,
-0.0716372505,
0.0005447225,
0.0098634148,
0.0334660299,
0.0500198863,
-0.0095552867,
-0.0219774097,
-0.0156454854,
-0.0132379662,
-0.0282522272,
0.0625269189,
0.0286643431,
0.0381946452,
-0.0029288414,
0.0303524546,
-0.0537344776,
0.0352568366,
-0.0400825515,
0.0360335633,
-0.0129201142,
-0.0460501015,
0.0132250609,
0.0200251881,
0.0253624748,
-0.0278447494,
0.0568073206,
-0.0405293107,
-0.0067178048,
-0.0287081432,
0.0333355702,
-0.0632479265,
-0.0149978483,
0.0097099366,
0.0105648823,
-0.0057985052,
-0.0072291214,
-0.0039799605,
0.0055038179,
-0.0292974282,
0.018030446,
-0.0000884532,
-0.0371660404,
0.0071647717,
-0.0254469495,
0.0224037245,
0.0141658764,
-0.0075741978,
-0.001009593,
0.0187664721,
0.1088993102,
-0.008867315,
-0.0436225682,
0.0098176505,
0.0461255386,
-0.053056024,
-0.0487182066,
0.0026339286,
0.0725508183,
0.035184253,
0.0156095782,
0.0209216177,
-0.0304143392,
0.0263495389,
-0.0378615372,
0.0715404823,
-0.0107554477,
-0.0379338339,
0.0344191827,
0.0104794074,
-0.0127671696,
-0.0164852478,
0.0293794181,
-0.0525329262,
0.0192039311,
-0.0236777831,
0.0375973545,
-0.0528372116,
-0.0407461226,
-0.0170045476,
0.010015212,
-0.0139381317,
0.0254448354,
-0.0186700411,
-0.0526025221,
-0.0358768888,
0.0224950612,
0.0236426573,
-0.0324559882,
0.0388460606,
0.0284527168,
-0.0332955793,
0.0027368427,
-0.0052700937,
-0.0633081496,
-0.0580426529,
-0.0323685855,
-0.0173265729,
-5.504097279e-33,
-0.055096779,
0.0018578422,
0.0254887529,
0.000827868,
-0.0438285172,
-0.027997395,
-0.060525775,
0.0023674956,
0.006161944,
-0.0157857984,
-0.0042247805,
0.000781199,
0.000646182,
0.0177538563,
0.0046865121,
-0.0018134179,
0.0520745516,
-0.0436319336,
-0.0151780071,
0.0281143151,
0.0548520572,
0.0111130076,
-0.0077305115,
-0.073786281,
-0.0393543318,
-0.0001195509,
-0.0456413813,
0.0055500311,
-0.032662414,
0.0500054918,
-0.0089096939,
-0.0076858704,
0.0082790703,
-0.0355963893,
0.0010750388,
0.0324264765,
-0.0505753048,
0.0055228788,
0.0101504335,
0.0304988697,
-0.0446143262,
-0.0025719544,
0.0088994997,
-0.0031359757,
-0.0316959843,
-0.0001084794,
0.0260237996,
-0.0063675041,
0.010678635,
-0.0142184077,
-0.0313846022,
0.0047417711,
-0.0407573059,
-0.0744665414,
0.0347364396,
0.0662105531,
-0.0069325776,
-0.0101871062,
-0.016399961,
0.0649830475,
-0.0265634339,
-0.0216671508,
0.0735322386,
0.0171595551,
-0.0005028165,
0.0578898676,
0.0194511097,
-0.0835242718,
-0.0341512784,
-0.0195379201,
0.0049992772,
0.0845940709,
-0.0205019806,
0.0206017345,
-0.0261959098,
0.0034093661,
-0.0003822058,
0.026354488,
0.0351633988,
0.0138436267,
0.0011662416,
0.0389255434,
-0.0530712679,
0.0360232741,
-0.0465882756,
-0.022585785,
-0.0329839289,
-0.0316970386,
0.0584946871,
0.009308177,
0.0226047337,
-0.0561904572,
0.0675849468,
-0.0144640133,
0.032286156,
0.0223052371,
-0.0466235057,
0.0238639135,
-0.0046889279,
0.0180627387,
-0.0377417654,
-0.028722547,
0.087020576,
0.0121050635,
0.0252145547,
-0.0042560706,
-0.0395694561,
0.0632328838,
-0.0076342882,
0.0011974062,
-0.0124266483,
0.0556606725,
0.0159841962,
-0.0021143339,
0.039836403,
-0.0225356817,
-0.0375311449,
0.0103716301,
-0.0259706322,
-0.0006205714,
-0.0559630916,
-0.0514665544,
-0.0341555849,
-0.0103991246,
-0.0370642133,
0.0197894964,
0.0033798108,
-0.0510902107,
0.032781709,
-0.0492432155,
-0.0222140849,
0.0226833243,
2.714e-7,
-0.051137656,
-0.0010857187,
-0.0041334671,
0.0309349615,
0.0646934882,
0.0321145728,
-0.062676467,
0.0300631542,
-0.012327427,
-0.0047471067,
0.0182209704,
0.0310814865,
0.0861215219,
-0.0021621168,
-0.0948356912,
-0.0185867641,
-0.0564079471,
0.0024494892,
-0.0338975377,
0.0222336631,
0.0790856332,
0.0710465163,
0.0005837949,
-0.0000727905,
0.0384818912,
-0.0225113463,
0.0460860766,
-0.0382336825,
0.0187890511,
-0.0490183681,
0.0150575386,
-0.0311075747,
-0.017376218,
-0.0046066195,
-0.0166772138,
0.0305789933,
0.0072267,
0.0759288818,
0.0125249587,
-0.0457065739,
-0.0087264935,
0.0607473254,
-0.0052730623,
-0.0323857218,
0.0388102047,
-0.0092883511,
-0.0333158337,
-0.0478723347,
-0.0304555465,
-0.0410045721,
-0.0553412698,
0.0016630645,
0.0100176642,
-0.0215352476,
-0.0219599195,
-0.0284792203,
0.0136592081,
-0.0578876473,
0.0113270786,
0.0023572897,
-0.1003379226,
-0.0276541635,
-0.0513070375,
-0.0251638778,
0.0235428438,
-0.0628912672,
-0.0384126864,
1.899020537e-34,
0.0169229005,
-0.0551339835,
0.0119857434,
0.0358002409,
0.0360602029,
-0.0016702937,
0.0171309039,
0.0388516337,
0.0129906619,
-0.0449278392,
-0.0434633344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12986v2 | Measuring Massive Multitask Chinese Understanding | 2023-04-25T16:51:53 | 2023-05-15T16:41:08 | Hui Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | The development of large-scale Chinese language models is flourishing, yet
there is a lack of corresponding capability assessments. Therefore, we propose
a test to measure the multitask accuracy of large Chinese language models. This
test encompasses four major domains, including medicine, law, psychology, and
education, with 15 subtasks in medicine and 8 subtasks in education. We found
that the best-performing models in the zero-shot setting outperformed the
worst-performing models by nearly 18.6 percentage points on average. Across the
four major domains, the highest average zero-shot accuracy of all models is
0.512. In the subdomains, only the GPT-3.5-turbo model achieved a zero-shot
accuracy of 0.693 in clinical medicine, which was the highest accuracy among
all models across all subtasks. All models performed poorly in the legal
domain, with the highest zero-shot accuracy reaching only 0.239. By
comprehensively evaluating the breadth and depth of knowledge across multiple
disciplines, this test can more accurately identify the shortcomings of the
models. | [
0.038159892,
0.0046599843,
-0.0262434017,
-0.0083801243,
0.0000260934,
0.023483485,
0.0450691767,
0.0266380254,
0.0114661222,
-0.0348812938,
-0.0660190657,
-0.1106768325,
0.0104378099,
0.004953512,
0.0013782125,
-0.0595047548,
0.0485283509,
0.0134712281,
-0.0061263563,
0.0000461974,
0.0042135897,
0.0055143842,
-0.0173307359,
0.066873081,
0.0348113701,
-0.0486030988,
0.0285563692,
-0.0118017541,
0.0148560777,
-0.0294016395,
0.0023340131,
0.0558779165,
0.0128155006,
0.0562515706,
0.0000020878,
-0.0430277884,
-0.0104926471,
0.0112472717,
-0.0155730536,
0.0294572581,
0.0644765943,
-0.0266416371,
-0.0185650494,
0.0258370563,
-0.036794737,
-0.0223467909,
0.0121763078,
0.0307937227,
-0.0228747819,
0.0398166627,
-0.0021139437,
0.0070438948,
0.0254876241,
-0.0413285159,
-0.012084919,
-0.0714123473,
0.0212218668,
0.0504010208,
-0.0113836573,
-0.0322888158,
-0.0448985063,
0.0189899988,
0.0049952413,
0.0336356163,
-0.0454407074,
0.0484708175,
0.0075779431,
-0.0107457796,
0.0138424104,
0.0279132556,
0.0089959707,
-0.005314548,
0.0004725893,
-0.001428039,
-0.0069366302,
0.0225207955,
-0.0818227082,
0.0294751059,
-0.0071692327,
-0.0234433822,
0.0313926414,
-0.0229238905,
0.0445638783,
0.0144321285,
-0.0281488262,
0.0169534478,
-0.0022699232,
-0.044776611,
0.0040531331,
0.0158561356,
-0.0119255697,
-0.020113593,
-0.0127295498,
0.0001859582,
-0.0565364696,
0.0429350436,
0.0007812211,
-0.0268585123,
0.0362279229,
-0.0398698226,
0.0232525878,
0.0429863818,
0.0040796669,
0.0395604484,
-0.0009149688,
0.028132705,
-0.0103417533,
-0.001331822,
-0.0374653824,
-0.0074941614,
-0.119098559,
-0.0202830639,
-0.0085858004,
0.0352271833,
0.0023620953,
-0.0352721773,
-0.0826106966,
-0.0011204715,
-0.0150813377,
-0.0231501255,
-0.0042832075,
-0.0056529953,
-0.047459852,
-0.005747084,
-0.0126069766,
0.070522666,
-0.0236296151,
0.0333242752,
-0.0280888434,
-0.0219692569,
0.038372159,
-0.0085392203,
-0.0284760538,
-0.0186236426,
-0.0045936788,
0.0649082512,
-0.009545818,
-0.0170081481,
-0.0316107981,
-0.0515064262,
-0.051656682,
-0.0766033307,
0.0202913024,
-0.0479872227,
-0.0157646351,
0.0197024774,
0.0493041314,
-0.0354996026,
-0.0084336633,
-0.0005442274,
-0.0309045929,
0.0075297714,
0.0089940131,
0.0214956328,
-0.0116288438,
0.0372523144,
-0.0454697683,
0.0949396864,
0.0132407555,
-0.0421439894,
0.0238256752,
-0.0140542248,
-0.0333763361,
0.0017271973,
-0.0077148969,
0.0074228854,
0.0153450957,
-0.0123260273,
0.030402936,
0.0074786674,
-0.0132987509,
0.0070263646,
-0.0326804966,
0.0520985834,
0.0493651405,
0.0458965227,
0.0384812839,
0.0155530255,
0.0333965756,
0.0076687806,
0.0153646367,
0.0121020759,
-0.0407797508,
0.0029636079,
-0.0285023917,
0.0221355893,
-0.0185447298,
0.0125502273,
-0.0447797142,
-0.0456041396,
-0.0272954199,
0.0093729626,
-0.0135076921,
0.0130734788,
0.0652303249,
-0.0388325639,
-0.0081679756,
0.0466551967,
0.0267693717,
-0.0385838747,
0.0109994262,
-0.0345437787,
-0.0235731322,
0.0914274901,
0.0225123335,
-0.0284496173,
-0.0229747389,
0.0065183942,
0.0382789783,
0.0538444445,
0.0554466397,
-0.00572199,
-0.0078432988,
-0.0385742225,
-0.026058564,
0.002278287,
0.0375469029,
0.0055581797,
0.0171324778,
0.0510585494,
0.0094731487,
-0.0499063507,
-0.0154296486,
0.0078167031,
-0.100839749,
0.0151445298,
-0.0252081435,
0.0072804191,
0.0134367673,
0.0460845158,
-0.0491439551,
0.0146268923,
-0.0010521894,
-0.0178025179,
-0.0185727179,
0.0088835442,
-0.0107564023,
0.0271909665,
0.0477333367,
-0.0420294814,
-0.0221494641,
0.0429464541,
-0.0051986915,
-0.0576919056,
-0.0083907219,
0.0044162087,
0.0480795614,
-0.0441700555,
0.0390804075,
-0.0605308264,
0.0102257812,
0.0145230256,
0.044242356,
-0.0003853148,
0.0358659625,
0.0367638431,
-0.0227744952,
0.0282091144,
-0.0076674647,
-0.0670189261,
-0.0113300169,
0.0040248833,
0.0296313912,
0.016386101,
0.0049236282,
-0.0479413867,
-0.0291198883,
-0.103247501,
0.0105952974,
-0.0324114636,
0.0198691636,
0.0562425852,
-0.0060792365,
-0.003542498,
0.026479952,
-0.0134845134,
0.0167603437,
-0.0272152741,
0.0241528675,
-0.0206952095,
-0.0144559415,
-0.0063152919,
-0.0083183367,
-0.0027721957,
-0.0547577813,
-0.0186407398,
0.0184509419,
-0.0014264911,
0.0082719289,
0.018316796,
-0.0035341284,
-0.0241304282,
0.0016045878,
-0.0423391685,
0.0193327833,
0.014493051,
-0.0159157738,
0.0391833223,
-0.0106395828,
0.0144957677,
0.0472220033,
0.0087865535,
-0.0133246398,
0.0057105231,
0.0273857359,
-0.0383892655,
-0.0263206866,
-0.0199005157,
-0.0445260108,
0.1060493514,
0.0359851085,
-0.0038149876,
-0.0531693399,
-0.0408365391,
-0.0904042721,
-0.0196603443,
-0.0294944979,
0.0566128157,
-0.0314312801,
0.0311456062,
-0.0235727541,
0.0055476851,
0.0446098931,
0.0075702108,
0.0279350355,
-0.0284832865,
0.0070049544,
-0.0102017717,
0.0518907346,
-0.0379627943,
0.0135706458,
0.0051257797,
-0.0340752415,
-0.0522616133,
0.0464620292,
0.0028927831,
-0.0510989055,
0.0705019459,
-0.0203570165,
0.0009048281,
-0.0373706892,
-0.013714374,
-0.0074684746,
0.0111593083,
-0.0383961424,
0.0481385216,
0.0154047301,
-0.0117188953,
-0.0241041575,
0.022138441,
0.0152803585,
0.0194793101,
-0.0033527405,
-0.014676963,
-0.0025706303,
-0.015368876,
0.0412833877,
0.0043427814,
-0.0154485116,
-0.0532044955,
0.069672063,
0.0626723766,
0.0427907035,
0.0539062247,
0.0338935815,
-0.022506984,
0.0195518322,
-0.0415677838,
-0.0544521622,
0.0298494063,
0.0403769054,
-0.0591323078,
0.0161630213,
0.1448744386,
0.01348205,
-0.025757527,
0.0005256076,
-0.0118878987,
-0.0175673142,
0.040915098,
-0.0059366133,
-0.1121542603,
-0.0342180505,
-0.017348526,
0.0052021202,
-0.0167281926,
-0.0202776678,
0.036429029,
-0.1195700392,
0.0252238307,
0.0031425911,
-0.0417537801,
0.0042994269,
-0.0006805582,
0.0300246142,
-0.0042908224,
0.0550226234,
-0.0187032018,
-0.0105970781,
-0.0207305606,
0.0223965794,
-0.0366533473,
-0.0809307843,
0.0945809409,
-0.0218024775,
0.0475257635,
0.0404763743,
0.0378133468,
-0.0347720794,
-0.0116520114,
-0.0102530597,
0.0159108974,
0.0098892059,
0.0259921756,
0.0556740649,
-0.0076366863,
0.0227673482,
-0.0156525318,
-0.0030038382,
-0.0404099897,
-0.0017765911,
0.0492495112,
0.0732153654,
0.0042420463,
-0.0336217582,
-0.0209308118,
0.0013307953,
-0.0277190991,
0.0988038331,
0.0106286872,
-0.0529409461,
-0.0095381616,
-0.0090988344,
-0.0277768541,
-0.0536224321,
-0.0284787975,
0.0762858912,
-0.015048991,
-0.0400990322,
-0.0407259017,
-0.022994753,
0.0455351733,
0.0020258937,
0.0241480637,
0.0656963214,
0.0394791253,
0.0059210821,
-0.0391767509,
-0.0261442605,
0.0053257174,
0.0334254541,
-0.0583338737,
-0.0252623912,
0.0405172929,
-0.0085522458,
0.0022326179,
0.0048324801,
-0.054599002,
-0.0325391032,
-0.0123821385,
-0.0107769212,
0.0182952434,
-0.0072419564,
-0.003349527,
-0.011889928,
0.0149915526,
-0.0031391152,
-0.050266996,
0.0137903355,
0.01974581,
-0.0324579999,
-0.0112042809,
0.0096575255,
-0.0300078746,
-0.0044321842,
0.0292264167,
0.0330411419,
-0.0144627681,
0.0352342911,
0.0202888791,
0.0194798335,
0.0347037241,
-0.0201634802,
-0.0041188956,
-0.0462601595,
0.0194675457,
-0.0345342308,
0.0090370299,
-0.0179190226,
-0.0485712551,
0.0785760805,
-0.0279344749,
0.0031657589,
0.0322854109,
-0.0234952793,
-0.0635536611,
-0.068232879,
0.0054268744,
-0.0161186326,
0.0266217235,
0.0074506239,
-0.02288137,
-0.0250702798,
-0.0455841161,
0.0108794374,
0.0058628339,
0.0000648849,
0.0888704062,
-0.0167213418,
0.008155833,
0.0297989715,
0.0219363905,
-0.07170102,
-0.0550808087,
0.0094611021,
0.030651601,
0.0740611181,
0.0048011006,
0.0440203808,
-0.0441450961,
0.0215823893,
-0.0467731506,
0.0177763328,
-0.0132530322,
-0.0164963119,
0.0116729904,
0.0156300813,
0.0126508884,
-0.0267488305,
0.1092873663,
0.0189451706,
0.0459939018,
0.0085934009,
-0.031171985,
-0.017857207,
-0.017438639,
0.0117112566,
0.0605551265,
-0.0514339767,
0.0282949135,
-0.1098842844,
-0.0619089976,
-0.0190460403,
0.0014414394,
-0.0180735681,
-0.0237050224,
0.0074107307,
0.0554404929,
-0.0168085024,
-0.0259426516,
-0.0703178346,
0.0013381409,
-0.0088533452,
0.0233860184,
0.0316919796,
-6.448559971e-33,
-0.0048603145,
-0.0110178236,
0.0319504403,
-0.0193676148,
-0.0065325308,
0.0125158541,
-0.0178664867,
0.0370757207,
-0.0664753094,
0.0073975418,
-0.0020708211,
0.0180932917,
0.0168543793,
0.0132029383,
0.0358922035,
0.0125763807,
0.0232102796,
0.0065955673,
0.0172719676,
0.0110800704,
0.0241216794,
0.0335459784,
0.0845757797,
-0.0384684913,
0.0304339509,
-0.0016474371,
0.0401917808,
-0.02921547,
-0.0196407959,
0.0972030833,
-0.0051051849,
0.0865325704,
0.0647250637,
-0.0845676661,
-0.0091275107,
-0.0268733725,
-0.0914159268,
-0.0250840541,
0.0296531823,
0.0063425917,
-0.0015358835,
0.0041559264,
0.0141071444,
0.0145314606,
-0.0125208674,
-0.0665858686,
0.0368353017,
-0.0425095446,
-0.0071820007,
0.0002369584,
-0.067743808,
0.0124678556,
0.0030343418,
0.0122337369,
-0.0223967452,
0.0224104524,
-0.0265843384,
0.0109790191,
-0.0643395036,
-0.0172976609,
0.0304906461,
0.0581094548,
0.0662439317,
0.0008405375,
0.0195688885,
0.0485665724,
0.0145360082,
0.0267665535,
0.0070037735,
-0.022620786,
0.0640206859,
0.0239636768,
-0.0132639548,
0.0753372237,
0.0423849076,
-0.0337151811,
-0.083735846,
0.0024432023,
0.0276820511,
0.0260034204,
0.0258470848,
-0.0149448877,
-0.0463509038,
-0.0306557305,
-0.0146855423,
-0.0008720475,
-0.0182773042,
-0.050237067,
0.0522217825,
-0.0083251232,
0.0140154073,
-0.0141255371,
0.0342034958,
-0.0885015577,
-0.00821607,
0.015969038,
-0.0190226287,
0.0413149074,
-0.0352068953,
0.0366083831,
-0.0639822781,
-0.0521319695,
-0.0270623695,
0.026980184,
0.0240758415,
0.0105381757,
0.0256437529,
-0.0318102837,
-0.0467358604,
-0.0213571992,
-0.0205309503,
-0.0382976308,
0.0630185306,
0.003980726,
0.0545510575,
0.0050033885,
0.0125381621,
0.0141241308,
0.021308478,
-0.0401393808,
-0.0567081906,
-0.0382229462,
-0.0337135941,
-0.018014228,
-0.0390501618,
-0.0042262319,
-0.0354670249,
0.0040953918,
0.0569611229,
-0.0385675505,
-0.0442513414,
-0.0097465999,
2.735e-7,
0.081535995,
0.0225229282,
-0.0389717296,
0.0281609055,
0.0075446442,
0.0217390805,
-0.0409645922,
0.0402858034,
0.0061254883,
-0.0068751839,
0.0183902755,
0.0123464223,
0.0645947903,
0.032925196,
-0.0955795199,
-0.0203339197,
-0.0163477566,
0.0212284215,
-0.0308630466,
0.0678555295,
0.0010538158,
0.0656496361,
-0.0238261316,
-0.0042980374,
0.0189071968,
-0.0267827436,
0.0514741726,
0.0073497202,
0.0082154935,
0.0427975953,
0.0023241846,
0.0401932448,
0.0093938671,
0.0661523715,
-0.018716054,
0.020853145,
0.0169752128,
0.0984862447,
-0.030491598,
0.0421014391,
0.0158304106,
-0.0277652219,
0.0169672128,
-0.0523191094,
0.0623091944,
-0.0240744445,
-0.0362062305,
0.0185312238,
0.0059399996,
-0.009527443,
0.02766864,
-0.0059419684,
-0.0037704785,
0.0218074042,
0.0095791258,
0.0081900405,
-0.0206958484,
-0.0138303274,
-0.0124035981,
0.031727761,
-0.0259868074,
-0.0752991512,
0.0240061097,
-0.0605811961,
0.0292738453,
-0.0757305995,
-0.0091207949,
2.13962219e-34,
0.0221000481,
0.0113119949,
0.0496071577,
0.0277622007,
0.0120734703,
-0.0181466192,
-0.0022188358,
-0.0055210046,
-0.0158048309,
-0.0574403666,
-0.0305607952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12982v1 | Intent Induction from Conversations for Task-Oriented Dialogue Track at DSTC 11 | 2023-04-25T16:45:50 | 2023-04-25T16:45:50 | James Gung, Raphael Shu, Emily Moeng, Wesley Rose, Salvatore Romeo, Yassine Benajiba, Arshit Gupta, Saab Mansour, Yi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With increasing demand for and adoption of virtual assistants, recent work
has investigated ways to accelerate bot schema design through the automatic
induction of intents or the induction of slots and dialogue states. However, a
lack of dedicated benchmarks and standardized evaluation has made progress
difficult to track and comparisons between systems difficult to make. This
challenge track, held as part of the Eleventh Dialog Systems Technology
Challenge, introduces a benchmark that aims to evaluate methods for the
automatic induction of customer intents in a realistic setting of customer
service interactions between human agents and customers. We propose two
subtasks for progressively tackling the automatic induction of intents and
corresponding evaluation methodologies. We then present three datasets suitable
for evaluating the tasks and propose simple baselines. Finally, we summarize
the submissions and results of the challenge track, for which we received
submissions from 34 teams. | [
0.0589789934,
0.0107485158,
-0.0318035781,
0.0087191649,
-0.0426072925,
-0.003949496,
0.0056853732,
-0.0340690874,
0.0539149642,
-0.0412404276,
-0.0005117789,
-0.0243341401,
-0.0063148537,
0.0719864964,
-0.0175866149,
-0.0414714068,
0.0409257561,
0.0088090496,
-0.0001946702,
0.0261149388,
0.0155585194,
-0.0046021109,
-0.0613155141,
0.052483052,
-0.0454321988,
-0.0308483858,
-0.0545372516,
0.0038783313,
-0.0010832838,
-0.0339417011,
0.0003245804,
0.0311183278,
0.0175153296,
0.0366238169,
0.0000018524,
-0.078914851,
-0.0128113208,
-0.0238794014,
-0.0984781384,
-0.0543268695,
0.000257378,
0.012467958,
0.0012623142,
0.0287044477,
-0.045118399,
0.0190816224,
0.0298092831,
0.0474104062,
0.0675230399,
0.0665884167,
-0.0337932855,
0.0254484117,
-0.0031894918,
0.0070864568,
0.0275768843,
-0.0500483885,
-0.0136283254,
0.0387858897,
0.0054741399,
-0.005675598,
0.0374766365,
0.0098583801,
0.0064090854,
-0.0193955991,
0.0150679266,
0.0282527898,
-0.0411298349,
-0.0612514392,
-0.043104019,
0.1034658775,
0.047608871,
0.0353736877,
-0.00371748,
0.0037713021,
0.0138791651,
-0.0447686203,
-0.0136983087,
0.0012717238,
-0.0444565453,
-0.0322716683,
0.007313753,
0.0302396119,
-0.0192684755,
-0.0040189079,
-0.0030647989,
0.0429381244,
0.0096053565,
-0.0528437309,
0.0174340699,
-0.0103058182,
0.0253644083,
-0.0598960258,
0.0024948618,
0.01006757,
-0.0965393782,
0.0267957188,
-0.0047501489,
-0.0121001611,
0.0218831003,
-0.0053030606,
0.0283234734,
0.0413279422,
-0.0433635563,
0.0491166264,
0.0018998691,
0.059701141,
0.0223397408,
0.0019421087,
-0.0415190905,
0.0170946773,
-0.0436011292,
0.0336502083,
-0.0636910051,
0.0295824166,
-0.0312588327,
-0.0193722751,
-0.0160951763,
0.0676556006,
-0.0015119358,
0.0342733525,
-0.0040257405,
0.0224458426,
-0.0561385527,
0.0212226082,
-0.0479276739,
-0.0131680565,
-0.0488537401,
0.0346138217,
0.0007739814,
-0.0617091022,
-0.0123120984,
0.0279686209,
0.0231139101,
-0.0069169607,
-0.0134256827,
0.0131815271,
-0.0064290129,
-0.0491982624,
-0.0044860723,
-0.0217184406,
-0.0072710863,
-0.0704028159,
-0.0409731008,
-0.0044704727,
0.0389007926,
-0.0069740461,
-0.0080860695,
0.0060374243,
0.0174964275,
0.0116999466,
0.0116952313,
0.0806451291,
-0.0469095334,
0.0173189789,
0.0327077135,
0.0112840496,
-0.0599530861,
0.0678450912,
0.0098741585,
0.0760458037,
0.0346829221,
0.0168035869,
0.0452015288,
0.0230976082,
-0.005430127,
-0.021276623,
0.0623569898,
0.0400431007,
-0.0260126069,
0.0631813705,
0.0014425155,
0.0422843955,
-0.0384971686,
0.0105439797,
0.0571469702,
0.0486269034,
-0.0237551555,
0.0061992714,
0.051487036,
0.0441860594,
0.0122260656,
-0.0181459039,
-0.0494595729,
0.0170253962,
-0.016087791,
0.0048577506,
0.0002160005,
0.0093271732,
-0.033464767,
-0.0303301625,
0.0271546002,
-0.0246369261,
0.0514497645,
-0.0220026821,
0.0293101259,
0.0149676939,
-0.0647901744,
-0.0019066139,
-0.0283745229,
-0.0495345332,
-0.0553117469,
-0.0450175814,
0.022162443,
0.0711182281,
0.0508333556,
-0.0355477184,
-0.0811015368,
-0.0258896202,
-0.02801455,
0.0476261079,
0.038928356,
-0.0438482612,
0.0225516576,
-0.0236333143,
-0.0051912065,
0.0153495716,
-0.0008954709,
0.008932584,
0.0033933229,
-0.0232767556,
0.021170795,
-0.0059693395,
0.0229193736,
0.0130351493,
0.0212689172,
0.0008731116,
-0.0004745177,
0.0395850502,
0.0579266958,
0.0505029112,
0.0131512089,
-0.0285179224,
0.0137267448,
-0.0144824926,
-0.0063040759,
0.0684196576,
-0.0100817997,
-0.0350687429,
0.0452993363,
-0.0196377616,
-0.0407786258,
0.0368291549,
-0.0068236222,
-0.0371614732,
-0.0043946085,
-0.0560876057,
0.0155474339,
-0.0505607016,
-0.0070336303,
0.0370944254,
0.0011112281,
0.0217564665,
0.0549549721,
0.0357852131,
-0.0314478762,
0.0698792562,
-0.0079246629,
0.0210156906,
-0.047163628,
0.0159017202,
-0.0344413184,
-0.0254073385,
0.0073202574,
0.0125225643,
-0.0052343947,
-0.0886493251,
0.0162418205,
-0.1512449235,
-0.0015448817,
-0.0046589789,
-0.0207999721,
-0.0140540488,
0.0190962981,
-0.0061534261,
-0.0242436919,
-0.043768622,
0.0163695477,
0.0087280255,
0.0138726849,
0.0469404571,
-0.0058077043,
-0.0702436343,
-0.0270164851,
0.0705707893,
-0.0183574632,
-0.010117677,
0.0045624548,
0.0097646154,
-0.0593731813,
0.035735514,
-0.0304749105,
0.0165328626,
-0.0285583623,
-0.0581618026,
0.032940492,
0.00166383,
0.0067030508,
0.0647907853,
0.0274439901,
0.0254109818,
0.000172883,
-0.0091571519,
-0.0434071906,
0.0338930972,
-0.0132391332,
0.0183933266,
-0.02951915,
-0.0329985619,
0.03375962,
0.0251365099,
-0.0152305569,
0.0282978565,
-0.0539741442,
-0.0074424027,
0.0180215649,
-0.0247148704,
-0.0049970262,
0.0075624874,
-0.0502164438,
0.0955884755,
0.0044261697,
-0.0726301596,
0.0523298979,
-0.0249986611,
-0.0309619065,
-0.0575998612,
0.001639941,
-0.0267374739,
0.0650060922,
-0.0233099367,
0.0287135486,
0.0388628319,
-0.0162626896,
-0.0128375459,
0.0186534878,
0.0251979306,
-0.0317753367,
0.0548324808,
-0.0222012401,
0.011665673,
-0.0084789796,
-0.0301980469,
-0.0911104381,
-0.0684729964,
-0.0377365761,
0.0106289778,
0.0563777499,
-0.0249428209,
-0.0207628813,
0.0142658073,
-0.0133555457,
0.0505718552,
0.0125340587,
-0.028748231,
-0.0144297378,
-0.0068259677,
0.0505844876,
0.0640972033,
-0.0177660156,
0.0267737135,
0.0655897707,
0.0082962941,
0.0339757949,
-0.0149836522,
-0.0261544418,
-0.0013413759,
0.003958941,
-0.0273769684,
0.0161022656,
0.0241744183,
0.0597313792,
0.0252114926,
-0.0210216399,
0.1165408492,
0.036907915,
-0.0407308973,
0.0051430864,
-0.0110020339,
0.0084266169,
0.0265781786,
0.0160332918,
-0.1126861945,
-0.0346598215,
0.0182012469,
0.0255732276,
-0.020777598,
-0.0380571075,
-0.0260533784,
-0.0973188281,
0.0646614209,
-0.0200536009,
-0.0209959578,
-0.0415848419,
-0.0206265524,
0.0255416762,
-0.0188696515,
0.0248188432,
0.0003435979,
0.0227387939,
-0.033195883,
-0.0004984889,
-0.0287350975,
-0.0035574827,
0.0411949009,
-0.0198149569,
0.0893741325,
0.0255806111,
0.0453817062,
0.0513811074,
0.0003689408,
-0.0556016453,
0.0175374951,
-0.0041788979,
0.0189132299,
0.0597702079,
-0.0251043532,
0.0060794153,
0.0140019348,
0.0386701487,
-0.0486231782,
-0.0062599177,
0.0393445864,
0.0263518114,
-0.054655619,
0.0254969038,
0.0050724111,
0.0340430997,
0.0525631085,
0.0896352455,
0.0294685736,
-0.0370367281,
0.0036448569,
-0.0171399452,
0.014397529,
-0.0005426876,
-0.0100593865,
-0.0108084856,
-0.0123415487,
-0.0198361129,
-0.0756323636,
-0.0886297375,
0.0359384567,
0.0376345254,
0.0294087138,
-0.0036690922,
0.0141192311,
0.044544287,
0.016272191,
0.0142587749,
-0.0203177184,
0.0179282464,
-0.0321037434,
-0.0239528026,
0.0060891374,
-0.0817695558,
-0.005483428,
0.0152956834,
-0.0648090392,
-0.0152206291,
0.0267736409,
0.0496512763,
0.0226565953,
0.0386665687,
-0.011305891,
0.0325189792,
-0.0534477457,
0.0003598392,
-0.0295215808,
-0.0404323041,
0.0585427023,
0.0558971241,
-0.0031033005,
0.0436792001,
-0.0409341455,
0.0231337361,
-0.050220266,
0.0281230304,
-0.048253268,
-0.0532142296,
0.0472391061,
0.0368789136,
0.0129650254,
-0.0213255249,
-0.0007447357,
-0.0265219342,
0.044122152,
-0.0211655106,
-0.0304361861,
-0.0603301153,
-0.0233418606,
-0.0265819952,
0.0024488349,
0.0220283754,
-0.0249937885,
-0.0843702033,
0.0253619552,
0.0035533607,
-0.0170972049,
0.0012676372,
0.0184232499,
0.0060772691,
-0.0410063528,
-0.0136168357,
0.0197067726,
0.0051769926,
0.0596799478,
0.009606678,
0.0932305604,
0.0099473288,
-0.0362830125,
-0.0138059109,
0.0606551804,
-0.0245052446,
-0.0629655495,
0.0151560726,
0.027639892,
0.0376989804,
-0.0131702004,
0.0668024644,
-0.0447139479,
0.0437929258,
0.0076205619,
0.0510998853,
0.0140236532,
-0.0133304,
-0.0046371585,
0.0062408396,
-0.027125081,
0.0001440674,
0.0450182483,
-0.0744215995,
0.0290489309,
0.0000624256,
-0.0071669836,
-0.0733585954,
-0.0202690531,
-0.0097680502,
0.0292046797,
-0.0138775865,
-0.0358540751,
-0.0875681713,
-0.0271391924,
0.004748839,
-0.0151770869,
-0.0116171315,
-0.0012168812,
0.0465544462,
0.0506202802,
-0.0055560749,
-0.0291844122,
-0.0202391446,
-0.0403870568,
-0.045423612,
0.0033091735,
-0.0338298231,
-5.66699398e-33,
-0.0060357824,
0.0019865218,
0.0232369546,
0.0079007354,
-0.0275719911,
0.011047706,
-0.0417017564,
0.0055095176,
-0.0140245026,
-0.0032163952,
-0.0317367613,
0.0071712062,
0.0195345543,
-0.0058060009,
-0.0252605118,
-0.0227209851,
0.0337155536,
-0.0347282402,
-0.0288493484,
0.0346839093,
0.0048447181,
-0.0060618888,
0.0064574527,
-0.0760202259,
0.0252112728,
0.0226940569,
-0.0118298689,
0.0466948375,
-0.0010178621,
0.0399468616,
-0.0144521557,
0.0328538492,
0.0229912773,
-0.0336090401,
0.0280517563,
0.0250931233,
-0.0411530472,
-0.0222621914,
0.0158702619,
0.0101458635,
-0.0474786274,
0.0151858553,
-0.0534842014,
-0.0195418764,
0.0011068825,
0.0273731332,
0.0031977806,
0.0017117638,
0.0003546417,
0.0089322403,
-0.0817525312,
0.0043862313,
-0.020778507,
-0.0876884609,
0.0301649813,
0.0463209376,
0.0142187104,
-0.0420323908,
-0.0305996947,
0.0338483937,
-0.0515633933,
-0.0337077677,
0.0337316282,
-0.0332595706,
-0.0035372963,
0.0611897297,
0.0492399074,
0.0400600247,
-0.016624203,
-0.0241402257,
-0.0437149704,
0.0539014377,
-0.0066883881,
0.0025073281,
-0.0008154321,
-0.0111798607,
-0.0113484729,
0.0522053391,
0.0943239182,
0.016911434,
-0.0076063257,
-0.0152574331,
-0.0706161708,
0.0221846234,
-0.0158334877,
0.0141108409,
-0.015980795,
-0.0443084314,
0.0376647711,
0.0183943827,
0.0098110549,
-0.0381103568,
0.0231384262,
-0.0258873925,
0.0292121246,
-0.006704506,
0.0061850208,
0.0043169665,
-0.0245583802,
-0.0158399139,
-0.0404842719,
-0.0350642465,
0.0406389348,
0.0358629711,
0.0360191725,
0.0133553036,
-0.0119785061,
0.0052086934,
0.0021098736,
-0.0010036435,
-0.0435371846,
0.0313365795,
-0.0520060137,
0.0244428683,
0.0439199209,
0.011024219,
-0.0399824306,
0.0429741889,
0.0187539086,
0.0186739471,
-0.0656287149,
-0.0135845784,
0.0138539271,
-0.0011209194,
-0.0357881151,
-0.0041406942,
-0.0217897762,
-0.0464176461,
0.0011136872,
-0.0412091874,
-0.0074544325,
-0.0432331562,
2.697e-7,
-0.0239045378,
0.0537158698,
0.0093384683,
0.072000064,
-0.0020232992,
0.0672931522,
0.0132757444,
0.02346275,
0.0022609844,
-0.0419577099,
0.0633098632,
-0.0077698519,
0.0444475263,
0.0215544999,
-0.11049705,
-0.0363974124,
0.0101677207,
-0.0236035846,
-0.0469891205,
0.0363678932,
0.0905628726,
0.0550631732,
-0.0011082098,
-0.0170348044,
0.0216246471,
-0.0028399772,
0.00050337,
-0.0377175286,
0.0026321658,
0.0335229672,
0.0452830419,
0.0041314024,
-0.0070455908,
0.0379526317,
-0.0048121531,
0.0298184901,
-0.0047864397,
0.0250695255,
-0.0202042814,
-0.0542197488,
-0.0219665132,
0.0045804093,
0.017632382,
-0.0381420441,
0.0377626941,
-0.0344302617,
-0.0172888134,
-0.0260758828,
-0.0388302915,
0.0212536883,
-0.0100290449,
0.0114521123,
-0.0077216825,
0.0219854824,
0.0042468971,
-0.0116094798,
-0.0030137661,
-0.061864499,
0.0146286217,
-0.0047511635,
-0.0350884385,
-0.0672667846,
-0.0184811372,
-0.0226569977,
0.0025598716,
-0.0125155384,
-0.0034343153,
1.974427581e-34,
0.0241971835,
-0.0062539107,
0.0381947495,
0.0910210237,
0.0222404841,
-0.0147809824,
0.0362986401,
-0.0052306834,
0.0376283564,
-0.0515080243,
0.0085111298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12979v1 | GMNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Sentiment Analysis with Phylogeny-Based Adapters | 2023-04-25T16:39:51 | 2023-04-25T16:39:51 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Ruoyu Xie, Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This report describes GMU's sentiment analysis system for the SemEval-2023
shared task AfriSenti-SemEval. We participated in all three sub-tasks:
Monolingual, Multilingual, and Zero-Shot. Our approach uses models initialized
with AfroXLMR-large, a pre-trained multilingual language model trained on
African languages and fine-tuned correspondingly. We also introduce augmented
training data along with original training data. Alongside finetuning, we
perform phylogeny-based adapter tuning to create several models and ensemble
the best models for the final submission. Our system achieves the best F1-score
on track 5: Amharic, with 6.2 points higher F1-score than the second-best
performing system on this track. Overall, our system ranks 5th among the 10
systems participating in all 15 tracks. | [
0.0393614434,
0.1021274775,
-0.0094838748,
0.0273564532,
0.0144175943,
0.0443680994,
-0.0063670925,
0.0022050622,
-0.0060128053,
-0.0588998422,
-0.0315083973,
-0.0802685767,
0.0218386035,
0.0365140624,
0.0055210823,
-0.030412456,
0.0463270061,
0.0227641333,
-0.0015979395,
-0.0138431787,
-0.0170876458,
0.0493367277,
0.0165327713,
-0.0060121054,
-0.0327242017,
-0.009403836,
-0.004454311,
0.003245387,
0.017488746,
-0.0307362527,
0.008728425,
0.0229471698,
-0.0222589988,
0.0367308781,
0.000002317,
-0.0463638641,
-0.0333971493,
-0.0108228261,
-0.0090302285,
0.0057652276,
0.0781877339,
0.0014585317,
-0.0115526319,
0.0203400012,
-0.0501593016,
-0.0273314845,
0.0647365823,
0.0072554103,
0.0409966633,
0.0887050927,
-0.0082956525,
-0.0581813976,
0.0237776302,
-0.0275487565,
-0.0125891073,
-0.0276156012,
0.0051877941,
-0.0065338402,
-0.0160156153,
0.0010432944,
-0.0304998495,
0.0146495551,
-0.0234681536,
-0.0086802188,
0.0253432207,
-0.0240913779,
-0.0072940076,
-0.0635579824,
-0.0137052722,
0.0025979022,
0.0024370097,
-0.009237322,
-0.0563542545,
0.0105635086,
-0.0554580241,
-0.0222284906,
0.0072507095,
0.0154459449,
0.0108762449,
0.0393923409,
0.0324174277,
0.01674092,
0.0300979875,
0.0259924512,
-0.0506247804,
0.0924857408,
-0.0054524015,
-0.0166797806,
0.0482108667,
0.0528619476,
0.0074506998,
0.0137717854,
0.0074299392,
-0.0091948295,
-0.0280045886,
-0.0130440099,
0.0526584461,
-0.0299304072,
0.0132190213,
-0.0844180956,
0.0593861677,
0.0242292527,
0.0072183986,
0.0214309152,
-0.061865896,
0.0050526946,
0.0125308586,
-0.0461008549,
-0.0021669758,
-0.0399083793,
-0.0569388419,
-0.0048388927,
0.0232058503,
0.0219502747,
-0.0448624305,
0.0665548816,
-0.0586510785,
-0.0244307816,
-0.022197945,
-0.0294720195,
-0.0017062139,
-0.0174689926,
0.0086398609,
-0.0103674056,
-0.0310015474,
0.0355740897,
-0.0327334255,
0.0146423001,
-0.0471532382,
-0.0724175572,
0.0234686006,
0.0005898877,
-0.0235060658,
0.0028740007,
0.0405402966,
0.0630237311,
0.0234853681,
-0.0581728518,
-0.0281633493,
0.002090361,
-0.0374729,
-0.0397675335,
-0.0307927821,
-0.0344433933,
0.0430083461,
0.02014222,
0.0454975143,
0.0174856205,
-0.024356246,
-0.0412895791,
-0.0240314119,
0.0585194007,
-0.0237467047,
-0.014175944,
0.0031216994,
-0.0051577762,
0.0378386304,
0.073858723,
-0.0142760314,
0.0158025958,
0.0286260266,
-0.0047219936,
-0.0496997796,
0.0075449804,
-0.0059467754,
-0.020870911,
-0.0204419065,
0.0277187154,
0.0248046406,
-0.0054635783,
0.0151278283,
0.0200620014,
0.0256855804,
-0.0268994439,
0.0382237881,
0.0109514566,
0.0088459076,
0.0449974127,
0.0036629119,
-0.0354545265,
-0.0079330159,
-0.0293193869,
0.0021134322,
0.0281980541,
-0.0613686368,
-0.0531982146,
0.0071655498,
0.0840578973,
-0.0040951935,
-0.0397528782,
0.0127585251,
-0.0224990305,
0.0069494173,
0.003866947,
0.0430550314,
-0.0203048792,
-0.0106948381,
-0.0164907947,
0.081322819,
-0.0973279104,
-0.0135788387,
-0.0288022421,
0.0638418347,
0.0594185628,
-0.0123503152,
0.0225709062,
-0.0349178053,
-0.0083853249,
-0.0076658945,
0.0642873868,
0.017782947,
-0.0131712835,
0.0261513926,
-0.0557612404,
-0.0090530887,
0.003189178,
0.0208592024,
0.0497179031,
-0.0066240071,
0.0712279454,
0.0068673189,
0.0232037473,
-0.0417564325,
0.025553925,
-0.0488990061,
0.0121454401,
0.0058584372,
-0.001829283,
0.0824248269,
0.0504982322,
-0.0241800416,
-0.0201379042,
0.0177990068,
-0.0390564166,
0.0024956814,
0.0455646217,
-0.0388104282,
-0.0055148685,
0.0397774279,
-0.0474920869,
0.0080875875,
0.0436180308,
0.005695621,
-0.0335504413,
0.0538503714,
0.0026034459,
0.075325951,
-0.0257682279,
0.0209833048,
-0.0639864653,
0.0133955488,
0.0183576662,
0.0188305043,
0.0467190817,
0.0102377273,
-0.0307358429,
-0.0313483663,
0.0314892009,
0.0186891966,
-0.0363348871,
0.0143181244,
0.0159761924,
-0.0307057779,
0.0217142347,
0.0200386941,
-0.0341379866,
-0.0296653919,
-0.1046608463,
-0.0004841293,
-0.0072990512,
0.0541738272,
-0.0042847591,
0.0362141207,
-0.0057109599,
0.0110338256,
-0.0180459004,
0.024128601,
-0.0140880635,
0.0147605054,
0.0133629199,
-0.01900311,
0.0290238801,
-0.0598657914,
0.0193049386,
0.0052284659,
0.0546143726,
0.0080610132,
-0.0551057532,
0.018907683,
-0.0318741798,
-0.0727892444,
-0.0212495215,
0.0006746948,
-0.053483434,
0.0137900347,
-0.0048992606,
0.0087730335,
0.0114888959,
0.0177790839,
0.0091561899,
0.0067344992,
0.0171617735,
-0.0258356091,
-0.0008756767,
-0.0177474581,
0.0271910708,
-0.013341303,
-0.0049884561,
-0.0214944482,
0.1042411402,
-0.0311207604,
-0.0336630903,
-0.0436114557,
0.021701958,
-0.0077239228,
-0.0404035226,
0.024934411,
0.0028493016,
0.013450874,
0.0063615432,
-0.0151513163,
-0.0514348336,
0.0618157871,
0.0244320575,
-0.030932134,
-0.0458903983,
-0.0008912415,
-0.0195686575,
0.0333884247,
0.0013313014,
0.0216816515,
0.0096389446,
0.0454259254,
-0.0169518925,
-0.0058021718,
0.0287743118,
-0.0165422093,
0.0279494394,
0.0250252392,
0.0089897318,
-0.0199670512,
-0.0457425863,
0.0195006914,
-0.0149676977,
-0.0665962026,
-0.0083626332,
0.0276658162,
-0.0423981957,
-0.0394127294,
0.0281301234,
-0.02211475,
-0.0639297813,
-0.0153985247,
-0.0110776369,
0.0390998721,
0.0060299593,
0.0199079756,
0.0042309267,
0.0501850359,
-0.0201729648,
0.027008526,
0.0226212032,
-0.0462377556,
-0.0158392414,
0.003649293,
0.0138938595,
0.0270642359,
-0.0281256493,
-0.0407947488,
-0.063638553,
0.0359529294,
-0.0278796218,
0.0404542275,
0.0935318917,
0.0278071295,
-0.0375313126,
0.0129289851,
-0.031483829,
0.0312878452,
0.011956769,
0.0125321923,
-0.0466801077,
-0.0244283006,
-0.022823751,
-0.0016382013,
-0.0001999588,
-0.0231744461,
0.0096967425,
-0.1143604144,
-0.0146779334,
0.0205137637,
-0.0260219201,
-0.0333530381,
-0.0427848175,
-0.020360807,
-0.0449620187,
-0.0233597048,
-0.0018007046,
0.0318030566,
0.0211882871,
0.0163691379,
-0.0189097635,
-0.0388011225,
0.0406096913,
-0.0227085426,
0.0450743176,
0.0584969968,
0.0391803384,
-0.0239996295,
-0.045979768,
0.0123680606,
-0.0346075445,
-0.0121419551,
-0.0327658094,
0.0138571104,
0.0052415738,
-0.0245037563,
-0.0195952374,
-0.0467542522,
-0.0263273343,
0.0422584862,
0.0074904449,
0.0710481107,
0.0038448558,
-0.0450246744,
-0.0525208674,
-0.0001768504,
-0.0144240716,
0.0455017872,
0.0206684396,
-0.0740177855,
-0.0351098999,
-0.0228419583,
0.0019121903,
-0.0500710942,
-0.0219697095,
0.0006228182,
0.0108824698,
-0.0503402464,
-0.0735871643,
-0.0632965863,
0.0365423113,
0.0236498136,
-0.0094723599,
-0.0220194906,
-0.0455397256,
0.0054096282,
-0.0341560021,
0.0312721618,
0.0161667988,
0.0168568213,
-0.0221154783,
-0.0469333455,
0.0940753743,
0.0219941866,
0.0031176482,
0.0098435059,
-0.0352175348,
-0.0679847151,
0.0033271611,
0.0615884475,
0.0212934799,
0.0177828763,
0.0316464305,
-0.0346444324,
0.0336577855,
0.0336970687,
0.0206638556,
0.0333930291,
0.0336948037,
0.0404483378,
-0.0147088878,
0.0511826128,
0.0029051676,
0.0509806536,
0.0352853499,
0.0249109119,
0.0083912909,
-0.0608982593,
-0.0288984943,
-0.0308671333,
0.0252962038,
-0.0512212105,
-0.1254548579,
-0.0215798933,
0.0048836009,
0.0139499269,
0.0152300401,
-0.0319334939,
-0.0062510367,
0.0070184488,
0.0217539463,
-0.0456933975,
-0.007055412,
-0.0267677773,
0.0142798498,
-0.0331163295,
0.0818753317,
0.0866122395,
-0.0105454503,
-0.0126457913,
0.0437174886,
0.0032916439,
-0.0112977726,
-0.0001878058,
0.0263085216,
-0.0320432298,
0.003368157,
-0.0119993761,
0.0277305227,
0.0079937931,
0.0287695229,
0.0028659261,
0.0570042878,
-0.0571427867,
0.0468148775,
0.0478034317,
-0.0230499972,
0.0954579115,
0.0182990823,
-0.0148478188,
-0.0213581044,
0.0462771207,
-0.0362693258,
-0.0260646883,
0.021388771,
0.0018888939,
-0.0416761413,
0.0139049282,
0.0320530236,
-0.0609422028,
0.0551383421,
0.0604230091,
0.0227401741,
-0.0133923069,
-0.0085151056,
0.0330290385,
-0.0407926925,
-0.0028444817,
0.0346547738,
-0.0728105381,
-0.0614472739,
0.0836876407,
-0.0178948287,
0.0079461969,
0.0397043079,
0.0114996461,
0.0240753759,
0.0126234256,
0.0437576659,
-0.0377978608,
-0.0312534012,
-0.03544892,
-0.0073265564,
0.0024386293,
-6.78648227e-33,
-0.0337623954,
-0.0069925026,
-0.0539042726,
-0.0162834357,
-0.0179560632,
-0.0164894462,
0.0031056749,
0.0385776944,
-0.0484385826,
0.0300859343,
-0.0060210042,
-0.0059772823,
0.0016282358,
0.0297858566,
0.0561995953,
0.0520714782,
0.0282796212,
0.0077362424,
0.0031643163,
0.0063665928,
0.0330947563,
0.0813525766,
0.0821640119,
-0.0439637601,
0.0402263813,
0.0016559603,
-0.0407302417,
-0.0165775865,
0.0006948397,
0.0483645163,
-0.0370494165,
0.0571711659,
0.0362066403,
0.0078986045,
0.0070792111,
-0.0492757782,
-0.0308120716,
0.0045494535,
0.0169366039,
0.0205345359,
0.0149893276,
-0.0211005788,
0.0217402559,
0.0058995243,
-0.0346746519,
-0.0043560383,
0.0307021849,
-0.0608944744,
-0.0021040463,
-0.035399247,
-0.0724958479,
0.0357231647,
0.0133515978,
0.0083225248,
0.0269423295,
0.0855441764,
0.0016029835,
0.0245830305,
-0.017616529,
0.026965946,
0.0254196245,
0.0273272339,
0.0074348547,
0.0305675026,
-0.0186350588,
0.0459796749,
0.0370080844,
-0.0233681612,
0.0197249614,
0.0425799526,
0.0255761649,
-0.0227114782,
0.0324236974,
0.0846309066,
0.0071077272,
-0.0722186193,
-0.0268951952,
0.0244873893,
0.0885206759,
0.0088546369,
0.0018202746,
0.0108685354,
-0.0107601872,
-0.0029191938,
0.0017033454,
-0.0435149446,
-0.0127089908,
-0.0367562994,
0.0004943071,
-0.0451284274,
-0.0208825339,
0.0162462853,
0.0171189867,
-0.0431059003,
-0.0361853801,
-0.0240235478,
-0.0213772655,
-0.0011837323,
0.0329063572,
0.0168519802,
-0.0301757529,
-0.0121710114,
-0.0177752804,
0.0373010412,
0.0072283191,
-0.0238211658,
0.0323364064,
0.0359489433,
-0.100707531,
-0.0001831094,
-0.0220081508,
0.0098673729,
-0.0054417904,
0.1256655604,
-0.0029971036,
-0.0321983844,
-0.0040470492,
0.0411339253,
0.0089608599,
0.0365831219,
0.0150644798,
0.0119370529,
-0.0105426507,
-0.007941002,
-0.0617587641,
-0.0191240907,
0.0048743971,
0.0177174434,
-0.0347236358,
-0.0384662151,
0.0074418979,
-0.0016289857,
3.042e-7,
0.0389475413,
0.047810968,
-0.021573931,
-0.0696808621,
0.0059498707,
0.0280437823,
-0.0193375219,
-0.012330276,
-0.0015867611,
0.0157198235,
-0.008447215,
-0.0154537698,
0.0737200528,
0.0391490832,
-0.0740398094,
0.0232163016,
-0.0440005399,
-0.0103864875,
-0.0139055811,
0.0156525653,
0.0006355908,
0.1740683764,
-0.0068211616,
-0.0265078619,
-0.0517566614,
0.009158521,
0.0636138692,
-0.0765034184,
-0.0301771034,
-0.0183636136,
0.0038221776,
-0.0068165492,
-0.0312498268,
-0.0087139877,
-0.0302770212,
0.017098289,
-0.0390573181,
0.0388910845,
-0.0112925349,
-0.0099869762,
0.0474595279,
0.0419554077,
-0.0246639885,
-0.0602453388,
0.0348678418,
0.0418323465,
-0.060253568,
-0.0892318934,
-0.0344142243,
0.0156815015,
0.0471817479,
-0.0329755582,
-0.0043595885,
0.0247537754,
-0.002348949,
-0.063378185,
-0.0562125333,
-0.0548830889,
-0.019992739,
0.0121129835,
-0.0111628026,
-0.0488975309,
0.0098790163,
0.0236030407,
0.0506851189,
-0.0238344669,
0.0204231869,
2.50458885e-34,
0.0614312328,
-0.0386453681,
0.0200216193,
0.0236776825,
-0.0046718414,
-0.0231238268,
-0.0249810424,
-0.0102652069,
0.0222147088,
-0.0421756953,
-0.0053426772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12959v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12959v2 | Escaping the sentence-level paradigm in machine translation | 2023-04-25T16:09:02 | 2024-05-16T13:32:14 | Matt Post, Marcin Junczys-Dowmunt | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is well-known that document context is vital for resolving a range of
translation ambiguities, and in fact the document setting is the most natural
setting for nearly all translation. It is therefore unfortunate that machine
translation -- both research and production -- largely remains stuck in a
decades-old sentence-level translation paradigm. It is also an increasingly
glaring problem in light of competitive pressure from large language models,
which are natively document-based. Much work in document-context machine
translation exists, but for various reasons has been unable to catch hold. This
paper suggests a path out of this rut by addressing three impediments at once:
what architectures should we use? where do we get document-level information
for training them? and how do we know whether they are any good? In contrast to
work on specialized architectures, we show that the standard Transformer
architecture is sufficient, provided it has enough capacity. Next, we address
the training data issue by taking document samples from back-translated data
only, where the data is not only more readily available, but is also of higher
quality compared to parallel document data, which may contain machine
translation output. Finally, we propose generative variants of existing
contrastive metrics that are better able to discriminate among document
systems. Results in four large-data language pairs (DE$\rightarrow$EN,
EN$\rightarrow$DE, EN$\rightarrow$FR, and EN$\rightarrow$RU) establish the
success of these three pieces together in improving document-level performance. | [
0.0348069966,
0.0661526322,
-0.020567514,
0.0529503562,
-0.0673603937,
0.0207520854,
0.0397319347,
0.0077148573,
-0.0493626222,
-0.0368643291,
-0.0423622392,
-0.0581701323,
0.0343148671,
-0.0159174036,
0.0294436403,
-0.0715007931,
0.006424732,
0.00446994,
-0.0470049717,
0.0019427845,
0.002691688,
0.004394189,
0.0379334278,
0.0130641498,
0.0041472293,
-0.0222751908,
0.0108636692,
0.0529340692,
0.0451762304,
0.0162193794,
0.0064296885,
-0.0003120151,
0.012772412,
0.0656064674,
0.0000020088,
-0.0207953285,
-0.0562342666,
-0.0040234895,
0.0286780577,
-0.021201577,
0.073115319,
-0.1120486036,
-0.0288766045,
0.0263547469,
-0.0181100201,
-0.056205757,
0.047455404,
0.0241241939,
0.0140323834,
0.1113456115,
-0.0463080034,
-0.0714875236,
0.0168893021,
-0.0356507525,
-0.0256034024,
-0.0425918475,
-0.0293183532,
-0.0091114854,
-0.0144692343,
0.0314519033,
-0.0164969452,
0.0470369905,
0.0193679295,
-0.029489249,
-0.0187572297,
0.0030023358,
-0.0247795731,
-0.0124705974,
-0.0098839654,
0.0331573896,
-0.0221786536,
-0.0208372362,
-0.0003163412,
-0.0120241903,
-0.0203025974,
-0.0031243882,
-0.0171325598,
0.0126891546,
-0.0157976113,
0.0247579273,
0.0600812025,
0.0608333722,
0.0181888957,
-0.0123626366,
-0.0724809393,
-0.0258796327,
0.051494386,
-0.0332140289,
0.003491194,
0.0152012659,
-0.0270825587,
-0.0213412959,
0.0356899202,
-0.0040353155,
-0.0126512079,
0.0046992563,
-0.0522544682,
-0.0854336023,
0.0135792783,
-0.0558292456,
0.0261146557,
0.0420878679,
-0.0125770904,
0.041870553,
-0.0064077554,
0.0897858813,
-0.0362179168,
-0.0198125299,
-0.0916402936,
-0.0327520035,
-0.000840715,
0.0456040278,
-0.0585305095,
-0.04199351,
-0.0685122833,
-0.0383510143,
-0.034842249,
0.0449252762,
0.0283145141,
0.0128133297,
0.0272260234,
-0.0549587794,
-0.0816941559,
-0.0166731384,
0.0324673876,
0.0409427807,
-0.0153073817,
-0.0227398593,
-0.0135887014,
-0.054479897,
0.011141533,
0.0524314828,
-0.0014583609,
-0.0358572043,
-0.0015903485,
0.0747026727,
-0.0101227527,
-0.0261860602,
-0.0229058005,
0.0068124225,
-0.0289941188,
-0.0721438527,
0.0124365818,
-0.0576496907,
0.0405101292,
0.0327973962,
0.0271276273,
-0.0045945812,
-0.018681718,
-0.0072141099,
0.0008728804,
0.062673226,
0.025774125,
-0.017207792,
0.0116799837,
-0.0299465042,
-0.0178555418,
0.0600429624,
0.0538160838,
0.0212245472,
0.0714346096,
-0.012388153,
-0.0305140149,
0.058533065,
-0.0236253925,
0.0140184751,
-0.0186405592,
0.0007013676,
0.0220351797,
-0.0021399995,
0.0207799375,
0.0712077692,
-0.012160155,
0.0031263125,
0.0627430007,
0.0212947559,
0.0483357124,
0.0421397649,
0.0456333123,
-0.0082744248,
-0.0278608482,
0.0526618659,
0.0156807639,
-0.0037588889,
0.0231263917,
0.0086910604,
0.0176152308,
0.0434608608,
-0.0269970819,
-0.0228946675,
-0.0078741405,
-0.0080558863,
-0.0060183844,
-0.0512480512,
0.0777530968,
0.0315439627,
-0.0493214875,
-0.0027516871,
-0.0258716308,
-0.0539398678,
0.0038530116,
-0.0044924421,
-0.0382739417,
0.045057442,
0.0470882356,
-0.0134565718,
0.007742384,
0.0089481948,
-0.0044681518,
0.0673771799,
0.0590431243,
-0.0002813501,
0.028706776,
-0.0389237851,
-0.0065873368,
-0.0049156542,
-0.0018672412,
0.0317257605,
-0.008635357,
0.0254002716,
0.0319623202,
-0.0515073314,
-0.0447938554,
0.0280720908,
-0.0258127656,
-0.0197777916,
0.0555809997,
0.0212414097,
0.0307684503,
0.0016474222,
-0.0084166406,
0.0016242593,
0.0135436514,
-0.0574629121,
0.00292523,
0.0517329052,
-0.0337481797,
-0.0496730357,
-0.0148775196,
-0.0545454025,
0.0101756947,
0.0173918437,
-0.0492256209,
-0.0587755702,
-0.0079240436,
-0.0492670611,
0.0525367595,
-0.0216865782,
0.0686070323,
-0.011553674,
-0.0065169833,
-0.0438528024,
0.0538602136,
-0.0072009871,
0.0149463741,
0.013768455,
0.0133966058,
0.0362192467,
-0.0012466126,
-0.026190605,
0.0178859215,
0.0240212157,
0.0257615652,
0.0552433878,
0.0112747718,
-0.0084311552,
-0.0560989119,
-0.0590451285,
0.041476056,
-0.052418571,
0.0628535002,
0.0680803806,
0.064812623,
0.0275830887,
-0.0015984935,
-0.0263575949,
0.0282655228,
0.026044827,
0.0234913211,
0.0324766934,
0.0020915507,
-0.0078838477,
-0.0052348394,
-0.0250014961,
0.0131309507,
0.0466194265,
0.0234247148,
-0.0049255341,
-0.0902315155,
0.0584354475,
0.0111235296,
0.0216356125,
-0.0242542401,
-0.0387293063,
0.0004736404,
-0.0139802508,
0.0532242209,
0.0588497221,
0.0146320779,
0.0189590845,
0.0124801947,
0.0107612582,
-0.025583297,
-0.0124676591,
-0.039062161,
-0.0136831002,
-0.036382664,
-0.051717516,
0.0308068339,
0.0451475531,
0.0073589138,
-0.0000495695,
-0.0360680781,
-0.0147285992,
-0.015272011,
-0.0015097085,
0.0203106925,
0.0134035926,
0.0091101816,
0.0227743909,
-0.0146165295,
-0.0487094223,
0.0346873254,
-0.0385412388,
0.0019945076,
-0.0699559152,
-0.0165609457,
-0.0368216969,
0.0407825336,
-0.0010424593,
0.0177190062,
-0.0421118028,
-0.0118902437,
-0.0298576169,
0.0309491493,
0.0115865441,
-0.0111723747,
0.0515471958,
-0.0508517511,
0.0080936616,
-0.0443110131,
-0.0612582527,
-0.0235473439,
0.0051539359,
0.0197913647,
0.0182786305,
0.0668836832,
-0.0434532501,
-0.0486024022,
0.0238689445,
-0.0088837026,
0.0953333825,
-0.011157033,
-0.0244274046,
-0.0213487707,
0.0905463994,
-0.0046314853,
-0.0353454649,
0.0375875533,
-0.0529904366,
0.0191294849,
0.033860974,
0.00842648,
-0.0291622449,
-0.0477522798,
-0.0338212512,
0.041854389,
-0.0109000076,
-0.0438528731,
-0.0360705294,
0.0275995247,
-0.0463194214,
-0.0451065227,
0.1042421237,
0.0019719996,
-0.0555707142,
-0.0213167127,
0.014493701,
0.0373737067,
-0.0070500765,
0.0120276501,
-0.0733964518,
-0.0159591194,
-0.0097574703,
0.0188138001,
0.0045398218,
0.0316335522,
-0.0146763008,
-0.0519039854,
0.030570114,
0.0251672585,
-0.0692333877,
-0.0429089107,
-0.0165082254,
-0.0096487505,
-0.0272835884,
0.011098545,
-0.0136186918,
-0.0026841047,
-0.0199393574,
-0.014682251,
0.0406082422,
-0.0486000627,
-0.0300172847,
-0.0440769829,
-0.0136388233,
0.054595124,
0.0370145477,
-0.0018044906,
-0.0337134004,
0.0074051395,
-0.0560119525,
-0.0016989631,
-0.0169840641,
0.036237251,
-0.0084130093,
-0.0045736488,
0.0033528376,
0.0106808627,
-0.0239319187,
0.0278789438,
0.0062156646,
0.0351550542,
-0.0275578443,
0.0032493537,
0.0018991927,
-0.0240603425,
0.0271451287,
0.0513239577,
0.0033113894,
-0.0573753938,
-0.0347787701,
-0.0021607981,
0.0215844177,
-0.0609262623,
0.0433986075,
-0.0369594507,
-0.0530128665,
-0.0325087793,
-0.0775972232,
-0.0354976244,
-0.0191651117,
0.0434490182,
0.0080962628,
-0.0269035827,
-0.003812148,
-0.0320370011,
-0.0187700577,
-0.0101593323,
-0.0054130638,
0.0136386761,
-0.0534066595,
0.0084082121,
0.0349387862,
-0.0026948585,
0.0023942401,
0.0317610651,
-0.0868941098,
-0.0607161932,
0.0020014721,
0.0283503588,
0.0207492355,
0.0453322195,
-0.0146753164,
-0.0189194772,
0.0439573154,
0.0090433685,
-0.0332406648,
0.0060510705,
0.0541315787,
-0.0064049684,
-0.0204083063,
0.0579792932,
-0.0260739345,
0.0037815261,
0.0339336097,
0.0368236117,
-0.0173243824,
-0.0446586646,
0.0085284412,
-0.0208498575,
0.031519644,
-0.0383407809,
-0.0153061124,
-0.0207349341,
0.0419467837,
-0.0530248024,
-0.0237807706,
-0.0548991673,
-0.0352290869,
0.0565196723,
0.0324492492,
-0.0267542396,
0.0637459084,
-0.0040924461,
-0.0007350076,
-0.018950047,
0.013792186,
0.0186568834,
0.0394906551,
0.006637936,
0.0221140459,
-0.0154999588,
0.0056990511,
0.0264773741,
0.0466285758,
-0.0374465212,
0.0710530281,
0.0361712351,
0.0007049993,
0.0013632678,
0.0465645529,
-0.0797849894,
0.0387671888,
-0.025619695,
0.0058871345,
0.0604479164,
-0.0311641656,
0.1050378457,
-0.0297600366,
-0.0228195544,
-0.0218002573,
0.0528958067,
0.0502437763,
-0.019227298,
-0.0342652723,
-0.0053079962,
0.0153372958,
0.0492234416,
0.0636932775,
-0.0404390134,
-0.0041152593,
-0.0025916421,
-0.0283712111,
-0.0266614128,
0.0051684682,
0.0152941905,
-0.0363784283,
-0.002645449,
-0.0235314853,
-0.0521693341,
-0.0381936431,
0.0174669698,
0.0225078501,
0.0219752397,
-0.0059249075,
0.0028552839,
0.0785865933,
-0.0215715412,
-0.014497716,
-0.0619936585,
0.0318819918,
-0.0380679369,
-0.0188246164,
-0.0718173683,
-5.941273914e-33,
-0.0157841649,
-0.0153674893,
-0.0245150756,
-0.0111746546,
-0.0151758138,
0.0167433843,
-0.0247492865,
-0.0526390411,
0.0019633551,
0.0102930721,
-0.0166340172,
0.0085560177,
0.0249106195,
0.0174440835,
-0.0153382132,
0.0368220434,
0.0767820254,
-0.0100052925,
-0.0394717157,
0.0315972865,
0.064334698,
-0.0136619424,
0.0750894248,
-0.0668963119,
0.0264959335,
-0.0429158881,
-0.0070049306,
0.0232131928,
0.0386944823,
0.0192796476,
0.0081447223,
-0.0002333803,
0.0175946821,
-0.0427120142,
-0.0231089424,
0.0284323674,
-0.0923521966,
0.0036035359,
0.0154964421,
0.0566829629,
-0.0176183786,
-0.0502398461,
0.0287184715,
-0.0363022089,
-0.0151288565,
-0.0276142936,
0.009739764,
-0.0251227245,
-0.0161021817,
-0.0309601389,
-0.0732419267,
0.0303674508,
0.0023616736,
0.0201474968,
0.0212596655,
0.0661321804,
-0.0059334952,
0.0135820443,
-0.0641610175,
0.0100451251,
-0.0004262189,
0.0497073457,
0.0494343005,
0.0279149134,
-0.0152362958,
0.0047161691,
0.0277720429,
0.0018273389,
0.0511615984,
-0.023968393,
0.020264402,
-0.0016481951,
0.0561307222,
0.0512908585,
0.0503553934,
0.0114579657,
-0.0637248904,
0.058513321,
-0.0101389214,
0.0158860106,
0.0208241045,
0.0167767629,
-0.0376442671,
-0.0054847235,
-0.0139878914,
-0.0638808236,
-0.0216085222,
-0.0057877903,
-0.0040484974,
0.0188682005,
-0.0170329735,
-0.027520515,
0.0629692674,
-0.0340870433,
0.0121131316,
0.0254252851,
-0.0324548297,
0.0191308837,
-0.0091038756,
0.0325234719,
-0.015439379,
-0.0501194671,
0.019679023,
0.0615029521,
0.0139745418,
-0.0230132733,
0.0598538108,
0.0231823176,
-0.0494997688,
0.0151499994,
-0.0301998705,
-0.0011188339,
-0.0363557562,
0.0123024704,
0.000826493,
-0.017668929,
0.0013000595,
0.0506760143,
0.0429012477,
-0.0011311137,
-0.0199713316,
-0.0296982434,
0.0081430906,
0.0371120647,
-0.055003196,
0.0160241593,
-0.0070132683,
0.0382594354,
0.062902309,
-0.0519291498,
-0.0162297636,
0.0075435457,
2.638e-7,
0.0594270937,
0.0149017638,
0.0420721062,
0.0222787019,
0.0148575986,
0.0193444174,
-0.0052779471,
0.0394280814,
0.0052789529,
0.0639018267,
0.0429398715,
-0.0112651028,
0.0851432532,
0.0230848286,
-0.0671729371,
0.0101249423,
-0.0510038137,
0.0238547865,
-0.0384746455,
0.0084924847,
0.048840005,
0.0814542249,
-0.0216331258,
-0.0132036638,
-0.0196681507,
-0.0316230468,
0.0778460875,
-0.0213236213,
-0.0008393734,
0.0155824656,
0.054443676,
0.012231946,
-0.0392328389,
-0.0005716878,
-0.0296481512,
0.0402856208,
0.0135485912,
0.0771336704,
0.0271231215,
0.0190331601,
0.0253985692,
-0.0430946276,
-0.0138446586,
-0.0533934645,
0.0504157841,
-0.0309816804,
0.0018364971,
-0.0193333346,
-0.0224933587,
0.0127436714,
0.0201747119,
-0.040461503,
-0.0636670217,
0.0246417839,
0.0483621173,
-0.016735943,
-0.022601733,
-0.0448512696,
-0.0196805298,
-0.0065609878,
0.0091681127,
-0.0350277312,
0.0028385648,
0.0269439537,
0.0090473546,
-0.0173615515,
0.0111485869,
2.691413932e-34,
0.0573522188,
-0.0033562183,
-0.011341433,
-0.0257017706,
0.0175578427,
-0.0444366932,
-0.0181848295,
-0.0031340274,
-0.0026510882,
-0.0811865404,
-0.014400865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12955v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12955v2 | Nondeterministic Stacks in Neural Networks | 2023-04-25T16:00:40 | 2023-05-18T01:56:21 | Brian DuSell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human language is full of compositional syntactic structures, and although
neural networks have contributed to groundbreaking improvements in computer
systems that process language, widely-used neural network architectures still
exhibit limitations in their ability to process syntax. To address this issue,
prior work has proposed adding stack data structures to neural networks,
drawing inspiration from theoretical connections between syntax and stacks.
However, these methods employ deterministic stacks that are designed to track
one parse at a time, whereas syntactic ambiguity, which requires a
nondeterministic stack to parse, is extremely common in language. In this
dissertation, we remedy this discrepancy by proposing a method of incorporating
nondeterministic stacks into neural networks. We develop a differentiable data
structure that efficiently simulates a nondeterministic pushdown automaton,
representing an exponential number of computations with a dynamic programming
algorithm. We incorporate this module into two predominant architectures:
recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and transformers. We show that this raises
their formal recognition power to arbitrary context-free languages, and also
aids training, even on deterministic context-free languages. Empirically,
neural networks with nondeterministic stacks learn context-free languages much
more effectively than prior stack-augmented models, including a language with
theoretically maximal parsing difficulty. We also show that an RNN augmented
with a nondeterministic stack is capable of surprisingly powerful behavior,
such as learning cross-serial dependencies, a well-known non-context-free
pattern. We demonstrate improvements on natural language modeling and provide
analysis on a syntactic generalization benchmark. This work represents an
important step toward building systems that learn to use syntax in more
human-like fashion. | [
0.0075719496,
0.1158290207,
-0.0269043483,
0.0298230331,
-0.0400480255,
0.0166029893,
0.0065401983,
-0.0486745797,
-0.024018947,
-0.0484755524,
0.0100254035,
-0.0483011045,
0.0028087718,
0.0547315665,
0.0319834203,
-0.0427420028,
0.0553240292,
-0.0301300902,
0.0236624833,
0.0149092423,
-0.0080151577,
-0.0107301613,
-0.0303337593,
0.0097812088,
-0.037931364,
-0.0258240476,
-0.0356635973,
-0.0076290355,
-0.0277129263,
-0.0210709572,
0.0217187963,
0.0169383436,
0.0047999574,
0.0664530024,
0.0000021452,
-0.0286536925,
0.0357452668,
-0.0204223339,
-0.0590506569,
-0.0184864495,
0.0000948138,
-0.0389093794,
-0.0313148163,
-0.0161464699,
-0.0381806567,
-0.0489512645,
0.0350594297,
-0.0213037804,
0.0747067556,
0.0593419932,
-0.0017527593,
-0.0280894339,
0.0301352758,
-0.0475199781,
0.0187836625,
0.0018727691,
0.0179446544,
-0.024952108,
-0.0404527597,
0.0109235737,
-0.0215362664,
0.0215863734,
0.0431472063,
-0.0053960904,
-0.0014261861,
0.0448594652,
-0.0178441331,
-0.0103354417,
-0.0369971469,
0.0469355844,
-0.0557409488,
-0.0418291092,
0.0176363289,
-0.0161223989,
0.0146273142,
-0.0337546803,
-0.0200651232,
0.0625794902,
0.0168088563,
0.0207362045,
0.0261088982,
0.0094029251,
0.0409119911,
0.0016212839,
0.0155861303,
0.056763567,
0.0031828254,
-0.007061224,
0.0008866167,
-0.0130748386,
0.0159730874,
-0.0654769018,
0.0196453445,
0.0545487739,
0.0129042333,
0.0110667115,
-0.0182356667,
-0.0922715291,
0.0236145016,
-0.0734467208,
0.0035529563,
0.0270188116,
-0.0046184221,
0.0173670854,
-0.0224284027,
0.049943395,
-0.0311376043,
-0.0067716092,
-0.0331509858,
0.0347247198,
-0.0465108715,
-0.0210463218,
-0.0399656929,
0.0546079688,
-0.0284922421,
-0.0121088503,
-0.045279514,
0.0141030829,
-0.0088676196,
0.0136187561,
-0.0389060266,
0.0336322375,
-0.0729059801,
0.0678362027,
0.01095377,
-0.0009728723,
-0.0157896001,
-0.0193890743,
0.0168041829,
-0.0434284396,
-0.0356970392,
0.0190808717,
0.0092732394,
-0.0102442214,
-0.014541138,
0.0626087561,
-0.0132258479,
0.0327843837,
-0.0365642235,
-0.0036631981,
-0.0023804912,
-0.0290447325,
0.0507498644,
-0.0604000688,
0.0250758138,
-0.0026502486,
-0.0186866187,
-0.0378672071,
-0.0041228281,
0.0385543592,
-0.0117187276,
0.0622728355,
0.0047426857,
-0.0579989627,
0.0329243913,
-0.033192683,
-0.0152763324,
0.0302231517,
0.0555814765,
0.0275184419,
-0.0171078853,
0.0142073343,
0.0161189884,
0.0184141304,
-0.0134052848,
-0.0366722271,
-0.0886477381,
-0.0338305868,
0.0017935772,
0.0086407792,
0.0328301266,
0.0632735789,
-0.0049642478,
-0.0156738572,
-0.0155240269,
-0.0102778124,
0.0312408805,
0.0603417344,
0.0980264992,
0.007053663,
-0.0061013857,
0.0068228091,
-0.0721501112,
-0.002217894,
-0.0254750736,
0.0261070207,
-0.0951221213,
-0.0153920101,
-0.0249867011,
-0.0325625762,
0.0021457283,
-0.0127206538,
0.0469624549,
-0.0031851809,
0.023191927,
0.0351446681,
0.005541685,
0.0284246001,
-0.0085266959,
-0.0297627095,
-0.00222364,
-0.0090030208,
-0.0187653471,
0.0050530587,
-0.0067708767,
-0.0351943672,
-0.040227659,
-0.0206896756,
-0.0433245301,
0.0585999675,
-0.0066353842,
-0.0194401126,
0.0355992392,
-0.0392190292,
0.0286067221,
-0.0178715233,
0.0327142663,
0.0237552114,
-0.0482023954,
0.0096336277,
0.0160906371,
-0.0183268618,
0.0018598883,
0.0525904931,
-0.0061067389,
-0.0336417593,
0.0274727251,
0.0008666156,
0.0473245345,
0.0016971704,
-0.0023379822,
0.0350590944,
0.0404380038,
-0.0605368055,
-0.0279720854,
0.0153952092,
-0.1400858313,
-0.0401197113,
0.0344207473,
0.0118114147,
-0.0058674542,
0.0350090899,
-0.0308678485,
-0.0645649433,
0.0638372451,
-0.0559469871,
0.0450053662,
-0.0454445705,
-0.0033755919,
0.0345490389,
0.0209189467,
-0.0034405862,
0.1048090532,
-0.0264115129,
0.0122731933,
0.0044328733,
0.0336216055,
0.0198092908,
-0.0129912831,
-0.043320924,
0.0017157621,
-0.0223913752,
-0.0050832611,
-0.002036815,
0.0010798799,
-0.0362825505,
-0.0090671722,
-0.0307387691,
0.0169437453,
-0.0309789255,
0.0311634727,
0.0169194359,
0.0102729034,
0.0418445133,
-0.0390702337,
-0.0680484176,
0.0116283344,
-0.0120663326,
0.0227366351,
0.0881814659,
0.0310029481,
-0.052482605,
-0.0263932813,
-0.0470930301,
-0.0555024371,
0.0487660095,
-0.0087088952,
-0.038063217,
-0.0255019572,
0.0146990716,
0.0050637014,
0.0469895601,
-0.0127545195,
-0.0493829362,
0.007822101,
-0.0236199275,
-0.0224936306,
0.0611139312,
-0.0205221139,
-0.02120273,
0.0198639277,
-0.0176905766,
-0.0455941446,
0.042032361,
0.0040270328,
0.0296911988,
0.0230319034,
0.0061980933,
-0.0194157716,
0.1171879843,
-0.0131448098,
-0.007973494,
-0.0356707312,
-0.0064442614,
-0.0093133077,
-0.0103595378,
-0.0132710496,
-0.0662100017,
-0.0271252636,
0.0300446264,
-0.027913779,
-0.0084885303,
0.0564166456,
-0.013979313,
-0.0305779874,
-0.0218767952,
-0.0151256109,
-0.0512651578,
0.0672420636,
0.0539185517,
-0.0153711997,
0.0622140095,
-0.0640406087,
-0.0134286406,
-0.0321781188,
-0.0143127972,
0.0075919237,
0.0386013202,
-0.0489814654,
0.009758207,
-0.0178384334,
-0.0529191531,
-0.054645244,
-0.0288307108,
-0.0159682687,
0.0393540859,
0.0016474163,
0.0027867786,
0.0033092326,
-0.032466583,
-0.0249489062,
0.0985952541,
0.0088023506,
0.0069014467,
-0.0383551084,
0.0161952674,
-0.0057764235,
0.0165293366,
0.0101443231,
0.0029647707,
0.0042654905,
0.0083311088,
0.0555359758,
0.0230905209,
-0.0672229081,
0.0528211929,
0.0045532496,
-0.0082122767,
-0.0582177527,
0.0212378595,
-0.0057273963,
-0.0695772916,
-0.01202749,
0.0820080116,
0.0175445601,
-0.0599786416,
0.0130111575,
-0.0135041047,
0.0260861963,
0.0382777415,
0.0383978523,
-0.0985770375,
-0.0143956346,
0.0196417104,
-0.0192078855,
0.0025364798,
-0.0473600365,
-0.0036617892,
-0.0863178968,
-0.0098383017,
0.0009138249,
-0.0623262823,
0.0608494096,
-0.0130687831,
-0.0040486716,
-0.0124112684,
0.0021416729,
0.0077978834,
-0.0026258978,
-0.0243129227,
0.0145817045,
-0.0188977905,
-0.0083648218,
0.0076792631,
-0.04487288,
0.0136194937,
0.0636425242,
0.0143771963,
-0.0455770828,
-0.0429204665,
0.0661396906,
-0.0059624272,
0.035225071,
-0.0062423842,
0.018062897,
0.0153931091,
-0.0084263794,
-0.0155197429,
0.0336577892,
-0.041063223,
-0.0080528883,
-0.0227890797,
0.0668881387,
-0.0006350154,
-0.0021573789,
-0.0331213512,
-0.0106968563,
0.0191740636,
0.0197183657,
0.03349353,
-0.0464158542,
-0.0596075654,
-0.0880886465,
0.0222973358,
-0.0578598939,
0.0082575381,
0.0219428018,
0.0577684604,
-0.0573520996,
-0.0784051269,
-0.0340079293,
-0.0034711154,
0.0003098068,
0.0204394013,
-0.0181000922,
0.0539117083,
-0.0111534409,
-0.0236260444,
0.0184097625,
0.0046957075,
0.0062579121,
-0.0453120247,
-0.0146444077,
0.0305370595,
-0.0076280381,
-0.0309901964,
-0.0200346075,
-0.0995961204,
-0.0521442555,
0.0597626418,
0.0579097383,
0.0169724226,
0.0325402841,
-0.0302066691,
-0.0189292002,
0.0200185347,
0.0624385215,
-0.0306093991,
0.0183524396,
0.041138757,
-0.0222417936,
0.0106294369,
0.0294832401,
-0.0287517365,
0.0349243358,
0.0086526973,
0.0210782625,
-0.0332978368,
0.0176805481,
0.0377434529,
-0.0092833098,
0.0366899259,
0.0338754244,
0.0005132647,
0.0026938701,
0.0007417009,
-0.0027938955,
-0.0165078323,
-0.0509183258,
0.0230200589,
0.01459218,
0.0064991801,
-0.0056700166,
-0.0389644355,
0.0268016458,
0.0459205844,
-0.0067787217,
0.0233662836,
0.0291311461,
0.002149448,
-0.0039319023,
0.0224481355,
-0.0186936595,
0.0286049526,
-0.0080457702,
0.0295334309,
-0.0216446817,
0.0105553586,
0.0313512199,
0.0236301012,
-0.0475476049,
-0.0146341752,
-0.0684544072,
0.0016298023,
0.0028217169,
-0.059666045,
0.0656026676,
-0.0310935136,
0.0170337409,
-0.0299861934,
0.0270341747,
-0.0037102026,
-0.0047354912,
0.0288787168,
-0.0420086421,
0.0032713995,
0.0551161095,
-0.0014293345,
-0.0101011069,
0.0756128132,
0.0223300662,
0.0150259687,
0.0296584237,
0.0623591319,
-0.0591492355,
-0.0053118295,
-0.0056989817,
0.0512118898,
-0.0022644892,
-0.0065623904,
-0.0373224616,
-0.0761343464,
0.0459992066,
0.0262184069,
0.062185239,
-0.0325163938,
0.0497174822,
0.0197182223,
0.013767831,
-0.0310618188,
-0.036722146,
0.0252485257,
0.0722734854,
-0.0142418779,
-0.0627735853,
-6.288186542e-33,
0.0040316,
0.0085068559,
-0.0359680839,
0.0325761177,
-0.0235292874,
0.0248319209,
-0.0452711061,
0.0161923785,
-0.0155775258,
-0.0023759271,
-0.0460036658,
0.0365701616,
0.0149809644,
0.0459057987,
0.0779022947,
-0.0199282039,
0.0515184402,
-0.0331034511,
0.0227499735,
-0.0014627612,
0.0335791707,
0.0407645293,
0.0352936499,
-0.0523711145,
0.0190666765,
-0.0189791117,
-0.0047278292,
0.0426012091,
-0.0172492322,
0.028485937,
-0.0259034093,
0.0158165935,
0.0225313362,
-0.02447097,
-0.0358283408,
0.0390720181,
-0.1017263606,
-0.063222304,
0.0043010921,
0.0202415828,
-0.0564418063,
-0.0335774086,
0.0848949105,
-0.0188383348,
0.0055658887,
0.0392763689,
0.0135327382,
-0.0140938601,
-0.014332219,
-0.0065079378,
-0.0132435076,
-0.0037411365,
0.0002249543,
-0.0102584809,
0.020022504,
0.001201713,
-0.0157344919,
0.0284168068,
-0.0940764472,
-0.0165431406,
-0.0367626138,
0.0392531194,
0.0300454702,
0.0414356515,
0.01439068,
0.0454163216,
0.0122455386,
0.018645376,
-0.0373988375,
0.020264782,
0.0270981565,
0.0242952537,
0.0238276981,
-0.0023629328,
0.1159587428,
0.0067249523,
-0.0607725829,
-0.0387070216,
0.074149698,
0.0655930415,
-0.0197626948,
-0.000877419,
-0.0236083027,
-0.0399761014,
-0.0171724353,
0.0158618093,
-0.0367964841,
-0.013496913,
-0.0017127435,
0.0013578198,
0.0099228062,
0.0221863054,
0.0019177744,
-0.0102451397,
-0.010026182,
0.051636111,
0.0472114198,
0.038172964,
0.0340500884,
0.0146111874,
-0.039872393,
-0.0079951026,
-0.0362321176,
0.0260884482,
0.0612349883,
0.0273076519,
0.0620326437,
0.0432406738,
-0.0335704535,
-0.0242644176,
-0.0333583355,
0.0151072359,
-0.0034535548,
0.0674854666,
0.0523400493,
0.0135065988,
-0.0075213695,
0.0506958142,
-0.0130923782,
-0.0165789928,
-0.0236048941,
0.0468859822,
-0.0252261497,
0.0433776416,
-0.039810285,
-0.0796237141,
-0.0163354985,
0.0167849734,
0.0324559473,
-0.0694655702,
0.0049556843,
0.0386314243,
2.893e-7,
0.0110266116,
0.0247970019,
0.0634640977,
0.0601976179,
0.0707806721,
0.0450530238,
-0.0272584427,
0.0226354953,
-0.0297417622,
-0.0103171468,
-0.0272128638,
-0.0068224855,
0.0094292192,
0.02417049,
-0.1238927916,
0.0034411731,
-0.0584581234,
0.0033719498,
-0.0093990527,
0.0102274921,
0.0112691512,
0.096181713,
-0.0123111932,
-0.0112211322,
-0.0107721891,
-0.018692784,
0.0170075577,
0.0304866116,
0.0305634551,
0.0017944749,
-0.0431163236,
0.0237842835,
-0.0319964774,
0.0460709296,
-0.0157371126,
0.0245359596,
-0.0272017065,
0.0566868149,
-0.0078274533,
0.0180637054,
0.02495322,
-0.0201309416,
0.0055684079,
-0.0185632873,
0.0328831561,
-0.0607808568,
-0.0194604564,
0.0071097473,
-0.0116654504,
0.0440536924,
0.0033155612,
0.0212821011,
-0.0105533954,
0.0000063942,
0.0162792802,
-0.0445261821,
-0.0050658677,
-0.0392630175,
-0.0593197942,
0.0185095649,
-0.0559109785,
0.037714947,
-0.0419537723,
-0.0001636672,
0.0424856395,
-0.0293098595,
-0.0145181986,
2.56619233e-34,
0.0284552407,
-0.0203008763,
0.0252296068,
0.023514444,
0.0054161889,
0.0027602927,
-0.0247746352,
0.0499065742,
0.028572822,
-0.0309857819,
-0.0246040318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12888v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12888v2 | Out-of-distribution Evidence-aware Fake News Detection via Dual Adversarial Debiasing | 2023-04-25T14:59:25 | 2024-04-15T14:17:30 | Qiang Liu, Junfei Wu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evidence-aware fake news detection aims to conduct reasoning between news and
evidence, which is retrieved based on news content, to find uniformity or
inconsistency. However, we find evidence-aware detection models suffer from
biases, i.e., spurious correlations between news/evidence contents and
true/fake news labels, and are hard to be generalized to Out-Of-Distribution
(OOD) situations. To deal with this, we propose a novel Dual Adversarial
Learning (DAL) approach. We incorporate news-aspect and evidence-aspect
debiasing discriminators, whose targets are both true/fake news labels, in DAL.
Then, DAL reversely optimizes news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing
discriminators to mitigate the impact of news and evidence content biases. At
the same time, DAL also optimizes the main fake news predictor, so that the
news-evidence interaction module can be learned. This process allows us to
teach evidence-aware fake news detection models to better conduct news-evidence
reasoning, and minimize the impact of content biases. To be noted, our proposed
DAL approach is a plug-and-play module that works well with existing backbones.
We conduct comprehensive experiments under two OOD settings, and plug DAL in
four evidence-aware fake news detection backbones. Results demonstrate that,
DAL significantly and stably outperforms the original backbones and some
competitive debiasing methods. | [
0.0335749313,
0.0233382341,
0.0169623327,
0.0588437393,
-0.0245089307,
0.0184595007,
0.0035013573,
-0.0069466615,
0.011043434,
-0.0152537683,
-0.030918967,
0.009488849,
-0.003295975,
0.0426521301,
0.0088775624,
-0.0386389121,
0.0659749433,
0.0303614605,
0.0788443238,
-0.0231349468,
0.0447568707,
0.0388887636,
-0.00821108,
-0.0046226657,
-0.0225378592,
-0.0199801717,
0.0285875034,
0.0213815495,
0.0525793284,
-0.0109241223,
0.0269177519,
0.0044695958,
0.040662162,
0.0982736871,
0.0000017279,
0.005518449,
-0.0170123912,
0.0059066555,
-0.0375566818,
-0.0150598027,
0.0508475453,
-0.0550167672,
-0.019449845,
0.0245785918,
-0.0208989717,
-0.0377580971,
0.0192677919,
0.0841244981,
0.0608992428,
0.109704189,
-0.0168213807,
0.006352196,
0.0313618667,
-0.0325168408,
-0.0095715346,
-0.0030221073,
0.0404418856,
0.0171901844,
-0.0342016406,
0.0310450457,
0.0104899788,
0.0101025775,
0.045295693,
0.0166537911,
-0.0300233178,
0.0330434032,
0.0122865792,
-0.0224419106,
0.0100628175,
0.0412933491,
-0.0900400952,
-0.0709153786,
0.0189170577,
-0.0395749547,
0.0463759452,
0.042706497,
-0.0051074633,
-0.0143069355,
-0.0315605402,
0.025229726,
0.0307385232,
0.0026212805,
0.0448878817,
0.0450243466,
0.0068790382,
0.0212376397,
-0.0195664112,
-0.0008758511,
-0.0032391497,
0.000662197,
0.000728829,
-0.0467038378,
0.0191810708,
-0.0077900761,
-0.0123669645,
-0.0147512173,
-0.0681686848,
-0.0254662409,
0.012170976,
-0.0836106837,
-0.034006577,
-0.0396058112,
-0.0400263928,
0.0434626639,
-0.0176011529,
-0.0477246642,
-0.0335673206,
0.0525762886,
-0.0031295454,
0.0002710711,
0.0207945351,
0.0267986432,
0.0101822903,
0.0148244873,
-0.0193976518,
0.0037688969,
0.0060578641,
-0.0185866393,
-0.0263954941,
0.0291651171,
-0.0024816152,
0.027725989,
-0.0347105376,
-0.032302212,
-0.0114358943,
0.0286987964,
-0.020616753,
0.0417197645,
0.0130071715,
-0.0361683294,
-0.0336078405,
0.0372248664,
-0.0391436107,
-0.0078491839,
0.0046191532,
0.0212715976,
-0.014787754,
0.0201869141,
-0.0426439643,
-0.0105757397,
-0.0241832789,
-0.0554514602,
0.002655176,
-0.0522309057,
-0.0250209775,
-0.035688635,
-0.0136485491,
-0.0587919578,
-0.0304470286,
0.0112956408,
-0.0234257169,
0.0293711293,
0.015187433,
-0.0630041063,
0.0433275923,
0.0438291878,
-0.0047473582,
0.0970377922,
-0.0217535291,
0.1161638051,
0.0162814204,
0.0583337434,
0.0066126427,
-0.0337853059,
0.085064359,
0.0179257412,
-0.0023263784,
0.005630062,
0.0039913184,
0.0131057547,
0.0088624954,
0.0046384046,
-0.0324390791,
-0.0600199103,
0.0564869456,
-0.1103324145,
0.0282359105,
-0.0158530567,
0.0366724133,
0.0234980695,
-0.0411050059,
0.006562693,
-0.0595758036,
0.0442344286,
-0.0394890681,
-0.0182867683,
-0.0328246169,
0.0750454962,
-0.0334036946,
-0.0321952701,
0.0065508606,
-0.0171682443,
-0.02108212,
0.0113319503,
-0.0007851978,
0.0444711,
-0.0137431938,
-0.0171174649,
0.0233512837,
0.0329426862,
-0.0071778097,
-0.0557078384,
0.0297875367,
-0.0122957984,
0.0567449443,
-0.0107460571,
0.0121477144,
-0.0233328827,
0.0059417705,
0.0150089366,
0.0190238412,
-0.0300318431,
-0.0232318807,
-0.0293559693,
-0.0292733386,
-0.0785995498,
0.0036078067,
0.0192978047,
0.0127061987,
0.0457585417,
0.0051541235,
-0.013248343,
-0.0147453435,
0.0112715,
-0.0102888467,
-0.0003603883,
0.0115997661,
0.0298600812,
0.0120360823,
-0.0077023474,
0.0193693154,
-0.0208568722,
0.0420029759,
0.0216992907,
-0.0384119302,
-0.0269250646,
-0.048654709,
-0.0661043972,
-0.0096537834,
-0.0449158177,
-0.0203895159,
-0.0012327043,
-0.0199628808,
0.0339143388,
0.0161426328,
-0.0178737734,
-0.0080230953,
-0.0296545699,
-0.0656865686,
-0.0201317836,
0.0345923007,
0.0240163691,
0.1040517315,
-0.040488977,
-0.0507394299,
0.0059540202,
0.0014182638,
-0.0118815973,
0.002684809,
0.0238836054,
-0.002358288,
-0.0075795786,
-0.0016085368,
0.0185723677,
-0.0316621698,
0.0177879855,
-0.0318567157,
-0.0077640163,
0.0148879383,
-0.0456169061,
-0.0060007111,
0.0438055918,
-0.0085921027,
0.0157988165,
-0.0132082375,
-0.0609069839,
-0.0064464626,
-0.0118247904,
0.0207639635,
-0.0039545596,
-0.0108112274,
0.030011462,
0.0040966552,
0.0220418219,
-0.0030412418,
0.0370074436,
-0.0090548052,
-0.0361473262,
-0.0352076218,
-0.0348171107,
-0.0324663967,
0.0125191147,
-0.0638548955,
0.0371223912,
0.000078071,
0.0241984036,
0.0012841589,
0.0801975206,
0.0186682157,
0.0536340065,
0.052110713,
0.0391484313,
-0.0231699888,
-0.0199395362,
-0.015918551,
0.1124996692,
-0.016772341,
-0.0175166763,
-0.0005986571,
0.022036463,
0.0126223071,
0.0111244181,
0.0192275606,
0.054766167,
0.0214979295,
-0.0689625442,
0.0271766763,
-0.0340306014,
0.0096640969,
-0.0165813435,
-0.0530344769,
-0.0324463546,
0.1044195667,
0.0044487598,
0.034651313,
-0.0412820876,
-0.027390318,
0.0061197723,
-0.0326977558,
-0.0210376251,
0.0170328766,
0.0101611372,
0.0104092918,
-0.0214291476,
-0.0343442373,
0.0714734569,
-0.0381772742,
-0.0069727656,
-0.0246334597,
0.004339389,
0.0208832938,
-0.0264367294,
-0.0638830438,
-0.093854323,
0.022297943,
-0.0089693628,
-0.0580064654,
-0.0114318719,
-0.1072810888,
-0.0375660807,
0.0224876385,
0.0522893034,
-0.0269230455,
0.0127145704,
0.0163420569,
0.0357763134,
0.0287209656,
-0.0234892592,
0.0437966995,
-0.0054719932,
-0.0176206045,
0.0600852296,
-0.0538725741,
-0.0034109773,
0.0017689113,
-0.0311259292,
-0.0216748305,
0.0312076453,
0.0119951721,
-0.011126101,
0.0009613577,
-0.0225042515,
0.0004436531,
0.040758267,
-0.0101726195,
-0.024257401,
-0.0011023994,
0.0449504219,
-0.0055591334,
0.0117031587,
-0.0365069434,
-0.0827550665,
-0.0200463049,
0.0033682219,
0.008273731,
-0.0253206454,
0.0049893642,
-0.0165250059,
-0.0518482625,
-0.0075342404,
-0.0142278764,
0.0344380178,
-0.0146826003,
-0.0471615233,
0.003675303,
-0.0395978242,
0.0175950825,
-0.0202012826,
0.0497933254,
-0.0052342932,
-0.0105123231,
0.0578133129,
-0.0498497784,
-0.0137709416,
-0.0118782762,
0.0343493484,
0.0325898267,
0.036176201,
-0.001519107,
-0.0465144217,
-0.0409859158,
0.0054774266,
-0.0140800495,
-0.0111712134,
0.0534669794,
-0.0495527647,
0.005240283,
-0.0330924317,
0.0679518133,
0.0426840298,
-0.00926995,
-0.0274473988,
0.0329565145,
0.019581629,
-0.0743916929,
-0.0434263572,
-0.0005976763,
0.0525405928,
0.0329234749,
0.0106522925,
0.0174643025,
0.003931067,
-0.0131389769,
-0.0358509794,
0.0208383631,
-0.0190415196,
0.0484626293,
0.006079474,
-0.0428264625,
-0.0312674567,
-0.0222078618,
-0.0288440678,
0.0348621048,
-0.0309754033,
-0.019917028,
-0.0491565689,
-0.0241825804,
-0.020016538,
-0.0113312732,
-0.0008209498,
0.0586888976,
0.0203618445,
0.0176792555,
-0.0229331292,
-0.0279523153,
-0.0227648392,
0.058473967,
-0.0410068147,
-0.0510345437,
0.0183522366,
0.0300161093,
0.0089289108,
0.0715180412,
-0.0461853705,
-0.0115903141,
0.0726341158,
0.06869445,
-0.0000468162,
-0.0177329984,
0.0502681248,
-0.0577217191,
0.0555551238,
0.011290988,
0.0094471723,
0.054722935,
0.0439249501,
-0.0662004501,
-0.0485738479,
0.0276491884,
0.0203270186,
-0.0189679004,
0.0575830229,
-0.0062615089,
-0.0181191321,
-0.0338425897,
-0.0284207873,
-0.0198522359,
-0.0276733916,
0.0179610271,
0.0551130883,
0.0491689071,
-0.0029821757,
0.0049809283,
0.0555547588,
0.0045219986,
-0.0031726775,
-0.0348397121,
-0.0362665094,
0.0203061178,
0.0692526624,
-0.0070738294,
0.0009237853,
-0.0386638828,
0.0200630538,
0.0264925975,
0.0366113745,
-0.0221673008,
0.0111520942,
0.0286714248,
-0.0380037166,
0.0170853529,
-0.0259110481,
-0.0453924052,
0.0474005789,
-0.0639497116,
0.0542304032,
0.0089228135,
-0.0053655286,
-0.0026994753,
0.0145116327,
-0.0147157693,
-0.0017751876,
-0.021028135,
0.0048041185,
-0.041746594,
0.0033641607,
0.0006430187,
-0.0239628926,
0.0242093075,
0.043454323,
-0.0021773817,
0.0300785359,
-0.0197850447,
-0.0383253396,
-0.0411172062,
-0.004173914,
0.0127230128,
0.045515731,
-0.0217209738,
-0.0009323733,
-0.0472046137,
-0.0360866301,
-0.0443426222,
0.0340528451,
0.0281126536,
0.0369791612,
-0.0209709331,
0.0682762489,
0.0113833612,
0.0017608991,
0.009367127,
0.0196084548,
0.0003006657,
-0.0781583264,
0.0285376683,
-5.902246032e-33,
0.0294608101,
-0.003151445,
-0.0541699193,
-0.0624059662,
0.0277969632,
0.0495034456,
-0.0003657682,
-0.0498057604,
-0.0662394017,
0.0495418832,
0.0299900509,
0.0606038086,
-0.0146027524,
-0.0028402135,
-0.0811457932,
-0.0138462316,
0.0678398311,
0.0057046032,
-0.0337985605,
0.0387719981,
0.0616783574,
-0.0055642207,
0.0290903095,
-0.0627353713,
0.0531716533,
-0.0240556709,
-0.0424081013,
0.0075929686,
-0.0327940844,
0.011797078,
-0.0076068747,
0.0146416938,
0.0222083796,
-0.0209880676,
-0.0220307037,
0.0037980389,
-0.0604852997,
-0.0300304219,
0.0415472314,
-0.0283378437,
-0.048144646,
0.0088320458,
0.0299444422,
0.0165341925,
0.0099990563,
-0.0107872095,
0.0134912506,
-0.0182492789,
-0.0093457708,
0.0042571733,
-0.0312765166,
0.0132283801,
0.0089898156,
-0.0174648538,
-0.0082110642,
0.0187809449,
0.0468144752,
-0.0001342579,
-0.0629120842,
-0.0054369499,
-0.0392169282,
-0.000800172,
0.026169369,
-0.0446764901,
-0.0519253276,
0.0662041903,
-0.0110543584,
0.0268576536,
-0.0336393975,
-0.0050650327,
0.0142463259,
0.0431610011,
0.0612879917,
0.1180745289,
0.0420723632,
-0.0526876077,
-0.0967138857,
0.0295321513,
0.0576279275,
-0.014556746,
0.0009305386,
-0.0043539149,
-0.0312747434,
0.0130406255,
0.0039090975,
-0.0413931683,
-0.0129046533,
-0.014773597,
-0.0155028841,
0.0717114285,
-0.0311933961,
0.0668019205,
-0.0199006442,
-0.0386652388,
0.029416047,
0.0762504935,
-0.0088326195,
-0.0285781603,
0.019199172,
0.0380373821,
-0.0771096498,
0.0057762801,
0.0723496526,
0.0198418386,
-0.0241994523,
-0.0014564444,
0.1031567752,
0.0004691579,
-0.0205476116,
0.0173125397,
-0.0268571824,
0.0642272234,
-0.0023859062,
-0.0105813006,
0.0164160673,
0.0050538634,
-0.0202271286,
-0.0049959617,
-0.0220221654,
0.0120063014,
-0.0179139301,
0.0111698238,
-0.0341324992,
0.0253749415,
-0.0146008497,
-0.009236292,
-0.0228799395,
-0.055032324,
0.0102174571,
-0.1114829928,
0.0165209211,
0.0136663038,
2.583e-7,
-0.0305945519,
0.0251546614,
0.009954554,
-0.0217384528,
0.0354707204,
0.0507938899,
0.0326679647,
0.0396604575,
-0.0278906636,
-0.1015742049,
-0.0148549769,
0.0471727476,
-0.0041581858,
0.0532411821,
-0.0335701704,
0.0423007309,
-0.056879852,
-0.0206915569,
-0.0359864905,
-0.0380392298,
-0.0187471304,
0.0702919587,
0.0364697687,
-0.0167922135,
0.0509208851,
0.0206571743,
0.039079953,
0.0625650212,
0.0102202073,
-0.0368909016,
0.0800122917,
-0.0267495364,
0.0401563011,
0.0082761766,
-0.0231560711,
0.007071529,
-0.0148005607,
0.0159832016,
0.0204736833,
-0.0116409911,
-0.0004652396,
-0.022708578,
0.0321630351,
-0.0670779198,
0.0826714113,
-0.0274648033,
-0.0330122039,
-0.073139213,
-0.0660405159,
0.00816138,
0.0378656685,
0.0114448639,
-0.011928997,
0.0147108585,
-0.0050944039,
0.0299637578,
0.0108724032,
-0.0175752826,
0.0009142119,
0.0135548301,
-0.0465414263,
-0.0105781229,
0.0078262771,
-0.0265689176,
0.0414956883,
-0.0377602689,
0.03345019,
1.74516325e-34,
0.0342805088,
-0.0057109674,
-0.0188047383,
-0.0662352592,
0.0122630931,
0.0152271148,
-0.0440888666,
-0.0387032107,
0.0321994759,
0.0133610647,
-0.0221066568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12847v1 | NLP-LTU at SemEval-2023 Task 10: The Impact of Data Augmentation and Semi-Supervised Learning Techniques on Text Classification Performance on an Imbalanced Dataset | 2023-04-25T14:19:46 | 2023-04-25T14:19:46 | Sana Sabah Al-Azzawi, György Kovács, Filip Nilsson, Tosin Adewumi, Marcus Liwicki | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a methodology for task 10 of SemEval23, focusing on
detecting and classifying online sexism in social media posts. The task is
tackling a serious issue, as detecting harmful content on social media
platforms is crucial for mitigating the harm of these posts on users. Our
solution for this task is based on an ensemble of fine-tuned transformer-based
models (BERTweet, RoBERTa, and DeBERTa). To alleviate problems related to class
imbalance, and to improve the generalization capability of our model, we also
experiment with data augmentation and semi-supervised learning. In particular,
for data augmentation, we use back-translation, either on all classes, or on
the underrepresented classes only. We analyze the impact of these strategies on
the overall performance of the pipeline through extensive experiments. while
for semi-supervised learning, we found that with a substantial amount of
unlabelled, in-domain data available, semi-supervised learning can enhance the
performance of certain models. Our proposed method (for which the source code
is available on Github attains an F1-score of 0.8613 for sub-taskA, which
ranked us 10th in the competition | [
0.0666146576,
0.0872180015,
-0.0136968838,
-0.0024259619,
-0.0102573661,
0.0317207687,
0.0316437632,
-0.0182331521,
0.0018670748,
-0.0855080187,
-0.0031455376,
-0.0221561696,
-0.0121742915,
0.011168235,
0.0185786691,
-0.0229670089,
0.0078539951,
0.0232730247,
-0.0082584145,
-0.0199957285,
0.0141650997,
0.0031606494,
0.0033806004,
0.0102728186,
0.0065107979,
0.0133330394,
0.0487943143,
0.019051984,
0.0399826691,
0.0010693806,
0.0628723204,
0.0637581423,
-0.010140474,
0.0599926785,
0.0000021058,
-0.0429036766,
-0.0188827366,
0.0115024317,
0.00303955,
-0.0498980694,
0.0336495973,
-0.088352032,
-0.0042606974,
0.0474145785,
-0.0253927242,
-0.0123366732,
0.0379968956,
0.0640676767,
0.0835434347,
0.0875307918,
-0.0169504415,
-0.0051474045,
0.0262976736,
-0.0108603947,
-0.0064222775,
0.0164044332,
0.0615989119,
-0.0345355794,
-0.0241187308,
0.0423914194,
-0.0301888231,
0.0295462869,
0.0238697808,
-0.0093755219,
0.0444640145,
-0.0189807862,
-0.0477042533,
-0.0553570725,
0.00397819,
0.061286442,
-0.029088011,
-0.0311611425,
-0.0027920674,
0.0028776815,
0.0116613042,
-0.0054406226,
-0.0379272066,
0.0337804481,
-0.0054761055,
0.0245408751,
-0.0077436608,
0.0376888774,
0.0543608032,
0.0689319372,
0.011539123,
0.027737096,
0.0025472096,
-0.0524157286,
0.0039132209,
0.0426972583,
-0.0140163675,
0.0058795149,
0.0485514365,
0.007466163,
0.0200525708,
-0.0002834237,
-0.0111860782,
-0.0713273361,
0.0245375969,
-0.073723577,
-0.0027437145,
0.0524772294,
-0.0073082331,
0.0015138307,
-0.0260743033,
0.0129173435,
0.0020298993,
0.0397309735,
-0.0257524513,
-0.0396939181,
-0.031174738,
0.0237404332,
-0.0240038298,
0.0284758005,
0.0045537781,
0.0535117202,
-0.0832375064,
0.0011844614,
-0.0628076866,
-0.0296759214,
0.0138075277,
0.0091090677,
-0.0286893733,
0.028528247,
0.0221299119,
0.0271942001,
0.0190277528,
0.0077483263,
-0.0426211953,
-0.0732990205,
-0.0059844321,
0.0203727055,
-0.0076497551,
-0.0497775562,
0.0239215605,
0.054451365,
0.0168011654,
-0.0552834757,
-0.026050536,
-0.0004170645,
-0.0297090039,
-0.0455734693,
0.0147624146,
-0.0750943795,
0.0230071619,
0.0221622158,
0.0144170541,
-0.034698844,
0.0079231719,
0.0305995662,
-0.0244725794,
0.0712091699,
0.047637511,
-0.0036203959,
0.0522821434,
0.0359229296,
-0.0254839975,
0.0990534201,
0.0164078586,
0.0448077954,
0.0445841961,
-0.0187999848,
0.0192771144,
0.0444322079,
0.055989828,
0.0414562263,
-0.0184980575,
0.0079584336,
-0.0071533998,
-0.0091142179,
0.0208936818,
-0.0025221824,
0.0190897137,
-0.0291208886,
0.0560558811,
0.0068416907,
0.0257515665,
0.0430218764,
0.0464699008,
-0.0069402903,
-0.0381572247,
-0.0063874531,
-0.0590604022,
-0.0133368047,
-0.0490149483,
-0.0527135059,
-0.0017488578,
0.0587866008,
-0.0265393034,
-0.0395888872,
-0.0049614231,
-0.0107086059,
0.0444606319,
-0.0049886871,
0.054019779,
0.0579598807,
0.0070114341,
0.0576440208,
0.0331728533,
-0.0359921902,
0.0092783896,
-0.0470419936,
-0.0041736676,
0.0195183922,
0.0137902703,
-0.0329442434,
-0.0062147598,
-0.0945820212,
0.0268071722,
0.0353652611,
0.0151423654,
0.0301946048,
0.0038900783,
-0.0043118661,
-0.0325379297,
0.011436414,
0.0059985756,
-0.0213802103,
0.0390986502,
0.045387987,
0.0281953849,
-0.0257395953,
-0.0622214302,
0.0447190627,
0.007595147,
-0.0170891862,
0.0274075791,
0.0333110057,
0.020924801,
0.0258304421,
-0.0161256418,
-0.0517563224,
0.0124091702,
-0.0277004372,
-0.0902151689,
-0.0320396498,
-0.029547954,
-0.0253160838,
0.0413718782,
-0.0479692854,
-0.0456735082,
0.0512028746,
-0.0233136285,
0.0133877192,
0.0544559173,
-0.0244816411,
-0.0080836508,
-0.020112304,
0.0006326151,
-0.0325074866,
0.0455652997,
-0.0166750345,
0.0502009317,
-0.0272425693,
0.0075127506,
-0.007528231,
-0.0723632276,
0.0080827093,
-0.0114544248,
-0.0241838917,
-0.0145321423,
-0.0102244411,
0.0048067588,
0.0339530855,
-0.0019867062,
-0.0079941265,
-0.0207982566,
-0.0757648274,
-0.0119246384,
-0.0353659615,
-0.020830648,
0.0166583825,
0.0452532172,
-0.0048979525,
0.013806019,
-0.0161620546,
-0.0499443002,
0.0256022215,
0.0183498133,
0.0095937075,
-0.0565844923,
0.0238525979,
-0.0056204731,
-0.0132037122,
-0.0166292004,
0.0718790591,
0.0225983988,
-0.0540061966,
-0.009592453,
-0.0004843248,
-0.0094142538,
0.0330129974,
-0.0009623481,
-0.0704204962,
-0.0165607594,
0.0379427709,
-0.0082985433,
0.0245112237,
0.0522051118,
0.0432362966,
0.011436969,
0.0448526815,
-0.037363667,
-0.0113545647,
-0.013370852,
0.0057440326,
-0.0029762788,
-0.0336151831,
0.0088839987,
0.048003722,
-0.0207256489,
-0.0300509688,
-0.0387522653,
-0.0073726955,
-0.0333529823,
-0.0331163816,
-0.0024147867,
-0.0306958035,
0.02592404,
-0.0097576715,
-0.0392808691,
-0.0486938879,
0.0625867397,
-0.0114012863,
0.0163358748,
-0.0253568254,
-0.061322093,
-0.0345792547,
0.0269240607,
0.0171961114,
0.0387646258,
-0.0254869573,
0.0036743842,
-0.0052089971,
-0.0185905714,
0.0083980439,
-0.0144563578,
0.0252315141,
0.0120753041,
0.0141792148,
-0.0057693878,
-0.0685311705,
-0.0705571175,
-0.0694898218,
-0.0108619295,
-0.016946476,
-0.0197982918,
-0.007706468,
-0.0545260422,
0.0252728891,
-0.0302126482,
0.0185087975,
-0.0306952223,
-0.0258668941,
0.012210303,
-0.0128404526,
0.0224132575,
-0.0190567132,
0.0139686074,
-0.0117403334,
0.0103355739,
0.0640882403,
-0.0479739569,
0.0044295867,
-0.0181179699,
-0.0031790428,
0.0373663753,
-0.0578091666,
0.0018172598,
-0.0645424351,
0.04276504,
-0.0241447892,
-0.013684839,
0.0990735516,
0.0046325726,
-0.0344029739,
0.0099156499,
0.0172171537,
-0.0257534012,
0.0260690134,
0.0120435106,
-0.0723812208,
-0.0099414578,
-0.0153106302,
0.0131161567,
-0.0659372285,
-0.0343640037,
-0.0023931353,
-0.1223396286,
0.0091378763,
0.0092722969,
-0.0497927368,
-0.0448387377,
-0.0331869163,
0.007623638,
-0.0460062809,
0.0135980714,
-0.0517625213,
-0.0050906879,
0.0174654368,
-0.0018227487,
-0.0304937568,
-0.0459667966,
0.0009822915,
-0.0600579791,
0.0257490873,
0.0040012812,
0.0514510386,
-0.0442900136,
-0.0260643382,
0.0662708953,
-0.005206652,
0.0083270334,
-0.0368595235,
0.0735230744,
-0.0529325642,
-0.0276959743,
-0.0240988992,
0.0463257097,
-0.0146258743,
-0.0072151031,
-0.0176426508,
0.0651830733,
0.0050468133,
-0.0093200915,
-0.0619741827,
0.0038124574,
0.0293079894,
0.0732830986,
0.0096927322,
-0.0542965718,
-0.0013405852,
-0.0723361075,
-0.0126497531,
-0.0210212842,
-0.0224398877,
0.0008154936,
0.0076992433,
-0.047482755,
-0.0261483882,
-0.0335414186,
0.022239279,
0.0021781777,
0.0018858904,
-0.0592430271,
-0.0075440002,
-0.0016511267,
-0.0704902932,
0.0253538676,
-0.0192249455,
0.0480567217,
0.0161250774,
-0.0308642294,
-0.0045927865,
-0.0438212678,
-0.0061675929,
-0.0109145697,
-0.072230652,
-0.0403140485,
0.0279781315,
0.047763072,
0.0169112496,
0.0307021923,
-0.0248358659,
-0.0393077247,
0.0607841425,
0.1041488349,
-0.0584984496,
-0.0252960511,
0.0371467993,
-0.0181905627,
0.0269373376,
0.0381140374,
-0.0024316774,
0.0190965328,
0.0392280221,
-0.0289294142,
-0.0017564363,
0.006382959,
-0.0100335786,
0.0032579908,
0.0582086816,
0.0056382325,
-0.0349970311,
-0.0308080371,
-0.0196665879,
0.0115447519,
-0.0339861289,
-0.0096390499,
0.0060270494,
0.0487800613,
0.0170146264,
-0.0487302952,
0.0292749293,
-0.0508378521,
0.0284135547,
-0.084654808,
0.0333394744,
0.0203645937,
0.0017114826,
-0.0013826949,
0.0265909936,
-0.0009987749,
0.0091961995,
0.0223109853,
0.0057374011,
0.0059781005,
-0.0027165194,
0.0109092826,
0.0752833709,
-0.0228240695,
0.0112015139,
-0.0400251821,
0.015702229,
-0.0496828407,
0.0078302054,
0.0316845216,
-0.0299638081,
0.0468571484,
0.0220450927,
-0.0421003774,
0.018361425,
0.0034388974,
-0.0313900001,
-0.010440629,
0.004100346,
0.0028961156,
-0.013504127,
0.0319357105,
0.0355994366,
-0.0330530368,
0.0426267311,
0.0555974022,
-0.0499871522,
-0.0225895829,
0.0079326406,
0.0353829041,
-0.0057982006,
0.0070730965,
0.0115438811,
-0.0227064043,
-0.0596294664,
0.0088507216,
-0.0705533624,
0.0174843706,
0.0143645545,
-0.0118017402,
0.0470726565,
-0.0060546645,
0.0056317849,
-0.0542826615,
-0.009990138,
0.0387393571,
-0.0354845934,
0.000635136,
-6.40132273e-33,
-0.0014719502,
-0.0291358493,
-0.0448542386,
-0.0062512364,
-0.0137892663,
-0.0101434207,
0.0373378396,
-0.0180087816,
-0.0044503603,
0.0224603321,
0.0197554175,
0.0413460098,
-0.006510979,
0.0473193936,
-0.008228926,
-0.0136618456,
0.0641104653,
0.0130522577,
-0.0353447869,
-0.0049624825,
0.0072546187,
0.0521614701,
0.0559794158,
-0.083620958,
0.0478741862,
-0.0030233699,
-0.0149637945,
-0.0067015756,
0.0140074445,
0.0461230315,
0.0082238624,
0.0939441398,
0.0507466234,
-0.0587604269,
0.0330134928,
0.0333630964,
-0.0664777011,
-0.0040317574,
-0.0285517424,
0.0625868216,
0.0284759961,
-0.0069955704,
0.0623372793,
0.0120906867,
-0.0116800871,
-0.0674669445,
0.052386649,
-0.0139424894,
0.0490985662,
-0.0507226326,
-0.0524791032,
0.0115998089,
-0.0460780561,
-0.0169385932,
-0.0107253697,
0.0666201487,
0.0111891273,
0.0553967357,
-0.0965934917,
0.0048061591,
0.0018533879,
-0.0235294513,
0.0285800416,
-0.0350309201,
-0.0093186228,
0.0378292985,
0.0066631283,
0.046453353,
-0.0345070139,
-0.0045095067,
0.0119070793,
0.0051247748,
0.0481007285,
0.0354265086,
0.0611670204,
-0.0530931912,
-0.0946947187,
0.0103232339,
0.0349169001,
0.0044168807,
-0.0027326711,
-0.0118620917,
-0.0354083367,
-0.0322605222,
-0.0059162267,
-0.0749749243,
-0.0212179348,
-0.0189134441,
-0.0135554485,
0.0083259679,
-0.0709470585,
0.0275401529,
-0.0098269116,
-0.0807910413,
-0.035344407,
0.0227099285,
-0.0221680496,
-0.0193953849,
0.0359512791,
0.011137954,
-0.0201843176,
-0.0073943161,
0.0372011326,
0.0231805369,
0.0201894343,
-0.0101505015,
0.0881609768,
0.052668374,
-0.0653442144,
-0.0057269745,
-0.031673234,
0.0525921248,
-0.0185876209,
0.1134317741,
-0.0054095625,
0.0469989143,
-0.0158206597,
0.0285039563,
0.0345905796,
0.0181349143,
-0.0076257405,
0.0296449941,
0.0136188203,
0.0046883854,
-0.0122847781,
-0.0330699012,
0.0079726558,
0.0142314648,
0.0262764245,
-0.0921683237,
0.0123066604,
-0.0500387847,
2.868e-7,
0.0485536829,
0.0454101227,
-0.0024446624,
-0.0213412028,
0.0228516385,
0.0298870597,
0.0171765201,
0.0512800626,
0.0378482863,
-0.0122440914,
-0.0279695019,
0.0498758666,
0.0163194034,
0.0244125575,
-0.0460505858,
-0.023003716,
-0.0684234798,
0.0050173923,
-0.0208459757,
0.0187050924,
0.0224390961,
0.1019920409,
0.0370007493,
-0.0473120846,
0.0181337111,
-0.0198425297,
0.0592570901,
-0.0151906852,
-0.0124611547,
0.0041653276,
0.0394767858,
0.0469167382,
0.0356540233,
0.0128055252,
-0.0293266363,
0.0278276708,
0.0279443264,
0.0176091623,
-0.0091257906,
0.0171984434,
-0.0008898507,
-0.0028262995,
0.0045081466,
-0.0515568815,
0.0689039603,
-0.059727449,
-0.0633709952,
-0.0497795306,
-0.0326416939,
0.0025501272,
0.0738753155,
-0.0280851126,
0.0093675805,
0.0283330828,
0.0549072921,
0.0121198185,
-0.0425964706,
-0.0663745701,
-0.0185641218,
-0.0277355965,
-0.0210286286,
-0.0325549096,
-0.005749458,
0.0028556958,
0.0380895697,
-0.0113488827,
0.0262907352,
2.552772638e-34,
0.0247496404,
0.0064933039,
0.0056880671,
-0.0533701256,
-0.0043451549,
0.0177582577,
0.0078614801,
-0.0219130833,
0.0008398863,
0.0010741157,
0.0102439662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12836v1 | Lessons Learned from a Citizen Science Project for Natural Language Processing | 2023-04-25T14:08:53 | 2023-04-25T14:08:53 | Jan-Christoph Klie, Ji-Ung Lee, Kevin Stowe, Gözde Gül Şahin, Nafise Sadat Moosavi, Luke Bates, Dominic Petrak, Richard Eckart de Castilho, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems use annotated corpora for
training and evaluation. However, labeled data is often costly to obtain and
scaling annotation projects is difficult, which is why annotation tasks are
often outsourced to paid crowdworkers. Citizen Science is an alternative to
crowdsourcing that is relatively unexplored in the context of NLP. To
investigate whether and how well Citizen Science can be applied in this
setting, we conduct an exploratory study into engaging different groups of
volunteers in Citizen Science for NLP by re-annotating parts of a pre-existing
crowdsourced dataset. Our results show that this can yield high-quality
annotations and attract motivated volunteers, but also requires considering
factors such as scalability, participation over time, and legal and ethical
issues. We summarize lessons learned in the form of guidelines and provide our
code and data to aid future work on Citizen Science. | [
0.0843081325,
0.0755922571,
-0.0066735321,
0.0395549163,
-0.0248610042,
-0.0014042414,
0.0023189059,
-0.0281261094,
0.0240463801,
-0.0549869426,
0.0253170598,
0.025778221,
-0.0034141336,
-0.0030476651,
-0.0094250832,
-0.0471139625,
0.0012242584,
-0.0045292294,
0.0520021766,
0.0139940884,
0.0591661371,
0.0027585507,
-0.0144577408,
0.0551254787,
-0.0301991682,
0.0266797822,
0.0161808282,
-0.0144298906,
0.0150019303,
-0.0386953317,
0.0168430377,
0.0448968187,
-0.0039439457,
0.0585733689,
0.000001545,
-0.0717148706,
-0.0023265104,
0.0422998331,
-0.0516711213,
0.0015223867,
0.040601477,
0.0126468046,
-0.013167873,
0.0091574611,
-0.035856925,
0.0035618672,
0.0674129575,
-0.0222543161,
0.0949576721,
0.0448396206,
0.0169404447,
-0.0058353827,
-0.0171408504,
0.0019125533,
0.0077918065,
0.0423120894,
0.0088035483,
-0.0180803593,
0.0106705511,
0.0104957819,
0.0412778333,
0.0314934514,
-0.024667725,
-0.022623321,
0.0532484464,
0.0146132382,
-0.0851207152,
-0.0243921485,
-0.02569592,
0.0438667163,
0.0577533506,
-0.0090507939,
0.0108005302,
-0.0211272202,
0.0113050584,
0.0101205362,
-0.0208415613,
0.0235605463,
-0.0068283379,
0.015608768,
0.0027782079,
0.02490866,
-0.009083041,
0.0287877452,
0.060177207,
0.0429304019,
-0.037652038,
-0.0147447726,
0.003260589,
0.0488950498,
0.0197274163,
-0.0193857718,
0.0432107598,
-0.0384929329,
0.0135533856,
0.0190179758,
-0.017265033,
-0.0578897372,
0.052444607,
-0.0344290845,
0.0121048689,
-0.0301607065,
-0.0171638262,
0.0775124654,
0.0191498362,
-0.0606195852,
0.03686722,
0.0585944876,
0.0008167129,
-0.0083330413,
-0.0951020569,
0.0081590777,
-0.0416995287,
0.0086073466,
-0.0192323104,
0.0416413471,
0.0052151624,
-0.033577919,
-0.0254355986,
0.0238216296,
0.0284397081,
0.0328646936,
-0.0044645569,
0.0072281589,
-0.0483838171,
0.0397283845,
-0.0447303429,
0.0177480131,
-0.0098773222,
-0.076014787,
0.00480456,
-0.0183047224,
0.0318656601,
-0.0124874571,
0.0284474511,
0.0260683671,
0.0228694901,
-0.0254725534,
-0.0568511672,
-0.0238983762,
0.0279409606,
0.0064851944,
0.0141254002,
-0.0442594513,
0.0126275858,
-0.008121945,
0.0178764593,
-0.0145763485,
0.0179260802,
0.0327723883,
-0.0350860655,
0.1344099641,
-0.0807690844,
-0.0341235213,
0.0089530768,
-0.024980966,
0.0171855893,
0.0666399151,
0.0629766062,
-0.0137879495,
0.0614630207,
-0.0030974646,
0.0310781524,
0.0175714623,
-0.0139513519,
-0.021964984,
0.0385417528,
0.0048693395,
-0.0505052321,
0.0418752693,
-0.007444927,
0.0467621945,
0.0083972113,
0.0221015438,
0.0169348493,
0.0740516111,
-0.0426030047,
-0.0297908951,
-0.024885904,
0.0428826287,
0.0072930641,
-0.0736034587,
-0.0163707994,
0.0090315174,
-0.0316050947,
0.0002498451,
-0.0126257865,
0.019952191,
0.0246208012,
-0.0324098095,
-0.0676508918,
0.0062428433,
0.0515631288,
-0.0063815112,
0.0226606689,
0.0197110549,
0.0031675107,
-0.0290341936,
0.0013327114,
-0.068609044,
0.0283912625,
-0.020368753,
-0.027945457,
0.0731438622,
0.0268985648,
-0.0480801985,
0.018519992,
-0.0623943582,
0.0115528489,
0.035963662,
0.0099831671,
-0.0335579403,
-0.0534392484,
-0.0219338629,
-0.0368148349,
0.0386154801,
-0.004729684,
-0.002368158,
0.0097223492,
-0.016990656,
0.0032460003,
-0.039503403,
-0.0536685288,
0.0595470555,
0.0316115506,
-0.0180946868,
-0.0238026809,
0.0015660308,
0.0289157089,
0.0625177696,
-0.0010900112,
0.0305560119,
0.0099657448,
-0.0115061384,
-0.029467212,
0.0226516798,
0.0657143816,
-0.0198183209,
0.0395555422,
-0.101143457,
-0.0337426439,
0.0494220331,
-0.0243846644,
0.0129268812,
-0.0015898735,
-0.0487631969,
-0.0000807803,
-0.022718871,
-0.0579229258,
0.0032680633,
-0.0209579729,
-0.0393697135,
0.0199997202,
0.0082726525,
0.0016958177,
-0.0117967576,
-0.0524044782,
0.0273550134,
-0.0134763513,
-0.0244008508,
-0.0101632895,
0.0305012017,
0.0337830819,
0.0455902442,
0.0072706807,
-0.0819664821,
0.0315970033,
-0.0419288836,
-0.0186362807,
-0.0035955445,
0.0453670137,
-0.0162789691,
-0.0125548365,
0.0009682757,
-0.0082827341,
0.0082916971,
-0.0236323941,
-0.0115507059,
0.0242180787,
0.0526297539,
0.0023986304,
0.0290121939,
-0.0274058767,
0.0098451283,
-0.011036979,
0.0020749778,
0.0881027207,
-0.0709898919,
-0.0343884975,
-0.0345795676,
0.0128455302,
0.0109989336,
0.0350292511,
-0.0186020322,
0.0202330388,
0.0265283603,
-0.0370544679,
0.0059983158,
0.0008913981,
0.0069744331,
0.0202224664,
0.0246053077,
-0.0204730574,
-0.0093817757,
0.0211841185,
0.0161921829,
-0.0225450229,
0.0032224082,
0.0500911772,
0.0326794386,
-0.0285837147,
-0.0239144675,
-0.0302395411,
0.0282344222,
-0.056288939,
-0.0108103501,
-0.0535298884,
-0.0225934833,
-0.0408935808,
0.0223660432,
-0.0107199531,
0.0047335271,
0.0727478862,
-0.0089718793,
-0.0129816448,
-0.067640841,
-0.0009627184,
-0.0243059937,
0.0657854676,
0.0081211785,
0.0121922195,
0.0370173343,
-0.0036712836,
0.0436070114,
0.0515039936,
0.047752399,
-0.0372123122,
-0.0324016325,
-0.040130835,
0.0074896589,
-0.0105108088,
-0.0132291466,
-0.0071931281,
-0.0556884892,
-0.0979906693,
0.0137709035,
0.0810878947,
0.0072604436,
0.0091229202,
-0.0224602912,
0.0295967329,
0.0355580002,
0.0634013787,
-0.0250798501,
0.0073952167,
0.0112942448,
-0.0257532168,
0.0643297881,
-0.0011186536,
0.0289487336,
-0.0674747378,
0.0335587636,
0.0472560897,
-0.0196074471,
-0.0084339809,
-0.0032305799,
0.0415119901,
-0.0390201882,
0.0165731721,
-0.0126603022,
0.0236829389,
-0.0409948267,
-0.0039548753,
0.0377835743,
0.0294098854,
-0.0136705618,
0.0085673761,
0.0015099412,
-0.0051107681,
0.0545610152,
-0.0074980874,
-0.0903940424,
-0.0476469733,
0.0082688909,
0.040560782,
-0.0457641855,
-0.0464055315,
-0.0217135362,
-0.1266017258,
0.0542297736,
-0.0186839923,
-0.0504225008,
0.0420879982,
-0.10981296,
0.0056060408,
-0.0588631518,
-0.0472452343,
-0.0596501864,
-0.0062755602,
0.0274459738,
0.0488365367,
-0.0312690139,
-0.0583280921,
-0.0034627295,
-0.0420310646,
0.1146420985,
0.0921268836,
0.0222562198,
-0.0267544035,
-0.0619919337,
0.0066163498,
-0.0084672868,
0.0038505171,
-0.0057178126,
0.0582699589,
-0.0120465429,
-0.0175403953,
-0.0020122218,
0.0528787412,
-0.0594851784,
0.0013257356,
0.0108061451,
0.0574356355,
0.0390646309,
0.0208199006,
-0.01380115,
-0.0303371437,
0.0371894538,
0.072679542,
0.0091556981,
-0.0246685836,
0.0131561505,
-0.0461684354,
-0.0125189237,
-0.0713194534,
-0.0700409114,
0.0310385115,
-0.0094652409,
-0.0507583953,
-0.0628321096,
-0.0456936248,
0.0735829026,
0.005762626,
0.0126025239,
0.0035647657,
0.0490837283,
0.0375577137,
-0.0422612764,
0.069789961,
-0.0397417471,
0.0298286695,
-0.0314622968,
-0.0783179179,
-0.0309529379,
0.0232295338,
-0.0428305455,
0.0370269865,
-0.0826447904,
-0.0293664541,
0.0500524305,
0.0298092086,
0.0149530834,
0.0154097583,
-0.0133870076,
-0.0493349507,
-0.0157982968,
0.0849859342,
-0.0342837572,
-0.0394859686,
0.0038199166,
0.014801167,
0.0018000541,
-0.016494872,
-0.0050037168,
-0.0166844986,
-0.0040809647,
0.0165341198,
-0.0443889759,
-0.0037716893,
0.0346969068,
0.0959507972,
0.0864774063,
-0.048785422,
0.001086168,
-0.0420208201,
-0.0282403752,
0.0262181107,
-0.0510350317,
-0.0386917293,
-0.0118903052,
-0.0155138234,
-0.0328902565,
-0.0124873035,
0.0638069808,
-0.0361938737,
0.0129082995,
-0.0268095881,
0.0536448136,
0.0931372792,
0.0209555384,
-0.0258629192,
-0.0062020938,
0.0097434167,
0.0105694132,
-0.0045390981,
0.0290944092,
0.0206191353,
-0.0390902273,
0.0048677223,
-0.0228442438,
0.0134915989,
0.0361369215,
-0.0284954775,
-0.0320195965,
-0.0267253388,
0.0547291301,
-0.0170602743,
0.0119965607,
0.0299256165,
-0.0327799805,
-0.0162024982,
0.0144970156,
0.0086048795,
0.005508834,
-0.0384133309,
0.0104410676,
-0.0003123984,
-0.0466939881,
-0.0099667143,
0.0457088053,
-0.040550638,
0.0409300923,
-0.0275887884,
-0.0197660942,
-0.0477032289,
-0.0031618963,
-0.071878694,
-0.0090129683,
-0.0005792115,
0.0046106158,
-0.0495516695,
-0.0051770438,
-0.0422284752,
0.0356467143,
0.0213114191,
0.0297918636,
0.0650365278,
-0.0066557229,
-0.0336314254,
-0.0098545011,
-0.0298202895,
0.0095203314,
-0.0067498838,
-0.0235089213,
0.0034254002,
-5.668281147e-33,
-0.0179396626,
-0.0540486574,
-0.0022584174,
-0.0136672668,
0.0141187012,
0.0067877476,
-0.0108980797,
0.0319232866,
0.0282688811,
0.0215438884,
0.0001428894,
-0.0328984372,
0.0215153024,
-0.013466198,
0.0656040832,
-0.0206564236,
0.0471290089,
-0.0058470545,
-0.0168749653,
-0.0407934785,
0.0175689664,
-0.005491639,
0.0500828885,
-0.0886750445,
0.0983740613,
0.0289957765,
-0.0625513047,
0.0330044329,
0.0091521144,
0.0344526134,
0.0040639215,
0.057771422,
0.0085631162,
-0.0545281768,
-0.0055138851,
-0.0002347505,
-0.052206777,
0.0225173663,
0.0101981629,
0.0158600472,
-0.0507731959,
-0.0033713456,
0.0395672284,
-0.0117142936,
-0.0122839473,
0.0547510162,
0.0593685918,
-0.027299311,
0.0285667796,
-0.0000972775,
-0.0382343791,
0.0117341792,
-0.0550306812,
-0.0033916747,
0.0319452696,
0.0061207828,
-0.0059228116,
0.0477160029,
-0.0479230061,
0.0201227088,
0.0054231058,
-0.0146530755,
0.0478440449,
-0.002607276,
0.0017577643,
0.053848397,
-0.0150412899,
0.0139282523,
-0.0238052215,
-0.0155861443,
-0.0009547261,
0.0214777049,
0.0484496839,
0.1130125597,
0.0492159426,
-0.0093513168,
0.0247950684,
0.0564045161,
0.0292856004,
-0.0207429267,
-0.0516800098,
0.0049173818,
-0.0526807718,
-0.0101195853,
-0.0374695174,
-0.055472251,
-0.0053702751,
0.0094584851,
-0.019642625,
-0.0027636269,
-0.0672319457,
0.0465324521,
-0.0327525735,
-0.018196268,
-0.0231798328,
-0.0138902385,
0.028767189,
0.0328204781,
0.0003542336,
-0.0190103408,
-0.0776557773,
0.0349262618,
-0.0233264398,
0.0311710965,
0.0498314202,
-0.0195589047,
0.0563789047,
-0.0020271558,
-0.0533059724,
0.0164825879,
-0.0172834583,
0.0341305286,
-0.0006488904,
-0.0230735689,
0.0175727569,
0.0152379321,
-0.0091668973,
-0.0011643479,
0.0226158705,
0.0133340666,
0.0052490584,
0.0072977603,
-0.028823901,
-0.0226093624,
-0.007945531,
0.0056477543,
0.0053060646,
-0.0040273652,
0.019629458,
-0.0187230092,
-0.0043209004,
-0.044674404,
2.228e-7,
0.0447457284,
0.0563066043,
0.0162975341,
-0.0436646864,
-0.0173398349,
0.0322477072,
-0.0011472908,
0.0426753052,
-0.0361210629,
-0.0515391827,
-0.0207043104,
-0.0257024728,
0.0178976152,
0.0552163273,
-0.1052296385,
-0.040074937,
-0.025477441,
0.0297570862,
-0.0402241163,
0.0268712509,
0.031725578,
0.0117405849,
0.0423285924,
-0.006973498,
-0.0164409447,
-0.0260309707,
-0.0039583244,
-0.0513039343,
-0.013973603,
0.0006789236,
0.0167936347,
0.0366480537,
0.0079544075,
0.0056194668,
-0.0316504501,
-0.0426433794,
0.0057095606,
0.003389159,
0.0026882123,
-0.007170395,
-0.0200632773,
-0.0136293359,
0.008165828,
0.0369383991,
0.0196666047,
0.0018722182,
-0.0272714458,
-0.0284893811,
0.0090838242,
-0.0250307806,
0.004804757,
-0.0102158887,
-0.0088009974,
-0.018294679,
0.0096633183,
-0.0327997394,
-0.0514901169,
-0.0579011701,
-0.0215730108,
-0.0311010312,
-0.0057279537,
-0.0416961759,
0.0233754888,
0.016639147,
-0.0076829856,
-0.0296465419,
0.0164504927,
1.214808668e-34,
0.0078002452,
0.0026450292,
0.0228117015,
0.0052886237,
0.0457308255,
0.0217524786,
0.0008374804,
-0.0368326567,
-0.0032574655,
0.0161869526,
0.0055913022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12833v1 | A New Information Theory of Certainty for Machine Learning | 2023-04-25T14:03:57 | 2023-04-25T14:03:57 | Arthur Jun Zhang | cs.IT | cs.IT, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, math.IT | Claude Shannon coined entropy to quantify the uncertainty of a random
distribution for communication coding theory. We observe that the uncertainty
nature of entropy also limits its direct usage in mathematical modeling.
Therefore we propose a new concept troenpy,as the canonical dual of entropy, to
quantify the certainty of the underlying distribution. We demonstrate two
applications in machine learning. The first is for the classical document
classification, we develop a troenpy based weighting scheme to leverage the
document class label. The second is a self-troenpy weighting scheme for
sequential data and show that it can be easily included in neural network based
language models and achieve dramatic perplexity reduction. We also define
quantum troenpy as the dual of the Von Neumann entropy to quantify the
certainty of quantum systems. | [
0.0004012272,
0.0836991742,
0.0080885431,
0.0154076116,
-0.0489889979,
0.0055826614,
-0.0545770489,
0.0148940645,
-0.0514694005,
-0.0298849586,
0.0264383834,
-0.0822217017,
-0.0171306562,
-0.0380352251,
0.0155815706,
-0.0576007403,
0.0073618595,
-0.0051558353,
-0.0237877835,
-0.052416414,
-0.0677732304,
-0.085629724,
-0.000683621,
-0.0103700059,
0.0380591527,
-0.0055150543,
-0.0057218983,
0.0105961505,
-0.028855158,
-0.0082687614,
-0.0426067039,
0.0864847824,
-0.0292375311,
0.0096254256,
0.0000016609,
-0.0130911162,
-0.0021546215,
0.0036306267,
-0.0223524533,
0.0022655095,
-0.0226987246,
0.0045935158,
-0.027832849,
0.0004507144,
-0.0191215705,
-0.0192864221,
0.0966935381,
0.0213818643,
-0.0343599953,
0.0325511321,
-0.0095747672,
-0.0606982708,
0.0426470861,
-0.0291271657,
0.0960003212,
-0.018189922,
0.0111600654,
-0.0144181708,
-0.0299991518,
-0.0142713282,
-0.0290933605,
0.0285992492,
0.0476383381,
0.021744512,
0.0627427772,
0.0123399533,
0.0353463851,
0.0098411385,
-0.0310432725,
0.041277796,
-0.0095162522,
-0.0167697147,
-0.0365719758,
0.0164896995,
-0.0102127139,
-0.0174382273,
-0.007051636,
0.0215250794,
0.0095233228,
0.0516382754,
-0.0173348933,
0.038444709,
0.056460049,
0.0079286629,
-0.0188602451,
0.0689114109,
0.0138206584,
-0.0039726603,
-0.0122845341,
0.0304248724,
-0.0223695617,
0.0051536257,
-0.0208685603,
0.0124704409,
0.0547386594,
0.0130570326,
-0.0127111198,
-0.0052707386,
0.0236684941,
-0.0772156417,
-0.0235378016,
-0.0031895728,
0.0182384495,
0.0231939368,
0.040235538,
0.0073401146,
-0.0001406539,
0.026451923,
-0.0525542758,
0.0191574097,
-0.0323373117,
-0.0071185213,
-0.0003306824,
0.0749963373,
0.0708611757,
-0.0343747735,
-0.0859901533,
0.0422194898,
-0.0323627144,
0.0073000034,
-0.0183474962,
0.0076390915,
-0.0101674711,
0.0121026393,
-0.0063406695,
-0.0125845494,
0.0074875546,
0.0121644782,
-0.0445857681,
-0.0328616649,
-0.0074575129,
0.0288053155,
-0.0244392026,
-0.0030883001,
-0.0129702492,
0.049573496,
0.0210407525,
-0.0139111811,
0.0285882931,
0.0253067426,
-0.0353458449,
-0.0182838887,
-0.0093744835,
-0.0516596399,
-0.0400983877,
-0.0027614229,
0.0308858622,
-0.0504525229,
-0.0060398108,
-0.0275860541,
-0.0147519875,
0.1090680435,
0.0076688724,
0.0006088149,
0.0161779504,
0.011018062,
0.0537656359,
0.0540691242,
0.0317611434,
-0.015140878,
0.0710705221,
-0.0261513535,
0.0146467537,
-0.0104758078,
0.0254731048,
-0.0384840593,
-0.0516287014,
-0.0366653018,
-0.0279766414,
0.0018337739,
-0.0384670831,
0.1032518595,
-0.0091527198,
-0.0247452892,
0.0460678525,
0.0063324096,
0.020694619,
0.0035243814,
-0.0060043205,
-0.0100241629,
0.0332761481,
0.0775540546,
-0.0272525456,
0.0333229601,
-0.0527423136,
0.0350633524,
0.0743347555,
-0.0668230206,
-0.0411277264,
-0.0771501064,
-0.0270976443,
-0.0108272554,
0.0464187898,
-0.0188096575,
0.0889694467,
-0.0406510942,
0.0008713235,
-0.0095145106,
-0.0125371655,
-0.0296308231,
0.0196410622,
-0.0313826427,
0.009008958,
0.0415070951,
-0.0043630423,
-0.0688253492,
0.0688193366,
0.0347522087,
-0.0711614266,
-0.0180072933,
0.0548844747,
-0.0059785414,
0.0333554111,
-0.034113422,
-0.0088278893,
0.0393234082,
0.0142009556,
0.0006465442,
-0.0290550012,
-0.0028681199,
0.0043406948,
0.0052810572,
-0.0412322544,
0.0125007369,
0.0644368529,
-0.0588504001,
0.0622684062,
0.0028753367,
0.0585818999,
0.0263941363,
-0.0526972748,
0.0596165545,
0.0580069423,
-0.0312728323,
-0.0321896337,
-0.0456398688,
-0.0009431319,
0.0210195053,
0.051474575,
-0.0226423126,
0.0414400883,
0.0168207046,
-0.0168145765,
-0.0464939289,
0.0639995262,
-0.0220226422,
0.0196311567,
-0.0603891723,
-0.0101660201,
-0.0213839151,
0.0388949811,
-0.0644493774,
0.0490606688,
0.0038548028,
0.0802447796,
-0.0512736551,
-0.0373006761,
0.0310361236,
-0.0424126014,
-0.0499616489,
-0.0019773161,
-0.0052039633,
0.0466467515,
0.0571164526,
-0.0297608022,
0.0707048848,
-0.0441213138,
-0.0048391866,
-0.0144909918,
-0.0365784094,
0.0151804518,
-0.0104217306,
0.0016029066,
0.0366072953,
-0.0447794311,
-0.034825094,
-0.0055134101,
-0.0220978539,
-0.0156348012,
0.0265433416,
0.0144489687,
-0.0101928487,
0.018255692,
-0.0556045435,
-0.0007694158,
0.0447173528,
0.0140887033,
0.0052975067,
-0.0508923121,
0.054725796,
-0.0192126203,
0.0051567648,
0.0021840225,
-0.0073097255,
-0.0145847974,
-0.0438733771,
-0.0143331178,
0.0096771959,
0.046533335,
0.0114192488,
0.0573960356,
0.0324483551,
0.0354662277,
-0.0157564413,
-0.0808024034,
0.0076966062,
0.0092427954,
-0.0367542468,
-0.0007097273,
0.0001093779,
0.0150772138,
-0.0458528921,
-0.0334350467,
-0.0270560328,
0.0023859462,
-0.0178977624,
-0.0350675695,
0.0006853334,
0.011741587,
0.0339811742,
0.0030266326,
-0.0380710252,
0.0897733271,
-0.0012127546,
0.0334128663,
-0.0439029261,
-0.0365807153,
-0.0091364337,
0.053215567,
0.0539202206,
0.0151709011,
0.0235456228,
-0.0082223956,
-0.0194728523,
-0.0473963469,
0.0582528524,
-0.02857453,
-0.007421616,
-0.0177592579,
0.0267434996,
0.0007811528,
-0.0351090804,
0.010139768,
-0.0156410765,
0.0047733374,
-0.0113245947,
0.014422846,
-0.0450360961,
0.0266074948,
0.0198488683,
0.0003697835,
0.0242430419,
-0.0157433525,
-0.0158690363,
0.012110997,
0.0230626427,
0.001679293,
-0.0122926133,
0.0652190149,
-0.0224625934,
-0.0168856326,
0.0128900968,
0.0403122492,
0.0702377707,
-0.0236383285,
-0.0106992573,
0.0471769944,
-0.0030687458,
-0.0294262562,
0.0348697156,
-0.0065602432,
0.0366842039,
0.0212109219,
0.1057710201,
0.005845868,
-0.0470791385,
0.002680022,
-0.0001431842,
0.0202341732,
0.008568597,
0.0014520353,
-0.0704460889,
-0.0089879837,
-0.0372486189,
0.0237596128,
-0.035299845,
-0.028525142,
0.0341804586,
-0.0082618641,
-0.0141688893,
0.0098276837,
-0.011645779,
-0.0615965091,
-0.0484117009,
-0.0171018075,
-0.0314994678,
-0.0071975701,
-0.0350050516,
-0.0084905662,
0.0240968168,
0.033693511,
-0.0378644839,
-0.0347596519,
-0.0340222269,
-0.000852577,
0.0219377242,
0.0445585176,
0.0247890111,
-0.0785248205,
-0.0393463746,
-0.0522582829,
-0.0764757693,
-0.0489184149,
0.0114788432,
0.0522971116,
0.0424554795,
-0.0293246843,
-0.0248753447,
-0.001454325,
0.0057120663,
0.0097582452,
-0.0403754823,
0.0138541562,
-0.0302615631,
-0.0302079432,
0.0005912071,
-0.0217265561,
0.0455938689,
0.0656682998,
-0.0174368527,
-0.0223095249,
-0.0616280921,
-0.0421735682,
0.0580951758,
0.0046350043,
0.0137837995,
-0.0112052076,
0.0009583964,
-0.1203371212,
-0.0828331113,
0.0350820571,
-0.0734561458,
0.0221439395,
-0.0126964916,
0.0113040553,
0.0339088365,
-0.0239454247,
-0.0572108962,
-0.0632202774,
0.0518606082,
0.0166790411,
-0.0601668507,
0.0111933835,
0.0339757726,
-0.0103415707,
-0.0199968424,
0.0104454402,
-0.0411103889,
-0.0723033026,
0.0143063553,
-0.0130868014,
0.0292186737,
-0.022084007,
-0.0004530688,
-0.0795092285,
0.0589592531,
0.0551762767,
-0.0098527186,
0.0135525409,
0.0454877242,
-0.0381616279,
-0.000384223,
0.034318015,
-0.0222444572,
0.0266027618,
-0.0350602232,
0.0069532096,
-0.0656851679,
-0.0620769076,
-0.0078278817,
0.0409216918,
0.0395281874,
0.0154774208,
-0.001748777,
0.0339356363,
0.0131545821,
0.0075553879,
0.0060903225,
-0.0245077442,
-0.0034236731,
0.0718745217,
0.0196391791,
-0.0178791843,
0.025151629,
0.0599100329,
0.0088455947,
0.0326068625,
-0.0090344409,
-0.0173936523,
0.0314016491,
0.008739775,
-0.0022009115,
0.0161531307,
0.0362202637,
0.0384443216,
0.0386943594,
0.0313702971,
-0.02513358,
0.0552684963,
0.0096507417,
-0.0352149382,
-0.0130839022,
-0.1339171529,
-0.0494192913,
-0.0040215021,
0.0201519132,
0.0349102542,
0.0654530302,
-0.0130465459,
-0.0741329938,
-0.0084599936,
-0.0212062206,
0.0168855544,
0.0431322232,
0.0136493277,
0.039772179,
0.0281663872,
-0.0128243165,
0.042519711,
0.0527100973,
0.0121772941,
0.0293945633,
-0.0485146232,
-0.0315764993,
-0.0214578472,
0.01977304,
0.0068181576,
0.0403119177,
-0.0144044925,
0.0410081819,
-0.0225156229,
-0.0453183018,
0.0425932482,
0.0406374075,
0.0643721521,
-0.0436241478,
0.0108099142,
0.0627593175,
-0.0030429882,
0.0062528928,
-0.0483452529,
-0.0073879617,
0.0310049411,
0.0074916445,
-0.031377662,
-6.117889369e-33,
-0.0109323896,
-0.0324536115,
-0.0439579822,
0.0615804642,
0.0411927104,
-0.0148031283,
0.0131046744,
0.0026971127,
-0.0307993703,
0.0147929667,
0.01512291,
0.0236160252,
0.0132911699,
0.015358082,
0.0135829663,
-0.0152810561,
0.0109050097,
-0.0237224586,
0.0306830313,
0.0183860771,
0.0168512575,
-0.0294479411,
0.0430513434,
-0.0114363302,
0.0351705663,
0.0293570962,
0.0032407194,
0.0550235026,
0.0009275484,
-0.0120054167,
-0.0297373887,
0.0085624093,
-0.0244896058,
-0.0119241513,
0.0180223119,
-0.0149002057,
-0.0177820791,
-0.0554594584,
-0.0185071975,
0.0392309092,
0.0054639671,
-0.0157969967,
0.0430937037,
-0.0135229696,
-0.0629417375,
-0.0027990753,
0.023014795,
-0.0040058973,
-0.0319712684,
-0.068972595,
0.0311463159,
0.0283535048,
-0.0079894625,
-0.0258866847,
0.0490694568,
-0.0296057221,
-0.0384072363,
-0.0655599535,
-0.0494420975,
0.0338589437,
-0.0060644927,
0.0220784079,
-0.0054743681,
0.044146508,
0.0061404496,
0.0323203281,
0.0859847441,
-0.0342811607,
-0.0386356041,
0.0141989542,
-0.0040623024,
-0.0020723587,
0.0448416695,
0.0352695994,
0.1021833867,
0.0010787989,
-0.0981673896,
0.0281938761,
0.0458363444,
-0.0044385442,
0.0280191861,
0.0124009838,
-0.0701608211,
-0.0628916696,
-0.0034486565,
-0.0635084733,
-0.000895243,
-0.0017255022,
-0.0686178803,
-0.0112725729,
-0.0074181962,
0.0197800659,
0.0123231579,
-0.062049862,
-0.0403621905,
0.0257036146,
0.0334485956,
0.0431355201,
0.0198302716,
-0.0263982639,
0.0148074916,
0.0014368556,
-0.0047739241,
0.0300769713,
-0.0107803391,
0.0344783328,
0.0418165997,
0.0453093871,
-0.0172137059,
-0.0181016605,
0.014658181,
-0.0483566299,
0.0405197628,
0.0014959504,
0.0090212878,
-0.0072194142,
0.0086173108,
0.0310604647,
-0.0023624566,
0.0454258174,
-0.0068387198,
0.038807109,
0.0060082609,
0.0387641788,
0.0069885408,
-0.0398559682,
-0.0413359068,
-0.0171913523,
0.0509184711,
-0.050118681,
-0.0238933247,
-0.0034757068,
2.637e-7,
0.0586917922,
0.0006471853,
0.0072093736,
0.0149760107,
0.0258411039,
0.0270650145,
-0.0165713932,
-0.0021354854,
-0.0267542247,
-0.0213765204,
0.012730672,
-0.0001552216,
-0.0081906775,
-0.0011751456,
-0.0380081087,
-0.0688080564,
-0.0103949513,
0.0142431185,
0.0422256626,
0.0540183596,
0.0295263734,
0.0890604034,
0.0351218395,
0.0005489416,
0.0356915183,
-0.0255002622,
0.0269671511,
0.0002706305,
0.0629441887,
0.0284173284,
0.0573790111,
-0.0378569849,
0.0199779645,
0.0433260798,
0.0028209125,
-0.0013335482,
0.0118392482,
-0.0028544783,
0.0042360672,
0.0071384916,
-0.0495922454,
-0.0413020439,
-0.0024055664,
-0.0163886901,
0.0359795019,
-0.0004790179,
-0.0694670975,
0.0079120565,
-0.0286431704,
0.0280950963,
0.0559539758,
0.044376187,
-0.0251637045,
-0.0124277342,
-0.0243514385,
0.0019961996,
0.0240325797,
-0.0478695445,
-0.0121318167,
-0.0111373169,
-0.0310718939,
0.0013173922,
-0.0021751963,
-0.0714607313,
0.0425217301,
-0.0750244707,
0.0239762105,
2.351026813e-34,
0.0577441528,
0.0021397802,
-0.0138197578,
-0.0071092835,
-0.0253188889,
-0.0335900672,
-0.0190271046,
-0.0207725707,
0.0392475575,
-0.0477550812,
0.0024898336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12814v1 | A Novel Dual of Shannon Information and Weighting Scheme | 2023-04-25T13:40:50 | 2023-04-25T13:40:50 | Arthur Jun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT | Shannon Information theory has achieved great success in not only
communication technology where it was originally developed for but also many
other science and engineering fields such as machine learning and artificial
intelligence. Inspired by the famous weighting scheme TF-IDF, we discovered
that information entropy has a natural dual. We complement the classical
Shannon information theory by proposing a novel quantity, namely troenpy.
Troenpy measures the certainty, commonness and similarity of the underlying
distribution. To demonstrate its usefulness, we propose a troenpy based
weighting scheme for document with class labels, namely positive class
frequency (PCF). On a collection of public datasets we show the PCF based
weighting scheme outperforms the classical TF-IDF and a popular Optimal
Transportation based word moving distance algorithm in a kNN setting. We
further developed a new odds-ratio type feature, namely Expected Class
Information Bias(ECIB), which can be regarded as the expected odds ratio of the
information quantity entropy and troenpy. In the experiments we observe that
including the new ECIB features and simple binary term features in a simple
logistic regression model can further significantly improve the performance.
The simple new weighting scheme and ECIB features are very effective and can be
computed with linear order complexity. | [
0.0148189357,
0.0233369712,
-0.0035538049,
-0.0041889469,
-0.0583772101,
0.0092480043,
-0.017397685,
0.0278147236,
-0.0754229426,
-0.0370986573,
0.0370727256,
-0.0578911491,
-0.0011649553,
-0.014820667,
-0.0288417637,
-0.0327101126,
-0.0170404445,
0.0003997697,
-0.0149406046,
-0.0036619769,
-0.0132098692,
-0.0572470613,
-0.021828264,
-0.0213618465,
0.02321277,
0.0348035619,
-0.0072154845,
-0.0054554897,
0.0219291039,
-0.0358325057,
-0.010508446,
0.0653243661,
0.0041101025,
-0.0013134967,
0.0000021494,
-0.0249809828,
-0.0280636996,
0.0124591347,
0.0117732221,
-0.0127628138,
0.0491721295,
-0.0050631915,
-0.0076767765,
0.0372231565,
0.0090494351,
-0.0168888662,
0.0691255182,
0.0926606581,
-0.0193637237,
0.0338579603,
-0.0125869121,
-0.0663816035,
0.0233337674,
-0.0181135703,
0.1045023352,
0.0021139097,
0.0288199689,
0.0021347215,
-0.0465620942,
-0.0004301937,
-0.0350490808,
0.0127466805,
-0.0077390191,
0.025492819,
0.067355819,
0.0147594409,
-0.015702622,
0.0305600874,
-0.0199573115,
0.0334126726,
0.0269146133,
-0.0277369246,
-0.0068473788,
0.0055865603,
-0.0149016054,
-0.0095225293,
-0.0165802874,
-0.0135951713,
0.0185269956,
0.0302340817,
-0.015236726,
0.044776991,
-0.0197872985,
0.0013893789,
0.0006146204,
0.0114530064,
0.0079047624,
-0.0389653482,
0.0211781226,
-0.0040628975,
-0.0066832826,
0.00021664,
0.0340634473,
-0.0041340739,
0.0878446624,
-0.0063415207,
0.0222549569,
-0.0271081049,
0.0444807522,
-0.1073014364,
-0.0323990509,
-0.0009247771,
0.0413919389,
0.0258811414,
0.0241739228,
-0.0235091802,
0.0327509269,
0.0197994951,
-0.0152902985,
0.0179207027,
-0.0565256551,
-0.0080938954,
0.0010095246,
0.0766554326,
0.0706886575,
-0.0425121561,
-0.0304385163,
0.0127389459,
0.0097732525,
-0.028757846,
-0.0051817442,
-0.0053321631,
0.0129169775,
0.0277193002,
-0.0114192013,
-0.0114418473,
-0.0125355273,
0.0122306477,
-0.0473287851,
0.0297275335,
0.0371693633,
0.0260813404,
0.0132873533,
0.0076974239,
-0.0077599762,
0.0354431048,
0.0085789645,
-0.0231604856,
-0.008923511,
-0.0032824441,
-0.0081085283,
0.0230377708,
-0.0342569724,
-0.0623610578,
-0.0480874293,
0.039744433,
-0.0002630408,
-0.01396761,
-0.0038585688,
-0.0210788604,
-0.0414031632,
0.0402003191,
-0.0108617488,
0.0261296108,
0.0521034002,
-0.0044671595,
0.0274859462,
0.0393587127,
0.0280922092,
-0.0080821272,
0.0502898768,
0.0042662672,
-0.0231647361,
-0.0087791989,
0.0018255865,
0.0076169106,
-0.0080483584,
-0.0568341091,
-0.0150947412,
0.000217299,
0.0118674729,
0.0201661661,
-0.0120015712,
-0.0439379439,
0.0460277535,
0.0083457399,
0.0423783697,
-0.0467137955,
-0.049399294,
0.0514272749,
-0.0365051292,
0.0144299548,
0.0557323769,
0.0053817062,
-0.0626654774,
-0.0254734214,
0.0708564594,
-0.0232683588,
-0.0168702081,
-0.0266334694,
-0.0175663494,
-0.0206811614,
0.0011987189,
-0.0336772278,
0.042659793,
-0.054941684,
0.0506693199,
0.0293746945,
0.0621366128,
-0.0151983788,
-0.0438936427,
0.0313744396,
0.0069573475,
0.0240062866,
0.0143047506,
-0.0498359166,
0.0142678972,
0.001302395,
-0.0340949744,
-0.0045928545,
0.0440625697,
0.025918927,
-0.0203569904,
-0.0584952533,
-0.0291891862,
0.1185677499,
-0.0035587065,
-0.0121170431,
-0.0467518531,
0.0708730444,
0.0404880792,
-0.0562398992,
-0.0681531057,
0.0101796044,
0.0764979497,
0.009847071,
0.0464291237,
0.0090133883,
0.039271038,
0.014064474,
-0.0282860138,
0.007184111,
0.0223881919,
-0.0401474833,
-0.0431026444,
-0.0151305236,
0.0259696487,
0.0506033823,
0.0154803842,
-0.0248289071,
0.0589376278,
0.0208039246,
0.0117294574,
-0.0090350267,
0.0124660721,
-0.0053593325,
0.0173467025,
-0.0469450578,
0.0312869623,
-0.0174600668,
0.0080540227,
-0.0552688539,
0.0415408947,
0.0236371029,
0.0919361264,
-0.0817885771,
-0.0938473493,
0.0554656386,
-0.0136683406,
0.0039460687,
0.0396475568,
-0.012488625,
0.0129648345,
0.0381428935,
-0.0202561542,
0.024464814,
-0.0327556245,
-0.0458107106,
0.0141127827,
-0.0053772111,
0.0247417782,
-0.0225185882,
0.0037748944,
-0.0098789083,
-0.0022462772,
-0.074942328,
0.0222258288,
-0.0547127351,
-0.0301857349,
0.0211856067,
-0.0034466675,
-0.0325655118,
0.0160111878,
-0.0194901619,
-0.0143046062,
0.0315463543,
0.0305250827,
-0.023159042,
-0.0403273627,
0.0673937425,
-0.0419087112,
-0.0017298606,
0.0360814333,
0.0002035409,
-0.0186080746,
-0.0358163789,
-0.0197059717,
-0.0403942056,
0.0747153312,
-0.0742329955,
0.0335694849,
0.0197004378,
-0.0482952408,
-0.0028575989,
-0.0544544533,
0.06198515,
-0.0065219868,
-0.0577074699,
-0.0000471787,
0.0111172693,
-0.0004209761,
-0.0204573143,
-0.0173347741,
-0.0658143982,
-0.0176580604,
-0.0171755515,
-0.0769967809,
0.043585062,
0.031644769,
0.0128292516,
0.0272552911,
-0.0193760768,
0.0100670429,
-0.0176444501,
0.0424095877,
-0.0671963692,
-0.0304962099,
-0.0338274464,
0.0143098896,
0.0376660004,
0.0606100522,
0.0367460102,
-0.0234258436,
0.0138202971,
-0.0432517305,
0.0686607361,
-0.01972216,
-0.0294125937,
0.02475092,
0.0062895729,
-0.0103442669,
-0.0252333302,
0.0042361408,
-0.0481749028,
0.04862893,
-0.0463391766,
-0.002636797,
-0.063006103,
0.0076908297,
0.0224881601,
0.0303736292,
0.0119516253,
0.0096003469,
-0.0356057771,
0.0201674718,
0.0397639424,
0.0165477339,
0.0001289475,
0.02858123,
0.0100448588,
-0.0255214591,
0.0465796478,
0.0394835845,
0.0680076554,
-0.0031412824,
-0.003811751,
0.0353824608,
-0.0357265063,
-0.0301383566,
0.0240629893,
-0.0266588815,
0.0454614945,
0.0235599149,
0.1036221907,
0.0696500242,
-0.0770977661,
-0.0101315985,
-0.0237327404,
0.049895443,
-0.0112369377,
-0.0099914549,
-0.0415316485,
-0.0168092195,
0.0170380659,
0.029349301,
-0.0478992462,
-0.0582672432,
0.0399258547,
-0.0505257137,
0.0111777335,
-0.0067994497,
0.0160169844,
-0.0539193228,
-0.0977533162,
-0.0123514924,
0.0112284021,
-0.0429039076,
-0.0236737374,
0.0192276593,
0.0184790138,
0.0380651243,
-0.09050107,
-0.020829618,
-0.0086362818,
-0.0258579664,
0.0313410014,
0.0153000373,
0.0175877772,
-0.0735000893,
-0.0442656875,
-0.0352666825,
-0.0605920814,
-0.0395277143,
-0.0201818757,
0.0827669278,
0.0070613697,
0.0003484411,
-0.0394251086,
-0.0110603767,
-0.0410041846,
0.0043704831,
-0.012330709,
0.0218204726,
-0.0410676114,
-0.0216540769,
-0.0380893759,
0.0110350186,
0.0442087911,
0.0745725632,
-0.0356837884,
-0.0316128954,
0.0168782659,
0.0076941079,
0.0273998436,
0.0373979621,
0.0113705229,
0.0062455484,
0.0127938837,
-0.1166696399,
-0.0817730203,
0.0114512965,
-0.0293289181,
0.0409665816,
-0.0025035173,
0.0509140417,
0.0045245118,
-0.0335403197,
-0.0385365114,
-0.0677746758,
0.0299012959,
0.0238693897,
-0.0670467019,
0.0099325301,
0.0608209111,
0.01226898,
-0.0559251346,
0.0093456442,
-0.0186438039,
-0.0502261519,
-0.0056937789,
-0.0592294298,
0.0218749922,
-0.0412833542,
-0.0351211242,
-0.0448523834,
0.0494352281,
0.0722727254,
0.002371683,
0.0091515379,
0.0075153201,
-0.0931623578,
0.0096791275,
0.0038865665,
-0.0237653498,
0.0485539585,
-0.0094679464,
-0.0116158854,
-0.0515186153,
-0.0240906253,
-0.0201931428,
0.0599207878,
0.0250508022,
0.036958918,
-0.0697355941,
0.0023588452,
0.0441695452,
0.0112826163,
0.0007323616,
0.0078247469,
0.0050993031,
0.070372045,
0.0305312779,
-0.0286682304,
0.0941386521,
0.0621875599,
-0.0462092981,
0.028236527,
0.0384623222,
-0.0473667383,
0.0439330041,
-0.0074238176,
-0.0032323606,
0.0194577612,
-0.0538205281,
0.0505290926,
0.0617086589,
0.031370528,
0.0158985164,
0.0280449912,
0.0255351607,
-0.0124072181,
0.0096023334,
-0.0755324289,
0.0009411469,
0.0019311348,
0.0409279577,
0.0152196074,
0.0295530166,
-0.0155927194,
-0.0544205084,
0.0017516193,
-0.007685937,
-0.028373437,
0.0083133951,
0.0448149405,
0.0240818877,
0.0098827975,
-0.0210117865,
0.066813387,
0.0605515838,
-0.0179131553,
0.007408354,
-0.0456310771,
-0.056188181,
0.0049386239,
0.0585751273,
0.0909085795,
0.0279271081,
-0.0009767656,
0.0430976786,
-0.0115889627,
-0.0087544434,
0.0541560575,
-0.0381040573,
0.0322406963,
-0.0191581715,
0.0343638062,
0.0668856204,
-0.0148235643,
0.0186260827,
-0.0403458625,
-0.0436303578,
-0.0564209707,
0.0133762816,
-0.0106396507,
-6.902724703e-33,
0.014653218,
0.0071493867,
-0.0616682991,
0.082663931,
0.0027410886,
-0.0015229123,
0.0336014219,
-0.0017871653,
-0.0133331418,
0.019666953,
0.0232708901,
-0.0060979268,
0.0109562743,
0.0041814535,
0.0154632078,
-0.0140525652,
-0.0525549129,
0.0056906398,
-0.0007169649,
0.0045761182,
0.0564498901,
0.0054926858,
0.0108906459,
-0.0492753759,
0.00580646,
0.0052213334,
-0.0033913373,
0.005239103,
0.0418738797,
0.007856871,
-0.0056978939,
0.0223446563,
0.0041739126,
-0.0168249365,
0.0001523569,
-0.0094410814,
-0.0161238573,
-0.0690241531,
-0.0251027383,
0.0284299497,
0.0553663187,
-0.0030887949,
0.0515966155,
0.0147076035,
-0.0697172433,
0.0210120715,
0.0444900058,
-0.002940105,
-0.0391333736,
-0.0776038766,
-0.000666023,
0.0450846441,
-0.0128640132,
0.0046337377,
0.0139134191,
-0.0155585725,
-0.0053840657,
-0.0341349207,
-0.0809004754,
0.029995352,
0.016330881,
0.0500411019,
-0.0596919432,
-0.004873388,
-0.0074053123,
0.0359327197,
0.0363976136,
-0.0689904839,
0.0157907624,
0.0134004671,
0.0090409461,
-0.0447031893,
0.0291063376,
0.0184517838,
0.0931570828,
-0.0285577867,
-0.0817144811,
0.0829629526,
0.0054687327,
-0.0169616621,
0.0256523341,
0.0149184056,
-0.1154657379,
-0.0106808357,
-0.0125363218,
-0.0239468198,
-0.0042205038,
-0.0260164905,
-0.0093589853,
-0.0129546346,
-0.0038389352,
0.0269534923,
-0.0104170823,
0.0015579843,
-0.0664266869,
0.015267387,
0.0222086702,
0.0659600496,
-0.0189110357,
-0.0164377373,
-0.0278614257,
-0.0170028415,
0.0148020601,
0.0018211437,
-0.01803267,
0.0006642365,
0.0723847374,
0.0179394986,
-0.0675378889,
-0.0223756395,
0.0417190194,
-0.0381330959,
0.0230264049,
0.0089146392,
-0.0243829098,
-0.032658916,
0.0023238794,
0.0012320525,
0.0188159756,
0.0144855706,
-0.0068814582,
-0.0119624492,
-0.0109298239,
-0.0020032634,
-0.0193428453,
-0.0141412709,
0.0090195946,
-0.02492892,
0.0685879737,
-0.0183833856,
-0.018081842,
-0.029589273,
3.095e-7,
0.0560244359,
-0.0106435614,
0.009020634,
0.0096502118,
-0.010673698,
0.0421598107,
-0.0013446354,
0.0240096804,
0.0154197747,
-0.0001225561,
0.0241897702,
0.0141718071,
0.0037565762,
-0.0088657476,
-0.0499441884,
-0.0367147736,
0.0253029987,
-0.0313251168,
-0.0060731713,
0.0263583474,
0.0504070707,
0.0835743099,
0.0137226228,
-0.0263470076,
0.0402316563,
-0.051303111,
-0.0060676928,
-0.0760746524,
0.0363297574,
0.0222074259,
0.0639842674,
-0.0340310521,
-0.0035341471,
0.0226214956,
-0.0071585146,
-0.0289663207,
0.0065001235,
-0.0244986825,
-0.0358289406,
0.0236703381,
-0.0411587544,
-0.0135175688,
0.0194542911,
-0.0173004903,
0.0460195839,
0.0495215617,
-0.056577839,
-0.0045222389,
-0.0125988601,
0.0001898102,
0.0207212511,
0.0520129241,
-0.0460529849,
-0.0318971127,
-0.0172478184,
-0.0071062827,
-0.0013587569,
-0.0525157191,
0.0114976279,
0.0106057525,
0.0067233937,
0.0078918375,
0.0034168451,
-0.0142292771,
0.0387872569,
-0.0478282273,
0.0270338766,
2.736601358e-34,
0.0397948213,
0.0351781957,
-0.0164240133,
-0.0197941251,
-0.0022933094,
0.0055779209,
-0.0126745915,
-0.0261496548,
-0.021128092,
-0.0314251967,
0.0223217886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12776v1 | State Spaces Aren't Enough: Machine Translation Needs Attention | 2023-04-25T12:54:20 | 2023-04-25T12:54:20 | Ali Vardasbi, Telmo Pessoa Pires, Robin M. Schmidt, Stephan Peitz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Structured State Spaces for Sequences (S4) is a recently proposed sequence
model with successful applications in various tasks, e.g. vision, language
modeling, and audio. Thanks to its mathematical formulation, it compresses its
input to a single hidden state, and is able to capture long range dependencies
while avoiding the need for an attention mechanism. In this work, we apply S4
to Machine Translation (MT), and evaluate several encoder-decoder variants on
WMT'14 and WMT'16. In contrast with the success in language modeling, we find
that S4 lags behind the Transformer by approximately 4 BLEU points, and that it
counter-intuitively struggles with long sentences. Finally, we show that this
gap is caused by S4's inability to summarize the full source sentence in a
single hidden state, and show that we can close the gap by introducing an
attention mechanism. | [
-0.0155290514,
0.061391931,
-0.0005087386,
0.0274241194,
-0.0393523648,
0.0104597518,
0.0191542264,
0.0180703886,
-0.042380508,
-0.0049482356,
0.009279429,
-0.0472090729,
0.0642266423,
0.0626848191,
0.0236416627,
-0.0858032182,
0.0132113928,
-0.0212083496,
-0.045867905,
0.0040153847,
-0.0212091673,
-0.0205007195,
0.010596686,
0.0324972421,
0.0329293758,
0.0066058775,
-0.0463511311,
-0.0022722301,
0.0549204275,
-0.0434713028,
-0.0306214727,
0.0450541973,
0.0304327682,
0.0390815809,
0.0000021243,
-0.0143751875,
-0.0228908658,
-0.0187466182,
0.036245618,
0.0065298956,
-0.0488606356,
-0.095127821,
-0.0033139677,
0.0194056518,
-0.025823161,
-0.0198721644,
0.0606200248,
-0.0027541053,
0.0691013113,
0.0993048772,
-0.0251131654,
-0.0430639349,
0.0119646313,
-0.0758118331,
0.0142246308,
-0.0478116125,
0.0126918564,
-0.0314687081,
-0.0142313838,
0.0147105819,
-0.0694108158,
0.0733170137,
0.0358562283,
0.0205269977,
0.0065339175,
0.0331552997,
-0.0023405296,
-0.0238414276,
-0.0359024145,
0.0636482462,
-0.0692327768,
-0.0030224647,
0.0151379043,
-0.0055399206,
-0.0202151928,
-0.0514502339,
-0.0322048441,
0.0376231559,
-0.0146472426,
0.0081471158,
-0.0221944414,
0.0381025374,
0.0272385348,
-0.0516643412,
-0.0480571687,
0.009845905,
0.0147177344,
-0.0452913269,
-0.0780457333,
0.0074692103,
0.0100691253,
-0.0632154047,
0.0620689131,
0.0464674607,
0.022404626,
-0.0026105805,
-0.0594781339,
-0.032877218,
-0.0343565121,
-0.0287876856,
0.0182726998,
0.0659520552,
-0.0102057923,
0.0315256566,
0.0029010293,
0.0823306367,
-0.0287440773,
-0.0294913407,
-0.0552820414,
0.0397518016,
-0.0190966856,
0.0251608472,
-0.0341762826,
-0.0182989035,
-0.0533666089,
-0.0382693261,
-0.0113192685,
0.0316039734,
0.0272463672,
-0.0184262879,
0.0203346945,
-0.0168544538,
-0.0561121255,
0.0045750523,
0.0188981891,
0.0554334335,
0.0294591542,
-0.0299828295,
0.0049872631,
-0.0217848737,
-0.0650640875,
0.0337644815,
0.0333835669,
-0.0074796118,
-0.0449249484,
0.0538389273,
-0.0016638935,
-0.0429856628,
0.0326662734,
0.0078969775,
-0.0386029817,
-0.0355830714,
0.0363308266,
-0.0323442593,
0.0330118984,
0.0125242919,
0.0111462502,
-0.0304339416,
0.0313750803,
0.0148544144,
0.0080634616,
0.0546946973,
0.0057689678,
-0.030689409,
-0.0118803848,
0.0237302966,
0.0296031535,
0.0035870625,
0.0520926975,
0.0480661839,
-0.0133710979,
-0.0209590346,
0.0136559792,
0.0517067239,
0.0028112389,
0.0327486843,
-0.0307521578,
-0.0162029993,
-0.0093483692,
0.0139225069,
0.0386223011,
0.064038448,
-0.0111905029,
-0.0073512034,
0.0552927442,
0.0355871655,
0.0305505432,
0.0444429293,
0.0272187069,
0.0120546231,
-0.0200742595,
0.0292031355,
0.005072589,
0.0651833788,
-0.0055346563,
0.0299521107,
0.0433573686,
0.0301301926,
-0.0162926838,
-0.0244276319,
-0.0123016015,
-0.0275332984,
0.0238544401,
-0.0319599435,
0.029720759,
0.0097618289,
-0.0824928209,
0.0702023283,
-0.0309103783,
-0.0678231791,
0.0153157618,
-0.0012559398,
-0.0220818371,
0.0688975826,
0.0286965128,
0.0029419721,
-0.0023245318,
-0.0273542665,
-0.0292220861,
0.059256237,
0.0030391489,
0.0435706005,
0.0225242134,
-0.0396501496,
-0.0610351339,
0.0322235152,
-0.0110732391,
0.0244513731,
-0.0207903478,
0.0428621545,
0.034984231,
0.0084985541,
0.0090861572,
0.0299669746,
0.0076706661,
-0.0229099598,
-0.012642419,
0.0058264649,
0.0714796185,
0.0042190696,
-0.0082692392,
0.0339135155,
0.0370077863,
-0.058954943,
0.0049841418,
0.0085531883,
-0.109918423,
-0.0694579333,
0.0171296317,
-0.0413823016,
0.0321142152,
0.0666011497,
-0.0342500545,
-0.0732061341,
0.0015246663,
-0.08204294,
-0.0010729497,
-0.0309065804,
0.0353981107,
0.029793499,
0.0675721616,
-0.0324464142,
0.0418822058,
-0.0520414263,
-0.0091376761,
-0.0144593716,
-0.026275849,
-0.0082288114,
-0.0190037023,
-0.0092649898,
0.0398397408,
0.026808219,
-0.0016015392,
0.0294050928,
-0.0007169737,
-0.0105359461,
-0.0280804224,
-0.0335601047,
-0.0214910638,
-0.0347672626,
0.0419593677,
0.0161249898,
0.0668841824,
0.0132759362,
-0.0169033036,
-0.0309621114,
0.0004026874,
0.0046675047,
-0.0214455165,
0.0315822139,
0.0121478941,
-0.0450045094,
-0.0220564529,
-0.0217539743,
0.022594491,
0.0191608537,
-0.0280008893,
-0.0516827218,
-0.0883695036,
-0.0051038279,
0.0098537374,
0.0209286585,
-0.0339614227,
-0.0256718174,
-0.0090421299,
-0.0175824463,
0.0538516603,
0.0335830189,
0.0327596776,
0.0343626514,
0.0425124802,
0.0033128983,
0.0017843152,
0.0162088666,
-0.0317191593,
0.0318220146,
-0.0269143842,
0.0029078536,
0.0355067961,
0.0860979334,
0.0157247838,
0.0166041777,
-0.0865071267,
-0.0279430412,
0.0501396917,
-0.0059635486,
0.0037555504,
-0.0101068532,
-0.0561004393,
0.0314939208,
-0.0318089798,
-0.0551718138,
0.0504196696,
-0.0705406368,
-0.0153883984,
-0.0283401273,
0.0142635107,
-0.036499206,
0.069527775,
0.0451957993,
-0.0080349939,
-0.0097618047,
-0.0090027014,
0.006934904,
0.0301983058,
-0.0148904026,
-0.0325113013,
0.0445495397,
-0.0412247628,
0.0075666402,
-0.0419779532,
-0.006427424,
-0.0216876362,
0.0287933927,
-0.0234747957,
-0.0211731419,
0.043247655,
-0.0402923226,
-0.0417149588,
0.0560232066,
0.0326003805,
0.0755645037,
-0.0035728184,
0.023579305,
-0.0339918956,
0.0521479584,
0.0298044458,
-0.0189953558,
0.0001220102,
-0.0674718171,
0.0021004758,
0.0532677323,
0.0156877488,
0.0305702463,
-0.0275390074,
-0.0061456724,
0.0506300628,
0.0019402184,
-0.0261069797,
0.0230560452,
0.0254541952,
-0.0664799213,
-0.0262103043,
0.1023780778,
0.0114894304,
-0.0406836234,
0.0392356701,
0.0200186167,
0.0455045365,
-0.0099321073,
-0.0066133495,
-0.0660241023,
-0.0263397042,
-0.0119718639,
0.0089700874,
0.0400227904,
0.0153879812,
-0.013586509,
-0.0529893301,
-0.0121297333,
0.0609858781,
-0.0433895513,
-0.0734708682,
-0.0046943235,
-0.0089045446,
0.0287056975,
0.0121343229,
0.0319608487,
0.0049387058,
-0.0113656968,
0.0219113305,
-0.0030479413,
-0.0398498327,
-0.0009606009,
0.0178082027,
0.0106098009,
0.0862501115,
0.0136662424,
-0.0013086374,
-0.0930584893,
0.0153786298,
0.0208570976,
0.0170559194,
-0.0084556499,
0.0049729552,
-0.0134889754,
-0.0312926657,
0.0275280885,
-0.0001311717,
-0.0417286195,
0.0153438188,
0.00094965,
0.0469345599,
-0.0276147984,
-0.0311490837,
-0.0043761232,
-0.0209087133,
0.0013317598,
0.0412758105,
0.0302115679,
-0.0330995917,
-0.0407149121,
-0.009245472,
0.0076973583,
-0.070194006,
-0.0256669931,
-0.0154257938,
0.0280752629,
-0.0503779128,
-0.0720916912,
-0.0525238998,
0.0027908839,
0.0166365616,
-0.0252574161,
-0.0074131005,
0.0429164842,
-0.0009908612,
-0.0582491122,
0.0186395794,
-0.0147842485,
0.0112847425,
-0.0147176906,
-0.0101428349,
-0.0181809869,
0.0018531935,
-0.0102646835,
0.0113724805,
-0.1234290302,
-0.0467635021,
-0.0026685332,
0.0658545718,
0.01860887,
0.023764357,
-0.001115387,
0.0100490693,
0.037651848,
-0.0098550366,
-0.0009423104,
0.0377464332,
0.0339107178,
-0.041598998,
-0.0091630211,
0.0366528705,
-0.0201509558,
-0.0146640707,
-0.015254641,
0.061964795,
-0.0068156901,
-0.068086423,
-0.0028494366,
-0.0318888165,
0.0663967356,
-0.0093215685,
0.0064456742,
0.0470962971,
0.0261042397,
-0.0163147114,
0.0282112006,
-0.0678377226,
-0.0011590128,
0.0112141622,
0.0099213338,
0.0188836697,
0.0194175392,
-0.0018902579,
-0.0712080076,
0.0060388879,
0.0387281105,
-0.0047634756,
-0.0169705879,
0.027936805,
-0.0068302429,
-0.0114825815,
0.000198578,
0.0022998215,
-0.0038530347,
-0.0114643695,
0.0371770076,
0.00351579,
0.0589954183,
0.0022585434,
0.0516801886,
-0.0577218048,
0.0245550722,
-0.0237293337,
-0.0089835431,
0.0737907588,
-0.0141592836,
0.0791756064,
0.0100291306,
0.0195284989,
-0.0367921814,
0.0585824512,
-0.0224500801,
-0.0504460186,
-0.0009328065,
0.015359588,
-0.001277863,
0.0223005693,
0.078597635,
0.0170087107,
0.0155150499,
0.0176468603,
0.0092701474,
-0.0399557129,
-0.0259634741,
-0.017519474,
0.0009770368,
-0.0117055913,
0.0072862003,
-0.0163069237,
-0.0568189695,
0.0475150272,
-0.0046417485,
0.025493836,
-0.0015521268,
0.0453390665,
0.0166311245,
-0.0484254137,
-0.0309349522,
-0.0220387615,
-0.0284618903,
0.0188091993,
-0.0597004108,
-0.0142875044,
-6.405913035e-33,
-0.0177118387,
-0.0212492757,
0.0028818469,
-0.0132245962,
-0.053493727,
-0.0107423905,
-0.0737646446,
-0.0089336801,
0.034162771,
-0.0243759993,
-0.0076194326,
0.0145165361,
0.0126975281,
0.0516649671,
-0.0023081971,
0.0045414856,
0.0617901422,
0.0121043846,
-0.0222627744,
0.029168291,
0.0100039011,
0.0274435133,
0.0582201295,
0.0005815352,
0.000002993,
-0.0302015282,
0.0052703288,
-0.017194258,
0.0127887866,
-0.005787191,
-0.0142640406,
0.0184622891,
0.0152689908,
-0.0501251481,
-0.0504540242,
0.0189517103,
-0.0525493361,
0.0097237658,
-0.0097857649,
0.0207279474,
-0.0595703721,
-0.0492998622,
0.0554133318,
-0.0187447798,
0.0117100254,
-0.039242778,
0.0095364349,
-0.0463668928,
-0.0494341031,
-0.0617095046,
-0.0188254081,
0.0240501538,
-0.0205600969,
-0.0163223241,
0.0241380185,
0.0559246093,
-0.002371189,
-0.0158428457,
-0.0537028722,
-0.0053485692,
0.017531734,
0.0806048885,
0.0749034956,
0.0176716093,
0.0221236236,
0.0010543399,
0.0069131646,
-0.0655609891,
-0.0175733045,
0.0339910462,
0.0167455338,
-0.0099361334,
0.0456243679,
-0.0532477237,
0.0317888893,
-0.007693423,
-0.032949321,
0.0130729647,
-0.0582385436,
0.0494736657,
0.0214368179,
0.0335450955,
-0.0345471315,
0.0020389713,
-0.0047455356,
-0.0011532347,
-0.0056608003,
-0.011883826,
0.0064778798,
0.0406955779,
-0.0001809691,
0.0025069448,
0.091832459,
-0.0232982561,
0.0270074233,
0.0023047598,
-0.0008086626,
-0.0017296465,
0.0000313879,
0.020534521,
-0.0284167957,
-0.0046851141,
0.0350733586,
0.0422245562,
-0.0064463378,
-0.0367613845,
-0.009164867,
0.0453244597,
-0.0547532439,
-0.0215486828,
-0.0367812552,
0.008730771,
-0.0175391585,
0.0537538379,
0.0607383549,
-0.0110318176,
-0.0084117176,
0.0576567464,
-0.0277806502,
-0.0352394469,
-0.0321989283,
0.0262651797,
-0.0029282505,
0.057390105,
-0.0309239067,
0.0114586074,
-0.053687159,
0.0660783425,
0.0781920627,
-0.0493527353,
-0.0311665423,
0.0385420546,
2.797e-7,
0.0289981738,
0.0401019119,
0.0545268431,
0.0078330981,
0.0316048115,
0.0144284116,
-0.0329722725,
0.0448862948,
-0.0134562366,
0.0121740196,
0.0255917087,
0.0123363519,
0.0752325878,
-0.0341859423,
-0.0795084536,
-0.0157458577,
-0.0595487244,
0.0119519718,
-0.0297949146,
-0.0153208906,
0.057101395,
0.0901953503,
-0.0130839543,
0.024288686,
0.0174446814,
-0.00471659,
0.0514811687,
0.0257711243,
0.028234832,
-0.0195029825,
0.0017071366,
-0.0133733684,
-0.0462268814,
-0.0355486795,
-0.0185779799,
0.0086060297,
0.0098789353,
0.0964518115,
0.0101557449,
-0.0492618345,
0.002409833,
0.0342695713,
-0.0490665808,
-0.0168929696,
0.0427410789,
-0.0440830886,
-0.0141583327,
0.0225035548,
-0.0458882898,
0.0457056537,
-0.0384445973,
0.0298016742,
-0.0084526269,
0.0194486305,
0.0255579203,
-0.0155548211,
0.0131984875,
-0.0634159893,
-0.0295043718,
-0.0481602363,
-0.0589661598,
0.004040604,
-0.059990894,
-0.0061702132,
0.0223674532,
0.0114434417,
-0.054585956,
2.734360113e-34,
0.027483141,
-0.0540774092,
0.0099873887,
-0.0094339009,
-0.0157335028,
-0.0397462808,
-0.0047659366,
0.0186850782,
0.0172718335,
-0.0706508905,
-0.0623503812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14275v1 | What's in a Name? Evaluating Assembly-Part Semantic Knowledge in Language Models through User-Provided Names in CAD Files | 2023-04-25T12:30:01 | 2023-04-25T12:30:01 | Peter Meltzer, Joseph G. Lambourne, Daniele Grandi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cc:68T50, I.2.7; J.6 | Semantic knowledge of part-part and part-whole relationships in assemblies is
useful for a variety of tasks from searching design repositories to the
construction of engineering knowledge bases. In this work we propose that the
natural language names designers use in Computer Aided Design (CAD) software
are a valuable source of such knowledge, and that Large Language Models (LLMs)
contain useful domain-specific information for working with this data as well
as other CAD and engineering-related tasks.
In particular we extract and clean a large corpus of natural language part,
feature and document names and use this to quantitatively demonstrate that a
pre-trained language model can outperform numerous benchmarks on three
self-supervised tasks, without ever having seen this data before. Moreover, we
show that fine-tuning on the text data corpus further boosts the performance on
all tasks, thus demonstrating the value of the text data which until now has
been largely ignored. We also identify key limitations to using LLMs with text
data alone, and our findings provide a strong motivation for further work into
multi-modal text-geometry models.
To aid and encourage further work in this area we make all our data and code
publicly available. | [
0.0322163552,
0.0442897081,
-0.0234571062,
0.0699987859,
-0.0351656973,
0.0101885311,
0.0433145277,
0.0000317029,
-0.0221141819,
-0.0425365418,
-0.0307217296,
-0.0234999955,
0.021291893,
0.0046248771,
0.0091495905,
-0.0338983946,
-0.0007831393,
-0.0327288881,
0.0096943947,
0.0225697644,
0.0079593845,
0.0235325005,
-0.0045835599,
0.0468724482,
-0.0444496423,
-0.0071447687,
-0.0442068912,
0.0208534095,
-0.0150921829,
-0.0250188652,
-0.0010347597,
0.0687956214,
0.0146535775,
0.0480855517,
0.0000020435,
-0.0349305533,
-0.0242828783,
-0.0027796412,
0.0082733454,
0.0208464153,
0.0636271313,
-0.0445120968,
-0.0310928114,
-0.04644363,
0.0215430278,
-0.0083040055,
0.0456115156,
0.0291004516,
0.0358906984,
0.0324006863,
-0.0106148804,
-0.015584494,
0.021062525,
0.0050305533,
0.0190391336,
-0.0048761857,
-0.0099245105,
0.0342993811,
0.0659723952,
0.0367696248,
0.0050362647,
0.0545001142,
-0.0054385588,
0.026443759,
0.0170557853,
0.0413803384,
-0.0153938653,
0.0059298114,
0.0340368897,
0.1070998013,
-0.0084322281,
0.0136192106,
0.020568436,
-0.045699019,
-0.0184261203,
0.0256747454,
-0.0259049665,
-0.0084156655,
-0.01938897,
-0.0179954804,
-0.0142461229,
-0.011753791,
0.0017510194,
-0.0395616144,
-0.0076400968,
0.0342103168,
0.0197057314,
0.0029078866,
-0.0204963963,
-0.0339334197,
-0.0025898023,
-0.0599731095,
-0.0233479179,
-0.0010168001,
0.0293640755,
0.0376209803,
-0.0416441038,
-0.0087143956,
0.0127194421,
-0.05561845,
-0.009539485,
0.0025606877,
-0.0345996171,
0.0492007434,
-0.056345284,
0.0504390039,
0.0038992753,
0.037276186,
-0.0823832378,
-0.0047391541,
-0.0393063687,
-0.0424511917,
-0.0746801049,
0.028788574,
-0.0671133921,
-0.032325618,
0.0031858529,
0.0269429572,
-0.0168231875,
0.0291311964,
0.0624964088,
-0.0076912045,
-0.029507203,
-0.0547610149,
-0.0465755165,
-0.0271296427,
0.0164473988,
0.007527004,
-0.0293542668,
-0.0607500039,
0.0198568832,
0.001688295,
0.009917127,
-0.0083211111,
-0.0069973287,
0.1088326201,
-0.0271382444,
-0.0252082832,
-0.0183537528,
-0.0534005277,
-0.0209299158,
-0.0079985131,
0.011772424,
-0.080938369,
0.0018993907,
0.0198090672,
0.0139673091,
-0.0696600899,
0.0184284821,
-0.0040826276,
-0.0206285194,
0.0884962976,
-0.0452180244,
0.03598997,
0.0106099145,
0.0000554212,
0.0399084464,
0.0496153533,
0.053367652,
0.0708490163,
0.0336078703,
0.0100362236,
-0.0061528161,
0.0433226638,
-0.0170136336,
-0.0552946776,
-0.0282899849,
0.0142944697,
0.0181475114,
0.0215185899,
-0.0388567112,
-0.0220686886,
0.0208964646,
-0.0127994874,
0.0320843458,
0.0518849716,
0.022482926,
0.0221356917,
0.0247689337,
0.0661725625,
-0.0091884127,
-0.04705346,
-0.0088439304,
-0.0066022738,
-0.0141742481,
0.0156435762,
-0.0219738334,
-0.0062888758,
-0.0187659804,
-0.0524866804,
-0.0051352596,
-0.0326555632,
-0.0102789504,
-0.0277675241,
0.0680019781,
0.0222846158,
-0.0356912054,
0.0274557974,
0.0228160694,
-0.0510634296,
-0.045221813,
0.0151742958,
-0.0000995403,
0.0759392455,
0.0183936544,
-0.0581743754,
-0.067459777,
0.0467801914,
0.0359325483,
0.0030218738,
0.0198559705,
-0.0233499371,
0.0115547767,
-0.0045112059,
-0.0355935879,
-0.0137884235,
-0.0004245635,
0.053569179,
-0.0095256837,
-0.0209015049,
0.0087552909,
-0.0260673538,
-0.0372498706,
0.0297564678,
-0.016667109,
-0.0406882353,
0.0042299959,
0.0300528854,
-0.0274912436,
-0.0143099437,
-0.0455440693,
0.0100198295,
0.0451696068,
-0.0328242555,
-0.0058530252,
0.0301442649,
-0.0146962283,
-0.0035215518,
0.0038713594,
-0.0429903939,
0.0079719834,
-0.0246962029,
-0.0094695101,
-0.0215802584,
0.0042554885,
-0.014487776,
0.0446075462,
0.0161735211,
0.0083887689,
0.0018680689,
-0.0310449116,
-0.0710843727,
0.0721795037,
0.0001601471,
0.0384079553,
-0.0041314405,
0.0269824676,
0.0462285876,
-0.0010605769,
-0.0646544248,
0.0547848605,
-0.0185222607,
0.0156015689,
0.0222874284,
0.0061452882,
-0.0145220095,
-0.0163289793,
-0.0848935246,
-0.0136107542,
0.0044729025,
0.0291752443,
0.0074204835,
-0.0227991901,
-0.0298616346,
-0.0292931702,
0.0051263729,
-0.0021546162,
-0.0112033952,
-0.0158360302,
0.0242167842,
0.0211766195,
-0.006429486,
0.013021715,
-0.01590023,
-0.0183033794,
0.0323437564,
0.0816356987,
-0.0233563557,
-0.0611453019,
0.0775849596,
-0.0086028529,
0.0141879926,
-0.0004861984,
-0.0278074034,
0.0029061527,
-0.0175506957,
0.0428605974,
0.0424405374,
-0.0315751545,
0.0021141216,
0.024249224,
-0.0546705388,
-0.0682055652,
0.0011409878,
0.0002277467,
0.0234197155,
-0.0050617321,
-0.0360512398,
0.0307235979,
0.0690011159,
-0.0201982278,
0.021196926,
-0.03490844,
0.0202212222,
-0.0195303522,
-0.017622143,
-0.0269399546,
-0.0108832978,
0.0445395522,
0.0612648837,
-0.0164978541,
-0.0297403652,
0.0594812036,
-0.0933474079,
-0.0026752942,
0.0330124907,
-0.0029004435,
-0.0410856977,
0.1218991876,
0.034874104,
0.0085548814,
0.0456916019,
-0.0221930631,
-0.0292408243,
0.0817708597,
0.0232167151,
0.0031049249,
0.020385284,
-0.0972689986,
0.0508438386,
-0.0240514651,
-0.0602275804,
-0.0229273885,
0.0181075167,
-0.0491296723,
0.000084803,
0.0406834967,
-0.0260814,
-0.0160278194,
0.0759174377,
0.0237830766,
0.0154226171,
0.0339066759,
-0.0023899374,
-0.0510405526,
0.0192264579,
0.0255428813,
0.0387902595,
-0.0426439829,
-0.0248257406,
-0.0572707467,
0.0273752119,
-0.0110931918,
0.0069978642,
-0.0735329688,
-0.0231675226,
0.0396833457,
0.0058216839,
-0.037882749,
-0.0016280526,
0.0196014624,
-0.0366589911,
-0.0064829793,
0.0675677657,
0.0313092545,
-0.0171919409,
-0.0368238762,
0.064358592,
0.0260067191,
0.0246984158,
-0.0199624784,
-0.0843791291,
-0.0417162366,
-0.0204875525,
-0.0414464884,
0.0225797016,
-0.0209664181,
-0.0005873076,
-0.1113276705,
0.0201292224,
-0.0189416818,
-0.0929934084,
-0.0369966514,
-0.0118881837,
-0.0084773442,
-0.0235633757,
-0.0798410326,
-0.0282040723,
-0.0395468324,
-0.0246472098,
0.0424170978,
-0.0622368343,
-0.0407238454,
0.0127236713,
-0.016888082,
0.020927608,
0.0456124544,
0.0566286296,
0.0147638936,
-0.0590796284,
0.0544353873,
-0.0067021814,
0.0199160166,
-0.0091948686,
0.02192064,
0.0118807536,
-0.0327723026,
0.000093827,
-0.0088402629,
-0.0581725724,
-0.0204984937,
-0.0060404292,
0.0355374478,
0.0124396468,
0.0576306209,
-0.0268843826,
-0.0421871953,
-0.0211867765,
0.0272469912,
0.0018510874,
-0.0248464886,
-0.0405232832,
-0.0777245909,
0.0192861632,
0.007230767,
-0.0458220094,
-0.0108147338,
-0.0709468275,
-0.022867199,
-0.0632475913,
0.0077381665,
0.0266721714,
0.0201538745,
-0.0035504589,
-0.0304537322,
0.0322007351,
0.0229244661,
-0.1025022417,
0.0446946211,
-0.0253027231,
0.0308576748,
-0.0430361144,
-0.000136282,
0.027449077,
-0.0377806649,
-0.0484431535,
-0.0008887642,
-0.0307282023,
-0.0325875208,
-0.0100504346,
0.0440808013,
0.0128028933,
0.0338208079,
-0.0240857732,
-0.0861945003,
-0.021156149,
0.0603544749,
-0.0311707929,
-0.0298879705,
0.0026758236,
0.0058223321,
-0.0005643182,
0.0047881878,
-0.0109671243,
0.0314747877,
0.0271153077,
-0.0196029153,
0.006099809,
-0.0480904914,
0.0252821613,
0.0592325293,
-0.001912758,
0.0185176805,
0.0587261803,
-0.0455163531,
0.0412255377,
-0.0043280348,
-0.0406586826,
-0.0258356072,
0.0325485654,
-0.0076468638,
-0.0647407025,
0.0081549594,
0.0347381756,
0.0112277726,
0.0806562677,
-0.0071486579,
0.0181525294,
0.0247883331,
0.0726148635,
0.0258295871,
0.0075670197,
0.0255458876,
0.0222361516,
-0.0172939282,
0.057518702,
-0.005322895,
-0.0154053699,
0.0226462763,
-0.0087231826,
-0.0385574549,
0.0408783108,
-0.0091966549,
-0.0569398738,
-0.0718522742,
-0.0028155292,
0.015929712,
0.0020011913,
0.0273557212,
-0.0314456634,
0.0040279031,
-0.0167027302,
0.0494161546,
0.0141902501,
-0.0135033028,
-0.0051305317,
0.0275924746,
-0.0018791419,
-0.075199686,
0.0681918859,
0.0029502197,
0.0088741705,
-0.0048031756,
-0.0358817838,
-0.0592928305,
-0.0019116173,
0.0350901149,
0.0168103706,
-0.0298667513,
0.0392091647,
-0.0834437087,
-0.0297543071,
-0.0007238298,
0.0562020913,
0.0274180826,
0.040522825,
0.0455467738,
0.0811870024,
0.0291473176,
-0.0006790841,
-0.0050074384,
-0.0108207194,
-0.0481691249,
-0.0018062494,
-0.0089819329,
-5.106452887e-33,
-0.0549344122,
-0.0503244363,
0.0189431533,
0.0236721486,
0.0297001749,
0.0052431165,
-0.0176561475,
0.0270577017,
0.0421748497,
-0.0044008642,
0.0089372387,
-0.0347152203,
-0.0005375263,
-0.0046817614,
0.0258179791,
-0.0081670117,
0.0381979384,
0.0284458864,
-0.0514789894,
0.0195010919,
0.0084442468,
0.0272753946,
0.053801734,
-0.0597441941,
0.0161777977,
0.0079590688,
0.0333427601,
-0.0041544433,
0.0467259511,
0.0597487018,
-0.0270765238,
-0.0017852586,
0.0238369405,
0.0131659564,
-0.0278850291,
0.0178093202,
-0.0964953601,
-0.0311787706,
-0.0022397204,
0.0272676256,
0.0154974069,
-0.0241824854,
0.0552241653,
0.0094933063,
-0.0123133408,
0.0369296521,
0.0751855075,
-0.0281989668,
-0.0191406887,
0.0041519837,
-0.0823457763,
0.0375086032,
-0.0184617136,
-0.0161720775,
0.074746035,
0.0090562934,
0.0364408381,
0.0601327643,
-0.0221400298,
0.0136370491,
0.0158888176,
0.0331703387,
0.1052934155,
0.0176531561,
0.0221707765,
0.0327436291,
0.0404637642,
0.0342609435,
-0.016063815,
-0.0112464009,
0.0524716228,
0.088126801,
0.0100133093,
0.0387200303,
0.038618084,
0.0013830303,
-0.0236659851,
0.0617383607,
-0.075487189,
0.0157762505,
0.0032219223,
0.0294698812,
-0.021995306,
0.0085408362,
-0.0503468663,
0.0324367583,
-0.0273387525,
-0.0001890888,
0.0040928251,
0.0323918313,
-0.0078418637,
0.0227788929,
0.002784468,
-0.0340885334,
-0.0304084979,
-0.0451294929,
-0.0150704579,
0.0150181819,
-0.0194681417,
0.0160976611,
-0.0424268395,
-0.0262207799,
-0.0024695119,
-0.0010052713,
0.0325379707,
-0.0377561525,
-0.0029549492,
0.0268254876,
-0.0720452815,
0.0170190204,
-0.0560016073,
-0.041941341,
-0.0218234137,
0.037141785,
0.0308257155,
0.0028741963,
-0.028757507,
-0.0057495637,
0.0063070292,
-0.0358604379,
-0.0374053083,
-0.0080170762,
-0.0308550335,
-0.0093402136,
-0.0132551156,
-0.0178013761,
-0.0292888787,
-0.0121191572,
0.0690130666,
-0.0391357802,
0.003016284,
0.0335952677,
2.662e-7,
0.033590842,
0.0399873517,
0.0165094715,
0.0367807187,
0.0034204246,
0.0291466601,
-0.0441543646,
0.0415242948,
-0.0193448234,
-0.0027216936,
-0.0008130518,
-0.0037370333,
0.0415300168,
0.0021354177,
-0.0966463387,
0.071274206,
-0.0021230611,
-0.0075575323,
-0.0896762684,
-0.0048956545,
0.0332771763,
0.0656934455,
-0.0296471436,
-0.009850529,
-0.018866973,
0.0026845729,
0.0230816379,
-0.067238383,
0.013285297,
0.0219187476,
0.0621862449,
0.0091100754,
-0.0595679544,
0.0118949851,
0.0176944938,
0.002824178,
0.0568869114,
0.0253961273,
0.0032226706,
0.0384074114,
0.0120797064,
-0.0555135943,
-0.022073919,
0.0182858631,
0.0273263976,
-0.0468343869,
0.0466632694,
-0.0414729118,
0.0017155181,
0.0045298156,
0.0035331778,
0.019513851,
0.0304555539,
0.0265341271,
0.0172326658,
-0.0615617558,
0.0329162329,
-0.0627750531,
-0.0134646483,
0.0489419959,
-0.0338566154,
-0.0212631244,
-0.0267066751,
-0.0100600403,
0.0148704099,
-0.0351095423,
-0.0019226663,
2.250205444e-34,
-0.0085876966,
0.0162175372,
-0.0379144289,
0.0671736822,
0.0502287522,
-0.0017797584,
0.0102481181,
0.0164176822,
-0.0339846574,
-0.0515270308,
0.0033578686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12764v1 | Test-Time Adaptation with Perturbation Consistency Learning | 2023-04-25T12:29:22 | 2023-04-25T12:29:22 | Yi Su, Yixin Ji, Juntao Li, Hai Ye, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Currently, pre-trained language models (PLMs) do not cope well with the
distribution shift problem, resulting in models trained on the training set
failing in real test scenarios. To address this problem, the test-time
adaptation (TTA) shows great potential, which updates model parameters to suit
the test data at the testing time. Existing TTA methods rely on well-designed
auxiliary tasks or self-training strategies based on pseudo-label. However,
these methods do not achieve good trade-offs regarding performance gains and
computational costs. To obtain some insights into such a dilemma, we take two
representative TTA methods, i.e., Tent and OIL, for exploration and find that
stable prediction is the key to achieving a good balance. Accordingly, in this
paper, we propose perturbation consistency learning (PCL), a simple test-time
adaptation method to promote the model to make stable predictions for samples
with distribution shifts. Extensive experiments on adversarial robustness and
cross-lingual transferring demonstrate that our method can achieve higher or
comparable performance with less inference time over strong PLM backbones and
previous state-of-the-art TTA methods. | [
0.0187729094,
0.1120805442,
-0.0191044435,
-0.0091490299,
-0.0068429932,
0.002848872,
-0.0353467949,
-0.0152725009,
-0.0222218931,
-0.0244142916,
-0.0531880036,
-0.0502121039,
-0.0326852575,
0.0239985473,
0.0330333151,
-0.0275379792,
0.0575611331,
-0.0174963363,
-0.026477227,
-0.0009511107,
0.0053584222,
-0.0157893188,
-0.0178949945,
-0.0159779452,
0.0129201328,
0.001195661,
-0.0092166914,
0.0019589677,
0.0194833465,
-0.0339204073,
0.0295138564,
0.0714989454,
0.0367308818,
0.0284109879,
0.0000022441,
-0.0312680788,
-0.0415906869,
-0.0235113092,
0.0026956231,
0.0274258871,
0.0428543128,
-0.0275788587,
-0.0189176593,
0.0467123613,
-0.0569549203,
-0.0358565077,
0.0493296534,
-0.0166424569,
0.0292737614,
0.0963114128,
-0.0119584594,
0.0227470119,
-0.0386705026,
-0.0632162914,
-0.0223724935,
-0.0879505798,
0.0189467743,
-0.0172434133,
-0.0170204323,
-0.0247287136,
-0.0401134714,
0.0220554657,
0.0102374256,
-0.0012069009,
-0.0470087789,
0.0247322656,
-0.0423793681,
0.0083752517,
-0.026426537,
0.0675209165,
-0.0465442017,
-0.0671397597,
0.001416598,
-0.0215485413,
-0.0194573775,
0.0235820767,
-0.0226447992,
-0.0322064124,
0.0416374169,
0.0283988733,
0.0175477304,
-0.0158502776,
0.0471521802,
0.011191004,
-0.0923050717,
0.0411941335,
0.0219375063,
-0.0204509385,
0.0017685823,
0.0148251085,
-0.0221398808,
-0.0057112924,
-0.0215112623,
0.0190635026,
-0.0318802334,
0.0064603216,
-0.0646144897,
-0.0552209504,
-0.0114769069,
-0.0146691995,
0.0625114813,
0.026601566,
-0.0678151026,
0.0354113244,
-0.0294005834,
0.0390780568,
-0.0031270881,
0.0858131498,
-0.0393752828,
-0.0004056617,
-0.0354964472,
0.0151435193,
-0.0308291968,
-0.0138997426,
0.0179405455,
0.0030436667,
0.0003923434,
0.051628001,
0.0287992936,
-0.0158045907,
-0.0029975118,
-0.0201931577,
-0.0786292925,
0.0007252967,
0.0063953511,
0.0633978248,
-0.0024839998,
0.0300479606,
-0.0185015332,
-0.0340609774,
-0.0403109193,
0.0575442053,
-0.0068028476,
-0.0169739742,
0.0217207372,
0.0694464594,
-0.0258902479,
-0.0432937294,
-0.0612386353,
0.0663499236,
-0.0262908097,
-0.0538458191,
0.0177215654,
-0.0253084768,
0.0334884748,
-0.0118509401,
0.0038081319,
-0.0789862052,
-0.0174227487,
-0.0268858206,
-0.0100067705,
0.0573392622,
0.0204166062,
0.0027181262,
0.0288998354,
-0.0263108797,
0.0030720895,
0.0770357698,
0.0358666144,
-0.0014739243,
0.0215897802,
-0.0178309027,
-0.0217652433,
0.0630584657,
0.0465800725,
0.0144022461,
-0.0493728593,
-0.0007857233,
0.0166579317,
0.0243553594,
0.0414355285,
0.006133433,
0.0067108134,
-0.0182302091,
0.0587803312,
-0.0149646075,
0.0386504792,
0.0038720449,
0.0202697944,
-0.0108830091,
-0.0287961885,
-0.0061338781,
-0.0586182848,
-0.0117829498,
-0.0249478128,
-0.0138751203,
-0.0002641911,
0.0228791703,
-0.0469045155,
-0.0069564865,
0.0084717795,
-0.0095097562,
0.0268059839,
-0.0051417928,
0.0692028552,
0.0099111749,
-0.0357410908,
0.0687509775,
0.0354718417,
0.0276432671,
0.0302509498,
-0.0391945057,
0.0241661239,
-0.0024502757,
0.0083959922,
-0.0580547713,
-0.0133730555,
0.0004761206,
0.0651685596,
0.0293540414,
0.0648802817,
0.0168704372,
0.0089791091,
-0.0432322361,
0.0004253295,
0.0160132796,
0.0190358888,
0.0722245052,
0.0195266716,
0.0536208153,
0.040157605,
-0.0890630856,
-0.0290811323,
0.0377521627,
-0.0437073782,
-0.0452137701,
0.0403765924,
-0.0062830239,
0.028873466,
-0.0192209445,
-0.0431138985,
-0.00164667,
0.0180503614,
-0.0178228822,
0.0355658494,
0.025337372,
-0.0433137082,
-0.0413289033,
0.0432272814,
0.0263171587,
0.0461095832,
0.0761636421,
-0.0493972786,
-0.0288243406,
0.0488474555,
0.0102235116,
0.0462148935,
-0.0125133777,
0.022877261,
-0.0236238558,
0.0660851821,
-0.0386836715,
0.0202211887,
0.0068996917,
-0.018271951,
-0.0667858347,
0.0500184223,
-0.0047170073,
-0.0123747978,
-0.0124514429,
0.0448703095,
-0.0031399243,
0.0214738064,
0.007680411,
0.0088239601,
-0.0058273263,
0.0054020947,
-0.0488007404,
0.0120865712,
-0.0596353747,
0.0552911945,
0.0354628041,
-0.0244454313,
-0.0262491889,
-0.0388197973,
-0.0260077063,
0.0261860676,
0.0025529643,
-0.0048840065,
0.02083176,
0.0197016113,
0.0243755188,
-0.0547023974,
0.0059310552,
-0.002281101,
0.0722766742,
-0.0596303567,
-0.0332438126,
-0.0562511757,
-0.0024131888,
-0.0312217139,
0.0389670394,
-0.0302965492,
-0.0285759922,
-0.0410132669,
-0.0051734187,
0.0299815387,
0.0414216034,
0.0398017429,
0.013798546,
0.0347184576,
0.0181097835,
-0.0327742435,
0.0040145828,
-0.0109169008,
-0.0446963534,
-0.0340833887,
-0.008156159,
0.0113518666,
0.0502407104,
-0.0153743075,
-0.008633255,
-0.0503539555,
-0.008740671,
-0.0178789347,
-0.0199783426,
0.0366627574,
0.0542948097,
-0.0377155803,
-0.0275573153,
-0.0259163268,
-0.0400773995,
0.073171027,
-0.0402745828,
0.0003561089,
-0.0784305409,
-0.0511110462,
-0.0126463324,
0.0340438895,
0.0134858983,
-0.0137708094,
-0.0073799011,
-0.0048829354,
-0.0584117137,
-0.0304833837,
0.0261236262,
-0.0116636995,
0.0208417531,
-0.0344155841,
0.0258338265,
-0.0057179206,
-0.0003160106,
-0.0321503542,
-0.0884456262,
0.0023197024,
0.0034213893,
-0.015288352,
-0.0118745342,
-0.0400223956,
0.0222710278,
0.0026559746,
0.0876418054,
-0.015466026,
0.0307222158,
-0.0108937826,
0.0128278816,
0.0512080565,
0.030516848,
0.0206800867,
-0.0429459028,
-0.000489429,
0.0097714923,
0.0080559682,
0.0159055926,
-0.0348914526,
0.001651003,
-0.0042410041,
-0.0018745036,
-0.0240033213,
0.0130532542,
0.0284455102,
-0.0084606437,
-0.0233449116,
0.0616873764,
0.0210318975,
-0.0042119687,
0.0252774488,
-0.00988831,
0.06824065,
0.0090783909,
0.0538201891,
-0.079446353,
-0.016514698,
-0.0191249233,
0.0434674397,
0.0382454917,
-0.0284400582,
-0.0255692303,
-0.0795977265,
-0.0125197126,
0.0262797009,
-0.0861169919,
0.0006056983,
-0.0431564674,
0.0253817178,
-0.0339498594,
0.0482416674,
-0.0054833642,
0.0062419046,
-0.006388972,
0.0491276085,
0.0125297289,
-0.0760350302,
0.0152283683,
-0.0455148369,
0.0185668059,
0.0740844607,
-0.006916068,
-0.0279002599,
-0.0289148595,
0.0523837693,
-0.0205174312,
-0.0146244857,
0.0126806097,
0.0038110046,
-0.0120001053,
-0.0278684944,
0.0931531563,
0.0098371124,
-0.0347636715,
0.0165700782,
0.0248916987,
0.0465488583,
0.0150084272,
-0.0436395444,
0.0156391114,
-0.0049817702,
0.0310668182,
0.0353979245,
-0.0100934198,
-0.07471852,
-0.0115436632,
0.0084503675,
-0.025870122,
-0.0154136317,
-0.0129429549,
0.0140818227,
-0.0286026169,
-0.0183875412,
-0.0618970543,
-0.0035548983,
-0.0162317175,
0.0627399981,
0.0126344273,
0.002588904,
-0.0636440665,
-0.0148277804,
-0.0392031856,
0.0328769758,
-0.0208648294,
-0.0032851268,
-0.0636225939,
-0.0226735119,
0.0508616306,
-0.0026040426,
0.0033727591,
-0.0132896099,
-0.0629555732,
-0.0824708715,
0.0098885037,
0.0405885279,
0.0057298634,
0.0327367708,
-0.0081003411,
-0.0191212427,
0.0494527072,
0.0660678521,
0.0019619446,
0.0500858165,
0.0529820584,
-0.0656678677,
-0.0031748661,
0.0265747793,
-0.0457354896,
0.0242537241,
0.0198247116,
0.0247425269,
0.0121890353,
-0.0255672783,
-0.0102746394,
-0.0188199468,
0.0553612337,
-0.0000819008,
-0.0405727625,
-0.0145657705,
0.032412298,
-0.0005816517,
0.0018071868,
-0.0109770158,
-0.0101699028,
0.0264410079,
0.0098227803,
-0.0072224028,
0.030401662,
-0.005435443,
0.0393223614,
-0.0368596353,
-0.0062441989,
0.0279365983,
0.0305339284,
0.018984884,
0.0182098038,
0.0130877029,
-0.023691101,
0.01217655,
0.0556848533,
-0.022182906,
0.0236648172,
0.0430357419,
-0.0128013846,
-0.0150236282,
0.0021376796,
-0.0388116501,
-0.0349168293,
-0.078805998,
0.0143161351,
0.0492146797,
-0.0367391035,
0.0433631316,
-0.0126020545,
0.0001663917,
-0.0229691043,
-0.0025963155,
-0.0140491771,
0.0051343399,
0.0326669142,
-0.0070682266,
0.0034747273,
0.0637349933,
0.0478835665,
0.0778429359,
0.0433068648,
-0.0112214191,
0.0285975002,
-0.035288699,
0.0270286426,
0.0137107503,
0.0087523442,
-0.0078858566,
0.021550009,
0.0029128117,
-0.0681676492,
0.0323265828,
0.0049991938,
-0.00458421,
0.0218263809,
0.0107451389,
0.0762776881,
-0.0286046583,
0.0281987339,
-0.0176967066,
-0.0274021327,
0.0591425523,
-0.0155942058,
0.0099864071,
-7.120610662e-33,
-0.0486003608,
0.0110465195,
0.016824143,
-0.0706643537,
0.0041096671,
-0.0240168907,
-0.0378249139,
0.0000672994,
-0.0324713662,
-0.0224803668,
-0.011868488,
0.0155815734,
0.0184990708,
0.0306051318,
-0.0297351889,
-0.016681103,
0.037861336,
-0.0117329536,
-0.0554573052,
-0.0050845849,
0.000647896,
0.0689837933,
0.1008383632,
-0.0756040141,
-0.0341680311,
0.0307561811,
-0.0005853144,
-0.018053405,
-0.0077241971,
0.0202811603,
0.0226052739,
0.0239672158,
0.0094347196,
-0.0239299126,
-0.0167949051,
-0.0095460601,
-0.0537349284,
-0.0460337996,
0.0106641017,
0.0265709925,
0.001057585,
0.0354173332,
0.0132588418,
-0.0434868895,
0.0388491713,
0.0037276766,
0.0058921268,
-0.0285247415,
-0.0315354168,
0.0009665201,
-0.0403899997,
0.0404368751,
0.0185870677,
-0.0092220055,
0.0099370135,
0.0545322262,
0.0049866983,
0.0108273942,
-0.049303893,
0.0000890916,
0.0167222526,
0.0458304733,
0.0661511123,
0.034484107,
-0.0093793599,
0.0343948118,
-0.0132373963,
-0.0053576734,
0.0386803783,
-0.0633351207,
0.0716214776,
-0.0294505544,
0.0061986195,
0.0576807,
0.036551971,
-0.0437171198,
-0.0896975547,
0.0088349488,
0.0220964421,
-0.0281259939,
0.0137263071,
0.0429895446,
-0.0403076969,
-0.0158716571,
-0.0360411555,
-0.0394325219,
-0.0099049713,
-0.0506564267,
0.0488347299,
0.0323983841,
-0.0514452159,
0.0149045968,
0.0342509188,
-0.0533579849,
-0.032085456,
0.0086875744,
-0.0678476319,
-0.0222642906,
-0.0197796803,
0.0484783128,
-0.0603183061,
-0.0677205622,
0.0282738078,
-0.0141725177,
0.0088438848,
-0.0201114714,
0.0223649908,
0.0393951423,
-0.0612562262,
-0.0058421963,
0.0053950753,
0.0198660959,
0.0258042943,
0.0302695557,
0.0240747016,
-0.0005575996,
0.006394668,
0.0390211903,
0.0464645587,
-0.0788819417,
-0.00204501,
0.0603589602,
0.0089094769,
0.0525969006,
-0.0433080271,
-0.0039195563,
0.0065692691,
0.0213515051,
-0.0109659508,
-0.0972633436,
-0.0035018297,
-0.0117888935,
3.01e-7,
0.047873538,
0.0506496131,
-0.0104772449,
-0.0331399888,
0.0054829386,
-0.0188490562,
-0.0416789763,
0.060566172,
-0.0188345201,
-0.0078346441,
0.0395120904,
0.0272768177,
0.0331621915,
0.0227731206,
-0.064488478,
-0.0403866284,
-0.0586097836,
0.045356866,
-0.0494805612,
-0.0363916345,
0.0233946741,
0.1271459758,
0.017830329,
-0.0121316677,
0.0048675286,
-0.0552610494,
0.0640001595,
-0.0147020658,
0.0280095637,
0.0148044275,
0.0242488794,
0.0193282254,
-0.0361168049,
0.0243517701,
-0.0435675941,
0.0666799545,
-0.0033805734,
0.0320374854,
0.0125933001,
-0.0559924021,
0.0102874544,
0.0243902393,
0.0076195956,
-0.0544988289,
0.0673046559,
-0.05699981,
-0.0167006254,
-0.0045473552,
-0.0389718562,
-0.0097314576,
0.0150389504,
-0.0197342578,
-0.0219721422,
0.0094901072,
0.0530713759,
0.0371505059,
-0.0680401921,
-0.0640119612,
-0.0058405036,
0.0675916523,
-0.039316576,
0.0014239856,
-0.0497330762,
-0.0421926044,
0.0043024719,
-0.0614024214,
0.0521988608,
2.545253837e-34,
0.0370232165,
-0.0324766897,
-0.0093582151,
-0.0135345031,
0.0167518407,
0.0002309464,
0.0805470347,
-0.0132005652,
0.0035134209,
-0.0334548913,
0.0013077076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12730v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12730v2 | CitePrompt: Using Prompts to Identify Citation Intent in Scientific Papers | 2023-04-25T11:19:52 | 2023-05-03T11:47:55 | Avishek Lahiri, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal, Imon Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Citations in scientific papers not only help us trace the intellectual
lineage but also are a useful indicator of the scientific significance of the
work. Citation intents prove beneficial as they specify the role of the
citation in a given context. In this paper, we present CitePrompt, a framework
which uses the hitherto unexplored approach of prompt-based learning for
citation intent classification. We argue that with the proper choice of the
pretrained language model, the prompt template, and the prompt verbalizer, we
can not only get results that are better than or comparable to those obtained
with the state-of-the-art methods but also do it with much less exterior
information about the scientific document. We report state-of-the-art results
on the ACL-ARC dataset, and also show significant improvement on the SciCite
dataset over all baseline models except one. As suitably large labelled
datasets for citation intent classification can be quite hard to find, in a
first, we propose the conversion of this task to the few-shot and zero-shot
settings. For the ACL-ARC dataset, we report a 53.86% F1 score for the
zero-shot setting, which improves to 63.61% and 66.99% for the 5-shot and
10-shot settings, respectively. | [
0.0451374352,
-0.0046969596,
0.0166505259,
-0.0148458742,
-0.0159559827,
-0.01956461,
0.0553567335,
-0.0057416754,
0.0474421047,
-0.0429489277,
-0.0518027693,
0.0609699599,
-0.0177002922,
-0.0011734123,
-0.0147342551,
-0.0075616292,
0.0451339558,
0.0169724301,
0.0970973596,
0.0272810776,
-0.0273658764,
0.0181850027,
0.0003626488,
0.0236027688,
0.0678278729,
-0.0753091574,
0.0197761096,
-0.0190083366,
0.044471398,
-0.0440280773,
0.0280832518,
0.0635189712,
-0.0038615696,
0.0186656658,
0.0000017782,
-0.0767646581,
-0.0093935439,
-0.0079275128,
-0.0274679419,
0.0306739211,
0.0433771871,
-0.0102532702,
0.0408255979,
-0.0193550866,
-0.028046703,
0.0123831052,
-0.0041142474,
0.0375671238,
0.0244936403,
0.0000417189,
-0.0047130487,
-0.0338279828,
0.0247459114,
0.0122056846,
0.0303033646,
-0.00823233,
0.0515004024,
-0.0290552825,
0.0388669297,
0.0952895656,
0.0311902985,
0.0350414664,
-0.0275955591,
-0.0480685644,
0.0642551705,
0.0022075844,
0.0288743116,
0.0146000953,
0.0208627786,
0.0393753722,
-0.0036445837,
-0.0163114704,
0.0377524123,
-0.0281117205,
-0.0213631149,
0.0358782336,
-0.0042166114,
-0.0053259311,
-0.0195126403,
-0.0576925948,
0.0444794595,
0.0185738839,
0.0224280227,
0.046318084,
0.0114281811,
0.0389254913,
0.0051652868,
-0.0218271594,
0.0223308075,
-0.0032229982,
0.0358771048,
-0.044755999,
-0.0085391141,
0.0474540517,
-0.0247384477,
-0.0015489493,
-0.0004267555,
-0.0159389339,
0.0533241443,
0.0300781876,
-0.0093905013,
-0.0202198233,
-0.0215918217,
0.0619787723,
-0.0048291921,
-0.0121160084,
-0.0155914482,
-0.0370464101,
0.0101039689,
0.0100923376,
-0.0476543605,
-0.0080949049,
-0.0003431203,
-0.0051529608,
-0.0219752397,
-0.0134627353,
-0.0472976938,
0.0192633104,
-0.0185967628,
-0.009309276,
-0.0001273978,
-0.0233270358,
-0.0228516404,
0.0501866378,
0.0012559076,
0.0242487025,
-0.0233146474,
0.0521077812,
-0.032772325,
-0.016249245,
-0.0276758596,
0.0166544076,
0.0196276624,
-0.0522388071,
0.0153483376,
0.0093447063,
0.0263417084,
-0.0436181128,
-0.0425872952,
-0.0616392754,
0.0163926501,
-0.0468894243,
0.0012730991,
-0.0229947791,
0.0273749586,
0.0129158925,
-0.0028654307,
-0.0409154706,
-0.0217716619,
0.0229756404,
-0.0137721226,
0.0372250862,
-0.0512139946,
-0.052695889,
0.0047376011,
-0.0035106093,
0.0105372882,
0.0115348939,
-0.0061307284,
-0.0111180032,
0.0303991716,
0.0226512551,
0.0096560614,
-0.021238979,
0.0522610098,
0.0314327069,
0.075428471,
-0.0088895904,
-0.0218300112,
0.0454099216,
0.0074741011,
0.0192623734,
-0.0296740402,
-0.0217624716,
0.0064245365,
0.008663361,
-0.0220702216,
-0.0110359285,
0.0698196366,
0.0217957031,
0.0329710022,
-0.0166077185,
0.0109964656,
-0.0039258865,
-0.0315761827,
0.0265280195,
0.0126413405,
-0.0147427684,
-0.0139179332,
-0.0089175766,
0.0146258995,
-0.0003298369,
-0.0308777504,
-0.0151785687,
0.0437092856,
0.0070849024,
-0.0332246535,
0.0244467501,
0.0066295001,
-0.0164854359,
0.0208808519,
-0.0060260659,
0.0856170878,
-0.0457768627,
0.042092938,
-0.0415889956,
-0.0163862519,
-0.0619568862,
-0.0122336401,
0.0166480877,
-0.0278569367,
-0.0344859883,
0.0075293896,
-0.0187190436,
-0.0381929241,
-0.0148224039,
0.0008799212,
-0.018827958,
-0.0072742021,
0.001445762,
-0.0193997677,
-0.013215228,
-0.0328264311,
0.0420604236,
-0.0201945417,
-0.0512773469,
0.0112616755,
-0.0117618712,
0.0533231571,
0.0402055867,
-0.0100748772,
0.0039924397,
0.0604127124,
-0.0115375714,
0.0372867323,
0.0388700999,
0.0035223286,
-0.0051113162,
0.0358635746,
-0.0065163975,
-0.0049344501,
-0.0309319142,
-0.0267016813,
-0.0307389516,
0.0172099844,
-0.000261215,
-0.029894311,
-0.0185432099,
-0.0137542989,
-0.0118640875,
0.0169400871,
-0.0488966294,
0.0628062338,
0.0276388284,
0.0811299756,
0.1128918901,
-0.0046704845,
0.0473324098,
0.0092951301,
-0.0385371856,
-0.0300506856,
0.0104737235,
-0.0604746342,
0.0501133204,
-0.0094850902,
-0.0377569459,
0.0373344161,
-0.0295414552,
0.0060898424,
0.0150701078,
-0.0036682109,
-0.0051323203,
-0.0035545805,
0.0148765752,
0.0045701014,
0.0271103326,
-0.0362710021,
-0.0466730483,
-0.0150166024,
0.0766710863,
0.0063860542,
0.0197214466,
-0.0237940643,
0.0059866044,
-0.0427034013,
0.0286572147,
0.0766700953,
0.0279154703,
-0.0728876591,
0.0219836198,
0.0077751935,
-0.0264062434,
-0.0254854951,
0.0237874519,
0.0177149065,
-0.0105895763,
-0.0039986297,
0.0748188943,
0.0134183858,
0.0257904194,
0.0317851491,
0.0423595123,
-0.0863109156,
-0.0018405201,
-0.0121768769,
-0.0144099807,
-0.0134612601,
-0.0185140092,
0.0514742546,
0.0546349101,
-0.0101416698,
-0.018549189,
-0.012770595,
-0.0233057067,
0.0053113587,
0.0061961655,
-0.0375278182,
-0.0042740526,
-0.0058805174,
0.0504221171,
0.0583097562,
-0.0128817372,
0.0595516562,
-0.0319631174,
-0.0268622935,
-0.0728273913,
0.0193926953,
-0.0416294374,
0.0216612164,
0.0015818423,
-0.0281374417,
0.0779000446,
-0.0006077762,
-0.0192593746,
-0.001491537,
0.0033029942,
0.0041190642,
-0.0184938218,
-0.0166955609,
0.0125527726,
-0.0255877059,
0.0130446348,
-0.0177528914,
-0.0581504181,
-0.0322606973,
0.0371021852,
0.0248551946,
-0.035314858,
-0.0176307522,
-0.0157743953,
0.0551990941,
0.031749174,
-0.0273527037,
-0.045630239,
-0.0353296027,
0.0403660052,
0.0648682415,
-0.0283029731,
0.0111670699,
0.0124595631,
-0.0276249759,
0.0281348098,
-0.0031097599,
0.0095179342,
-0.0546405651,
-0.0225391351,
0.0279013831,
-0.0785897896,
-0.0038388923,
-0.0050470498,
0.0623091757,
-0.0220110528,
0.0127732707,
0.0978580788,
0.034827292,
-0.0631654859,
-0.0415023379,
-0.0134636723,
-0.0071634371,
0.0222675242,
0.0213057511,
-0.1037041619,
-0.0290829167,
-0.0332427174,
0.0146758417,
-0.0346675292,
-0.0463201664,
-0.0026852002,
-0.0884184912,
0.0261212979,
-0.0424904823,
0.0298151802,
-0.0071327556,
-0.0866381228,
0.0282439906,
-0.030612953,
-0.062805675,
-0.0000727281,
-0.0303304978,
0.005738196,
0.019914642,
0.0049445019,
-0.0476725884,
0.0376301482,
-0.035019502,
0.0237609651,
-0.011928481,
0.0654924139,
0.0029282018,
-0.0372674242,
-0.0118771354,
-0.0922792479,
-0.0285605621,
-0.028807858,
0.024304701,
0.0084580854,
0.039122656,
0.0040894672,
0.0574232526,
-0.0272619966,
-0.0170174297,
0.0536354035,
0.0724146813,
-0.0224258024,
0.0327328295,
-0.0692382604,
0.029846916,
0.0392564982,
0.0688605532,
0.019156523,
-0.0163052604,
-0.035912659,
-0.0151360817,
0.027170904,
-0.0369288847,
-0.0524036959,
-0.02984819,
-0.0609415658,
0.0098501612,
-0.0589135438,
-0.029493846,
-0.0078815417,
0.0024708139,
0.0382505096,
0.03115502,
-0.0050784191,
0.0092586763,
-0.0374661237,
0.0349919945,
0.000920978,
0.0258716494,
-0.0073712938,
-0.0074670925,
0.0651306957,
-0.0113271652,
-0.0300581027,
0.0229713377,
0.0560285337,
-0.0060037598,
-0.0104980376,
0.0066603716,
0.0177456401,
0.0258148275,
-0.0500521921,
-0.0078511881,
0.0494121574,
0.0736559555,
-0.0123427594,
-0.0155916037,
0.0395182371,
-0.0021397541,
-0.043577265,
-0.0278967489,
-0.0377309658,
0.0341329165,
-0.0198361371,
-0.0200840421,
-0.0737071112,
-0.0379273221,
0.0122504961,
0.0198761672,
0.08627671,
-0.0345576108,
-0.0079327598,
-0.0097112656,
-0.025579473,
0.0187665746,
-0.0177707952,
-0.0040852902,
0.0183696225,
-0.0058743069,
-0.0199762695,
-0.0357812196,
0.0295050889,
-0.0428249352,
0.0425735191,
-0.0354774967,
0.0258604605,
0.0127499457,
0.068280749,
-0.0336711183,
-0.0282941833,
-0.0333049037,
-0.0267710276,
-0.0154441576,
0.0415294468,
0.0190289374,
0.0660636052,
0.0436883867,
0.0306123011,
0.0293172561,
-0.003780748,
-0.1299622506,
0.0377679244,
0.0039506,
-0.0383840352,
0.0304468423,
-0.0177610591,
0.0441257581,
-0.0301796608,
-0.0258745495,
-0.0266443714,
0.0690304637,
-0.0032984184,
0.0171233825,
0.0561205894,
0.005055469,
-0.0107134013,
-0.003054152,
0.0181700736,
0.0057114097,
0.0272466335,
0.0063492036,
-0.0256405417,
-0.0395355783,
-0.0301600769,
-0.0595708415,
0.0252826344,
0.0072062574,
0.0012381236,
-0.0425279364,
0.0200164746,
0.0729028136,
-0.0095743341,
-0.0048840255,
-0.0220384393,
0.0210019238,
0.01057625,
-0.0148913218,
-0.0470695123,
-0.0690844581,
0.0752143189,
-0.0096416222,
-0.0742707103,
-0.0693726465,
-5.439621414e-33,
-0.0098983841,
-0.0279613994,
0.0027802901,
0.0126510216,
-0.0064802794,
0.0195308607,
-0.0646164939,
-0.0506069548,
-0.0640102252,
0.021576006,
-0.0368047208,
-0.0029660936,
0.0008060385,
-0.0010602243,
0.0405596159,
0.0093563478,
0.0321476273,
0.0015607551,
-0.010810216,
0.0410238542,
0.0479861386,
-0.002906746,
0.014837279,
-0.128222093,
0.0924259201,
-0.0383844376,
-0.0335965082,
-0.023152288,
0.0183257349,
0.0486690328,
-0.0294109304,
-0.0017312519,
-0.0073579527,
-0.0543450937,
0.034206409,
-0.0025480667,
-0.094620727,
-0.0266602952,
0.0225365907,
-0.0183286499,
-0.0571521521,
-0.0686571673,
-0.019092286,
-0.0085132476,
-0.0387014709,
-0.0337259881,
0.0906188488,
-0.0060782968,
-0.0227151755,
-0.0973903462,
-0.045760043,
0.0061561777,
-0.017762851,
0.0367228836,
-0.0003649922,
0.075893715,
0.000811636,
0.1183487549,
-0.0516979881,
0.0171857122,
-0.0111348694,
0.0144579504,
-0.0257021561,
-0.0244186055,
0.029819442,
0.0171941109,
-0.0043540457,
-0.0608072914,
0.0318167359,
-0.0194700621,
0.0039824555,
0.0041237967,
0.051856041,
0.0806081668,
0.023648398,
0.0317965858,
-0.044446636,
0.0276524648,
0.0625092834,
0.0306458753,
0.0337374583,
-0.0277809482,
0.0360514894,
0.0132445414,
0.0158133078,
-0.0551883057,
-0.0083379997,
-0.0031570285,
-0.0304529313,
-0.0009416759,
-0.0063395575,
0.0418494977,
0.0393908136,
-0.0238741245,
-0.0417506583,
0.0914532617,
0.0152887525,
0.051651895,
0.0291902851,
-0.0312728882,
-0.0722508132,
-0.0263076816,
0.0130132241,
-0.0017178971,
0.0342129618,
0.0179748163,
0.0243257768,
-0.014613675,
-0.0118644089,
-0.0482995883,
0.0057721343,
0.0121366773,
-0.0430225879,
0.0079655536,
-0.0103221163,
0.0516513884,
0.0123444516,
0.0383341387,
0.0429618321,
0.0207098108,
0.0164581519,
0.0023029277,
0.0118452953,
0.0317223817,
-0.0067849085,
-0.0420595109,
0.0328492746,
0.0763938725,
-0.0487459004,
-0.0679403543,
0.0227449071,
-0.0178996585,
2.558e-7,
0.0510253571,
0.004637389,
-0.0083303507,
-0.0009420447,
-0.0070984061,
0.0272107143,
0.004418375,
0.0142772635,
0.0257936064,
0.045636937,
0.0127503658,
-0.0625697896,
0.0018133634,
-0.0236749072,
-0.117748037,
-0.0311444253,
-0.0547794625,
-0.0329806469,
-0.0309749842,
0.0278829876,
0.0113900304,
0.0304834936,
-0.0060810689,
0.0029213722,
0.0132747544,
-0.0117813721,
0.0250124261,
-0.041317381,
0.0299971364,
0.0291986056,
0.0467903614,
-0.0336570293,
0.001139011,
0.0276415329,
-0.0304677673,
0.0135654267,
-0.0357545838,
0.047383029,
0.034621425,
-0.0111229615,
0.0176101513,
-0.0246285517,
0.0645083785,
-0.0379166827,
0.0360909142,
0.0009586694,
0.0005961054,
-0.026363967,
-0.0732108504,
0.0031242138,
0.0118496884,
-0.0069194585,
-0.0006348008,
0.0179647841,
-0.0386348553,
-0.000937803,
-0.0229060166,
-0.0733739436,
0.0063408092,
0.038248308,
-0.011839116,
-0.0341718905,
0.0210656784,
-0.0554166734,
0.0204658303,
-0.06902989,
0.0219599251,
2.119374759e-34,
0.0449587852,
-0.0305303093,
0.0006751993,
0.0330124311,
0.0100687994,
0.0140426718,
-0.021509517,
0.0425615981,
0.0618270002,
-0.052171424,
0.003741194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12706v1 | What does BERT learn about prosody? | 2023-04-25T10:34:56 | 2023-04-25T10:34:56 | Sofoklis Kakouros, Johannah O'Mahony | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have become nearly ubiquitous in natural language processing
applications achieving state-of-the-art results in many tasks including
prosody. As the model design does not define predetermined linguistic targets
during training but rather aims at learning generalized representations of the
language, analyzing and interpreting the representations that models implicitly
capture is important in bridging the gap between interpretability and model
performance. Several studies have explored the linguistic information that
models capture providing some insights on their representational capacity.
However, the current studies have not explored whether prosody is part of the
structural information of the language that models learn. In this work, we
perform a series of experiments on BERT probing the representations captured at
different layers. Our results show that information about prosodic prominence
spans across many layers but is mostly focused in middle layers suggesting that
BERT relies mostly on syntactic and semantic information. | [
0.0166519843,
0.0221863072,
-0.0183522198,
0.0067414474,
-0.0211697016,
-0.0155682107,
-0.0195063949,
-0.0491785407,
-0.0663365275,
0.0003297681,
-0.0651968941,
-0.0334741063,
0.0189634133,
0.0221061986,
0.0516373441,
-0.0670501888,
0.0278614108,
-0.0305962823,
0.0684955716,
-0.0217673872,
0.0235016551,
-0.0200604927,
-0.0419870764,
0.0605791286,
-0.0165878832,
-0.0044550467,
-0.023665173,
0.018676281,
-0.0079325559,
0.0245470777,
0.0009048323,
0.0610584095,
0.015885219,
0.0156734791,
0.0000015012,
-0.0349358991,
0.01227115,
-0.0243596919,
-0.0346234068,
0.0640400052,
-0.016089322,
0.0222476088,
-0.0624798089,
0.0007826827,
-0.0170912687,
0.0146915168,
0.0504637919,
-0.0020156277,
-0.011136896,
0.0351203158,
-0.0144560412,
-0.0229475684,
0.0195860434,
-0.0185124241,
-0.0293282717,
0.0268815327,
0.0136588374,
-0.0626344085,
-0.009774196,
-0.0351784118,
-0.0291081183,
0.0158661921,
-0.0087409643,
0.040006239,
0.0234029684,
0.0323057026,
-0.0475673415,
-0.0560721532,
-0.0065076053,
0.027264623,
0.0019779496,
-0.0112712337,
-0.0254900511,
0.0268934499,
-0.0047174897,
-0.0113661084,
0.0066979025,
0.0255608242,
0.0170445666,
0.0150434598,
0.009551255,
-0.0182008613,
0.0208519343,
-0.0219301283,
-0.0357882716,
0.045410011,
0.0321660377,
-0.041025456,
0.0041510048,
-0.0189740155,
-0.0477679968,
0.0055863103,
0.0652511492,
-0.0083673699,
0.0036176445,
0.0068255505,
0.0148492353,
0.0021587096,
0.0310461987,
-0.0311998781,
0.0345701091,
0.0163947772,
-0.0865803584,
-0.0167670064,
-0.0395602584,
0.0543172807,
-0.0128949396,
0.0180894025,
-0.0239835046,
0.0041100685,
-0.0442733914,
-0.0414398424,
-0.0461909473,
0.0301616825,
0.0185627397,
-0.0290365964,
-0.0095209423,
-0.0027724078,
-0.0315463655,
-0.0040529575,
-0.0340484269,
0.0272261985,
-0.0528520346,
0.0407973342,
-0.0076079727,
0.0748218819,
-0.0512822717,
0.0540171042,
-0.031370081,
-0.0387479626,
0.0158078019,
0.0068164687,
0.0269386005,
0.0198427308,
0.0037841212,
0.0042808997,
0.0182141997,
-0.017467197,
-0.0305436999,
0.0058301883,
-0.0712695792,
-0.0261023548,
-0.0011081785,
-0.0296868589,
-0.019482445,
0.0047030332,
-0.0033513806,
-0.005855931,
-0.0254620612,
-0.0206605792,
0.0106812567,
0.0615360327,
-0.0062096552,
0.0278554671,
0.0047240546,
0.0117213055,
0.0025893182,
0.0680667087,
0.0393237993,
0.0108528882,
0.0071445638,
-0.0324731804,
-0.0444493964,
0.0471632257,
0.0213842466,
-0.0060605784,
-0.0457592085,
-0.0146662984,
-0.0206041932,
0.0176064875,
0.0497318581,
0.0241008606,
-0.0239441618,
-0.0456860363,
0.0754374713,
0.0949268043,
0.0014977554,
0.029953545,
0.0084599359,
0.0125040757,
0.0405508727,
0.0392110087,
-0.032131996,
-0.0235270988,
-0.0189749785,
0.0156028429,
-0.0241320506,
0.0145096108,
-0.0382738449,
0.0213218331,
-0.0189447254,
-0.0075038639,
-0.0541896708,
-0.0262179505,
0.0395156369,
0.0493610688,
-0.051171463,
0.0919789821,
0.0174502432,
-0.0346556567,
0.0104920669,
-0.0427013226,
0.0236311704,
0.0446499996,
0.0022472867,
-0.0325743146,
-0.0095725888,
0.0191484354,
-0.0305495821,
0.0496811606,
0.0148264561,
-0.0124612246,
0.0648845509,
-0.0199391153,
-0.0116526242,
-0.0145982616,
0.0442757457,
0.0454984866,
-0.0379297808,
-0.0325345211,
-0.027644664,
-0.0747894496,
0.0112341521,
0.0143749695,
0.0061288783,
-0.0342441276,
-0.0158044994,
0.020173071,
0.0146408658,
0.0245733988,
-0.0355432592,
0.0411925204,
0.0368003771,
-0.0409366526,
0.0196457133,
0.0360108986,
-0.0720903128,
-0.0360955708,
0.0097114649,
-0.0599517673,
0.0230739284,
0.0437981188,
0.0349718444,
-0.0538573973,
0.0563464798,
-0.0748197213,
0.1044083834,
-0.0412775502,
0.0138151878,
-0.0406798236,
0.0122625204,
0.0089745102,
0.0195036065,
-0.0103460113,
-0.0038791669,
0.0369751789,
0.0452712812,
0.0322354324,
-0.0654263049,
-0.0428657159,
0.0323810428,
-0.0215368606,
0.004801902,
-0.0021458704,
-0.0609520003,
-0.0452184752,
-0.0455299616,
-0.0865280628,
-0.0117064621,
-0.0258214381,
0.0607951246,
0.0373995937,
-0.0246870946,
-0.0061031301,
-0.0125172837,
-0.0104736155,
-0.0482755899,
-0.0442616194,
0.0333073922,
-0.0075735929,
-0.0036516611,
-0.0359266475,
-0.0538848191,
-0.0105221923,
-0.0204711892,
0.0408616923,
-0.0282028783,
0.0264983829,
-0.0185684841,
-0.0831256956,
-0.0138648935,
0.0145208044,
0.0522880889,
-0.0771332011,
0.0373511538,
-0.0188779272,
0.0838399902,
0.0257677492,
-0.0120651219,
0.069400318,
0.0173029676,
-0.036919456,
-0.0186846107,
-0.000074052,
-0.0315866284,
0.030521933,
-0.0460948497,
-0.041789908,
-0.030975353,
0.0834446102,
0.0496076867,
0.0258310735,
-0.0686829612,
-0.0232167244,
-0.0269623622,
-0.0295484047,
0.0141972657,
-0.0357828811,
-0.0418255255,
0.0148982638,
-0.0310084559,
-0.0629743189,
0.0741919354,
-0.0333391614,
-0.04032645,
-0.0531760976,
0.0074594668,
0.0072750063,
0.0400551632,
0.0080071874,
0.0107387649,
-0.0090103708,
-0.0718776956,
-0.0068867612,
0.0089680562,
0.025313152,
-0.0457472876,
-0.0059593292,
-0.0295845587,
-0.0346319973,
0.0227473006,
-0.035377644,
-0.0265211649,
-0.0222895388,
-0.033374764,
0.0660924911,
-0.0015186651,
-0.0263464041,
0.0132791735,
-0.0022016994,
0.0232398454,
-0.0119708339,
-0.0075417203,
0.0210908521,
-0.0146726891,
0.0451903529,
-0.010151403,
0.0351519845,
0.0112169553,
-0.0257656518,
0.0004241662,
-0.0097984606,
0.0597501844,
0.0601820387,
-0.0648605302,
0.0641441494,
0.0387118347,
-0.0157349724,
-0.0247228313,
0.0064922329,
0.0520857796,
-0.0307288337,
0.0028779588,
0.0896327943,
0.030227948,
0.0116609279,
0.0391866267,
0.0025073786,
0.0752846152,
0.0181542281,
-0.004149416,
-0.0218397975,
-0.0146503597,
0.0327458382,
0.0269984622,
-0.0074184565,
0.0228789076,
0.0077399998,
-0.0825768188,
0.0372321121,
-0.0019140646,
-0.0155542744,
-0.0324844308,
-0.0628908798,
0.0137943076,
0.007707709,
0.0230518971,
0.02838175,
-0.0117811272,
-0.0114451731,
0.0358069986,
-0.0392078571,
-0.0440824218,
0.0376024842,
-0.0662507638,
0.0539489314,
0.1016407609,
0.0176434666,
-0.049876105,
-0.0462487526,
-0.0142672556,
-0.0151337301,
-0.0050294972,
0.010698651,
0.0275483485,
0.0535600707,
-0.0262723863,
-0.0519836396,
0.0290402714,
-0.024991557,
0.0039246744,
-0.0448730215,
0.0576995723,
-0.0084837722,
-0.007127462,
0.0071816882,
0.0522724874,
-0.0131215788,
0.0695615858,
0.089842841,
-0.0537841134,
-0.0292110108,
-0.0156571493,
0.0264030918,
-0.0181895364,
0.0206676349,
0.0657713339,
0.0415826887,
-0.044836916,
-0.0572377145,
-0.0343455449,
-0.0091100652,
0.0263382681,
0.0327765457,
-0.028040586,
-0.0251208711,
-0.0124760354,
-0.0287792198,
0.0715571642,
0.0598414429,
0.0383212678,
-0.0497409068,
-0.041233398,
0.0619026348,
-0.0360206626,
-0.0279986784,
-0.0530231334,
-0.0134502426,
-0.0572950915,
0.0495697521,
0.0155588798,
0.0279038511,
0.0089573106,
-0.0281288102,
-0.0748164356,
0.0490445755,
0.0175397787,
-0.0296825804,
0.0233806279,
0.086662136,
-0.0275947526,
-0.0003597168,
0.0511791185,
-0.0223502014,
0.0301585998,
-0.0367709696,
0.0416630954,
0.0419867933,
-0.0417592116,
0.0350480601,
0.0045054336,
0.0465489067,
0.0063819578,
-0.0431811586,
-0.0306846295,
-0.0019096097,
0.0188017562,
0.0565990172,
-0.0119764339,
-0.0102190403,
0.0222551599,
0.0133651858,
-0.0164869633,
0.0113937082,
-0.0227071382,
0.0399141461,
-0.0239134971,
0.0527902506,
0.0432605073,
-0.006518641,
-0.0021544369,
0.0334064513,
-0.0242656227,
0.0541890003,
-0.0310306326,
0.0167833269,
0.0076701348,
0.0214586239,
0.0115480628,
0.0045124781,
-0.0066224188,
-0.0029733283,
-0.0594739355,
-0.0190211274,
0.0003592725,
-0.0008643343,
0.0532506704,
-0.0316980071,
0.0399484001,
-0.0144880563,
0.0254007392,
-0.017556265,
-0.0062922486,
-0.0530575998,
0.0041375896,
0.04961868,
0.0089595057,
0.0011955502,
-0.0097269313,
0.0593181886,
0.0364593156,
0.0509921238,
-0.0355334394,
0.022131104,
-0.0164754484,
-0.0247165021,
0.0252691694,
0.0479279272,
-0.029172739,
0.0213258509,
-0.0465945154,
-0.0636280328,
0.0115028135,
0.004260309,
0.0417655855,
-0.0588044785,
0.0119326934,
0.0322997384,
-0.039536804,
-0.0369235165,
0.0233423598,
-0.023501059,
0.0066778394,
0.0218041129,
0.0227123834,
-5.757934999e-33,
-0.024922898,
0.0009358391,
-0.0330712162,
-0.0219007004,
-0.012989278,
0.0286588855,
-0.0555976965,
0.0047040931,
-0.0257444587,
0.0398135632,
0.0002243613,
0.0031108351,
0.02943689,
0.0116157774,
-0.0041045425,
-0.0079160221,
0.0516588762,
-0.0194448456,
-0.0020175071,
-0.0144972149,
0.0033359625,
0.04494581,
0.0758553594,
-0.003260796,
0.0004119106,
0.0013590785,
-0.0223803427,
-0.004365223,
0.007921217,
0.0653790906,
-0.035685394,
0.0482526757,
0.0074083488,
-0.0183337834,
-0.0375080854,
0.0459873155,
-0.093770802,
-0.0451298431,
0.0423075147,
0.0411106981,
-0.0577925704,
0.0263369214,
0.0550823621,
-0.0099560367,
0.0007969431,
0.0178542491,
0.0158917792,
-0.022886781,
-0.0065268166,
-0.0333135724,
-0.0354115963,
0.0062867594,
-0.0301034041,
-0.0406539515,
0.0576433688,
0.0033941651,
-0.0200472251,
-0.003110911,
-0.0035960814,
-0.0060336036,
0.0279710479,
0.0334010236,
0.0465638861,
0.0508967899,
-0.018508371,
0.0540774502,
0.0580228753,
-0.0272155274,
0.0333636813,
-0.0461855754,
0.0779731497,
0.0573955067,
0.0249965265,
-0.0580485724,
0.0118835671,
0.007732511,
-0.0122743314,
-0.0433960147,
0.0780608207,
-0.0210921839,
0.0153877493,
0.0116010625,
-0.0189583991,
-0.0252490044,
-0.0751666054,
-0.0544510446,
-0.0340420194,
0.0131142577,
0.0298889205,
-0.0291364994,
0.0229387805,
0.0328893326,
0.0319942385,
-0.010900219,
0.0099433744,
0.003126642,
-0.0307667851,
0.0044486369,
0.0135815535,
0.0503595695,
-0.0677999631,
-0.0161993336,
0.0185617767,
0.0174974389,
0.0046541565,
0.0166580435,
-0.0035042595,
0.0346871577,
-0.0323156528,
0.0092302067,
-0.0553506128,
-0.0367346518,
0.0048043183,
0.0271759816,
0.0361754671,
0.0160682853,
-0.0138524855,
0.0440993309,
0.0103025986,
0.0686312988,
-0.0308926553,
0.0242153574,
-0.0151798725,
0.0601948053,
-0.0288727786,
-0.0488849916,
-0.0102231158,
0.0393649079,
0.0094502056,
-0.0440336727,
-0.024884047,
0.0125042377,
2.338e-7,
0.0315862186,
0.0313065201,
0.0787829757,
-0.0100704562,
0.0569709055,
0.0164434016,
-0.0515360981,
0.0321143754,
0.0158469379,
-0.0246946439,
-0.0068704402,
0.0057757832,
0.0684312358,
0.0276081748,
-0.084066622,
-0.0075884713,
-0.076559037,
0.0171667244,
-0.0537148267,
0.0169590414,
0.0231458507,
0.0866348073,
-0.0217581093,
-0.0362544842,
0.0317423642,
-0.0346786901,
0.0499185808,
-0.0242619142,
0.0468803011,
0.0223401673,
0.0369068086,
-0.0058868709,
-0.0083158854,
0.0435573682,
-0.0338023305,
0.049294658,
-0.0280817635,
0.0651423112,
-0.0134188933,
-0.0713483915,
0.0278893765,
-0.0053104265,
-0.042986922,
-0.0243323315,
0.0211076979,
-0.0322170109,
-0.0527943298,
0.0249971282,
-0.0157258548,
-0.0137276473,
-0.001512541,
-0.0407390632,
-0.0244787112,
0.0053910431,
-0.0141076436,
-0.0427951626,
-0.0320656709,
-0.0342553519,
-0.0269606467,
0.029058015,
-0.0656420812,
-0.0322296768,
-0.0304631758,
-0.0312362071,
0.0268323515,
-0.0623908937,
0.0160136241,
1.848436283e-34,
0.0458565615,
-0.0427261591,
0.0128963273,
0.0441810861,
0.0002380464,
-0.0448984988,
0.062882185,
-0.0137113063,
0.0379899964,
-0.052363269,
-0.0212008078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12674v1 | Compressing Sentence Representation with maximum Coding Rate Reduction | 2023-04-25T09:23:43 | 2023-04-25T09:23:43 | Domagoj Ševerdija, Tomislav Prusina, Antonio Jovanović, Luka Borozan, Jurica Maltar, Domagoj Matijević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, 62M45, I.2.7; I.2.0; I.5.3 | In most natural language inference problems, sentence representation is
needed for semantic retrieval tasks. In recent years, pre-trained large
language models have been quite effective for computing such representations.
These models produce high-dimensional sentence embeddings. An evident
performance gap between large and small models exists in practice. Hence, due
to space and time hardware limitations, there is a need to attain comparable
results when using the smaller model, which is usually a distilled version of
the large language model. In this paper, we assess the model distillation of
the sentence representation model Sentence-BERT by augmenting the pre-trained
distilled model with a projection layer additionally learned on the Maximum
Coding Rate Reduction (MCR2)objective, a novel approach developed for
general-purpose manifold clustering. We demonstrate that the new language model
with reduced complexity and sentence embedding size can achieve comparable
results on semantic retrieval benchmarks. | [
0.0061701066,
0.0184136163,
-0.0142897386,
0.0583976358,
-0.0385144092,
0.0301273186,
0.0029796837,
-0.0122134313,
0.0249746088,
-0.036297407,
0.0135957813,
0.021410048,
-0.0246877093,
-0.0158162285,
0.0464121215,
-0.0599529631,
0.0371836983,
-0.0043269782,
0.0235160664,
-0.0152666001,
0.0114302225,
0.0128296688,
0.0112035181,
0.0452492386,
-0.0375242904,
-0.0096050613,
0.0053338734,
0.003481016,
0.0039525176,
-0.0051644649,
0.0154687595,
0.0214444716,
0.0992734283,
0.0226405635,
0.0000018106,
-0.0121375937,
-0.0355643556,
0.003133419,
0.0006757301,
0.0467180535,
0.0209282525,
-0.035717763,
0.050934501,
-0.0108274166,
-0.0027067796,
-0.0456952751,
0.0253584702,
0.0416911468,
0.0672392249,
0.0724160746,
-0.0336487927,
-0.048683282,
-0.0153093059,
0.0031153103,
-0.0431130156,
-0.0382718369,
0.0378737263,
0.0363204964,
0.0032288842,
0.0271463282,
-0.0291951019,
0.0231071543,
0.002262888,
0.0558181852,
0.0372646265,
0.0316899754,
-0.0860257447,
0.0012583081,
0.0181654505,
0.0609667525,
0.0040185223,
-0.0114545729,
0.0146110179,
0.0265286472,
-0.0041457335,
-0.0250501111,
-0.0516886115,
0.0227586217,
0.0208284575,
0.0334462672,
-0.0343438201,
-0.0098831011,
0.0327649787,
-0.0027338821,
-0.0658138841,
0.0311435703,
0.0468213782,
-0.0375899523,
-0.0324281901,
-0.0084916474,
-0.0601949058,
0.0242578145,
0.0256082956,
-0.0287976433,
0.0110612363,
-0.0186690874,
-0.0170899276,
-0.0266218148,
-0.009966122,
-0.06156848,
0.0395433195,
0.0332349986,
0.0270031914,
0.0652654991,
-0.0213629827,
0.0761755332,
-0.0372678898,
0.041549772,
-0.0759272203,
-0.0337876752,
-0.0226346534,
-0.0265417621,
-0.0699377954,
0.0781709254,
-0.0392396189,
-0.0573819131,
-0.0381512605,
0.0244294833,
0.0123127708,
-0.009840115,
0.0048521352,
0.0110473325,
-0.0061993888,
-0.004631965,
-0.0030304966,
0.0244733021,
-0.0254096556,
0.013492804,
-0.0431574695,
-0.0220184065,
-0.0446215868,
0.0311436951,
0.0371519402,
-0.0508551411,
0.0096862298,
0.0105554853,
-0.001518796,
-0.0702369511,
0.0097069303,
-0.0023990683,
-0.0420370027,
-0.0575018898,
-0.0089054825,
-0.0582067855,
0.0351791419,
0.0136122378,
-0.0030530952,
-0.0362015553,
-0.0196253713,
0.000842624,
-0.0409200229,
0.0241151378,
0.0369595625,
0.006594426,
0.028337881,
-0.0043151588,
0.0203469507,
0.063732326,
0.0225323997,
0.0498530455,
0.0406300426,
0.0006292319,
-0.0291457232,
0.0180840492,
0.0204153266,
0.0090458374,
-0.0346104987,
0.0233519748,
0.0287538785,
0.0308409315,
0.0194371957,
0.0767842606,
-0.0815703198,
-0.007725114,
0.0091395956,
0.05129667,
0.0237350222,
0.0166094992,
0.0219074283,
0.0516339727,
-0.0284763798,
-0.0090463804,
-0.0057135122,
0.0092248991,
0.0164889842,
-0.0122484481,
0.1107032821,
-0.0048538833,
-0.0621508472,
0.003315164,
-0.0069631287,
-0.0226691421,
0.0092722736,
0.0023499376,
0.0487741977,
-0.0208351873,
-0.040032886,
0.1172099113,
0.0192449838,
-0.0720934942,
-0.0182536077,
-0.0162390862,
-0.0149416514,
0.014000834,
0.0261597876,
-0.0465880632,
0.0092095481,
0.0249584783,
0.0231496226,
0.001256671,
0.0178543981,
-0.0073679895,
0.0521774068,
-0.0378923826,
-0.0123580936,
-0.0290896557,
0.0218507946,
-0.0075388369,
0.0308530256,
-0.0146154463,
0.0405909158,
-0.0858464465,
-0.002543289,
0.0385319069,
0.0317071714,
-0.0385292955,
0.0108228512,
0.0483416282,
0.021404177,
-0.0044157822,
-0.0238640662,
0.007411663,
0.0592813715,
-0.0647577941,
-0.0180561561,
-0.0236167125,
-0.0500338711,
-0.1467720866,
0.0112889456,
-0.0672083944,
-0.0013575348,
0.0534211174,
-0.0418636501,
-0.0272332504,
0.016331641,
-0.0544656776,
0.0437301993,
-0.0450998694,
-0.0184208713,
-0.0210091844,
-0.0076572066,
-0.0341340303,
0.0399379469,
-0.0173276924,
0.0267421212,
-0.0133730145,
-0.0142817292,
0.0245051757,
-0.0326281153,
-0.0743727311,
-0.0101030376,
0.0044856467,
0.0379173458,
0.03511535,
-0.0479048267,
-0.005298167,
-0.0465016812,
-0.1019435823,
-0.0146872904,
-0.0321408734,
-0.0124127334,
-0.0004124094,
0.0154544553,
0.0138196275,
-0.0250220746,
0.0135708926,
-0.0475232005,
-0.0088529671,
0.0468739048,
0.0182868596,
-0.0198197756,
-0.0306880865,
-0.0178861748,
-0.0359492525,
0.0073767612,
0.0881639645,
-0.0732483342,
-0.0110444315,
-0.0137072382,
0.0115043269,
-0.0218379851,
0.0078868419,
-0.0057120831,
-0.0250760298,
0.0171833038,
-0.0632062927,
0.0646707565,
0.0445110761,
0.0001580746,
0.0249327235,
0.01790151,
0.0007291159,
-0.0290876795,
0.0224947948,
-0.059843421,
0.0217110328,
-0.0191694498,
-0.0259819366,
0.0104515264,
0.0296712592,
0.0304324571,
-0.0042600427,
-0.0726351067,
-0.0309679098,
0.0011358865,
0.0057123709,
-0.0609353557,
0.0074843923,
0.0100152129,
-0.0051649716,
-0.0173363518,
-0.0452147014,
0.040715199,
-0.0320129842,
-0.000357494,
-0.0293563846,
-0.0138571914,
-0.0365923643,
0.0478622615,
0.0276363734,
0.0423532836,
-0.0497561023,
-0.0063572749,
-0.0180240646,
0.0428262204,
0.0149396528,
-0.0039249384,
-0.0053618839,
0.0050922963,
0.0273529682,
0.0078050145,
-0.0427833833,
-0.0060721985,
-0.0725800022,
-0.0151877161,
0.0221401621,
-0.0031784794,
0.0116370507,
-0.0523923337,
0.0241372213,
0.0124215484,
0.0098420558,
-0.011154362,
0.028980799,
-0.0179851074,
0.050853394,
0.0441676266,
0.0069164103,
-0.0377679542,
-0.0408460535,
0.013027126,
0.0345342606,
0.0204869173,
0.0264352877,
-0.0404785648,
0.0206248984,
0.0000745649,
0.0102995094,
-0.0180210155,
0.0178319067,
0.0353980847,
0.0170152951,
-0.0317760892,
0.109051697,
0.0192521662,
-0.0083213998,
-0.0207168926,
0.0442081802,
0.0588257648,
0.02380931,
-0.0087482557,
-0.020877324,
-0.0102279084,
-0.015634371,
-0.0134783238,
0.0459307171,
-0.0005671018,
0.004719255,
-0.0522636995,
0.0178923048,
0.032416556,
-0.0057100258,
-0.0446096957,
-0.0453851819,
-0.0183918942,
0.0107672503,
0.0033133773,
0.0044257883,
0.0093441643,
-0.0090120127,
0.0068717883,
-0.0394487977,
-0.0292388909,
0.0022303252,
-0.016672546,
-0.0188519638,
0.0139188711,
0.0409816056,
0.0010953414,
-0.0301526859,
-0.0046056192,
-0.0069340207,
-0.0130677065,
0.0017507918,
0.0586154088,
-0.021828346,
-0.0057472838,
-0.0165638961,
0.0038110961,
-0.0225270502,
-0.0059790588,
0.0001976924,
0.0835967362,
-0.0041784677,
0.0149673345,
-0.0079687592,
-0.0035626742,
-0.0473905131,
0.07635919,
0.0353136659,
0.0029833594,
-0.0200429149,
0.0364662595,
0.0259216074,
-0.0089699496,
0.0182246044,
0.0195654649,
0.0037435067,
0.020312883,
-0.0432501361,
0.0058856769,
0.025583066,
0.0406670682,
-0.0414055772,
0.0006402168,
0.0225848127,
0.0076131909,
-0.0688937977,
0.0417358577,
-0.0188306198,
-0.0013398135,
-0.0234137606,
0.0003631487,
-0.0010809781,
0.008562522,
-0.0340860076,
-0.0511941873,
-0.0872398242,
-0.0693373755,
-0.0147474371,
0.0369942039,
0.0021181745,
0.0330440626,
-0.0036552842,
-0.0299565811,
0.0397678055,
0.0261356961,
-0.0376297981,
0.0515681505,
0.0190571547,
-0.0089270733,
-0.0310788434,
0.0454783253,
-0.0362130478,
0.0414282605,
0.0121422373,
0.0386736058,
0.0015355943,
-0.0536936671,
0.0131623102,
0.0383947678,
0.0844018981,
0.0086081065,
-0.0002643718,
-0.0184688382,
-0.0109857125,
-0.0332177617,
-0.0177341867,
-0.0155012235,
0.0055679311,
0.0055482774,
0.0117231682,
-0.0393552817,
0.0446014293,
0.023437174,
0.0219061263,
-0.0634102896,
0.0063377111,
-0.0017106256,
-0.0105436062,
0.020734245,
0.0193609856,
-0.0462682284,
-0.0348244645,
-0.0496124476,
-0.0144540817,
-0.0405672863,
0.0012777572,
0.014858989,
0.0082590366,
-0.0800203681,
0.0312512666,
-0.0661360696,
-0.0101623824,
-0.0012455184,
0.0466335937,
0.036792133,
-0.0243930556,
0.0278310627,
0.0190934762,
-0.032351505,
-0.0298480112,
0.0276052281,
0.0290956814,
-0.0111524174,
0.0395139754,
0.0199421216,
-0.0246771965,
0.0033462718,
0.0536040142,
0.0022597758,
0.0135600446,
0.0123996716,
-0.0246284101,
-0.0774464756,
-0.0249182787,
0.0022074762,
0.0635701716,
0.0143639389,
0.023052346,
-0.0018158789,
-0.0387340114,
0.0280141681,
-0.0338800624,
-0.038827382,
-0.0081197917,
0.0343300179,
0.0479845777,
0.0200002696,
-0.0437074006,
-0.0064429464,
0.0162383858,
0.0012358968,
-0.0289019682,
0.0076666614,
-6.387077208e-33,
0.0163426865,
0.0349703059,
-0.0332035236,
-0.0550975241,
-0.0458609797,
0.0322965533,
-0.0117343143,
-0.0183669832,
-0.0065696836,
0.0130986627,
0.0089249471,
0.0209299326,
-0.0016316592,
0.054086104,
-0.0491265766,
0.0367457457,
0.0748338178,
-0.0011482834,
-0.0112352557,
0.0364195593,
0.0369905718,
0.0655278265,
0.0247946903,
0.0128903678,
-0.0679619163,
-0.0384538397,
0.0214848574,
0.0128601417,
0.049030643,
0.0331915356,
-0.0497339107,
0.0463618562,
0.0207377709,
-0.0074321041,
-0.0085365996,
0.0264266338,
-0.0660520345,
-0.0266286079,
-0.0050832578,
-0.0184348244,
-0.0213193279,
-0.0374526419,
0.0356001779,
-0.003194015,
0.0102924854,
-0.0147882216,
0.0391283333,
0.0041917544,
-0.0689579621,
0.0097770141,
-0.0447992086,
0.0346694216,
-0.0138742439,
0.0084860139,
0.0658773556,
0.0409736931,
-0.0073611136,
0.0520017296,
-0.0328886509,
0.010696278,
-0.0376485139,
0.0440048352,
-0.0243777111,
0.0218822267,
0.0229661036,
0.060391698,
0.0071972031,
-0.0102913687,
-0.0630662292,
0.0274041519,
0.0343012661,
0.054637596,
-0.0003626932,
0.052480977,
-0.0138632916,
-0.0228082314,
-0.088996008,
-0.0018303192,
-0.0329796188,
0.0088751381,
0.0860855505,
0.0403787568,
-0.042739559,
-0.0484509617,
-0.0350506753,
0.0060542161,
-0.0298257843,
0.016582571,
0.0402502641,
0.036712788,
-0.011285142,
-0.042831853,
0.0342455097,
-0.0462502427,
0.010897425,
-0.0002174238,
-0.0275768433,
-0.000486159,
0.0126165813,
0.0517599173,
-0.0381631367,
-0.0285229087,
0.0373163074,
0.0176157225,
0.0113393385,
-0.0181932636,
0.0286168382,
0.0106474664,
-0.0449912436,
-0.0189326331,
-0.0242792312,
-0.0972689688,
-0.0328635462,
0.0500082262,
0.0087565714,
0.0440667346,
-0.009563827,
0.042100098,
-0.0107250912,
0.0213736054,
-0.0139337555,
-0.0385570154,
0.0448551886,
0.0360293165,
-0.0122393472,
0.0058950759,
-0.0424973182,
0.0497949608,
0.0507952608,
-0.075722903,
-0.0237986241,
0.0071092015,
2.574e-7,
0.0344713815,
0.0389594436,
0.0339892432,
-0.0555597804,
-0.0051226104,
0.0181197226,
0.0008384582,
0.0438861884,
-0.0089771897,
0.0059720753,
0.0407192074,
0.0518151298,
0.0313651077,
0.0050497712,
-0.086240761,
0.0624385625,
-0.0739602149,
-0.0160230529,
-0.0390570462,
0.0124164103,
0.0984535515,
0.1094123125,
0.019628603,
0.0071308846,
-0.0073438403,
-0.0275212843,
0.0652218387,
-0.0200979412,
-0.0086334785,
-0.0034872976,
-0.0292867403,
0.0301890504,
0.0053998055,
0.0074633141,
0.0240660086,
0.0406907462,
0.0262934063,
0.0665309057,
-0.0228088293,
0.0010660156,
0.0166823324,
0.0302200075,
-0.0406952351,
-0.0580261014,
0.0757573321,
-0.0706666037,
-0.0181065239,
-0.0230642222,
-0.0158168878,
0.0210306048,
0.0514215492,
0.022364134,
-0.0328893177,
0.0163303688,
0.0423555225,
-0.0351169258,
0.0330357291,
-0.1317579299,
0.0202871766,
0.0101441434,
-0.0815890431,
-0.0223971326,
-0.0320966654,
-0.0076857586,
0.0496948585,
-0.034545172,
0.0266692042,
2.344687179e-34,
0.0120442668,
-0.00685634,
-0.0040399469,
-0.0095807211,
0.0339907967,
-0.0579727888,
-0.0167832915,
-0.0250518732,
-0.0121455994,
-0.1419285238,
-0.0148133179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12633v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12633v2 | PUNR: Pre-training with User Behavior Modeling for News Recommendation | 2023-04-25T08:03:52 | 2023-10-30T08:13:42 | Guangyuan Ma, Hongtao Liu, Xing Wu, Wanhui Qian, Zhepeng Lv, Qing Yang, Songlin Hu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | News recommendation aims to predict click behaviors based on user behaviors.
How to effectively model the user representations is the key to recommending
preferred news. Existing works are mostly focused on improvements in the
supervised fine-tuning stage. However, there is still a lack of PLM-based
unsupervised pre-training methods optimized for user representations. In this
work, we propose an unsupervised pre-training paradigm with two tasks, i.e.
user behavior masking and user behavior generation, both towards effective user
behavior modeling. Firstly, we introduce the user behavior masking pre-training
task to recover the masked user behaviors based on their contextual behaviors.
In this way, the model could capture a much stronger and more comprehensive
user news reading pattern. Besides, we incorporate a novel auxiliary user
behavior generation pre-training task to enhance the user representation vector
derived from the user encoder. We use the above pre-trained user modeling
encoder to obtain news and user representations in downstream fine-tuning.
Evaluations on the real-world news benchmark show significant performance
improvements over existing baselines. | [
0.0195698012,
-0.0032757225,
-0.0247488227,
0.0257474314,
0.0429847501,
0.022348674,
0.0071998872,
-0.0124567375,
0.0179140512,
-0.0231892597,
-0.0530456677,
0.0279802699,
-0.0730995014,
0.0624385811,
0.0172784552,
-0.0608703159,
0.0276248492,
0.0082030669,
-0.0445073545,
0.0277232695,
0.0390551053,
0.0252987295,
0.0429964177,
-0.0062572192,
0.0335803628,
0.0028177267,
-0.025609849,
0.0151825333,
0.0439363047,
-0.0290038195,
0.0389288142,
0.0062644463,
0.0650375634,
-0.0249214862,
0.0000019914,
-0.0075634234,
-0.0183922034,
-0.0513289534,
0.0183072053,
-0.0084068393,
0.016904138,
0.0060227923,
0.0468357988,
-0.0083684549,
-0.0456850566,
0.0321056992,
-0.0257365461,
0.0809866637,
0.0494970344,
0.0563276857,
-0.0342371538,
0.0067523425,
0.0049758744,
-0.0182322226,
0.0685737506,
-0.0175239649,
0.0088288765,
-0.0309354234,
-0.0502119474,
-0.0006369654,
-0.0137717631,
-0.0266329423,
0.009350542,
0.027675258,
0.0241419952,
0.0102085825,
0.0654520988,
-0.010936629,
-0.0051211496,
0.0694375709,
-0.055208005,
-0.0317957364,
-0.0045020827,
0.0191229433,
-0.0458280072,
0.0032987467,
-0.0158463176,
-0.0591496862,
0.00850162,
0.0388294719,
-0.0137374802,
0.0485362411,
0.0084389551,
-0.0000972802,
0.0015440867,
0.0347580761,
0.0006157149,
-0.033105582,
-0.0031646797,
-0.007970619,
0.0321121924,
-0.0167208351,
0.0518160127,
-0.0024544206,
-0.0107524879,
-0.0128141781,
-0.0397617593,
0.0165449306,
0.0011371629,
-0.0680304542,
0.0471517481,
0.040271502,
-0.000964708,
0.0419998579,
-0.0159425139,
-0.0320752077,
-0.0089628873,
0.0326355733,
-0.0073419865,
0.0483717583,
-0.0008247829,
0.0033171542,
0.0129520986,
0.03404551,
-0.0200490989,
-0.0546286888,
-0.0375667885,
0.0663931742,
0.0241257511,
-0.0170938428,
-0.0188634712,
0.0357258059,
-0.0572749451,
0.0085061463,
-0.0477874093,
-0.0144967334,
-0.0656951517,
0.0184350852,
0.0006230082,
0.0317998081,
0.0145359216,
0.0300304294,
0.0121690808,
-0.0415488593,
0.0229072999,
0.0036949415,
-0.0088551072,
-0.0365658961,
-0.0668095425,
-0.031640999,
0.0452736951,
-0.0467406549,
-0.0368611738,
-0.024405852,
0.0431451723,
-0.0006917507,
-0.0010947792,
-0.0143039674,
-0.0288010817,
0.0113125034,
0.0205992516,
0.0712910295,
0.0352234729,
-0.0356046185,
-0.0077529061,
0.0335038863,
0.0274075009,
0.0494199842,
-0.0071632364,
0.0943518281,
0.021862397,
-0.0075396341,
-0.0059706727,
0.0171615239,
0.0099787861,
-0.0143448301,
-0.0020269647,
0.0133238873,
-0.0018021062,
-0.0251622722,
0.077479884,
0.0141648492,
-0.0736202449,
-0.031676773,
0.04808883,
0.0017714855,
-0.001661783,
0.0484635085,
0.0736548007,
-0.0035708968,
-0.0016414096,
0.0226891022,
0.0225129295,
0.0369869098,
-0.0555632338,
-0.0263685174,
-0.0127289798,
0.0385595113,
-0.076279968,
-0.0083414679,
0.0763549805,
-0.0448255427,
0.0568793602,
0.0153086809,
0.0242585447,
0.0006576868,
-0.0480766818,
0.0040985332,
0.0139341289,
-0.0176451448,
0.0488641001,
-0.0286259018,
0.040624626,
0.0798362941,
0.0378228687,
-0.014517027,
0.0035486557,
-0.0224159546,
-0.0021141537,
-0.0333870538,
0.0424531735,
-0.0288928337,
0.0105231339,
-0.0371504873,
-0.0462689549,
-0.0119359968,
-0.0225184951,
0.0305574648,
0.0081465403,
0.0175404046,
0.0362329111,
0.0046622362,
0.0215227529,
0.0096624363,
-0.05973294,
-0.0315807723,
0.0047363024,
0.0018245652,
0.0617109947,
0.0109105082,
0.0527379923,
-0.0308921598,
0.033461079,
-0.0168918204,
0.0249740724,
0.0033236323,
-0.0357161984,
-0.0546293966,
0.0044538686,
-0.0790630504,
0.0412755124,
0.0897723809,
0.011195261,
-0.0259912796,
-0.0068014003,
0.0201492459,
0.0460423008,
-0.0627229735,
0.0127370087,
0.00267532,
0.005696435,
-0.007511097,
0.0393077619,
-0.0124100316,
0.0066829836,
0.0136835678,
0.0084449574,
-0.029505495,
-0.0312286764,
-0.0378981158,
-0.0710410625,
0.0060146642,
-0.0090774652,
0.0459917448,
-0.0167378392,
-0.0534964688,
0.0166071896,
-0.0515176132,
0.0178891886,
-0.0064614844,
-0.0036931257,
0.0120795369,
0.0424437672,
-0.0222471729,
-0.0567183755,
-0.0285415482,
0.0217488017,
-0.0388459861,
0.0162276682,
-0.0136054736,
0.010693185,
0.0094865235,
-0.042223379,
0.0258034021,
-0.0059589786,
0.0204022527,
-0.022596607,
-0.0051356289,
-0.0327431709,
-0.0117731849,
0.011715116,
-0.003315605,
-0.0568396747,
0.010287798,
-0.0109190438,
-0.0105140284,
0.0325881466,
0.0433103442,
0.0303160902,
0.0755229518,
0.001523882,
0.0300611984,
-0.0839510188,
0.0095044235,
-0.0861617178,
0.0345810652,
-0.0599830113,
0.001923834,
0.076485537,
0.0001945511,
-0.0180180632,
0.0255395584,
-0.0269591827,
0.0023332727,
0.037806794,
-0.039834246,
-0.0069762156,
-0.0196831878,
-0.035679888,
0.031544812,
-0.0062091863,
-0.0027839574,
0.0584228821,
0.0092405565,
0.0134659503,
-0.035596177,
-0.009839966,
-0.0047294828,
-0.0202894341,
0.0255830735,
0.0337204002,
-0.0525694974,
-0.0479285084,
-0.0255935509,
0.0136064179,
0.0097048031,
-0.0057293186,
0.0175186973,
0.0523027033,
-0.0178089961,
0.0154734319,
-0.0272032525,
-0.0425773598,
-0.1026350334,
0.0169498902,
-0.0595505945,
0.0138807064,
0.0288503468,
-0.0497833863,
-0.002659987,
-0.0225108173,
0.0385374539,
-0.0246215723,
-0.0402993374,
0.0041754507,
0.0165352952,
0.0588785186,
-0.0515927821,
-0.0578481071,
-0.0532939546,
0.0037075554,
0.0541076586,
-0.0080556218,
-0.0379425809,
-0.0308032315,
0.0277343672,
0.0610391647,
-0.0130229723,
0.0181103963,
0.0323230848,
0.0171294082,
0.0311526787,
0.0089952815,
0.0850015581,
0.0461426154,
-0.1092047617,
-0.0111623863,
0.0149212759,
0.0314762034,
0.0236885417,
0.059262149,
-0.0579022467,
-0.0223918743,
-0.0271774679,
0.0277627818,
0.0191674605,
0.0010640317,
-0.0167618673,
-0.0372525342,
0.010789047,
0.0282965582,
0.0030828614,
-0.018485589,
-0.0858313888,
0.0012852604,
-0.0345962159,
0.0060698609,
0.0161660369,
-0.0113802394,
-0.0092367064,
0.0133345323,
-0.0205019489,
-0.0788572058,
0.0137911141,
-0.0209553335,
-0.0287209731,
0.0533952266,
0.0095462808,
0.0151247364,
-0.0243897773,
-0.0499986745,
0.0194451716,
0.0280906726,
-0.0125457384,
0.0675247535,
-0.0765422881,
0.0490730442,
-0.0491774417,
0.0471779965,
-0.0287448484,
-0.0476644523,
-0.0023228796,
0.018465817,
-0.0396629982,
-0.0199395437,
-0.0405362509,
-0.0085794041,
0.0353450216,
0.033236675,
0.0235791076,
-0.0504103228,
-0.0069629452,
-0.0063096252,
0.010134385,
-0.0395102762,
-0.0437226407,
-0.0465198718,
-0.010344727,
-0.011227211,
-0.029858144,
-0.0491886288,
0.0263600554,
0.0451706462,
-0.0124382954,
-0.0187639352,
-0.0014697792,
-0.0512023233,
-0.0168221146,
0.0147812935,
-0.0072931736,
-0.0085582612,
-0.0321654268,
-0.0368918404,
0.04734914,
-0.0326999612,
0.0084914165,
-0.0107419277,
-0.0683873072,
-0.0115064876,
-0.0209519174,
0.0969741046,
0.0207855105,
0.0763140991,
-0.0125942109,
-0.0369356312,
0.0808685049,
0.0195897967,
-0.037620768,
-0.0299264863,
-0.0175793618,
-0.0331843793,
-0.0180596951,
-0.024824271,
-0.0219943207,
0.0148746148,
-0.0403873213,
-0.0401582569,
-0.0769275352,
-0.0141241271,
0.0119618364,
-0.0466734506,
0.0612175651,
-0.0245212093,
0.0040895585,
-0.0220994297,
-0.0205336828,
-0.0142695857,
-0.0190782342,
-0.0196856987,
-0.0489651449,
0.0663110763,
-0.0001694471,
-0.0460963733,
0.0243425947,
-0.0285918768,
-0.0105360923,
-0.0746266469,
0.0015772142,
0.0144996187,
0.0218649656,
-0.0078147287,
0.0376518592,
-0.0256286152,
-0.0174244754,
0.0188412815,
0.0286446195,
-0.0034568482,
0.0201407503,
-0.0214063898,
0.0439505056,
0.0020641736,
0.0475476086,
-0.0269986503,
0.0106757637,
-0.0760877207,
-0.0527712144,
-0.0003336553,
-0.0572133213,
0.0219916981,
0.0004552394,
-0.0023354311,
-0.0168024786,
0.0294136032,
-0.0312543958,
-0.0126870349,
-0.0015162975,
0.0088157961,
0.0014179661,
-0.0012583151,
0.1056128442,
-0.025990013,
-0.000426988,
-0.0025328116,
-0.0557612665,
-0.06184268,
0.0358576924,
0.0581799112,
0.0991798192,
-0.0347566754,
-0.0204544105,
0.0094957249,
-0.0308516361,
0.0122717638,
-0.0516154878,
0.0289301258,
0.0069637182,
0.0619810708,
0.0609340221,
-0.0223457813,
0.0031108584,
-0.0477431156,
-0.0269740652,
-0.0330424868,
-0.0079875477,
-0.0041860458,
-6.317223456e-33,
-0.0134323072,
0.0078679025,
-0.0065445285,
0.0222784486,
-0.0109541528,
-0.0291151386,
-0.0051774108,
-0.0390568636,
0.0468309149,
-0.0450378358,
0.0075874054,
-0.0206833705,
0.0128541011,
0.0106661124,
-0.0206677914,
0.008529122,
0.0826435089,
0.0001752389,
0.000248415,
0.0477294177,
0.0245093964,
0.0456469394,
-0.0124985138,
-0.0671827123,
-0.017618984,
-0.0186924078,
-0.037166331,
-0.0403162539,
0.0753249153,
0.0679271817,
-0.0343830325,
0.0153182093,
0.0115026804,
0.0124017615,
-0.0141795911,
0.0514897406,
-0.085227564,
-0.0330112129,
0.0252103508,
0.0293134954,
-0.0487965494,
-0.0093795825,
0.0168629307,
-0.0142388912,
0.0027844016,
0.0014134319,
0.0438327603,
0.0038699827,
0.0126213413,
-0.0262475647,
-0.0271132365,
0.0224409848,
-0.0067826505,
-0.0186348148,
0.0265273545,
0.0473368615,
-0.0134054227,
0.0516227148,
-0.0950028896,
0.0276024863,
-0.0136788515,
-0.002946008,
0.0335106514,
0.0217634123,
-0.0055592144,
0.0839119107,
0.0140674096,
0.0014860142,
0.0059610615,
0.0531283394,
0.0094549162,
0.0679090619,
-0.0341867916,
0.0254970808,
0.052226387,
-0.0266822428,
-0.0550873205,
0.1201240048,
0.0667923838,
-0.0315669365,
0.0608302541,
0.0328473561,
0.0014687112,
-0.014442726,
0.017942939,
-0.0043420917,
-0.0146050183,
-0.0783181638,
0.0352007784,
0.0618501045,
-0.0319360867,
0.0266889669,
0.0289457664,
-0.0280780774,
0.0173015129,
0.0076964726,
-0.0233424939,
0.0095927576,
0.0147700794,
-0.0082379812,
-0.0503651388,
-0.0410882309,
0.0201625675,
-0.0561120212,
-0.032009732,
0.0100111226,
0.0342555158,
0.0267678536,
-0.036116194,
-0.019900905,
0.0247078873,
-0.0129562048,
0.0277707763,
0.0382743701,
0.0051185591,
0.0166950766,
-0.0514669269,
0.0578560121,
-0.0123590734,
0.0018780576,
-0.0019150989,
-0.0545511618,
0.0182916149,
0.0415078625,
0.0183665436,
-0.0372494347,
-0.0341823176,
0.0017756183,
0.0332725421,
-0.0802752599,
-0.0087416675,
-0.0025312616,
2.7e-7,
-0.0073752413,
0.0168852024,
-0.0051739397,
-0.0160717834,
0.0078062597,
0.0203605648,
0.0190658681,
0.0771028623,
0.058461044,
-0.0075631388,
0.0551161468,
0.0230071209,
-0.0161646865,
0.0152348187,
-0.0821610838,
0.0297336206,
-0.0021338104,
0.0171918608,
-0.0403545201,
-0.0242706332,
0.0323006287,
0.0508567095,
0.0144478735,
-0.0046168063,
0.0641201138,
0.0267210621,
0.0840583816,
-0.0349590443,
-0.0580235831,
-0.0079578506,
0.0222962033,
0.0176774748,
-0.0139260273,
0.0209232923,
-0.0540375337,
0.0301963575,
0.0301155094,
0.0266835205,
-0.0080176285,
-0.0428630821,
0.0191979688,
0.0207452029,
0.0264587943,
-0.0149404388,
0.0879539847,
-0.0303802248,
-0.0335332379,
-0.0036376554,
-0.0789108053,
0.0063956291,
0.0025238781,
-0.0238237921,
-0.0105897859,
0.014029053,
0.0254920106,
0.012310301,
-0.0482493117,
-0.0731081292,
0.0154433465,
-0.0083621973,
-0.0505595542,
-0.0232174862,
-0.0425640568,
0.0097512007,
-0.0045739668,
-0.026813224,
0.0427783579,
2.112361971e-34,
-0.0016792369,
0.0727824271,
0.0268211309,
-0.0536753945,
0.0086276717,
0.021684682,
0.0218078792,
0.0094122766,
0.070652023,
-0.0479516201,
-0.0287868474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12631v1 | Explain like I am BM25: Interpreting a Dense Model's Ranked-List with a Sparse Approximation | 2023-04-25T07:58:38 | 2023-04-25T07:58:38 | Michael Llordes, Debasis Ganguly, Sumit Bhatia, Chirag Agarwal | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Neural retrieval models (NRMs) have been shown to outperform their
statistical counterparts owing to their ability to capture semantic meaning via
dense document representations. These models, however, suffer from poor
interpretability as they do not rely on explicit term matching. As a form of
local per-query explanations, we introduce the notion of equivalent queries
that are generated by maximizing the similarity between the NRM's results and
the result set of a sparse retrieval system with the equivalent query. We then
compare this approach with existing methods such as RM3-based query expansion
and contrast differences in retrieval effectiveness and in the terms generated
by each approach. | [
0.0474109948,
-0.0108019346,
0.0032771006,
0.0208135769,
0.0061574071,
0.0223771296,
-0.0136658335,
0.0278833341,
-0.0628149062,
-0.0134074036,
-0.0181705058,
-0.0340511352,
-0.0081211282,
-0.0043952796,
0.0053851674,
-0.0565468855,
0.0439821742,
-0.0176927391,
0.0049809646,
-0.0113353739,
-0.0260278713,
0.0075807688,
0.0170340873,
0.0399820022,
0.0763828382,
0.0271088034,
-0.0131100724,
0.0508217774,
-0.0612975359,
-0.0215430632,
-0.0470273644,
0.0201618169,
0.0506077074,
0.0249803513,
0.0000021443,
-0.0072280387,
-0.0528015234,
0.0072581843,
-0.042818781,
0.0150735267,
0.0077746068,
0.0202424489,
0.0794476792,
-0.0416671894,
0.0125037106,
-0.0058489731,
-0.0014416758,
0.0270148907,
-0.0205374528,
0.0232301075,
0.0118789645,
-0.015019848,
-0.0340281837,
-0.0239494629,
0.0665226951,
-0.0705176741,
0.0006274661,
-0.0333653204,
0.0619402677,
0.0636302307,
0.0221058913,
0.0067998217,
-0.020523442,
-0.0054551288,
0.0478105769,
0.013357508,
-0.0401846208,
0.0086094169,
0.0532567985,
-0.0115659619,
0.0049756784,
-0.0029316212,
-0.0170861948,
0.0693117455,
0.0051630721,
0.0295470655,
-0.0677148253,
-0.0220801607,
-0.0049101133,
0.0316524059,
-0.0198712852,
0.0657571182,
0.0364126898,
0.0209864005,
-0.0524841808,
0.0239996463,
-0.0066622077,
-0.0431857146,
-0.0165625848,
0.0311805401,
-0.0464961119,
0.0184033774,
0.0265445374,
0.0272125658,
0.0055082245,
0.0084331995,
0.0441007577,
0.0267655179,
0.0331993997,
-0.0218226481,
0.0536672473,
0.0463124625,
-0.0187814794,
0.0335266441,
-0.0041069835,
0.0266657006,
0.0042828126,
0.0263703503,
-0.0473035388,
-0.0050397865,
-0.0280757956,
-0.0609677136,
-0.0038025959,
0.0738639161,
-0.0223432109,
-0.0034971777,
-0.0327706039,
-0.0183156375,
0.0040964298,
-0.0259706061,
-0.0120812813,
0.0234963503,
-0.0334512703,
0.000121905,
-0.0969678834,
0.0031787409,
0.006894296,
0.0270202346,
0.0159095693,
-0.002987595,
-0.0223240033,
-0.0227777362,
0.0048801899,
-0.0477279462,
-0.0130444467,
-0.0010866907,
0.0138391191,
-0.0031710137,
0.0114026424,
-0.0170301739,
0.0296343174,
0.0022318917,
0.001722343,
-0.0392049439,
0.0024972991,
0.0148830647,
0.0079217367,
-0.0251723547,
-0.0094008772,
0.014011451,
-0.077405192,
0.0080571864,
-0.0425574705,
0.0059380587,
-0.0039204946,
0.0310838446,
0.0381347574,
0.0176456813,
-0.0581044406,
0.0324513838,
0.0321251936,
-0.0115791745,
-0.035531383,
-0.0453945659,
-0.0012829901,
-0.0265369341,
-0.0828706771,
0.0253970344,
-0.047948759,
0.0198111534,
0.0295919608,
0.0172844585,
-0.0504058599,
-0.0357975028,
0.0292931926,
0.0804160163,
0.0449134819,
0.0074921963,
-0.0385168158,
-0.0114156269,
0.0069402577,
0.0522135384,
-0.0093564987,
0.0118903527,
-0.0366094746,
-0.0022525634,
0.051798705,
-0.0122107677,
-0.0425811186,
-0.0520933084,
-0.0220458135,
0.0514581837,
-0.0451161601,
-0.0146771604,
0.02456671,
-0.0134327374,
0.0307610538,
0.0238954313,
0.0278672837,
0.0063992906,
0.0204137936,
-0.0654830709,
-0.0128309494,
0.0350704491,
0.015933577,
-0.0272980053,
-0.0216106437,
0.0284701288,
-0.0614223368,
0.0014234402,
-0.0288555548,
0.0083383834,
-0.0178474654,
-0.0188717525,
-0.0409953855,
-0.0296440832,
0.0336313695,
0.0130947083,
-0.0475782529,
-0.0196477026,
0.0217787158,
-0.0981503502,
-0.0176183432,
0.0019152163,
0.022384163,
-0.0307950433,
-0.0059037399,
-0.0066248961,
-0.036468666,
0.0386167243,
0.0158856902,
0.02788385,
0.0369519331,
-0.0065013487,
0.0214364156,
-0.0617452525,
-0.0353422724,
0.052168496,
-0.0199548192,
0.0109105436,
0.0291947257,
0.0623249076,
-0.0015309042,
0.0058938102,
-0.0054363906,
-0.0062180194,
0.0180454012,
-0.0437899418,
-0.0320438147,
-0.0059619187,
0.02254848,
-0.0490499958,
0.0912149474,
-0.0201252457,
0.0322621539,
0.0516381003,
-0.0304851439,
0.0054697637,
-0.0639368892,
-0.0419723205,
0.0178008173,
-0.0066361702,
-0.013751111,
-0.0095270341,
-0.0169347282,
0.0117077548,
0.0494957604,
0.0006538035,
-0.0009757188,
-0.0087798238,
-0.0177533776,
-0.0004678363,
0.0138711268,
0.0152330426,
-0.0291219428,
0.0118971914,
-0.0036253445,
0.0221169833,
0.0290656947,
0.0230317395,
0.0548041984,
-0.020135168,
-0.0592858456,
-0.0685843676,
0.0131681524,
0.0821120664,
-0.0068045375,
-0.0028857437,
-0.0185556915,
0.0374811888,
-0.0557122938,
-0.0150357587,
-0.0204158742,
0.0207192563,
0.0042467536,
-0.0823073536,
-0.0420123786,
0.0498750284,
0.0286099371,
0.0814032033,
0.0453369319,
0.0382012203,
-0.0767175257,
-0.0207840148,
-0.03945053,
-0.0059068962,
-0.038151715,
-0.0474632978,
-0.0052239555,
0.0214546286,
-0.0158950016,
-0.0275185984,
-0.0300698094,
0.0267679505,
0.0394461937,
-0.0278923903,
-0.1091149896,
-0.0035378339,
0.0235710014,
0.0636255592,
-0.0179807432,
-0.0536398515,
0.0367774889,
0.0011276187,
0.0257437732,
-0.0085954396,
-0.03615015,
-0.0447449796,
0.0469002761,
0.0005603046,
0.000099443,
-0.0257694591,
-0.0140562262,
0.015770793,
0.0122516779,
-0.0152051812,
-0.0189544465,
0.0521136522,
0.0004848408,
-0.0036399511,
0.0045914804,
0.0078824805,
-0.0091839796,
-0.021168638,
0.0236569364,
0.0310333129,
0.0213875286,
0.0150342248,
-0.0456537865,
0.0484412126,
0.0321860947,
-0.0019261572,
-0.029665716,
-0.0297701694,
-0.0039208615,
-0.0051581189,
0.037610732,
0.0203189868,
0.0384625271,
0.010513681,
0.0670893267,
0.053902261,
0.0201669056,
-0.0583092831,
-0.0220634695,
0.0417700335,
0.043808464,
-0.0219257344,
-0.0653801858,
-0.0007880836,
-0.0311043616,
-0.0377104618,
-0.0322940759,
0.0696924105,
-0.0025254921,
-0.0697063208,
0.019027628,
-0.0843714699,
0.0772524178,
0.0485125706,
0.0180970933,
-0.009921913,
0.0319749042,
0.0101568121,
0.0673523247,
0.0136419777,
-0.0401807651,
0.0526244715,
-0.0535647385,
0.0499853157,
-0.0352552347,
-0.0180938691,
0.0246444643,
-0.0242751446,
0.0101042073,
0.0165863018,
-0.0198686011,
0.0267446917,
-0.0165413525,
0.0077893557,
0.0497875363,
0.0645340234,
-0.0274342131,
-0.0095624449,
-0.0224149097,
-0.000489049,
0.0323822722,
0.0319094621,
-0.0457810387,
-0.0111749265,
-0.0395535305,
0.012396846,
0.0565808453,
-0.0170957819,
0.0209792145,
0.0265417993,
-0.0010776799,
-0.00182977,
-0.0478938445,
0.0125422413,
0.0121253161,
-0.0427569114,
0.0333649106,
-0.0672638193,
0.0220404286,
-0.0521985032,
-0.0340718925,
-0.0314697325,
0.0453737564,
0.0164396986,
0.0612029992,
-0.008603706,
0.0047525419,
0.0376331992,
0.0255366564,
-0.0707210153,
0.0482611805,
-0.0405257493,
0.0009434693,
0.0256513711,
-0.0126705151,
-0.0402838886,
0.0411293693,
-0.035061948,
0.0530510172,
-0.0472827666,
-0.0114311539,
0.032628119,
0.0582205467,
0.0347287133,
-0.0400118567,
0.0119132819,
-0.0396800078,
0.0085002836,
-0.0502313413,
-0.0525414571,
-0.1335632205,
0.0263879746,
0.033861842,
-0.0005028307,
0.0140507463,
0.027049616,
0.0315520875,
0.0081675295,
-0.0826963559,
0.0372906588,
0.0524303243,
0.0046887356,
0.0082778092,
0.0088817943,
-0.0510441363,
-0.0139410496,
0.0062107374,
-0.0609899051,
0.0555989221,
-0.0209445562,
0.0364868194,
-0.0000223385,
-0.0424726866,
0.0336178541,
0.0163682438,
0.0781854764,
0.0341992304,
0.0035136892,
0.0212995578,
0.0096466765,
-0.0441587009,
0.0008828801,
-0.0321341269,
-0.0321752653,
0.0368446596,
0.0403836071,
0.003764217,
-0.0351065621,
-0.0005064278,
0.0940305516,
-0.0908440575,
0.0096113291,
0.0047670892,
-0.0534667373,
-0.0262072571,
0.0220418926,
-0.0519571118,
0.0290854443,
-0.0195030756,
0.0566106848,
-0.0197406672,
-0.0103021329,
-0.0030205848,
0.0052484209,
-0.022227833,
0.0418671221,
-0.1217026189,
-0.07474415,
0.0201358683,
-0.0307482649,
0.0136715006,
-0.058773715,
-0.020752674,
0.0151074361,
0.0138156796,
-0.0000750361,
-0.0598858073,
0.045407854,
-0.0105441539,
0.0183105096,
0.04335941,
0.0246042833,
0.0208847206,
0.0945345312,
0.0370858908,
-0.0095945038,
0.0076407446,
-0.0398038924,
0.0210946016,
-0.0495058484,
0.0776942372,
0.0870466679,
-0.0124186808,
-0.0216393825,
-0.0011105129,
-0.0229735728,
0.0440430939,
-0.0140760681,
-0.0073797042,
-0.0425603911,
0.004028412,
0.0997424796,
0.0122928359,
-0.0154933659,
-0.0193506442,
0.0103766946,
-0.0783527493,
-0.002588477,
-0.0020024444,
-6.783650064e-33,
-0.0195421763,
-0.0343629271,
0.0053348644,
-0.0360854641,
-0.014699175,
-0.0063793357,
0.0022776418,
-0.021719303,
-0.0004416931,
0.02197925,
-0.0402231589,
-0.0028380479,
-0.0018922044,
-0.0218937676,
-0.0179259721,
-0.0162959415,
0.0150026437,
0.0394555293,
0.029379813,
-0.0239014383,
0.0342397802,
0.0541741177,
0.0035054632,
-0.0520115271,
0.0405550599,
-0.0243745949,
0.0025149165,
0.0089295115,
0.0041478937,
0.0707343444,
-0.0028109006,
0.0131591363,
0.0204510055,
-0.0299247783,
-0.0118907429,
-0.0113165686,
-0.0621408783,
-0.0131677873,
0.049189277,
-0.0381790102,
0.013376818,
0.0252642408,
0.0145342331,
-0.0009688179,
-0.0218065213,
-0.0116395839,
0.0349750072,
-0.0446201861,
-0.0804137439,
-0.0396653004,
-0.0000651191,
-0.0022762658,
-0.0040126625,
0.0445137285,
0.0380065925,
0.0613804944,
-0.0226699524,
0.0745303556,
-0.0177141838,
-0.0089940568,
-0.0448605865,
0.0798102692,
-0.0005803934,
0.0138493422,
-0.0453267433,
0.0431662947,
0.0145659037,
-0.026470596,
-0.0308588222,
0.0186118446,
0.0216596294,
0.0365751125,
0.0291297417,
-0.0028155867,
0.0765241012,
0.0219047032,
-0.0718047991,
0.0537671,
-0.0810854137,
0.0510339774,
0.0741466358,
0.0389126278,
-0.0485161878,
-0.0125009725,
0.0090700155,
-0.0176162925,
-0.0660834387,
-0.0439845733,
0.0183594543,
-0.005139228,
-0.0383452736,
0.0528436936,
0.0157942344,
-0.0218307879,
-0.0071276533,
-0.0001683924,
0.033524204,
-0.0370318368,
0.0046087853,
-0.0016881105,
0.0090715103,
-0.0382259972,
-0.0069994316,
-0.0038235881,
0.007271159,
0.034707725,
0.01059986,
0.0147680985,
0.0360883363,
-0.0270544682,
0.0091581689,
-0.0630567074,
-0.0490472876,
0.0019662988,
-0.0034010729,
-0.0071087843,
0.0142429071,
0.0482422039,
0.0283313766,
0.0341104716,
-0.0105175627,
-0.0231235456,
-0.0147428503,
-0.0007022065,
0.0042328336,
-0.0033829457,
-0.0460214838,
-0.0121190436,
0.0268419478,
-0.0353788547,
-0.0190992448,
0.0415896475,
2.856e-7,
0.0472394861,
0.0042133299,
-0.0065378146,
-0.0261431728,
-0.0250260923,
0.0012672596,
-0.0025909457,
0.002435266,
0.0405524373,
-0.0538013726,
0.0260763802,
0.0312667564,
-0.0032109329,
0.0355900191,
-0.0227318201,
-0.0230351724,
-0.0833460465,
-0.0463306718,
-0.0431767404,
0.0135214487,
0.0597652309,
0.0485630557,
-0.035190206,
-0.0051015033,
-0.006567345,
-0.0349446051,
0.0167239495,
-0.0287436787,
0.0250111986,
0.0040910984,
0.1240780652,
-0.0398242772,
0.0353756361,
-0.0336435996,
0.0292129833,
0.0366732813,
0.0562787242,
0.0408585146,
-0.0369248576,
-0.0320825242,
-0.0305338223,
-0.0278070122,
0.0520782955,
-0.0724637061,
0.0567859411,
0.013638908,
-0.0135580748,
0.044740282,
-0.0119194239,
-0.0025300465,
-0.0156839043,
-0.0039750901,
0.0105485776,
-0.0052153361,
0.018203197,
-0.0307599735,
-0.0005497904,
-0.0538271852,
-0.0029127372,
-0.0195961408,
-0.0438482426,
0.0113144917,
-0.0343430229,
0.0117653925,
-0.0159010123,
0.0237059519,
-0.0482759401,
2.831346203e-34,
0.0390050299,
0.0581798069,
0.0285890847,
0.0126917288,
0.0196605735,
0.0084852008,
-0.0206587035,
0.0229795333,
0.0032440976,
-0.1037371084,
-0.0091650849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12569v1 | KINLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Kinyarwanda Tweet Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-25T04:30:03 | 2023-04-25T04:30:03 | Antoine Nzeyimana | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper describes the system entered by the author to the SemEval-2023
Task 12: Sentiment analysis for African languages. The system focuses on the
Kinyarwanda language and uses a language-specific model. Kinyarwanda morphology
is modeled in a two tier transformer architecture and the transformer model is
pre-trained on a large text corpus using multi-task masked morphology
prediction. The model is deployed on an experimental platform that allows users
to experiment with the pre-trained language model fine-tuning without the need
to write machine learning code. Our final submission to the shared task
achieves second ranking out of 34 teams in the competition, achieving 72.50%
weighted F1 score. Our analysis of the evaluation results highlights challenges
in achieving high accuracy on the task and identifies areas for improvement. | [
0.0770751312,
0.0634691045,
-0.015563502,
0.0315674692,
-0.0134536438,
0.0366984829,
-0.0021822797,
0.0040312661,
-0.0266876426,
-0.0254183896,
-0.0346149467,
-0.0813353136,
0.0129952086,
0.0479792617,
0.0192705486,
-0.0472368933,
0.020653354,
0.016938163,
-0.007789047,
-0.0078370105,
0.0101139536,
0.0526194796,
0.0006641093,
0.0006470348,
-0.0515591018,
0.0117098624,
-0.008191227,
-0.0005057662,
-0.0093478672,
-0.0079794517,
0.0317654051,
0.0323898531,
-0.0580556169,
0.0330109261,
0.0000023363,
-0.0318598934,
-0.0261929426,
-0.0177622493,
0.0039060873,
0.0101495199,
0.1095195785,
-0.0353296325,
-0.02816654,
0.0255749859,
-0.0551303886,
0.0076952712,
0.0827186182,
0.0404490344,
0.0658242479,
0.0763227865,
-0.0238150172,
-0.0331724659,
0.0122263273,
-0.0337921679,
-0.0473157056,
0.0097911311,
0.000493189,
-0.0212439653,
-0.0521011427,
0.0127469972,
0.0056663183,
0.0092914905,
-0.0171337817,
0.0048446525,
-0.0091679282,
-0.0207579341,
-0.0257727597,
-0.079854086,
0.0077087777,
0.0144416755,
-0.016591277,
-0.0104579618,
-0.0129905175,
0.0101744831,
-0.040644493,
0.0123086711,
-0.0271855835,
0.0123546962,
0.0067273397,
0.0258843787,
-0.0124032684,
0.0610982142,
0.0232963767,
0.0390475579,
-0.0307846759,
0.0343678892,
-0.0099001499,
-0.02207518,
0.0144049749,
0.0647172183,
-0.0023910953,
0.0029849531,
0.02789676,
-0.0150292637,
-0.0148008699,
-0.0235097259,
0.0270266943,
-0.0703079179,
0.0347625837,
-0.0856782719,
0.0193642415,
-0.0094149858,
-0.0087208422,
0.0229242388,
-0.079412587,
0.0020744556,
-0.0090975147,
-0.0159547124,
-0.0073637902,
-0.0482775569,
-0.0455477126,
-0.0198743455,
0.0072176117,
0.0126140835,
-0.0429218188,
0.0395384282,
-0.0414685979,
0.0005418273,
-0.0253934581,
-0.0277917217,
0.0356361531,
0.0042352933,
-0.0138091082,
-0.0328787453,
-0.0016256564,
0.0409777276,
-0.0235310011,
0.0210969113,
-0.05653283,
-0.0481906198,
0.0182510335,
0.0123889158,
-0.0024016562,
-0.000384436,
0.0310405139,
0.0585289113,
0.0022395386,
-0.0429329611,
-0.0179761034,
-0.0230767764,
-0.0296829846,
-0.0439893454,
-0.0353911221,
-0.0560829267,
0.0340150967,
0.013865293,
0.0283188615,
0.0361369997,
-0.0012730267,
0.0052679763,
0.0211460851,
0.0566396788,
-0.0069550239,
-0.0134684872,
0.0093380185,
0.0226168688,
0.0141766872,
0.0659401119,
-0.0179862473,
0.0814931169,
0.0228073709,
0.0037388916,
-0.0401107855,
0.0405057669,
-0.0136179728,
-0.0207014829,
-0.0056784404,
0.0046469811,
-0.0030525061,
-0.0301204138,
-0.0032463516,
0.043308422,
0.033924412,
-0.0083240326,
0.0476674959,
0.0279362425,
0.0054983157,
0.049963288,
0.0089891395,
-0.0150857437,
-0.002537566,
-0.0333671868,
0.0170130264,
0.0087986607,
-0.0169306323,
-0.0316040926,
-0.0116001759,
0.0813235864,
-0.0197545942,
-0.0445129573,
0.0160993878,
-0.0475452393,
0.0171841905,
-0.0182429105,
0.0535196923,
-0.0048799478,
-0.0608320907,
-0.0018606514,
0.0582053587,
-0.0668434501,
-0.0192765966,
-0.0619249567,
0.019837141,
0.0164740048,
-0.0065703178,
0.0191224795,
-0.0421252735,
-0.0061069923,
-0.0370812044,
0.0441418476,
-0.0182645917,
-0.0143318539,
0.0217564646,
-0.0553519763,
0.0256777704,
0.0271691289,
0.0163703132,
0.0110635497,
-0.0025822527,
0.0762014017,
0.0099604316,
-0.0033400748,
-0.0010216624,
0.0227483045,
-0.0112935584,
-0.0015882343,
0.0180140994,
0.0105129732,
0.0580799691,
0.0290691759,
-0.0151515286,
-0.0112609025,
0.0211881269,
-0.0473496504,
0.0042479089,
0.0594339147,
-0.0403389372,
-0.028408723,
0.0021427346,
-0.0281333253,
-0.0096258959,
0.1060578525,
-0.0064204801,
-0.028890932,
0.0533071831,
-0.0075999214,
0.068606928,
-0.048439391,
0.000307999,
-0.048776187,
0.0156730562,
-0.0014494575,
0.027027199,
0.0352488384,
-0.0185015779,
-0.0202505682,
-0.045768287,
0.0407606885,
0.0241872258,
-0.0371203087,
0.038135048,
-0.0084646707,
-0.018466631,
0.0170034394,
0.0055156318,
-0.0251329523,
-0.0456311703,
-0.1264231503,
-0.0157528147,
-0.0220865961,
0.0244743377,
0.017264273,
0.0498644598,
-0.0039360472,
0.0074435524,
-0.0121109579,
0.0017723667,
0.0182921607,
-0.0085723037,
0.0146955885,
-0.0097295577,
0.0335717797,
-0.0438689813,
-0.0029777226,
0.0033668594,
0.054904934,
0.0478320867,
-0.048021514,
-0.0069540814,
0.0254064146,
-0.0104196137,
0.0121845407,
0.0099984817,
-0.0641977116,
0.0051111006,
-0.0334391855,
0.0354311951,
0.0218927003,
0.0125583448,
0.0070537687,
0.0201328099,
0.0099760136,
-0.0058385846,
-0.014698281,
-0.0568559542,
0.0178686846,
-0.0191532709,
-0.0133996624,
0.0115859304,
0.1138685048,
-0.0101479003,
-0.0125901606,
-0.0494245924,
-0.02522761,
-0.0328719243,
-0.0159040559,
0.0198541414,
0.0080798576,
-0.006254964,
0.0168100856,
-0.0069920626,
-0.0070139021,
0.0694579482,
0.0061181234,
-0.0159459673,
-0.059383329,
-0.000086958,
-0.0285270363,
0.0573466606,
-0.0187173579,
0.0124449646,
0.0159748662,
0.0078716949,
-0.012540211,
0.014381039,
0.0074931714,
-0.0291008968,
-0.0144633045,
0.0208687782,
-0.0205415189,
0.0101163285,
-0.0380786508,
0.0228452478,
-0.0390490219,
-0.0571488217,
-0.0196715053,
0.0587868877,
-0.0103346827,
-0.0020446638,
0.0356140696,
-0.0481689945,
-0.0379245058,
-0.002374633,
-0.0138610331,
0.022538282,
0.0480147824,
0.0257031396,
-0.0249535162,
0.0418336242,
-0.0281863268,
-0.003366444,
0.0520148799,
-0.0037391977,
-0.0157806482,
-0.0056602927,
-0.0336984806,
0.0476933047,
-0.0272460934,
-0.0242537372,
-0.0501029752,
0.0412450098,
-0.0096321721,
0.0241199825,
0.11703334,
0.031243179,
-0.0263817813,
-0.0026886738,
-0.0024751644,
0.0398041867,
-0.0125173451,
0.0194537342,
-0.0752140731,
-0.0183130521,
-0.0047200262,
0.00362387,
-0.0107547771,
-0.0196893923,
0.0196115263,
-0.1139128059,
0.0110583408,
0.0036948188,
0.0256062206,
-0.049794022,
-0.0421653055,
-0.0204828046,
-0.0573704988,
-0.0289098192,
-0.0272490419,
0.0119149433,
0.0234062839,
0.0366031192,
-0.0526648015,
-0.0638455376,
0.0528914146,
-0.0247287825,
0.0131298266,
0.0290421061,
0.0230755806,
-0.026901409,
-0.0222968068,
-0.0200623367,
-0.0182737708,
-0.0081830844,
-0.024810534,
0.020027468,
0.0023563148,
-0.057574302,
-0.0512805171,
-0.0408997834,
-0.0376255102,
0.0216768663,
-0.0362976566,
0.062323533,
0.0199825596,
-0.013128994,
-0.0181899443,
0.0052128574,
0.0112286387,
0.0132442499,
0.0007303867,
-0.0817566887,
-0.0428935438,
-0.0004602292,
0.039181821,
-0.0500881076,
-0.0482718535,
-0.011312631,
0.0097768959,
-0.0443432182,
-0.0985274538,
-0.0658536553,
0.0290675797,
0.0135083776,
-0.0175697021,
-0.04614776,
-0.0101773525,
-0.0011375665,
-0.0682897046,
0.0219236314,
0.0329285376,
0.0355041586,
-0.0436000936,
-0.0070212586,
0.0818759203,
0.0018550211,
0.0081897117,
0.0148606151,
-0.0895409137,
-0.0380757451,
0.026698254,
0.0569552816,
0.0162911769,
0.0032582146,
-0.0127935074,
-0.0238123983,
0.0134854391,
0.0172613151,
-0.0289519392,
-0.0013723902,
0.0623169802,
0.0219041165,
-0.0078390399,
0.0339149833,
0.0089741219,
0.0592063256,
0.0058443449,
-0.0339106098,
-0.0277101062,
-0.0382182449,
-0.0229058955,
-0.0240298454,
0.0971571878,
-0.0173271168,
-0.0456411988,
-0.012265183,
-0.0033727577,
0.0422957949,
0.0057575121,
-0.0322855972,
-0.0319926441,
0.0392353609,
0.0423979685,
-0.0454891734,
0.0618850626,
-0.0220700596,
0.0025502695,
-0.0362844504,
0.06949763,
0.0609852299,
-0.00289705,
0.0149077307,
0.0518199243,
0.0017194276,
-0.0158115271,
0.0164267272,
0.0229471289,
-0.0344126895,
-0.0009991748,
-0.0209502783,
0.0218166877,
0.0137597658,
0.0501183569,
0.0215917081,
0.0620671399,
-0.0561123528,
-0.0264814589,
0.0478330627,
-0.0494331531,
0.0547206253,
-0.0069197039,
-0.0067568105,
-0.004152569,
0.0271222778,
-0.0678638741,
0.0178341344,
0.0155816386,
-0.0185650829,
-0.0142532783,
0.0166880898,
0.0578859188,
-0.0437595956,
0.0260944236,
0.0671760514,
0.0135822976,
-0.027323477,
-0.0160962213,
0.0346651897,
-0.0246325396,
0.0048064138,
0.0369302966,
-0.0538457893,
-0.0726521835,
0.0872282013,
-0.0678972378,
0.0141520239,
0.0357186012,
0.0277725719,
0.0304301493,
0.0186136458,
0.0600478351,
-0.0520455018,
-0.0455074273,
0.0082284305,
-0.0021838553,
0.0101611912,
-7.072613758e-33,
0.0027185383,
0.030722091,
-0.0522601008,
0.0045202766,
-0.0162345115,
-0.0144082718,
0.0026950783,
0.0302338507,
-0.0374470912,
0.0397755206,
-0.0234183352,
-0.0029361928,
0.0162629578,
0.0321704336,
0.0472093225,
0.0422903895,
0.0309558343,
-0.009132524,
0.0085350266,
0.0038858817,
0.010746548,
0.0714859292,
0.073552832,
-0.0797706693,
0.0316381268,
-0.0057687582,
-0.0538103245,
-0.0257465374,
0.0303730611,
0.0433121026,
-0.0400079712,
0.0581279285,
0.0262300819,
-0.0486949161,
-0.0134961996,
0.0183821786,
-0.0372803025,
-0.0106900185,
0.0123151811,
0.0540558845,
-0.0186257288,
-0.0306925513,
0.0239288285,
-0.0217105877,
-0.0317728743,
0.0054350477,
0.0154625718,
-0.0287796482,
0.0084108403,
-0.0391128883,
-0.0431515761,
0.03071725,
0.0011995668,
-0.0226202644,
0.0569773689,
0.0723719895,
0.0160843097,
0.0158008579,
-0.0581728369,
0.0378096737,
-0.0272397324,
0.0429986119,
0.0208764523,
0.0304301511,
-0.0284089781,
0.0421968661,
0.0290452,
-0.0230627693,
-0.011994252,
0.063083455,
0.0326658711,
0.0187422745,
0.0521180667,
0.0588984452,
0.0091755493,
-0.0607899316,
-0.0497487076,
0.0151650766,
0.047887858,
0.040656697,
-0.0009165452,
-0.013099337,
-0.0199163202,
-0.0278382786,
0.0280949604,
-0.0207529608,
-0.0114109805,
-0.0156037286,
0.0042591584,
-0.0227366537,
-0.044630982,
0.0806175396,
0.0002272119,
-0.0550766699,
0.0111795133,
0.0016866778,
-0.0384910852,
0.0572139695,
0.0128712608,
0.0273125861,
-0.0549219251,
-0.009260918,
-0.0210304633,
0.0684907287,
0.0046404349,
-0.0182347558,
0.025671415,
0.0516063236,
-0.1173395887,
0.0132253589,
-0.0250009578,
0.0439882129,
0.0021901287,
0.0804531425,
-0.0111435968,
-0.0135281077,
-0.0233430229,
0.0499649793,
-0.0031459015,
0.0093353707,
0.0138848303,
0.0253411159,
0.0102965208,
-0.0046421001,
-0.0463376641,
-0.0413702838,
-0.0202781036,
0.0001539315,
-0.0025512329,
-0.0156146735,
-0.0017976786,
-0.0125733241,
3.075e-7,
0.0440014787,
0.0809770897,
-0.0247702859,
-0.0414849371,
0.0151712038,
0.0356956534,
-0.0056443643,
0.0093712527,
-0.0036719046,
0.0404804349,
0.0075174244,
-0.0271389652,
0.050310567,
0.0116498685,
-0.131402567,
-0.0004431547,
-0.064923428,
-0.0128530124,
-0.0140355183,
0.002282283,
0.0210532323,
0.1586059481,
-0.0078191524,
-0.0241914168,
-0.0344564617,
-0.0129302954,
0.0717006177,
-0.035089191,
-0.0099284872,
-0.0025395004,
0.008281908,
0.0025038547,
-0.0302322377,
-0.0188243333,
-0.0424779542,
0.0080291117,
0.0012195545,
0.0696791261,
-0.0042385585,
-0.0064105107,
0.0516458116,
0.0400076173,
-0.0258333888,
-0.0378161557,
0.0667376071,
-0.0084754797,
-0.0757038593,
-0.057387311,
-0.0194637831,
0.0265340414,
0.0265293755,
-0.0233100113,
-0.0341446102,
0.0141030159,
0.010340929,
-0.0536996908,
-0.0584945343,
-0.0708201751,
-0.000043636,
-0.0016772706,
-0.0194949638,
-0.0107884062,
-0.0015090842,
-0.0203566775,
0.029283002,
-0.0168699268,
0.035054829,
2.651566281e-34,
0.048394151,
-0.0191933345,
0.0207851604,
0.0298762675,
-0.0275711641,
-0.0186528116,
0.0165066496,
0.0073348768,
0.0292843934,
-0.0171180572,
0.013445043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12519v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12519v2 | GlyphDiffusion: Text Generation as Image Generation | 2023-04-25T02:14:44 | 2023-05-08T07:44:48 | Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jian-Yun Nie, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Diffusion models have become a new generative paradigm for text generation.
Considering the discrete categorical nature of text, in this paper, we propose
GlyphDiffusion, a novel diffusion approach for text generation via text-guided
image generation. Our key idea is to render the target text as a glyph image
containing visual language content. In this way, conditional text generation
can be cast as a glyph image generation task, and it is then natural to apply
continuous diffusion models to discrete texts. Specially, we utilize a cascaded
architecture (ie a base and a super-resolution diffusion model) to generate
high-fidelity glyph images, conditioned on the input text. Furthermore, we
design a text grounding module to transform and refine the visual language
content from generated glyph images into the final texts. In experiments over
four conditional text generation tasks and two classes of metrics (ie quality
and diversity), GlyphDiffusion can achieve comparable or even better results
than several baselines, including pretrained language models. Our model also
makes significant improvements compared to the recent diffusion model. | [
0.0184696745,
0.0383775346,
-0.0055252658,
0.021971466,
-0.0256028213,
-0.0055189929,
0.0276591107,
0.0341543518,
-0.0041665481,
0.0197118465,
0.0144700063,
-0.0539759658,
0.0105855456,
0.0189085696,
0.0234091077,
-0.0677685589,
-0.0280527174,
-0.0535684079,
-0.0584115572,
-0.0207657311,
0.017319303,
0.0197405387,
-0.0140941069,
-0.0177024864,
-0.0617991127,
-0.0226225015,
-0.0100893518,
0.0259921141,
0.0329657234,
-0.0284492411,
-0.0312057603,
0.0447756089,
0.0469848327,
-0.0012882407,
0.0000018812,
0.01454568,
0.0346349925,
0.0130060725,
0.0504623875,
0.0021847179,
0.0796932578,
-0.0360118821,
-0.0343854278,
-0.0012618668,
0.0027651852,
0.0375343822,
0.081739746,
0.0440774448,
0.0793946981,
0.0198951494,
-0.0425799862,
-0.084768638,
-0.0024307007,
-0.0523522124,
0.0361382104,
0.0255600996,
0.0049958467,
0.053385064,
-0.0354324207,
0.0419592746,
-0.0248537324,
0.051605206,
0.0476190224,
-0.0361674502,
0.0425147302,
0.0739044845,
0.0790762752,
-0.0394287668,
-0.0086810915,
0.0554906428,
-0.0306111369,
0.0004368495,
0.0078808488,
-0.0361360572,
0.0027265395,
-0.0055314689,
-0.0145199401,
0.0150417956,
0.0006547561,
0.0480518378,
-0.023584079,
0.0122799547,
-0.0088355858,
-0.0022319229,
-0.0198583938,
-0.0270180143,
0.0299074762,
0.004255956,
-0.0461756885,
0.0426010378,
-0.0181634184,
-0.046851106,
0.0528961197,
0.0348236449,
0.0173344817,
0.0054381969,
-0.0678476989,
-0.0330833532,
0.0073726363,
-0.036737293,
0.0639409944,
-0.0066316244,
0.0134403128,
0.0017845634,
-0.057039097,
0.0184539147,
-0.0336370245,
-0.0008976417,
-0.0446686037,
0.0062284041,
0.0058648079,
-0.0030502253,
-0.0426728167,
0.0025782168,
-0.0374220274,
-0.0412713215,
-0.052838102,
0.0266109295,
0.0382757708,
-0.0356262662,
0.0263169836,
0.0166313481,
-0.0419956259,
-0.0242999271,
-0.0072111455,
-0.0040259296,
-0.0093669193,
0.0039335317,
0.0447263904,
0.0320550166,
-0.0179563966,
0.0189528801,
0.0525341444,
0.0011994758,
-0.0183326304,
0.0907915533,
-0.0658929944,
-0.010168355,
-0.0362916887,
0.0194356348,
-0.0243997797,
-0.0396613814,
0.0164411142,
-0.0717008561,
0.0052362261,
-0.0343127362,
0.0015642896,
-0.0288530681,
0.0355053656,
-0.0000993139,
0.012588406,
0.0302342065,
-0.0268497355,
-0.0002406191,
0.0651580617,
-0.0105438195,
0.0025458413,
0.0305256508,
0.0349960327,
0.0658812076,
-0.0244475864,
-0.0116962111,
-0.0054324428,
0.024438167,
0.0253519211,
0.0395562276,
-0.0166704785,
-0.0429281294,
-0.015270954,
0.0344721861,
0.0447323732,
0.0853024796,
-0.0499998853,
0.0025380577,
0.1102909893,
0.0461101867,
0.0164250508,
0.0197281465,
0.0525668636,
0.0396638475,
-0.0552449487,
0.0361019485,
0.040376205,
0.0307915509,
0.0478212684,
0.0157208461,
0.0325885378,
0.0404763855,
-0.0614860356,
-0.0405573137,
0.042950511,
-0.035611473,
0.0421024375,
-0.0718989968,
0.0465412065,
0.0512559377,
-0.0762727559,
-0.0004211782,
-0.0053135697,
-0.0602292791,
0.014080802,
-0.0366708636,
0.0459354483,
0.0763791054,
0.052330371,
0.0428162664,
0.0493693873,
0.0163584389,
0.0404039547,
0.1033276916,
-0.0272657368,
0.0446962081,
0.0129434112,
-0.0723261759,
0.0129719339,
0.0144500369,
-0.0043798946,
0.0386777222,
-0.0168886818,
0.0574866831,
0.0176310278,
0.0274381731,
-0.0482377745,
0.0513374507,
-0.0243329089,
-0.0154090989,
0.0166786443,
-0.0248379093,
-0.0247804131,
-0.0517130271,
-0.0541100055,
0.0134578831,
-0.0094698332,
-0.0501344651,
-0.0292402264,
-0.0229812637,
-0.0342497043,
-0.0468667112,
-0.0353535414,
-0.0669835359,
0.020033801,
-0.0318739563,
-0.0067421654,
-0.0133962529,
0.0039357576,
-0.0581014454,
0.0040282845,
-0.0509805791,
-0.0025731649,
0.01443596,
0.025874529,
-0.021932967,
0.04543145,
-0.0188198853,
-0.0238376055,
-0.0432602949,
0.0397187322,
-0.0278716646,
-0.0144675476,
0.0257580169,
-0.0348823369,
0.0078723691,
0.0247256868,
-0.0061052823,
0.038078934,
-0.031629391,
-0.0469549932,
-0.0587101765,
0.0014524605,
-0.0167200472,
-0.0297571179,
0.0272172578,
0.0147450855,
0.0039788079,
0.0019552722,
-0.0568335392,
0.0337204486,
0.0231303629,
-0.0175580997,
0.056362927,
-0.0135504501,
0.0201503485,
-0.0198706686,
-0.0208238605,
0.0547340959,
0.0489989556,
0.0217542741,
-0.018418001,
-0.053887561,
0.0484008454,
-0.0279808249,
-0.0058627962,
0.0056564203,
-0.043821834,
0.0345723107,
0.0120564988,
0.0922207758,
0.0488735884,
0.0624925382,
0.0214704312,
-0.0330014676,
-0.0251085162,
0.0181138311,
-0.0123781813,
-0.0445534922,
0.0366615579,
0.0189672429,
-0.0321634598,
-0.0072442181,
0.0551619567,
0.0172987822,
0.0200617947,
-0.0831072256,
0.0022744816,
-0.0268177465,
-0.0513791107,
-0.0071695512,
0.0000489537,
-0.0122924,
-0.015931176,
-0.0628619939,
-0.0835538432,
0.0294414833,
-0.0421904661,
0.0067790439,
-0.0112005332,
-0.0110294335,
0.0140211154,
0.0213502645,
0.0247614458,
0.0497745574,
-0.0013766917,
0.0078455713,
-0.0371807925,
0.0219098143,
-0.0119910622,
-0.0440252237,
0.0285798647,
-0.0432196856,
0.011054636,
-0.0211488418,
-0.0042215106,
-0.0287409704,
-0.0126348613,
0.0579156168,
-0.0432187431,
-0.0015148015,
-0.0305825826,
-0.001109349,
0.0248361155,
0.0126308491,
0.0138024092,
-0.0001215684,
-0.0225771368,
-0.0146212177,
0.0632699057,
0.0274970606,
-0.0283573642,
-0.0165199172,
-0.0805421472,
0.0269313361,
0.0415128097,
0.0187421385,
-0.0056804614,
0.0029461917,
-0.0072975713,
-0.025542574,
0.058852572,
-0.0016275645,
-0.0004779502,
0.0868065357,
-0.0206644926,
-0.0108270012,
0.0312798209,
0.0119785815,
-0.0112872506,
0.0014899903,
0.0434769839,
0.0750114918,
-0.0299063642,
-0.0124448156,
-0.0785966814,
-0.0036212637,
-0.0317523293,
-0.0221662149,
-0.0168245453,
-0.0024859309,
-0.0355587974,
-0.0528388359,
0.0512475967,
0.0389377847,
0.0167997312,
0.0021358016,
0.0126700336,
-0.0052193454,
0.053348314,
-0.0304203816,
-0.0107215345,
0.0055592018,
0.0051047052,
0.0366866961,
0.0385093912,
-0.0340123177,
-0.0587390848,
-0.0024932637,
-0.0287522022,
0.0545276143,
0.0182101745,
-0.0009021073,
-0.0686834604,
0.0292997509,
-0.0289067365,
0.0161778443,
0.0025936312,
0.0549398921,
0.0363363735,
-0.0214856416,
-0.0279594623,
0.0223227106,
-0.0273687895,
-0.0204583555,
0.0041675409,
-0.001003019,
-0.0149673466,
-0.0559059195,
-0.0310612191,
0.0105757285,
0.0408882499,
0.0131430207,
0.0357156582,
-0.0958188474,
-0.0563057512,
-0.0386562645,
0.0568495616,
-0.0786307082,
-0.0714011788,
-0.0058176643,
0.0003125683,
-0.0316564366,
-0.0894306824,
-0.0109312506,
-0.0105320159,
0.0768709034,
-0.01283383,
0.0008337261,
-0.0268868655,
-0.0327566788,
-0.0133171417,
-0.0089294119,
-0.0171860456,
0.0273719523,
-0.0520941056,
-0.0534557328,
-0.0001802162,
-0.0244966745,
-0.0121205319,
0.0567899384,
-0.1038565934,
-0.0589118227,
-0.0226096064,
0.042936679,
0.0138881989,
0.011858711,
-0.0259189028,
-0.0155735202,
0.121607013,
0.0339473374,
0.0327500068,
0.0473811477,
-0.0089694951,
-0.0352664925,
-0.0069877673,
-0.0023687957,
-0.0018459152,
0.0684031919,
-0.019987965,
0.0287490431,
-0.015149029,
0.0197826698,
0.0033083893,
-0.0493924432,
-0.0287186317,
-0.0508900993,
0.0613077618,
-0.0499377288,
0.0006993058,
-0.018516561,
0.0158389118,
-0.0699834228,
-0.0118553918,
0.0596984439,
0.0176057089,
-0.0097726816,
-0.0216560923,
0.0211602207,
0.0233410746,
-0.0020063506,
-0.0014545866,
-0.0041846605,
0.0600907058,
0.0172924194,
0.0086651444,
-0.0020255139,
-0.0034538584,
-0.052206967,
0.0214371886,
0.0079360669,
0.0510876849,
0.0220430791,
-0.023986537,
-0.0007711802,
0.044080101,
-0.023023393,
-0.023287937,
-0.0462965071,
0.0267015006,
0.0368776806,
0.0447075069,
0.0470275246,
-0.0137801133,
0.0085944524,
-0.0236796923,
0.0244598649,
-0.0111037865,
-0.0101772882,
-0.0028637615,
-0.0147527521,
0.0292619299,
-0.0411291309,
0.0656048879,
0.0053843632,
-0.0064391079,
-0.0183109194,
0.0245315935,
-0.0210455824,
-0.0290673021,
-0.0369219445,
-0.0427378006,
0.0496870279,
0.0278662704,
-0.012649524,
-0.0595177673,
0.0086847851,
0.026225334,
0.0389955454,
-0.0152537441,
0.0399714597,
0.013381918,
-0.0245283041,
0.0385078155,
-0.0257837996,
0.0155879557,
-0.0196378846,
-0.0226136893,
0.0073278621,
-5.860395495e-33,
-0.0452442057,
-0.0355924517,
0.0102981161,
-0.0359439552,
-0.0557947941,
0.0138807371,
-0.0350625142,
0.012710182,
0.0265498739,
0.0124736587,
0.0243523624,
0.0077433693,
0.0185268912,
0.0527878888,
-0.0392378792,
0.0482712388,
0.0351329409,
-0.0304463692,
-0.0031268597,
0.0502160527,
-0.0037918363,
0.0266557299,
0.0047161477,
-0.0519381166,
-0.0185995363,
-0.0354522318,
-0.0244584791,
-0.0521547571,
0.0385264345,
0.0255730469,
-0.033809457,
0.0114598982,
0.0126529466,
0.007408842,
-0.0266179703,
0.0536640286,
-0.01386749,
-0.009634655,
-0.0299102198,
-0.0188721865,
-0.098436892,
-0.0279403497,
0.0143768862,
-0.0221300963,
-0.0006700283,
0.009668095,
0.0495458879,
-0.0099444427,
-0.0017507684,
0.0175467636,
-0.0589566939,
0.0222793166,
-0.0126973176,
-0.0100181745,
-0.0122289332,
-0.0070573068,
0.030644197,
0.0252564307,
-0.0274744499,
0.03788675,
0.0511484519,
0.0365493298,
-0.0001023677,
0.0594648905,
0.0153802792,
0.0431913584,
0.0045263041,
0.0147324577,
-0.0106029091,
0.0053673764,
0.0121449875,
0.0364152044,
0.03418798,
0.0236326586,
0.0164678562,
-0.0429906547,
-0.0690152347,
0.0273715593,
-0.0894960538,
-0.0584306456,
0.0545291975,
0.0180510543,
0.0254697576,
0.0098664872,
-0.0248719547,
-0.0235289149,
0.0016812558,
-0.0411867313,
0.0236777663,
0.0460878015,
-0.0212055277,
-0.0106669329,
0.0361617096,
0.0158453193,
-0.0404608138,
-0.0195743442,
-0.0465859994,
0.0559362061,
-0.0142931035,
-0.004698561,
-0.0297418442,
-0.0544746667,
0.0526745319,
0.0656675249,
-0.0115563795,
0.0266138799,
-0.002539156,
-0.0137713738,
-0.0417876318,
0.0051894607,
-0.0437069349,
0.0402365588,
0.0253892057,
0.0553179011,
-0.0016963199,
-0.0240313075,
-0.0513637103,
0.0255870633,
0.0045145368,
0.0079600066,
0.0042923912,
-0.002685349,
-0.0131611144,
0.0459899604,
-0.0432350747,
0.01844199,
-0.0406828187,
0.0476838537,
0.0553782322,
-0.0718506426,
-0.0477659404,
0.0198575482,
2.552e-7,
0.0266508628,
0.0071815029,
0.0316512808,
0.0256034918,
0.0206192322,
0.017601084,
-0.0238697454,
0.0111079374,
-0.0112678176,
-0.0594799593,
0.0226145759,
0.0695792809,
0.0493178964,
-0.0068302695,
-0.0357236639,
0.035019666,
-0.0369344801,
0.0354974717,
-0.0171252899,
0.0003345923,
0.0494647734,
0.0378548428,
-0.0197927188,
-0.0378682204,
0.0472254939,
-0.0107749887,
0.1072093248,
-0.0052332664,
0.0271932147,
-0.0210601911,
-0.0387698077,
-0.0302425958,
-0.0286177769,
-0.0046924306,
-0.0028556902,
-0.0427818038,
0.040419817,
0.0065772859,
-0.0670200363,
0.0185734332,
0.0416742712,
0.0329731256,
-0.0054790061,
-0.0136788171,
0.0370211489,
0.0051671569,
-0.0030140649,
-0.022724716,
-0.0332874507,
0.0100891786,
0.0495958365,
-0.0549294055,
-0.0666414648,
0.0199085437,
0.0322315209,
0.0284197628,
-0.0038149264,
-0.0207149256,
-0.0151432697,
-0.0571116246,
-0.0475966111,
-0.0253287368,
-0.1086728573,
0.0213361233,
-0.0186758302,
0.0123390835,
-0.0070648179,
1.84016466e-34,
0.0226728786,
-0.0196469594,
-0.0147199761,
-0.0011778416,
0.0279880837,
0.0024211379,
-0.001292519,
-0.0086187292,
-0.0121237459,
-0.0178238545,
-0.0231494885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12443v1 | Understanding and Predicting Human Label Variation in Natural Language Inference through Explanation | 2023-04-24T20:45:09 | 2023-04-24T20:45:09 | Nan-Jiang Jiang, Chenhao Tan, Marie-Catherine de Marneffe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (Plank 2022), or annotation disagreement, exists in
many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. To be robust and trusted, NLP
models need to identify such variation and be able to explain it. To this end,
we created the first ecologically valid explanation dataset with diverse
reasoning, LiveNLI. LiveNLI contains annotators' highlights and free-text
explanations for the label(s) of their choice for 122 English Natural Language
Inference items, each with at least 10 annotations. We used its explanations
for chain-of-thought prompting, and found there is still room for improvement
in GPT-3's ability to predict label distribution with in-context learning. | [
0.0593832135,
0.0227325391,
-0.0153458137,
0.0118732573,
-0.0094569316,
0.0402672701,
0.0223970152,
-0.0252339952,
0.0119226845,
-0.0210694764,
0.0046109133,
0.0129661802,
0.0057964679,
-0.0083565703,
0.0371312127,
-0.0798116401,
0.025543185,
-0.0064198961,
0.0245804358,
0.0152399559,
0.0250199493,
0.0264106616,
-0.0221620891,
0.0689677596,
-0.006798591,
-0.0146650486,
-0.0469369851,
-0.0034249609,
0.0393671133,
-0.0155415945,
0.0192108452,
0.0544946566,
0.0273285042,
0.009190225,
0.0000017566,
-0.0315487944,
0.0144634554,
-0.0048366566,
-0.0712716132,
0.0120873051,
-0.0087200962,
0.0458233282,
0.02521546,
-0.0001328089,
-0.0002482988,
0.0156987254,
0.0651924685,
0.0615798794,
0.0448114648,
0.0030969412,
0.0159500558,
-0.02752419,
-0.0680816472,
-0.0260676816,
0.0459772721,
-0.0541825518,
-0.0128883943,
-0.0108123384,
-0.0097365323,
0.0596000776,
-0.0137495929,
-0.0166651215,
0.0425935052,
-0.0084388619,
-0.0063226353,
0.0420978256,
-0.0247200076,
-0.053341832,
0.0040054829,
0.0648878217,
0.0622497126,
-0.0338450968,
-0.0124811428,
-0.02843998,
0.027009733,
0.0134163471,
-0.0136509053,
0.0238445122,
-0.0499204807,
0.0043747164,
0.0277529433,
-0.0053730593,
0.0167322438,
0.0261613894,
0.0207570642,
0.1005130187,
-0.0110703949,
-0.0084088966,
0.0394418314,
0.0257021245,
-0.0733438283,
-0.0406802855,
0.0090037817,
-0.0084937857,
-0.0423588865,
0.0149422185,
-0.0106041236,
-0.0316210315,
0.010851685,
0.0285538118,
0.0116186012,
0.0283601042,
-0.056738846,
0.0309640896,
0.0483857058,
0.0339888968,
-0.0171896629,
0.0372047387,
-0.0168716628,
-0.0378819294,
-0.0815360174,
-0.0227073617,
0.0017219024,
0.0019328502,
-0.0320283547,
0.0216205698,
-0.0233186763,
-0.0003734159,
-0.0391584858,
-0.0368583389,
0.0258152522,
0.0381080769,
-0.0362465456,
-0.0056252815,
-0.0746758655,
0.0383816995,
-0.0818764642,
0.0328501835,
0.0452831201,
-0.0541380197,
-0.0402680971,
0.0204972271,
-0.004836902,
-0.0443099737,
-0.0124763548,
0.0248880368,
0.0034221613,
0.0021847934,
-0.0388307013,
-0.0265340302,
-0.0314625055,
-0.0412030146,
-0.0180009361,
-0.0284859054,
0.0141795725,
0.0037950971,
-0.015107804,
-0.0306604691,
0.0089876316,
0.0255554672,
-0.0546292961,
0.0876486227,
-0.0404121764,
-0.0088275122,
0.0223324969,
0.0152492225,
-0.0418731757,
0.0279922877,
-0.0166211464,
-0.0179536752,
0.0313604437,
-0.0136176879,
0.0202474482,
-0.0213919729,
0.0072073312,
-0.0272178091,
0.0286056828,
-0.0105598867,
-0.0259069074,
0.0351381153,
0.0362300538,
0.0061323638,
-0.0229531527,
-0.0369389281,
0.0464829095,
0.0678656101,
-0.0192883909,
-0.0375956967,
0.0449928641,
0.0284091011,
-0.0039563407,
0.0179741569,
-0.0633605719,
0.0291196425,
-0.0024342907,
-0.012254064,
0.0206661932,
-0.0221598707,
-0.0209756028,
-0.0550448708,
-0.0308944006,
0.0253353771,
-0.0109811584,
0.0057224683,
0.0157116037,
0.0081191789,
0.0029441714,
0.0635260269,
0.0509813353,
-0.0479126535,
-0.0276908111,
-0.0345528983,
0.0561297163,
0.0550534092,
-0.0116317812,
-0.019006839,
-0.0139199896,
-0.0262266602,
0.0464394502,
0.0416154824,
0.0442247987,
-0.0136863543,
0.0382518657,
-0.0335462615,
-0.028748082,
-0.0074108546,
0.0315454192,
0.0028738859,
0.0327005126,
-0.0247321688,
0.0075332974,
-0.0900202468,
-0.0201813839,
0.0395160206,
0.0011194054,
-0.0280377176,
-0.0046757679,
0.0119449701,
0.0364585817,
0.0209007021,
0.0211046208,
0.002462894,
-0.0046427073,
0.0031617649,
-0.001857838,
0.0329158753,
-0.0317428,
-0.0414522886,
0.0181195345,
-0.0494076423,
-0.0657919794,
-0.0118406676,
-0.0857008547,
-0.041201055,
-0.027172057,
-0.0520394817,
-0.026338838,
-0.0335432515,
-0.0645696372,
0.0183427613,
0.0069185272,
-0.0439114124,
0.0685754567,
0.0029266111,
0.0276876204,
0.000332632,
0.0309760328,
0.0179676004,
-0.0160585083,
0.0365215614,
-0.0026866186,
0.0129497312,
-0.0341455825,
0.0283252113,
0.0158214197,
-0.0723185167,
0.0314131416,
-0.0653538182,
-0.0030709379,
-0.0157930087,
0.0189213753,
0.0423717164,
-0.0150284749,
0.0142744603,
-0.0252895262,
-0.0061484003,
0.0110636251,
-0.0529070608,
0.0406555757,
0.0571487322,
-0.0221980512,
0.0178747848,
-0.0241537727,
0.0098531479,
-0.0381369181,
0.052939713,
0.0117422305,
-0.0231645871,
-0.0685337558,
-0.0350941643,
-0.0391707495,
-0.0129816802,
0.0083023692,
-0.0072476943,
0.0510270037,
0.0276221,
0.0460703112,
0.0489741787,
0.0042629121,
0.0547443181,
0.0165224038,
0.0020800191,
-0.0582360104,
-0.0043538576,
-0.0324170627,
-0.0430043116,
-0.0027017265,
-0.0360700078,
-0.0077434038,
0.0928143635,
0.0070269215,
0.0040431009,
-0.0767451525,
-0.0134146316,
0.0078545408,
-0.017918665,
-0.0359159671,
-0.0158922318,
-0.0233070403,
0.0763315335,
-0.0198207144,
-0.0321878344,
0.1083722115,
0.0032362156,
-0.0047904053,
-0.0519242361,
-0.0026726797,
0.0015474034,
0.0809696764,
-0.0233118106,
-0.0130578671,
0.0540714003,
-0.0200300291,
-0.0256204773,
0.0048495647,
0.0606213808,
0.0117669208,
0.0269293115,
-0.0822606608,
-0.0061154678,
0.0175038669,
-0.0094888899,
-0.0264884271,
-0.021742478,
-0.0686532035,
0.0002861695,
0.0012691988,
-0.0025980594,
-0.0101197027,
-0.0173945408,
0.033009693,
0.0279647745,
-0.0046138652,
-0.0096500479,
-0.0129715474,
0.0031466123,
0.0175230801,
0.0447634682,
0.0383065306,
-0.019108573,
-0.0154459244,
0.0491766185,
-0.005500529,
0.0049977712,
-0.001001625,
0.0313643478,
-0.0131113129,
-0.0185792372,
-0.0162615292,
0.0267230328,
0.0701850355,
-0.050942108,
-0.0161517225,
0.0887824446,
0.0322508737,
-0.050715249,
0.0227061361,
-0.0424261242,
0.0850223079,
0.0316453576,
0.0021839789,
-0.0789445043,
-0.0741979107,
0.0071356231,
0.0234800857,
-0.0012642475,
-0.0238304883,
-0.0110664228,
-0.0962660834,
0.0412117019,
-0.0382855386,
-0.0659366027,
0.0039519253,
-0.0765177459,
0.0150404796,
-0.0088255517,
0.0037164325,
-0.0112417098,
0.0542158075,
0.0507280603,
0.0573114194,
-0.0193939861,
-0.0457702167,
0.0480016135,
-0.0253379233,
0.0308737792,
0.0224492531,
0.0158636142,
-0.0060795574,
-0.0568987206,
0.0739916265,
-0.0335624292,
0.008986746,
-0.0061016693,
0.0715994835,
0.0205750577,
-0.0114888698,
-0.0680441707,
0.0643334836,
-0.0426833369,
-0.0470119268,
0.0100332778,
0.082406126,
-0.0129425339,
0.0023629919,
-0.0063661523,
0.0237101931,
0.0094916858,
0.0878849924,
0.0575464666,
-0.0386227816,
-0.0415658467,
-0.0367470309,
0.0052047949,
-0.0054446338,
-0.0258136578,
0.0501661971,
0.0154168857,
-0.0615861155,
-0.0132152271,
-0.0514874682,
0.0216581672,
0.023540305,
-0.0057015633,
-0.0123734428,
-0.0048408979,
0.0127895419,
0.0011155636,
0.0726946741,
0.0013293576,
0.0013361592,
0.027917482,
-0.0262493584,
0.000188063,
0.0015844443,
-0.0358659439,
0.0558816977,
-0.039814923,
-0.0342020579,
0.001590573,
0.0153923277,
0.0286177434,
0.063161768,
0.0116384197,
-0.0488864221,
-0.0562313832,
0.0319546349,
0.0369020291,
-0.0043690102,
0.0063035614,
0.0391493924,
0.0228132755,
0.0488238186,
-0.0197049305,
0.0082383184,
0.0095583219,
0.017233748,
0.0023143445,
-0.0374554694,
0.0446546115,
-0.0183585957,
0.0391468182,
-0.027002193,
-0.0066757537,
-0.0438148752,
0.0004554751,
0.0224771202,
-0.033140339,
-0.0173579417,
0.0243585929,
-0.0079079354,
-0.0624223873,
-0.0226041675,
-0.0260216314,
-0.0129657332,
0.0418270193,
-0.0206165425,
-0.0530683771,
0.0541651361,
0.0253368802,
-0.0366372913,
-0.0064025559,
-0.0267620496,
-0.0249655619,
-0.0157603025,
0.0761743858,
0.011132611,
0.0873362049,
0.0585083365,
-0.0104385726,
0.0356015712,
-0.0206848755,
-0.0724802837,
-0.0403123051,
0.0155890901,
-0.0141117992,
0.0103247538,
-0.0233073924,
0.0337450989,
-0.0011648114,
-0.0168920718,
0.0077938261,
0.0463459305,
0.0181580074,
-0.0091423234,
0.0371830538,
0.0093205208,
-0.0283687524,
-0.0145301837,
0.0576234274,
0.0288755447,
0.0047873459,
0.0078184688,
-0.026408447,
-0.0113304891,
0.0080346875,
-0.0576648824,
0.0500779115,
0.0283379983,
0.0233779754,
-0.0563401096,
-0.0442884862,
-0.0010886139,
-0.0012546929,
0.0130943134,
0.0206403732,
0.03868296,
0.072960645,
-0.0279783811,
-0.0810195804,
-0.0021722873,
0.0024914162,
0.0062849629,
0.0133823212,
-0.057501927,
-6.267855632e-33,
-0.0208692849,
-0.061091017,
-0.0280700326,
-0.0236596651,
0.0019801727,
-0.0074269827,
-0.0615736283,
-0.0237133019,
-0.0241140053,
0.0763486326,
0.0123974103,
0.0399201587,
0.0270214938,
0.037820287,
0.0408413932,
-0.0520324707,
-0.0080740778,
0.0270405691,
-0.0288462639,
0.0231217463,
0.0451557115,
-0.0047872765,
0.0905447826,
-0.0927042887,
0.0669503659,
0.0306022428,
0.0067844605,
0.0159473531,
-0.0450243466,
0.0194929391,
-0.0032312078,
0.066252172,
0.0226093922,
-0.0671214908,
0.0255328305,
0.0224474464,
-0.0615497939,
-0.0696835816,
0.0550736077,
-0.0091277007,
-0.0659549981,
-0.0196743142,
0.0079795327,
0.0005331184,
0.0275791269,
-0.0195777863,
0.062051747,
0.0007949693,
0.0255393349,
0.0093637183,
-0.0163805038,
0.0129682813,
-0.032597132,
-0.0073288432,
-0.0296394527,
0.0457508862,
-0.0162340198,
0.034307763,
-0.0480285548,
-0.0024519465,
0.0014158243,
0.0029531945,
0.0458157063,
-0.0090159969,
-0.0200931504,
0.0454266258,
0.0052372362,
0.0093964087,
-0.0684054792,
-0.0414536893,
-0.035053812,
0.0376705788,
0.0702660978,
0.0453911759,
0.0263441242,
0.0461624861,
-0.0475696065,
0.0137172863,
-0.0118019311,
0.0032305461,
0.0055267587,
0.0034649118,
-0.0300704259,
-0.0383954048,
-0.0555488728,
-0.0416433103,
-0.0459615923,
0.0094300667,
0.0471049212,
-0.0284692142,
-0.0261148028,
0.0210964158,
-0.0077085993,
-0.0036015147,
-0.0193986688,
-0.0126321176,
-0.0095556518,
-0.0278735124,
0.016849516,
0.0128932809,
-0.0390427858,
-0.0043464298,
0.0016191727,
0.0191962719,
0.0397924855,
-0.0014774131,
0.0575558506,
-0.020214593,
-0.0246338882,
-0.0161357354,
-0.0654156953,
-0.0128248492,
-0.0558885783,
-0.0273278542,
0.0447145589,
0.0463591814,
-0.0374269895,
0.0445605293,
0.0447952859,
0.0002026608,
-0.0035038535,
-0.0122200502,
-0.0379002914,
-0.0002262445,
0.0113309808,
-0.0025986708,
0.0101779569,
-0.0264084022,
-0.0039762342,
-0.0296645407,
-0.0070958692,
0.0294241793,
2.382e-7,
0.0479908437,
0.0452325195,
0.0266096015,
-0.0551498011,
0.0091555528,
0.0414541587,
0.049997516,
-0.0128003443,
-0.0107099526,
-0.1057482436,
-0.0222532526,
0.0262835175,
0.0494093969,
0.0258632265,
-0.0115124835,
-0.0279626139,
-0.040345449,
0.0023201546,
-0.0405260958,
0.0152568836,
0.1081372052,
0.0481418148,
0.0497195795,
-0.0063951253,
0.015070823,
0.0200118143,
0.0199041441,
-0.0268394779,
0.0468370877,
-0.0280939694,
0.0457650498,
-0.0185801927,
0.0353538245,
0.066066809,
0.0004545994,
-0.0549474619,
-0.0013309025,
0.0327231921,
-0.0268530492,
-0.0348714404,
-0.0592514984,
-0.0148975765,
0.0221539848,
-0.0697572902,
0.0515105911,
-0.0374548659,
-0.0545830391,
0.0121785216,
-0.0388877206,
-0.0285823401,
0.0056806672,
0.0027722644,
0.0007789214,
0.0027749606,
-0.0189704895,
0.0086558266,
-0.0240183976,
-0.0849588066,
-0.0422620177,
0.0243054498,
-0.0435813256,
0.0051703341,
-0.011930055,
0.0113534322,
0.0469813496,
-0.0513522103,
-0.0228271,
1.723521756e-34,
-0.0141696138,
0.0233415794,
0.0479539074,
0.0310743619,
0.0498591624,
0.0203240085,
0.0150043052,
-0.0157793276,
0.0294709019,
-0.0266034976,
-0.0138540249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12425v1 | TIGTEC : Token Importance Guided TExt Counterfactuals | 2023-04-24T20:11:58 | 2023-04-24T20:11:58 | Milan Bhan, Jean-Noel Vittaut, Nicolas Chesneau, Marie-Jeanne Lesot | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ME | Counterfactual examples explain a prediction by highlighting changes of
instance that flip the outcome of a classifier. This paper proposes TIGTEC, an
efficient and modular method for generating sparse, plausible and diverse
counterfactual explanations for textual data. TIGTEC is a text editing
heuristic that targets and modifies words with high contribution using local
feature importance. A new attention-based local feature importance is proposed.
Counterfactual candidates are generated and assessed with a cost function
integrating semantic distance, while the solution space is efficiently explored
in a beam search fashion. The conducted experiments show the relevance of
TIGTEC in terms of success rate, sparsity, diversity and plausibility. This
method can be used in both model-specific or model-agnostic way, which makes it
very convenient for generating counterfactual explanations. | [
0.0826767907,
0.0058291606,
-0.0150818508,
0.0101325456,
-0.0658047572,
-0.0008835616,
0.0176840015,
-0.0065442966,
-0.0145466989,
-0.0753020197,
0.0337331221,
-0.0117810583,
-0.0042562112,
0.0887934715,
0.018074872,
-0.0580242649,
0.0566121191,
0.0198068563,
0.0230515227,
-0.0023383738,
-0.0181146245,
-0.0038794852,
0.0058252024,
0.0376415327,
-0.0082286261,
0.0039455071,
-0.0194543321,
0.029498715,
0.0559044443,
-0.0034599677,
0.0026816207,
0.0150605598,
-0.015952047,
0.0263392348,
0.0000024466,
-0.0259401985,
-0.0568869635,
0.0268731955,
-0.0420708954,
-0.0096841641,
0.0083607463,
0.0290732719,
-0.0183132384,
-0.0139378915,
-0.0075757816,
0.0636577085,
0.0758234262,
0.0616318844,
0.0593710504,
0.0844329596,
-0.0095538413,
0.003964433,
-0.026859777,
-0.008535332,
0.0553910211,
-0.0217394456,
-0.0002361435,
-0.0139561808,
-0.016801374,
0.0279258378,
-0.0098351147,
0.0173046105,
0.0246230904,
-0.0499055386,
0.064471595,
0.0248998217,
-0.021626601,
0.0123757673,
0.0101118712,
0.0127646066,
-0.003961097,
-0.0663232058,
-0.00886166,
-0.0477031469,
0.0265975557,
0.0365472808,
-0.0190934464,
-0.0334950536,
-0.0008096304,
-0.0226883944,
0.0377551988,
0.0151220988,
0.0256702751,
0.0104411375,
-0.0039827921,
0.0224613491,
0.0039169351,
-0.0367329195,
-0.0790732428,
-0.0332541242,
-0.0370244794,
-0.0650944486,
0.0435214937,
0.0370827764,
-0.0283427015,
-0.0229255892,
-0.0200854167,
-0.0553338565,
0.0252028573,
-0.0895513967,
-0.0026714411,
0.0180377271,
-0.0262924787,
0.0588466264,
-0.029047668,
0.0226005763,
0.0003390254,
-0.0090943296,
-0.0429523773,
-0.0206635483,
-0.0354610719,
-0.0278558582,
-0.0442283191,
0.0152847217,
-0.0687525272,
0.010393234,
0.0171566997,
0.0015006815,
-0.0335008092,
-0.0072395504,
0.0045091715,
0.0605518185,
-0.0357403085,
-0.0440860875,
0.0033349143,
-0.0141933048,
-0.0455799289,
0.0011106449,
-0.0237344336,
-0.0184547026,
-0.0368310213,
0.0137416339,
0.0022693519,
-0.044432357,
0.0044327751,
0.0895887688,
-0.007663677,
-0.0278642885,
-0.0141810086,
-0.0402579829,
-0.0418388806,
-0.0478448793,
-0.0320152305,
-0.0415921248,
-0.0674165189,
0.0075547681,
-0.019782139,
-0.0112196598,
0.0177076645,
-0.0093086762,
-0.0282831863,
0.0390259288,
-0.0173270963,
-0.0193285346,
0.0469543189,
-0.0115664611,
-0.0251862854,
0.0150383292,
0.0200822186,
0.0351890214,
0.0458257683,
-0.0259993449,
0.031149378,
-0.0482233651,
0.0458311699,
-0.008700503,
-0.0462583154,
0.0140704773,
-0.0038171927,
-0.0103190364,
0.0095124012,
-0.0301336199,
-0.0077599469,
-0.0271081235,
0.0541636497,
-0.0075445096,
-0.0179055016,
0.030936351,
0.0112116328,
0.0272764806,
-0.0617932305,
0.025285827,
-0.0435196608,
0.0854671896,
-0.0887743831,
-0.0106231431,
0.020746015,
-0.0202379264,
-0.0041303001,
-0.0409821905,
-0.0066704527,
0.0300524328,
0.0184789244,
0.0065748612,
0.04200048,
0.0061342046,
-0.0514569283,
0.0028357829,
0.0156871732,
-0.0186889023,
-0.0315007828,
-0.0325156786,
-0.0139356656,
0.0922058448,
0.0457713567,
-0.0843901187,
-0.0386540592,
-0.0188291874,
-0.0430302694,
-0.0008572807,
0.0324459113,
0.0206840318,
-0.0137741659,
-0.0158974137,
0.0034964543,
-0.0714286715,
0.0485590324,
0.0276764911,
-0.0183315519,
-0.0044802902,
0.0131210638,
-0.0126049733,
-0.0291558448,
0.0226954482,
0.044000335,
-0.0007038141,
0.0391654596,
-0.0011488308,
0.012360787,
0.0130357044,
-0.0083474722,
0.0048840535,
0.0231784787,
0.0026713298,
-0.0452441052,
0.0270586926,
-0.0015748934,
-0.0626687706,
-0.0123311915,
-0.0476088487,
-0.0340144634,
0.0385687351,
-0.0404369831,
-0.0404149145,
0.0533226505,
-0.0983541459,
0.0443530753,
-0.0391362011,
0.0238831993,
-0.0089265928,
0.0050769355,
-0.0371672623,
0.0697116777,
-0.0242131501,
0.0195150655,
-0.0285178535,
-0.0109349489,
0.0302614402,
-0.0358071439,
0.0256308243,
-0.0077150413,
-0.010135497,
-0.0534093529,
0.0191378724,
-0.0099811964,
0.0103062093,
0.0021607687,
-0.0598101914,
-0.0243919566,
-0.0497864671,
-0.0060473322,
0.0287215989,
-0.000779296,
0.0031585004,
-0.0345328264,
0.0237932764,
-0.0269366559,
-0.0122609865,
0.0210686363,
0.0503959432,
0.0057950742,
0.0101965861,
-0.0191294067,
-0.0085088331,
-0.0087369597,
0.0722627416,
0.0352624729,
-0.033590097,
-0.0332547389,
0.012902447,
-0.0085992739,
-0.0225070845,
-0.0128832478,
-0.0361557342,
-0.0208536647,
0.0301395357,
0.0363360681,
0.045042254,
0.0309837051,
0.0275227241,
0.0344136506,
0.0123341186,
-0.0291680582,
0.0057162466,
0.0005758884,
0.0757714435,
0.0105973277,
-0.075704515,
-0.0085088909,
0.0352514312,
0.0116897281,
-0.03652687,
-0.0719766691,
0.0279759485,
0.0247618426,
-0.0264626052,
-0.0241516251,
-0.0284589045,
-0.0171224829,
0.0285498761,
-0.0343622006,
-0.0557272285,
0.1083290577,
0.0034198673,
0.012722184,
-0.0568035394,
-0.018925013,
-0.0234846696,
0.0578093827,
-0.0196789298,
0.0295092873,
-0.0050195623,
0.0032576434,
0.0233467575,
-0.0089444211,
0.0428666957,
0.0239273813,
0.0023648751,
-0.0447084233,
-0.0091948751,
0.0126234666,
0.0077355751,
-0.0157046448,
-0.0995411128,
0.0177173279,
0.0069483584,
0.0459598154,
-0.0233742222,
-0.0861481726,
0.0271266587,
0.0149629787,
0.0523702949,
-0.0148920659,
0.0038573015,
0.001756132,
-0.0171138048,
0.0119546521,
0.0181954447,
0.0616790019,
0.0070022484,
-0.0152729265,
0.0226748846,
-0.0099246083,
-0.0599792004,
0.0013803635,
-0.018538693,
-0.056536857,
-0.0599416047,
-0.0218250696,
-0.0272834208,
0.0390733592,
-0.0671370551,
-0.0046157092,
0.0484751612,
0.0585931093,
-0.0125057139,
0.0525160246,
-0.0382849276,
-0.0103887524,
0.024061447,
0.0065037999,
-0.012766026,
-0.0276071355,
0.0105986223,
-0.0016187456,
-0.0479982421,
-0.0221268069,
-0.0270210411,
-0.0409829654,
0.0513237976,
-0.0143922726,
0.0008277577,
-0.0491760336,
-0.0532238036,
-0.0056098471,
-0.0057265079,
-0.0788808689,
0.0176285096,
0.0234329458,
0.0267140809,
-0.0284941941,
-0.0189541057,
-0.0334955938,
0.0006398439,
0.0259886831,
0.0054351659,
0.082451269,
0.0182387773,
0.009009419,
0.015409234,
0.0134490049,
0.0196757969,
0.0558122545,
-0.0255991388,
0.0922512785,
0.013353141,
0.0156846642,
-0.0288233887,
0.0258984547,
0.0202479865,
-0.0597258247,
-0.0027151068,
0.0737463161,
-0.0408847816,
0.0199297965,
-0.0239660852,
0.0015515804,
0.0444187671,
0.0615570545,
0.0231278464,
-0.0326144062,
-0.0280506443,
-0.0391294248,
-0.0147286067,
-0.0425844304,
0.010130614,
-0.0644752234,
0.0388363674,
-0.016960144,
-0.045715943,
-0.0412928499,
0.0069539398,
0.0239512194,
-0.0063965716,
-0.0086275805,
-0.0769235045,
-0.0315152369,
-0.0454514399,
0.0110767074,
0.0309287794,
0.022321729,
0.0024395329,
-0.0263067335,
0.0241874792,
-0.0698485821,
-0.0413912013,
-0.0023126258,
-0.0487033166,
-0.0304694586,
0.0095011806,
0.0169323143,
0.0151683912,
0.051583793,
-0.011265655,
-0.0622296669,
0.029080119,
0.0426353812,
-0.0407171845,
0.0271821972,
0.0645887032,
-0.0259196162,
0.0034966359,
0.0313197039,
-0.0118360184,
-0.0101640327,
0.0433972888,
0.0298484508,
-0.0185069498,
0.0198079403,
0.0116516808,
-0.0349515527,
0.0593044087,
-0.0214015804,
-0.0146074519,
-0.0307060368,
0.0826392323,
-0.0265100095,
-0.0090807648,
-0.0172460489,
0.0392808393,
-0.0313467458,
-0.0354811661,
-0.0233552307,
0.0282223206,
-0.0550832152,
-0.0182137676,
-0.0345147513,
0.056233719,
0.0221766625,
0.0423914269,
0.0208894368,
0.0167870261,
-0.0017678945,
-0.0031894678,
0.0198667906,
0.0197210182,
0.0000057786,
0.0213076305,
0.0220957994,
-0.0227227416,
-0.0202014726,
-0.0018563725,
-0.1098968461,
0.0429238528,
-0.0479612239,
0.0329154804,
0.0198909882,
-0.0163907874,
0.0077781547,
-0.0182120353,
-0.0256087892,
0.0051195547,
0.0419769101,
0.0436032489,
-0.0386547819,
-0.0436730385,
0.003760234,
-0.0229358971,
0.0478553437,
0.0516510718,
-0.0329329185,
0.0552180856,
-0.0074235946,
-0.0235071145,
-0.0146904904,
-0.0470037684,
0.0179814007,
0.0790362805,
0.0055498397,
0.0169838257,
-0.0805286765,
-0.000380878,
0.0431834273,
-0.0168270897,
-0.0094162375,
0.016414186,
0.0248899329,
0.0352874659,
0.0120627731,
-0.0177407898,
-0.0312632732,
0.027548261,
0.0115053691,
0.0281775016,
-0.0403442308,
-6.988754726e-33,
-0.0178277921,
-0.0936901122,
-0.0210567955,
-0.0088305324,
0.0337247625,
-0.0010633599,
-0.0470518842,
-0.0383695066,
0.0144661367,
0.0344854407,
0.0093739154,
0.055177398,
0.001644893,
0.0108406488,
-0.0110904509,
0.0192584638,
0.0670014396,
0.0686234459,
-0.0154116852,
0.0408035815,
0.0323091932,
0.0284675658,
0.0966219902,
-0.0840307921,
0.0548425466,
0.0037894258,
-0.0028708219,
-0.0152106052,
-0.0822521746,
0.0407532342,
0.0007675632,
0.0174289495,
0.0039334628,
-0.0340613127,
-0.0284564402,
-0.0750804916,
0.0448591635,
-0.0518196151,
0.013928812,
-0.0067360168,
0.0199343674,
-0.0709370002,
0.0005333127,
0.0068343249,
-0.0027520638,
-0.0056884959,
0.0483781621,
-0.0283304472,
0.024619611,
0.0424068309,
-0.0813504979,
0.0551198646,
-0.052519653,
-0.0057207914,
-0.037730068,
0.0408419743,
0.0446113385,
-0.0158724356,
-0.0559402034,
0.0362053327,
0.0603848472,
-0.0011329881,
0.0386002362,
-0.0192371812,
0.0027489176,
0.0439409986,
0.0387464203,
0.0115363095,
-0.0143526075,
-0.0174994934,
-0.0319957733,
0.038183853,
0.0915965736,
0.0901592001,
0.0718686134,
0.0181006435,
-0.0509551689,
0.0103845028,
-0.065447934,
0.0255348943,
0.0583003834,
0.032187324,
-0.0083555505,
0.0060847644,
-0.0170684792,
-0.0229120199,
-0.0248373151,
-0.0073913778,
0.0033604759,
0.004541609,
-0.0382812247,
0.0504149944,
0.0336162262,
-0.0330630094,
0.0418612957,
0.048537299,
-0.0056548836,
0.0051949909,
0.0318858065,
-0.0178539548,
-0.0220054537,
0.0557100028,
0.0800157338,
0.0022910121,
0.0232269149,
-0.0118136872,
0.0468504652,
0.0109743606,
-0.0467813574,
0.0147768026,
0.0080084428,
-0.0133450544,
-0.0361835696,
-0.0353197083,
0.0093192495,
0.0069222725,
-0.0339983553,
0.0548159592,
0.0190459471,
0.0292980876,
-0.0382854044,
0.0230319817,
-0.0276224427,
0.0260835886,
0.0069666412,
0.0330827087,
0.0032444894,
-0.0105937421,
-0.0067846654,
-0.0281264,
-0.0240450576,
0.0388613045,
3.073e-7,
0.0526435524,
0.0598460734,
0.0273799542,
-0.0375239998,
0.0406855866,
0.0524037704,
0.0000401437,
0.0021225708,
0.0067269965,
0.0508606471,
0.0480281524,
0.0121094212,
0.0112080071,
0.0113414796,
0.0027553828,
0.0425631069,
-0.0702996626,
-0.0639473125,
-0.0327135399,
-0.0102387751,
0.0617475174,
0.0567465089,
0.0374763571,
0.0051844316,
0.0064002848,
0.0036511631,
0.0457794666,
-0.0158214029,
-0.0025642638,
-0.0065495186,
-0.0097784707,
-0.0238981545,
-0.0154005988,
0.0327825285,
-0.0299772285,
-0.0107255783,
-0.0392208025,
0.0070327688,
-0.0710378066,
-0.0432221852,
-0.0368691161,
-0.0147063248,
0.0180194173,
-0.056417983,
0.069897078,
0.0119005339,
-0.0155726429,
-0.0158693381,
-0.042254515,
0.048511371,
0.0281014871,
-0.0198675711,
-0.0080475807,
0.0083136084,
-0.0312667191,
0.032991115,
-0.0230275281,
-0.0539254993,
-0.0326911472,
0.0214083083,
-0.027471561,
0.0103953006,
-0.0545598231,
-0.0130407736,
0.0940033942,
-0.0434780791,
0.0105834119,
3.112263868e-34,
0.0546625257,
0.0382926539,
-0.0454746224,
-0.0074103368,
0.0418585949,
0.0149636678,
-0.0079454482,
0.0079373019,
0.0580823049,
-0.0133508425,
-0.0314229243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12410v2 | PEFT-Ref: A Modular Reference Architecture and Typology for Parameter-Efficient Finetuning Techniques | 2023-04-24T19:43:11 | 2023-10-19T15:08:05 | Mohammed Sabry, Anya Belz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) techniques aim to improve over
the considerable cost of fully finetuning large pretrained language models
(PLM). As different PEFT techniques proliferate, it is becoming difficult to
compare them, in particular in terms of (i) the structure and functionality
they add to the PLM, (ii) the different types and degrees of efficiency
improvements achieved, (iii) performance at different downstream tasks, and
(iv) how differences in structure and functionality relate to efficiency and
task performance. To facilitate such comparisons, this paper presents a
reference architecture which standardises aspects shared by different PEFT
techniques, while isolating differences to specific locations and interactions
with the standard components. Through this process of standardising and
isolating differences, a modular view of PEFT techniques emerges, supporting
not only direct comparison of different techniques and their efficiency and
task performance, but also systematic exploration of reusability and
composability of the different types of finetuned modules. We demonstrate how
the reference architecture can be applied to understand properties and relative
advantages of PEFT techniques, hence to inform selection of techniques for
specific tasks, and design choices for new PEFT techniques. | [
0.0261443853,
-0.0153068658,
-0.0070588537,
0.0069452343,
-0.0370606929,
0.02081245,
0.0249556154,
-0.0328073725,
-0.063510105,
-0.0470187329,
-0.0643798709,
-0.0211332254,
0.0556275249,
-0.0009566572,
0.0684928074,
-0.0945720896,
0.0399320349,
-0.057146702,
-0.0034227853,
0.0108625172,
0.0355017669,
-0.0015873292,
-0.0054091038,
0.0430219844,
0.0275128111,
0.012650216,
-0.0321066268,
0.0299905911,
0.0423142128,
0.0182963442,
0.0271043032,
0.0669717938,
-0.0042951489,
-0.0005110576,
0.0000021452,
-0.0001459208,
-0.0156997908,
0.0216041785,
0.0302028898,
0.0616560988,
0.0702930242,
0.0473798551,
-0.0430720486,
0.0290886611,
0.0035926099,
-0.0368048139,
0.0899009705,
0.0299617983,
0.0498340316,
0.0613181219,
-0.015872987,
-0.0229124855,
0.00016289,
-0.020045884,
-0.0669170916,
-0.0067624529,
0.0139124123,
-0.0168772452,
0.0392204449,
-0.0232961923,
-0.0240476411,
0.0265128836,
0.0039242748,
0.00283899,
-0.0298776086,
0.0077087623,
-0.0592543222,
-0.0345246568,
-0.0064881328,
0.0725624412,
-0.0839658976,
-0.0163252614,
0.0238301326,
-0.0190314576,
-0.0501051061,
-0.0156803448,
-0.0506311543,
-0.0018742789,
0.0070381747,
0.0354651175,
0.0383855477,
-0.0367297381,
0.0070137554,
0.0086324895,
-0.0382160321,
0.0569198057,
0.0382008106,
0.0041872561,
0.0219613761,
-0.022708863,
-0.0058250907,
-0.030032251,
0.0096447011,
0.0041158488,
-0.0072597666,
0.0055035995,
-0.0835864842,
-0.0172741134,
0.0186120216,
-0.0105926869,
0.0680997968,
0.0549988784,
-0.0256620813,
-0.0072767213,
-0.0500940457,
0.015741,
-0.0380611457,
0.0306557752,
-0.0731136575,
0.0188455693,
-0.02250796,
0.0028175563,
-0.0978522897,
0.0203642063,
-0.0410497673,
-0.0383096114,
-0.0214601792,
0.022480851,
0.0011409036,
-0.0141555332,
0.0252125803,
-0.0444331728,
-0.049515374,
-0.0106026642,
0.0240810793,
0.042104058,
-0.0298133418,
0.0058953944,
-0.0265317392,
-0.0724309981,
0.009389109,
0.0213746615,
-0.0125830676,
-0.0406533591,
-0.009549465,
0.0229283888,
-0.0257850233,
-0.0287367217,
-0.0356943607,
-0.0025415444,
-0.022592159,
-0.069047533,
-0.0021398638,
-0.0841738358,
-0.0120554594,
-0.0036316682,
0.0169354118,
-0.0158651564,
-0.0175730716,
0.0036958046,
-0.0282885805,
0.0289945994,
-0.0256512295,
0.0371367894,
0.0131148128,
-0.0177509617,
0.0357515775,
0.079435572,
0.0400139987,
0.0270015523,
0.0129153347,
-0.0271753035,
-0.0369564258,
0.0737551823,
-0.0198309366,
-0.0054324586,
-0.039027784,
-0.0225458574,
0.002061663,
-0.0282063689,
0.0358843021,
0.0513963588,
-0.0283171926,
0.028840242,
0.0452206396,
0.0100322226,
0.0608616471,
-0.003625355,
0.0560860597,
0.0219740476,
0.0454301499,
0.0240377635,
-0.0352856219,
0.0150293345,
-0.0083196266,
0.0306458473,
0.0245232638,
0.0645175725,
-0.0514424704,
0.0002547896,
-0.0038984574,
-0.0156768076,
0.0081634,
-0.0070814444,
0.0511766449,
0.0127814999,
-0.050228294,
0.0385242887,
0.0369933434,
-0.029282188,
-0.0176593903,
-0.0543614738,
-0.031571202,
0.0615476482,
0.012677202,
-0.0434758067,
-0.0558253303,
0.0477915667,
0.0226804782,
0.0315479971,
0.0924769491,
0.0045582508,
0.0061701448,
-0.0437433682,
-0.0371821448,
-0.0063641011,
0.0049320366,
0.020239884,
0.0248083062,
0.0003817822,
0.0207578074,
-0.03231024,
-0.0242169779,
0.0303145647,
0.0209307168,
0.0055207284,
-0.025026625,
0.0261092037,
0.0234593153,
0.0030370285,
-0.0283215046,
0.0118020931,
0.0131981904,
0.0037507399,
0.0594528951,
-0.0064650527,
-0.0157786999,
0.0073998584,
0.0250184797,
-0.0115590496,
0.0222025178,
0.0219895802,
-0.0379821956,
-0.0830889717,
0.0006067227,
-0.0137118027,
0.0401800163,
-0.0411772951,
0.0481804423,
-0.0369625762,
0.0086645745,
-0.0282108039,
-0.0001215431,
0.0067288256,
-0.0009510466,
0.0434010737,
0.0176277459,
0.0517680608,
-0.0286293086,
-0.0862150416,
0.0319379494,
0.0084073516,
0.0108312266,
0.0205617063,
0.0254018568,
-0.0263819192,
-0.0399748646,
-0.0775828734,
0.0222605281,
-0.0351743698,
0.0430985838,
0.0109595936,
0.0152863385,
-0.0036506292,
-0.0009609666,
-0.0001334309,
0.0258348193,
-0.0322920904,
0.0300379507,
0.0024402139,
0.0190466046,
-0.0725051165,
-0.0499741435,
-0.0505105183,
0.0062607084,
0.0109954188,
-0.050998576,
-0.0463271663,
-0.091712147,
0.019739721,
-0.0154990889,
0.0611491017,
0.0048466446,
-0.0671964362,
0.0214272868,
-0.0341323689,
0.0480121784,
0.042593047,
-0.0407339558,
-0.0019012651,
0.0564268753,
-0.0154806934,
-0.0188382491,
0.0186279006,
-0.0323056802,
-0.0301928632,
-0.0412601121,
0.0129636489,
-0.0237147678,
0.0662149489,
-0.036608085,
0.0044735777,
-0.0777597278,
-0.0042322669,
-0.0168371666,
-0.0253290944,
0.0479614548,
-0.0142510552,
-0.0233455971,
0.0128978547,
-0.0244281441,
-0.0772267506,
0.0443055443,
-0.0728245825,
-0.008098159,
-0.006169958,
-0.019712925,
-0.000699893,
0.033872176,
0.044907432,
0.0153725836,
0.0354528502,
-0.0416232832,
-0.0642779246,
0.0097706616,
0.0292760823,
-0.0226982478,
0.0503302999,
-0.0522799045,
0.0179396793,
-0.0354016311,
0.0014074544,
0.0097826039,
0.0053745368,
-0.024869781,
0.0386048965,
0.0043303468,
-0.0339173488,
0.0039950805,
0.078064926,
0.0076790559,
0.0330601744,
-0.0380684547,
0.0186042245,
-0.0235065576,
0.0121292938,
0.0365911052,
0.0052960087,
0.0193308871,
-0.0316643044,
-0.0100785708,
-0.0090975743,
0.0239436328,
0.0143370526,
-0.067080155,
-0.0069388803,
0.0511788987,
-0.0487188771,
-0.060645204,
0.0229891818,
0.057224039,
-0.0851011798,
0.0147606209,
0.0915229246,
0.0220773164,
-0.0082381675,
0.0050115348,
0.0372097492,
0.0723749474,
-0.0018711245,
0.0352087207,
-0.0182506256,
-0.0194369387,
0.0140379081,
0.0299148653,
-0.0165395718,
0.038248308,
-0.007557001,
-0.0762265995,
0.0424752422,
0.0267752595,
-0.0276002102,
-0.041763898,
-0.0137013244,
0.019037975,
0.0109991226,
0.0045012743,
0.033086542,
-0.0274225157,
0.0070131607,
0.0257867519,
-0.0717833564,
-0.0507557653,
-0.0124610458,
-0.0305809192,
0.056254141,
0.0528098866,
-0.0218748301,
-0.0106614837,
-0.0092874514,
0.0378960557,
-0.0731520653,
0.0245634448,
-0.0536666811,
0.0257957801,
0.0085875569,
-0.037941657,
0.0228654239,
0.0113001782,
0.0057574594,
0.0014075246,
-0.0670753345,
0.0555195622,
-0.0329659432,
0.0098357126,
0.0038749797,
-0.0113113215,
-0.0043995031,
0.0159118846,
0.0239302106,
-0.0273086857,
-0.0283775516,
-0.0005291878,
-0.0465146452,
-0.0489661954,
-0.0088293124,
0.0123788817,
-0.0450926945,
-0.0405442975,
-0.0170447119,
0.0107482662,
0.0402902737,
0.0399367139,
0.0038083026,
0.006080382,
0.0339201279,
-0.007716612,
-0.0544516072,
0.0135613689,
-0.015073345,
0.0326517336,
-0.0519508161,
-0.0420822576,
0.0434601046,
-0.0008553401,
-0.0118038049,
0.0090463618,
-0.0485056005,
-0.0696827322,
0.0209885482,
0.0742816851,
0.022387024,
0.0140021164,
-0.0240873396,
-0.0885678381,
0.0047754101,
0.0030591972,
-0.0140749235,
0.032853011,
0.0386865214,
-0.0463052131,
-0.0167070292,
0.027210556,
-0.0387629718,
0.0155653423,
0.0052549406,
0.0400430486,
0.0221308507,
-0.0797701254,
0.0035202696,
0.0002499076,
0.0333205946,
-0.0307116639,
0.0078975912,
-0.0389047898,
0.0272134207,
0.0031037654,
0.0011046228,
-0.0631399304,
-0.0032850751,
0.000650956,
0.0276988465,
-0.0003423209,
-0.0023381247,
-0.0012105078,
0.0476649366,
-0.0005922985,
0.0490853377,
-0.0363347866,
0.0069026765,
0.0161611214,
0.0091975108,
-0.0088639176,
0.0395979732,
-0.0291732606,
0.0097229648,
-0.0516697094,
0.0521126837,
0.0218605641,
0.0187168606,
-0.0495882258,
0.0515686907,
-0.0069915997,
-0.0607687384,
-0.0644213259,
0.0018167199,
0.0439714715,
-0.0045196228,
0.1115373373,
-0.0379295424,
-0.0176605508,
-0.0228938349,
0.0504173338,
0.0098499414,
0.0261916015,
0.0085651735,
0.0251969527,
-0.0121924542,
-0.0220961627,
0.0305909347,
-0.0061171437,
0.0078322068,
-0.0007342392,
-0.024695456,
0.0023078865,
-0.0377723873,
-0.0207085852,
0.0015641446,
-0.032877028,
-0.0266726073,
-0.0497800522,
-0.024706101,
-0.0311541837,
0.0189593248,
-0.0214090087,
-0.0217193067,
0.0559803694,
0.0289520491,
-0.0066161687,
-0.0296925232,
-0.0093903933,
-0.0667540729,
0.0310581718,
-0.0025086047,
0.0076647201,
-6.237620448e-33,
-0.065267995,
0.027716469,
0.0106496364,
0.0418959633,
-0.072358273,
-0.0022582589,
-0.0128230834,
0.0127304755,
0.0025580446,
-0.0047447309,
0.01494422,
-0.0353403762,
0.033885736,
-0.0102895191,
-0.0162693188,
0.0270963572,
0.0812683627,
-0.0070596077,
0.0081232255,
0.0110652568,
0.0045664171,
0.021989692,
0.0746651068,
-0.0439267978,
-0.0428519882,
0.0016363752,
-0.0172607563,
0.0166683886,
0.0264129713,
0.0482348986,
0.0205569398,
0.0166442543,
-0.008205343,
-0.037471775,
-0.052844096,
0.0207154341,
-0.0893800035,
-0.0199782494,
0.0464525633,
0.0416274928,
0.0081200982,
-0.0117305908,
0.0566007681,
-0.0061549279,
0.0091005191,
-0.0175054185,
0.0072205826,
-0.0288777985,
-0.0002523121,
-0.0005765817,
-0.0893797651,
0.0467069037,
0.0276017543,
-0.005821873,
0.0620345622,
0.0201132037,
-0.0362190939,
-0.0220367387,
-0.0270043258,
-0.0107510705,
0.0828092918,
0.0864935294,
0.065371111,
0.0453066453,
0.0259636473,
-0.0129526164,
0.0472021177,
-0.0228997953,
0.0154229663,
0.0131617077,
0.091502361,
0.0511328727,
0.0024123471,
-0.0061679813,
0.0271691084,
-0.0080444375,
-0.0267332196,
-0.000651608,
0.0106145507,
0.0545636006,
0.0112436963,
0.0248290803,
-0.0008944786,
-0.0257500391,
-0.0618631244,
0.0103612803,
-0.0109424507,
-0.0415072963,
0.0412630253,
0.0009460367,
-0.0217246339,
0.0114026451,
0.0512245558,
-0.0178436916,
0.0211088303,
-0.0249039419,
-0.0577934906,
0.0808218718,
-0.0180790797,
0.0292462036,
-0.0474261269,
-0.0814484581,
0.0254623257,
-0.0168645456,
0.0234563611,
-0.0377766863,
0.0097990884,
0.0858062357,
-0.0570668019,
0.0251145922,
-0.0166297797,
-0.0202987902,
0.003229833,
0.0635065734,
0.0264209434,
-0.0008545551,
-0.0124207428,
0.0073418943,
-0.0129734976,
-0.0464421213,
-0.0412466004,
0.0057583051,
0.0431018919,
0.0192427672,
-0.0179226417,
0.0451023802,
-0.0288891997,
0.0197928827,
0.0523023382,
-0.0218046494,
-0.0262665953,
0.0607888252,
2.837e-7,
0.067345202,
0.0257833488,
0.0516457148,
0.0088578276,
0.0010203382,
-0.0008865888,
-0.0002460377,
0.0056561353,
0.0029466832,
0.0169267952,
0.0239791758,
0.0425752103,
0.0386620574,
0.0134894662,
-0.0404117033,
-0.0095031094,
-0.0047349357,
0.0295042079,
-0.0298390146,
-0.014080693,
0.0082480675,
0.0667942241,
0.0126991263,
-0.0147370007,
0.0156936459,
-0.0073069348,
0.0159114525,
-0.0188363697,
0.0307620503,
0.0493336543,
0.0067791548,
0.0388797708,
-0.0367871597,
0.0249694102,
0.0069514099,
0.0193172172,
0.0134946937,
0.07771869,
-0.0314468667,
0.0045829997,
0.0469304323,
-0.0253731348,
-0.0231131557,
-0.0688348785,
0.059450414,
-0.0754218549,
0.0107891606,
-0.0356807709,
-0.024086941,
0.0284125358,
-0.0267571975,
-0.025239978,
0.0121144252,
0.0682366192,
0.0432950109,
-0.0219649542,
-0.0352749787,
-0.0542759746,
-0.0283308886,
0.0696835816,
-0.0085571688,
-0.0789070874,
-0.0356653333,
-0.0534625463,
-0.0050730831,
-0.0346694961,
-0.0124650588,
2.983120661e-34,
0.0270604398,
-0.049955748,
0.0271814428,
0.0029193957,
-0.0222645737,
0.0072686668,
-0.0326936357,
0.0239744335,
-0.0173308421,
-0.0713918954,
-0.0481837243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12404v1 | Semantic Tokenizer for Enhanced Natural Language Processing | 2023-04-24T19:33:41 | 2023-04-24T19:33:41 | Sandeep Mehta, Darpan Shah, Ravindra Kulkarni, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditionally, NLP performance improvement has been focused on improving
models and increasing the number of model parameters. NLP vocabulary
construction has remained focused on maximizing the number of words represented
through subword regularization. We present a novel tokenizer that uses
semantics to drive vocabulary construction. The tokenizer includes a trainer
that uses stemming to enhance subword formation. Further optimizations and
adaptations are implemented to minimize the number of words that cannot be
encoded. The encoder is updated to integrate with the trainer. The tokenizer is
implemented as a drop-in replacement for the SentencePiece tokenizer. The new
tokenizer more than doubles the number of wordforms represented in the
vocabulary. The enhanced vocabulary significantly improves NLP model
convergence, and improves quality of word and sentence embeddings. Our
experimental results show top performance on two Glue tasks using BERT-base,
improving on models more than 50X in size. | [
0.0336155482,
0.0502589494,
-0.0009916124,
0.024795156,
-0.0218852554,
-0.0134866294,
0.0016012117,
0.0399872139,
-0.0376411192,
-0.0539719872,
0.0122148646,
0.021507524,
-0.0482800603,
0.0446610153,
0.0426062271,
-0.0922315717,
0.0625099912,
0.0206542034,
0.0118099889,
0.0280538835,
0.030807402,
0.0196852144,
0.034877453,
0.0658139065,
-0.0778628811,
0.0231875069,
-0.0203376245,
-0.0003669679,
-0.0236781389,
-0.0475991108,
-0.0067102937,
0.0141100399,
0.03928091,
-0.0111138085,
0.0000019248,
-0.0343353413,
-0.0209008716,
0.0186968073,
-0.010661683,
-0.0007174333,
0.0556479655,
-0.0632239357,
0.027145043,
0.0520905443,
-0.0177784432,
-0.0069809947,
0.0101125389,
0.0867239013,
0.0575768985,
0.0597650111,
-0.02230631,
-0.0241987482,
0.0626835376,
0.0217137393,
-0.0375411585,
-0.0111898612,
-0.0174956005,
-0.0374655947,
0.0372660384,
-0.0243946705,
-0.0154412864,
-0.0002324656,
0.0041655367,
-0.0047449274,
0.0750236288,
0.0189344827,
-0.0547662824,
-0.0359818824,
-0.019521093,
0.015261732,
-0.0428332575,
-0.0204988532,
-0.0199086182,
0.0022139912,
0.0134712765,
0.0220080875,
-0.0158678479,
-0.0144497342,
0.0113738887,
0.0196683686,
0.0462765656,
-0.0161103643,
0.0138184261,
-0.0051681926,
-0.0454812758,
0.0640319437,
0.0418536142,
-0.0542345047,
-0.0254762266,
-0.0082018021,
-0.018509822,
-0.0725722313,
0.0262893811,
-0.0050104843,
-0.0669980943,
0.0077805086,
-0.0638826638,
-0.0433919355,
0.0039944868,
-0.0371157005,
-0.0269810837,
0.0314995535,
0.0392985269,
0.0214452464,
-0.047585316,
0.0212258156,
0.0094587496,
0.0285071991,
-0.0622535087,
-0.0477653556,
-0.0497486778,
-0.026212085,
-0.1069011241,
0.081045866,
-0.0286819506,
-0.0745521337,
-0.0033517156,
0.0242556017,
0.0271598231,
-0.0258094203,
-0.0196487047,
0.0149223693,
-0.0054777609,
0.0051841377,
-0.004113018,
-0.020058142,
-0.0722451583,
-0.0167579837,
0.0242677201,
-0.0243038479,
-0.01826551,
0.0089491727,
0.0454754047,
-0.012737656,
-0.015452222,
0.0246101432,
-0.0079659326,
-0.0682928562,
-0.0217962246,
-0.0124480492,
-0.0000104917,
-0.0179726258,
-0.0512502491,
-0.0623571426,
0.0288768187,
0.009443948,
-0.0158112887,
-0.0193440337,
-0.0017339144,
0.0136484522,
-0.0426692292,
0.0581165627,
-0.0838976204,
-0.0315752588,
0.0033443493,
-0.0221850295,
0.0276950784,
0.0540948994,
0.0586697161,
0.0368148722,
0.0540209971,
0.006905288,
-0.0220593568,
0.0153597156,
-0.0027399566,
-0.0475142337,
-0.0457091667,
-0.0224571843,
-0.0030260142,
0.0570605174,
0.0065674204,
0.0761904195,
-0.0517620333,
0.0543175898,
-0.0330661274,
0.0978720635,
0.005895792,
0.0170334969,
0.02667352,
0.0314170979,
-0.0148072569,
-0.002480306,
-0.012346128,
-0.0154504003,
0.0223012771,
-0.0318813585,
0.0350418091,
0.0312605351,
-0.0199951828,
-0.0283243265,
-0.0412348025,
-0.0200280603,
0.0174014028,
-0.0551740527,
0.0305053629,
0.0092803687,
-0.0504098609,
0.082278423,
0.0145091936,
-0.0527120978,
0.0245589688,
-0.0313889123,
0.014458322,
0.1218645349,
0.0704929009,
-0.018997835,
-0.0161553603,
-0.0209227167,
-0.0228122436,
0.0647900328,
0.0120718349,
-0.0206171367,
-0.0164719597,
-0.0482080355,
-0.0247485004,
-0.0017120285,
0.0210601147,
-0.0201533139,
0.0170639716,
0.0025278351,
0.010620689,
-0.0355205573,
0.0112654027,
0.0650820509,
0.005876801,
-0.0090315714,
0.0048020855,
0.0059089218,
0.0105045475,
0.0504629798,
-0.0228459593,
0.0060476093,
0.0393950008,
-0.0592568293,
-0.0586023666,
0.0081406971,
-0.0219629072,
-0.0439934842,
0.0317265987,
-0.0067385975,
0.0141470172,
0.0034423848,
-0.0315699875,
-0.0416702069,
-0.0068523502,
-0.0621194132,
0.1314859688,
-0.0396688282,
0.0437495299,
-0.0023607286,
0.0000788426,
-0.0334361047,
0.0255902447,
-0.0044526909,
0.0160201658,
-0.02909928,
0.0196349602,
0.0351028927,
-0.0119256759,
-0.0273001995,
-0.00217218,
-0.0130734975,
-0.011205106,
0.0654440001,
-0.0048594652,
-0.0198965482,
-0.013024671,
-0.0783639848,
0.0258655809,
-0.0102667483,
0.0138037484,
-0.0123570319,
0.0508954898,
0.0097428765,
0.0172064826,
-0.0043004383,
-0.0068710851,
-0.0108767767,
0.0032192296,
0.0326146893,
-0.0011180057,
-0.0402712636,
-0.0174478423,
-0.0063814498,
0.0041674487,
0.0584606566,
0.0179823842,
-0.0241636001,
-0.0382595807,
-0.0324885882,
-0.0056956629,
0.0233308971,
0.0426667742,
-0.0481938086,
0.006801547,
-0.0177656151,
0.0490820818,
0.0247383509,
0.0305906106,
0.0473014638,
0.0101220533,
0.0630303174,
-0.0540411323,
0.0198148433,
-0.0020285815,
0.0342488475,
-0.0128826974,
-0.0032074163,
0.053031534,
0.0205606855,
-0.0250985008,
0.0039070235,
-0.0653408095,
0.0015842241,
-0.017909972,
-0.0377105102,
-0.0123055801,
-0.026540624,
-0.0238570031,
0.0003353215,
-0.0077360184,
-0.0216368269,
0.0442075059,
-0.003393562,
0.0247308705,
-0.0634710416,
-0.0308347195,
-0.0181934964,
0.0167072117,
0.0035462857,
0.0306210592,
-0.0405969545,
-0.0457725488,
0.013340014,
-0.0158211477,
-0.0261649266,
-0.0045027668,
0.0110419411,
-0.0099690156,
-0.0034141275,
0.0025577038,
-0.0446185917,
-0.065974474,
-0.0252706781,
-0.0317562595,
0.0466410704,
0.0735881999,
-0.0083678383,
-0.0502134822,
-0.0021187093,
-0.0021924211,
0.0255549904,
0.0055421791,
0.0069445418,
-0.0167804845,
0.0551286153,
0.0248297043,
0.0016895884,
-0.012354821,
0.0190027766,
0.0411297195,
0.0503703058,
0.0341847911,
-0.0292115416,
-0.0314754732,
-0.0299406033,
0.0207320359,
-0.072238192,
-0.0147638554,
-0.0057177707,
0.0115012191,
-0.0294272695,
-0.0090801762,
0.1437131912,
0.0807929412,
0.0223214198,
0.0059455987,
-0.0252317153,
0.0453540646,
0.0221820623,
0.0106363036,
-0.0423564278,
-0.0359273702,
0.0484439209,
0.0156178204,
0.049116984,
-0.0119977687,
0.0144941742,
-0.0966553017,
0.0167776123,
-0.0180233642,
-0.0349520147,
0.000078591,
-0.0802670866,
-0.0317237377,
0.0108960252,
0.0645297244,
-0.0006637925,
0.0069538951,
0.0051170206,
0.0147296768,
-0.0463406667,
-0.0070254705,
-0.0295811966,
-0.0764582381,
0.0154336356,
0.0307524409,
0.0395612456,
-0.0123519478,
-0.0270869639,
0.0572764389,
0.0313683189,
-0.0050472403,
-0.041441381,
0.0471100099,
-0.0641274974,
0.0070921062,
-0.0154862525,
-0.0071288575,
0.0085079838,
-0.0410444513,
-0.0092634279,
0.0506571345,
0.0199169517,
0.0258305445,
-0.0432571955,
-0.0366166644,
-0.035610877,
0.0688343272,
0.0097998185,
-0.0585944057,
-0.023174528,
-0.0062697758,
-0.0116504803,
-0.0660142377,
0.0163201746,
-0.0166696738,
-0.0420238227,
-0.0280040037,
-0.0781848431,
-0.0095376996,
0.068907477,
0.0349052474,
0.0024160144,
0.0056275479,
-0.0068982975,
-0.025778871,
-0.0602068268,
-0.0019399098,
0.0223696362,
0.0031921261,
-0.0625302345,
-0.0006716617,
0.0218604449,
0.0167179182,
-0.0110588036,
0.0032548103,
0.0273482148,
-0.036262013,
-0.0027311908,
0.0319072977,
0.0041518728,
0.0352760628,
-0.007828082,
-0.0444111191,
0.0063774106,
0.0679067299,
-0.0624974072,
-0.0290802624,
0.0008103462,
0.0002657656,
0.0091150207,
0.0278084502,
-0.0379153267,
-0.0073878733,
-0.0274225287,
0.0476627462,
0.0328667238,
0.033314731,
0.0199094377,
0.039525494,
0.0444490202,
-0.0575551279,
0.0217852481,
-0.025613375,
-0.0021869643,
-0.0506132841,
-0.0026183191,
-0.0471760482,
0.0309374183,
-0.0011025947,
-0.0054928861,
-0.0073370822,
0.0013430078,
-0.0507670678,
0.0305452533,
-0.0059436243,
0.0331799649,
-0.0546800755,
0.0064861635,
0.0122944424,
-0.0035031429,
-0.0195164345,
-0.0498123281,
-0.031949982,
-0.030248791,
-0.0844060257,
-0.0514183231,
0.0196789447,
0.0109441392,
-0.0471985154,
0.0252421591,
-0.0475900732,
-0.0208473131,
-0.0407653153,
0.0781493038,
0.025306711,
-0.020451583,
0.009943286,
-0.0110971909,
-0.0448622517,
0.0263705365,
0.010106327,
0.0039080125,
-0.0389833674,
0.0202888418,
0.008534885,
-0.0474674478,
-0.0532733239,
0.0568890795,
0.0053372732,
0.0467012562,
-0.0042697387,
-0.025695648,
-0.0639543757,
0.025120914,
0.0645185933,
0.0819886252,
-0.0290194154,
0.0325310044,
-0.0224194098,
-0.0397671573,
0.0074999742,
0.0136091439,
-0.0078593744,
0.0235244557,
0.0716200024,
0.0174185671,
-0.0002333502,
-0.0364380404,
0.012062584,
0.0100198109,
0.041532483,
-0.045525685,
0.0252869185,
-6.055440497e-33,
-0.0162582435,
0.0018896114,
-0.0038141944,
0.0306433309,
-0.0216915347,
-0.0027956157,
-0.0059769629,
-0.009480522,
0.023878891,
0.0081997057,
-0.02328448,
0.0159150232,
0.0026625502,
0.0389892869,
0.0160791185,
0.0143969906,
0.0820718855,
-0.0152689731,
-0.006323643,
-0.023220133,
0.0315694623,
0.0597639978,
0.0301900022,
-0.0362686627,
-0.0499659479,
0.0231052767,
0.0030378238,
0.0227604657,
0.0636331663,
0.0250060838,
-0.0173548609,
0.046129439,
0.0175388679,
-0.0333338007,
0.0052060136,
0.0402595587,
-0.0784753636,
-0.0269711372,
0.0325762257,
0.0080765383,
-0.0386097543,
-0.0605076812,
0.0212013125,
-0.0119965244,
-0.0253272969,
0.0573890731,
0.0236682799,
-0.0203972962,
-0.0471318886,
-0.001337902,
-0.0804731324,
0.0102294525,
-0.0004450628,
0.0197040495,
0.0349649675,
0.0062921797,
0.0157302432,
-0.0153607531,
-0.0182046574,
-0.0163457431,
0.0192981306,
0.020570267,
0.0305214785,
0.0202533863,
-0.0246750154,
0.0694033876,
0.0345504619,
-0.0443062671,
0.0001187531,
0.0278032944,
0.007702176,
0.0687870681,
0.0478535742,
0.0162126794,
0.0573544875,
-0.0465935357,
-0.046415545,
0.0222126991,
0.0202927683,
0.0474093854,
0.0170504712,
0.0636307597,
-0.0143957185,
-0.0098503539,
-0.0160843059,
0.029663926,
-0.0171833504,
-0.0252831485,
0.0473767072,
0.0453290828,
-0.014039035,
-0.0166270789,
0.0001532537,
-0.0172946341,
0.0142224086,
0.0186666604,
0.0103806229,
-0.0250900295,
-0.0123154111,
0.0111864097,
-0.0239169691,
-0.0528383441,
0.0132193528,
0.0083758663,
-0.0106220962,
-0.0212017223,
0.0494463444,
-0.012664821,
-0.0681231618,
0.0430384167,
-0.0042832633,
-0.0003072924,
-0.0097365268,
0.0013189254,
0.0285233967,
-0.000354148,
-0.0145328902,
-0.0029898698,
0.026393326,
-0.0155901965,
-0.0096691605,
-0.0235219747,
0.0357161649,
0.0097996099,
-0.0055039488,
0.0239969976,
-0.038252838,
0.0334163383,
0.005659245,
-0.0555510893,
-0.0215195268,
0.0059039877,
2.721e-7,
0.0437843613,
0.0759058669,
0.0518325008,
-0.0170080569,
-0.0041481019,
-0.0206095148,
0.0235601608,
0.0426703915,
-0.0202262923,
0.0331982225,
-0.0293221865,
0.0024679599,
0.0035291843,
-0.0040278323,
-0.1077057794,
0.0046867067,
-0.0080500748,
-0.0150847435,
-0.0673833638,
0.0258215964,
0.115125075,
0.0980424136,
0.0211914629,
0.0042051626,
-0.0103968065,
-0.0281622428,
0.0207591318,
-0.0085862083,
-0.02144357,
0.0199083667,
0.0011144751,
0.0908768326,
0.0259871799,
-0.0048727212,
-0.0512826517,
0.0522189699,
0.0349330567,
0.0290187467,
-0.0372281373,
0.0236399174,
0.0233486909,
-0.0453108251,
-0.003380798,
-0.0334837995,
0.0436052643,
-0.0166281965,
0.0055175913,
-0.0085102478,
-0.0519424714,
0.0267219506,
-0.0040645399,
-0.0185144879,
-0.0502642728,
0.0280120876,
0.057382077,
0.0128778648,
-0.0296861604,
-0.1048046499,
0.001713978,
0.0003496675,
-0.0563228428,
-0.013259857,
-0.0144863129,
0.0320269838,
0.0444056019,
-0.032008104,
-0.0210272931,
2.505862378e-34,
0.041427426,
0.0176749546,
0.0201944783,
0.0581070483,
0.0541483015,
-0.025727652,
0.0153359883,
-0.0073667089,
0.0150983017,
-0.0583218224,
0.0027443806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12397v1 | On the Challenges of Using Black-Box APIs for Toxicity Evaluation in Research | 2023-04-24T19:11:51 | 2023-04-24T19:11:51 | Luiza Pozzobon, Beyza Ermis, Patrick Lewis, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Perception of toxicity evolves over time and often differs between
geographies and cultural backgrounds. Similarly, black-box commercially
available APIs for detecting toxicity, such as the Perspective API, are not
static, but frequently retrained to address any unattended weaknesses and
biases. We evaluate the implications of these changes on the reproducibility of
findings that compare the relative merits of models and methods that aim to
curb toxicity. Our findings suggest that research that relied on inherited
automatic toxicity scores to compare models and techniques may have resulted in
inaccurate findings. Rescoring all models from HELM, a widely respected living
benchmark, for toxicity with the recent version of the API led to a different
ranking of widely used foundation models. We suggest caution in applying
apples-to-apples comparisons between studies and lay recommendations for a more
structured approach to evaluating toxicity over time. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/for-ai/black-box-api-challenges. | [
0.0085501671,
0.0745881423,
-0.0133220181,
-0.0549104102,
-0.0020997338,
0.0121280299,
0.0363889858,
0.0024030241,
0.0642581955,
-0.0180110615,
-0.014858244,
0.0651861876,
-0.0146771213,
0.0382811278,
0.0322370008,
-0.0084591778,
0.0358671322,
0.0116033209,
-0.0374105088,
0.0380371846,
-0.0141728902,
0.016934704,
0.0206750371,
0.0386736244,
-0.017349517,
-0.028567031,
0.0345114358,
0.0082880147,
0.0482505783,
-0.0857820436,
0.0160702877,
-0.0208689515,
0.0177802406,
0.0153259132,
0.0000021274,
-0.0043472569,
-0.0026794516,
0.0370143652,
0.0123719852,
-0.029163843,
0.0672235638,
-0.0128710428,
0.0183654949,
0.048126962,
0.0129909879,
-0.0321730077,
0.0410867706,
-0.0347388051,
0.0447912849,
-0.0123289889,
-0.0237857178,
0.0217245873,
0.0407164283,
-0.0043281289,
-0.0169255529,
0.0728711262,
0.0357823037,
0.0027316185,
-0.0205972046,
-0.0262057502,
-0.0499791577,
0.0510465726,
0.0131589118,
0.0065063252,
-0.0137845054,
0.016757343,
0.0062064258,
-0.104712747,
0.0209151823,
0.038239494,
-0.006341734,
0.0420799404,
-0.0169354286,
0.0076934467,
0.0058089923,
-0.033789549,
-0.0138320737,
-0.0189719312,
0.0193553064,
-0.0302023105,
-0.0403810441,
0.0405192934,
0.0005273537,
0.0167355333,
0.0420266837,
0.0574012399,
-0.0048723808,
-0.020675635,
0.0366112553,
-0.027048301,
0.0128367003,
0.0575331189,
-0.0015243057,
-0.0409628265,
-0.0323015787,
-0.0260348655,
0.0381392986,
0.0158180911,
0.0645413995,
-0.0477926396,
0.0670094937,
0.0094195511,
-0.0860305727,
-0.0058809766,
-0.0028991841,
-0.0236901026,
0.0134216677,
0.0215132628,
-0.0108276596,
0.0423829369,
-0.0148677267,
0.0235489625,
0.0410560854,
-0.0469116382,
0.0164291747,
0.0265813079,
-0.0017785652,
-0.0143653927,
-0.0797302201,
-0.0272801947,
-0.0172492377,
0.0385864675,
0.0213555116,
0.0788660869,
0.0210068505,
0.0112451147,
-0.0199464392,
0.0167580023,
0.0067047714,
-0.0327975638,
-0.0190448035,
-0.0162815675,
-0.0423376858,
-0.0509813093,
0.0018103305,
0.0959303752,
0.0614263713,
-0.0078321984,
-0.0234441292,
0.01060188,
-0.0242990162,
-0.0023239604,
-0.0147352098,
-0.0087931836,
0.0380477831,
-0.011301972,
0.0448118597,
-0.0582115985,
-0.0197672751,
-0.0019917993,
-0.0499435291,
-0.0006922124,
-0.0408028625,
0.0122260675,
0.0132604633,
0.001207381,
-0.0517188907,
0.0466799811,
0.0095146848,
0.0281638633,
0.0173947979,
0.0074426644,
-0.0593650788,
0.0008077129,
-0.0059083742,
0.0642356873,
-0.0152137587,
0.0102671757,
-0.0300586987,
0.0226293858,
-0.038639918,
-0.0022057178,
-0.0140815359,
0.0372567885,
0.0648561344,
-0.0060394849,
-0.0109592313,
-0.0033693365,
0.051619228,
-0.0160853267,
-0.0237054881,
-0.0643545538,
-0.1125311181,
-0.014335894,
-0.0281560011,
-0.0448557213,
0.017536642,
0.0546635427,
0.0288306754,
-0.0653071478,
0.0076100468,
-0.0019696935,
0.0109747471,
-0.0429807901,
0.0175323654,
-0.0207616799,
0.0295333005,
-0.033724729,
0.0221818089,
-0.0508225448,
-0.0168827251,
0.0012074413,
0.0222693123,
0.033371415,
0.0190655794,
-0.0321541429,
-0.0349217206,
-0.0504969247,
-0.0283647683,
-0.0489609279,
0.0008641191,
-0.0075135264,
0.0551059321,
0.0517139733,
-0.0157228373,
-0.0090912813,
0.0110961748,
-0.0316111371,
0.0072058975,
0.0565649457,
0.0239640139,
-0.0468902513,
-0.0852543488,
0.0386442803,
-0.0202011876,
-0.0147842094,
0.0108405165,
-0.0062526413,
0.0384065472,
-0.0216983017,
-0.0205166731,
0.0058877771,
0.0231110789,
0.0152097,
-0.002504684,
0.0081014568,
0.0424052328,
0.0456756502,
-0.0037059153,
-0.0030082548,
0.0077991229,
0.0993459746,
-0.0345166661,
0.0309208669,
-0.0485893935,
0.0206634402,
-0.0414592847,
0.0375202261,
-0.0196581222,
-0.0055002221,
0.0362488069,
-0.0080127269,
0.0028430147,
0.0281543396,
-0.0620798431,
-0.0296116844,
-0.0459393598,
-0.0115655176,
-0.0306117442,
-0.0426210165,
-0.0769529268,
-0.0069199437,
-0.023698872,
0.0134047698,
0.0043352423,
-0.0447333418,
0.0698902607,
-0.0438244864,
-0.0071184966,
-0.0034904347,
-0.0262047816,
-0.0305637792,
-0.0550646,
0.0029009359,
0.0002079469,
0.0270869602,
-0.0354122706,
-0.0034965025,
0.059642911,
-0.0165665597,
-0.0258544628,
0.0064523011,
-0.0653124824,
-0.0114023127,
-0.0774713382,
0.0830127075,
-0.006157449,
-0.0517191216,
0.0369359329,
0.0152782639,
-0.0120578706,
-0.0331208892,
-0.0032992775,
-0.0461623147,
0.0173505694,
0.0361902341,
-0.0137214381,
0.0730490983,
0.0242567603,
0.0456794389,
0.0489996225,
0.049511198,
-0.0023088718,
0.0220498703,
-0.0444257483,
-0.0012366805,
0.0194317251,
-0.082903862,
-0.0434361212,
0.0168323629,
-0.0680703819,
-0.0000764875,
0.0043336786,
0.0930283368,
-0.0131080011,
-0.0436809398,
-0.0073630107,
-0.0152526107,
0.0123659214,
-0.0052838498,
-0.0070244349,
-0.0848973095,
0.0077549345,
0.041618932,
0.0234272704,
0.0045605903,
0.0221755635,
0.0205981657,
-0.0014959368,
0.0299554449,
0.0010215916,
0.0396845788,
0.0502370857,
0.0204884745,
-0.014688665,
0.0031874764,
-0.0077712419,
-0.0130902296,
-0.0500595346,
-0.0286277309,
0.0386940911,
-0.0409525,
0.0141550358,
0.0208333265,
-0.0250974316,
0.0471982434,
-0.0200843569,
-0.0036821286,
-0.0167790633,
0.0358427353,
0.0256624948,
-0.0626848713,
-0.0067539448,
-0.012896494,
0.0280118641,
-0.0698968768,
0.0522625782,
-0.0404131711,
0.0843684301,
0.0241990071,
0.0782908127,
0.0292644855,
0.002043454,
0.0076792184,
-0.0177975725,
0.0570935532,
-0.0584912337,
0.0401996076,
0.0023789662,
0.0019638685,
-0.0187775735,
0.0190120898,
-0.0226966515,
0.0159488376,
-0.0249748416,
-0.0030936748,
0.055735372,
-0.0425595418,
-0.004816114,
-0.0010057269,
-0.0074900938,
-0.0243436974,
0.008536499,
-0.0011040687,
0.0196641348,
-0.0556944422,
-0.0414686911,
0.0427460298,
-0.0535876155,
0.0250988845,
0.0315371193,
-0.065865472,
0.0037046694,
-0.0440807566,
0.0161202028,
-0.1170036793,
0.0105276275,
-0.0151799778,
0.0192744322,
-0.0545672253,
-0.0188963395,
-0.0855989903,
-0.0330463424,
0.0376718976,
-0.01304607,
0.0147960186,
0.0087290844,
-0.002080437,
-0.0070071444,
0.0476644076,
0.0197499879,
0.002891572,
-0.0074910237,
0.0098992735,
0.0727500021,
-0.0093210284,
0.0097035067,
-0.0272303298,
0.0275715273,
-0.0322382972,
-0.0057816966,
-0.0030453606,
0.0610007644,
-0.0016863754,
-0.0326756574,
-0.073605746,
0.0231526233,
0.0394914933,
0.0284930468,
0.0313938223,
-0.0301880632,
-0.022214666,
-0.0310067832,
-0.0192289297,
-0.0363091417,
-0.0400777645,
0.0261510722,
-0.0642011613,
-0.0679583102,
-0.0157216806,
0.0192804504,
0.000177619,
-0.0051713283,
0.0014453707,
-0.0368112624,
0.0105897114,
-0.0327994265,
0.0101201423,
0.083677277,
0.0730418265,
0.0194660407,
0.0066820984,
-0.0074506593,
0.0436795354,
0.039540004,
-0.0310594384,
0.074426353,
-0.0288796984,
-0.035647478,
0.0729902014,
0.1155603379,
0.0149893425,
-0.0107195172,
-0.0179072563,
0.0302349553,
0.0674083009,
0.0454213619,
0.0418271795,
-0.0272375569,
0.0290680192,
-0.0101030311,
0.0065822653,
-0.0150992796,
-0.0263640601,
0.025341671,
0.0596267805,
0.0409743488,
-0.0508072264,
0.0649850294,
0.0358602293,
0.0277229175,
0.079140231,
-0.0403787531,
0.0020963368,
0.0335381404,
-0.022823697,
0.0225577485,
-0.0112908827,
-0.0031257404,
-0.0096487049,
0.00773742,
0.0291770995,
-0.0221548732,
0.0601717904,
-0.0212563742,
0.0172903277,
-0.0637752935,
0.0521511398,
0.0008013141,
-0.01659563,
0.0463210195,
0.027392555,
-0.0218186844,
-0.0144401835,
-0.0482077636,
0.0104083875,
-0.0097841974,
-0.0437709615,
-0.0442319438,
0.0183389634,
-0.0117073851,
0.1083508953,
-0.0004440852,
-0.0276505481,
-0.0635673553,
-0.0223748442,
-0.0068751224,
-0.0373803973,
0.0065666698,
-0.022628976,
-0.0103353914,
-0.0799982995,
-0.0368563011,
-0.0260348208,
0.0074260612,
-0.0191417318,
0.0032737441,
-0.0381867625,
-0.0323854089,
0.0358163901,
0.0288701989,
0.0537694953,
-0.0115895094,
-0.0359266959,
0.0183460936,
-0.0362188816,
0.0173691288,
-0.0065396326,
-0.009612442,
-0.0368562527,
-0.0445016287,
-0.0607106909,
0.0146461455,
0.0051241326,
-0.0039453642,
-0.002280815,
-0.0569789037,
-0.0324866138,
0.0155311273,
-0.0722112507,
0.007266005,
-0.0167575888,
-0.053299658,
-0.0287431367,
-0.0128326267,
-5.18176681e-33,
0.0050421651,
-0.017113518,
-0.0455203652,
-0.0108464025,
-0.0210292041,
0.0012734976,
-0.0030290342,
-0.0183717478,
-0.0187343583,
0.0472777039,
0.0161756109,
-0.0260014497,
-0.006257541,
-0.0195532627,
0.0532208979,
-0.0183081217,
-0.0408209153,
0.0021321212,
-0.0103461612,
-0.0035665219,
0.0328776054,
0.0294386353,
-0.0187484492,
-0.0881622359,
0.0041097566,
0.0563212372,
0.0045368574,
-0.0330341309,
-0.071378611,
0.0644836202,
0.0630522743,
0.0413984805,
0.016570352,
-0.0041619334,
-0.0157331899,
-0.0102996016,
-0.0135280732,
0.0451214761,
0.0137937572,
-0.084944956,
-0.0373275504,
0.0016069093,
0.062749505,
0.0379739776,
-0.0136661772,
0.0030813182,
-0.0040911022,
-0.0831416175,
0.0289512575,
-0.0221317913,
0.0090082595,
-0.0145769883,
-0.0254215263,
-0.0109073184,
-0.0261597354,
0.0961822495,
0.0213230439,
0.0608777441,
-0.0139795393,
-0.0175221581,
-0.0125647346,
-0.031211907,
0.045520626,
0.0281872209,
0.0626121685,
0.0472912788,
0.012483947,
0.0445983149,
0.001090235,
-0.0367084481,
0.0350064076,
0.0312798209,
0.0413369872,
0.0162153598,
-0.0331016667,
-0.0228639673,
-0.0540924445,
0.0423724353,
-0.0036416128,
0.0421740934,
-0.0174822416,
-0.0330155082,
0.0081996899,
-0.0013524172,
-0.0302553847,
-0.0575681552,
-0.0060047582,
0.0213411376,
0.0245037396,
-0.0315452293,
-0.0392403081,
-0.0052378932,
0.0085489731,
-0.024483839,
0.0814631432,
-0.0162637476,
0.0253405962,
0.020251859,
0.0361776017,
0.0194962174,
-0.0473228395,
0.0379311219,
-0.030471826,
0.0294374451,
0.0588023774,
-0.021028094,
0.0665703341,
0.010639987,
-0.0031258008,
-0.0094677359,
-0.0294230785,
0.0242117178,
0.0515482835,
0.0126600005,
-0.0054623736,
-0.0050744065,
0.0250075422,
0.0017842905,
0.0696874931,
0.0674434304,
-0.0140897138,
0.0010340863,
-0.0242254511,
-0.0073145619,
0.0309368111,
-0.0619495995,
-0.0135020185,
0.0329408161,
0.0100384904,
-0.0467776321,
0.0186641421,
-0.0427726284,
2.842e-7,
0.027270155,
0.0337552764,
-0.006039531,
-0.0271585509,
0.0167058557,
0.0207628347,
-0.0225778315,
0.0146545703,
-0.026687542,
-0.0149532054,
0.0574577376,
-0.0224274956,
0.020278601,
0.0028459406,
0.009190253,
-0.0112606389,
-0.0847879052,
-0.0051390142,
-0.0490251668,
0.0278697796,
0.0019868556,
0.0450147353,
-0.0085332077,
0.0023765448,
0.0324858837,
-0.0134713147,
-0.0233213436,
-0.0879793763,
0.0169061795,
0.019039711,
0.006507996,
0.0330633037,
-0.0003552405,
0.0194089562,
-0.0245297309,
-0.0501056314,
-0.0130365416,
0.0185609832,
-0.0337776467,
-0.0176610649,
0.0143674128,
-0.0201742556,
0.0209600404,
-0.0511984527,
0.0601683408,
0.0121430438,
0.0287068486,
-0.0028324807,
-0.0529915541,
-0.0013753123,
0.0948637575,
-0.0240886435,
-0.023029929,
0.0000269905,
0.0009543606,
0.0266547035,
0.0065594427,
-0.0045095077,
0.0045971689,
-0.0163756143,
-0.0187161826,
-0.0910801515,
-0.0442809127,
0.0031396826,
-0.0520981289,
-0.0142957643,
-0.0062125144,
2.403256186e-34,
0.0233328436,
-0.0281022042,
-0.0010804083,
-0.0643206388,
0.0424716212,
0.0014819603,
0.0020364008,
-0.0325439088,
-0.0343447402,
-0.0533889122,
0.0017955113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12395v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12395v2 | Extreme Classification for Answer Type Prediction in Question Answering | 2023-04-24T19:08:51 | 2023-04-26T19:52:57 | Vinay Setty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Semantic answer type prediction (SMART) is known to be a useful step towards
effective question answering (QA) systems. The SMART task involves predicting
the top-$k$ knowledge graph (KG) types for a given natural language question.
This is challenging due to the large number of types in KGs. In this paper, we
propose use of extreme multi-label classification using Transformer models
(XBERT) by clustering KG types using structural and semantic features based on
question text. We specifically improve the clustering stage of the XBERT
pipeline using textual and structural features derived from KGs. We show that
these features can improve end-to-end performance for the SMART task, and yield
state-of-the-art results. | [
0.0448318943,
-0.0436969139,
0.0040688789,
0.0054477402,
0.0295428187,
0.0150487823,
-0.0476629287,
-0.0043074079,
0.0601751544,
-0.0531114265,
-0.0126272803,
0.0253245104,
-0.0266211778,
0.0346981585,
0.0012489585,
-0.0120887682,
0.0232069716,
-0.0273340978,
0.0216413047,
0.005429741,
0.0119821839,
0.0236727782,
0.0002598157,
0.0432699621,
-0.0133561436,
-0.0359038599,
-0.0061117797,
-0.0302837081,
0.0193894412,
0.0057765548,
0.0584569611,
0.0543237403,
0.0099749342,
-0.0236476474,
0.0000015221,
-0.025620034,
-0.0200239308,
-0.0148413386,
-0.0287348591,
-0.0242248923,
-0.053175386,
-0.0239253081,
0.0646530986,
0.0309458878,
-0.0447814651,
-0.0256120451,
0.0097557316,
0.0734421685,
0.0930603072,
0.0082822461,
0.0001781664,
-0.0413938798,
0.0588444695,
0.0484734178,
0.0165580027,
-0.033143945,
0.0423719622,
0.0032530411,
0.0166796278,
0.0620442554,
0.021586258,
0.0007156311,
0.0167960636,
0.0098994458,
0.0081761898,
0.0287072137,
-0.0278805327,
0.0174939744,
0.0088056065,
0.0834344923,
0.034710817,
-0.0325495936,
-0.003400017,
0.0203839317,
0.0281529892,
0.0069537442,
0.0064439499,
-0.0105363615,
-0.0480547696,
-0.0231964178,
-0.0044984054,
0.0415712185,
-0.0243744235,
0.0108223893,
-0.0322592631,
0.0694543123,
0.012594074,
-0.0184572283,
0.0188416298,
-0.0045098802,
-0.0509332009,
-0.0406819768,
-0.009155686,
0.0532898046,
-0.0071800854,
-0.0255300719,
0.0114446655,
-0.0285706464,
0.0401160978,
-0.0400307961,
-0.0285920594,
-0.001492122,
0.0013339688,
0.0300397146,
-0.0219157264,
0.0608845577,
-0.0224288926,
-0.0024394239,
-0.0353217535,
-0.0609191135,
-0.0666477755,
-0.0386612937,
-0.0548441298,
0.0457497835,
-0.0146302907,
0.0043393914,
-0.0279474072,
0.0246738102,
0.0038319894,
-0.0312933736,
0.0467267968,
0.0725317225,
-0.0046210894,
-0.0035082491,
-0.0237017758,
0.0543048829,
-0.0820801407,
0.0433833264,
-0.0335466862,
0.0140989227,
0.0389758274,
0.0405748524,
0.0085234828,
-0.0217618961,
0.0043070531,
0.0444906801,
-0.0501098409,
0.0028961259,
-0.0320728905,
-0.0246105511,
-0.0260850508,
0.0067544887,
-0.0226556156,
-0.0660839602,
0.0021590875,
0.0215258002,
-0.0258075707,
0.0130525595,
0.0074823438,
-0.0091501828,
-0.0327665955,
0.0552813485,
-0.0052236766,
0.0028450852,
0.0822722167,
-0.0143666025,
-0.0662865713,
0.0208498873,
-0.0019145077,
-0.0126301348,
0.0476749577,
-0.0130741419,
0.0593458675,
0.0482961126,
-0.0263784844,
-0.0058694151,
0.015985053,
0.0376976691,
0.024933232,
0.0022130781,
-0.0238859933,
0.0168473311,
0.014855844,
-0.0504540913,
0.0210032202,
-0.0153672667,
-0.0362030119,
0.0193036888,
0.0090116216,
0.0290412325,
0.0004585936,
-0.0178103168,
0.013999315,
0.020507602,
-0.0276175924,
0.0043793861,
0.0047847531,
0.0288356226,
-0.0531082079,
-0.0208301228,
-0.0211648867,
-0.0059056799,
-0.0089685488,
-0.0009951524,
0.0490030833,
0.0261225626,
-0.0178672299,
0.1060940772,
0.0121918051,
0.0127466265,
-0.0140662361,
-0.051821325,
0.0089186952,
-0.0063644652,
-0.0175544359,
-0.0313728154,
-0.0260777604,
-0.0001620537,
0.0172992963,
-0.0224053748,
0.0075704711,
-0.046495989,
-0.0360037275,
-0.0193305984,
-0.0022349176,
0.0362249538,
0.0084005902,
-0.0373809338,
0.0190942567,
0.0355135463,
0.0034133864,
-0.1119770408,
0.0334083848,
0.0266627204,
-0.0194644034,
-0.0074505094,
0.0229806509,
-0.0058082668,
-0.0300632007,
0.0099488152,
0.0101860007,
0.0015952755,
0.0536261424,
-0.0344226733,
-0.0666662455,
-0.0167199355,
0.0081501761,
-0.0076353285,
0.0243134219,
-0.0344692431,
0.0021444848,
0.0333006494,
-0.0302581992,
-0.0223700348,
-0.0211960673,
-0.0196480993,
0.025032388,
-0.02200808,
-0.0304829739,
-0.0025891575,
-0.0121516027,
-0.0533302464,
0.0768544152,
0.0311553814,
0.0324234515,
-0.0043179533,
-0.0711373016,
-0.0180808455,
0.0256865583,
0.0068465145,
0.0032360237,
-0.0283796787,
0.0292645302,
0.0515497327,
-0.014137866,
-0.0690770745,
-0.0401567407,
-0.1090178564,
0.001741963,
-0.0055151614,
0.0024953051,
0.033502616,
-0.0001701151,
0.015762629,
-0.0035793802,
-0.0661372691,
-0.0033211738,
0.0069825794,
0.0126056653,
0.0319524035,
0.0041854726,
0.0130440285,
0.015905194,
-0.0213799477,
-0.0256659631,
0.0852745548,
-0.00979451,
-0.0016293274,
-0.0219529904,
-0.0285261068,
-0.0215905886,
-0.0052633216,
-0.0043220585,
-0.0097254738,
-0.0101565728,
-0.0172330681,
-0.009884852,
0.03638025,
0.0735222772,
-0.0287226439,
-0.0307059959,
0.0345424637,
-0.0231442377,
-0.0065572634,
-0.0482056141,
-0.0503039099,
-0.0448627137,
0.0018594482,
0.0032098161,
0.0643313006,
0.0254094508,
-0.0211379621,
-0.0606532022,
0.008269581,
-0.0309670363,
0.0220203511,
-0.0390916988,
0.0367530361,
-0.0028745399,
0.0080847014,
0.0255773626,
0.030670125,
0.0601949431,
0.0073796213,
-0.0036081565,
-0.0317968875,
-0.0490507446,
-0.0805672184,
0.035391055,
-0.0155705996,
0.0126084508,
0.0155193601,
0.0031092174,
-0.0626820251,
-0.0269167926,
-0.0210881159,
-0.0094814785,
0.0301107131,
0.0096233143,
0.0070800893,
0.0160375349,
-0.0501513742,
-0.0322641432,
-0.0610512495,
-0.0105711129,
0.0354975574,
-0.00236174,
0.000375662,
-0.0606829897,
0.0055734646,
-0.0022958841,
0.0168741681,
-0.0454550348,
-0.0290830843,
-0.0317637734,
0.1466635764,
0.0811818168,
0.0183483381,
-0.0030832924,
0.0140992552,
0.0164474286,
0.0765466616,
-0.0007993316,
0.0170640368,
-0.0042872857,
-0.0206221435,
0.0379766077,
-0.0239311066,
-0.0129808541,
0.0111007383,
0.0371567979,
-0.0113906823,
0.005242019,
0.1005491987,
0.0678695738,
-0.0021843016,
0.0095179742,
-0.0117847575,
0.0367662162,
0.0366111286,
0.0197005328,
-0.0381366834,
-0.0506242886,
-0.0460358486,
0.045732066,
-0.0096327439,
-0.0483287387,
0.0508094057,
-0.0643563271,
-0.0237593558,
-0.0354078822,
-0.0832835808,
-0.0079322262,
-0.0403374806,
0.0253086481,
-0.0289047137,
-0.0443722345,
-0.0292613935,
0.0163536668,
0.0003774401,
0.0618332401,
-0.0231835693,
0.034666691,
0.0839057639,
-0.0185951497,
-0.01848731,
-0.0129563203,
0.0045877136,
-0.0446692631,
-0.03336161,
0.009166454,
-0.0375399441,
0.0127161499,
0.0266182218,
0.0176540315,
0.003261663,
0.0058007706,
-0.0259320531,
0.0536108166,
-0.0759927183,
0.0041362899,
0.0353413112,
0.1207494363,
-0.0017642695,
-0.0559986904,
-0.0398430005,
-0.0212718062,
-0.0274503324,
0.0394250751,
-0.0198182855,
-0.0441889055,
-0.0154306442,
-0.0365449637,
0.0270266961,
0.0147789791,
-0.0174435563,
0.0467108376,
0.0154310679,
0.0166479517,
-0.0757822543,
0.0055843876,
0.0443153679,
0.0054348083,
-0.046296373,
-0.0093191192,
0.0167784393,
0.0243606307,
-0.0573129393,
0.0243115742,
-0.0043189246,
-0.0094611617,
-0.0408338197,
0.0041376115,
0.0921572447,
-0.0127707832,
-0.0517113544,
0.0179080609,
-0.0271177161,
-0.072807543,
-0.0203004405,
0.028069498,
0.0136602232,
0.0076615093,
-0.0014787626,
-0.0221509412,
0.075801976,
0.0379090905,
-0.0449947566,
-0.0050578145,
0.0038181616,
-0.0249698348,
-0.0323526338,
0.0336810872,
-0.0711518824,
0.0074380529,
-0.0225605629,
-0.0024665843,
-0.0645491183,
-0.0740518719,
0.0026456807,
-0.0008619929,
-0.0047611538,
0.0395347998,
-0.0105629629,
0.0105674304,
0.0000937191,
0.0334977247,
-0.0321497694,
0.0154461851,
0.0164792649,
0.0166840199,
-0.0082896939,
0.00038213,
0.0347793736,
0.0482130125,
0.0438129157,
0.009150994,
0.0009308032,
0.0659360588,
-0.009756323,
0.0098737692,
-0.0181635506,
-0.0505287051,
-0.0297720097,
0.0211082026,
0.051914826,
-0.0146502368,
0.0468516909,
0.0289547835,
0.0026992357,
-0.0574177727,
0.0018902133,
-0.0734962597,
-0.0834876224,
-0.035588339,
-0.0290564764,
-0.0183057543,
0.0118571315,
-0.0070129307,
0.0040568588,
-0.0602234975,
-0.0138768889,
0.0278159771,
0.0121414484,
-0.0199373253,
0.0359151959,
0.0310521834,
-0.0360082015,
0.0024401145,
0.0598889217,
-0.0082175564,
0.030818684,
0.0020244746,
-0.046522405,
-0.0365600809,
0.0275706388,
0.0019457577,
-0.0233731139,
0.0644234717,
0.0256145503,
-0.0359404087,
-0.0386399627,
0.0668607205,
-0.0487964936,
-0.0262067467,
-0.0125729945,
0.068966046,
0.0384774581,
0.0811697543,
-0.0202667341,
-0.0425460935,
-0.0148538891,
0.0130708218,
0.0219086427,
-0.0233858805,
-5.74888259e-33,
0.0093402108,
-0.0593482815,
-0.0278244447,
-0.034831401,
0.0149936248,
0.0014358873,
0.021991523,
-0.0008128327,
-0.0265326221,
0.0015348176,
-0.0025623504,
0.0064690211,
-0.0151156336,
0.0510569215,
0.0390369445,
-0.018349478,
-0.0128550492,
-0.0091226147,
-0.0120100435,
0.0386739038,
0.0839318335,
0.0082082376,
0.0648948178,
-0.0386182182,
-0.0024026805,
-0.0187331773,
0.0262759514,
0.0232407022,
0.0103484858,
0.0722742155,
0.0020705885,
0.0651997477,
0.0522184931,
-0.0940261483,
0.0422841571,
0.0420316122,
-0.0714155808,
-0.0306286346,
-0.0342916362,
-0.0143668819,
-0.0258281454,
-0.009546428,
0.0111300135,
-0.0075166193,
0.0435088351,
-0.0630027056,
0.0810404643,
-0.0057180054,
-0.0072976924,
-0.0554925799,
-0.01696405,
0.0171951633,
-0.0474439971,
0.033566799,
-0.0446696132,
0.0674923062,
-0.0002537349,
0.0029025322,
-0.055538483,
0.0204626005,
-0.0182634648,
0.0063031451,
0.0139690759,
0.0132166091,
-0.0129828993,
-0.000542564,
-0.0101827784,
-0.009570919,
-0.0291899983,
-0.0107792253,
-0.0363965556,
0.0354393236,
0.0623632334,
0.0424470901,
-0.0312443599,
-0.0039421855,
-0.0223398283,
0.0553217009,
0.0177895091,
-0.0036574029,
-0.0051122913,
-0.0285414476,
-0.0270446986,
-0.0383315049,
-0.0641368777,
0.0476302318,
-0.0316447876,
0.0059516462,
0.0013598324,
-0.018306341,
0.0030686432,
0.0075742556,
0.021480538,
-0.0385388508,
0.0147858746,
0.0545284189,
-0.0267793294,
0.0551494882,
0.0258687641,
0.0445279144,
-0.0060346015,
0.0092683043,
0.0312337819,
-0.0396121107,
0.0205725878,
0.0240869466,
0.0007947896,
-0.0219557732,
-0.0612472147,
-0.0027855649,
0.0126508335,
-0.01172507,
-0.009027157,
0.0101274019,
0.0088562975,
0.0378306657,
-0.0064646648,
0.0416809134,
-0.0044645644,
0.0472786278,
0.0065107672,
0.0122581236,
0.0268411599,
0.0074399863,
-0.0211262722,
0.0022941311,
-0.033507973,
-0.0186558962,
-0.0231792927,
-0.0633854568,
0.0019810761,
0.033525046,
2.253e-7,
0.0534379221,
0.0188710075,
-0.0023202407,
0.0285268892,
0.0159610156,
0.0938618928,
0.0679979324,
0.0371279866,
0.0294023696,
-0.0308938362,
0.0029501761,
0.0004640794,
-0.0085292095,
0.0734982193,
-0.0725165009,
-0.0320700407,
-0.0539589003,
0.0091733728,
-0.0519264452,
0.0103472285,
0.0694232434,
0.1019767448,
-0.0165537503,
-0.0001723875,
-0.0525616519,
-0.069970876,
0.0423234366,
0.0324589685,
0.0254032202,
0.0282210838,
0.0091794394,
-0.0365069024,
0.0262158792,
0.0583193786,
0.0085978638,
-0.0282107946,
0.0533724427,
0.0083533712,
-0.0156614501,
-0.0601430088,
0.0391137563,
0.0133305509,
0.0034343814,
-0.0689533353,
0.0835992843,
-0.0855820999,
-0.0286511742,
0.0310055818,
-0.0352264456,
-0.0065139979,
-0.0193791967,
-0.0272675082,
0.0437654592,
0.0496563204,
0.0091218315,
0.0082588717,
0.0345276594,
-0.0562200546,
0.0077240188,
0.0270486344,
-0.0509179048,
-0.0268659573,
0.0146185756,
0.0284822229,
0.0061882124,
-0.0503444895,
0.0408033952,
1.834142662e-34,
0.0011997658,
0.0419177711,
-0.0016882489,
0.0085100075,
0.0187288113,
-0.0293386728,
-0.0115626957,
-0.0174966361,
0.0275541525,
-0.1022398397,
0.0110826865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12370v1 | Better Question-Answering Models on a Budget | 2023-04-24T18:06:27 | 2023-04-24T18:06:27 | Yudhanjaya Wijeratne, Ishan Marikar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) and question-answer datasets from large language
models have made it much easier for much smaller models to be finetuned to the
point where they display sophisticated conversational abilities. In this paper,
we present Eluwa, a family of LoRA models that use the Stanford Alpaca dataset
and massively improve the capabilities of Facebook's OPT 1.3B, 2.7B and 6.7B
models. We benchmark these models in multiple ways, including letting GPT-4
judge their answers to prompts that span general knowledge, writing,
programming and other tasks. We show that smaller models here can be fine-tuned
to be as performant as models 3x larger - all for as little as 40 USD in
compute. | [
0.0657040253,
0.0567287728,
-0.0185112078,
0.0421342663,
0.0337542184,
0.0221992079,
-0.0090063717,
0.0063210959,
0.0354040973,
-0.0356509611,
-0.0333304368,
-0.015642453,
-0.0267758146,
0.0141393915,
0.0030419484,
-0.0410890579,
0.0423201621,
-0.0446687602,
0.0279982071,
-0.0295472033,
-0.0024072868,
0.0154415909,
-0.0160840992,
0.0188772641,
0.0597337075,
-0.0284552407,
-0.0151656549,
-0.0005383645,
-0.0040587438,
0.0132634956,
0.0402534604,
0.0771814287,
0.012848326,
0.0436905734,
0.000001949,
-0.0414637066,
-0.0033452734,
-0.0357141048,
-0.0331640579,
-0.0091561554,
-0.0163491257,
0.0213619974,
0.0207357127,
0.0407703295,
-0.0616704151,
0.0043671583,
0.0276935194,
0.0155940959,
0.0724796504,
0.0552536547,
-0.0030133817,
-0.0004802553,
0.0224730801,
-0.0353238434,
0.0277252533,
-0.0727816299,
0.0147096142,
-0.0090222927,
0.0151244448,
0.025017973,
-0.0245680362,
0.0186633337,
0.0129709672,
-0.0100627923,
0.0219461061,
0.0128005678,
-0.0342596732,
0.022686094,
-0.030588787,
0.1038833335,
0.0036947906,
-0.0020283712,
-0.0030455217,
0.0053253472,
0.0458692126,
-0.0210096128,
-0.0601532534,
-0.0242202915,
0.0140357539,
-0.0263849013,
-0.0124706691,
-0.0009132489,
-0.0150041599,
0.0199304186,
0.0026021623,
0.0582630597,
0.012063168,
-0.0356094837,
-0.0011511865,
0.0121074114,
-0.0070950114,
-0.0363353975,
-0.0126689039,
0.0528495759,
-0.0237559434,
0.00974542,
-0.0618273169,
0.0244541056,
0.0211126786,
0.0060752337,
0.0347202867,
0.0314183049,
0.0207383148,
0.077863887,
-0.0271989442,
0.050393153,
-0.0097065633,
-0.0163991991,
-0.0433607735,
-0.0115713226,
-0.0262843613,
-0.0288272258,
-0.0328609906,
0.0332314782,
-0.0666457191,
-0.0153640183,
-0.0182585139,
0.0443567038,
0.0146524198,
-0.0016012464,
-0.0132929441,
0.0341368355,
-0.0095112454,
-0.0022867143,
-0.0620595329,
0.044432234,
-0.0285611749,
0.0210112948,
0.0304503497,
-0.0916312709,
-0.0276672896,
-0.0093030296,
0.0533753447,
-0.0390405469,
0.0442816503,
0.0451136976,
-0.0184717868,
-0.0292092785,
0.0424558446,
-0.0079163881,
0.0088243512,
-0.0440540127,
-0.0154067622,
-0.0414762646,
0.0612387657,
0.0275073182,
0.0129797794,
0.0017734375,
-0.0154732103,
0.0664689615,
-0.0385816619,
0.0518570207,
-0.0213831011,
0.0250130948,
0.030574318,
0.0160868075,
0.0054008262,
0.0382004976,
0.0117342463,
0.0104074674,
0.0337061323,
-0.0394638143,
0.0218370911,
0.0057341033,
0.0199544299,
-0.0107066892,
0.0559933335,
0.0679960996,
0.0049121361,
0.0166364573,
0.0285034403,
0.021257231,
-0.0110157309,
-0.0228518229,
0.0849467665,
0.0693138987,
0.0047665196,
0.0456371307,
-0.0240604356,
0.014685641,
0.0162993278,
-0.0338983461,
-0.0355601683,
0.071740225,
-0.0733124912,
-0.002340537,
0.0300682392,
0.0209567845,
-0.0441271514,
-0.031128604,
-0.000863671,
0.0222511832,
-0.0079852259,
0.042986773,
-0.0087704472,
0.003999162,
-0.0337021053,
0.0243677702,
0.0129471906,
-0.058925394,
-0.029570641,
-0.0737680942,
0.0820697844,
0.0432484858,
0.0398311578,
-0.0368078388,
-0.0253795851,
-0.0263759363,
0.0258937925,
0.0208437946,
0.0697361901,
-0.0256631337,
0.019643588,
-0.0344350114,
-0.0035408742,
-0.0225738697,
-0.0202611256,
0.013230443,
0.0343986936,
0.0034299872,
-0.0029865163,
-0.0529053584,
0.0028084998,
0.012012993,
0.0100228917,
-0.030904511,
0.010986343,
0.0011785172,
0.0200950895,
0.030825397,
0.0223996546,
-0.0043005231,
0.0180893838,
-0.0058631874,
-0.0117347362,
-0.0456456318,
-0.031009689,
-0.0097230766,
0.0191679336,
-0.0038814405,
0.005879622,
0.0932511091,
-0.0324484296,
-0.0504864007,
0.0198522713,
-0.0510623679,
0.0229235906,
-0.024607705,
-0.0163844358,
0.0018130424,
0.039258074,
-0.0187749173,
0.0706519336,
0.0268581994,
0.0489092395,
0.0264429096,
-0.0034337484,
0.0017442283,
-0.0687914044,
-0.0223387107,
0.0082063377,
-0.0086124269,
0.021375997,
0.0138436183,
0.0298622567,
-0.0643445626,
-0.0327117182,
-0.0921560526,
0.0178667065,
-0.0100329462,
0.0432235263,
0.0448889211,
0.0187909417,
-0.0024006381,
-0.0504842475,
-0.0603838935,
0.031379696,
0.0141904335,
0.0329802632,
0.0482669845,
-0.0031722842,
0.0242584143,
-0.0616654977,
-0.0266275257,
0.0068995734,
0.0012450501,
-0.0005181115,
-0.0235633459,
-0.024198018,
0.0043407157,
-0.0561134405,
0.0300719626,
-0.0185231492,
-0.0304583833,
-0.0077383248,
-0.0321236514,
0.0403601155,
0.0883709714,
0.0392302983,
-0.0071403314,
0.0060464381,
0.0359064415,
-0.0475706607,
0.0430257805,
-0.0062213074,
-0.0432828963,
-0.036826577,
-0.0173714869,
-0.0015583149,
0.0434656404,
-0.0142393382,
-0.0046225088,
-0.0670449883,
0.0575954281,
0.0157122165,
-0.0105691813,
-0.0618117116,
0.0475523621,
0.0037478937,
0.0285459161,
-0.0282582715,
-0.0059844949,
0.0648364127,
-0.0092504192,
-0.0347983502,
-0.0431043915,
-0.0270638354,
-0.0406873859,
0.0327923112,
0.0053226696,
0.0122850882,
-0.0417755283,
-0.0048562582,
-0.0544029474,
-0.0023274766,
-0.001102151,
-0.0410882495,
0.0301026832,
-0.0175797753,
0.0257308856,
-0.043910373,
-0.0795930251,
-0.0266178064,
-0.0617886595,
-0.045207262,
0.0093449708,
-0.026067866,
-0.0388326943,
-0.0071458397,
-0.0071903979,
0.0424982384,
0.044325687,
-0.0249975752,
-0.0111148031,
-0.0274963193,
0.0785606727,
0.1047856435,
0.0807212666,
0.0207502022,
-0.0334601849,
0.0744313374,
0.0462008826,
0.054318279,
-0.0196221527,
0.014905489,
0.0082284184,
0.0468121171,
-0.0030484435,
-0.0033622552,
0.0223936886,
0.0716874227,
-0.014967124,
-0.020515874,
0.1030990258,
0.0049214307,
-0.0220032148,
0.0038011705,
-0.0359470807,
0.0474887826,
0.0339812934,
0.0506250411,
-0.0717867315,
-0.0475363694,
-0.0123792617,
0.0531867594,
-0.0026993663,
-0.0298329461,
0.0121683646,
-0.1304898709,
0.0044819433,
-0.0514919013,
-0.0473154522,
-0.0138539299,
-0.0369069688,
0.0234710518,
-0.0082876664,
0.0033760089,
0.0035543689,
-0.0258134678,
-0.005094544,
0.0003821174,
-0.0039708223,
0.0186571367,
0.0398295261,
0.0197799355,
0.0653919205,
0.0424984358,
0.0322593935,
-0.0272308365,
-0.0337701179,
0.0002314541,
-0.0734099001,
-0.0036200772,
-0.0086339833,
0.047358416,
-0.0257767718,
-0.0094224876,
-0.023630321,
0.047326263,
-0.0429920591,
0.0091386754,
0.0419305228,
0.0528599583,
0.010758888,
-0.0210025907,
-0.0120195178,
-0.0032456219,
-0.0090766558,
0.0623448454,
0.037966907,
-0.0543871596,
-0.0371687599,
-0.0186781809,
-0.0277014412,
-0.0541543663,
-0.0177634992,
-0.0195659976,
0.0344015621,
0.0467225499,
-0.0563361645,
-0.0438009575,
0.046306774,
0.0110414131,
-0.0456048436,
0.0005219751,
-0.026920883,
0.0329113789,
-0.0206913278,
0.0375607871,
-0.0454646051,
-0.0025667215,
-0.0529371686,
-0.0251758676,
0.0227430295,
-0.0533650406,
-0.0264999494,
-0.0170814544,
-0.0527105518,
-0.0217271727,
-0.0143507486,
0.0594665296,
0.0259649567,
-0.0139032174,
-0.0191241167,
-0.0820000544,
0.041759152,
0.0095629692,
-0.0155737102,
0.0330808274,
0.0031339654,
0.0058600437,
-0.0282483343,
0.0452787615,
-0.053146109,
0.0101700732,
0.0146313459,
0.031997975,
-0.043433696,
-0.0675728992,
-0.0034218247,
0.0262662526,
-0.0312008541,
0.0621104091,
-0.039097134,
-0.0116770864,
0.045710288,
-0.0101677831,
0.0029784949,
-0.0218727868,
-0.0281047784,
0.0126371197,
-0.0405727774,
0.007169601,
-0.0237663984,
0.0067901653,
0.0093077496,
-0.0893700123,
-0.0104045924,
0.0417240784,
-0.0075113992,
0.0033674387,
-0.0173786767,
-0.0294674728,
-0.0047393492,
0.0310394336,
0.0590142012,
0.0030435787,
0.0428958237,
-0.0049415845,
-0.0380824693,
0.0186502337,
0.0542291068,
-0.0949272439,
-0.1086982265,
-0.0229142979,
0.0302793868,
0.0189057663,
0.0254171658,
0.067045033,
0.0246242695,
-0.0208042916,
0.0008216624,
-0.0272726417,
0.0421167724,
-0.0071973708,
0.0640666634,
0.0412477553,
0.0025566202,
0.0091682319,
0.0628073663,
0.0207097828,
0.049823828,
0.0031472642,
0.0006005655,
-0.0454098992,
-0.0147196343,
-0.0227200557,
0.0381900556,
0.0059624817,
0.0353789106,
-0.0098634558,
-0.0417964421,
-0.0237184297,
-0.0042339754,
-0.0290700085,
-0.0434055962,
0.019615259,
0.0450714491,
0.0068252054,
-0.053107515,
-0.041591499,
0.0286490805,
-0.0424407758,
-0.012936132,
-0.0086492617,
-6.485695306e-33,
-0.023484394,
0.0034534761,
0.0052055344,
-0.0206320193,
0.0244093481,
0.0245377738,
-0.0283200946,
0.0029441533,
-0.0754695684,
-0.0376090966,
-0.0377074555,
0.0263784993,
0.0065838946,
0.0432349779,
-0.0069346759,
-0.0450989082,
0.0247648209,
-0.0092328237,
-0.0326669775,
0.0584175885,
0.0173836164,
0.0139964642,
0.022672262,
-0.0070651481,
0.011328104,
-0.031869553,
-0.0043934141,
0.0145665118,
-0.020176826,
0.0494609103,
-0.0384321138,
0.0581950098,
0.0473260619,
-0.0210251268,
-0.0014939022,
0.050955005,
-0.0943503976,
-0.0337032042,
0.0225149952,
-0.0377016626,
-0.0542828217,
-0.0211818926,
0.0112170735,
-0.002291702,
0.0109355282,
-0.0327232406,
0.0401548296,
-0.0293159634,
0.0166707393,
0.0169479847,
-0.0247053187,
-0.0074759107,
-0.0113710696,
-0.0201589558,
-0.0181572139,
0.0912224427,
-0.0105074635,
0.0292248707,
-0.0453933962,
0.0260610748,
0.0069082361,
0.0619565882,
0.0521273017,
-0.0098096766,
-0.0434374176,
0.0242524203,
0.0148836104,
-0.0129101817,
0.0320201665,
-0.0311832186,
-0.0395777486,
0.0206515789,
0.0654884428,
0.0466700122,
-0.0020272189,
0.0077155228,
-0.0464117005,
0.0333187655,
0.0468768477,
-0.0068532364,
0.0342419073,
-0.0169737618,
-0.0349067524,
0.0080880634,
-0.0410296507,
0.0264932644,
-0.0632308275,
-0.0101002296,
0.0433170907,
0.0225597546,
-0.0200524759,
0.003764478,
0.0208044928,
-0.0444567837,
0.0000075821,
0.0063146218,
-0.0078573683,
0.0207526907,
0.0176676195,
0.0335757807,
-0.0422497503,
-0.0138873393,
0.0342453197,
0.008000223,
-0.0052772453,
0.0230705012,
0.0018072204,
-0.0102911806,
-0.0722741336,
-0.0147648668,
-0.0300847664,
0.0371890254,
-0.0477029718,
0.0464792177,
-0.0159617066,
-0.0034483168,
-0.0000953225,
0.0274616275,
-0.0020953438,
0.0267168153,
-0.0324061178,
-0.0736754164,
-0.0020712798,
-0.0144016948,
-0.0419361517,
-0.0028080528,
-0.0290728044,
0.0347682275,
-0.0403215997,
-0.0406772047,
-0.0078269867,
0.0136968251,
2.611e-7,
0.0238893926,
0.0201964546,
-0.0230677463,
-0.0062022605,
0.0177702364,
0.0289913435,
0.0259468239,
0.0634059533,
0.0499839857,
-0.0047251792,
-0.009408324,
0.0147546958,
0.0359827429,
-0.0133446259,
-0.0532929078,
-0.030997755,
-0.0863738135,
-0.0051446119,
-0.0516555645,
-0.0356125496,
0.0493365899,
0.075572744,
-0.0150080668,
-0.0215077735,
-0.018768305,
-0.0315480977,
0.0392507687,
-0.0088826735,
-0.0179149918,
-0.004704182,
0.0511909537,
0.0315554626,
-0.0016036853,
0.0159983933,
-0.0063139843,
0.0314836577,
0.0116632506,
0.0661511645,
-0.0047112121,
-0.0415698178,
0.0072825802,
0.0097401524,
0.0336868726,
-0.0732824951,
0.1084419787,
-0.0051208856,
-0.0341252722,
-0.0027431312,
-0.0181176029,
-0.0306448173,
-0.0095017534,
-0.0197877642,
-0.025079824,
-0.019254582,
0.0058411132,
-0.01117534,
0.0133994278,
-0.0639752448,
0.0107659716,
0.0040821382,
-0.0378001742,
-0.0956638306,
-0.0599754304,
-0.0177651178,
0.0043151812,
-0.066733174,
0.0120641077,
2.171403471e-34,
0.000185612,
0.0259684194,
0.0452202559,
0.0122455759,
0.0039249458,
0.0210290626,
0.0264046416,
-0.0533861592,
0.0591905117,
-0.1191842556,
-0.0082432088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12272v1 | AMR Parsing with Instruction Fine-tuned Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-04-24T17:12:17 | 2023-04-24T17:12:17 | Young-Suk Lee, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo, Radu Florian, Tahira Naseem, Salim Roukos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction fine-tuned language models on a collection of instruction
annotated datasets (FLAN) have shown highly effective to improve model
performance and generalization to unseen tasks. However, a majority of standard
parsing tasks including abstract meaning representation (AMR), universal
dependency (UD), semantic role labeling (SRL) has been excluded from the FLAN
collections for both model training and evaluations. In this paper, we take one
of such instruction fine-tuned pre-trained language models, i.e. FLAN-T5, and
fine-tune them for AMR parsing. Our extensive experiments on various AMR
parsing tasks including AMR2.0, AMR3.0 and BioAMR indicate that FLAN-T5
fine-tuned models out-perform previous state-of-the-art models across all
tasks. In addition, full fine-tuning followed by the parameter efficient
fine-tuning, LoRA, further improves the model performances, setting new
state-of-the-arts in Smatch on AMR2.0 (86.4), AMR3.0 (84.9) and BioAMR (82.3). | [
0.0376937203,
0.0369979031,
0.0032072305,
0.0182593055,
-0.010410686,
0.056958843,
-0.001998863,
-0.0775788575,
-0.0465790592,
-0.0535904802,
-0.0634803399,
-0.0246894173,
-0.0341964923,
0.0063366732,
-0.006639943,
-0.0212157425,
0.0554469638,
0.0153057119,
0.0406219959,
0.0189274233,
0.0094914846,
0.0349815115,
0.0087795267,
0.0277877748,
-0.0095578246,
-0.0288490877,
0.0126022231,
-0.0112373792,
0.0217448715,
-0.0237974077,
0.0477139167,
0.0202497747,
0.0319551155,
0.0046040933,
0.0000021715,
-0.0335955173,
-0.0483356677,
0.0207371581,
-0.0337543376,
0.0049652574,
0.078950204,
-0.0203163251,
0.0187941175,
0.0309493281,
-0.0446488075,
-0.0567017458,
0.0268940516,
0.03440056,
0.0492825955,
0.0904558823,
-0.0218976494,
-0.0790861771,
0.0428716764,
-0.038690947,
-0.0340530463,
-0.0171929691,
-0.0094008129,
0.0400959477,
-0.0189086888,
0.0186514966,
-0.0364030935,
0.0218182169,
0.0139882602,
0.0215044096,
0.0075901225,
0.0051580337,
-0.0565982759,
-0.0211562589,
0.0185506549,
0.0847248286,
-0.0509747714,
-0.0363496095,
-0.0016110454,
-0.0229889248,
-0.0496336222,
-0.0022959558,
-0.0027015975,
0.0517424569,
-0.0083493181,
0.0490023308,
0.098334901,
0.0076511321,
0.0116317309,
0.0371049307,
-0.0246181618,
0.0628921911,
-0.0008858141,
-0.044730287,
0.0297454912,
0.0109193772,
-0.0734207705,
-0.0095504262,
0.0371207073,
-0.0162340086,
0.012118334,
0.0135319959,
-0.0471804552,
-0.0305630956,
0.0074700685,
0.0163070094,
0.0591637082,
0.0627010167,
-0.0586765036,
0.0102930181,
-0.0050199302,
0.0128845032,
0.0132921906,
0.0317382105,
-0.0446664058,
0.0170531664,
-0.0577752888,
0.0179595258,
-0.0504170619,
0.0423505716,
-0.0663869232,
-0.0307106562,
-0.0329531468,
0.0168866888,
0.0124316271,
0.0082347514,
0.0337938555,
-0.0317404717,
-0.0511739403,
0.0229449552,
0.0019559234,
0.0450974144,
0.001269175,
0.011789646,
-0.0066758986,
-0.05986467,
-0.0352308005,
0.0044819559,
0.0227718484,
-0.0625296384,
0.0264871679,
0.0205898117,
0.0054606851,
-0.0403729901,
0.0095541039,
-0.0248641651,
0.0339795873,
-0.0540625006,
-0.0024299801,
-0.0369316638,
0.0234731883,
0.0136812609,
0.0252298396,
0.0085462695,
0.009900271,
0.030992331,
0.0112350797,
0.0546725877,
-0.0326202884,
-0.0051940475,
-0.0159196276,
-0.0078064953,
0.0266945995,
0.0291164648,
0.0053670937,
0.012506674,
-0.0038803734,
-0.0047146454,
-0.0123537416,
0.0045356345,
-0.0041024243,
-0.0290894527,
0.045455426,
0.0362579338,
-0.0547055081,
0.0099486802,
0.0430724807,
0.0228636246,
-0.0205291715,
0.0108830445,
0.0184614211,
0.0095101474,
-0.0172661934,
0.0111802137,
0.07732784,
0.0441210344,
0.0101605412,
-0.0194986742,
-0.0832805485,
-0.0057639219,
-0.0228899382,
0.0349075906,
-0.0720589459,
0.0019498188,
-0.0169555042,
-0.0249005165,
-0.0164543912,
-0.0384114459,
-0.0126950154,
0.0241548773,
0.0461202078,
0.0353838913,
-0.0490484051,
0.0637928098,
0.0292371213,
-0.0265925955,
0.0077652866,
-0.019364519,
-0.0067778477,
0.0277865529,
0.023350155,
-0.0660475716,
-0.0613821819,
-0.0444006957,
0.0455380008,
0.0240611937,
0.0333230235,
0.006033883,
0.014361375,
-0.071057938,
-0.0105277086,
-0.0396319292,
0.035290096,
-0.0098603982,
-0.029019,
-0.0267082322,
0.0132385725,
-0.0185773652,
-0.0700781122,
0.0431637652,
0.0015430547,
-0.017800875,
-0.0312775709,
0.0086272396,
0.0466548689,
0.0280130357,
-0.0198565889,
0.0192962792,
0.0274612997,
-0.0446192548,
0.0370486863,
0.0216680504,
-0.0984157547,
-0.0582905374,
0.0209270865,
-0.0242499392,
-0.0303471852,
0.0736702532,
-0.0579946041,
-0.0344171301,
-0.0220649894,
0.0060051414,
0.0310348682,
-0.0014224789,
0.0260219853,
0.0418958217,
0.0023680041,
-0.0262809061,
0.0578039587,
-0.0500842035,
-0.0020655722,
-0.0126470923,
0.0287770834,
-0.0025340545,
-0.0201922674,
-0.0353248082,
-0.0151022701,
-0.0016986311,
-0.0352623202,
-0.0071714171,
0.0193755683,
-0.0284817014,
0.0060618236,
-0.0304661673,
0.0042070071,
-0.0513279289,
0.0493762754,
0.0607626513,
0.0096544512,
0.0332903899,
0.0169389788,
-0.0093131429,
-0.0215254389,
-0.0191805977,
-0.0002837772,
0.0163614918,
0.0046121958,
-0.0188583434,
-0.0462159552,
-0.0271597914,
-0.0183877386,
-0.0141358534,
0.001433099,
-0.0010116342,
-0.0181357339,
0.0429469608,
0.0152073381,
0.0140747465,
-0.0224214382,
-0.0488786437,
-0.0222310349,
-0.0139148645,
-0.0368664414,
0.0495733693,
-0.0251769684,
0.0366099812,
0.0137057863,
0.0182165466,
-0.0319915228,
0.0122791296,
0.0101105869,
-0.0080497377,
-0.043685142,
-0.0334065631,
-0.0064332737,
0.0941198096,
0.005216707,
0.0202113073,
-0.026471138,
-0.0247002058,
-0.0574345477,
-0.0339658298,
0.0220052619,
0.0076890457,
-0.0039649722,
-0.011306324,
-0.0698998123,
-0.0072838478,
0.0511807948,
-0.0185521245,
-0.05988748,
-0.0756107196,
-0.0267651714,
-0.0439715274,
0.0220543239,
0.0236641187,
0.0057749632,
-0.0016796427,
-0.0598016083,
0.000012118,
-0.0050305105,
0.0243186448,
-0.0278420504,
0.0303695202,
-0.0373071395,
0.0078145443,
-0.0279226433,
-0.0238179471,
0.002053716,
-0.06716571,
-0.0218964312,
0.052813258,
-0.0084768524,
0.0328836367,
-0.0313586369,
0.0008586914,
-0.0208361112,
0.0459296666,
-0.0026732835,
0.025361713,
-0.0476386137,
-0.0128794173,
0.0875429139,
-0.0203058477,
0.0007078597,
-0.0056243134,
0.0350705683,
-0.0132885044,
-0.0092811733,
-0.035299249,
-0.0409440137,
0.0496428311,
0.0253258031,
-0.0212066378,
-0.0212181527,
-0.0218376704,
0.0796454474,
-0.0583056919,
-0.0202270281,
0.1097430363,
0.0444753468,
-0.0070919651,
0.0300908796,
0.019500833,
0.0165462736,
0.0294472538,
-0.0018830956,
-0.1124001369,
-0.0376714282,
0.0071131005,
-0.0133590372,
-0.001370114,
-0.0328736044,
0.0273623522,
-0.1162956059,
0.0139155686,
0.0010090084,
-0.0354930684,
-0.0143959159,
0.0186027344,
-0.0232892819,
-0.0694398805,
0.0625527725,
-0.0065353932,
-0.0565395616,
0.0159291569,
0.0362407044,
-0.0219177473,
-0.0736688226,
0.0482325703,
-0.0270086788,
0.0526333563,
0.0475620106,
-0.0094354777,
-0.0512230769,
-0.0144795803,
0.0538517758,
-0.0385018922,
0.0226008482,
-0.0375123061,
0.0217400715,
-0.0460498855,
-0.0231042784,
0.0031086567,
0.021500187,
-0.011597923,
0.0063099009,
-0.0456276983,
0.050118234,
-0.022908939,
0.0293470211,
0.0283394977,
-0.0456477292,
0.0084178774,
0.0679671615,
0.0280017741,
-0.0042286706,
-0.0627217889,
-0.0190708898,
0.0278353076,
-0.0562781356,
0.0160147231,
0.0189839825,
-0.0282369424,
-0.0163256302,
-0.0282571949,
-0.0735059083,
0.0801222771,
-0.025100071,
-0.02469985,
-0.0011481433,
0.0257481243,
-0.0260898154,
-0.0385764241,
0.07428056,
-0.0089638997,
0.0262880791,
-0.0654708594,
-0.0674154982,
0.0360127278,
-0.002694098,
-0.0509022214,
-0.0035721015,
-0.0224401876,
-0.0483099371,
0.02520095,
0.0830527097,
0.013384169,
0.0205003433,
-0.0441693328,
-0.0387662202,
-0.011720039,
-0.0294218361,
-0.0512763597,
-0.0050790403,
0.0652109608,
0.0191808864,
0.0011073983,
0.024979597,
-0.0246782638,
0.064329505,
0.017837381,
0.072076261,
-0.0113282464,
-0.0013759023,
0.065416798,
0.0462521352,
0.0550243147,
0.0095377043,
-0.0135450428,
-0.0271462165,
0.0276212208,
-0.0468053557,
-0.0100575294,
-0.0488606952,
0.0289141126,
0.0490542091,
-0.0279575624,
-0.0212372523,
0.0171926506,
-0.0026509694,
0.0281700417,
-0.0241940692,
0.0579007082,
0.0218849089,
0.0170471296,
-0.0093857795,
0.0437279493,
-0.0649325103,
-0.0129044335,
0.0172921028,
0.0276764985,
-0.0121794613,
0.0117141521,
-0.001263427,
0.0344239399,
-0.0485184193,
0.0429546498,
0.0005791302,
-0.0030309018,
-0.017707143,
0.0058282297,
0.0642215312,
-0.0653983802,
0.0936279818,
0.0106159421,
0.0126177277,
-0.018698154,
0.042246189,
-0.0030901725,
-0.0186169483,
0.0366070718,
0.0073072426,
-0.0250433143,
-0.032298103,
0.0578469783,
-0.0071256589,
0.0771136507,
0.0056774989,
0.0227818582,
-0.0468031056,
0.0130126113,
-0.0041738017,
0.0293540023,
-0.0262242816,
0.0124459099,
-0.019246608,
-0.0538291149,
-0.0096735107,
-0.003098635,
-0.0108889751,
-0.0079762712,
0.0121939359,
0.0260800999,
0.0107490942,
-0.0623461045,
-0.0317011885,
-0.0495856777,
0.0034541006,
-0.0121374559,
-0.0494971611,
-6.683001299e-33,
-0.045448456,
0.048264239,
0.0026521059,
-0.0185556393,
-0.0213853512,
-0.0038153031,
-0.031994015,
-0.02901843,
-0.0335329473,
0.0241882093,
0.0048461184,
-0.0135038858,
0.0254101958,
0.0184586141,
0.0278897882,
-0.0087346798,
0.0732771456,
-0.0043736477,
0.0074505867,
-0.0116356462,
0.0035451211,
0.0422324613,
0.0719992295,
-0.0176267438,
-0.0277400706,
-0.0091748023,
-0.0000448984,
-0.0049910406,
-0.0257543735,
0.0545432977,
-0.0007981973,
0.0257351603,
0.0344204642,
0.0196232814,
-0.0473651774,
-0.0186283495,
-0.1389357895,
-0.0079569472,
0.0622752495,
0.0047285841,
-0.0355451331,
-0.0279210303,
0.0317967534,
-0.0173034947,
0.0122672291,
-0.0050944262,
0.0304378178,
-0.012590006,
0.0316644795,
-0.009393109,
-0.0512484796,
0.0228916761,
0.0137944203,
-0.0126870768,
0.0585080832,
0.0246514026,
0.0062048198,
0.0069603487,
-0.0333959982,
-0.0294749681,
-0.0050226003,
0.0625034869,
0.0125692878,
0.0079103159,
0.0236426108,
0.0393800102,
-0.0056452751,
-0.0287857782,
0.0518801659,
0.0349949338,
0.0085377088,
0.0909331366,
-0.0334168375,
-0.0054553524,
0.0185881518,
0.0052628,
-0.0238347314,
-0.0278485864,
0.0287065823,
0.0848439634,
-0.0213836264,
0.0186635889,
-0.052531559,
0.0058432855,
-0.0189378913,
0.0289241839,
-0.0285373796,
-0.0096359849,
0.0466758497,
0.0177149903,
-0.013187835,
0.0666071624,
0.0378678851,
-0.0200591609,
0.0117161917,
-0.0282575916,
0.0208172388,
0.0096420944,
-0.0149993636,
0.0192939769,
-0.0745355412,
-0.051105395,
0.0061854324,
-0.031816151,
0.0278746821,
0.0112979254,
0.0619575381,
0.0274771228,
-0.0257688835,
0.0169089455,
-0.0279628467,
0.0135669475,
-0.005460036,
0.0548207425,
0.0210162345,
0.0349890888,
-0.0260723997,
0.0478163958,
0.0075757378,
0.00971046,
-0.0304226372,
0.0056525539,
0.0207703672,
0.0388379544,
-0.0339356959,
0.0102749811,
0.0058784122,
0.0079993485,
0.0207119826,
-0.0311471205,
-0.0252449289,
0.0145290978,
2.801e-7,
0.0642298535,
0.0520619228,
0.0382508188,
0.0002996024,
-0.0165207181,
-0.0160196349,
-0.023234928,
0.0337295607,
0.004367738,
0.0011027677,
-0.0134876817,
-0.0093964022,
0.0339388624,
0.0014877695,
-0.0622375533,
0.0400185585,
-0.0477891713,
-0.0039228927,
-0.0229572505,
0.0179938078,
0.0665356517,
0.1194952875,
-0.0103166299,
0.0188044216,
-0.0218730178,
0.0001893079,
0.0291970298,
-0.0175667554,
-0.0279341191,
0.0089342911,
-0.0246525239,
0.034438394,
-0.0121307559,
-0.0046320991,
0.0037058576,
0.0264325067,
0.0070370212,
0.0919433832,
-0.0360964574,
0.0140004326,
0.012803534,
0.0028988349,
-0.0193534251,
-0.0111034336,
0.0619801618,
-0.0736001059,
-0.0268763117,
-0.0115967253,
-0.081972748,
0.0268909335,
-0.0263080429,
0.0122028748,
0.0159301516,
0.0082751019,
0.0259702876,
-0.0238542221,
-0.0568353012,
-0.078103587,
-0.0181944352,
0.0572280884,
0.0161285494,
-0.0166313313,
0.0031679654,
-0.0127162831,
0.0254755672,
-0.0662622154,
-0.0358599536,
2.849442158e-34,
0.0476877764,
-0.000020986,
0.0302435234,
0.0596271418,
0.0337091349,
0.0155290365,
-0.0702921227,
0.0506703071,
-0.0444435365,
-0.092995137,
-0.0033766262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12269v1 | Enriching Source Code with Contextual Data for Code Completion Models: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-24T17:09:14 | 2023-04-24T17:09:14 | Tim van Dam, Maliheh Izadi, Arie van Deursen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based pre-trained models have recently achieved great results in
solving many software engineering tasks including automatic code completion
which is a staple in a developer's toolkit. While many have striven to improve
the code-understanding abilities of such models, the opposite -- making the
code easier to understand -- has not been properly investigated. In this study,
we aim to answer whether making code easier to understand through using
contextual data improves the performance of pre-trained code language models
for the task of code completion. We consider type annotations and comments as
two common forms of additional contextual information that often help
developers understand code better. For the experiments, we study code
completion in two granularity levels; token and line completion and take three
recent and large-scale language models for source code: UniXcoder, CodeGPT, and
InCoder with five evaluation metrics. Finally, we perform the Wilcoxon Signed
Rank test to gauge significance and measure the effect size. Contrary to our
expectations, all models perform better if type annotations are removed (albeit
the effect sizes are small). For comments, we find that the models perform
better in the presence of multi-line comments (again with small effect sizes).
Based on our observations, we recommend making proper design choices when
training, fine-tuning, or simply selecting such models given the intended data
and application. Better evaluations and multi-modal techniques can also be
further investigated to improve the practicality and accuracy of
auto-completions. | [
0.0203073863,
0.0690408573,
-0.0520317741,
-0.0039392575,
0.0229358766,
0.009244075,
-0.0188453831,
-0.0029862106,
-0.0207916182,
-0.0212321598,
-0.0063627195,
0.0695511177,
0.0101614334,
0.0268386658,
0.0279670972,
-0.0334473178,
0.0412467867,
-0.0226874612,
-0.0320728347,
0.0402218066,
-0.0184130669,
0.0065749851,
0.021428803,
0.0870051533,
0.0181582384,
-0.0278889593,
-0.0017798651,
0.0013800708,
-0.0351891108,
-0.0106166406,
0.0060050511,
0.0629438683,
0.0086010899,
0.0114818867,
0.0000022069,
-0.0285467003,
-0.0184036177,
-0.0037021881,
-0.0207579155,
0.0340549089,
-0.0365416147,
-0.0384673513,
0.0278767664,
-0.0036881827,
-0.0378482081,
-0.0199365504,
0.0604032613,
-0.0059944433,
0.028649319,
0.0072273538,
0.0078160083,
-0.0035504466,
0.0193632822,
0.0040422222,
0.0584768839,
-0.0123129515,
-0.0014045959,
0.0659973994,
0.0166488234,
0.0639291406,
-0.003922232,
0.0219490547,
0.0091406945,
0.0023184221,
0.0573181547,
0.0553001054,
-0.018467145,
-0.011916724,
0.0350868702,
0.0166891403,
-0.0380925871,
-0.0237184167,
-0.0048221019,
-0.0223269183,
-0.0205932651,
-0.0291424748,
-0.0350796059,
-0.0046639494,
-0.0163651705,
-0.0157847162,
-0.0159093235,
-0.0200931244,
0.0057540322,
-0.0313523412,
-0.0110338768,
0.0393393673,
-0.0215124078,
-0.003720873,
-0.0193608422,
-0.0142216962,
-0.0265218355,
-0.079377763,
-0.0069811661,
0.0295603909,
0.006579373,
-0.0046533667,
-0.0134111894,
-0.0227533281,
0.0350922979,
-0.0272654258,
-0.0350256711,
0.0773144662,
-0.0766279995,
0.0032029741,
-0.0619844273,
0.0450494364,
-0.0039263777,
-0.0106833884,
-0.0131110987,
0.0021904872,
-0.044117514,
-0.0069492697,
-0.0600883178,
0.0346379317,
-0.0078955842,
0.0321681462,
-0.0257641878,
0.0600203387,
0.0270949937,
0.0378298648,
-0.0054376307,
-0.0465155058,
-0.0425927192,
0.0229708347,
0.0250047203,
-0.0253477693,
-0.0406756476,
-0.0139299342,
-0.0370392911,
-0.0353365988,
0.0061533293,
-0.0069871973,
-0.0289056599,
-0.0373401307,
0.0178029761,
0.0566491932,
0.0350664593,
0.0183978267,
-0.0535880253,
-0.0172984395,
0.0148149915,
0.0323070697,
-0.0410801172,
-0.09613996,
-0.0620753765,
0.0724992305,
0.0044348668,
-0.0451447591,
-0.0211353302,
0.0018886529,
0.0092365397,
0.0598597154,
-0.0881926939,
0.02362407,
0.0313278958,
-0.0070371232,
-0.0502788946,
0.0217102449,
0.0261494331,
0.0238587074,
0.0230978224,
-0.0932314843,
0.049878832,
0.0003758989,
-0.0216953568,
-0.0219910927,
0.0060674394,
0.0352044217,
0.0137935448,
-0.0520392247,
0.0385453999,
-0.004436492,
-0.0099652475,
0.0138738146,
-0.0076379566,
0.0136324102,
0.0545001663,
0.0702423528,
0.0596647933,
0.0279606618,
0.0067438055,
-0.0129674552,
-0.050456997,
0.0553002395,
-0.0198202394,
0.0400397293,
0.0020131061,
0.0177571271,
0.006060462,
-0.1005717665,
-0.0071829418,
-0.0286046211,
0.0103018377,
-0.0005299452,
0.049734883,
0.0097913919,
-0.0357869677,
0.0022358897,
0.0437604375,
-0.0367342234,
-0.0422697328,
-0.0268531311,
0.0373208039,
0.0217041001,
0.0301734656,
-0.071442984,
-0.0092279259,
-0.0398216695,
-0.0008132574,
-0.0706567317,
0.0223489273,
-0.009569726,
0.0158108473,
-0.0522336252,
-0.0379030667,
-0.0340876691,
-0.0069529228,
0.0587432943,
0.0097719561,
-0.0413828157,
0.0292469617,
-0.0320320688,
-0.047948163,
0.0379834399,
0.0149009787,
-0.0091705844,
-0.0039160629,
-0.0127691338,
-0.0005419929,
-0.0297731292,
-0.0393469781,
0.0082158484,
0.0284492597,
-0.001779484,
-0.031636063,
0.0157741643,
-0.0149924997,
-0.0152776418,
-0.0088367872,
-0.029779071,
-0.0278999098,
0.0039261142,
0.002618595,
0.0043544802,
0.0300121121,
-0.0283337552,
0.0733561739,
0.0185479335,
0.0069173384,
-0.0223774482,
-0.0270961616,
-0.0341185033,
0.0525994785,
0.0264547635,
0.0491639823,
0.0103990976,
0.0334942713,
0.048010692,
0.0367832631,
-0.0468706749,
-0.0067744609,
-0.0284584723,
0.0152289355,
0.0370998755,
0.0179973654,
-0.0214349814,
-0.0171039365,
-0.1303834617,
-0.0066457936,
-0.0094857113,
-0.0026914314,
-0.0146079846,
0.0447091982,
0.0000909869,
-0.0400347598,
0.0118796751,
-0.0355098583,
-0.0652587563,
0.0071353032,
0.0312490072,
0.0147470124,
-0.0429198295,
-0.061400678,
-0.032413628,
-0.0470042787,
0.0386390314,
0.0130287604,
-0.029422028,
-0.0392552987,
0.0844672248,
0.0269313138,
0.0116681289,
-0.0406387299,
-0.0476698838,
0.0253172256,
-0.0179256815,
0.0775577798,
0.0525644347,
0.0109618641,
-0.0159848295,
0.0412403978,
0.0225574803,
-0.0668394268,
0.0255431887,
0.0274013262,
-0.0645003021,
-0.0091455728,
-0.0323628932,
0.0517627858,
0.085265927,
-0.0155139025,
-0.0094609056,
-0.0361270122,
-0.0235441476,
0.0020664104,
0.0216385685,
0.0051295715,
-0.042644009,
0.0025023541,
0.0668996125,
-0.0037478271,
-0.0984311476,
0.0675723702,
-0.0614051707,
-0.0414999202,
-0.0043757427,
-0.0076291445,
-0.062785618,
0.0507525802,
0.0303118974,
-0.0011236267,
0.0036774641,
-0.0467888527,
0.0058480273,
0.0288291927,
-0.0133787394,
0.0132491412,
0.051966235,
-0.0005684971,
0.0084122466,
-0.0034256617,
0.0003138061,
-0.0428857394,
-0.0292171761,
-0.0382535532,
-0.0318640508,
0.0673625246,
0.004216678,
0.0600001849,
0.0269857962,
0.027284706,
0.0487862863,
0.0522901192,
-0.0645723939,
-0.0405017808,
-0.0660832152,
-0.0399848744,
-0.0390015207,
-0.0090363948,
-0.0087826028,
-0.020857539,
-0.0067790044,
0.0547444299,
0.0452725105,
-0.0838902071,
-0.0350984484,
0.0426206477,
-0.0308046788,
-0.0914277509,
0.0429443382,
0.0520844087,
-0.0157448072,
0.0146913975,
0.0833564252,
0.0393904969,
-0.0399991684,
0.0085711274,
-0.0170691814,
0.0337560065,
0.0816473439,
0.0297070798,
-0.0790133476,
-0.024804147,
0.001520536,
0.0193155259,
-0.0158511009,
0.0015560144,
0.0031342711,
-0.0221438836,
0.0146611622,
-0.0098287519,
-0.0336736143,
-0.0245338324,
-0.0227494519,
0.0186194591,
-0.0215690956,
-0.0651081204,
0.0075802184,
-0.0066176062,
0.0299105644,
0.0317071266,
-0.0409663282,
0.0170233045,
0.0239378754,
-0.0366583169,
0.0310613643,
0.0953227133,
-0.0073551629,
-0.0096342368,
0.0020361836,
0.0551719181,
0.0001428763,
0.0257565193,
-0.0135210166,
0.0599506758,
-0.0058411919,
-0.0039403299,
0.0518682562,
-0.0128550138,
-0.0374061391,
-0.0174670704,
0.0433402844,
0.0286938921,
-0.0058511249,
0.0098903403,
-0.0218755696,
-0.0016354522,
-0.0345376767,
0.0212845393,
0.065506272,
-0.0119341891,
-0.0034842964,
-0.0797534809,
0.0222421419,
-0.0329417028,
0.0044392208,
-0.0249582082,
-0.0046391245,
-0.0212517325,
-0.0161798578,
-0.0219867788,
0.0442271084,
0.0179414228,
0.0062996782,
0.0046556001,
0.019104816,
0.0081111901,
-0.0434657708,
0.0424289182,
0.0110556018,
0.0065689874,
-0.0366221815,
-0.043575827,
0.0112317074,
-0.0450919494,
-0.0464364588,
-0.0296671074,
-0.0682255924,
-0.0023509813,
-0.0244895089,
0.058419086,
0.019262448,
0.022254834,
-0.047341641,
-0.0835775509,
-0.0658091381,
0.0270747766,
-0.0343457609,
-0.0069718612,
0.0487762764,
0.0138930688,
0.0215818956,
-0.0258393269,
-0.046374891,
0.0017532941,
-0.0093947873,
-0.0496912673,
-0.0331696458,
-0.0066495952,
0.0529738329,
0.0077937432,
0.0320100188,
0.0544126481,
0.0013663881,
-0.008574117,
-0.0016192271,
-0.0014392331,
-0.0019518068,
-0.0365648977,
0.005682359,
0.0091177151,
0.0056059314,
0.0446359217,
0.0130576668,
-0.0665594935,
0.0321294256,
-0.0278023556,
0.0748066083,
0.0382619239,
0.0501418598,
0.0620244816,
0.0147055248,
-0.0312612392,
-0.0225699078,
0.0401126742,
0.0402201787,
-0.0203526802,
0.0426210128,
0.0065845074,
0.0331226699,
0.0257746149,
0.000742609,
-0.0674011186,
-0.0599460006,
-0.0125661362,
-0.0179408975,
-0.0162265897,
0.0220321901,
0.0116705522,
0.0020161353,
0.0319770463,
-0.0154186655,
0.0555781983,
0.0238015577,
-0.0358527713,
0.0040863534,
0.0336577073,
-0.033409562,
-0.0432950817,
0.1105793938,
-0.0253221299,
0.0119086448,
-0.0374302566,
-0.0357364379,
-0.0207468662,
0.048477117,
0.0508860722,
0.0368322432,
-0.0384312645,
-0.0139097171,
-0.0184565298,
-0.0475913435,
-0.0022805433,
0.0078143207,
0.0140642198,
-0.0105367992,
0.0174124148,
0.1061692536,
0.0126745356,
-0.0600934997,
-0.0159366261,
0.003863022,
0.0349342376,
-0.0287486054,
-0.0583736524,
-5.228685565e-33,
-0.0373328663,
-0.0190652236,
-0.0039273808,
0.0228678565,
0.0470022336,
0.001315043,
-0.0473377183,
0.0205091536,
-0.0203610379,
-0.0488074236,
0.0159626566,
0.0231701043,
-0.014367369,
-0.0389707126,
0.075090304,
0.0199780446,
0.064834401,
0.0750349537,
-0.0364910327,
0.0274182931,
-0.0489715338,
0.0193054285,
0.0101424186,
-0.0667521358,
0.0275201257,
-0.0071667326,
0.0452654436,
-0.0388309546,
0.0358070023,
0.0927581191,
0.009960182,
-0.0028561493,
0.003081064,
-0.0156702455,
-0.0467285067,
-0.0213040765,
-0.0285035186,
-0.0179700945,
0.0231158584,
0.0207508858,
0.0039506149,
-0.0469524749,
0.0805054605,
-0.0206509195,
-0.0042516463,
0.0030428877,
0.05474912,
0.0030285926,
-0.0020080679,
-0.0252772756,
-0.054652635,
0.0410002545,
-0.0640950352,
0.0053546517,
0.0003058809,
0.064588584,
0.02857426,
0.0708745047,
0.0320131518,
-0.0060565793,
0.0291177016,
0.0469869375,
0.0445800424,
-0.0110547468,
-0.0103866663,
-0.0339739099,
0.0414284393,
0.0270751305,
-0.0250324737,
-0.0028700565,
0.0448204316,
0.0398458354,
0.0178145301,
0.017365003,
0.0378385857,
-0.0215650592,
-0.0011874968,
0.0371689349,
-0.019683456,
0.0094432533,
0.0007046341,
0.0523222275,
-0.0644205883,
-0.0010330426,
-0.0515105538,
-0.0351455249,
-0.0079701282,
-0.0564104393,
0.0277665816,
-0.0120192338,
0.0075515695,
0.0176337734,
0.0152983833,
-0.0302012134,
0.0213746503,
0.0048897373,
-0.0559714772,
0.0644207597,
-0.0189395212,
0.0173304267,
-0.0064599556,
0.0070543224,
0.0256064422,
-0.0264808182,
0.087616615,
0.0159187317,
0.0278322659,
0.0037740846,
-0.0678125992,
-0.0237413198,
-0.0281649698,
-0.0454354621,
-0.0338663608,
-0.0075343405,
0.0196627732,
0.0100797173,
-0.0031311519,
0.0278699677,
-0.0130658662,
-0.0137109058,
-0.0814583674,
-0.0184079576,
0.0076173386,
0.0026732285,
-0.0049569714,
-0.0689715147,
-0.0179657806,
0.042536445,
0.0361790806,
-0.0086234985,
-0.0590707846,
0.0149337137,
2.743e-7,
0.0273976456,
0.0312464628,
0.0051707043,
0.0090430211,
-0.0189565066,
0.039862562,
-0.014264565,
-0.0117520252,
0.0540534593,
0.0133741675,
-0.0201098435,
-0.029334439,
0.0139680291,
0.0492568575,
-0.0393066704,
-0.0430325232,
0.0018325804,
0.0055643367,
-0.0629715398,
0.018221084,
0.0564986877,
0.0486780927,
-0.0157970767,
0.0512597747,
0.0252858121,
-0.0248902626,
0.0007766447,
-0.0432930626,
0.0373113714,
0.0636817515,
-0.0282309838,
0.0382160358,
0.0055787498,
0.0008719629,
-0.0113242054,
-0.0322329961,
0.034433838,
0.0209872797,
0.0130581306,
0.0681006536,
0.01721281,
-0.0037727479,
0.0019134699,
-0.0872831047,
0.0283376537,
-0.0455972105,
0.0199024417,
0.0162020791,
-0.0497150235,
0.0037972275,
-0.0145717915,
0.0111397794,
0.0163821112,
-0.0056642452,
0.0071861651,
-0.027623862,
-0.0412413701,
-0.0312735587,
-0.0418995172,
0.0291707702,
-0.0253904462,
-0.0248940662,
-0.0602657981,
-0.0135232694,
0.0428505652,
-0.0197227988,
0.0165160783,
2.493298594e-34,
0.0441013835,
-0.0246660784,
0.0336036645,
0.0326778628,
0.0467657074,
-0.021065535,
0.001766858,
0.0228762124,
0.0187793765,
-0.0111332713,
-0.0337577686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12244v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12244v2 | WizardLM: Empowering Large Language Models to Follow Complex Instructions | 2023-04-24T16:31:06 | 2023-06-10T13:18:25 | Can Xu, Qingfeng Sun, Kai Zheng, Xiubo Geng, Pu Zhao, Jiazhan Feng, Chongyang Tao, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training large language models (LLMs) with open-domain instruction following
data brings colossal success. However, manually creating such instruction data
is very time-consuming and labor-intensive. Moreover, humans may struggle to
produce high-complexity instructions. In this paper, we show an avenue for
creating large amounts of instruction data with varying levels of complexity
using LLM instead of humans. Starting with an initial set of instructions, we
use our proposed Evol-Instruct to rewrite them step by step into more complex
instructions. Then, we mix all generated instruction data to fine-tune LLaMA.
We call the resulting model WizardLM. Human evaluations on a
complexity-balanced test bed and Vicuna's testset show that instructions from
Evol-Instruct are superior to human-created ones. By analyzing the human
evaluation results of the high complexity part, we demonstrate that outputs
from our WizardLM are preferred to outputs from OpenAI ChatGPT. In GPT-4
automatic evaluation, WizardLM achieves more than 90\% capacity of ChatGPT on
17 out of 29 skills. Even though WizardLM still lags behind ChatGPT in some
aspects, our findings suggest that fine-tuning with AI-evolved instructions is
a promising direction for enhancing LLMs. Our code and data are public at
https://github.com/nlpxucan/WizardLM | [
0.0199821852,
0.0572109744,
-0.0239641424,
0.0253944322,
-0.026867263,
0.0382316075,
-0.0522412471,
-0.0172043517,
0.0102623245,
-0.0342854634,
-0.0715111867,
0.0134848962,
-0.0030217341,
0.0017509084,
0.0243893992,
-0.0587086082,
0.038455721,
-0.0535896011,
-0.0330190808,
0.0041865506,
-0.0178054832,
0.0145357195,
-0.0190799795,
0.0422700346,
0.0224623699,
-0.0013408386,
-0.0305275302,
-0.0076746549,
-0.0036696328,
-0.0114645585,
-0.0024608844,
0.0319299996,
0.0218049623,
0.0275591444,
0.0000020731,
-0.0404320322,
0.0236837976,
-0.0015830006,
-0.0329975858,
0.0459499806,
0.0165609829,
-0.0020642537,
-0.0223610085,
0.0373616703,
-0.0157392882,
-0.0201502368,
0.0177019406,
0.0147389704,
0.0642956942,
0.122204639,
0.0190867633,
-0.0340897329,
0.0375970565,
-0.030391695,
0.0096352343,
-0.0511222929,
0.0058681578,
-0.0131614888,
0.0411914028,
0.020517353,
-0.0068425275,
0.0133308899,
0.0558022782,
-0.0048778886,
-0.0316635706,
0.0497679003,
0.0103866076,
-0.0136642037,
-0.0175913908,
0.0768745989,
-0.0172938947,
-0.0103384014,
-0.022291638,
-0.0080270721,
0.0352203473,
-0.0285082851,
-0.0370485857,
0.0399373136,
0.0104950899,
0.0313974619,
0.0169105753,
-0.0360703804,
0.0271048546,
0.0163050871,
-0.0060077612,
0.0665036812,
0.0222991593,
-0.0368985832,
-0.0066906102,
-0.0109171961,
-0.0160491783,
-0.0495757274,
-0.023186814,
0.0548829399,
-0.0574455559,
0.0145136314,
-0.0656466261,
0.0102391411,
0.0069158967,
-0.0087621231,
0.0948975906,
0.0605117679,
-0.0311800204,
0.0212482307,
-0.0357787944,
0.0589411817,
-0.0059791435,
0.0437736027,
-0.0619007759,
-0.0003333392,
-0.0645793527,
0.0172241069,
-0.0396653451,
0.0181258433,
-0.0500211827,
-0.0023409901,
-0.0431772172,
0.0341748968,
-0.0134193916,
0.0157607589,
0.0343573391,
-0.0162705891,
-0.0223014019,
-0.0053842086,
-0.0306132231,
0.0203994606,
-0.0349335894,
0.0225316733,
0.0263882186,
-0.0409940071,
0.0043916097,
0.0256106369,
-0.0083899656,
0.0012534896,
0.0259085726,
0.0941160992,
-0.0109110633,
-0.024874568,
-0.0565978698,
-0.0110191163,
0.0203707647,
-0.0769093484,
0.0150958104,
-0.0515043028,
0.0363737382,
-0.0230493974,
-0.0106079616,
-0.0242143515,
0.0068879928,
0.0318862535,
-0.0241042506,
0.0448183753,
-0.0157298688,
0.0316549912,
0.0161720719,
-0.002213663,
-0.0216832366,
0.0570759177,
0.0524411872,
0.014461928,
-0.0032236262,
-0.0149930678,
0.0293086916,
0.0536577739,
-0.0006020515,
0.0230377652,
0.0247449279,
0.0211867411,
0.0046468931,
0.0460342094,
0.0408863612,
0.0594830215,
-0.0276078694,
0.0151001271,
0.0521814488,
0.0200653188,
0.0170914065,
0.0045843641,
0.0953569561,
0.0127449641,
0.0128815779,
0.0249700155,
-0.093826063,
0.0282924026,
-0.023454221,
0.0150505966,
-0.0074322685,
0.0250178054,
-0.0465812832,
-0.0551518574,
-0.0058372021,
-0.01875709,
0.0045418236,
-0.0000982405,
0.0233982224,
0.0146835307,
-0.0752435699,
0.0065892627,
0.0554801896,
-0.0374148861,
-0.020714011,
-0.0860071555,
0.0257592704,
0.0886808932,
0.0249065682,
0.0102425851,
-0.0459937751,
0.0144438772,
0.0353756212,
0.0199330524,
0.0465977043,
-0.0187785607,
-0.0076594641,
-0.0574045144,
-0.0136053059,
-0.0322200917,
0.0234689694,
0.0308937952,
0.0533432886,
-0.0207319502,
0.0062094084,
-0.0024341743,
-0.0490028858,
0.0485836156,
-0.0444799289,
-0.0492316112,
-0.004511849,
0.0058976053,
0.0328323171,
-0.0048775971,
-0.0064693959,
0.0167330336,
0.0192355029,
-0.0097722868,
-0.0259260386,
-0.0156527851,
-0.0483151823,
-0.0031983294,
0.0386987329,
0.0102123348,
-0.0452350453,
0.0080542238,
-0.0579774566,
-0.0151233329,
0.0123678269,
-0.0284530129,
0.0282907598,
-0.022023458,
0.0217360668,
0.0233195238,
-0.0150486138,
-0.0222931374,
0.0601843446,
-0.0194245782,
-0.0244883057,
0.038993638,
0.0235722438,
0.0051139458,
-0.0303858779,
0.0054523549,
-0.0090042884,
0.0107874051,
0.036414925,
-0.0122968564,
0.0652605221,
-0.0322198644,
-0.0619469434,
-0.0845807865,
0.0279449578,
-0.0198323429,
0.0144514553,
0.0333309844,
-0.0002432992,
-0.0200927127,
0.011741139,
-0.0224061683,
0.0225734469,
0.0113304015,
0.0020149478,
0.0070548817,
0.0026795527,
-0.0652636811,
-0.0279137716,
0.0057602841,
-0.0153187551,
-0.0239825342,
-0.0130244838,
0.0585585944,
-0.0827608481,
0.0229919087,
-0.0033061916,
0.0459083654,
-0.0072919708,
-0.0616260059,
0.0240668915,
-0.0175171774,
0.0357408784,
0.0673474893,
-0.027824806,
0.0304432511,
0.0570182912,
-0.0016457649,
-0.0359720588,
0.0377383418,
-0.0086052669,
-0.0604705811,
-0.0378956385,
-0.0007526184,
-0.0056806863,
0.0552218929,
-0.019553164,
-0.0009744216,
-0.0682416111,
-0.0117897484,
-0.0145131582,
-0.0192092564,
0.0166909713,
-0.0102098044,
-0.0415495634,
0.0136321839,
-0.0294827931,
-0.0624796152,
0.0495892428,
-0.02649967,
-0.0093606943,
-0.0589179061,
-0.0109834941,
-0.0433339477,
0.0637390986,
0.0083555495,
0.0068559386,
-0.0145039847,
-0.0145156616,
-0.0654855892,
0.0006347571,
0.0007741286,
-0.0131544061,
0.0429861061,
-0.0866993815,
-0.0122538069,
0.0088146282,
-0.044278577,
-0.0496529341,
0.0085237063,
-0.0067704697,
0.0296756402,
0.010159133,
-0.0407285728,
-0.0323811397,
-0.04714825,
0.0069620679,
0.0343183428,
-0.0208488982,
-0.0037603234,
-0.0489671677,
-0.0188036412,
0.046501644,
0.0324880667,
-0.0108143697,
-0.0485759936,
0.0277633853,
0.043639265,
0.0248544086,
-0.0204552021,
-0.0332116224,
0.0127676409,
0.0195125211,
-0.04662925,
-0.0008713998,
0.0669593066,
0.0716489032,
-0.0554042235,
-0.0048982217,
0.1142845526,
0.0236306377,
-0.0174792707,
0.0261298958,
0.0169143304,
0.0449857563,
0.0145619679,
0.0772281736,
-0.0965125561,
-0.0326854661,
0.0174964927,
0.0489801764,
0.0096347313,
-0.0013991955,
-0.0072311708,
-0.1504147798,
0.0558869727,
0.0048324973,
-0.0300173648,
-0.0276779775,
-0.0191371683,
-0.0098622963,
-0.0020083042,
0.0359479152,
0.0324817188,
-0.0233729426,
-0.005241734,
0.0270555038,
0.001054365,
-0.0777782723,
0.0617984049,
-0.0460135601,
0.0798374563,
0.0761995837,
-0.0003808733,
0.0241969377,
-0.0417656824,
0.064509742,
0.0094092609,
0.0111651691,
-0.0021007012,
0.0326300301,
0.0053732893,
-0.0258749779,
0.0026804153,
0.0662530884,
-0.0297566075,
0.0198030304,
0.0288146622,
0.066009067,
-0.0033919071,
-0.0190570895,
-0.0086772097,
-0.0375686772,
-0.0142552024,
0.0538627952,
0.0372881554,
-0.0398218967,
-0.0348135643,
-0.0464116819,
-0.0604141019,
-0.0700754076,
-0.0454909243,
0.0304350872,
-0.0269521065,
-0.0290338714,
-0.0705791488,
-0.0618564896,
0.0615022667,
0.0191836935,
0.0223120283,
-0.0542634428,
0.0123247243,
-0.0039431173,
-0.0185676906,
0.0088828243,
-0.0562960431,
0.0297970939,
-0.1051884666,
-0.0610103421,
0.0345441662,
-0.0079194056,
0.0003578191,
0.019796811,
-0.0959550589,
-0.0634907857,
0.0116668027,
0.0873455405,
0.0156113822,
0.0503701977,
-0.0254182033,
-0.0352064818,
0.0068273554,
0.0207224879,
-0.0571542978,
0.0253450405,
0.0271279681,
0.0081879618,
0.0267022047,
0.0326562971,
-0.0319987237,
0.0244356282,
0.0049730744,
0.0299138781,
-0.0075317984,
-0.0042618192,
0.0491260961,
0.0241716318,
-0.0053325836,
-0.0285372976,
0.007432343,
-0.0259954091,
0.0201298296,
-0.0210241769,
-0.0148657402,
-0.0576639883,
-0.0183440465,
0.0292723142,
0.011897671,
0.0231638867,
-0.0229151566,
0.0168925487,
0.0051533966,
-0.0492637157,
0.0235222746,
-0.0053473413,
0.0282350741,
0.0227788743,
0.0120578762,
-0.0118136462,
0.0204331391,
-0.0009103231,
0.0397741124,
-0.0131050488,
0.0520840995,
0.0068999943,
0.0124176843,
-0.0255055744,
0.0316711925,
-0.0402343683,
-0.0677956045,
-0.010025043,
0.0698999688,
0.0682109892,
-0.0007949127,
0.0521776825,
-0.0431025624,
-0.0016429666,
-0.0145113859,
0.020379195,
-0.0269566234,
-0.015425032,
0.0187813248,
0.0353255868,
0.0043457565,
-0.0276528373,
0.0850313231,
0.0127410768,
0.0836026371,
-0.0184155684,
0.0372124724,
-0.0416872799,
-0.0459055118,
-0.0003951558,
-0.0032707027,
-0.0280444901,
0.0012645607,
-0.0124466959,
-0.0697985515,
-0.0699197054,
0.0461186282,
0.0072966996,
-0.0219376199,
0.0467838757,
0.0207888857,
-0.0263812989,
-0.0238942783,
-0.0262817815,
-0.0439457856,
0.0155892093,
-0.0463438369,
0.0011088918,
-6.454502829e-33,
-0.0452925637,
0.0082084117,
0.075656794,
0.0161168836,
-0.0081896018,
-0.020648364,
-0.0310224351,
0.0190353077,
-0.0145799499,
0.0042146472,
0.0000881792,
-0.0088755423,
-0.0008704395,
0.0124286506,
0.0517942011,
-0.0042402451,
0.0288674701,
-0.0337889977,
-0.0132998731,
0.0144060496,
-0.0118881268,
-0.0078246854,
0.0335006155,
-0.065553844,
-0.0126634473,
0.0015984004,
-0.0243247822,
0.0310835168,
-0.0536099933,
0.0730626434,
-0.0071395147,
0.0043580392,
0.0019649984,
-0.0285751242,
-0.0271111075,
-0.0358013436,
-0.0588783771,
-0.0369622894,
0.0264930483,
0.0086391596,
-0.0498453863,
-0.0564372428,
0.0456368327,
-0.011698219,
-0.0331875794,
-0.0012722133,
0.0137749044,
-0.0110895075,
0.0205631945,
0.0540572442,
-0.069804199,
0.0096873567,
-0.006643753,
-0.0715181828,
-0.0153015237,
-0.007985062,
-0.0068220915,
-0.0376396775,
-0.0299487896,
0.0236082301,
0.0335175805,
0.047418911,
0.0512393303,
-0.0194247421,
0.0043952339,
0.005852004,
0.0512568057,
0.0020151646,
-0.0241264291,
0.0048414022,
0.0288659986,
0.0598020554,
0.0099262213,
-0.0131809777,
0.000431842,
0.0102674868,
-0.0470425747,
0.0241160262,
0.0288745984,
0.0613046847,
-0.0042692255,
0.0185090601,
-0.0422773436,
-0.0236438774,
-0.0110317217,
0.0240930021,
-0.0225493032,
-0.0252726674,
0.0606686436,
0.0263772756,
-0.0112292506,
-0.0451550819,
0.026564924,
-0.0269084573,
-0.019805925,
-0.0011459864,
-0.0491521135,
0.0362629034,
-0.0005413772,
0.0041675828,
-0.0553282537,
-0.0656442642,
0.0315925591,
-0.012705504,
0.0225908924,
0.0280403495,
0.037920773,
0.0577929653,
-0.0745995492,
0.0218001138,
-0.0499083959,
0.0151866889,
0.0275067557,
0.0206899103,
0.0293289516,
0.01137337,
-0.0038377538,
0.0418287143,
0.0025902421,
-0.0272950195,
-0.0523110703,
-0.0052094599,
0.0264454801,
0.0061124936,
-0.0306532755,
0.0233453996,
-0.0412197858,
-0.0138576897,
-0.0251712222,
-0.0298759826,
-0.0273116957,
0.0181457959,
2.809e-7,
0.0181518923,
0.042556528,
0.0240539815,
0.0830532834,
0.0147603136,
0.0295773149,
-0.0503190979,
-0.0007740583,
0.0124836043,
0.0077630822,
0.0171877649,
0.0466788448,
0.0401911102,
0.0012122885,
-0.088676542,
0.000570973,
-0.0153269768,
0.009469837,
-0.0601835772,
-0.0135752512,
0.0357075222,
0.0894106776,
0.0239984356,
-0.0023047202,
0.0166490972,
-0.00668649,
0.0405253917,
-0.0101507837,
-0.0005191848,
0.0150378514,
-0.0324731953,
0.0657611936,
-0.0268932935,
-0.0144222351,
-0.0161373261,
0.0093125496,
-0.0302906781,
0.0996707082,
-0.0088114236,
-0.0083316453,
0.0491865613,
-0.0035980579,
-0.0136091318,
-0.0287522655,
0.0482661501,
-0.0409334935,
-0.0190252438,
-0.0167682655,
0.0031006944,
-0.0080844034,
-0.0220797732,
-0.007344129,
-0.007544748,
0.0116364192,
0.0219794288,
-0.018593099,
-0.0294902846,
-0.0621510111,
-0.0013692405,
0.0032218338,
-0.0308179501,
-0.0444607623,
-0.050654605,
0.0261898376,
0.0055009648,
-0.017868489,
-0.0117953541,
2.634957372e-34,
0.0271198507,
-0.0241984595,
0.0552169457,
0.0440046303,
0.0397649556,
0.0084754806,
0.0051851775,
0.0254514311,
0.0295085441,
-0.0583352484,
-0.0343315937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12206v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12206v2 | PAXQA: Generating Cross-lingual Question Answering Examples at Training Scale | 2023-04-24T15:46:26 | 2023-10-17T15:46:54 | Bryan Li, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing question answering (QA) systems owe much of their success to large,
high-quality training data. Such annotation efforts are costly, and the
difficulty compounds in the cross-lingual setting. Therefore, prior
cross-lingual QA work has focused on releasing evaluation datasets, and then
applying zero-shot methods as baselines. This work proposes a synthetic data
generation method for cross-lingual QA which leverages indirect supervision
from existing parallel corpora. Our method termed PAXQA (Projecting annotations
for cross-lingual (x) QA) decomposes cross-lingual QA into two stages. First,
we apply a question generation (QG) model to the English side. Second, we apply
annotation projection to translate both the questions and answers. To better
translate questions, we propose a novel use of lexically-constrained machine
translation, in which constrained entities are extracted from the parallel
bitexts.
We apply PAXQA to generate cross-lingual QA examples in 4 languages (662K
examples total), and perform human evaluation on a subset to create validation
and test splits. We then show that models fine-tuned on these datasets
outperform prior synthetic data generation models over several extractive QA
datasets. The largest performance gains are for directions with non-English
questions and English contexts. Ablation studies show that our dataset
generation method is relatively robust to noise from automatic word alignments,
showing the sufficient quality of our generations. To facilitate follow-up
work, we release our code and datasets at https://github.com/manestay/paxqa . | [
0.0449285097,
0.0245150588,
-0.0042732549,
0.070799537,
0.0006937324,
0.0174442604,
0.0221644565,
-0.0327831656,
-0.0227541439,
-0.0324486792,
-0.0447151288,
-0.0481831245,
-0.0473104268,
-0.0298654363,
0.046863351,
-0.0225475375,
0.0341449231,
-0.0207101312,
-0.0461331308,
-0.0209767986,
0.0281143151,
0.0155859264,
0.0043746885,
0.0173951983,
-0.0092708329,
-0.0146246757,
0.0051032957,
-0.0086787716,
0.0277958047,
0.0074245743,
0.0253175367,
0.0473608635,
0.0063813487,
0.0227213483,
0.0000018925,
-0.0362528265,
-0.0114222877,
0.0132300286,
-0.0198369883,
0.0005729655,
-0.0271574203,
-0.0168233048,
0.0249694865,
0.0097706523,
-0.055316478,
-0.0636784434,
0.0437488928,
-0.003495256,
0.0938704461,
0.0696716383,
-0.0023355766,
-0.0155258691,
-0.0082317879,
-0.012927006,
0.0248525813,
-0.0323271491,
-0.0083770677,
0.0232128967,
-0.0062233447,
0.0428993814,
0.0022499259,
0.0300398376,
0.0630751848,
-0.0075234165,
-0.0133615974,
0.0058217598,
-0.0555174351,
-0.0110792955,
-0.0184515417,
0.1038974226,
0.0188380927,
-0.0209175218,
-0.0155725321,
0.0042966502,
-0.0071318373,
-0.0241695251,
-0.0331178494,
0.0315198191,
-0.012695997,
0.0043264916,
0.0430638529,
0.0290260073,
-0.0112355798,
-0.0135405213,
0.0060134926,
0.0163418036,
0.0246137604,
-0.0283941943,
0.0098533314,
0.0393958427,
-0.0267846119,
-0.0323388726,
-0.0152143957,
0.0298886057,
-0.0415406786,
0.0282380693,
-0.0463552475,
-0.0547807664,
0.0404283777,
-0.0409342311,
0.0188972149,
0.0585492924,
-0.0064890548,
0.0369878188,
-0.015052977,
0.0656061918,
-0.0403191596,
0.0121956682,
-0.0851850063,
-0.0397910848,
-0.0385824814,
-0.0094842678,
-0.041889444,
0.0055661518,
-0.0746622309,
0.0238568,
-0.0297860224,
0.0091051832,
0.0139465788,
0.0074679856,
0.0246834103,
0.0100823669,
-0.0531928837,
0.0138753979,
-0.0142619973,
0.0334059447,
-0.0825855061,
-0.0169939734,
-0.0148916906,
-0.058821369,
-0.0250084233,
0.0276389513,
-0.007194119,
-0.0496730208,
-0.0028924732,
0.0734243095,
-0.0379003622,
-0.0000300758,
-0.0179319214,
-0.0576080158,
-0.002751268,
-0.056533888,
0.0117408112,
-0.0576651618,
0.0762043074,
0.0030999321,
-0.0205504782,
0.0178445783,
0.0346189253,
0.0462384298,
-0.0089825289,
0.0599314719,
-0.0233840216,
0.0098930653,
0.0165022351,
-0.0092515061,
0.0036013497,
0.0839135945,
0.0285847932,
-0.0402412005,
0.0557932034,
0.0000670013,
-0.0067999368,
0.0498460233,
0.0534145311,
0.0061238264,
0.0139054442,
0.0732020065,
0.0377545692,
0.0121820318,
0.0072007636,
0.0418652445,
-0.0167220458,
-0.0068392586,
0.0024849391,
0.0001360234,
-0.0237497333,
0.0680411756,
0.076929763,
-0.0075376513,
-0.007905338,
0.0025814397,
-0.0145134069,
0.0410091616,
0.0272268895,
0.0012550402,
0.0291021671,
0.0243766978,
-0.0476705059,
-0.0375828333,
0.0138632488,
0.0240206681,
-0.0246980079,
0.0178462565,
0.0097757243,
0.0601646379,
-0.0319081843,
0.0558674335,
0.024136588,
-0.0734775364,
0.0143902889,
0.0086220652,
0.0392240547,
0.0408510081,
0.018031219,
-0.0086282678,
-0.0562230833,
-0.0067594433,
0.0289833564,
0.0455690958,
0.0732688382,
-0.0422806256,
0.0236131903,
-0.0368625447,
-0.0115938308,
-0.0228380244,
-0.0265523158,
0.0097840447,
0.0315069482,
0.0347034372,
0.0303118546,
-0.0612026453,
-0.0237413924,
0.0412542298,
-0.0615984909,
-0.0624221563,
0.0456352644,
0.0138328103,
0.0176410452,
0.0519918688,
-0.0048449039,
0.0042513041,
0.0476196483,
-0.0621820576,
0.0067058611,
0.0205543041,
-0.0186106078,
-0.0825756565,
0.0359643213,
-0.0579814985,
-0.0233718622,
0.0041217455,
-0.0565977395,
-0.0580228642,
-0.0319082402,
-0.0340645686,
-0.0070831077,
-0.0787956417,
-0.0322342217,
0.0035134284,
0.032444071,
-0.022114452,
0.053876996,
0.0188672468,
0.0538222417,
0.0419501886,
-0.0150497071,
0.0502758287,
-0.0277744215,
0.0015654314,
0.0006196991,
-0.0047679427,
0.0251127612,
0.0501045324,
0.0559991561,
-0.0509850234,
-0.0059370943,
-0.0838521421,
0.0461461246,
-0.0383784026,
0.0648858547,
0.062977843,
0.0218175929,
-0.0109923026,
-0.0217935517,
-0.0887816325,
-0.0099512106,
0.034805987,
0.0152369104,
0.0438161194,
0.0280959103,
0.0387528427,
-0.0326769315,
0.0001817946,
-0.0034309258,
0.0173490103,
0.0084637171,
0.0333017856,
-0.0634961575,
0.0112660853,
-0.0533490144,
0.0100410087,
0.0292464625,
-0.0481316298,
-0.0025456422,
0.0025631043,
0.0362701118,
0.0007683107,
-0.0256902985,
-0.0370959751,
0.0214501861,
-0.004756555,
-0.0453175008,
0.0487080477,
-0.0114610055,
-0.0199531354,
-0.0124319801,
-0.0476887412,
-0.00644325,
0.0357546546,
-0.0024870338,
-0.0342719294,
-0.0723385587,
0.0287716817,
-0.027816277,
-0.0446467474,
-0.018156644,
0.0419440828,
0.0128595363,
0.0416947715,
-0.0325019881,
0.0194210429,
0.0672031119,
-0.0151075963,
-0.0350445658,
-0.0692901164,
0.0255384669,
-0.0621728115,
0.0422996245,
-0.0244474001,
0.0233195517,
-0.0296026543,
0.0147199864,
-0.0461339578,
-0.0039262227,
-0.0052089542,
-0.024336718,
-0.0072611901,
-0.0466475897,
-0.0009091243,
-0.0315080322,
-0.0368826054,
-0.0643192828,
-0.0365086757,
-0.006157761,
0.0057799309,
-0.0011728153,
0.0146880448,
0.0010648213,
0.0025387313,
0.0168831795,
0.0249974113,
-0.0429769047,
0.0084049888,
-0.018844666,
0.0536633283,
0.0397155024,
0.0312455017,
0.0033000626,
-0.0338035449,
0.0481514744,
0.0348308012,
0.0246265084,
-0.0029890863,
0.0164519884,
-0.0010334938,
0.0088797612,
-0.0183340833,
-0.0177127868,
-0.0303292796,
0.0793340057,
-0.0499177538,
-0.0446185917,
0.0841991305,
0.0432371385,
-0.0056754476,
-0.0121623455,
-0.0217736345,
0.0279743131,
0.0459642895,
0.0771423951,
-0.1091760769,
-0.0384613425,
-0.0390217341,
0.0382607207,
0.0109665869,
0.0047682924,
-0.0144254984,
-0.1447479725,
0.0233286731,
-0.0083935559,
-0.1031240076,
-0.0202814471,
-0.0159134641,
-0.021494627,
-0.0172403716,
0.0129952375,
-0.0009387424,
0.0169045366,
0.0271682125,
0.0204480663,
0.0384777635,
-0.0143404985,
0.0209419597,
-0.0399327315,
0.0027144309,
0.0392381214,
0.0437396169,
0.0159133486,
-0.0288069248,
-0.0155133484,
-0.1092482433,
-0.0201098192,
0.0027454267,
0.0445844345,
0.0061464109,
-0.040165659,
0.0165988691,
0.0495746136,
-0.038234774,
0.0368071944,
0.0545994006,
0.0705016851,
0.0221753269,
0.0181834828,
-0.0018885691,
0.0158978198,
0.0298244469,
0.0802326426,
0.0197166894,
-0.049660109,
-0.0229617376,
-0.0034139289,
0.0003192076,
-0.108460784,
-0.006986782,
0.0308249723,
-0.0092460401,
0.0102969883,
-0.0955247879,
-0.080681704,
0.0496091805,
0.0303141586,
0.0091558769,
-0.0162009951,
-0.0355543718,
0.0123401256,
-0.0229650885,
0.0270266347,
-0.0325140432,
-0.0025781747,
-0.0046674004,
-0.0012732371,
0.0137680834,
-0.0414909646,
-0.0033809457,
0.0387135409,
-0.0729149058,
-0.0626748428,
-0.0499717519,
0.0805455521,
0.0072126458,
0.0394426212,
-0.0164925624,
-0.0115920389,
0.0134509113,
0.0122390054,
-0.0202715211,
-0.0167430956,
0.0231471155,
0.0207362007,
-0.0072403545,
0.0651185513,
-0.0462534763,
-0.005163929,
-0.0072430056,
0.0680474788,
-0.0397794917,
-0.0362943113,
0.0403824225,
0.0107540907,
-0.0430964977,
-0.0247576609,
0.0140160536,
-0.0228728093,
0.0451394618,
-0.0431243144,
-0.0287085958,
-0.046331007,
0.0112261791,
0.0015749957,
-0.072687678,
0.0171421152,
0.0038153832,
-0.0362008661,
0.0216858033,
-0.0348945037,
-0.0193287823,
0.0393568985,
0.0090946937,
-0.0246903617,
0.0153661091,
-0.0027651298,
-0.0129923578,
0.0271224473,
0.063838616,
-0.0353718996,
0.0497070886,
0.0187979359,
0.0159549732,
-0.0035987457,
-0.0027593488,
-0.0285446737,
-0.0239840001,
0.0012158959,
0.0261249039,
0.062191166,
-0.0091464408,
0.0740261003,
0.0075657112,
-0.0394927934,
0.0219955705,
0.0181149896,
-0.0008884121,
-0.0106260786,
0.0399387069,
0.0033951933,
-0.0054667071,
-0.0133004384,
0.0908038095,
-0.0051849531,
0.0311513189,
0.0033056724,
0.0124683119,
-0.0559811033,
-0.0026827157,
0.0024725946,
-0.0263344236,
-0.006932592,
-0.004810784,
-0.0350824967,
-0.0646617338,
-0.0187048186,
0.0337201804,
-0.0281499978,
0.0056182216,
0.0238817576,
0.0522284098,
-0.0089716054,
-0.0359219462,
-0.0577609949,
0.0323401876,
-0.0368222594,
-0.0218884181,
-0.0138249984,
-5.995654119e-33,
0.004039505,
0.0126140807,
0.0298854932,
-0.0100884913,
-0.012550272,
0.0024568394,
-0.0353415869,
-0.0233030561,
-0.0092591709,
0.0166363027,
-0.0103911562,
-0.0290234834,
0.0068473164,
0.0402412005,
0.0086257486,
-0.0472853296,
0.0233525727,
-0.0267565157,
-0.0161565673,
0.0536251068,
0.0371292979,
0.0054680174,
0.0593528077,
-0.005850981,
0.0560532436,
-0.0529565178,
0.0053350688,
0.056491144,
-0.0048468681,
0.0628243163,
-0.0205288548,
0.0280441698,
0.0275644902,
-0.0435851626,
0.0002546554,
0.0347865224,
-0.0798301026,
-0.0388124995,
0.0254210234,
0.0011876966,
-0.0617616251,
-0.0436244085,
-0.0012825077,
-0.0336985104,
0.0307257399,
0.0109081492,
0.0207156818,
-0.0226641707,
0.0297110137,
-0.0344866626,
-0.0418510288,
-0.0163778923,
-0.0153600313,
-0.0436864793,
0.0091948388,
0.1139345393,
0.0128962183,
-0.01281521,
-0.0369165652,
0.0046312548,
-0.0193747785,
0.0208364893,
0.0493212417,
-0.0074803066,
-0.0081520034,
0.0036770508,
0.0127129564,
-0.0002182927,
0.0191033166,
0.0100666815,
-0.0255297907,
0.0090796603,
0.0612565503,
0.0904436186,
0.0311660655,
0.0230489392,
-0.0921185985,
0.0507420003,
-0.0078429999,
0.0042389208,
-0.0035350393,
-0.0607739091,
-0.0021068146,
0.0018622011,
-0.0544347651,
-0.0225362759,
-0.0209408198,
-0.0169173218,
0.0372929052,
-0.0018840176,
-0.0754565224,
-0.0025334253,
0.0482106172,
-0.0258639529,
0.0205221623,
0.0285845026,
-0.0279427189,
-0.0037663635,
0.0004132959,
0.0296826288,
-0.053246662,
-0.005676975,
0.0243682507,
-0.0010144592,
0.0100001311,
0.0125629138,
0.0508663394,
-0.0218190216,
-0.0396698751,
0.0231734198,
-0.054537829,
0.0757162273,
-0.0599636249,
0.0227947719,
-0.0012515798,
0.0285184328,
-0.0100438651,
0.0137121193,
0.0471793599,
0.0132140536,
-0.0177662801,
-0.0222465079,
0.0075768419,
0.0383015573,
-0.0194589812,
0.0427966565,
-0.0216840152,
0.0342971683,
-0.0179728195,
-0.061902374,
-0.0043607121,
0.0470272042,
2.475e-7,
0.0601373687,
0.0097205332,
0.0219443832,
0.0362789333,
0.0163113438,
0.0230001528,
0.0044050929,
0.0211622939,
0.0073780874,
-0.0268864874,
0.0063679451,
0.0203164294,
0.0522893816,
0.0505259931,
-0.0990468413,
-0.0053307074,
-0.0435738526,
0.0043664007,
-0.0537465513,
0.0019613095,
0.0539512336,
0.0571225658,
-0.0203838702,
-0.0147909513,
-0.0364778787,
-0.0345944799,
0.0525540151,
0.0175114032,
-0.0429465845,
0.0337777622,
0.0021062293,
0.0235535409,
-0.0056330697,
0.0305436216,
-0.0342811979,
0.0301568247,
0.0221782103,
0.0396012515,
0.0326430723,
-0.0409066677,
-0.0103854816,
-0.0182550084,
0.0074179652,
-0.0537315607,
0.0635171533,
-0.0356076173,
0.0131165674,
0.0079706628,
-0.0180877745,
0.0285972971,
0.0308013149,
-0.0328224041,
-0.0153238475,
0.0318719596,
0.0391147025,
-0.0117311496,
-0.0086439904,
0.0053037289,
-0.016629234,
0.0111843785,
-0.0166147854,
-0.0238010157,
-0.0043304134,
0.0038269772,
-0.0560409352,
-0.0373709053,
0.0117087895,
1.986798741e-34,
0.00237904,
-0.0184355043,
0.0198033936,
0.0063511953,
0.019279277,
-0.0281258505,
-0.0021074566,
-0.0204426721,
0.0111564901,
-0.0365573503,
-0.0255581941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12102v1 | Unlocking Context Constraints of LLMs: Enhancing Context Efficiency of LLMs with Self-Information-Based Content Filtering | 2023-04-24T13:55:47 | 2023-04-24T13:55:47 | Yucheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have received significant attention by achieving
remarkable performance across various tasks. However, their fixed context
length poses challenges when processing long documents or maintaining extended
conversations. This paper proposes a method called \textit{Selective Context}
that employs self-information to filter out less informative content, thereby
enhancing the efficiency of the fixed context length. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach on tasks of summarisation and question answering
across different data sources, including academic papers, news articles, and
conversation transcripts. | [
0.0432145596,
0.0127693163,
0.0125079956,
0.0476047322,
-0.0441178158,
-0.0054776613,
0.0035818336,
0.0033706473,
0.0082954317,
-0.0503737256,
-0.0408421531,
-0.0098314919,
-0.0133265825,
-0.013858363,
-0.0079282876,
-0.0178437196,
0.0506630279,
-0.0427539051,
-0.0059508043,
-0.0405226834,
-0.0005190963,
0.0010947139,
0.0201450884,
-0.0259360112,
0.0126562808,
-0.0137062911,
-0.0035805348,
-0.0195048768,
-0.0233953837,
-0.0148544135,
0.0183372609,
0.0397442468,
0.0261621717,
-0.0129917478,
0.0000018832,
-0.0465471633,
-0.031029772,
-0.0212154891,
-0.0271936022,
0.0286597461,
0.0337184668,
-0.0023556945,
0.0081109926,
0.0163969714,
-0.0297519714,
0.0690709129,
-0.010027403,
0.0361803509,
0.0512174852,
0.0703331307,
-0.0017540778,
-0.030544566,
0.0191185214,
-0.0200487636,
0.0458074696,
-0.0617412291,
0.029028995,
0.0243497845,
0.048747696,
0.0264946073,
0.0150197847,
0.0722078085,
0.016407568,
-0.0217646379,
0.0145764323,
0.0316896252,
-0.0166172776,
0.0050020264,
0.0109034255,
0.0536843352,
0.0597848967,
-0.0129455216,
0.0265219659,
-0.003514962,
0.0054138154,
-0.0000927885,
-0.0744803473,
0.0284417029,
0.0048454991,
0.0237641186,
0.0231132265,
0.026428096,
0.0105830813,
0.0462607853,
-0.0433942042,
0.0798525289,
0.0033276973,
-0.031361524,
-0.046288453,
-0.0100456327,
0.0066055413,
-0.0587860793,
0.0132752266,
0.0891061872,
0.0016182151,
0.0113275303,
-0.0451460481,
-0.0122688683,
0.0414618887,
-0.0469609387,
-0.0704488531,
0.0158295855,
0.0273371525,
0.0926526487,
-0.0037331909,
-0.0019841462,
-0.0077505475,
-0.0152450921,
-0.0591083951,
-0.031081941,
-0.0130636729,
-0.0276865233,
-0.051630903,
0.083030954,
-0.0574861541,
-0.045790121,
-0.0106300022,
0.0669460818,
0.0284855422,
-0.0150390211,
-0.0025883792,
-0.0048845019,
-0.0088679865,
-0.0074243289,
-0.0119690942,
0.0024746172,
-0.0279923342,
-0.0256505255,
0.0102657266,
-0.0366981998,
-0.0136684654,
0.0046654581,
0.0209937226,
-0.0396409035,
-0.0027909242,
0.050205186,
0.0098151593,
-0.0561501868,
-0.0270486753,
-0.0246889088,
-0.0429568589,
-0.0616739802,
-0.0097975796,
-0.0589606799,
0.0215655845,
0.016354721,
-0.0232095588,
-0.0251624528,
0.0000245057,
0.0225243531,
-0.0419619083,
0.0499209985,
-0.0258509647,
0.0278484859,
0.0568021759,
0.0344366431,
0.0578095876,
0.0951920226,
0.0142123085,
0.0072559412,
0.0627445579,
0.0026802428,
-0.0130494274,
0.0266190581,
0.038487196,
0.0123574845,
-0.0308433287,
0.0530588441,
-0.0179690011,
-0.0079098437,
0.0241496116,
0.0520700552,
-0.0165117495,
-0.0058339816,
0.0535715222,
0.073984459,
0.0193364508,
0.0117304055,
-0.0147744101,
0.0336997174,
0.0236994606,
0.0637833551,
-0.0215316042,
0.040288493,
-0.0482134931,
0.0252518374,
0.1052824184,
0.0141078644,
-0.0504253842,
-0.0395248532,
-0.0179607663,
-0.0083417865,
0.0106746573,
0.0242079869,
0.0290484093,
-0.0050554043,
-0.0019328116,
0.0621200539,
0.0191260781,
-0.0484776683,
-0.0028019568,
-0.024999436,
0.0520705469,
0.0584924184,
0.0573167391,
-0.0638134405,
-0.0189767648,
0.0084099034,
0.0388780758,
0.0309825391,
0.0523674414,
-0.0017098841,
0.0029315043,
-0.0193441082,
-0.0163187496,
-0.0267810449,
-0.0022056371,
-0.0225650854,
0.0435397364,
-0.0042508114,
0.0352942795,
-0.0120119667,
0.0117860092,
0.0048678219,
-0.0422780849,
-0.0369431265,
0.0146957617,
-0.0237884,
0.0255055167,
0.0258405693,
-0.0010569595,
0.0350413062,
0.0422963314,
-0.0421125367,
-0.0297758039,
-0.0175874364,
-0.0984561816,
-0.0272004716,
0.0424156971,
-0.0012355662,
-0.015529329,
-0.006814329,
-0.0109092426,
-0.066738151,
0.0038387224,
-0.0511411428,
0.0305532403,
-0.033289317,
0.0005131119,
0.0374764167,
0.0061095669,
-0.051814992,
0.077859208,
0.0032501912,
0.0108868601,
0.0480410755,
-0.0045467345,
0.0018296718,
-0.0531963892,
-0.0066238665,
0.0146131935,
0.003792644,
-0.0122989556,
0.0548563749,
-0.0125126671,
-0.0319871791,
-0.0465549417,
-0.0904468372,
0.0247310847,
-0.0136348456,
0.016438501,
0.0429037809,
0.0503069349,
-0.0101663982,
-0.0071899025,
-0.0573141314,
-0.0298294146,
0.0266789012,
0.0241035167,
0.0435595401,
0.0335146673,
0.0284633338,
-0.0720486715,
-0.0329195075,
-0.0065177321,
0.0200110599,
-0.0116724344,
-0.0416359566,
-0.0285369791,
0.0433740988,
-0.0299023837,
0.0366355889,
-0.0105680581,
0.0139036262,
-0.028318122,
-0.0483670793,
0.0329018794,
0.0584436022,
0.0317736939,
0.0079637691,
0.0282662176,
-0.0101028485,
-0.056177821,
0.0269231126,
-0.0264456887,
0.043197833,
-0.0143789304,
-0.0070475945,
0.0249816235,
0.0275569931,
0.0001532851,
-0.0089184446,
-0.0157117862,
0.027207477,
-0.0002291354,
-0.0099945804,
-0.0363965519,
-0.0198324174,
-0.0018653972,
0.0387030579,
-0.0188024025,
-0.0136917122,
0.0426139534,
-0.0448844656,
0.0185525082,
-0.0414170735,
-0.0335448086,
-0.0776958317,
0.0564116985,
-0.0017544345,
0.0137729784,
-0.0240848009,
-0.0124881202,
-0.0262203496,
-0.0224984642,
0.0163804907,
-0.0445622653,
0.0703668892,
-0.03475881,
0.0498428419,
-0.0104348399,
-0.0481274463,
-0.0279219113,
-0.0611156896,
-0.0167309232,
0.0038407512,
0.0102193058,
0.0066489549,
-0.0124090482,
0.0164201912,
0.0358253494,
0.0591595247,
-0.0482345186,
-0.0002178493,
-0.0212520752,
0.0720996186,
0.0653299317,
0.0246448927,
0.023665918,
-0.0046022329,
0.0647147447,
0.0733613744,
0.0200505666,
0.0148477126,
0.0296172705,
-0.0238411836,
0.0193852577,
-0.0707134679,
-0.0265900511,
-0.0093788514,
0.0748377144,
-0.0467995442,
-0.0121843778,
0.1504323483,
0.0330694541,
-0.0530639887,
-0.0240036361,
-0.0369850621,
0.002805202,
0.0224357359,
0.0178445932,
-0.075332351,
-0.0179346744,
-0.0013276804,
0.0017505572,
-0.0025065884,
-0.037394125,
-0.0122458944,
-0.065055199,
0.0142547274,
-0.0055126045,
-0.0328264721,
-0.015410847,
-0.0448666438,
0.0147581138,
0.010199286,
0.0104678646,
0.0244650561,
-0.0623261034,
-0.0086154239,
-0.0059653907,
-0.0500964671,
-0.0188942757,
-0.0010961002,
0.0235928781,
0.0358845368,
0.0156321563,
0.0306485202,
0.0025317792,
0.0224424079,
0.0718474761,
-0.0569161251,
-0.0145282419,
-0.0374420397,
0.0493519604,
-0.0267071277,
0.0164299347,
-0.0170226041,
0.036617212,
-0.0099076228,
-0.022071965,
0.0116373478,
0.0348603204,
-0.018376112,
0.0042206477,
-0.0440729,
0.0154296216,
-0.0161412135,
0.1322724819,
0.043781504,
-0.0138085391,
-0.0364637747,
-0.0038367447,
-0.0222295914,
-0.0126707312,
-0.0178876556,
-0.0097114593,
0.0081482083,
-0.0088234507,
-0.0588480718,
-0.0478720441,
0.0272349734,
-0.0114908274,
-0.0351011641,
0.0532956794,
-0.0095468471,
-0.0125730252,
-0.0314049982,
-0.0258339774,
-0.0643369853,
-0.0122673819,
-0.0405322351,
0.0269078482,
0.0535947494,
-0.0412040278,
0.0071987999,
0.0228174832,
-0.0849741176,
-0.0757757351,
-0.0223147608,
0.0059517147,
0.0264886357,
0.077001065,
-0.0219291169,
-0.0313536637,
0.0430708714,
0.0199967083,
-0.0440319069,
0.0337635987,
0.0097762104,
0.0502799787,
0.0099385185,
0.0376272984,
-0.0706566796,
0.0299001411,
-0.0280016493,
0.0230563208,
-0.0701591223,
-0.0815500468,
0.0227223448,
0.030224571,
-0.0278135985,
0.0117237167,
0.0420310013,
-0.0070626992,
0.0282871015,
-0.0542227589,
-0.0199013762,
-0.0189732276,
0.0339731723,
-0.018512059,
-0.0366623439,
0.0068678819,
0.0414806902,
-0.0194350742,
0.0139385434,
-0.0558671542,
0.0055733649,
-0.0411056727,
-0.0339931287,
-0.0080004446,
-0.0222088955,
-0.0199992675,
-0.0038651875,
-0.001550795,
0.0171841588,
-0.0394621752,
0.036830008,
0.02139467,
-0.0264980271,
0.0042208717,
0.038239032,
-0.1338610798,
-0.0215765145,
-0.0167845804,
0.033699736,
0.0270117894,
-0.0373494364,
0.0559156798,
-0.010856607,
-0.0318027027,
-0.030978227,
0.0194657966,
0.048858624,
0.0100608682,
0.0131148752,
0.0379624516,
-0.0164961983,
0.0304516423,
0.0910495594,
0.0089901192,
0.026086757,
0.0440205783,
-0.0184444506,
-0.0361731052,
-0.031504713,
-0.0230370499,
0.0542385876,
-0.0166069381,
0.0022439922,
-0.0351176336,
-0.044847142,
0.0255766511,
0.0202608798,
-0.0133187175,
-0.043718908,
0.0312795602,
0.0619370416,
0.0377643593,
-0.0207419023,
-0.0488470085,
0.0431115478,
-0.0053749941,
-0.006951395,
0.0068988935,
-6.788561426e-33,
-0.0398929529,
-0.0234400388,
0.0179247521,
0.0308088697,
-0.0172906239,
0.0205812827,
-0.0436280817,
0.0046954346,
-0.0146487169,
-0.0252381507,
-0.0441111065,
0.0406227149,
0.0023188516,
0.0415327586,
-0.0303851441,
-0.0048092017,
0.0298179127,
-0.0110352142,
-0.0074146753,
0.0241417121,
0.0051343888,
0.0169954803,
0.0119771436,
-0.0443364494,
0.0158056784,
-0.0184011646,
0.0147882011,
0.0225833245,
0.0350198112,
0.0537035316,
-0.0392496288,
0.0062055429,
0.047673963,
-0.0430031493,
-0.028572062,
0.0336388312,
-0.1149408817,
-0.0467082784,
0.0384501405,
-0.0401387699,
-0.0524542145,
-0.0521125682,
0.0637110844,
-0.0097010527,
0.0193798989,
-0.0233980194,
0.0233022943,
-0.0290500205,
-0.0370516367,
-0.0316972882,
-0.0205820855,
0.0417027734,
-0.015038996,
-0.0112504112,
0.04595723,
0.0039194687,
0.0131256273,
0.0516757593,
-0.0254981462,
0.022334775,
-0.0004371206,
0.0500034653,
0.026338825,
-0.0245808177,
0.0169077348,
0.038187854,
0.0088748643,
-0.0180690195,
-0.0359410383,
-0.0528292172,
-0.0190958474,
0.0080855098,
-0.0009315212,
0.0162377656,
0.0172219984,
0.0028249014,
-0.0756588876,
0.0420996174,
-0.0122308359,
0.0166054796,
0.0123284031,
0.0054795397,
-0.0180496592,
-0.0056010569,
-0.0222199522,
0.034104079,
-0.0156250652,
-0.0049494854,
-0.0004988109,
0.006481146,
-0.028428847,
-0.0195927564,
0.0228745341,
-0.0388975143,
-0.0302592162,
0.0409328863,
-0.016117217,
0.0142181711,
0.0116932699,
0.0334057175,
-0.0404672325,
0.0392770916,
-0.0106228888,
-0.0035143336,
-0.0249012988,
0.0200204086,
0.0145747876,
0.0037106425,
-0.0642512962,
-0.02297014,
-0.0254282691,
0.0302277263,
-0.0401686542,
-0.0172556192,
0.0071759396,
0.0193207432,
0.0223576166,
0.0893798843,
0.0044284593,
0.0002927858,
-0.0416428074,
-0.0422478653,
0.0151383886,
0.01492895,
0.0009509086,
0.0067923861,
-0.009900325,
0.0526991785,
0.0321643203,
-0.0498444587,
-0.0000565639,
0.0191894565,
2.623e-7,
0.0585354045,
0.0356547907,
0.0459037274,
0.0245210249,
0.040098764,
0.0042762342,
-0.0021988896,
0.0205150917,
-0.0003170733,
-0.0122493785,
0.0158206988,
0.0697171167,
0.0222692993,
0.0264220349,
-0.0919781625,
-0.0033152651,
-0.0755952224,
-0.037271291,
-0.0203789715,
-0.0145194829,
0.036467649,
0.0786544234,
-0.0099926442,
0.005384021,
-0.0468570329,
-0.0445787795,
0.0481111482,
-0.0322573595,
-0.0166290067,
0.0482094884,
0.0549972467,
0.02382732,
0.0032870632,
-0.0258038957,
-0.0033827408,
0.0245966967,
-0.0005071209,
0.0781506449,
0.0170667861,
-0.0288553685,
0.0030551527,
-0.0458713733,
0.013270746,
-0.0068839467,
0.1117204353,
-0.0369788706,
-0.0094313044,
-0.0460057668,
-0.0054803398,
-0.0013631096,
-0.0057680192,
0.0288552623,
-0.0338518582,
0.0240192469,
-0.0023333454,
-0.0361927822,
0.0044193473,
-0.0917651951,
-0.0276699904,
-0.0089830607,
-0.0672329962,
-0.0157214906,
-0.0400594957,
-0.0204737689,
0.0143834408,
-0.0723284632,
0.0097595239,
2.43306438e-34,
0.048468072,
-0.0099010766,
-0.0347286202,
0.0388224907,
0.0045263902,
-0.0101807127,
-0.0367530845,
-0.0079350276,
0.024671372,
-0.09397237,
-0.0075696269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14276v1 | AI, write an essay for me: A large-scale comparison of human-written versus ChatGPT-generated essays | 2023-04-24T12:58:28 | 2023-04-24T12:58:28 | Steffen Herbold, Annette Hautli-Janisz, Ute Heuer, Zlata Kikteva, Alexander Trautsch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Background: Recently, ChatGPT and similar generative AI models have attracted
hundreds of millions of users and become part of the public discourse. Many
believe that such models will disrupt society and will result in a significant
change in the education system and information generation in the future. So
far, this belief is based on either colloquial evidence or benchmarks from the
owners of the models -- both lack scientific rigour.
Objective: Through a large-scale study comparing human-written versus
ChatGPT-generated argumentative student essays, we systematically assess the
quality of the AI-generated content.
Methods: A large corpus of essays was rated using standard criteria by a
large number of human experts (teachers). We augment the analysis with a
consideration of the linguistic characteristics of the generated essays.
Results: Our results demonstrate that ChatGPT generates essays that are rated
higher for quality than human-written essays. The writing style of the AI
models exhibits linguistic characteristics that are different from those of the
human-written essays, e.g., it is characterized by fewer discourse and
epistemic markers, but more nominalizations and greater lexical diversity.
Conclusions: Our results clearly demonstrate that models like ChatGPT
outperform humans in generating argumentative essays. Since the technology is
readily available for anyone to use, educators must act immediately. We must
re-invent homework and develop teaching concepts that utilize these AI models
in the same way as math utilized the calculator: teach the general concepts
first and then use AI tools to free up time for other learning objectives. | [
0.0327663049,
0.0296688117,
-0.0054772524,
-0.0242110416,
-0.0555056632,
-0.0033138276,
0.0249756202,
-0.0296939649,
0.0374462791,
-0.0907452032,
0.0307573378,
-0.0210375022,
-0.01907303,
0.0203607492,
0.0204228759,
-0.044178687,
-0.0086069228,
0.025424581,
0.0549853817,
0.0083754314,
0.0228852499,
0.0190426279,
-0.0301967654,
0.0584569164,
-0.0503185168,
-0.0589666925,
-0.0176081769,
-0.0206855088,
-0.0016775946,
-0.0119916694,
0.0393000357,
0.0741467923,
-0.0223800093,
0.0314628519,
0.0000022331,
-0.0422291905,
0.0223543346,
-0.0017299997,
0.0042548003,
0.039163854,
0.0698545426,
0.0809057578,
-0.029807318,
0.0283354521,
-0.0662800744,
0.0302031562,
0.0426562205,
0.0586076267,
0.0535873733,
0.0672529265,
-0.0098019494,
-0.0173066258,
0.0618358962,
0.01872476,
0.0106673986,
0.0278245397,
0.0033674075,
0.0241198931,
0.0335790999,
0.0064486586,
-0.0019351923,
0.0356678776,
0.0112378467,
-0.0700902119,
-0.0026346096,
0.0185528453,
-0.0513371527,
-0.0194811448,
0.0214951672,
0.0012475516,
0.0403181575,
-0.0408743322,
0.0297037866,
0.000340301,
0.0399248265,
-0.0086814463,
-0.0673108771,
0.069719255,
-0.0306197815,
0.014252889,
0.0748915747,
-0.0171843655,
-0.0115246009,
0.0358883031,
0.046208851,
-0.0380671434,
-0.008558278,
-0.0401063263,
-0.0043192296,
0.0340756811,
0.0128017217,
-0.0722058564,
0.0023584967,
0.0380450562,
-0.013395627,
0.0075872447,
-0.0412738323,
-0.0466868728,
0.0262950361,
-0.0532460175,
0.0501021668,
0.0302900542,
0.0353539586,
-0.0186228063,
0.0092410259,
0.0400852673,
-0.0050822305,
0.0422061384,
-0.015872499,
0.0391134098,
-0.089100115,
-0.0476403646,
-0.0522142872,
0.0629368499,
0.0208220016,
-0.0114576602,
-0.0277488753,
-0.016406985,
-0.0372587666,
-0.0086765466,
0.0041722134,
0.0273719747,
-0.0259358995,
0.0172376074,
-0.0074939062,
0.0131667862,
-0.0334597491,
0.0104072895,
0.0439190716,
-0.0488877222,
0.0223760102,
0.0392400473,
-0.000220936,
0.0063714134,
-0.011756029,
0.0234214887,
-0.0434131846,
0.0164519176,
-0.0027190514,
-0.0506531559,
-0.0055566542,
-0.0480391905,
0.0001309917,
-0.0738598928,
0.0002722397,
0.0099858604,
-0.0020802987,
-0.0614534654,
0.0079314224,
0.0336870328,
0.0278051589,
-0.0074612722,
-0.016782267,
0.006595958,
0.076184921,
-0.0008361902,
-0.0196111482,
0.0071551409,
0.0572146587,
0.0197780579,
0.0168948919,
-0.0156831648,
0.0634805188,
-0.0112429662,
-0.0222140271,
-0.0152661921,
0.0500271022,
-0.018306464,
-0.0384101346,
0.0325735249,
-0.0325512141,
0.0737640634,
-0.0039486694,
0.03026025,
0.0630758926,
0.0649121031,
-0.0003266845,
0.061169669,
0.0305118039,
0.0315184705,
0.0689583123,
0.0439029448,
-0.0068146568,
0.0064787185,
-0.0027603244,
0.0034083726,
0.0158258025,
-0.0026621614,
0.0041545331,
-0.0877735913,
-0.0239019822,
-0.0039487369,
-0.0156838894,
-0.0229941178,
-0.0001231799,
-0.0086883269,
-0.0103568304,
-0.0144465426,
0.0103120459,
-0.0682595596,
-0.012678558,
-0.0451241918,
0.0569601841,
0.0531864241,
0.0430874303,
-0.0081891036,
0.0011778827,
-0.0379986502,
0.0599815585,
0.0898865536,
0.0551633425,
-0.0202103183,
-0.0709160566,
-0.0204306282,
-0.0092133516,
-0.0545774326,
0.0183401704,
0.0003558099,
0.0166042447,
0.0116302567,
0.0215355586,
0.0217760652,
-0.1029252037,
0.0509758554,
-0.0443047471,
-0.0150811477,
-0.0096224984,
-0.0030207434,
0.0076437485,
0.0286371112,
-0.0396824367,
0.0430753455,
-0.0068606832,
-0.010624635,
-0.045447167,
-0.0198399723,
-0.038992852,
0.0462394096,
0.0287718028,
-0.1056228504,
0.0080791404,
-0.0108609218,
0.001670285,
-0.0197303947,
0.0060754125,
-0.0511371456,
0.02170109,
-0.0163048729,
0.0005976991,
-0.0086186836,
-0.0366828181,
-0.0171503387,
0.0055084359,
0.0430164151,
-0.0000765286,
-0.0230234656,
0.0211815462,
0.0232915692,
-0.0293182749,
0.0006943155,
0.0347351357,
0.0059562488,
0.0299853981,
0.0354008488,
0.0089521706,
-0.0554394349,
-0.0336125307,
-0.0963728353,
-0.0287944693,
0.0045712912,
0.0123196943,
0.0264428575,
-0.0467389934,
-0.0098916655,
0.0385080166,
-0.0453489684,
-0.0507901721,
-0.0007235818,
-0.009376402,
0.0355655253,
-0.0350109302,
0.0447190814,
-0.0356222875,
-0.0012745482,
-0.0496325269,
0.0017553509,
0.105738543,
-0.0222570356,
-0.0133529436,
0.0543556996,
0.0018928493,
-0.0405996479,
0.0089624049,
-0.0613398701,
0.0427049473,
-0.0009592714,
0.0453824103,
0.0821102038,
0.0512864105,
0.0399014056,
0.0284799263,
0.0142662972,
-0.0196171328,
-0.0171934124,
0.0085155284,
0.0306920949,
-0.0113926232,
-0.0632317811,
-0.0045847972,
0.029969193,
0.0341322087,
0.0016716684,
-0.0470311046,
0.0870364308,
-0.0548728257,
0.0102481367,
-0.0014270073,
-0.0480874814,
-0.0292106587,
0.0106335934,
-0.012145604,
-0.012098656,
0.0486114211,
-0.0055170082,
0.0221213531,
-0.035429392,
0.0092291674,
-0.0132118044,
0.0474722572,
-0.002059256,
0.0034736535,
0.0041741827,
0.0368647315,
-0.0476285033,
-0.0013748019,
0.0549395382,
-0.0280406084,
0.0196505506,
-0.026921371,
0.0020711941,
-0.0161247198,
-0.0212172214,
-0.0224290304,
-0.0233965591,
-0.0090601481,
0.0017304778,
0.0341468565,
-0.0280667748,
-0.0018007881,
-0.0291638225,
0.0289690755,
0.0254683476,
-0.0627610385,
-0.0123108802,
-0.0001721484,
0.0140930852,
0.0137828067,
-0.0299942084,
-0.0257868432,
-0.0170008391,
0.0746926144,
0.0731152445,
-0.0130548216,
0.0263164919,
-0.0158469565,
-0.0420818329,
-0.0231736209,
-0.0399465673,
-0.0512515977,
-0.0201269072,
0.0483408049,
-0.0613337569,
0.009184368,
0.0917114615,
0.0098288711,
-0.0095849801,
-0.0103207147,
-0.0260599162,
-0.0006546216,
-0.009637543,
0.0527717583,
-0.0602195337,
0.0104231294,
-0.009010626,
0.03854765,
-0.0642754585,
-0.0303177498,
0.0072367303,
-0.0759054646,
0.0531419516,
0.0151354969,
0.0209124107,
0.0232958086,
-0.0201105755,
-0.0401613079,
-0.0096654715,
-0.0423222743,
-0.0090584327,
-0.0090290317,
0.0430629551,
0.0540843569,
-0.0186149962,
0.0244829841,
-0.0114329448,
-0.0000178827,
0.0417170562,
0.0177239906,
0.0728457868,
-0.0217772853,
-0.0410021096,
0.0245050825,
0.039133247,
-0.0267219599,
0.0132342493,
0.0326548293,
0.0004972743,
0.0160102583,
-0.0543034859,
0.035703972,
-0.0097554373,
-0.0393164828,
0.068312712,
0.0728324875,
-0.0241819955,
-0.0340438485,
-0.0426910073,
0.0043023578,
0.0031506936,
0.0637837946,
0.0425182879,
-0.0336851738,
-0.042589169,
-0.0716261417,
0.0004215342,
-0.0836772993,
-0.0335405543,
-0.0078881085,
-0.01838018,
-0.0075971223,
-0.0622493699,
-0.0941705033,
0.004599486,
0.0348726287,
0.0151206339,
-0.0111336578,
0.0263578799,
0.0088202246,
-0.0334151052,
-0.0192731675,
0.0056775408,
-0.0174764823,
-0.0423588157,
-0.0572648495,
-0.0266471449,
-0.0225299206,
-0.0192744937,
0.005408905,
-0.01225984,
-0.058678031,
0.0547490418,
0.0460973382,
0.0160031468,
-0.0085425014,
0.021506669,
-0.0206856243,
0.0336810239,
0.0341028385,
0.0185157526,
0.0092919236,
0.0022238076,
-0.0220395997,
0.013013483,
-0.011736148,
0.0180706065,
0.022559626,
0.0093307244,
0.0342350341,
-0.0130683091,
-0.0094729299,
0.0334881842,
0.0589054897,
0.0043893987,
-0.04112342,
-0.0200643055,
-0.035254214,
-0.0323325247,
-0.0676961318,
-0.0266506784,
-0.0256654993,
-0.0211449713,
0.0096872067,
-0.0038347414,
0.0140601387,
0.0180423558,
-0.0564722233,
0.0289757624,
0.0012431894,
0.0539205037,
-0.0334864445,
0.0704802871,
0.0004185545,
-0.0153458519,
-0.037699163,
0.0572598651,
-0.020276824,
0.0400760435,
-0.0181009527,
0.044537209,
0.009718623,
0.0066661709,
0.0552139916,
0.0129800746,
-0.0540701263,
-0.0327922106,
-0.037437018,
0.0416508429,
0.0085175894,
-0.0116895633,
0.0519009419,
-0.044123143,
-0.0018718345,
-0.0139084719,
0.0490010045,
0.0418919772,
-0.0155490851,
-0.0095353834,
0.0014393985,
-0.0132534206,
-0.0495189913,
0.0475750864,
-0.0413861237,
0.0156553593,
0.0143915582,
-0.0257533323,
-0.0244404562,
-0.0357596688,
-0.0124918446,
-0.0182643998,
0.0551967546,
-0.0126549862,
-0.0269903746,
-0.0170345642,
-0.0433475114,
0.0312839523,
0.0260453261,
-0.0361027159,
0.0166887082,
0.0505369231,
-0.024864234,
0.0118687702,
-0.0704813525,
0.0522310026,
-0.0418560989,
-0.0207188297,
-0.0140830837,
-5.883324614e-33,
-0.0065622497,
-0.0688227117,
0.0163313076,
0.0735667869,
-0.0133212246,
-0.0096251117,
-0.0380038507,
0.0476782583,
0.009704655,
0.0673963353,
-0.0246508028,
-0.0000967991,
-0.0102346735,
0.0340688676,
0.0371165015,
0.0091080032,
0.02832078,
-0.0182356779,
-0.0257995706,
0.0145357903,
-0.0053509143,
-0.019486608,
0.0406559817,
-0.0498813316,
0.063503556,
-0.0640172735,
-0.0042455383,
-0.0622273386,
-0.0402864963,
0.0412336327,
0.0052188635,
0.0576290339,
0.0303576831,
-0.0135874702,
0.0010113368,
0.0209292118,
-0.0120860105,
-0.0447035134,
0.010329227,
-0.028404355,
-0.0225330703,
-0.1000325084,
0.0136813521,
-0.0223322045,
-0.0523907356,
-0.0229576062,
0.0567983948,
0.0018378946,
0.0170437247,
-0.0273828469,
-0.0796921179,
0.0234946311,
-0.0322405174,
-0.0137671633,
-0.0378363505,
0.0516980104,
-0.0024925533,
-0.0084616756,
-0.0314752497,
0.0450583324,
0.0063305618,
0.0260040238,
0.0280596521,
-0.0410140306,
-0.0019946303,
0.048394531,
0.0280094743,
0.0370000005,
-0.0710382909,
0.0011888292,
-0.0271298289,
-0.0089464877,
0.0756351501,
0.0808538571,
-0.001380562,
-0.0335041322,
-0.0252299756,
0.0124367829,
0.035287369,
0.0004889224,
-0.0013428302,
-0.0452761501,
-0.0443740711,
-0.0331105627,
-0.0080107106,
-0.0747896954,
0.0097772172,
-0.039737463,
0.0180089455,
-0.0451324023,
-0.0026830521,
-0.0353457779,
-0.0254887305,
-0.0270274263,
0.0022839608,
-0.0116475848,
-0.0391019881,
0.0286281426,
-0.0146499453,
-0.0044761482,
-0.0125679066,
0.01841419,
0.0231814459,
0.0526921675,
0.0602680147,
0.0163763128,
0.0357800499,
-0.0094162505,
-0.0233205743,
-0.0274973586,
-0.0303888693,
0.0332728364,
0.0307653118,
-0.0315259807,
0.0039249291,
0.0191058759,
0.0071026683,
0.012144194,
0.0172048341,
0.015061697,
-0.0470948666,
-0.0633412153,
0.0096108476,
-0.0259758942,
-0.0197117999,
0.0218967535,
-0.0493170358,
0.0290675852,
0.0169885587,
-0.0519005395,
-0.011660371,
-0.0320154615,
2.734e-7,
0.050113868,
0.0499111712,
0.035366822,
-0.0123089319,
0.0074663092,
0.0321753584,
-0.0101758521,
-0.0067002759,
0.0192180425,
0.0362249203,
0.007728572,
0.0183078181,
0.0636538714,
0.0403675698,
-0.0696441755,
-0.0365297459,
-0.0699529946,
-0.0215559471,
-0.0561896451,
0.0614329763,
0.123067975,
-0.0142002106,
0.024715161,
-0.0249706581,
-0.0412804857,
-0.0066394187,
0.0351311713,
0.0211311765,
-0.0039493809,
0.0283673145,
0.0425039232,
-0.0337253623,
0.0408084914,
0.010998344,
-0.0251536779,
-0.0600990877,
0.0179618001,
0.0758090615,
0.0124615356,
0.0248929095,
0.0421050712,
-0.0055652889,
0.0237257537,
-0.0795358643,
0.0515060835,
-0.0263109002,
-0.0127555588,
-0.0375803597,
-0.0452888273,
-0.011015445,
0.011215521,
-0.0211713817,
-0.0035385336,
-0.0061792345,
-0.0114746494,
-0.0250560101,
0.0497160256,
-0.0080319606,
-0.0400495343,
-0.0059748283,
-0.0196289867,
-0.0184266549,
-0.0232562199,
0.0106764426,
0.0398338176,
-0.0197693203,
-0.0019537804,
2.228644306e-34,
0.02456275,
-0.0264592487,
0.0499581955,
-0.0006787392,
0.0397317,
0.0567929409,
0.0338618681,
-0.0012089749,
0.0046080509,
-0.0145801967,
-0.0265262071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12036v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12036v3 | Generating Post-hoc Explanations for Skip-gram-based Node Embeddings by Identifying Important Nodes with Bridgeness | 2023-04-24T12:25:35 | 2023-05-15T09:31:29 | Hogun Park, Jennifer Neville | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | Node representation learning in a network is an important machine learning
technique for encoding relational information in a continuous vector space
while preserving the inherent properties and structures of the network.
Recently, unsupervised node embedding methods such as DeepWalk, LINE,
struc2vec, PTE, UserItem2vec, and RWJBG have emerged from the Skip-gram model
and perform better performance in several downstream tasks such as node
classification and link prediction than the existing relational models.
However, providing post-hoc explanations of Skip-gram-based embeddings remains
a challenging problem because of the lack of explanation methods and
theoretical studies applicable for embeddings. In this paper, we first show
that global explanations to the Skip-gram-based embeddings can be found by
computing bridgeness under a spectral cluster-aware local perturbation.
Moreover, a novel gradient-based explanation method, which we call GRAPH-wGD,
is proposed that allows the top-q global explanations about learned graph
embedding vectors more efficiently. Experiments show that the ranking of nodes
by scores using GRAPH-wGD is highly correlated with true bridgeness scores. We
also observe that the top-q node-level explanations selected by GRAPH-wGD have
higher importance scores and produce more changes in class label prediction
when perturbed, compared with the nodes selected by recent alternatives, using
five real-world graphs. | [
-0.0128272837,
-0.0163747557,
-0.0187588297,
0.0468247347,
-0.0026713843,
-0.0019468422,
0.0132327089,
-0.0208175927,
0.0880210549,
0.0042462787,
0.0470932201,
0.0111307725,
-0.001999842,
0.0248255655,
0.048555214,
-0.0253930427,
0.0229584221,
0.0316638649,
-0.0164602157,
-0.0183628108,
-0.000456136,
0.0287445318,
0.0161025301,
0.0479252115,
0.0037174153,
0.0059099765,
-0.0362191461,
-0.0073638321,
0.0362181887,
-0.022919897,
-0.0249344483,
0.0077253627,
0.0571859926,
-0.0136617655,
0.0000019422,
0.024434261,
-0.0310209878,
0.0156376902,
-0.0305834673,
-0.0021020926,
-0.0284422878,
0.0269939993,
0.0351772793,
-0.0042021736,
-0.0181077514,
-0.0554603785,
0.0473937318,
0.0360727534,
-0.0055825221,
0.0359290577,
-0.0148234963,
-0.0221013892,
-0.005025431,
-0.0387049206,
0.0082683899,
-0.0121500436,
0.0235983469,
0.0238936525,
-0.01718596,
0.0110657234,
-0.0712983161,
-0.0051518539,
0.0120701827,
-0.0337624662,
0.0989446193,
0.0470769107,
0.0157495495,
0.029776467,
0.062303409,
0.1209810749,
-0.011998985,
-0.0157132354,
0.0575474761,
0.0166244768,
0.003604867,
0.0519397706,
-0.0417733863,
-0.0860262886,
0.0347803943,
0.0403270163,
-0.0099663371,
0.0144481966,
0.0957367793,
-0.0189895742,
-0.0018546946,
0.0210293829,
-0.0245974772,
0.0215473808,
-0.0064279791,
0.0239509996,
-0.0001773044,
-0.0085984012,
0.0494291708,
0.009869515,
-0.0016530743,
-0.0047115646,
0.0318759456,
0.0625488088,
-0.0322350077,
-0.0020429969,
0.0332205407,
0.0119153978,
0.0151272016,
0.0354480706,
-0.0624603033,
-0.0099998442,
-0.0427806079,
0.0270197093,
-0.0235514846,
-0.0245772246,
-0.0640385747,
-0.0115420856,
-0.0081285378,
0.0085010296,
-0.031312421,
-0.0287772287,
-0.0287565421,
0.0216188449,
-0.0487266928,
-0.035073325,
-0.0150269242,
0.0468960367,
0.0288422424,
0.0181634128,
0.0042341514,
-0.0000712528,
-0.0507818982,
0.0293004997,
-0.0016012853,
0.0353236832,
-0.0045943363,
-0.0122307986,
0.0559742823,
-0.0033874896,
-0.0067177662,
0.0531963184,
0.0195367225,
-0.0112941805,
-0.0114467861,
-0.0242793318,
0.0062093879,
-0.0445346758,
0.011500027,
-0.0263326075,
0.0274729077,
0.0436075814,
-0.0144266179,
0.0240208823,
-0.0034237837,
-0.0241098553,
-0.065283522,
0.0392423123,
-0.0002178553,
-0.0202927608,
0.0139141791,
0.003037421,
0.0215191469,
0.0172499418,
0.0082211299,
0.0112732882,
0.0169025641,
-0.0390355401,
-0.0564061105,
-0.03299224,
0.0585079715,
-0.0312808901,
0.0206994098,
-0.0401766151,
0.0000895572,
0.0236877184,
0.0516580045,
0.0231245309,
-0.0660168976,
-0.0372271985,
-0.02088416,
0.0387732573,
0.019908186,
0.0356649011,
0.0532426946,
-0.0153332194,
-0.0397412926,
0.0412865281,
-0.0575402342,
0.0462999977,
-0.0289580058,
-0.0212939121,
0.0413784906,
-0.023519244,
-0.0241464116,
-0.0232193898,
0.0347174183,
0.0004862033,
0.0695122778,
0.0057640281,
0.0489860103,
-0.015057805,
-0.0066252346,
0.0205088481,
0.0432722047,
-0.0193755925,
-0.0029577634,
0.0075815478,
-0.0101065421,
0.0493950956,
0.0676771775,
-0.0080623226,
0.0605282113,
-0.0019974192,
0.0456953011,
-0.0286794435,
0.0363953598,
-0.0198422931,
0.0016102825,
-0.0325954482,
-0.0561961532,
-0.0275503732,
0.0009731082,
0.0487485789,
-0.0344014131,
-0.016270455,
0.0226444099,
-0.0891998187,
-0.071440585,
0.005648159,
0.0019092194,
0.0312144104,
0.0303684771,
0.0170165952,
-0.0327862687,
0.0421542004,
0.008703989,
-0.0085253473,
0.0236905422,
-0.0142187532,
-0.0402170382,
-0.0342065841,
-0.0579638407,
-0.0393674858,
0.004180043,
-0.0619932152,
-0.0028352409,
0.0430985466,
-0.0345617309,
-0.0556989834,
0.0390826911,
-0.0494394489,
0.0605656877,
-0.0196291879,
-0.0597220808,
-0.0159177799,
0.0040566423,
-0.0026861336,
0.0448154621,
-0.0220114179,
0.0466521233,
-0.0213973429,
0.0211570114,
0.013621999,
-0.0076506319,
-0.0129961912,
0.0243586842,
0.0045254002,
-0.0101197185,
0.0213172808,
-0.0302590933,
-0.0071728425,
0.0417463779,
-0.0943255574,
-0.0515212342,
0.008945981,
-0.0185749158,
-0.0279048197,
-0.0224011969,
0.0651391223,
-0.0214852747,
-0.0320864022,
0.0559402891,
-0.0357620418,
0.0053798421,
0.0335746109,
-0.0275319275,
-0.0371858142,
-0.0518646315,
-0.0547949895,
-0.0403810591,
0.1054681987,
-0.0014664287,
-0.0332742408,
0.0006380106,
-0.0299912505,
-0.0381367356,
-0.0118917767,
-0.037326999,
-0.0114246951,
-0.0222461,
-0.0107865278,
0.0193956029,
0.0136012025,
-0.0350903757,
0.0903080255,
0.0267733168,
0.032259576,
-0.0387546681,
-0.025248399,
-0.0620602593,
0.0678384975,
-0.0471264049,
-0.0143092507,
-0.06107549,
0.0402577557,
0.005408708,
-0.0196887441,
-0.0346389525,
-0.0248295981,
-0.017028993,
0.0176920146,
-0.0039576804,
-0.0366631076,
0.0236724969,
-0.0052566212,
-0.0255895108,
-0.0306462627,
0.1036568433,
-0.0001121594,
-0.0174559094,
0.0137159303,
-0.0315507017,
-0.0160967596,
0.0441792831,
-0.0016927258,
0.032331802,
-0.0065669259,
-0.0289068725,
-0.011384435,
0.0046759816,
0.0279583167,
-0.0119093163,
-0.0185908265,
0.0335265286,
0.0077844802,
0.0203023702,
-0.0068417951,
0.0100114094,
-0.0103338817,
-0.022961434,
0.0233463701,
0.0252269134,
-0.0323512442,
0.002124724,
0.0039359876,
-0.0180414133,
-0.0039208005,
-0.0264066197,
0.0042717569,
-0.013195809,
0.0394977108,
-0.0185482334,
-0.0133404946,
0.0442065708,
0.0056763883,
0.006223924,
0.02492024,
-0.0041048778,
-0.0510129668,
-0.024920404,
0.0021720338,
-0.0256098658,
0.0146939326,
-0.0373955034,
-0.0399587676,
0.0318127275,
-0.0365606248,
-0.0004403867,
0.0387789495,
0.0301461071,
-0.0617501549,
0.0286817513,
-0.0004298333,
0.0219313074,
0.0297811683,
0.0179016478,
-0.0211092494,
-0.0276781823,
-0.0124547482,
0.032634709,
0.0364985429,
-0.0508766361,
0.0260389764,
-0.0531535111,
0.0242075175,
0.0417507403,
-0.0096317409,
-0.0211492572,
-0.0842866153,
-0.0181200951,
0.0296218116,
-0.0359595716,
-0.0194551945,
0.0399696268,
0.0099810166,
0.0307302736,
-0.0557557531,
-0.0323809087,
0.0278902333,
0.0049874578,
0.0425270461,
0.0216450784,
0.0561508536,
0.0186926741,
-0.0253076516,
0.0554314181,
-0.0529584326,
0.0263349302,
-0.0327328444,
0.0893298239,
-0.0020968504,
-0.0075838934,
-0.0452735201,
0.0453299172,
-0.0315898135,
-0.0081796544,
-0.0907817557,
0.1365451664,
0.0005276594,
-0.0658354834,
-0.008595882,
-0.0196538065,
0.0057513444,
0.0231359471,
0.0510860085,
0.0045739817,
-0.0416476056,
-0.0564973019,
0.0367398374,
0.0150721213,
-0.0242576115,
-0.0148688667,
0.0001084479,
0.0038483846,
-0.0093494495,
-0.0268731304,
0.0298625883,
0.0153520079,
-0.0127283027,
0.0072073555,
0.0037255401,
-0.0571660176,
-0.069931373,
0.0066296351,
0.0125268698,
0.0475344472,
0.0410380401,
-0.0117445868,
0.0527786724,
0.0006490971,
-0.0054977159,
-0.0176233165,
0.0110954866,
-0.067313306,
-0.0346447043,
-0.0058902758,
0.0077990424,
0.0549791642,
-0.0265161525,
-0.0844938979,
0.0320331492,
0.01218352,
-0.0360804163,
-0.0116542187,
0.0440122746,
-0.0380068906,
-0.0319570377,
0.0620547198,
-0.0545611382,
-0.0094390586,
0.00095008,
0.0350159183,
-0.0175707098,
0.0332814679,
0.0044324482,
-0.0092368536,
0.084948875,
0.0286937859,
0.0258580614,
-0.056685634,
-0.0264079254,
-0.0226588268,
-0.0321643166,
-0.0146432817,
0.0165281408,
0.0465374477,
0.0073046461,
0.0195467249,
-0.053022936,
0.0007358448,
0.0374225453,
-0.0143513642,
0.0006391222,
0.0112434262,
-0.0311855599,
0.0154405497,
0.0522860438,
-0.0271342434,
-0.0175764691,
0.0063931961,
0.0168106016,
-0.0244764704,
0.0172672402,
0.0314573534,
0.0114365695,
-0.0736223534,
0.0094013158,
-0.0765079185,
0.0269677024,
-0.0135903358,
0.0288467258,
0.045505356,
0.0217705611,
0.0479723066,
0.0431693867,
-0.0220798682,
-0.0258859191,
0.0597887263,
-0.0045464756,
-0.0416488759,
0.041848585,
0.0180325191,
-0.023200687,
0.0468009822,
0.0300686378,
0.0157866161,
-0.0180410948,
-0.0117015354,
-0.0454961471,
-0.008560163,
-0.0075916126,
0.0021773046,
0.0901445076,
-0.0084734671,
0.0130669847,
-0.0582148172,
-0.076903455,
-0.0147152068,
-0.014139411,
-0.0313706025,
-0.0183518212,
0.004876174,
0.0222518481,
0.0248503108,
0.0119631188,
-0.0518450029,
0.0082581509,
-0.0313070565,
-0.0286084153,
0.0354905203,
-6.451356912e-33,
0.0119649237,
-0.0642053112,
-0.0283648819,
0.0070028985,
-0.0278510749,
0.0428666174,
-0.0661640316,
-0.0167973861,
-0.0112321926,
0.0968570486,
-0.0138139781,
0.0044011213,
-0.0159539301,
0.0174283832,
-0.0275080726,
-0.0065860734,
0.0239575487,
0.0328934491,
0.0147240302,
0.0688469484,
0.0681729093,
0.0322033428,
0.0545216911,
-0.0797828808,
0.0406397656,
-0.0215586964,
0.0171887483,
-0.0052063977,
0.0289062932,
0.0187400114,
-0.0346876793,
0.0255801361,
0.0200000592,
0.0237379503,
-0.008960586,
-0.0011196221,
-0.0967191234,
-0.0122828148,
-0.0101183765,
-0.0014450437,
-0.0908007547,
-0.0131073799,
0.0005245575,
0.0153882531,
0.0240672939,
-0.0687822327,
0.0568237081,
0.0168860573,
-0.0735781789,
-0.0158206001,
0.0219903048,
0.0384741463,
-0.0566297211,
0.0027729787,
-0.0020255367,
0.0142170778,
0.0137538631,
0.0040351199,
-0.0587131716,
-0.0152291423,
-0.0486833937,
-0.0296918117,
0.013897622,
-0.0035503658,
0.0070055127,
0.0692337006,
0.0323410518,
-0.0195723791,
0.0004671006,
0.0313215479,
-0.0046034777,
0.030066032,
0.0341263115,
0.028024178,
0.0009716239,
0.0010361995,
-0.0950862989,
0.0092636542,
-0.0006673772,
0.000202148,
0.0017738469,
0.0310343001,
-0.0362028889,
-0.0759486109,
-0.0268448666,
-0.125803709,
-0.0147974258,
-0.0524842441,
-0.0178269818,
-0.0144974021,
-0.0624253415,
0.0190641861,
0.0005115406,
-0.0942051336,
-0.0426003486,
0.0421353504,
-0.0191606469,
0.018055439,
0.0458527803,
-0.0072598387,
-0.0225453936,
0.0001045956,
0.0082477536,
-0.0242459979,
0.0346674882,
-0.0002255467,
0.0319066159,
-0.0039281724,
0.0105507551,
-0.0216941088,
-0.0224013925,
-0.0724530816,
-0.0450420827,
0.009283171,
0.0219444484,
0.0093097193,
-0.0273222048,
0.0863635764,
0.0445790291,
0.1059204936,
0.0125071462,
0.036150936,
-0.0241081305,
0.0282501429,
-0.0205136053,
-0.0501604043,
-0.0200330615,
0.0297617316,
0.0819560513,
-0.069464393,
-0.0229005311,
0.0002730142,
2.671e-7,
0.025868753,
0.0280361623,
0.03049374,
-0.0456394292,
0.0186846759,
0.0457925498,
0.0240405779,
0.0373311415,
0.0063594086,
-0.0113395462,
0.01999088,
0.0291348211,
0.0153118474,
0.0015064972,
-0.0251789056,
0.0345426686,
-0.0472455099,
-0.0253239721,
-0.0243799016,
-0.0336526632,
0.0050287275,
0.0435185097,
0.0355232991,
0.0155995013,
0.0092713516,
-0.0339373201,
0.0482845604,
-0.0177322179,
0.0273634307,
-0.0173670333,
0.0251153801,
-0.0419831872,
-0.0012464063,
0.0022523757,
-0.0262716319,
0.0560285114,
0.0207056087,
0.0260103736,
-0.0108482102,
0.0082358429,
-0.0131758563,
-0.0224691425,
0.048164241,
-0.0559365489,
0.0602471381,
-0.0454963744,
-0.0487165824,
0.0551328249,
-0.041066274,
-0.0325988494,
0.0200306941,
0.0087833274,
-0.0049145697,
0.0346899182,
-0.0215376392,
-0.0450484343,
0.0283960644,
-0.1068400592,
0.0071267085,
0.0148927132,
-0.0035822776,
-0.0136262728,
0.0269378759,
0.0031686707,
0.0975711122,
0.0416898318,
-0.0013997343,
2.275631708e-34,
0.017053334,
0.0286408104,
0.0178384874,
-0.026524052,
0.0299040359,
-0.0305330455,
0.0117203202,
-0.0042920252,
0.057364922,
-0.0638561323,
-0.0235994849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12026v1 | SocialDial: A Benchmark for Socially-Aware Dialogue Systems | 2023-04-24T11:55:22 | 2023-04-24T11:55:22 | Haolan Zhan, Zhuang Li, Yufei Wang, Linhao Luo, Tao Feng, Xiaoxi Kang, Yuncheng Hua, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Suraj Sharma, Ingrid Zukerman, Zhaleh Semnani-Azad, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been widely applied in many scenarios and are now more
powerful and ubiquitous than ever before. With large neural models and massive
available data, current dialogue systems have access to more knowledge than any
people in their life. However, current dialogue systems still do not perform at
a human level. One major gap between conversational agents and humans lies in
their abilities to be aware of social norms. The development of socially-aware
dialogue systems is impeded due to the lack of resources. In this paper, we
present the first socially-aware dialogue corpus - SocialDial, based on Chinese
social culture. SocialDial consists of two parts: 1,563 multi-turn dialogues
between two human speakers with fine-grained labels, and 4,870 synthetic
conversations generated by ChatGPT. The human corpus covers five categories of
social norms, which have 14 sub-categories in total. Specifically, it contains
social factor annotations including social relation, context, social distance,
and social norms. However, collecting sufficient socially-aware dialogues is
costly. Thus, we harness the power of ChatGPT and devise an ontology-based
synthetic data generation framework. This framework is able to generate
synthetic data at scale. To ensure the quality of synthetic dialogues, we
design several mechanisms for quality control during data collection. Finally,
we evaluate our dataset using several pre-trained models, such as BERT and
RoBERTa. Comprehensive empirical results based on state-of-the-art neural
models demonstrate that modeling of social norms for dialogue systems is a
promising research direction. To the best of our knowledge, SocialDial is the
first socially-aware dialogue dataset that covers multiple social factors and
has fine-grained labels. | [
0.0781055316,
0.035632737,
-0.018890569,
0.0594110601,
0.0059883618,
0.0113164699,
0.0074043158,
0.0137986755,
0.0518914387,
-0.0474191345,
-0.0528153852,
-0.0326740444,
-0.0181786865,
0.0309747551,
-0.0029058238,
-0.0416948274,
0.0507658608,
0.0265474897,
0.0341860056,
-0.0107934279,
0.0273063909,
0.0221236236,
0.0124777304,
0.0367102437,
-0.0658136979,
0.0073604165,
-0.024791453,
0.0155615835,
0.0506378226,
-0.0030805909,
0.0641080663,
0.078597337,
0.0209234543,
0.0526326224,
0.0000017412,
-0.0328189284,
0.0315786339,
-0.0289761443,
0.0138176205,
-0.0125397081,
0.0440170504,
0.015562376,
-0.0105180396,
0.0204247255,
-0.0858765543,
-0.0206994172,
0.0138834221,
0.0814880282,
0.076056689,
0.0858141482,
-0.0171163715,
-0.0340776406,
-0.0117250262,
-0.0301322732,
-0.0160133429,
-0.0629345551,
0.0056565925,
0.0270809401,
-0.0180315971,
0.0330977663,
0.0142167583,
-0.0127666164,
0.0081424387,
-0.0406065919,
0.0183588229,
-0.0132742692,
-0.0593167804,
-0.0382908247,
-0.0184397735,
0.1239707097,
0.0465544686,
-0.0201152749,
0.0333260447,
0.0149890389,
0.0209351107,
-0.0284321196,
-0.0097614992,
0.000855985,
0.0012102057,
0.0224819537,
-0.0072916881,
0.0211639125,
0.0000263593,
0.0161575451,
0.0258021653,
0.0360992178,
-0.03782003,
-0.0020399855,
-0.0390409194,
-0.017004557,
-0.0141058397,
-0.0451498292,
0.0235954784,
0.0240841154,
-0.0480318293,
0.0112480773,
-0.0436562486,
0.0402224958,
0.0357618853,
-0.0484895334,
-0.0326227732,
0.0165686999,
-0.0031748912,
0.0263886377,
0.0377407596,
0.0001933472,
-0.0176547524,
-0.0088017387,
-0.0021594816,
-0.0335500725,
-0.0504680462,
0.003374083,
-0.0559629463,
0.0129959872,
-0.0651662871,
-0.0261820257,
-0.0258862898,
0.0417522602,
-0.0286658071,
0.0257290863,
0.032468345,
0.042880211,
-0.0158073884,
0.0189982783,
-0.0107667483,
-0.0123560727,
-0.0595821701,
0.0137383202,
0.022441959,
-0.076124385,
0.032205265,
0.002490256,
0.0355307087,
0.01326025,
-0.0225286726,
0.0582372025,
0.0014819133,
-0.0174588095,
-0.0227851979,
-0.0370443761,
-0.0291813295,
-0.0590450987,
0.0038508764,
-0.0213134233,
0.0733226016,
-0.0344957709,
-0.0189319178,
-0.0260301288,
0.0482589118,
0.0100736003,
-0.0266172625,
0.0553325415,
-0.0124085434,
0.0006258155,
0.0384677425,
0.0471913517,
-0.0080966139,
0.0674697757,
0.0509533361,
-0.0194751341,
0.0807267576,
-0.0000914035,
0.0063079163,
0.0166429114,
0.0135214189,
-0.0388549455,
0.0316282548,
0.0127267679,
-0.0340405516,
0.0303752962,
-0.0035335142,
0.0559487343,
-0.0400489829,
-0.0447900258,
0.0520292632,
0.0688828379,
-0.0319281667,
0.0551287904,
0.0279113222,
0.0572451912,
-0.0018340546,
-0.0105194207,
-0.0482493453,
0.0119606052,
-0.0015851045,
-0.0357414745,
0.0066874363,
-0.0077485768,
-0.0488924943,
-0.0430427939,
-0.00451667,
0.0110513754,
0.0413212627,
-0.0187418181,
-0.0057429462,
0.0070327604,
-0.021539297,
0.0302185621,
0.0314487368,
-0.0725868717,
-0.0238894094,
-0.0139631098,
0.0432842784,
0.0622430444,
0.0455076508,
-0.0259342398,
-0.0270439666,
-0.015100373,
-0.0065678116,
0.0690746382,
0.0757794827,
-0.0552921854,
0.0195860956,
-0.0571431555,
0.0156597905,
0.0264859051,
-0.0003474214,
-0.0052951057,
0.0443039276,
-0.0084069204,
0.0162493084,
0.0222037788,
-0.0171005875,
-0.0062161698,
-0.0119607765,
0.0039940909,
0.0096677355,
-0.002570238,
0.0646330565,
0.0433663316,
-0.0247532707,
-0.0432592146,
0.0186566319,
0.0287750345,
-0.0282899141,
0.0272067282,
-0.0668434426,
-0.0884480253,
0.0304690376,
-0.0084519619,
-0.0414792672,
0.0518832356,
-0.0560885295,
-0.0264936537,
0.0283404402,
-0.036510013,
0.0523014292,
-0.0658336133,
-0.008812028,
0.0228484813,
0.0465610288,
0.0067843855,
0.0260352436,
-0.0079059675,
-0.0350293778,
0.0046570059,
0.006988808,
0.0090634245,
-0.0603887737,
-0.0079213241,
-0.0073157181,
-0.0154470494,
0.0097088702,
0.0149709862,
0.0376651995,
-0.054583706,
-0.0228043403,
-0.1169684529,
-0.0118303876,
-0.012965627,
-0.0267785341,
0.0079005184,
0.0015594679,
0.0020894145,
-0.0346925631,
-0.0803878978,
0.0444182605,
0.0272394232,
-0.0190713834,
0.0517270155,
-0.009849783,
-0.0416549221,
-0.0325546376,
0.0130039928,
-0.000847484,
0.0185802002,
-0.0148247797,
-0.0199215543,
-0.0226112306,
-0.010706949,
-0.0758771002,
0.0672397241,
-0.0191657711,
-0.0647829995,
0.0179747045,
0.0418775976,
0.0268075559,
0.045671884,
0.0707085952,
0.0503851622,
-0.0295827389,
-0.0117584867,
-0.0406215526,
0.0215347316,
-0.0257025063,
0.0525828339,
-0.0378190055,
-0.0399392359,
-0.0070236553,
0.0343478955,
-0.0005472711,
0.0168443024,
-0.0638382286,
0.0003008837,
0.0264681354,
-0.0701211169,
0.0005033082,
-0.0044747218,
-0.0328012109,
0.0149449334,
-0.03029879,
-0.0072733881,
0.0521619134,
-0.0107429307,
-0.0259690825,
-0.0209655091,
-0.0101183243,
-0.020993799,
0.0578125305,
-0.0119047845,
0.0176144205,
-0.0088606458,
-0.0310510527,
-0.0220219512,
-0.0163976718,
0.0372927897,
-0.0399237759,
0.0002976639,
-0.0273441002,
-0.0131055592,
0.026022831,
-0.034725301,
-0.0487217344,
-0.0144768013,
-0.0233579669,
0.0196563769,
0.0091588628,
-0.0529463515,
0.0587873496,
0.0022917949,
-0.0399088785,
0.0306151323,
0.015560912,
0.0081305467,
-0.0243362952,
0.034185674,
0.0304586757,
0.0224202257,
0.0055924738,
0.010238559,
0.063974902,
0.0318947248,
0.0267286375,
-0.015099314,
-0.0052503338,
-0.0005545226,
0.0222970042,
0.0170667097,
-0.0180640668,
-0.0019794782,
0.068205975,
-0.0215857569,
-0.0140843662,
0.115007773,
0.0242413227,
-0.0018827381,
0.019249158,
0.0070012072,
0.0106608635,
0.0028345957,
0.0108230067,
-0.0827150941,
-0.0165848341,
0.0024609589,
-0.0008057947,
-0.0276611932,
-0.0561571121,
0.0140644545,
-0.0883360878,
0.055133611,
-0.0115689812,
-0.0536039472,
-0.0268928185,
0.0101569928,
-0.002066388,
-0.0198772848,
0.0245075468,
-0.0165868662,
0.03467815,
-0.048638057,
-0.0048745177,
-0.0185709093,
-0.0144094238,
0.0665631369,
-0.0360850058,
0.1188115478,
0.0113823218,
0.1012112424,
0.0328944996,
-0.0280465148,
0.0328277797,
0.0368781127,
-0.0163764283,
-0.0172470361,
0.0492832586,
-0.0056065004,
-0.028715726,
-0.0230551977,
0.0470936,
-0.0360858329,
-0.0274095908,
-0.0129969157,
0.0056864172,
-0.0275600329,
-0.0287896693,
0.0083310539,
0.0752824619,
0.0103326216,
0.0729119256,
0.0311301518,
-0.014589441,
0.0055552623,
-0.0061452985,
-0.0315322764,
-0.0420911126,
-0.0011242592,
-0.0067516202,
-0.0278425831,
-0.0488474481,
-0.1070614159,
-0.0675096512,
0.0021998116,
0.0109153483,
-0.0152862361,
-0.062331561,
0.0589578226,
0.0316842273,
-0.0203331634,
0.0164617058,
-0.033720497,
-0.0235591754,
0.0020351256,
-0.0317172222,
0.0255746115,
-0.0269942209,
-0.0157778654,
0.0082379682,
-0.0218023341,
-0.0659073144,
0.0124287885,
0.0375705212,
0.0171494465,
0.0524736792,
-0.0286876354,
-0.0006685151,
0.0061921226,
0.0295186006,
-0.0334421322,
-0.0048138197,
0.0542287305,
0.0449247696,
-0.0075236289,
0.0617982522,
-0.0002400731,
0.0371116772,
-0.032793805,
0.0091593228,
-0.0712366924,
-0.0648816675,
-0.019445464,
-0.0184177663,
0.022187436,
0.019711623,
-0.0253883414,
-0.0425466374,
-0.0172042474,
-0.0663891286,
-0.0239552651,
-0.0545101762,
0.0044900356,
-0.0230826624,
-0.0011719597,
-0.0268695056,
-0.0042718556,
-0.0532947592,
0.0457234457,
-0.0167945474,
-0.0217675846,
0.0231730845,
0.0297974851,
-0.0111996839,
-0.0165805314,
-0.0266683903,
0.0337695293,
-0.0145366741,
0.0130881174,
0.003745045,
0.1048962772,
0.0227261335,
-0.0301388036,
0.0295826178,
0.0354560986,
-0.0578041896,
-0.0224336628,
-0.0451201797,
0.0684771538,
0.0162400138,
0.0063841003,
0.0380139425,
-0.0423103236,
0.0027603377,
-0.004528475,
0.0852753073,
-0.0203259774,
-0.0563053265,
0.0051798192,
0.0087198494,
-0.0451723486,
0.0095237968,
0.0630806163,
-0.0113615179,
0.0030382678,
0.0221439563,
-0.0229368825,
-0.031971056,
-0.0062736357,
0.0772617906,
0.000888042,
-0.0093963491,
0.003450928,
-0.0407455936,
-0.0615185834,
-0.0320766121,
0.0348228067,
0.0143561987,
0.0247473661,
0.042743735,
0.046955213,
-0.0220252294,
-0.010393884,
-0.0426946655,
0.002389499,
-0.0369347967,
-0.0117042586,
-0.0164849423,
-5.884165092e-33,
-0.0197560806,
-0.0191539954,
0.0109897181,
0.0505056605,
-0.0464173518,
-0.0385612622,
-0.0457774401,
-0.0064063827,
-0.0236712471,
0.0325740017,
-0.0247176066,
0.0555935651,
0.0029016538,
0.0248674303,
-0.0162007827,
-0.0519996174,
0.0328277573,
-0.0197851025,
0.0144190257,
0.0487811193,
0.0456580855,
-0.0069786562,
0.0442437008,
-0.0922384784,
0.01048957,
0.0050551291,
-0.0045407973,
0.0603222512,
0.0232741199,
0.029970279,
-0.0154540166,
0.0535225235,
0.010524747,
-0.0013683435,
0.0094383266,
0.0603922121,
-0.0737021789,
-0.0227585733,
-0.0018231622,
0.0080751115,
-0.0269592553,
0.0000746446,
0.0019164331,
-0.0513722897,
0.0049150907,
0.0412396081,
0.0233194865,
-0.0163589548,
0.0211475492,
-0.0390535742,
-0.049087856,
0.0123957889,
-0.0115142865,
-0.0588882975,
-0.0575797893,
0.0476561636,
0.025566753,
-0.031587936,
-0.0257446915,
0.0250926204,
-0.0378575996,
-0.0353926048,
0.0043484215,
-0.008244236,
0.0359461792,
0.0448868871,
0.0314473063,
0.0561014637,
0.0022195885,
-0.0431260169,
0.0040840209,
0.0640561506,
-0.0043442934,
0.0715836436,
-0.0203114133,
-0.0418395735,
-0.0430321805,
-0.0014059792,
0.0654262602,
-0.0212899316,
-0.0324411355,
-0.005195694,
-0.0382560752,
-0.01786061,
-0.0016139651,
-0.0134370169,
-0.0041850749,
-0.0078999531,
0.019198481,
0.0265404414,
-0.023161618,
-0.0077689826,
0.024068661,
-0.0734311715,
0.0104267048,
0.0026444364,
-0.0060638199,
-0.017290568,
0.0022172132,
-0.0049286429,
-0.0202430394,
-0.0563710891,
0.0412249193,
-0.0078586293,
0.0056259627,
0.0043168324,
0.0306727625,
0.001215431,
0.001220249,
0.0041441415,
-0.0043764631,
0.0581522025,
-0.0627679527,
0.0048925737,
-0.0057558459,
0.0063271173,
-0.034302514,
0.0255006887,
0.0161554664,
0.0468165725,
-0.0420475565,
-0.0054556555,
0.0047321417,
0.0105552794,
-0.0241773408,
-0.0081653977,
-0.0295060426,
-0.0106558111,
0.0247520376,
0.0003511785,
-0.0009391414,
-0.0387291946,
2.43e-7,
-0.0444049649,
0.0201570541,
0.0514051095,
0.0331502855,
0.021540666,
0.0400376022,
0.0391831659,
0.0925254449,
-0.0265043508,
-0.0334581211,
0.0336833932,
0.0294070505,
0.0600858442,
0.0325534195,
-0.0998355821,
-0.0899632126,
-0.0652949512,
-0.0832266361,
0.0025343627,
-0.0183292013,
0.0171122961,
0.0665635988,
0.033631172,
-0.0035081424,
0.0129119018,
-0.0079563241,
0.037734285,
-0.0520733297,
-0.0098174242,
0.0379292294,
0.0552724786,
-0.0253080316,
0.0170741435,
0.0183431413,
-0.0007023692,
0.0243148059,
0.0153622329,
0.062214423,
-0.0106625073,
-0.047319226,
-0.0027859204,
-0.01500683,
0.0131168487,
-0.0355628319,
0.0147798155,
-0.0339186266,
-0.0080079054,
0.0054299957,
-0.0069486415,
-0.0090396944,
0.0101516377,
-0.0165974349,
-0.0108942511,
0.021913087,
0.0267534144,
-0.0142396055,
0.0426121168,
-0.0648577958,
0.0143069737,
-0.0053187865,
-0.0556842163,
-0.0750087574,
0.0168471951,
-0.0338180996,
0.0218370855,
0.0027649002,
0.0090507567,
1.51000836e-34,
0.0256596785,
0.0062521161,
-0.0086331954,
0.0059561152,
0.0492830686,
-0.007980491,
-0.0303126201,
-0.0023084488,
0.0669746548,
-0.0105515905,
0.0067281937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12008v2 | CHEAT: A Large-scale Dataset for Detecting ChatGPT-writtEn AbsTracts | 2023-04-24T11:19:33 | 2024-02-24T05:52:28 | Peipeng Yu, Jiahan Chen, Xuan Feng, Zhihua Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | The powerful ability of ChatGPT has caused widespread concern in the academic
community. Malicious users could synthesize dummy academic content through
ChatGPT, which is extremely harmful to academic rigor and originality. The need
to develop ChatGPT-written content detection algorithms call for large-scale
datasets. In this paper, we initially investigate the possible negative impact
of ChatGPT on academia,and present a large-scale CHatGPT-writtEn AbsTract
dataset (CHEAT) to support the development of detection algorithms. In
particular, the ChatGPT-written abstract dataset contains 35,304 synthetic
abstracts, with Generation, Polish, and Mix as prominent representatives. Based
on these data, we perform a thorough analysis of the existing text synthesis
detection algorithms. We show that ChatGPT-written abstracts are detectable,
while the detection difficulty increases with human involvement.Our dataset is
available in https://github.com/botianzhe/CHEAT. | [
0.0475650132,
0.0315733626,
-0.0044218134,
0.0541355871,
-0.0459492691,
-0.0310463067,
0.0261816308,
0.0295201167,
0.0348505899,
-0.0169790015,
-0.0109381014,
-0.0196860731,
-0.0058506858,
0.0592246987,
0.0607767366,
0.006575414,
0.0077549177,
0.0279139075,
0.005978351,
0.0005694154,
0.0322814286,
0.0234925523,
0.0377527624,
0.0410034321,
0.0342276283,
-0.0388992056,
-0.0054423828,
0.0046341764,
0.0240056664,
0.0072825192,
0.0078098145,
0.0656652525,
-0.038495779,
0.0993613675,
0.0000016671,
-0.0372257531,
-0.0317958556,
0.01863732,
0.0109359119,
0.0495036356,
0.0659155622,
0.0111735836,
-0.0422873758,
0.0358605608,
-0.0508237779,
-0.0042770337,
0.00028313,
0.0595982037,
0.0618528016,
0.1050361022,
-0.0297178868,
0.0123749888,
0.0528694168,
0.0092846593,
0.0268086009,
0.0279669631,
0.0173920821,
0.0066046701,
-0.0094088549,
0.0785687938,
0.0147114228,
0.0070691016,
-0.0296252444,
-0.0655848607,
-0.0130898822,
-0.0102589196,
-0.0777935013,
-0.0063905409,
0.0223856978,
0.0141286002,
-0.0445344932,
-0.0516260453,
0.080964826,
0.0026241278,
0.016704578,
0.0367829874,
-0.0092121493,
0.0280761253,
-0.051455196,
-0.0138389664,
0.0232917145,
-0.0049196742,
0.0148313856,
0.0204381142,
0.0380719826,
-0.0118679572,
0.0137729757,
-0.0581080727,
-0.0160843711,
-0.0292478073,
0.0050200508,
-0.0788407326,
0.0320897698,
0.002309287,
0.0266994424,
-0.0163034406,
-0.0512027852,
-0.1221078932,
0.0265146159,
-0.0534477048,
-0.0619524419,
0.031658683,
0.0380050577,
0.0122553054,
-0.0428687707,
0.0104085365,
-0.0102509139,
0.0350178443,
0.0160049833,
0.0305391252,
-0.0049593863,
0.0016677876,
-0.0410569198,
0.0208463985,
-0.0171785653,
0.0038520903,
-0.0593663268,
0.0305700935,
0.004670321,
0.0510801114,
-0.0136067523,
-0.0084295589,
-0.0383795202,
-0.0004237297,
0.0663109794,
-0.0192173366,
0.0351399705,
-0.0147052109,
-0.0037974284,
-0.035529092,
0.006688395,
0.0386887491,
0.0298573021,
0.0159414336,
0.0121758264,
0.0558504909,
0.0014554587,
0.0037495082,
0.0277268905,
-0.1126755327,
0.0079617836,
-0.0096661421,
0.0194915663,
-0.0587912053,
0.000025365,
-0.0104096308,
-0.0165441409,
-0.0187030919,
-0.0105673596,
0.0390130058,
-0.0272025466,
0.0092417421,
-0.0511766635,
-0.0097581046,
0.0217733048,
0.0318365097,
-0.0322473012,
-0.000341032,
-0.0083167786,
0.0602459535,
0.0601868145,
-0.0170975495,
0.0552518927,
0.0511459,
0.0462513305,
0.0251545198,
0.1062652469,
-0.0185658447,
0.018194994,
0.00468553,
-0.0036215207,
0.0623395443,
-0.0313312449,
-0.0409072302,
0.0312545486,
0.0445247255,
-0.0222382918,
0.0463503376,
0.0132161435,
0.0603592135,
0.0210099835,
0.0290870294,
0.0144821182,
-0.0253068767,
-0.0491306335,
-0.0156015344,
0.042047929,
-0.0066259168,
0.0255188178,
0.0201927908,
-0.0020538752,
-0.0037515394,
-0.0260462463,
-0.0550485514,
0.0030494325,
0.0396532975,
-0.039941743,
-0.0194876678,
0.0011966408,
-0.036905434,
0.0023879674,
-0.0570247024,
0.0282351505,
0.0351936035,
0.1109180301,
-0.0099594574,
0.029083401,
-0.0266402494,
0.0009744352,
0.057094764,
0.0088193519,
-0.0103863105,
-0.0206979103,
-0.021694595,
-0.023601573,
-0.0163807571,
-0.0023681677,
-0.0088214474,
0.0530996509,
0.0290958118,
0.0227211565,
-0.0144477384,
-0.0708491206,
0.0125698401,
-0.0305255335,
-0.0129434159,
-0.0067723203,
-0.014038017,
0.0381811,
0.0205478668,
-0.0294956733,
0.0387849659,
0.0102217961,
-0.0086715659,
-0.025323974,
0.0121480338,
0.0255166758,
-0.0074969586,
0.0210188609,
-0.1050575897,
-0.0305289663,
0.0254164189,
-0.0213618074,
0.0030227271,
0.0489475131,
-0.0238613449,
0.0348742902,
-0.0317677073,
-0.0121213468,
-0.0075079207,
0.0226076823,
0.0098536313,
0.0197107084,
-0.0146226957,
0.053826049,
0.0462190211,
-0.008463853,
0.0529387183,
-0.006339279,
-0.0165865477,
-0.0297205038,
-0.0438399576,
-0.0158487856,
0.0263213757,
0.0225912649,
-0.0216557328,
-0.020097062,
-0.0462735854,
-0.0087109143,
-0.0081981085,
0.044753328,
0.0671552122,
-0.0127232727,
-0.0044706129,
0.0215175766,
-0.0283088982,
-0.0343196169,
0.0054348498,
-0.0181745458,
0.0298846532,
-0.0192944035,
0.0210193265,
-0.0157964993,
0.0004189409,
-0.0241521727,
0.024915196,
0.0524061918,
-0.0446740612,
-0.0495361648,
0.0508477241,
0.0288532805,
-0.0214042496,
-0.01479189,
-0.0277396869,
-0.0285234507,
-0.0265569128,
0.0034538929,
0.0321805738,
0.0344424732,
0.0001937304,
0.026563013,
0.0259866994,
-0.0110201919,
-0.0389757715,
-0.0334838703,
0.0296377297,
0.0177629199,
-0.0752141401,
0.0638652518,
0.0037558689,
0.0227293521,
-0.0232486352,
-0.0225033034,
0.0168592483,
-0.0234122165,
-0.0060256645,
0.0020868019,
-0.0503163114,
-0.0323031768,
-0.0229758639,
0.0015529019,
-0.0259124618,
0.0072714617,
-0.0489542149,
0.0028045287,
-0.0674317703,
0.0054236581,
-0.0180028453,
0.0222882126,
-0.0198965576,
0.0235123783,
0.0319989882,
-0.003804419,
-0.0370870493,
0.0103020482,
0.0698596612,
-0.0226569213,
-0.0413353927,
0.0102685867,
0.0144652994,
-0.034798339,
0.0116190426,
-0.0155347949,
-0.055570025,
0.0350548215,
-0.0109616006,
0.0760164633,
-0.0430352055,
-0.0059361816,
-0.0094935475,
0.0120898681,
0.0397172831,
-0.0158737041,
-0.0352400094,
-0.0136970282,
0.0525704212,
0.0293272194,
-0.0826042742,
-0.0044085034,
-0.0334249288,
-0.0071569798,
0.0959986448,
-0.0183412042,
-0.0030259916,
0.0188248567,
-0.0869454145,
-0.0168865286,
-0.0095209014,
0.0125279063,
-0.0072780028,
0.0057459688,
-0.0289236531,
-0.0098488471,
0.0756728202,
0.0083302148,
-0.0367908217,
-0.0212416239,
-0.0242854171,
0.0265751127,
-0.0194202811,
0.0048295809,
-0.1170160845,
0.0182781816,
0.0129191997,
0.0399648063,
-0.0616132654,
-0.0202170685,
-0.0059691337,
-0.0649241358,
0.0522598363,
0.0242211949,
-0.0648774728,
-0.0086331703,
-0.0124795912,
-0.050077036,
0.0179771297,
-0.0243422668,
-0.0350800343,
-0.0068215523,
0.0155620174,
0.0155485692,
-0.1012349948,
-0.0220106356,
-0.0223320443,
-0.0277989469,
0.0173624288,
0.0017176542,
0.0414361618,
-0.01667968,
-0.0169215128,
0.0628047138,
-0.0065162573,
-0.0643959939,
-0.0052606571,
0.0740893036,
-0.0064369971,
-0.0054938807,
-0.0062645273,
0.0711418316,
-0.01906785,
-0.0244628526,
0.0314066857,
0.0714629889,
-0.0253305845,
-0.0387485363,
-0.0430913456,
0.0176370721,
0.043159496,
0.0587728135,
0.014445045,
-0.0187032279,
-0.0392722376,
-0.0404277109,
0.0217465032,
-0.0550929271,
-0.0554252453,
-0.0587712154,
-0.0497961193,
-0.0237459317,
-0.0854370743,
-0.0161779989,
-0.0150027378,
-0.0052750711,
0.0279058889,
0.0128969261,
-0.0036163689,
-0.021836441,
-0.0647495016,
-0.0357075669,
-0.0296076797,
0.012832473,
-0.016653074,
-0.0361665785,
-0.0080615385,
-0.0174245723,
-0.0047649546,
0.0340971537,
-0.0218279008,
-0.0448391624,
0.020892214,
0.0018901762,
0.0237533692,
0.0255832281,
-0.01892123,
0.0033334133,
0.072272785,
0.053728655,
0.0172574129,
0.0107822865,
0.0368862003,
-0.0259771198,
-0.0040596467,
-0.0036816625,
-0.033972092,
-0.0082939556,
0.0174493641,
-0.051313106,
-0.0194368176,
0.0460304022,
0.0223203897,
0.0526209846,
0.0031324334,
-0.0280836597,
0.0442891233,
-0.0374862701,
-0.0023070518,
-0.0524227247,
-0.013984195,
-0.0117034633,
0.0200420786,
0.0159884691,
-0.0049490742,
0.01854668,
0.0631487444,
-0.0366514884,
0.0064838477,
0.0062415875,
0.0047186213,
-0.0380299389,
0.0696116239,
0.0543695576,
-0.0232254602,
-0.0063957656,
0.0095225144,
-0.0257463362,
0.0408620499,
0.0079403659,
-0.0121815652,
0.0423394553,
-0.0120518841,
0.050171461,
0.0409565009,
-0.0858801678,
-0.0094451578,
-0.051035367,
0.0415173545,
0.0228364524,
0.0243577417,
0.0627463013,
-0.0685234368,
-0.0098911235,
-0.0287445411,
0.0492589734,
-0.0086124148,
-0.0461035259,
-0.0537381098,
-0.0232939161,
-0.0347214714,
0.0133342519,
0.0929960012,
-0.0324323773,
0.024117494,
0.0240743663,
-0.0544883497,
-0.0208959933,
-0.0180622898,
-0.0065408666,
-0.0041008336,
-0.0046070148,
-0.0299922731,
-0.048357375,
-0.0360495783,
-0.0155756287,
0.0418935455,
0.0138691291,
0.035123419,
-0.0080527421,
0.0321776383,
0.00101315,
0.0208108872,
-0.0461427644,
0.0785413235,
-0.031972982,
-0.051712811,
0.0003598832,
-4.875977383e-33,
0.0431025587,
-0.0470621102,
-0.0297567137,
0.0787996054,
0.0013346347,
0.0056342264,
-0.0489645749,
-0.0129867941,
0.0056055658,
0.0256843306,
-0.0292114932,
0.0366022363,
-0.0089110788,
0.0109721683,
0.0041157664,
0.0151210111,
0.0312249977,
-0.0041890657,
-0.0281675216,
0.0594581664,
0.0845919177,
-0.0084355297,
0.0389908887,
-0.0698027462,
0.0189762395,
-0.0579594113,
-0.0408344977,
-0.0297215693,
-0.0277853012,
0.0364411436,
-0.0122355921,
-0.009209522,
0.0205957219,
0.0222565457,
-0.016578557,
0.0104564205,
0.0060330098,
-0.0210544784,
0.0010286963,
0.0228881426,
-0.0185436103,
-0.0743722543,
0.0723576248,
-0.0317971185,
-0.0315540396,
-0.0050761462,
0.0349715948,
-0.0004006681,
-0.0164932385,
-0.0848785862,
-0.0423978902,
0.0296971798,
-0.0236569233,
0.0398342423,
-0.0233583059,
0.0201151222,
0.0360490978,
-0.0426344872,
-0.0218589455,
0.039608296,
0.0259481259,
0.0262117106,
-0.0126513224,
-0.0476079285,
0.0082181618,
0.0492471829,
0.0129640913,
0.0298403781,
0.0441818312,
0.022272151,
-0.0064890557,
0.0136924842,
0.0799074546,
0.0873524174,
0.0595206469,
-0.0342664421,
-0.0227799751,
0.0637203902,
-0.0067986143,
0.0050306637,
0.0291663893,
-0.0307430271,
-0.0139760906,
-0.0303554926,
0.0422053635,
-0.0169566069,
-0.0018674945,
-0.0250791963,
0.0084994491,
-0.0112522217,
-0.0320010707,
-0.0356508419,
-0.0145205893,
-0.0796726495,
0.0101319058,
0.0102185262,
-0.0714952424,
-0.0056402124,
-0.0026246328,
-0.0093419831,
-0.0255260188,
-0.0214675516,
0.0349078067,
-0.0184833147,
0.0275607258,
-0.0043124161,
0.0586211123,
0.0250311233,
-0.0492467582,
-0.0065842038,
-0.0111988746,
0.0505207628,
0.002207112,
0.0038317298,
-0.0015840124,
-0.0136563014,
0.0216072164,
-0.0547986031,
0.0290049575,
0.0622096211,
-0.0393621847,
0.0434094332,
-0.0109173488,
0.0165912062,
-0.0235493071,
0.0165413246,
-0.0149539318,
-0.0025291957,
0.0543105192,
-0.0653849766,
-0.0009525906,
-0.05564861,
2.415e-7,
0.0371391252,
0.0218205098,
0.0344456993,
-0.0104860393,
0.0313957892,
0.0194194335,
-0.0162719581,
0.0664836913,
-0.0340755023,
0.0204789154,
0.0054539116,
-0.0568849817,
0.04090368,
0.0228442475,
-0.1246040091,
0.0314701796,
-0.0703250244,
-0.0522770025,
-0.0696502551,
0.0238857921,
0.0432301722,
0.0351339579,
0.0015119771,
-0.0207991265,
0.0120818438,
-0.0283437446,
0.0219708625,
0.0251340624,
0.0035498324,
0.02648017,
0.0556416437,
-0.0092102122,
0.0317707509,
-0.0195879079,
-0.0561003722,
-0.0232892539,
-0.0073213615,
0.0193036329,
0.0407824032,
0.0296926498,
0.0134626403,
-0.0763479695,
0.021296503,
-0.0183755402,
0.0462468974,
0.0173918996,
-0.0005623293,
-0.0482556745,
-0.0623033941,
-0.0462601073,
0.018815672,
-0.0056726211,
-0.0125188241,
0.0235958155,
-0.016079966,
0.0203042291,
0.0245397054,
-0.0389244594,
0.0044237752,
-0.0227530319,
-0.0307404175,
-0.0540212356,
-0.0060171364,
0.0103938887,
0.0332820714,
-0.0347100012,
0.0128481695,
2.496820944e-34,
0.0510408096,
-0.0297531616,
-0.001355914,
0.004996601,
-0.0047909622,
-0.0256762952,
0.0482430644,
0.036654368,
-0.0067006154,
-0.0039207335,
-0.0059358366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12940v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12940v2 | Topological properties and organizing principles of semantic networks | 2023-04-24T11:12:21 | 2023-08-17T14:51:25 | Gabriel Budel, Ying Jin, Piet Van Mieghem, Maksim Kitsak | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | Interpreting natural language is an increasingly important task in computer
algorithms due to the growing availability of unstructured textual data.
Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications rely on semantic networks for
structured knowledge representation. The fundamental properties of semantic
networks must be taken into account when designing NLP algorithms, yet they
remain to be structurally investigated. We study the properties of semantic
networks from ConceptNet, defined by 7 semantic relations from 11 different
languages. We find that semantic networks have universal basic properties: they
are sparse, highly clustered, and many exhibit power-law degree distributions.
Our findings show that the majority of the considered networks are scale-free.
Some networks exhibit language-specific properties determined by grammatical
rules, for example networks from highly inflected languages, such as e.g.
Latin, German, French and Spanish, show peaks in the degree distribution that
deviate from a power law. We find that depending on the semantic relation type
and the language, the link formation in semantic networks is guided by
different principles. In some networks the connections are similarity-based,
while in others the connections are more complementarity-based. Finally, we
demonstrate how knowledge of similarity and complementarity in semantic
networks can improve NLP algorithms in missing link inference. | [
0.0087089017,
-0.0271084253,
-0.047859367,
0.0619437844,
-0.0438499898,
-0.005720634,
-0.0293304473,
0.0239716321,
-0.0070226197,
-0.0036730769,
0.0179313384,
-0.0065337955,
0.0169043466,
-0.0315007381,
0.0165750701,
-0.0205070749,
0.022031514,
0.0180045143,
-0.034379188,
0.0026818328,
-0.0117251333,
0.009319813,
-0.0283267647,
-0.0184199829,
-0.0295224749,
0.0472001955,
-0.0088824164,
-0.0101167057,
0.0140307723,
-0.0419438407,
-0.0234307665,
0.0301702954,
-0.0306353886,
0.0325772539,
0.000001862,
-0.0494514257,
-0.0034325256,
-0.0240252931,
0.0269683022,
-0.027644543,
0.0079160593,
-0.0113907885,
0.0253147576,
-0.0148558179,
-0.0148107903,
-0.0342761874,
0.0819567069,
0.0598961823,
-0.0410431363,
0.0486366525,
-0.0327736847,
-0.066088818,
0.021585267,
-0.0052615018,
0.0136892702,
0.0178315118,
0.0068339235,
0.0480001718,
-0.0199375059,
-0.0382958874,
-0.0073960093,
0.0024208631,
-0.0075478656,
0.01429307,
0.0196313374,
0.0441290624,
-0.027194418,
-0.0412588716,
0.0503234901,
0.0443980657,
0.0124485279,
0.0142899146,
0.0135138314,
0.0010266409,
-0.0182752628,
0.0984575376,
-0.0261349585,
0.0148803284,
-0.0119955065,
0.0359281301,
0.0351391472,
0.0267594047,
0.0559383109,
-0.0202291943,
-0.0520905145,
0.0707366168,
0.0077496436,
-0.0056153354,
-0.0202297326,
-0.0119632063,
-0.0431437679,
-0.0133716697,
0.0049063996,
-0.0042816196,
0.0205030944,
0.0400668494,
0.0381586514,
0.0136951944,
0.0263691694,
-0.0694937333,
-0.0159522332,
-0.0187587589,
0.0225280672,
0.0196816716,
-0.0759716108,
-0.0031812731,
0.0111807911,
-0.0119028948,
-0.0438231267,
-0.0377337709,
-0.0551316999,
-0.0060327351,
-0.0080989152,
0.0423265733,
-0.015537722,
-0.0007351881,
-0.0394596606,
0.040263027,
-0.0271170791,
0.0034869472,
-0.0280649401,
0.0072768931,
0.0084042056,
0.0105323745,
-0.0565645769,
0.0206236504,
-0.0120875891,
0.0221517067,
-0.03712143,
-0.0204456672,
0.0201347452,
-0.0021159227,
0.0207520183,
-0.0384853557,
-0.0011544442,
0.0755142942,
0.0570080914,
-0.0035130342,
-0.0713003427,
-0.0531473868,
0.0255558956,
-0.0272579882,
0.0127600515,
-0.0816270486,
-0.0069863857,
0.0586362518,
-0.0156081235,
-0.0434648767,
0.0208867528,
-0.0006746586,
-0.0789545625,
0.0206600241,
-0.0575204752,
0.0193012767,
-0.0084814383,
-0.0182872731,
0.0355775319,
-0.0041947155,
-0.0174158439,
-0.0103465905,
0.0599072166,
-0.0230919141,
-0.0663059652,
-0.020147521,
0.0236284547,
-0.0079864711,
-0.0140562244,
-0.0424240381,
0.0166823752,
-0.0003255004,
-0.0352120772,
0.0450296812,
-0.0427445956,
-0.0389603488,
-0.0060753166,
0.0653254092,
0.0158131421,
0.0411846042,
-0.016790105,
-0.0604732409,
-0.009537288,
0.0075247604,
-0.0447286852,
-0.0121483412,
-0.0410222597,
-0.0145353386,
-0.0467033982,
-0.0008142862,
-0.0038708933,
-0.0234068763,
-0.0043493952,
-0.0002109853,
0.0522259101,
-0.0622932538,
0.0818030313,
0.0044186441,
0.013045853,
0.0213110428,
0.0520301908,
-0.0239578225,
-0.0006621782,
0.0523897856,
-0.0232466422,
0.0590181015,
0.0058212145,
-0.0224458035,
-0.0153577914,
0.044528842,
-0.0415591598,
-0.0096844193,
-0.0341168158,
-0.010165222,
-0.0363547094,
-0.0586798713,
0.0094953999,
0.0405461043,
0.0019809876,
0.0296553075,
-0.0296425894,
0.0317868888,
0.0165952872,
-0.048448205,
-0.0119894538,
0.0045818747,
0.0007525763,
0.0621788688,
0.0156191364,
0.0123155834,
0.0235842671,
0.0681522116,
-0.001281673,
-0.0130002871,
0.0468269736,
-0.0609818958,
-0.0407650433,
0.0199725907,
-0.0283825882,
-0.0030057493,
0.0372441188,
-0.0506199971,
0.0131551269,
0.0100615136,
0.0112245167,
-0.0304927211,
0.0887846276,
-0.0099334931,
0.0767088011,
-0.0337984636,
0.0089699505,
0.0105051119,
0.0053336136,
-0.0169902965,
0.0842683166,
-0.004974986,
0.0808647126,
-0.0165530406,
-0.021620404,
0.0550488234,
-0.0023310811,
0.0012034236,
-0.0042080968,
-0.0066686654,
-0.0338560231,
0.0422793627,
-0.0412552468,
0.0201686379,
0.0145682292,
-0.0241367538,
0.0000870452,
0.0040852935,
0.0410210676,
0.0227938164,
0.04733539,
0.0284001045,
-0.0366200283,
-0.0082326122,
0.082694523,
0.0161482841,
-0.0115544805,
0.0535628982,
-0.0076024267,
-0.0578942932,
-0.0023903188,
-0.0671021715,
-0.014603856,
0.0560088418,
0.0215478186,
-0.0706789494,
0.0253910217,
0.1074811667,
-0.0745919049,
0.0305133983,
-0.0461733378,
-0.0037964669,
-0.0255506579,
-0.0007703074,
-0.0037177915,
-0.0206622574,
-0.0227774307,
0.0001706799,
0.0444474965,
0.0173944253,
-0.0014555253,
-0.013709465,
-0.0770094544,
0.0629876852,
-0.0532692,
-0.0151517484,
0.0033180532,
0.0004950513,
0.0376165956,
-0.0331030563,
0.0116309598,
-0.02391476,
-0.0199491773,
0.0482392609,
-0.0250687953,
0.0055089216,
0.0414442644,
0.0283864308,
0.0033357129,
-0.0172085203,
0.0158060119,
0.0084642731,
0.0447065234,
-0.0103430124,
-0.0476012826,
-0.014146667,
0.0675476938,
0.0738777593,
0.0535927452,
0.0055536334,
-0.0447448529,
-0.0566864833,
-0.0075821741,
0.0715424195,
0.0105618369,
-0.0013788443,
-0.0286083277,
0.0130616706,
-0.0095232865,
0.0026221778,
-0.0313773081,
0.0312922411,
-0.0160429589,
0.0020085636,
0.058324229,
-0.0471391268,
0.0324841067,
0.0040086806,
0.0005911738,
-0.0076772766,
0.0440059118,
-0.0183778722,
0.0029033534,
0.0574853867,
0.0185627732,
-0.0244018957,
0.0516437367,
0.0234569181,
-0.0330345891,
0.0246048495,
-0.0468202643,
-0.0349028111,
-0.0029951916,
0.0043151313,
-0.0174038745,
-0.0276741907,
-0.042905733,
-0.0140801836,
-0.0409789123,
0.0042214342,
0.0265646055,
0.0730979368,
0.051542148,
-0.0194959678,
0.0439760275,
0.0099695604,
0.0057202545,
0.0561728626,
-0.0364134833,
-0.0615164824,
0.0210875832,
-0.0274968334,
-0.0462696999,
-0.0287939347,
-0.066740267,
0.0347109698,
-0.0867663696,
-0.0078015584,
-0.0231015906,
-0.0577378981,
-0.0521754771,
-0.0889808163,
-0.0049229409,
-0.0483318269,
-0.044739686,
-0.0280705281,
0.0125709902,
0.0042339046,
0.0201606546,
-0.0033730795,
-0.021634208,
-0.0100408839,
-0.0316775404,
0.0619401261,
-0.014172934,
0.0386444442,
-0.0711895972,
-0.0175037645,
0.0472373106,
-0.051594574,
0.0160466358,
-0.0286560394,
0.0255662762,
0.0509919748,
0.0031629205,
-0.0623325631,
0.0032799833,
-0.0564790703,
0.0007227767,
0.0005111087,
0.0786873698,
-0.019029351,
-0.0235522371,
-0.0060406458,
-0.0420539454,
-0.0374019071,
0.027502453,
-0.0278662145,
0.0431804843,
-0.0186386406,
0.0168432407,
0.0333512686,
0.0186822955,
-0.0265943073,
0.0150342202,
-0.0049214778,
-0.0468672402,
-0.0302832257,
0.0092169186,
-0.0058371481,
0.0061701867,
-0.0081275217,
0.0202939864,
0.0553703122,
-0.0366360508,
-0.073719725,
-0.0274528489,
0.0455662794,
0.013765933,
0.049158901,
0.0077143987,
0.0187128112,
-0.012129074,
-0.0355578773,
-0.076259315,
-0.002746834,
-0.0362170376,
0.0044464911,
-0.0219088402,
0.01097738,
0.0392574407,
-0.0166394953,
-0.0124876034,
0.0019068274,
0.0932709277,
-0.0848522633,
0.0126443757,
-0.0107656233,
-0.0378638729,
0.0255605411,
0.0582782291,
-0.0200348273,
0.0345770493,
-0.0097095789,
0.0420288071,
-0.0380771123,
-0.031029474,
0.0260124914,
0.0449987687,
0.0435581878,
0.0375583284,
0.0052470537,
-0.0577192791,
0.0235879719,
-0.0303189009,
-0.0160829294,
0.0073834485,
0.0077655599,
0.0077667781,
0.0232062712,
-0.0191336162,
-0.071424745,
0.0114270942,
0.0043281796,
0.0415828861,
0.0156980064,
0.0873384997,
-0.0005470463,
0.0389225967,
0.0233863369,
0.0143593596,
0.0010244345,
-0.0110009154,
0.0020392935,
-0.0323319361,
-0.0197317488,
0.0253771096,
-0.0261322688,
-0.0774928629,
0.0006783592,
-0.0214617476,
0.0373777561,
0.0187738054,
-0.0057221712,
0.0499781296,
-0.0136827733,
-0.0104478123,
-0.070301868,
0.0179436132,
-0.0128613738,
0.0133143822,
0.0074211243,
-0.0015726764,
0.0181311686,
0.0139896283,
-0.0042752186,
0.0675026104,
0.0725737736,
-0.0576851591,
0.0511074923,
-0.0017044124,
-0.0344802514,
0.0067206635,
0.0079736412,
0.0055137239,
0.0603550151,
-0.0030051048,
0.0529760458,
-0.0463421717,
-0.0808564201,
-0.000673411,
-0.0044831675,
0.0442472696,
0.0032158287,
0.0452007949,
0.0284393393,
0.0413582325,
0.0297213849,
0.0000909593,
0.0075673261,
-0.0709172189,
-0.0230568629,
-0.023158472,
-6.253303012e-33,
0.0255353656,
-0.0855707899,
-0.0154991206,
0.0615339577,
-0.0003397165,
-0.0009915649,
-0.0221735127,
0.0248962957,
-0.0573166981,
0.0545751713,
0.0239737537,
0.0116621936,
0.0028322979,
-0.0125748822,
-0.0087635936,
0.0283701159,
-0.0097263977,
0.0422510095,
0.0442988127,
0.0104576591,
0.0624614321,
-0.0147087285,
0.0451968983,
-0.1283463538,
-0.0046576946,
-0.0352545492,
0.0404302813,
0.0547520593,
0.0419863462,
0.0535654724,
0.005334592,
0.0630207434,
0.031973619,
-0.0431318395,
0.0130302971,
-0.0625861138,
-0.0807984397,
-0.0951170996,
0.0152053107,
-0.0027824261,
0.0130735021,
-0.0290932748,
0.0469486751,
-0.0347781442,
0.0022379404,
0.0013757362,
0.0811826661,
0.0146612246,
-0.0485397279,
-0.0088407015,
-0.0096609509,
0.0468813442,
-0.0079187388,
0.0426745266,
-0.0116524696,
-0.0410963669,
-0.0396005809,
-0.0589186847,
-0.0201672968,
0.001426929,
-0.037079297,
0.0284074675,
-0.0108720837,
0.0222600382,
0.0032085376,
0.0585392863,
0.0492753163,
0.0124449264,
0.0053487746,
0.0477754995,
-0.0039155385,
0.0451521017,
-0.0010946731,
0.043857161,
0.0162065104,
-0.0062142862,
-0.1199649498,
0.0002269657,
-0.0216109399,
-0.0012669897,
0.0028893754,
-0.0025793049,
-0.0192946922,
-0.0249416512,
-0.0017467029,
-0.0445503369,
-0.0229204036,
-0.0466346443,
-0.0300321523,
-0.0529833995,
0.0101315565,
0.0106490804,
-0.0225440674,
-0.0566270351,
-0.0273982864,
0.0407836698,
0.0148020154,
0.0236784052,
0.0003553627,
-0.0195254143,
-0.0342286229,
-0.0445957258,
-0.0421676375,
0.0262835752,
0.0224925037,
0.0122028468,
0.035218142,
-0.0066059665,
0.0204735473,
-0.0385172591,
0.0226693116,
-0.0610391982,
-0.0292563252,
-0.0147633767,
0.0112928497,
0.0276973173,
-0.0160606671,
-0.0050980207,
0.0595571883,
0.0159975309,
0.0087852236,
-0.0120393597,
0.002351176,
-0.0352713875,
-0.0316915475,
-0.0445995964,
-0.0357492827,
0.0243070424,
0.0540076494,
-0.0139042344,
-0.0378108621,
-0.0159111228,
2.934e-7,
0.0544626191,
0.0107961446,
0.0467264168,
0.0394122899,
0.0182210207,
-0.0067262044,
0.0243896488,
0.031510476,
-0.0332394205,
-0.0070119775,
0.0135982856,
0.0065689604,
-0.0755641386,
0.0533384494,
-0.0606448948,
0.0394584127,
-0.0148752974,
-0.0684949979,
-0.0111338077,
0.0182428285,
0.0327940322,
0.0483137518,
0.0194379948,
0.0134107694,
-0.0185814314,
-0.0084870076,
-0.0261540227,
-0.0214059763,
0.0235814732,
-0.0300638024,
-0.0145713137,
-0.0265801214,
0.0263403729,
0.0549125858,
0.0220476203,
0.037003167,
0.0132573573,
-0.0311316289,
-0.0407202877,
0.0453008786,
0.0190374386,
-0.0785129443,
0.0138002057,
-0.0027719804,
0.0372566842,
-0.0021416461,
-0.0299448967,
0.0771774277,
-0.011447412,
0.036340192,
0.0254056584,
0.0673678741,
-0.0247368924,
0.0195077583,
0.016775785,
-0.0044774995,
-0.0127654765,
-0.0235532392,
0.0073627187,
0.0727998167,
0.0325804465,
-0.0589870661,
0.0306763183,
0.0081417719,
0.0494741164,
0.0160458125,
0.0238762945,
2.32089949e-34,
0.0113191241,
0.0069474992,
-0.0098055582,
-0.0105961403,
0.0094649624,
-0.063301973,
-0.0384696499,
0.0188999586,
0.0070300801,
-0.085015662,
-0.018904807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11960v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11960v2 | ThreatCrawl: A BERT-based Focused Crawler for the Cybersecurity Domain | 2023-04-24T09:53:33 | 2023-04-26T13:25:45 | Philipp Kuehn, Mike Schmidt, Markus Bayer, Christian Reuter | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Publicly available information contains valuable information for Cyber Threat
Intelligence (CTI). This can be used to prevent attacks that have already taken
place on other systems. Ideally, only the initial attack succeeds and all
subsequent ones are detected and stopped. But while there are different
standards to exchange this information, a lot of it is shared in articles or
blog posts in non-standardized ways. Manually scanning through multiple online
portals and news pages to discover new threats and extracting them is a
time-consuming task. To automize parts of this scanning process, multiple
papers propose extractors that use Natural Language Processing (NLP) to extract
Indicators of Compromise (IOCs) from documents. However, while this already
solves the problem of extracting the information out of documents, the search
for these documents is rarely considered. In this paper, a new focused crawler
is proposed called ThreatCrawl, which uses Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT)-based models to classify documents and
adapt its crawling path dynamically. While ThreatCrawl has difficulties to
classify the specific type of Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) named in texts,
e.g., IOC content, it can successfully find relevant documents and modify its
path accordingly. It yields harvest rates of up to 52%, which are, to the best
of our knowledge, better than the current state of the art. | [
0.0551286489,
0.021393232,
-0.006323447,
0.0204183534,
-0.0724867955,
-0.0278849434,
-0.0075647919,
0.0117596108,
0.013837615,
-0.0735895336,
-0.0034453652,
0.0306024943,
-0.0572489314,
0.0451923683,
-0.0083677461,
-0.0139860017,
0.0351796038,
-0.0027858026,
0.0372620411,
0.0258265566,
0.0074081905,
0.0132511305,
-0.0107566779,
0.0271105096,
0.0231349096,
0.0149949379,
-0.0376814865,
-0.0200071968,
0.045949921,
-0.0331344903,
0.0132565759,
0.0120398449,
0.0344425291,
0.0232539773,
0.0000018652,
-0.0424303301,
-0.0870852917,
-0.0095840013,
-0.0081067001,
-0.0302678607,
0.0177353788,
-0.0414067805,
-0.0113210334,
0.0200712923,
-0.0116294287,
0.0188992862,
0.00611438,
0.0828576609,
0.0709361807,
0.1352308989,
-0.018037606,
-0.0287979823,
0.0407828391,
0.0255470593,
-0.0392692648,
-0.0132115036,
0.0400982872,
-0.0431256145,
-0.0052404297,
0.0431061126,
0.0309735872,
-0.005631302,
-0.023266241,
0.0080743916,
-0.006007235,
0.0327877887,
-0.0335832089,
-0.000092419,
-0.014964656,
0.0059133382,
-0.0304283202,
0.0122548575,
0.0041315318,
-0.010487142,
0.0149738826,
0.0492408462,
-0.0033852765,
0.0243886895,
-0.0340031236,
-0.0074405097,
0.0339040272,
0.0179594699,
-0.0091079837,
0.0065302174,
-0.039432466,
0.0490190089,
-0.0121738166,
-0.0563017987,
0.0058056628,
-0.0760709494,
0.0485531203,
-0.0196965896,
0.0536905229,
0.0281952377,
0.041613061,
0.0039414205,
-0.0354270563,
-0.0911159292,
0.0443198197,
-0.0468441434,
-0.0316608287,
-0.0008428299,
-0.0191779733,
0.0225550421,
0.0195973124,
0.0239033829,
-0.0078634089,
0.0080082528,
-0.0027278538,
-0.0186009891,
-0.0404459387,
-0.0513277277,
-0.0422581211,
0.0724311098,
0.0375985131,
-0.0070238765,
0.0011796922,
0.0320212916,
-0.0412395932,
0.0095595093,
0.0106727127,
-0.0103694685,
-0.020077277,
0.024975175,
0.0214531422,
0.0035911358,
-0.0167218819,
0.0076110074,
-0.058092393,
-0.0215514302,
-0.0055158404,
0.0234419741,
0.0400219113,
-0.0507434979,
-0.0078153368,
0.0745299831,
0.0372092687,
-0.0478421114,
-0.0367656723,
-0.035576839,
0.0149494903,
0.0450491905,
0.0020880022,
-0.0287867524,
-0.0179799944,
0.0074774805,
-0.0050516254,
-0.0186172929,
-0.0192106497,
0.0074373153,
-0.042305395,
0.0267544687,
-0.0198300611,
-0.0210374743,
0.0244184062,
-0.0295882113,
0.0191043895,
0.0165967438,
0.0189506318,
0.0845955983,
0.0340005085,
-0.0149204005,
0.0436177365,
0.0343933888,
0.0052343546,
-0.0289071947,
0.06461972,
0.0190332048,
-0.0055979905,
-0.0346880034,
-0.0033434555,
0.0368351936,
-0.0049351575,
-0.0130835939,
0.0091430042,
0.0431160927,
-0.0030852952,
0.0288880151,
0.0040334864,
0.064979054,
-0.0064553884,
-0.0010227968,
0.0099148173,
-0.0053831427,
-0.0799103305,
-0.0485846885,
-0.0445298254,
0.0362502635,
0.0037714168,
0.0124277174,
-0.0472088791,
-0.0081494087,
0.0151033718,
-0.0456571281,
0.06662824,
0.031290099,
-0.0348767564,
0.0088401791,
-0.0033687528,
0.0014157855,
0.0176805146,
-0.0604722686,
-0.0251400173,
0.0498957075,
0.0557963699,
-0.065629527,
-0.0604915097,
-0.0331270956,
-0.0560250245,
0.0263613332,
-0.0291180089,
-0.010366668,
-0.0465927906,
-0.0397647582,
-0.0344891176,
-0.0181486774,
0.0089776274,
0.0053781099,
-0.0074517084,
0.0202088822,
0.0036755467,
-0.0225870647,
-0.0212480277,
0.0384419225,
0.0327407345,
-0.0123798857,
-0.032238964,
0.0243854374,
0.0633457601,
-0.0004327252,
-0.0202746633,
0.0273124091,
0.0637482405,
-0.0180868171,
-0.0805282965,
-0.0065029133,
0.0662843436,
0.0585310273,
0.0149007197,
-0.0625634119,
0.0524942316,
0.0693278611,
-0.0279492717,
0.0175524689,
0.0467459746,
-0.0747328028,
-0.0052514141,
-0.0134317381,
-0.0102098035,
-0.0167569406,
0.0169611964,
-0.0236910973,
0.0667928606,
-0.0010121228,
-0.0227266811,
-0.0009347289,
-0.0466559902,
-0.0021531959,
0.0038799269,
-0.0001959861,
0.0133668482,
-0.043177668,
0.0064380625,
0.055662211,
-0.0039901622,
0.0090046208,
-0.0505391657,
-0.0482976884,
0.0100828791,
-0.0141532999,
0.0511105545,
0.0395939313,
-0.0185945891,
-0.0256534498,
0.0020193972,
-0.005130948,
-0.0239116903,
-0.0120880753,
-0.0144406985,
0.0390856303,
-0.0203616191,
-0.0212304574,
0.0132086929,
-0.0128559452,
-0.0272315852,
0.0299747419,
0.0238927044,
-0.0649145767,
-0.0260625575,
0.0132548669,
-0.0188176278,
-0.0076781819,
-0.0219434481,
-0.0488555767,
-0.0184551794,
-0.0534428731,
-0.0082302028,
-0.0127159217,
0.0609985404,
0.0971079841,
0.0296361167,
-0.0086965738,
-0.0425513871,
0.0037592072,
-0.0513387658,
0.0121906567,
-0.0383748226,
-0.0204080604,
0.1092267632,
0.008425015,
0.0467251502,
0.0068656062,
-0.0101328874,
-0.0328826047,
-0.0077542462,
-0.0041902321,
-0.0144009171,
-0.0933587775,
-0.0006331407,
0.0004989912,
0.0266719647,
-0.0164452773,
0.0847624466,
0.0058340924,
0.0611284114,
-0.0856754109,
-0.0228269342,
-0.0368597396,
0.0514484085,
-0.0041142865,
0.0211542789,
0.0296169631,
-0.0409092307,
0.0264180209,
-0.0064886399,
0.0361315198,
-0.0298139285,
-0.0248959102,
0.0338154323,
0.0180915352,
0.0086658038,
0.0007058171,
-0.0534307361,
-0.0436463803,
-0.0164659303,
0.0137859089,
0.0228047874,
-0.0465481877,
-0.0592930466,
0.0190969352,
0.067800723,
0.0233146455,
-0.0049521457,
-0.0176649429,
0.0025195009,
0.0416948348,
0.0043310793,
-0.061016269,
0.0097790258,
0.020252103,
-0.0236627515,
0.0559809506,
0.0188785978,
-0.0172417499,
-0.0378460512,
0.0086660963,
0.0222086385,
-0.0748989284,
0.0068854792,
-0.0150938686,
-0.0247754045,
-0.0460054949,
-0.0038733399,
0.0926800817,
0.0502122156,
0.0061349608,
-0.0152133098,
-0.0487731956,
-0.0525811911,
-0.0154363457,
0.0103220493,
-0.0244327877,
-0.0021410575,
0.0186504349,
0.063895978,
-0.0344163515,
-0.04594649,
0.0201912206,
-0.0470288694,
0.0165988468,
-0.0197892748,
-0.0106186625,
-0.0464093499,
-0.1056874022,
-0.004633517,
0.0041256417,
-0.0450137481,
0.0070880717,
0.0013274831,
0.0122842677,
0.0155949024,
-0.0647385046,
-0.0212600734,
-0.014823636,
-0.0168805644,
-0.0273856372,
0.0579765588,
0.0451167412,
-0.0584942922,
-0.0013226564,
0.0342838839,
-0.0566376932,
-0.0197883304,
-0.0164027531,
0.0817473307,
-0.0260848235,
0.017204253,
-0.025951134,
0.0256796721,
-0.0138504161,
-0.0315647423,
0.0285479482,
0.0819176137,
-0.0643068478,
-0.0213717427,
-0.0428948104,
-0.0430832729,
-0.0044068084,
0.0610462464,
-0.0188966971,
-0.0177994203,
0.0111259706,
-0.0108723575,
0.0221964773,
0.0041589784,
-0.0131861558,
0.0257810354,
-0.0390071198,
-0.0861827731,
-0.0652616769,
-0.0345050283,
0.0048582815,
0.0080569535,
0.0227002632,
-0.0791723058,
0.0530580543,
0.0129393451,
-0.080697298,
-0.0225044638,
0.0180392116,
0.0292851049,
-0.018910924,
0.0091117918,
0.0372042246,
0.0094715524,
-0.0442884602,
0.0237030573,
-0.0201870184,
-0.0438714512,
-0.0106398603,
0.0094290683,
0.0184491873,
-0.0191164371,
-0.0502877459,
-0.0280634854,
0.0738835111,
0.044298254,
-0.0342489146,
-0.0387540162,
0.0594274104,
-0.0435171798,
0.0088180108,
0.0160035174,
-0.043153584,
0.0112078367,
-0.0207981877,
-0.0179110188,
-0.0479743741,
-0.0129533056,
0.0328913964,
0.0566396751,
0.0418175608,
0.0163987614,
-0.0033896968,
-0.0348267145,
0.007254512,
-0.0003577529,
-0.0143404165,
0.0327148326,
0.0475555845,
0.0078979461,
-0.0331578404,
0.0125324391,
0.1156220436,
-0.0264927968,
-0.0335759521,
-0.0550464541,
0.0313892663,
0.0528020412,
0.0637206137,
0.0208877381,
-0.0227348078,
-0.0100913607,
-0.0061671482,
0.0112651456,
0.0142070893,
-0.0095716855,
0.0100015476,
0.0107212309,
-0.0032115804,
0.0139173372,
0.0275439527,
-0.091411978,
0.0043725115,
-0.0236172266,
0.0166221615,
0.0213211607,
0.04919561,
0.0356272943,
-0.040659219,
0.0070914305,
0.0013237814,
0.030852709,
0.0109465094,
-0.0350395292,
0.0287594236,
0.0135642532,
-0.0342176817,
0.0064798873,
0.0547045246,
-0.0805534348,
0.0525811799,
-0.003083803,
-0.0686043128,
-0.0394501463,
-0.0081345169,
0.0187453497,
0.0433488302,
-0.0196804293,
0.0087670684,
-0.0179038886,
0.0065990905,
0.0776377469,
-0.0180323459,
0.0235975068,
-0.0028957985,
0.0299817063,
0.0590916276,
-0.0089438418,
0.0093117198,
-0.0582588166,
0.0511428937,
-0.0410904214,
-0.0238332842,
-0.0036118666,
-5.739740918e-33,
0.0132191908,
-0.0337031856,
-0.015715275,
0.0369191542,
0.0104619674,
0.0367371328,
0.0070499247,
-0.0375542603,
-0.0230510086,
-0.0198179726,
0.0077699004,
0.0036668647,
-0.0065432936,
0.0090273554,
-0.0207535289,
-0.0054119565,
0.0082871737,
0.0121392496,
-0.0144070806,
0.0226118583,
0.127478987,
0.0321988724,
0.0710479021,
-0.0739088058,
0.0274070296,
-0.0100920172,
-0.0228249431,
0.0044592111,
0.0572607778,
0.0137636093,
-0.0274805911,
0.0163060483,
0.0262533389,
-0.0231127013,
0.0344217718,
0.010794498,
-0.0251886323,
-0.0307711903,
-0.0345978327,
0.0126552796,
0.0316275991,
-0.0298488475,
0.0378196463,
0.0026288154,
0.0079714833,
0.0467946231,
0.0487705953,
-0.004500228,
0.0103879608,
-0.0761357173,
-0.0343312249,
0.0229903348,
-0.0549325347,
0.0214065183,
0.0026698336,
0.0597940944,
0.0542293154,
0.0067778626,
-0.0424432382,
0.0030077114,
0.0118184229,
0.0115609737,
0.0356215164,
-0.0166552737,
-0.0219761003,
0.059235055,
-0.0486322828,
-0.0682161599,
0.0185849071,
0.0113463253,
0.0008262823,
0.044801075,
0.0236669406,
0.0079561789,
-0.0022584307,
-0.0196562894,
-0.0541756228,
0.0621664599,
0.057496585,
0.0435716435,
0.0472443327,
0.0002599841,
-0.0363543145,
0.0384595171,
0.0537428558,
-0.0306137167,
-0.0116453068,
-0.0135293333,
-0.0197255034,
-0.022035649,
-0.0413728915,
0.0051363776,
-0.0128869042,
0.0037052524,
0.0197071116,
0.0745667145,
-0.0354540534,
0.0164670292,
-0.0258475896,
0.0076902378,
0.0106938714,
-0.0367058478,
0.0341613926,
-0.0229047928,
-0.0091911266,
0.0020448635,
0.0247086696,
0.0278781839,
-0.045223251,
-0.0038441843,
-0.0007783666,
0.045042567,
0.0028388223,
0.0558459274,
0.0120522026,
0.0309336148,
0.0002260417,
-0.0234292112,
0.0598821379,
0.0161102097,
-0.0208485685,
0.0568224937,
-0.028266089,
-0.0112373577,
0.0033797668,
0.0127093969,
-0.0141397873,
0.067471385,
-0.0429924801,
-0.0805762485,
-0.0073844045,
0.0081507144,
2.765e-7,
0.0527824573,
0.0348236971,
0.039992772,
0.0356356725,
-0.007339051,
0.0395961553,
0.0186078567,
0.0652573779,
0.0016548724,
-0.0262988973,
-0.0210036542,
0.0079747429,
-0.0271501001,
0.061740499,
-0.0518895648,
-0.0201362725,
-0.0308125783,
-0.043998573,
-0.0786363184,
0.0364787914,
0.09007705,
0.044938188,
0.028061714,
-0.0047317701,
-0.0593655892,
-0.0458254516,
-0.0287262481,
0.02789272,
-0.0077680275,
0.0099609112,
0.0457635671,
0.0423653498,
-0.007541771,
0.0368535891,
-0.0215547886,
0.0367386304,
-0.0292366277,
-0.0053184368,
0.0170638449,
-0.0226826593,
-0.0141803045,
-0.0595746487,
-0.010960428,
-0.0146008534,
0.0670520738,
-0.013009591,
-0.0288652461,
0.0079011545,
-0.0505387411,
0.0067110984,
-0.0229682103,
-0.0568847731,
-0.0200672261,
0.0430596732,
-0.0208622627,
-0.0367924385,
0.0154182287,
-0.0588163957,
0.0458517522,
-0.0282404367,
-0.0444995202,
-0.0187848639,
0.0069381977,
0.0145954778,
0.0472576283,
-0.009278533,
0.0412837379,
2.474306095e-34,
0.0259262696,
-0.0004918988,
-0.0582792796,
0.0206467398,
0.009018762,
0.0224478077,
-0.0062289722,
0.0240529571,
-0.0137971034,
-0.0697961226,
-0.0279538874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11957v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11957v4 | Benchmarking ChatGPT-4 on ACR Radiation Oncology In-Training (TXIT) Exam and Red Journal Gray Zone Cases: Potentials and Challenges for AI-Assisted Medical Education and Decision Making in Radiation Oncology | 2023-04-24T09:50:39 | 2023-08-21T09:20:48 | Yixing Huang, Ahmed Gomaa, Sabine Semrau, Marlen Haderlein, Sebastian Lettmaier, Thomas Weissmann, Johanna Grigo, Hassen Ben Tkhayat, Benjamin Frey, Udo S. Gaipl, Luitpold V. Distel, Andreas Maier, Rainer Fietkau, Christoph Bert, Florian Putz | physics.med-ph | physics.med-ph, cs.CL | The potential of large language models in medicine for education and decision
making purposes has been demonstrated as they achieve decent scores on medical
exams such as the United States Medical Licensing Exam (USMLE) and the MedQA
exam. In this work, we evaluate the performance of ChatGPT-4 in the specialized
field of radiation oncology using the 38th American College of Radiology (ACR)
radiation oncology in-training (TXIT) exam and the 2022 Red Journal Gray Zone
cases. For the TXIT exam, ChatGPT-3.5 and ChatGPT-4 have achieved the scores of
63.65% and 74.57%, respectively, highlighting the advantage of the latest
ChatGPT-4 model. Based on the TXIT exam, ChatGPT-4's strong and weak areas in
radiation oncology are identified to some extent. Specifically, ChatGPT-4
demonstrates better knowledge of statistics, CNS & eye, pediatrics, biology,
and physics than knowledge of bone & soft tissue and gynecology, as per the ACR
knowledge domain. Regarding clinical care paths, ChatGPT-4 performs better in
diagnosis, prognosis, and toxicity than brachytherapy and dosimetry. It lacks
proficiency in in-depth details of clinical trials. For the Gray Zone cases,
ChatGPT-4 is able to suggest a personalized treatment approach to each case
with high correctness and comprehensiveness. Importantly, it provides novel
treatment aspects for many cases, which are not suggested by any human experts.
Both evaluations demonstrate the potential of ChatGPT-4 in medical education
for the general public and cancer patients, as well as the potential to aid
clinical decision-making, while acknowledging its limitations in certain
domains. Because of the risk of hallucination, facts provided by ChatGPT always
need to be verified. | [
0.0453606658,
0.0100086275,
-0.0194412582,
-0.047488194,
-0.0250160098,
0.0418779477,
0.0415104479,
0.0339280181,
0.0353746936,
0.0138468146,
0.0071544298,
-0.0468381271,
-0.0182247441,
0.0359327495,
-0.0054099765,
-0.0524836443,
0.0151985995,
-0.0140747856,
0.0440135226,
-0.0004059222,
-0.0006627042,
0.0022775731,
-0.0542023852,
0.0437020101,
0.0086481087,
0.0155488634,
0.057951659,
-0.0449470989,
-0.007273878,
-0.0690540448,
0.0162085816,
-0.0250374079,
-0.0242501497,
0.0525886752,
0.0000024682,
-0.0706002563,
-0.035289336,
0.047099635,
-0.0064154817,
-0.0284877457,
0.0733695328,
-0.0064458023,
-0.0137074161,
0.035050597,
-0.0188930836,
0.0220867395,
0.0127387838,
0.0324537829,
0.0092971018,
0.0766341463,
-0.0071547516,
0.0165564176,
0.0805472434,
0.0035760498,
-0.0104032196,
-0.034303017,
-0.0082698045,
0.0434958786,
0.0064147664,
0.0087250117,
0.0027381463,
0.0623420849,
0.0266389009,
-0.0012686228,
-0.011044072,
0.0748852193,
-0.013553747,
0.018736558,
-0.0173974317,
-0.0131669389,
0.0227320585,
-0.0104696956,
0.0141426167,
-0.0069814767,
0.0201567262,
-0.0127594182,
-0.0446313582,
-0.0058991686,
-0.0195329338,
-0.0310952812,
-0.0177106224,
0.0090339063,
-0.0306542329,
0.0008082747,
0.0028824587,
0.0117439758,
0.0120796561,
-0.0106369518,
0.0513353571,
0.0235437136,
0.0150445765,
-0.0165271033,
0.0153352581,
0.0544395484,
-0.0629381686,
0.0172085594,
0.0138897859,
0.03431217,
0.078417547,
-0.0792197585,
-0.038213551,
0.0199871957,
-0.0000570754,
0.0323358215,
-0.0288128629,
0.0568657778,
0.0024295079,
0.0667593107,
-0.0581425689,
0.0410610363,
-0.0537863187,
0.0001360525,
-0.0333128497,
-0.0056310412,
0.0452713072,
-0.0006831384,
-0.0831115544,
-0.044902727,
-0.0117160771,
0.0104191042,
0.0666023791,
0.0373189338,
-0.0395931453,
0.0371183716,
-0.0402568728,
0.0024086877,
0.0117223207,
-0.0296816397,
-0.0094219679,
0.0024099674,
0.0421427377,
-0.001103579,
-0.0436152853,
-0.017346615,
-0.0152350804,
0.0502109304,
-0.014661327,
0.0134076951,
0.0798983127,
-0.035476733,
-0.030496126,
-0.0758847743,
0.0453943051,
-0.0470740907,
-0.0086309453,
0.0085245725,
0.0225463901,
-0.008067633,
0.0206598137,
-0.0161146466,
0.0053551565,
0.0278256945,
-0.0225227047,
-0.0141021553,
0.0722678974,
0.0441947356,
-0.0283001252,
-0.017142918,
0.0202463325,
-0.0058009634,
-0.031744957,
-0.0523555949,
0.0000527788,
-0.0213434119,
0.0101642096,
-0.0092725074,
0.0120406589,
-0.0007199328,
-0.0282495338,
0.0841878355,
-0.046533972,
0.046838332,
-0.0145892659,
0.0036530346,
-0.0102908611,
0.0223438777,
0.0587606616,
0.0458582416,
-0.019247504,
-0.0238671042,
0.036639668,
-0.0123801744,
-0.0095827449,
0.0411962196,
-0.0337079167,
0.001528059,
-0.0274053924,
-0.000269003,
-0.016563978,
-0.0646952316,
-0.0227673352,
0.0206902437,
-0.0115355374,
-0.0014438861,
0.0503578857,
-0.0733547509,
-0.0122059826,
-0.0481870733,
0.0828313828,
0.0311748274,
-0.0593680255,
-0.0750478059,
-0.0839249492,
0.061700888,
0.0430714339,
-0.0426481217,
-0.0702266172,
-0.0351726785,
0.0171207804,
0.0002980685,
0.0414096192,
0.0188284758,
-0.0311907697,
-0.0050567081,
-0.024337206,
0.0106683942,
0.002542688,
0.0189950205,
-0.012047953,
0.0453902595,
-0.0430237688,
0.0143915927,
-0.0435909368,
0.0211654864,
-0.0560285263,
-0.0347109996,
-0.0374690741,
-0.0068453993,
0.0374440402,
0.0116712451,
-0.0008125023,
-0.0019492517,
0.0002517841,
0.0224052053,
-0.0527550615,
-0.000354316,
-0.0235041734,
-0.0125861699,
0.0238206536,
-0.0511287637,
-0.0152343828,
-0.0419995226,
-0.0221558604,
0.0097158505,
-0.0532405339,
-0.020691663,
0.0248362329,
0.0270729996,
0.0289129149,
0.0260675121,
-0.0105050607,
-0.0197800826,
0.0362676382,
0.0024328742,
-0.0201770756,
0.0046882886,
-0.0988719016,
0.039429266,
-0.0569783226,
-0.0441072062,
0.00631712,
-0.0160676334,
0.0274561755,
-0.0096588396,
0.0453385934,
-0.0299264099,
0.0160866585,
-0.0783566162,
-0.0208244883,
0.0267041549,
-0.008760062,
0.0267941207,
-0.0418295898,
-0.0009144904,
-0.0132268472,
-0.0576313362,
-0.005799666,
0.0275476202,
-0.0098036518,
0.033194121,
0.0414070673,
0.0099907136,
-0.0514556952,
-0.0268534105,
-0.0631550997,
-0.0068677026,
0.080243811,
-0.0070890984,
0.0316559486,
0.0729984269,
-0.0090503953,
0.0134397456,
-0.0101867206,
-0.0934288204,
0.0520108119,
-0.0287317261,
-0.0840215459,
0.0285149664,
0.0094608217,
0.0172779933,
0.0268694498,
0.0148310373,
-0.0249480996,
0.0059650168,
-0.0264891591,
-0.0721108988,
0.0523500666,
-0.0363768935,
-0.0363518707,
-0.0007253037,
0.0047328901,
0.0217138771,
-0.0267804023,
-0.0017071289,
-0.0539725684,
-0.0117998812,
-0.0666184276,
0.0675008073,
0.0010445296,
0.0018320201,
0.0124305608,
-0.0090514803,
0.1138922572,
0.0403184108,
0.0500197001,
-0.1227671281,
-0.0121604539,
-0.0080220057,
0.0037433871,
0.0061751218,
0.0263503734,
0.0083442619,
0.008063402,
-0.0312379915,
-0.0347667411,
0.0041101528,
-0.0308668669,
0.0139693879,
-0.0178958774,
0.007820148,
0.0156429075,
-0.0115698716,
-0.0520879105,
0.0023501117,
0.0455222465,
0.0111323148,
0.0134117147,
-0.0089827171,
-0.0560588688,
-0.02034311,
0.0039910232,
0.0452804603,
-0.0120099988,
-0.0138565963,
-0.0050122091,
0.009239967,
0.0408739075,
-0.0227125343,
0.0080409311,
-0.0080863601,
0.0431247689,
0.0668618083,
-0.0033743142,
-0.001693242,
-0.0385964438,
-0.0130464723,
-0.0102718109,
-0.0128421951,
0.0276471172,
0.0200267844,
0.0164403804,
-0.0352504067,
0.0171762221,
0.0922955722,
0.0046866345,
-0.0202160217,
-0.0138408169,
0.0043071848,
-0.0552227125,
-0.0420586318,
0.0422710739,
-0.049261678,
0.0330697447,
-0.0513679795,
0.0120099513,
-0.0343513004,
-0.0118808709,
0.0269214381,
-0.0041429102,
0.0332334265,
0.0070689721,
-0.0364209302,
0.0139262481,
-0.0024320022,
0.0009063537,
-0.0165139493,
-0.0202126,
-0.0062582903,
0.0143751176,
-0.0389671773,
0.0309503283,
-0.0576055832,
-0.0426813252,
0.0370080918,
-0.036927525,
0.0270304885,
0.0195870586,
0.041913379,
-0.0569122881,
0.0066207373,
-0.0290096328,
0.0663259029,
0.0225253645,
0.0115918387,
0.0800149366,
0.0290981513,
0.036120683,
-0.0633242205,
0.01975476,
0.0045078518,
0.0339443572,
0.0443223715,
0.0784144029,
-0.0582318753,
-0.0295529813,
-0.0348367728,
0.0105244061,
0.0204735603,
0.0117855323,
-0.0161099434,
0.0218136869,
-0.0263288468,
-0.0353350639,
0.0873833969,
0.0320057608,
0.0229513235,
0.0005628912,
-0.0244827792,
-0.071600087,
-0.0595879965,
-0.0130122229,
0.0201988295,
-0.022340294,
0.006569142,
0.0004432428,
-0.0087105464,
0.0081055285,
0.0046237446,
0.0413732529,
0.0393097959,
0.0082840687,
-0.0520785786,
-0.0854071006,
0.0291739497,
-0.0411739498,
-0.0311935619,
0.015655797,
0.0527660437,
0.0283994321,
-0.0306663383,
0.0631199032,
0.0245539788,
-0.0442900136,
-0.0282214787,
0.0011664953,
0.0721015781,
0.026813671,
-0.0314891264,
-0.0225056354,
-0.0193479788,
-0.0205371771,
-0.0054569202,
-0.0453218855,
0.0042982027,
0.0284222271,
-0.0267505813,
0.0029520106,
-0.0264161043,
0.0023233788,
0.0515548289,
0.0840041786,
0.0506702997,
-0.0032503752,
-0.0093479762,
-0.0018678553,
-0.0043598139,
-0.0440855101,
0.0117346933,
-0.0213053934,
-0.0470136888,
0.0492084995,
0.0293437224,
0.0083289091,
-0.0134335412,
-0.0326175615,
-0.0768767893,
-0.0720853806,
0.0494697392,
0.0622033402,
0.0390744843,
0.072416015,
-0.0077200816,
-0.0195950996,
-0.0642355084,
0.0014713395,
-0.0137274843,
-0.001433327,
0.035294883,
0.0117927557,
0.0149897831,
0.0274975337,
0.0444534309,
-0.0333283097,
-0.0542431809,
-0.0194509458,
0.0575872287,
0.0487949289,
0.0374109969,
-0.0176706277,
-0.0531069562,
0.0206075925,
-0.0191734787,
0.0178724378,
-0.0103957104,
0.0430865958,
0.0160218664,
0.0160467811,
0.0328518599,
-0.0298221726,
0.0665985793,
0.0156593248,
0.0461994708,
-0.0409051143,
-0.0560473166,
-0.0475688502,
-0.0247473195,
0.0115128253,
-0.0052825185,
-0.0150483986,
0.00963121,
-0.0333710276,
-0.0224409569,
-0.0066045597,
0.0304161496,
-0.0400842056,
-0.029064931,
0.0476562828,
0.0115639307,
-0.0032765579,
-0.0397557877,
-0.0211918596,
0.0282081459,
0.0110707823,
-0.001928676,
0.0000450447,
-6.253658599e-33,
0.0181250516,
-0.0004714591,
0.067791149,
0.0203055274,
0.0168132577,
0.0353913568,
-0.0352164954,
-0.01501959,
0.0139696822,
0.0121243931,
-0.0078312745,
-0.0006719511,
-0.0003835266,
0.0016149724,
0.0188350417,
-0.0386441872,
0.0033102229,
-0.034860462,
0.0075281872,
0.0116984742,
-0.0269686021,
0.0240306053,
0.0283707511,
-0.0667425469,
-0.0072783777,
0.0415851586,
-0.0089066895,
-0.0576977059,
-0.0761736929,
0.053777542,
0.0198281519,
0.0429631323,
0.0120341647,
-0.0043373317,
0.0088395337,
-0.0520919897,
-0.0439678058,
-0.0236282144,
-0.021129135,
-0.0015361526,
-0.0136388009,
-0.0038218484,
0.0564718693,
-0.0415234603,
-0.0265010335,
-0.0278678741,
0.0205024574,
-0.0077400925,
0.0002391102,
0.0034423855,
-0.0134465499,
0.0432912745,
-0.0183066819,
-0.0138908383,
-0.0400693603,
-0.0034177976,
-0.0377667807,
0.031807635,
-0.0465833992,
0.0169829577,
0.0501176603,
0.0158695113,
0.0228449963,
-0.0827027187,
0.0003893728,
0.0225053318,
0.0401504748,
-0.0240728743,
-0.0080630211,
-0.0333176889,
-0.0102066183,
0.0222356319,
0.0229408816,
0.0153613416,
0.0155000761,
-0.0472483709,
-0.1148506105,
0.0255130194,
-0.0021660929,
0.0786215141,
-0.0207748469,
-0.0112845562,
-0.1132633388,
-0.0118982419,
0.0412593,
-0.0146963475,
-0.0049076052,
-0.043006923,
0.0306678731,
-0.0306872725,
0.0202494785,
0.0302783363,
-0.0063651376,
-0.0214925576,
0.0631481186,
-0.0053911111,
0.035277009,
0.0450054072,
-0.0373113267,
0.0296166185,
-0.0436398648,
-0.0264577679,
0.0246454403,
-0.0451075695,
0.0551284179,
-0.00231667,
0.0251419172,
0.0131785804,
-0.0071610874,
0.0037669963,
-0.0164417811,
0.0026129854,
0.0206943024,
-0.0136724757,
0.0101825958,
0.023328362,
0.0170744564,
0.0386837013,
0.0039738757,
-0.0077531664,
-0.0470581204,
-0.0717812255,
-0.0231140014,
-0.0386338644,
-0.029888805,
0.0140725682,
-0.0103472779,
-0.0118732844,
0.0199456178,
-0.0311028529,
-0.0259922072,
0.025222009,
3.225e-7,
0.0590821616,
0.0812273696,
-0.0154679688,
-0.0389421955,
0.0021708934,
-0.0093852431,
-0.058867231,
-0.0133860707,
0.0466380715,
0.0265924335,
0.0777804703,
-0.0013069027,
0.0232634936,
0.012597573,
-0.0051385304,
-0.0862693414,
-0.0369529352,
-0.0409608223,
-0.0054993527,
0.0010911687,
0.0909401327,
-0.0135025568,
0.0193101261,
-0.043829862,
-0.0026051917,
0.0062170522,
0.0105841057,
-0.05233787,
0.0138257025,
0.0186347403,
0.0111062555,
0.0283325706,
0.0237732455,
0.0844282508,
0.0122379484,
-0.0449258164,
0.0414436795,
0.0772969872,
-0.0184412431,
0.0398087613,
0.0706120729,
0.0159690529,
0.0258253925,
-0.0634269491,
0.0401894264,
-0.02405053,
-0.0325694904,
-0.0166979767,
-0.02754803,
-0.0362303071,
0.0911924839,
-0.0185609236,
-0.0468792878,
-0.0200449824,
-0.0008961068,
0.0213337876,
-0.0365224555,
-0.0061248704,
0.0329958461,
0.0384755991,
-0.0229063034,
-0.0684168115,
0.0189605244,
-0.0152469818,
0.0468386561,
-0.0520419851,
0.0299091469,
2.682584867e-34,
0.0265056621,
0.0007164462,
0.0171974339,
-0.031054277,
0.0277673434,
0.0324026309,
0.0500644483,
-0.003069656,
0.0074588116,
-0.0254955553,
-0.0220546927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11943v1 | Constructing Tree-based Index for Efficient and Effective Dense Retrieval | 2023-04-24T09:25:39 | 2023-04-24T09:25:39 | Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Jingtao Zhan, Jiaxin Mao, Yiqun Liu, Zheng Liu, Zhao Cao | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that Dense Retrieval (DR) techniques can
significantly improve the performance of first-stage retrieval in IR systems.
Despite its empirical effectiveness, the application of DR is still limited. In
contrast to statistic retrieval models that rely on highly efficient inverted
index solutions, DR models build dense embeddings that are difficult to be
pre-processed with most existing search indexing systems. To avoid the
expensive cost of brute-force search, the Approximate Nearest Neighbor (ANN)
algorithm and corresponding indexes are widely applied to speed up the
inference process of DR models. Unfortunately, while ANN can improve the
efficiency of DR models, it usually comes with a significant price on retrieval
performance.
To solve this issue, we propose JTR, which stands for Joint optimization of
TRee-based index and query encoding. Specifically, we design a new unified
contrastive learning loss to train tree-based index and query encoder in an
end-to-end manner. The tree-based negative sampling strategy is applied to make
the tree have the maximum heap property, which supports the effectiveness of
beam search well. Moreover, we treat the cluster assignment as an optimization
problem to update the tree-based index that allows overlapped clustering. We
evaluate JTR on numerous popular retrieval benchmarks. Experimental results
show that JTR achieves better retrieval performance while retaining high system
efficiency compared with widely-adopted baselines. It provides a potential
solution to balance efficiency and effectiveness in neural retrieval system
designs. | [
0.0160165988,
0.0057828138,
0.001997581,
0.0295019411,
-0.0148951728,
0.00392952,
-0.0162761789,
0.0332359523,
0.0209057461,
0.0069538387,
-0.04552003,
-0.0321524031,
-0.039888002,
0.002750773,
-0.0121734506,
-0.0374696478,
0.0379462168,
0.0235661156,
0.0259330869,
-0.0066527203,
-0.0018064396,
-0.0053334972,
0.0235827956,
0.0156561714,
-0.0361388251,
0.0113967992,
-0.0615802482,
0.0624567196,
-0.0005978095,
-0.0698227957,
0.019297896,
-0.0061039478,
0.0587103479,
0.0196841955,
0.0000020004,
-0.0123097403,
-0.0457987934,
0.0082331123,
-0.0283894613,
-0.0025337744,
0.0696272328,
0.0135489376,
0.0558422543,
0.0055195317,
0.0023982632,
-0.0553044751,
0.0621833205,
0.0456483029,
0.0103777675,
0.0494356528,
-0.0189797059,
-0.0209667031,
0.0342957005,
-0.0128575964,
0.0117172701,
-0.0506762825,
0.0232971143,
-0.0124220774,
-0.0013544789,
0.0443901047,
0.0071706031,
0.0340832062,
0.0548735783,
0.0118880533,
0.0210888945,
0.0238669608,
-0.0636875331,
0.0239841752,
0.0084218727,
0.0191034637,
-0.0160199367,
-0.0137400916,
-0.0191741362,
0.0154399341,
-0.0350720957,
-0.0346373096,
-0.0362038501,
0.012707524,
-0.0017213236,
0.0101725319,
-0.0549461059,
0.0614971146,
0.0234524943,
0.0140890665,
-0.0329889879,
0.0046184002,
0.0279720239,
-0.0353053883,
0.0014448969,
-0.0046568345,
-0.0148899909,
0.0164732542,
0.0398250706,
-0.0028968723,
-0.014839448,
0.0022561746,
0.030808147,
-0.0263763648,
0.0037512868,
-0.0381450467,
-0.0048225001,
0.0532137714,
-0.0225543659,
0.0574245937,
-0.0126598012,
0.0577863194,
0.0011666489,
-0.0031191427,
-0.0534467883,
-0.0677928105,
-0.0356941335,
-0.0500031412,
-0.0580236763,
0.0666395798,
-0.021595329,
-0.0308584049,
-0.0151394699,
0.0167980902,
0.0280042496,
-0.0519404896,
-0.0116058597,
0.0339788869,
-0.0698090345,
0.0102779875,
-0.0176407546,
0.0376487523,
-0.020476209,
-0.0131372781,
0.0082833609,
-0.0022224095,
-0.0164795872,
0.0423733816,
-0.004481202,
-0.0288434085,
0.0279833898,
0.0148824109,
-0.0276850909,
-0.0809799731,
0.005711759,
-0.0289817266,
-0.0149588147,
0.0126507897,
0.0465493873,
-0.0458603948,
0.0501484834,
-0.0096547855,
-0.0154787488,
-0.0173611436,
-0.0055854837,
0.0427095219,
-0.0091867857,
0.0394531675,
-0.0152469808,
-0.0136823971,
0.0383996554,
-0.0105361491,
0.0012112968,
0.0384114385,
-0.0012258455,
0.0661384687,
0.0251555536,
0.0245461632,
-0.0099367741,
-0.0007696028,
0.020476725,
-0.0198493917,
-0.0244475473,
0.0113425618,
-0.0627221987,
0.0315722749,
0.0191327408,
0.0373920575,
-0.0724979937,
-0.0374151953,
-0.0092060491,
0.0563443378,
0.0166966785,
-0.0028044099,
-0.0307868794,
0.0148728518,
-0.0535653643,
-0.0649527237,
-0.0027929863,
0.0575097166,
-0.0433249213,
-0.0230650138,
0.0453958698,
-0.0127993384,
-0.0639984682,
-0.0048613711,
-0.0086420206,
0.0383732058,
-0.0243328717,
0.0011126017,
0.0461845398,
-0.0307108704,
0.0134790912,
0.0355947316,
0.0168682132,
-0.0221226346,
-0.0115495119,
-0.034985356,
-0.0275877845,
0.0281519908,
0.0443012342,
-0.0452207103,
0.021327002,
0.0641203746,
-0.0133370357,
-0.0026403088,
0.0093392693,
-0.0123855397,
0.0196997467,
-0.0406165905,
-0.0650533587,
0.0264673252,
-0.0195322521,
0.038025517,
0.0113746403,
0.0069252038,
0.0289536398,
-0.056947615,
-0.0216869749,
-0.0021544339,
0.0033875043,
-0.0212528389,
0.0349800587,
0.0110627534,
0.0069237859,
0.0119438693,
-0.0056167613,
-0.0058918009,
0.0664572865,
-0.0050492845,
-0.0363132842,
-0.0413106419,
-0.0589077696,
-0.0492480919,
0.0035176892,
-0.0201824438,
0.0293071102,
0.0566274971,
-0.0151613336,
-0.0246787276,
-0.0080611594,
-0.0392391756,
0.0327046029,
-0.0490531661,
0.0041836374,
0.0045516123,
-0.0290756095,
-0.0527074188,
0.0647647679,
-0.0299586505,
0.0211217813,
-0.0222456604,
-0.0339316316,
0.0414577276,
-0.0846319199,
-0.0413022488,
0.0041919579,
-0.0344614498,
-0.0005890044,
0.0516939051,
-0.0026261033,
-0.0140662948,
0.0188913587,
-0.0804985538,
0.0266513191,
-0.0234815273,
-0.0387417488,
-0.0134708118,
0.030535467,
0.0325430371,
-0.054973945,
-0.0052083968,
-0.00128503,
-0.025377525,
0.0499032401,
-0.0042357449,
0.0213986225,
-0.0042206389,
-0.0334244184,
-0.0846717805,
0.00421461,
0.0383576937,
-0.0294347443,
-0.0753030628,
0.0037638205,
0.0319387689,
-0.0205323286,
-0.002139786,
-0.0168561842,
-0.0062552374,
0.0133198332,
-0.0734680519,
-0.0348023511,
0.0608809963,
0.0092787426,
-0.0078063509,
0.0026782095,
-0.0114723602,
-0.083632797,
0.0319858342,
-0.0428680852,
0.0020070388,
0.0503890477,
0.0042495336,
0.0134381717,
-0.0259655137,
-0.0180687215,
0.0308966264,
-0.0338485725,
-0.0144941937,
0.0373000279,
-0.0346828923,
-0.0815728307,
0.0093656285,
0.0161907226,
0.0078826919,
-0.0607158616,
-0.0336174294,
0.0319962837,
0.0054985434,
-0.0024384328,
-0.0040733488,
-0.0043457006,
-0.0221870821,
0.0638921633,
-0.0026053749,
0.0251037125,
-0.0201674737,
-0.0373657607,
-0.0181447919,
0.0408632345,
0.0029543347,
-0.0266901795,
0.0025416561,
0.0314258896,
0.0196605474,
-0.0065102605,
-0.0761284009,
-0.0164611973,
-0.0203266665,
0.0548479073,
0.0299842209,
0.0075163366,
-0.0004341399,
-0.0389542729,
0.0563410446,
0.023511162,
0.0394678302,
-0.017961815,
-0.0364082046,
0.0004952236,
0.0347074792,
-0.0073514124,
-0.0172074586,
0.0154557927,
0.0143851684,
0.0032630437,
0.0605320409,
0.0430694818,
-0.0329287872,
-0.0491459817,
0.0185531639,
0.0396875255,
0.0104796691,
-0.0273173209,
-0.0077258819,
0.0072482247,
-0.0299425889,
-0.0461691841,
0.0432124175,
0.0200645756,
-0.0972173437,
-0.0370911956,
-0.0390552506,
0.0509006605,
0.0320462435,
0.030353466,
-0.0080255559,
-0.019162856,
0.0117369369,
0.055302415,
0.0270211101,
-0.0149802808,
0.0291249417,
-0.0973707661,
0.0272105541,
0.0043755649,
-0.0017485127,
-0.0771291032,
-0.0093840985,
-0.0178282168,
0.0134470845,
0.0045160237,
0.0593295507,
0.0127723021,
-0.0272339303,
0.0301096551,
0.0179758929,
0.0012892741,
-0.0103756245,
-0.0546927378,
-0.0345184766,
0.0564326346,
0.0326397456,
0.0587309673,
-0.0152655682,
-0.0233362857,
-0.0367982611,
0.0341896228,
-0.0328754038,
0.0671636984,
-0.0136902416,
-0.0136220232,
-0.0284189414,
-0.028858345,
0.0066162352,
0.0022082585,
-0.0351491608,
0.0601448454,
-0.0332539231,
0.0489965715,
-0.0350631364,
-0.0763864368,
-0.0134108597,
0.0593197607,
-0.0360586904,
0.0711598843,
-0.0211298745,
-0.0012179668,
0.0441444032,
0.0141950054,
-0.0203709882,
0.0079108095,
-0.0275051221,
0.0118692722,
-0.0418338627,
-0.02747906,
-0.0246126,
0.0605143197,
-0.0468041524,
-0.022635255,
-0.0430081002,
-0.0162866022,
-0.0544405095,
0.0255139172,
-0.0462811813,
-0.030046761,
-0.0169154089,
0.0198664442,
0.0398098789,
-0.0267901272,
-0.0282856803,
-0.0203508884,
0.0269532446,
-0.0156742521,
-0.0086235683,
0.0316396952,
0.010820468,
0.0449445881,
-0.0121830096,
-0.0556549653,
0.0453689061,
0.0362740792,
-0.0499271974,
0.0088660847,
0.0256157424,
-0.0416297503,
-0.0239709578,
0.015834609,
-0.1035785154,
0.0364040695,
-0.0011890527,
0.0415337943,
-0.0498379469,
-0.0313429534,
0.0276111197,
0.0364975519,
0.0974028707,
0.0389936976,
-0.0091053313,
-0.0062117456,
0.0354207605,
-0.0427453034,
-0.0153677193,
-0.0115656434,
0.011174744,
0.0301497113,
0.0211694371,
-0.0118446667,
0.0671944991,
0.0572678074,
0.0043698796,
-0.0191808138,
-0.0494019948,
0.0288755614,
0.0264192559,
-0.0344655402,
0.0181088615,
-0.0400289036,
-0.0124057671,
0.0189713296,
0.0523689277,
-0.0282296538,
0.0156255495,
0.0293137021,
0.0004004041,
-0.0426719189,
0.0336549692,
-0.0656467304,
-0.0495088436,
-0.0401273631,
-0.0437300615,
0.05183677,
-0.0020130787,
-0.0250227582,
-0.0117206965,
0.0073814713,
-0.0249122381,
-0.0347488001,
0.0366608575,
-0.0602256693,
0.033498086,
0.0459086597,
0.0147832194,
0.022155365,
0.0278643742,
-0.0030392678,
0.0235226769,
-0.0470119976,
-0.0370498449,
0.0037207343,
-0.0104265865,
0.086110279,
0.0412988327,
0.0011901911,
-0.0369857661,
0.0058038631,
0.0050032665,
0.0464712121,
-0.0050381878,
-0.0088392887,
0.0001418501,
0.0918251649,
0.0356103927,
0.0189018752,
-0.0339654051,
0.0138799632,
-0.0409970358,
-0.0610978305,
0.0132089909,
-0.0114437426,
-6.341626719e-33,
-0.0278332196,
0.025741674,
0.027475113,
-0.0266798325,
-0.0381813087,
0.0130020157,
-0.0072231777,
-0.0226603616,
-0.02378566,
-0.0129214823,
0.000190476,
0.027847996,
0.0077362498,
0.0301218461,
0.0104113529,
-0.0002417217,
0.0601963252,
0.0042595495,
0.0141145587,
0.0122397179,
0.0550024249,
0.0461735614,
0.034668766,
-0.0616818219,
-0.0966678485,
0.0177794006,
0.0429346748,
0.0513381362,
0.0234820042,
0.0350684151,
-0.0268390402,
0.0293356646,
-0.0074246731,
-0.0476526171,
-0.0019178963,
-0.0186461713,
-0.0738087744,
-0.0570033193,
-0.0638831258,
-0.0064723077,
-0.0077235848,
0.0091875028,
0.0450624935,
-0.0125072366,
-0.0006329051,
0.004528014,
0.0090470156,
0.0138086965,
-0.039773047,
-0.049058497,
-0.0081371339,
0.024094427,
0.0390228629,
0.01048565,
0.0210114457,
0.0607884824,
0.026853675,
0.0442718193,
-0.0659187064,
-0.0176031962,
-0.0866575316,
0.0729183033,
-0.0211631265,
0.0365431085,
0.0191298332,
0.0700597987,
0.0765242577,
-0.0219016876,
0.0412636548,
-0.0116420109,
0.0256979372,
0.0264657009,
0.0629946366,
0.0684789419,
0.0676455498,
0.0227898918,
-0.0625787377,
0.0266502388,
-0.002785685,
0.0924942344,
0.0168790352,
0.0737264529,
-0.0774418935,
-0.0243685152,
-0.0018753948,
-0.033745151,
-0.0531619079,
-0.0354319066,
0.0632344708,
0.0613740496,
-0.0024015063,
0.0090630604,
0.0709823146,
0.0083190287,
0.024550017,
0.0537167788,
0.0113336854,
0.0209477972,
-0.009954785,
0.0185262579,
-0.0209324565,
-0.0335314274,
0.0459916145,
-0.017705176,
-0.0156931579,
-0.0117666367,
0.0019059766,
0.0351015404,
-0.0320005752,
-0.0338905789,
0.0140351709,
-0.0526842214,
-0.0101208072,
-0.0029929832,
0.0203279257,
0.0140298773,
0.0384446718,
0.0602535009,
0.0360818692,
0.0209472422,
-0.0415959209,
-0.0955776796,
0.0259156823,
-0.0326963142,
0.0255333353,
0.0532036312,
-0.0579607934,
-0.0101871304,
-0.0221504439,
-0.0649635941,
-0.0128891002,
0.087435469,
2.761e-7,
0.0432475992,
0.0101169329,
0.030616669,
0.015845241,
-0.0227925703,
0.0109258955,
0.0182999764,
0.0280213077,
0.0444084704,
0.0066081919,
0.0192208719,
0.0139368707,
0.0174400397,
0.0082116947,
-0.1087605506,
-0.0147411386,
-0.0359994359,
0.0068246559,
-0.0373142697,
-0.0337344967,
0.0578018017,
0.1094598025,
-0.0173589196,
-0.0024071138,
0.0125679718,
-0.0610856824,
0.0549975857,
0.0196347088,
0.0256930608,
-0.0307164695,
0.0309152398,
0.0092538595,
-0.0106238835,
-0.0028993906,
0.0132461125,
0.0324049443,
0.0288863685,
0.0075571262,
-0.0408507623,
-0.1036681756,
0.0292317308,
0.025122093,
-0.0077040354,
0.0040636896,
0.0724175945,
-0.0219008885,
0.0253469571,
0.0600745901,
-0.0352685377,
-0.0001486014,
-0.0317583233,
0.0137404911,
-0.0324436836,
0.0029863685,
-0.0020477886,
0.0091171367,
-0.0024701885,
-0.0923668146,
0.0287835114,
-0.0167088546,
-0.0305649284,
-0.0007691651,
-0.0565287098,
0.0376355685,
0.0004739828,
0.0222184528,
-0.0336666256,
2.501858351e-34,
0.0064801448,
0.0103429547,
0.0027552815,
0.0160840005,
-0.0007611352,
-0.0003930862,
-0.0429323949,
0.0347794592,
0.0198364276,
-0.0872390121,
-0.0254118927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12331v1 | USTEP: Structuration des logs en flux gr{â}ce {à} un arbre de recherche {é}volutif | 2023-04-24T09:12:00 | 2023-04-24T09:12:00 | Arthur Vervaet, Raja Chiky, Mar Callau-Zori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Logs record valuable system information at runtime. They are widely used by
data-driven approaches for development and monitoring purposes. Parsing log
messages to structure their format is a classic preliminary step for log-mining
tasks. As they appear upstream, parsing operations can become a processing time
bottleneck for downstream applications. The quality of parsing also has a
direct influence on their efficiency. Here, we propose USTEP, an online log
parsing method based on an evolving tree structure. Evaluation results on a
wide panel of datasets coming from different real-world systems demonstrate
USTEP superiority in terms of both effectiveness and robustness when compared
to other online methods. | [
0.0103872884,
0.0297540221,
-0.0096794656,
-0.0091416948,
-0.022255661,
-0.0213944949,
-0.0434722528,
0.00329879,
-0.0009377475,
-0.0536291935,
0.1047265455,
-0.0005387952,
-0.0499286763,
0.0753359273,
-0.0345499404,
-0.0500574112,
0.0412650891,
-0.0072580343,
-0.0030627116,
0.0466642305,
0.0126911942,
0.0162118692,
0.0031304848,
-0.0005647269,
0.0102291526,
-0.03248154,
-0.0096652079,
0.0514564961,
0.0052358583,
-0.033207573,
-0.0194818322,
-0.0599688515,
-0.0227169245,
-0.0015845463,
0.0000020775,
-0.0366177559,
-0.0444960333,
0.0134691019,
-0.064213343,
0.0105567491,
0.007194302,
-0.0242049806,
-0.0504055247,
0.0284902304,
-0.0280156992,
-0.0420654081,
0.0494890213,
-0.0081342123,
0.0457455069,
0.0072806855,
-0.0266598146,
-0.0233761556,
-0.005017045,
0.0279423296,
-0.0263116397,
0.0243509058,
0.0178863313,
0.0095181055,
0.0198349301,
-0.0352122784,
-0.0114351651,
-0.056042973,
0.0130971847,
-0.0159725584,
0.0361558869,
0.0149464989,
0.0064777005,
-0.0015463893,
-0.0037321311,
-0.0259909518,
-0.0298302416,
0.0055600354,
0.0719488859,
-0.0389203802,
-0.0367951244,
-0.0619808696,
0.0258474778,
0.0541224517,
-0.0434561484,
0.0122226188,
0.0530976392,
0.0130887199,
-0.0603338927,
-0.0467303842,
-0.0462965295,
0.0168277901,
-0.0250074975,
-0.0226686932,
0.0008743484,
0.0027146521,
0.0096838791,
-0.0122291259,
0.0095731039,
0.00011578,
-0.0180321094,
0.024962984,
0.0057625491,
0.0411161445,
-0.006472799,
-0.005744867,
-0.0298384167,
-0.0056366841,
-0.0100905951,
0.007825912,
0.0162991155,
-0.0006789624,
0.0367876925,
-0.0213889964,
0.0056568366,
-0.0147909382,
-0.0641604736,
-0.0348163918,
-0.0416185185,
0.0112688532,
-0.0171344429,
0.0336094201,
-0.0086195273,
0.0663168281,
0.0108188055,
0.0203329548,
0.0002887994,
-0.0683092773,
0.0334900282,
0.0730889067,
0.0131091578,
-0.0306865294,
-0.0056343591,
-0.0182071999,
-0.0159220118,
-0.0347238332,
0.0031018951,
0.0215310715,
0.0257573854,
-0.0044386238,
-0.0066427686,
0.0172262564,
0.0431116894,
0.0066297739,
-0.0336240716,
-0.0747395232,
0.0169637613,
0.0420628004,
-0.0351753086,
-0.0054607182,
-0.0148625653,
-0.0391381718,
0.019332448,
0.0459000282,
-0.0480035208,
-0.0606706552,
-0.0016250662,
-0.0481720343,
-0.0854159966,
0.0305646025,
-0.0296710692,
-0.0233419724,
0.0272957347,
0.036821913,
0.023252856,
0.0245968904,
0.0262224115,
-0.0569900237,
0.0098499926,
0.0152955735,
-0.0378590673,
-0.0749890357,
-0.0061684363,
0.0148925213,
-0.0940903574,
-0.0256208982,
0.0105596054,
-0.0187342111,
0.0191741697,
-0.0212358721,
-0.0129951667,
0.0133392895,
0.03382916,
0.0304731838,
0.0393768549,
0.0226627905,
-0.0446146205,
-0.0387578309,
0.0237267595,
-0.031120697,
0.0042011989,
-0.0270328205,
-0.0402623303,
0.0240306146,
0.0206244029,
-0.0419806205,
-0.013863707,
0.0497337021,
-0.0337466933,
-0.0008587122,
0.0129208006,
0.0067996224,
0.0193641149,
0.0224895328,
0.0352692269,
0.0440972894,
-0.0079815928,
-0.0093733603,
-0.0073020253,
0.0457873531,
0.0466995984,
-0.0537711084,
-0.0732217804,
-0.0085244169,
0.0269330572,
-0.0276362635,
-0.0207987707,
-0.0259697549,
0.0553289428,
0.043321602,
0.0111882994,
0.0565658435,
-0.0032763965,
0.0042881523,
-0.0690042451,
-0.0202071257,
-0.0206466839,
-0.0086068325,
-0.0665220469,
0.0254183095,
-0.004554031,
-0.0121727102,
0.0329421088,
0.0128604332,
-0.0164937638,
-0.0009439633,
-0.028940374,
-0.0159168337,
0.046920605,
-0.0084990589,
-0.0261060316,
0.0956294835,
-0.0046336139,
0.0383471847,
-0.0121859564,
0.0159225501,
-0.0044889003,
-0.0481627174,
-0.0814491361,
-0.0374160074,
0.0296811108,
-0.060193345,
0.0476953648,
0.0403274111,
-0.000048,
-0.0136095854,
-0.0301553737,
-0.041525729,
0.0146567496,
0.0439574085,
0.0076845731,
-0.0622621253,
-0.0301528908,
0.0242920294,
0.0007679017,
0.0206993259,
0.03626718,
-0.0846823603,
-0.0326430127,
0.0187302157,
-0.019516388,
-0.0275080614,
0.0129586579,
-0.0316838585,
-0.0121622123,
0.0142654078,
0.1012862399,
0.0550183132,
0.0576574467,
-0.0270226169,
-0.007715459,
0.0180271883,
-0.0003561881,
0.0184373818,
0.0131109366,
0.0499957725,
0.0338762477,
-0.0561466068,
0.0145676211,
-0.033908695,
-0.0672999024,
0.0375688784,
0.015461049,
-0.0267199855,
-0.0896342099,
0.0349093676,
-0.0093343398,
-0.001406599,
-0.0094583919,
-0.0011264798,
-0.0119408369,
-0.0357920155,
0.0583263151,
0.0761787668,
0.0438843556,
0.0286909789,
-0.0243324023,
-0.015570214,
0.0152629837,
-0.0100051463,
0.0084402226,
0.0427473113,
-0.0004082604,
-0.0150759909,
0.0917282254,
0.0499755107,
-0.0196500961,
-0.0319662876,
0.0091156624,
-0.0248134024,
0.0002112277,
0.0299930796,
0.0122552011,
-0.0392459966,
-0.0180276297,
0.0200481806,
0.0139618991,
-0.0100529585,
0.0805666223,
0.0505921543,
-0.0422181264,
-0.0382066146,
-0.0621656291,
-0.0291335694,
0.0704034865,
0.0260215309,
0.0295276027,
0.0383872315,
-0.0577535629,
0.066398032,
-0.0406929441,
0.0541704185,
-0.0061055506,
-0.0210763868,
-0.0374843143,
-0.0010032078,
-0.0055623087,
-0.0216419082,
0.0139679937,
-0.0672478303,
0.0167293418,
-0.0291011054,
-0.0489880107,
0.0205766577,
-0.0311571416,
0.0414983928,
-0.0032189419,
0.0285307076,
0.0686386749,
-0.0285909288,
0.0118318554,
-0.0261255316,
0.0005099261,
0.0173159428,
0.0375850499,
0.0129905557,
0.0552774332,
0.0562039949,
0.0299638584,
-0.0157307889,
-0.0213011708,
-0.0499695465,
-0.0228681192,
-0.0257921778,
0.0038993454,
0.0038500463,
-0.0118338251,
-0.0498583391,
-0.0387083516,
0.0287846755,
0.0009160569,
0.001919631,
0.035753306,
0.0081212064,
0.0328925513,
0.0038586487,
0.0362204164,
-0.0716297552,
-0.0089036012,
-0.0254306775,
0.0532359555,
-0.0139015988,
-0.0283152759,
0.0126448143,
-0.0215473957,
0.0067556049,
0.0004496877,
0.0106912404,
-0.0022210346,
-0.1135408878,
-0.0371983126,
-0.0399590954,
-0.0749498531,
0.0039930223,
-0.0198700167,
0.0053434782,
0.0292079244,
-0.1339803189,
-0.0303960443,
0.0335944928,
-0.0204639193,
0.0066046515,
0.0498833917,
-0.0019568845,
-0.0035533281,
0.0063283448,
0.1117185205,
-0.0251228958,
-0.0073897522,
-0.0324267335,
-0.0428168736,
0.0628925115,
-0.0118034268,
-0.0037044622,
-0.0008903361,
-0.0223104376,
-0.0033759091,
0.026084166,
0.0883216038,
-0.037659198,
0.0301711056,
-0.0076220869,
-0.0264289752,
0.0334533229,
0.0248352718,
-0.0050443592,
-0.0445510708,
-0.0395578891,
-0.0016725882,
0.0011469403,
0.0574701168,
-0.0004807569,
0.0498666205,
-0.0277570095,
-0.0206670277,
-0.0263033565,
0.0092809526,
-0.0216721501,
0.0441805534,
-0.0393847041,
-0.0310685467,
0.0419870429,
0.0151727023,
-0.0167382006,
0.0077174562,
-0.0011851003,
0.013876019,
-0.0279581454,
0.0356454626,
0.0368958116,
0.0485313758,
-0.0448596552,
0.0228783656,
-0.0641974211,
-0.0280779712,
0.0424002595,
-0.0229157843,
0.0132859405,
0.0081973467,
-0.0267275795,
-0.0136610642,
-0.064123556,
-0.005539868,
-0.0023602871,
-0.0191683285,
-0.0410280861,
0.0320748389,
0.0053190617,
-0.0569550879,
-0.0102960775,
0.0479133874,
-0.0251606721,
-0.0608527474,
-0.0251817387,
0.0188481454,
0.0096181221,
0.0549541637,
0.0291697979,
0.0743235275,
-0.0558689088,
0.0505408309,
0.0121198446,
-0.0227648988,
-0.0299589913,
-0.012309541,
0.0770309567,
-0.0159890559,
0.0086160628,
-0.0008105836,
0.0374996103,
-0.0063244416,
0.0137787517,
-0.0329816304,
0.0166693851,
0.0242202431,
0.0256781522,
-0.0097851949,
0.0089541534,
0.0171840601,
-0.0309999064,
0.0275757052,
0.0862318128,
-0.0041284664,
0.0106613887,
0.0273045804,
-0.0038495988,
-0.0166900046,
0.0004442318,
-0.0624277517,
0.0497233346,
0.0456874333,
-0.0587353818,
0.0309065357,
0.0290672705,
0.0650480688,
0.0099186394,
0.0531980842,
-0.0220662486,
0.0158307496,
-0.0128642824,
-0.0146788303,
0.0048680361,
-0.0021050356,
-0.0682699457,
-0.0314589068,
-0.0010321396,
0.0579740964,
0.0021131583,
-0.0022687544,
-0.0295082163,
-0.0352767482,
0.0056975721,
-0.0083450712,
0.0022405367,
-0.0209409371,
-0.0347847603,
-0.033446718,
0.0978450775,
0.012473858,
0.0114189917,
0.0269026961,
-0.0334312916,
0.0046563372,
0.0711663365,
0.0437454395,
0.0173777416,
-0.0080000702,
-0.0103518693,
0.0029027713,
-0.0010560411,
0.0145705882,
-5.842926547e-33,
0.0031869758,
-0.028875757,
-0.0391204804,
0.0242412239,
-0.0599655472,
-0.009694797,
-0.0378811955,
-0.0104014622,
0.0308330152,
-0.030844273,
0.0482213832,
0.0186296403,
0.0112894066,
-0.0398268066,
0.0500101,
-0.0059802784,
0.0189283788,
0.0478089564,
-0.0093358299,
0.0158207249,
0.0949712098,
-0.0034973477,
0.0140042379,
-0.0864141285,
0.0148808332,
-0.0110935289,
0.019045515,
0.0260842703,
0.047077585,
0.0219592284,
0.0446095988,
-0.0409718417,
0.0006774548,
-0.0149054118,
-0.0338371955,
-0.0840109959,
-0.0183245745,
0.0311035905,
-0.0035188859,
0.0116766375,
0.0094655687,
0.0347270817,
0.0534233898,
0.0199709833,
0.0518071465,
0.0313436799,
0.0153640872,
0.0109543037,
-0.0200090669,
-0.055191543,
0.0063523646,
0.0116155101,
-0.0491084196,
0.0444702953,
0.0204118155,
0.0466615446,
0.0569163598,
-0.0174687058,
-0.015892297,
0.0350523107,
-0.0453917794,
-0.0065713553,
-0.0202828553,
0.0041832752,
0.0458305851,
-0.0050805653,
-0.0089425249,
0.0252788272,
0.0086982958,
0.0647723973,
-0.0092428066,
0.0185871329,
-0.0271448623,
0.000323156,
0.0601089075,
-0.0443760715,
-0.0633245111,
0.0189091619,
0.0515219979,
-0.0020148768,
0.0124233961,
0.0268879738,
-0.0166960657,
0.0095110964,
0.0382401049,
0.0203446168,
0.0126442239,
0.0324499495,
-0.0031415978,
0.044260893,
-0.0291661806,
0.0197663698,
0.03677921,
-0.0219276436,
-0.0340400822,
-0.0026454465,
-0.0141892713,
-0.0121485349,
-0.0499003306,
-0.0093998285,
0.022791015,
-0.059361726,
0.0026782546,
0.0187294483,
0.0358871669,
-0.0361622088,
-0.0090378616,
0.0133600635,
-0.0436833836,
0.0364305675,
-0.0091734389,
0.0312975533,
-0.0891223177,
0.0164715648,
0.0879013389,
-0.0352631509,
0.0247163866,
0.0851588622,
0.0271962285,
-0.0451714881,
-0.0047392063,
0.0356277712,
0.0214286037,
0.0121925958,
-0.0210219268,
-0.0306685157,
0.0058220765,
-0.0572917089,
0.0211471841,
0.0076614777,
-0.0013480067,
0.0012068426,
2.865e-7,
0.00725216,
0.0382969342,
0.0657318532,
-0.0667285398,
0.0848712698,
0.0150216147,
0.0157205723,
-0.038405709,
-0.0352679715,
-0.00286331,
-0.0300011765,
-0.0637571514,
0.0583976135,
0.031095108,
-0.0312178172,
-0.025781149,
-0.0556610227,
-0.0284845326,
-0.0791886672,
0.0098647745,
0.1095575616,
0.0547271706,
0.013689287,
0.0079189008,
0.030036239,
-0.0342919827,
-0.0450687371,
0.031283129,
0.0369879007,
-0.0047873468,
-0.0002895861,
0.0312082563,
-0.0056089093,
-0.0409567542,
-0.0173365548,
-0.0036412508,
-0.0650184527,
0.0693365037,
0.0058120945,
0.0784615502,
0.021793291,
-0.0276199132,
-0.0013760661,
-0.0018899045,
0.0117010511,
-0.0072033638,
-0.0306285061,
-0.0649121329,
0.0214083456,
-0.0025665946,
-0.0527430214,
0.0065729748,
-0.0411836132,
0.0368048102,
-0.0124639729,
-0.0517483391,
0.0097790519,
-0.0697595179,
-0.0799206421,
0.0109077161,
-0.0227844752,
0.0292117503,
0.0018468495,
0.0900772735,
0.0776316822,
0.0239945613,
-0.0057909451,
2.802495163e-34,
0.0026849159,
0.0161920097,
-0.0124678835,
0.0195809919,
0.012667316,
0.0149281928,
-0.0202639159,
0.0220263358,
-0.0153437946,
-0.0122850435,
-0.0088003529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11924v1 | KInITVeraAI at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Simple yet Powerful Multilingual Fine-Tuning for Persuasion Techniques Detection | 2023-04-24T09:06:43 | 2023-04-24T09:06:43 | Timo Hromadka, Timotej Smolen, Tomas Remis, Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the best-performing solution to the SemEval 2023 Task 3
on the subtask 3 dedicated to persuasion techniques detection. Due to a high
multilingual character of the input data and a large number of 23 predicted
labels (causing a lack of labelled data for some language-label combinations),
we opted for fine-tuning pre-trained transformer-based language models.
Conducting multiple experiments, we find the best configuration, which consists
of large multilingual model (XLM-RoBERTa large) trained jointly on all input
data, with carefully calibrated confidence thresholds for seen and surprise
languages separately. Our final system performed the best on 6 out of 9
languages (including two surprise languages) and achieved highly competitive
results on the remaining three languages. | [
0.0491684414,
0.0572780333,
-0.015139807,
0.055558566,
-0.0144954193,
0.0214160401,
0.0335196145,
0.0293879658,
-0.0079230126,
-0.0293264221,
-0.087797828,
-0.0340826213,
0.0295155123,
0.0254269987,
0.0317975841,
-0.0139858751,
0.0168822799,
-0.0324825346,
0.0346141681,
-0.0180353802,
0.0095365345,
0.0066562751,
0.0173647478,
0.0597051121,
-0.012289892,
-0.0373944491,
0.0120688537,
-0.021242369,
0.0180816576,
-0.0402171686,
0.0534119494,
0.0741236731,
0.0037235464,
0.0608324558,
0.0000020234,
-0.0414750427,
-0.0138291894,
-0.0234199986,
-0.0306482837,
-0.0066306349,
0.0734777674,
-0.0477996245,
-0.0211497527,
0.0189240202,
-0.0452268086,
-0.007124865,
0.0599789098,
0.095122315,
0.0414389372,
0.0638220981,
-0.012819659,
-0.0360410772,
-0.0009922717,
-0.039772477,
-0.0368464701,
-0.0170831122,
0.0317353196,
-0.0765352473,
-0.0366228968,
0.0292840321,
-0.002454527,
0.0232940335,
-0.0223459173,
-0.0280346833,
-0.0923078284,
-0.0131787611,
-0.0198864061,
-0.0420293696,
-0.033741653,
0.0387345478,
-0.0359646045,
-0.0132433381,
-0.0092521971,
0.0007952171,
-0.0029424524,
0.0014828559,
0.0017303564,
0.02621671,
0.0114062233,
0.0048669619,
0.0135945361,
0.0119168581,
0.0133799929,
0.0165987089,
0.0128957797,
0.0444067866,
0.0036240485,
-0.0385290682,
0.0777316764,
0.0022004892,
-0.0004490647,
-0.0350698903,
0.009348128,
-0.0143200327,
-0.0508796684,
-0.0053475243,
0.0027235989,
-0.0622039326,
0.024727812,
-0.0871172473,
0.0130026154,
0.0223031919,
-0.0198723804,
0.0187377427,
-0.0190586466,
0.0489975847,
-0.0319968536,
0.011727673,
-0.0178338569,
-0.0183772594,
0.0006957048,
0.0104947379,
-0.0229960661,
-0.0263418667,
-0.0224949233,
-0.0081697796,
-0.0666406676,
-0.005557809,
-0.0421899371,
0.0107036605,
-0.0204022601,
-0.0226664729,
-0.0352749974,
-0.0204268061,
0.0053426316,
0.0722492114,
-0.0081269527,
-0.0027875484,
-0.0132123204,
-0.0601168685,
0.0015674379,
0.0677002966,
-0.0165432859,
-0.0317192599,
0.0195920002,
0.0028916569,
-0.0413703062,
-0.0219103135,
-0.0373173691,
-0.0069179591,
-0.0480362363,
-0.0607884414,
0.0076242783,
-0.0520483702,
0.0124226296,
0.0022876214,
0.0314953662,
-0.0502405018,
-0.0038483362,
-0.0027096502,
-0.0300119705,
0.0566147119,
0.0499451458,
-0.0141760288,
0.0311549101,
0.0231110826,
-0.0263651628,
0.0886614993,
-0.0054214704,
0.071763292,
0.0484101735,
-0.0268689431,
0.0630749837,
0.0775274336,
0.0073522511,
0.0259829201,
0.0252977628,
-0.030556215,
0.0043467269,
-0.0263693035,
0.0010940186,
0.0242622886,
-0.0043211821,
-0.0142067485,
0.0585377403,
0.007567029,
-0.0097367102,
0.0079760375,
0.0137978764,
0.0154068489,
-0.0131660793,
0.0264986362,
-0.0150968488,
-0.026298847,
-0.0431829952,
-0.037275698,
0.0071348827,
0.0533760749,
-0.0188351199,
-0.0231191982,
0.0029852819,
-0.035753049,
0.0103259496,
0.0057748621,
0.06171415,
0.0312790908,
-0.0518781245,
0.0312038325,
0.0458164476,
-0.0292461421,
-0.0173579734,
-0.0295783952,
-0.0005750633,
-0.0168230981,
-0.0145391822,
0.0138950208,
0.0386254191,
-0.0524093173,
0.0150518212,
0.0737151504,
0.0460923649,
-0.0084102554,
-0.0019204561,
-0.0395221226,
-0.0448800549,
-0.0012213439,
0.0118960552,
0.0407839492,
-0.0118018836,
0.0358282849,
-0.0030618529,
-0.0376100913,
-0.0040092878,
0.012740531,
0.0138807157,
-0.0198863577,
-0.0087513551,
0.0405345634,
0.0496678464,
0.0072836159,
0.0022570207,
-0.0268554147,
0.0367963463,
-0.0189625509,
0.026345944,
0.0196390226,
0.0036423875,
-0.0286936555,
0.0205752477,
-0.0185867343,
-0.0408028252,
0.0308859106,
-0.0062236357,
-0.0157525446,
0.0363484919,
-0.0286192782,
0.0379290842,
-0.0263032056,
0.0023831176,
-0.022296479,
0.039628312,
0.011902797,
0.02732707,
0.0098226182,
0.0062762839,
-0.0027071086,
-0.0454796851,
0.0386377834,
-0.0136366822,
-0.0486374907,
0.0023932569,
0.0051359786,
-0.0192438681,
0.0453139581,
0.0060416237,
0.0101881409,
-0.0597153306,
-0.0784354582,
-0.0603318214,
-0.0303323641,
-0.003068299,
-0.0256250426,
-0.0070006759,
0.0056943148,
0.0099441903,
-0.0547437891,
-0.0107100923,
0.0086331535,
0.0333918855,
-0.0054060142,
-0.0097695878,
-0.0202123635,
0.0210817624,
0.0228402428,
0.003695345,
0.0830523074,
0.0120146666,
-0.0438931771,
-0.0485469662,
-0.0106961196,
0.007456685,
0.0295020137,
-0.0267000031,
-0.0754155293,
0.0087532056,
0.0395662151,
0.0695592985,
0.0510332473,
0.0173362195,
0.0098373638,
0.0272895452,
0.0349813551,
-0.0445092842,
-0.0149904545,
-0.0388542749,
-0.0063564121,
-0.0844036415,
-0.0214331709,
0.0212399736,
0.0562197343,
-0.0039227917,
0.0081227953,
-0.0200107843,
0.007778123,
0.0391591191,
-0.0535285287,
-0.0037021236,
-0.0318779238,
-0.0320527703,
0.036597997,
0.0195938163,
-0.0478348657,
0.0775716603,
-0.0516836569,
-0.0457010604,
-0.0253700148,
-0.0215874743,
0.017193418,
0.0381841213,
-0.0141971903,
0.0361641645,
0.0334433876,
-0.0193836857,
-0.0251272507,
-0.0349872485,
0.0395464674,
-0.0313923284,
0.0388663746,
0.0243395176,
-0.0034614452,
0.0336242653,
-0.0469380729,
-0.077744469,
-0.0376424864,
-0.0399168618,
-0.0369645096,
0.0505933091,
-0.0221509729,
-0.0804428682,
-0.004178273,
-0.0024377161,
0.0320066586,
0.0147272879,
0.0039960961,
0.0181134474,
-0.0086056376,
0.0396038555,
0.0065001533,
0.0355733559,
-0.0594496913,
0.0052907341,
0.0410663597,
-0.0338435993,
-0.0232281275,
0.010566147,
-0.0210302677,
0.0562093109,
0.0041850414,
0.0135367494,
-0.0247073807,
0.017188577,
-0.0300454926,
0.0185754392,
0.0894312263,
-0.0124794766,
-0.0867429748,
-0.000671108,
-0.0044954685,
0.0252810866,
-0.00676357,
0.0208854619,
-0.1049696952,
-0.0117588025,
-0.0008868171,
0.00661396,
-0.0326974578,
0.0157014094,
-0.0191792697,
-0.1195429638,
0.0312639996,
0.0124177691,
0.0026116516,
-0.0206408855,
-0.0327101834,
-0.0196546782,
-0.0248329025,
0.0265421718,
-0.0523405038,
0.0056634401,
-0.0356894173,
-0.015324207,
-0.0134601425,
-0.0775989816,
0.0069055776,
-0.0247834679,
0.0148205515,
0.0358445086,
0.0432523191,
-0.0348689109,
-0.106308572,
0.0821634829,
0.0187075902,
-0.0154921906,
-0.030087065,
0.0409690179,
-0.0265305247,
-0.0164136067,
0.0020924278,
0.02095492,
-0.0074483068,
-0.0112819551,
0.0224609189,
0.062796928,
-0.0099313268,
-0.0545972101,
0.0606864728,
0.0128197726,
0.0526359566,
0.0759325996,
0.0029470623,
-0.0463371128,
0.0195111446,
-0.0291357953,
0.0294277035,
0.0296952259,
-0.0270666424,
-0.0062527899,
0.0310251918,
-0.0582194068,
-0.0302730631,
-0.0344342738,
0.0140225738,
0.0204828121,
0.0321352221,
0.0090457946,
-0.0211106185,
0.0264147259,
-0.0027171241,
0.0266662147,
-0.0247073118,
0.0393674523,
-0.0919031128,
-0.0116225956,
-0.0061518592,
-0.0364835709,
-0.0204326548,
-0.010184586,
-0.0400118791,
-0.064923808,
-0.0217861105,
0.0598813966,
0.0162031129,
0.0604863502,
0.0053114514,
-0.0435601361,
0.0125140371,
0.0215628985,
-0.0046155429,
-0.0045629237,
0.0773310214,
-0.026575258,
-0.0222338829,
0.0342025049,
0.0225385651,
0.0555700287,
0.067762278,
-0.0209470298,
-0.0279247966,
-0.0421159826,
0.011342058,
-0.0074787578,
0.0741758943,
-0.0598961301,
0.006428821,
-0.0517674014,
-0.0071669226,
0.0262835454,
-0.0229487233,
-0.0465600118,
-0.0213963166,
0.0205374453,
0.011505696,
0.0275870878,
0.0194011312,
-0.0394707397,
-0.008486391,
-0.032963004,
0.0876336172,
0.0260228775,
0.0485158116,
0.0281982645,
0.0163782053,
0.0017703634,
0.0684967041,
0.0444116592,
0.0465478487,
0.0254181344,
0.0621476918,
0.02450555,
-0.0331409164,
0.0420100987,
0.0314478576,
0.0297277141,
-0.0146717839,
-0.0122993533,
-0.0127885984,
0.0365123004,
0.0027605838,
0.0624915436,
-0.0238716509,
-0.0088042617,
-0.0253472738,
0.0194904376,
-0.0318843797,
-0.0127102099,
0.0145312035,
-0.0264197309,
-0.0379748605,
0.0212171134,
0.0382703356,
-0.0812029615,
0.0231085457,
0.0356607325,
-0.0149029186,
-0.0184880514,
-0.0258966163,
0.0264733676,
-0.0039935396,
-0.0268520862,
0.014089589,
-0.0271521397,
-0.0282797404,
0.0232205167,
-0.0239661187,
-0.0404443368,
0.0157078411,
0.0157572385,
0.0594057031,
-0.0164945405,
0.0397365391,
-0.0493088365,
-0.0330768749,
0.050593473,
-0.0153623465,
0.008398219,
-6.324289646e-33,
0.0322108679,
-0.0378364772,
-0.0416826829,
0.0330448635,
0.0118324729,
-0.008157311,
-0.005764972,
0.0136513999,
-0.0381888524,
0.0738599002,
0.0127200279,
-0.0078444034,
0.0210951101,
-0.0060637118,
-0.0162908621,
-0.0022474478,
0.069876641,
0.0280777439,
-0.05604003,
0.0095306803,
0.0354424007,
0.0198915992,
0.1058920473,
-0.1055824682,
0.0496395864,
-0.0071350886,
-0.060189873,
0.0034690518,
0.0016318131,
0.0770070106,
-0.0142459609,
0.0541129857,
-0.0029635122,
-0.0514798984,
0.0203569531,
0.057090722,
-0.014631019,
-0.0118765449,
0.0355842225,
0.0472633429,
0.0359821208,
-0.0225758646,
0.0213181619,
-0.0500282459,
-0.0412411168,
0.0224286839,
0.0185365584,
-0.0358907245,
0.0171019975,
-0.0077758641,
-0.0439177006,
0.0082036871,
0.0120980022,
-0.006209332,
0.0442801081,
0.0985068083,
-0.0001272116,
0.0090434849,
-0.0934029818,
0.067624554,
0.0131737273,
0.0008213585,
0.0282502268,
-0.0049590715,
-0.0156803355,
0.0634835735,
0.0308632012,
0.0117104696,
0.0158507172,
-0.0254867375,
0.0341933742,
0.0273943394,
0.0605940744,
0.065819487,
-0.0092922673,
-0.0523528047,
-0.0428083912,
0.0265797619,
0.0768086314,
-0.0247592386,
0.0285548568,
-0.0337236226,
-0.0286848769,
-0.0572415143,
-0.0296295658,
-0.0310749635,
-0.0370845906,
-0.0206910688,
0.0235349741,
0.0207239334,
-0.0065720365,
0.0452059396,
0.0489868224,
-0.0584010147,
-0.0630128458,
0.0121661695,
0.021424938,
0.0101307631,
0.0039542667,
0.002461714,
-0.0155604985,
-0.0469996259,
0.0038006983,
-0.0200790688,
0.0193121657,
-0.0122651886,
0.0648867488,
0.0092641711,
-0.0811887607,
0.0148638459,
-0.0066923844,
0.0130286058,
0.0248445794,
0.0454037227,
0.0138320196,
-0.0197186768,
-0.0127100889,
0.0253065638,
-0.0014793284,
0.0038956441,
-0.0220127031,
0.0049265865,
0.0124063566,
0.0598791614,
-0.0541248098,
-0.016466327,
-0.0073548909,
-0.0190824624,
0.0472973883,
-0.0303380173,
0.0133277625,
-0.0561058819,
2.744e-7,
0.0172744673,
0.0395881273,
-0.0412356667,
-0.023409551,
-0.0025942505,
0.0577578507,
-0.0348578617,
-0.0020693061,
0.0097385859,
-0.0282518901,
-0.0159966908,
-0.0201987512,
0.0547979623,
0.0155231683,
-0.1031434759,
-0.0198263209,
-0.0462206528,
-0.0131154871,
-0.0538662747,
0.0116493423,
0.0051874295,
0.1284641773,
0.0248001534,
-0.011860962,
-0.0158565342,
-0.0126801822,
0.0646353737,
-0.0448620766,
-0.0201882329,
0.022546649,
0.0182109717,
-0.0425119177,
-0.0085715344,
0.0254489351,
-0.0281327814,
0.0216787886,
-0.0319488868,
0.0542242937,
0.0186999179,
-0.0062958887,
0.0179228149,
0.0310223233,
-0.054692708,
-0.0347223617,
0.0177380964,
-0.0516494997,
-0.0498762205,
-0.0365110785,
-0.0075169462,
-0.0172665957,
0.0483455956,
-0.0440505855,
-0.0129340952,
0.0111979581,
0.0439455658,
-0.0002242444,
-0.0022205068,
-0.0301838163,
0.0137208216,
0.0105310222,
-0.0061530443,
-0.0441170596,
-0.0023077894,
-0.0524164997,
-0.0020582422,
-0.0112549663,
0.0250850394,
2.314089658e-34,
0.0614692047,
-0.0208094362,
0.0195191316,
0.0017712314,
0.0288482308,
-0.006542779,
0.0482207984,
0.0086435797,
0.0209542681,
-0.0550296716,
-0.0061434833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11922v1 | Generating Topic Pages for Scientific Concepts Using Scientific Publications | 2023-04-24T09:03:14 | 2023-04-24T09:03:14 | Hosein Azarbonyad, Zubair Afzal, George Tsatsaronis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR | In this paper, we describe Topic Pages, an inventory of scientific concepts
and information around them extracted from a large collection of scientific
books and journals. The main aim of Topic Pages is to provide all the necessary
information to the readers to understand scientific concepts they come across
while reading scholarly content in any scientific domain. Topic Pages are a
collection of automatically generated information pages using NLP and ML, each
corresponding to a scientific concept. Each page contains three pieces of
information: a definition, related concepts, and the most relevant snippets,
all extracted from scientific peer-reviewed publications. In this paper, we
discuss the details of different components to extract each of these elements.
The collection of pages in production contains over 360,000 Topic Pages across
20 different scientific domains with an average of 23 million unique visits per
month, constituting it a popular source for scientific information. | [
0.0335604027,
-0.0323555283,
-0.00757284,
-0.0071212645,
-0.0179272238,
0.0025518218,
-0.0009326682,
0.0130208042,
-0.051788535,
-0.0619810112,
0.0168087948,
0.0908556581,
0.0089505138,
0.0621990338,
0.0152843436,
-0.0775486976,
0.0153944129,
0.0014810676,
0.0511504821,
0.0028992733,
0.0066501922,
-0.0045065526,
-0.0222778656,
0.01675025,
0.037555784,
-0.0456311554,
-0.005128765,
-0.0491929501,
0.0116521744,
-0.0801469758,
-0.0124502918,
0.0117721129,
0.0175938383,
-0.011870767,
0.0000018124,
-0.0716141388,
-0.0480717644,
0.0187729001,
-0.0033205226,
0.0238253158,
0.0798777789,
-0.0411966145,
0.0143092284,
-0.0502270795,
-0.0058060451,
0.0161630511,
0.0326361395,
0.0824459121,
-0.0061616939,
-0.0009127374,
-0.0090499688,
-0.0349231213,
0.0250941422,
0.0417771526,
0.0782950446,
-0.0053295195,
0.0387886986,
0.0451102108,
0.045947846,
0.0616022721,
0.0258372501,
0.0297701284,
-0.0357734002,
-0.0531058498,
0.0772268847,
0.041576542,
0.0010771748,
-0.0505094528,
-0.0096769743,
0.0493561812,
0.0641543791,
-0.0345914736,
0.0435947366,
-0.0183837693,
-0.0380660444,
0.0633603036,
-0.0835340768,
0.0256447494,
-0.0080605755,
-0.0309941974,
0.0363543034,
0.0134476488,
0.0170738678,
-0.0025684503,
-0.0122677814,
0.0659382567,
0.0162598621,
-0.034392789,
-0.0100816051,
-0.0078358371,
0.0597154014,
-0.0542898662,
0.0268060509,
0.0317884274,
0.0481783226,
0.0149417939,
0.0226899888,
-0.0561835431,
0.072167851,
-0.0111778229,
-0.028293157,
-0.041604802,
0.0188959613,
0.0451392755,
0.04691571,
-0.0372653492,
-0.0385743566,
-0.0502203032,
-0.0005985339,
0.0230876096,
-0.0625584796,
-0.0195395835,
0.017616678,
0.008298534,
0.0093146358,
-0.022808427,
-0.0236919373,
-0.0121446354,
-0.0269058123,
0.0084665837,
-0.0214464441,
0.0048786439,
-0.0342293754,
-0.0008615436,
-0.0286807828,
-0.0080361785,
-0.0350479595,
0.0068761064,
-0.0208509509,
-0.0067185378,
0.0249222629,
-0.0050470117,
0.0199240483,
0.0267748535,
-0.0174124073,
0.0413666666,
0.0492826514,
-0.0553222746,
-0.0230091233,
-0.0518734269,
0.0211067386,
0.0031186687,
0.0306773819,
-0.0517509803,
0.0509181172,
0.0203106664,
0.0063490784,
0.0136015099,
-0.0068064383,
0.0245024879,
-0.038961079,
0.0555181243,
-0.0971098021,
0.0021575931,
0.0725625232,
0.0120969098,
0.020814646,
0.0140340095,
-0.0088726748,
-0.011490575,
0.070011206,
-0.023596473,
-0.0001932295,
-0.0622200854,
0.0358195864,
-0.0281322505,
0.0339585841,
0.0074189692,
-0.0112763094,
0.0154547803,
-0.0308222454,
0.0132440487,
-0.0473270938,
0.0161051229,
-0.0127431238,
0.0807647929,
0.0109531153,
0.0688493624,
0.0168245193,
0.0157060418,
0.0288996715,
-0.0048231282,
-0.0011191034,
0.0472820513,
0.0018602023,
0.0160958413,
0.0053237076,
0.0323472433,
0.0309731904,
-0.0355319604,
-0.0256189648,
0.0327027775,
-0.0227977857,
-0.0472445302,
0.0664999112,
0.0181293655,
0.0347273611,
0.0138674462,
0.0461069718,
0.008440895,
0.0402775295,
0.046879828,
0.0511449948,
0.039098613,
0.0505954735,
-0.0470265709,
-0.0486650057,
-0.0058862986,
-0.0298354551,
0.0417646281,
0.0077552428,
-0.0505790748,
-0.0567194298,
-0.0067547765,
-0.0158345513,
-0.0408607386,
0.0035346418,
-0.0134187136,
0.0205872543,
-0.0043356195,
-0.0078424411,
-0.0492963493,
-0.0360910073,
0.0577603281,
-0.0483470559,
-0.0012379301,
-0.0044661313,
-0.0527825058,
0.0407279432,
0.0324713737,
0.0175937936,
0.0291865561,
0.085592404,
-0.0282138363,
-0.0181424897,
0.002182537,
0.0560293868,
0.040683113,
0.0579451919,
-0.0960361883,
0.0223027784,
-0.0370501205,
0.0021115604,
-0.0248107444,
0.0116898958,
-0.0153348548,
-0.0158472974,
0.0184316877,
-0.0105637582,
0.0215470064,
0.007402644,
-0.0207331814,
0.035650786,
0.0167065244,
0.0486497059,
0.0413336754,
-0.0490256734,
0.0070393714,
-0.0180009175,
0.0287939105,
0.0101960385,
-0.0040835682,
-0.0471619703,
0.0755120963,
-0.026980577,
-0.0253550522,
0.0058720224,
-0.0016764025,
-0.0160006713,
0.0285265427,
-0.0033093088,
0.045872841,
-0.0290063247,
-0.0019559802,
0.0196825601,
0.0248463172,
0.0154484566,
-0.0401933268,
-0.0405567922,
0.0639692917,
0.0206270535,
0.0059823752,
-0.0485423543,
0.0052313949,
-0.0573294312,
0.0341498069,
0.0655553862,
-0.0493913591,
-0.0418703221,
0.0304529257,
-0.0009823156,
-0.01145133,
-0.0118087744,
0.0271208882,
0.0247641932,
-0.0196574889,
0.0142198782,
0.0479325652,
0.0321961381,
0.0664781928,
0.0579148307,
-0.0435933471,
-0.0496376529,
-0.0115250936,
-0.0524938218,
0.0718310326,
0.0038405147,
-0.0080052316,
0.0672369748,
-0.0209479593,
-0.0159304757,
0.0120569868,
-0.0002309499,
0.0504343286,
-0.0478029661,
-0.0035138277,
-0.0335189737,
0.0284270588,
-0.0094240569,
0.0647586659,
0.041286245,
-0.0205377899,
0.044588834,
-0.0039338437,
0.0205298215,
-0.0991794616,
-0.0054622344,
-0.0296158753,
0.0126760071,
-0.0115911169,
0.0145806838,
0.0279146787,
0.007286578,
0.0196994152,
0.0324780792,
0.0011416476,
-0.003033658,
-0.0146499425,
-0.0270225313,
0.0068765543,
-0.0125145651,
0.0256175529,
-0.0034120758,
0.018167153,
0.0037673407,
0.0062670917,
-0.0011437496,
-0.0576743297,
-0.0472915694,
-0.003861821,
0.0705603659,
-0.0309850592,
-0.016846532,
-0.0150118582,
-0.0150096836,
-0.0023081256,
0.0747541338,
-0.0289268419,
0.0165057629,
0.0081531284,
0.0055705304,
0.0660417527,
-0.0073407022,
0.0133759705,
-0.0130319577,
-0.0262295585,
0.0244809017,
-0.0921095163,
0.0132434508,
0.0002574048,
-0.0235742945,
-0.0225662403,
-0.0056854426,
0.0877171755,
0.0451071784,
-0.0712677911,
-0.0071782907,
-0.0468926616,
-0.0377562344,
0.0046073357,
0.0127335088,
-0.0695154592,
0.0634054467,
-0.0143176429,
0.0173141081,
0.003506511,
-0.0018519618,
-0.022833636,
-0.0189187936,
0.0363370255,
-0.0174265653,
-0.0376158506,
-0.0420600735,
-0.0887196735,
-0.0215559099,
-0.0257298611,
-0.0600547493,
0.0143761672,
-0.0261319336,
-0.0006767917,
0.0005758055,
-0.025074359,
-0.0960316733,
0.011889481,
-0.0104507385,
0.0123239793,
0.0082285348,
0.0686210096,
-0.0358761325,
0.0028106971,
-0.0302145835,
-0.0383044817,
-0.0417835936,
-0.0232471041,
0.0321626104,
0.0049944613,
0.0230600443,
-0.0245287679,
0.0720609277,
-0.0314251482,
-0.0225671232,
0.0427587703,
0.0597207062,
-0.025518056,
-0.0051157079,
-0.1067334488,
0.0125802923,
-0.0124068381,
0.0687696785,
0.0113065615,
0.0055888137,
-0.0122738853,
-0.0169171225,
0.0357470363,
0.0190555044,
-0.0224702619,
-0.0320807546,
-0.0715041161,
-0.0412968621,
-0.0674268529,
-0.0003165102,
0.0356831998,
0.0228410717,
0.036830347,
0.0149058113,
0.0464699566,
-0.0262808204,
-0.0453462116,
0.0145545024,
-0.0005583382,
-0.025889907,
-0.0042230985,
-0.0871819258,
0.0827562287,
0.003083487,
-0.0211006794,
-0.0036531151,
0.0416882895,
-0.0502031408,
0.0195564702,
0.0100781899,
0.020233158,
0.0148391826,
-0.0135917692,
-0.0174974129,
0.011103644,
0.0305780713,
-0.0356540047,
-0.0222578701,
-0.032573659,
0.0110245645,
-0.0233473107,
-0.041925855,
-0.0475370288,
0.0497193895,
-0.0686429441,
0.0000167565,
-0.0555587895,
-0.0648107007,
0.0505344346,
0.0327132531,
0.0461798757,
-0.0448599868,
-0.0287081636,
-0.0033435854,
-0.0210211258,
-0.0076970207,
-0.0176938288,
-0.0029483708,
0.0317534581,
-0.0004133042,
-0.0032479044,
0.013794235,
0.0154586807,
-0.0328784585,
0.0248471517,
-0.0116153052,
0.0355230756,
0.0182240345,
0.015313304,
0.0095777502,
-0.0254242159,
-0.01211394,
-0.0252087582,
-0.0757153928,
0.0064217192,
-0.0143049574,
0.0125365881,
0.0476046689,
-0.0062600751,
-0.023869345,
0.0077644135,
-0.0881187692,
0.0129242539,
-0.018769931,
0.0162923522,
0.0278251171,
0.0398827568,
0.0238993894,
-0.065309003,
-0.0562351942,
-0.0154485209,
0.0291987062,
0.0056906403,
0.0337915495,
0.0469488315,
0.0442826077,
-0.0182232186,
-0.0625186786,
0.0434510037,
0.0024518184,
-0.0074044634,
0.0278247185,
-0.0134754879,
-0.0354796834,
0.0237725377,
-0.0498652421,
0.0285965074,
0.0088380482,
-0.0154413935,
-0.0541238822,
0.0352921486,
0.0536865667,
0.0451519489,
0.0043275347,
-0.0035654337,
0.0347593091,
0.0655991286,
-0.0044949511,
-0.0310782492,
-0.032714583,
0.0662826896,
-0.0638789162,
-0.0461553372,
-0.0301536433,
-5.882989598e-33,
-0.0246186722,
-0.0712258667,
0.0265794136,
0.0578519665,
-0.0083757006,
0.0064418921,
-0.0351000689,
-0.0542321652,
0.0032720633,
0.0603381135,
0.0068462854,
-0.0121832257,
-0.0062834201,
-0.0567992665,
0.0326782912,
0.0193224177,
0.0280712843,
0.0084927892,
-0.0076694177,
0.0402341373,
0.0612003356,
0.0097876415,
0.0295785256,
-0.1040307656,
0.0367910676,
-0.0156872459,
0.0321287438,
-0.0199825596,
0.0415508486,
0.0545977578,
-0.0570571907,
-0.0016326724,
0.0207743272,
-0.0660828725,
0.0033599765,
-0.0016962052,
-0.0910304114,
-0.0120035289,
0.0057904003,
-0.0309852734,
0.017867595,
-0.0288488865,
0.0099290349,
0.0152132884,
-0.0079398882,
-0.0027011845,
0.0955459177,
0.003980997,
-0.0458107367,
-0.0538195297,
-0.0521420762,
0.0329793207,
-0.0277762618,
0.0666818097,
0.0305777825,
-0.0201403946,
0.0073829549,
0.0609664358,
0.0197098926,
0.0696431845,
0.036729604,
0.033382047,
0.0098467702,
-0.0350161083,
0.0524242409,
0.0487425402,
-0.0097843427,
-0.006962121,
0.0280662924,
0.0126584237,
0.016689105,
0.0296042562,
0.0253948886,
0.0356930383,
0.0061918385,
0.0231248606,
-0.0372045077,
0.0455108993,
0.0212181304,
0.0313159823,
-0.0207881071,
0.003143962,
0.0359665342,
-0.0054946188,
0.0104714017,
-0.0155034112,
0.0046260078,
-0.0198124386,
-0.0196609795,
-0.0353933945,
-0.0835782662,
0.0025071746,
-0.0170007497,
-0.0052906941,
-0.0248044897,
0.0567105971,
0.0299270879,
0.0143702179,
-0.0182295181,
-0.0371017009,
-0.0922343954,
-0.05949964,
-0.0256666169,
-0.0017290835,
0.0100241154,
-0.0122855641,
-0.027182959,
-0.0200226326,
0.0343741328,
-0.0190426726,
0.0391556211,
-0.0521309711,
-0.0157122668,
0.0394747667,
0.0068764589,
0.0310369395,
0.0017766587,
0.0037448525,
0.0612402298,
0.0420097299,
0.0225919764,
-0.0148990266,
-0.008393608,
0.0237139091,
-0.0265684426,
-0.022821147,
-0.0234866291,
0.013764184,
0.0203324296,
-0.0222752523,
0.0012779275,
0.0101026176,
2.587e-7,
0.0665728226,
0.080253154,
0.0272595733,
0.0000616573,
0.040705286,
-0.0063702217,
-0.0178516582,
-0.021125393,
-0.0222847629,
-0.039157331,
-0.0039804024,
-0.0212812368,
-0.0432891287,
0.0397280902,
-0.0795049444,
-0.0301401708,
-0.01796804,
-0.0442243032,
-0.0405510738,
0.0097932555,
-0.0020080705,
-0.025454931,
-0.0119708478,
0.0239845086,
-0.016259307,
-0.0018731962,
-0.0139271868,
-0.0257323291,
0.018838862,
0.0682880208,
0.0566191748,
0.0164876822,
0.0110026039,
-0.0127161434,
-0.0205501709,
0.0107218772,
-0.0285684206,
0.0147609729,
0.021143334,
0.008564258,
0.0141273523,
-0.0308670606,
0.0522144698,
-0.0456567667,
-0.0065628067,
-0.0329101272,
-0.0234672874,
-0.0508139692,
-0.0489371866,
0.0013588577,
-0.0209382717,
-0.0262024831,
-0.0017694252,
0.0316814072,
-0.0555085056,
-0.0112564908,
-0.0293256491,
-0.0590232797,
0.0108843762,
0.0345065817,
-0.014826606,
-0.0092041083,
-0.0028305349,
-0.0423076451,
-0.0048404629,
-0.0225405991,
-0.0113092437,
2.247233647e-34,
0.033646401,
-0.0223077796,
-0.0492861643,
0.0361998007,
-0.0210188199,
-0.0186639875,
-0.0345503986,
0.0322938561,
-0.0018301279,
-0.0239408482,
0.0154105648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12329v1 | Pre-trained Embeddings for Entity Resolution: An Experimental Analysis [Experiment, Analysis & Benchmark] | 2023-04-24T08:53:54 | 2023-04-24T08:53:54 | Alexandros Zeakis, George Papadakis, Dimitrios Skoutas, Manolis Koubarakis | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Many recent works on Entity Resolution (ER) leverage Deep Learning techniques
involving language models to improve effectiveness. This is applied to both
main steps of ER, i.e., blocking and matching. Several pre-trained embeddings
have been tested, with the most popular ones being fastText and variants of the
BERT model. However, there is no detailed analysis of their pros and cons. To
cover this gap, we perform a thorough experimental analysis of 12 popular
language models over 17 established benchmark datasets. First, we assess their
vectorization overhead for converting all input entities into dense embeddings
vectors. Second, we investigate their blocking performance, performing a
detailed scalability analysis, and comparing them with the state-of-the-art
deep learning-based blocking method. Third, we conclude with their relative
performance for both supervised and unsupervised matching. Our experimental
results provide novel insights into the strengths and weaknesses of the main
language models, facilitating researchers and practitioners to select the most
suitable ones in practice. | [
0.015441102,
0.0410693698,
0.0131304441,
0.0374010578,
0.0175993294,
0.0293229502,
0.0479235202,
0.0189956538,
0.046742104,
-0.0179742053,
0.0124916136,
-0.0556199141,
-0.0223163515,
0.0029294582,
0.0102689853,
-0.0262152813,
0.0422820747,
0.0088644652,
-0.0017683735,
-0.0206254534,
0.0119731911,
0.0294622201,
0.0032113821,
0.0185344219,
-0.0079340087,
0.0111700632,
0.0095766336,
-0.0019739699,
0.0283116512,
-0.0129442718,
0.0270311702,
0.0671269298,
0.0180947501,
0.0820890814,
0.0000017704,
-0.0460366271,
-0.0215989314,
-0.0018359625,
-0.0481900461,
0.0471968241,
-0.0269791409,
-0.0362028144,
0.0043474515,
0.0025685758,
0.000125793,
-0.0893464908,
0.037642058,
0.0388600826,
0.019111393,
0.0246878117,
-0.0114120701,
-0.0480883531,
0.0101400102,
-0.0270758662,
-0.0621004961,
-0.050655812,
0.05131891,
-0.0111500509,
-0.0046822582,
-0.0119207585,
-0.0015617475,
0.0601198189,
-0.0012845141,
0.0249507427,
-0.002071688,
0.0382766128,
-0.0100685423,
0.0247908421,
0.0394197106,
0.1149192825,
-0.0469277687,
-0.0059417663,
0.0236791,
0.0022199959,
-0.0275683254,
-0.0111705558,
-0.0029838099,
-0.0094529297,
0.0315772519,
0.0173490401,
-0.0394002832,
-0.0035902453,
0.035273999,
-0.002114583,
-0.0632442087,
-0.0200633239,
0.0357667319,
-0.017423315,
0.0260067228,
0.0195667651,
-0.0104552088,
-0.0851123631,
0.0522975959,
0.0220843218,
-0.005269364,
-0.0004151488,
-0.0603778437,
-0.0496210866,
-0.0270794872,
-0.0571411289,
-0.0264502857,
0.0067512086,
0.014633188,
0.0518533662,
-0.0758096054,
0.0136610745,
-0.0381941125,
0.0526061244,
-0.001342736,
-0.0169518571,
-0.0215430055,
0.0197310615,
-0.0690597817,
0.0442110375,
-0.0356690362,
-0.0313310847,
-0.0143888826,
-0.0049391072,
-0.0061757881,
0.0439073145,
-0.0671952888,
0.0038808838,
0.0213343371,
-0.0025114066,
-0.0214109067,
0.0161189996,
-0.0457497649,
-0.0243609622,
-0.0468727127,
-0.0249282457,
-0.0119072162,
-0.0146435769,
0.0428902768,
-0.0620096512,
0.0374757051,
0.0151563957,
0.0143009508,
-0.0732713118,
-0.0272156075,
0.0090495674,
0.02953998,
-0.0349465311,
-0.0361935236,
-0.045194611,
0.0787715018,
-0.005808719,
-0.0092813289,
-0.063372992,
0.0119684963,
0.0119059375,
-0.0708214492,
0.081349127,
-0.0251257606,
0.0213142,
0.0265834536,
0.0035137611,
0.0645658597,
0.0244234167,
0.0253693331,
0.0044870935,
0.0340880044,
-0.0380392112,
-0.005726465,
0.0679829642,
0.0605315007,
-0.010091248,
0.0088212965,
0.0089017656,
0.023427261,
0.0466402136,
0.0240907073,
0.0491576195,
-0.013405975,
-0.0610808507,
0.0172648076,
0.0269817133,
0.0056604496,
0.0366535559,
0.0208075009,
0.0119955661,
0.0212961677,
0.000146696,
-0.0202344097,
0.0015167205,
-0.0231122691,
-0.0210355744,
0.0559753031,
0.0384117439,
-0.0693006143,
0.0362988301,
0.0056732218,
-0.011491186,
-0.0145041524,
0.0141783245,
0.0444557667,
-0.0084134117,
-0.0467665978,
0.0541458726,
0.0051979772,
-0.0039426605,
0.0090353386,
0.0072575053,
-0.0201596729,
0.0311826393,
0.074453555,
-0.0418983102,
-0.0255036671,
-0.0151882619,
-0.0067720483,
0.0263536833,
0.0725108683,
-0.0011044828,
0.0538409241,
-0.023324063,
-0.0191367567,
0.0422495864,
-0.0296292622,
0.039294377,
0.0519716702,
0.0369849727,
0.0339120477,
-0.026077548,
-0.0167828258,
0.0591537096,
-0.057131242,
-0.0116644306,
0.0036470564,
0.0453492031,
-0.027664464,
0.0387339741,
-0.0392949656,
-0.0209826082,
0.0348148607,
-0.021611806,
0.0039871507,
-0.0176540352,
-0.0187754128,
-0.0279972088,
0.0301271006,
-0.0160678625,
-0.0460656546,
0.0430707783,
-0.0186790973,
-0.0302551221,
-0.0139784869,
-0.0028963133,
0.0372602232,
-0.0330067463,
0.00894388,
-0.0015472412,
0.0454473011,
-0.0306239799,
0.0642619506,
0.0027702614,
0.0432033762,
0.0380247422,
-0.0070246803,
0.0292824227,
-0.038768366,
-0.0950412676,
0.011409496,
-0.0137713598,
-0.003924971,
0.0057988404,
-0.0428724252,
-0.0373056941,
0.0137852374,
-0.0578181185,
0.0146879572,
-0.0051531759,
0.013680052,
-0.0226770286,
0.0486158058,
-0.0067791636,
-0.0164384376,
-0.0171972569,
-0.0610959195,
0.026798496,
0.0208442919,
0.0301738996,
0.0290461034,
-0.056053862,
-0.032713484,
-0.0348311402,
-0.017446667,
0.0572417341,
-0.0237863399,
-0.0354644358,
-0.016811043,
0.0181498807,
-0.0440719686,
0.0600499101,
0.0285045207,
0.015476848,
-0.0140994946,
-0.0085405465,
0.0161367692,
0.0377979651,
-0.0093737552,
0.0158800203,
-0.0029471144,
-0.0087746065,
-0.060112644,
0.0100429095,
-0.0216268431,
0.0431058183,
-0.0013112479,
-0.0165472906,
-0.008039983,
0.0359985083,
-0.0359719247,
-0.0220535453,
-0.0621359758,
0.0073606847,
0.0233674198,
0.0286769457,
-0.0369200557,
0.0040503256,
0.0192913581,
0.0248228088,
-0.0439852551,
0.0129084177,
0.0661532953,
-0.048766315,
-0.0181908179,
0.0076486892,
0.0176132433,
-0.0065242806,
0.0401870273,
0.0271195322,
0.0280937515,
-0.0397726037,
-0.0664290711,
-0.0018367695,
0.0413154028,
-0.0098598599,
-0.0394585133,
0.02536311,
0.0018746416,
0.0559031181,
-0.0363436155,
-0.0001333964,
-0.0665796995,
-0.0360664092,
-0.01798754,
0.0134900184,
0.0186921116,
0.0000687397,
-0.0445172153,
0.0592715368,
-0.0009381376,
0.0332770906,
0.0335665718,
0.0066307313,
-0.0479310267,
0.0377562791,
0.0011686509,
0.0036175449,
0.0608547591,
0.0029392513,
0.027460089,
0.0259080008,
0.0672019869,
-0.0150711806,
-0.0342605487,
-0.0232908204,
0.0284849517,
-0.0835359991,
0.0063439817,
-0.0314570814,
0.0403019674,
-0.0081101591,
-0.0002430502,
0.105816476,
0.0280357338,
0.0035007941,
-0.0202542562,
0.052528467,
0.0132562369,
-0.0029853343,
0.0289330576,
-0.0948137864,
-0.0155998291,
0.0029359029,
-0.022227671,
0.0494286902,
-0.0932509676,
0.00944243,
-0.1091576889,
-0.0270870365,
-0.0324215516,
-0.0068607964,
-0.0467521511,
-0.0531014353,
0.0030451978,
0.0235253312,
0.0164029244,
-0.0056555187,
-0.0117589459,
-0.0189995002,
-0.000672869,
-0.0197915696,
-0.0344919562,
0.038174022,
-0.1125172675,
0.0536645763,
0.037829861,
0.054418806,
0.0007516728,
-0.0047546262,
-0.03745557,
-0.0446608141,
-0.062198285,
-0.0007115994,
0.0532490537,
-0.0359090343,
-0.0307740234,
-0.017594846,
-0.0236619078,
0.0033830339,
0.0029443845,
-0.022868719,
0.03963653,
0.0139229298,
-0.0022224539,
-0.0154598318,
0.0089212349,
-0.0121981082,
0.0873888209,
0.0263969917,
-0.0053003887,
-0.0174549911,
0.0107240034,
0.0523938313,
-0.0460399128,
-0.0153706623,
0.0220545456,
-0.0490962639,
0.0089613777,
-0.0281655733,
-0.0704006106,
0.0892914757,
0.0235524178,
0.0275335554,
0.0107040806,
0.0003599009,
-0.0100899767,
-0.0447787791,
0.0415790379,
-0.0500035733,
0.0350267217,
-0.0503702611,
-0.0030214672,
-0.0167993996,
0.0189339928,
-0.0373414084,
0.0259346943,
-0.0258201584,
-0.0638010129,
0.0005999362,
-0.0133043788,
0.0078675244,
0.025744155,
-0.054259941,
-0.0618007779,
0.0029226965,
0.0032422398,
-0.0076668095,
-0.0019140866,
-0.0163655467,
-0.0295853652,
-0.0105914501,
0.0328310542,
-0.047441449,
0.0416258797,
0.0331827365,
0.0169659648,
-0.0174241569,
-0.0814498067,
-0.0106180198,
0.0315282308,
0.0203191787,
0.0183765292,
-0.0111448849,
-0.0463561639,
0.0012265295,
-0.0065406561,
0.0178444199,
-0.002970448,
-0.019514244,
0.0137329847,
0.0083298422,
-0.0034682187,
0.0795028284,
-0.0103014773,
0.016188113,
-0.0288830828,
-0.0046236329,
-0.045254834,
0.0308475532,
0.0208747443,
-0.0003050996,
-0.0191825479,
0.031780798,
0.0306658316,
0.0534211695,
-0.0726497993,
-0.0355669744,
0.0226958003,
0.0247139093,
-0.0169149134,
-0.0044507403,
-0.0198901929,
-0.0225061513,
-0.0229294747,
0.030601142,
0.0816337541,
-0.0617606416,
0.0270639732,
-0.0033764096,
0.00055197,
-0.0086923977,
-0.0385903716,
-0.0138009973,
0.0066145747,
0.0189045202,
0.0134154139,
0.0071590785,
0.0214659311,
0.0591538921,
0.038911134,
0.0707142949,
0.0253932122,
-0.0170119461,
-0.0413249731,
-0.0238423944,
0.0202456471,
0.0335298665,
-0.0472707711,
-0.0158056058,
-0.0211515073,
-0.0601404794,
0.0151239717,
-0.0319306888,
-0.054530248,
0.0114206215,
-0.0012837721,
0.0068884534,
0.0721126571,
-0.0050723315,
0.0072054942,
0.0479586832,
0.010380256,
-0.0650450289,
0.0057144728,
-5.588048515e-33,
-0.0374264978,
-0.0105075985,
0.0034268403,
-0.067988947,
-0.0065699732,
0.0093087805,
0.0004928082,
-0.0073026842,
-0.0595712997,
-0.0146627212,
-0.0275889989,
0.0092264712,
0.0160225183,
0.0195664167,
-0.0688969865,
-0.0237506032,
0.0460180454,
0.0042994521,
0.006539064,
0.016787732,
-0.0010176522,
0.0787289217,
0.0391061641,
-0.0559196956,
0.0156301744,
-0.0212995131,
0.016001977,
-0.0005459651,
0.0520623848,
0.0395390652,
-0.051240176,
-0.012416577,
0.0091042714,
-0.0262245964,
-0.0236846115,
0.0476891883,
-0.1555460542,
0.0195339043,
-0.0227315333,
0.0444939323,
-0.0223691557,
-0.0090331519,
0.046678368,
-0.0030517087,
0.0206318516,
0.0331834331,
0.0356041156,
-0.0160181504,
-0.0181144774,
-0.0207120962,
-0.0686473101,
0.0428882539,
-0.0124092298,
0.0089425296,
0.0872320309,
-0.0176829882,
0.0366839319,
0.0249618813,
-0.1119342446,
-0.0211104471,
0.0049784118,
-0.0000991582,
-0.002487171,
-0.006706906,
-0.0064453119,
0.0451682992,
-0.0007343444,
-0.0543177873,
-0.0340617113,
-0.0040477887,
0.0618615262,
0.0263402108,
-0.0014854344,
0.0399429016,
0.0277406648,
-0.0213300101,
-0.0983814523,
0.054861974,
0.0011510643,
-0.0096612787,
0.0046410575,
-0.0231609289,
-0.0467511415,
-0.0049628709,
-0.0461831465,
0.0035839106,
-0.0425604619,
-0.0257995967,
0.0342086554,
0.0106736356,
-0.0529090278,
0.0277760383,
0.0337945744,
-0.0571632162,
-0.0771173313,
0.0001742805,
0.0386802591,
-0.0088695763,
0.0173939392,
0.0437881164,
-0.0355950147,
-0.0315448232,
0.0257385653,
-0.056539122,
-0.0130845923,
-0.0221437663,
0.0190271754,
-0.0570321828,
-0.0495239645,
-0.0077278586,
0.0063489545,
0.0307375174,
-0.0308464579,
0.0000869955,
0.0210902747,
0.0085691726,
0.0576062351,
0.0183655135,
0.0762826279,
-0.0093459319,
-0.0341245607,
0.0105150044,
0.0602230355,
0.0498689488,
0.0035399036,
-0.0074536311,
-0.0543851219,
0.0173880924,
0.0369058065,
-0.066617988,
-0.0068201018,
-0.0058065248,
2.302e-7,
0.0502015911,
0.0026401184,
0.0894953758,
0.0133074243,
-0.0068744994,
0.018448839,
0.0327010714,
0.0466832519,
-0.0220688712,
0.0166822337,
-0.0078994306,
0.018977385,
0.0239521749,
0.0019021896,
-0.0490656979,
0.0031988064,
-0.0341275074,
0.0201341547,
-0.0721684471,
-0.052639883,
-0.0022208379,
0.0886888877,
0.0113853272,
-0.0048501482,
-0.0349609405,
-0.018050354,
0.0481040776,
-0.0011873931,
0.002237214,
0.049094405,
0.0252890736,
0.0350240991,
-0.0128546283,
0.042870339,
0.0046348879,
0.0374711789,
0.0441089571,
0.0395982377,
-0.0008381439,
0.0187047515,
-0.0248101261,
-0.0534056537,
-0.0107008433,
-0.0267221704,
0.0914936587,
-0.029995054,
0.0040881555,
0.021976674,
-0.035638921,
-0.0102337291,
0.0039471388,
0.0232676882,
-0.0039448789,
0.0338449292,
0.038034711,
-0.0095191495,
0.0115804262,
-0.1002581716,
0.0346876197,
0.0124227889,
-0.0231294725,
0.0005311797,
-0.0279027671,
-0.0622480735,
0.034495566,
-0.0083566997,
0.0175054874,
2.271375592e-34,
-0.0092172502,
0.0460890979,
0.0034822994,
0.0265031736,
0.0191820301,
-0.0348872654,
0.0091795921,
0.0061858888,
-0.0103207789,
-0.0537968427,
0.0144521045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11913v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11913v2 | Development of a Trust-Aware User Simulator for Statistical Proactive Dialog Modeling in Human-AI Teams | 2023-04-24T08:42:51 | 2023-06-18T18:56:01 | Matthias Kraus, Ron Riekenbrauck, Wolfgang Minker | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The concept of a Human-AI team has gained increasing attention in recent
years. For effective collaboration between humans and AI teammates, proactivity
is crucial for close coordination and effective communication. However, the
design of adequate proactivity for AI-based systems to support humans is still
an open question and a challenging topic. In this paper, we present the
development of a corpus-based user simulator for training and testing proactive
dialog policies. The simulator incorporates informed knowledge about proactive
dialog and its effect on user trust and simulates user behavior and personal
information, including socio-demographic features and personality traits. Two
different simulation approaches were compared, and a task-step-based approach
yielded better overall results due to enhanced modeling of sequential
dependencies. This research presents a promising avenue for exploring and
evaluating appropriate proactive strategies in a dialog game setting for
improving Human-AI teams. | [
0.0949839652,
0.0000677543,
-0.0625238791,
0.0131364251,
-0.0294893552,
-0.0132359406,
0.0394563153,
-0.0381062068,
0.0428692549,
-0.0118016824,
0.0062704175,
-0.0459168293,
-0.0224051159,
0.0653396994,
0.0026902917,
-0.0782206506,
0.0295221265,
-0.0376554802,
0.0517672338,
0.010400204,
0.024235433,
0.0153636681,
-0.059937451,
0.0733690262,
-0.0266861152,
0.009010775,
-0.0325214043,
-0.0142628988,
0.0292533506,
-0.0261332225,
0.0103213675,
0.0452550389,
0.0102597913,
-0.0312110502,
0.0000021087,
-0.0587515123,
0.0316579677,
-0.0117028086,
-0.0240174532,
-0.0158617422,
0.0431068204,
0.0686922073,
-0.0005064124,
0.0184564404,
-0.0442708209,
0.0672546104,
0.0191995613,
0.0110610165,
0.0686024576,
0.0042022867,
-0.0207260884,
0.0474929512,
-0.0007141336,
0.0028551263,
-0.02054164,
-0.0609090216,
0.0059464434,
-0.0108894985,
0.0349132828,
-0.0127087114,
0.0243464503,
-0.0092327492,
-0.0071941754,
-0.0203152187,
-0.0217311885,
0.0223296583,
0.0005150745,
-0.053480126,
-0.0148940599,
0.0636969134,
0.0363790393,
0.0199717022,
0.0373438671,
-0.0209520552,
0.0236496124,
0.0527423881,
0.0191566292,
-0.0208189618,
-0.0467915162,
-0.0466995873,
-0.0257921051,
0.0011579653,
-0.0186862573,
0.0028836103,
0.0130731668,
0.0284912363,
-0.012688173,
-0.0211772639,
0.0028878625,
-0.0010970214,
0.0258784965,
-0.0612371042,
0.0291226637,
0.0157159269,
-0.0839859545,
0.0335437879,
-0.0186051782,
0.0067826612,
0.0138065172,
0.0149348602,
-0.0136681199,
0.0211133268,
0.0181891266,
0.0171220619,
0.0721937343,
0.0411269404,
0.0429412797,
-0.0399229936,
0.0343027115,
-0.0007419682,
-0.0735771358,
0.0004836335,
-0.0518519953,
-0.007374852,
0.0140901506,
-0.0290012304,
-0.0323956795,
0.0403642319,
-0.0390616246,
0.0387544632,
0.0258731823,
-0.0002266617,
-0.0473019555,
0.0133418329,
-0.0640973076,
-0.0161091406,
-0.0588327125,
0.0361594819,
-0.0015768217,
-0.0599463396,
0.0231343471,
-0.0067046848,
-0.0278172325,
-0.0004450414,
-0.0247791465,
0.0037469536,
-0.0109404409,
-0.0160516277,
0.0120158689,
-0.0196648184,
-0.000361689,
-0.0376992859,
-0.0332138799,
-0.0297589302,
0.0343798883,
-0.0243794471,
0.0018379788,
-0.0358227715,
0.0057534832,
0.0387657657,
-0.002116425,
0.0611874349,
-0.0114782043,
-0.0006795229,
0.0432218537,
0.0306657441,
-0.0578452572,
0.0249687303,
0.0284014158,
0.0355641358,
0.0196197871,
0.0040397281,
0.0326912031,
0.007350619,
0.0001306847,
0.0049193874,
0.0591796525,
-0.0031812987,
-0.0422119647,
0.0087037263,
0.0150025003,
0.0511331744,
-0.0449186973,
-0.0112537462,
0.0708172172,
0.0983336791,
-0.0029582032,
0.0146379285,
0.0357074216,
0.0640542433,
0.0235402379,
-0.0193704553,
-0.0087584145,
0.0189202074,
0.0383661129,
-0.0064516491,
-0.0418725908,
0.0579342544,
-0.0315778069,
-0.0133497696,
0.0398896039,
-0.0306890476,
0.0180880334,
-0.0066803037,
0.0054892637,
-0.0194096267,
-0.0223584659,
0.0047459072,
-0.0198633708,
-0.0552503914,
-0.0175872426,
-0.0539918691,
0.0417841934,
0.1133305803,
0.0510383397,
-0.0267941877,
-0.0276966784,
-0.0260209534,
-0.0182739776,
0.0335080586,
-0.0028277705,
-0.0094561093,
-0.0130149499,
-0.0360450782,
-0.0379566401,
0.0365696624,
-0.0177809875,
0.0481104665,
0.0099155065,
0.0036886667,
-0.0037331786,
0.0705814511,
0.0419405587,
0.0013125099,
-0.0204444937,
0.0334597938,
-0.0351374373,
0.0017894445,
0.0784321949,
0.0482207462,
-0.018984044,
-0.0195593741,
0.0171956215,
0.03948313,
-0.0233837366,
0.0776530951,
-0.0234210473,
0.0333127715,
0.0200771131,
-0.0457897931,
-0.0372803658,
0.0106804073,
0.011253044,
-0.016763011,
0.0065544602,
-0.0225393735,
-0.0056709382,
-0.0364269018,
0.0098508932,
-0.0158808231,
-0.0001222769,
-0.008580694,
-0.0018725938,
-0.0332517251,
-0.0355205834,
0.004894007,
0.0180217959,
0.0083195902,
-0.0683195442,
0.0319729708,
0.0206339862,
0.0088003157,
-0.0017446824,
0.0219372064,
-0.0050588055,
-0.054715503,
-0.007539744,
-0.0959475338,
-0.0492878966,
0.0106428638,
-0.0167352874,
-0.0152596422,
-0.0046882126,
-0.0399033651,
-0.0286537185,
-0.033873979,
0.0075749187,
0.0182378776,
0.0013831794,
0.0312028527,
0.0031975855,
-0.0400585644,
-0.0507125258,
0.0287966896,
-0.0080359755,
-0.0291092545,
0.0076643345,
0.0028729369,
-0.0538291745,
-0.0244942792,
-0.0109223779,
0.0217540208,
-0.0239973012,
-0.063334696,
0.0563350283,
0.0260525085,
0.0489201397,
0.0311901346,
0.0310486034,
0.0588600822,
0.0262995642,
-0.0073751323,
-0.0420850106,
0.0251124483,
0.0223068167,
-0.000138943,
-0.0465318784,
-0.0676567703,
0.0265214574,
0.0467281044,
-0.000276372,
0.0357370228,
-0.0360417999,
-0.0015431723,
-0.0038709734,
-0.0636634901,
0.0157978665,
-0.0648962259,
-0.0544520617,
0.0306262337,
-0.0079515148,
0.0038831134,
0.0812981352,
-0.0057520187,
0.0147318561,
-0.0615487695,
-0.016945146,
0.0191041715,
0.0306485351,
0.0141405025,
-0.0101554822,
0.0270396974,
-0.0124322604,
-0.0316264667,
-0.0295236185,
0.0364054553,
-0.0214178581,
-0.0188997742,
-0.0575545952,
-0.0237783566,
0.0291050132,
-0.0099838097,
-0.0280007981,
-0.0294792764,
-0.057753861,
-0.0312491599,
0.073610954,
-0.0557773449,
-0.0133343823,
0.0038019987,
0.0438462645,
0.0029428278,
0.0170622189,
-0.0330653489,
0.0069155465,
0.0001017557,
0.0708520114,
0.0164142027,
-0.027987415,
0.0041862284,
0.0417860709,
0.0532113649,
0.0691994205,
-0.0371788256,
-0.017545389,
-0.0524707884,
0.0177099891,
-0.0210247319,
0.0087562306,
0.0607779622,
0.0381889194,
0.0177064445,
-0.0045569362,
0.1066187471,
0.053127747,
-0.0445435867,
0.0084500639,
-0.012222819,
0.0048593385,
-0.0073256181,
0.0378842689,
-0.0597388744,
-0.0015101482,
-0.0090615842,
0.0260912795,
-0.0379281193,
-0.0570184849,
0.017452715,
-0.0603384078,
0.0312167145,
-0.04558108,
0.0060329121,
-0.005950809,
-0.0452956222,
0.0227489099,
-0.0115237348,
0.0053531541,
-0.0326960497,
0.0440932326,
-0.010063,
0.0248119682,
-0.0635458007,
-0.0125783747,
0.0634106472,
-0.0505402908,
0.0788173229,
0.0559868515,
0.070983693,
0.0170234982,
-0.0275048725,
-0.0615130104,
0.0482260212,
0.0412905738,
0.0007540767,
0.0470512062,
-0.0216910038,
0.0379565619,
-0.0332474299,
0.0111181643,
-0.0277012754,
-0.0167314205,
0.0552565791,
0.0272958856,
-0.0611622222,
0.0074060597,
-0.0513912737,
0.0155090941,
0.0692780688,
0.0315446407,
-0.0002049134,
-0.0626594126,
0.0006357823,
-0.0080946051,
-0.0069688461,
-0.0315411203,
-0.0311676078,
-0.0382970087,
0.0025861345,
-0.0148677472,
-0.0655282959,
-0.0905875787,
-0.0186313,
0.0221269,
-0.0094619254,
-0.0406169668,
0.0501972996,
0.0290440191,
0.0104167564,
-0.0203076862,
-0.0125150448,
0.05874281,
-0.0098486459,
0.0115152681,
0.0153813269,
-0.0130129149,
0.0165774506,
0.0237018764,
-0.0085119605,
-0.0383744016,
0.023455495,
0.0827654302,
0.0261187628,
0.0177832469,
-0.0065890024,
-0.0530782416,
-0.0169459116,
-0.0227333512,
-0.0491413027,
-0.0102699678,
0.0279142894,
0.0273694396,
0.0074631139,
-0.0137140611,
-0.0005229828,
0.0122790057,
-0.0592380464,
-0.0101361498,
-0.0712225512,
-0.0992693827,
-0.0038028141,
-0.0107002966,
0.0390833318,
-0.0126705486,
0.0032451574,
-0.0256988052,
0.0383697711,
-0.0651128888,
0.0255424269,
-0.0137020824,
0.004550728,
-0.0083550392,
-0.0234717131,
0.0361082368,
-0.0361258611,
-0.0677568391,
0.0202760212,
0.0195670631,
0.0295706093,
0.0558945835,
0.0893714949,
-0.0088138813,
-0.0267429054,
-0.0051098899,
0.0086081671,
0.0124564469,
0.0365084074,
0.0451965556,
0.1088368669,
-0.0112632047,
-0.0626354441,
0.0482683517,
0.035329558,
-0.056434378,
-0.0108884424,
0.0377869122,
0.0083955042,
0.0078884531,
0.0139272278,
0.0139340274,
-0.0679536387,
0.031628523,
0.0150304874,
0.0117306737,
0.0086415559,
0.0070788055,
0.0183228981,
0.0323555507,
-0.0076912283,
0.0217309631,
0.0622814,
0.0143514303,
0.0031768258,
-0.0698668286,
-0.0410778485,
-0.0502410568,
-0.0071397838,
-0.0228350013,
0.0658341795,
-0.0339746401,
-0.0277344882,
-0.0818017721,
-0.055218149,
-0.0041199988,
0.0198497586,
0.0226161852,
-0.0456911176,
0.0485442318,
0.0547908284,
-0.0001986988,
-0.0061670155,
-0.0445722751,
0.0027367021,
-0.0294696111,
-0.0129155945,
-0.0377869271,
-5.540044264e-33,
-0.0121705439,
-0.0887760669,
0.0477779694,
0.0190377962,
0.0109844292,
-0.0394667871,
-0.0350733474,
0.0170766097,
-0.0086177988,
0.016227968,
-0.0213859826,
0.033843834,
0.0153759317,
-0.0464828759,
-0.0050359378,
0.0449270904,
0.0386162624,
-0.0379055552,
-0.0077522658,
0.0182998329,
0.0276001263,
-0.0023794153,
-0.0340016186,
-0.1098456681,
0.0503266454,
-0.0075182095,
-0.0416851602,
-0.0135701271,
0.0088086445,
0.0391711481,
0.0037648848,
0.013641716,
0.0162018389,
-0.0224734284,
0.0298411082,
0.0538037606,
-0.0218303502,
-0.0570892058,
0.0209087413,
-0.023744015,
-0.0006727734,
-0.010533358,
-0.0583553314,
-0.0102313561,
-0.0431991406,
0.0230672415,
0.0430784672,
-0.0033265543,
-0.0015455072,
-0.0189580061,
-0.0534582846,
0.0040359921,
-0.0416694805,
-0.0334189646,
-0.015219572,
0.0793542117,
-0.0286941156,
-0.0431618914,
-0.0459022149,
0.0405038074,
-0.010466774,
-0.0471614711,
0.0692888424,
0.0140557811,
0.0256568789,
0.028563248,
0.023784833,
0.0418339558,
-0.0622788519,
-0.0295846183,
-0.0021224024,
0.0223640297,
0.0348052345,
0.0766030699,
-0.0408091843,
-0.0327254795,
-0.0006128993,
0.0518893488,
0.0945306793,
0.0429970771,
0.0019574701,
0.0282211676,
-0.0937654525,
0.0143639725,
-0.0119050695,
0.0126922801,
0.0011530335,
-0.0836582109,
0.0209955126,
-0.0003972806,
0.0068786349,
-0.0054174289,
-0.0041509978,
0.0068191206,
0.0081394706,
0.0027812996,
0.0093652187,
-0.0038423804,
0.0010509989,
-0.0284062568,
-0.0585155226,
-0.0032847999,
0.0275818985,
0.0422540233,
0.0494442023,
0.0064984323,
-0.0141263632,
-0.0053090807,
-0.0081531517,
-0.0260280631,
-0.0146864578,
0.0369832739,
0.0130088842,
-0.0153507115,
0.011917985,
-0.0162245762,
-0.0383377038,
0.0593805201,
-0.0047939513,
-0.0648218021,
-0.0394139439,
0.0242263693,
-0.0149666257,
-0.0170742106,
-0.0223836713,
-0.0337223038,
-0.0296020638,
0.0030881925,
0.0316969529,
-0.032805413,
-0.0080244979,
-0.0518105589,
2.787e-7,
-0.0515373424,
0.0460583344,
0.0057098935,
0.010819912,
0.0359474756,
0.0428087711,
0.0126816761,
0.0198665727,
0.0459029227,
-0.0165337808,
0.0790513158,
0.0321548432,
0.024171954,
0.0378474109,
-0.0697676763,
-0.0436742343,
-0.0228713825,
-0.0229582042,
-0.0500665121,
0.0286889393,
0.0711475462,
-0.0102968672,
0.0227652974,
-0.0057282732,
-0.002456815,
0.0280944705,
-0.0018722955,
-0.0282906778,
-0.0202296171,
-0.0147670545,
0.0581502728,
-0.0433765538,
0.0120439362,
0.0664226636,
-0.0294560418,
-0.0026622978,
-0.0098874876,
0.0585464984,
-0.0229358748,
-0.0171883199,
0.0012669689,
-0.0377686918,
0.0040830979,
-0.0325585566,
-0.0032966423,
-0.0538636521,
-0.0307830945,
0.0022391009,
-0.0503061377,
-0.0290493276,
-0.0003513109,
-0.0089943791,
0.013787861,
0.0180515777,
-0.0344339497,
0.0280543324,
0.0274401121,
-0.0299922135,
0.0262138564,
-0.0280711688,
-0.0169161092,
-0.0792871565,
-0.0121303108,
-0.0243365504,
-0.0125576481,
-0.0067374413,
0.0419583097,
1.989552199e-34,
-0.0026789312,
0.0001443199,
0.0042151343,
0.0103994748,
0.0628493726,
0.0293591712,
0.0249375105,
0.0611566901,
0.0911954939,
-0.0168958288,
-0.0179417599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12998v1 | ChatLLM Network: More brains, More intelligence | 2023-04-24T08:29:14 | 2023-04-24T08:29:14 | Rui Hao, Linmei Hu, Weijian Qi, Qingliu Wu, Yirui Zhang, Liqiang Nie | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Dialogue-based language models mark a huge milestone in the field of
artificial intelligence, by their impressive ability to interact with users, as
well as a series of challenging tasks prompted by customized instructions.
However, the prevalent large-scale dialogue-based language models like ChatGPT
still have room for improvement, such as unstable responses to questions and
the inability to think cooperatively like humans. Considering the ability of
dialogue-based language models in conversation and their inherent randomness in
thinking, we propose ChatLLM network that allows multiple dialogue-based
language models to interact, provide feedback, and think together. We design
the network of ChatLLMs based on ChatGPT. Specifically, individual instances of
ChatGPT may possess distinct perspectives towards the same problem, and by
consolidating these diverse viewpoints via a separate ChatGPT, the ChatLLM
network system can conduct decision-making more objectively and
comprehensively. In addition, a language-based feedback mechanism comparable to
backpropagation is devised to update the ChatGPTs within the network.
Experiments on two datasets demonstrate that our network attains significant
improvements in problem-solving, leading to observable progress amongst each
member. | [
0.0457736924,
0.0380103774,
-0.0215972364,
0.0230025984,
-0.0690487698,
-0.0061540846,
0.030063292,
-0.0259984341,
0.0629554316,
-0.0192716829,
-0.0402407944,
-0.0343356915,
0.0007715856,
0.0497478507,
0.0223191306,
-0.0208885465,
0.0428168513,
-0.0452227592,
0.0382716917,
-0.0323802046,
-0.0029272807,
-0.0062328596,
-0.034339577,
0.0624420792,
0.003306411,
0.0078713605,
-0.0485837497,
-0.0179918893,
-0.0067332624,
-0.0017629524,
0.013902626,
0.0432798639,
0.0057176854,
0.0497933328,
0.0000021411,
-0.0280430019,
0.0143243372,
-0.0598455742,
0.0091712242,
-0.0298343636,
-0.0022561485,
0.0577192269,
-0.0179595426,
0.0347759873,
-0.0749634653,
-0.0076137325,
0.0222522169,
0.0541027747,
0.0932991207,
0.0682274625,
0.009345673,
0.0060409205,
0.0134125892,
-0.0317676403,
0.0442008711,
-0.0505409911,
0.0310307331,
0.0392056294,
0.0172466263,
0.0091071576,
-0.0175366364,
0.0459021702,
0.0276612043,
-0.0450248346,
-0.0050629466,
0.0354281701,
-0.012901322,
-0.0302825235,
-0.0141824726,
0.0679249838,
0.0002650012,
-0.0067826454,
-0.0155887138,
0.0160034634,
0.0248033982,
-0.0088140778,
-0.0667014569,
0.0251693465,
0.0091339117,
0.0134031074,
-0.0261125136,
0.0014783217,
0.0381494388,
0.00571266,
-0.0122879064,
0.0497207418,
-0.0155284824,
-0.0140740788,
-0.0136865722,
0.007434451,
-0.0098772841,
-0.0564177781,
0.0300185904,
0.0473145321,
-0.0565353632,
0.0292578116,
-0.007239508,
0.0115275504,
0.0021282209,
-0.069716692,
0.0100248121,
0.0150389066,
0.0130636171,
0.0522013828,
-0.0026009989,
0.0282884669,
-0.018625522,
0.0071747676,
-0.0346235447,
-0.022699913,
-0.0859226808,
-0.0259325337,
-0.034204334,
0.0536965318,
-0.0073089027,
-0.0569815636,
-0.0372748151,
0.0588208027,
-0.0229526814,
0.0034454055,
0.0320780016,
0.0586175956,
0.010950095,
-0.0135112936,
-0.052074898,
0.0164554343,
0.0083479136,
-0.0014940161,
0.0275447872,
-0.0265867338,
-0.0153174903,
0.0118731512,
-0.0259849969,
0.0126862274,
-0.0170016512,
0.1270574778,
-0.0175410509,
0.0050257728,
-0.0119206654,
-0.0066259908,
0.0171348676,
-0.0386401974,
-0.0034830484,
-0.0782341361,
0.0294017047,
-0.011031298,
-0.0161330663,
-0.0164569058,
0.0149989352,
0.0102483984,
-0.0454921573,
0.06754677,
-0.0229989085,
0.0152679356,
0.0805290937,
0.0155377397,
-0.009041829,
0.0545561686,
0.0551291741,
-0.0246619843,
0.0187385026,
0.0061106719,
0.010931096,
0.0492065661,
0.0093533853,
-0.0136071779,
0.0168518461,
-0.0402184874,
0.0020455127,
0.0629911348,
-0.0436926298,
0.0583723858,
-0.0591745004,
-0.0087090144,
0.0761922449,
0.0728282109,
0.0006469226,
0.0348453857,
0.0088837706,
0.0163905118,
-0.0009547693,
-0.0238788761,
-0.0335406736,
0.052869916,
-0.0005763855,
-0.0097250072,
0.0029811254,
-0.0002405266,
-0.0321064964,
-0.0464599989,
0.0106346048,
-0.0018310422,
0.0410488248,
0.0206144676,
0.0376909785,
-0.003542691,
-0.0284855459,
0.0173894241,
0.0160814412,
-0.0209041368,
-0.025262855,
-0.0631943345,
0.0208233371,
0.0724904239,
0.0628554821,
0.0012767604,
-0.0720357969,
-0.009451922,
-0.0107415793,
0.0656083003,
0.0423685946,
-0.0098902937,
-0.0205794759,
-0.0461565182,
-0.0197926331,
0.0335530117,
-0.0259319041,
0.0414265767,
-0.0096088592,
-0.012634364,
-0.0214461088,
0.0623667873,
-0.0092579136,
0.0042207981,
-0.0299147386,
0.0517258532,
0.0171478484,
-0.0199481044,
0.0502832904,
0.0025560393,
-0.0032595817,
0.0011693583,
-0.0003269818,
-0.0241948385,
-0.0688370168,
0.0443194285,
-0.0613955222,
-0.0609339699,
0.0402775072,
0.0027144537,
0.0065537198,
0.0119812218,
-0.0316251926,
-0.0667185038,
0.0676889494,
-0.0450619906,
0.0200636424,
-0.0479840189,
0.0018174472,
0.0132425074,
-0.0048551233,
-0.0303488448,
0.0388246216,
-0.0162579417,
-0.016772151,
0.0014550687,
0.0433695093,
0.0260932576,
-0.0714538693,
-0.0118493,
0.0112357102,
0.0049160123,
0.0129432399,
0.0183767527,
0.0551741235,
-0.0275638755,
-0.0312799029,
-0.1103032082,
-0.0152889481,
0.0106288753,
-0.0074913227,
-0.003864822,
0.008194657,
0.0067645046,
-0.0210365895,
-0.0687900558,
0.0488304086,
0.0593729503,
-0.0098480908,
0.052103702,
0.0096169431,
-0.0441136397,
-0.0581695773,
-0.0227903519,
-0.0043706261,
0.034592703,
0.0050535384,
-0.0551534966,
-0.071915552,
-0.0008514282,
-0.0493158773,
0.0581400506,
-0.0324663222,
-0.0486098528,
0.0370266959,
-0.023261629,
0.0190985613,
0.0664008185,
0.041060172,
-0.0095252078,
0.0206905957,
-0.036686115,
-0.090071857,
0.0401623622,
-0.0254608821,
0.0079814419,
-0.0182585958,
-0.0074804337,
-0.0013286389,
0.058085613,
-0.000053464,
-0.0081237704,
-0.0478006341,
0.0566932522,
0.0451132841,
-0.0284555629,
-0.052775722,
-0.0333574563,
-0.031121321,
0.0246722847,
-0.0332463942,
-0.0256031435,
0.0965713114,
-0.0089495871,
-0.0107097067,
-0.041142799,
-0.019281555,
-0.0342333354,
0.043975018,
-0.0021598835,
0.0100493226,
-0.0165394843,
-0.022496663,
-0.046837192,
0.0118021136,
0.0179744624,
-0.0302294828,
0.0277526621,
-0.0496388227,
0.0189806167,
0.0220032055,
-0.0463330299,
-0.0572368316,
0.012999326,
-0.0312303603,
0.0274146665,
0.0571481399,
-0.0223846398,
-0.0308949873,
0.020813223,
0.0119595164,
0.0189907141,
-0.0383191146,
0.0017836434,
-0.0326538235,
-0.006441969,
0.0284021609,
0.0113641741,
0.0258109067,
-0.0232305005,
0.0568674207,
0.0473779403,
0.0307290815,
0.0023379922,
-0.0223979894,
0.0165320747,
-0.0078819199,
-0.0132862804,
-0.0066302158,
-0.0280916765,
0.0452800058,
-0.0211823303,
-0.0380464345,
0.120935075,
0.0254206434,
-0.0736490935,
-0.024350293,
-0.0201648865,
0.002184564,
0.0107803391,
0.0445469357,
-0.0425247028,
-0.0244697351,
0.0023074199,
-0.0032993504,
0.008408024,
-0.0396575406,
-0.0133212032,
-0.0969584733,
-0.0193804521,
0.0110779442,
-0.0427491926,
0.0151832132,
-0.0019397833,
-0.0204756856,
-0.0152207064,
0.0076635778,
0.0195264369,
0.0454722382,
-0.0430126451,
-0.0084236693,
-0.015172461,
-0.0119776065,
0.0372657105,
-0.0291973762,
0.1160820723,
0.0730734915,
0.0008490046,
0.0140354736,
-0.0092808548,
0.0856227279,
0.0492436551,
0.0088979583,
-0.0155774234,
0.0074965903,
-0.0059692683,
-0.0255574044,
-0.0203029551,
0.0247935634,
-0.0299110413,
-0.0010196152,
0.0150615452,
0.0496345125,
-0.0341662504,
-0.0091225393,
-0.0208909772,
0.0630224794,
0.0156010976,
0.0511630476,
0.017898431,
-0.0659610331,
-0.0460967533,
-0.0336953849,
-0.0670872629,
-0.0275475271,
-0.0491896011,
-0.0172264427,
0.0198556818,
0.0096311551,
-0.0559864156,
-0.0316482484,
0.0148357712,
-0.0065330039,
0.0072192973,
-0.0233466923,
0.0302194413,
0.0274709146,
0.0270507317,
0.0030469634,
-0.0031903307,
-0.006291782,
-0.0477206334,
-0.0182561427,
0.0380264707,
-0.0500469394,
-0.0190211739,
0.0497197658,
-0.0805855617,
-0.0670848489,
-0.0117857577,
0.0749188215,
0.0274634529,
0.0295929145,
-0.0248101726,
-0.0463585332,
0.0160834994,
0.0218409114,
-0.0200058687,
-0.005196074,
0.0027815192,
0.0670215487,
0.0049622385,
0.0499235317,
-0.0146701783,
0.0336239338,
0.0110210776,
0.028761087,
-0.0591009706,
-0.0489373691,
-0.0127648832,
-0.0167220067,
0.0177330282,
0.0355115496,
0.0132692717,
-0.046368029,
0.009503128,
0.0004218739,
-0.0330780819,
-0.0658406466,
0.015889775,
0.0008417885,
-0.0564331934,
0.0252107587,
-0.0428151749,
-0.0042502484,
-0.0070109945,
0.0172737315,
-0.0265391022,
0.0072708228,
0.0149287609,
0.0036004919,
0.0110311294,
-0.0136927059,
0.0146406069,
0.0130443182,
0.006270715,
-0.0084693423,
0.091972664,
0.0099326596,
-0.0390964337,
-0.0008000864,
0.0271636397,
-0.0958732516,
-0.0825520009,
0.0185607411,
0.093396768,
0.0455892645,
0.0834571347,
0.0172368754,
-0.0598481409,
0.0240825638,
-0.024021361,
0.0189987347,
0.0028716212,
-0.0090663675,
0.0355817415,
0.0218384787,
-0.0053267521,
-0.0121191284,
0.0582360886,
-0.0172931198,
-0.0222075619,
-0.0078106276,
0.0041171131,
-0.0391943827,
0.0008665589,
-0.0020252499,
0.0485695824,
-0.0226822849,
0.0251541119,
-0.0055108848,
-0.0389697067,
-0.0258912165,
0.0619156659,
0.0361685753,
-0.0043977839,
0.0273364633,
0.0528311282,
0.0129552092,
0.0050743995,
0.0082480088,
0.0114911702,
-0.0389599167,
-0.0256241094,
-0.0396733731,
-6.300821636e-33,
-0.0139047727,
-0.032989338,
0.0388136618,
0.0470171608,
-0.0165364705,
-0.0339242183,
-0.0432695337,
0.0426299125,
-0.034744937,
0.0098919645,
-0.021972185,
0.0427254513,
0.0041372506,
0.0302651804,
0.0294011701,
-0.0127400104,
0.0195534565,
-0.0117344372,
0.0077069183,
0.045937065,
0.0323766693,
0.028898811,
0.0641304329,
-0.0722479671,
0.0140407681,
-0.0364043228,
-0.0035524212,
0.064866513,
-0.0239563175,
0.0454828516,
-0.0282201916,
0.0335349701,
0.0184113607,
-0.0482288711,
-0.0382301807,
-0.0006212141,
-0.0322593339,
-0.0430007651,
0.0206646789,
0.0110926349,
-0.0453979149,
0.0018887885,
0.0376721844,
-0.0267796516,
-0.0228828005,
-0.0013311668,
0.0273121521,
-0.0126439249,
-0.0234324224,
0.0509610102,
0.0006856574,
0.0069437064,
-0.0115130255,
-0.0592120439,
-0.0398154445,
-0.0002627168,
-0.0426533222,
-0.0327040367,
-0.021024473,
0.0365909301,
-0.0003793359,
0.0223953873,
0.0408933237,
0.0150470166,
0.0189809706,
0.0645235255,
0.0370601974,
0.016703859,
-0.0449665077,
-0.0370051712,
0.0030287181,
0.0465987623,
0.0614655726,
0.0320793986,
-0.0369771756,
-0.0195210837,
-0.0596861504,
-0.0168117639,
0.0601378828,
0.032107275,
0.0287302006,
0.008562495,
0.0009307227,
-0.031902995,
-0.0394593552,
-0.0383867994,
-0.032965295,
-0.0396204367,
-0.0013130646,
0.0126267709,
0.0129744029,
-0.0380330086,
0.0248897206,
-0.0573630482,
0.009353552,
0.0403326154,
-0.0182055105,
0.0179754458,
0.0062846644,
-0.0006246606,
-0.0653936416,
-0.0078844987,
-0.0126358317,
0.035852626,
-0.0364664681,
0.0249807332,
0.0041185212,
-0.0049954457,
-0.0272851661,
-0.0248663705,
-0.0203313939,
0.0324248858,
-0.0246906728,
0.0222587511,
0.012970292,
-0.0072636977,
-0.0314636715,
0.0292840526,
0.0008159424,
-0.0147806089,
-0.0338211395,
-0.019780023,
-0.0277720988,
0.0080589708,
-0.0300018732,
0.0226722918,
-0.0490778089,
0.023943672,
0.0099841524,
-0.0412585065,
0.0031934166,
0.014398546,
2.824e-7,
-0.0102041122,
0.0485891886,
0.0332508646,
0.0259844977,
0.0677951947,
0.0460374467,
-0.0394899882,
0.014386504,
0.0375846326,
-0.0187818576,
-0.0032612071,
0.06957113,
0.028434746,
0.0010447409,
-0.0981795937,
-0.0564207546,
-0.0928995833,
-0.0244484805,
-0.0221282188,
-0.0184202455,
0.0468351096,
0.056516692,
0.0313940682,
-0.015259726,
0.0075500729,
-0.0436028652,
0.0714424327,
-0.044852104,
-0.0281761624,
0.030189354,
0.0142398113,
-0.0032152699,
-0.0093815271,
0.0325418003,
0.0296834335,
0.0158197396,
-0.0429152846,
0.0343213342,
0.0064260508,
-0.0451355539,
-0.0052090259,
0.0216031969,
0.0065095578,
-0.0218517538,
0.0399502814,
-0.0759081766,
-0.0222822987,
-0.021249745,
0.0620213225,
-0.0439418592,
0.0600723363,
-0.0307967179,
-0.0405998789,
-0.0003725757,
0.0041721929,
0.0086500859,
0.0222277101,
-0.0958211273,
0.0124540534,
-0.0145362206,
-0.0724563152,
-0.0501375645,
-0.0311858561,
-0.0043635964,
0.0385236815,
-0.0151000638,
0.014373431,
2.118434134e-34,
0.051364623,
0.0042323279,
0.0113114296,
0.0381965265,
0.0323664583,
0.0044106338,
0.0354140177,
0.0168303996,
0.0390424356,
-0.0457530729,
-0.050386034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13731v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13731v2 | Text-to-Audio Generation using Instruction-Tuned LLM and Latent Diffusion Model | 2023-04-24T07:45:28 | 2023-05-29T12:09:08 | Deepanway Ghosal, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Soujanya Poria | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | The immense scale of the recent large language models (LLM) allows many
interesting properties, such as, instruction- and chain-of-thought-based
fine-tuning, that has significantly improved zero- and few-shot performance in
many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Inspired by such successes, we
adopt such an instruction-tuned LLM Flan-T5 as the text encoder for
text-to-audio (TTA) generation -- a task where the goal is to generate an audio
from its textual description. The prior works on TTA either pre-trained a joint
text-audio encoder or used a non-instruction-tuned model, such as, T5.
Consequently, our latent diffusion model (LDM)-based approach TANGO outperforms
the state-of-the-art AudioLDM on most metrics and stays comparable on the rest
on AudioCaps test set, despite training the LDM on a 63 times smaller dataset
and keeping the text encoder frozen. This improvement might also be attributed
to the adoption of audio pressure level-based sound mixing for training set
augmentation, whereas the prior methods take a random mix. | [
-0.0008559339,
0.0157071911,
0.019740643,
0.0426075347,
-0.0000900755,
-0.0257593449,
0.0266280882,
-0.0374427438,
-0.0715509281,
-0.0154214595,
-0.0586139597,
-0.0422923863,
0.0325776227,
0.0376214832,
0.0316948034,
-0.0479562953,
-0.0216913912,
-0.0514767766,
-0.0416385196,
-0.0199229587,
-0.0197920073,
0.0328135863,
-0.0350961573,
0.0125914002,
0.0091737071,
0.0023158677,
-0.0112101324,
0.0222952329,
0.0336768255,
-0.0087732049,
-0.0323766693,
0.0060373386,
0.0591265634,
-0.0156252515,
0.0000021311,
-0.0105862617,
0.0035349715,
0.0108767562,
0.0188808739,
0.0106622959,
0.0522151105,
-0.02648413,
-0.0402857512,
0.0441524535,
0.0310929641,
0.0038312308,
0.0364848301,
0.0583516881,
0.0606744848,
0.0849808976,
-0.0164037328,
-0.1107400432,
0.0323430113,
-0.033551462,
0.0452166945,
-0.017108297,
-0.008156823,
-0.0144722378,
0.0192641411,
0.0230882969,
-0.0145691289,
0.0413633063,
0.0095575154,
-0.0006013531,
0.0406057052,
0.0580023155,
0.0057171336,
-0.0132251224,
-0.0034892601,
0.0810963884,
0.0026112546,
-0.0085399188,
-0.0088220369,
0.0039762594,
-0.0493820645,
-0.0289428718,
-0.0159367565,
0.0328424983,
0.0246441532,
0.0376619212,
-0.0080330884,
0.0096334415,
0.0347992592,
-0.0372911431,
0.0149602648,
-0.0198750421,
0.0238605626,
-0.0505565889,
0.0055783992,
0.0009242757,
-0.0237629041,
-0.033834625,
0.0396380797,
0.0323016755,
-0.0092886621,
-0.0227939039,
-0.0537340678,
-0.0305246115,
-0.0313785896,
-0.0280841663,
0.0453696027,
0.0554256588,
0.0040450594,
0.0266381968,
-0.0394550636,
0.0047402875,
-0.0067083989,
-0.039042864,
-0.0433086902,
0.0098397527,
-0.0203924384,
0.0091539351,
-0.0282837097,
0.0130114537,
-0.0237415805,
-0.0349352732,
-0.0521426685,
-0.0146172419,
0.009613621,
0.0107240155,
0.0322975554,
0.0131827267,
-0.0505504832,
-0.0168761499,
0.0135468338,
0.0180600192,
0.0047486397,
0.0730504468,
0.0193080772,
0.0239844266,
-0.0478955023,
0.0301130526,
0.0354048237,
-0.0162893087,
0.0292635038,
0.0531472005,
-0.0345964879,
-0.008443675,
-0.0338385813,
-0.0110454094,
-0.0069792317,
-0.0696719661,
-0.0053233504,
-0.0825371966,
0.0404023044,
-0.0282756016,
-0.0088195475,
-0.0007466386,
0.0080904076,
0.0353739262,
0.0001763959,
0.0345928259,
-0.0051850062,
0.0483493358,
0.050716199,
-0.0038993207,
0.0331816971,
0.0557951443,
0.1081301495,
0.0401058421,
-0.0407218821,
-0.0168565437,
-0.0219097268,
0.0445914194,
0.0087639196,
0.0093586408,
-0.0144727025,
-0.0337673128,
-0.0583319962,
0.0558230281,
0.0757142529,
0.0768078938,
-0.0251983348,
0.0122753708,
0.0835895911,
0.0104807196,
0.0368104242,
0.0006220593,
0.0839627981,
0.0125783123,
-0.0183642451,
0.0049712895,
0.040779788,
0.051085636,
0.0054609142,
0.0462319031,
0.08067967,
0.0251595825,
-0.0291012898,
-0.0058255857,
0.0015183809,
-0.0338818505,
-0.0022423887,
-0.0208467878,
0.0265153442,
0.0261326227,
-0.0732498616,
0.0399614647,
-0.0057436218,
-0.0450203791,
0.0132310167,
-0.0117486371,
0.0287743527,
0.0762885883,
0.0371329337,
-0.0111462288,
0.0338583104,
-0.0523277,
0.0064076297,
0.0914570764,
0.0044724173,
0.0203662589,
0.0124713769,
-0.0672897846,
-0.0208673961,
-0.0355048105,
0.0073162317,
0.0188477878,
-0.0257035233,
0.0565988459,
0.0249695815,
-0.0120932339,
0.0023421864,
0.0072074705,
-0.0474143364,
-0.0381944627,
0.0341692343,
0.000377782,
0.0253131557,
0.0263502672,
-0.0471240953,
0.0147109665,
0.0178624224,
-0.0712034926,
-0.0165699292,
-0.0038592627,
-0.0666885003,
-0.033945892,
-0.0176934004,
-0.051474344,
0.0390560627,
0.0024187686,
-0.0068043931,
-0.0551388599,
0.0166106205,
-0.0094233779,
0.0252046213,
-0.0176757742,
0.0143176904,
0.0389913395,
0.0148520265,
0.0328567438,
0.0336467288,
-0.0038673796,
-0.0312261563,
0.009170359,
0.0611479506,
-0.0074092057,
-0.0209533442,
-0.0277301185,
0.0044233967,
0.0340638012,
0.0034251974,
-0.0223107692,
0.0134672746,
-0.0206567179,
-0.0618898273,
-0.0422937684,
0.0249522179,
-0.0248875041,
0.0043957122,
0.0099946484,
0.003148003,
0.0109773586,
0.0392210223,
-0.0446560942,
-0.0077890982,
-0.0045613418,
-0.0243461356,
-0.0085973246,
-0.0177147426,
-0.0189905539,
-0.0247757602,
0.0058452478,
0.0459320433,
-0.0090964418,
-0.0174639821,
-0.0024473744,
-0.0273896791,
0.0807756856,
0.0023633738,
-0.0115931518,
-0.0034270384,
-0.0257904846,
-0.0071066525,
0.0254548416,
0.0846455693,
0.0150556611,
0.0142983133,
0.0144483205,
0.037989147,
0.0172723401,
0.0014192668,
0.0190258753,
-0.0041055316,
0.0152212903,
-0.0302426703,
-0.0099641513,
-0.0522938296,
0.0562634021,
0.0546958745,
0.0259674769,
-0.0655404106,
-0.0161280204,
-0.0187416468,
-0.0293496978,
0.0024296306,
-0.0456320047,
-0.0416780449,
0.0048874528,
-0.0386347398,
-0.0214383304,
0.0525015108,
-0.0758040398,
-0.0303116422,
-0.0677150041,
-0.0586813018,
-0.0405691303,
0.009895049,
-0.0061951377,
0.019174302,
-0.0020162058,
-0.0061723492,
-0.0385887846,
0.0471174978,
0.0226680003,
-0.0524562746,
0.0188097656,
0.0141611779,
0.0052801655,
-0.0316352397,
-0.0156513341,
-0.0178458542,
-0.0446724519,
0.0125001837,
0.0315489992,
-0.0000485154,
-0.0170337856,
-0.0342697687,
0.040169701,
0.0415313207,
0.0483708493,
-0.0074070832,
0.0050230548,
-0.0582023636,
0.0384212583,
0.0447763093,
-0.0119744064,
-0.0436286926,
-0.057616882,
0.0460093282,
-0.0101455962,
0.0138769718,
0.0100441882,
-0.0313092731,
0.0036206432,
0.0031507469,
0.0336543433,
-0.0211732592,
0.0365596786,
0.0817809701,
-0.0597149245,
-0.0243977178,
0.1061054021,
0.0008314984,
-0.0196312796,
0.0058670202,
0.0643178001,
0.058617074,
-0.0080960244,
-0.0193985663,
-0.0635488853,
-0.0150281591,
0.0179013107,
0.0476868264,
0.017432075,
0.0393093117,
-0.0363682322,
-0.094643265,
0.0684119016,
0.0467717983,
-0.0095517552,
-0.0284995269,
-0.0632374957,
-0.0295970347,
0.0157246813,
0.0503076017,
-0.0049360916,
-0.015535349,
0.0175223369,
0.0413465425,
-0.0068743443,
-0.1056745648,
-0.0029215743,
-0.0302327555,
0.0567417555,
0.0818198696,
0.0239669327,
-0.0421106666,
-0.0299382694,
0.0219788421,
-0.0043834737,
0.0076942956,
0.0238748509,
0.032283105,
0.0073910612,
0.0086772852,
0.0380836949,
0.0517947078,
-0.0188668184,
0.0139546618,
-0.0096234521,
0.0314318798,
-0.0167120956,
-0.0175968911,
-0.006039707,
0.0554576144,
-0.0031309789,
0.0837662518,
0.0312121771,
-0.0523324311,
-0.0066929883,
-0.025653461,
0.0103930831,
-0.0891137719,
-0.0369043574,
-0.0158877447,
-0.0056833406,
-0.0353067741,
-0.0616342053,
-0.0190621596,
-0.0291409455,
0.0328427553,
0.0238750894,
0.0288559832,
-0.0014534513,
-0.0425076969,
-0.0365713611,
-0.0061807944,
-0.003668265,
0.0494486205,
-0.0287981778,
-0.038683176,
0.0458354764,
-0.0604266226,
-0.0099025648,
0.0282735918,
-0.11025621,
-0.0508845784,
-0.0505332574,
0.0014354972,
0.0116803171,
0.0368224122,
-0.0088183666,
-0.0170088205,
0.0963993296,
0.0095893843,
-0.0160746314,
0.0824640915,
0.0149787189,
-0.0088793077,
0.0043606991,
0.0099212723,
-0.0646094307,
0.0459826365,
0.0002385954,
0.0474615246,
0.0197462384,
-0.0231229663,
-0.0032412787,
-0.0393931381,
-0.0007118679,
-0.0229177885,
0.0460183062,
-0.0568224378,
0.0154171707,
-0.0426413603,
0.0289068725,
-0.0663137436,
-0.0129250363,
0.0547121502,
0.0095785195,
-0.0272285379,
-0.0063255564,
0.0261779111,
0.0274314992,
-0.0223701186,
0.0355940834,
0.0064153359,
-0.0251715574,
0.028851673,
0.0137369651,
-0.0177213661,
-0.0063984403,
-0.0141508104,
0.0261006616,
0.0138714612,
0.0506782457,
-0.0132626118,
0.0203388855,
-0.0215725061,
0.0243690889,
-0.0292812884,
0.0261021927,
-0.0683536381,
0.0219193287,
0.0466380641,
0.0001135871,
0.0850476474,
-0.0046685752,
0.0129483975,
-0.0247979555,
0.0230373349,
-0.0509303436,
-0.0061662355,
0.0110232104,
-0.0112555558,
-0.0036434035,
0.0083425771,
0.05167564,
-0.0332177095,
0.0431372039,
-0.0190952271,
0.0459743291,
-0.0070145279,
-0.0032233133,
-0.0463118814,
0.0309674405,
0.033249449,
0.0145030729,
-0.005394361,
-0.0567089804,
0.0064595295,
-0.0237399545,
0.014827895,
-0.0172201581,
0.0454211719,
0.0094000371,
-0.0298766866,
0.025163753,
0.0004175377,
-0.0585380457,
0.009729798,
-0.0360379741,
-0.0260697696,
-6.209830292e-33,
-0.0709281266,
0.0025086219,
0.0238316264,
-0.0172308236,
-0.0626260787,
-0.0200250354,
-0.0702208653,
-0.0187985916,
-0.0063904864,
-0.0065091643,
0.0120216729,
-0.0081289699,
0.0111506982,
0.047153946,
-0.0146969631,
0.0274915006,
0.0881752893,
-0.0719770566,
-0.0244140252,
0.0307678208,
0.0310796089,
0.0131219141,
-0.0125817657,
-0.0338245444,
-0.029536942,
-0.0203559287,
-0.0332274549,
-0.0285541285,
0.01687379,
0.0353968255,
-0.0162076801,
0.0473647267,
-0.0152039388,
-0.0361791328,
-0.025031019,
-0.008806021,
-0.0284855962,
0.000651988,
-0.0036100664,
-0.0051201326,
-0.0151968524,
-0.0346403085,
0.0753440857,
0.0207435731,
-0.0182524696,
-0.0340640135,
0.0267771017,
-0.0128748696,
0.0023757096,
-0.0639808774,
-0.0434517376,
0.009951557,
-0.0247521829,
-0.0522984527,
0.039853368,
0.0296635386,
-0.0171843115,
-0.0001644481,
-0.0923284292,
0.0542991795,
-0.0012364645,
0.0223853812,
0.0354089364,
0.0010735018,
-0.0095195919,
0.0304418597,
0.0168915726,
-0.0076696081,
-0.0338138901,
0.0279227495,
-0.0044646524,
0.0406465232,
0.0008773446,
-0.0050936565,
0.0064294389,
-0.0200550165,
-0.0453172252,
0.0299948081,
-0.0405582637,
-0.0335326865,
0.0523341261,
0.0534808002,
-0.0301596988,
-0.0102071036,
-0.0560461134,
0.0081647132,
-0.0151552148,
-0.0428237282,
0.0518609583,
0.0246826559,
0.0219803974,
-0.059527941,
0.0337508991,
-0.0028946518,
0.0143036172,
-0.0312044192,
-0.0841994584,
0.0331214741,
-0.0195328668,
0.0041720755,
-0.0712845102,
-0.0146892117,
0.0963682532,
0.023821352,
0.0062827365,
0.0177185107,
-0.0009477742,
0.0597340278,
-0.0487023033,
0.0092610801,
-0.0132388687,
0.0227319058,
0.0139054721,
0.0388812609,
-0.0280169249,
-0.0244911741,
-0.0266272705,
0.0640971214,
-0.0324708223,
0.0071682036,
-0.0153987883,
0.0017198761,
-0.0162817165,
0.0225322023,
-0.0455763601,
0.0797179043,
0.0286651608,
0.0124108056,
0.0668675527,
-0.0295098387,
-0.038588874,
0.0247205086,
2.838e-7,
-0.0188728552,
-0.0097126039,
0.0002073352,
0.0110672368,
0.037107788,
0.0250062104,
-0.040696837,
0.0343366116,
0.0161213744,
-0.0190320984,
0.02232733,
0.0315283909,
0.0818732083,
0.0113483919,
-0.0844769627,
0.0321318582,
-0.0562528372,
0.0333152562,
-0.0274543203,
-0.0327443369,
0.0318182185,
0.0757385343,
-0.0161637366,
-0.0222264677,
0.0187969543,
-0.0044131195,
0.0666850358,
0.0083241845,
-0.0228045937,
-0.0428126194,
-0.0043882569,
-0.0156010082,
-0.0264776405,
-0.0074738376,
-0.0538314171,
0.0258872751,
0.0391189121,
0.0664420053,
0.0139125567,
-0.0544847548,
0.0084720422,
0.0505664982,
-0.0332769081,
-0.0023450134,
0.0707594901,
-0.011853558,
-0.043751955,
0.0004096304,
-0.0460419022,
0.0168182496,
-0.0026940638,
-0.0322514847,
-0.0026484213,
-0.0343521908,
0.0350233428,
0.0455783382,
-0.0363012962,
-0.0289360732,
-0.0116464449,
0.0199738834,
-0.0622002184,
-0.0270451792,
-0.0367071815,
-0.0065015652,
0.0195798986,
-0.0265393779,
-0.0369682945,
2.436052248e-34,
0.024224354,
-0.0737209395,
0.0121617168,
-0.0188798495,
0.0201297682,
0.021587193,
-0.0053766984,
-0.0018273756,
-0.0243520327,
-0.09142147,
-0.0619700216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11872v2 | Generation-driven Contrastive Self-training for Zero-shot Text Classification with Instruction-following LLM | 2023-04-24T07:35:38 | 2024-04-15T02:40:54 | Ruohong Zhang, Yau-Shian Wang, Yiming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in zero-shot
language understanding has garnered significant attention. However, employing
LLMs for large-scale inference or domain-specific fine-tuning requires immense
computational resources due to their substantial model size. To overcome these
limitations, we introduce a novel method, namely GenCo, which leverages the
strong generative power of LLMs to assist in training a smaller and more
adaptable language model. In our method, an LLM plays an important role in the
self-training loop of a smaller model in two important ways. Firstly, the LLM
is used to augment each input instance with a variety of possible
continuations, enriching its semantic context for better understanding.
Secondly, it helps crafting additional high-quality training pairs, by
rewriting input texts conditioned on predicted labels. This ensures the
generated texts are highly relevant to the predicted labels, alleviating the
prediction error during pseudo-labeling, while reducing the dependency on large
volumes of unlabeled text. In our experiments, GenCo outperforms previous
state-of-the-art methods when only limited ($<5\%$ of original) in-domain text
data is available. Notably, our approach surpasses the performance of Alpaca-7B
with human prompts, highlighting the potential of leveraging LLM for
self-training. | [
0.0198545102,
0.0342289172,
0.0274448041,
0.0284740869,
-0.0035405699,
0.0376599766,
0.0501931161,
-0.0076434766,
0.0115582133,
-0.0734287798,
-0.053349521,
-0.0261511374,
-0.0398153476,
0.0031942329,
0.0248866826,
-0.0122246621,
0.0212659724,
-0.0232668016,
-0.0415344611,
-0.0017760145,
-0.0218841881,
0.0322809331,
-0.0137192616,
-0.0165841114,
0.0186189022,
-0.036274761,
-0.0177580528,
0.0283047333,
0.0149979293,
-0.0670329705,
0.0193344429,
0.0645183548,
0.0497106239,
0.0589892156,
0.000002042,
-0.0437952168,
-0.0143398093,
-0.0147241084,
-0.0725297481,
0.0026463128,
0.072960414,
-0.0127255153,
0.0010842417,
0.0062621511,
-0.0127571169,
-0.0643936694,
0.0268287286,
0.0468854234,
0.0443328507,
0.096308127,
-0.0107724601,
-0.0673220605,
-0.0007902132,
-0.0416013338,
0.0302124247,
-0.0281525422,
0.027309116,
-0.0444948412,
0.0062590404,
0.0523731597,
-0.0130514326,
0.0130779361,
0.0356766768,
-0.0105491858,
0.0182736162,
0.0619149022,
0.0013890141,
-0.0265679657,
0.0014210745,
0.0699989498,
0.0170615744,
-0.0353503153,
0.0115187317,
-0.0174727216,
-0.0186271556,
-0.032223165,
-0.0311610512,
0.0250222478,
0.0166942421,
0.0471272059,
0.0423795059,
0.0292058419,
0.0125761954,
0.0000221612,
-0.0170373823,
0.0125572113,
0.0057732603,
-0.0175915416,
-0.014259872,
0.0041195736,
0.0037481512,
-0.0638670623,
-0.0479978509,
0.0418173373,
-0.0082255788,
0.0202352945,
-0.0664370731,
-0.0323169418,
0.0287163556,
-0.0236582924,
0.0687720999,
0.0321674868,
-0.0281683523,
0.0558179244,
-0.0454354398,
0.0094640329,
0.0040501053,
-0.0137928678,
-0.0573732629,
0.0083958264,
-0.072918497,
0.0015163405,
-0.0353852287,
0.03726089,
-0.0286055654,
0.0165732205,
-0.0454741493,
0.0277826916,
0.0252137352,
0.0127625847,
-0.0018741166,
0.0008278347,
-0.0573665947,
-0.0332339257,
0.004162699,
0.0322859883,
-0.0358458199,
0.0064301393,
-0.0214238483,
-0.0566351116,
-0.0355431214,
0.0250635482,
0.0178892724,
-0.0104106488,
0.0103105353,
0.0803189799,
-0.0181560479,
-0.0814981386,
-0.0753745437,
-0.0051449463,
-0.0312464442,
-0.0640564263,
-0.0094116861,
-0.0402377546,
-0.0037787755,
-0.0069592018,
-0.0103953509,
-0.0424576104,
0.0263592806,
0.017070476,
-0.0090651345,
0.0898000523,
-0.0440497883,
-0.0264961179,
0.0178549439,
0.0111776274,
0.0290104449,
0.0933843255,
-0.0032505798,
0.0189132728,
0.0093748774,
0.0325344242,
0.0261358209,
0.0141019281,
0.0122017637,
0.0263811089,
-0.0246158745,
0.0170336347,
0.0057998803,
0.0281173754,
0.0594146773,
-0.0033823671,
-0.0335030816,
-0.0152771538,
0.0446342193,
0.0330536254,
0.0313982032,
0.0185163841,
0.0672863647,
0.041237209,
-0.0232208818,
0.0178983603,
-0.0283850878,
0.0239625294,
-0.024268629,
0.002611455,
0.0305000506,
-0.0110434368,
-0.065523833,
-0.055006437,
-0.0044322251,
-0.0186597258,
-0.0200690757,
-0.0060444903,
0.0713088587,
0.0453779511,
-0.0485735647,
-0.0032153428,
0.0441728607,
-0.0327913649,
-0.0019187166,
-0.0345139243,
0.0610089451,
0.0655585602,
0.0178089775,
-0.0390316173,
-0.0428608172,
-0.023114359,
0.0395641699,
0.0657456815,
-0.006812118,
-0.0165081695,
0.0161858276,
-0.0551789887,
-0.0247351676,
-0.0569795407,
0.0207679216,
0.020076463,
-0.0151198767,
-0.0081805447,
0.0300101712,
-0.0055685025,
-0.0002752628,
0.050604254,
-0.0669208467,
-0.0913769975,
0.0571876764,
0.0065226383,
0.0047808592,
0.0047403635,
-0.0305795185,
-0.0264267419,
0.0095837386,
-0.0394236967,
-0.022972472,
-0.0282448195,
-0.0523696691,
-0.0750874579,
0.0210661814,
0.0099889776,
-0.0175549276,
-0.0338075534,
-0.0839687064,
-0.0503258742,
0.0099800294,
0.0053273784,
0.0306176133,
-0.0615284741,
0.0133897569,
0.0164065938,
0.0116619905,
-0.0207137503,
0.0531037897,
0.0313438103,
-0.0109904362,
0.0057701995,
0.0165764708,
0.0483024195,
-0.0330914743,
-0.0067648892,
-0.0292289089,
-0.0105806841,
-0.0135782855,
-0.0035160319,
0.0333755352,
-0.0584398098,
-0.0157927331,
-0.0655644089,
0.02538931,
-0.0206507687,
0.0176715273,
0.037167199,
-0.010722287,
-0.015413289,
-0.0303656124,
-0.0210034046,
-0.0111665577,
-0.0158556458,
-0.0046225716,
0.054517936,
0.005271235,
0.01219639,
-0.011623621,
0.0135882003,
0.007570737,
0.0545425639,
0.0097392881,
0.0283001587,
-0.0496402532,
0.0619240254,
-0.005276945,
0.0241445322,
0.000893462,
-0.0281220786,
-0.012365886,
-0.0038776116,
-0.0057144682,
0.0534474887,
0.0027454067,
0.0051297713,
0.0250105746,
0.0066112382,
-0.0238186922,
0.0033437766,
-0.0123140076,
-0.0102948369,
-0.0000879348,
-0.0049562221,
-0.0210552122,
0.1051101238,
-0.0155725973,
-0.0152204679,
-0.0505051799,
0.0143187493,
-0.0047453032,
-0.0209158715,
-0.0159024335,
0.031220967,
-0.0035359624,
0.0291171391,
-0.0308586825,
-0.0344840065,
0.0615433827,
-0.0458175205,
-0.0179592706,
-0.0326268561,
-0.0236152094,
-0.0399697609,
0.0444062613,
0.0153545858,
0.00776023,
0.0748520494,
0.0065477886,
-0.0344416909,
-0.0203558672,
0.0053875279,
0.00760468,
0.035870783,
-0.0308715384,
0.0535655133,
-0.0158921909,
-0.0388434269,
-0.0571020506,
-0.0520025901,
-0.0153119667,
0.0051096724,
-0.050426662,
-0.0157136824,
-0.015828209,
-0.0116754323,
0.0170366392,
0.0813791975,
-0.0194227472,
-0.0271196347,
-0.019095324,
0.0515132137,
0.043881312,
-0.0264231917,
-0.0064658802,
-0.018563401,
0.0413716398,
0.044653479,
0.0120269405,
0.0367589183,
-0.0339603983,
-0.001171455,
0.0113147236,
-0.0252030119,
-0.0224763844,
0.0124280015,
0.0461129919,
-0.0425166339,
-0.0324181691,
0.1189989671,
0.0188091919,
-0.0443541408,
-0.0197661947,
-0.0147475041,
0.0049022874,
0.0258179791,
0.0416886732,
-0.0942369252,
-0.0574295036,
-0.008870014,
0.0422351994,
0.002188988,
-0.0198199023,
-0.022363469,
-0.1208940297,
0.0482190028,
-0.0016543342,
-0.0272589419,
0.0226757005,
-0.0462995507,
0.0047309301,
-0.0168119408,
-0.0203708597,
0.0077124746,
-0.0298330057,
0.0081696436,
0.0150017766,
0.0265993886,
-0.0557152778,
0.0154752005,
0.0023609137,
0.0524430089,
0.0529776812,
0.0006168286,
0.0347047858,
-0.0068596853,
0.0061157141,
-0.0415912084,
-0.0105343172,
-0.0450584628,
0.0845292509,
-0.0320693851,
0.0011330369,
0.0118052037,
0.0549839213,
-0.0215614419,
-0.0223420095,
0.000498857,
0.022754889,
0.0131945489,
-0.0005445384,
-0.0186594836,
-0.0022342934,
0.0124314204,
0.0738820806,
0.0378500037,
-0.0352428928,
-0.0333686657,
-0.0479527861,
-0.0035703776,
-0.0954220891,
-0.0086374851,
-0.0096381623,
-0.0268258806,
-0.0338342488,
-0.0388712473,
-0.0301620346,
0.0118867066,
0.0466468707,
-0.0148072755,
-0.0121730603,
-0.0420658067,
-0.0320713632,
-0.0223060641,
-0.0085845869,
-0.0542047955,
-0.0250119977,
-0.0572451465,
-0.0218250509,
0.0830293298,
-0.0484263599,
-0.0121316472,
0.0170843992,
-0.0596388616,
-0.0626595914,
-0.0229609199,
0.0686770231,
0.010397587,
0.0548580103,
0.0106729874,
-0.057040602,
0.1058132946,
0.0755277276,
-0.0179112051,
0.0110493833,
0.0419984125,
0.0360188708,
0.0059124432,
0.0504308157,
-0.0075392365,
0.0671425685,
0.04621353,
0.0109630087,
-0.0473037288,
0.0002043123,
0.0112115536,
-0.0351221338,
0.0369200446,
-0.0322830454,
0.0227182731,
-0.0337989703,
0.0175095499,
-0.0338758565,
-0.006973397,
-0.044850789,
0.0135661969,
0.0089703957,
-0.0511763617,
-0.0143044041,
0.008293909,
-0.0864411294,
0.0627069175,
-0.0174667761,
0.0053374446,
0.0219160784,
0.0170961767,
-0.003600721,
-0.0007701108,
-0.0020987359,
0.0144112175,
0.0245018713,
0.0473794565,
-0.0321010873,
0.0621636957,
0.0206021648,
0.0336120576,
-0.0335154273,
0.0190057233,
-0.0433786511,
0.0240242444,
-0.041002851,
0.0367594622,
0.0693904087,
-0.000543354,
0.0246074591,
-0.0091321338,
-0.029737927,
-0.0040070293,
0.0341634452,
-0.031300351,
-0.0275172945,
0.0002099575,
0.0281129945,
-0.018861318,
0.022478316,
0.0861008838,
0.0287006702,
0.0458020642,
0.0423056707,
0.0452506542,
-0.0505311601,
0.0071081291,
0.0064378167,
0.0123858945,
0.0148193371,
0.024079185,
-0.0378423221,
-0.0698105618,
0.0414280891,
-0.0026201226,
-0.0112791006,
-0.0036561808,
0.0455413125,
-0.0041434029,
-0.0017748211,
-0.0063144756,
-0.0387071483,
0.0054690354,
0.0174884032,
-0.0205595568,
-0.0111571951,
-6.66894459e-33,
-0.0412665345,
-0.0291260481,
0.0431831963,
-0.0310404468,
0.0094740456,
0.0096186576,
-0.0367595814,
-0.0181079376,
0.0082282275,
0.0021397653,
-0.017572565,
-0.0104867751,
0.0087603377,
0.0571801551,
-0.0054688766,
-0.0050712475,
0.0682838038,
-0.0266642887,
-0.0133825652,
0.0283962302,
0.0260034297,
0.0406254232,
0.0461309589,
-0.0434250273,
0.0100110229,
-0.0186140351,
-0.0029995884,
0.0365925431,
0.0514812954,
0.0290236231,
-0.0160546247,
0.0352829099,
0.033147607,
-0.0636602342,
-0.0024197642,
0.007838143,
-0.0892982557,
-0.0544718765,
-0.005810895,
-0.0266504157,
-0.0349709131,
-0.0340402015,
0.0146001913,
-0.0036439858,
0.0153165255,
-0.032783661,
0.0250642318,
-0.0153437611,
-0.0131064774,
-0.0078671305,
-0.0557565056,
0.0185030084,
0.0013086189,
-0.053988222,
0.0407246053,
0.0530383661,
0.0200263523,
0.0451702736,
-0.0777915791,
0.0092146648,
0.0210119989,
0.0368659496,
0.037971884,
0.0384732857,
0.0171327405,
0.0340513363,
0.0255897511,
-0.0044168481,
-0.0517863072,
-0.0245652255,
0.0055227163,
0.0005842351,
-0.0164459366,
0.0691618174,
0.0645209774,
0.0070503699,
-0.0827036202,
0.0303185694,
-0.0076139853,
0.0093501247,
0.0054504266,
0.0150653394,
-0.0055272994,
-0.0111088743,
-0.0273458492,
-0.0702935234,
-0.0287997834,
-0.0294097122,
0.0095346486,
0.0433050916,
-0.0396743715,
-0.0070373043,
0.0403915755,
-0.0229313094,
-0.0298630446,
0.0138088688,
-0.0206495728,
0.0203012004,
0.0082139354,
0.0185471121,
-0.0677324608,
-0.0285533816,
0.0309381951,
0.0221212693,
0.0104321353,
-0.0042240741,
0.0670999736,
0.0110793794,
-0.0607909188,
0.0046209292,
-0.0153133394,
0.0295555256,
-0.0047834651,
0.0384302251,
0.0017707086,
0.0368450321,
0.0023225949,
0.0811750516,
0.0424010865,
-0.02130327,
0.0057675773,
-0.0080140792,
-0.0202702861,
0.0312595591,
-0.0353818126,
0.0281188656,
0.0005410685,
0.0296489894,
0.0249751639,
-0.0586872585,
-0.0011553946,
0.0182340033,
2.713e-7,
0.0241106041,
0.0240095183,
0.0051967809,
-0.0053762812,
0.0239775423,
0.0682456493,
-0.0049196784,
0.0230395384,
0.0019340593,
-0.0241644382,
0.0196046829,
0.0485770889,
0.0418886319,
0.0116120605,
-0.0930094048,
0.0567909591,
-0.0263828337,
0.0323453136,
-0.044941783,
-0.0057344385,
0.0681033283,
0.1068378165,
0.032728035,
-0.0157070309,
0.0270698778,
-0.0084362915,
0.072254695,
0.0281523447,
0.001595309,
-0.0008914497,
-0.0098017417,
0.0563818626,
-0.0443795659,
-0.0101231616,
-0.0130298464,
0.011738047,
-0.0625520796,
0.0580229647,
-0.0039238799,
-0.024491597,
0.0405531563,
0.0028018751,
-0.0060235895,
-0.0102141788,
0.0927236378,
-0.0988322943,
-0.0260420963,
-0.0273547471,
-0.0328436121,
-0.002857019,
0.0165376663,
-0.0190126058,
-0.0297426973,
0.0370281935,
0.0154894404,
-0.0121532883,
-0.0402943864,
-0.0775450245,
0.0144327702,
-0.0110841822,
-0.0414752923,
0.0322126783,
-0.0429780632,
0.0106026661,
0.028892573,
-0.0634986013,
0.024660999,
2.287563205e-34,
0.0136981476,
-0.0243856721,
-0.0151783228,
0.0018142497,
-0.013302559,
0.0040372591,
-0.040657267,
-0.003648256,
0.0278850719,
-0.0708730891,
-0.0011389825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11791v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11791v1 | Directed Acyclic Transformer Pre-training for High-quality Non-autoregressive Text Generation | 2023-04-24T02:30:33 | 2023-04-24T02:30:33 | Fei Huang, Pei Ke, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Non-AutoRegressive (NAR) text generation models have drawn much attention
because of their significantly faster decoding speed and good generation
quality in machine translation. However, in a wider range of text generation
tasks, existing NAR models lack proper pre-training, making them still far
behind the pre-trained autoregressive models. In this paper, we propose
Pre-trained Directed Acyclic Transformer (PreDAT) and a novel pre-training task
to promote prediction consistency in NAR generation. Experiments on five text
generation tasks show that our PreDAT remarkably outperforms existing
pre-trained NAR models (+4.2 scores on average) and even achieves better
results than pre-trained autoregressive baselines in n-gram-based metrics,
along with 17 times speedup in throughput. Further analysis shows that PreDAT
benefits from the unbiased prediction order that alleviates the error
accumulation problem in autoregressive generation, which provides new insights
into the advantages of NAR generation. | [
0.0009041525,
0.060695719,
0.0240237825,
-0.0195270944,
-0.0049855812,
0.003020185,
0.0522091389,
-0.0208892953,
-0.0260507036,
0.007518963,
-0.0211197454,
-0.0662351549,
0.0067316885,
0.037176989,
0.0324880108,
0.0045761983,
0.003210068,
-0.0316813588,
-0.0187820401,
-0.0071109119,
-0.0038145029,
-0.0005494377,
-0.0196178518,
0.0315632224,
-0.0143813379,
-0.0184964892,
0.0003655678,
0.0119356271,
0.0008161501,
-0.0450879186,
0.0180687085,
0.0684572756,
0.0076957652,
0.036419265,
0.0000021489,
0.0121979583,
-0.0039470061,
-0.0000876676,
0.0217202362,
-0.0221543647,
0.0380371809,
-0.045552358,
-0.0207864493,
0.0434240252,
-0.0362557508,
-0.0382417217,
0.0341857746,
0.0249943864,
0.082862623,
0.0691125765,
-0.0109657934,
-0.023783654,
0.0065252059,
-0.0696100295,
-0.0264485776,
0.0053958972,
-0.0260424018,
-0.0085553993,
-0.0606671423,
0.0225569513,
-0.0137250684,
0.0450396799,
0.0420481153,
-0.020700926,
0.0241520293,
0.0308553148,
-0.0119395629,
-0.0362811685,
-0.0019125709,
0.0354717523,
-0.0224234927,
-0.0466321819,
0.0061905915,
-0.0037944508,
-0.033543516,
-0.0229301751,
-0.024405269,
0.0607943237,
-0.0134870578,
0.0028906667,
0.0207421556,
0.0572066344,
0.000552901,
0.0133934617,
-0.0182569157,
-0.0119316252,
0.0134939896,
-0.0313402116,
-0.0112657743,
0.0593253933,
0.0269740243,
-0.0277167857,
0.0420149043,
0.0279029589,
-0.021018263,
-0.0102504855,
-0.0859295577,
-0.0249330569,
-0.0062536136,
-0.0068873991,
0.0836707056,
0.0427379757,
0.005278673,
-0.0371063165,
-0.069005698,
0.0425807387,
-0.018081829,
-0.0170425195,
-0.0417613611,
0.0213156752,
0.0077087679,
-0.0138923805,
-0.0573162548,
0.0117812445,
-0.0242717136,
-0.0223742202,
-0.0513812676,
0.0238054842,
0.0099652009,
-0.0316114798,
0.0423669666,
0.0275926366,
-0.0930612385,
-0.035597913,
0.007357005,
0.0211676434,
0.0167734176,
-0.0096531399,
0.0330524072,
-0.032062158,
-0.0404343382,
0.0309860185,
0.0207083523,
-0.0137846675,
-0.0090010772,
0.0651177838,
-0.0526002496,
-0.0098746829,
-0.02845053,
-0.0405901596,
0.0052219834,
-0.0527434498,
0.0047604935,
-0.0382038169,
0.0060856878,
0.0397730432,
-0.013488452,
0.0124135884,
0.0242396723,
0.0329129323,
0.0289151017,
0.0050307848,
0.0156504512,
0.0074987314,
0.0387117304,
-0.0132471323,
0.0162871573,
0.0298225768,
0.0275575146,
0.0782093555,
-0.0357642062,
0.0184456147,
-0.0045388108,
0.0047695176,
0.0403078198,
-0.0013720511,
-0.008753066,
-0.040496137,
-0.0488461256,
0.0062177898,
0.0559500083,
0.0374280624,
-0.0220746696,
0.0143585261,
0.0857888088,
-0.025827406,
0.0490016453,
0.0366337001,
0.0903790817,
-0.0257161632,
-0.0247847531,
0.0221480262,
0.0048908177,
0.074384056,
-0.0227800999,
0.031517081,
0.0108439513,
0.0722827986,
-0.0271836407,
-0.0449742898,
0.0411400348,
-0.0323061906,
-0.0069741183,
-0.0389367156,
0.0188999176,
0.0514462553,
-0.0888597518,
0.0084576812,
-0.0105418852,
-0.0839981288,
0.0266622845,
-0.0227385834,
-0.0302488972,
0.0194245744,
0.041839283,
0.0571188368,
-0.0253993906,
-0.0184138082,
-0.0047189295,
0.0951540247,
0.0097022122,
0.0368840992,
-0.0142131792,
-0.0778053179,
-0.0231002606,
0.0168296769,
-0.0090282941,
0.0428251475,
-0.0034902606,
0.0528800674,
0.0762459189,
0.0317634009,
-0.0501779802,
0.019731082,
-0.0472337827,
-0.0369094275,
0.0160227343,
0.0088018309,
-0.0111179752,
-0.0082430597,
-0.0331223831,
0.0315053388,
0.0099877687,
-0.0558829755,
-0.0358310901,
0.0236551743,
-0.130836159,
-0.054207433,
-0.0208329391,
-0.0405857787,
0.0243844185,
0.021601662,
0.0083210357,
-0.073995918,
0.0041893311,
-0.0398483649,
0.0201161895,
-0.0488037653,
0.0356755927,
0.0756003559,
0.0221513137,
0.0189853478,
0.0291067231,
-0.0117361313,
-0.0125563005,
0.0369276144,
0.0297953468,
0.0100287087,
-0.003578919,
-0.0057579209,
0.0020032227,
0.0040492322,
0.0116532389,
0.0797720328,
0.0312120877,
0.011501411,
-0.0535051785,
-0.0008430618,
0.0056844107,
-0.0381091051,
-0.0116316136,
0.0184652414,
0.0179895926,
0.0106951222,
-0.0089783752,
-0.0544590689,
0.0300879329,
0.0378768891,
-0.0086425617,
0.0221573506,
0.0030575315,
0.0237212926,
0.0112813748,
-0.0123254815,
0.0324133821,
0.0388831124,
0.0438978337,
-0.0102092158,
-0.075334616,
0.0425979458,
-0.015037437,
-0.0156225357,
0.0074476427,
-0.06867522,
0.010502167,
0.0221685469,
0.0713914856,
0.0169144347,
0.059440583,
-0.0050595836,
-0.0184792206,
0.0135468487,
-0.0140943956,
-0.0010037832,
-0.0684007183,
-0.0116156582,
0.0160511434,
-0.0503923558,
0.0313058048,
0.0860534459,
0.0326867402,
0.0101541039,
-0.0867976099,
-0.0167632028,
-0.0290123951,
-0.0268188827,
0.0028755192,
-0.0110517517,
-0.0021871442,
0.0252243094,
-0.0175492894,
-0.0539440252,
0.0390666574,
-0.036160931,
-0.0152530316,
-0.0181273818,
-0.0005389435,
-0.0259734523,
0.000669665,
0.0418640412,
0.0449766517,
0.0202744119,
-0.0274035763,
-0.0582060143,
0.0552976951,
0.0140512353,
-0.0201221518,
0.0592268296,
-0.0110116741,
-0.0045141736,
-0.0154323569,
-0.0470113643,
-0.0477508567,
-0.0048739756,
0.031515155,
-0.0068711094,
0.0401642323,
-0.0285926312,
-0.0127056865,
0.0257750787,
0.0133164171,
0.0597161502,
-0.0559387431,
-0.0225734729,
-0.0119613968,
0.0380007438,
0.0428144075,
-0.037667308,
-0.0192645751,
-0.0543140769,
0.0042558843,
0.0277193245,
0.01554929,
0.0111646829,
-0.0384164825,
0.0033758944,
0.0081832008,
0.0074924682,
-0.0256156977,
-0.0075844885,
-0.0033575359,
-0.0332532227,
-0.0261676125,
0.0954235941,
-0.0093300166,
-0.0282066129,
-0.0083161993,
0.0368461944,
0.0730297044,
-0.0022406154,
-0.0072487816,
-0.0826676637,
-0.0126786204,
-0.0240226928,
0.0401620008,
0.0082278382,
-0.0101378709,
-0.0377367139,
-0.1037464216,
0.024875652,
0.0326821432,
-0.010260052,
-0.0018328018,
0.0001965582,
-0.077611804,
-0.0328782685,
0.0051486455,
0.0370800197,
-0.0248762183,
0.0348110646,
0.0454643294,
-0.0426913239,
-0.0169554986,
-0.0649463311,
-0.0022597299,
0.0303948633,
0.0669033229,
0.0250074882,
0.0040523647,
-0.0261013471,
0.0011348447,
-0.0240306109,
0.0429896191,
-0.0188408289,
0.0062755072,
0.0074218358,
-0.0213779174,
-0.0111491829,
0.0129785119,
-0.0359568149,
0.0086109461,
-0.0147311948,
0.0208835565,
-0.0013156906,
-0.0281654596,
0.0131630795,
0.0355972499,
0.0074336943,
0.0366864651,
0.0057244706,
-0.0386915952,
-0.0610044263,
-0.0186937582,
0.0520579517,
-0.0899425149,
-0.0462757871,
-0.0044517657,
0.0156213343,
-0.0585590266,
-0.0908448398,
-0.0461763963,
-0.0255269501,
0.061964415,
-0.0188596547,
-0.0038449205,
0.0024423688,
-0.0373475179,
-0.0579144172,
-0.0251756106,
0.0106075546,
-0.0102416435,
-0.0837912261,
-0.0306178089,
0.0243182573,
-0.0292618126,
-0.0057252501,
0.0606895573,
-0.0708652809,
-0.0625107512,
0.0347734764,
0.0521280244,
0.021136757,
0.0280977264,
0.0330255963,
-0.0056659551,
0.0701222941,
0.0383335017,
-0.0092655318,
0.0076311254,
0.0149684781,
-0.0030751789,
-0.0288004298,
0.0110923769,
-0.0016694119,
0.0354321823,
-0.0388536789,
0.0593423508,
0.0227667559,
-0.0535776019,
0.0384867601,
-0.0021246753,
0.0314103477,
-0.0617851838,
0.028717231,
-0.0280571301,
0.0044784807,
-0.0179908294,
0.0156626385,
-0.0516809858,
0.0340573378,
0.0578945614,
0.0157343093,
-0.0161690023,
0.0450003669,
-0.0170390271,
0.0431691296,
-0.0085402727,
0.0198507849,
-0.0383045934,
0.0412197299,
0.038655445,
0.0026027139,
-0.0251537319,
-0.008822253,
0.0392102711,
0.0262127221,
-0.0485083759,
0.0337792821,
0.0071659731,
0.0497802049,
0.0045457236,
0.0449650921,
-0.0456148349,
0.0170894116,
-0.0717933029,
-0.0397170968,
0.023998715,
-0.0057491232,
0.0973886847,
-0.0535452589,
0.0400847085,
0.0064605288,
0.068846941,
0.0157807339,
0.0014071512,
-0.0159697179,
-0.0325920209,
-0.0134810908,
-0.0213068258,
0.0935919508,
-0.0350429863,
0.0020205891,
0.0086851362,
0.0160228331,
-0.0400542058,
-0.0311250743,
0.0022154343,
-0.0735769048,
0.0010547694,
-0.0137227159,
0.0016591689,
-0.036244113,
0.0239706542,
-0.0146495011,
0.0214390103,
-0.037786793,
0.0305185094,
0.0355749466,
-0.0361216664,
0.0103204679,
-0.0455174781,
0.0003281252,
-0.0073029501,
0.0055909068,
-0.0292866714,
-6.699598544e-33,
-0.0324635468,
-0.015612009,
0.0169200767,
-0.0382168889,
-0.0259167422,
0.0268357452,
-0.0201269183,
-0.006641347,
0.0388941914,
-0.0110123921,
0.0000331351,
-0.00995507,
0.0191550087,
0.0247448385,
-0.0063291118,
0.0545156375,
0.0802916586,
-0.0233122632,
-0.0192378554,
0.0598010272,
0.0252674073,
0.0548379682,
0.0208342578,
-0.0309200995,
-0.0314877518,
-0.0206433721,
-0.0184741449,
-0.0439625867,
0.0440782048,
0.0064389817,
-0.0067010047,
0.018743664,
0.0007689236,
-0.052932132,
-0.0208736919,
0.0005554287,
-0.0560767911,
-0.0082922364,
-0.0385878868,
0.008525705,
-0.0367827713,
0.0001459428,
-0.000964822,
-0.0289260205,
-0.0402553044,
-0.012405118,
0.0119302543,
-0.0008751586,
-0.0258774441,
-0.0691007227,
-0.0538017489,
0.0179775488,
0.0023972478,
-0.0377584994,
0.0042947191,
0.0616873577,
-0.0056483238,
-0.0283496398,
-0.0568859875,
0.0290130991,
0.0262529701,
0.0663921684,
0.0352735519,
0.0322266817,
-0.0162450708,
0.0228318498,
0.0491715334,
0.0143198678,
-0.0010228439,
0.0217658002,
-0.0015970409,
0.0330074243,
0.007813842,
0.0271261018,
0.0533870645,
-0.0327643715,
-0.0299943518,
0.0772484541,
-0.0220441613,
0.0177423395,
0.0300390013,
-0.0213116091,
-0.0054605934,
-0.0088398261,
-0.0197550412,
-0.0326915346,
-0.0053797276,
-0.0318105258,
0.0122131696,
0.0740177706,
-0.023237722,
0.0050557139,
0.041992534,
0.0066261394,
-0.0054451013,
0.031016361,
-0.0544805974,
0.0017026061,
-0.0357718468,
0.0393742174,
-0.0440237597,
-0.0266811587,
0.0391368046,
0.0395785458,
-0.0023674094,
0.0114053078,
0.0263228267,
0.0688039586,
-0.0798032731,
-0.0049144356,
-0.053746447,
0.0650607124,
0.0566523969,
-0.0125691937,
0.006898426,
-0.0370441824,
-0.0348910689,
0.0819432959,
-0.0345324613,
0.0047667725,
-0.0094535155,
0.0067010252,
0.0409351997,
0.0431195274,
-0.0333184451,
0.0383699462,
-0.0162614584,
0.0361239091,
0.0424556695,
-0.0641170591,
-0.0346743241,
0.0002852604,
2.792e-7,
0.0170254335,
0.0533086061,
0.0512315854,
0.0252550598,
-0.0281759277,
0.00544419,
-0.0189410001,
0.0480179153,
-0.0123366285,
0.0435637459,
-0.0047430075,
-0.0071309865,
0.0710827038,
0.0231228936,
-0.0304013547,
0.0267624818,
-0.0907608643,
0.0217119996,
-0.0279216859,
-0.0434878282,
0.0366696008,
0.0040348605,
-0.0980839431,
-0.0262975022,
0.0468334705,
-0.0055290987,
0.096341826,
0.032958407,
-0.0066433651,
-0.0097713238,
0.0482233241,
-0.017110195,
-0.0215445012,
-0.0318968594,
-0.0507734306,
-0.0321851,
0.0076630358,
0.0290494952,
0.0111901714,
-0.0381639749,
0.0814866647,
0.0310986526,
0.007641498,
-0.0038590503,
0.026643822,
-0.0446857922,
-0.0035520177,
-0.0050286641,
-0.0385515764,
0.0346459523,
-0.0002694401,
-0.0426575877,
-0.0269773342,
0.0258717034,
0.0346416682,
0.0293550808,
-0.0115579702,
-0.0434281677,
-0.0350247957,
-0.0095835775,
-0.0256217625,
-0.0159646962,
-0.071516335,
0.007602978,
0.0314232558,
-0.0196414161,
-0.0055817594,
2.609894547e-34,
0.0310026947,
-0.0230713375,
0.0022912933,
-0.0155913141,
0.0354964733,
-0.0172260068,
0.0418740101,
0.0252855383,
-0.0193426982,
-0.0325447731,
-0.066779308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11766v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11766v4 | NAIST-SIC-Aligned: an Aligned English-Japanese Simultaneous Interpretation Corpus | 2023-04-23T23:03:58 | 2024-04-01T01:07:54 | Jinming Zhao, Yuka Ko, Kosuke Doi, Ryo Fukuda, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | It remains a question that how simultaneous interpretation (SI) data affects
simultaneous machine translation (SiMT). Research has been limited due to the
lack of a large-scale training corpus. In this work, we aim to fill in the gap
by introducing NAIST-SIC-Aligned, which is an automatically-aligned parallel
English-Japanese SI dataset. Starting with a non-aligned corpus NAIST-SIC, we
propose a two-stage alignment approach to make the corpus parallel and thus
suitable for model training. The first stage is coarse alignment where we
perform a many-to-many mapping between source and target sentences, and the
second stage is fine-grained alignment where we perform intra- and
inter-sentence filtering to improve the quality of aligned pairs. To ensure the
quality of the corpus, each step has been validated either quantitatively or
qualitatively. This is the first open-sourced large-scale parallel SI dataset
in the literature. We also manually curated a small test set for evaluation
purposes. Our results show that models trained with SI data lead to significant
improvement in translation quality and latency over baselines. We hope our work
advances research on SI corpora construction and SiMT. Our data can be found at
https://github.com/mingzi151/AHC-SI. | [
0.0135079492,
0.0400264449,
-0.007567999,
0.0315980092,
-0.0010535582,
0.0398233011,
0.0298483111,
-0.0207255967,
-0.043606434,
0.0305598099,
-0.0925909355,
-0.0472748019,
0.0425290614,
-0.0354679711,
0.0054758973,
-0.0326330289,
0.0557329878,
0.0192474648,
-0.0308605768,
0.0071100681,
0.0590157472,
0.0317977145,
-0.0034846989,
0.0141329411,
-0.013647181,
-0.0594631769,
0.0178800933,
0.0324011818,
0.0702274293,
-0.0294238143,
0.0083052432,
0.0139234876,
0.0004564194,
0.0538014136,
0.0000019251,
-0.0207732618,
-0.0336562097,
0.0105177443,
0.0090483334,
0.0439236052,
0.0268132389,
-0.0802318156,
0.004178423,
0.0405721702,
-0.0098465458,
-0.0434622467,
0.0761053786,
-0.0110597415,
0.0875537246,
0.061600402,
-0.0394754447,
-0.0619587265,
-0.0147387367,
-0.0669443533,
-0.0875236765,
0.0079636974,
-0.0283654388,
0.0030924426,
-0.0683500841,
0.0235970393,
0.0216838792,
0.0549619123,
0.0152290547,
-0.0002831405,
-0.0341122672,
-0.0073312158,
0.0058487048,
-0.0267273095,
0.0049598888,
0.0592998452,
-0.0204621311,
0.0057762228,
-0.031715937,
-0.0197813418,
0.0022882894,
-0.0124197649,
-0.0376784019,
0.0256302655,
-0.0195252635,
0.0095488746,
0.0534965135,
0.0213035066,
0.0363757275,
-0.0257434789,
-0.0278923195,
-0.0122660855,
0.0378518291,
-0.0439530015,
-0.0252087507,
0.0144767836,
-0.0408671238,
0.0016209879,
0.0495097376,
-0.0320301242,
-0.0473786518,
0.0552152731,
-0.0538284332,
-0.0659557804,
0.0172628574,
-0.0674159452,
0.0289503355,
0.0840289146,
-0.0148878945,
-0.0051292167,
0.0265808646,
0.012625007,
-0.0360016897,
0.0315489955,
-0.0902062207,
-0.0200533308,
-0.0187780429,
0.0226443559,
-0.0372172333,
-0.0389979556,
-0.0551682226,
-0.0254332945,
-0.0374182276,
0.0332535841,
-0.0142492866,
-0.0018001471,
0.0377190523,
-0.0650977418,
-0.0763723031,
0.0243240278,
0.0250063837,
0.0694761425,
-0.0341900624,
0.0348855369,
-0.0108729154,
-0.0268525109,
-0.0579415001,
0.0104291672,
0.0099236965,
-0.0693622902,
-0.0261895787,
0.0243811756,
-0.0246331561,
-0.0171341542,
-0.0149483541,
-0.0000968826,
-0.0316511951,
-0.0165213179,
-0.0063800705,
-0.0233976953,
0.1074302271,
-0.0022907504,
0.0665809736,
-0.0251379553,
-0.0155187976,
-0.0117731877,
0.0132493135,
0.0640195385,
-0.0292457212,
-0.0003235805,
-0.0349584743,
-0.0159330536,
-0.0085246321,
0.0699891597,
0.054912053,
-0.0132356873,
0.0319016166,
-0.0108371014,
-0.0935903639,
0.0821442604,
0.0009149786,
0.0155423805,
-0.0099475933,
0.0381250195,
0.0062928279,
0.0496688746,
0.0296165366,
0.0280872043,
-0.0307035297,
0.007491902,
0.0361550786,
-0.0124251479,
0.0121831121,
0.0367646329,
0.0548011512,
0.0137170414,
-0.0090057356,
0.0212049652,
-0.0035178489,
0.0079761595,
0.0139288362,
0.0544253923,
0.0287999976,
0.0379186273,
-0.0122715579,
-0.0410702303,
-0.0232060347,
-0.0009580264,
-0.0362123623,
-0.0051092207,
0.0233058501,
0.000227284,
-0.0285250861,
0.0629412085,
0.0057278331,
-0.054139521,
-0.0066335551,
0.0198293477,
-0.0449928045,
0.0598297343,
0.0084286388,
0.0129960841,
-0.0497488342,
0.0169299562,
-0.0066643865,
0.0336900577,
0.0394464917,
-0.0062249196,
0.0458336286,
-0.0395774916,
-0.0192590039,
0.0085487487,
-0.0087108975,
0.0463031568,
0.0038857604,
0.0284786411,
0.0242135823,
0.0258097239,
-0.0241874177,
0.0410564728,
-0.0549189709,
0.0210966282,
-0.0138276126,
0.0275798794,
0.0583548844,
0.0230103265,
-0.0369492397,
0.0007195786,
0.0344820954,
-0.0260951594,
0.0353501365,
0.0745182186,
-0.0093301749,
-0.0523724556,
0.0385381952,
-0.0200270209,
-0.0523332916,
0.0669721216,
-0.032543119,
-0.0350578614,
-0.0670197457,
-0.0200954825,
-0.031292513,
-0.0629023314,
0.0349395126,
-0.0032082787,
0.042821534,
-0.0180381518,
0.0182305053,
0.0105986996,
0.0209114123,
0.0363875404,
-0.018279599,
0.0432359055,
-0.0555869415,
-0.0281338859,
0.029167084,
0.0291478168,
-0.0217574202,
0.0068385797,
-0.0217949226,
-0.0315085277,
-0.0174684655,
-0.0843176246,
0.0584099926,
-0.026029693,
0.0471774936,
0.0643992946,
0.0219057295,
-0.0030216156,
0.0203802306,
-0.010020298,
0.0132819833,
0.0107903657,
0.0020987752,
0.0091163721,
-0.0041736295,
0.0138364481,
-0.0394966528,
-0.0168724842,
0.0080874646,
0.0043671699,
0.0228022039,
-0.0276228245,
-0.0484240353,
0.0120608425,
0.0085043535,
-0.0239945967,
0.0098399483,
-0.0623206794,
0.013868453,
-0.0242392085,
-0.0106219314,
-0.0122808218,
0.0079786703,
0.0270100329,
0.0152403302,
-0.0070582321,
-0.0208100062,
0.0175519511,
0.0191408731,
-0.0111771226,
-0.0482576527,
-0.0521238633,
0.0166560616,
0.0841229558,
0.0147215324,
-0.0210301075,
-0.0502899326,
-0.0532975383,
-0.0117461896,
-0.0158704799,
0.0051951264,
0.0124444142,
-0.0165591203,
-0.0017594794,
-0.0329059251,
-0.0383855589,
0.0724122226,
-0.0362109989,
-0.0286897048,
-0.0993638486,
0.0099858781,
-0.0322496369,
0.0632828325,
-0.0318596549,
0.0027173723,
-0.0204442907,
-0.022810705,
-0.0373172984,
0.0546653643,
0.0195973348,
-0.0125247827,
0.014041312,
-0.0669757873,
0.0073443889,
-0.0279815067,
-0.0174502581,
-0.0164680369,
-0.0891339853,
-0.0060964986,
-0.0279909074,
0.0685689524,
-0.0038811099,
-0.0498935059,
0.0217810515,
-0.008546913,
0.0480239317,
-0.0012994175,
0.0156402364,
-0.0159020163,
0.0174955688,
0.0450479165,
-0.0053025628,
-0.0019643127,
-0.0638169199,
0.0393735655,
0.0077285855,
0.0372636318,
-0.0044289273,
-0.0448134355,
-0.0290105958,
0.0648590997,
-0.029476596,
-0.0110773202,
-0.0342027247,
0.0452381223,
-0.0170571525,
0.0092462553,
0.1235171631,
0.0282261111,
-0.019430628,
0.0006321943,
0.0109307179,
0.0129238814,
-0.0261338074,
0.0024016746,
-0.0769134313,
-0.0342753083,
-0.0027533241,
0.0103266248,
0.0366828516,
0.0394972265,
-0.043704588,
-0.0858443081,
0.0165593196,
0.0551335625,
-0.035530284,
-0.0100012412,
0.0186768211,
-0.0146700777,
-0.0494872965,
0.0534988344,
-0.0091560753,
-0.0021916765,
0.0071479627,
-0.0037973218,
0.0327194706,
-0.0431241915,
-0.0136297597,
-0.0539835021,
0.0351666994,
-0.0164506249,
0.031446863,
0.0002776622,
-0.0131009994,
0.0336009525,
-0.0445382595,
-0.0202998128,
-0.0058817291,
0.0095300581,
-0.0171702746,
-0.0341730192,
0.0099642612,
-0.0001265018,
-0.0098101506,
0.0020656246,
0.0429092124,
-0.024828732,
0.0207266305,
0.0377380662,
-0.019612927,
-0.0202351417,
-0.0032397113,
0.0446593277,
-0.0083473548,
-0.0446781665,
0.0580682568,
0.010521872,
-0.0186148323,
-0.0421406254,
0.0423418283,
0.0369167551,
-0.0900394395,
-0.0136252139,
-0.0548061654,
-0.0708254874,
-0.0209693816,
0.0261556637,
0.0429962166,
-0.0044691395,
-0.0096178474,
0.0058772895,
-0.0155302333,
0.0617617108,
0.0203946587,
0.0357153378,
-0.0102904569,
0.0128019685,
-0.0115000494,
-0.0025971953,
0.0109260464,
0.0472900979,
-0.0702980608,
-0.0545698963,
-0.0013439902,
0.0354703441,
0.007593147,
0.0591406487,
-0.0162163749,
-0.0164621174,
-0.0449496955,
-0.015251644,
-0.0263863038,
0.0082667638,
0.0024411886,
-0.0190889258,
-0.0078909164,
0.0010612179,
-0.0061696908,
-0.0064970371,
-0.0268475395,
0.0574985594,
-0.0036286931,
-0.0234156679,
0.0127039431,
0.0247375034,
0.0337600149,
-0.034768492,
0.0127375508,
-0.0364942327,
0.0249778051,
-0.0399692655,
-0.0194276627,
-0.031380713,
-0.0280951001,
0.0654002056,
-0.0288837906,
-0.0450352803,
0.03187038,
-0.0117567042,
-0.0192438662,
-0.0125863263,
-0.0174338929,
-0.011266022,
0.0117127383,
-0.0294516589,
0.0195685867,
-0.0297890045,
-0.0114956116,
0.0039776219,
0.0008443739,
-0.0064325854,
0.0483588651,
0.001025614,
0.0221861918,
0.0192374736,
0.0608719289,
-0.0198653527,
0.0277397167,
-0.0174749251,
-0.0337417424,
0.0578784868,
-0.0138231348,
0.1399289966,
-0.0150093725,
0.0079614157,
-0.0123206638,
0.0498927273,
0.0005228908,
-0.0067083426,
-0.0365876965,
0.0001596964,
-0.0149082299,
-0.0444635861,
0.0752415732,
-0.0215543918,
0.0010393742,
-0.0309896488,
-0.0105217174,
-0.0282609463,
-0.0138210794,
-0.0232492331,
0.0214109123,
-0.0273374449,
-0.0594094694,
-0.0042700926,
-0.0361457616,
0.0081125693,
0.0364135988,
0.0035657962,
0.0171762295,
-0.0096100913,
0.0472139493,
-0.048045449,
-0.0120092053,
-0.0129125267,
-0.0183468442,
-0.0273430608,
0.0001439178,
-0.039452754,
-5.63106573e-33,
-0.0573171042,
0.0217665192,
0.0071675717,
-0.0610614344,
-0.0421673134,
-0.0081608258,
-0.0148262801,
-0.0293548889,
-0.0032066109,
-0.0009232135,
0.0001122004,
0.0424102694,
0.0341180265,
0.0060087917,
0.0141666196,
0.0270314217,
0.0566016696,
0.0175894592,
-0.0166099053,
-0.0287542902,
0.0509840325,
0.014581671,
0.0610787049,
-0.030455675,
0.0684371367,
-0.0087220473,
-0.0276783612,
-0.0030955572,
-0.0091409162,
0.0515104569,
0.0099500082,
0.0256308783,
0.013815131,
-0.024970524,
-0.0281289984,
0.0266991667,
-0.1133339852,
0.0207268652,
0.063183926,
0.0672057495,
-0.0124431644,
-0.0435548387,
-0.0118910819,
-0.0407822914,
0.0321760923,
-0.0492828265,
0.0246197451,
-0.0569916032,
0.0113255195,
0.0022383668,
-0.0336546414,
0.0182113871,
-0.058957316,
0.0112210913,
0.0478125699,
0.0583727956,
0.0121066142,
0.0033003979,
-0.051677417,
0.0090763364,
-0.0355543084,
0.0311875138,
0.0414271094,
0.0021448676,
0.0049431021,
0.0125558302,
0.0386276543,
-0.0459506921,
0.0550610945,
0.0037696483,
-0.0052362485,
0.0055478583,
0.028361192,
0.0712373182,
0.0592403263,
-0.0073402058,
-0.0725487396,
0.032970082,
-0.0139596509,
0.0046223188,
0.0096098073,
-0.010900001,
-0.0280961022,
-0.0075538377,
-0.0145991752,
-0.0256185737,
-0.0159715489,
-0.0167269129,
0.0206692666,
-0.0091989776,
-0.0074026836,
0.0523689948,
0.0753393844,
-0.0110893128,
-0.0001695795,
0.0267733466,
-0.0086212978,
0.0043880888,
-0.0338626839,
0.0351310968,
0.0064214878,
-0.0520088449,
-0.0012546299,
0.0116479686,
0.0253848322,
-0.0102535123,
0.0607065819,
0.0060993899,
-0.0257996172,
0.0236313026,
-0.0280338302,
-0.0275139082,
-0.0270968731,
-0.0333843715,
0.0378354527,
0.0086151361,
0.0010157615,
0.0309744421,
0.0524243116,
0.0237493515,
-0.0216722246,
-0.00548568,
-0.008895128,
0.0168477166,
-0.003818681,
0.0325390995,
0.0274071693,
-0.0164615158,
0.0459716618,
-0.048776798,
-0.0257423036,
0.0066214264,
2.528e-7,
0.0563179813,
0.0027163976,
0.0532542132,
0.0539241806,
0.0091230534,
-0.0016543913,
-0.0342705734,
0.0475663058,
0.0117826536,
0.0709443763,
0.0383108892,
-0.0072755767,
0.0922563151,
0.0052133105,
-0.0646375343,
-0.0428532064,
-0.0422119908,
0.058921732,
-0.0573084354,
0.0648625419,
0.0625269264,
0.07829009,
-0.0145841278,
0.0291352887,
-0.0010988239,
-0.0127362264,
0.0682785362,
-0.0016542384,
-0.0237836111,
0.0285245087,
0.0117700025,
-0.0489255153,
-0.0472324491,
-0.0114070559,
-0.0415500328,
0.0576059297,
0.0321171209,
0.0827642903,
0.0113992784,
0.0050789653,
0.0335594453,
0.0086081522,
-0.0199138969,
-0.0262930021,
0.0522601306,
-0.0495292097,
-0.0203024782,
0.0279995184,
-0.0552393608,
0.0146614695,
-0.0016886707,
0.0122439414,
-0.0126156276,
0.0392799862,
0.058140032,
-0.0233884919,
-0.0479833372,
-0.0257617999,
-0.0755947158,
0.0034835206,
-0.0249489043,
-0.0459520333,
-0.0085879136,
-0.0214731954,
0.0425642803,
-0.061405763,
-0.0182987135,
1.969458362e-34,
0.0360557847,
-0.0348363332,
0.0345642865,
0.0245867521,
0.0064141597,
-0.0724066123,
0.0097123673,
0.0363406427,
-0.0317896567,
-0.0433583967,
-0.0246728156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11721v1 | A Lightweight Constrained Generation Alternative for Query-focused Summarization | 2023-04-23T18:43:48 | 2023-04-23T18:43:48 | Zhichao Xu, Daniel Cohen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Query-focused summarization (QFS) aims to provide a summary of a document
that satisfies information need of a given query and is useful in various IR
applications, such as abstractive snippet generation. Current QFS approaches
typically involve injecting additional information, e.g. query-answer relevance
or fine-grained token-level interaction between a query and document, into a
finetuned large language model. However, these approaches often require extra
parameters \& training, and generalize poorly to new dataset distributions. To
mitigate this, we propose leveraging a recently developed constrained
generation model Neurological Decoding (NLD) as an alternative to current QFS
regimes which rely on additional sub-architectures and training. We first
construct lexical constraints by identifying important tokens from the document
using a lightweight gradient attribution model, then subsequently force the
generated summary to satisfy these constraints by directly manipulating the
final vocabulary likelihood. This lightweight approach requires no additional
parameters or finetuning as it utilizes both an off-the-shelf neural retrieval
model to construct the constraints and a standard generative language model to
produce the QFS. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach on two public QFS
collections achieving near parity with the state-of-the-art model with
substantially reduced complexity. | [
0.044123102,
0.1007957757,
0.0301615093,
0.0014472405,
0.0183111858,
-0.0016257715,
-0.0354902484,
-0.0119683826,
-0.0417921692,
-0.0253899861,
0.0015543934,
-0.0026480472,
0.0068775085,
0.0381985046,
0.0337969437,
-0.0587477796,
0.0151063614,
-0.0066625169,
-0.0142602241,
0.0064675822,
0.0274373777,
0.0137589937,
0.0175996069,
0.0501310602,
-0.0168150607,
-0.0000657457,
-0.0189931281,
0.0148656191,
0.0129208891,
-0.0018226173,
-0.0016143702,
0.0360071175,
0.0540388748,
0.0046483348,
0.0000019165,
-0.0197524726,
-0.0230887737,
0.0103293778,
0.0036064975,
0.0029708128,
0.0328091234,
-0.0072826711,
0.0316735357,
0.009552449,
-0.0155113535,
-0.0151093351,
0.0335764661,
0.0563157797,
0.0743429661,
0.056463629,
-0.0114966426,
-0.0090514142,
0.03585824,
-0.0407904424,
0.0313240066,
-0.0236351211,
-0.0215332378,
-0.0147970011,
-0.0030861765,
-0.000877714,
-0.0183486063,
0.0318319872,
0.0403387062,
-0.0187697057,
0.0298276786,
0.0511116758,
-0.0416798219,
-0.0082291877,
-0.0015982472,
0.0869574621,
0.0073197647,
-0.0233797282,
0.0138213942,
0.0082062632,
0.0064683501,
-0.0069564329,
-0.0900881961,
0.0580576099,
0.0003058423,
0.0307140667,
0.0024293885,
0.0197514314,
0.0115139782,
0.0200950932,
-0.0278618224,
-0.0035086963,
0.0089351311,
-0.0098966714,
-0.0412276573,
0.0059288074,
-0.0288236178,
-0.0193004459,
-0.0128597924,
0.0337819606,
-0.0264878608,
-0.0089700166,
-0.0578228459,
-0.0831077844,
0.0262269415,
0.0187413525,
0.021323422,
0.0149491923,
0.0440957844,
0.0367711857,
-0.0226173941,
0.0560747497,
-0.0109175621,
0.0205850452,
-0.0815053955,
-0.0093943411,
-0.0195335187,
-0.0228905939,
-0.0510326028,
0.0509618893,
-0.0624334924,
-0.0605522729,
-0.0211198516,
0.027371902,
0.031025894,
-0.0226177648,
-0.0042407499,
0.0666411221,
-0.0485086851,
0.0126414541,
0.0223625787,
-0.01260396,
-0.0298167821,
-0.0272202436,
0.0578248352,
-0.0248920638,
-0.0273983851,
0.043697942,
0.0133654103,
0.0009624605,
0.0001354076,
0.0360121876,
-0.0249012187,
-0.0164413042,
-0.0109676979,
-0.0547735319,
-0.0055029183,
-0.01638682,
0.0012513447,
-0.0576703772,
0.04153689,
-0.0088130813,
-0.0142833637,
-0.0284602772,
0.0234880354,
0.0356369205,
-0.0256656576,
0.0331489556,
-0.0116373664,
0.0001066792,
0.0313721113,
0.0111760776,
0.0476964526,
0.0711114779,
0.0545703508,
0.0557580814,
0.0204454158,
0.0505785756,
0.0026370545,
0.0081461743,
0.0377369039,
0.0046908488,
-0.0284892675,
-0.0056443098,
-0.0042582452,
0.0068540657,
0.0641852692,
0.0808344483,
-0.0468233638,
-0.0128009822,
0.0424293391,
0.0615502484,
0.0058213696,
0.0209071506,
0.0148280095,
0.0238592271,
0.0009079713,
0.0095966747,
-0.0348988809,
0.0527873673,
0.0064299311,
0.0353948176,
0.0716111287,
0.0172103681,
-0.0342099741,
-0.0265743267,
0.0409414507,
0.002025275,
-0.0126839383,
0.0011980258,
0.0115221841,
0.0373937003,
-0.0421247855,
0.0383621417,
0.0035490978,
-0.0738868117,
0.0511181615,
-0.0380691588,
0.0095639369,
0.0247203261,
0.0800797641,
-0.0102607775,
-0.0172539279,
-0.0030966916,
-0.023978401,
0.0869782418,
0.0173877738,
-0.0136633907,
0.0074859923,
-0.0660271198,
-0.046445556,
-0.0361684524,
-0.0077216374,
0.0014383582,
0.0175487045,
-0.0219856277,
0.054632064,
-0.0552542731,
-0.05460779,
0.0378743969,
-0.0061992118,
-0.0531909876,
0.0171043333,
-0.0246085674,
0.0163120981,
0.0226915292,
-0.0101646194,
0.0476820245,
0.0071004704,
-0.0419991091,
0.0100230202,
-0.0086767012,
-0.0510479137,
-0.0247172359,
-0.0066935932,
-0.0483485237,
0.0312652253,
0.0402382724,
-0.0285891853,
-0.068988964,
0.0215989761,
-0.0546640716,
0.0086877355,
-0.0683181509,
-0.0380394831,
0.0350402743,
0.0082304645,
-0.0464236513,
0.0550481454,
-0.0117140505,
-0.0026570188,
0.043951299,
-0.0312019195,
0.0068984134,
-0.059480641,
-0.0125232721,
-0.0096071819,
-0.018215999,
0.0136442371,
0.0425903127,
0.0347646587,
-0.0231901146,
-0.0032522762,
-0.0781446174,
-0.0127323614,
-0.0020819886,
0.0100639341,
0.0493888445,
0.0490264818,
-0.001955434,
0.0047508185,
-0.0705071315,
-0.0131079555,
0.0167573206,
0.0108235711,
0.0073615746,
0.0378102176,
0.0425905548,
-0.0369940288,
-0.0251093302,
0.0116499914,
0.0477431417,
0.0365581699,
-0.0041938256,
-0.0353121608,
0.0412132517,
-0.0101734875,
0.0091356244,
-0.0032184843,
-0.003072527,
0.0154250478,
-0.0334878527,
0.0415865555,
0.0466752686,
0.0256023947,
-0.005206659,
0.029499732,
0.0085645523,
-0.0630481616,
0.0215722919,
-0.060952235,
0.0119003141,
0.0129554747,
-0.0342853181,
0.0504558422,
0.0348691419,
0.0475354828,
0.001667548,
-0.0594744869,
0.043712277,
-0.0176713802,
-0.0436664522,
-0.0885742307,
-0.0012637816,
-0.0053256461,
0.0270900968,
-0.0372305699,
-0.0328624584,
0.0529447645,
-0.0375661254,
0.0197984092,
-0.026571257,
0.0181182139,
-0.0839237049,
0.036390841,
0.0063644447,
0.0428806879,
0.0186208189,
-0.0271362811,
-0.0428091884,
-0.0044036065,
-0.0075395466,
-0.0351109616,
0.0370045155,
-0.019020807,
0.0115926433,
-0.0327183604,
-0.026058346,
-0.0325456858,
-0.0169503056,
0.0423197113,
0.0255013313,
0.0685447007,
-0.0428272262,
-0.0066197584,
0.0036880595,
0.0395256095,
0.0819630548,
-0.0792426243,
-0.0200106557,
-0.0146145876,
0.0634582192,
0.0890629664,
0.0090565663,
0.0257629044,
-0.0539948083,
-0.0175902769,
0.0568334274,
0.0605970435,
0.0125862174,
0.0180189982,
0.0132062891,
0.0079433033,
-0.0145992646,
0.037236616,
0.003381263,
0.0329304487,
-0.0321986899,
-0.0654533133,
0.0830483511,
0.0221566577,
-0.0891712308,
-0.0179105774,
-0.006951292,
0.0671544448,
0.0122457165,
0.0247410722,
-0.046209082,
-0.0080719255,
0.0127267959,
0.0915766209,
0.0309842192,
-0.0167397391,
-0.0226569083,
-0.0745047331,
0.0223445706,
0.0074369702,
-0.0632062703,
-0.0263961907,
-0.0215460919,
-0.0022571108,
-0.0072018695,
0.0067048371,
0.0532029606,
-0.0177251827,
0.0201884843,
0.0237731244,
0.0024085629,
-0.0101675848,
-0.0454484895,
-0.0227739792,
-0.006148607,
0.0732778311,
0.0129482327,
0.0130458446,
0.0264166929,
0.0269344002,
-0.064034842,
0.0059019611,
-0.0165454354,
0.0419692695,
-0.0132461805,
0.0078815464,
-0.0436759666,
0.0550017878,
-0.0320166051,
-0.0070436541,
-0.0025948628,
0.0254745334,
-0.0093892179,
0.0091304239,
-0.0815603584,
-0.013184051,
-0.0185284447,
0.0925795585,
0.0666714981,
-0.0293129496,
-0.0403554365,
-0.038031105,
0.0176527947,
-0.1241323501,
-0.0152190588,
-0.0096651083,
0.0190208573,
-0.0297430754,
-0.099382937,
-0.0397627689,
0.0090695862,
-0.020519644,
-0.0015340481,
-0.0048209648,
0.0213559661,
-0.0393073596,
-0.0401236676,
-0.0028094456,
-0.0227279887,
-0.0505164303,
-0.0491184667,
-0.0191105846,
0.0431340002,
-0.0474994183,
-0.0131898653,
0.0277067833,
-0.0425717123,
-0.0364605226,
-0.0274438728,
0.039820455,
0.0145527767,
0.0522843786,
-0.0132966368,
0.0019412907,
0.0547191799,
0.0810793415,
-0.0104151862,
0.0146634877,
-0.0179898553,
0.0183294434,
-0.0141813392,
0.0133602871,
-0.0874924809,
0.0068799835,
0.0046952581,
0.0824193656,
-0.0137343677,
-0.042848587,
0.0447038226,
0.0211010333,
-0.0037077193,
-0.0492366552,
0.0206242893,
-0.0424832441,
-0.0294304807,
-0.0213487856,
-0.0011194053,
-0.0556364991,
0.0270228405,
0.0050892667,
-0.0034381379,
0.0184939038,
0.037255872,
0.026592372,
0.060926009,
-0.0421917289,
-0.017321758,
-0.0542077273,
-0.03641247,
-0.0358218253,
-0.0096058743,
-0.0311098341,
0.0090540955,
-0.0641435906,
0.0137895299,
-0.0120742647,
0.0046837479,
0.0422101021,
-0.026249731,
-0.0102340169,
0.0384509675,
-0.0828723535,
-0.0119355014,
-0.0606229715,
-0.0214536712,
0.0093356026,
-0.0017746511,
0.0387437679,
0.0004140175,
0.0037818707,
-0.0117909806,
0.0314378217,
0.0379722416,
-0.0064605041,
-0.0053623454,
0.0389209054,
0.0303961951,
-0.0306656472,
0.0850556865,
0.0045506083,
0.0008508814,
0.0070696766,
-0.0140843568,
-0.050304722,
-0.0490793698,
-0.0025128541,
0.0238562729,
-0.0188751779,
-0.0155140841,
-0.0203457121,
-0.0217680801,
-0.0016646875,
0.0317423679,
0.0128055913,
0.0136146694,
0.0598060191,
0.0297575258,
-0.0260642115,
-0.046843037,
-0.0230829529,
0.0266605336,
-0.031206049,
-0.0410632566,
-0.015045519,
-6.076542457e-33,
-0.0303505957,
-0.008143899,
-0.0041126972,
0.0012945855,
-0.0339879356,
0.0127443904,
-0.0598259941,
-0.0378210135,
0.0233046152,
-0.0289308839,
-0.0313361697,
0.0061505395,
-0.0006630188,
0.0654695332,
-0.0047342824,
0.022556467,
0.0327426605,
-0.0136517044,
-0.0393097997,
0.0881159529,
0.0614076294,
0.0101047484,
0.0244709402,
-0.0129813273,
-0.0036687048,
-0.0294692945,
-0.0173973888,
0.0183852464,
0.0109423883,
0.039636042,
-0.0350557007,
0.0205554105,
0.0364917107,
-0.0423818417,
-0.0571744032,
0.0319873802,
-0.1090406701,
-0.0239453632,
0.0016834233,
-0.0493042618,
-0.0505253449,
-0.048462823,
0.0574124493,
-0.0358081982,
0.0153901083,
-0.0386447199,
0.0387587771,
-0.0236942265,
-0.0260812882,
-0.1117354259,
-0.0127994418,
0.0048425016,
0.0022087418,
-0.0121600479,
-0.002344273,
0.0574205257,
-0.0120643796,
0.0079057049,
-0.0301062986,
0.0446940847,
0.0217218827,
0.0675572455,
0.03288747,
0.032926742,
0.0092187049,
0.0449502133,
-0.0097320275,
-0.0485087894,
-0.040216852,
0.0129590975,
0.0251147877,
0.0013537437,
0.0281494185,
0.0206460934,
0.0419881567,
0.0310151204,
-0.0555761941,
0.0820084065,
-0.0572465621,
0.0546124056,
0.0425018445,
0.009388377,
-0.0257199798,
-0.0193630159,
-0.0345372893,
0.0069503374,
-0.0425085276,
0.0089673651,
0.032675501,
0.0546384193,
-0.0572059639,
-0.0527036525,
0.0436992794,
-0.0337723158,
0.0365818106,
0.0546386503,
0.0032088626,
0.0117755048,
0.0032612074,
-0.0321379639,
-0.0309258588,
0.0275618974,
0.058830604,
-0.0164356772,
-0.0016713493,
0.0143832723,
0.0296315849,
0.0304097924,
-0.0109391492,
0.0012975303,
-0.0120731676,
0.0348045565,
-0.0119961984,
0.0033273618,
-0.0044263857,
0.0041979076,
-0.0157353133,
0.0066214264,
-0.008834755,
0.0306407791,
-0.0147596411,
-0.0216219854,
0.0146383084,
0.0530330464,
-0.025316935,
0.027777534,
-0.0266215708,
0.0224734731,
0.0421829261,
-0.0489877202,
-0.0225706808,
0.0402001701,
2.554e-7,
0.0381298624,
0.0131106405,
0.0687248334,
0.0443836637,
-0.0051397891,
0.0178418048,
0.0417856723,
0.0506455041,
0.0015195357,
-0.0238080416,
0.0213460866,
0.0591579266,
0.0295956098,
0.0088206921,
-0.1067483723,
0.0196913164,
-0.061677698,
-0.018115988,
-0.0234895293,
-0.0269474126,
0.0541632362,
0.0616832934,
-0.0244537778,
-0.0186996702,
0.0050395783,
-0.0399027728,
0.0276472475,
-0.0076385755,
-0.0223340467,
0.0390352793,
0.0343982577,
0.0169793461,
-0.0107979551,
-0.0267197248,
-0.0001116395,
-0.0114992708,
0.0350115709,
0.0145080714,
0.0179540571,
-0.056037806,
0.017139772,
-0.0083360774,
0.0231514052,
-0.0396807715,
0.0243292935,
-0.0344360806,
0.0076232213,
-0.0121312207,
-0.0269989669,
0.0157548748,
-0.0073871319,
-0.0244382769,
-0.0248762388,
0.0103995381,
0.0000733723,
0.0059700431,
0.009444993,
-0.0625908598,
-0.0328441411,
-0.0146054579,
-0.0378982276,
-0.0160583444,
-0.0629353747,
-0.0077160108,
-0.0193001106,
-0.0781686231,
-0.0194124524,
2.76375987e-34,
0.0437599383,
0.0106499996,
-0.0197149403,
-0.0045538414,
0.0164371859,
-0.0057516708,
-0.0247006491,
-0.0022645998,
0.017612068,
-0.1121112108,
-0.0583476424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11693v1 | Studying the Impact of Semi-Cooperative Drivers on Overall Highway Flow | 2023-04-23T16:01:36 | 2023-04-23T16:01:36 | Noam Buckman, Sertac Karaman, Daniela Rus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Semi-cooperative behaviors are intrinsic properties of human drivers and
should be considered for autonomous driving. In addition, new autonomous
planners can consider the social value orientation (SVO) of human drivers to
generate socially-compliant trajectories. Yet the overall impact on traffic
flow for this new class of planners remain to be understood. In this work, we
present study of implicit semi-cooperative driving where agents deploy a
game-theoretic version of iterative best response assuming knowledge of the
SVOs of other agents. We simulate nominal traffic flow and investigate whether
the proportion of prosocial agents on the road impact individual or system-wide
driving performance. Experiments show that the proportion of prosocial agents
has a minor impact on overall traffic flow and that benefits of
semi-cooperation disproportionally affect egoistic and high-speed drivers. | [
0.0224002432,
0.0191264115,
-0.0327181965,
0.0172420591,
-0.0618875735,
0.0062399572,
0.016139159,
0.0152033102,
-0.0596419089,
0.0293816179,
0.034536127,
0.0161925852,
-0.0669175982,
-0.0042546233,
0.0133220498,
-0.0349984355,
-0.0544638112,
-0.0515082181,
0.0247518383,
-0.0148689114,
-0.0028810105,
-0.0491906255,
0.0346775427,
-0.0036431758,
-0.0520111918,
0.0532327741,
-0.0029079178,
0.0167103577,
0.0640139654,
-0.0134693896,
0.0113873892,
0.0048564761,
0.0679955706,
-0.0345554687,
0.0000021327,
-0.011144083,
0.0138056073,
0.0036548816,
0.0456288606,
-0.0535984635,
0.0318649858,
0.0629790574,
0.0063466039,
0.0459778607,
-0.0569414012,
0.0524424054,
-0.0469379276,
-0.017024193,
0.0190091152,
0.0290358793,
0.000683533,
0.0399130806,
-0.0341815576,
0.0064030252,
-0.0287635177,
0.0102094095,
0.0184127465,
0.0227323025,
-0.0501162857,
-0.0402682051,
0.0069862246,
-0.0016204575,
0.0217429381,
-0.0148578463,
0.0895707756,
0.0314922333,
0.0130603788,
-0.0097240442,
0.0102499202,
0.0567535013,
0.0375573412,
-0.0325990021,
0.0279405676,
-0.0120451879,
0.0046467646,
-0.0265587233,
-0.0080610691,
-0.0358211435,
0.0249625985,
-0.0034545043,
-0.0184744317,
0.0788556859,
-0.0352984071,
0.0071154926,
0.0051405705,
0.0512059294,
-0.0169592742,
-0.0104873385,
-0.0004345152,
0.0451274998,
-0.0070295683,
-0.0439273342,
-0.0065617892,
0.0161082298,
-0.0254494194,
-0.0317309648,
0.0753945932,
0.0209803097,
0.0034350224,
-0.0527599789,
0.0366734751,
-0.0368290804,
0.0289119538,
-0.0101509048,
0.039833378,
-0.0252981968,
0.0478435643,
0.0190104581,
-0.00071027,
0.027338149,
-0.0094305724,
0.0115676457,
-0.0200062767,
0.0044201557,
0.0135630341,
0.0471930429,
0.0328106508,
0.0639207289,
-0.0498928316,
0.0181218646,
-0.0660392642,
0.0613665283,
0.0142914169,
0.0008658846,
0.0034838698,
-0.0696410537,
-0.0755715519,
-0.0136115886,
-0.0132434042,
0.0126975859,
0.0410232246,
-0.0433472693,
0.0110253226,
-0.0250370651,
0.006844217,
0.0751642734,
0.0141270943,
-0.0350789316,
0.0147908926,
-0.0343818888,
0.019421028,
-0.0642521009,
-0.0561661422,
-0.0531363748,
0.0268137529,
0.0211735014,
-0.0531619303,
0.0230828784,
-0.0327215046,
-0.0353794023,
-0.0191780236,
0.012244571,
0.0114994561,
0.0311139803,
0.0199264549,
-0.0117802098,
0.0110658873,
0.0473513938,
0.0189871639,
0.0045010522,
0.01970632,
0.031220438,
0.0227649622,
-0.0161883552,
0.0267339312,
0.0616707914,
0.0142073696,
0.0079180133,
-0.0147203505,
0.0415216684,
0.0385995023,
0.028880477,
-0.0552163906,
-0.0340802148,
0.0280180424,
0.0038507904,
-0.0108226277,
0.0203167088,
-0.031768579,
0.069855921,
-0.0204397235,
0.0169889126,
-0.0451656617,
0.0332442895,
-0.0576254576,
0.0094282385,
-0.0426812246,
0.065351896,
-0.0443959609,
-0.0297490712,
0.0357646011,
-0.0094015803,
0.0450076088,
0.0164634474,
0.0142786345,
-0.0733130351,
-0.0129856598,
-0.1344494969,
-0.0520302132,
-0.0094480021,
0.0332722254,
-0.0266179815,
0.035409268,
0.0045982692,
0.025804935,
-0.0313067436,
-0.0034973791,
-0.0007469005,
-0.012938451,
-0.0452366322,
0.0252469555,
-0.0130257439,
0.0168522988,
-0.0002903042,
-0.0159202814,
0.0742544457,
0.0142335556,
-0.0135222767,
-0.0025893513,
0.0416903161,
0.0114552313,
0.0413899384,
-0.0015465895,
0.0046437201,
0.0074905716,
0.0233850256,
-0.0265372135,
0.0082953414,
0.0225399453,
-0.0250926446,
-0.0509350635,
0.0238390621,
0.0101455292,
0.0294187479,
-0.0390258804,
0.0705755651,
-0.0064682811,
0.0542766638,
0.012332038,
-0.0486125089,
-0.0012375752,
0.0484772511,
-0.0118448939,
0.0451039933,
-0.0357663892,
0.0286711212,
-0.0133649539,
0.0334383734,
0.0094707254,
0.0202974677,
-0.0116716186,
-0.0168150458,
-0.0219896752,
0.0337857269,
0.0103903851,
-0.0058621354,
-0.0019384951,
0.0191050582,
-0.0292964503,
0.0454646982,
0.0303322915,
-0.0257844441,
-0.0131394397,
0.0329462849,
-0.0214221571,
0.0168788601,
-0.0053224568,
0.0220047366,
-0.0452113301,
-0.0381252989,
-0.0219497327,
-0.0420646146,
-0.0482968092,
-0.005563844,
0.0156723373,
0.0301407427,
0.0769665092,
0.042473495,
0.0046997541,
0.0264611747,
-0.0088827116,
-0.0487563945,
-0.0217055529,
-0.0033530421,
-0.0431681015,
-0.0534520708,
0.0619332828,
-0.0285893604,
-0.0217900164,
-0.0274910368,
-0.042886667,
0.0290048476,
0.0150216063,
-0.0728172883,
0.0216093715,
0.0437791832,
0.0385940075,
0.1013362408,
0.0606918894,
-0.0314811282,
0.0104285059,
-0.0317440853,
-0.0601979792,
0.0185539406,
-0.0361196212,
-0.0084425174,
-0.0328791365,
-0.0884677395,
0.0163251292,
0.0737831369,
-0.0128163453,
-0.0167888701,
-0.0244838204,
-0.0533815548,
-0.0180889778,
-0.0845065787,
-0.0240657888,
0.0033647865,
0.0191728678,
0.0132298162,
0.0077500525,
0.0230169613,
0.0366273075,
0.0281768534,
0.0235787779,
0.060166046,
0.0415871628,
-0.0082949698,
0.0694699585,
0.0702261254,
-0.0160581265,
-0.0200106911,
0.0556974858,
0.0121254986,
-0.025595108,
-0.0151682217,
0.0117004057,
0.0056182384,
-0.0210946556,
-0.0321767405,
-0.0497335829,
-0.0775209442,
0.04498671,
-0.0629217476,
0.0127275893,
0.0135867475,
0.0128238546,
-0.0143444045,
0.0703987703,
-0.0082738027,
0.0299646724,
0.0184307955,
-0.0147806611,
-0.0258176737,
0.0066157752,
-0.0503507815,
0.0547724068,
0.0590090565,
0.0318629257,
-0.0400188379,
0.0253729932,
0.0101458421,
0.0713709518,
-0.0042660921,
0.0010239454,
-0.0027204631,
0.031002095,
-0.0063564535,
0.0121906148,
0.0713966265,
0.0254492629,
0.0279485472,
-0.0210544374,
0.0177124962,
-0.0128341801,
-0.0133267669,
0.0397032388,
-0.027960781,
0.0217747707,
-0.0132596642,
0.0133733666,
-0.0067157811,
0.0084028132,
-0.0085330801,
-0.0078449342,
-0.0542492047,
-0.0295117144,
0.0788079575,
0.0196770709,
0.0472119078,
-0.0100881048,
-0.0435508117,
0.0565433726,
-0.0623950809,
-0.0240875706,
-0.0629927814,
-0.050063394,
-0.0158021767,
0.0205288939,
-0.033849407,
0.0291098338,
0.0159743167,
0.0520645753,
0.0047469768,
-0.0442470945,
0.035674043,
0.0519631617,
0.0334468409,
-0.0460966751,
-0.0090284972,
-0.0350426398,
0.0259396657,
0.0240154751,
0.0002838013,
0.0320416428,
-0.1112428159,
0.0314222574,
-0.0072024819,
0.004800736,
-0.009616063,
0.0330634601,
-0.0022332082,
-0.0189737733,
-0.0082701091,
-0.0523152761,
-0.0404755063,
0.0264739711,
0.0049078413,
0.0142613426,
-0.0607429557,
-0.0131858224,
-0.0082659349,
0.0011475986,
-0.0268859062,
-0.045527488,
-0.0388572961,
-0.0982698202,
0.0315721557,
-0.0630232319,
0.003936789,
-0.0875719637,
-0.0475597866,
-0.0018538685,
-0.0250814538,
-0.055717878,
0.0442621447,
-0.0105598513,
-0.0116853844,
-0.028732514,
0.0083684269,
0.0301060267,
0.0078074369,
0.0242090337,
-0.0182971507,
-0.0177481901,
-0.0330933183,
-0.04225659,
0.0093535511,
-0.0618081018,
0.0685745105,
0.0525039658,
0.006925473,
0.0183168091,
-0.0002374778,
-0.0185037013,
0.0193477925,
0.0292829089,
0.0054164603,
0.0615866706,
0.0021811156,
-0.0146875037,
0.0244209673,
0.0242385026,
-0.0085097998,
-0.0031520412,
0.0328774527,
-0.031019453,
-0.0337364338,
-0.0213899165,
-0.0178821236,
-0.0002177339,
0.0210212264,
0.0381228179,
0.0524094366,
0.0085962871,
0.000043305,
-0.023196429,
0.0233898629,
-0.0427584499,
-0.025408892,
-0.0531849079,
0.003659802,
-0.0345538966,
0.0020765429,
0.0304249451,
-0.0518920347,
0.0330955051,
-0.0002218331,
0.0389196649,
-0.0019592466,
-0.0262211598,
-0.0189977083,
0.039795544,
-0.0504387207,
0.0243747495,
0.0179857742,
0.0456812009,
0.0356038287,
0.017641861,
0.0382323563,
0.0090471301,
0.0251381956,
-0.0621377751,
-0.0643780306,
-0.0238914788,
0.0230268296,
-0.0161299631,
0.0014335803,
0.0076305429,
-0.0613192953,
0.0324757136,
-0.0253969282,
0.0151519869,
-0.0148988683,
0.0053695966,
-0.0200712997,
-0.0158985741,
-0.0487070754,
0.0057986258,
0.0513141155,
-0.0021243992,
0.0189885627,
-0.048923932,
-0.0061316197,
0.0045679109,
0.0072190193,
0.0761780217,
-0.0367799625,
-0.0134614585,
-0.0194486305,
-0.0442836136,
0.0012694425,
-0.0279678274,
0.0673396066,
0.0384488143,
-0.0236664135,
-0.0177002456,
-0.0202656798,
-0.0323177129,
-0.0421130732,
0.0074599851,
-0.0268729012,
-0.0507585779,
-0.0065822396,
-0.0248222575,
-6.614082799e-33,
-0.0239986703,
-0.0159902256,
0.013262976,
-0.0080171302,
-0.0308995713,
-0.0375304483,
0.0004773644,
0.0333919898,
-0.0239167884,
-0.0008123193,
-0.0272850767,
0.0198255908,
0.0177874099,
-0.0241271853,
0.0313423313,
-0.0317967422,
-0.0128032994,
-0.0288261957,
-0.021472998,
-0.000757024,
-0.0448376983,
-0.0386226736,
-0.0251964405,
0.0025734629,
0.0039570108,
-0.0273610782,
0.0049413722,
0.0346210748,
-0.0456542596,
-0.0542187057,
0.019167522,
-0.0231373627,
0.0152042368,
0.0122628268,
0.0019687903,
0.0002848696,
0.005702225,
0.0029468865,
-0.0385656767,
-0.0016736023,
-0.1025015563,
-0.0172849987,
0.0496588461,
0.0250844024,
-0.0681948289,
0.0068026786,
0.0589768775,
0.0313542113,
0.0035442431,
0.0231267512,
-0.0308254194,
-0.020837171,
-0.0382092781,
-0.0417217761,
0.0505591445,
0.0359115638,
0.0158519838,
-0.0209697802,
-0.0059065144,
0.0091488753,
-0.0198988896,
-0.0112407394,
0.0116767185,
-0.0039431085,
0.0813531429,
0.000849983,
-0.0051388652,
0.0098147942,
-0.0403547026,
-0.047215011,
0.0291185826,
0.0418869443,
-0.0143823819,
0.0521068014,
-0.0625700355,
-0.0721552521,
0.003560768,
0.0050626406,
0.0311898664,
-0.0406000279,
0.0010174477,
-0.0206870288,
-0.0948696956,
0.013939363,
-0.0009715548,
-0.0431568846,
0.0315477923,
-0.0311981384,
-0.0017197726,
0.025264848,
0.0124695003,
-0.0377655327,
0.037628714,
-0.0224584211,
-0.0249202028,
-0.0387991779,
-0.0030663479,
0.0209626611,
0.0013996267,
-0.0208684076,
-0.1662015468,
-0.0217449255,
-0.0815467685,
-0.0101195872,
0.0222161692,
0.025594851,
-0.0273296777,
0.0271371529,
0.0274823103,
-0.0188557226,
-0.0168261025,
0.0061277472,
0.1008674875,
-0.028429294,
0.031729605,
0.0064918231,
-0.0025272232,
-0.0230881143,
-0.037564937,
-0.0535905957,
-0.0120127387,
0.0023976879,
-0.0125441104,
0.0065177656,
0.0255626868,
0.015578812,
-0.0170519948,
-0.0309925228,
-0.0403929763,
0.0435346067,
-0.0240385123,
-0.0652805641,
2.777e-7,
-0.062602438,
0.0436909199,
0.0029891031,
0.0208378248,
-0.002551052,
0.1060363427,
-0.0025844325,
0.041748248,
0.0225149989,
0.0089544533,
0.0613081269,
0.0735392421,
-0.0071490463,
-0.0300448015,
0.0404536873,
0.0212472267,
0.022714762,
0.0181637518,
0.041573979,
-0.0321657173,
0.0482980944,
-0.0095658423,
0.0100371744,
0.0254552774,
0.0331645235,
0.0729943812,
0.017837964,
-0.0588674657,
-0.0217447896,
0.0544785559,
-0.0271739792,
-0.0150148729,
-0.0074198642,
0.0443594679,
0.0118526975,
-0.0245119464,
-0.0658384487,
0.0503229834,
-0.0122070713,
-0.0439664014,
-0.0064719464,
-0.0406281166,
0.0153500047,
-0.0073248474,
-0.0063174246,
0.009423798,
-0.0070578652,
0.011075981,
0.0098886164,
-0.0015288563,
0.0328316055,
0.0531964228,
0.011498672,
0.0234398711,
0.0385900103,
0.0208655708,
-0.0127219362,
0.0242582858,
0.004326704,
-0.0416546389,
0.0454440191,
-0.0654487759,
0.0181974564,
0.1652775556,
0.0063165021,
0.0155662755,
-0.0623703487,
1.474749384e-34,
0.005827365,
0.0439354256,
-0.0051639858,
-0.0378699899,
0.0393471047,
0.02546902,
-0.0354806446,
0.0148213478,
-0.0134232678,
0.0540568419,
-0.0070777973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11679v2 | Domain Mastery Benchmark: An Ever-Updating Benchmark for Evaluating Holistic Domain Knowledge of Large Language Model--A Preliminary Release | 2023-04-23T15:11:49 | 2023-08-10T05:27:58 | Zhouhong Gu, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Haoning Ye, Lin Zhang, Zhuozhi Xiong, Zihan Li, Qianyu He, Sihang Jiang, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain knowledge refers to the in-depth understanding, expertise, and
familiarity with a specific subject, industry, field, or area of special
interest. The existing benchmarks are all lack of an overall design for domain
knowledge evaluation. Holding the belief that the real ability of domain
language understanding can only be fairly evaluated by an comprehensive and
in-depth benchmark, we introduces the Domma, a Domain Mastery Benchmark. DomMa
targets at testing Large Language Models (LLMs) on their domain knowledge
understanding, it features extensive domain coverage, large data volume, and a
continually updated data set based on Chinese 112 first-level subject
classifications. DomMa consist of 100,000 questions in both Chinese and English
sourced from graduate entrance examinations and undergraduate exams in Chinese
college. We have also propose designs to make benchmark and evaluation process
more suitable to LLMs. | [
-0.0079413345,
-0.0185087174,
-0.0353218168,
0.0587187447,
-0.0040802122,
0.0164943077,
0.0096992189,
0.001576239,
0.0183795765,
-0.0388867334,
-0.0592537299,
-0.0613955222,
-0.0343246125,
0.0233348235,
0.0181903187,
-0.049071148,
0.0343569554,
-0.0003081817,
-0.0445982553,
-0.003026241,
0.0013820641,
-0.042353373,
-0.0070821382,
0.0122527471,
0.0375460386,
-0.068357721,
0.0161498711,
-0.0128852911,
0.0062258733,
-0.0521455556,
0.0495473966,
0.0353269689,
0.0314273201,
0.0361001268,
0.0000022938,
-0.0812152773,
-0.0336102135,
-0.0023289181,
-0.0331685729,
0.0282193013,
0.0254361182,
0.0382578075,
0.0146850413,
0.0208814014,
-0.0538784079,
-0.0254040826,
-0.011752083,
0.0452082753,
0.0389556848,
0.0737342387,
0.0123928329,
-0.0269966703,
0.0263709612,
-0.0414820462,
-0.0483393744,
-0.0945577174,
0.0326888561,
0.0832145587,
0.0202232394,
-0.021981515,
-0.0511387326,
0.0051327082,
0.0314499959,
0.0008727031,
-0.015014424,
0.0179578997,
0.0096874302,
0.0216731764,
0.0428909026,
0.07102222,
0.0282953698,
0.0242906976,
-0.0108050471,
0.0175222717,
0.0047577778,
0.0460888632,
-0.0603818558,
0.0053249886,
0.0111386832,
-0.0093849292,
-0.0176736284,
0.008051577,
0.0244856253,
0.0131232375,
-0.0216172691,
0.0657475516,
0.0122923153,
-0.0255376231,
0.0229657181,
-0.0085218865,
-0.0105527779,
-0.040509697,
-0.0227331724,
0.0157123413,
-0.0243403353,
0.0255481154,
0.0237255991,
-0.0227937549,
0.0171104185,
-0.0428502597,
0.0094407685,
0.0073414631,
-0.0171961859,
0.0552892275,
-0.0092818281,
0.0885214582,
0.0246345606,
-0.0280801561,
-0.056488961,
-0.0283575971,
-0.0635504648,
0.0002357082,
0.0118923215,
0.061340794,
-0.0066272859,
0.0033080303,
-0.067023091,
-0.003684879,
-0.0254862309,
0.0164280795,
-0.0205508191,
-0.0291789807,
-0.005809701,
-0.0250978675,
-0.0536884218,
0.0564651005,
-0.0371518955,
0.0136852134,
-0.0224460624,
-0.0154846087,
0.0154540949,
0.0002067904,
-0.0275730845,
-0.0215867031,
-0.0008466621,
0.0664399117,
-0.0086933514,
-0.0111395568,
-0.0387708433,
-0.0193091016,
0.0084867831,
-0.0700916871,
0.0478033163,
-0.0745580867,
-0.0247351583,
0.014457671,
0.0360025913,
-0.0545064211,
0.0156431869,
-0.009275455,
0.0362295285,
0.0116862999,
-0.0045259479,
-0.0047082291,
0.0234269109,
0.0482167266,
-0.0053594187,
0.0822414681,
-0.0238220785,
0.008904798,
0.0490354784,
-0.0194214843,
-0.0189725868,
0.0224020258,
0.0030829892,
0.0088518206,
-0.0161902811,
0.0553552993,
0.0146004483,
0.001685197,
0.0108390246,
0.0013258638,
0.0053385491,
0.0099805845,
0.0379375555,
0.0361502282,
0.0104979603,
0.001676834,
0.0205073934,
0.0182619635,
0.0434807166,
0.0221802108,
-0.0044242693,
-0.0072137997,
0.0005429093,
0.0168256722,
-0.0076817693,
-0.0176894087,
-0.009924721,
-0.0597308278,
-0.0234373286,
0.0174929406,
-0.0356750228,
0.0337459818,
0.0557966307,
-0.0137247862,
0.0065834518,
0.0468931235,
0.0059856628,
-0.0287526958,
0.0241885521,
0.0015532667,
-0.0142723639,
0.0112680886,
0.0278508794,
-0.0676296726,
-0.0754064396,
0.0088904155,
0.0486531146,
0.0615972765,
0.0683230758,
-0.0244351551,
-0.0335375071,
-0.0264158174,
-0.0145461941,
-0.0177032892,
0.0310067907,
-0.0065791924,
0.0070231352,
0.0322618149,
0.0091677709,
-0.104633294,
-0.0350095592,
0.0134185152,
-0.078811869,
-0.034563791,
-0.0132116759,
0.0047201025,
0.0256253742,
0.0198593456,
-0.0291961785,
-0.0052952557,
0.011579236,
-0.0245525185,
-0.0386918522,
-0.0204966702,
-0.0167313647,
-0.0004203319,
0.082007274,
-0.0823648795,
-0.0677818656,
0.0661737919,
-0.0482267439,
-0.0340779461,
0.0065089962,
0.0156200714,
-0.0113123972,
-0.0554767922,
0.0373070575,
-0.0585121438,
0.0122406697,
-0.026607912,
0.0798361897,
0.0247065257,
0.0517564677,
-0.0105688758,
0.0081237759,
0.0577895083,
0.0104219345,
-0.0355609544,
-0.022843698,
-0.0367627293,
0.0587791763,
0.0082876394,
0.0150507651,
-0.1002476513,
0.008433694,
-0.0451743789,
0.0332157612,
-0.0125696864,
0.0230941009,
0.0285068937,
-0.0282495767,
-0.0109010572,
0.0073792245,
-0.0545418486,
-0.006135466,
-0.0289625302,
-0.0198727846,
0.0095181782,
0.012522785,
-0.0013012232,
-0.0308990628,
0.0254401155,
-0.0294517558,
0.0239966083,
-0.0027386849,
0.044036191,
0.0116098588,
0.0829613358,
-0.0188909099,
-0.0117830848,
-0.012133033,
-0.0388583839,
-0.0203050654,
-0.0058659986,
0.0156232445,
0.0202891324,
-0.0010429518,
0.0157324541,
0.0459731221,
-0.0138790635,
-0.0271282867,
0.002068589,
-0.0005964946,
-0.0157395657,
-0.0585721768,
0.0123034893,
0.0218607429,
0.0556610301,
0.0027169706,
-0.0278584994,
0.0071574589,
-0.0072206808,
-0.0980862528,
0.0141514316,
-0.0592399538,
0.0553042032,
-0.0300165657,
0.0211487431,
-0.0222457834,
-0.0061902078,
0.0527566448,
-0.0234518778,
0.0045931726,
-0.0631370842,
-0.0041634422,
-0.0435763523,
0.0559209026,
-0.0354480371,
0.0110959774,
0.0242945421,
-0.0364981182,
-0.0683701783,
0.0345956683,
0.001613659,
-0.0540250316,
0.0583768003,
-0.0437661782,
0.0085458616,
-0.0083233723,
-0.016928494,
-0.0584746115,
0.033184953,
-0.015101146,
0.0376789235,
-0.0084182303,
-0.003933215,
-0.0127049647,
-0.0022654096,
0.0025543736,
-0.0116407899,
-0.0022774127,
-0.0084072538,
0.0052489387,
0.0411045253,
0.0290101636,
0.0348040275,
-0.0045347228,
-0.0531137176,
0.0589653812,
0.0423788354,
0.040793553,
0.0053427401,
-0.001584193,
0.0052812994,
0.032241527,
-0.0723080635,
0.0042653047,
0.0252816994,
0.0166692454,
-0.0574311763,
0.0028607114,
0.141826719,
0.0203219075,
0.0004173684,
-0.0074670347,
-0.0481561273,
-0.0174464434,
0.065247491,
0.0339392908,
-0.0874291584,
-0.0151389148,
-0.0101788752,
0.0096115153,
0.0311041307,
-0.0337415226,
0.0130395154,
-0.1333550513,
0.0180126913,
-0.0308715291,
-0.0347771272,
-0.0096001308,
-0.0184256863,
0.0265738238,
0.0213684756,
0.0421745516,
-0.0046281242,
-0.0164731517,
-0.0268596765,
0.0447387397,
-0.033240281,
-0.0886326581,
0.0833803341,
-0.0487001166,
0.0291805547,
0.028007526,
0.0472910404,
-0.0424324088,
0.0083109308,
0.0219371319,
-0.0291134249,
-0.0224547572,
0.0073348247,
0.0441309847,
0.0076799532,
-0.0146197146,
0.0246272627,
0.0151978098,
-0.0379077047,
0.0315159187,
0.0669403747,
0.0801227614,
0.0077428729,
-0.023493994,
-0.0148957064,
-0.015180923,
-0.0447000302,
0.0691306219,
0.0436336547,
-0.0318470597,
0.02614481,
-0.0181079656,
-0.0308526494,
-0.0191153139,
-0.0366790444,
0.0591017827,
-0.0259227473,
0.0071269688,
-0.0629602224,
-0.0194526725,
0.0507148691,
0.0068636639,
0.0256621931,
0.0467743874,
0.0350717828,
0.0111621059,
-0.0676524714,
0.0190101936,
-0.0375316627,
0.0245565921,
-0.0938802138,
0.0060341465,
0.0447102264,
-0.0057375287,
-0.0386622883,
0.0039018786,
-0.0310508534,
-0.029633319,
-0.0133739319,
0.0050697606,
0.0076436214,
-0.0254611466,
-0.017831482,
-0.0355704129,
0.0043836543,
-0.0278692245,
-0.0221794602,
0.0150243295,
0.0143466117,
-0.0762089714,
-0.0113481181,
0.0192895588,
-0.0506116077,
0.0266873464,
0.0458961353,
0.0299721658,
0.0210217573,
0.0092248116,
0.0260205325,
0.0418807119,
0.0272279922,
0.0343187451,
-0.0000452035,
-0.0277530421,
0.0295639113,
-0.0119436393,
-0.0373091102,
-0.0099701202,
-0.0341463685,
0.0574448481,
-0.0186705757,
-0.0033954028,
0.0535686873,
-0.0139149409,
0.0011702809,
-0.0130314566,
0.0284990277,
0.0133385658,
0.0242993832,
0.0236802567,
-0.0131804142,
0.0043780147,
-0.0732011124,
0.028114127,
0.0472433269,
0.0037012268,
0.062621057,
0.0080421343,
0.0206525344,
0.0194794741,
0.0021487798,
-0.0122085037,
-0.0505188815,
0.0264438447,
0.0046716793,
0.0862799212,
-0.0123242587,
0.0116777653,
-0.0356952436,
0.0207150597,
-0.036956571,
-0.0093312021,
-0.0291925147,
-0.0208041407,
0.0430866219,
0.0386641659,
-0.0077290433,
0.021339234,
0.0861527994,
0.0340045616,
0.0355322175,
0.0111159971,
0.0125567969,
-0.029834792,
-0.0077264337,
0.0580552369,
0.0291512832,
-0.0109558534,
0.0264746845,
-0.1051987112,
-0.1026864871,
0.0193899591,
0.0133248866,
-0.000177908,
-0.0026583441,
0.0176540408,
0.0602586605,
-0.0142121147,
0.0092514418,
-0.042964384,
0.0106060831,
-0.0297401249,
-0.0080645895,
0.0127428807,
-6.630885756e-33,
-0.020994395,
-0.0354872346,
0.029491825,
-0.0333779007,
-0.0118826861,
0.0222268514,
-0.0259291492,
0.019556677,
-0.047860276,
0.0196463391,
-0.0280726776,
0.0302024242,
0.0018375248,
0.0161889326,
-0.007989035,
-0.0010641726,
0.0278338119,
-0.0045855842,
-0.0078955824,
0.0017248464,
0.0199672692,
0.0426952578,
0.0577861704,
-0.0730240121,
0.0206782315,
-0.0004000389,
0.0137252072,
-0.0060140663,
0.0172178149,
0.0637736768,
0.0008117326,
0.0470079072,
0.0423342027,
-0.0971830487,
-0.0052556396,
-0.0430244654,
-0.0770497546,
-0.0560833178,
0.0357581824,
0.0245800037,
0.0279979277,
-0.0195840672,
0.0131882671,
0.0238267388,
0.0075668842,
-0.0264569148,
0.0483755767,
-0.0410276689,
0.0100512207,
-0.0279411823,
-0.0431955718,
0.0143393176,
-0.024245007,
0.0117369127,
-0.0069239694,
-0.0099120988,
-0.001684762,
0.0024138999,
-0.0410220996,
0.0077740112,
0.0219025146,
0.0740426034,
0.0667819157,
-0.0079052513,
0.005502231,
0.0644285977,
-0.021587966,
0.0284844078,
0.070962064,
0.0025386668,
0.0333397798,
0.0587366521,
0.0022284372,
0.0799075663,
0.0198600851,
0.0001498547,
-0.0813041031,
0.0615050085,
-0.0184745751,
0.008822008,
-0.015721377,
-0.0157982744,
-0.0248950813,
-0.0057676351,
-0.0611110255,
0.0690550804,
-0.0233787969,
-0.0207231566,
0.0537394993,
-0.0428253226,
-0.0201902483,
-0.0376299433,
0.0090680746,
-0.0895586386,
-0.0470235497,
-0.0027686772,
0.0080719842,
0.0156830456,
-0.005002684,
0.039061442,
-0.0379133373,
-0.0411412604,
-0.0410005525,
0.0020956695,
0.0127836047,
-0.0152118718,
0.0219860338,
-0.0245695841,
-0.0215816833,
-0.0113477595,
-0.0200394113,
-0.0424557291,
0.0217309967,
0.0751254112,
-0.0003029334,
0.0232778788,
0.0092608398,
0.0398325548,
0.0270571858,
-0.0472419895,
-0.0446142256,
0.0171775743,
-0.0084649241,
-0.0015888775,
-0.0388680771,
-0.0104897749,
-0.0308168605,
0.0060065272,
0.0803491399,
-0.0326857455,
-0.0121764997,
-0.0279052425,
2.837e-7,
0.0618427023,
0.0525191985,
-0.017775245,
0.0499469824,
-0.0198420584,
0.0495603159,
-0.0579449125,
0.0076967538,
0.0142087219,
0.0037932277,
-0.0123970639,
0.0122325318,
0.050638672,
0.0217277315,
-0.1014978737,
-0.0301222075,
0.0407970473,
-0.0170227084,
-0.0224502943,
0.0264687818,
0.0132555189,
0.0619284026,
0.0080009559,
-0.0099007161,
-0.0043950798,
-0.0623904876,
0.0256077629,
-0.0074618803,
0.0152752325,
0.0826280788,
-0.0129654622,
0.0433157831,
0.0067751934,
0.0177388396,
-0.0110986372,
0.0227862559,
0.033464022,
0.0653009415,
0.0360886417,
0.035094846,
-0.0128321033,
-0.0269323587,
0.0088648386,
-0.0459792651,
0.0320696197,
-0.0501528345,
-0.0462957211,
0.0006416091,
-0.0248506721,
-0.0341896676,
-0.0141282231,
-0.0075454814,
0.0048798672,
0.0188238882,
-0.0103237145,
-0.0296556577,
-0.0036913822,
-0.0016917908,
-0.0248854253,
-0.0030087582,
-0.0330517627,
-0.0663615614,
-0.0040266104,
-0.0472870655,
0.0065677464,
-0.0530781634,
0.0077917767,
2.422279909e-34,
0.0118433833,
-0.0092595778,
0.008483436,
0.0500127599,
0.0330022164,
-0.0262611061,
-0.0336361825,
-0.0039582909,
-0.0302361101,
-0.051660005,
0.0108855115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11666v1 | Hold the Suspect! : An Analysis on Media Framing of Itaewon Halloween Crowd Crush | 2023-04-23T14:22:25 | 2023-04-23T14:22:25 | TaeYoung Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, stat.AP | Based on the 10.9K articles from top 40 news providers of South Korea, this
paper analyzed the media framing of Itaewon Halloween Crowd Crush during the
first 72 hours after the incident. By adopting word-vector embedding and
clustering, we figured out that conservative media focused on political
parties' responses and the suspect's identity while the liberal media covered
the responsibility of the government and possible unequal spillover effect on
the low-income industry workers. Although the social tragedy was not directly
connected to institutional politics, the media clearly exhibited political bias
in the coverage process. | [
0.012689,
0.0093988031,
0.0024161888,
0.0158178192,
-0.0085941805,
-0.0052328594,
0.0092036808,
-0.0002366676,
-0.0147704696,
-0.0261095744,
0.0467605181,
0.0485857725,
0.004164842,
0.0038210645,
-0.0098521374,
-0.0861071795,
0.0389688052,
0.0586284474,
0.0434864834,
-0.003365133,
-0.0081156651,
0.0181359649,
0.0204266515,
0.03249662,
-0.0220776889,
0.0175593961,
-0.0287706126,
0.0014207419,
0.0422024801,
-0.0480675288,
-0.0332765393,
-0.0254016537,
0.064074479,
0.0273239259,
0.0000018016,
0.0047062421,
-0.0194111727,
-0.0279475413,
0.0082769478,
-0.0248890817,
0.0597892255,
-0.0726347789,
-0.0218590051,
-0.0201778617,
0.0038309554,
-0.07540261,
0.0275417455,
0.0297958553,
0.0697561204,
0.0600611679,
0.0154658584,
-0.0631075576,
-0.0510328487,
0.022694489,
-0.0442087688,
-0.0364502817,
0.0240323506,
-0.0225578211,
-0.045336578,
-0.0145493308,
-0.0059569613,
-0.0107344938,
-0.0245446153,
0.0269624386,
-0.0458172895,
-0.0040075397,
-0.0246907044,
-0.0211589392,
0.0601664111,
0.0225901306,
0.0197275728,
-0.0190738309,
0.0124967229,
0.0023826016,
-0.0083177593,
0.0251861792,
-0.0058960156,
0.0299782287,
0.0072907335,
0.0149388118,
0.0024285682,
0.0246049892,
0.0226206202,
0.042763371,
-0.0099362452,
0.0310626775,
0.0063675707,
-0.025051279,
-0.0458873212,
-0.0410990901,
-0.0219365787,
0.0080434242,
0.0023247332,
0.0031287777,
-0.0059199585,
0.0191671178,
0.0202534087,
-0.0107876472,
-0.0108909942,
-0.1113085076,
-0.0725909397,
0.0123012755,
0.0305613279,
0.0162406806,
0.0687855557,
-0.0507999547,
-0.0006370282,
0.0176709779,
0.0044333423,
0.04142325,
-0.020848766,
0.0484145619,
-0.0053033656,
-0.0130344117,
-0.0258222483,
0.002319108,
0.0090046301,
0.0000253913,
0.0005871051,
0.0097305737,
-0.0515806414,
-0.0078978557,
-0.0207455102,
0.0357924551,
-0.0165376347,
0.0321206599,
-0.0797817409,
0.0291207917,
-0.0021743102,
0.0517782755,
-0.0088515244,
0.0501231775,
0.0395558961,
0.0354804248,
-0.0313675813,
-0.072861135,
-0.0064325607,
0.0357401781,
-0.069904767,
-0.0256814603,
-0.0261320043,
-0.0335753299,
0.0131279193,
-0.0388775356,
-0.0007094672,
-0.0111197531,
-0.0088832173,
0.033813756,
-0.0102145998,
0.0228704344,
-0.015964387,
0.0411955565,
0.0343037248,
0.0100294454,
0.0294771865,
0.0317349955,
0.034319479,
0.0475194529,
0.011616285,
0.0331693441,
0.0286678504,
-0.0346808136,
0.0202095732,
-0.0167790689,
-0.0176485796,
-0.0024386803,
-0.0326875076,
-0.0025255219,
-0.0059078289,
-0.0002266518,
0.0210257638,
-0.0337038226,
0.0199055113,
0.0401479118,
-0.0297629125,
0.0354637653,
-0.1154279113,
-0.0007947229,
0.0174211133,
0.0422415547,
-0.0568263978,
0.0373114087,
0.0280124247,
-0.025801396,
-0.04067415,
-0.004600259,
-0.0109926844,
0.0069891065,
-0.0399489142,
0.0374345891,
-0.0178846717,
0.0282921214,
0.0793490782,
-0.0392136611,
0.0031967955,
-0.0008370451,
-0.0591171123,
0.0352178104,
0.0244812444,
0.005587542,
-0.0093941847,
-0.0349141806,
-0.0178131144,
-0.0038316706,
-0.0046619405,
0.0145048769,
0.0500312708,
-0.0350414179,
0.0232953057,
0.0181139726,
-0.0120844496,
-0.0014880297,
-0.0723108947,
0.0027955447,
-0.0083381571,
-0.0036774403,
0.0697223619,
0.0297003053,
-0.0183425974,
0.0294891167,
0.0148347123,
0.0274177082,
0.0108552743,
0.011203764,
0.0402304269,
-0.0034612559,
-0.0708271265,
0.0061055161,
0.0466861837,
0.0422273912,
-0.0059603932,
-0.0259500258,
0.0487887561,
0.0009250116,
-0.0550307333,
0.0328600183,
-0.0095073516,
-0.0267496426,
-0.0610921495,
-0.0545343235,
-0.0215566438,
0.0093971984,
-0.0147600388,
-0.0070648179,
0.1060387343,
0.0333642215,
0.0331139602,
-0.0220003892,
0.0138666285,
-0.0381986573,
-0.0372759551,
0.0054129693,
0.0779814124,
-0.0119785136,
0.0293022338,
-0.044644773,
0.0078344643,
0.0214049388,
0.0085911024,
-0.0222078618,
0.0187472831,
-0.0085196886,
0.0675026327,
-0.0288571604,
-0.0333718508,
-0.0243712403,
-0.0352229103,
0.0107682189,
0.0207714904,
-0.0338316001,
-0.0263017751,
0.0232552998,
0.0174088348,
-0.0263605192,
0.0069085839,
0.018510865,
-0.0428435095,
-0.0054077627,
0.0036498413,
-0.0433953963,
0.0020501448,
0.004233194,
0.011087873,
-0.0075200424,
-0.0659116134,
-0.011929783,
0.0129238619,
-0.0709086508,
0.0191479735,
0.0183203276,
-0.0212029088,
-0.0622879192,
-0.0240136348,
-0.0471057743,
0.007447477,
0.0198793709,
-0.0139933303,
0.0770943686,
0.0371053293,
0.0531866737,
0.0261960886,
0.0272440948,
-0.0012806999,
0.0120744528,
-0.0586521067,
-0.0254018866,
-0.0293451585,
-0.04273092,
-0.0096747559,
0.0274845865,
0.0464360304,
0.0253840517,
-0.0312435627,
-0.0542292334,
-0.074212499,
0.013902626,
-0.0132954698,
-0.0597341061,
-0.0258628763,
0.0235595573,
0.0161089562,
0.0487912335,
0.0036501486,
0.0284156986,
0.0766343549,
-0.046152629,
0.0060698912,
-0.0182692371,
0.032803461,
-0.0311901923,
0.0155467326,
-0.0534111224,
-0.0209635999,
0.0087907724,
-0.0478210635,
0.0153133078,
-0.0385922976,
-0.0072887419,
0.0227962136,
-0.001772802,
-0.0201320667,
0.0227879602,
-0.0063485955,
-0.0950543806,
-0.0288225338,
-0.0235076472,
0.0423900671,
0.0244794916,
-0.039814122,
0.0873722658,
0.0233894847,
-0.0986122862,
0.0354162715,
0.0097798072,
-0.0260305181,
0.0113974093,
-0.0337270349,
-0.0127446176,
0.0033405907,
0.0167764723,
0.0021493363,
0.0079696784,
0.0472209826,
0.0252078809,
0.0008954295,
0.0209890436,
0.0072654067,
-0.0106468042,
0.0089227566,
-0.0288283546,
0.0691655576,
-0.0276873056,
0.0797444731,
0.0678189918,
0.0311248321,
-0.0314045511,
-0.0070366068,
0.0240185801,
-0.0532159917,
0.0535172522,
0.0160691869,
-0.0010393197,
0.0507694744,
0.0565719195,
0.0067631332,
-0.0250145141,
-0.0201745816,
0.0142640853,
-0.0730587617,
0.0221953951,
0.007196506,
0.0208861176,
-0.0094480375,
-0.1021345854,
0.0221851338,
-0.0115396054,
0.003603088,
0.0077964915,
0.0279788151,
-0.0355473645,
-0.0179066993,
-0.0660048723,
-0.0352301337,
0.0145364692,
-0.0353968963,
0.0267894045,
-0.0205048714,
0.0838582069,
-0.0349251479,
0.0116347205,
0.0165064447,
-0.0051617208,
-0.0372933671,
-0.0351140387,
0.0690996349,
-0.0466066152,
0.0004777941,
-0.0184355155,
0.0334682018,
0.0178848524,
0.0052114953,
-0.0025470166,
-0.0093026459,
0.0386694483,
-0.0832631811,
0.0164814871,
0.0309317596,
0.0451157987,
0.0213548504,
0.0229747128,
0.0132407704,
0.0632933602,
-0.0402918421,
0.0404110402,
0.0262875129,
-0.0110251904,
0.0184327364,
-0.0301516317,
-0.0177026372,
0.0326733738,
-0.0509409122,
-0.0383547805,
0.0722633153,
0.0037331367,
-0.0189207215,
0.0144154252,
-0.0242114551,
-0.0210183039,
0.0040987018,
0.0431295298,
0.0032776608,
0.0722530931,
0.0051319073,
-0.0490827225,
0.0981038883,
-0.0360039696,
-0.0080430014,
-0.004160434,
-0.0184427761,
0.0466214344,
-0.0567291565,
0.009395388,
0.0445171557,
-0.0330762863,
0.0524065085,
0.0112789245,
-0.0034334827,
-0.0657041669,
0.0110609122,
-0.0234767348,
-0.0022529436,
0.0116910813,
0.0164036602,
-0.0008421499,
0.0475841053,
0.0206852425,
-0.0039037769,
-0.0823050961,
0.005143594,
-0.0232833084,
0.0019304164,
0.0204523858,
0.0050255978,
-0.0176541563,
-0.0380692892,
-0.0450099148,
-0.0357530937,
-0.0338335149,
0.0418463461,
-0.0466934294,
0.0041240552,
-0.0157801192,
-0.0613273084,
0.0676004142,
-0.0423283763,
0.0324204527,
-0.0417580083,
0.0386649519,
0.0576995984,
0.0474217534,
-0.0089807054,
-0.014266083,
-0.0114598237,
-0.0251394454,
-0.0109180091,
-0.0086730858,
0.0131556643,
0.0062121176,
0.0328010619,
0.0188092832,
0.017229924,
-0.0198654849,
0.0101163266,
0.0056763617,
-0.0132750329,
-0.0211942215,
-0.0005440072,
-0.0520660058,
-0.0252356008,
0.0281735398,
-0.0335816853,
0.0246020798,
0.0151980426,
-0.0143634332,
-0.067219831,
0.0401554815,
0.0129032331,
-0.0525856391,
0.0503155813,
-0.0051825671,
-0.0087285247,
0.0150584606,
0.0716645196,
-0.0202361532,
0.0212944746,
0.0088686366,
0.077635996,
0.0413381681,
-0.0004255855,
-0.036356438,
-0.0745032281,
-0.0323617049,
-0.0090713138,
-0.0235221721,
0.0022181447,
0.0432260074,
-0.0321812555,
0.0384974852,
0.0382260941,
-0.0055246344,
0.0018214567,
0.0358222425,
-0.0475931726,
-0.0288314484,
0.0822112262,
-6.464166862e-33,
-0.0070986166,
-0.0243941005,
-0.0206406042,
-0.0168998465,
-0.0194285568,
0.0321955681,
-0.0030356417,
0.0153091662,
-0.0281864908,
-0.0067292517,
0.0030319586,
0.0324104019,
0.025628088,
-0.0347777791,
-0.0062231044,
-0.0397509299,
0.0209802967,
0.0027234196,
-0.0240688883,
0.0049344529,
0.0202340484,
-0.0192614011,
0.0270390585,
-0.0416253395,
0.0451444834,
0.0119994031,
-0.0099330349,
-0.0490807705,
0.1059001908,
0.0026452339,
-0.0157858469,
-0.0117056053,
0.0444083177,
-0.0182350501,
-0.0014210992,
0.0898778066,
-0.0099005187,
-0.0136185484,
0.0355397575,
0.0045440695,
-0.0299819075,
-0.0089098345,
-0.0101878671,
-0.0192527343,
-0.0183908213,
0.0276422556,
0.0204061214,
0.0052113673,
0.0037953078,
0.070706293,
-0.0471353903,
0.0150336036,
-0.0364824049,
0.0485919714,
-0.0317259394,
-0.0339632705,
0.0333406627,
0.077244468,
-0.0843419954,
-0.0425815247,
-0.1051189825,
-0.0270562209,
0.0142051456,
-0.0030597826,
-0.0020000029,
0.0265017003,
-0.0138527555,
0.0317494348,
-0.0772729144,
-0.0025951073,
0.0283328798,
0.0535203367,
-0.015346515,
0.0641201511,
0.0273937155,
-0.1099604219,
-0.078564167,
-0.0212358888,
-0.0206787754,
0.0394186676,
0.0561431311,
0.011246358,
-0.0377341621,
-0.0074417074,
-0.033631295,
-0.0348082669,
-0.0368486047,
-0.0084867198,
-0.0226763003,
0.0419462398,
-0.0647444949,
0.0074106059,
0.0302134082,
0.0002848258,
0.0173319038,
-0.0114018209,
-0.0074446145,
-0.0019922459,
-0.0105453618,
0.0368675515,
-0.0588197261,
0.0147899054,
-0.0189040117,
0.0728862062,
0.0311770942,
-0.0290270858,
-0.006066211,
0.0146009093,
-0.0149830142,
-0.0139455022,
0.0379832499,
-0.0567557178,
-0.0129101835,
-0.0381144509,
0.075370416,
0.0459997058,
0.0193362776,
-0.0866208673,
0.0745623708,
0.0218295325,
0.0540467463,
-0.0197449252,
-0.0775543973,
-0.0084983148,
0.0091256816,
0.0054065292,
0.0085423198,
0.011446543,
0.0203499775,
-0.0449517481,
-0.0073574609,
-0.0324875228,
2.664e-7,
0.0444996841,
0.019030055,
0.0017346013,
0.0240190532,
0.0027834873,
0.005787754,
-0.0132640796,
0.0561114997,
0.0022541506,
-0.0958051905,
0.0109510636,
0.028484663,
0.0053387061,
0.0487982146,
-0.0673139393,
0.085863322,
-0.0032908637,
0.0429402292,
-0.0408053622,
0.0209070146,
-0.017845476,
0.0333929844,
0.0323913358,
0.0279545113,
-0.0349075682,
-0.0383201279,
0.0080694677,
-0.002655226,
-0.0699670538,
0.0018243808,
0.0100466534,
0.0407634452,
0.0028513568,
-0.0046521886,
-0.0100842081,
0.0176975355,
0.0234967023,
0.0143814282,
0.0162511002,
0.0300251041,
-0.0145204943,
-0.0448030904,
0.0006011674,
-0.048362989,
0.0626859441,
-0.0146844564,
-0.0479505844,
-0.0516496301,
-0.0435258709,
0.0087741604,
0.0505192317,
0.0310427584,
-0.015653288,
0.0541717038,
0.0000425191,
0.0205160417,
0.0154896295,
-0.0135597056,
-0.0216187779,
0.0031091801,
-0.0587752797,
-0.0214859955,
0.0231032707,
0.0263137631,
0.0499568805,
0.0313120708,
0.0444461145,
2.192598185e-34,
0.045622997,
0.0135596059,
-0.0636938587,
-0.0626389235,
0.0351875164,
0.0116124786,
-0.0986074135,
-0.0393468067,
0.0193364359,
-0.0635434911,
0.0275989566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11664v1 | IslamicPCQA: A Dataset for Persian Multi-hop Complex Question Answering in Islamic Text Resources | 2023-04-23T14:20:58 | 2023-04-23T14:20:58 | Arash Ghafouri, Hasan Naderi, Mohammad Aghajani asl, Mahdi Firouzmandi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, one of the main challenges for Question Answering Systems is to
answer complex questions using various sources of information. Multi-hop
questions are a type of complex questions that require multi-step reasoning to
answer. In this article, the IslamicPCQA dataset is introduced. This is the
first Persian dataset for answering complex questions based on non-structured
information sources and consists of 12,282 question-answer pairs extracted from
9 Islamic encyclopedias. This dataset has been created inspired by the HotpotQA
English dataset approach, which was customized to suit the complexities of the
Persian language. Answering questions in this dataset requires more than one
paragraph and reasoning. The questions are not limited to any prior knowledge
base or ontology, and to provide robust reasoning ability, the dataset also
includes supporting facts and key sentences. The prepared dataset covers a wide
range of Islamic topics and aims to facilitate answering complex Persian
questions within this subject matter | [
0.0341109969,
0.0236450154,
-0.0298583452,
0.0166618545,
-0.0466748737,
0.0407288559,
0.0344571956,
-0.0029125307,
0.0047248011,
-0.0144189168,
-0.0039936448,
-0.0219104011,
0.015696587,
-0.0399148427,
0.0350894816,
-0.0179387704,
0.0398847871,
-0.0383943208,
-0.0030615891,
-0.0197274406,
0.0361605957,
0.0486194342,
-0.0445136689,
0.003466222,
-0.0101662157,
-0.0487080775,
-0.0341514125,
-0.0348621011,
0.0042358446,
-0.0173167083,
0.0207941439,
0.0557602346,
0.0313866064,
-0.0222649071,
0.0000019825,
-0.0742512345,
-0.0336668938,
-0.0211067088,
-0.003620893,
-0.0453749262,
-0.0409243964,
0.0106733292,
0.0106493719,
-0.0079546999,
-0.0312134158,
-0.0043103462,
0.0375444628,
0.0737741515,
0.066074647,
0.027480619,
0.0103975441,
-0.1070603058,
-0.0075642955,
0.0382628515,
0.0357779302,
-0.0228490848,
0.0140717421,
0.024859529,
0.0085555641,
0.002918123,
0.0104800919,
-0.0159427263,
0.0036974484,
-0.0278432816,
-0.0339659415,
-0.0377034508,
-0.0600938946,
-0.0177973043,
0.0487236641,
0.0555392951,
0.0700657666,
-0.0290641338,
0.0129854353,
0.0263419263,
-0.0123671927,
0.0848738253,
-0.0491840653,
0.0238362979,
-0.0670807734,
-0.03032762,
0.0420788825,
0.0187483691,
-0.0365151241,
0.0003262332,
-0.0386105292,
0.0859761536,
0.0074417675,
-0.0009564905,
-0.0140367644,
-0.0343225971,
-0.0428055823,
-0.0387237594,
0.0319421254,
0.0651443601,
-0.0179312602,
-0.006872905,
-0.0045174677,
-0.0060753347,
0.0490339287,
-0.0820318386,
-0.0116842082,
0.0629762188,
0.0323471725,
0.0335873738,
-0.0179157015,
-0.0291591734,
0.0398267247,
-0.0166573692,
-0.037405476,
-0.0159002356,
-0.042796053,
-0.0094286744,
-0.049917616,
0.0580662042,
-0.0291608982,
0.0374900177,
-0.048784703,
0.0083330758,
0.0014994846,
0.0305161346,
-0.0058565349,
0.0123080583,
-0.0091511123,
0.009966108,
-0.0453806259,
-0.0029543522,
-0.0864734426,
0.0126827853,
-0.056624569,
-0.0656491295,
0.0159913432,
0.0070446227,
0.0226712357,
-0.0042574899,
0.0000681805,
0.0723934919,
0.0048716618,
0.0091642709,
-0.0498804934,
-0.0210336912,
0.0360980779,
-0.0287128258,
-0.0179393664,
-0.0769963488,
0.0376214199,
0.039405182,
-0.0474141762,
0.0151340142,
0.0132617243,
0.0655875877,
0.0109687448,
0.0666346624,
0.0161655582,
0.0189407747,
0.0885561705,
0.0032515721,
0.0325230919,
0.0385984369,
0.0166499484,
-0.00618893,
0.0559292436,
0.0093736015,
-0.0032204511,
-0.0142738251,
0.0230935495,
-0.0162426829,
0.0237172917,
0.0658085868,
-0.0249787401,
0.0509404391,
-0.0683488399,
0.020352181,
-0.0254081916,
0.0180116724,
-0.0263341013,
0.0571874157,
0.0137544619,
0.0350799263,
-0.0181168299,
0.0143871382,
0.074857913,
0.0217196811,
0.0054991767,
0.0436199009,
0.062201485,
0.012096554,
0.0205703508,
0.0414302647,
-0.0166530441,
-0.0515586771,
-0.0066610845,
0.0123083144,
-0.0086696343,
0.0202642977,
0.0762277171,
-0.0135840951,
0.0164367147,
0.0315987058,
0.0387735404,
-0.019681178,
0.0089992005,
-0.0386124365,
0.0596871413,
0.0370428152,
0.0311183669,
-0.0714156255,
-0.0168945268,
-0.0016803871,
0.0350150466,
-0.0222567189,
-0.0011228238,
-0.0406759493,
-0.0120076444,
-0.0248150881,
-0.0119482446,
0.0189647451,
0.0057874676,
-0.0339155607,
0.0182000324,
0.0331968553,
-0.0014213487,
0.0070485054,
0.0302085113,
0.0315587409,
-0.0107245333,
0.0079778871,
-0.0407687388,
0.0137154777,
-0.0077545471,
0.0258007403,
-0.0123158554,
0.0216574129,
0.0366919339,
-0.0323370732,
-0.0333576091,
-0.0218764208,
-0.014705658,
0.0042084758,
0.0441424884,
-0.099777922,
-0.016963603,
0.0261793733,
-0.0143982032,
-0.0806424469,
0.0319541693,
-0.0275250524,
-0.0217810255,
-0.0255471077,
0.006558049,
0.0214727037,
0.0100792907,
-0.0370654576,
0.053540878,
-0.0023778551,
0.0366310179,
-0.0018886353,
-0.0274818093,
0.0579621866,
0.0413953587,
0.0333010033,
0.0110309254,
0.0150883896,
-0.03185945,
0.0419543125,
-0.0092445733,
-0.0450900272,
0.0250331163,
-0.0123313852,
-0.0084272977,
-0.021392256,
0.0586793758,
0.0072839623,
0.0091363695,
0.0017871018,
-0.0153853437,
-0.0458187386,
-0.0283712037,
0.0004281707,
0.022897752,
0.0698962435,
-0.0156726651,
0.0254371818,
-0.0134655088,
-0.0400649123,
0.0092423707,
0.0449448079,
0.0123005426,
-0.0217300802,
0.0387314931,
-0.0634723455,
-0.0396047197,
0.0163923688,
0.0047230637,
-0.0230754223,
0.0054342742,
-0.0267776605,
-0.0196534842,
0.0138661545,
0.0154166073,
-0.032123968,
-0.0180374775,
-0.0036590979,
-0.0324983224,
0.0058455449,
0.0094858725,
0.0112396274,
0.0190794654,
-0.0625907555,
-0.0410040282,
-0.0361159295,
-0.0237390324,
-0.0183762051,
-0.0241842847,
0.0446285717,
-0.0105741723,
0.0433154181,
-0.01701851,
-0.0071183597,
0.0134880682,
0.120659627,
0.0089902654,
-0.0128178019,
0.01465372,
0.0096903509,
0.0229283739,
-0.0323386118,
0.0276927389,
-0.0740099847,
0.0267908871,
-0.0282073021,
0.0254179854,
-0.0280096792,
-0.0153387412,
-0.0577917323,
-0.0445581079,
0.0256930552,
-0.0029664924,
0.036338646,
0.001706759,
0.0325133502,
-0.0656141415,
0.0337855294,
-0.0258961897,
0.0315435007,
-0.011409984,
-0.0228467006,
0.032952264,
-0.0083736312,
0.0219484828,
0.0185876042,
0.0152110392,
0.010980879,
-0.0235018749,
0.0036194013,
-0.0012692563,
0.0297669414,
0.0681930482,
0.0462633222,
0.0500145853,
0.0244539306,
0.0242545474,
0.083695285,
-0.0147209046,
-0.0369990766,
0.0303522218,
-0.0074215983,
0.0389435515,
-0.0466841981,
-0.0296213534,
-0.0502080321,
-0.0475279018,
-0.0798577964,
-0.0138870822,
0.0707473308,
0.0429008715,
-0.0085172448,
0.0054820348,
-0.0573633015,
-0.0563062765,
0.004778157,
0.0348336212,
-0.138327226,
0.0046463804,
-0.0040118909,
-0.0056581162,
-0.0265058633,
-0.0100838253,
0.0282448269,
-0.0609298311,
-0.0279934518,
-0.0377796069,
-0.0481948741,
-0.0538639165,
-0.0396642871,
-0.0012356335,
0.0269010402,
-0.0461881906,
-0.0128731262,
0.0021855207,
0.043139521,
0.0198208913,
-0.0142577942,
-0.002116136,
0.0320953429,
0.0048680482,
-0.0270794742,
0.0398241021,
0.0522509851,
-0.0206207167,
-0.0371190198,
-0.0171731971,
-0.0715515763,
-0.0586172827,
0.0014190498,
-0.0231505856,
0.0200663637,
0.0115287621,
-0.0482284091,
0.0107328715,
-0.0660244748,
0.0085123461,
0.0513365269,
0.0378777161,
-0.0445821099,
0.0330559239,
-0.0185822658,
0.0350697711,
-0.020184584,
0.0337425098,
-0.0275328252,
0.0014309828,
-0.0376586094,
-0.0058216192,
-0.0517551899,
-0.0911087766,
-0.0313194096,
-0.0009803888,
0.0308012571,
-0.0164979026,
-0.0958770886,
-0.0304405075,
0.0093784463,
0.0498161241,
0.0165431537,
0.0330794342,
0.017391935,
0.0600379854,
-0.0447611064,
-0.0377300233,
0.0282487776,
0.0002619787,
-0.011204253,
-0.0152435675,
0.0192551818,
-0.0555410236,
-0.0084576048,
0.0019684106,
-0.0416508131,
-0.0010596295,
0.0198999457,
0.012729683,
0.0141245732,
-0.0346378423,
-0.0099771237,
-0.0340234227,
-0.0010071293,
0.0069831931,
-0.0537532754,
-0.0057681156,
0.0170849171,
0.0473651811,
-0.0278973822,
0.0603715777,
-0.0009983998,
0.0047447989,
-0.0221343283,
-0.0320025645,
-0.005692367,
-0.0425887816,
0.0191097092,
-0.0103088655,
-0.0538497567,
0.016014738,
-0.0155484229,
0.001639483,
0.0482882187,
-0.0496892482,
-0.0248776749,
-0.0208068285,
0.0282767806,
-0.0252041053,
0.0056961239,
-0.0372988395,
-0.0302865393,
0.0329074338,
-0.0097595602,
-0.0361234397,
0.0319861323,
0.0511424616,
0.0421200097,
-0.0534236059,
-0.013680662,
-0.0055296454,
-0.0584211573,
-0.037507847,
0.0386341996,
-0.0248779338,
0.0267260093,
0.0106927706,
0.0086657712,
0.0095110862,
0.0194794629,
-0.0439125784,
-0.0698396489,
0.0377926715,
0.026380375,
0.0348503664,
0.0034159927,
0.0014301148,
0.0380718298,
-0.0233912356,
0.0396126918,
0.0154421395,
0.041834794,
-0.0086269761,
0.024384724,
0.0171857979,
-0.0067975814,
0.0165546685,
0.0568611845,
-0.0342555717,
0.0161205623,
0.0194817316,
-0.0180933233,
0.0113231987,
-0.037585292,
-0.0543987788,
0.0249390732,
-0.0172820482,
-0.0011526217,
-0.051879283,
-0.064382121,
-0.0139176343,
0.0204924978,
-0.0168968886,
0.0031467476,
0.046102941,
0.0530347526,
0.0906804129,
-0.0868100896,
-0.0631061047,
0.07866247,
-0.0606120378,
-0.0111039793,
-0.0063891476,
-5.985742131e-33,
-0.0187687427,
-0.0318661295,
0.025576964,
-0.0334742144,
0.0072352397,
-0.0698154122,
-0.0154395485,
-0.0242581405,
-0.0604504682,
0.0136923855,
-0.0430247262,
0.0548084639,
0.0172533803,
0.0187708866,
0.0277549382,
-0.0543680452,
-0.0096996641,
-0.0290753469,
-0.0149403969,
0.0447858833,
0.0891271308,
0.0061338837,
0.0719486773,
-0.0596931651,
0.0227006674,
-0.0503744408,
-0.0205378197,
0.0639717504,
-0.0335678272,
0.063778758,
-0.0016656027,
0.0384004638,
0.0206883978,
-0.0416091755,
0.0163430311,
0.0086215194,
-0.1084290445,
-0.0328937918,
0.0097399019,
0.0358692482,
-0.0234787352,
-0.0271933191,
-0.0198124014,
-0.0053937389,
0.0300955027,
0.0375219434,
0.0412276909,
-0.0268037915,
0.0087627284,
-0.0309540108,
-0.0498909056,
0.0256247371,
-0.0190768205,
0.017209826,
-0.0332461298,
0.0854836255,
0.0136391418,
0.0075421883,
-0.0382115804,
-0.0022355572,
-0.0178546589,
0.0055478299,
0.0073189726,
0.0048621581,
0.000582159,
-0.0015807945,
-0.0040199086,
-0.0255040806,
0.0197043568,
0.0258763824,
-0.0561862551,
-0.0108807795,
0.0250525512,
0.0677743405,
0.0176332723,
0.008889351,
-0.1168712378,
0.0346605144,
-0.0127076488,
0.0612318888,
-0.0159331299,
-0.0464874767,
-0.045401901,
-0.0097552212,
0.029104922,
0.0457808189,
-0.0134103186,
0.0007816318,
-0.0168962497,
-0.0438964851,
-0.0233654957,
0.0335235931,
-0.0242828559,
-0.0301295053,
0.0466538854,
0.018353913,
0.0007736648,
-0.0220713913,
0.0075990716,
0.0537133031,
-0.0416575707,
0.0187453516,
0.0127285607,
-0.0101208501,
0.0195495188,
0.0204521939,
0.0249270815,
0.0143301254,
-0.0736161694,
0.0038987624,
-0.0168808904,
0.0387070626,
-0.0190993398,
0.0506119505,
0.0087644225,
0.0289641693,
-0.0044215159,
0.0237055812,
0.034118887,
-0.0053730728,
-0.0383275524,
-0.0377169438,
-0.0353066698,
-0.0351109542,
0.0324648246,
0.0409496278,
-0.0623942316,
0.0046477839,
-0.0127755627,
-0.0643900186,
-0.0064262017,
0.0236322358,
2.685e-7,
0.0716223568,
-0.0367970727,
0.0210134722,
0.0626058429,
-0.0029483684,
-0.0166916288,
0.0218211208,
0.0181782935,
-0.0159160011,
0.0290613454,
0.0116769727,
0.0096381456,
0.020558672,
0.0351087674,
-0.0656334758,
-0.0553463921,
-0.0169700067,
-0.0050289147,
-0.0445064828,
0.0089735901,
0.0707873926,
0.0754618719,
-0.0319631733,
-0.0066450289,
-0.0280260518,
0.0145768961,
0.0005152748,
0.0301742367,
0.0093873255,
0.0507764891,
0.018838359,
-0.0279798079,
0.0302315634,
0.0403841734,
-0.0276016369,
0.0202421919,
0.0317628421,
0.0436188057,
0.0303834695,
-0.0262726601,
-0.0284298826,
-0.0402132571,
0.0613348782,
-0.0443198979,
0.1235397607,
0.0142891789,
-0.0160124227,
0.0115490481,
-0.0263929572,
0.0024618984,
0.0008507751,
0.0221258011,
0.0205310863,
0.0299069285,
0.0318972729,
-0.0212147888,
0.0298882555,
-0.0571549498,
0.0244224053,
-0.0047178385,
-0.0060211024,
-0.0114166681,
0.0281612072,
-0.0447789878,
0.0047188113,
0.0074418494,
-0.0393086709,
2.23735054e-34,
0.021262547,
-0.0087528741,
-0.0132288998,
0.0055370266,
0.0632472411,
-0.038330432,
-0.0077617471,
-0.0007673773,
0.0605197735,
-0.037675079,
-0.0263799299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11657v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11657v3 | Enhancing Chain-of-Thoughts Prompting with Iterative Bootstrapping in Large Language Models | 2023-04-23T13:54:39 | 2024-03-15T10:28:13 | Jiashuo Sun, Yi Luo, Yeyun Gong, Chen Lin, Yelong Shen, Jian Guo, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) can achieve highly effective performance on
various reasoning tasks by incorporating step-by-step chain-of-thought (CoT)
prompting as demonstrations. However, the reasoning chains of demonstrations
generated by LLMs are prone to errors, which can subsequently lead to incorrect
reasoning during inference. Furthermore, inappropriate exemplars (overly
simplistic or complex), can affect overall performance among varying levels of
difficulty. We introduce Iter-CoT (Iterative bootstrapping in Chain-of-Thoughts
Prompting), an iterative bootstrapping approach for selecting exemplars and
generating reasoning chains. By utilizing iterative bootstrapping, our approach
enables LLMs to autonomously rectify errors, resulting in more precise and
comprehensive reasoning chains. Simultaneously, our approach selects
challenging yet answerable questions accompanied by reasoning chains as
exemplars with a moderate level of difficulty, which enhances the LLMs'
generalizability across varying levels of difficulty. Experimental results
indicate that Iter-CoT exhibits superiority, achieving competitive performance
across three distinct reasoning tasks on ten datasets. | [
0.0292128753,
0.0394067429,
-0.0071986713,
0.0305493567,
-0.0721825585,
0.0519672669,
0.0270044599,
-0.0007195977,
0.0140131237,
-0.0320973098,
0.0116365505,
-0.0177422948,
-0.0173987318,
-0.004267992,
0.0350608267,
-0.0470550284,
0.0167833753,
-0.07161735,
-0.0123556228,
-0.035357099,
-0.0111816041,
0.0133979078,
-0.0378575511,
0.0242264196,
0.0026427568,
-0.0429592803,
-0.0351525396,
-0.0012409638,
0.0129024452,
-0.0740022957,
-0.0271742027,
0.0654926747,
0.0353307687,
0.0190098044,
0.0000023353,
-0.0568884611,
0.0002173761,
-0.0081905769,
-0.0871428624,
-0.0050175148,
-0.0144234682,
0.0287924595,
0.025537882,
0.0348291434,
-0.0386599191,
-0.0160993654,
0.0008793529,
0.0545120127,
0.0531785861,
0.023534622,
0.008678332,
-0.0099398512,
-0.0145407552,
0.002799958,
0.0221298635,
-0.0385951437,
0.0195036437,
0.0492770411,
0.0444662943,
0.029785974,
-0.0270073842,
0.0296773948,
0.0537645742,
-0.0044190749,
-0.0262306426,
0.0229278691,
-0.002662048,
-0.0226139706,
-0.0192977451,
0.0832621604,
0.023310136,
-0.031985905,
-0.0402868427,
-0.0053506508,
0.0210074745,
0.0475043356,
-0.0610976852,
0.048822172,
-0.0198131837,
0.0080832196,
0.0254002344,
0.0315740854,
0.0149158295,
0.0219221935,
-0.047124587,
0.0841145143,
-0.0145815732,
-0.0574251413,
0.0646868199,
0.0205757245,
-0.0054746391,
-0.0585970581,
0.0148959439,
0.0476283543,
-0.0574766621,
0.0271218438,
-0.0000232782,
0.0044865082,
0.0180108231,
0.0242987033,
0.0436330438,
0.0233700499,
-0.0039832438,
0.0705946535,
-0.0318504162,
0.0301741343,
-0.0214311574,
0.0121741602,
-0.0265676267,
0.0052789287,
-0.0534650572,
0.0011926964,
-0.0397968553,
0.0425716229,
-0.0297213122,
-0.0099255834,
-0.0028276348,
0.0281031691,
-0.0055348286,
0.0056848968,
-0.0195453484,
-0.0042832489,
0.0373133235,
-0.0369446538,
-0.053150434,
0.0074288971,
-0.0546987355,
0.0264696442,
0.0585962646,
-0.0474600866,
-0.0236243866,
-0.0031532296,
-0.0059180777,
-0.0174709503,
0.0366439894,
0.050062485,
-0.015936166,
-0.0240975134,
-0.0244708788,
-0.0141912457,
0.0245400369,
-0.0867396817,
0.0044078524,
-0.0973962173,
0.0234650765,
0.030375069,
-0.0037591062,
0.006267224,
0.0102771549,
0.0320455655,
-0.0126361763,
0.0808882862,
-0.011360636,
0.0241592228,
0.0086123701,
0.0025558115,
-0.0367439799,
0.0566905066,
0.0162451379,
0.0094946977,
0.011770213,
0.0109071732,
0.0315978043,
0.018267462,
0.0058897668,
0.0059827087,
-0.0160703454,
0.0362052359,
-0.0149532249,
0.0518229939,
-0.0247860271,
0.0410934761,
-0.0288628358,
0.0566624515,
0.0339281224,
0.0600840412,
-0.0099935252,
0.0088350959,
0.0595997795,
-0.0168526508,
0.0288234819,
0.0102901291,
-0.06069443,
0.0288738087,
-0.0335057974,
-0.0009094269,
-0.0000318596,
0.0317482948,
-0.0388984978,
-0.0453903228,
-0.010415934,
0.0459011309,
0.0160043072,
0.0630107075,
0.0374593101,
0.0306050237,
-0.0389361456,
0.0165884625,
0.0160852745,
-0.0251060985,
-0.0256192461,
-0.0569153428,
0.0524938032,
0.0334915705,
0.0464685149,
-0.0091676321,
-0.0279455353,
-0.0121991392,
0.0779567063,
0.0318872668,
0.0106264902,
-0.0217783786,
-0.0364591442,
-0.0442083851,
-0.0188245885,
0.000606827,
0.0020485949,
-0.0155448588,
0.0304540992,
-0.0112223858,
-0.0009316132,
-0.0447216518,
0.0107436059,
0.0286189262,
-0.0386672467,
-0.0166416448,
-0.0133112958,
0.0202110037,
0.0060253413,
-0.0051254211,
0.0187445283,
0.0133016519,
0.0071884841,
-0.0444543436,
-0.0231693052,
-0.0090875309,
-0.0634947345,
-0.0743387192,
0.021371508,
-0.0247844942,
-0.059894789,
-0.0117133483,
-0.047924269,
-0.0403965637,
0.0108741,
-0.0286465101,
-0.0006806352,
-0.0185848083,
0.0299279243,
-0.007483962,
-0.0223403294,
-0.0391789563,
0.0816435292,
-0.0115723209,
0.043664407,
0.0251124036,
0.0483504906,
-0.0144431787,
-0.0342988558,
-0.0021811484,
-0.0093147755,
-0.0137114795,
-0.0100854905,
0.0008601393,
0.0373404808,
-0.0727087781,
-0.0118187834,
-0.0667365044,
-0.0006047884,
-0.0167069156,
0.0226354245,
-0.0049102819,
-0.0125583,
-0.0204590391,
-0.0203342214,
-0.0465190746,
0.0119172158,
0.0116259633,
0.0269871764,
0.0198222417,
-0.0042763739,
-0.012701733,
-0.0007573913,
-0.0033226125,
-0.0221586265,
0.0591592006,
0.0125607541,
0.0116489055,
-0.0557518452,
0.0274834931,
-0.039535366,
0.009133528,
-0.0043561091,
0.0099015916,
0.0423616171,
-0.0227274541,
0.0831108615,
0.0688533708,
-0.0076889447,
0.0112631796,
0.0524255559,
-0.0243842844,
-0.0670409128,
0.0279531442,
-0.0151359299,
-0.0045472374,
0.0006661981,
-0.0352272913,
-0.0318329148,
0.0620350167,
0.0051213806,
0.0109914327,
-0.0385876708,
0.0335572436,
-0.0170810055,
0.0026007241,
-0.0484277979,
-0.0198122282,
-0.0041991584,
0.0722078755,
-0.021711126,
-0.0276090894,
0.1010077521,
-0.0159765184,
-0.0028285568,
-0.0457860827,
0.0171634369,
-0.022234356,
0.0869113505,
-0.0074129789,
-0.0129397232,
0.0200214926,
-0.0110441605,
-0.0483702868,
-0.002399314,
0.007441496,
-0.0512772165,
0.056994006,
-0.0600174144,
-0.0018219051,
0.0198978223,
-0.0431864858,
-0.0643009022,
-0.0102310311,
-0.0417424962,
-0.010438527,
-0.0211934447,
0.01437297,
0.0108135445,
-0.0102240173,
0.0558502823,
0.0307897609,
-0.0171168838,
-0.022819167,
-0.024600774,
0.0084266532,
0.0434670746,
0.0126358224,
0.0612272173,
-0.0420880727,
0.0794435591,
0.0343966931,
0.0805165172,
0.0172633566,
-0.0193014406,
0.0179550406,
0.0042474512,
-0.0080846054,
0.0008514992,
0.0298963413,
0.0657363907,
-0.0679078624,
-0.0355972536,
0.1196662337,
0.043168176,
-0.0441745967,
0.0082685491,
-0.0317440778,
0.0494933352,
0.0429595858,
0.031248033,
-0.0930629969,
-0.0404048227,
0.0380537398,
-0.0099247489,
-0.0219138376,
-0.0529888049,
0.0096818972,
-0.1486002505,
0.0473926403,
-0.0157476682,
-0.0368300416,
-0.009783078,
-0.0492099859,
0.0184777081,
0.039267987,
-0.0005663103,
0.039697241,
-0.0139392391,
0.0117592458,
0.0397005044,
0.0107499277,
-0.0430924483,
0.0563080683,
-0.0171418525,
0.0253485385,
0.0058791474,
-0.0076071774,
0.0235860422,
-0.0578611344,
0.0488609485,
-0.0282582957,
-0.0070494716,
-0.0301556438,
0.0095777493,
0.0384143516,
-0.0027165157,
-0.0629681796,
0.0440503545,
-0.0205002967,
-0.0229353607,
0.0387585722,
0.1210462973,
-0.0348380767,
-0.009432354,
-0.0059348447,
0.0204645898,
-0.0189370718,
0.0493013375,
0.0577163808,
-0.0516428538,
-0.0146300057,
-0.0332702063,
-0.0278011952,
-0.0321200863,
-0.0312596895,
0.0431272686,
0.0280351695,
0.0567900278,
-0.0328069478,
-0.0361590795,
0.0573256984,
0.0843313709,
0.0013843739,
0.006052502,
-0.0102682272,
0.0096079623,
-0.0105970381,
0.0323499367,
-0.0415580049,
0.0140167018,
-0.0416646637,
0.0265155584,
0.0016869433,
-0.0326680839,
-0.0167384706,
0.0117225675,
-0.0643018559,
-0.0481415838,
-0.0350664966,
0.0494970903,
0.0271688383,
0.0252472144,
-0.004050442,
-0.0441066027,
0.0413220264,
0.015299377,
-0.0008091542,
-0.0162553117,
-0.0040098787,
0.0022199592,
0.0039736475,
0.0475592799,
-0.0205553975,
0.0298623759,
0.008991871,
0.0724292621,
-0.0339201652,
-0.0124528883,
0.0459391698,
0.013635898,
0.0333006382,
-0.0089551099,
-0.0203755572,
-0.029571373,
0.0359319709,
-0.0100774178,
-0.0478729233,
-0.0423733033,
0.0387048572,
0.0054659643,
-0.0111604044,
0.0193956029,
-0.0727820694,
0.0036802902,
0.0355670191,
-0.0219166912,
0.0267927181,
0.0004648977,
0.0448997803,
0.0401858091,
-0.0162977017,
-0.0241306443,
-0.017147718,
0.0136829885,
0.0196896475,
0.0060437284,
0.1102193594,
0.0544847399,
-0.0116565442,
-0.0288993437,
-0.0122679397,
-0.0474582762,
-0.0620955601,
0.0140078235,
0.0135816289,
0.0245707799,
0.0108011728,
-0.0022152665,
-0.0317242965,
-0.0095081404,
0.0226692427,
0.023149319,
0.0135137681,
-0.0587902591,
0.0531250946,
0.0470500775,
0.0097795529,
-0.0025058792,
0.0276622977,
-0.0269114692,
0.0224753544,
0.0228750408,
-0.0069261212,
-0.0287003703,
-0.0254639667,
-0.0377676822,
-0.0095471824,
-0.0075225653,
0.0532763675,
-0.0751621798,
-0.0936840624,
-0.0585769154,
0.0267785769,
-0.0079476982,
-0.0042650341,
0.0445678122,
0.0700934827,
0.0044675483,
-0.0253361147,
-0.0191367399,
0.0256115086,
-0.0181320701,
-0.0495320968,
-0.0286276378,
-6.834100077e-33,
-0.01070836,
-0.0490150563,
0.0535674542,
0.0111419866,
-0.0093031665,
-0.0063322592,
-0.0590796657,
0.0282215793,
-0.0266161729,
0.0374943726,
-0.0328112654,
-0.0155989705,
0.0008349725,
0.0265866425,
0.0174032561,
-0.0012884272,
0.0061831539,
0.0070518432,
-0.033931341,
0.0098311864,
0.0011136824,
0.0147591727,
0.0317008346,
-0.0590610802,
0.0201986507,
-0.0228563007,
-0.0024132244,
0.0516483635,
-0.0519112535,
0.0351135507,
-0.0062763798,
0.0233147219,
0.0283989683,
-0.0617573299,
0.0067578559,
0.0182551369,
-0.0765421242,
-0.0316723697,
0.0374571383,
-0.0099953804,
-0.0786601529,
0.0032698887,
0.00859256,
-0.0143915191,
-0.0065017226,
-0.0215101521,
0.006039835,
-0.0344137959,
-0.0005479605,
0.0106231561,
-0.030502094,
0.0087656472,
-0.0017736282,
-0.0572863109,
0.0030189168,
0.0781914666,
-0.0330458954,
-0.0126509732,
-0.0126488199,
0.0172374323,
0.0462945811,
-0.0067099757,
0.0597309507,
0.0070669176,
0.005647752,
0.0531222932,
-0.0388326719,
-0.0179238431,
-0.0369271562,
0.0099287145,
-0.010308302,
0.0429332629,
0.0730186924,
0.0241300743,
0.0440836512,
0.0506232977,
-0.0822438002,
-0.0168357305,
0.0384115353,
0.0115119489,
0.0378140062,
-0.016687572,
-0.0377026536,
-0.0119857406,
-0.0659219548,
0.0186045803,
-0.0425197445,
-0.0424931422,
0.035599988,
-0.0009381729,
-0.0420068949,
-0.009683365,
0.0252856612,
-0.0112296948,
-0.0546720773,
0.0098473886,
-0.0060748034,
0.0234875865,
-0.0111042792,
0.0219408404,
-0.0469668135,
-0.0216314904,
-0.0081205945,
0.0030710881,
0.0184588749,
0.027642753,
0.033779569,
-0.0055962359,
-0.068139784,
-0.0184824541,
-0.0610835925,
0.0354653336,
0.0009470615,
-0.0027825485,
0.0483078174,
0.0199718326,
-0.0178397521,
0.0457838848,
-0.0035324937,
-0.0441154875,
-0.035044726,
0.0195826758,
-0.0440440588,
0.0158649199,
-0.0336618461,
-0.0104301702,
-0.0357675143,
0.0066780588,
0.0033901837,
-0.0657122284,
-0.009211381,
0.0450294055,
3.001e-7,
0.0112551674,
0.0626125261,
0.0017460306,
0.0224209111,
0.0048679737,
0.0279216226,
-0.0178493448,
-0.0387956835,
0.0311072301,
-0.0764687955,
-0.0183014944,
0.0670918375,
0.0465938821,
0.038723141,
-0.088398166,
-0.0328119956,
-0.0503124706,
-0.0039998516,
-0.0410332046,
-0.02394839,
0.0765082538,
0.0677517131,
0.0124312369,
-0.0299323648,
-0.0064399582,
-0.0257291235,
0.0430118516,
-0.0107979989,
0.0015810081,
0.0045536906,
-0.0159863681,
0.0023772779,
0.0222987887,
0.0745074004,
0.0229966287,
-0.0094313035,
-0.003954899,
0.00672701,
0.0302132387,
0.0054602162,
-0.0199507996,
-0.0203614216,
0.0153051969,
-0.0671099871,
0.0739332438,
-0.0754208639,
-0.0226025023,
0.0006163066,
0.0079291714,
-0.0377325863,
0.0163245089,
-0.0041463338,
-0.0033331299,
0.0115570035,
0.0152330166,
-0.0103523405,
0.0056586815,
-0.0706251115,
-0.0253133476,
0.0233778693,
-0.0259324536,
-0.0284612626,
-0.0481470749,
-0.0116205215,
0.00167364,
-0.0573781356,
-0.014082578,
3.010385013e-34,
0.0248006023,
-0.018801257,
0.0561904907,
0.0409459546,
0.0329580531,
-0.0019970911,
-0.0131203514,
0.018750824,
0.015058632,
-0.0924240723,
-0.0185216572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11633v1 | Evaluating ChatGPT's Information Extraction Capabilities: An Assessment of Performance, Explainability, Calibration, and Faithfulness | 2023-04-23T12:33:18 | 2023-04-23T12:33:18 | Bo Li, Gexiang Fang, Yang Yang, Quansen Wang, Wei Ye, Wen Zhao, Shikun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT to comprehend
user intent and provide reasonable responses has made them extremely popular
lately. In this paper, we focus on assessing the overall ability of ChatGPT
using 7 fine-grained information extraction (IE) tasks. Specially, we present
the systematically analysis by measuring ChatGPT's performance, explainability,
calibration, and faithfulness, and resulting in 15 keys from either the ChatGPT
or domain experts. Our findings reveal that ChatGPT's performance in
Standard-IE setting is poor, but it surprisingly exhibits excellent performance
in the OpenIE setting, as evidenced by human evaluation. In addition, our
research indicates that ChatGPT provides high-quality and trustworthy
explanations for its decisions. However, there is an issue of ChatGPT being
overconfident in its predictions, which resulting in low calibration.
Furthermore, ChatGPT demonstrates a high level of faithfulness to the original
text in the majority of cases. We manually annotate and release the test sets
of 7 fine-grained IE tasks contains 14 datasets to further promote the
research. The datasets and code are available at
https://github.com/pkuserc/ChatGPT_for_IE. | [
0.0694559142,
0.0314982608,
0.0002806409,
0.0651238412,
-0.0656888261,
0.0301390979,
-0.015448438,
0.0178265367,
0.0262702703,
-0.0460879877,
-0.0316669196,
-0.0170662459,
-0.0091095241,
0.0173595194,
-0.001410661,
-0.0433699414,
0.0320425965,
-0.0072012856,
0.0396795981,
0.0426567718,
0.0358750671,
0.0222362485,
0.0055017252,
0.0452852659,
0.019980358,
-0.0118323164,
0.0065154037,
-0.0127295768,
0.0043274052,
-0.0131450901,
0.0320546702,
0.0147454897,
-0.0088697597,
0.0406149551,
0.0000020531,
-0.0347949415,
-0.0365120582,
0.0161858853,
-0.0610075109,
0.0321742743,
0.0330554582,
0.0272865109,
0.0021705297,
0.0007572845,
-0.0434567258,
0.0039999611,
0.0408882536,
0.0754911453,
0.0471584611,
0.0820790678,
-0.0156657174,
-0.0078574009,
0.0018104691,
-0.0169263426,
0.036155317,
-0.0662167743,
0.0187396612,
0.0448673815,
-0.0007938253,
0.0362977311,
0.0457431562,
0.0276200715,
0.0013164823,
-0.011858047,
-0.0290398635,
0.0338011459,
-0.0507979617,
-0.0440568179,
-0.0147311436,
0.0833771378,
0.0195329823,
0.0058910795,
0.0188003443,
-0.0094126659,
-0.0084225414,
0.00777358,
-0.0489105806,
-0.0021988407,
-0.0308725368,
0.0079228282,
0.0033889394,
0.0281354487,
0.0310266633,
0.01497842,
-0.0243490115,
0.0467244722,
-0.0047558644,
-0.026683351,
0.01862951,
-0.0006596401,
-0.0259410199,
-0.0467227846,
-0.0080191074,
0.0219220482,
0.0077404208,
0.0342683606,
-0.0124016749,
0.010879348,
0.0162628945,
-0.0469215102,
-0.0371854752,
0.0399581827,
-0.0399513394,
0.0691449717,
-0.0045356438,
0.0606873594,
0.0060999542,
0.0301933941,
-0.01375781,
-0.0358017869,
-0.0895661935,
-0.0217579398,
-0.0169262644,
0.0201635361,
-0.0232436825,
-0.0308082458,
-0.0223851465,
0.0129830334,
0.0143941175,
0.0088408152,
0.0425752364,
-0.0183895025,
-0.0135736307,
-0.0192970987,
-0.026779782,
0.0299484022,
-0.0354139619,
-0.0053551067,
0.0378445424,
-0.0516977943,
-0.0102215139,
0.0329000689,
0.0004802365,
-0.021489704,
-0.0036956901,
0.0782145411,
0.0198068246,
-0.0380589068,
-0.0366027802,
-0.0418835357,
-0.0189012196,
-0.0700319782,
-0.0209422726,
-0.0252832454,
0.0522305742,
0.0265998933,
-0.0230747461,
-0.047366567,
0.0154145341,
0.0007159229,
-0.0653486699,
0.070105046,
-0.038519688,
0.0062200814,
0.013545109,
0.0247958619,
-0.0437817499,
0.070742771,
0.0244884249,
0.0552710444,
0.0816340744,
-0.0118290372,
0.0146148279,
0.0463888794,
-0.0136881042,
-0.0222463496,
0.0515598133,
0.0181883257,
-0.0176731981,
-0.0155181531,
0.0199857131,
0.0484816916,
-0.0296073109,
0.0022527229,
0.0698747933,
0.0453937277,
0.0414011031,
0.021605242,
0.0365053527,
0.050671909,
0.0311052203,
0.0224357117,
-0.0615578145,
-0.0070553506,
-0.0162081923,
0.0317279994,
0.0135243814,
0.0190597493,
-0.0040197936,
-0.0393073857,
-0.008305613,
-0.0029237897,
0.0211839657,
0.0097311577,
0.0626309663,
-0.0214228202,
-0.0461975485,
0.0397824943,
0.0722685978,
-0.0326821692,
-0.005312257,
-0.0717214271,
0.0312470291,
0.0584854782,
0.0459177606,
-0.0251615942,
-0.0233645383,
-0.0040025217,
0.0062453565,
0.0086556161,
0.0589642711,
-0.0117773153,
0.0135949515,
-0.0513732694,
-0.0463393144,
0.0092479549,
0.0058664284,
0.0151145635,
0.0565443486,
-0.0279406831,
0.0309141707,
-0.0449166223,
-0.0328519754,
0.0346626826,
-0.0191017371,
-0.0387592129,
-0.0156672429,
-0.0162099637,
0.0265317149,
0.0131681748,
-0.0193298068,
-0.0120995771,
0.0004171766,
0.0101081934,
-0.0013275201,
0.011714898,
-0.0319887921,
-0.0282261316,
0.0191124585,
-0.0207378045,
-0.0029124052,
-0.0011676013,
-0.0461555384,
-0.0173344836,
-0.0457950719,
0.0122530991,
0.0253811218,
-0.0579915754,
0.0004377646,
0.0158177614,
0.0152853243,
-0.0468184985,
0.0630612969,
0.0350814015,
-0.0223210007,
0.0054240846,
-0.0112524172,
0.0016720038,
-0.0024246445,
-0.0223674513,
0.0203115288,
-0.0115097836,
0.0106950533,
0.0382958651,
0.0198188778,
-0.0474997237,
-0.0278888345,
-0.108692117,
0.018161729,
-0.0309924427,
0.0514224321,
0.0429230593,
0.0294636451,
-0.0355367139,
0.0063203662,
-0.0331460983,
0.0097882319,
-0.0183872227,
-0.0090063605,
0.0421502702,
0.0377233587,
0.0201747231,
-0.0589678176,
0.0264255293,
-0.0117780687,
0.0306689795,
0.0302833617,
-0.0575611889,
-0.0501358882,
0.0322776884,
-0.0310495663,
-0.0014619081,
-0.0318815075,
-0.0504423268,
-0.0191280395,
-0.0104461573,
-0.0117406864,
0.0042039617,
0.0209306665,
0.0337112844,
-0.0103524514,
0.002949741,
-0.0689957663,
0.0048775719,
-0.0515266694,
-0.0154529568,
-0.0214920416,
-0.0141641516,
0.0485883765,
0.0711977854,
0.0056097852,
0.0483238995,
-0.0615067817,
0.0090920385,
-0.0241517983,
0.0017240255,
-0.0297899935,
0.0196926221,
-0.0225404371,
0.03749552,
-0.0240480676,
-0.0308526587,
0.0731865689,
-0.0476537496,
-0.014639304,
-0.0449673943,
-0.0220048781,
-0.0422877967,
0.0678067952,
-0.0379837379,
0.0073839454,
0.0637967363,
-0.035041593,
-0.016331261,
-0.0149191935,
0.0273200106,
-0.0338175483,
0.0343529955,
-0.0408585407,
0.0147308381,
0.0050929906,
-0.0163164604,
-0.0425394475,
-0.0906313732,
-0.0251998752,
-0.0082050366,
0.0399978422,
-0.0245522261,
-0.0077768713,
0.0277344361,
0.0190043878,
0.0140231969,
-0.0453665033,
-0.0095242448,
-0.0040589795,
0.0242182519,
0.0761107802,
0.0160655957,
0.0051770275,
-0.0142692812,
0.0282224379,
0.0722059682,
-0.0050176564,
-0.0055936924,
-0.0045073763,
-0.0314262919,
-0.0111729139,
-0.0475985222,
-0.0128021408,
-0.0046018977,
0.0703933463,
-0.0650389344,
-0.0059437552,
0.1452045441,
0.0183005538,
-0.0285385791,
-0.0193297435,
-0.0173275564,
0.0416409634,
-0.0078172507,
0.0110557163,
-0.0732125938,
-0.0592266805,
0.0001017293,
0.0329450183,
0.0034281516,
-0.0104867751,
-0.0245745257,
-0.1012157723,
0.040519312,
-0.0079601221,
-0.0215968471,
-0.0290254038,
-0.0250091739,
0.0183069762,
-0.0243479498,
0.0374127924,
0.0094045065,
-0.0210105199,
0.010396474,
0.0321282521,
-0.0854976848,
-0.0409790576,
0.0586766154,
-0.015896976,
0.0495842099,
0.0699881241,
0.0315182954,
0.0085014533,
0.0165062919,
0.0441137142,
-0.0140918344,
-0.0101403203,
-0.0085873092,
0.1071463525,
-0.0193587001,
-0.0100702457,
-0.0124002919,
0.0260822885,
-0.0090221073,
0.0020247546,
0.0384968333,
0.0440797657,
-0.0103172502,
-0.0176229347,
0.0249922127,
0.0111905178,
0.0157805979,
0.1199053973,
0.0425253399,
-0.0273518916,
-0.0503995307,
-0.0136613511,
-0.0292018577,
-0.01813058,
-0.0370888002,
0.00803262,
-0.001787614,
-0.0174514074,
-0.0708839968,
-0.0770978481,
0.0448017679,
0.0164726805,
0.0037971663,
0.0060653896,
0.0113353189,
0.0282594692,
-0.0108269323,
0.0290469714,
-0.0481498912,
-0.0126039553,
-0.0468755886,
0.0079318983,
0.0179326721,
-0.0335250758,
-0.0343333669,
0.0182293821,
-0.0629604757,
-0.0533199757,
0.0049791443,
0.0165444147,
0.0299839396,
0.049090378,
-0.043215543,
-0.0321144834,
0.0189700779,
0.0229340382,
-0.0697217509,
-0.0523022488,
0.0349557698,
0.0270296279,
0.0091012772,
0.0364278667,
-0.046165131,
0.0121207954,
-0.0137304962,
0.0133739356,
-0.0285490546,
-0.039123375,
0.0250317398,
0.0430874303,
0.0573472865,
0.0151421241,
-0.00888272,
-0.0476100557,
-0.0161948167,
-0.0155751659,
-0.0100747999,
-0.0465641916,
0.0007715938,
0.0168555826,
-0.0299600232,
-0.0076012141,
-0.0158780776,
-0.0366363674,
0.0207727756,
-0.053824544,
0.0021521,
-0.0204136595,
0.032834515,
0.0254694466,
-0.0259458832,
-0.0258276053,
0.0052533429,
0.0167091899,
0.0379207358,
-0.0344148651,
0.0912098885,
0.0114437276,
-0.0320743732,
0.0223885346,
0.0370419733,
-0.0612562262,
-0.0144994445,
-0.0178285334,
0.0498993658,
0.024288917,
-0.0153588839,
0.0765611008,
-0.0312720723,
-0.0085233683,
-0.0228018202,
0.0567267239,
0.0042593563,
0.0145647712,
0.0137461042,
0.0135018239,
-0.0710121095,
0.00068153,
0.0785917044,
-0.0229445472,
0.0220503751,
0.0080472967,
-0.0279073361,
-0.0554905832,
-0.0164253619,
0.0020999662,
0.0239806995,
-0.0173799302,
-0.0212431848,
-0.0452569947,
-0.0278165154,
-0.0331913158,
-0.005428277,
-0.0267336015,
-0.0064519239,
0.0155687388,
0.087800324,
-0.0161306299,
-0.0072235712,
-0.0604408011,
-0.0232753251,
-0.0203373078,
0.0073291124,
-0.0186983068,
-6.756628387e-33,
-0.0192535482,
-0.0010070737,
0.0157057419,
0.0346756317,
-0.030832503,
0.0119631207,
-0.0346060023,
-0.0063738665,
-0.0296082702,
0.013678872,
-0.0113542555,
-0.0174407922,
0.0279401913,
0.012126537,
-0.0249127839,
-0.0436334722,
0.0143232038,
0.0121123223,
-0.0248080771,
0.0423254482,
0.0457234345,
0.0417039581,
0.0693300441,
-0.1049776971,
0.0630714148,
-0.012204635,
-0.0029286295,
-0.0060149608,
0.0472623333,
0.0691792816,
-0.0188668277,
0.0213371329,
0.0325019993,
-0.0498425961,
-0.0027261511,
0.0289479103,
-0.0962458849,
-0.0215815473,
0.0321857259,
-0.0038008315,
-0.0051605245,
-0.0096654501,
0.0313503146,
-0.0317315571,
0.0338861533,
-0.0219351687,
0.039950978,
-0.0104124006,
0.0030276095,
0.0019506875,
-0.068590194,
0.0639987737,
-0.0001814572,
-0.0210305229,
0.024784388,
0.0517500304,
0.0073277378,
0.0133608701,
-0.0257317889,
-0.0193821825,
-0.0052395957,
0.0233087167,
0.0561488606,
0.0031639531,
-0.0053748288,
0.0805530623,
-0.00210724,
-0.0093466155,
-0.0336843766,
-0.0281908587,
-0.0013227866,
0.0545514561,
0.0019812922,
0.0246074479,
0.0047303443,
-0.0177433155,
-0.063390471,
0.0387483202,
0.0347489119,
0.0175161939,
0.0196827073,
0.0002758308,
-0.0943011642,
-0.0004931124,
0.0188700389,
0.0084905243,
-0.0242004599,
-0.0528501272,
0.0445540361,
-0.0270005371,
-0.044251252,
0.0047748792,
0.0238324422,
-0.0592408963,
0.0270143617,
0.009146316,
-0.0495571829,
0.0052266438,
-0.0167883337,
0.0216274299,
-0.0500084311,
-0.0267976541,
-0.0157302804,
0.0236408059,
0.0109995389,
0.0023576343,
0.0327523611,
-0.0093267048,
-0.0482263975,
-0.0131486943,
-0.0513363704,
0.0230935086,
-0.0361306183,
0.0114106843,
0.0240102019,
0.0151131796,
-0.0394826382,
0.008232154,
0.0432887189,
0.0138516398,
-0.0195958614,
-0.0218591094,
0.0104942722,
-0.0123555856,
-0.0197044332,
-0.0038669135,
-0.0000410151,
-0.0292865504,
-0.0030776865,
-0.007663148,
0.004838035,
0.0235235579,
2.715e-7,
0.056130331,
0.0572221801,
0.0223364681,
0.0041342168,
-0.0232199375,
0.0459581465,
0.0051861568,
-0.014541368,
0.0194898751,
-0.021654252,
0.0328048542,
0.0112208975,
0.0651226565,
0.0209877193,
-0.0795624629,
-0.0448753946,
-0.0523498654,
-0.0743830577,
-0.0454222746,
0.0219307262,
0.1045354456,
0.0954256728,
0.0173134692,
0.0158049855,
-0.0324623175,
-0.0784401521,
0.0305699706,
-0.0476870574,
-0.0288350396,
0.0620454289,
0.0597173013,
0.0231905654,
-0.0016249788,
0.0064738467,
-0.0011116503,
0.0085585071,
0.0227009133,
0.0887369886,
0.00378205,
-0.0128600458,
-0.0351840295,
-0.0360705294,
0.0335597359,
-0.0752827525,
0.0866588578,
-0.0699194521,
-0.032981731,
-0.0514051877,
-0.0231127124,
-0.0253424235,
-0.0296532046,
-0.0041833306,
-0.0125740282,
0.0443541482,
0.0004367597,
-0.0185002759,
-0.0640991777,
-0.09499567,
-0.015975222,
-0.0178673677,
-0.024718402,
-0.0413012728,
-0.0207032058,
0.0014522958,
0.027226422,
-0.0539931171,
0.0244702715,
2.444880165e-34,
0.0100074438,
0.0013041575,
-0.0209197402,
0.0181765277,
0.0626407713,
0.0291103646,
0.0254801176,
0.003069242,
-0.0153164463,
-0.0422535874,
0.0202378035
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.