id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14481v2 | FOCUS: Effective Embedding Initialization for Monolingual Specialization of Multilingual Models | 2023-05-23T19:21:53 | 2023-11-06T17:47:47 | Konstantin Dobler, Gerard de Melo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Using model weights pretrained on a high-resource language as a warm start
can reduce the need for data and compute to obtain high-quality language models
for other, especially low-resource, languages. However, if we want to use a new
tokenizer specialized for the target language, we cannot transfer the source
model's embedding matrix. In this paper, we propose FOCUS - Fast Overlapping
Token Combinations Using Sparsemax, a novel embedding initialization method
that initializes the embedding matrix effectively for a new tokenizer based on
information in the source model's embedding matrix. FOCUS represents newly
added tokens as combinations of tokens in the overlap of the source and target
vocabularies. The overlapping tokens are selected based on semantic similarity
in an auxiliary static token embedding space. We focus our study on using the
multilingual XLM-R as a source model and empirically show that FOCUS
outperforms random initialization and previous work in language modeling and on
a range of downstream tasks (NLI, QA, and NER). | [
0.0002086799,
0.0301327556,
0.017321635,
0.0489090905,
-0.0259425417,
0.0102369618,
-0.0024832336,
-0.002839847,
-0.0435325578,
-0.0255700406,
-0.0525325462,
-0.0333197974,
-0.0170326997,
0.0082168486,
0.0635855943,
-0.0046371045,
0.0573705025,
-0.0126381712,
-0.0377080999,
-0.0089572603,
0.0161355678,
0.0128686717,
0.0344056375,
0.055639457,
-0.0691791773,
0.0004011127,
0.0020488603,
0.0285261925,
-0.004093105,
-0.0121331438,
-0.0222541895,
0.0550724976,
0.0137604903,
0.0279974006,
0.0000018302,
-0.039791245,
-0.0399557501,
0.0089628641,
0.0310267266,
-0.0076364116,
0.053516645,
-0.0367409922,
0.0111490134,
0.0231129564,
-0.0083620632,
-0.0435850322,
0.0536705814,
0.0373794213,
0.0318173505,
0.0375584103,
-0.0365567729,
-0.0046706414,
-0.0070508062,
-0.0263568088,
-0.054089617,
-0.0543267652,
0.0266571548,
-0.0211868435,
-0.0407266095,
-0.0111679854,
-0.0437761322,
0.0092532104,
0.0033595946,
0.0222885329,
0.0138673484,
0.0316650197,
-0.0553942919,
-0.0142821129,
-0.0047873314,
0.0523638092,
-0.0694821626,
-0.0261892807,
-0.0062465444,
0.0195165295,
0.02036421,
-0.0420676172,
-0.0283381045,
-0.006264321,
0.0140009327,
0.0463859066,
0.0577903874,
-0.0631928593,
0.0381306149,
0.0158620514,
-0.0470870733,
0.0618059784,
0.0732546523,
-0.0291530751,
-0.0017872261,
-0.001301633,
-0.0135021778,
-0.0343507826,
0.0078480328,
-0.0018416619,
-0.0321810171,
0.0147580924,
-0.0714179948,
-0.0546824262,
0.0290949345,
-0.0123971337,
0.0263560861,
0.0468902364,
-0.0278660692,
0.0480985232,
-0.062637195,
0.0110599576,
-0.0134989861,
0.0213722903,
-0.0525109321,
-0.0531038083,
-0.0132743716,
-0.0191334821,
-0.0724687055,
0.0452764183,
-0.0328493752,
-0.0171802957,
-0.0273899026,
0.0356994905,
-0.0048532202,
-0.0186590794,
-0.0004992048,
-0.0250403751,
-0.01901903,
0.0014684963,
0.0286499225,
0.0251506958,
-0.0593271442,
0.0026040927,
-0.0288739968,
-0.04268739,
-0.0222529769,
0.0359452516,
0.0174685679,
-0.0203589611,
0.0021703958,
0.0539410859,
-0.039196603,
-0.0346692353,
-0.0138544543,
-0.0032568946,
0.0303763244,
-0.0372708179,
-0.0283456817,
-0.080492653,
0.0333915502,
0.0178182777,
0.0255155563,
-0.0225786958,
-0.0144142872,
-0.0102361664,
-0.043959409,
0.063244611,
-0.0414629839,
-0.0036680675,
0.0146557475,
-0.0255241562,
0.0096973293,
0.0887568891,
-0.02353842,
0.0072554601,
0.0623939447,
-0.0019397354,
-0.0202667378,
0.0587618947,
0.0194073915,
0.0169445369,
-0.0571262464,
-0.0264009852,
0.0244505927,
-0.0001245009,
0.0452710912,
0.0446994118,
-0.0512030721,
0.0149589423,
-0.0088855978,
0.0902784988,
-0.0008566377,
0.0245602913,
0.0766146928,
-0.0284788348,
-0.0427917503,
0.0141798118,
-0.0086639924,
-0.0094209854,
0.0234880131,
-0.0037782232,
0.0517000668,
0.0710908473,
-0.0408813357,
-0.002202871,
-0.0233519394,
-0.0423740633,
0.0015269589,
-0.040039964,
0.0529799461,
0.0043880991,
-0.0615319386,
0.1010254174,
0.0350526311,
-0.033746317,
0.0080456631,
-0.0428142697,
-0.0130240312,
0.0146823768,
0.0010990136,
-0.0197920315,
-0.0480730273,
0.0142476838,
0.0065944199,
0.03310721,
0.0401290655,
-0.0077795386,
0.0562695079,
-0.066421181,
-0.0090650171,
-0.001479488,
0.0152820442,
0.067469731,
-0.0064316997,
0.0379311107,
0.0150597636,
-0.0359175615,
-0.0198985804,
0.0385234617,
-0.0291706137,
0.0237076618,
0.0285146423,
0.0248410925,
0.0284525696,
0.039862778,
-0.0021180096,
0.0073342281,
0.0396758579,
-0.0564471744,
-0.0096043684,
0.0109523777,
-0.035636466,
-0.0268943962,
0.0508251637,
-0.0054259934,
-0.0131890122,
0.0140705658,
-0.0298959427,
-0.0491754636,
0.0232463926,
0.0255983453,
0.0583365634,
-0.0678170919,
0.0297436081,
-0.0061004176,
0.0166223459,
-0.0176485553,
0.0368826501,
-0.0056320904,
0.0296277367,
0.0017057125,
-0.0058402102,
0.0469206199,
-0.0381869972,
-0.0744029656,
-0.0078969132,
-0.0307930447,
0.0178923719,
0.0087414728,
0.005416024,
-0.0142112235,
-0.0484476499,
-0.1237031072,
-0.0039409199,
-0.0353757367,
-0.0163516831,
-0.0014643838,
0.0234817155,
0.0085826209,
-0.0306523647,
-0.0247242115,
-0.0371892676,
-0.0017694255,
0.0482528619,
0.0015423521,
0.0006916348,
-0.0149647472,
-0.0172269586,
-0.0211339463,
0.0151800355,
0.0570851229,
-0.0301460642,
-0.0030582794,
-0.0593256839,
-0.0384877212,
-0.0314435847,
0.0154550914,
-0.0031979412,
-0.0193089731,
0.0169566888,
-0.0101531046,
0.0561218224,
0.0222684965,
-0.0049552065,
0.009894901,
0.0433753617,
0.0236949082,
-0.0192515552,
0.0173114613,
0.009320477,
0.0196212623,
-0.0408192761,
-0.0138612883,
-0.0011934083,
0.0582107343,
-0.0307778157,
-0.0279494636,
-0.0478890687,
-0.0168545377,
-0.0316082165,
-0.0463905595,
-0.028788751,
-0.0093173217,
-0.0296146404,
0.0080782464,
-0.0183173344,
-0.0356662385,
0.0578087904,
-0.0420675054,
-0.010016595,
-0.0453045294,
-0.0181819107,
-0.0608940795,
-0.0085323006,
-0.0097536612,
0.0252781827,
-0.0472098552,
-0.0429040231,
-0.0225134492,
-0.0042876191,
-0.0143107343,
0.0023330557,
0.069774352,
0.0283220317,
-0.0066271084,
0.006398268,
-0.0354603939,
-0.0329103991,
-0.0332776159,
-0.0142571675,
0.0340222344,
0.0490697809,
0.0095912023,
-0.0253711902,
0.0166586526,
-0.0153627628,
0.0584181137,
-0.0097836414,
0.0352287143,
-0.0112676769,
0.0394259915,
0.0508739352,
-0.0026480369,
-0.0403287448,
-0.0184550267,
0.0078181801,
-0.0028104854,
0.0548943877,
-0.045377478,
-0.0229953155,
0.0050353878,
0.0589214191,
-0.012553012,
-0.0006778188,
-0.0283811577,
0.0390613563,
0.0370409526,
-0.0054087057,
0.0954766646,
0.0270531904,
-0.0612785779,
0.005744128,
-0.0516768731,
0.0665075853,
0.0544652119,
0.0145100076,
-0.0775977001,
-0.0191859715,
0.0125556001,
-0.0158039276,
0.0527163893,
-0.0028489302,
-0.0069676754,
-0.0969976336,
-0.0049631149,
-0.0020396279,
-0.0906547159,
-0.0113982325,
-0.0341260247,
-0.0190865919,
-0.0121039571,
0.0514258482,
-0.0037587602,
-0.0015187919,
-0.014647047,
0.0144036105,
0.0143291177,
-0.0302244928,
-0.021847643,
-0.0659007207,
0.0229953453,
-0.0021477891,
0.017069852,
-0.0215137918,
0.0001919337,
0.0642365962,
0.0442346074,
-0.0196234789,
-0.0230735522,
0.0075909342,
-0.0147119267,
-0.0282138605,
0.0234987717,
-0.0090142367,
0.0073265187,
-0.0230637174,
-0.0169147197,
0.0718054697,
0.0383520797,
0.015909737,
0.0041352301,
-0.0401330106,
-0.0085503198,
0.0633480549,
0.046749562,
-0.0564302877,
-0.0103977239,
-0.0003508595,
0.0134958858,
-0.0418865792,
0.0202836562,
-0.0199391413,
-0.0259272736,
-0.0269972291,
-0.0571620017,
-0.023944119,
0.0401054844,
0.0717086121,
0.0002459266,
0.0716302618,
-0.0609106943,
-0.0363963433,
-0.0211002491,
0.0385200456,
-0.0096580582,
-0.0076219379,
-0.0872827694,
-0.0038989929,
0.0186888352,
0.0040510879,
-0.0234762225,
0.0057668597,
-0.0292202737,
-0.0622838922,
-0.0218949709,
0.0408762991,
0.0086670695,
0.0521477573,
-0.0165532771,
-0.0273780972,
0.0441264436,
0.0069948738,
-0.0118868919,
0.0129193803,
0.0385796614,
-0.0536415465,
-0.0141936531,
0.0442825183,
-0.0551837683,
0.011871106,
0.0044960342,
0.0609134771,
-0.0032032193,
-0.0152428998,
-0.0071692509,
0.0219173189,
0.0400276594,
-0.0491595194,
0.0322186425,
-0.046595566,
0.0202592462,
-0.0501023084,
0.0036542204,
-0.03568675,
0.0212035365,
0.0291587003,
-0.0025421779,
0.0089649577,
-0.0205746274,
-0.0319043919,
0.067433998,
0.0110969786,
0.0064694728,
-0.0065459562,
0.0074149971,
0.0274606403,
0.0242517963,
-0.0199421458,
-0.0271234009,
-0.011919166,
-0.0188588705,
-0.0886457786,
-0.0189131815,
0.0051781749,
0.0263113882,
-0.049145814,
0.0434808396,
0.0187011212,
-0.0219890811,
-0.0176104233,
0.0237488039,
0.0812575817,
-0.0413212813,
0.0699945763,
-0.008335893,
-0.0285871271,
0.0041716965,
0.0142481131,
0.0041868878,
-0.0677542761,
0.0282008871,
0.0174103323,
-0.0416058078,
0.0166821461,
0.0902810022,
0.0478935502,
0.0161241367,
-0.0039007771,
-0.0047207922,
-0.0183611847,
0.0278404374,
0.0626795664,
0.0361025631,
-0.0354687795,
0.0381490253,
-0.0371274389,
-0.0828225538,
0.0316874944,
0.0005693773,
-0.0540726781,
0.0454057641,
0.0252143946,
0.0683440864,
0.0020056651,
0.0102440557,
-0.0185732059,
0.0007715013,
0.0685165897,
-0.0656315908,
0.0298281461,
-6.277016406e-33,
0.0021195246,
-0.0014720466,
-0.019953249,
-0.0468985736,
0.0055046841,
0.0355428867,
0.0030490339,
0.0145223271,
-0.0102990801,
0.0023880133,
-0.0359966345,
-0.019580204,
0.0222939793,
0.0397141688,
-0.0175647959,
0.0405215323,
0.0350351818,
0.0180933233,
0.0186028033,
-0.0151139274,
0.0298421551,
0.0626386404,
0.0724960864,
-0.0066227587,
-0.0207428932,
-0.0070536486,
0.0335667916,
0.0077711996,
0.0380376056,
0.0641896352,
-0.0164250098,
0.0422417857,
0.0295610428,
-0.0749699473,
-0.0124204913,
-0.0126982266,
-0.0794140026,
-0.0621175058,
0.0744765922,
-0.0051194909,
-0.0345464163,
-0.0325976647,
0.0188254323,
-0.023719009,
0.0096311597,
0.0145934504,
0.0178513285,
0.0095541282,
-0.0488461293,
0.0245752521,
-0.0888585895,
0.0123790624,
0.0233506709,
0.0413944572,
0.0669768602,
-0.0153943552,
0.0123410616,
-0.0125291422,
-0.0320626013,
-0.0034426646,
-0.030861415,
0.0453341566,
0.0555127859,
0.0514248647,
-0.0145188356,
0.0556099415,
0.0302293487,
-0.006256362,
0.0322868936,
-0.0142300949,
0.0464817099,
0.005634658,
0.0177502092,
0.0345746242,
0.0289627016,
-0.037904162,
-0.0663188323,
0.0040059839,
0.009227192,
0.0318604,
0.0530194975,
0.0322458372,
0.0064073531,
-0.0289338119,
-0.0436503738,
-0.0072594373,
-0.0608581007,
-0.0304109342,
0.0319023728,
0.0199353397,
-0.0154969497,
0.0192154665,
0.0421458706,
-0.0044572866,
-0.0334363952,
0.0605653152,
0.0070746718,
-0.0044158068,
-0.0216153208,
0.0425328687,
-0.0178964753,
-0.0648617074,
0.0105414316,
-0.0388620906,
0.0230333544,
-0.004912985,
0.0469681621,
-0.0242330823,
-0.0593094826,
0.0090197995,
-0.0132296262,
-0.0107309343,
-0.0005547383,
0.0421583615,
0.0434265733,
0.0227464717,
0.0002167939,
0.032612998,
0.0487688109,
0.0058368831,
-0.0222722664,
-0.036985077,
0.0178475175,
0.0449733362,
-0.0285643768,
0.0153705571,
-0.0320196562,
0.0297914017,
0.046008978,
-0.0367132463,
-0.019927701,
0.0113824764,
2.565e-7,
0.0271546245,
0.0189958662,
0.01389373,
-0.0443119705,
-0.0146144917,
-0.0013057602,
-0.0495962016,
0.0350292288,
0.0085577648,
0.023789838,
-0.0131775774,
0.0087041901,
0.0098557388,
0.0204107407,
-0.1251734793,
0.0292649828,
-0.0527277589,
0.0452461466,
-0.0425362401,
0.000736678,
-0.0155761279,
0.1454753876,
-0.002725193,
0.0022224707,
-0.0691438094,
-0.050717894,
0.03885331,
-0.0149863232,
-0.0193267446,
0.0268368684,
0.0215020515,
0.012451686,
0.0130131533,
-0.0032974323,
-0.0303790495,
0.0357724875,
0.0704319701,
0.0534951277,
-0.0447822399,
-0.0175198205,
0.0463974364,
0.0141201569,
-0.0364719406,
-0.0560484007,
0.0457139052,
-0.0180913527,
-0.0224364009,
-0.0283959582,
-0.0087238438,
0.0678626448,
0.0092921564,
-0.0308472626,
-0.0367187895,
0.0540326945,
0.0657667145,
0.0070235464,
-0.0247943345,
-0.0559148677,
-0.0030327926,
0.0193107985,
-0.0438789912,
-0.0166814011,
-0.0300591327,
-0.0223668292,
0.041374322,
-0.0114034116,
0.0332092345,
2.507634115e-34,
0.0535823777,
-0.0122362198,
0.0260845162,
0.0644115955,
0.0242005102,
-0.0549474023,
-0.0259105507,
0.0569991879,
-0.0190353468,
-0.0721843094,
-0.0013457203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14480v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14480v2 | BAND: Biomedical Alert News Dataset | 2023-05-23T19:21:00 | 2023-10-15T15:09:24 | Zihao Fu, Meiru Zhang, Zaiqiao Meng, Yannan Shen, David Buckeridge, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Infectious disease outbreaks continue to pose a significant threat to human
health and well-being. To improve disease surveillance and understanding of
disease spread, several surveillance systems have been developed to monitor
daily news alerts and social media. However, existing systems lack thorough
epidemiological analysis in relation to corresponding alerts or news, largely
due to the scarcity of well-annotated reports data. To address this gap, we
introduce the Biomedical Alert News Dataset (BAND), which includes 1,508
samples from existing reported news articles, open emails, and alerts, as well
as 30 epidemiology-related questions. These questions necessitate the model's
expert reasoning abilities, thereby offering valuable insights into the
outbreak of the disease. The BAND dataset brings new challenges to the NLP
world, requiring better disguise capability of the content and the ability to
infer important information. We provide several benchmark tasks, including
Named Entity Recognition (NER), Question Answering (QA), and Event Extraction
(EE), to show how existing models are capable of handling these tasks in the
epidemiology domain. To the best of our knowledge, the BAND corpus is the
largest corpus of well-annotated biomedical outbreak alert news with
elaborately designed questions, making it a valuable resource for
epidemiologists and NLP researchers alike. | [
0.0465048626,
0.0851164311,
0.006825008,
0.0063070739,
-0.0195821729,
0.0287541412,
-0.0088342736,
-0.0033335146,
0.0497375913,
-0.0146121616,
0.0136239752,
0.0095957788,
-0.055155281,
0.0798656866,
0.0106810993,
-0.04290656,
0.0401798747,
0.0279172901,
0.0447839387,
0.040543709,
0.0396109186,
0.0314742252,
-0.0070092576,
0.0478498265,
0.0209031161,
0.0032142568,
-0.000541079,
0.0007077965,
0.066014953,
-0.0972007811,
0.0273744855,
-0.0005502681,
0.0119632231,
-0.002348756,
0.0000015251,
-0.044061657,
-0.0257403553,
-0.0015980646,
-0.0448531955,
-0.0222800821,
-0.0018670445,
-0.0888826847,
0.028410567,
0.0086019542,
-0.0615932047,
-0.0345001072,
0.0377427302,
0.0418614298,
0.0474288687,
0.0873752087,
-0.0132253086,
-0.0111006694,
0.031849999,
0.0084687537,
0.0144787226,
-0.0498007759,
0.0769359842,
-0.0590973236,
0.0171133354,
-0.018004369,
0.044205647,
0.0387943499,
-0.0126791531,
0.0325755887,
-0.006422461,
0.049923975,
-0.027865177,
-0.0211045258,
-0.0316812098,
0.0685130432,
0.0122772641,
-0.0204174165,
0.0505655594,
0.0185731631,
-0.0278914291,
0.0314082131,
-0.0346934274,
-0.0326801687,
-0.0283943638,
0.0159588642,
0.0361967124,
0.0158738419,
0.0283603091,
0.0280003231,
0.0102944896,
0.0445229709,
-0.003056206,
-0.0371201001,
-0.0428227186,
-0.0020358807,
-0.0038628501,
-0.0442324094,
0.0711316988,
0.0473971926,
-0.0269509144,
0.0434340462,
0.0227926411,
-0.0292860847,
0.0481151268,
-0.1034626439,
-0.0557085015,
-0.0154784899,
0.0298836529,
0.0598353483,
0.0186915509,
-0.0580714829,
-0.0186549667,
0.0189015344,
0.0206987318,
-0.0203892644,
-0.0568694547,
-0.0120217074,
-0.0417017862,
0.0288983099,
0.0064730803,
0.0316823125,
-0.0367014967,
-0.0261640921,
0.0051851347,
-0.009723722,
-0.0158285517,
0.0301320404,
-0.031519793,
-0.0075004767,
0.0018218994,
0.009424693,
-0.04960493,
0.0085249543,
-0.0022679744,
-0.0398081616,
-0.0305284802,
-0.0539218262,
0.0520252697,
-0.0074795103,
0.0076081911,
0.0366057567,
0.0271144044,
-0.0318647325,
-0.0343030803,
-0.0326397717,
-0.0213472359,
0.0012197979,
-0.0452648737,
-0.0486751273,
0.0621902272,
0.0279463902,
-0.016520571,
-0.0282325502,
0.0025479917,
0.0014910934,
-0.0700868666,
0.0521223135,
-0.0386336707,
0.0109831495,
0.0388396531,
0.027443191,
0.0235187449,
0.0407043323,
0.0221924391,
-0.0021829817,
0.0395316519,
0.0127033815,
0.0200570747,
0.0105350837,
0.059998244,
-0.0030641833,
0.0263880529,
0.0328962132,
-0.0180890691,
0.0033463514,
-0.0200613644,
0.0289971121,
0.011782988,
-0.0470442846,
0.0038217842,
0.0317416899,
-0.0538448393,
-0.0392962731,
0.0223987717,
0.0208840184,
-0.0251606349,
-0.0046878629,
0.0055993823,
-0.00463288,
-0.0414744653,
-0.0112171434,
-0.0009867878,
0.0197591148,
-0.0303009264,
-0.0081172027,
-0.0352933556,
0.0358100832,
-0.0108015193,
0.0106135737,
0.0177337136,
-0.0029336393,
-0.0111834975,
0.0743853822,
0.0510298237,
-0.0108877756,
0.0319809541,
-0.0341692753,
0.0145823415,
0.0404194891,
0.0295834169,
-0.032198716,
-0.0677370727,
-0.0174264442,
0.0184825007,
0.0082063535,
-0.013117848,
-0.0228782557,
0.0399663448,
-0.0013274809,
0.0224291515,
0.0142491804,
0.0212951526,
-0.0193843972,
0.0336616114,
0.0391382538,
-0.0110648945,
-0.00641667,
-0.0378900655,
0.0249851607,
-0.0336715803,
-0.0504875146,
-0.0157707501,
0.02666994,
0.0457691252,
0.0034540165,
0.0404131562,
0.0308045894,
0.0345383137,
-0.0660168976,
-0.0379407629,
-0.0025471733,
-0.0010294394,
-0.0347454771,
0.0028170687,
-0.0522091016,
-0.0314038731,
0.0367001742,
-0.0555971712,
-0.0168501902,
-0.0073524225,
-0.0155449072,
0.0112877348,
0.0043077474,
-0.0166160017,
0.0555895828,
0.0048240614,
-0.0197750367,
0.0417854153,
-0.0375775956,
0.0086838417,
-0.0037219622,
-0.0444703214,
-0.0008341636,
-0.0219626427,
0.0016999783,
-0.0011781568,
0.0118898703,
-0.0245942995,
0.0027061815,
-0.045722045,
-0.0561096892,
-0.0014705962,
-0.0743846223,
0.0305510126,
0.0008803101,
0.0569023266,
0.070925653,
0.0514420122,
-0.027864743,
-0.0178728681,
-0.032302089,
-0.0530297831,
0.0131265512,
0.0322246924,
0.0519907512,
0.0404366367,
0.0049407193,
-0.0417732857,
0.0024373839,
-0.0789505616,
0.0305891633,
0.0141154714,
-0.0813389421,
-0.0119529013,
-0.0244114716,
-0.0472461581,
0.0145327747,
0.0011981031,
-0.0204877481,
-0.0153253134,
-0.0218072869,
-0.0186500791,
0.0448293798,
0.0127697177,
0.0430374183,
0.0106322002,
0.0010924904,
-0.0504084416,
0.0367746316,
-0.0902001336,
0.0209863801,
-0.004999212,
-0.0499942191,
0.0372332521,
0.0676329508,
0.0264660008,
0.000343651,
-0.0198926218,
0.0491103083,
-0.0291667357,
-0.0232672542,
-0.0519724563,
-0.000504629,
-0.0140039017,
0.0191720258,
-0.0437474176,
0.0072039748,
0.081522733,
0.0213837996,
0.0249030218,
-0.0707560927,
-0.0121826148,
-0.0694749206,
0.0112262433,
-0.0156814959,
0.019469833,
0.0284150485,
-0.055173263,
0.0502577797,
0.0000685515,
-0.022772653,
-0.0313325822,
-0.0151493847,
-0.0194732752,
0.0408181511,
0.0127567332,
-0.053709995,
-0.0336895399,
-0.0617997721,
-0.0591428541,
-0.0159730054,
-0.0092930039,
0.0270938203,
-0.0621056519,
0.052416008,
0.0030113356,
0.0113209123,
0.0156117538,
-0.016449146,
0.0082969368,
0.0530664884,
0.067609705,
-0.005033893,
0.016346762,
0.0139157455,
0.0218714122,
0.0719548836,
0.0252815653,
0.026451584,
-0.0201941859,
0.0439887829,
0.0078525757,
-0.0539667197,
0.0173429493,
-0.0158501398,
0.0714482069,
-0.0610301681,
0.0049293013,
0.0975709856,
0.0382050872,
0.0079576802,
0.0197905377,
-0.0124184517,
-0.0077014063,
-0.0292819384,
0.0352333635,
-0.0448149033,
-0.0208199993,
-0.0150632914,
-0.0111305416,
-0.0260643158,
-0.0924387202,
0.0042946334,
-0.0264249761,
0.0195519123,
-0.0206889436,
-0.0163927954,
-0.0197068639,
-0.0928066149,
0.0126602193,
-0.0343530551,
-0.0284476019,
-0.0479935557,
0.0082939081,
0.0023179611,
0.006046169,
-0.0405350663,
-0.0682114959,
0.0331371948,
-0.0174780358,
0.0233163629,
0.0346007906,
0.0498098508,
-0.0039942097,
0.01412147,
-0.0191800781,
-0.033581689,
-0.0076490426,
-0.018720882,
0.0844597146,
-0.0150646046,
-0.0325568542,
-0.0614933297,
0.0394993424,
-0.0428527594,
-0.0232295841,
0.0270898622,
0.0864994973,
0.0074342513,
-0.0399489962,
-0.0476415195,
0.0193500537,
0.0333060659,
0.0648180991,
0.015191772,
0.0172094777,
-0.0149114626,
0.0110818185,
0.0130508421,
-0.0518002398,
-0.0260820519,
0.0182898901,
-0.0001783486,
-0.0703124702,
-0.0497591719,
-0.0297874957,
0.0749761313,
0.002649195,
-0.0160096399,
-0.0213442687,
0.0567405596,
0.0018115954,
-0.0467789248,
0.0386972725,
-0.0083582588,
-0.0086739538,
-0.0187401362,
-0.0334971026,
0.0254216194,
0.0738077536,
-0.0354464427,
0.048872944,
-0.0698520318,
-0.053057421,
-0.0260906387,
-0.0125308307,
0.0192652885,
0.004355554,
-0.0077316496,
-0.0162662715,
0.0188575946,
0.0493014567,
-0.0321178623,
-0.0633442029,
-0.0195471831,
-0.006530398,
0.0102041997,
0.0318758078,
-0.0093450407,
0.0192360859,
0.0095591713,
0.0566718876,
-0.0821915269,
0.003160943,
0.022902349,
0.0063424394,
0.0378213786,
0.0115607893,
-0.0460858643,
-0.064029634,
-0.0016348162,
0.0217615552,
0.0100026568,
0.0092124911,
0.0257471707,
-0.0027119529,
-0.0191475935,
-0.0552626401,
0.0726011395,
-0.0528618172,
-0.0216315407,
-0.0884940699,
0.0178594347,
0.0477775335,
0.0218529645,
0.04995187,
-0.0219509862,
-0.0116743138,
0.0211648382,
0.0178523269,
0.0226358119,
-0.0086164419,
-0.0185839906,
0.0040394729,
0.0172568075,
0.007367589,
0.0191160049,
-0.0824842155,
-0.0146022737,
-0.0259390846,
0.0361479782,
0.024241142,
-0.0076497938,
0.0102108782,
0.0028622823,
-0.0348918103,
0.002741161,
0.0255386252,
-0.0195076112,
-0.0022845145,
0.0563356169,
0.0143554164,
-0.0339418091,
0.0019293219,
0.0600211732,
0.0095681986,
0.0955750793,
0.0641380399,
-0.0495102853,
-0.0345343947,
-0.0140581271,
0.0152451675,
0.0214908812,
-0.0101282345,
0.030670885,
-0.0444545597,
-0.0416493155,
0.0602499954,
-0.0503239892,
-0.025968615,
0.010803787,
0.015528122,
0.0329370871,
0.0554494634,
-0.0177273471,
-0.0388503373,
0.0390385538,
-0.0481901169,
-0.0416921638,
-0.0145744737,
-5.747512405e-33,
0.014437044,
-0.0062969537,
0.0243545864,
-0.0195902977,
0.0447653495,
0.0596278571,
-0.0335151404,
-0.0423793793,
-0.0281689074,
0.0086989189,
-0.0068222145,
-0.0005230404,
0.0109446216,
0.0195071436,
-0.0007351425,
-0.045716051,
0.0215006005,
0.0200386737,
-0.0096461102,
0.0161891188,
0.0438590758,
0.0913703442,
0.0402515493,
-0.0664848611,
0.0073961024,
0.0023107615,
0.0129804071,
0.0165765285,
0.0309557859,
0.0515685901,
-0.0356191285,
0.0211341456,
0.0534636304,
-0.0428509302,
0.0013065966,
0.0470318235,
-0.0898676068,
-0.0484813303,
0.0038896687,
-0.0427504294,
-0.0403842777,
-0.0419479571,
0.0631079227,
0.0273726583,
0.025103692,
0.0176546406,
0.0224947799,
-0.0150962081,
0.0278521292,
-0.0367003679,
-0.0276372191,
0.0323560238,
-0.0211607404,
0.0105266124,
-0.0245218314,
0.0141915912,
-0.0238528103,
0.0642853305,
-0.0229013152,
-0.0086998334,
0.0190739911,
0.0070734848,
0.0220411979,
-0.0327346809,
-0.0143345483,
0.0286517683,
0.0131183621,
-0.0392786674,
-0.0468425155,
0.036584232,
-0.0474073701,
0.0492066294,
0.0066946601,
0.0423930958,
0.0286737364,
0.0081675639,
-0.0952923447,
0.0607759617,
-0.0215673912,
0.0274235029,
-0.0024792897,
-0.0222152639,
-0.0326882862,
0.0142476829,
-0.0151637578,
0.0471082069,
-0.0323112495,
0.0131841255,
0.0231250226,
-0.0064795977,
-0.0241618864,
0.0575541891,
-0.0325171463,
0.0094565954,
-0.0435464308,
0.007532014,
0.0642129779,
-0.0353866555,
0.0108691314,
0.0510111563,
-0.086538136,
0.0261677429,
-0.0059440807,
0.0041489373,
0.0132311843,
0.0078336149,
0.0271097794,
-0.024725195,
-0.0389043093,
-0.0188124459,
-0.0054569645,
0.0486221947,
-0.0540428497,
0.0252992604,
0.0318905413,
0.026480671,
0.0147624575,
0.0246273614,
0.0063503464,
0.0153637109,
0.0058599748,
-0.0051679639,
-0.0138129946,
0.025067063,
-0.0153041985,
-0.0160916541,
-0.0272059236,
0.0196227301,
-0.0318087749,
-0.0632045567,
0.0106942924,
-0.0176299475,
2.39e-7,
0.1098224148,
0.0219407156,
0.0394834131,
0.0411492325,
0.0111413868,
0.0048347916,
0.01188209,
0.0334058255,
-0.0077668778,
-0.0393123068,
-0.0012409607,
0.0283387844,
-0.0224789791,
0.0480313897,
-0.0691346377,
-0.0301148761,
-0.0742512345,
0.0080170417,
-0.0597818196,
-0.0032982009,
0.0580150224,
0.0707700476,
0.0084712254,
-0.0024719506,
-0.0110453283,
-0.0083008809,
0.0250412282,
-0.0022774464,
-0.0346291475,
0.0502421595,
0.0058635511,
0.0312274471,
-0.0059789997,
0.0412502773,
-0.0397241376,
-0.0059617748,
-0.0244123247,
0.0652304664,
-0.0066057877,
-0.0158887636,
-0.01412322,
-0.0524651743,
-0.0001382747,
-0.0328155346,
0.1144996434,
-0.0513328202,
-0.0539344624,
0.0289418641,
-0.018104976,
0.0203845371,
-0.0067585022,
-0.0182765257,
-0.0393038206,
0.0281007029,
-0.0073337769,
-0.0154234944,
0.0041968166,
-0.0839158297,
0.0273026656,
0.0077000046,
-0.0238049626,
-0.0330553167,
0.0013189659,
-0.0282645468,
-0.0102319457,
-0.0748620257,
0.0367729366,
1.849783969e-34,
0.0091952672,
0.0385552794,
-0.0336329415,
0.0181154888,
0.0198258515,
-0.0166311525,
-0.0325646996,
-0.0288442392,
0.0141395526,
-0.0407527536,
0.0025750441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14471v1 | CGCE: A Chinese Generative Chat Evaluation Benchmark for General and Financial Domains | 2023-05-23T18:54:15 | 2023-05-23T18:54:15 | Xuanyu Zhang, Bingbing Li, Qing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative chat models, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, have revolutionized
natural language generation (NLG) by incorporating instructions and human
feedback to achieve significant performance improvements. However, the lack of
standardized evaluation benchmarks for chat models, particularly for Chinese
and domain-specific models, hinders their assessment and progress. To address
this gap, we introduce the Chinese Generative Chat Evaluation (CGCE) benchmark,
focusing on general and financial domains. The CGCE benchmark encompasses
diverse tasks, including 200 questions in the general domain and 150 specific
professional questions in the financial domain. Manual scoring evaluates
factors such as accuracy, coherence, expression clarity, and completeness. The
CGCE benchmark provides researchers with a standardized framework to assess and
compare Chinese generative chat models, fostering advancements in NLG research. | [
0.0315773152,
0.0528112166,
-0.0043691131,
0.0084380358,
-0.0196344685,
-0.0025023033,
0.0393950231,
0.0138514033,
0.0356818438,
-0.0094628381,
-0.0316681564,
-0.0740213022,
-0.0075785662,
0.0540170707,
0.0327132381,
-0.0708165616,
0.0095143579,
0.0395287871,
0.015135562,
-0.0084797442,
0.0275753941,
-0.0072082323,
-0.0002911143,
0.054316476,
-0.0036734149,
-0.040306136,
-0.0182616096,
0.0061280546,
0.0053853327,
-0.0133641083,
0.0181634724,
0.0564735755,
-0.0191359259,
0.0285942852,
0.0000020424,
-0.0553314127,
-0.0184796154,
0.0001144992,
-0.014735627,
0.0213746242,
0.0534021743,
-0.0052395179,
0.0001436206,
0.03128203,
-0.0619997382,
-0.027990045,
0.0346987508,
0.0560409203,
0.073888272,
0.0876701698,
-0.0179525968,
-0.0236941651,
0.0074401582,
-0.0760094896,
0.0073230108,
-0.0824024007,
-0.0176552776,
0.0823405012,
-0.0177021902,
-0.0081408722,
-0.0137128448,
0.0051394599,
0.0297258887,
-0.0274599735,
0.0111676957,
0.0273512397,
-0.0563149638,
-0.0120235607,
-0.0209908169,
0.0664663315,
0.0222527049,
0.0288641304,
0.0114929518,
-0.0214364734,
0.0237985756,
-0.0290363673,
-0.042807065,
0.044073984,
-0.0059117456,
-0.0181257166,
-0.0074703046,
0.0200544465,
-0.003319667,
-0.0072716223,
0.014818822,
-0.0224512219,
0.0198655818,
-0.0055976533,
-0.0154444436,
0.0037414762,
-0.0461342596,
-0.0586387105,
0.0102591859,
0.0007383255,
-0.0335789621,
-0.0010731516,
-0.0393856168,
0.0118748304,
-0.0063276361,
-0.0352818221,
-0.0185368471,
0.0569365248,
-0.0052652517,
-0.0127741024,
-0.018563129,
0.0770826712,
0.011755893,
-0.0361374058,
-0.0540758148,
0.0184731372,
-0.0609346889,
-0.0166318603,
-0.058017984,
0.050265763,
-0.0479125343,
-0.0714989454,
-0.1068419367,
0.0099465465,
-0.0002515417,
-0.0191961974,
0.0331964046,
0.0047134864,
-0.0547248423,
0.00070854,
-0.0212569106,
-0.0231798105,
-0.0569245294,
-0.0011416539,
0.0520166568,
-0.0696334839,
0.0039652195,
0.0524023771,
0.0011651247,
-0.0080411742,
-0.0442163832,
0.0811653435,
-0.0118388878,
0.005383533,
-0.0031949675,
-0.060558673,
-0.0283340141,
-0.0371794216,
-0.0024762291,
-0.02839984,
0.0212061908,
-0.0199139845,
-0.0090867411,
0.0017534009,
0.0125406645,
-0.0077219545,
0.0396793038,
0.0202063937,
0.0195232388,
-0.0298586078,
0.0144199152,
0.0089127412,
-0.0173867512,
0.0434153676,
0.0098745637,
0.0225074049,
0.0378458798,
-0.0002490463,
0.0207352862,
0.0253814235,
-0.0044280612,
-0.0539759621,
0.0433620438,
0.0105573554,
0.0112716565,
0.0329911038,
0.0265987106,
0.0487202257,
-0.0566072948,
0.0129722115,
0.0398888551,
0.0041882126,
0.0393566303,
0.0346971229,
0.0516203828,
0.0440711714,
0.0128530487,
0.0280209538,
0.0145304669,
0.0213598218,
-0.0219300911,
0.0598571301,
0.0447316468,
-0.0004046411,
-0.0187592246,
-0.059919972,
-0.0012279238,
0.0029071819,
-0.0012677996,
-0.0166269802,
-0.0002245305,
0.0073387688,
-0.0616030321,
0.0217361897,
0.0030257446,
-0.0728455037,
-0.0134859476,
-0.0323192887,
-0.0010706909,
0.0918747485,
0.0731641203,
0.0511016212,
-0.0510451719,
0.0033724599,
-0.0305311494,
0.0771869645,
0.0670880452,
-0.0069865244,
-0.0224618614,
-0.0625101775,
-0.0077876495,
0.0036793875,
0.0205361284,
0.0289804172,
0.0306532998,
0.008714851,
0.0566385277,
-0.0108079286,
-0.0191415884,
0.0011808177,
-0.0140159009,
-0.0273544304,
0.0181135852,
-0.0354457609,
0.0198089983,
0.0227110013,
-0.0338080339,
0.0313630551,
-0.0123195685,
-0.0168229248,
-0.050143823,
0.0550786629,
-0.0764278397,
-0.0721230879,
-0.0005306595,
-0.04354937,
-0.0075120009,
0.0055412091,
-0.0620267838,
-0.0462347008,
-0.0009320371,
-0.012964149,
0.0124723436,
-0.08440689,
0.0103238011,
0.0340324529,
0.0237340461,
0.0090672411,
0.0777095184,
0.0167866033,
0.0067356434,
0.0144365057,
0.0702555701,
0.0127358483,
-0.0786235482,
0.0317007415,
0.0079714898,
-0.0353433564,
0.0267377682,
0.0320871957,
0.0626545772,
-0.0317089744,
-0.0291538555,
-0.0899406448,
-0.0017453913,
-0.0129210744,
0.0233744197,
0.0339680165,
-0.0132350689,
-0.0173258092,
0.0251050238,
-0.0707554296,
0.0090173166,
0.0104064289,
-0.0285432208,
0.049442742,
-0.0257561654,
-0.000315615,
-0.0566062294,
0.0299540143,
0.0221779663,
0.0100220991,
0.0391095169,
0.0014731718,
-0.0139519693,
0.0246718787,
-0.0168927796,
-0.0250072274,
0.0054360912,
-0.0451037288,
0.0094217425,
0.0093823411,
0.05500241,
0.0100934282,
0.0538370311,
0.0568582751,
-0.0747882128,
-0.0170513187,
-0.0417444296,
0.0206884108,
-0.0196174644,
-0.0175856836,
0.0124559114,
-0.02995166,
0.0232828856,
0.0524554178,
0.0144087132,
0.0015172419,
-0.0860066116,
0.0210120007,
-0.037043415,
-0.0122713596,
-0.0222124532,
0.0247002747,
-0.0207977649,
0.0174618624,
-0.0119277025,
-0.0286173727,
0.048121579,
-0.0218343139,
-0.0265745707,
-0.054725837,
0.0143650007,
-0.0485492684,
0.055601541,
-0.021064952,
0.0241887961,
0.0521565154,
-0.0361714959,
-0.0405042209,
0.0263978485,
0.0483911745,
-0.0253997166,
-0.01561963,
-0.0325550511,
0.0179874972,
-0.0022203231,
-0.0045116409,
-0.0410504751,
-0.037919376,
0.0114459675,
0.0309871137,
0.1217479482,
-0.0160065442,
0.0157845095,
0.0528531112,
-0.0319446847,
-0.0042161206,
-0.0306385849,
-0.0123711899,
-0.0000851281,
0.0461071655,
0.0562832318,
0.0160685573,
-0.0137802288,
-0.0332063325,
0.049813509,
0.039862629,
0.0011640586,
0.0251445249,
0.0124983704,
-0.0019146333,
-0.0167448837,
-0.0288002584,
-0.0156672392,
0.0330516696,
0.0282430556,
-0.0375354886,
-0.0209698379,
0.118710734,
0.0226552319,
0.0436215177,
-0.0001998158,
0.0100247478,
0.0527348481,
-0.0278328024,
0.0131013067,
-0.110732168,
-0.0166983083,
-0.0128101241,
0.0149018597,
-0.0041513615,
-0.0059431791,
-0.0185704324,
-0.1503762156,
0.0743924901,
-0.0004209201,
-0.0177162681,
0.0012250631,
0.012030472,
-0.0456221849,
-0.0037321227,
0.0204771385,
0.0141774686,
-0.0019943363,
0.025222905,
0.0288415477,
-0.0654367134,
-0.0443565212,
0.0087312972,
-0.0164543781,
0.0420375913,
0.0646249726,
0.0377591737,
0.0317743197,
0.0135274967,
0.0001949877,
0.0231818389,
0.0023354408,
-0.0029687276,
0.0507402606,
0.0227942187,
-0.0060728104,
-0.0128682321,
0.0278893579,
-0.0004376461,
0.0327265933,
0.0250651035,
-0.0219793785,
-0.0103459982,
-0.0283192545,
0.0087969871,
0.0805286244,
-0.0074390015,
0.0879551917,
0.0379123315,
-0.032188151,
-0.0420335867,
-0.0358014368,
0.0296320599,
-0.0920076445,
-0.0020620972,
0.0005355883,
0.025623871,
-0.0197475627,
-0.1374109238,
-0.0742149502,
0.0060790889,
0.0187557954,
-0.0246281177,
-0.0313820876,
0.0147939017,
-0.0013899719,
0.0096295727,
-0.0151285846,
-0.0167625658,
-0.0198310874,
-0.0628267229,
-0.0039667771,
0.0065823528,
-0.0445364788,
-0.0267405137,
0.0608275831,
-0.0758131891,
-0.0441493168,
-0.0126945823,
0.0241199471,
0.0128509402,
-0.0252679288,
-0.0292422995,
0.0461531058,
-0.0155081805,
0.043172732,
-0.0339799784,
-0.0061972528,
0.0351928361,
0.0276468527,
-0.0220870953,
0.0261472054,
-0.0325887129,
0.0239799377,
-0.0210161861,
0.0862739757,
0.0155548658,
-0.0134165538,
0.0323925167,
0.0296539702,
-0.0286028162,
-0.0170480758,
-0.0064579463,
-0.0197677333,
0.007120945,
-0.0560439788,
-0.0151883168,
-0.063009508,
-0.017270226,
0.0308903512,
0.0063035977,
0.0009201012,
0.0294857789,
-0.0552980825,
0.0258702021,
-0.0293460023,
-0.0222959798,
-0.0198348705,
-0.0180017296,
-0.0144114736,
-0.0391425528,
-0.0059618172,
-0.0228489935,
0.0084109707,
0.0248187687,
-0.0097626178,
0.0702411011,
-0.0091189053,
0.0182081275,
0.033159107,
0.0077480827,
-0.0264465455,
-0.0264135767,
-0.0219662376,
0.0662612617,
0.058150053,
0.0283546988,
0.0420453958,
-0.0545397922,
0.017908005,
-0.0062086731,
0.0527234189,
0.0267523862,
-0.0708714128,
0.0017891261,
-0.0081628468,
-0.0425194725,
-0.0623456053,
0.1278833598,
-0.0026661521,
0.0191687923,
-0.0289087724,
-0.0032082829,
-0.0571086444,
-0.0467292704,
0.0318141878,
-0.0211903583,
0.0176715329,
0.0209397878,
-0.070295386,
-0.045205459,
-0.0313680172,
0.0287448429,
0.0192539599,
0.0165449157,
0.0673338547,
0.0615055338,
-0.0295624007,
0.0070706909,
-0.0185039397,
0.0181626286,
-0.0378926583,
0.0098347813,
-0.0498669147,
-6.825768026e-33,
-0.0401869453,
-0.0199550968,
0.0280376337,
-0.0095327236,
-0.0243056696,
-0.0116090206,
-0.0527033694,
0.017708635,
0.0275842808,
0.0066046109,
0.000202399,
0.0180007648,
0.0156927947,
0.0450051799,
-0.0143684074,
-0.0123029239,
0.0407831296,
-0.0103883529,
-0.0378914922,
0.0261707641,
0.0155245299,
0.0433930941,
0.0266434569,
-0.0096596181,
0.0383664891,
-0.0149468742,
-0.0420791917,
-0.0136562828,
0.0579152107,
0.0550757907,
-0.0167542286,
0.0193255842,
0.0086755101,
-0.0709753633,
-0.0135228327,
-0.007311218,
-0.0293751676,
-0.0332917534,
0.0054568653,
0.002898837,
-0.0244773794,
-0.0156973675,
-0.0002747556,
-0.0325846449,
-0.0075213728,
0.0032878637,
0.00936634,
-0.0008209468,
0.0088406103,
-0.0564013906,
-0.0719208941,
0.0452164188,
-0.0119764404,
-0.0111162104,
-0.0385469012,
0.080178991,
-0.0182003956,
-0.0168210436,
0.0144921103,
0.0083071962,
0.028405834,
0.0343653113,
0.0406424068,
-0.0057376358,
-0.0081369951,
0.0375992879,
-0.0016055367,
0.0315101743,
-0.0222448576,
0.0074530263,
-0.0081357788,
0.040652398,
0.0289615076,
0.0737975538,
0.0175845157,
-0.0102708703,
-0.0488448516,
0.06116594,
0.0179068092,
0.0016201537,
-0.0086848447,
0.0023999731,
-0.03134178,
-0.0331255421,
-0.0076617748,
0.0300324243,
-0.019638719,
-0.0522174984,
0.0306568611,
0.0022024792,
-0.0213973932,
-0.0550886169,
0.0298636481,
-0.0322837904,
-0.014825467,
-0.0169066936,
-0.0225889925,
-0.0003042445,
-0.0300205909,
0.0176281277,
-0.0300997607,
-0.0295161027,
0.047490485,
0.0384129211,
-0.014721808,
-0.0118793026,
0.0131419301,
-0.005474491,
-0.0279541556,
0.010928547,
-0.0181821156,
0.0425197519,
-0.024433529,
-0.0044372617,
-0.011823291,
0.0140679106,
-0.0323644765,
0.010951505,
0.012524996,
0.0324859768,
-0.0560162589,
0.0044857534,
0.0036434163,
0.0345531926,
-0.0196190644,
0.0582186058,
-0.0043155691,
0.0188275035,
0.0486387499,
-0.0171212796,
-0.0336845107,
0.0190459955,
2.712e-7,
0.0325338393,
0.0355253629,
0.0441688858,
0.0613511726,
0.0018872358,
0.0261195228,
0.0112564024,
0.0327432975,
0.0053866394,
0.0251191817,
0.0173811838,
0.0042166407,
0.0791921318,
-0.0115596764,
-0.0737447664,
-0.0270445198,
-0.0703542307,
-0.0289260894,
-0.0157539807,
0.0037488232,
0.0605301186,
0.0431961156,
-0.0553341992,
0.009873216,
0.0146817081,
-0.0508406721,
0.0654618144,
-0.0177535377,
-0.0520933457,
0.0711196885,
0.0379504971,
0.019515343,
0.0059229298,
-0.0001219043,
-0.0084548108,
-0.0111917602,
0.0525781661,
0.0529099852,
0.0609149225,
-0.0146137895,
0.0052794139,
0.0070968643,
0.0085065607,
-0.0421379618,
0.0249815844,
-0.0794270784,
-0.0245233215,
-0.0089858482,
-0.0240884908,
-0.0028304718,
0.020731451,
-0.018645959,
-0.0340892524,
0.0317676812,
0.023266403,
-0.0022291194,
0.0191949978,
0.004469635,
-0.0526966006,
-0.0115035288,
-0.0632992089,
-0.0254634526,
-0.040087577,
-0.0138582708,
-0.0000135274,
-0.0043969448,
-0.0067396639,
2.088680581e-34,
0.0566386357,
0.0071873497,
-0.0135639692,
0.0231247284,
0.0620638728,
0.0084531372,
0.0104847765,
0.0078881718,
-0.0089038638,
-0.0516484268,
-0.0328203999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14468v1 | Run Like a Girl! Sports-Related Gender Bias in Language and Vision | 2023-05-23T18:52:11 | 2023-05-23T18:52:11 | Sophia Harrison, Eleonora Gualdoni, Gemma Boleda | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Gender bias in Language and Vision datasets and models has the potential to
perpetuate harmful stereotypes and discrimination. We analyze gender bias in
two Language and Vision datasets. Consistent with prior work, we find that both
datasets underrepresent women, which promotes their invisibilization. Moreover,
we hypothesize and find that a bias affects human naming choices for people
playing sports: speakers produce names indicating the sport (e.g. 'tennis
player' or 'surfer') more often when it is a man or a boy participating in the
sport than when it is a woman or a girl, with an average of 46% vs. 35% of
sports-related names for each gender. A computational model trained on these
naming data reproduces the bias. We argue that both the data and the model
result in representational harm against women. | [
0.0078440784,
0.0873164311,
-0.0663750246,
0.0250777658,
0.0507419482,
0.0477994047,
0.0333422832,
-0.0075841602,
0.0177658573,
-0.0318346098,
0.0385520533,
-0.0272917505,
0.0438125953,
0.0045989626,
0.0254681911,
-0.0518587008,
-0.0133471023,
0.0056672897,
0.0594226308,
-0.0437013805,
0.0099321902,
0.017854413,
0.0516080558,
0.057780914,
0.0032161609,
-0.0364163369,
0.1012450531,
-0.0188230909,
-0.0566721,
-0.0035324709,
0.0040326738,
0.0073685194,
-0.0082516707,
-0.0252242051,
0.0000015609,
-0.0734411851,
0.0772782788,
-0.0029924184,
0.0184333734,
0.0046836804,
0.0053960062,
-0.014126556,
0.0152183343,
-0.0030010815,
0.0131670078,
0.0056918878,
0.0286428034,
-0.006602616,
-0.0017971194,
-0.0338607356,
0.0093081156,
0.0212326739,
-0.0704510137,
-0.0150685459,
0.0174394399,
0.0387537032,
0.0436264314,
-0.0422770008,
-0.0615901947,
-0.0079667261,
-0.0371139571,
-0.0137683684,
-0.0379670449,
0.0452418402,
-0.0209837835,
0.0324709527,
-0.0463000461,
-0.0318340957,
0.0468612313,
0.0182822999,
-0.0075194649,
-0.0233986899,
0.0294221789,
0.0074727279,
0.0189883336,
0.0149761876,
0.0015225221,
0.0594387241,
0.0033523412,
-0.0444023386,
-0.0472792163,
-0.0039775716,
0.0122282701,
0.0440989174,
0.0145005984,
0.0460705608,
0.0133652976,
0.0017993205,
-0.0340692885,
-0.0001244977,
0.0314951241,
-0.0770322606,
0.008253715,
-0.0469846204,
0.01182409,
0.0023516535,
-0.0243753344,
-0.0323530436,
0.0081650298,
-0.0830104202,
0.0313268974,
0.0490812697,
0.0456068069,
-0.0328042433,
-0.0256684721,
0.0249437336,
0.0134760365,
0.0098070363,
-0.0033342508,
-0.0159798432,
-0.0356430523,
-0.0182576012,
0.0251328982,
-0.0182876755,
-0.0386368819,
0.0397936553,
-0.0565828532,
0.0130409766,
-0.0545216538,
-0.0209308751,
-0.0332358927,
0.0279652104,
0.0133394608,
-0.0069760284,
-0.0331741832,
-0.0462967195,
-0.0663271993,
0.0217612367,
-0.0358493626,
-0.0771444589,
0.0118870791,
-0.0125022121,
0.0016687905,
-0.0166301504,
0.0265984014,
0.0314721093,
0.0486693084,
-0.0161917154,
0.0183364619,
-0.0215974301,
-0.0303360019,
-0.0396644883,
0.0042525986,
-0.0570566058,
0.0019453447,
0.0298847966,
0.0107734781,
-0.0862132013,
0.000021607,
0.0292097926,
-0.0619173385,
0.0479201004,
0.0566235334,
0.0145996697,
0.0789675862,
0.0096688615,
-0.0121862497,
0.0650695488,
0.0347094946,
-0.0339155793,
-0.021627428,
0.0080170315,
-0.0032425916,
0.0150896814,
0.038908612,
0.017964229,
-0.049418278,
0.001532193,
-0.0002370572,
0.0273360796,
0.0546402186,
-0.0410495512,
0.0048543317,
-0.0468452349,
0.0619521067,
0.0877607092,
0.0116074765,
0.0474615842,
0.02719553,
-0.0141656417,
-0.0305567924,
-0.0110595329,
-0.0471169911,
-0.0116628204,
0.0437551141,
-0.0237976778,
-0.0641121864,
0.0628554299,
-0.0410639048,
-0.0278969575,
0.0137596186,
0.0252605714,
0.0196091793,
0.0236212853,
0.020093346,
0.0418252647,
0.0125446944,
0.0639093891,
0.0296596866,
-0.0235948171,
0.0160787329,
-0.0187130496,
0.0001100714,
0.0187309086,
-0.0427880771,
0.002856883,
0.0332751386,
-0.0181865431,
-0.0135969222,
-0.0106216669,
-0.0018979664,
0.0502569117,
0.0403671339,
-0.0029911634,
0.0015207706,
0.0635036305,
0.0616609901,
0.0522106588,
0.009841756,
0.0164459608,
0.0230253134,
0.0261443686,
-0.1118706018,
0.0057774871,
-0.0129135456,
-0.0518418811,
0.032561224,
-0.0264073852,
-0.0162682422,
0.0110448105,
-0.034190055,
-0.0077749724,
-0.0152453296,
0.0049057542,
0.0331367441,
0.0577207133,
0.0003689353,
0.0346570536,
0.0046348562,
-0.0792762116,
-0.0618754327,
0.0163431093,
0.0129814269,
0.0084056845,
0.0778098181,
0.0127393184,
0.0158794019,
0.0158900861,
-0.0294006187,
-0.0238997322,
0.0403264575,
0.0128856236,
-0.0061554681,
-0.003636057,
-0.0373252816,
-0.0003840018,
-0.0416390896,
-0.0051400554,
-0.0806687698,
-0.0351111293,
0.0340225436,
-0.0037062424,
-0.0041554077,
0.026790455,
-0.0386134423,
-0.0229780748,
0.0185165461,
-0.0531085804,
0.0055745407,
0.0059894505,
-0.0319481157,
-0.0346081853,
0.0241704527,
-0.034572091,
-0.0117069343,
0.0308702681,
-0.0246221535,
0.0028486711,
0.0536645725,
-0.013955174,
-0.0263313167,
-0.0060034571,
0.0100438101,
-0.0441716276,
-0.0290563349,
0.0790140107,
0.0474029444,
-0.020765841,
-0.0371794067,
-0.0065595992,
-0.0653735399,
0.009808911,
-0.0025959634,
0.0224678218,
0.0161683653,
0.0665831193,
0.0544828027,
0.0635103881,
0.0313787237,
-0.0106998477,
0.0547471419,
-0.0340411402,
0.0081234677,
-0.04126231,
-0.0009631588,
-0.0047244914,
-0.0039608805,
-0.0980085954,
-0.0063933167,
0.0054935012,
-0.0120402742,
-0.0229231585,
-0.0328680798,
0.0520326458,
-0.0448716357,
-0.024750717,
-0.0551727228,
-0.0804716796,
-0.0412841216,
0.0518678948,
-0.0314287134,
-0.0269586314,
-0.0128794052,
0.0206256006,
0.0104698977,
0.0212246682,
-0.0013957855,
0.0076101222,
0.0516438335,
0.0434779264,
0.0467571057,
0.024899099,
-0.0215995256,
-0.0362335704,
-0.0352884941,
0.0591832697,
-0.01977681,
0.0338374898,
-0.0081681525,
0.0280570816,
0.0193723626,
-0.0098257307,
-0.0193786416,
-0.0091924882,
-0.0201250669,
-0.0464768335,
-0.0193694029,
0.0077853333,
-0.0258414727,
-0.016352674,
-0.002855507,
-0.0217684899,
-0.0024222783,
-0.0186779983,
0.0200120565,
-0.0425229743,
0.002189799,
0.0064325081,
0.0158595666,
-0.0285241976,
-0.0239698887,
0.0183947664,
-0.0193270091,
0.0558121353,
0.0264595728,
0.0450957641,
0.0188783612,
-0.010929158,
-0.0254405849,
0.0125331106,
0.0335455462,
-0.0234215558,
0.0230114292,
0.0447074436,
-0.0015455254,
-0.0177442878,
0.0063450779,
0.0588629507,
0.0306846127,
0.0313377082,
-0.0327039324,
-0.0587353855,
0.0344156623,
0.0452129394,
0.0048190104,
-0.0691999719,
-0.0583608486,
-0.0317002945,
-0.0947615951,
-0.0374490917,
0.0007949689,
-0.029592799,
-0.0237111766,
0.0160999876,
0.0190905351,
-0.0083400747,
0.0089292889,
0.0004932308,
-0.0009003849,
0.0223794058,
-0.0107888943,
-0.0247888677,
-0.0119757364,
0.013803497,
-0.0774939209,
0.0352041833,
-0.0115812011,
0.0459850468,
-0.0417971499,
-0.0120416889,
-0.006654189,
0.0151127744,
-0.0151112527,
-0.0265955888,
0.0316758752,
-0.0359219946,
-0.0211274158,
-0.06927865,
0.0158815328,
0.0447345674,
-0.0008701055,
0.024918329,
0.0088937655,
0.0654164627,
-0.0050824927,
-0.0227224696,
-0.0222472623,
-0.0274423715,
0.0250835177,
0.0249245372,
0.0040652598,
0.0145486454,
-0.063466616,
0.0391850732,
0.0298354011,
-0.1091492772,
-0.0414998829,
0.0298868623,
-0.054253675,
0.0071674758,
-0.0331952088,
0.0233670101,
0.0032390521,
0.0285220183,
-0.0326677971,
-0.0193847436,
-0.014294561,
-0.0897353292,
0.0685314834,
0.0188617855,
-0.0073778252,
0.0512437411,
-0.022299327,
0.0251446702,
-0.0113141323,
-0.0305912495,
0.0582040027,
0.0041137305,
-0.0219742619,
0.0617194735,
0.033308845,
0.0210783575,
0.0464405864,
0.0261705071,
-0.0505367368,
-0.003044677,
0.0285072438,
-0.0018908889,
0.0342536345,
-0.0125919478,
-0.0002537882,
0.0121716801,
0.0021353427,
0.0255197641,
0.0479413643,
0.0142421909,
-0.0392948426,
-0.0572951958,
0.0178236775,
0.0110434266,
-0.006306672,
0.0497790538,
-0.0320562758,
-0.0004291811,
-0.0173725858,
-0.0508239046,
-0.0448638424,
-0.0075343819,
0.023181634,
-0.0332251713,
0.0403512418,
0.0653021634,
-0.0404010937,
-0.0196641907,
-0.0714131668,
0.0314561725,
-0.0289038811,
0.0232310314,
0.0240336675,
0.0387280434,
0.0187449306,
0.0104365367,
0.0530609004,
0.0181602035,
-0.0247551743,
0.0048196642,
0.0158953462,
-0.0395023115,
0.0194953699,
0.0216773655,
-0.0366002657,
-0.0414821804,
0.0135038067,
-0.0070352084,
0.013603433,
0.0163415093,
0.0102770813,
-0.05618174,
0.01407653,
0.0089964634,
-0.0289624725,
0.029389007,
-0.0061781611,
-0.0272095744,
-0.0059587983,
0.0482909791,
-0.0048349421,
0.0082356017,
-0.0292019676,
-0.0078461664,
0.0571820773,
0.0297298748,
0.0042508366,
-0.0787009522,
0.0158181954,
-0.0217677355,
0.023907654,
0.0101733925,
-0.016865585,
0.0168898366,
-0.1016946658,
-0.0268580765,
-0.0245128218,
-0.0357189327,
0.0509697907,
0.0237055514,
0.0074954857,
0.0199716762,
0.0003133943,
-0.0428465195,
-0.0018291799,
0.0073800203,
-0.0332403183,
-0.0662676245,
-0.0026549099,
-4.715789462e-33,
0.0004116531,
-0.0468811095,
0.0162150338,
-0.0227691941,
-0.0474965908,
0.0072018369,
-0.0071093938,
0.0265414156,
0.006338608,
0.0162642673,
0.0223194491,
0.0285924431,
0.0027167636,
-0.0138024297,
0.0508498549,
-0.0267165266,
0.0446811393,
0.0146219889,
-0.0144076385,
-0.0586728342,
-0.0035809076,
0.0295634158,
0.0154724279,
-0.0639526248,
0.0690425858,
-0.0051742145,
-0.027866913,
-0.0472798981,
0.0210252292,
-0.0035371939,
0.0168831963,
0.0344339199,
0.0164261237,
-0.0234399997,
0.0094153602,
0.0985789746,
-0.0393116474,
-0.0314567536,
-0.0047478573,
0.0181075055,
0.058792416,
0.014700545,
0.0441374704,
0.0192946512,
-0.0618039034,
-0.0406380929,
0.071111232,
-0.0153027093,
0.0662266463,
0.0362130813,
-0.0184848234,
0.0152702751,
-0.0195143502,
0.0396893248,
0.0582837127,
0.005380467,
0.0106145283,
0.0344899334,
-0.0585811697,
0.0519361608,
-0.0286514461,
-0.0003666986,
0.0102423197,
0.064146854,
0.0669820458,
-0.0174953379,
0.1410183161,
0.0315227509,
-0.0389904082,
-0.0488570407,
0.0411694683,
-0.0227520671,
0.0136506706,
0.0505178757,
0.0577320158,
-0.040116787,
-0.0090087745,
-0.0743181035,
0.0143094333,
0.0031885419,
-0.0421048924,
0.0029935089,
-0.0937454253,
-0.0491136387,
-0.0215566009,
-0.0742840394,
-0.0085277045,
-0.0283818711,
0.0280831214,
-0.0315748937,
-0.0131440908,
0.0422765277,
-0.021747807,
-0.0178015102,
-0.092448689,
-0.0165387783,
0.0037838474,
-0.0240464117,
0.0362390764,
-0.0141862864,
-0.0496721603,
0.0280211214,
-0.0242826398,
0.0305848476,
0.0197214391,
-0.0033822868,
-0.011043855,
-0.0224436373,
-0.0608684793,
-0.0126955463,
-0.0109475534,
-0.0158789512,
0.0576855019,
0.0150078898,
0.0158453826,
0.0286315903,
-0.0010883793,
-0.0457520485,
0.0684296489,
-0.0368797407,
-0.0400670916,
0.0039664581,
-0.0398522615,
0.04706854,
-0.0057342346,
-0.0352824517,
-0.0249123424,
0.043143902,
0.0848022699,
-0.0330447182,
-0.02828677,
-0.0615500361,
2.192e-7,
-0.0137048652,
0.08167319,
-0.0524400808,
0.0162108969,
0.0135400323,
0.0375686437,
0.0108327316,
0.0480229743,
0.0951995999,
0.0267987512,
-0.0277158804,
0.0394838117,
-0.0258252658,
0.0027350739,
-0.0279687289,
0.0087112095,
-0.0514662527,
0.0152769284,
-0.0194257647,
0.0125364438,
-0.0223691612,
0.0224315934,
0.0710759088,
-0.0082107717,
-0.0217249952,
-0.0304248966,
0.0229759756,
-0.0468209684,
0.0301898215,
-0.0016205773,
-0.0258162655,
-0.0157737546,
-0.0121570565,
0.0280916411,
0.0143040493,
0.0138501665,
0.0404604673,
-0.03385517,
-0.0244998597,
0.0914796218,
-0.0261198804,
0.0202532206,
-0.0506017916,
-0.0298272409,
0.0217208154,
0.0218489766,
-0.0537860692,
-0.0215407684,
-0.0571046136,
0.0177025683,
0.0700851381,
-0.0083572706,
-0.0162957255,
-0.0118823135,
0.0209444799,
0.0104429778,
0.027389193,
-0.0415602848,
0.0111341896,
-0.0145007735,
-0.0095299343,
-0.0247431602,
-0.0068971929,
0.0381287858,
0.004701552,
-0.0306616575,
0.0236737225,
1.362044616e-34,
-0.0198088046,
0.0441315137,
0.0094593186,
-0.0664874837,
-0.0241662282,
-0.0124405725,
0.0190920122,
-0.0199071541,
0.0766016319,
0.0385780521,
0.0174273178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14463v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14463v3 | ReadMe++: Benchmarking Multilingual Language Models for Multi-Domain Readability Assessment | 2023-05-23T18:37:30 | 2024-06-08T15:54:54 | Tarek Naous, Michael J. Ryan, Anton Lavrouk, Mohit Chandra, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present a comprehensive evaluation of large language models for
multilingual readability assessment. Existing evaluation resources lack domain
and language diversity, limiting the ability for cross-domain and cross-lingual
analyses. This paper introduces ReadMe++, a multilingual multi-domain dataset
with human annotations of 9757 sentences in Arabic, English, French, Hindi, and
Russian, collected from 112 different data sources. This benchmark will
encourage research on developing robust multilingual readability assessment
methods. Using ReadMe++, we benchmark multilingual and monolingual language
models in the supervised, unsupervised, and few-shot prompting settings. The
domain and language diversity in ReadMe++ enable us to test more effective
few-shot prompting, and identify shortcomings in state-of-the-art unsupervised
methods. Our experiments also reveal exciting results of superior domain
generalization and enhanced cross-lingual transfer capabilities by models
trained on ReadMe++. We will make our data publicly available and release a
python package tool for multilingual sentence readability prediction using our
trained models at: https://github.com/tareknaous/readme | [
-0.0032820771,
-0.0036440291,
-0.0209015347,
0.0552760065,
-0.0543551147,
0.0457447879,
0.0650326237,
-0.0136639876,
0.0593142956,
-0.020953685,
-0.0647672638,
-0.0577855781,
0.0160541721,
0.0006508112,
0.0328837931,
-0.0368687734,
0.0169623308,
-0.0488542952,
0.0063574361,
0.0144680012,
0.0193196144,
0.0071725133,
-0.0269434191,
0.0239774641,
0.0458374768,
-0.065890111,
0.0297444686,
0.019925341,
0.0143894367,
-0.0243498813,
0.0152050303,
0.0515317768,
-0.031047821,
0.0119567998,
0.0000021368,
-0.042895589,
-0.0467877612,
-0.0035493404,
0.0396711268,
0.0287203696,
0.0782843903,
-0.0474093333,
0.0001168073,
-0.0156822465,
0.0079596052,
-0.0173279401,
0.0325729474,
0.0292202216,
0.0626025423,
0.0594850332,
-0.0150837218,
-0.0402750298,
-0.0134802451,
0.0157285277,
-0.0133236442,
-0.0509949028,
0.0096875681,
0.0359569825,
-0.003541301,
0.0104887104,
-0.0185313728,
0.036299672,
0.0064893831,
-0.035910733,
-0.0234383326,
-0.0134078488,
-0.0009965122,
-0.0337571613,
-0.0015618448,
0.0912706703,
0.0030555278,
-0.0320547037,
-0.0085438769,
0.0070639942,
-0.0049030795,
0.0089310445,
-0.0125666037,
-0.0127653312,
-0.0165852122,
-0.0097099189,
0.0035639759,
0.0302695539,
0.0418772139,
-0.0166569613,
0.0400183909,
0.0728778318,
0.0290422328,
-0.0307228118,
0.0247892104,
0.0630043447,
-0.0015004295,
0.0260944441,
0.0462429635,
-0.0259572808,
-0.0403808355,
0.0019053899,
-0.0440962799,
-0.0731673092,
0.013610905,
-0.0371522084,
0.0477363914,
0.0394854508,
-0.0567751639,
0.0342942402,
-0.0243138708,
0.0369489044,
0.0233943183,
0.0179512557,
-0.0546878614,
0.0012289545,
-0.0004782985,
0.0314032361,
0.0001241219,
0.0145448297,
-0.0425669178,
-0.0162913185,
-0.0633990318,
-0.0214121304,
0.0159184206,
-0.0307253134,
0.0122242123,
-0.0539758615,
-0.0316355042,
-0.0117937718,
0.0218069088,
0.0381201431,
-0.0587129742,
0.0208422523,
0.0069292313,
-0.0374024473,
0.0082408711,
0.0446077362,
-0.0205787029,
-0.0400296301,
-0.0473173,
0.0790023804,
-0.0517696068,
-0.0298102871,
-0.0745784864,
0.0101053789,
-0.0193218365,
-0.0291554071,
-0.0098207574,
-0.0455874726,
0.0203783512,
-0.0056858091,
0.0351946391,
-0.0460616834,
-0.0345092118,
-0.0038469792,
0.0039192908,
0.0550098903,
0.0247793961,
-0.0013779532,
0.0336824059,
0.0330739468,
-0.0102512203,
0.0763169527,
0.014607247,
-0.0205687582,
0.0836889371,
-0.0091168508,
0.0048965719,
0.0338688269,
-0.0191030968,
0.0215335339,
0.0495948158,
-0.0281431377,
-0.0216426104,
0.0060392544,
0.0015158938,
0.0308756344,
-0.0093762716,
-0.0128381466,
0.0784369409,
0.0076067988,
0.0310417358,
-0.0151523389,
0.0692571104,
0.0330269225,
0.0131258033,
0.0568822138,
0.0027914871,
-0.0051177898,
-0.0144225052,
0.041208677,
0.0622920617,
0.0371039174,
-0.0093618659,
-0.064878799,
0.0267478898,
-0.0030015619,
0.0340042189,
-0.0388702974,
0.0622431189,
0.0067354282,
-0.0676142424,
-0.024930561,
0.0293927062,
-0.0853601918,
0.0197025631,
0.0103551513,
0.0290765967,
0.0633656457,
0.0217053965,
-0.0309747495,
-0.0133344037,
0.0131082088,
0.0474608243,
0.0370608456,
0.0121913068,
0.0030696392,
0.0687657669,
-0.0683572814,
-0.0129593052,
0.0208788887,
0.0257278755,
0.0328940637,
-0.0307493191,
0.0362207443,
0.0265619587,
-0.0730942786,
-0.0410432816,
0.0327190123,
-0.0756383613,
-0.0133599089,
0.0137333022,
0.012691061,
0.0182729885,
0.0338215232,
-0.0239344221,
-0.0166103635,
-0.0030437221,
-0.0215482302,
0.0384400301,
0.0024930215,
-0.0179765746,
-0.0445856303,
-0.0070203189,
-0.0498583578,
-0.0127336094,
0.0326264389,
-0.0097843586,
-0.0343830958,
-0.0058575734,
-0.0089566456,
-0.0160189606,
-0.0187969562,
0.0422122963,
-0.024928065,
0.0125007629,
-0.020818267,
-0.0076805879,
0.0124100987,
0.0253210608,
0.0033966263,
-0.0349942744,
0.0071741771,
-0.0129410885,
-0.0576037392,
0.0070691165,
-0.0210473705,
0.0348367207,
0.0323336199,
0.0544997342,
-0.0633652583,
-0.0006283182,
-0.0544737317,
-0.0210278593,
-0.0221836697,
0.0358702168,
-0.0229875222,
-0.0039597368,
-0.0208159517,
-0.0045517827,
0.0221097358,
-0.0154159917,
-0.0415335633,
0.0337815434,
0.0238288268,
-0.0143528869,
0.0382042155,
-0.0465513133,
-0.0377392694,
0.0271367673,
0.0732606426,
0.0267014783,
-0.0060569341,
-0.0374548994,
0.0231246818,
0.0122957733,
-0.0596843846,
0.0163425431,
-0.0346792825,
-0.0137874987,
0.0109342178,
0.0532001853,
0.0731620565,
-0.0408637188,
0.0083225649,
0.0385971069,
-0.0071096905,
-0.0386888869,
0.0014308868,
0.0061322399,
-0.006721471,
0.0015453167,
-0.04557468,
0.0060756505,
0.0426340736,
-0.0155413784,
-0.0173513349,
-0.0396526493,
-0.0004053576,
-0.0766823068,
-0.0599099062,
-0.0614460818,
0.0284653883,
0.0074946443,
0.0634627044,
-0.023680469,
-0.0296866875,
0.073515594,
-0.0638838038,
-0.0159653258,
-0.0533236302,
0.0077806353,
-0.0182251334,
0.012951822,
-0.0209366325,
0.0195600688,
0.0216613989,
-0.049976252,
-0.0323960967,
-0.0000814376,
0.0254491661,
-0.0074360198,
0.0484055914,
-0.0630787387,
-0.0137223182,
0.0251201317,
-0.0146446154,
0.0008453322,
0.0037529666,
-0.0120480685,
-0.0697282776,
0.0089942152,
-0.0016742897,
-0.0410836078,
-0.0246058553,
0.0220368654,
0.0419385992,
-0.0300388224,
-0.0050430624,
0.0150160389,
0.0408701226,
0.0233930536,
-0.0230846684,
-0.0224175826,
-0.072642915,
0.0322321691,
0.0113879442,
-0.0677793026,
-0.0351573303,
-0.0088159395,
0.0109778503,
0.0423091538,
-0.014368549,
-0.0244933199,
-0.031455338,
0.0660481974,
-0.0722592473,
-0.014848779,
0.0855547786,
0.0048538819,
-0.0350346193,
-0.0155766681,
-0.0356320329,
0.0239188019,
-0.0296756253,
0.0139655722,
-0.048618868,
-0.0446701683,
0.0190050527,
0.0329876579,
0.0036541494,
0.0100254854,
0.024947403,
-0.086233981,
0.0058337594,
0.009061561,
-0.0569075793,
-0.0272809286,
0.0016895785,
-0.014868713,
-0.0162114445,
0.0255377498,
-0.0107228877,
0.0229359977,
-0.0002701401,
0.012239187,
-0.0156973191,
-0.0611948147,
-0.0309039801,
0.0051031746,
0.0379994661,
0.0720330104,
0.0282176342,
-0.0124912253,
-0.0258559268,
0.0319161788,
-0.0053536608,
-0.0130823059,
-0.0297599044,
0.0619159117,
-0.00117709,
-0.0130330715,
-0.0216064323,
0.0069321152,
-0.0206719767,
0.0013193795,
0.0549203046,
0.0025381842,
0.0453122593,
-0.0224535465,
-0.0189250931,
0.0355871879,
0.0296528395,
0.0502516851,
0.0186610911,
-0.0474393331,
-0.0119392499,
-0.0495614223,
-0.0276537612,
-0.1012503579,
-0.0435653254,
0.009843369,
-0.0380112827,
-0.0410720482,
-0.0871877894,
-0.064972803,
-0.0079887286,
-0.0079734456,
0.0333230421,
0.0253576618,
-0.0115941502,
0.0190544911,
-0.0131062893,
-0.0042333328,
-0.0024715883,
0.0213120319,
-0.1001843959,
0.0025394242,
0.0092806863,
-0.0442072935,
-0.026591951,
0.0175837912,
-0.0356035754,
-0.0306631718,
-0.03373776,
0.0480262935,
0.0101129748,
0.0095187984,
-0.024092542,
-0.0390799232,
0.0330162235,
-0.0042246901,
-0.041868668,
-0.0012376859,
0.0493936427,
-0.0110129332,
-0.0059922687,
0.0287669916,
-0.0134691754,
0.0415708385,
0.0082724616,
0.0042851833,
0.0179624204,
-0.0462917648,
-0.0354564935,
0.0061146808,
0.0346749648,
0.0045572389,
-0.0262592137,
-0.0426767431,
0.0152378241,
-0.0270278063,
0.0039269393,
-0.0471103787,
0.0243999362,
0.0433350056,
-0.0075174007,
-0.042304717,
0.0211435053,
0.0015437145,
-0.0095629646,
-0.0218528081,
0.0354720652,
0.0244343001,
0.0465538986,
-0.0076181944,
0.007262392,
-0.0252017584,
-0.0179488156,
-0.0193405617,
0.0446021818,
0.034375336,
0.0488303714,
0.0048131291,
0.0009319775,
0.0671283156,
0.0504093133,
0.004472774,
0.0640465245,
-0.0002967353,
0.0225746222,
0.0132307997,
-0.0290209707,
0.1153790578,
0.0077375211,
0.0191710349,
-0.0575293414,
0.0778817534,
0.0304527432,
-0.0186338369,
-0.0201408397,
-0.0132681662,
0.004443143,
-0.0033889445,
0.1214223504,
-0.0135877859,
-0.0465619527,
0.0400623716,
-0.0227147508,
-0.032855466,
-0.0171019193,
-0.0057708649,
0.0341734588,
-0.0271519329,
0.0029528339,
-0.0438252054,
-0.0475926735,
-0.0025270586,
0.0275680553,
-0.0098008998,
0.0237262528,
-0.0337383226,
0.0701755658,
-0.0222770199,
0.0098202378,
-0.0816879645,
-0.0300701167,
-0.0447796881,
-0.0214930773,
0.0089765219,
-5.905127463e-33,
-0.0252395794,
-0.0218305867,
-0.024766285,
-0.0165339429,
-0.0045189913,
0.015520717,
-0.0613413155,
0.0114800017,
-0.003785654,
0.0502151698,
0.016302187,
0.0026362897,
0.0191735514,
0.017156437,
-0.0013795765,
-0.0172135383,
0.0563125536,
0.0373848528,
-0.0292473547,
0.0139288604,
0.0371113829,
0.0398844182,
0.0466218665,
-0.0599210262,
0.0836241543,
-0.031703759,
-0.0214568861,
-0.0119304424,
0.0404143371,
0.062153738,
0.0067944676,
0.0513813086,
0.0281198658,
-0.0268742386,
-0.0166689232,
0.0385818705,
-0.0485654138,
-0.014826633,
0.0243319962,
0.0315669775,
-0.0207331274,
-0.0507290959,
0.0100927604,
-0.0109751243,
0.0236132182,
-0.0276691802,
0.0527094305,
-0.043904867,
-0.0059842602,
-0.015545778,
-0.0997159109,
0.0352406874,
-0.0466764346,
-0.0271826014,
0.0586294532,
0.1128464341,
-0.0152562475,
0.0501228347,
-0.0496039204,
0.0442635939,
-0.005258868,
0.0292687695,
0.0670332387,
-0.0201037191,
-0.036958281,
0.0366897397,
-0.012488775,
-0.0056485576,
0.0204086676,
0.0066175405,
0.0435847752,
-0.0052137445,
0.0165142175,
0.1098297909,
-0.0001381165,
-0.0185673442,
-0.0395595282,
0.0895782262,
-0.0172771737,
-0.0137708392,
0.0417786762,
-0.0120726209,
-0.041006241,
-0.0208239369,
-0.0013117398,
-0.0107200993,
-0.0496321321,
-0.0408886001,
0.0386012718,
-0.0641180947,
-0.04715221,
0.017048033,
0.0334878676,
-0.0177516397,
-0.0060940892,
0.026300244,
-0.0377117507,
0.0286402348,
-0.0262673367,
0.0495214835,
0.0014605635,
-0.0246712063,
-0.0136538558,
0.0309659559,
0.0231879074,
-0.0264894795,
0.0536613204,
-0.0084674964,
-0.063435182,
-0.0069011319,
-0.0031159306,
0.0138397636,
0.0074458881,
0.0879458115,
-0.0045771389,
-0.0107467789,
-0.040023908,
0.0810031146,
0.0107342992,
-0.0082249073,
-0.020036906,
-0.027478151,
-0.0044392319,
0.0085745202,
-0.0400273167,
-0.0174533147,
-0.0130886286,
-0.0250657592,
0.0285631027,
-0.0342097245,
-0.0028952854,
-0.0093301507,
2.671e-7,
0.0221810844,
0.0513494909,
-0.0137563124,
-0.0226501934,
-0.0179554503,
0.0536265448,
-0.0380781554,
0.0491089895,
0.0132151758,
0.0051026745,
0.0123397941,
-0.0169195738,
0.1036196947,
-0.0064916234,
-0.1016850695,
-0.0270465761,
0.0130541241,
0.0390440412,
-0.0301065296,
0.0126367528,
0.0498531535,
0.0439539477,
-0.0296534132,
0.0146980528,
0.0207419377,
-0.0362030752,
0.0199598223,
-0.0684879571,
-0.0175744761,
0.0268948954,
0.0624495298,
-0.0081721582,
0.0196985323,
0.0364044122,
-0.0468618423,
-0.0435265712,
0.0732296035,
0.0691038892,
0.0725791752,
0.0083558252,
0.0112189986,
0.0154401036,
-0.003421413,
-0.0372314416,
0.0324673913,
-0.0012430685,
-0.0276648607,
0.0321546607,
-0.0475795865,
-0.0123832347,
0.0491661318,
-0.0357294343,
-0.0447046719,
0.0119519746,
0.0411468968,
-0.0460686311,
0.0034707529,
0.0091403993,
-0.0337078087,
-0.0061430801,
0.0218760371,
-0.0152979717,
-0.0040688757,
-0.029620083,
0.0151027478,
-0.0788983256,
0.0122178039,
1.897594791e-34,
0.050822515,
-0.0213368367,
0.0388991535,
0.0049041142,
0.013006595,
-0.0160149895,
-0.0223821774,
-0.0340115353,
-0.0205370318,
-0.0415615328,
0.0180818662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14459v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14459v3 | Advancing Precise Outline-Conditioned Text Generation with Task Duality and Explicit Outline Control | 2023-05-23T18:33:52 | 2024-02-07T06:28:44 | Yunzhe Li, Qian Chen, Weixiang Yan, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Hari Sundaram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing works on outline-conditioned text generation typically aim to
generate text using provided outlines as rough sketches, such as keywords and
phrases. However, these approaches make it challenging to control the quality
of text generation and assess consistency between outlines and generated texts
due to lack of clarity and rationality of the rough outlines. In this paper, we
introduce a novel text generation task called Precise Outline-conditioned
Generation, which requires generating stories based on specific, sentence-level
outlines. To facilitate research on this task, we construct two new datasets,
WPOG and CDM. We provide strong baselines based on fine-tuning models such as
BART and GPT-2, and evaluating zero-shot performance of models such as ChatGPT
and Vicuna. Furthermore, we identify an issue of imbalanced utilization of the
outline information in the precise outline-conditioned generation, which is
ubiquitously observed across fine-tuned models and zero-shot inference models.
To address this issue, we propose an explicit outline utilization control
approach and a novel framework that leverages the task duality between
summarization and generation. Experimental results show that the proposed
approaches effectively alleviate the issue of imbalanced outline utilization
and enhance the quality of precise outline-conditioned text generation for both
fine-tuning and zero-shot settings. | [
0.0114593282,
0.0143899359,
0.0084273564,
-0.0138422335,
-0.0328145213,
-0.0158944149,
0.0112725357,
0.0036375129,
-0.0601250157,
-0.0302466471,
0.0208810698,
-0.0611148626,
0.0095431507,
0.0588297322,
0.0313198119,
-0.0828445852,
-0.0188865587,
-0.0165403429,
-0.0094348332,
0.017533144,
0.0302382819,
0.0206599645,
-0.0130593348,
0.0220262539,
0.0038705233,
0.0039608525,
-0.0188408736,
0.0138202943,
0.0375814922,
-0.0241999216,
0.0087503195,
0.0515402183,
0.011885413,
-0.0085278219,
0.0000018323,
-0.031829033,
-0.0129757226,
-0.0035508792,
0.038763456,
-0.0030803524,
0.0155689102,
-0.0405917987,
0.0140822129,
0.0016594238,
0.0182380844,
0.0456197746,
0.0304636713,
0.0898337588,
0.044869706,
0.0560408831,
-0.0232866164,
-0.0296916496,
-0.0260087475,
-0.0326801166,
0.0105703464,
0.0135750994,
-0.0235661659,
-0.0269031804,
-0.0077213137,
0.0092875529,
0.0225864686,
-0.0154859498,
0.0137005737,
0.0160678141,
0.027606694,
0.0679881424,
-0.0268582162,
-0.0026749431,
0.013569504,
0.0577270575,
0.0131683145,
-0.0293739196,
0.050679449,
-0.0408390425,
-0.001917496,
-0.0486853458,
-0.080310218,
0.0822930336,
-0.045386482,
0.0270913281,
0.0032707739,
0.0275628027,
-0.0111458832,
0.0171216018,
0.0141194277,
-0.0028092733,
0.0192964524,
0.0011511291,
-0.0462383777,
0.0289571621,
-0.0643891022,
-0.106053412,
0.0251183938,
0.0385517702,
-0.0130017484,
-0.0104394825,
-0.0976832956,
-0.0338693522,
0.023391718,
0.0164860412,
0.0745818764,
0.0196003672,
0.0014151627,
-0.0143038398,
-0.0242667422,
0.0304736141,
0.013802221,
-0.0351597592,
-0.0345620289,
0.033839874,
-0.018334629,
0.0005457609,
-0.0575794615,
0.0325042494,
-0.02786454,
-0.0217940491,
-0.030628575,
0.0167029928,
0.0372072905,
-0.0197448097,
-0.0176768713,
0.0235898923,
-0.0592957698,
-0.0072435657,
0.0123667857,
-0.0018379461,
-0.0789133906,
0.0012648295,
0.0594079867,
0.0276978761,
-0.0172301661,
0.0054031624,
0.0271441229,
0.0024556993,
0.002326502,
0.0077960803,
-0.0429352969,
-0.0153576639,
-0.035819985,
-0.0732665658,
-0.01796248,
-0.0678199157,
-0.0230453927,
-0.0584278181,
0.0067297248,
0.005322407,
0.002658987,
0.0092292838,
0.0123893796,
0.0248858891,
-0.0248924438,
-0.0026868372,
-0.020973241,
-0.0083806301,
0.0201282166,
0.0210412089,
-0.0142144486,
0.0580956005,
0.0687229857,
0.0625879988,
0.0071440344,
0.0393902622,
0.0063597825,
0.0068639079,
0.0090843085,
0.015433277,
0.0109111201,
-0.0289284345,
-0.0574540384,
0.0367981084,
0.0550138429,
0.0487036519,
-0.0375416838,
0.0457689613,
0.0779266879,
0.0360746868,
0.0335924253,
0.0385777168,
0.0913610905,
0.0020769311,
-0.0018319117,
0.0823392421,
0.00754106,
0.0063096285,
-0.0051768557,
0.0772415698,
0.0524891578,
0.0192751065,
-0.0167206656,
-0.0153114405,
0.0042835022,
0.0166176911,
-0.0114930235,
-0.0503080562,
0.0273533799,
0.033020325,
-0.0702558756,
0.0041060722,
0.0054914346,
-0.0829968899,
0.0300534312,
0.0012071021,
0.0405869558,
0.0392560028,
0.062583521,
0.0295430925,
-0.024403546,
0.0123603744,
0.0568892621,
0.0810171962,
0.0196259413,
0.0031070206,
0.0159789044,
-0.039430581,
0.0003743033,
-0.0491915494,
0.0137361502,
0.0128893433,
-0.0194379818,
-0.0055667115,
0.0267016422,
-0.0408259965,
-0.0232093427,
0.0435541756,
-0.0119102029,
0.0113597736,
0.0095489183,
-0.009469118,
-0.0510643423,
-0.0102957636,
-0.0265356116,
0.024295371,
-0.0047015068,
-0.0536671169,
-0.0084225349,
0.0012034395,
-0.0479243025,
-0.0115980906,
-0.045388367,
-0.048464112,
0.0453972332,
-0.0317939855,
0.0129630147,
-0.0778705776,
-0.0002685562,
-0.0050632046,
0.0019235278,
-0.0386945792,
0.0131833749,
0.0272454396,
-0.0123143932,
-0.0255675279,
0.0810541287,
0.0139125232,
-0.0027572184,
0.05222027,
0.014363762,
-0.0141796283,
-0.0572795086,
0.020589076,
-0.0077298381,
0.0266593676,
-0.0176963639,
0.038634114,
0.0296150986,
-0.038362816,
-0.0172905885,
-0.0682969987,
0.0380165577,
-0.011251647,
0.0014660984,
0.0643588752,
-0.0064247162,
-0.0303736459,
0.0364017375,
-0.0368577391,
0.0017654555,
0.038770467,
-0.0045910603,
0.0465232916,
0.0140748741,
0.0348644517,
-0.0173081327,
0.0093554407,
0.0210561231,
0.0165716391,
0.0643248111,
-0.0242212266,
-0.0575593226,
0.0883392543,
-0.0258257408,
-0.0244960524,
-0.0000767982,
-0.0041132495,
0.0253671706,
0.010798811,
0.0688915327,
0.0094536589,
0.029578276,
0.0087203244,
0.0465984009,
-0.0229852553,
0.0141130863,
0.002138657,
-0.0158381201,
0.063533172,
0.0282696057,
-0.0415841341,
0.052018594,
0.0711384639,
0.045347888,
0.015101878,
-0.0626671836,
0.008282694,
-0.0138071664,
-0.0158285834,
0.0088858791,
-0.0275277086,
-0.0088817449,
0.0267457608,
-0.0315746181,
-0.0342551358,
0.0444686376,
-0.0566792116,
-0.0027740921,
0.0077520069,
0.0206843689,
-0.0474329554,
0.03205809,
0.0379931293,
0.0433682725,
0.0578040034,
0.0026462025,
-0.0854038522,
0.0170354079,
0.0284323748,
0.0101442914,
0.0215459187,
-0.0402837545,
-0.0090218121,
-0.0326304697,
-0.0158327147,
-0.0229183622,
-0.0203947034,
0.0113867018,
0.0195918456,
0.0382907577,
-0.0250594355,
-0.0022117039,
0.0463581868,
0.0022702073,
0.0599650219,
-0.0336590335,
-0.0313767232,
-0.035258051,
0.0378613956,
0.0844448134,
-0.0372317396,
-0.0104392096,
-0.0775053725,
0.0234964304,
0.0496290289,
0.0243463796,
0.0117360521,
0.0266426653,
0.0123374267,
-0.0103768781,
-0.039257586,
-0.0187760442,
0.0260210969,
0.0885558873,
-0.0553885959,
-0.0593504608,
0.0841081217,
0.0143032111,
-0.0116202626,
0.002724617,
0.0100264773,
0.0650259927,
-0.0093261255,
-0.002656264,
-0.0741632283,
-0.0248478446,
0.0268136039,
0.0450614579,
-0.0341205783,
-0.047304865,
-0.0409854017,
-0.0661872402,
0.0322543532,
0.0288012456,
-0.0680743232,
-0.0104100434,
-0.0058920472,
0.0047113025,
0.0112720886,
-0.0066811433,
0.0117975129,
-0.0322782025,
0.0375296548,
0.0102496883,
-0.0295124948,
-0.0007251236,
-0.0272009838,
-0.0559408665,
-0.0095743341,
0.0424570553,
0.0213332418,
0.0082288301,
0.058615569,
0.014979152,
-0.055097688,
0.0058575058,
-0.0093505979,
0.0288858842,
-0.0020049717,
0.0080193048,
-0.0154237803,
0.0586993024,
0.034312848,
-0.0434953794,
0.0027885996,
-0.0094227241,
-0.0365272611,
-0.0633488894,
-0.0186000951,
0.0468613952,
-0.0021795989,
0.0806115419,
0.0637396947,
-0.0243477281,
-0.0479575023,
-0.020118339,
0.0010705226,
-0.1247160211,
0.0079765525,
-0.0136474287,
-0.0271915533,
-0.0071968124,
-0.0997995287,
-0.0524941385,
0.0515610464,
0.0475653931,
0.0043523577,
0.007257767,
-0.0427201837,
-0.0429953858,
-0.0151102152,
-0.0059561566,
-0.0292033702,
-0.0015769476,
-0.038521219,
-0.0455208048,
-0.0131001789,
-0.0705875233,
0.0003080144,
0.0674374104,
-0.0976496339,
-0.0611565299,
-0.0131660355,
0.0231356174,
0.026022695,
0.0104440311,
0.0206904318,
-0.0380856954,
0.0742259249,
0.0313412212,
0.0151353395,
0.0469637401,
-0.0250538532,
0.0215592738,
-0.0027295526,
0.0152819203,
-0.0368415713,
0.0109394891,
0.0016593027,
0.0797616988,
-0.0111572817,
-0.0208611805,
0.0147708459,
-0.0061463444,
-0.0230254494,
-0.0510470346,
-0.0178712718,
-0.0722484812,
-0.0462291948,
-0.03829531,
-0.0165479705,
-0.0590876602,
0.0281229727,
-0.0130347237,
0.0047910819,
0.0090856291,
0.0146438908,
-0.037054535,
0.0454675965,
-0.0643755198,
-0.0645376667,
-0.017747568,
-0.0139515726,
0.0117961261,
-0.0068039284,
-0.0295494441,
0.0051838537,
-0.0682703182,
0.0339418873,
-0.0246801991,
0.0561517887,
0.0300524626,
0.0073999818,
-0.0110053876,
0.0300205201,
-0.0559245646,
0.0350735374,
-0.0628034994,
0.0160327293,
0.0431795157,
0.0018610966,
0.083717607,
-0.0402927101,
0.0197265893,
-0.0005731616,
0.0511826202,
0.018366944,
-0.0432811305,
-0.0261034872,
0.0135697993,
-0.0003469382,
-0.028117884,
0.0946472436,
0.0360852443,
0.0360117741,
-0.0046598194,
0.0036196313,
-0.0155272195,
-0.0024782696,
0.0118493913,
0.0144140432,
0.025424784,
-0.0452453569,
-0.0403858051,
-0.0083048679,
0.0581144579,
0.0008152447,
0.0257126503,
-0.0134884687,
0.0374519564,
0.018825857,
-0.0135099515,
0.0067330734,
-0.0414920375,
-0.0008427993,
0.011149236,
0.015724197,
-0.0410069972,
-5.678464601e-33,
-0.0609367117,
-0.0349996537,
0.0113526685,
-0.0226388276,
-0.0597042367,
-0.0001782626,
-0.0540198311,
0.0085664624,
0.0714591816,
-0.0114332186,
0.0006760875,
-0.0196649916,
0.0065678116,
0.0333278626,
-0.0065002465,
0.0081618186,
0.0731241032,
0.006739662,
-0.080860883,
0.0402691774,
0.0496710837,
0.0168009438,
0.0206452776,
0.0602376722,
0.017043693,
-0.0809972882,
-0.0344759971,
-0.0236736815,
0.0330720805,
0.0257708244,
-0.0043150433,
-0.0135392155,
0.0407999605,
0.0179082919,
-0.0596554577,
0.0198897235,
-0.0420250595,
-0.0027705648,
0.0089561576,
-0.045839671,
-0.0501929894,
-0.0539983101,
0.031162966,
-0.0126407677,
0.0391339175,
-0.0275445208,
0.0263993498,
-0.0270101782,
-0.0035709257,
-0.0678553805,
-0.056177225,
-0.0098813549,
-0.0220549647,
-0.0582607128,
-0.0209614001,
0.0491390117,
0.0064736856,
-0.0201469976,
0.0023561113,
0.0288594887,
0.0259970836,
0.0188570172,
0.0123498579,
0.0344064496,
-0.0368980058,
0.0557016023,
-0.0132824667,
0.0242782664,
-0.0581413582,
0.0156405941,
-0.0138383992,
0.0202602465,
0.007012255,
0.0211338606,
0.0533382967,
0.028308183,
-0.0473395437,
0.0969719365,
-0.0095911026,
0.0090636285,
0.0299794767,
-0.0033508309,
0.001995482,
-0.0221793335,
-0.0333470777,
-0.0626157001,
-0.0254945047,
0.0020097673,
0.0179804806,
0.0443147235,
-0.011870929,
0.0089547588,
0.0206864662,
0.0406340845,
0.0364420675,
-0.0327787995,
-0.0652256906,
0.0346329883,
-0.0152372671,
-0.0048242589,
-0.0351929329,
-0.0225179959,
0.065757826,
0.0293301195,
0.0105031431,
0.0353389718,
0.0416967049,
-0.003162229,
-0.0220975913,
0.0155792935,
-0.0390623771,
0.0333400331,
-0.0037991756,
0.0098121101,
0.0061163981,
-0.0223547183,
-0.0164527372,
0.0436643809,
-0.0032013461,
-0.0140981674,
-0.0199938919,
-0.0025290528,
0.0069364356,
0.0398395918,
-0.0143732633,
0.0324745774,
-0.0156635772,
0.0079832692,
0.0448529832,
-0.0347272344,
-0.0272767842,
-0.0167410336,
2.412e-7,
0.0017347899,
-0.0012457062,
0.0265674256,
0.0448554195,
-0.0311340746,
0.0108918129,
-0.0092141433,
0.0342503116,
0.005429042,
0.0158059429,
0.0380542092,
0.0175430402,
0.0464437902,
0.0305801164,
-0.0806809813,
0.0120619666,
-0.0627455264,
-0.0067329044,
-0.062181294,
-0.0327960812,
0.0570379123,
-0.0241491534,
-0.0268322974,
-0.005875465,
0.0450732931,
-0.0386142544,
0.0749834031,
0.0109214988,
-0.01455878,
0.0203965325,
0.0147701576,
-0.0071893674,
-0.0297454335,
-0.0122594479,
-0.0113394996,
-0.0245314315,
0.0379017219,
0.0236863308,
0.0233976785,
0.0261932649,
0.0435321629,
-0.0172396358,
0.0051307362,
0.0037650603,
0.051835347,
-0.0485512018,
-0.0164226014,
-0.0018539736,
0.0027143352,
0.008050723,
-0.0377714001,
-0.0382723361,
-0.0569563471,
0.0210385043,
0.0123823145,
0.0155946808,
-0.0064834617,
-0.0212845169,
-0.044395566,
0.0351360068,
-0.0334356576,
-0.0168828107,
-0.0523005277,
-0.0117548201,
-0.0278543364,
-0.1119630858,
-0.0263503268,
2.518507896e-34,
0.0314279534,
-0.013059861,
-0.0234717913,
-0.0048886272,
0.0101438658,
-0.0124847265,
0.0158722159,
-0.0173339546,
-0.0080504902,
-0.0455033481,
-0.0360629298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14458v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14458v2 | Dancing Between Success and Failure: Edit-level Simplification Evaluation using SALSA | 2023-05-23T18:30:49 | 2023-10-22T18:25:46 | David Heineman, Yao Dou, Mounica Maddela, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (e.g., GPT-4) are uniquely capable of producing highly
rated text simplification, yet current human evaluation methods fail to provide
a clear understanding of systems' specific strengths and weaknesses. To address
this limitation, we introduce SALSA, an edit-based human annotation framework
that enables holistic and fine-grained text simplification evaluation. We
develop twenty one linguistically grounded edit types, covering the full
spectrum of success and failure across dimensions of conceptual, syntactic and
lexical simplicity. Using SALSA, we collect 19K edit annotations on 840
simplifications, revealing discrepancies in the distribution of simplification
strategies performed by fine-tuned models, prompted LLMs and humans, and find
GPT-3.5 performs more quality edits than humans, but still exhibits frequent
errors. Using our fine-grained annotations, we develop LENS-SALSA, a
reference-free automatic simplification metric, trained to predict sentence-
and word-level quality simultaneously. Additionally, we introduce word-level
quality estimation for simplification and report promising baseline results.
Our data, new metric, and annotation toolkit are available at
https://salsa-eval.com. | [
0.0135474121,
0.0084626535,
-0.0206543747,
0.0020227847,
-0.0089781759,
0.0092638703,
-0.0241003707,
0.0394952893,
-0.0276720505,
-0.0423569977,
-0.0384377018,
0.0592949912,
0.0507702194,
-0.0450453572,
0.0608365871,
-0.077121824,
0.0266333837,
-0.0077421083,
-0.0041898047,
0.0366849452,
0.0243750308,
-0.0071764085,
0.0194144938,
0.0626829714,
0.0071988115,
-0.0292471368,
0.0215059668,
0.016878562,
0.0011138368,
0.0217658002,
0.0237848833,
0.0927209035,
-0.0240213517,
0.0213791002,
0.0000020099,
-0.0167463403,
-0.0172544587,
0.0000314765,
0.0109392032,
0.1060002968,
0.0780985802,
-0.0296785999,
-0.025102105,
0.0057217046,
-0.0206632372,
-0.0073902193,
0.019117428,
0.0315731987,
0.0836919695,
0.0508870259,
-0.0269198939,
-0.0178314745,
-0.0386093557,
-0.0247219969,
0.0150600411,
-0.0033561261,
0.0162014198,
0.0001445965,
-0.0214720219,
-0.0002939418,
0.0062858867,
0.0283256043,
0.0131836636,
-0.0525279343,
0.0143119898,
-0.0077230996,
-0.0601535514,
-0.008879601,
0.0303015336,
0.0423187315,
-0.0234686546,
-0.0513642281,
-0.0012566595,
-0.0054848371,
0.0095251147,
0.0006139589,
-0.0501927175,
-0.0457735136,
0.0221042652,
-0.0063733035,
-0.0327627696,
-0.039575275,
0.0362152644,
0.0226909965,
0.0570588969,
0.0316418149,
0.0358616747,
-0.0116801746,
-0.0200902615,
-0.0064184391,
-0.0118225971,
-0.1049856022,
0.025314115,
0.0144446334,
0.0156639591,
-0.0378542393,
-0.0491989404,
-0.0497144684,
0.0269493461,
-0.0191631541,
0.0094843702,
0.0166957919,
0.0093724951,
0.0310340654,
-0.0352661051,
0.0465552993,
0.0226569064,
0.0053265747,
-0.0120390942,
0.0233018361,
-0.0033447852,
0.0240522996,
-0.0411739275,
0.0301655233,
-0.015840264,
-0.0001652905,
-0.0579122119,
-0.0026718283,
-0.0069585876,
-0.0304031689,
0.0008170094,
0.0019135566,
-0.0090654977,
-0.0501974374,
0.0062443754,
0.0459578298,
-0.0306653082,
0.0478346348,
0.0083182361,
-0.0339143611,
-0.0154078342,
0.0283145607,
0.0410328992,
-0.0139810722,
-0.0084216772,
-0.0302751437,
-0.0198099222,
-0.0134057933,
-0.0353683792,
-0.0233652871,
0.0367329083,
-0.0251824167,
-0.0380066261,
-0.0693282932,
0.011626347,
-0.010657832,
-0.0061807735,
-0.0681852847,
-0.0067305844,
0.0107199755,
-0.0207810663,
0.0481383316,
-0.0698278397,
0.0211345833,
0.020779172,
0.0065469369,
-0.0259234682,
0.0330310762,
0.0397330485,
0.0174420513,
0.0708464682,
-0.0206991788,
0.0770816356,
0.042521771,
-0.0034949966,
0.0149652399,
0.0378954634,
-0.0253811534,
-0.082146734,
0.0286256503,
0.0626659468,
0.0671784431,
-0.0620078743,
0.0101076039,
0.0924910754,
0.0290695895,
-0.0005390075,
0.0236902609,
0.0621056892,
0.0273243655,
0.0634870306,
0.0254565757,
-0.0406500101,
0.0016396901,
-0.0382225662,
0.0206300002,
0.0595497712,
-0.0315038636,
-0.0076354649,
-0.0517622158,
-0.0033208078,
-0.0071770344,
0.0298133884,
-0.0359738618,
-0.009718921,
0.0317735337,
-0.0507889017,
0.0198295172,
-0.0137192747,
-0.057886485,
0.0088113574,
-0.032451544,
-0.0000145986,
0.0628939942,
0.0509027764,
0.0032481197,
-0.0533683598,
-0.0363371409,
0.025719652,
-0.0066295434,
0.043837022,
-0.0386556499,
0.0188336708,
-0.0416021645,
0.0154592516,
-0.0025880453,
0.0550244823,
-0.0309314188,
0.0582057461,
-0.0741951466,
0.0330396742,
-0.0785529017,
-0.0545173772,
0.0359152406,
0.0288988911,
-0.0219407603,
0.0046289652,
0.0138062229,
-0.0003331581,
-0.0037292847,
-0.0154385353,
0.0173571538,
-0.0125248544,
-0.0124395518,
-0.0063133272,
0.0030305001,
0.0300611649,
-0.0367893241,
0.0361540765,
-0.0471010432,
-0.0350553803,
0.0482836515,
-0.0392966196,
-0.0164801739,
-0.024642719,
-0.0504437126,
0.0019270069,
-0.0599952675,
0.0585498549,
-0.0022592952,
0.0019025299,
-0.018717356,
0.0160158277,
0.0151668778,
0.0234916843,
0.0553455018,
-0.0230547208,
0.0129731046,
-0.0259438772,
-0.0109448917,
-0.068096891,
-0.0086082164,
-0.0032842509,
0.0386246741,
0.0532817431,
-0.0276698116,
0.0041683731,
-0.1073583066,
-0.0104379766,
-0.0252010021,
0.0301640984,
0.0587541908,
0.0230769571,
-0.014264022,
0.0014029859,
-0.0018514111,
-0.0223125275,
-0.0270783007,
0.0287689529,
0.0786447078,
-0.010821457,
-0.0237653609,
-0.0713310093,
0.0026920305,
-0.0073466264,
0.023003947,
0.0230344087,
-0.0281531699,
-0.0230751,
0.0093599642,
-0.0183646902,
-0.0318774804,
0.0519381091,
-0.0454616286,
-0.0394693762,
0.0092534134,
0.0662829876,
0.0762043446,
0.003064842,
0.0108405184,
0.0205530431,
0.0277029481,
-0.0321342535,
-0.0133991018,
0.0222176444,
0.0022794101,
-0.0022069118,
-0.0511004031,
0.0470731705,
0.0591952614,
-0.0090502501,
0.0041745063,
-0.0622348785,
0.0209755134,
-0.0213281624,
-0.0133148199,
-0.051005017,
-0.0155913532,
-0.0251230784,
0.0377169959,
-0.0324428268,
-0.0479739718,
0.0494234413,
0.0117811188,
0.0093510132,
-0.0163458027,
0.0062967665,
-0.0188080091,
0.0077894316,
-0.0201106314,
0.008010379,
-0.0017707433,
0.0024723294,
-0.0516136959,
0.0023874496,
0.0396713242,
-0.0189590603,
0.0392258056,
-0.0966320634,
0.0048848819,
-0.0263724178,
-0.0563281663,
0.0145339323,
-0.0482087694,
-0.019461181,
0.0003624557,
0.0610732175,
-0.0142505337,
0.0022263848,
-0.0141075375,
0.012728923,
0.0920229182,
-0.0313941874,
-0.0269900635,
0.0049637072,
0.0155684669,
0.0365283862,
-0.0078125782,
0.0322873332,
-0.0447891206,
0.0141528351,
0.0163968839,
0.0024535279,
-0.0195507165,
0.0040430021,
-0.0089689819,
-0.0068491851,
-0.0507107377,
-0.0378454439,
0.0361300409,
0.0403219201,
-0.0617730804,
0.0204211306,
0.095965676,
0.0179214366,
-0.0236587655,
0.0110236341,
-0.0182518028,
0.0251375176,
0.0008881332,
0.0242783632,
-0.0639160722,
-0.0405277982,
0.0328829326,
0.0197390988,
0.0339852683,
-0.0115547897,
-0.0027970355,
-0.0337578207,
0.0574951135,
0.0029144858,
-0.036426466,
-0.0310784876,
-0.0302541684,
0.0400581025,
-0.0235164165,
-0.0240070075,
0.0391911417,
-0.0386923477,
0.0227344576,
-0.0388878845,
-0.0828168839,
-0.0453089401,
-0.0073383874,
-0.0370888934,
0.0119260577,
0.0129024945,
0.0439330079,
0.0241041165,
-0.0348962471,
0.0667342022,
0.0310952459,
-0.0129062897,
-0.0208672378,
0.0468359962,
0.0156148542,
0.0327439234,
-0.017523611,
0.040702574,
0.0089066736,
-0.0160781238,
-0.000940787,
0.061807327,
0.0138621079,
-0.0202788655,
0.0259671956,
-0.0105346469,
-0.0422139317,
0.0647103414,
0.0850609764,
-0.0012878085,
-0.0402013734,
-0.0297548063,
-0.0245898943,
-0.0598544702,
-0.0612724349,
-0.0200161543,
-0.0322194956,
-0.064498812,
-0.0996329635,
-0.042820178,
0.0652336925,
-0.0156455822,
0.0289022587,
0.0026547252,
-0.0108699901,
-0.0011478646,
-0.0089349924,
-0.0058382968,
-0.0049905432,
0.0351757146,
-0.0320670344,
-0.0004300378,
-0.0220401864,
0.0270384699,
-0.0053252387,
0.0538733117,
-0.0926729068,
-0.0413393937,
-0.0142558124,
0.0546981171,
0.0232845452,
0.032442864,
-0.0077874409,
-0.0800589696,
-0.0286901612,
0.0282254629,
-0.030160144,
0.0549558289,
0.0446542799,
0.0094717061,
0.0129657714,
0.0683750436,
-0.0332678892,
-0.0179320592,
-0.0145303244,
0.033543475,
-0.0169281699,
-0.045077689,
0.0118214153,
0.0402740575,
0.0237508211,
-0.0281606019,
-0.0097499359,
-0.0259668324,
0.0000204428,
-0.0619177483,
0.0006948005,
-0.0199697018,
0.0229502004,
0.0037128106,
0.0246254578,
-0.0515782312,
0.0634460896,
-0.0065926216,
0.0032749032,
-0.0188923478,
-0.0042082234,
-0.0287942607,
-0.0284266919,
-0.0030674257,
-0.0118526556,
-0.013818074,
-0.0149359088,
-0.0265974067,
-0.0021168701,
-0.0206839293,
-0.0037162148,
-0.0049361517,
0.0333454385,
-0.0290079489,
0.0500626899,
-0.015093171,
-0.0230549574,
-0.0190330241,
0.0345050767,
0.0477744862,
-0.0016522398,
0.1108691767,
-0.0269101635,
-0.0628990829,
-0.0261165295,
0.0488984175,
0.0008306296,
0.0075017409,
-0.009995833,
0.0138485357,
-0.0117236087,
0.0175929796,
0.0854822248,
-0.0632732585,
0.0482178293,
-0.0217164271,
-0.0259787664,
-0.0296288952,
-0.0187454838,
-0.024600843,
0.0357879885,
-0.0090068467,
-0.0489323139,
-0.074260056,
-0.0546837337,
-0.0117203994,
0.0274132248,
-0.0081753749,
-0.0239687618,
0.0187792294,
0.0475363359,
-0.0343074836,
-0.0283600036,
-0.0453025661,
-0.0277036335,
-0.0001242296,
-0.0197291579,
-0.0407567881,
-6.152212335e-33,
-0.0000302567,
0.005414329,
-0.0073858718,
-0.0075129126,
-0.0326665901,
0.0212146956,
-0.0821067989,
0.0055686934,
0.0250031017,
0.0471680574,
-0.0382186286,
0.0343796499,
0.0046302141,
-0.0298146866,
0.0135345785,
0.0501876287,
0.0987455398,
0.0131968036,
-0.0490115546,
-0.0065919566,
-0.0448704176,
0.0030601453,
0.0186271369,
-0.0626028925,
0.0175465588,
0.0249469075,
-0.069044359,
0.0051564495,
0.0259254407,
0.0453399681,
-0.0026266833,
0.0022101391,
0.0132773519,
-0.0296112206,
-0.0234454181,
-0.0182356015,
-0.0443154275,
-0.0032671436,
0.0532010235,
-0.0194932148,
-0.075118877,
-0.0777503401,
0.0846540853,
-0.0034230126,
-0.0332677104,
-0.0166298673,
0.0222246759,
-0.0375584848,
0.0165872239,
-0.0465863347,
-0.0591184236,
0.0438844264,
-0.0146757821,
-0.0376071446,
-0.0054726284,
0.0254927464,
-0.036616385,
-0.0090783779,
-0.0378286503,
0.0203294363,
0.047550898,
0.0601256192,
0.0531371832,
-0.0491396338,
0.0040202336,
0.0185850207,
0.0064431536,
0.0217189789,
-0.008109035,
0.004197347,
0.004529621,
0.0314350165,
0.0632147416,
0.0601887926,
0.0079028001,
0.0086606378,
-0.0101088034,
0.0696499571,
-0.0198284984,
0.0309824664,
-0.0465107709,
0.0293348506,
-0.0018170876,
-0.0065966044,
-0.0350745879,
0.0313471183,
-0.01408563,
-0.0190426856,
0.0011531748,
0.009385678,
-0.0238905568,
0.0020520813,
0.0069669075,
-0.0046869656,
0.0028592886,
0.007548938,
-0.0376449116,
0.0431549065,
0.0225143973,
-0.04760262,
0.0090029128,
0.0513189323,
0.0236698426,
0.0417646952,
0.0467973016,
-0.0115482919,
0.0628596097,
0.0333128087,
-0.0772797987,
0.004006613,
0.0219406802,
-0.0110732662,
0.0004203835,
-0.0333930962,
0.0098544089,
0.030862553,
0.004170544,
0.0115998201,
0.0203063898,
0.0051063178,
-0.022423977,
0.0397996828,
0.0410426408,
0.014251871,
-0.0041610831,
0.0159340035,
-0.01595724,
0.0061459052,
0.0333046503,
-0.0282276981,
-0.0378175788,
-0.0046342141,
2.594e-7,
0.0865114853,
0.0839864686,
0.0268787593,
-0.0064770523,
0.0098458827,
0.0229874961,
0.0272992365,
-0.0232206378,
-0.0062286989,
0.0304181539,
0.0611250512,
-0.0187669657,
0.0483579822,
-0.0031912285,
-0.0718851537,
0.0136765977,
-0.0377284326,
-0.0215307511,
-0.0288824644,
-0.0605886877,
0.024537079,
0.0409454554,
0.0093010375,
0.0053100791,
0.0000060547,
-0.0034586049,
0.0495591201,
-0.042058561,
0.0054009142,
0.0397197567,
0.0552630238,
-0.0239844043,
0.0097159361,
-0.0131086363,
-0.0464829579,
-0.0206770282,
0.0437752344,
0.1124230623,
-0.0398121551,
0.0797924921,
-0.0143599128,
-0.0746118575,
0.0065391804,
-0.0675036833,
0.0683887899,
-0.0359106138,
0.0145844901,
-0.0011583061,
-0.0278933588,
0.0281764865,
0.027527269,
-0.0102369869,
-0.0525919795,
0.048283603,
0.01306313,
0.0246914364,
-0.0325261131,
-0.045938205,
-0.059293028,
0.0024796757,
0.0110539142,
-0.0213499237,
-0.0302490126,
0.0024652528,
0.0121285198,
-0.0580413677,
0.0062706177,
2.223208792e-34,
0.0448628329,
-0.005082909,
0.0286929403,
-0.0056116502,
0.0566768236,
-0.019257918,
-0.0246832222,
-0.0026047947,
0.0013652077,
-0.0415585712,
-0.0150700686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16337v2 | Handling Realistic Label Noise in BERT Text Classification | 2023-05-23T18:30:31 | 2023-10-20T11:26:43 | Maha Tufail Agro, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Labels noise refers to errors in training labels caused by cheap data
annotation methods, such as web scraping or crowd-sourcing, which can be
detrimental to the performance of supervised classifiers. Several methods have
been proposed to counteract the effect of random label noise in supervised
classification, and some studies have shown that BERT is already robust against
high rates of randomly injected label noise. However, real label noise is not
random; rather, it is often correlated with input features or other
annotator-specific factors. In this paper, we evaluate BERT in the presence of
two types of realistic label noise: feature-dependent label noise, and
synthetic label noise from annotator disagreements. We show that the presence
of these types of noise significantly degrades BERT classification performance.
To improve robustness, we evaluate different types of ensembles and
noise-cleaning methods and compare their effectiveness against label noise
across different datasets. | [
0.0576631501,
0.0431276113,
0.0092395572,
0.0250293259,
0.0188694149,
0.0029962554,
-0.0000272219,
0.0191264004,
0.0060094614,
-0.0775074288,
-0.0333968736,
-0.0154455127,
0.0148075009,
-0.0479555354,
0.0063611274,
-0.039380122,
0.0067881565,
-0.0006672656,
0.068627432,
-0.0130637093,
0.0176054332,
-0.0350662097,
0.0235367026,
0.0347289219,
-0.0215813722,
0.0115107745,
0.0128357215,
0.0308735687,
0.000544259,
-0.0049145264,
0.0559548251,
0.0843286365,
-0.032450337,
0.0625192821,
0.0000015471,
-0.0524793752,
-0.022042824,
0.039229311,
-0.0006233937,
0.0322512761,
-0.0391854234,
0.0751338229,
-0.0148966219,
0.0315270536,
0.0184728019,
0.0030290431,
0.0351209678,
0.0694666207,
0.0580447838,
0.0461837389,
-0.0046230741,
0.0265000332,
-0.010041656,
0.0147645259,
0.029996369,
-0.0197108574,
0.0543172397,
-0.0601573251,
-0.0201652329,
0.0042337133,
0.011124705,
-0.0096654966,
-0.0228229389,
0.0029965513,
0.0507173538,
0.0308588836,
-0.1058079749,
-0.0220505334,
-0.0039786813,
0.0709939525,
0.0337063931,
-0.0149369938,
0.0098601691,
0.0101948855,
0.0308765508,
0.0087399185,
0.0259027593,
0.0136815961,
-0.0254695173,
0.0253346413,
-0.0476142839,
0.0053236238,
0.0240298919,
0.0120918946,
0.0026837487,
0.0343180299,
0.0014002877,
-0.0794309527,
0.0207104161,
0.0361563303,
-0.0091181649,
-0.0562189743,
0.0153536908,
0.011360595,
-0.0092165982,
-0.0031924001,
-0.0814145282,
-0.0966438949,
-0.004705173,
-0.0692802817,
-0.0153993284,
-0.0171725806,
-0.061484497,
0.0193666983,
0.017690789,
-0.0010313586,
0.0470107272,
0.0164946355,
0.0033516954,
-0.0065844427,
-0.0364818946,
0.0292560011,
-0.0603304021,
0.07123404,
0.0124646891,
-0.0015457239,
-0.0388468057,
0.0070719859,
-0.02689231,
0.0173220374,
0.0014134507,
0.003749897,
-0.0102070905,
0.0292004738,
-0.0014580284,
-0.0157258864,
0.0009708208,
-0.0019449351,
-0.037705332,
-0.0119431522,
0.0087860664,
0.026003005,
0.0019387144,
-0.0284275468,
0.0217191726,
0.0451254211,
0.0291048437,
-0.0398947373,
-0.0404972173,
-0.0027801108,
-0.0502592288,
0.030102754,
-0.0261925813,
-0.0079260767,
-0.031622164,
-0.0166289229,
-0.0051567927,
-0.013540417,
0.0095178327,
-0.0153281931,
-0.0557194687,
0.0747068226,
-0.0696308017,
-0.0184376873,
0.0640734285,
-0.0128805069,
-0.0011719615,
0.0355811678,
0.0392593369,
0.0016293051,
0.051341176,
0.0137820402,
0.0343395211,
0.0516112484,
0.031717658,
-0.0099157095,
-0.0201362241,
-0.0305900797,
0.0223002769,
0.0085033597,
-0.0302917417,
0.0572199374,
-0.0253041554,
-0.012979852,
0.062167123,
0.0015811579,
-0.0238687638,
0.0092725744,
-0.0522153042,
0.015917303,
0.0431773327,
0.0095794108,
-0.0194860566,
-0.0266500209,
-0.0928476378,
-0.0192663129,
0.0707993209,
-0.0175629947,
-0.0191200227,
-0.0434668027,
-0.0450326316,
-0.0104546146,
-0.0215555336,
-0.0201899502,
0.0520614907,
-0.0111920154,
-0.0197580848,
0.0459600799,
0.0337617211,
-0.0400324836,
-0.0040130839,
-0.0412167236,
0.0290791709,
0.0748197585,
0.0370323434,
-0.057788413,
-0.0293498635,
-0.0302308425,
-0.0051005897,
0.0311553981,
0.0208105743,
-0.0225348361,
-0.0041615278,
-0.0522625633,
-0.0846820772,
0.0511885211,
0.0150936181,
-0.0143686421,
0.0143875089,
-0.0156840701,
-0.0290848538,
-0.0653915405,
-0.0489944629,
0.0460041352,
0.0405762605,
-0.0363369696,
0.0394082107,
0.0217103176,
0.0345463678,
0.012889768,
-0.0619207583,
-0.0093076341,
0.0009711375,
0.0155212926,
-0.0131364726,
0.0001184944,
0.0322627835,
-0.023537159,
0.0597353205,
-0.0080212289,
-0.0460358709,
-0.0050645792,
-0.0336693153,
-0.0042637899,
-0.0501128435,
-0.067619212,
0.0152768064,
-0.0516487285,
0.0175969098,
-0.0265873298,
-0.0027104479,
-0.0366143361,
0.0551203825,
0.0108993473,
0.0357965603,
-0.0227620229,
0.0044953609,
0.0459038615,
-0.0208392572,
-0.0408088975,
-0.0240148455,
-0.0131585198,
0.0323119573,
0.0396868512,
-0.0139318332,
-0.0277226735,
-0.0170629974,
-0.0684892312,
-0.040945366,
-0.0181895141,
0.0025888521,
-0.0016697005,
-0.0303557627,
-0.0057853656,
-0.0091192368,
-0.0187645275,
-0.0341333002,
-0.0520496666,
0.0121338582,
0.0403482318,
-0.037342377,
-0.0143420883,
0.0131096812,
0.0092202621,
-0.0245152432,
0.0513948947,
0.0164636057,
-0.0621942468,
-0.0738809705,
-0.0172253158,
-0.0200179536,
0.0409080721,
0.0423619673,
-0.0393088087,
0.0001060246,
0.0066081043,
0.0114550628,
-0.021209592,
0.0194040574,
0.0429118201,
0.0339790732,
0.0096104164,
-0.0237823091,
0.0177062377,
0.0161311626,
0.0572767295,
-0.0082469573,
-0.0535538532,
0.0111705558,
0.0462486446,
-0.0365591347,
-0.0098695736,
-0.0531383902,
-0.0339338854,
-0.0084359962,
-0.0289619751,
-0.058108598,
-0.0261255652,
-0.0347978771,
0.0345797874,
-0.0166272335,
-0.0192321669,
0.0726394802,
-0.0219447166,
0.0245400406,
-0.0507947318,
0.016419854,
0.0364648253,
0.0048991879,
-0.0171919633,
0.016292803,
0.0655221641,
-0.0321853682,
0.0007508527,
-0.0427619442,
0.0538145415,
-0.0416840576,
-0.011791802,
-0.0337401517,
0.0452889092,
0.0103775319,
-0.0210806858,
-0.0556540862,
-0.0409262218,
0.0123507921,
-0.0030334438,
-0.0024367808,
-0.054041937,
-0.0415319949,
-0.0019835501,
0.014024199,
0.0248055831,
-0.0021839729,
-0.022055205,
0.0307605565,
0.0940262452,
-0.0099938056,
-0.0107165147,
0.0004161854,
-0.0426267534,
-0.0409424528,
0.0150901126,
0.0241157915,
0.0213962439,
-0.017056236,
-0.0201401096,
0.0188480318,
-0.0321389511,
-0.0326879472,
0.0260350388,
0.0277721696,
-0.018619325,
-0.0286091082,
0.1091772914,
0.0308792423,
-0.0019859045,
-0.0216577761,
0.0036366398,
0.0538684055,
-0.0013189112,
0.0190419201,
-0.0050138789,
-0.0166031327,
0.0306012388,
0.0421769954,
-0.0115812477,
-0.0097328564,
0.0248010345,
-0.1024920195,
0.0392902531,
-0.0070904326,
-0.0561032966,
-0.0077107637,
-0.059686292,
0.0184376705,
-0.0046404121,
0.0220346749,
-0.0299514085,
0.0403526276,
0.0266302563,
0.0754210055,
-0.0666291714,
-0.0699033886,
-0.0286381207,
-0.0260497257,
0.0665700361,
0.0420736484,
0.0300704315,
-0.0692453012,
-0.0617554113,
0.0510005131,
0.0268745013,
-0.0466856398,
-0.0001200453,
0.1159861684,
0.0043930826,
-0.037844386,
-0.0186319947,
-0.0218105987,
-0.003253516,
-0.0005749792,
-0.0256706476,
0.0382119007,
-0.0155691868,
0.0000588797,
-0.0158731788,
-0.0112349251,
0.012917988,
0.0755712837,
0.0329754092,
-0.0699366778,
-0.0157412216,
-0.0265020411,
0.0041109975,
-0.0493266061,
0.0353663266,
0.0741698667,
-0.0606363676,
-0.1369146258,
-0.088853009,
-0.0825024396,
0.0228539295,
0.0301020239,
0.0259799473,
-0.0055191363,
0.0103848064,
0.0373709537,
-0.0356106833,
0.0089693051,
0.0215043873,
0.0123260608,
-0.0217147507,
-0.0187917147,
0.0254280511,
-0.0095690386,
-0.0429257005,
-0.0004832969,
-0.0153493071,
-0.0643406436,
0.0338889472,
0.0197827406,
0.0128321443,
0.0315811969,
-0.0210912284,
-0.0751243159,
0.0542551056,
0.1172136739,
0.0383125842,
-0.0235824697,
0.0487889536,
-0.0121402694,
-0.0094753746,
0.0205794144,
-0.0558131747,
0.0090810349,
0.0194970928,
-0.0011579487,
-0.0394584611,
-0.0403028764,
0.0080287196,
0.0313769057,
0.0614994131,
-0.0316448919,
-0.0307432692,
-0.0183793269,
0.019435985,
0.0335636586,
-0.0220872816,
-0.0067096683,
-0.0032422766,
0.0033284798,
-0.0264385249,
-0.0415173136,
0.0827407166,
-0.0155839352,
0.0278250165,
-0.0045121931,
-0.0225094948,
-0.0152524142,
0.0778262168,
0.0219300371,
0.0001968298,
-0.005993471,
0.0010560257,
0.0756940097,
0.0226535648,
0.0225675926,
-0.0293184537,
0.0490593277,
0.0211108997,
0.031863559,
-0.0113031203,
-0.0515247546,
-0.0012361207,
-0.0659608617,
0.0549945682,
0.0130896401,
0.0059235464,
0.0127467094,
-0.0055152122,
-0.0248303227,
-0.0141309956,
-0.0155201666,
0.018277185,
0.0285107419,
0.0098625906,
-0.0087855877,
-0.0223725531,
0.0040651415,
0.0631178021,
0.0031805795,
0.0513045639,
-0.0188682582,
-0.0272558797,
-0.0482333042,
0.0203950349,
0.0380629599,
0.0006674557,
-0.0347884148,
-0.0017757789,
0.0034562596,
-0.0373046398,
0.0620520934,
-0.0152364261,
0.0392419025,
0.011587739,
0.0191450566,
0.0476506986,
-0.0046885028,
0.0298462864,
0.0127750607,
-0.0146299638,
0.0387685001,
-0.0162871983,
-0.0147333294,
-5.529720852e-33,
0.0105201211,
-0.0335842408,
-0.0563715957,
-0.0270513911,
-0.003134744,
-0.0140754236,
-0.0079864012,
-0.0118713919,
0.0087631885,
0.0504825749,
-0.0022877243,
0.0265078619,
0.0150765078,
0.0165089015,
0.0237962026,
-0.0234036073,
0.0593049042,
-0.0091385022,
-0.0188901927,
0.0066440245,
0.0265925601,
0.0535518378,
0.0493718497,
-0.0997219011,
0.0461966135,
0.0241219774,
-0.0207220092,
0.0173666365,
0.0396338739,
0.023843389,
-0.0093043977,
0.0444838814,
0.0014483151,
0.0325617678,
0.007121312,
-0.0048477589,
-0.065962024,
-0.024505455,
-0.0534884669,
0.0369678289,
-0.0001693132,
-0.0023891875,
0.0960684866,
0.0046228608,
-0.0411467552,
0.0155450096,
0.0834167823,
-0.0308938324,
-0.0378356688,
-0.0682111681,
-0.0168229043,
0.028803613,
-0.0182108879,
-0.0208167937,
0.0208675619,
0.0143213216,
0.0128779477,
0.0333260298,
-0.0545427166,
0.0039005564,
0.0249214862,
-0.0068925917,
-0.0313299187,
0.0173871536,
-0.0160678141,
0.0435270369,
0.0124425907,
0.0212463327,
0.0034098229,
-0.0649186969,
0.021295093,
0.0213832296,
0.0412501246,
0.036099311,
0.023563236,
0.008388604,
-0.0806153417,
0.0848605856,
0.0086557316,
-0.0612879619,
-0.006523666,
-0.0031660271,
-0.0390208699,
0.0042141145,
0.0153987128,
-0.0345799997,
-0.0318748541,
0.0452388413,
-0.0198517516,
-0.023283476,
-0.0344509222,
-0.0056007626,
-0.0230549145,
-0.0377774872,
-0.0598864891,
-0.0153564001,
0.0102765094,
0.0133803543,
0.0075921807,
-0.0124900499,
0.0010180239,
-0.0299502555,
0.0236137304,
0.0586322099,
-0.0002998585,
-0.0061761993,
0.07721176,
-0.0021584921,
-0.0736180246,
0.0207970012,
-0.0094121434,
0.0033998063,
0.0105322236,
0.0254772101,
0.0050990735,
-0.0119826728,
0.021397043,
0.0028254059,
0.0213394202,
0.0614967979,
0.0125709996,
0.0158849899,
-0.0168631822,
-0.011716608,
0.0189688616,
-0.0281421077,
0.0132987583,
0.0324236341,
-0.0026887427,
-0.0270888377,
0.0153148398,
-0.0490928106,
2.315e-7,
0.0296017453,
0.0848586634,
0.0274363402,
-0.0521547645,
0.0097450903,
0.0570972972,
-0.0525569059,
0.0256713815,
-0.0113434745,
-0.0270488355,
0.0304099806,
-0.0470843464,
0.0369384326,
0.0418154337,
-0.0383456722,
-0.0672728345,
-0.0737862512,
0.0124945892,
-0.0190974344,
0.0401509665,
0.0740774646,
0.0654459298,
0.0544323847,
-0.0379522592,
0.0246772934,
-0.0353325419,
0.0462793708,
-0.01536474,
0.0213204771,
0.0376510657,
0.0381610058,
-0.0045220787,
0.0135126999,
0.027971467,
-0.0486904047,
-0.0094995536,
0.0095241787,
0.003734302,
-0.0449983999,
-0.0076158489,
-0.021564275,
0.010191353,
0.027440317,
-0.0019301997,
0.0118564116,
0.0149482498,
-0.0087943543,
0.0079718065,
-0.0443137437,
-0.0378202237,
0.0541010946,
-0.0099610249,
-0.0140579678,
0.0018757046,
-0.0119002061,
-0.0024823686,
-0.0193596948,
-0.0885262713,
-0.0045417454,
-0.0261674728,
-0.0299799424,
-0.0312533975,
0.0252837073,
0.0073818057,
0.0399894007,
-0.0546188056,
0.0417723581,
1.662085646e-34,
0.0577186793,
-0.0169824846,
-0.008526382,
0.0187936984,
-0.0260141436,
-0.0017984689,
0.0251971688,
-0.0379633345,
-0.0020272241,
0.0006381863,
0.015317345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14457v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14457v4 | Pre-training Language Models for Comparative Reasoning | 2023-05-23T18:28:42 | 2023-11-28T05:54:11 | Mengxia Yu, Zhihan Zhang, Wenhao Yu, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Comparative reasoning is a process of comparing objects, concepts, or
entities to draw conclusions, which constitutes a fundamental cognitive
ability. In this paper, we propose a novel framework to pre-train language
models for enhancing their abilities of comparative reasoning over texts. While
there have been approaches for NLP tasks that require comparative reasoning,
they suffer from costly manual data labeling and limited generalizability to
different tasks. Our approach introduces a novel method of collecting scalable
data for text-based entity comparison, which leverages both structured and
unstructured data. Moreover, we present a framework of pre-training language
models via three novel objectives on comparative reasoning. Evaluation on
downstream tasks including comparative question answering, question generation,
and summarization shows that our pre-training framework significantly improves
the comparative reasoning abilities of language models, especially under
low-resource conditions. This work also releases the first integrated benchmark
for comparative reasoning. | [
0.0354891643,
0.0687087253,
0.0236138962,
0.0057318322,
-0.0222172383,
0.0523758382,
0.0138822645,
-0.0125299282,
-0.0113138072,
-0.0797537416,
-0.007917597,
-0.0144014619,
-0.0244992338,
-0.0249020886,
0.0302778799,
-0.0556267351,
0.0055345469,
0.0048523927,
0.0162518658,
0.003610299,
0.0269102529,
0.0285114795,
-0.0149610061,
-0.0165321026,
0.0410734899,
0.0137124127,
-0.0043992945,
0.0058946139,
0.0499952435,
-0.0593950897,
0.0121898819,
0.0546358898,
0.0560778901,
-0.0128772706,
0.0000019835,
-0.0578616485,
-0.0184794031,
-0.0028053576,
0.0135445641,
0.0021663408,
0.0236509722,
0.0217337925,
0.0376216322,
0.01396186,
-0.0477901362,
-0.0571893081,
0.023789579,
0.0316806622,
0.0402369127,
0.0492800027,
-0.0209377222,
-0.027215207,
-0.0304870699,
-0.0195873063,
-0.02213067,
-0.0337513424,
-0.0108091049,
0.0481874943,
0.0052318503,
0.0410845838,
0.040485952,
0.0205505248,
0.0218946561,
0.0168657992,
0.0266801417,
0.0303923972,
-0.0186205041,
0.0266397558,
0.0141162667,
0.087734893,
-0.0053568161,
-0.0649523661,
0.0423480943,
-0.0169115849,
-0.0201756675,
-0.0264106318,
-0.0065078228,
0.0395755693,
-0.0091407206,
0.0335220844,
0.016863538,
0.0466137975,
-0.0041635707,
0.0375936888,
-0.0564170144,
0.0379116647,
0.0183550976,
-0.0146748358,
0.017943494,
0.0029792588,
-0.0220279694,
-0.0750170574,
0.0206321534,
0.0557685867,
-0.0467665456,
-0.0036977334,
-0.0409424193,
-0.0268423315,
0.0035220978,
-0.0342141241,
0.0204383936,
0.0055107726,
0.0136861885,
0.0683246404,
-0.0404762253,
0.027982017,
0.0043653161,
0.0248540491,
-0.0521896407,
-0.0162027366,
-0.0626813844,
-0.0096384138,
-0.0363873392,
0.0360964574,
-0.0275550783,
0.0123819802,
-0.0258945357,
-0.0054311026,
-0.0097077042,
0.0032087264,
0.0148933325,
0.0235937908,
-0.0084873652,
-0.0018333317,
-0.0750275925,
-0.0344598778,
-0.0900234878,
0.0020482289,
0.0072681587,
-0.0394391976,
0.0041675866,
-0.0033088855,
0.0232288688,
-0.0604601614,
0.0182397682,
0.0396178178,
-0.0087824017,
-0.0000760593,
-0.0554882921,
0.0018773688,
0.0463382713,
-0.0431297794,
-0.004986078,
-0.0858973563,
0.0506357141,
0.0251896512,
-0.0297165625,
-0.0150337946,
0.0134390686,
0.046297837,
-0.0259984657,
0.0525312014,
-0.0179856494,
-0.0010840682,
0.0250537042,
-0.0064963475,
0.0213556644,
0.0449076593,
-0.0070459628,
-0.044588916,
0.0228367206,
0.0148090841,
-0.0425365642,
-0.013544891,
0.0068472885,
-0.0217637103,
-0.0215890463,
0.0675824732,
-0.0361913592,
0.0524280667,
0.0215310138,
0.0712379515,
-0.0327325165,
-0.0160549972,
0.0366510302,
0.0461402088,
-0.0225260817,
-0.0283190105,
0.0271704178,
0.0150397681,
-0.0150444917,
0.0354221724,
-0.0126820188,
0.0417341664,
-0.0089413179,
0.0039528711,
0.0277395006,
0.0215919949,
-0.0479949117,
-0.0463660471,
-0.0232580211,
-0.0001063559,
0.0159756374,
0.0287064873,
0.0105163902,
0.0466741882,
-0.0333542675,
0.0685279891,
0.0390707888,
-0.065888904,
-0.0234099608,
-0.0363334231,
0.0106028263,
0.0248815995,
0.0269341543,
-0.0306743663,
-0.0177841317,
0.0133278035,
-0.0099344086,
0.0320376866,
0.0770064965,
-0.0139888898,
-0.01218969,
-0.0400860831,
0.0034082115,
-0.0470740944,
0.0048145731,
0.0110210134,
0.0587833934,
0.0232283603,
0.0662240982,
-0.0549045689,
-0.0428019017,
0.0454728529,
-0.0068970821,
-0.0399416909,
-0.0139357392,
0.0310564097,
-0.0341283493,
-0.0037277089,
-0.0065939929,
0.043496415,
-0.0063947253,
-0.0276668947,
-0.0441926196,
0.0142430272,
-0.0392615497,
-0.0589627326,
0.0090194792,
-0.0257811062,
-0.0170799699,
0.0228565857,
-0.0631167367,
-0.0361587889,
-0.0272213127,
-0.0012672629,
0.0642446578,
-0.0331074446,
0.0133739673,
0.001211997,
-0.0425079353,
-0.0618967377,
0.1182253063,
0.0130257066,
0.0584742539,
0.0174658559,
0.0125531908,
0.0287031643,
-0.028314827,
-0.0550899245,
0.0186856613,
0.0098550031,
-0.0131418705,
0.021192234,
-0.0009079588,
-0.0594987087,
0.0257155094,
-0.0901535153,
0.0302089937,
-0.0036061567,
0.0263027046,
0.060131859,
0.0087054754,
0.0221656337,
-0.0100878812,
-0.0626013577,
0.0080726678,
0.0336621515,
0.0465377234,
0.0915283263,
-0.0189495888,
0.0466279536,
-0.0743784979,
-0.0162249431,
-0.0221504197,
0.0606270395,
0.0215456095,
0.0248687472,
-0.0186894462,
0.0698463321,
-0.0867704079,
0.0136433309,
0.0311583243,
-0.0120108211,
0.0234052911,
-0.0268811714,
0.047414504,
0.0798146054,
0.030607678,
-0.008939066,
0.0670018643,
0.0006914276,
-0.0613400564,
-0.0060241958,
-0.0030408646,
0.0302199312,
0.0022901238,
-0.0221537501,
0.0131585188,
0.0523483269,
-0.0111779664,
-0.025513541,
-0.0324821472,
0.0354056545,
-0.0243352465,
0.0210510381,
-0.0588388368,
0.0103765037,
0.0298933312,
0.0563204661,
-0.0355267935,
0.0140766613,
0.1038280204,
-0.0082941623,
0.0285155606,
-0.0466541685,
0.0135924965,
-0.0747941285,
0.0696256757,
0.0352663621,
0.0200970285,
-0.026367249,
0.0011668185,
-0.0632332042,
0.0093947733,
0.0471033007,
-0.0107898479,
0.0414917655,
-0.0454417169,
0.0188079663,
-0.0167183615,
-0.0488475822,
-0.0328980982,
0.0052390844,
-0.0415576883,
-0.0119265039,
0.01745083,
0.008626394,
-0.0115105519,
0.0407162048,
-0.0324626677,
0.0564296618,
0.0040478287,
-0.0200339314,
-0.0013768283,
0.0553302281,
0.0305164512,
-0.0114214206,
0.0547462106,
-0.0106488243,
0.0337450877,
0.043266464,
0.0629888028,
-0.0452376381,
-0.0291397721,
-0.0088667097,
-0.0064935852,
-0.085512206,
0.0024582045,
-0.0253583696,
0.0442164764,
-0.0402214117,
-0.0056235087,
0.148328647,
0.0588320866,
0.0101819756,
0.0103262952,
0.013056282,
0.0451236777,
0.0352250449,
0.0379861258,
-0.0545330457,
-0.0340968445,
-0.0236127358,
-0.0029929536,
-0.0195735972,
-0.0495934635,
-0.0113886809,
-0.1269891113,
-0.0264659915,
-0.0325166881,
-0.0297496039,
-0.0017498021,
-0.0119335288,
-0.0060056834,
-0.008162424,
-0.0493511632,
0.0145576419,
-0.0197289009,
0.01986962,
-0.0121221701,
-0.0068898215,
-0.0235149153,
0.0357179642,
-0.0488712639,
0.0184014924,
0.0199429728,
0.0613718443,
0.0234040953,
-0.004269924,
0.0253223591,
-0.0442746505,
0.0025582914,
-0.0082374904,
0.0590147376,
0.0028210713,
-0.0014648574,
-0.0506999791,
0.0073740245,
0.0077061965,
-0.0101495078,
-0.0028078398,
-0.0226670019,
0.0286031272,
-0.0377027243,
-0.0069745625,
0.0184529852,
-0.0129905129,
0.0853375196,
0.0285866763,
-0.0168350711,
-0.0524213053,
-0.0142314481,
-0.0396375023,
-0.0625001863,
-0.0084482701,
0.002631027,
0.0325807333,
0.0080244327,
-0.1089185178,
-0.0489207916,
0.0250264294,
-0.01336955,
-0.0162646193,
-0.0474254154,
0.0118995998,
-0.0226755012,
-0.0800924227,
0.0310692098,
-0.0051295473,
0.0139847258,
-0.0169246085,
-0.0328026563,
0.0393662937,
0.0121006696,
-0.0487705357,
-0.025606459,
-0.1012313887,
-0.0556696281,
-0.0364578888,
0.0374458916,
0.0160769112,
0.0333026946,
-0.0172217339,
-0.0381464213,
-0.0063496344,
0.0138753094,
-0.0547033176,
-0.0095797209,
0.0204782188,
0.0107598053,
0.020033963,
0.0333258696,
-0.0265281089,
0.0319500007,
0.0214857142,
0.0298318192,
-0.0185511466,
-0.0217091981,
0.0333966725,
0.0151348002,
0.0018177419,
0.033335533,
0.0021820972,
-0.0533517748,
-0.0105719185,
-0.0197963174,
-0.0626067668,
-0.0087704202,
-0.0004050455,
-0.0249920711,
0.0321246237,
-0.0338228866,
0.0290021878,
0.0036743586,
0.0307739861,
-0.0128981005,
0.0122396173,
0.0247560572,
0.0236095674,
-0.0010764342,
-0.0254299883,
-0.0635323748,
0.0121964738,
-0.0095696673,
0.0688396394,
-0.0271627381,
0.0712142661,
0.0242396593,
-0.0082950303,
0.024470767,
0.016527012,
-0.1050125062,
-0.0249272864,
0.0052390988,
-0.0035020343,
0.0187964607,
-0.0464430489,
0.042757906,
0.0125287985,
-0.0039172801,
0.021721743,
0.0085658813,
-0.007272135,
-0.0243623834,
0.0098847691,
0.0139096901,
0.0052333036,
0.0307252184,
0.0696624517,
0.003572392,
0.0254857261,
0.0271659251,
-0.0099108331,
-0.0323956981,
-0.0332762562,
-0.0183810592,
0.0125734331,
0.0054416386,
0.0132038966,
-0.0217716228,
-0.0529715568,
-0.0340353101,
0.0312569886,
-0.0054988191,
0.0292054154,
0.0608495809,
0.0334783085,
0.0123268021,
-0.0062494273,
-0.027017083,
0.0234936122,
-0.0353066474,
-0.0227964465,
-0.0620479509,
-6.451258465e-33,
-0.0251109414,
-0.0324381515,
0.0195345711,
-0.0437995344,
-0.0044216365,
-0.0032808627,
-0.0376197174,
-0.0401893668,
-0.0338316858,
-0.0002309094,
-0.0016525507,
0.0215386469,
-0.0041530496,
0.0231173262,
-0.0047515081,
-0.0206287112,
0.0232374128,
0.0215542763,
-0.0354440995,
0.0004865681,
0.0212674774,
0.0304326601,
0.0255661588,
-0.0129319709,
-0.0043536508,
-0.0292700678,
0.0112975575,
0.0331127569,
-0.0050131488,
0.0266641695,
-0.0033261452,
-0.0161377713,
0.0369507074,
-0.0157213695,
0.0077385926,
0.0240235403,
-0.087280564,
-0.0225491896,
0.0229518767,
-0.0230892617,
-0.0221952796,
0.0035269642,
-0.0162049066,
-0.0344494209,
0.0377613194,
-0.0230216924,
0.0611451678,
-0.0224691462,
0.0302740447,
-0.0420132726,
-0.0622174963,
0.0461640507,
-0.0355211981,
0.0221980941,
-0.0153607968,
0.0691686124,
-0.0167377926,
0.0299254376,
-0.0544759706,
0.04216085,
0.0197306368,
0.0149004981,
0.0274344329,
-0.0037110036,
-0.0134243835,
0.0582584143,
-0.0259894393,
-0.0233747512,
-0.039134331,
0.0357153751,
-0.0200029053,
0.0426981226,
0.0202497169,
0.0238623228,
0.0682220832,
0.0121074552,
-0.0586144142,
0.027669996,
-0.0150120882,
0.010544166,
0.0154647641,
-0.0144274132,
-0.0162383206,
-0.0104241837,
-0.0694148615,
0.0035821979,
-0.0697963834,
-0.0118782427,
0.057255879,
-0.0155131556,
-0.0415480882,
-0.027650686,
-0.0250470676,
-0.0302968621,
-0.0358600803,
0.0064028902,
-0.0011651681,
-0.0123747718,
-0.0200792421,
0.0376328528,
-0.0378274284,
-0.0071858228,
0.0381155349,
0.0060200365,
0.017085908,
0.0123232063,
0.0427156948,
-0.0267322399,
-0.057006415,
0.0040430645,
-0.0388657153,
-0.0053387228,
-0.0795495734,
-0.008529623,
0.0056770882,
0.0421475954,
0.0010269611,
0.0415919684,
0.0349041335,
-0.0470246263,
-0.0572096705,
-0.0033645751,
0.0245777704,
0.0466855578,
0.011489694,
0.0206238125,
-0.0285789743,
0.0134753352,
-0.00861008,
-0.0383043401,
-0.0151728839,
0.0363057703,
2.596e-7,
0.0433854833,
0.0572835058,
0.0256156679,
0.0294539481,
-0.0256363004,
0.0168008003,
0.0232907478,
0.0189418588,
0.0244646352,
0.0127063515,
0.0043236227,
0.0608945675,
0.0300644394,
0.0422531441,
-0.0499342345,
-0.0441115536,
-0.0933581963,
-0.0626545176,
-0.0495560393,
-0.0600597039,
0.1060209647,
0.042474024,
0.0124609433,
0.0059816712,
-0.0181603245,
-0.0186271071,
0.064963989,
-0.0163906571,
0.012643869,
0.0268017557,
0.0131652914,
0.0382646099,
-0.0125143202,
0.048844561,
-0.0089627365,
0.0058298223,
0.0269385036,
0.0324493721,
0.0157887843,
-0.0228419229,
0.0063930242,
-0.0275522787,
0.0074143978,
-0.0734114274,
0.108371377,
-0.0708365664,
0.0026502551,
0.0103556877,
-0.024202574,
0.0102804005,
0.0072926856,
-0.0190318413,
-0.0517425276,
0.0208024923,
0.0262203664,
-0.0092062633,
-0.0083911587,
-0.1028049812,
-0.0480828173,
0.050392203,
0.0150667029,
-0.0193131324,
-0.037527997,
-0.0076464163,
0.0094822142,
-0.0336788818,
0.0071555534,
2.291756873e-34,
0.0160033274,
0.0283266492,
0.0025051269,
-0.0337491408,
0.0602706224,
0.0213253461,
-0.0213843882,
-0.0383075662,
0.0176676791,
-0.0468054041,
0.0199469551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14456v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14456v4 | Having Beer after Prayer? Measuring Cultural Bias in Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T18:27:51 | 2024-03-20T17:16:37 | Tarek Naous, Michael J. Ryan, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As the reach of large language models (LMs) expands globally, their ability
to cater to diverse cultural contexts becomes crucial. Despite advancements in
multilingual capabilities, models are not designed with appropriate cultural
nuances. In this paper, we show that multilingual and Arabic monolingual LMs
exhibit bias towards entities associated with Western culture. We introduce
CAMeL, a novel resource of 628 naturally-occurring prompts and 20,368 entities
spanning eight types that contrast Arab and Western cultures. CAMeL provides a
foundation for measuring cultural biases in LMs through both extrinsic and
intrinsic evaluations. Using CAMeL, we examine the cross-cultural performance
in Arabic of 16 different LMs on tasks such as story generation, NER, and
sentiment analysis, where we find concerning cases of stereotyping and cultural
unfairness. We further test their text-infilling performance, revealing the
incapability of appropriate adaptation to Arab cultural contexts. Finally, we
analyze 6 Arabic pre-training corpora and find that commonly used sources such
as Wikipedia may not be best suited to build culturally aware LMs, if used as
they are without adjustment. We will make CAMeL publicly available at:
https://github.com/tareknaous/camel | [
0.0453646742,
0.0696094781,
-0.0319705456,
0.0261766557,
-0.0388014317,
0.0662716553,
0.0805353746,
-0.0474532321,
0.0021549114,
-0.0451168418,
-0.0179832019,
-0.0986716226,
0.0234985445,
0.0131084369,
0.0432849415,
-0.0346917175,
0.0250960998,
-0.0133689689,
0.0323753245,
-0.0269354414,
0.0371073149,
0.0540867597,
-0.0080147637,
0.0401404984,
-0.0264083836,
-0.0062155346,
0.0276165344,
-0.03293477,
0.0349032171,
-0.0074647549,
0.0128059462,
0.0469074249,
-0.0193402488,
0.0053682239,
0.0000022065,
-0.0823150724,
-0.0114885028,
-0.0390331112,
0.021474814,
0.0239390265,
0.0859362334,
-0.0410850532,
-0.0199209433,
-0.0087361429,
-0.0283912253,
0.0098683927,
0.0425756313,
0.0594138391,
0.0194409154,
0.0494535975,
0.0130474949,
-0.0252863299,
-0.0647957474,
-0.0291693769,
-0.0080879927,
0.0122709144,
0.0138384132,
0.002501477,
-0.0511418544,
-0.0280478802,
-0.0412643403,
0.0238313377,
0.0188648719,
0.013415481,
-0.0045132022,
0.0005454422,
-0.0510037653,
-0.038193576,
0.0414338149,
0.0214317162,
0.0319639258,
-0.0150029697,
0.0112122912,
-0.0039403983,
-0.0083218832,
0.0082603842,
-0.0004711869,
0.0627733991,
-0.0149628911,
0.0053761965,
0.06057119,
-0.0069759493,
0.0068484596,
0.0352043547,
-0.0042748512,
0.0621124767,
0.0338070802,
-0.0257431958,
-0.013375177,
0.0502363518,
0.0017395478,
-0.0685283914,
0.0048297546,
-0.0077345581,
-0.0536895543,
-0.0069997138,
-0.0304704234,
0.0378684178,
0.0244972035,
-0.0584055111,
0.0157187898,
0.0715736598,
0.0015862846,
-0.0077571985,
-0.0156916901,
0.0254607089,
0.0143993804,
-0.0239599682,
-0.0409432054,
-0.0204108171,
-0.0175114125,
0.0177238677,
0.0342122614,
0.0119094159,
-0.0583960414,
0.0256888494,
-0.0843695626,
0.0143549321,
-0.0314346887,
0.0026045272,
-0.0037413875,
-0.0169398338,
-0.0032910546,
0.0077159866,
-0.0439862125,
0.0379655734,
-0.0492912643,
-0.0165619031,
-0.0579728819,
-0.0843759924,
0.0398508869,
0.0006887338,
-0.0253109448,
-0.0206663609,
0.0036807181,
0.0403935984,
0.0046824026,
-0.01958864,
-0.0699732304,
0.0154347289,
0.0023677333,
-0.0534285344,
-0.0073148319,
-0.0500545427,
0.0497364178,
0.0310232956,
0.0185903907,
-0.0340793058,
0.0109134642,
0.0309632421,
0.000333532,
0.006973194,
0.0464003794,
0.0300475992,
0.0911979228,
0.0076694693,
-0.0019298859,
0.0968064889,
0.0245305356,
-0.0069544022,
0.0452469103,
-0.0090304958,
-0.0251717214,
0.0221612398,
-0.0017826615,
-0.0031043342,
-0.0470552891,
-0.0273567084,
-0.001737298,
0.0314499103,
0.0129649788,
0.04410794,
-0.0104197655,
0.0120149273,
0.0646668524,
0.0323200673,
-0.0270380806,
0.0326074623,
0.056864474,
-0.0052259876,
0.0069533689,
0.0320789851,
-0.0498480499,
0.034773536,
0.0232406054,
-0.0143501665,
0.043642506,
0.1177439317,
-0.0359737575,
-0.0397989154,
0.0175587032,
0.0234905854,
0.0194732156,
0.0083003696,
0.0340546742,
-0.0166029632,
0.0064097769,
0.0261379331,
0.054942701,
-0.0448131226,
0.0346849337,
-0.0166545138,
0.0200016778,
0.0702581257,
-0.0064269747,
0.0193831343,
-0.0006470536,
-0.0028476964,
-0.005888206,
0.0915452838,
0.0635399669,
-0.0300183166,
0.0154125579,
-0.0338160247,
-0.0055455952,
-0.0140052866,
0.0159359481,
0.0127110826,
0.0311161708,
0.0770625174,
0.0183804128,
-0.0191215053,
-0.0380742662,
0.0236427188,
-0.073151052,
-0.0006426118,
-0.0207529236,
0.0186087824,
0.0027361931,
0.0349800661,
-0.0396457464,
-0.0183962081,
-0.0202596635,
-0.0415031388,
-0.0274854433,
0.0543677434,
-0.0817225724,
-0.0225984529,
0.0347115323,
-0.0353058018,
-0.0238442309,
-0.0045915265,
-0.0102139553,
-0.0299913026,
0.0827730298,
0.0191819612,
0.0350353606,
-0.0254655387,
0.0068446035,
-0.0406267904,
0.0024571456,
-0.0008033087,
0.0536894165,
-0.0242658481,
0.0327887572,
-0.0252004694,
-0.0089998227,
0.0367250033,
0.020852413,
-0.0538066737,
0.0338985324,
0.0153913712,
-0.0012361241,
0.0796465129,
-0.0150225395,
-0.0292008929,
-0.0180800222,
-0.0944102183,
-0.0025590085,
-0.0164609868,
0.0138187502,
0.0049816812,
0.0192544404,
-0.0377805196,
0.0095596891,
-0.0607209615,
-0.0577213019,
0.0211162679,
0.0507100224,
0.0179442037,
-0.0247177128,
0.0165767521,
-0.0152532626,
-0.0028518415,
0.0017431161,
0.0535896607,
0.0019263279,
-0.0258340854,
0.0047912207,
-0.0129678864,
-0.0659507439,
-0.0147881219,
-0.000168914,
-0.0137384599,
0.0318158492,
0.0468940958,
0.0528022945,
0.0670946762,
0.0381854214,
-0.0184812173,
0.0280397013,
0.0029960263,
-0.0387018807,
-0.0199988224,
0.0283252876,
0.0077431495,
-0.0072809481,
-0.106442526,
-0.0353723913,
0.0517513938,
0.0064843791,
-0.0066260332,
-0.0472905748,
0.0547613837,
-0.0753391758,
-0.0352504738,
-0.0059278775,
0.0059482665,
0.0131415511,
0.0669979602,
-0.0242342148,
-0.0459877439,
0.0443312526,
0.0006972292,
0.0078515727,
-0.0077916742,
-0.0018616406,
-0.0484369397,
-0.0077648438,
-0.0128655611,
0.0456080586,
-0.0059170248,
-0.0108749783,
-0.0690631047,
-0.0034803872,
0.0308850929,
-0.0143743381,
0.0367211439,
-0.0275189336,
-0.0374015272,
-0.0292913727,
-0.0341295078,
-0.0346332118,
0.0015137994,
-0.0292837452,
0.0045668003,
0.0382538214,
0.0078987926,
-0.0233563408,
-0.0120077729,
0.0406694934,
-0.0236257799,
-0.0236877855,
0.0079432027,
0.023691088,
-0.0426287167,
0.0535461307,
-0.0209881514,
0.0512982234,
-0.0233070645,
0.0139761884,
0.0122402422,
-0.013075687,
-0.0299924407,
-0.0054976312,
0.0189454705,
0.0121695176,
-0.0409903862,
-0.0151296388,
-0.036476694,
0.0493479744,
-0.0083710114,
0.0388838127,
0.1183748692,
0.021518793,
-0.0493424051,
0.0147122853,
-0.0111029083,
0.003694403,
0.0392082743,
0.0018070939,
-0.1439892948,
0.0236946624,
0.0181394443,
0.0029766161,
-0.042407006,
-0.046961531,
-0.0006724641,
-0.13256751,
-0.0181259066,
0.0016664447,
-0.0655568615,
-0.0486595407,
-0.0073200567,
-0.0138800126,
-0.029606102,
0.0187505949,
-0.0318265371,
-0.0039178431,
0.0343215391,
0.0186258778,
-0.0077745705,
-0.0796478242,
0.0240295492,
-0.0433049574,
0.0333422907,
0.0104003698,
0.0200009961,
-0.0043834145,
-0.0055395598,
-0.0244710501,
-0.0277124532,
-0.0102609126,
-0.0015831414,
0.009837579,
-0.018779669,
-0.0353662372,
-0.0417751782,
-0.0252447072,
-0.0147438543,
0.0085111288,
0.0054103909,
0.0469606929,
0.0162997246,
-0.0058138436,
-0.0096875736,
0.0216108393,
0.0206925776,
0.0845831931,
-0.0110690398,
-0.07387878,
-0.0102202808,
-0.0363860838,
-0.0370726623,
-0.0206480995,
-0.0417098254,
0.0028234397,
-0.0126459822,
-0.001142694,
-0.0572155491,
-0.0825970247,
-0.0171123017,
0.008212626,
0.0377548374,
-0.0062997732,
0.0013295856,
-0.0184257273,
-0.0096439915,
-0.0033446986,
-0.0215040315,
0.019484628,
-0.0111400299,
-0.0357941352,
0.000841014,
-0.0596423224,
0.0248132087,
0.0072872103,
-0.0419297777,
-0.0536914207,
0.0319149867,
0.0242888257,
0.0116615389,
0.0247936938,
0.0418820567,
-0.0494439341,
0.0541486219,
0.0054406044,
-0.0207559112,
0.0386485755,
-0.0114435488,
0.0365891717,
-0.0082233371,
0.049033992,
-0.0154803386,
0.0454604514,
0.0086675473,
0.0237658676,
0.0055905026,
-0.0371253341,
0.0067203348,
-0.0178825613,
-0.0398617424,
-0.0605290011,
-0.0384617373,
-0.0780040026,
-0.0163414814,
-0.031433247,
-0.0357080437,
-0.0045139734,
-0.0173729844,
0.0250795688,
0.0339316353,
-0.0036808699,
-0.0004914267,
-0.011693812,
0.0022356668,
-0.0467541628,
0.0102792457,
0.0294499435,
0.0323160216,
-0.0209425334,
0.0497484021,
-0.0070774746,
-0.0370950401,
-0.032362923,
0.0389531888,
-0.0406061821,
0.0703071058,
-0.0063887001,
0.0245095957,
0.0335944518,
0.019202698,
-0.0057939845,
-0.0042406432,
0.0133305574,
0.0263418537,
0.0762154087,
-0.0699321851,
0.075666897,
0.0242363829,
-0.0004962717,
-0.0176944863,
0.0246778838,
0.0164837446,
-0.0327131115,
-0.0020787334,
-0.0167227574,
-0.0266959164,
0.0051743123,
0.0670410171,
-0.0409219563,
0.0203270093,
0.0432012267,
-0.0219068155,
-0.0063156844,
-0.0165549293,
0.0213956814,
-0.0258497391,
-0.0405567065,
0.0104132518,
-0.0997137725,
-0.0764260069,
-0.0138386339,
0.004765565,
-0.0073049422,
-0.0273518935,
0.0022045022,
0.0873384401,
-0.0059335963,
0.0013132992,
-0.0824482366,
0.0041974084,
-0.0314236768,
-0.0177244749,
0.0096566984,
-6.742164664e-33,
-0.0212009475,
-0.0161469765,
0.0118680894,
-0.0126014911,
0.0144547541,
-0.0092188604,
-0.0113636628,
0.0283487048,
-0.0159432236,
0.0217108373,
-0.0070199911,
-0.004774211,
0.007676431,
-0.0185448714,
0.058853969,
-0.0020365715,
0.0413595103,
0.0019519097,
-0.0318779647,
0.0266353153,
0.0506623909,
0.0216538385,
0.0663544536,
-0.0545670204,
0.0473389067,
-0.0170381423,
-0.0033214919,
-0.0146637606,
0.0353769027,
0.0554532818,
-0.0460871048,
0.0752615184,
0.0304290969,
-0.0582862087,
0.0067893355,
-0.0074759214,
-0.0275493357,
-0.0291527584,
0.0444653966,
0.026225647,
0.0467854924,
-0.054495398,
-0.0306155123,
-0.0149978586,
-0.065405488,
0.0369918421,
0.0284587294,
0.0053901952,
0.0485536791,
-0.019234471,
-0.1074316129,
0.0233310591,
-0.0022917879,
0.0277601853,
-0.0298613384,
0.0476992987,
0.0215673931,
0.0101031801,
-0.0290287659,
0.0222200528,
-0.0240840875,
0.017449962,
0.0639135316,
-0.0087135034,
-0.0269202236,
0.0632495359,
0.0195491724,
0.0512699708,
0.0226650499,
-0.0141747296,
0.0437868498,
-0.0520561188,
0.0044849212,
0.125311017,
0.0272898003,
-0.0093804859,
-0.0600011759,
0.0266979244,
0.0396907851,
0.0108534861,
0.0322054848,
-0.0338591561,
-0.0117804045,
-0.0322190225,
-0.0077943206,
-0.0504911691,
-0.0235163178,
-0.0199536942,
0.0286671091,
0.0156781096,
-0.0075096362,
0.0264625233,
0.0337247923,
-0.0086243898,
0.0170220304,
0.0404670164,
-0.0259991139,
-0.0436050631,
0.0136751253,
0.016299475,
-0.08092428,
-0.0344985053,
-0.0066929362,
0.0180041548,
0.0246846434,
0.0024827786,
0.0098529877,
0.0245540868,
-0.0689022318,
0.0300179459,
-0.0381457768,
0.0307599623,
0.0056014722,
0.0146392239,
0.0183765478,
-0.0223916993,
-0.028236391,
0.0009524683,
0.0338731706,
-0.0330160633,
-0.0283826105,
-0.0398042202,
-0.0085405214,
0.020928679,
-0.0311591756,
0.0123524182,
-0.0466493778,
0.0200314838,
0.0320834666,
-0.0392024182,
-0.0087853028,
-0.0347028375,
2.989e-7,
0.0159667302,
0.0198811051,
-0.0230509471,
0.0374115631,
0.0087466324,
0.014552244,
0.0087019699,
0.0271288883,
0.0436824523,
0.0152571611,
-0.0363840722,
0.0154565759,
0.0584837049,
0.0503673553,
-0.0801128373,
-0.0364165902,
-0.0373710282,
0.0348757356,
-0.0424617045,
0.0161152072,
-0.0076902919,
0.0839333087,
-0.0232044235,
-0.01389689,
-0.0558484346,
-0.0440203063,
0.0568910949,
-0.0528179556,
-0.0335139781,
0.0108902045,
-0.00194908,
-0.0131607512,
0.0240887348,
0.0219960809,
-0.0273081325,
0.0204022545,
0.0292714611,
0.0638885498,
0.0420324951,
0.0041762753,
0.0144389952,
0.0121023348,
-0.0350674503,
-0.0892890543,
0.0571965538,
0.0384120606,
-0.0240844376,
-0.021274766,
-0.0101079447,
0.0022284698,
0.0575400852,
-0.0378431641,
-0.0206359997,
0.0187384486,
0.0292856004,
0.0082166204,
0.0195424724,
-0.0009407342,
-0.0119896969,
-0.0106737893,
0.0088831242,
-0.0617618673,
0.0040296325,
-0.0365897268,
-0.0199948307,
0.0149067668,
0.0246323403,
2.483505715e-34,
0.0429276153,
0.0094536487,
0.031772729,
-0.0075935815,
0.0583535507,
-0.0015613369,
-0.0377532281,
-0.0151041914,
-0.005618786,
-0.0147855412,
-0.007848422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14453v2 | On Robustness of Finetuned Transformer-based NLP Models | 2023-05-23T18:25:18 | 2023-11-08T16:46:20 | Pavan Kalyan Reddy Neerudu, Subba Reddy Oota, Mounika Marreddy, Venkateswara Rao Kagita, Manish Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based pretrained models like BERT, GPT-2 and T5 have been
finetuned for a large number of natural language processing (NLP) tasks, and
have been shown to be very effective. However, while finetuning, what changes
across layers in these models with respect to pretrained checkpoints is
under-studied. Further, how robust are these models to perturbations in input
text? Does the robustness vary depending on the NLP task for which the models
have been finetuned? While there exists some work on studying the robustness of
BERT finetuned for a few NLP tasks, there is no rigorous study that compares
this robustness across encoder only, decoder only and encoder-decoder models.
In this paper, we characterize changes between pretrained and finetuned
language model representations across layers using two metrics: CKA and STIR.
Further, we study the robustness of three language models (BERT, GPT-2 and T5)
with eight different text perturbations on classification tasks from the
General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) benchmark, and generation
tasks like summarization, free-form generation and question generation. GPT-2
representations are more robust than BERT and T5 across multiple types of input
perturbation. Although models exhibit good robustness broadly, dropping nouns,
verbs or changing characters are the most impactful. Overall, this study
provides valuable insights into perturbation-specific weaknesses of popular
Transformer-based models, which should be kept in mind when passing inputs. We
make the code and models publicly available
[https://github.com/PavanNeerudu/Robustness-of-Transformers-models]. | [
0.042205207,
0.0325049646,
-0.0127042802,
0.0170460176,
-0.0015252025,
0.011159353,
-0.0089712627,
-0.0093662683,
-0.0447654575,
-0.0715304613,
-0.0299232304,
-0.0086708069,
0.018429881,
0.0003150776,
0.0180202071,
-0.0842182338,
0.041711472,
-0.0077135903,
-0.0449884981,
0.0135141611,
0.0297851339,
-0.0111983428,
0.0038511525,
0.0662776902,
0.0320263319,
0.0058882209,
-0.0005728683,
-0.0061242352,
0.0287786275,
0.0266048573,
0.0382928364,
0.0950258821,
-0.0022247026,
0.0437551439,
0.000001876,
-0.0358577669,
-0.0307524242,
0.0015164001,
-0.0050513227,
0.0200748406,
0.0160015039,
-0.0336527266,
-0.0208118036,
0.033244241,
-0.0174586251,
-0.0116234282,
0.0458965525,
0.0959987566,
0.0882715285,
0.0629529282,
-0.0116810929,
-0.0291469637,
0.0476442575,
-0.0374857485,
-0.0562625304,
-0.0439858921,
0.0101283472,
-0.0398664549,
-0.0274592675,
-0.0043414738,
-0.0253705159,
0.0064396458,
0.0077177421,
0.0233041849,
-0.0397696309,
0.0423846655,
-0.0804173648,
-0.0417165421,
-0.0115037439,
0.0628417507,
-0.0650092363,
-0.0301744211,
-0.0050847912,
-0.002647859,
0.0103175044,
0.0408255644,
-0.0187457353,
0.0267278627,
0.011817188,
0.0148529662,
0.0074407649,
0.0017742325,
0.0084835263,
0.0185723752,
-0.0337543003,
0.0088164005,
0.0320826024,
-0.0352179185,
-0.0355833992,
0.0236207489,
-0.0341659337,
-0.0479668193,
0.0131222336,
0.0201410055,
-0.0056791287,
0.0066297394,
-0.0779745504,
-0.0300969239,
0.0040278523,
-0.0498523228,
0.0345938988,
0.0433344655,
-0.0394610651,
0.0058915373,
-0.0501464121,
0.0819447637,
-0.0053477478,
0.0587077923,
-0.0060985736,
0.0065106163,
-0.0550094917,
-0.0262443405,
-0.0757560059,
0.0498763397,
-0.0358372889,
-0.0134872906,
-0.0428147316,
0.0330988318,
0.0019282548,
-0.0307966936,
0.0199067257,
0.0022788383,
-0.0455762856,
0.0086209802,
0.0146692786,
0.0514198691,
-0.0446523428,
0.0119456109,
0.0107920738,
-0.0769564509,
-0.0181198362,
0.0028732715,
0.0135383345,
-0.0339824781,
-0.0074307662,
0.0280101541,
-0.0046211099,
-0.0652182251,
-0.0403229445,
0.0067122579,
-0.044548478,
-0.0580648854,
-0.0043185255,
-0.033006642,
0.0196441989,
0.0234060436,
0.020460574,
-0.0329483971,
0.0005180144,
0.0215325635,
-0.0317923836,
0.0675697476,
0.0009455986,
-0.0050259326,
0.0121455202,
0.0146559151,
-0.0036799619,
0.0504158475,
0.0537533797,
0.0052387151,
0.0424559526,
-0.0324107818,
0.0241368338,
0.0410281047,
-0.0135721248,
0.0009996585,
-0.0031768212,
-0.0257843938,
-0.0129443826,
-0.0042698248,
-0.0165844895,
0.0822705552,
-0.0382227451,
0.0109070437,
0.0834878832,
0.0279116854,
0.0315341726,
0.0362498462,
0.0138739301,
-0.0023812361,
0.0190383904,
0.0458564349,
-0.0522833541,
-0.0026187371,
-0.0576124452,
0.0029395092,
-0.0109315189,
0.03538578,
-0.0374147519,
-0.0161014888,
-0.0182115454,
-0.0050821118,
0.0232162979,
-0.0436994433,
0.0342092253,
0.0394380018,
-0.0461979881,
0.0864529461,
-0.0106033823,
-0.0749592856,
0.0244365875,
-0.0599051677,
-0.0101029025,
0.007398596,
0.0480158888,
-0.0095212739,
-0.0503517166,
-0.0150186634,
-0.0026045917,
0.0240072757,
0.057339374,
0.0090817912,
0.0030099775,
-0.0489812903,
-0.0222553648,
-0.006773368,
0.0285218563,
-0.0139405299,
0.0249171611,
-0.0015623627,
0.0257498119,
-0.0306476243,
-0.0128737921,
0.0519773364,
-0.0135147413,
-0.017152112,
-0.0050316402,
0.00140886,
0.0023303812,
-0.0017178099,
-0.0228252411,
0.0152329914,
0.0349494331,
-0.0153385671,
-0.0069838888,
0.0393718109,
-0.0282586478,
-0.0388781391,
0.0094895111,
-0.0021344179,
0.0184527896,
0.0654115826,
-0.0351405479,
-0.0432555526,
0.0002674736,
-0.0518652014,
0.0155393425,
-0.0379507355,
0.0454076976,
-0.0250814557,
0.0358266458,
-0.0324334279,
0.037962269,
0.0065241414,
0.0347967185,
0.0024081224,
0.0251973886,
0.0492888801,
-0.0063695046,
-0.08455538,
0.021969676,
-0.0352344289,
0.0157269165,
0.0560933165,
-0.0080725634,
-0.0225568954,
-0.0491767563,
-0.0671129152,
0.0057255533,
-0.0531926937,
0.0361032151,
0.0274522398,
0.0330140144,
-0.0169975236,
-0.0004674243,
-0.0027683924,
-0.006396465,
0.0206357408,
0.0283201337,
0.0387685858,
0.0017360464,
0.0142057789,
-0.0202995855,
-0.0181409027,
0.0063626873,
0.0590593889,
-0.0028612644,
-0.0409522392,
-0.0491810776,
0.0077163796,
0.0032143069,
0.0296941455,
0.0040286756,
-0.0842120424,
0.0137248794,
0.0208629537,
0.0987697616,
0.0443956889,
0.0487612858,
0.0676655397,
0.0003883988,
0.0080214189,
-0.0160294846,
0.0132871047,
-0.0501803495,
-0.049377691,
-0.036475528,
-0.0067921993,
0.0352979116,
0.0827828497,
-0.0012726573,
-0.018249061,
-0.0923031867,
0.0095481351,
-0.0390630029,
0.0265305061,
0.0256935563,
-0.0068840818,
-0.0480033383,
0.0201078877,
-0.0284653064,
-0.0232830681,
0.071433574,
-0.0413074605,
0.0036513365,
-0.0439570025,
-0.0003531991,
-0.0387795344,
0.0482206009,
0.0121135674,
0.0187628623,
0.0229083411,
-0.043410182,
-0.0608986914,
-0.0012775196,
0.0226194263,
-0.0448914357,
0.0495730005,
-0.0208068937,
-0.0033602184,
-0.0261731055,
-0.051215563,
-0.039518334,
-0.0496418215,
-0.0035853726,
0.0359621421,
0.0301240999,
-0.0146659939,
-0.0373041071,
0.0240381397,
0.0154627236,
0.0579221621,
-0.0540028289,
0.0042318897,
-0.0291774869,
0.0666573569,
0.0266137682,
0.0180976707,
0.0174524281,
-0.0339081548,
0.0142100453,
0.0239623059,
0.0028696265,
0.016423529,
-0.0302569699,
0.0257525053,
0.033730574,
-0.0488778166,
-0.0179977994,
0.0203738511,
0.0932009891,
-0.0534450263,
-0.0519933254,
0.0999477729,
0.0324053206,
0.0003812379,
0.0134322327,
0.0256800745,
0.0199520141,
0.0104687102,
0.0042980718,
-0.0311313011,
-0.040456526,
0.0153829055,
0.036969848,
0.0065108794,
-0.0209778696,
0.0244860202,
-0.1152142882,
0.0180192273,
-0.0227579363,
-0.0295318868,
-0.0320012346,
-0.0453356244,
0.0009964287,
-0.0173834413,
0.0446487628,
-0.0124838417,
-0.002259518,
0.00461938,
0.04892575,
-0.0356403477,
-0.0813217461,
-0.0054616854,
-0.0532553792,
0.0253225565,
0.0740676373,
0.0189966504,
-0.0475158766,
-0.043929603,
0.0680615529,
-0.0549022034,
-0.0071375081,
0.0316190906,
0.050976824,
-0.0011949711,
-0.0231872201,
-0.0111605283,
0.0113426242,
-0.0081751961,
-0.0187724605,
-0.0590483174,
0.0295879319,
-0.0006242279,
-0.0565406345,
-0.0130272377,
0.0028901147,
-0.0349333286,
0.0848365128,
0.0361140855,
-0.0427130572,
-0.0555557236,
-0.0128072994,
0.0338371433,
-0.0753015205,
-0.0136091392,
0.0215659924,
0.0072602988,
-0.0328527875,
-0.0795445964,
-0.0456989184,
0.0182358306,
0.0163276903,
0.0073419064,
-0.0134505164,
0.0105222473,
0.00545396,
-0.0310647227,
0.0414649248,
0.013806683,
0.0115080019,
-0.0742992088,
0.0045125247,
0.0624324679,
-0.00642775,
-0.0405307487,
-0.0128199616,
-0.0809896886,
-0.0585201271,
0.0219959542,
0.0531027801,
0.0255626701,
0.0146799199,
-0.0206705816,
-0.06432686,
0.0259423517,
0.0466164872,
-0.0311280228,
-0.0008603848,
0.0219568554,
-0.0511170253,
-0.0315184109,
0.0177326389,
-0.0415227897,
0.0135264415,
0.0052878312,
0.0594117865,
0.0118250418,
-0.0573580265,
0.0188245606,
0.007539066,
0.0542451441,
-0.0103445817,
0.0035786477,
-0.0111230994,
-0.0158035345,
0.0207652766,
-0.000431873,
-0.0364245921,
0.0067725927,
0.0276292972,
0.0040321732,
-0.0196354967,
0.0393653996,
-0.0362197682,
0.0472919233,
-0.0446851887,
0.011442964,
-0.0015858074,
0.0082476679,
0.0130911926,
0.0207116511,
-0.0272073038,
-0.0106948167,
0.0159697067,
0.004618749,
-0.0266538374,
0.0515199713,
0.0387762114,
0.0311786048,
0.0034585383,
0.0465262756,
-0.0733249262,
-0.0054268469,
-0.055670239,
-0.002961878,
0.0137328822,
-0.0102717048,
0.0296631884,
-0.0161481183,
-0.0149846077,
-0.031714458,
0.0145751815,
0.0080121877,
0.0031832401,
0.0292321146,
0.0062317136,
0.0030015921,
-0.0064733829,
0.0822817162,
-0.0023265106,
0.0454145819,
0.0063320743,
-0.0095462268,
-0.0374221504,
-0.0006039171,
0.0031120121,
-0.0028386174,
-0.0085007157,
0.0171552077,
-0.039027784,
-0.0479152724,
0.0375552885,
-0.0250511933,
0.0546603464,
-0.025306996,
0.0128539596,
0.0593875721,
-0.005931796,
0.0105939452,
-0.0329555348,
-0.0036037003,
0.0187057033,
0.0224523377,
-0.0233038105,
-6.363589361e-33,
-0.0290751681,
0.0163884144,
-0.0086062457,
-0.0066661569,
-0.0364285447,
-0.0102276225,
-0.0552757755,
0.0026202132,
-0.0071482928,
0.0136294784,
-0.0144708985,
0.001774831,
0.0018278569,
0.0379771851,
-0.0280973315,
-0.0383769348,
0.0630789399,
0.0079265768,
-0.0679561943,
0.0048811315,
0.000173789,
0.0235826708,
0.0636899918,
-0.0088348771,
0.0105098113,
-0.0070623923,
-0.0279488768,
-0.0073135882,
0.0016732226,
0.0646115988,
-0.0051252595,
0.0352651104,
0.0371775255,
-0.0509121083,
-0.0208190903,
0.0164321456,
-0.1005384773,
-0.0265695993,
0.0094990563,
0.0322397649,
-0.0225492362,
-0.0095358808,
0.0699745715,
-0.008799864,
-0.0180674456,
-0.0047961902,
0.0124835931,
-0.0026924049,
-0.0130357211,
-0.0590158887,
-0.0375969298,
0.0185927637,
-0.0017523083,
-0.0555456951,
-0.013993226,
0.0531577207,
-0.0170928296,
0.0339298286,
-0.041647315,
-0.0298821591,
0.0637227967,
0.0410563685,
0.020144593,
0.0059360033,
-0.0341277458,
0.0300056133,
-0.0250910837,
0.0186083727,
-0.0259309616,
-0.0394592434,
0.0477803908,
0.0440494344,
0.0645285696,
0.0219580568,
0.0281019602,
0.0013247629,
-0.0294755679,
0.04788699,
-0.0116532948,
0.0294818375,
0.0557729043,
-0.0065102223,
-0.0136760324,
-0.0175160859,
-0.065899156,
-0.0224530492,
-0.025397826,
0.0105031002,
0.0283087604,
0.0315354094,
-0.019005863,
0.0368212461,
0.0343682915,
-0.0268582664,
0.0300856289,
0.0055556721,
-0.0439789332,
0.0164342858,
-0.0046912115,
0.0508122183,
-0.0047541973,
-0.0261517186,
0.0420338698,
0.0056360918,
0.0011724705,
0.0034849944,
0.0413947664,
0.0283470545,
-0.0616641752,
0.0025321029,
-0.0076397718,
0.0296761375,
-0.0247993488,
0.0831831321,
0.0236631297,
0.0162999239,
-0.0118598994,
0.0195410494,
0.0203838684,
0.0219306406,
-0.0284144171,
0.0407506377,
0.0395013355,
0.0332678035,
-0.000869057,
-0.0183993913,
-0.0194319412,
0.0734337568,
0.0075726602,
-0.0704079494,
-0.0238209553,
0.0060285325,
2.662e-7,
0.0595025644,
0.0695261508,
0.0632357523,
-0.0214452129,
0.0045988406,
0.0288684238,
-0.0140434271,
0.0437060036,
0.0316444039,
0.0346631929,
-0.0183320735,
-0.0126706902,
0.0404091738,
0.0008846638,
-0.05248845,
-0.0362765007,
-0.0733160153,
0.0412883759,
-0.0289479084,
0.0123367002,
0.0813737735,
0.0943963826,
-0.0083277179,
0.0063646794,
-0.0103854686,
-0.0311428979,
0.0793850422,
-0.0034439529,
0.0145300068,
0.0295414366,
0.0361294597,
0.036094293,
0.0177474916,
0.0161170959,
-0.0397496857,
0.0362425447,
0.0260637384,
0.0368905179,
-0.0071333507,
-0.0324605331,
0.010826868,
-0.0229961667,
0.0109525444,
-0.0695214793,
0.0730558708,
-0.1086628139,
-0.0248742029,
0.0261303671,
-0.0576564446,
-0.0008782811,
0.0074239834,
-0.0427233167,
-0.0363360383,
0.0315681808,
0.0360560417,
0.0288093407,
-0.0310753658,
-0.1044974476,
-0.0121803628,
0.0072427536,
-0.0311634764,
-0.0268347543,
-0.0427201688,
-0.0527750589,
0.0389921665,
-0.0774630532,
0.011087182,
2.595027298e-34,
0.0385275781,
-0.013332434,
-0.0011390414,
-0.0109222811,
0.0272653606,
-0.0181491636,
0.0609835424,
-0.0049201245,
-0.0150737278,
-0.0655022413,
-0.0262390878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14450v1 | Is Information Extraction Solved by ChatGPT? An Analysis of Performance, Evaluation Criteria, Robustness and Errors | 2023-05-23T18:17:43 | 2023-05-23T18:17:43 | Ridong Han, Tao Peng, Chaohao Yang, Benyou Wang, Lu Liu, Xiang Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT has stimulated the research boom in the field of large language
models. In this paper, we assess the capabilities of ChatGPT from four
perspectives including Performance, Evaluation Criteria, Robustness and Error
Types. Specifically, we first evaluate ChatGPT's performance on 17 datasets
with 14 IE sub-tasks under the zero-shot, few-shot and chain-of-thought
scenarios, and find a huge performance gap between ChatGPT and SOTA results.
Next, we rethink this gap and propose a soft-matching strategy for evaluation
to more accurately reflect ChatGPT's performance. Then, we analyze the
robustness of ChatGPT on 14 IE sub-tasks, and find that: 1) ChatGPT rarely
outputs invalid responses; 2) Irrelevant context and long-tail target types
greatly affect ChatGPT's performance; 3) ChatGPT cannot understand well the
subject-object relationships in RE task. Finally, we analyze the errors of
ChatGPT, and find that "unannotated spans" is the most dominant error type.
This raises concerns about the quality of annotated data, and indicates the
possibility of annotating data with ChatGPT. The data and code are released at
Github site. | [
0.04283344,
0.0185634177,
0.0040043616,
0.07005281,
-0.0636550114,
0.0394029319,
-0.0113295987,
0.0100103943,
0.0270857904,
-0.0812097266,
-0.0471444987,
-0.0236910731,
-0.0171222966,
0.0129485847,
0.0090155583,
-0.0327556431,
0.0555225387,
-0.0181678478,
0.0264949407,
0.0262463577,
0.0234667771,
0.0112145012,
-0.0315993838,
0.0274075363,
-0.0076815984,
-0.0212731175,
0.0067105754,
-0.0044100778,
0.0160331447,
-0.0215050206,
0.0268217828,
0.0534370057,
-0.0296621546,
0.0482748784,
0.0000019076,
-0.0306086242,
-0.0257284753,
0.0130667109,
-0.0488430411,
0.0121178124,
0.0164123345,
-0.0019077649,
-0.0075594373,
-0.0119841071,
-0.0222075544,
-0.0523329601,
0.0386989936,
0.0506553352,
0.0296465494,
0.0901719928,
-0.0257042125,
0.0058977786,
0.0427382924,
-0.0237636287,
0.0360581279,
-0.0511674695,
0.0521475933,
0.0183838345,
0.0107197193,
0.0487328023,
0.0145595837,
0.040822655,
-0.0110192029,
0.0213157926,
-0.0167563558,
0.0607743897,
-0.0898122787,
-0.0160210393,
-0.0159792174,
0.0761570856,
0.0057808887,
0.0050947145,
0.0324862413,
0.0165355802,
-0.0235581715,
-0.0102065075,
-0.0459399074,
-0.0069946726,
-0.0328225084,
0.0145399887,
0.0151586467,
0.0146997301,
-0.0042754635,
-0.0188404415,
-0.016670756,
0.0186851639,
0.0207015444,
-0.0386140198,
0.0225767195,
0.0267094243,
-0.0471389592,
-0.0700680241,
-0.0072992737,
-0.0007055948,
0.0069246627,
0.0066423621,
-0.0314050615,
-0.0292122364,
-0.0031930432,
-0.016671773,
-0.0160718746,
0.0300258547,
-0.0486325175,
0.0665556565,
-0.001712034,
0.04693643,
-0.0184583142,
0.0166700669,
-0.0228210408,
-0.0355987735,
-0.0740401894,
-0.0194168128,
-0.0282683186,
0.0546421893,
-0.0196179785,
-0.0274451431,
-0.0299112592,
0.0035453551,
0.0089275083,
-0.0017091054,
0.0025572274,
-0.0427070148,
-0.0317684785,
0.0114825638,
0.0068538985,
0.0472830348,
-0.006879237,
-0.0064192475,
0.0087558255,
-0.0586073399,
-0.0116872881,
0.0119623756,
0.0198850278,
-0.0615467429,
0.0140771363,
0.0885167643,
0.0043678791,
-0.0636363178,
-0.01384666,
-0.0072551654,
-0.0407259092,
-0.0778301582,
0.0255862791,
-0.0591610707,
0.0547947921,
0.0104723573,
-0.0215832144,
0.0111819105,
-0.0012074508,
0.0126797957,
-0.0529140458,
0.0795763507,
-0.0205946397,
0.002882143,
0.000272922,
0.006721905,
-0.0332644992,
0.0796192959,
0.0126166511,
0.0127745839,
0.0518295318,
0.0030783466,
0.0211726148,
0.064180024,
0.0106157847,
-0.0209508408,
0.0321260542,
0.0096428609,
0.0218802206,
-0.0370644554,
0.0270098094,
0.0681857616,
-0.0542243347,
-0.0118733114,
0.047645025,
0.0586319342,
0.0208369289,
0.0296263788,
0.0159378331,
0.026353281,
0.035950169,
0.0483984798,
-0.0477259755,
0.0078843338,
-0.0418300219,
0.018058328,
-0.007580467,
0.0310088005,
-0.0267986879,
0.0073868395,
-0.0298768803,
-0.0045000976,
0.0094026364,
0.0094006415,
0.0741628408,
-0.011555559,
-0.016518306,
0.0244235322,
0.0578466393,
-0.0210970007,
-0.0251983386,
-0.0681699142,
0.0266800467,
0.0049253879,
0.0548705049,
-0.0395912267,
-0.0504116006,
0.0196943246,
0.0152322045,
0.0404135101,
0.0525048114,
-0.0158614013,
0.0075871171,
-0.0237356517,
-0.0204856135,
0.0349265635,
0.0092745181,
0.0196182597,
0.033225242,
-0.0109357564,
0.0037008263,
-0.0039116861,
0.0161930826,
0.0276841391,
0.000394014,
-0.0073112529,
-0.0068644914,
-0.0179366209,
0.0501311794,
0.0099101719,
-0.0359855108,
0.0046020267,
0.0125999972,
-0.0269863885,
-0.0133639639,
0.0035998041,
-0.0347322747,
-0.0791514963,
0.0226737838,
-0.0317903757,
-0.0165379159,
0.0147899045,
-0.0328379907,
-0.0326143317,
-0.0099924281,
0.0058479672,
0.0101990998,
-0.0421999618,
-0.004677807,
0.0434519798,
0.0163821466,
-0.0717032403,
0.0676599443,
0.041758921,
-0.0098863719,
-0.0094764372,
-0.0244873762,
0.008205317,
-0.0397710614,
-0.0527777597,
0.0430354737,
-0.0097598825,
-0.012464907,
0.0246899053,
0.0322144292,
-0.0493231937,
-0.0462786481,
-0.1362937391,
0.0329463445,
-0.0216235034,
0.0405175984,
0.031454742,
0.0293358788,
-0.0334109887,
0.0258979648,
-0.0408865139,
0.0172416233,
-0.0095198127,
0.0264733266,
0.020785626,
0.0128525207,
0.007209647,
-0.0631045401,
-0.0086820135,
-0.0438414514,
0.0213522688,
-0.0046472927,
-0.0944671631,
-0.0153370285,
0.03799209,
-0.031528946,
0.0399280414,
-0.0242260341,
-0.0213754494,
-0.0103254309,
-0.0354383849,
0.045165278,
0.0201071538,
-0.0141925588,
0.0077331094,
-0.0066236476,
-0.0529076345,
-0.0414377861,
0.0324820988,
-0.0398561507,
-0.0138663147,
0.0039367671,
-0.0051351972,
0.0081897285,
0.0650807172,
0.0122586135,
0.007215031,
-0.0555762164,
-0.0054430808,
-0.0277377218,
0.0263577867,
-0.0363167673,
0.0289774574,
-0.0076934421,
0.0067428309,
-0.0364340171,
0.0035888471,
0.061130289,
-0.0586517341,
-0.0259754006,
-0.0553862266,
0.0130204875,
-0.0558191314,
0.0753965154,
-0.0012109583,
-0.0158249754,
0.0149445105,
-0.0240410883,
-0.0279681385,
0.0064406362,
0.006437968,
-0.0300663095,
0.0411668122,
-0.0381218605,
0.0517433658,
-0.0393614173,
-0.0256590322,
-0.0260735936,
-0.0675075129,
-0.0098774899,
-0.0067414553,
0.0054041473,
0.0056412737,
-0.0045397994,
0.03954193,
0.0127628976,
0.0395252034,
-0.0392480008,
-0.0037212553,
-0.0315281935,
0.0590295047,
0.078436777,
-0.015949171,
-0.020826254,
0.0105222641,
0.0310329702,
0.0810508281,
0.0127213718,
0.0348807387,
-0.0147414459,
-0.0029506315,
0.009134694,
-0.007521674,
-0.0242773853,
-0.0093244677,
0.0652655661,
-0.0424190275,
-0.0235552024,
0.1181604192,
0.018998988,
-0.0401229225,
-0.0169290267,
0.0297190789,
0.0338145606,
0.0000620793,
0.0120322267,
-0.0805056989,
-0.0517292805,
0.0083507067,
-0.0072860485,
-0.011407665,
-0.0371380411,
-0.0230218973,
-0.1099241897,
0.0437848903,
-0.0117103318,
-0.0499242097,
-0.017945854,
-0.006840738,
0.0433444008,
-0.0369605869,
0.0029366538,
0.0089082615,
-0.0242780931,
0.0215050597,
0.0368812829,
-0.0443451963,
-0.0336852595,
0.0514932796,
-0.0436300896,
0.0644877627,
0.0662096068,
0.0172080006,
0.0117660239,
0.0312804468,
0.0699376389,
-0.0119220419,
-0.0455911756,
-0.0128752757,
0.075489074,
-0.0323686749,
-0.0190352667,
-0.014971639,
0.0409536809,
-0.0122049414,
-0.0008763343,
0.0334817693,
0.0595833436,
-0.0068384325,
0.0030669621,
-0.0137594566,
-0.0035042544,
-0.0041459971,
0.1059870124,
0.0299495328,
-0.016342571,
-0.032860782,
0.0063782134,
-0.023052441,
-0.0245288871,
-0.0466277264,
0.0189690758,
-0.0114154425,
-0.023480922,
-0.067940779,
-0.075166896,
0.0492604338,
0.0195287783,
-0.0121566616,
0.0039048919,
0.0183493756,
0.0270132236,
-0.0217015967,
0.0238228459,
-0.0471760295,
-0.013513973,
-0.0241662804,
-0.0011687109,
0.0263020862,
-0.0106757358,
-0.0322055034,
0.0277289897,
-0.1101677269,
-0.0498790927,
0.0015500908,
-0.003071181,
0.0288208947,
0.0284061991,
-0.0306367967,
-0.0069701322,
0.0033585574,
0.0391967222,
-0.0424210429,
-0.003373537,
-0.0011131639,
0.026188761,
0.0001605556,
0.0239203349,
-0.0364604257,
0.0388471708,
0.0066888477,
0.0394975841,
-0.0196955726,
0.0126838256,
0.0357953385,
0.0397596955,
0.0867373496,
0.0302276071,
-0.0076948358,
-0.0452920869,
-0.024468191,
-0.0433755964,
-0.0040652738,
-0.064039357,
-0.0207995251,
-0.0039623762,
-0.0199265704,
-0.0296668708,
-0.0293014552,
-0.0210452955,
0.0496748239,
-0.0654428825,
-0.0267079547,
-0.0216260441,
-0.0068973857,
0.016025709,
-0.0251419842,
-0.0204629358,
0.0158550274,
0.0339688845,
0.0115311751,
-0.0479791351,
0.0687702149,
0.0263206847,
-0.0323873051,
0.0240942817,
0.0305384118,
-0.0606666729,
0.030097926,
-0.0202069264,
0.0822327137,
0.0545751899,
-0.0185231101,
0.0622097105,
-0.0231426619,
-0.008533108,
-0.0319684297,
0.0425735265,
0.005040314,
0.0230493546,
0.043643862,
0.0233365241,
-0.0461862125,
-0.0300113764,
0.0931046382,
-0.0111627132,
0.0203972384,
0.0470206663,
-0.0147078978,
-0.0502535999,
-0.0154326269,
-0.0127287842,
-0.0140251843,
-0.0188900195,
0.0151847843,
-0.0525536612,
-0.0435606092,
-0.0065920791,
-0.0097181536,
-0.0123153245,
0.0110589964,
0.0198178459,
0.0701274872,
0.0058703483,
-0.0193819385,
-0.0256774835,
-0.0166730713,
-0.0154693732,
-0.0243222993,
-0.0140721351,
-6.610789211e-33,
-0.0537176728,
0.0101943323,
0.0339074433,
0.0515967384,
-0.0260824002,
0.0409117155,
-0.0199274477,
0.0185078681,
-0.0008722053,
-0.0116679231,
-0.0020874212,
-0.0059887981,
0.0238690376,
0.026572939,
-0.0201026015,
-0.0529604293,
0.000391714,
-0.014640525,
-0.0029250041,
0.0025172166,
0.0340014733,
0.0264518484,
0.0743964463,
-0.0870453715,
0.0268530659,
-0.0145525262,
0.0195527859,
-0.0068526431,
0.0353350453,
0.0655092373,
-0.0460908599,
0.0257302579,
0.0375300497,
-0.0109130768,
-0.0010927718,
0.0252139252,
-0.1131435707,
-0.0283416957,
0.0202876031,
0.0045889509,
-0.0071911602,
-0.0040921378,
0.0037875073,
-0.0258312151,
0.0223681834,
-0.0358680524,
0.0157683268,
-0.0201168172,
0.0093048187,
0.0143009992,
-0.0603927113,
0.0478523001,
0.0036827906,
-0.0182342716,
0.0487522148,
0.0460700952,
0.0142744258,
0.0250067189,
-0.0418738648,
-0.0192592572,
-0.0112151336,
0.046868965,
0.0327094682,
0.0029378328,
0.0192205962,
0.0790765435,
0.030065313,
-0.0166424308,
-0.0210896246,
-0.0201793686,
0.0214191545,
0.0327154249,
0.0155120576,
0.0219201334,
0.0214068871,
0.0319116451,
-0.0881437659,
0.0121494727,
0.0595339164,
0.015019522,
0.0014165551,
-0.0033719251,
-0.0744545907,
-0.0059137857,
0.0287454557,
-0.0020750538,
-0.0344616547,
-0.030688487,
0.0528369136,
-0.0098191891,
-0.0006429232,
0.0379139557,
0.0560179502,
-0.0093103405,
0.0002476973,
-0.0067263357,
-0.046371121,
0.0253022444,
-0.0219248775,
0.0256634951,
-0.0750299618,
-0.0409601778,
0.0167874452,
0.0301918238,
0.0142385159,
0.0121060079,
0.0465742797,
0.0013892212,
-0.0565013476,
-0.0343484581,
-0.0470847338,
0.0333565809,
-0.0451485962,
0.0093772123,
0.0395316556,
0.0114492364,
-0.0069121872,
0.0305357315,
0.0564739928,
0.0101972735,
-0.0383625738,
0.0062984014,
-0.0074579907,
-0.024412835,
0.0117642097,
0.0080175642,
-0.0122470642,
-0.0473175086,
-0.0002343153,
-0.0314102843,
0.012260492,
0.0210927539,
2.629e-7,
0.033961419,
0.0511679761,
0.0379352123,
0.0154041471,
0.0200031567,
0.0283177048,
-0.0185246747,
0.0222214647,
0.0184616037,
-0.0000267057,
0.0088766096,
0.0097528808,
0.0634697229,
0.0392400958,
-0.0838429928,
-0.0375955217,
-0.0669265315,
-0.0597926192,
-0.054828234,
0.0094231628,
0.0832464546,
0.1065683663,
0.0156378914,
0.0201568604,
-0.0197800007,
-0.0568686724,
0.0606035404,
-0.0209373906,
-0.0482863709,
0.0354385972,
0.0289506465,
0.0146469865,
0.0037973651,
0.0516346768,
0.0256544817,
0.0123633314,
0.0620381534,
0.0596980304,
0.0096153859,
-0.0307394285,
-0.0075088646,
-0.0119514065,
-0.003228117,
-0.0268776212,
0.1072184145,
-0.0695959628,
-0.0314028338,
-0.0350006036,
-0.0232087616,
0.001420163,
-0.0284318756,
0.0090699987,
-0.0320516117,
0.0407048948,
0.0333129577,
-0.0055991788,
-0.054890994,
-0.0804187059,
-0.0023933486,
0.013689952,
-0.0501747616,
-0.0353837386,
-0.0061844331,
0.0034524766,
0.0187569745,
-0.0796454176,
-0.0117801186,
2.890267168e-34,
0.0064695184,
-0.0042302092,
-0.0113331061,
0.0159674436,
0.0179067031,
0.0008614467,
-0.0050256322,
0.0156887975,
-0.0497870259,
-0.0756430179,
-0.0021480382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14441v1 | Exploring Contrast Consistency of Open-Domain Question Answering Systems on Minimally Edited Questions | 2023-05-23T18:07:04 | 2023-05-23T18:07:04 | Zhihan Zhang, Wenhao Yu, Zheng Ning, Mingxuan Ju, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrast consistency, the ability of a model to make consistently correct
predictions in the presence of perturbations, is an essential aspect in NLP.
While studied in tasks such as sentiment analysis and reading comprehension, it
remains unexplored in open-domain question answering (OpenQA) due to the
difficulty of collecting perturbed questions that satisfy factuality
requirements. In this work, we collect minimally edited questions as
challenging contrast sets to evaluate OpenQA models. Our collection approach
combines both human annotation and large language model generation. We find
that the widely used dense passage retriever (DPR) performs poorly on our
contrast sets, despite fitting the training set well and performing
competitively on standard test sets. To address this issue, we introduce a
simple and effective query-side contrastive loss with the aid of data
augmentation to improve DPR training. Our experiments on the contrast sets
demonstrate that DPR's contrast consistency is improved without sacrificing its
accuracy on the standard test sets. | [
0.0366802216,
0.0830018371,
0.0027627475,
0.031181071,
-0.02914056,
0.0075787283,
0.0104157822,
0.0083326418,
-0.0135284467,
-0.0489109904,
0.0138180489,
-0.0749243572,
-0.0282666218,
0.0293897372,
0.0242036004,
-0.0518606119,
0.0272000171,
-0.0143378498,
-0.0228262283,
-0.0083489241,
0.0233676005,
-0.0041143526,
0.0050642975,
0.003799251,
0.0408480614,
-0.0321796834,
-0.0309428647,
0.013436568,
0.0260371678,
-0.0199174602,
0.0605095327,
0.0869942084,
0.0219724756,
0.0182805769,
0.0000019008,
-0.0444547087,
-0.0372682065,
0.0231749527,
-0.044096496,
0.0144086732,
0.0282343198,
0.0102187274,
0.0408398248,
0.0233494323,
-0.0429898649,
-0.011382659,
0.0318537541,
0.054216601,
0.102493614,
0.0752922669,
0.0081726564,
-0.016218517,
-0.0122780371,
-0.0268148053,
0.0043504536,
-0.0512417108,
0.0376242734,
-0.0042839861,
-0.0045636948,
0.053053882,
-0.0028238569,
0.0036195104,
0.0506586432,
0.018651953,
0.0099562472,
0.0098936511,
-0.0447290838,
0.0477537736,
0.0083315438,
0.10759525,
0.051840879,
-0.019090116,
-0.0177316833,
-0.0047161165,
-0.0044212537,
-0.0077930093,
-0.0341202654,
0.0113867521,
-0.0084283799,
0.010063326,
-0.0078493999,
0.0061985147,
-0.0085925013,
0.033531785,
-0.0420266576,
-0.0199228581,
0.0187197402,
-0.0470459424,
0.002416644,
0.0267774239,
-0.0831338912,
-0.0430314392,
-0.0089352662,
0.0224399995,
-0.0200022459,
0.0018956943,
-0.0334476046,
-0.0479904823,
0.0305072814,
-0.0227655116,
0.0374829918,
0.0079413075,
-0.0561458617,
0.0526288934,
0.0005636227,
0.0718885809,
-0.0200080052,
0.0149567788,
-0.0440133065,
-0.0310134552,
-0.0228055604,
0.002321702,
-0.0480812676,
0.0469204485,
-0.0803471878,
0.0397288054,
-0.011770037,
-0.0099788504,
0.0077949902,
-0.0090840338,
0.0096368203,
0.0390360989,
-0.0482036062,
-0.0321903042,
-0.0366345271,
0.0360552967,
-0.0345601104,
0.0296085179,
0.0314989388,
-0.0673477575,
-0.0359857902,
-0.0139630176,
-0.0033639367,
-0.0495807528,
-0.0001748111,
0.0231949911,
-0.0172031503,
-0.052005183,
-0.0543571636,
-0.0088807736,
-0.0041671414,
-0.0387790725,
-0.01764597,
-0.0636713877,
0.0471587852,
0.0055150944,
-0.0303961467,
-0.0630155206,
0.0207871348,
0.0373091809,
-0.0008430544,
0.0707319602,
-0.0349800438,
-0.0342823826,
0.015418062,
0.0026869304,
-0.0006564815,
0.0686004162,
0.0052555902,
-0.0346545205,
0.0517746173,
0.0139945149,
-0.0067349416,
0.0098348428,
0.0150650712,
0.0114049446,
-0.0057549626,
0.0620477386,
0.016909657,
0.0016020042,
0.0318604968,
0.0651997998,
-0.0423457474,
-0.0871083736,
0.0428109765,
0.0222840924,
0.0093631037,
0.0347022153,
0.0052570431,
0.0064389077,
0.0280365292,
0.0536817089,
-0.0187828634,
0.0001267575,
-0.0148608033,
-0.0040544253,
0.0714759454,
0.0123117482,
-0.0368227698,
-0.0499729291,
-0.0136564085,
0.0103113772,
0.0062801139,
0.002805115,
0.0585099794,
0.0267290361,
-0.0305151399,
0.0223381743,
0.0508099459,
-0.0299911518,
-0.0067918836,
-0.017457027,
0.0172116403,
0.0146476608,
0.0526531301,
-0.0463134535,
-0.0198485348,
-0.0325139053,
0.039884612,
0.0376835614,
0.06550733,
-0.021678241,
0.0220594648,
-0.0430935435,
-0.0162317958,
-0.0324321985,
0.0147317993,
0.0081540747,
0.0559671335,
0.0106112715,
0.025556583,
-0.083486557,
-0.040521767,
0.0283654518,
-0.0464065336,
-0.0404669903,
0.0313022397,
-0.0181151778,
0.0058294144,
0.017800888,
-0.0363404267,
0.0127001004,
0.0158219598,
-0.0564193204,
-0.0339227431,
-0.0250000749,
-0.0411516465,
-0.0283428226,
0.0391959623,
0.0021565764,
-0.016783433,
0.0760105848,
-0.0576979928,
-0.0212219413,
-0.0251125693,
-0.0656278804,
0.0038229423,
-0.0435137004,
-0.0300840214,
0.0246225875,
0.0022286554,
-0.0656581596,
0.0657100752,
-0.0070661698,
0.0464421436,
0.0006558512,
0.0384428799,
0.0181486961,
-0.0319879986,
-0.0087535242,
-0.0055074655,
0.0010027448,
0.0294970758,
0.0307373572,
0.000682578,
-0.0613319427,
0.0163689312,
-0.0520748794,
0.0228269845,
-0.0426256247,
0.0305580888,
0.064614445,
0.0133318501,
0.0011929285,
-0.0216333941,
-0.0208209045,
-0.0338549912,
0.0107688177,
0.0442430452,
0.0457448624,
0.0407793745,
0.0294787511,
-0.0432492383,
-0.0330026783,
0.0008430593,
0.0573194288,
-0.0111265406,
0.0143513763,
-0.0460943244,
0.0306051299,
-0.0160283539,
0.0629886985,
-0.0077039083,
-0.0248768423,
0.0030256191,
-0.036863625,
0.0104447836,
0.0727368966,
0.0327480324,
-0.0114426352,
0.0103900367,
-0.0069951084,
-0.0594759919,
0.0250990912,
-0.0288119018,
-0.0213760305,
0.0058070291,
-0.0529769622,
-0.0012647499,
0.0700177625,
-0.0090019433,
-0.0160143953,
-0.0365455858,
0.0111002438,
-0.0227668844,
0.007732959,
-0.0068005477,
0.0542368479,
-0.0158732366,
0.0491406061,
-0.0400281958,
-0.0195003264,
0.079159528,
0.0002196266,
-0.0035365943,
-0.0872995257,
0.0081492607,
-0.0483090878,
0.0464814156,
-0.0079241628,
0.0025934749,
0.0449300781,
-0.0137362853,
-0.0606723428,
-0.0368989259,
0.022611225,
-0.0519995056,
0.0521057993,
-0.0543817468,
0.0160642546,
-0.0104409019,
-0.0614988022,
-0.0684584975,
-0.0649226531,
-0.0208421797,
0.0319891982,
0.0109794261,
-0.0033057928,
-0.0039299433,
-0.0073522208,
0.0165830646,
0.0601261295,
-0.0177606959,
-0.0091637392,
-0.0113347871,
0.0814009756,
0.0826999396,
0.0607994832,
0.0405409969,
-0.041757036,
0.0418837108,
0.0863721967,
0.0198260322,
-0.0189948082,
-0.0081127658,
0.0011645332,
0.0054557575,
-0.0434148982,
0.0168829672,
-0.00685655,
0.0916017219,
-0.061753653,
-0.0568276346,
0.0837101117,
0.0381131992,
-0.0231416263,
-0.0250451267,
-0.035180226,
0.0120009957,
0.014671972,
0.0307681803,
-0.0947626606,
-0.0484386161,
-0.0179905631,
0.0766051263,
0.0205668025,
-0.0437583998,
0.0028683222,
-0.1261942089,
0.006869195,
-0.0267093889,
-0.050610777,
-0.0141853942,
-0.0573159605,
0.0357759446,
-0.032563787,
0.001474774,
0.0266912282,
-0.001338574,
0.0090616113,
0.0336187966,
0.0427192189,
-0.0064324364,
0.0207165107,
-0.033762563,
-0.0048414269,
0.0605661124,
-0.0047227028,
-0.009578974,
-0.0268309563,
0.0248053987,
-0.0986099243,
-0.0243377667,
0.0111749908,
0.0764517114,
0.0157050304,
-0.0139756529,
-0.0352281332,
0.030219296,
0.0040005716,
-0.0200742856,
0.0096010165,
0.0190355983,
0.0182454102,
-0.0124814631,
-0.0209299214,
-0.0004147426,
0.0023247863,
0.0633365363,
0.0117827235,
-0.0296864919,
-0.0549013317,
-0.016229704,
0.002246761,
-0.0579568967,
-0.015140079,
0.0052788127,
0.0141980611,
0.0635280535,
-0.0800073519,
-0.0305839069,
-0.0035012702,
0.0090461681,
-0.0346529335,
-0.0076568439,
-0.0198199358,
-0.009588249,
-0.0230439156,
0.0561495125,
-0.0451894403,
0.0009091662,
-0.0452192388,
-0.0431185625,
0.0161801092,
-0.0357628614,
-0.0290416125,
-0.0063305409,
-0.0737422705,
-0.0485513695,
0.020219557,
0.0450715274,
0.0147907017,
0.031005742,
-0.0048220768,
-0.0291041583,
0.0054114321,
0.0253648367,
-0.0226720963,
0.0227274094,
0.0275146216,
-0.0147967059,
-0.0060846638,
0.0263831429,
-0.0447583385,
-0.0024688465,
0.0256703701,
0.0530201979,
-0.0146812107,
-0.0633263364,
0.0375140905,
-0.0095930053,
0.0276140217,
0.0586373769,
-0.0086725485,
-0.0286877826,
0.036011748,
-0.0073432573,
-0.0170101412,
-0.0338479839,
0.0366088524,
-0.002041715,
-0.0262297411,
-0.0134417824,
0.0398724638,
-0.0281381346,
0.0547088645,
-0.0706572086,
-0.0108174542,
0.0505551435,
-0.0061334861,
0.014393338,
-0.0046779211,
-0.0314929858,
-0.0091852006,
-0.0066525093,
0.1035683155,
0.0105526056,
0.0647527874,
0.0434773229,
-0.0143676931,
0.0148836812,
0.012530826,
-0.102175653,
-0.0229371954,
-0.0420681797,
0.0039798552,
0.0376204029,
-0.0177387334,
0.0158179887,
0.001767888,
-0.0269486886,
-0.0293141678,
0.0012683509,
0.0177714638,
0.0367875546,
0.014132686,
0.0450012237,
-0.0023458796,
0.0610448346,
0.0619053841,
0.0000718475,
0.0523485243,
0.0102605019,
-0.0067936652,
-0.0077903182,
-0.0031316853,
-0.0097137373,
0.0264980737,
0.0052757463,
0.0237080306,
-0.0467748307,
-0.0637441874,
0.0636829361,
-0.0064995144,
0.0147244334,
0.0253835842,
0.0364240445,
0.0354430899,
-0.0037789172,
-0.0325304195,
-0.028774241,
0.0448491387,
-0.0363760889,
-0.0052491361,
-0.0315039754,
-6.485872365e-33,
-0.0214913096,
-0.0209011044,
-0.0075077727,
-0.05729267,
-0.0136882719,
0.0200135447,
-0.0459844992,
-0.0105715794,
-0.039532762,
0.0180760529,
-0.0058481311,
0.0326783657,
-0.00570192,
0.0288310759,
-0.0186262578,
-0.0414295718,
0.0414313339,
-0.016956551,
-0.0252204053,
-0.0052922773,
0.0149146374,
0.0262033269,
0.0275562927,
-0.017310435,
0.0147450883,
-0.0439307354,
0.0043545295,
0.0337730013,
-0.0119972527,
0.0537279062,
-0.0107595352,
0.0342920572,
0.0299569424,
-0.0651773065,
-0.0110813333,
-0.0016985971,
-0.0733991936,
-0.022861477,
-0.0107820826,
-0.019334767,
-0.0660019442,
0.0062529901,
0.0218866952,
-0.0219663084,
0.0574961454,
-0.0338370018,
0.0110920547,
-0.0283313319,
0.0159563478,
0.0007298233,
0.0088101337,
0.0251778942,
-0.0100099165,
-0.025508957,
-0.0377080739,
0.0600329451,
0.0261694714,
0.0026008461,
-0.0245722551,
-0.0240709912,
0.0447818525,
0.0162639767,
-0.0111420956,
-0.0067057544,
-0.0190726742,
0.0490934923,
0.004706813,
-0.00205493,
-0.0172430221,
-0.0180501267,
-0.0439307243,
0.0097893421,
0.0539709963,
0.0858910233,
0.0314460918,
0.0434813127,
-0.071815677,
0.0332255922,
-0.0438006781,
0.0492518246,
0.0089944098,
-0.0107513675,
-0.0330137946,
-0.0030401859,
-0.0435061567,
-0.0157584958,
-0.0411601625,
-0.0111843254,
0.0441102982,
0.0175449923,
-0.0544172563,
-0.0063751698,
0.0204588044,
-0.0457810499,
0.014429573,
0.0180549733,
-0.0291456673,
-0.0077578882,
0.0146042025,
0.0342243016,
-0.0353835672,
0.0233303979,
0.0163416155,
-0.0171505716,
-0.0053179134,
0.0071757059,
0.0455463938,
-0.0309323445,
-0.0594994053,
0.0147290993,
-0.0315700434,
0.0419442356,
-0.0115982182,
0.0552136786,
0.028902147,
0.0334957801,
-0.007730193,
0.0895529687,
0.0139482953,
0.0223047957,
-0.0662911162,
0.0121468883,
0.0225065742,
0.0100461394,
-0.008534628,
0.0240373239,
-0.0105390167,
0.0689273253,
-0.0343248025,
-0.0157261435,
-0.0183496438,
0.0333938934,
2.568e-7,
0.0450496562,
0.0038635307,
0.0447240062,
0.0342752673,
-0.0155171081,
0.0396841168,
0.0013995093,
0.0053459443,
0.0168814994,
-0.0383420289,
-0.0287955534,
0.0548070893,
0.0445527025,
0.0511600152,
-0.0689521357,
-0.0023088155,
-0.0365384482,
-0.0266697649,
-0.0099318987,
-0.0413132273,
0.0893807933,
0.0609851219,
-0.0006712315,
-0.0029159007,
-0.0048574931,
-0.0246725343,
0.0547093116,
0.0180544145,
-0.0057624197,
-0.0001303194,
0.0178802665,
0.0085848477,
0.0098053664,
0.0071920534,
-0.0135708498,
0.0304525327,
0.0122225098,
0.0593379922,
0.0218764227,
-0.081452392,
-0.0223154072,
-0.0185193028,
0.0100193266,
-0.0379503965,
0.0880822837,
-0.0202951226,
-0.0053176344,
-0.0254058465,
-0.0451888517,
-0.014739302,
0.0313286372,
-0.0061825598,
-0.0122041712,
0.0046812855,
-0.0073625674,
0.0192186199,
-0.0030346005,
-0.0547126271,
-0.022032395,
0.0069640623,
-0.0141677158,
-0.0513915233,
-0.0182246603,
-0.0039799367,
-0.019041175,
-0.0494044498,
0.0102846222,
2.366585124e-34,
0.0339585207,
0.0040708184,
0.0180635434,
0.0455586612,
0.0279704295,
-0.0164952483,
0.010281371,
-0.0467264615,
0.0265689772,
-0.1021267325,
-0.0083041741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14434v1 | Domain-Expanded ASTE: Rethinking Generalization in Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2023-05-23T18:01:49 | 2023-05-23T18:01:49 | Yew Ken Chia, Hui Chen, Wei Han, Guizhen Chen, Sharifah Mahani Aljunied, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) is a subtask of Aspect-Based
Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) that considers each opinion term, their expressed
sentiment, and the corresponding aspect targets. However, existing methods are
limited to the in-domain setting with two domains. Hence, we propose a
domain-expanded benchmark to address the in-domain, out-of-domain and
cross-domain settings. We support the new benchmark by annotating more than
4000 data samples for two new domains based on hotel and cosmetics reviews. Our
analysis of five existing methods shows that while there is a significant gap
between in-domain and out-of-domain performance, generative methods have a
strong potential for domain generalization. Our datasets, code implementation
and models are available at https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/domain-expanded-aste . | [
0.0333977528,
0.0498044118,
0.0040120152,
0.0500429347,
-0.0285987686,
0.0114010833,
0.0121963453,
0.0191669483,
-0.0495150238,
-0.0469318815,
-0.0677988306,
-0.0425303467,
-0.0396867953,
0.0485132784,
-0.0272402689,
0.0056922548,
0.0250632167,
0.0405461229,
0.0122018149,
-0.0007487672,
0.0202825014,
0.0265461933,
0.0031009077,
0.009403985,
0.0094711874,
-0.0257104356,
0.0304112025,
-0.0020397534,
0.0410507098,
-0.0396915488,
0.0339644477,
0.0093039582,
-0.0091561172,
-0.0180118252,
0.0000021182,
-0.016332645,
-0.0453433692,
-0.0029406957,
0.0858589262,
0.0017294089,
0.0589072779,
-0.0269177407,
0.0265374165,
0.0103854667,
-0.0728971362,
-0.0727853402,
-0.0063920147,
0.0738201514,
0.013418857,
0.0916352943,
-0.032380946,
-0.0312578417,
-0.039216809,
-0.0514518619,
-0.0431318656,
-0.0503741913,
-0.0027976052,
-0.0066779056,
-0.0319608971,
0.0323142782,
0.0138064045,
-0.0065796347,
0.0053658127,
0.0245391354,
-0.0107165473,
0.00631394,
0.0117012709,
0.0064379033,
-0.0193906613,
0.035351187,
0.0295002088,
0.0224203672,
-0.0069623697,
-0.0155367246,
-0.0074950242,
0.0072766715,
0.0109374505,
-0.0121665206,
-0.015613935,
0.0445895977,
-0.0068208687,
0.0634345338,
0.0022068932,
-0.0071026785,
0.0269810893,
0.0418138281,
-0.0135279596,
-0.0310062002,
0.035839323,
0.1062782258,
-0.0259073172,
-0.0104731098,
-0.0003991243,
-0.0499919355,
0.0274994988,
0.0115453405,
0.0265628994,
0.0057114954,
0.0136456089,
-0.0273853261,
0.0221746098,
-0.009014545,
-0.0530884303,
0.022680549,
0.0133715989,
-0.0193505958,
0.0108009875,
-0.0286218133,
-0.0373538621,
0.058453247,
-0.0805536211,
0.0278725494,
0.0122746937,
0.0594038703,
-0.0444473214,
0.033325512,
-0.0656641647,
-0.0299265608,
-0.0120249037,
-0.0153889218,
0.066721186,
-0.0001641311,
0.0196327604,
0.000542198,
-0.013268779,
0.050600592,
-0.0791344047,
0.0427571572,
-0.031283129,
0.0081625208,
0.0024909007,
0.0087559,
0.0165071767,
-0.0373123288,
-0.0220361222,
0.0438821018,
0.0198611859,
-0.0497866981,
-0.0399210118,
-0.029457096,
-0.0157265719,
-0.075397253,
0.0075034201,
-0.053340286,
0.0485922731,
-0.007282984,
-0.0011465615,
-0.0385872498,
-0.004685455,
-0.0147821233,
-0.0105158202,
0.0342679657,
-0.0347694978,
-0.0269191805,
-0.0461989641,
0.0388437174,
0.0595119074,
0.057191167,
-0.0356294513,
0.0490621626,
0.0180980358,
0.0260982681,
0.0120525407,
0.0066820034,
0.0227327477,
-0.0015233238,
0.0344341062,
-0.0115243448,
-0.0367238261,
-0.0348509252,
0.0023251548,
0.017067669,
-0.0244568922,
-0.0238695834,
0.0182342976,
-0.0361967981,
-0.0061156577,
0.0863149613,
0.0443774946,
-0.0153131746,
-0.0092839869,
0.0151316561,
0.0024978244,
-0.0071748733,
0.0075292266,
0.0057799332,
0.016130697,
0.0401592031,
-0.0147131803,
-0.0655822679,
-0.0081002256,
-0.0182365458,
-0.0302119255,
-0.0112440009,
0.0683574528,
0.0234341305,
-0.0467414521,
-0.0392279439,
0.0675165728,
-0.0412521102,
-0.0255940612,
-0.0101509122,
0.0273802038,
0.0537848137,
-0.0091444291,
-0.0113095753,
-0.0088202991,
-0.0024368186,
-0.0441623926,
0.0038236503,
0.0373101085,
0.0020402696,
0.0117089069,
-0.0336103514,
-0.0075991936,
-0.0300955046,
0.0222097766,
0.0273475926,
0.0263347644,
0.076601401,
-0.0112143215,
-0.034538202,
0.052888833,
-0.0225663465,
-0.0157574713,
-0.0273352172,
0.0319856703,
-0.0036267759,
0.0101199793,
0.0824275538,
-0.0270799734,
-0.0331264138,
0.0224490501,
-0.0506675504,
-0.074272655,
0.017141344,
-0.0390058532,
-0.043416176,
0.0070443847,
-0.0276166052,
-0.0172225572,
-0.0139971869,
-0.0249611177,
-0.0015861877,
-0.0096498467,
0.0478371121,
0.0437108539,
-0.023145631,
-0.0104868067,
0.0482547842,
0.0243558232,
-0.0040287003,
0.0838860497,
-0.0263780653,
-0.0211522467,
-0.0473715924,
-0.0291665569,
0.0130805513,
0.05456236,
-0.0203769002,
-0.0040780893,
0.0056646517,
0.0229207091,
0.022461772,
0.026669709,
-0.0195359904,
-0.0130853401,
-0.0909246653,
0.0052043991,
0.0055752122,
0.0477203652,
0.0195650253,
0.0039547775,
0.0019600445,
0.0515662432,
-0.0442392156,
-0.0054864027,
-0.0450491533,
0.0232837554,
0.0036892344,
0.0301588234,
0.0177476481,
-0.0370859727,
-0.0049035698,
-0.0330615975,
0.0162516348,
-0.0149451243,
-0.0145350434,
-0.0295755267,
0.0450065024,
-0.0279182382,
0.0018523074,
-0.0028838846,
0.0006855218,
-0.0366580002,
-0.0270754155,
-0.0060371868,
-0.0344650522,
-0.0180874318,
0.0491212569,
0.0176216885,
0.0151077323,
-0.0347601548,
0.0357600935,
-0.0715012848,
0.0069449311,
-0.0000273808,
-0.0087439455,
0.007820012,
0.0550099984,
-0.0015890701,
-0.0186563637,
-0.0332971402,
0.024922777,
-0.0276536979,
-0.008277175,
0.0315627754,
0.0398925766,
0.014328978,
0.0527441911,
0.0212223977,
0.023022851,
0.035445191,
0.0101903947,
0.0272942148,
-0.0591318645,
0.0235370453,
-0.039533101,
0.0631420091,
-0.0509221926,
0.0208802726,
0.0572350062,
0.00626782,
0.0431057476,
-0.0363357961,
-0.0069098673,
0.0003588681,
0.0692497417,
-0.0031417257,
0.0228837058,
0.0165272672,
-0.0683630928,
0.0198732093,
-0.0058495952,
-0.0401384048,
-0.0136088775,
-0.0332337208,
-0.0093493061,
0.0198725183,
-0.0179726463,
-0.0626990348,
-0.0040194285,
-0.0189459771,
-0.0384760611,
0.0263591502,
0.0544143878,
0.0531663038,
-0.0286434367,
-0.0164486598,
-0.0028277284,
-0.0231271032,
0.0868158638,
-0.0634211525,
-0.001116361,
-0.0281722005,
0.0022815361,
0.0307291225,
-0.0134213157,
0.0162240509,
-0.0549086481,
0.0580804236,
-0.0295921024,
-0.0175744221,
0.1018301174,
0.0297787301,
-0.0679333657,
0.0058852062,
0.0301042981,
0.0008405113,
0.0240837801,
0.0057048756,
-0.0947990119,
-0.0332836322,
-0.0484824516,
0.0243096296,
0.0027191658,
0.004529336,
0.0060441117,
-0.1092598811,
0.0305500589,
-0.0238862634,
-0.0275253206,
-0.0516089015,
-0.0074290168,
0.0068870024,
-0.03490109,
-0.016592579,
-0.0528656505,
0.0057775942,
0.0243512075,
-0.0076220636,
0.010745733,
-0.0442148596,
0.0442308597,
0.0012567186,
0.0032518129,
0.038742125,
0.0256422907,
0.0113421977,
-0.0286071636,
0.0325056165,
-0.040236555,
0.0165737532,
-0.0613387339,
0.0761756375,
-0.0254756305,
-0.0280675385,
0.0450332053,
0.004754805,
-0.0981836021,
0.016383009,
0.0084816655,
0.0155341709,
0.0150321992,
-0.0272685196,
-0.0341011137,
0.031943243,
0.0105943279,
0.0502191819,
-0.011869574,
-0.0574142896,
-0.0026063796,
-0.0076285554,
-0.0384152047,
-0.0598080046,
-0.073294796,
-0.0391135924,
-0.0031008073,
-0.0567564368,
-0.0739925653,
-0.0619462281,
0.0028413131,
0.0575523488,
-0.0234141089,
-0.0249941982,
0.0081898654,
0.0416812599,
-0.0172232185,
-0.0183355249,
-0.0178652871,
-0.0173546076,
0.0322558023,
-0.0121790003,
0.0946786851,
-0.0298895761,
-0.04116375,
-0.0088042589,
-0.0462388247,
-0.0377722234,
0.0057126754,
0.0209423341,
0.0077435607,
0.0175916795,
-0.0067463545,
0.0354915112,
-0.0151410922,
0.044688262,
0.0048311683,
-0.0038091931,
0.0463593118,
0.0436866172,
0.0246859975,
0.0319670774,
-0.0119810663,
0.0612003878,
0.0229802746,
0.0002235082,
-0.0220126882,
0.0015065353,
0.0133049069,
-0.0166974645,
0.0733742416,
0.0107415318,
0.0121852737,
-0.0313145481,
-0.0066593499,
-0.0298159756,
0.0019489579,
-0.0644989982,
-0.0121717472,
0.0183444526,
0.0169131383,
-0.0796373934,
0.063594237,
-0.0118502369,
0.0209294781,
-0.0618165024,
0.0353308767,
0.0181592628,
0.0209983904,
-0.0324380584,
-0.0065085823,
-0.0115932757,
-0.0159364995,
0.0213331543,
0.0021079322,
-0.0451564305,
0.050275214,
0.0189810302,
0.0421285741,
-0.0072162375,
0.0332687423,
-0.0068992563,
0.0572456494,
-0.0440775901,
0.0154776471,
-0.005039514,
-0.0464763641,
0.0695940703,
-0.0375313349,
-0.0018511759,
0.0200924817,
0.039498914,
-0.0299206935,
-0.0018079805,
0.0244989991,
-0.0011830975,
-0.0081168599,
-0.0259445552,
0.0786492527,
-0.0885272548,
0.0467056893,
0.0470661409,
-0.0154345287,
-0.0365059301,
-0.0008686942,
-0.0166627932,
-0.012696513,
0.0143752126,
-0.0019147744,
-0.0698590279,
-0.0394853055,
-0.0020733466,
-0.0050501102,
0.0260108318,
0.0308087282,
0.0067845318,
0.0596802793,
0.0265155639,
0.0150708584,
-0.047682602,
-0.0484676883,
-0.031085141,
-0.0340322852,
-0.0125945983,
-7.009861462e-33,
-0.0148375388,
0.0056268899,
-0.0225644782,
0.0213958006,
-0.0436071828,
0.0073382137,
-0.0022929031,
0.053908933,
0.0182110146,
0.0268444102,
0.0106024006,
0.0068576639,
0.0015913043,
0.0315098204,
0.0119374599,
-0.0166479386,
0.0302107409,
-0.0190639067,
0.0017609231,
0.0402704775,
0.0135919591,
0.0294529051,
0.0783777609,
-0.1427214295,
0.0095684482,
0.0065700719,
-0.0545593686,
-0.0113855386,
0.0277020484,
0.0224491544,
0.0028719392,
0.0407720357,
0.043551825,
-0.0619731769,
0.0248102453,
-0.0595733076,
-0.0596081913,
-0.0240436513,
0.0238761213,
-0.0180616397,
-0.0125784678,
-0.0442764834,
-0.0170764681,
0.0090629878,
0.0004531164,
-0.0431565903,
-0.0031691906,
-0.0240014698,
0.016174309,
-0.1124970764,
-0.0649035871,
0.0247273613,
0.0003237733,
0.0161124412,
0.0426702052,
0.0217984654,
0.0229603816,
0.0307034198,
-0.0035268206,
0.0003762717,
-0.0123544689,
0.0278939195,
-0.0049161571,
-0.0683545545,
-0.0219500493,
0.0686312914,
-0.0090933945,
0.0361439884,
0.002052617,
0.0336947776,
-0.0037901045,
0.0331789777,
-0.0410038047,
0.0668752715,
0.0170973651,
-0.0418981649,
-0.0475746803,
0.0203882195,
0.0184123274,
-0.0739601552,
0.0457889475,
-0.0039863572,
-0.0366693921,
0.0138300266,
0.047345344,
-0.0210592076,
-0.0282854941,
-0.0368878283,
0.0122385379,
0.0423048586,
-0.0348781459,
0.0576299727,
-0.0248636268,
-0.0568545274,
0.0035487418,
0.0140033765,
-0.0621318407,
0.0280067902,
-0.0098540997,
-0.0165110026,
-0.0359194614,
-0.0270465296,
-0.0546279214,
0.0846217424,
0.0263129491,
-0.0269971974,
0.0896265656,
-0.0084445234,
-0.0898605436,
-0.0106867775,
-0.0226366203,
0.0445027053,
-0.0165821128,
0.0563475527,
0.0082178656,
0.008552094,
-0.0331703238,
0.1005247086,
0.0153302904,
0.0422913544,
-0.0360425673,
0.032722719,
0.0387138501,
0.0274567548,
-0.005280273,
-0.0244142916,
0.0368246399,
-0.0633716509,
0.008886761,
-0.0325135738,
-0.0379920229,
0.0057187611,
2.791e-7,
0.0361247919,
0.0320394486,
0.0007098108,
0.0147466362,
0.0138982264,
0.05172728,
0.0203619096,
0.0216656029,
0.0072151916,
0.0012895011,
0.0112547092,
0.0135959582,
-0.00227157,
0.0342640541,
-0.0444605947,
0.0878751725,
0.0286364276,
-0.0378095992,
-0.0151052913,
0.0194091406,
0.0671058744,
0.0671898648,
0.0039919922,
0.0048093237,
0.0169706196,
0.0166398343,
0.0475908183,
-0.0177259613,
-0.0332881249,
0.0302010234,
-0.044267416,
0.0270606801,
-0.0173665341,
-0.0509802401,
-0.0249289479,
0.0108261192,
0.0355765186,
0.0679855719,
0.0497030392,
-0.0510377139,
0.0410169438,
0.0305105485,
0.0239977762,
0.0207400471,
0.0437685736,
-0.0252697431,
-0.033596985,
-0.0955243483,
-0.0124978013,
0.0503940694,
0.0054324754,
0.007472069,
0.0082947062,
0.0519970655,
0.0015453756,
-0.0207018964,
-0.0503037348,
-0.0482353196,
0.0002419001,
0.0400199331,
0.0052993614,
-0.017147122,
0.0303663369,
0.0146887051,
-0.030858079,
-0.0430078134,
-0.0225779954,
2.205906296e-34,
0.0484209768,
-0.0130117852,
0.0079390053,
0.0333795138,
0.0135370241,
-0.0118163945,
-0.0493775308,
-0.0445879921,
-0.0093430206,
0.0119009828,
0.0249782596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14342v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14342v4 | Sophia: A Scalable Stochastic Second-order Optimizer for Language Model Pre-training | 2023-05-23T17:59:21 | 2024-03-05T17:07:16 | Hong Liu, Zhiyuan Li, David Hall, Percy Liang, Tengyu Ma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC | Given the massive cost of language model pre-training, a non-trivial
improvement of the optimization algorithm would lead to a material reduction on
the time and cost of training. Adam and its variants have been state-of-the-art
for years, and more sophisticated second-order (Hessian-based) optimizers often
incur too much per-step overhead. In this paper, we propose Sophia,
Second-order Clipped Stochastic Optimization, a simple scalable second-order
optimizer that uses a light-weight estimate of the diagonal Hessian as the
pre-conditioner. The update is the moving average of the gradients divided by
the moving average of the estimated Hessian, followed by element-wise clipping.
The clipping controls the worst-case update size and tames the negative impact
of non-convexity and rapid change of Hessian along the trajectory. Sophia only
estimates the diagonal Hessian every handful of iterations, which has
negligible average per-step time and memory overhead. On language modeling with
GPT models of sizes ranging from 125M to 1.5B, Sophia achieves a 2x speed-up
compared to Adam in the number of steps, total compute, and wall-clock time,
achieving the same perplexity with 50% fewer steps, less total compute, and
reduced wall-clock time. Theoretically, we show that Sophia, in a much
simplified setting, adapts to the heterogeneous curvatures in different
parameter dimensions, and thus has a run-time bound that does not depend on the
condition number of the loss. | [
0.0073486548,
0.091161713,
0.0141812591,
0.0467356741,
0.0127669666,
0.0143789928,
-0.0182867628,
0.005270984,
-0.0425780937,
-0.0171357151,
-0.0394373126,
-0.0793761685,
0.0310116652,
-0.0046864063,
0.0245632436,
-0.0640549809,
0.0368084684,
-0.045342233,
-0.0090419184,
-0.0231309943,
0.0106172776,
0.0346299484,
-0.002477854,
0.0088560274,
-0.0455036946,
-0.0133448606,
-0.0118988128,
0.0185659211,
0.0175414383,
-0.0299967714,
0.0171537381,
0.0681085214,
0.0076669701,
0.0643768236,
0.0000023531,
-0.0263606254,
0.0194595251,
0.0079632122,
-0.0144902049,
0.0717359036,
0.0456593968,
-0.0052084574,
-0.0284293387,
0.0005631131,
-0.0416011475,
-0.0471167974,
0.0394337513,
0.0070159584,
0.0387281924,
0.061450839,
-0.0215148777,
-0.0572923124,
0.0214182939,
-0.0622224398,
-0.0459762551,
-0.0860581249,
0.0255936366,
-0.0730153769,
-0.0591352582,
-0.0035062707,
0.0005710927,
0.0429191254,
-0.0148132183,
0.0288120471,
-0.0146576473,
0.0389832444,
-0.0314114429,
-0.0225257091,
-0.0136472136,
0.067702353,
-0.0179026406,
-0.014098892,
-0.0189075712,
-0.0032680137,
-0.0259441715,
-0.0187929329,
0.0023227814,
-0.0071106888,
0.0154557554,
0.0276799873,
-0.0231492575,
-0.0607985593,
0.0329056457,
-0.0186412055,
-0.066529125,
0.0541663058,
0.0295162816,
-0.0120466277,
0.0394988507,
0.0245432332,
-0.0481222197,
-0.0157787446,
0.005960647,
0.0046530282,
-0.0102737285,
0.021101404,
-0.0512731373,
-0.0576806776,
-0.0320047215,
-0.0442488007,
0.0856795609,
0.0075599118,
0.031521529,
0.0523192845,
-0.0454921462,
0.0009750054,
-0.0086293546,
0.0130987968,
-0.0312621109,
0.0151882432,
0.0084316768,
-0.0112606417,
-0.0493733026,
-0.0096185859,
0.0105751678,
-0.0197165925,
-0.0189168453,
-0.0069242408,
0.0121585056,
-0.021167947,
0.0624745898,
0.010872744,
-0.0171235744,
-0.0248720534,
0.0086186389,
0.0023864824,
-0.033122018,
0.0070761791,
-0.0132248625,
-0.0395022035,
-0.0350912474,
0.0112548787,
0.0307562146,
0.0063463473,
0.0193416215,
0.0547460876,
-0.009528745,
-0.0361190736,
-0.0239688382,
0.0223172233,
-0.0045954636,
-0.0491978601,
-0.0082759643,
-0.0231213998,
0.0331897326,
0.0173590649,
-0.0053536738,
-0.0516228378,
0.0045810654,
-0.0090049701,
-0.056088198,
0.0530080833,
-0.0218922775,
0.0064702863,
0.031815812,
-0.0212552864,
0.0408597365,
0.1087449268,
0.0134846177,
0.0191765763,
0.0263330843,
0.01658177,
-0.0609850995,
0.0677418485,
0.0790685639,
0.047389809,
-0.0180827118,
-0.0307759028,
0.0020786792,
0.0376355648,
0.0774130151,
0.0449651033,
-0.0359238014,
-0.0297700856,
0.0458526053,
0.0740507916,
0.004100692,
0.0426885113,
0.0220290162,
-0.0053425888,
0.0178004,
-0.0311915912,
-0.0199615173,
-0.0092017855,
-0.0225324277,
0.0035511479,
0.0059205005,
0.0445449203,
-0.0386278182,
-0.0237489454,
-0.0071900194,
-0.0204187334,
0.0016167038,
0.0177939571,
0.0363387614,
-0.0173605606,
-0.0881083682,
0.0836301222,
0.0226123612,
-0.0423505493,
-0.0239025373,
-0.0351494923,
-0.0397709571,
0.0188785549,
0.0101669924,
-0.0395767614,
-0.0556271598,
0.0061514783,
0.0056801662,
0.0289675649,
0.0292972978,
0.0224181879,
0.0226334576,
-0.0528711304,
0.0043262807,
0.037419904,
0.0199052747,
0.065818496,
0.0289683491,
0.0380322598,
0.0127212945,
0.0325687341,
-0.0168443304,
0.0285134874,
0.0069768382,
-0.0429000519,
0.0136360647,
0.010204291,
0.0154233268,
-0.0018011825,
-0.026169382,
-0.0251164697,
-0.0115892589,
-0.0382102206,
-0.0006183965,
-0.0171123445,
-0.0591004267,
-0.0211360902,
0.0485475585,
0.0215498023,
-0.018161919,
0.0478855781,
-0.0302996896,
-0.0530828871,
0.0398157388,
-0.0088475477,
0.0576849394,
-0.0733796209,
0.0067244489,
-0.0077656079,
0.0501255207,
-0.0205160938,
0.0006682361,
-0.0576706715,
-0.0010942647,
-0.0329716876,
-0.0100197438,
0.0034871453,
-0.0123597169,
-0.0547433943,
0.0195130762,
0.0050828015,
0.0348820351,
-0.0110230567,
0.01945116,
0.0382408015,
-0.0118225357,
-0.0794913843,
-0.0096712373,
-0.0523918122,
0.0266856123,
0.0242468417,
0.019432297,
-0.030348042,
0.0015699788,
0.0119547807,
0.0273778476,
-0.0581475236,
0.0084779123,
-0.0107935229,
0.0211551115,
0.0059829582,
-0.0072075855,
-0.0552292354,
-0.0011947633,
0.0493206978,
-0.0040838569,
-0.0124957953,
-0.0353716873,
0.0517221466,
-0.0324801579,
0.0353495143,
0.0011618419,
-0.0340460055,
0.0040182327,
-0.050509315,
0.0423815437,
0.0569277182,
0.0095983027,
0.0086603723,
0.0183386803,
0.0223798975,
0.0016036397,
0.0134766502,
-0.0231777076,
-0.0201948397,
-0.0487012081,
-0.0085894149,
0.0167470481,
0.0957709923,
-0.0246707201,
-0.0223396532,
-0.0570449829,
-0.0081199259,
-0.022946123,
-0.0213451553,
-0.0353275351,
0.0296058729,
-0.0457368791,
0.026516743,
0.0206562206,
-0.0144892335,
0.0409380607,
-0.0410759263,
-0.0099853743,
-0.0166032687,
-0.0061330819,
-0.0421998277,
-0.008049733,
0.0283343308,
0.0273063388,
-0.0800134391,
-0.0474462658,
-0.022165671,
-0.0063210786,
0.0570964217,
-0.0249180831,
-0.0080528762,
-0.006089123,
0.0407985449,
-0.0155069623,
-0.0426146798,
0.0087279957,
0.0094310502,
-0.0429518223,
-0.0245308485,
0.0488805659,
-0.0505504273,
0.0170857292,
0.0162214022,
-0.0335818417,
0.0858661979,
-0.0172179136,
0.0143244537,
-0.0058605205,
0.0366877615,
0.046404358,
0.0040011811,
-0.0171670094,
-0.0675752535,
-0.0099050393,
0.0239839479,
0.0190385617,
0.0114911115,
-0.0377432257,
0.0028428964,
0.055001229,
-0.0058254469,
-0.0259643011,
-0.0007046719,
0.0105356891,
-0.0164427198,
-0.0048284773,
0.0942927897,
0.0101335272,
-0.1159211695,
-0.0334891342,
0.0025543175,
0.0749035478,
0.0031848226,
0.0250587612,
-0.0403451845,
-0.0372597948,
0.0127910376,
0.0261371769,
0.0388443358,
-0.0341254547,
-0.0102006905,
-0.0860130861,
0.0066043213,
-0.0075556836,
-0.080130063,
0.0302010849,
-0.0426589996,
-0.0075333463,
-0.0299257282,
0.0171029475,
0.0247673038,
-0.0228905845,
0.0257567167,
0.0122610414,
-0.0568665788,
-0.0278965551,
0.0121494206,
-0.005377329,
-0.007197543,
0.0567415208,
-0.0033743507,
-0.0290648863,
0.0102323089,
0.0506185703,
0.0288770031,
-0.0319218189,
-0.0153273502,
0.0187481605,
-0.0097453203,
-0.0081247902,
-0.001707859,
0.043446213,
-0.019440461,
0.0469786488,
0.0025356316,
0.0614752993,
0.0228614062,
-0.019215377,
0.0120150372,
-0.0145499269,
0.0121470131,
0.0354590714,
0.0412695892,
-0.0705781579,
-0.0427057035,
-0.0267579257,
0.0191213097,
-0.0428736508,
-0.0246502645,
-0.0182075854,
0.0411504433,
-0.0085766818,
-0.0319876857,
0.0132560637,
-0.0278265867,
0.050100483,
-0.0087091429,
-0.0152688092,
0.051403299,
0.0362062678,
-0.0675421283,
-0.0000207276,
0.0002000442,
0.0010705065,
-0.0824707523,
0.0053939554,
0.0511883572,
0.042915985,
-0.0144996708,
0.042073518,
-0.0950630605,
-0.0619120225,
-0.001427567,
0.0234979019,
0.0102855396,
0.0585305654,
-0.0015580782,
-0.0319493227,
0.0564486086,
0.0120321643,
0.0020425722,
0.0438873693,
0.0756911039,
-0.048821006,
-0.0179162733,
0.0465716906,
0.0067558959,
0.0057073338,
-0.0053505753,
0.0289891381,
-0.0087342756,
-0.0154967634,
-0.0243812092,
0.0295219775,
0.0437973067,
-0.0302520618,
-0.009971953,
-0.0420648493,
0.0385338701,
-0.0017937814,
0.0372126475,
-0.032194227,
0.0055846674,
0.0033731319,
-0.0399654955,
-0.0301845446,
0.0142115531,
0.0485860556,
-0.0197023489,
-0.0027009598,
-0.00131359,
-0.0348660499,
-0.0049981661,
0.0646457598,
0.0101433815,
0.0041806055,
0.0199138448,
0.0219197441,
0.0201740228,
-0.0435984395,
0.0149149699,
0.0150414715,
0.0091758026,
-0.0241674054,
0.0264008977,
-0.0338157602,
-0.0882145241,
-0.070466198,
0.0253582876,
0.0646611303,
-0.0188458376,
0.0613436103,
-0.0429618619,
-0.0354214869,
-0.0188141707,
0.0305721089,
-0.0188473798,
0.0076802615,
0.0293291565,
0.0003506221,
0.0002021535,
0.0458853208,
0.0754400417,
0.0240866821,
0.0349059403,
-0.0114956163,
-0.0046964916,
-0.0271390826,
-0.0436130464,
-0.001945751,
0.023140898,
-0.0351145305,
0.0066391681,
-0.0194624923,
-0.0736599416,
-0.0283663906,
-0.0173696801,
-0.0290421229,
-0.0068199583,
0.0620691329,
0.0416547842,
-0.0496109352,
0.0300531518,
-0.0312917642,
-0.0232988205,
0.0007935795,
-0.0318349637,
0.039694909,
-6.715503717e-33,
-0.0177404843,
0.0375883691,
0.0050385282,
0.0435235649,
-0.0104318345,
0.0040416075,
-0.0048469389,
0.0191654898,
-0.0275772791,
0.0295719523,
-0.0443228856,
0.0016716687,
0.0060779909,
0.0319239348,
-0.0248589981,
0.0234539565,
0.0278321896,
-0.0257906318,
-0.0051868446,
0.0578367449,
0.0255357232,
0.0756576434,
0.0860848352,
0.0166973919,
-0.0412529185,
-0.0040560672,
-0.0127645023,
-0.0098205414,
0.0134645477,
0.001711084,
-0.0506596975,
0.040473707,
-0.0235260464,
-0.0535507239,
-0.0099851126,
-0.0376685709,
-0.0569527149,
-0.0353192016,
-0.0201406516,
0.0454014502,
-0.0390697457,
0.0314518847,
-0.0308658946,
0.0459596738,
-0.0516443402,
-0.0145974243,
0.0259003546,
0.0258187354,
-0.0762632713,
-0.0107983658,
-0.0282915719,
0.0493299142,
0.0019912017,
0.0029445428,
0.053785298,
-0.0266106408,
-0.0227931682,
0.001507626,
-0.0408986285,
0.0168710109,
0.0388379693,
0.0288659874,
0.0130418846,
0.027463695,
0.0075365119,
0.0362625457,
0.0569385327,
-0.0033804134,
-0.0038939442,
0.0072030579,
0.0575897805,
-0.0039114198,
-0.0121460781,
-0.0179334506,
0.0181009099,
-0.0397188365,
-0.08530619,
-0.0168290026,
-0.0019392752,
0.0376099646,
0.0047495458,
0.0112642134,
-0.008512279,
-0.0314043127,
-0.0413047299,
-0.0555320866,
-0.0154969823,
-0.0000446942,
-0.0122810295,
0.0301636439,
-0.0391704887,
0.0061056744,
0.0142729022,
-0.0169378556,
0.0056336983,
0.0255615525,
0.0024674211,
0.0171976518,
-0.0102677634,
0.0775789768,
-0.0149724195,
-0.0100654969,
-0.0518431626,
-0.0234705284,
0.01000854,
-0.0204880051,
0.0270362608,
0.0151324365,
-0.048426453,
-0.0040501477,
-0.0173172355,
0.0265254546,
0.0149534689,
0.0615074821,
0.0431762263,
-0.0332030915,
0.0492914692,
0.0931947082,
0.0332100093,
0.0387160666,
-0.0280775242,
-0.0327422768,
0.0207029823,
0.0223280173,
-0.0256399792,
0.0131201353,
-0.0135542508,
-0.044574786,
0.0156427547,
-0.0821880326,
-0.018802397,
0.0140718324,
2.931e-7,
0.042019885,
0.0697995201,
0.0022682154,
0.0088949883,
0.0234292019,
0.0017234174,
-0.0102345794,
0.0086139133,
-0.0118026147,
0.0310239401,
0.0323204063,
0.0402752832,
0.0549099259,
-0.0072040898,
-0.0900013,
-0.0144273806,
-0.0714715049,
0.0633838624,
-0.0586769618,
-0.025852168,
-0.0379631855,
0.1075507104,
-0.0064702583,
-0.0403368548,
0.0001210832,
-0.0196170323,
0.0628588721,
-0.0182389729,
0.0336680859,
0.0350549109,
0.0249588303,
0.0293959901,
-0.0215521809,
-0.0211477801,
-0.0386143103,
0.0213819481,
-0.010046673,
0.0756019577,
-0.0262028519,
-0.0246420726,
0.0540640615,
0.0256616659,
-0.022339737,
-0.0643534511,
0.0636974126,
0.0300355647,
-0.0038208116,
-0.0560025685,
0.012116963,
-0.0461108014,
0.0524882078,
-0.0542353056,
0.0020546843,
0.0434268601,
0.0330048203,
-0.0163607374,
-0.0310505126,
-0.1089340076,
0.0512633957,
0.0568883158,
-0.0292023197,
-0.0321597122,
-0.0303209797,
0.0229653623,
0.062725924,
-0.0122142872,
-0.0010781743,
2.755974286e-34,
0.0690164044,
-0.0161579903,
0.0261794999,
0.0525070205,
0.0023840135,
-0.0284672398,
0.0523922555,
0.0052084993,
-0.0067962562,
-0.105050087,
-0.0352398567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14341v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14341v2 | APPLS: Evaluating Evaluation Metrics for Plain Language Summarization | 2023-05-23T17:59:19 | 2024-01-31T02:32:19 | Yue Guo, Tal August, Gondy Leroy, Trevor Cohen, Lucy Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While there has been significant development of models for Plain Language
Summarization (PLS), evaluation remains a challenge. PLS lacks a dedicated
assessment metric, and the suitability of text generation evaluation metrics is
unclear due to the unique transformations involved (e.g., adding background
explanations, removing specialized terminology). To address these concerns, our
study presents a granular meta-evaluation testbed, APPLS, designed to evaluate
metrics for PLS. We define a set of perturbations along four criteria inspired
by previous work that a PLS metric should capture: informativeness,
simplification, coherence, and faithfulness. An analysis of metrics using our
testbed reveals that current metrics fail to capture simplification
consistently. In response, we introduce POMME, a new metric designed to assess
text simplification in PLS; the metric is calculated as the normalized
perplexity difference between an in-domain and out-of-domain language model. We
demonstrate POMME's correlation with fine-grained variations in simplification
and validate its sensitivity across 4 text simplification datasets. This work
contributes the first meta-evaluation testbed for PLS and a comprehensive
evaluation of existing metrics. The APPLS testbed and POMME is available at
https://github.com/LinguisticAnomalies/APPLS. | [
0.008742325,
-0.0118421214,
0.0094267614,
-0.0184926763,
-0.0288508311,
0.0020576667,
-0.007546362,
0.0154239638,
-0.0639204457,
-0.0227055401,
0.0119064357,
0.0383874364,
0.0681504086,
0.0120300772,
0.028019486,
-0.097142294,
0.0139131648,
-0.0042461641,
0.0061609168,
0.0298280362,
0.0383921973,
-0.0076903179,
0.0144396611,
0.0513120852,
0.0461897738,
-0.0010605603,
0.001077145,
0.0263957456,
0.0439038612,
0.00235776,
-0.0080879228,
0.0471840464,
-0.0002096937,
0.0160532556,
0.0000021537,
-0.0492355563,
-0.0240068845,
0.0087744398,
0.0399948806,
0.0498818643,
0.0661949441,
-0.0332601704,
0.0204322245,
0.0254520923,
-0.0128015317,
0.0070062992,
0.0244105216,
0.0108195972,
0.0677729174,
0.0566347279,
-0.017824525,
-0.0284489226,
-0.0159711353,
-0.0290069282,
-0.0367353633,
-0.0008055419,
-0.0216053873,
0.0338448659,
-0.0294110235,
-0.0236503724,
-0.011676209,
0.0241913311,
0.007123142,
-0.0196253918,
0.0084724734,
0.0340425298,
-0.0271913148,
-0.0122851189,
0.0271089859,
0.0812400728,
-0.0104144458,
-0.0308427121,
0.0116361836,
0.0008453189,
0.0189907756,
-0.0004167181,
-0.0850993395,
0.022586666,
0.0267422311,
0.0150153786,
-0.0360571928,
0.0307315756,
0.0064137154,
0.0138905412,
-0.0070824758,
0.001758968,
0.0272288192,
-0.0076134168,
-0.0536344089,
-0.0153655009,
-0.0311476551,
-0.0785986036,
0.0187291466,
0.0314700343,
-0.0077655567,
-0.0209814832,
-0.0500111505,
-0.1005382091,
0.0345682278,
-0.0116794864,
0.0154627021,
0.0136374533,
0.0052068071,
0.000111463,
-0.0223629232,
0.0646793619,
0.0629306659,
0.0176806618,
-0.0675200447,
0.0308572017,
-0.0164221842,
0.0189405289,
-0.0381948501,
0.0301421881,
-0.0233134683,
-0.0330156833,
-0.0394620635,
0.0075368164,
0.0071276212,
-0.0263592582,
0.0037253911,
-0.0010060819,
-0.0064508403,
-0.0228619184,
0.0162927713,
0.0382509269,
-0.0492475294,
-0.0136705795,
0.0519342646,
-0.0240552891,
-0.0221329089,
0.0327752382,
0.0305835288,
0.0261218939,
-0.0203233082,
0.0011160733,
-0.0292537678,
-0.0197443999,
0.0039658779,
-0.0331479497,
0.025790086,
-0.0409156866,
-0.0376745351,
-0.0784445405,
-0.012351118,
0.0079453941,
-0.001063943,
-0.0341728702,
-0.006207135,
0.0177300721,
-0.0247173849,
-0.0162249263,
-0.051658269,
0.0328507721,
0.0099618724,
0.0246551875,
-0.0026195911,
0.0288553759,
0.0355075561,
0.0318934508,
0.0500595197,
-0.0088526672,
0.0335389078,
-0.0057404148,
0.0214830898,
0.0060056769,
0.005373125,
-0.0232694317,
-0.0770107806,
-0.0069744587,
0.0534724928,
0.0664846227,
-0.051838018,
0.0263525844,
0.0680523738,
0.0270414818,
0.0131870341,
-0.0001744381,
0.0620058812,
0.0441923998,
0.0514204837,
0.0677558407,
0.0045902911,
0.0072895722,
-0.0581340231,
0.0732719824,
0.0939655825,
0.0263662413,
-0.0270152241,
-0.0602253079,
0.0210140273,
-0.0284755304,
0.0229865573,
-0.0214659143,
0.0164399836,
0.0204931758,
-0.0658171922,
0.0196708404,
-0.0033294219,
-0.0761272684,
0.0278743394,
-0.0256868228,
0.0081271762,
0.0550856814,
0.0551473685,
0.0030049928,
-0.0348058008,
-0.0079210438,
0.0162771102,
0.0440616496,
0.0296266917,
-0.0079791611,
0.0352006145,
-0.0657365099,
-0.0067944005,
-0.011004569,
0.0260927044,
-0.0271888673,
-0.001075662,
-0.0418681502,
0.0692227557,
-0.0731966197,
-0.0500140637,
0.0446307771,
-0.0008914757,
0.002074121,
-0.0164663158,
-0.0193243679,
-0.0061102128,
0.0337621383,
-0.0217507947,
0.0344481319,
0.0024023971,
-0.0181888994,
0.0138156703,
0.0278239939,
-0.0078646298,
-0.0340442359,
0.0165013261,
-0.0723690242,
0.0094921784,
0.0500005186,
-0.0365933515,
-0.061801713,
0.0286744721,
-0.0509141386,
0.0042454805,
-0.0418481752,
0.0432193801,
-0.0079770982,
0.0251193047,
-0.0365738831,
0.0485272482,
0.0255741887,
0.0072514117,
0.0783922523,
-0.0474122427,
0.0316743143,
-0.004398013,
-0.0074484427,
-0.037463259,
-0.0457842685,
-0.0059748562,
0.0661342666,
0.0543390401,
-0.0345886052,
-0.002378599,
-0.0966445953,
-0.0130900294,
-0.0230288226,
0.0110214949,
0.0898589194,
0.0419560261,
0.0009567347,
0.0205328111,
-0.0320253484,
-0.0223423522,
0.0363407582,
0.011522349,
0.0485163853,
0.0047265566,
-0.011354195,
-0.056579601,
-0.0136061264,
0.0423271731,
0.0445699804,
0.03246025,
0.0117844548,
-0.0100558475,
0.0490035415,
-0.0352592207,
-0.0620227493,
0.0373617373,
-0.0211599432,
-0.0353058949,
0.0050510555,
0.0499780476,
0.0302654095,
0.0498500057,
-0.0175835155,
0.0218772572,
0.0071444842,
-0.023712188,
-0.035403505,
-0.0292634461,
0.0183006246,
0.0206371024,
-0.061011631,
0.0640882477,
0.0291924551,
0.0012178486,
0.0197720472,
-0.0697296932,
0.0051539545,
-0.0254763365,
-0.0208339319,
-0.0454663001,
-0.0025900882,
0.0003206457,
0.0456522629,
-0.0265668351,
-0.066350624,
0.0537505932,
-0.0366277099,
0.0112282801,
-0.0548593849,
0.0098917605,
-0.0415862054,
0.0098146489,
-0.0086956816,
0.0462447554,
0.0133542614,
-0.0116053363,
-0.0288074538,
-0.0369649157,
0.0326884128,
-0.020364793,
0.0521236695,
-0.0652068332,
-0.0032384596,
-0.0194960684,
-0.005594403,
0.0021174867,
-0.0449573249,
0.0004917042,
0.0045038252,
0.0317973755,
-0.0240303073,
-0.0221541394,
0.0196308754,
0.0301760249,
0.0539962798,
-0.0471944138,
-0.0130702006,
-0.0072652996,
0.0337696634,
0.0510722175,
0.0056779627,
0.0376565605,
-0.0407171845,
0.0334326215,
0.0204316936,
0.0010174938,
-0.0164032485,
0.0185400117,
-0.0293808561,
-0.0168462321,
-0.0480488501,
0.0013393442,
0.0358472988,
0.0440492555,
-0.0409865007,
-0.015536136,
0.112983875,
0.0138631854,
-0.0097934492,
0.0135782361,
0.0128563344,
0.0771869645,
-0.0221474599,
-0.0065439562,
-0.0210951604,
-0.0220805742,
0.0216260776,
0.0529589765,
0.0173205696,
-0.0059633655,
-0.0148255341,
-0.0467385985,
0.0085842358,
0.0200817101,
-0.0667002425,
-0.0705805197,
-0.0263975691,
0.0138095422,
0.0019556198,
0.018478509,
0.0348291099,
-0.033112213,
0.034458749,
-0.0148405749,
-0.0977996886,
-0.0655397028,
-0.0580386519,
-0.0216546394,
0.0145968823,
0.0556860529,
0.0162297152,
0.0024035112,
0.0244957246,
0.057169307,
0.0049795294,
-0.0146235088,
-0.0190377198,
0.0469535924,
0.0541541167,
0.0296374355,
-0.0195682775,
0.0261156745,
-0.0064498619,
-0.0050943717,
0.0073968307,
-0.022198515,
0.0307292268,
-0.0313987322,
-0.0216430575,
0.0424221903,
-0.037507996,
0.0670503676,
0.0874370039,
0.0223025102,
-0.0603655316,
-0.0264133345,
0.0053791683,
-0.0840128437,
-0.0123039782,
-0.0159558468,
0.0012194605,
-0.0524680652,
-0.08481168,
-0.0527663454,
0.015188734,
-0.0101255365,
0.0025082428,
-0.0031235886,
-0.018126661,
0.0111747188,
-0.0316308178,
0.0019871432,
-0.0085795792,
0.0011472818,
-0.043895606,
-0.0038314327,
-0.0139094274,
-0.0103064142,
-0.0087342262,
0.0454018191,
-0.070724152,
-0.0375760123,
-0.0132257175,
0.039525874,
0.0279079396,
0.0344945863,
-0.0006707651,
-0.0194405485,
0.0478054397,
0.0187220052,
-0.019414207,
0.0687956214,
0.0242851712,
-0.0140326777,
-0.0031995396,
0.0209127348,
-0.0488350652,
0.0017248425,
-0.0369551219,
0.062419951,
0.0437766835,
-0.028611619,
0.0182024129,
0.0559252501,
-0.0029459812,
-0.0215012562,
0.0014245053,
-0.0071466756,
-0.0540203452,
-0.0543502979,
-0.0040440084,
-0.0507829785,
0.0429148823,
-0.006877793,
0.047380168,
-0.0069541605,
0.0738326833,
-0.0347906873,
-0.0047564558,
-0.0151623692,
-0.0116575174,
-0.0811856836,
-0.0037340347,
-0.0162387453,
-0.0332969129,
-0.0452850759,
-0.04932376,
-0.0590300113,
-0.0226921439,
-0.0153722204,
-0.010435652,
0.0084145544,
0.0254546218,
-0.0210185908,
0.0807786807,
-0.0592480637,
0.015956454,
-0.0355381444,
-0.0021083767,
0.0392352939,
0.0172675233,
0.1367059946,
-0.0008463323,
0.0000995411,
-0.0338585861,
0.0464016609,
0.031927444,
-0.0102343885,
-0.0563671589,
0.0052827722,
-0.0049037882,
-0.0023941502,
0.1042931899,
-0.0576570854,
-0.011928767,
-0.0091641033,
-0.005975021,
-0.0295457002,
-0.0384743586,
-0.0324787796,
0.0636695772,
-0.00734139,
-0.0604068823,
-0.0693726391,
-0.0391182117,
0.0082858885,
0.0101608839,
0.0298509393,
-0.0173852853,
0.0343860909,
0.0315978415,
-0.0183171295,
-0.0094933072,
-0.0338367745,
-0.0152087519,
-0.0232591908,
-0.0012523448,
-0.0329605415,
-6.346925994e-33,
-0.0149708427,
0.004233812,
-0.0289238356,
-0.0292954855,
-0.0638589114,
0.0192840584,
-0.100472413,
0.0029379406,
0.017050948,
0.0259022079,
-0.0046385801,
0.0013295236,
0.0092158988,
0.0326435044,
-0.0266079232,
0.0204015933,
0.054671146,
0.0057801688,
-0.0744254887,
0.0442075133,
-0.0131564457,
0.0020978162,
0.0049493574,
-0.05130684,
0.0056575094,
0.0032868371,
-0.06473618,
-0.0273046475,
0.0518802255,
0.0132478569,
0.0242712367,
0.0231766868,
0.0268812217,
-0.0218036007,
-0.0653115511,
0.0060773613,
-0.0471106954,
-0.0272613671,
0.0478825681,
-0.0549177974,
-0.076965563,
-0.0467210077,
0.0386136472,
-0.0267239269,
0.0002864822,
-0.0384451561,
0.0317792706,
-0.0415060893,
-0.0153570715,
-0.0478059836,
-0.0235266667,
0.0439594574,
-0.0464469977,
-0.0357701741,
-0.0006375932,
0.0466560647,
-0.0306613948,
0.0206674598,
0.0214773826,
0.069943808,
0.0651334077,
0.0516082421,
0.0568664484,
0.0067623397,
0.0112634888,
0.041345153,
0.0009896295,
0.0078517487,
-0.0155507084,
0.0288157072,
0.0183198452,
0.0116594844,
0.034320917,
0.0179751087,
0.0324043259,
0.0328750648,
-0.0341185331,
0.0909103528,
-0.0262012202,
0.0074373391,
0.0161796976,
-0.0184654798,
-0.0045359647,
-0.0238197539,
-0.0443508551,
0.0210312083,
-0.0169234257,
-0.026437737,
-0.0014569871,
0.0187000651,
-0.0636237487,
-0.047947675,
0.0218864679,
-0.0115978457,
0.0415561944,
0.0489859693,
-0.0365861021,
0.039524477,
0.0174573343,
-0.0342987888,
-0.0066797091,
0.0252145305,
0.0467515551,
0.0412654057,
0.0057382709,
-0.0024675666,
0.0268372465,
0.0151898982,
-0.0301939212,
0.0156917516,
0.0122639257,
0.0033926391,
-0.0214160345,
-0.0275476631,
-0.0229052138,
0.0046372167,
-0.0061578481,
0.0133060552,
0.0117806448,
-0.029593965,
0.0007328035,
0.0305103399,
0.041565679,
0.0212054085,
-0.0078454791,
0.013872005,
-0.0288288239,
-0.0104299607,
0.0573759004,
-0.0122014992,
-0.0368840285,
-0.0118942363,
2.694e-7,
0.058044605,
0.0394143648,
0.0561460219,
0.0117797852,
-0.0218223501,
0.0108984262,
0.0220987611,
0.0063920002,
0.0012915214,
0.0284732692,
0.0529097393,
0.0146726398,
0.0408275351,
-0.0033616794,
-0.0620583892,
0.0087142652,
-0.0742259473,
-0.0515808873,
-0.0152622722,
-0.0263210498,
0.0544852242,
0.0291002672,
-0.0362196714,
0.0122065032,
0.0142935859,
-0.018341817,
0.0065408689,
-0.0379134491,
0.0067926031,
0.0390942097,
0.0442139283,
-0.0231005047,
0.0095798234,
-0.0155685004,
-0.0105120493,
-0.0193049051,
0.0419616327,
0.0752219334,
0.0178517941,
0.0223410651,
0.003943197,
-0.0503663011,
0.0357576869,
-0.0421374366,
0.0474128909,
-0.0320452154,
-0.0016861043,
-0.0204737671,
-0.040480487,
0.0391072258,
0.0000521602,
-0.0057917163,
-0.0814069659,
0.0548409149,
0.0096489601,
0.0181894042,
-0.0128889605,
-0.0375931524,
-0.0859509632,
-0.0228005834,
-0.002292393,
-0.0374188162,
-0.0425002873,
0.0146615207,
0.0092253853,
-0.0454264097,
0.020595653,
2.862399917e-34,
0.0863405392,
-0.0231372062,
-0.0194417275,
-0.039865721,
0.0209837146,
-0.0381723307,
-0.0082673207,
-0.0117876977,
-0.0081025111,
-0.0757853091,
0.0038251188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14410v2 | Image Manipulation via Multi-Hop Instructions -- A New Dataset and Weakly-Supervised Neuro-Symbolic Approach | 2023-05-23T17:59:10 | 2023-10-24T20:44:09 | Harman Singh, Poorva Garg, Mohit Gupta, Kevin Shah, Ashish Goswami, Satyam Modi, Arnab Kumar Mondal, Dinesh Khandelwal, Dinesh Garg, Parag Singla | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | We are interested in image manipulation via natural language text -- a task
that is useful for multiple AI applications but requires complex reasoning over
multi-modal spaces. We extend recently proposed Neuro Symbolic Concept Learning
(NSCL), which has been quite effective for the task of Visual Question
Answering (VQA), for the task of image manipulation. Our system referred to as
NeuroSIM can perform complex multi-hop reasoning over multi-object scenes and
only requires weak supervision in the form of annotated data for VQA. NeuroSIM
parses an instruction into a symbolic program, based on a Domain Specific
Language (DSL) comprising of object attributes and manipulation operations,
that guides its execution. We create a new dataset for the task, and extensive
experiments demonstrate that NeuroSIM is highly competitive with or beats SOTA
baselines that make use of supervised data for manipulation. | [
0.0408166349,
0.0705074444,
-0.0139829265,
0.051088497,
-0.0432874672,
0.0289971326,
0.041755762,
-0.0092864279,
-0.0226793289,
-0.0341183431,
-0.0556678101,
0.0272012893,
0.0040236153,
0.0666025206,
0.0408755429,
-0.0400083773,
0.0453798324,
-0.0067828768,
0.0227616932,
0.0053038653,
0.0107336286,
0.0107511887,
-0.0123395566,
-0.0032328903,
-0.0673995838,
-0.0110692568,
-0.0431485251,
0.0124702677,
0.0156335514,
-0.0058425455,
-0.0244540107,
0.0174839441,
0.0759229064,
0.0081382683,
0.0000018992,
-0.0028143453,
0.0252654906,
0.0110571757,
0.0075805741,
-0.0279009659,
0.0022339975,
-0.0461456515,
-0.0001145412,
-0.0271615442,
-0.0539523996,
0.0112294983,
0.0542957373,
0.0535528511,
0.1074514091,
0.0701438636,
-0.0203462876,
-0.0167916082,
0.0185198635,
-0.0205980558,
0.0553808138,
0.0072463602,
0.016853122,
0.0208555833,
0.0068572205,
-0.0119563332,
-0.0258979257,
0.047785148,
0.0544811375,
-0.0279521979,
-0.0358912684,
0.031250976,
-0.0056830631,
0.0009816267,
-0.0242544599,
0.0605990887,
-0.0212835539,
0.0438212454,
-0.0281510856,
0.0135473199,
0.0065023364,
-0.0263292808,
-0.054559879,
0.02705306,
-0.0119568584,
-0.0181881543,
-0.0266735405,
-0.0210928302,
-0.015465769,
-0.0223019123,
0.0078272577,
0.0353872292,
0.0099038724,
-0.0014224834,
-0.0051488914,
-0.019295929,
-0.0793248564,
-0.0193068348,
0.0100831799,
0.0567503534,
-0.0168159921,
0.0376765653,
-0.0155895995,
-0.0320203342,
-0.02255545,
-0.0535070747,
0.0816178322,
0.0262351446,
-0.0232280865,
0.0584030747,
-0.0212235469,
0.0376908742,
-0.0183158834,
0.0830756575,
-0.0124433441,
-0.002699547,
-0.0685922429,
-0.0240976419,
-0.0413204692,
0.0689173862,
-0.0453325175,
-0.0235522576,
0.0136188632,
0.0263749771,
-0.0259037875,
0.0207688306,
0.004687367,
0.0341411084,
-0.0117492415,
-0.0048528505,
-0.058781784,
0.033067029,
-0.048147954,
0.0270439684,
-0.023834087,
0.0095011583,
-0.000417077,
0.0033031735,
0.0259726327,
-0.043551188,
0.0357571766,
0.0874166787,
-0.0556825772,
-0.014882124,
-0.0559769794,
-0.0456349403,
0.0070806923,
-0.0319719538,
0.0300450344,
-0.0537722856,
0.060405869,
-0.0213443078,
-0.0482228883,
-0.0681967288,
0.00542092,
0.0487792641,
-0.0094941193,
0.0866196454,
-0.0162531231,
-0.0621110126,
0.0352500267,
0.0200053453,
-0.0708835497,
0.0343704596,
0.0306777768,
0.0353768915,
0.0090724006,
0.0289532896,
-0.0016790574,
0.0186673105,
-0.0086003691,
-0.0063814032,
-0.0552217104,
0.0022080196,
-0.0396365263,
0.0299837496,
0.0239862949,
0.0514027961,
-0.038598083,
-0.0545568094,
0.0377660803,
0.0373607837,
-0.0240228232,
-0.0026442392,
0.0585313253,
-0.0287628565,
0.0213932153,
-0.0260640085,
-0.0981497169,
0.0924306065,
-0.0077360049,
-0.0169488266,
-0.0607405566,
0.0438500829,
-0.0250032358,
-0.058208026,
0.0506419875,
-0.0119733913,
-0.0059214178,
-0.0109162619,
0.0434910767,
0.0178553872,
-0.0146438284,
-0.0188808087,
0.0051540276,
-0.0003130706,
-0.0231197216,
-0.0324127488,
0.0460435785,
0.0476487949,
0.0224778373,
-0.0287748873,
-0.0165690612,
-0.0101806466,
0.0119236037,
0.0616942607,
-0.0466457717,
-0.0099057592,
0.0246542469,
-0.0122377891,
-0.0092467628,
-0.0839277506,
-0.0033094096,
0.0466725528,
-0.0084308451,
-0.0052526705,
-0.0075949328,
-0.0104508763,
0.0143131278,
0.0660095662,
0.0528499447,
-0.0037860472,
-0.0141698327,
0.0345635265,
0.0146422544,
-0.0099210283,
-0.0074925264,
-0.0053215399,
-0.0144377239,
-0.0485264994,
-0.0398488045,
-0.0367242396,
-0.0335465819,
-0.0669393912,
0.0399378389,
-0.0720291957,
-0.0158610623,
0.0211338289,
-0.0813129991,
-0.0140960449,
0.0585928783,
-0.0157055371,
-0.0423185378,
-0.0359261297,
-0.0382854454,
0.0737560466,
0.0038862978,
0.0024070526,
0.0679263696,
0.0042112456,
-0.0258360114,
0.0289343651,
0.037784256,
0.0071342532,
0.0036834646,
-0.0105541479,
-0.0097794635,
-0.0069026258,
-0.014420962,
-0.0110142771,
0.0285217874,
-0.0246108789,
-0.009360848,
-0.048947189,
-0.0102693969,
0.0002264232,
-0.0177128557,
0.0349632353,
-0.0098081594,
0.0228550844,
-0.0361000486,
-0.0376512446,
0.0458479002,
-0.0311612207,
0.0000107885,
0.0607004575,
0.0544695444,
-0.0083247423,
-0.0227100942,
-0.0132098747,
-0.0181717221,
0.0544323362,
0.038405396,
-0.0174466111,
-0.0197245833,
0.0073272991,
-0.0683381185,
0.0773335472,
0.0020413403,
-0.0134967091,
0.0175813567,
-0.0100541022,
-0.0069859861,
0.0938457996,
-0.0260957591,
-0.0183735061,
0.0179534107,
-0.0122579178,
-0.0305715688,
0.0243678801,
0.0350227058,
0.0200751107,
-0.005228247,
-0.0050058691,
0.0061227474,
0.0726591498,
-0.0093037663,
-0.0025075362,
-0.0347469412,
0.0434156507,
0.0223109275,
-0.0254457053,
-0.0598533787,
0.0178884473,
0.0143057415,
0.0035878157,
-0.0812920481,
-0.0497809798,
0.0983229503,
0.012939902,
-0.0211779661,
0.0285004508,
-0.012865941,
-0.0367244184,
0.1007448658,
0.0258867387,
0.0310277492,
0.0338284969,
-0.0069776219,
-0.0710013732,
-0.0175922103,
0.0034306918,
0.0325843133,
0.0457837023,
-0.0705633909,
0.0230601896,
-0.0208372232,
-0.0308207478,
-0.0142239491,
0.0281108432,
-0.0056355675,
0.0017281692,
-0.0015918235,
-0.0265144743,
0.0183889065,
-0.0188085847,
0.0218374524,
0.0725303367,
-0.0013060087,
-0.0329337679,
-0.0368624404,
0.0112038944,
0.0588921495,
0.0129036773,
-0.0661184639,
0.0086227385,
0.0064625763,
0.0603768267,
-0.022362005,
-0.0566361435,
-0.0625061765,
0.0658379421,
-0.0203008037,
-0.011231238,
0.009155306,
0.0159745291,
0.0136927022,
-0.0744337365,
-0.04806244,
0.0665345639,
0.0392277353,
-0.0249294061,
-0.0104164211,
-0.0125930328,
-0.030822549,
0.0565513,
0.0626302436,
-0.1063298136,
-0.0506660305,
-0.0436890237,
-0.0216655713,
0.0200520679,
-0.0173321199,
-0.0536447801,
-0.0711165443,
0.0319523215,
-0.0142592704,
-0.0774503052,
-0.0279091373,
-0.0086409301,
0.0042157662,
-0.0077625052,
-0.0402779318,
-0.0067899562,
0.0322032124,
-0.0053385925,
-0.0417722128,
0.0452537984,
0.017623106,
0.0517943762,
-0.0220067259,
-0.0107665993,
0.0152923763,
0.0099646347,
-0.0067221872,
-0.0405142605,
0.0533398129,
-0.0002396545,
0.0296850782,
-0.0165219121,
0.0684644282,
-0.0168373194,
-0.0435423441,
0.00285131,
0.0599471107,
-0.047068473,
-0.0383318327,
-0.0025384678,
0.0507719032,
-0.0222380776,
0.0068561709,
-0.022040775,
-0.0352022946,
-0.0090357503,
0.0147478133,
-0.0096198134,
-0.0312693976,
-0.0304400008,
-0.0199270751,
-0.042745892,
-0.0142375706,
-0.0067379246,
-0.0040501682,
0.0103397574,
0.010639336,
-0.0632233173,
-0.0097248806,
0.071154587,
0.0552277528,
0.0066000372,
-0.0453419052,
0.024142215,
-0.0127284611,
-0.0525778085,
0.0439914167,
-0.042051971,
0.0308394041,
-0.0196433552,
-0.0188108291,
0.0142109087,
0.0025222192,
-0.0269768089,
-0.0141732339,
-0.0359298512,
-0.0250804927,
-0.0366234221,
0.0927105993,
0.0106070833,
0.0337748826,
0.0059498311,
0.0161889642,
0.0018717883,
0.0431607999,
-0.0121029606,
-0.0130484486,
0.0041769845,
-0.007367237,
0.0020727231,
0.0191732142,
-0.0187981632,
0.043370001,
0.0226633996,
0.00655891,
-0.0132170431,
0.0522865392,
0.0342683904,
0.0072471807,
0.0186026655,
0.0213003661,
0.0109882187,
-0.0268208906,
0.0085503682,
-0.0096639367,
-0.0028471684,
-0.0678800493,
0.0102976402,
-0.0130428188,
-0.0010331814,
0.007882582,
-0.0362127647,
0.0155044328,
0.0041125324,
0.0285167266,
-0.0352941342,
0.0515817665,
0.0208841041,
-0.0330054648,
0.0163387246,
-0.0009276815,
-0.004302518,
-0.0199264921,
0.0686334893,
-0.0250016227,
0.075612478,
0.0538976677,
-0.0068200938,
-0.0674479604,
0.0458010621,
-0.038182687,
-0.0149101308,
-0.0135519225,
0.0005202935,
0.0349651203,
0.0394738428,
-0.0317472406,
-0.0343523286,
-0.006704676,
0.0342067517,
0.0205603782,
0.0227436274,
-0.0342201702,
0.0539416373,
0.0461937338,
0.0441456139,
-0.0126128411,
0.0531214662,
-0.0677331984,
0.044606898,
-0.0029487528,
0.0079757357,
-0.0577862151,
-0.0279992111,
0.0306865592,
-0.030772958,
0.0008196984,
0.0120516224,
-0.0175285898,
-0.0691730157,
-0.0157947447,
0.0344575159,
0.0022881741,
0.0537616387,
0.0457739793,
0.014799295,
0.0430857353,
-0.0316753574,
0.0313549563,
-0.0345048718,
0.0388316736,
-0.0431161374,
-0.0235585365,
-5.624607124e-33,
-0.0377190709,
-0.019222606,
0.0639038458,
0.0079585724,
-0.0053784349,
-0.0056929193,
-0.0215503909,
-0.0076471367,
-0.0109346453,
0.0080661466,
0.000287557,
-0.0030514654,
-0.0033841787,
0.0421041884,
0.0109331636,
-0.0229659732,
-0.0044977232,
0.000141905,
-0.04060065,
-0.0052081826,
0.0402813405,
0.0009979681,
0.0468092933,
-0.0118711423,
-0.0145547315,
0.0661695823,
-0.0139515474,
0.0282449014,
-0.0174999516,
0.0206339359,
0.0014555834,
-0.0043998724,
0.0231191106,
-0.0162280984,
-0.0039306921,
0.0022495168,
-0.0847746059,
-0.0617944822,
0.019330781,
0.0259847008,
-0.0668810159,
-0.0000280178,
0.0219195504,
-0.0254749916,
0.0532082282,
-0.0171865877,
0.0259986296,
-0.0307493303,
0.042737335,
-0.0102982856,
-0.0408855267,
-0.0216940325,
-0.0139401713,
-0.0210998151,
-0.026505705,
-0.0212255791,
0.0258655548,
-0.0156250596,
-0.0440218672,
-0.0097539416,
-0.0095955385,
0.0146172857,
0.0328904428,
-0.0052733012,
0.01814612,
0.0272815879,
0.0494262204,
-0.0312255807,
-0.0006824681,
0.0239117704,
0.0175092053,
0.0781831741,
0.0350176021,
0.0296076294,
0.0837622508,
0.0552094616,
-0.0424750373,
0.0051010577,
-0.0349289551,
0.110563077,
-0.03615655,
0.0141344285,
0.0278420039,
0.0031741895,
-0.0317791328,
0.0153269311,
-0.0480866171,
-0.0448717736,
0.0293908659,
0.0053964136,
-0.0121736676,
0.0170716476,
0.0214585699,
-0.0299641583,
-0.0203101654,
0.0000204833,
0.0049087158,
0.0592007451,
0.0113104321,
-0.0013636013,
-0.0063917311,
-0.0276783034,
0.0617166944,
-0.0125162527,
0.0238214023,
0.0074342247,
0.0723609701,
0.0750806183,
-0.0493295081,
-0.0055131484,
-0.0543218888,
0.0084120752,
-0.0025843168,
-0.0021076554,
-0.0062270537,
0.0033973213,
-0.0619634427,
-0.0107065607,
-0.0372270197,
-0.0311426148,
-0.012107091,
0.0045401836,
-0.0134717058,
0.0219600759,
-0.0353075825,
-0.0059850542,
-0.0305813439,
-0.0339678787,
0.0113448789,
-0.0787953734,
-0.0007918486,
0.0269605219,
2.67e-7,
0.0194729678,
0.0050064251,
0.0385615639,
0.0620399602,
0.0191895533,
0.0197452921,
-0.0458984151,
0.0071802041,
-0.0143571403,
-0.0662758201,
0.0026995763,
0.0663706809,
-0.0264157727,
0.0171729773,
-0.030239312,
0.0368066095,
0.031612251,
-0.0231324881,
-0.0721223503,
0.010651351,
0.0641983673,
0.1038671583,
0.016936006,
-0.0353147164,
0.0213925373,
-0.0517681204,
0.0557775646,
0.0016837398,
0.0378314145,
-0.0364169441,
-0.0256942175,
-0.0188246612,
-0.00894784,
0.0507354699,
-0.0049572717,
-0.0262794476,
0.0062825629,
0.0350997373,
-0.0293076485,
-0.0299993437,
-0.0293229669,
-0.0042736395,
-0.0173438117,
0.0081109405,
0.08191026,
-0.1028685123,
-0.0335397162,
-0.0103935776,
-0.0211715922,
0.0082549732,
-0.0001991139,
-0.0131263863,
-0.000497896,
0.0175228361,
0.0104301274,
-0.0039664977,
-0.0200721417,
-0.0597251579,
-0.0182413701,
0.0156690236,
-0.005680277,
0.0066357693,
-0.0486794375,
0.0033170364,
0.0306982119,
-0.0283299591,
-0.054182753,
2.030238078e-34,
0.0153399045,
-0.0247321632,
0.0258466005,
0.0437261164,
0.0466914997,
-0.0028594434,
-0.0734619424,
-0.0025604591,
0.0078616505,
-0.0102898823,
-0.0279493593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14337v2 | Anchor Prediction: Automatic Refinement of Internet Links | 2023-05-23T17:58:21 | 2023-05-24T07:12:33 | Nelson F. Liu, Kenton Lee, Kristina Toutanova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Internet links enable users to deepen their understanding of a topic by
providing convenient access to related information. However, the majority of
links are unanchored -- they link to a target webpage as a whole, and readers
may expend considerable effort localizing the specific parts of the target
webpage that enrich their understanding of the link's source context. To help
readers effectively find information in linked webpages, we introduce the task
of anchor prediction, where the goal is to identify the specific part of the
linked target webpage that is most related to the source linking context. We
release the AuthorAnchors dataset, a collection of 34K naturally-occurring
anchored links, which reflect relevance judgments by the authors of the source
article. To model reader relevance judgments, we annotate and release
ReaderAnchors, an evaluation set of anchors that readers find useful. Our
analysis shows that effective anchor prediction often requires jointly
reasoning over lengthy source and target webpages to determine their implicit
relations and identify parts of the target webpage that are related but not
redundant. We benchmark a performant T5-based ranking approach to establish
baseline performance on the task, finding ample room for improvement. | [
0.04539942,
-0.0108001521,
-0.0250826459,
-0.0143891843,
0.0101127075,
-0.0131993005,
0.0299614947,
0.0039195432,
0.0684711114,
-0.0543803312,
-0.0576878451,
0.0617890283,
-0.0391952321,
-0.0089862123,
0.0124219805,
-0.0518474653,
0.0088689905,
0.0222605169,
-0.0046613421,
0.0289250053,
0.0096469168,
0.0286224,
0.0079480158,
0.0024196564,
0.0388893336,
-0.0073652598,
0.0078709107,
0.0244840384,
0.0476101376,
-0.0308286864,
0.023756953,
0.0498607457,
-0.0091128657,
-0.0241365675,
0.0000017659,
-0.012283626,
-0.0271589719,
-0.0392713062,
-0.028916005,
0.0489174388,
-0.0031894327,
0.0079592913,
0.0186760239,
-0.0187810883,
-0.0050234846,
0.0309864208,
-0.0255797766,
0.0713278651,
0.0373267233,
0.0181481633,
0.0095244693,
-0.0057889442,
0.0160120931,
0.0165309664,
0.0708568394,
-0.0446458757,
0.0204321425,
0.0215795375,
-0.0440564007,
0.0500905141,
0.0093913507,
0.0164287705,
-0.0184999313,
-0.0224794075,
0.0912493616,
0.025874896,
-0.0464161746,
0.0120085571,
0.0194525141,
0.1023811996,
0.0114927413,
-0.045225177,
0.0492581241,
0.0236998647,
-0.0064426046,
0.088515386,
-0.0552264415,
-0.0298439208,
-0.0267549064,
-0.0083048986,
0.0129887704,
-0.0060143261,
0.0287284572,
0.0183623377,
0.0330199115,
0.0805115998,
-0.0246648658,
-0.0035037752,
0.03881412,
0.0417213924,
0.0337225236,
-0.0461809337,
0.0669340119,
0.0129200919,
0.0080954842,
0.0207454115,
-0.0089796288,
0.0142123671,
0.028664913,
-0.0618828945,
-0.0316498503,
-0.027869666,
-0.0001545335,
0.0253641941,
-0.0587365106,
-0.0337581113,
-0.0361476541,
-0.0427260511,
-0.0124692023,
0.0329208747,
-0.0309155416,
-0.020390613,
0.0004467437,
0.0274199229,
-0.0109661398,
-0.0194516852,
-0.0067368508,
0.011968161,
-0.0250651222,
0.0114352684,
-0.0167616326,
0.0127101038,
-0.0477341898,
-0.0016461851,
-0.0403646976,
0.0113226827,
-0.0567612536,
0.0057806727,
-0.0070287292,
-0.004806079,
0.0196751337,
0.0133434115,
0.0065029273,
-0.0439935029,
-0.0041030142,
0.0319005474,
0.0044484758,
-0.0177511945,
-0.0682149902,
-0.0846026093,
0.0511298738,
-0.0345180109,
-0.0060847811,
-0.0435323864,
-0.0164814088,
0.0401480608,
-0.0022334545,
-0.0332350768,
-0.0033778897,
0.0630092397,
-0.0460360907,
0.0304916371,
0.0186869781,
-0.0379843749,
0.0314725116,
0.0406828336,
0.0182574037,
0.0172773749,
-0.0523574315,
0.0647795796,
0.0428066999,
0.058791697,
-0.0520369709,
-0.05124446,
0.0646477193,
0.0129596209,
0.0702215061,
0.0388647616,
-0.0398394875,
0.0239618737,
0.0094005158,
-0.0021606798,
-0.0396328494,
-0.0168874878,
0.0223543886,
0.0216656644,
0.0378492773,
0.0457562059,
0.0379215367,
0.0309308525,
0.0041138511,
0.0262705497,
-0.0430582464,
0.0614570342,
-0.0233564228,
-0.0154527742,
0.0301757436,
0.0124742128,
-0.0329910889,
-0.0297104605,
-0.0028660961,
0.0359968394,
-0.0341198854,
0.0072192764,
0.0501593985,
-0.0004975816,
-0.0308648106,
0.0383922942,
-0.0068531553,
0.0039267959,
0.0358108319,
0.025284674,
-0.004775506,
0.0510933734,
0.0348781124,
-0.0503090993,
-0.0522888824,
-0.0384690799,
0.036620684,
-0.0276172198,
0.0005919327,
-0.033161521,
-0.0566280745,
-0.0129711498,
-0.0358001143,
0.0109308278,
-0.0108445249,
0.0093993759,
0.00708682,
0.0215301458,
0.0421075039,
-0.0532295853,
0.0206367895,
0.0237856023,
-0.012902257,
0.0298251901,
-0.0298960451,
-0.007368851,
0.0060405233,
0.0406119525,
0.0264411326,
-0.0234131068,
0.0482322685,
0.0096136695,
-0.0220075622,
-0.0147459432,
-0.0027107564,
0.0302370321,
0.0514623746,
-0.0986797586,
0.0201458577,
0.0030440527,
0.0164092667,
-0.0118584745,
0.0639967918,
0.0169752222,
-0.0163991898,
0.0097365147,
-0.0186886508,
0.0194789134,
-0.0192213114,
-0.0355004221,
0.0640719011,
0.015379901,
0.0227118414,
0.0690892786,
-0.0324693136,
-0.0320638753,
-0.0555566065,
0.0072262133,
-0.0744621977,
-0.0010748738,
0.0005678355,
0.0687868148,
-0.0103206411,
-0.0629995763,
0.0186397079,
-0.0466558002,
0.003673427,
-0.019642923,
0.0339621343,
0.0139790867,
-0.0197407287,
0.0070546875,
-0.0144675728,
-0.0243608598,
-0.0169996005,
-0.0756902099,
-0.0210225843,
0.0210603662,
0.0534644164,
0.0021066351,
-0.0537639819,
-0.0316206366,
-0.0226999745,
0.0428077132,
0.0585099384,
-0.0299673192,
-0.034474384,
-0.0138483485,
-0.0126662217,
-0.0279938243,
-0.0418123528,
0.0179210752,
-0.0528999604,
-0.0087327315,
-0.009450228,
0.0634964556,
-0.0150339743,
0.0481386818,
0.0556366146,
-0.0041236738,
-0.0811172873,
0.0068141855,
-0.020474473,
0.0566620044,
-0.0361997262,
-0.0121375006,
0.0078970501,
0.0082367137,
-0.0164962746,
-0.0274422839,
0.0009268046,
0.0212464146,
-0.0198262408,
0.0153386947,
-0.0710918978,
-0.014275413,
0.0142808883,
0.0661226735,
0.0154431155,
-0.0032118629,
0.0384153239,
0.0357462168,
0.0598872676,
-0.0339812748,
0.0224594716,
-0.053916119,
0.0051133209,
-0.016563816,
0.0109573388,
-0.0330745652,
-0.016334435,
-0.0028281459,
0.0793399885,
0.0476823784,
-0.0109143695,
0.0486227758,
0.0130093256,
0.0335737392,
0.0160164628,
-0.0360244699,
-0.0057573426,
-0.0365888849,
-0.0250714049,
-0.0424225181,
-0.0154937068,
-0.0205483977,
-0.0419594049,
-0.0069453358,
0.0480704121,
0.0115302913,
-0.0258782972,
-0.0688880309,
0.0338441506,
0.0297502782,
0.0578292869,
-0.0493993685,
-0.0305826366,
-0.0034006741,
-0.0167714674,
0.0466587469,
0.0046436656,
-0.0354056805,
0.0109667368,
-0.0190043934,
0.0351325311,
-0.0926720724,
-0.0454415865,
-0.0023550831,
-0.0088807149,
-0.0190301668,
-0.0055449796,
0.0881437808,
0.0750094429,
-0.0667062029,
-0.0381080247,
-0.0363300592,
0.0258240122,
0.0186110605,
0.0312397368,
-0.0744491518,
-0.0087002357,
0.0188789628,
0.0125389537,
0.0088323057,
-0.0109691536,
0.0404439718,
-0.0763508379,
0.0165832862,
-0.014755724,
-0.0077817193,
-0.0197679419,
-0.0756380707,
0.0235806257,
-0.0276452471,
-0.0601759255,
0.0669265389,
-0.0417172387,
0.0138414344,
0.0205695815,
-0.0098841283,
-0.00603715,
0.0122605944,
-0.0199559685,
-0.0149383321,
-0.0054056789,
0.0333042815,
-0.0030065726,
-0.0049056481,
0.0312043615,
-0.052984532,
0.0107201608,
-0.006745025,
0.0872764811,
-0.0462580323,
0.0713900477,
-0.0746356025,
0.0590808168,
0.0171186123,
0.0017949686,
0.0098441746,
0.0595709607,
-0.0103369281,
-0.0007965863,
-0.0410064422,
0.0035927822,
-0.0473291837,
0.0272983704,
0.0029208797,
-0.0232716016,
-0.0107449889,
-0.0284399912,
0.0393143073,
-0.0141525725,
-0.0593467653,
0.0187890567,
-0.0562364198,
-0.0310152825,
-0.1030383334,
-0.0221624561,
0.0025638405,
0.0105764717,
0.0114462217,
0.008405488,
-0.0038259765,
-0.0269640405,
-0.0565482043,
0.0092663001,
-0.0157346297,
-0.0036575224,
0.0131958732,
0.003690575,
0.0750295669,
-0.0643791556,
-0.0186046269,
0.0260419976,
0.0020996707,
-0.003298827,
-0.0183195565,
-0.0033662366,
0.0216538869,
0.0387601256,
-0.0418536402,
-0.0290822219,
-0.0258320179,
0.024257591,
-0.0447774716,
0.003275437,
-0.0045059258,
0.0046351324,
0.0035414032,
0.0304905493,
-0.0933638886,
0.0224374477,
-0.0293753594,
-0.0187819079,
-0.0164496079,
-0.0319220796,
0.0231895912,
0.0265766904,
0.056296058,
0.0110121276,
0.0516414493,
-0.0274132565,
0.0285707973,
0.0156680644,
-0.0325796455,
0.012561054,
0.0546541139,
0.0376017205,
-0.0034429522,
-0.0197556708,
0.0237617083,
0.0300032813,
0.0230651945,
-0.0702448562,
0.0081616445,
0.0573657453,
0.0262044072,
-0.0345080048,
0.0142866438,
-0.0354239307,
-0.065179795,
0.0375322476,
0.0514419824,
-0.010317008,
0.0023540165,
0.0526511446,
0.0073378193,
-0.0290795267,
0.015212005,
-0.0748973638,
0.0447550826,
-0.0270220861,
-0.0403348468,
0.0467800684,
-0.0175887421,
0.0584197566,
-0.0136709148,
-0.0401247591,
0.0080727963,
0.028163882,
0.0159291271,
-0.0051602032,
-0.0126977023,
0.0358287506,
0.0104575083,
0.0608806759,
0.0655962229,
-0.0273588765,
0.0163043812,
0.0084461644,
-0.0742396936,
-0.0324414968,
0.0135493046,
-0.0380076692,
0.0626888424,
0.0188100394,
-0.0266252067,
-0.0162454136,
-0.034259472,
0.0524032451,
-0.0037345716,
0.0295944549,
-0.0121371709,
0.0553141162,
0.0776778758,
0.0054894499,
-0.0493974127,
-0.0427264497,
-0.0093953116,
-0.0548888594,
-0.0095563,
-0.0426375493,
-6.149060908e-33,
-0.0193304736,
-0.0282354224,
-0.0441416986,
0.0469930433,
-0.0427772999,
0.0298982766,
-0.0111512998,
-0.0165599082,
-0.0438128673,
0.0052096006,
-0.0012627258,
0.0188789163,
0.0139432121,
-0.0098591419,
-0.0022166877,
-0.0147116138,
0.0315293558,
0.0227090176,
-0.0173693132,
0.0476970188,
0.0474911146,
-0.0059839366,
0.0192964543,
-0.0697862431,
0.0438685492,
-0.0268029477,
-0.0233637933,
-0.0294041373,
0.0335278697,
0.068859987,
0.0020436111,
0.0294685271,
0.0379807502,
-0.0482513495,
0.0315347426,
0.0097773224,
-0.1414327472,
-0.0254346225,
0.0222893022,
-0.0199749693,
-0.0311123002,
-0.0273506567,
0.0501000099,
0.0227403343,
-0.0086231967,
-0.0442506522,
0.0748645961,
0.0151352277,
-0.033185441,
-0.0595286004,
-0.0080338214,
0.046346575,
-0.0644459799,
0.0421663448,
-0.0193513446,
0.0498832539,
-0.0006599872,
0.0184430983,
-0.0515967458,
0.0005183074,
-0.0282957722,
0.0669102147,
0.0438177697,
-0.0135921007,
0.0015558529,
0.042297449,
0.0129052661,
0.0125389984,
-0.008155915,
0.002167501,
-0.0249897223,
-0.0339442641,
0.0084266346,
0.0310830921,
0.0077263238,
-0.0048412564,
-0.0831957906,
0.0539923906,
0.0371093005,
0.0207470637,
0.0292001534,
0.0329929814,
-0.0001993447,
-0.0221560374,
-0.042705562,
-0.0035673971,
-0.0255303308,
-0.0501781851,
0.0049744863,
0.0232089665,
-0.0391578004,
0.0325575024,
-0.020646425,
-0.010612241,
0.0146561591,
0.0630873442,
-0.0135378493,
0.0493064113,
0.0101621561,
-0.0560427792,
-0.0390555188,
0.0280079003,
-0.03517171,
-0.0240891539,
0.0137154087,
-0.0241136681,
0.0223864205,
-0.0368712619,
-0.0363741852,
-0.026858842,
0.0054020095,
-0.0384785905,
-0.031944856,
-0.0177488513,
0.0397793911,
-0.0011634228,
-0.0392395258,
0.0690033734,
0.029006958,
0.0603499562,
0.0029388224,
0.007957452,
-0.001633975,
-0.023565324,
-0.0128315249,
0.0011214458,
0.0098595675,
0.0279997624,
-0.0385377817,
-0.0934571177,
-0.0155401928,
0.0076774512,
2.579e-7,
0.0293773469,
0.0607775673,
0.038651444,
-0.0125321001,
0.0094607882,
-0.0299864952,
0.0459670722,
0.0383084677,
0.0315312929,
-0.0244616102,
0.0057448042,
-0.0008130521,
-0.0310097076,
0.0134237492,
-0.0991329998,
-0.0294331163,
-0.051649671,
-0.0547775291,
-0.0024420721,
-0.0496801175,
-0.0134085175,
0.020344682,
0.0077752559,
0.0394545272,
0.0199420322,
-0.0251584817,
0.0184998363,
0.001035388,
0.0043927338,
0.0181015041,
0.033247795,
0.0057401359,
-0.0378490761,
0.0154811731,
-0.0252306629,
0.0226333961,
0.0596115142,
0.0289522503,
0.0178107619,
-0.003380019,
0.0007515969,
-0.0346329696,
0.0476631224,
-0.0116623361,
0.0596839935,
0.0145504577,
-0.0192663167,
0.080136165,
-0.0509507656,
-0.0178448856,
-0.0114390329,
0.0143579897,
-0.0063831047,
0.0420226753,
-0.0524054877,
0.0117735919,
-0.0226059612,
-0.1041520685,
-0.0591334216,
0.05747848,
-0.0158209968,
0.0029883306,
0.0092534535,
-0.016392827,
0.0015026495,
-0.0515234433,
-0.0118801715,
1.78501997e-34,
0.0048795305,
0.0112138409,
-0.0295991972,
-0.0119661437,
0.0521612093,
-0.0157296695,
-0.0574795753,
0.01979932,
0.0563693754,
-0.0532913692,
0.0129152499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14336v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14336v3 | Schema-Driven Information Extraction from Heterogeneous Tables | 2023-05-23T17:58:10 | 2024-03-12T18:54:12 | Fan Bai, Junmo Kang, Gabriel Stanovsky, Dayne Freitag, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we explore the question of whether large language models can
support cost-efficient information extraction from tables. We introduce
schema-driven information extraction, a new task that transforms tabular data
into structured records following a human-authored schema. To assess various
LLM's capabilities on this task, we present a benchmark comprised of tables
from four diverse domains: machine learning papers, chemistry literature,
material science journals, and webpages. We use this collection of annotated
tables to evaluate the ability of open-source and API-based language models to
extract information from tables covering diverse domains and data formats. Our
experiments demonstrate that surprisingly competitive performance can be
achieved without requiring task-specific pipelines or labels, achieving F1
scores ranging from 74.2 to 96.1, while maintaining cost efficiency. Moreover,
through detailed ablation studies and analyses, we investigate the factors
contributing to model success and validate the practicality of distilling
compact models to reduce API reliance. | [
0.0162330624,
0.0678424612,
0.0058600619,
0.0240975656,
-0.0357386731,
0.0327231698,
-0.0246668253,
0.0466207378,
0.0231056865,
-0.0455893762,
-0.0370171517,
0.0073428699,
-0.0320480056,
0.0437699258,
0.0100330766,
0.0237191357,
0.0261402298,
-0.004794057,
-0.0028469963,
0.048509188,
-0.0142991599,
-0.0268523898,
0.0006691339,
-0.0235708635,
0.0265496746,
0.028453473,
-0.0113940313,
-0.0213417467,
-0.0273852088,
-0.0004640232,
0.002341548,
0.0651883557,
-0.0059235082,
0.0269512832,
0.0000019459,
-0.0299420562,
-0.0683322176,
0.0221262872,
-0.0068311687,
-0.0081980545,
0.0490542389,
-0.0542150587,
-0.0269587841,
-0.0110968109,
-0.0377321579,
-0.0180841424,
0.0179936811,
0.0201576483,
0.0146898525,
0.0547697768,
-0.021189848,
-0.0586859547,
0.0251637101,
0.0005729796,
0.0455917157,
-0.043849159,
0.0112165725,
0.0226101615,
0.0005959034,
-0.023904264,
0.0347060636,
0.0553894043,
-0.0127536608,
-0.0194808617,
0.0183681492,
0.0192398019,
-0.0769348145,
0.0126042329,
-0.0187800694,
0.0718396679,
0.0182166528,
0.0005894964,
0.0376164801,
-0.0123554738,
-0.0034022939,
-0.0043803849,
-0.0302491914,
0.0193055831,
-0.0060034082,
0.0031909903,
0.0299416687,
-0.0163050871,
0.0115485741,
-0.0178658795,
-0.0301833693,
0.0628649667,
-0.0347264968,
-0.0416210517,
0.0330641754,
-0.0109281298,
0.0208126046,
-0.0156366043,
-0.0062923855,
0.0122856256,
0.0254506655,
0.0281471498,
-0.0064489623,
-0.0517610461,
0.0366034359,
-0.0426550768,
0.0419543609,
0.0191640817,
-0.0072619468,
0.0343018807,
-0.0157688744,
-0.0176246595,
-0.0017530839,
0.0228800718,
-0.0097553823,
-0.0141668934,
-0.0426672436,
0.0164396372,
-0.0007641011,
0.0547712967,
-0.0710066035,
-0.008958187,
-0.0223627277,
0.0232970808,
-0.0057210773,
0.0622635297,
0.0191806834,
-0.0083632935,
-0.0006493786,
-0.0092205796,
-0.027600741,
-0.0092859101,
0.0307332221,
-0.0273388904,
-0.0151821775,
-0.0845773444,
0.0013312666,
-0.0071208128,
0.0312291309,
-0.0187784955,
0.0462732129,
0.1112135649,
-0.017102465,
-0.0188564919,
-0.0649660677,
-0.0417028666,
0.0036723223,
-0.0285921451,
0.0061477488,
-0.0337316431,
0.0724591091,
0.0190970469,
-0.0185615607,
-0.0931030363,
0.010700929,
0.0081970701,
-0.0480385497,
0.0525864027,
-0.053663265,
0.0067049055,
0.0016397473,
-0.0247674938,
-0.0496023409,
0.0833465531,
0.0267112739,
0.0230271071,
0.017601192,
-0.0208596792,
-0.0080946237,
0.0599946529,
0.0085199913,
-0.0120014027,
-0.0063507906,
0.0281719249,
0.0539380759,
0.0138164274,
-0.0047951397,
0.0088634714,
0.0061376281,
0.035777282,
0.051675424,
0.0380840562,
0.0155833177,
0.0493558571,
-0.0133767677,
0.0080340737,
0.064057,
-0.0174161475,
-0.0194997471,
0.0052887741,
-0.011542202,
0.0194045287,
0.0188323408,
0.01504575,
0.022743579,
-0.0556815565,
-0.0122523159,
-0.0071535972,
-0.0128702819,
-0.0115403393,
0.0771675184,
-0.002599614,
-0.0445283763,
0.0439352691,
0.0188312847,
-0.0808814764,
-0.030587228,
0.0189053752,
0.018916402,
0.0566335544,
0.0464972183,
-0.1125792563,
0.003571169,
0.0125850448,
0.0053373761,
0.0366296284,
0.037628606,
-0.0565962382,
0.0211835187,
0.0071062869,
-0.0286238696,
0.0400313511,
0.0293264017,
-0.0407838374,
0.0374724157,
-0.0268867929,
0.0060539795,
-0.0681137517,
-0.076480329,
0.0449515693,
-0.0317521952,
-0.0188553743,
-0.0185380429,
-0.0034245907,
0.010653222,
0.0390622802,
-0.0093848752,
0.0344048105,
0.0636647865,
-0.0483352244,
0.0208339747,
-0.0335784666,
0.0460552499,
0.0515856855,
0.0255985223,
0.033415366,
-0.0267018769,
-0.0444675088,
-0.0290650688,
0.0022963244,
-0.0178131107,
0.0320165828,
-0.0038469895,
0.0066154655,
0.017439317,
0.0169566702,
0.0231251139,
-0.0377368741,
0.0615724102,
-0.0128243603,
0.0062040156,
0.0082798032,
-0.1353314519,
0.0103876395,
0.0031202796,
0.0231311247,
0.0185347628,
-0.0082691517,
0.0400606468,
0.0084723299,
-0.0023165022,
-0.0746869147,
-0.0321580507,
-0.0466639102,
0.0340193249,
-0.0014878445,
0.0524067543,
0.0180005003,
0.0025627622,
-0.022400856,
-0.0212903079,
-0.0316064619,
-0.0080953594,
-0.0494888909,
-0.0246167574,
0.0751822665,
0.0045276354,
-0.0190992933,
-0.0534850135,
-0.0136092361,
-0.0460874736,
0.0269015748,
-0.0103080841,
-0.0342680924,
0.0031317566,
-0.0029519482,
0.0247170385,
0.0423332341,
0.0109095946,
0.0342758559,
-0.0244385973,
-0.0302291811,
0.0100543909,
0.0543310307,
-0.0154339019,
0.0272881258,
0.0408090912,
-0.0295814667,
-0.0121688573,
0.0014331337,
-0.0086694462,
0.0294932015,
0.0055706007,
-0.0799129382,
0.0829128027,
0.0165625177,
-0.0468728542,
0.0308500528,
-0.0004076898,
-0.0071499366,
0.0162546672,
-0.0195513777,
-0.0422631241,
0.0908668339,
0.015051364,
0.0312265791,
0.0157476235,
-0.0068352413,
-0.0009490888,
-0.0591569543,
0.0405795872,
-0.0078883823,
-0.0044106329,
-0.0529902391,
0.0745527148,
-0.0038031719,
-0.0036936961,
0.0095363371,
-0.0123742344,
-0.001229801,
-0.0022485775,
0.0171679799,
-0.0475371778,
0.1145139039,
-0.0594287515,
0.0250525959,
-0.033879146,
-0.0112025281,
-0.0015138497,
-0.0378111191,
-0.014348587,
0.0299532581,
0.0233154874,
-0.020680083,
-0.0367727987,
-0.0035308858,
0.0305320062,
0.049449496,
0.009276812,
-0.0171447638,
-0.0271147713,
0.0386646166,
0.020874057,
-0.0328984037,
-0.034469679,
0.0006045244,
0.0207819548,
0.0574805401,
-0.0075626019,
-0.0151299303,
-0.0084913187,
0.012568756,
0.0074017178,
-0.0537428111,
-0.0022197741,
0.0368734226,
-0.0557748452,
-0.0509759188,
0.0078264633,
0.0789350569,
0.0265860744,
-0.0242546834,
-0.0253645703,
-0.0001528428,
0.0034463687,
-0.0024588378,
0.0404980965,
-0.1187345609,
-0.0175631642,
0.0057537546,
0.0260761455,
0.0297282729,
-0.0614447109,
-0.0270761326,
-0.0843203291,
0.04915905,
-0.0261228923,
-0.0817301273,
-0.0669426173,
-0.041267287,
-0.0029665355,
-0.0440451726,
-0.005325478,
0.0660092905,
-0.0442256406,
-0.0107908426,
0.0197522603,
-0.0661825985,
-0.0634840503,
-0.0070943064,
-0.0301966574,
0.0188174229,
0.03030934,
0.0190228168,
-0.0284085143,
0.0003548692,
0.020511819,
0.0103259692,
-0.0027164035,
-0.0467176139,
0.0807144046,
-0.0037109391,
-0.008815879,
0.0203953627,
-0.0030875637,
-0.0496929884,
0.0109986411,
0.0229114275,
0.0797139928,
-0.01020402,
0.0025229591,
0.0015484989,
-0.0615663379,
0.0025860607,
0.0675264373,
0.0155080399,
-0.0008955409,
-0.0649450496,
-0.0088527771,
-0.0755477548,
-0.0340445042,
0.0200932603,
0.0438479185,
-0.075031735,
-0.0427803136,
-0.0359200872,
-0.0110880118,
0.0277309604,
0.0006376914,
0.0032928013,
0.0698605627,
0.0062309108,
0.0139619298,
-0.0748834386,
-0.0140886167,
-0.061492078,
-0.0091525353,
-0.0439480059,
-0.0531383082,
0.0123077799,
-0.0158893019,
-0.0269794054,
0.0261199325,
-0.0266942009,
-0.0322714001,
0.0238149632,
0.0043567638,
0.0235506278,
0.0035709357,
0.0223703217,
-0.0083568003,
-0.028771868,
0.0435080603,
-0.0604020767,
-0.0355758145,
0.0050105704,
-0.0428989641,
0.0033459254,
0.0180239603,
-0.0218150653,
0.0101551004,
-0.0244522002,
0.0296613779,
0.0031302916,
0.0026973106,
0.0501941666,
0.0617156066,
-0.0002777136,
0.0177049749,
-0.0593966283,
-0.0059498516,
0.0220606849,
-0.0354612246,
-0.0462160334,
-0.0141853662,
0.0177875478,
0.0023087317,
-0.0333125554,
-0.0137839019,
0.0323033221,
0.0188431069,
0.0385985076,
-0.0385294929,
0.0208849944,
0.0091711432,
-0.0025204537,
0.0469531566,
-0.0544418059,
-0.0120757706,
-0.0256109443,
0.0026345151,
0.035426911,
-0.0205504727,
-0.0186388697,
0.0149879679,
-0.0187489856,
-0.0233449526,
0.0526627339,
-0.0322888233,
-0.0140436552,
-0.0131606935,
-0.0050533484,
0.0176217072,
0.0149809755,
0.0554923192,
-0.042271167,
-0.0217908025,
-0.0016240675,
0.0233354755,
0.0551851094,
0.059467189,
0.0270636734,
-0.0060868533,
-0.0404197201,
-0.0292212218,
0.1030082703,
0.0411795937,
-0.0034404958,
-0.0036492639,
-0.025797084,
-0.0611095279,
0.0022296079,
0.0021138566,
-0.0320490412,
-0.0333432183,
-0.0427232198,
-0.0392631702,
-0.0150964297,
0.0406982526,
0.0393377841,
-0.0209147986,
-0.0060502295,
-0.0120790005,
0.0934917182,
0.06603688,
-0.0150284525,
-0.0540913902,
0.0435684919,
-0.0155141875,
-0.0427481979,
0.0398750566,
-6.438332435e-33,
-0.0392411165,
-0.0205028355,
0.0214277338,
0.0108779632,
0.0136833377,
-0.0011659146,
-0.0581896044,
-0.0071499259,
0.0194353573,
-0.0026644601,
-0.0341686197,
0.0105803041,
0.033235874,
-0.0286052059,
0.0529730655,
-0.0497796014,
-0.0016931166,
-0.0083008697,
-0.0067722551,
-0.0279480908,
0.0357053988,
0.0506945252,
0.0300587565,
-0.0548860617,
0.0529257581,
0.0115683554,
0.0078875246,
-0.0309980139,
0.0391667746,
0.0116387857,
-0.0476574302,
0.032279335,
0.0285204686,
-0.0422290824,
-0.0094785644,
0.0019112886,
-0.1543467045,
0.0027887721,
0.0089641605,
-0.0032236187,
0.0055649984,
-0.0080097551,
0.0406511463,
0.0011697237,
-0.0250766072,
-0.0190639868,
0.0232422408,
-0.0466038398,
-0.0286025312,
-0.0277601369,
-0.0457253717,
0.0362527594,
0.0463310778,
0.0583805703,
0.1059437022,
0.0151257506,
-0.0016480759,
0.0265082363,
-0.0311992597,
0.0008069423,
-0.0110448357,
0.0485059135,
0.0445884615,
-0.015558471,
0.025025852,
0.023056468,
0.0042037615,
0.0229756292,
-0.0098537952,
-0.0015972099,
-0.0127552459,
0.0696533918,
-0.0001637012,
-0.0120823504,
0.014343719,
-0.0000123677,
-0.0858360007,
0.060520865,
0.010407974,
-0.0435723625,
-0.0276371166,
0.0039617098,
-0.0152749699,
-0.0099143814,
0.0069487835,
0.0145122269,
-0.003996545,
0.0012379067,
0.0000282817,
-0.0235284381,
-0.0074986694,
-0.018964693,
-0.0060604895,
-0.0108481906,
-0.0388071463,
0.0445073731,
-0.0161960497,
0.0250409245,
-0.011903041,
-0.0352173001,
-0.0409026258,
-0.0474786572,
-0.0331026688,
-0.0107258242,
0.0485083237,
0.0295306835,
0.0350526609,
0.0276702698,
-0.0484164022,
-0.0209858511,
-0.043633718,
0.026413206,
0.0292126872,
0.032292787,
-0.0024230287,
0.021590285,
0.017163828,
0.015896054,
0.0486894064,
0.0450355113,
0.0110963276,
0.0421639085,
0.014041556,
0.0039739613,
0.0252574254,
0.0071718725,
-0.0333974175,
0.0113675902,
0.0291603263,
-0.010792275,
0.0085957814,
0.0038502174,
2.58e-7,
0.1052147001,
0.0286426675,
0.0454361588,
0.0583853126,
0.0021735993,
0.0133701265,
-0.0078545492,
-0.0142905759,
-0.0337113738,
-0.0307119265,
0.0496424437,
-0.0359118991,
0.072620064,
0.0496623069,
-0.0484898947,
-0.0498189777,
-0.0320073701,
-0.0422840416,
-0.0408582501,
0.0097461203,
0.0040897382,
0.0276954174,
-0.0480489768,
-0.0185233131,
-0.034544751,
0.0012662179,
0.002343745,
-0.0796748176,
0.0489575714,
0.0481725298,
0.0598813556,
-0.0041689868,
-0.0121665653,
0.0550430492,
-0.0436356328,
0.0051458259,
0.0054823193,
0.0535047203,
-0.0147984866,
0.0442612618,
0.0354865268,
-0.102466695,
0.0421834551,
-0.0311523825,
0.065301165,
0.0004626487,
-0.0189382248,
0.0434990488,
-0.0229993518,
0.0122076375,
-0.0298111364,
-0.0122089814,
0.0096589047,
0.0145089347,
0.0140157752,
-0.0135532515,
-0.0222800896,
-0.0368618444,
-0.0322941914,
0.0518826842,
0.0129661085,
-0.0095861955,
0.0036667737,
-0.0090381484,
-0.0431294702,
-0.038461484,
-0.0002138456,
2.580284487e-34,
0.0492650755,
0.0233933758,
0.0054241261,
0.0712267533,
0.0552599989,
-0.0138373571,
-0.0115214065,
-0.0103417886,
-0.0604081005,
-0.0857171714,
0.0145888459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14333v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14333v2 | Automatic Model Selection with Large Language Models for Reasoning | 2023-05-23T17:57:59 | 2023-10-23T14:46:07 | James Xu Zhao, Yuxi Xie, Kenji Kawaguchi, Junxian He, Michael Qizhe Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and Program-Aided Language Models (PAL) represent two
distinct reasoning methods, each with its own strengths. CoT employs natural
language, offering flexibility and interpretability, while PAL utilizes
programming language, yielding more structured and rigorous logic. We introduce
a model selection method to combine the best of both worlds by employing a
large language model (LLM) to dynamically select between them. Our theoretical
analysis underscores the feasibility of this method, which is further
corroborated by empirical results. Our proposed method demonstrates significant
performance improvements across eight reasoning datasets with Codex, ChatGPT,
and GPT-4. Additionally, our method is complementary to self-consistency; when
integrated, it can further enhance performance while significantly reducing
computation costs. Moreover, we achieve new state-of-the-art results on GSM8K
and SVAMP, with respective accuracies of 96.8% and 93.7%. Our code, data and
prompts are available at https://github.com/XuZhao0/Model-Selection-Reasoning | [
0.0006753822,
0.0850911289,
-0.012218006,
0.0307406113,
-0.0690073296,
0.0271888115,
0.0352417454,
-0.0029714424,
0.0572557524,
-0.0438927151,
0.0058532115,
0.0044842325,
-0.0159814321,
0.0128782718,
0.0244531874,
-0.0349179246,
0.0461057164,
-0.0782127678,
0.0335906036,
-0.0118427174,
-0.0250467937,
0.0347661972,
0.0023494423,
0.0189354792,
0.0253964942,
-0.0313385762,
-0.0097785415,
-0.0143712824,
0.0147518301,
-0.0440353863,
-0.0316637643,
0.048817981,
0.0291598514,
0.0522573404,
0.0000024707,
-0.0419440903,
-0.0433073081,
0.0027923638,
-0.0546629652,
0.0067050694,
-0.0172794834,
0.0206574295,
-0.0028570341,
0.013963433,
-0.0234366804,
-0.0166845154,
0.0272824448,
0.0206711553,
0.0679579005,
0.0345735103,
-0.0081687439,
-0.0518748388,
-0.0041206786,
-0.011980487,
-0.0155422138,
-0.0441258177,
0.0503201857,
0.0888742879,
0.0289182626,
0.0404615887,
0.0264768116,
0.0277483594,
0.0115491077,
-0.0219921991,
-0.0122686224,
0.0313465558,
-0.0515395664,
-0.0165471807,
0.0250606686,
0.0687856078,
-0.0041804295,
-0.0487581976,
0.01557294,
0.0109618129,
-0.0197793283,
0.0007284729,
-0.040553242,
0.0383516364,
-0.035086032,
0.0351486765,
0.0417783894,
-0.0225218795,
0.0507196896,
0.0328080654,
-0.0622971654,
0.0889415815,
0.02099685,
-0.0327585228,
0.04154424,
-0.015145516,
-0.0537382402,
-0.0908225775,
0.0139946146,
0.0351121463,
-0.0565953851,
0.0286180228,
-0.0031942371,
0.0196026992,
-0.0114033865,
-0.0222867075,
0.0306394175,
0.0577895604,
0.0149526596,
0.0704556927,
-0.0379347205,
0.0421138406,
-0.0270421468,
0.0249132067,
-0.0169944186,
-0.0182365533,
-0.0899029002,
-0.0176773965,
-0.0128403781,
0.037354283,
-0.0030788037,
-0.0023875553,
-0.0382389612,
-0.0033470883,
-0.0057043852,
0.0177406576,
0.011343915,
-0.0244245231,
0.0269608404,
-0.0151900155,
-0.0248921271,
0.027925292,
-0.0528941415,
0.0210044906,
0.0028700843,
-0.0205306914,
0.0111327302,
-0.0064244498,
-0.0329808258,
-0.0403027721,
0.0298319571,
0.0618862808,
-0.00105342,
0.0090287905,
-0.0492985509,
-0.0235903729,
-0.0003764968,
-0.100617677,
0.0009021208,
-0.0796925277,
0.0141827408,
0.0325794592,
-0.0160330273,
-0.0239293594,
-0.0055057439,
0.0328759812,
-0.0198696852,
0.0838862062,
-0.0143497037,
0.014611234,
0.0193305854,
0.0164953582,
-0.0322969146,
0.0531427711,
0.0165504552,
0.010196154,
0.036688447,
-0.0085419063,
-0.0067182332,
0.0151987914,
-0.0149628241,
-0.0179253276,
-0.0317941308,
0.0284143463,
0.0085915448,
0.0056966185,
-0.0449248031,
0.0409311391,
-0.029223904,
0.0014216509,
0.0428568758,
0.0485074036,
0.0144048119,
0.0362559147,
0.0296441037,
-0.0023990674,
0.0285872482,
-0.0386746675,
-0.0580356531,
0.0178929251,
-0.0667696148,
0.0076671927,
0.000418222,
0.0423329361,
-0.0212659687,
-0.0470746867,
-0.0415692218,
0.0355193205,
0.0095605282,
0.0346294232,
0.0661121458,
-0.0134028606,
-0.0183451977,
0.0554754548,
0.0191339403,
-0.0278758351,
-0.0583239906,
-0.048005376,
0.0471284613,
0.0303565431,
0.0378486067,
-0.029862823,
-0.0113960579,
-0.0064571905,
0.0087091066,
0.0084768431,
-0.0025438992,
-0.0053240736,
-0.0384232178,
-0.0550788008,
-0.0213460717,
0.0244768336,
0.0003973594,
-0.0066279029,
0.0102145812,
0.0104376012,
0.0071408963,
-0.0317098014,
0.0013101958,
0.0223024599,
-0.0060147857,
0.0053079403,
-0.0000943921,
0.0020009661,
0.0377462395,
-0.0032993825,
0.0119712027,
0.0083158417,
0.0062382896,
-0.0088988123,
-0.0310197603,
-0.0095546274,
-0.0591995716,
-0.0466028117,
0.0328467451,
0.0178815816,
-0.04376911,
0.0140285892,
-0.0514976531,
-0.0291550346,
0.0524278395,
-0.0085878968,
0.0030871823,
-0.0382016189,
0.0239315908,
-0.0093917223,
-0.0310428962,
-0.035677027,
0.1104126424,
0.0227215569,
-0.0215756204,
0.0360888466,
0.0469224751,
0.0464445576,
-0.0190358255,
0.0036160825,
0.0585427023,
-0.0121141849,
-0.0080636293,
0.0107819587,
0.0090189511,
-0.0587505437,
-0.0105235921,
-0.0867347792,
0.0113970693,
-0.0044715921,
0.0114572011,
-0.0210851617,
-0.0268054456,
0.0068205311,
0.0215998646,
-0.0227591861,
-0.005473813,
0.0167897996,
0.0204750784,
0.007855515,
-0.0309730638,
-0.027401004,
-0.0144613106,
-0.038390778,
-0.0376205742,
0.0738111883,
0.004602015,
-0.0092634037,
-0.0401758291,
0.0225427207,
-0.0709035918,
0.0075046285,
-0.0239434019,
-0.0032427087,
0.0250791721,
-0.0262192357,
0.0000414886,
0.0714287311,
-0.029424116,
-0.0120195448,
0.0873944834,
-0.010394128,
-0.0332317464,
0.012504125,
0.0203228705,
0.0006247095,
0.0148240952,
-0.003482555,
-0.0216397084,
0.0567788184,
-0.0028931331,
-0.0007144534,
-0.0335547365,
0.0262352284,
-0.0105518447,
0.037157394,
-0.023295816,
-0.031330701,
0.0170905031,
0.0751796588,
0.0094811106,
-0.0292929392,
0.0906269923,
-0.0136471046,
0.0028856643,
-0.0599263757,
0.0136141162,
-0.0269768499,
0.0708521977,
-0.0215956941,
-0.0067344452,
0.0190837514,
0.0092892544,
-0.0137690436,
-0.0475830995,
0.0419222713,
-0.0142295389,
0.0559777617,
-0.0762148872,
0.032999564,
0.0194791369,
-0.0500536188,
-0.0418695509,
0.0154592004,
-0.0868002474,
0.0362751521,
-0.0155410487,
-0.0011407293,
0.0026447007,
-0.0013583419,
0.010450311,
0.0061608148,
-0.0154380677,
-0.0110242032,
-0.0224348176,
-0.0039985487,
0.0200854465,
-0.027641369,
0.0368944146,
0.0087196957,
0.0600923784,
0.030524049,
0.0282805506,
-0.0092224265,
-0.046995014,
0.0353557877,
0.006401021,
-0.0001683717,
-0.0346469693,
0.027844673,
0.0342227332,
-0.0667849183,
-0.0095877871,
0.1369092017,
0.0289764311,
-0.0507678986,
-0.0160513557,
-0.0499270037,
0.0323287398,
0.0293834321,
0.0455507748,
-0.0468958169,
-0.071761094,
0.0307565704,
0.0099611506,
-0.0001607889,
-0.0457882397,
0.0078646699,
-0.0819794685,
0.033977177,
0.0106219733,
-0.013587106,
-0.0111946361,
-0.067837581,
0.0188885611,
-0.0179916508,
-0.0371307172,
0.0402427167,
0.007746228,
-0.0165816545,
-0.0131130265,
-0.0320784561,
-0.0231225528,
0.0858443528,
-0.00832495,
0.0171804633,
0.0638490319,
0.0267727841,
0.0014811313,
-0.0649242997,
0.0577480718,
0.0003181829,
-0.0193259399,
-0.053955216,
0.0077131344,
0.0254940502,
0.0002379628,
-0.0444159023,
0.0593567826,
-0.0234196,
-0.0213434584,
0.00903212,
0.1170510948,
-0.0094366977,
-0.0341720805,
0.015035823,
0.01374151,
-0.0200543404,
0.072536476,
0.0025630016,
-0.0017840054,
-0.0698226988,
-0.0504109003,
-0.0589048155,
0.0077655218,
-0.0335178375,
0.0148640526,
0.0167422369,
-0.007027647,
-0.0109424246,
0.0186735932,
0.0459155254,
0.0384790003,
-0.0054692673,
0.04755136,
0.0525474362,
0.028733518,
-0.0079581859,
0.0398082435,
-0.0537922382,
0.0154273529,
-0.0353509523,
0.002656087,
-0.0134433955,
-0.0431934781,
-0.0238602608,
0.019302126,
-0.0571714975,
-0.0557133444,
-0.0219103787,
0.0353225581,
0.0299754646,
0.0373363644,
-0.0125336079,
-0.0279814471,
-0.0161905512,
-0.0030285164,
-0.0119940918,
-0.0182005465,
0.0184776243,
0.0125288898,
-0.0010619899,
0.043067079,
-0.0160463005,
0.0371292457,
0.0221875738,
0.0341347605,
-0.0062098331,
0.0033536369,
0.0316876881,
0.0646653473,
0.0281351991,
-0.0048164264,
-0.0295765232,
-0.0253013875,
0.021221472,
-0.0279502328,
-0.0311619919,
-0.0301612355,
0.05066837,
0.0051352158,
-0.0451491885,
0.003933629,
-0.079824701,
-0.0048659965,
-0.0015969214,
0.011362928,
0.0073618186,
-0.008611233,
0.0590968356,
0.0451729223,
-0.0510301627,
-0.0315033048,
-0.0046356446,
-0.0026936177,
0.0441564694,
-0.056884028,
0.0924034491,
0.0451995395,
-0.012485791,
-0.0533232801,
-0.0026912675,
-0.0523137301,
-0.093443267,
0.0369363092,
-0.0013391271,
0.0457151532,
-0.013119963,
0.025855964,
-0.0545442142,
-0.0277996175,
-0.0221423283,
0.0459906161,
0.0644304827,
-0.0353360139,
0.0069168801,
0.032231722,
-0.0322858617,
-0.0227300432,
0.033896178,
-0.0113560082,
0.0065459749,
0.0430910848,
-0.0539226159,
-0.0396171957,
-0.0231545307,
-0.0482376143,
-0.0108708218,
-0.0195125137,
-0.0067160996,
-0.0637805387,
-0.087344937,
-0.0355017819,
-0.0142489821,
-0.0142905479,
0.0145304268,
0.0295952987,
0.0920629576,
0.024815768,
-0.0150564415,
-0.0038788563,
0.0125838295,
-0.0141852796,
-0.0244953372,
-0.0325451866,
-6.575100468e-33,
-0.0013375873,
-0.0336056203,
0.0373754948,
-0.0316537172,
0.0014957684,
-0.0322657526,
-0.0591360219,
0.0093404381,
-0.0302765239,
0.0203306153,
-0.012100474,
-0.003728871,
0.0011102582,
0.0191288758,
0.0077189975,
-0.0083966749,
0.0105042718,
0.0321863294,
-0.0211116057,
0.0181100033,
0.0456979908,
-0.0103968577,
0.0255410317,
-0.0642150789,
-0.0003637171,
0.0132711409,
0.0145527767,
0.0280968156,
-0.0708931759,
0.0664099678,
-0.0138653852,
0.0188143644,
0.022900559,
-0.0467772223,
0.0125055676,
0.0046443497,
-0.0556488372,
-0.0252979156,
0.0332535729,
-0.0314950421,
-0.0295550823,
-0.0424036384,
0.0010583044,
0.0029215151,
-0.0117963981,
-0.0486478098,
0.016000282,
-0.0425860025,
-0.0220689531,
0.0167227667,
-0.0499959067,
0.0409920923,
-0.0249971319,
-0.025113672,
0.0154338023,
0.0402085446,
-0.0470442064,
0.0364187621,
0.0122040929,
0.00319929,
0.0424661748,
0.0047746524,
0.0833690315,
0.0087698195,
0.0195370093,
0.0553506985,
-0.0322166197,
-0.0292416327,
-0.0644616857,
-0.003413917,
-0.0150337648,
0.0769348964,
0.062455602,
-0.0156677533,
0.0179860238,
0.0152190784,
-0.1328558326,
-0.0195403676,
0.0030003085,
0.0521041341,
0.0437173508,
0.016419895,
-0.0474729203,
-0.0259042587,
-0.0317412242,
-0.034874782,
-0.0503315777,
-0.0180061329,
0.0301384535,
-0.0285980739,
-0.0420955643,
-0.0210496429,
0.0347950682,
-0.0241965521,
-0.0307052191,
0.0406635739,
-0.0262465924,
-0.0221115872,
0.0111323791,
0.0527142659,
-0.0113955596,
-0.0031208529,
-0.0019234359,
0.0018275206,
0.0322878994,
0.0022077879,
-0.0012953138,
-0.0126191257,
-0.0095871044,
-0.0043305359,
-0.0615524538,
-0.0224561933,
-0.0095321592,
0.0195576269,
0.0444420762,
0.0196570661,
0.0158660468,
0.0531656072,
-0.0087504778,
-0.0096583311,
-0.0195424035,
0.0206916686,
-0.0027573772,
0.0265646018,
0.0023679531,
-0.0105803348,
-0.0342865065,
0.0071546002,
0.0196258612,
-0.0327496491,
-0.0168922581,
0.0245928951,
3.087e-7,
0.0211567655,
0.0585798547,
-0.0225006063,
0.0368455984,
0.0113968756,
0.0536778122,
-0.0159195475,
-0.0274501741,
0.0309978239,
-0.0295295697,
-0.0261320639,
0.0499004573,
0.0613206662,
0.0568960942,
-0.0242062379,
-0.0024605207,
-0.0357909873,
-0.0205305703,
-0.0663634911,
-0.0045869243,
0.1001667976,
0.0844580606,
0.0128758308,
-0.0116067529,
0.0136910854,
-0.024300646,
0.0223332644,
-0.0183004886,
0.0239914972,
0.0092179719,
0.0109064793,
-0.0147260698,
0.0038318776,
0.0511456989,
0.0172382016,
-0.0155230183,
-0.0016629447,
0.0666695684,
0.0152587332,
0.0125343623,
-0.0146987308,
-0.0222892836,
0.0389356501,
-0.0923062637,
0.11425253,
-0.0547079034,
-0.0461401716,
0.0198347196,
-0.0130001446,
-0.0361318961,
0.0166773517,
-0.0025419886,
-0.0020969296,
0.0169113148,
-0.0152686564,
-0.0162679814,
0.0120785553,
-0.0755469278,
-0.0183629096,
0.0214877371,
-0.0491868295,
-0.0201294068,
-0.0432583056,
-0.012359363,
0.0505813994,
-0.0480305962,
0.0280046575,
3.227635654e-34,
0.0116034141,
-0.0140216183,
0.0204915889,
0.0099864416,
0.0545803718,
-0.0039422852,
0.0116324285,
0.0225128122,
0.0080058398,
-0.1055365354,
-0.0086255996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14332v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14332v2 | Evaluating and Modeling Attribution for Cross-Lingual Question Answering | 2023-05-23T17:57:46 | 2023-11-15T17:15:31 | Benjamin Muller, John Wieting, Jonathan H. Clark, Tom Kwiatkowski, Sebastian Ruder, Livio Baldini Soares, Roee Aharoni, Jonathan Herzig, Xinyi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Trustworthy answer content is abundant in many high-resource languages and is
instantly accessible through question answering systems, yet this content can
be hard to access for those that do not speak these languages. The leap forward
in cross-lingual modeling quality offered by generative language models offers
much promise, yet their raw generations often fall short in factuality. To
improve trustworthiness in these systems, a promising direction is to attribute
the answer to a retrieved source, possibly in a content-rich language different
from the query. Our work is the first to study attribution for cross-lingual
question answering. First, we collect data in 5 languages to assess the
attribution level of a state-of-the-art cross-lingual QA system. To our
surprise, we find that a substantial portion of the answers is not attributable
to any retrieved passages (up to 50% of answers exactly matching a gold
reference) despite the system being able to attend directly to the retrieved
text. Second, to address this poor attribution level, we experiment with a wide
range of attribution detection techniques. We find that Natural Language
Inference models and PaLM 2 fine-tuned on a very small amount of attribution
data can accurately detect attribution. Based on these models, we improve the
attribution level of a cross-lingual question-answering system. Overall, we
show that current academic generative cross-lingual QA systems have substantial
shortcomings in attribution and we build tooling to mitigate these issues. | [
0.0677038059,
0.0170097221,
-0.0281499065,
0.0641795844,
-0.0148986205,
-0.0079779411,
0.0248837173,
-0.0453204662,
0.0297117736,
-0.0186769553,
-0.0400533602,
0.0080308057,
-0.0118408836,
-0.0095736301,
0.0463790447,
0.0081358086,
0.0088339867,
-0.0118311634,
0.0202089977,
-0.0352207273,
0.0045674937,
0.030234037,
0.0174083766,
0.0331639461,
0.0194120761,
-0.0290176552,
0.066774711,
-0.0423901007,
0.0502957404,
0.0087302867,
0.0188533105,
0.0491863638,
-0.0388906412,
0.0117625976,
0.0000017257,
-0.0359578393,
0.0248752832,
0.0008367031,
-0.0234673098,
0.0170311667,
-0.0057497271,
0.0373177901,
0.0052967728,
0.0085444832,
-0.0408029445,
0.0039480212,
-0.0013152992,
-0.0055491393,
0.0535042137,
0.0069235442,
-0.0082690921,
-0.0212009996,
-0.0013417419,
-0.0122614158,
0.02455342,
-0.0400920883,
0.015959546,
0.0163307022,
-0.0162067264,
0.0429710522,
-0.0081611304,
0.0519107468,
0.038813334,
-0.0177971292,
0.0272334386,
0.004714543,
-0.0007620468,
0.0197641794,
0.0107658841,
0.048917491,
0.0233346783,
-0.0508263595,
-0.0003790349,
0.0158847496,
-0.0093514696,
0.04901921,
-0.0281646233,
0.0258955788,
-0.0160407797,
-0.026884215,
0.0596296266,
0.0118574211,
0.0107970955,
0.028165536,
0.0336223803,
0.0549035631,
0.0158559624,
-0.0024763886,
-0.0050152629,
0.0337900221,
0.0188601967,
-0.0691718683,
0.0107636917,
0.0157935768,
0.0280776024,
0.0197419822,
0.0170169547,
-0.0248560309,
0.0577642247,
-0.0223394837,
-0.0396608599,
-0.0035850946,
-0.0401560217,
0.0691805109,
-0.0345576964,
0.0153879048,
-0.0374514274,
0.0167488698,
-0.0360926241,
-0.0636651963,
-0.02591905,
-0.0057017095,
-0.0303633027,
0.001093141,
-0.0125847654,
0.0393257961,
-0.0623121262,
-0.0011776227,
-0.0075383037,
-0.0161325112,
0.0187689383,
-0.004553475,
-0.0174304377,
0.0087146265,
-0.049268052,
0.05714247,
-0.0792978033,
0.0400157496,
-0.0183878038,
-0.0801377147,
-0.0115468465,
0.0237939954,
-0.0052883555,
-0.0443257205,
0.0155171193,
0.0641930923,
0.0137123661,
-0.0014358456,
-0.0292691663,
-0.0515013412,
0.0054104202,
-0.0594683029,
-0.0285563748,
-0.0776922256,
0.0279149245,
0.0477875993,
-0.0179188233,
-0.0157010276,
0.0007839988,
0.031253241,
-0.0414496213,
0.0381282605,
-0.0136653828,
0.0072977836,
0.0369968601,
-0.0178476069,
0.0001648036,
0.0130296098,
0.0161827914,
0.0194297004,
0.0519289374,
0.0242532566,
0.035664048,
-0.0025612365,
0.0263136402,
0.0050845714,
0.0708291605,
0.0469076931,
-0.0005856666,
-0.04362005,
0.0219750702,
0.0420528688,
-0.0209028032,
-0.0170852244,
0.0474405214,
0.0367118157,
-0.0457599573,
0.0534138493,
0.0346362665,
-0.0215740055,
-0.0090757562,
-0.0062441621,
-0.0237429403,
0.0779910162,
0.0036077399,
-0.0343399234,
-0.0023434155,
0.0645812228,
-0.0314349346,
-0.0355214626,
0.0073573967,
-0.0057274415,
-0.0050866115,
0.0387650654,
0.0261123236,
0.0089055579,
0.0147595713,
0.0290306434,
0.0040147873,
-0.0550622009,
0.0542561337,
-0.0281359497,
0.071210593,
0.0403687581,
0.0046543092,
0.0011987892,
0.0248659551,
-0.0338611789,
0.0429848731,
0.0190428738,
0.0276513882,
-0.0189145133,
0.0123040052,
-0.0220456868,
-0.0403113626,
-0.0011541825,
-0.007670518,
0.0282499101,
0.0043296465,
0.0584810525,
0.0079773227,
-0.0617501624,
-0.0242108833,
0.0019283263,
-0.0148242349,
-0.0015269802,
0.021089837,
0.0266583599,
0.0242809355,
0.0524689481,
0.0067961216,
0.0092182141,
0.0126940729,
-0.0373884924,
-0.0101587856,
0.0433661304,
-0.0078035193,
-0.0065302216,
-0.0068277931,
-0.0754502714,
-0.0211090334,
-0.0150903985,
-0.0248915553,
-0.0419918969,
0.0302974228,
-0.0442226715,
-0.0119427247,
-0.0462863855,
-0.0195263978,
-0.0044274102,
0.006110779,
-0.0205321591,
0.0833981186,
-0.0010062223,
0.0625799745,
0.0100391451,
-0.0122381691,
0.0715946332,
-0.0270087663,
0.0076952749,
-0.0151837217,
-0.0130037284,
0.0092951758,
0.057699509,
-0.0190847442,
-0.0129238656,
-0.0105621852,
-0.0216628332,
-0.019953493,
-0.0194729399,
0.0470134877,
0.0171356518,
0.0022738397,
0.0156555567,
-0.0147829214,
-0.102674596,
-0.004211429,
0.0192686692,
0.0058159637,
0.0279652309,
0.0235124119,
0.05007964,
-0.0505941212,
0.0053348267,
-0.0043547219,
0.0137504339,
0.0586876459,
0.0094368719,
-0.074813351,
-0.0027697752,
-0.0546953343,
0.0127310343,
-0.0025582137,
-0.0577350147,
-0.0234391671,
0.023781307,
-0.00059747,
0.0597356558,
-0.0122000156,
-0.0531570502,
0.0302198362,
-0.00015917,
-0.0565291122,
0.0069059799,
-0.0284916013,
-0.03401912,
-0.0068105385,
-0.0687045157,
0.0170853548,
0.0515385866,
0.0206175689,
-0.0225468911,
-0.0334767886,
0.0170667861,
-0.0361250564,
-0.0208630264,
0.0058523701,
-0.0075670565,
0.0328690447,
0.0603115223,
-0.0149849029,
-0.0028501321,
0.0866742656,
-0.007565788,
0.011999147,
-0.047266122,
-0.0002987596,
-0.0502955876,
0.0073688533,
-0.0305534862,
0.0360015854,
0.0185761023,
0.0005824647,
-0.0287190303,
-0.0161180981,
0.0792706981,
-0.0110724745,
0.0015874418,
-0.0114470618,
0.0050582937,
-0.0061206436,
-0.0384467728,
-0.0244492292,
-0.0432754681,
-0.0179396309,
-0.0057338243,
0.0107130622,
-0.0175205562,
-0.0120996861,
-0.0195706636,
0.0826195031,
-0.0443212241,
-0.0297534727,
-0.0039274185,
-0.0040946989,
0.0721116215,
0.0469179749,
0.0017929169,
0.0473823771,
-0.0233973488,
-0.0348672606,
0.0272513945,
0.0022497156,
-0.0104976073,
0.037141487,
-0.0318754017,
0.0404063053,
-0.0200615618,
-0.0528051704,
-0.024516955,
0.0674294382,
-0.0524827242,
-0.0165535994,
0.0700241178,
0.0180033408,
-0.0500147082,
-0.0452006198,
-0.0519714691,
-0.0098026237,
0.0332173593,
0.0383692756,
-0.1157480553,
-0.0179132856,
-0.0567203276,
0.0116540827,
-0.0064973142,
-0.0093156248,
0.0099129332,
-0.1319043636,
0.0274551716,
-0.0453645512,
-0.0515371598,
-0.0189634766,
-0.0690873638,
-0.0095108952,
-0.0265998859,
-0.0418644957,
-0.0159171056,
0.0119472481,
0.0123766297,
0.0303542167,
0.0145524498,
0.0008682492,
0.0541598611,
-0.0625128299,
-0.0047636088,
0.0393632874,
0.0518311523,
-0.0252419133,
-0.0645957589,
-0.0502304323,
-0.0948537737,
-0.0207849592,
-0.0054408573,
0.0329548009,
-0.0184441376,
-0.0172430072,
-0.017190177,
0.0335941575,
-0.0131574068,
0.0304794125,
0.0434191823,
0.0896527469,
0.047239203,
-0.0056188321,
-0.0239173267,
-0.0158960931,
0.0203276407,
0.0918162167,
0.0034987666,
0.000250107,
-0.0415799767,
-0.0077053187,
0.0018327917,
-0.0106726475,
-0.0254807286,
0.0523337573,
-0.0103291003,
-0.0676208809,
-0.0826426744,
-0.0611409657,
-0.0001200609,
-0.0210877825,
0.0219737142,
0.0376182534,
-0.0078511629,
-0.0161246546,
-0.0063555054,
-0.000498684,
-0.0807384625,
0.0478885621,
-0.0085000591,
0.0174049288,
0.0289567448,
-0.0403602794,
0.0045783473,
0.0227956362,
-0.022801809,
-0.0197314844,
-0.0424058996,
0.0702093244,
0.0154940691,
0.0084293708,
-0.0650976673,
-0.0529281646,
0.0282293335,
-0.0090381503,
-0.0395357683,
-0.0199287646,
0.0174810793,
0.0143152298,
0.0016237933,
0.0387553424,
-0.0679743513,
0.0180320349,
0.0097249048,
-0.0017481582,
-0.0477819629,
-0.0421909764,
-0.0001303022,
0.0055685784,
0.0014367228,
0.0082848864,
0.0345561951,
-0.0172610916,
0.0281832535,
-0.0247859284,
-0.0019453958,
-0.001500019,
0.0195274744,
0.0204734672,
-0.0210950766,
0.0216861367,
0.0019438027,
-0.0142378937,
0.0369941369,
-0.0421798229,
0.0408539437,
0.0487982333,
0.0378818214,
-0.0377570093,
0.0059791338,
-0.0132906996,
-0.0305349976,
0.0328791998,
0.0641732439,
0.0014251133,
0.060544692,
0.0030657439,
-0.0560833514,
0.0426797643,
-0.0159513932,
-0.08511547,
-0.0148978774,
-0.0089650257,
-0.014259004,
0.054075107,
-0.0145287849,
0.0591109209,
0.005632339,
-0.0045530479,
0.0009996585,
0.0282927155,
0.0312267467,
-0.0325246789,
0.0438269526,
-0.0063762767,
-0.0215166025,
0.0214474276,
0.0662308633,
-0.0119407894,
0.0101158917,
-0.039031107,
-0.0666406378,
-0.0286102165,
-0.0209821984,
-0.0305506159,
-0.0333374217,
-0.0213154405,
0.020644838,
-0.0737961158,
-0.0926616713,
-0.011285956,
0.0168930814,
0.0174345784,
-0.0189120006,
0.0182797313,
0.0755525306,
0.035567686,
-0.0182597525,
-0.0646147281,
0.034400437,
-0.0442994758,
-0.017487511,
-0.0088688768,
-5.841151917e-33,
-0.0029009846,
-0.0171454325,
-0.0053751254,
0.0332767516,
0.0261612218,
-0.0053131464,
-0.0543096215,
-0.0243960582,
-0.0704186261,
0.0438905731,
-0.0213279072,
0.0099795917,
0.0092519158,
-0.0027030285,
0.0231965054,
-0.0322880261,
0.0282091945,
0.0148579869,
-0.0279877353,
0.0481201671,
0.0509565473,
-0.0203017537,
0.087013118,
-0.0701010078,
0.0877010971,
-0.0462604985,
-0.0074949088,
0.0402760655,
0.0013552783,
0.0675897375,
-0.0149422353,
0.0420988239,
0.0339265838,
-0.049021218,
0.0593999848,
0.0042049862,
-0.1105406806,
-0.0528825484,
0.0545038469,
-0.0135808298,
-0.0384765603,
-0.0520255826,
0.0108772404,
-0.0056421687,
-0.0081632473,
0.0139968041,
0.0860357806,
-0.0254724976,
0.0201335661,
-0.0815615207,
-0.0348355845,
0.0092150979,
0.0084738443,
-0.0033424196,
-0.0257698596,
0.0901343226,
-0.0033512011,
0.0012812248,
-0.0259997137,
0.0086991936,
-0.0073275669,
0.0068019857,
0.0701960176,
-0.0575390384,
0.0083719669,
0.0213455036,
-0.0087348847,
0.0069008023,
-0.0027212049,
-0.0240356885,
-0.021354828,
-0.0049222861,
0.1050021499,
0.1253522933,
-0.0182099994,
0.0101401424,
-0.1118582115,
0.0306951609,
0.0399415866,
0.0558479838,
0.0179020707,
-0.0422513895,
-0.0351462476,
-0.0030528381,
-0.0586603433,
-0.0374662504,
-0.055387795,
-0.0403348319,
0.0182613861,
-0.0034110891,
-0.045923166,
-0.0076587996,
0.0338008255,
-0.045504149,
-0.0252893958,
0.0589145087,
0.0065984493,
-0.00101743,
0.0347291566,
0.0428552628,
-0.0743701607,
0.04841353,
-0.0184019245,
0.0001520488,
0.0058576749,
0.0376530103,
0.0350613855,
-0.0258798096,
-0.0365268663,
0.0164128002,
-0.0249650963,
0.0264482312,
-0.0446436182,
-0.0048521399,
0.020209983,
0.0309429392,
-0.014104858,
0.0063928254,
0.0484673083,
0.035949342,
-0.0233374555,
-0.0037108453,
-0.0099474713,
0.0175965875,
-0.0525095835,
-0.0040274514,
-0.0101613915,
0.0429126099,
-0.0349788368,
-0.0328247286,
-0.0055856309,
0.0024361375,
2.457e-7,
0.0289002396,
-0.0191757176,
-0.0023963032,
0.0162872709,
0.0180250388,
0.0282725859,
0.0295753144,
0.0256390497,
0.0330415778,
-0.0305277668,
-0.0345850773,
0.0064143888,
0.036968708,
0.0501748659,
-0.0883873254,
0.0230331216,
-0.0266216788,
-0.0046007056,
-0.0049855667,
-0.0088030938,
0.0196191464,
0.0593799762,
0.0083980579,
-0.0045615938,
-0.0659442618,
-0.0305636227,
0.0477514341,
0.0040983548,
-0.0355930626,
0.0171508603,
0.078197889,
0.0181167033,
0.0156216267,
0.0311828721,
-0.0209015664,
0.0082143852,
0.0202007592,
0.015545967,
0.0228425041,
-0.0294696856,
-0.0205037501,
-0.0655699894,
0.0497660264,
-0.0845661461,
0.0307873283,
-0.0173165426,
0.0086973328,
0.0003833519,
-0.0380252302,
-0.028530186,
0.0351368859,
-0.0263821464,
-0.0432458855,
0.022053631,
-0.0047588558,
0.0109091196,
0.0084204804,
-0.0179223809,
-0.0135822874,
-0.0281733237,
0.0156009095,
-0.0413475372,
0.0327849872,
-0.0105299708,
-0.0173337404,
-0.0243137106,
0.0466090888,
1.433593306e-34,
0.0200379882,
0.0048237634,
0.0165534951,
0.0232064631,
0.0536519811,
0.011939493,
-0.021395795,
-0.0012741145,
0.0529107302,
-0.0204592124,
-0.02720665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14331v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14331v2 | What Else Do I Need to Know? The Effect of Background Information on Users' Reliance on QA Systems | 2023-05-23T17:57:12 | 2023-10-26T01:01:11 | Navita Goyal, Eleftheria Briakou, Amanda Liu, Connor Baumler, Claire Bonial, Jeffrey Micher, Clare R. Voss, Marine Carpuat, Hal Daumé III | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | NLP systems have shown impressive performance at answering questions by
retrieving relevant context. However, with the increasingly large models, it is
impossible and often undesirable to constrain models' knowledge or reasoning to
only the retrieved context. This leads to a mismatch between the information
that the models access to derive the answer and the information that is
available to the user to assess the model predicted answer. In this work, we
study how users interact with QA systems in the absence of sufficient
information to assess their predictions. Further, we ask whether adding the
requisite background helps mitigate users' over-reliance on predictions. Our
study reveals that users rely on model predictions even in the absence of
sufficient information needed to assess the model's correctness. Providing the
relevant background, however, helps users better catch model errors, reducing
over-reliance on incorrect predictions. On the flip side, background
information also increases users' confidence in their accurate as well as
inaccurate judgments. Our work highlights that supporting users' verification
of QA predictions is an important, yet challenging, problem. | [
0.065866515,
0.0496629961,
-0.0259192921,
0.019359028,
0.0034869858,
0.0118379695,
-0.0160387773,
-0.01355989,
0.0057713296,
-0.052137319,
0.0199726727,
-0.0026580235,
0.0247202981,
0.0051847403,
0.0096019087,
-0.0801128373,
0.0083147828,
-0.0058400109,
-0.0067105545,
0.008547293,
0.0175918564,
-0.0090401778,
0.0035581037,
0.0675275698,
-0.0309530217,
-0.0549440496,
-0.0124540906,
-0.0204739962,
-0.0414693542,
-0.0280776341,
-0.0023871914,
0.0856681764,
0.0063933209,
0.0024032237,
0.0000020879,
-0.0444391631,
-0.0026727433,
0.0043330635,
-0.0974323675,
0.0391352363,
-0.0323878676,
0.0405225083,
0.0291761048,
0.0146245267,
-0.0554155596,
0.0171162058,
0.0488362499,
0.0661521628,
0.0443605036,
-0.0330402926,
-0.013544797,
0.006030479,
-0.0119802039,
0.0190412179,
0.0465042219,
-0.1009646505,
0.0144378096,
0.0437719114,
0.0269731618,
-0.0129447784,
0.0185394231,
0.0256545823,
0.0111982711,
-0.0006657098,
-0.0172609165,
0.0299093258,
0.042259194,
-0.0280549321,
-0.008210537,
0.0764535889,
0.0611869395,
-0.011501289,
-0.0635800883,
-0.0125670061,
0.004772482,
0.0544467159,
-0.0546131991,
0.0202323385,
-0.0330389999,
-0.0444318689,
-0.0246918332,
-0.0096659325,
0.0243540034,
0.0018956895,
0.0176141132,
0.0679189265,
-0.030704882,
-0.043484237,
0.0128299538,
0.0439068228,
0.0008382861,
-0.0722908452,
-0.041299995,
0.0499294177,
-0.0203809105,
0.0368518829,
0.0281095039,
0.021016106,
0.0267654788,
-0.0182725471,
-0.0019045831,
0.0280287098,
-0.0300688278,
0.0113773942,
0.0058129509,
0.0320679881,
-0.0098709762,
-0.0211472474,
0.0101246815,
0.0128968963,
-0.0490449592,
-0.0261507574,
-0.0060551977,
0.0298445877,
-0.0269860253,
0.0270671938,
-0.0004973164,
0.0247741845,
0.0039105457,
0.0362370089,
-0.0327183791,
0.0408830307,
-0.0020765413,
-0.0164976958,
-0.0998408496,
0.0096595017,
-0.073255837,
0.0418544523,
-0.0264973249,
-0.0926665291,
0.0083336923,
-0.0070156623,
0.0021126096,
0.0226428416,
-0.0066916789,
0.0504660793,
0.0329636633,
-0.0138187269,
-0.0613844357,
-0.0651179329,
0.0247514658,
-0.0466463044,
-0.0550178513,
-0.0332158841,
-0.0192247108,
0.0792641267,
-0.0000714031,
-0.0068508401,
-0.017353395,
0.0522275604,
-0.0360497721,
0.0926832259,
-0.0734660029,
0.0393660925,
0.032668978,
0.0294909105,
-0.0279022269,
0.057875894,
-0.0156858452,
0.005054161,
0.0385931991,
0.0059946491,
0.0705946162,
-0.013822576,
-0.032122422,
-0.0159699116,
0.0025993728,
0.0606755689,
-0.03648578,
-0.0448523164,
-0.0362727232,
0.0421174876,
-0.0415376164,
0.0570439585,
0.0499601513,
0.0809404179,
0.0049678958,
0.0413464159,
0.0130882915,
-0.0337075815,
0.0346602425,
0.0420556441,
-0.0280381739,
0.0356684439,
-0.0441826582,
0.0135226762,
-0.0261766557,
-0.0022915995,
-0.0341202468,
-0.0504105948,
-0.0398913212,
-0.0033240449,
0.0047686212,
0.0240437221,
0.0048838099,
0.0279722046,
-0.0129722087,
0.0295644756,
0.0085080704,
-0.0266019497,
-0.0328531675,
-0.0386669151,
0.0657698587,
0.0682992116,
0.0251839757,
-0.0268985014,
0.0042144908,
-0.023576498,
0.0136090983,
0.0195280351,
0.0504871011,
-0.0188607238,
-0.0275080819,
0.0055570486,
-0.0475948974,
-0.0301336795,
0.0214050878,
0.0024221872,
0.0492033958,
0.0015825527,
0.0086278822,
-0.0101425154,
-0.0305310898,
0.0296980496,
-0.0582597479,
-0.0480028726,
-0.0476362109,
0.0266335886,
0.0029926049,
0.0286192559,
0.0134523818,
0.0398947112,
0.0114980042,
0.0440281294,
-0.0194139201,
0.026838135,
-0.0225294903,
0.0331898183,
0.0026141484,
-0.0004871717,
-0.0191286746,
-0.0033156651,
0.0256367177,
-0.0212610699,
0.0180597212,
-0.0410750136,
0.0352173969,
-0.0003147312,
-0.0324063189,
-0.0129215131,
-0.0283691902,
-0.0302819423,
0.0568213053,
0.0330758356,
0.0461699143,
0.0326501727,
0.0018869229,
0.0172277577,
-0.0192248896,
-0.0163024087,
-0.0155342016,
0.0211486444,
0.0191289373,
0.0290580839,
-0.0472584665,
-0.0528465584,
0.0716035739,
-0.0815749615,
-0.0221295748,
-0.025195213,
0.0348075479,
0.0320245065,
0.0275342409,
-0.0246284604,
-0.045521304,
-0.0186408944,
-0.0235281661,
-0.0314383917,
0.0571009703,
0.0278540701,
0.0640144795,
0.0317591093,
-0.0563177317,
0.0029295241,
-0.017237775,
0.0770713538,
0.0668385699,
-0.0109066991,
-0.0371319205,
-0.0126861054,
-0.0270006396,
0.0293741208,
0.0113177747,
0.0302207973,
0.0412905179,
0.0088364417,
-0.00204599,
0.0266306829,
0.0005194843,
0.0130846966,
0.0441850759,
0.0225131437,
-0.0382818058,
0.0274445657,
-0.0221889,
-0.0549797527,
0.0101863006,
-0.0432210416,
0.016092971,
0.0565664545,
0.0168920476,
0.0166173447,
-0.0451089256,
0.0608921945,
-0.0237424038,
-0.0217344519,
-0.0420054607,
-0.0486597121,
-0.0137253376,
0.0916808769,
-0.0029395986,
-0.0292399731,
0.0767116174,
-0.008446306,
-0.0046517961,
-0.0079718735,
-0.0054332167,
-0.0220681988,
0.044726748,
-0.0525414683,
0.0196446124,
0.0455540679,
-0.0047449702,
-0.0233439431,
-0.0626709089,
-0.0070662475,
-0.0404961631,
0.0187602174,
-0.040484909,
0.0082955919,
0.0206429623,
-0.0293338895,
-0.0697359592,
-0.0298862457,
-0.0794738233,
-0.0253300555,
-0.0106520643,
-0.0292601418,
0.0316428691,
-0.0282557085,
0.0687965602,
0.0038657908,
-0.0183766801,
-0.0435785949,
-0.0012785062,
0.0288617015,
0.0348816775,
0.0050929789,
0.0957492813,
-0.049753245,
0.0537644736,
0.0406628773,
0.0462634042,
-0.0059575513,
-0.0210463684,
-0.0550077036,
0.0171790104,
-0.0168375,
-0.0283903964,
0.0558318458,
0.0300985649,
-0.0414211079,
0.0063337409,
0.0769001395,
0.0583699569,
-0.0078353547,
-0.0030443417,
-0.0541603565,
0.00955988,
0.044458475,
0.0390447639,
-0.0802158788,
-0.0408040211,
0.0092588365,
0.0575522482,
-0.0273799039,
-0.0316265598,
-0.0240388606,
-0.090713203,
0.0142869856,
-0.0338891149,
-0.0014480215,
-0.0167030264,
-0.0556064844,
0.0195536744,
-0.0135578196,
0.0365943462,
0.0445759781,
-0.0230845511,
0.0168719459,
0.0248468425,
-0.0677410588,
-0.007655092,
0.0332470238,
-0.0265695527,
-0.0104214363,
0.0549476482,
-0.0074866149,
-0.0101845413,
-0.0236752573,
0.0025556667,
-0.0711929202,
0.060912732,
0.0080478098,
0.0874708593,
-0.028448062,
0.014350106,
-0.0383611582,
-0.0136526274,
-0.0337277018,
-0.0119237704,
0.0188834369,
0.0531126894,
0.0107747205,
-0.0122721232,
-0.0052746134,
0.0003726087,
0.0120860795,
0.0385971703,
0.0398939513,
-0.0396853536,
-0.0431568846,
-0.0542097166,
0.0005321342,
-0.0122771822,
-0.0267079305,
0.0079626087,
-0.0015031346,
0.0234861281,
-0.054401163,
-0.0683694109,
0.031330552,
0.0085009811,
-0.0016374,
0.0313289836,
0.0107765896,
0.0154586956,
-0.002580727,
0.0424141735,
-0.0116496487,
0.0038262622,
0.012602469,
0.0174758416,
0.0235924069,
-0.0336858742,
0.0223979242,
-0.0326856822,
0.0026967465,
-0.0327463113,
-0.0190174691,
0.0351906605,
0.0295156017,
0.0092391372,
-0.0042756866,
-0.0563591495,
-0.0233083051,
0.0109163448,
-0.0379108228,
-0.0182773918,
0.0142790964,
0.0008399869,
-0.0165546164,
0.0013999374,
-0.0203835387,
-0.0083300825,
-0.0221760105,
0.0158409849,
-0.0548368692,
-0.0401671045,
0.0440267324,
0.0370537378,
0.0415018126,
0.0303145368,
-0.0096873976,
0.0163105428,
0.0011266567,
-0.0066289958,
-0.0083908131,
-0.0000744948,
0.0002578156,
-0.0229373146,
-0.0194502845,
0.0185306314,
-0.0126516875,
-0.0624841377,
0.0197093058,
-0.0407435186,
0.0164498799,
0.037743371,
0.0286020022,
0.0088005038,
-0.0210325699,
-0.025466295,
-0.0498721674,
-0.0008693711,
0.0457647666,
0.0462960899,
0.0395791344,
-0.0163501743,
0.0036450599,
0.0079279635,
-0.0206856001,
-0.0858460292,
-0.104073368,
-0.0116714668,
0.0114192916,
0.0007958017,
-0.0236075483,
0.0121468725,
-0.028456904,
0.0141702639,
0.0263746735,
-0.0169949513,
0.0034577809,
-0.0163420197,
0.0558085851,
0.0312967524,
-0.0333335213,
-0.0016729832,
0.0800935999,
-0.0195792597,
0.0771548003,
-0.0633328035,
-0.056979727,
-0.0190487616,
-0.0017553746,
0.0068586981,
0.0249335226,
-0.0259712245,
0.0116153844,
-0.0805501342,
-0.0732857808,
-0.0220942441,
-0.0042282594,
0.0006444111,
-0.0148737077,
0.0247178115,
0.0668204129,
0.0496724844,
-0.0461396985,
-0.0407145657,
0.0205894895,
-0.0639592409,
0.0386371911,
-0.0155893918,
-6.451658133e-33,
-0.0016373283,
-0.0764813721,
0.0124940481,
-0.0181226674,
0.0401320942,
0.0024576485,
-0.0028494035,
0.0339878239,
-0.0339605249,
0.0106056649,
-0.0364660919,
0.0143218888,
-0.0064246687,
-0.0322743654,
0.0099929096,
-0.0191060361,
0.0159239527,
0.0152891781,
-0.0182731096,
0.0006285299,
0.0340801626,
-0.0008240232,
0.0265292544,
-0.0883564427,
0.0638445392,
-0.0265938081,
0.0015186222,
-0.0065438454,
-0.0452028513,
0.0422481038,
-0.0202184208,
0.0433197804,
0.0461606495,
-0.0362756774,
-0.0149636101,
0.0873173028,
-0.0123841064,
-0.0285942834,
0.0336072817,
0.0060239076,
-0.0370402895,
0.0107486406,
0.0418531857,
-0.0054387432,
-0.0070206467,
0.0262437332,
0.0233960394,
-0.0253973324,
0.0371086113,
-0.0066578332,
-0.0397077799,
-0.0008293422,
-0.0007265595,
0.0099461982,
0.0085354643,
0.1224031821,
0.0085473349,
-0.0309990589,
-0.0142327575,
0.013592571,
0.046753522,
-0.0093131978,
0.0701801255,
-0.0109405415,
-0.0125266667,
0.0258414373,
-0.0040256251,
-0.0015068325,
-0.0374562629,
-0.0329329222,
-0.0260763131,
0.0376144275,
0.0565896519,
0.0356160142,
0.0263781101,
-0.0212258808,
-0.0477204844,
0.0330827609,
-0.0295034051,
0.0594850704,
0.0451519229,
-0.0232264604,
-0.0783548653,
-0.0129949134,
-0.0737208724,
0.0200823862,
-0.0512489714,
-0.0492355898,
0.0220549274,
0.0155912992,
-0.0203333348,
0.0025149477,
-0.0601636022,
-0.0411622226,
-0.0149079086,
-0.0246216692,
-0.0204916447,
-0.0068242624,
-0.0133195538,
0.0011444427,
-0.0566669852,
0.0317197219,
-0.0217201766,
0.0199913904,
0.0230700467,
0.0204575192,
0.0132046491,
-0.0085060121,
-0.0546390153,
-0.0159574542,
-0.0012931455,
0.040774256,
0.0404716767,
-0.0279771388,
0.0539578162,
0.0407386199,
-0.0241678525,
0.0328021832,
0.0065856376,
0.0285010356,
-0.0313110687,
-0.0436451249,
-0.0125614787,
0.0024735483,
-0.0343878977,
-0.0761388838,
-0.0216484051,
0.051052276,
0.0421282947,
-0.0182166994,
-0.0291001759,
0.0004880866,
2.748e-7,
0.0506648496,
0.0531715304,
0.0131741473,
0.004408157,
0.0119899921,
0.0471872017,
-0.0031897959,
-0.0125315059,
0.032326404,
-0.0528235398,
-0.0165214483,
-0.0060190554,
0.0014686974,
0.0661715791,
-0.0635440946,
-0.0792466775,
-0.0431478098,
0.015392405,
-0.0202161986,
0.0111389626,
0.0661341473,
0.0251564402,
-0.0123973638,
0.008369416,
-0.057586547,
-0.0276032388,
0.0493484102,
0.0124897808,
0.0139887277,
0.0189030562,
0.080879882,
0.0081942035,
0.0310181752,
0.0318949334,
-0.0070133,
-0.0192436762,
-0.0288403202,
0.0086379964,
-0.0021120538,
-0.0325707458,
-0.0013136426,
-0.000718076,
0.0641560927,
-0.0593898185,
0.0474046953,
-0.0255125277,
-0.0249970537,
-0.027212346,
-0.0230488814,
-0.0460341461,
0.0121988999,
0.0090825958,
0.0045665256,
-0.0164011307,
-0.0261845794,
0.0012911811,
-0.0245645978,
-0.0367506742,
-0.0181113444,
0.0448894762,
0.0164303165,
-0.0339571238,
-0.0216334257,
-0.0617321469,
0.0006860683,
-0.0886324868,
0.037191499,
1.99124266e-34,
0.0002538699,
0.0256924108,
0.0542899892,
0.0316739939,
0.0427198596,
0.0047360519,
0.0335133895,
0.0016425489,
0.0362101644,
-0.0247848239,
-0.0131698586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14330v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14330v3 | DirecT2V: Large Language Models are Frame-Level Directors for Zero-Shot Text-to-Video Generation | 2023-05-23T17:57:09 | 2024-02-06T18:44:30 | Susung Hong, Junyoung Seo, Heeseong Shin, Sunghwan Hong, Seungryong Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the paradigm of AI-generated content (AIGC), there has been increasing
attention to transferring knowledge from pre-trained text-to-image (T2I) models
to text-to-video (T2V) generation. Despite their effectiveness, these
frameworks face challenges in maintaining consistent narratives and handling
shifts in scene composition or object placement from a single abstract user
prompt. Exploring the ability of large language models (LLMs) to generate
time-dependent, frame-by-frame prompts, this paper introduces a new framework,
dubbed DirecT2V. DirecT2V leverages instruction-tuned LLMs as directors,
enabling the inclusion of time-varying content and facilitating consistent
video generation. To maintain temporal consistency and prevent mapping the
value to a different object, we equip a diffusion model with a novel value
mapping method and dual-softmax filtering, which do not require any additional
training. The experimental results validate the effectiveness of our framework
in producing visually coherent and storyful videos from abstract user prompts,
successfully addressing the challenges of zero-shot video generation. | [
0.003997989,
0.0110582262,
0.0402017124,
-0.0014841628,
-0.0005081827,
0.0027710903,
0.0228257608,
0.0145159354,
-0.0190372709,
-0.0460043512,
0.0068191914,
-0.0563856475,
-0.0096954098,
0.0628072172,
-0.0089339213,
-0.08392407,
0.0009129461,
-0.0239521042,
-0.0231415406,
0.0058678663,
0.0158792119,
0.0065199654,
-0.0125868022,
-0.0125370268,
-0.067196317,
-0.0178610645,
-0.0330379307,
0.0104065696,
0.0880601704,
-0.0397100896,
-0.0491699986,
0.0194677319,
0.0534150489,
-0.006324674,
0.0000020336,
-0.0213421546,
0.0180435758,
-0.0081563173,
0.0044358689,
0.0112820407,
0.0339665003,
-0.0158163868,
-0.00601643,
-0.0232057124,
-0.0196038336,
0.0222545043,
0.0745136291,
0.0039523235,
0.1054777578,
0.0610942021,
-0.0431853794,
-0.0715702102,
-0.0338161103,
-0.0094509935,
0.0453657731,
0.0050902884,
-0.0093300929,
0.0096694492,
0.0324794874,
0.0020040886,
-0.0277957208,
0.0206082128,
0.0263353214,
-0.0386503413,
0.0408678576,
0.0841600671,
0.0037003094,
-0.0171687454,
-0.0167321097,
0.0839891136,
-0.0213702787,
0.0185685605,
-0.0029171938,
-0.0213707723,
-0.007623692,
-0.0146192843,
-0.0450543165,
0.0315414853,
0.0164811108,
0.0243041441,
-0.0075731161,
0.0256547518,
0.0136787044,
-0.0232884698,
0.0073593389,
-0.0043504569,
0.0474957973,
0.022507038,
-0.0587273687,
0.0172746647,
0.0044945148,
-0.0922259092,
0.0357818231,
0.0759777501,
0.0187011492,
0.0170867797,
-0.0937686786,
0.0084234364,
-0.0576128103,
-0.0724724233,
0.0834642947,
0.0222162306,
-0.0162485279,
0.0402672179,
-0.0389709473,
0.0523653589,
-0.0004201864,
0.0047571384,
-0.0209697131,
0.0166665483,
-0.0268386267,
0.0062469458,
-0.0204513501,
0.0104478188,
-0.0572632924,
-0.024132384,
-0.023133602,
0.0158426818,
-0.0324464366,
0.0210821163,
-0.0396525897,
0.0281022433,
-0.0397957489,
-0.0244956613,
-0.0504106134,
0.0506549813,
-0.0110787544,
0.0264443662,
0.0397198237,
-0.008048337,
-0.0271437187,
-0.0138728116,
0.0508329496,
0.0017439325,
0.0060740313,
0.0624325238,
-0.0868754014,
0.024348639,
-0.0452817231,
-0.0025028789,
-0.0261417683,
-0.0097883251,
0.0001151886,
-0.0668312386,
0.0370721593,
-0.0171990804,
0.0064496193,
-0.032778237,
0.0303000212,
-0.0013550631,
0.0024332169,
0.0234439075,
0.0168091524,
0.0265907571,
0.0338710137,
-0.0024313224,
0.0237533785,
0.0247115307,
0.0505208112,
0.0640761703,
-0.0109802205,
0.0164468046,
0.0175526682,
0.0352320187,
-0.0135043953,
0.0564875603,
-0.0921002999,
-0.0125997011,
0.0063459268,
0.0547430217,
0.0372066163,
0.0513215959,
-0.0203553569,
0.0380387977,
0.0980352312,
-0.001727235,
0.0092700813,
-0.0273398329,
0.1201431602,
0.021542741,
-0.0288158972,
-0.0083499104,
0.0203672592,
0.0910451859,
0.0559289269,
0.0014155869,
0.012783139,
-0.0002835816,
-0.0623015016,
-0.0378038995,
0.0300432704,
-0.019507464,
0.009018125,
-0.0150665222,
0.0061909826,
0.0196709074,
-0.0992752612,
0.0045050681,
-0.014752253,
-0.0509659462,
0.0871614888,
-0.0098272683,
0.0448591262,
0.1076812595,
-0.0043669255,
0.0268267319,
-0.033532463,
0.0035783302,
0.0450974628,
0.07522396,
0.0221420843,
-0.0284760371,
0.0295612048,
-0.0382853933,
0.0093440227,
-0.0224478673,
-0.0078277774,
0.057169538,
-0.0556913577,
0.0725765452,
0.0035275123,
0.0551778786,
-0.0605760813,
0.04495712,
-0.0067203697,
-0.0363162085,
0.0079607219,
0.0072400551,
-0.0046302732,
-0.006459719,
-0.0417993702,
-0.0109372074,
0.0134066492,
-0.008704314,
-0.0106186811,
0.0167445727,
-0.0615967289,
-0.0175243374,
0.0025193654,
-0.035753455,
0.0189701598,
-0.0185492858,
-0.030952882,
-0.0519867651,
0.002225382,
0.0077269776,
-0.0196567457,
-0.0084395669,
0.0104421303,
0.0336895175,
-0.0127982367,
-0.0180462021,
0.038637016,
-0.0047804532,
-0.02997238,
0.025748767,
0.037358705,
-0.0096965898,
-0.0041492335,
0.0261677969,
0.0127951037,
0.0140672876,
-0.0162189789,
0.0179326143,
0.0196772646,
-0.0513218194,
-0.0296796523,
-0.0605559461,
-0.0348672941,
0.015998669,
-0.040750023,
0.0140250316,
-0.0005229773,
-0.0183660816,
0.0150326248,
-0.0662588701,
0.0156458616,
0.0164534915,
-0.0293790381,
0.031730555,
0.032198742,
0.0265757535,
-0.0310565867,
0.0129998289,
0.0141358925,
0.0135312136,
0.0289688241,
-0.0458377041,
-0.043071311,
0.037573982,
-0.0069547552,
0.0155405216,
-0.0143564874,
0.0023128183,
0.0103906216,
-0.0066681076,
0.0394441262,
0.0729690716,
0.0260158367,
0.0033489161,
0.0381674059,
-0.0495279729,
-0.0317895338,
0.0277822856,
-0.0167291481,
-0.0115954317,
-0.0324372873,
-0.005255145,
0.0136686368,
0.0261757839,
0.020699162,
0.0369496495,
-0.0824682042,
0.0179504082,
-0.0164274052,
-0.0448256247,
0.0201698467,
-0.0129691903,
-0.0281977095,
0.0096953986,
-0.0415909439,
-0.0396039002,
0.0403222069,
-0.0529576913,
-0.0293154791,
0.0149190342,
0.0016114395,
-0.0169695374,
0.0334812701,
0.015383143,
0.0565189645,
-0.021158278,
0.019231176,
-0.0534341894,
-0.0144491689,
0.016392231,
-0.0020837106,
0.0317735747,
-0.0451170579,
-0.0147552509,
-0.0293364171,
0.007828908,
-0.025543157,
-0.0451629832,
0.008486541,
-0.0165291801,
-0.0283299107,
-0.0357988477,
-0.0307555683,
0.0274254251,
0.0118746674,
0.0420724973,
-0.0324086249,
-0.0249585956,
-0.035891138,
0.0218770579,
0.0893785283,
-0.008723639,
-0.060397543,
-0.0693960339,
0.0751248598,
0.0088814348,
-0.0101631526,
-0.0020174226,
-0.0311249997,
0.0344741866,
0.0158067681,
0.0090152184,
0.0125689646,
0.0314975046,
0.090774864,
-0.0511075594,
-0.0208496302,
0.0920997262,
0.021224454,
-0.0611690879,
0.0116167944,
0.015315583,
0.0131226806,
0.0103147216,
0.0182042625,
-0.0677212253,
-0.0285364781,
-0.0226622131,
0.0015052697,
0.0126920696,
-0.0228777844,
-0.0562577955,
-0.0905857608,
0.0787651464,
0.0508434698,
0.0055043604,
0.0040745065,
0.0021748899,
0.0448633842,
0.0295882374,
-0.0227164868,
0.0055166399,
0.0098361215,
0.0126947621,
0.0217344034,
0.0674416497,
-0.0494282953,
-0.0174443908,
-0.007484687,
0.0420559235,
0.081645295,
0.0423656367,
-0.022795504,
-0.0082831094,
-0.0164391398,
0.0114308735,
0.0141721778,
0.0018393707,
-0.0020013598,
-0.0313554332,
-0.0140743917,
0.0127655491,
0.0519816019,
0.0565046147,
-0.0220979676,
0.0209708512,
0.0369986407,
-0.0316578373,
-0.0346467905,
-0.0404662415,
0.01902714,
0.0466285236,
0.0379443914,
0.0225388408,
-0.0749302506,
-0.0068902052,
-0.0112814615,
-0.0136955623,
-0.0477776043,
-0.0558219291,
-0.0210652873,
-0.0500138849,
-0.0081890412,
-0.0622210167,
-0.0265636239,
0.0483207889,
0.0606875569,
0.0122878943,
-0.0172621384,
-0.0147871003,
-0.0298056658,
-0.0485500507,
0.0077566723,
-0.0150025385,
0.0160507541,
-0.0663287044,
-0.0185489208,
0.0149806626,
-0.0496533923,
0.0025589736,
0.0476228073,
-0.0534530319,
-0.0551300943,
-0.0143670868,
0.0430207476,
0.0134749208,
0.060300339,
0.0318268314,
-0.0343114547,
0.0895371288,
0.0312611982,
0.0203489475,
0.0317324549,
-0.0223491155,
0.0424210019,
-0.0133042214,
-0.0004967291,
-0.0629907027,
0.015157681,
0.0210127607,
0.0268672444,
0.0067052958,
-0.0030375568,
0.0259105805,
-0.0529007167,
-0.020738218,
-0.0362379923,
0.0174109042,
-0.0513878241,
-0.0417161137,
-0.0423431471,
-0.0260973759,
-0.069355987,
-0.009618897,
0.0371420942,
0.0062081157,
0.0026695954,
0.0006177252,
-0.0107710501,
-0.0056460975,
-0.0250972733,
-0.0586630739,
0.0003394231,
0.004618099,
0.035531085,
0.0381761305,
0.0153806629,
0.0332713611,
-0.0372215286,
0.0402407721,
-0.002552462,
0.0586483367,
0.0161958616,
-0.0118853347,
-0.0009704666,
0.0324762613,
0.0023626087,
-0.0296552591,
-0.0354075581,
0.024401851,
0.0478925742,
-0.0157629512,
0.0543994345,
-0.0503170341,
0.0164134614,
-0.026694933,
0.0125883995,
0.0211127214,
-0.0731068701,
0.0041478463,
-0.0128872143,
0.0051730876,
0.0038496095,
0.0408506021,
0.0096639581,
0.0128983185,
-0.0213811267,
-0.0087323152,
-0.0126513764,
0.014336382,
0.0067087174,
-0.0268122759,
-0.0012100737,
0.0136327203,
-0.048143167,
-0.0413329303,
-0.0056813671,
-0.0085487133,
-0.0270909369,
-0.018185515,
0.0495875143,
0.0021708012,
-0.016723603,
0.0116309896,
-0.0187867545,
-0.0018506505,
-0.0123927584,
-0.0518957339,
-0.0473981649,
-5.793251992e-33,
-0.0765413493,
-0.0406536162,
0.0207924973,
-0.0281254295,
-0.0556243919,
0.010624229,
-0.0287731867,
0.0165245403,
-0.0184387453,
0.0354213715,
0.0141179133,
0.0091685113,
0.007623631,
0.0334691331,
-0.0253898744,
-0.0092028361,
0.039552398,
-0.018881781,
-0.0442491509,
0.0534529313,
0.0258160289,
0.0134269642,
0.0262791123,
-0.0191416536,
-0.0060944706,
-0.0057161627,
-0.036829032,
0.0004660109,
0.0513561927,
0.0079561938,
0.0145745398,
0.0012872096,
-0.0118758166,
-0.0282147992,
-0.0169455614,
0.0117383068,
-0.028679708,
-0.0194372162,
-0.0049575176,
-0.0210622866,
-0.0767625347,
-0.0430976078,
0.0271542594,
-0.0110374941,
-0.0022341961,
-0.0258105956,
0.0561478771,
0.0069221463,
0.031219786,
-0.0267346539,
-0.0790151432,
0.0092082433,
-0.0428190008,
-0.075990878,
0.0075764484,
0.0274463408,
0.0243557859,
-0.012354522,
-0.0710449219,
0.0533539653,
-0.0051890234,
0.0535782501,
0.0817240998,
0.0355279744,
-0.0096861599,
0.0612978563,
0.0274548829,
-0.0012942475,
-0.0457638502,
0.0370853879,
0.0002910974,
0.0358771272,
0.0113212233,
0.0044351793,
0.0233941227,
-0.0032803214,
-0.06104891,
0.0493283719,
-0.0789004043,
0.0271607805,
0.0154872816,
0.0338262022,
0.020244956,
-0.0010153813,
-0.0421442278,
-0.0313891768,
-0.0100785634,
-0.0482168905,
0.0258357748,
-0.0065806601,
0.0260121915,
-0.0483200736,
0.0837937295,
0.0295910593,
0.0098206783,
0.0049965465,
-0.0737893805,
0.0739061609,
0.0090191681,
0.0276627745,
-0.0260324087,
-0.0094129853,
0.0664561838,
0.0244614165,
0.0327059552,
0.0498573519,
-0.0185796022,
0.0844958797,
0.0081106918,
0.0002550702,
-0.013923509,
0.0320480876,
0.0054241777,
0.0448996164,
0.0010366127,
-0.0245294664,
-0.0459671468,
0.0434393957,
-0.0161986053,
-0.0131093357,
0.0323592536,
-0.0154760377,
-0.0116777681,
0.0195328705,
-0.0541478544,
0.0635565147,
-0.0557604283,
0.0112172365,
0.0548303798,
-0.0584990159,
-0.0217841361,
0.0330472812,
2.765e-7,
-0.037130326,
0.0003625805,
-0.0100060813,
0.0256456025,
0.0078934636,
0.0556857064,
-0.012423085,
0.0467213616,
0.0210953746,
-0.0232165158,
0.0336101502,
0.0544327199,
0.0290426128,
-0.01413796,
-0.0493615307,
-0.0049585039,
-0.0378111154,
-0.012969844,
-0.0550945513,
-0.0252491534,
0.0232547391,
0.0263544358,
0.0198029429,
-0.0034409675,
0.0498355813,
-0.0220701601,
0.0895203203,
0.0194704384,
-0.0159096997,
0.0079625864,
-0.0070454525,
-0.0240461845,
-0.0495689549,
-0.0424268693,
-0.0181850959,
-0.0051215095,
0.0382637344,
0.0476447754,
-0.0606276765,
-0.0281015355,
-0.0047467607,
0.0338287018,
-0.0099533712,
-0.0147033324,
0.0564654507,
-0.0502293706,
-0.0256059635,
-0.0180636831,
-0.0359435566,
0.0093910443,
-0.0185796823,
-0.0353837237,
-0.046470996,
0.0176953189,
0.0435796529,
0.0377130657,
-0.0450548492,
-0.05114026,
-0.0304963049,
-0.0370221548,
-0.0215671975,
-0.0053164279,
-0.0558206365,
0.0301858895,
0.0101468172,
-0.0062741498,
-0.0197527893,
2.280793551e-34,
-0.0171140861,
0.0022909725,
-0.0032129132,
-0.0541263036,
0.0225550178,
0.0627121106,
-0.0131203514,
0.0220718775,
0.0163531806,
-0.065026693,
-0.0638673455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14328v2 | Benchmarking LLM-based Machine Translation on Cultural Awareness | 2023-05-23T17:56:33 | 2024-03-23T02:20:02 | Binwei Yao, Ming Jiang, Diyi Yang, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translating cultural-specific content is crucial for effective cross-cultural
communication. However, many MT systems still struggle to translate sentences
containing cultural-specific entities accurately and understandably. Recent
advancements in in-context learning utilize lightweight prompts to guide large
language models (LLMs) in machine translation tasks. Nevertheless, the
effectiveness of this approach in enhancing machine translation with cultural
awareness remains uncertain. To address this gap, we introduce a new data
curation pipeline to construct a culturally relevant parallel corpus, enriched
with annotations of cultural-specific items. Furthermore, we devise a novel
evaluation metric to assess the understandability of translations in a
reference-free manner by GPT-4. We evaluate a variety of neural machine
translation (NMT) and LLM-based MT systems using our dataset. Additionally, we
propose several prompting strategies for LLMs to incorporate external and
internal cultural knowledge into the translation process. Our results
demonstrate that eliciting explanations can significantly enhance the
understandability of cultural-specific entities, especially those without
well-known translations. | [
0.0251226015,
0.0228396039,
-0.0289255604,
0.0471530296,
-0.0096194781,
0.0319769233,
0.0415456854,
-0.0127964541,
-0.0049086032,
0.0174537282,
-0.0341741517,
-0.0588448122,
-0.0001700227,
-0.0176054351,
0.0178120229,
-0.0189588312,
0.023483593,
0.002433524,
-0.0034648951,
0.0138466749,
-0.003200073,
0.0407045558,
0.0312376618,
0.0396616422,
0.0082453126,
-0.0230692197,
0.0025668954,
0.0580622517,
0.0621275939,
-0.0410330333,
-0.0264456421,
-0.0035780377,
0.0262567382,
0.0628178567,
0.0000021601,
-0.030049555,
-0.0208722558,
-0.0136554632,
-0.0083585428,
0.0117551954,
0.0615636967,
-0.0512773246,
0.0033039865,
0.0035577882,
-0.0309330337,
-0.003847494,
0.0393535681,
0.0403002687,
0.0538726114,
0.0782038644,
-0.00105024,
0.0159777086,
-0.0526918918,
-0.0581623912,
-0.0035664954,
-0.0346318968,
-0.0145817874,
0.0072004409,
-0.0269473214,
0.0434726626,
-0.0084806997,
0.0509823598,
0.0284011606,
-0.0262576994,
-0.0288286395,
-0.0087655708,
-0.0124797309,
-0.0343553089,
-0.0091595864,
0.0818220899,
0.0222472064,
0.0139523065,
0.0034391149,
-0.0213779937,
-0.0036663716,
-0.0120326718,
-0.0470167249,
0.0229642298,
0.000095579,
0.0277382191,
0.0188172143,
0.0485261194,
0.0619118884,
0.0199168827,
-0.0047825188,
0.0141354883,
0.0017735425,
-0.0194079056,
-0.0230851937,
-0.002253338,
-0.0106910523,
-0.0413996875,
0.0398721322,
0.0009201572,
-0.0202099457,
0.0338555835,
0.0212169904,
-0.0105050076,
0.0127760125,
-0.0416274853,
0.0184216816,
0.0872173458,
-0.0516845621,
0.0452689081,
0.0141474139,
0.0487691201,
-0.0364506952,
-0.0156354383,
-0.0634417757,
-0.0351325236,
-0.0285304189,
0.0132601941,
0.0122018177,
-0.0262424611,
-0.0611480735,
0.0072028418,
-0.0438578501,
0.0260917395,
-0.0118476823,
0.0235833675,
0.0152466977,
-0.0604598857,
-0.0558411889,
-0.0077209375,
-0.0178514905,
0.0779529065,
-0.0372640193,
-0.0408108979,
0.0045012287,
-0.0570641533,
-0.0265741739,
0.0026780737,
-0.0385749154,
-0.0510601476,
-0.0152221788,
0.0611352138,
0.0086907372,
-0.0296857655,
-0.0212543681,
0.0136897024,
-0.02246961,
-0.0486067981,
0.0186174158,
-0.030499883,
0.0618084818,
-0.0115327016,
0.0317232423,
-0.0406099409,
0.0148251411,
0.0188957807,
-0.0097324252,
0.0462960899,
0.0333567932,
0.0067770402,
0.0560266525,
0.0130696204,
-0.0220682323,
0.0770726651,
0.0338105634,
0.0329114422,
0.0645151734,
-0.0044215387,
-0.0508842133,
0.0352407731,
0.0029983486,
0.0107496604,
-0.032566186,
0.0091507165,
0.0144636491,
0.0297774617,
0.0221124403,
0.034266416,
0.0032521046,
0.0342381857,
0.0682640374,
0.0361928903,
-0.0275674704,
0.0445839576,
0.0633298829,
0.0199608952,
-0.0198198874,
0.0092512099,
-0.0585093051,
0.0546168648,
0.017293375,
-0.01348734,
0.01883143,
0.0702404007,
-0.0291977916,
-0.0494509563,
-0.006582703,
-0.0140859028,
0.0336415656,
0.0104476307,
0.0318204463,
-0.0007091091,
-0.0252830666,
0.0387353264,
0.0094920686,
-0.066711545,
0.0073087504,
0.0083067529,
0.0047159381,
0.0741444752,
0.0118814567,
0.0048151962,
-0.0092125032,
-0.0454274528,
0.023497507,
0.0688898265,
0.0494851433,
0.0151155544,
0.0434022136,
-0.0498976707,
-0.0201509092,
-0.021359738,
0.0099959373,
0.0223783199,
0.0244822558,
0.0362165198,
0.0521387607,
-0.0243028421,
-0.0583142601,
0.0227228757,
-0.0457115993,
-0.0416374132,
0.0501918085,
0.0013545377,
0.0337819718,
0.0786210671,
0.0115465885,
-0.0400279872,
0.0250404328,
-0.0418564118,
0.001356104,
0.0575474054,
-0.0732218251,
-0.0450476035,
0.0129649499,
-0.0331105217,
-0.0473864079,
-0.0130671263,
-0.0660588816,
-0.0616439879,
-0.0238890797,
-0.0071158879,
-0.0144788716,
-0.0731745884,
-0.0063123172,
0.0042079519,
0.0279771201,
-0.031405177,
0.0294719469,
-0.005106227,
-0.0078586545,
0.0131245852,
-0.0408713408,
0.03558347,
-0.0376973338,
-0.0399169847,
0.0263076127,
0.0287453365,
-0.0162131768,
0.0282201879,
0.0535701029,
-0.0212717317,
0.0098773809,
-0.1025127172,
0.0085428525,
-0.0327962302,
0.0118306857,
0.023859527,
0.0679340288,
-0.0169416592,
-0.0041202204,
-0.0452042222,
-0.0041473,
0.0080013089,
0.0011197651,
0.0457666256,
0.0009773729,
0.00963559,
0.012993264,
-0.0054329634,
0.023800971,
0.0221244041,
0.0188888386,
-0.0231460109,
-0.0612710901,
-0.0211880282,
-0.0455636978,
-0.040811982,
-0.0197714325,
-0.0465403348,
-0.0156229325,
0.0020275437,
0.0319125243,
0.0188981052,
0.0021095953,
0.0120653203,
0.0335603431,
0.0060199434,
-0.0296735112,
0.0164646711,
-0.0101562729,
-0.0145107126,
-0.0032106361,
-0.0659612715,
0.0149243837,
0.0324478708,
-0.0096054552,
-0.0122901946,
-0.0529543981,
-0.0078193434,
-0.0237546712,
-0.0227279551,
-0.0197925121,
0.017211793,
-0.0021956002,
0.0646493062,
-0.0414456502,
-0.0468118601,
0.0808481202,
-0.0340313539,
-0.0193091519,
-0.0169807188,
-0.0119694956,
-0.0563561693,
0.0297971927,
-0.0388202854,
0.017369194,
-0.044215057,
-0.0335587673,
-0.025434643,
0.0179869384,
-0.0008981248,
-0.0230550747,
0.040032465,
-0.0634533912,
-0.0340751223,
-0.0179112107,
0.0062982766,
-0.0327187143,
0.0135291032,
0.0098403841,
0.0083867898,
-0.0053327139,
0.0122923451,
0.0091623189,
-0.0031329656,
0.0394587927,
0.0336881466,
-0.0227044113,
0.0309917089,
-0.0073181684,
-0.0107037649,
-0.0215565786,
0.0172686744,
0.0311160553,
-0.0463934392,
0.0449292697,
-0.0239772052,
0.0314985551,
-0.0645846426,
0.0070329872,
0.0057646898,
0.0382824317,
-0.0103789223,
-0.0301119685,
-0.0164778121,
0.0942802429,
-0.0501433797,
-0.0063809603,
0.1147177964,
0.0185516793,
-0.06391076,
-0.0123395715,
-0.0242388528,
-0.0218312964,
0.0145574464,
0.037634559,
-0.1110607833,
-0.0076061334,
0.0110179717,
0.0146549651,
0.0082979687,
0.0032390179,
-0.0342817046,
-0.0950781778,
0.0248171911,
0.0289615039,
-0.0645734891,
-0.0363143981,
-0.0001324116,
-0.0439044274,
-0.028129017,
0.064062655,
-0.0300867427,
0.0314473361,
-0.0165470839,
-0.013435307,
0.038259767,
-0.0667480081,
0.0090425834,
-0.0440472141,
0.028651651,
0.0590159558,
0.0599183291,
0.0099649597,
-0.0269903969,
0.0167758502,
-0.038181562,
0.0088658854,
-0.0101486761,
-0.0059159556,
0.0023579986,
-0.0383272693,
0.0207205843,
0.0002250003,
-0.0271155611,
0.0139832273,
0.0314485542,
0.0593859144,
-0.0161897484,
0.0419182181,
0.0287897903,
-0.0206649806,
0.0340059623,
0.0900202692,
0.0222952981,
-0.0474641398,
0.0321811102,
-0.0330636576,
-0.0269366037,
-0.0229963101,
0.0181929488,
0.0213283338,
-0.0637039989,
-0.0336960666,
-0.0697770044,
-0.0624628775,
0.0051168995,
0.0036016949,
0.0464229248,
0.0037229001,
-0.0174730588,
0.0382303782,
-0.0256191157,
0.0722799376,
-0.037254177,
0.0026538845,
-0.0149037773,
0.0056787301,
-0.0123900855,
-0.0785188451,
0.0077190297,
0.0546373874,
-0.0677520707,
-0.0415555239,
-0.0215478092,
0.0439465493,
0.0134974122,
0.0474863313,
-0.0011485951,
-0.0268558525,
0.0038824494,
0.0048709284,
-0.0305585377,
-0.0428286307,
0.0164318308,
0.0595790148,
-0.0183233265,
0.0451677144,
-0.0209090747,
0.0266166013,
0.0117015662,
0.0638459995,
-0.0063036727,
-0.0520333387,
0.0040710629,
0.0149554536,
0.0090323323,
-0.051690314,
-0.0525112897,
-0.0532923006,
0.0081666,
-0.0202721711,
-0.0178425927,
-0.0467481166,
-0.0182451643,
0.0430899449,
-0.0195984039,
0.0025792022,
-0.0077968077,
-0.0094093271,
-0.015644474,
-0.0382222719,
-0.0030842591,
-0.0431095436,
0.0386678837,
-0.0335662179,
0.0256612841,
-0.017959062,
0.0352504291,
-0.0057424223,
0.0029273001,
-0.0368053354,
0.1016234085,
0.0011382076,
0.0337288715,
0.0468678661,
0.0270304587,
-0.0208916143,
-0.0024489232,
0.0024395057,
0.03560137,
0.084016636,
-0.0310579725,
0.1050519422,
0.0247461107,
-0.0210022219,
0.0105473902,
0.0620953962,
0.0365566537,
-0.0285814479,
0.0027088621,
0.0009326547,
-0.0125139588,
-0.0031637964,
0.0510982573,
-0.0535192005,
-0.0203468967,
0.0326056331,
-0.017433418,
-0.0211242028,
-0.0018373079,
0.0224431828,
-0.000072767,
-0.0181210004,
-0.0015619381,
-0.0364005528,
-0.0502171181,
-0.0036707735,
0.0028021745,
-0.0204393566,
-0.0240556709,
-0.0095008537,
0.0838775262,
-0.0369916596,
-0.0227110665,
-0.0528138131,
-0.0134266661,
-0.0232472066,
-0.0041034827,
-0.0220122263,
-6.529518471e-33,
-0.0392591804,
-0.0224426165,
-0.0009871686,
0.0019720262,
-0.0124938311,
-0.0190895405,
-0.0559873208,
-0.0492193028,
-0.0151465172,
0.0125192478,
-0.014680936,
0.0156128379,
0.0267819986,
0.0162944589,
0.0201767515,
0.0078148181,
0.0530672036,
0.031213114,
-0.0241766982,
0.057737302,
0.049702771,
0.0400799066,
0.0917036757,
-0.0587803237,
0.0884880573,
-0.0082641225,
-0.007952881,
0.0350387879,
0.0221700817,
0.0199922752,
-0.020840561,
0.0064520459,
0.0203119423,
-0.0357452072,
-0.0044198474,
-0.0060377014,
-0.1177459806,
-0.0085158898,
0.0460516624,
0.0167616308,
0.0365696698,
-0.082244955,
0.0127925482,
-0.0588313043,
-0.0044873115,
0.0163607821,
0.0172637682,
-0.0490795784,
0.0050315317,
-0.0175303295,
-0.0198688339,
0.0207838062,
-0.0167854037,
0.0253618229,
0.0240172762,
0.0867159963,
-0.0235941596,
0.037323527,
-0.0640649572,
0.0136447139,
-0.0245510973,
0.0098849861,
0.0860897601,
-0.0009310695,
-0.0144403186,
-0.0008137955,
-0.0032451737,
-0.002231691,
0.0101652797,
-0.0142659834,
0.0144919567,
-0.0298697781,
0.0406361893,
0.0854960382,
0.0426562242,
0.0033008505,
-0.069683902,
0.0435402691,
0.024733115,
-0.017903639,
0.0336679406,
-0.0000462512,
-0.0066261678,
-0.0080366749,
-0.033164449,
-0.0440063849,
-0.0222472064,
-0.0412552021,
0.0239568334,
0.0238089915,
-0.0259308182,
0.0098561859,
0.0701979771,
-0.0168044586,
0.0326789059,
-0.0014115871,
0.0068951845,
-0.0524813682,
0.022390319,
0.0187195167,
-0.0365682505,
-0.0223444514,
-0.0069248038,
0.0000491131,
0.0125060026,
-0.0273436774,
0.0541245565,
0.0025730175,
-0.0378987826,
0.0123080108,
-0.0495134629,
0.0290816296,
-0.0618713759,
0.0130719366,
0.011770268,
-0.0098417914,
-0.0283612162,
0.0122243706,
0.0534325205,
-0.0027195062,
-0.0127247302,
-0.0354091786,
-0.0028288139,
0.0211267825,
-0.0571723953,
0.0122636734,
0.0223603696,
0.04707212,
0.0446769297,
-0.0445633009,
-0.0173352212,
-0.0065832045,
2.89e-7,
0.0330881141,
0.0240626317,
-0.011025955,
0.0368690342,
-0.0008399801,
-0.0038327705,
-0.0403791033,
0.0093813054,
0.0118411556,
-0.0008452441,
0.0474852324,
0.0394137204,
0.1245268658,
0.0395734645,
-0.1188238859,
-0.0621173233,
-0.0248430241,
0.0076122563,
-0.0584311225,
0.0293595325,
0.016915217,
0.0786928535,
0.0142857283,
0.0112647666,
-0.0288335029,
-0.0345841907,
0.0672258139,
-0.0846237242,
-0.0162431393,
-0.0102929045,
0.0574203506,
0.001716744,
-0.0504539311,
-0.0052503874,
-0.0139041357,
0.0196627416,
0.0538153835,
0.0978880078,
0.0501241982,
0.0004999462,
-0.0129039465,
0.0318918303,
0.006213998,
-0.0739687234,
0.0302548949,
-0.0207928885,
-0.0299344826,
0.0163430795,
0.0089231618,
-0.0239419583,
0.0352020748,
-0.0153596699,
-0.0107239569,
0.0255389176,
0.0311032664,
-0.0213644896,
-0.0000601055,
-0.0508985929,
-0.031452056,
-0.0252281018,
0.0015335318,
-0.0433272533,
-0.0167853888,
-0.041794233,
-0.0291109085,
-0.0182535108,
-0.0094658593,
2.630075397e-34,
0.0283172168,
-0.0207110383,
-0.0140646324,
0.005505749,
0.0539730825,
-0.0159704685,
-0.0201765206,
-0.0133683123,
-0.0135554327,
-0.0375312343,
-0.0223846808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14327v2 | Dynosaur: A Dynamic Growth Paradigm for Instruction-Tuning Data Curation | 2023-05-23T17:56:26 | 2023-10-26T05:10:18 | Da Yin, Xiao Liu, Fan Yin, Ming Zhong, Hritik Bansal, Jiawei Han, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning has emerged to enhance the capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) to comprehend instructions and generate appropriate responses.
Existing methods either manually annotate or employ LLM (e.g., GPT-series) to
generate data for instruction tuning. However, they often overlook associating
instructions with existing annotated datasets. In this paper, we propose
Dynosaur, a dynamic growth paradigm for the automatic curation of
instruction-tuning data. Based on the metadata of existing datasets, we use
LLMs to automatically construct instruction-tuning data by identifying relevant
data fields and generating appropriate instructions.
By leveraging the existing annotated datasets, Dynosaur offers several
advantages: 1) it reduces the API cost for generating instructions (e.g., it
costs less than $12 USD by calling GPT-3.5-turbo for generating 800K
instruction tuning samples; 2) it provides high-quality data for instruction
tuning (e.g., it performs better than Alpaca and Flan on Super-NI and Longform
with comparable data sizes); and 3) it supports the continuous improvement of
models by generating instruction-tuning data when a new annotated dataset
becomes available. We further investigate a continual learning scheme for
learning with the ever-growing instruction-tuning dataset, and demonstrate that
replaying tasks with diverse instruction embeddings not only helps mitigate
forgetting issues but generalizes to unseen tasks better.
Code and data are available at https://github.com/WadeYin9712/Dynosaur. | [
0.0217182264,
0.0627811402,
-0.030002363,
0.0120207462,
-0.0016953932,
0.0308917221,
-0.00935282,
-0.0288958736,
-0.0302866269,
-0.039239917,
-0.04536549,
-0.02168875,
0.0047303368,
0.0009363639,
0.0177194308,
-0.0411866941,
0.0663165376,
-0.0651807711,
-0.0258792359,
0.0044301432,
-0.009498653,
0.0091068251,
-0.0305422321,
0.0444640182,
0.0133001609,
-0.0231389049,
-0.0327809304,
-0.0003415384,
0.0013092196,
-0.0276424251,
0.030025471,
0.0399230085,
0.037630152,
0.0241898857,
0.0000021766,
-0.0170499664,
-0.0191333499,
-0.0271787047,
-0.0402622335,
0.0335599445,
0.0442439578,
0.0065230108,
-0.0363358632,
0.035468746,
-0.0281368569,
-0.0271542184,
0.0461745709,
-0.0386717208,
0.0862870887,
0.0794505253,
0.0218949709,
-0.0251828805,
0.0238136649,
-0.0095712421,
0.0066993386,
0.0056463694,
0.0041596312,
0.0129912142,
0.026294386,
0.0295307506,
-0.0215945635,
0.0168395676,
0.0351736546,
-0.0163329896,
-0.0307784323,
0.0370897241,
-0.0042410716,
-0.0008274534,
-0.0360892527,
0.0539632291,
-0.0164596867,
-0.0214144699,
0.0042386707,
-0.0050533889,
-0.0007346406,
-0.0138133708,
-0.0542501062,
0.028662404,
0.0008608559,
0.0068621053,
0.0347069278,
-0.0612059459,
-0.0016846175,
-0.02175151,
-0.0012811561,
0.0503663868,
0.0144100655,
-0.0285992827,
-0.0473361723,
-0.0411075242,
-0.039155867,
-0.0610746443,
-0.0011629041,
0.0728555098,
-0.0450639352,
0.039568115,
-0.0564628802,
-0.0425442904,
0.0377891697,
0.0061545973,
0.0939922556,
0.0591702424,
-0.0235769991,
0.0035817772,
-0.010228782,
0.0596343726,
-0.0074053444,
0.0180382654,
-0.0366289392,
0.033191245,
-0.0993373841,
-0.001889605,
-0.0349473059,
0.0307932459,
-0.0177187808,
0.0225998834,
-0.0180443879,
0.0755972788,
-0.0023709831,
0.0018087799,
0.0294440482,
-0.0428689308,
-0.0751245692,
0.0309290793,
-0.0279983878,
0.0297205951,
-0.0559322499,
0.003333255,
0.0187495593,
-0.0546698533,
-0.0231457539,
-0.0066787712,
0.0073861293,
-0.0281330999,
0.0311921071,
0.0571844652,
-0.0016511146,
-0.0182559658,
-0.0370080881,
-0.0301716551,
0.0212205853,
-0.0542260818,
0.0050248709,
-0.0546434224,
0.0186459664,
-0.0126760472,
-0.0134444255,
-0.0204952098,
0.0026174376,
0.0448089018,
-0.0034868328,
0.0356289148,
-0.0011308449,
0.0287243053,
0.0003439565,
-0.0131193986,
0.0028255226,
0.0637754351,
0.0357361771,
0.0014067792,
0.026285449,
-0.0104870377,
0.0194713362,
0.0342575908,
0.0162308943,
0.0235590301,
-0.0007956426,
0.0055578314,
0.0393689312,
0.0094750356,
0.0352419503,
0.0039974595,
-0.0188274756,
-0.0013069328,
0.039654009,
0.0289078727,
-0.0020366849,
0.0178403724,
0.0676014796,
0.025841862,
0.0066022747,
0.0173128191,
-0.0604342707,
0.0452998579,
-0.0028365268,
0.0215870161,
-0.0130731286,
0.0428544134,
-0.0346090756,
-0.0628377646,
-0.0004065467,
0.0023650967,
-0.0151237547,
0.0290935393,
0.0389171503,
-9.955e-7,
-0.0637112036,
0.0308812968,
0.0505452044,
-0.0374453291,
-0.0170706771,
-0.0697095618,
0.0352990404,
0.0859234557,
0.0405943468,
-0.0539374091,
-0.0773380846,
0.0062418641,
0.0297126304,
0.0102462899,
0.0241725501,
-0.0354668647,
0.014318726,
-0.05697193,
-0.0371204168,
-0.0321172513,
0.006316958,
0.0270925201,
0.0412198752,
-0.0197922606,
0.0012709969,
-0.0092199836,
-0.0533812679,
0.05358316,
-0.0459237844,
-0.0555790178,
-0.0104322908,
-0.0120813884,
0.0051433523,
0.0128722247,
-0.0125571061,
0.0052941134,
0.0556567162,
-0.0099248039,
0.0427920111,
-0.0092452485,
-0.0564346611,
-0.0071957437,
0.0380020812,
0.0166400578,
-0.014931269,
-0.0037779727,
-0.0602089688,
-0.0554967821,
0.005079722,
-0.0417282246,
0.0301694237,
-0.0103946254,
0.0245767049,
-0.0312135909,
-0.0009526156,
-0.0197432488,
0.0393804349,
-0.0232566502,
-0.0035572576,
0.0544867441,
0.0285748783,
-0.0052115591,
-0.0522513166,
-0.004452426,
0.0036648083,
-0.001650123,
0.0198849943,
0.0153007908,
0.0304565709,
-0.0340878889,
-0.0329458155,
-0.0785588771,
0.0412696972,
-0.0339483321,
0.034456905,
0.0406226218,
-0.0018162312,
-0.0226277336,
-0.0066142413,
-0.0085492777,
-0.0234045722,
-0.0143695055,
0.0323692299,
0.0197636299,
0.0242496338,
-0.0514013618,
-0.0374703147,
-0.0233629942,
-0.0203646868,
-0.0154953478,
-0.0168897659,
0.0161389057,
-0.0805792212,
0.0111676808,
-0.0076415977,
0.0536906645,
-0.0131754205,
-0.0630354211,
0.0415976793,
-0.0135256667,
0.0493977331,
0.0905327052,
-0.0362654366,
0.0113244578,
0.0659284741,
-0.0218211506,
-0.0697504804,
0.0413491987,
-0.0297419801,
-0.0436938256,
-0.0196638368,
-0.0286193583,
-0.0124879545,
0.0924792662,
-0.0142922644,
-0.0127470503,
-0.0678631514,
-0.0071189054,
-0.0227430817,
0.0165695325,
-0.0028470713,
0.0234281756,
-0.0195705052,
-0.0074864011,
-0.0295024551,
-0.0968324989,
0.0916542709,
-0.0056955698,
-0.0069420626,
-0.0749346018,
0.0009209142,
-0.0204214118,
0.0453461409,
0.0133171007,
-0.0006003784,
0.0126393568,
-0.0180936698,
-0.0571005456,
0.0402547978,
0.0123969922,
-0.0291343741,
0.0383762158,
-0.0730998442,
-0.0115529085,
0.0096437316,
-0.0171363838,
-0.0549439788,
0.0187470317,
0.0174658224,
0.0013954156,
0.0202804487,
-0.0502640083,
-0.0297865849,
-0.0198800396,
0.0306206197,
0.0689057186,
-0.0192486364,
0.0015294056,
-0.0446880646,
-0.0342352949,
0.0462974273,
-0.0037988056,
-0.0285323821,
-0.0374928899,
0.0260856673,
0.0148376431,
0.0658280179,
-0.0248308722,
-0.0160700995,
0.0201753154,
0.021563381,
-0.0449242219,
0.000578133,
0.0608953126,
0.0721977726,
-0.0791226402,
-0.0436525159,
0.1095425338,
0.0405549556,
-0.0302830301,
0.0069457777,
0.0198464245,
0.0407646336,
0.0428394303,
0.0477794632,
-0.0709153935,
-0.0210172758,
0.0019750958,
0.0578067005,
-0.000690462,
-0.0026068245,
-0.0266280025,
-0.120803766,
0.0242143441,
0.015129366,
-0.0219062306,
-0.0125767514,
-0.0434520915,
-0.0121324779,
-0.0005950597,
0.035574656,
0.0246407595,
-0.0317240283,
0.0274735242,
0.0418508872,
-0.0228775814,
-0.0694494098,
0.0320764333,
-0.0046178359,
0.065263778,
0.072373122,
0.0043524825,
0.030358091,
-0.0398957208,
0.0490890071,
0.0051973662,
0.0077555468,
-0.0154095432,
0.0369851962,
0.0013835283,
-0.0119790426,
-0.0003954982,
0.055533655,
-0.0237838998,
-0.0012616921,
0.0181862488,
0.0658036545,
-0.0133029092,
0.0346361101,
-0.0248063281,
-0.0448548719,
0.0254748315,
0.0351775773,
0.0471896566,
-0.0624593012,
-0.0018631003,
-0.0240133721,
-0.033041548,
-0.0942819118,
0.0094329426,
0.0403230786,
-0.0440174937,
0.0054189125,
-0.064081721,
-0.0323070735,
0.0392363109,
0.0196669642,
0.04078269,
0.0082595134,
0.0229463726,
-0.0073988931,
-0.0463872515,
0.025341928,
-0.0256899036,
0.0166437943,
-0.1045822501,
-0.1051965132,
0.0243992079,
0.016580224,
-0.0002986192,
0.0141376797,
-0.0979487523,
-0.0702613816,
0.0089235371,
0.0828926936,
0.0192789361,
0.0618561842,
0.0029524169,
-0.0306321755,
0.0082234582,
0.0057126908,
-0.0227012523,
-0.0112062385,
0.0191190951,
-0.0145674478,
0.0074092406,
0.0139627671,
-0.0386543684,
0.0397829451,
0.0144528169,
0.0392790362,
-0.0225825198,
0.0329344496,
0.0357670002,
-0.0129194399,
0.003708825,
-0.0008759364,
-0.011846453,
-0.0365626253,
0.025581615,
0.0051693018,
0.0100913076,
-0.0502298065,
0.0144204814,
-0.0014712092,
-0.0474631637,
0.00805905,
-0.0090365876,
-0.0093920548,
0.0249720644,
-0.0541829169,
0.0459467247,
-0.0111302342,
0.0359678902,
0.0357588753,
0.0185163524,
-0.007294219,
0.0146759562,
-0.0008860147,
0.056611158,
0.0019008603,
0.0599751249,
0.0059664007,
0.0294408295,
-0.0235741045,
0.037798021,
-0.0246204175,
-0.0374208502,
-0.0526244827,
0.0080178725,
0.0401949361,
-0.0019364302,
0.0366388224,
-0.009820139,
0.0021031017,
-0.0140244858,
0.0169334672,
0.00942057,
-0.0246218443,
0.0034401659,
0.0476673841,
-0.003703713,
-0.0340280272,
0.1030275747,
-0.0065901573,
0.0637018085,
-0.0000587145,
0.0360964462,
-0.0392358564,
-0.0193412695,
0.0015376648,
0.0109510766,
-0.0246343743,
0.0166661255,
0.0000541205,
-0.055442173,
-0.0621711574,
0.0358944871,
0.0030827858,
-0.0214749984,
0.0403504334,
0.0072014583,
-0.0381673314,
-0.0290167648,
-0.0285598729,
0.0108245881,
-0.0118199373,
-0.0427633673,
-0.0019237782,
-6.410736236e-33,
-0.0498084277,
0.0057444912,
0.0405149199,
0.0067130546,
-0.0204799678,
0.0054424168,
-0.0570829175,
-0.0240041092,
-0.0106134955,
-0.0256163403,
-0.0063539259,
0.0152775357,
0.0166034605,
0.0143910125,
0.0399796367,
-0.0134902336,
0.0453954116,
-0.018182354,
-0.0494876653,
0.0582939051,
0.0417510681,
0.0072967927,
0.0473269448,
-0.0250149686,
0.0102361748,
-0.0060809534,
0.0079716314,
0.0358853824,
-0.014391643,
0.0852892846,
0.013447105,
0.0323564261,
0.0017185085,
-0.0621968545,
-0.0581813119,
0.0004247296,
-0.0720876157,
-0.0393120423,
0.0051098536,
0.0040036738,
-0.028322367,
-0.0544752777,
-0.000482168,
-0.0171198137,
-0.024613617,
-0.0016739208,
0.0230494291,
-0.0203099214,
-0.0231449753,
0.0190983936,
-0.0629284456,
0.0049692141,
0.0075920876,
-0.0526460223,
0.0219305754,
0.0189483557,
0.0298205838,
-0.0330431573,
-0.0467327908,
0.0288985204,
0.0624818467,
0.0795029551,
0.0602585487,
0.0440446548,
0.0439903066,
0.01872514,
0.0177011564,
0.0271619242,
0.0405856483,
0.0111874323,
0.0325974636,
0.0310140476,
-0.0048870142,
-0.0438663289,
0.0482398719,
-0.0276959594,
-0.0361316279,
0.0148436176,
0.0559728295,
0.0480717793,
0.0305472296,
0.0005827178,
-0.0261176825,
-0.006920618,
-0.0313403197,
0.0359454826,
-0.0248506982,
-0.0031978276,
0.0540993102,
0.0369704403,
-0.034608189,
-0.0216275584,
0.0317026526,
-0.0166363977,
0.0035899598,
0.004677231,
-0.017641848,
0.0236607417,
-0.0070652836,
0.0117549989,
-0.0346976556,
-0.0760839432,
0.0284661595,
-0.0314765275,
0.0365349203,
0.0182682388,
0.0277866032,
0.062548317,
-0.0582697317,
0.0128290132,
-0.0641085878,
0.0469148569,
-0.0019256742,
-0.0060951477,
0.0147618139,
0.0233001988,
-0.0072887512,
0.046928905,
0.0269744135,
-0.0264912266,
-0.047640048,
-0.0164872278,
0.015778536,
0.0284592994,
-0.0306042358,
0.0023714877,
-0.0533412769,
0.0040876814,
-0.0165141355,
-0.0592668951,
-0.0165389236,
0.0318403617,
2.813e-7,
0.0030876636,
0.0576377809,
0.0258211922,
0.0286459811,
0.0339773409,
0.0040412801,
-0.0393149555,
-0.0115894424,
0.0327065513,
-0.0107540004,
0.0058962167,
0.0334486924,
0.0433795862,
0.0223105568,
-0.0733660758,
-0.0074090618,
-0.0357216895,
0.0216710567,
-0.0792099237,
-0.0088527109,
-0.0031806165,
0.089064464,
0.0001870994,
0.0152461249,
0.0198829751,
0.0070199594,
0.0066699064,
0.0010479923,
0.0244276579,
0.033765737,
-0.0095667709,
0.0440660939,
-0.0146396318,
0.0002695656,
-0.0509131439,
0.0175402872,
-0.0546731465,
0.0695895925,
-0.0142116183,
-0.0312488955,
0.0466594435,
-0.027567761,
-0.0158629157,
-0.0320019275,
0.0517617799,
-0.0543405302,
0.0198460072,
-0.018086398,
0.0254930649,
-0.0121583305,
-0.0285507441,
-0.0213440042,
-0.0131960781,
0.0406172052,
0.0180572812,
-0.0114055872,
-0.000794605,
-0.0722202733,
-0.0058873077,
0.0375884995,
-0.0336370468,
-0.0510378219,
-0.0723890513,
-0.0207615718,
-0.0098841703,
-0.0531401895,
0.006796679,
2.823185471e-34,
0.0223154202,
-0.0288300421,
0.0396738723,
0.0452326536,
0.0312542543,
-0.0069285468,
-0.0093526347,
0.0330622494,
0.046274405,
-0.0748962536,
-0.0580301397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14326v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14326v2 | TalkUp: Paving the Way for Understanding Empowering Language | 2023-05-23T17:55:34 | 2023-10-23T06:37:47 | Lucille Njoo, Chan Young Park, Octavia Stappart, Marvin Thielk, Yi Chu, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empowering language is important in many real-world contexts, from education
to workplace dynamics to healthcare. Though language technologies are growing
more prevalent in these contexts, empowerment has seldom been studied in NLP,
and moreover, it is inherently challenging to operationalize because of its
implicit nature. This work builds from linguistic and social psychology
literature to explore what characterizes empowering language. We then
crowdsource a novel dataset of Reddit posts labeled for empowerment, reasons
why these posts are empowering to readers, and the social relationships between
posters and readers. Our preliminary analyses show that this dataset, which we
call TalkUp, can be used to train language models that capture empowering and
disempowering language. More broadly, TalkUp provides an avenue to explore
implication, presuppositions, and how social context influences the meaning of
language. | [
0.0517750196,
0.1077869311,
-0.0189906396,
-0.0047454219,
-0.001747222,
0.0066243843,
-0.0114747984,
-0.0318223238,
0.0041364944,
-0.067234531,
0.0240700785,
0.023531707,
-0.012030256,
0.010156136,
0.0285242945,
-0.0381929725,
0.000596921,
0.0523637906,
0.0323239043,
-0.0028162322,
0.0489037745,
0.0445108265,
-0.0032260213,
0.0702167153,
-0.0118324095,
-0.0020687364,
0.0500002913,
0.0198013075,
-0.0030288938,
-0.0211716183,
0.0510231219,
0.0793646351,
-0.0071983384,
0.0149386199,
0.000001812,
-0.0229632184,
0.0268017519,
-0.0219620857,
-0.0080515211,
-0.0463156924,
0.0723894015,
-0.0471558087,
0.0003463314,
0.0218608603,
-0.0325456634,
-0.0373011082,
0.0289428942,
0.0490866788,
0.0293035693,
0.0176340789,
-0.0040265573,
0.0001488964,
-0.0448761955,
-0.0014391179,
-0.0105204638,
0.0219422802,
0.0222956799,
-0.0387036316,
-0.0146248396,
0.0067246053,
0.025397785,
0.0443802886,
0.0311414842,
-0.0480375215,
0.019350512,
-0.0102728242,
-0.0269349646,
-0.0465721712,
-0.0110655036,
0.0803300515,
0.020854421,
-0.0285667572,
0.0089253159,
0.0003728739,
0.0139930379,
0.068775259,
-0.0535824187,
0.0184210297,
0.0265261028,
0.0202029757,
-0.0052845576,
0.0277823154,
0.032460168,
0.041469235,
0.0593168959,
0.0438877381,
-0.0122802183,
0.0106971171,
0.0282434635,
0.021186674,
-0.0268717501,
-0.0404762663,
0.0391888432,
-0.0245286506,
0.0197838042,
0.0437661856,
-0.0299271792,
-0.0577015467,
0.0460455157,
-0.0516736284,
0.0125839151,
-0.0032220534,
0.009682226,
-0.0005891012,
0.0097596096,
-0.0548226349,
0.0092474455,
0.0625773221,
-0.0101776496,
-0.0062495586,
-0.0311710443,
-0.012869738,
-0.0295024626,
-0.0313550159,
-0.0384733155,
0.0117595419,
-0.0299531277,
-0.0298250858,
-0.0499203429,
-0.0164514482,
-0.0562361181,
0.0295214057,
0.0067345477,
0.0130816828,
0.001220518,
0.0033453265,
-0.0393790863,
0.0271428972,
-0.0136785535,
-0.0621695891,
0.0292245559,
-0.0349215157,
-0.0122156749,
-0.0280131046,
-0.0278457459,
0.0276190396,
0.0316277668,
-0.0319720544,
-0.0574024953,
-0.0287187342,
0.0045359218,
0.0218888186,
0.0092091346,
-0.0688582063,
0.0441406928,
0.0327672251,
0.0303898491,
-0.0524503104,
0.0285175256,
0.0574137978,
-0.022474302,
0.065549925,
-0.019111,
-0.0090908352,
0.0571532212,
0.0417356044,
-0.0000955536,
0.0803049728,
0.026842149,
-0.0012209065,
0.0697803721,
-0.0095718838,
0.0223815478,
0.0300085023,
0.0218167696,
-0.0053079571,
0.001380847,
0.0163692404,
-0.0189643819,
-0.0273769163,
-0.0180736464,
0.0173437353,
0.0137193613,
0.0082820691,
0.0694369897,
0.0895088166,
-0.0178937558,
0.0197946671,
-0.0137489745,
0.0238390807,
-0.0283647478,
-0.0564241447,
-0.0351099372,
-0.0224442501,
-0.0318533331,
-0.0780835822,
-0.0196256712,
0.0077237026,
0.0034665703,
-0.0423379317,
-0.033733353,
0.0062962202,
0.0217755251,
0.00009677,
0.0053663445,
0.0379782133,
0.0243078265,
0.028790541,
0.0683043525,
-0.0926679,
0.0167030673,
-0.031886939,
-0.0085358061,
0.0039119511,
0.0246726964,
-0.0364755727,
0.0464482903,
-0.0384428613,
0.0599176511,
0.0881295875,
-0.0031811006,
0.0046360195,
-0.0394107923,
-0.0079387641,
-0.0236766189,
0.0403720848,
0.0123078665,
-0.0177678894,
0.0056683989,
-0.0114222756,
-0.0097387126,
-0.0014088769,
-0.0867468789,
0.042249985,
0.0402633213,
-0.0149846245,
-0.0103429044,
0.0263733901,
0.0075325202,
0.0332761146,
-0.0011370699,
-0.0071458928,
-0.0155030303,
-0.0356192216,
-0.1024386212,
0.0241954681,
-0.0631380305,
-0.0038759101,
0.0134729696,
-0.0643548667,
-0.0232247859,
0.0748535171,
0.0006094862,
0.0162516478,
0.0778294504,
-0.0337997153,
0.0343287624,
-0.0016734721,
-0.0211102497,
-0.0100391041,
0.0083261328,
-0.0274150334,
0.0390936881,
-0.0332715437,
-0.005693661,
0.0035032998,
-0.012388574,
-0.0222880468,
0.0327259302,
-0.0212546624,
0.020571921,
0.00380887,
0.0055230591,
0.0722313523,
-0.0181883015,
-0.0577349886,
-0.0023519136,
-0.075467214,
-0.0511375926,
-0.0370234773,
-0.0191616043,
0.0368662179,
-0.0019148441,
-0.00232501,
-0.0162991788,
-0.0285144467,
-0.0253634322,
-0.0332228728,
0.0092199594,
0.0229213629,
-0.0215224214,
0.0301203933,
-0.0552928299,
-0.0283882897,
-0.0193705466,
0.0644582883,
0.0503314473,
-0.0166102797,
0.0363381505,
-0.0277101938,
-0.016615482,
-0.0133668678,
-0.0120124593,
-0.0391048938,
0.0028909757,
0.0347554199,
0.0192257334,
0.0112219853,
0.036633011,
0.0726869032,
0.0088377064,
0.021034861,
-0.0487509742,
-0.0204754993,
-0.017333027,
-0.0229215417,
0.0010675176,
-0.0746996552,
0.0171915144,
0.0518707931,
0.0480979457,
-0.0054472499,
-0.0624121912,
0.0385443754,
-0.0640578121,
-0.0555961952,
-0.0535273142,
-0.0082155494,
-0.0122301718,
0.0225756168,
-0.0520717539,
-0.0273056347,
0.0218005963,
0.032365378,
-0.0086478628,
0.0007007782,
-0.0433869734,
-0.0283805206,
0.077595301,
-0.0003614085,
0.0345230326,
-0.0043500438,
-0.026387712,
0.0165790971,
-0.026444016,
0.001741392,
-0.0413658805,
0.0115600508,
-0.050675571,
0.0141813336,
0.0254427809,
-0.035447754,
-0.0274641942,
-0.0862412825,
-0.0002880631,
0.0045371163,
0.0231081732,
-0.0099001164,
0.0166673176,
-0.0453624502,
0.002730096,
0.0166192614,
0.0132407416,
-0.0411207564,
0.0003834005,
-0.0176518299,
0.0578524694,
-0.010791217,
0.0275998805,
0.0022565769,
-0.0014359392,
0.0769120306,
0.0309559908,
0.0007802805,
-0.0104651814,
-0.0158458538,
0.0283691939,
-0.0316978134,
0.0360633433,
-0.052666571,
0.0580112971,
-0.0265597422,
0.0309578497,
0.0685282126,
0.0082025565,
-0.0199267305,
0.0483245812,
-0.0328723602,
0.0242793225,
0.0305663384,
0.0125320032,
-0.1324377805,
-0.0288802404,
-0.0281723198,
0.0419544466,
-0.0522618853,
-0.043928504,
-0.003266322,
-0.111815542,
-0.0061997999,
-0.0020979268,
0.0156422947,
0.0218435079,
-0.0300284736,
0.0266053453,
-0.0044390927,
-0.0035280758,
-0.0210806169,
0.014737213,
0.0163270477,
0.017648641,
-0.016719874,
-0.0406820849,
0.0104953712,
-0.0404216349,
0.031539429,
0.0219592303,
0.0435615107,
0.0014675597,
0.0178548414,
0.032381665,
-0.0067039127,
-0.0177326631,
-0.0265936386,
0.0295931324,
-0.015889788,
-0.0109472414,
-0.0368192941,
0.0892987177,
-0.0548057221,
-0.0088920472,
0.0180514064,
0.0296495613,
0.0132975541,
-0.0297568552,
-0.0445657298,
-0.0006981152,
0.0498283803,
0.0503439493,
0.0502445064,
-0.0528436117,
0.003020335,
-0.0604404174,
0.0264812764,
0.0327464603,
-0.1109378263,
-0.0389296897,
0.00695574,
0.0030926277,
-0.0537820607,
-0.0361810438,
0.0457345322,
-0.0155697679,
0.0379433446,
-0.0434014723,
0.0449665748,
-0.0213894956,
-0.0409583524,
0.045893874,
-0.0211330354,
0.0264809988,
-0.0214273371,
-0.0815678686,
0.0058113071,
0.0209428873,
-0.0022710075,
0.034259513,
-0.0154629983,
-0.0575578436,
0.0430023223,
-0.0049943165,
0.0174033418,
-0.0096602254,
-0.0106170755,
-0.076274246,
0.0410129465,
0.0638618246,
-0.0394897759,
0.0292731822,
0.026076654,
0.0102232592,
0.0174280535,
0.0460256487,
-0.0231687967,
0.0511401258,
-0.0014487294,
0.0035335401,
-0.043328166,
0.0227039102,
-0.0056028641,
0.0007433192,
0.0329167806,
-0.0098632947,
-0.0283784457,
-0.0481286235,
-0.0450731069,
-0.0467805564,
-0.0324924476,
-0.0321110412,
-0.0019218645,
0.013921639,
0.0190095175,
-0.0369290933,
-0.0225477442,
-0.0139639871,
0.0341834985,
-0.0626737028,
0.0531939305,
0.0085796444,
0.0369929448,
-0.0154248932,
0.0147365555,
-0.0103788255,
0.0256002862,
-0.0207419265,
0.0179211926,
0.0093341451,
0.0434411913,
0.0247106124,
-0.0222780257,
0.0239346698,
0.0095177209,
-0.0361086242,
-0.0505220965,
0.0309859905,
0.0034184332,
0.0086721517,
-0.0434706956,
0.0684240237,
-0.0156842135,
-0.0131424023,
0.0165287759,
0.0213496219,
0.0166190825,
-0.0244148504,
0.0283733383,
-0.0039538927,
-0.0135478582,
0.0286758076,
0.0074152369,
-0.0525689423,
0.0498960912,
0.0274380445,
-0.0267302357,
-0.0119652487,
-0.0113063818,
0.0168048963,
0.0189221278,
-0.0039178291,
0.0392444022,
-0.084776774,
-0.0345113911,
-0.019074792,
0.013064472,
0.0231921226,
0.0138055943,
0.0214941055,
0.0213641189,
-0.0166575946,
-0.015599099,
-0.0580675714,
0.0091911005,
-0.0578496158,
0.0109999198,
0.0133971293,
-5.898192781e-33,
-0.0059042471,
-0.0657309294,
-0.0451830514,
0.0073872497,
-0.0105900569,
0.020239016,
-0.0192971434,
0.0241708886,
0.0080944831,
0.0533661991,
-0.0019210732,
0.0247094743,
0.0006901021,
0.0576923341,
0.0213251747,
0.0000399587,
0.0429855995,
-0.002659729,
-0.0173123013,
-0.0012893243,
0.0349294953,
0.0190532841,
0.0276900679,
-0.1081094369,
0.0822828338,
-0.0053190794,
-0.0174687598,
0.0434327349,
0.0279369894,
-0.0012192414,
-0.0192119684,
0.0984703973,
0.0066701947,
-0.0208612699,
0.0113085695,
0.0980282053,
-0.0794064179,
-0.043800965,
0.0175781213,
0.0020653782,
-0.0852925479,
0.0040595508,
0.0460582301,
0.011553376,
-0.0195752811,
-0.0152514689,
0.0648172423,
0.0001459934,
0.0751183406,
0.0022042841,
-0.0491973497,
0.0050131609,
-0.0325594246,
-0.0048316121,
-0.0113110216,
0.0229521357,
-0.00640448,
0.0012389597,
-0.0375946648,
-0.0119922757,
-0.0043338463,
0.033248391,
0.06378185,
0.0094202636,
0.0290318616,
0.1133125797,
-0.027674824,
0.0115287695,
-0.0311868005,
0.007079205,
0.017599754,
0.0009503266,
0.0633775294,
0.0366483778,
0.0201126952,
-0.019180147,
-0.0190961938,
-0.0457193367,
0.0615443327,
-0.0112183271,
0.0443439111,
-0.0332299732,
-0.0435701646,
-0.0318260491,
-0.0440002978,
-0.0650099739,
0.0016372111,
-0.0417534709,
-0.026571447,
-0.0199094843,
-0.0529212765,
0.0426078252,
-0.0298122521,
-0.0192997735,
-0.0625478402,
0.0217106957,
-0.0000735699,
-0.0125230169,
0.0260407496,
-0.0292438902,
-0.0472341999,
0.0518790483,
-0.0290906541,
0.0152098211,
0.0422112942,
0.0078624468,
0.0123814493,
0.0099383825,
-0.051759623,
-0.0239085648,
-0.0342483632,
0.0495952033,
-0.0392713808,
-0.0060051675,
0.0406549685,
0.0454015769,
-0.0167065188,
0.0254629962,
0.0249570739,
0.0476234034,
-0.0116711315,
0.020271603,
-0.0329417586,
-0.0098125366,
-0.0532716401,
-0.0472751521,
-0.0058357762,
0.0412782542,
0.0721627101,
-0.0290379394,
-0.0207879022,
-0.0633465648,
2.366e-7,
0.0396346524,
0.06865298,
0.0011365555,
0.0226720385,
-0.0050213621,
0.0323166028,
0.041405376,
0.0419608429,
-0.0015308345,
-0.0227305386,
-0.0398750491,
0.013619436,
0.0353180133,
0.0159537941,
-0.0716197044,
-0.023348704,
-0.072321482,
0.0362883955,
-0.022216158,
-0.0021732741,
0.067002371,
0.0376601741,
0.0389916115,
0.0010628538,
-0.0495352522,
-0.0073725278,
0.0212200265,
-0.0784264877,
0.0052643414,
0.0047502043,
0.014264252,
0.0114733921,
0.0201439634,
-0.0321405008,
-0.0212418493,
-0.0154838152,
0.0493735559,
0.035680946,
-0.0052556656,
-0.0074888212,
-0.0080377469,
0.0001189698,
-0.0189200677,
-0.0020789574,
0.0284087937,
-0.0747478083,
-0.0372050665,
-0.0601392053,
-0.0162544698,
-0.0215587169,
0.0413960218,
-0.0212467723,
-0.0532633513,
0.0045016995,
0.0253858157,
-0.0217174478,
-0.0197488628,
-0.0908731818,
-0.0332177319,
-0.0201026332,
0.0222143121,
-0.0020886939,
0.0062910076,
0.0348597281,
-0.0530353338,
0.0123045566,
0.0403557047,
1.737571898e-34,
-0.0157930739,
0.0324915126,
0.006349951,
-0.0189069528,
0.0512573831,
0.0181733891,
0.0351026431,
-0.0066384231,
0.0313705876,
-0.0302273557,
0.001672781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14325v1 | Improving Factuality and Reasoning in Language Models through Multiagent Debate | 2023-05-23T17:55:11 | 2023-05-23T17:55:11 | Yilun Du, Shuang Li, Antonio Torralba, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Igor Mordatch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
language generation, understanding, and few-shot learning in recent years. An
extensive body of work has explored how their performance may be further
improved through the tools of prompting, ranging from verification,
self-consistency, or intermediate scratchpads. In this paper, we present a
complementary approach to improve language responses where multiple language
model instances propose and debate their individual responses and reasoning
processes over multiple rounds to arrive at a common final answer. Our findings
indicate that this approach significantly enhances mathematical and strategic
reasoning across a number of tasks. We also demonstrate that our approach
improves the factual validity of generated content, reducing fallacious answers
and hallucinations that contemporary models are prone to. Our approach may be
directly applied to existing black-box models and uses identical procedure and
prompts for all tasks we investigate. Overall, our findings suggest that such
"society of minds" approach has the potential to significantly advance the
capabilities of LLMs and pave the way for further breakthroughs in language
generation and understanding. | [
0.0356390215,
0.0608132482,
-0.0204486363,
0.0344600156,
-0.0762618557,
-0.0235261843,
0.0450454019,
-0.0335602425,
-0.0248209257,
-0.0362478606,
-0.0005211985,
-0.0705896243,
-0.0023630783,
0.0315334722,
0.0304595437,
-0.0334489495,
0.0168303642,
-0.0566949062,
0.0355915353,
-0.0562549271,
0.0069168108,
-0.0048241201,
-0.0327858739,
0.0392782353,
-0.0085944971,
-0.0166293196,
-0.0312251132,
-0.0350177512,
0.0062661902,
-0.0414049551,
-0.011963062,
0.0692096502,
0.0134349894,
0.0597157329,
0.0000023821,
-0.0480699241,
-0.0157316644,
-0.0123870661,
-0.0629150346,
-0.0065245591,
0.0410573445,
0.0563662611,
0.0174439736,
0.0090981545,
-0.067081742,
0.0021786804,
0.0469039343,
0.0075028008,
0.0650127903,
0.0347442515,
0.01676175,
-0.0252884682,
-0.0084888507,
-0.0043208902,
0.015197712,
-0.0334960632,
0.0082738409,
0.0471248589,
0.0305938143,
0.0023764945,
-0.0031901416,
0.0293254219,
0.0365902297,
-0.0440964177,
0.0144176297,
0.0327886865,
-0.0420759246,
-0.0348577872,
-0.0022851566,
0.0551670603,
0.0731623322,
-0.0213625114,
-0.013470809,
-0.0136279296,
0.0063665509,
0.0429151691,
-0.0651244372,
0.0621995777,
-0.0027814077,
0.017451033,
0.0221466236,
0.0240049046,
0.0185267162,
0.0325708985,
-0.0152012846,
0.0770308152,
-0.0079224147,
-0.018084513,
-0.0234443247,
0.0248148087,
0.0087183816,
-0.0988293067,
-0.0116040297,
0.050653521,
-0.0456994809,
0.0303422529,
-0.0038591332,
-0.0083688572,
0.0315686427,
-0.0360038541,
0.0679530799,
0.0283390712,
0.0249698926,
0.0586442091,
0.0058921375,
-0.0011799741,
-0.0161616337,
0.0131189078,
-0.0071620666,
-0.0004091206,
-0.0529549196,
-0.0291270744,
-0.0357659385,
0.0507870093,
0.0022753086,
0.0109222122,
0.0066427616,
0.00064497,
-0.0647764131,
0.0300797112,
-0.0259521883,
0.0376099162,
-0.0057696267,
-0.0637646616,
-0.0696088672,
0.0425640009,
-0.0477445498,
0.0075840619,
0.0329297334,
-0.0624041334,
-0.0190978125,
-0.0015833231,
-0.0180967171,
-0.0015736655,
0.00983808,
0.0385291651,
-0.009997108,
0.030048212,
-0.0109091355,
-0.0480026975,
-0.0098503632,
-0.0788493007,
-0.0041221445,
-0.1092359722,
0.0221880544,
0.0053351056,
-0.0188703537,
-0.0244519524,
0.0314130224,
0.0098740142,
0.0088820923,
0.0741332918,
-0.0369841456,
0.0067354799,
0.0579581335,
0.0198142175,
-0.0339312889,
0.0883917212,
0.0465888269,
-0.0013179049,
0.0066094021,
0.0106424643,
0.005781977,
0.0238848124,
0.0193390325,
0.0190610029,
-0.0083173253,
0.0230237357,
0.0169531293,
0.0324357674,
-0.0389820859,
0.0487092026,
-0.0559965707,
-0.0106940102,
0.0561222695,
0.0503056161,
-0.0329211317,
0.017451793,
0.0286204256,
-0.0112020429,
0.0139958477,
0.0137335761,
-0.007850647,
0.0575796477,
-0.0106335729,
-0.0068524149,
0.0404957086,
0.0239919536,
-0.0076268264,
-0.0410016552,
-0.0036759947,
0.0200427566,
0.0190918893,
0.0394455828,
0.0280402731,
-0.0133393807,
0.0007216228,
0.0452631861,
0.0302456673,
-0.0221933033,
-0.0100995423,
-0.0769873634,
0.0547841527,
0.0204123612,
0.0524016768,
-0.001877428,
-0.0680818781,
-0.03896375,
0.0248929895,
0.0883670151,
0.0895242169,
-0.0324528702,
-0.0594541244,
-0.0383302011,
-0.0203085113,
-0.0161649827,
0.0024533954,
0.0377830155,
0.0013613916,
-0.024895113,
-0.0069139823,
0.0186334625,
-0.0188685991,
0.0012801432,
-0.0297763292,
-0.008363137,
-0.0267549865,
0.0072932513,
0.0462927148,
0.0046711015,
-0.0177139435,
0.0386355519,
0.0028512392,
-0.0225699991,
-0.0258924328,
0.0037571811,
-0.0522608496,
-0.0013409178,
0.0502385572,
0.003002367,
-0.002235234,
-0.0394079611,
0.0030984217,
-0.0190701522,
0.0496864468,
-0.0145612285,
-0.0127327433,
-0.0172979087,
0.002357366,
-0.017796291,
-0.028223861,
-0.0415666029,
0.0571021289,
0.0409010276,
-0.0064373515,
0.0321667008,
0.0241508801,
0.0322803296,
-0.0509137176,
0.0157005806,
0.0420244038,
0.0162358414,
0.0125312107,
0.0594742857,
-0.0073298709,
-0.0515916906,
-0.0249891896,
-0.0741273463,
-0.0212612692,
-0.0152441263,
0.0149143636,
0.022037698,
-0.0457346849,
0.0127512077,
0.0130979111,
-0.0566964373,
0.0152273346,
0.0549233891,
0.0078064376,
0.040565677,
0.0082454225,
-0.0159159265,
-0.0207854658,
0.0148063349,
-0.0230230633,
0.0408147238,
0.0538157783,
0.0005408583,
-0.0476437435,
0.0004431904,
-0.0829240307,
-0.0019838242,
0.002460537,
0.0046652225,
0.0636892244,
-0.0144453496,
0.0152829541,
0.0405897275,
0.0146902967,
0.0400449038,
0.0538949333,
-0.0325389095,
-0.0881568417,
0.0033142422,
0.0031770545,
0.0305817742,
-0.0191069636,
-0.060873583,
-0.0153531479,
0.0723016039,
0.0104489103,
0.0021612521,
-0.0597018264,
0.1198067889,
-0.0156236812,
-0.0347207226,
-0.053782776,
-0.0422778279,
-0.0097970339,
0.069687888,
-0.0255407374,
-0.0255979616,
0.0885031894,
-0.0281089414,
-0.0058083711,
-0.0232108831,
0.0097321775,
-0.0335875861,
0.07565438,
-0.0087480498,
0.0124472706,
0.0161243435,
0.027747849,
-0.0775171816,
-0.0362175256,
0.0655091256,
-0.0446887352,
0.0268547721,
-0.0637890026,
0.0106658395,
-0.0111517506,
-0.0243541747,
-0.0301608369,
-0.0226521231,
-0.0349423513,
0.0355898701,
-0.0046258434,
0.0060538216,
-0.0174982511,
0.0120524801,
0.0544028692,
-0.0167567655,
-0.0205317512,
-0.0144377761,
0.0005929539,
0.0120547786,
0.0450832956,
0.0276636239,
0.0570628308,
-0.050155405,
0.0470512398,
0.0759460032,
0.0537956245,
0.0035041051,
-0.0075772721,
-0.0190681424,
0.0163416527,
-0.0042473059,
-0.0147053497,
0.0149206184,
0.0347370021,
-0.0626201406,
-0.0163904801,
0.0843981951,
0.0340272151,
0.0101463646,
-0.014938144,
-0.0729893073,
0.0401966609,
0.0119856037,
0.0348597318,
-0.0945381522,
-0.0011662415,
-0.0155028449,
-0.012835823,
-0.0315221511,
-0.072169967,
-0.036605902,
-0.1229001954,
0.0375695564,
0.0299260616,
-0.0364353545,
0.0355390422,
0.0058141886,
0.0037784595,
0.0065264408,
-0.0125507675,
0.0398692116,
0.0294327419,
0.0223809127,
0.0330208838,
0.0208785832,
0.0018738472,
0.0124894483,
-0.0304569583,
0.0944161862,
0.032000877,
0.0145823378,
0.0031329563,
-0.0536151901,
-0.0073373457,
0.0185530912,
-0.0327210799,
-0.004047072,
-0.0064661745,
0.0159952696,
-0.0075380919,
0.0063665551,
-0.011466735,
0.0081487047,
-0.0508567616,
0.0287262462,
0.0614812709,
-0.0294080246,
-0.0453569852,
-0.004273592,
0.03070103,
0.0066321893,
0.0687347129,
0.0158203151,
-0.018994756,
-0.0292468145,
-0.0633291081,
-0.0324214101,
-0.0626555905,
-0.0449884236,
-0.0116872322,
0.0445062295,
0.033038117,
-0.0609163828,
-0.041571781,
0.045252651,
0.037383344,
-0.0031323966,
-0.0119443368,
0.0273747686,
0.0060285013,
0.0273959283,
-0.006492001,
-0.0610331483,
-0.0040111849,
-0.0234931316,
-0.0399631001,
-0.0136693697,
-0.053001944,
-0.0116773341,
0.0098143807,
-0.055123046,
-0.0734752938,
0.0074720015,
0.0501985438,
0.0299925096,
-0.0060653449,
0.0324550644,
-0.0267337337,
0.0267653391,
0.0115793925,
-0.0093666939,
-0.0049690879,
-0.0057575963,
0.0105979415,
-0.0094053904,
0.029271679,
0.0007252351,
0.0203996301,
0.0117266262,
0.0558284782,
-0.0524368845,
-0.0449165367,
0.0411545634,
0.0255576521,
-0.0117698321,
-0.0066842563,
-0.0153697142,
-0.0219338425,
0.0013961432,
-0.0345492214,
-0.0378058068,
-0.016771283,
-0.0227469727,
-0.0299937725,
-0.0516727567,
0.0465096943,
-0.0249394532,
-0.0159463342,
0.0551632047,
0.0337789804,
0.0179476142,
0.0035063424,
0.0163293276,
0.0238089375,
-0.0072062588,
-0.0030809906,
0.0088349544,
-0.0103939483,
0.0667027012,
-0.003188591,
0.0698786676,
0.0133661842,
-0.0394720361,
0.0121568954,
0.0055648498,
-0.0712595433,
-0.1012576967,
0.0089547737,
0.0273030642,
0.0211116988,
0.0382857807,
0.0052611958,
-0.0464977138,
-0.0115212081,
0.0176452752,
-0.0195020549,
0.0499113128,
-0.0480536185,
0.023880247,
0.0346577987,
-0.01161109,
-0.0299534202,
0.0475395545,
-0.0181925632,
0.0255693998,
-0.0030979689,
0.0234864503,
-0.0458923355,
-0.0491585396,
-0.0258078333,
0.009090405,
-0.0080224341,
0.0290743578,
-0.0895799771,
-0.0229017697,
-0.021553183,
0.0469163842,
0.0072696335,
-0.0124968672,
0.0361475684,
0.0641117096,
-0.0067122914,
0.015498139,
-0.0448329933,
0.0540793613,
-0.0194635261,
0.0190711748,
-0.0290492848,
-6.858170528e-33,
-0.0392891206,
-0.0763870031,
0.0683082864,
-0.0342493653,
0.0009275884,
-0.036395479,
-0.0390495956,
0.0339112878,
-0.0217705965,
0.018378675,
0.0062237242,
-0.0171172004,
0.0016629905,
0.0094995918,
0.0267283265,
-0.0249427352,
0.0360957198,
-0.0064592585,
-0.0351638719,
0.0009790944,
0.0170230474,
-0.0312818587,
0.0273699053,
-0.0107252551,
0.0540202372,
0.0061703431,
-0.0092150029,
0.0263784658,
-0.0705914423,
0.0247343816,
-0.0091994405,
0.0199196264,
0.0049717631,
-0.0706335083,
-0.0153976521,
-0.00351775,
0.0126654087,
-0.0273998324,
0.027778687,
-0.0480812825,
-0.013192012,
-0.0343599357,
0.0109863635,
0.0005736037,
-0.0211864207,
-0.0058976929,
0.0075090686,
-0.01612713,
0.0034731668,
0.0300827455,
-0.0635280982,
0.0208821651,
-0.0138978343,
-0.0094072865,
-0.0044377279,
0.03515964,
-0.0107653188,
-0.009286969,
-0.0645128638,
0.0703044161,
0.0330458991,
-0.0054028491,
0.0727883652,
-0.0111246035,
0.0054416279,
0.0717721805,
0.0226003397,
0.022359604,
-0.0582992435,
-0.0416578315,
-0.0117876809,
0.0327166244,
0.0934311301,
0.0795590132,
0.0016783031,
0.040596921,
-0.0391146131,
0.0048184837,
0.0420907289,
0.0296194311,
0.0282468386,
-0.0115571506,
-0.008312908,
-0.0230930522,
-0.050791692,
-0.0263455119,
-0.0253850818,
-0.0346031338,
-0.0028907626,
-0.0010860887,
-0.0416102,
-0.0178776514,
0.028264612,
-0.0377551429,
-0.0337109566,
-0.0136904437,
0.0185184814,
0.0115788961,
0.0055316822,
0.0049825613,
-0.0508672297,
0.0244726259,
-0.0277827084,
0.023368597,
0.0111816358,
0.0419689827,
-0.0231535137,
-0.007978416,
-0.050211601,
0.0122044971,
-0.0547052659,
0.0192558672,
0.0107101165,
-0.0309123229,
0.0177078657,
-0.0041879592,
-0.0123224026,
0.015976049,
0.0141073745,
-0.0507509559,
-0.0152669856,
0.02849387,
-0.0381231718,
0.0185427405,
-0.0134703163,
0.0331278406,
-0.0578166135,
0.0312871374,
0.0396042615,
0.0048840805,
-0.0102529293,
-0.0211708657,
2.942e-7,
0.0313958526,
0.0599014089,
-0.0020960772,
0.0223072916,
0.0228483211,
0.0682173595,
-0.0284324028,
-0.030793665,
0.0348271057,
-0.0516961776,
-0.0116877137,
0.0544293039,
0.0440307856,
0.0795029849,
-0.0647901893,
-0.0308739431,
-0.0767470747,
0.0059238351,
-0.0315539949,
-0.0032442154,
0.0500458069,
0.0158686992,
0.0178891066,
-0.0088473232,
-0.0210332368,
-0.0222409815,
0.0701922476,
-0.0167241581,
-0.0167647377,
0.0527082458,
-0.009148743,
-0.0677682683,
0.0166368894,
0.0200380199,
0.0109501835,
-0.0063582426,
-0.0471154004,
0.0247826818,
0.0196155757,
-0.0047505125,
-0.0206850991,
-0.0235938337,
0.0118909096,
-0.0877867863,
0.060351193,
-0.0791929066,
-0.0311224945,
-0.0341165885,
0.0162689686,
-0.0171963125,
0.0336454175,
-0.0255726334,
-0.0286811832,
-0.0005632276,
-0.0115199983,
0.0110085495,
0.0251364838,
-0.0293072555,
-0.0335248783,
-0.0031615472,
-0.0341517143,
-0.0597281232,
-0.0200093444,
-0.0090869246,
-0.0173488613,
-0.0334208012,
0.0067790272,
2.646928588e-34,
0.0252638776,
0.0141293099,
0.0202128477,
0.0404477753,
0.0448985435,
0.018226862,
-0.0274189562,
-0.0093838656,
0.0506086797,
-0.0452387221,
-0.0335169211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14324v2 | Ties Matter: Meta-Evaluating Modern Metrics with Pairwise Accuracy and Tie Calibration | 2023-05-23T17:54:57 | 2023-10-17T16:33:33 | Daniel Deutsch, George Foster, Markus Freitag | cs.CL | cs.CL | Kendall's tau is frequently used to meta-evaluate how well machine
translation (MT) evaluation metrics score individual translations. Its focus on
pairwise score comparisons is intuitive but raises the question of how ties
should be handled, a gray area that has motivated different variants in the
literature. We demonstrate that, in settings like modern MT meta-evaluation,
existing variants have weaknesses arising from their handling of ties, and in
some situations can even be gamed. We propose instead to meta-evaluate metrics
with a version of pairwise accuracy that gives metrics credit for correctly
predicting ties, in combination with a tie calibration procedure that
automatically introduces ties into metric scores, enabling fair comparison
between metrics that do and do not predict ties. We argue and provide
experimental evidence that these modifications lead to fairer ranking-based
assessments of metric performance. | [
0.0084394012,
0.0575154275,
-0.0034775937,
0.0028316251,
-0.0261064172,
0.0010117588,
0.0757670105,
0.0192348007,
-0.0453777872,
-0.0280953404,
-0.0566372313,
0.0208129324,
0.048925221,
-0.0007038394,
0.0028207754,
-0.0561046898,
0.0286099501,
0.0174655989,
0.0039971336,
-0.0166927576,
-0.0301097222,
-0.0114858421,
-0.0083269421,
0.0383679643,
0.0479968525,
0.0161672644,
0.0575999171,
0.0361090377,
0.0663905069,
-0.0292366575,
-0.0473866835,
0.0518491752,
-0.0461642966,
0.0737086907,
0.0000018545,
-0.0595830493,
-0.0277305637,
0.0214666426,
0.0058728093,
0.0223955829,
0.0269406103,
-0.0244794879,
0.0116387373,
-0.0047212145,
-0.0445104912,
-0.0021451078,
0.0402656831,
-0.0819962472,
0.0335333496,
0.0260742921,
-0.0062765433,
0.0171905793,
-0.0441757292,
-0.0562684536,
-0.0307101216,
-0.0476241745,
-0.0271800272,
0.0079798317,
-0.0882480741,
-0.0073581086,
-0.0003823933,
0.0579576604,
-0.0146295652,
0.0056537176,
0.0140308235,
0.0028352134,
-0.0742725655,
0.0038975475,
0.021081537,
0.0416462049,
0.0045424514,
0.0299754944,
-0.0088140238,
0.0035292904,
0.0405620299,
0.0385241769,
-0.0374519043,
-0.0116708055,
0.0017604429,
-0.0314602293,
-0.0190477632,
0.0899385512,
0.0175637566,
0.0008045627,
-0.049244374,
0.0191590954,
0.0168414786,
-0.0365465321,
0.0140910689,
0.0506707765,
-0.0469991975,
-0.0096962238,
0.0502530932,
-0.0519341938,
-0.0300097242,
-0.0122932959,
0.0232995432,
-0.0314784758,
0.0155604947,
-0.0480265543,
0.0178038795,
0.0379172191,
-0.0042495462,
0.042750936,
-0.0002106022,
0.0456238762,
0.0245527271,
0.0493567362,
-0.0531990528,
0.0270745046,
-0.0274081994,
0.038233798,
0.0294271894,
-0.0287560932,
-0.0341408141,
0.0277125705,
-0.0618754216,
-0.0268943943,
-0.0352783687,
0.0237830896,
0.0621003322,
-0.0275218431,
-0.0380107351,
-0.0034716064,
-0.0116719976,
0.0526898764,
-0.046019841,
0.0184536036,
-0.0034752844,
-0.0125364102,
-0.0047465833,
0.0168135874,
-0.0285299663,
-0.0252857413,
0.011571439,
0.0765728727,
0.0120716449,
-0.0117773628,
0.0988453329,
-0.0142364744,
-0.038399104,
-0.0641303435,
-0.0118901338,
-0.0786734149,
0.0711761042,
0.018338358,
0.0253326576,
-0.0063470281,
-0.013451538,
-0.0211979728,
-0.0133107211,
0.0168571938,
0.020964345,
0.0069379611,
-0.0376949832,
-0.0009655007,
-0.0657210797,
0.0349446535,
0.0370383598,
0.0295178555,
0.0280704368,
-0.017240759,
-0.0685602501,
0.0375796743,
-0.0051187878,
0.0418868773,
-0.0141302133,
0.0090061435,
0.0341361314,
0.0616933033,
0.008049937,
0.0317830443,
-0.0153881051,
0.0368287824,
0.0657428876,
0.0160916448,
0.0486993939,
0.0215486959,
0.012581666,
-0.0361892395,
-0.007705682,
0.0110201668,
-0.0420200862,
0.0086926958,
-0.012498253,
-0.0027557365,
0.0520884134,
0.0601036139,
0.0155905364,
-0.0354777724,
0.0124767162,
0.0546499602,
-0.0245649256,
-0.0102440752,
0.0233749393,
0.0103423884,
0.0118538802,
-0.0101427091,
-0.0358561389,
-0.0304345991,
0.0115459226,
-0.0267283078,
-0.0919615552,
0.0405450054,
0.037871927,
0.0011081655,
0.0015733765,
-0.0188098252,
-0.0080678994,
0.0302598868,
0.0310852285,
0.0055454392,
0.0142422169,
-0.0172007922,
-0.0251507051,
0.0580896996,
0.0197855011,
0.0286381319,
-0.0351480581,
0.0522588566,
-0.0030843755,
-0.0836635679,
-0.0452793054,
0.0229737852,
0.0543977767,
0.0097357836,
0.0157759935,
0.0153157888,
0.0295146741,
0.0427600108,
-0.0352599509,
0.0039068717,
0.0024038258,
-0.0111190937,
-0.0021292728,
0.0421273597,
-0.0092096822,
-0.0139468713,
0.0082153417,
-0.0532975607,
-0.0305537172,
0.0082735736,
-0.0487923324,
-0.0112374276,
-0.0305345207,
0.013627016,
0.0078723533,
0.0095823603,
0.0367161408,
-0.0210467894,
-0.0290112719,
-0.0438758768,
0.0489046238,
-0.017869696,
0.0498029999,
0.0124764284,
-0.0785807744,
0.0103218509,
0.0048784767,
-0.0368869156,
0.0455077998,
0.010230883,
0.0221081823,
0.0443649814,
0.0275334325,
-0.0471970625,
-0.0516081043,
-0.0696242601,
0.0187485702,
0.0064700129,
0.0469963588,
0.0399055481,
-0.0153782247,
0.0096792812,
0.0072570182,
-0.0210748278,
-0.0424215682,
0.0193909351,
0.0116476798,
0.0003600619,
0.022511933,
0.0241789035,
-0.0347029492,
-0.041000694,
-0.0092564076,
0.0592632294,
0.0404692926,
0.0120038996,
-0.0326591283,
0.0688877627,
-0.0625563338,
-0.0358300731,
0.0190813672,
-0.0462066568,
0.02500429,
0.0300550293,
-0.008025662,
0.0717087016,
0.0174989589,
-0.0128041264,
0.0795102194,
-0.0189510118,
-0.0430857241,
-0.0233698655,
0.0058515631,
-0.0320314355,
-0.0097573623,
-0.0661973432,
0.0058415798,
0.0052052881,
0.023062529,
-0.0160793271,
-0.0283611771,
0.0004426636,
-0.0497193411,
-0.0174782202,
-0.057626389,
0.0244058054,
-0.009282372,
0.061290659,
-0.0143862069,
-0.0405598469,
0.0646083802,
-0.0076003713,
0.018222874,
-0.0489326976,
0.0420570709,
-0.0081792865,
0.0393709429,
-0.0214021057,
0.0199390221,
-0.0699938908,
-0.0057518496,
-0.058387477,
0.0077107553,
0.0651319548,
-0.060311418,
0.0232560914,
-0.0365049131,
-0.03407114,
-0.0144986603,
-0.0230242666,
0.0169760473,
0.0367329828,
-0.0121939927,
-0.0171090234,
0.0161301885,
-0.0246564653,
-0.0440281071,
0.0025814772,
0.0447121896,
0.0148740206,
-0.0292558279,
-0.0157094747,
0.0188223589,
0.0263273846,
-0.0159474891,
-0.0295155831,
0.0195174441,
-0.0417164005,
0.0396391973,
0.0192894414,
-0.0171719305,
0.0324650072,
0.0225235242,
-0.0253245477,
0.0212534573,
-0.0159162022,
-0.0321994498,
-0.004372858,
0.0657911301,
-0.0251670722,
0.0185617451,
0.0813142657,
0.0373507477,
-0.0416700616,
-0.026536325,
-0.0000934862,
0.052221667,
0.0158772245,
-0.0022895974,
-0.0422271192,
0.0039373632,
0.0033830865,
0.063019909,
-0.0077263135,
-0.0310818404,
0.0328129493,
-0.063973017,
-0.0049535949,
0.0245941766,
-0.0635060593,
-0.0030939823,
-0.0392028615,
0.0138265714,
-0.0593486689,
0.0168036558,
0.0010614888,
-0.0011266532,
0.0415891521,
0.0020720318,
0.0038867565,
-0.0571704842,
0.0094952723,
-0.0835156366,
0.0473707505,
0.0244885813,
0.047234565,
-0.029138688,
-0.0477071591,
0.0129734082,
0.0089413887,
-0.0283548366,
-0.0048800511,
0.0672547147,
-0.0107179852,
-0.0048207226,
-0.038049262,
-0.0451341309,
0.0362834483,
0.0451950319,
0.0030175517,
0.0205287281,
0.0231535826,
0.0214672256,
0.0281303469,
0.0120793488,
-0.0270704012,
0.0341890901,
0.0112374043,
-0.0405802876,
0.0383246914,
-0.0535538718,
0.0306659602,
-0.053627748,
-0.0419960096,
0.0255070142,
-0.042166125,
-0.0155819952,
-0.0767929032,
-0.0662550479,
0.0160802361,
0.0355145112,
0.0129082287,
0.0059754564,
-0.0811374336,
0.0068066679,
-0.0427456498,
0.0163313784,
0.0070626573,
0.0138846533,
-0.0193777699,
0.0437702127,
-0.0061614802,
0.0287215896,
-0.0361703299,
0.0442361385,
-0.0284056328,
-0.0060571404,
-0.0003682331,
0.0684557334,
0.0295498837,
-0.0312959515,
-0.0062901652,
0.0250691678,
-0.0257906038,
0.0645048395,
-0.0121627394,
-0.0075613121,
0.0383742824,
-0.0292765871,
-0.0281666964,
0.0109073734,
-0.028522566,
-0.0141656268,
0.006580411,
0.0465953574,
0.0026104741,
-0.0453597419,
0.0230864026,
0.0333635844,
0.0720709637,
-0.0630667433,
-0.0163001157,
0.0124882311,
-0.0104132397,
-0.0406466536,
-0.028574653,
-0.0099533359,
-0.0238914657,
0.0449795239,
0.0403472558,
-0.0082459496,
0.0755640343,
-0.044782687,
-0.0178069677,
-0.0504405312,
0.0379049741,
-0.0245774668,
0.0885764286,
-0.004430173,
0.0144094061,
-0.0427635163,
-0.0320160091,
0.0342879109,
0.0386682004,
-0.0206039716,
-0.0113219526,
0.0297421012,
0.0203909706,
0.0237107165,
0.0766655728,
-0.0552395172,
0.0171961877,
-0.0095082326,
-0.0302739851,
0.0269652084,
0.0245836433,
0.0879615545,
0.0458557718,
-0.0093905628,
-0.0101045957,
0.0046623172,
0.0096179284,
0.004495672,
-0.044921618,
-0.0279230401,
0.023985846,
0.0294612925,
0.0316872559,
-0.0695545524,
-0.0087630972,
-0.0305575021,
-0.0454468802,
-0.0101483054,
-0.0304654203,
-0.046027936,
-0.0251053944,
0.0055343858,
-0.0630495623,
-0.0866992623,
-0.0376005024,
0.0058544441,
0.0335760154,
0.0455219075,
0.0073497961,
-0.0321151353,
0.0743149742,
-0.0387173332,
-0.0191766601,
-0.030150054,
0.0007853836,
-0.0101528019,
-0.0401276201,
-0.0203794912,
-5.88357257e-33,
-0.0277921874,
-0.0158128683,
-0.0219089352,
-0.0433265939,
-0.031731043,
0.0010600351,
-0.0150679778,
0.0207753796,
-0.0168568864,
0.0146827921,
-0.0116560943,
-0.0177241545,
0.0258370005,
-0.036625091,
0.0339856409,
0.0024630392,
0.036700543,
0.011297415,
-0.06109979,
-0.016306337,
0.0056673153,
-0.0198890381,
0.0720053762,
-0.040688958,
0.0716644153,
0.0114772413,
-0.0453367345,
-0.0034995722,
0.0062871287,
-0.0000914152,
0.0331916735,
0.0106013101,
0.0308417659,
-0.0383380763,
-0.0074345465,
-0.0343161263,
-0.0591212809,
-0.0078032492,
0.0489727631,
-0.0056512123,
0.0007064856,
-0.0079618888,
0.0295320526,
-0.0121053392,
-0.0562844537,
-0.0575072616,
0.0197231062,
-0.0480284169,
-0.0432074443,
-0.0050720554,
0.006236827,
0.0149572557,
-0.0246283021,
0.0172194261,
0.0105733387,
0.0516532548,
-0.0050567561,
-0.0030528069,
-0.0601746105,
0.0275164954,
-0.0334629416,
0.0598545074,
0.0453035384,
-0.0223254692,
-0.0187555812,
0.0402462222,
-0.009033842,
0.011702463,
0.0313788019,
-0.0021908549,
0.0335983373,
-0.0319029391,
0.0797707215,
0.059577845,
0.0415637456,
-0.003171439,
-0.0556153655,
0.0696621984,
-0.0400942713,
0.0098809591,
-0.0236190222,
0.0110004684,
-0.0435805656,
-0.0083344197,
-0.0474595502,
-0.1052597463,
-0.0252023209,
-0.0521796495,
0.017782934,
0.0026623395,
-0.0499886982,
-0.0085531715,
0.0640859976,
-0.0044698478,
0.0112069491,
-0.0147098713,
-0.0249258317,
0.0501820631,
-0.0136093339,
0.0191029124,
-0.0036486308,
0.0177615732,
0.036188852,
0.104836598,
0.0497318208,
-0.0506104752,
0.0395005532,
-0.0247334093,
-0.0581360757,
0.0124031752,
-0.0250259675,
-0.0089807734,
-0.0168294851,
-0.0817328021,
-0.0043025292,
0.0103069181,
0.0210207831,
0.0229364727,
0.0191245787,
0.0053806724,
-0.0537722558,
0.0650150552,
-0.018268941,
0.0387089737,
-0.0187443942,
0.0193411205,
-0.0073062144,
0.024928635,
0.0309336856,
-0.0270950198,
-0.0523395203,
-0.0359423645,
2.541e-7,
0.0972039178,
0.0623963997,
-0.0154725807,
0.0083521325,
-0.0239227172,
0.0013539449,
-0.0256045312,
0.0398219638,
0.0735712275,
0.0169958174,
0.0356313102,
0.0121683199,
0.0316483602,
0.0536118746,
-0.0213973541,
-0.0558774285,
-0.070428744,
0.0085860305,
-0.0391498618,
-0.0213069152,
0.0581837483,
0.0216605663,
0.0103488406,
0.0228616893,
-0.0021750946,
-0.0332986787,
0.0509908125,
-0.0204545967,
-0.0000995041,
-0.0021917878,
0.0237913299,
-0.0373355858,
-0.0229443237,
0.0253711753,
-0.0080503374,
0.0208786093,
0.0815999955,
0.0329659544,
0.0195936989,
0.0305704363,
-0.0181114636,
-0.0090618897,
0.0146686463,
-0.0568224452,
0.0360262655,
-0.0339843817,
-0.0335426293,
0.0054454566,
-0.0616875514,
0.0216269623,
0.0804545581,
-0.0076403092,
-0.0366490819,
0.0493386239,
0.0174675565,
0.0631944835,
-0.0075646462,
0.0047478676,
-0.0434292182,
-0.0112069156,
0.0009052852,
-0.0762772486,
0.0198491439,
0.0030920333,
-0.0350864828,
-0.0362563208,
-0.0087526888,
1.943916156e-34,
0.0424514823,
-0.0130813466,
0.03486773,
-0.0673965514,
0.0432055034,
-0.0246950835,
-0.040086776,
-0.0391026177,
0.0022278137,
-0.04363098,
0.0029442899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14323v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14323v3 | ChatCoT: Tool-Augmented Chain-of-Thought Reasoning on Chat-based Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:54:33 | 2023-11-06T11:00:26 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Beichen Zhang, Zheng Gong, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) have achieved excellent performance in
a variety of evaluation benchmarks, they still struggle in complex reasoning
tasks which require specific knowledge and multi-hop reasoning. To improve the
reasoning abilities, we propose ChatCoT, a tool-augmented chain-of-thought
reasoning framework for chat-based LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT). In ChatCoT, we model
the chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning as multi-turn conversations, to utilize
tools in a more natural way through chatting. At each turn, LLMs can either
interact with tools or perform the reasoning. Our approach can effectively
leverage the multi-turn conversation ability of chat-based LLMs, and integrate
the thought chain following and tools manipulation in a unified way. Specially,
we initialize the early turns of the conversation by the knowledge about tools,
tasks, and reasoning format, and propose an iterative tool-augmented reasoning
step to perform step-by-step tool-augmented reasoning. The experiment results
on two complex reasoning datasets (MATH and HotpotQA) have shown the
effectiveness of ChatCoT on complex reasoning tasks, achieving a 7.9% relative
improvement over the state-of-the-art baseline. Our code and data are available
at: \url{https://github.com/RUCAIBOX/ChatCoT}. | [
0.0129585685,
0.0197418258,
-0.0095391488,
0.056841217,
-0.0656498,
0.033374466,
0.0235083457,
-0.0202453341,
0.0500131473,
-0.0402804315,
-0.0264415927,
0.0095998468,
-0.0055154418,
0.0061881104,
0.0209041145,
-0.03913242,
0.0288392194,
-0.0432713293,
-0.017108541,
-0.0148176197,
0.0043241857,
0.0202356074,
-0.0568668433,
0.0398409478,
-0.0166457463,
-0.0495714322,
-0.0333203189,
-0.0270819739,
0.0147877578,
-0.0079770954,
-0.0017437552,
0.072430633,
0.0065273689,
0.0518852919,
0.0000021685,
-0.0444897264,
-0.0107098417,
0.0068667829,
-0.0520862341,
-0.0254924428,
-0.0024427662,
0.0343658999,
0.0124311214,
0.0449998938,
-0.0441938341,
0.018806044,
0.0197002552,
0.0311875399,
0.0688001513,
0.0632609501,
0.0028855128,
-0.0224193111,
0.0022676901,
0.0033178818,
0.019613618,
-0.0590007417,
0.0094448728,
0.0652297065,
0.0543822907,
0.0344382674,
0.011768437,
0.0421333797,
0.0502492562,
-0.0279105417,
-0.0046911999,
0.0269745998,
-0.0404646359,
-0.013925924,
0.0180721376,
0.0731744319,
-0.0077153347,
-0.0221737549,
-0.0129567822,
0.0162887517,
0.0096789543,
0.0018867914,
-0.0785654932,
0.0171304513,
-0.0104265204,
-0.0159185771,
-0.0104477918,
-0.0329916589,
0.0204242319,
0.0276609138,
-0.0438133404,
0.0775423273,
-0.0146530867,
-0.0164999012,
-0.0075191869,
-0.0113397064,
-0.025811296,
-0.0708924904,
0.0009177444,
0.0710378811,
-0.0513722412,
0.0176855437,
0.022932345,
0.0124948267,
-0.0101142181,
-0.0447504148,
-0.0203263145,
0.05577261,
0.004640182,
0.0654180869,
-0.012755136,
0.0003589152,
0.0034307714,
0.0333314277,
-0.0288471822,
-0.0406358317,
-0.0752988085,
-0.0065125744,
-0.0106620481,
0.0473536849,
-0.0103277089,
-0.010668613,
-0.0241512712,
0.039651867,
-0.0140425311,
0.0190272629,
0.0227667838,
-0.0175868627,
0.0405698977,
-0.0308508836,
-0.0341515318,
0.0536654294,
-0.0228713434,
0.012869128,
0.0390478931,
-0.0385845192,
-0.0210777037,
0.0051378212,
-0.0261542238,
-0.025621146,
-0.0026268142,
0.0843132064,
-0.0218759738,
0.0229504798,
-0.0107543487,
-0.0534252971,
0.0248698201,
-0.0843111575,
0.0030476397,
-0.079573229,
0.0396600775,
0.0439459346,
-0.0215474274,
-0.0021985001,
0.0089340014,
0.0288269538,
-0.0386345722,
0.0642038509,
0.0203138702,
0.0001338452,
-0.0018385716,
0.0348269157,
-0.0794124529,
0.0592133775,
0.0110412836,
0.0094972095,
0.0005340406,
-0.000836932,
-0.0001718378,
0.0462017208,
0.0109195923,
-0.0203657262,
0.0139244134,
0.0376409478,
-0.0031802505,
0.0459640659,
-0.0531212129,
0.0340944119,
-0.0485739782,
0.0097138071,
0.0360933095,
0.041722659,
0.0277646258,
0.0201000385,
0.0177918505,
0.0065471125,
0.0218055565,
-0.0204980075,
-0.0770108923,
0.0428934582,
-0.0616272651,
-0.0151504176,
0.0068675918,
0.0057181283,
-0.0137857422,
-0.0382830426,
-0.0154140973,
0.0316916816,
-0.0091606313,
0.0312881134,
0.0414357595,
-0.0160994828,
-0.0007560169,
0.0515555255,
0.0343802199,
-0.0283314567,
-0.0453433357,
-0.0619315691,
0.0056948392,
0.0629272833,
0.0659711137,
-0.0152275562,
-0.0546387173,
-0.0198790487,
0.0188235752,
0.017699901,
0.0163294934,
-0.0059967702,
-0.0400085188,
-0.0423335321,
-0.0272204392,
0.0028630919,
-0.0211095009,
-0.0279394314,
0.0299125519,
-0.0169059839,
-0.0069912542,
-0.0148454607,
0.0310017914,
-0.0151871089,
-0.0111771198,
0.022663394,
-0.023446383,
0.0079269484,
0.0274070986,
0.004543866,
0.0082637314,
0.0295989588,
-0.0121426312,
0.0003091077,
-0.0593608208,
0.0269435812,
-0.0436473563,
-0.0797843561,
0.0493228324,
-0.0086234175,
-0.0422239006,
-0.0059363609,
-0.0575815514,
-0.0141259283,
0.0373262912,
0.0103545263,
0.0299981553,
-0.0096200136,
0.0212307256,
0.0115019325,
-0.0128435735,
-0.0281079113,
0.0682076886,
-0.0147265606,
0.0028465267,
-0.0079227444,
0.0182919893,
-0.0081763538,
-0.0011148469,
0.0159087833,
0.021864228,
0.0017215215,
0.0046482724,
-0.0207003132,
0.0356845893,
-0.0536532402,
-0.0280176662,
-0.0935331285,
0.0056180051,
0.0018139478,
0.0201311335,
0.0077499961,
-0.0073150685,
0.008476112,
0.0102073392,
-0.0501781292,
0.0372571014,
0.0013723549,
0.0205939393,
0.0286775101,
-0.0253161248,
-0.0073716971,
-0.0045061065,
-0.0200818442,
-0.036434833,
0.0637272596,
0.0051425528,
-0.0094273053,
-0.0146618839,
0.0298395138,
-0.084376879,
0.0184858963,
-0.0114692617,
0.0000053889,
0.0244840756,
-0.0231057368,
0.0285075158,
0.0571719408,
-0.0163678415,
0.0045701689,
0.0266270973,
-0.0162597131,
-0.0716884658,
0.0290785246,
0.0040500523,
-0.0103695253,
-0.0076818741,
0.0146598788,
-0.0459673665,
0.052965913,
-0.0189900938,
-0.0124378046,
-0.015389381,
0.0149725024,
0.0159926899,
0.0120759113,
-0.0419301614,
0.004097017,
0.02800004,
0.0318539739,
-0.0255138166,
-0.0163386874,
0.0802976638,
-0.0220510457,
-0.0197407976,
-0.065425545,
-0.0029202197,
-0.0328186229,
0.072256662,
-0.0078712087,
-0.0090263616,
-0.0360911563,
0.0033126241,
-0.0585146993,
-0.0310550258,
0.0424490646,
-0.0477612168,
0.0238791462,
-0.0570697486,
0.0152154351,
-0.0176416226,
-0.0399461985,
-0.0432845205,
0.0201704241,
-0.0536902621,
0.022073511,
0.0224294476,
-0.0350404903,
0.0096974121,
-0.002326661,
0.0308481306,
0.0242582019,
0.0007828666,
-0.0137670012,
-0.0151276002,
0.0247028787,
0.0221221633,
-0.0039964318,
0.0425185896,
-0.0093770921,
0.0670593828,
0.0737398267,
0.03370497,
-0.0460436009,
-0.0272311214,
-0.0126268584,
-0.0030083626,
-0.0029968699,
-0.011813079,
0.001929324,
0.0347922854,
-0.0738716647,
0.0036261159,
0.1266403645,
0.0477021448,
-0.0355511196,
-0.0055690031,
-0.0255623236,
0.0470638983,
0.0160875525,
0.0304821562,
-0.1171696335,
-0.0539811365,
0.0287441108,
-0.0432819389,
0.009727384,
-0.06620235,
-0.008137905,
-0.1053353995,
0.0366439261,
0.0034011113,
0.0016761601,
0.0125525314,
-0.02787745,
0.0083331782,
0.0188303869,
-0.0133735705,
0.0419568121,
0.0217195861,
0.0056948075,
0.0091960076,
-0.0164952744,
-0.0056295479,
0.0723560527,
-0.0222760458,
0.0264033489,
-0.0068808109,
0.0041030128,
0.0398066454,
-0.0132508688,
0.1022476554,
0.0618513636,
-0.0087047322,
-0.0426524878,
0.0059992545,
0.0006837973,
-0.0176276639,
-0.0526144914,
0.051148247,
-0.0315357596,
-0.0166791491,
0.0121419029,
0.1173971891,
-0.0281301308,
-0.0012232857,
-0.0102032125,
0.0270643011,
-0.0258752443,
0.0530260094,
0.0144620193,
-0.0025410417,
-0.0403540395,
-0.0455427878,
-0.0825885162,
0.0024162685,
-0.0430677645,
-0.0042354357,
0.0521310419,
0.01775291,
-0.046621304,
-0.0268761981,
0.0525653809,
0.0422782376,
-0.0277907345,
-0.0007625757,
0.0238447431,
0.0274606049,
-0.0134918494,
0.0365283117,
-0.0546150394,
0.0347507298,
-0.0065970956,
0.0232242681,
0.0198682249,
-0.0202694405,
-0.025664784,
0.0399612151,
-0.098220624,
-0.056805443,
-0.0575992763,
0.0284479689,
0.0275823679,
0.0513420887,
-0.0325426199,
-0.0265417546,
-0.0016312054,
0.0196175463,
-0.0538568012,
-0.0216421243,
0.0310332719,
0.0585191324,
0.0332591906,
0.0513072237,
-0.0229332,
-0.0034042525,
-0.0064867861,
0.0621673949,
-0.0202623308,
-0.0295068063,
0.0208120029,
0.016163785,
-0.020846447,
0.0454475284,
0.0131629752,
-0.0123245204,
0.0631384179,
-0.0244721249,
-0.0539221689,
-0.0398743823,
0.0222226232,
-0.0094119702,
-0.0331657343,
0.0318990387,
-0.0296695773,
0.0128154662,
0.0211324152,
0.0278062206,
0.0002889817,
-0.0108757494,
0.0032264031,
0.0458059087,
-0.0207342654,
-0.0085051386,
-0.0097025111,
0.0034196875,
0.0281575583,
-0.0412940048,
0.1059994474,
0.0300404672,
-0.0308457445,
-0.0371527672,
-0.0117284833,
-0.0550176613,
-0.1053729877,
0.0218759831,
0.0387138426,
0.0352618136,
0.0277894661,
0.0112639032,
-0.0493285507,
-0.0126834186,
0.0118627939,
0.0555197895,
0.0035255454,
-0.0295359101,
0.0340131782,
0.032495793,
0.0098697199,
-0.0092845205,
0.049495589,
-0.0485583507,
0.0109706288,
0.024832705,
-0.0338070095,
-0.0329013467,
-0.0625301525,
-0.0265972037,
0.0013991609,
0.0086565148,
0.0447966196,
-0.0629684106,
-0.0982198417,
-0.0584988743,
-0.0107658776,
-0.0063427882,
0.0003560042,
0.0322910771,
0.0748358443,
0.0027117087,
-0.0161497649,
-0.016108796,
0.0206521433,
0.0081283636,
-0.0307430625,
-0.0157277789,
-6.294177155e-33,
-0.0059112734,
-0.0343687534,
0.0773026571,
0.0393141396,
-0.0032709367,
-0.0463902317,
-0.0407143533,
0.0304627419,
-0.0355984382,
0.039151527,
-0.0091706375,
0.0235967599,
-0.0077756643,
0.0319259651,
-0.0051234565,
-0.0179155208,
-0.0027586855,
0.0109435674,
-0.0082909884,
0.0140092764,
0.0427276976,
-0.0078810733,
0.0417999029,
-0.052401524,
0.0108484989,
-0.0116791725,
0.0090646809,
0.0572558306,
-0.0621015951,
0.0343094096,
-0.0079399217,
0.0054260711,
0.0244267657,
-0.0352371447,
0.0045893448,
-0.0098951301,
-0.0638567135,
-0.0169212166,
0.0373433046,
-0.0018792112,
-0.044852633,
-0.004794871,
0.0207576994,
0.0156295206,
0.0092537887,
-0.0644341037,
0.0097496575,
-0.0237873495,
-0.0165149923,
0.0257261861,
-0.0249667838,
0.032670781,
-0.0517252982,
-0.0744275376,
-0.0097953007,
0.0354336649,
-0.012887517,
-0.0187854022,
-0.0348410979,
0.0110980812,
0.0104427813,
0.0100530675,
0.0842898116,
-0.0260829274,
-0.0006346711,
0.0401260778,
0.00956266,
-0.0089318249,
-0.0532620847,
0.0126928436,
-0.007649241,
0.0591276959,
0.049373053,
-0.0036689737,
-0.0273787193,
0.0459947661,
-0.0888907015,
-0.0116591593,
0.0489603914,
0.0666356608,
0.0303880293,
0.0099156387,
-0.0215528011,
-0.0065251533,
-0.0484142601,
0.0169080142,
-0.0558796749,
-0.0256439075,
0.0001361169,
-0.0098350244,
0.0076340414,
-0.0312567241,
0.0272358805,
-0.030309692,
-0.0290269013,
0.0381188393,
-0.015919352,
0.0213734284,
-0.0004149158,
0.0436610132,
-0.0271944199,
0.0067366259,
0.0019930105,
0.0039266935,
0.0032262816,
0.0160541125,
0.0438768566,
0.0024249083,
-0.0373483784,
-0.0209853686,
-0.1016063839,
0.0255359355,
-0.0206150543,
0.0097737722,
0.0203041956,
0.0140580926,
-0.0185783934,
0.078771241,
-0.0091069499,
0.0096371537,
-0.020738773,
0.0109771565,
-0.0169387497,
-0.0306730866,
-0.023856746,
0.0018915967,
-0.0357946493,
-0.0136062112,
0.0389522128,
-0.0476094335,
-0.0039083348,
0.0008856135,
2.873e-7,
0.0316887274,
0.0407759324,
0.00327934,
0.0450895317,
0.0309538748,
0.0336178839,
-0.0296692513,
-0.0251679979,
0.0289746411,
-0.0224480554,
-0.0167351905,
0.07977321,
0.0493759513,
0.0404351689,
-0.0516656004,
-0.047178857,
-0.0615372844,
-0.0589198545,
-0.0500282235,
-0.020451026,
0.0664273053,
0.0789871886,
0.0413794927,
-0.0075404411,
-0.0063574701,
-0.0343777835,
0.0410006754,
-0.0131114125,
-0.026843166,
0.0087700076,
0.0062976382,
-0.0077152611,
0.0463715196,
0.0399917029,
0.0324702412,
0.0003246617,
-0.0061816382,
0.0637250766,
0.0074715414,
0.0021540637,
-0.0115714148,
-0.0621547699,
0.0097715529,
-0.0565217249,
0.0809260383,
-0.0775596499,
-0.0455968976,
-0.0142539851,
0.0223008469,
-0.0358500183,
0.002563261,
0.0089129619,
-0.0067457459,
0.0233896431,
0.0096688494,
-0.0127223032,
0.009595071,
-0.0835489258,
-0.0472048111,
0.0236739144,
-0.0395483896,
-0.0529866777,
-0.0215510819,
-0.0288055856,
0.0237034541,
-0.0240380224,
-0.0103214663,
2.889419986e-34,
0.0492856987,
-0.0020489239,
0.0348321013,
0.064243421,
0.0748978406,
-0.013930562,
0.0345101245,
0.0086406879,
0.039879065,
-0.0899115801,
-0.014719096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14322v1 | RET-LLM: Towards a General Read-Write Memory for Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:53:38 | 2023-05-23T17:53:38 | Ali Modarressi, Ayyoob Imani, Mohsen Fayyaz, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing (NLP) through their extensive parameters and comprehensive
data utilization. However, existing LLMs lack a dedicated memory unit, limiting
their ability to explicitly store and retrieve knowledge for various tasks. In
this paper, we propose RET-LLM a novel framework that equips LLMs with a
general write-read memory unit, allowing them to extract, store, and recall
knowledge from the text as needed for task performance. Inspired by Davidsonian
semantics theory, we extract and save knowledge in the form of triplets. The
memory unit is designed to be scalable, aggregatable, updatable, and
interpretable. Through qualitative evaluations, we demonstrate the superiority
of our proposed framework over baseline approaches in question answering tasks.
Moreover, our framework exhibits robust performance in handling temporal-based
question answering tasks, showcasing its ability to effectively manage
time-dependent information. | [
0.0573932938,
0.0644207001,
-0.0078853024,
0.0413721278,
-0.0423878096,
0.0048149056,
-0.020904744,
-0.0074315052,
0.0097125219,
-0.0586983375,
-0.0123556014,
-0.0318355076,
-0.0490368716,
0.0173918214,
-0.0111722434,
-0.0344114192,
0.0819356218,
-0.0393437855,
0.009395537,
-0.0089164833,
0.014383235,
0.006553899,
0.0158682279,
-0.0280984547,
0.0010437936,
-0.0326095596,
-0.0234251507,
-0.0340381637,
-0.0173001885,
-0.0145593062,
-0.014254747,
0.0137091335,
0.0237249546,
0.0155509757,
0.0000019503,
-0.0238475986,
-0.0426665284,
0.0101586236,
-0.0330801867,
0.0310718939,
0.0034116427,
0.0041713566,
0.0258761141,
0.0042769574,
-0.041897662,
-0.0091098566,
0.007194709,
0.0328886323,
0.0605339631,
0.0549708568,
0.012047397,
-0.0364198461,
0.0478180535,
0.0011544027,
0.0443687402,
-0.069747448,
0.0292053744,
0.0578087717,
0.0317731537,
0.0096574249,
-0.0008478883,
0.0601793937,
0.0203585345,
0.0258855429,
0.016910119,
0.0301562473,
-0.0332506448,
0.0281505063,
-0.0154243577,
0.0475389846,
0.0340812467,
-0.0130414804,
0.0018944234,
0.032566905,
-0.0236487575,
0.0209468491,
-0.0547094606,
0.0305478312,
-0.0251245853,
0.0004389749,
0.0076414463,
-0.010680506,
0.0384906903,
0.0281119458,
-0.0363149345,
0.0574558973,
0.0190316327,
-0.0271563027,
-0.0144946808,
-0.0045497012,
-0.0395104736,
-0.031644877,
0.0191381648,
0.0912245736,
-0.0123759964,
0.04547631,
-0.0085493401,
0.0003707729,
0.0177818798,
-0.0432992354,
0.0355306566,
0.0280745924,
0.0090257265,
0.0702960491,
-0.0297777411,
0.0474349856,
-0.0704379976,
0.0102683352,
-0.0631333441,
-0.0528525077,
-0.0616625734,
-0.0552596897,
-0.0304242931,
0.0801632628,
0.0150218857,
-0.0081625069,
-0.0177416094,
0.053708002,
0.0168374591,
-0.0191431157,
0.0300379731,
0.0364021249,
-0.0336844735,
0.0016622641,
-0.0523444079,
0.0378837883,
-0.0222169999,
-0.0184861869,
-0.011865438,
-0.0500501692,
-0.0211215597,
-0.0083350427,
0.0145999435,
-0.0522003062,
0.0055333069,
0.082080029,
-0.011697555,
-0.05083533,
-0.069502905,
-0.0273006875,
0.0039863461,
-0.0837036073,
0.0092504704,
-0.0512474664,
0.0835496336,
0.0383281261,
-0.0250270255,
-0.0361260436,
0.0091006365,
0.0331215598,
-0.0327923745,
0.0556927919,
0.0295740031,
0.0049156207,
0.0431389138,
0.0167982373,
0.0257982537,
0.0397518687,
0.0366477333,
0.0089569604,
0.0247769821,
0.0091577135,
-0.0259192549,
0.0156125342,
0.0277176984,
-0.0088357311,
-0.0505841002,
0.0686412528,
0.010417074,
0.0126625057,
0.0092302244,
0.0726906583,
-0.0012633092,
-0.0318723507,
0.0469185151,
0.0290095322,
0.0198422726,
0.0383757018,
0.0617446937,
-0.008942889,
0.0087801246,
-0.0256263204,
-0.031378489,
0.0351520889,
-0.0473492816,
0.0271346811,
-0.0049882461,
-0.0000797011,
-0.0177483521,
-0.0140352026,
-0.0164159946,
0.0089119701,
-0.0171697885,
0.0256710686,
0.0498151965,
-0.0027689759,
-0.016821865,
0.075070329,
0.0148700736,
-0.0140998792,
0.010616269,
-0.026289843,
0.0494341403,
0.0584465936,
0.0366829149,
-0.05754954,
-0.0082526589,
-0.0056052445,
-0.0042952243,
-0.0019872957,
0.0448936559,
-0.0136141786,
-0.0183908809,
-0.0200744569,
0.0184786674,
-0.0154511351,
-0.005957298,
0.0316382423,
0.0828640908,
0.0320203304,
0.0007084269,
-0.0083956923,
0.0056275679,
0.0016924356,
-0.0336183012,
-0.0476672165,
-0.0155700445,
-0.0253942013,
0.0254981332,
0.0055284258,
-0.0179873537,
0.0306685306,
0.0466840938,
-0.0517340675,
-0.0408010893,
0.0029992834,
-0.0684627667,
-0.034133181,
0.0387898535,
0.0432803072,
-0.0307040364,
0.0150686,
-0.0325864404,
-0.0428325161,
0.0275476798,
-0.0415273905,
0.0533389598,
-0.0631995052,
-0.0238421466,
0.0453871861,
-0.0153066404,
-0.0351543352,
0.1140602306,
-0.0274876077,
0.0046762386,
0.0154637685,
-0.0054086647,
-0.0292297117,
-0.0134726251,
-0.0240629986,
0.0398685932,
0.0271984916,
0.0432485156,
0.0178447329,
-0.0171196591,
-0.0428656004,
-0.0378463566,
-0.0531981066,
0.0489533618,
-0.0246048458,
0.0194731243,
0.0046066944,
0.0256212,
0.0098688174,
0.012334886,
-0.0383635424,
-0.0041989842,
0.0151416603,
0.0278145242,
0.0313237384,
0.0219105482,
0.0090422975,
-0.0046498654,
-0.0310097579,
-0.0311968662,
0.0420660041,
-0.0216069147,
-0.0062411339,
-0.0127300713,
0.0133935148,
-0.0541330054,
0.0375882871,
-0.0058906688,
0.0224803984,
-0.0189551488,
-0.0610668696,
0.0506813377,
0.0607747175,
-0.0014953098,
0.0393497609,
0.0180018041,
-0.0352082625,
-0.0336309299,
0.0395784155,
-0.0471903495,
-0.0168999564,
0.0027408591,
-0.0210803002,
-0.0089504123,
0.0582866929,
-0.0027537069,
-0.0085177682,
-0.037553031,
-0.0039278097,
-0.0230616331,
-0.0093990732,
-0.0611579493,
0.0071410001,
-0.0436297134,
-0.0014392396,
-0.0172452293,
-0.0196317025,
0.0430668592,
-0.0050619147,
-0.0003528546,
-0.0344788581,
-0.0206444636,
-0.0741620138,
0.1157248095,
0.0038045312,
0.0155443205,
-0.0460509099,
-0.0346987322,
-0.0147496015,
-0.0547334217,
0.0075581996,
-0.0586118288,
0.0566068217,
-0.052174855,
0.0368410051,
-0.0211921446,
-0.0222674403,
-0.0426511057,
-0.0407056995,
-0.0484973192,
0.0210105479,
-0.0432576351,
-0.0086126123,
-0.0290587973,
-0.0031830431,
0.0329713672,
0.0146420365,
-0.0289255287,
-0.0011525903,
-0.0221163444,
0.0618575513,
0.0443795584,
0.0312292539,
-0.010208359,
-0.0054466682,
0.0133056678,
0.09637288,
0.02328966,
-0.0223362166,
-0.0274404939,
-0.0038235267,
0.0136946701,
-0.0583109483,
-0.0025002928,
-0.0012297991,
0.0151530458,
-0.0765236691,
-0.0376875475,
0.1120344177,
0.0311095621,
-0.0162048377,
-0.0250960775,
0.0019590061,
0.0353604555,
0.0230215136,
0.0316827781,
-0.081181936,
-0.0437743999,
-0.0173784196,
-0.0136875622,
-0.0056976853,
-0.0483140498,
-0.0350837559,
-0.0899597481,
-0.0080604469,
-0.018817652,
-0.0410764217,
0.0028688132,
0.0071203508,
-0.0420130566,
0.0223488193,
0.0220155437,
0.0234427005,
-0.0230412316,
0.0159007944,
0.0216784216,
0.0101723736,
0.0229820348,
0.0677031949,
0.0025792487,
0.0200671144,
0.044474747,
0.0408290178,
-0.0143459905,
-0.0211267304,
-0.0260223728,
-0.0318018198,
0.0042987759,
-0.0252844971,
-0.0042016767,
-0.0404065028,
-0.0111126509,
-0.0342154838,
0.0060850405,
-0.021594543,
-0.0313661657,
0.018559821,
0.0925766751,
-0.0188137926,
-0.0103292922,
-0.0230971184,
-0.0014491206,
-0.0224835481,
0.1098296493,
0.0069324141,
-0.0127247153,
-0.036451865,
0.0046377834,
-0.0468063541,
-0.0623474568,
-0.0604751147,
0.0023742104,
0.0205731709,
0.019367598,
-0.0484685004,
-0.0178299304,
0.0233625229,
0.0013919083,
-0.0081512062,
0.0223479159,
0.0594307445,
-0.0024942502,
-0.0883544013,
0.018898122,
-0.0610989146,
-0.0061101322,
-0.006801378,
0.0008718647,
0.0557541847,
0.000100801,
-0.0293089058,
0.0094351359,
-0.0599155165,
-0.0433227234,
0.0344827138,
0.058156345,
0.0243538413,
0.0326861888,
0.0111476984,
-0.0068064085,
-0.007325321,
0.0225472562,
-0.0565385781,
0.0245330464,
-0.0169923212,
0.0422852486,
0.0111726383,
0.0502291359,
-0.0450754836,
-0.0043241661,
-0.0038763392,
0.0263001099,
-0.0286779851,
0.0011080411,
0.0385183133,
0.0268647801,
-0.0047551175,
0.0561197251,
0.0370831862,
0.0034836503,
0.0075041153,
-0.0426159687,
-0.0117881708,
-0.0424116328,
0.0278095864,
0.0204286501,
-0.0416905358,
-0.0506224185,
-0.0132037122,
0.0397863016,
0.010860024,
-0.0048826453,
-0.0156564768,
0.0040229987,
-0.0106965071,
0.0198100135,
-0.0192462429,
-0.0389685482,
0.0134499539,
-0.0128659727,
0.0624587014,
-0.0283878744,
0.0538070127,
0.0294512007,
-0.0357632972,
-0.0321132056,
0.0022237955,
-0.0842915326,
-0.0704512298,
0.0308014117,
0.0341148563,
0.0126802195,
-0.0041751065,
0.0169670749,
-0.0375630148,
-0.0259126071,
-0.0010224023,
-0.0030572002,
0.0417016782,
-0.0030770863,
0.0529443398,
0.0388437137,
-0.0330649242,
-0.0063369181,
0.0516352393,
-0.0095361872,
0.0380633846,
0.0285089221,
-0.0316611528,
-0.0489260554,
-0.0359167047,
-0.0183679275,
0.0103315264,
-0.0113547854,
0.0102722943,
-0.0821261257,
-0.0424172655,
0.0101120062,
0.0115841189,
-0.013945586,
-0.0391761176,
0.0198615175,
0.0444803834,
0.0325549617,
-0.0471785069,
-0.0460324772,
0.0779495388,
-0.0712472871,
-0.0152596487,
0.0325694494,
-6.394242581e-33,
-0.043873217,
-0.0154835554,
0.0463194177,
-0.0094485376,
-0.0409513786,
0.0209417846,
-0.0251843967,
-0.0153869037,
-0.0253382009,
-0.0139725041,
-0.0269801039,
0.0399459675,
0.0033353281,
0.0450871699,
-0.0081150746,
-0.0342413746,
0.0063358089,
-0.0081043066,
0.0008978375,
0.0360334702,
0.0811455101,
0.0332503915,
0.0503764786,
-0.0185347125,
-0.0082592005,
-0.0481220633,
0.042438969,
0.0354947709,
-0.022589786,
0.044478327,
-0.0468046963,
0.0264123119,
0.026120957,
-0.0604163706,
0.0085993223,
0.0325339437,
-0.1262113005,
-0.0294363536,
0.0487058274,
0.0063932575,
-0.0556064695,
-0.0191788133,
0.0109465681,
-0.0072698966,
0.0541618653,
-0.0312059708,
-0.0164544769,
-0.0003841392,
-0.0347914323,
-0.0213291999,
-0.0349568874,
0.0211233664,
-0.0006730323,
0.0033123435,
0.0233787131,
-0.0256885886,
0.0085731763,
0.0175334197,
-0.0447288267,
-0.0456671081,
-0.0167841334,
0.0305306707,
0.0186671894,
0.0153334336,
-0.0040486865,
0.056280762,
-0.0098126428,
-0.0172597729,
-0.019681653,
-0.0027171625,
-0.0276773032,
0.0258310549,
0.0068767825,
0.0075310469,
0.0192169156,
0.0024347946,
-0.0686047226,
-0.0026832693,
0.0451679528,
0.0452818908,
0.0322402008,
0.0039683874,
-0.0197471175,
0.001530178,
-0.0373948701,
0.0590520576,
-0.0330409259,
-0.0086358124,
0.0489553623,
0.0033281005,
-0.0362171419,
0.0429333784,
0.041296199,
-0.0388691351,
-0.0075023323,
0.052805379,
-0.0077598267,
-0.0060850051,
-0.0077678729,
0.0601251274,
-0.0303932726,
0.0068529295,
-0.0399844795,
-0.011694897,
-0.0099425819,
0.0182249378,
0.0092498399,
0.0181775689,
-0.055239141,
-0.0055456492,
-0.055998534,
0.0423583649,
-0.0590714924,
0.010659134,
0.0289837793,
0.050689254,
0.0091697006,
0.0485393293,
0.0220309068,
-0.0052648708,
-0.0275963917,
0.0077250544,
0.0433631055,
0.0201306548,
0.0002457952,
-0.0070281946,
-0.0192242134,
0.0302741323,
0.0181157812,
-0.0355015807,
0.0298440233,
0.0245810561,
2.641e-7,
0.0658196062,
0.0255753547,
0.0452820361,
0.0400312021,
0.0209803525,
0.0135564161,
0.0185981207,
0.024660971,
0.016261274,
-0.0179274846,
-0.0082339495,
0.0715092048,
0.0095925694,
0.0245276354,
-0.0845731571,
-0.0083301291,
-0.0743105337,
-0.0428150818,
-0.050219506,
-0.0193145573,
0.053655766,
0.0873615518,
0.0112393685,
-0.0155908484,
-0.0202251524,
-0.0634667054,
0.0842765793,
-0.0051401886,
-0.0131310336,
0.0200828016,
0.0539518446,
0.0208235458,
0.0047901641,
0.0027955666,
0.0087007117,
0.0148383565,
-0.0032119434,
0.1076299921,
0.009958595,
-0.0333536007,
-0.0299727377,
-0.0488070399,
0.0086700087,
-0.0335399583,
0.1054140702,
-0.0499689169,
-0.0501911268,
-0.0236956365,
-0.0011352353,
-0.0081506558,
0.00365632,
0.0279426984,
0.0102882516,
0.0187990479,
-0.0020472256,
-0.02215885,
-0.0136369038,
-0.1059158742,
-0.0197731033,
0.0443814322,
-0.0364683345,
-0.0170772877,
-0.0263260175,
-0.0118533345,
0.0068718535,
-0.0955008641,
-0.0262679383,
2.385917873e-34,
0.0303764828,
0.0232524704,
0.0068308543,
0.0560738221,
0.0300849807,
-0.0024674574,
0.0031353373,
0.0086018154,
0.015802687,
-0.1050888896,
-0.0278592352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14321v1 | ConGraT: Self-Supervised Contrastive Pretraining for Joint Graph and Text Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:53:30 | 2023-05-23T17:53:30 | William Brannon, Suyash Fulay, Hang Jiang, Wonjune Kang, Brandon Roy, Jad Kabbara, Deb Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose ConGraT(Contrastive Graph-Text pretraining), a general,
self-supervised method for jointly learning separate representations of texts
and nodes in a parent (or ``supervening'') graph, where each text is associated
with one of the nodes. Datasets fitting this paradigm are common, from social
media (users and posts), to citation networks over articles, to link graphs
over web pages. We expand on prior work by providing a general,
self-supervised, joint pretraining method, one which does not depend on
particular dataset structure or a specific task. Our method uses two separate
encoders for graph nodes and texts, which are trained to align their
representations within a common latent space. Training uses a batch-wise
contrastive learning objective inspired by prior work on joint text and image
encoding. As graphs are more structured objects than images, we also extend the
training objective to incorporate information about node similarity and
plausible next guesses in matching nodes and texts. Experiments on various
datasets reveal that ConGraT outperforms strong baselines on various downstream
tasks, including node and text category classification and link prediction.
Code and certain datasets are available at
https://github.com/wwbrannon/congrat. | [
0.0090527935,
0.0234035254,
0.02551274,
0.0519533381,
-0.0014780959,
0.0135880951,
-0.0213995147,
0.0168932807,
0.0651901811,
-0.0275918357,
-0.0410617404,
0.0103846369,
-0.0255963653,
0.0170376468,
0.0303020384,
-0.0356514566,
0.0079761762,
0.0416653156,
-0.0021751805,
-0.0179064646,
0.0253515784,
0.0520381927,
0.0371668302,
-0.0151107833,
0.0032095502,
-0.0338776894,
-0.0118708266,
0.0539891347,
0.0087548001,
-0.047051318,
0.0219313689,
0.0319174454,
0.0675201714,
-0.0224584155,
0.0000017212,
0.0162315052,
0.0156039344,
-0.0184661001,
-0.0017292887,
-0.0166218244,
0.0571432523,
-0.0422214828,
0.0547682755,
0.0069911089,
-0.0324479379,
-0.0384538993,
0.0387531221,
0.0346516781,
0.0292851962,
0.0642203838,
-0.0457119681,
-0.0435562916,
0.0161442738,
-0.013256453,
-0.0142830107,
-0.0124154333,
0.0054582465,
0.012708473,
-0.0177898705,
0.0571663678,
-0.0556404814,
0.0123631526,
0.0157532822,
-0.0060540712,
0.0774840713,
0.0530441366,
0.0456031524,
0.0226931907,
-0.011245707,
0.1343086809,
-0.0281881373,
-0.0355219916,
-0.0034694201,
-0.0194179211,
-0.0238068551,
0.014078333,
0.0054490832,
-0.0435623713,
-0.0054866006,
0.0404450223,
-0.0013260432,
0.0167987961,
0.0328713767,
-0.031404648,
0.000513868,
-0.0227872748,
-0.0050246334,
-0.0256847553,
0.0410013273,
0.0516614914,
0.005515228,
-0.0257322341,
0.0293941945,
0.0208743345,
0.0061218119,
-0.000980906,
-0.0475670248,
-0.0164679158,
-0.0091240825,
-0.0267832596,
0.013616913,
-0.0231972747,
-0.020318117,
0.0503936186,
-0.0113121001,
0.0067586051,
-0.0476211831,
0.0259178802,
-0.0327887721,
-0.0114640826,
-0.0244305488,
0.0236432254,
-0.0376289114,
0.011834803,
-0.0264153294,
-0.0507842824,
-0.0194217581,
0.0295959599,
0.0025654193,
0.0022459009,
0.0329066031,
0.0449455678,
-0.0148775326,
-0.0106108747,
0.0327544957,
0.0333361141,
-0.0058786646,
0.0418376923,
-0.0415190309,
0.0334425829,
-0.007861102,
0.026713619,
0.0594789423,
-0.0565542467,
0.0102939671,
0.0514190048,
-0.0006433642,
-0.0299006663,
-0.016869517,
-0.003641784,
-0.005457079,
-0.0364566222,
0.0425051674,
-0.0744752511,
0.0515321903,
0.0238125399,
-0.012721492,
-0.0313884318,
-0.0076930709,
-0.0089410506,
-0.0570223145,
0.0745085999,
-0.0468790419,
-0.0355761312,
-0.0010182686,
0.0067945253,
-0.0007615366,
0.0311089586,
0.0146292169,
0.0554481931,
0.021100739,
0.0054544085,
-0.0286048613,
-0.0039734277,
0.051679574,
-0.0006912116,
0.0270073675,
0.0163578354,
-0.0208970699,
0.0105365487,
0.0487915166,
0.0565788113,
-0.0292277932,
-0.0542278215,
0.0219023041,
0.0367795303,
0.0285084397,
0.0263958797,
0.0442160442,
0.0245816093,
-0.0097757792,
0.0209369306,
-0.0236234181,
0.0490386002,
-0.0015386908,
-0.0009963587,
0.0572310165,
-0.0054560369,
-0.0629389659,
0.0128320167,
0.0422231816,
-0.0413550958,
0.0464229956,
-0.0302571207,
0.0717668161,
0.0212145485,
-0.0602427684,
-0.021401396,
0.0230416693,
-0.00704714,
0.0172709357,
0.0376756825,
-0.0092652366,
0.0413330905,
0.0059230551,
-0.0044646864,
0.0234914999,
-0.0165412668,
0.0182582326,
-0.0125312489,
0.0011441209,
-0.018780401,
0.0161420982,
-0.0494342335,
-0.0786920786,
-0.0501563624,
-0.0229595136,
0.0192461312,
-0.0141969752,
0.0317215845,
0.0280118305,
-0.0341444761,
-0.0054451027,
-0.0026296172,
0.0050359657,
0.0123037072,
-0.0065911906,
0.0159982536,
-0.0127575556,
0.0404946096,
-0.0019296146,
-0.014251668,
0.0261474773,
0.005249951,
-0.0220107809,
-0.0133857466,
-0.0538510308,
-0.0991588831,
0.0357285254,
-0.0689803809,
-0.0191684552,
0.0328393355,
-0.047531452,
-0.0300865341,
0.0756228045,
-0.0387641564,
0.0266974103,
0.0060412823,
-0.0315736979,
-0.0005395167,
-0.0051816478,
0.037215855,
0.0385272652,
0.000835421,
0.0057366807,
-0.0126918778,
-0.0146996332,
0.035834644,
-0.0311070252,
-0.024383571,
-0.027702108,
0.0270043761,
0.018493101,
0.034860719,
0.0073055797,
-0.072215192,
0.0229548607,
-0.0879385769,
-0.0000450361,
-0.0183718875,
0.0071203788,
0.0080732992,
-0.0081972145,
0.0352558941,
-0.047548335,
-0.0467439108,
0.0369882323,
-0.0282651708,
0.0084248334,
0.0310359858,
-0.0190052819,
0.0450979099,
-0.04038883,
-0.0498684011,
-0.0088205161,
0.0912124813,
0.0236171018,
-0.0403568633,
0.0015474345,
0.0277661495,
-0.0276848245,
0.0129598705,
-0.0183746908,
-0.0046207211,
-0.0025791051,
0.0024929286,
0.0460033081,
0.0311957393,
-0.0087283971,
0.0392005555,
0.0139396116,
0.022948917,
-0.0543994717,
-0.0227237735,
-0.0525859296,
0.022615727,
-0.0368796699,
-0.0076315878,
-0.0496872962,
0.0310532879,
-0.0020875046,
-0.0005778216,
-0.0432181247,
-0.0334721357,
0.0042713224,
0.0216272771,
-0.0004460882,
-0.0190102756,
0.0411547869,
-0.031655848,
-0.0328413732,
-0.0207075682,
0.0868226737,
0.0104630357,
-0.0088962717,
0.0174259339,
-0.0486623198,
-0.0269264802,
0.0659130439,
0.0255056694,
0.0205756184,
0.0031884811,
-0.0135214431,
-0.0259404331,
0.0258721188,
0.0150167113,
-0.0204711966,
-0.0088722818,
0.066878736,
0.0174227729,
-0.0175784603,
-0.0692686066,
0.0041009933,
-0.0352122635,
-0.0189847667,
0.0112622613,
-0.0014548954,
-0.0166634209,
0.0037213841,
-0.011885494,
-0.0316574089,
0.0117505686,
-0.0201156978,
-0.0139820715,
-0.0280022528,
0.0847437829,
0.0269153975,
-0.0527960658,
-0.0342760682,
-0.0229991619,
-0.0161938369,
0.0522618443,
0.0039318381,
-0.0399043858,
-0.0646118373,
0.0168749318,
-0.0096721631,
0.021989014,
0.0030153142,
-0.0305716321,
0.0546220355,
0.0161240716,
-0.0051374803,
0.0654263049,
0.017953217,
-0.0854162797,
-0.0230711531,
0.0195392556,
-0.0032844685,
0.0201230105,
-0.0071205483,
-0.1013285145,
-0.0280017462,
-0.0536758006,
0.0069909198,
0.0601005182,
-0.0241834987,
-0.0256223977,
-0.069957003,
-0.0301950946,
0.0529551804,
0.0170525368,
-0.0560703538,
-0.0672264323,
-0.0043415949,
-0.0232922807,
-0.0312372912,
-0.0153389098,
-0.020685222,
0.0054611149,
0.016639689,
-0.0167911891,
-0.0297408495,
0.0010574388,
-0.0404903367,
0.003760292,
-0.0517920554,
0.0302849617,
0.0421637334,
-0.0133939516,
0.0319255441,
-0.0478658229,
-0.0239144079,
-0.0359835327,
0.085837096,
-0.0484775677,
0.0268268622,
-0.0332053974,
0.0125493528,
-0.0329026207,
-0.0264165625,
-0.0410898477,
0.0712357983,
0.001267311,
-0.0588880181,
-0.0277756434,
0.0046871253,
0.0268320795,
0.0039947163,
0.0472536907,
-0.007398847,
-0.0487120785,
-0.0236691441,
0.0316631384,
-0.0281225611,
-0.0262014344,
-0.0099443272,
-0.040900562,
0.0567067675,
-0.0390201844,
-0.0525202602,
0.0007998912,
-0.0006615803,
-0.0304902103,
-0.0248371642,
-0.0088007143,
-0.0643191189,
-0.1052287146,
0.0056954054,
-0.0374870338,
0.0054864935,
0.0137932217,
-0.0211496875,
0.0492618233,
-0.0152660562,
-0.010381598,
-0.0255644489,
-0.0340642184,
-0.0642976239,
-0.0653187633,
0.0313813798,
0.0062862942,
0.0766514018,
-0.0233178921,
-0.0322208926,
0.0745241493,
0.0596790053,
-0.0451453626,
-0.0106493523,
0.0333913565,
-0.0196769573,
-0.0070584635,
0.0233163089,
-0.0469564982,
0.0350041613,
0.0100801438,
-0.0014551429,
-0.0208809078,
-0.0563247278,
-0.0069255913,
-0.0004953787,
0.0707787946,
0.008903265,
0.0526549779,
-0.0799259096,
-0.023180563,
0.0008483751,
-0.0172306113,
-0.0249318667,
-0.0105221448,
0.0266336426,
0.006843789,
-0.0175505746,
0.0062059578,
0.0046059145,
0.0525022633,
-0.0452843867,
-0.0077277636,
0.0287066083,
0.0310200062,
0.0046784994,
0.0310192052,
-0.0062005594,
-0.0071701091,
0.0439085327,
0.0053015104,
-0.0131701529,
0.0099626053,
0.032490585,
0.0138629582,
-0.0380418338,
0.0356523283,
-0.0427946858,
0.0195245631,
-0.0382983796,
-0.0425289534,
0.0774677098,
-0.0150647908,
0.0222278107,
0.0023666192,
0.0023342788,
-0.0249383617,
0.0621373132,
-0.0356369503,
-0.0290482361,
0.0379552022,
-0.0054876315,
-0.0090243416,
0.0470984727,
0.055098854,
0.0287527647,
0.0034522365,
0.0325429216,
-0.0339174718,
-0.0191249494,
-0.0024488976,
0.0055259825,
0.036966335,
0.0045911348,
0.0088102445,
0.0109743243,
-0.0810297504,
0.0489146635,
-0.0218306445,
-0.0246976912,
0.0821756423,
0.050661616,
0.0015840913,
0.0246105418,
0.0316076241,
-0.0205488782,
0.0255304109,
-0.0020054644,
-0.0413406901,
0.0026328606,
-6.28304155e-33,
0.0061453367,
-0.0491751805,
0.0102174375,
0.0082885651,
-0.0364503972,
0.032322403,
-0.043527212,
-0.0158180837,
-0.0234770048,
0.0332370177,
0.0016932134,
0.0189605355,
-0.0102130519,
0.0258585662,
-0.0299889948,
-0.0116523411,
0.0260917023,
-0.0034492875,
0.0139052905,
0.0438881665,
0.0266978163,
0.0275171641,
0.063561976,
-0.1244737431,
0.0152509632,
-0.0186122172,
0.026874464,
0.0019263007,
0.1039862707,
0.0292478725,
-0.0215936229,
0.0599203967,
0.0186359771,
0.0252059326,
-0.0105250701,
0.0547246784,
-0.1083697528,
-0.0573190451,
-0.0220980681,
-0.0215332415,
-0.0816617385,
0.0004884717,
0.0187847614,
0.0033616314,
0.0086948369,
-0.0577554107,
0.0579701103,
0.0422321372,
0.0002436766,
-0.0078603765,
-0.0032612414,
0.0308794826,
-0.0326968655,
0.0144400382,
0.0233767852,
0.0337798037,
0.0543489754,
0.0395857282,
-0.0868793875,
0.0214608517,
-0.0711640939,
-0.0274101887,
0.0085158786,
-0.002554066,
0.0096476795,
0.0581536777,
0.009558578,
-0.006331766,
-0.0060452935,
0.0190535951,
0.0012552352,
0.0352054946,
0.0323658548,
0.0342979915,
0.0110851899,
-0.0236955862,
-0.1003286242,
0.0177683812,
-0.0113069313,
-0.0130669642,
-0.028585976,
0.0563326962,
0.007098488,
-0.0314532891,
-0.0107630445,
-0.0709495991,
-0.0231039617,
-0.0538686924,
-0.0309873838,
0.0281496216,
0.0025306169,
0.063163951,
0.0145387491,
-0.059516415,
-0.0415902957,
0.0707373694,
-0.0206580609,
0.0346172191,
0.0056719389,
0.0265982766,
-0.0556401834,
-0.0299760699,
0.0554609038,
-0.0140406778,
0.0155801624,
0.0108057735,
0.0644138157,
0.0071037649,
-0.0368862301,
-0.0151535943,
-0.0347105972,
-0.0664971843,
-0.0242294576,
-0.0329546854,
0.0441709459,
0.0669242218,
-0.0260068588,
0.0674222335,
0.0563866943,
0.0360522866,
-0.0091954591,
0.007474192,
0.0249376539,
0.0271284766,
0.0009609992,
-0.0157761928,
-0.0329681374,
0.0254225954,
0.0253614988,
-0.0771417543,
-0.0194812547,
0.0096480036,
2.492e-7,
0.0514916256,
0.0179236159,
0.0492280237,
-0.0152505133,
0.0202129073,
0.024305569,
-0.0059007453,
0.0731463432,
0.0009337238,
-0.0181883611,
0.0492271781,
0.0492993593,
-0.0191316232,
0.0081191445,
-0.0505736507,
0.0324825086,
-0.0944765061,
-0.0232762266,
-0.0377862416,
0.0092991674,
0.0406021327,
0.0512855239,
0.0428542458,
0.0049063107,
-0.017316103,
-0.0482905582,
0.0970613137,
-0.0033469896,
0.0229915064,
-0.0416218415,
-0.034091156,
0.0155805396,
-0.0573313907,
0.0064359508,
-0.0341490507,
0.0330355614,
0.0373237133,
0.0244589895,
-0.0254978482,
-0.0326974392,
0.023952961,
0.0157867186,
0.0012433626,
0.0046507162,
0.0487498231,
-0.0663882867,
-0.0350554213,
-0.0056018233,
-0.0672470406,
-0.0027992991,
0.049840264,
0.0194523633,
-0.0168274343,
0.033721596,
0.0261794217,
0.0349992774,
-0.0281825159,
-0.0966518894,
0.0046531446,
0.0476727672,
-0.0057977829,
-0.0162550472,
0.0072501712,
0.0284119043,
0.053586565,
-0.00683429,
0.0409156866,
1.638644061e-34,
0.0182815101,
-0.0154450983,
-0.0062016603,
-0.0081941141,
-0.0087628439,
-0.0540361218,
-0.0390742011,
-0.0215739217,
0.0521779582,
-0.0657923296,
-0.0095314374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14318v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14318v3 | CREATOR: Tool Creation for Disentangling Abstract and Concrete Reasoning of Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:51:52 | 2024-06-21T16:51:22 | Cheng Qian, Chi Han, Yi R. Fung, Yujia Qin, Zhiyuan Liu, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in utilizing
tools, but their ability is limited by API availability and the instability of
implicit reasoning, particularly when both planning and execution are involved.
To overcome these limitations, we propose CREATOR, a novel framework that
enables LLMs to create their own tools using documentation and code
realization. CREATOR disentangles abstract tool creation and concrete decision
execution, resulting in improved performance. We evaluate CREATOR on MATH and
TabMWP benchmarks, respectively consisting of challenging math competition
problems and diverse tabular contents. Remarkably, CREATOR outperforms existing
chain-of-thought, program-of-thought, and tool-using baselines. Additionally,
we introduce the Creation Challenge dataset, featuring 2K diverse questions, to
emphasize the necessity and benefits of LLMs' tool creation ability. Further
research demonstrates that leveraging LLMs as tool creators facilitates
knowledge transfer, and LLMs exhibit varying levels of tool creation abilities,
enabling them to adapt to diverse situations. The tool creation ability
revolutionizes the LLM's problem-solving paradigm, driving us closer to the
next frontier of artificial intelligence. All the codes and data are released. | [
-0.0070685819,
0.1055406407,
-0.032913439,
0.0500937738,
-0.0623227805,
0.0149401575,
-0.0054769064,
-0.0013296264,
-0.0187907182,
-0.0062401961,
0.0175171252,
0.0162120257,
-0.0253602508,
0.0527222976,
0.0316737182,
-0.018940635,
0.0274286177,
-0.0483009517,
-0.0266337153,
0.0115847373,
-0.0069111846,
0.0305492189,
-0.0324209109,
0.0416663326,
-0.0400759727,
-0.0249821432,
-0.0310477056,
-0.0232673716,
-0.0256726816,
-0.0146866934,
-0.0319991708,
0.0500628762,
0.0118765226,
0.0477569439,
0.0000024086,
-0.0469881929,
-0.0168485772,
0.0166663788,
-0.0488302335,
-0.0011476404,
-0.0216298439,
-0.0118271085,
0.0199126136,
0.035376057,
-0.0581811853,
0.0100849029,
0.0061645401,
-0.0078322012,
0.0609995984,
0.0550618581,
-0.0065908735,
-0.0095664933,
0.0200871155,
0.013428092,
0.0235222932,
-0.0423733369,
-0.005321824,
0.0325304568,
0.0358474664,
-0.0389745869,
0.0111840572,
0.0407699831,
0.0631928444,
-0.0368524045,
0.0143040884,
0.0099845044,
-0.041253306,
-0.0322301388,
-0.0015772497,
0.0571452901,
-0.0004405673,
-0.0414359868,
0.0171717871,
-0.012257142,
0.007988249,
0.016566962,
-0.0553910322,
0.0330884904,
-0.0107658701,
-0.003436202,
0.0284899008,
-0.0298206229,
0.0346589424,
0.0235753302,
-0.0425164811,
0.0907678157,
-0.0072783451,
-0.0115660047,
-0.0001338926,
-0.0049828044,
-0.0143355662,
-0.1002276167,
0.02231366,
0.0823179409,
-0.0494652241,
0.0197754577,
-0.0109195756,
-0.0329597779,
-0.012788753,
-0.0396564305,
0.0801115185,
0.061995782,
0.0273952577,
0.0311958343,
-0.0338124633,
0.0537104383,
-0.0200245883,
0.0258076489,
-0.0424515642,
-0.0000186746,
-0.0485447422,
-0.0028210399,
-0.022385804,
0.0294299163,
-0.0313794874,
0.0078074103,
0.0138994213,
0.0517085902,
-0.0366408825,
0.0442992002,
0.0029094496,
-0.0148091987,
0.0044488702,
-0.049394384,
-0.0370826647,
-0.0213255938,
-0.035424564,
-0.0078932717,
0.0132475877,
-0.0314624161,
-0.01979075,
0.0188084524,
-0.0315518789,
-0.0085692797,
0.0247302949,
0.1109632701,
-0.0277777631,
0.0425090007,
-0.025701452,
-0.0482465588,
0.0337535515,
-0.0904844627,
-0.0125444373,
-0.104981795,
0.0530632436,
0.0423339121,
-0.0574671142,
-0.0651332736,
0.0051922579,
-0.0018120668,
0.0251033846,
0.0465290956,
-0.0004663778,
0.0416010804,
0.0407879725,
0.0016971545,
-0.0706561506,
0.0643374026,
0.0365327485,
0.0243197456,
-0.018772291,
-0.0032455039,
0.0084567303,
0.052266717,
0.0102937333,
0.0013861813,
-0.0547693744,
0.0309677217,
0.0066523966,
0.044031933,
-0.0465998687,
0.0216586646,
-0.0113579696,
0.044770211,
0.0109052006,
0.0470340215,
0.0165761709,
0.0532311015,
0.0611073188,
-0.0045983493,
0.02288674,
-0.0266323891,
-0.0388460457,
0.0273187924,
-0.0322489366,
-0.017232744,
-0.0230156332,
0.0246131942,
0.0012674329,
-0.0737040192,
-0.0244674049,
0.0140492516,
-0.0313005038,
0.0186074749,
0.046011921,
0.0129570374,
-0.0152389072,
0.064940162,
-0.0160039887,
-0.0329107083,
-0.0215039104,
-0.0497399867,
0.051086273,
0.0269063655,
0.0657855421,
-0.0601458997,
-0.0444973446,
-0.0086951712,
0.0021404426,
0.0352639146,
0.0637120232,
-0.0409352742,
-0.028057497,
-0.0420934185,
-0.0133185564,
-0.0189857986,
0.0096733868,
-0.0045506833,
0.0669601336,
-0.0256372821,
0.0049550589,
-0.0532604419,
-0.0204758123,
0.0349144973,
-0.0539154746,
-0.0431325473,
-0.0112749962,
-0.0012336364,
0.0369972698,
0.0096113374,
0.0091522606,
0.0447256342,
0.0291211735,
-0.0321408585,
-0.0355727933,
-0.0063522984,
-0.042090077,
0.0126150791,
0.0559399538,
-0.008039875,
-0.0383058079,
-0.0052527939,
-0.0460345857,
-0.0240305308,
0.0545102134,
0.0006531443,
0.0237273965,
-0.01084683,
0.0389042869,
-0.005504794,
-0.0347037949,
-0.0007159267,
0.0752269849,
-0.0161971133,
-0.0208620261,
0.0399825089,
-0.0038563765,
0.0181843136,
0.0370567851,
0.0434975177,
0.012606984,
-0.0230187587,
0.027890997,
-0.0063403663,
0.0390250608,
-0.0294321515,
-0.048979599,
-0.0286079757,
0.0368690863,
-0.0083041005,
0.0239577889,
0.0063790986,
-0.0043775951,
-0.0003060809,
0.0273797438,
-0.0282703843,
0.0159620289,
-0.0083956355,
-0.0073012467,
0.0385588482,
0.0151803484,
-0.0235503465,
-0.0245133974,
-0.0096708126,
-0.0487892404,
0.0465420857,
-0.0073485738,
-0.0052840537,
-0.0438552722,
0.051060088,
-0.0369370617,
0.0288549643,
0.0050464123,
0.0270323157,
0.023489682,
-0.0584553666,
0.0253112968,
0.0437949151,
-0.059279345,
0.0645082742,
0.0621006191,
-0.0266359858,
-0.0915171877,
0.028463494,
0.0116116479,
-0.0036393702,
-0.0029695076,
-0.0389197133,
-0.0090072388,
0.0665540546,
-0.0411650687,
0.0022348287,
-0.0221333262,
0.0566578954,
0.0107572107,
-0.0133648831,
-0.0265549272,
-0.0207616482,
0.0017448288,
0.0706770048,
-0.017883705,
-0.0608672611,
0.0531457551,
-0.0260986201,
0.006401428,
-0.0288879648,
-0.0369648859,
-0.0580778494,
0.0944617093,
-0.0025258265,
-0.0040564858,
-0.0307765193,
0.0093467869,
-0.055553697,
-0.0127892243,
0.0259429589,
-0.0328303836,
0.0651872605,
-0.0862733424,
0.0027644529,
-0.0113770328,
-0.0440350473,
-0.0441401154,
0.0077467961,
-0.0215101987,
0.0278979689,
0.0276902411,
-0.0211270098,
-0.0072885891,
-0.0152905788,
0.0236800332,
0.0260054618,
0.0094790906,
-0.022227684,
-0.0339567699,
-0.0033531652,
0.00868853,
0.0018569106,
0.0398144647,
-0.0352375917,
0.0294204727,
0.0402515568,
0.0502760671,
-0.0093564996,
-0.029235648,
0.0012496185,
0.0104124425,
-0.0218747202,
-0.012059683,
0.0403100364,
0.0168400872,
-0.0814171955,
-0.0033077898,
0.0889708325,
0.0579601862,
-0.0397007316,
0.0108065512,
-0.043175146,
0.0368369743,
0.0453964062,
0.0720357299,
-0.0852495283,
-0.0209713038,
0.0184837971,
-0.0140217002,
0.0013806628,
-0.0612679832,
-0.0360809378,
-0.1130352765,
0.0490477756,
0.0060395044,
-0.032414224,
0.0278835073,
-0.0221144427,
-0.0153561253,
0.021066675,
-0.0266925637,
0.0423067659,
0.0016262684,
0.0196147654,
0.0032508841,
-0.0301896315,
-0.0301313475,
0.018202208,
-0.0078607425,
0.0002631845,
0.0210068095,
0.0209579822,
-0.0018781379,
-0.0299037434,
0.0670184717,
0.0339619592,
-0.0089400597,
-0.0475550443,
0.0112185171,
0.0249834508,
-0.0128296083,
0.0002560795,
0.0378012247,
-0.0706395656,
-0.0384302773,
0.0285983831,
0.1138087139,
-0.0185188781,
-0.0138017861,
-0.0052154851,
-0.0292316489,
-0.0159805287,
0.0576641485,
0.0365679488,
-0.0153926741,
-0.0510321371,
-0.055750791,
-0.0660126731,
-0.0489666685,
-0.0008842878,
-0.0164890308,
0.026901044,
0.0016013454,
-0.0263598748,
-0.0031429057,
0.0829830319,
0.0311773699,
0.0344175585,
-0.021333294,
-0.0026073146,
-0.0256972592,
-0.0618777573,
0.0289261322,
-0.0310420245,
0.0257461928,
0.000921944,
-0.0292550549,
-0.0223911684,
-0.027880976,
-0.0145982374,
0.0659038499,
-0.0534684584,
-0.0661199316,
-0.0232916158,
0.0501074307,
0.0332480557,
0.0251919962,
-0.0055301622,
-0.0136641795,
-0.0182423014,
0.0074365614,
-0.0336975046,
-0.0137657393,
-0.0031932814,
0.0002641072,
0.0274111126,
0.0448050573,
-0.03485379,
0.0045407484,
0.0022243063,
0.0288338531,
-0.0222080853,
0.0336092524,
0.0394681543,
0.0526882075,
-0.0588212237,
0.0088049639,
0.0059187659,
-0.0339635536,
0.0134134684,
-0.0279998221,
-0.057700675,
-0.055386398,
0.0236142185,
-0.0085725579,
-0.0091786524,
0.0433945991,
0.0133447591,
0.0314097255,
0.0355768912,
0.0101799453,
0.0445990115,
0.0290146619,
0.0239626244,
0.0615361258,
-0.0192149915,
0.0004311141,
0.0094170216,
-0.0164519921,
0.0460632443,
-0.0449281,
0.0470070913,
0.0243968852,
0.0161795076,
-0.0326725841,
-0.0115386993,
-0.027207613,
-0.1499195844,
0.0006851536,
0.0243952591,
0.0200504307,
0.0070584952,
0.0176542774,
-0.0663521215,
-0.0267922189,
0.0129592968,
0.0308007617,
0.0204437878,
-0.0164532326,
-0.0110055404,
0.0342940837,
-0.0075550834,
-0.0518760942,
0.0627655461,
-0.0222264677,
0.0250722971,
0.0036784373,
-0.0183872432,
-0.0567491353,
-0.0266083907,
0.0369196497,
-0.0098858029,
-0.0057930546,
0.0018902173,
-0.0904643089,
-0.0616874956,
-0.0145090735,
0.0201973449,
-0.0187820662,
0.0035740053,
0.0317128971,
0.0805539116,
0.0119058462,
-0.0208346117,
-0.0168344714,
0.0259790309,
-0.0362793952,
-0.0543420166,
-0.0048509063,
-6.48941795e-33,
-0.0230303742,
-0.0294061303,
0.0628457889,
-0.0019116894,
0.0180333182,
-0.0023397796,
-0.0726559013,
0.0102920746,
-0.0060437266,
0.0048134127,
-0.0088031674,
0.0267427769,
-0.0010601454,
-0.0055374312,
0.0258270483,
-0.0100979954,
0.0233151503,
-0.0090092812,
-0.0172321294,
-0.004910422,
-0.0042772251,
-0.010241597,
0.0162480883,
-0.0590931028,
-0.0185970273,
0.0099218506,
-0.0023017623,
0.0332772247,
-0.0433040969,
0.0448503383,
-0.0138151478,
0.0192692652,
0.00021666,
-0.0104699787,
-0.0194804668,
-0.0267095529,
-0.0378731862,
-0.0243084077,
0.0250809733,
-0.007630053,
-0.0590130016,
-0.0536551364,
0.0446436405,
0.0257772524,
-0.0358425118,
-0.03209861,
0.0029632535,
-0.0152571471,
0.0190749988,
0.0003158826,
-0.0547689088,
0.0209001247,
-0.0263550859,
-0.0340987705,
0.0366885848,
0.0047511603,
-0.0033128168,
-0.0196404476,
-0.0273346715,
0.0057946341,
0.0338628627,
0.0102849752,
0.1063068211,
-0.0267420411,
-0.0073875929,
0.0160316098,
0.0340295471,
-0.0089373859,
-0.0221782848,
0.0151028531,
-0.0033124867,
0.1093188971,
0.0560861342,
-0.0082187336,
0.0128601231,
0.0319023579,
-0.0475361086,
0.0302322879,
0.0073820185,
0.0279974155,
0.0320798755,
0.0177756343,
-0.0283804499,
-0.0094203549,
-0.0436637625,
-0.0379979238,
-0.0390322059,
0.0012569271,
0.0253473464,
-0.0109467134,
0.0094382884,
-0.0094815902,
0.0086691445,
-0.0403837562,
-0.0063379821,
0.0178144742,
-0.0183986966,
0.0202936772,
0.0200234037,
0.0282894298,
-0.0347244889,
-0.0072540292,
-0.0396570452,
0.0186005868,
0.0605885908,
0.0521960445,
0.0038790123,
0.0345728621,
-0.0341203362,
-0.0029893254,
-0.1032250375,
0.0251861755,
0.0094259912,
0.0276848376,
0.0133009991,
0.0180265848,
-0.003132723,
0.0165500641,
0.006247194,
-0.0314037055,
-0.0012698543,
0.03196574,
0.009398574,
-0.0008400987,
-0.0088482909,
-0.0174211506,
-0.0358535238,
0.0226070099,
0.084585309,
-0.0344121307,
-0.0093979603,
0.0055877026,
3.097e-7,
0.0610873513,
0.0583976321,
0.0215846598,
0.0552839376,
0.0102755772,
0.0281101894,
-0.0354994163,
-0.034722466,
-0.0146213071,
-0.0170877874,
-0.0102562523,
0.0648232028,
0.0638561547,
0.0542021915,
-0.039112471,
-0.0035487746,
-0.0196768064,
-0.0324199311,
-0.0917559415,
-0.0001399824,
0.058260154,
0.0413398296,
0.0215603448,
-0.0205520205,
-0.0042468896,
-0.0448601395,
0.0120633757,
-0.0248302352,
0.0260987226,
0.0364763029,
-0.0269712619,
-0.0039688842,
0.0222604629,
0.0147081902,
-0.0081874812,
0.0090947868,
0.0012244192,
0.0859067366,
0.0105384663,
0.0166527946,
-0.0086137066,
-0.0534807444,
0.010590787,
-0.069719851,
0.0592994541,
-0.0336950906,
-0.0288963225,
0.0070835217,
0.0056627113,
-0.0209878609,
-0.0235554185,
-0.0043654041,
0.0512096472,
0.020537151,
-0.0062524164,
-0.022066474,
-0.0211652815,
-0.0536754727,
-0.0515347421,
0.0410885736,
-0.0301646963,
-0.0293619875,
-0.0436219424,
0.0030105405,
-0.0082095861,
-0.0429172441,
-0.0152221769,
3.570007568e-34,
0.0274734925,
0.0156819001,
0.0467082635,
0.0687697604,
0.0652277619,
0.0081220921,
-0.0094230641,
0.0295216367,
0.0059785605,
-0.0717159882,
-0.028107075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14310v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14310v3 | Navigating Prompt Complexity for Zero-Shot Classification: A Study of Large Language Models in Computational Social Science | 2023-05-23T17:48:21 | 2024-03-24T18:03:10 | Yida Mu, Ben P. Wu, William Thorne, Ambrose Robinson, Nikolaos Aletras, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive
language understanding and the capacity to generate responses that follow
specific prompts. However, due to the computational demands associated with
training these models, their applications often adopt a zero-shot setting. In
this paper, we evaluate the zero-shot performance of two publicly accessible
LLMs, ChatGPT and OpenAssistant, in the context of six Computational Social
Science classification tasks, while also investigating the effects of various
prompting strategies. Our experiments investigate the impact of prompt
complexity, including the effect of incorporating label definitions into the
prompt; use of synonyms for label names; and the influence of integrating past
memories during foundation model training. The findings indicate that in a
zero-shot setting, current LLMs are unable to match the performance of smaller,
fine-tuned baseline transformer models (such as BERT-large). Additionally, we
find that different prompting strategies can significantly affect
classification accuracy, with variations in accuracy and F1 scores exceeding
10\%. | [
0.0295256954,
0.0375261828,
-0.0087775607,
0.0106560057,
-0.036656972,
0.0277507063,
0.0474261716,
-0.0045561115,
0.0051102783,
-0.1140236408,
-0.0186821166,
-0.0443566181,
0.0062787398,
-0.0066554854,
-0.0093220072,
-0.0339032561,
0.0595144518,
-0.0247266144,
-0.0013146838,
-0.0152651761,
-0.0579406545,
-0.0113635045,
-0.0153271407,
0.0412018038,
0.014951475,
-0.0039706216,
-0.0241869316,
-0.0154995304,
-0.0174145848,
-0.0331893489,
0.0128531232,
0.0994460732,
0.0256364737,
0.0809221938,
0.0000019419,
-0.0850171447,
0.0174955595,
0.0018519524,
-0.0671187192,
-0.0092179449,
0.0382620618,
0.0098482575,
0.0208086744,
0.0332439765,
-0.0004589276,
-0.0564314649,
0.0860686153,
0.038263876,
0.0173824169,
0.0350235663,
0.0119021535,
-0.0586545542,
0.0346432328,
-0.0142323878,
0.0217993911,
-0.007282983,
0.0528182425,
-0.0414077602,
-0.0166168865,
0.0377671458,
-0.0427082852,
0.0301380251,
0.0135883288,
0.0105620762,
0.0250171889,
0.0740436763,
-0.0592888221,
-0.0435329862,
0.0069433432,
0.0612241291,
0.0199456848,
-0.0153620848,
-0.0189884994,
-0.0023638655,
0.0048988461,
0.0279811453,
-0.0448976457,
0.0452970341,
0.0028494578,
-0.0014857431,
0.0153663326,
0.0207094289,
0.0161890462,
0.0284366924,
-0.041710794,
0.0490198396,
0.0128257954,
-0.0334304348,
0.0229545049,
0.0067692851,
-0.0012434344,
-0.0739400014,
-0.0242903233,
0.0300064534,
-0.0257977191,
0.0273544639,
-0.0176983923,
-0.0031534538,
0.0294488817,
-0.0330925882,
0.0193926301,
0.0392365418,
-0.0324428082,
0.0545854978,
-0.0058909045,
0.0631011724,
0.017249912,
0.0317579098,
0.0179597121,
-0.0042638197,
-0.0972770974,
-0.0187722426,
-0.0287744664,
0.0207402408,
-0.0021080212,
0.0076597305,
-0.0478438362,
-0.001564621,
0.0023204405,
-0.011219061,
-0.0141139403,
-0.0159509666,
-0.0188288428,
0.020782331,
-0.055262506,
0.0484284945,
-0.0105486158,
-0.0018387892,
-0.0073608039,
-0.0781279728,
0.0033900545,
-0.004989712,
-0.0084244898,
-0.037180312,
0.0148690967,
0.0112782279,
-0.0042532505,
-0.0628720149,
-0.0348373652,
0.0124220131,
-0.0248785522,
-0.0786170736,
0.0278060511,
-0.0539857708,
0.0294408947,
0.0339675583,
0.0023961836,
-0.018485263,
0.0015293668,
0.007513437,
-0.0610934012,
0.0847720429,
-0.0017809634,
0.0027649601,
0.0369341038,
0.0103890263,
0.0169748086,
0.0801781788,
-0.0193604771,
-0.0039033797,
0.0163940545,
-0.0452438258,
0.0274374709,
0.0345808007,
-0.0122163408,
0.0215985719,
-0.0242921002,
0.0094829407,
0.024849385,
0.0197157376,
0.0157881398,
0.0519848093,
-0.0261684041,
-0.0249651615,
0.0424338281,
0.0789149925,
0.0309157651,
0.0101809101,
0.0298287719,
0.0239993073,
0.0042711212,
-0.0075997403,
-0.0638106987,
0.0032027778,
-0.0381148383,
-0.0079108682,
0.0053329975,
0.0112126656,
-0.0485403612,
-0.008523874,
-0.0165756997,
-0.0099724187,
0.0015979558,
0.0137136839,
0.0795932189,
-0.0089522321,
-0.0334527604,
0.0669895634,
0.0345369093,
-0.0219176561,
-0.0215875544,
-0.0879842937,
0.0246601198,
0.0302368514,
0.0393860973,
-0.0178724732,
-0.0347836763,
-0.0443978906,
0.0448373593,
0.0498821326,
0.0534066893,
-0.0113268057,
-0.0283370018,
-0.0369764417,
-0.0251787119,
0.0085399728,
0.0321840495,
0.0161515977,
0.0381329507,
-0.0057793241,
0.0135171311,
0.0042352891,
-0.0074889613,
0.0439881757,
-0.0276907627,
-0.0595760047,
-0.0061426628,
0.0063964198,
0.0314575844,
0.0021257482,
-0.0185246486,
-0.0059329933,
0.0069746566,
-0.0093461061,
-0.0187122002,
-0.021945117,
-0.0258483756,
-0.0104474984,
0.035471946,
0.025659319,
-0.0111849718,
0.0218491722,
-0.0175631288,
-0.0223386157,
0.005774084,
-0.0082752202,
0.0513390526,
-0.0237436723,
0.0351515263,
-0.0542627908,
-0.0093877865,
-0.0571421795,
0.0591619797,
0.0151393265,
0.0482475236,
0.0146946963,
-0.0102468254,
0.0150160342,
-0.0307600107,
-0.0505884141,
0.0117721139,
-0.0190023221,
-0.0105612827,
0.0116317142,
-0.014430494,
-0.0481646433,
-0.0424255803,
-0.0996248424,
0.020321928,
-0.0136116073,
0.0039770752,
-0.0143504469,
0.00049072,
-0.0133826546,
0.0107551776,
-0.0033946545,
0.0106221559,
-0.0247072596,
0.0734255686,
0.0139988046,
-0.0204434823,
-0.0495216958,
-0.0043995338,
-0.0077783652,
-0.0216728076,
0.074072741,
0.0294552483,
-0.0161161181,
-0.0281619467,
0.0231369939,
-0.0303406436,
0.0172838047,
-0.0143699301,
-0.0276193898,
0.0291140713,
0.0100212898,
0.048470404,
0.0462847315,
0.0192849468,
0.0384089462,
0.0419422314,
-0.0011711898,
-0.0537776276,
-0.0156104239,
-0.0328373313,
-0.0736327246,
0.0016624989,
-0.0145987431,
-0.0226659495,
0.1168218181,
-0.0183118451,
-0.0104454951,
-0.0411965102,
-0.0058542653,
-0.0283209942,
-0.011061091,
-0.0563247986,
0.0009013718,
-0.0198081955,
0.0173274707,
-0.0049347277,
-0.04510713,
0.0407719053,
-0.0088536376,
-0.0016391713,
-0.0182268117,
0.0140470089,
-0.0266041085,
0.0715124011,
0.0158601608,
-0.0025887601,
0.0616203696,
-0.0347625166,
-0.0423873067,
-0.0227405597,
-0.0211821496,
-0.0402821712,
0.0174539387,
-0.028857585,
0.0220106374,
-0.0431346744,
-0.022865748,
-0.0453400649,
-0.0662432984,
-0.0410787202,
0.0401964076,
-0.0022639805,
-0.0154457819,
-0.0488104261,
0.0238259453,
0.0386246853,
0.0277524479,
-0.0109476931,
-0.0185645334,
-0.0001731617,
0.022043569,
0.0160578173,
0.0197838023,
-0.0037511871,
-0.0387176275,
0.0305798743,
0.0165298637,
0.0328638963,
0.0269022807,
-0.0194083117,
-0.0260668844,
0.0391549766,
-0.0429803804,
-0.03536788,
0.0355488285,
0.0310147107,
-0.0499671139,
0.0034973584,
0.1434515566,
0.0424995944,
-0.0395981744,
-0.022507064,
-0.0210362934,
0.0218749717,
0.0528478734,
0.0088303592,
-0.0984394252,
-0.031126773,
0.0074423994,
-0.0030168688,
-0.0284577757,
-0.0532334894,
-0.0075237961,
-0.138111636,
0.0371033251,
-0.0091909328,
-0.0481983013,
0.0156763829,
-0.0600871295,
0.0060168724,
-0.0121955099,
-0.0243061539,
-0.0081121344,
-0.0174722709,
-0.0051868325,
0.0313577428,
-0.011788507,
-0.058140941,
0.053053394,
-0.0337166376,
0.0887429491,
0.0270501822,
0.0124163218,
-0.023932891,
-0.0328220241,
0.0648245737,
-0.0188275073,
-0.0073816716,
-0.0217879508,
0.0456596278,
0.0111078545,
0.0124173081,
-0.0138323847,
-0.0070810616,
0.0045240903,
-0.0155216157,
-0.0023459748,
0.0984862819,
-0.0122013986,
-0.0301656537,
0.0009387948,
-0.0189530496,
0.0034105165,
0.0997793004,
0.0493046232,
-0.0365110673,
-0.0273926742,
-0.0278022103,
0.0012140657,
-0.0137696126,
-0.0352237597,
0.0356722176,
-0.0432358384,
-0.0702605546,
0.0099226311,
-0.0101659251,
0.0709097013,
0.0120902946,
0.0074010808,
-0.0381692797,
0.0100122197,
0.0277553424,
-0.0529594198,
0.0529054701,
-0.0566194877,
0.0148235727,
-0.0796948969,
-0.024512345,
0.0668178126,
0.001477964,
-0.0220050868,
-0.0172989126,
-0.0368028693,
-0.0456512943,
0.0438684039,
0.0101190591,
0.0340808742,
0.0000386035,
0.0172380488,
-0.0545164533,
0.0459462665,
0.0762348399,
-0.0010297723,
0.0136556728,
0.020097062,
0.0140950242,
-0.0077713886,
0.0202381592,
-0.0149827944,
0.0143784881,
0.0298955627,
0.0123386988,
-0.0443825535,
-0.0131613761,
-0.0023088974,
0.0181283392,
0.1006860808,
-0.0187053066,
-0.0362687223,
-0.0213583689,
-0.0192246046,
0.0028914202,
-0.0056445822,
-0.0064421752,
-0.0454166457,
0.0291728582,
-0.0013447166,
0.0000017795,
0.0122005986,
-0.061292503,
0.0586646497,
-0.0284546316,
0.0148342289,
0.0140954833,
0.0287790988,
0.0350825898,
0.0035249628,
-0.0517818891,
-0.0029501894,
0.04216519,
0.0246370658,
-0.0138197234,
0.0746971741,
-0.0036276507,
0.0394632556,
-0.0198318195,
0.0012839437,
-0.0410326868,
-0.0205979478,
0.0088346666,
0.0566888228,
0.024009021,
0.0028332726,
-0.014724114,
-0.0084873224,
-0.0299731176,
-0.0392116532,
0.0041146982,
0.0094894981,
-0.0531945378,
0.0708632469,
0.0243244451,
-0.0201310776,
0.0141662434,
0.0742876306,
0.0189593323,
0.0372533575,
0.0079195835,
-0.0002463506,
-0.0198793132,
0.006578628,
0.0067768558,
-0.0042779078,
0.0091526164,
0.019654505,
-0.0955771357,
-0.0337920822,
0.0276998281,
-0.0251053013,
0.0098871933,
-0.0022309611,
0.0385065079,
0.0495223142,
-0.0285318103,
-0.0245920699,
-0.0470240116,
0.0356808864,
-0.0060014711,
-0.0128297294,
-0.0282846708,
-6.578746705e-33,
-0.0392127559,
-0.0285936352,
0.0338619985,
-0.0234893784,
-0.0355896354,
0.0204122514,
-0.0304914266,
0.03548453,
-0.0381789766,
0.0021376237,
-0.0175845195,
-0.0199773535,
0.013273498,
0.0239872839,
0.0165797286,
-0.031530641,
0.0430883989,
-0.0155406166,
-0.018898651,
0.0066696228,
0.0240772329,
0.0059340135,
0.0377909914,
-0.0580109656,
0.0257922839,
0.0075680804,
0.0366214961,
0.0172468126,
0.0304241665,
0.0477630198,
-0.0298419036,
0.0567088239,
0.03350126,
-0.0744534284,
0.018964842,
0.0640768334,
-0.0652869418,
-0.0406902879,
0.0032007678,
0.0015137207,
0.011618874,
-0.0419008471,
0.0295917057,
0.0119913444,
-0.0398961045,
-0.043748796,
0.0280588809,
-0.0313446335,
-0.0439348109,
-0.0078027127,
-0.0649725646,
0.0205498952,
-0.0003395916,
-0.0339994952,
-0.0005915737,
0.0544390492,
-0.0023674823,
0.0532063134,
-0.0289445315,
0.0284882132,
0.0681816936,
0.0055524982,
0.0477155596,
0.0733958334,
0.0162363499,
0.0659855455,
0.0448572002,
0.0203647837,
-0.0443137549,
-0.0230574626,
0.0496908575,
0.004884081,
0.0316710919,
0.0410085097,
0.0423756689,
-0.0066943243,
-0.0587787591,
-0.0096379472,
0.0371630155,
-0.0045122216,
0.0286682863,
-0.017419301,
-0.0274706054,
-0.0542902201,
-0.0613879487,
-0.0081124986,
-0.0372541212,
-0.0022660217,
0.0244087223,
-0.0097529301,
-0.0110821277,
-0.0035987224,
0.0565125979,
-0.0220758952,
-0.0252608284,
-0.0096902745,
0.0217514075,
0.0492958315,
-0.0120654898,
-0.0042742207,
-0.0868377686,
-0.0331748016,
0.0095968777,
0.0195480864,
0.0272488594,
0.0200593378,
0.0285956915,
0.0243817791,
-0.0762415528,
-0.0375298895,
-0.0133684119,
-0.0088651692,
0.0105360206,
0.0146765513,
0.0159258414,
0.0278580077,
0.0183883365,
0.0655740723,
0.0307207331,
-0.0183897577,
0.0017030685,
-0.0067886282,
-0.0057762866,
0.0126129445,
-0.0148160709,
-0.0066084974,
-0.0106864078,
0.0376178585,
0.0119122118,
-0.0482267328,
-0.0140815144,
-0.0112250121,
2.72e-7,
0.0409372039,
0.081935443,
-0.0283242408,
-0.016846532,
0.0104054697,
0.0417254977,
0.0109019605,
0.002603187,
0.0225570574,
-0.0115626846,
-0.0087278932,
0.0272185672,
0.0452699512,
0.0275468268,
-0.0936681554,
-0.0386285931,
-0.0606322363,
0.0167561229,
-0.0654409453,
0.0464818478,
0.0548001528,
0.0780115798,
0.0184913669,
-0.0031063755,
-0.0149272932,
-0.0230795667,
0.0545210876,
-0.0353502594,
-0.003266877,
0.0183196254,
0.0069599664,
0.0286537241,
0.0312940665,
0.0442168787,
0.00225685,
-0.000759968,
-0.0272417776,
0.0593627654,
-0.0177997127,
-0.0059403009,
0.0203804728,
-0.0341785066,
-0.0270410255,
-0.0600244515,
0.0860092938,
-0.1102661639,
-0.0411333255,
-0.0105022062,
-0.0285654049,
-0.0122911567,
0.035334453,
-0.0215659831,
-0.0127345407,
0.0000661686,
0.0097200964,
-0.0179026108,
-0.0201253574,
-0.0659482256,
0.0153239733,
0.0039638323,
-0.0391970724,
-0.0877057165,
0.0101983314,
-0.007102659,
0.0332523175,
-0.0497364812,
0.0282600373,
2.710556812e-34,
0.0421557464,
0.0142117087,
0.0204357356,
-0.0018406006,
0.0204489958,
-0.0138273388,
0.0153553654,
-0.0018148327,
0.0388499908,
-0.0956771448,
0.0121062007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14307v1 | Debiasing should be Good and Bad: Measuring the Consistency of Debiasing Techniques in Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:45:54 | 2023-05-23T17:45:54 | Robert Morabito, Jad Kabbara, Ali Emami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Debiasing methods that seek to mitigate the tendency of Language Models (LMs)
to occasionally output toxic or inappropriate text have recently gained
traction. In this paper, we propose a standardized protocol which distinguishes
methods that yield not only desirable results, but are also consistent with
their mechanisms and specifications. For example, we ask, given a debiasing
method that is developed to reduce toxicity in LMs, if the definition of
toxicity used by the debiasing method is reversed, would the debiasing results
also be reversed? We used such considerations to devise three criteria for our
new protocol: Specification Polarity, Specification Importance, and Domain
Transferability. As a case study, we apply our protocol to a popular debiasing
method, Self-Debiasing, and compare it to one we propose, called Instructive
Debiasing, and demonstrate that consistency is as important an aspect to
debiasing viability as is simply a desirable result. We show that our protocol
provides essential insights into the generalizability and interpretability of
debiasing methods that may otherwise go overlooked. | [
0.0287437066,
0.0406108573,
-0.0277210567,
0.0322187245,
-0.0523107424,
-0.0198120661,
0.0504838265,
-0.0131511725,
0.0164110865,
-0.0714750662,
-0.0010198362,
0.0154358903,
0.02862758,
0.0188465081,
0.0056258105,
-0.0626860783,
0.0413526148,
-0.0072763874,
0.0392461643,
-0.0275892615,
0.0246990025,
0.008108641,
0.0327504501,
0.0325188227,
0.0300190914,
-0.0135906711,
0.0575964116,
-0.0060651032,
-0.0071234652,
-0.0144573217,
0.025283007,
0.0366684422,
-0.0079521537,
0.0215082113,
0.0000021263,
-0.0472419709,
-0.0419505835,
0.0004069326,
0.0000043119,
0.0035374737,
0.0682299286,
-0.0253297351,
-0.0049322732,
0.037649978,
-0.018884711,
-0.0087250322,
0.0755539462,
-0.0000648634,
0.0445756577,
0.0526398234,
-0.0144233899,
0.0182285476,
-0.0182826109,
0.002989291,
-0.002763625,
0.0139411641,
0.0633075312,
0.0024238233,
-0.0422688387,
0.0280888118,
-0.0145787075,
0.0242034215,
0.0019483204,
-0.0066587077,
-0.0106755849,
-0.0104522239,
-0.0019618224,
-0.0332399011,
0.0314719342,
0.0297406539,
0.0011984373,
-0.0451064818,
0.0107554393,
-0.004596991,
0.0155217573,
0.0454124995,
-0.0299297012,
0.0323711857,
0.0024971827,
0.0086355815,
0.0256733801,
0.0392258652,
0.0422992036,
0.0423788726,
0.0108335828,
0.1129785329,
0.0288583748,
-0.0266128052,
-0.0071435105,
0.0385811292,
0.0215638485,
-0.0395113491,
-0.0075059445,
-0.0380269513,
0.0150030563,
0.0367383957,
-0.0443231538,
0.0148198567,
0.0445831828,
-0.0483560227,
-0.0180281159,
-0.0073700938,
-0.0174938273,
-0.0034240291,
-0.0010294176,
-0.0233905055,
0.0094882622,
0.0059994063,
-0.0070195622,
0.0268169399,
0.0270006098,
-0.0052746986,
0.0078587346,
0.0025032228,
0.020684639,
0.0508844331,
-0.0399421193,
0.0290488005,
-0.0505287126,
-0.0108516123,
-0.0138463238,
-0.0046432419,
-0.0442347527,
-0.0049738931,
-0.000993797,
0.0317560844,
-0.0409802124,
0.0545469746,
-0.0231229085,
-0.0830267221,
-0.00596399,
0.0323405899,
-0.0471839197,
-0.0458023734,
-0.0193839446,
0.1067535654,
0.0360540375,
0.0026906144,
-0.0248526949,
-0.0472699739,
-0.0609733686,
-0.0353193991,
-0.0089980243,
-0.0756881014,
-0.0368461236,
0.0175004303,
-0.0002689134,
-0.1063345447,
-0.0197336841,
-0.0078809857,
-0.0420768708,
0.0517238304,
-0.030272875,
-0.0012275587,
0.0182655826,
0.0341491774,
-0.0030310676,
0.0942088142,
0.0003051065,
0.0398792252,
0.0647181049,
0.0072058742,
0.0399929248,
0.025859002,
0.0448629409,
0.0262696333,
-0.0542637296,
-0.0138889384,
0.0070312386,
-0.0297280625,
0.0134379286,
0.0703177601,
-0.0133038266,
-0.0285711829,
0.0941948369,
-0.0006448408,
-0.0444968306,
0.0063048708,
0.0513148978,
0.0164688621,
-0.0271604117,
0.0473200418,
-0.0666576102,
-0.0154301124,
-0.0205882974,
0.0050987615,
0.018242754,
0.0249708146,
-0.00620325,
-0.0471710525,
-0.0111535322,
-0.0065958016,
0.0383231193,
-0.0157909784,
0.038986627,
0.0144084794,
0.0026025549,
0.0467679016,
0.0515340492,
-0.0543673746,
0.0153552219,
-0.0525735468,
0.0147484709,
0.0339299068,
0.0458322801,
-0.0286400523,
0.0021418645,
-0.0355902947,
0.0139293009,
0.0403646193,
0.0359315611,
-0.0175002478,
0.02740358,
-0.0382442325,
-0.0330975242,
-0.0029164497,
0.0462871306,
0.0162596833,
0.0312478133,
0.0099825561,
0.0118154436,
-0.0771469474,
-0.0413848795,
0.0446717925,
-0.0098645929,
-0.0403136723,
-0.0212768987,
0.0010378027,
0.0021177339,
-0.0010209609,
-0.0282926839,
-0.0227103978,
0.0048066522,
0.0192510728,
0.008891318,
0.012018133,
-0.040938694,
0.0074532535,
0.0316825546,
-0.0692532137,
-0.0000146072,
0.0491754264,
-0.0292004924,
0.007713859,
0.0714364275,
-0.0170915239,
0.0047823014,
-0.0032358835,
0.0302487891,
-0.0615282841,
0.0035792405,
-0.0425028205,
0.0208546687,
0.0074017649,
0.0006895792,
-0.0109928604,
-0.0433781408,
-0.0035826503,
-0.0135730319,
-0.0655707642,
0.0065191803,
-0.0060896841,
0.0246233828,
0.0778678805,
-0.012806504,
-0.0021021308,
0.0015678982,
-0.0259028357,
-0.0231348462,
-0.0181804318,
0.0280468501,
0.0161081012,
0.0234709997,
-0.0102456799,
-0.0093615772,
-0.0133090895,
-0.0793872699,
-0.0156317763,
0.0481059588,
0.0360607468,
-0.0243443102,
-0.012579185,
-0.0353016593,
-0.0262761544,
-0.0203449856,
0.0842218474,
0.0155651942,
-0.0030254638,
-0.0477690063,
0.0367304347,
-0.0580530874,
0.0134238824,
-0.0170809776,
-0.0263875891,
0.0210416224,
0.0281081572,
-0.0120892199,
0.0596659705,
0.0120428773,
0.0325917676,
0.0788276345,
0.0126669118,
-0.0735792741,
-0.0421159193,
-0.0257844757,
-0.0030219022,
0.0072939037,
-0.0801502839,
0.008296147,
0.0646202117,
0.0170054119,
-0.0339969657,
-0.0295627844,
0.0297465958,
-0.0497416556,
-0.0412121601,
0.0063067423,
-0.0627146214,
-0.0170116108,
0.0173002649,
-0.0109065594,
-0.10512615,
0.0769455656,
-0.0248109028,
0.0415588059,
-0.0482623056,
0.0014272738,
0.0029023851,
0.0250130631,
-0.0299248528,
0.0306893457,
0.0722533911,
-0.0005255879,
-0.0515260659,
-0.0363727249,
0.0870164484,
-0.0258144028,
0.0430309325,
-0.0718522295,
0.0263196472,
0.016990412,
-0.0271239392,
-0.0422297679,
-0.0448039807,
-0.0022916014,
-0.0188148078,
0.0399065576,
0.0217456613,
-0.0378019772,
0.0202148892,
0.0201371089,
0.0017810891,
-0.0176589936,
-0.0056065037,
0.0251233224,
-0.0168398675,
0.0372198448,
-0.0689537302,
0.0322977677,
-0.0228825156,
-0.0144874062,
0.0435080901,
-0.0166313555,
0.0113940649,
-0.0207972173,
-0.0153339664,
0.0080610523,
-0.0405032225,
-0.0169980023,
0.016652735,
0.0510267317,
-0.0413065404,
-0.013457316,
0.1011217907,
0.0034423305,
-0.0495615266,
0.0181719903,
0.0106052523,
0.030415317,
0.0130219385,
-0.0020397985,
-0.0803306177,
0.0006456615,
0.0148025518,
0.051903747,
-0.0491570868,
-0.0308901463,
-0.0229530036,
-0.0850605071,
-0.0034243264,
0.0138635319,
0.0020013431,
-0.0166390594,
-0.0680244192,
0.0199440103,
-0.0452033617,
0.034141928,
-0.0115980022,
-0.0055358848,
0.0105492938,
0.0344908051,
-0.0686738119,
-0.0789005682,
-0.0283487327,
-0.0457933284,
0.0876116231,
0.066712752,
0.0117352745,
-0.0433775187,
0.0105091566,
0.0210650582,
-0.0087015377,
-0.0454127416,
-0.0193551127,
0.0846050456,
-0.0353016742,
0.001452582,
-0.0257746894,
-0.0002656441,
0.0300227366,
0.00527009,
-0.0064934101,
0.0228755306,
0.0167296734,
-0.0514207073,
-0.0266923569,
0.0223135632,
0.0374177545,
0.1082529053,
0.023056265,
-0.0360662751,
-0.0159072746,
-0.073506698,
-0.0087937852,
0.0332002975,
-0.0283117779,
-0.0205702558,
-0.0214441195,
-0.0398488156,
-0.0656755567,
-0.0180918034,
-0.0073936488,
0.0233008619,
0.0289631505,
0.012169064,
0.0047646561,
-0.0151528027,
-0.0075226775,
-0.000660155,
-0.0237077344,
0.0143985301,
-0.0157723371,
0.0370205604,
-0.0185157545,
-0.0063809562,
-0.0058688032,
0.0307065118,
-0.0034683729,
-0.1089382097,
0.0526805893,
0.0414201356,
0.0321901813,
0.0312694833,
-0.0125499032,
-0.0579403453,
0.0566799603,
0.0456757322,
-0.0161126703,
0.0026082434,
0.061819952,
-0.0306898113,
0.0304795373,
0.0304229222,
-0.0374995321,
0.0347917154,
0.0399379544,
-0.0317179523,
-0.0207248628,
-0.0262162946,
-0.0055819931,
0.0067267218,
0.0560657121,
-0.0347461142,
0.0099321827,
-0.0271109156,
-0.0250794794,
-0.0418716297,
-0.0589805357,
-0.0099321073,
0.0399447568,
0.0108053787,
0.0402729921,
-0.0378549434,
0.007433115,
-0.0638009459,
0.0290554501,
-0.0234457757,
0.0515416786,
-0.012158487,
0.0352013633,
0.0110153081,
0.0056169084,
-0.0230505355,
0.0117801698,
-0.0185280163,
0.0345468372,
0.007345248,
-0.0180713218,
0.0293564778,
0.0183916911,
0.0014816332,
0.0216796268,
-0.0289218221,
0.0268795472,
-0.0314662233,
0.0226075705,
-0.0045429673,
-0.009367683,
0.0771149248,
-0.0001399818,
0.0167615097,
-0.019586768,
0.0003026695,
0.0347696021,
-0.0192970634,
0.0038781504,
-0.0070925206,
-0.0585567132,
0.0245621074,
0.0699543208,
0.0126676429,
0.0348144062,
-0.0281593688,
-0.0345292985,
-0.0218940806,
-0.0351911522,
0.0184824336,
0.0006340226,
-0.0350046568,
-0.0435394049,
-0.0576619431,
-0.0750892535,
-0.0350480117,
-0.0062428759,
0.0431689434,
-0.0077743186,
-0.0179423764,
0.0788738206,
0.006415308,
-0.0188281443,
-0.0455773585,
-0.0017455147,
-0.0133183682,
-0.0201738086,
-0.0012047404,
-6.450368762e-33,
-0.0099102287,
-0.0052714148,
-0.0518765524,
-0.0182407591,
0.0118886596,
-0.013193001,
-0.0203035399,
0.0155829778,
-0.0298302174,
0.0337819196,
0.0163723864,
0.002265983,
0.0211032424,
-0.0143817253,
-0.0052082106,
-0.000337329,
0.0455544777,
0.0001735941,
-0.0654456466,
0.0069832723,
0.0298650544,
-0.0161681678,
0.0493367352,
-0.0873019695,
0.1028852835,
-0.0291118044,
-0.0453533009,
0.0061379108,
0.0054879333,
0.0369190574,
0.0051923809,
0.0436250083,
0.0115769366,
-0.0533219166,
-0.0148245851,
0.0175054297,
-0.0163873173,
-0.0386987031,
0.0624473765,
-0.000942938,
-0.0135523146,
-0.0165692791,
0.0614537336,
-0.0024054376,
-0.0348282866,
-0.0070099514,
0.0308333635,
-0.0100045511,
0.0049389354,
0.0228126273,
-0.0663087815,
0.0411980525,
-0.014669152,
0.0162997525,
0.0294228569,
0.0376477912,
0.0177762359,
-0.0114132296,
-0.0005029056,
0.0296876263,
0.0157398209,
0.0123748658,
0.0784617364,
-0.0033979139,
-0.0050267978,
0.0873252824,
-0.0103215678,
0.0416640639,
0.0371739753,
-0.0651025549,
0.0309337247,
-0.0167475305,
0.0332058147,
0.0742893964,
0.0002765979,
-0.0215149596,
-0.0501179136,
0.0463342294,
0.0245173443,
0.0064589148,
0.0434299111,
-0.026322173,
-0.0919132829,
-0.0705678836,
-0.0285323784,
-0.0520206727,
-0.0039614686,
-0.0582862198,
0.0206205398,
-0.009995603,
-0.0688176975,
0.0167940855,
0.0159657095,
-0.0766099691,
-0.021685686,
0.0437921397,
-0.0257503558,
-0.0170112755,
0.0107124895,
0.0217741337,
-0.044870168,
0.0025330791,
0.0119633144,
0.0200106967,
0.0237399563,
-0.0134345666,
0.0242308117,
0.0116430968,
-0.0768318102,
0.0007128781,
-0.0237156563,
0.0288715791,
0.0237280298,
0.0468891375,
0.0308400244,
0.003119654,
0.0036932423,
-0.0103558637,
0.051805906,
-0.0115029914,
-0.0370143764,
0.0204722006,
-0.0144832255,
0.0019781769,
-0.0388544723,
-0.0359436311,
0.0002965062,
0.0120254131,
0.044327233,
-0.0367773883,
-0.0283154305,
-0.0491036512,
2.855e-7,
0.044949457,
0.0661311075,
0.0096225711,
0.0208137203,
0.0110452743,
0.0454640538,
0.0264239293,
0.0580070801,
0.0251951646,
-0.0206487123,
-0.016627796,
0.0043504597,
0.0378511883,
0.0455557369,
-0.0499436557,
-0.0161909927,
-0.0655035153,
0.0087666046,
-0.0119071519,
-0.0150698703,
0.0082973093,
0.0356650688,
0.0146406488,
0.0076280991,
-0.0125475843,
-0.0301083475,
0.0112521322,
-0.032924097,
0.0316618793,
0.0388394259,
0.0628360659,
-0.0109041901,
0.0399619564,
0.0128935268,
-0.0136355199,
0.011168886,
-0.0156205865,
0.0748223588,
0.005678019,
0.0088393642,
-0.0319056362,
-0.0293370113,
0.0194313284,
-0.0913875178,
0.0698831901,
0.0042951643,
-0.0221415814,
-0.0926231891,
-0.0288241152,
-0.0175667629,
0.0576149411,
-0.0110617569,
-0.0284790322,
0.0270010941,
-0.0076643461,
0.0153732272,
-0.034434054,
-0.0521312058,
-0.0703458339,
-0.0420420058,
-0.011443574,
-0.0813473538,
0.0224543381,
0.013596409,
-0.0003544133,
-0.058116477,
0.0754809305,
2.517229317e-34,
0.0307520293,
-0.0176485125,
0.0022238006,
-0.0252987836,
0.0130254729,
0.0140052997,
-0.0206784252,
0.0114546325,
0.0016642592,
-0.0267561432,
-0.0043850034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14303v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14303v2 | QTSumm: Query-Focused Summarization over Tabular Data | 2023-05-23T17:43:51 | 2023-11-07T04:53:07 | Yilun Zhao, Zhenting Qi, Linyong Nan, Boyu Mi, Yixin Liu, Weijin Zou, Simeng Han, Ruizhe Chen, Xiangru Tang, Yumo Xu, Dragomir Radev, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | People primarily consult tables to conduct data analysis or answer specific
questions. Text generation systems that can provide accurate table summaries
tailored to users' information needs can facilitate more efficient access to
relevant data insights. Motivated by this, we define a new query-focused table
summarization task, where text generation models have to perform human-like
reasoning and analysis over the given table to generate a tailored summary. We
introduce a new benchmark named QTSumm for this task, which contains 7,111
human-annotated query-summary pairs over 2,934 tables covering diverse topics.
We investigate a set of strong baselines on QTSumm, including text generation,
table-to-text generation, and large language models. Experimental results and
manual analysis reveal that the new task presents significant challenges in
table-to-text generation for future research. Moreover, we propose a new
approach named ReFactor, to retrieve and reason over query-relevant information
from tabular data to generate several natural language facts. Experimental
results demonstrate that ReFactor can bring improvements to baselines by
concatenating the generated facts to the model input. Our data and code are
publicly available at https://github.com/yale-nlp/QTSumm. | [
0.0349479914,
0.0595375448,
0.0277419146,
-0.006734529,
-0.0107724015,
0.0290227737,
-0.0391554274,
-0.0223668255,
-0.0346628353,
-0.0240653213,
0.0010234544,
-0.0153190959,
0.0092756329,
0.0289580524,
0.0624256283,
-0.0282594692,
0.0223023538,
0.0194428712,
-0.0382634215,
0.0393663198,
0.0235358831,
0.0100255543,
-0.006095734,
0.0204485506,
-0.0104437713,
0.0200733747,
-0.0235122088,
-0.0069242828,
-0.0077919643,
0.005514306,
0.014126501,
0.0574392192,
0.0161096472,
-0.0149220303,
0.0000018518,
0.0002286966,
-0.0359610096,
-0.0019441369,
-0.0055492469,
0.0160503164,
0.046214316,
-0.0075310441,
0.0257481989,
0.0212304275,
-0.0371803753,
0.0061171721,
-0.0152464993,
0.0516034514,
0.0962524414,
0.0586853139,
0.0065663834,
-0.0292092394,
-0.0237569567,
-0.0204809327,
0.0483264402,
-0.034994334,
-0.0288960729,
0.012299832,
0.0182097834,
-0.0103651974,
0.0385765433,
0.032662794,
0.0266814474,
-0.0239444673,
0.0284897182,
0.0480260961,
-0.0270964634,
0.0147040868,
0.0215834342,
0.1043260917,
0.024127923,
-0.0057115788,
0.0430766828,
0.0326266773,
0.032916598,
-0.0303442329,
-0.0461562648,
0.0346336253,
-0.0056131748,
-0.0082439939,
-0.0000010913,
0.0049381205,
0.0031922944,
0.009854367,
-0.035908971,
0.0228250418,
-0.0159216933,
-0.0112422034,
-0.0102987532,
-0.0131694693,
0.0028441739,
-0.0526052378,
0.0031062022,
0.0523506999,
-0.065592654,
-0.006069514,
-0.0276655089,
-0.0539584681,
0.0245023314,
-0.0447937697,
0.0144495433,
0.0447584949,
0.0206108503,
0.0243731849,
-0.0259310864,
0.0122495284,
0.00541755,
0.010195259,
-0.0564847924,
-0.0184868462,
-0.0457668304,
0.0085426299,
-0.0334355198,
0.030234864,
-0.0850825384,
0.0134081785,
-0.0013807091,
0.0029996703,
0.0103327949,
0.0273959432,
0.0133709153,
0.0537116043,
-0.01628544,
0.0053591286,
-0.0376817137,
-0.0168292448,
-0.0588552281,
-0.0304625146,
0.0408204645,
-0.0550119989,
-0.0166259445,
-0.027780287,
0.0033753552,
-0.0072416365,
0.0202204976,
0.0511118919,
-0.0773202702,
0.0036237501,
-0.0560139343,
-0.0521252714,
-0.0181405526,
-0.064223893,
-0.0191323888,
-0.0520486683,
0.0447465219,
0.0092347162,
-0.0220431276,
-0.0447491519,
0.0216876976,
0.0716684535,
-0.0277986713,
0.0313395187,
0.0092409234,
0.0259971656,
0.0319244713,
-0.0257696994,
0.00632923,
0.0591134392,
0.0495305434,
0.0287629757,
-0.0233892538,
0.0081664268,
-0.0147449737,
0.0026643442,
0.043423716,
0.0029565629,
0.0212976038,
0.0424365662,
-0.0036856674,
0.0331982374,
0.0014981863,
0.0527616739,
-0.0193408225,
0.0590647906,
0.046505928,
0.0126509899,
-0.007985089,
0.0742806941,
0.0230316129,
0.0326849893,
0.0190134645,
0.0153702367,
-0.026990721,
0.0586668625,
-0.0003591987,
0.0481502824,
0.0892484486,
0.0177834332,
-0.0187855326,
-0.061513748,
0.0233831406,
0.0185096357,
-0.0071065924,
0.0049121706,
0.0147985537,
0.0418134816,
-0.0658647195,
-0.0066808928,
-0.0162610542,
-0.0930346698,
0.0319887735,
0.0040462282,
0.0301207472,
0.0481302924,
0.035169933,
-0.046116326,
0.005025472,
-0.0042556371,
0.0142166214,
0.0161128696,
0.0594849251,
-0.0357216485,
-0.0158025399,
-0.0099718804,
-0.0233798083,
-0.0066124075,
0.0267382246,
-0.0313311219,
0.0196507331,
-0.0557789989,
0.0460998341,
-0.0754215792,
-0.0556061082,
0.035023272,
0.0026741489,
-0.0001644106,
0.0172156878,
-0.0189269409,
-0.0117795151,
0.0448906608,
0.0000232001,
0.0650087222,
0.0270184819,
-0.0337328166,
0.0002047547,
-0.005981694,
0.0042291023,
-0.0130161056,
0.0277626216,
-0.0198617075,
-0.0201160703,
-0.0219570752,
-0.0639250502,
-0.0694069788,
0.0237462521,
-0.0592610054,
-0.0512024872,
-0.0375799909,
0.0078950208,
0.0456407815,
0.0066197808,
0.010505436,
0.0921696052,
-0.0062415521,
-0.0090775164,
0.0516598634,
-0.0940688625,
-0.0068867709,
-0.0553632826,
0.0480498336,
-0.0488666594,
-0.034007255,
0.017667938,
0.0410203449,
0.0248139072,
-0.0638330057,
-0.001816727,
-0.0962251648,
0.0411200896,
-0.0402220897,
0.0227924082,
0.0555646978,
0.0183223411,
-0.0135340942,
0.0010767335,
-0.0733875707,
-0.0531864949,
0.021076493,
-0.0151406871,
0.0936494395,
0.0147274453,
0.0190833919,
-0.0651316419,
-0.0141755193,
-0.0117240101,
0.0231484789,
-0.0041101384,
-0.0146307088,
0.0076614888,
-0.021124782,
-0.0259994194,
-0.014467828,
0.0253440831,
0.0049689263,
-0.0105445664,
-0.0184177551,
0.0851963013,
0.0373065658,
0.0316248164,
0.0225323923,
0.0211555809,
-0.0004673663,
-0.0253522806,
0.02473877,
-0.0241049584,
0.0316794999,
0.046629183,
-0.0906110257,
0.0713995546,
0.0356958248,
-0.0105786333,
-0.0012804256,
-0.0380463079,
0.0439217091,
0.0108767143,
0.0016432907,
-0.0929344594,
0.0547281951,
0.0143843666,
0.0225613825,
-0.0421646945,
0.0196565315,
0.0216176119,
-0.0306088999,
0.0229070447,
-0.0261718947,
0.0143875396,
-0.0559231751,
0.0489133634,
-0.0075840643,
0.0138783613,
-0.0314174108,
-0.0017775809,
-0.0414213464,
-0.0203082394,
0.0217274744,
-0.0344242454,
0.1114735752,
-0.0869535431,
0.0169314276,
-0.0181769822,
-0.0193075705,
-0.0200884361,
-0.0443698764,
-0.0155985141,
0.0142436698,
0.047372289,
-0.0056601861,
-0.0248873439,
-0.0512300134,
0.0573534369,
0.0453287661,
-0.0186470598,
-0.0415158644,
-0.0141634615,
0.0381668694,
0.0376643278,
0.0293177962,
-0.0109882914,
-0.0149058811,
0.0299250986,
0.0574037321,
0.0246616844,
-0.027460508,
0.0220794883,
0.008173693,
-0.0290521719,
-0.0341426022,
0.0193843301,
0.0474981368,
0.0209619757,
-0.0360865034,
-0.0284820218,
0.065762572,
0.0256609712,
0.0305037275,
-0.0108706029,
0.0404240228,
0.0613143817,
0.0083040418,
0.0535122082,
-0.0637152269,
-0.0252318047,
-0.0029584258,
0.0340722501,
0.0098615056,
-0.0497627854,
-0.0516681261,
-0.0968652368,
0.0139225563,
-0.0241001993,
-0.0585831627,
-0.0806829259,
-0.034516599,
-0.00984817,
-0.0314552709,
0.0129108513,
0.085468851,
-0.0191182122,
0.0466834642,
0.0199121926,
-0.0545732006,
-0.0131247062,
-0.0264019296,
-0.0435572043,
0.0006318154,
0.04839959,
0.022940509,
0.0095628323,
0.0214819666,
0.0070842085,
-0.007147606,
0.0124807488,
0.0205835514,
0.082055904,
0.0019870189,
0.0035502983,
-0.014249254,
0.0415903181,
-0.0365226492,
0.0217787754,
0.0289346315,
-0.0059842332,
-0.0109968903,
-0.0070563541,
-0.0073726508,
0.0285827201,
-0.0344938375,
0.0806983635,
0.0498112068,
0.0117357867,
-0.055015903,
-0.0246924032,
-0.045852717,
-0.1161990538,
0.009585646,
0.015230123,
-0.0304132402,
-0.0318408459,
-0.0911031142,
-0.0222123284,
0.0530511737,
0.0313563012,
0.0006972793,
0.0067896377,
-0.0201784,
-0.0120088207,
-0.040872626,
-0.0145533234,
-0.0425675921,
0.0107156858,
-0.0196993947,
-0.0482114963,
0.0036251675,
-0.0562327765,
-0.001148769,
0.0385078453,
-0.0730623826,
-0.0318570845,
-0.0251746681,
0.0252508521,
0.0203376003,
0.0276462175,
0.0118878745,
0.0162892342,
-0.0234178361,
0.0304184537,
-0.0626922026,
-0.0286363438,
-0.0124151111,
-0.0060259379,
-0.0059842472,
0.0362928845,
-0.0468274727,
-0.0099011697,
-0.0277139209,
0.0598209538,
-0.019212123,
0.0060739415,
0.0639699996,
0.0295306835,
-0.0152101973,
-0.0065721576,
-0.0136069814,
-0.0213688314,
-0.0294549502,
-0.0671408102,
-0.0444512665,
-0.0321578197,
0.0290667769,
-0.0019665805,
0.0136596868,
-0.0032472303,
0.0136927608,
0.0203610994,
0.0337667614,
-0.0046882113,
-0.0517744385,
-0.0086172745,
-0.0099234562,
-0.0083906399,
-0.0481310375,
-0.0346042216,
-0.0134721799,
-0.0220411252,
0.0316367671,
0.0044622878,
0.0140281059,
0.0343272723,
-0.0235640593,
-0.0166992117,
0.0368348137,
-0.0494821258,
-0.0157838631,
-0.0467087366,
0.014850311,
0.0077135023,
0.0153950071,
0.0196625404,
-0.0305353831,
-0.0132321306,
0.0050262087,
0.0556941517,
0.0283715464,
0.0130256033,
-0.0240108538,
-0.0045612715,
-0.0023281665,
-0.0566327535,
0.0925549865,
0.0143672386,
-0.0172870643,
-0.0050825612,
-0.0221668798,
-0.0658917427,
-0.0027050204,
-0.0271928906,
-0.013986635,
-0.0103903152,
-0.0366441682,
-0.0469390117,
-0.0317179412,
0.0367979966,
0.0517631732,
0.0062062182,
-0.0010100433,
0.0439974777,
0.0401942283,
0.0232842285,
-0.0077118594,
-0.0609042421,
0.0320816003,
-0.0218398515,
-0.0136873135,
-0.0233785864,
-6.244320766e-33,
-0.0534580871,
-0.0167929418,
0.0218051653,
-0.0485359468,
-0.0189222544,
-0.0248838179,
-0.0701379254,
-0.0107486565,
0.009599275,
0.0006838829,
-0.0214581229,
0.0376614369,
0.0086844917,
0.0283437409,
0.0024456729,
-0.0634458289,
0.0398482643,
-0.0208354965,
-0.0434453711,
0.0407891981,
0.0123366136,
0.0109995697,
-0.0137981055,
-0.0074880002,
0.0613641553,
-0.0225885995,
-0.0269383304,
0.0173502713,
0.0182730872,
-0.017665863,
-0.0312441811,
0.0124120191,
0.0309400074,
-0.0474904962,
-0.063581489,
0.0156035181,
-0.1236653253,
-0.0160662476,
0.000118516,
-0.0362485982,
-0.034591943,
-0.0377709158,
0.0327536277,
-0.0077081821,
-0.007652137,
-0.0316397846,
0.0316691399,
-0.0289680902,
-0.0083078258,
-0.0308711622,
0.0146320788,
0.008759642,
-0.032483343,
-0.0232313778,
0.0090050837,
0.0575208627,
0.0123296063,
-0.0219349265,
-0.0198627729,
0.0438897721,
0.0220437553,
0.0197933819,
0.0604044273,
-0.0191917978,
0.0098136598,
0.0181086101,
0.0247562025,
0.0185545329,
-0.0756623819,
0.0426525734,
-0.067521438,
0.048810225,
0.0579975918,
0.0376907811,
0.0128156058,
0.0247299895,
-0.0178198051,
0.1088555306,
-0.0199808571,
-0.0088445274,
-0.0223533306,
-0.0269436799,
0.0113898134,
-0.0242307186,
-0.030654788,
0.0264440905,
-0.0207620822,
0.0191543903,
0.009742355,
0.0149675999,
-0.0053612441,
-0.0511059314,
-0.0208736118,
0.020910522,
0.0132372966,
0.024540443,
-0.0058694389,
-0.0007266935,
0.0035717778,
-0.0270041954,
-0.021231642,
0.0187582597,
0.0398006514,
0.0197768155,
0.0097943414,
0.0396043174,
0.0232735761,
0.008071295,
-0.0247957576,
-0.0007295155,
-0.0151414061,
0.0898195505,
-0.0303815659,
0.0062406803,
-0.0232548695,
0.0121369381,
-0.0043140771,
0.041649729,
0.0028991301,
0.013378636,
-0.0177407414,
-0.0024860075,
0.0242170449,
0.0087528266,
0.0456480421,
0.0406705551,
-0.0413070358,
0.0154424571,
0.0289020576,
-0.0125870248,
0.0031262403,
0.0112001244,
2.371e-7,
0.0732636154,
-0.0016702145,
0.0854149535,
0.035587173,
-0.0428871401,
0.0216976497,
-0.0000919165,
0.0091077769,
-0.0031781062,
-0.0250446498,
0.0506203584,
0.0117984973,
0.0690100342,
0.0257186256,
-0.0376840904,
-0.0470932275,
-0.0840568468,
-0.0199957434,
-0.0423736982,
-0.0293231457,
0.0584028736,
0.0395726562,
-0.0483546034,
-0.0049320515,
-0.0044792071,
-0.0167061575,
0.0257322211,
-0.0486620106,
-0.0169516336,
0.0335187167,
0.0846699625,
-0.0291949958,
0.0070027993,
0.0220268872,
-0.047327593,
-0.0320006423,
0.0276495274,
0.0399570018,
0.0406358652,
0.000051765,
-0.0079199616,
-0.0561881885,
0.0493947454,
-0.0196352992,
0.071764797,
-0.0582557507,
0.0234235823,
0.0751715451,
-0.0249345191,
0.0349839926,
-0.0049625398,
0.0104158875,
-0.0314671323,
0.0186029226,
0.0156341158,
-0.0009412891,
0.0240180697,
-0.0303150397,
-0.0494402573,
0.0435877293,
-0.0209907684,
-0.0104867676,
-0.021081062,
-0.0073266597,
-0.0280577727,
-0.0454396605,
-0.0353004597,
2.10943173e-34,
0.0602685288,
0.00682496,
0.0029820211,
-0.0180874784,
0.0864412487,
-0.0393073671,
-0.0215981621,
-0.009144688,
0.0192673579,
-0.0609711669,
-0.0186948292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14299v1 | TaDSE: Template-aware Dialogue Sentence Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:40:41 | 2023-05-23T17:40:41 | Minsik Oh, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning high quality sentence embeddings from dialogues has drawn increasing
attentions as it is essential to solve a variety of dialogue-oriented tasks
with low annotation cost. However, directly annotating and gathering utterance
relationships in conversations are difficult, while token-level annotations,
\eg, entities, slots and templates, are much easier to obtain. General sentence
embedding methods are usually sentence-level self-supervised frameworks and
cannot utilize token-level extra knowledge. In this paper, we introduce
Template-aware Dialogue Sentence Embedding (TaDSE), a novel augmentation method
that utilizes template information to effectively learn utterance
representation via self-supervised contrastive learning framework. TaDSE
augments each sentence with its corresponding template and then conducts
pairwise contrastive learning over both sentence and template. We further
enhance the effect with a synthetically augmented dataset that enhances
utterance-template relation, in which entity detection (slot-filling) is a
preliminary step. We evaluate TaDSE performance on five downstream benchmark
datasets. The experiment results show that TaDSE achieves significant
improvements over previous SOTA methods, along with a consistent Intent
Classification task performance improvement margin. We further introduce a
novel analytic instrument of Semantic Compression method, for which we discover
a correlation with uniformity and alignment. Our code will be released soon. | [
0.0181917828,
0.0418722257,
0.0132726179,
0.0386324078,
-0.0103679262,
0.0193240494,
-0.0018725101,
-0.0340011157,
0.0096225953,
-0.0291394312,
-0.0318276323,
0.0200788174,
-0.0281668659,
0.0092766332,
0.0193573851,
-0.0445293784,
0.0337180495,
0.0297076311,
0.0269934889,
0.0155001739,
0.0070204302,
0.0203797221,
-0.0199484862,
0.0336734615,
-0.0326197371,
-0.0267016087,
-0.0186173469,
0.0486998037,
0.0171343777,
-0.0086135278,
0.0204174835,
0.0394369252,
0.0396709852,
-0.0003699253,
0.000001823,
-0.0208882317,
-0.0182426963,
-0.0155940484,
-0.0731914192,
0.0116114505,
0.0177895147,
-0.0111721298,
0.0149299419,
0.0509426482,
-0.0192371756,
-0.0484168679,
0.0228946693,
0.0934545919,
0.0614218488,
0.0641992688,
-0.0290438551,
-0.040033292,
0.0089335265,
-0.0338290185,
-0.0220897142,
-0.0039480692,
-0.008294194,
0.0076526734,
-0.0316617154,
0.0491199084,
-0.0093581667,
0.0419564359,
0.0348325819,
-0.0078064487,
0.0297764074,
0.0334364735,
-0.0324833319,
0.0193694308,
-0.0201534592,
0.0749459714,
0.0503290333,
-0.0040692072,
-0.0123865614,
-0.0139464373,
0.0206119027,
-0.0429424942,
-0.0155633017,
-0.0349266343,
0.0245027654,
0.04586697,
0.0619933009,
0.0488362759,
0.0036548791,
0.0130980825,
-0.0099746948,
-0.0140831321,
0.0040153065,
-0.046882093,
-0.0527098402,
-0.0047122743,
0.021306254,
-0.0318670236,
0.0092075327,
-0.0170272682,
-0.0360599235,
-0.0065670819,
-0.0428789854,
-0.0376792736,
0.0133803356,
0.006673452,
0.0125080403,
0.0592516661,
-0.0318191387,
0.0588141903,
-0.0179693121,
0.0526049696,
-0.0414969362,
0.015495671,
-0.0628965721,
-0.0102844564,
-0.0368830375,
-0.0022793985,
-0.0690765157,
0.0396052487,
-0.0714696348,
-0.0543940701,
-0.0105742849,
0.0296756774,
0.0231842771,
0.018079944,
0.0140774148,
0.0208509713,
-0.0042344332,
0.0228205454,
-0.0055175899,
0.0298850201,
-0.047277756,
0.0055275941,
-0.004453734,
-0.0149325468,
-0.0399155132,
0.041151382,
0.0156346876,
-0.0291141402,
0.0071264924,
0.0319064744,
-0.0115978187,
-0.06414745,
0.0116589423,
0.0212891679,
-0.0431979336,
-0.0416614152,
-0.0518168211,
-0.0445804037,
0.0543596745,
-0.0121069634,
-0.0098200636,
-0.0062343031,
0.0111661535,
-0.0193805899,
-0.0048664082,
0.0790019035,
0.0119998343,
-0.0191454813,
0.0029713584,
0.0037557634,
0.0224279203,
0.0579584651,
0.0378958918,
0.0039788485,
0.0134750679,
0.0031838715,
-0.0012695022,
-0.0117643606,
0.0195656996,
0.0025556008,
0.0178684909,
0.0589852147,
0.019523697,
0.0488922447,
0.0546870008,
0.0610915571,
-0.0508024655,
-0.0551730506,
0.0217733774,
0.0242139809,
0.0109868878,
0.038785331,
0.0344908722,
0.0733333379,
-0.0324563272,
0.0311745126,
-0.0297167692,
0.008300649,
0.0511915945,
-0.0151060401,
0.0807048529,
-0.0183060113,
-0.0397633128,
-0.0255540404,
0.0010466807,
-0.0216227062,
0.0054751891,
-0.0108204624,
0.005935627,
0.0180717707,
-0.0677436218,
0.0879382491,
-0.0015780705,
-0.0466832854,
-0.0580709949,
0.0049325079,
0.0058917347,
0.040456295,
0.0281936675,
-0.0234961193,
-0.0764978454,
-0.0535759777,
-0.0510727391,
0.045257967,
0.0139026642,
0.0069317608,
0.0707399324,
-0.0576711744,
-0.0060375226,
-0.0757221952,
-0.0011969734,
0.033108376,
0.001788983,
-0.0018102943,
0.0204005931,
-0.0147862872,
0.0245237574,
0.014127248,
0.0227875281,
-0.0299235135,
0.0592350513,
0.0339145325,
0.0305934381,
0.0512051582,
-0.0104138646,
-0.0242171828,
0.0297554862,
-0.0511041209,
-0.0197756719,
0.0235587358,
-0.0991473421,
-0.1193976998,
0.004217288,
-0.0267755594,
-0.0262477975,
0.0186097529,
-0.0565150715,
-0.0681810156,
-0.0052031912,
-0.0444406569,
0.0455304682,
-0.0575632527,
-0.0403918549,
0.0490516983,
0.0588763542,
0.0055874605,
0.0423490927,
-0.0006832943,
0.0031669377,
0.0394785888,
0.0225382838,
0.047354769,
-0.0540828705,
-0.0061738798,
-0.0382212326,
-0.0221961625,
-0.0033332116,
0.0137365256,
0.009286236,
-0.0406874828,
-0.0233146232,
-0.1544137597,
0.0037886451,
-0.0126265781,
0.0313823894,
0.0193245541,
0.0164127219,
-0.0178184304,
-0.0312646553,
-0.0486087054,
-0.0773650631,
-0.0013125549,
-0.0116254147,
0.0428213701,
0.0083750226,
-0.0223771464,
-0.0235992763,
0.0290868077,
-0.0068838773,
0.0361724086,
-0.0407548919,
-0.0141842151,
-0.0275831502,
0.0208341852,
0.0152325071,
-0.0055207987,
0.0128021073,
-0.0679798648,
-0.0080964854,
0.0247763842,
0.0272775665,
0.081743136,
0.0143980449,
0.0445723273,
-0.008760334,
0.003924984,
-0.0491470993,
0.0727902278,
-0.0019672716,
0.0751837492,
-0.0226203408,
-0.0024983815,
-0.0071784509,
0.0441425145,
0.0449360944,
0.051794529,
-0.0484664477,
-0.0271926094,
0.0433716141,
-0.0270007104,
0.0031342385,
0.0057485471,
-0.0338609293,
-0.0256038401,
-0.0105712982,
-0.0185771305,
0.0522136576,
-0.0469411463,
-0.0545037799,
-0.045060169,
-0.0314538255,
-0.0419560336,
0.02987637,
-0.0157640614,
0.0105136074,
0.0111825382,
-0.0566550642,
-0.0056500845,
-0.0291397646,
0.0008692922,
-0.0132670496,
0.0122590614,
0.0467461199,
-0.0100393863,
-0.0112172728,
-0.0698892921,
-0.0600020401,
-0.0701236501,
-0.0169594698,
0.0151925627,
0.0162907299,
-0.0132568423,
-0.0057061678,
-0.0089771412,
-0.0136958612,
0.0338988453,
-0.0107119996,
0.0152376881,
-0.0259634722,
0.1060157344,
0.0055352976,
0.0237872861,
-0.006435697,
0.024423806,
0.0652456954,
0.0361151062,
0.0015287423,
0.0130209951,
-0.0508755483,
-0.0034774211,
0.0020106975,
0.0094534904,
-0.0093619134,
-0.0232781004,
0.0623622425,
-0.0177505016,
-0.0089986259,
0.1276608407,
0.027926404,
0.0055972571,
-0.0263736099,
0.0039188727,
0.0192169249,
0.0166732892,
0.0218169801,
-0.0920796394,
-0.0636690184,
0.0029065853,
0.0103470897,
0.0011704395,
-0.006802306,
-0.0089205429,
-0.0534388386,
0.032568913,
-0.0153596755,
-0.0418372713,
-0.0056249797,
-0.0197582692,
0.0132775698,
-0.035983149,
0.0301085431,
-0.0218296722,
0.001037477,
-0.0204423219,
0.0085137822,
-0.0491718613,
-0.0114426892,
-0.0090848897,
-0.0042488435,
0.072725147,
0.0192114692,
0.0484847277,
0.0039846734,
0.0099384068,
-0.0018797475,
-0.0522738658,
-0.0138883991,
-0.0153606609,
0.0720711574,
-0.0615388677,
-0.0196238663,
0.0142349573,
0.0369023457,
-0.037400011,
-0.0067831529,
-0.0163939632,
0.0456113294,
-0.0016233824,
0.0539569892,
-0.0277149081,
-0.0039426559,
0.0331527665,
0.0991025344,
0.0574466437,
-0.007877755,
-0.0102894213,
-0.0148909744,
0.0155539829,
-0.0533730276,
0.0536200628,
-0.0240390878,
0.0393352211,
0.0199463591,
-0.0610847883,
-0.0600172095,
0.0088025443,
0.0133070936,
-0.0481094383,
0.0063626361,
-0.0645714849,
-0.0047071422,
-0.025873512,
0.0097833918,
-0.0385025777,
-0.0015000812,
-0.0533058941,
-0.0198076498,
0.0463842936,
-0.0191660486,
-0.0254340228,
0.0186626203,
-0.0682560951,
-0.0367821269,
-0.029775165,
0.0307965279,
-0.0033737624,
0.0745810717,
-0.0228330959,
0.0577682219,
0.0566641577,
0.0504686609,
-0.0801595524,
-0.0104987007,
0.0779857561,
0.0119196791,
0.0012467046,
0.0414513946,
0.0020050793,
0.0003639639,
-0.0100654,
0.0339116193,
-0.0206697062,
-0.0624433868,
0.0129616978,
-0.0156167503,
0.0477750637,
-0.0021264639,
0.0204462633,
0.0045614452,
0.0575470999,
-0.0108262943,
-0.0117131593,
-0.0684231594,
0.0091942549,
-0.0087793218,
-0.0015702501,
-0.0078433705,
0.0110148564,
-0.0288257021,
0.034114141,
-0.0053159026,
-0.0000215083,
-0.0221594647,
-0.0261947755,
-0.0229182206,
0.002556107,
-0.0322869979,
0.0174311157,
0.0048915106,
0.0143718803,
-0.0054220608,
0.0687667653,
0.0074921497,
-0.0035559658,
0.0067118937,
0.0592281446,
-0.0212314408,
0.0055217897,
-0.0354450457,
-0.0093927132,
0.0252867732,
-0.0434312001,
0.0178509075,
-0.0274319965,
0.0165059157,
0.0046058395,
0.0539701916,
-0.0319624059,
-0.0000203259,
0.0320621245,
0.0145231206,
-0.031365633,
0.0118695488,
0.0311161857,
-0.0411792137,
0.0264948271,
0.0407801829,
0.0082583902,
-0.069227919,
-0.0208110753,
0.0329132341,
0.0328838341,
-0.0051288027,
0.0009327523,
-0.0006913674,
-0.0451999977,
0.0198991951,
-0.0083265081,
-0.0391808003,
0.0187424906,
0.0366089083,
0.0186824761,
-0.0005650832,
-0.0001861266,
-0.0036493542,
-0.0016532231,
-0.0008298373,
-0.0147035569,
-0.0178027153,
-5.8813406e-33,
-0.0160838235,
0.0218019057,
-0.017524844,
-0.023025047,
-0.0274961479,
0.0390453376,
-0.0294957962,
-0.0186834745,
0.0000907085,
0.0088514481,
-0.0080881519,
0.0239407029,
0.0097009372,
0.0572152212,
-0.0336604305,
-0.0333125331,
0.0602709353,
0.0091495309,
-0.0312247444,
0.0254154895,
0.0257927366,
0.0193969533,
0.0473934487,
-0.0575865917,
-0.0416989736,
0.0119894026,
-0.0058239242,
0.0352583416,
0.0354240425,
0.0764894858,
-0.025452204,
0.0287617184,
-0.0014078643,
-0.056086164,
-0.0025330251,
0.0339091979,
-0.1072590798,
-0.0233695749,
0.0284367017,
0.003749693,
-0.0530344509,
-0.0515518747,
-0.0158270933,
-0.0071661025,
0.0273982305,
-0.014880809,
-0.0073399772,
-0.0163339134,
0.0204333793,
-0.0063545164,
-0.0181252807,
0.0139149269,
-0.0471968763,
-0.0493093468,
0.0316364206,
0.026916787,
0.0503321737,
-0.0300881993,
-0.0351258814,
-0.015802497,
-0.0250971001,
0.0177275706,
0.0025882144,
-0.0099920658,
-0.0201824568,
0.0293951388,
0.0003245919,
-0.0594595224,
-0.0002282618,
-0.0527840741,
-0.0239287,
0.0245309044,
0.0099354265,
0.0336668976,
0.0164085459,
0.0425137095,
-0.0347985737,
0.0201175716,
0.0136867138,
0.0325914882,
0.0197055079,
0.0358529091,
-0.0477604866,
-0.0032165477,
-0.0088511854,
-0.0432120301,
-0.0170761328,
-0.0314423256,
0.0254852436,
0.0269350447,
-0.0262076575,
-0.0049259723,
0.0495670028,
-0.0478243269,
0.013450576,
0.0677756667,
-0.0298240203,
-0.0128841894,
0.0103450771,
0.0143274348,
-0.05666475,
-0.0062778951,
0.0522996001,
0.0211144704,
0.0016219598,
-0.0110516008,
0.0357578509,
-0.0105085308,
-0.0733226687,
0.0065999115,
0.012276304,
0.006992294,
-0.0920006633,
-0.0097676236,
0.0364851505,
0.0242673792,
-0.0198185872,
0.0739625916,
-0.0013642615,
0.0074200756,
-0.0582676455,
-0.0087209772,
0.01841354,
0.0352513492,
-0.0121067399,
0.0161672346,
-0.0053312611,
-0.0164503753,
-0.0112482533,
-0.0355335809,
-0.0007975532,
-0.003796713,
2.45e-7,
0.0060059386,
0.0315439664,
0.0720852315,
-0.0144523783,
0.0147467814,
0.0747196451,
0.0239154659,
0.0512721725,
-0.0062605678,
-0.0089161191,
0.0497946069,
0.0283584576,
0.04463071,
-0.0049586133,
-0.1085188985,
0.0646365136,
-0.0782348663,
-0.0134540051,
-0.0425236151,
0.0088034561,
0.0879823193,
0.1090487987,
0.0362231955,
0.0244386345,
-0.0091383811,
0.0169009063,
0.0292665605,
-0.0273763686,
-0.0026082848,
-0.0149661396,
-0.0266376119,
0.0463596769,
-0.0183153786,
-0.0035254683,
-0.0011655979,
0.0734855384,
0.0001946119,
0.0430027843,
0.0403841585,
-0.0311818048,
-0.0310237929,
0.0034415647,
-0.0029850244,
-0.0616904423,
0.0546537749,
-0.059068203,
-0.009942255,
-0.0389768071,
-0.0503184162,
0.0208404455,
0.0486071855,
0.0184742212,
-0.038737487,
0.0229740404,
0.0414937139,
-0.0361410193,
-0.0178784672,
-0.1038896963,
-0.0069973092,
0.0047796192,
-0.0319081247,
0.0112256547,
-0.0298775658,
0.0030442544,
0.0211245678,
-0.0513794459,
0.0030024308,
2.242977531e-34,
0.0127045969,
0.0072474177,
0.0149587858,
0.0548469462,
0.008631953,
-0.0412119664,
-0.0116502419,
-0.0378596447,
0.0406285785,
-0.0722172633,
0.0065304474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14296v2 | USB: A Unified Summarization Benchmark Across Tasks and Domains | 2023-05-23T17:39:54 | 2023-12-04T15:53:50 | Kundan Krishna, Prakhar Gupta, Sanjana Ramprasad, Byron C. Wallace, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Zachary C. Lipton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While the NLP community has produced numerous summarization benchmarks, none
provide the rich annotations required to simultaneously address many important
problems related to control and reliability. We introduce a Wikipedia-derived
benchmark, complemented by a rich set of crowd-sourced annotations, that
supports $8$ interrelated tasks: (i) extractive summarization; (ii) abstractive
summarization; (iii) topic-based summarization; (iv) compressing selected
sentences into a one-line summary; (v) surfacing evidence for a summary
sentence; (vi) predicting the factual accuracy of a summary sentence; (vii)
identifying unsubstantiated spans in a summary sentence; (viii) correcting
factual errors in summaries. We compare various methods on this benchmark and
discover that on multiple tasks, moderately-sized fine-tuned models
consistently outperform much larger few-shot prompted language models. For
factuality-related tasks, we also evaluate existing heuristics to create
training data and find that training on them results in worse performance than
training on $20\times$ less human-labeled data. Our articles draw from $6$
domains, facilitating cross-domain analysis. On some tasks, the amount of
training data matters more than the domain where it comes from, while for other
tasks training specifically on data from the target domain, even if limited, is
more beneficial. | [
0.0446357094,
0.0079000052,
0.0336270705,
-0.0039878436,
-0.030889485,
0.0133909406,
-0.0138031011,
-0.0341258049,
-0.022519093,
-0.0737408623,
0.0147858793,
-0.0116662318,
0.0269268528,
-0.0157934576,
0.0132163111,
-0.0852978826,
0.0220436975,
-0.0080500133,
0.0099411821,
0.0033133461,
0.0259262584,
-0.0057212822,
-0.0162523352,
0.0397023,
-0.019194698,
0.0212023165,
-0.0003249154,
-0.0080037508,
0.0481798686,
-0.0177912209,
0.0628143623,
0.0495862812,
0.01870781,
-0.007665161,
0.000001908,
-0.0394432396,
0.0008257671,
-0.0136393737,
-0.0129260523,
0.0486186706,
0.0445042178,
-0.048262503,
0.0335747898,
0.0036763737,
-0.0029879226,
-0.0197257008,
-0.0095396386,
0.0720720291,
0.0814668089,
0.082120195,
0.0062157833,
-0.0457972251,
-0.0039046223,
-0.0367381126,
-0.039644517,
-0.0234002508,
0.0047811242,
0.0181592721,
-0.0102587175,
-0.0115641579,
0.001265819,
0.0221693087,
-0.0063501028,
0.0126931807,
0.0270382706,
0.024489535,
-0.0948967636,
-0.0274416469,
0.0181432348,
0.0680100322,
0.031814266,
-0.0140353441,
0.037376646,
0.0160761327,
0.0064956495,
-0.0116770202,
-0.0408929586,
0.0544365346,
-0.0038602266,
0.0199559536,
-0.0030271471,
0.0197721384,
-0.0073771779,
0.0313461237,
0.0092771081,
0.0302434098,
-0.0016699191,
-0.0022356138,
-0.015620552,
0.0322074071,
-0.0298467111,
-0.0682959631,
-0.0286586583,
0.0274312533,
-0.0275829174,
-0.033655379,
-0.0644155219,
-0.0457668938,
0.0430143028,
-0.0193979703,
-0.0046124496,
-0.0035582832,
0.0143164685,
0.0526349247,
-0.002293451,
-0.0078422716,
0.0257156566,
0.0124303671,
-0.0431546755,
-0.0104262987,
-0.027200615,
0.0438360274,
-0.0480716079,
0.0366376303,
-0.0295670368,
-0.014767292,
-0.049779512,
-0.0094108935,
0.0006089538,
0.0151800402,
-0.0131301042,
0.0003466455,
0.0008690293,
0.0096445112,
-0.0129160983,
0.0286066476,
-0.0797233954,
0.0100992629,
0.0390724428,
0.0044097682,
-0.0215789452,
0.0143420445,
0.0153440917,
0.0022552754,
0.010543677,
0.029386105,
-0.0162859354,
-0.0381539948,
-0.0393615812,
-0.0321300551,
-0.0246939566,
-0.0562677719,
-0.0139494585,
-0.0777715817,
-0.0066388934,
0.0088708205,
-0.0199302733,
-0.0177617036,
0.0046531809,
0.0339714289,
-0.0403284244,
0.0298909545,
-0.0443704613,
0.0049926792,
0.0405222327,
-0.0035258378,
-0.0023678537,
0.0727534741,
0.0349997655,
0.056997411,
0.0583741143,
0.0490623415,
-0.0029417942,
0.0014924846,
0.0291745625,
0.0031676081,
0.0598107129,
0.0003315463,
-0.0268794093,
0.009965945,
0.0392336436,
0.060851071,
-0.0421053544,
0.0320245624,
0.0570840128,
0.0415657163,
-0.032240022,
-0.0097499778,
0.026370842,
0.0351122171,
0.0522745438,
0.0450637154,
-0.0656037703,
0.017485071,
-0.0250716321,
0.0490305424,
0.0878416002,
0.0212196819,
-0.0153061012,
-0.0432707928,
-0.0108192917,
-0.0129532339,
-0.0099875377,
-0.0115903746,
0.0236003846,
0.0215487052,
-0.0087468233,
0.06283243,
0.0398436524,
-0.0536676943,
0.0169701036,
0.0250460282,
0.0196710732,
0.0309407227,
0.0281508379,
-0.0457061157,
-0.0215500835,
-0.0325234942,
0.0482505523,
0.0307251737,
0.0675329417,
-0.0430484526,
0.0045354832,
-0.0258511119,
-0.0219152663,
-0.0310210567,
0.0449121557,
-0.0141048878,
0.0081624277,
-0.0442186669,
0.0394395553,
-0.0465978198,
-0.0458092876,
0.0427966453,
-0.0062291864,
-0.0227197874,
-0.0152487876,
-0.009269014,
0.0003747166,
0.0387289338,
-0.0380076393,
0.0147904381,
0.011865152,
-0.0219590683,
-0.0104153892,
-0.0035142142,
-0.0138600357,
-0.0528121591,
0.0477641448,
-0.0588975176,
-0.032969147,
0.0314051285,
-0.0501100533,
-0.0346732326,
0.0053307856,
-0.0560239963,
-0.0349638388,
-0.0436636694,
-0.0074715964,
0.0329423286,
0.0015683114,
-0.0138524929,
0.0684638098,
0.025975626,
-0.0181468967,
0.0586524308,
-0.0565077513,
0.0051151854,
-0.025788568,
-0.020073548,
-0.0151182301,
-0.0038423745,
0.0255967155,
0.0657332987,
-0.0006502867,
-0.0528040119,
0.014370665,
-0.111899443,
0.0333831273,
-0.0483243875,
0.0069154738,
0.0402957611,
0.0084350407,
0.0012490198,
0.0007664838,
-0.0298965387,
-0.0399781652,
0.0040348289,
0.020778222,
0.0306058619,
0.0177550465,
0.0555257499,
-0.0661994219,
-0.0055203894,
-0.0016379076,
0.0349008404,
-0.0047405148,
-0.0254805181,
-0.0085277464,
0.0374616422,
-0.018295126,
-0.0117008807,
0.0121256551,
0.0027388225,
-0.0145695256,
-0.0010934699,
0.0552558191,
0.0384787731,
0.0400546491,
-0.0072166119,
0.0309534464,
0.0103838723,
-0.0313931257,
-0.0040321029,
-0.0272174124,
0.0130979139,
0.0203222092,
-0.0019246552,
0.0344704278,
0.0580961555,
0.0048467787,
0.0130241551,
-0.0370973535,
0.018184239,
-0.0435041524,
-0.0032333916,
-0.0598927513,
0.0119024245,
0.0010834076,
0.0414795354,
-0.054057911,
0.0229941327,
0.0775697753,
-0.0131338108,
0.0316707194,
-0.0415220298,
-0.0184980221,
-0.0360236764,
0.0169601217,
0.0067090997,
0.0149421999,
0.0273735523,
0.0208468717,
-0.0314944796,
-0.0062069795,
0.069572635,
-0.0123283733,
0.0873840004,
-0.0564997755,
0.0182649959,
-0.0451379642,
-0.0278325677,
-0.028994523,
-0.0762304068,
-0.0194706861,
0.0205268804,
0.0002326481,
0.0238911826,
-0.0344980843,
-0.0206870269,
0.0377495401,
0.0672349259,
-0.0177392233,
-0.0221375078,
-0.0052305101,
0.0622397028,
0.0693874061,
0.0112396255,
0.0346357189,
-0.0332938135,
0.018154623,
0.047615651,
0.0215305071,
0.0031136305,
-0.0049517085,
-0.0148637053,
-0.0251170993,
-0.0895036161,
0.0017025769,
0.0015733772,
0.0946166664,
-0.0356052294,
-0.0097110812,
0.1164360642,
0.0096673667,
-0.0151420385,
-0.0176613126,
0.0235442594,
0.022212632,
0.0081465608,
-0.0077495538,
-0.0618358739,
-0.0348632,
-0.0031608252,
0.0531340204,
0.0313535519,
-0.045793809,
0.0062818481,
-0.1133214682,
0.0050450624,
0.0055508045,
-0.0462878048,
-0.0226460434,
-0.0541504137,
0.0328921787,
-0.0446438789,
0.0232801717,
0.016290905,
-0.017250102,
0.0370828472,
0.0206598714,
-0.0559033938,
-0.0225026906,
-0.0030641977,
-0.0591052771,
0.0377692357,
0.0324238352,
0.0222685486,
0.0003086486,
0.0662616715,
0.0339267813,
-0.0210437961,
-0.0128613999,
0.0172005594,
0.1318594366,
-0.0184308961,
0.0084412657,
-0.0136706587,
0.048421979,
-0.0073616505,
-0.026375575,
0.0190772507,
0.0173466783,
0.0372891091,
-0.0266786423,
-0.0486461818,
0.0322220847,
-0.0272605754,
0.0925638452,
0.045696225,
-0.004862349,
-0.0315182917,
-0.0259836651,
-0.0124929547,
-0.0800363123,
-0.0435787328,
-0.0034431966,
-0.0097954338,
-0.01469504,
-0.0995191112,
-0.0848100334,
0.033075992,
-0.0195253883,
-0.0084313154,
-0.0219803192,
0.018157078,
0.0051173056,
-0.0448825881,
0.0010212194,
-0.0375053175,
-0.0038476393,
-0.0282575767,
-0.0027952001,
0.0294803567,
-0.0182443578,
-0.0123385889,
0.0265659206,
-0.0726982579,
-0.0612275377,
0.0037177238,
0.0695478618,
0.0163942482,
0.0505305044,
0.0013823075,
-0.0189270489,
0.0332748964,
0.0559644513,
-0.0266360007,
0.0286947358,
0.0141461957,
0.0245901849,
-0.0131047238,
0.0330896676,
-0.0789777935,
0.0554624647,
-0.0342698395,
0.0378041901,
-0.0079371557,
-0.0401842222,
0.0146347303,
0.0492206179,
0.0531473085,
-0.0292984359,
-0.0178802013,
-0.0260258932,
-0.0545116588,
-0.0167170465,
-0.0432169884,
0.0021834534,
0.0440243743,
-0.0252959505,
0.0133425305,
-0.0212983936,
0.0582405329,
-0.0100959223,
0.0261415504,
-0.0573869944,
-0.0342130363,
-0.0243118107,
-0.0132556465,
-0.0441445038,
-0.0082251038,
-0.0616034344,
-0.0443029702,
-0.0228383224,
0.0210976377,
-0.0291880462,
-0.007219404,
0.0340787508,
-0.0017580424,
0.0036440883,
0.0252794288,
-0.0868311524,
0.0485689417,
-0.0459992513,
0.0243176706,
0.0600497089,
-0.0648583546,
0.0690805614,
-0.0140142143,
-0.0258668978,
-0.0266087297,
0.0356326774,
0.0287560411,
0.0124408007,
-0.0482149944,
0.019755492,
-0.0103109656,
0.0054532634,
0.0807161629,
-0.0448710471,
0.0328798778,
0.0313461386,
-0.0052038152,
-0.0514623448,
-0.0432289504,
-0.0637699217,
0.0212833583,
0.005901726,
-0.0329901055,
-0.0677476823,
-0.0202796068,
0.0240047649,
0.0091310274,
0.0101677859,
-0.0107395966,
0.0351323485,
0.006357294,
0.0153332744,
0.0092874486,
-0.0508431904,
0.0001500627,
-0.0052206987,
0.0274068471,
-0.0321823657,
-6.113789098e-33,
-0.0370822214,
0.0104567064,
-0.0220361762,
0.0314182751,
-0.0193424467,
0.0180898868,
-0.0570774414,
0.0137479454,
-0.0195192117,
0.0299616642,
-0.0100628017,
0.0086656297,
0.0056840857,
0.0246850476,
0.001160688,
0.000701763,
0.058764182,
-0.0000885605,
-0.0847408846,
0.0311525278,
0.0389968567,
-0.0026980292,
0.0242717583,
-0.0499751419,
0.031256713,
-0.0136437705,
-0.026139982,
0.0104996553,
0.0504229143,
0.0020570199,
0.0091336854,
0.0409617685,
0.0309657212,
-0.0565356575,
-0.0205960646,
-0.0148177296,
-0.1065021008,
-0.0474649258,
0.0237779729,
-0.0450994,
-0.0469369069,
-0.0313496254,
0.0366591327,
-0.0148625756,
0.0092702359,
-0.0512997471,
0.0590499751,
-0.0438657366,
-0.0226371065,
-0.0708389804,
-0.0390732475,
0.0186004862,
-0.0204720628,
-0.0392874815,
0.0106994528,
0.0500384942,
0.0246960782,
0.0052636089,
-0.0370206274,
0.0370631814,
-0.0197262261,
0.041435454,
0.0168617312,
-0.0196099654,
-0.0129921576,
0.1001006812,
-0.0109830704,
0.0312996134,
-0.0428881682,
0.0019259092,
-0.0273910984,
0.0305129942,
0.0240578949,
0.068330586,
0.0241300482,
0.0278227609,
-0.0507946871,
0.0955431238,
-0.0017955274,
0.0159812532,
-0.001599088,
-0.0197382215,
-0.018015461,
-0.0164448991,
-0.0465916097,
0.0112767844,
-0.0010817565,
0.0194955841,
-0.0179067869,
0.0308070816,
-0.0432684422,
-0.0082282471,
-0.0029633464,
-0.030358728,
0.039029412,
0.0277595073,
-0.0312545523,
0.0124342693,
0.0127307288,
-0.0141360424,
-0.0412820466,
0.0278939269,
0.0089061772,
0.0317031406,
0.0157873183,
-0.0114587341,
0.0724996626,
-0.0009815861,
-0.0345752947,
0.0287492946,
-0.0001859848,
0.0345908105,
-0.0520267859,
-0.0006213388,
0.0005647001,
0.0379637517,
0.0064317677,
0.0219435561,
0.0133536477,
-0.0043795505,
-0.0103697423,
-0.0015024923,
0.0254188385,
0.0191734359,
-0.0043510203,
0.0258974899,
-0.0171863288,
0.0208910629,
0.0290563516,
-0.0346129909,
-0.0106050055,
-0.0063309986,
2.453e-7,
0.0452035367,
0.0476006903,
0.065412946,
0.0126909232,
-0.0234395526,
0.0447830781,
-0.0094289789,
0.0414837003,
0.016270984,
-0.021535201,
0.0153808286,
0.0379889533,
0.0527476147,
0.0328032263,
-0.0897891372,
-0.0369031616,
-0.048020266,
-0.0289897099,
-0.0196067337,
-0.0286794212,
0.049857825,
0.055239033,
-0.0056775981,
0.0014816452,
-0.00872037,
-0.0281412844,
0.0394188538,
-0.0200534742,
-0.0483791381,
0.0252373349,
0.0357183218,
0.0230401922,
-0.0125700664,
-0.0184451863,
-0.0327120945,
-0.0191056877,
0.0371276215,
0.0527908579,
0.0260095559,
-0.014323486,
-0.0120245116,
-0.0380619541,
0.0448409952,
0.0211058799,
0.0465609469,
-0.073268123,
0.0048701162,
-0.0297894832,
-0.0536292046,
0.0318466164,
-0.0129373977,
0.0030997894,
-0.031892959,
0.0378971733,
-0.0100974496,
0.0246932562,
-0.0197530147,
-0.0651254058,
-0.0616708212,
0.0263199303,
0.0058100652,
-0.0303232297,
0.0056356145,
-0.0102510201,
0.0050270269,
-0.0982024521,
0.0081155561,
2.037508695e-34,
0.0880816281,
-0.0286911894,
-0.0331959464,
-0.0254631713,
0.0214617159,
-0.0294281244,
-0.0421152264,
-0.0511211976,
0.0194215346,
-0.0444225706,
0.012829762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14293v2 | WebIE: Faithful and Robust Information Extraction on the Web | 2023-05-23T17:37:53 | 2023-06-15T13:51:36 | Chenxi Whitehouse, Clara Vania, Alham Fikri Aji, Christos Christodoulopoulos, Andrea Pierleoni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting structured and grounded fact triples from raw text is a
fundamental task in Information Extraction (IE). Existing IE datasets are
typically collected from Wikipedia articles, using hyperlinks to link entities
to the Wikidata knowledge base. However, models trained only on Wikipedia have
limitations when applied to web domains, which often contain noisy text or text
that does not have any factual information. We present WebIE, the first
large-scale, entity-linked closed IE dataset consisting of 1.6M sentences
automatically collected from the English Common Crawl corpus. WebIE also
includes negative examples, i.e. sentences without fact triples, to better
reflect the data on the web. We annotate ~21K triples from WebIE through
crowdsourcing and introduce mWebIE, a translation of the annotated set in four
other languages: French, Spanish, Portuguese, and Hindi. We evaluate the
in-domain, out-of-domain, and zero-shot cross-lingual performance of generative
IE models and find models trained on WebIE show better generalisability. We
also propose three training strategies that use entity linking as an auxiliary
task. Our experiments show that adding Entity-Linking objectives improves the
faithfulness of our generative IE models. | [
0.0588060655,
0.0310075469,
0.0089543546,
0.056023363,
-0.0289691631,
0.045398891,
-0.0374674648,
0.0015225761,
0.0223617144,
-0.061432384,
0.0023716963,
-0.0111564621,
-0.0283247977,
0.0004367798,
0.0366317444,
-0.0157364085,
0.0105611244,
0.0118895425,
0.0096913707,
0.0004448081,
0.0078621078,
0.0307938084,
-0.0156923402,
-0.0277025737,
-0.0402011424,
0.0440767929,
0.0070174802,
0.0054287519,
0.0525184348,
-0.0215414073,
0.0229073223,
0.0457840897,
-0.0133373104,
0.002541516,
0.0000016182,
-0.0660398901,
-0.0200245716,
-0.0096005071,
-0.0579485707,
0.0163147617,
-0.0301197767,
-0.0276601315,
-0.0162880365,
-0.0220255516,
-0.0207626875,
-0.0306078698,
0.0208062269,
0.0734112561,
0.0414719544,
0.0956033543,
-0.0157435741,
-0.0359611772,
0.0416158065,
-0.0061003007,
0.0139309159,
0.0076427595,
0.0464308858,
0.0236668475,
-0.0224395823,
0.0398387238,
0.0316556208,
0.0071706367,
0.0106464569,
0.0073420089,
0.0037603779,
0.0106117474,
-0.063297458,
-0.0443852916,
0.0217972789,
0.1136292294,
0.0017558913,
-0.0096837338,
0.0387701876,
0.0152584696,
-0.0024493989,
-0.0008012782,
-0.0295125041,
0.0315863937,
-0.0362303443,
0.014785843,
0.0094224131,
-0.0024430396,
0.0296474025,
-0.0017843297,
0.0092338566,
0.0397483893,
0.0099601122,
-0.0233970191,
0.0187221579,
0.0703208894,
-0.0060586305,
-0.0121915964,
0.0092579238,
-0.0028954176,
0.0434274264,
0.016188778,
-0.0200094283,
-0.0136022503,
0.0161686726,
-0.0572171584,
-0.0843544528,
-0.011841259,
-0.059303645,
0.0552743822,
-0.0391939655,
-0.0256274194,
-0.0280192271,
0.0045264354,
0.0198724046,
-0.0206819642,
-0.0143202692,
0.0429338142,
-0.0022834593,
0.0392450541,
-0.0189937521,
0.0305644777,
-0.0155534912,
-0.0206110999,
-0.0005094375,
0.0535755083,
0.0340507254,
-0.0369292721,
-0.041073516,
-0.0164750554,
-0.010521465,
0.0192979816,
-0.0349373072,
0.0317508131,
0.0009672111,
-0.0580925457,
-0.0142785339,
0.0012444304,
0.036447987,
-0.0443056412,
0.0152145345,
0.0454924479,
0.0024596774,
-0.0107658803,
-0.084414266,
-0.0412466936,
0.0289522279,
-0.0566224046,
-0.0184458885,
-0.0672635734,
0.0541889779,
0.0063843583,
-0.0177607853,
-0.0600170903,
0.0390399173,
0.0029918393,
-0.0390856154,
0.0750463679,
-0.039677985,
-0.0446658246,
-0.0018768383,
0.0092781745,
0.0293134078,
0.0722242668,
0.0252459142,
0.0256189425,
0.084710665,
0.064098075,
-0.0109250639,
0.0304945819,
0.0562840961,
0.0044557005,
0.0856918693,
0.023780223,
0.0043246485,
-0.0108438116,
0.0264667254,
0.0481694937,
-0.0105093848,
-0.008851924,
0.0393299051,
-0.0449680649,
-0.0285568517,
0.0360846967,
0.053041555,
-0.0063265753,
0.0421905331,
0.0323605239,
-0.0710941777,
-0.0231954195,
-0.0307917576,
0.0451132841,
-0.0106197316,
0.0539387614,
-0.0025804869,
-0.0126646655,
-0.0250501148,
-0.0191429947,
0.0017634059,
-0.0124577666,
0.0823832527,
0.0155286547,
-0.0349789336,
0.0413933992,
0.0611229464,
-0.0450915657,
0.0316398777,
0.0152040906,
0.0056687952,
0.0255401693,
0.0125675034,
-0.0312711522,
-0.0358123183,
-0.0159171894,
0.0160947703,
0.0476017967,
-0.0057488182,
-0.0715277717,
0.0232148394,
-0.0243425276,
-0.0493080989,
0.0386633351,
-0.0064720362,
-0.0213731546,
0.0467338413,
0.0185050536,
0.0490464084,
-0.0658744052,
0.0097515117,
0.0479958057,
-0.023205515,
-0.0106646689,
-0.0274512153,
0.027891228,
-0.005199458,
0.0339292549,
-0.0113242846,
-0.0469241478,
0.0504912585,
-0.0254176445,
-0.0089703575,
-0.0001364154,
0.0117167607,
-0.0555804744,
0.0369863026,
-0.03908512,
-0.022308426,
0.0318517908,
-0.0382929444,
-0.0066370573,
-0.0520426594,
0.0224751048,
0.0302466303,
-0.0274515934,
0.0012907212,
0.052267611,
0.0243708361,
-0.0117234299,
0.0857818201,
-0.0109952632,
-0.0421839692,
0.0096239829,
-0.0637976527,
0.0156398881,
-0.0396869592,
-0.0195662603,
0.0250053983,
0.021956047,
0.0108124008,
0.0318791308,
0.0277755987,
-0.0723130628,
0.0208661444,
-0.0610013977,
0.0184726845,
-0.0256408248,
0.0651608631,
0.0227831025,
0.0054740533,
-0.0164923798,
-0.0095190555,
-0.0303230658,
-0.019638937,
-0.0318493247,
-0.0164349843,
0.0521722846,
0.049067013,
0.0133578498,
-0.0414404534,
-0.0126272244,
-0.0188021716,
0.0204168819,
0.0189256966,
-0.0432840884,
-0.0299300998,
0.0223804843,
-0.0444541872,
0.0205941964,
-0.0078050476,
0.0030452246,
-0.0659944937,
-0.003802568,
0.0346142165,
0.0368281975,
-0.0117774829,
0.018844638,
-0.0117786964,
0.0058931885,
-0.0176714379,
0.007908131,
-0.0357091241,
0.0532064438,
-0.0230884384,
-0.0070946328,
0.0396468826,
-0.003111965,
0.0112153431,
-0.0117768021,
-0.0137045542,
0.0186876003,
0.0125431409,
0.0154610444,
-0.0342703834,
0.0448436737,
-0.0038027426,
0.0370588377,
-0.0313438401,
-0.0047381087,
0.0623483248,
-0.0146330083,
0.0300557204,
-0.0156290252,
0.0086904289,
-0.0135836704,
0.025716804,
-0.0184435528,
0.006918163,
0.0239526723,
-0.0034890096,
-0.0236654095,
0.0278971475,
0.0585639067,
-0.011854345,
0.0284963977,
-0.030105304,
0.0306202509,
-0.0159296468,
-0.035236191,
-0.0494963415,
-0.0326057412,
-0.0045303488,
-0.0057939244,
-0.0133753233,
-0.0039603859,
-0.0194461253,
-0.0228597652,
0.0303884912,
0.0175194759,
-0.0022740215,
-0.0268995464,
0.0062557249,
0.0497794487,
0.0580617562,
0.0047175428,
0.0188978035,
0.0105284257,
-0.0155391879,
0.0524195954,
-0.0075928769,
-0.0164881274,
0.034519501,
0.0025923427,
0.0123614809,
-0.0580861904,
-0.0061411094,
-0.0337669142,
0.0268540513,
-0.0255964231,
-0.0218350962,
0.0929755121,
0.0283495821,
0.0071372823,
-0.0076271961,
0.0024312653,
0.0191980284,
-0.0015676762,
-0.0004095672,
-0.069464162,
-0.0067866095,
-0.0037134716,
0.0039108591,
0.0105357934,
-0.0193403028,
0.0157366153,
-0.1211415678,
0.0050784857,
-0.0102028307,
0.0242247339,
-0.0517437384,
-0.0623123311,
0.0307755433,
-0.0586893074,
-0.0169708338,
0.0250629336,
0.0039795334,
0.0232911687,
0.0185936522,
0.01506624,
-0.0857276767,
0.0143308714,
-0.0509182289,
0.016139973,
0.0053842054,
0.0094930278,
0.0016657547,
-0.0260638073,
0.0302310549,
-0.0337153971,
-0.0596669726,
-0.0167393424,
0.0912141427,
-0.0435562655,
-0.0085270004,
-0.0284146611,
0.0377599075,
-0.0279835146,
-0.0008040128,
0.0121101048,
0.0818651244,
0.0305019543,
0.0298758689,
0.0112117995,
-0.067357026,
-0.0064644823,
0.0705207661,
0.0100949872,
-0.0087922635,
0.0032708035,
-0.0272971001,
-0.0283614807,
-0.0451533571,
-0.0703692734,
0.0372124389,
-0.0632886142,
-0.0435695015,
-0.1218714565,
-0.0871030465,
0.0193836726,
0.0601818375,
0.0079443585,
-0.0343195088,
0.0152790667,
0.0176264644,
-0.051270172,
0.0006591463,
-0.0335826278,
-0.0244131517,
-0.0195796527,
-0.0110424394,
0.0414796583,
-0.044725135,
-0.0302172676,
-0.000443821,
-0.0739766061,
-0.0453755893,
0.0088663353,
0.0226608999,
0.0181038901,
0.0460924357,
-0.0302519388,
0.0101690283,
0.0131694563,
0.049513381,
-0.0621037185,
-0.029349504,
0.0487902649,
0.0065460908,
0.0258170422,
0.0465081371,
-0.0651884302,
0.0241124965,
0.0151235042,
0.0537546203,
-0.0436001532,
-0.0425770469,
0.0317810141,
0.0676938444,
0.0762283728,
-0.0238317698,
-0.0007644614,
-0.0570224151,
0.0021921634,
-0.0321615674,
-0.0110027259,
-0.0127516259,
0.047118973,
0.0146143055,
0.0174497459,
-0.0294266641,
0.0394311994,
0.0015053925,
0.0098168049,
-0.0537756681,
-0.0332455523,
0.0154986661,
0.0279980898,
-0.0033016154,
-0.0376888216,
-0.0201396812,
-0.0005750563,
0.0259166416,
0.0096745826,
-0.0582605153,
-0.0065673105,
0.0240105614,
-0.036424987,
0.0006234666,
0.0154136252,
-0.0080402177,
0.0794236287,
-0.0585756153,
0.0200453009,
0.0472813807,
-0.0209710393,
0.0781933963,
-0.0200677849,
-0.0455947071,
0.0100063449,
0.0412453413,
-0.0036259587,
0.015125758,
0.0051731667,
0.0046880618,
-0.0466051698,
0.03231005,
0.0622205958,
-0.0201997235,
0.0478852391,
0.0097420169,
-0.020237742,
-0.060926903,
-0.0087890495,
-0.0546002649,
-0.026995426,
0.0006878827,
-0.0209234767,
-0.0460512638,
-0.0542334989,
0.003117901,
0.0135282744,
-0.0031117334,
0.0190126449,
0.0247574393,
0.0590352751,
0.0207502525,
-0.0328856781,
-0.0219027977,
0.019733252,
0.003026468,
-0.0068954551,
-0.0256205741,
-6.124102959e-33,
-0.02909863,
-0.0073796767,
-0.0136540746,
0.0149979973,
-0.0175426304,
-0.0173813514,
-0.0141245686,
-0.0145134358,
-0.0559131168,
0.0215919185,
0.0189682227,
-0.0102483984,
0.0246968623,
0.0200198088,
-0.0205412582,
-0.028430732,
0.047417298,
0.0248323772,
-0.0441241339,
0.0089118946,
0.0690344647,
0.0290637724,
0.1014233083,
-0.0946897194,
0.0541133508,
-0.0360961296,
-0.0293000694,
0.0295238085,
0.0678632036,
0.0498488881,
-0.0100668818,
0.0491656177,
0.0127339736,
-0.0605720654,
0.0242642835,
-0.0436812602,
-0.1558095217,
-0.0148697533,
0.0079674153,
0.0206450634,
-0.0068363193,
-0.0128789824,
0.0319555402,
-0.0260937717,
0.0398291983,
-0.0105093159,
0.0512823127,
-0.0268582143,
0.0073193563,
-0.0732865483,
-0.0720639005,
0.0430436246,
0.021724714,
0.0367252156,
-0.0060298159,
0.0338951759,
0.008582606,
-0.0019072529,
-0.0661530793,
-0.0119533464,
-0.0300207064,
0.0176771376,
0.0447415188,
-0.039726451,
0.0107806763,
0.0604308248,
-0.0256827474,
-0.0144823585,
-0.0555070341,
0.0285939276,
0.0012773629,
0.0258590505,
-0.0040927827,
0.1036398783,
-0.0136214988,
-0.0186365116,
-0.117928043,
0.0589309819,
-0.0013122838,
0.0112587158,
-0.0649289712,
-0.0193163194,
-0.0578238666,
0.0153396772,
0.0086092781,
0.0094600786,
0.0021782261,
-0.0314019956,
0.0093906643,
-0.016206976,
-0.0749327242,
0.0347582735,
-0.0013816328,
0.0107822251,
-0.0071749748,
0.0569388568,
-0.0429876372,
0.0120497756,
-0.0062029618,
-0.0386842266,
-0.0639258847,
-0.027096577,
-0.0099306423,
0.0433221124,
0.010267619,
-0.0047982563,
0.0700865015,
0.000276539,
-0.0581338741,
0.0083847838,
-0.0308665037,
0.0289075188,
0.0104223508,
0.0237710029,
0.0206461828,
0.0119253574,
-0.0323708653,
-0.0031117275,
0.060545668,
0.0106828148,
-0.0154233444,
0.0252460577,
0.0144097181,
0.0170356762,
-0.0047444343,
-0.0078383693,
-0.0149947107,
0.0015830252,
-0.0145851271,
-0.0751180649,
-0.0061624018,
-0.0122143179,
2.46e-7,
0.013436174,
0.0251005255,
0.0532402471,
0.0182643421,
-0.0175462402,
0.0105642118,
0.0218704026,
0.0266285855,
-0.0295429174,
-0.0735133588,
0.0000281954,
0.0004499294,
0.0125507386,
0.034483999,
-0.0692044199,
0.0069155362,
-0.0056370827,
-0.0542827211,
-0.0280631967,
-0.0270099808,
0.0374195948,
0.0659747273,
0.0532994866,
0.017439682,
-0.0240569338,
-0.0258026365,
0.0341181196,
0.0143611738,
-0.0415944792,
0.0123388767,
0.0607861653,
0.0295915361,
-0.0143328439,
0.025031643,
-0.0305813812,
0.0216311812,
0.0422959514,
0.0636922866,
0.0302193109,
0.0249879584,
-0.0284400638,
-0.0813033953,
0.0361411609,
-0.0056030103,
0.0692016408,
0.0172325373,
0.0107875764,
0.0329186283,
-0.0264695603,
0.0161370058,
-0.0155814299,
-0.0327004865,
-0.0252960157,
0.049858015,
0.0161255952,
-0.0081815254,
-0.0218620636,
-0.0301395282,
-0.0244894493,
0.0139463795,
-0.0050193877,
-0.0432450138,
0.055706203,
-0.0305842739,
0.0021046612,
-0.0395918489,
0.0115112755,
2.031138985e-34,
0.0138030993,
-0.0080172252,
-0.0240846183,
0.0021481351,
0.0387530923,
-0.0158903208,
-0.0413856469,
-0.048937697,
-0.0001085235,
-0.0119112292,
0.0118704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14292v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14292v2 | WikiChat: Stopping the Hallucination of Large Language Model Chatbots by Few-Shot Grounding on Wikipedia | 2023-05-23T17:37:36 | 2023-10-27T19:11:55 | Sina J. Semnani, Violet Z. Yao, Heidi C. Zhang, Monica S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the first few-shot LLM-based chatbot that almost never
hallucinates and has high conversationality and low latency. WikiChat is
grounded on the English Wikipedia, the largest curated free-text corpus.
WikiChat generates a response from an LLM, retains only the grounded facts,
and combines them with additional information it retrieves from the corpus to
form factual and engaging responses. We distill WikiChat based on GPT-4 into a
7B-parameter LLaMA model with minimal loss of quality, to significantly improve
its latency, cost and privacy, and facilitate research and deployment.
Using a novel hybrid human-and-LLM evaluation methodology, we show that our
best system achieves 97.3% factual accuracy in simulated conversations. It
significantly outperforms all retrieval-based and LLM-based baselines, and by
3.9%, 38.6% and 51.0% on head, tail and recent knowledge compared to GPT-4.
Compared to previous state-of-the-art retrieval-based chatbots, WikiChat is
also significantly more informative and engaging, just like an LLM.
WikiChat achieves 97.9% factual accuracy in conversations with human users
about recent topics, 55.0% better than GPT-4, while receiving significantly
higher user ratings and more favorable comments. | [
0.0614376366,
0.0062635099,
0.0012131645,
0.0248511285,
-0.0271883011,
0.0042420588,
-0.0225223619,
0.0197915491,
0.0739765018,
-0.0385411792,
-0.0250377227,
-0.0184850488,
-0.0171832684,
-0.0082941139,
0.0143283857,
-0.0270036124,
0.0528742373,
-0.0010850999,
-0.003726583,
-0.0362257138,
0.0188875012,
-0.001750911,
-0.0480746217,
0.0387289375,
-0.0311879106,
-0.0097944345,
-0.0330776796,
-0.0029276381,
0.0159771387,
-0.0058230883,
0.0252074618,
0.0487310775,
0.0158290043,
0.0467162095,
0.0000020344,
-0.0378821902,
0.0020991585,
-0.0183616262,
-0.0426066145,
-0.0028755812,
0.0310201831,
0.0258292984,
-0.0122229308,
0.0270209815,
-0.047392115,
0.0489493236,
0.0315527841,
0.0731832013,
0.0860041007,
0.0852891952,
-0.0022739007,
-0.0300407112,
0.0468446873,
0.0108350785,
0.0818012953,
-0.0368619934,
0.0122947684,
0.0170598719,
0.005910181,
0.0039290991,
0.0031702109,
0.0211763233,
0.0054679122,
-0.0173716769,
0.0389960296,
0.0389722176,
-0.072182864,
-0.0449781828,
0.0020172659,
0.090109013,
0.0514708087,
-0.0260615777,
0.0109012909,
0.0380736403,
0.0224441625,
0.0032671236,
-0.0613526851,
-0.0027446921,
-0.0077874553,
0.0099642947,
-0.0242326632,
-0.0252510607,
0.0130113084,
0.0383727886,
-0.0147050191,
0.0714186132,
0.014814835,
-0.0225734133,
0.0055550491,
0.0232242476,
0.0304044448,
-0.0571099296,
0.0212432947,
0.0566649251,
-0.0320749879,
0.0078551574,
-0.0283792056,
0.0198550895,
0.051668711,
-0.0827680975,
-0.0601940751,
0.044912383,
-0.0320494212,
0.0622816682,
0.0021750708,
0.0205058735,
-0.0184404142,
0.0296749379,
0.0151373772,
-0.0113349902,
-0.0427461639,
-0.0026226393,
0.0013982777,
0.0537294298,
0.0016476936,
-0.0302177817,
-0.0261674821,
0.0361211225,
0.0205238163,
0.0202962141,
-0.0206077099,
0.0078218607,
-0.0295338146,
-0.0041034962,
-0.043033246,
0.01853057,
-0.0436593331,
0.0134369852,
0.0165789556,
-0.074807696,
-0.0289800912,
0.0199532378,
-0.004795494,
-0.0079446556,
0.0192497652,
0.0432446897,
0.0239422992,
-0.0286759548,
-0.0195288546,
-0.0316501781,
0.0054907729,
-0.0692063421,
-0.0035811632,
-0.0640478879,
0.0366643704,
0.0010078921,
-0.0175651964,
-0.0391129404,
0.03180895,
0.0428534634,
-0.0182367805,
0.0653422847,
-0.0469935536,
-0.0045253769,
0.0526481569,
0.0344791748,
-0.036799293,
0.0629971251,
0.0116719725,
0.043667715,
0.0553252958,
0.0165902339,
0.0213256925,
0.0174867492,
0.0183864608,
0.0013164522,
0.0249400195,
0.0082067885,
-0.0289651025,
0.0296470411,
0.0180618595,
0.0418502204,
-0.0375448316,
-0.0048758588,
0.0769463703,
0.0705115125,
-0.0463451892,
0.0117479973,
-0.0129197948,
0.0168379247,
0.0465233587,
0.0067578852,
-0.0745564327,
0.0368758738,
-0.0545081012,
-0.0188129954,
0.0454285629,
0.0003168222,
-0.0295316204,
-0.0142294699,
0.0236637797,
-0.0305178203,
0.035042692,
-0.0133232782,
0.017007729,
-0.0202855989,
-0.0382842869,
0.103234753,
0.0354158171,
-0.0603429824,
-0.0248293709,
-0.0511120446,
0.0328975171,
0.0727606416,
0.0529654622,
-0.0199634675,
-0.0423873626,
-0.0128738834,
0.0362471119,
0.0889033601,
0.0200796388,
0.0039149974,
-0.0044879792,
-0.0354273729,
-0.02416992,
-0.0086397249,
0.0151554951,
0.0024814152,
0.0276044253,
0.032621678,
0.0121918675,
-0.0467772484,
0.020057898,
0.0396594889,
-0.0231161397,
0.0074589611,
-0.0578621738,
-0.0112311337,
0.0220081173,
0.041725684,
-0.0000527184,
0.0150599098,
0.0374147892,
-0.0205565132,
-0.0401881784,
0.0000234244,
-0.0124864075,
-0.0289603658,
0.0578941554,
-0.0174975209,
-0.001572585,
0.0627245978,
-0.0065006893,
-0.0283117983,
-0.0113580311,
-0.0501312166,
0.0607531704,
-0.0388298295,
-0.005716193,
-0.0155076254,
0.041233819,
-0.0117055345,
0.0552224927,
-0.0177893825,
-0.0195380077,
0.0240318719,
-0.0193109419,
-0.0163248051,
-0.034555871,
-0.0302279051,
0.0273261573,
0.0229333751,
0.0173563138,
0.0223326273,
-0.0010313645,
-0.08850611,
-0.0035155516,
-0.1216690019,
0.0051462227,
-0.024146501,
0.0039645745,
0.0176467691,
-0.0193619598,
-0.0067594666,
-0.0162705984,
-0.0556169041,
0.0116589824,
-0.0002236935,
0.0356238075,
0.0307768676,
-0.0035378269,
-0.0307510849,
-0.0456806496,
0.024154136,
0.0157519933,
-0.0009594457,
-0.0010991512,
-0.0408776887,
-0.0502964966,
0.0513411947,
-0.0698892921,
0.013833642,
-0.0210025422,
-0.0429893546,
0.0357143879,
-0.0141523564,
0.0087663084,
0.0487809256,
0.0452831835,
0.0106378216,
0.0296440311,
0.0057213372,
-0.0783657208,
0.0038032185,
0.0012843909,
-0.0106084589,
-0.0256143026,
0.0019710064,
-0.004469634,
0.0011146181,
0.0051008458,
0.0267654266,
-0.0646358356,
0.0388173088,
0.0279048029,
-0.0302828196,
-0.0149447005,
0.0033567396,
-0.04335941,
0.0408940911,
-0.0211448502,
-0.0342667401,
0.0703706071,
-0.0253486261,
0.0090827169,
0.001530488,
0.00570687,
0.0035225805,
0.0061348318,
-0.0217079408,
0.0087908693,
-0.0241646841,
-0.0150266523,
-0.0294208936,
0.0148667339,
0.0060577816,
-0.0811187401,
0.0337912068,
0.0102850106,
0.0238913056,
0.00534104,
-0.0194339808,
-0.0664993748,
-0.0454869159,
-0.0288793556,
-0.0268794354,
-0.0261295363,
-0.0146330614,
-0.0355754793,
-0.0057670772,
0.0420899726,
0.0002978184,
-0.0155248046,
-0.0135282129,
0.0028492063,
-0.0085342592,
0.0320536755,
0.0255890619,
0.0379962176,
0.0059325509,
0.0634786487,
0.0777199715,
0.0535767525,
-0.0049067517,
0.0155647397,
-0.0385599956,
0.0092242202,
-0.022891771,
-0.0452592857,
-0.0082201865,
0.0563980266,
-0.0396919101,
-0.0090264697,
0.1260817945,
0.0130136283,
-0.0779982731,
-0.0156577621,
-0.0554208532,
0.016601244,
0.0113398228,
0.0172012262,
-0.0651473254,
-0.0277734622,
0.0303647853,
0.0460514985,
-0.0012243632,
-0.0531657524,
-0.0028274492,
-0.1055967286,
0.0034660196,
0.0033394175,
-0.0058219708,
-0.0418030843,
-0.0560546368,
0.0083075687,
-0.0000083628,
0.0336562246,
0.0279347729,
0.0328058228,
-0.010348456,
-0.0075821858,
-0.0207832158,
-0.0236935299,
0.0557802431,
-0.021475628,
0.0818033218,
0.0484589487,
0.059696734,
-0.006908596,
-0.0355443358,
0.0042739981,
0.0047247922,
-0.0100748651,
0.0116080502,
0.0564875044,
-0.0209073257,
-0.0009198812,
-0.0458130687,
0.0280423183,
-0.0133468807,
-0.0146728856,
-0.0046873456,
0.0435427576,
-0.0463120863,
0.0215463713,
-0.0265906081,
0.0308178309,
0.0195356533,
0.0712542757,
0.0358458459,
-0.0267723501,
-0.0141436365,
-0.043394804,
0.0012051475,
-0.003675042,
-0.0955291986,
-0.0084533505,
0.0038535791,
-0.0069258641,
-0.1033577025,
-0.0550925434,
-0.004986254,
0.0095651643,
-0.0130456286,
0.0378083736,
-0.0012995827,
0.0017374929,
-0.0034091661,
0.01397081,
-0.0572888628,
-0.0008482909,
-0.041168917,
0.017037224,
0.045255471,
-0.0354385786,
0.0124893328,
0.0079243816,
-0.0579824746,
-0.064104192,
0.014966025,
0.0475871488,
0.0240635332,
0.0321919881,
-0.0144625828,
-0.0351406857,
0.0480315126,
0.0682994798,
-0.0352120176,
0.0183904152,
0.0270741228,
0.0715859383,
0.0038922841,
0.0446503311,
-0.0733798295,
-0.0166013166,
-0.0379328169,
0.0322197564,
-0.024412496,
-0.0267842375,
0.0264943074,
0.0402605049,
0.034388043,
-0.0066157561,
0.0021947445,
-0.0032739195,
0.0093257157,
-0.0410210565,
-0.0003751512,
-0.0079752393,
0.0011999244,
-0.0040733111,
-0.0556625277,
0.0246192366,
0.0037363118,
-0.0495884307,
0.0358548574,
-0.0376569256,
-0.0218913704,
-0.015447801,
-0.0260220598,
0.011655435,
-0.0091911657,
-0.0448565073,
-0.0027011277,
0.0226140134,
0.0315039009,
-0.0222946908,
0.0478669964,
-0.0044554123,
-0.0470023863,
0.0138155362,
0.0473094769,
-0.0736723319,
-0.0607560389,
-0.0016476655,
0.0662254766,
0.0488277264,
0.0502575673,
0.0635867193,
-0.0236758683,
-0.0015730568,
-0.0029645225,
0.0092496453,
0.0152766434,
0.0009959593,
0.0164514761,
0.0232843701,
-0.0164108053,
0.0150225647,
0.0475217141,
-0.0259645395,
0.0570165813,
0.0084915031,
-0.019662628,
-0.0358537585,
-0.0446834378,
-0.0267487355,
0.0041403039,
-0.0157099012,
-0.0253622644,
-0.0565233901,
-0.0535790808,
0.0054649054,
-0.0184072237,
-0.0465226844,
-0.0237773415,
0.0359879695,
0.0504702628,
-0.0016908852,
-0.0073367287,
-0.041948393,
0.0063463748,
-0.0138333142,
-0.0085412655,
0.016811071,
-6.722388441e-33,
-0.0426514,
-0.0365850739,
0.0140930088,
0.0281877052,
-0.0483430959,
-0.0230275597,
-0.0252277795,
0.0290337019,
-0.0432527959,
0.0020031796,
-0.0233076084,
0.0471401997,
0.0195045136,
-0.0225247946,
-0.0190583803,
-0.0275072847,
0.0251802988,
-0.0148121277,
-0.0329667144,
0.0324255601,
0.0343943834,
0.0404913723,
0.0340824984,
-0.0530576631,
0.057859242,
-0.0349698141,
-0.0148288123,
0.011745505,
-0.0048628352,
0.0388831273,
-0.0329653323,
0.0749914274,
0.0129542481,
-0.0230261572,
-0.0134030227,
0.0140116494,
-0.0420755856,
-0.0414612852,
0.006645557,
0.0069829924,
0.0174584184,
-0.0304845329,
0.0581270754,
-0.0361142978,
-0.0183042753,
0.0105045186,
0.0210002977,
-0.0264603905,
-0.001818553,
0.0249407925,
-0.028504381,
0.0031269311,
0.0080505731,
-0.0430449396,
-0.0176142864,
0.0534220226,
0.0249219034,
0.0182043444,
-0.1061602756,
0.0342271253,
-0.0379598252,
-0.0168060195,
0.0422121882,
-0.0491554514,
0.0331057534,
0.083773084,
0.0251894966,
0.0252202973,
-0.0766763613,
-0.0356564,
0.0204550587,
0.0324352272,
0.0404502936,
0.0642175823,
0.0013249409,
-0.030044632,
-0.0728257969,
0.0507112294,
0.0351846479,
0.0795573518,
0.0233768895,
0.0113379564,
-0.0583811179,
0.0009698457,
-0.0113008954,
0.0093461396,
-0.0317387246,
-0.0524393842,
0.0130326888,
0.0043732184,
-0.0391041152,
-0.0789568275,
0.0253266543,
-0.0431295112,
0.0065138624,
0.0557203665,
-0.0290259868,
-0.0073943348,
-0.0096727964,
-0.0127266394,
-0.02500722,
-0.001614362,
0.0131087489,
-0.0096699297,
0.0195218436,
0.016760271,
-0.0294339228,
0.0199976079,
-0.0401700586,
-0.0077399253,
-0.0324592628,
0.0055709928,
0.0128403287,
-0.0268675759,
0.021187311,
-0.0147242984,
-0.0102638062,
0.044702597,
0.0287527479,
0.0165698025,
-0.0152938245,
-0.0457749739,
0.0035681375,
-0.0033664221,
-0.0396438316,
0.0128666172,
-0.023028601,
0.0449526533,
0.0028479057,
-0.0602167435,
-0.0225785524,
-0.0401886627,
2.806e-7,
-0.0023613935,
0.0514695607,
-0.007528503,
0.0325225666,
0.0160302315,
0.0421460532,
-0.0047473991,
0.0423428454,
-0.0142184105,
-0.0911841765,
-0.0136946952,
0.047901433,
0.0449162908,
0.0334217362,
-0.1011357978,
-0.0546035729,
-0.0374135114,
-0.0253010411,
-0.0425804332,
-0.0378004499,
0.0540929772,
0.053374853,
0.025955243,
-0.0227107853,
-0.0057960302,
-0.038215965,
0.0646147281,
-0.0248128381,
-0.0322862715,
-0.0065534604,
0.069290325,
0.0405247025,
0.0214357432,
0.0096602794,
0.0103792101,
0.0046475115,
0.0101541262,
0.0567942671,
-0.0098247146,
-0.0862024799,
0.0075942245,
-0.0172818005,
0.019151777,
-0.0420151278,
0.0755596086,
0.0077579273,
-0.0381607078,
0.0046802936,
-0.0278839823,
-0.032846909,
0.0513131022,
-0.0419530347,
-0.0312290695,
0.0009581482,
-0.0182052627,
0.0212400276,
-0.0019737971,
-0.0690912828,
-0.0209670831,
-0.0394118875,
-0.063346155,
-0.0737312958,
-0.0127289528,
-0.0409099832,
-0.0208825525,
-0.0369600467,
0.0253235847,
2.240574885e-34,
0.0182061344,
0.007677882,
0.0211875066,
0.0725040361,
0.017681947,
0.0222954955,
0.0458886176,
-0.0019850447,
0.0276543926,
-0.048529163,
-0.0050713252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14291v2 | Evaluation of African American Language Bias in Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-23T17:34:37 | 2023-11-13T01:41:43 | Nicholas Deas, Jessi Grieser, Shana Kleiner, Desmond Patton, Elsbeth Turcan, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL | We evaluate how well LLMs understand African American Language (AAL) in
comparison to their performance on White Mainstream English (WME), the
encouraged "standard" form of English taught in American classrooms. We measure
LLM performance using automatic metrics and human judgments for two tasks: a
counterpart generation task, where a model generates AAL (or WME) given WME (or
AAL), and a masked span prediction (MSP) task, where models predict a phrase
that was removed from their input. Our contributions include: (1) evaluation of
six pre-trained, large language models on the two language generation tasks;
(2) a novel dataset of AAL text from multiple contexts (social media, hip-hop
lyrics, focus groups, and linguistic interviews) with human-annotated
counterparts in WME; and (3) documentation of model performance gaps that
suggest bias and identification of trends in lack of understanding of AAL
features. | [
0.0252589211,
0.0603318214,
-0.0221147016,
0.0166938137,
-0.0080141639,
0.0318971686,
0.0256532636,
-0.0355070867,
-0.0006988579,
-0.0625968128,
-0.0264091063,
-0.0544336364,
0.0104641514,
0.0148248849,
0.0358423963,
-0.0091376733,
0.0088259922,
0.0524566956,
0.037723314,
-0.0307907145,
-0.0136216516,
0.0535265952,
0.0099188602,
0.0548388548,
-0.0511160977,
0.0151177803,
0.0260122288,
0.0079861386,
-0.019531738,
-0.0200335868,
0.0184174199,
0.0754924119,
-0.0400037579,
0.0095199812,
0.0000018831,
-0.0815324858,
0.0140603073,
-0.0402714983,
-0.0151081579,
-0.0068050325,
0.0338860154,
0.005409467,
-0.0118928384,
0.0343585648,
-0.0589171946,
0.0262720529,
0.021506371,
-0.0013936416,
0.0283430032,
0.0329345055,
0.0127734654,
0.0063893776,
-0.0015010074,
-0.0153194144,
0.0169202331,
-0.0185996685,
0.0319347084,
-0.01276566,
-0.012730591,
-0.0653900579,
-0.0260235872,
0.0082489122,
0.0260317381,
-0.0091998708,
0.0556452125,
0.0159435309,
-0.0468657725,
-0.0332332812,
-0.017975498,
0.0308776926,
-0.0040035043,
-0.0059614684,
0.0040622926,
0.0079474226,
0.0013448016,
-0.016159974,
-0.0164401382,
0.0570217445,
0.0235361271,
0.0081749605,
-0.0295316316,
-0.0275701694,
0.0380730629,
0.0500876978,
0.018310871,
0.0850167423,
0.0388852619,
-0.0180043001,
0.0005301797,
0.0571292825,
0.0291609615,
-0.0849186778,
0.0326573253,
-0.015901437,
-0.0640441552,
0.0378708839,
-0.0112848906,
-0.0335301645,
-0.0006010805,
-0.0101046804,
0.0434216149,
0.0253174435,
-0.0178914666,
-0.050162822,
-0.0356772803,
0.0257846564,
0.0184140019,
0.0169631001,
-0.0136835286,
0.0268305987,
0.0263416413,
-0.0351250246,
0.0006862754,
0.0246666707,
-0.0139029911,
0.0260265172,
-0.0639593899,
-0.0276261177,
-0.0324249715,
-0.0027966069,
-0.0210998394,
0.0178180039,
-0.0359124728,
0.0082512572,
-0.0023993868,
-0.0174570493,
0.0008140358,
0.0412722751,
0.0270020496,
-0.0889297426,
0.0181670338,
-0.0104388492,
-0.0011805866,
-0.0225626156,
0.0036326353,
0.0277126692,
-0.0109762009,
-0.0472700894,
-0.1130230129,
-0.0656443387,
-0.0474105701,
-0.0471327528,
-0.047895059,
-0.0787582994,
0.0058366228,
-0.0016812108,
0.0156763513,
-0.0395604409,
-0.0160966516,
0.0259920452,
-0.0023436276,
0.0175384153,
0.0173818767,
0.0224502236,
0.0690377206,
0.0260145944,
0.046446301,
0.0514271334,
0.0431543812,
0.0208101943,
0.0417804867,
-0.023314422,
-0.0462705232,
0.0405024402,
0.0214138366,
-0.0009954341,
-0.0251978841,
-0.0334529467,
-0.0170748085,
0.0317808762,
0.0409044735,
0.0646690801,
0.014335514,
-0.0379396342,
0.0531021282,
0.086283654,
-0.0247133151,
0.0541676432,
0.101281926,
0.0346026197,
0.0093368012,
0.0341668427,
-0.0455420017,
0.0079544773,
-0.0346325971,
-0.036583472,
0.0571051128,
0.0893613622,
-0.0251617711,
-0.0313104726,
-0.0325099342,
-0.0127897896,
0.0065701469,
-0.0047528027,
-0.0359936543,
0.0480766706,
-0.0337817073,
0.0665839761,
0.0381872617,
-0.0487986654,
0.0290267356,
-0.0562520251,
0.0306403171,
0.0510653295,
0.0044423193,
0.0577103421,
0.0200664792,
-0.0275264084,
-0.0161515586,
0.0716781393,
0.0143191256,
-0.012022269,
0.0083493646,
-0.0332893208,
0.0066414359,
0.0046824054,
0.0362016633,
0.0362755805,
0.0233039968,
0.0289220512,
0.0433412604,
-0.0242002737,
-0.0709195063,
0.0434069894,
-0.0704953894,
-0.032913167,
0.0329964459,
-0.001984057,
0.0289691146,
0.0501162745,
-0.0352265537,
0.0071150865,
-0.0212360993,
0.0097602848,
-0.020298833,
0.0271124169,
-0.0965193883,
-0.0235369205,
0.0254370961,
-0.0761965066,
0.0087265316,
0.059770871,
0.013172958,
-0.0583127551,
0.0911982059,
-0.0227489639,
0.0254729278,
-0.039967753,
0.0121347606,
0.0068631913,
0.0197420791,
-0.0216173455,
0.0261223596,
-0.0084448438,
-0.000948954,
0.0252337307,
0.0057929214,
0.0219764709,
0.0120721394,
-0.0197334718,
0.0352865122,
-0.0208865628,
-0.0168834664,
0.0293214992,
0.0243049227,
-0.0679538175,
0.0031521532,
-0.0288899485,
0.0367412679,
-0.0338552818,
-0.0269467216,
0.0012912867,
-0.008264319,
-0.0407744199,
-0.0028896125,
-0.0427677855,
-0.0369825587,
0.0573339798,
-0.0037168651,
-0.0305228606,
-0.0038114877,
0.0007721673,
-0.0267522633,
-0.0260115452,
0.0139955878,
0.0329283029,
0.0151036065,
-0.0054302816,
0.0054346812,
0.0215667132,
-0.0426982678,
-0.0651475638,
0.0490963683,
-0.0296127982,
0.0078609409,
0.0303911995,
0.0549488105,
-0.0174302571,
0.0174718406,
0.0211548749,
0.041747719,
-0.0371929482,
-0.0196138807,
-0.0341607779,
-0.030315809,
-0.0258600079,
-0.0072224988,
-0.0915186554,
-0.0031239607,
0.0699699745,
0.0753813833,
-0.0343464464,
-0.0444610342,
0.0219685864,
-0.0523116514,
-0.0799910277,
0.0158460103,
-0.0386030339,
-0.0490093119,
0.0253713652,
-0.0725780427,
-0.0639269799,
0.0477612615,
0.0037431649,
-0.0086007193,
0.0023038683,
-0.0146185961,
-0.0374334678,
-0.0105664302,
-0.016833812,
0.0258198287,
-0.0100761084,
-0.0400944389,
-0.0374665409,
0.0194211919,
0.0144486818,
-0.0424691178,
0.0288371425,
-0.0428237282,
0.0023446633,
0.0329240672,
-0.0031774244,
-0.065322049,
-0.0180287622,
-0.034652479,
-0.0233672746,
0.0232668966,
0.001323706,
0.0332353637,
-0.050798893,
-0.0067281416,
-0.0000084805,
-0.0307488162,
-0.0009359314,
0.0118511748,
0.0052542021,
0.0333925039,
-0.0098847505,
0.0315243006,
-0.0537738092,
0.0207251497,
0.0130480975,
-0.0033950675,
0.0346290357,
-0.0170753468,
0.0260977279,
0.0515153632,
-0.0097951591,
-0.0156054366,
0.0690600574,
0.0422256067,
0.0067525851,
0.0060800528,
0.0952652171,
0.041671928,
-0.0059711295,
0.0258884393,
-0.0349167958,
0.0603001527,
0.0079775341,
-0.010766523,
-0.1013245285,
0.0166386198,
-0.009481403,
0.0506016351,
-0.0298362561,
-0.0358451195,
-0.0366016105,
-0.1216356903,
0.0288896766,
0.0272237863,
0.0128275845,
0.0278252866,
0.0127878124,
-0.0103222392,
0.0203676447,
0.0421426669,
-0.0168288611,
-0.0053335326,
0.0242493693,
0.0379331037,
-0.0476013012,
-0.064258121,
-0.0093803899,
-0.0118612852,
0.0519196615,
0.0225592088,
0.0266567823,
-0.0102486145,
-0.0497008376,
0.0190799553,
-0.0218800157,
0.0222149733,
-0.0466259271,
0.0268191062,
0.0353276543,
0.0042504077,
-0.0473042242,
0.0515954159,
0.0012731443,
-0.0073355897,
0.0038903167,
0.0342399143,
-0.0036406082,
-0.0416381545,
-0.0190554354,
0.032987956,
-0.00218137,
0.0857989639,
0.0901566371,
-0.0252613574,
-0.0068341219,
-0.0355066918,
0.0467673726,
-0.0619763918,
-0.0728238225,
0.0472109765,
-0.0316813067,
0.0178471599,
-0.0364224091,
-0.0421912745,
0.0138240727,
0.0024846571,
0.0324774832,
-0.0175209884,
0.0057971287,
-0.0659486055,
-0.027116809,
0.0265573077,
-0.027415622,
0.0521792434,
0.0052856663,
-0.0560800023,
-0.0178620573,
-0.063947022,
0.0092366319,
0.0062882267,
-0.0891190767,
-0.0656277239,
0.0684774071,
0.0261080507,
0.0248209275,
0.0395394675,
0.0301265866,
-0.0826145038,
0.0250517689,
-0.0077060829,
-0.0069763148,
0.038798105,
-0.0214837436,
0.0042243758,
-0.0097688939,
0.032427378,
-0.0393535048,
0.0648528412,
0.0324112624,
0.0314779654,
-0.014981878,
-0.0431762673,
-0.0069182515,
0.0110042011,
0.0156105841,
-0.091178067,
-0.0265303086,
-0.0455868915,
-0.041421663,
-0.0219816137,
-0.0024286599,
-0.0155296903,
-0.0272331666,
0.0256333537,
0.0379059203,
-0.0376545712,
0.0020445255,
-0.0469042584,
0.0598480105,
-0.0260742325,
0.042527359,
-0.0181730818,
0.0104479399,
0.0192414951,
0.0376128927,
-0.0188844334,
0.0277313516,
0.0121319387,
0.0521236956,
0.0593990311,
0.0337981954,
-0.004097369,
0.0116156507,
0.016140094,
-0.0204849616,
-0.0197398551,
0.0213288888,
-0.0069642644,
0.0232682694,
0.0406519622,
-0.0550368614,
0.0677135587,
0.0159649998,
0.0054312916,
0.0015040367,
0.024465885,
0.0093406495,
-0.0576421395,
0.0579608753,
-0.0404055007,
-0.0183216482,
-0.0117977681,
0.0386575684,
0.000227745,
0.0247713011,
-0.0061179581,
-0.0370564386,
-0.0292761493,
-0.0276066288,
0.0110039106,
-0.0135707064,
0.0210602395,
0.0113047175,
-0.0858082995,
-0.0712861344,
0.018116923,
0.0072050379,
0.0447213911,
-0.0221041571,
0.0261333473,
0.0253122952,
-0.0342765488,
0.0006780812,
-0.0064832978,
-0.0333789028,
-0.0081691844,
-0.0221835747,
0.0224446859,
-6.326556147e-33,
-0.0365555808,
-0.091491878,
0.0021643718,
-0.0161793474,
-0.0441668592,
-0.0115282461,
-0.0478365608,
0.0195365306,
0.0279019978,
0.0119418148,
0.007351472,
-0.0178150628,
0.0126181822,
0.0259587821,
0.0469371639,
0.0158774499,
0.037347015,
-0.0121606216,
-0.0272857621,
0.001287336,
-0.0204839502,
0.0551552549,
0.0234523565,
-0.0241797306,
0.0439093634,
-0.0300577786,
-0.0029158208,
-0.0152685614,
-0.0041902671,
0.0036743591,
-0.0378509648,
0.0593282953,
0.0392355397,
-0.0227748714,
-0.029150404,
0.0231860522,
-0.0189647712,
-0.0372394845,
0.0357167125,
0.0111923208,
-0.0328471996,
-0.025625281,
0.0309068188,
0.0049766479,
-0.0776467472,
0.0285599269,
0.0447841436,
-0.0278566498,
0.0242548697,
0.0077407714,
-0.0550068878,
0.0357801206,
-0.0214141887,
0.0091059655,
0.0003121801,
0.0462597534,
-0.0317671709,
-0.0308850668,
0.0128469551,
0.0100341281,
0.0187686011,
-0.0005494238,
0.0760922283,
0.0548593812,
-0.031141175,
0.0559025817,
0.0430869423,
-0.0386885554,
-0.0049512582,
-0.018765131,
0.0474792607,
0.0014893218,
0.0103961509,
0.095596157,
0.0144541059,
-0.0455478951,
-0.0096480036,
0.0356968008,
0.0038796277,
-0.0054956037,
-0.0207931958,
-0.0380872637,
-0.0179977957,
-0.0579774417,
-0.0189534724,
-0.0324564017,
0.0054691718,
-0.0234977677,
0.0484506264,
-0.0051387246,
-0.0047473996,
0.0385391414,
0.0128190322,
0.0109472675,
-0.0251281504,
-0.0201601461,
-0.0586788841,
-0.0477165058,
0.0076510366,
0.0370550416,
-0.0876274034,
0.0356536135,
0.0384625979,
0.0245946273,
0.01259699,
0.0019651928,
0.0212253109,
0.039275758,
-0.0647842214,
0.0432708003,
-0.0250508208,
0.0436216742,
0.0338806026,
-0.0301134549,
0.0462437607,
0.0249665659,
-0.0254939627,
0.0352639966,
0.0193965659,
-0.0093431994,
-0.0139472177,
-0.0196638703,
0.0034766456,
0.0263549071,
-0.0755477697,
0.0013307298,
0.0279559493,
0.0311090164,
0.0508527309,
-0.0298893042,
-0.0063193133,
-0.0356712304,
2.517e-7,
0.0033573899,
0.0134056145,
0.0260982923,
0.0131416703,
0.0099507011,
-0.0072346195,
-0.0143977385,
0.0048746672,
0.0389506109,
0.0148292929,
0.000496723,
0.0059935651,
0.0984189436,
0.0472912379,
-0.0533084609,
0.0212932453,
-0.087106511,
0.0543099456,
-0.065163143,
-0.044469282,
0.034123823,
0.027371088,
-0.0101851383,
-0.043569915,
-0.0641711727,
-0.0180543736,
0.0290644541,
-0.0385804288,
-0.0014307711,
-0.039275676,
0.0500408895,
0.0192223266,
0.0139492685,
0.0064815572,
-0.0431156307,
0.0436084978,
0.0110633196,
0.0147745796,
0.0418568514,
0.0149218366,
0.0096806334,
0.0552781522,
-0.0395933837,
-0.035796009,
0.035331063,
0.0309012402,
-0.0438210666,
-0.0278751794,
-0.0448535271,
0.0037472816,
-0.0289759077,
-0.0394777209,
-0.0139648728,
-0.0004066087,
0.0184908789,
-0.0237298515,
0.024529608,
-0.0517160445,
-0.0225596931,
0.0073480774,
-0.0300057214,
0.0019830805,
-0.0132411662,
0.0313089266,
-0.0386294015,
-0.0306400266,
0.0389557146,
2.124363263e-34,
0.018248938,
-0.0050928178,
0.0673623681,
-0.0080508888,
-0.018720137,
0.0124078011,
-0.0015648974,
-0.0032189051,
0.0260998793,
-0.0199397616,
-0.0050339056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14288v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14288v2 | LLM-powered Data Augmentation for Enhanced Cross-lingual Performance | 2023-05-23T17:33:27 | 2023-10-22T22:57:00 | Chenxi Whitehouse, Monojit Choudhury, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the potential of leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs)
for data augmentation in multilingual commonsense reasoning datasets where the
available training data is extremely limited. To achieve this, we utilise
several LLMs, namely Dolly-v2, StableVicuna, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, to augment
three datasets: XCOPA, XWinograd, and XStoryCloze. Subsequently, we evaluate
the effectiveness of fine-tuning smaller multilingual models, mBERT and XLMR,
using the synthesised data. We compare the performance of training with data
generated in English and target languages, as well as translated
English-generated data, revealing the overall advantages of incorporating data
generated by LLMs, e.g. a notable 13.4 accuracy score improvement for the best
case. Furthermore, we conduct a human evaluation by asking native speakers to
assess the naturalness and logical coherence of the generated examples across
different languages. The results of the evaluation indicate that LLMs such as
ChatGPT and GPT-4 excel at producing natural and coherent text in most
languages, however, they struggle to generate meaningful text in certain
languages like Tamil. We also observe that ChatGPT falls short in generating
plausible alternatives compared to the original dataset, whereas examples from
GPT-4 exhibit competitive logical consistency. | [
0.0343124606,
0.0528970137,
-0.0043654875,
0.04496333,
-0.0467802994,
0.003335305,
-0.009933942,
-0.0049241921,
0.0595163554,
-0.0373524204,
-0.0145347929,
0.0014925598,
0.0007640228,
-0.010502452,
0.0316899642,
-0.0281420015,
0.0472299159,
-0.0219226833,
-0.0351284817,
-0.0319780633,
-0.0010841404,
0.0467583574,
0.0006468247,
0.0156986788,
-0.000275107,
-0.0065229079,
0.0189051125,
-0.0036279166,
0.0403547436,
-0.0160530787,
-0.0324035697,
0.0259974003,
0.0239861757,
0.0405708589,
0.0000022912,
-0.0356959961,
0.0265117791,
0.0080497758,
-0.0086899418,
-0.010238328,
0.0367793255,
-0.0257199854,
0.0097768111,
0.0049926839,
-0.0329948589,
0.0212533511,
0.0161065888,
0.0092729004,
0.0625431538,
0.0785530284,
-0.0169017017,
-0.0182175245,
0.0531527176,
-0.0152327707,
0.0411402732,
-0.0400809944,
-0.0007920053,
0.0783361942,
0.0472650379,
0.0091478182,
-0.0079653412,
0.0488937348,
0.0498273782,
-0.0151810301,
-0.0462396741,
0.0402982049,
-0.0439101234,
-0.0087610697,
0.0157951862,
0.0819015503,
0.0168970451,
-0.0336935893,
-0.0211246386,
0.0102048051,
-0.0153566618,
0.0002015716,
-0.0315350667,
0.0350992121,
-0.0043457374,
0.0548388697,
0.092673935,
-0.0243961364,
0.0285791401,
0.0460939631,
0.0009879017,
0.0678244606,
0.0211761631,
-0.0162110459,
0.0157592408,
0.0016716393,
-0.0304601099,
-0.0507712625,
0.0193523765,
0.0539386533,
-0.0450483337,
0.0397295281,
-0.0358336009,
-0.0276250653,
0.037626233,
-0.0898414999,
-0.0077039576,
0.0689293444,
-0.0401889943,
0.0562706068,
-0.0433268808,
0.0337065235,
-0.0177830532,
0.0655555353,
-0.0275887474,
-0.0371496826,
-0.0533144586,
-0.0207032431,
0.0166526251,
0.0298068859,
-0.059288606,
0.0184692498,
-0.0579102971,
0.008622624,
0.0056144837,
0.0228330884,
0.0551315621,
-0.0229847245,
-0.0340151675,
-0.0474014767,
-0.0442915261,
0.0395292789,
-0.0396168232,
0.045422256,
0.0227236841,
-0.0705499873,
0.0020132079,
0.0131464303,
-0.019750176,
-0.0353445709,
0.0331981666,
0.0536130555,
-0.0328441262,
-0.0050226012,
-0.0583839454,
-0.0168820191,
0.0050194324,
-0.0768502355,
-0.0446985699,
-0.0925203413,
0.046024669,
0.0082813883,
-0.0169898514,
-0.0029997972,
0.0230813958,
0.0286677741,
-0.0312634744,
0.0703417063,
-0.027045276,
0.0105359359,
-0.0003396803,
-0.0036689048,
0.0144525524,
0.0724408999,
0.0119998194,
-0.0359109603,
0.04321656,
-0.0094976071,
-0.0143730873,
0.0233459193,
-0.0141466632,
0.0097736558,
-0.0073648072,
0.0381134637,
-0.0312952772,
0.0391613878,
0.038605772,
0.0105509721,
-0.0549730472,
0.0293413457,
0.0398538932,
0.0337257944,
-0.0191189218,
0.0267328639,
0.0126978001,
-0.0190763511,
-0.0026141652,
0.0213907193,
-0.0589542575,
0.0223245732,
-0.0239399727,
0.0263510048,
-0.0037385738,
0.0350810699,
-0.0252629071,
-0.0228851661,
0.004069949,
-0.0186159108,
0.0380532518,
0.0208933018,
0.0434817187,
-0.0121812969,
-0.01443893,
0.0799517706,
0.0677419379,
-0.0921317786,
0.0288887937,
-0.036430303,
0.0253413226,
0.0509637445,
0.023579333,
-0.0119410921,
-0.0696722046,
0.0062395395,
0.0019226064,
0.0728971064,
0.0314330794,
-0.0019078052,
0.0156732667,
-0.0781060681,
-0.0041330559,
-0.006104683,
-0.0100923637,
0.0227203462,
0.0101637626,
0.031230351,
0.0189170074,
-0.0529166088,
-0.0268841032,
0.022834029,
-0.0658898875,
0.0088759419,
0.0069976486,
-0.0153067242,
0.0343327187,
0.0300996117,
0.0220907535,
-0.0043208138,
0.0186398849,
-0.0333313122,
0.0046582688,
0.0690169334,
-0.0352818072,
-0.0772643983,
0.0627704561,
-0.0380327478,
-0.040605735,
0.0344018303,
-0.0434507541,
-0.0511220954,
-0.0090519954,
0.0014514823,
0.0049767615,
-0.0787778273,
-0.0075452421,
0.0076835486,
-0.0063144462,
-0.0048793349,
0.0768492669,
-0.0012998435,
0.0133210663,
0.0167994257,
0.0054186475,
0.0595846139,
-0.0499946363,
0.0119484207,
0.0261789542,
0.0107340906,
0.0099037252,
0.0085633192,
0.0331386775,
-0.0449682251,
-0.030940745,
-0.0833724812,
0.0066151554,
-0.0117444536,
-0.0035484117,
-0.004481039,
-0.0039675538,
0.0078181121,
0.0048604999,
-0.0600214675,
-0.0172489341,
0.070087567,
0.0170954578,
0.0189700034,
-0.0080038495,
0.0004322077,
0.0036905345,
-0.0053711105,
-0.0005518513,
-0.0012036404,
0.0018423698,
0.0262825452,
-0.0614347458,
-0.0011654911,
-0.058746811,
-0.005432907,
-0.0263084043,
-0.0482224822,
-0.0144569091,
-0.0036240113,
0.0029166695,
0.0275209062,
-0.0353994034,
-0.0325931609,
0.0390566662,
-0.0111025311,
-0.0377016477,
0.0226886552,
-0.0011271784,
-0.0011763981,
-0.0460991785,
-0.0317826979,
-0.0383248441,
0.0068923216,
-0.0228350013,
-0.0178281218,
-0.0596890412,
-0.0242202301,
-0.002917341,
-0.0234029554,
-0.036640875,
0.0177796371,
-0.0000281088,
0.0584882088,
-0.0188897941,
-0.0142417029,
0.0830013156,
-0.0220521092,
-0.0026698064,
-0.0862047449,
0.0077371458,
-0.0496288687,
0.024598537,
-0.0320599563,
0.0144868875,
-0.0683465078,
-0.0107607692,
-0.0383157432,
-0.0195519738,
0.0268515106,
-0.027264541,
0.0248166118,
-0.0570839681,
0.0219007675,
-0.0361001492,
-0.0571265183,
-0.0283650905,
-0.0294514224,
-0.0082296198,
0.0182506256,
0.0120571516,
-0.0035912995,
-0.0245850626,
0.011316278,
0.0161011145,
0.0206466075,
-0.0095286882,
0.0141139086,
-0.0181043688,
0.0171481967,
0.0295285676,
0.0616796054,
-0.007401512,
0.0055469279,
0.0014213533,
0.0128361108,
0.0108938059,
-0.0740004405,
0.0192217398,
0.0464879945,
0.0253339391,
-0.0120552583,
-0.0277474653,
-0.0076972647,
0.0571518391,
-0.0596064627,
-0.0143337306,
0.0791582167,
0.0300742388,
0.0053668632,
-0.0206291806,
-0.0680687949,
0.0164301097,
0.021755496,
0.036653813,
-0.0776949823,
-0.0484068617,
0.0171060655,
-0.0340301879,
-0.0074354787,
-0.0359648019,
0.00030832,
-0.1433434039,
0.0280578416,
0.0022931346,
-0.0608793087,
-0.0435083769,
-0.0425404981,
-0.0361298211,
-0.0219279882,
0.0379472002,
0.0352459289,
0.0028132875,
-0.0130262738,
0.0050230394,
-0.0188498609,
-0.0673752427,
0.0081196548,
-0.0211542435,
0.0303371996,
0.038376566,
0.0481489263,
-0.0285540354,
-0.0941149518,
0.0051847519,
-0.0109188342,
-0.000129638,
-0.0122584999,
0.0044265972,
0.0131532894,
-0.0285669379,
-0.0361416601,
0.0757696629,
-0.0042664441,
-0.0295547228,
0.0071917283,
0.0994914174,
0.0035829896,
0.0189649425,
0.0107196793,
0.0055000763,
-0.0137617923,
0.0828117579,
0.0140934922,
0.0114577534,
-0.0208057426,
-0.0281671789,
-0.034723267,
-0.0425030701,
-0.00112254,
0.035325557,
-0.0155671146,
-0.0130028669,
-0.0404026993,
-0.0728261843,
0.0550639331,
0.0005925453,
0.0160521939,
0.0506751761,
-0.0289092101,
-0.0101826033,
-0.0103419051,
0.0397154577,
-0.0392607674,
0.0083702523,
-0.0267548226,
0.0392597839,
-0.0032868946,
-0.0443033502,
-0.022128351,
0.0275288913,
-0.0206527188,
-0.0802718177,
-0.0369066745,
0.0421010442,
0.0227769986,
0.0322256647,
-0.0179731604,
-0.0309689436,
0.0558741279,
0.0500436574,
-0.0280957781,
-0.0071702916,
0.0475317091,
0.0311081037,
0.02363028,
0.0654345229,
-0.0207391642,
-0.0222784504,
-0.0103778969,
0.060404323,
-0.0229617767,
-0.000505725,
0.0294919498,
0.0531365536,
0.0007258318,
-0.0610145889,
0.0241573099,
-0.0337403305,
0.0270488653,
-0.0573866405,
-0.0258846506,
-0.0155358342,
0.0141800204,
0.040004801,
-0.0490554571,
-0.0030128653,
0.0103091775,
-0.0288338438,
0.0172505137,
-0.0126109282,
0.0269383155,
0.0169053916,
0.0337215252,
0.0136331161,
-0.0169834252,
-0.03222996,
-0.0261445604,
-0.0324740894,
0.0420061387,
-0.036027316,
0.0629218668,
0.0231607128,
-0.0224289447,
0.0138831995,
0.0037641446,
-0.0117289629,
-0.0247310307,
0.0138778957,
0.0676061511,
0.0755826682,
-0.0086325649,
0.0641697496,
-0.037103612,
-0.0410272926,
-0.0036544541,
0.0653019249,
0.0310636517,
-0.0259037092,
0.0429963283,
-0.0004394648,
-0.0441940017,
-0.016437076,
0.0857619196,
-0.0520461425,
0.0334610455,
0.0112910429,
0.0049115568,
-0.0342003405,
-0.0595432483,
0.0041680187,
0.0128726615,
-0.006657735,
0.0032417828,
-0.0546254255,
-0.0753573477,
0.0025581208,
0.0265440866,
-0.0054177907,
-0.0025965369,
-0.011194556,
0.0513127148,
0.0273751374,
-0.006960432,
-0.0248158835,
0.0000428075,
-0.0596900061,
0.0040547489,
0.0008646841,
-6.457999925e-33,
-0.0201850682,
0.0196199678,
0.0364209972,
-0.0110576637,
-0.0186274461,
-0.0249634013,
-0.041792661,
-0.0152681433,
-0.025927797,
0.0369774103,
-0.0191085953,
0.014889366,
0.0166963916,
0.0172673203,
-0.0043746945,
-0.0148498164,
0.0126279118,
0.0653216615,
-0.0050860178,
-0.0025917569,
0.0685942098,
-0.01428553,
0.1046858504,
-0.0247358046,
0.0422964543,
-0.0213394277,
-0.007066451,
0.0360033363,
-0.0507840477,
0.058805082,
-0.0251070429,
0.0632869378,
0.0170588903,
-0.0283344872,
-0.0128237689,
0.0045418525,
-0.0662138909,
-0.0346327759,
0.0822834671,
0.0066332165,
-0.0323808454,
-0.0402112193,
0.023348717,
-0.0061987257,
-0.0113761518,
0.0053989175,
0.0177937802,
-0.0533545837,
-0.0152281569,
0.0086751822,
-0.0453489535,
0.0467046723,
-0.0113137206,
-0.0026658184,
0.0036370365,
0.0391577259,
-0.025078509,
0.0133931963,
-0.0583854094,
0.0122425966,
0.0312729664,
0.0147381481,
0.0719675571,
-0.0263359118,
0.0072646388,
0.027980838,
-0.027337689,
-0.0292588398,
-0.027840266,
0.044138778,
0.0029775521,
0.0540812761,
0.0476157442,
0.1092895344,
0.0402310379,
-0.0342482924,
-0.0968209654,
0.0444059148,
0.0049781012,
0.0557290316,
0.0215086602,
-0.0110752014,
-0.0233210716,
-0.0290247928,
-0.0413043089,
-0.0035323626,
-0.0388680175,
-0.0423334651,
0.0181861147,
-0.0204791371,
-0.0279779546,
0.0296495706,
0.0361666046,
-0.011197621,
-0.0374853462,
0.0238926094,
-0.0321780965,
-0.0127473129,
0.008508143,
0.0292308331,
-0.0370727703,
-0.0268455315,
-0.0031360467,
0.0036650724,
0.0054276874,
0.0133847147,
0.0497563854,
-0.0001840669,
-0.0413246825,
0.0091490438,
-0.0372502878,
0.0439102463,
-0.0187551267,
0.0058403518,
0.0510510951,
0.0205698106,
-0.0089880601,
0.0236378387,
0.0265290122,
0.0030992276,
-0.0229481366,
-0.0210219659,
0.0180779118,
0.0213506464,
0.0048871613,
0.0295851454,
-0.0400125459,
-0.0460593961,
0.0194722805,
-0.0307329763,
-0.0051372405,
0.0541418567,
2.906e-7,
0.0125606637,
0.0387281664,
0.010434431,
0.0059238016,
-0.029699238,
0.0264556892,
-0.0529345274,
-0.0076889689,
0.0119093079,
-0.0438274108,
-0.0165260397,
0.049206201,
0.0684298426,
0.0474046879,
-0.0549499467,
0.0062022498,
-0.0773161799,
-0.0428583845,
-0.0488607585,
0.0091016423,
0.0483054407,
0.0721353516,
0.022521805,
-0.0354512669,
0.022749301,
-0.0335219875,
0.0665335953,
-0.0439450704,
-0.0539413169,
0.0055406145,
0.0060700751,
0.0177867934,
0.0069833845,
0.0359614603,
-0.0127252275,
0.0159089789,
-0.0140135707,
0.0669956505,
-0.0023018201,
-0.0064549609,
-0.0049046241,
-0.0341866761,
-0.0049691973,
-0.0624822304,
0.0910148248,
-0.0256847236,
-0.0474821106,
-0.0111507941,
-0.0394709781,
0.003796356,
0.0353715941,
-0.0334388055,
-0.0277815759,
0.008982433,
0.0238184426,
-0.0291060321,
-0.0197964441,
-0.0405457839,
-0.0372036882,
0.0163789261,
-0.0204965658,
-0.0474345833,
-0.0113996305,
0.0063301926,
0.0298558809,
-0.0826529041,
0.0118593806,
2.859790641e-34,
0.0508585908,
0.0060890955,
0.0171288904,
0.0044009313,
0.0464351587,
0.0076038488,
0.0207061432,
0.0183242857,
0.0095769055,
-0.0628364235,
0.0052037598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14283v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14283v3 | Query Rewriting for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:27:50 | 2023-10-23T02:34:49 | Xinbei Ma, Yeyun Gong, Pengcheng He, Hai Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) play powerful, black-box readers in the
retrieve-then-read pipeline, making remarkable progress in knowledge-intensive
tasks. This work introduces a new framework, Rewrite-Retrieve-Read instead of
the previous retrieve-then-read for the retrieval-augmented LLMs from the
perspective of the query rewriting. Unlike prior studies focusing on adapting
either the retriever or the reader, our approach pays attention to the
adaptation of the search query itself, for there is inevitably a gap between
the input text and the needed knowledge in retrieval. We first prompt an LLM to
generate the query, then use a web search engine to retrieve contexts.
Furthermore, to better align the query to the frozen modules, we propose a
trainable scheme for our pipeline. A small language model is adopted as a
trainable rewriter to cater to the black-box LLM reader. The rewriter is
trained using the feedback of the LLM reader by reinforcement learning.
Evaluation is conducted on downstream tasks, open-domain QA and multiple-choice
QA. Experiments results show consistent performance improvement, indicating
that our framework is proven effective and scalable, and brings a new framework
for retrieval-augmented LLM. | [
0.0556149893,
0.0204935186,
-0.0133115929,
0.0292566121,
-0.0218533706,
0.0110946475,
-0.0316457376,
0.0148262195,
0.0434608199,
-0.0611518435,
-0.0417807214,
-0.0147038111,
-0.0634723976,
0.0229146667,
0.016869016,
-0.0323904604,
0.0290093739,
-0.0332649611,
-0.0164613687,
0.0093227737,
0.0027805811,
0.0175194051,
0.0280065369,
0.0145833427,
0.0331787504,
-0.0056148143,
-0.0270186737,
0.0295096077,
-0.0226256587,
-0.0199280754,
0.0412468128,
0.0269564632,
0.0407499783,
0.0394686721,
0.0000017858,
-0.058918573,
-0.0745832995,
0.0091581549,
-0.0247575864,
0.0142292455,
0.0512843095,
0.0049671992,
0.0250880383,
0.0215240438,
-0.0304831713,
0.0011410287,
0.0207863245,
0.0530394539,
0.0544566028,
0.0878144726,
0.0083369883,
-0.0288554002,
0.0145712579,
-0.0230427086,
0.0455322154,
-0.0694427714,
0.0490438938,
0.0239343587,
0.0462374613,
0.0454493351,
-0.0108113177,
0.0554715991,
0.0085256556,
-0.0175889283,
0.0052391323,
0.0115376869,
-0.0233975556,
0.0190035962,
0.0024959336,
0.0835672468,
0.0071091382,
-0.0086722737,
0.0141204577,
0.0147636691,
-0.0072351182,
0.0301818922,
-0.0451066382,
0.0025734855,
0.0026711544,
-0.0184934344,
-0.0212711841,
-0.0396081284,
0.034278255,
0.0298318863,
-0.0614540763,
0.0688395128,
0.0135676274,
-0.055650387,
-0.0098810634,
-0.0016364501,
0.0192808248,
-0.0081930971,
0.0185894128,
0.0568348393,
-0.0453105718,
0.0368798748,
-0.0116539141,
-0.0321290083,
0.0148486933,
-0.0230509713,
0.0228787921,
0.015722895,
-0.0186104141,
0.0647151172,
-0.0176925585,
0.0487054251,
-0.0269094817,
0.0164595135,
-0.0828853175,
-0.026751969,
-0.0513180867,
-0.0309988074,
-0.0389455818,
0.0335988551,
-0.0593157671,
-0.0057663647,
-0.0303780772,
0.0688525662,
0.027683448,
0.0076100486,
-0.0136239901,
0.0055613569,
-0.0511487722,
-0.022697553,
-0.0551683232,
0.0533565767,
0.0198649503,
-0.0014428297,
-0.0046612979,
-0.040535856,
-0.0190071296,
-0.0134522887,
0.0220564101,
-0.0419542156,
-0.0006286085,
0.0472898372,
-0.02808729,
-0.0507512502,
-0.043353565,
-0.0315794796,
0.0055356571,
-0.019650979,
-0.0053884899,
-0.0407510065,
0.0323781744,
-0.0122687155,
-0.0073394575,
-0.0344689004,
0.0172436405,
0.0423264317,
-0.0148949502,
0.0547787696,
0.0529476181,
0.0128398323,
0.0398673862,
0.0097833872,
0.0094820512,
0.0720334947,
-0.0107675539,
0.0345463343,
0.0538632274,
0.0009186101,
0.0214372538,
0.0166124236,
0.0051324307,
0.0334163606,
-0.032012742,
0.0647125393,
0.0255850945,
0.0476360954,
0.0292985179,
0.0363016091,
-0.034111511,
-0.0053897807,
0.0444412604,
0.0440867655,
0.060943298,
-0.0137156844,
0.0241398718,
0.0286133159,
-0.0136528453,
-0.0090903165,
-0.034823209,
0.0225629341,
-0.0258966889,
0.0262882151,
0.0165842324,
0.0119838491,
-0.0144585017,
-0.0324703157,
0.0383354872,
0.0164278019,
-0.0339080989,
0.0530231036,
0.0505286306,
0.0166616794,
-0.0467228442,
0.0061334474,
0.0144693078,
-0.0281434301,
0.0378412753,
-0.0386941954,
0.0277026799,
0.0781538486,
0.0742426217,
-0.0653316751,
-0.0263380781,
-0.0022547054,
-0.0254068207,
-0.0028500874,
0.033098381,
-0.0183636025,
-0.0262768455,
-0.0368538275,
-0.0502623729,
-0.0041037761,
0.010365665,
0.0202812385,
0.0516375527,
0.0030645216,
0.0410197154,
-0.0270623378,
-0.024570182,
0.0263524055,
-0.0447006635,
-0.0592972264,
0.010424667,
0.0013313892,
0.0086403619,
-0.006529354,
-0.0084496345,
0.0246747416,
0.0447571613,
-0.011235687,
-0.0261509381,
-0.0310935583,
-0.0208887104,
-0.0113425273,
0.0290988311,
0.0108156251,
0.0221088491,
0.0099725761,
-0.039481353,
-0.0290102363,
-0.0112364311,
-0.0152872363,
0.0467670634,
-0.0370187052,
0.0173305832,
-0.0132244248,
-0.0337624587,
-0.1040338278,
0.0357699171,
0.0227397289,
0.0107445978,
0.0223362241,
-0.019883886,
-0.0289212447,
-0.0610066317,
-0.0334841311,
0.0310095847,
0.0200670473,
0.0339741148,
0.0180898383,
0.0004617409,
-0.0541807897,
-0.0312377606,
-0.0658495352,
0.0272501465,
-0.0275734048,
0.0014185073,
0.0279906373,
0.0551006421,
-0.0163011625,
-0.0304344017,
-0.0095499493,
-0.0295057297,
0.0040314388,
0.0281207766,
0.0082306145,
0.0547425896,
-0.0077418438,
-0.0409935191,
-0.0345402919,
0.006339814,
0.0374945924,
-0.0144465007,
0.0220825057,
-0.0516327024,
0.0436872654,
-0.0229618512,
0.013232707,
-0.0259011164,
0.0137921711,
-0.0258092806,
-0.067658484,
0.0268195458,
0.0801624134,
0.0157643519,
0.0022983795,
0.0403322168,
-0.0266736392,
-0.0730543062,
0.0320531577,
-0.0427494869,
-0.0792267472,
-0.037676435,
-0.0343730487,
0.0367593318,
0.0117398202,
-0.0156092541,
-0.0076613063,
-0.0115277339,
0.0006045887,
-0.0170434881,
-0.0284929611,
-0.0916530266,
0.0134642581,
0.0002631261,
0.0347366072,
-0.016826719,
-0.0290338527,
0.0792561471,
0.0004776402,
-0.0044763377,
-0.0480247587,
-0.0246183127,
-0.0731236413,
0.0773109049,
-0.0145777371,
0.0104236659,
-0.026092995,
-0.0361694694,
-0.052426327,
-0.0288974177,
0.0115584359,
-0.0668430179,
0.079561606,
-0.0416532531,
0.0154152177,
0.002382922,
-0.0514372922,
-0.0406078994,
-0.0130321765,
-0.0224082097,
-0.010273085,
0.0013391016,
-0.033811152,
-0.0536428317,
0.0060484339,
0.077674374,
0.0531356484,
-0.0291967057,
-0.0155380033,
-0.0306438766,
0.0261440035,
0.0683510005,
0.0179069638,
-0.0305321496,
-0.0238412097,
0.0248044915,
0.0375155322,
0.0443145297,
-0.0604483224,
0.0230707247,
-0.0127303302,
0.0396580063,
-0.0610483885,
-0.0048145768,
0.0249322355,
-0.0165737178,
-0.0929808095,
-0.0363022126,
0.0720633566,
0.0236871187,
-0.050956104,
-0.0407259762,
-0.0294088684,
0.0210616924,
0.0255866069,
0.0929721668,
-0.0537444763,
-0.0071187238,
0.0250090379,
0.0557322763,
0.0106359571,
-0.0044362033,
0.0019326948,
-0.1170440689,
0.031205941,
-0.0022710399,
-0.0239857212,
-0.0338883698,
-0.0477789417,
-0.0054296483,
-0.0003534192,
0.0234502591,
0.0818080902,
-0.0554922558,
-0.0047649578,
0.0096402485,
0.060941197,
-0.0167546757,
0.0060272291,
-0.0171860009,
-0.0115330666,
0.0748984739,
-0.0012945979,
0.0121691991,
0.011896953,
-0.0077777784,
-0.0462567918,
-0.0035211893,
-0.0189266279,
0.0174691528,
-0.0149319395,
-0.0021072181,
-0.0213627722,
-0.0113229789,
-0.01574938,
0.0166674666,
0.0167822093,
0.0833684206,
-0.0220556278,
0.0164854564,
-0.0290733296,
-0.0479506403,
-0.0077287448,
0.0623119995,
0.0037094979,
0.0108179087,
-0.0415393673,
-0.0115667954,
-0.0168666523,
-0.0532108583,
-0.0299031641,
0.000686947,
-0.0575727485,
0.0662098974,
-0.0586941428,
-0.0188240428,
0.0238315836,
0.0250830222,
0.0238331035,
0.0542455316,
0.0386980399,
-0.00908456,
-0.0817344189,
0.0382073522,
-0.0688491315,
0.0194448363,
-0.043251276,
-0.0035665627,
0.0511723459,
-0.0475621484,
-0.0289001968,
-0.0140680037,
-0.017349042,
-0.0418150946,
-0.0351792015,
0.0179264005,
0.0186998527,
0.0567524582,
-0.0013688422,
-0.0460423492,
0.0308454502,
0.0181172974,
-0.0417924002,
0.0101466198,
-0.0181664079,
0.0260593817,
-0.0210595373,
0.0229683612,
-0.0836455151,
-0.0197195448,
-0.0027286692,
0.0510642268,
-0.0057696928,
-0.0490669347,
0.0510137118,
0.0319359638,
0.0001104555,
0.0441326909,
0.0039693415,
-0.0365951695,
0.0620661229,
-0.0332756825,
-0.0331355184,
-0.0211024508,
0.0251850057,
0.053906098,
-0.0179439187,
0.0136219729,
0.0074666701,
0.0009532892,
0.059049882,
-0.0538841039,
-0.0064611877,
0.0077219764,
-0.0178186875,
0.0608374402,
0.0010031915,
-0.0153559493,
0.0292282924,
0.0189426318,
0.0697673783,
-0.0207130443,
0.0202505216,
0.0445201471,
-0.0279335883,
-0.065221712,
-0.0010411271,
-0.0945892036,
-0.046700567,
-0.0052729598,
0.0025240721,
0.0293001588,
0.0001293851,
0.0169986561,
-0.0249895789,
-0.037061289,
-0.0231205504,
-0.0020184522,
0.0147580756,
-0.0008339353,
0.0445016213,
0.043346785,
0.0094350381,
0.0237098821,
0.0612359717,
0.0192220174,
0.0570341311,
-0.0196758378,
-0.033762455,
-0.03182346,
-0.0436099768,
0.041686032,
0.0287286118,
-0.038092576,
-0.0224134363,
-0.0245274138,
-0.0379312113,
0.0262414198,
-0.0070175626,
-0.0384140611,
-0.0325953402,
0.0457437113,
0.0898902118,
0.0220256988,
-0.0355922207,
-0.0587624572,
0.0488111675,
-0.034905348,
-0.0646821484,
-0.0137463165,
-6.1310516e-33,
-0.0209939349,
-0.0130591616,
0.0458475612,
-0.042969048,
-0.0515246652,
0.0254257433,
-0.0129520688,
-0.0383149087,
-0.0059525049,
-0.0195144415,
-0.0303458963,
0.0160421897,
0.0113588711,
0.0173980128,
-0.0107905613,
-0.0150185702,
0.0429299995,
0.0124300886,
0.0008237538,
0.0337535925,
0.0315114483,
0.0663995817,
0.010286564,
-0.0299694836,
0.0175923575,
-0.0284160115,
0.0243393183,
0.0471126251,
-0.0043927501,
0.0466450602,
-0.0173375309,
0.0183025096,
0.0228071045,
-0.0302811824,
0.0042331405,
0.0344781801,
-0.0740262195,
0.0173322838,
0.012865969,
0.0011974417,
-0.0350379013,
-0.0276523922,
0.0469906144,
-0.0239023641,
0.0196241811,
0.0113056237,
0.0273341667,
-0.0159501173,
-0.0454279222,
-0.0154097211,
-0.0364962406,
0.0074430136,
0.0089260032,
-0.0002380441,
0.0189561229,
0.0500314347,
0.0188556351,
0.0699070916,
0.004927238,
0.0096795661,
-0.0048978617,
0.0744033679,
0.0281056184,
0.0564451143,
0.0102098258,
0.0248403326,
-0.0013248996,
0.0066143959,
-0.0123402076,
-0.0526906252,
0.0167036895,
0.0209337007,
-0.0321084447,
0.059576422,
-0.0142549574,
0.0210505556,
-0.039737504,
0.0289314557,
-0.0114960922,
0.0595996231,
0.0437346622,
0.0410962589,
-0.0366683528,
-0.0098376963,
-0.0604077913,
0.0527398884,
-0.0589596517,
0.0024301154,
0.0659177527,
0.0368842371,
-0.0167742409,
-0.0141923828,
0.0406622738,
-0.019105345,
-0.0087786373,
0.0220924933,
-0.0023450244,
0.0077112443,
-0.0223946497,
0.036541231,
-0.0213949475,
-0.0190012231,
0.0131765716,
-0.0429990068,
-0.0417357348,
-0.0011146849,
-0.0203302186,
0.0265521407,
-0.0608005337,
-0.0096747363,
-0.0267291106,
0.0041465578,
-0.0122705884,
0.021300802,
-0.0011123897,
0.0387496538,
0.0217654109,
0.0416154079,
0.0509061143,
-0.0158568528,
-0.0319434479,
-0.0566256419,
0.0164943896,
0.0098558683,
-0.0169134401,
0.0297619123,
-0.0153892748,
0.0423194319,
0.020838201,
-0.0550454259,
0.0116590634,
0.0218927991,
2.687e-7,
0.0574785806,
0.0439805686,
-0.001545377,
0.0452882759,
-0.0065722279,
0.0217543542,
-0.008286979,
0.0085852602,
0.0447602198,
0.017183993,
0.036368195,
0.020902995,
0.0174167585,
-0.0167898498,
-0.1082599163,
-0.0184825025,
-0.0410177633,
-0.0210091099,
-0.0668154657,
-0.0453972258,
0.0396965109,
0.0940112248,
0.0000313373,
-0.0059108119,
-0.0099644847,
-0.0765820071,
0.0566756949,
-0.0270389114,
-0.0227227751,
0.0294357985,
0.0425660461,
0.0453853011,
0.019482255,
-0.015509163,
0.0037198996,
0.0200442132,
0.0031305675,
0.0624537654,
0.0209310986,
-0.0252080318,
-0.0074438597,
-0.0121316053,
0.0026060231,
-0.0650672466,
0.0470429286,
-0.0279935338,
0.0224567428,
-0.0047684112,
-0.02962761,
-0.0373495929,
0.000512143,
-0.0273667742,
-0.0126396669,
0.0082274126,
0.008978528,
0.0125050517,
0.0016408958,
-0.089151755,
-0.0175036993,
0.0099499254,
-0.0327584147,
-0.0340383425,
-0.0640628934,
-0.008059578,
-0.0208906457,
-0.0496263057,
0.0039337301,
2.516694145e-34,
0.0295745749,
-0.0003277245,
-0.0088861752,
0.0456204824,
0.0514169633,
0.0109283524,
-0.0344105326,
0.0263716672,
0.0087282266,
-0.129332751,
-0.0270488057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14282v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14282v3 | INSTRUCTSCORE: Explainable Text Generation Evaluation with Finegrained Feedback | 2023-05-23T17:27:22 | 2023-10-26T18:21:30 | Wenda Xu, Danqing Wang, Liangming Pan, Zhenqiao Song, Markus Freitag, William Yang Wang, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatically evaluating the quality of language generation is critical.
Although recent learned metrics show high correlation with human judgement,
these metrics can not explain their verdict or associate the scores with
defects in generated text. To address this limitation, we present
InstructScore, an explainable evaluation metric for text generation. By
harnessing both explicit human instruction and the implicit knowledge of GPT-4,
we fine-tune a text evaluation metric based on LLaMA, producing both a score
for generated text and a human readable diagnostic report. We evaluate
InstructScore on a variety of generation tasks, including translation,
captioning, data-to-text and commonsense generation. Experiments show that our
7B model surpasses all other unsupervised metrics, including those based on
175B GPT-3 and GPT-4. Surprisingly, our InstructScore, even without direct
supervision from human-rated data, achieves performance levels on par with
state-of-the-art metrics like COMET22, which were fine-tuned on human ratings. | [
0.0059985104,
0.0636466146,
-0.0009848519,
-0.0005298949,
0.006807229,
0.01489936,
0.0104844216,
0.0039630905,
0.006691712,
-0.0145060224,
-0.0516320132,
-0.0123068467,
0.0294135362,
0.0481078699,
0.0637627468,
-0.0511129275,
0.0006343683,
-0.0110116303,
-0.0072933715,
0.0218731146,
0.0192448311,
0.0276091583,
-0.0072715338,
0.0428101197,
0.0127316415,
-0.0194877051,
-0.0040316726,
0.0024879368,
0.0203544702,
-0.0057541924,
0.004361955,
0.0613194071,
0.011030986,
0.0092649041,
0.000001808,
-0.0095671648,
0.0183664951,
-0.0101501467,
0.0158255044,
0.0342017077,
0.0174285807,
-0.0235604327,
-0.0018665991,
0.0200562682,
-0.0147556076,
0.0285690743,
0.0183598399,
0.0485029407,
0.0986700431,
0.0486120135,
0.0045051808,
-0.004505449,
-0.0128484722,
-0.0285681617,
0.0304238088,
-0.0039424151,
-0.0417869091,
0.0181057062,
-0.0027108651,
0.001223454,
0.0027673098,
-0.0023385845,
0.0441247635,
-0.0672073215,
0.0200599115,
0.0422191396,
0.0011521588,
-0.0183639042,
0.0081213964,
0.0800871477,
0.0239906665,
-0.0363614336,
0.0135995531,
-0.0173043795,
0.0049565048,
-0.0264328402,
-0.0220623221,
0.0150402347,
0.0138004906,
0.0280389078,
0.0160265882,
0.019274706,
0.033890076,
0.0322846994,
0.0393902212,
0.0200566892,
0.002717563,
0.0180929564,
-0.0215647481,
0.0499254577,
-0.0375889875,
-0.0518655106,
0.0265541337,
0.0441377386,
-0.0643224046,
0.0044445149,
-0.0488816835,
-0.0092352126,
0.024197571,
-0.0014683364,
0.049821794,
0.0423966199,
-0.0157693513,
-0.0066527529,
-0.0392670333,
0.0788278505,
0.0168490149,
0.0199237466,
-0.0271896552,
0.0280534737,
-0.0493862033,
-0.0226538833,
-0.0039936271,
0.0098443357,
-0.0295673218,
-0.01037193,
-0.0522837676,
-0.0089973817,
-0.01160709,
0.0043214192,
0.0301912557,
0.0320846252,
-0.0559727289,
-0.0077017252,
-0.0349983387,
-0.0147906914,
-0.0640211478,
0.0009541304,
0.0762194172,
-0.0095090223,
-0.024451131,
0.0514394455,
-0.0046996777,
0.0137109207,
-0.0051834686,
0.0643866286,
-0.0568007119,
-0.0060950778,
-0.0285518318,
-0.0695613399,
-0.0090129199,
-0.0706559718,
-0.0391765609,
-0.0268580876,
-0.0086457171,
-0.0107365847,
-0.0214355122,
-0.0164935272,
0.0142261144,
0.0234500896,
0.0343791656,
0.0368198901,
-0.0278645512,
-0.0113227814,
0.0127285523,
0.0313304216,
-0.0040694014,
0.0239838418,
0.0400276594,
0.0570789278,
-0.0130993677,
0.0017678161,
0.0263373647,
-0.0087711327,
0.0462992676,
0.0050941068,
-0.0077880761,
-0.0202042852,
-0.0747473538,
0.0742722228,
0.0724512041,
0.0495937951,
-0.0306130089,
0.0480234288,
0.0662399381,
0.0016808652,
0.0076730158,
0.053351488,
0.0812761411,
0.0223326925,
-0.0296910144,
0.0338285528,
-0.0450045466,
0.0747087002,
-0.0054010195,
0.0243966337,
0.0505069681,
-0.0055997488,
-0.0169467758,
-0.0703024417,
0.0243350584,
-0.0145909274,
-0.0210230425,
-0.0292525906,
0.0039964854,
0.0280272402,
-0.0731997564,
0.0172047839,
0.0014083645,
-0.0864304081,
0.0439553261,
-0.0434832089,
0.0906700715,
0.0912393779,
0.0607514642,
0.0426819324,
-0.0251918174,
-0.0090103922,
0.0066448743,
0.0785222873,
0.0124130659,
-0.0095608532,
0.0103090452,
-0.06716986,
-0.0034050096,
-0.0252577923,
0.0316589288,
-0.0049593388,
-0.0030907986,
-0.0043299836,
0.04920578,
-0.0504615903,
-0.0774231777,
0.0483075306,
-0.0083227325,
-0.0465373844,
-0.0073629422,
-0.0120843723,
0.0151943993,
0.0183682069,
0.0095202578,
0.025603855,
0.0036841198,
-0.0398775712,
-0.027349269,
0.0103910537,
-0.0609301552,
-0.0589918531,
-0.0201841593,
-0.0506755002,
-0.0016021846,
0.0053094178,
-0.0278240032,
-0.0677741691,
0.0011064506,
-0.051035028,
-0.0128865698,
-0.0625282004,
-0.0135100856,
0.031603951,
-0.0006168715,
-0.0042072507,
0.0452348627,
-0.0151879713,
0.0048872824,
0.0166024491,
-0.010216902,
0.0107923253,
-0.0223235227,
0.0179612935,
-0.0070430799,
0.0020999936,
0.0091843354,
0.0097658075,
0.0761206299,
-0.0470816232,
-0.0252217147,
-0.0540691689,
0.0175493862,
-0.012652792,
0.031639073,
0.0585271567,
-0.025437234,
0.0072704689,
0.0199270565,
-0.0747284889,
-0.0022219487,
0.0585397519,
-0.0172223132,
0.0800924003,
-0.0066322265,
-0.001865637,
-0.0302839614,
0.0238579344,
0.0161209945,
0.0161366444,
0.0536820479,
0.0402498357,
-0.0655286163,
0.0541190654,
-0.0347793028,
-0.060080789,
0.0080419909,
-0.096982792,
0.0434229635,
0.0272928458,
0.0309732445,
0.0264436658,
0.0043649925,
0.0521587841,
0.0147281634,
0.0243767388,
-0.0248821862,
-0.0233462937,
-0.023940634,
-0.023027217,
0.0089005409,
-0.047124438,
-0.0038119173,
0.0671059489,
0.0094768573,
0.0103686647,
-0.0804886594,
0.0336938202,
-0.0156186754,
-0.0313608982,
-0.0114444634,
-0.0109804897,
-0.0033073951,
0.0459249206,
-0.0367307514,
-0.0797379985,
0.0611544847,
-0.0510779768,
-0.0029691029,
0.0076899994,
0.0019367595,
-0.0204191785,
0.0308315717,
-0.0136882029,
0.0247753784,
-0.0179091636,
-0.0236793105,
-0.0392997451,
0.0178039595,
0.0233413279,
-0.0205724649,
0.0292359293,
-0.0666483939,
-0.009927636,
0.0061058723,
-0.0194600634,
-0.0274884086,
-0.0194138326,
0.0213134754,
0.0057203383,
0.043312449,
-0.0370178372,
0.0064933943,
-0.0097192898,
0.0208379086,
0.0210249871,
-0.0333939493,
-0.0175264403,
-0.0176557023,
0.0164155494,
0.0253719669,
0.0316418968,
0.0227629486,
-0.079433836,
-0.0076225321,
0.030565545,
0.0039990596,
0.0069483612,
-0.0118773319,
0.0158632323,
-0.013011734,
0.0108332476,
-0.0161074493,
0.0328635834,
0.0974048525,
-0.0553049818,
-0.0402861722,
0.0927860811,
-0.0022882442,
-0.0195196904,
0.0146282623,
0.0136272991,
0.0633260161,
-0.0112455618,
0.0116938958,
-0.0199662354,
-0.0312407836,
0.0012304626,
0.058158908,
-0.0048802132,
-0.028252447,
-0.0160250757,
-0.0799841732,
0.0433443151,
0.0156215709,
-0.0326419175,
-0.0406118743,
-0.0229356531,
-0.0365099907,
-0.00167948,
0.0027849295,
0.0108905938,
0.0107981917,
0.05349987,
0.0296326149,
-0.0045466856,
-0.0504992045,
0.0202258229,
-0.0152533287,
0.0516275205,
0.0687603652,
0.0689477399,
0.0293573737,
-0.0445451885,
-0.0115040578,
-0.0356185697,
0.0194753706,
-0.0024914148,
0.055680912,
0.0166465547,
-0.0044349683,
-0.0528466739,
0.0808226243,
-0.061274834,
0.0023319775,
-0.0221324526,
0.0146366321,
-0.0117395418,
-0.0153712854,
0.0170288328,
0.0316526145,
0.0183791686,
0.0760664865,
0.0680163205,
-0.0157862026,
-0.0401921161,
-0.0306055434,
0.0145481583,
-0.1098994091,
-0.0069393646,
-0.0046624737,
0.009501555,
-0.0142484969,
-0.1243566871,
-0.0606180876,
0.011706247,
0.0510185398,
0.0084021809,
-0.0137719298,
-0.046456553,
-0.0421621092,
-0.0044712732,
0.0337317735,
-0.012653877,
-0.0071850773,
-0.0694327429,
-0.0424335636,
-0.009232427,
-0.0402938277,
-0.0128690442,
0.0615417771,
-0.0507115163,
-0.0332652032,
-0.0384704992,
0.0617903434,
0.0274399407,
0.0167681798,
0.0020477122,
-0.0481491536,
0.0504687577,
0.0540477373,
-0.0510819033,
0.017352879,
0.0137878954,
0.0182084572,
0.0092956759,
0.0474506468,
-0.0029613248,
-0.0025807398,
-0.0208659638,
0.0320179984,
0.014657151,
-0.017837422,
0.0216100086,
0.0133790458,
-0.014684001,
-0.0897234678,
0.0067487801,
-0.065019004,
-0.0344194844,
-0.018012939,
-0.008264076,
-0.0632680058,
0.012926653,
0.0353971459,
-0.0191289634,
-0.008321058,
-0.0045038187,
-0.0379058085,
0.0330358483,
-0.0279921051,
0.006350508,
-0.0151571091,
0.0289321765,
0.0024604318,
0.0099323634,
-0.0283737592,
-0.0199266747,
-0.0518591888,
0.0435980372,
-0.009766303,
0.0716942251,
0.0224266928,
0.0240309425,
0.0400385037,
0.0583137497,
-0.0045406693,
0.0045721899,
-0.0512452386,
0.0342126042,
0.0285602994,
0.0171600115,
0.0927843526,
-0.0205132011,
0.015624729,
0.0137254708,
0.1016903371,
-0.012391529,
-0.0363582708,
0.0013405655,
-0.0050106291,
-0.0040220912,
-0.034949407,
0.0919636562,
0.0007257368,
0.0004296638,
-0.0120731518,
0.0090084616,
-0.0323890522,
-0.0249539502,
0.0114316316,
0.0022341083,
0.015829701,
-0.0054757576,
-0.0177411176,
-0.0497096702,
-0.0098699257,
0.0441105329,
-0.0098927477,
-0.0196805373,
0.0425675251,
0.053510882,
-0.0488782078,
-0.0050028106,
-0.0505585298,
-0.0107639944,
-0.0376509838,
0.0104178805,
-0.0167865679,
-5.925833796e-33,
-0.0609317645,
-0.0827168822,
0.0209161323,
-0.0159581248,
-0.0171531215,
-0.0091363285,
-0.0832166374,
-0.0141527941,
0.0541881062,
0.0403207727,
0.0223364122,
-0.0011252558,
-0.0054326546,
0.0360764861,
-0.0045673274,
-0.0170489307,
0.0440562852,
0.0112716127,
-0.0667603537,
0.0812724084,
0.0448456854,
0.0096860733,
0.0311243199,
-0.0214532465,
0.0367467776,
-0.0180242453,
-0.0601293594,
0.0089205233,
-0.0171187595,
0.0398993976,
-0.0349238105,
0.0156702027,
0.0182646289,
-0.0042511881,
-0.0189182498,
0.00463366,
-0.0267296061,
-0.0251406152,
0.0121633876,
-0.0269237719,
-0.0619186163,
-0.0542609319,
0.0275125783,
-0.0254199393,
-0.0190907288,
0.0134846326,
0.0256707985,
-0.0108306743,
0.0004137634,
-0.0199447852,
-0.0461268835,
0.0099679343,
-0.0387152582,
-0.06696257,
-0.0280149076,
0.0235236064,
-0.0246553309,
0.0098922206,
-0.019275954,
0.0057441713,
0.0277254283,
0.0378653482,
0.0904529393,
-0.0194898732,
-0.0265207775,
0.0465818979,
0.0075846408,
-0.0065581319,
-0.0469970033,
0.0171082504,
-0.0080786338,
0.0400955267,
0.063408576,
0.0678505823,
-0.0065904586,
-0.011539869,
-0.0449885093,
0.0892249942,
-0.0375008322,
0.0014482905,
0.0094789872,
-0.0093509145,
-0.0334213711,
-0.0157754775,
-0.0271401331,
-0.0682739466,
-0.0200992916,
-0.0290819537,
0.0341435187,
0.0223842207,
-0.0260663256,
-0.0479424931,
-0.0003963124,
0.019237658,
0.0271415878,
-0.009648297,
-0.0674360394,
0.0047954577,
-0.0089755133,
-0.0050716167,
-0.0441540517,
-0.0168480631,
0.0345114768,
0.0518335402,
0.0289244726,
0.002194705,
0.0310995225,
0.0296970867,
-0.0369098596,
0.0381734967,
-0.0746354982,
0.0487724952,
-0.0153504508,
-0.0338429436,
0.003669298,
-0.0364001915,
-0.0525136217,
0.0486101918,
-0.0099483915,
0.0111036887,
0.0088941287,
-0.0068681189,
-0.0097681703,
0.0064827446,
-0.0547598675,
0.0032369501,
-0.002555992,
-0.0257000178,
0.02389507,
-0.0506430753,
-0.0080353748,
0.0278527271,
2.388e-7,
0.0155205633,
0.0373462625,
0.0246674269,
0.0029124478,
0.00181057,
0.0413047597,
0.0024194031,
0.0235865824,
-0.0239507519,
-0.0129137747,
0.0132830888,
0.0054838439,
0.0532495007,
0.0264625326,
-0.0322416686,
0.0320658013,
-0.0597520657,
0.0031967915,
-0.0464168563,
-0.0534730107,
0.0877567679,
0.0118318042,
-0.0267024767,
-0.0306365751,
0.0576784313,
-0.0454524681,
0.0633350611,
-0.016275961,
-0.0340254754,
0.0015346025,
0.072154291,
0.021364009,
-0.0180055276,
0.0043338104,
-0.0373965502,
-0.0438754894,
0.0079697045,
0.0579553284,
0.0254319794,
-0.0272064507,
0.0116349226,
-0.0014561614,
0.0296029579,
-0.056240879,
0.0365461037,
-0.0309134834,
-0.0376266688,
0.0534201935,
-0.0222249292,
-0.037781354,
0.000709669,
-0.0483899489,
-0.0245300215,
0.0330487862,
0.0010069655,
-0.0000872826,
-0.0029234893,
-0.0289043654,
-0.0540297218,
-0.018285865,
-0.0308167469,
0.0014683056,
-0.080443278,
0.0026763002,
-0.0022869254,
-0.0628713816,
-0.0206275992,
2.024937563e-34,
0.0052856873,
-0.0347044431,
0.0234102048,
-0.0239350982,
0.0485677011,
0.0284452625,
0.0139696384,
-0.0016286881,
0.0317557342,
-0.0248861089,
-0.0143296132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14281v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14281v2 | Weakly-Supervised Learning of Visual Relations in Multimodal Pretraining | 2023-05-23T17:27:12 | 2023-10-19T17:46:34 | Emanuele Bugliarello, Aida Nematzadeh, Lisa Anne Hendricks | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent work in vision-and-language pretraining has investigated supervised
signals from object detection data to learn better, fine-grained multimodal
representations. In this work, we take a step further and explore how we can
tap into supervision from small-scale visual relation data. In particular, we
propose two pretraining approaches to contextualise visual entities in a
multimodal setup. With verbalised scene graphs, we transform visual relation
triplets into structured captions, and treat them as additional image
descriptions. With masked relation prediction, we further encourage relating
entities from image regions with visually masked contexts. When applied to
strong baselines pretrained on large amounts of Web data, zero-shot evaluations
on both coarse-grained and fine-grained tasks show the efficacy of our methods
in learning multimodal representations from weakly-supervised relations data. | [
0.0297175311,
0.0407418273,
0.0094890511,
0.0746958107,
0.0178909767,
0.0130092232,
-0.0028621824,
0.0068091941,
0.0009829686,
-0.1008269042,
-0.0540564209,
-0.0090896171,
-0.0188185498,
0.0405016392,
0.0412424281,
-0.0940297246,
0.0069064549,
0.0169816539,
-0.0172832534,
0.017432617,
0.0550952703,
0.0234986283,
-0.0166714825,
0.0128519973,
-0.0591340065,
-0.0001863556,
0.0049730153,
0.0187032707,
0.0193009824,
-0.0880446509,
0.0049186791,
0.0318053253,
0.0644049942,
-0.018224569,
0.0000018417,
-0.0233511273,
0.0347697735,
-0.0156575367,
0.0214712806,
-0.0223768558,
-0.0297687519,
-0.0858743712,
0.048452694,
-0.0435334966,
-0.036993634,
-0.0444907881,
0.0601410381,
0.0416155346,
0.0720631853,
0.0226289593,
-0.0574103557,
-0.0129270749,
-0.0126279155,
-0.0376189277,
0.0228694137,
-0.0246165749,
-0.0118273664,
0.0102011273,
-0.0341888145,
0.0106610991,
-0.087088123,
-0.0007285065,
0.0031121722,
-0.0045789503,
0.0466529168,
0.062492054,
-0.0256583765,
-0.0133145154,
-0.0094693042,
0.1146545112,
0.0051541617,
0.0101608774,
-0.024618607,
-0.0023644343,
-0.0201217104,
0.0031365191,
-0.0276509784,
-0.0050056195,
-0.0276509747,
0.0064178561,
-0.0718663335,
0.0193920676,
0.0086042481,
0.0024990374,
-0.0078461571,
-0.0145574659,
-0.0110500837,
0.0285058655,
0.0140938638,
0.0217181742,
-0.0230646282,
-0.049146384,
-0.0259827971,
0.0357222892,
-0.0076273619,
-0.0023094604,
-0.0508538745,
-0.0027980378,
-0.0223336443,
-0.0110777803,
0.0150279282,
-0.015479913,
-0.0757331923,
0.0709201917,
-0.0457976498,
0.006267088,
-0.039975848,
0.0138863567,
-0.0211027656,
0.0121326409,
-0.0424615704,
0.0100878477,
-0.0224561561,
0.0252010133,
-0.0114232693,
-0.0279050544,
-0.0074302317,
-0.0031191951,
-0.0205923393,
0.0051954044,
-0.032388892,
0.0376990922,
-0.031962987,
0.0015509423,
-0.018970564,
0.0326390341,
-0.0555777475,
0.029417146,
-0.0631335527,
-0.0107164374,
-0.0048498455,
0.0162539352,
0.0369032286,
-0.0426837914,
0.0032735304,
0.1077626497,
-0.0187616292,
-0.052459415,
-0.0352215059,
-0.0837234929,
-0.0125492662,
-0.0234601162,
0.0455981754,
-0.0092491722,
0.0542884246,
0.0039365934,
0.0440067537,
-0.0015676306,
0.0179743059,
-0.0301887598,
-0.0344811007,
0.0902339295,
-0.0419378094,
-0.0247369409,
-0.0320054926,
0.0137523403,
0.0011372754,
0.0487495735,
0.0078199571,
0.0403954461,
0.00369704,
-0.0040207561,
-0.0141429286,
0.0056885229,
0.0387024432,
0.0243294127,
-0.0166418012,
-0.0171566755,
-0.012385428,
-0.0093686525,
0.0602825694,
0.0152803464,
-0.0325967669,
-0.0356207229,
0.0389575399,
0.0124503877,
-0.0086991349,
-0.0006797013,
0.0621392727,
-0.0207948629,
0.0061055664,
0.0264630876,
-0.0796211511,
0.0717095435,
0.0065985546,
-0.0031067946,
-0.0179300457,
0.0240826141,
-0.031821195,
0.0107022952,
0.0351762213,
-0.0157898646,
-0.0058787633,
-0.0084582223,
0.0723672956,
0.0522695184,
-0.0393875539,
0.0002141497,
0.0613364652,
0.0116517339,
0.0119367074,
0.0130487047,
-0.0142018385,
0.0448227152,
0.0053366586,
0.0051224595,
-0.0203463137,
-0.0038426085,
0.0665414706,
0.0078503983,
0.0109532773,
-0.0279623438,
0.0452658758,
-0.0227406099,
-0.0787977502,
-0.0344723985,
-0.0230357405,
0.0245796293,
0.011593692,
-0.0115854088,
0.036655657,
-0.0410991162,
0.0524897091,
0.0404269136,
0.0703428909,
-0.005082991,
-0.0326484554,
0.0347746164,
0.0173352342,
0.0147753377,
-0.0202549696,
-0.0307937376,
0.0135104517,
-0.0399839915,
0.0040940498,
0.0174991675,
-0.0348056592,
-0.0436893664,
-0.0009574376,
-0.0385189652,
-0.0094334101,
-0.0273305085,
-0.0208009779,
-0.009037192,
0.0063380525,
-0.0048979684,
0.0225382522,
-0.0083266515,
-0.0586284362,
0.0459956042,
0.0232206322,
-0.0058039189,
0.0518633164,
-0.0064767515,
0.0078804633,
0.0036974233,
-0.0149667514,
0.0241465177,
0.02523016,
-0.0130070392,
-0.0219983999,
0.0022989837,
-0.0153576173,
0.0207960531,
0.0067924224,
-0.0397129655,
0.0511754416,
-0.0890455171,
-0.0320584513,
0.0222732052,
-0.0193330441,
-0.0109348325,
-0.0141306529,
0.0342373699,
-0.07228861,
-0.0049068341,
0.0453761481,
-0.0236384012,
0.0203389525,
0.0274225473,
0.0268011615,
0.0023522261,
-0.0026385589,
-0.0108523425,
-0.0177592747,
0.087502934,
0.0249731001,
-0.0416061319,
-0.0092294849,
0.0174690746,
-0.0482235812,
0.0446256362,
-0.016361773,
-0.0187792573,
0.025464246,
-0.0138017116,
0.0416778177,
0.0305058528,
-0.0166067723,
0.0511016212,
0.015309616,
-0.0314646363,
-0.0137612745,
-0.0004762129,
-0.0010234768,
-0.0341400318,
-0.0288989637,
-0.0077347206,
-0.0418517403,
0.0354441889,
0.0077533061,
-0.0039171283,
-0.0570829436,
0.0168001875,
0.0043078135,
-0.041516412,
-0.0690204948,
0.0232711323,
0.0415060483,
0.0013774902,
-0.0562673174,
-0.0285072103,
0.0517645031,
-0.0209672377,
-0.0033411321,
0.0666338056,
0.0028650938,
-0.0057267044,
0.1155497283,
0.0382360294,
0.0513498709,
-0.0147376256,
-0.0017184459,
-0.0674708262,
-0.0174251497,
0.0085589131,
0.0465480499,
0.0004692148,
-0.0362649783,
0.0087252576,
-0.0174304545,
-0.0274129957,
-0.0055991374,
-0.0213213954,
-0.0275183506,
-0.0113255773,
-0.0434609391,
0.0131773343,
0.0181158893,
0.0185309108,
0.0204479545,
0.0106045892,
0.0015473487,
-0.029644832,
-0.0140707679,
0.0456446745,
0.0406130441,
0.0025023425,
-0.0567531884,
-0.0403040349,
-0.0010890769,
0.0383131914,
0.0141203851,
-0.0075791674,
-0.0488526337,
0.0533423163,
-0.0260180198,
0.0416001268,
-0.0148540288,
0.0170566402,
0.0433395319,
-0.0388670862,
-0.0001543203,
0.0437716544,
-0.0068573123,
-0.0483947098,
0.0034176034,
0.052907832,
0.0015759863,
0.0862880722,
-0.0019953421,
-0.0837078243,
-0.0579631627,
-0.0490333065,
-0.0214024726,
0.0493167341,
-0.0256573707,
-0.0169068482,
-0.0745839179,
-0.0125989513,
-0.0064999131,
-0.0555210821,
-0.0178055782,
-0.0334460437,
0.017995676,
0.00988058,
-0.0369642228,
-0.0297067724,
-0.0192844197,
-0.0057446309,
0.0150195835,
0.0516060404,
-0.0244670361,
0.0151814483,
-0.060883753,
-0.0018298896,
0.0337015353,
0.0186894219,
-0.0179967247,
0.0104804896,
0.0289483834,
-0.0022055984,
0.0322886519,
-0.0214954168,
0.0943359211,
-0.0564238541,
-0.0545325726,
0.0023227348,
0.0068648919,
0.0008564736,
-0.0433575101,
-0.0283833388,
0.0374718942,
-0.021940643,
-0.0044210786,
-0.0239807833,
-0.0027553334,
0.0090954201,
0.0129694799,
0.0093904063,
-0.0333981924,
0.0052226037,
0.0237300359,
0.0487171263,
-0.022572346,
0.0062311608,
0.0037190432,
-0.0624709241,
0.0141651472,
-0.0573741049,
-0.030746296,
0.0756720826,
0.0435073487,
0.0134976376,
-0.0124506764,
0.0003604323,
0.018269809,
-0.0882996693,
0.0805196986,
-0.0168819763,
0.0126260845,
-0.0079433275,
-0.0378738157,
0.043955151,
-0.0333865173,
-0.0062810974,
0.0034255446,
-0.0703483745,
0.0050456692,
-0.0389729217,
0.0703922957,
0.0055515296,
0.0450033508,
0.0445686281,
-0.0156847853,
0.011282282,
0.054875683,
-0.0392781943,
0.0339848883,
-0.0062633357,
-0.0361566581,
-0.0147295492,
-0.0052262559,
-0.064951703,
0.0423678458,
0.019448828,
0.0224048737,
0.0013832776,
-0.0250568222,
0.0185599271,
-0.031559445,
0.0679478124,
-0.0373593308,
0.0383240953,
-0.022450231,
-0.0055528791,
0.0206406303,
-0.012688634,
-0.0492741689,
0.0057289824,
0.0132835908,
0.0358284377,
-0.0028566492,
0.0036769726,
0.0282110684,
0.0678615123,
-0.0389770046,
-0.0331065133,
0.0339660682,
-0.0361474305,
0.0099383453,
0.0390290767,
0.012608435,
0.0308597311,
-0.0156812575,
0.0018437867,
-0.0158395022,
0.0555587932,
0.0336631872,
-0.0120728426,
-0.0498313643,
0.0298247114,
-0.0073015797,
0.033128567,
-0.0447890423,
0.0082143722,
0.0174740087,
-0.0142982779,
0.0001753522,
-0.0173806939,
-0.0058618383,
0.038075082,
0.0615721382,
-0.0245879572,
-0.0314565226,
0.0570242144,
0.0242530778,
0.0055293739,
0.0402352251,
0.0812146142,
0.0142394705,
0.0720108747,
0.0169943385,
-0.0020143073,
-0.0388556346,
-0.014936246,
0.0392376743,
0.0386684313,
0.0075608506,
0.0422913618,
-0.0042744111,
-0.0678342879,
-0.0161578171,
-0.0293923113,
-0.0174556673,
0.0434797592,
0.0631737933,
0.003469707,
0.0377799757,
-0.0276755318,
0.0048382431,
-0.0125679318,
0.0251359735,
0.0199854989,
0.0046781795,
-6.10453208e-33,
-0.0542988665,
-0.0590591952,
-0.0029599362,
-0.0073566698,
-0.0186539833,
0.0428563617,
-0.0355447456,
0.0001234389,
-0.0291524585,
0.0396702141,
0.0217507891,
0.0045974622,
-0.0070262928,
0.0249961577,
-0.0096123023,
-0.017705664,
0.0450085849,
0.0116092376,
0.0409836993,
0.032372091,
0.0210892223,
0.0284040086,
0.0845615119,
-0.1105811894,
0.0122095915,
0.021357486,
-0.0535737313,
0.0436769314,
0.019532023,
0.0351721495,
-0.0538607836,
-0.0045358897,
0.0318047516,
0.0167386644,
-0.0160187744,
0.0019447141,
-0.1385314763,
-0.0084252674,
0.0031149264,
0.014443812,
-0.0699967369,
0.0210141782,
0.0268244501,
-0.03783397,
0.0502877757,
-0.0317460746,
0.0535684265,
-0.0146609051,
0.0122525226,
-0.0518679433,
-0.0511319079,
-0.0070234896,
-0.0168642085,
-0.0295408163,
0.0369698964,
0.0101799844,
0.0470376983,
-0.0032057751,
0.0064368052,
0.0052672969,
-0.0348090418,
0.0078182397,
0.0238023978,
0.0561631247,
-0.0126177538,
0.0878001004,
0.0171659011,
-0.0033162693,
-0.0108541166,
0.0117839109,
0.0381493494,
0.0471021086,
-0.0025776019,
0.0640692338,
0.0282297451,
0.0383989289,
-0.0630871132,
0.0052123182,
-0.0732234642,
0.0522619449,
-0.0253248122,
0.0096570132,
0.0195490606,
-0.0196593199,
-0.0203585029,
-0.0062341192,
-0.0440515652,
-0.0219715443,
0.0302334856,
0.0010812118,
-0.0188075043,
0.0588571019,
0.0406352654,
-0.0405412018,
-0.0466081016,
0.0212860517,
-0.0014987653,
0.0504111573,
-0.003988455,
-0.0173839573,
-0.0187039413,
-0.0505873635,
0.0871895403,
-0.0336470045,
0.0472162738,
0.0220414568,
0.0867399201,
0.0352094546,
-0.034619607,
-0.0210160892,
-0.039465107,
-0.0292967167,
0.009973485,
0.0047678053,
0.0231052581,
0.0341140665,
-0.0672850385,
0.0413197912,
0.0332142822,
-0.0132021056,
-0.0091309091,
-0.0168100372,
0.0046322029,
0.0559956953,
-0.0128142582,
-0.0246393848,
-0.0322272666,
-0.0681354478,
0.0576801635,
-0.0786729231,
-0.0130053554,
0.0119585823,
2.559e-7,
0.0283209383,
0.020840656,
0.0191986598,
0.0214092433,
-0.0060425657,
0.0421669446,
-0.0053909798,
0.0603804328,
-0.0308065377,
-0.0686089247,
0.019960992,
0.0341035202,
-0.0253846534,
0.0221884884,
-0.0190517791,
-0.0013239401,
-0.0249476954,
-0.0357606113,
-0.0756013691,
0.005648145,
0.0609502569,
0.0712237954,
0.0166194551,
-0.0120208887,
0.0260748379,
-0.0646624342,
0.0764310285,
-0.0249869861,
0.0200865865,
-0.012609886,
-0.0235828161,
0.0245254524,
-0.037799608,
0.0562564842,
-0.01897588,
-0.0325194113,
0.051250197,
-0.0026463629,
-0.0427412465,
0.0217129365,
-0.0169564821,
0.0352349877,
-0.004163072,
0.0196258072,
0.0667157024,
-0.0639264584,
-0.0217503086,
-0.0008246434,
-0.028446991,
-0.0071968501,
-0.0347075947,
-0.0209305827,
-0.0119711999,
0.027647512,
0.0240140092,
0.0255423598,
-0.0498911887,
-0.0868474245,
-0.0296440441,
0.0610299781,
-0.0008136171,
-0.0241563693,
-0.0073353131,
-0.0310466439,
0.0306563135,
-0.039260719,
-0.0488098562,
1.718095311e-34,
-0.013982106,
0.0081798807,
-0.0024789756,
0.0069976156,
0.0324692279,
-0.0408403464,
-0.0481240563,
-0.0026031281,
0.0086126747,
-0.035177514,
-0.0122112092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14280v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14280v2 | Multilingual Pixel Representations for Translation and Effective Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-23T17:26:50 | 2023-10-24T13:36:49 | Elizabeth Salesky, Neha Verma, Philipp Koehn, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce and demonstrate how to effectively train multilingual machine
translation models with pixel representations. We experiment with two different
data settings with a variety of language and script coverage, demonstrating
improved performance compared to subword embeddings. We explore various
properties of pixel representations such as parameter sharing within and across
scripts to better understand where they lead to positive transfer. We observe
that these properties not only enable seamless cross-lingual transfer to unseen
scripts, but make pixel representations more data-efficient than alternatives
such as vocabulary expansion. We hope this work contributes to more extensible
multilingual models for all languages and scripts. | [
-0.018929651,
0.0225670468,
-0.0178449955,
0.0775571689,
-0.0305910371,
0.0029866255,
0.0140899448,
0.0223763771,
-0.0218709484,
-0.0235174634,
-0.036360871,
-0.0492229797,
0.0164992828,
0.0244634785,
0.0691035017,
-0.0766140521,
0.0080960104,
-0.0358836539,
-0.0472110584,
0.0024667149,
0.0152725866,
0.0285882708,
0.0227400903,
0.009270086,
-0.0268453732,
-0.0224369206,
0.015766941,
0.0304310191,
0.067756176,
0.0132878674,
-0.0404614732,
0.0089513743,
0.0689702705,
0.0271793213,
0.0000018719,
-0.0185601637,
-0.0259023458,
-0.0061334763,
0.0338573754,
0.0153902126,
0.0968134105,
-0.0859041438,
-0.0210522078,
-0.0192932039,
-0.0138453292,
0.0005964204,
0.0919707343,
-0.0106719462,
0.0260001533,
0.0677217394,
-0.0479191206,
-0.0147918686,
-0.027302295,
-0.0326900557,
0.0263776518,
-0.0168360304,
-0.0261462331,
0.0103574432,
-0.0172110833,
-0.0063504018,
-0.0445498787,
0.0270538367,
-0.0212799869,
-0.0033686638,
-0.0256196447,
0.0207821894,
0.0075597893,
-0.0326055586,
-0.0144128911,
0.0822051391,
-0.0584242009,
-0.0080446228,
-0.038183134,
-0.0044015441,
-0.0289204493,
0.0153666325,
-0.0595270805,
0.0130848,
0.0268846173,
0.0177495312,
-0.0089545129,
0.0436085984,
0.0437344797,
-0.0420648716,
-0.02621755,
-0.0299817286,
0.0357228518,
0.001241477,
-0.0309342295,
0.0280340705,
-0.0023203511,
0.0003707957,
0.0442936197,
-0.0174171831,
0.0726390406,
0.0205890331,
-0.0283318534,
-0.0456188619,
0.0221950319,
-0.017333772,
0.0592515506,
0.034114521,
-0.048249051,
0.0576021783,
-0.0448189601,
0.0498616621,
-0.0217413325,
0.024921516,
-0.02238339,
-0.0077954391,
-0.0357994325,
0.0274990387,
-0.0342421196,
-0.0013053672,
-0.0128566287,
-0.0081451694,
0.045912113,
0.0252938028,
-0.0037217992,
-0.001374269,
0.0061207353,
-0.0356912464,
-0.0431609005,
-0.0258646216,
0.0023439131,
0.0657435954,
-0.0104094418,
-0.0196724534,
-0.0131800557,
-0.040818654,
-0.0403181724,
0.0151527068,
0.0501897149,
-0.0162001923,
0.0045066755,
0.0899298042,
-0.0212016776,
-0.0628499314,
-0.0166349728,
0.0223333519,
-0.0366919413,
-0.0220023617,
-0.0056761671,
-0.0619078279,
0.0864689872,
-0.0122287916,
0.0321743414,
-0.0377573743,
0.0045237606,
0.0084639937,
-0.014974473,
0.0767865479,
0.0130739808,
-0.0200969055,
-0.0082978886,
-0.0148539143,
-0.0092332531,
0.0873760432,
0.0683543608,
0.0418112874,
0.0362259187,
-0.029910801,
-0.0630848482,
0.0524189137,
-0.00249448,
0.0473444983,
-0.0294741429,
-0.033494167,
0.0646624714,
0.0145731382,
0.0347417369,
0.0342777409,
-0.0199006386,
-0.0208504256,
0.0576627217,
0.0236984789,
-0.0090308702,
0.0182425473,
0.0711308718,
0.0014490755,
-0.0463799983,
-0.0021410568,
0.0111810155,
0.0306648947,
0.0951256007,
-0.0105137732,
0.0200078487,
0.0529984273,
-0.0141232247,
0.012058083,
0.006423125,
-0.0324070193,
0.0079655731,
-0.0251545645,
0.0174598191,
0.0328712761,
-0.0609840155,
0.0075934669,
0.0158365946,
-0.0743981451,
0.0438643619,
-0.0070404056,
-0.0090074893,
0.0812613368,
0.0348584689,
0.0186766312,
-0.028032558,
-0.0231978595,
0.0365629978,
0.0347394608,
0.0481459312,
-0.0020229046,
0.0790734068,
-0.075860627,
0.0157321617,
-0.0213249922,
-0.0239686407,
0.108082138,
-0.0389708728,
0.0350539684,
-0.0065323026,
-0.0814990401,
-0.0208633076,
0.0146280015,
-0.017568389,
-0.0157710277,
-0.0062069716,
0.0259351227,
0.0041323965,
0.0017666982,
-0.0394010097,
-0.0237091295,
0.0054057585,
-0.0578816682,
0.0178061873,
0.0056116991,
-0.0288484078,
-0.057778161,
-0.0074317944,
-0.0472899228,
0.017160818,
-0.0011248611,
-0.0183699876,
-0.0175811443,
0.0004766919,
-0.0266711917,
0.0657987818,
-0.0243535452,
-0.004966903,
-0.0035610737,
0.0511495285,
-0.0299982298,
0.0088693546,
-0.0124811986,
-0.0098265791,
0.0028691317,
0.004868736,
0.0308812596,
-0.0223981496,
0.0251353625,
0.0662411898,
0.0048651118,
0.028363904,
0.0247986522,
0.010874222,
0.0149867544,
-0.0385016352,
-0.0330015607,
-0.0010169004,
0.0009109697,
-0.002502681,
0.0059847319,
0.0307687446,
0.0105716847,
-0.0209024046,
-0.0072617643,
0.0436445475,
-0.0051684612,
0.0087976195,
0.0153998202,
-0.0005530592,
0.0149771906,
-0.0271972138,
-0.0106845554,
-0.0078972289,
0.0678705424,
-0.0259792395,
-0.0215655379,
-0.0213345941,
0.0292652175,
-0.0105779413,
-0.0024947934,
-0.0219353922,
-0.0354332365,
-0.0110897711,
-0.0357548855,
0.0214415807,
0.0537808798,
-0.0340938382,
0.0008091283,
0.0459702983,
-0.0631202683,
-0.0370722935,
0.001596282,
0.0237344429,
-0.0351131968,
-0.0156883597,
-0.0436586626,
-0.0192425363,
0.0653979033,
0.0163771864,
0.0057806456,
-0.0887449384,
-0.0236134604,
0.0078789173,
-0.0258052312,
0.0018288085,
0.0504723229,
0.0185415354,
0.0347962044,
-0.0429725237,
-0.0618931837,
0.0511681102,
-0.0733361468,
-0.0470875837,
-0.0293144751,
0.0170574952,
-0.0223991852,
0.0461066328,
0.0274265297,
0.0453295223,
-0.0447404385,
0.0033523566,
-0.0427918509,
0.0311075971,
0.0297310166,
-0.0174120218,
0.0192111339,
-0.0273297597,
-0.0073266639,
-0.0318105705,
-0.011064304,
-0.0002283388,
-0.0127477236,
0.0126533369,
-0.0140146036,
-0.0022331572,
-0.023497317,
0.0006548492,
0.0273904204,
0.0022632924,
0.0320228711,
0.0305302739,
-0.003950465,
-0.0273039248,
0.0110537354,
0.0106480001,
-0.0025993485,
-0.0328435488,
-0.0261172019,
0.061374139,
-0.0024357322,
-0.0211983565,
-0.0062396112,
-0.0503358059,
0.0284359548,
0.0294246078,
0.0391518027,
-0.0241972022,
-0.0102598984,
0.0715352893,
-0.0463676788,
0.0117920712,
0.0595919043,
0.0122488178,
-0.0464592278,
-0.0314609259,
-0.0444926992,
0.0391346961,
0.0139755346,
0.0138826286,
-0.0865205377,
-0.0433744341,
-0.0178521164,
-0.0029767381,
0.0523914173,
0.012850496,
-0.0479937643,
-0.0915557072,
0.0320053324,
0.0463171601,
-0.0486402586,
-0.0509080477,
-0.0281207971,
-0.0244072434,
-0.0216747485,
-0.00783082,
-0.0545397773,
0.0009661133,
-0.0114385597,
-0.0070211818,
0.0338970795,
-0.0288654733,
0.0136458501,
-0.0470194966,
-0.0089671519,
0.0794038251,
0.0481264628,
-0.0125010666,
-0.0278188866,
-0.0583824441,
-0.0333337337,
-0.0137256794,
0.0008140433,
0.0569828711,
-0.0286072418,
-0.0357016362,
0.0545264184,
-0.0140901143,
-0.0376652963,
-0.031162031,
-0.0072964644,
0.0770169944,
0.0004837348,
-0.0418563001,
-0.004277837,
0.0198160913,
-0.0079415916,
0.0324436836,
0.0090610581,
-0.0419498719,
-0.0100225955,
-0.0168802142,
0.013527425,
-0.0521994866,
0.0247739889,
-0.0009775615,
-0.040207684,
-0.0588413998,
-0.0845457241,
-0.0443666652,
0.0360008515,
0.0501525961,
0.0322670788,
-0.0290621333,
-0.0295475367,
0.0197958164,
-0.0245379321,
-0.0026587872,
-0.0358407423,
0.0161001217,
-0.0373771116,
-0.0332862884,
0.0107115991,
-0.0342821404,
0.0086047947,
-0.004196174,
-0.0872010961,
-0.0549175516,
-0.0500866361,
0.0766976997,
0.0107031791,
0.027211247,
-0.012628586,
-0.0317541882,
0.029216066,
0.0048767189,
0.0171554275,
-0.006173641,
0.0487981103,
-0.0047755074,
-0.0116614467,
0.0360917188,
-0.0195571743,
0.0081617208,
-0.0302032474,
0.0251463298,
-0.033125449,
-0.0540403053,
0.0044253529,
-0.0330283716,
0.0173958261,
-0.0137342662,
-0.0039362386,
-0.0468573458,
0.0029655807,
-0.0038748446,
0.0179634709,
-0.0494710244,
-0.0312306825,
0.0706152096,
-0.0052954578,
0.0139694251,
0.008758598,
-0.0014016579,
-0.0415942855,
-0.0068829153,
0.0283794533,
0.0008906161,
0.0177107174,
0.0050117411,
0.0671786666,
-0.0007386176,
0.0132172443,
-0.0461071543,
0.0153574934,
-0.0442297943,
0.0487261787,
-0.011523216,
-0.0266956519,
0.0240154583,
0.0365730152,
-0.0086608808,
-0.0269234441,
-0.0039141076,
0.0051995153,
0.0639657453,
-0.0294025782,
0.1029540822,
-0.0133017441,
0.0025302921,
-0.0106843635,
0.043153327,
0.0149678076,
-0.022276409,
0.0287379064,
-0.0005539259,
0.0035748526,
0.0130317491,
0.0605230145,
0.0043844664,
-0.0053562582,
-0.0179160647,
-0.0003193534,
-0.012867447,
0.003352117,
0.0385967456,
-0.0038511674,
0.009319081,
0.0167824216,
-0.0033268477,
-0.0784304887,
0.0052897381,
-0.0137725184,
-0.0063754558,
0.0132791111,
0.0188858602,
0.0852189064,
-0.025358256,
0.0200609528,
-0.041138947,
0.0043633096,
0.0133218113,
-0.0151759358,
-0.0013003302,
-5.279231088e-33,
-0.0303981695,
0.0496201552,
0.0032647979,
0.0351884738,
0.0051488024,
-0.0013231472,
-0.0265529025,
-0.0156814251,
-0.0237172022,
0.0093796933,
0.0281123742,
-0.0062942007,
0.0193405394,
0.0166025851,
-0.0126413517,
-0.0123460311,
0.0585586913,
0.0283087045,
-0.0136239883,
0.0344344862,
0.0346207246,
0.043155659,
0.1006992236,
-0.0358559266,
0.0019542123,
-0.0027175096,
-0.0013107461,
-0.0262449328,
0.0811408907,
0.0275165364,
-0.0154904593,
0.0113008097,
0.0181789044,
-0.0110082999,
-0.0408775173,
0.028329229,
-0.0585456416,
-0.0102358814,
0.0053873966,
0.0504765771,
-0.0338257775,
-0.0738650933,
0.0093768034,
-0.0681016222,
0.0250313766,
-0.0358485393,
0.0355306268,
-0.0310021862,
-0.0338987671,
0.0176155027,
-0.0754376352,
0.0215539373,
-0.0148252118,
-0.0357572362,
0.0549165308,
0.0664561242,
0.0260521211,
0.0376403257,
-0.0521103665,
0.0227025505,
-0.0502156429,
0.0476289615,
0.0711237341,
-0.002463517,
-0.0256396662,
0.0243838448,
0.021746086,
-0.0117129991,
0.0223783161,
0.0298716966,
0.0370440036,
0.0251496993,
0.0362781398,
0.0742484108,
0.0178469177,
-0.0066863401,
-0.0454754755,
0.0507070571,
-0.0124354158,
0.0283600353,
0.0217786413,
0.027870385,
0.0059589036,
0.0137151042,
-0.0489640348,
-0.0782988071,
-0.0023462081,
-0.0543775521,
0.0382243134,
-0.0055945423,
-0.0116694411,
0.0251134299,
0.1119926646,
-0.0430692472,
-0.0148552423,
0.0127479872,
-0.0521672778,
0.0391234346,
0.0014662263,
0.0454281121,
-0.0070391637,
-0.0570444874,
0.0122922091,
-0.0112291668,
0.0506953374,
-0.0155289089,
0.0533379354,
0.0403533764,
-0.059203729,
-0.0121308435,
-0.0441088341,
-0.0315572992,
-0.029932797,
0.0284153149,
0.0107294461,
-0.0038958304,
-0.0193534121,
0.0395531505,
0.0199538395,
-0.0222317316,
0.0055925678,
-0.0513079502,
-0.0230580382,
0.017646376,
-0.0602498911,
-0.0021607124,
-0.0526281632,
-0.0229980778,
0.038001854,
-0.0517841093,
-0.0414435752,
-0.0133813564,
2.447e-7,
0.0546129383,
0.0072994404,
0.0025714291,
-0.0050123772,
0.012704391,
0.0276481621,
-0.039878834,
0.0746677667,
-0.0131251849,
-0.0341363586,
-0.0013250972,
0.0262868963,
0.0555574037,
0.0226067491,
-0.0509038828,
-0.0172464121,
0.0062945755,
0.0129570458,
-0.0435490571,
0.0045742122,
0.0344609655,
0.1106393635,
-0.0122414967,
-0.0055267913,
0.0143750412,
-0.0672866702,
0.1133746877,
-0.0683902651,
-0.002647785,
-0.013916905,
-0.0072411038,
0.0217711441,
-0.0630294383,
0.0095203193,
-0.0296668801,
0.0255353134,
0.0610690825,
0.0707474276,
-0.0166541878,
0.0082756821,
-0.0068288534,
-0.0503926575,
-0.029602414,
-0.0411341451,
0.0628226846,
0.022054296,
-0.0342779048,
-0.0177241173,
0.0168222561,
0.0361198895,
0.0464011878,
-0.0565156378,
-0.0603870861,
0.0091451872,
0.0723938867,
0.0072222929,
-0.050343588,
-0.0256281737,
-0.024409337,
0.053481102,
0.0100009413,
-0.0208572913,
-0.0387517177,
-0.0219294056,
0.0439526513,
0.0049162479,
0.0026126422,
2.110326667e-34,
0.0190353654,
-0.0304974932,
0.0195393935,
-0.0300155953,
0.039023757,
-0.0520693883,
-0.0077150147,
0.0071120532,
-0.0161654893,
-0.0441908017,
-0.0241886005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14279v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14279v4 | Two Failures of Self-Consistency in the Multi-Step Reasoning of LLMs | 2023-05-23T17:25:59 | 2024-02-02T18:37:07 | Angelica Chen, Jason Phang, Alicia Parrish, Vishakh Padmakumar, Chen Zhao, Samuel R. Bowman, Kyunghyun Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved widespread success on a variety of
in-context few-shot tasks, but this success is typically evaluated via
correctness rather than consistency. We argue that self-consistency is an
important criteria for valid multi-step reasoning in tasks where the solution
is composed of the answers to multiple sub-steps. We propose two types of
self-consistency that are particularly important for multi-step reasoning --
hypothetical consistency (a model's ability to predict what its output would be
in a hypothetical other context) and compositional consistency (consistency of
a model's final outputs when intermediate sub-steps are replaced with the
model's outputs for those steps). We demonstrate that multiple variants of the
GPT-3/-4 models exhibit poor consistency rates across both types of consistency
on a variety of tasks. | [
0.0078827189,
0.0219091345,
-0.0042078802,
0.0095789311,
-0.0733540058,
0.0135745769,
0.0020738698,
-0.0145789813,
-0.0089228749,
-0.0484565571,
-0.0065299477,
-0.0210504849,
0.0067574801,
-0.0263016764,
0.0247231834,
-0.0160882603,
0.0687540919,
-0.079036206,
-0.0248921122,
-0.0304450747,
-0.0165142193,
-0.0116356611,
-0.0158755127,
0.0220273323,
0.0153526301,
-0.0477242619,
-0.0252074227,
-0.002478997,
-0.0117954286,
-0.0206755064,
-0.0310048126,
0.0550360046,
0.0428075716,
0.0334160253,
0.0000020689,
-0.0662185103,
0.0136928558,
-0.006389569,
-0.0602633841,
0.018074777,
-0.035931278,
-0.0106684454,
-0.0127973435,
0.0205270424,
-0.0131781669,
0.0188493542,
0.0095539726,
0.02963778,
0.0553060248,
0.056279242,
0.0151946638,
-0.0689830035,
0.0116421608,
-0.0111307185,
0.0214144439,
-0.0501833409,
0.029075956,
0.0490722805,
0.0265363175,
0.0185631588,
-0.0002146279,
0.0238244459,
0.0510126352,
0.0261432398,
-0.0687731728,
0.0359168239,
-0.0065683494,
-0.027331369,
-0.0139163723,
0.0108311474,
0.013000166,
-0.0191937108,
-0.0120944735,
-0.0140750986,
-0.025522422,
-0.0016611327,
-0.0708864555,
0.0427507646,
-0.0163893104,
0.0314087309,
-0.0033340112,
-0.0202081427,
0.0377294309,
0.0013514531,
-0.0550242662,
0.1292497665,
0.006027197,
-0.047997091,
-0.0096623665,
0.0151462583,
-0.0182897151,
-0.0704640001,
-0.0025101372,
0.0608019233,
-0.0131176757,
0.0303450152,
-0.0022936973,
0.0403636545,
0.0318110809,
-0.019460272,
0.0229782201,
0.0699711591,
0.0037545753,
0.0501874126,
-0.0205471069,
0.0524414219,
-0.0399747714,
0.021601107,
-0.0224342179,
-0.0053925011,
-0.0510113835,
-0.0298736542,
-0.0315147005,
0.0668143108,
0.0103727411,
-0.011039786,
-0.054725714,
0.0201983377,
-0.0131646888,
0.0242824871,
0.0252031069,
-0.0316328518,
-0.0040088645,
-0.0449119657,
-0.0317216925,
0.0354418606,
-0.0300983209,
0.0391054116,
0.0101136006,
-0.0310873929,
-0.0155010568,
-0.0188493151,
-0.0288281571,
-0.0374503136,
-0.004632697,
0.0617612712,
0.0187946353,
-0.0171444882,
-0.0649875998,
-0.0329498686,
-0.0494876243,
-0.1309698075,
0.0159642827,
-0.0798976943,
0.0469035357,
0.0192999691,
-0.0272285417,
-0.0196390525,
-0.0070655714,
0.0105013587,
-0.0213873256,
0.0793609396,
0.0289737005,
0.0346393026,
0.0062812013,
0.0390968136,
-0.0171906725,
0.0535205193,
0.0121799568,
-0.0047908383,
-0.0015433058,
-0.009276717,
0.0210834034,
0.055563055,
-0.0119528417,
-0.0136765698,
-0.0355592482,
0.021456521,
-0.0070116897,
0.0329813249,
0.0157375056,
0.0505787134,
-0.036077898,
-0.0018227998,
0.0535497442,
0.0673026815,
0.0520829409,
-0.0169914681,
0.0513205417,
-0.0255752485,
0.0133038061,
0.0639699847,
-0.0857652128,
0.0386543311,
-0.0550054088,
0.0357483998,
0.0123082623,
0.0190546438,
-0.0348665081,
-0.0363159403,
-0.0439432301,
0.0276572388,
-0.0202319324,
0.0030890063,
0.0641677454,
-0.0334408171,
-0.0254924856,
0.0463564023,
-0.0050159404,
-0.0378555171,
-0.0210483652,
-0.0654271767,
0.0381420478,
0.0656899363,
0.0281289909,
0.0142667945,
-0.0426548794,
0.0106463367,
0.038461946,
0.0187148713,
0.0237783417,
0.0290876087,
-0.009088275,
-0.0352327861,
-0.0346358679,
-0.0188220572,
0.0030603751,
0.0006264753,
0.0189204495,
0.0095777009,
0.0072751348,
-0.0182600953,
0.058266174,
0.0086046848,
-0.0375836454,
-0.0181236863,
-0.054028146,
-0.0043281098,
0.0223188195,
0.0115645221,
0.016680371,
0.028348418,
0.0286159143,
0.0134701245,
-0.0157499406,
0.0038932422,
-0.0744026378,
-0.0320958011,
0.0450054854,
0.027657276,
-0.0262786411,
-0.0067709056,
-0.0253071729,
-0.0470962413,
0.0196810998,
-0.0273901653,
0.0197396986,
-0.0427791551,
0.0573741943,
0.015447584,
-0.029391598,
-0.0251587201,
0.0589625537,
-0.01456415,
0.00358278,
0.0071991915,
0.0183005445,
0.0065800841,
-0.0560786277,
-0.0198734626,
0.0541384332,
0.0107842814,
-0.001429169,
0.0021821975,
0.0012487595,
-0.0516681224,
-0.0257811621,
-0.0474807881,
0.0038746682,
-0.0109706866,
0.0277433973,
0.0088444641,
-0.0147716589,
-0.0105639938,
0.0118127856,
0.0017220768,
0.0060593779,
0.0371162519,
0.0336587578,
0.0119619872,
-0.0060931607,
-0.0306510553,
-0.0170740113,
-0.0329109989,
-0.0384708755,
0.0144996811,
-0.0217110757,
-0.0143043911,
-0.0698592886,
0.0076979827,
-0.0529523119,
0.0219047759,
-0.010838531,
-0.0018598591,
0.0578980297,
-0.0080813309,
0.0450267829,
0.0348042846,
-0.0301763229,
0.0192354992,
0.0761753768,
-0.0426112786,
-0.0408524685,
0.0141517017,
-0.0172988195,
-0.0409097672,
0.0069174799,
-0.0287440978,
-0.0386783034,
0.0712219775,
0.0215828829,
0.0126719978,
-0.0448656939,
0.0150922006,
-0.0116789164,
-0.0103695132,
-0.0071709035,
-0.0324549749,
-0.0335201398,
0.0418750457,
-0.0111865159,
-0.0335285515,
0.0678904057,
-0.036212381,
0.0160578564,
-0.0045662094,
0.0146992058,
-0.020466404,
0.0788361207,
-0.015986193,
-0.0010896389,
-0.0043576723,
-0.0057445965,
-0.0303518716,
-0.0388963372,
0.0307138823,
-0.0138499821,
0.0728484839,
-0.0575702414,
0.0255705789,
-0.0201424826,
-0.0524355546,
-0.0193178747,
0.0110588726,
-0.0419938043,
0.0302362218,
-0.059914507,
0.0143045522,
-0.0176612865,
0.0256866347,
0.0563992634,
0.0136944493,
-0.0187907275,
-0.0394971184,
-0.0343071185,
0.0043619811,
0.0196991172,
0.0298144165,
0.0236683507,
-0.0258754715,
0.0488277562,
0.0470693819,
0.0559580997,
0.0312327165,
-0.0250497963,
0.0242365561,
0.0216866434,
-0.0141060269,
-0.0595397353,
0.0466347598,
0.0534230769,
-0.0737828612,
-0.0055027534,
0.1176723912,
0.0263562761,
0.0093986029,
0.0053303787,
-0.0609133244,
-0.008486486,
0.0137196844,
0.0125749996,
-0.0926605687,
-0.0364589728,
0.0288689733,
-0.0000442988,
0.0053325314,
-0.0157929249,
-0.0172510408,
-0.098085098,
0.0622612014,
0.033393316,
-0.0272480082,
0.003188523,
-0.0361891016,
0.0011030409,
0.0180020817,
0.04016684,
0.0610364377,
-0.0159615725,
-0.016061971,
-0.0033400154,
0.0011148528,
-0.0282201134,
0.058420416,
-0.0269004069,
0.0335410647,
0.0466638468,
-0.005760334,
-0.0023770209,
-0.051841002,
0.0721977577,
-0.0104096103,
0.0188734457,
-0.0146824829,
-0.0227335785,
0.007018989,
0.0155018615,
-0.039219629,
-0.0030611686,
-0.0153530724,
-0.0575542897,
-0.0017670648,
0.0961868018,
-0.0343156196,
-0.0661490336,
-0.0266480818,
0.0169978514,
-0.0545937009,
0.1053283587,
0.006081433,
-0.010865083,
-0.0741558671,
-0.0151199056,
-0.0294176247,
0.0055895355,
-0.0169739071,
0.0201383121,
0.0252359435,
0.0350837372,
-0.00531785,
-0.0371461548,
0.032769341,
0.0345464274,
-0.0264736582,
0.032569129,
0.0051675336,
-0.0028648609,
-0.0046362537,
0.0029310719,
-0.0330641568,
0.0234013107,
-0.0459103547,
0.0541805811,
0.0348332487,
-0.0307216104,
0.0125315739,
0.0161646064,
-0.074393414,
-0.0548669845,
-0.0111711174,
0.0308250431,
0.0402447954,
0.0369455777,
0.0110714808,
-0.0176701397,
0.0001162158,
-0.026096886,
0.0070850425,
0.0500286967,
0.0199951176,
0.0407691225,
0.0119544258,
0.0351972729,
-0.0152695198,
0.0080314148,
0.0010077656,
0.0605169721,
-0.0159219392,
-0.0266396292,
0.0404267237,
0.0049208491,
0.0316007063,
0.0141610941,
0.0145846512,
-0.0032463984,
0.0282202866,
-0.0402089134,
-0.0058075576,
-0.0274027325,
0.0148562398,
0.0121051511,
0.0016166571,
-0.0128492117,
-0.0259207357,
-0.0113917403,
0.0110013895,
-0.0244900081,
-0.0224771351,
-0.0010324013,
-0.0139952181,
0.0289890971,
-0.0134152435,
-0.0369585976,
0.034619417,
-0.0319156572,
0.0190546419,
-0.0196914207,
0.1001053229,
0.0330071375,
0.0090538459,
-0.0336832479,
0.0028778526,
-0.0683910474,
-0.0611029789,
-0.0029724727,
0.0164079126,
0.0301049855,
0.0241350383,
0.0398288444,
-0.0464598872,
-0.0055060466,
-0.0217581764,
0.0254501272,
0.0254283622,
0.0097211888,
0.0433680266,
0.0547817089,
-0.0108467434,
-0.0084361294,
0.0470919609,
0.0115645761,
0.0494792573,
-0.0184562597,
-0.0036353916,
-0.0101976022,
-0.0690307915,
-0.0490337051,
0.0327079333,
-0.0107215485,
-0.0230852943,
-0.0815948173,
-0.0759753138,
-0.0192046724,
0.0498022214,
-0.0126552889,
-0.02186203,
0.014731002,
0.0900686011,
0.0043305461,
-0.057542488,
0.0288671702,
-0.0263653528,
0.0044488553,
0.0115512265,
0.0100701703,
-6.361010621e-33,
-0.0410263985,
-0.033149343,
0.0975369662,
-0.019764185,
-0.0229857191,
-0.0529022254,
-0.0469380803,
0.0142026301,
-0.03135271,
-0.0120717911,
-0.0122483913,
0.0104319397,
0.0234953631,
-0.0127044814,
0.0480577461,
0.0082042301,
0.0136317816,
0.0115595208,
-0.0204966478,
-0.0330496989,
0.0281779859,
-0.0302938204,
0.0488362238,
-0.0138089713,
0.0249393657,
-0.0026412962,
-0.0327839218,
0.0359707251,
-0.0867724493,
0.072214745,
-0.0218611062,
0.0001259636,
0.0348891653,
-0.0534171872,
-0.013144372,
0.0111517245,
-0.0413341187,
-0.039159853,
0.0579791777,
-0.0172194187,
-0.052001562,
-0.0205692742,
0.0515632294,
-0.0028230378,
-0.0536021329,
-0.026700817,
-0.0157870632,
-0.007909691,
0.001596762,
0.0210322365,
-0.07174436,
0.006827448,
0.0195560623,
-0.0199476685,
0.0179615263,
0.0197074357,
-0.019303577,
0.0060703419,
-0.0332759917,
-0.0135156615,
0.0109752826,
-0.0146190282,
0.1056828797,
0.0113872113,
0.0018402169,
0.0440568775,
0.0396076031,
-0.0227962658,
-0.0494777635,
-0.0495893806,
0.0057524308,
0.0628543124,
0.0479048565,
0.0029871105,
0.007616506,
0.0311031099,
-0.0622464493,
-0.0107248081,
-0.0047262353,
0.0618318133,
0.0305381194,
0.0317141786,
-0.0410751402,
-0.0377009511,
-0.046759516,
-0.0042837877,
-0.0436618701,
-0.0343066268,
0.0481926724,
-0.0128936572,
0.0276759081,
0.0049440949,
0.0466095656,
-0.0082970364,
-0.0403929949,
0.0004133114,
-0.0347839855,
0.0187080484,
-0.013081965,
0.0648798123,
-0.0385268815,
0.0022424506,
-0.0292494427,
0.0193322971,
0.0080752717,
0.0203967094,
0.0065040425,
0.0297294632,
-0.0430480056,
-0.0280883573,
-0.0649973303,
-0.0047586961,
0.0251629427,
-0.0545449704,
0.0835773647,
0.0065426468,
-0.0049832962,
0.0583479479,
-0.0133091323,
-0.0511316732,
-0.0242009014,
0.0531267934,
-0.0120844655,
0.0341372676,
0.0091773625,
0.0158832017,
-0.0238956437,
0.0193594396,
0.0283166282,
-0.0085762525,
-0.0140982904,
0.0586851835,
2.764e-7,
0.0279753525,
0.0241804421,
0.0127250683,
0.0303478334,
0.022624908,
0.0140385972,
-0.0654065385,
-0.0248442385,
0.0089322813,
-0.0379050747,
0.0167910066,
0.0682613179,
0.0296758562,
0.0319436416,
-0.0043390328,
0.0213718843,
-0.0538869947,
-0.0208448581,
-0.0474695861,
0.0366667658,
0.0526756831,
0.0322306417,
0.0294309109,
-0.0079796137,
-0.0127387894,
-0.0292837173,
0.0795447528,
-0.0195110999,
0.0154983653,
0.0016612186,
0.0057119499,
0.0094222724,
0.0258686393,
0.0219340753,
0.0368053503,
0.0105315922,
0.0074598952,
0.086317122,
-0.0022696499,
-0.0164722316,
-0.0167431589,
-0.0372400507,
0.0012258945,
-0.0695368871,
0.0902994648,
-0.0776976496,
-0.0311532952,
-0.0059390431,
0.0203197524,
-0.0472431034,
0.0150438771,
0.021133326,
0.0041563371,
0.0044718287,
0.0101040443,
0.0048094769,
-0.0340355746,
-0.085708037,
-0.0224552788,
0.0465304852,
-0.054612387,
-0.0386221632,
-0.0303166769,
0.0015222728,
0.0452986546,
-0.0850932822,
-0.0625121817,
2.61029449e-34,
0.0205642916,
-0.0209886581,
0.0474147424,
0.0147393234,
0.0097201299,
-0.0024177548,
-0.0080271019,
0.0393614881,
0.0050377585,
-0.0764006749,
-0.0434055924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14268v1 | Masked Path Modeling for Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2023-05-23T17:20:20 | 2023-05-23T17:20:20 | Zi-Yi Dou, Feng Gao, Nanyun Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-and-language navigation (VLN) agents are trained to navigate in
real-world environments by following natural language instructions. A major
challenge in VLN is the limited availability of training data, which hinders
the models' ability to generalize effectively. Previous approaches have
attempted to address this issue by introducing additional supervision during
training, often requiring costly human-annotated data that restricts
scalability. In this paper, we introduce a masked path modeling (MPM)
objective, which pretrains an agent using self-collected data for downstream
navigation tasks. Our proposed method involves allowing the agent to actively
explore navigation environments without a specific goal and collect the paths
it traverses. Subsequently, we train the agent on this collected data to
reconstruct the original path given a randomly masked subpath. This way, the
agent can actively accumulate a diverse and substantial amount of data while
learning conditional action generation. To evaluate the effectiveness of our
technique, we conduct experiments on various VLN datasets and demonstrate the
versatility of MPM across different levels of instruction complexity. Our
results exhibit significant improvements in success rates, with enhancements of
1.32\%, 1.05\%, and 1.19\% on the val-unseen split of the Room-to-Room,
Room-for-Room, and Room-across-Room datasets, respectively. Furthermore, we
conduct an analysis that highlights the potential for additional improvements
when the agent is allowed to explore unseen environments prior to testing. | [
0.0366650559,
0.0120073715,
-0.0139784319,
0.0012213212,
-0.0320801735,
0.023000177,
0.0045483718,
-0.0339227617,
0.0451776199,
-0.0548050739,
-0.0055411076,
0.0006656605,
-0.0338475741,
0.0474162884,
0.0131317712,
-0.0631280839,
0.0434099808,
-0.0714830086,
-0.0411079489,
0.017575562,
-0.0575286932,
-0.0169698503,
-0.0186534096,
0.0420331731,
-0.0146704642,
0.0079915887,
-0.056620758,
-0.0152486395,
0.0131879635,
-0.0818873569,
0.0257390197,
0.0097012492,
0.0924412906,
0.0264980085,
0.0000021911,
-0.0277443398,
0.0018356406,
-0.0359852128,
-0.0091487439,
-0.0709673613,
0.0143758589,
0.002594495,
0.0170994457,
0.0275501627,
-0.0434035249,
-0.0317461118,
0.0221975632,
0.0518002771,
0.0412263647,
0.0508748703,
-0.0053201197,
-0.0085148336,
-0.0486718863,
-0.0009952916,
0.0197650809,
-0.0336468555,
0.016214082,
0.0032030521,
-0.0355122201,
0.0057489965,
-0.0138508417,
0.0127627654,
0.0313946344,
0.0091022337,
0.0322009064,
0.0565979294,
-0.0107190469,
-0.0206260607,
-0.0378892086,
0.0909808353,
-0.0471648425,
-0.0349904485,
0.0271169152,
-0.006068747,
-0.0205861051,
-0.0449014269,
-0.026401246,
0.0191700906,
0.0096725235,
0.0076467469,
-0.0217251051,
-0.0005853369,
0.0158699173,
-0.0012798868,
-0.0015477582,
0.037517935,
-0.0140705109,
-0.0036044007,
0.0205068234,
-0.0064315395,
-0.0123529052,
-0.0651176423,
0.0042213146,
0.0634625331,
-0.0295820162,
0.051800672,
-0.0544092543,
-0.0143884402,
-0.0076502003,
-0.0417107604,
0.0264016651,
0.0117570683,
-0.0302918237,
0.0461843759,
-0.0516011827,
0.0358969234,
-0.0247540604,
0.0645473897,
-0.0236800388,
-0.0014529221,
-0.036648456,
0.0502070971,
-0.0669022724,
0.0421733074,
-0.0730748847,
-0.0332892202,
-0.0029894589,
0.0367824882,
-0.0296890307,
0.0199731886,
-0.0096301576,
0.0211034399,
-0.0270194691,
0.0026849811,
0.0002999523,
-0.0926764384,
-0.0284615718,
0.0189485475,
-0.0179003756,
-0.0078418488,
0.0009471957,
0.0005438839,
0.0093374597,
0.0017776808,
0.0091579594,
0.1297388077,
0.013077409,
-0.0464230664,
-0.0745584741,
-0.0282000173,
0.0279791225,
-0.0453512706,
0.0422399081,
-0.0770550072,
0.0439812839,
-0.0120080067,
-0.0404118039,
-0.0313819312,
0.0213098638,
0.0330278128,
-0.0036221277,
0.0578504242,
0.0194937047,
0.0099322908,
0.0353483483,
-0.0039033298,
-0.0200221781,
0.0217489898,
0.0314321257,
0.0382760987,
-0.0003896195,
0.0539986268,
0.0365712829,
0.031891223,
0.0157688987,
0.0159429386,
0.0549478307,
0.0061322181,
0.0053933277,
0.0181513187,
-0.0052378862,
0.0473658517,
-0.0606242567,
-0.029066829,
0.0022791538,
0.0671813264,
-0.0163255837,
-0.0114939045,
0.0596610978,
0.017141046,
-0.0144913094,
-0.0277780313,
-0.032088805,
0.0424689278,
-0.0265461635,
-0.0341412574,
-0.0424560644,
0.0054556103,
-0.0352018625,
-0.0692103505,
0.0328994617,
0.0011548069,
0.0625920594,
0.0078122038,
0.0375638641,
-0.001880682,
-0.0753792077,
-0.0075600548,
0.0531093143,
-0.0570000187,
-0.0255963318,
-0.0246842261,
-0.000043718,
0.0647597089,
0.0305480808,
0.0112538449,
-0.0220321491,
-0.0133590344,
0.0024242613,
-0.0205306821,
-0.0005647155,
-0.0244994387,
0.0597483478,
-0.0353806205,
-0.0565406531,
0.001201279,
-0.0073713432,
0.0610378794,
0.0246316325,
-0.0076379306,
0.0118089477,
-0.020751223,
-0.0188117418,
0.0700955167,
0.0044208691,
-0.0489731357,
-0.0016580881,
-0.00429891,
-0.0015099347,
-0.0036003208,
-0.0049606282,
-0.0339805111,
0.0388075598,
-0.0014394269,
-0.0148221822,
0.0156205725,
-0.0203334466,
-0.0367083773,
0.0155375972,
-0.0705305934,
-0.0640889779,
0.0957405865,
-0.0378684998,
-0.0241611563,
-0.0339060947,
-0.0349167287,
-0.0335378535,
0.0041416697,
-0.0088841654,
0.0490333065,
-0.0156697016,
-0.0327970721,
0.0460177585,
-0.0098687271,
-0.0010582488,
0.0236667283,
0.0011157797,
0.0372902304,
-0.0422479324,
0.0226492342,
-0.0434399769,
0.0123241674,
-0.0043990938,
0.0376783088,
0.0145906247,
-0.0117566213,
0.0170568191,
-0.0658260733,
-0.0246432424,
-0.0313151702,
-0.0287511535,
0.0247397106,
-0.0406176001,
-0.006103788,
-0.014522491,
-0.0089791454,
0.0209094994,
0.0274115652,
-0.0138399815,
-0.0018271517,
-0.0064026499,
-0.0368671529,
-0.0526601858,
0.0003762658,
-0.0186875723,
-0.0302100889,
0.0124510331,
-0.0440453961,
-0.030200446,
0.0395986773,
-0.015869122,
0.0745927617,
-0.0491398983,
-0.0439026989,
-0.0088390298,
-0.0511314534,
0.0080109267,
0.028187288,
-0.0186513867,
-0.0046998239,
0.0775568038,
-0.0283094905,
-0.0392618738,
0.0255114008,
-0.0238247477,
-0.0086826701,
-0.0714654103,
-0.0238600206,
0.0283699911,
0.0059703765,
0.0026014729,
0.012558328,
-0.0525965318,
-0.0502165854,
-0.0429839529,
-0.0595009588,
-0.0368615724,
0.0429903679,
-0.028513696,
0.0530110933,
-0.014058427,
-0.0073841088,
0.0233033467,
0.0024028462,
0.0000871372,
-0.0307026859,
-0.0104540624,
0.0063172849,
0.0715359673,
0.0553767271,
0.0381946936,
0.0302279778,
-0.0040721004,
-0.0276575144,
-0.0223187227,
0.0015474446,
0.0013531434,
0.0424649455,
-0.1028102264,
0.0358639881,
0.0146061638,
-0.0309129711,
-0.0635613427,
-0.0439560786,
-0.0034583244,
-0.0117672272,
-0.0099495165,
-0.0118440194,
-0.0239332411,
-0.0000470914,
0.0258268025,
0.0924017504,
0.044560574,
-0.0442531407,
-0.0243653655,
-0.0322679989,
0.0703382492,
0.0104729142,
0.0049561062,
-0.0364288054,
0.0205470491,
0.0623705946,
0.0587836839,
0.0012010648,
-0.0290826615,
0.0522329174,
0.0304554179,
0.014634179,
-0.0000810052,
0.0824477822,
0.0361528732,
-0.0497040711,
-0.0353035405,
0.0954900235,
0.051183641,
0.025497973,
-0.0071787103,
-0.0114296312,
-0.0125901466,
0.0209142845,
0.0433991365,
-0.0355968513,
-0.0142692132,
0.0044571352,
0.0313045159,
-0.0079193674,
-0.0045962622,
0.016477311,
-0.0908650234,
0.0804693401,
0.0153089473,
-0.0324146003,
-0.0134699261,
-0.0355289057,
-0.0024231568,
-0.0217721872,
-0.0145476796,
-0.0028791525,
0.0063480414,
-0.046225857,
0.003041303,
-0.0208140649,
-0.0038613111,
0.0445854478,
-0.0398980342,
0.0385084674,
0.0143722333,
0.0296057127,
0.025902858,
-0.0155951306,
0.0121226264,
0.0264467932,
0.0196853075,
0.0020382525,
0.0629230067,
-0.0124208014,
0.0049440647,
0.013305787,
0.052226916,
-0.0284262896,
-0.0515068918,
0.0075455667,
-0.0081280991,
-0.0206700098,
0.0259927567,
-0.0302235316,
0.0080949729,
0.0205522794,
0.0545710027,
-0.049396567,
0.0243729837,
-0.0708781928,
-0.0322689489,
-0.0269773118,
-0.0564157628,
-0.0418960564,
0.0291507561,
-0.0596788861,
-0.0181896612,
-0.0822306871,
-0.0796938762,
0.0556091592,
0.1011449024,
0.0089534512,
-0.0302503239,
0.0369367786,
0.0090765674,
-0.0104863597,
0.0056728185,
-0.0603415705,
0.0466341712,
-0.0083731469,
-0.029412182,
-0.0149296941,
-0.043845173,
-0.0150474384,
0.0532156639,
-0.0430387743,
-0.0855944306,
0.033441361,
0.0749606043,
0.0202736836,
0.0571897179,
0.0094150072,
0.0120067401,
0.0451180488,
-0.0306167882,
0.006411775,
0.0129677299,
0.068591699,
0.0214813631,
0.0055989567,
0.0122094825,
-0.0787630752,
0.0145704625,
0.0009576155,
0.0256960504,
-0.0589737631,
0.0436694771,
0.0317724235,
-0.0547203161,
0.0579361692,
0.0066187559,
0.0570113361,
-0.0149233909,
0.0261046197,
-0.050519295,
-0.0104376702,
-0.0374093428,
0.0032663106,
0.0356826372,
0.0366749503,
0.0329643637,
0.0399825945,
-0.0437972508,
-0.0213142782,
-0.0603118911,
-0.0481036641,
0.0071381428,
0.0120185642,
0.0007266827,
-0.0012181939,
-0.0142181842,
0.0101561416,
0.0064244606,
0.0038612508,
0.040936958,
0.0430432484,
0.0338359326,
0.0147178126,
-0.0797021687,
0.0030993079,
-0.0712097734,
-0.0373554938,
0.0108958129,
0.048013404,
0.0606826618,
-0.0076435748,
0.0231533665,
-0.0775042847,
0.016870616,
0.0154304048,
-0.0293078385,
0.0166556574,
-0.0375519432,
0.0550772548,
0.0147695225,
0.0220705122,
-0.0157097299,
0.0741918162,
0.042189341,
0.0876876041,
-0.0124247307,
-0.0047313464,
-0.055809658,
0.0005509942,
0.0205577668,
0.0500521697,
-0.0042299321,
0.0074481457,
-0.0097163096,
-0.0467423685,
0.0073235813,
0.0368554667,
0.0218870565,
-0.0468636379,
0.0889022797,
0.00233769,
0.0078595746,
-0.0681534857,
-0.0322447494,
-0.0404689647,
-0.0057784123,
-0.0144580444,
-0.0415548049,
-6.098946277e-33,
-0.0063436045,
-0.0281289145,
0.0843224823,
0.0411112569,
0.0018292612,
-0.0298365578,
-0.0339398906,
-0.0027512312,
-0.0333585776,
0.0169737451,
0.0044307765,
0.0057174489,
0.0228528231,
0.0516216829,
-0.0219334736,
-0.0063140509,
0.0483349524,
0.0033575876,
-0.0370957442,
-0.0077357762,
0.0214955993,
-0.0082913991,
-0.0180567577,
-0.0720456094,
-0.0148455566,
-0.0398879983,
-0.0150479833,
0.0335323364,
-0.0044604489,
0.0068473993,
0.000876405,
-0.0038949321,
-0.0002878731,
-0.0147039946,
-0.0359868743,
0.0216516498,
-0.0885455683,
-0.0316120833,
-0.0279562902,
0.0322910026,
-0.0831168815,
-0.0087838657,
0.0121377418,
-0.0052666706,
-0.0289322082,
0.049752906,
0.0297380202,
0.0113635296,
-0.0099368431,
0.0301480237,
-0.0343309082,
0.0056910245,
-0.0142309424,
-0.0676945597,
0.0398819968,
0.0483000316,
0.0170648172,
-0.0511117503,
-0.0494003594,
0.008209276,
0.0303690769,
-0.0138299949,
0.0356922299,
0.0473933183,
0.0753499866,
0.0432205498,
0.0486532934,
0.0108119855,
0.0061918446,
0.0117863258,
0.0079329815,
0.0587603264,
-0.0046462538,
0.0205071773,
-0.0153428009,
0.0435369089,
-0.0590936095,
0.0385980457,
-0.0568836778,
0.0355718248,
0.0016907408,
0.0552155301,
-0.0232097283,
0.0079710288,
-0.0461937748,
0.0015826009,
0.0067449501,
-0.0025646768,
0.0316823237,
0.0532062389,
-0.0193283036,
-0.0379370674,
0.0388122573,
0.0049415906,
-0.0207326803,
0.0077466988,
-0.0030670224,
0.0246045962,
0.0021756587,
0.0232505072,
-0.0527095683,
-0.0371230878,
0.0600063168,
-0.0054362514,
0.0054395706,
0.0160352532,
-0.0283880085,
0.0639667958,
-0.030102523,
0.0064698732,
-0.0535836481,
-0.0045668143,
0.0295231864,
-0.0082597192,
0.0516302511,
-0.0064981612,
-0.0187048353,
0.051985193,
0.0015139994,
-0.0516528562,
-0.0031924646,
0.0008444272,
-0.0220835544,
0.0114474148,
-0.0325790979,
0.0083666258,
-0.0482384264,
0.0171146337,
0.0486529283,
-0.0589652248,
0.0014940305,
0.0332040116,
2.855e-7,
-0.0249274075,
0.0099806907,
0.0131320283,
0.0576895587,
-0.0144868121,
0.0526378453,
-0.0050194738,
0.0337781273,
0.0090557942,
-0.034903083,
0.0126299886,
0.0410181768,
-0.017476216,
-0.010441089,
-0.0252757929,
0.0327944681,
0.047412239,
-0.044273939,
-0.0462717004,
0.0182917379,
0.050989937,
0.0652582347,
0.0048151379,
0.0133457016,
0.014491491,
-0.0270431247,
0.0289977379,
-0.02015456,
-0.0198800266,
-0.0381244868,
0.001979874,
0.0940444916,
-0.0404551253,
-0.0156774782,
-0.0290792361,
0.0120664863,
-0.0098868283,
0.0520317443,
-0.0387082249,
-0.0335262157,
0.0052207024,
-0.0027028373,
-0.00760384,
-0.0157289319,
0.060986843,
-0.0491853617,
0.0171830617,
0.0189645085,
-0.0117233107,
0.0347258486,
-0.0108886482,
0.0012394241,
-0.0222985726,
-0.0168048628,
0.021902658,
0.0334753133,
-0.0146573847,
-0.0732196942,
0.005981585,
-0.0095316246,
-0.0056356033,
-0.0027539469,
0.0035282886,
0.0249156766,
-0.0070863944,
-0.0319536887,
-0.0540918261,
2.106708578e-34,
-0.0014163299,
-0.0323393866,
-0.0161360893,
-0.0274764914,
0.0234425962,
0.0158174299,
-0.0222876333,
0.0311300457,
0.0291787442,
-0.0236546155,
-0.0354839973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14264v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14264v2 | Active Learning Principles for In-Context Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:16:04 | 2023-11-22T10:22:18 | Katerina Margatina, Timo Schick, Nikolaos Aletras, Jane Dwivedi-Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The remarkable advancements in large language models (LLMs) have
significantly enhanced the performance in few-shot learning settings. By using
only a small number of labeled examples, referred to as demonstrations, LLMs
can effectively grasp the task at hand through in-context learning. However,
the process of selecting appropriate demonstrations has received limited
attention in prior work. This paper addresses the issue of identifying the most
informative demonstrations for few-shot learning by approaching it as a
pool-based Active Learning (AL) problem over a single iteration. Our objective
is to investigate how AL algorithms can serve as effective demonstration
selection methods for in-context learning. We compare various standard AL
algorithms based on uncertainty, diversity, and similarity, and consistently
observe that the latter outperforms all other methods, including random
sampling. Notably, uncertainty sampling, despite its success in conventional
supervised learning scenarios, performs poorly in this context. Our extensive
experimentation involving a diverse range of GPT and OPT models across $24$
classification and multi-choice tasks, coupled with thorough analysis,
unambiguously demonstrates that in-context example selection through AL
prioritizes high-quality examples that exhibit low uncertainty and bear
similarity to the test examples. | [
-0.0105408533,
0.0235562939,
-0.0055259489,
-0.0081630675,
-0.0397214927,
0.037702892,
0.0388208702,
0.0054923566,
-0.0001204295,
-0.0787740126,
-0.0109307552,
-0.0754052922,
0.0014042568,
-0.0597339757,
0.0356272012,
-0.0520874336,
0.0262962095,
-0.0442830622,
-0.0019280652,
-0.0184103902,
-0.0440463647,
0.0062162578,
-0.0304413475,
0.0361142792,
0.0087053049,
0.0206644274,
-0.0037308077,
0.0020668544,
0.0001873286,
-0.0310402699,
-0.0175614301,
0.071651414,
0.0482358895,
0.002206994,
0.0000020489,
-0.0475054979,
-0.0062251231,
-0.0011945121,
-0.041051507,
0.00991451,
0.0375028029,
0.059982568,
0.0068282722,
0.004148921,
-0.0063340627,
-0.0646994933,
0.0512942448,
-0.0139194112,
-0.0031915873,
0.0186017249,
0.0014393325,
0.0123867067,
-0.0198255144,
-0.034804374,
0.0287516508,
-0.0710067004,
0.0389971025,
-0.0214546621,
0.0507994145,
0.0036563596,
-0.0105098113,
0.0055203722,
0.0118847238,
0.0242666081,
-0.0255331174,
0.048448585,
-0.0524226427,
-0.0136510264,
0.0178586561,
0.0409272388,
-0.0333961546,
-0.0191193577,
-0.0186080765,
-0.0582840107,
0.0056335428,
0.0589290708,
-0.0707555041,
0.016754223,
0.0093953973,
0.0342659205,
-0.0403589159,
0.0013569378,
0.0217626449,
0.0303405952,
-0.002548275,
-0.0162642617,
0.0015483637,
-0.0386783481,
0.0536582284,
0.0473132618,
-0.0458120741,
-0.0212375131,
-0.0254450496,
0.0271973964,
-0.0761149824,
0.023717761,
-0.0062362822,
-0.051714737,
0.0233938806,
-0.0251922999,
0.0525224805,
0.0142112598,
0.0086656678,
0.0767605379,
-0.0063188714,
0.0281704273,
0.0329518057,
0.0385857373,
-0.0311911665,
-0.0011098544,
-0.0521553159,
0.0201095343,
-0.0486919396,
0.0466037318,
0.0186809711,
-0.0229853969,
-0.0654414594,
0.0266230889,
-0.0131664835,
0.022135783,
-0.0240325611,
-0.0258695278,
-0.0512510762,
-0.0116858827,
0.0233160984,
0.0013361644,
0.0076591796,
0.0244500898,
-0.0356532745,
-0.0510115139,
-0.0297826529,
0.0161528792,
0.0054536206,
-0.0384608693,
-0.0043109064,
0.0703013539,
-0.0250930712,
-0.1096816659,
-0.0213641971,
0.0671139285,
0.0039456743,
-0.0353639834,
-0.0105046406,
-0.0578210056,
-0.0035904753,
-0.0168070849,
0.0556536764,
-0.0524310656,
0.0018490879,
0.0176043473,
-0.0110121816,
0.0426919013,
0.0279518124,
0.0123483194,
0.0179361776,
-0.012397076,
-0.0169061664,
0.1156552881,
-0.0031829716,
0.0230058152,
0.0322333053,
0.0094165169,
0.0325315148,
0.0247946009,
0.0259875171,
0.036780972,
-0.046657525,
0.0043479386,
0.0200655516,
0.0192554779,
-0.0564478338,
-0.0151878465,
-0.0590157136,
0.0230883062,
0.0598475114,
0.0311307646,
-0.0140870865,
-0.0671740845,
0.0336921327,
0.0285602976,
0.0437467434,
-0.0288928095,
-0.0419785939,
0.0130421873,
-0.0159944706,
0.0049396181,
-0.0026776982,
0.0184171367,
-0.0413871855,
-0.0039271731,
-0.0319422148,
-0.037226025,
-0.0259282719,
0.0717373639,
0.0842454508,
0.0110434229,
-0.0417719632,
0.0451249145,
0.0400349237,
0.0283021834,
-0.015922023,
-0.0692517906,
0.0189505871,
0.0016986382,
0.0209172405,
-0.0623267777,
-0.0486293286,
-0.035666436,
0.0547853224,
0.0211994294,
0.0460327268,
-0.0243953895,
0.0177422035,
-0.0572563894,
-0.0437911637,
0.0116334558,
0.0487398915,
-0.0016732392,
0.0362295359,
0.0259171221,
-0.0134967361,
-0.0474057198,
-0.0023452956,
0.0362754241,
0.0003977071,
-0.0543435104,
0.0332596041,
0.0018422331,
0.0468239002,
-0.0280391686,
-0.0208459236,
-0.0199254192,
0.0122747691,
-0.0033064971,
0.0079417471,
0.0131939929,
-0.0215907414,
-0.0547055192,
-0.0054945694,
0.0072846501,
-0.0386639796,
-0.0081139663,
-0.0691651776,
-0.0145587046,
-0.0537137985,
-0.0245829299,
-0.007634813,
-0.0461212657,
0.045589637,
-0.0431629568,
-0.0080932109,
-0.065457195,
0.0921993628,
-0.0103802253,
0.0094177686,
0.0643613413,
0.013437584,
-0.0074517964,
-0.0605783947,
-0.0210391246,
0.0207245909,
0.0023044806,
-0.0009616836,
0.0143517414,
0.0494089499,
-0.0288485885,
0.0151818013,
-0.0635161698,
0.0152260344,
-0.0354055651,
-0.0124626989,
-0.0161624383,
-0.0026831964,
-0.0202139933,
-0.0100142062,
0.007466889,
-0.0015999319,
-0.0556168854,
0.0376349613,
-0.0017764154,
0.0172120258,
0.0106254807,
-0.0181378983,
-0.0083794342,
0.0283179004,
0.0830697939,
-0.0303894226,
0.0283328444,
-0.0320769623,
0.0269133579,
0.0290759038,
-0.0244702082,
0.0157283917,
0.038788043,
0.0251442343,
-0.0402353965,
-0.0481156744,
0.0417093448,
0.0156053072,
0.0729245991,
0.0119195404,
0.0277816914,
-0.0689686015,
0.0138311721,
-0.0478994958,
-0.0115970159,
-0.0220191684,
0.0056920489,
0.0011188777,
0.0242701136,
-0.0076240427,
-0.0038280014,
-0.0502436571,
0.0324970782,
-0.0282000303,
-0.0215616096,
-0.0817791969,
0.0098375604,
-0.0249457024,
-0.025042085,
-0.0055825016,
-0.0420689918,
0.0639831796,
0.0069388095,
-0.0038469508,
-0.0584870167,
-0.0021890956,
0.0086540952,
0.014337128,
0.0176565759,
-0.0071477937,
-0.0249816682,
-0.0173535515,
-0.0555147156,
-0.038837295,
0.0239741709,
-0.0289475173,
0.0416776985,
-0.0591811277,
0.0141577171,
0.0000028458,
-0.0407489352,
-0.049829118,
-0.0317048058,
0.0018271533,
0.039390225,
-0.037680354,
0.0238644686,
-0.0278952923,
0.0184886977,
0.0148577746,
0.0487645939,
0.0096149407,
-0.0120599745,
-0.021197835,
0.0198602434,
0.0273878109,
0.0003523565,
-0.0001734138,
-0.0449729897,
0.0254784506,
0.0377499349,
0.0717588812,
-0.0027678548,
-0.0129049299,
0.0211218018,
0.0279160235,
-0.0398479924,
0.0100420481,
0.0461800098,
0.0482544824,
-0.0164271388,
-0.0042008529,
0.093035765,
0.0294376072,
-0.0755481794,
-0.0059635038,
0.0283786952,
-0.0239325892,
0.0205083042,
0.0267993994,
-0.0105980504,
-0.0364290997,
-0.0028988724,
0.0325730219,
0.0022538593,
-0.016389668,
-0.0019231436,
-0.1283464283,
0.063006863,
0.0303195976,
-0.0839215964,
0.0256592408,
-0.0420464464,
0.0463348478,
-0.0316416882,
0.0518991984,
-0.0184423141,
-0.0155330636,
0.0000312821,
0.038974721,
0.0397464186,
-0.1125471145,
0.0088893883,
-0.0079004131,
0.0113676125,
0.0118550742,
0.0157528371,
-0.0154034086,
0.0288467817,
0.0572821014,
-0.0660069287,
0.009394194,
-0.033485584,
0.0224114712,
0.0255488884,
-0.0010013878,
0.0376090221,
0.026453333,
-0.0114765642,
-0.0406704284,
-0.0023128206,
0.0705839768,
-0.0258857831,
0.0071537285,
0.0030180425,
-0.0634901524,
0.0669523627,
0.0364622474,
0.0205366649,
-0.0550702848,
0.0023289828,
0.0130221602,
0.0063622957,
-0.0193856955,
0.0030030527,
0.0139151057,
-0.0217984151,
-0.0182923824,
-0.0305872262,
-0.0047770524,
0.0979663581,
0.0956684351,
-0.009764757,
0.0282446425,
-0.0014537165,
0.0206604656,
0.0258725248,
0.0124683781,
-0.0372021198,
0.0417474546,
-0.0023984571,
-0.0651693195,
0.0452153981,
-0.0472010002,
-0.0306537971,
0.0148578044,
-0.0729397833,
-0.0487973019,
0.0203920398,
0.047078304,
0.0220163595,
0.0463380329,
-0.0118448092,
-0.046845641,
0.076446861,
0.0505524389,
0.0356954411,
0.0165400114,
0.0120074321,
-0.0184045825,
-0.0343415402,
0.0234313793,
-0.053999532,
0.0152889555,
0.0637209117,
0.0225612745,
-0.0579226017,
0.0050322148,
0.0183008444,
-0.023912264,
0.0611667261,
-0.0300872512,
-0.0477423407,
-0.0097818272,
0.0396360271,
0.0278735105,
0.0015570737,
-0.032508973,
-0.0065041222,
-0.000217748,
0.0035041675,
-0.0240583029,
-0.0079992572,
0.0160582829,
0.0734675378,
-0.0217791945,
-0.0074995933,
0.0388193764,
-0.0110582821,
0.0243448466,
0.0273781922,
-0.0268050972,
0.0156602152,
0.0065498557,
0.0345105976,
-0.003789834,
0.0817896947,
0.0143891182,
0.0049487143,
-0.0138331829,
0.0113784662,
-0.0536789261,
-0.0445937999,
-0.0649055019,
0.081983529,
0.0633074865,
-0.0431812853,
0.0212969445,
-0.0445552915,
-0.0226487312,
-0.0148785496,
0.0034722085,
0.0053742826,
-0.0290763136,
0.0082005449,
0.0597861223,
0.0242974181,
0.0365495123,
0.0829080343,
0.0100562843,
0.0304262247,
0.0116000865,
0.0250174738,
-0.0419247448,
-0.0107933292,
0.0595013797,
0.058205571,
0.0123351207,
0.0264869146,
-0.0515818633,
-0.0496576466,
-0.0066173212,
-0.044155594,
-0.0231261253,
-0.026067147,
0.0566425472,
0.0514227413,
-0.0125001315,
0.0223615654,
-0.0235645473,
-0.0276983511,
0.0282312483,
-0.0004629123,
-0.0122004673,
-6.064866492e-33,
-0.020612482,
-0.0421145149,
-0.0083344057,
-0.0515565686,
0.004793182,
-0.0029469312,
-0.009755834,
-0.0017420413,
-0.0034448726,
0.0131549248,
-0.0158998948,
-0.0324418582,
0.0178723186,
0.028410852,
0.0122798076,
-0.0167639758,
0.0340311974,
-0.0201937221,
-0.0189605579,
0.0285910536,
0.0082774274,
0.0143516539,
0.0339439549,
-0.0183561761,
-0.0161576271,
0.0200482495,
-0.0284752287,
0.0093531832,
-0.0265199766,
0.0468251854,
0.0019265367,
0.0472892374,
0.0008918592,
-0.0422511585,
-0.0243776347,
-0.0443700925,
-0.0305383131,
-0.0534039512,
-0.0159680489,
0.0428285263,
0.0082923928,
0.0348637886,
0.0038539069,
-0.0252352729,
-0.0086655356,
-0.0067381319,
0.0136325099,
-0.0213838574,
-0.0742768422,
-0.038477011,
-0.0174330473,
0.026860185,
-0.0140289348,
-0.0142912082,
0.0321246535,
0.0007035214,
-0.0269206204,
0.0264699459,
-0.0288286302,
0.0046869707,
0.0222872496,
0.0016287876,
0.0241550487,
-0.0013724903,
0.0329975076,
0.0574981794,
-0.0120243644,
-0.0173037071,
0.0185249131,
-0.0304133873,
0.0211601853,
0.0320350341,
0.0112349186,
0.0593867749,
0.0407363698,
0.0240496844,
-0.0574335642,
0.0046494808,
0.0592644364,
0.0082970411,
0.0663056448,
0.007713228,
-0.0558546036,
-0.0370107368,
-0.0335580222,
0.0224499181,
-0.0184862185,
-0.0286771152,
0.030856587,
0.0412145145,
-0.0809210688,
0.0244779047,
0.0593685172,
-0.0295988265,
-0.0612775795,
0.020317303,
-0.015636446,
0.0360937864,
0.0098190131,
-0.0239258241,
-0.0270770323,
-0.0932250395,
0.0041852379,
0.0048270347,
-0.0088668363,
0.0083880033,
0.0264676865,
0.0599608161,
-0.0552622713,
0.0182048548,
-0.0062717088,
-0.0107355891,
0.0162988398,
0.0019419421,
0.0247907527,
0.0045478912,
0.0046808035,
0.0706428587,
0.0337445922,
-0.089003861,
0.0218606498,
0.0000405497,
-0.0588929243,
0.0035109255,
-0.0105778351,
-0.0026928312,
0.001067742,
-0.0417956822,
0.0351385549,
-0.0352629796,
-0.0081874244,
0.0178157892,
2.699e-7,
0.0168160684,
0.0422617048,
-0.0601554364,
-0.0061287433,
0.0339939147,
0.0416954383,
-0.0337256826,
-0.0085957749,
0.0297495462,
0.0283531975,
0.031203201,
0.0230383053,
0.0420632586,
0.0592542551,
-0.1018278375,
0.023534799,
-0.0076830229,
0.0327946804,
-0.0500302054,
-0.0047826474,
0.0147435749,
0.0920185074,
0.0282083545,
-0.0190951861,
-0.0007453566,
-0.0667844564,
0.0749925599,
-0.0490019992,
0.019982785,
0.0232685786,
-0.0258360747,
0.0092919581,
-0.0029189701,
0.0409695581,
-0.0315390192,
0.0127874156,
0.0219371468,
0.0402206667,
-0.0047923718,
-0.0162129235,
-0.0147310887,
-0.0089467997,
0.0330097266,
-0.0310971886,
0.0798232108,
-0.1260216087,
0.0017357219,
-0.010204182,
0.0086576473,
-0.0634688959,
0.0398431793,
-0.0030987374,
-0.0010903102,
0.0127868168,
-0.0155127719,
0.0249342918,
-0.0415918566,
-0.0674017891,
0.0041433303,
-0.0174564589,
-0.05811508,
-0.033427801,
0.0020648732,
0.0117959017,
0.0033814947,
-0.0375996046,
-0.0025604514,
2.396862139e-34,
0.0414158963,
0.0064708232,
0.010156054,
0.0608115606,
-0.0407503843,
0.0011000923,
0.0252301581,
0.0123985345,
0.0258037616,
-0.0201691985,
0.0179053918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14263v2 | LIMIT: Language Identification, Misidentification, and Translation using Hierarchical Models in 350+ Languages | 2023-05-23T17:15:43 | 2023-11-06T16:29:21 | Milind Agarwal, Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowing the language of an input text/audio is a necessary first step for
using almost every NLP tool such as taggers, parsers, or translation systems.
Language identification is a well-studied problem, sometimes even considered
solved; in reality, due to lack of data and computational challenges, current
systems cannot accurately identify most of the world's 7000 languages. To
tackle this bottleneck, we first compile a corpus, MCS-350, of 50K multilingual
and parallel children's stories in 350+ languages. MCS-350 can serve as a
benchmark for language identification of short texts and for 1400+ new
translation directions in low-resource Indian and African languages. Second, we
propose a novel misprediction-resolution hierarchical model, LIMIt, for
language identification that reduces error by 55% (from 0.71 to 0.32) on our
compiled children's stories dataset and by 40% (from 0.23 to 0.14) on the
FLORES-200 benchmark. Our method can expand language identification coverage
into low-resource languages by relying solely on systemic misprediction
patterns, bypassing the need to retrain large models from scratch. | [
0.0516821854,
0.0387240984,
-0.0316277258,
0.0745377168,
-0.0269808508,
0.040916536,
0.0088804252,
-0.0176875517,
-0.0028917105,
-0.0380939431,
-0.008672135,
-0.0371260457,
0.0429814495,
-0.0087329289,
-0.0060381494,
-0.0664343014,
0.0600398667,
-0.0361374095,
0.0240311306,
0.0117764724,
-0.0094309859,
0.0535488985,
0.0104200542,
0.017220661,
-0.0198004078,
-0.0457474142,
0.027296938,
0.0516102053,
0.0245547127,
-0.0215841681,
0.0342259444,
0.0123383654,
0.0079101371,
0.1065035686,
0.0000016638,
-0.0340662822,
-0.0539852045,
-0.0384158604,
-0.0172197428,
-0.0203720275,
0.0635246783,
-0.0440120883,
-0.0389689915,
0.0028847468,
0.0314204954,
-0.01749379,
0.0696608126,
0.0089003593,
0.0249021333,
0.0698491186,
0.0004413414,
-0.0664097443,
-0.0156815946,
0.0244195666,
0.0100262677,
-0.0381862707,
-0.0073606707,
0.0274710041,
0.0105176093,
-0.029327726,
0.0051685716,
0.0261327755,
-0.0276040565,
-0.0059249769,
-0.0222130977,
-0.0400701836,
-0.0092982193,
-0.0290167965,
0.0030360133,
0.0492728166,
-0.0573549643,
-0.0756402388,
0.0041268212,
0.008011831,
-0.0498601235,
-0.0126122748,
-0.0016962541,
0.0527481288,
-0.0446929075,
0.0276392233,
0.0820703059,
0.0261651035,
0.0480626486,
-0.0009841763,
0.0233497974,
0.0434941128,
0.0027568727,
0.0200449247,
-0.0149751883,
0.0132570053,
-0.0173525438,
-0.0332657993,
0.0323479213,
-0.0292019527,
-0.0266555194,
-0.0268950388,
-0.0420203246,
-0.0626431853,
-0.0296076443,
-0.0590578727,
-0.0176558401,
0.0234270226,
-0.0216553863,
0.0624371283,
0.004763172,
0.0400754511,
0.0101177972,
-0.0219742004,
-0.049502831,
-0.0333371907,
0.0046736393,
0.0067863041,
-0.0084984526,
-0.0118723148,
-0.0468528308,
0.0260583926,
-0.0292648133,
-0.025283901,
-0.0174536481,
0.005227258,
-0.0442390628,
-0.0499345586,
-0.0401950143,
-0.0267283153,
0.0482049733,
0.0632889643,
-0.0115391631,
0.001869065,
-0.0114473831,
-0.0616988093,
-0.0269750338,
0.0482146218,
0.0058634169,
-0.0016839368,
0.0249937139,
0.0423443466,
-0.004737739,
-0.0278901272,
-0.0793915614,
-0.0001146117,
-0.0299363229,
-0.0570466593,
-0.0216293335,
-0.0781878754,
-0.0124479523,
-0.011037861,
0.040718846,
-0.0325250402,
-0.0058294516,
-0.0143919038,
-0.0343399495,
0.0472788773,
-0.0219663512,
-0.0177459046,
0.0561619885,
0.0135710463,
0.0196175948,
0.0580342337,
0.0485670529,
0.0219935942,
0.0750339031,
-0.0074431584,
-0.0227201059,
0.057540223,
-0.0712405443,
-0.0137035605,
-0.0365229957,
-0.0443129465,
0.0006707546,
-0.0037150076,
0.0297116898,
0.0484592579,
0.0140775312,
0.0232588109,
0.0417534895,
0.0538103022,
-0.0792939588,
0.0105429199,
0.0336511247,
0.0119470526,
0.02977903,
0.0200005807,
0.0027378523,
-0.0121405972,
-0.0156194037,
-0.0222509708,
0.0406856872,
0.0206698887,
0.0148880519,
0.0202926621,
-0.0478476286,
-0.0094292881,
-0.0301866457,
0.0091782156,
0.0430001542,
0.0297604073,
-0.0011612765,
-0.0246494617,
0.0457052067,
-0.0391126908,
0.0562319569,
0.0000425987,
0.0328324586,
0.0551090203,
0.0502435714,
-0.0485830344,
0.0133076236,
-0.0302849524,
-0.0078035216,
0.0504944474,
0.0162026957,
-0.0410259776,
0.0225171316,
-0.0119135901,
0.0211410634,
0.050714504,
0.0284081418,
0.0059634624,
0.0008478398,
0.0084025711,
-0.004417839,
-0.040373113,
-0.0569641553,
0.0291627962,
-0.0432181917,
-0.0050746072,
0.0461772233,
0.0178546496,
0.0225658845,
0.0303936787,
-0.0293945633,
-0.0329727679,
-0.0090465331,
-0.0014266282,
0.0092401356,
0.0025885545,
-0.0233475193,
-0.0861820206,
0.0202540737,
-0.0328860804,
-0.0270529538,
0.0071691754,
-0.0264705662,
-0.0385215655,
0.0579050891,
-0.0299485736,
0.0507505871,
0.0052619022,
0.0684407577,
-0.0330426246,
-0.0227474645,
-0.0164522249,
0.0459717326,
0.0144860968,
0.0022153149,
-0.0362336561,
-0.0531797111,
0.0339546464,
-0.0495373681,
-0.0431969687,
0.0234434418,
0.0163743943,
-0.0113709243,
0.0172515083,
0.0009630347,
-0.0146108307,
-0.0082525061,
-0.0459164269,
0.0190230925,
-0.0234767608,
0.0366713293,
-0.0072103147,
0.0337908678,
-0.0019139309,
-0.0346955284,
0.0222913306,
0.000222286,
0.017142117,
-0.0025237212,
-0.0148416404,
-0.0108952206,
0.0032293829,
-0.0450873487,
0.0156759154,
0.0023923891,
0.0568210147,
0.0058740182,
-0.0638991818,
-0.0418366194,
-0.002802639,
-0.0207173005,
0.0225927457,
0.0038367403,
-0.0331415683,
-0.0305953175,
-0.000487338,
0.0066126171,
0.0452381,
-0.052409105,
0.0067997118,
0.0483537763,
-0.0117616206,
0.0002483714,
-0.004938439,
0.0123329442,
-0.0028345417,
-0.0111519461,
-0.0294788517,
-0.0279605631,
0.0859917775,
0.017166581,
0.0106612127,
-0.007900185,
-0.0220872331,
-0.0273098461,
0.0112473574,
-0.0147756105,
-0.0238792095,
-0.0051789838,
0.0527973212,
-0.0388621315,
-0.0628830269,
0.0641436875,
-0.0361634381,
-0.0144022172,
-0.0588586517,
-0.0120721199,
-0.0059095174,
0.043125432,
-0.0213828925,
0.0417150632,
0.0312827229,
-0.0424016193,
-0.0105580939,
0.0461453088,
0.0652799532,
-0.0347269997,
0.037912257,
-0.086653091,
0.0196205899,
-0.0047184103,
-0.0447008684,
-0.0363744088,
-0.048192583,
-0.0157324765,
-0.0301412903,
-0.004169411,
-0.0495908596,
-0.0500321686,
0.0206917897,
0.0433284454,
0.0609966181,
0.0098145548,
0.0181374308,
0.0007633022,
0.0609209649,
0.04636259,
-0.0262097325,
0.0828496441,
-0.0375909954,
0.018606957,
-0.0082431873,
0.0194805861,
-0.0124419006,
0.0106271338,
0.0148950377,
0.0378778614,
0.012085733,
-0.0425063744,
0.0046442538,
0.0239094961,
-0.0285802744,
-0.0020029279,
0.0889052153,
0.0308474973,
-0.0402388163,
-0.0200486984,
-0.0160973407,
0.0246717557,
-0.0056767594,
-0.0071997698,
-0.0475469865,
-0.0259637032,
0.0784848854,
0.0255691539,
0.0073104254,
-0.0139459651,
-0.008624915,
-0.088274993,
0.0059084673,
0.0487131923,
-0.0241870787,
-0.0340060517,
0.0318785347,
-0.0387730412,
0.0165778995,
0.0142639251,
0.0038644692,
-0.0519563109,
-0.0217630323,
-0.003915593,
0.0072534354,
-0.0562099293,
0.0321376063,
-0.040144898,
0.0570122637,
0.0339975506,
-0.0099532688,
-0.0281597804,
0.0254236385,
-0.0212860797,
-0.0111713149,
-0.0677448809,
-0.0159848444,
0.0047894609,
0.0043212883,
-0.0068890825,
0.003515481,
0.0265475325,
-0.0024884488,
-0.0134164728,
-0.0108220866,
0.0575064085,
0.0139699569,
-0.0344975218,
0.0379318707,
-0.0006133368,
0.0319386907,
0.0721624717,
0.003201735,
-0.0099514499,
-0.0076894118,
-0.0479191355,
0.0207151715,
-0.0241233073,
-0.0089033116,
0.0430568904,
-0.0330713987,
-0.0501959138,
-0.0790296346,
0.0032511083,
-0.0069345399,
0.0063006096,
0.0457964726,
0.0337786749,
0.0212415252,
-0.0109272152,
-0.0266649704,
0.0188228954,
-0.033179909,
0.0296133105,
-0.0667836666,
0.0028447397,
0.0007540799,
-0.0247571543,
-0.0149203483,
0.0209691264,
-0.1102201268,
-0.0519479662,
-0.0110142138,
-0.0130609348,
0.022237191,
0.0204803962,
-0.0134206824,
-0.0855151191,
-0.0126019036,
-0.0028999283,
-0.0339753814,
-0.0023915772,
-0.0035297843,
0.0188802034,
-0.035929732,
0.0606370606,
-0.0364738964,
0.0073239091,
0.0292462017,
0.0079009598,
-0.0212714598,
-0.0340613164,
-0.0020971182,
-0.0283346735,
0.0497883596,
-0.062507838,
-0.0263251178,
-0.0704824179,
-0.0284579862,
-0.0065672942,
-0.0191990398,
-0.0063054985,
-0.0072543002,
0.0500964224,
-0.0017118927,
-0.0085796332,
0.0370253362,
0.0133765806,
0.0116556128,
0.0046483362,
0.048664026,
0.0205058157,
0.0250688791,
-0.0091212234,
0.0135350311,
-0.0116402935,
0.0237570126,
0.0115992548,
0.0688092038,
-0.0069033755,
0.0288640577,
-0.0081856251,
-0.0150011294,
-0.0093513224,
-0.0265984237,
0.0207302384,
0.0425774902,
-0.0260291174,
0.0083420463,
0.1222399175,
-0.0420392565,
0.0976879522,
0.0013744811,
0.0036546693,
-0.067077294,
0.0212528277,
0.0150429495,
-0.0354479775,
-0.0259366296,
-0.0208396185,
-0.0335893482,
0.067783244,
0.0767474324,
0.0341895521,
-0.0048486474,
0.0215889383,
-0.0161383022,
0.0040679397,
-0.0286152437,
-0.0044524935,
0.0183551759,
-0.0159782581,
0.0377148315,
-0.0614329502,
-0.0562104061,
0.0098024579,
-0.0166159123,
0.0185650121,
0.0027389831,
-0.0207920223,
0.0315490589,
-0.0077948123,
-0.0226192102,
-0.0544774197,
0.014206361,
-0.0167431813,
-0.0159323998,
-0.0396966748,
-5.022746669e-33,
-0.0041423552,
-0.0255326815,
-0.0456233472,
-0.0147557547,
0.0115566887,
-0.0170521401,
-0.0513781086,
0.0114603974,
0.003280483,
0.0098098675,
0.0099411448,
-0.0178217124,
0.0269847084,
0.007866838,
0.0201608222,
0.0390688665,
0.0545788035,
0.0109330714,
-0.0032641564,
-0.0101612378,
0.0990179777,
-0.0150657948,
0.0856113434,
-0.021965567,
0.0130430218,
-0.0846917853,
-0.0294434763,
0.0406174846,
0.0058667189,
0.0438707061,
-0.026371194,
0.0046241544,
0.009088221,
0.0389619395,
0.0102364738,
-0.0076167709,
-0.0759186,
0.0100443074,
-0.0018279862,
0.0520944409,
0.0041999049,
-0.0514276735,
0.0541619919,
-0.025585955,
-0.0194038115,
0.0042462014,
0.0141925542,
-0.0295279957,
0.0099932821,
-0.005256739,
-0.1107886881,
0.0367137082,
-0.0127259297,
0.0068398761,
0.0517839901,
0.0710712597,
0.0163034014,
-0.0255315136,
-0.0849948227,
-0.0171058942,
-0.0054621408,
0.0503375791,
0.0391583331,
0.058053948,
-0.0564815477,
0.0591938123,
0.0460421517,
-0.035011638,
0.0321246274,
0.0416715108,
0.0105976211,
-0.0533175357,
0.0225115344,
0.0765911937,
0.0478177592,
-0.0262103118,
-0.0603013933,
0.0316364951,
0.0208990872,
0.0144961309,
0.0207773,
-0.0077385725,
-0.0884540007,
-0.0039700335,
-0.0109246112,
-0.0616150051,
-0.025238676,
0.0044647246,
0.0297963023,
-0.0223479643,
0.0081195105,
0.0045882193,
0.0728047192,
-0.0108674597,
0.0098159071,
-0.0304596703,
-0.0008359171,
0.023670435,
0.0153138954,
0.0800862312,
-0.0144345853,
-0.0535988435,
0.0062158108,
-0.0107730282,
0.0451120511,
-0.00748681,
0.0694683194,
0.0046778545,
-0.0605080053,
0.0472513437,
0.0042521139,
0.020067554,
-0.001298912,
0.0713331848,
0.0398838446,
-0.0249802452,
0.00595346,
0.0003710087,
0.0353699401,
0.0361835659,
-0.0054213991,
0.0170387067,
-0.0528388619,
0.0004466274,
-0.0092045069,
0.0323475786,
-0.0138062537,
0.0172010865,
-0.0139930435,
-0.0251848307,
0.0351859666,
0.0305740908,
2.341e-7,
-0.0383879542,
0.0287799034,
0.0454333909,
-0.0189424977,
0.0381170474,
0.0445762537,
-0.0396678485,
-0.0257018749,
-0.0315763839,
0.0146670518,
-0.0447816998,
-0.0372706763,
0.141059041,
0.0350496657,
-0.1139547527,
0.0206176322,
-0.0326834843,
0.0365742221,
-0.0414706543,
-0.033935871,
0.0032923727,
0.1142378151,
0.0366908088,
-0.0247924887,
0.0014815531,
-0.0265621655,
0.0396718495,
0.006656622,
-0.0051073055,
0.0127296206,
-0.0247522537,
0.0291699711,
-0.0290378761,
-0.0261945501,
-0.0297702532,
0.0322140716,
0.0355498157,
0.0511589721,
-0.0046303528,
0.0316352397,
-0.0239398163,
-0.0014605069,
-0.026912855,
-0.0704688653,
0.0395040661,
0.0524625666,
0.0091577917,
0.0244182087,
0.0075832787,
-0.0013721985,
-0.0261331405,
-0.0284514688,
-0.0429899208,
0.0192340519,
0.0258543529,
-0.0360492058,
-0.0312834494,
-0.0148361083,
0.013113061,
0.0422258824,
-0.0339610986,
-0.0117621254,
0.0312939808,
0.0141632324,
-0.0110515505,
-0.0402760729,
0.0411434956,
2.034198714e-34,
0.0336461142,
-0.0490397103,
-0.0358064808,
-0.0386950299,
0.0450600199,
-0.0061510229,
-0.0303850193,
-0.0034053822,
0.0029154904,
-0.0373473354,
0.0230423622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14260v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14260v2 | R2H: Building Multimodal Navigation Helpers that Respond to Help Requests | 2023-05-23T17:12:09 | 2023-10-17T17:46:41 | Yue Fan, Jing Gu, Kaizhi Zheng, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intelligent navigation-helper agents are critical as they can navigate users
in unknown areas through environmental awareness and conversational ability,
serving as potential accessibility tools for individuals with disabilities. In
this work, we first introduce a novel benchmark, Respond to Help Requests
(R2H), to promote the development of multi-modal navigation helpers capable of
responding to requests for help, utilizing existing dialog-based embodied
datasets. R2H mainly includes two tasks: (1) Respond to Dialog History (RDH),
which assesses the helper agent's ability to generate informative responses
based on a given dialog history, and (2) Respond during Interaction (RdI),
which evaluates the effectiveness and efficiency of the response during
consistent cooperation with a task performer. Furthermore, we explore two
approaches to construct the navigation-helper agent, including fine-tuning a
novel task-oriented multi-modal response generation model that can see and
respond, named SeeRee, and employing a multi-modal large language model in a
zero-shot manner. Analysis of the task and method was conducted based on both
automatic benchmarking and human evaluations. Project website:
https://sites.google.com/view/response2helprequests/home. | [
0.0545668006,
0.0091872187,
-0.0387572795,
0.0173324067,
0.0089655612,
0.008754136,
0.0174646731,
-0.0188647434,
0.0268134158,
-0.0767537281,
-0.0286450814,
-0.0350138061,
0.006159157,
0.0343819782,
0.0287093502,
-0.0840134025,
0.0291110948,
-0.0479660369,
-0.0015147432,
0.008489755,
0.0101828314,
0.0021117758,
-0.0561758913,
0.0844449028,
-0.0171686951,
0.0061425385,
-0.0645924881,
0.0255262591,
0.0167990103,
-0.0742023215,
0.020566931,
0.0195974633,
0.0691695288,
0.0259189717,
0.0000021801,
-0.0156388991,
0.0682745576,
-0.0263583809,
0.0115834726,
-0.0745214745,
0.0203004535,
0.0054748747,
0.0299462471,
0.0201926697,
-0.0163898934,
-0.0466994569,
0.0228682589,
0.0521429107,
0.0419481248,
0.0550952889,
-0.0146699985,
0.0018370082,
0.0217559431,
0.0160659309,
0.0587328337,
-0.0140120797,
-0.018050164,
-0.0003098952,
0.0338577628,
-0.014993079,
-0.0420835949,
0.0178241767,
0.0140552297,
-0.0175671801,
0.0032963906,
0.0315979421,
0.010135226,
-0.0353407823,
-0.0328662582,
0.1446415186,
0.0451737866,
0.0447465107,
-0.0006326891,
0.0103585944,
0.0050078542,
0.0303196609,
-0.0055105542,
-0.0041652624,
-0.0055752136,
-0.0210928507,
-0.049861908,
0.0181721188,
-0.0175482854,
-0.0023777513,
0.0018427073,
0.0036564041,
-0.0042925118,
0.0050807623,
0.0350510851,
-0.0207148623,
0.0057271146,
-0.040297877,
0.0308248363,
0.04945077,
-0.0731001645,
0.0089183114,
-0.0421811901,
0.0117859226,
-0.0163473822,
-0.0503666364,
0.0567280501,
0.0631364435,
-0.0337201022,
-0.0185160786,
-0.0165090635,
0.0501433201,
-0.0325256921,
-0.0110371253,
0.0029035949,
0.0198310427,
-0.0363338403,
0.0170697253,
-0.037236847,
0.003800008,
-0.0892236009,
-0.0456990488,
0.0171982013,
0.0506028309,
-0.0010792254,
-0.0217765514,
-0.0357696973,
0.0580325872,
-0.0100964196,
0.020192422,
-0.0384460241,
-0.0309420675,
-0.0291526951,
0.0399399623,
0.0075579952,
-0.0508359559,
0.0261564031,
0.0304603577,
0.0140475072,
-0.0269042291,
-0.0381262451,
0.0924224854,
-0.0182918217,
-0.0288739279,
-0.0173617546,
-0.0151825612,
-0.0058258735,
-0.0537090674,
-0.000985843,
-0.0318474248,
0.0365659595,
-0.0102456249,
-0.020094078,
-0.0171844382,
0.0292274747,
0.0003079565,
-0.0053210491,
0.0502542555,
0.0129654724,
0.0233782288,
0.0617572367,
0.0074226442,
-0.0054620942,
0.0398768373,
0.0529611893,
0.0211058091,
0.008513323,
-0.0261812024,
0.0108255465,
0.0167341791,
-0.0267179068,
0.0003045015,
0.0168122444,
0.0110029671,
-0.0388030373,
0.0588655025,
0.0157554131,
0.0400936902,
-0.0328335129,
-0.0049134833,
0.0372366868,
0.0285429172,
0.0202123336,
-0.0322363973,
0.032099247,
0.0225871429,
-0.0184987579,
-0.0471138023,
-0.035593424,
0.0388321355,
-0.0077505857,
-0.0203679595,
0.0033078331,
0.0337727517,
-0.0410554484,
-0.0302881636,
0.040715903,
0.0002896235,
0.0166973677,
0.0127298348,
0.044259537,
-0.0219360925,
-0.056706015,
-0.0223910753,
-0.0169720575,
-0.0399146602,
-0.0222254768,
-0.0504808165,
0.0066633737,
0.04625085,
0.0310024619,
0.0149025759,
-0.0183551535,
-0.0118763754,
0.0218094438,
0.044674404,
-0.0246801656,
0.0035945727,
0.0543937534,
-0.0358724371,
-0.0645282194,
0.0294532683,
-0.0061421767,
0.040332187,
-0.0269487519,
0.0294706393,
0.0283624306,
0.0175399352,
0.0252769589,
0.0377875008,
0.0153033733,
0.0337897949,
0.003228009,
-0.0032148138,
0.0329135172,
0.0354533121,
-0.0398662202,
-0.0081692468,
0.0181821808,
-0.01041051,
-0.0093035391,
0.0708427802,
-0.0442769267,
-0.0511954874,
0.0173358638,
-0.0602086931,
-0.0047770743,
0.0739086643,
0.0303842295,
-0.0516234227,
0.0000404442,
-0.0652847961,
-0.0058253468,
-0.0222353004,
0.0245149992,
0.0409964174,
-0.0057165297,
-0.0049664113,
0.0221844334,
-0.0113887731,
0.0293508451,
0.0125558758,
0.028517833,
0.0238889772,
-0.0782627538,
-0.0185655709,
0.0138604231,
-0.0282951221,
0.0175982136,
0.0268247481,
0.0148962848,
-0.0392819121,
0.0001955993,
-0.0968298167,
-0.0506086722,
-0.0221278481,
-0.0169704631,
-0.0006652771,
-0.0170596465,
-0.0210619215,
-0.0110519622,
-0.0069489763,
0.0836981833,
0.048357062,
-0.015285085,
0.0055103344,
-0.0034055933,
-0.0390233733,
-0.0657400116,
0.0348504819,
0.0008247403,
0.011737003,
0.0314509831,
-0.044692561,
-0.0424302444,
-0.0045094928,
-0.0248109121,
0.0641922951,
-0.0280329082,
-0.0554693937,
0.0569544509,
-0.0023544312,
0.0300804563,
0.0043313247,
0.0452968217,
0.0187664609,
0.0389253795,
-0.0688751116,
-0.0840845928,
0.0453136973,
-0.0212833639,
0.0296307597,
-0.0715108588,
-0.0470628403,
0.0072107622,
0.0183375776,
0.0149682248,
0.0409422442,
-0.0458493754,
-0.0201738309,
0.0172177758,
-0.0968426168,
-0.0122024389,
0.0434234962,
-0.0601168647,
0.0223204158,
-0.0218978953,
-0.0219456628,
0.0172873531,
-0.028736515,
-0.0405176654,
0.0225011781,
0.030197287,
-0.0028133665,
0.0927741379,
0.0025940472,
0.0205372032,
-0.0142047917,
-0.026928734,
0.0064653438,
-0.0022466041,
-0.0134360539,
-0.01239751,
0.0294175986,
-0.0746419951,
0.0170799978,
-0.0181118902,
-0.0023365219,
-0.0310127456,
-0.0079376418,
0.005788492,
-0.0134922601,
-0.0087035419,
-0.0389413536,
-0.0540016852,
0.0103667798,
0.0548226647,
0.0781529918,
0.0222562943,
-0.0174653474,
-0.0086411275,
0.00682414,
0.0715839341,
0.1034053564,
-0.0299404003,
-0.0238112863,
0.0746609867,
0.0345901698,
0.0513740368,
-0.0273330435,
-0.0356317498,
-0.0163498949,
0.0537217408,
0.0580520779,
0.0348341875,
0.0691061765,
0.0694168285,
-0.0063445996,
-0.0126131512,
0.0951094404,
0.0074398373,
-0.0337224044,
0.0185905173,
-0.0485262945,
-0.0071406639,
0.0154447025,
-0.0065875966,
-0.0443832539,
-0.0385403708,
-0.0191065259,
0.0136489384,
0.0047018058,
-0.0225478448,
0.0078935456,
-0.0976310149,
0.0597440414,
-0.0203231163,
-0.050970424,
-0.0255518444,
-0.0008759284,
0.0162837151,
0.0377944298,
-0.0008373455,
0.0152823692,
-0.0074599897,
-0.0282859765,
0.0182248745,
-0.0016030576,
-0.0370868854,
0.0025527754,
-0.0229862686,
0.1051746607,
0.0277746338,
0.0484149121,
-0.0107425498,
0.0023395193,
-0.0146018788,
-0.0107869264,
0.043207068,
-0.0345160216,
0.0295676906,
-0.0110225677,
-0.0213285349,
-0.029735893,
0.0381661318,
-0.0686698258,
-0.0023777841,
0.0596147105,
0.0111409593,
-0.0847959742,
0.0176875424,
-0.0670565143,
0.0216901042,
0.0405352861,
0.0401136279,
-0.0139598995,
-0.0497903712,
-0.0405532978,
-0.0080449339,
-0.0190224554,
-0.0476079881,
-0.0315438807,
-0.012325733,
-0.0213259924,
-0.0090039596,
-0.082080029,
-0.0581381395,
0.0225708224,
0.058595024,
-0.0052653337,
-0.0278487653,
-0.0210480727,
0.0379566513,
-0.0204278734,
0.0379653051,
0.0051738312,
0.0398636535,
-0.0664831847,
0.0091061238,
-0.0109949876,
-0.0581308566,
-0.0030366285,
0.0119189611,
0.0041123792,
-0.061307013,
-0.0006673995,
0.0573086552,
0.0233372878,
0.0136342254,
0.0121777635,
-0.0395435244,
-0.0076476713,
0.0331779048,
-0.0451555699,
0.0184354614,
0.0341997333,
0.0129589988,
-0.0233394392,
0.0095470138,
-0.052949395,
0.0225258451,
-0.0156308543,
0.0461940132,
-0.0106952479,
-0.0393569991,
-0.0081296954,
0.017708417,
0.0514534265,
-0.0134984041,
0.016331939,
-0.0207654983,
0.0156570934,
-0.0270986091,
0.0267884377,
-0.0930411518,
0.0204591211,
0.0164065827,
0.0091746878,
0.0421580337,
-0.0014577379,
-0.039988935,
0.0071271523,
-0.0346564464,
0.0459589101,
0.0224857517,
0.0382162109,
-0.0314109065,
0.0170902051,
-0.0159925874,
0.0191248879,
-0.0016248766,
0.0163101293,
0.0267318543,
0.115657039,
0.0092111072,
-0.0374141894,
0.0037275325,
0.0373730138,
-0.0102066286,
-0.050736215,
0.0040651178,
0.0349576063,
0.0252342485,
0.0533180051,
0.018155193,
-0.0006364422,
0.0290709957,
-0.0336988904,
0.026312001,
0.0089128902,
-0.0279667899,
0.058405228,
0.01505828,
0.0007183423,
-0.0214419886,
0.0440760069,
-0.0001658027,
0.0259846672,
0.000210961,
0.0176202413,
-0.0418189466,
-0.0418629535,
0.0159842763,
0.0403680094,
-0.0182319507,
0.0190317724,
-0.0237280037,
-0.0328137726,
-0.0381628238,
0.0273242667,
-0.0017661937,
-0.0304348264,
0.0540617332,
-0.0181779414,
0.0201583914,
-0.0621708035,
-0.0483788028,
-0.0364062823,
-0.0933561698,
0.008578172,
-0.0491209291,
-5.58134085e-33,
-0.0373421907,
-0.0339949355,
0.0365037359,
-0.0094492696,
-0.0395011567,
-0.0048812572,
-0.0556155108,
0.0366500765,
-0.0423116423,
-0.0046139699,
0.0370185263,
-0.0127947275,
0.0040759565,
0.0271479599,
-0.0174667742,
0.0212201104,
0.0091847442,
0.0091466345,
-0.0358166434,
0.0163135342,
0.0436099283,
-0.0080278721,
0.0001452186,
-0.0650077909,
0.0248241518,
-0.0355140194,
-0.0260974523,
0.0295870788,
-0.0100489818,
0.0410443433,
-0.0468179919,
0.0516338758,
0.0199995115,
0.0079510026,
-0.0067949295,
0.0555764176,
-0.0223824773,
-0.0374533981,
0.0266287979,
0.0241863094,
-0.0809340551,
0.0210757628,
0.0103689767,
-0.0034226771,
-0.0351076014,
-0.0136666745,
0.0288219173,
-0.0032376228,
-0.0144225508,
0.0304831211,
-0.0732177272,
0.0198608935,
-0.0119330743,
-0.0800656974,
0.003261646,
0.107974492,
0.0007982404,
-0.0255889781,
-0.0021685213,
0.0053241123,
-0.0187881403,
-0.0325481854,
0.0333151966,
0.0532572642,
0.0352539644,
0.0788744912,
0.0386947319,
-0.0033783761,
-0.0465621836,
-0.021895716,
0.0027297689,
0.0817162991,
-0.0041668345,
0.0969253108,
-0.0049070325,
-0.0058255787,
-0.0223304164,
0.0656144992,
0.0176692307,
0.054827597,
0.0136178313,
0.0062657576,
-0.0402997471,
0.0323888399,
-0.056311097,
0.0344070122,
-0.0187700335,
-0.0493824221,
0.0545209348,
0.0221177507,
0.0155106122,
-0.052915141,
0.0736186206,
-0.0081319846,
0.0137293367,
-0.010958001,
-0.0081511829,
0.0356381387,
0.009829659,
-0.0022333784,
-0.0419235192,
-0.0420236066,
0.0751553401,
-0.0248582661,
0.0183478966,
-0.00195165,
-0.0710752085,
0.0404859148,
-0.0351388156,
-0.0272638537,
-0.0325174853,
0.0203881748,
-0.0068497253,
0.0247532818,
0.0218725689,
-0.0240289681,
-0.0646651164,
0.070133768,
-0.049303066,
-0.0353426598,
-0.0448186025,
-0.0524618067,
0.0054230262,
0.0280401241,
-0.0327172279,
0.0017752622,
-0.0173086878,
-0.0231383145,
0.0256962124,
-0.041061841,
-0.0088889031,
0.0212516636,
2.785e-7,
-0.0289102104,
0.0149972858,
0.0063833133,
0.0293441005,
0.0263887066,
0.04978076,
-0.0145055335,
0.0455257967,
-0.0108924685,
-0.0289342646,
0.0123562105,
0.0199524686,
0.0308644753,
0.0010032591,
-0.0203329865,
-0.0188592318,
-0.0110744936,
-0.0495049208,
-0.0302280672,
0.0260911919,
0.0882471129,
0.0164660364,
-0.0534099825,
-0.0156883169,
0.0051756874,
-0.0186797883,
0.0524565466,
-0.073240608,
-0.007978973,
-0.0233744103,
0.0279460121,
-0.0017588033,
-0.0089557599,
0.0115412585,
0.0079751937,
0.0186615866,
-0.0221138149,
0.0512403883,
-0.0457625128,
-0.0343654826,
0.0186203923,
0.0288261361,
-0.0058609201,
-0.0256137252,
0.0350292325,
-0.044342611,
-0.0299254581,
0.0050948588,
-0.0156672318,
-0.002814376,
-0.018613033,
-0.0331805237,
0.0080148568,
-0.0277832001,
-0.00149185,
-0.0288059171,
0.0033369747,
-0.0684662834,
-0.0104900906,
0.0159920938,
-0.0610039011,
-0.0362517796,
-0.0449858382,
0.0074026403,
0.0003351704,
-0.0316173322,
-0.0315782502,
1.608722449e-34,
0.0003649599,
0.0235674884,
-0.0195986461,
0.0188245811,
0.0402721725,
-0.001892588,
-0.0113082519,
0.0073860744,
0.0406584591,
-0.0409810431,
-0.0396997705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14259v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14259v7 | SciMON: Scientific Inspiration Machines Optimized for Novelty | 2023-05-23T17:12:08 | 2024-06-03T21:15:28 | Qingyun Wang, Doug Downey, Heng Ji, Tom Hope | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We explore and enhance the ability of neural language models to generate
novel scientific directions grounded in literature. Work on literature-based
hypothesis generation has traditionally focused on binary link
prediction--severely limiting the expressivity of hypotheses. This line of work
also does not focus on optimizing novelty. We take a dramatic departure with a
novel setting in which models use as input background contexts (e.g., problems,
experimental settings, goals), and output natural language ideas grounded in
literature. We present SciMON, a modeling framework that uses retrieval of
"inspirations" from past scientific papers, and explicitly optimizes for
novelty by iteratively comparing to prior papers and updating idea suggestions
until sufficient novelty is achieved. Comprehensive evaluations reveal that
GPT-4 tends to generate ideas with overall low technical depth and novelty,
while our methods partially mitigate this issue. Our work represents a first
step toward evaluating and developing language models that generate new ideas
derived from the scientific literature | [
0.0390104018,
0.0261291619,
0.0017562648,
0.0066325176,
-0.0432088189,
-0.0461640656,
-0.0250494778,
-0.0087573193,
-0.0014842985,
-0.004356428,
-0.0174607411,
-0.0174967945,
-0.0100939646,
0.0815384611,
0.0163387209,
-0.0348958448,
0.0205474589,
0.0032327606,
0.0256975442,
-0.0242061615,
-0.0446574911,
0.001094384,
0.0287895668,
0.0267030019,
0.0468315519,
-0.0269141011,
0.0081764432,
-0.0002131999,
0.0351613015,
-0.0680536702,
0.0097909579,
0.0329916589,
0.033385016,
0.0904273242,
0.0000017108,
-0.0685458556,
-0.0274692178,
0.016774809,
0.0518646725,
0.0086874831,
0.0550564378,
0.0015232188,
0.0140852565,
-0.0226970557,
-0.029610591,
0.0106720449,
0.0238914937,
0.04080626,
-0.0095185908,
0.0224958435,
0.0024033079,
-0.0523177907,
0.062117096,
-0.0372407958,
0.0627117082,
0.0397003517,
0.0245520212,
-0.01645758,
0.0306592807,
0.0709105283,
0.0079563763,
0.0291024763,
0.0284689907,
0.0053557386,
0.0672676489,
0.0571237989,
-0.0036632549,
0.0130708572,
-0.0029125572,
0.0706289336,
-0.0386246257,
-0.069043003,
0.0021369942,
-0.027145559,
-0.0371464267,
0.0350522399,
-0.0682986975,
-0.0046644015,
0.0031153173,
0.0132951774,
0.0649307445,
0.0024867156,
0.0526414327,
0.0141580831,
0.0130069098,
0.0771093592,
0.0603404008,
-0.0336375162,
-0.0120954225,
-0.0132015003,
-0.0032643892,
-0.0250945352,
0.0017669534,
0.0115145417,
-0.003149905,
0.0180659294,
-0.0040491046,
-0.0284390524,
0.0437185951,
-0.0256173667,
0.0530948043,
0.0180168189,
0.0046933563,
0.0539838336,
-0.0298489779,
-0.0213251319,
-0.0829111785,
-0.0364411026,
-0.0183382463,
-0.0013518176,
-0.091346316,
-0.045832783,
-0.0213128533,
0.0118491706,
-0.0091008423,
-0.0327583179,
0.0012286701,
0.0319794193,
0.029834209,
-0.0462126881,
-0.0197370462,
0.0412692539,
-0.0489600636,
-0.0224583317,
-0.0460701659,
0.0164159145,
-0.019690156,
0.0202226583,
0.0129922759,
-0.0087631168,
-0.0361591876,
-0.007297961,
-0.0266928114,
-0.0136650726,
0.0339990109,
0.0351837724,
0.028845137,
-0.0135844303,
-0.0003694322,
-0.0573336706,
0.0322560892,
-0.0281823501,
0.0779026821,
-0.0610455424,
0.0263888519,
-0.0007143512,
-0.0176086854,
-0.0297689661,
0.0099901725,
0.0172608793,
-0.0452612303,
0.0227587465,
-0.0710547939,
-0.0143132899,
0.0369606614,
0.0265754275,
-0.0128975101,
0.028743973,
0.0207022373,
-0.0222485643,
0.0295993183,
0.0109413704,
0.0229413714,
-0.0248463675,
0.0130058303,
-0.0205071401,
0.0145966932,
-0.0156677794,
-0.0384997465,
0.0839430764,
-0.0184255522,
0.0358647518,
-0.0280486271,
0.0292962771,
0.0323221982,
0.0742297024,
0.0132659758,
0.0554825068,
0.0376943201,
-0.0290085282,
-0.0134581849,
-0.0065273368,
0.0174874552,
0.0595442206,
-0.0319725946,
0.0057072951,
0.0156389456,
0.0401646271,
-0.0191150866,
0.005064589,
0.0125076007,
0.0411490239,
-0.0211993586,
-0.0540805869,
0.0422945991,
0.0194899421,
-0.0164481886,
-0.0114829326,
0.0386788063,
-0.015143835,
0.0075223534,
0.0027944192,
0.0358512551,
0.035994526,
0.0755589753,
-0.0461393669,
-0.0256268401,
-0.0152049493,
-0.0339010693,
0.05263751,
0.0210823882,
-0.0021188855,
-0.0198247023,
-0.0187479611,
-0.0055680592,
-0.0602751113,
0.0025646142,
0.019346755,
-0.0024334278,
0.0116766682,
-0.008128684,
0.000746122,
-0.0076372949,
0.0543323271,
-0.0709791332,
0.0099610891,
0.0455244668,
-0.0866283923,
0.0254959911,
0.0076306961,
0.0001698742,
0.0497446693,
0.0687764809,
-0.0572399907,
-0.0812122375,
0.0460664928,
-0.0040034135,
-0.0118122911,
0.0421312638,
-0.0904873535,
0.0423478298,
-0.0052968492,
-0.0020131005,
-0.0392136201,
0.0840139985,
-0.020883644,
0.0183378011,
-0.0287135728,
0.0033124178,
-0.0275014378,
0.0368960053,
-0.0274976473,
0.0719569847,
0.004622445,
0.046897091,
0.0399045125,
-0.0097598135,
0.0228102226,
-0.0247889943,
-0.0244410094,
-0.0214815512,
0.0436849371,
-0.019552961,
0.0520141572,
-0.0173339732,
-0.0197568852,
-0.0140474346,
-0.0144116562,
0.014963883,
0.0138472309,
-0.0279697441,
0.0217166543,
-0.0006288898,
0.0098300884,
0.000296681,
-0.0062967245,
0.0186449587,
0.0044229026,
-0.0076208403,
0.0580263138,
0.0051795575,
-0.0051691094,
-0.0528866686,
-0.018037146,
-0.0537221506,
0.0567692481,
0.0353044197,
0.0152601777,
-0.0653731972,
0.0051793698,
-0.0212876722,
0.0218057763,
-0.0493595488,
0.0354077145,
0.0510174371,
-0.0403595641,
0.0248427596,
0.0111826984,
0.0187999401,
0.0271908753,
0.054649435,
0.0218287148,
-0.0484471358,
-0.0039838022,
-0.0756560266,
0.0582021959,
0.0153694563,
0.0147650056,
0.0447158515,
-0.004645844,
-0.0011197939,
-0.016199898,
-0.0283242296,
0.0767450333,
0.0245857332,
-0.0329078287,
0.0206529908,
-0.0255564619,
-0.0042026746,
0.0243931245,
0.0302588455,
-0.0275329314,
0.0911752433,
0.0049663275,
0.006680659,
-0.0585963689,
0.0168131534,
-0.0406126045,
0.0534415692,
-0.0168790165,
-0.0047708708,
0.0477335155,
0.0320673399,
-0.0271608308,
0.027554661,
-0.0159586277,
0.0005711985,
-0.003014297,
-0.0302250981,
-0.0042968895,
0.0480198413,
-0.0202501193,
-0.0247731004,
-0.026078308,
0.0122266142,
0.0473462828,
0.0310728066,
-0.0298763495,
-0.0387965441,
-0.0364973359,
0.0429607369,
0.0283828098,
-0.0071305032,
-0.0336426049,
-0.0251779109,
-0.0034461913,
0.0724216476,
-0.0612202063,
0.030073842,
0.0067678601,
0.0181330219,
0.0329234377,
-0.0361389481,
-0.0026502984,
-0.0498945788,
0.0112931505,
-0.0104992781,
-0.014147358,
-0.0262087844,
-0.0158047024,
0.0288333986,
-0.0309068486,
-0.0410153978,
0.0636901557,
0.0227409545,
-0.0317467265,
0.0151583478,
-0.0182644669,
0.023710832,
0.0274449009,
0.0393186659,
-0.0614867918,
0.0056770183,
-0.043407701,
-0.0105204256,
-0.0116097778,
-0.0457169637,
-0.0348502845,
-0.0817998946,
0.026310686,
0.0122418962,
-0.056304343,
-0.0188091025,
-0.0571433119,
-0.0287455246,
-0.0021273154,
-0.0543174259,
0.026094174,
0.0159751866,
0.0099620689,
-0.0212613735,
0.0155085111,
-0.0748812333,
0.0024341638,
-0.0349555351,
0.0251812022,
0.0598856285,
0.0161680058,
-0.0032731628,
-0.0303751789,
-0.0406871624,
-0.0563825034,
0.0029302847,
-0.0174461938,
-0.0021031974,
0.0348570868,
0.0023145587,
-0.0130301621,
0.0748201385,
-0.0585724972,
-0.0361505114,
0.0063012885,
0.0870029926,
-0.0221937373,
-0.0290462151,
-0.0828643069,
0.0007915326,
0.0110320486,
0.0983781368,
-0.0048651025,
-0.051893793,
-0.0304192882,
-0.0217183474,
0.0242321733,
-0.0110257166,
-0.0107975826,
-0.0724535063,
-0.0051395856,
0.0276976749,
-0.0782269612,
-0.0126485955,
-0.0271234438,
0.0241427254,
0.0055098003,
0.0401652418,
-0.0325736329,
-0.0385248587,
-0.0269072466,
0.030299684,
0.0254524797,
-0.013565368,
-0.0076616062,
-0.0113055622,
0.0717098862,
-0.0357505567,
-0.0390294231,
0.0476613864,
-0.0369976498,
-0.0858906955,
-0.0484617464,
0.0283136647,
0.0280584861,
0.0173712522,
-0.0094367573,
-0.0542284846,
0.0536292419,
0.0240941048,
0.044570934,
0.0039183884,
-0.0069403388,
0.0038077596,
-0.0072066151,
-0.0124158394,
-0.0122750448,
0.0132890651,
0.0162842926,
0.0277477652,
-0.0369832069,
-0.0268621016,
0.0247758292,
0.0094707226,
0.0626584068,
-0.0588903353,
0.0137980906,
-0.0378566347,
-0.0422642343,
-0.0067483797,
0.009216221,
-0.0629493147,
0.026789397,
0.0104136989,
-0.0009032087,
-0.0258269701,
-0.0297743175,
-0.0411089584,
0.0475699678,
-0.0614762269,
-0.036552459,
0.0225833114,
0.0444568545,
0.013115691,
-0.0133352792,
-0.0185924917,
0.012233316,
-0.0671338215,
0.0450798422,
-0.0310513079,
0.0309685003,
0.0511981212,
0.0026312389,
-0.0205553044,
0.0261771455,
-0.1341594309,
-0.0584154874,
-0.0699588358,
0.0446739942,
0.0059140394,
0.0739468485,
0.0306451879,
-0.0589741394,
-0.0282944385,
-0.0212803576,
0.0428524688,
-0.0131221432,
-0.0139606176,
0.0599347576,
0.0234289896,
-0.0218641162,
-0.0126753794,
0.0621366203,
-0.0346436352,
0.0407968052,
0.0125825889,
0.0179364979,
-0.0212732702,
0.015095477,
-0.0102512101,
0.0539304577,
0.0025987183,
-0.0069332719,
-0.0550304204,
0.0292819869,
0.0930871367,
0.0438306704,
0.0224742591,
0.0148742255,
0.0457482636,
0.0483881123,
-0.0407230221,
-0.0204758085,
0.0186825059,
0.0106210588,
-0.0474202558,
-0.0742832497,
-0.0480142981,
-5.92452863e-33,
0.0200807843,
0.0127072399,
0.0126417717,
0.0046877069,
-0.0156495795,
0.0080105383,
-0.0821470618,
-0.011456836,
-0.0170649625,
0.0305994805,
0.0050829654,
0.002270292,
-0.0325776897,
-0.0072100852,
0.0191239771,
0.0063878498,
0.0213650484,
0.0040933155,
-0.0152266622,
0.0420998968,
0.0530577339,
0.0233507417,
0.041687008,
-0.0406575389,
0.0025532937,
-0.0188772399,
0.0069680973,
0.0046765655,
-0.0217445772,
0.0318066441,
-0.0558913089,
0.0335158408,
-0.0015226386,
-0.0806688964,
-0.0019676944,
-0.0409661122,
-0.0091769574,
-0.0461497493,
0.0019904191,
-0.0740397796,
-0.006368645,
-0.0279275496,
0.0263561029,
-0.0055315122,
-0.0304314923,
-0.0277367551,
0.0366443209,
-0.0048140748,
-0.0295438413,
-0.0293749142,
-0.0652658716,
-0.0058895811,
0.0153553169,
0.0142549891,
-0.0253791977,
-0.0113004269,
-0.003695806,
0.0578021705,
0.0021158839,
0.0618816987,
0.024997374,
-0.0044880449,
0.0093874941,
-0.0204663333,
0.0427015685,
0.0794730484,
0.0393596031,
-0.0174110141,
-0.0139922071,
-0.0103454832,
0.018654054,
0.0349120833,
0.0867226943,
0.0276139546,
0.0468161404,
0.0573637523,
-0.0687713623,
0.0061483439,
0.041448649,
-0.0143475411,
0.0490471236,
0.031012807,
0.0347953849,
-0.024788389,
-0.0091585498,
-0.0781316087,
-0.0163070709,
-0.0290859323,
-0.0120752323,
-0.0099401195,
-0.0306489635,
0.0560627319,
0.0290713776,
-0.0310919136,
0.0283252317,
0.0662666112,
-0.0361634754,
0.0151956566,
0.0154791949,
0.0043801786,
-0.0590196885,
-0.0228763223,
0.0432866737,
0.0347876176,
0.0330512188,
0.014749716,
-0.0212576222,
0.0091062188,
-0.0106562395,
-0.0155485487,
-0.0397419222,
-0.0098654311,
0.039534416,
-0.0151136061,
-0.020308502,
0.0159601644,
0.0010684865,
0.0296512004,
0.0324031152,
0.0378717445,
-0.0226740949,
0.0313171484,
0.0098356688,
0.0340283029,
-0.014115449,
0.0015831594,
0.0204521101,
-0.0052820542,
0.0146943517,
-0.0666013807,
-0.0295623839,
0.0367099643,
2.528e-7,
0.0298187193,
0.0383770168,
0.010033655,
-0.0206659473,
0.0390886553,
0.0159055833,
-0.0235546548,
0.0186054111,
0.019997485,
-0.0027350078,
-0.0172913894,
-0.0027061629,
-0.0249371678,
0.0115021709,
-0.0835442543,
-0.0504600517,
-0.087083213,
-0.0134637291,
-0.0442396812,
-0.0179331098,
0.0153349834,
0.0508464016,
0.0313050933,
-0.0318344384,
0.0093284165,
-0.0403876752,
0.0836935416,
-0.0316042565,
0.0370287336,
0.0561661273,
-0.0040467102,
0.021070743,
-0.0222679116,
-0.0121840443,
-0.011884925,
0.0098993005,
-0.0214111488,
-0.0240104049,
-0.0115174977,
-0.0313472897,
0.0426507108,
-0.0013806847,
0.0105486233,
-0.0489707068,
0.0112565113,
-0.0631708726,
-0.0146509465,
-0.0131888269,
-0.0070990287,
-0.0010296298,
0.0550640449,
-0.0520967245,
0.0143642984,
-0.0239571109,
-0.021269314,
0.0664198622,
-0.0391087569,
-0.0653181374,
-0.0279911403,
0.0329063125,
-0.0715717599,
-0.0219015647,
-0.0138379699,
-0.0124473786,
0.0184747316,
-0.0463177934,
0.0201096423,
2.434245615e-34,
0.0541246943,
-0.0261506159,
-0.0325505883,
0.031775374,
0.0060597914,
0.014915538,
0.0120999152,
0.0056585665,
0.0263680425,
-0.0685303882,
-0.0355563685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14257v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14257v3 | Hierarchical Prompting Assists Large Language Model on Web Navigation | 2023-05-23T17:10:39 | 2023-10-30T00:55:53 | Abishek Sridhar, Robert Lo, Frank F. Xu, Hao Zhu, Shuyan Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) struggle on processing complicated observations
in interactive decision making tasks. To alleviate this issue, we propose a
simple hierarchical prompting approach. Diverging from previous prompting
approaches that always put the full observation (e.g. a web page) to the
prompt, we propose to first construct an action-aware observation which is more
condensed and relevant with a dedicated SUMMARIZER prompt. The ACTOR prompt
then predicts the next action based on the summarized observation. While our
method has broad applicability, we particularly demonstrate its efficacy in the
complex domain of web navigation where a full observation often contains
redundant and irrelevant information. Our approach outperforms the previous
state-of-the-art prompting mechanics by 6.2% on task success rate,
demonstrating its potential on interactive decision making tasks with long
observation traces. | [
0.0500512458,
0.0178229194,
-0.0107093668,
-0.0105225965,
0.0116241304,
0.0251956992,
0.0007676187,
0.009571298,
0.0622087494,
-0.0541792922,
-0.0259115286,
-0.0662783384,
-0.0014502815,
0.0451543555,
0.0278314017,
-0.0740391687,
0.0208531152,
-0.0941871405,
0.0311394613,
-0.0058005922,
-0.007563306,
-0.0262138508,
-0.0042736907,
0.0770342425,
0.0452490561,
-0.0233393293,
-0.0337698385,
0.0001926452,
0.009990667,
-0.0753752589,
-0.0005793546,
0.053201627,
0.0432933681,
0.0279060248,
0.0000019302,
-0.0413246676,
0.0278392751,
-0.0448173955,
-0.0501547828,
0.0147097185,
-0.0017444808,
0.0418524817,
-0.0032557542,
0.0416030213,
-0.0004433734,
-0.0041684299,
-0.008420595,
0.0674528256,
0.0275546461,
0.0245699752,
-0.0022216996,
0.0267081875,
-0.0054872739,
-0.0257408153,
0.0220096856,
-0.0407368951,
0.0060103158,
-0.0080530066,
0.0152721675,
0.0265791062,
-0.0132698314,
0.0190956295,
0.0141988276,
-0.0309862886,
0.007843405,
0.0534630567,
0.0131905703,
-0.0206394978,
-0.0235467423,
0.067525804,
0.0085471161,
0.0128772315,
0.0269817729,
0.0074665467,
0.0353457145,
0.0231462419,
-0.0484765843,
0.0213767663,
-0.0083438605,
-0.0018995887,
0.003973241,
0.0082256459,
0.0144492304,
0.0180244073,
-0.019089235,
0.050806094,
0.010044043,
-0.0328873768,
0.0166109614,
0.0004790643,
0.0206840802,
-0.0832559168,
0.0149165196,
0.0493434444,
-0.1012299657,
0.0155610871,
-0.0145232752,
0.0373404548,
0.0096567888,
-0.0558037385,
0.0530390181,
0.0377535224,
-0.0144603504,
0.073047623,
0.003457325,
0.0558451451,
-0.0161128119,
-0.0230104681,
-0.050559666,
0.0364025757,
-0.0203175358,
0.0020123781,
-0.0145581653,
0.0124311391,
-0.0391969271,
-0.0548290163,
-0.003150196,
0.0789988637,
0.0105223581,
0.0530993752,
-0.0171198528,
0.0094580641,
-0.0051645166,
0.0007205962,
-0.0566224381,
0.0269494578,
-0.0448329821,
-0.00470781,
0.025617972,
-0.0170321763,
0.0087505998,
0.0194087066,
-0.0170867722,
-0.0075957431,
-0.0291477852,
0.0631591305,
-0.0294200387,
-0.0175811183,
-0.0449179448,
-0.035699375,
-0.00635166,
-0.027098136,
-0.0104015311,
-0.0570289157,
0.0385776721,
0.0179674663,
-0.0223051384,
0.0065555843,
0.0180240925,
0.0542510711,
-0.0173104331,
0.0361097455,
0.0354016833,
-0.0015815969,
0.002536735,
0.0053354139,
0.0071232258,
0.05503067,
0.0144962594,
0.0940034389,
0.0120153269,
0.0228976924,
-0.0022973344,
0.0281691607,
-0.0315690972,
0.0229624081,
0.0034372259,
-0.0092917085,
-0.0051199128,
0.0135245305,
0.015068993,
0.0643258318,
-0.0451610088,
0.0354319774,
0.0830059126,
0.0408059731,
-0.0045576738,
-0.0228160489,
0.0341305062,
0.0218386035,
-0.0009974887,
0.0252430998,
-0.0828325674,
0.0479825288,
-0.0523054712,
-0.0116112083,
0.0478404388,
0.0271056835,
-0.0342291147,
-0.0458415188,
0.0081748022,
0.0081909103,
0.0022232684,
0.0413862728,
0.0305472035,
-0.0291914605,
-0.0367095657,
-0.0156824272,
0.0410658121,
-0.0178443715,
0.0288738534,
-0.0382667594,
0.0536957681,
0.1282293797,
0.0645542592,
-0.0093062278,
-0.0392993316,
-0.0366097353,
0.0324948244,
0.0091260504,
0.0389558263,
-0.0311396103,
-0.0277547296,
-0.0325453579,
-0.0949003249,
0.0455620065,
-0.0051658414,
0.0022296484,
0.001416333,
-0.0208260864,
0.0261058826,
0.0021064992,
-0.0237895139,
0.0226935297,
-0.011411258,
-0.0341969058,
-0.0118819941,
0.0083906464,
0.0191855766,
0.0130560705,
0.0263891257,
-0.0070700007,
0.0254380852,
-0.0010925947,
-0.0160857346,
-0.0236292034,
-0.0273398589,
-0.0416560471,
0.0294957031,
-0.0169622991,
0.0022211953,
-0.0023225958,
0.0073242746,
-0.0565614589,
-0.0486742072,
-0.034470994,
0.0134404656,
0.0096748779,
0.0352860987,
0.0279983897,
-0.0129442234,
-0.0452102236,
0.061553549,
0.0115185408,
0.0157204885,
0.0587062947,
0.0162837431,
-0.0376345329,
-0.0418148264,
-0.0375499427,
0.0078316974,
0.0055809226,
-0.0007856572,
0.0678735971,
0.0143460864,
-0.0630155951,
-0.0254552439,
-0.0976207778,
-0.011215887,
-0.0277597159,
0.0230525136,
0.0085030496,
0.0259257518,
-0.0229073446,
-0.0077841859,
-0.0448479615,
-0.0049600778,
0.0096073663,
0.0343595035,
-0.0042159692,
0.0006538573,
-0.0271027703,
-0.038476456,
-0.0180613454,
0.0002576022,
0.0402102135,
0.01724484,
-0.0583798885,
-0.0785419419,
0.0017270212,
-0.0141360098,
0.0415114798,
-0.0398536883,
-0.013879953,
0.0125751384,
-0.0352005325,
0.060677778,
0.0609811321,
0.0345842578,
0.0430516116,
0.0683214143,
-0.0128749516,
-0.0850169808,
0.0162673648,
-0.0287804473,
-0.0072790729,
-0.0738490671,
0.0083691766,
0.0301103164,
0.0311080609,
-0.0356574208,
0.0272791386,
-0.027523296,
-0.0267474521,
-0.0365063697,
-0.017715646,
-0.0542334765,
-0.0096475165,
-0.0471320786,
0.0707929954,
0.0076964861,
-0.0198509376,
0.0635368749,
-0.0148010729,
-0.0126868282,
-0.0116625857,
0.0045480896,
-0.0118883345,
0.0713770539,
0.0031364174,
0.0241345651,
-0.0118017504,
-0.0413226821,
-0.0444746986,
-0.0048376811,
0.0169625655,
-0.0223863162,
0.070447959,
-0.0580715798,
0.019379437,
0.0082856305,
-0.0502173118,
-0.0863357633,
-0.0481863245,
-0.0221108813,
-0.0152701596,
-0.0116140395,
-0.0324303806,
-0.0457250178,
0.005884001,
0.0700469241,
0.0710063055,
-0.010338624,
-0.0348080732,
-0.0002891634,
-0.0022028992,
0.0608723797,
0.0241197739,
-0.0005113062,
-0.0443303213,
0.0491732433,
0.0565086119,
0.0435042083,
-0.0299647935,
0.0183068253,
-0.0023223774,
0.0682395175,
-0.0417940505,
-0.0228402503,
0.0610878505,
0.0151214525,
-0.0585759915,
0.016052654,
0.1412087828,
0.051432129,
-0.0932019278,
-0.0164510477,
-0.0316911191,
0.0513343737,
0.0093000801,
0.0288965628,
-0.037397705,
-0.0197121799,
0.0314192548,
0.0127535732,
0.0288847834,
-0.0028754841,
0.0171251129,
-0.1020543352,
0.0334030427,
0.0007325008,
0.0209948476,
0.0177586339,
-0.0348347537,
0.0350994058,
0.0111654578,
0.0150195016,
0.0541899242,
-0.0268549696,
-0.0316399038,
0.0225903187,
-0.0188475344,
-0.0338606685,
0.0121594109,
-0.0367891677,
0.0346346051,
0.0402414277,
0.0196738616,
0.0066823605,
-0.003475002,
0.0222549587,
-0.0171490684,
0.0023596671,
-0.0188638326,
0.0285441317,
-0.0115536097,
0.0095634954,
-0.0542362928,
0.0241612121,
-0.0100857029,
-0.0191040784,
0.0217825063,
0.0527183861,
-0.0427548662,
0.0027789765,
-0.018841181,
-0.0155441593,
-0.0036178324,
0.0678770021,
0.0028773514,
-0.065565154,
-0.03635782,
-0.0509920605,
-0.0562973469,
-0.0023839273,
-0.0215385724,
0.0154143721,
0.0059585008,
-0.0463338345,
-0.0899135917,
-0.0511044972,
0.0297812466,
0.0351481251,
0.0232604779,
0.0124205779,
0.0278042313,
-0.0105393808,
0.0101117818,
0.023954954,
-0.0707008988,
0.0342117511,
-0.0658130273,
0.0219214987,
0.0267136656,
-0.0535186157,
-0.0065123742,
0.0185792204,
-0.0365177542,
-0.0582963005,
-0.019509241,
0.0252944045,
0.0235931296,
0.0389733799,
-0.0288024303,
-0.0410299115,
0.0239452962,
-0.0156221297,
-0.0146298502,
-0.0010768432,
0.0191051587,
0.0367471315,
-0.0172797609,
0.021958841,
-0.0755030289,
-0.016911719,
-0.0284518413,
0.0433644764,
-0.0211265888,
-0.051318638,
0.0388282798,
0.0174093377,
0.0467831753,
-0.0294858571,
0.0250282623,
-0.0190877095,
0.0269084424,
0.0048377058,
-0.0298278164,
-0.0300987326,
0.0257148892,
0.0177261662,
0.0168293659,
0.0340932608,
0.0179439019,
0.00051645,
-0.0410631821,
-0.0478003323,
0.0064617544,
-0.0077234162,
-0.0120331459,
0.0370506346,
0.0089633754,
-0.0287288055,
0.0080822874,
0.0320840701,
-0.0030666527,
-0.0025580581,
0.0706875175,
0.0355379209,
-0.0310882572,
-0.0549470522,
0.0399992466,
-0.0705168247,
-0.0464220904,
0.0116489278,
0.0308215246,
0.0445797071,
-0.0188916363,
0.0376746543,
-0.0388510823,
0.0105763609,
-0.0092905601,
-0.0046630655,
0.0087361671,
-0.0378913768,
0.0142248292,
0.0479873121,
0.0097170966,
0.0129667446,
0.0735578537,
-0.0211089365,
-0.0017594998,
0.0051066619,
-0.0159158204,
-0.0319751464,
-0.0440027751,
0.0032607028,
0.0442562737,
-0.0494080186,
-0.0140564553,
-0.0412274823,
-0.0208333842,
-0.0399672799,
-0.0077439109,
0.0039747744,
-0.0516729653,
0.0843649358,
0.0503952466,
-0.0004252377,
-0.0186191853,
-0.0473106541,
-0.0359665044,
-0.0103382422,
0.0008609664,
-0.0597500503,
-6.14025719e-33,
-0.0137797184,
-0.030373795,
0.035216257,
-0.0076005892,
-0.0337992869,
-0.0299404636,
-0.0409634113,
0.0134339007,
0.000687971,
-0.0180725101,
-0.0331351086,
-0.0000843244,
0.0241505262,
0.0324461572,
0.0217733961,
-0.0338435955,
0.0632217377,
0.0179112535,
-0.0708180591,
0.0397419892,
0.0332788453,
0.0096960953,
-0.021480212,
-0.0153403003,
0.0314195007,
-0.0360216908,
-0.0163839441,
0.0171151888,
-0.0087732458,
0.0669004917,
-0.0412193798,
0.0351550169,
0.0135535486,
-0.0246359408,
-0.0095276861,
0.0596159026,
-0.0625176877,
-0.0386994109,
0.0553312376,
0.0048511336,
-0.019749511,
-0.0103234649,
-0.0046064891,
-0.0038336508,
-0.0135951582,
0.0101722898,
0.0205514133,
-0.0253994595,
-0.0768308491,
-0.0294484701,
-0.0550450198,
0.0120149963,
-0.0118246013,
-0.0411684103,
0.0184577387,
0.0974008963,
-0.0095013212,
-0.0125085805,
-0.0087611033,
0.0535371937,
0.0263510104,
0.0387444645,
0.0585083142,
0.0691699162,
-0.0027544308,
0.0747217685,
0.0043731276,
0.0126870479,
-0.0399556495,
0.0031162233,
-0.0104187895,
0.010816724,
-0.0055534141,
-0.0182318036,
-0.0104411216,
0.0201955903,
-0.0250646435,
0.0378593095,
0.0382366627,
0.0322074145,
0.0180777647,
0.0225809906,
-0.0362778679,
-0.0438292176,
-0.0536622368,
0.0198002681,
-0.0237493441,
-0.0288816337,
0.0546496995,
0.0432906076,
-0.0154528804,
-0.0404078923,
0.0446471833,
0.0097777126,
-0.0295779612,
0.0295376852,
0.0117495125,
0.047830604,
0.0016958552,
-0.007846131,
-0.0186665077,
-0.0321661718,
0.0045130658,
-0.0415516049,
-0.0355716012,
0.0154630961,
-0.0103826094,
0.0135824271,
-0.063254647,
0.0111532621,
-0.0359194912,
-0.001513501,
0.0211720522,
-0.0113325827,
0.0659876913,
-0.0285078231,
-0.0153619321,
0.0779104531,
-0.0036441186,
-0.0322094373,
-0.0091510694,
-0.0191579331,
-0.0357109532,
0.0046105823,
-0.0143814385,
-0.0012179181,
-0.0581791699,
0.071893692,
0.0266011506,
-0.0422286801,
-0.0070140152,
0.0142119527,
2.591e-7,
-0.0227294434,
0.0495599508,
-0.0031018716,
0.0145050008,
-0.0028325752,
0.0219191443,
0.0062059634,
0.0144506572,
0.0266630091,
-0.0001746177,
0.0286246315,
0.0388219431,
-0.0002696349,
0.0001011665,
-0.1054670364,
-0.0541316904,
-0.0497278124,
-0.0337133445,
-0.0576814301,
-0.0052547543,
0.0600270852,
0.089410685,
0.0013150445,
-0.0077768797,
0.0334806554,
-0.0501196235,
0.0225503854,
-0.0306571517,
-0.0325941853,
0.0015757881,
0.0137057872,
0.0092124939,
-0.0187979862,
0.0305977054,
0.0112180458,
-0.0011454646,
-0.0025304612,
0.049212005,
0.050955493,
0.0222440194,
-0.0095992358,
0.0043297512,
0.0321200751,
-0.0323454812,
0.0700229257,
-0.0301919393,
0.0106952395,
0.0201532841,
0.0218403041,
-0.0445348546,
-0.0057588746,
-0.0215353612,
-0.003992436,
-0.0131745674,
-0.014415334,
0.0098819761,
-0.002903363,
-0.0876659751,
-0.0267424509,
0.0156194903,
-0.026691623,
-0.0671145245,
-0.0357172824,
0.0208501071,
-0.0083098561,
-0.0666756928,
-0.0190801397,
2.423723563e-34,
0.0383087695,
-0.003818491,
-0.0022016475,
0.0041258968,
0.0341492295,
0.0102779856,
-0.0126800183,
0.0374358706,
0.082303606,
-0.0995429382,
-0.0373254754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14256v2 | Linear Cross-Lingual Mapping of Sentence Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:10:37 | 2024-06-27T03:43:18 | Oleg Vasilyev, Fumika Isono, John Bohannon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantics of a sentence is defined with much less ambiguity than semantics of
a single word, and we assume that it should be better preserved by translation
to another language. If multilingual sentence embeddings intend to represent
sentence semantics, then the similarity between embeddings of any two sentences
must be invariant with respect to translation. Based on this suggestion, we
consider a simple linear cross-lingual mapping as a possible improvement of the
multilingual embeddings. We also consider deviation from orthogonality
conditions as a measure of deficiency of the embeddings. | [
0.0186788663,
0.0161551591,
-0.028405603,
0.0833825618,
-0.0708660632,
0.0274813622,
-0.0214950033,
-0.0087140864,
-0.0194071271,
-0.0233184341,
-0.0233934019,
-0.0107680028,
0.0032896767,
-0.0671027154,
0.0345568843,
-0.0215994064,
0.0604773127,
0.0310903341,
-0.0256094486,
-0.0201072097,
0.0130475406,
-0.0265428983,
0.0279812291,
0.0066167042,
-0.0102768,
0.0037175305,
0.0261290036,
-0.0462263748,
0.0385377854,
-0.0158071835,
-0.0385731906,
-0.0248216037,
0.0166055448,
-0.0185224917,
0.0000013969,
-0.0071108383,
0.0004065422,
-0.0286829099,
0.0542925,
-0.0041370722,
0.0002111913,
-0.0951976925,
0.0097748693,
-0.0134690283,
-0.0324830376,
-0.0212186389,
0.0525840111,
0.0497149155,
0.0127862711,
0.0538768321,
-0.0229505524,
-0.0726877525,
-0.0029850502,
-0.0086917523,
0.0232848935,
-0.0373935737,
-0.0159159843,
0.0268844683,
-0.0299349483,
0.0383272097,
-0.033978954,
0.0346766338,
0.0078980895,
0.0370770656,
-0.0021124394,
0.0196016412,
0.012096541,
0.0036530599,
0.0029203829,
0.0292439945,
-0.0251679607,
-0.0117799882,
-0.0363447703,
0.0358844064,
-0.0056673889,
-0.0066408874,
-0.0178269129,
0.0320628807,
0.0433176793,
0.0545748733,
0.0558941923,
0.0245609824,
0.0199941341,
-0.0176777169,
-0.0212974194,
0.0488270596,
0.0391459726,
-0.084828265,
-0.0020693156,
0.0110479118,
-0.0259279981,
-0.0175270233,
0.0007673558,
-0.0045214174,
0.0012339744,
0.0101138921,
-0.0401580483,
-0.0389932059,
0.0084237717,
-0.0756993443,
0.0664131343,
0.0365830362,
-0.0093701873,
0.0443231687,
-0.0899659917,
0.0533458479,
-0.0350477211,
0.0651029199,
-0.0713907331,
-0.0427218415,
-0.050497409,
-0.0041153678,
-0.0282148477,
0.0233685803,
0.0079722349,
-0.0459000506,
-0.0571417958,
0.0396301225,
0.0071315239,
0.0099603767,
-0.0337746814,
-0.0306044836,
-0.0061947433,
0.0327154361,
-0.0079508834,
0.017654242,
-0.027171772,
0.0069655487,
-0.0696575269,
-0.0204139855,
-0.0182062332,
0.0398067981,
-0.0097102132,
-0.0188853405,
0.0047368375,
0.0414275862,
0.0167645197,
0.0080478843,
-0.020006381,
0.0107419081,
-0.030954998,
-0.0335950479,
0.0066258288,
-0.0505222827,
0.0219709687,
0.0048828521,
-0.0042672679,
-0.0037227739,
0.0176418088,
0.0074946061,
-0.0455094501,
0.0669496506,
0.0577850156,
-0.0110891201,
-0.0440015048,
-0.0158488769,
0.0528195947,
0.0488494635,
0.0104081379,
-0.0170804504,
0.0700790286,
0.0120219197,
-0.0717509836,
0.021764908,
0.0042253439,
-0.0187392831,
-0.0382700451,
0.0320591107,
0.0573987812,
0.0289999228,
-0.0219375957,
0.0253763776,
-0.0303672571,
0.0118586868,
0.0132335331,
0.02757347,
0.0229601394,
-0.0049368567,
0.0353198573,
-0.0441697538,
-0.0839180052,
0.0695420653,
-0.0388156138,
0.0222151559,
0.0361477397,
0.0100706946,
-0.005111841,
0.0086697927,
-0.0373546332,
-0.0099478327,
-0.0176274031,
-0.0539416037,
0.0262228511,
-0.042395927,
0.0249264445,
0.0095741926,
-0.0122172404,
0.0640079305,
0.0178069919,
-0.0558120869,
-0.0192800313,
0.0401616953,
-0.0035417443,
0.0191931129,
-0.0387986191,
0.0099652261,
-0.0007350671,
0.0016756959,
0.0172970667,
0.0511634722,
0.0627575368,
-0.0037400273,
0.0316429362,
-0.0482140444,
-0.000880124,
-0.0238297358,
0.022217432,
0.0377858989,
-0.0572994202,
0.0250425544,
0.0231353436,
-0.0518906638,
0.0186035652,
0.0367709137,
-0.0135058854,
-0.0024734857,
0.0319496989,
0.0599374026,
0.0302936044,
0.0194098614,
0.0126632378,
0.0384488739,
0.0401416197,
-0.1054797769,
-0.0293502379,
0.048990313,
-0.0273841005,
-0.0866736472,
0.0103658773,
-0.0813124403,
-0.0286480915,
0.02356207,
-0.026981771,
-0.017593652,
0.0046427287,
-0.0155742876,
0.0193632431,
-0.0473980717,
-0.0031236839,
-0.0190167613,
0.0253487322,
-0.018016804,
0.0543354563,
-0.0011811717,
0.0830411389,
-0.0242105573,
-0.0256154574,
0.0712544098,
-0.0065577715,
-0.0443379991,
0.0351780988,
0.00956719,
-0.0072695091,
0.0368668661,
0.0177482646,
0.0159270279,
-0.0492437817,
-0.0630599782,
0.0008841698,
-0.0288363807,
0.0497740321,
0.0481270924,
0.0198510922,
0.0343500823,
-0.0275230128,
-0.0521256104,
0.0171405282,
0.0165314507,
0.0510831177,
0.0738845393,
0.0028753087,
-0.0046293205,
0.0031971785,
0.005661224,
-0.016452359,
0.0180316903,
-0.0612665787,
-0.0223285928,
-0.0724652857,
0.0313088633,
-0.0676725283,
-0.029605981,
0.0058986163,
-0.046598468,
0.0033808348,
0.0302368347,
0.0500308089,
0.0309019201,
-0.0164545886,
0.0141914068,
0.0615646094,
0.016665658,
0.0144233704,
0.0115112029,
-0.029695008,
0.0196138378,
-0.0617931113,
-0.0118418224,
0.0201492161,
0.0345029272,
0.0276479628,
-0.036118295,
-0.0525098555,
-0.0161058735,
-0.0431930013,
-0.005969238,
-0.0267137662,
0.0061453748,
-0.0092890719,
0.0281270146,
-0.0150478147,
0.0038051598,
0.0403652117,
0.0029707251,
0.0161890276,
-0.0755466968,
-0.0280422121,
-0.0449011326,
0.0331464633,
-0.0185200889,
0.0462810397,
-0.0398908257,
0.0016667034,
-0.0256269947,
-0.0355026424,
0.0373461433,
0.0117867338,
-0.0091692973,
-0.0025453928,
-0.0384373032,
-0.0326978527,
-0.0337686241,
0.0121867293,
-0.070865728,
0.0125052193,
0.0201518424,
-0.0110210516,
0.0366043486,
-0.0211683623,
0.0057423459,
0.0012063661,
-0.0368228965,
-0.0207215436,
0.0157021079,
-0.0373847634,
0.0335568003,
0.0340923332,
0.0152665935,
-0.0330435298,
-0.0012767469,
0.0324308313,
-0.0083511975,
-0.0175998285,
0.004619597,
-0.0048052706,
0.0088238446,
0.0305779167,
0.0129189743,
-0.082897529,
-0.0247738622,
0.0120295724,
0.0360075459,
-0.00555168,
0.0801422969,
0.0209259354,
0.0000017676,
0.0228490494,
-0.017264599,
0.0092855403,
0.0262304246,
-0.0204562489,
-0.0890785977,
-0.0189850274,
-0.0032952772,
-0.0681782812,
0.0240019895,
0.0121652512,
-0.0224354062,
-0.0571377277,
-0.0020718006,
0.0059139221,
-0.0547021218,
-0.0691109076,
-0.0129545117,
0.0048299157,
-0.0067199934,
0.0303333402,
-0.0506461747,
0.0321405306,
-0.0153111061,
0.0128409611,
0.0237387661,
-0.0603990741,
-0.0339051336,
-0.0552873835,
0.0029554239,
0.0224589333,
0.0928418115,
-0.0083590243,
-0.0372267775,
0.0011471105,
-0.027558146,
-0.027084738,
0.0110062072,
-0.0038505581,
0.0001365109,
-0.0389560498,
0.0113372877,
-0.003698939,
-0.0370843112,
0.0151743088,
0.0162454434,
0.0886047632,
0.0160092227,
0.0118321069,
-0.0190929677,
0.0104527799,
-0.0219695903,
0.0736091435,
0.0022020708,
-0.0334601142,
-0.0145630836,
0.0275273994,
0.0074576084,
-0.0103370668,
-0.0067490395,
-0.0015458987,
-0.0197608639,
-0.008328042,
-0.0628700331,
-0.0844236612,
-0.0186930746,
0.0187633503,
0.0081308326,
0.048774194,
-0.0066758073,
-0.0369854122,
0.0148399202,
-0.0433947444,
-0.0124364439,
0.0340699032,
0.0421706811,
0.0535488501,
0.0267646648,
0.036196731,
-0.020030776,
-0.0517985672,
-0.051644627,
-0.0535443835,
-0.0198772587,
-0.0106625063,
0.0005500148,
0.0217821542,
-0.0187491886,
0.0268701222,
0.0267463587,
0.0117879901,
0.0003677878,
0.0428466573,
0.0676886663,
0.0287866443,
0.0304799508,
0.086215049,
-0.0313912369,
0.0042331242,
0.0064408528,
0.0617297851,
0.0164221078,
-0.0638940185,
0.0175996162,
0.0047813454,
0.019626081,
-0.0039198729,
-0.0228074379,
0.0023957274,
0.0311404765,
-0.0490359254,
-0.0460509323,
-0.0041584102,
-0.0168245006,
0.0614024289,
-0.0092547843,
-0.0161020067,
0.0248931199,
0.000115164,
0.0187158715,
-0.0026507233,
-0.0020363405,
0.034493845,
0.0040153293,
-0.058754541,
0.0559705496,
-0.03092869,
-0.0229538791,
-0.0369074978,
-0.0116218599,
-0.0614056773,
-0.0176235512,
0.0105570033,
-0.0022606726,
-0.0107649146,
0.0381239094,
-0.0382718034,
0.0681230947,
0.0467244312,
-0.0206447616,
0.0610980056,
-0.0484191589,
0.0566917323,
-0.0407625772,
-0.0222852435,
0.0139468797,
0.042794995,
0.0017952478,
-0.0216224156,
0.0554385632,
-0.0373065434,
-0.0249248538,
-0.0091360714,
0.0461246334,
-0.0524152592,
0.0249113776,
-0.0061600921,
-0.0310410485,
-0.0325357132,
0.001387698,
0.05070832,
0.0239222702,
0.0022095612,
0.0245382544,
-0.0200598352,
-0.049967546,
0.0213086624,
0.0252612978,
-0.0071383878,
0.0279464759,
-0.0103749614,
0.0704423711,
0.0156883299,
0.001803991,
-0.0266087856,
0.0192698985,
-0.0344334729,
-0.0388055705,
-0.0503634214,
-4.720626621e-33,
-0.011620786,
0.0515240766,
-0.0597192347,
-0.0083328541,
-0.0172807146,
-0.0197112113,
-0.0071422299,
0.0001313597,
-0.0580608994,
0.0460684523,
0.0162445977,
-0.0115686208,
0.0078484621,
0.0250326395,
-0.0050939959,
-0.0184822716,
0.017008476,
-0.0161094386,
-0.027009761,
-0.0127335126,
0.0573505573,
-0.0005669502,
0.0953704342,
-0.0431609042,
0.0462963991,
-0.0228351317,
0.019077016,
0.0484754704,
0.0560242645,
0.0671299174,
-0.0256218184,
0.0294352546,
0.0225658771,
0.0033528865,
-0.0314710476,
0.0072329352,
-0.0396987796,
-0.0772662237,
0.0603565797,
0.026357647,
-0.0095849978,
-0.0584170595,
-0.0103227124,
-0.0581128858,
-0.0013463055,
0.0072354423,
0.0203190595,
-0.0085392641,
-0.0160421301,
0.0398600847,
-0.0642798021,
-0.0149895605,
-0.0117013147,
-0.0016260854,
0.0670320094,
0.0324467532,
-0.0233804379,
0.0215641521,
0.0024216562,
0.0301467944,
-0.0948260352,
0.0690914541,
0.0093055777,
-0.0494739711,
0.0101723606,
0.0533966832,
0.0154732149,
-0.0176346507,
0.0279399361,
-0.0102697564,
0.0247958004,
0.0165847801,
0.0304242168,
0.0958450735,
0.0324038342,
-0.0002165988,
-0.0882498547,
-0.0063745868,
-0.0105981631,
0.009321644,
0.0504830107,
0.0168403555,
-0.0043285019,
-0.0182402898,
-0.0404636972,
-0.0334086195,
-0.0056111985,
-0.040134538,
0.0318248682,
-0.0231774263,
-0.0028054221,
-0.008759574,
0.039045006,
-0.0575077608,
-0.0233702399,
0.0398401357,
-0.0143235894,
0.0053289067,
0.0330891497,
0.0181972776,
-0.0375211127,
-0.0470665097,
-0.0438683666,
0.0169255957,
0.0372726917,
-0.0053878715,
0.1134838089,
-0.0022722869,
-0.0325499475,
-0.0022095484,
-0.0334075801,
-0.0740708411,
-0.0658166111,
0.0170339923,
0.0162788033,
0.0263743047,
-0.0173625872,
0.0289983973,
0.0319527574,
0.0127384113,
-0.0060043358,
-0.039147716,
0.0251063369,
0.0565369576,
-0.0206111763,
0.0053768801,
-0.0250599012,
0.0505037904,
-0.023328308,
-0.0157932546,
-0.0018822543,
0.009576926,
2.269e-7,
0.0392955504,
-0.0015022014,
0.0217634235,
0.0129791694,
0.0226009656,
0.0213303771,
-0.0432344563,
0.0742189586,
-0.0570224747,
0.0030104383,
0.0147691788,
-0.0015919643,
0.0253689513,
0.0069892625,
-0.0463367887,
0.060470663,
-0.0326592065,
-0.0489101373,
-0.0064517548,
0.0389332622,
0.101570867,
0.0892797112,
0.0178026855,
0.0298550688,
-0.0458058454,
-0.0115204854,
0.0506061502,
-0.0444362462,
-0.0339617394,
-0.0472969823,
-0.0403656811,
0.0361560769,
0.0088387681,
0.027108144,
-0.0129330028,
0.0547263436,
0.0428184234,
0.0192799624,
0.0079033365,
-0.0069082575,
-0.0327945761,
-0.0138418274,
-0.0158757046,
-0.0328655839,
0.0478602424,
-0.0312606432,
-0.0587031879,
-0.0141273849,
0.0098832315,
0.0638930574,
0.1255701035,
0.0069628367,
-0.0637891442,
-0.0332597084,
0.0752457231,
0.019040592,
-0.0369303413,
-0.0233876724,
-0.0269595403,
0.0211054198,
-0.0199606083,
-0.0381792784,
-0.0002294758,
0.0382573642,
0.0913268328,
-0.0480073579,
-0.0096958131,
1.554419087e-34,
0.0060656434,
0.0132121835,
0.0218611639,
-0.0278773475,
-0.0119348643,
-0.0380897485,
0.0461166687,
0.0015118581,
0.0196890086,
-0.0505363531,
0.0015639981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14251v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14251v2 | FActScore: Fine-grained Atomic Evaluation of Factual Precision in Long Form Text Generation | 2023-05-23T17:06:00 | 2023-10-11T05:27:50 | Sewon Min, Kalpesh Krishna, Xinxi Lyu, Mike Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Pang Wei Koh, Mohit Iyyer, Luke Zettlemoyer, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Evaluating the factuality of long-form text generated by large language
models (LMs) is non-trivial because (1) generations often contain a mixture of
supported and unsupported pieces of information, making binary judgments of
quality inadequate, and (2) human evaluation is time-consuming and costly. In
this paper, we introduce FACTSCORE, a new evaluation that breaks a generation
into a series of atomic facts and computes the percentage of atomic facts
supported by a reliable knowledge source. We conduct an extensive human
evaluation to obtain FACTSCOREs of people biographies generated by several
state-of-the-art commercial LMs -- InstructGPT, ChatGPT, and the
retrieval-augmented PerplexityAI -- and report new analysis demonstrating the
need for such a fine-grained score (e.g., ChatGPT only achieves 58%). Since
human evaluation is costly, we also introduce an automated model that estimates
FACTSCORE using retrieval and a strong language model, with less than a 2%
error rate. Finally, we use this automated metric to evaluate 6,500 generations
from a new set of 13 recent LMs that would have cost $26K if evaluated by
humans, with various findings: GPT-4 and ChatGPT are more factual than public
models, and Vicuna and Alpaca are some of the best public models. FACTSCORE is
available for public use via `pip install factscore`. | [
0.0398417227,
0.064620696,
-0.0111209452,
0.0367425568,
-0.0352595821,
-0.008841387,
-0.0083968332,
-0.0168710705,
-0.0109227775,
-0.0196222272,
0.0478985533,
-0.0777384937,
0.0242211744,
0.045378495,
0.0107451165,
-0.024133563,
0.0225015525,
0.0260550622,
0.0412069708,
0.0084998887,
0.0003008765,
0.0311519317,
-0.0093533667,
0.044911854,
-0.0524980053,
-0.0009989952,
-0.0153648304,
0.0080955904,
0.048788365,
-0.0281428006,
-0.0199573152,
0.0422131792,
-0.0140296547,
0.0434532501,
0.0000021578,
-0.0366377644,
-0.0010730207,
0.0079163779,
-0.0017171936,
0.0297552571,
0.0461108536,
0.0187505744,
-0.0354917645,
0.0104638422,
-0.0150146037,
0.0266053192,
0.0309084076,
0.0396591574,
0.0611167401,
0.0848717764,
0.0062696561,
-0.0052507673,
0.0425325781,
-0.0229314379,
0.0192813557,
0.0179888885,
-0.0023618275,
0.0236295499,
-0.0348747,
0.0385794342,
0.0337799005,
0.0164303966,
0.0063942531,
-0.0158616174,
0.0176928565,
0.0455803908,
-0.0307029206,
-0.0208664536,
0.062532261,
0.055550199,
0.0545333028,
-0.0184532329,
0.0164100453,
0.0060655489,
0.0131891649,
0.0072624278,
-0.0312341526,
0.0644591302,
-0.0280593541,
0.005028211,
0.0418158844,
-0.0097330008,
0.0173135195,
0.0094790384,
0.0148279415,
0.0159387961,
0.0152182821,
-0.0208594203,
-0.0005782527,
0.0049318443,
-0.0218759682,
-0.0556983128,
0.0116922734,
0.0108623616,
-0.016726248,
0.0085282493,
-0.0680706576,
0.0146061294,
0.0459982418,
-0.0611522608,
-0.0045401026,
0.0196262468,
-0.0149824964,
-0.0005561981,
-0.0066373185,
0.0421038494,
0.0090079634,
-0.0516047142,
-0.0106671453,
0.0327773616,
-0.0281236619,
0.0087863943,
-0.0169182196,
0.0139611857,
-0.0164067969,
-0.0242984779,
-0.0615490377,
-0.0045434316,
0.0083771674,
0.0388152935,
0.0021166268,
0.0191969704,
-0.0323892124,
0.0212015118,
-0.0618149117,
0.0272511877,
-0.0447616428,
-0.0125769805,
0.0324268639,
-0.0241675358,
-0.0031742223,
0.0031098919,
0.011093962,
-0.0080390861,
0.0179417115,
0.0089879064,
-0.0119224796,
-0.0261678267,
-0.0429623164,
-0.0684603974,
-0.0264407899,
-0.0961145312,
-0.0265808702,
-0.0746507943,
0.0183683932,
-0.0018234329,
-0.0059082592,
-0.0387985967,
0.0275887474,
0.0579075739,
-0.0256146006,
0.0208112132,
-0.0119620292,
0.0053542731,
0.0192483924,
0.0023438896,
0.0242979024,
0.0349309705,
0.0697385669,
0.0694979653,
0.0383757278,
0.0317608379,
0.0014836837,
-0.0026671111,
0.0282118637,
0.0217787381,
0.0245219786,
-0.0182978027,
-0.0212357659,
0.0458623655,
0.0320351794,
0.0734929442,
-0.0038229891,
0.0206730366,
0.0890929252,
-0.0272332393,
0.0069603589,
0.0548469387,
0.0698950067,
0.024438912,
0.0413811095,
0.0339110531,
-0.0262360591,
0.0245689508,
-0.0341462456,
0.0397497155,
0.0176032968,
0.0641054586,
0.0085453922,
-0.0250539593,
-0.0053616799,
-0.007227696,
0.0032782687,
-0.0396547355,
0.0036962368,
-0.0041857678,
-0.0683704764,
0.0567777641,
0.0149775939,
-0.0942020938,
0.0252563059,
-0.0213034861,
0.0374009088,
0.0805445164,
0.0785895362,
0.0220785197,
-0.0137724392,
0.0154080922,
-0.021975657,
0.0460272618,
0.0266136564,
-0.0021635138,
-0.0270805024,
-0.0448144861,
0.0174863413,
-0.0232922155,
0.0212470125,
-0.0019144205,
0.0434421785,
0.0230625793,
0.0717283264,
-0.0352914557,
-0.0155057823,
0.0335872062,
-0.0363954455,
-0.0108450651,
-0.0220213998,
0.000763781,
0.0058796573,
0.039353732,
-0.0276543759,
0.015790483,
0.0174500253,
-0.0069549265,
-0.0193407312,
0.0092382086,
-0.0122506805,
-0.0433052927,
0.0381090231,
-0.0326870196,
0.0046824808,
0.0054738042,
-0.0297022425,
-0.0515981317,
-0.0219677091,
-0.0709810778,
-0.0111709284,
-0.0515802987,
0.023554977,
0.0388139971,
0.0067852796,
-0.0195367988,
0.1149313003,
-0.011201866,
0.0180831719,
0.0123199383,
-0.0140889911,
0.0175720863,
-0.0782724991,
-0.0243243128,
-0.0123789823,
0.0182676259,
0.0090781581,
0.0369373038,
0.0241570398,
-0.0377534702,
-0.0343618058,
-0.0997859687,
0.0423610434,
-0.0181263052,
0.0254217014,
0.0137206335,
-0.0131716169,
-0.0177693348,
0.0448333099,
-0.0488960333,
-0.0153473029,
0.008681762,
-0.0003155684,
0.0529002398,
0.0102350255,
-0.008759846,
-0.0398495533,
0.0078611383,
-0.0025786425,
0.0109222149,
0.0625790954,
0.0372242667,
-0.0476011261,
0.0249217823,
-0.0901079476,
-0.0148580177,
0.0005761521,
-0.0430232286,
0.0202574469,
0.0074372492,
0.0635283962,
0.0180513654,
0.048320692,
0.0337406918,
0.0167581514,
-0.007322154,
0.0146524003,
0.0059908503,
-0.0357861742,
0.0159242246,
0.0143410992,
-0.0585109815,
0.0069453684,
-0.0122618033,
0.0164496787,
-0.0099645127,
-0.0644281954,
0.0476353317,
0.0032090358,
0.0106262397,
0.0085798949,
0.0041869562,
-0.0045245672,
0.0385813862,
-0.0191761646,
-0.0178206526,
0.0642713159,
-0.0768728927,
0.0297544058,
-0.0039681308,
-0.0083462745,
-0.0281454958,
0.0750843659,
0.0386898816,
0.0312882401,
-0.0031711382,
0.0214645658,
-0.0419222042,
0.0550398938,
0.0463133268,
-0.0570000224,
0.0319602974,
-0.0437875502,
0.0011157064,
-0.0007800518,
-0.0159151014,
-0.0368215032,
-0.058340326,
0.0008689924,
-0.0100399526,
0.0457926169,
-0.0591853857,
-0.0249747224,
-0.0262562558,
0.0577149577,
-0.001530265,
-0.030547969,
0.0003331745,
-0.014071892,
0.0308670308,
0.0473606214,
-0.0171743799,
0.0274633002,
-0.0247498695,
0.0093179774,
0.0546139404,
-0.0068388777,
0.0278207213,
0.0093379728,
-0.0382172652,
-0.0129591255,
-0.018692933,
-0.0494865067,
0.0340019055,
0.0576592088,
-0.0573857501,
-0.0321083926,
0.1173189357,
0.0343407877,
0.0231786389,
0.0083265845,
0.0271050613,
0.0109148463,
-0.0103361523,
0.0120667471,
-0.0673191473,
0.0041771214,
0.0154559724,
0.0332997441,
-0.042438563,
-0.0390808694,
-0.0317520015,
-0.1146655232,
0.0661990121,
0.0201491211,
-0.0158729851,
-0.0443126857,
-0.0494261794,
-0.0297913216,
-0.0205973424,
-0.0273293294,
0.0374597721,
-0.0085023725,
0.0323440954,
-0.0112703899,
-0.01155362,
-0.0411147326,
0.0268240236,
-0.0304076578,
0.0412131734,
0.0420501903,
0.0833500624,
-0.003002746,
-0.0513181053,
-0.0158872791,
-0.0202463958,
-0.0116548203,
0.0124401134,
0.0713433847,
0.0011018579,
0.0054570772,
-0.0640531331,
0.0266218651,
0.0215189215,
-0.0221266933,
0.0011599547,
0.0263223015,
-0.0313228667,
0.0121881263,
-0.009828968,
0.0373269133,
0.0127551621,
0.09189336,
0.0255642794,
-0.0069251265,
-0.015801698,
-0.0327554122,
0.0317667089,
-0.0803444758,
-0.0139247132,
0.0276961625,
-0.0472893789,
-0.040119715,
-0.1121668071,
-0.0464237034,
-0.0105890045,
0.0389394574,
-0.0088274553,
-0.0379573032,
0.0231998824,
-0.0076967822,
-0.0322666727,
0.0175776705,
-0.0376489833,
0.0075061899,
-0.040122021,
-0.0084581589,
0.0265648365,
-0.0310602263,
-0.0014881785,
0.0162215382,
-0.0598296039,
-0.032003738,
0.0062595764,
0.0185379125,
0.0230342019,
0.0220097713,
-0.0029734885,
-0.0179349985,
0.0677383244,
0.0721128657,
-0.0166794639,
0.0161957238,
-0.0247359965,
-0.0121616684,
-0.0132252462,
-0.0070507289,
-0.009886899,
-0.0005985607,
-0.0502054431,
0.0580631942,
0.0066806329,
-0.066056557,
0.021338325,
0.0725591257,
-0.0082121799,
-0.0684278607,
0.0158556961,
-0.0267000273,
-0.0167817939,
-0.0548759364,
-0.0240502059,
-0.0421039686,
-0.0132715069,
0.0281444676,
0.0158109274,
-0.0086656203,
-0.0199229103,
-0.0309313945,
0.0630996004,
-0.0501013808,
-0.0422699712,
-0.0455501303,
0.0278636888,
0.0251294449,
-0.0519564301,
-0.0416155159,
-0.0058134617,
-0.025452368,
0.049669873,
-0.0214879159,
0.0400056504,
0.0112743555,
0.0000383666,
0.0030565099,
0.023560321,
-0.0599543266,
-0.0063896817,
-0.0859220698,
0.0370389819,
0.054801926,
0.0124187982,
0.0785945877,
-0.0634006485,
-0.0029497279,
-0.005802189,
0.0417340472,
0.0138058066,
-0.0382626168,
-0.0299422834,
0.0007247481,
-0.0271645207,
-0.0020538347,
0.0753966793,
0.0041452791,
0.021856878,
-0.0007334504,
-0.0577957816,
-0.0320728272,
-0.0503405258,
-0.0706238672,
0.0038101922,
0.003585729,
-0.0315654129,
-0.0805482343,
-0.0493980125,
0.0208492558,
0.0670345277,
0.0271390993,
-0.0192949884,
0.0134466439,
0.0371067934,
-0.0218581129,
-0.0305424109,
-0.0797471181,
0.0175863989,
-0.0406037681,
0.0090936208,
-0.0045497436,
-6.603174212e-33,
-0.0695881769,
-0.0517851934,
0.0087136207,
-0.0033959069,
-0.0692379922,
0.0034479003,
-0.049192775,
0.0128300237,
0.0271478221,
0.0179284792,
-0.0038841015,
-0.0118731605,
0.0092207529,
0.0119840549,
-0.0249110349,
0.003501554,
0.056888666,
0.0271200333,
-0.0746843815,
0.0466908477,
0.0650823489,
-0.0091609135,
0.0181566793,
-0.0482371859,
0.0465938859,
-0.0298121646,
-0.0509142987,
0.0021140391,
-0.0283218585,
0.0340289958,
0.0101355007,
0.0188461412,
0.0062430203,
-0.0440399908,
0.008057232,
-0.0184303597,
-0.0496140048,
-0.0085411137,
0.0170281492,
-0.0350259207,
0.0196504127,
-0.0250030831,
0.0171996914,
-0.0093248812,
-0.004818358,
-0.0089180646,
0.0418475941,
-0.0469089299,
0.0128368661,
-0.0499764383,
-0.0426900648,
0.021840198,
0.0092691621,
-0.0187656488,
-0.0589578263,
0.0097565018,
0.0182324331,
0.0009722962,
-0.0658302009,
0.0115101868,
0.0240781903,
0.0320008099,
0.0311823655,
-0.02023606,
-0.0077231331,
0.0550040603,
-0.012422706,
0.0354336426,
-0.0766694099,
0.0102931308,
0.0025396142,
0.0474121831,
0.0158738624,
0.1038503274,
0.0053851493,
-0.0334015787,
-0.0661741346,
0.0651877448,
0.0222578384,
0.0154973334,
0.0024970579,
-0.0305921715,
-0.0431230888,
-0.0111586191,
-0.0312563553,
0.0282936953,
-0.0138954828,
-0.0275568776,
-0.0031163848,
0.0064736926,
-0.0313813575,
-0.0385281369,
-0.0002524143,
-0.0011824113,
0.0038778996,
0.0227041338,
-0.0796016976,
0.0101634217,
-0.030130418,
0.0031383468,
-0.036243055,
-0.0184551924,
0.0298584681,
0.0136511186,
0.0100860391,
0.0118240034,
0.0367189124,
0.03037058,
-0.043480657,
0.0233343858,
-0.0394461453,
0.0247900132,
0.0003973496,
-0.0375970975,
0.0002525085,
-0.0045825131,
-0.0308716446,
0.0082045905,
0.0364114866,
0.0686104298,
-0.0385184921,
-0.0428634286,
0.0301861875,
-0.0001637188,
-0.0255178418,
0.0329454392,
-0.0346288607,
0.0011130308,
0.0100913057,
-0.04870487,
-0.0163450427,
-0.0077690673,
2.846e-7,
0.0100492584,
0.0430673473,
0.0257332772,
0.0326406322,
-0.0134378998,
0.0491540134,
-0.0075175632,
0.0156482439,
-0.0056037768,
-0.0105957957,
0.0304381903,
0.0143509805,
0.0528611951,
0.0688440576,
-0.0651027858,
0.0040629855,
-0.0778325945,
-0.0722027868,
-0.0560914092,
-0.0119152488,
0.0588038713,
0.0200877246,
0.0288528781,
-0.0197173022,
0.0329413973,
-0.0297963545,
0.0829684958,
0.0120327435,
-0.1075734943,
0.0221261531,
0.0796851888,
0.0098781511,
-0.0215721764,
-0.0103799347,
-0.0257189758,
-0.0049740667,
0.001438668,
0.0618549734,
0.0272771269,
0.0034701275,
0.0203157347,
-0.0193058942,
-0.00376076,
-0.0350509137,
0.0406373888,
0.0429737158,
-0.0084066875,
-0.0254076626,
-0.0460230745,
0.0294571444,
-0.0018123131,
-0.0154009704,
-0.0348402373,
0.0252692979,
-0.0128965024,
0.0120360572,
-0.0121180126,
-0.0156994648,
-0.0411979444,
0.0309452768,
-0.0479661189,
-0.0789163038,
0.0000020799,
-0.024667969,
0.0014089422,
-0.0718735904,
0.0156282485,
2.813272977e-34,
0.0449583158,
0.0039068009,
-0.0100782113,
-0.0611636862,
0.05608752,
0.0284330044,
0.0165726505,
-0.0136888875,
-0.0146890907,
-0.0306426026,
-0.0150657855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14250v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14250v2 | Language Models with Rationality | 2023-05-23T17:04:25 | 2023-10-29T14:51:48 | Nora Kassner, Oyvind Tafjord, Ashish Sabharwal, Kyle Richardson, Hinrich Schuetze, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) are proficient at question-answering (QA),
it is not always clear how (or even if) an answer follows from their latent
"beliefs". This lack of interpretability is a growing impediment to widespread
use of LLMs. To address this, our goals are to make model beliefs and their
inferential relationships explicit, and to resolve inconsistencies that may
exist, so that answers are supported by interpretable chains of reasoning drawn
from a consistent network of beliefs. Our approach, which we call REFLEX, is to
add a rational, self-reflecting layer on top of the LLM. First, given a
question, we construct a belief graph using a backward-chaining process to
materialize relevant model beliefs (including beliefs about answer candidates)
and their inferential relationships. Second, we identify and minimize
contradictions in that graph using a formal constraint reasoner. We find that
REFLEX significantly improves consistency (by 8%-11% absolute) without harming
overall answer accuracy, resulting in answers supported by faithful chains of
reasoning drawn from a more consistent belief system. This suggests a new style
of system architecture in which an LLM extended with a rational layer can
provide an interpretable window into system beliefs, add a systematic reasoning
capability, and repair latent inconsistencies present in the LLM. | [
0.0637479573,
0.1098550335,
0.0119045563,
0.0578045547,
-0.0047862199,
-0.0081536733,
-0.0257528238,
-0.0382258259,
0.0188243594,
-0.0238093268,
0.0126373814,
0.0124861803,
-0.0415973663,
0.047029119,
-0.0008447886,
-0.0295117758,
0.0165333878,
-0.0208728369,
0.0702150911,
-0.0340643264,
0.0279539283,
0.0271509532,
0.0185852535,
0.0053063263,
0.0200483818,
-0.0484493896,
-0.0199450031,
-0.0105454978,
0.0026822295,
-0.0244849734,
-0.0361624695,
0.0043192012,
0.013058898,
0.0290014241,
0.0000023568,
-0.0402494855,
-0.013368723,
-0.008607002,
-0.0736664161,
0.0062270542,
-0.0612147897,
0.0116799893,
0.011482819,
0.007854376,
-0.0508518815,
0.0274893548,
0.0226206668,
0.0476812236,
0.0762529597,
-0.0001362793,
-0.0025655003,
-0.0438905507,
-0.0063557094,
0.0137803433,
-0.0365973338,
-0.0305465572,
0.0176801607,
0.0772721618,
0.0155532584,
0.0257592835,
-0.0217883419,
0.0199575592,
0.0435193777,
-0.0377423912,
-0.0252660532,
0.002724014,
0.0263026357,
-0.0357308723,
0.0170440618,
0.0409255959,
0.0533259325,
-0.0624250025,
-0.0101490468,
0.0013401749,
0.0000022291,
0.0684797242,
-0.0545604341,
0.0545623414,
-0.0245927405,
0.0044406038,
0.0117917759,
-0.0041056792,
0.0502263978,
0.0101765515,
-0.0603286661,
0.0964361355,
-0.0055953083,
-0.007667996,
-0.0138715897,
-0.0010953697,
-0.0438926555,
-0.0798914656,
-0.021784693,
0.0696324259,
-0.0267540608,
0.0404607691,
0.0013019092,
0.0756000206,
-0.0027541032,
-0.0462593399,
-0.0289929919,
0.0321659967,
0.0632593855,
0.0438961014,
0.0008822994,
0.039125111,
-0.0396447293,
-0.0043410603,
-0.0301415771,
-0.0444930419,
-0.0315255709,
-0.0443931483,
-0.0202559512,
0.0429836363,
-0.0023343263,
0.0036833982,
-0.0215634163,
0.0484094284,
-0.0409182087,
0.0093876896,
0.0092732999,
0.0276992284,
0.021989977,
-0.0524566025,
-0.0774140954,
0.0390198454,
-0.0341937467,
0.026973037,
0.0002991689,
-0.0588113554,
-0.0010901185,
-0.0151872989,
-0.0144093577,
0.0013533878,
0.0031611868,
0.0348739699,
0.0156774558,
0.0391171761,
-0.0272506904,
-0.0373567194,
-0.0044457857,
-0.0545771047,
-0.0392404459,
-0.0761977211,
-0.0242380649,
0.040533144,
0.0275328178,
-0.0622910112,
0.012755217,
-0.0067149606,
-0.0102208275,
0.0667702183,
-0.0172983613,
0.0160349645,
0.0363016501,
0.0258378237,
0.002276201,
0.040502321,
0.0418696404,
0.0087036761,
0.0459739529,
-0.0003982934,
0.0093950387,
-0.0098258592,
0.0031513714,
-0.0317735672,
-0.0391163453,
0.0673108101,
-0.0459636226,
-0.0093021281,
-0.0096336519,
0.0368222669,
-0.0114642996,
-0.0207650624,
0.0426305644,
0.0360452458,
0.0116886888,
0.0345758796,
0.0193060916,
-0.0030495687,
0.0114559978,
-0.0015248244,
-0.0338050649,
0.0441257469,
-0.0083843591,
-0.0106347371,
-0.0049902643,
0.0100702811,
-0.0196907036,
-0.0772407502,
-0.0148406047,
0.0126074804,
-0.00875213,
0.0427915566,
0.0370249972,
-0.0255395155,
0.010219669,
0.0257091038,
-0.0070152301,
-0.0327447578,
0.0005502177,
-0.048903469,
0.0652297139,
0.0566153042,
0.0446152948,
-0.0117584364,
-0.0331883207,
0.0108289681,
0.014468072,
0.0266184285,
0.0483728908,
-0.0330562107,
-0.0181805976,
-0.0284173843,
-0.0327524357,
0.0063179024,
0.0185617525,
0.0146113811,
-0.0047132652,
0.0101446677,
-0.0142749064,
-0.0170818176,
-0.0033564919,
0.0052394639,
-0.0230067316,
-0.0267157909,
-0.0332728513,
-0.0131581184,
0.0419130474,
0.0409614816,
0.0049100309,
0.045737125,
0.0239658616,
0.0128225777,
-0.0397792235,
0.0580958128,
-0.0443323292,
0.0173457246,
0.0358769372,
-0.0283271484,
-0.020597497,
0.0012101241,
-0.0156870838,
-0.0556856766,
0.033005733,
-0.0337930918,
0.0061511714,
-0.0297963545,
0.0005721863,
-0.0103081884,
-0.0484746173,
-0.0134523362,
0.0446632579,
0.0200558081,
-0.0231780093,
0.0182036087,
-0.0042393166,
0.036459893,
-0.0710989684,
0.0138613526,
0.0088930326,
0.0218501855,
-0.0035913016,
0.0480107144,
-0.0395027995,
-0.0308255255,
0.0123161264,
-0.0121966386,
-0.0211147889,
-0.0019086377,
0.0136355711,
0.0071438942,
0.0316288806,
0.030652998,
-0.0234185681,
-0.0329392441,
0.0242243689,
0.0548808202,
0.0136622116,
0.0232895743,
-0.0114865815,
-0.0044369739,
-0.0300455708,
-0.004241935,
-0.0242769383,
0.0328113474,
0.0180982798,
0.028084388,
-0.0573374517,
-0.0362148695,
-0.0769779086,
0.0417323932,
-0.0061196634,
-0.0159842018,
0.0248516258,
0.0039650137,
-0.0205831248,
0.0379386917,
-0.0112277884,
0.0107464362,
0.0472758524,
-0.0020997047,
-0.0823836178,
0.0091123497,
-0.035361141,
0.0090606371,
-0.029101193,
-0.0623059124,
-0.0127048101,
0.0817764848,
0.0055259047,
0.0000145044,
-0.0796601102,
0.0907423794,
-0.0044724201,
-0.0218818001,
-0.0477172695,
-0.0744617432,
0.0102540143,
0.0760807768,
-0.0091250036,
-0.0367874652,
0.0847618505,
-0.0164361857,
0.0165450517,
-0.0147710321,
-0.019310575,
-0.0606857128,
0.03802827,
-0.0197974723,
-0.0072081247,
0.0227988586,
0.0359230675,
-0.0268694684,
-0.0407733619,
0.0331013389,
-0.0309974384,
0.0626610741,
-0.0912281349,
0.0006096786,
0.0292844158,
-0.0166706312,
-0.0675387755,
-0.0066777295,
-0.0671199784,
-0.0018323099,
-0.0251255408,
-0.0238202382,
0.0162219964,
-0.006367838,
0.0287840292,
-0.0047692894,
-0.0063013146,
-0.021303324,
-0.0185704567,
0.0098621091,
0.0621659532,
0.0379480943,
0.0816414729,
0.0005178273,
0.0797818229,
0.0649810508,
0.0355696343,
-0.0503926799,
-0.0134412711,
-0.0298809968,
0.0087880893,
0.0022491775,
-0.0066671977,
0.0027988497,
0.0648498982,
-0.0349611081,
-0.0174448248,
0.12508066,
0.0411103033,
-0.0038369719,
-0.0118481573,
-0.0448220298,
0.034970779,
0.0330423675,
0.0437265299,
-0.0403648093,
-0.0134972809,
-0.0142791225,
0.039786078,
-0.0047199582,
-0.0276160911,
-0.0218303204,
-0.0601929799,
0.0099597452,
-0.0078400495,
0.0146697685,
-0.0045280308,
-0.0628004074,
-0.0181670561,
-0.0088055031,
-0.019752821,
0.0344822221,
-0.0015634719,
0.0150440261,
0.006014708,
-0.0165680386,
0.0365844704,
0.0225455258,
-0.0243408885,
0.0122093884,
-0.0054450124,
0.0319347568,
0.0040818555,
-0.0575748049,
0.0135479569,
-0.0384894498,
-0.0111441277,
-0.0306217521,
-0.0291266032,
0.0002351725,
0.0148793841,
-0.0513889492,
0.0109329028,
-0.03589103,
-0.0277439058,
0.0182456598,
0.1196872219,
-0.0294623617,
-0.0156228775,
-0.0158365741,
0.0155090336,
-0.0532113537,
0.0788796172,
0.0197604671,
-0.0025115111,
-0.0547167398,
-0.0726047456,
-0.0181972776,
-0.0165733825,
-0.0285089873,
-0.005926854,
0.0209649149,
0.0347544774,
-0.0427966341,
-0.0414831899,
-0.0187413301,
0.0289613381,
-0.0164528731,
-0.0230239816,
0.0294494908,
-0.0036098897,
-0.0250467248,
0.0097342534,
-0.0529334694,
-0.0112719713,
0.0014431266,
0.0507516973,
-0.0040477226,
-0.046389062,
-0.0094723776,
-0.0095697548,
0.0231588855,
-0.0397897996,
-0.0135727236,
0.0468965173,
0.0342410468,
0.0236792136,
-0.0236808043,
-0.0266569573,
-0.0154691385,
-0.0426822752,
-0.0286160912,
-0.0149237197,
0.0591376647,
0.0261960644,
0.0086595882,
0.0402863696,
-0.0511013232,
0.0268048085,
0.0062789358,
0.0363113098,
-0.047458604,
-0.0916829184,
0.0636002496,
0.0091582723,
-0.0136686265,
0.0519842803,
-0.0022738311,
-0.0155505547,
0.0175421946,
-0.0585408993,
-0.0144015728,
-0.0209942292,
0.028005477,
0.0281085465,
-0.0120070493,
-0.0088688936,
-0.0505164303,
-0.0253890865,
0.028749207,
-0.0004129348,
0.0239514448,
0.0437805131,
0.0073889499,
0.0066346996,
-0.0421179421,
-0.0094922986,
0.0028834739,
-0.0037760381,
0.0519867614,
0.0026789925,
0.0840311274,
0.0354634374,
-0.0386987403,
-0.0247040596,
-0.022991145,
-0.0936667249,
-0.1110201478,
0.0393485986,
-0.012043274,
0.0046886792,
0.0208680984,
0.051446192,
-0.0294706393,
-0.0084123071,
0.0157625172,
0.0062635546,
0.08575432,
-0.0433497503,
0.052697923,
0.0259833094,
-0.029457273,
0.0033366063,
0.0321149975,
-0.0013654421,
0.0333106816,
-0.0312647149,
-0.0430802107,
-0.0367797688,
-0.0456189848,
-0.0444260687,
0.0225945469,
-0.0227001663,
0.0114426427,
-0.0828900263,
-0.0506725274,
-0.0215749871,
0.046149943,
-0.0227542762,
-0.0397483185,
-0.0074938536,
0.0590016544,
0.0392172672,
-0.0395261757,
-0.023838751,
0.0655280203,
-0.0346267708,
0.0113448817,
-0.015227518,
-6.253870923e-33,
0.005081458,
-0.0464133136,
0.0315035135,
-0.0205351971,
0.0157150235,
-0.0130262831,
-0.0543784611,
-0.0128412396,
-0.0493910126,
0.0477082767,
-0.0243812203,
0.0332713164,
0.0100322403,
0.0080238832,
0.0146080405,
-0.0050131236,
0.0449501947,
0.0260909926,
-0.0147521896,
-0.001558186,
0.0566796772,
-0.0381585211,
0.0279743671,
-0.0431332141,
0.0581055991,
-0.0004876508,
0.0170348901,
0.0859817937,
-0.0532861874,
0.0508261882,
-0.0143945524,
0.0039922632,
0.0254563633,
-0.0612361953,
-0.0025111423,
0.0331574194,
-0.073489666,
-0.0196448714,
0.0485270396,
-0.0068450314,
-0.0537822917,
-0.0219447967,
0.0126861259,
0.0103012575,
-0.0255800448,
-0.0101068178,
0.0159515273,
-0.0216617417,
0.0267851502,
0.0087286532,
-0.0234941132,
0.0221026484,
-0.0104239546,
0.0121929282,
-0.0212409515,
0.0373447314,
-0.0236265752,
0.0170396902,
-0.0409726128,
0.0033429633,
-0.0065515446,
-0.0087863067,
0.0792096183,
0.0003272286,
0.0083690872,
0.0622168705,
-0.0100176167,
-0.0118154818,
-0.071216248,
0.0096867103,
-0.0424247496,
0.0156755652,
0.0995839611,
0.050470598,
-0.0013194151,
0.0440888554,
-0.1060158461,
0.0230899062,
-0.0014131082,
0.0649162233,
0.0346878432,
0.0370583013,
-0.0420745052,
-0.0067750723,
-0.05772103,
0.0151945427,
-0.0419604778,
-0.017333854,
0.0073480583,
-0.0082978504,
-0.0632276908,
-0.0022930587,
0.0142439576,
-0.0684096068,
-0.0262515824,
0.0442873612,
0.0357953794,
-0.0303207543,
0.0095882146,
0.0443115197,
-0.0232264139,
0.0549754985,
-0.0035096067,
0.0079483902,
-0.0043503535,
0.0378029533,
-0.0232450068,
-0.0099340491,
-0.017210912,
0.004151735,
-0.0604567863,
-0.0180924796,
-0.0348431207,
-0.0121337548,
0.0515428521,
0.0396209434,
0.0018133684,
0.0202243626,
-0.0069716522,
-0.003623592,
-0.0121621303,
0.0316649191,
0.0150395455,
0.0123808682,
-0.0127832936,
-0.0261799153,
-0.0235906094,
0.0359780304,
-0.025437301,
-0.0465114564,
-0.0159189906,
0.0215916838,
2.852e-7,
0.0328805558,
0.0137006417,
0.0280539859,
0.0110144662,
0.0522206575,
0.0353628732,
0.0168285016,
-0.0211953856,
0.0358919092,
-0.0416857228,
-0.0087349657,
0.0479048304,
0.0171490684,
0.0569539629,
-0.0201111007,
-0.0129462527,
-0.0484946705,
-0.0204582401,
-0.0035153178,
0.0175593961,
0.0755755901,
0.0504731387,
0.0225856248,
0.0122626545,
-0.0375822261,
-0.0197612569,
0.0272793379,
-0.016684724,
0.0076302602,
0.0167568959,
0.0441925079,
-0.0357054137,
0.0285393372,
0.0032910258,
0.0026968557,
0.0061687734,
-0.0417870842,
0.0648130402,
-0.0130404057,
-0.0270098113,
-0.0423255898,
-0.0502996296,
0.0448202193,
-0.1028617769,
0.0722348765,
-0.0296699107,
-0.0470891483,
-0.0002683674,
-0.028753968,
-0.0467897132,
-0.023826709,
0.0146442531,
0.0025498827,
-0.0132470597,
0.0068316343,
0.0076755816,
0.0253417753,
-0.0313468277,
-0.0229709055,
-0.0343926363,
-0.0335126929,
-0.0235955603,
-0.0297338609,
-0.012896128,
0.0400860384,
-0.0390123352,
0.0100376615,
2.501598456e-34,
0.0184972081,
0.0219416656,
0.0184580293,
0.013782002,
0.0604776964,
0.0004099511,
-0.0179905351,
0.0233519804,
0.0974546671,
-0.0898737684,
-0.0316113345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14246v2 | Modeling Empathic Similarity in Personal Narratives | 2023-05-23T17:00:45 | 2023-12-06T10:13:44 | Jocelyn Shen, Maarten Sap, Pedro Colon-Hernandez, Hae Won Park, Cynthia Breazeal | cs.CL | cs.CL | The most meaningful connections between people are often fostered through
expression of shared vulnerability and emotional experiences in personal
narratives. We introduce a new task of identifying similarity in personal
stories based on empathic resonance, i.e., the extent to which two people
empathize with each others' experiences, as opposed to raw semantic or lexical
similarity, as has predominantly been studied in NLP. Using insights from
social psychology, we craft a framework that operationalizes empathic
similarity in terms of three key features of stories: main events, emotional
trajectories, and overall morals or takeaways. We create EmpathicStories, a
dataset of 1,500 personal stories annotated with our empathic similarity
features, and 2,000 pairs of stories annotated with empathic similarity scores.
Using our dataset, we fine-tune a model to compute empathic similarity of story
pairs, and show that this outperforms semantic similarity models on automated
correlation and retrieval metrics. Through a user study with 150 participants,
we also assess the effect our model has on retrieving stories that users
empathize with, compared to naive semantic similarity-based retrieval, and find
that participants empathized significantly more with stories retrieved by our
model. Our work has strong implications for the use of empathy-aware models to
foster human connection and empathy between people. | [
0.0279529784,
0.0402471647,
-0.0416415334,
0.0166006759,
-0.0433066525,
0.0266833194,
-0.0239072051,
-0.0047743926,
0.0278989896,
0.0065194378,
0.0017019896,
0.0194799453,
-0.0070662736,
-0.0141355293,
-0.0324964821,
-0.0530446284,
0.0100324126,
0.0825390592,
0.042858921,
0.0252734013,
0.0052489862,
0.0576829091,
0.0172051825,
0.0662205219,
-0.0053722057,
-0.0022049677,
0.0234652422,
0.0346085168,
0.0492859595,
-0.0137448367,
0.0116428239,
0.011272002,
0.0009862535,
-0.0348688029,
0.0000020564,
-0.0153360134,
-0.0209683031,
-0.0209826194,
0.0601425171,
-0.0537896194,
0.0855579451,
-0.0117999874,
0.0484168492,
0.0147639988,
-0.029037457,
-0.052429162,
0.0139504215,
0.0345287696,
0.0305105615,
0.0374845564,
-0.0257110242,
-0.0281834714,
-0.0210691039,
0.0043052072,
0.0040135053,
0.0320293941,
-0.0213490035,
-0.0152157415,
0.0131441411,
-0.045286797,
-0.0049801269,
0.0220252611,
0.0025568537,
0.039399866,
0.0098167583,
0.0456648394,
0.0350476839,
-0.0239740778,
0.0316900648,
0.0783987492,
0.0250481181,
-0.0222279597,
0.0381520726,
-0.0138577856,
0.0047086268,
0.0446198061,
-0.0387018323,
-0.0003881682,
-0.0314994007,
0.0092690894,
-0.0004547808,
0.0649862364,
0.0080220709,
0.0279947389,
0.0691619739,
-0.0369151123,
-0.0140179014,
-0.0009647207,
-0.0191913415,
-0.0034491664,
0.0004807771,
-0.0143632563,
0.0265121758,
0.005537889,
0.0203902777,
0.0049882885,
-0.0440319553,
0.035266418,
0.0266462807,
-0.033287432,
0.0315493122,
0.0573646501,
0.0045780651,
0.0032153586,
0.0062634656,
-0.0164531171,
0.0143917594,
0.0256637819,
-0.056648057,
0.0013243903,
-0.0349777341,
0.0410995334,
0.0036557114,
0.0506202988,
-0.0267425608,
-0.0052538812,
-0.0290414318,
-0.0055642864,
-0.0034374937,
0.0017711496,
-0.053883601,
0.0091227936,
-0.0154430717,
-0.0065590828,
-0.02263695,
-0.024103839,
-0.0883064047,
0.0090109194,
-0.0053320788,
-0.0171482228,
0.0119493753,
-0.0518736914,
0.0383630805,
-0.0345846415,
0.0254150145,
-0.0071069505,
0.0169468634,
-0.0621041358,
-0.043492008,
-0.0342217311,
0.0420975946,
-0.0154574215,
-0.0669121295,
-0.0442986004,
0.0826561376,
0.0309769325,
0.0216945056,
-0.0450849682,
0.0017357806,
0.0393864252,
-0.0882922933,
0.0497833416,
0.0127690304,
0.0405958518,
0.0069263708,
0.0257359631,
0.0271721072,
-0.0277375467,
0.0067686746,
0.0136792297,
0.076942116,
0.0292234235,
0.0065743383,
-0.0453242026,
-0.0167478547,
-0.0245543644,
0.0174601953,
-0.0011805228,
-0.0131176151,
0.0688088387,
0.0211326648,
0.0348594971,
-0.0459564924,
-0.0828906223,
0.0451024435,
0.150916636,
0.0245208181,
0.0742198676,
0.0227709655,
0.0147435088,
-0.0199217703,
0.0309172049,
-0.0292762779,
0.0267012622,
0.0327328742,
-0.0199192986,
0.0110813482,
0.0273949541,
-0.035967011,
-0.0059640273,
-0.0189127009,
-0.0265412182,
0.0110621331,
-0.0038913882,
-0.0487578586,
-0.0104332296,
-0.0114836488,
-0.0159204602,
0.0648460686,
-0.1039940789,
0.0155582046,
0.0020087184,
0.0153238662,
0.0966642797,
0.0533693954,
-0.022363048,
-0.0302403774,
-0.0080731446,
-0.0596381985,
-0.0433061384,
0.0280983262,
0.0226224232,
0.0420627892,
-0.0451013073,
0.0144508081,
0.0224582423,
0.0066329762,
0.00695229,
-0.0262586102,
0.0282507483,
0.0153443115,
-0.0225671846,
-0.0062031527,
0.0604917556,
-0.0782009065,
0.0213462189,
0.0184918493,
0.0395361111,
-0.0217283256,
0.0274530351,
0.0062515927,
0.0079933507,
0.0274882764,
-0.0284840167,
-0.048178792,
0.0894387811,
-0.0494215079,
-0.0058669448,
0.0106410198,
-0.0789053813,
0.0164860245,
0.0334577411,
0.0169102736,
-0.0000254419,
0.0324501842,
-0.0146457888,
0.0292750467,
-0.0428999104,
0.0038272887,
-0.0236896053,
-0.0146517027,
-0.016941363,
0.042782858,
-0.0048205,
0.0523957536,
-0.0802907795,
-0.0329432003,
-0.0012064582,
-0.0142575055,
-0.0279560499,
-0.0084318463,
0.0139572844,
-0.0147058303,
0.0204405729,
-0.0511516556,
-0.052066166,
-0.0467243604,
-0.1324712783,
0.0169280525,
0.0121570863,
-0.0059967521,
0.0138003891,
-0.01628902,
-0.0258776285,
-0.0041445913,
-0.049145259,
0.0216521863,
-0.0001557531,
-0.0019324704,
0.0236183908,
0.0245287754,
-0.0023005682,
-0.0900107324,
-0.0020006911,
-0.0323652849,
0.0592373572,
0.0062740413,
0.0275416952,
-0.0020073692,
0.0170603152,
-0.0646578521,
0.0082282312,
0.007054918,
-0.0233561732,
-0.0307735279,
-0.0096877785,
0.0037916095,
0.0070182891,
0.0134776309,
0.0469366163,
-0.0001790142,
0.0038806915,
-0.0532910489,
0.0175568089,
-0.0383385085,
0.0159564018,
-0.0176259,
-0.0688379556,
-0.0104730194,
0.0061339033,
0.0132778268,
-0.0076370249,
-0.051306691,
-0.0255896971,
0.0139026353,
-0.004406353,
-0.0027249837,
-0.0215087663,
0.033167474,
-0.0138907032,
-0.0264449883,
-0.0344070941,
0.0894809738,
0.0234308168,
0.0168724842,
-0.0005619782,
-0.0166987926,
-0.0344173387,
0.1215833127,
-0.0391624905,
0.0311635956,
0.0180818029,
0.0053733378,
-0.0131056169,
-0.0046533067,
0.056363292,
-0.0288680755,
-0.0014434626,
0.0007517031,
-0.0176269691,
0.0573629364,
-0.0337673053,
-0.0204270985,
-0.0819418356,
-0.0266173892,
-0.0245812796,
-0.0094918134,
0.0082774786,
-0.0260547325,
-0.0391521491,
0.026434375,
-0.0064417855,
-0.0169336926,
-0.0349835865,
-0.0047238083,
0.0387223251,
0.0196602698,
-0.043859005,
0.0032389511,
-0.0100447349,
0.0613213778,
0.033927463,
0.0684942603,
0.028268164,
0.0423426852,
0.0136112114,
-0.0002454204,
-0.029474752,
0.0003516428,
-0.0288888533,
-0.0016786666,
-0.0089322887,
-0.0203980003,
0.1001549438,
0.0219984669,
-0.0327808745,
0.010985543,
-0.0236708764,
-0.0184450187,
0.0208386295,
-0.0023715894,
0.0035642486,
-0.0164633226,
0.0005040198,
0.0128427623,
-0.033975374,
-0.0711986199,
-0.0042970679,
-0.0472603329,
-0.0004421408,
-0.013566725,
0.044318758,
-0.0511820465,
-0.0454554036,
0.0029327737,
0.0063281176,
-0.0094985291,
-0.0099978484,
-0.0402558036,
0.0001137169,
-0.0307004731,
0.005218192,
0.0082435263,
0.0215799864,
-0.0673495159,
0.0310744531,
0.0101147583,
0.0981735736,
0.0209294613,
-0.0197079629,
-0.0800472498,
0.0099478047,
0.001655162,
0.0123914238,
0.0306001529,
-0.04151446,
0.0227287523,
-0.0461566783,
0.0690950006,
-0.0139812818,
-0.0125798713,
-0.0128644742,
0.029437691,
-0.0203969013,
-0.0464441329,
-0.0141784903,
0.0327377282,
-0.0022223063,
0.0768856108,
0.0128333522,
-0.0073615988,
0.0252618678,
0.0536592864,
0.0476113148,
0.0197601169,
-0.0187779292,
-0.0014385292,
-0.0028367266,
0.0114204399,
-0.040829245,
-0.0798894018,
-0.0100404611,
-0.008298534,
0.0026387759,
-0.0429998972,
0.0105912816,
-0.0118806977,
-0.0840890482,
0.0324472152,
-0.0190590005,
0.0521858372,
0.03230666,
0.0689544901,
0.0384962931,
-0.0152809015,
-0.0217989739,
-0.0160369817,
-0.0194826201,
-0.0165783633,
-0.0061817183,
-0.018405864,
-0.0010358682,
0.0251576323,
0.0035984744,
-0.0587424152,
-0.0016619546,
0.047923658,
-0.1069030166,
0.0095636034,
-0.0285566542,
0.0226281825,
0.0136351222,
0.0244238079,
-0.0135959741,
0.0048865397,
0.0263144579,
0.0014436697,
0.005964322,
-0.0527113937,
0.0147819575,
-0.0051078019,
0.0184665024,
0.0088844402,
-0.0304593649,
-0.0491019189,
-0.0457320139,
-0.0152536845,
0.0091511486,
-0.0139477421,
0.0076331059,
0.019715935,
0.0334045589,
-0.0605425164,
-0.0513493307,
-0.0572125763,
0.0444319025,
-0.0643311068,
-0.0290891081,
-0.032480821,
0.0063933413,
-0.0508469306,
0.0113246785,
-0.0249606688,
0.0023803615,
-0.0138934301,
0.0016262266,
-0.0358465984,
0.033706218,
0.0150145702,
0.0023690395,
-0.024890596,
0.0154654663,
-0.0280741006,
-0.0146121196,
-0.0073648635,
0.0277677607,
0.0389420725,
-0.0040895496,
-0.0009550909,
-0.024293473,
0.0240745787,
0.0006488443,
0.0058176951,
-0.0164815318,
-0.0094595887,
-0.0239274502,
0.0205238555,
-0.0091723958,
0.0268389415,
0.0053526675,
-0.0950579792,
0.040661782,
0.0024214913,
-0.0689291507,
0.0062742061,
0.0052669412,
0.0744626373,
0.062955752,
-0.0170898363,
0.0031877363,
-0.0901841968,
-0.0096311439,
0.0709371865,
-0.0033825568,
-0.0130182896,
-0.0325374939,
0.0266502406,
0.0562842749,
-0.0012120962,
0.0180262476,
-0.0120889824,
0.0156557094,
-0.068971321,
-0.0070412457,
-0.0012207937,
-5.764476625e-33,
0.0064349538,
-0.0059135123,
-0.0319364071,
0.0157030039,
-0.0454487056,
0.0150849605,
-0.0058754631,
0.0116637368,
0.0025939657,
0.0630820617,
-0.0020093629,
0.0392591171,
-0.0020300276,
-0.028729314,
-0.0143094519,
0.0105508827,
0.0113857212,
0.0359725393,
0.0007253945,
0.0297005586,
0.0207710657,
0.0559678376,
-0.0047198422,
-0.0774242952,
0.0093647819,
-0.0192181543,
0.0056028678,
0.0068453168,
0.0755724534,
0.0198182333,
-0.0029602731,
0.0612542778,
0.0301640034,
0.0123011265,
0.0211448949,
0.0081397481,
-0.0948036835,
-0.0352042094,
0.0110017387,
-0.0510989688,
-0.0428129397,
-0.0193102024,
0.0424110815,
0.0280252397,
-0.0212762766,
-0.0474387445,
0.054949265,
0.0288342424,
0.0300737508,
-0.0012656217,
-0.0003423388,
-0.008927349,
-0.0108147329,
-0.0595977157,
-0.0048515466,
0.0331683606,
0.0012206211,
0.0418843366,
-0.0092744762,
-0.0053491727,
-0.1122180447,
0.0065139756,
-0.0384086296,
-0.0721490383,
-0.0134533104,
0.1165013537,
0.00789876,
-0.0047089546,
-0.0346427448,
0.055579219,
0.0253729653,
0.0035524194,
0.0211451221,
0.0863513127,
-0.0269087423,
-0.0596235953,
-0.0122992685,
0.0710216835,
0.0363022387,
0.0129131172,
0.032436125,
-0.0033411975,
-0.0413411818,
0.0173012111,
-0.0573728159,
-0.0578830056,
-0.0317791738,
-0.0085562309,
-0.0079096537,
-0.0061650341,
-0.0217327662,
0.000611668,
-0.040132422,
-0.0127504179,
0.006354962,
0.0050640837,
-0.0316500887,
-0.0061525102,
-0.0099012582,
0.024975637,
0.0100302352,
-0.0348995067,
-0.0118864821,
-0.0113798585,
0.0571160875,
-0.0128018577,
0.0203671008,
-0.0065987585,
-0.0419437289,
-0.0120425168,
-0.0103518739,
-0.0097240517,
-0.0217802171,
-0.0795569047,
-0.0113608232,
0.0588582605,
0.0025336666,
0.0012336756,
0.0374560207,
0.0634625629,
-0.0561498702,
-0.0656968802,
-0.017466642,
0.0291094948,
0.0250962954,
-0.0057830936,
-0.0244783722,
-0.0246827919,
0.0280514508,
0.0104175992,
-0.0336547419,
-0.0142098283,
2.713e-7,
-0.0360534899,
-0.0032089818,
0.0432220735,
-0.0326632671,
-0.031386029,
0.0698037595,
0.0293235425,
0.0924081132,
0.0304268412,
-0.0409299172,
0.0297996495,
0.0197520182,
0.036214713,
0.0160860419,
-0.0418401584,
0.0621035211,
-0.0455665439,
-0.0396833457,
-0.0382931605,
-0.021287512,
0.0817461833,
0.0131317955,
0.0898828804,
-0.0131999794,
0.0328676477,
0.009805534,
0.0234161578,
-0.0955301449,
-0.0344366729,
0.018731216,
-0.0382436588,
-0.0132230837,
0.0171347465,
-0.0255266018,
0.0086848233,
0.0257650185,
0.0580698624,
0.0275819022,
-0.0354162082,
-0.0533391088,
0.0140007101,
0.0066553792,
-0.0448780395,
-0.048528254,
0.0149402348,
-0.0641962811,
0.0038852356,
0.0231006388,
0.0222012941,
0.032959044,
0.0164491292,
0.0156489108,
-0.0833156854,
0.0512823388,
0.0386296287,
0.0121474164,
0.011532221,
-0.0676030219,
0.0197204985,
-0.0045371908,
-0.0070996387,
-0.0331596173,
0.0125792874,
0.0027228927,
-0.0164232384,
-0.0142312404,
0.0035108859,
1.802201243e-34,
-0.0205371398,
0.0377358794,
-0.0095631341,
-0.0139440307,
0.0524354242,
0.0109565426,
-0.0265820175,
-0.0129368082,
0.0286841411,
-0.0283782203,
-0.0037677914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14240v1 | Revisiting Machine Translation for Cross-lingual Classification | 2023-05-23T16:56:10 | 2023-05-23T16:56:10 | Mikel Artetxe, Vedanuj Goswami, Shruti Bhosale, Angela Fan, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Machine Translation (MT) has been widely used for cross-lingual
classification, either by translating the test set into English and running
inference with a monolingual model (translate-test), or translating the
training set into the target languages and finetuning a multilingual model
(translate-train). However, most research in the area focuses on the
multilingual models rather than the MT component. We show that, by using a
stronger MT system and mitigating the mismatch between training on original
text and running inference on machine translated text, translate-test can do
substantially better than previously assumed. The optimal approach, however, is
highly task dependent, as we identify various sources of cross-lingual transfer
gap that affect different tasks and approaches differently. Our work calls into
question the dominance of multilingual models for cross-lingual classification,
and prompts to pay more attention to MT-based baselines. | [
-0.0031642949,
0.0285931882,
-0.0280921198,
0.0685463399,
-0.0504505746,
0.0151529787,
0.0465291739,
-0.0011239487,
-0.015562945,
-0.0393413454,
-0.0422480255,
-0.0476513878,
0.011795586,
-0.0401428975,
0.0262127146,
-0.0425622463,
0.0474867709,
0.0147522371,
-0.0533055849,
0.0023695936,
-0.0250417069,
0.0203354135,
0.0206117202,
0.0105023189,
0.0184300039,
0.0089868475,
0.0399357751,
0.0108852182,
0.0552481078,
0.0063894009,
-0.0122502446,
0.0367910862,
0.0159411449,
0.064005293,
0.0000016798,
-0.0545010865,
-0.0265536215,
0.0147078205,
0.005790594,
-0.0297961533,
0.0416315943,
-0.0838165954,
0.0147706317,
0.0113027543,
-0.0159704182,
-0.0333509408,
0.0623355955,
0.0247538704,
0.0199079756,
0.0886327326,
-0.0190639328,
-0.003335007,
-0.0022031658,
-0.0381730497,
0.0300867558,
-0.0634345561,
0.0098508419,
0.0208245013,
-0.0523796529,
0.0328978673,
-0.0210595876,
0.0469901077,
0.0131478673,
0.0283776931,
-0.038104564,
0.0089489929,
-0.0052640736,
-0.0117279328,
0.0108425319,
0.0410339534,
-0.0445529893,
-0.0398566388,
-0.0188020337,
0.0070301611,
-0.0118633658,
0.0088330954,
-0.0202572327,
0.0073301136,
-0.0071959682,
0.0063866996,
0.059265025,
0.018916633,
0.0289521087,
0.0150716109,
-0.0444425568,
-0.0093047377,
0.0154172173,
-0.0114826672,
0.0468507893,
0.0628231913,
0.0046137744,
-0.0080913194,
0.0084746201,
-0.0255206749,
-0.0089780521,
-0.0043270863,
-0.0293608475,
-0.0563682094,
0.0128759919,
-0.0481314287,
0.010121082,
0.0568315908,
-0.0356641002,
0.042890951,
-0.0407516323,
0.0586402453,
-0.0094190016,
0.024774909,
-0.0681008101,
-0.0374306329,
-0.0399512164,
0.0317819156,
-0.0117634963,
-0.0277451612,
-0.0263445843,
0.0277615637,
-0.0441455245,
-0.012058638,
0.0136237331,
-0.0294054635,
-0.0163340513,
-0.0650845692,
-0.0673683435,
0.0076700402,
0.0173764452,
0.0560666658,
-0.0149946371,
0.0023199269,
-0.0227491446,
-0.0411143415,
-0.025232885,
0.0063196439,
-0.0269159954,
-0.0674399063,
0.0207458362,
0.0899373889,
-0.0385291204,
-0.0358752459,
-0.017164018,
-0.0010584522,
-0.0228560492,
-0.0768612325,
0.0241304003,
-0.0310100634,
0.0644931421,
0.0205418319,
0.0474770181,
-0.0122609334,
-0.0084778108,
0.0095422771,
-0.0168897212,
0.0691064075,
0.0366251767,
-0.0123960255,
0.0280129164,
-0.0251144301,
-0.0668252409,
0.0806127265,
0.0085456716,
-0.0000416261,
0.0443762131,
-0.0063436585,
-0.0574703142,
0.0562769286,
0.0221913047,
0.0189807117,
-0.0059256675,
-0.0040772175,
0.0186246932,
0.0174086466,
0.0139549971,
0.0023627151,
-0.017694056,
0.0289220568,
0.0455861427,
0.01930511,
0.0158932414,
0.0550083593,
0.0536637567,
0.001292518,
-0.0372797288,
0.0336828232,
-0.0274693444,
-0.0124162016,
-0.0043608998,
-0.016456319,
-0.003088342,
0.0368011594,
-0.0324281678,
-0.019190954,
0.008886613,
-0.0276785009,
0.0545767508,
-0.0147833005,
0.0730040446,
0.0290013123,
-0.0162719153,
0.0368329436,
0.0320422091,
-0.0366113074,
0.0265747681,
-0.0427142493,
-0.0204013232,
0.0264916997,
-0.0152413184,
-0.0019913036,
-0.0015364633,
-0.0029552323,
0.0423736349,
0.0277476721,
0.103483133,
-0.0049028988,
0.0283904038,
-0.037823759,
-0.0102609592,
-0.0013479572,
0.0176472198,
0.039117109,
-0.0086303214,
0.0573747978,
0.0429646261,
-0.0496356636,
-0.0683422089,
0.0428025126,
-0.046791479,
-0.0108497078,
0.0488923527,
0.0308912545,
0.0061292513,
-0.000368312,
-0.0117219184,
-0.0299270879,
0.007613875,
-0.0400787219,
-0.0063803848,
0.030451091,
-0.0025417279,
-0.0583655685,
0.0045818118,
-0.0448468104,
-0.0174445938,
0.0429892242,
-0.0472901501,
-0.0245772246,
-0.0071952995,
-0.0258844551,
-0.0079028625,
-0.037780147,
0.0144722853,
-0.0436092988,
0.0270108618,
-0.0181840621,
0.0395412035,
0.0462387912,
0.0333429761,
-0.0063195238,
-0.0629562512,
0.0410611071,
-0.0201615375,
-0.0102049131,
0.0374843143,
-0.0069605354,
0.0326501951,
0.0549844801,
0.0648426041,
-0.0249311924,
-0.004558648,
-0.0721574128,
0.0328680873,
-0.0328544192,
0.0577139892,
0.0317282304,
0.0206877328,
-0.0016085303,
-0.0131122749,
-0.0204444099,
-0.0056997724,
0.0186747331,
0.0370678939,
0.0098395795,
-0.0053803464,
0.0448326804,
-0.0070769289,
-0.0053792186,
0.0074559432,
0.0625437871,
-0.0071241702,
-0.0399625562,
-0.0526238233,
0.0327262059,
-0.0530144013,
-0.0195335429,
0.0035685098,
-0.0284202378,
-0.0065706279,
0.0247215927,
0.0327426717,
0.0377369635,
-0.0217150152,
-0.0211018082,
0.0241646487,
-0.0032445476,
-0.0517873876,
0.0068311733,
-0.0086369375,
-0.0445541665,
-0.0423955917,
-0.0651897117,
-0.0034527679,
0.0506078042,
0.0029037204,
-0.044398278,
-0.072770834,
-0.0102572013,
-0.0353640318,
-0.0125738541,
-0.0172584709,
0.0503257774,
0.0258738734,
0.0506721139,
-0.0355751552,
-0.0410497524,
0.0797689259,
-0.0164045636,
0.0107889082,
-0.0788579881,
0.0155549794,
-0.0380554348,
0.0499154441,
-0.0220526606,
0.0317702219,
-0.0221482385,
-0.0079071308,
-0.0302529931,
0.0129777836,
0.0264320318,
-0.0222077873,
0.0185565092,
-0.0739070699,
-0.012302028,
-0.0365806557,
-0.0272865836,
-0.0085784113,
0.0035096654,
0.0085791945,
0.0038639926,
-0.0188724082,
0.0155856684,
-0.054764241,
0.0110293385,
0.0196726546,
0.0367737114,
-0.0183164496,
0.0099745411,
-0.0003359184,
0.025713779,
-0.0110888537,
-0.0150057906,
0.0024245514,
-0.0587776862,
0.0272330306,
0.004587491,
0.0024841519,
0.0172579251,
0.0026284584,
-0.0259419605,
0.0286734365,
-0.0031309759,
-0.04917261,
-0.0385845564,
0.0566055551,
-0.0218788255,
-0.0191788934,
0.0684961975,
0.0117876967,
-0.0247400589,
-0.0296190921,
-0.0205075629,
-0.0078868968,
0.0045763585,
0.0376821198,
-0.0790947899,
-0.0228843149,
0.00500286,
0.0062894807,
0.014953143,
0.0220141001,
-0.0286526307,
-0.0707239583,
-0.0021970368,
0.0256064758,
-0.0973690078,
-0.0407849662,
-0.0540889464,
-0.0029865049,
-0.0455673039,
0.0253823418,
-0.0603892319,
0.0242684297,
-0.0090593807,
0.0035244478,
0.0291157961,
-0.0549017899,
0.0365626812,
-0.0586313754,
-0.0196264237,
0.0550262295,
0.0690319017,
-0.003471341,
-0.0202925056,
0.0400239043,
-0.0597242676,
-0.0192505661,
-0.0278892089,
0.050019715,
0.0097771231,
-0.0189010389,
0.0589528121,
-0.0124218464,
-0.013907115,
0.0220643673,
0.017945746,
0.0865348354,
0.0206255224,
-0.0191080794,
0.0348861106,
-0.0109938588,
0.0258103106,
0.052728001,
-0.0208615493,
-0.0493321978,
-0.0051026787,
-0.0097381994,
-0.0031666062,
-0.0614366718,
-0.0327416025,
0.0163296442,
-0.0965850353,
-0.0405224152,
-0.069604069,
-0.0810086876,
0.0167715717,
0.0054015541,
0.0283247158,
-0.0065892036,
-0.0400081687,
-0.011721774,
-0.0308620427,
0.0541973449,
-0.0326031558,
0.0409883186,
0.0110559417,
0.0106606307,
0.0180352703,
-0.0479060188,
0.0098363496,
0.0228196159,
-0.0612193346,
-0.0614848509,
-0.0630911663,
0.0489273928,
0.0145790465,
0.0341550931,
-0.0180047955,
-0.0076190908,
0.0144693712,
-0.0125886407,
-0.0229273606,
-0.0097439224,
0.0560515895,
-0.0157820024,
-0.0295935683,
0.0604576506,
-0.011509452,
0.0057129925,
0.0141079687,
0.0313445814,
-0.0105889598,
-0.0538313389,
0.0168267488,
0.007322445,
0.0496436134,
-0.0275926515,
-0.0529169179,
-0.035577368,
0.0181523953,
-0.015714664,
-0.0331122205,
-0.0112656029,
-0.0325504355,
0.059049394,
0.004763192,
-0.0093275774,
0.0404088162,
-0.0148818158,
-0.0103955707,
-0.0297621582,
-0.0061450955,
-0.0025206283,
0.0555512868,
-0.00849107,
0.0325349085,
-0.0168367419,
-0.0417454056,
0.0203926563,
0.037453074,
-0.0477664806,
0.0481423736,
0.0009041541,
0.0163652338,
0.0111566046,
-0.0031865481,
-0.0098114414,
-0.0126915323,
-0.0110031422,
-0.0169568937,
0.0593935996,
-0.0284230169,
0.1153269783,
0.0095789544,
-0.0380806588,
-0.021922078,
0.0389952473,
-0.0042794859,
0.0027340737,
-0.0144488942,
-0.0290775355,
0.0053161155,
0.0167507418,
0.0496033616,
0.0016973254,
0.0223377999,
-0.0054834946,
-0.0257848166,
-0.0210752357,
-0.0060911113,
0.0259448383,
-0.0476680063,
0.0145701757,
-0.0285524298,
-0.0223963857,
-0.0584075265,
0.0426823981,
0.0162508357,
0.0040718033,
0.0143904304,
-0.017942097,
0.1170186326,
-0.0333294496,
-0.0067126388,
-0.0614069328,
0.0040451395,
0.0181554444,
0.0067940238,
-0.0454269163,
-5.194109868e-33,
-0.0067829266,
0.0198192243,
0.0230961442,
-0.0054863221,
-0.0212373268,
0.0031106148,
-0.019850269,
-0.0240780711,
-0.019573329,
0.0338908322,
0.0149278808,
-0.0162191764,
0.0285709407,
-0.001355343,
0.0198021643,
0.0005265321,
0.0550844446,
-0.0012691411,
-0.0356430486,
0.0300082173,
0.0375386626,
0.0297991391,
0.1175854802,
-0.0437246934,
0.0732861683,
-0.0022484565,
0.0140909636,
0.0122262612,
0.0111999298,
0.0169797223,
-0.0022502735,
0.0377462208,
0.0471628681,
-0.0266300254,
0.001809385,
-0.0007934204,
-0.0892187729,
-0.0207667686,
0.0306813158,
0.0323024318,
-0.0002134287,
-0.0440012552,
0.0029814562,
-0.0358043388,
0.0139238313,
-0.0424239486,
0.0405382253,
-0.060856428,
-0.0077398708,
-0.01205571,
-0.0869870856,
0.0256235432,
0.0007305988,
-0.0309634581,
0.0437465906,
0.117099233,
0.0031011945,
0.0054928334,
-0.0503203645,
0.0150071131,
-0.0596498065,
0.0167054478,
0.0536111742,
0.0026494213,
-0.042508021,
-0.00472295,
0.0118496884,
0.0099226153,
0.049014315,
0.0093427617,
0.0319177695,
-0.0014703501,
0.0447789542,
0.0823702589,
0.0394399129,
-0.0217956491,
-0.0971986949,
0.0548736826,
-0.0231576934,
0.0139425071,
0.0059309225,
-0.0146165174,
-0.0187525861,
-0.0124544902,
-0.0630780011,
-0.0551101416,
-0.0165388715,
-0.0378718339,
-0.0082428763,
0.0126977619,
-0.0383658148,
0.0004809074,
0.0793942586,
-0.0183988083,
-0.0188636482,
-0.0089562675,
-0.0302583296,
-0.0257828068,
-0.0178674161,
0.0434444845,
-0.0259059686,
-0.0790424421,
0.0069923997,
0.0207758863,
0.0293044522,
-0.0268578958,
0.1050347537,
0.0004484864,
-0.0472262017,
0.0092696389,
-0.0513840988,
-0.0044159042,
-0.0247621126,
0.0828169212,
0.0133387344,
0.0340414457,
0.0129389362,
0.0324477777,
0.0647546723,
-0.0314953327,
-0.030470917,
0.0056807878,
0.0024389245,
0.0257186927,
-0.0135517456,
0.0081086187,
-0.028114846,
0.0214539059,
0.0177600067,
-0.0666749403,
-0.0239974912,
-0.0052627288,
2.372e-7,
0.0565270558,
0.0384642929,
-0.0156403407,
0.0132586397,
-0.002594667,
0.0262344237,
-0.0450163074,
0.0232480597,
0.033137545,
0.0294032041,
0.0199636053,
0.0336862132,
0.1086315811,
0.0613793246,
-0.040066652,
-0.0243123025,
-0.0128853135,
0.0218329821,
-0.0432602726,
0.0216113348,
0.0508633591,
0.0662818551,
-0.0168144032,
-0.000616525,
-0.0144206909,
-0.0396753959,
0.1107531115,
-0.049519144,
-0.0450997204,
0.0068911258,
0.0238102227,
0.0094902264,
-0.0228435211,
0.0415519476,
-0.0504964963,
0.0345835648,
0.0387964845,
0.0459638052,
0.0122572156,
0.0054447851,
-0.0069788317,
-0.0101866797,
-0.0149261858,
-0.0232558325,
0.0528686158,
-0.0608312264,
0.0003737717,
-0.0125622423,
-0.0065277643,
0.0302349348,
0.0867584199,
-0.0381138436,
-0.0363273025,
0.0472791977,
0.064104937,
0.0249295998,
-0.0460064523,
-0.0376392342,
-0.0161126275,
0.0247957725,
-0.0288812704,
-0.0269107204,
0.0146951256,
-0.0050018136,
-0.0073825959,
-0.0493319221,
0.0367371812,
1.563003066e-34,
0.0103637474,
-0.0197176114,
0.0065837726,
-0.0528113693,
0.0381839573,
-0.0304597951,
0.007455179,
-0.0091608232,
-0.0347382687,
-0.0081741465,
0.0072161527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14239v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14239v2 | On Learning to Summarize with Large Language Models as References | 2023-05-23T16:56:04 | 2023-11-16T05:55:43 | Yixin Liu, Kejian Shi, Katherine S He, Longtian Ye, Alexander R. Fabbri, Pengfei Liu, Dragomir Radev, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have found that summaries generated by large language models
(LLMs) are favored by human annotators over the original reference summaries in
commonly used summarization datasets. Therefore, we investigate a new learning
setting of text summarization models that considers the LLMs as the reference
or the gold-standard oracle on these datasets. To examine the standard
practices that are aligned with this new learning setting, we investigate two
LLM-based summary quality evaluation methods for model training and adopt a
contrastive learning training method to leverage the LLM-guided learning
signals. Our experiments on the CNN/DailyMail and XSum datasets demonstrate
that smaller summarization models can achieve similar performance as LLMs under
LLM-based evaluation. However, we found that the smaller models can not yet
reach LLM-level performance under human evaluation despite promising
improvements brought by our proposed training methods. Meanwhile, we perform a
meta-analysis on this new learning setting that reveals a discrepancy between
human and LLM-based evaluation, highlighting the benefits and risks of this
LLM-as-reference setting we investigated. | [
0.0679673553,
0.0277451314,
0.0485227406,
-0.0130259497,
-0.0108466726,
0.0084803831,
-0.0056056441,
-0.0021686603,
-0.0100290552,
-0.0561406128,
-0.0350043587,
-0.0231696852,
0.0171609782,
-0.024915766,
0.0234897044,
-0.0917663798,
0.0187092982,
-0.013155262,
-0.018323373,
0.0051413896,
0.0302385651,
-0.0022364818,
0.051745005,
0.0295898449,
0.0066274595,
0.015616918,
0.0407118499,
-0.0064367349,
0.0534162857,
-0.0009062372,
0.0047213747,
0.0232285447,
0.0077141006,
0.0281463806,
0.0000017703,
-0.0331065319,
-0.0176848061,
0.0232904069,
0.0072214804,
0.0498567224,
0.0764501393,
-0.0366856791,
0.0126114301,
0.0311581735,
0.0098965252,
0.0015191145,
0.0083612734,
0.0807891861,
0.0829296634,
0.0444580913,
0.0040283343,
-0.0258712862,
0.0421716906,
-0.0384683833,
-0.070628874,
-0.0063087251,
0.0136346491,
0.0602174029,
-0.0238891561,
-0.0030979018,
0.025650993,
0.0359085239,
0.0067429841,
-0.0029690994,
0.0066109546,
0.0382779315,
-0.0549060814,
0.0109425653,
0.0305889044,
0.0527630784,
-0.0122462707,
0.0026134863,
-0.0009701724,
0.0191007257,
0.0269139651,
0.009290711,
-0.0496508107,
0.0519051813,
0.0018390052,
0.0442015082,
-0.0046096691,
0.02233091,
-0.0044346652,
0.0473859757,
-0.0097591272,
-0.0165348351,
-0.0079321386,
-0.012062992,
0.0018675533,
0.0317195393,
-0.0216201432,
-0.0157659259,
-0.0122999046,
0.008870801,
-0.0110430177,
-0.0162462238,
-0.062253844,
-0.0694203079,
0.0488523245,
-0.0618280098,
0.0334808715,
-0.010234951,
-0.0118552968,
0.0263049174,
-0.0337814279,
0.02273863,
0.0360798649,
0.0340435095,
-0.0537934713,
-0.0196076147,
-0.0207701884,
0.0180847608,
-0.0128264474,
0.0523973666,
-0.035747163,
-0.0008805342,
-0.0557178557,
0.0080132633,
0.00696206,
-0.0172811095,
-0.0004236447,
0.0015873021,
0.006474948,
0.0066720294,
-0.0161497053,
0.0184705351,
-0.0264135487,
-0.0125219235,
0.0152041642,
-0.0265657008,
-0.0010461956,
0.0226164721,
-0.0112384018,
-0.0011763965,
0.0152805522,
0.0419888645,
-0.035413444,
-0.0481116697,
-0.0365864299,
-0.0072505688,
-0.0233342182,
-0.0573377833,
0.0005762509,
-0.0845674202,
-0.0346173309,
-0.0018012032,
-0.0079584774,
-0.0164959244,
-0.0052061505,
0.0283359811,
-0.0552081093,
-0.0019705682,
-0.0306521878,
-0.0037763061,
0.036477007,
-0.0024518126,
0.0165358186,
0.0510994755,
0.0504682884,
0.025426019,
0.0294954218,
0.0342413969,
0.0034488689,
0.008829508,
0.004226835,
0.0165438652,
-0.0127221216,
-0.0122615602,
-0.0083175022,
-0.0199134611,
0.0583643503,
0.1030880064,
-0.0546620674,
0.0003019476,
0.0786315948,
0.0383615158,
-0.0100585585,
0.0226028617,
0.0121090068,
0.0331647098,
0.0566195436,
0.0557140633,
-0.0223834161,
0.0273652188,
-0.0451716073,
0.0524275936,
0.109764494,
0.0295895897,
-0.0255497862,
-0.0703814477,
-0.0001862678,
-0.0045522195,
-0.0002893586,
-0.0045302394,
0.0251701009,
-0.0001765547,
-0.0221017823,
0.0477992706,
0.0214380063,
-0.0528349392,
-0.0028401061,
-0.0304996409,
0.0215485599,
0.0209125709,
0.0403392538,
-0.0210198667,
0.0080085443,
-0.0279599037,
0.0001264206,
0.0367223807,
0.0454613827,
-0.0012526175,
-0.0069294288,
-0.044671189,
-0.0363999307,
-0.0245908294,
0.0113661103,
-0.0295058656,
0.0032129784,
-0.0474447012,
0.0430768654,
-0.0405753516,
-0.116012685,
0.0353698172,
-0.0171927474,
-0.0194359981,
-0.0197142679,
-0.026842162,
0.0165474769,
0.0216226317,
-0.0348471068,
0.018027056,
0.0060036257,
-0.0292766262,
0.0078354385,
-0.0121540762,
-0.0419723876,
-0.0170101374,
0.0436260514,
-0.0687179044,
0.0065027475,
0.0498354249,
-0.0540020578,
-0.0467776507,
0.0066518215,
-0.0627687201,
0.0030797096,
-0.0488418043,
-0.0044649472,
0.0073167505,
0.009796368,
-0.0225669108,
0.059367951,
-0.0186792407,
-0.0019720197,
0.0638977438,
-0.0415637195,
0.0073971376,
-0.0180821642,
-0.0254183169,
-0.004476184,
-0.007322384,
0.0338221602,
0.0438853279,
0.0109687094,
-0.0427751504,
-0.0264649913,
-0.0885615051,
-0.008534614,
-0.0318696722,
0.0088886078,
0.0391783193,
-0.0024217004,
0.0077470089,
0.0048489845,
-0.0297288615,
-0.0569475181,
0.0102112582,
0.0199983604,
0.032036148,
0.0160350725,
0.0588356368,
-0.0839195698,
-0.0327334553,
0.0300095249,
0.0665916353,
-0.0091868332,
-0.0351037979,
-0.0338657238,
0.0367213823,
-0.0097175809,
-0.0438516475,
0.0134303132,
-0.0170495864,
-0.0191442017,
0.0084064575,
0.0414471924,
0.0433087572,
0.0480177552,
-0.0085648298,
0.0542956777,
0.0347080044,
-0.0436611995,
-0.0200717319,
-0.0028639787,
-0.001057879,
-0.0006255077,
-0.0407515392,
-0.0049015642,
0.0462789126,
-0.0056889085,
0.0149621237,
-0.012498525,
0.0145462565,
-0.0342907384,
-0.0089459093,
-0.0274494682,
-0.004606782,
-0.0153825125,
0.0140095586,
-0.035728354,
-0.015098013,
0.0594757572,
-0.0118452413,
0.0276631024,
-0.0546981581,
-0.0247740727,
-0.0510296412,
-0.0054492159,
-0.0002472466,
0.025474051,
0.0059300149,
0.0117141763,
-0.0540064089,
-0.0559422262,
0.018763436,
-0.0161630809,
0.0897306874,
-0.0320279114,
0.0150179788,
-0.0404933244,
-0.0146900378,
-0.0274059363,
-0.0244197976,
-0.0664126426,
0.0621977933,
0.0142781464,
0.018167045,
-0.0505606793,
0.0366676226,
0.0403185263,
0.0450242311,
-0.0324371345,
-0.0338625945,
0.0112129683,
0.0562691912,
0.0738037378,
0.0147508234,
0.0450925902,
-0.0575854219,
0.024619922,
0.0459761843,
0.0034186384,
-0.0025737339,
-0.0152488137,
-0.0293333307,
-0.0026848121,
-0.0593335107,
0.0133799473,
-0.0119042825,
0.0380241834,
-0.0419068187,
0.0058703455,
0.1026827544,
0.001173335,
-0.0442733206,
-0.0233662464,
0.0103602316,
0.0344682671,
-0.0028305643,
-0.0068047871,
-0.0383322909,
-0.0368208103,
-0.0068922956,
0.0479089953,
0.0209316034,
-0.0044187931,
0.0019510323,
-0.0882655606,
0.0028460349,
0.0219434556,
-0.0731073096,
-0.0313089564,
-0.0487128347,
0.028953461,
-0.0649388656,
0.0477175117,
0.0206796415,
-0.0461476967,
0.0104255062,
0.0215641391,
-0.0668225586,
-0.011912521,
-0.03552901,
-0.0494779386,
0.0219625924,
0.0691847429,
0.0249865409,
-0.0076135229,
0.0341064818,
0.0481205434,
-0.043168474,
0.0072784452,
0.0020105301,
0.1290465593,
-0.005450699,
0.0346415527,
-0.0269657597,
0.0237699021,
0.0222363472,
0.0003812371,
-0.015665587,
-0.0053568743,
0.0394912027,
-0.0259546842,
-0.049609568,
0.0471610241,
-0.0431664735,
0.0709583834,
0.0457834788,
-0.0163538139,
-0.0246938318,
-0.0293901693,
-0.0012542142,
-0.0537644699,
-0.0444193445,
0.0141231641,
-0.0346118063,
0.0057280129,
-0.0672973692,
-0.0764019117,
-0.0024494771,
-0.0441314019,
-0.0178365968,
-0.0139248101,
-0.0270426087,
0.0087403459,
-0.0059602363,
0.0169810206,
-0.0454271771,
0.0015666774,
-0.0576241687,
0.0092175286,
0.0611668378,
-0.0418737046,
-0.0193475187,
0.0215401426,
-0.0573043674,
-0.0360431224,
-0.0321891494,
0.0668446645,
0.0166976936,
0.0610961132,
0.026849417,
-0.0275224373,
0.0520365313,
0.0380113944,
0.0200999063,
0.0113509037,
0.034598127,
0.0096743507,
-0.0170702394,
0.0013464786,
-0.066706717,
0.0411576927,
-0.0018390607,
0.0305992719,
-0.038404271,
-0.0471497029,
0.0147446161,
0.0361725725,
0.0114370035,
-0.0271773152,
0.0204441193,
-0.0326336026,
-0.0238636155,
0.0060136337,
-0.0067582275,
-0.0365309939,
0.0568263233,
-0.0128679555,
0.0208560992,
-0.0168858636,
0.0787138268,
-0.0091573596,
0.0421938449,
-0.0176212303,
0.0100694066,
-0.030031139,
-0.0099852225,
-0.0704823583,
-0.0059607262,
-0.0661751553,
-0.0427013785,
-0.0241889879,
0.0012959669,
0.0060195909,
-0.0272927284,
0.0237624794,
0.0104183694,
0.0120571377,
0.0449373685,
-0.0941037759,
0.0034292827,
-0.0842640847,
0.0008204351,
0.0573615655,
-0.0510939062,
0.0873578712,
-0.0113700777,
-0.0110347811,
-0.0325388052,
-0.0016103534,
0.0305418856,
0.021865733,
-0.0386848673,
0.0214843806,
0.0067203715,
-0.0017220963,
0.0892351866,
-0.0263985675,
0.0194822755,
-0.0109266043,
-0.0329672508,
-0.0397548042,
-0.0238125287,
-0.0429477543,
0.0038372539,
0.0153172631,
-0.0335470811,
-0.0551792085,
-0.0334218852,
0.0312393885,
0.0006648658,
0.0151363164,
-0.0365528688,
0.0262451023,
0.0065295515,
0.0172246546,
0.0125568788,
-0.0579668842,
-0.0466097295,
0.034816429,
0.0072006662,
-0.041686859,
-6.0170573e-33,
-0.0168667771,
0.0158842485,
-0.0330200568,
-0.0114346286,
-0.0305766203,
0.0208091997,
-0.0443295538,
-0.0182632953,
-0.0209473856,
0.0117911603,
-0.0170261376,
0.0128531987,
0.0146164559,
0.0407357886,
-0.0091791833,
0.0341259316,
0.0660381913,
-0.0063694553,
-0.0448080152,
0.0170253608,
0.012444254,
0.0127023887,
0.0439977683,
-0.0513918363,
0.0194063745,
0.0091082267,
-0.0195232872,
-0.010398237,
0.0569283515,
0.0443816371,
-0.0113322362,
0.0366063341,
0.0389688984,
-0.0513378046,
-0.057906229,
-0.0147774704,
-0.0882061496,
-0.0158494115,
0.0292805992,
-0.0526824631,
-0.046206262,
-0.0406889543,
0.043100059,
-0.0137216514,
-0.0052392865,
-0.0542926602,
0.0653219074,
-0.0751445442,
-0.0546820387,
-0.0578309186,
-0.0087427851,
0.0472923964,
-0.0154749174,
-0.0087258695,
0.0505907163,
0.0464050807,
-0.0078029446,
0.0150454594,
-0.0207542703,
0.0337230265,
0.0499320626,
0.0298520178,
0.0265745167,
0.0385893472,
-0.0067586941,
0.0535391718,
-0.0209165551,
0.0111819385,
0.0106401443,
-0.0288511142,
-0.0154197505,
0.0201781448,
0.0452832617,
0.0562910065,
0.0366864465,
0.025151236,
-0.041750975,
0.083533287,
-0.0241923463,
0.0253270008,
0.0336477682,
-0.0005318308,
0.0117853396,
-0.0100501869,
-0.0485205017,
-0.0008186159,
-0.0109966546,
0.0010932056,
-0.020078402,
0.03696087,
-0.033766076,
-0.0287282951,
0.0195635166,
-0.0252042562,
0.0063390671,
0.0469283052,
-0.0226197708,
0.0133811636,
0.026757678,
-0.0476883277,
-0.057618808,
0.0369943455,
0.0199920386,
0.0016029772,
-0.0172239728,
-0.0088746734,
0.0921223462,
-0.0038908788,
-0.0348325185,
0.0200316422,
0.0093474872,
0.0231084488,
-0.0122301709,
-0.0079429848,
-0.0084384987,
-0.0150911175,
0.0133598605,
0.0442519337,
-0.0102606332,
0.0186089333,
-0.0007111606,
0.0115326038,
0.0243994277,
0.0390295722,
-0.0133292694,
0.0260242689,
-0.018210711,
0.0346222036,
0.0521570928,
-0.033619266,
-0.0261836685,
-0.0025934286,
2.315e-7,
0.0571353547,
0.0261370745,
0.0478620604,
0.0218978766,
-0.0323576406,
0.0372184925,
0.022978764,
0.0228386577,
0.049736701,
0.0317264348,
0.0372386798,
0.0252301861,
0.0848602355,
0.0304092914,
-0.0718393177,
-0.0217211284,
-0.1077673063,
-0.0226042159,
0.0092458855,
-0.0268560778,
0.0362315625,
0.0777169541,
-0.030286856,
-0.0242443904,
-0.0088754334,
-0.0415412523,
0.0579639859,
-0.0488149896,
-0.017161103,
0.013876725,
0.0615857169,
0.0148129547,
0.0014141257,
-0.0291716363,
-0.0126026161,
-0.0250094589,
0.05620021,
0.0399187617,
0.0435334295,
-0.0103708301,
0.0322489068,
-0.0109954365,
0.0474335924,
0.0153367957,
0.038978748,
-0.0596357435,
0.000529197,
-0.0435307138,
-0.0576467291,
0.0144657595,
0.0159105323,
-0.0075133881,
-0.0293014403,
0.0509302653,
-0.024225425,
0.0140254591,
-0.0009016946,
-0.0495949984,
-0.0637139454,
0.0376787558,
0.0095987786,
-0.0384579375,
-0.0080462089,
-0.0292518903,
-0.0117728319,
-0.0689977556,
0.0069165211,
1.989080164e-34,
0.1073062718,
-0.0356699377,
-0.0286014825,
0.0052815541,
0.0102039911,
-0.0058546755,
-0.0224609766,
-0.015550687,
0.0022831711,
-0.0761344954,
0.0072982181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14237v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14237v1 | HOP, UNION, GENERATE: Explainable Multi-hop Reasoning without Rationale Supervision | 2023-05-23T16:53:49 | 2023-05-23T16:53:49 | Wenting Zhao, Justin T. Chiu, Claire Cardie, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Explainable multi-hop question answering (QA) not only predicts answers but
also identifies rationales, i. e. subsets of input sentences used to derive the
answers. This problem has been extensively studied under the supervised
setting, where both answer and rationale annotations are given. Because
rationale annotations are expensive to collect and not always available, recent
efforts have been devoted to developing methods that do not rely on supervision
for rationales. However, such methods have limited capacities in modeling
interactions between sentences, let alone reasoning across multiple documents.
This work proposes a principled, probabilistic approach for training
explainable multi-hop QA systems without rationale supervision. Our approach
performs multi-hop reasoning by explicitly modeling rationales as sets,
enabling the model to capture interactions between documents and sentences
within a document. Experimental results show that our approach is more accurate
at selecting rationales than the previous methods, while maintaining similar
accuracy in predicting answers. | [
-0.0172945466,
0.0677608028,
0.0002124089,
0.0212922413,
-0.0185893849,
0.0270876642,
0.0369565301,
-0.0175664872,
0.008144848,
-0.0310410969,
0.0044911355,
0.018748302,
-0.0365678854,
0.0168202538,
0.0008483161,
-0.0245436002,
0.0492123105,
-0.0193305779,
-0.0089459894,
-0.0052553928,
-0.002699719,
0.0745231509,
-0.0238665212,
0.0262433309,
0.0052712578,
-0.0429388471,
-0.0343366973,
-0.0377536826,
0.0078271087,
0.0230365172,
-0.0036563219,
0.0341752134,
0.0380732343,
-0.031033257,
0.0000018351,
-0.0157814845,
-0.0573850833,
0.0069658286,
-0.0354929715,
-0.0242765043,
-0.0688000172,
0.0050238543,
0.0329773426,
0.0061122868,
-0.0083671464,
0.0786839202,
0.0215317588,
0.0828470364,
0.0655725077,
0.0376557522,
-0.0019287574,
-0.0557520352,
-0.0086086765,
0.0055303066,
0.0346697867,
-0.0407303236,
-0.0063228616,
0.0557642058,
0.017684333,
0.0100986362,
-0.002977116,
-0.0167595204,
0.0231975745,
-0.0504066236,
0.0065911636,
-0.0027476647,
0.0265999995,
-0.0058062328,
0.0145692565,
0.0960598961,
0.0076693813,
-0.0352866277,
0.027772421,
-0.0137534644,
-0.0183392242,
0.0395900607,
-0.0558645576,
0.026501447,
-0.0123421215,
0.0159152523,
0.0089092851,
0.0182488486,
0.0333861969,
0.0226429943,
-0.0000536617,
0.0585380048,
-0.0160661433,
0.0095036486,
0.0023279074,
0.0132368943,
-0.0142146787,
-0.051545199,
-0.0107190097,
0.0749858767,
-0.0344834924,
0.0385391153,
0.0215269793,
0.0236808229,
0.0235221144,
0.0096724024,
-0.0288724415,
0.0163425915,
0.0189817715,
0.0821689367,
-0.0174833797,
-0.0132424757,
-0.0242396146,
0.0132150128,
-0.0230164174,
-0.0286390651,
-0.0727520883,
-0.0269786324,
-0.0323842652,
0.070749864,
-0.0937713385,
-0.0093312804,
-0.0187015589,
0.0005416665,
-0.0214015134,
-0.0321397856,
-0.0022089712,
0.0473551378,
0.0012442865,
-0.0299596786,
-0.0272222795,
0.0140965898,
-0.1117018014,
0.0263125747,
0.0242260173,
-0.0049355859,
-0.0379860364,
0.0204004012,
0.0308772046,
-0.0180598404,
-0.0211042706,
0.0825371295,
-0.0246793535,
0.0067734923,
-0.0364974216,
-0.0843745768,
0.0196389593,
-0.043167565,
-0.0221299361,
-0.0144765377,
0.0305935051,
-0.0051672435,
-0.0116592897,
-0.0301885847,
-0.0046735029,
0.0402493365,
-0.018219253,
0.083002694,
0.0178078357,
-0.0258427244,
0.0088709649,
0.0147725958,
-0.0528783537,
0.0710593313,
-0.0003057689,
0.0003297344,
0.0633948296,
-0.0048981626,
0.0230261702,
-0.0343321711,
0.0432023816,
-0.0163184106,
0.0207345653,
0.0345167369,
-0.0139316265,
0.0041481089,
0.0089010708,
0.0015071882,
-0.0275467392,
-0.0175839402,
-0.0275959019,
0.0589865744,
0.0152312778,
0.001322826,
0.0418143384,
-0.0035584092,
-0.0060523478,
0.0176781267,
-0.036799822,
0.059008114,
-0.0315631591,
0.0033331625,
0.0139663313,
-0.0134192975,
-0.0297429897,
-0.0464397855,
0.0149808973,
-0.0244793762,
-0.0079749133,
0.0038371654,
0.0534340292,
0.0043516862,
-0.0244383086,
0.0257413108,
0.027280299,
-0.0419940241,
0.0137638496,
-0.0275451131,
0.0834819824,
0.0547287501,
0.0376416631,
-0.0186734982,
-0.0005654921,
-0.0313403457,
0.070947215,
0.0026961307,
0.0212192014,
-0.0533681251,
0.0469515622,
-0.0358688347,
-0.0116722565,
-0.0576036461,
0.0107988892,
0.0215227157,
0.006016531,
-0.00950009,
0.0122893732,
-0.0546874814,
0.0134526379,
0.0386134945,
-0.0417212434,
-0.0360242724,
-0.0026277888,
0.003323582,
0.0257104561,
0.0428440087,
0.0179234277,
0.0291950032,
0.0208815597,
-0.0226820558,
-0.0537532493,
0.0401506536,
-0.0211497974,
-0.034381479,
0.0038407256,
-0.0193355195,
-0.034537483,
-0.0206745714,
-0.0290035326,
-0.0846311674,
0.0101588927,
-0.0223226063,
0.0016891483,
-0.0405741073,
-0.05472859,
0.0301998034,
-0.0228576884,
-0.0439030379,
0.0687000826,
0.0224130638,
0.0052133426,
-0.0133948354,
0.0266469326,
0.0427451767,
-0.0263066161,
0.0478868373,
0.0147287892,
0.0161020886,
0.0001573022,
0.0166790988,
-0.0228754319,
-0.0390370041,
0.0096906247,
-0.0226655211,
0.0014514242,
-0.0157620981,
0.0221676622,
0.0193513725,
-0.0036780653,
0.0280598272,
-0.0313322656,
-0.0625153035,
0.0066231522,
-0.0054807183,
0.0054363701,
0.0554956011,
-0.0072412668,
0.005047041,
-0.0158254188,
-0.0007418254,
-0.0423170589,
0.0690146685,
0.0099694058,
0.0144588938,
-0.0221653637,
-0.0492547974,
-0.0396237783,
0.0244634598,
-0.0108300215,
-0.0101376036,
0.0355839729,
-0.0165795851,
-0.0240004379,
0.0317704156,
0.0108243311,
0.0233968347,
0.0334347859,
0.014025311,
-0.0400572792,
0.026435066,
-0.0410437509,
0.0412327088,
0.0135826943,
-0.0242435932,
0.0020830836,
0.0482397377,
-0.0159718543,
-0.0044194795,
-0.0569851846,
0.0654794499,
0.026665058,
0.0052526342,
-0.0721105784,
-0.0478089862,
0.0250846371,
0.0754661858,
-0.0043771304,
-0.0211144909,
0.0844852328,
0.012041443,
-0.0082178656,
-0.0582506433,
-0.013990798,
-0.0591147169,
0.0651529133,
-0.0439460129,
0.0064469837,
-0.0073889876,
-0.0029480434,
0.0004968877,
-0.0594711229,
0.0404243432,
0.0123677477,
0.030177718,
-0.0663132668,
0.0351551473,
0.0087186061,
-0.0137246754,
-0.0171958022,
-0.0409509912,
-0.0451700166,
0.0080152256,
-0.0375481322,
-0.0105596697,
0.0156859793,
0.0140314149,
0.0278775338,
0.0166173913,
-0.0320956409,
0.0148443533,
-0.0074518314,
0.0510345772,
0.0683928058,
0.0270604286,
0.0135126365,
-0.0255880672,
0.0769938603,
0.0474113934,
0.0261469539,
-0.0343400761,
0.0179796498,
-0.00165968,
-0.0359127,
-0.031300541,
0.0038462828,
-0.0236236136,
0.0777285621,
-0.062959224,
0.0058788182,
0.0791639611,
0.0534011871,
0.005917687,
-0.0022620785,
-0.0363592319,
0.0150966076,
-0.0208533444,
0.0348227434,
-0.054220479,
-0.0612381138,
-0.0334882289,
0.0284315106,
0.0119416313,
-0.035706196,
0.004840327,
-0.0836191028,
0.0051333965,
-0.0164301414,
-0.0609032586,
-0.0365866162,
-0.0534421429,
-0.0141458884,
-0.0190872401,
-0.0313941799,
-0.005172641,
0.0263452101,
0.0236274917,
0.0362919718,
0.0011539595,
0.0219974834,
0.0556911007,
0.012712379,
0.0037681221,
0.0291860811,
0.0314033739,
0.024740627,
-0.0581214279,
0.0168449841,
-0.0781641975,
0.0284471251,
0.0110165384,
0.0395694599,
0.0176872835,
-0.0058150138,
-0.010466109,
0.0874751285,
-0.0611037761,
-0.0454660468,
0.0302154906,
0.0901194662,
-0.0398444496,
-0.0199075956,
-0.0292911436,
0.0309838057,
0.0116105359,
0.0710047409,
0.0262708217,
-0.0106531167,
-0.0730211288,
-0.0456425399,
-0.0022347611,
-0.0975257456,
0.0250492897,
-0.02289824,
0.0037346575,
0.0228526555,
-0.0731148198,
-0.0502471365,
0.0070588039,
0.0569801219,
-0.0370007381,
0.0255860407,
0.0112728961,
0.014601619,
0.0040850616,
0.0393429361,
-0.0194966886,
-0.0071387347,
0.0385626256,
0.002838443,
0.0477732979,
-0.0220804196,
-0.0163088515,
-0.0223172139,
0.0106234932,
-0.0235290378,
-0.0470770933,
0.01385458,
0.0273982212,
0.0581664219,
-0.0373916216,
0.0010538724,
-0.0108163673,
-0.0266631898,
-0.0304115433,
-0.0265101343,
0.0673405007,
0.0214593373,
-0.0179647282,
0.0512159988,
-0.0384342335,
0.026433697,
-0.0325988717,
0.0535263717,
-0.0504197255,
0.0144454781,
0.0331223756,
-0.0385788605,
-0.0191760603,
0.0326686017,
0.0368272401,
-0.0283442587,
0.0174777918,
-0.0445463024,
-0.0153249279,
-0.003912407,
0.03740054,
-0.0092867566,
-0.07402087,
-0.0124445828,
-0.0621962361,
-0.0308286604,
0.014784052,
0.0414547808,
0.0226467103,
0.0199692622,
-0.003359885,
-0.030445816,
-0.020229971,
-0.0230851881,
-0.0039174356,
-0.0192737058,
0.0526236445,
-0.0065517691,
0.0671554804,
0.054071717,
-0.006111742,
-0.0392885581,
-0.0255898368,
-0.0972868726,
-0.0222302508,
0.0243963152,
-0.0073371078,
0.0052900445,
-0.0166874398,
0.0316840746,
0.0156835988,
-0.030869063,
0.0363706984,
0.0475338623,
0.0679915249,
-0.0051705632,
0.0431704186,
0.0348843224,
-0.0222950019,
0.0041517802,
0.0669643804,
-0.046630092,
0.0239386819,
-0.0164708849,
-0.0251446515,
-0.0367128663,
-0.019691024,
-0.0537234023,
0.0500930883,
0.0006854498,
-0.0044399207,
-0.0525522456,
-0.0374164656,
-0.041878473,
0.0107407458,
-0.0172195211,
-0.0145413969,
0.0355521888,
0.0618920773,
0.0438345708,
-0.0339850858,
-0.0484746955,
0.0392255485,
-0.0661699101,
0.0023209886,
-0.0212697238,
-5.787869697e-33,
0.0083577503,
-0.0741022527,
0.013613224,
-0.0353814885,
0.0029136939,
0.0006952063,
-0.0578656867,
-0.0356938727,
-0.0592831038,
0.0409022383,
-0.0017746276,
0.0311574955,
0.0059942058,
0.0175074991,
0.0268095229,
-0.0167508125,
0.0027194938,
0.0081904186,
-0.0277454015,
0.0447460301,
0.0728582889,
-0.0268578921,
-0.0002927986,
-0.0025150224,
0.0263334308,
-0.0160209313,
-0.0252802055,
0.0507651307,
-0.0403775051,
0.0626448244,
-0.008202455,
-0.0031679433,
0.0390789621,
-0.0388340726,
0.0307292733,
0.064407602,
-0.0958379805,
-0.0523265004,
0.0331872478,
-0.0408290215,
-0.0650449321,
-0.0460252054,
0.0076689804,
0.0024140042,
0.0797865391,
-0.013145186,
0.0297011789,
-0.0147724357,
-0.0233858116,
-0.0068263113,
-0.0283243582,
0.0324849524,
-0.0659687296,
-0.0170969944,
-0.0487687066,
0.0567494668,
0.0104859285,
0.048221685,
-0.0064340327,
-0.0190487355,
0.0118239671,
-0.0161290783,
0.0275758617,
-0.0353347771,
-0.0245529748,
0.0641085207,
-0.0072344113,
-0.0059889639,
-0.0759774297,
0.0301538222,
-0.0658423826,
0.0199538078,
0.0839440003,
0.0341454707,
0.0320180394,
0.0449522361,
-0.1132851169,
0.0342818163,
0.0198773667,
0.0195984282,
0.0170315299,
-0.0042082728,
-0.0106719276,
-0.0110676568,
-0.0284644887,
0.0059049758,
-0.0137638971,
-0.0393033326,
0.0040815254,
-0.0328192301,
-0.0539172962,
0.0129378363,
-0.0109365331,
-0.0415594578,
0.0145897362,
0.0464911275,
-0.0071484488,
0.0048177205,
0.0108779091,
0.0173759591,
-0.0169558302,
0.0043490031,
0.0094461301,
0.0109437136,
0.0183161814,
0.0162073597,
0.042112451,
-0.0387801863,
-0.0384707041,
-0.0042503565,
-0.05112027,
0.0154012302,
-0.0543948859,
0.0044355183,
0.0318690054,
0.0364578627,
-0.0051455828,
0.0351466611,
-0.0229568072,
0.0333936885,
0.0055379616,
-0.0139366426,
-0.0191632546,
0.0200557131,
-0.0103681246,
-0.018311521,
0.0067683435,
0.0120096188,
0.0166564677,
-0.0468673855,
0.0069033713,
0.0484797731,
2.393e-7,
0.0438250937,
-0.0101048062,
0.0539513901,
-0.0218794886,
0.034792006,
0.0334017351,
0.0333043784,
-0.0223618094,
-0.018589532,
-0.0380387641,
-0.010831777,
0.0184416678,
0.0310786217,
0.0460953936,
-0.068058759,
-0.0182632226,
-0.0237565525,
-0.0559661984,
-0.0453002416,
-0.020461686,
0.0854993612,
0.0233889688,
0.0205433313,
-0.0184711777,
-0.013762204,
0.0057734246,
0.0229766276,
0.0148773417,
-0.0199200884,
0.011418689,
0.0408441499,
-0.040403679,
0.0173412319,
0.0224890243,
-0.0370066836,
0.0311646555,
-0.0206909776,
0.0630258247,
-0.0057599619,
-0.0611419417,
-0.0246666018,
-0.0540194437,
0.0604052246,
-0.0214846916,
0.1110868752,
-0.0229050666,
-0.042109523,
-0.0125794029,
-0.0376879051,
-0.0197644681,
-0.0255046785,
0.0037855015,
-0.0167076495,
0.0227352101,
-0.0158274453,
-0.0267499145,
0.0561979413,
-0.0948669612,
-0.0285682213,
0.028080523,
-0.0058591827,
0.0063246349,
0.0178379938,
-0.0115345465,
0.0571657866,
-0.0595528781,
-0.0417744853,
1.737783579e-34,
0.0254819319,
-0.0124957738,
0.0227043778,
0.0316238403,
0.0646024421,
-0.0092036026,
-0.0104865544,
-0.0138052069,
0.0723228827,
-0.0470593199,
-0.0040686782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14235v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14235v2 | Multilingual Large Language Models Are Not (Yet) Code-Switchers | 2023-05-23T16:50:48 | 2023-10-23T15:17:59 | Ruochen Zhang, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Jan Christian Blaise Cruz, Genta Indra Winata, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently shown great
capabilities in a wide range of tasks, exhibiting state-of-the-art performance
through zero-shot or few-shot prompting methods. While there have been
extensive studies on their abilities in monolingual tasks, the investigation of
their potential in the context of code-switching (CSW), the practice of
alternating languages within an utterance, remains relatively uncharted. In
this paper, we provide a comprehensive empirical analysis of various
multilingual LLMs, benchmarking their performance across four tasks: sentiment
analysis, machine translation, summarization and word-level language
identification. Our results indicate that despite multilingual LLMs exhibiting
promising outcomes in certain tasks using zero or few-shot prompting, they
still underperform in comparison to fine-tuned models of much smaller scales.
We argue that current "multilingualism" in LLMs does not inherently imply
proficiency with code-switching texts, calling for future research to bridge
this discrepancy. | [
0.017683886,
0.0622138232,
0.0081916722,
0.0687986761,
-0.0583971441,
0.0447682254,
0.0201756489,
-0.0220778007,
0.0235238802,
-0.0285112951,
-0.0451527275,
-0.0514211655,
-0.0024774356,
0.0109469071,
0.0238195807,
-0.0065311594,
0.0357463621,
-0.0591447242,
-0.0131334541,
-0.0264735986,
0.0306207426,
0.0050497381,
0.0178753622,
0.0256285369,
0.0216599852,
-0.0263465904,
0.0360526405,
0.0067197499,
0.0087718517,
-0.0159199312,
0.0096073234,
0.0319168009,
0.0008470357,
0.0464171804,
0.0000018906,
-0.0308549087,
-0.0295261834,
-0.0226935148,
0.002255775,
0.0103767486,
0.0651164725,
-0.075455904,
0.0046575954,
0.0238857418,
-0.0160080791,
-0.0207592119,
0.0694394484,
-0.0019583006,
0.0467371643,
0.0768107399,
-0.0145829665,
-0.0484214351,
-0.0076273177,
-0.039770294,
-0.0397514701,
-0.0320868939,
0.019770978,
-0.015193264,
-0.0023844799,
-0.0139958002,
-0.0221189838,
0.0683234856,
0.01590042,
-0.0085118255,
-0.0473363139,
0.0006409473,
-0.0412942804,
-0.0004546325,
-0.0073268847,
0.0493697263,
-0.0602281615,
-0.0302249007,
0.0091661522,
0.0046017398,
-0.0411843061,
-0.0502271503,
-0.0287927762,
0.0369015224,
0.0023301437,
0.0239288136,
0.0535566062,
0.0142790228,
0.0395506807,
0.0114866961,
-0.0595684871,
0.0328233019,
0.014899848,
-0.0318367481,
-0.0030062099,
0.0436716042,
0.0132309385,
-0.0521658547,
0.0031210622,
0.0091446191,
-0.0532103181,
0.0186888203,
-0.0200060736,
-0.0444575511,
0.0058094766,
-0.0463937297,
0.025094863,
0.0225602165,
-0.0544734113,
0.0777882561,
-0.0249537583,
0.0350470431,
-0.0159465559,
-0.0244092681,
-0.0429211892,
-0.0433318391,
-0.0104237357,
0.0010175855,
-0.0152546437,
0.0096173827,
-0.0165723823,
-0.0041750073,
-0.0000173499,
0.0270617139,
-0.001557073,
0.009809888,
-0.0294755679,
-0.0522900969,
0.0165079702,
0.0061914506,
0.054551255,
0.0733272955,
-0.0253843926,
-0.0201956015,
-0.0281713326,
-0.0704929158,
-0.0057539484,
0.0519227348,
-0.0314619914,
-0.0206417963,
0.0181050301,
0.054941345,
-0.0224731658,
-0.0206522234,
-0.0236191135,
0.0019801811,
-0.0317920931,
-0.0857212245,
0.0025095765,
-0.0910390541,
0.0389057398,
0.0382446572,
0.0310899615,
-0.022034999,
0.0086291507,
-0.0172319915,
-0.0284358338,
0.0542440079,
-0.0090012196,
0.0202208776,
0.0041299411,
-0.0301169828,
-0.012671574,
0.1107859686,
0.0072419639,
-0.0076847281,
0.0813516751,
-0.0217293445,
0.0007692793,
0.0901145712,
-0.0418117046,
0.0300929323,
-0.0312066767,
-0.0201169811,
0.0282595512,
-0.0164395198,
0.0166803338,
0.0592998974,
-0.0273566432,
-0.0088581787,
0.0411771871,
0.0240180772,
-0.0280451328,
0.0221011713,
0.0411101021,
-0.0052124932,
0.0025552216,
0.0417371355,
-0.0006227414,
0.0231423378,
-0.0127167944,
0.0064328192,
0.0503992178,
0.0356373675,
-0.039436195,
-0.0207886286,
-0.0138771357,
-0.047271736,
0.0389282666,
0.0118371444,
0.0462938808,
-0.0272268876,
-0.0196823329,
0.0042424505,
0.0400803164,
-0.0413698032,
0.0082796775,
-0.0525451675,
0.00775608,
0.074073337,
0.000031079,
0.0047799111,
-0.0003982085,
-0.0433846302,
0.0296701528,
0.0555896945,
0.0572302677,
-0.0160251129,
0.0301720016,
-0.0384418741,
0.0269386154,
-0.0151372468,
0.0043946458,
0.0477579869,
-0.0074516283,
0.0318624899,
-0.0267975368,
0.0129978443,
-0.0280973595,
-0.0107858246,
-0.061686594,
0.0277265441,
0.0374972709,
-0.0103739044,
0.0131905889,
0.0180201381,
-0.0304513108,
0.0002739626,
0.0007192943,
-0.0630380958,
-0.0216407701,
0.0236584451,
-0.0176938195,
-0.0703344569,
0.0180752669,
-0.0087769777,
-0.0063163443,
0.0242776982,
-0.0257972032,
-0.0502463691,
0.0344285816,
-0.0083954437,
0.0272410195,
-0.0221302975,
0.0261781942,
-0.024463173,
0.0185218211,
0.0084087178,
0.025412621,
-0.0005568436,
0.0506981015,
0.0235113744,
-0.0161748547,
0.0162976608,
-0.0215449668,
-0.0780771747,
0.0532931536,
0.0128770024,
0.0224693399,
0.0343152918,
0.0192728639,
0.005923877,
-0.0633405149,
-0.1066383868,
0.0027908066,
-0.0508250073,
0.0218878724,
0.0303966794,
0.0062459656,
-0.0217123758,
-0.0137744313,
-0.0329373665,
-0.0182833895,
0.0246008243,
0.0493128747,
0.0169133414,
-0.0090037538,
0.0251761619,
-0.047256127,
-0.0171291903,
0.0118017476,
0.0500477962,
-0.0328592993,
-0.0490436964,
-0.0506417975,
0.0279015712,
-0.0368812308,
0.0029388804,
-0.0122811664,
-0.0342963524,
0.0077431509,
-0.014385445,
0.0673583969,
0.0459568687,
-0.0091322111,
-0.0175769664,
0.0472171977,
-0.0192048475,
-0.0340776034,
-0.0005178433,
0.0040138992,
-0.0360469632,
-0.0271602347,
-0.0233831108,
0.0099781053,
0.0584887005,
0.0094336243,
-0.0061916918,
-0.040380802,
-0.023622537,
-0.0330968797,
-0.0004477589,
0.0030766872,
0.0056200065,
-0.0032846425,
0.0300578922,
-0.0076675452,
-0.021173846,
0.0601500161,
-0.0245585982,
-0.016219534,
-0.0586747304,
-0.0220496524,
-0.0524626002,
0.026235776,
-0.0135448705,
0.026103694,
-0.0195647515,
0.0046671294,
-0.0089451298,
-0.028546948,
-0.0287621524,
-0.0230228994,
0.0788506344,
-0.0343206339,
0.008923064,
0.0021758317,
-0.0724740475,
-0.0021713937,
-0.053645961,
-0.0615814403,
-0.0014970565,
0.0381765626,
-0.02491289,
-0.0048154918,
0.0146594774,
0.0436497852,
0.0309489537,
-0.0178959481,
0.0203853734,
0.0166116748,
0.0383224823,
0.0299235787,
-0.0251546539,
0.0211855248,
-0.039415352,
0.0376642272,
0.0100563914,
0.015517652,
0.0298652947,
-0.0169728734,
-0.0167609062,
0.0331710018,
0.0045369756,
-0.0397981368,
-0.0405701846,
0.0483905114,
-0.0345336609,
0.0254417434,
0.1063218564,
0.0167332571,
-0.1063182428,
-0.0107896728,
-0.0287558474,
0.019853767,
0.0322388411,
0.0117381671,
-0.0903646201,
-0.0395039245,
-0.0232367683,
0.0070543112,
0.0061919149,
-0.0093712853,
-0.0117677785,
-0.1095909923,
-0.0106174275,
0.0062317299,
-0.0632993728,
-0.046398934,
-0.0133806942,
-0.0071283136,
-0.0324524269,
-0.011919314,
-0.0198857803,
-0.003030573,
-0.0169165786,
0.0096137924,
-0.0192076229,
-0.0308940038,
0.0146915615,
-0.0399697237,
0.0387811214,
0.0877372846,
0.0156734399,
-0.0303609986,
0.0134754954,
0.0131625915,
-0.0290769879,
-0.0283338074,
-0.0284584891,
0.0458018743,
-0.0122554256,
-0.0385109596,
0.0221110303,
0.0031086951,
-0.0218722187,
0.0197250918,
0.0207660608,
0.0424910374,
0.0289367139,
-0.0450024381,
0.021268446,
0.0167334192,
0.0218229312,
0.0695145875,
0.0157916658,
-0.0835028812,
-0.0226400942,
-0.038896203,
0.0014233243,
-0.0517642722,
0.001879792,
-0.0160499513,
0.0103479987,
-0.037804544,
-0.0707266182,
-0.0514948107,
0.0118990345,
-0.0044702338,
-0.0010308553,
0.0421884134,
-0.0150492145,
-0.0132262111,
0.00447533,
-0.0242598075,
-0.0197449811,
0.0254184641,
-0.0760135278,
-0.0076258238,
0.0864586532,
-0.0348308645,
0.0034117887,
-0.0101160984,
-0.1143915504,
-0.0594632477,
-0.0203276072,
0.0271660946,
0.0113621345,
0.0522178635,
-0.0136049995,
-0.0556044392,
-0.0302426983,
0.0315267071,
-0.0089775529,
0.0429468453,
0.0536883622,
0.0682107434,
-0.017977979,
0.0630372912,
-0.0327773616,
0.0027909488,
0.0023942785,
0.0230238456,
-0.0692514926,
-0.0386644676,
-0.0195951331,
0.0000584377,
0.0035872483,
-0.0037486998,
-0.0118538653,
-0.0204785243,
-0.001193294,
0.017940443,
-0.0202343538,
-0.0346773118,
-0.0141234826,
0.0299838893,
-0.0127516417,
-0.0311423186,
0.0267034434,
-0.0095975967,
0.0190543961,
-0.013402272,
0.0576556548,
0.0365378521,
-0.000728337,
0.0166137479,
0.0214545839,
-0.0415790863,
0.0305035077,
0.0226246417,
-0.0037610778,
-0.0335943252,
0.0477202572,
0.0163401458,
-0.0223595761,
0.0248495061,
0.0140766604,
-0.0407183655,
-0.0191411357,
0.0392517708,
0.014351801,
0.082511805,
-0.0029964312,
0.101854682,
0.0135263372,
-0.0143249147,
-0.0505119711,
0.0176796615,
0.0051112804,
-0.0306706131,
0.0143025815,
-0.0013192538,
-0.017368,
0.0459366217,
0.0944024175,
-0.0359755568,
0.0165202711,
0.0372903012,
0.0240238588,
-0.0204721205,
0.0060895481,
0.0347477943,
-0.021626275,
0.0052769198,
0.0113057289,
-0.0510072969,
-0.0528845452,
0.0565756969,
-0.0257426109,
0.0169216245,
-0.0173851792,
-0.0171041675,
0.098729834,
0.0205054712,
0.0555933937,
-0.0746268705,
-0.0007946347,
0.0510282628,
-0.0266514346,
-0.0162995141,
-6.310680361e-33,
0.0147217261,
0.0107308999,
-0.0139399646,
-0.0169490371,
0.016248282,
-0.0093106097,
-0.0555370301,
0.0295971278,
-0.0289872419,
-0.0131275738,
-0.0068447897,
-0.0139779653,
0.0061244094,
0.0177120157,
0.0519301072,
-0.0104971454,
0.044253394,
0.0094418311,
0.000013773,
0.0280993003,
0.0336629525,
0.0114005059,
0.0611883029,
-0.0347047411,
0.0487979352,
-0.0502752438,
-0.007974999,
0.0108975377,
0.0201258585,
0.0517514423,
-0.0159822162,
0.0402393155,
0.0377325714,
-0.0120626297,
-0.0219128504,
0.0108073037,
-0.0168693289,
-0.0115247713,
0.0413709655,
0.0081312768,
0.0085455012,
-0.0506971367,
0.0117190247,
-0.0338105038,
-0.0100066112,
-0.0075451415,
0.0165573172,
-0.0221269522,
0.0001402219,
-0.0366527103,
-0.0711573288,
0.0405448042,
-0.0074887495,
-0.0154380715,
0.0311499797,
0.078786239,
-0.0118433777,
0.0489953458,
-0.0640379936,
0.0353708193,
-0.0024363194,
0.008543347,
0.0343943946,
0.0069221766,
-0.0081066238,
0.0440171845,
0.0458854437,
0.0184864607,
0.029197095,
0.0250894651,
0.0309801437,
-0.0383594297,
0.056287311,
0.0665698946,
0.0238902494,
-0.0033742278,
-0.0552875437,
-0.0340019017,
0.0497620143,
-0.008709725,
0.0657429397,
0.0002212148,
-0.0193953589,
-0.037573237,
-0.0137365954,
-0.069875069,
-0.0385420062,
-0.036706429,
0.0184755549,
0.0027715086,
-0.003876481,
-0.0075476542,
0.090552628,
-0.0380743891,
-0.0330275856,
0.0650649071,
-0.030968897,
0.0504691191,
0.0273964703,
0.0629736334,
-0.0766604021,
-0.0074203089,
-0.0119235134,
-0.000607039,
0.0118987802,
0.0248416178,
0.0635717362,
0.019331174,
-0.0783070326,
-0.0036918693,
-0.0013162796,
0.027102299,
-0.0311242584,
0.0574017204,
0.0114772376,
0.0007825767,
0.0021952491,
0.0874183625,
0.0109785665,
-0.0150385685,
-0.0301620979,
-0.027830597,
-0.0275926925,
0.0239319969,
-0.0455185436,
0.0156285912,
-0.0208098795,
0.0372096375,
0.0049013696,
-0.043374531,
0.003448463,
0.0148901064,
2.59e-7,
0.0404923782,
0.0344594344,
-0.015353417,
0.0046956548,
0.0215614717,
0.0231505856,
-0.0646717325,
-0.007293195,
0.0335645676,
0.0368812233,
-0.0289032198,
0.0395349488,
0.0694202408,
0.022745356,
-0.1002973169,
0.0120445443,
-0.0461774841,
0.0252813697,
-0.020959571,
0.010467317,
0.0445832908,
0.1353491247,
-0.0127634136,
0.0230487157,
-0.0236677695,
-0.0389097482,
0.0596159473,
-0.0299826134,
-0.0412215255,
-0.0099718887,
-0.0230716728,
0.0182258468,
-0.0190910473,
-0.0118539538,
0.0059201508,
0.0000466653,
0.0455596372,
0.0750841573,
0.0346632749,
-0.0177600328,
0.0230499133,
-0.0042682225,
-0.0405938849,
-0.0454753377,
0.0902181342,
-0.0291484874,
-0.0020231819,
-0.0632627532,
0.0086881854,
0.0110859973,
0.0324117243,
-0.0578131452,
-0.0618707389,
0.0558835305,
0.0155267399,
-0.0207589008,
-0.0173595678,
-0.0341078751,
-0.0343844891,
0.0023694211,
-0.0125209177,
-0.0327906124,
-0.0039429232,
0.0018149706,
0.0074953255,
-0.0417566858,
0.0399505347,
2.249293287e-34,
0.0874137953,
-0.0242703501,
-0.0163299162,
0.016445756,
0.0169501938,
-0.0261882748,
-0.0596482083,
0.0166499689,
-0.0197080933,
-0.0491341874,
-0.0021981657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14233v1 | Enhancing Chat Language Models by Scaling High-quality Instructional Conversations | 2023-05-23T16:49:14 | 2023-05-23T16:49:14 | Ning Ding, Yulin Chen, Bokai Xu, Yujia Qin, Zhi Zheng, Shengding Hu, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Bowen Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fine-tuning on instruction data has been widely validated as an effective
practice for implementing chat language models like ChatGPT. Scaling the
diversity and quality of such data, although straightforward, stands a great
chance of leading to improved performance. This paper aims to improve the upper
bound of open-source models further. We first provide a systematically
designed, diverse, informative, large-scale dataset of instructional
conversations, UltraChat, which does not involve human queries. Our objective
is to capture the breadth of interactions that a human might have with an AI
assistant and employs a comprehensive framework to generate multi-turn
conversation iteratively. UltraChat contains 1.5 million high-quality
multi-turn dialogues and covers a wide range of topics and instructions. Our
statistical analysis of UltraChat reveals its superiority in various key
metrics, including scale, average length, diversity, coherence, etc.,
solidifying its position as a leading open-source dataset. Building upon
UltraChat, we fine-tune a LLaMA model to create a powerful conversational
model, UltraLLaMA. Our evaluations indicate that UltraLLaMA consistently
outperforms other open-source models, including Vicuna, the previously
recognized state-of-the-art open-source model. The dataset and the model will
be publicly released\footnote{\url{https://github.com/thunlp/UltraChat}}. | [
0.0520855822,
0.0278933402,
-0.0231406018,
0.0315865465,
-0.019333357,
-0.0053517148,
-0.0004367864,
-0.0436164364,
0.0323052667,
-0.0468942039,
-0.058756806,
-0.0363984965,
0.0129303942,
0.0552333705,
0.0193207841,
-0.0735051557,
0.0131885335,
-0.0260134749,
0.0062082168,
0.0017237952,
0.0265171584,
0.0035551905,
-0.0279218946,
0.063425459,
-0.0061261184,
-0.0330004878,
-0.0563452542,
0.0069231447,
-0.0282249525,
-0.0073707066,
0.0332332179,
0.0525173843,
0.0034645665,
0.005919992,
0.0000019966,
-0.0204277281,
0.0045325304,
-0.0456832498,
-0.0353800729,
0.0262720045,
0.0262699015,
0.0147683332,
-0.0144455228,
0.0447286479,
-0.0434594341,
0.0375279374,
0.0308065452,
0.0063087204,
0.0918230116,
0.0708831325,
-0.0029624579,
-0.0039241943,
0.0398187302,
-0.0099024763,
0.006247655,
-0.0571586266,
-0.0124821346,
0.0493934304,
0.0361692868,
0.0305627212,
-0.0283299927,
0.0334327556,
0.0285806898,
-0.0576765351,
0.006638844,
0.0296514947,
-0.0506105758,
-0.0224900898,
-0.0166291017,
0.1304362714,
-0.0011307764,
0.0104401028,
0.0067993053,
0.0230131112,
0.0323140174,
-0.051908385,
-0.0988286585,
0.0183709208,
0.0081097148,
-0.0025513307,
-0.0040389048,
0.0050323373,
-0.0236790366,
0.0056611323,
0.0115689645,
-0.0079782661,
-0.0100570051,
-0.0142685492,
-0.0367521122,
-0.0069370759,
-0.0092895571,
-0.053249836,
0.0243161265,
0.050500486,
-0.0633664206,
0.0361535251,
-0.041483704,
0.034576714,
0.0283218604,
-0.0322236978,
0.0259116534,
0.0545367934,
-0.0287172608,
0.0390531309,
0.0373567306,
0.0527934842,
0.0132598188,
0.012888466,
-0.0382411852,
-0.0136481458,
-0.0412065424,
0.0075497688,
-0.04284871,
0.0297714807,
-0.0365842022,
-0.0341800787,
-0.0396555774,
0.0607136413,
0.0244843997,
0.0235270951,
0.0310047865,
0.0032159619,
-0.0346876681,
0.0086579835,
0.0150681445,
0.0306748897,
-0.032031782,
0.0091233263,
0.0291972384,
-0.0970635042,
-0.0055332161,
0.0212195348,
-0.0072857044,
0.0071100504,
-0.0130625004,
0.0673533827,
-0.0167278815,
-0.0422704667,
-0.0030382499,
-0.0249949321,
-0.0088559492,
-0.059102159,
-0.0057844841,
-0.0350890718,
0.064839229,
-0.0176684204,
0.0030956373,
0.0130095361,
0.0086001838,
0.0399744511,
-0.0221349392,
0.0440340638,
-0.0067860265,
0.0367258117,
0.0459221005,
0.0287436452,
-0.0299568381,
0.0693261623,
0.0627381727,
0.0277493913,
0.0546442419,
-0.0306851119,
0.0160011128,
0.0465523936,
0.017534636,
-0.0117745586,
0.0316739939,
0.0220918562,
-0.0249312166,
0.0467465185,
-0.0194893777,
0.0610844605,
-0.0367407799,
-0.0315056928,
0.069470562,
0.0495453142,
-0.0195367187,
0.0291113146,
0.0366042033,
0.0525209419,
0.0337081291,
0.0163190588,
-0.0505978949,
0.0387606695,
0.0044196933,
-0.0098494589,
0.0531779304,
0.0209040269,
-0.0541632883,
-0.0713142604,
0.0162331872,
-0.0280134231,
-0.0111620203,
0.0028365771,
0.0149322441,
0.0029339411,
-0.0680002421,
0.0303774141,
0.0438924506,
-0.0404253416,
-0.0106633501,
-0.0505250357,
0.0425400138,
0.1028151065,
0.0875957608,
-0.0190844387,
-0.0705437288,
-0.0097333072,
0.0402919017,
0.0330618285,
0.0193607584,
-0.0387784019,
0.0239875671,
-0.0862960964,
0.0027652082,
-0.0062675243,
-0.0080906628,
0.0096178241,
0.0256646536,
-0.0144715058,
-0.0019482851,
-0.0274040177,
-0.0166764781,
0.0134415012,
-0.0446861871,
-0.0268813837,
-0.0026787061,
-0.0080646565,
0.0222306419,
0.0289684627,
0.005231834,
-0.0020834131,
0.0158823654,
-0.0025073001,
-0.0079246331,
0.0090118768,
-0.080250755,
-0.0628451556,
0.0470758229,
-0.0359002315,
-0.0041946536,
0.0188352298,
-0.0410254896,
-0.0376622975,
0.0279476997,
-0.0299665239,
0.0262946542,
-0.0061150524,
0.0284355823,
0.0406782813,
0.0295635816,
0.0025961557,
0.0124602327,
-0.0045484868,
-0.0142170265,
0.0151486192,
0.0121489046,
0.0064380155,
-0.0700101778,
0.0139516173,
0.0318558179,
-0.0313694514,
0.0103989923,
-0.0056735934,
0.0392251872,
-0.0745929256,
-0.0579169206,
-0.1228410676,
0.0285132732,
-0.005926521,
-0.0013272822,
0.0284090526,
0.0225373022,
-0.0178982243,
-0.0267464425,
-0.0497191735,
-0.0007454258,
0.03463066,
0.0123520102,
0.0253082141,
-0.0097434688,
-0.0177340601,
-0.0906247124,
-0.0220559519,
0.0109079406,
0.0260610338,
0.0085324571,
0.0287124645,
-0.019615408,
0.0013356928,
-0.0350542478,
0.0256657377,
-0.0288005695,
-0.0696090683,
0.0140600158,
-0.0049379775,
0.034741044,
0.068299666,
0.0410084017,
0.0409894437,
0.0000740475,
-0.0261822268,
-0.0503150523,
0.0348101184,
-0.0087043289,
-0.0266963076,
-0.0167442542,
-0.0323853306,
-0.000827285,
0.035996262,
0.0038148274,
0.0227795858,
-0.0556186214,
-0.0102679692,
0.0104328413,
-0.0061875442,
-0.0043686475,
-0.0067413724,
-0.0080279447,
-0.0135006458,
-0.0293107126,
-0.0482516102,
0.0609089546,
-0.0392062739,
-0.0158754941,
-0.0480384305,
-0.0252022427,
-0.0422609337,
0.0423748195,
-0.0257275384,
-0.0107542491,
-0.0290925056,
-0.014512674,
-0.0280550085,
0.0044701141,
0.0142938215,
-0.0494270213,
0.0327252708,
-0.0690717921,
-0.0091912383,
0.0346329771,
-0.0294373017,
-0.0599008612,
-0.0116392579,
-0.0120938318,
-0.0033408587,
0.0380454883,
-0.0209745932,
-0.052262459,
-0.0018504614,
-0.0034975316,
0.006612685,
-0.0197649095,
-0.005505417,
-0.0344092473,
0.0343591198,
0.0548240729,
-0.0192686915,
-0.0259070657,
-0.0290163103,
0.0925502181,
0.050570216,
0.0267509297,
-0.0151809743,
0.0131267924,
-0.0220328588,
0.0243383143,
-0.0026300072,
-0.0051985988,
0.0260715485,
0.0658469051,
-0.0215882678,
-0.0299273878,
0.1357055455,
0.0225399788,
-0.0390071832,
0.0050530373,
-0.0298669003,
0.0439227894,
-0.0173531752,
0.0236937888,
-0.0675248802,
-0.0291516259,
-0.0003748413,
0.0399478488,
0.0199070163,
-0.0335180387,
-0.0039598774,
-0.0876770392,
0.0212269276,
0.005706822,
-0.0480492227,
-0.0103712333,
-0.0298774112,
-0.0064487979,
-0.0329916142,
0.0513301715,
-0.0243802276,
-0.0072292956,
0.0065293009,
0.0141666392,
-0.0199347325,
-0.0115066804,
0.0519334562,
-0.0138846152,
0.076471664,
0.0406557247,
0.080763571,
0.0415957868,
0.0178933889,
0.0407973789,
0.0034834915,
-0.0223761275,
0.0044075432,
0.0762322024,
-0.0196672194,
-0.0154453684,
-0.0192693751,
0.0514819399,
-0.0233637951,
-0.0027840389,
0.0438139625,
0.01227812,
-0.0255101714,
0.0092284828,
-0.0301060025,
0.0360336155,
0.0217255373,
0.0881180912,
0.0393216014,
-0.0309398156,
-0.0052056811,
-0.0302774068,
0.0169304926,
-0.0309822131,
0.0011918512,
-0.0037939327,
-0.0094907954,
0.0100293262,
-0.0745674968,
-0.0627168044,
0.024351256,
-0.0100589497,
-0.0195638873,
-0.0222308245,
0.0440146923,
0.0054915575,
0.0219769701,
-0.0011683232,
-0.0497082807,
0.0100987358,
-0.0723773465,
-0.038924288,
0.0368726738,
-0.0404487848,
0.0101521276,
0.0432989225,
-0.0756557286,
-0.0688133463,
-0.0025503226,
0.0628357977,
0.0170969944,
0.0572397709,
-0.0099102715,
-0.0078277318,
0.0039784056,
0.0117295301,
-0.0431548581,
-0.0086117554,
0.0259398818,
0.0612503476,
0.0150483213,
0.0433363393,
-0.0334092602,
0.0278817192,
-0.0427092947,
0.0320565253,
-0.0564217865,
-0.085556753,
0.0080402996,
-0.0007618003,
-0.0038911509,
0.0165037215,
0.005731212,
-0.0004945341,
0.0343541354,
-0.0420674607,
-0.0023064569,
-0.0554231331,
-0.0014685276,
0.0169263203,
-0.0316536315,
0.0013292418,
-0.0050105178,
-0.0534723215,
0.0481725782,
-0.0247706212,
0.0163850188,
-0.020268077,
-0.0266877823,
0.0036458685,
-0.0220313184,
-0.013905162,
0.0102287875,
0.0130130574,
0.0406222343,
0.0084035462,
0.078587994,
-0.0019531171,
-0.0208537132,
0.0384021215,
0.050106436,
-0.0523536839,
-0.0380356573,
-0.0102094328,
0.072641246,
0.0286361724,
0.0171282887,
0.0513072275,
-0.0152184721,
0.0324404389,
-0.0188284907,
0.0732760727,
-0.0110176308,
-0.0466804728,
0.0338607356,
0.0145660276,
0.0062593548,
0.0035125017,
0.0921733975,
-0.0241094064,
0.0608857237,
0.0089373067,
0.0076850294,
-0.0489572585,
-0.0221588705,
0.0283420458,
0.0265878867,
0.0091199055,
0.0075925547,
-0.0256546866,
-0.0353267901,
-0.0264965221,
0.0009417039,
0.0126119601,
-0.0212813821,
0.0476395637,
0.055325333,
-0.0101467259,
0.014858447,
-0.0429645479,
0.0053926725,
-0.0082350923,
-0.0300817918,
-0.0045309397,
-6.294403437e-33,
-0.0321900509,
-0.0344641656,
0.0403117016,
0.0318313837,
-0.027067231,
-0.0064149606,
-0.0373586528,
-0.0048947129,
-0.0432113931,
-0.0102175558,
-0.0180845242,
0.053433761,
0.0054819398,
0.044818949,
-0.0179399457,
-0.0232393723,
0.0351624936,
-0.0020866967,
-0.0023933584,
0.0798434243,
-0.0026099063,
0.0070907231,
0.020130327,
-0.0634846315,
0.0147130974,
-0.035948135,
-0.0063758316,
0.0274038613,
-0.0049746083,
0.0598408505,
-0.0347385295,
0.0278858654,
0.0154817896,
-0.0216571782,
-0.0103149414,
0.026083611,
-0.0345930494,
-0.0373741575,
0.014072964,
-0.006206336,
-0.0270877313,
-0.022984555,
-0.0025996547,
-0.0152673488,
0.0185756348,
-0.029667709,
0.0321195498,
-0.0010742459,
-0.0191361383,
0.0072760107,
-0.0550283194,
0.0246373676,
-0.0697064623,
-0.0999255031,
-0.0284064841,
0.0541472472,
0.0338155888,
-0.0240935255,
-0.0232219566,
0.0680173412,
0.0262034256,
0.002815064,
0.0506877527,
-0.0226205811,
-0.0046192617,
0.0339168981,
0.0206042286,
0.0328817517,
-0.0348728858,
-0.0247850753,
-0.017554,
0.0462294109,
0.0064222873,
0.0030341167,
-0.0256923977,
0.0014662974,
-0.0532702729,
0.0300570913,
0.0599626414,
0.0194791108,
-0.0208762754,
0.0077296263,
-0.0718414783,
-0.0095566865,
-0.0189503971,
0.0039871065,
-0.0026667297,
-0.0424466506,
0.0288394485,
0.006822248,
0.002625647,
-0.0435670614,
0.016227331,
-0.0514454581,
-0.0072247488,
0.0206639357,
-0.0414748862,
0.0098353745,
-0.0191174671,
0.0084121656,
-0.0510256216,
-0.0396297872,
0.05385736,
-0.0120315431,
-0.0080224061,
0.0379384644,
0.0183404963,
0.0388081111,
-0.0282589868,
0.007761301,
-0.0363243856,
0.0318279006,
-0.0105596865,
-0.0230126902,
0.0030588291,
0.0080993455,
-0.052095823,
0.0951594636,
0.0055971858,
0.0246729031,
-0.0336242057,
-0.0751656741,
-0.0023964224,
0.005154524,
-0.0649462938,
0.0130704883,
-0.0614052042,
-0.0287727714,
-0.005745281,
-0.0403742269,
-0.0140340626,
-0.0381859317,
2.604e-7,
-0.0076335929,
0.0495368876,
0.0473505594,
0.0385481268,
0.0135297459,
0.0242257454,
-0.0099375974,
0.0290737748,
0.0163357407,
-0.0000179126,
0.017233979,
0.0581627749,
0.049263142,
0.0014238785,
-0.100001432,
-0.037131343,
-0.0732908547,
-0.0582987592,
-0.0450331047,
-0.0171934608,
0.0737262517,
0.096852608,
0.0006431761,
0.0007491704,
-0.0185105447,
-0.008841306,
0.0415067337,
-0.0277741328,
-0.0558488965,
0.0617041141,
0.0625321418,
0.0186246727,
-0.0089470344,
-0.0329068601,
-0.0040007178,
0.004363501,
0.005192691,
0.0672397986,
0.0027262308,
-0.0315649174,
0.0454213172,
-0.0083562359,
-0.007486091,
-0.0386412777,
0.0524507649,
-0.0240420122,
-0.0288589317,
0.0025694286,
-0.0201329701,
-0.0012712133,
0.0226364266,
-0.0318472497,
-0.0091290474,
0.0312434752,
-0.0117836362,
-0.0183919091,
0.0179009624,
-0.0471135192,
-0.0089513976,
-0.0176856853,
-0.0535436943,
-0.0431726202,
-0.0394971669,
-0.0197498277,
-0.0086806212,
-0.0157679282,
0.0346659087,
1.878999595e-34,
0.0324987285,
-0.0244282372,
0.0300957151,
0.0521118939,
0.0210834295,
-0.0239204876,
0.0276217237,
0.0125383735,
0.0344859846,
-0.0747130737,
-0.016663814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14232v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14232v2 | Pre-training Multi-task Contrastive Learning Models for Scientific Literature Understanding | 2023-05-23T16:47:22 | 2023-10-19T01:18:49 | Yu Zhang, Hao Cheng, Zhihong Shen, Xiaodong Liu, Ye-Yi Wang, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Scientific literature understanding tasks have gained significant attention
due to their potential to accelerate scientific discovery. Pre-trained language
models (LMs) have shown effectiveness in these tasks, especially when tuned via
contrastive learning. However, jointly utilizing pre-training data across
multiple heterogeneous tasks (e.g., extreme multi-label paper classification,
citation prediction, and literature search) remains largely unexplored. To
bridge this gap, we propose a multi-task contrastive learning framework,
SciMult, with a focus on facilitating common knowledge sharing across different
scientific literature understanding tasks while preventing task-specific skills
from interfering with each other. To be specific, we explore two techniques --
task-aware specialization and instruction tuning. The former adopts a
Mixture-of-Experts Transformer architecture with task-aware sub-layers; the
latter prepends task-specific instructions to the input text so as to produce
task-aware outputs. Extensive experiments on a comprehensive collection of
benchmark datasets verify the effectiveness of our task-aware specialization
strategy, where we outperform state-of-the-art scientific pre-trained LMs.
Code, datasets, and pre-trained models can be found at
https://scimult.github.io/. | [
0.0509108528,
0.0290681664,
0.0143867498,
-0.0089779375,
0.0136479568,
0.0004947095,
0.0544626489,
-0.0331691429,
-0.0027277893,
-0.0181989018,
-0.0998147726,
-0.0046477099,
-0.0140455645,
0.0080927946,
0.0105544999,
-0.0530910455,
0.0337184072,
-0.0185830165,
0.0620439127,
-0.0069800992,
-0.0141990855,
0.0017196023,
0.0069651911,
0.0126524745,
0.0712655336,
-0.0589209236,
0.03733835,
-0.0221977439,
0.0496390499,
-0.0265391264,
0.0651002079,
0.0651197508,
0.0586541407,
0.0233462714,
0.0000019704,
-0.0356217362,
-0.027269179,
0.0073906528,
0.0055802213,
0.0040631304,
0.0827550143,
-0.0296771247,
0.0460465513,
-0.0056124493,
-0.0225963145,
-0.0350474715,
0.0405401811,
0.041537717,
0.0128278695,
0.0258957744,
-0.0019859322,
-0.0091217291,
0.0197986197,
-0.0250110421,
0.0208301935,
-0.0125230588,
0.038684126,
-0.0099602826,
0.038158156,
0.0727429986,
0.021664001,
0.0501721874,
0.011288844,
0.0086962851,
0.0499911532,
0.0475444235,
0.020928923,
-0.0022515154,
-0.0189879742,
0.0627472997,
-0.0261678044,
-0.0409384333,
0.0098218331,
-0.0164637752,
-0.0385532677,
0.023401482,
-0.0353403911,
0.015713295,
-0.0061461148,
-0.0191773102,
0.0523259789,
0.036016807,
0.0229120348,
0.0224771388,
-0.0270595998,
0.0490339696,
0.0150336716,
-0.0129972873,
-0.0058812625,
0.0148413526,
-0.0145677449,
-0.0198736992,
0.0316399559,
0.0239386484,
-0.0590565689,
-0.0026129868,
-0.030062329,
-0.1225936338,
0.0232112594,
0.0076396526,
0.0270189773,
0.012455428,
-0.046388112,
0.0532951467,
0.0191643275,
-0.0261707734,
-0.0433327407,
0.0069724624,
0.0024266569,
-0.0444089025,
-0.0614177212,
-0.0164432507,
0.019627668,
0.0011294242,
-0.0184260141,
0.011431965,
0.0120438747,
0.0065512345,
-0.0007675861,
-0.0427173004,
0.0273946319,
0.0122332331,
-0.0749430582,
-0.0245595574,
-0.0037865848,
0.0785110816,
-0.0161117632,
0.0361699574,
-0.0163848568,
-0.0068151061,
-0.022625966,
0.0147129651,
-0.0185431577,
-0.0584228896,
0.0433924571,
0.0204703566,
-0.0235169046,
-0.0385521427,
-0.0202041101,
-0.0060834605,
0.0091927955,
-0.0729811341,
0.0335387588,
-0.0440681502,
0.0422969311,
0.0196452383,
0.016314147,
-0.0438721851,
-0.0173710044,
-0.0056265625,
-0.0391748995,
0.0701983497,
-0.036466971,
-0.045286797,
0.0377623849,
0.019002825,
-0.0476791821,
0.0339366347,
0.0012273481,
-0.0408196263,
0.0114252111,
0.0032239414,
-0.0065376842,
-0.0174919255,
0.0069272746,
-0.014078225,
0.03049157,
0.0232526232,
-0.0202988833,
0.0128997974,
0.0596603341,
0.0147165339,
-0.0294671897,
-0.0096655209,
0.0271681156,
0.0339921489,
0.0178231709,
0.0375118144,
0.0329452716,
0.0286869183,
-0.0004438702,
0.0106428573,
0.0007007844,
0.0608963668,
-0.009551188,
-0.0169280954,
0.0306258947,
0.0649091303,
-0.0435117371,
-0.0079049924,
0.0357582308,
-0.0042751767,
-0.0138851311,
-0.0004165652,
0.0879013166,
0.0016506449,
-0.0167295616,
0.0128019257,
0.0599161088,
-0.0218633171,
0.0292843152,
-0.007853277,
0.0155799985,
0.0202304292,
0.0269317031,
-0.0692346469,
-0.039862968,
-0.011301103,
0.0342312641,
0.0221072994,
0.0064018806,
-0.0052578188,
0.0111556565,
-0.0408614501,
-0.0533017665,
-0.0662233606,
0.0081993304,
-0.0029116273,
0.0065031564,
0.0103244996,
-0.0151739391,
-0.0225968622,
-0.0278737191,
0.0323845595,
-0.0765550807,
0.0141759701,
-0.0085438807,
-0.0362235196,
0.0160241239,
-0.0173595231,
-0.0302645043,
0.0115507757,
0.0298706479,
-0.0321915261,
0.0114393951,
0.0092234854,
-0.0045574829,
-0.0237460807,
0.0365698896,
-0.0670727193,
-0.0104503473,
0.0318202414,
-0.0321733132,
-0.0268491153,
0.0319756046,
0.0227856729,
-0.0060349465,
0.0347188152,
-0.0256680474,
-0.0110973781,
0.0220801216,
-0.0102351038,
0.0544121414,
0.0012506705,
0.0394366421,
0.0415169485,
-0.0206018463,
-0.0134590697,
0.0034115524,
-0.0236771591,
-0.0593694262,
0.0445358902,
0.0009304287,
0.0449502468,
-0.0088281808,
-0.0305668432,
-0.0219968408,
-0.0367159247,
0.0384590961,
-0.0202911291,
0.0063447203,
0.0402106643,
0.0009246297,
0.0207483638,
0.0161240008,
0.0028251421,
-0.0094018159,
-0.0495284833,
-0.0139568867,
0.0254580937,
0.019544635,
0.0296435133,
-0.0389350019,
-0.0132947788,
-0.0386256687,
0.0303292014,
0.011200618,
0.0030262277,
-0.0520181134,
0.0135945771,
0.0216125082,
0.021740621,
-0.0315636545,
0.0410335138,
0.0263238624,
-0.0259155836,
0.0530339964,
0.0635009035,
-0.0035223523,
0.0142657878,
0.0545821451,
-0.0033842172,
-0.0320169367,
0.0182698984,
-0.0032939725,
0.0212559402,
-0.0320586562,
0.022672683,
0.0049258014,
0.0797925144,
-0.0453229025,
-0.0471003167,
-0.0257982668,
-0.0103412475,
0.007033742,
-0.0267103463,
0.0353748351,
0.0339689925,
0.0216412973,
0.0193542372,
-0.0018667639,
-0.0086442679,
0.0797223076,
0.0071923495,
-0.0395016819,
-0.0934000015,
-0.0238322355,
-0.0274051707,
0.002561844,
-0.0067702844,
-0.0182848144,
0.0411383212,
0.0131006865,
-0.0770542994,
0.0217030142,
-0.0226138718,
0.0017464076,
-0.0067708795,
-0.0478809178,
-0.0028794545,
-0.0142649626,
-0.021244254,
0.0143144149,
-0.0170455668,
-0.0380983092,
0.0681212172,
0.0627583265,
-0.0587643795,
-0.0827354491,
-0.0101394039,
0.053959012,
0.0467109755,
-0.02932477,
-0.0398975722,
-0.0370176062,
0.0116219381,
0.050007049,
-0.0032136377,
0.0136252102,
-0.0441658124,
-0.0269247238,
0.0520958304,
0.0173267238,
-0.05502785,
-0.0194979962,
-0.0148394043,
0.0503173359,
-0.0589534827,
-0.0084879007,
-0.0103610288,
0.0472096093,
-0.0470159277,
-0.0090535879,
0.0805939287,
0.0040227408,
-0.1070819646,
-0.0348247215,
-0.0248984061,
-0.0047589666,
0.0291839838,
0.0339727476,
-0.0691598728,
-0.0191574078,
-0.0473447144,
0.0153412968,
0.0490657389,
-0.0504701957,
-0.0166183468,
-0.0305850543,
0.0120632695,
-0.007646434,
-0.0176343042,
-0.0120805614,
-0.0478634723,
0.0044092699,
-0.0524647869,
-0.0165013373,
-0.0007947598,
-0.0201721378,
0.0107503626,
0.0275674146,
0.0481824465,
-0.0676546469,
0.042290099,
-0.0352070145,
0.0259513333,
-0.0087946802,
-0.0123277484,
0.0030348061,
-0.0424066149,
-0.0501801334,
-0.0212785322,
-0.0116887391,
-0.0148403123,
0.0347290002,
-0.0347101316,
0.0074655619,
-0.0098426547,
0.051049374,
-0.0428756177,
-0.0155147659,
0.0165574197,
0.0908978358,
0.0001339635,
-0.009469742,
-0.0499728993,
-0.0107182357,
0.0318447426,
0.0832001567,
0.0053351959,
-0.0532193519,
-0.0392958298,
0.0116191804,
0.0178174842,
-0.0426507182,
-0.0468205325,
-0.0134943109,
-0.0103671988,
0.0057534073,
-0.0029713244,
-0.0022114844,
0.0469498113,
-0.0046566385,
0.008845266,
0.0170786697,
0.0116822124,
-0.0217510741,
-0.0549477078,
0.037098445,
-0.0194453187,
-0.0171105489,
-0.0393400043,
-0.0514107347,
0.103231512,
-0.0182326939,
-0.0213330295,
0.0101581505,
-0.0327392332,
-0.0517516509,
-0.0298289713,
0.0448107906,
0.0162168853,
0.0439457297,
-0.0009440726,
-0.0636426806,
0.0447913669,
0.033232525,
-0.0659971759,
-0.0262606051,
0.0450724438,
-0.0453440361,
-0.0054352013,
-0.0065347063,
-0.0270053484,
0.0244062189,
-0.000467977,
0.0013093681,
-0.0490398183,
-0.0451697446,
-0.0088803172,
-0.0243306533,
0.084569566,
-0.0263558198,
0.0261665005,
-0.0571806431,
-0.0207504835,
0.020629108,
-0.0091334693,
-0.0362859704,
0.0194785148,
0.006126327,
-0.0125989495,
0.002396801,
0.0791536346,
-0.0015110156,
0.0286157019,
-0.0553019457,
0.0381820239,
0.0025641045,
0.0196832437,
0.0346785672,
0.0014421825,
-0.0127025135,
-0.0413492285,
0.002362049,
0.0280243047,
-0.0028359082,
0.0335861631,
0.0461966284,
0.0111428183,
-0.013732072,
0.0239703953,
-0.1068193316,
-0.0506119058,
-0.0206296518,
-0.0339925326,
0.042061273,
0.0021186825,
0.0379347131,
-0.043721728,
-0.0260973293,
-0.0439486466,
0.0437941737,
0.0002777686,
0.0483424552,
0.0246321429,
0.0150390556,
-0.0082956348,
-0.0090864347,
0.1062119454,
0.0062873983,
0.0357097164,
0.030346714,
-0.0259074438,
-0.0270498004,
-0.0245461259,
-0.0276911389,
0.0431109369,
-0.0108067235,
-0.0095733209,
-0.0149425799,
-0.0039343634,
0.0582357943,
-0.0269083958,
-0.0473338366,
-0.0150996828,
0.0346690007,
0.0282548163,
-0.0338206887,
-0.0307267439,
0.0028248373,
0.0180201624,
0.0359913744,
-0.0460970625,
-0.0281444956,
-6.432891366e-33,
0.0061719771,
0.0042913812,
0.0140382657,
-0.0016173973,
0.0364632234,
0.0198942348,
-0.0583155379,
-0.0236926079,
-0.0276901927,
0.0251837149,
-0.0117350249,
0.0297020711,
-0.0083970334,
0.0082363589,
0.0400688313,
0.0145902522,
0.0653615221,
-0.0116578648,
0.0012538701,
0.0533343814,
0.0304958578,
0.0604172871,
0.0806883872,
-0.0951367468,
0.0230290014,
0.0076493854,
0.0456338488,
-0.0034692327,
-0.0061003393,
0.0258544683,
-0.0377804302,
0.034606304,
0.0025454066,
-0.088888295,
-0.0430152863,
-0.0035018721,
-0.0981940776,
-0.0441415869,
0.0149856498,
-0.0302480292,
-0.0599091835,
-0.0349786244,
0.0367050655,
0.026752349,
0.0330715962,
-0.0803911015,
0.0850721747,
0.0039120275,
0.0044617606,
-0.0547682717,
-0.0560197011,
0.0018001642,
-0.0239666943,
0.0111374604,
0.0386273488,
0.0254639275,
0.0146930953,
0.109209314,
-0.0683370754,
0.0321699195,
0.0002722704,
0.009740944,
0.0130842552,
0.0017014983,
0.0036085639,
0.0295148306,
0.001750377,
0.0038201446,
0.0508981943,
-0.0242771842,
0.0217373278,
0.0310027916,
0.0066243121,
0.0280001964,
0.0369582213,
0.043300543,
-0.0700297281,
0.025690401,
0.0207749996,
0.0163162909,
0.0305695962,
0.0462341085,
0.0532904826,
-0.0217948817,
0.0009685709,
-0.0122791091,
-0.0152723026,
-0.0026311164,
-0.0331845917,
-0.010620039,
-0.0386724956,
0.0459381491,
0.0415445641,
-0.0523843281,
-0.0274369251,
0.054079473,
0.0007714827,
0.0223413259,
0.0293795466,
-0.001931266,
-0.1121423021,
-0.0347532742,
0.043510437,
-0.0129834665,
0.015567488,
0.013243733,
0.0181935299,
0.015782157,
-0.0168250091,
-0.0391017869,
-0.0014626944,
-0.0114336386,
0.0345941931,
0.0533082597,
0.002146183,
0.0419193283,
0.003409202,
0.0506851152,
0.0439770222,
0.0007798262,
-0.0031828242,
0.0133573161,
0.003433597,
0.0325688981,
0.0061229081,
-0.0365300998,
-0.0426527113,
-0.005022964,
0.0076458203,
-0.0540484749,
-0.021404922,
-0.0093355933,
2.696e-7,
0.06772466,
0.0374804065,
-0.0183727257,
-0.0349763036,
0.0345442258,
0.0278984979,
-0.0109540205,
0.0287723597,
0.0072046635,
-0.0240265951,
0.0163904168,
0.0083259596,
0.0088199237,
0.0210127104,
-0.0517934412,
-0.0641973093,
-0.0293384269,
-0.0018330311,
-0.0425346009,
-0.0175588429,
0.011995458,
0.0364725143,
0.0173949134,
0.0049942103,
0.0152470814,
-0.0150487367,
0.0701352209,
-0.0428509004,
0.0553764962,
0.0638657883,
0.0202283431,
0.023577664,
-0.0256687514,
0.0281227715,
-0.0128887435,
0.0235842206,
-0.021739373,
0.0572936535,
0.0031452801,
-0.0221722648,
0.062124595,
0.0121398401,
-0.0081841201,
-0.0224959645,
0.0372961946,
-0.1174055189,
-0.0443524458,
-0.0064054662,
-0.0316758156,
0.0030404488,
0.010958584,
-0.0142948776,
0.005136353,
0.0021796357,
-0.0253253356,
0.030256357,
-0.049190484,
-0.0885384306,
-0.022019824,
0.0926052928,
-0.0472953171,
-0.0431209393,
-0.0074423021,
-0.0588499419,
0.0371606722,
-0.0644454733,
0.0409700833,
2.340145225e-34,
0.0475363024,
0.0036737537,
-0.0260322336,
0.0322273634,
0.0088247331,
-0.0361982659,
-0.0860947892,
-0.0053693801,
0.0340778343,
-0.0730713531,
-0.0268542077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14230v2 | Exploring Representational Disparities Between Multilingual and Bilingual Translation Models | 2023-05-23T16:46:18 | 2024-03-26T13:16:37 | Neha Verma, Kenton Murray, Kevin Duh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual machine translation has proven immensely useful for both
parameter efficiency and overall performance across many language pairs via
complete multilingual parameter sharing. However, some language pairs in
multilingual models can see worse performance than in bilingual models,
especially in the one-to-many translation setting. Motivated by their empirical
differences, we examine the geometric differences in representations from
bilingual models versus those from one-to-many multilingual models.
Specifically, we compute the isotropy of these representations using intrinsic
dimensionality and IsoScore, in order to measure how the representations
utilize the dimensions in their underlying vector space. Using the same
evaluation data in both models, we find that for a given language pair, its
multilingual model decoder representations are consistently less isotropic and
occupy fewer dimensions than comparable bilingual model decoder
representations. Additionally, we show that much of the anisotropy in
multilingual decoder representations can be attributed to modeling
language-specific information, therefore limiting remaining representational
capacity. | [
-0.0122224633,
0.0344999097,
-0.0209678598,
0.0672856569,
-0.0494498312,
0.0318178758,
0.0686202496,
0.002091133,
-0.0668679774,
-0.0120778009,
-0.0446986929,
-0.080615975,
0.0333727896,
-0.0236307625,
0.0367651805,
-0.0660883635,
0.0113336137,
-0.0298788603,
-0.0352707393,
-0.0293402579,
-0.0596811995,
0.028313769,
0.0349202789,
0.0269037932,
0.0016439883,
-0.0072845537,
0.0173141044,
0.0076411888,
0.0219634473,
-0.0025934693,
-0.0480266102,
0.0208356492,
0.0374062434,
0.0597420931,
0.0000018642,
-0.0221392363,
-0.0344902761,
0.029142268,
0.0376739949,
0.0406862535,
0.0740074143,
-0.0887304097,
-0.0124198403,
-0.0169506054,
-0.0051066433,
-0.0342515372,
0.0674271286,
-0.0026639106,
-0.0196566768,
0.0429904871,
-0.0267569087,
-0.0558436103,
-0.0118632251,
-0.0331372023,
-0.0198292993,
-0.0027304329,
-0.0380211584,
0.0330831483,
-0.079862088,
0.0251509231,
-0.0589976013,
0.0665801913,
0.0161750186,
0.0564105734,
-0.0256567784,
-0.0001752642,
0.0051263412,
-0.0231183618,
0.0126832062,
0.028916914,
-0.0406231247,
0.0072835283,
-0.0228408854,
0.0175893176,
-0.0144659476,
0.0103466054,
-0.0240199994,
0.0093876533,
-0.0046623969,
0.0011862691,
0.020262884,
0.0674338862,
0.0365957506,
-0.0403338745,
-0.0309292004,
0.0069544842,
0.04017248,
-0.0187429618,
-0.026320681,
0.0365852378,
0.0302477051,
0.0340365991,
0.0370053165,
-0.0374441594,
0.0253123902,
-0.0043489235,
0.0136924898,
-0.0483096167,
0.0093830395,
-0.1049729139,
0.0786621273,
0.0476823635,
0.0082275607,
0.0208483618,
-0.011753059,
0.0780668184,
-0.0297209527,
0.0572849326,
-0.0793946236,
-0.0222423486,
-0.004242436,
0.0166226886,
-0.0071371333,
-0.0267674737,
-0.0182187967,
0.0035702426,
-0.0130503299,
0.040363837,
0.0199878607,
-0.0114921834,
0.0373019427,
-0.0349595211,
-0.0281462558,
-0.0156326126,
0.0215350091,
0.0530176274,
-0.0261302311,
-0.044740878,
-0.0453940071,
-0.0605233237,
-0.0080839554,
0.0059630536,
-0.0087582441,
-0.0515444055,
0.0085528055,
0.1193713993,
-0.0081635844,
-0.037040282,
0.0156942401,
0.012653538,
-0.0434758849,
-0.071972847,
-0.0026690804,
-0.0482817143,
0.1007963941,
0.0476492569,
0.0094366027,
-0.0622888245,
-0.0296941251,
-0.0416667908,
-0.0122531699,
0.0584592856,
0.0573606417,
0.0143664796,
0.0510948189,
-0.0273536183,
-0.016363807,
0.1123889387,
0.0131589808,
-0.000937295,
0.0445893817,
-0.0326753967,
-0.0428442694,
0.0321094431,
0.006915227,
0.0506935008,
-0.0601719618,
0.0057132835,
0.0453061387,
-0.0025094126,
0.0491183922,
0.0503737181,
-0.0352086797,
-0.0056326571,
0.0577903874,
0.0360688753,
0.0281752162,
0.0480386056,
0.0610705167,
-0.003089712,
-0.0220859051,
0.0162185654,
0.0118853971,
0.0250232834,
0.0612952523,
-0.0075950958,
0.0581956841,
0.0612060577,
-0.0295224246,
-0.0174809005,
-0.002122635,
-0.0222115517,
0.0321797207,
-0.0306277927,
0.0518861897,
-0.0117799714,
-0.0418844298,
0.0668791309,
-0.0083650611,
-0.0647057667,
0.0111494716,
0.0326616876,
-0.041932039,
0.0224941578,
0.0096572228,
0.0274246056,
-0.0028168543,
0.0296596251,
-0.0368652083,
0.0188432727,
0.0927621052,
0.0020274366,
0.0519033074,
-0.0448361821,
-0.0208437033,
-0.0024280478,
0.0249765571,
0.0820339695,
-0.0119303623,
0.0310346652,
0.0289351512,
-0.0828677863,
-0.0449355207,
-0.009595979,
-0.0294707399,
-0.0152297188,
0.0154292593,
0.0166875497,
0.0208394472,
0.0188208222,
0.0022548784,
0.0108674392,
-0.0035045391,
-0.0459980406,
0.0001213428,
0.045025982,
-0.04687896,
-0.0325656272,
0.0087880967,
-0.0218896251,
0.0298973341,
-0.024557611,
0.004489894,
-0.0174703877,
0.0280951001,
-0.0292871054,
0.018025754,
-0.0328209884,
0.0316296965,
-0.0508388877,
0.0120057426,
-0.0264472235,
0.0358827226,
-0.0093769617,
0.0366253518,
0.0147350198,
0.0018995233,
0.0215598773,
-0.0232643578,
0.0112901963,
0.0612618998,
0.0280890968,
0.0340580083,
0.0252007488,
-0.0303339083,
0.039919734,
-0.0616670325,
-0.0066984901,
-0.043774832,
-0.028304724,
0.0430260487,
0.0148966415,
0.0175872501,
0.0318801701,
0.0049241246,
-0.0390425473,
-0.0192905907,
-0.019619111,
0.0360768177,
-0.0191019978,
0.0015453669,
0.0117599145,
0.0033454057,
-0.0190352555,
0.0344809704,
0.0624017306,
-0.0209378302,
-0.0115105454,
-0.0732767656,
0.0225345045,
-0.0277380515,
-0.0036787901,
-0.0179747287,
-0.0599860512,
0.0065661706,
-0.0036814548,
0.0449229591,
0.0223973673,
-0.0200258605,
0.0026436551,
0.0619060248,
-0.0249036252,
-0.041910857,
0.0088064959,
-0.0186310448,
-0.0000765875,
-0.0517911948,
-0.0964906365,
0.0121417111,
0.0623455159,
0.0254165605,
-0.008286871,
-0.075689815,
-0.0302773416,
-0.02371113,
-0.0264768209,
-0.03253223,
0.0310608149,
0.0238335058,
0.0403171293,
-0.0239003841,
-0.0646653324,
0.0399371572,
-0.0549653322,
-0.022668032,
-0.0426609218,
0.0287260357,
-0.0441753343,
0.0627264678,
-0.0153400982,
0.0415329859,
-0.0540025905,
-0.0191186555,
-0.0043166932,
0.044552058,
0.0421550386,
-0.0235532802,
0.006976624,
-0.0471582599,
-0.0349409059,
-0.0179749522,
-0.0073979739,
0.0152187487,
0.0110824937,
0.0087206829,
-0.0139616234,
0.0017060806,
-0.0404453278,
-0.0303802751,
0.038981583,
0.031322401,
0.0310781505,
-0.0098031163,
0.0169025958,
0.0074210861,
-0.011483483,
-0.0108390599,
-0.0090717534,
0.0031666073,
-0.0765690282,
0.0407677218,
-0.0077397227,
-0.0134252002,
-0.0093272552,
-0.0016340006,
-0.0126366382,
0.0432423279,
0.0577871092,
-0.0575864427,
-0.0140570179,
0.0490664244,
-0.0050528599,
-0.0138653349,
0.0607533194,
0.0178841781,
-0.0757712424,
-0.0108609917,
-0.0398321375,
0.0340464637,
0.0126044285,
0.0078246975,
-0.0170773193,
0.0220229439,
-0.0166333076,
0.0066135423,
0.0503890552,
0.0312568285,
-0.0190846976,
-0.0710796565,
-0.0102525158,
0.0540939681,
-0.0509357713,
-0.0741944462,
-0.022700591,
-0.0653377026,
-0.0406255126,
0.0441989936,
-0.0247901976,
0.0099137863,
-0.0137552544,
0.0099806283,
0.0219102632,
-0.0269885212,
0.0071904021,
-0.0337978229,
-0.0218506567,
0.0480695181,
0.0467987247,
-0.0069902972,
-0.0382162891,
-0.0393947735,
-0.0099405022,
-0.0138096819,
-0.0013327708,
0.0235613249,
0.0336081944,
-0.0163767841,
0.044487372,
-0.0265647098,
-0.0427166037,
0.0361175276,
-0.0211376585,
0.0586594045,
-0.0132173346,
0.0048117777,
0.0122905737,
-0.0401252285,
-0.0185806714,
0.0493442491,
0.0170861837,
-0.0281019062,
-0.0002701598,
-0.0239540692,
0.0112076951,
-0.0736606866,
-0.0213925987,
0.0104617411,
-0.039400842,
-0.0773851573,
-0.0494962819,
-0.0355480164,
-0.0256090909,
0.0358508639,
0.010971643,
-0.0064427857,
-0.0057979864,
-0.0175050218,
0.015206486,
0.0096602142,
-0.0023964816,
0.0131530045,
-0.0166019034,
0.0174036697,
-0.0104170348,
-0.0220906734,
0.0144579764,
0.0092958473,
-0.0431322306,
-0.0651504472,
-0.0227747709,
0.0265323929,
0.0081651295,
0.0209779255,
-0.0078997836,
-0.0107820593,
-0.0064495616,
-0.0440230891,
0.0359678082,
0.0146062132,
0.0344282538,
-0.0093802474,
-0.0111772744,
0.067495279,
-0.0215230528,
-0.0141583644,
-0.0014859311,
0.0265507679,
-0.0266826674,
-0.0543995649,
0.0014634536,
-0.0026815166,
0.0159440618,
-0.0338648893,
-0.0098326225,
0.0015718273,
0.0190509241,
-0.0702735856,
0.0038384167,
-0.0390199721,
-0.0101357102,
0.0499787107,
-0.0178716499,
-0.0075847059,
0.0202666186,
0.0293449666,
-0.0009238624,
-0.0112136984,
-0.0006959174,
-0.0262331869,
0.006198247,
0.0090586301,
0.0554700196,
-0.0233034305,
0.0202002507,
-0.0273823068,
-0.0091165612,
-0.0487084091,
0.0386531614,
-0.0146814818,
0.0400620997,
-0.0078054415,
0.0222918466,
-0.0028576462,
-0.0067949519,
0.0158894826,
-0.045032654,
0.0624436513,
-0.0137114944,
0.1157195568,
-0.0198095404,
-0.003442944,
-0.0161658414,
0.0351770855,
0.0255802665,
-0.0159972943,
0.028934937,
-0.012866307,
0.0029630056,
-0.0030796609,
0.0936544761,
-0.0271881558,
0.0147309238,
-0.0363067016,
-0.0073557682,
0.0049340399,
-0.001103439,
0.0021983332,
-0.014980197,
-0.0344288945,
-0.0301876813,
-0.0321718454,
-0.040737614,
-0.0131999608,
-0.0089524845,
0.0019829539,
0.0003819247,
-0.0099181551,
0.0947763994,
-0.0476912186,
-0.0069568674,
-0.0416032858,
-0.0066384291,
0.0092934351,
0.001602795,
-0.0000847014,
-5.621967404e-33,
-0.0044584419,
0.0229303781,
-0.0321450792,
-0.0748139843,
0.0039524757,
0.0120554334,
-0.0069809542,
0.0115273846,
-0.0158946272,
0.0079265255,
0.0277878214,
-0.0013268563,
0.0210611727,
-0.0088766301,
0.0497081019,
0.0169613212,
0.0390859805,
0.020435581,
-0.0101182275,
0.0267547276,
0.0485669896,
0.0026450062,
0.0858065039,
-0.0754650384,
0.0541945808,
-0.0031693666,
0.0054453616,
0.0078497184,
0.0365369245,
0.0240021218,
-0.0074496605,
0.0410191603,
0.0119250407,
-0.0350605957,
-0.046548143,
-0.0759343356,
-0.0547460094,
-0.017872436,
0.0246514548,
0.056722641,
-0.0308907647,
-0.1028054506,
0.0048448658,
-0.019438073,
-0.0137042329,
-0.0445094034,
-0.0058273235,
-0.0346060619,
-0.0417071022,
0.0312335808,
-0.0413754545,
0.0184028633,
0.0016000442,
0.0294451769,
0.0756994933,
0.0702295005,
-0.0004581798,
-0.0030090217,
-0.0322048962,
0.0189877693,
-0.03911715,
0.0484672748,
0.0746191144,
0.0061159329,
-0.0062472476,
-0.0006414379,
0.0539586134,
0.001190957,
0.0192794893,
0.0058782673,
0.010445551,
-0.0050384928,
0.052567251,
0.0624048933,
0.0176636335,
-0.0162499566,
-0.0151493428,
0.0208867472,
-0.0332108401,
-0.0276706778,
0.0626116022,
0.0074085551,
-0.0259270836,
-0.0163806658,
-0.0457925163,
-0.069527559,
-0.0223175772,
-0.0647521019,
-0.0087272068,
0.0011470285,
0.0095459055,
-0.0017661249,
0.0909564644,
-0.0058091758,
-0.0039656064,
0.0229261778,
-0.0181708522,
0.0350723229,
-0.0007019138,
0.0304964427,
0.019880861,
-0.0519732572,
-0.0211647991,
0.037440531,
-0.0032170799,
-0.0024340716,
0.0303857811,
0.0288374275,
-0.0323292203,
-0.000825657,
-0.0370970741,
-0.0783217624,
0.0074094394,
0.0624942891,
0.0075934804,
0.0088440562,
-0.0053257267,
0.0334449485,
0.0175117645,
0.0133087961,
-0.0182953756,
-0.0438744687,
0.0199780315,
0.0673073381,
-0.027461255,
0.0103744725,
-0.0609386377,
-0.0376056097,
0.0984990075,
-0.0227163639,
-0.0481584892,
-0.0022451032,
2.591e-7,
0.0690362677,
0.0466738567,
0.0043725823,
0.0121826837,
0.0116767725,
0.0219802279,
-0.0346779414,
0.0454399884,
-0.0166778471,
0.0053477506,
-0.0110531738,
0.0365411118,
0.0782837272,
0.0485409759,
-0.0241949726,
-0.0234586224,
-0.0337333977,
0.0398278721,
-0.0233611465,
0.0313365199,
0.0197902489,
0.07412415,
-0.0302196499,
-0.000252651,
-0.0185375251,
0.0043547624,
0.0770606399,
-0.0406665094,
-0.0110436641,
-0.0052944282,
0.0035942663,
-0.0301319454,
-0.0121384067,
-0.0087289149,
-0.0287738983,
0.0114160832,
0.0177066606,
0.0637425706,
-0.0124154072,
-0.0238694046,
0.0383576341,
-0.0471079871,
-0.0717334896,
-0.0513530225,
0.0394637734,
0.0060860664,
-0.0304477047,
0.016177604,
-0.0058646179,
0.0654660761,
0.0486141145,
-0.0364102125,
-0.0221023615,
0.0477144904,
0.0517300814,
-0.0218029954,
0.0060084211,
-0.0020152228,
-0.0521304309,
-0.0011721686,
-0.0137095386,
-0.03117509,
-0.0157333761,
0.0025429965,
0.0472694859,
-0.0368764736,
0.0071463534,
2.118429313e-34,
0.0439518541,
0.0209876485,
0.0228031985,
-0.020328138,
0.0174163058,
-0.0830698386,
-0.0187989362,
0.0123768225,
-0.0366280414,
-0.0476400629,
-0.0289415568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14225v2 | ManiTweet: A New Benchmark for Identifying Manipulation of News on Social Media | 2023-05-23T16:40:07 | 2024-06-12T06:25:15 | Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Kathleen McKeown, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Considerable advancements have been made to tackle the misrepresentation of
information derived from reference articles in the domains of fact-checking and
faithful summarization. However, an unaddressed aspect remains - the
identification of social media posts that manipulate information within
associated news articles. This task presents a significant challenge, primarily
due to the prevalence of personal opinions in such posts. We present a novel
task, identifying manipulation of news on social media, which aims to detect
manipulation in social media posts and identify manipulated or inserted
information. To study this task, we have proposed a data collection schema and
curated a dataset called ManiTweet, consisting of 3.6K pairs of tweets and
corresponding articles. Our analysis demonstrates that this task is highly
challenging, with large language models (LLMs) yielding unsatisfactory
performance. Additionally, we have developed a simple yet effective basic model
that outperforms LLMs significantly on the ManiTweet dataset. Finally, we have
conducted an exploratory analysis of human-written tweets, unveiling intriguing
connections between manipulation and the domain and factuality of news
articles, as well as revealing that manipulated sentences are more likely to
encapsulate the main story or consequences of a news outlet. | [
0.0706986338,
0.0533173755,
-0.0235697571,
0.024980288,
-0.0892961398,
-0.0071122381,
-0.0197976939,
-0.017282337,
0.0009965784,
-0.0267094783,
-0.0011393313,
0.0107525196,
0.0384328105,
0.027723914,
0.0175609179,
-0.0090570226,
0.0553591996,
0.040704336,
0.0175605919,
0.019298248,
0.0460175984,
0.0489853546,
0.0405431241,
0.0163788274,
-0.0314455144,
-0.0200489797,
0.0258406512,
0.0123124598,
0.0373117402,
0.0354387872,
0.0066205454,
0.0910295546,
0.0110528953,
0.0981098562,
0.0000016357,
0.0058290022,
-0.0007166701,
-0.0245946143,
0.0117104976,
0.0082084527,
0.1040149555,
-0.0527740344,
0.0090098353,
0.018711973,
-0.0545341074,
-0.0047540679,
0.007509178,
0.0583061688,
0.1225033104,
0.1160099804,
-0.0105949929,
0.024323456,
0.0011030678,
-0.016832022,
-0.0178386234,
-0.0055402289,
0.0370966159,
-0.0198518429,
-0.043385189,
0.0417590886,
0.0326510854,
0.0402393639,
0.0197935142,
-0.0201085098,
-0.0481114797,
-0.0323099494,
-0.0173006877,
-0.0049903332,
0.0218321644,
0.0370680504,
-0.0219012424,
-0.0671211556,
0.0124098714,
0.0028968155,
0.026393285,
0.0513088256,
-0.00087818,
0.0345129073,
-0.0089926384,
-0.0001371824,
-0.0232634936,
-0.0466771275,
0.0109237889,
0.0695677027,
0.0445856825,
0.0205579493,
-0.0053379778,
-0.0193941612,
-0.015262207,
-0.0028869547,
0.0048405239,
-0.0554458499,
-0.0022149403,
0.0186997801,
-0.0168253966,
0.0136020184,
-0.0850364044,
-0.0670720264,
0.007960014,
-0.0992201567,
-0.0241253674,
-0.0151584083,
0.0133800041,
0.0340165459,
0.0184401181,
0.0012714277,
-0.0354146026,
0.0252891835,
-0.0135895992,
0.0180854518,
-0.0048523401,
0.0033262374,
0.0128297266,
0.0127203176,
-0.0360967927,
-0.0023581376,
-0.0601515286,
-0.0052520963,
-0.0034048522,
0.0062508257,
-0.0143599501,
0.0145825893,
-0.001367269,
-0.0127841234,
-0.0035690211,
0.0341560543,
0.0027386923,
0.0413058735,
-0.0184844192,
0.0110784052,
-0.0257087201,
0.0305619985,
-0.0002140859,
-0.0109879486,
-0.0129498858,
0.0144028449,
0.0025853289,
-0.0163228214,
-0.0378273204,
-0.0675450638,
-0.0376589783,
-0.061507076,
-0.0109041343,
-0.0538447909,
0.0387596637,
0.0017683308,
-0.0328813642,
-0.0475632325,
-0.0018588277,
0.0694656372,
-0.0926151648,
0.0224386677,
-0.0013375498,
0.024848368,
0.0333957262,
0.0374692678,
0.0040746247,
0.0595481507,
0.0155896517,
0.1245528981,
0.0636276826,
0.0019794593,
0.021068994,
0.0238286145,
0.0260647591,
0.0309955198,
0.0175098423,
-0.0141284186,
-0.0609668307,
-0.0075910864,
-0.0071714679,
0.0478728749,
0.0119255958,
-0.0071901125,
0.1076416448,
-0.0187840685,
-0.0413635187,
-0.0049074176,
0.0383234806,
0.0290097613,
0.0261137467,
0.0130210901,
-0.0537000485,
-0.0033503054,
-0.031946566,
-0.0265445691,
0.0101417927,
0.0477458574,
0.0161806569,
-0.0041769035,
0.0265272781,
-0.0049799168,
0.0080194091,
-0.0048070205,
-0.0413927361,
0.0018830708,
-0.022042226,
0.0518586896,
0.0186837465,
-0.0168638621,
0.0268210582,
-0.0000050821,
0.005744386,
0.0142322127,
0.0432863086,
0.0031665585,
0.0318975113,
-0.0598544665,
0.0184244998,
0.0426803045,
0.0234183464,
-0.0258978307,
-0.0617448464,
0.0424673297,
-0.0170647986,
-0.0156250801,
0.0138999913,
-0.0114374515,
0.0337066464,
0.0042491034,
0.0254132915,
-0.0262496639,
-0.0267998911,
0.0144543918,
0.023903776,
-0.0261470582,
0.0152837625,
0.03087092,
0.0035754237,
0.0474805683,
-0.0022533697,
-0.0391517207,
0.031730596,
0.0365683958,
-0.0454988144,
-0.0011082857,
-0.0151323089,
0.0035310488,
0.0171682369,
-0.0339334346,
-0.0737227499,
0.0386497006,
-0.0353594534,
-0.0062797158,
0.0835332498,
-0.0112721752,
0.000162312,
-0.0363041982,
-0.0263174437,
-0.0299215317,
0.0007154421,
0.0086435359,
0.0802275166,
-0.0379621945,
-0.0306609869,
0.0094475178,
-0.0749201328,
-0.0100816889,
0.0360833742,
0.0237145573,
-0.0161366127,
-0.0011667493,
0.0302970838,
0.0466807634,
-0.0414802954,
-0.0420595817,
-0.0379382595,
-0.0761855096,
-0.0078774923,
-0.0363437533,
-0.0075610019,
0.0627602935,
0.0225578994,
-0.0003900279,
0.0227144919,
-0.0167944618,
-0.0354695097,
0.011897142,
0.0205335505,
0.0114011224,
0.0022031907,
0.0350701809,
-0.0354588814,
0.0273698512,
-0.0652159303,
0.0309731904,
-0.0126461154,
-0.0411850959,
-0.0269465465,
-0.0217788611,
-0.0127550671,
-0.0189860743,
-0.016711995,
-0.0202532709,
-0.0228516608,
0.0074801501,
0.0078952871,
0.0327710696,
0.0361306705,
0.0398975462,
0.0236435775,
0.0288682133,
-0.0006959982,
-0.017090613,
-0.0580463707,
0.0143849803,
-0.0334379673,
-0.0427456349,
0.0497888774,
0.0430321619,
0.0285162032,
0.0170880668,
-0.0068182237,
0.064651154,
-0.015938716,
-0.0064219595,
0.0311788525,
-0.0289608929,
-0.0266902037,
0.0020567249,
-0.0441100746,
-0.0292390045,
0.0446777716,
-0.007923115,
0.0747964829,
-0.0123330075,
-0.0369227231,
-0.0383210555,
0.0244035982,
0.00480262,
0.0309618767,
0.0112340786,
0.0153670302,
-0.0230683703,
-0.0408166498,
0.0449627824,
-0.006450464,
0.0506425202,
-0.0388478711,
0.0394767635,
0.0403480679,
-0.0384137407,
-0.0226152521,
-0.1294129938,
-0.0172214173,
-0.0323645435,
0.0267867483,
-0.048450496,
-0.0643246993,
-0.039399568,
0.0457609147,
-0.0166084822,
-0.0537114926,
0.0118978992,
-0.0043396135,
0.0448442623,
0.0601592325,
-0.0144433361,
0.0348450169,
-0.0076515796,
-0.0282750372,
0.0423371494,
-0.0217361134,
0.0251426212,
-0.0074488111,
-0.0349477939,
-0.0337598585,
-0.0545931831,
0.031692002,
-0.0369854197,
0.0405005403,
-0.0260575935,
0.0283418503,
0.101431042,
0.0270190481,
-0.0217620898,
-0.0020085459,
0.0420362502,
-0.0227596462,
0.0035468272,
0.0082890652,
-0.0891989619,
-0.0102261305,
-0.020974094,
0.0004996419,
-0.0246019233,
-0.0340427458,
-0.043870084,
-0.1088158265,
-0.0132883601,
0.0060056355,
-0.0052630701,
-0.0466273278,
-0.0525910817,
0.0005696359,
-0.0256739687,
0.0192791745,
-0.0100508397,
0.0015793826,
-0.0185885485,
-0.0447748639,
-0.0357726105,
-0.0326237902,
-0.0206017531,
0.015284949,
-0.0017386625,
0.0201399066,
0.0416655354,
-0.0146899736,
0.0170398485,
0.0450297482,
0.0528780222,
-0.0362656228,
-0.0297005102,
0.092060186,
-0.0462671407,
-0.0094565898,
-0.017164262,
0.0547328107,
-0.0050331079,
-0.015079366,
-0.0221706722,
0.0385071523,
0.0325222537,
-0.058891695,
-0.0098897489,
-0.0058558108,
0.0618368834,
0.0517027974,
0.0291072726,
-0.0042686281,
-0.0196336675,
-0.032566525,
-0.0156157417,
-0.0281427409,
-0.0456601568,
-0.0122833652,
0.0237009618,
0.0302325245,
-0.0472061299,
-0.0398979522,
0.0238868166,
-0.0403534994,
0.0276948512,
0.0016733559,
0.0483818613,
-0.0096365558,
-0.0416059569,
0.0018230984,
-0.0318575874,
0.0576821789,
0.0119368825,
-0.0134974765,
0.0008746876,
0.0152846938,
0.0078500258,
0.0146991629,
-0.0829093233,
-0.0630398914,
0.0131007507,
0.002110058,
0.0132936193,
0.0441440828,
0.0043779798,
-0.007418911,
0.0055335602,
0.0412245169,
-0.0678925291,
0.0158892479,
0.0008161822,
-0.0111369174,
0.0252173431,
0.0295963455,
-0.0004618778,
0.0164886154,
0.0286283344,
-0.0369929709,
-0.0593685918,
0.0112101119,
0.0385626517,
-0.0045468742,
0.0365972072,
0.0012144838,
0.0045069368,
-0.0520742238,
-0.0509222895,
-0.040758878,
-0.0480003022,
-0.0041416371,
0.0053938245,
0.0183280613,
0.0376691073,
-0.0343938656,
0.0058323522,
-0.0423617251,
0.0151544362,
-0.0249380246,
0.0087229153,
-0.0227436088,
-0.0036424845,
-0.0020879181,
-0.0006447571,
-0.0214376561,
0.0369135328,
-0.0055960473,
0.0366730019,
-0.003159659,
0.0026257846,
0.024468597,
-0.0232195351,
0.0146864364,
0.0074776765,
-0.0559406281,
0.0182905495,
-0.0127772754,
0.012801487,
0.0078216093,
-0.073502861,
0.0376895182,
0.0045751818,
-0.0225144643,
-0.0118607609,
-0.0094398046,
-0.0160989631,
-0.0050552585,
-0.0288634729,
0.0144386925,
-0.0598567724,
0.0724547356,
0.0481031984,
-0.0256431382,
0.0317570232,
0.0610792413,
-0.0479082651,
-0.0186661743,
-0.0206011347,
0.0076092193,
0.0376952402,
-0.0063354098,
-0.0239862856,
-0.0642638132,
-0.0550516471,
0.0295346603,
-0.0171998329,
0.021015143,
0.0213092715,
-0.0559366979,
0.0650837123,
0.0351965465,
0.0387157016,
-0.0614851266,
0.014181871,
0.0086109592,
-0.0651144832,
0.0103531061,
-6.047748356e-33,
0.0397338048,
-0.0470668152,
-0.0421590805,
0.0072660679,
-0.0040339734,
0.0193287097,
-0.0111711845,
0.00457027,
-0.0458337218,
0.0368513651,
-0.0084736561,
0.0400638394,
-0.0083999038,
0.0088889757,
-0.035226725,
0.0255500022,
0.0431445204,
-0.0154470652,
-0.0550292432,
0.0206059627,
0.0558660999,
-0.0079867495,
0.0235305559,
-0.0821523294,
0.0454562046,
-0.0154672498,
-0.058853779,
0.0023356704,
-0.004411004,
0.0213816408,
0.0057638045,
0.0406569876,
0.0376125425,
-0.0219482575,
0.0015103016,
0.0875803456,
-0.0179571509,
-0.0205861386,
0.0485662594,
-0.0017009244,
-0.0180629268,
-0.015387767,
0.0356070511,
-0.0119890906,
-0.0397759117,
-0.0145979477,
0.0292976834,
-0.0056210319,
0.0364275426,
0.0158937238,
-0.0460135229,
0.0211749971,
-0.0081665926,
-0.0052870624,
-0.0062447996,
0.0201545656,
0.0279843602,
0.0186525714,
-0.0707017779,
0.0273087602,
-0.0315556638,
0.0520648286,
-0.0013315803,
-0.0490892865,
-0.0121819666,
0.0424989462,
-0.0045043635,
0.037199121,
-0.0320006683,
0.0578825362,
-0.0283910464,
0.0387296453,
0.0467598997,
0.0842753798,
0.0084244469,
-0.0643328801,
-0.0485426262,
-0.0252573155,
0.0490699708,
0.0115283187,
0.0099512609,
-0.0457496494,
0.0004921301,
0.0130312536,
-0.0387514643,
-0.0236896165,
-0.046997834,
-0.0236313026,
-0.019393662,
0.0516831167,
-0.0361639969,
0.0231345166,
0.0006254116,
-0.0766109675,
-0.0104819452,
0.0167712718,
-0.0487932861,
0.0176128875,
0.0291195717,
0.0430770367,
-0.0313847736,
0.0307018533,
0.0200078934,
-0.008189138,
0.0228624474,
-0.0215007961,
0.0710352734,
0.0133309178,
-0.0460727997,
0.0038640837,
0.0006092351,
0.0431542248,
-0.0560119413,
-0.0276623052,
0.0389837027,
0.0386666991,
-0.0178133342,
-0.0418633558,
0.0224788543,
0.0540338121,
-0.0128850937,
-0.0093876598,
-0.0295095369,
-0.0027700267,
0.0088628223,
-0.0195947699,
0.0039982251,
0.0332203805,
0.0087629808,
-0.0614810586,
0.0334804431,
-0.0335868038,
2.525e-7,
0.0243292768,
0.0951074287,
-0.0234265178,
0.0256561171,
0.0241296347,
0.040267624,
0.0242132787,
0.0191978347,
-0.0102491295,
-0.1101991758,
0.0011937706,
0.0128814699,
0.0466606058,
-0.0009041142,
-0.083814472,
0.0425748117,
-0.0312297717,
-0.0095152259,
-0.0609781481,
0.0070412266,
0.0036459113,
0.0728322789,
0.0533007644,
-0.0263208803,
-0.0433122888,
-0.0345747061,
0.0636392161,
0.0101234224,
-0.0777890608,
0.0324798375,
0.0288677402,
-0.0095186969,
-0.0109009175,
-0.0228997525,
-0.0443013683,
0.016529005,
-0.0192713141,
0.0396896005,
0.0319595113,
-0.0101588741,
-0.0118897278,
-0.0442884564,
0.0268718582,
-0.0335032046,
0.061115887,
-0.0491374843,
-0.0354820378,
-0.1029584259,
-0.0201409049,
0.0122990003,
0.0360129774,
-0.0046319077,
-0.0508894175,
0.0291205477,
-0.0034473992,
0.0433935598,
0.0029044584,
-0.0593459792,
-0.0110433847,
0.0123859942,
-0.0428140685,
-0.0015352976,
-0.0124337003,
-0.0093519678,
0.0428880043,
-0.0288334806,
0.0671026856,
2.019336057e-34,
0.0375317596,
-0.0311063454,
0.0206731893,
-0.0278996658,
0.0236864351,
0.0209993795,
-0.0418323055,
-0.0082947388,
0.0065966272,
-0.0490825027,
0.0052937851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14224v1 | mmT5: Modular Multilingual Pre-Training Solves Source Language Hallucinations | 2023-05-23T16:38:01 | 2023-05-23T16:38:01 | Jonas Pfeiffer, Francesco Piccinno, Massimo Nicosia, Xinyi Wang, Machel Reid, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual sequence-to-sequence models perform poorly with increased
language coverage and fail to consistently generate text in the correct target
language in few-shot settings. To address these challenges, we propose mmT5, a
modular multilingual sequence-to-sequence model. mmT5 utilizes
language-specific modules during pre-training, which disentangle
language-specific information from language-agnostic information. We identify
representation drift during fine-tuning as a key limitation of modular
generative models and develop strategies that enable effective zero-shot
transfer. Our model outperforms mT5 at the same parameter sizes by a large
margin on representative natural language understanding and generation tasks in
40+ languages. Compared to mT5, mmT5 raises the rate of generating text in the
correct language under zero-shot settings from 7% to 99%, thereby greatly
alleviating the source language hallucination problem. | [
-0.0094912816,
0.0776095837,
0.0037453922,
-0.000864946,
-0.0078031071,
0.0212802254,
0.0322747305,
-0.027729271,
-0.0489434376,
-0.0256729666,
-0.0316142663,
-0.0754692927,
-0.0058570779,
0.0019986122,
0.0536559671,
-0.0548310764,
0.0637936592,
-0.0306080338,
-0.0764028057,
0.0125223491,
0.0015173383,
0.0178836063,
0.0087780021,
0.0156482905,
0.0069570476,
-0.0169458836,
-0.0062957872,
-0.0047417306,
0.0242369082,
-0.0075446996,
-0.0244405009,
0.0867779851,
0.0236613862,
0.054938741,
0.0000019591,
-0.0120163886,
-0.0032636421,
-0.0029724108,
-0.0048515704,
0.0050159968,
0.0327622928,
-0.0366181396,
-0.0043863426,
0.0030181468,
-0.0156711936,
-0.0276696254,
0.0488192141,
0.017633725,
0.0343100876,
0.0792127848,
-0.0148234935,
-0.0341087058,
0.0101557318,
-0.049074091,
0.0840978473,
-0.0032723953,
0.0157007184,
0.0200365577,
-0.0017950935,
-0.0233482774,
-0.0267063379,
0.0311049372,
0.0381934084,
0.0166731831,
0.002634997,
0.0258936882,
-0.0284144655,
-0.0535289384,
0.007519993,
0.0642857254,
-0.0600473583,
-0.0328758135,
0.00059784,
-0.0144015793,
-0.0036605969,
-0.0370948575,
-0.0463730358,
0.0470910147,
0.0195396952,
0.0051296474,
0.0264438149,
-0.0029699567,
0.0436450988,
-0.0148716373,
-0.0491243675,
0.0028594111,
0.0451698154,
0.0066805785,
-0.0093598552,
0.0169731565,
-0.010569999,
-0.0474439971,
0.0171573386,
0.020451447,
-0.029393062,
0.0145717356,
-0.0889668092,
-0.051687412,
0.0202165525,
-0.0331112891,
0.0204752609,
0.05057339,
-0.0371899717,
0.0120141217,
-0.0441266969,
0.0089035667,
-0.0156092206,
0.0232403539,
-0.0494430773,
-0.0167975724,
-0.0450096093,
0.0041494593,
-0.0295163803,
0.0050466447,
-0.0443579964,
-0.0107205594,
-0.0166164283,
0.0008502045,
0.0060283639,
-0.0189583022,
-0.0242547467,
-0.0010856219,
-0.0701622292,
-0.0257316809,
0.0169661157,
0.0688363239,
-0.0306387823,
-0.0178524517,
0.0545633808,
-0.064873144,
-0.0627402887,
0.0371539742,
0.0115579544,
-0.0438010991,
0.0091267973,
0.0645376071,
-0.0451130867,
-0.0146396384,
-0.0194548294,
-0.0144744571,
-0.0284583718,
-0.0844163969,
0.0502680987,
-0.0592335723,
0.0561807193,
-0.0061976109,
-0.009270913,
-0.0069719967,
0.0016366816,
-0.0074807028,
0.0090316832,
0.0471472666,
-0.0014024116,
-0.025744969,
0.0025163556,
0.0302454494,
0.0153658586,
0.0653918833,
-0.0041878456,
0.0326698795,
-0.0064282594,
-0.0054110563,
0.0152106117,
0.0293365121,
0.0256184377,
0.0175060183,
0.0036327157,
-0.0186389126,
0.0354361422,
0.0158156957,
0.0496442169,
-0.0103627881,
-0.0398279428,
0.0140055567,
0.0420185737,
-0.0006334268,
0.0259565338,
0.0343574323,
0.0837498084,
-0.019218659,
-0.0373774283,
0.0272990726,
-0.0301672332,
0.0696548745,
-0.0159870554,
0.0144094257,
0.0303302407,
0.0688762069,
-0.0436992422,
0.0051292754,
0.0170413703,
-0.0073599475,
0.0020663887,
-0.0091247074,
0.0313857831,
0.0386314429,
-0.0547996312,
0.0846392065,
0.0374591611,
-0.0533172637,
0.0583786294,
0.0102022244,
0.0093972124,
0.059231516,
0.0154959308,
0.0048397952,
-0.0578362048,
-0.0260985419,
0.0056648063,
0.0711677447,
0.0290749092,
0.0248495825,
0.0690114871,
-0.0553571284,
-0.0110708065,
-0.0325516649,
0.0219745152,
0.0693094879,
-0.0310496818,
0.0272793807,
0.0332631096,
-0.0116667887,
-0.0048985509,
0.0265916269,
-0.0754806548,
-0.0064925933,
0.0126682939,
-0.0148856929,
0.0331682414,
-0.0160549916,
-0.0086548496,
0.0091267852,
-0.0068123667,
-0.0356262401,
-0.0047412701,
0.0293963552,
-0.1054689586,
-0.0677419081,
0.019687131,
-0.0249279775,
0.0177015588,
-0.0176986158,
-0.0222263206,
-0.0615930967,
0.0492043979,
0.006223972,
-0.0054898104,
-0.0540118441,
0.0181331784,
0.034153726,
0.0736992955,
0.019922154,
0.0476875938,
-0.0085825194,
-0.0121884914,
0.0396963134,
-0.0029568516,
0.0276279766,
-0.0080422936,
0.0054234187,
0.036382854,
-0.0013586547,
0.0016258972,
0.0041601341,
0.0141686536,
-0.0404862501,
-0.0142986244,
-0.0780085102,
0.0251163859,
-0.0298788287,
0.0129629215,
0.0436579026,
0.0188310929,
0.0127374809,
0.0178798139,
-0.0493105799,
0.0142822471,
0.0332636572,
0.013738649,
0.0088607688,
0.0120265428,
0.03284017,
-0.0216600168,
-0.0058674607,
0.0276409965,
0.049722787,
-0.0400008783,
-0.0133955292,
-0.056008406,
0.0012441316,
-0.0657773763,
-0.0009019595,
-0.0140510248,
-0.040522892,
-0.0137156919,
-0.0277307015,
0.0667231977,
0.001388169,
-0.0111913066,
-0.0061468827,
0.0590703525,
-0.052729927,
-0.0207787883,
0.0107534826,
-0.0075210449,
0.046422787,
-0.0251844022,
-0.0295930915,
-0.0053893351,
0.076133959,
-0.006877468,
-0.0112479841,
-0.0929622725,
0.0037609823,
0.013950686,
-0.0322245955,
0.0362234376,
0.0247231983,
-0.0029982119,
0.0174199976,
-0.0396028422,
-0.0148642268,
0.0323083773,
-0.0454747863,
-0.0289630108,
-0.0336019173,
0.0139693255,
-0.023162568,
0.0138632134,
0.0339880995,
0.0243646838,
0.0034628867,
-0.0292988215,
-0.0610773414,
0.0150340805,
0.0049553197,
-0.0039017771,
0.0185332093,
-0.0258287415,
-0.0147457514,
-0.040954981,
0.0015240574,
-0.0170527902,
0.0080377636,
0.0379813462,
0.0340358689,
0.0131848361,
-0.0024706488,
-0.0583072826,
-0.0224532038,
0.0356428362,
0.0606730096,
-0.0154673466,
0.0068209907,
-0.0274103824,
0.0328583196,
0.0309982225,
0.0002579053,
0.0425698347,
-0.0669126213,
0.0244000461,
0.0207697917,
0.0021612311,
0.0290143043,
-0.0188203733,
0.0050735585,
0.005803457,
0.0002512535,
-0.0356495976,
0.0170623586,
0.0636237785,
-0.0542035028,
-0.0304473545,
0.0755194873,
-0.0047063944,
-0.029760275,
-0.0016480673,
-0.0116683617,
0.0807215944,
-0.0079134675,
0.0351165868,
-0.1037748381,
-0.0278428942,
-0.0028644905,
-0.0173049103,
0.0183187146,
-0.0136851473,
-0.0174558181,
-0.0975089371,
0.0220457278,
0.0462227017,
-0.0988038853,
-0.0180954076,
0.0174115151,
-0.0597128384,
0.0315285139,
0.0436628498,
-0.0054176897,
0.0006886173,
0.0069569894,
0.0334883817,
0.0014626961,
-0.0686131343,
0.0248797853,
-0.0125744743,
0.0507084206,
0.0633678585,
0.00668306,
0.016553374,
-0.0254879575,
0.0067839613,
-0.0275295656,
-0.009386885,
0.0030207054,
0.0467818603,
0.0092048915,
-0.0134023856,
0.0382967852,
0.0024750459,
-0.0238421075,
-0.019559361,
-0.0216995664,
0.0653696209,
0.0052125365,
-0.0563164279,
0.0010618616,
0.0366536565,
0.0040321653,
0.0584053993,
0.0416400991,
-0.0283254515,
-0.0331102647,
-0.0113645075,
0.0254636407,
-0.0946675763,
0.0059437081,
0.0262821075,
0.0072201123,
-0.0696902275,
-0.0873209909,
-0.060883604,
0.0075872024,
0.0525897667,
0.0029897837,
0.0121430997,
-0.0587551072,
-0.0259977542,
0.0072389222,
0.0264646988,
-0.0423129946,
-0.0408357829,
-0.0406991802,
-0.0171926655,
0.0202961192,
-0.0640215799,
-0.004921631,
0.0107657975,
-0.1355329007,
-0.0634938776,
-0.020999901,
0.0815122575,
0.0107909469,
0.0608475432,
0.0056769503,
-0.0328684449,
0.034543328,
0.0408639908,
-0.0223047398,
-0.000427885,
0.0469617732,
-0.0209213346,
-0.0064017288,
0.0330570005,
-0.0168486778,
0.0313470028,
0.0318004005,
0.0457679406,
0.0038559989,
0.0181996841,
0.0056755021,
-0.0289397389,
-0.0221724231,
-0.0284528304,
0.0027681214,
-0.0300817955,
-0.0047414708,
-0.0218360666,
-0.0004525616,
-0.0646510124,
-0.0245407969,
0.0635721907,
-0.0159576107,
0.0268400796,
0.0203302018,
0.0039372449,
0.0246420205,
-0.005687899,
-0.0334585868,
-0.0060482277,
0.0157270916,
0.018811034,
0.0154630141,
-0.0078639537,
0.0003216159,
-0.0195646025,
0.0278124716,
-0.0637765303,
0.0453064926,
-0.0025395697,
0.0116048818,
0.0057924618,
0.0128134917,
-0.0288336165,
-0.0412136987,
-0.0406689122,
0.0244546831,
0.0707133636,
0.0014955311,
0.1118914932,
-0.0069978731,
0.0064650201,
-0.0117918961,
0.0536166653,
-0.0094153713,
-0.0321335532,
-0.0171077792,
-0.005818374,
0.0053200843,
-0.0135904504,
0.0864597857,
0.0031325845,
0.0403768495,
0.0145111224,
0.021181168,
-0.0173119865,
-0.0386175662,
0.0195637774,
-0.0281357877,
-0.0181289241,
-0.0084187165,
-0.0132275717,
-0.0363629386,
0.0171437822,
-0.0227992553,
-0.0106646009,
0.0299366955,
0.0255102813,
0.0612044185,
-0.0571453795,
-0.0330884345,
-0.025610989,
0.0104291923,
0.0582458079,
-0.0039442764,
0.0217940789,
-6.585189883e-33,
-0.0528855287,
0.0131190317,
0.0404146053,
-0.03162935,
-0.0406349674,
-0.0611397736,
-0.0489056557,
0.0069733784,
-0.0029683891,
-0.0103598395,
0.0229955427,
-0.0101273861,
0.0041610566,
0.0552951247,
0.0269049201,
-0.0082150698,
0.0699347258,
0.0066224448,
-0.0241051055,
0.0622798577,
0.0497785136,
0.0401331596,
0.0990492851,
0.0176322684,
-0.0247228984,
-0.0062213312,
-0.0113097345,
-0.0385635048,
-0.0044442657,
0.002843682,
-0.0173570011,
0.0022865979,
0.0095393527,
-0.0346628092,
-0.0795569047,
-0.0190523081,
-0.0483476706,
-0.0298974998,
-0.0071145878,
0.0151978284,
-0.0107874991,
-0.0569591746,
0.0500608571,
-0.0416965708,
0.045547232,
-0.0193124898,
0.030073544,
-0.0043114931,
-0.0415685102,
-0.0177298505,
-0.0991501883,
-0.0064347521,
-0.0078098923,
-0.0026950354,
0.0096899355,
0.1038573682,
-0.009618069,
-0.0000998529,
-0.0542668551,
0.0042683454,
0.0001293337,
0.0453714356,
0.0510878563,
0.0139888776,
0.0079832077,
0.0379290096,
0.0568622686,
-0.0027587223,
0.0115494067,
0.0252277609,
0.0481572635,
0.0201092809,
0.022578977,
0.02951397,
0.0616774336,
0.0101190237,
-0.0478270128,
0.0123980055,
-0.0454580635,
0.0250523351,
0.0317008495,
0.0124982437,
0.0501059517,
-0.0181571953,
-0.0090927714,
-0.041826494,
-0.0055910419,
-0.0591682121,
0.0383961536,
0.0273217261,
-0.009109268,
-0.0009224961,
0.1034123302,
0.002575381,
-0.0071037086,
0.0322960466,
-0.0523035638,
0.0139353378,
-0.0077978852,
0.0247322731,
-0.0741190687,
-0.0341612883,
0.0602932163,
0.0002673292,
-0.0069850278,
0.0234413873,
0.0416914001,
0.0284245498,
-0.0383193605,
0.0077047423,
-0.0715248138,
0.043076735,
0.0098436428,
0.0589676127,
0.0259675048,
-0.0222967546,
-0.0329646356,
0.0203635804,
0.0012922401,
-0.0397152044,
0.0065169344,
0.0141944597,
0.0131272543,
0.0337174945,
-0.0244012382,
0.0195415765,
-0.0696760863,
-0.0347926281,
0.0509616062,
-0.0366504006,
-0.0132197132,
0.014649136,
2.638e-7,
0.0190866459,
0.0103377365,
-0.0007090323,
-0.028095996,
0.0185983405,
0.0125082685,
-0.0333816893,
0.034983974,
0.0145675428,
0.0081396187,
0.0083793029,
0.0280956682,
0.0583024062,
0.041939564,
-0.0479882061,
0.0066920593,
-0.0287593044,
0.040954493,
-0.0581178479,
-0.055605337,
0.0079359375,
0.0685490295,
-0.0338637605,
-0.0142795667,
0.0512206294,
-0.0467831977,
0.1095395982,
0.0069581228,
-0.0338706598,
0.0263350476,
-0.0044774273,
0.0316262394,
-0.0225735344,
-0.0199683625,
-0.0526202507,
-0.023431614,
0.0196889341,
0.0479362868,
0.0078866342,
-0.0654171333,
0.0090899523,
0.019609008,
-0.0160368159,
-0.0232853368,
0.0486134514,
-0.0440063998,
0.0000604527,
-0.0094982712,
-0.0649316013,
0.0323660858,
0.0454982556,
-0.0356878377,
-0.0157785509,
0.0301845167,
0.0397661254,
0.0192415994,
-0.0498308763,
-0.0347986519,
-0.009263047,
-0.0139402328,
-0.053483326,
0.0075288569,
-0.0500243641,
-0.0369793959,
0.0043481332,
-0.0471238568,
-0.0174916796,
2.469471645e-34,
0.0093641784,
-0.0168683771,
0.0164559595,
-0.0073517771,
0.015152432,
-0.0175147336,
-0.0091992039,
0.0279930159,
-0.0087753702,
-0.0376893021,
-0.0436756983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14221v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14221v3 | Question Answering as Programming for Solving Time-Sensitive Questions | 2023-05-23T16:35:16 | 2023-10-20T13:21:53 | Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Bei Chen, Siheng Li, Jian-Guang Lou, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering plays a pivotal role in human daily life because it
involves our acquisition of knowledge about the world. However, due to the
dynamic and ever-changing nature of real-world facts, the answer can be
completely different when the time constraint in the question changes.
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable intelligence in
question answering, while our experiments reveal that the aforementioned
problems still pose a significant challenge to existing LLMs. This can be
attributed to the LLMs' inability to perform rigorous reasoning based on
surface-level text semantics. To overcome this limitation, rather than
requiring LLMs to directly answer the question, we propose a novel approach
where we reframe the $\textbf{Q}$uestion $\textbf{A}$nswering task
$\textbf{a}$s $\textbf{P}$rogramming ($\textbf{QAaP}$). Concretely, by
leveraging modern LLMs' superior capability in understanding both natural
language and programming language, we endeavor to harness LLMs to represent
diversely expressed text as well-structured code and select the best matching
answer from multiple candidates through programming. We evaluate our QAaP
framework on several time-sensitive question answering datasets and achieve
decent improvement, up to $14.5$% over strong baselines. Our codes and data are
available at https://github.com/TianHongZXY/qaap | [
0.0471925735,
0.083267957,
-0.0132586965,
0.0087303994,
-0.0303489454,
0.0124550126,
-0.0096506383,
0.001180524,
-0.0074161226,
-0.0466625877,
0.0121348063,
0.0059077488,
-0.0157345701,
0.0322497375,
0.0008992509,
-0.0199144576,
0.0708502233,
-0.0178239886,
0.0147906691,
-0.0070732841,
0.0345198177,
0.0247933157,
-0.0244412515,
0.0585605167,
0.0107208686,
-0.0292302556,
0.0032831174,
-0.0269695409,
0.0194290765,
-0.0031071545,
0.0405346155,
0.0300474502,
0.0236206781,
-0.0220312197,
0.0000019904,
-0.0289228093,
-0.0136185791,
-0.0187798534,
-0.0468967482,
0.0105871689,
0.0169682242,
0.0246866494,
0.0412190072,
0.0432173982,
-0.0862832293,
-0.008793599,
0.0411116034,
0.0008100992,
0.076156795,
0.0666203201,
0.0141130071,
0.001705855,
0.0220363587,
0.0132118501,
0.0390359797,
-0.0802036151,
0.0179919079,
0.0221296772,
0.0474269055,
0.0383059047,
-0.0048147286,
0.0227019545,
0.0233736932,
0.0119557744,
0.0450629741,
0.0368925966,
-0.0488533974,
0.0311973598,
-0.0351818912,
0.0992001817,
0.0217257999,
-0.0428943411,
0.0075245393,
0.0201964453,
-0.0047506704,
-0.0275779516,
-0.0452413522,
-0.0044990676,
0.0069966661,
0.0220045466,
0.0272384603,
0.034149725,
-0.0026608519,
0.0561621301,
0.0060756207,
0.0812482089,
0.0016487332,
-0.0202329233,
-0.0295441505,
-0.0104176486,
-0.0099344505,
-0.0620800257,
0.0284594949,
0.0888053253,
-0.0280439854,
0.0172154196,
-0.027119495,
0.0239927601,
0.0160190072,
-0.0127166277,
0.0127997929,
0.0534307472,
0.0409320481,
0.0611242279,
-0.0053657135,
0.0696535036,
-0.0186959188,
-0.0193268172,
-0.0743776113,
-0.040120475,
-0.0678301603,
-0.0494101606,
-0.0194711145,
0.0223364625,
-0.0502923839,
-0.0041273977,
-0.0203342531,
0.0309503265,
0.0071623144,
0.004610254,
-0.0293033253,
0.0725940987,
-0.0395996794,
0.0117234439,
-0.070780158,
0.0273657553,
-0.0666131824,
0.0016187771,
-0.0198973287,
-0.0464623049,
-0.0204278082,
0.0002454136,
0.0027799367,
-0.0507467389,
0.0255869087,
0.0690169409,
-0.0370914638,
-0.0168313496,
-0.0104503706,
-0.0289120879,
-0.0316572525,
-0.0067917714,
-0.0032442019,
-0.0932112038,
0.047664322,
0.0248572696,
-0.0274530482,
-0.0183290057,
0.0090211853,
0.0501769148,
-0.0031370816,
0.0638823286,
0.0201630108,
0.0382972583,
0.0478117093,
0.0062821163,
0.0116630346,
0.0511633903,
0.0377323702,
-0.0214825533,
0.0399314277,
0.0135475174,
0.0014899969,
0.0093856379,
0.0139665967,
0.0130963661,
-0.0197443217,
0.0842955038,
0.0261633117,
0.0106907627,
0.0281992331,
-0.0046091191,
-0.0114273299,
-0.060299553,
0.0238512345,
0.0439207815,
-0.046065066,
0.0349777564,
0.0096067814,
0.0136478264,
0.0178634413,
-0.0342766941,
-0.0061766971,
0.0582288653,
-0.0508263037,
0.0018563301,
-0.0105890771,
0.0312200245,
-0.0573872142,
-0.0539449193,
-0.0060086627,
-0.0011735917,
0.0230632555,
0.0419400781,
0.0072601568,
0.0270583592,
-0.0110499384,
0.0422113687,
0.0065601096,
0.0239957068,
-0.0250756238,
-0.0448115654,
0.0353975259,
0.0573728681,
0.0457574725,
-0.0606492274,
-0.0212061871,
-0.0078606801,
0.0379331484,
-0.0026754027,
0.0419804044,
-0.0366721302,
0.007329768,
-0.0087606451,
0.0024378519,
-0.0263583846,
-0.0327234864,
-0.0029112911,
0.0743111223,
0.0278567523,
-0.0003495858,
-0.0160118546,
-0.0028473923,
0.0339250341,
-0.0223013684,
-0.0297737401,
-0.0072151134,
-0.0132393399,
0.0195813179,
0.0074598049,
-0.0025784748,
0.0484306365,
0.0404133908,
-0.0632929057,
-0.0337442458,
-0.032226257,
-0.047528483,
-0.0440264717,
0.0406569019,
-0.0098413574,
-0.0440897942,
0.0543252528,
-0.062648572,
-0.0269404668,
0.0305809826,
-0.0317779444,
0.0230964851,
-0.0072744694,
-0.0314522088,
0.0212040283,
0.0202410836,
-0.0896569118,
0.0701075718,
0.012906055,
0.0337106846,
-0.0040151868,
0.024550112,
-0.0279099531,
-0.030646883,
0.0059588426,
0.0026514053,
0.0023156905,
0.0120794792,
0.0336126499,
0.0300560035,
-0.0537553877,
-0.0079917544,
-0.0612837188,
0.0157781411,
0.0129130734,
0.024848057,
0.0221340843,
0.011619309,
0.0076559456,
-0.016453404,
-0.0650322288,
-0.017802313,
0.0083424393,
0.0095211267,
0.0671964809,
0.0028746289,
-0.0027331389,
-0.0274391044,
-0.0206477512,
-0.0354333296,
0.0577439293,
-0.0069237384,
0.0022466856,
-0.0456629023,
-0.0188982654,
-0.0524309203,
0.0046699746,
0.018470319,
-0.0145693962,
0.0001832261,
-0.0101191439,
0.0323749222,
0.0860038102,
0.0179855265,
-0.0218848418,
0.0415281244,
0.0127169089,
-0.0732114241,
0.0448361412,
-0.030609889,
-0.0140269138,
0.0034399561,
-0.0483528636,
0.0093245953,
0.0577694476,
0.0053523737,
-0.0011096915,
-0.0542254969,
0.0608377941,
-0.0120592546,
0.0078372322,
-0.0371040031,
0.0171136316,
0.0004076702,
0.0526418127,
-0.0360245556,
-0.036638137,
0.0918295383,
0.0314751193,
-0.0183228161,
-0.0638573021,
-0.0214643907,
-0.0562730767,
0.0671021044,
-0.0386944935,
0.0221208725,
-0.0180471092,
-0.0142578436,
-0.0513165928,
-0.0506425463,
-0.0244719703,
-0.0594742745,
0.0486186668,
-0.044883389,
0.0216110256,
-0.0160143878,
-0.0481369048,
-0.0479151607,
-0.0518374331,
-0.0563230701,
-0.0004731369,
-0.0640044808,
0.0078983922,
-0.0068738349,
0.0085584559,
-0.0104316631,
-0.0171340052,
-0.0227717943,
-0.0381064825,
0.0019022697,
0.0622256249,
0.0654223487,
0.0265352745,
0.0227102116,
0.0458957627,
0.035800688,
0.0525395609,
0.0849387944,
0.0145701068,
-0.039376203,
0.0116672944,
0.0135645773,
-0.0142345252,
0.0130534144,
0.011995215,
0.0292543489,
-0.0310198031,
-0.0498286113,
0.1005734727,
0.0779556185,
-0.0066851159,
0.0199470222,
-0.0377658196,
0.0332465805,
0.0365526043,
0.051101923,
-0.0537437722,
-0.0730526969,
-0.0061921822,
0.0246826597,
-0.0144662261,
-0.0479447097,
-0.0044808132,
-0.0837397054,
-0.0113381473,
-0.0031829835,
-0.0275986381,
-0.0329903141,
-0.0417242758,
-0.0109968837,
-0.0070252013,
0.0037556444,
0.0170494318,
-0.0178992189,
0.0214264914,
0.0207278095,
-0.0283431485,
0.0055581573,
0.0964004397,
0.0293450244,
0.0332941301,
0.0788360685,
0.0294637121,
-0.0087541007,
-0.0358960368,
-0.0289552696,
-0.0375230238,
-0.0176999755,
-0.0399933159,
-0.0147397965,
-0.013809476,
-0.0305197593,
-0.0252787843,
0.0458893105,
-0.0468078703,
-0.0340462811,
0.0461603403,
0.0795710608,
-0.0175787937,
0.0080128536,
-0.0523357205,
-0.0015486458,
-0.0027120502,
0.0782044753,
0.0033091668,
-0.0446522497,
-0.0626527593,
-0.0252220612,
-0.0212441795,
-0.0676706582,
-0.0501926914,
0.0104228593,
0.0262296554,
0.0416026711,
-0.0808738247,
0.0030973624,
0.0334347747,
-0.0070343153,
-0.0228324682,
-0.0040396829,
0.0143359043,
0.0074499911,
-0.0824526772,
0.0268300939,
-0.0409683958,
0.0267897118,
-0.0064381724,
-0.0200190265,
0.0116800275,
-0.0364529379,
-0.0213257316,
0.0311162546,
-0.0866571665,
-0.030208014,
0.0026139084,
0.0024945191,
0.0242933966,
0.0160113983,
-0.0150207104,
-0.0156108569,
-0.0117970333,
0.0149019044,
-0.0281378739,
0.0161550026,
-0.0028586667,
0.0429818444,
0.0049344231,
0.0404203162,
-0.0689983144,
-0.0010255765,
0.0066764411,
0.0625317916,
-0.0539721921,
-0.00836307,
0.0403613411,
0.0044723176,
-0.0323827788,
0.0325668231,
-0.0281970594,
0.0083435122,
-0.0128853237,
0.0202766769,
-0.0279428717,
-0.0269285459,
0.0098945294,
0.0170985479,
-0.0509641655,
0.0241863336,
-0.0076479404,
-0.0172014609,
0.0090171723,
-0.0064734994,
0.0009425583,
0.0353884771,
0.01622447,
0.0006171545,
-0.0237282831,
-0.0247619171,
-0.0103585692,
-0.0254180394,
0.0451401733,
-0.0256243739,
0.0178681221,
0.0071154605,
-0.0107009243,
-0.0623438731,
-0.0075984453,
-0.0978631824,
-0.0579480194,
0.0300838407,
0.0194423031,
0.0271895565,
-0.002484367,
-0.004431535,
-0.0137400953,
-0.0189340301,
-0.0068575628,
-0.0007461295,
0.0402479507,
-0.0041573104,
0.0671774894,
0.0311943293,
-0.0259785838,
0.0134405708,
0.085697718,
0.0081966482,
0.0396025255,
0.0502292551,
-0.0246849526,
-0.0342099406,
-0.0227794517,
-0.0090379231,
0.0045386855,
-0.0070689199,
0.0179923121,
-0.0503781959,
-0.0375072993,
0.0264026262,
-0.0093296329,
-0.0196037292,
-0.0132239386,
0.0223028641,
0.0524544977,
0.0358167514,
-0.0476797298,
-0.0569477417,
0.0494937636,
0.0036680917,
-0.0337756202,
-0.0374020487,
-6.434084492e-33,
-0.0121882698,
-0.0260303691,
0.0147183007,
-0.0276089869,
0.0108165182,
0.0407462306,
-0.0089042066,
-0.020058779,
-0.0442874879,
-0.0354664661,
-0.0242829584,
0.0316532254,
-0.00307728,
0.0185275022,
0.0203046873,
-0.0270580035,
-0.0172684342,
-0.0300853197,
-0.0010977947,
0.0259695947,
0.0197149403,
-0.0068468563,
0.0107009951,
0.0095621301,
-0.0082228938,
-0.0309349746,
0.005019791,
0.042614866,
-0.0076890835,
0.085084565,
-0.0420981459,
0.0389439762,
0.0391752943,
-0.0401646495,
0.0053042541,
0.0796091855,
-0.1108179316,
-0.0597650968,
0.0278157834,
-0.0268370565,
-0.0371088423,
-0.0361551456,
0.0081754494,
0.001029167,
0.0266255029,
-0.0178930517,
0.0277726296,
-0.0485323779,
-0.0104997335,
-0.011173496,
-0.0129115023,
0.0224367138,
-0.0615592971,
-0.0303451344,
-0.0264677722,
0.0553197525,
-0.0103722885,
0.0417301208,
-0.0383233465,
-0.0100848181,
-0.0116489343,
0.0240760632,
0.0335393436,
0.0178837311,
0.0143179651,
0.0240570288,
0.0044398741,
-0.0278752223,
0.0019144431,
0.0241754875,
-0.0239986125,
-0.0003448635,
0.0366389565,
0.0301156584,
0.0460815392,
-0.0157207139,
-0.1053745672,
0.0251452476,
0.0235056281,
0.0466145761,
0.0606774464,
0.0027811143,
-0.0367672928,
-0.007453687,
-0.0396871045,
0.071544677,
-0.0508144721,
0.025449343,
0.0353639573,
0.0211948175,
-0.03275536,
-0.0000900981,
0.0007475737,
-0.0555392727,
0.0021689723,
0.0240893457,
-0.0212229285,
-0.003945773,
0.03585485,
0.0553999618,
-0.0465649329,
0.0067398907,
0.0243178476,
-0.0400635228,
0.0268289186,
0.002491605,
0.0017735893,
-0.0022456087,
-0.0541031472,
-0.0126262652,
-0.0229569227,
0.0335356891,
-0.0157284439,
0.0064457348,
0.0227197818,
0.036262989,
-0.0089942692,
0.0218377747,
0.0024566294,
-0.0047183754,
-0.0215927865,
-0.0245139413,
0.0042822571,
0.028118981,
-0.0215461273,
0.0137788272,
-0.0394943394,
0.0414389558,
-0.0364720784,
-0.0165271256,
-0.0399483219,
0.0359768607,
2.554e-7,
0.0754229724,
0.0329539366,
0.0173291862,
0.0670464337,
0.003170748,
0.0210035965,
0.0022199701,
0.0442809388,
-0.0109603638,
-0.0114462031,
-0.0083525218,
0.0549578108,
0.0410277061,
0.028712837,
-0.0442539863,
-0.0019979195,
-0.0522179529,
-0.0031572843,
-0.0658279285,
-0.0209224783,
0.0898569524,
0.0897307843,
0.0204448719,
-0.0047861757,
-0.0209741723,
-0.0593961775,
0.0467446595,
0.0118510481,
0.0031159883,
0.0012209771,
-0.0212214384,
0.004358388,
0.0062554185,
0.0239171647,
0.0154966544,
0.0011977277,
0.002793662,
0.0635929778,
-0.0275968779,
-0.060209062,
-0.0353686735,
-0.0435463972,
0.0135731613,
-0.0601742566,
0.107161738,
-0.03519959,
-0.0363377482,
-0.0375531353,
-0.0037055563,
0.0152213937,
0.0149848005,
0.0043197735,
-0.0517949015,
-0.0068568145,
0.0145923086,
0.0080676368,
-0.0166992825,
-0.1011068448,
-0.0026736981,
0.0271921605,
-0.0172883514,
-0.0182557888,
-0.045702599,
0.0110259149,
0.0064253025,
-0.0677846596,
-0.0091035198,
2.577860948e-34,
-0.005163251,
0.0130239232,
-0.0191890337,
0.0503913648,
0.040614713,
-0.0079120863,
0.0045259208,
-0.021379048,
0.0367013551,
-0.0631423742,
-0.0142345978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14215v2 | Exploring Chain-of-Thought Style Prompting for Text-to-SQL | 2023-05-23T16:32:36 | 2023-10-27T15:21:38 | Chang-You Tai, Ziru Chen, Tianshu Zhang, Xiang Deng, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning with large language models (LLMs) has recently caught
increasing attention due to its superior few-shot performance on various tasks.
However, its performance on text-to-SQL parsing still has much room for
improvement. In this paper, we hypothesize that a crucial aspect of LLMs to
improve for text-to-SQL parsing is their multi-step reasoning ability. Thus, we
systematically study how to enhance LLMs' reasoning ability through chain of
thought (CoT) style prompting, including the original chain-of-thought
prompting (Wei et al., 2022b) and least-to-most prompting (Zhou et al., 2023).
Our experiments demonstrate that iterative prompting as in Zhou et al. (2023)
may be unnecessary for text-to-SQL parsing, and using detailed reasoning steps
tends to have more error propagation issues. Based on these findings, we
propose a new CoT-style prompting method for text-to-SQL parsing. It brings 5.2
and 6.5 point absolute gains on the Spider development set and the Spider
Realistic set, respectively, compared to the standard prompting method without
reasoning steps; 2.4 and 1.5 point absolute gains, compared to the
least-to-most prompting method. | [
0.0305308662,
0.039567817,
0.0213084072,
0.0194667,
-0.0265437327,
0.034068875,
0.0026665272,
-0.0114509836,
-0.0086750425,
-0.0607985035,
-0.0006242536,
-0.0389071032,
-0.0167941134,
0.0047586961,
0.0302882809,
-0.0357049182,
0.0366531424,
-0.0355936587,
0.0006895566,
0.0190988481,
-0.013414233,
0.0062713665,
0.0070993761,
-0.0102890152,
-0.008568191,
-0.0538055822,
-0.0407938994,
0.0272778161,
-0.0121909771,
-0.0650611743,
-0.0241183843,
0.0363834985,
0.0171017796,
0.0211270973,
0.0000023098,
-0.0861180052,
-0.07362023,
0.0100263506,
-0.0690059736,
0.0173794068,
0.0174350515,
-0.0346039608,
-0.0055729188,
0.0551136024,
-0.0403543711,
0.0002811839,
0.0111192744,
0.0402808003,
0.0385154523,
0.1042958125,
-0.0160433762,
-0.0492721014,
0.0086249653,
-0.0050894679,
0.0173901655,
-0.0585222095,
0.0161167849,
0.018051805,
0.0423743725,
0.026252741,
0.0118681071,
0.0192367639,
0.0206804797,
-0.0198031068,
-0.0118895769,
0.0202650465,
-0.0085727256,
-0.0055877399,
-0.0191102326,
0.0414868109,
-0.001061884,
-0.0172751471,
-0.0070675714,
0.0151030822,
-0.0033778786,
-0.0049065733,
-0.0167299751,
0.0520481728,
-0.0156251844,
0.0364842415,
0.0046651331,
0.0022996594,
-0.0003219192,
-0.0020900432,
-0.0685025379,
0.0420456454,
-0.0332256071,
-0.0535976328,
0.0458380096,
0.018959811,
-0.0089677032,
-0.0371335,
0.0210704375,
0.0381577872,
-0.0683503151,
0.0146192582,
-0.0169808306,
-0.0041360646,
-0.0104409223,
-0.0134761427,
0.0197385959,
0.058964327,
-0.0174831823,
0.0523986109,
-0.043649625,
-0.0012888483,
0.032167688,
0.0123762749,
-0.0427385531,
-0.0052372753,
-0.071555458,
0.0051657716,
-0.0561610013,
0.0440114699,
-0.0737739727,
-0.0393979512,
0.0084033469,
0.0147834402,
0.0060912231,
0.0684542879,
0.0212827232,
-0.0146541288,
0.0050637596,
-0.0059624333,
-0.0339144915,
0.006792435,
-0.0048821243,
0.0153131746,
0.0279884785,
-0.0468312874,
-0.0410021096,
-0.0028910835,
0.0091719963,
-0.0432508104,
0.0176374111,
0.0459563099,
-0.0349348411,
-0.0032898425,
-0.0874723941,
-0.0384164229,
0.0036120266,
-0.0297117718,
-0.0016842096,
-0.0544857383,
0.0385522805,
0.0155572053,
-0.0034173196,
0.0036748399,
-0.000169996,
0.0405164883,
0.0041403016,
0.0709777921,
-0.0396337211,
0.0111510875,
-0.0035070626,
-0.0122506833,
-0.0133308815,
0.0820376202,
0.005594979,
0.0293988865,
-0.0136814406,
0.0143337082,
-0.0270512905,
0.016320901,
0.0203674082,
0.0053664306,
-0.0378647856,
0.0308806058,
0.0121847894,
0.0350214131,
0.0400289111,
0.0618384406,
-0.0245945472,
0.0557751656,
0.0158877503,
0.0175191108,
0.0367654823,
0.0214272272,
0.0498889908,
0.0263617449,
0.0174723584,
-0.0199513417,
-0.0721697211,
-0.0075994842,
-0.037539091,
0.0562029667,
0.0011988524,
-0.0038283172,
-0.0137223685,
-0.0295462292,
-0.0122660957,
0.0110136205,
-0.0083948588,
0.0186015498,
0.0151920607,
0.0131765148,
-0.0526639,
0.0066258856,
-0.0041958154,
-0.0154704591,
-0.0148735633,
-0.020372903,
-0.0088868104,
0.0851144418,
0.0082316827,
-0.0306980927,
0.0129083497,
-0.0315269977,
0.0535986461,
0.0275450647,
-0.0123767192,
-0.0272512399,
-0.0336765945,
-0.0270800702,
-0.0223565977,
0.0300883818,
0.0145502808,
-0.0281615909,
0.0006061323,
-0.0115179522,
0.0126922131,
0.0222211014,
-0.013994216,
0.0366778448,
-0.0124935582,
-0.014433437,
-0.0095694494,
0.0075112167,
0.0134701021,
0.0342262872,
-0.0090759806,
0.0334687307,
0.0000803407,
-0.0133691551,
-0.0113686426,
-0.0333357453,
-0.0530234836,
-0.1045936719,
0.0208927654,
0.0301853865,
-0.026372809,
-0.0802395493,
-0.0503859892,
-0.0354214497,
-0.0474162698,
-0.0080452459,
0.0290174987,
-0.0311139338,
0.0416853353,
0.012875081,
-0.0552087091,
-0.0459470041,
0.0985625982,
-0.0076959343,
-0.0031033065,
0.0083642621,
0.0011782562,
-0.0018052174,
-0.0617804676,
0.0203699283,
-0.0057681752,
-0.0019326127,
0.0002550428,
-0.0531216338,
0.0393038392,
-0.0689039752,
0.0052551632,
-0.0721825361,
-0.0196292493,
-0.0398402698,
0.0396663025,
0.018783642,
-0.0027091766,
0.0027425068,
-0.0028014295,
-0.0343553387,
-0.0194031782,
-0.0216874387,
0.0246935207,
0.0457703248,
0.004464603,
-0.0100573814,
-0.005976168,
-0.0039934148,
-0.0734783858,
0.0567223728,
-0.0275612995,
-0.0648067892,
-0.0389749184,
0.0867955089,
0.0238834601,
0.0057994318,
0.0137690119,
0.0019900433,
0.0019319479,
-0.040281035,
0.0458808802,
0.0637685582,
-0.0068073007,
-0.0371824689,
0.0072520222,
-0.0099568898,
-0.049548801,
0.0227634124,
0.0139234252,
0.0176958442,
-0.0152724059,
-0.0230016354,
0.0207408797,
0.0421386808,
0.0011024965,
0.001141796,
-0.0363894477,
-0.0081030205,
0.023721572,
0.0116200894,
-0.0469888933,
-0.0132685043,
0.0060727266,
0.0346946791,
-0.0338549688,
0.008058575,
0.0864576176,
-0.0360255167,
-0.0220946223,
-0.0700596794,
0.0202086344,
-0.042659048,
0.0555072427,
-0.0086446181,
0.0111907274,
-0.0236901995,
-0.0686709136,
-0.0376024432,
-0.0116391694,
0.0174732972,
-0.0022503235,
0.0743771195,
-0.0350836813,
0.0207589325,
-0.0242729876,
-0.0266643818,
-0.0233121812,
-0.003969287,
-0.0554914512,
0.0365082882,
0.0220997427,
0.0097433217,
0.0503212139,
-0.0163697843,
0.0047508962,
0.0509772636,
0.0031598336,
-0.0281848367,
-0.0045249276,
-0.0325683281,
-0.0000074105,
0.0088892151,
0.0269046407,
-0.0247921217,
0.0925087556,
0.043733716,
0.0788194612,
-0.0365862474,
-0.0074983984,
0.0176733639,
-0.0043402668,
-0.0206155591,
-0.0242863335,
0.015242965,
0.0143986214,
-0.0685834065,
-0.0198753048,
0.1140110791,
0.0306059457,
-0.0148732197,
0.0112619037,
-0.021918755,
0.017439343,
0.0244355258,
0.0360535681,
-0.1178345904,
-0.0640423596,
0.0143485023,
0.0041246936,
0.0299722794,
-0.041656062,
0.0044488292,
-0.1553267241,
0.0241846424,
-0.0087939976,
-0.0000886716,
0.0191281084,
-0.008581168,
-0.0366719663,
-0.0017186246,
0.003717971,
0.0891874656,
-0.0415019952,
-0.0011473708,
0.0254325755,
0.0314394571,
-0.0637040883,
0.0098698968,
-0.0545183048,
-0.005620244,
0.0577963628,
-0.0136030251,
0.0309819113,
-0.0051600239,
0.060736604,
-0.0213170815,
0.012071955,
-0.0342151113,
0.0359819978,
0.0084800608,
0.0088529233,
0.0187922399,
0.0332027785,
-0.0215515606,
-0.0084376149,
0.0056663421,
0.0968691334,
-0.0458655395,
0.0176483877,
0.0177151468,
-0.0246372707,
0.0076795211,
0.0806041732,
0.0085678371,
-0.0268858969,
-0.0773246661,
-0.0351824425,
-0.0597145595,
-0.043151699,
0.0207716376,
0.0658773035,
-0.01532894,
-0.039831046,
-0.0656729639,
-0.033864364,
0.0715071857,
0.0865258127,
-0.0118047595,
0.0273464173,
0.0256974883,
0.0045156227,
0.0017510856,
-0.0082259411,
0.0011621101,
0.0070469463,
-0.0606024526,
0.0136587797,
0.0056249453,
-0.0365570225,
-0.0292343739,
-0.0256800447,
-0.0707378238,
-0.0174077805,
-0.0172573086,
-0.0064168423,
0.0207854211,
0.0348500907,
-0.0214715358,
-0.0455884226,
0.0104222894,
0.0448174253,
-0.0268116128,
-0.0420906544,
0.0266799126,
0.073261492,
0.0109697999,
0.0432416089,
-0.0274853222,
-0.0054120389,
-0.0240571089,
0.0513517223,
-0.0465713963,
0.032623522,
0.0654300824,
0.0499000624,
0.0287823211,
0.0261388086,
-0.0242831986,
-0.0111761345,
0.0527004488,
-0.0583487973,
-0.0581035838,
-0.044915922,
0.0238945726,
0.0301108975,
-0.0055731419,
0.0273810513,
-0.0322284475,
0.0240235515,
0.0251272991,
-0.0012013892,
0.0060553965,
0.0375618264,
0.0401710458,
0.0354219489,
-0.0380351543,
-0.0094445562,
0.0131776314,
0.0387127027,
0.037014883,
-0.0141626764,
0.0628640801,
0.0590794533,
-0.0064471941,
-0.0505955778,
-0.0049355077,
-0.0379741602,
-0.0318024457,
0.0044739516,
-0.005110295,
0.0424671583,
-0.013577641,
0.0443525463,
-0.0195451137,
-0.0056069773,
0.0048765512,
0.0193411447,
0.0453785062,
-0.0356083177,
0.0446069315,
0.0169338863,
-0.0230842978,
-0.0420546606,
0.051039625,
-0.0068807108,
0.0142927375,
-0.0121735726,
-0.0277487375,
-0.0252457075,
-0.0332063735,
-0.0222543553,
-0.0076801982,
-0.0152757596,
-0.0045253732,
-0.0388709046,
-0.0319801159,
-0.0100473948,
0.0023528771,
-0.0056103258,
-0.0103361746,
0.0681315288,
0.0919289142,
0.0390592664,
-0.0250850227,
-0.0189917181,
-0.0081658624,
0.0303965341,
-0.0610640571,
-0.045430284,
-6.652554525e-33,
-0.0136186052,
-0.0172627755,
0.0642904416,
-0.0135625061,
0.0135321897,
-0.0305395164,
-0.0461431816,
-0.0180447996,
-0.0380517654,
0.0222927518,
-0.0402561612,
0.0088254493,
0.0340208486,
0.0443628691,
0.0476106927,
-0.0226615667,
0.0438017882,
-0.024397919,
0.0088624647,
-0.0186514333,
0.0462980643,
0.0551565699,
0.030728437,
-0.0042545777,
0.0177939069,
0.024881674,
-0.028910201,
0.0546782278,
-0.0091007203,
0.0155632943,
-0.0030587334,
-0.0192993432,
0.0210382678,
-0.0050674984,
-0.0189553201,
-0.0062102554,
-0.1005571336,
-0.0086357398,
0.0257483888,
-0.0088485107,
-0.0214492474,
-0.0149783464,
0.0384164378,
-0.0357860066,
-0.009880485,
-0.0153155057,
-0.0109645613,
-0.0404574759,
-0.008640131,
-0.0551287234,
-0.0611388311,
0.032378424,
0.0283855796,
-0.0098047573,
0.0409103036,
0.060367696,
-0.0219487846,
0.0373368375,
-0.0493917875,
0.018541744,
-0.0032877789,
0.0480382927,
0.0556795299,
0.0220445003,
0.0118522281,
0.0197162349,
0.0026127158,
-0.015134057,
-0.0360291116,
0.068171002,
-0.0022571881,
0.0451558158,
0.0142185586,
0.0226579737,
0.0070094741,
0.0068836017,
-0.095727548,
0.0137202274,
-0.0080186082,
0.0147546558,
0.0010735334,
0.0139792664,
-0.0828432292,
-0.046116624,
-0.0088420538,
0.0105885183,
-0.0291496962,
-0.02360834,
0.0385785513,
-0.0015688826,
-0.0091208266,
-0.013969887,
0.035256587,
0.0034029931,
-0.0492387637,
0.0084377406,
-0.0335902423,
0.0078677386,
-0.0211460348,
0.010456861,
-0.0784623623,
-0.0538771451,
0.0016777503,
0.0422078781,
0.010248092,
0.0282422975,
0.0607034341,
0.0100029195,
-0.0873155892,
0.0168345124,
-0.0368889384,
0.056569878,
-0.0177991707,
0.0474794097,
0.0275252648,
-0.0270771757,
0.0233099367,
0.0574142002,
0.0003870813,
-0.0317823179,
-0.0161498673,
0.0263692811,
-0.0162077416,
0.0114841582,
0.0063171131,
0.0268767904,
0.0004363138,
-0.0032906383,
0.0190344807,
-0.0444213636,
0.0010395093,
0.062559396,
3.009e-7,
0.0491316728,
0.0450010635,
0.0230095051,
0.0291336197,
-0.0029788022,
0.0414679423,
-0.0157796629,
-0.0142650511,
0.0035277363,
-0.0104017612,
0.0123170642,
-0.0034311197,
0.0420954712,
0.0318735093,
-0.1052732617,
-0.031224614,
-0.0498091504,
-0.0029999099,
-0.0526417978,
-0.0064636506,
0.0690715685,
0.0745570213,
-0.0425181687,
-0.0031543872,
0.0307412967,
-0.0603291579,
0.0082944622,
0.0016591686,
-0.0150669273,
0.047758244,
-0.016101284,
-0.0285291169,
0.0012162618,
0.0322005115,
0.0039561349,
0.0362557359,
-0.0184542704,
0.0664179176,
0.0173667073,
0.0275371224,
0.0058603748,
-0.052662164,
0.0282125976,
-0.0431685485,
0.0810095221,
-0.0454578772,
-0.005050627,
0.0689207092,
0.0044040796,
-0.054328151,
-0.0240722094,
0.006698431,
0.0153624928,
-0.0195298865,
0.0239339713,
0.0007566846,
-0.0073730103,
-0.0548650436,
-0.0466374196,
0.0557545684,
-0.0083365673,
-0.028668236,
-0.0026912461,
0.0425471254,
0.0036815293,
-0.0375671759,
-0.0444378108,
3.149768337e-34,
0.040317703,
-0.0312211066,
0.0574432798,
0.044640962,
0.0506923683,
0.0271124486,
-0.0392661393,
0.0161425676,
0.0134106008,
-0.0933688357,
-0.0257403813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14214v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14214v2 | CompoundPiece: Evaluating and Improving Decompounding Performance of Language Models | 2023-05-23T16:32:27 | 2023-10-23T11:17:53 | Benjamin Minixhofer, Jonas Pfeiffer, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL | While many languages possess processes of joining two or more words to create
compound words, previous studies have been typically limited only to languages
with excessively productive compound formation (e.g., German, Dutch) and there
is no public dataset containing compound and non-compound words across a large
number of languages. In this work, we systematically study decompounding, the
task of splitting compound words into their constituents, at a wide scale. We
first address the data gap by introducing a dataset of 255k compound and
non-compound words across 56 diverse languages obtained from Wiktionary. We
then use this dataset to evaluate an array of Large Language Models (LLMs) on
the decompounding task. We find that LLMs perform poorly, especially on words
which are tokenized unfavorably by subword tokenization. We thus introduce a
novel methodology to train dedicated models for decompounding. The proposed
two-stage procedure relies on a fully self-supervised objective in the first
stage, while the second, supervised learning stage optionally fine-tunes the
model on the annotated Wiktionary data. Our self-supervised models outperform
the prior best unsupervised decompounding models by 13.9% accuracy on average.
Our fine-tuned models outperform all prior (language-specific) decompounding
tools. Furthermore, we use our models to leverage decompounding during the
creation of a subword tokenizer, which we refer to as CompoundPiece.
CompoundPiece tokenizes compound words more favorably on average, leading to
improved performance on decompounding over an otherwise equivalent model using
SentencePiece tokenization. | [
0.0017621637,
0.0507823266,
0.0044353642,
0.0304398052,
-0.0560070127,
0.0197958015,
0.0168426223,
0.0297012385,
-0.0088324631,
-0.0122122848,
-0.0116414623,
-0.0523782335,
0.0050729727,
-0.0172480457,
0.0481532812,
-0.0528669432,
0.0768329799,
-0.0445048511,
0.0023792335,
0.0172150414,
0.0252576228,
0.0246846247,
-0.0087248329,
0.0234571286,
-0.0347560197,
-0.0130460989,
0.0145806121,
-0.0026555946,
-0.007048015,
0.0166208968,
0.002776769,
0.034459684,
-0.0357280858,
0.0786585063,
0.0000018206,
-0.0444990732,
-0.0419010147,
-0.0215889458,
0.0121579804,
0.0588763393,
0.082309179,
-0.061467126,
-0.0355333276,
0.0308235921,
0.0124141714,
-0.0121037066,
0.0464677587,
0.0227461699,
0.0373035632,
0.0521157868,
0.0032416917,
-0.0451646633,
0.0385744795,
-0.0206332393,
-0.0563200824,
-0.0063026934,
0.0151784057,
-0.0085838819,
-0.0484418161,
-0.0260640047,
-0.0361448638,
0.0137735801,
-0.021506723,
0.0195576418,
0.0272414349,
0.0227171145,
-0.0303836204,
-0.061019212,
0.0196298212,
0.0727193281,
-0.0937445387,
-0.0247726515,
0.0196291301,
-0.0263513122,
-0.0206139926,
-0.0217319224,
-0.0205188692,
0.0107026184,
-0.0042785099,
0.0270707216,
0.0587203577,
-0.0257694237,
0.0584011041,
0.0378472134,
-0.041299127,
0.0547253527,
0.0528941602,
-0.0281307809,
-0.001612999,
-0.0059171095,
-0.0066128401,
-0.0294636283,
-0.0086711235,
-0.0152316736,
-0.0222513229,
0.0080256173,
-0.0141090425,
-0.0673752874,
0.011878157,
-0.0134181008,
-0.0140463952,
-0.0081598805,
-0.0003347374,
0.0308006257,
-0.0195972957,
-0.0239441115,
0.0114030447,
-0.0171173997,
-0.0643703863,
-0.0386175141,
-0.0247216038,
0.016110681,
-0.015799202,
0.0436487496,
-0.0532119535,
-0.0561441444,
-0.0437776074,
-0.0340895057,
0.0215903837,
-0.0272833258,
0.0376084968,
-0.0291989818,
-0.0235336814,
-0.0232463554,
0.0436738096,
0.0522847995,
-0.0399501026,
0.0483075194,
0.003272498,
0.0052547716,
-0.0068202359,
0.0060234778,
0.0259123314,
-0.0102646919,
0.0414606817,
0.0135124605,
-0.0169875938,
-0.0295094009,
-0.0081052287,
-0.0186654255,
-0.0377097428,
-0.0294594485,
-0.0207519904,
-0.0993154794,
0.0723310336,
-0.0244739242,
0.0227903221,
-0.0590728,
0.0172436535,
-0.0102830445,
-0.0428903326,
0.1220501363,
-0.0649252683,
0.0065732994,
-0.0012003052,
0.0059024883,
0.025871098,
0.0521448515,
0.0624644682,
0.0306708235,
0.0784441531,
-0.0297211502,
0.0300925951,
0.0648073927,
-0.0215204842,
-0.0221012104,
-0.0208282452,
-0.0624545068,
-0.0147139942,
0.0204450171,
0.0571542121,
0.0696100071,
-0.0227219928,
0.038072817,
0.0007559214,
0.0332233422,
0.0608851314,
0.0263333302,
0.0376083851,
0.0243947804,
-0.0042589591,
0.0018576988,
-0.0011637583,
-0.0560546257,
-0.0127545064,
0.0344397388,
0.0504740216,
0.0420717001,
-0.0073737237,
-0.0246423911,
-0.014094797,
-0.0487069078,
0.040071886,
-0.0377567783,
0.0797100812,
0.025394205,
-0.0571369082,
0.0551828966,
0.0606295839,
-0.0894001946,
0.0423472598,
-0.0292365309,
0.0343667492,
0.0615010262,
0.0241396744,
-0.0184537489,
0.0245866012,
0.0037175599,
-0.0041934433,
0.0052698706,
-0.0320350677,
-0.0305950474,
0.0440919995,
-0.075229913,
0.0143839791,
0.0268546343,
0.027134601,
0.0060682511,
0.0097390739,
0.0059243636,
0.0171134509,
-0.0935531855,
0.0165351126,
0.0383687839,
-0.0101370765,
-0.0382621437,
0.0161349289,
0.0112530999,
0.0014210707,
0.0431021415,
-0.0094647855,
0.039702829,
0.0310187563,
-0.0418830067,
-0.0040793065,
-0.000013885,
0.0204067361,
-0.0683682635,
0.0315388665,
-0.0195275191,
0.0308768936,
0.0005532965,
-0.0139405001,
-0.0466849133,
0.0340880416,
-0.0065673953,
0.041120775,
-0.0525374077,
0.0408395119,
0.0343233533,
0.0269771069,
-0.0221450347,
0.0505677536,
0.0176518857,
0.0046524219,
-0.0517673306,
0.010348713,
-0.0216178317,
-0.0137264011,
-0.0020584504,
0.0223110393,
-0.0366224386,
0.0177426264,
0.0076444959,
-0.0121523822,
-0.0618289113,
-0.0350724533,
-0.0862135738,
-0.0001365784,
-0.0045296205,
0.012528115,
-0.0341902934,
0.0300025418,
-0.0078411829,
-0.009009609,
0.0306871478,
-0.0089305164,
0.0058536292,
0.0244056694,
-0.0014955257,
-0.0194106922,
-0.0530152991,
-0.0578046739,
-0.0394714773,
0.0102087334,
0.020565616,
-0.0217728037,
-0.0455757901,
-0.0307637118,
-0.0106191123,
-0.0179452691,
-0.0154976109,
0.026781043,
-0.0516198799,
-0.0073005697,
-0.0283262171,
0.0460248478,
0.0252417475,
0.0011086192,
-0.0263315775,
0.0224898905,
-0.0241268966,
-0.0209313072,
-0.0258796066,
-0.0206868779,
0.021425128,
-0.0024523498,
-0.0062281843,
0.0128479628,
0.083001405,
0.0221232846,
0.0232328828,
-0.0443718359,
0.0125367166,
-0.0463659726,
-0.0040156618,
-0.0284804329,
-0.032233648,
-0.0398744345,
0.0316769183,
0.0151669038,
-0.0258388445,
0.0264111068,
-0.0427126661,
0.0053472933,
-0.0497801229,
-0.0231728628,
-0.0260890797,
0.0565891936,
-0.0092068519,
0.0057686334,
0.0433525033,
-0.053289637,
-0.027097743,
0.0262677241,
0.0089281304,
-0.0345208459,
0.0214092787,
-0.0208435804,
-0.021907866,
-0.0124371555,
-0.0244376771,
-0.0093976017,
-0.0192531738,
-0.0235204026,
-0.0004390725,
0.0454452224,
0.0145946024,
0.010510819,
0.0192527846,
-0.0181508195,
0.0000747893,
0.0174729116,
0.0185442995,
-0.0084767379,
0.0892982259,
0.0306316912,
-0.0332878046,
0.0249146819,
-0.0516683161,
0.0413169414,
0.0179409888,
0.0979878008,
0.0033137687,
0.0128857726,
-0.0058239587,
0.0266708825,
-0.0264387894,
-0.0080987234,
0.000606477,
0.0344485752,
-0.0265233517,
0.0022696133,
0.1239447072,
0.0450464562,
-0.0276691895,
0.0158908051,
0.0236072671,
-0.0127063142,
-0.0095195221,
-0.0163091477,
-0.0655771941,
-0.0343057886,
0.0397535563,
0.0011249431,
0.0428283028,
-0.0244062636,
0.0132444892,
-0.1293246895,
0.0308118165,
0.0442474484,
-0.022118384,
0.0052222242,
-0.0302499738,
-0.0243534353,
-0.0696473643,
0.0267519765,
0.0227787066,
-0.0354972593,
0.0133645823,
0.0142243421,
-0.0726822019,
-0.0502136983,
-0.0062076603,
-0.0672257021,
0.0502823368,
0.0156181511,
0.0500901751,
-0.035676524,
-0.0036677588,
0.0624497719,
-0.0797360688,
-0.0347501896,
-0.0095363939,
0.0176530909,
-0.0138279628,
-0.0181862097,
0.0032009014,
0.0278154723,
-0.0400190093,
-0.0315417722,
0.02556004,
0.0409536809,
0.0410552025,
0.0038115135,
0.0075646136,
0.0059219683,
0.0051169368,
0.0665450022,
0.0159350503,
-0.022719726,
-0.0028601587,
-0.0035962746,
0.0015690844,
-0.0272469819,
-0.0073031858,
-0.0253669973,
-0.0110073294,
0.0333011895,
-0.095286876,
-0.0547045693,
0.0619964413,
0.0425903983,
0.0057119033,
0.0657779798,
-0.0329203494,
0.0106897522,
-0.0555322208,
0.0336589813,
0.0011451039,
0.0094992248,
-0.0741946548,
-0.0035254101,
-0.0110051017,
0.004825267,
-0.0196566507,
-0.0073434375,
-0.073075451,
-0.0562417507,
0.0236013476,
0.0155135393,
0.0214584135,
0.0282727517,
-0.0261424445,
-0.0319154635,
-0.0321717858,
0.0376131982,
-0.0560214594,
-0.0114997551,
0.0420159921,
-0.012530271,
-0.004294001,
0.0258949772,
-0.0273966398,
0.0371802934,
-0.0030986248,
0.0537350997,
-0.0091040665,
-0.0207990315,
-0.0092693884,
0.010362519,
0.0426185019,
-0.0934918001,
-0.0012340078,
-0.0467648357,
-0.0301685464,
-0.0057030721,
0.0001512643,
-0.0269301888,
0.0121589685,
0.0629638433,
-0.0180817153,
-0.028149914,
0.0467116013,
-0.0161478166,
-0.0056118886,
-0.0079396926,
0.0036014295,
-0.0084930891,
-0.0204757042,
0.0103146238,
-0.0167865474,
0.0013153282,
-0.0153515497,
-0.0351214856,
0.0140705351,
-0.0510589108,
-0.0316085964,
-0.0273427404,
0.0261447858,
-0.0778572559,
0.0404531471,
0.0285971202,
-0.0002315775,
-0.0392072089,
0.0144192362,
0.054554496,
-0.0439436473,
0.0749869794,
-0.0205910634,
-0.020922171,
-0.0276771467,
0.0334630124,
-0.023289917,
0.0229759105,
-0.0074281371,
0.0278001707,
-0.0643221587,
-0.0280268881,
0.0827070773,
0.0023025705,
0.0058247279,
0.0257047936,
0.0266305599,
-0.0284589659,
0.0012742048,
-0.0481078327,
0.0490758829,
-0.0480105467,
0.0113761732,
-0.0607719496,
-0.0491472743,
-0.0008965409,
-0.0125649683,
0.0002296682,
0.0196378846,
-0.0021665341,
0.0480723605,
0.0065586045,
0.0280997287,
-0.0127467168,
-0.0224776641,
0.0693316013,
-0.0500898063,
0.0247850437,
-5.780460777e-33,
-0.0070146276,
0.017282838,
-0.0135110198,
-0.0489972644,
-0.0357252471,
0.0180962887,
-0.0246338379,
0.0043980791,
0.0117927715,
-0.0080860844,
-0.0085209413,
-0.0007867581,
0.0401052646,
0.0137541713,
0.0585725307,
0.0453021862,
0.0428354889,
-0.0162170641,
-0.0129258689,
-0.0108360704,
0.0099972254,
0.0597922616,
0.0343627036,
0.0119764041,
-0.0262952875,
0.0208222196,
-0.0413233973,
0.0087100957,
0.0478304476,
0.069954522,
-0.0299574807,
0.0229690131,
0.0119846314,
0.0005969098,
-0.0100856274,
0.0655655786,
-0.0915743336,
0.0053310823,
0.0401233099,
-0.0362934582,
-0.0287598502,
-0.0361595526,
0.0270122364,
0.0001949888,
-0.0047069225,
-0.0083338851,
0.0016447897,
-0.0433431342,
-0.0052406997,
-0.0013970354,
-0.1114976704,
0.034375824,
-0.0072889267,
-0.0045337966,
0.0725607425,
-0.0281435847,
0.0136829503,
0.0011767716,
-0.0674923435,
0.0326936133,
0.0157319978,
0.0588802174,
0.0382889993,
0.0175869875,
-0.0301873907,
0.0520940609,
0.0658046901,
-0.0363951996,
0.016340645,
0.0295451507,
0.059336897,
0.0686361045,
0.0701568872,
0.0428733565,
0.0546880439,
-0.0225124583,
-0.0400232449,
0.0038020997,
0.0171152689,
-0.0067619369,
-0.0013087941,
0.0322930589,
-0.0449155793,
-0.0086482549,
-0.0000678566,
0.0041146139,
-0.0296220798,
-0.0194955487,
0.0371574685,
0.0370886177,
-0.0318694115,
-0.0311472248,
0.0167593975,
-0.0346640348,
-0.0107699698,
-0.0008818707,
0.0064592618,
0.017531801,
-0.027817592,
0.0009767773,
-0.0543536693,
-0.0372258015,
0.0082863197,
0.0054164096,
-0.0026903085,
-0.0155407703,
0.0279789194,
-0.0172171835,
-0.0704048946,
0.0056951977,
-0.035239879,
0.0082456684,
-0.0132791661,
0.0127284499,
0.0531296134,
0.0556582808,
-0.0039486177,
-0.0148887271,
0.0421300083,
-0.0181839485,
-0.0026315341,
-0.00128201,
-0.0046565784,
0.0431386903,
0.0007037955,
-0.0090534016,
0.0014524173,
-0.0232019071,
0.0634298697,
-0.0177665204,
-0.0321940891,
0.0000884906,
2.565e-7,
0.066908963,
0.0674437508,
0.0374224447,
0.0111524398,
0.0085327988,
0.0111918049,
-0.0294642597,
0.0034632103,
-0.011167407,
0.0331651531,
0.0202373676,
-0.0223237798,
0.0711799487,
0.0036985688,
-0.0732970238,
0.0559317023,
-0.0514196381,
0.0036171398,
-0.0719639733,
-0.0403437614,
0.0137995686,
0.1159984097,
0.0285106022,
-0.0443654023,
-0.0418637991,
-0.0085043935,
0.0251562446,
-0.0277657788,
-0.0433319472,
0.0078125019,
-0.0279073603,
0.0182192344,
0.0231540762,
-0.0124013815,
-0.0397295393,
0.0247970764,
0.0739738941,
0.0288591962,
-0.0134494696,
0.026593959,
0.0372652374,
-0.0244163405,
0.0000256883,
-0.045470573,
0.0793658793,
0.0074442537,
0.0096371491,
-0.0346290506,
-0.0220977571,
0.055713091,
0.0078242999,
-0.035806369,
-0.0243434999,
0.0525833592,
0.0365165919,
0.0268603731,
-0.0359868966,
-0.0362468511,
-0.0415796936,
0.0361708514,
-0.0239437539,
-0.0089933611,
0.0015356292,
0.004957194,
-0.0079772118,
-0.0669407696,
-0.0252302401,
2.364848974e-34,
0.0424347818,
-0.0178853888,
0.013917882,
0.0603866205,
0.0283081885,
-0.0351902209,
-0.0116599966,
0.0367797986,
-0.0366733037,
-0.0341257527,
-0.0064666462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14211v1 | Towards Graph-hop Retrieval and Reasoning in Complex Question Answering over Textual Database | 2023-05-23T16:28:42 | 2023-05-23T16:28:42 | Minjun Zhu, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Textual question answering (TQA) systems, complex questions often require
retrieving multiple textual fact chains with multiple reasoning steps. While
existing benchmarks are limited to single-chain or single-hop retrieval
scenarios. In this paper, we propose to conduct Graph-Hop -- a novel
multi-chains and multi-hops retrieval and reasoning paradigm in complex
question answering. We construct a new benchmark called ReasonGraphQA, which
provides explicit and fine-grained evidence graphs for complex questions to
support interpretable reasoning, comprehensive and detailed reasoning. And
ReasonGraphQA also shows an advantage in reasoning diversity and scale.
Moreover, We propose a strong graph-hop baseline called Bidirectional Graph
Retrieval (BGR) method for generating an explanation graph of textual evidence
in knowledge reasoning and question answering. We have thoroughly evaluated
existing evidence retrieval and reasoning models on the ReasonGraphQA.
Experiments highlight Graph-Hop is a promising direction for answering complex
questions, but it still has certain limitations. We have further studied
mitigation strategies to meet these challenges and discuss future directions. | [
0.0120518832,
-0.0214625373,
-0.0000299392,
0.0477375798,
-0.0588385463,
0.0241502747,
-0.0194389913,
0.0079629766,
0.0560060181,
-0.0105090346,
0.0193375498,
-0.0099477628,
-0.0237451978,
0.0299784932,
0.0052708611,
-0.0316515081,
0.0253279228,
-0.0084303645,
0.0320281275,
-0.0161139183,
0.0267804768,
0.051127132,
-0.0215459969,
-0.006559181,
-0.0371601284,
-0.025130488,
-0.0423588865,
0.0219794735,
0.0241843741,
-0.0395383239,
-0.0354259871,
-0.0210072845,
0.0275360849,
-0.0082465354,
0.0000016865,
-0.0176374353,
-0.0520012192,
0.0322292075,
-0.0766293257,
-0.0239378978,
-0.0338797756,
0.0269154236,
0.0430564508,
0.0202586949,
-0.0345698521,
-0.0206924807,
0.0191775244,
0.0599327534,
0.0552481636,
0.0610378012,
-0.0108778439,
-0.0740538016,
-0.0323613249,
0.0243017524,
-0.009509461,
-0.0524847731,
0.0114771677,
0.0620811954,
0.0594276078,
0.0393967777,
-0.0093462449,
-0.0063214405,
0.007787324,
0.0126320459,
-0.0104720267,
0.012227606,
0.0128972521,
0.0243777707,
0.033332698,
0.09391056,
0.0470563807,
-0.0201144479,
-0.0047078896,
0.0049785818,
0.0144194998,
0.0695639178,
-0.0568370633,
0.0012537384,
-0.0661325082,
0.0010713228,
-0.0214709453,
-0.0386494622,
0.0486217104,
-0.0282003768,
-0.0286246892,
0.0791612342,
-0.0181814302,
-0.0099424273,
0.0193465799,
0.0028819242,
-0.012158921,
-0.0325183943,
0.0216443595,
0.0742557049,
-0.0537855849,
0.0193255208,
0.0400636494,
0.0141684273,
0.0229052305,
-0.0048021143,
-0.0106880665,
0.0056439056,
-0.0174990911,
0.0720090121,
-0.0127116963,
-0.0017698656,
-0.0290023535,
0.0117932847,
-0.0427834019,
-0.0639388412,
-0.059771169,
-0.0020987382,
-0.0562808923,
0.0572560765,
-0.0468470156,
-0.0153595936,
0.0237255208,
0.0206831023,
0.0040135523,
-0.0176541414,
0.0280187819,
0.0452739298,
0.0163446851,
-0.0289842505,
-0.0172572508,
0.0422095954,
-0.0924937502,
0.0092174513,
0.0153079396,
0.0042493506,
-0.0152388765,
0.0046627326,
0.0643431842,
-0.0187710281,
0.0088095991,
0.0484846309,
0.0081137633,
0.0075473627,
-0.029443346,
-0.0689111501,
-0.0119559169,
-0.0446368977,
-0.0239400435,
-0.0645840019,
0.0066978647,
0.0318842493,
-0.0186924953,
0.0120376563,
0.0090380674,
0.0241801627,
-0.0508855991,
0.0325357132,
0.0027771525,
-0.0321845338,
0.0089374585,
0.0111868773,
-0.046818193,
0.0568801425,
-0.0044420538,
0.0210396312,
0.0550923124,
0.0217530224,
-0.0044932896,
-0.03289086,
0.0428474024,
0.0023279926,
0.0665088296,
0.0496554561,
-0.028408004,
0.0073401704,
-0.0477719121,
0.0483763143,
-0.0540261902,
-0.0204277616,
-0.0039637652,
0.0466649458,
0.0472243018,
-0.0360607617,
0.0126324287,
0.0058957646,
0.0110649178,
0.0227503851,
-0.0207499694,
0.0243455917,
-0.0199319087,
0.0189009961,
0.0088733193,
0.0010666098,
-0.0181190893,
-0.0309634153,
-0.0329956673,
0.035952054,
0.0164357442,
0.0127194552,
0.0548781343,
-0.0094555933,
-0.0330078229,
0.0075268256,
0.0256061181,
-0.0208424032,
-0.0100024603,
-0.0084847072,
0.0129661718,
0.070311524,
0.0524939112,
-0.0328649916,
-0.0095152184,
0.026733214,
0.0354199931,
-0.0411078222,
0.0108182877,
-0.0260988884,
0.0030961221,
-0.0402908474,
-0.0388075896,
-0.0308290496,
-0.0066143791,
0.0075412076,
0.0101899151,
0.0039218487,
-0.0134525495,
-0.0669603944,
0.0098905666,
0.0018099035,
0.0105567807,
0.0230333861,
-0.0051144185,
0.0106993783,
0.0027099873,
0.052842591,
-0.0149188209,
0.0360577367,
0.0301666483,
-0.0089923833,
-0.0607945584,
-0.0023548529,
-0.0041928976,
-0.0787114054,
0.0255951472,
-0.053195361,
-0.0116706667,
-0.0226422735,
-0.0197121743,
-0.0700756907,
0.009225389,
-0.0558174327,
0.0193614252,
0.0026581353,
-0.039552182,
0.0351582542,
-0.0188081618,
-0.0300147627,
0.0578934848,
0.0201245956,
-0.0117817428,
-0.031383466,
0.0211537443,
0.0322940722,
-0.0232316703,
0.031931933,
0.034226615,
0.0061467956,
0.0042064623,
0.0188169219,
-0.0392368287,
-0.0659516752,
0.037516918,
-0.0655181259,
0.0358114019,
-0.0290414337,
0.0332863741,
0.0111816796,
-0.0034694101,
0.0309757255,
-0.0221147723,
-0.0565000102,
0.04956837,
-0.0153040672,
0.0252562035,
0.0355408862,
0.0076773865,
-0.0009339904,
-0.0103177186,
-0.0330705531,
-0.0373648256,
0.075919725,
-0.0024997245,
-0.0047426168,
-0.0085223401,
-0.0447059348,
-0.0503132232,
0.0169648994,
-0.0080262199,
0.0261195991,
0.04797462,
-0.0412177853,
0.0343859941,
0.0443352014,
-0.0228625368,
0.0052671074,
-0.0034618187,
-0.0337198414,
-0.0397177599,
0.018404739,
-0.0534573905,
0.0410942771,
-0.0109981447,
-0.0257969704,
-0.0112849874,
-0.0265328288,
0.0032714554,
-0.0250894334,
-0.0371381305,
0.0059476919,
0.0182827562,
0.0534583516,
-0.0313732326,
-0.0177601669,
0.0416568853,
0.0354162492,
-0.0234635696,
0.0068317531,
0.0856852829,
0.0010141097,
0.0138745336,
-0.0101695191,
-0.0077821217,
-0.0459410027,
0.1052000225,
-0.0170039032,
0.0190109145,
-0.0193185713,
-0.0063058957,
0.0008144677,
-0.0257846043,
0.0852570161,
-0.0436946563,
0.0026520242,
-0.0257663224,
0.021520121,
0.0127222277,
-0.0156610049,
0.0019536829,
0.0051569198,
-0.0343202129,
-0.0029006575,
0.0077364189,
-0.0386068746,
-0.0090182219,
0.0050403499,
0.0154682165,
-0.0014788052,
-0.0166141745,
-0.0118648745,
0.0017725732,
0.045013871,
0.0341953374,
-0.007293961,
0.0576815605,
-0.0069678407,
0.0583447255,
0.0968372896,
0.0106524266,
-0.0554192774,
0.029529281,
-0.0104722157,
-0.0144675262,
-0.0274035856,
-0.0183901321,
-0.022073444,
0.0441931263,
-0.0687010288,
-0.0069449879,
0.0457402244,
0.0283712726,
-0.0181871392,
-0.013590266,
-0.0385347605,
0.0298032239,
0.0087331645,
0.023763258,
-0.1228334978,
-0.0438991673,
-0.0019203174,
0.0253427681,
0.0091500403,
-0.038403213,
-0.0021694498,
-0.0597170517,
0.0165340006,
-0.0139068663,
0.000739924,
-0.0383044332,
-0.0905907974,
-0.0003309151,
0.0025337634,
-0.0420373268,
0.0234672315,
-0.0000084463,
0.0079222284,
0.002684308,
0.010980214,
0.0433845744,
0.0436732918,
-0.0089336745,
-0.0172517244,
-0.0354697555,
0.0265551358,
0.0389137045,
-0.0136710815,
0.0231947172,
-0.0386407934,
0.004845174,
-0.0281505268,
0.0490858518,
0.0127032408,
0.0119364234,
-0.0650350973,
0.0226583462,
-0.0449785516,
-0.0256441254,
0.0113976719,
0.1017459705,
-0.0142372847,
-0.0256417878,
-0.0109129408,
0.0013736577,
-0.0289529543,
0.0523031838,
0.0077322037,
0.0234235097,
-0.0810981616,
-0.033474423,
-0.0018249224,
-0.0631331354,
-0.0171773136,
0.0248347968,
-0.0025183794,
0.0347444229,
-0.057844121,
-0.043169722,
0.0121551566,
0.0766412988,
-0.0573725514,
0.0326180793,
0.036249768,
-0.0054651769,
-0.0329205208,
0.0180277321,
-0.0244828798,
0.0283147674,
0.0066847652,
0.016540911,
-0.0031823255,
-0.0228302646,
-0.0109428251,
-0.0239234455,
-0.0421737917,
-0.0532365814,
-0.0190453678,
-0.0110676512,
0.0136201633,
0.0695863888,
-0.0134555865,
-0.0064727515,
-0.0000401221,
-0.010923137,
-0.0086365063,
-0.0324941799,
0.0424185842,
-0.0206085313,
-0.0162404012,
0.0350291096,
-0.0550348684,
0.0045309206,
-0.0117539037,
0.0610477142,
-0.0375887603,
-0.0154798487,
0.0331929997,
0.034798272,
0.0028644383,
0.0591310598,
-0.0332445912,
-0.0352664813,
0.0070974808,
-0.0567787848,
-0.0381662771,
0.0040494837,
0.0302803013,
-0.0117338588,
-0.0721043125,
0.0033716869,
-0.0351267159,
0.0095004393,
0.0066982685,
-0.0022001816,
-0.0188467149,
0.0196546409,
-0.0229095817,
0.0172217637,
-0.0371598117,
-0.0146684274,
-0.0073326989,
-0.0013740173,
0.0522214994,
-0.0075976206,
0.0737544671,
0.0527024493,
-0.0446133725,
-0.0646070912,
-0.023944417,
-0.1161689237,
-0.0335208215,
0.0360103361,
-0.0169106778,
0.0311866552,
0.0329606086,
0.0349828042,
0.0225665234,
-0.0335694402,
0.0270643104,
0.0119867809,
0.0243156254,
-0.002270394,
0.0263517518,
0.0465454832,
0.0007335725,
0.0342154875,
0.0498213246,
-0.0248763505,
0.0223111343,
-0.0100908037,
-0.0641848817,
-0.008037366,
-0.0376791544,
-0.0424051583,
0.0425448604,
0.0145215336,
-0.0112913027,
-0.0609450229,
-0.0457193702,
-0.0131504089,
0.0267679188,
-0.0090319384,
-0.0108085964,
0.0311656091,
0.0447906554,
0.0801436752,
-0.0429570377,
-0.0330767892,
0.0582033694,
-0.0303182043,
0.0171602033,
0.024749212,
-6.161611881e-33,
0.0122343227,
-0.0640427247,
0.0301715918,
-0.0311788339,
-0.028198259,
0.0109822424,
-0.0377915204,
-0.0058060372,
-0.0608820692,
0.0796140358,
-0.0104507906,
0.0406970344,
0.0029240178,
0.0241052508,
-0.0311458558,
-0.0252608899,
-0.0155320466,
0.0211526211,
-0.0224389583,
0.0464308783,
0.0974620432,
0.0009357207,
0.0087773055,
-0.0165062435,
0.0248743892,
-0.0200479198,
0.0359334275,
0.0607048757,
-0.0264040641,
0.0490767956,
0.0229249615,
0.0208471268,
0.0341305174,
-0.0314129665,
0.0219843686,
0.0106472643,
-0.1110026911,
-0.0524899885,
0.027511457,
-0.0129778925,
-0.0569220893,
-0.0023293095,
0.0084204767,
-0.0007207923,
0.0737042949,
-0.0531413257,
0.0252730586,
0.0094237085,
-0.0408981852,
-0.006485783,
0.0076355864,
0.0411812477,
-0.0453328788,
0.0074986597,
-0.0328510329,
0.0585301742,
0.0107436636,
0.0223516356,
-0.0431882776,
-0.0047948882,
-0.0557539389,
-0.0353736132,
-0.0063710236,
0.0129251583,
-0.00465259,
0.0472515002,
0.0194733739,
-0.0052521504,
-0.071537368,
0.0108579602,
-0.0689442754,
0.0458862074,
0.0531880483,
0.038196139,
0.0141501622,
0.0319985263,
-0.1260482371,
0.0090768011,
0.0082036173,
0.0258711744,
-0.002103766,
0.0115461014,
-0.0322203115,
-0.0422638319,
-0.0251545738,
0.0126040634,
-0.0357774459,
0.0017183603,
-0.0020993243,
-0.0181756541,
-0.0183060803,
0.022166986,
-0.0023763641,
-0.0245428961,
0.0023559234,
0.0811790749,
-0.0103564914,
0.0069437441,
-0.014268213,
0.0585624762,
-0.002746356,
0.0133645181,
0.0132404361,
-0.0032991676,
0.0043928637,
0.0179305337,
0.0545644835,
-0.0339971408,
-0.0242063869,
-0.0096507762,
-0.0503299721,
-0.0108080469,
-0.0457736999,
-0.0340838097,
0.0576060228,
0.0632220656,
0.014186318,
0.0853490233,
0.0477655232,
0.059209317,
-0.0221859254,
0.0105214929,
-0.0168205537,
-0.0302683283,
0.0141921742,
0.0191587713,
-0.0237028953,
0.006419153,
-0.0052423957,
-0.0786264092,
-0.0188789517,
0.0650324598,
2.407e-7,
0.0545909442,
0.0088085337,
0.0547355451,
0.0245264899,
0.0013865124,
0.0208154172,
0.0146069769,
-0.036852207,
0.0246760156,
-0.0295330826,
-0.0078869238,
0.0847487003,
-0.0095272055,
0.0847270712,
-0.025426982,
-0.0170850735,
-0.0446869098,
-0.0748494938,
-0.0335263088,
-0.0046771299,
0.1111318246,
0.0122566121,
0.0123660052,
-0.0042840592,
-0.0112377889,
-0.0319005437,
0.0406360812,
0.0282769874,
0.0184128936,
-0.0059166602,
0.0415239707,
-0.0412893817,
0.0314538106,
0.0192491747,
0.0014389807,
0.0190121718,
-0.0304651577,
0.012638879,
-0.0086259414,
-0.0287667438,
0.001013689,
-0.0764054656,
0.0430087447,
-0.0052609849,
0.1113671958,
-0.0211195964,
-0.0353789516,
-0.0080756377,
-0.0601070337,
-0.0226088353,
-0.0136994645,
0.0089826845,
-0.0098511698,
0.0310780145,
-0.002633743,
-0.0098539582,
0.0430071093,
-0.0849207714,
-0.0075362646,
0.0483826026,
0.008520321,
0.0007632317,
0.0224583652,
0.0071326871,
0.0311940908,
-0.0197781231,
-0.0265473723,
1.801596851e-34,
0.0459993295,
-0.0080241952,
0.0217670295,
-0.009868714,
0.0584430955,
-0.0434123911,
-0.030594103,
-0.0326617211,
0.051662609,
-0.095425494,
-0.0241832417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14210v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14210v2 | Skill-Based Few-Shot Selection for In-Context Learning | 2023-05-23T16:28:29 | 2023-10-10T16:23:33 | Shengnan An, Bo Zhou, Zeqi Lin, Qiang Fu, Bei Chen, Nanning Zheng, Weizhu Chen, Jian-Guang Lou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning is the paradigm that adapts large language models to
downstream tasks by providing a few examples. Few-shot selection -- selecting
appropriate examples for each test instance separately -- is important for
in-context learning. In this paper, we propose Skill-KNN, a skill-based
few-shot selection method for in-context learning. The key advantages of
Skill-KNN include: (1) it addresses the problem that existing methods based on
pre-trained embeddings can be easily biased by surface natural language
features that are not important for the target task; (2) it does not require
training or fine-tuning of any models, making it suitable for frequently
expanding or changing example banks. The key insight is to optimize the inputs
fed into the embedding model, rather than tuning the model itself. Technically,
Skill-KNN generates the skill-based descriptions for each test case and
candidate example by utilizing a pre-processing few-shot prompting, thus
eliminating unimportant surface features. Experimental results across five
cross-domain semantic parsing datasets and six backbone models show that
Skill-KNN significantly outperforms existing methods. | [
0.0269573294,
0.0068061012,
-0.0110004274,
0.0209189709,
-0.0411968306,
0.0305202939,
0.0374127924,
-0.0371242762,
-0.003621296,
-0.0855736509,
-0.0315443352,
0.0303547829,
-0.0478815474,
-0.0308618173,
0.0253566206,
-0.0305017494,
0.053578902,
0.0255052894,
0.0051929909,
0.0491535403,
-0.0000748114,
0.0403278843,
0.0011246154,
0.0580378138,
-0.0083133532,
-0.0234042332,
0.0211524423,
0.0015134945,
-0.0134718176,
-0.0233437233,
0.028785836,
0.0301403664,
0.0448639505,
-0.0424883254,
0.0000018678,
-0.0339205302,
-0.0144842677,
0.015546252,
-0.0542448945,
-0.0364470519,
0.0462859869,
-0.0180260688,
0.03534659,
0.0088764168,
-0.0493310168,
-0.0614484511,
0.0241303369,
0.0390855446,
0.0380566865,
0.0662390366,
-0.0101500619,
-0.0172808506,
-0.0315375589,
-0.0188076403,
-0.0075972201,
-0.0349966176,
0.0042485911,
-0.0202801116,
0.0077884831,
0.006645014,
-0.0262633804,
0.0037186849,
0.0028860068,
0.0069316616,
0.0203695875,
0.0175495706,
-0.0417221226,
0.0098829661,
0.0110318977,
0.0860706493,
-0.0778118744,
-0.0251641944,
-0.0150990533,
-0.0377399437,
0.0018603891,
0.0327356644,
-0.0340003483,
-0.018608544,
0.0201443508,
0.0363408662,
0.024262568,
0.0303486716,
0.008444557,
0.0235747788,
0.0099268472,
0.0023955253,
0.001309158,
-0.0288316607,
0.0160128735,
0.0325226523,
-0.0671664774,
-0.0284340605,
-0.0423788838,
0.0015071281,
-0.0510866605,
0.0109083857,
-0.0591026098,
-0.0120521709,
-0.0111690555,
-0.0048542134,
0.039733775,
0.0542246401,
0.0045998166,
0.0731767118,
-0.0170496982,
-0.0055667614,
0.0428180397,
0.0237304531,
-0.0495422333,
-0.0097761899,
-0.0771558583,
0.010191137,
-0.0735839754,
0.0436722487,
-0.0337673686,
-0.0540014245,
0.0016751332,
0.0109171923,
-0.0148691786,
0.0181527063,
0.0182981081,
0.0059163375,
-0.0567230433,
0.0338129289,
0.0155767193,
0.0082092313,
-0.0416551828,
0.0175949316,
0.0000919928,
-0.0381814018,
-0.039795775,
0.0097697433,
0.0150836371,
-0.0460215807,
-0.0091233598,
0.0521427654,
0.0094113341,
-0.0492869988,
-0.0030550673,
-0.0116356714,
-0.0056790765,
-0.0324077159,
-0.0156872217,
-0.0362151489,
0.0161593724,
0.0002978816,
0.0097606797,
-0.0446512699,
-0.0197573509,
0.0322474241,
-0.0123823611,
0.0481797159,
0.0135090668,
-0.0159775596,
-0.0129610645,
-0.0057939985,
-0.0210879445,
0.0762848705,
0.0058780662,
-0.0415577404,
0.0387578458,
0.0020700824,
-0.0076416228,
0.0044227671,
0.013231569,
-0.0114509482,
-0.0370365642,
0.0328054391,
0.0292506404,
0.0400584973,
0.0311163515,
-0.0433203653,
-0.0572388954,
-0.0019964154,
0.0066767335,
0.0500424467,
0.0303816944,
-0.0038723529,
0.0837336332,
0.0510338806,
-0.0020127501,
-0.0130847571,
-0.046294,
0.0068272669,
0.0071579465,
-0.0051775901,
-0.0327184796,
0.0173914935,
-0.0568787828,
0.0129692107,
0.0120725231,
-0.0194469951,
-0.0156168994,
0.0302225892,
0.0334963612,
0.0526256189,
-0.0235866345,
0.0583258979,
0.0311674327,
-0.0031444682,
0.001208827,
-0.0021246728,
0.0147490874,
0.0384368747,
0.0447770022,
-0.0388252363,
-0.0507116094,
-0.0381697863,
0.0559176505,
0.0052913316,
0.0307478998,
-0.0531110428,
0.0312540419,
-0.0649496242,
-0.0498348735,
-0.0431082584,
0.0272023231,
-0.0334880799,
0.0043315757,
0.0003187822,
0.0199799202,
-0.0411667302,
0.0143931992,
0.0432332717,
-0.0270082671,
-0.0281927418,
0.0292603299,
0.0248439163,
0.0128802955,
0.0107346559,
-0.0057881577,
-0.0090976348,
-0.0094347345,
-0.0417355001,
0.0425989293,
0.0349339209,
-0.0721378624,
-0.1002320126,
-0.019878434,
-0.0095568867,
-0.0204725415,
0.008177544,
-0.0665142611,
-0.0138381366,
-0.0359883979,
0.0206696484,
0.0496992953,
-0.0331428908,
-0.0257564597,
0.0025366188,
0.0104877604,
-0.0541119352,
0.070267424,
0.0118292645,
0.013597236,
-0.0119208973,
0.0267613158,
-0.0018055645,
-0.0316723622,
-0.0078528719,
-0.0081481421,
-0.0006862049,
-0.0212706495,
-0.0147520509,
0.0202200785,
-0.0552634113,
0.0188753009,
-0.0705162585,
0.0072965813,
-0.0279899053,
0.0138824638,
0.0139495004,
0.0175336376,
0.0039634854,
-0.0434121378,
-0.0197963491,
-0.0122031886,
-0.0364096984,
0.0132345771,
0.0297891181,
0.0071112853,
0.009175228,
0.0032686284,
0.0136801898,
-0.0100420313,
0.0828893408,
-0.0126671474,
0.0208917446,
-0.0184654985,
0.0495288484,
0.030203592,
-0.0013013167,
0.0229007434,
0.0079693859,
-0.0157870147,
-0.0011812674,
-0.0323595628,
0.0288035199,
-0.0461402088,
0.0420385525,
0.0136786755,
0.0133352894,
-0.0581647903,
0.0197807942,
-0.0055724704,
0.0474686585,
-0.0193025004,
0.045683749,
0.0190002508,
0.0256830938,
0.0235280506,
-0.0076379208,
-0.0402129889,
0.0388085097,
-0.0256108213,
-0.0106114764,
-0.0062127374,
-0.0048206979,
-0.000001143,
-0.0267822184,
-0.029225057,
-0.0006561124,
0.0809120014,
0.0095967297,
-0.0156122893,
-0.0869568735,
-0.0042461874,
-0.0271872208,
0.0242678262,
-0.0226608906,
-0.0032534103,
0.0114167202,
-0.044681441,
-0.0351663418,
-0.0364264548,
0.0413163044,
0.0202797279,
0.0289122462,
-0.0247541983,
0.0067174672,
-0.0017625077,
-0.0468732007,
-0.0385001116,
-0.0821363553,
-0.0379861109,
0.0434140824,
-0.0360246375,
0.0442613065,
0.0080892825,
-0.0227916893,
-0.006231721,
0.0330587663,
0.0035173232,
-0.0086477185,
-0.0233469717,
0.0437347926,
0.0476214848,
0.0356845073,
-0.0204942469,
0.0308481865,
0.0658478439,
0.022647012,
0.0447948948,
0.0210667085,
-0.0410186872,
0.0372936837,
0.0058196564,
-0.0568903498,
-0.0340208896,
0.0323495157,
0.0490773655,
-0.0522913858,
-0.0110954111,
0.1069084033,
0.0392877981,
-0.0430904999,
0.023127839,
0.038975399,
-0.0206158031,
0.0421869643,
0.0519062504,
-0.0794959813,
-0.0702446848,
0.009156133,
-0.0058211479,
0.014086036,
-0.0347832479,
-0.0096210157,
-0.1381532848,
0.0411490537,
0.0011461341,
-0.0252385773,
0.0124278469,
-0.0349238776,
0.0260867123,
-0.039383363,
0.0277384464,
-0.0370272473,
-0.0255380906,
0.0083714593,
0.024785677,
-0.000023397,
-0.1297285408,
0.0630319118,
-0.0451689363,
0.0113237966,
0.0421606451,
0.0141837336,
-0.004617759,
0.0143064205,
0.0222089868,
-0.0218718741,
0.0255330987,
-0.0346865617,
0.0556302369,
-0.0220932662,
-0.0199535321,
0.0120843509,
0.0459546857,
-0.0241162404,
-0.0305399634,
-0.0177433211,
0.0826505795,
-0.0170223489,
0.0398118794,
0.0014632749,
-0.0447253622,
0.0725907683,
0.0856279507,
0.0180545207,
-0.0568237863,
-0.0248795543,
-0.0014776988,
-0.0077170134,
-0.0216287952,
-0.0145924762,
0.0117101017,
0.0118159186,
0.0018481617,
-0.0517911576,
-0.0543849319,
0.0960403681,
0.0542665683,
-0.0061366959,
0.0054418193,
0.0130691184,
0.0057476382,
-0.0065600066,
0.0411659144,
-0.0126636205,
0.0258993879,
-0.0023197888,
0.0131346723,
0.0575454235,
-0.0282331426,
-0.0303089544,
-0.0419001356,
-0.0184704289,
-0.0209478308,
0.000969274,
0.0306929052,
0.0013443828,
0.074577339,
-0.0553120188,
-0.0400434434,
0.070989579,
0.0397010557,
-0.0776644349,
-0.02179504,
0.0401604511,
-0.0187806487,
-0.009717565,
0.0548538044,
-0.038284868,
0.0123997228,
0.0334523246,
0.0480239838,
-0.0303684864,
0.0424809419,
0.0416637287,
-0.0436638892,
0.0450889096,
0.0160462111,
0.0100353407,
-0.0334531777,
0.0274353735,
-0.006249499,
-0.0323905014,
-0.065545857,
-0.0002397912,
0.0098819099,
-0.0306333601,
0.0131777497,
0.0076914411,
-0.0221369322,
0.0455153435,
-0.0456446968,
0.0235263407,
0.0245660339,
0.0212849472,
-0.0164019465,
0.0325917937,
-0.0532182194,
-0.0264867861,
-0.0166460443,
-0.0024330991,
-0.0403234735,
0.0190882217,
0.0147535075,
0.0115734264,
-0.0337572172,
-0.0006529844,
-0.0262822304,
0.0148777366,
-0.0453416929,
-0.0244682748,
0.0593326278,
-0.1135146022,
0.0243072361,
0.010348957,
-0.0223563556,
-0.0106222136,
0.0458061136,
-0.0102634476,
-0.0355905406,
0.027692426,
0.0274193063,
-0.0244169421,
-0.016128201,
0.0750190318,
0.0080925496,
0.0635079294,
0.020470459,
0.0038756141,
-0.058385998,
-0.0148396743,
0.0812768191,
0.0508691333,
-0.0169979334,
0.0338682905,
-0.0545461252,
-0.0524391234,
-0.0207152925,
-0.0426900908,
-0.0715290383,
0.0095608551,
0.054268159,
0.0395522453,
-0.0038757534,
-0.0046172701,
-0.0185196754,
-0.0405929536,
-0.0102121159,
-0.0399699844,
-0.0425518006,
-5.572709048e-33,
-0.0086597688,
-0.0056698425,
0.0202000812,
-0.017929025,
0.0288900323,
-0.0166741721,
-0.0215146821,
-0.0309721511,
-0.0412179828,
0.0302625597,
-0.0199095905,
-0.026140634,
0.0122660305,
0.0348172896,
0.0299097504,
-0.0137884663,
0.056772463,
-0.021891268,
-0.0009156264,
0.0306577422,
0.0149774877,
0.0449615978,
0.0728404224,
-0.0610967502,
-0.0160429981,
0.0367452167,
0.0037974603,
0.0072354656,
0.0193014015,
0.0621828809,
0.0188838784,
0.0025641797,
0.012644696,
-0.0639211833,
-0.0381843597,
-0.0353799909,
-0.075162515,
-0.0734095573,
0.0045402884,
0.024562113,
-0.0032626942,
-0.0179004185,
0.0115690129,
-0.0366539396,
0.0352969058,
-0.0243481621,
0.0306052417,
-0.0229597632,
-0.0363543518,
-0.0122271804,
-0.0431970172,
0.030232992,
-0.0010552895,
-0.0476567782,
0.0473912582,
0.0179230683,
0.006222615,
-0.0122530777,
-0.0535345264,
-0.0190000031,
-0.0350187644,
0.0313661061,
0.0299543627,
-0.0316794254,
0.0174401999,
0.0770595446,
-0.0153967906,
-0.0299274698,
0.061629653,
-0.0035863558,
0.0315781757,
0.069526419,
-0.0222927239,
0.0656171665,
0.0621932633,
0.0073136236,
-0.0753053427,
-0.0026701663,
0.0367041789,
0.0642142296,
0.0017257634,
-0.0020088132,
-0.0593978129,
-0.0264503416,
-0.0143317189,
-0.0188145023,
-0.0122352587,
-0.0414531715,
0.0497063659,
0.024158854,
-0.0113313925,
0.046744328,
0.0428061299,
-0.0478710607,
-0.0124237724,
0.0561726354,
-0.0209571235,
-0.0043562297,
0.0283030625,
-0.0138216838,
-0.0547647104,
-0.0645569041,
0.0025318782,
-0.0066113872,
0.0188986193,
0.0123262228,
0.0775617138,
0.0393345803,
-0.0369103663,
-0.0054535,
-0.0101754544,
-0.0226755384,
-0.0178469941,
0.0494285226,
0.0235363524,
0.026637448,
-0.0299719926,
0.0437631533,
-0.0047117444,
-0.0661824942,
0.0060268175,
0.0168384202,
0.0057822405,
0.0204385221,
-0.0020776156,
-0.025552962,
0.0045780363,
-0.0278051551,
0.0318672359,
-0.0084360046,
-0.0052523534,
0.0225197785,
2.545e-7,
0.0169772971,
0.0313660614,
-0.0371218696,
-0.0000150265,
0.0325973779,
0.0417878702,
-0.0036366449,
0.0479004793,
-0.0060699154,
0.0170094259,
0.0055842497,
-0.0151915504,
0.0473771505,
0.0378918201,
-0.1273854226,
0.0458846763,
0.0054540941,
0.0272561144,
-0.0084021129,
-0.0473968461,
0.0411752909,
0.1009108648,
0.0134505434,
0.0136775626,
-0.0267905798,
-0.0347187147,
0.0546243414,
-0.0208179466,
0.0036695534,
0.0089036524,
-0.0524795353,
0.0454338454,
-0.0049887504,
0.0234909765,
-0.0491713583,
0.0421804376,
0.0210444089,
0.0681426004,
0.0001995228,
-0.009572817,
-0.0341075771,
-0.0011161291,
0.0308956187,
-0.0100601008,
0.0826765075,
-0.130892396,
-0.0215477217,
-0.0212294254,
-0.0237990189,
-0.0044825915,
-0.0077270456,
0.010235304,
-0.0067943726,
-0.0032735919,
0.0582773574,
-0.0115780849,
-0.021830976,
-0.0547756515,
-0.0109323962,
0.0532955974,
-0.0303151403,
0.003042747,
0.0133951493,
-0.0196274128,
0.0580626987,
-0.050921917,
0.0091525093,
2.482316905e-34,
0.0043901489,
0.0171981938,
0.0472627394,
0.0425125398,
-0.0193082802,
0.0065173912,
0.0145520428,
-0.0036879878,
0.0516384095,
-0.0388776623,
-0.0038595528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14208v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14208v2 | Domain Private Transformers for Multi-Domain Dialog Systems | 2023-05-23T16:27:12 | 2023-12-07T19:46:09 | Anmol Kabra, Ethan R. Elenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large, general purpose language models have demonstrated impressive
performance across many different conversational domains. While multi-domain
language models achieve low overall perplexity, their outputs are not
guaranteed to stay within the domain of a given input prompt. This paper
proposes domain privacy as a novel way to quantify how likely a conditional
language model will leak across domains. We also develop policy functions based
on token-level domain classification, and propose an efficient fine-tuning
method to improve the trained model's domain privacy. Experiments on membership
inference attacks show that our proposed method has comparable resiliency to
methods adapted from recent literature on differentially private language
models. | [
0.0307920612,
0.0685468689,
-0.021687394,
0.06376791,
-0.046378538,
-0.0183226373,
0.082340084,
-0.0050673415,
0.0415286906,
-0.0514919981,
-0.0744691715,
-0.0512593612,
-0.0141422376,
0.0456038117,
0.0173686184,
-0.008663157,
0.0611461587,
-0.0661485568,
-0.0086036539,
-0.0210082456,
-0.0309889931,
-0.0119580468,
-0.0222612303,
0.0725938082,
0.0027818838,
-0.0190412086,
-0.0046398239,
-0.0234463289,
0.0078473184,
0.0093154022,
0.0267921127,
0.0714271888,
0.0326560363,
0.064894326,
0.0000020086,
-0.0491206497,
-0.0483384728,
0.035445191,
-0.0131899472,
-0.0099149924,
-0.0225930009,
0.0214716326,
0.0380062275,
0.0160511974,
-0.0368963256,
-0.0162621718,
0.0323428176,
0.0696499944,
0.0607164688,
0.0696612,
-0.006291647,
-0.0325381048,
-0.0097929295,
-0.0530921184,
-0.0367226973,
-0.1057966948,
0.0259405561,
-0.034311194,
-0.0297625903,
0.0148609094,
-0.0119643891,
-0.0001119951,
-0.0062548262,
-0.0156566873,
-0.0533292368,
0.018484896,
0.005728405,
-0.0293155145,
-0.0085924258,
0.0341944396,
0.028991513,
0.0147080189,
0.0261188708,
0.0348339006,
0.0522055551,
0.005277867,
-0.0026949449,
0.0116452901,
-0.0048581581,
-0.0278960783,
-0.0177321676,
0.0305948872,
0.0185735468,
0.0020000734,
-0.0162381902,
0.0801943317,
0.0185343139,
0.0026940142,
-0.0461172238,
-0.016495686,
-0.0196563508,
-0.0664409474,
0.0444649346,
-0.0270578805,
-0.0040592132,
0.0136322165,
-0.0751698539,
-0.033340212,
0.00610366,
0.0022557287,
-0.0149170998,
0.0018932725,
-0.0046271076,
0.0255779214,
0.0177990124,
0.0520810969,
-0.0339360982,
0.0437401682,
0.0295108017,
-0.0059756907,
-0.0386266336,
-0.0249307081,
-0.0253239237,
0.0843895599,
-0.0517245531,
-0.0016790506,
-0.0330348909,
0.0228380766,
-0.0097363228,
-0.0009047045,
0.011393941,
-0.0017608416,
-0.045633696,
-0.0276331939,
-0.0025133134,
-0.0099737355,
0.0015405046,
0.0201627258,
0.0356819145,
-0.0429372527,
-0.0199204702,
-0.0366176665,
-0.0302064903,
-0.0157146193,
-0.0716616511,
0.1385514885,
0.0177427791,
-0.0314536206,
0.0068087815,
-0.0811538175,
-0.0295414031,
-0.0515516214,
-0.0002951149,
-0.0283611342,
0.0020419906,
-0.0066517321,
0.000728786,
-0.0805897862,
0.0124158664,
-0.0088329036,
0.0116017777,
0.0659390911,
0.0294270776,
-0.0232655387,
0.035897743,
0.0466127358,
-0.0436095037,
0.0546046607,
-0.0088409027,
0.0039935661,
0.0477487929,
0.0078748791,
0.0460336097,
-0.0186122656,
0.0329193138,
-0.0116689131,
0.0154278027,
0.0340355113,
0.0174153931,
-0.0557298809,
-0.0266304165,
0.0393938608,
-0.0186707843,
-0.0610282011,
0.0628852844,
0.0606862903,
-0.0140087763,
0.0163943134,
-0.0097789327,
0.0339501947,
-0.0402370207,
0.0105361808,
-0.0606543422,
-0.0091094244,
-0.0056174984,
-0.0346793123,
0.014745988,
0.0094713233,
-0.0100519946,
-0.0216480754,
0.0288905706,
-0.039826788,
0.0154796792,
0.012449204,
0.0431248136,
0.0390991792,
0.0050294953,
0.0982058719,
0.0111231627,
-0.0355854407,
-0.0213401262,
-0.0652103871,
-0.0090507921,
0.0009386581,
0.0153416824,
-0.0214336943,
-0.0037601269,
-0.0702210665,
0.0042527164,
0.0597993955,
0.0315368064,
0.0217450261,
0.0630702227,
-0.0122495247,
-0.0372993127,
-0.018922735,
0.0487447977,
0.050917238,
-0.0024525293,
-0.0067547099,
0.0301717892,
-0.0389878638,
0.0432425253,
0.0002133953,
-0.0121250423,
-0.0085258521,
0.0551216118,
0.0249794815,
0.0371506028,
0.0230018981,
-0.0057769683,
0.0136408368,
-0.0021116431,
0.0066522355,
-0.0259289388,
-0.0079823034,
-0.0250312723,
-0.0101377601,
-0.0118402727,
-0.0302661974,
0.026670849,
0.0550918654,
-0.0025215039,
-0.0290012881,
0.041476693,
-0.0308524389,
0.0320820063,
-0.0194689836,
0.0293851681,
0.0008366296,
0.0313322954,
-0.034208931,
0.0201347582,
-0.0220164098,
-0.0139889568,
-0.0396941602,
0.0214410108,
0.0099460622,
-0.0281496607,
-0.0329519734,
-0.0244341046,
-0.0565653108,
0.0176884942,
0.0177688245,
-0.0189939495,
-0.0075909332,
-0.0264827069,
-0.0022432527,
-0.0033924391,
-0.019274909,
0.022002833,
-0.017694572,
0.0196519941,
0.0031811504,
-0.0288974065,
-0.0077913338,
-0.0247905757,
-0.0372063331,
0.0300260652,
0.0160817318,
0.0301790349,
-0.0516553707,
-0.000279708,
0.0028239209,
0.0018560806,
0.0451739542,
-0.04900131,
-0.0027340646,
-0.0493807048,
0.0391879231,
-0.0154275028,
0.0609217472,
-0.0183883943,
-0.0203521848,
0.001529319,
0.0320043936,
-0.0202045813,
0.0440700948,
0.0353664644,
-0.0007616342,
0.0342110656,
-0.0001384466,
-0.0521954484,
0.0139600504,
-0.0101629673,
-0.011659543,
-0.056900464,
0.0403421074,
0.0291900821,
0.06023762,
0.0173179638,
-0.0347394831,
-0.0575331412,
0.030078724,
-0.0109794121,
-0.0385768227,
0.0302439947,
-0.0202662442,
-0.0156898741,
0.0296802893,
0.0232160296,
-0.0388967134,
0.0719185621,
-0.031722296,
0.0230547208,
-0.0375903361,
-0.0215206686,
-0.0254479386,
0.0319407061,
-0.0228466801,
0.0294878948,
0.1042686924,
-0.0859816521,
-0.0285452809,
0.0146936551,
0.0273919348,
-0.0248473249,
0.0770594776,
0.0113579473,
-0.0028901908,
-0.0053638164,
-0.0870787129,
-0.0682482496,
-0.0437489748,
-0.0212786403,
-0.0160662718,
-0.003996673,
-0.0453988872,
-0.0398536511,
0.0223613214,
-0.0088316593,
0.0108064413,
-0.0128210383,
0.0077942107,
-0.0298722852,
0.0008126692,
0.030820407,
-0.0104779899,
-0.0290530976,
-0.0309810173,
0.0141935991,
0.0447626747,
0.0292721987,
-0.0044668815,
0.027152976,
-0.0651428476,
0.0235495716,
0.0041386946,
-0.0234553088,
-0.0011850768,
0.0428187624,
-0.0467008874,
-0.0335309878,
0.0875024348,
-0.0005442606,
-0.0457105562,
-0.0183373857,
0.0079310872,
0.0169387609,
0.0157421436,
-0.0095261084,
-0.0814489424,
-0.0287130438,
0.031852819,
0.0160924327,
-0.0006309671,
-0.0237813182,
0.0002136792,
-0.1108950078,
-0.0457554646,
-0.0135069778,
-0.0157378707,
-0.0316117965,
-0.0194484405,
0.0046567838,
0.0157825388,
0.0029080615,
-0.0725837126,
0.0237546843,
-0.0323634222,
0.0077013476,
0.0163969994,
-0.0234984569,
-0.0023592182,
-0.0229803454,
0.0424423218,
0.0771025419,
-0.0024829358,
0.004117263,
-0.0284213908,
0.0418763869,
0.0304059908,
-0.0070101256,
0.0079238517,
0.0495328419,
-0.0194222704,
-0.0101027107,
0.0237909388,
0.0369800888,
0.0030428227,
-0.0000549334,
0.0225913506,
0.0116284303,
-0.0066023283,
-0.0080634076,
-0.0007406631,
0.0035620492,
0.0205040388,
0.0641813725,
0.0033462807,
-0.0386953279,
-0.0150682461,
-0.046983894,
0.0271118302,
-0.0171133317,
-0.0303358361,
-0.0029297916,
0.0367078781,
-0.0487827174,
-0.0319610611,
0.0401650108,
-0.0249333102,
0.0164834186,
0.0204835776,
-0.0066021914,
0.0199069567,
0.0483656563,
0.0007709451,
0.0062922584,
-0.0798578262,
0.029844759,
-0.0676902831,
0.0179661606,
0.0556459837,
-0.0047528795,
-0.0427447371,
0.0080124186,
-0.0718200952,
-0.0860725641,
0.0150625622,
0.0445086136,
0.0138639435,
0.0277627576,
-0.0490707085,
-0.0471801609,
0.0599903949,
0.0375390351,
-0.0663199797,
-0.0122116571,
0.0938608721,
-0.0131009845,
-0.008281094,
0.0571257807,
-0.0421150066,
-0.0067891893,
0.0321305171,
-0.0095921634,
-0.0193465464,
-0.0402492359,
-0.0271574762,
-0.0112485047,
0.0836047232,
0.0314719006,
0.0200605001,
-0.0112567712,
0.0635272413,
-0.038286496,
-0.0084879072,
-0.0398669057,
-0.0070147603,
0.0136213787,
-0.032487046,
0.0550980419,
-0.0132740391,
0.0007654343,
0.0452728495,
-0.0137396948,
0.0184980836,
0.0592765585,
0.0138120111,
0.0179099813,
-0.0106788976,
-0.016981462,
0.0118407644,
0.0612868778,
0.0092956042,
0.0014680112,
0.0651672333,
-0.0000100384,
-0.0130775655,
0.0087203877,
0.0448968373,
-0.0591819994,
-0.0191383641,
0.0054391311,
0.0353414714,
0.0003034632,
0.0125581725,
-0.0148340622,
-0.014651197,
0.0136283627,
-0.0073725772,
0.0213546641,
0.0043027359,
-0.0230132248,
0.0383264683,
-0.0095907338,
0.0000021395,
0.0245694853,
0.0996607095,
0.0268217605,
0.0204822887,
0.0009563075,
0.0049464121,
-0.056922026,
-0.0323307551,
-0.0041460283,
0.047268834,
-0.0186403338,
-0.0064543486,
-0.0611868314,
-0.0840931386,
-0.0144721288,
-0.0453652367,
0.0222023297,
0.0295869,
-0.0045483536,
0.0300929621,
-0.0023537397,
-0.0435572602,
-0.0729200393,
-0.0030067898,
0.0319803506,
0.0036295585,
-0.0075923968,
-5.465415801e-33,
-0.0217053797,
-0.0266639199,
-0.0320636481,
0.0503177792,
0.0147405043,
-0.0117259221,
-0.0106833642,
0.0132233109,
-0.0149479015,
-0.01664274,
-0.0143734077,
0.0159625299,
0.0139143057,
0.0508281514,
-0.0408006832,
-0.0266175531,
0.0690377727,
-0.0264993478,
-0.0023483189,
0.0327588432,
0.0601875409,
0.0219785124,
0.0227350853,
-0.100563392,
0.0255644452,
-0.0051235128,
-0.0262172054,
0.0304302722,
0.0067111957,
0.0595589839,
-0.0131815355,
-0.0098756608,
-0.0091852406,
-0.0532947369,
-0.0162094105,
0.0482273847,
-0.0374222137,
-0.0121991811,
-0.0102447914,
-0.0229049381,
0.0667857379,
-0.0626342967,
0.0005877625,
-0.0151088471,
0.0247638971,
-0.0320930108,
-0.0084808022,
-0.0028454426,
0.0162780322,
-0.0299829934,
-0.004413648,
0.0152840978,
-0.0154786082,
-0.0364347063,
0.0548158623,
0.0517404564,
0.0416288674,
-0.0408639982,
-0.0076745069,
0.0419158787,
0.0059707784,
-0.0078596333,
0.0565794855,
-0.0021859126,
0.0103617534,
0.0304401908,
0.0491543822,
0.0482497513,
0.0206897445,
-0.0536751822,
-0.036391668,
0.0511664748,
0.0023095927,
0.056169603,
-0.0071726725,
-0.0330780372,
-0.0388438068,
0.0001393386,
-0.0607149489,
0.0019000636,
0.0697251335,
-0.0119884815,
-0.0537865758,
0.0186808817,
-0.0379657038,
0.0190682132,
-0.027763322,
-0.0033508814,
0.0238497462,
0.0144447284,
-0.0409662426,
-0.0223506391,
0.0350276902,
-0.0912339389,
-0.0435583256,
0.0290340278,
0.0602189563,
-0.0194654409,
-0.0188364256,
-0.0022499878,
-0.0042474237,
-0.0289138574,
0.0198261552,
-0.0162745789,
0.0094135888,
-0.0064478754,
0.0076850653,
-0.029081637,
-0.0765957758,
-0.0256202649,
-0.0084402738,
0.0347863585,
-0.003123825,
0.0801624581,
0.0507973507,
-0.0056835092,
-0.0244658757,
0.0326438397,
0.007926845,
0.0082703615,
-0.0418545157,
0.0573466606,
-0.0102958046,
0.0169213861,
-0.0133135477,
-0.0428772941,
0.0224698298,
0.0049037877,
0.0602419563,
0.0036211039,
-0.0059060929,
-0.0522576123,
2.743e-7,
-0.0325601473,
-0.0001035714,
-0.0107743992,
0.0088663008,
0.0316728391,
0.1018550098,
0.0172080919,
0.0827330798,
0.0137899453,
0.0010205501,
-0.0573654287,
-0.0240735728,
0.0385164842,
0.0212248638,
-0.1139239892,
-0.0063924971,
0.0118596032,
0.0037098974,
-0.0181671251,
0.0050748764,
-0.0058939592,
0.1160869375,
0.0179449935,
-0.0067634908,
-0.0164755676,
-0.0496037938,
0.035313841,
-0.0173289236,
-0.0132411979,
0.0154889449,
0.0288786776,
0.0461509824,
0.0268766023,
0.0285298415,
-0.0389467441,
0.0622769408,
-0.0348324217,
0.0846638754,
0.0409462713,
-0.044284936,
-0.0192544851,
-0.0176526252,
0.003380873,
-0.0093477396,
0.0327796042,
-0.0530278385,
-0.031195119,
-0.0442793518,
0.0166507382,
-0.0587302335,
0.0154100694,
-0.001630612,
0.0082781939,
0.0334794559,
-0.0177427679,
0.001237063,
0.0382593274,
-0.0783349648,
-0.0292273406,
-0.0918352008,
-0.0586299449,
-0.0108000748,
0.0099140182,
-0.0093628094,
0.0025802059,
0.0099993441,
0.0460437089,
2.498749489e-34,
-0.002994051,
-0.0139685674,
-0.0130470805,
0.0607351772,
0.0334369354,
-0.0223572254,
0.0293679908,
0.0014088133,
0.0350037515,
-0.0343310386,
-0.0201196875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14205v2 | $μ$PLAN: Summarizing using a Content Plan as Cross-Lingual Bridge | 2023-05-23T16:25:21 | 2024-01-31T13:28:58 | Fantine Huot, Joshua Maynez, Chris Alberti, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Priyanka Agrawal, Constanza Fierro, Shashi Narayan, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual summarization consists of generating a summary in one language
given an input document in a different language, allowing for the dissemination
of relevant content across speakers of other languages. The task is challenging
mainly due to the paucity of cross-lingual datasets and the compounded
difficulty of summarizing and translating. This work presents $\mu$PLAN, an
approach to cross-lingual summarization that uses an intermediate planning step
as a cross-lingual bridge. We formulate the plan as a sequence of entities
capturing the summary's content and the order in which it should be
communicated. Importantly, our plans abstract from surface form: using a
multilingual knowledge base, we align entities to their canonical designation
across languages and generate the summary conditioned on this cross-lingual
bridge and the input. Automatic and human evaluation on the XWikis dataset
(across four language pairs) demonstrates that our planning objective achieves
state-of-the-art performance in terms of informativeness and faithfulness.
Moreover, $\mu$PLAN models improve the zero-shot transfer to new cross-lingual
language pairs compared to baselines without a planning component. | [
0.0244390909,
-0.0279084258,
0.0176986028,
0.0054849745,
-0.0159667786,
0.0141305206,
-0.0385681242,
-0.0302745365,
-0.0020335349,
-0.0064739129,
0.0245371554,
-0.010568765,
0.0329867415,
-0.0077225165,
0.0077507389,
-0.1078720838,
0.0406873561,
-0.0421977341,
-0.0489759669,
-0.0287743863,
0.0061719343,
0.0207950864,
0.0104174381,
0.001522828,
0.0105970902,
0.0298745446,
-0.02764697,
-0.0168199427,
0.0647842139,
-0.0109195188,
-0.0221665595,
0.0059997444,
-0.0008917005,
0.0053351955,
0.0000018262,
-0.0346497521,
-0.0464237146,
-0.0016785949,
0.0144503694,
-0.0118241683,
0.0041609816,
-0.1038239971,
0.01578255,
-0.0075134379,
0.0081666904,
0.0062095304,
0.0229038056,
0.0401969589,
0.0705262572,
0.0611931905,
-0.0227725226,
-0.0571007989,
0.0023608783,
-0.0092743905,
0.0072403336,
-0.0659247041,
-0.0155630363,
0.0308557171,
0.0094339959,
0.0173554439,
0.0093056317,
0.0396559499,
0.012910733,
0.0009052837,
-0.036515303,
0.0143147241,
-0.0081869625,
-0.0197888892,
0.0004336366,
0.0734379888,
0.0086421389,
0.000582338,
0.0371631794,
0.0097882366,
-0.0052731447,
-0.0061662123,
-0.0969704613,
0.0516298302,
-0.0037954168,
-0.0054567279,
0.0314460993,
0.0297926683,
0.0013767384,
0.0096161813,
-0.0306563526,
0.0416338407,
0.0104943896,
0.004292001,
-0.0103783468,
0.0380031653,
0.0437875539,
-0.0982786417,
0.0219672043,
0.0711938888,
-0.0253469925,
0.0034480274,
-0.0306172352,
-0.0451239161,
0.0242170151,
-0.0348747708,
-0.0064526019,
0.0487112477,
0.0230681486,
0.0690598339,
-0.0204231795,
0.0391373187,
-0.0000340652,
-0.0086726667,
-0.0624733195,
-0.0453340523,
-0.0405702554,
0.031104235,
-0.0254148133,
0.0418423414,
-0.0616010465,
0.0010874973,
-0.0478274301,
0.0341101401,
0.0248227976,
0.0326517187,
0.0394277275,
-0.0357253626,
-0.0181243885,
-0.0143173486,
-0.0269280877,
0.0553142503,
-0.0786480308,
-0.0545645021,
-0.0037302142,
0.0230721328,
-0.0161786322,
0.0158115905,
0.0016918537,
0.0094491579,
-0.0131467506,
0.0698626414,
-0.0357250422,
-0.0060918839,
-0.0283107068,
-0.0520800166,
-0.0257939696,
-0.0445829593,
0.0120370751,
-0.0903131291,
0.0380726717,
0.0192630291,
-0.0153264254,
0.0175842773,
0.0027488226,
0.0089445515,
-0.0524421334,
0.0044377898,
0.0031404714,
0.035396684,
0.0103030102,
0.0036397637,
-0.0007582225,
0.1057256386,
0.0253445134,
0.0216667056,
0.0381624922,
0.0762231722,
-0.0521075018,
0.0299325362,
0.0120775793,
0.0470064543,
0.0425937362,
-0.0074270158,
-0.0026428814,
-0.0072568916,
0.031181531,
0.0278122276,
-0.0374578983,
0.0365583748,
0.0165327024,
0.03206807,
-0.0356572084,
0.0277841743,
0.0582296476,
0.0187586136,
-0.0255821589,
0.0571518131,
0.0209724847,
0.045959048,
0.0079522654,
0.0357016362,
0.0493188314,
0.0280047897,
-0.0488922074,
-0.0375204794,
0.0116347726,
-0.020796122,
0.0046865353,
-0.0058868844,
0.0227707364,
0.0287369676,
-0.02810698,
0.0789905563,
0.0058996971,
-0.061085958,
0.0530770756,
0.0222048052,
0.0248786211,
0.0633685887,
0.0088503482,
-0.0164468456,
-0.0298228227,
0.0086246748,
0.0287058856,
0.0214608964,
0.0786478892,
-0.0547480173,
0.0228882786,
-0.0558289401,
-0.0661811829,
-0.0199663602,
-0.0230599698,
0.0455279201,
0.0093776891,
0.0223288927,
0.0355308875,
-0.0034643449,
-0.0252694525,
0.0090917973,
-0.0470557585,
-0.0020564375,
-0.0058847275,
0.0079456232,
0.0082923975,
0.069401525,
0.0265209004,
0.005940794,
0.0215030909,
-0.0262696762,
-0.0043451246,
0.0374724045,
-0.0042054383,
-0.0362339318,
0.0392719097,
-0.0793676972,
-0.0049592168,
-0.0221636556,
-0.0255185533,
-0.078234598,
0.0204621274,
-0.0123030366,
0.0053888918,
-0.0113469716,
0.0169045106,
0.0370013714,
-0.0118124634,
0.0095772939,
0.0665565953,
0.0250204802,
0.0058247941,
0.0710297003,
-0.0842288584,
0.0191747472,
-0.0414610654,
0.0001130296,
0.0522283725,
0.0176535882,
-0.0107720392,
0.0639784113,
0.0276039597,
-0.0316385552,
-0.0072744656,
-0.1249055043,
-0.0053926925,
-0.0323590562,
0.0186131485,
0.0450383313,
0.0359380692,
0.0159412436,
-0.0017356123,
-0.0453153215,
0.0025938533,
0.0291535277,
0.0189032033,
0.0114782825,
0.0417052619,
0.0577756055,
-0.0237273369,
-0.0124459257,
0.0174151193,
0.0082870144,
0.0220547821,
-0.0573630817,
-0.0467004515,
0.0290181413,
-0.0705357641,
-0.0306595732,
0.0082495967,
0.0195284542,
-0.0309634209,
0.0062524485,
0.0336750597,
-0.0253095888,
-0.0183592308,
-0.0346413888,
0.0508703887,
-0.0351076052,
-0.0334694833,
0.0141557464,
-0.0360122733,
0.000043924,
-0.0202573668,
-0.0500839241,
0.0042383438,
0.0494235009,
-0.0297373068,
-0.0009849111,
-0.0654788241,
-0.0186357945,
-0.0228938721,
-0.0151758194,
-0.0302887112,
-0.0214886088,
0.0211262852,
0.0605770387,
-0.0280147064,
0.0353254527,
0.0489681289,
-0.0258099344,
0.0151520111,
-0.0509425625,
0.0407920331,
-0.0647740439,
0.049409125,
-0.0279708281,
0.0415340066,
-0.0491277315,
0.0108982306,
-0.0647271201,
-0.017662406,
0.0253742728,
0.0116030108,
0.0171154682,
-0.0655998886,
0.0092763025,
-0.042806942,
-0.0154246781,
-0.0123435268,
0.0042638388,
-0.0269394089,
0.0324688777,
0.0104247201,
0.0127258254,
-0.0353496149,
0.0070477831,
0.0721482262,
0.0389170051,
-0.0128066158,
-0.0078517515,
0.0009929264,
0.0504685454,
0.0332809426,
0.0175815877,
-0.0055389111,
-0.0445697755,
0.0359373391,
0.035637062,
0.0232840776,
-0.0103781056,
0.0646811351,
0.0031179038,
0.0166935585,
-0.0484242514,
-0.0159440972,
-0.022438651,
0.0466429777,
-0.0210852157,
-0.0026612924,
0.0721900985,
0.0229356438,
-0.0287602562,
-0.0293722227,
-0.0095224818,
0.0287979804,
0.0117824944,
0.0244175233,
-0.0717462301,
0.0095058158,
-0.0001178055,
-0.0102702985,
0.0212253835,
-0.0298955925,
-0.0116271367,
-0.0855793655,
-0.0066474779,
0.0196269359,
-0.0959317088,
0.0016171628,
-0.0425937362,
0.0009356607,
-0.0154031934,
0.0009049574,
0.0017522373,
0.0001595439,
-0.0080837877,
-0.0152021227,
-0.0342766568,
-0.0056844633,
-0.0320136845,
-0.0098658064,
-0.0309525356,
0.0612489246,
0.038811665,
-0.000811507,
0.033068791,
0.004518732,
-0.0376199149,
-0.001423237,
-0.0169900563,
0.057221774,
-0.0129618486,
0.0166733172,
0.0029355371,
0.0139083127,
0.0119974501,
-0.0093652904,
0.0224400703,
0.0620374829,
0.0385486744,
0.0013492082,
-0.0076128361,
0.017973505,
-0.0138799418,
0.0656967461,
-0.0029695262,
0.0153180035,
-0.0027821134,
-0.0063708751,
-0.0087716402,
-0.110270083,
-0.030609712,
0.0069346922,
-0.0559077114,
-0.0483384579,
-0.0997121632,
-0.0928361863,
0.0416567549,
-0.0072309854,
0.0290145334,
0.0096621327,
-0.0156472828,
0.0098156333,
-0.0180761013,
-0.0256961081,
-0.01506087,
-0.0062213116,
-0.0225443002,
-0.013598647,
0.0127419857,
-0.0395961888,
0.0021541736,
0.0212547015,
-0.0338968225,
-0.0709312931,
-0.0225146562,
0.0505870692,
0.014827894,
0.0556293689,
0.0013496812,
-0.0142330443,
0.0960005149,
0.0079689315,
-0.001735329,
0.0212384984,
0.0209535249,
0.0790880024,
-0.0211314131,
0.0571536943,
-0.0830093697,
0.0226406716,
-0.0672281384,
0.0577550195,
-0.0542836338,
-0.0394260623,
0.0018979607,
0.0569889322,
-0.0483058617,
-0.0454732291,
-0.0147465961,
-0.0184032191,
0.003264246,
-0.0455521941,
-0.0324188583,
-0.0091055613,
0.052755177,
-0.0003414906,
-0.0269336142,
0.0434871949,
0.0874471217,
-0.0058277836,
-0.0292955339,
-0.0337726362,
0.0031063564,
-0.0142992688,
-0.0136813605,
-0.0440603681,
0.0385623798,
-0.0330701992,
-0.0386870615,
-0.0272344202,
0.0060626972,
-0.0411347188,
-0.0000983487,
0.0178623721,
-0.0150016341,
-0.0165469311,
0.0073706405,
-0.049786184,
-0.0202687737,
-0.0050253556,
0.0394372158,
0.0349147134,
-0.0335794464,
0.1246819794,
-0.022891704,
-0.0358080752,
-0.0011939931,
0.0222433377,
-0.0051884777,
-0.0179679058,
-0.0223584846,
0.0382411666,
0.0188717339,
-0.002697696,
0.072339274,
-0.0633408502,
-0.0156301577,
0.0073285489,
-0.0120267505,
-0.043005947,
-0.0485481732,
-0.0053748456,
0.0161441453,
-0.014159305,
-0.0645378232,
-0.0655085668,
-0.026954392,
0.0380187295,
0.0220685843,
-0.0195890926,
0.0015299965,
0.0357231833,
0.0332667828,
0.0173368193,
0.0177262407,
-0.0456750058,
-0.0078542642,
-0.0095866062,
-0.0251306128,
0.0203924775,
-5.401195239e-33,
-0.0488896407,
0.0033778017,
0.0109002804,
0.0007667145,
-0.0290530529,
0.019647073,
-0.0553611219,
-0.0113487551,
0.0118986042,
0.0085634151,
-0.018865373,
-0.015678687,
0.0349633135,
0.0145209134,
0.0038133026,
0.0085952366,
0.0373163596,
0.0011041256,
-0.0414449088,
0.0529241264,
0.0755057409,
-0.0117155071,
0.0671198145,
-0.0109992605,
0.0783130303,
-0.0124838781,
0.0173149835,
-0.0011504182,
0.0768348724,
0.0307752155,
0.0086295027,
-0.0080879806,
0.0225332845,
-0.001767419,
-0.0339455567,
0.0085495822,
-0.0737472251,
-0.050686799,
0.0348179415,
-0.0232387017,
-0.0569238812,
-0.0542973876,
0.002169498,
-0.0357927345,
0.0141756823,
-0.0330051892,
0.0306753945,
-0.0387130976,
-0.015230909,
-0.0325677134,
-0.0187675785,
0.0179787036,
-0.0221692901,
-0.0088286893,
0.0857757255,
0.0887765363,
0.0368609503,
-0.0169623215,
-0.0039453944,
0.0824680477,
-0.0352884382,
0.030745538,
0.0683710575,
-0.0310017243,
-0.0001407282,
0.0393899828,
0.0136329783,
-0.0088214539,
0.000791878,
0.0412978753,
-0.0100204563,
-0.007234823,
-0.0041510412,
0.067003563,
-0.0085419407,
0.0266321301,
-0.0607420765,
0.0991661623,
-0.028929323,
0.0324816629,
-0.0035696994,
-0.0228194203,
-0.0026519329,
-0.0179698914,
-0.037572328,
-0.0316454545,
0.0040982491,
-0.0217849892,
-0.0366979167,
0.0266576968,
-0.0450505875,
0.0043395036,
0.0465744138,
0.0080854092,
0.0117954547,
0.0374958999,
-0.0290389415,
0.0427165926,
0.0277403686,
0.0078061922,
-0.0433141813,
0.0070377667,
0.0033056394,
-0.0031006599,
0.0076688328,
0.0037944741,
0.0480427556,
0.0316131264,
-0.0206025224,
0.0148685602,
-0.0307707693,
0.0040260442,
-0.0684628785,
0.0020393161,
-0.0212190356,
0.0158104002,
-0.0051364307,
-0.0032147896,
0.0325201079,
-0.0531095192,
-0.0013163782,
-0.0199947506,
0.0253785122,
0.0330742784,
0.0004191695,
0.0347071327,
0.0063769738,
0.0075307987,
0.040119119,
-0.032707274,
-0.0124924714,
0.0318169706,
2.449e-7,
0.0277626943,
0.0013444897,
0.053841155,
0.0262438599,
-0.0239145365,
-0.0160545819,
-0.0295804907,
0.0283986107,
-0.0203807671,
-0.0145669011,
0.0618663989,
0.0498853922,
0.0241418444,
0.0631560907,
-0.119197242,
-0.0046639154,
-0.0072429348,
-0.0692215934,
-0.0448176153,
-0.0195456576,
0.0194258522,
0.0277944859,
-0.0216117669,
0.0016129727,
-0.0220040344,
0.0111298859,
0.0647308156,
-0.0365247838,
-0.03847434,
0.0038725929,
0.0029894547,
-0.0229435377,
-0.0407147035,
-0.0081511196,
-0.015122544,
0.0113427034,
0.0526906624,
0.032739196,
0.0204169899,
-0.0422338583,
-0.0036932507,
-0.0494195707,
0.0015511513,
0.0045359083,
0.0347725563,
-0.0235891156,
0.0248348638,
0.0103621138,
-0.0255939681,
0.0504387878,
-0.0000559249,
0.0189084765,
-0.0466244072,
0.0737870336,
0.0048817527,
0.0043453341,
0.0152410474,
-0.0253629033,
-0.0215558484,
0.0143062873,
0.029305499,
-0.027133191,
0.0007167992,
-0.0243058223,
-0.0463594235,
-0.0726017281,
-0.0016350923,
1.98743585e-34,
0.0475357808,
-0.0153508196,
-0.055192057,
-0.0462212116,
0.0090678148,
-0.0492388383,
-0.0225939695,
0.004214149,
0.0130159054,
-0.0425500423,
-0.0429039523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14202v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14202v2 | Fine-tuned LLMs Know More, Hallucinate Less with Few-Shot Sequence-to-Sequence Semantic Parsing over Wikidata | 2023-05-23T16:20:43 | 2023-11-05T19:26:17 | Silei Xu, Shicheng Liu, Theo Culhane, Elizaveta Pertseva, Meng-Hsi Wu, Sina J. Semnani, Monica S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) can answer many questions correctly, they
can also hallucinate and give wrong answers. Wikidata, with its over 12 billion
facts, can be used to ground LLMs to improve their factuality. This paper
presents WikiWebQuestions, a high-quality question answering benchmark for
Wikidata. Ported over from WebQuestions for Freebase, it consists of real-world
data with SPARQL annotation. This paper presents a few-shot
sequence-to-sequence semantic parser for Wikidata. We modify SPARQL to use the
unique domain and property names instead of their IDs. We train the parser to
use either the results from an entity linker or mentions in the query. We
fine-tune LLaMA by adding the few-shot training data to that used to fine-tune
Alpaca. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this
methodology, establishing a strong baseline of 76% and 65% answer accuracy in
the dev and test sets of WikiWebQuestions, respectively. By pairing our
semantic parser with GPT-3, we combine verifiable results with qualified GPT-3
guesses to provide useful answers to 96% of the questions in dev. We also show
that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art for the QALD-7 Wikidata
dataset by 3.6% in F1 score. | [
0.0550147817,
0.0496684834,
0.0047824075,
0.0426768064,
-0.0238007028,
0.0398820043,
-0.0220538229,
0.0000199713,
0.0194965452,
-0.0772349164,
0.0119437249,
-0.006106121,
-0.0254882164,
-0.0009709605,
0.0017535014,
-0.0052648503,
0.0181090236,
-0.0298823565,
0.0049504503,
0.0042704707,
-0.0072959224,
0.0396485217,
-0.0242082868,
0.0259657465,
-0.0181469135,
-0.0287973061,
-0.0059793191,
-0.0083978362,
-0.0065631829,
-0.0523342267,
0.0550427772,
0.0422327854,
0.0255572498,
0.0169389769,
0.0000020375,
-0.0619010925,
-0.0152475126,
0.0158024523,
-0.053173244,
-0.0027155906,
-0.0432793535,
0.0024565228,
0.0255200621,
0.0045913532,
-0.0461337864,
-0.0242916197,
-0.0118821226,
0.0790883005,
0.0618719012,
0.064322941,
0.0128185172,
-0.0657385066,
0.0582012646,
-0.0053919926,
0.0777506232,
-0.0557029657,
0.0215043556,
0.0138469609,
0.002391876,
-0.0114335231,
0.006025366,
0.0224212222,
0.0138513967,
0.0326138809,
-0.00720709,
0.0180796385,
-0.0515034348,
0.0113812275,
0.0102601722,
0.0957568511,
0.0197865702,
-0.0141518991,
0.0281920731,
0.0141862957,
0.000919775,
-0.0062129847,
-0.0370595641,
0.0331826992,
-0.0156563073,
0.006163327,
-0.0012961023,
-0.0053569144,
0.009304069,
-0.0079373606,
-0.0108755752,
0.1205190495,
0.0088136401,
-0.0233738218,
-0.0038271032,
0.0245295446,
0.0088826437,
-0.0548388101,
-0.0251214709,
0.0450832769,
-0.0144455312,
0.0208868422,
-0.0367068611,
0.0102960281,
0.0456424952,
-0.0236037243,
-0.0335073397,
0.0503528677,
-0.0173608754,
0.0477969758,
-0.025255125,
0.0102486024,
-0.0064271661,
0.0079883523,
-0.0256460309,
-0.0329390801,
-0.0950740054,
0.0010842949,
-0.0238170642,
0.0784804821,
-0.0342290401,
-0.0097602401,
-0.0089271059,
0.022729883,
0.0389189795,
0.0554271191,
0.0165578797,
0.0067544272,
-0.0171824638,
0.0153092137,
-0.0656485483,
0.0464485325,
-0.0442843959,
0.0331088081,
-0.0078086029,
-0.0496740974,
-0.0055796732,
-0.0172538757,
0.0280482471,
-0.0339448005,
0.0129963858,
0.0872163996,
0.0345011428,
-0.0313501023,
-0.065006271,
-0.0740423501,
0.0459245779,
-0.0241400339,
-0.0100986939,
-0.0562398061,
0.0363550782,
0.0486592166,
-0.0095291911,
-0.0524520688,
0.0175985824,
0.0434094295,
-0.0414965078,
0.0801870674,
-0.0634608641,
-0.003774347,
0.0496690869,
0.0249847323,
-0.0199919809,
0.0890665352,
0.0176437143,
0.0184259191,
0.0314443484,
0.0238148309,
-0.0272862688,
0.0064275363,
0.0266909413,
-0.010615441,
0.0361322537,
0.0713974833,
0.0044607301,
0.0092701269,
0.0166131128,
0.0233285241,
0.0003869013,
-0.0317844003,
0.0312663913,
0.0423109978,
-0.0322198011,
0.0075978884,
0.0386442505,
0.0355533473,
0.0166273806,
-0.0045308894,
-0.0831974074,
0.0350617915,
-0.0076377327,
0.0194317624,
0.0030204952,
0.0355633199,
-0.0134183168,
-0.007826617,
-0.0061213453,
-0.0049547446,
-0.0411668196,
0.0191183873,
0.0162889604,
0.0050925273,
-0.0545008518,
0.13027969,
0.0456592552,
-0.0184909087,
0.0065414221,
-0.0236043669,
0.0430964753,
0.0654587075,
0.0378507264,
-0.0346835069,
-0.0721697807,
-0.0382273495,
0.0362708606,
0.0359266847,
0.0224051587,
-0.0116116814,
-0.0030681442,
-0.0090932753,
-0.0403304994,
-0.032346908,
0.0166609343,
-0.0128808068,
0.0083802855,
0.0292623024,
0.0488697216,
-0.0540815145,
0.0036481826,
0.0434313118,
-0.0150884818,
-0.0312110148,
-0.0305713583,
-0.0094815409,
-0.0025218758,
0.0239646845,
0.0119640678,
0.0101374555,
0.0085915681,
-0.0261884127,
-0.0322313271,
-0.015185928,
0.0183195788,
-0.0624437742,
0.065365687,
-0.0147747239,
-0.0440714061,
-0.0053338408,
-0.0895685777,
-0.0315397754,
-0.0115188872,
-0.0065640397,
0.032022655,
-0.0222883057,
-0.0362014547,
0.0460636839,
0.0025686447,
-0.024830455,
0.0705715567,
-0.0174953472,
0.0075302292,
-0.0170759466,
-0.0222305506,
0.0112184081,
-0.0046860804,
-0.0173574071,
-0.0174531899,
-0.0096567431,
0.0086623644,
-0.0102556618,
0.0027256343,
-0.0843193978,
-0.001659525,
-0.0708246231,
0.0081051551,
-0.0278421082,
0.0532733835,
0.0057180505,
0.0025625476,
0.0103018377,
-0.0140319075,
-0.0735501945,
0.0135769565,
-0.0138943465,
0.0120732337,
0.0522565767,
0.0452185497,
0.0062593636,
-0.0262867678,
0.0021832315,
-0.0337479487,
-0.0086135129,
0.0013909047,
0.0420456901,
-0.0354550071,
0.0006231946,
-0.0548827276,
0.0068404451,
0.007427203,
-0.0030892293,
-0.0072353259,
-0.0350807086,
-0.0298597813,
0.0340434983,
-0.0157025456,
-0.0168782715,
0.0045889565,
-0.0121690072,
-0.0400000103,
0.0288300421,
0.0049578319,
0.0071508209,
-0.0382342301,
0.0154722389,
0.027212033,
0.040325135,
-0.0300315209,
0.0065883468,
-0.0461519063,
0.0666633621,
-0.0028301023,
0.0228841249,
-0.0228469186,
0.004312899,
0.0169193782,
0.03141772,
-0.0011476825,
0.0256806556,
0.0819442794,
-0.0230615679,
-0.0042832373,
-0.0307791084,
0.0130669121,
-0.0320250019,
0.0368986353,
-0.0067864158,
-0.008722404,
-0.0226077847,
-0.0252793487,
-0.038594611,
-0.0201565977,
0.0154092908,
-0.0255027954,
0.039922297,
-0.0183739606,
0.0346154906,
-0.0310320631,
-0.0160431322,
-0.0410643891,
-0.0297189895,
-0.0647258088,
-0.0029121144,
-0.0595412962,
0.0193020012,
0.0125870965,
-0.0219348967,
-0.0092912121,
0.0182903018,
-0.0026167557,
-0.0248427596,
-0.0119835949,
0.0383804515,
0.1038733572,
0.0060570268,
0.0048049069,
0.0219052657,
0.0160044394,
0.046933271,
0.0313806087,
-0.0062436312,
0.0040125931,
-0.0052996627,
0.0106761549,
-0.0904805288,
-0.0173334796,
0.0023944515,
0.0226825345,
-0.083658807,
0.0003923542,
0.1351957321,
0.0363948159,
0.0035158743,
-0.0024254404,
-0.0155137386,
-0.0034148516,
0.0239010118,
0.0423868373,
-0.0889239833,
-0.0807255656,
-0.0303446315,
0.0212696902,
0.0206861757,
-0.0551598296,
0.0333668701,
-0.1338235289,
-0.014047551,
-0.0421051309,
-0.0129455468,
0.0059110327,
-0.0272556357,
-0.0258986931,
-0.0236011297,
0.021460712,
0.02085899,
-0.0102790715,
0.0209999327,
-0.0028813621,
0.0249982327,
-0.023701217,
0.0817363858,
-0.0433630273,
0.0460713133,
0.069475174,
0.021348184,
-0.0295460727,
-0.0487998426,
-0.0156097487,
-0.0193527266,
-0.0089430008,
0.0028287033,
0.0592766702,
-0.0241375808,
-0.0129160266,
-0.0139782932,
0.0267951433,
-0.0580128282,
-0.0001907045,
0.0209270976,
0.0842878073,
-0.0014434739,
0.0062496471,
-0.002817387,
-0.0425952859,
-0.0136022381,
0.0908365175,
0.0144205652,
0.0123291165,
-0.0420248583,
-0.0496463887,
-0.0233753212,
-0.035370551,
-0.0279568899,
0.0130594186,
0.0353433415,
0.0134274485,
-0.1003265232,
-0.0603236482,
0.0713009313,
-0.0066406894,
-0.0142542189,
0.005937818,
0.0046639997,
0.0089390827,
-0.0680429935,
0.0325185917,
-0.0561121069,
0.0004081955,
-0.023254022,
0.0264716167,
0.0823410526,
-0.0111165661,
-0.0217843167,
0.0032526092,
-0.0732812732,
-0.0502858572,
-0.0356117897,
0.066993922,
0.0128881512,
0.0166612715,
-0.0420438685,
-0.0282552987,
0.0276492275,
0.0611979179,
-0.0814280435,
-0.0227868538,
0.0060948823,
0.0213155635,
-0.0030422083,
0.0591541715,
-0.0835656598,
-0.0130427973,
-0.0252826232,
0.0656147972,
-0.0243267715,
-0.0026046035,
0.0333218016,
0.0289809369,
0.0150540601,
0.0135167493,
0.0178152658,
0.0276864618,
0.0525701642,
-0.0200590864,
-0.0035959878,
-0.0099639883,
0.018159477,
0.0077709849,
-0.0391256772,
-0.0061964002,
-0.0064056176,
-0.0395484939,
0.0521158241,
-0.0403221324,
-0.0242692307,
0.0364838094,
-0.0016886158,
0.0277147256,
-0.0286670662,
-0.0271037258,
-0.0278690699,
0.0334766544,
0.0484723635,
-0.0252688881,
0.015404583,
0.0218276177,
-0.0076890318,
-0.0019648897,
0.0179482829,
-0.040209353,
-0.0380368531,
0.002193907,
0.035841085,
0.0405046009,
0.0032173039,
0.0568797104,
0.0010516967,
-0.0319841169,
0.0125782797,
-0.0050096805,
0.0061236317,
-0.0159927458,
0.0591567121,
0.0391327776,
-0.0540414676,
-0.0128077222,
0.0706019551,
0.0068360837,
0.0712448582,
0.0342467465,
-0.0203024801,
-0.0507434309,
-0.0431786291,
-0.0065378826,
0.0103596319,
-0.0226534437,
-0.008947962,
-0.0559291206,
-0.0752131492,
0.0082518542,
-0.0055126697,
-0.0229853392,
0.0019295865,
0.0209597945,
0.0312610045,
0.0426893756,
-0.06908793,
-0.0221300665,
0.0073743099,
-0.0406241007,
-0.0484950393,
-0.0158270355,
-6.650434962e-33,
-0.0375692137,
-0.0226844922,
0.0298918001,
0.007189055,
-0.0037143512,
-0.040910162,
-0.0040121847,
-0.0304611437,
-0.044146385,
-0.0019764211,
-0.0143943848,
0.005063537,
0.0026207967,
0.0296516325,
0.0190294459,
-0.0598501936,
0.0310542323,
-0.0009638059,
-0.0229765233,
0.028638022,
0.039989017,
0.0429356433,
0.0644937083,
-0.0052385014,
0.0011960957,
-0.041079551,
0.0064550755,
0.0320375599,
-0.0077338866,
0.0403398238,
-0.0166588239,
0.0318336934,
0.0176795796,
-0.038478002,
0.0205594674,
-0.0526546799,
-0.1014034972,
-0.0293467324,
0.0121648889,
-0.004676172,
0.0218119174,
-0.0178553313,
0.0351721607,
-0.0198456049,
0.0560247749,
-0.0155978408,
0.0388174988,
-0.0141943507,
0.0172152482,
-0.0268652886,
-0.0449848548,
0.0147533221,
-0.0029214357,
-0.0005372106,
-0.0077546136,
0.0214018244,
0.0427420028,
0.022464402,
-0.0849520341,
-0.0193089824,
0.0126827378,
0.0393835418,
0.0393795967,
-0.0553244911,
0.0020630271,
0.0313107669,
-0.0238438342,
-0.0181497186,
-0.0107764779,
0.0553766154,
-0.0207702108,
0.0406066887,
0.028531516,
0.054363817,
0.0354789086,
-0.0015160227,
-0.0701493472,
0.0397312418,
-0.0176416971,
0.075989157,
-0.0348535217,
-0.0170056019,
-0.0478463545,
0.0000782154,
-0.0489580967,
0.0351821259,
-0.0422832854,
-0.0276500881,
0.0531436764,
-0.0247012004,
-0.0219340753,
0.0262294561,
0.0186003279,
-0.0482317358,
-0.0243142601,
0.054554224,
-0.026898507,
-0.0204605125,
0.0013610257,
0.0191457849,
-0.0159746408,
0.0053290366,
0.0037354177,
-0.0287158135,
0.0218136031,
0.0131265922,
0.015943503,
0.0088830516,
-0.0387479328,
0.0108554224,
-0.0270453803,
0.0188406054,
-0.0204507783,
0.0043879477,
0.0193459261,
0.0228694845,
-0.0129244495,
0.0244155601,
0.0216502063,
-0.020508131,
-0.0378668234,
-0.0350101069,
0.0111830924,
0.0084888227,
-0.0321883708,
-0.005851361,
0.0086563434,
0.0227834359,
-0.0233041551,
-0.0414619744,
-0.0075171813,
0.0170243513,
2.767e-7,
0.0135659948,
0.0422771424,
0.0077010705,
0.0464364961,
-0.0208882373,
0.0439873263,
0.0167199206,
0.0735687613,
0.0068407217,
-0.0640109703,
-0.0242317524,
0.0182937291,
0.0277218688,
0.0450052507,
-0.1182527691,
-0.0238423124,
-0.0181158781,
-0.0308937933,
-0.0664300099,
-0.0424529091,
0.0591123551,
0.0627337173,
0.0239543747,
-0.0165958833,
0.0128945448,
-0.0335886106,
0.029107932,
0.0110732904,
-0.0184746124,
0.0365665816,
0.0309071224,
-0.0015755916,
0.013629117,
0.0200989731,
-0.0318878181,
0.0175291672,
0.0007030693,
0.0585972145,
0.0038189311,
-0.0410425253,
-0.0395924896,
-0.0914196819,
0.0393878706,
-0.02880642,
0.0937365815,
-0.0385370553,
-0.0085730217,
0.0600591004,
-0.0413410999,
-0.0380170979,
-0.0020671375,
-0.0310804788,
0.0194909759,
0.0094368374,
-0.0055508707,
-0.012015719,
0.0190458838,
-0.0351298563,
-0.0160218123,
0.0097440472,
0.0095545407,
-0.0262272488,
-0.0276265796,
-0.0185845401,
0.0005014255,
-0.0401593484,
0.0063973204,
2.286656789e-34,
0.012849167,
-0.0022832034,
0.0147406142,
0.0493061841,
0.0289930254,
0.0349971429,
0.0027869781,
0.0006358934,
0.0185765587,
-0.0807310864,
0.0276059397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14201v1 | Goat: Fine-tuned LLaMA Outperforms GPT-4 on Arithmetic Tasks | 2023-05-23T16:20:30 | 2023-05-23T16:20:30 | Tiedong Liu, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce Goat, a fine-tuned LLaMA model that significantly outperforms
GPT-4 on a range of arithmetic tasks. Fine-tuned on a synthetically generated
dataset, Goat achieves state-of-the-art performance on BIG-bench arithmetic
sub-task. In particular, the zero-shot Goat-7B matches or even surpasses the
accuracy achieved by the few-shot PaLM-540B. Surprisingly, Goat can achieve
near-perfect accuracy on large-number addition and subtraction through
supervised fine-tuning only, which is almost impossible with previous
pretrained language models, such as Bloom, OPT, GPT-NeoX, etc. We attribute
Goat's exceptional performance to LLaMA's consistent tokenization of numbers.
To tackle more challenging tasks like large-number multiplication and division,
we propose an approach that classifies tasks based on their learnability, and
subsequently decomposes unlearnable tasks, such as multi-digit multiplication
and division, into a series of learnable tasks by leveraging basic arithmetic
principles. We thoroughly examine the performance of our model, offering a
comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of our proposed decomposition
steps. Additionally, Goat-7B can be easily trained using LoRA on a 24GB VRAM
GPU, facilitating reproducibility for other researchers. We release our model,
dataset, and the Python script for dataset generation. | [
-0.0346972272,
0.1021611914,
-0.005474952,
0.0161559377,
-0.0002634655,
0.0169836078,
0.0207115244,
0.006877399,
-0.0636346862,
-0.0165642723,
-0.067294389,
0.0037671018,
0.0075062122,
0.0251678433,
0.0313879214,
-0.0192042943,
0.0402162708,
-0.0271473378,
0.0020594164,
0.0159607586,
-0.0130546894,
-0.0205138307,
-0.0225969534,
-0.0133883711,
-0.0174157005,
-0.0544126071,
0.0193657167,
-0.0731561631,
0.0146105746,
-0.004767091,
-0.0029206818,
-0.0139654968,
0.037928123,
0.0943022221,
0.0000021385,
-0.0354911648,
0.0069724843,
0.0090014152,
-0.0237425566,
0.066746138,
0.0346514732,
-0.0130561767,
-0.0250668433,
0.0285586175,
-0.0342136845,
-0.0331113413,
0.0175464805,
0.0360880792,
0.0453672595,
0.0811221227,
-0.0051965406,
-0.041103974,
0.0550863072,
-0.0504294485,
0.0206859224,
-0.0237798393,
-0.0104072252,
-0.0147570781,
-0.0040280619,
0.012806111,
-0.0141095174,
-0.0212636106,
0.0707968026,
0.0117171183,
-0.0175726637,
0.025362242,
-0.0315724649,
0.0105992267,
-0.0099412706,
0.0724857226,
-0.0772420764,
-0.0153574599,
-0.0039046153,
-0.0158384405,
-0.0190756507,
-0.0802368745,
-0.0862727761,
0.0331086069,
0.0492134243,
0.0365937687,
-0.0213407837,
-0.0159963612,
0.051144734,
-0.0112765813,
0.0041278978,
0.0463715233,
0.0178869609,
0.0145570356,
-0.0417229794,
-0.0141071565,
-0.0587585717,
-0.028990699,
0.010136446,
0.0522232838,
-0.0165815447,
0.0018481882,
-0.0547452793,
-0.0427387469,
0.0172870997,
-0.0259902161,
0.037570361,
0.0887535438,
-0.0168628227,
0.0198468864,
-0.0821606591,
0.0510016903,
-0.0398176834,
0.0301009417,
0.0037526086,
0.0519276783,
0.0158625897,
0.0026146695,
-0.0125140399,
0.0507807843,
-0.0509101041,
0.0012761218,
-0.0644119829,
0.0224607345,
0.0009540693,
0.0126499627,
0.0263816249,
-0.0057850587,
0.0011101236,
-0.0192817561,
-0.0173765738,
0.0046712151,
-0.0632384792,
0.0491274297,
0.0110024763,
-0.0552535765,
-0.0160705056,
0.0026200779,
-0.0170972589,
-0.0011567734,
0.0599518605,
0.0617527962,
-0.0232325681,
-0.0319455415,
-0.045038607,
-0.0025770215,
0.0293491706,
-0.066379182,
0.0042470656,
-0.0568890572,
0.0358175971,
0.0027036818,
-0.0156248063,
0.0118593825,
0.0363811739,
0.0343378372,
0.0499082953,
0.0709082559,
0.0079726065,
-0.0375026017,
0.0151591981,
-0.0108392956,
-0.0127806962,
0.053710822,
0.0527481474,
0.020908786,
-0.004921935,
0.0092890281,
0.0077279471,
0.070113264,
0.0041833823,
-0.019431239,
-0.0269905776,
-0.0105384178,
0.003775371,
0.0520939343,
0.063916184,
0.0728985742,
-0.0679644644,
-0.0296545234,
0.0392897278,
0.0447497927,
-0.033041615,
0.0499914698,
0.0509531461,
-0.0481645614,
0.0304542538,
-0.027346639,
-0.0944486707,
0.0280781798,
0.0027126465,
0.0115386108,
0.0362940617,
0.0459146723,
-0.0227843523,
-0.0618551113,
0.0184645243,
-0.0447422788,
0.0206405446,
-0.0005647086,
0.049011454,
-0.0093281139,
-0.0242657401,
0.0273566861,
-0.008212748,
-0.0741317123,
-0.0361138955,
-0.0842547119,
0.0615290217,
0.003577657,
0.055181697,
-0.0280588605,
-0.0338455364,
-0.030022392,
-0.0145248184,
-0.0164409205,
0.0015567954,
0.0031770896,
0.0027609288,
-0.0794798285,
0.0092091281,
-0.0237479694,
0.0399655439,
-0.0076406458,
0.0323143676,
0.0149673754,
0.015268635,
-0.05871512,
0.0087724328,
0.0291632731,
-0.018815523,
-0.100001514,
0.0315337703,
-0.0085676443,
-0.0153590646,
-0.008901719,
0.0247216355,
0.0435430072,
0.0404679552,
-0.0277038682,
-0.0097220214,
-0.0276668873,
-0.0467778817,
-0.0069884756,
0.0787001923,
-0.0104991412,
-0.0030982059,
0.0535875857,
-0.0326451175,
-0.0548043288,
0.0519842133,
-0.029170081,
0.0292010754,
-0.0363494642,
0.0255138129,
0.0077316016,
-0.0025121009,
0.0067193899,
0.0680377111,
-0.0136754531,
0.0052007404,
-0.0290241018,
0.0012028749,
0.0164466817,
0.0154532678,
0.0095210243,
-0.0247504245,
0.0032034423,
0.0366256721,
-0.0340527147,
0.001852727,
-0.0199624635,
-0.0200001411,
-0.0617180541,
0.0267370827,
-0.0479779281,
0.0889428109,
0.0340972953,
-0.0041041472,
0.004284197,
-0.03129806,
-0.0288397763,
0.0168178957,
-0.0204946492,
-0.0037201119,
0.0192168653,
-0.0042989897,
0.0011109784,
-0.0128075955,
-0.02051045,
-0.0328937955,
0.0236878656,
-0.018278284,
0.0531918257,
-0.0090445979,
0.0213207491,
-0.0095502101,
0.0423966832,
-0.0108062476,
0.0077879787,
0.0165746752,
-0.0176804103,
0.0325648226,
0.0275559593,
-0.0442635007,
0.0203044973,
0.024511721,
0.033480864,
-0.0117891831,
0.0070302002,
0.0067932582,
-0.0359922573,
0.0077974973,
0.0154359788,
-0.0463143811,
0.0921166465,
-0.0492675751,
-0.0415688194,
-0.0130174393,
0.0028949222,
0.027593499,
0.0058015818,
0.0159924645,
0.0184196662,
-0.0209234934,
-0.0052248826,
-0.017024992,
-0.0547160544,
-0.0037748911,
-0.0124783739,
-0.0361994058,
-0.0393644162,
0.0024131595,
-0.0646490306,
0.0410180502,
0.0199353453,
-0.018836543,
-0.0214329269,
-0.0263376813,
-0.0224298686,
0.015019333,
-0.0029631152,
-0.0228218678,
0.1024781317,
-0.0338125378,
0.0133981509,
-0.0483872667,
-0.0673376024,
-0.0203464292,
0.0345184803,
-0.0401191227,
0.0698928833,
-0.0053770933,
-0.0542371422,
-0.0109665273,
-0.0448908396,
0.0417744927,
0.0863564983,
-0.0411857702,
-0.0057027107,
-0.040058285,
0.0184654277,
0.0389763564,
-0.0038169995,
0.0370605215,
-0.0355627835,
-0.0109562948,
0.0267041754,
0.0862531215,
-0.0119533269,
-0.0745245591,
0.0095740687,
0.0086755129,
-0.0486608297,
-0.0333435908,
0.0455899574,
0.0357289836,
-0.0717609823,
-0.0040068403,
0.0690562204,
0.0263368152,
-0.0724097118,
0.0045194696,
-0.0420059524,
-0.0147550842,
0.0292680487,
0.0099996701,
-0.0611108877,
-0.042565234,
0.0218029618,
-0.0300699435,
0.0019492704,
-0.0389458276,
0.0080206348,
-0.1006839126,
0.017889645,
0.0077795694,
-0.0720157847,
-0.0198618528,
-0.0511067994,
-0.0067676306,
-0.0228655264,
0.0346497521,
0.0116433874,
-0.0208389368,
0.0318193436,
0.0012618242,
0.0165247396,
-0.0020248666,
0.0384222902,
-0.0113978079,
-0.0059296852,
0.0568629913,
-0.0024012281,
-0.0330676213,
-0.0705367401,
0.0415197574,
0.0122740893,
-0.0372636765,
0.035235703,
-0.0002954478,
0.0215330608,
-0.0112576699,
0.0128886523,
0.0580469295,
-0.0382581688,
0.0000250388,
0.0090869395,
0.0881520286,
-0.0186284631,
0.0101973331,
0.0233586077,
-0.0589138828,
-0.0125238281,
0.0105217695,
0.0419024415,
-0.0074991756,
-0.0613511838,
-0.046697516,
-0.0080172727,
-0.0366080515,
-0.0171384029,
-0.0409864224,
0.0393681377,
-0.0397123806,
-0.0379035063,
-0.0253087766,
0.0358115397,
0.0356890336,
-0.0145957153,
-0.0292739999,
0.0516875833,
-0.027442798,
-0.0853091702,
0.0151645094,
-0.0293979775,
0.0446936414,
-0.0612291098,
0.0352282822,
0.0450064093,
-0.0200892575,
0.0057332651,
0.0338214524,
-0.1182951331,
-0.0365248695,
-0.0282055624,
0.0580197126,
0.0221100133,
-0.0195854846,
0.0011723319,
-0.0249977894,
0.0147002684,
0.0514235944,
-0.0727456063,
0.0607973598,
0.013303251,
-0.0081368191,
0.0133675877,
0.0149320802,
0.0079426058,
0.0181653369,
0.0118636917,
0.020601226,
-0.0541560575,
0.0515173078,
0.0152765466,
0.0082440106,
0.0255239382,
-0.0061351256,
0.0266539399,
-0.0027837942,
0.0272877775,
-0.0242809523,
0.0556638278,
-0.0412155204,
-0.0134612359,
0.0339379311,
0.0351573415,
-0.0034493348,
-0.0285247751,
0.0385075323,
0.0138407731,
-0.0000703368,
0.018473886,
-0.0008237161,
0.0507186875,
0.0134369461,
-0.0388170443,
0.0118523771,
-0.0281294622,
0.0034165522,
0.0411779322,
-0.0128819756,
0.0201543476,
-0.0213916656,
0.020059783,
-0.0547495075,
0.0376557186,
-0.0053443937,
-0.0739388242,
-0.0404753983,
0.023941448,
0.0174294226,
0.0198687334,
-0.0009885114,
-0.0334758535,
-0.0123562701,
-0.0214913134,
0.0037351174,
-0.0247282088,
0.0075202785,
-0.0074834754,
0.0283472799,
-0.0134142442,
-0.0500561669,
0.0299872924,
-0.0366360284,
0.0465862527,
0.0275108069,
0.0390884355,
-0.01331692,
-0.0584210493,
0.001576308,
0.0146931242,
-0.0152908983,
-0.0288231168,
-0.0253684223,
-0.0583744161,
0.0034749229,
0.0080244951,
-0.0199023616,
-0.0176294576,
0.0393024497,
0.0394160748,
-0.0590294227,
-0.0014102143,
-0.0244265888,
0.0037658359,
0.0164358858,
-0.0212250762,
-0.0364350714,
-5.907036172e-33,
0.0084237736,
-0.0008031827,
0.0740822926,
-0.0089100562,
-0.0036151453,
0.0066879895,
-0.0136664538,
0.0156157399,
-0.006368225,
-0.0065044276,
-0.0400335938,
0.0155850919,
0.011745112,
0.019028442,
0.037510708,
-0.0033138683,
0.0385651067,
-0.0624882095,
-0.0421762429,
0.0261867139,
0.0095439088,
0.0240091942,
0.0954012051,
-0.02647762,
-0.0133756138,
0.028376881,
-0.0300927684,
-0.0000133156,
-0.0408455133,
0.0509076044,
-0.0436063707,
0.0541383252,
0.0060380544,
-0.0521849431,
-0.0322289579,
0.0042205965,
-0.0476089492,
-0.0480633713,
-0.0057721385,
0.0176118333,
-0.0452211276,
-0.0463487208,
0.0498518012,
-0.0008049256,
-0.0415011905,
0.0054232352,
-0.0075642257,
-0.0338390283,
0.0007451369,
0.021989841,
-0.0476740859,
0.0035950979,
0.0336895622,
-0.0080088163,
0.0515450835,
-0.044426728,
-0.0539184734,
-0.0076050209,
-0.067955941,
0.0322483554,
0.0457081422,
0.0469779894,
0.05015615,
-0.0058389185,
0.0101426421,
0.0220244173,
0.0603962615,
-0.0248249993,
-0.0182952434,
-0.0031840266,
0.0417972468,
0.0335339047,
0.0540586561,
0.0159087572,
0.0864570886,
0.0185072571,
-0.0670344383,
0.0252498128,
0.0797774941,
0.0071917637,
-0.0291131586,
-0.0025682303,
0.0071210186,
0.0229706988,
0.0045499252,
0.0328626111,
-0.0492592566,
-0.0071937502,
-0.0041047684,
0.0330661535,
0.0558308139,
0.0204391647,
-0.0104055796,
-0.0066308863,
0.0094425958,
0.0206596777,
0.0033901888,
0.0628174841,
0.0403541327,
-0.0035713331,
-0.023323359,
-0.0241667591,
-0.0181855466,
-0.0093463277,
0.0211771466,
-0.0054247496,
0.0343953148,
0.045968391,
-0.0820273682,
-0.0014084537,
-0.0344987139,
0.0145059517,
0.0518113859,
0.0413104258,
0.0212896802,
-0.0201074481,
0.0138652073,
0.02174538,
-0.0481974222,
-0.0185931772,
-0.0049669351,
0.0189686753,
-0.0160566904,
0.0572422482,
-0.019266123,
-0.0197070763,
-0.0292898435,
0.0315359905,
-0.0048681111,
-0.0710071921,
-0.0124547007,
-0.0251625758,
2.778e-7,
0.0337092988,
0.0281158481,
0.0120305354,
0.0166257154,
0.020274369,
0.050564032,
0.0041063586,
0.0423242599,
-0.045594126,
-0.019770205,
0.0219183844,
-0.0174889043,
-0.0176199805,
0.0027981666,
-0.0373022296,
0.0123290448,
0.0172674637,
0.0323940814,
-0.0170203522,
-0.0242130775,
-0.0253707338,
0.106977798,
0.0256017484,
-0.0110325534,
0.0571574345,
-0.0093941316,
0.0399277546,
-0.000179695,
-0.0042962995,
0.0083621237,
0.0048728408,
0.0236087479,
-0.0253224466,
-0.0357047953,
-0.0117962742,
0.0254671536,
0.0292624626,
0.1135864481,
0.0039307489,
0.0065634595,
0.0189027768,
-0.0114854705,
-0.0289194882,
-0.0319227763,
0.0551873371,
0.0047586779,
-0.0153893661,
-0.0317113549,
-0.0015772899,
-0.0039490233,
0.012998064,
-0.0260691084,
0.0601074472,
0.012413864,
0.0099194236,
-0.0226708557,
-0.0175169799,
-0.061341349,
-0.0432511382,
0.0019765992,
-0.062509872,
-0.041051086,
-0.0749932155,
0.0218894426,
0.0321717821,
-0.047814481,
-0.0177453961,
2.750173956e-34,
0.0426044129,
-0.0273278411,
0.0464724451,
0.0608778782,
-0.0105369734,
-0.0040084003,
-0.0405680239,
0.0222166255,
0.0306131132,
-0.0064915791,
-0.0109869754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14200v1 | Accessing Higher Dimensions for Unsupervised Word Translation | 2023-05-23T16:19:30 | 2023-05-23T16:19:30 | Sida I. Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The striking ability of unsupervised word translation has been demonstrated
with the help of word vectors / pretraining; however, they require large
amounts of data and usually fails if the data come from different domains. We
propose coocmap, a method that can use either high-dimensional co-occurrence
counts or their lower-dimensional approximations. Freed from the limits of low
dimensions, we show that relying on low-dimensional vectors and their
incidental properties miss out on better denoising methods and useful world
knowledge in high dimensions, thus stunting the potential of the data. Our
results show that unsupervised translation can be achieved more easily and
robustly than previously thought -- less than 80MB and minutes of CPU time is
required to achieve over 50\% accuracy for English to Finnish, Hungarian, and
Chinese translations when trained on similar data; even under domain mismatch,
we show coocmap still works fully unsupervised on English NewsCrawl to Chinese
Wikipedia and English Europarl to Spanish Wikipedia, among others. These
results challenge prevailing assumptions on the necessity and superiority of
low-dimensional vectors, and suggest that similarly processed co-occurrences
can outperform dense vectors on other tasks too. | [
0.0094172899,
0.0611724667,
0.024664741,
0.0692143738,
-0.0093697403,
0.0274126828,
0.0376271307,
0.0008826654,
-0.0081765354,
-0.0147132613,
-0.0528520495,
-0.0364397727,
0.0294665694,
0.0113315638,
0.0211035572,
-0.0526702516,
0.0603383593,
-0.0021072412,
-0.0496247523,
-0.0118093258,
-0.0577804148,
0.0020835511,
-0.0281268321,
-0.0005900159,
-0.0350325517,
-0.0247904174,
0.0161023624,
0.0307604,
0.0294037331,
-0.0046597989,
-0.0176263414,
0.0412779599,
0.0453777276,
0.0446620658,
0.0000021018,
-0.0349658616,
-0.0157438982,
0.0215143636,
0.0512356795,
0.0348715261,
-0.0119053712,
-0.0699440837,
-0.0142902015,
-0.0208624769,
0.0086763473,
-0.0530304015,
0.0348832384,
0.026576193,
0.0504013114,
0.0968719423,
-0.0376045927,
-0.0666982755,
-0.0147168916,
-0.0442047082,
0.0235685334,
-0.0619607046,
-0.0015697018,
0.0210173279,
-0.0759302527,
0.0186231751,
-0.0520189404,
0.0646159127,
-0.0184414145,
-0.0243031271,
0.0157557819,
0.0316182859,
-0.0163737293,
-0.0341249779,
0.0172274876,
0.0869588628,
-0.0448649973,
0.0201910269,
0.0140421791,
0.0239037555,
-0.0250246655,
0.0115134791,
-0.0271427035,
-0.0412794948,
0.0331055559,
0.0179939959,
-0.0187204052,
0.0456579812,
0.0240504052,
-0.0052313539,
-0.0111990198,
0.0081392899,
0.0380746387,
0.0008739585,
-0.0023012629,
0.0159302,
0.0426346809,
0.0056891907,
0.0571277328,
0.0083321584,
0.0241324808,
-0.0013560002,
-0.0364819057,
-0.0545297712,
-0.0159066971,
-0.1082258224,
0.0125159631,
0.0325521603,
-0.0172412954,
0.1076140925,
-0.0307312906,
-0.0078509031,
-0.0606883392,
0.0219401084,
-0.066007413,
-0.0381942615,
-0.0175500531,
0.0432978272,
-0.0598157011,
-0.0035824848,
-0.0328388438,
-0.0160329901,
-0.0430504493,
-0.017980257,
0.0180622041,
-0.015953768,
-0.0210905131,
-0.0016377538,
-0.0625190511,
-0.0468557142,
0.018136587,
0.0367378704,
-0.0425991975,
0.0071964827,
-0.0383393317,
-0.004336854,
-0.0249623787,
0.0346607044,
0.0423054658,
-0.0701202825,
0.0167585891,
0.0576035716,
-0.0233475417,
-0.0471500643,
-0.0000656038,
-0.0117218262,
-0.0352452956,
-0.0478941724,
-0.0187540967,
-0.0792741403,
0.0493668504,
-0.0008568174,
0.031851545,
-0.0581824854,
0.0013171363,
-0.002412912,
-0.0868864805,
0.0819910169,
-0.0151968691,
0.0052642361,
0.0151796984,
-0.010193428,
0.0170109309,
0.0491209179,
0.0284352507,
0.0142726377,
0.0572714433,
0.0221734773,
0.0027912194,
-0.0012282752,
0.0051709949,
0.0265909936,
-0.0076994323,
0.0033344759,
0.0217612442,
0.0601217672,
0.1031330302,
0.0315634906,
-0.0377539657,
-0.0260634702,
0.0638365522,
0.0294378139,
0.0209561307,
0.0660807118,
0.0571119338,
-0.0110583333,
-0.0043220399,
0.0291851237,
-0.014671484,
0.0051566004,
0.0048763575,
-0.0272759013,
0.0734879747,
0.0221237559,
-0.0506572649,
-0.0099321436,
0.0390733257,
-0.0281288885,
0.0142595489,
-0.0340574197,
0.0523975492,
0.0017506363,
0.009063351,
-0.0009489731,
-0.002034371,
-0.0535885692,
0.0518225469,
0.0127961412,
0.0038390185,
0.0374277048,
0.0355533101,
-0.0165828969,
-0.0112975044,
0.0156616718,
0.048229225,
0.0512734503,
0.0769812465,
0.0026873455,
0.0389009975,
-0.0289204791,
-0.008192949,
-0.0048459726,
-0.0022016412,
0.0070495233,
0.0113228615,
0.0710023865,
0.0497082584,
-0.0796255395,
-0.0288840774,
0.0141883846,
0.0134318843,
-0.0132422429,
0.0140431719,
0.0141108558,
-0.0234114304,
0.0361455306,
-0.0169051141,
0.0125156902,
0.0050020935,
-0.0589706376,
-0.0380692519,
-0.0025667378,
-0.0432457626,
-0.0400385484,
0.0207952093,
-0.076984711,
-0.0267362557,
0.0224104766,
-0.0111689391,
-0.0224420112,
0.0144260544,
-0.0074246447,
0.0135162827,
-0.0340371542,
0.011051178,
0.0073585548,
0.0500785746,
-0.0174096152,
0.0477049984,
0.0370382182,
-0.0115484102,
0.030595202,
-0.0108685326,
0.0053760651,
0.0035112894,
-0.0481418967,
0.0188006274,
0.0211885851,
0.0362440646,
0.029610876,
-0.0074545708,
-0.0259701367,
-0.0011308853,
-0.0140208248,
0.0251201484,
-0.0109893735,
0.005774206,
0.0151980072,
0.0332784019,
0.0078554805,
-0.015352739,
-0.0307215042,
0.0399505794,
-0.0021142007,
0.0296304449,
0.0029258425,
-0.0359314866,
0.0318012424,
-0.0339498855,
0.0107549429,
0.0351160057,
0.0379622914,
-0.006075542,
-0.0591107644,
-0.0243938249,
0.0664629042,
-0.0437959656,
0.0041596568,
0.023041375,
-0.0322732851,
-0.0228075385,
-0.0193906389,
0.0196938403,
-0.0010466361,
-0.0044464092,
0.0026479396,
0.048861675,
-0.03726184,
-0.0414739996,
0.0141770672,
-0.031014204,
-0.0118429475,
-0.0370218195,
0.0395740084,
0.0143335005,
0.0394835696,
0.0032272898,
-0.0201218873,
-0.0374679379,
-0.0503421463,
-0.0216716863,
-0.0263295788,
-0.0389969721,
0.0381404907,
0.02645538,
0.0177735835,
-0.0039317324,
-0.0018746069,
0.0183131825,
-0.025797341,
0.0076150778,
-0.0420001,
-0.0004683309,
-0.0148177436,
0.037894994,
-0.0096520605,
0.0574139357,
-0.04530086,
-0.0023939759,
0.0030242028,
0.0312811136,
0.0011665697,
-0.0116852354,
0.0347848125,
-0.0561741702,
0.0140764695,
-0.0370910875,
-0.0238445234,
-0.0264740512,
-0.033719711,
0.0169642139,
-0.0156580172,
0.0024812522,
-0.0357691422,
-0.0332195535,
0.0149637908,
0.0438458845,
0.0941717103,
0.0007721816,
-0.0302775651,
-0.0131264748,
0.0930339172,
0.0008326778,
0.0523324609,
-0.0199777242,
-0.0074323188,
0.0078658089,
0.0301631913,
-0.0238949768,
-0.0363867246,
0.0023222009,
-0.0183274876,
0.0195478443,
0.015978381,
-0.0270790998,
-0.0241159666,
0.0514075831,
-0.0209115297,
-0.0545292199,
0.0979931876,
0.009699557,
-0.0552191138,
-0.0175600518,
0.0033605173,
-0.0278427936,
0.0246142801,
0.0084179509,
-0.0429004841,
-0.0178931057,
-0.0102446424,
0.00984086,
0.0597149506,
-0.0344036706,
-0.0166795049,
-0.0671781749,
-0.0014680667,
0.0330786929,
-0.0140135493,
-0.0989791751,
-0.0745783225,
0.0053965612,
-0.0086091924,
-0.024733806,
-0.0362198465,
0.0353955217,
-0.0164666325,
0.0012411325,
-0.0137521261,
-0.0803397596,
-0.0160181727,
-0.0566623807,
0.0209579412,
0.0100557823,
0.080225721,
-0.0302538108,
-0.0251952466,
-0.0121774608,
-0.00873945,
-0.0095619401,
-0.0019761841,
0.0625786632,
-0.0046326448,
-0.0208540652,
0.036863748,
0.0351646766,
-0.0508824959,
-0.0303134657,
0.0138593987,
0.0554098748,
-0.0211080369,
-0.0133651476,
0.0182763916,
-0.0116296718,
0.028576443,
0.0540193729,
0.0249112379,
-0.0140417824,
0.037481606,
0.0186557025,
-0.0139644472,
-0.0448665321,
-0.0363630131,
-0.012016939,
-0.0275133848,
-0.0459914394,
-0.0755519122,
-0.0445355177,
0.0261014886,
0.065125145,
-0.0008577918,
0.0137764849,
0.0377802849,
-0.0246358607,
0.0027838603,
0.0153104011,
-0.0723113492,
0.0281677209,
-0.027224144,
-0.007046137,
-0.005252663,
0.0099557573,
0.0143820439,
0.0330195688,
-0.0037221019,
-0.0618301705,
-0.0079370458,
0.0306274462,
0.0121976146,
0.0253019389,
-0.0377630852,
-0.0308518838,
0.0503715612,
0.0031333202,
-0.0440760925,
0.0370790549,
-0.013083077,
-0.0280005578,
-0.0005105242,
0.0464193001,
-0.0083690537,
0.0145129506,
0.0194622949,
0.0441392623,
-0.0115464684,
-0.0545090623,
0.0156729687,
-0.0410906672,
0.0923311189,
-0.0420581587,
0.0514506176,
-0.046424713,
-0.0128692491,
-0.0098002777,
-0.010018453,
-0.0139960507,
-0.0415809602,
0.0739840344,
-0.0138636529,
-0.0267538577,
0.0815598518,
-0.0221181009,
-0.0179667249,
-0.0449297428,
-0.013368777,
-0.0259436518,
0.0039999085,
0.0122724622,
0.0117051778,
-0.0250407197,
-0.0008195388,
-0.0268069822,
0.0116269561,
-0.0339797772,
0.0040894356,
0.0165415965,
0.0057607521,
-0.0013344785,
0.025775196,
-0.0551894493,
-0.0102332458,
-0.0098073594,
0.0234325714,
0.0962150842,
-0.0449866541,
0.0968599617,
-0.0182437226,
-0.0304010976,
-0.0361149684,
0.033466965,
0.02067912,
-0.0150474515,
-0.00782141,
-0.007943186,
0.0041576014,
0.026404541,
0.0871598646,
-0.0399285443,
0.0339659937,
0.013388969,
-0.0026693603,
0.0047223102,
0.001847046,
0.0262117125,
-0.0111762257,
-0.0519289449,
-0.0124301175,
-0.0293072015,
-0.0504143536,
0.011021602,
-0.0107367625,
-0.0298492089,
0.0135968104,
0.0346825607,
0.0383371077,
-0.0055879797,
0.0437323749,
-0.0403497703,
0.0180837214,
0.0003726486,
-0.0156653095,
-0.0048905113,
-6.294905226e-33,
-0.0261802357,
-0.0118125482,
-0.0237363968,
-0.0202804934,
0.0011197402,
0.0114363693,
-0.0297671985,
0.0188340899,
-0.0109752268,
0.0368660241,
0.0030158001,
0.0023700532,
0.0211794637,
-0.0118934996,
-0.0018205674,
0.0247320551,
0.0548334494,
0.0129559739,
-0.0110998806,
0.0294389147,
0.0449718311,
0.0307659432,
0.0943891555,
-0.119301267,
0.0139149986,
0.0079865241,
0.0170487445,
0.0106790792,
0.088008292,
-0.0301017314,
-0.0374241471,
0.041894909,
0.0055736732,
-0.024506757,
-0.0102460608,
-0.0129396878,
-0.0964348912,
0.0064068809,
-0.0282954313,
0.0268867966,
-0.0205397941,
-0.0211185608,
-0.0007500043,
0.0309900511,
0.0341878496,
0.0086345337,
0.0288146921,
-0.054882966,
-0.028251715,
-0.0083316751,
-0.1145694181,
0.041379936,
-0.027556086,
-0.0271438658,
0.0227091964,
0.0297142155,
0.0059030247,
-0.0496822484,
-0.0800591484,
0.0133021455,
-0.0614793748,
0.0598659143,
0.0417644531,
-0.0090211835,
-0.0470359698,
0.0519772805,
0.0140425386,
-0.0266435128,
0.0050893878,
0.0207940452,
0.020497011,
-0.0075255609,
0.0082611572,
0.063496843,
0.0398840234,
-0.0349649116,
-0.061745774,
0.0878263041,
-0.0589468144,
0.0105712488,
0.0201992821,
-0.0050535332,
-0.0072862366,
0.0139070991,
-0.0069075106,
-0.0038362031,
-0.0363345593,
-0.0389883481,
-0.0139258206,
0.0131722754,
-0.0484878123,
0.0257016998,
0.0472607873,
0.0104953069,
-0.0395789146,
-0.002375613,
0.0272020716,
0.0030324629,
-0.0262092128,
0.0220741257,
0.0001050802,
-0.0962025896,
0.0035439529,
0.0324207544,
0.0227952916,
-0.0342042334,
0.0365578048,
0.0371799991,
-0.0395588204,
-0.0160264168,
-0.0421888158,
-0.0547871701,
-0.0045725335,
0.0275460631,
-0.0116580743,
-0.0180053171,
-0.0172892641,
0.018790571,
0.0142037831,
0.0059971735,
0.0201576687,
-0.0335615277,
0.031475056,
0.0265468527,
-0.0374320894,
0.0024198862,
-0.0577505864,
-0.0316907503,
0.0563216135,
-0.0745769665,
-0.0228213947,
0.0032269354,
2.911e-7,
0.0459223241,
0.0398120731,
-0.0001121722,
-0.0288301632,
-0.0135782482,
0.0181407463,
-0.0248545893,
0.081353873,
-0.045827765,
0.0007833595,
0.025028836,
0.0595591962,
0.0364659615,
0.0412630066,
-0.0541652702,
0.0248412061,
-0.0033578137,
0.03647108,
-0.0530549586,
-0.0389147997,
0.0395954177,
0.0642505586,
-0.015332534,
0.0048700715,
0.0231589675,
-0.015438918,
0.0887706131,
0.0005909671,
-0.0214003865,
-0.0038775438,
0.0247699711,
0.0438045897,
-0.0265376046,
-0.0204867199,
-0.0338192545,
0.0306898318,
0.1025329232,
0.0667270571,
-0.0101901302,
0.0307328664,
0.0134475268,
-0.0257950574,
-0.0109114852,
-0.002902308,
0.0666799918,
-0.0478213169,
-0.0074049914,
-0.0063861376,
0.0152340122,
0.0697113648,
0.043572098,
-0.0418714844,
-0.0589389615,
0.011480663,
0.0562686548,
-0.004979617,
-0.0264179595,
-0.0248918589,
-0.0334604643,
-0.0210997015,
-0.0265980903,
-0.0270946454,
-0.0360682942,
-0.0028917021,
0.0377909839,
0.0377744585,
0.0356968231,
2.035515864e-34,
0.006801249,
0.0173443425,
-0.0197199788,
-0.0758821741,
0.0005821553,
-0.0386614613,
-0.0253429208,
-0.0120645277,
-0.0218199752,
-0.0328878537,
-0.0232902057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14196v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14196v3 | ZeroSCROLLS: A Zero-Shot Benchmark for Long Text Understanding | 2023-05-23T16:15:31 | 2023-12-17T17:05:09 | Uri Shaham, Maor Ivgi, Avia Efrat, Jonathan Berant, Omer Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML | We introduce ZeroSCROLLS, a zero-shot benchmark for natural language
understanding over long texts, which contains only test and small validation
sets, without training data. We adapt six tasks from the SCROLLS benchmark, and
add four new datasets, including two novel information fusing tasks, such as
aggregating the percentage of positive reviews. Using ZeroSCROLLS, we conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of both open-source and closed large language models,
finding that Claude outperforms ChatGPT, and that GPT-4 achieves the highest
average score. However, there is still room for improvement on multiple open
challenges in ZeroSCROLLS, such as aggregation tasks, where models struggle to
pass the naive baseline. As the state of the art is a moving target, we invite
researchers to evaluate their ideas on the live ZeroSCROLLS leaderboard. | [
-0.0072275242,
0.0555589907,
0.024079185,
0.0748335049,
-0.0174796171,
0.0117688505,
-0.0156311691,
-0.0148580624,
-0.0330207683,
-0.0321060866,
-0.0191539768,
-0.0390009061,
0.0076440754,
0.0400195569,
0.0019844382,
-0.0254283007,
0.0528874509,
0.0062351692,
-0.0130072599,
0.0389424637,
0.0237185284,
0.018674586,
-0.0187216215,
0.0185628626,
0.0270526633,
-0.0251109432,
-0.0193138272,
0.0046075014,
0.0322277509,
-0.0450018048,
-0.0222551413,
0.0324992836,
0.0334945843,
0.0893255174,
0.0000017894,
-0.0242903251,
-0.0025246865,
-0.0001630104,
-0.0423090495,
-0.0357726552,
0.0479737632,
-0.0674785003,
0.0140101295,
0.0022960489,
-0.0068909479,
-0.0542848706,
0.0224919058,
0.0545592606,
0.0623311326,
0.0989129469,
-0.0092540719,
-0.0385260135,
0.0188787244,
-0.0574062094,
0.0449015461,
-0.0665483773,
-0.0044519701,
-0.009075474,
0.0149248289,
0.0055962931,
-0.0261664726,
0.0137081053,
0.0308342837,
-0.013282042,
0.0296295322,
0.0519605502,
-0.0771799237,
-0.0079671098,
0.005258319,
0.1148599312,
-0.0222991239,
-0.0088432413,
-0.004072105,
0.000836144,
-0.0083633801,
-0.0320051163,
-0.0629530251,
-0.0153976139,
0.0007708021,
0.0112154139,
-0.0439499728,
0.0001342365,
0.0393611304,
0.0105754351,
-0.0247236229,
0.0370579474,
-0.0202586446,
-0.013081274,
0.0328742266,
0.002423503,
0.0013353786,
-0.0483875088,
-0.047822848,
0.0485448763,
0.0039644428,
0.0140176993,
-0.0102666924,
-0.0071120365,
0.028527962,
-0.0383331142,
0.0138714015,
0.043858666,
-0.0122471787,
0.1152823493,
-0.0271796379,
0.044681903,
0.0019242014,
-0.000091707,
-0.0404685885,
0.0002408307,
-0.0663466305,
0.0134098865,
-0.0137458947,
0.0259307381,
-0.0286502596,
-0.0276569836,
-0.0071165957,
-0.0045611323,
0.0123354373,
0.0244534276,
0.0040363106,
-0.0065485258,
0.004616031,
-0.0161699671,
0.0045022215,
0.082747668,
-0.0557608195,
-0.0022418026,
-0.0142630031,
-0.0269681979,
-0.049936343,
0.0001419281,
-0.0072150473,
-0.0083549786,
-0.0030276866,
0.036203485,
-0.0156209674,
-0.0437612385,
-0.0100747114,
-0.0260658674,
-0.0269162115,
-0.0804513544,
-0.003101283,
-0.0496241674,
0.0436781757,
0.0038407655,
0.0017769075,
0.0160350353,
-0.0066030137,
0.0245690681,
-0.0549877323,
0.0747262836,
-0.008979558,
-0.0353011638,
-0.0468882099,
0.021726843,
-0.0048016501,
0.1028256938,
-0.0029942116,
0.0221038293,
0.0114416359,
0.01182946,
-0.0105287442,
0.0120272106,
0.0327155702,
0.0229538046,
-0.0100304931,
0.0288890451,
-0.0194850639,
0.0067025577,
0.0207403991,
0.0126709547,
-0.0428907797,
-0.0521634109,
0.0280455258,
0.0374692827,
-0.0105759529,
0.0026738478,
-0.0052035814,
0.0149577362,
-0.0027636285,
0.0015388366,
-0.0405567326,
0.0223740023,
-0.051341638,
0.0120798368,
0.0289958436,
-0.0002524129,
-0.0485456437,
-0.0123597505,
-0.0351617895,
-0.0074321693,
0.0217015967,
0.0055414359,
0.0634774566,
-0.0052894815,
-0.0455634966,
0.0030380522,
0.0224669892,
-0.0499932803,
0.0056469534,
-0.0186045524,
0.0632380843,
0.0355919674,
0.0535954908,
-0.0278398097,
-0.049146831,
-0.0219796672,
0.0159052555,
0.0351974145,
0.0333300866,
-0.0164318029,
0.0176649448,
-0.052950006,
-0.0200838353,
0.0048124287,
0.0115575418,
0.0171031933,
-0.0188825019,
0.0082266591,
0.0215461999,
-0.0439183936,
-0.0038476139,
0.0161364321,
-0.0012252578,
-0.0171210431,
-0.0114971427,
-0.0356113501,
0.0237919055,
0.0413073264,
-0.0419921242,
0.0083971191,
0.0368933752,
-0.0217120107,
-0.0454841219,
-0.0190570131,
-0.0166546628,
-0.0576225668,
0.0356340259,
-0.0564705916,
-0.0308247767,
0.0307147242,
-0.0706622973,
-0.064219974,
0.0007103287,
0.018947348,
0.009684192,
-0.0133719146,
0.0096636638,
0.0179360807,
0.0174654089,
-0.0235959534,
0.0384720676,
-0.006311384,
0.0223885383,
-0.0415064953,
-0.0365835615,
0.0301077794,
-0.0091513749,
-0.0344459824,
0.03322253,
0.0046736016,
0.0037628938,
0.0238349475,
-0.0105013251,
-0.0706029758,
-0.0309216771,
-0.128187865,
0.0370067284,
-0.0239095353,
0.0158069581,
0.0294967648,
0.0182792097,
0.0098118028,
-0.0235794988,
-0.0424466617,
0.0188015867,
0.0190630853,
0.0071263709,
0.03633013,
0.0019229677,
0.0148050673,
-0.0483697429,
-0.0276947264,
-0.0369172767,
0.0413586907,
0.0102960672,
-0.015327286,
0.0180121735,
-0.0043445504,
-0.0708573014,
0.0133996224,
-0.0369942896,
-0.0266918093,
0.0124401031,
-0.0256449617,
0.0100912461,
0.0248897932,
0.0014200228,
0.0161797255,
-0.0162708778,
-0.0169647951,
-0.0270980615,
0.0250747502,
-0.0167322252,
-0.017875405,
-0.0152688585,
0.0237960014,
0.0035911775,
0.094947882,
-0.019350484,
-0.0181164853,
-0.0484012999,
-0.0023825846,
-0.0168026444,
0.0218727812,
-0.041137293,
0.01317723,
0.0327967666,
0.0028736941,
-0.0729188994,
0.0073015764,
0.0448522568,
-0.055201333,
-0.0254417993,
-0.0321415365,
0.0123523353,
-0.0744203329,
0.0699765608,
0.0151077239,
-0.0050511453,
0.0153921917,
0.0205448642,
0.0062019196,
-0.0242885686,
-0.0062418166,
-0.0360014327,
0.0851970762,
0.001615915,
0.0562801659,
-0.0380872339,
-0.0365840122,
-0.018580405,
-0.0897413418,
-0.0397440307,
0.0112829702,
0.0003023364,
-0.0339882262,
-0.0613354966,
0.0040961667,
0.0196001716,
0.057664454,
-0.0167033523,
-0.0154385567,
-0.0046986057,
0.0187813323,
0.0516291633,
-0.017305389,
0.0070732739,
-0.0497437604,
0.0488612466,
0.0726902932,
0.0491367988,
0.010527269,
-0.0179707743,
-0.0185619593,
0.0039783269,
-0.0304798819,
-0.0034548212,
-0.0330529772,
0.043725539,
-0.0482039973,
0.0146071371,
0.143563956,
0.0176371001,
-0.0743762329,
-0.0260233264,
-0.0063758944,
0.0398272648,
0.0331859179,
-0.0097519811,
-0.1128394827,
-0.0674023628,
0.0081137046,
0.0031534955,
0.0364425741,
-0.0407681353,
-0.0431814715,
-0.1087453738,
0.0074839643,
0.000793212,
-0.0682999343,
0.0208349042,
-0.0455614105,
0.0202286281,
-0.0472251736,
-0.001939556,
0.0145267313,
-0.0083738752,
0.0143045392,
-0.0191185847,
-0.0028160033,
-0.0028190969,
0.0433788821,
-0.0056521161,
0.0270503983,
0.0135613838,
0.0418100618,
-0.0000665583,
0.0022993907,
0.0542140976,
-0.0378882773,
-0.0215806663,
-0.010997667,
0.1060597971,
-0.022731673,
-0.0074915453,
-0.0078635355,
0.0197283421,
-0.0562622435,
0.0409708768,
0.0138842817,
0.0252947547,
-0.0077481251,
-0.0254269782,
-0.0193063263,
-0.0085089179,
-0.0243412312,
0.1008771732,
0.0074571487,
0.0069757206,
-0.0461382158,
0.0060830736,
-0.0335199349,
-0.0222219378,
-0.0134148831,
-0.0100033972,
0.0170005802,
-0.0414316282,
-0.0403577127,
-0.0676984936,
0.0350166634,
0.0472202227,
-0.0134065663,
0.00954038,
0.0250267815,
-0.0112016294,
-0.0450489298,
0.0396790467,
-0.0079181343,
0.0026383628,
-0.0504825599,
0.0225564111,
0.0399309397,
0.0031687797,
-0.0098124333,
0.0078214789,
-0.1011653543,
-0.0553208031,
-0.0304030702,
-0.0002735798,
0.0304486398,
0.0393665209,
-0.0454771295,
-0.0116123958,
0.0237988755,
0.0172186885,
-0.032880418,
-0.012908496,
0.0164691545,
-0.0089700874,
0.0080974074,
0.0427712016,
-0.0137028145,
0.0407213159,
-0.0288364068,
-0.0103854612,
-0.0542516187,
0.0041534603,
-0.0098628998,
-0.0032466794,
0.0404451527,
0.0310658757,
0.0287727453,
-0.0131127769,
-0.0012532569,
-0.0270540472,
0.0028376828,
-0.0515185371,
-0.0178998709,
0.0353178978,
-0.0478465706,
-0.0157764871,
0.0434615053,
-0.0219122451,
0.0243067332,
-0.0606245436,
0.0021511528,
0.0199846476,
-0.0145301567,
0.0097937239,
-0.0455639288,
-0.0165513139,
-0.0042135618,
-0.0260302722,
0.0351773016,
-0.0009011701,
0.0486375839,
0.0373811126,
0.0374775939,
0.0046311263,
0.0218659211,
-0.074210085,
-0.0113145644,
0.0065485812,
0.0482373685,
0.0508985035,
-0.0069093322,
0.0728450865,
0.0219700523,
0.0029218865,
-0.023395298,
0.0110887475,
-0.00976835,
-0.0198982134,
0.0087221004,
0.0598515458,
-0.0050014644,
-0.0007122448,
0.0917764604,
-0.0061064898,
0.0064037298,
0.0299024861,
0.012714739,
-0.0373382606,
0.0056523108,
0.0126077235,
0.0276043303,
0.0211453456,
0.0537102073,
-0.0574830249,
-0.0539790653,
0.0509627759,
-0.0008497656,
0.0207498372,
0.0011471487,
0.0132997492,
0.0339640491,
-0.0019053391,
0.0067436579,
-0.0355511382,
0.0009123563,
-0.0583059266,
-0.0129762916,
0.0015105261,
-6.735002965e-33,
-0.0176378842,
-0.0020598609,
-0.0009410755,
0.007000729,
-0.0422916785,
0.0331795327,
-0.0437720641,
0.0191920176,
-0.0151204756,
0.0209314413,
-0.0039583067,
0.0584939718,
0.001276608,
0.0394689403,
-0.034777794,
-0.0468895026,
0.0587558039,
-0.0035384728,
-0.0352833122,
0.0148947136,
0.0499536358,
0.0212126393,
0.0298084356,
-0.0185200013,
0.0445910767,
-0.0177361406,
-0.0015961385,
0.0281725489,
0.0290992111,
0.0274374057,
-0.0060994742,
0.0222317837,
0.0633394942,
-0.0354963765,
-0.0102425218,
0.0190234426,
-0.0981286094,
-0.0282395706,
0.0226934701,
0.0066872369,
-0.024324486,
0.0263437796,
0.0357616246,
0.0041401042,
0.0398596078,
-0.0537158549,
0.0099577457,
-0.0177504458,
-0.0228035506,
-0.0095509356,
-0.0294490196,
0.0520467125,
-0.0224916581,
-0.0415454581,
0.0479301549,
0.0409489796,
0.0033287629,
0.0491800047,
-0.0520181432,
-0.0288555194,
-0.0151686547,
0.0521989465,
0.0285355505,
0.0116842808,
-0.0115178926,
0.0848000348,
-0.0043359161,
0.0004823258,
-0.089740403,
0.0097161364,
0.0131114805,
0.0031372341,
0.0415359735,
0.0264524203,
0.0949384794,
0.0324517749,
-0.0707096457,
0.0350240692,
0.0607666597,
0.0429733023,
0.0045220545,
0.01798415,
-0.0432915092,
0.0177590623,
-0.0355631523,
-0.0056661824,
-0.0421013609,
0.0148586007,
0.0173465721,
0.0232930779,
0.011595102,
-0.0000290926,
0.0324647203,
-0.0228998195,
0.0044784197,
0.0674655586,
0.0137672685,
0.0080145421,
0.0174591541,
0.0195140466,
-0.0496794134,
0.0016383729,
0.0010115504,
0.0756607652,
-0.0045360364,
-0.0043897736,
0.0825871751,
-0.0149407806,
-0.0493835509,
-0.0354212411,
-0.0407157689,
0.0390721597,
-0.045992732,
0.0647628009,
0.0505118668,
0.0149743399,
-0.0195130967,
0.073706381,
-0.0113208033,
0.0148011344,
-0.0106732501,
0.0323594771,
-0.0036603608,
-0.0128729939,
-0.0200103279,
-0.0257741138,
0.0026462243,
-0.0166833624,
0.0252085291,
-0.0823227689,
-0.0108814742,
0.0358879082,
2.526e-7,
0.0293465052,
0.0145772407,
0.0591373518,
0.0106410338,
0.0095698917,
0.0318072326,
-0.0367587693,
0.020597158,
-0.0174259171,
-0.0259839483,
-0.0383947417,
0.04642893,
0.034908697,
0.0292767882,
-0.0743824318,
-0.0079805367,
-0.049720142,
0.0067438316,
-0.0334843397,
0.0210357234,
0.097211808,
0.0991209298,
0.0014309085,
0.0061906236,
0.043738883,
-0.0303972457,
0.055658184,
0.0171129405,
-0.0085499575,
0.0068423511,
0.0378373116,
0.0428183489,
-0.0137047144,
0.010761084,
0.0086346213,
0.0152376108,
0.008849768,
0.0468607359,
-0.022207709,
-0.0150814457,
0.0298543051,
-0.0301092602,
0.0005650689,
-0.0070003299,
0.1132242531,
-0.0381130166,
-0.0421264209,
-0.0451603383,
-0.040469639,
0.00672644,
0.034014184,
0.0474626869,
-0.02295449,
0.0463965051,
0.0189502016,
-0.0543815903,
-0.0172007624,
-0.0938294679,
-0.0428448282,
0.0094055925,
-0.0146158636,
0.0111631965,
-0.0253746212,
-0.0037923525,
0.0068109958,
-0.0572314151,
-0.013808338,
2.189101319e-34,
0.0836449414,
-0.0456491634,
-0.0058532092,
-0.043004524,
0.0357019603,
-0.0283408798,
-0.0280957371,
-0.0406239554,
0.0150546199,
-0.073791571,
0.0173485614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14195v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14195v3 | HumBEL: A Human-in-the-Loop Approach for Evaluating Demographic Factors of Language Models in Human-Machine Conversations | 2023-05-23T16:15:24 | 2024-02-05T17:28:07 | Anthony Sicilia, Jennifer C. Gates, Malihe Alikhani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While demographic factors like age and gender change the way people talk, and
in particular, the way people talk to machines, there is little investigation
into how large pre-trained language models (LMs) can adapt to these changes. To
remedy this gap, we consider how demographic factors in LM language skills can
be measured to determine compatibility with a target demographic. We suggest
clinical techniques from Speech Language Pathology, which has norms for
acquisition of language skills in humans. We conduct evaluation with a domain
expert (i.e., a clinically licensed speech language pathologist), and also
propose automated techniques to complement clinical evaluation at scale.
Empirically, we focus on age, finding LM capability varies widely depending on
task: GPT-3.5 mimics the ability of humans ranging from age 6-15 at tasks
requiring inference, and simultaneously, outperforms a typical 21 year old at
memorization. GPT-3.5 also has trouble with social language use, exhibiting
less than 50% of the tested pragmatic skills. Findings affirm the importance of
considering demographic alignment and conversational goals when using LMs as
public-facing tools. Code, data, and a package will be available. | [
0.0465539172,
0.1019285694,
-0.0051877401,
-0.0137804514,
-0.027847385,
0.029994268,
0.0206437968,
0.0039771544,
-0.006179295,
-0.0166554172,
-0.0506750345,
-0.0597931109,
0.0360293724,
0.0290672835,
0.0012208885,
-0.0592701137,
0.0220968015,
-0.025001755,
0.0398665778,
-0.0103784539,
-0.020739343,
0.0409403816,
-0.0500313528,
0.0490533561,
0.002284748,
-0.016120078,
0.0370185785,
-0.0104538752,
-0.0192042366,
-0.0057907333,
0.0189586058,
0.0589883141,
0.0215808395,
0.0155073116,
0.0000019641,
-0.0590916052,
0.0361449607,
0.0022172784,
-0.0475089289,
0.0089005679,
0.0646809489,
0.0073766848,
-0.0313917957,
0.0299574006,
-0.060836833,
-0.004971147,
0.0210613683,
-0.0088980403,
0.0182538964,
0.0541663207,
-0.0171571504,
0.0243465323,
0.0215169806,
-0.0148416907,
-0.002680701,
-0.0380256027,
0.0042723422,
0.0190186519,
0.0176733993,
-0.0708759055,
0.0277394671,
0.0590990968,
0.0103168683,
-0.0012934314,
0.0051975292,
0.0162160303,
-0.0004920977,
-0.0454914346,
-0.0201076455,
0.0380603895,
0.0099849682,
-0.0067569688,
-0.0005910932,
0.0164226834,
0.0026602305,
0.0115524419,
-0.0453096591,
0.0000932478,
0.0101135187,
-0.0117351552,
-0.0292452537,
-0.0379392169,
0.030523777,
0.0094637005,
0.0386710614,
0.0392092243,
0.0155589264,
-0.014389378,
0.0266071912,
0.0133526009,
0.008800054,
-0.0254357737,
0.0480564944,
0.0128102154,
-0.0757765919,
0.0222328398,
-0.038575571,
-0.0151080117,
0.0435167216,
-0.0164870657,
0.0074113831,
-0.0019223174,
-0.0353711769,
0.0369704962,
-0.0044738417,
0.0077165295,
0.0232006963,
-0.0100421822,
-0.0133773964,
-0.0024124272,
-0.019597197,
-0.0195169877,
-0.0066600638,
-0.022207547,
-0.004192336,
0.0132204881,
-0.0831515118,
-0.000251555,
-0.0159453377,
-0.0253130756,
-0.0141582452,
0.0287368726,
-0.0222990438,
-0.0126129184,
-0.0286260545,
0.0408289395,
-0.014675525,
0.0254558157,
-0.0198374875,
-0.1184178367,
0.0239067115,
0.000493197,
0.0035167623,
-0.0367015935,
0.0106780995,
0.0419987701,
-0.0181096457,
0.0018627776,
-0.0280776061,
-0.0204418972,
-0.0258585345,
-0.0690762103,
0.0146678127,
-0.0456185304,
0.0068645542,
0.0022503284,
0.0156991202,
-0.0470198542,
-0.0366762727,
0.0138374288,
-0.0423782729,
0.0415827148,
0.0028444401,
0.0482513905,
0.0619037375,
0.0015727229,
0.0295955297,
0.049685806,
0.0268820841,
-0.0722485036,
0.0155863669,
-0.0530371405,
0.0026904712,
0.0749723017,
0.0187704861,
-0.0023195867,
0.0047312845,
-0.0025744797,
-0.0111720534,
0.0477763228,
0.0743613914,
0.0298467316,
0.0263427459,
-0.041081503,
0.0663440675,
0.1135818958,
0.0127607929,
0.0213789195,
0.0497351326,
0.0228553917,
0.0377204344,
-0.0184453242,
-0.0450791605,
-0.0111942273,
-0.0407783836,
-0.039820537,
-0.0201933943,
0.0654214472,
-0.028808685,
-0.0085624,
-0.0044216323,
-0.0133122299,
0.0219468102,
0.0271657519,
0.0172712803,
0.0008932051,
-0.021144554,
0.0478002094,
0.0341697261,
-0.0506320931,
-0.0027480109,
-0.0487498641,
-0.0252078678,
0.0460416153,
-0.006676232,
-0.0123887444,
-0.0135588106,
0.005271974,
-0.0121748671,
0.0354541428,
0.0360647999,
0.0151127847,
0.0452388525,
-0.0366429277,
0.0148001527,
0.0626178533,
0.018392263,
-0.0190847311,
0.0623596534,
0.0303533189,
-0.0018639727,
-0.0359621681,
0.0092190038,
0.0296656843,
-0.0861133337,
0.0041888482,
-0.0090557728,
-0.0112727378,
0.0500845946,
0.0231335927,
-0.0046824119,
0.0101759089,
-0.0192760061,
0.0413229205,
0.0467237085,
0.0444093905,
-0.0944429338,
0.0050664861,
0.0363230072,
-0.0137828328,
-0.0787108019,
0.0189966764,
0.0034603525,
-0.0130445138,
0.0596439727,
-0.0845534131,
0.0226713922,
-0.0315784663,
0.027354937,
-0.0126113975,
-0.0030150022,
0.0023886736,
0.0209189914,
0.0016139464,
-0.0475014597,
0.0248026159,
-0.0273128096,
-0.0279972572,
-0.0855862126,
-0.0388160571,
-0.0084243417,
-0.0033809561,
0.0351812951,
-0.0113731744,
0.0233041514,
-0.0750329122,
-0.0270786881,
-0.096180819,
-0.0074522691,
-0.007741455,
0.001794829,
0.0073105134,
-0.0262640845,
-0.028599564,
-0.0581949353,
-0.0408511236,
0.0245672893,
0.0164392423,
0.0178713091,
0.0110327676,
-0.0161818061,
-0.005191402,
-0.0236895233,
-0.0064303828,
-0.0404137895,
0.0206942912,
0.0393536165,
-0.0024544604,
0.0091855647,
0.0171350688,
-0.0404701307,
0.0157639068,
-0.0035004383,
-0.011367158,
0.0264921188,
0.0165252071,
0.0640069544,
0.0714935735,
0.0269481149,
0.060203582,
0.0167810619,
-0.0265705083,
0.0013767264,
-0.0101448428,
-0.0286621395,
-0.0226599742,
-0.0418816432,
-0.0448539369,
0.0089747775,
0.0441745631,
0.0061493702,
0.0233343653,
-0.0645396337,
0.0069613918,
-0.0181785859,
-0.0242258459,
-0.0412421525,
-0.0141049,
-0.0398801304,
0.0246898718,
-0.0214197226,
-0.0719448254,
0.0634778515,
-0.0064652599,
-0.02333395,
-0.0204892196,
-0.0492284372,
-0.0332761928,
0.0530816391,
-0.0166387223,
0.0002548728,
0.0415119156,
-0.0349989533,
-0.0490976498,
0.0053190128,
0.0086648688,
-0.0789154246,
0.0669103488,
-0.0873004645,
0.0054089404,
0.0548250899,
-0.0431035422,
-0.0246764049,
-0.0053170789,
-0.06301599,
0.0224685948,
-0.0019844319,
-0.0417788327,
-0.0553540438,
-0.0183498021,
0.0269605033,
0.0663127005,
0.0156020736,
0.0168387089,
0.009365269,
-0.0132802622,
0.0238629244,
0.0583699048,
-0.0129080676,
-0.0440221429,
0.0184527412,
0.0229345653,
0.0085770916,
-0.0025980959,
-0.0372422375,
0.0453479439,
0.0152839338,
0.0006743233,
0.0190980081,
0.0345202908,
0.048857823,
-0.0239080079,
0.0311505049,
0.1085824743,
0.0187578797,
-0.070607543,
0.0002578834,
-0.0055410359,
0.0403743312,
-0.0210692678,
0.0037955528,
-0.0744798928,
-0.0160476174,
0.0293368977,
0.0545104146,
-0.0138631267,
-0.0134683624,
-0.0318321846,
-0.082400471,
0.0271290932,
0.0100573385,
-0.0612530932,
-0.0001692958,
-0.005388042,
0.0042765732,
-0.0059642345,
0.0679813996,
-0.0052793282,
-0.0331450999,
-0.0062109409,
0.0087540513,
-0.1258559972,
-0.0999120325,
0.1019187942,
-0.0122327488,
0.1072045639,
0.0447246619,
0.0167367514,
-0.0025567035,
-0.0310102031,
0.0506515205,
0.0276586991,
0.006425296,
-0.0258419029,
0.0484075584,
-0.0065299729,
0.003326148,
-0.0804153234,
0.0506254882,
-0.0173671041,
-0.0129860248,
0.0121571189,
0.0357483141,
-0.0163827389,
-0.0362117216,
-0.0046844617,
0.0461878516,
-0.0063377321,
0.0514771603,
0.0326250345,
-0.0395082757,
-0.0119595518,
0.0037452362,
0.0356638692,
0.0293817241,
-0.0644652992,
0.027768936,
0.0101574361,
-0.0484219678,
-0.0224237274,
-0.0054289512,
0.0663601384,
-0.0157946851,
0.0063322806,
-0.033523567,
0.040395692,
-0.0019513374,
-0.0495529212,
0.1117437035,
-0.0026947588,
0.0386612527,
-0.1071117893,
-0.0580439083,
0.0108485697,
-0.0304821245,
-0.0260589048,
0.0062583522,
-0.0304693189,
-0.0222348198,
0.0438373201,
0.0248328503,
0.0284650568,
0.0498346798,
-0.0164941773,
-0.0749011263,
0.0492929593,
0.0021140298,
-0.0325877517,
0.026344005,
0.0051913522,
0.0028952933,
-0.0011932913,
0.0261372793,
-0.0065737003,
0.0038808584,
-0.0222039092,
-0.0122716436,
-0.0606209226,
-0.0499922186,
0.0062107653,
0.0265583564,
0.0118908202,
0.001460789,
-0.0113779046,
-0.020955814,
-0.0041554542,
0.0272167474,
0.0262514781,
-0.0548914112,
-0.0465836599,
0.0242470279,
0.0088259336,
0.0010720786,
-0.0406746678,
-0.0563939773,
-0.0226202495,
-0.0081768911,
0.0420348682,
-0.0030113903,
0.0322076939,
0.0244324114,
0.0178700145,
-0.006111491,
0.0064195534,
-0.0474542901,
0.0545150153,
0.0326335989,
0.075321354,
-0.0198442135,
-0.0310052335,
0.044379022,
0.0200651567,
-0.0475019328,
-0.0152702956,
-0.02953941,
0.0029835287,
0.035768237,
-0.0100154094,
0.0529276095,
-0.026090119,
0.0315928869,
-0.0218584873,
0.0012482607,
-0.0211544521,
-0.0018191359,
0.0223876499,
0.0034023041,
-0.0034423533,
-0.0139709562,
0.0583318062,
0.0566396788,
0.0177859943,
-0.0175300185,
-0.0044331793,
-0.0308828596,
-0.0425174497,
0.0153846992,
-0.0198955592,
-0.0744047165,
0.0090160081,
-0.0555225052,
-0.0778272226,
-0.0177379623,
0.0112445895,
-0.0196364578,
-0.0289851371,
0.0383714214,
0.0225051194,
-0.049467735,
-0.0373268798,
-0.0354859568,
0.0075441734,
-0.0160635412,
0.0133640263,
-0.0046449834,
-6.607799047e-33,
-0.0327958614,
-0.0543495417,
0.0342308171,
-0.0185667723,
-0.0293370876,
0.0215774775,
-0.0380574502,
0.029953761,
-0.0115393382,
0.0132981297,
-0.0014334107,
0.0044941925,
0.0290341936,
0.0238118917,
-0.013179129,
-0.011139649,
0.0427456871,
-0.0133330524,
-0.0020862105,
-0.0208270475,
-0.054518152,
0.0267230812,
0.0639510453,
-0.0662580803,
0.0594631545,
0.0182342418,
0.0042284955,
0.0251936074,
-0.0015287006,
0.0230922848,
-0.0238688122,
0.0407940075,
0.018121535,
-0.0065138037,
-0.0101974532,
0.0483210906,
-0.0807827637,
0.0040669516,
0.0525686927,
0.0346371345,
-0.0200922452,
0.0167671219,
0.0295301061,
-0.004112774,
-0.0228601061,
-0.0185822211,
0.0431811623,
-0.0125287026,
0.0571458004,
0.022929823,
-0.0085795214,
0.033494927,
-0.0276667606,
-0.0356042609,
0.01122336,
0.0154273231,
-0.0579432175,
-0.0186007638,
-0.026851451,
0.0396432653,
0.0257947873,
-0.0107104201,
0.0425048172,
-0.0025021969,
0.0178780463,
0.0615945607,
0.0211273991,
-0.004392643,
-0.0199311059,
-0.0484215952,
0.0333172232,
0.0269299094,
0.0286670849,
-0.0048015504,
0.0196893625,
0.0195456613,
-0.0174817871,
-0.0175740458,
0.0287529938,
0.0529381521,
0.0037804833,
-0.0160621684,
-0.0247151963,
-0.0160029884,
-0.0326735154,
0.016763309,
-0.0130993249,
-0.0406541377,
0.0124424277,
-0.0207576063,
0.0115137324,
0.0078756241,
0.0015166417,
-0.000398157,
-0.0093315179,
-0.0411357954,
0.0213282332,
-0.0085146995,
-0.0062722,
0.0428051315,
-0.0576731674,
0.0032824434,
0.0504759885,
0.0121156964,
0.045296587,
0.0156637747,
-0.0339858085,
0.021598408,
-0.0692833439,
0.0052330582,
0.0012723965,
0.0043576565,
-0.0058098282,
0.0082767112,
0.0406423956,
0.029369818,
-0.0266718119,
0.0227879304,
-0.0473996587,
0.0049117678,
-0.0431046337,
-0.0080505116,
-0.0269762948,
0.0332336612,
-0.0336051248,
-0.0028129651,
-0.0087585626,
0.003934144,
0.0522826687,
-0.0095630065,
0.0225068927,
-0.0259111691,
2.709e-7,
0.0612788126,
0.0711581707,
0.0275538731,
-0.0008943347,
0.0378675088,
0.0057684509,
-0.0283177141,
-0.0041251476,
0.0555591509,
0.0185757391,
0.0053493553,
0.040914461,
0.096302487,
0.0379598923,
-0.0724942982,
-0.0191548783,
-0.1162322685,
0.0000984748,
-0.0254121553,
0.0261273552,
-0.0066241995,
0.0432345346,
-0.0190861169,
-0.0562544316,
-0.0074915919,
-0.0397227891,
0.0205226876,
-0.0730289072,
-0.0225554612,
-0.002155045,
0.0074257222,
-0.0018915104,
0.0484456494,
0.0974865928,
-0.0402415842,
-0.0002199679,
-0.0094125848,
0.0864525586,
-0.0438159108,
-0.0311664734,
-0.0083091268,
0.0416021943,
-0.0405699089,
-0.0200631544,
0.0352038108,
-0.0324377306,
-0.0702430755,
-0.0415418558,
0.0060449308,
-0.0404288843,
0.0495861731,
-0.0305616558,
-0.0363738202,
0.0218230486,
0.0347105525,
-0.0061600469,
-0.0158197843,
-0.0433680527,
-0.0049213902,
0.0042000394,
-0.0543244034,
-0.0655714795,
-0.0109649412,
-0.0240200497,
-0.0228146743,
-0.0049660252,
0.0413789935,
2.073672136e-34,
0.0275330786,
0.0486413799,
0.0492045991,
0.0051318253,
0.0188855641,
0.0152219497,
0.0838605687,
0.0367777869,
0.0334203616,
-0.0111640049,
-0.0001173221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14189v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14189v3 | Beyond Shared Vocabulary: Increasing Representational Word Similarities across Languages for Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-05-23T16:11:00 | 2024-01-20T22:29:15 | Di Wu, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Using a vocabulary that is shared across languages is common practice in
Multilingual Neural Machine Translation (MNMT). In addition to its simple
design, shared tokens play an important role in positive knowledge transfer,
assuming that shared tokens refer to similar meanings across languages.
However, when word overlap is small, especially due to different writing
systems, transfer is inhibited. In this paper, we define word-level information
transfer pathways via word equivalence classes and rely on graph networks to
fuse word embeddings across languages. Our experiments demonstrate the
advantages of our approach: 1) embeddings of words with similar meanings are
better aligned across languages, 2) our method achieves consistent BLEU
improvements of up to 2.3 points for high- and low-resource MNMT, and 3) less
than 1.0\% additional trainable parameters are required with a limited increase
in computational costs, while inference time remains identical to the baseline.
We release the codebase to the community. | [
-0.010925659,
0.0415574536,
0.0050339918,
0.067914106,
-0.0384873077,
-0.0082085654,
0.0085857008,
-0.0143409986,
-0.0186685603,
0.0011596793,
-0.0318806805,
-0.0151950093,
0.0345745161,
0.0199554581,
0.0536818653,
-0.0241321102,
0.0348607525,
0.0234314762,
-0.057315968,
-0.0165506788,
0.013425882,
0.0398966372,
0.0425862111,
0.0080354447,
-0.0306378379,
0.0172545295,
0.0274457578,
0.03327078,
0.03765231,
-0.0144352578,
-0.0531677529,
0.0123959864,
0.0276713111,
0.0916004479,
0.0000018106,
-0.0285760034,
-0.0370663814,
0.011393073,
0.0522997826,
-0.0099660214,
0.0617197342,
-0.0545779504,
0.0293636434,
0.0125292623,
-0.007387931,
-0.039378766,
0.0998314768,
0.0056360052,
0.0183873735,
0.0690109506,
-0.0436502211,
-0.0098088691,
-0.013559103,
-0.0662000105,
-0.0066238102,
-0.0527627766,
-0.0169752743,
0.0135189155,
-0.0358450077,
-0.0111970762,
-0.0653284714,
0.0654274002,
0.0128931981,
0.0076860278,
0.0104474695,
0.0327667221,
0.0240112972,
0.0063633043,
0.0131149227,
0.0856105089,
-0.0611160956,
-0.0335271209,
-0.041478429,
-0.0127750272,
0.0151094589,
-0.0054507991,
-0.0501874201,
-0.0152206002,
0.0094488235,
0.0515559129,
0.0179082137,
0.0358334593,
0.0934871137,
-0.0261073299,
-0.0264809672,
0.0175925177,
0.077516593,
-0.01036584,
-0.0025040149,
0.0326834843,
0.0054938667,
0.0011185559,
0.0282178335,
0.0008962366,
0.0012582057,
0.0206879117,
-0.041731488,
-0.0237388313,
-0.0039556893,
-0.026082702,
0.0445398577,
0.0692437738,
0.011234724,
0.0427226499,
-0.0502115972,
0.0161825251,
-0.0351295024,
0.0420280881,
-0.0777302161,
-0.0516660176,
-0.0450274199,
0.0214788299,
-0.0415105112,
0.0028451623,
-0.0070324647,
-0.0196927432,
-0.0160868317,
0.0184171554,
-0.0165029075,
-0.0258121304,
0.0199965741,
-0.021718869,
-0.0345392004,
0.0126438346,
0.0422361977,
0.0401575789,
-0.0377436392,
-0.0172696039,
-0.0096100364,
-0.0204411,
-0.0346232988,
0.0134039391,
0.018338494,
-0.0574057251,
0.0130736725,
0.0766813159,
-0.0300429352,
-0.0227778833,
-0.0162758976,
0.0158957448,
-0.006584655,
-0.0344322957,
0.0107265785,
-0.0793066323,
0.0993791446,
-0.0028331024,
0.0124030076,
-0.0399145782,
-0.0050535505,
-0.0102685085,
-0.0485613197,
0.0624904931,
-0.0396828428,
-0.0154370442,
0.0151922069,
-0.0199295003,
-0.0134134954,
0.0270731207,
0.0437135845,
-0.0008451612,
0.0375178233,
-0.0046894406,
-0.0543949604,
0.0258626994,
0.0361756459,
0.0251672063,
-0.0104866745,
-0.0678428262,
0.0211959425,
0.0457332171,
0.0578528792,
0.0708583444,
-0.0355376787,
-0.0289892145,
0.0496540107,
0.0653152689,
-0.0087008821,
0.0515566058,
0.0419728868,
-0.0125988936,
-0.0726450384,
0.0013568642,
-0.0140527701,
0.0445252694,
0.0313661434,
-0.0046918844,
0.0528296381,
0.0654817,
-0.0386531241,
0.0095625874,
0.0180105437,
-0.0423346385,
0.0812339336,
-0.0559165627,
0.0253206324,
0.0409617946,
-0.0235501546,
0.0522038303,
0.0374418013,
-0.0669004917,
0.0426150039,
0.0205805153,
-0.0327338874,
0.0464883521,
0.0220589545,
0.0394356921,
-0.0340215713,
0.005204807,
-0.0105413506,
0.0188274663,
0.0747826248,
-0.0000206192,
0.0475509427,
-0.0717657954,
0.0011923501,
-0.0471009947,
-0.0280944686,
0.0820508152,
0.0088606589,
0.0372496732,
0.0443101227,
-0.0738692358,
-0.0509078428,
0.0213318225,
-0.0159003101,
0.004600076,
0.0240198616,
0.0252240635,
0.019207228,
0.0054988274,
-0.004313115,
0.0296328608,
-0.0121967001,
-0.0653301477,
-0.0427650027,
0.0627185479,
-0.0679687634,
-0.0390897095,
0.025593359,
-0.0488752089,
0.0092990277,
0.0242048185,
-0.0511814281,
-0.0428484157,
0.0163808707,
-0.0320564844,
0.0350489318,
-0.0313076638,
0.0035206976,
0.0129479375,
0.0243494418,
-0.0103719542,
0.0240017008,
0.0029653299,
0.0130979652,
-0.0139243649,
0.0090394411,
0.0301415604,
-0.0157639645,
-0.0271048583,
0.0620509125,
0.0315049961,
0.0239683893,
0.0251471158,
0.0194563475,
0.0054426757,
0.0121060992,
-0.0929924026,
-0.0011639682,
-0.0054910071,
0.0270220265,
0.0266105682,
0.0620205104,
0.0166999362,
-0.0125089819,
-0.0463828482,
0.0509538874,
0.0065356842,
0.0516422838,
0.0309281498,
-0.0257381499,
-0.0041280198,
-0.0307998359,
-0.032397069,
0.0240589287,
0.0667789131,
-0.0033538537,
-0.0323946103,
-0.0327748507,
0.0264391489,
-0.0713424608,
0.0092537589,
-0.0052753636,
-0.0424544364,
-0.0201396961,
-0.0030786155,
0.0284124706,
0.0179796312,
-0.0082235001,
-0.0103805913,
0.0542811677,
-0.0034163378,
-0.0532551929,
-0.0130945854,
-0.0387662016,
-0.0057994956,
-0.0170296952,
-0.0158918146,
0.0063542454,
0.0362640321,
0.0039137667,
-0.0380525701,
-0.0615082383,
-0.0493950322,
-0.0045664902,
-0.0270915646,
-0.0130949719,
0.0215083584,
0.016707506,
-0.0466235541,
-0.0389423817,
-0.0422159955,
0.0706451014,
-0.0371246189,
0.0040611685,
-0.0314601474,
-0.0212699976,
-0.0483630747,
0.0418744646,
-0.0013648893,
0.0444223322,
-0.0901717097,
-0.0111142881,
-0.0222741738,
0.0132687017,
0.0281407554,
0.0091129718,
-0.0013973352,
-0.0229316559,
-0.0123413447,
-0.0218840726,
-0.0203883648,
0.0058737569,
0.0303027332,
0.0005616758,
0.007512006,
0.0405557193,
-0.0104160309,
0.0004521432,
0.0098208496,
-0.0080931382,
0.057745479,
-0.0023974625,
0.0214482173,
-0.0171494614,
0.0400352329,
-0.0111922761,
-0.021255454,
0.015099938,
-0.040058922,
-0.0125853354,
0.0222686771,
0.0364615954,
-0.014394491,
-0.0440880917,
-0.0148239238,
0.0212698895,
-0.0052609248,
-0.01038484,
-0.0365537852,
0.0453827307,
-0.0038044485,
-0.0211190581,
0.0775122121,
-0.0034915651,
-0.0540938154,
0.0054097115,
-0.0213100947,
0.0433464684,
0.0329460166,
0.0026210747,
-0.0663171038,
-0.0264689699,
-0.0084901694,
0.0031102821,
0.0669585466,
-0.0029308987,
-0.0386750922,
-0.0945117772,
-0.0478378572,
0.0854108483,
-0.0718917623,
-0.0716675594,
-0.034136299,
-0.0131231463,
-0.0014384313,
0.0090664113,
-0.0521584488,
0.0455250517,
-0.01708984,
-0.007796112,
0.039553009,
-0.0265858062,
0.0094244992,
-0.0849249735,
-0.0051633655,
-0.0106368689,
0.0596738234,
-0.0136658475,
-0.025227502,
0.0550476909,
-0.0074003045,
-0.0319809094,
-0.0042140055,
0.0059205964,
-0.0260142405,
0.0039191847,
0.0472787395,
0.0000976973,
-0.0177298579,
0.0031062916,
-0.0096999779,
0.063834928,
0.0243639518,
-0.049272377,
0.0216905642,
-0.0172828697,
-0.0065678325,
0.0263246149,
0.03778686,
-0.0317938961,
0.0235940572,
0.0327195302,
0.0074528316,
-0.0484791361,
0.0331550166,
0.0077883722,
-0.0549831465,
-0.0250867661,
-0.0892463028,
-0.0489077382,
-0.017788833,
0.0336796902,
0.0332537591,
0.0290521681,
0.0155518912,
-0.0297193956,
-0.0407444499,
0.031855341,
-0.047485929,
0.0079943165,
-0.0281893928,
0.0127670076,
-0.025600791,
-0.0166932326,
-0.0055893427,
0.0088419318,
-0.0786488131,
-0.0775204822,
-0.0511252433,
0.0436880477,
0.0069909785,
0.0562721342,
-0.015480632,
-0.0087088421,
-0.0000610919,
-0.0113143502,
0.0216768999,
-0.0157688949,
0.0162030421,
-0.0056186444,
0.0194771141,
0.0504901893,
-0.0213478506,
0.0048639565,
0.0160479527,
0.0456502922,
0.0246334299,
-0.068978034,
-0.0152769871,
0.0043327967,
-0.0051350105,
-0.0234508347,
-0.0112645049,
-0.0846060589,
0.0005020055,
-0.0099431882,
0.0121812951,
-0.0415410772,
-0.0314046815,
0.0508396849,
0.011635798,
-0.0045794058,
-0.0384582877,
0.0615848638,
0.0037032499,
0.0157540124,
-0.0600753501,
-0.023242712,
-0.0004030431,
0.0046593598,
0.0308083519,
-0.0274778642,
0.0131441364,
-0.031242948,
-0.0202019941,
-0.071121268,
0.0318122506,
0.0258511882,
0.0009086388,
-0.0090409238,
0.0541413352,
-0.0160121769,
0.0031930439,
-0.0230313297,
0.0133343004,
0.0801575631,
-0.001120383,
0.0870847106,
-0.022039324,
-0.0229128562,
-0.02135491,
0.0530979894,
-0.0356142037,
-0.0450106487,
0.0218241829,
-0.0120150149,
0.0148210358,
0.0212707501,
0.0422280505,
-0.015742844,
-0.0147942631,
-0.0034414607,
-0.0182590075,
0.0045050285,
0.0096173426,
0.0279059783,
0.019523561,
-0.0154349925,
-0.006879379,
-0.0089664115,
-0.0818572491,
0.0176026542,
0.0122882538,
-0.0217807237,
0.0526995733,
0.026114108,
0.078479059,
-0.0465161502,
0.0216871742,
-0.0099874372,
0.0267520193,
-0.0049849963,
-0.0269929152,
-0.0015149057,
-5.838603666e-33,
-0.0230946522,
-0.0076923864,
-0.0026968515,
-0.0172766205,
-0.0276104193,
0.0038834305,
-0.0377533995,
-0.0308133177,
-0.0294117983,
0.0251350123,
0.0180438831,
-0.0093001025,
0.0062385071,
0.0180699416,
-0.0049545402,
0.0024777791,
0.0416303873,
0.0548443049,
-0.0220495667,
0.0528578497,
0.0613617636,
0.0226471815,
0.094689101,
-0.032523226,
0.0057980046,
0.0015084167,
0.0473906472,
0.0144767929,
0.0346706547,
-0.0055240495,
-0.01334887,
0.0225830823,
0.0357774459,
0.0337044038,
-0.0268589128,
-0.0091002202,
-0.0819850862,
-0.0628795326,
0.0335504711,
0.0231152885,
-0.0321348608,
-0.0537673458,
0.058267571,
-0.0512694567,
0.0169564635,
-0.0305584576,
0.0003956138,
0.0121270316,
-0.0408376753,
0.0118604023,
-0.0958505645,
0.0198786054,
0.031065084,
0.0076355599,
0.0368411466,
0.0043586418,
0.0080397846,
-0.0389708839,
-0.0702814087,
0.0130617544,
-0.096174188,
0.0284460355,
0.0636470169,
0.0143810632,
-0.0123605188,
0.0154209668,
0.0268673413,
-0.0372346938,
0.0493520536,
0.0231635887,
0.0454171076,
-0.0029723253,
0.0672643781,
0.0408885106,
0.016146386,
-0.0560009554,
-0.0432101339,
0.0068103988,
-0.0095731346,
-0.0080866674,
0.0195016488,
0.0343024805,
-0.0051684957,
-0.0297967661,
-0.0461393334,
-0.0240227971,
-0.026325427,
-0.0308220685,
0.0076361424,
-0.0205638129,
-0.0040882705,
0.003745087,
0.0679865405,
-0.0086603826,
-0.0132734207,
0.0625795126,
0.0116079412,
0.0031240936,
-0.0234675352,
0.049095463,
-0.0382107608,
-0.0637249276,
-0.016739998,
-0.0101886103,
0.0121519556,
-0.0129204178,
0.0572591051,
0.0187775679,
-0.0296265744,
-0.0116325337,
-0.0820346326,
-0.0565081947,
-0.0086517176,
0.0031110682,
0.0286446493,
0.0175156314,
0.0003917055,
0.0180589091,
0.0695300251,
0.0054840059,
-0.0072014141,
0.0026840733,
0.0240533445,
0.0465023816,
-0.0475237817,
0.0151329255,
-0.043292515,
-0.0131418705,
0.0458954088,
-0.0604510009,
-0.0369460657,
-0.0077913487,
2.785e-7,
0.0598052293,
0.0024480706,
0.0229582544,
-0.0037271164,
-0.0077919839,
0.0223123077,
-0.0387933105,
0.0680407211,
0.0036030356,
0.0457281992,
0.0288994145,
0.0480243415,
0.0303947125,
0.0565986261,
-0.0627151057,
-0.0059919576,
-0.0495099612,
0.0010460183,
-0.0323458239,
-0.0179508924,
0.0243827403,
0.0598384105,
0.0286569074,
0.0000896051,
-0.0325156376,
-0.0660040081,
0.0786747634,
-0.0374168195,
-0.0159569718,
-0.0150384661,
0.0146334879,
0.0064484826,
-0.0244899951,
-0.0044407775,
-0.0255310684,
0.0378783122,
0.0752903,
0.011720839,
-0.0217763968,
-0.0052750395,
-0.0107065868,
-0.033532396,
-0.0322198607,
-0.0419696905,
0.0396315046,
-0.0355683193,
-0.0080878017,
-0.03122494,
0.0188015271,
0.0340451114,
0.0656592548,
-0.0122614317,
-0.0508198515,
0.0213974509,
0.0677831024,
0.0260917414,
-0.0479909256,
-0.0366420113,
-0.0171278603,
-0.0023414758,
-0.0057434863,
-0.0304840673,
-0.0317524746,
-0.0129131656,
0.0242968947,
-0.0158758741,
0.0015026403,
2.1793252e-34,
0.0079851542,
-0.0016818506,
0.027266426,
-0.0277825873,
0.0427923128,
-0.055252064,
-0.0159309749,
0.0146280844,
-0.0214857906,
-0.027729759,
-0.0338202901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14171v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14171v3 | In-Context Probing: Toward Building Robust Classifiers via Probing Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T15:43:04 | 2023-12-22T13:27:11 | Afra Amini, Massimiliano Ciaramita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models are able to learn new tasks in context, where they are
provided with instructions and a few annotated examples. However, the
effectiveness of in-context learning is dependent on the provided context, and
the performance on a downstream task can vary considerably, depending on the
instruction. Importantly, such dependency on the context can surface in
unpredictable ways, e.g., a seemingly more informative instruction might lead
to a worse performance. In this paper, we propose an alternative approach,
which we term In-Context Probing (ICP). Similar to in-context learning, we
contextualize the representation of the input with an instruction, but instead
of decoding the output prediction, we probe the contextualized representation
to predict the label. Through a series of experiments on a diverse set of
classification tasks, we show that in-context probing is significantly more
robust to changes in instructions. We further show that ICP performs
competitive or superior to finetuning and can be particularly helpful to build
classifiers on top of smaller models, with less than a hundred training
examples. | [
0.0106690889,
0.0320310108,
-0.0337822661,
0.044421494,
-0.0202328563,
0.0441679396,
0.0175908674,
-0.016356416,
-0.0218568835,
-0.1073872223,
-0.0312177669,
-0.0415245704,
0.0002996467,
0.0095027611,
0.039471183,
-0.0091634244,
0.0355408452,
-0.0550477169,
-0.0182757974,
0.0145727023,
-0.0208587609,
0.0132520469,
0.0302561112,
0.0564581677,
-0.008501308,
-0.018093951,
-0.0332453065,
0.0033157566,
-0.0125661995,
-0.0058957431,
0.0355543196,
0.0491482988,
0.0378905125,
0.0525699146,
0.0000019539,
-0.0173212495,
-0.0108118029,
-0.0002014717,
-0.045956172,
0.0263627172,
0.0533898883,
-0.0415857807,
-0.0062656398,
0.0189306401,
-0.0368927084,
-0.0107690934,
0.0489686169,
0.024851596,
0.0153596373,
0.0497592203,
0.0016277509,
-0.0107353562,
0.0024484193,
-0.0233589094,
0.0176005624,
-0.067015864,
0.0121343238,
-0.0331779905,
0.002339548,
0.0352279991,
-0.043360237,
0.0199317932,
0.0162400864,
0.0097115021,
-0.0285679772,
0.0496848822,
0.0007959639,
-0.013659331,
-0.0149223059,
0.0502457172,
-0.0491413921,
-0.0183615014,
-0.014828085,
-0.0248515531,
0.0210507289,
-0.0001117263,
-0.0195319187,
0.0148551641,
0.0248467587,
0.01944381,
0.0516618676,
-0.0059633683,
0.0451666564,
0.0209324248,
-0.0284126773,
0.0680157244,
0.0020933673,
-0.019902721,
-0.0057170405,
0.0262158457,
-0.0298532192,
-0.0429948382,
-0.049667187,
0.0135815563,
-0.0473531224,
0.0211759787,
-0.0317881815,
-0.0101161031,
0.0045908662,
-0.0152683435,
0.0419480093,
0.036625281,
-0.053255178,
0.0394364707,
-0.0414820351,
0.0389793441,
0.0054203873,
0.0370624252,
-0.0452510044,
-0.0002704565,
-0.0558712147,
-0.0048294165,
-0.0274032652,
0.0192422736,
-0.021264879,
-0.0054060929,
-0.0322874896,
0.0375497714,
-0.0253357552,
0.0188893285,
-0.0309664737,
-0.0141405491,
-0.0435978994,
0.0362341963,
0.0220619049,
0.0079914089,
-0.0316369832,
0.0263271201,
-0.0214924011,
-0.0431955196,
-0.021974856,
0.0272914916,
0.0024682297,
-0.0303273946,
0.0201003905,
0.0490751117,
0.0091419742,
-0.0683295876,
-0.0041135889,
-0.0376588069,
-0.0238027349,
-0.0656756163,
-0.0112714488,
-0.0433309376,
-0.0195946395,
0.027142372,
0.0045845602,
-0.0310089942,
0.00853799,
0.0081557576,
-0.0117898779,
0.1121790335,
0.0252316594,
-0.0146896793,
-0.0147426119,
0.0049951132,
0.0174333025,
0.0858262479,
-0.0129634384,
0.0135511234,
0.0177456681,
-0.0154707199,
0.0146833863,
0.0564819835,
0.0200016499,
0.0044312035,
-0.0267061926,
0.0022206809,
0.0486422218,
-0.011525237,
0.0009383635,
0.0260992274,
-0.0157435052,
0.0311072506,
0.0357442237,
0.0448433124,
0.0011972761,
-0.0131300567,
0.0536430441,
-0.0140364049,
-0.0398667455,
0.0252018347,
-0.0946163908,
-0.0236308612,
-0.0393724926,
-0.0065671038,
-0.0084886309,
-0.0296949558,
-0.0376210473,
-0.0302011017,
-0.0239511486,
-0.0118172672,
0.0294337533,
0.03532153,
0.057226833,
0.0199916791,
-0.033827614,
0.0001554415,
0.0430396013,
-0.0083254371,
0.0022689952,
-0.0760954767,
0.0185824353,
0.0400783941,
0.0028725192,
-0.0494388193,
-0.0180741213,
-0.0154446159,
0.0360010974,
-0.0072351159,
0.0488817953,
-0.0638243333,
0.0280804187,
-0.0206512045,
-0.016116308,
-0.0152672986,
0.0453112982,
0.0019430658,
0.0238354877,
-0.0127984788,
0.0197632648,
-0.0413167179,
0.0002790915,
0.0587985367,
-0.004792274,
-0.0729020312,
0.0094439415,
0.035306558,
-0.0009734447,
-0.0072392067,
0.0045689452,
-0.0025225952,
0.04459114,
-0.0438041091,
0.0265082922,
-0.0106185507,
-0.0251483526,
-0.0600136779,
0.0311343148,
0.0333096795,
-0.0266576987,
-0.0085794069,
-0.041835811,
-0.0284821391,
0.0160517059,
-0.0225966461,
0.0544390306,
-0.0328470394,
0.0029892563,
-0.041933015,
0.0200995523,
-0.0609809197,
0.0757133737,
0.0176782664,
0.0232259315,
0.0269232709,
0.0227809623,
-0.0106571829,
0.0064238193,
-0.0314255878,
-0.0021782408,
0.0011506059,
0.0109807998,
0.0114050601,
0.0110353902,
-0.0436575264,
-0.0100978278,
-0.086387597,
-0.0018565815,
-0.0460495986,
0.024707688,
0.0217845496,
0.0022634279,
0.0223612599,
-0.0385698043,
-0.0196888503,
-0.0279391222,
-0.0163195953,
0.0496832877,
0.0178508591,
0.0439513735,
-0.0287093762,
-0.0163073149,
-0.0190653279,
-0.0277957395,
0.0538548753,
-0.0193374343,
0.0077788085,
-0.1039121822,
0.0090901796,
0.0314893164,
0.0320524313,
-0.0018212402,
-0.031478256,
0.0159706213,
-0.0442064218,
-0.0249724034,
0.1018610746,
-0.0261878856,
0.0824785233,
0.0672706291,
0.0105708297,
-0.051386863,
0.0006541391,
-0.0121076843,
-0.042220071,
-0.042264536,
-0.0037838507,
-0.0386457928,
0.0898678079,
-0.0089226197,
-0.0262924824,
-0.0516027361,
0.01429985,
-0.0400152504,
-0.00745168,
-0.0638671443,
0.0013890722,
-0.0047142692,
0.0495239869,
0.0046538641,
-0.0589102469,
0.09063337,
-0.0104150707,
-0.003574478,
-0.0214611497,
-0.0339429416,
-0.0025013285,
0.0800200626,
-0.0106659699,
-0.0021488967,
0.0276313387,
-0.0376461446,
-0.0858788863,
-0.0110925203,
0.0053002462,
-0.0156695377,
0.0495794564,
-0.0609857142,
0.0004517387,
-0.0043210443,
-0.0436508544,
-0.0774287656,
-0.0341181941,
-0.0325591713,
0.0495222881,
-0.0054542264,
-0.0023473664,
-0.0093212649,
0.020895442,
-0.0230657291,
0.0503509641,
-0.0265925899,
-0.0105355335,
-0.0272114202,
0.01885847,
0.0239061862,
-0.0222287495,
0.002595861,
-0.0465800613,
0.0252143443,
0.0342492424,
0.0188243724,
0.0283183977,
-0.0336812362,
0.0107089048,
0.0494994409,
-0.012876831,
-0.0320386589,
0.0438828617,
0.0418069623,
-0.099492088,
-0.0634052306,
0.1107265949,
0.0381780043,
-0.0561796986,
0.0150681157,
0.0254174452,
0.0254442524,
0.0401596427,
0.0387720205,
-0.0658898652,
-0.058526095,
0.0248625465,
0.0228593536,
0.0042652916,
-0.0026730977,
0.0185436253,
-0.1165330559,
0.0317217223,
-0.0010324639,
-0.0335147083,
-0.0361403525,
-0.034243688,
0.0340722278,
-0.0014467658,
0.0292157345,
-0.0091385879,
-0.0029003769,
0.0069496818,
0.0278346501,
0.0282292794,
-0.0881777853,
0.0475351252,
-0.0306253526,
0.0399042405,
0.0707165748,
0.0207337774,
-0.0004773092,
0.018933244,
0.0612787977,
-0.0535445288,
0.0297301542,
-0.015299432,
0.050472118,
-0.0135359671,
-0.016420098,
0.0481384248,
0.0451086499,
-0.0205700137,
-0.0088304197,
0.0068826731,
0.0712338462,
-0.0141051337,
0.0084390957,
0.0120330267,
-0.0519293994,
0.0548350923,
0.0630260929,
0.0396363139,
-0.0657970533,
-0.0389303342,
-0.0434184968,
0.0055352654,
-0.0099550197,
-0.028290011,
0.0270928424,
0.0026015055,
-0.0200212132,
-0.0397049785,
-0.0395801179,
0.0671385601,
0.0210607853,
0.0170268714,
0.0139169926,
-0.0046521304,
-0.0055024568,
-0.0666234046,
0.0244886745,
-0.0163522195,
0.0483654179,
-0.0223931,
-0.031030992,
0.0340626836,
-0.0199765898,
-0.0114202946,
0.0136492671,
-0.1103121862,
-0.0839310363,
0.0097184973,
0.0329568237,
0.0144222025,
0.0586172976,
-0.0418289751,
-0.0569561422,
0.0316525027,
0.0269859284,
-0.02547637,
-0.0033772911,
0.0363996886,
-0.0099629099,
-0.0055520725,
0.0531226806,
-0.0526897199,
0.0164659861,
0.041726511,
-0.002912798,
-0.0522959009,
-0.0143603152,
0.0359452739,
-0.0306009501,
0.0744481906,
-0.0343186967,
-0.026018532,
0.0059558619,
0.0057124966,
-0.0050748596,
-0.0437212549,
-0.0058390549,
-0.014102323,
0.0274098944,
-0.0115740653,
-0.0010320125,
0.0143824555,
0.006129757,
0.0532616228,
-0.0627026409,
0.0279889908,
0.0246435944,
0.0086618178,
0.0407694653,
0.0405421108,
-0.0005054101,
0.0001265828,
0.0184241813,
0.0589364395,
-0.0349283181,
0.027410375,
0.0292896479,
0.030168673,
-0.0551862642,
0.008788581,
-0.0776728541,
0.00568067,
-0.0109440284,
0.0240049139,
0.0359582603,
-0.0455762446,
-0.0008473383,
-0.0199415162,
-0.0316679366,
-0.0053321798,
0.026059309,
0.0020610283,
-0.0472896546,
0.0286291912,
0.0413752273,
-0.0097348196,
0.0226306114,
0.0720546544,
0.0043615997,
0.0521530807,
0.0076719765,
-0.0113559086,
-0.0423173048,
0.0313707255,
0.0175292119,
0.0335801095,
-0.0274262596,
0.054689236,
-0.0263875797,
-0.0740002841,
-0.0184887741,
-0.0102450075,
0.0011276607,
-0.0165537205,
0.0149812959,
0.0380250625,
0.0044707516,
-0.0232294183,
-0.0392968021,
0.0116461525,
0.0291624181,
-0.025302114,
-0.0469797365,
-6.08414864e-33,
-0.0270575844,
-0.0298660304,
-0.0157434996,
-0.0081934109,
0.0196913779,
0.0174998548,
-0.0232276898,
0.0003333008,
-0.0155636799,
0.0215532705,
-0.0170541741,
0.016390672,
0.0111478362,
0.0203013979,
0.0408177078,
-0.0471694693,
0.0641275644,
-0.0013159281,
-0.0242108312,
0.0197083782,
0.0324630849,
0.0235266574,
0.0663826168,
-0.0787953585,
0.0187909082,
-0.0057971799,
-0.0273733046,
0.0281599797,
-0.0298887882,
0.0565434322,
-0.0078155529,
0.0291194934,
0.0152648361,
-0.0218932498,
-0.0064636292,
0.0409507938,
-0.0816487297,
-0.0178204477,
-0.0128530348,
0.0398129039,
-0.0276915003,
-0.034660846,
0.0209161211,
-0.0310054813,
0.0032835666,
-0.0012305779,
0.0210532248,
-0.0149550997,
-0.0293938741,
-0.0108896159,
-0.0787729621,
0.0095158992,
-0.0140754329,
-0.052505292,
0.08296258,
0.0223585106,
0.0276962947,
-0.0011987444,
-0.0362089649,
0.0031554843,
0.0117090326,
0.0656094328,
0.0502563752,
0.0605586693,
-0.0159246456,
0.0267058592,
0.0087675378,
0.0140703665,
0.0225880314,
-0.0363686085,
0.0509511381,
0.0291364118,
0.0051702117,
0.0299505331,
0.0537922867,
-0.0058208713,
-0.0460213311,
-0.012749373,
0.0380064547,
-0.0018559902,
0.0441080555,
-0.0075566536,
-0.050075043,
-0.0421980135,
-0.0726444945,
-0.0210806224,
-0.0369291455,
0.010739509,
0.0363987759,
0.0282060206,
-0.0239366684,
0.0249014255,
0.037115477,
-0.0649410784,
-0.0214511026,
0.0205159821,
-0.0355988778,
0.0048302542,
0.0016178896,
-0.0013530263,
-0.0176215917,
-0.0579062812,
0.0083744014,
-0.0134301111,
0.0462170281,
-0.0087445285,
0.0815887153,
0.0382936746,
-0.071003899,
-0.0155922435,
-0.0317140371,
0.0225947332,
0.0105951056,
0.0385997966,
0.0401605666,
0.0200192165,
0.0035012176,
0.0349195451,
0.052351173,
-0.0032972305,
-0.0335902162,
-0.0117253335,
-0.0165350977,
-0.0024967685,
-0.0382625274,
-0.0352888741,
-0.0152442977,
0.0243417304,
0.0458207503,
-0.0420131609,
-0.0050047324,
0.01768356,
2.658e-7,
0.0422222354,
0.0718562827,
-0.0188973565,
0.0201537497,
0.032150425,
0.0672473237,
-0.0121607408,
0.0119467359,
0.0127236713,
-0.0379354954,
-0.0076339389,
-0.0109928669,
0.032228332,
0.0362365618,
-0.066565603,
0.0140427938,
-0.017351402,
0.0424429514,
-0.0295632686,
0.0071655912,
0.0294371601,
0.1218932495,
0.0165236257,
-0.0081885559,
0.0030343356,
-0.039736256,
0.0408672653,
-0.0153768463,
0.0301683787,
0.0087665198,
-0.057482671,
0.0377487354,
0.0161766261,
0.0637117997,
-0.0175803341,
0.033600837,
-0.0308153145,
0.0310140867,
-0.0230456628,
-0.0089745903,
-0.042351637,
0.0005102154,
0.0064944653,
-0.0507487059,
0.0690697506,
-0.0859802142,
-0.0069943951,
-0.061553698,
0.0437537879,
-0.0155035695,
0.0072500086,
0.0087057073,
0.0054337229,
0.0385272466,
0.0044138841,
-0.0333384052,
-0.0300475061,
-0.101591818,
-0.0414896198,
0.0277352128,
-0.0122675514,
-0.0271365419,
-0.0042869938,
-0.0041793841,
0.0271324422,
-0.0888259485,
0.0071989824,
2.463197903e-34,
0.026322566,
0.0025046002,
0.0149638755,
0.0562911555,
0.0152466586,
-0.0103789931,
-0.0317135341,
0.0219328254,
0.0659647807,
-0.0577833168,
-0.0161109418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14169v1 | EASE: An Easily-Customized Annotation System Powered by Efficiency Enhancement Mechanisms | 2023-05-23T15:38:37 | 2023-05-23T15:38:37 | Naihao Deng, Yikai Liu, Mingye Chen, Winston Wu, Siyang Liu, Yulong Chen, Yue Zhang, Rada Mihalcea | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The performance of current supervised AI systems is tightly connected to the
availability of annotated datasets. Annotations are usually collected through
annotation tools, which are often designed for specific tasks and are difficult
to customize. Moreover, existing annotation tools with an active learning
mechanism often only support limited use cases. To address these limitations,
we present EASE, an Easily-Customized Annotation System Powered by Efficiency
Enhancement Mechanisms. \sysname provides modular annotation units for building
customized annotation interfaces and also provides multiple back-end options
that suggest annotations using (1) multi-task active learning; (2) demographic
feature based active learning; (3) a prompt system that can query the API of
large language models. We conduct multiple experiments and user studies to
evaluate our system's flexibility and effectiveness. Our results show that our
system can meet the diverse needs of NLP researchers and significantly
accelerate the annotation process. | [
0.0500631519,
-0.0234762095,
-0.037253987,
-0.0038665417,
0.0124094617,
0.0466892868,
0.0417882577,
-0.0231263638,
0.0527906306,
-0.0811238885,
-0.0166526288,
0.0540687926,
-0.0203628205,
0.0400382243,
0.0151021536,
-0.0606575646,
0.0464620627,
-0.0092070103,
0.0525406189,
0.0165661275,
0.027714042,
0.0190913361,
-0.0363509841,
0.074121505,
-0.0389712416,
-0.0083012441,
-0.0003354168,
-0.0092165219,
-0.0100017544,
-0.0077676652,
0.0423119776,
0.0784487054,
-0.0048237578,
0.0233202707,
0.0000020271,
-0.0488895327,
-0.0025879841,
0.0280073099,
-0.05536348,
0.0099776415,
0.0246594585,
0.0535414927,
0.0186835378,
-0.0152103659,
-0.0406782143,
-0.0226805937,
0.0769794285,
-0.0208404083,
0.062768437,
0.0074168383,
-0.0127797592,
0.0184769444,
-0.0163117032,
-0.0210926756,
0.0125229396,
-0.0529567339,
0.0024961864,
-0.0224126298,
-0.0104967635,
0.0093099745,
0.028304657,
0.0620307587,
-0.0050292909,
-0.054231517,
0.0428238884,
-0.010002275,
-0.0385332182,
-0.0627016276,
-0.0006756883,
0.0330078937,
0.0429685451,
0.0020105022,
0.0013771856,
-0.0448603332,
0.0244617146,
0.0346883014,
-0.0350898243,
0.0166992377,
-0.0096099144,
-0.0224761106,
0.0008542512,
-0.0045347074,
-0.0023464493,
0.0175355859,
0.0569518879,
0.0387653112,
-0.0152602075,
0.000471973,
0.042898152,
0.0558005907,
-0.0410081334,
-0.0639138073,
0.0208282955,
0.0393353254,
-0.0384981297,
0.0075450125,
-0.0213583726,
-0.0734157488,
0.0499238782,
-0.0408240706,
0.0368061811,
0.0008617169,
-0.0447635986,
0.0492805876,
0.0148393111,
-0.004664625,
0.0435482375,
-0.008456748,
0.0146584595,
-0.0232235249,
-0.05072245,
-0.0041199927,
-0.0633575916,
0.0260242559,
0.0034058732,
0.0018474414,
-0.083528094,
0.0295812786,
-0.0457308404,
0.0199798979,
0.0333316326,
0.0110857738,
-0.0396250822,
0.0231704079,
-0.0316670127,
-0.0038453704,
-0.04765632,
0.0206859224,
0.0002437921,
-0.0509965941,
0.0398102105,
0.0198092163,
0.0191065632,
-0.0269362405,
-0.011205947,
0.0256882105,
0.0229249895,
-0.0482337698,
-0.0569754802,
-0.0213511791,
0.0246825591,
-0.0227699429,
-0.0176489018,
-0.0606816225,
0.0146101164,
0.0155658489,
0.0137680918,
-0.0539263114,
0.0074527799,
0.0287414454,
-0.0084268451,
0.055459328,
-0.0454139262,
-0.0260766409,
0.0537337847,
-0.0148937134,
-0.0344600193,
0.0909437686,
0.0128536113,
0.0254415963,
0.0695212781,
0.0065461569,
-0.0069698012,
0.0201901793,
-0.0195401572,
-0.0314052626,
0.0338044465,
0.0143217538,
-0.0504194945,
-0.0197399985,
-0.0517937653,
0.0077521508,
-0.001499616,
0.0309492797,
0.0298892912,
0.0392086916,
-0.013987869,
-0.0084850248,
0.0684208497,
0.0310223475,
0.0446623936,
-0.0368409492,
-0.0444543473,
0.050812196,
-0.0297046416,
-0.0266912021,
-0.0143035026,
0.0256178007,
-0.0146175884,
-0.0731785372,
-0.0527839176,
-0.0559511147,
0.0280503277,
0.0486142337,
0.0319627523,
0.0203174595,
0.0328125544,
0.0443424992,
0.045285821,
-0.0231257156,
-0.0340023302,
-0.0582254939,
0.0171371568,
0.0408856049,
-0.0103158308,
-0.0660119504,
-0.0624676608,
-0.0256593954,
0.027023701,
0.0224461108,
0.0595464446,
-0.0452977903,
-0.0057428014,
-0.0401615761,
-0.0349123366,
0.0122994464,
0.040163938,
0.0014913973,
0.0678101853,
-0.0284474194,
-0.0024028183,
-0.0210281182,
-0.035183847,
0.0335594863,
-0.0134236673,
-0.029229166,
0.0111810807,
0.0071569285,
0.0354805812,
0.0298523623,
0.0265331119,
0.0057620006,
0.009059445,
0.0159522165,
-0.0070199287,
0.017071493,
0.0466274694,
0.0351404436,
0.0036203342,
0.0009715436,
-0.0693443418,
0.0026836607,
-0.022855958,
-0.0234933551,
-0.0599115267,
-0.0419909507,
-0.0001439552,
-0.0541762672,
0.0071860035,
-0.0180793498,
0.0019599199,
-0.0545026697,
0.0648520216,
0.0125118028,
-0.0005981585,
0.0579471998,
-0.0417916141,
0.0020280504,
-0.0154472431,
-0.0413858108,
-0.0572116151,
0.0103097549,
-0.0398731045,
0.0145906499,
0.024302911,
-0.0415543057,
0.0335734747,
-0.1170653328,
0.0095405355,
-0.0092345243,
-0.0197404828,
0.0032426992,
0.0383246429,
-0.0028174736,
-0.0323473625,
-0.0067808935,
0.0476619229,
-0.0308270194,
0.0484659299,
0.0134600895,
0.0221934244,
0.0193041991,
-0.0559422262,
0.0006154725,
-0.0140124196,
0.01417387,
0.0450493842,
-0.0706180185,
-0.0329333544,
-0.0099311052,
-0.0205188915,
0.0166185666,
0.0438763686,
0.0110874614,
0.0250675213,
-0.0174660608,
-0.0158673264,
0.0572738536,
-0.0024769441,
0.0730726719,
0.0530279838,
0.0130908638,
-0.0497015007,
0.0269966666,
-0.0195737481,
0.0042484296,
0.0069672884,
-0.0479281917,
-0.0018352729,
0.021057494,
-0.011333568,
-0.0202155374,
-0.0476942286,
0.0225317217,
-0.0236009434,
-0.0362401605,
-0.0324703306,
0.0149424504,
-0.006817176,
0.0266089235,
-0.0065946844,
-0.0507095903,
0.0602834225,
0.0043733809,
-0.0228847768,
-0.0165707469,
-0.0298902001,
-0.022578571,
0.0469854176,
0.0052712788,
0.0176568851,
0.0285178106,
-0.0272655189,
-0.0116907377,
0.0188821815,
0.0354547799,
-0.0325782597,
0.0297170207,
-0.0507130176,
0.0044164509,
0.0025855633,
-0.0467823073,
-0.0381608158,
-0.0321811773,
-0.049849797,
0.0167927984,
0.0324159935,
-0.0359460041,
0.0187852122,
-0.0086374916,
0.0108282901,
0.0568104126,
-0.0003673714,
-0.0172815789,
-0.0015931528,
-0.0158573389,
0.0780535638,
0.0081833238,
-0.0214156397,
-0.0071838037,
-0.0103033772,
0.040875636,
-0.0544462092,
-0.0096402522,
0.0087126223,
-0.0079415468,
0.0472488962,
-0.0831640586,
-0.0411568992,
0.0297252201,
0.0450140275,
-0.0620351471,
-0.0035472088,
0.128231287,
0.0500422008,
-0.0867042467,
0.0022225128,
-0.0257723276,
0.0272680689,
0.0573226102,
0.0443952568,
-0.047086928,
-0.0396183804,
-0.0075693573,
0.0536315851,
-0.0102697341,
-0.0266724527,
0.004271389,
-0.0723506287,
0.0383668058,
-0.0281077046,
-0.040062163,
0.0363881923,
-0.0330203548,
0.0196336396,
-0.0261397958,
-0.0174802337,
-0.0512442328,
0.0078527192,
0.0160090216,
0.0377428494,
-0.042004019,
-0.0282230582,
-0.0178379323,
-0.0356480554,
0.0916565731,
0.0292905997,
0.0207425691,
0.0199119095,
-0.0053070281,
0.0520615876,
0.0314072222,
0.0176573265,
-0.0440053456,
0.0790264681,
-0.0003557328,
-0.0022088059,
-0.0255229473,
0.0170554854,
0.0245123226,
0.0061332644,
0.0433612131,
0.0503004342,
-0.0141252605,
0.0742961839,
-0.0421994105,
-0.0258657634,
0.031239558,
0.0564277135,
0.0264647137,
-0.0397512652,
0.0117197074,
-0.0327667184,
-0.0189442206,
-0.0177436005,
-0.0617108084,
0.0280295778,
-0.0829156339,
-0.0589499548,
-0.0578193292,
-0.0607995279,
0.09467455,
0.0513954237,
0.0446990654,
0.0263436232,
0.0259016175,
0.0196719822,
-0.0460753217,
0.0135489972,
-0.0311936624,
0.0051967339,
-0.0013843275,
-0.1135825738,
0.0315869823,
-0.0021835563,
-0.013339485,
0.027817674,
-0.0489924885,
-0.0439440757,
0.0471013822,
0.0683023781,
0.0233644973,
0.033449553,
-0.0201743376,
-0.08530543,
-0.0355746262,
0.0151802236,
0.0076647825,
-0.0304651763,
0.0159280133,
0.0015810527,
0.0039027524,
0.0316862278,
-0.0645044744,
-0.0149433389,
-0.0070393323,
0.0220285282,
-0.0269483346,
-0.0316587016,
0.0027330299,
0.0195599273,
0.0326335244,
-0.0463666208,
-0.0465041995,
-0.04120294,
0.0045443904,
-0.0106646158,
-0.0404003114,
-0.030727081,
0.0302669071,
-0.0154415276,
0.007904334,
-0.0315036587,
0.0380427316,
0.0134218251,
0.0543967374,
-0.0483159237,
0.0349566899,
0.0035459609,
0.0098607158,
-0.024396548,
0.0111220712,
-0.0418827422,
0.0494411364,
0.0169242844,
0.0551181994,
-0.0124829402,
0.0661716834,
-0.0210433044,
-0.0053511099,
-0.0044609853,
0.0425159261,
-0.0332614556,
-0.0328689888,
-0.0288099609,
0.0806107,
0.0520650633,
-0.0484683476,
0.0757485405,
-0.0247753523,
-0.0400649197,
0.0080749458,
0.0234495085,
0.0401634127,
-0.0476191714,
-0.0028981341,
0.0017938637,
-0.0039794645,
-0.0170753133,
0.0450577252,
-0.0291819964,
0.0277119558,
-0.0054262932,
-0.0622864701,
-0.0421076082,
-0.0079951175,
0.0210520141,
0.0268962048,
-0.0255321749,
-0.0050831507,
-0.0318332538,
-0.0607485063,
0.0056831618,
-0.0402345508,
-0.0286224615,
0.0259478111,
0.0639178157,
0.0441165678,
-0.0004208733,
-0.0586602949,
-0.0680120066,
0.0159868561,
-0.0299849734,
0.0007554215,
-0.0053624059,
-6.016961424e-33,
-0.0538208894,
-0.0292699747,
-0.0003272898,
-0.0009314942,
0.0312558152,
0.025855666,
-0.0153292036,
0.0128702652,
0.0014926435,
0.0130198346,
-0.000822736,
-0.0091804024,
0.038064193,
0.0010084341,
0.0274044741,
-0.0167874768,
0.0327991024,
0.0195561964,
0.0011239907,
0.014661869,
0.016069755,
0.0084323632,
0.0308194123,
-0.1137149781,
0.0632152557,
0.0277044568,
-0.0138245989,
0.0195809901,
-0.0024084772,
0.0638938099,
0.0030272561,
0.0347209647,
0.0109683545,
-0.0152915977,
0.0081128348,
-0.000608751,
-0.0738706291,
-0.0223402455,
0.0217900462,
0.0467213914,
-0.0166191254,
-0.0269528087,
-0.0085982149,
-0.025123667,
0.0060529802,
0.0340867527,
0.0796647891,
-0.0220029838,
-0.0111652939,
-0.0376452506,
-0.0683811381,
0.0143004209,
-0.0262013916,
0.0352355391,
0.0041880906,
0.0330536775,
0.0041629327,
-0.0343634449,
-0.047913976,
0.0006127417,
-0.0016119025,
0.0121826287,
0.0225992594,
-0.0058760298,
-0.0148807047,
0.0343643203,
0.0295875669,
0.0153841274,
-0.0207991526,
0.0410401225,
0.0017886851,
0.0266971048,
0.0378198102,
0.0156456772,
-0.0060153906,
0.0032787602,
-0.0183223877,
0.0288696513,
0.0683567524,
-0.0078826472,
0.0273740161,
0.0090547977,
-0.0581258275,
0.0050722803,
-0.0232241042,
0.0226300545,
-0.0215249527,
-0.0463960916,
0.0244060345,
-0.0047111106,
-0.066287078,
0.0287561435,
-0.0100358324,
0.0065481728,
-0.0162453745,
-0.0034287523,
0.0450360328,
0.0330812708,
-0.0112398248,
-0.0221661441,
-0.0150345191,
-0.0169997923,
-0.0022080729,
0.0028735935,
0.0445726924,
0.0322470441,
0.0664971098,
0.0324158594,
-0.0582340695,
-0.0030468972,
-0.0082583474,
0.0075394381,
-0.0236290619,
-0.01383832,
0.0249357428,
0.0104322983,
-0.0306550507,
0.042357184,
0.024062233,
0.0161599759,
-0.0440402329,
-0.0445439443,
0.0032370477,
-0.0274224449,
-0.0182511751,
0.0046629063,
0.006956141,
0.0085540367,
0.006302122,
-0.0548968092,
0.0155780921,
-0.0193270184,
2.534e-7,
0.0658814237,
0.0585437454,
-0.0220289938,
-0.0033284097,
0.0171346795,
0.0110539775,
0.0376814939,
-0.0225031096,
0.0396005437,
0.0271334443,
0.0082078055,
0.0201372895,
0.0081782611,
0.0604868792,
-0.1107319966,
-0.0869934261,
0.0162671618,
0.0202972274,
-0.0538744926,
0.0504189953,
0.0314820297,
0.0532862693,
0.038556695,
0.0048226537,
-0.0047629313,
-0.0434549898,
-0.0010706141,
-0.0263279956,
0.020042723,
0.022603238,
0.0361549705,
0.0237172116,
0.0193868112,
0.0288422275,
-0.054595463,
-0.0184766818,
0.0241161697,
0.0761887878,
-0.0199427493,
-0.0284231491,
-0.0054982365,
0.0006292182,
0.0448173136,
-0.0014660174,
0.065074563,
-0.0214028526,
-0.0415241309,
-0.0482578501,
0.0040629907,
-0.0054610767,
-0.0040107584,
0.0011575636,
-0.0088663511,
0.0163098145,
-0.0010718805,
-0.0253431574,
-0.0604111589,
-0.0869400725,
-0.0501091965,
-0.0199857764,
-0.0082273185,
-0.0492998734,
-0.0351402462,
0.0023884224,
-0.0293469559,
-0.0516100563,
0.0127290133,
2.328884816e-34,
0.0117965294,
0.0406846702,
0.0481879488,
0.0758110881,
0.0324840322,
0.0297322404,
0.016918458,
0.0056794193,
0.0205842312,
-0.037902981,
-0.0289346986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14163v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14163v2 | Leveraging Open Information Extraction for More Robust Domain Transfer of Event Trigger Detection | 2023-05-23T15:27:35 | 2024-02-01T17:34:22 | David Dukić, Kiril Gashteovski, Goran Glavaš, Jan Šnajder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Event detection is a crucial information extraction task in many domains,
such as Wikipedia or news. The task typically relies on trigger detection (TD)
-- identifying token spans in the text that evoke specific events. While the
notion of triggers should ideally be universal across domains, domain transfer
for TD from high- to low-resource domains results in significant performance
drops. We address the problem of negative transfer in TD by coupling triggers
between domains using subject-object relations obtained from a rule-based open
information extraction (OIE) system. We demonstrate that OIE relations injected
through multi-task training can act as mediators between triggers in different
domains, enhancing zero- and few-shot TD domain transfer and reducing
performance drops, in particular when transferring from a high-resource source
domain (Wikipedia) to a low(er)-resource target domain (news). Additionally, we
combine this improved transfer with masked language modeling on the target
domain, observing further TD transfer gains. Finally, we demonstrate that the
gains are robust to the choice of the OIE system. | [
0.0156931803,
0.0313289873,
0.0098769953,
0.0637347698,
-0.0330047868,
0.0261510126,
0.001036554,
0.0298002865,
0.0147642838,
-0.0809853896,
-0.0237558074,
0.002166922,
-0.073981449,
0.0638872012,
-0.0471443832,
-0.0317575596,
0.057250727,
-0.0104239238,
-0.011651393,
0.0383660607,
-0.0089898547,
0.0074881325,
-0.0346527472,
0.0159191899,
0.0019968508,
0.0084442468,
0.0139231263,
-0.0149033535,
0.0273506287,
-0.0262682196,
-0.0056976713,
0.0414857119,
0.0316984057,
0.0145381019,
0.0000017699,
-0.0774470195,
-0.0112446435,
-0.007995462,
-0.0183561761,
-0.0076821195,
0.0380989984,
-0.0652522892,
-0.0025015185,
-0.0253886227,
-0.0107782232,
-0.0580620915,
0.0355004445,
0.0701476187,
0.0050949887,
0.0931610763,
-0.0371005461,
-0.0157691352,
0.0461012647,
-0.0088553205,
-0.0045979861,
-0.0626673698,
0.0606031716,
-0.0557016321,
-0.0279193427,
-0.0292148255,
-0.0111503564,
0.00550158,
-0.0016356697,
-0.0066406983,
0.0129711097,
0.0479100198,
-0.0278353076,
-0.0122052729,
-0.0130189145,
0.0739067867,
-0.0037639234,
0.0210897624,
0.0295377783,
0.0093499068,
-0.0099603152,
0.0499267578,
-0.0382492803,
-0.0132734338,
-0.014602365,
0.0099268472,
0.007750053,
0.0138894096,
0.0011801861,
0.0317070596,
-0.0212989226,
0.0488060154,
0.0321623497,
-0.0143887773,
0.0186152663,
0.0369285457,
-0.0023148251,
-0.0594053455,
0.032538902,
0.0217213649,
-0.0012939174,
0.0248794015,
-0.0822260752,
-0.0624655671,
-0.0238406844,
-0.0508774444,
-0.0565871932,
0.0326750614,
-0.0557694659,
0.0554992072,
-0.0597446412,
0.0046528741,
-0.0362016782,
0.0177160241,
-0.0029023923,
-0.0242789537,
-0.0596865751,
0.0172109213,
-0.0229087546,
0.0478218608,
-0.0789876357,
-0.0146371946,
0.0045218328,
0.0190049205,
0.0022948084,
-0.0439085551,
-0.0401116535,
-0.0226328187,
-0.0425317474,
-0.0159517378,
-0.0190642979,
0.0272978097,
-0.0276823975,
0.0189855043,
-0.0073324344,
-0.0239110012,
-0.0440285131,
0.0076701781,
0.0526933596,
-0.0272440016,
-0.0266389567,
0.0706088692,
-0.0336401127,
-0.0181841683,
-0.0667700544,
-0.0352022462,
0.0191370919,
-0.0097899986,
0.0137186544,
-0.0443878807,
0.0228978209,
0.022969624,
-0.0014696299,
-0.044528164,
0.0260315333,
0.0002101782,
-0.056366384,
0.0677032843,
-0.0330221541,
-0.0399299785,
-0.0090320632,
0.0235348698,
-0.0113692647,
0.0952987075,
0.0256849267,
0.0125142224,
0.0555581227,
0.0464068316,
-0.0247923546,
0.0111218533,
0.0337078571,
0.0139650712,
0.057218641,
0.0121853817,
0.0483144782,
0.0132585159,
0.0925476626,
0.0105823008,
-0.0341454521,
0.0020879924,
0.0395113528,
0.0274080299,
-0.0157669801,
0.0020944343,
0.0366987698,
-0.0207811184,
-0.0332867913,
0.0568146892,
-0.0455212668,
0.0107788239,
0.0038423103,
-0.0064390274,
-0.010542254,
0.0358506143,
-0.0050987541,
0.0106803412,
0.0070345877,
-0.0290838927,
-0.0209174287,
-0.0406547785,
0.0873856395,
0.0106257545,
-0.0440408736,
0.0648854077,
0.0583983921,
-0.0285880174,
0.0497104861,
-0.033369936,
-0.0022330857,
0.0117266094,
0.014459244,
-0.0554555692,
-0.0085618403,
-0.0272302702,
0.0615174323,
0.061843399,
0.0184777044,
-0.0281132068,
0.0184281915,
-0.0303020533,
-0.0344542414,
-0.0011580576,
0.0104968818,
0.0052847043,
0.0249333084,
0.0207987055,
0.0146449227,
0.0122124078,
0.0175922066,
0.0559071228,
-0.0105936509,
-0.0389017984,
-0.0281933956,
0.015446255,
0.0134260561,
-0.0168391541,
-0.0148690296,
-0.0135231484,
0.0182277672,
-0.0585284196,
-0.0314291753,
-0.0029791777,
-0.0176161621,
-0.0100758485,
0.0181335472,
-0.0067219944,
-0.007268473,
0.0575885028,
-0.0268560201,
-0.0181332361,
-0.0039764699,
0.0305532925,
0.02435291,
0.001092921,
-0.0131652802,
0.0274260305,
0.0018481979,
-0.0305955429,
0.0817663074,
0.0242922939,
-0.0293563865,
0.030509321,
-0.0314336494,
0.0159150157,
0.0157056618,
0.0047394978,
0.0226643179,
-0.0119416071,
-0.0156147396,
0.0089781936,
-0.0403060727,
-0.0785688236,
0.0011784685,
-0.0571666025,
0.035739623,
-0.0243613776,
0.0629764125,
0.0355862007,
0.0299667884,
-0.0188344456,
-0.0122564016,
0.0204422288,
-0.0181357693,
-0.0474888422,
0.0404257514,
0.0230542179,
0.0326076075,
0.0172051676,
-0.0220451448,
0.003612695,
-0.0380200781,
0.0518173166,
0.0255859606,
-0.0576762967,
-0.0370830297,
0.0598652624,
0.0013757126,
0.0379200093,
0.0055219135,
0.0162788685,
-0.0336487256,
0.0062571643,
0.0545523502,
0.0439905226,
-0.0049549299,
0.0268434584,
0.0313655101,
-0.0472387522,
-0.0464625433,
0.0145778889,
-0.0355906114,
-0.0107132886,
-0.0227443594,
0.0419569388,
0.0520043299,
0.0130293919,
-0.006523645,
-0.018820053,
-0.0269251671,
-0.021172829,
-0.0254350174,
-0.0376133174,
-0.0404426605,
-0.0250778254,
-0.0183696821,
0.0243079737,
-0.0509120896,
0.0113153057,
0.0573223792,
0.0342146493,
0.0248421244,
-0.0653851181,
0.025089737,
-0.0518952832,
0.030385267,
-0.0320511535,
0.0116640497,
0.0441693775,
-0.0478483737,
-0.038419567,
0.0332872346,
-0.0033950491,
-0.0090819718,
0.0486643165,
-0.0407515019,
0.0264567118,
-0.0322305262,
-0.026494598,
-0.0370454751,
-0.0513096079,
0.0087929349,
0.0167846419,
-0.0238207541,
0.011107442,
-0.0225543324,
0.0080308532,
-0.0038044567,
0.0386522189,
0.0046448121,
-0.0269279387,
-0.0171107221,
0.0696253851,
0.061035011,
-0.0288501661,
-0.0381991304,
-0.0075260308,
-0.0068504536,
0.0604089312,
0.0427694395,
-0.0085409861,
0.0034640224,
0.0094535016,
0.0246221106,
-0.0733315572,
0.0005270524,
-0.0224434659,
0.0247991867,
-0.0427813493,
-0.0190854408,
0.0993635654,
0.0144916782,
-0.0321858935,
-0.0325343162,
-0.017523244,
-0.0004337647,
0.0149098998,
-0.0007699319,
-0.0827500448,
-0.0441402718,
-0.0071469774,
0.0031494591,
0.0144246761,
-0.037586309,
0.0095789414,
-0.1055582985,
-0.0229355358,
-0.0202554408,
-0.0475553982,
-0.0546156615,
-0.0546327457,
0.0644801408,
-0.0197246298,
-0.0182053223,
-0.0115827657,
-0.0058208178,
0.0040264791,
0.0066971253,
0.0347907655,
-0.0620630346,
0.0010827964,
-0.0651612803,
0.0094483653,
0.04399243,
0.0192951318,
-0.0006603887,
0.0032468326,
0.0277449861,
-0.0059625027,
-0.008112194,
-0.0093731964,
0.090335004,
-0.024158949,
0.0013212134,
-0.0217809193,
0.0218053218,
-0.0091428105,
-0.04645098,
-0.0134931458,
0.0733909681,
0.0329032689,
-0.0035472072,
-0.003651083,
-0.032575231,
0.0499382168,
0.0475982167,
-0.0017027175,
-0.0125188846,
-0.0022156746,
0.021312803,
-0.0091460012,
-0.0631129965,
-0.0224415548,
-0.0200885199,
-0.0635547042,
-0.0672621429,
-0.091293864,
-0.0091953492,
0.0282776989,
0.031249661,
0.0023756919,
-0.0088002998,
0.0108739743,
0.0079055894,
-0.0415510498,
0.047446195,
-0.0527408458,
-0.0161058623,
-0.0167336408,
0.0154526103,
0.0182470921,
0.0087180967,
-0.0319946222,
0.0438870415,
-0.0555297211,
-0.0299516544,
0.0124068372,
-0.0149210673,
0.0123810973,
0.0211196057,
-0.0081206514,
-0.0195565186,
0.0142170312,
0.055670727,
-0.078007631,
0.0079893516,
0.0237516128,
-0.0301152989,
-0.0053159175,
0.0136822434,
-0.0384714603,
0.0181434583,
0.008066142,
0.01223813,
-0.0004756354,
0.0034221401,
0.0129718687,
-0.0152985128,
0.1095071882,
0.0063685491,
-0.0329452418,
-0.0661168471,
-0.0005269899,
-0.0063874624,
0.0074114352,
-0.0206883475,
0.0162519962,
0.0213464126,
0.018412305,
-0.016795788,
0.035472665,
0.0088751465,
0.0142256292,
-0.0717970505,
-0.0380295292,
0.0153357312,
0.0538428761,
0.0205896609,
-0.0043571619,
-0.0301503241,
-0.0238925777,
0.0159060657,
-0.0119855013,
-0.0670072809,
0.0288461521,
0.0527302064,
0.0065623019,
0.0313419551,
-0.0052537858,
-0.0596239492,
0.0776845366,
-0.009342595,
-0.0287005864,
0.0718686953,
-0.0290738661,
0.040038079,
-0.0017190044,
-0.0191443209,
0.0156408306,
0.0244149789,
0.0066850684,
0.0173194837,
0.0307869986,
0.0159139279,
0.0036443614,
0.0029200101,
0.0659956113,
-0.0343894362,
0.0849997103,
0.0008324289,
-0.0223595686,
-0.0110749071,
-0.0121475533,
0.0075524305,
0.0383822843,
-0.0256572738,
0.0014755492,
-0.0431201272,
0.0039947308,
0.0227081627,
-0.0356219038,
-0.0157847367,
0.008149798,
0.040301647,
0.0524016768,
0.02811707,
-0.060265474,
-0.0055291434,
0.0095321862,
0.0155210448,
-0.0268255305,
-0.0220558383,
-5.86535902e-33,
-0.0581044294,
-0.024554953,
0.0191733036,
0.0905511081,
-0.0351157933,
0.0229392797,
-0.0131035615,
-0.0198686905,
-0.011136842,
0.0023373801,
0.018894475,
0.0210907143,
0.0247651767,
-0.016322149,
-0.0235798545,
-0.0539048947,
0.0506133661,
0.0039681438,
-0.0162455291,
0.002509098,
0.0819858089,
0.0567453764,
0.0499517061,
-0.1210554764,
0.0296044797,
0.0268578958,
0.0344621204,
-0.0126651833,
0.0854255185,
0.0308378413,
-0.0178825688,
0.0582044646,
0.0344595388,
-0.078159824,
-0.0005317157,
0.0629887953,
-0.1249722987,
-0.0342222527,
0.0333279073,
-0.0059526083,
0.0078198034,
-0.0554032512,
0.0216723308,
0.0198004078,
0.0539776683,
-0.0402342342,
0.0462431237,
-0.0193491969,
0.0172332022,
-0.0327091515,
-0.1290152222,
0.0358237028,
0.0254759826,
-0.0052471464,
0.030139694,
0.0160802286,
0.0380103253,
-0.0270194579,
-0.0285788309,
-0.0069977087,
-0.0583595894,
0.0473824069,
0.0192292687,
0.0205201618,
-0.0414015204,
0.060932368,
-0.0162861012,
-0.0017282934,
-0.0354895368,
0.0209108628,
0.0143366801,
0.0463995039,
0.023084728,
0.0436229855,
0.0213505533,
-0.003701647,
-0.116278708,
0.0227834992,
-0.0193742719,
0.0119147738,
-0.0157359783,
0.0347040594,
-0.0049238531,
0.0287969876,
-0.0070890747,
0.0574034303,
-0.0352016352,
-0.0101701245,
0.0216532741,
0.0187113155,
-0.011657808,
0.0593348965,
0.0285787098,
0.0065253861,
0.0155553147,
0.0303960145,
0.0223697554,
0.0242810603,
-0.0329621248,
-0.0368400365,
-0.0685134828,
-0.0297711994,
0.0268307347,
0.0094690584,
0.0442957878,
-0.004429989,
0.0382476635,
-0.0090649128,
-0.0533042625,
-0.0107299248,
-0.0457136929,
0.009231382,
0.0187292304,
0.0179933142,
0.0171782896,
0.0133539634,
-0.0176597834,
0.0301213115,
0.0508261546,
-0.008044281,
-0.0173215382,
-0.0123958588,
-0.0006400392,
0.0149083128,
0.0001879609,
-0.0068078255,
-0.0058879741,
0.0312440787,
-0.0041187145,
-0.0440415777,
-0.0235963576,
0.0015647159,
2.557e-7,
0.0439068787,
0.0190310329,
0.0202500913,
0.0484501123,
-0.0308041889,
0.0227203462,
0.0282111112,
0.0645499453,
0.012093001,
-0.001563931,
-0.0397235118,
0.0079494901,
-0.0089943865,
0.0385114215,
-0.083885625,
-0.0726225376,
0.0260520335,
-0.0107499836,
-0.0461724699,
-0.0273495875,
0.0755408779,
0.0092724022,
0.0363189243,
0.0083216922,
-0.0036920141,
-0.0377311856,
0.0555002987,
-0.0147520471,
-0.0129869403,
0.0180569142,
0.0115001276,
0.0311428793,
-0.0296911858,
0.0831273496,
-0.0332278423,
0.021402454,
0.0223238152,
0.0376170427,
0.0034144071,
0.0159246288,
-0.0114950184,
-0.0435800888,
0.0046877246,
-0.0023180649,
0.0823095143,
-0.0450171232,
-0.0001806107,
0.0085647646,
-0.0313630737,
0.0145990979,
-0.0537029915,
0.0046104216,
-0.0414822213,
0.0165592264,
0.0068230522,
0.0405770056,
-0.0445635654,
-0.0924154744,
0.0076320204,
0.0013268573,
-0.0189300533,
-0.0411835425,
-0.0127269803,
-0.0272977073,
0.0309489127,
-0.0813576505,
-0.0070944447,
2.268229996e-34,
-0.0369063355,
0.0287455954,
-0.0202592071,
0.0491671897,
0.0190910958,
-0.0127876271,
-0.0551608428,
-0.0124234809,
0.0019803059,
-0.0441910625,
0.0325269848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14160v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14160v4 | Label Words are Anchors: An Information Flow Perspective for Understanding In-Context Learning | 2023-05-23T15:26:20 | 2023-12-19T15:13:52 | Lean Wang, Lei Li, Damai Dai, Deli Chen, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In-context learning (ICL) emerges as a promising capability of large language
models (LLMs) by providing them with demonstration examples to perform diverse
tasks. However, the underlying mechanism of how LLMs learn from the provided
context remains under-explored. In this paper, we investigate the working
mechanism of ICL through an information flow lens. Our findings reveal that
label words in the demonstration examples function as anchors: (1) semantic
information aggregates into label word representations during the shallow
computation layers' processing; (2) the consolidated information in label words
serves as a reference for LLMs' final predictions. Based on these insights, we
introduce an anchor re-weighting method to improve ICL performance, a
demonstration compression technique to expedite inference, and an analysis
framework for diagnosing ICL errors in GPT2-XL. The promising applications of
our findings again validate the uncovered ICL working mechanism and pave the
way for future studies. | [
0.0049770414,
0.0165596195,
-0.0068702702,
0.0439596772,
-0.0488605276,
0.0203820635,
0.0098555302,
-0.0078264354,
-0.0223556533,
-0.0448129363,
-0.0425433703,
-0.0554164909,
0.0449031182,
-0.0083107362,
0.0430565588,
-0.0159669947,
0.0434157439,
-0.0310576912,
-0.0246175248,
-0.0097621931,
0.0017458398,
0.0050405962,
0.0220179148,
0.0383451134,
-0.0169417113,
-0.0210782513,
0.0024843989,
0.0259886105,
-0.0213172399,
-0.0444021448,
-0.0047339969,
0.0406083427,
0.0408075862,
0.0565246567,
0.0000020379,
-0.0404932573,
-0.0145170577,
0.0164886229,
-0.0390074141,
0.0360774696,
0.0460709743,
-0.0003409197,
-0.0289189331,
0.0263053551,
-0.0030419144,
-0.051187329,
0.0632451624,
0.0462559424,
0.0169980749,
0.037998639,
-0.0179877635,
-0.0248630736,
-0.0025172788,
-0.0347459391,
0.061575871,
-0.088102378,
0.0415570065,
-0.0137021421,
-0.01919505,
-0.013750582,
-0.0437986329,
0.0393019281,
0.0344151668,
0.0342575945,
-0.0210235659,
0.0831151307,
-0.0219370965,
-0.0183853097,
-0.0338478908,
0.0488375984,
-0.0157926381,
-0.0240352489,
-0.0374681205,
-0.0170949455,
0.0082920995,
-0.0113894502,
-0.0473949574,
0.0266150609,
0.0070759114,
0.0426938348,
0.0353336781,
-0.0014312695,
0.0651214942,
0.0049711652,
-0.0494816378,
0.0841040909,
0.0064503504,
-0.0458596051,
0.0132071618,
0.0321843363,
-0.039374195,
-0.0289402418,
-0.017164886,
0.0008103623,
-0.0042097215,
0.0577027537,
-0.0291767847,
0.0130320843,
-0.0004868125,
-0.0385675542,
0.0330710784,
0.0254406724,
-0.0046927775,
0.0380213819,
-0.0179080088,
0.0526355989,
0.0007937505,
0.031070726,
-0.0414825864,
-0.005665055,
-0.0194267221,
-0.0386451483,
-0.0574354529,
0.0389583819,
-0.0205881931,
-0.0300342701,
-0.0037689656,
0.0380865224,
-0.0137653816,
-0.0200522095,
-0.0251347888,
-0.0228466298,
-0.0360622816,
-0.0023772996,
-0.0291470662,
0.0299416147,
-0.0004835446,
0.0252476372,
-0.0177528262,
-0.0470307879,
-0.0185569599,
0.0096328733,
-0.0159710608,
-0.0277690385,
0.0026467524,
0.0544950254,
-0.0122449463,
-0.0691615045,
-0.0304232128,
-0.0061048875,
-0.0291326586,
-0.0728264004,
-0.0072377222,
-0.0641464964,
0.0112207532,
0.0301572494,
0.013534911,
-0.0496486612,
0.0027488547,
0.0505145974,
-0.0535356663,
0.07671123,
0.0112422155,
0.0128872925,
0.0115621788,
0.0126688331,
0.0468754508,
0.0816769674,
0.024181569,
0.0015064693,
0.010281275,
0.0025477812,
-0.0055457302,
0.041026365,
0.0639475212,
0.0298830513,
-0.0590144433,
-0.0172668491,
0.0505281724,
0.0443228967,
0.033188235,
0.0395527221,
-0.0385122001,
0.0244510453,
0.0510068238,
0.0680773184,
0.006952344,
0.0095115267,
0.0144913904,
-0.0064469543,
-0.0304367281,
0.0185500123,
-0.0711430162,
0.00994597,
-0.0282905791,
0.0106656514,
0.0470499732,
0.0213606749,
-0.0270332228,
-0.0182116795,
-0.0339536108,
0.0279276967,
-0.0030741557,
0.001878796,
0.0225694794,
0.0378002413,
-0.0617078952,
0.0769890919,
0.0289970394,
-0.0131887356,
-0.0172939021,
-0.0660360456,
-0.004244749,
0.0312071238,
0.0379120037,
-0.006164975,
-0.0040522795,
0.0210251808,
0.0313735008,
0.0416344255,
0.0349294096,
-0.0106187286,
-0.0158142652,
-0.0414649434,
-0.0229836758,
-0.0175178796,
0.0108721834,
0.0139628667,
0.0272615422,
-0.0188435055,
0.0183079392,
-0.0430721641,
-0.0290413629,
0.040280316,
-0.0084613049,
-0.0385220498,
0.0095772045,
-0.0019526371,
0.022227047,
-0.0181831401,
0.0013676631,
0.022665333,
0.0333191454,
0.000075853,
0.0079882313,
-0.0126923155,
-0.0883666053,
-0.0558151901,
0.0282985754,
0.0024174834,
0.007598679,
-0.0301045701,
-0.0332627594,
-0.0424039699,
0.0040001157,
-0.0251376666,
0.08288908,
-0.0378835909,
0.0291566756,
0.0002431405,
0.0234080423,
-0.0502443723,
0.0832944959,
-0.0020539628,
0.0254835766,
0.0312243253,
0.0855527818,
-0.0230206847,
0.0035797879,
0.000763174,
0.0127003379,
0.000837927,
0.0127140842,
-0.00964789,
-0.002153469,
-0.033894062,
-0.0019771438,
-0.0898477361,
0.0155178579,
-0.0017817107,
0.006931683,
0.0265672654,
0.0155394683,
-0.0000905247,
-0.0113890152,
-0.0147514762,
-0.006699923,
-0.0203394163,
0.0358728804,
0.0106686763,
0.0119556971,
-0.0163046904,
-0.0143827563,
-0.0181908198,
-0.0383509099,
0.0774852782,
-0.0151950214,
-0.0499351099,
-0.0522466488,
0.0377879292,
0.0030466479,
0.0143110938,
-0.0041097207,
0.0162670314,
0.0238169506,
-0.0070423028,
0.0630238503,
0.030426655,
-0.0156847276,
0.0705206096,
0.0551771298,
-0.0188548174,
-0.057645008,
0.0176837966,
-0.0297063701,
-0.032233756,
-0.0514655001,
0.0033478062,
-0.0295727719,
0.0965573639,
0.0184703618,
0.0026768968,
-0.0516217165,
-0.0062809782,
-0.0281052198,
-0.0140040275,
-0.0764350742,
-0.0246945564,
-0.0480681024,
0.0011169617,
-0.0205103196,
-0.0730514228,
0.0521572791,
-0.0343693681,
-0.0121842017,
-0.0666366294,
-0.0043215081,
-0.0280328542,
0.0585212335,
-0.00519387,
0.0105481008,
-0.0028207763,
-0.02732349,
-0.0499099307,
0.0239898134,
-0.0132469013,
-0.0343095958,
0.0349064693,
-0.0408751741,
-0.0001143016,
-0.0048944051,
-0.0292948578,
-0.0276729632,
-0.0062239491,
-0.0332488306,
0.0085387602,
0.0003219871,
-0.0023670492,
-0.0264092125,
0.0087565994,
0.0426693819,
0.0369232297,
-0.003333909,
-0.0110410955,
-0.0298718009,
-0.0042472952,
0.0148099763,
0.0086796498,
0.0261173267,
-0.044167012,
0.011172344,
0.0432611145,
0.0550285392,
0.0048267287,
-0.0016048799,
0.0233495161,
0.0557684824,
0.0008950524,
-0.0176790673,
0.0462431684,
0.0382266156,
-0.062593624,
-0.0424136072,
0.1019395664,
0.0374125391,
-0.103987284,
-0.0018830976,
0.0150313517,
0.0488375165,
0.0454706289,
0.0112055317,
-0.0533666611,
-0.0378619507,
0.0249755085,
-0.0032116782,
-0.0133876167,
0.0203972291,
-0.0314632505,
-0.1419176608,
0.0374647155,
0.0228590798,
-0.0900113806,
-0.0149823278,
-0.0585201457,
0.0007571729,
0.0357907601,
0.0645846948,
0.0069488049,
-0.0284229834,
-0.0020402544,
0.0285141971,
0.0203808229,
-0.0676373318,
0.0394272543,
-0.0016916899,
0.0394685939,
0.0729709864,
0.0073281219,
-0.0281595048,
-0.031155698,
0.095562458,
-0.0550490133,
-0.0080834441,
-0.0306836125,
0.0323907062,
-0.0071432041,
0.0041467608,
-0.0065522217,
0.0118069714,
-0.0351849645,
-0.0452781767,
-0.0331488475,
0.1019729152,
0.0021357103,
-0.022649372,
-0.0002108803,
-0.0222960431,
0.0126974452,
0.0959661603,
0.0401120558,
-0.0451805815,
-0.0135529572,
-0.0094051231,
0.0152600827,
0.0253520403,
-0.0260418225,
0.0436637998,
0.0008248008,
-0.0237002671,
-0.036525961,
-0.0079803541,
0.0370100327,
0.048400037,
-0.0142566599,
0.0324717052,
-0.0342075303,
-0.0232153945,
-0.0414280295,
0.0324590988,
-0.0325168185,
0.0392281935,
-0.0458337702,
-0.0008153385,
0.0257937014,
-0.0267704688,
-0.0272673983,
0.0704029948,
-0.0644110888,
-0.0710190237,
-0.0108244698,
-0.0196229164,
0.023357695,
0.0520998761,
-0.0176247153,
-0.0313329957,
0.0516058281,
0.060313303,
-0.0141603937,
0.0320501737,
0.0128408577,
-0.0350561552,
-0.0003785226,
0.0320536755,
-0.0320168585,
-0.0014778142,
0.0164970234,
0.0359642804,
-0.0189865287,
-0.0249345023,
0.0516684838,
-0.0221816003,
0.0617144965,
-0.0276483931,
-0.0199571904,
-0.0191481411,
0.0346200131,
0.0270454064,
-0.0248198919,
-0.0287074614,
-0.0220395569,
0.0309547614,
0.0133882491,
-0.0072838073,
0.013755125,
0.043729689,
0.0235605668,
-0.0064308671,
-0.0249971878,
0.0060812011,
0.0230251215,
0.0312401205,
0.0238612872,
-0.0027871043,
-0.0098048402,
0.0005098952,
0.0416256376,
-0.0178438257,
0.0624111891,
0.0415279567,
-0.0075665009,
-0.0229991414,
0.0173093304,
-0.0637113154,
-0.0162805244,
-0.0658209473,
0.0146090342,
0.0379183516,
-0.0237171128,
0.0260045938,
-0.0408944003,
-0.0194406789,
-0.0131321158,
-0.0258439705,
-0.0365944728,
-0.0538269281,
0.0530377999,
0.0262998324,
-0.001293882,
0.0130167231,
0.0692637861,
0.0515710078,
0.0375249386,
-0.0191484056,
0.0012368241,
0.0076020262,
-0.026351871,
0.0415360071,
0.0456418917,
-0.0184988827,
-0.0043776734,
-0.0703254864,
-0.0805688351,
-0.0052078371,
-0.0206274912,
0.0061624404,
-0.0366246514,
0.0384046547,
0.0848715007,
-0.0074497438,
-0.0285967924,
-0.0091171069,
-0.0268671401,
0.0125778606,
-0.0086617852,
-0.014609904,
-6.848711472e-33,
-0.0514222831,
-0.0345903337,
0.0337504968,
0.0049538924,
-0.0121111535,
0.0273270849,
-0.0389916822,
-0.0040283008,
0.0031902604,
0.0349816158,
0.0044978466,
0.0213362314,
0.0181434862,
0.0242531989,
-0.0168286189,
-0.0101968581,
0.0112522766,
0.0140928803,
-0.0075519211,
0.0433096513,
0.0021719788,
0.0209955573,
0.0783651099,
-0.0690380856,
0.0091923624,
-0.004453687,
0.0091307675,
0.0022298533,
-0.0418334417,
0.0344546698,
-0.0515881516,
0.0421488658,
0.015169749,
-0.0773538426,
-0.019624915,
0.0328316353,
-0.0645338222,
-0.0258100219,
0.048636768,
0.0070576686,
-0.0293847974,
-0.0105373375,
0.0619951673,
0.0124962442,
-0.0228799973,
-0.0126767186,
0.0236994158,
-0.002192002,
-0.0595305003,
-0.029753454,
-0.0937352329,
0.0214048941,
0.0338965319,
0.0044820299,
0.0282848794,
-0.037056163,
-0.0060120309,
0.0037660941,
-0.0558163561,
0.0087864669,
-0.0022690797,
0.0416098759,
0.0504659712,
0.0636531264,
0.0118270591,
0.0527000763,
0.0206719283,
-0.0027212286,
0.0009880819,
-0.037690524,
0.0726044551,
-0.0021125644,
0.0272429194,
0.0273845624,
0.0566581339,
0.0040219142,
-0.0503258109,
-0.0223892443,
-0.0132841701,
0.0150987683,
0.0466031805,
0.0191400386,
-0.0371561199,
-0.0510564297,
-0.0634459853,
-0.0244718362,
-0.0431572981,
-0.0051411288,
0.0343302488,
0.0306190699,
-0.0024185213,
0.0130602503,
0.0026726602,
-0.0410240702,
-0.0678666681,
-0.0156569872,
0.0005793466,
0.0284667481,
0.0014989134,
0.0456808619,
-0.0739095807,
-0.0446477011,
-0.0190495495,
0.0172292702,
0.0082980767,
0.0219910871,
0.0363408551,
0.0398904681,
-0.0581057109,
-0.0102704139,
-0.068129696,
-0.0172609556,
0.0072900336,
-0.0293712467,
0.0422438234,
0.0085993158,
-0.0061453152,
0.0254348759,
0.0489993691,
-0.0044859666,
-0.0164295156,
-0.0259044226,
-0.0361242071,
0.0202598777,
-0.0257144831,
-0.0288566481,
-0.0238129664,
0.0215087943,
0.0793791041,
-0.0457961001,
-0.0351552032,
0.0354441665,
2.892e-7,
0.0486360192,
0.0332488194,
0.0050310683,
0.0006519557,
0.0161993559,
0.0162527282,
-0.031889312,
0.023892859,
0.0427458957,
-0.0478104614,
0.0161252972,
0.0398053862,
0.0320370421,
0.0205484517,
-0.0831229538,
0.0118272761,
-0.0319874249,
0.0279511865,
-0.0450631417,
0.0187534355,
-0.009307568,
0.1170472577,
0.0107749458,
-0.0305653736,
0.0068864999,
-0.050391864,
0.0587997101,
-0.0421714,
0.0475215577,
0.0089940671,
-0.0416698568,
0.0459106341,
0.0039040626,
0.0386713929,
-0.0063838866,
0.0279844906,
-0.0013898832,
0.0395558029,
-0.0045285816,
-0.019134853,
-0.0170072597,
-0.0122558689,
0.0038050292,
-0.0746893212,
0.0611770451,
-0.0699769408,
-0.0120766032,
-0.0283815116,
0.0316912234,
-0.0287885219,
0.0018533752,
0.0316292606,
-0.0112318564,
-0.0000850884,
-0.0035994411,
-0.0011384868,
-0.0405098423,
-0.1039792895,
-0.0450834781,
0.0380897224,
-0.0455748439,
-0.0303928964,
-0.0566866212,
0.001531546,
0.0194967948,
-0.0458998196,
-0.003107985,
3.050499905e-34,
0.0174738988,
-0.0414239392,
0.0256408788,
0.0414277129,
0.0222147387,
-0.0242274515,
0.0128788259,
0.0392978936,
0.0197919458,
-0.063244462,
0.005914201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14150v1 | WYWEB: A NLP Evaluation Benchmark For Classical Chinese | 2023-05-23T15:15:11 | 2023-05-23T15:15:11 | Bo Zhou, Qianglong Chen, Tianyu Wang, Xiaomi Zhong, Yin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To fully evaluate the overall performance of different NLP models in a given
domain, many evaluation benchmarks are proposed, such as GLUE, SuperGLUE and
CLUE. The fi eld of natural language understanding has traditionally focused on
benchmarks for various tasks in languages such as Chinese, English, and
multilingua, however, there has been a lack of attention given to the area of
classical Chinese, also known as "wen yan wen", which has a rich history
spanning thousands of years and holds signifi cant cultural and academic value.
For the prosperity of the NLP community, in this paper, we introduce the WYWEB
evaluation benchmark, which consists of nine NLP tasks in classical Chinese,
implementing sentence classifi cation, sequence labeling, reading
comprehension, and machine translation. We evaluate the existing pre-trained
language models, which are all struggling with this benchmark. We also
introduce a number of supplementary datasets and additional tools to help
facilitate further progress on classical Chinese NLU. The github repository is
https://github.com/baudzhou/WYWEB. | [
0.0634222031,
0.0464009643,
0.0263813194,
0.0595012754,
-0.039252542,
0.0147921182,
0.0022521163,
-0.0058068708,
0.0008866997,
-0.0486577712,
-0.0514156446,
-0.071376726,
0.0065509006,
0.0121828318,
-0.0136107448,
-0.0542677119,
0.0406569429,
0.0331706367,
-0.0096705165,
0.0424114689,
0.0212101955,
-0.0115169222,
0.0028955366,
0.0327073783,
0.0169543866,
-0.0501539893,
0.0001073289,
0.0087681469,
0.0122290002,
-0.0512649044,
0.0185533985,
0.0485128276,
-0.0122166444,
0.0404275432,
0.0000020393,
-0.0482599884,
-0.0292579457,
-0.039385926,
-0.0093940077,
0.0557153784,
0.0064152898,
-0.0183394831,
-0.0104255034,
0.0195488259,
-0.0455582961,
-0.0186826177,
0.0201568659,
0.0990326852,
0.0355214588,
0.0753388926,
0.001872184,
-0.0355310328,
0.0060222605,
-0.0345400199,
-0.0054226243,
-0.1053816974,
-0.0032442345,
0.0385214016,
-0.0103902882,
-0.0279266182,
-0.0270884465,
0.0130062168,
0.0091256183,
0.0012870779,
-0.0166273843,
0.0124106314,
-0.0377844088,
-0.0007421016,
-0.0266194008,
0.1055504531,
-0.0047023315,
-0.0187483616,
-0.0102833454,
0.0265012961,
-0.0456902832,
-0.0192400925,
-0.0350182913,
0.0227895603,
-0.0093610417,
0.0171557292,
0.0383246467,
0.0083766039,
0.0386778973,
0.0349961929,
-0.0099321371,
0.060130354,
0.0138034588,
-0.0192528851,
0.0040498027,
-0.0072330358,
-0.0261681806,
-0.0358228609,
0.0094783837,
0.0490934402,
-0.0271908008,
0.0306975935,
0.0054029441,
0.0211651362,
-0.0220856983,
-0.0454555526,
0.0260034073,
0.0421114266,
-0.0038026602,
0.0580313355,
-0.0125851287,
0.0529353283,
0.0252141133,
-0.0150640532,
-0.0643566251,
0.0000921984,
-0.0496979281,
-0.0090360818,
-0.037989568,
0.0551711321,
-0.0341373943,
-0.0484955646,
-0.0132324975,
-0.0220326521,
-0.0099589732,
0.0102496622,
-0.0175788738,
-0.0186490342,
-0.0283142235,
0.0030404916,
-0.017554421,
0.0259140059,
-0.0467661358,
-0.0050946749,
-0.0423475318,
-0.0273495149,
-0.0269623175,
0.0121135404,
0.0006788247,
-0.0438366346,
0.0135305375,
0.0487155057,
-0.0061534047,
-0.0317829512,
-0.0347799398,
0.0034179462,
-0.0393403284,
-0.040625684,
0.0064868815,
-0.0358906761,
-0.0082879961,
-0.0002709481,
0.0387538821,
-0.0320671052,
0.0294926465,
0.005651298,
0.0046207798,
0.0352557153,
-0.0016288143,
-0.0209612641,
-0.0726148263,
0.0294898804,
0.0182210151,
0.0307200272,
0.0209641811,
0.0340891927,
0.0707304329,
0.0040763235,
-0.0083825067,
-0.010391227,
-0.0052668639,
-0.0291259978,
-0.008881662,
0.0235737115,
0.0626165047,
0.0241419859,
-0.0303702801,
0.0160227213,
-0.0209080018,
-0.0037924966,
0.0411681682,
0.0065553407,
-0.0030393738,
0.0055540227,
0.0127695389,
-0.0053266818,
0.0369752906,
0.0358299315,
-0.0505409911,
0.0017788413,
-0.0433650874,
0.02589502,
0.0025397041,
-0.0065570367,
-0.011467508,
-0.0747101903,
-0.0527869239,
0.0050942912,
0.0034786367,
-0.0140403761,
0.0312544778,
0.0098741539,
-0.0347838737,
0.0036233701,
0.0207897741,
-0.0508469045,
0.0215145573,
-0.0185086429,
0.0095505342,
0.0841686204,
0.0571672954,
-0.0318083502,
-0.0212921407,
0.030445233,
-0.0071071484,
0.0563068986,
0.0571371131,
-0.0340871774,
0.0343127437,
-0.0287005566,
-0.009257284,
-0.0231420528,
0.0096631497,
-0.0143973939,
0.0005873015,
-0.0057317726,
0.0164029673,
-0.0541820638,
-0.0593507774,
0.0755077153,
-0.0355379991,
-0.0410633609,
-0.0279584527,
0.0050079194,
0.0135007473,
0.05959066,
-0.0354645513,
0.0192700308,
0.0363191254,
-0.0411883779,
-0.0197183117,
0.0123205101,
-0.0336980671,
-0.0876318216,
0.0809040442,
-0.038976077,
-0.0103673274,
0.0391262472,
-0.085788995,
-0.0581081733,
0.0039681313,
0.0327541642,
0.028782906,
-0.0509022884,
0.0497299135,
-0.0017988273,
0.0131512322,
-0.0237027127,
0.0659501925,
0.0178096741,
0.047520943,
-0.0082313241,
0.0195038114,
0.0259526763,
0.013996671,
-0.0709246099,
0.0073616263,
0.0108026667,
0.03151308,
0.0321723893,
0.0281019974,
-0.0524891131,
-0.0293878764,
-0.0479340926,
0.0626781359,
-0.0710379705,
0.0245081261,
0.0375027396,
-0.0042492533,
0.0058110976,
-0.0162016377,
-0.025487233,
0.0148882736,
-0.0557863377,
-0.0336664021,
0.0284210034,
0.0146590946,
0.0131537132,
-0.0333141536,
0.0023999715,
0.0114845615,
0.0055505242,
0.0230841115,
-0.0230051558,
0.0022611334,
-0.0118741766,
-0.0070933714,
-0.0019690075,
-0.0248688143,
-0.0543186776,
-0.0401442647,
0.0003999376,
0.0295566972,
0.042285528,
-0.0032752915,
0.0458376817,
0.0407246016,
0.0093215704,
0.0042014145,
-0.0051870574,
-0.0019371436,
-0.0153110614,
-0.0193240102,
-0.01927278,
0.001071165,
0.0689691082,
-0.0066059842,
0.0012595247,
-0.0204686821,
-0.0204047263,
-0.0364490077,
0.0184025764,
-0.0219762847,
0.0370596424,
-0.0352905653,
-0.0022796912,
-0.0655379966,
-0.0016989715,
0.0390720144,
-0.0365328342,
-0.002634445,
-0.065995343,
-0.0007056269,
-0.0582368113,
0.0774517432,
0.0158136208,
0.0186805148,
-0.0052659353,
-0.0322298631,
-0.0162322838,
0.047597263,
0.0012521298,
-0.0389891416,
-0.0014123153,
-0.0026288955,
0.0199372973,
-0.0480685644,
0.0172120575,
-0.0317887999,
0.0063963118,
-0.0400075801,
0.0250285007,
0.0223937314,
0.0069983848,
0.0096102776,
0.0453955866,
-0.0296284501,
0.0532343723,
-0.0343297124,
0.0375924781,
-0.0299705714,
0.0395304076,
0.0138088968,
0.057535179,
0.009691014,
-0.0067086197,
0.0705664828,
0.0494970158,
0.0441620201,
-0.0017157659,
0.0038238543,
0.0183232501,
0.0408084281,
-0.0477443561,
-0.004402807,
0.0160157662,
0.0328673162,
-0.0740238801,
0.0074176756,
0.1376238316,
0.0612325296,
0.0044155759,
0.011683844,
0.0177789629,
0.0054276292,
0.0181972887,
-0.0355644822,
-0.0662915558,
-0.0634720027,
0.0168271232,
0.0054627783,
0.0449737981,
-0.0243298318,
0.0177696403,
-0.1273813546,
0.0159598775,
-0.0157709327,
-0.002228925,
0.0068297926,
-0.038705267,
0.002876749,
-0.033086393,
0.0416426361,
0.0212774482,
-0.01733841,
-0.0099211615,
0.0133751463,
-0.0238898881,
-0.0678352267,
0.0303381253,
-0.0555015877,
0.0251207724,
0.0362190753,
0.0718024895,
-0.0143881487,
0.0116044646,
0.0370245539,
-0.0331686698,
0.0004476017,
0.0022590649,
0.0942176953,
-0.0152822342,
-0.0117616542,
0.0059129265,
0.0225934219,
-0.0556643978,
-0.0032991841,
0.0473884754,
-0.0031241365,
-0.0032451141,
-0.0228154976,
0.0007835783,
0.0352534838,
-0.0167919546,
0.1327666789,
0.0162950344,
-0.0423037224,
-0.0530253462,
0.0032324148,
-0.0105838235,
-0.0614747815,
-0.0455370843,
0.0635089725,
-0.0253802463,
0.0048516593,
-0.1267926693,
-0.0906367376,
0.0113048386,
0.0209808964,
0.0107132168,
0.0368624181,
-0.0291260481,
0.0095627541,
-0.067827709,
0.0170584712,
0.0176339224,
0.0045310725,
-0.0714798197,
0.0007229226,
0.041916322,
-0.0319926031,
-0.0106075248,
0.0242607668,
-0.0449988022,
-0.0266284943,
0.0033782958,
-0.0065418216,
0.0077165673,
0.0255083684,
-0.0423024185,
0.0121768173,
-0.0293847602,
-0.016738845,
0.0004088447,
-0.0312105156,
0.027299175,
-0.0210473984,
-0.0046789995,
0.0123316683,
-0.0102883186,
0.0250387266,
0.0489979498,
0.0849115998,
0.0219920836,
0.0230588727,
0.0650981069,
0.0401142985,
0.0097493427,
-0.0023703733,
0.0119423475,
-0.0201855712,
0.0189863145,
-0.0099491701,
-0.0506669544,
-0.0403467976,
-0.0118320733,
0.0539560765,
-0.0169356242,
-0.0432511792,
0.0501743853,
0.0137657896,
-0.0327990167,
-0.0278368201,
0.0120681785,
0.0311552491,
0.0155037697,
-0.0556140468,
-0.0086306483,
-0.0181735419,
-0.0102651548,
0.0090115285,
0.04741285,
0.0076497276,
0.0360295177,
0.0265869182,
0.0069082757,
0.0017268452,
0.0299873687,
-0.0886874646,
-0.004877165,
-0.0282231178,
0.0436339937,
0.0878200233,
-0.0293100737,
0.0573804751,
-0.0527391359,
-0.0141938347,
-0.0323186666,
0.0433977544,
0.0256364606,
-0.0024344369,
-0.0247470178,
0.0147416973,
-0.0225655735,
-0.0247430298,
0.0718668699,
0.0069854404,
0.0388362855,
0.085277386,
0.005912499,
-0.0413293913,
0.0026560556,
0.0227486491,
-0.0041389619,
-0.0014747464,
0.0544546023,
-0.070380941,
-0.0678890944,
0.0086554941,
0.0223254915,
0.01474261,
0.0101587828,
-0.0262372456,
0.058103174,
0.0222569518,
0.0153946588,
-0.0673301592,
-0.0051006763,
-0.0153390802,
0.008083052,
-0.0197399035,
-6.594596042e-33,
-0.0273265298,
-0.0197503306,
0.0012793548,
-0.0034906,
-0.0018672959,
0.0165128857,
-0.0402636006,
-0.0080081401,
-0.0539981686,
0.0027415687,
-0.0286744367,
0.0111475028,
0.0171726868,
0.025596723,
-0.0582385585,
-0.0120452177,
0.0440800376,
0.0188603774,
-0.0333556868,
-0.0062348661,
0.0520904325,
0.0528173,
0.0780009851,
-0.0260721315,
0.0127348173,
-0.0114494013,
0.0063472651,
0.0144895948,
0.0352712795,
0.0265610907,
-0.0281313341,
0.0113112284,
0.0510484912,
0.002280642,
-0.0030285744,
-0.0330421515,
-0.1184606254,
-0.0489802361,
0.0008903052,
0.038750682,
-0.0283077545,
0.0321145579,
-0.0193055682,
-0.0130689247,
0.030754786,
0.0024854629,
0.0290616062,
-0.0612254329,
-0.0087004062,
-0.0291607063,
-0.0685116649,
0.0571975894,
-0.0246512853,
-0.0004418484,
0.0235533156,
0.0085291872,
-0.0351455808,
0.0251315311,
-0.0682772323,
-0.0286333133,
0.0376380868,
0.0704974532,
0.0027992099,
0.0125046484,
-0.0113159455,
0.025334321,
-0.0084025087,
-0.0037130509,
0.0254613794,
0.0275085066,
0.0259953178,
0.0359755494,
0.0259203129,
0.0449368209,
0.0654566213,
0.0103919394,
-0.0638865381,
0.0447040871,
0.0482738279,
0.0078149112,
-0.0027109245,
-0.0198771693,
-0.0280162208,
0.0115598887,
-0.0345820636,
-0.0158686657,
-0.0296566952,
-0.0016148108,
0.0428637676,
0.0183490925,
-0.0625170544,
-0.0207354221,
0.0018881636,
-0.0658208951,
-0.0126600871,
0.0402769856,
-0.0007079383,
-0.0166078899,
-0.0173466988,
0.0331456102,
-0.0372645147,
-0.0460715629,
-0.0141886855,
0.0150075993,
-0.0088138543,
-0.0480007976,
0.0608501136,
0.0019855371,
-0.0194215775,
0.0042990292,
-0.032762181,
-0.0335952379,
0.0026845215,
0.033344578,
0.0388964713,
-0.0003545874,
-0.0138661945,
0.01766745,
0.0590258315,
0.0202448722,
-0.0267093517,
0.0009333527,
0.0045553725,
0.0018295684,
-0.0193832368,
0.0249754246,
-0.0108014988,
0.0051567755,
0.0184236839,
-0.0650491863,
-0.0137463333,
0.0139128761,
2.741e-7,
0.0537756868,
-0.0067668865,
0.0322870985,
0.0641248077,
-0.0272736456,
0.0126989419,
-0.0695942044,
0.0295740869,
-0.0325232074,
-0.0088736024,
0.036833223,
0.0095905084,
0.0826196,
-0.0229957029,
-0.0481854454,
0.0127685172,
-0.0386298969,
-0.022253057,
-0.0171216801,
0.033016637,
0.0439277627,
0.1107281148,
-0.038936764,
0.0049677729,
0.0113292597,
-0.0507241227,
0.0224557109,
-0.0030634953,
0.0147775188,
0.0653682351,
0.002668607,
0.010611183,
-0.0195947941,
-0.0112282671,
-0.0297047757,
0.0527065657,
0.0614957772,
0.0680056587,
0.0052601402,
-0.0102086542,
-0.0255644359,
-0.009336683,
0.0378285646,
-0.0344800763,
0.0856854916,
0.0226993337,
-0.0505510457,
0.0242543574,
-0.0507453568,
-0.0026416238,
0.0021067185,
0.0060343007,
-0.0081240023,
0.043175824,
0.0072801937,
-0.0272979904,
-0.0231588148,
-0.0622670166,
-0.0603676327,
-0.003677763,
0.0057966104,
-0.0201158635,
0.0287370253,
-0.0428226106,
-0.0125502767,
-0.0714557245,
-0.0488205105,
2.404532699e-34,
0.0315102674,
-0.0565402843,
-0.00143816,
0.0401598401,
0.0292071979,
-0.0182803404,
-0.0414857641,
-0.0435486026,
-0.0289294217,
-0.0535116903,
-0.0024405194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14128v1 | Dr.ICL: Demonstration-Retrieved In-context Learning | 2023-05-23T14:55:25 | 2023-05-23T14:55:25 | Man Luo, Xin Xu, Zhuyun Dai, Panupong Pasupat, Mehran Kazemi, Chitta Baral, Vaiva Imbrasaite, Vincent Y Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL), teaching a large language model (LLM) to perform a
task with few-shot demonstrations rather than adjusting the model parameters,
has emerged as a strong paradigm for using LLMs. While early studies primarily
used a fixed or random set of demonstrations for all test queries, recent
research suggests that retrieving semantically similar demonstrations to the
input from a pool of available demonstrations results in better performance.
This work expands the applicability of retrieval-based ICL approaches by
demonstrating that even simple word-overlap similarity measures such as BM25
outperform randomly selected demonstrations. Furthermore, we extend the success
of retrieval-based ICL to instruction-finetuned LLMs as well as
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. For instruction-finetuned LLMs, we find that
although a model has already seen the training data at training time,
retrieving demonstrations from the training data at test time yields better
results compared to using no demonstrations or random demonstrations. Last but
not least, we train a task-specific demonstration retriever that outperforms
off-the-shelf retrievers. | [
0.0106244488,
0.0410820544,
0.0000219857,
0.0380111411,
-0.0546672828,
-0.0029362873,
0.0128670372,
0.0134254089,
-0.0082479231,
-0.0485834815,
-0.0535199232,
-0.0571933202,
-0.0206120443,
-0.0341471583,
0.0455673859,
-0.0430710055,
0.0250565391,
-0.0238327142,
-0.0240916107,
0.019651847,
-0.018615609,
0.0092126606,
-0.0247246958,
0.0284372345,
-0.0116805211,
-0.0039737336,
-0.0127655258,
0.0165469162,
0.0005014147,
-0.0548008308,
0.0104761943,
0.0363779701,
0.0679982826,
0.0187977646,
0.000001997,
-0.0520483963,
-0.020640688,
0.0164560843,
-0.0328818746,
-0.0018202546,
0.0722928643,
0.0362890027,
0.0184774902,
0.044875361,
-0.0461768769,
-0.0164686572,
-0.0097286832,
0.0407689214,
0.0136220064,
0.0875527263,
0.0082643246,
0.0098726936,
-0.0050251847,
-0.0312861241,
0.0302744042,
-0.0287156794,
0.02458697,
-0.0106641287,
0.0579454638,
0.0377269462,
-0.0257881694,
0.0380998366,
0.031925533,
0.0279459823,
-0.0473440178,
0.040142823,
-0.044087626,
0.0165981017,
-0.0066863867,
0.0345913656,
0.0030392383,
-0.0254701246,
0.004445951,
0.0060491897,
0.0105548594,
0.0158350319,
-0.0654864386,
0.0123676509,
0.0169734824,
0.025676854,
-0.0134875756,
0.0154705681,
0.0193517357,
0.013735272,
-0.0338398591,
0.0141903078,
-0.0018712946,
-0.067265518,
0.0115912734,
-0.0032811125,
0.0110969692,
-0.0103241568,
-0.0375947692,
0.017562408,
-0.0722870529,
0.0437754914,
-0.0143031282,
-0.0533521399,
0.0338399559,
0.0055400385,
0.0627373978,
0.0190375634,
-0.0333492495,
0.0477226004,
-0.0265126843,
0.0628661811,
0.0183372963,
0.070959188,
-0.0391760543,
0.0040988177,
-0.0727152824,
0.0086888028,
-0.0493348576,
0.0335797668,
-0.005999337,
-0.0196724795,
0.0091253296,
0.031442076,
-0.0298044905,
0.0056709726,
-0.0185451936,
-0.0154267978,
-0.0463167652,
-0.0079380553,
-0.0071569486,
0.0043791854,
0.0040482781,
0.0379964337,
0.0166910589,
-0.0519492887,
-0.0351203047,
-0.0019620315,
0.0133212907,
-0.0174567904,
0.0312146042,
0.0339238904,
-0.0461412743,
-0.1074932218,
-0.018410001,
-0.0051187165,
0.0144365942,
-0.0468611233,
-0.009634411,
-0.0793849975,
0.0338327475,
-0.0076237144,
0.0143614914,
-0.0241621304,
0.0133170029,
0.0457131714,
-0.0067178071,
0.0492042117,
0.0308188219,
0.0354861096,
0.0229842756,
0.0054099336,
-0.0219929349,
0.078345485,
0.0000255984,
0.0043440997,
0.0298335254,
0.0459371544,
0.0166252311,
0.0356115401,
0.0441632308,
0.0323809423,
-0.0504488125,
0.0120504424,
0.0212549083,
0.0449200086,
0.0094070565,
0.0499223396,
-0.0344704613,
0.0324520431,
0.0452599041,
0.0612813942,
-0.002994135,
-0.06735342,
0.0365546457,
0.0596544407,
0.0072785043,
-0.0119459145,
-0.0506407656,
-0.0166267399,
-0.0194647443,
0.0306062046,
0.046314925,
-0.0144777289,
-0.0350505114,
-0.0035069284,
-0.003201047,
-0.0021808022,
0.0139248827,
0.0587489083,
0.0736821294,
0.0264498238,
-0.074377194,
0.0070904363,
0.0283910781,
-0.0163492635,
0.020096371,
-0.0578290783,
0.0013995228,
0.0264450777,
0.060155265,
-0.0213094112,
-0.0080624679,
-0.0085268728,
0.0566263273,
0.0264667608,
0.0067291977,
-0.0247525554,
-0.0181711763,
-0.0369893573,
-0.0364794955,
-0.0257071648,
0.0230889916,
-0.0076329093,
0.0590411164,
0.018119771,
0.0194186103,
-0.0649435669,
-0.0401532985,
0.0478438996,
-0.0310372598,
-0.0541330725,
-0.0075934585,
0.007751191,
0.0109914262,
0.0097175008,
-0.0178260598,
0.0107674906,
0.0650669858,
-0.0118766902,
0.0329172909,
-0.0326042213,
-0.0486959629,
-0.073690325,
0.0097833825,
-0.0008617415,
-0.022230532,
0.0160824042,
-0.0347211398,
-0.0149500752,
-0.0467144512,
-0.0087741613,
0.0562530421,
-0.0418393463,
0.0237040948,
-0.0146296676,
-0.0395229012,
-0.0567497537,
0.05062842,
-0.0051709064,
0.0374483354,
0.0356236547,
0.0397971794,
-0.0267842077,
-0.0667189509,
-0.0399214588,
-0.0190655664,
-0.0075237607,
0.0479087383,
0.0059638787,
0.0495070145,
-0.0552145988,
-0.0179072898,
-0.1023881212,
0.0184875615,
-0.0392264202,
-0.0041863313,
-0.0151331369,
-0.008538479,
-0.0288845859,
-0.0276972186,
-0.0167640932,
-0.0415600501,
-0.0000717417,
0.0250049923,
-0.0145515837,
0.0456553251,
-0.006969823,
-0.017879786,
0.0071440097,
0.0100574316,
0.0594009124,
-0.0375673957,
0.0253537297,
-0.0257825386,
0.0543758906,
0.0144297406,
0.0217508711,
-0.0245029852,
0.0269379746,
0.0450779162,
-0.0436374806,
0.0205208492,
0.0590366013,
0.0233382192,
0.0180455614,
0.0263057984,
0.009432124,
-0.0995857567,
0.0101874722,
-0.0226072501,
-0.0468561873,
-0.0345033966,
0.0103923557,
0.02730445,
0.0096514486,
0.0142659908,
-0.0053684046,
-0.0405928418,
-0.0139171444,
-0.0212890487,
-0.0299608838,
-0.0661511347,
-0.0003237822,
-0.0411323979,
-0.0293808095,
-0.033350151,
-0.0498959906,
0.0725768134,
-0.0238047149,
0.0069440375,
-0.0399832912,
-0.0147114322,
-0.0132547459,
0.0614998676,
-0.0248883236,
0.007012161,
-0.0327676088,
-0.033314459,
-0.0554355718,
0.0050279195,
-0.0223299675,
-0.0644179061,
0.0591965578,
-0.0407119282,
0.0195597913,
0.0242938604,
-0.0474960133,
-0.0775348246,
-0.0070383204,
0.0134413857,
0.0191065054,
-0.0216398258,
0.0338281468,
-0.0286616422,
-0.0372708887,
0.0399144217,
0.0364910178,
0.0116829015,
-0.0098552052,
-0.0138380863,
-0.0035215414,
0.040979974,
0.0081470953,
-0.0431069396,
-0.0654849336,
-0.0032040433,
0.0227364041,
0.1049397513,
-0.0237106699,
-0.0059122089,
-0.0130392397,
0.0182125382,
-0.0150863854,
0.0335271843,
0.0643227845,
0.031709075,
-0.0563880503,
-0.0378434286,
0.0856949463,
0.0101119429,
-0.0654037595,
-0.017574003,
0.0155559126,
-0.0073494022,
0.0310523119,
0.0489365682,
-0.0569586307,
-0.0126806442,
0.0141112991,
0.0282140318,
0.0152617451,
-0.0023929472,
-0.0198125653,
-0.1637384892,
0.0153863085,
0.0134783238,
-0.0520406254,
-0.0293683372,
-0.0460031629,
0.012249033,
0.0284646954,
0.0426306352,
0.0452347621,
-0.0393493176,
0.0015387747,
0.0364836492,
0.0667651072,
-0.1147408411,
0.0240230765,
-0.0565819107,
0.0230385084,
0.0354660749,
0.0019702737,
0.0052502756,
-0.0251833741,
0.0136118531,
-0.0250100009,
0.0105275661,
-0.0129768746,
0.0335546583,
-0.0415620245,
-0.0029029502,
0.0066332952,
0.0371755213,
0.0093168644,
-0.0140234102,
0.0032016723,
0.0743841082,
-0.0327062607,
0.0139251519,
-0.0186922122,
-0.0523631349,
0.0451213531,
0.0720365494,
0.0245774221,
-0.0283872932,
0.0273504369,
0.0308545288,
-0.0200306345,
-0.0007606238,
-0.0043979986,
0.0078543006,
-0.0140030263,
0.0570179857,
-0.0436103009,
-0.0346433744,
0.0422776379,
0.0698617548,
-0.0002459801,
0.0417845435,
-0.0252661165,
0.000558976,
-0.0572394133,
0.0486997999,
-0.0403292887,
0.0304436982,
-0.0834153667,
-0.0313807838,
0.0386634395,
-0.0324068703,
-0.0242719818,
0.0118714338,
-0.072719641,
-0.0512162969,
-0.0267585348,
0.0429423638,
0.0112264454,
0.0604802929,
0.0106778527,
-0.0075111561,
0.0621564314,
0.064926669,
-0.0187459122,
0.0223779008,
-0.0096220588,
-0.0262656752,
-0.0097852498,
0.0260495953,
-0.0657812357,
-0.0067911465,
0.0155750914,
0.0691148043,
-0.0165712349,
-0.016031649,
0.0391643345,
-0.0021740911,
0.0744445696,
-0.0043128063,
-0.0324970223,
-0.0422086306,
0.0228205379,
-0.0077953469,
-0.0092425384,
-0.0224857926,
-0.0095297154,
-0.007451585,
-0.0058808206,
-0.004314302,
-0.014888254,
0.0100832293,
0.0497349016,
-0.0300656408,
-0.0063364706,
-0.0004554445,
-0.0357377268,
0.03700234,
0.0256915856,
-0.026164161,
-0.0133196143,
-0.0045466106,
0.034553986,
-0.005464734,
0.0672092959,
0.0440584272,
-0.0062563634,
-0.0204594582,
0.0219768826,
-0.0327005275,
-0.0226954706,
-0.0474723913,
0.0399868637,
0.034941975,
-0.0338237472,
0.0060700863,
-0.0340185091,
0.0072823619,
-0.0183627252,
-0.0081183333,
-0.044907894,
-0.0452564731,
0.0357482098,
0.0376521125,
0.0205919407,
0.0412696861,
0.0662142336,
-0.0062360289,
0.0355973877,
-0.0107142404,
0.0137378955,
-0.0324342698,
-0.0074976915,
0.0897540972,
0.0332336538,
-0.0141641162,
0.0016364921,
-0.0197312757,
-0.0545713753,
-0.0087315021,
0.0128976759,
-0.0395825841,
-0.0206646938,
0.0629036352,
0.0806632936,
-0.0344422795,
-0.0151128769,
-0.0217550769,
-0.0206601638,
0.0345065407,
-0.071717523,
-0.0261339117,
-6.012014062e-33,
-0.0208005551,
-0.0171874836,
0.0522413477,
-0.0224247798,
-0.0259833597,
0.0222231243,
-0.0307456627,
-0.0144425854,
-0.0096919145,
0.0056690434,
-0.0260937009,
-0.0122811394,
0.0030506225,
0.0322492346,
0.0176306311,
0.0018742037,
0.0423293896,
-0.0086016338,
-0.0119938292,
0.0137094408,
0.0189865418,
0.0630867332,
0.0340263732,
-0.0569231026,
0.021073943,
-0.0140391765,
0.0156558529,
0.0153137427,
-0.0239950269,
0.0454954989,
-0.0068074921,
0.0472374447,
0.0149096511,
-0.0281241499,
-0.028301144,
0.0139596863,
-0.0596122146,
-0.0368334167,
-0.0025201372,
-0.0064278576,
-0.0323294476,
0.0212552603,
0.0461987592,
-0.0373528711,
-0.0402192995,
0.0220013391,
0.0156812388,
0.0014858131,
-0.0428338647,
-0.0270940624,
-0.0280097798,
-0.0050471332,
0.0341624133,
-0.0545929037,
0.0386640504,
0.0194190573,
0.0018570328,
0.0025993637,
-0.0308713466,
0.0307137892,
0.0166038573,
0.0301583577,
0.0438964814,
0.0275434796,
0.0182772763,
0.0685673803,
-0.0076254639,
0.0017677416,
0.0472578444,
-0.0625170991,
0.0783226192,
0.0488620996,
-0.0033929907,
0.0366824828,
0.0207505822,
0.012732096,
-0.0234667473,
0.0308562499,
0.0127532538,
0.0168458093,
0.0449324958,
0.0225137286,
-0.0737687051,
-0.0259263851,
-0.0442611836,
0.0401783474,
-0.0288711414,
-0.0290755872,
0.0760371163,
0.0576984435,
0.0003251503,
-0.0131336069,
0.0562304929,
-0.0405717678,
-0.0474704243,
0.0408768505,
-0.0097658709,
0.0133346245,
-0.0291797221,
-0.0089441072,
-0.0538094193,
-0.0681983307,
0.0228268765,
-0.0095677217,
-0.0163141694,
-0.0040373476,
0.0320283361,
0.0273479763,
-0.0659141988,
0.0086725913,
-0.0223602206,
0.0108509976,
0.0123649053,
-0.0513861254,
0.0475647934,
0.0346417986,
-0.0014170719,
0.0603345409,
0.0165741388,
-0.0998981372,
-0.0159907863,
-0.0136786047,
-0.0443273373,
-0.0190437119,
-0.0149077233,
0.0332587138,
-0.0228387062,
0.0287411604,
0.0159070306,
-0.0242787823,
0.0038059643,
0.0310580265,
2.73e-7,
-0.0013705282,
0.042824097,
-0.0053492654,
0.032848414,
-0.010563584,
0.0118430853,
-0.0519109815,
0.0320358276,
0.0389462151,
-0.0119109461,
0.0319255963,
0.0305819418,
0.0524590909,
0.0138962837,
-0.1108592972,
-0.0211214125,
-0.0451523103,
-0.0121373469,
-0.0705439448,
-0.0256304406,
0.0370364599,
0.0697845072,
0.0194541477,
0.0075412137,
0.0014742701,
-0.0577075891,
0.0640814751,
-0.0441889241,
-0.003755098,
-0.0053781401,
-0.0239431541,
0.0159617253,
0.030780673,
0.0339299776,
-0.0127263321,
0.0482720807,
0.0028521877,
0.0239155702,
0.0103788339,
-0.0121641522,
0.0083847055,
0.0004196429,
-0.0190563221,
-0.0575510338,
0.0504095107,
-0.0861238763,
0.0224563498,
0.0041679684,
0.0017520139,
-0.0425708741,
0.0007586459,
0.0044201235,
-0.0131647065,
0.0131844385,
0.0125956414,
0.0041017295,
-0.0048013423,
-0.0816613808,
0.0025781111,
0.0319878906,
-0.0512209609,
-0.02661057,
-0.0320407636,
0.0283316299,
-0.0445802845,
-0.058492247,
-0.0004367925,
2.40809913e-34,
0.0254893266,
-0.0005744174,
0.0228621401,
0.0389749445,
0.0069242972,
-0.0020265579,
-0.0190168489,
0.0334496573,
0.0099177388,
-0.0662201494,
-0.0152672864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14126v1 | To Copy Rather Than Memorize: A Vertical Learning Paradigm for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-05-23T14:53:20 | 2023-05-23T14:53:20 | Rui Li, Xu Chen, Chaozhuo Li, Yanming Shen, Jianan Zhao, Yujing Wang, Weihao Han, Hao Sun, Weiwei Deng, Qi Zhang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Embedding models have shown great power in knowledge graph completion (KGC)
task. By learning structural constraints for each training triple, these
methods implicitly memorize intrinsic relation rules to infer missing links.
However, this paper points out that the multi-hop relation rules are hard to be
reliably memorized due to the inherent deficiencies of such implicit
memorization strategy, making embedding models underperform in predicting links
between distant entity pairs. To alleviate this problem, we present Vertical
Learning Paradigm (VLP), which extends embedding models by allowing to
explicitly copy target information from related factual triples for more
accurate prediction. Rather than solely relying on the implicit memory, VLP
directly provides additional cues to improve the generalization ability of
embedding models, especially making the distant link prediction significantly
easier. Moreover, we also propose a novel relative distance based negative
sampling technique (ReD) for more effective optimization. Experiments
demonstrate the validity and generality of our proposals on two standard
benchmarks. Our code is available at https://github.com/rui9812/VLP. | [
0.0302223079,
-0.0021304789,
-0.0217383876,
0.0140150236,
-0.0040041967,
-0.0216524042,
-0.0562359504,
0.0142021282,
0.0849222913,
-0.0127843898,
-0.0052966066,
0.0313944928,
0.0014466777,
-0.0080357995,
0.0484251864,
-0.0254507251,
0.0177641939,
0.017895475,
-0.0226370264,
-0.0310579166,
-0.0242901184,
0.0133585213,
0.0158167407,
-0.0283325743,
-0.0256139468,
0.0156034287,
-0.0114708701,
-0.0072134184,
0.0065789493,
-0.026303092,
-0.0182947554,
0.0095677869,
0.0092377495,
-0.0487717688,
0.0000019543,
-0.0262173004,
-0.0178225841,
-0.022790784,
-0.0258523133,
-0.0267884172,
-0.0440133885,
-0.030792851,
0.0680282786,
-0.0112557607,
-0.0382632427,
-0.0340061858,
0.0133398101,
0.1077897325,
0.0041785659,
0.0186367836,
-0.0150061715,
-0.0159813445,
0.0299316701,
-0.0360810943,
0.0147079788,
-0.030222429,
0.0497906096,
0.06153984,
-0.0208014157,
0.0135155441,
-0.0229323562,
0.0214961972,
0.0167605188,
0.0269268416,
0.0652946383,
0.048901666,
0.0126820616,
0.0267456453,
0.0447690375,
0.1153457016,
0.0131183844,
0.0130040478,
0.009835721,
0.0164145194,
0.0276650377,
0.0408149101,
-0.0285916049,
-0.0541080125,
-0.0457098037,
-0.0081354547,
-0.050410822,
-0.0217626188,
0.0499127358,
-0.0102198059,
0.0170504525,
0.0228184033,
-0.0094097806,
-0.0500199385,
0.0220092498,
0.0183079168,
0.0143908821,
-0.00689189,
0.0408484451,
0.0054634623,
-0.000359458,
0.0264669862,
-0.0117184985,
0.0296188369,
0.015065142,
-0.0093851918,
-0.0090243807,
0.013929992,
0.0349708162,
0.053466171,
-0.0965090841,
-0.0102721304,
-0.0190995522,
-0.0068476587,
-0.0241520237,
-0.0083919959,
-0.0604551695,
0.0051127141,
-0.0179345869,
0.0782850459,
0.0050970614,
-0.0155200558,
-0.0319090076,
0.0004341578,
-0.0495366566,
0.0433892235,
-0.0114625087,
0.0313682258,
0.0177890901,
0.0039151637,
-0.0310764499,
-0.0017685639,
-0.0391414911,
0.0179003216,
-0.0582205988,
0.0549171865,
-0.0150660668,
-0.0275237244,
0.0117371473,
-0.0105570639,
0.0131604737,
0.0748030394,
0.026252998,
-0.0068471166,
-0.048605185,
-0.067381151,
0.0354882777,
-0.0433746167,
0.0198997669,
-0.0400851481,
0.0407865793,
0.0100153526,
-0.019395588,
-0.0234910753,
0.0378540531,
-0.0118582975,
-0.1017220169,
0.040685147,
-0.0102648959,
-0.0257801898,
-0.0273313001,
0.0024843384,
-0.0417932384,
0.0338482261,
-0.013510121,
0.0163958501,
0.0267871562,
0.0386072546,
-0.0408714339,
-0.0106131928,
0.0876328871,
0.0009151215,
0.0091693634,
-0.0089193508,
-0.0081562586,
0.0302203074,
0.0424055159,
0.0222240295,
-0.0526019074,
-0.0167320967,
0.0269284099,
-0.0036898525,
0.0221450459,
0.0284418315,
0.0448000096,
-0.0059183738,
-0.0003050964,
0.0043232185,
-0.0482499599,
0.0475045368,
-0.015576141,
0.0139769325,
0.003727772,
0.0120971575,
-0.0192395672,
0.010240132,
0.0436113849,
-0.0221357048,
0.0166937578,
0.0284627862,
0.0615154803,
0.0102505004,
-0.0174678415,
0.0653837323,
0.0477467142,
0.00972242,
0.0066794748,
0.0600543842,
0.0289020631,
0.0392293148,
0.0440903269,
-0.0115865851,
-0.0203407947,
-0.0133269802,
-0.0279887319,
-0.0133062303,
0.0241134055,
-0.0472214222,
-0.0211868845,
-0.0285981633,
-0.0928001255,
0.0349449627,
-0.0126489,
0.0043129977,
0.0607959218,
0.0311588943,
0.0390409566,
-0.0914822668,
0.0471016951,
0.0157160722,
-0.0612111017,
0.0348160155,
0.008173774,
0.0584660172,
-0.0024317089,
0.037626978,
0.0411862954,
-0.0237459652,
0.0498364344,
-0.0261678677,
-0.0791054666,
-0.0185716245,
-0.0275221113,
-0.039763052,
0.0430906601,
-0.0276515,
0.0185863655,
-0.0085506001,
-0.0047742133,
-0.0382236429,
0.0564795621,
-0.0108233895,
0.0798727423,
-0.008153907,
-0.0270006564,
0.0230641142,
-0.0183038376,
-0.0059231613,
0.0893930644,
-0.0282033589,
0.0163501017,
0.0245748181,
-0.0167167652,
0.0216293689,
-0.0041477056,
-0.0074407198,
-0.0357102007,
0.0092030466,
-0.0146494471,
0.0122238854,
-0.0248649195,
-0.077026248,
0.007182295,
-0.0519326031,
0.0305808187,
0.0314106792,
-0.0198731869,
-0.045014713,
0.0008363404,
0.0261303168,
-0.0443437546,
-0.0064700502,
0.0202958863,
-0.0774189457,
0.0133795384,
0.0096620759,
0.0106691597,
-0.0199537054,
0.0172618981,
-0.0283305552,
-0.0265831128,
0.036168471,
-0.0380073562,
-0.0140559804,
-0.0245622881,
0.0256522223,
-0.0646067411,
0.0172044244,
-0.0113803716,
0.0376208276,
-0.0499052294,
0.0070365486,
0.0383281708,
0.0141024385,
-0.0535020232,
-0.0314334966,
0.0092383344,
0.0289963726,
-0.0533598736,
0.0160712805,
-0.0448637977,
0.033061374,
-0.0052947295,
0.0183675531,
-0.0810404047,
-0.0074319122,
0.014828667,
-0.024309475,
-0.0695085377,
0.0073944479,
0.0223492794,
0.0093609998,
-0.0260757077,
0.0082078399,
0.0341406353,
-0.0333901867,
-0.0408316441,
-0.0006085752,
0.0670633465,
0.0145769557,
0.0253802016,
0.0339256041,
0.0264732782,
-0.0093738027,
0.0810234547,
0.0207473319,
0.0092618912,
0.0196173508,
-0.033649452,
-0.0342798792,
0.010736566,
0.0332963429,
-0.0173664317,
0.0239743628,
0.0093377782,
0.0168114286,
0.0212605186,
-0.0210030582,
-0.0400916412,
0.008583392,
-0.0045832875,
0.0159279089,
-0.04084865,
-0.0065377341,
0.0126754185,
-0.0121927448,
0.0298672989,
-0.0112723261,
0.0113932267,
-0.0432442762,
-0.013702739,
0.0308752656,
0.0476168096,
-0.0396280028,
0.0275246017,
0.0237816367,
0.0012852894,
0.0611814149,
0.0427420437,
-0.01543268,
0.022544587,
0.0266019329,
-0.008212273,
-0.0196392965,
-0.0395427682,
-0.0118226847,
-0.01174914,
-0.0149047105,
0.031158587,
0.0774485543,
0.0142726898,
-0.035705518,
0.0225000158,
0.0067128073,
0.0255214758,
0.0618774407,
0.0085927891,
-0.0742946565,
-0.0058064461,
-0.0026077442,
0.0182560682,
0.0231341682,
-0.1096404344,
0.0181326456,
-0.1034030393,
-0.0252293851,
0.0067439913,
-0.0138740102,
-0.0383650437,
-0.0762410387,
0.0222453326,
0.0002918854,
-0.0518163405,
0.001615023,
-0.0331902429,
-0.0008465131,
-0.0137753608,
-0.0357267037,
-0.0122637004,
0.0376565084,
-0.0694823936,
0.0425920375,
-0.0262498967,
0.0260043573,
0.0183474347,
-0.0017346538,
-0.0265623946,
-0.0075530559,
-0.01631427,
-0.0182248484,
0.0910244137,
-0.009082268,
0.0005898923,
-0.0254976768,
0.0174056515,
-0.058364857,
-0.0011407913,
-0.0150833949,
0.1160050631,
0.0123455347,
-0.0292214192,
-0.001703024,
-0.0039952286,
-0.0020784934,
0.0531322844,
-0.0198819861,
0.0148662273,
0.0031681256,
0.0132753141,
0.0527384877,
-0.0160573144,
0.030759275,
0.0415521264,
-0.0794000253,
0.0230068155,
-0.049194552,
-0.0670926347,
0.0529351607,
0.052923549,
0.0270455331,
0.0631920546,
0.0322161242,
-0.0357881263,
-0.0541401319,
-0.0166757312,
-0.0397612639,
0.0125330091,
0.0671310723,
-0.0051550665,
0.00926702,
-0.0160755124,
-0.019555036,
-0.0463541932,
-0.0397235043,
-0.0168828163,
-0.0622328334,
0.0382623561,
0.0024086563,
0.1039969549,
-0.0126205897,
-0.0018920643,
0.0468535125,
0.0238939207,
-0.0229907203,
0.0215336215,
0.014989784,
-0.0519801229,
-0.0009383584,
0.0583409145,
-0.0782625899,
-0.0291452911,
0.0109331785,
0.0613907538,
-0.0350341536,
-0.0033341295,
0.012112298,
0.0041594519,
0.0257869549,
0.0143515216,
0.0038015603,
-0.0204607211,
0.0156607442,
-0.0187345073,
-0.0160060469,
-0.0446992442,
0.0094087748,
0.0196610391,
0.0218101386,
0.007106646,
-0.0700080097,
0.0290121697,
0.0484661497,
-0.0160288084,
-0.0497203693,
0.008157691,
-0.0125526274,
0.0402860381,
-0.000920557,
-0.044900164,
0.0097282007,
0.03143261,
0.0029216583,
-0.0472623333,
0.0170298405,
0.0167863499,
-0.0049789385,
-0.0391691662,
-0.0267953891,
-0.0272299536,
0.0185526907,
-0.0017251584,
0.0152488761,
0.0744551942,
-0.0281632971,
0.0219192374,
-0.0237637609,
-0.010509382,
0.0091434885,
0.0108707706,
-0.0424156152,
-0.0490889512,
0.0216874164,
0.0037206395,
-0.0121731311,
0.0618716031,
0.076932542,
-0.0138852932,
0.0996028557,
-0.0427602232,
-0.0277455468,
-0.0425732359,
-0.0122509887,
0.0564630032,
0.0386655629,
-0.0042244545,
0.0170238651,
-0.0422402397,
-0.0864931941,
0.0463333949,
-0.0450642668,
-0.0551550239,
0.0063977949,
0.0129287802,
0.0293521043,
0.0359389745,
-0.066474624,
-0.0394365191,
0.0112160509,
-0.0152094169,
-0.0155309606,
-0.0006006869,
-5.87518652e-33,
-0.0149567919,
-0.0276879612,
0.020276038,
0.0210113861,
-0.0857221186,
0.0129143558,
-0.0151417442,
-0.0179287307,
-0.0320615619,
0.0305520687,
-0.0153841199,
-0.013783738,
-0.0110573145,
0.0016587519,
0.007350578,
-0.0116558867,
0.0285593886,
0.0239106324,
0.0485791452,
0.0269434862,
0.0369012244,
0.0520282984,
0.0369082168,
-0.0870277062,
-0.0043995273,
-0.0150220916,
0.0232941173,
0.0290384032,
0.0389280729,
0.0438393392,
-0.0086873937,
0.0148290917,
0.0137847513,
-0.0136275264,
-0.0063650347,
-0.0364040807,
-0.1659972519,
-0.0459585674,
0.0032883936,
-0.0061817672,
-0.0116074244,
-0.0035028446,
0.0310013313,
-0.0018184686,
0.0528135709,
-0.0535415001,
0.0259066988,
-0.0361235999,
-0.1099487692,
-0.0443686768,
-0.017831482,
0.0194751043,
0.0319305807,
0.0284980237,
-0.0149387587,
0.0046274718,
0.0419106372,
-0.0378292054,
-0.0894953832,
-0.0117759453,
-0.0501256362,
-0.0147495922,
-0.0108866263,
-0.0093095526,
0.0208468381,
0.061810568,
0.0084564947,
-0.0242456794,
-0.0229286589,
0.0002007437,
-0.0132006742,
0.0266592689,
-0.0327767432,
0.0216439888,
-0.0151340663,
-0.0338564441,
-0.0792028606,
0.0038315847,
0.0137563748,
0.050914757,
-0.0084310006,
0.0098564206,
-0.0435526632,
-0.0307851844,
-0.0440054946,
-0.0088171279,
-0.0061978768,
-0.0687239915,
0.0042945012,
0.0490558706,
-0.0061999271,
0.0235513542,
-0.0149819683,
-0.0511101261,
-0.0241026301,
0.0579529554,
0.0171134137,
0.0023864384,
-0.0058525358,
-0.0006886143,
-0.0465295017,
-0.0217748489,
0.0040066354,
-0.0542441197,
0.0160698984,
0.0330203399,
0.0642627254,
-0.0004364812,
-0.0476809368,
-0.0219379645,
0.0068462724,
-0.0343402959,
0.009955938,
-0.0307110418,
0.0467608906,
0.0490125977,
0.0031562629,
0.027059745,
0.0833946094,
0.0222699996,
-0.0189662464,
0.014888105,
0.0443439595,
-0.0068852589,
0.013127028,
-0.0270427708,
-0.0353807099,
-0.0161474682,
0.0101064723,
-0.0821012631,
-0.0192116145,
-0.0192618389,
2.679e-7,
-0.0096526947,
-0.0027625749,
0.0295874793,
0.0243423823,
-0.0241656862,
0.0307484902,
0.034738481,
0.0279832948,
-0.0088506006,
0.0108254896,
0.0235326607,
-0.0064397897,
-0.027307963,
0.0370215103,
-0.0898105055,
0.0091995895,
-0.0177374091,
-0.0715409443,
-0.0143066654,
-0.0254212506,
0.0266131368,
0.0484258197,
0.0788135827,
0.0108504323,
-0.0065608532,
-0.0514906645,
0.0767019019,
0.0126825254,
-0.012264628,
0.000815142,
0.0279696826,
0.0157975778,
-0.0229393728,
0.0773415118,
-0.0206157602,
0.027264975,
0.019249158,
0.0261950586,
0.0066256481,
-0.0065973331,
-0.0283133816,
-0.0327071771,
0.0347169749,
0.0038619,
0.0652568564,
-0.0509035103,
0.0009186532,
0.0618018657,
-0.0406897701,
0.0118480632,
-0.0061906232,
0.0436734073,
0.0085292468,
0.0060550119,
0.0081180008,
0.0387188382,
0.001563685,
-0.0695372,
0.0257119369,
0.0385530852,
-0.0080346186,
-0.0431228019,
0.0353960134,
-0.0430026613,
0.0243129749,
-0.027723426,
0.0089302594,
2.392338782e-34,
-0.0065176394,
0.0045897509,
0.0178145822,
0.0027763827,
0.0159678031,
-0.0790563226,
0.0084946379,
0.0024692779,
0.0381263047,
-0.0643230826,
0.0060551851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14124v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14124v3 | When Does Monolingual Data Help Multilingual Translation: The Role of Domain and Model Scale | 2023-05-23T14:48:42 | 2024-03-30T08:49:04 | Christos Baziotis, Biao Zhang, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual machine translation (MMT), trained on a mixture of parallel and
monolingual data, is key for improving translation in low-resource language
pairs. However, the literature offers conflicting results on the performance of
different methods of including monolingual data. To resolve this, we examine
how denoising autoencoding (DAE) and backtranslation (BT) impact MMT under
different data conditions and model scales. Unlike prior studies, we use a
realistic dataset of 100 translation directions and consider many domain
combinations of monolingual and test data. We find that monolingual data
generally helps MMT, but models are surprisingly brittle to domain mismatches,
especially at smaller model scales. BT is beneficial when the parallel,
monolingual, and test data sources are similar but can be detrimental
otherwise, while DAE is less effective than previously reported. Next, we
analyze the impact of scale (from 90M to 1.6B parameters) and find it is
important for both methods, particularly DAE. As scale increases, DAE
transitions from underperforming the parallel-only baseline at 90M to
converging with BT performance at 1.6B, and even surpassing it in low-resource.
These results offer new insights into how to best use monolingual data in MMT. | [
-0.0187802315,
0.0478478745,
-0.0200826079,
0.0336464681,
-0.0341681801,
0.0200513564,
0.0756818652,
0.0170121398,
-0.0606524982,
-0.0146442503,
-0.0218358561,
-0.0680478141,
0.063425459,
0.0072920718,
0.0134225208,
-0.0387943015,
0.0111036059,
-0.0370933861,
-0.0361321568,
-0.016257694,
-0.03974583,
0.0332888402,
0.0229872055,
0.008602296,
-0.0124484031,
0.0053447532,
0.0191635285,
0.0489101335,
0.0376766026,
-0.0030438823,
-0.0303231869,
0.0253949333,
0.0350097455,
0.0589053668,
0.0000024181,
-0.0332263336,
-0.0300856177,
0.0036698277,
-0.0001649032,
0.0071623423,
0.0366948955,
-0.0795840845,
-0.0046407687,
0.0197400469,
0.0083002057,
-0.0588112138,
0.025749065,
-0.0248062294,
0.0339916311,
0.0565845482,
-0.0263192095,
-0.0183813013,
0.0072492501,
-0.0618017428,
-0.0809296295,
-0.0302057285,
-0.0107079037,
0.0371306837,
-0.0553693324,
0.0109234909,
-0.0150369117,
0.0723835677,
0.0086350348,
0.0072124498,
-0.049472928,
0.0059961355,
0.0282280538,
-0.0680785477,
0.012790042,
0.0519696549,
-0.0475515686,
0.009384851,
-0.0278672166,
-0.0263783317,
-0.0066209347,
0.0260217916,
-0.0062978002,
0.0202377792,
0.0203804895,
0.0015917382,
-0.0117483409,
0.0353860073,
0.0683171228,
-0.0302642137,
-0.0392885543,
-0.0294660609,
0.0340715908,
-0.0149735641,
0.0034619581,
0.0101643391,
-0.0044796774,
0.0112092383,
0.0660963133,
-0.046646677,
0.0174245853,
-0.0025302847,
-0.0184058025,
-0.0847350657,
0.0109945731,
-0.0468889438,
0.0101713249,
0.0747661889,
-0.0215715691,
0.0106635848,
-0.0149433976,
0.0306914579,
-0.0239995737,
-0.0141842226,
-0.0934413001,
-0.0375489555,
0.0291564334,
0.0358477905,
-0.0334393047,
-0.0297710821,
-0.0647830442,
0.0077421363,
-0.018836299,
-0.0194698051,
0.0206264872,
-0.0331003964,
0.0110735325,
-0.0285459198,
-0.0979044437,
-0.0310023576,
0.0478096008,
0.1058472618,
-0.0548031442,
-0.0035467206,
0.0236211643,
-0.036262054,
-0.0237511992,
-0.0021075516,
0.0008884104,
-0.0523114726,
0.0066929725,
0.102662921,
-0.0068216319,
0.0066093295,
-0.0119376155,
0.0149215506,
-0.0174722914,
-0.0673357248,
0.0004722743,
-0.0685045943,
0.0667358115,
0.0376558714,
0.0530688986,
-0.0432111509,
-0.0106817726,
-0.0466540605,
-0.0373910889,
0.0830029845,
0.0027680106,
0.0088528721,
0.0696139261,
0.0053092912,
0.0130761517,
0.0896245986,
0.0386222005,
-0.0074275094,
0.0374520496,
-0.0091905892,
-0.0671736524,
0.04843086,
0.0173577797,
0.0625711456,
-0.0378231965,
-0.0132211577,
0.0135881174,
0.0290548094,
0.0461480021,
0.0315820612,
-0.0410694256,
-0.0041653188,
0.0411688834,
0.0139317578,
0.0059241909,
0.0002535835,
0.0256876331,
0.0031987303,
-0.0482201502,
0.0196180586,
0.0169218387,
-0.0075554261,
0.0316084549,
-0.0069494927,
0.0818479732,
0.0746154189,
-0.0169349983,
-0.0166800302,
-0.0149038536,
-0.0235217754,
0.023662515,
-0.020010937,
0.042787198,
0.0301952213,
-0.0279486552,
0.0173332058,
0.0060375524,
-0.0410376377,
0.0178024489,
0.012370998,
-0.1078300476,
0.0002009351,
0.0239827689,
0.0490751415,
-0.0097713694,
-0.02238301,
-0.0140493298,
0.0566746928,
0.0517342761,
0.0189833026,
0.0550783947,
-0.0733855218,
-0.0244087353,
0.0118052457,
0.0055376934,
0.0429993607,
-0.0122107863,
0.0530697778,
0.0310034472,
-0.0538503155,
-0.0383821987,
0.0037925527,
-0.0449109972,
-0.014153095,
0.0452118367,
0.0251623709,
-0.0034296745,
0.0245339274,
-0.0166154467,
-0.0059354799,
0.0139472159,
-0.0204308052,
-0.0207738429,
0.0295422263,
-0.0730689168,
-0.0481815413,
0.0148917045,
-0.0042215283,
-0.0159844179,
0.0202414747,
0.013517282,
-0.0612210035,
0.007622018,
-0.0043439702,
-0.0250121821,
-0.0084704095,
0.0463313274,
-0.0249791909,
0.0200473927,
-0.0272818357,
0.0039919992,
-0.004689483,
0.0081279809,
0.0010587024,
-0.0217209458,
0.0664839968,
-0.0020064008,
-0.0279503334,
0.038977012,
0.0173013136,
0.0245755445,
0.0539243743,
0.0114847226,
0.0072865118,
0.0135526694,
-0.0168854576,
0.013540078,
-0.044579193,
0.0322157778,
0.0379813649,
0.0983373448,
0.0061132764,
-0.0088008186,
0.0138226943,
0.0235885903,
0.0077000097,
0.0417993069,
-0.0053573786,
0.0054700286,
0.0438016318,
-0.0130093284,
-0.0337812155,
0.0203507319,
0.0447171554,
0.0167189743,
-0.0103479596,
-0.0384351164,
0.0403934754,
-0.0280981939,
0.0022968675,
-0.0067333826,
-0.0678716376,
0.0130993016,
-0.006503976,
0.0501300544,
0.0042587835,
-0.060657151,
-0.0136280246,
0.0620595217,
-0.0034935225,
-0.0736161321,
0.0090298802,
0.0093197441,
-0.0025897659,
-0.0462235473,
-0.059767019,
-0.0036964722,
0.0701771304,
0.0188633613,
0.0020428994,
-0.0594990104,
-0.036372181,
0.0043272418,
-0.011502807,
-0.0045413286,
0.018286027,
0.0210662745,
0.0675301775,
-0.0047921678,
-0.0421252623,
0.0653043836,
-0.0043803528,
-0.0273872335,
-0.0544457324,
0.0187860969,
-0.011379377,
0.0220724363,
-0.0186624769,
0.0197715573,
-0.0462856591,
-0.0203189775,
-0.0138974162,
0.0226742812,
0.0283188391,
0.0197363738,
0.0308222119,
-0.0666478202,
-0.018200893,
-0.020849973,
-0.0511317737,
-0.0258791093,
0.0393602215,
0.0252232794,
-0.0072019906,
0.0440686196,
-0.0132464459,
-0.0822950676,
0.0065819509,
-0.0008189701,
0.0726451874,
-0.004075035,
0.0038219809,
0.0120932618,
0.0570505336,
-0.0014848111,
-0.0060699857,
0.0238329172,
-0.0640197694,
0.0319766514,
-0.0269674733,
0.0015183225,
-0.0445512161,
-0.0155646456,
-0.0202301126,
0.0508858636,
0.0043809335,
-0.0247511473,
-0.0135028064,
0.0536680222,
-0.034449257,
-0.0229035653,
0.0724671856,
-0.0093672974,
-0.0475265197,
-0.0160400104,
-0.0423757881,
0.0483446755,
0.0122641567,
-0.0135243395,
-0.0606361143,
-0.0146637438,
-0.0055132965,
0.0303499773,
0.05409915,
0.0375731848,
-0.0087147336,
-0.0698965341,
0.0015597084,
0.0424766205,
-0.0779020637,
-0.0469146408,
-0.0612782799,
-0.0452963859,
-0.0466026291,
0.0711728856,
-0.0230819862,
0.023447996,
-0.0201041587,
0.0065903096,
0.0406196862,
-0.0711276606,
-0.0251078997,
-0.0627805367,
0.0480472408,
0.0317593962,
0.0463616364,
-0.0189007726,
0.0074235983,
0.0493847094,
0.0441552885,
-0.0032032996,
-0.0283179544,
0.0336231515,
0.0096090641,
0.0034827476,
0.048050046,
-0.0176424626,
-0.0477739051,
0.0332142934,
0.0178307109,
0.0342876539,
-0.0097040273,
-0.0213115793,
0.0007478453,
-0.0407702588,
-0.0163796991,
0.0255854074,
0.008533976,
-0.0286293663,
-0.0026938929,
-0.0321444124,
0.0045925491,
-0.0624405928,
-0.0063228253,
-0.0034980897,
-0.0267300308,
-0.0574815422,
-0.043337781,
-0.0610804632,
-0.0177030843,
0.0131031228,
0.0311396886,
0.0031480924,
-0.0102458633,
0.0205962099,
-0.0094525553,
0.0221348777,
-0.0144619709,
-0.0057441131,
-0.0380597226,
0.0423364304,
-0.0169986952,
-0.0238925144,
0.0313375965,
0.0219413731,
-0.1040990651,
-0.0633964315,
-0.0030532526,
0.0299361646,
0.0136510357,
0.0563822612,
0.0220997874,
-0.0140143204,
0.0047895997,
-0.0010323558,
-0.0359815098,
-0.006452539,
0.0406355187,
-0.0341776609,
-0.0283927284,
0.0425327942,
-0.013686331,
0.0004526328,
-0.012932227,
0.0462681241,
-0.0006113754,
-0.0674619228,
-0.0169375911,
0.0263071023,
0.0225131568,
-0.0605000965,
-0.0295453873,
-0.0411782861,
0.0029687891,
-0.0253585298,
-0.0062539848,
-0.0387972854,
-0.0129643483,
0.0688218772,
0.0228598714,
-0.0073317806,
0.0191119686,
-0.0115908366,
-0.0489346273,
-0.0226928163,
0.0081492243,
-0.0356386565,
0.0462122709,
0.0242458917,
0.0107740471,
-0.004289824,
0.0263896268,
0.0154735763,
0.0164437145,
-0.0404177941,
0.0199733712,
-0.0217376817,
0.0243473146,
0.0073431991,
0.0336716026,
-0.0210299883,
-0.0183214061,
-0.0160493478,
-0.0589608103,
0.0547437258,
-0.0179095715,
0.1473194063,
-0.0053943205,
-0.0027412982,
-0.0296797771,
0.0192307383,
0.017584458,
0.002571906,
-0.0162919909,
-0.0243312214,
-0.0068344395,
0.0604140311,
0.0749910325,
0.0108506754,
0.0167540889,
-0.0038327866,
-0.0011483444,
-0.0003928277,
-0.0302446969,
0.0163855273,
0.0180678666,
-0.0492449179,
-0.0304984152,
-0.0246634446,
-0.0486654863,
-0.0300451834,
-0.0027195502,
0.0002324099,
0.0028753721,
0.0028088195,
0.063054271,
-0.0365181714,
0.0157861467,
-0.0434070006,
0.0304984879,
-0.004566567,
-0.0112932744,
-0.0113003561,
-6.537385466e-33,
-0.0065702428,
0.0084200716,
-0.0239767656,
-0.0699694827,
0.0041789352,
0.0152522232,
-0.0223205406,
0.00476899,
-0.010424315,
0.0311015993,
0.0055166394,
0.0115872845,
0.020498516,
0.0042837099,
0.0355065018,
0.0406470336,
0.0707094893,
-0.0015152898,
-0.0298436582,
0.0048967972,
0.0169852506,
0.0272889733,
0.0682666972,
-0.0947906524,
0.0516020469,
-0.0207495876,
0.0043477882,
-0.0160385575,
0.0098399771,
-0.0020142091,
-0.0000657889,
0.0555346608,
0.004970639,
-0.0342750028,
-0.0441284738,
-0.0653148443,
-0.1065873951,
-0.0069624311,
0.0006022868,
0.0548058785,
-0.0242704377,
-0.0320310332,
0.0377529785,
-0.0163637381,
-0.0054569081,
-0.0375371911,
0.0113851316,
-0.0321716145,
-0.030153919,
0.0099442694,
-0.0495570935,
0.0173664279,
-0.0099270418,
-0.0145531977,
0.0548958331,
0.065777421,
-0.0103946533,
-0.0038760286,
-0.0691329911,
0.0179545972,
-0.0010756707,
0.0368224233,
0.0772645697,
0.001636077,
-0.0386515073,
-0.0104281111,
0.0130387675,
0.0265822262,
0.0752637759,
-0.0221599638,
0.0468211323,
-0.0013396512,
0.0334917642,
0.0617543943,
0.0597762316,
-0.0311085992,
-0.0504294932,
0.056822069,
-0.0410519652,
-0.0008333956,
-0.0009803897,
0.0078466665,
-0.0213501472,
-0.0262884535,
-0.0424690396,
-0.0406143554,
-0.0181980506,
-0.0219797026,
-0.0235529523,
-0.0024107406,
-0.0162251126,
0.0019638883,
0.0850999951,
-0.0124434279,
-0.0147233969,
0.0181439556,
-0.0262040589,
-0.0200789198,
-0.0154464468,
0.0644882023,
-0.0035702023,
-0.0342385732,
0.0062883534,
0.0371972322,
0.0103899604,
-0.0314068012,
0.0053717797,
-0.000500577,
-0.0425427854,
-0.0044738883,
-0.0382960849,
-0.0342083536,
0.010693402,
0.0413477086,
0.0090329424,
-0.0064068725,
0.0029084608,
0.0313123576,
0.0512583032,
-0.044967968,
-0.0270622261,
0.0164516419,
0.0260861516,
0.0143439667,
-0.0541161522,
-0.0118972436,
-0.0397327729,
-0.000650437,
0.0693600103,
-0.0445228703,
-0.0585161187,
0.0096940817,
2.945e-7,
0.0601773225,
0.0594573766,
0.0368566215,
0.0098518515,
-0.0046947375,
0.0388762914,
-0.0289110858,
0.0177386273,
0.0047577922,
0.0556091703,
0.0293345451,
0.0283983126,
0.0992901549,
0.05508513,
-0.002180371,
-0.0143705402,
-0.0083882157,
0.037529707,
-0.0328013487,
-0.0150346337,
-0.0462295711,
0.0508584827,
-0.0167350117,
-0.0047961152,
0.0097224079,
-0.0004162917,
0.0645769462,
-0.0270782374,
-0.0056391922,
0.0282376613,
-0.011024775,
0.0271462873,
-0.0374254584,
0.0000876907,
-0.0460931659,
0.0098389816,
0.0481310822,
0.0612226985,
0.0024432258,
-0.0110614188,
0.036273066,
-0.0156005425,
-0.0401965715,
-0.0339626372,
0.0187987164,
-0.0154305315,
-0.0181571394,
0.0350322761,
0.0210503712,
0.0554561205,
0.0945749283,
-0.0462137684,
-0.0466666855,
0.0259896088,
0.0611884408,
0.0127479648,
-0.0289443415,
-0.0015621572,
-0.0329110883,
0.0002485567,
-0.0129778367,
-0.0100661479,
-0.0143258115,
-0.0252469797,
0.0204634499,
-0.0189030375,
-0.007493142,
2.850693646e-34,
0.0474403985,
-0.0166688114,
0.0013383026,
-0.0179171953,
0.0136223715,
-0.0639146119,
-0.0173023548,
0.0092634251,
-0.032512892,
0.0030372189,
-0.0363452584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14106v1 | Better Zero-Shot Reasoning with Self-Adaptive Prompting | 2023-05-23T14:27:16 | 2023-05-23T14:27:16 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hanjun Dai, Sercan O. Arik, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Modern large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities
at sophisticated tasks, often through step-by-step reasoning similar to humans.
This is made possible by their strong few and zero-shot abilities -- they can
effectively learn from a handful of handcrafted, completed responses
("in-context examples"), or are prompted to reason spontaneously through
specially designed triggers. Nonetheless, some limitations have been observed.
First, performance in the few-shot setting is sensitive to the choice of
examples, whose design requires significant human effort. Moreover, given the
diverse downstream tasks of LLMs, it may be difficult or laborious to handcraft
per-task labels. Second, while the zero-shot setting does not require
handcrafting, its performance is limited due to the lack of guidance to the
LLMs. To address these limitations, we propose Consistency-based Self-adaptive
Prompting (COSP), a novel prompt design method for LLMs. Requiring neither
handcrafted responses nor ground-truth labels, COSP selects and builds the set
of examples from the LLM zero-shot outputs via carefully designed criteria that
combine consistency, diversity and repetition. In the zero-shot setting for
three different LLMs, we show that using only LLM predictions, COSP improves
performance up to 15% compared to zero-shot baselines and matches or exceeds
few-shot baselines for a range of reasoning tasks. | [
0.0195236597,
0.0095450161,
0.0049125627,
0.0408568606,
-0.0518540479,
0.0110389432,
0.059796188,
-0.0152211851,
0.0153046828,
-0.068879135,
-0.0388714634,
-0.0276543722,
-0.0216745492,
0.0004094436,
0.0065225852,
0.0010559718,
0.0547912009,
-0.0724936649,
0.016494019,
-0.0230157394,
-0.0312315896,
0.0109480163,
-0.0299635734,
0.0181658696,
0.005302703,
-0.0381839648,
-0.0438610204,
0.0007681935,
-0.0211267564,
-0.0497276671,
-0.0084316069,
0.0789990127,
0.0212556943,
0.0539080203,
0.0000020919,
-0.0638964921,
0.0404176936,
-0.0207951069,
-0.0966495275,
-0.01960022,
-0.013529364,
-0.0003355706,
-0.0045225946,
0.0103388866,
-0.0240333416,
-0.0130362902,
0.0158482883,
0.0452112667,
0.0452433825,
0.0612678267,
-0.000181766,
-0.0200124662,
-0.0033601071,
-0.02640686,
0.0607344992,
-0.0051923445,
0.0045791846,
-0.031183701,
0.0423380733,
0.0521651246,
-0.0001713072,
0.0246092472,
0.0586379096,
-0.0203606542,
-0.0076019084,
0.0605341643,
-0.0375533178,
-0.0617479049,
-0.0103071202,
0.0923685804,
0.019101033,
-0.0143700382,
0.004161241,
-0.0306721609,
-0.0044320477,
-0.0364447162,
-0.0583086014,
0.050730601,
0.0286299717,
0.0173037797,
0.0000083438,
0.0189001244,
0.0262120683,
0.0229882337,
-0.0182682108,
0.0825205967,
0.0058343769,
-0.0372069143,
0.0004411963,
-0.0012224984,
-0.002028933,
-0.0825863108,
-0.0572971664,
0.0678710863,
-0.0601423159,
0.0155751612,
-0.0451931022,
0.0027403515,
0.0251140874,
0.0099356705,
0.0626077577,
0.068092823,
-0.0329477601,
0.0773507953,
-0.0541874282,
0.0516686961,
0.0036299978,
0.0448472239,
-0.0358259752,
0.0015709179,
-0.0494340286,
-0.0011938731,
-0.0224530026,
0.0419915244,
-0.0295157321,
-0.013199822,
-0.0263483897,
0.0467486344,
-0.014743153,
0.0315856151,
0.0100936638,
0.0127498908,
-0.0096764974,
-0.036877729,
-0.0348820798,
0.0201184303,
-0.0497562476,
0.009571108,
0.0412621014,
-0.0741629601,
-0.0380401649,
0.0083872229,
0.0094914762,
-0.0280507114,
0.0065399748,
0.0675419047,
-0.0108962087,
-0.0487430505,
-0.0472313948,
-0.0205526203,
-0.0209656376,
-0.0774004832,
0.0208193399,
-0.0567092597,
0.0322577618,
0.0050514592,
-0.027021924,
-0.0117802545,
0.0166296288,
0.0186779983,
-0.0221140403,
0.0774692222,
0.0026493398,
0.0105951754,
-0.007761756,
0.0021358018,
-0.0268613305,
0.0737873912,
0.0104367081,
0.0149785541,
0.0175350774,
0.0044703074,
0.0064369142,
0.0109649906,
0.0219141003,
0.0096939756,
-0.0376463756,
0.0234653205,
0.0080034956,
0.0398119129,
0.0304036047,
0.020660039,
-0.0273660943,
-0.02457444,
0.0629487038,
0.0583318099,
0.0056835646,
-0.0281021539,
0.0528861918,
-0.0075546918,
-0.009772162,
0.0016177016,
-0.1020179689,
0.0502535775,
-0.0271662343,
0.0161874704,
0.0381139331,
-0.0045883507,
-0.0821405947,
-0.0228461288,
-0.0213446114,
0.0026671421,
-0.0170697924,
0.0318578817,
0.032635916,
0.016759159,
-0.0451678708,
0.0339577906,
0.0066546942,
-0.0283786058,
-0.0255251899,
-0.0705531538,
0.1019812226,
0.062552467,
0.0266282633,
0.0050739329,
-0.0411077701,
-0.0002381384,
0.0524290502,
0.0532721318,
0.0169493351,
0.0008621214,
0.020956384,
-0.0422883779,
-0.0238748044,
-0.0251061618,
0.0098389536,
-0.0075213793,
0.0015676969,
-0.0068144798,
0.0160565879,
-0.0148358066,
0.0391950496,
0.0342997536,
-0.0305143539,
-0.0617413186,
0.0326585546,
-0.0061684106,
0.0058291918,
0.0144176381,
0.0155883245,
0.0195992365,
0.0307959728,
-0.0354415141,
-0.0343137942,
-0.0137130376,
-0.0928438455,
-0.0636507571,
0.0295272861,
0.0434458293,
-0.019321451,
-0.0150037166,
-0.0475081131,
-0.0614712685,
0.0178305302,
0.0381031111,
-0.0042900033,
-0.0518930629,
0.0093818111,
0.0328095928,
0.0084493542,
-0.0230081771,
0.0639233664,
0.0069538024,
-0.0004538287,
0.0211961623,
0.0502332337,
0.0010908049,
-0.0546135679,
-0.0206846949,
0.0095284646,
-0.0274897031,
-0.012648223,
-0.015659485,
0.0154071301,
-0.0614471883,
0.0012291794,
-0.0730320588,
-0.0025977576,
-0.0247664303,
-0.0102706794,
0.0059061679,
0.0007913598,
-0.0036396286,
-0.0303520914,
-0.0114153111,
0.0178537071,
0.0298848618,
0.038712699,
0.0342029035,
0.0015948376,
-0.000031362,
-0.000253246,
-0.0145783303,
-0.0050839027,
0.0275338106,
-0.0167566705,
0.0339453518,
-0.0342924297,
0.0276168529,
-0.0282026809,
0.0193494614,
0.0016640309,
-0.0089657186,
0.0359410122,
-0.023393821,
0.022645643,
0.0751817524,
-0.0289591923,
-0.0037387838,
0.043233119,
-0.0032723669,
-0.0636949018,
0.024628114,
-0.0185275953,
-0.0273584146,
0.019733591,
0.021337701,
-0.0294612236,
0.0716705322,
-0.0013893425,
0.0098078717,
-0.0645839125,
0.0081815962,
0.0175570399,
-0.0301528554,
-0.0492689274,
-0.0077960007,
-0.0161432624,
0.0528016426,
-0.0154908998,
-0.0321878381,
0.0600553043,
-0.0279889442,
-0.018001372,
0.0160251465,
0.0066649197,
-0.0199647713,
0.0520477332,
-0.0113361767,
-0.0297278706,
0.0374471769,
0.0160563681,
-0.0560187027,
-0.0401438624,
0.0106528206,
-0.0072895447,
0.0327077769,
-0.0360422358,
0.0194529481,
-0.0303828586,
-0.0474142879,
-0.0761536062,
-0.0224030297,
-0.0483276509,
0.037471462,
-0.085219346,
0.0161472522,
0.0013803409,
-0.0153811751,
0.0364537947,
0.0616573915,
-0.022809878,
-0.0079465508,
-0.0334466174,
0.0221666396,
0.0396745093,
0.0353675634,
0.0029217936,
-0.0080693234,
0.0733061507,
0.0356707647,
0.0640954748,
0.0310031958,
-0.0336365476,
0.0334541723,
0.0136992,
0.0035389496,
-0.0029284358,
0.0510158129,
0.0568379089,
-0.0624809898,
-0.0027673175,
0.1310803443,
0.0212235767,
-0.0309305899,
-0.0053181895,
-0.045253925,
0.0278146807,
0.0342054889,
0.0211367197,
-0.0875226259,
-0.0648930073,
0.0207651127,
0.0061402386,
-0.0158795454,
-0.0337726921,
-0.0064594136,
-0.1504752487,
0.0478708856,
-0.0064540217,
-0.030260155,
0.0152480109,
-0.0330879837,
0.0172966123,
0.0048259269,
0.005401405,
0.0359565131,
0.0102982027,
-0.0132648256,
0.0145183941,
0.0157736558,
-0.0734843537,
0.0715058297,
-0.0070183058,
0.0723048896,
0.0447785109,
-0.0169278514,
0.0165718645,
-0.045416832,
0.0431989655,
-0.021148039,
0.0221197754,
-0.0285463408,
0.0251684822,
-0.0065725525,
-0.0062680743,
-0.0166422408,
0.0498936996,
-0.0289271213,
-0.0624886155,
-0.0075070951,
0.0924796984,
-0.0302689727,
-0.0249615461,
-0.0247586202,
-0.0048932508,
0.0044117006,
0.0930923,
0.0296112783,
-0.0359897986,
-0.0535717495,
-0.0089602098,
-0.0403732918,
-0.0492698476,
-0.0114484038,
0.0183894876,
0.0139822289,
-0.0154411895,
-0.043202877,
-0.028173916,
0.0556500256,
0.0562620386,
-0.01623285,
-0.0218813643,
-0.0302093122,
0.0033239375,
0.0015436696,
0.0091418773,
-0.0501435809,
0.0012404426,
-0.0763677284,
0.0196993966,
0.0220186487,
-0.0201194026,
0.0117804147,
-0.005381329,
-0.0711815655,
-0.0669307634,
-0.0121167926,
0.055885978,
0.0237925481,
0.0430841222,
-0.0130996099,
-0.0512500815,
0.0687375665,
0.0499315113,
0.0032306234,
0.0199228041,
0.0336335003,
0.0189433582,
0.0003623106,
0.0543585159,
-0.0388102606,
0.0473965369,
0.0241461564,
0.0512028635,
-0.0137833953,
-0.0082063004,
0.0128164459,
0.0169425346,
0.0477845408,
-0.0194273554,
0.0311704203,
-0.0102794804,
0.0354038738,
-0.0216759723,
-0.0053538354,
-0.0289265364,
0.0124803931,
0.0007637214,
-0.0372748673,
0.0202720072,
-0.0354970805,
-0.0408294052,
0.0568046011,
-0.0269866623,
-0.0128310844,
-0.0000085458,
0.0192421861,
-0.0043960107,
0.0038282948,
-0.025314115,
0.0498536974,
-0.0141988592,
0.0278635323,
-0.0296393186,
0.074584581,
0.0285063498,
0.0079848543,
-0.03304765,
0.0133308191,
-0.0758356825,
-0.0480470769,
0.0162383206,
0.0382761657,
0.0253817141,
0.0220515411,
-0.0070889737,
-0.0084257862,
-0.0161909312,
-0.0190360509,
0.0351947397,
0.0243897587,
-0.0308494661,
0.0303670485,
0.0562907606,
-0.0063363258,
-0.0102712512,
0.040648181,
-0.00916903,
0.0367739573,
0.0166430846,
0.0645035729,
-0.031608209,
-0.0153276287,
-0.0080160433,
-0.0140419006,
-0.0118990922,
0.0270825755,
-0.0702358931,
-0.0622949488,
0.0282374881,
0.0305765867,
-0.016607875,
-0.021520339,
0.0143237179,
0.0302212164,
0.0056026387,
-0.023524018,
-0.0139794713,
0.0080680232,
-0.0017121597,
-0.0237862878,
-0.0299667064,
-6.809023109e-33,
-0.0277320743,
-0.01887987,
0.0507871099,
-0.0532028005,
0.0136031518,
-0.0196841955,
-0.0449524149,
0.0099232066,
-0.0371603742,
0.0031538731,
-0.041904252,
-0.0078985598,
0.013485075,
0.0295661315,
0.0344720073,
-0.0388022028,
0.0270980354,
-0.0240106098,
-0.0314606242,
0.0144241797,
0.0312966965,
-0.0044321078,
0.022770362,
-0.0106970072,
0.0210728459,
-0.0198693611,
-0.0144531261,
0.04505134,
-0.033835832,
0.0640980303,
-0.023496775,
0.0285643246,
0.0312582701,
-0.040514227,
-0.0187774356,
0.0214465801,
-0.077846989,
-0.0607092828,
0.0147767561,
-0.0362179354,
-0.0701187551,
-0.0169751011,
-0.0068157371,
-0.0015710098,
-0.0245229471,
-0.0205029789,
-0.0069451686,
-0.0008071906,
-0.0342492424,
0.0314583294,
-0.0312341992,
-0.002190467,
0.00553936,
-0.0523695461,
0.0207679514,
0.0696052313,
-0.0153436055,
0.0428157151,
-0.0559623204,
0.008520497,
0.0036958603,
0.0164283533,
0.068745926,
0.023358332,
-0.0012684198,
0.0444196276,
0.0248683468,
0.0042019933,
-0.0537368953,
-0.0239378978,
0.0226731636,
0.0486845933,
0.0295446515,
0.0543938093,
0.0543893129,
0.0226527695,
-0.0558926873,
-0.0124567114,
0.014221075,
0.0480868481,
0.0398865305,
-0.0006176242,
-0.0229797643,
-0.0248995889,
-0.0298243314,
-0.018123785,
-0.0682630017,
-0.0199639089,
0.0611845106,
0.0243667308,
-0.0213692226,
-0.0137170963,
0.0637427792,
-0.0030220391,
-0.0002992452,
0.0184022151,
-0.014379574,
0.0137178414,
0.0049617128,
0.0165251531,
-0.0620370917,
-0.0233733747,
0.0442921482,
0.0206496306,
0.0064084181,
0.0284086373,
0.0413082652,
0.0311689898,
-0.0486524478,
-0.0354498848,
-0.0461871624,
0.0356460735,
-0.0002768505,
-0.0045754975,
0.015691353,
0.0182221495,
-0.0250463188,
0.0611971766,
-0.0203012154,
-0.0525232665,
-0.0208226703,
0.0312501304,
-0.0059974301,
0.0079218084,
-0.0216121897,
0.010523051,
-0.019669367,
0.0121250004,
0.0204851627,
-0.0241293591,
-0.006675486,
0.0398085862,
2.82e-7,
-0.0140645755,
0.0169533379,
0.0002559463,
0.0224260166,
0.016717134,
0.0672439858,
-0.0312970243,
0.0241332743,
0.0005901271,
-0.0461749472,
-0.0124994451,
0.0559931323,
0.0363117978,
0.0173606295,
-0.0673017874,
0.0319021903,
-0.0576941594,
0.0034726229,
-0.0538842455,
0.0069940798,
0.0683487803,
0.0685626939,
0.025670331,
-0.0213882625,
0.0270047076,
-0.0152883055,
0.052201245,
-0.0006626539,
0.0087456424,
-0.0234246328,
-0.005244243,
0.0045708893,
0.0084264772,
0.0319867805,
0.0119404253,
-0.0110860774,
-0.0482281037,
0.0723917633,
-0.0131024132,
-0.0378564112,
-0.0287573915,
-0.0075998716,
0.0210013967,
-0.0408935063,
0.1020202413,
-0.0757985339,
-0.0369128585,
-0.0226869788,
0.0106656412,
0.0048820623,
0.0053774947,
0.0019889185,
-0.0252833869,
-0.0028950879,
0.0218979437,
-0.001519148,
-0.0195251126,
-0.0869012699,
-0.0253886506,
-0.0117955403,
-0.0371873379,
-0.0210869256,
-0.0500498414,
-0.0045128721,
0.0459046252,
-0.0471786223,
-0.0146064833,
2.550822512e-34,
0.0123850983,
0.0068008071,
0.0276481844,
0.0458093286,
-0.0236971229,
0.0096338205,
-0.0230947435,
0.0127153601,
0.0450047255,
-0.0757388994,
-0.0328109451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14105v2 | CTQScorer: Combining Multiple Features for In-context Example Selection for Machine Translation | 2023-05-23T14:26:17 | 2023-10-21T14:22:02 | Aswanth Kumar, Ratish Puduppully, Raj Dabre, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have demonstrated the capability to perform on machine
translation when the input is prompted with a few examples (in-context
learning). Translation quality depends on various features of the selected
examples, such as their quality and relevance, but previous work has
predominantly focused on individual features in isolation. In this paper, we
propose a general framework for combining different features influencing
example selection. We learn a regression model, CTQ Scorer (Contextual
Translation Quality), that selects examples based on multiple features in order
to maximize the translation quality. On multiple language pairs and language
models, we show that CTQ Scorer helps significantly outperform random selection
as well as strong single-factor baselines reported in the literature. We also
see an improvement of over 2.5 COMET points on average with respect to a strong
BM25 retrieval-based baseline. | [
0.0156766381,
0.050081186,
-0.0016723478,
0.0344925784,
-0.0503761135,
0.005177028,
0.0704447702,
0.0401064344,
-0.0350818373,
-0.0315554515,
-0.015355208,
-0.0845294669,
0.0086873658,
0.0158187766,
0.0396979414,
-0.0285895541,
0.0251740143,
0.0028078926,
-0.0283976104,
0.0064437226,
-0.0261674728,
0.0343122855,
0.0327953063,
0.0508470796,
-0.0007255896,
0.0070848064,
0.013723636,
0.0334077179,
0.0247131456,
-0.009971153,
-0.0144152725,
0.0589377582,
0.0003368956,
0.0347767174,
0.0000018178,
-0.0595418327,
-0.056842763,
0.0075555742,
0.0056967027,
-0.0329882763,
0.0340379737,
-0.0276140459,
0.0104711698,
0.0327138752,
-0.0394694805,
0.0103465393,
0.0563100502,
0.0276022442,
0.0380114242,
0.0732325837,
-0.0196183342,
-0.0057438728,
-0.045862481,
-0.0266264472,
0.0343975239,
-0.0481990278,
0.0012714027,
0.0186729748,
-0.0271641687,
0.0452996939,
-0.0022713537,
0.0217595007,
-0.0033067078,
-0.0183192138,
0.0180464499,
-0.0011254391,
-0.0837262645,
-0.0300142132,
0.0193390809,
0.0680832416,
-0.0275451951,
-0.0277869068,
-0.0084067378,
-0.0072398172,
-0.0239662305,
-0.0309038144,
-0.0369907916,
-0.042469725,
-0.0137216896,
0.0241164621,
0.0236854125,
0.0534491912,
0.031945806,
0.0290033557,
-0.0434426405,
-0.0474306606,
0.0307329707,
-0.0227733497,
0.0138607183,
0.040191479,
-0.0375160612,
0.0043379096,
0.0288564637,
-0.0152501389,
-0.0500522554,
0.0170482974,
-0.0161519926,
-0.0458430685,
0.0134389363,
-0.0584350973,
0.0302841812,
0.0612692535,
-0.0275443662,
0.0808783993,
0.0073558581,
0.0567332692,
0.0040802243,
0.0027481823,
-0.0560911186,
-0.0277654212,
-0.023795329,
0.0490721799,
-0.0288095586,
0.0179076027,
-0.0158158783,
-0.0029230495,
-0.0232185759,
0.0077250311,
0.019018447,
-0.0070972592,
0.0280420855,
-0.0141601032,
-0.0794078037,
0.0098468456,
0.024826197,
0.0108255846,
-0.0162412561,
-0.0267782714,
-0.0016634874,
-0.0855121836,
-0.0125409886,
0.0153843351,
-0.0003350264,
-0.0600566007,
0.0027824864,
0.0634329841,
-0.0175708719,
-0.0570556745,
0.0227634162,
-0.0098783681,
-0.0239302665,
-0.0617079362,
-0.0295709819,
-0.0729351491,
0.0356096327,
0.0296205021,
0.0245186556,
-0.0448244177,
-0.0173395351,
0.0087295165,
-0.0079620909,
0.0320483521,
0.0547148734,
-0.0214202534,
0.0387695543,
-0.008231339,
-0.0266938284,
0.0689084753,
0.0303606745,
0.0117907785,
0.0458259322,
0.0157098304,
-0.0058310837,
0.0296912603,
0.0072026034,
0.0615033135,
-0.0413946919,
0.0140264025,
0.0421514921,
0.0385501944,
0.0033877748,
0.036239706,
-0.0192887578,
0.0346913524,
0.0513518453,
0.0107989646,
0.032554552,
0.0568122007,
0.0419794433,
0.0241227783,
-0.0104927793,
-0.0133674461,
-0.0183416475,
0.0336236358,
0.0024955252,
-0.0151624484,
0.0584531613,
0.0409094505,
-0.0003606659,
-0.0583248399,
0.0002528992,
0.0214843955,
-0.0100818872,
0.0085599236,
0.0464851744,
0.0031390514,
-0.0743059963,
0.0065314723,
-0.0140197193,
-0.0553565323,
0.0127898706,
-0.0140599916,
-0.0028879421,
0.0413569286,
0.0545070469,
0.0006221122,
-0.0068323268,
-0.0236492772,
-0.0219489038,
0.031567838,
0.0773075745,
0.0084285187,
0.0415602513,
-0.045474235,
-0.0545999296,
0.0383487456,
0.0198637825,
-0.0080462955,
0.0053703571,
0.0520923622,
0.0263082366,
-0.0323184393,
-0.0800877213,
0.027354544,
-0.0003841245,
-0.0402448252,
0.0461525135,
0.0208817143,
0.0336183272,
-0.0032319294,
-0.0025761954,
-0.0122262603,
0.016687246,
-0.0310677849,
-0.0014683481,
0.0300797168,
-0.0496785343,
-0.0937902257,
-0.0111165522,
-0.0145071382,
-0.0054611233,
-0.003620659,
-0.0543098152,
-0.0414218158,
-0.0415932722,
-0.0301526058,
0.0107173128,
-0.0504699051,
0.0339136235,
-0.0412661918,
-0.0040951194,
-0.0388715491,
0.0561122634,
0.0128801838,
0.0044525322,
0.0018520869,
-0.0267332345,
-0.0015127904,
-0.0477221683,
-0.0065443646,
0.0158439297,
0.0263989586,
0.0485864207,
0.054155916,
0.0263392627,
-0.0332461149,
0.0020870753,
-0.0899515003,
0.022050485,
-0.0550494269,
0.0069988775,
0.0031470673,
0.0302644651,
0.0277672596,
0.0005317756,
-0.029565433,
-0.0580244102,
0.0062768483,
0.0148089984,
0.0138735669,
0.0233099721,
0.0019600315,
-0.0173451994,
-0.0106481584,
0.0215237588,
0.0881273076,
0.0014379519,
-0.0177976191,
-0.0420791991,
0.0690073445,
-0.0339163505,
-0.0378877781,
0.0051840157,
-0.0094408253,
-0.012084364,
-0.0151350293,
-0.0096419211,
0.0442456566,
0.0094867507,
-0.0032695786,
0.0414993428,
0.0122603439,
-0.0642365143,
-0.0006370787,
-0.0204826202,
-0.0014733523,
-0.0109003829,
-0.0326759443,
0.0492473356,
-0.0174852498,
0.0104868738,
-0.0036602216,
-0.0561334565,
0.0404344611,
-0.0137323085,
-0.0083185863,
-0.0442122445,
0.0228261128,
0.001692387,
0.0669715852,
-0.0176577959,
-0.0777626634,
0.0918353945,
-0.0112877851,
0.0082651284,
-0.0483304821,
0.009729133,
-0.0373099372,
0.0279469211,
-0.054798685,
0.033211492,
-0.0469212271,
-0.0184952058,
-0.0123298997,
-0.0079075042,
0.0290796887,
-0.0398861356,
0.0487276465,
-0.0438069291,
-0.009104236,
0.0083230799,
-0.0277922992,
-0.0307634324,
0.007416287,
0.0060750348,
0.0152595444,
-0.0059486893,
0.0090033216,
-0.0298657138,
-0.0144714462,
-0.0039500818,
0.0526992679,
-0.0214653835,
-0.0033587033,
0.0078906603,
-0.0059188823,
0.0007087908,
-0.0027558955,
0.0350461192,
-0.0505260602,
0.0241134707,
-0.0105488263,
0.0215656683,
-0.0317057744,
0.0072781872,
-0.0192363951,
0.0472773798,
-0.010945349,
-0.0562823266,
-0.0043779043,
0.0517228208,
-0.0575158298,
-0.0111145591,
0.0838206112,
0.0208990034,
-0.0648256913,
-0.015079312,
-0.0255647469,
0.0181455817,
0.013380236,
0.0406573154,
-0.0527886823,
-0.0158744659,
0.0088960482,
0.0165175684,
0.0147388605,
0.0297271777,
-0.0328279808,
-0.0739873126,
0.0368220247,
0.0429739431,
-0.0795664266,
-0.0252545681,
-0.0428954847,
0.0035549665,
-0.0801950544,
0.0348709896,
-0.0018918737,
0.0093097631,
-0.0044266386,
-0.0043414845,
0.0414500087,
-0.096730642,
0.0063803829,
-0.0438124947,
-0.0315134935,
0.0792142153,
0.0513763726,
-0.0053593135,
-0.0144740595,
-0.0073042884,
-0.0604264736,
-0.0003170058,
-0.0195537191,
0.0371098407,
0.0024724999,
-0.0255548973,
0.0200333148,
0.0142968688,
0.0052937935,
0.0223305766,
-0.0091872495,
0.0526256487,
-0.0437293202,
0.0215267446,
0.0447825827,
-0.0544162206,
0.0187810212,
0.067033492,
0.0048337672,
-0.0617418624,
-0.0052800621,
-0.0100156134,
-0.0399158821,
-0.0408829823,
-0.0331072062,
-0.0123153832,
-0.0422348157,
-0.027808629,
-0.0989565477,
-0.0326019675,
0.0483927168,
0.071021609,
-0.019781433,
0.0477232188,
-0.058820948,
0.0064008692,
0.0221547894,
0.0445850082,
-0.0207820367,
0.0178792886,
-0.0480235964,
0.0408506989,
0.0174978767,
-0.0587140061,
-0.0112088239,
0.0157894902,
-0.0471018888,
-0.051552847,
-0.0106878383,
0.0432253592,
0.0200448707,
0.0274165645,
-0.0260420125,
-0.0099533619,
0.0337395817,
0.0216416251,
0.0028829481,
-0.0123919547,
0.0340037048,
-0.0358488373,
-0.034199249,
0.0588492937,
-0.03506786,
-0.00741792,
-0.0138887251,
0.0486310571,
-0.0346632078,
-0.0359724611,
0.0360180773,
-0.0151310898,
0.0246138722,
-0.0511355139,
-0.0185642745,
-0.0196527876,
0.0433371067,
0.0213454999,
-0.0209571309,
-0.0400977992,
0.0163077433,
0.0166981705,
-0.0160017386,
-0.006616625,
0.0062672826,
-0.0543650761,
0.0054710042,
-0.037065845,
0.0069260746,
-0.0458236672,
0.0141409822,
0.0291820839,
0.0141188065,
-0.0299096368,
0.0077034673,
0.0073656999,
0.0136675192,
-0.0442776531,
0.0039683585,
0.0115943616,
0.0364070944,
0.0083517386,
0.0062579527,
-0.0412342027,
-0.0162762273,
-0.0482627675,
-0.0138377016,
0.0895443857,
-0.0230973829,
0.1208494604,
0.0184937771,
-0.0255555734,
-0.0431407616,
0.0402762666,
0.0481263585,
-0.0264010821,
-0.0238652863,
0.000178891,
-0.0062660188,
0.0463149399,
0.0491559952,
-0.0334487967,
-0.0090771988,
0.001223005,
-0.007929977,
-0.0175335575,
0.0470389724,
0.0351832397,
-0.026228616,
0.0022962224,
-0.0190219227,
-0.0369839035,
-0.0384913236,
0.0580799878,
-0.0336911902,
-0.0373078547,
-0.0080768848,
0.0223919004,
0.0965854824,
-0.0415712334,
0.0116559593,
-0.0578263961,
-0.0329386108,
-0.0081497114,
-0.0128897941,
-0.0302089751,
-5.932304157e-33,
0.0070189494,
-0.020662928,
-0.0227171369,
-0.0195664261,
0.013616601,
-0.0060927914,
-0.0338794403,
-0.0314984322,
-0.0075867432,
-0.0056874147,
-0.0163458884,
-0.0210217424,
0.0354227535,
0.0007661454,
0.0053377054,
0.0032058626,
0.0920692831,
0.0535502993,
-0.032280609,
0.0341050178,
0.0452778563,
0.0251607206,
0.0708622113,
-0.0609783269,
0.0271311998,
-0.0355442762,
-0.023578018,
0.0248744749,
0.0194804631,
0.0629636124,
0.031245837,
0.0154086631,
0.0188556425,
-0.0344292298,
-0.0175951216,
-0.0596952885,
-0.0521114133,
0.0034811073,
0.0031950471,
0.0209022332,
-0.0007683072,
-0.0627949908,
0.0287713706,
-0.0485155396,
-0.011076075,
-0.0193792973,
0.0230947435,
-0.0391318165,
-0.0681654885,
-0.0575993881,
-0.0440041311,
0.0350541286,
0.0008150574,
0.0204672124,
-0.0047429525,
0.0684323609,
-0.0301193986,
0.0461004861,
-0.0343599059,
0.0129592568,
-0.0462578945,
0.0448919907,
0.0669947118,
-0.0064741136,
-0.0045418665,
0.0319920965,
-0.0363644175,
-0.0206054524,
0.0452233888,
-0.0559132509,
0.0219695605,
0.026488645,
0.063269645,
0.0789785981,
0.0631567016,
-0.0290246159,
-0.0746191591,
0.0541019179,
0.0075453371,
0.0004150512,
0.0291107111,
0.0132853007,
-0.0305474363,
0.0000757017,
-0.0836503282,
-0.0292890072,
-0.0428455882,
-0.0549370795,
0.0183189232,
0.0460945107,
-0.0490680896,
0.0121238101,
0.0806472898,
-0.0034759534,
-0.023255609,
0.034081284,
-0.0648268089,
-0.0170252435,
0.0075893938,
0.0267391428,
0.0071142484,
-0.0411444567,
0.006573373,
-0.0016291951,
-0.000960911,
-0.0361878686,
0.0624760054,
0.0149993114,
-0.0726828724,
0.0291085951,
-0.0270092543,
-0.0191662163,
-0.0258592516,
0.0171681717,
0.007540775,
-0.0104480237,
-0.0076249768,
0.058238335,
0.0058043357,
0.013351839,
-0.0329826176,
-0.0023906403,
-0.0162648801,
0.0507450737,
-0.0390754566,
0.0092301331,
0.0016079911,
0.0189199969,
0.0732964724,
-0.0099676354,
-0.0374500304,
-0.0004210479,
2.534e-7,
0.0452454314,
0.0660641864,
-0.058249414,
0.00322492,
-0.0380848385,
0.0291221198,
-0.0318899192,
0.0372934192,
0.0115036545,
0.0416763648,
0.0191698223,
0.0206154976,
0.0905686617,
0.0515596904,
-0.0878665745,
-0.0028439374,
-0.0394144729,
0.0174990911,
-0.0582789518,
-0.0242534075,
0.0457256399,
0.1166630462,
-0.0090118619,
0.000466656,
0.0014884525,
-0.0303514376,
0.0847323164,
-0.0233260542,
-0.0366324633,
0.0172039755,
0.0324048027,
0.0157331508,
0.0023952816,
-0.0152737815,
-0.0418245122,
0.0264127608,
0.0478867851,
0.0857947692,
0.0210710037,
-0.0255726967,
0.0055892994,
0.0199014805,
0.0108922347,
-0.0397359319,
0.056390278,
-0.0252540596,
0.0039599687,
0.0104518887,
-0.0111430744,
0.0146106556,
0.0886604413,
-0.009454824,
-0.0167391542,
0.0324112959,
0.0356338285,
0.0075030625,
-0.0149828997,
-0.0405943356,
-0.0220909081,
0.0066021229,
0.0062778872,
-0.0233424865,
0.0082454989,
-0.0100427028,
0.0114566907,
0.0052182167,
0.0191289876,
2.224813158e-34,
0.063959904,
-0.0117068775,
0.0176553782,
0.0110620726,
0.0127077205,
-0.0154944062,
0.0223013908,
0.0018995415,
0.001417073,
-0.0363893732,
0.0013970793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14104v1 | Out-of-Distribution Generalization in Text Classification: Past, Present, and Future | 2023-05-23T14:26:11 | 2023-05-23T14:26:11 | Linyi Yang, Yaoxiao Song, Xuan Ren, Chenyang Lyu, Yidong Wang, Lingqiao Liu, Jindong Wang, Jennifer Foster, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Machine learning (ML) systems in natural language processing (NLP) face
significant challenges in generalizing to out-of-distribution (OOD) data, where
the test distribution differs from the training data distribution. This poses
important questions about the robustness of NLP models and their high accuracy,
which may be artificially inflated due to their underlying sensitivity to
systematic biases. Despite these challenges, there is a lack of comprehensive
surveys on the generalization challenge from an OOD perspective in text
classification. Therefore, this paper aims to fill this gap by presenting the
first comprehensive review of recent progress, methods, and evaluations on this
topic. We furth discuss the challenges involved and potential future research
directions. By providing quick access to existing work, we hope this survey
will encourage future research in this area. | [
0.0569883324,
0.0467155762,
0.0115747275,
0.0082800305,
-0.0244160295,
0.0272092465,
-0.0428065658,
0.0565044582,
0.0017706621,
-0.069082737,
0.0082835713,
-0.0249328408,
0.0188696124,
0.0040587527,
-0.0155400867,
-0.0281748008,
-0.018885944,
0.0432648957,
0.0014318513,
-0.0010542993,
-0.0173375085,
0.0106798131,
0.0273351781,
0.005064155,
0.0265900157,
-0.0100324079,
0.041124709,
0.0180200916,
0.0041579423,
0.0064912443,
0.0163148716,
0.009883902,
0.0138866166,
0.0063797971,
0.0000016555,
-0.0553833209,
-0.0332647264,
0.0032581673,
0.015540041,
-0.0022939176,
0.0586001389,
-0.0667273775,
0.0063088271,
0.0267739259,
-0.018718252,
-0.0118543738,
0.0512975343,
0.0160408746,
-0.0076568783,
0.0880552232,
-0.0269532856,
0.0161042195,
0.0302294046,
-0.0086992765,
0.0006481959,
-0.0046333577,
0.0437146574,
-0.0278160702,
0.0086381137,
-0.0229926724,
-0.0445814468,
-0.0170514975,
0.0026077321,
0.0809827447,
0.0121772373,
0.0156616271,
-0.036895778,
0.0357276052,
-0.0206661467,
0.0624712072,
-0.0637501925,
-0.0400390178,
-0.0158607084,
-0.0363693163,
0.0190449692,
0.0728520826,
-0.0120375948,
0.0146124298,
-0.011969639,
0.0475216657,
0.0135644143,
0.030392969,
0.0202036183,
0.0218785796,
-0.0696842149,
0.0470506623,
-0.0318676904,
-0.0396743454,
0.0086965803,
0.0165485088,
-0.0916498005,
-0.0000966042,
-0.0229541361,
0.0157505721,
0.0384685956,
0.0076911338,
-0.0361822359,
-0.0287356675,
0.0360854752,
-0.0563017428,
0.0429470986,
-0.0182587262,
-0.0341575556,
0.0184075162,
0.0219643675,
0.0135615524,
-0.0006007332,
0.0456336215,
-0.0298348013,
0.0129743684,
-0.0947756246,
0.0268798452,
0.0004927061,
0.0448787957,
-0.004145728,
-0.0170886312,
-0.0524050668,
0.0087749846,
-0.0116959671,
-0.0185294952,
-0.0059941127,
0.0181569066,
-0.0111991446,
0.0208303705,
-0.0041870438,
0.0063505578,
0.0004175333,
0.0184054151,
-0.0786470845,
-0.0175668895,
-0.0036477542,
0.0497378446,
0.0156403445,
0.0169603787,
0.0318572,
0.0570399165,
0.0225928314,
-0.0746537074,
-0.0242307093,
0.0158541277,
-0.0323737934,
-0.0105143012,
-0.0160940979,
-0.0419745706,
-0.056491822,
0.0166258775,
0.0077498835,
-0.0307495035,
0.0048154048,
0.0216914043,
-0.0410314091,
0.0118358731,
0.002557358,
-0.0241912212,
0.0406998545,
-0.0202413835,
0.0370583236,
0.0610383935,
0.0048422925,
-0.0303275418,
0.0533793345,
0.0445179977,
0.0776098371,
0.0607927442,
0.0106685208,
-0.0022804062,
-0.0015103023,
0.012608327,
0.0331364311,
-0.0014341964,
0.0350815877,
-0.0118100969,
-0.0190418214,
-0.0205497891,
0.0262610596,
0.00741407,
0.0230645537,
-0.0255456585,
-0.015340955,
0.0055332081,
-0.0255413558,
0.0293622948,
-0.0225971006,
-0.0407077111,
-0.0037478877,
-0.007409472,
-0.0183476564,
0.0061181025,
-0.0449214652,
-0.043014776,
-0.0408895239,
-0.0192887802,
0.0320429951,
0.0111405738,
0.1048521549,
0.0051056691,
0.0238627866,
0.0031711911,
0.0565074198,
0.0341530554,
-0.0088098366,
-0.0532787107,
-0.0035152442,
-0.022795761,
0.0481542647,
-0.0863769054,
0.04971065,
-0.0163762067,
-0.0155475456,
-0.0082993247,
0.0057516675,
-0.0133664459,
0.0107790874,
-0.0248563252,
-0.0174218491,
0.0172199197,
0.0510761105,
-0.0116757434,
0.02686847,
0.0103265401,
0.0169158131,
-0.0990796015,
-0.0368874818,
0.048189722,
0.0268481951,
-0.0602581799,
0.0656075031,
0.007780456,
0.0309828315,
0.0118490262,
-0.0378827117,
-0.0213115253,
0.0059434939,
-0.0323234163,
-0.0329996273,
-0.0309941247,
-0.0086133257,
-0.0521683358,
0.0066747153,
-0.0330273211,
-0.0020110675,
0.0219826177,
-0.0485037304,
0.0115883686,
0.0051246341,
-0.0294040367,
0.0406500734,
-0.0603378378,
-0.0012016946,
-0.0288350917,
0.0296813119,
-0.0545467064,
0.0913070738,
-0.0225850735,
0.0245562363,
-0.0351130962,
-0.0291835535,
0.0593636408,
-0.0178302713,
-0.024880521,
0.0040105353,
-0.0262716934,
0.0283413418,
-0.0016018561,
0.0143494597,
-0.0184282046,
-0.017201148,
-0.0811024383,
-0.0108756749,
-0.054838948,
0.0102775227,
0.0166654494,
-0.0106265265,
-0.0288038738,
-0.0280554127,
-0.0297733806,
-0.0624345802,
0.0366214626,
0.0034712404,
0.0343377516,
-0.0389797762,
-0.0068303333,
0.0502078794,
-0.0112599479,
-0.0027312143,
0.101682812,
-0.0451982059,
-0.0217743982,
-0.0980114415,
-0.0019648792,
-0.0400797166,
0.0044618892,
-0.0009038998,
0.0468711145,
-0.0564583689,
0.0260107759,
-0.0141128451,
0.0511172749,
0.0020952292,
-0.0229576007,
0.0411729068,
0.0359432735,
-0.0105162049,
-0.0309687592,
-0.0117486781,
-0.0023861332,
0.0177575406,
-0.0092530372,
0.0310673416,
0.0043251151,
0.0144496262,
-0.0497687049,
-0.0055623646,
-0.0129514858,
-0.0263647642,
0.0200030915,
-0.0150340684,
-0.0016942387,
0.0064823916,
0.0150891198,
0.010302701,
-0.0685332566,
0.0505526662,
0.0051228777,
0.0321673416,
-0.1052066609,
-0.0426104888,
-0.0588996448,
0.045173604,
-0.0170173869,
0.0215122979,
0.0290977657,
-0.029296428,
-0.0050607249,
-0.0602084957,
0.0038994637,
-0.0047815167,
0.0629401803,
-0.0305186231,
0.0288059935,
0.0151472986,
-0.0152131412,
0.0094208969,
-0.0680923015,
0.010434133,
0.0097335996,
-0.0363611206,
-0.0121457297,
-0.0436322503,
0.007454989,
-0.0487450399,
0.0650811493,
-0.0046015307,
-0.0130696315,
0.0100482069,
0.0379502326,
0.0155469822,
-0.042384129,
-0.0380047821,
-0.0358334854,
-0.0490579121,
0.0162305217,
0.0471418835,
0.0014566022,
0.0038369677,
-0.0011573025,
0.0322334282,
-0.034954641,
-0.0181005765,
0.0497037582,
0.0177449919,
0.018502282,
-0.030375829,
0.0625743195,
0.0491283722,
-0.0607747883,
0.0149576329,
0.0051399935,
0.0163724087,
0.014284784,
0.0130263912,
-0.0612383261,
-0.0085271243,
-0.0033223261,
0.0048790597,
-0.0422223397,
-0.0336395539,
0.0163987093,
-0.1078616604,
0.0350256003,
0.0079615116,
-0.0441588461,
-0.0531596728,
-0.0467940532,
0.0103807347,
-0.0216163862,
-0.0025187195,
-0.0511297472,
-0.0093223583,
-0.021549385,
0.0250859149,
-0.0617768168,
-0.0568990335,
0.0364759266,
-0.0174354594,
-0.0006915432,
0.0345306508,
0.0265500005,
0.0041383998,
0.022115957,
0.0184319802,
-0.0522749089,
0.013231582,
-0.0190253891,
0.0547537804,
-0.0011388449,
0.0151815424,
0.0095448773,
0.0382432528,
-0.0390975401,
0.011824403,
0.0063717267,
0.0708876327,
-0.0020850427,
-0.0403615087,
-0.0319094025,
-0.0276091602,
0.0187838189,
0.0323057994,
-0.0388227515,
-0.0728551075,
-0.0231148731,
-0.0338638313,
-0.0200303365,
0.0530271009,
0.048588898,
0.0473339148,
-0.0081066284,
-0.0629862249,
-0.0591848716,
-0.0153383473,
-0.0275923479,
0.0603257269,
0.0200918335,
0.0022516064,
-0.0061503854,
-0.0155699505,
-0.0187445879,
-0.0029479165,
-0.0182289556,
0.0028454179,
0.024308905,
-0.0073512834,
0.017037021,
-0.0451401547,
-0.0374649689,
0.0129525494,
-0.0508243628,
-0.0517016724,
-0.0111069027,
-0.0097735599,
0.0286209416,
0.0238167048,
0.014068896,
-0.0611431934,
0.1292444766,
0.0560809635,
-0.000315325,
-0.0037110073,
0.0188928619,
-0.0045622066,
-0.0052464581,
0.0129406676,
-0.0207945909,
0.0096295858,
0.0504909307,
-0.0516354404,
-0.0255631357,
0.0067616999,
0.0029934067,
-0.0387866795,
0.0340002552,
-0.006099802,
-0.0953272358,
-0.0398764499,
0.0245502163,
0.0317656063,
-0.0155746648,
-0.0105182985,
0.0259091668,
0.0692107007,
0.0352977738,
-0.0518349223,
0.029805826,
-0.0366326086,
0.0466642566,
0.0019893802,
-0.0035914078,
0.0617189854,
0.013240424,
-0.0090540433,
-0.0044029863,
-0.0217560753,
-0.014931933,
-0.0027358115,
0.0309654772,
0.0198061317,
0.0517457388,
0.0137955593,
0.0596102104,
-0.035769444,
-0.0373380743,
-0.0848603249,
0.0433721803,
-0.0359987803,
0.0201166086,
0.0276800152,
-0.0446801856,
-0.0654966086,
-0.0093619144,
-0.0208397638,
-0.0080567542,
0.0260946937,
-0.0236167386,
0.009739616,
-0.0120475078,
-0.0011774197,
-0.0246659145,
0.0449707843,
0.0578020886,
0.0555577353,
0.0201583803,
-0.0182358474,
-0.0204643384,
-0.0526570901,
0.029853927,
0.0379024744,
0.0374774709,
-0.0082218787,
0.0187488291,
-0.029581625,
-0.0334076956,
0.0572672524,
-0.0437676497,
0.0388986357,
-0.0071220747,
0.0056734551,
0.1000673771,
0.0074960748,
0.0162623338,
-0.025081452,
-0.0731123015,
0.000409147,
0.0027015503,
-0.0358654819,
-5.16894731e-33,
0.0534960665,
-0.029159192,
-0.0290884655,
-0.0141673321,
0.032698445,
0.0077280728,
0.0741350278,
-0.0211714376,
-0.0125530791,
-0.0193482768,
-0.0195817072,
0.0168060455,
0.0035394737,
0.03384123,
-0.0120020108,
0.0040743519,
-0.0092619024,
-0.0024503956,
-0.0409678333,
-0.0000374293,
0.0367843993,
0.0444623828,
0.0607034452,
-0.0479355492,
0.0726585686,
0.001634003,
-0.0066557964,
0.0145110013,
0.0372198969,
0.0218268875,
-0.0074269157,
0.0888835788,
0.0499663167,
0.0054033389,
0.0191986095,
0.0105439089,
-0.025346417,
-0.0145791648,
-0.0256220344,
-0.0205774009,
0.0688637048,
0.0454163477,
0.0211487636,
0.003125397,
-0.0099626696,
-0.0535844937,
0.0619561113,
-0.0220180638,
-0.0346738249,
-0.0094116619,
-0.0379237719,
0.067686379,
0.0099818259,
0.0161157418,
-0.0121001489,
0.0069313566,
-0.0067359293,
0.0230387971,
-0.0098919189,
0.0005928208,
0.0204569101,
-0.0029597536,
-0.0031869942,
0.0087779574,
-0.0230415892,
0.0410738364,
-0.043040514,
0.0303461906,
-0.0576414987,
-0.0381270014,
0.0481461883,
-0.0096051507,
-0.0056448104,
0.0612564236,
0.0870563537,
-0.0060489243,
-0.1114631519,
0.0223922692,
0.0175485238,
-0.0468239412,
0.019896619,
0.0105285943,
-0.0842972621,
-0.0474405214,
-0.0047006332,
-0.0303112511,
-0.0101112658,
-0.0141516086,
-0.0023663975,
0.0347164236,
-0.0088102631,
0.0318462066,
-0.0131361205,
-0.057685867,
-0.0243215263,
0.0245435089,
0.0009207531,
0.0347641371,
-0.0027216072,
-0.0294270646,
-0.0396743193,
-0.0550854132,
-0.0033726234,
0.0221914686,
-0.0031302646,
-0.0160177927,
0.0835143402,
0.0328160003,
-0.0781520829,
0.0093245776,
0.0116049238,
0.0212590881,
-0.0012528547,
0.1189491004,
0.0134451361,
0.0316610746,
0.0015656526,
0.0370206237,
0.0201009996,
0.0309305452,
-0.0082591493,
0.0385725051,
-0.0151238209,
0.0015624085,
-0.0119220046,
-0.010435421,
0.0520670488,
-0.0039489693,
0.0102777211,
-0.0502717756,
0.0066759181,
-0.0212854445,
2.265e-7,
0.0797159299,
0.032469403,
-0.0112759089,
-0.0179027114,
-0.0001308008,
0.0042700958,
-0.0048594773,
0.0385299586,
-0.0264547262,
-0.0399866626,
0.0369745865,
-0.0118331602,
-0.0012454458,
0.0216481388,
-0.1024076417,
0.0253358949,
-0.0285989642,
0.0142893549,
-0.0210509747,
-0.0164458249,
0.0176356826,
0.1118215472,
0.017324904,
-0.0594599769,
-0.0126283588,
-0.0642383397,
0.0491376668,
-0.0231374502,
0.013438032,
-0.0049965335,
0.0263573658,
0.0041768532,
0.0421376973,
0.0834048241,
-0.0165744778,
0.0693449602,
0.0343781747,
0.001829403,
-0.0159195922,
-0.0017373788,
0.0028999706,
0.0444428697,
-0.0009312783,
-0.0571638569,
0.0519861169,
-0.0478338115,
-0.0255469214,
-0.0150543489,
-0.0103879087,
-0.0194229279,
0.0650094375,
-0.0123769566,
0.0252624899,
0.04841315,
0.0395507812,
0.0025616053,
0.0149398884,
-0.0875075981,
0.0033352331,
0.0213414449,
-0.0370053016,
-0.0345219076,
0.0075903591,
0.0221786555,
0.050714545,
-0.0670577511,
0.0314029753,
2.059301717e-34,
0.0446820259,
0.0225710757,
-0.047512088,
-0.0396858007,
0.0162732136,
-0.0284309871,
0.0176496003,
-0.0082142884,
0.0112958299,
-0.0557878576,
0.0420772843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14091v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14091v3 | Revisiting Acceptability Judgements | 2023-05-23T14:16:22 | 2023-09-28T02:58:48 | Hai Hu, Ziyin Zhang, Weifang Huang, Jackie Yan-Ki Lai, Aini Li, Yina Patterson, Jiahui Huang, Peng Zhang, Chien-Jer Charles Lin, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we revisit linguistic acceptability in the context of large
language models. We introduce CoLAC - Corpus of Linguistic Acceptability in
Chinese, the first large-scale acceptability dataset for a non-Indo-European
language. It is verified by native speakers and is the first acceptability
dataset that comes with two sets of labels: a linguist label and a crowd label.
Our experiments show that even the largest InstructGPT model performs only at
chance level on CoLAC, while ChatGPT's performance (48.30 MCC) is also much
below supervised models (59.03 MCC) and human (65.11 MCC). Through
cross-lingual transfer experiments and fine-grained linguistic analysis, we
provide detailed analysis of the model predictions and demonstrate for the
first time that knowledge of linguistic acceptability can be transferred across
typologically distinct languages, as well as be traced back to pre-training.
Our dataset is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/huhailinguist/CoLAC}. | [
0.0701905936,
0.0734889954,
-0.0161119159,
0.0698691607,
0.0074854498,
0.0090454267,
-0.0189890359,
0.0178892519,
0.037231829,
-0.0094740232,
-0.0655773357,
-0.0168389734,
-0.0035987496,
0.0289402343,
0.0097431447,
-0.0470197387,
0.0377190225,
-0.00308266,
0.0166379381,
-0.0240329932,
0.0466896258,
-0.0191787034,
0.0383568071,
0.0415890552,
0.0061718402,
-0.0097517306,
0.0133452965,
-0.0235777162,
-0.027336264,
-0.0180126503,
0.026590541,
0.0628434569,
-0.0252618454,
0.0482307822,
0.000001962,
-0.0301625356,
0.0081291413,
-0.0202980284,
-0.0273622777,
0.0415053703,
0.0390247591,
0.0029219922,
-0.0176131986,
-0.0121372957,
-0.0478950553,
0.0135120424,
0.0404612981,
0.0600152388,
0.0654284358,
0.0513674878,
-0.010130235,
0.0183957927,
0.0040610619,
-0.0187655035,
-0.0364910662,
-0.0388872735,
0.0188490823,
0.0014863425,
0.0043022963,
0.0270633716,
-0.0393237174,
0.0302393548,
0.0225061253,
-0.038610585,
-0.0203628428,
0.0070108878,
-0.0348391682,
-0.0557311513,
-0.0149140498,
0.0736099556,
-0.0033286868,
-0.0589336753,
-0.0130033866,
0.0007120843,
-0.0071541588,
0.0224121865,
-0.0228044242,
-0.0220474787,
0.0055840951,
0.0313632078,
0.0246151499,
-0.01817655,
0.0269182436,
0.0127793867,
-0.0026372045,
0.1181040704,
0.0020997077,
-0.0247568414,
0.0134265339,
0.0220174417,
-0.0131102707,
-0.0681959987,
-0.0066881645,
-0.0169703495,
-0.0566458069,
0.0163130108,
-0.015230746,
0.0219560396,
0.0294817835,
-0.0248191394,
0.0252220277,
-0.0164872911,
-0.0487275273,
0.0585160777,
0.0111843012,
0.0249194242,
-0.0257790685,
0.0151995318,
-0.0294370074,
-0.0172504131,
-0.0737788528,
0.0154481484,
-0.0391520821,
-0.0267874617,
-0.0052099484,
0.0240102075,
-0.0503049828,
-0.0113432733,
-0.0505623184,
-0.0177545678,
0.0308948904,
-0.0236297566,
-0.0108622294,
-0.035563264,
-0.0345318057,
0.0370110422,
-0.0350308344,
0.0319612883,
-0.0108765271,
-0.0686753392,
0.0278264247,
0.0107898591,
-0.0144288056,
-0.0188734662,
-0.0010308481,
0.0247628074,
-0.0115539981,
-0.0101546096,
-0.008596329,
0.0145684574,
-0.062403027,
-0.0363221429,
-0.0077950158,
-0.0442636423,
0.0040657977,
-0.0256627332,
0.023353247,
-0.0786438659,
-0.0269956049,
-0.0095662009,
-0.0483747944,
0.0526311547,
0.0025964628,
0.0048421952,
0.0289184861,
0.000926565,
-0.0364763923,
0.0497963689,
0.0449699275,
0.0160420276,
0.0872576609,
-0.0332776494,
0.0170819741,
0.0591126531,
0.0446161777,
0.0388527438,
0.014524213,
0.0169145893,
-0.005303666,
-0.0116116283,
0.0350471176,
0.100671038,
0.0001902683,
-0.0717709437,
0.0813428089,
0.0519186705,
-0.0187547095,
0.0275115855,
-0.0012856909,
0.0432606414,
0.009508295,
0.0105231255,
-0.0424704254,
0.016862588,
-0.0300585087,
-0.0106924884,
0.0269405376,
0.0117376838,
-0.0135452235,
-0.0511423573,
-0.0054518087,
0.0116010047,
0.0559906214,
-0.016889587,
0.0438348241,
0.0020032653,
-0.0098539377,
-0.0127209714,
0.0527341478,
-0.0805825889,
-0.0010849886,
-0.0401936136,
0.0709201843,
-0.0037807291,
0.012052007,
-0.0032863,
0.0416437238,
-0.009361811,
-0.0124963196,
0.0323722661,
0.0859303847,
-0.0168556087,
-0.018055154,
-0.0130377682,
0.0029766557,
0.1016624942,
0.0051867142,
0.0325509943,
0.010766712,
0.0275893826,
-0.0388330445,
-0.02386011,
-0.075616166,
0.0185058918,
-0.0216387045,
-0.0186598655,
-0.0060678707,
-0.0061649517,
0.0870542824,
0.0164858941,
-0.0172515083,
-0.0146627109,
0.0043120743,
0.0098603647,
-0.0446758904,
0.049289193,
-0.0413567759,
-0.0390755497,
0.0535433106,
-0.0566993505,
-0.0520264767,
0.0107035395,
-0.0144834844,
-0.0440943055,
-0.0055563636,
-0.005656362,
0.0158385094,
-0.0672791749,
0.0104287462,
-0.0186263416,
0.0247148648,
-0.0034922301,
-0.024157865,
0.0031634578,
0.0178025328,
0.0023333451,
-0.027303854,
0.0386391357,
-0.0278413612,
-0.09285748,
0.0343938246,
-0.0061291652,
0.0289748199,
0.0450500771,
0.0052403351,
-0.0389837399,
-0.0191672221,
-0.0987406,
-0.014648173,
0.003879851,
-0.0029111621,
-0.0129681788,
-0.0366426967,
0.0057893232,
-0.0084944945,
-0.0453010537,
-0.0076477956,
0.0031532694,
0.0341125242,
0.0138219362,
-0.0296869464,
-0.0055030072,
-0.0406522937,
-0.0021372011,
0.0059019998,
0.0279425159,
-0.008813371,
0.000629075,
-0.0068892296,
0.010882156,
-0.0247561075,
-0.0026836197,
-0.0127627617,
-0.0957724079,
-0.010842504,
0.0218964145,
-0.0345902778,
0.0212223548,
-0.0072983894,
0.0468662195,
0.0217868946,
-0.0000237835,
-0.0295519959,
-0.024496045,
0.010744039,
-0.0483054556,
-0.0107659344,
-0.0439023636,
-0.0123603577,
0.1036053449,
0.0103159742,
-0.0402790718,
-0.0791108534,
-0.0304601658,
-0.0788553655,
-0.0495036021,
-0.0323614925,
0.0142639512,
-0.0554529615,
0.0473410711,
-0.0265900083,
-0.0539145507,
0.0778855607,
-0.0570143573,
-0.0406106301,
-0.0135750137,
-0.0069117369,
-0.0051665823,
0.0383090861,
0.0255890097,
-0.008804054,
0.0533283651,
-0.0017087875,
-0.0325560272,
0.0165901333,
0.0173381548,
-0.0247190669,
0.0269984044,
-0.0462368615,
0.0044732196,
0.0059587783,
-0.014409407,
-0.0009548533,
-0.0493427776,
-0.0255638137,
0.0068502612,
0.0302846991,
-0.0350563005,
0.0318917893,
-0.0193171706,
0.003797319,
0.0137267094,
0.0095929923,
0.0218652599,
-0.0073686754,
-0.0033433591,
0.0263535865,
0.0725719109,
-0.0057887109,
-0.029578764,
0.0119573334,
0.0580173433,
0.0092606423,
0.0181373861,
-0.0287000164,
0.0195365883,
0.0269739907,
0.0273354296,
-0.0106667252,
0.0213841479,
0.0667746142,
-0.0145081198,
0.006634187,
0.0696260482,
0.0135696214,
-0.0356703661,
0.0010703726,
0.0061678994,
0.052546721,
0.0113242473,
-0.0040048021,
-0.0802518874,
-0.0228272788,
0.014607178,
0.0075193197,
-0.0211464837,
-0.0245474428,
0.0032046628,
-0.0994130373,
0.0525764078,
0.0080224248,
-0.0369670577,
-0.0011947283,
-0.0135260439,
0.0012186248,
-0.0261018928,
0.0321993865,
0.0037334163,
0.0166954994,
-0.0117569407,
0.0306603573,
-0.03195123,
-0.0274742767,
0.0542349219,
-0.0318296999,
0.107977055,
0.0217707325,
0.0396966189,
-0.0261352323,
-0.0441985354,
0.0229350086,
0.0264665391,
-0.0601848178,
-0.0073843468,
0.0517358258,
0.0233931281,
-0.0215842221,
-0.0070074499,
0.0311947316,
-0.0430830792,
0.0089206705,
0.0495904125,
0.1025312543,
0.0393216722,
-0.0601803958,
0.0048988783,
-0.0046357242,
0.0143738305,
0.1067844182,
0.0499096587,
-0.0652347356,
-0.003517952,
-0.0499241389,
-0.0468376465,
0.0081008328,
-0.0588416681,
0.0745754167,
-0.0408615284,
-0.0615935698,
-0.1068102643,
-0.0349990278,
-0.0021032586,
0.0116539886,
0.0405555591,
-0.0211347826,
0.0670590177,
-0.020976387,
-0.0013848658,
0.0600272156,
-0.0240793284,
-0.0196356699,
-0.1170122772,
-0.0101499045,
0.0116092013,
-0.0082450164,
-0.0314803906,
0.0418848731,
0.0009798727,
-0.0724731833,
0.0343600027,
0.0327410996,
0.025151439,
-0.0058559189,
-0.0156876594,
-0.0601053908,
-0.0055987979,
0.0216400642,
-0.0154592292,
0.0156299304,
0.0668007061,
0.0057134139,
-0.0031417683,
0.0367513485,
0.0001892249,
0.0457134768,
0.0292338524,
-0.0199885312,
-0.0273218919,
-0.0536544025,
0.0147862639,
0.0447836407,
0.0192919802,
-0.0078579793,
-0.0128356954,
-0.0544560663,
-0.0133129731,
0.0040099327,
-0.0086420225,
-0.0497119017,
-0.0513765812,
0.0372576341,
-0.0310612153,
-0.0484077632,
-0.020017352,
-0.0288914479,
0.0225907173,
0.0082198009,
0.0148989605,
0.0138273677,
0.0724326968,
0.0148431594,
-0.001830238,
0.0097869188,
-0.014576057,
-0.0315040834,
0.0314975753,
-0.0007968984,
0.0660722405,
0.0382183567,
-0.0082064876,
0.0535952821,
-0.0002781728,
-0.0291317292,
-0.0138624143,
0.0075401324,
0.0474795103,
0.0293771923,
-0.0224974062,
0.0732924268,
-0.0185899362,
-0.0023612035,
-0.0614237227,
0.0476545691,
-0.0244065318,
-0.0342193991,
0.0433602743,
-0.006832025,
-0.0511089712,
0.0140668191,
0.0559858195,
0.0108062429,
-0.0303519312,
0.0083631044,
0.0189542491,
-0.0242089666,
0.0093042618,
-0.0205084812,
-0.0414509885,
-0.0150297228,
0.0417619795,
-0.0620119832,
-0.0855891854,
-0.0100651626,
0.0373973735,
-0.0033315362,
0.0036816318,
-0.0113498187,
0.0600862317,
-0.0084658209,
-0.0019717666,
-0.0531823188,
0.0014257294,
0.0207156613,
-0.0064513856,
-0.0346559472,
-6.004492735e-33,
-0.0118873827,
-0.0096359309,
-0.0333887041,
0.0051602665,
0.0120575344,
-0.0519772917,
-0.048362758,
0.0317925662,
-0.0259926803,
0.0621463954,
-0.0466345809,
0.0187444687,
0.009850516,
0.040773429,
0.033339113,
-0.0100885956,
0.032108251,
0.0048791808,
-0.0001279788,
-0.0056926194,
0.0521159396,
0.001991098,
0.0634408444,
-0.0663618371,
0.0824338198,
0.0132901967,
0.0134806186,
0.0053701755,
-0.0129535245,
0.0601212233,
-0.0331481993,
0.0345177427,
0.0300966091,
-0.0104231788,
-0.0063768481,
0.0140132103,
-0.069060415,
0.0120930495,
0.0093823429,
0.0236523543,
-0.004842618,
-0.0182543751,
0.0347942263,
-0.039842613,
-0.0295564048,
0.0120176449,
0.0151724229,
-0.0247401204,
-0.0000776744,
0.0542065986,
-0.0443944708,
0.0374924988,
-0.010699274,
-0.0034495245,
-0.0037870798,
0.0053021046,
-0.0114400117,
0.0102665126,
-0.0497558899,
0.0101173073,
-0.030953167,
0.0329641812,
0.0403496735,
-0.0711582601,
0.0099781305,
0.0618885495,
0.0205945093,
0.0100622093,
0.0299611688,
-0.0613972135,
0.038597066,
0.0246366635,
0.0437966995,
0.0874098167,
0.0091870995,
-0.0531006828,
-0.0142811574,
0.01640491,
0.024364531,
-0.0086982716,
0.0014449744,
0.0257130247,
-0.0588515438,
-0.0254988391,
0.0018510561,
-0.0523639657,
-0.0300737452,
-0.0070465361,
0.050071612,
-0.0516296998,
-0.0153088644,
-0.0494906604,
0.0532257035,
-0.0620324947,
-0.0357578285,
-0.0040313192,
-0.0081664789,
0.020833645,
0.0257517435,
0.083077535,
-0.0669354945,
-0.0156465285,
-0.0571368672,
-0.0066494411,
0.0036627196,
-0.0003292832,
0.0418481901,
0.0113573177,
-0.0618699975,
0.0164130609,
-0.0259674285,
0.0107341288,
-0.0129951024,
0.0358783863,
0.0321019515,
0.0158215221,
-0.0042458945,
0.0066199186,
-0.0054364125,
-0.0186595563,
-0.0638659894,
-0.0077614663,
0.0023154793,
0.0196556989,
-0.0292788316,
-0.0235622395,
-0.0125243394,
0.0155094769,
0.0492463522,
-0.0116567966,
0.0063390685,
-0.0011936213,
2.63e-7,
0.0159785282,
0.0345189944,
-0.0138616571,
-0.0055922205,
0.0167910885,
0.05199356,
-0.0635205731,
0.0326954462,
0.0263709612,
-0.0076145171,
-0.0006477246,
0.0103695309,
0.1020370647,
0.0174038969,
-0.0897882432,
-0.0428845435,
-0.029402446,
-0.0022202549,
0.0266488567,
0.0232342202,
0.0185719002,
0.0836006105,
0.0318492651,
0.0150079913,
0.0052300594,
-0.0204882994,
0.0473045409,
-0.056415353,
-0.0032909759,
0.0244975947,
0.0643634275,
-0.0208405685,
0.0020734624,
0.0094806841,
-0.0060970518,
0.0231347922,
0.0233177412,
0.0668209419,
0.0197858587,
0.0064242976,
-0.0153349852,
-0.0441035256,
-0.0010533979,
-0.0749338716,
0.0254678205,
-0.016584035,
-0.0272080712,
-0.0452276021,
-0.0223319866,
-0.0448658541,
0.0328261033,
-0.012015759,
-0.0113473525,
0.0167470649,
0.0308703315,
-0.0172290597,
0.0020476035,
-0.0340956785,
-0.0132732876,
-0.0164691936,
-0.051175572,
-0.0488414355,
-0.0117147071,
-0.0071402472,
0.0153001426,
-0.0498864129,
0.0204906147,
1.823965452e-34,
0.0409143306,
-0.0071742893,
0.037785206,
0.0151720364,
0.0489465669,
-0.0046264092,
0.0424106605,
0.0051095383,
0.0315792821,
-0.0275210477,
-0.007252194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14087v1 | BM25 Query Augmentation Learned End-to-End | 2023-05-23T14:11:42 | 2023-05-23T14:11:42 | Xiaoyin Chen, Sam Wiseman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Given BM25's enduring competitiveness as an information retrieval baseline,
we investigate to what extent it can be even further improved by augmenting and
re-weighting its sparse query-vector representation. We propose an approach to
learning an augmentation and a re-weighting end-to-end, and we find that our
approach improves performance over BM25 while retaining its speed. We
furthermore find that the learned augmentations and re-weightings transfer well
to unseen datasets. | [
0.0112132505,
0.0407399312,
-0.0115395654,
0.0003596541,
0.0086788759,
0.0055864686,
-0.0236772951,
0.0655269474,
-0.0108175287,
-0.0064004068,
-0.040399231,
-0.0495497137,
-0.0578155145,
0.0409131274,
0.0178076793,
-0.0158150215,
0.0218227897,
0.0428849012,
-0.063186571,
0.0112418868,
-0.0114353364,
0.0328558013,
0.0274646841,
-0.0198508464,
0.033077158,
0.0519951172,
-0.0371895097,
0.0415992215,
-0.0248150378,
-0.0377680175,
0.0076192645,
0.0227919165,
0.0549659282,
0.0440593548,
0.0000017974,
-0.0345025547,
-0.0157216322,
0.0125196865,
-0.0346274935,
0.046537485,
0.0620939434,
-0.0152038932,
0.0759979263,
-0.0035193341,
-0.0285711735,
-0.0163460728,
0.0089217499,
0.0486168265,
0.05030239,
0.0626261532,
-0.0027061075,
0.0184821896,
0.0221631899,
-0.0356194079,
0.0619041845,
-0.0607891083,
0.0352018811,
-0.0357762724,
0.0492409058,
0.0844144821,
-0.0111812223,
-0.0044033015,
-0.0197141245,
0.0286577828,
0.0881986171,
0.0159022603,
-0.0314357281,
0.0499011055,
0.0224851519,
0.0325219631,
-0.0060902182,
-0.0157254506,
-0.0041501806,
0.0289621931,
-0.030883722,
-0.0368056558,
-0.0506591722,
-0.0456768125,
0.02474197,
0.0296241622,
-0.0515221246,
0.0002250941,
0.0527848937,
0.0402169488,
-0.0301750973,
0.0518474244,
-0.0053679375,
-0.030337166,
-0.0170222279,
0.040710032,
0.0088464273,
-0.0029335092,
0.0090647265,
0.0090362001,
-0.001614574,
-0.0013209775,
0.0020275495,
-0.0152572552,
0.0329416059,
-0.0197993498,
0.0153966872,
0.0239603184,
-0.0515070818,
0.0555714443,
-0.0340403877,
-0.0014215208,
-0.0309952088,
0.0379419513,
-0.0367518887,
0.0019863052,
-0.0386742651,
-0.0189299602,
-0.0298436508,
0.0715081021,
0.0329995453,
0.0096945884,
-0.0509369038,
0.0154441418,
-0.0022397221,
-0.0413522013,
-0.0024345734,
0.0188440643,
-0.0656339899,
-0.0034650406,
-0.0504457578,
0.0007534379,
-0.0073849754,
0.0104087209,
-0.0114711719,
-0.0115309358,
-0.001405036,
-0.0077677867,
0.0311038066,
-0.0563709661,
0.0215550158,
-0.021221282,
-0.0326664262,
-0.0289754812,
-0.0233131535,
0.0102869114,
0.0428408682,
0.0096962517,
-0.0455806442,
-0.0174283702,
0.0257419329,
-0.0137047041,
-0.0104538659,
0.0024084656,
-0.0053777709,
0.0368244946,
-0.0627141297,
0.0463610291,
-0.0033573147,
-0.0164410789,
0.0051065413,
-0.0067069624,
0.031710811,
0.0552747063,
-0.0313883089,
0.0355350487,
0.0290377345,
0.0084401518,
-0.0220128391,
-0.0022967851,
0.0380746052,
0.0205538739,
-0.0171155352,
0.005832409,
0.0125791105,
0.016680656,
-0.0043202033,
-0.0127504673,
-0.0464646444,
-0.054965917,
0.0092047341,
-0.011807844,
0.0184761491,
-0.0210855994,
-0.0446235798,
-0.0153667433,
-0.059889935,
-0.0077108811,
0.0004427186,
0.0427225791,
-0.0725545958,
-0.0167016219,
0.0545230992,
-0.018340813,
-0.0184486303,
-0.020947393,
-0.0054903971,
0.0547842048,
-0.0029815517,
0.0489588305,
0.0464700721,
-0.0416696407,
0.0186053496,
0.0080711413,
-0.0032029471,
-0.0391193628,
0.027489366,
-0.0531073511,
-0.0197940264,
0.0052706203,
0.0463843271,
-0.0514816903,
0.0009956562,
0.0187439434,
-0.0040948326,
-0.0050102309,
0.0111530451,
0.0019613882,
0.042092327,
-0.0513808727,
-0.0253049396,
0.0028636309,
0.0186177474,
0.0094536273,
0.0031362448,
0.0247239899,
0.0331999548,
-0.0856891945,
-0.0244245622,
0.0199541785,
0.0341299623,
-0.0542074926,
0.0419475697,
0.0008891655,
0.0032782701,
-0.0031463108,
0.0099088363,
0.0048476481,
0.0620859377,
-0.0153794289,
-0.0286215823,
-0.0492462777,
0.0133191142,
0.0023539546,
0.0354875438,
0.0148514509,
0.051383622,
0.0097806612,
-0.0441514552,
-0.0226986408,
-0.0019294466,
0.0058917827,
-0.006652243,
-0.0433000438,
0.0187793504,
-0.0305769239,
0.0200160649,
-0.0493557118,
0.0306116454,
0.0104789715,
0.0230944715,
-0.054284595,
-0.0407278016,
-0.0008399349,
-0.0650600791,
-0.0393735394,
0.0022868414,
0.0089854598,
0.0128186978,
-0.0143414792,
-0.0355639346,
-0.0322520211,
0.0490688756,
-0.0720522702,
0.0314205326,
-0.0167173035,
-0.0233709849,
0.0105587635,
0.0382752903,
0.024086833,
-0.0036342763,
-0.0479287878,
-0.0453805625,
0.0014018898,
0.0488977619,
0.0109928437,
0.0616863333,
0.0002455567,
0.0092747631,
-0.0599262565,
0.0077855727,
0.0095626507,
-0.0390208364,
-0.0309540983,
0.0065329834,
-0.0103263408,
-0.0646468848,
-0.0270753093,
-0.026515672,
0.0226745643,
0.0076039992,
-0.1056347042,
-0.0483226664,
0.0303442068,
0.0325955823,
-0.0013934135,
0.0516077094,
0.0302450303,
-0.0613736399,
0.0272754766,
-0.0154836178,
0.0277153496,
-0.0110138888,
-0.0376732089,
0.0624496862,
-0.0396660045,
-0.0368005447,
-0.0170692708,
-0.0306151342,
-0.0066658314,
0.0575435497,
-0.0370269045,
-0.118400149,
0.008575581,
0.0095241247,
0.0345958099,
-0.0256769583,
-0.025624536,
0.0675116107,
0.0009242256,
0.0097927591,
0.0266756136,
-0.0561144873,
-0.0503667146,
0.0300856233,
-0.0123063708,
0.0124990549,
-0.0329733565,
-0.0303321034,
-0.0039077066,
-0.0183779709,
0.0126768611,
-0.0384020172,
0.0532398894,
0.0299758036,
0.041793555,
0.0035152084,
-0.0520739853,
-0.0039637024,
-0.005596281,
0.0233298186,
0.0105517292,
0.0119789327,
-0.0065690931,
-0.0636068806,
0.04461734,
-0.017117817,
0.0184856225,
-0.0176127404,
0.0012471344,
0.0287091509,
-0.0392349139,
0.009824357,
0.0307464413,
-0.0506159142,
-0.0189668778,
-0.0574515276,
0.0216215868,
0.0648760945,
-0.1013567075,
0.0091072163,
0.0126087954,
0.0917451978,
-0.002833938,
-0.0172523167,
-0.0426103957,
-0.0238621328,
-0.0209824722,
-0.0019476408,
0.0333755501,
0.0083360327,
-0.0615145415,
-0.0029339611,
-0.0631265342,
0.0200296231,
0.0513939224,
0.0868309736,
-0.0866744965,
0.0208725706,
-0.0070848186,
0.0668024868,
-0.0083220266,
-0.0538725965,
-0.0006150211,
-0.111063011,
0.0604971275,
-0.0150623471,
-0.0046740789,
-0.0108041214,
-0.0632696077,
0.007351893,
-0.0395370685,
-0.0402665474,
0.0285770409,
0.0078607993,
-0.0303442609,
0.0333407,
0.0144520802,
-0.0296271853,
-0.0300370697,
-0.0076811905,
-0.0162685271,
-0.0027693585,
0.0056657041,
-0.0034781876,
-0.0391971096,
-0.0094408309,
-0.0297868401,
-0.0142785143,
-0.0537716597,
0.0967166722,
-0.0620414019,
-0.0292635504,
0.0188788082,
-0.0272434317,
0.0382915512,
0.0047954591,
-0.0261074547,
0.046774596,
-0.0496790707,
0.06723959,
-0.0144144725,
-0.0706183165,
-0.0415731259,
0.0248411037,
-0.0315824561,
0.0452425294,
0.0107444981,
-0.0048748148,
-0.0182379335,
-0.0321489237,
0.0067796255,
0.0023454363,
-0.0647194907,
0.0080651334,
-0.0414040908,
0.0117427632,
0.0272416156,
0.0797098875,
-0.0422060303,
0.0211536698,
-0.0573221371,
-0.0146544771,
-0.0328159332,
0.0060623614,
-0.0262248553,
0.0256614834,
-0.0392172225,
-0.0289130826,
0.0418575704,
-0.0432985537,
0.0036250711,
-0.070470646,
-0.0208533462,
-0.0315814503,
-0.008090158,
0.0389581099,
0.0157314986,
0.0384507254,
-0.0232111178,
-0.0364101008,
0.0526002869,
0.094271265,
-0.0056264028,
0.0221055951,
-0.0041018859,
-0.0753285736,
-0.0303332899,
0.0230193082,
-0.0601483397,
0.0017525621,
-0.0199610572,
0.0629775003,
-0.0428085886,
0.0123138921,
0.0294390414,
0.069750376,
0.0605383813,
0.013524875,
0.0141105764,
-0.0316271968,
0.0373461209,
-0.0187585745,
-0.0237279702,
0.0061498187,
0.0071978574,
0.0582564361,
0.0105855083,
-0.0101848617,
0.0335385539,
-0.0174597781,
0.0478286482,
-0.0703278631,
-0.0166198332,
-0.0261990763,
-0.0224801544,
0.0076268315,
0.0267530177,
-0.0312489513,
0.0012334172,
0.0292967893,
0.0551580787,
-0.0374224223,
-0.049503006,
0.0126092201,
0.0271636993,
-0.0841458514,
0.022317769,
-0.1146990433,
0.0087305875,
-0.0209945552,
0.0153651424,
0.0358764306,
-0.0405326076,
-0.0312140621,
0.0100509077,
-0.0244957656,
-0.0244439468,
-0.0301864073,
-0.0049104472,
-0.0308255423,
0.0113024721,
0.0401370488,
0.022542784,
0.0613229647,
0.0465545356,
-0.0130706923,
0.0581049621,
-0.0369513296,
-0.0423582643,
-0.0072075292,
0.0006639907,
0.0903417468,
0.0814672783,
-0.0266314037,
-0.0222067963,
0.0274605434,
-0.0243459027,
0.0698378161,
-0.0498717539,
-0.0035395473,
-0.0546647608,
0.0421313494,
0.0727140754,
0.0511632562,
0.0060855234,
-0.0327261239,
-0.0203697681,
-0.0410011075,
-0.0001873767,
0.0261837374,
-6.490256959e-33,
0.017452091,
0.0306313708,
-0.0010657556,
-0.0650611818,
-0.0549692027,
-0.0007774587,
0.0303584151,
-0.03865394,
-0.0047421223,
-0.0238732565,
-0.0427610613,
-0.0045164227,
-0.0006326301,
0.0124513274,
0.0171073638,
-0.0140887238,
0.0935552493,
0.0148238242,
-0.0062531028,
-0.0080795288,
0.0410168618,
0.0762672275,
-0.0109441951,
-0.0328866132,
-0.008245864,
-0.0033272312,
-0.0303430557,
0.0406819433,
0.0386421196,
0.0624888204,
0.0115113929,
0.0374824181,
0.0436565764,
-0.0202083495,
0.0213208813,
-0.0527788065,
-0.0593799613,
0.009659877,
0.0038966653,
-0.0086848857,
0.0021497479,
0.0028179369,
0.0044467943,
-0.0090808049,
0.0003657124,
-0.0106070647,
0.005745213,
-0.0306625944,
-0.0671570748,
-0.0153277265,
0.0220426992,
0.0054488806,
0.0063564698,
0.0525612347,
0.0230223965,
0.0071272068,
-0.006015907,
0.0607895479,
-0.0155410133,
0.0205237865,
0.001836569,
0.0450028107,
-0.0048992294,
0.059293922,
0.0127990115,
0.0310222711,
0.0136121027,
0.0088061336,
0.0025775854,
0.0350991897,
0.0426488444,
0.0174051598,
0.0220738817,
0.0413907319,
0.0641226396,
-0.01815667,
-0.0397912264,
0.0585175641,
0.0591019541,
0.0492243804,
-0.0124980174,
0.0964920446,
-0.0099410256,
-0.0184902605,
0.0012043391,
0.0288985465,
-0.0540176593,
-0.0145304669,
0.0031100316,
0.0751090497,
-0.0523919575,
0.0510048009,
0.0206331573,
-0.0192629732,
-0.046986118,
0.0108722774,
0.0179529488,
-0.0123213157,
0.0146297663,
-0.0310122818,
0.0075723091,
-0.012164087,
0.0412130952,
0.0067500472,
-0.0366900526,
-0.0249446351,
0.0432091504,
-0.0082379421,
-0.0356751047,
-0.0184239186,
0.0244679525,
-0.0144374548,
-0.0174929183,
0.0538660623,
-0.0093867248,
0.0180218369,
0.0025811545,
0.0528190657,
-0.0046713301,
0.0440463461,
-0.0056967163,
-0.0821235627,
0.0167229325,
0.0059542148,
-0.0138208698,
0.0338325314,
0.0253458396,
-0.0186712276,
0.0345371179,
-0.0491966791,
-0.0295553096,
0.0204365849,
2.597e-7,
0.0321319848,
0.0245077536,
-0.0043545314,
0.0019859336,
-0.0529169105,
-0.0173809417,
-0.0481915735,
0.0434227884,
0.016173372,
0.0149454819,
0.0442676358,
0.0176632293,
0.0245859828,
0.0286172535,
-0.0560798012,
-0.0316616781,
-0.0415698476,
-0.0224464703,
-0.0508599095,
-0.0401403829,
0.0384526663,
0.0951138288,
-0.0095729446,
-0.0118071614,
0.0401729122,
-0.0519646034,
0.0461038053,
-0.0047559822,
-0.0102139944,
-0.0399683826,
0.0331528671,
0.0625993088,
0.0092821456,
-0.0113159157,
-0.0265899319,
0.0434409864,
0.019269824,
0.024509551,
-0.0296269767,
-0.0026606149,
-0.0070950612,
0.0481339581,
0.0376435071,
0.0001012556,
0.0619165786,
0.0206994358,
-0.0071227001,
0.0000561048,
-0.0429598354,
-0.0023123429,
0.0088018645,
-0.0115922196,
-0.0404466093,
0.0103823785,
0.0301513746,
-0.0212850906,
-0.0121058533,
-0.0975256264,
0.0293355472,
0.022297373,
-0.0089043863,
-0.0109860795,
-0.0410414599,
0.0492622294,
0.0030494165,
-0.0243185908,
-0.0167890061,
1.975756211e-34,
0.0526735745,
0.028859796,
0.0124432426,
0.0151527235,
-0.0084081003,
0.0153336218,
-0.0052399188,
0.0313030742,
0.0285381824,
-0.0991614312,
-0.0202660877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14083v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14083v2 | Counterfactual Augmentation for Multimodal Learning Under Presentation Bias | 2023-05-23T14:09:47 | 2023-10-30T22:05:11 | Victoria Lin, Louis-Philippe Morency, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Srinagesh Sharma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In real-world machine learning systems, labels are often derived from user
behaviors that the system wishes to encourage. Over time, new models must be
trained as new training examples and features become available. However,
feedback loops between users and models can bias future user behavior, inducing
a presentation bias in the labels that compromises the ability to train new
models. In this paper, we propose counterfactual augmentation, a novel causal
method for correcting presentation bias using generated counterfactual labels.
Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that counterfactual augmentation yields
better downstream performance compared to both uncorrected models and existing
bias-correction methods. Model analyses further indicate that the generated
counterfactuals align closely with true counterfactuals in an oracle setting. | [
0.0195677634,
0.0652252287,
-0.0244589821,
0.0366880558,
-0.0122568682,
0.0158389155,
0.0271853544,
-0.0060024606,
0.0446999632,
-0.048299484,
-0.0450551957,
0.0463753641,
-0.0435575619,
0.0417425334,
0.0658476204,
-0.095260419,
0.0609470606,
0.0240234155,
-0.002505136,
-0.0088962698,
0.0306582134,
-0.024192417,
-0.0210243072,
0.0245971624,
-0.0819186866,
-0.0323252678,
-0.0189610422,
0.0180577971,
0.0166892298,
-0.0261194129,
0.0311656687,
0.0082214931,
-0.0086843185,
0.0044938107,
0.0000021015,
-0.0289519764,
-0.0096747894,
-0.0035073219,
-0.0098181171,
-0.0341655016,
0.0531981327,
-0.0247167833,
0.0299406089,
-0.0027070644,
-0.0387592167,
0.0320648812,
0.0541844927,
0.0706769526,
0.062275704,
0.0103820097,
-0.0335878506,
0.0079816189,
-0.0080298474,
0.0027494654,
0.0262100697,
-0.0353759788,
-0.0174338911,
0.0052382592,
-0.0767161101,
-0.0478009656,
-0.0490451083,
0.0235969517,
0.0315659791,
0.0352346227,
0.0601998642,
0.0058132173,
0.0374625474,
0.0025992382,
-0.0202922355,
0.0800934806,
0.0078036557,
0.0210021101,
-0.0362929516,
-0.0555867292,
0.0722994134,
0.0319768749,
-0.0297001917,
-0.0366237424,
-0.0057991636,
-0.0139359515,
-0.064084135,
0.009630301,
0.0357909165,
0.0085311858,
0.0092606805,
0.0385774858,
0.0023836344,
-0.0068851188,
-0.0097618075,
0.0038960946,
0.0060657575,
-0.001580064,
0.0055255885,
-0.0175418034,
-0.0306381248,
-0.0291976389,
-0.0166411996,
-0.0309845041,
0.0016455487,
-0.0618250743,
0.0413772836,
0.0068717878,
-0.0901091695,
0.0210265573,
-0.0018632488,
-0.0037609101,
-0.0605425574,
0.0299364906,
-0.0284708608,
0.016189998,
-0.0065477649,
-0.0183677506,
-0.0102165593,
-0.0066150744,
-0.0424669795,
0.0069048582,
-0.0242761169,
0.0358755253,
-0.063449271,
-0.0004857664,
-0.0365377814,
0.0484933257,
-0.0472529046,
-0.0098515339,
-0.0365552381,
0.0664743781,
-0.0233692154,
0.0557933971,
-0.0147855571,
-0.0223940238,
0.0067607728,
0.028637968,
-0.0304004736,
-0.0389332734,
-0.0012381027,
0.1254221499,
-0.0033545182,
0.0110017918,
-0.058640305,
-0.0587519854,
-0.000300155,
-0.0226339642,
0.0394651145,
0.013148535,
-0.015882086,
-0.0040843231,
0.0200285278,
-0.0156428702,
-0.0269346498,
-0.0280332062,
-0.0074911248,
0.0784503818,
0.0180623904,
-0.0277672745,
0.0325637609,
0.0010759627,
-0.0680471063,
0.0696634874,
0.0388130285,
0.0209490433,
0.0324310958,
-0.0223112367,
0.0221717395,
0.0429120027,
0.0429955125,
-0.0078005907,
-0.0422353968,
-0.0151596768,
0.0264346506,
-0.0064953668,
0.0227362253,
-0.0081167808,
-0.0340700224,
-0.0253533069,
0.0544034392,
-0.0793833137,
-0.0132474713,
-0.0114418175,
-0.0390114002,
-0.0643345937,
-0.0434466489,
0.0414657146,
-0.0466293395,
0.0719776005,
-0.0546356738,
-0.0034594834,
0.0052548787,
0.0011444129,
-0.0292482432,
-0.0437678024,
0.0288544558,
-0.0182064977,
0.0274034254,
0.027476985,
0.0410885997,
0.0358571969,
-0.0288361683,
-0.0276623182,
0.0284882188,
-0.0266895741,
-0.0052435054,
-0.0649026409,
-0.0372130536,
0.0483940355,
0.010269328,
-0.038673684,
-0.0010229826,
-0.0206454806,
-0.0068825567,
-0.0046522552,
0.0754850283,
-0.0203139987,
0.025133675,
0.0069579794,
-0.0696351007,
-0.0211678259,
0.0136826811,
0.0311974995,
-0.0335740075,
-0.0170576442,
-0.0019545075,
0.0017119396,
-0.0011276833,
0.0288559273,
0.0020468389,
-0.0090926923,
0.0052191098,
0.0466902032,
0.0522015989,
0.0007019368,
0.0369106121,
-0.0108132632,
0.0073008095,
-0.0067567318,
0.0141858691,
0.0457928553,
-0.0383600444,
-0.0521012545,
0.0217256099,
-0.0468344316,
-0.0017168719,
0.0165572111,
-0.0484176427,
-0.0114070689,
0.071763806,
-0.0001478339,
0.0665344596,
-0.0107026072,
-0.01957996,
0.0329344831,
-0.0046810894,
0.0000119784,
0.0245171506,
-0.0365668647,
-0.0575840361,
-0.0130054094,
-0.0207531024,
0.0383207835,
-0.0147895105,
0.0048012296,
-0.0121985897,
0.0261415541,
-0.006416738,
0.0173562616,
-0.0561853014,
-0.0378908478,
0.0373873487,
-0.0621414967,
-0.0421284288,
-0.0122450273,
-0.0160105601,
-0.0196068287,
-0.0000198266,
0.002187751,
-0.0929117501,
-0.0133967791,
0.0003225435,
-0.0069763735,
0.0412636809,
0.0137675283,
0.0444395654,
0.0388681032,
-0.0310589653,
-0.0138394227,
-0.0180160254,
0.0649629906,
0.0325362571,
-0.0063476209,
-0.0241740216,
-0.0664779395,
-0.0088657476,
0.0263164919,
-0.0315821841,
0.0359047987,
0.0006482102,
0.0133084403,
-0.0062668077,
0.0434166938,
0.0140127679,
0.0388303027,
0.0173918512,
0.0276276674,
-0.0571350232,
0.0100719715,
-0.0222164039,
-0.0253377855,
0.0061016981,
-0.0392048955,
-0.0009498772,
-0.0014081185,
-0.0048236437,
0.0031180473,
-0.0522630438,
0.037176352,
0.0382905044,
-0.0622289851,
-0.0482707098,
-0.0323138423,
-0.0066688661,
-0.000226684,
-0.0259554889,
-0.0679223835,
0.0660062656,
0.0117652472,
-0.008084341,
0.0172201358,
0.0202859603,
0.0335861482,
0.0475277789,
0.0299312808,
0.0323786475,
0.0367932059,
0.0072619962,
-0.0468992293,
0.0036582451,
0.0512931235,
-0.0061164536,
-0.0417584553,
-0.0287716705,
-0.0294580143,
-0.0006366427,
-0.0540226959,
-0.0449489057,
-0.0709155947,
0.0316178314,
-0.0231964048,
-0.0433863848,
0.023718724,
-0.0320358202,
-0.0123916818,
-0.0026137277,
0.0015618283,
-0.0079375189,
-0.0316502266,
0.0108358683,
-0.0288168862,
0.0245526303,
0.0341324061,
-0.0110290647,
-0.0641724691,
-0.0401762985,
0.0204793103,
0.0575547703,
-0.0506934635,
-0.0445929021,
0.0322382972,
-0.0082971519,
0.0398148671,
-0.0192067306,
0.0071001016,
0.000173883,
-0.026392106,
0.0475785397,
-0.0015264351,
0.0021109825,
-0.0691083148,
0.0101496149,
0.0213198494,
0.0500052683,
0.0399923101,
-0.0060088737,
-0.0767047852,
-0.035615474,
-0.0181983579,
0.0384033695,
-0.0103748245,
0.0097149648,
-0.0051212409,
-0.11009074,
0.0454171672,
0.0147778895,
-0.0244047791,
-0.0221177302,
-0.0029677011,
-0.0069077946,
-0.0512525551,
-0.0101294192,
0.0090340236,
-0.00733406,
0.0048746355,
0.044131659,
0.0060457187,
-0.0610806644,
-0.0549826883,
-0.0191785041,
-0.0304672085,
0.0677206516,
-0.0145320781,
0.0109587861,
-0.0327456854,
0.029074071,
0.0147671616,
0.0634231418,
-0.0123106046,
0.1174836531,
-0.0477474295,
-0.0042550885,
-0.0052800435,
0.0406567119,
0.0660035461,
-0.0048310501,
0.0112372264,
0.0599136502,
-0.0019071052,
0.0431585796,
-0.0503643118,
-0.0136055164,
0.0361276604,
0.0052011199,
-0.005398239,
-0.0593179874,
-0.0188277867,
-0.0316374376,
0.0333664082,
0.0182153452,
0.0286412258,
-0.0296342615,
-0.0048583518,
-0.0189748555,
-0.0496403277,
-0.0400911458,
-0.0400095992,
0.0640658289,
-0.0101412907,
-0.0227960348,
-0.064580068,
-0.0001733015,
-0.0345161036,
0.0454401895,
0.018900238,
0.0313263834,
-0.00006015,
-0.0248376876,
0.0236927494,
-0.0682700798,
-0.0313005522,
-0.0216510892,
-0.0181640387,
-0.0502129719,
-0.0146512762,
0.0866322443,
0.0199378412,
0.0844867229,
0.0220009815,
-0.0654370636,
-0.0015928901,
0.0941269398,
-0.0264278743,
-0.0064803963,
0.0782809332,
-0.0211217366,
-0.0260136817,
-0.013360722,
-0.0339186154,
-0.0123836016,
0.011822178,
-0.010678296,
-0.0325284824,
0.0130461017,
0.0098020174,
-0.0291982871,
0.1156626269,
-0.060406968,
-0.0029760431,
-0.0083461525,
0.0023791266,
0.0054631201,
-0.0213349164,
-0.0161744598,
0.0270576533,
0.0016781816,
0.0088385493,
-0.0029744306,
-0.0116826827,
-0.0044427565,
0.0089495117,
-0.044426281,
0.0264876485,
0.0641193688,
0.0245845951,
-0.0308041126,
0.0290151797,
0.0197426639,
0.023517888,
0.0420297869,
0.0208557043,
0.0017363257,
0.0594512783,
0.0320438258,
0.0252254866,
-0.0455167741,
0.0321955271,
-0.057190951,
0.0360945389,
-0.0585837029,
0.0434742905,
0.0293506589,
-0.0077689486,
0.0033875718,
-0.0162981525,
0.0007848515,
0.0019064763,
0.0188120585,
0.0082001192,
-0.0477407649,
0.0121345287,
-0.0120491507,
-0.0088184578,
0.0063194893,
0.0292310175,
-0.004036638,
0.0576497428,
-0.100497134,
-0.0235602446,
-0.0356599577,
-0.0483664386,
0.0860384405,
0.0385456346,
-0.018772481,
0.0078547765,
-0.0689662099,
-0.051969137,
-0.0112152016,
0.0201416537,
0.043820601,
-0.0076945634,
0.0376888365,
0.040384531,
0.0036551596,
-0.0732267424,
-0.0095702335,
0.0137417028,
0.0177612361,
0.0326315388,
-0.0150772706,
-6.05708325e-33,
-0.0138874883,
-0.0165332127,
0.0020338553,
-0.0499930978,
-0.0013933232,
-0.0318543874,
0.0033389856,
0.0328337774,
0.0039944658,
0.0046563465,
0.0215023663,
-0.0264143609,
0.013469479,
0.0046351706,
0.0098995203,
0.0107928887,
0.0748237073,
-0.0025170981,
-0.0288514886,
0.0216973107,
-0.0032202289,
0.0174850319,
0.0285964869,
-0.1298223585,
0.0227980707,
0.0107363407,
-0.0373465419,
-0.0203717276,
-0.0480567329,
0.0450833514,
-0.0363349244,
0.0343119465,
0.0196265038,
0.005624698,
-0.0227368195,
-0.0059521957,
-0.0215642545,
-0.0003039531,
-0.0062216697,
0.0463193543,
-0.0309368391,
0.0066789063,
0.0473751053,
0.001676148,
-0.0590747558,
0.0233070869,
0.0511318482,
-0.029660169,
0.0211733785,
0.0557340272,
-0.038266737,
0.0063832891,
-0.0128789237,
0.0165020134,
0.0218447261,
0.1017188653,
0.0421026684,
0.0046334052,
-0.053343121,
0.0433923155,
0.0024031231,
-0.0710292906,
0.0790320411,
0.0558862947,
0.0122049106,
0.0399675034,
0.0496168621,
0.026646601,
0.0072128144,
-0.0174859706,
0.0172534026,
0.0535239838,
0.0369660556,
0.1022531241,
0.0693705678,
-0.0173283592,
-0.0017414447,
0.0304261781,
-0.0441087559,
-0.0015168221,
0.0085848663,
0.040805798,
-0.0339003243,
-0.0076641538,
-0.0188394673,
-0.0378893018,
-0.0108048292,
-0.0084298877,
0.0349799395,
0.0343143716,
0.0145384464,
0.0427579507,
0.0472056754,
-0.0264366027,
-0.046334859,
0.0122689018,
-0.0082058385,
0.0253547262,
0.0057733669,
-0.0130874673,
-0.0359492116,
0.0011957128,
0.0424373895,
0.0102177514,
0.0327918269,
-0.0198875833,
0.0483921804,
0.0109587023,
-0.0407328792,
0.0022208951,
-0.0100104073,
0.0062420061,
0.0235340074,
-0.0157172792,
0.0542723536,
-0.0088728881,
-0.0291731115,
0.0504736044,
-0.0120012639,
0.0173617918,
-0.0621205345,
-0.0489291288,
-0.0235588755,
0.0162447281,
-0.0147950705,
-0.0037338901,
0.0057362136,
-0.040687941,
-0.0080035515,
-0.084496811,
-0.0241238717,
0.0045907674,
2.665e-7,
-0.0005039597,
0.0171762165,
0.0174386743,
-0.027997857,
0.0598757975,
0.0834560469,
-0.0316808634,
0.0161318835,
0.0211570188,
0.0010969486,
0.0165490117,
0.0257691499,
0.0121139139,
0.0089795282,
0.0461291857,
-0.0203823876,
-0.0341351703,
0.0221732613,
-0.0215735342,
0.0308230817,
0.0415898226,
0.0290723648,
0.0279390663,
-0.0192764979,
0.0601281933,
0.0022846826,
0.0679975897,
-0.0254886504,
0.0307344496,
-0.0541396886,
0.0125401188,
0.017483091,
-0.0180498399,
0.0585076846,
-0.0263531003,
-0.0276217833,
-0.0255561825,
-0.0191165637,
-0.0341708325,
-0.0394078754,
-0.0283509176,
0.0806551427,
-0.0055788485,
-0.0094777495,
0.0446071513,
-0.006040582,
-0.0068623824,
-0.0515460186,
-0.0543712452,
0.0143252555,
0.031655021,
-0.0084645059,
-0.0513063259,
-0.0072283335,
0.0155975493,
0.0167182796,
-0.0463490076,
-0.0679950044,
-0.0381943136,
0.0250895694,
-0.0398820303,
-0.0245365519,
-0.0135090584,
0.043556273,
0.0369856469,
-0.0550075211,
-0.0134666814,
1.994615549e-34,
0.0442864783,
-0.0057354965,
0.0397256911,
-0.0398210138,
0.016585432,
0.0013058268,
0.006600738,
-0.0077847093,
0.0713434815,
-0.0016149353,
-0.0091487244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14081v2 | How to Solve Few-Shot Abusive Content Detection Using the Data We Actually Have | 2023-05-23T14:04:12 | 2024-05-06T07:41:19 | Viktor Hangya, Alexander Fraser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the broad range of social media platforms, the requirements of abusive
language detection systems are varied and ever-changing. Already a large set of
annotated corpora with different properties and label sets were created, such
as hate or misogyny detection, but the form and targets of abusive speech are
constantly evolving. Since, the annotation of new corpora is expensive, in this
work we leverage datasets we already have, covering a wide range of tasks
related to abusive language detection. Our goal is to build models cheaply for
a new target label set and/or language, using only a few training examples of
the target domain. We propose a two-step approach: first we train our model in
a multitask fashion. We then carry out few-shot adaptation to the target
requirements. Our experiments show that using already existing datasets and
only a few-shots of the target task the performance of models improve both
monolingually and across languages. Our analysis also shows that our models
acquire a general understanding of abusive language, since they improve the
prediction of labels which are present only in the target dataset and can
benefit from knowledge about labels which are not directly used for the target
task. | [
0.0687360838,
0.0438859202,
-0.0096392976,
0.0244569071,
0.0055843391,
0.0516566485,
0.0331466869,
0.0245914143,
0.0028915012,
-0.0817353204,
-0.0326474607,
-0.0253299829,
-0.0408885777,
0.0104579134,
0.0190253388,
-0.0574560948,
0.0267907195,
0.0209878962,
0.031076191,
0.0129408324,
0.0809367672,
-0.001093985,
-0.0070679309,
0.0057347757,
-0.0714120418,
0.0080289664,
0.0272265654,
0.020818809,
0.0130496807,
-0.0114559019,
0.0612726919,
0.0484457128,
0.016735645,
0.0665874705,
0.000001624,
-0.029145157,
0.0080133537,
0.0100968815,
0.0029133945,
-0.0482771434,
0.1040449142,
-0.0497934334,
-0.0223816708,
0.0198584236,
-0.0251043681,
0.0122450152,
0.0725816488,
0.0431156345,
0.0725525469,
0.0539067015,
-0.0169993155,
-0.0283343811,
-0.021175826,
0.0007856922,
0.0035726689,
-0.00620544,
0.0343787819,
-0.0497646704,
-0.0369378589,
0.0047643799,
-0.0165534038,
0.0286332238,
0.0078957407,
0.0083721299,
0.0333754569,
-0.0475989655,
-0.0324374512,
-0.0406999141,
0.0238769446,
0.0553994551,
-0.0707764849,
-0.0240954291,
-0.0248513259,
-0.0206613466,
0.0039444831,
-0.0486889593,
-0.0175564606,
-0.0151660563,
0.0006484931,
0.0283852909,
-0.0189716704,
0.0107965786,
0.0374081731,
0.0722102746,
0.0418683663,
-0.0290248096,
-0.0417650715,
-0.0269141272,
0.0183219686,
-0.0022268535,
-0.0048854374,
0.0043591135,
-0.0164588895,
0.003526818,
-0.0078150183,
0.0102259591,
-0.0710685998,
-0.0752637759,
0.0081988331,
-0.0770527124,
0.031332925,
0.0222479813,
-0.0403621159,
0.0073500373,
-0.0005479835,
0.0044205128,
0.0132369371,
0.0234936457,
-0.025676664,
-0.0270325057,
-0.0322690271,
0.0244785473,
-0.0267624576,
-0.0076052621,
0.0160756782,
0.071488671,
-0.0532530211,
-0.0144919483,
-0.0495924428,
-0.0328878909,
-0.0160952024,
0.0011813957,
-0.0272909794,
0.0125729088,
0.0054023229,
0.0028488531,
-0.0267251562,
0.0403753966,
-0.0287841056,
-0.0691648126,
-0.0038637668,
0.0306410939,
-0.014979315,
-0.01115207,
0.0482114814,
0.0810851231,
0.0304525159,
-0.0578550436,
-0.0549242646,
-0.0404679962,
-0.0206180364,
-0.0253315587,
0.0167039838,
-0.0697954148,
0.0214311182,
-0.0184094924,
-0.0286820047,
-0.0611498803,
0.0029688284,
0.0133265276,
-0.087311469,
0.0987944826,
-0.0200568922,
-0.0284155495,
0.0301632416,
0.0308086611,
-0.0276938099,
0.0820102096,
0.0349081941,
0.0280206092,
0.0513566285,
-0.0014848257,
0.0110813435,
0.0709607601,
0.0356406942,
0.0365142152,
-0.0122660566,
0.011722411,
-0.0512378775,
-0.0441953614,
-0.0008535365,
-0.0002273907,
0.007580847,
-0.0379765518,
0.0545329005,
0.0291187875,
-0.0074690217,
-0.0107061602,
0.053121563,
0.0063255723,
-0.0380932689,
-0.0668907315,
-0.0699619353,
-0.0126336776,
-0.027317483,
-0.0591324233,
0.0111300359,
0.0309754815,
-0.0228377655,
-0.0351953022,
-0.0273151286,
-0.0120019726,
0.014443337,
-0.0246891174,
0.042399697,
0.0547150336,
0.0069914171,
0.0156780239,
0.0585301183,
-0.0064539849,
-0.0182000101,
-0.0112407058,
0.0209885743,
0.0671900064,
0.0043233098,
-0.019710565,
-0.0018150822,
-0.0845619664,
0.0373879708,
0.0289828759,
0.0075151799,
-0.0205164682,
0.039961949,
-0.0171995964,
-0.0217851009,
0.0281677563,
-0.0110831428,
0.0009135649,
0.0649864674,
0.0117927724,
0.0021102848,
0.0272711329,
-0.0476142429,
0.0215721466,
0.0293569863,
-0.0424211025,
0.0252363849,
0.0314302444,
0.070431076,
0.0343710482,
-0.0279608443,
-0.0744710416,
0.0061580199,
-0.0113837207,
-0.0213962886,
0.0030800933,
-0.0164631661,
-0.0091161272,
0.0350158848,
-0.035683386,
-0.0223561339,
0.0182189383,
-0.0353576057,
0.0220114868,
0.0437062979,
-0.0235927124,
-0.0323440656,
-0.0198702663,
-0.0531763919,
-0.0332454294,
0.0429688878,
-0.008020415,
0.0442225337,
-0.0057908134,
-0.0142834056,
-0.0000534594,
-0.0444102585,
0.0256860219,
0.0409056991,
-0.0572023131,
-0.0428359509,
-0.0499253124,
0.0153953619,
0.0314670987,
0.0412517786,
-0.0156238107,
0.0113342153,
-0.0427486673,
-0.0046909819,
-0.0240766183,
-0.023646839,
0.0236658901,
0.0070396112,
-0.0127898399,
-0.0268391706,
-0.0057722926,
-0.0204441957,
0.0217370745,
0.0419929363,
-0.0016440372,
-0.0410280153,
0.0105237234,
-0.0352781713,
0.0098989839,
-0.0055465628,
0.0084940204,
-0.0131745236,
-0.075637877,
0.0299791675,
-0.0147516048,
0.0034449412,
0.038984701,
0.0004691081,
-0.0602106601,
0.0091132931,
0.0329652168,
-0.0393976159,
0.0326406248,
0.0155583471,
0.0890946537,
0.0274524353,
0.014345373,
-0.0192849021,
0.0261776503,
-0.006261379,
0.0087419897,
-0.011118887,
-0.0438042171,
-0.0160739087,
0.0822646469,
0.0038822559,
-0.0048539182,
-0.0422633886,
0.0210704077,
-0.0422904864,
-0.0579886474,
-0.0448096804,
-0.0319689587,
-0.0053293318,
-0.0199497212,
-0.0168122277,
-0.0539516956,
0.068386659,
0.016269993,
0.0170913935,
0.0038860401,
-0.0453875661,
0.0175036322,
0.0422304869,
0.0189809278,
0.0444514304,
0.0159427635,
0.0298010241,
-0.0047909403,
-0.0255420208,
0.0645976737,
0.0081715127,
-0.0130098825,
-0.0173597671,
-0.0066266665,
-0.0018095619,
-0.0611392222,
-0.054358568,
-0.0502032414,
-0.0303662978,
-0.03398408,
-0.0350926295,
0.0030165766,
-0.0418124944,
0.0066345711,
0.0329761989,
0.0049099345,
0.0055013774,
0.0012973158,
0.0252712872,
-0.0121334242,
0.0206792708,
-0.0237476546,
-0.0248280652,
0.0053269165,
-0.0034227928,
0.074295789,
-0.008387221,
0.0099482397,
0.0062454431,
0.0144162532,
0.022708619,
0.0197538119,
0.015913194,
-0.018057989,
0.0278198645,
-0.0084591135,
-0.0103079742,
0.0574123934,
0.0066065025,
-0.0086055193,
0.0058903461,
0.002806185,
0.0159074124,
0.0388130099,
0.0014529224,
-0.1086522639,
-0.0320335813,
-0.0298550874,
0.0479016304,
-0.082205385,
-0.0375504494,
-0.028754998,
-0.0851042494,
0.0063180979,
-0.0140195545,
-0.0581293926,
-0.0021712356,
0.0050332523,
0.0239768792,
-0.0378751308,
0.0190117657,
-0.0435189977,
0.0359049514,
-0.0241293367,
0.0131384684,
-0.0276638214,
-0.0331776254,
0.0160638429,
-0.0143027138,
0.0575441904,
0.0175677836,
0.0318319425,
-0.0356959663,
0.0302574746,
0.0272833146,
0.0337011926,
-0.0034241159,
-0.0319331922,
0.0659521818,
-0.0031788312,
-0.0493264422,
0.0055616042,
0.0501548834,
-0.0004528148,
-0.0133787571,
0.0058895275,
0.0434502922,
0.0594064817,
0.0199892558,
-0.0609492287,
-0.0121369623,
0.0418263152,
0.0727263689,
0.0225632228,
-0.0645044819,
0.0189041272,
-0.0478485338,
-0.0612472966,
-0.0476856977,
-0.0568312779,
0.01064796,
-0.0533041619,
-0.0429719426,
-0.0398761593,
-0.0308410395,
0.0499796607,
0.0131867472,
0.0089584421,
-0.0279925,
0.0079043172,
-0.0049816533,
-0.0495912209,
0.0003733512,
-0.0014492285,
0.0499699302,
-0.0011237471,
-0.0136407679,
-0.0080231847,
-0.004953438,
-0.0175010078,
0.0447706692,
-0.0695041642,
-0.0513386168,
0.0402742848,
0.0780442506,
0.0090591162,
0.0531885885,
-0.034644708,
-0.0671167523,
0.02997634,
0.0884616897,
-0.014693019,
-0.0271936543,
0.0589648299,
-0.0266709942,
0.0206852853,
0.0178693123,
-0.0379760042,
0.0506630652,
0.057756342,
-0.0629357845,
-0.0440447964,
0.0320386626,
-0.0098870117,
0.0050154729,
0.0496937037,
-0.0396120884,
-0.0703889504,
0.00286008,
-0.0161769073,
0.0015712052,
-0.0426246785,
-0.0093540782,
0.0281184576,
0.0116543425,
-0.0188026521,
-0.0443242565,
0.0010424978,
-0.0303935744,
0.0509521551,
-0.0454185829,
-0.0032186236,
0.0163219552,
0.0167181902,
0.0216434337,
0.0258823633,
0.0019352902,
0.0350423791,
0.0250579063,
-0.0245902818,
-0.0101113282,
0.0135084679,
0.0065665324,
0.0371174514,
0.0400847122,
-0.0054090777,
0.02064378,
0.0235478245,
-0.0701461583,
-0.007900469,
-0.0200812649,
-0.0218642764,
0.0556714796,
0.0151367178,
-0.0212763418,
0.0005385993,
-0.0056285798,
-0.044793833,
-0.0629943758,
0.0078370553,
0.0406122394,
-0.0040785209,
0.0279149152,
0.0580502823,
0.0223645288,
0.0316974074,
0.0414241664,
-0.0320949517,
-0.0349316821,
0.0228826776,
0.0348281711,
0.0273063965,
0.0077397488,
0.0404964201,
-0.0263644084,
-0.0397110768,
-0.016189903,
-0.0812078565,
0.0278363302,
0.0355431139,
0.0291355308,
0.0492334925,
0.0134727992,
0.03526932,
-0.0142203765,
-0.0150408996,
0.0574528798,
-0.0739724711,
0.0449329503,
-5.31790779e-33,
-0.0088870088,
-0.0055431449,
-0.0234713685,
-0.017515298,
0.0386150405,
-0.046074044,
0.0421344861,
-0.0031518189,
-0.0193576645,
0.0154251549,
0.018223865,
0.0060733482,
0.0029579585,
0.0070351446,
-0.0025569694,
-0.0067432676,
0.0188875683,
-0.0233302321,
-0.0153581314,
0.0039118566,
0.0480052866,
0.0155119579,
0.0541611351,
-0.0819698349,
0.042384129,
-0.0045856321,
-0.04782876,
0.0252276547,
0.0185240768,
0.0810592473,
-0.0095657436,
0.0945541859,
0.0377846844,
-0.0328157656,
-0.011390972,
0.0209934618,
-0.0539505929,
0.0039935866,
0.0014494032,
0.0293305293,
0.0130806193,
-0.0007496065,
0.0390343368,
0.0107941851,
-0.0184551738,
-0.0324508399,
0.0356181972,
-0.0485548303,
0.0318663903,
-0.0459152572,
-0.0695695654,
0.0196891837,
-0.0319257788,
-0.0395727754,
0.0019617362,
0.0462971553,
0.0216151886,
0.0127869863,
-0.06636215,
0.0040256092,
0.0002882353,
-0.0031915982,
0.0093778111,
-0.0331931263,
-0.0114339758,
0.0540242493,
-0.0089273723,
0.0182916038,
0.0103561478,
0.0136276186,
0.0124936849,
0.0543305166,
0.0354292728,
0.0870936364,
0.0368078649,
-0.0562393554,
-0.1029110923,
-0.0170812979,
0.03908398,
0.0151516283,
-0.0149810724,
-0.0195343196,
-0.0384692736,
-0.0275067277,
0.0010890807,
-0.0527615361,
-0.028608175,
-0.0342836045,
0.0193879195,
-0.0056137051,
-0.021312993,
0.0103548635,
0.0155975344,
-0.0546438433,
0.0052569392,
0.0277044624,
-0.0464930385,
0.0073613925,
0.0345126241,
0.0323087946,
-0.0375884771,
-0.0033312398,
0.0284378733,
-0.017012747,
0.0275304038,
-0.0036312263,
0.1529559195,
0.046189256,
-0.0702907369,
-0.0020900015,
-0.0157524087,
0.0814042762,
-0.0290410146,
0.0470808037,
-0.0101411287,
0.0486294068,
-0.0173045173,
0.0284152068,
0.0258159637,
-0.0214989055,
-0.0120291486,
0.0206535701,
-0.0388907753,
-0.0208567083,
0.0025383516,
-0.0258212201,
0.0012597111,
-0.0269298349,
0.0326993763,
-0.0825980231,
0.0175248235,
-0.0333013013,
2.429e-7,
-0.0015978168,
0.0473998077,
-0.0250826236,
0.0074489978,
0.0449190922,
0.055712983,
0.025014773,
0.0450619869,
-0.017199209,
-0.0288832225,
-0.0204514414,
0.0205848087,
0.0051683504,
0.0609818995,
-0.0408088863,
-0.0045462255,
-0.0762046874,
0.0048342529,
-0.0351495408,
0.0018646347,
0.0103459097,
0.1108522117,
0.0806275904,
-0.0549204126,
-0.0177803393,
-0.0255594682,
0.0194674209,
-0.0265882667,
-0.0205329694,
-0.0334650762,
0.0396425426,
0.0527581647,
0.0184208043,
-0.0142991953,
-0.0303634014,
-0.004763579,
-0.0123697082,
0.0269773398,
0.0034271989,
0.0146339899,
0.0075888643,
-0.007505219,
0.0018351331,
-0.0154381637,
0.0614495724,
-0.0197817702,
-0.0174896196,
-0.0431877188,
0.0083933743,
0.0206998456,
0.0112448679,
-0.030817477,
-0.0045976485,
-0.0080112163,
0.059895657,
-0.0205282886,
-0.0388804674,
-0.069880031,
-0.0110751996,
0.0169003569,
-0.0004637862,
-0.0192088373,
-0.0180464145,
0.0018633718,
0.0430501401,
-0.0055555329,
0.0434841253,
1.421461493e-34,
0.0068574389,
-0.0301140361,
0.0200820956,
-0.0209933408,
-0.0096934047,
0.0162057765,
-0.0206355639,
-0.0263500568,
0.0531992018,
-0.0062024882,
0.0056930319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14071v1 | Disentangled Variational Autoencoder for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-05-23T13:50:06 | 2023-05-23T13:50:06 | Kailai Yang, Tianlin Zhang, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC), the emotions of target
utterances are closely dependent on their context. Therefore, existing works
train the model to generate the response of the target utterance, which aims to
recognise emotions leveraging contextual information. However, adjacent
response generation ignores long-range dependencies and provides limited
affective information in many cases. In addition, most ERC models learn a
unified distributed representation for each utterance, which lacks
interpretability and robustness. To address these issues, we propose a
VAD-disentangled Variational AutoEncoder (VAD-VAE), which first introduces a
target utterance reconstruction task based on Variational Autoencoder, then
disentangles three affect representations Valence-Arousal-Dominance (VAD) from
the latent space. We also enhance the disentangled representations by
introducing VAD supervision signals from a sentiment lexicon and minimising the
mutual information between VAD distributions. Experiments show that VAD-VAE
outperforms the state-of-the-art model on two datasets. Further analysis proves
the effectiveness of each proposed module and the quality of disentangled VAD
representations. The code is available at
https://github.com/SteveKGYang/VAD-VAE. | [
0.0128174582,
0.123870343,
-0.020591313,
0.033938311,
0.0081171626,
0.0190895312,
-0.0220055319,
-0.0359552391,
0.0021148489,
-0.014690659,
-0.0281213671,
-0.0334002711,
-0.0235487483,
0.0957474411,
-0.0093834559,
-0.0750046149,
0.0141246328,
0.0327552781,
0.0026884836,
-0.0508654155,
0.0288432669,
0.005313681,
-0.030321449,
0.012600203,
-0.0329718292,
0.0278830156,
-0.0472322926,
0.0143244211,
0.0313633718,
0.0179401617,
0.0510177463,
0.0532076545,
0.0745288134,
-0.03618237,
0.0000023729,
0.0175955333,
0.0023695275,
-0.0548456609,
-0.049237892,
-0.0192716289,
0.04030082,
-0.0336620994,
-0.0168853048,
-0.0049609211,
-0.0078136278,
-0.0443754531,
0.0448527224,
0.0514356308,
0.0833968222,
0.0480989888,
-0.019848505,
-0.0230626315,
0.0242794286,
-0.0303417835,
0.0232935511,
-0.0287349448,
0.018316634,
0.0070220553,
-0.0005715376,
-0.0120449401,
-0.0705235079,
-0.0183538422,
0.0503940359,
-0.0054214937,
0.0249083061,
0.0048517534,
0.0292233564,
-0.0593949556,
-0.0405088775,
0.0700365379,
0.0087248702,
0.0069492264,
-0.036190182,
-0.0195333641,
-0.0288052093,
-0.0202878881,
0.0008581898,
-0.0042692297,
0.0562616959,
0.0274894685,
-0.0291322544,
0.0782608986,
-0.0185769349,
0.0063507599,
-0.0149070071,
-0.02343091,
0.0075526214,
-0.0003179866,
-0.0003410268,
-0.0072220117,
-0.0262897089,
0.0064930385,
0.0158568025,
-0.0333323963,
-0.0170115773,
-0.0293107126,
-0.028878551,
-0.0561057255,
-0.0432673804,
-0.0045170132,
-0.053446129,
0.0401911922,
-0.025068583,
-0.0063520065,
0.0023060923,
0.0463224053,
-0.0160997473,
-0.0475348718,
-0.0176172573,
-0.0336964615,
-0.025817249,
0.0156868678,
0.0269937292,
0.0423487835,
-0.0670362115,
-0.0739616379,
-0.0588975959,
-0.0123117436,
-0.0525810011,
0.0219544191,
-0.0334121324,
0.0802526921,
-0.0163905695,
0.0124662919,
0.0081220428,
0.0504334792,
-0.0391053334,
0.0212675575,
0.0001526047,
-0.023265196,
-0.0040243496,
0.0259524584,
0.0496281683,
-0.0178424343,
0.0239491258,
0.014482677,
-0.0224018153,
-0.0098957904,
0.0027888704,
0.0054769963,
-0.0226623267,
-0.0228845719,
0.015676856,
-0.034384694,
0.0536868647,
-0.0055392883,
0.0055899988,
-0.0087874662,
0.0255466085,
-0.074712716,
-0.0201291256,
0.071257472,
0.0171732325,
-0.03955568,
0.0229651257,
0.0214231145,
0.0628801808,
0.039685186,
-0.0135391271,
0.0767064169,
-0.0161492322,
0.0023657226,
0.0178096071,
-0.0249872804,
0.0246253107,
-0.0312407427,
-0.0323143937,
-0.0157465916,
-0.0348509774,
-0.0094708428,
0.0566818118,
0.045293469,
-0.0593574792,
-0.0219095573,
0.0210221671,
0.0141152749,
-0.0282646138,
0.0038599286,
-0.0532857478,
0.050239075,
-0.0240883045,
-0.0263876636,
-0.008260767,
0.0729390755,
-0.0148983337,
-0.0030451349,
0.0211107042,
0.0000055563,
-0.0378626175,
-0.038685143,
0.0413479246,
-0.0211911015,
0.0150031867,
0.0282657463,
0.0418751203,
0.0171325188,
-0.0594851114,
0.0151011283,
0.0346914828,
-0.037412867,
0.0112311803,
-0.015313644,
0.0014360922,
0.0444130786,
0.0206599049,
0.0176606122,
0.0056418255,
-0.0696771517,
-0.0238582622,
0.055296652,
-0.0121041294,
-0.0092073204,
0.0799841732,
-0.0593962073,
-0.0485772751,
-0.0342985652,
0.004610444,
0.0417241901,
-0.009174183,
-0.0049149618,
0.0054873321,
0.0234012343,
0.087985158,
-0.0251134411,
-0.0093576647,
0.0014598292,
0.0167370159,
0.0185889732,
0.0478579141,
0.0260764658,
-0.0244128611,
-0.0220899861,
0.0281949714,
-0.0430781767,
-0.0354906842,
-0.0097716441,
-0.0364073589,
-0.0832642466,
-0.0073907231,
-0.0355453379,
-0.014792976,
0.0404432602,
-0.0193922333,
-0.0688017681,
0.076810278,
-0.0195829086,
0.0135997664,
-0.0061994935,
-0.0250970181,
0.0073660244,
0.0596896894,
0.0072123399,
0.0300221778,
-0.0377668254,
-0.0072900318,
0.0112102041,
0.0689923167,
0.021529343,
0.0117117092,
-0.0531053096,
0.0022715679,
0.0033490122,
-0.0056268158,
0.0463796891,
0.0091124624,
-0.0208556671,
-0.0646049231,
-0.0769514516,
-0.0065030991,
-0.0316146351,
-0.0196838137,
0.0078313109,
0.0618081354,
-0.0145483604,
-0.0135716666,
-0.0104898028,
0.0330823772,
0.0275342353,
0.0126799308,
0.0019531683,
-0.0205999892,
0.0124310153,
-0.0501559898,
0.0157364756,
0.0152054969,
0.0328658782,
-0.0492084287,
-0.0031312923,
0.0425031967,
0.0059454781,
-0.0107946834,
0.0314093977,
-0.0106098335,
-0.0841909945,
-0.0051297583,
-0.006134273,
0.0469847284,
0.0263227932,
-0.0032982016,
0.1058330387,
0.0053686476,
-0.0167963021,
-0.044221051,
0.0466322973,
-0.0731500313,
0.0268703345,
-0.0162567515,
0.0078687752,
-0.0476563536,
0.0272106733,
0.0417580232,
0.0400790796,
-0.057361193,
0.0059356568,
0.0606303513,
-0.0577910431,
-0.003507996,
-0.0108427415,
-0.007468116,
0.0310148057,
-0.0394110233,
-0.0208983496,
0.0394063927,
0.0429999605,
-0.0374648347,
-0.0576787814,
-0.0088300351,
-0.0007141184,
0.0714572296,
0.0084254285,
0.0072013601,
-0.0353811383,
-0.035033986,
-0.0215936452,
-0.0076998691,
-0.0268882997,
-0.0135275619,
-0.0138767939,
0.0040812287,
-0.0216613468,
0.0422252566,
-0.0465123169,
-0.0479220748,
-0.0194092672,
-0.0056950063,
0.0195843801,
0.0506837144,
-0.0132581862,
-0.0247138198,
-0.055517219,
0.0200938247,
-0.0414324477,
-0.006466357,
0.0005763441,
-0.0179322027,
0.0744226053,
0.0873759091,
0.0066425726,
0.0116034523,
-0.0244798008,
0.0142443068,
0.0401588902,
-0.003898704,
0.0169254858,
-0.0325039402,
0.0690033287,
0.0172834825,
0.0475280359,
0.0443583764,
-0.0319705307,
0.025368087,
0.0078376802,
-0.0012303354,
0.0983560979,
-0.0037856023,
-0.046806477,
0.0089290962,
-0.0360551216,
0.031540364,
0.020239519,
0.0114578884,
-0.0403051004,
-0.019799931,
-0.0220795423,
-0.0118150357,
0.022753695,
0.0162291527,
0.0237297341,
-0.0555294193,
0.0136564709,
0.0113127371,
0.0071215592,
-0.075330548,
-0.0326795578,
0.0263012256,
-0.0343588553,
0.0245346595,
-0.0568022393,
0.0543834157,
-0.0034386285,
0.0132117774,
0.0386834219,
-0.0702197105,
0.0115311416,
-0.0018398913,
0.0821261927,
0.085643217,
0.0558021702,
-0.0114552211,
0.0044015995,
-0.0044440357,
-0.0463870764,
-0.036380928,
-0.0292647406,
0.0676361471,
-0.0100782569,
-0.0237958264,
-0.0090376139,
0.0450417288,
-0.0529448465,
-0.0044751298,
-0.0400236063,
0.0173839647,
-0.0438239798,
-0.0207827892,
-0.03674566,
-0.0008457711,
0.0328428112,
0.0300737396,
0.0339016393,
-0.0446800701,
-0.033192087,
-0.0127531756,
0.0626222566,
-0.0321337059,
-0.0078799045,
-0.0241808631,
0.0464333929,
-0.04661965,
-0.0238201637,
-0.0533752032,
-0.0127628371,
0.0007512404,
-0.0309095532,
-0.0525294058,
0.0064960234,
-0.0267926194,
-0.0312525518,
-0.0022714559,
0.0719332099,
-0.0000563527,
0.0134810274,
-0.0191133842,
0.0111656617,
-0.0461955629,
-0.0238375459,
-0.0379177108,
-0.0589912795,
-0.0497045517,
0.0064410595,
0.0559610389,
0.0085818488,
0.0565246753,
0.0336739086,
-0.0085862977,
0.0432027467,
0.011135038,
-0.0272678826,
0.0135216936,
0.0395725295,
0.0639789104,
-0.0294048153,
-0.0013815662,
-0.0248741992,
0.070424825,
0.0182040967,
0.0140795177,
-0.0009649753,
-0.0665022731,
-0.0284813158,
-0.0535897948,
0.0336498283,
0.0264676586,
-0.0254679061,
-0.0391435362,
-0.015802227,
-0.0002902256,
0.015025896,
-0.0652040839,
-0.0012396869,
0.0282098353,
0.0089673148,
-0.026556598,
-0.0268910844,
0.0363265462,
0.0038461224,
-0.0279730316,
0.0105824983,
0.0002804405,
0.0103380429,
-0.0288843401,
0.0391816422,
0.0025486408,
0.0217253119,
0.0340849534,
0.0001165378,
-0.0041650115,
0.0347576477,
0.0179333966,
-0.0424650945,
-0.00416916,
0.0201918166,
-0.0662301108,
0.0210314989,
-0.0575329661,
-0.0034897963,
0.0008784768,
-0.0092906216,
0.0547068939,
-0.0380749628,
0.0322400443,
-0.0169735868,
0.0325297229,
-0.0441402346,
-0.0318363495,
0.0212265328,
0.0022630556,
-0.0066671087,
-0.0116421841,
0.0424766727,
-0.0280953422,
0.0414766744,
-0.0082616201,
0.0333555825,
-0.0694265068,
-0.0126571469,
0.0764800683,
0.0372917056,
0.0252833888,
0.082019344,
0.0136942975,
-0.0077077933,
0.0021163493,
-0.0171764921,
-0.0082516167,
-0.0056587323,
0.0479155332,
0.021277396,
-0.0192214586,
-0.0182057042,
-0.0296643507,
0.0244011562,
-0.0098271398,
-0.0208575558,
-0.0279951114,
-7.03842377e-33,
-0.0108500989,
-0.0094232447,
-0.0712981969,
-0.0357279852,
-0.0257332232,
0.0334695987,
-0.0480667837,
-0.0078834426,
0.0064470214,
0.0306264181,
0.0289269965,
0.0606429912,
-0.006372774,
0.0708572417,
0.0072729182,
-0.0320711471,
0.0795936137,
0.018444987,
0.0383341312,
0.0398331098,
0.0371865481,
0.0615750924,
0.0346529,
-0.1459167898,
-0.0081176255,
-0.0032685613,
0.0066438192,
-0.0120340167,
0.0335994102,
0.0144851804,
-0.0348854251,
0.0421295203,
-0.0256259628,
0.0123666804,
-0.0219433121,
-0.0168604944,
-0.0501765721,
-0.04768648,
-0.0424333997,
0.0170925763,
-0.0288708266,
-0.011185918,
0.0349000245,
0.0152056506,
0.0174321495,
-0.0418817922,
0.0119818123,
0.0171932969,
0.0142872138,
-0.0903822258,
-0.0194552168,
-0.0018242463,
-0.0243627355,
-0.0521218479,
0.0529109798,
0.0189591441,
0.0217861515,
0.0065019797,
-0.0509194918,
0.0033135661,
-0.013813585,
0.0065344949,
0.0179080125,
0.0042534913,
0.0195730142,
0.084105514,
0.0371916294,
-0.027827993,
-0.0301278103,
0.0197920911,
-0.025987938,
0.0542155653,
-0.0088719651,
0.012206669,
0.0126539031,
-0.0151441684,
-0.0214651618,
0.0223464426,
0.0063939495,
0.0515045859,
0.0102554085,
0.0431164429,
-0.0176740792,
-0.0469599031,
-0.0078446968,
-0.0282871127,
-0.006003323,
-0.0257802214,
0.0207261387,
-0.000692467,
-0.0208413918,
-0.0333024226,
0.0158944055,
-0.0328695327,
-0.0034762993,
0.078928262,
-0.005557002,
0.0356850289,
0.0191266667,
0.0026354068,
-0.0204758868,
-0.0141514782,
0.0692479461,
-0.0182930771,
0.0065638898,
0.0081542647,
-0.0514530092,
0.0375074595,
-0.010683855,
-0.0441699624,
-0.0372167788,
0.0269273799,
-0.0082345344,
0.0378518365,
-0.0256978273,
0.0329334326,
-0.0244373418,
0.039582748,
-0.0206951797,
0.065036431,
-0.0113644861,
-0.059222769,
0.0245554429,
0.0756035447,
-0.0532153472,
-0.0203857198,
-0.0260274317,
-0.0169870686,
0.0071103699,
-0.0368067995,
0.0159843974,
-0.0081893168,
2.967e-7,
0.0019615341,
0.0222176183,
0.0522850007,
-0.0367505737,
0.0344653279,
0.0619870722,
0.01118185,
0.0260169189,
-0.0099891657,
-0.0478119254,
0.0326494277,
0.0479341149,
0.0511943996,
-0.0023772439,
-0.0147702638,
0.0211114977,
-0.0172535814,
-0.0463861264,
0.0018208845,
-0.0027493539,
0.1119856909,
0.0885217562,
0.0249716174,
0.0176417381,
0.0411043614,
0.0853293017,
0.052332662,
-0.0245406665,
-0.0176289324,
-0.0001202275,
-0.0235486124,
-0.0287156031,
0.0067182966,
0.0064580366,
0.0077527785,
0.0296379756,
0.0163788106,
0.0372794457,
0.0066989223,
-0.0806609616,
-0.030637959,
0.0336558931,
-0.0091475276,
0.0288623869,
0.0334710255,
-0.0812428668,
-0.048296582,
-0.0124642169,
-0.0334601328,
0.0430332348,
0.0582755841,
-0.0145802842,
-0.0390182175,
-0.0190820266,
0.008848194,
-0.006241424,
-0.0462065488,
-0.088510938,
0.0319457948,
0.0053522908,
-0.0593970791,
0.0054261549,
-0.0222623013,
0.0269235764,
0.0298050269,
0.0143258236,
-0.0254706331,
2.349490176e-34,
-0.0032379357,
0.0164811257,
-0.0380718298,
0.0306720585,
0.0264311563,
-0.0418860242,
-0.0423454829,
-0.0158396754,
0.0260243732,
-0.0286244489,
-0.0199654978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14070v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14070v2 | Assessing Linguistic Generalisation in Language Models: A Dataset for Brazilian Portuguese | 2023-05-23T13:49:14 | 2023-06-07T08:53:08 | Rodrigo Wilkens, Leonardo Zilio, Aline Villavicencio | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much recent effort has been devoted to creating large-scale language models.
Nowadays, the most prominent approaches are based on deep neural networks, such
as BERT. However, they lack transparency and interpretability, and are often
seen as black boxes. This affects not only their applicability in downstream
tasks but also the comparability of different architectures or even of the same
model trained using different corpora or hyperparameters. In this paper, we
propose a set of intrinsic evaluation tasks that inspect the linguistic
information encoded in models developed for Brazilian Portuguese. These tasks
are designed to evaluate how different language models generalise information
related to grammatical structures and multiword expressions (MWEs), thus
allowing for an assessment of whether the model has learned different
linguistic phenomena. The dataset that was developed for these tasks is
composed of a series of sentences with a single masked word and a cue phrase
that helps in narrowing down the context. This dataset is divided into MWEs and
grammatical structures, and the latter is subdivided into 6 tasks: impersonal
verbs, subject agreement, verb agreement, nominal agreement, passive and
connectors. The subset for MWEs was used to test BERTimbau Large, BERTimbau
Base and mBERT. For the grammatical structures, we used only BERTimbau Large,
because it yielded the best results in the MWE task. | [
0.0222237818,
0.0691978782,
-0.0185527578,
0.0477336831,
-0.0307833757,
0.011437214,
-0.0251138881,
0.0118286675,
-0.0623868257,
-0.0321647003,
-0.0838263407,
-0.0795100555,
-0.0026496539,
-0.0001370866,
0.0355727337,
-0.0342327096,
0.048963137,
-0.0003952739,
-0.0086610317,
-0.0086962841,
0.0045561092,
-0.0033705311,
0.0114817582,
0.0291852206,
-0.0167818423,
-0.0012711576,
-0.0093759345,
-0.037415836,
0.0035948188,
0.0267982613,
0.0236674044,
0.0487939119,
0.0042207339,
0.0210349318,
0.0000020317,
-0.0764701217,
-0.0089596277,
-0.0203192327,
-0.0158895906,
0.0188286044,
0.0290036127,
0.0129729966,
-0.0075558643,
-0.0088619338,
-0.0839405209,
-0.0210684501,
0.0331330113,
0.0290141292,
0.0363352858,
0.0609315261,
-0.0192295443,
-0.0342280716,
0.0225812625,
-0.0251778141,
-0.0299171116,
-0.0151103865,
0.0162803493,
-0.0185605492,
-0.0179588627,
-0.0346021391,
0.0102985222,
0.0152994012,
0.0375335924,
0.0042463499,
-0.0231185853,
-0.013360179,
-0.0522463918,
-0.0665407553,
-0.0021019026,
0.0559521057,
-0.0158210117,
-0.0093645984,
-0.0176906325,
0.0082538147,
-0.006397658,
0.0260627121,
-0.0290886424,
0.0180691686,
0.0238251314,
0.0266248491,
0.0202645753,
-0.0122289732,
0.0326241031,
0.0425988361,
-0.0307159685,
0.0703803301,
0.0260850694,
-0.0371347666,
0.0431356505,
-0.0110975122,
-0.0447707064,
-0.040481627,
-0.0042639705,
0.0163432211,
-0.0259257387,
0.0379923433,
-0.0155795086,
-0.0280111898,
0.0515183844,
-0.0954685584,
0.0470086783,
-0.0130383885,
-0.0442381166,
0.027046185,
-0.0270212516,
0.0599726886,
-0.0316457935,
0.039699059,
-0.0312178638,
-0.041237805,
-0.0601356253,
-0.0274391025,
-0.0202191975,
0.0546282344,
-0.0206737462,
-0.0184104033,
-0.0405949242,
-0.0000779078,
-0.0088788243,
0.0036640821,
0.0069201868,
0.0122987079,
-0.0261613168,
0.0043349094,
-0.0274015591,
-0.0069921734,
-0.0540194362,
0.041350428,
-0.0050387597,
-0.069883965,
0.0218314528,
0.0114964666,
-0.0121094221,
-0.0302776936,
0.0159627609,
0.0132901222,
-0.0147323003,
-0.052613195,
-0.022389967,
-0.0229404923,
-0.0606112927,
-0.0855813175,
0.0248142425,
-0.0546564646,
0.0186047126,
-0.0123768644,
0.0120173879,
-0.0192320403,
-0.0031849667,
-0.0042897719,
0.0277101845,
0.0381774902,
0.0178037677,
-0.0017060145,
0.0168661624,
0.0057273889,
0.0353488177,
0.0796657652,
0.02782337,
0.0055031213,
0.0379721075,
-0.012611554,
-0.0053443899,
0.0651451051,
0.0099144001,
0.0120492009,
-0.025852222,
0.0060223956,
-0.0007958825,
0.0183659606,
0.0102882683,
0.0817447975,
-0.0209725536,
0.0199803151,
0.0309162326,
0.0215730425,
0.0077673555,
0.0188260451,
0.0905212015,
-0.033069253,
0.0396902412,
0.0464437976,
-0.0103874439,
-0.0428271554,
0.0084598307,
0.003859675,
-0.02520594,
0.0318951458,
-0.0205791406,
-0.0423028618,
-0.0304743275,
-0.0191436838,
0.0200814866,
-0.0326901525,
0.0781462044,
0.0377475359,
-0.0048651677,
0.0469862707,
0.0289966296,
-0.0603376664,
-0.0057504848,
-0.0836405978,
0.0349631086,
-0.0183318928,
0.0145575898,
-0.0223012436,
-0.02843716,
0.0113678016,
-0.0281035416,
0.0292876512,
0.0393651463,
-0.0202114657,
0.0446770526,
-0.0575377792,
0.0063520255,
-0.0042363205,
0.0427722447,
0.0535510331,
-0.026823787,
-0.0131573863,
0.0203778557,
-0.0555158891,
-0.0299517419,
0.0558602922,
-0.0093038203,
0.0021663615,
0.0106152268,
0.0156276543,
0.0488904566,
0.0410356037,
0.0044846847,
-0.0003716287,
0.0476782992,
-0.0218673665,
-0.0130374562,
0.0338535011,
-0.0222809687,
0.0112054255,
0.0125013823,
-0.0573347881,
-0.0134081999,
0.0709148869,
-0.0103115011,
-0.0621407181,
0.0004359026,
-0.0303657055,
0.0794148073,
-0.0423247218,
0.0293450821,
-0.0455518439,
0.0554834828,
0.0023136234,
0.069585979,
-0.007665107,
0.0351562612,
0.0190792121,
-0.0207897238,
0.0411573797,
-0.0415993929,
-0.0605119206,
0.023829734,
-0.0218359921,
-0.017442679,
0.0356676504,
0.0415887274,
-0.0578268245,
-0.0117577463,
-0.1294697672,
-0.0015557143,
-0.0364161022,
0.039089933,
0.0364073329,
0.0154608097,
0.0097587248,
-0.0054900139,
-0.0022217045,
-0.0224778801,
-0.0056772535,
0.0111886188,
0.0436864756,
-0.0068037906,
-0.025050655,
-0.059821628,
-0.0022866647,
-0.0197521839,
0.0815024897,
0.0179942288,
-0.000916995,
-0.0181251708,
0.0000950466,
-0.0294550005,
0.0196860749,
0.0103450734,
-0.0765942186,
0.0307944082,
0.0102968113,
0.020241864,
0.0709630176,
-0.0074360319,
0.0468821712,
0.023613859,
0.0340085886,
-0.0523239821,
-0.0104608927,
0.0028266143,
-0.0017000856,
-0.0607389659,
-0.030743964,
0.0193472523,
0.1069189012,
0.0119938506,
-0.0173285045,
-0.0177158993,
-0.0037687814,
-0.0425509401,
-0.0496742837,
-0.0128587689,
-0.0276638214,
-0.0468763672,
0.0114124268,
-0.00462115,
-0.0450528972,
0.0514469966,
-0.0452869199,
-0.0184313376,
-0.0734718516,
-0.0201744698,
-0.0297528692,
0.0690076873,
0.0069010924,
0.003659344,
-0.0174359847,
-0.0249257982,
-0.0454019494,
0.0140591655,
0.031569019,
0.002501244,
0.0401185155,
-0.0647549033,
-0.0095388209,
0.0277306922,
-0.0427533872,
-0.0145815546,
-0.0363229103,
-0.0053859702,
0.0439124517,
0.0421713628,
0.0159037262,
-0.0075930026,
-0.0134399785,
-0.0030163061,
0.0142492186,
-0.0184458531,
0.0125899483,
-0.0206609163,
0.030760562,
0.0299962573,
0.0079452991,
-0.0004371229,
-0.0428208075,
-0.0078894123,
-0.007787725,
0.0122075435,
0.032127481,
-0.0835557953,
0.01605721,
0.0011930309,
-0.0166491028,
-0.0545361415,
-0.0327601209,
0.0483904816,
-0.0260606501,
-0.0027537912,
0.0841623917,
0.0440136194,
-0.0276968777,
0.0231481232,
-0.0028558276,
0.0295100827,
-0.0017802063,
0.0061591365,
-0.0417815894,
-0.0113644702,
-0.0011206984,
-0.0350854993,
-0.0302023962,
0.0031497821,
0.0094413096,
-0.1093819961,
-0.0141427554,
-0.040842481,
-0.0305954535,
0.0055010719,
-0.0298584346,
0.005499756,
-0.0284438878,
0.0644463673,
-0.0246638339,
0.0210844148,
-0.0258635357,
0.0349805094,
-0.02843659,
-0.1008110791,
0.022929607,
-0.0447371006,
0.0256885886,
0.0724759176,
0.0308543853,
-0.0398388766,
-0.0193238165,
0.0901558399,
0.0064928541,
0.0156548098,
0.0026560524,
0.0333667845,
0.0188691057,
-0.0162086803,
-0.003375666,
0.0199761968,
0.0030899551,
0.0140455402,
-0.0098181181,
0.0629346892,
-0.0074283076,
-0.0124463476,
-0.0176687818,
-0.0566118211,
-0.0185583737,
0.0346091129,
0.0480792597,
-0.056132704,
0.0011208997,
0.0023838393,
-0.000006201,
-0.0280444771,
0.0156734083,
0.0547082722,
-0.0384340174,
-0.0273375772,
-0.0742953792,
-0.0614100695,
0.0202445481,
0.0118354615,
0.0036544632,
-0.0481208265,
-0.0007573072,
-0.0038932732,
-0.010502927,
0.0513431951,
0.0365657359,
-0.0008858461,
-0.0385230891,
-0.0147216422,
0.0445798486,
0.0169311762,
-0.0537248068,
-0.0104669584,
-0.0693673864,
-0.0559688136,
0.0192842614,
0.0379310362,
0.027472686,
0.0266140811,
-0.0467502326,
-0.0757103115,
0.0108663291,
-0.012385549,
-0.0453144051,
0.0036713067,
0.0495411754,
-0.0269016437,
-0.0193195064,
0.0379768088,
-0.0254104659,
0.0260467995,
0.0165630542,
0.0214616153,
-0.0079079987,
-0.0125277555,
0.0235800613,
0.029943129,
0.0606645867,
-0.0080615124,
0.0011948626,
-0.0446202271,
0.0013232471,
0.0164192598,
0.0017935773,
-0.0355802588,
0.0365887992,
0.0435111709,
0.01422951,
-0.0217857938,
0.0010564091,
-0.0251450576,
0.0093775485,
-0.0136611667,
-0.003445609,
0.0584895015,
0.0109318169,
-0.0144876698,
0.0243091173,
-0.021811543,
0.0273387451,
-0.0265703481,
-0.008292919,
-0.0266980045,
0.035552755,
0.0113337692,
0.0093687791,
0.0196189228,
0.0361472666,
-0.0205259975,
0.0190719534,
-0.0461179502,
0.0148502169,
0.0458102413,
-0.0192618445,
0.0631255135,
-0.0163791794,
0.0105665205,
-0.0146768298,
0.0210865885,
-0.0088758785,
-0.0052461955,
0.05248788,
0.0072030653,
-0.024407953,
0.0064402116,
0.0655646399,
-0.024318872,
0.0370500162,
-0.0238843765,
0.0148550607,
-0.0417416766,
0.0062505407,
0.0737589449,
-0.0151398247,
-0.0365600921,
0.0046583209,
-0.0299232174,
-0.0639091805,
-0.002885201,
0.0309450105,
0.008767046,
0.016195083,
0.0437597558,
0.1128180027,
-0.0218843166,
-0.0024333999,
-0.0273243822,
-0.0385592431,
0.007694548,
0.0234109424,
-0.0484619811,
-6.396672915e-33,
-0.0179457497,
-0.0067004487,
-0.0114742527,
-0.0520272925,
-0.0130432276,
0.0046766847,
-0.0173838716,
0.0079169283,
-0.0279410202,
0.0460233428,
-0.003841141,
0.0264034979,
0.0216028243,
0.0187699143,
0.027782185,
-0.0235120486,
0.0110185537,
-0.0101236701,
-0.023925513,
-0.0428583361,
0.0205733906,
0.029512547,
0.1306002289,
-0.0213655569,
0.0621279106,
0.006827374,
-0.0431138165,
0.0207375064,
-0.0442439243,
0.0991979763,
-0.0108698318,
0.0205132253,
0.0222973675,
-0.0332438499,
-0.0143223247,
0.0435981229,
-0.0323015787,
-0.0704631507,
0.0705264062,
0.0277241729,
-0.0690980405,
-0.0329218842,
0.0742064863,
-0.0230703577,
-0.0028556585,
0.036961589,
0.0419072583,
-0.0086297421,
0.0086701941,
-0.0271772835,
-0.0426747799,
0.031789761,
-0.0019429255,
-0.0035739779,
0.0059816455,
0.0587529019,
-0.0632506236,
-0.0502066463,
-0.0198286232,
0.0190664101,
0.0100599183,
0.0316918716,
0.0654833764,
0.0147253396,
0.0053573051,
0.0537238903,
0.0379445963,
-0.0519287512,
0.0065328227,
0.0011530117,
0.1044460535,
0.0665067285,
0.0228615701,
0.0660585761,
0.018747868,
0.0313106589,
-0.0689487681,
-0.014367898,
0.0376860127,
0.0359670073,
0.0112261474,
-0.0244724099,
-0.017120745,
-0.005797415,
-0.0588340834,
-0.0257588867,
-0.0256510377,
-0.0278312657,
0.0345112495,
-0.0345167331,
-0.0149903279,
-0.0003768522,
0.0028520913,
-0.0395286903,
-0.0243857317,
-0.0087631522,
-0.019549245,
0.0361009017,
0.0195178129,
0.0376465507,
-0.0197478905,
-0.0318127461,
-0.017266633,
0.0619172193,
0.045905374,
0.0037932901,
0.0375745967,
-0.0046087294,
-0.0269231461,
0.0135673592,
-0.0315618031,
-0.0428176969,
-0.0248774942,
0.03570728,
0.0357786827,
0.0174485389,
-0.0362830721,
0.0586501621,
-0.0008791219,
0.0247421712,
-0.0492821187,
-0.0245847162,
0.0192039236,
0.0610404536,
-0.0292703062,
-0.0303965043,
-0.013569315,
0.0084841978,
0.054732129,
-0.0081236456,
0.0015964833,
0.0277040321,
2.789e-7,
0.0532768369,
0.04615191,
0.0121512134,
0.0164500233,
0.0044415132,
0.0146447746,
-0.0242537744,
0.0169653967,
-0.0413062051,
-0.0046687191,
0.021585308,
-0.0015740844,
0.0512287505,
0.0218546707,
-0.0764873475,
-0.0229989719,
-0.0995762125,
-0.0180523712,
-0.0219793562,
0.0156748481,
-0.0023873865,
0.1287851483,
0.0162510239,
-0.0069779032,
-0.0593940429,
-0.04166146,
0.0414958298,
-0.02862297,
-0.0368663743,
0.0456797741,
0.0476148278,
0.014872184,
-0.0043468806,
0.0342869274,
0.0031138712,
0.0499429554,
0.0203800648,
0.0624614023,
-0.0202558786,
0.0279213507,
0.0166327786,
-0.0259106085,
-0.0345262736,
-0.0689975098,
0.0687658638,
-0.0579025112,
-0.0297794305,
-0.0132246641,
0.0255006943,
-0.006808056,
0.0470387414,
-0.03573801,
0.0065843733,
0.0203104727,
0.0310931802,
-0.047347907,
-0.0396647416,
-0.0430833213,
-0.0151016321,
0.032498274,
-0.0507399738,
-0.0466563888,
-0.0118822744,
-0.0266552679,
0.029883584,
-0.0830064341,
0.0183492731,
2.179009516e-34,
0.0276924931,
-0.0115915025,
0.0077254511,
0.0232142936,
0.0337968506,
-0.0274023749,
-0.0399892628,
0.0150265545,
-0.0095548257,
-0.0488910377,
0.0191364177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14069v2 | Evaluating Factual Consistency of Summaries with Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T13:48:32 | 2023-10-12T06:20:42 | Shiqi Chen, Siyang Gao, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting factual errors in summaries has been an important and challenging
subject in summarization research. Inspired by the emergent ability of large
language models (LLMs), we explore evaluating factual consistency of summaries
by directly prompting LLMs. We present a comprehensive empirical study to
assess the ability of LLMs as factual consistency evaluators, which consists of
(1) analyzing different LLMs such as the GPT model series and Flan-T5; (2)
investigating a variety of prompting methods including vanilla prompting,
chain-of-thought prompting, and a sentence-by-sentence prompting method to
tackle long summaries; and (3) evaluating on diverse summaries generated by
multiple summarization systems, ranging from pre-transformer methods to SOTA
pretrained models. Our experiments demonstrate that prompting LLMs is able to
outperform the previous best factuality systems in all settings, by up to 12.2
absolute points in terms of the binary classification accuracy on inconsistency
detection. | [
0.0599851944,
0.0195793398,
0.014671348,
0.0211405288,
-0.0215208158,
0.0188161153,
-0.0061217202,
-0.0488786697,
-0.0195917487,
-0.0458164029,
0.0095206955,
-0.0367069058,
0.0485155024,
0.0010091084,
0.0032180124,
-0.0616051108,
0.0531781763,
-0.0115987593,
-0.0038301577,
-0.0103152608,
0.0309792534,
0.0244137868,
0.0011543701,
0.0348739214,
-0.0176642574,
-0.0250117853,
0.0027439964,
-0.01398886,
0.049578581,
-0.0278765727,
0.0024455767,
0.0192365777,
0.0180248469,
0.0689253956,
0.0000018966,
-0.0795620605,
-0.0136325974,
0.0009129166,
-0.0435442105,
0.0687387437,
0.0096213538,
-0.0118540404,
0.0115283765,
0.0207996964,
0.007419215,
-0.0027710877,
0.0096988259,
0.0720100924,
0.1117621288,
0.0449909903,
0.003727121,
-0.0366169214,
0.0108223604,
-0.0027929088,
-0.0614195913,
0.0027562729,
0.01834259,
0.0397295766,
-0.024624588,
0.0160567705,
-0.0029791037,
0.0238647833,
0.0015395484,
-0.0058188559,
-0.0212466251,
0.0321920738,
-0.0626610741,
-0.0228273924,
0.0021953559,
0.0637414604,
0.0440479517,
-0.0180455316,
-0.0163048357,
0.0114386668,
0.0033545317,
0.0037825322,
-0.0309555158,
0.0725953132,
-0.0324491113,
0.026280662,
0.0089702159,
0.0188432988,
-0.0047363727,
0.0287612155,
-0.0107734865,
0.0340391025,
0.0007022853,
-0.0428548902,
-0.0252808705,
0.0301764235,
-0.028669985,
-0.0919685513,
0.0035867719,
0.0200048555,
-0.0258407928,
-0.0239537153,
-0.0602808334,
-0.0229981411,
0.0324124247,
-0.0392099135,
0.0241938233,
-0.004016737,
-0.0581485406,
0.0314211175,
-0.0073757838,
0.0681716353,
0.0436156578,
0.018514242,
-0.0288691316,
0.0129871415,
-0.0128569063,
0.0151576921,
-0.0401524827,
0.0303283036,
-0.0293324143,
-0.0171835236,
-0.0415239446,
-0.0003635905,
0.0112171341,
0.053288877,
-0.021895662,
-0.0197830237,
0.0215860717,
0.0063672108,
-0.0513354391,
0.034172155,
-0.0207313169,
0.0048686559,
0.0194729455,
-0.0224913228,
-0.0332139693,
0.0093087722,
-0.0164884627,
0.0092654992,
0.0062503568,
-0.0266287681,
-0.0320724659,
-0.0217454582,
-0.0430915244,
-0.0225164071,
-0.031090416,
-0.0705100596,
-0.0487989299,
-0.0614957511,
-0.0115037533,
-0.0021530024,
-0.0023104749,
0.0309230033,
0.0041688285,
0.0306611825,
-0.023447657,
0.0381199382,
-0.0200355332,
0.0162186418,
0.0245296229,
-0.0015987313,
0.0124637773,
0.0169331376,
0.0416107513,
0.0391544662,
0.0723428354,
0.0619844384,
0.0071857916,
0.0083615081,
-0.0180035997,
0.010260052,
0.0301631819,
-0.0031896003,
-0.0265015587,
0.0046656206,
0.0302219465,
0.0891334638,
-0.0268224105,
0.0264663249,
0.0818507746,
0.0271216482,
0.0194624495,
0.0296128113,
0.0624705069,
0.0348560698,
0.0644044802,
0.070815593,
-0.0400102995,
-0.0005562165,
-0.0520131253,
0.0635009184,
0.0827379823,
0.0656063929,
-0.0195579063,
-0.0621655472,
-0.0328030065,
0.0192303602,
-0.0316290334,
-0.0076957359,
0.0081208907,
-0.0100665316,
-0.0556087717,
0.0379036218,
-0.0050295233,
-0.0741777271,
-0.0181480553,
-0.0369980447,
0.0480088554,
0.0492479615,
0.0513650812,
-0.0155338002,
-0.022144923,
-0.0258798711,
0.0045300107,
0.0415495597,
0.0407118611,
-0.0247358587,
-0.0193370394,
-0.025832206,
-0.0005959537,
-0.0068840729,
0.0509212539,
-0.0149910459,
-0.0078633968,
0.0033322757,
0.0364868268,
-0.0069376472,
-0.0507826395,
0.0264261197,
0.0175707676,
-0.0020812422,
-0.0294947792,
-0.0108602419,
-0.0053511746,
0.0358681679,
-0.0529687256,
0.0000808877,
-0.000667932,
0.0085395155,
-0.0160192661,
0.0054945699,
-0.042023167,
-0.0494313762,
0.0411977023,
-0.0105289584,
-0.0244445745,
0.009350284,
-0.0462228507,
-0.039010413,
-0.0162257049,
-0.0621757209,
-0.0403524712,
-0.0559436083,
0.0378501192,
0.0150924874,
0.0070038862,
0.0046610832,
0.0513519123,
0.0123598324,
-0.0104701957,
0.0468354672,
-0.0273244232,
0.0217132308,
-0.044481203,
-0.0073568635,
0.009136037,
0.0123121515,
0.0310212187,
0.0535631403,
0.0143404044,
-0.012302204,
-0.0204458591,
-0.1184906885,
-0.0019492523,
-0.0444306023,
-0.0022451221,
0.0363003239,
-0.014478907,
-0.0306785181,
0.0096127857,
-0.0101001719,
-0.0536390096,
0.0398360789,
0.0020615994,
0.0365981087,
0.0161641762,
0.0365292244,
-0.0589399599,
0.0084874593,
-0.0117623452,
0.0475249514,
0.0339825787,
-0.0530265085,
-0.0689691976,
0.0167914517,
-0.0437925793,
-0.021462772,
0.0066168299,
-0.0036865512,
0.0075975843,
0.0368456021,
0.0952044055,
0.0223628841,
0.0613314062,
0.0040932628,
0.0776896253,
-0.0139084021,
-0.0071605011,
0.0106832283,
-0.014245742,
-0.0239843354,
0.0329995453,
-0.0269722138,
0.031424012,
0.0084270816,
0.0273068789,
0.0003517741,
-0.0189861469,
0.004699463,
-0.0305262543,
0.0081384405,
-0.0392687619,
-0.0410948135,
-0.0202305298,
0.0530982465,
-0.0163859352,
0.0032856883,
0.0666679293,
-0.0659871474,
0.0167141445,
-0.062085513,
-0.0167248491,
-0.0485463217,
0.0141680501,
0.0143191973,
0.0034797254,
0.0135822464,
0.0170260668,
-0.0319904462,
-0.0243873429,
0.0573566109,
-0.024753971,
0.1076576561,
-0.0485378727,
0.0213889666,
-0.0023164961,
-0.0199407544,
-0.0482421927,
-0.0779739693,
-0.0341327973,
-0.0029565052,
-0.0401056372,
0.004800261,
-0.0445184335,
0.0095863445,
0.0562767759,
0.0759592429,
-0.019995274,
-0.0229262672,
-0.0061924825,
0.0392180644,
0.0650144368,
0.0303374231,
0.0789295435,
-0.0502696186,
0.0415830128,
0.0247311201,
-0.0028564876,
-0.022360146,
0.0087876115,
-0.0296482816,
-0.0103701912,
-0.0629140735,
-0.0037588633,
0.0012584813,
0.0680470541,
-0.0406484529,
0.0018233944,
0.1153683737,
0.030454712,
0.0051514688,
-0.0250851996,
0.0035566115,
0.0030511552,
-0.0103946524,
0.0026435349,
-0.0777336285,
-0.0238271449,
0.0067779259,
0.0183912814,
-0.0109244278,
-0.0103976186,
-0.0294695199,
-0.1032334194,
0.0476015173,
0.0181718823,
-0.0320700184,
-0.0503031723,
-0.0093685193,
0.0278193001,
-0.0097716879,
0.0403234959,
0.0361077897,
-0.0442289487,
0.0174947772,
0.0017112558,
-0.0648981184,
-0.0137605304,
0.00602342,
-0.036527127,
0.007764054,
0.0615095757,
0.0061770165,
-0.0166162495,
0.0052090804,
0.0051246691,
-0.0325071067,
-0.0358808786,
0.0271903183,
0.0735381842,
-0.0194371548,
0.0262402929,
-0.0268700738,
0.0025229005,
0.0463981181,
-0.0156436097,
0.0170965306,
0.0171345696,
0.0106328679,
-0.0425150022,
-0.025406139,
0.0750359669,
-0.0236227959,
0.0879279524,
0.0341887251,
0.0186472572,
-0.0214626938,
-0.0485482849,
-0.0034020138,
-0.007312018,
-0.0172221866,
0.0073468657,
-0.023806531,
0.0058129528,
-0.0802114159,
-0.0498269983,
-0.0157340299,
-0.0397425964,
-0.009170101,
-0.0121067911,
0.0175756197,
0.0170705356,
0.006881651,
0.0052833576,
-0.0275179502,
0.0098937629,
-0.0486693569,
0.0135655794,
0.0578957759,
-0.0252284948,
-0.0050610495,
0.0305746347,
-0.0767500475,
-0.0407436639,
-0.0114359595,
0.0241295863,
0.021897424,
0.0493834391,
0.0063350382,
0.0244881958,
0.0675407946,
0.0630010515,
0.0081200423,
0.0848707855,
0.0267272871,
0.0231190231,
-0.0161626562,
0.0061682174,
-0.0428308807,
0.0274739694,
-0.0602696873,
0.0570258461,
-0.0193153881,
-0.0883610696,
0.029795656,
0.0644288808,
0.0268788468,
-0.0114648938,
0.0151961567,
-0.0569380969,
-0.0176276695,
-0.0108143203,
-0.0223757252,
-0.023342045,
0.0463133678,
-0.0233091321,
0.0175121408,
-0.0248069931,
0.0277140401,
-0.0440652519,
0.020756634,
-0.0327366032,
-0.0374781527,
-0.0374331921,
-0.0141722606,
-0.0356760658,
-0.0270260535,
-0.0714125931,
-0.0356465876,
-0.0033067802,
0.0150014088,
0.0161048956,
0.0544518642,
0.0275254939,
-0.0031868631,
0.0033626703,
0.0317953564,
-0.0743831694,
0.0120110381,
-0.0661833584,
0.0422210209,
0.0651951805,
-0.0287958607,
0.0711248666,
-0.0475141183,
-0.0033170646,
-0.0355974846,
0.02747312,
0.0237739123,
-0.0091127893,
-0.024032969,
0.0106872814,
-0.0090532545,
0.0206936467,
0.0476047359,
-0.037325725,
0.0160676092,
0.0334667228,
-0.0531424209,
-0.029252518,
-0.0734519511,
-0.0586490966,
-0.0108435126,
-0.0001590198,
-0.0237478334,
-0.0865043551,
-0.0305473655,
0.0604576729,
0.0189181957,
0.0272782482,
-0.0214489177,
0.0151662864,
0.0434546359,
0.0155968349,
0.0076204124,
-0.0304801632,
-0.0151802618,
0.0107594756,
0.0110348528,
-0.0336585119,
-5.987336395e-33,
-0.0437748879,
-0.0068455362,
-0.0080153514,
0.0080021285,
-0.0626520291,
0.0201752391,
-0.0475870594,
0.0025702671,
-0.0079633994,
0.0521212704,
-0.0034586976,
0.0203373916,
0.0153509453,
0.004204114,
-0.0087661687,
-0.016088061,
0.0794682354,
0.0190565884,
-0.0671445131,
0.008869119,
0.0259196088,
-0.0365299955,
0.0336291119,
-0.0309923906,
0.0515340939,
-0.0218511336,
-0.0406636037,
0.0044488707,
-0.0154159945,
0.0324461311,
-0.0012112547,
0.0594130009,
0.0154397292,
-0.0279524717,
-0.0264738686,
-0.0070789768,
-0.0639540479,
-0.0493680909,
0.0616935082,
-0.0337308981,
-0.0354831256,
-0.0078024683,
0.0086680632,
-0.0170051642,
-0.0094750673,
-0.0399514139,
0.039948903,
-0.0429417714,
0.0040930239,
-0.0517476238,
-0.0375316367,
0.021879252,
0.0025621189,
-0.0150983213,
-0.0246732067,
0.0441811979,
0.0145029677,
-0.0176284704,
-0.0509184301,
0.0305250436,
0.0649060681,
-0.0021820485,
0.0266449079,
-0.0024389164,
-0.0261532981,
0.0656955764,
-0.057722643,
-0.0225939061,
-0.0887843743,
0.0117678419,
-0.0169452485,
-0.0301904585,
0.0402481072,
0.0535370931,
0.0215475373,
0.0415575691,
-0.0461627394,
0.0597015694,
-0.0192500576,
0.0262197107,
0.0306118876,
-0.0481075533,
-0.0229045395,
-0.011148206,
-0.0493424162,
0.0339372605,
-0.0075321132,
0.0031988374,
-0.0060773361,
0.0138414456,
-0.0157316923,
-0.0225469582,
0.0049810717,
-0.0233568344,
0.0101416744,
0.0114115244,
-0.0619365908,
0.0091691967,
0.0081801713,
0.0238635782,
-0.0378716141,
0.0459976122,
0.0157272425,
0.0283823032,
-0.0126216607,
0.0009026396,
0.0621671006,
0.0046882643,
-0.0428858511,
0.0461651385,
0.0303399861,
0.0232679918,
-0.0475702435,
-0.0317987278,
0.007354944,
0.0227547437,
-0.0145612489,
0.0376165658,
-0.0176525954,
0.007600883,
-0.0217035767,
0.0208842065,
0.0181437749,
0.040021684,
-0.0289337933,
0.0456508733,
-0.0256459843,
0.0263130497,
0.0246092025,
-0.0530558787,
0.0038215769,
0.0091583217,
2.482e-7,
0.00496834,
0.037343014,
0.0565576106,
0.005672616,
-0.031968195,
0.0329657458,
-0.0169110168,
0.0230596866,
0.0294817034,
-0.0197679885,
0.0288112741,
0.0521003827,
0.0448248498,
0.0422702655,
-0.0557372347,
-0.026744606,
-0.1068678349,
-0.0397832505,
-0.049316138,
-0.0259103067,
0.0804746896,
0.0555259213,
0.0195233617,
0.0028187761,
-0.0022698054,
-0.0415574983,
0.0455018617,
0.0151571445,
-0.0523932837,
0.0086433832,
0.0642339513,
0.0084357196,
0.0088019203,
-0.013996345,
0.0083855307,
-0.0144996233,
0.0350247547,
0.0214137509,
0.0357738994,
0.0145987906,
-0.0295388941,
0.0180777088,
0.015964875,
-0.0134439627,
0.0482812859,
-0.0552101843,
0.0111190081,
-0.0333840773,
-0.0319394283,
0.0090992209,
0.012187981,
-0.004409479,
-0.0391685031,
0.0459764674,
-0.0078710597,
0.0214733109,
0.0078772847,
-0.0477522537,
-0.0249753557,
0.0311872214,
-0.0034871942,
-0.0574650615,
-0.0075391508,
-0.0163141396,
0.0070155608,
-0.0738446116,
0.0105352588,
2.459276297e-34,
0.0906090811,
-0.0380270034,
0.0036395923,
-0.0406732894,
0.0477415994,
-0.0037061588,
-0.0150947915,
-0.00890591,
-0.0070241536,
-0.0594550185,
-0.0042983177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14066v2 | One-stop Training of Multiple Capacity Models | 2023-05-23T13:44:09 | 2023-05-24T09:37:47 | Lan Jiang, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Rui Jiang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Training models with varying capacities can be advantageous for deploying
them in different scenarios. While high-capacity models offer better
performance, low-capacity models require fewer computing resources for training
and inference. In this work, we propose a novel one-stop training framework to
jointly train high-capacity and low-capactiy models. This framework consists of
two composite model architectures and a joint training algorithm called
Two-Stage Joint-Training (TSJT). Unlike knowledge distillation, where multiple
capacity models are trained from scratch separately, our approach integrates
supervisions from different capacity models simultaneously, leading to faster
and more efficient convergence. Extensive experiments on the multilingual
machine translation benchmark WMT10 show that our method outperforms
low-capacity baseline models and achieves comparable or better performance on
high-capacity models. Notably, the analysis demonstrates that our method
significantly influences the initial training process, leading to more
efficient convergence and superior solutions. | [
0.0231374204,
0.0416734554,
-0.0153675564,
0.0059063667,
-0.0158580933,
0.0220200252,
0.0384241007,
-0.0444831289,
-0.0286208075,
-0.0021624486,
-0.0391314663,
-0.0777245313,
-0.0052045346,
0.0169981197,
0.035325747,
-0.0519762672,
0.0234615933,
-0.0408809222,
-0.0506028049,
-0.0137242824,
-0.0179246273,
0.0118066296,
0.0064537958,
0.016457092,
-0.0036955436,
-0.001840342,
-0.0026779771,
0.0342877656,
0.0367178358,
-0.0377969109,
0.0375059023,
0.0396230035,
0.0641691834,
0.0142190848,
0.0000022333,
-0.0333746336,
-0.0401405059,
0.0203647912,
-0.0108806528,
0.0248293914,
0.0592078902,
-0.0760745555,
0.0343877263,
0.0505339354,
0.0139336521,
0.0215503424,
0.0363576412,
-0.0068802824,
0.0513143279,
0.0546986833,
-0.0034817781,
-0.0508801863,
0.0339335278,
-0.0632830486,
-0.0600592233,
-0.0755206421,
0.0044721174,
0.0654603392,
-0.0431991294,
-0.0182580445,
-0.005937546,
0.05236331,
0.0346399918,
0.0254136007,
-0.0035459027,
0.0312433597,
-0.0146669764,
-0.0443414338,
-0.0299929194,
0.0499789454,
-0.0046290588,
0.0122884596,
0.0089461599,
-0.0096366415,
-0.0147362323,
-0.0184737667,
-0.018886717,
0.019561043,
0.0068433774,
-0.0123521425,
-0.0254672449,
0.0190021414,
0.0332544856,
-0.0004468748,
-0.0563693643,
-0.0205244962,
0.0034162498,
-0.0332682766,
0.0308824051,
0.0187126603,
-0.0578500219,
0.0117919128,
0.0356562547,
-0.001817285,
0.0028853433,
0.0278168898,
-0.0465287417,
-0.0523267314,
0.0216017198,
-0.045812957,
0.0460144617,
0.0367082432,
-0.0296987742,
0.0618714839,
-0.0392325558,
0.0347778276,
-0.0235538967,
-0.015755916,
-0.0700463504,
-0.0075566131,
-0.0717948228,
-0.0065969685,
-0.0536082014,
0.0092207864,
-0.0411506444,
-0.0257660598,
-0.0447190069,
0.0016301777,
-0.0176347438,
-0.0183340274,
0.0695129335,
-0.0246416554,
-0.0718092322,
-0.000994281,
0.0145949619,
0.0790790915,
-0.029555494,
0.0017063074,
-0.0158089586,
-0.0605166778,
-0.0182120167,
0.0023502628,
-0.0336225107,
-0.0346092768,
0.0191098265,
0.0676464885,
-0.0516286679,
-0.004097377,
-0.0667483658,
-0.0335258618,
-0.0207105558,
-0.1078401655,
-0.0222450923,
-0.0676972046,
0.0776850805,
0.0077685132,
0.0390567221,
-0.0053800032,
0.0000105288,
-0.0187758803,
-0.0294552557,
0.0443950742,
0.0305026434,
0.0114584509,
0.0434827842,
0.0115501434,
-0.0320908725,
0.1206745505,
0.0188497026,
0.0180461612,
-0.007422524,
0.0128303729,
-0.0629726276,
0.0538492575,
0.0198255926,
0.0579024479,
-0.0540560894,
-0.0036148906,
0.0464343056,
0.0159126986,
0.0497071594,
0.0259944815,
-0.0553320423,
0.0424645916,
0.0783521384,
0.0058388202,
0.0306885187,
-0.0147471875,
0.08054021,
-0.0028516159,
-0.0216556452,
-0.0124146482,
-0.0254444387,
0.0085628144,
0.023378348,
0.0065393969,
0.0596200153,
0.0581927747,
-0.0174647681,
-0.0362959802,
0.0177798532,
-0.0047742394,
-0.043387793,
-0.0445998199,
0.0748593807,
-0.0027406036,
-0.03185587,
0.0479507297,
0.0143923359,
-0.0195941087,
0.033928562,
-0.0174027104,
-0.0746996105,
0.037725769,
0.0269400291,
0.0012808763,
-0.0108603342,
-0.0171951875,
-0.0046851835,
0.0225745067,
0.0800017416,
0.0244278852,
0.0256582834,
-0.0412632935,
-0.0323938392,
0.0100900233,
0.0003224692,
0.0364106782,
0.0039521637,
0.0518117994,
0.036914587,
-0.036937099,
-0.0607980825,
0.0273555536,
-0.0397837088,
0.0091499109,
-0.0057794596,
0.0328279287,
0.0417266339,
0.0046500377,
-0.0538585,
-0.0213523023,
0.0009438933,
-0.034963876,
-0.0413449183,
0.0391097441,
-0.052470725,
-0.0139844483,
0.035755828,
0.0054129916,
0.0157711767,
0.0034160314,
-0.011185484,
-0.0735163093,
-0.0065169125,
0.0116507271,
0.0171761159,
-0.0523923337,
0.0546681881,
-0.0027587682,
-0.0054686139,
-0.0061310334,
0.0754879341,
-0.0280753467,
-0.0323025063,
0.0035462617,
-0.0397933982,
0.0149507141,
0.0023969412,
-0.0553121939,
0.0006584822,
0.006620815,
0.032047607,
0.025085466,
0.0119187552,
-0.0256578866,
-0.0425550789,
-0.0727799833,
0.0438213497,
-0.039217066,
0.0186780039,
-0.0065269624,
0.0207318161,
0.0186896883,
-0.0147671616,
-0.0049513448,
-0.0139182964,
-0.0165666677,
0.0455840081,
-0.0406996645,
0.0377174877,
0.0132123325,
0.0062148175,
-0.0055862176,
0.015654508,
0.0347485989,
0.0016970994,
-0.0164255872,
-0.0178576633,
0.0186824091,
-0.0037561171,
0.022447668,
-0.0100896172,
-0.0519133285,
0.0026113936,
-0.0126577634,
0.0335159898,
0.0266799368,
-0.0122785904,
0.0055382964,
0.0462635532,
0.012361764,
-0.0742576644,
0.0394938141,
-0.0099934665,
-0.0754682794,
-0.0295988396,
-0.0428844988,
-0.0087221824,
0.055369582,
0.0066525377,
0.0124876387,
-0.0539380088,
-0.0410717875,
0.0042398353,
-0.0384787954,
-0.0438100621,
0.0511347726,
0.0314714052,
-0.0022610601,
-0.0287845284,
-0.0450566821,
0.0497875065,
-0.0279530752,
-0.0065876092,
-0.0147256693,
-0.0207323655,
-0.0138876047,
0.0245521478,
0.0098823486,
0.0425982289,
-0.0080216667,
0.0004538921,
-0.0253946166,
0.0387176238,
0.0452151187,
0.0059039858,
-0.0105158761,
-0.0705460832,
-0.0013007277,
-0.0376957953,
-0.0321416818,
-0.0085358657,
0.0180602111,
-0.0038700737,
0.0381081775,
0.0207614731,
-0.0397394672,
-0.0601568297,
0.0290443134,
0.0210783519,
0.0962252766,
-0.0020909698,
-0.0163137689,
-0.0137066264,
0.0160437319,
0.0102391765,
-0.0010920538,
-0.0166209694,
-0.0877878442,
0.020881651,
0.0225111842,
0.0025713847,
-0.0214898009,
-0.0256045535,
-0.0042987959,
0.0296744388,
-0.02435904,
-0.0162456278,
0.0067216842,
0.0406781919,
-0.0648143366,
0.0188951865,
0.0775762126,
0.0054131239,
-0.0540000387,
-0.0116668772,
0.0108047454,
0.0290644877,
0.0338974111,
0.0333017185,
-0.0769954994,
-0.0155085549,
-0.0144525329,
0.0376761481,
0.0143615939,
-0.001209882,
-0.0365789197,
-0.1013686955,
0.0061868485,
0.0112932138,
-0.0378798991,
-0.0297780894,
-0.016632989,
-0.0392563939,
-0.0319455229,
-0.0075494736,
-0.0056630187,
0.0219902843,
-0.0165583491,
0.0242302082,
0.0100707933,
-0.0560401008,
-0.0161000676,
-0.0568086989,
0.0387727767,
0.0269126557,
-0.026528446,
-0.0241270419,
-0.0016726705,
0.0084221726,
-0.0317150988,
0.0342640318,
-0.0105376048,
0.0211832765,
0.0051360861,
-0.0139118358,
0.0656904951,
0.0181664228,
-0.0030373249,
0.0083362507,
0.054007832,
0.0592213981,
0.0301573277,
-0.0025145395,
-0.000355189,
-0.0194843523,
0.0374560133,
0.0641447678,
-0.017972026,
-0.0291471127,
-0.0129272984,
0.0166874733,
-0.0422595739,
-0.0857490897,
0.0253822673,
0.0290907826,
-0.0402172692,
-0.0172095262,
-0.0418190956,
0.0013665031,
0.0247669853,
0.0453533344,
0.0203702729,
0.0235592388,
0.0017623965,
0.0292190295,
-0.0292446632,
0.0323077701,
-0.0426560082,
0.0128167802,
-0.0653741062,
-0.0049545448,
0.0150976097,
-0.0367611721,
-0.0274569951,
-0.0067410064,
-0.0855744183,
-0.0806815103,
-0.0523655526,
0.0907835662,
0.0225118659,
0.0402961709,
0.0057483651,
-0.0506455936,
0.0293303691,
-0.0055420133,
-0.0379155241,
0.0099523133,
0.0438333564,
0.0003575794,
-0.0185930729,
0.0263066329,
-0.00203232,
0.0217077918,
0.0004914951,
0.0351320952,
-0.0414663479,
-0.0115023553,
-0.0126981391,
0.0026882959,
0.0074783145,
-0.0261936989,
-0.0066310125,
-0.0334289968,
0.0221937113,
0.0144743556,
-0.0159292184,
-0.0378554389,
0.0102832066,
0.0503347926,
0.0053313742,
0.0068085608,
0.0094369669,
0.0642196089,
-0.0247555785,
-0.0183280278,
-0.015980836,
-0.0012355549,
-0.0148204416,
0.0167133398,
0.0037510558,
-0.0195713248,
-0.0319191441,
-0.0055339974,
0.011434529,
-0.0344299898,
0.0608269572,
-0.0170953702,
0.0279841255,
0.0024591179,
0.01334746,
-0.024357114,
-0.0412486866,
-0.0102584409,
0.0308272373,
0.0771913007,
0.0212292168,
0.0718984529,
-0.0212640166,
0.0059147803,
-0.0424229018,
0.0043258364,
-0.0078277569,
0.0138824396,
0.0032317033,
0.0068090125,
0.001922938,
0.0365233459,
0.091754362,
0.0209134202,
0.050711263,
-0.0271860752,
-0.0143475132,
-0.0225064326,
-0.039168369,
0.0007273015,
0.0159195103,
0.0137316054,
0.0211353339,
-0.0142490296,
-0.0446328968,
-0.0027595602,
0.0032309575,
-0.0086634457,
0.0069080428,
0.0147465533,
0.0612576045,
-0.0457115769,
-0.0170851611,
-0.046016939,
-0.0228295606,
0.032829307,
0.0310198851,
0.0290254634,
-6.790855844e-33,
0.0001346294,
0.0160614513,
0.0432829745,
-0.054510586,
-0.0453769416,
0.0161357615,
0.0148153938,
-0.0282486361,
-0.0285613015,
0.0163248889,
-0.0047069434,
0.0059166793,
0.028913524,
-0.0192737095,
0.028982101,
0.0562998056,
0.0876580179,
0.0038904091,
-0.0143572502,
0.0273400098,
0.0391490832,
0.0436712354,
0.0756064802,
-0.0250426289,
-0.0041861227,
-0.0250011235,
-0.0229851827,
0.0258236825,
0.0274212863,
0.019703541,
0.0049057514,
0.015992485,
0.0233501885,
-0.0706232041,
-0.0195999425,
-0.0124703348,
-0.0887462422,
-0.0122375572,
0.0327250995,
0.0100963609,
0.0016013165,
-0.0309326053,
0.0233428031,
-0.0158957336,
0.0431726351,
-0.0359795578,
0.0255808588,
-0.0505446456,
-0.0500485748,
-0.064716585,
-0.0484243408,
0.0233080201,
-0.0123027256,
0.0079410682,
0.0303817894,
0.065257974,
-0.02156201,
-0.0153824864,
-0.0707348734,
-0.0055514406,
-0.0094841924,
0.0526297577,
0.0715297014,
0.0298608802,
-0.0385208428,
0.0238979142,
-0.0317171365,
-0.0030852496,
0.0240623336,
-0.0142517556,
0.0536843762,
0.0416306295,
0.0279475655,
0.0288826637,
0.0539556257,
-0.0318218581,
-0.0651153624,
0.0283540078,
0.0318591222,
0.0362640359,
0.0528560467,
-0.0056126462,
-0.0155515475,
-0.0098731779,
-0.0805779845,
-0.0362073071,
-0.0354483388,
-0.0059052007,
0.0210502762,
0.0657170489,
-0.0287508704,
0.0057392684,
0.0830399692,
-0.0293414705,
0.0282927155,
0.0254669003,
0.0109349033,
0.0238602404,
-0.0173070598,
0.0600076243,
-0.0328503698,
-0.0673125386,
-0.0046661347,
0.0504790805,
0.0031632145,
-0.0141093219,
0.0544911176,
0.0011021685,
-0.0373667628,
0.0083018765,
-0.0309740696,
0.0143276714,
-0.0124764573,
0.0355494432,
0.024555305,
0.0018682037,
-0.0186623316,
0.004280068,
0.0155772213,
-0.0373935364,
-0.0208409112,
-0.007847392,
0.0337653495,
0.051595971,
-0.0258935243,
0.0164985005,
-0.0215952527,
-0.0023235544,
0.0569971912,
-0.0434221663,
-0.0289250538,
0.0333581008,
2.849e-7,
0.0400549285,
-0.0067045167,
-0.0222397465,
-0.0133537007,
-0.0120502179,
0.0147704184,
-0.0193938762,
0.0275269207,
0.0022735633,
-0.0153899407,
0.0226401743,
0.0720140189,
0.0696377084,
0.0204730928,
-0.0586461425,
-0.0674280077,
-0.0499211922,
0.0361966193,
-0.0504019335,
-0.032152243,
0.0290050525,
0.0542078055,
-0.0152785573,
-0.0041141873,
0.0026585122,
-0.0233814344,
0.0793481395,
0.0045608473,
0.0137243783,
0.0512287095,
0.0330022909,
0.0481198169,
-0.0274810903,
0.0583923347,
-0.0413333289,
0.0286892075,
0.0141540719,
0.0981126353,
0.0159740131,
0.0068262774,
0.0530409627,
0.0151105681,
-0.0566719435,
-0.0284885392,
0.0701906607,
-0.0936302841,
0.0234479476,
-0.0033491743,
-0.0180758312,
-0.0000066975,
0.0545597374,
-0.0241742395,
-0.0167517513,
0.0511008948,
0.0343796611,
0.0044520246,
-0.0336187631,
-0.07560426,
0.0008230216,
0.0146708116,
-0.0125867687,
-0.0674544498,
-0.0314784534,
-0.048514992,
0.014497268,
-0.035980016,
-0.0198572725,
2.501001525e-34,
0.0625768527,
-0.0382616408,
0.0388478041,
0.0105815744,
0.0045863613,
-0.0285005141,
-0.0582840964,
-0.0013075944,
-0.0459326506,
-0.0742286742,
-0.0194761865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14057v1 | Can Language Models Understand Physical Concepts? | 2023-05-23T13:36:55 | 2023-05-23T13:36:55 | Lei Li, Jingjing Xu, Qingxiu Dong, Ce Zheng, Qi Liu, Lingpeng Kong, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Language models~(LMs) gradually become general-purpose interfaces in the
interactive and embodied world, where the understanding of physical concepts is
an essential prerequisite. However, it is not yet clear whether LMs can
understand physical concepts in the human world. To investigate this, we design
a benchmark VEC that covers the tasks of (i) Visual concepts, such as the shape
and material of objects, and (ii) Embodied Concepts, learned from the
interaction with the world such as the temperature of objects. Our zero
(few)-shot prompting results show that the understanding of certain visual
concepts emerges as scaling up LMs, but there are still basic concepts to which
the scaling law does not apply. For example, OPT-175B performs close to humans
with a zero-shot accuracy of 85\% on the material concept, yet behaves like
random guessing on the mass concept. Instead, vision-augmented LMs such as CLIP
and BLIP achieve a human-level understanding of embodied concepts. Analysis
indicates that the rich semantics in visual representation can serve as a
valuable source of embodied knowledge. Inspired by this, we propose a
distillation method to transfer embodied knowledge from VLMs to LMs, achieving
performance gain comparable with that by scaling up the parameters of LMs 134x.
Our dataset is available at \url{https://github.com/TobiasLee/VEC} | [
-0.0218775272,
0.0173154082,
-0.0321976058,
0.0894705281,
-0.0059894249,
0.0129744075,
0.0037054096,
0.0094196266,
-0.0292009227,
-0.0193557926,
-0.0460993424,
-0.0254397038,
0.0198016465,
0.0521214381,
0.0173224993,
-0.07608179,
0.0041934713,
-0.0492135547,
-0.0431687757,
-0.0094198147,
-0.0221111104,
-0.023894988,
-0.0157714337,
-0.0011159043,
0.0197832175,
0.0340465382,
-0.0372964442,
-0.0076301526,
0.0267336722,
-0.0055484865,
-0.0444236323,
0.0193748251,
0.0569137782,
0.0240398888,
0.0000018364,
-0.0205429457,
0.0755919889,
0.0066619911,
-0.012213422,
-0.012636493,
0.0201245379,
-0.1177578792,
-0.0132060815,
-0.0265467018,
-0.0367099345,
-0.0214646664,
0.0742678121,
0.0076291664,
0.0084183523,
0.01777035,
-0.008792595,
-0.0134748053,
0.0240041148,
0.0281247869,
0.0651394874,
0.0324066877,
0.0083097965,
0.0137374317,
0.0369937196,
0.0170021914,
-0.0605056286,
0.0532766953,
0.0520951822,
0.0119714579,
0.0136120804,
0.0861884579,
-0.0317702405,
-0.0035410805,
0.0188053139,
0.0760034472,
-0.024512697,
-0.036856629,
-0.0067740572,
0.0010659259,
-0.0206872355,
-0.0228519253,
-0.0527532324,
0.0127674714,
0.0410711505,
0.0098980302,
-0.0803656653,
-0.0173182078,
0.0193882063,
0.0340561606,
-0.0115455445,
0.0556828491,
-0.0075223134,
0.0272584297,
-0.0063421223,
-0.0138827423,
0.0038540575,
-0.0548049584,
-0.0592303425,
0.0308059864,
-0.0008875062,
0.0050000106,
-0.0406040698,
0.0165262427,
-0.020818973,
-0.0590911619,
0.0745154172,
0.0239931662,
-0.0061679399,
0.031598486,
-0.0426565446,
0.0597609133,
-0.0041182716,
0.0600258149,
-0.0468345881,
0.0210156981,
-0.0397540219,
-0.0012075532,
-0.0070197536,
-0.0071477224,
-0.0634325519,
-0.0279570632,
0.0012370042,
-0.0021145283,
-0.0192813985,
-0.0005974715,
-0.0326710753,
0.0242102463,
0.0158920605,
-0.0170060806,
-0.043280758,
-0.0038609272,
-0.0061919685,
0.0466439947,
-0.0067533324,
-0.0871065035,
-0.0278217643,
-0.0161011647,
0.0133946408,
-0.0183661431,
-0.0069500338,
0.0715347081,
0.006648045,
-0.0416356847,
0.0304523706,
-0.007099492,
0.0130739762,
-0.0575035177,
0.0393040329,
-0.053345792,
0.0167319812,
-0.0182116386,
0.0083233388,
-0.0375234149,
0.0332036614,
-0.0079150973,
-0.0188977197,
0.1103598103,
-0.0151802823,
0.0114137065,
-0.0178648178,
0.0221817158,
0.027225947,
0.0675244257,
0.0250504296,
0.0041330652,
-0.0318510644,
-0.0108978665,
0.0010404519,
0.0120676495,
0.0174281728,
0.0226734839,
-0.106363833,
-0.0318419598,
-0.0075512752,
0.0490744784,
0.0384856984,
0.0591531992,
-0.0425716303,
-0.0293174237,
0.075906828,
0.0315124579,
-0.0645808578,
-0.0105106868,
0.0215704087,
-0.0047202944,
0.0160208642,
-0.0270945113,
-0.0715271533,
0.0590130985,
-0.0031188724,
-0.0075356364,
-0.0116605097,
0.0076618306,
-0.0481838286,
-0.0345757641,
-0.0426076613,
-0.0162902754,
0.0222214144,
0.0200378876,
0.0651740581,
0.0001041108,
0.0408515073,
0.0274785273,
-0.0046289824,
-0.0219489057,
0.0002169079,
-0.0248110071,
0.0001851522,
0.0334679931,
-0.0171189923,
0.0115981745,
0.0066921958,
0.0108522717,
0.0308114551,
0.0376423672,
0.0478065684,
0.0061775283,
0.0326863565,
-0.0022456397,
-0.0174453836,
-0.0187515654,
0.0075668697,
-0.0033166648,
-0.0232961532,
-0.0131360525,
0.0105150491,
-0.0185002945,
0.0003831561,
0.0563034378,
-0.0306595992,
0.001947467,
-0.0226250868,
-0.0267156921,
0.0181626659,
-0.0270407032,
-0.0112320278,
-0.0072989138,
0.0246128552,
-0.0623868331,
-0.0014538445,
0.0427359864,
0.0040463079,
-0.0302149206,
0.0362471715,
-0.0437108949,
-0.0006964102,
0.005276693,
-0.0330721252,
-0.0388364494,
0.0529063754,
-0.0035059878,
0.0278013591,
-0.0213597976,
-0.0223594476,
-0.0181924067,
0.0321259238,
0.0090087531,
0.024955947,
-0.0359400809,
0.0266956799,
0.0020415832,
-0.0064179413,
-0.0021942309,
-0.0445595272,
-0.0304708667,
0.0264271088,
0.0199203677,
0.0122978864,
-0.0404898748,
-0.0246659573,
-0.0226057321,
0.0278818998,
-0.0579580069,
-0.0442366414,
0.0111619905,
-0.0193766281,
0.0147014605,
-0.0006253849,
-0.0075280266,
0.0010428514,
0.0093074972,
0.0411415026,
-0.0281290635,
0.0265876912,
0.0180713832,
0.0090432111,
-0.0080375252,
-0.0010641621,
-0.0141373072,
-0.005750312,
0.0493683666,
0.0018352694,
0.002733933,
0.0031997184,
0.0202869289,
-0.0539875403,
0.0397087559,
-0.0101507809,
-0.0379652195,
0.0212317724,
-0.0631209686,
-0.0130733885,
0.0803000182,
-0.002176255,
0.0370790251,
0.0599806085,
-0.0152206114,
-0.0523738824,
-0.0334008075,
-0.0189901795,
0.0480321124,
-0.021132322,
0.0222668964,
-0.0167407971,
0.0502073318,
-0.0010886694,
0.0018582144,
-0.0550442599,
0.0790120661,
-0.0071614049,
-0.0724115297,
-0.0674445927,
0.0585533828,
-0.0318539068,
0.0381052941,
-0.0415435173,
-0.0662346706,
0.0421103723,
-0.0203303844,
0.0003524727,
0.0525150225,
-0.0081357248,
0.0068937247,
0.0752366185,
0.052531302,
0.0153257754,
-0.0381331705,
0.0235275831,
-0.0391468182,
0.0062997248,
-0.0131669119,
-0.0079140365,
0.0262831524,
-0.0984857753,
0.0059595285,
-0.0427031927,
-0.0269803423,
-0.0107933171,
0.0532925203,
-0.0548456647,
0.0526501425,
-0.0629897639,
-0.0277693383,
-0.0357510373,
0.0249688271,
0.0374273844,
0.0164358187,
-0.01990778,
-0.0097990409,
-0.0495211184,
0.0008421023,
0.0455405414,
0.0551810041,
0.0103364382,
-0.0377570614,
0.0261848848,
0.0587431118,
0.0112607852,
-0.0125593683,
-0.0934247151,
0.0513779186,
0.0388709158,
0.0358257517,
-0.0086126868,
0.009225145,
0.0537413992,
-0.0507526472,
-0.0282499492,
0.054425776,
-0.0018420703,
-0.0045239422,
0.0169486441,
0.0131678842,
0.0380340256,
0.0220625121,
0.0004110264,
-0.0789538026,
-0.0169702824,
0.0021143118,
-0.0121265184,
0.0346247703,
-0.0438204668,
-0.0213164203,
-0.0864013582,
0.0317103863,
0.0190290492,
-0.0606836937,
-0.055914171,
0.0094019538,
0.0212293677,
-0.0011123795,
0.0066085914,
0.0040548001,
-0.0183973331,
0.0208737012,
0.0170744192,
0.0249586552,
-0.0499339104,
0.0174022801,
-0.0218883101,
0.0103638992,
0.0423004478,
0.0277694594,
-0.0506164692,
-0.0709346011,
0.0206757449,
-0.018238686,
-0.0044812006,
-0.0103820637,
0.0266444907,
0.0081040543,
-0.0090898899,
0.0320629962,
0.071322538,
-0.0324211679,
-0.0565770827,
-0.0269901548,
0.0638338029,
-0.028436359,
-0.043147359,
-0.0254426282,
-0.0323278345,
-0.0321544111,
0.0612272471,
0.0423657224,
-0.033327207,
-0.0529610291,
-0.0245506745,
-0.0322960466,
0.0474495851,
-0.0798295587,
-0.0130925216,
0.0102440696,
-0.0246182829,
-0.0517798215,
0.0120780021,
0.0238641351,
0.0892277434,
-0.0030871243,
-0.043303147,
-0.0204330012,
0.0058811805,
-0.0317286402,
0.0252901893,
-0.012933095,
0.033452455,
0.0016595718,
-0.0011939191,
0.0415996313,
-0.0654274672,
-0.0046539521,
-0.0060008438,
-0.0419789515,
-0.0754297227,
-0.0004935912,
0.0593215004,
0.038291201,
0.0724251866,
-0.0028725627,
-0.0528739654,
0.0644432828,
0.0528530218,
0.0081882598,
0.0764892548,
-0.0304944105,
-0.0079441005,
0.0134423692,
0.0137435561,
-0.0076214839,
0.0307991691,
0.003809494,
0.0107069435,
-0.0109159406,
-0.0405442528,
0.0072180526,
0.0076505146,
0.0573196411,
0.0152570922,
0.0241529066,
-0.0344280638,
-0.0145556172,
0.0318215117,
0.0400836244,
-0.1025874168,
-0.0186461937,
0.0180551987,
0.0604464971,
-0.007857821,
-0.0079275705,
0.0225159973,
0.0448991545,
0.0054646181,
-0.0051932358,
0.0209064372,
0.0155763272,
0.003250113,
0.0297812633,
0.0314277224,
0.0290436521,
-0.0583896302,
0.0443395451,
-0.0061817742,
0.0104035456,
0.042103678,
0.0001743728,
-0.0564763471,
0.0369609855,
-0.0696098208,
-0.0667037591,
-0.0270758178,
0.0114647606,
0.0115877204,
-0.0048032873,
0.0047731465,
-0.0552722625,
0.0024662281,
-0.0074500833,
0.0774407759,
0.0271960571,
-0.0388586596,
0.092071943,
0.0564585738,
-0.0023675999,
-0.0332931615,
0.0130520053,
-0.0233412329,
0.041397281,
0.0043391162,
0.015106041,
-0.0018748642,
0.0012852708,
0.0054770829,
-0.0135528464,
0.0110429032,
0.0303277448,
-0.0482576713,
-0.0667330101,
-0.0001793952,
0.0775634274,
-0.0170930903,
-0.0257777553,
0.0676577315,
0.0134378113,
0.0232023317,
-0.0208188798,
0.0065367846,
-0.0119175008,
-0.0036666451,
-0.0083672581,
0.0210081097,
-5.269360976e-33,
-0.0282515362,
0.0317163542,
0.0161137562,
0.0430969968,
-0.0283704121,
0.0264314599,
-0.0315143988,
0.0150703844,
-0.0367389098,
0.0189658646,
0.0244729389,
-0.0064039771,
-0.0044550709,
-0.0103680342,
0.0193767548,
-0.0225774683,
-0.0071672271,
-0.0260053016,
0.0082156071,
-0.0003645166,
0.0228508543,
0.0045465073,
0.0480367392,
-0.0141502013,
-0.0010196374,
0.0412045605,
0.0122403819,
0.0311423745,
-0.0087352926,
0.0153259188,
-0.0601684563,
0.0258554034,
0.0045350189,
0.0265181027,
-0.0512623824,
0.0106099695,
-0.0590302311,
-0.0316295773,
-0.0069783959,
0.0264772885,
-0.0829592422,
0.0172546878,
0.0621058941,
-0.0074643334,
-0.0194676761,
-0.0161699243,
0.0204330403,
-0.062164329,
-0.0192533433,
0.0113872234,
-0.0103867063,
0.0013801075,
0.0038678467,
0.0004677497,
0.1050440818,
0.0016913679,
-0.020813277,
0.0316574723,
-0.0501723364,
0.0260014813,
0.0174997523,
0.0240276083,
0.060373459,
0.0371077731,
0.0325511247,
0.0860660598,
0.0574880429,
-0.0542094,
-0.0579888523,
-0.0086306836,
0.0952368602,
0.0700768158,
0.0002310282,
0.0492073111,
0.0367605761,
0.0245439578,
-0.0208447203,
0.0085260496,
-0.0008190075,
0.0910447091,
0.0024341561,
0.0060535455,
0.0135620786,
-0.0094341151,
-0.0387871191,
-0.0348909795,
-0.0315129571,
-0.0309098847,
0.0341682769,
-0.0225505438,
0.0157703552,
-0.0335990451,
0.0453148708,
-0.0675238892,
-0.0116912555,
-0.0074533145,
-0.0057800822,
0.0371050425,
0.0405230895,
-0.0132510494,
-0.0735867471,
-0.0426535904,
0.0057021752,
0.0156206023,
0.0205994323,
-0.0061390665,
-0.0024008253,
0.0477843769,
0.0089661432,
-0.0396332778,
-0.0502795577,
-0.0275761168,
0.0413560718,
0.0382662043,
0.0422681198,
-0.0055322079,
-0.0245674998,
0.0056681363,
-0.0485137329,
-0.0379208364,
-0.0100260079,
0.0453415997,
-0.0303872451,
0.0258627981,
-0.0580789223,
-0.0431551747,
-0.0556529835,
-0.0178926233,
0.0741708204,
-0.0523622446,
-0.0066461414,
0.0495628156,
2.696e-7,
0.0160550959,
0.0042572552,
-0.0029970198,
-0.0183017887,
0.0266809314,
0.0335815549,
-0.0411449485,
0.0585551187,
-0.015253746,
-0.0614378229,
-0.017383324,
0.0674961582,
0.0365885831,
0.0004828326,
-0.0684648007,
0.0007502667,
0.005496603,
-0.0228911862,
-0.0143140275,
-0.0338665619,
0.0009056821,
0.0508116633,
0.0437120013,
0.0112112844,
0.0367442146,
0.0321506374,
0.0629347712,
-0.0756635964,
0.0545887165,
-0.0364334099,
-0.0086202826,
-0.0197028387,
-0.0152303074,
0.0388726778,
0.0084669851,
0.0040451363,
0.0116095664,
0.0398594886,
-0.0118810162,
0.0016793379,
-0.0150202038,
-0.0028185651,
-0.0084087187,
-0.0461582579,
0.0604804195,
-0.0645118356,
-0.0281928852,
-0.0177527424,
-0.0285213683,
-0.0025712575,
0.000526596,
0.026070796,
-0.0067105549,
0.0042439951,
0.0089638419,
-0.0343713351,
-0.0342016853,
-0.0769161433,
-0.0282287244,
-0.0165706202,
-0.0531043112,
-0.0278433617,
-0.0458386987,
-0.0070969402,
0.0223180261,
-0.0095280437,
-0.0666962862,
1.863507636e-34,
-0.0029683674,
0.0257026665,
0.0010165853,
0.0209702235,
-0.0287277643,
-0.0177285131,
0.0180275906,
0.0463911593,
0.0160064641,
-0.0605103672,
0.0145542547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14049v1 | Rethinking Speech Recognition with A Multimodal Perspective via Acoustic and Semantic Cooperative Decoding | 2023-05-23T13:25:44 | 2023-05-23T13:25:44 | Tian-Hao Zhang, Hai-Bo Qin, Zhi-Hao Lai, Song-Lu Chen, Qi Liu, Feng Chen, Xinyuan Qian, Xu-Cheng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Attention-based encoder-decoder (AED) models have shown impressive
performance in ASR. However, most existing AED methods neglect to
simultaneously leverage both acoustic and semantic features in decoder, which
is crucial for generating more accurate and informative semantic states. In
this paper, we propose an Acoustic and Semantic Cooperative Decoder (ASCD) for
ASR. In particular, unlike vanilla decoders that process acoustic and semantic
features in two separate stages, ASCD integrates them cooperatively. To prevent
information leakage during training, we design a Causal Multimodal Mask.
Moreover, a variant Semi-ASCD is proposed to balance accuracy and computational
cost. Our proposal is evaluated on the publicly available AISHELL-1 and
aidatatang_200zh datasets using Transformer, Conformer, and Branchformer as
encoders, respectively. The experimental results show that ASCD significantly
improves the performance by leveraging both the acoustic and semantic
information cooperatively. | [
-0.0444208421,
0.0494667776,
0.0167917516,
0.0345403031,
-0.016508583,
-0.0229863543,
0.0612189062,
-0.0309496,
-0.0742785707,
-0.0247501191,
-0.0545783415,
-0.0230401959,
0.0380146541,
0.0332252271,
0.0031633563,
-0.0354063883,
0.0169683974,
-0.0452837795,
0.0019968092,
-0.0355432555,
0.0009159926,
-0.0116585847,
-0.0355645604,
0.0561827533,
-0.0242856387,
0.0017084104,
-0.0341867916,
0.0222880188,
0.0053144838,
-0.0280289669,
-0.0220406484,
-0.0353470296,
0.0252497364,
-0.0157436635,
0.0000021777,
-0.0077475761,
-0.0131430989,
-0.002388506,
-0.0505176708,
-0.013628385,
-0.0068989727,
-0.0356697217,
0.0141875362,
0.0252207462,
0.0033384268,
-0.0301071983,
0.0484190509,
0.0347739346,
0.0532278009,
0.0105948905,
-0.0004056359,
-0.063396275,
0.0190488622,
-0.0253114887,
-0.0164229218,
-0.0271893907,
-0.0450830907,
-0.0446278118,
-0.0606929734,
-0.0274489783,
-0.0980942994,
0.0912968814,
0.0387446582,
0.0103555517,
0.0811470374,
0.0161815342,
0.0189875662,
-0.0653253645,
-0.0245991554,
0.0262151826,
0.0427624397,
-0.0022069933,
-0.0118690711,
0.0106757423,
-0.0207290109,
0.0131414961,
-0.0074164327,
0.0427122787,
-0.0420199707,
0.0210134573,
-0.0094263228,
0.0651895478,
0.0062843366,
-0.0313528553,
-0.0267958064,
0.0377431512,
-0.0299873594,
-0.0295486841,
0.0321587026,
-0.0475093313,
0.0089811049,
0.0202805586,
0.0619648732,
0.0115304058,
-0.0036192758,
-0.029490551,
-0.0342782363,
-0.0827553123,
-0.0119433627,
-0.0389157571,
0.0156037798,
0.0369743444,
-0.0551519804,
0.0338004939,
-0.0048775254,
0.0322843567,
0.0379063971,
0.0364571027,
-0.0114914663,
-0.0282979906,
0.0184246879,
0.0048392103,
-0.0631636232,
0.0170787945,
-0.0026269294,
-0.0469589904,
-0.0152077191,
0.0129009169,
-0.0125068044,
0.0005398935,
0.0452098958,
0.0054286001,
-0.0617583171,
-0.0175046176,
0.0402274504,
0.0376138389,
0.0312690474,
0.0229580775,
0.0067539937,
-0.0292873736,
-0.040300902,
0.0309823118,
0.0320205428,
-0.0262047164,
-0.0424113721,
0.0719479918,
-0.0126750693,
-0.0359534509,
0.0144781657,
0.0084824869,
-0.0063679167,
-0.0019192724,
0.0294235405,
0.011005084,
0.0386172794,
-0.0056937826,
0.0256108772,
-0.0535280108,
-0.0051167738,
-0.02679093,
0.0707012936,
0.0809907094,
0.0078894477,
0.0066009476,
0.0493524037,
0.0117409695,
0.0044370014,
0.0389818698,
0.0354402773,
0.0010665697,
-0.012442613,
-0.0585651472,
-0.0163649824,
0.0025558639,
-0.0006445228,
-0.0435023382,
0.0397913754,
-0.0383399725,
0.0319873691,
-0.002811294,
0.0601749606,
0.0528831221,
-0.0364528075,
-0.0405540057,
0.0506427698,
-0.029183086,
0.0442104414,
0.006829151,
0.032376077,
0.0091167307,
-0.0425247028,
0.0090687638,
0.0080116866,
0.0348641984,
-0.0045153755,
0.0099581042,
0.0654809773,
0.0189086255,
-0.0245237295,
-0.0151705556,
0.0133902738,
-0.0509292372,
0.0234790146,
0.0484594889,
0.0462534279,
0.0315371491,
-0.0425189435,
0.025328774,
-0.0246379208,
-0.0309726503,
0.0260527637,
-0.0250442848,
-0.0114979902,
0.0055557475,
0.0167410411,
-0.0099480422,
-0.0064336085,
-0.0056931749,
-0.0080273664,
0.0198279936,
-0.0251956619,
0.0203286186,
0.0752935931,
-0.0849604458,
-0.0458161607,
0.0060831732,
-0.0199084282,
0.043291267,
-0.0432645269,
-0.0039160559,
0.0018270704,
0.0144024445,
0.0863518566,
-0.0091880616,
0.0424583741,
0.0032731374,
0.0018644528,
0.0229135957,
0.0660886168,
0.0168776177,
-0.0140678817,
0.0023112535,
0.048423782,
-0.0622094795,
-0.0069806916,
0.0478313379,
-0.0887393057,
-0.0565257445,
0.0005333934,
-0.0446788035,
0.0146322306,
0.0707012936,
0.0320497863,
-0.0479739308,
0.0431113727,
-0.0701666623,
0.0703353435,
-0.0359626971,
0.0457027778,
0.0801725835,
0.0542671047,
0.0173785072,
-0.0173338801,
-0.0259100404,
-0.0308026485,
-0.028279556,
0.0048369849,
-0.0214457568,
-0.0781434178,
-0.0264697056,
0.03972774,
-0.0332222544,
-0.0253001712,
0.0078731906,
-0.0285745822,
0.0185895879,
0.0153069133,
-0.0577167273,
-0.0650085285,
-0.0454006679,
-0.0076801707,
-0.0547482297,
0.0132307401,
0.0488855727,
-0.0242017228,
0.0116284126,
0.0372109599,
-0.0330209136,
-0.0178775284,
-0.068286106,
-0.0090138139,
-0.0268095322,
0.0206148587,
-0.0112364655,
0.0399789885,
0.0283067897,
0.0003204228,
-0.0654348731,
-0.0509980507,
-0.0255969372,
0.0441075675,
0.0139700528,
-0.0263224337,
-0.0092699146,
0.00771889,
0.0146892667,
0.012256993,
0.0357692391,
0.0152875921,
0.0376581661,
0.0282375589,
0.0024771888,
-0.038506493,
0.0324833319,
0.0081578204,
0.0326966196,
-0.0046309084,
0.0005556064,
0.0076313792,
0.0503389202,
0.0579712614,
0.0432112031,
-0.053405337,
-0.073658675,
-0.0075130905,
-0.068129085,
-0.0265576001,
-0.0299871769,
-0.0458947755,
-0.0271275528,
-0.0032797535,
0.0017725368,
0.0377911143,
-0.0583061762,
-0.0743734464,
-0.0186286531,
-0.0204835646,
-0.0086305635,
0.0466326773,
0.0146232089,
0.0241492856,
-0.0056003095,
-0.0421509482,
0.0255485848,
0.0378198959,
0.0081946906,
-0.0256570783,
0.0241014063,
-0.0002282907,
-0.0154914679,
-0.0171525441,
-0.0189541765,
-0.0105912555,
-0.0140718017,
-0.0118394196,
0.0461689569,
0.0250007641,
0.0071927928,
-0.0106386729,
0.0190257933,
0.0315227732,
0.0540533848,
0.0446793027,
0.0029403563,
-0.0351486169,
0.0196050182,
0.0302313734,
0.0624144711,
-0.0415280312,
-0.0210553557,
0.0307619628,
0.0478426702,
0.0604301319,
-0.0084037911,
-0.0337336361,
-0.0229781922,
0.050085932,
0.018532306,
0.0076172808,
0.0106344,
0.019392807,
-0.0512925237,
0.0260198377,
0.0620655119,
-0.0095025348,
-0.0469785146,
-0.0001255233,
-0.0043877475,
-0.004033688,
-0.0025397104,
-0.0770164952,
-0.0468601845,
-0.0618442148,
0.0442871079,
0.0150132906,
0.0422986634,
0.0357982442,
0.0010629194,
-0.0486735925,
0.0187291168,
0.0208243057,
-0.0551814847,
-0.0240083952,
-0.063265644,
-0.035944365,
-0.0175594166,
0.0320779793,
0.0229942407,
-0.009735994,
-0.0313470662,
0.0428240597,
-0.0432341136,
-0.0428161435,
-0.004768739,
-0.0136030596,
0.0636410788,
0.0809153914,
0.0050064265,
-0.0330773368,
-0.0304906946,
0.0368627384,
-0.0027250533,
0.0149122793,
-0.0211793203,
0.0197744109,
-0.0684806332,
-0.005578829,
0.0383163765,
0.0269078705,
-0.0057838294,
-0.002730337,
0.0191514436,
0.045876272,
-0.0682944208,
-0.0068515497,
0.0069712698,
0.0110477367,
-0.0168611556,
0.0754133984,
0.0318348482,
-0.030015979,
-0.0022402587,
0.0183911789,
0.0712608397,
-0.0565879121,
0.0343975089,
0.0301398858,
0.000763944,
-0.1078950018,
-0.015423853,
-0.0419108681,
0.0155182425,
0.0037111726,
0.0103890011,
-0.002911472,
0.01095457,
0.0167623218,
-0.0564230271,
-0.0085743722,
-0.0029777701,
0.0162828248,
-0.0583911575,
-0.0194670986,
0.0122220302,
-0.0756875426,
0.0126784621,
0.0457399748,
-0.0285223071,
-0.0254264157,
0.0596654043,
-0.0205604173,
0.0055460865,
0.0360179693,
-0.0105502717,
-0.0688259378,
0.0601741634,
-0.0081111575,
-0.0359447971,
0.0538575761,
0.0605575666,
-0.007532822,
-0.0155182201,
0.0148513913,
-0.0344020687,
0.0032147334,
-0.027425468,
0.0335942619,
-0.0315269008,
-0.0093857916,
0.0076330793,
0.0375571214,
0.0947577506,
-0.0358491316,
0.04740474,
-0.0022011658,
0.079598397,
0.0326192379,
0.0773084685,
-0.0643097907,
-0.0015505168,
0.0134644154,
0.0360624045,
0.0105421124,
0.0754473954,
0.0288992152,
-0.0332288444,
-0.0046576578,
0.0954585001,
-0.0193893816,
-0.0202125255,
-0.0267921425,
0.0078507019,
-0.0192894526,
0.0278320648,
0.0385272056,
0.0003514555,
0.022436928,
0.0508820228,
0.0112190647,
0.0206332393,
0.0216656104,
0.0466030277,
-0.0125423186,
0.0149414679,
-0.0173548274,
0.01372205,
0.0110688005,
0.0465450622,
0.0060539665,
-0.0035732416,
0.0212377962,
-0.0268370137,
0.0589270368,
-0.0167248901,
-0.0394898169,
0.0589753054,
-0.0190452617,
0.0002512656,
0.0096947299,
0.0282947011,
-0.0509732254,
0.0185755473,
-0.0568678714,
0.0454205424,
-0.0515128635,
-0.0602125786,
0.0139311207,
0.0289823841,
-0.03312096,
-0.0217891317,
0.0226067659,
-0.0483470149,
0.0094274003,
-0.0309053175,
0.0334514156,
-0.0331313573,
0.0378567986,
-0.0185913555,
-0.0127780493,
-0.0311553404,
0.010705621,
-0.0261093266,
-0.0081090899,
0.0261579882,
0.0055331853,
-6.778063527e-33,
-0.0368059576,
0.0344995037,
0.0099748652,
-0.001958647,
-0.0448152311,
0.0270146783,
-0.0245120823,
0.0043071373,
0.0102333855,
-0.0211880598,
0.0022680536,
-0.0133276461,
0.0229826272,
0.0375186726,
-0.007894842,
-0.025021825,
0.0693973228,
-0.0064581251,
-0.0085089989,
-0.0044557601,
0.0185001343,
0.0182174481,
0.0131649617,
-0.0437134914,
-0.0526984893,
0.0394121595,
-0.018756466,
-0.0385927707,
-0.0269918721,
0.0252384469,
-0.0185354706,
0.0496548414,
-0.0063212509,
-0.0431025326,
-0.0067692576,
0.0034081084,
-0.080676645,
0.0485112146,
-0.0163502414,
0.0654789954,
-0.0745894238,
-0.0341806822,
0.037221916,
0.0285414886,
-0.0310925879,
-0.0476765819,
0.0103560155,
-0.0172919836,
-0.0342974886,
-0.0643501282,
0.018014675,
0.0266763587,
-0.0359890051,
-0.0182481017,
0.0874371603,
0.0431208201,
-0.002759415,
-0.0235356148,
-0.0674106479,
0.0240572784,
-0.0179992728,
0.0120906178,
0.0575950071,
0.0304382201,
-0.010899175,
0.0202949215,
0.0541256405,
-0.0708419681,
-0.0206518006,
-0.0044872961,
0.0074982326,
0.0359689854,
0.0011374369,
0.0104603264,
0.0174126048,
-0.0290677082,
0.008260549,
-0.0000064342,
-0.0270882472,
0.0619424023,
0.044133164,
0.0640168861,
-0.0401574187,
-0.0045668958,
-0.0402420796,
0.0208782461,
-0.027792044,
-0.0044675642,
0.0435596332,
0.018270636,
-0.020600168,
0.0306777563,
0.0850503296,
-0.0141562354,
0.0691543147,
0.0133535853,
0.040894229,
0.0376671776,
-0.0061942297,
-0.0012516603,
-0.0381746441,
0.0118424259,
0.0725213885,
0.0077577913,
0.0257627498,
-0.0244665816,
-0.0071709184,
0.0804861858,
-0.0380869992,
-0.0390452743,
-0.0066185971,
-0.005363388,
0.003722158,
-0.0340732783,
0.0370678194,
-0.0073121483,
-0.0342050195,
0.0197467059,
-0.0258630943,
0.0292645469,
-0.0712079927,
-0.0107988119,
0.0133556621,
0.0061788801,
-0.0023394465,
0.0384808965,
0.0087975385,
-0.0688188449,
0.0318005085,
-0.0086358404,
-0.0262719262,
0.0303945225,
3.003e-7,
-0.0361669585,
-0.0157150161,
0.0110253869,
-0.0366880149,
0.0305945668,
0.025538126,
0.0111951632,
0.0365904644,
-0.0191964619,
0.0130450185,
-0.0044459845,
0.0185694303,
0.0678129345,
-0.0151248602,
-0.0474955924,
-0.0289196894,
-0.0130938431,
0.0082854405,
0.004402786,
0.0188851729,
0.0567021482,
0.066649057,
-0.0293513276,
-0.0241133589,
0.0351625457,
-0.0021070761,
0.043010883,
-0.0009746664,
-0.0000279494,
-0.0065685911,
-0.0166464765,
-0.0713368058,
-0.0308834426,
0.0276377704,
-0.0047945157,
-0.0390089527,
0.0332721099,
0.0091879228,
-0.0198030118,
-0.1057558432,
-0.0117799416,
0.0826488808,
-0.0529277325,
0.0167818759,
0.0539938062,
-0.0255846865,
-0.0440950692,
0.0269440189,
-0.071668826,
0.025899535,
-0.0165151004,
0.009711287,
-0.0070378408,
-0.0099933557,
-0.0075001838,
-0.0106635196,
-0.0501193888,
-0.0416915677,
-0.0172972325,
-0.0215401333,
-0.0874988958,
-0.008456734,
-0.0252902582,
0.0106651718,
0.0041438211,
-0.0451650955,
-0.0339407884,
1.984714764e-34,
0.0393876247,
-0.0048185615,
0.0231063366,
0.0079143355,
0.0113133742,
-0.0773176923,
-0.0273397993,
0.0317728184,
-0.0100110527,
-0.0418950878,
-0.0452873223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14045v2 | The CoT Collection: Improving Zero-shot and Few-shot Learning of Language Models via Chain-of-Thought Fine-Tuning | 2023-05-23T13:14:59 | 2023-10-14T10:46:55 | Seungone Kim, Se June Joo, Doyoung Kim, Joel Jang, Seonghyeon Ye, Jamin Shin, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) with less than 100B parameters are known to perform
poorly on chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning in contrast to large LMs when
solving unseen tasks. In this work, we aim to equip smaller LMs with the
step-by-step reasoning capability by instruction tuning with CoT rationales. In
order to achieve this goal, we first introduce a new instruction-tuning dataset
called the CoT Collection, which augments the existing Flan Collection
(including only 9 CoT tasks) with additional 1.84 million rationales across
1,060 tasks. We show that CoT fine-tuning Flan-T5 (3B & 11B) with CoT
Collection enables smaller LMs to have better CoT capabilities on unseen tasks.
On the BIG-Bench-Hard (BBH) benchmark, we report an average improvement of
+4.34% (Flan-T5 3B) and +2.60% (Flan-T5 11B), in terms of zero-shot task
accuracy. Furthermore, we show that instruction tuning with CoT Collection
allows LMs to possess stronger few-shot learning capabilities on 4
domain-specific tasks, resulting in an improvement of +2.24% (Flan-T5 3B) and
+2.37% (Flan-T5 11B), even outperforming ChatGPT utilizing demonstrations until
the max length by a +13.98% margin. Our code, the CoT Collection data, and
model checkpoints are publicly available. | [
0.0027745359,
0.0474863611,
0.0017311423,
0.0430434942,
-0.0396855809,
0.0440865159,
0.0462391712,
-0.0274351351,
-0.0323760584,
-0.0378327332,
-0.0475084297,
-0.0463925898,
0.0011771925,
0.00423533,
0.0197251569,
-0.0386061184,
0.0395044014,
-0.0528286546,
0.0019153116,
-0.0142100165,
-0.0259411242,
0.0244796816,
-0.0463515632,
0.0305394549,
0.033433225,
-0.0412659086,
-0.0317255221,
-0.004944081,
0.0112837711,
-0.0049219816,
0.0020957014,
0.065077804,
0.043128036,
0.0489760712,
0.0000023489,
-0.0249414835,
-0.0112922145,
0.0001778559,
-0.0622266792,
0.0156861078,
0.0029034598,
0.0240362268,
-0.002227233,
0.0324519314,
-0.0204269625,
-0.0088265771,
0.0376604237,
0.0173262488,
0.0478432737,
0.0703121424,
0.0102570718,
-0.0202245917,
0.0082532624,
-0.0332122929,
0.0131645603,
-0.059239313,
-0.0069248681,
0.0032108019,
0.0427405015,
0.0161954723,
-0.0146311978,
0.0173510797,
0.0356295034,
0.0318228453,
-0.0457938612,
0.0420904607,
-0.0434626453,
-0.0144664999,
0.0237337258,
0.062379539,
-0.044325944,
-0.0435093753,
-0.0180321168,
0.003224988,
-0.0152163617,
-0.0338872112,
-0.0551794432,
0.0383900218,
0.0082517453,
0.0173474196,
0.010089986,
-0.0345332548,
0.026463395,
0.0200366303,
-0.0438989103,
0.0402846262,
0.0025966219,
-0.0136677036,
-0.0118838279,
-0.0074182674,
-0.0339315534,
-0.0546893068,
-0.0478144176,
0.0392397791,
-0.0394498333,
0.0096790986,
-0.0153546007,
-0.0224161334,
-0.0068842247,
-0.0004202043,
0.0596456453,
0.0587617606,
-0.0075397189,
0.0586777776,
-0.0510203429,
0.0468158387,
-0.0045633069,
0.0421686321,
-0.0312385224,
-0.0032661636,
-0.0765745938,
0.010404231,
-0.0412138253,
0.0447262451,
-0.0318328924,
-0.0014500257,
-0.020314673,
0.0027122311,
0.0211778339,
0.0107748462,
0.0249146409,
-0.0145080006,
-0.0199757591,
-0.0308498219,
-0.0050956686,
0.0427337401,
-0.0413628221,
0.0218687821,
0.033458516,
-0.0644385666,
-0.0537600219,
-0.0249802601,
0.0042385245,
-0.0423366763,
0.0435332954,
0.041997958,
-0.0083549041,
-0.0559185892,
-0.0364322811,
-0.0013911375,
0.0031150631,
-0.1280687749,
0.0242512785,
-0.0765222535,
0.0186285563,
0.001741134,
-0.0181609355,
-0.0105901817,
0.0038499488,
0.0400279984,
-0.0364304893,
0.0741945133,
0.0071659675,
-0.013103338,
-0.0277406424,
0.0156951156,
-0.037020009,
0.0959298983,
0.0309538525,
0.0410936102,
0.0029683176,
0.0296691228,
-0.0016169058,
0.0161488894,
0.0306831505,
0.001537865,
-0.0067019239,
-0.0000954232,
-0.0035356856,
0.0183901731,
0.0117512001,
0.0309780929,
-0.0331760235,
-0.0059167892,
0.0369916409,
0.0442506559,
0.0345659479,
-0.000819931,
0.063253589,
0.0054058339,
0.0128733693,
-0.0183143411,
-0.073944442,
0.0553343482,
-0.0362936035,
0.0222619735,
0.0057580029,
0.0243180376,
-0.0483167358,
-0.0216884278,
-0.0198077708,
0.0164453313,
-0.0082886461,
0.0274649635,
0.053564176,
0.0085916482,
-0.0435865559,
0.0460263677,
0.0342408754,
-0.0299890116,
-0.0570624359,
-0.0562737584,
0.0181244276,
0.0419487543,
0.0354971811,
-0.0069042169,
-0.0710749328,
-0.0093098944,
0.048050642,
0.0311894398,
0.0269175116,
0.0150365336,
0.016473515,
-0.0622544102,
-0.0152753359,
-0.0511283092,
0.0317417644,
0.0153663782,
0.0206548832,
0.0087592052,
0.0026148979,
-0.0323416367,
0.0166368559,
0.0110444762,
-0.0217957422,
-0.0346174575,
0.0120059121,
0.0251792409,
0.0150720011,
-0.0023130476,
-0.0055629518,
0.014026151,
0.007259585,
-0.0124835875,
0.0231749695,
-0.0190314706,
-0.0489339195,
-0.0497910604,
0.0375877023,
0.0054842257,
-0.0100772418,
0.0134711489,
-0.0621607229,
-0.0365723707,
0.0461672246,
-0.0048776967,
0.0081588197,
-0.0186684839,
0.021654835,
-0.0061020702,
0.0202597622,
-0.0160925202,
0.0793140456,
-0.0295131113,
0.002261997,
0.0245039389,
0.0281205624,
0.0064915922,
-0.0281699281,
-0.010606356,
-0.0013687423,
0.0004317866,
0.0010247648,
-0.0217080619,
0.0401350781,
-0.0227491315,
-0.0047237473,
-0.0779747516,
0.030528944,
-0.0236091595,
0.0122937793,
0.0110420538,
-0.0001006789,
0.0054067741,
0.0079880515,
-0.0058240262,
0.0161826145,
-0.0179914776,
0.0176967978,
0.0129452255,
0.0098786186,
-0.0354286656,
-0.0226724502,
-0.0227007791,
-0.0315941833,
0.0323931277,
-0.0504684225,
0.0066992058,
-0.0122829201,
0.0530727692,
-0.02272534,
0.0273416806,
-0.0173794478,
-0.0410179086,
0.0278047938,
-0.0357134417,
0.00157232,
0.0936681032,
-0.0214571673,
0.0148336114,
0.0595049337,
-0.0086608091,
-0.0381509662,
0.0493462682,
0.0104771797,
-0.029958589,
0.0074468288,
0.0204056893,
-0.0466678366,
0.0935314223,
-0.0364308879,
-0.0142117711,
-0.0880403519,
0.0252033435,
0.0141742155,
-0.0021186396,
-0.024352055,
0.0243846662,
-0.020478392,
0.0195057951,
-0.0462118462,
-0.0079475911,
0.0674240068,
-0.035713356,
-0.0075912336,
-0.0647503287,
0.012524833,
-0.0273705535,
0.0648063943,
0.0150789339,
0.0033093404,
0.0298145209,
0.0077195377,
-0.0795775279,
-0.011187111,
0.0102353487,
-0.0076490026,
0.0578300767,
-0.044732675,
0.0017873774,
-0.0360293426,
-0.0616574287,
-0.0367717482,
0.0049805576,
-0.04332266,
0.0475210249,
-0.008869363,
-0.0293096621,
-0.020805534,
-0.0298820045,
0.0418456532,
0.0514948964,
-0.0049869465,
0.0029862309,
-0.0276721083,
0.002022933,
0.0447586998,
-0.0063788192,
0.0364291146,
-0.0234918278,
0.0359518491,
0.0394479223,
0.0627447963,
-0.0130736791,
-0.0343164653,
0.0205333326,
-0.0049031675,
0.0107139032,
-0.0267882757,
0.0311026685,
0.0757512003,
-0.0738908798,
-0.0304505099,
0.1122773588,
0.0216514952,
-0.0311043542,
0.0024339492,
0.003256453,
0.035189189,
0.0322184898,
0.0156468712,
-0.0989602506,
-0.0516489893,
0.0240688231,
-0.0068348735,
-0.015761517,
-0.0339364409,
-0.0221583918,
-0.1281071454,
0.0231540147,
0.0186040346,
-0.0109639885,
0.0071194172,
-0.0351921842,
-0.0126110287,
-0.0117774801,
0.0167597588,
0.0260078404,
-0.0044424604,
0.0027442465,
0.0271134935,
0.017204497,
-0.061628174,
0.0908033326,
-0.0167706143,
0.0464574024,
0.0032134133,
0.0028783972,
0.0217771232,
-0.0468696021,
0.0442355312,
-0.0222248845,
0.0114159584,
-0.0059856125,
0.0186259225,
0.0031407271,
-0.0208854917,
0.0113355378,
0.0497442409,
-0.0143949818,
-0.0291657839,
-0.0288919527,
0.0848754495,
-0.0126399416,
-0.0108816028,
0.0011901741,
-0.0149541954,
-0.0433159545,
0.0504703932,
0.0582435243,
-0.034821514,
-0.0444139726,
-0.0359598696,
-0.0783575028,
-0.0789443329,
-0.0239765551,
0.0097908741,
0.029829599,
-0.0175408591,
-0.0363605395,
-0.0195622947,
0.0271571185,
0.0852437764,
-0.0267533995,
-0.0034334708,
-0.0138531867,
0.0350264087,
-0.0356155299,
0.0228286143,
-0.0604876578,
0.0115556298,
-0.0599849559,
0.0032502378,
0.026028173,
-0.0262702126,
-0.0262088943,
0.015132782,
-0.1119083539,
-0.0569943711,
-0.0270199813,
0.063801676,
0.0282863081,
0.0494181253,
-0.0303009786,
-0.0288681425,
0.0364184044,
0.0285969246,
-0.0315744765,
0.009115804,
0.0460211188,
-0.0283015929,
0.0188995209,
0.0542599484,
-0.0514565371,
0.0200437568,
0.0470648706,
0.0406213775,
-0.0156678557,
0.0419331565,
0.0199723989,
0.0000635746,
0.0479273684,
0.002555971,
-0.0225257222,
-0.0067840116,
0.0543149859,
-0.0325292423,
0.0062655816,
-0.0479697734,
-0.0151005592,
0.0026874503,
-0.0245441664,
0.000066681,
-0.0589946099,
0.0352651663,
0.040385697,
0.0140461037,
0.0069948118,
-0.0119677987,
0.0477303118,
0.0313186124,
-0.0106732883,
-0.0432995781,
0.0089084832,
-0.0036592437,
0.0384680219,
-0.0299299881,
0.091253683,
0.0269567594,
0.0148543846,
-0.078822948,
0.0373841114,
-0.0663849488,
-0.0604885928,
-0.0278105307,
-0.0064602764,
0.0664914474,
-0.0004063239,
0.0096529573,
-0.0301636085,
-0.0188935082,
-0.01267247,
0.0179934911,
-0.0013569955,
-0.0291642845,
0.0046855607,
0.0542956591,
0.0175780356,
-0.0104520479,
0.0887757316,
0.0078907004,
0.0539113395,
0.0393767394,
0.0475102812,
-0.0287338533,
-0.0333001167,
-0.0280936845,
0.0042287409,
0.026347911,
0.0290265679,
-0.0550439395,
-0.0905602425,
-0.0151026035,
0.0130108912,
0.0051527512,
0.0118166329,
0.0448184833,
0.0435146615,
-0.003445975,
-0.0332814939,
-0.0094953645,
-0.0238974951,
0.0539381728,
-0.0349268094,
-0.0068807267,
-6.854867389e-33,
-0.0342889093,
0.0227788631,
0.0506792925,
0.0204875227,
0.0099790422,
-0.0229454432,
-0.0572806895,
0.0110896444,
-0.0599741712,
0.0075434712,
-0.0309676379,
0.0019602047,
0.0100995172,
0.0307819191,
0.0175046474,
-0.0197707936,
0.0399246439,
-0.0180263408,
-0.0304416437,
0.0148899378,
0.0316377096,
0.0055698575,
0.052296605,
-0.0034872342,
-0.0395024307,
0.0031238028,
-0.0182315074,
0.0377821848,
-0.0371451862,
0.0671741515,
-0.0011905821,
0.0083390856,
0.021536909,
-0.0334268957,
-0.0202114694,
-0.0493121184,
-0.0775848404,
-0.0329500996,
0.020939596,
0.0022012298,
-0.024099227,
-0.049845051,
0.0108999237,
0.0180350821,
-0.015919121,
-0.0597424172,
-0.0234572906,
-0.0400128439,
-0.0088976631,
0.0198453236,
-0.0160134323,
0.0021656603,
-0.0077094641,
-0.0545247979,
0.033554323,
0.038856592,
-0.020165896,
-0.0079928525,
-0.0380479768,
0.0015443717,
0.0135507593,
0.0441872887,
0.0722825006,
-0.0075513809,
0.0190998297,
0.0428197905,
0.0071304552,
-0.0021834879,
-0.0447142646,
0.004579742,
0.0550183244,
0.0777848363,
0.0421142764,
0.018913867,
0.0370794274,
0.0208354965,
-0.084320955,
-0.0142003708,
0.0251974091,
0.08417923,
0.034146037,
0.0081653316,
-0.0563374013,
-0.0125677669,
-0.0354983136,
-0.0090344921,
-0.0614322759,
-0.0260087382,
0.0269333143,
0.0236793626,
-0.0157197099,
-0.0517413951,
0.0553965159,
-0.0367527828,
0.0065988069,
0.0409549661,
-0.0206941087,
0.0246344805,
0.0062436485,
0.0345935896,
-0.0745490417,
-0.027404597,
0.0195330586,
0.0358711444,
0.0169111304,
0.0127184326,
0.0684577078,
0.0400226004,
-0.0492208004,
-0.0193568636,
-0.0729184523,
0.0177683048,
0.0046972018,
0.0391827226,
0.018836692,
0.0119536715,
0.00044843,
0.0564443655,
-0.0378326476,
-0.0447110198,
0.0031910317,
0.0186868552,
0.0033189531,
0.0158638358,
-0.0256741624,
-0.0058150715,
-0.0341223218,
0.0054294067,
0.0269229077,
-0.0514049344,
-0.0203883089,
0.0444404185,
3.034e-7,
-0.0018935839,
0.0483804159,
-0.0017881388,
0.0215237774,
0.0137964571,
0.0458423235,
-0.026932653,
0.0018151392,
0.0117953215,
-0.0280395672,
-0.0053276699,
0.0539351143,
0.0467249528,
0.0336533897,
-0.0690119937,
0.0163073577,
-0.0218180735,
0.0040932633,
-0.0458998829,
-0.0319903083,
0.0261326637,
0.1259318739,
0.0303428341,
0.0041719289,
0.0354103819,
-0.0011755405,
0.0217726473,
0.0039344341,
-0.0177403074,
-0.0162140559,
-0.0313887671,
0.033435341,
0.0007474684,
0.0247079004,
-0.015847031,
0.0216253158,
-0.0339563079,
0.0569353104,
0.0069383592,
-0.0411857665,
-0.0003866177,
-0.0373041481,
-0.0053847288,
-0.0496359318,
0.1027705371,
-0.0458798148,
-0.0251325201,
0.0112835653,
0.0062902546,
-0.0085921297,
-0.0162042174,
-0.0057058632,
0.0040186155,
0.0135038188,
0.0040454851,
-0.0161695872,
-0.0045159101,
-0.1097439006,
-0.017207915,
0.0482539572,
-0.0232748967,
-0.0072281505,
-0.0349753462,
-0.0200593155,
0.0437295623,
-0.0599248596,
-0.0089422138,
3.205177972e-34,
0.0311066248,
-0.0513296351,
0.039918419,
0.033221446,
0.029379515,
-0.012401049,
-0.0403884016,
-0.0053316718,
0.0340225175,
-0.0812359825,
-0.0300116893
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.