id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13628v2 | Improving Self-training for Cross-lingual Named Entity Recognition with Contrastive and Prototype Learning | 2023-05-23T02:52:16 | 2023-06-04T16:32:41 | Ran Zhou, Xin Li, Lidong Bing, Erik Cambria, Chunyan Miao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In cross-lingual named entity recognition (NER), self-training is commonly
used to bridge the linguistic gap by training on pseudo-labeled target-language
data. However, due to sub-optimal performance on target languages, the pseudo
labels are often noisy and limit the overall performance. In this work, we aim
to improve self-training for cross-lingual NER by combining representation
learning and pseudo label refinement in one coherent framework. Our proposed
method, namely ContProto mainly comprises two components: (1) contrastive
self-training and (2) prototype-based pseudo-labeling. Our contrastive
self-training facilitates span classification by separating clusters of
different classes, and enhances cross-lingual transferability by producing
closely-aligned representations between the source and target language.
Meanwhile, prototype-based pseudo-labeling effectively improves the accuracy of
pseudo labels during training. We evaluate ContProto on multiple transfer
pairs, and experimental results show our method brings in substantial
improvements over current state-of-the-art methods. | [
-0.000106918,
0.0012416085,
0.0128588313,
0.0367610268,
0.0379428938,
0.0351386741,
0.0199335236,
-0.0264540296,
0.024366973,
-0.0039383643,
-0.0945569649,
-0.0261812434,
-0.0152220596,
-0.0109038865,
0.0508047827,
-0.0689675286,
0.0362903886,
0.008934333,
-0.0231298506,
0.0068911305,
-0.0146613792,
-0.0098921191,
-0.0200469419,
-0.0345905647,
0.0114532188,
-0.015777763,
-0.0072170757,
0.0005356356,
0.0346482061,
-0.0570239201,
0.0258325506,
0.0513624959,
-0.0113989292,
0.026699109,
0.0000017685,
-0.0499263778,
-0.0390170887,
-0.0032600493,
0.0138758449,
-0.0101943798,
0.0703542903,
-0.0493953899,
-0.0272968616,
0.0044101067,
-0.0056879809,
-0.1163744032,
0.0592803396,
0.0854213834,
0.0150483269,
0.0680951104,
-0.0211679228,
-0.0249089748,
0.0315615088,
-0.0337868258,
-0.0175175499,
-0.0264029969,
0.002533765,
-0.0014468943,
-0.0419139341,
-0.0025264837,
0.0016925038,
0.0172288232,
-0.0005464454,
0.0307982229,
0.002578771,
0.0385756828,
-0.0261706207,
0.0031710113,
-0.0068657156,
0.073186934,
-0.0221143365,
0.0122578293,
0.0283535738,
-0.0053097364,
-0.0199657455,
-0.0658431053,
-0.0014150537,
-0.0250048116,
-0.0152147636,
0.0150835421,
0.0630128682,
0.0543696955,
0.0371390991,
-0.0001850703,
-0.0295177586,
0.0124040097,
0.0019699263,
-0.0294170659,
0.0427888557,
0.0429550111,
0.0351577252,
-0.019871274,
0.0413564891,
-0.0062155048,
0.0347967967,
0.0178406872,
-0.025789218,
-0.018592909,
0.0034369021,
-0.0192815922,
-0.0138881318,
0.0275747813,
-0.060888309,
0.0206878204,
-0.0770644173,
0.0006977486,
-0.0371128134,
0.042319268,
-0.0094390623,
-0.034373723,
-0.0802064911,
0.0176608507,
-0.065574646,
0.0416569449,
-0.0335585773,
0.0359539762,
-0.0369457453,
-0.0037432741,
-0.0091577601,
0.0194539763,
0.0102845151,
-0.0456946455,
-0.036925789,
-0.0099241948,
-0.0228654463,
0.0465005226,
-0.0251343064,
-0.0305719711,
-0.0379674919,
-0.046471864,
0.0045730416,
-0.0204176921,
0.0148238307,
-0.063341029,
0.0179630294,
0.0766545907,
-0.0163994282,
-0.0696510449,
-0.0692481026,
0.0359643511,
-0.0052995966,
-0.0714806095,
0.003172233,
-0.0316726044,
0.0316312127,
-0.0014699079,
0.0133995451,
-0.0436047055,
-0.00797428,
-0.0402626805,
0.0028659841,
0.1010324359,
-0.0640898049,
-0.0436907783,
-0.0005403912,
-0.0034095526,
0.004074309,
0.0743335634,
0.0310737751,
-0.0258812904,
0.0289655868,
-0.0025503819,
-0.022387296,
0.0348283015,
0.0274081342,
-0.0074874195,
-0.0186732002,
0.0057251481,
0.0499208756,
-0.0053228899,
0.0556938164,
-0.005001938,
0.0015897418,
-0.0222575404,
0.0054703313,
0.0025976896,
0.0216489155,
0.067553632,
0.0376072787,
-0.0043598707,
-0.0087722791,
0.0218043104,
-0.026206892,
0.0208539292,
0.0016582924,
0.01540686,
0.0044738152,
0.0489924215,
-0.0543448888,
-0.0039459863,
0.0286902953,
-0.0121140117,
0.0108407661,
-0.0017353733,
0.0609788969,
0.0346044116,
-0.0287638567,
0.028280329,
0.0624001585,
-0.0223050825,
0.0482795872,
0.0096335597,
-0.0130849481,
0.0635309294,
-0.026954418,
-0.0508984327,
-0.0434941947,
-0.0236969981,
-0.0133172926,
0.0555513315,
0.0579660833,
-0.0176196601,
0.0573150367,
-0.0258219,
-0.0134679517,
-0.0110284062,
-0.0116689755,
0.0480568819,
-0.0294757485,
0.0578350872,
0.0298925359,
-0.0622611381,
-0.0215816908,
0.0310332254,
-0.0395354182,
-0.0139693217,
0.0425176956,
0.0485455617,
0.0134215541,
0.0552168004,
0.0061857509,
-0.0326979235,
0.0123352176,
-0.0363101885,
0.0180358533,
-0.001445731,
-0.0229621511,
-0.0835379884,
0.0064000534,
-0.0123614902,
-0.0399197303,
-0.0074899103,
-0.0315885544,
-0.0548479706,
0.0050623212,
0.0349484645,
0.0629444495,
-0.0400780328,
0.0124909766,
0.0173738599,
0.0369042754,
0.0176661052,
0.0322124399,
0.0360980742,
0.0371624716,
-0.0029431887,
0.0218466111,
0.0278878845,
-0.0194623228,
-0.0328980573,
0.0617837906,
-0.0072398456,
-0.0299580824,
-0.0020075704,
0.0082751252,
-0.0657223538,
-0.0100496691,
-0.0596344881,
0.0045083952,
-0.0154931583,
0.0567062944,
0.0165071599,
0.0161406416,
-0.0163602009,
-0.0216899496,
-0.0322561562,
-0.0071712593,
-0.036934834,
0.0031723559,
0.041833587,
0.011161509,
0.0200784225,
-0.0002115658,
0.0111663425,
-0.0046942164,
0.0085377339,
-0.0228448138,
-0.00736717,
-0.0793128535,
0.0366196893,
-0.0405906811,
0.0235369503,
0.0156951584,
0.0052275988,
-0.0359542109,
0.0355741158,
0.0119855609,
-0.0000423607,
-0.0179664642,
-0.0252552852,
0.0239354186,
-0.035888236,
-0.0419059545,
0.0267670751,
-0.0008838648,
0.0264275149,
-0.015396948,
-0.0380214527,
-0.011435329,
0.0721261501,
-0.0367377289,
0.0155981779,
-0.0653904453,
-0.0475782566,
-0.0075187623,
-0.0206152853,
0.0297458954,
0.0527657419,
0.0071922312,
-0.0050712056,
-0.0345379449,
-0.0030633165,
0.0766111389,
-0.056627091,
-0.040627569,
-0.0308329612,
-0.01340508,
-0.0323730148,
0.03145881,
-0.0203431193,
0.0146197258,
0.0477368645,
-0.080324173,
-0.0139399357,
-0.0150495721,
-0.0082788523,
-0.0213977955,
0.0035840808,
0.023955496,
0.0094348257,
-0.0101375878,
-0.0328183398,
-0.0278225094,
-0.0114354836,
-0.017938586,
0.0180467628,
-0.0399143696,
0.0062839733,
0.0023943386,
0.04623897,
0.0069154082,
0.0663764477,
-0.001207912,
-0.0011497502,
-0.0004176205,
0.049855981,
-0.0178109538,
-0.01353464,
0.019565491,
0.002987253,
0.0073021152,
0.0080688354,
0.0207304619,
-0.0362515599,
-0.0114708347,
0.0271531194,
0.0101392837,
-0.0370757356,
-0.0370415002,
-0.0429493301,
0.019493755,
-0.0163454693,
-0.0144602256,
0.0890416875,
-0.0123175308,
-0.0491301753,
-0.0283780638,
-0.00284877,
0.0118740723,
0.0366358161,
0.032224413,
-0.0269654635,
-0.0177515689,
-0.0037656976,
0.006967383,
0.0143896481,
-0.0402657613,
-0.018984545,
-0.1225538477,
-0.0112120323,
-0.0010575537,
-0.1061520576,
-0.0128120435,
-0.0693497211,
0.0187855996,
-0.0363112278,
0.0055548167,
-0.0336458571,
-0.0219843965,
-0.0124278776,
0.0176676083,
0.0052033165,
-0.0360338353,
0.0019768293,
-0.0466409549,
0.0284540672,
0.0222947635,
0.039616663,
-0.0052845436,
-0.0060296282,
-0.0023765333,
-0.1266940683,
-0.03986267,
-0.0522163846,
0.0821519494,
-0.0395214595,
-0.0411436744,
0.0334525257,
-0.0352779515,
-0.0249817539,
-0.0095447907,
0.0032129891,
0.0553029068,
0.0596068092,
0.0222952385,
0.0382647961,
-0.0229892172,
0.042451296,
0.0611963943,
-0.014002162,
-0.0089950236,
0.0036250113,
0.0331205465,
0.0287585165,
-0.026688179,
0.0146060036,
0.0151235154,
-0.0490301773,
-0.0483301245,
-0.0360372774,
-0.093548432,
0.0305529255,
0.0486799218,
-0.0002176793,
0.0212660655,
-0.0064357906,
-0.0083071487,
-0.0478787981,
0.0401914679,
-0.0288156457,
-0.0226259734,
-0.0425766297,
-0.0279357303,
0.0514864959,
-0.0321731307,
-0.0038546857,
-0.009899931,
-0.0195924509,
-0.0506370068,
-0.0197608192,
0.0323215015,
-0.0011922847,
0.0589124747,
-0.0012507215,
-0.0210270807,
0.0333744586,
0.0373259112,
-0.0559500158,
-0.0352395251,
0.0685871542,
0.031324964,
-0.004045886,
0.0296348147,
-0.0123572014,
0.0251398999,
0.0576696396,
0.0323824622,
-0.0359626785,
-0.0180552937,
-0.0054567852,
-0.0071626198,
0.0685798079,
-0.0275325533,
0.0230738316,
-0.0676140189,
0.0196896866,
0.0072040209,
0.016152909,
-0.0076469369,
-0.0008670813,
0.0266912859,
-0.0305295531,
0.0008355501,
0.0403034389,
-0.0520887561,
-0.0120659862,
-0.0109828003,
-0.0082439799,
-0.0253374167,
0.0592941083,
-0.0271208789,
0.018835986,
0.007183691,
0.0182047226,
0.0790697709,
0.0505560748,
-0.0666923001,
-0.0156145655,
0.012233126,
0.0170005169,
-0.0112204757,
0.0109010916,
0.0017994881,
0.0406831205,
-0.0440370776,
0.0188588053,
0.0514872968,
-0.0070506698,
0.0679083019,
-0.0031738,
-0.0117315929,
0.0129078096,
-0.014927214,
-0.0387015194,
-0.016411148,
0.0088659329,
-0.0026147363,
-0.0028581577,
0.0061081527,
0.0423829667,
-0.0022310701,
0.0141173843,
0.0207760837,
0.0172792487,
-0.0483704507,
0.0018580756,
0.0181046929,
-0.0239084661,
-0.027021097,
-0.0039431904,
-0.0107690105,
-0.0767794773,
0.0583665296,
-0.0339777283,
-0.0344709679,
0.0270146336,
0.0120440908,
0.0164800957,
0.00247086,
-0.0036634488,
-0.0101877553,
-0.0026697607,
0.0820418298,
0.0009110087,
0.0012564186,
-5.810555269e-33,
-0.0423655622,
0.0073225587,
0.0199432578,
-0.0182277653,
-0.0161509626,
0.0137431631,
-0.0314384066,
0.0035855812,
0.0104846237,
-0.0170697886,
-0.0097025102,
-0.0229618996,
0.0477737896,
0.0084050149,
-0.018035356,
-0.0418365709,
0.060886573,
0.0242552403,
-0.0079005389,
0.0409355052,
0.0207007658,
0.0670431554,
0.1271543056,
-0.0979579836,
0.0330380835,
0.0202271715,
0.0130558014,
-0.0065208455,
0.1100550368,
0.0360275805,
-0.0222814884,
0.0106660444,
0.0050636167,
-0.032503102,
0.0122729745,
0.0018211966,
-0.1613668501,
-0.0319819972,
-0.0240159817,
0.0406249128,
-0.0105687035,
-0.0348692983,
0.0160351936,
-0.0152668683,
0.0236102939,
-0.0007923829,
0.0300081912,
-0.0345857628,
0.0112761818,
-0.0041087861,
-0.0580048598,
0.0340779275,
0.0017332311,
0.0471497811,
0.0936471969,
0.0486113802,
0.039056398,
-0.0073265112,
-0.0889705643,
-0.0004049389,
-0.0348753668,
-0.0090100337,
0.0455581173,
0.0327957422,
-0.0174916126,
0.0137771657,
0.0693392083,
0.006329318,
0.0432925746,
0.0038393172,
0.0354141779,
-0.0063364487,
-0.0209027808,
0.0669148192,
0.0446202084,
-0.0377153754,
-0.0634302944,
0.0380789973,
-0.0237374902,
-0.0202867165,
-0.0214664768,
-0.0167133473,
-0.0280954558,
0.0095698228,
-0.0169179477,
-0.0928510949,
-0.0277839564,
-0.0397672877,
0.0076624095,
0.0101303654,
-0.0568411909,
0.0702702329,
0.0237346925,
0.0067468397,
-0.0753051937,
-0.008591231,
0.0142869633,
0.0303517915,
-0.0012510447,
0.0069379201,
-0.0595044866,
-0.0906410962,
0.0002801011,
0.0136533082,
0.0142840557,
-0.0042241635,
0.0629753172,
-0.0302445926,
-0.0645395517,
0.0135748181,
-0.0140489247,
0.0462889858,
-0.0291463453,
0.0119125126,
0.0113563705,
-0.0098381583,
-0.014012224,
0.034181796,
0.0740219951,
-0.0404794142,
-0.0048688995,
0.0222854782,
0.0306665283,
0.0800168738,
0.0133631108,
0.0056279725,
0.003153601,
0.0142903812,
0.04422497,
-0.0518425778,
-0.003497499,
-0.014194984,
2.463e-7,
0.0086001838,
-0.0116529362,
0.0263037607,
-0.0301873311,
-0.0256408677,
0.0274330582,
-0.0162984263,
0.0418843627,
-0.0020138365,
-0.0362311043,
0.009247697,
0.011031244,
0.0316163674,
0.0534381159,
-0.063057363,
-0.0039931913,
0.0348299704,
0.0148546575,
-0.029233763,
0.0458653383,
0.0264529027,
0.0717841834,
0.0124371611,
-0.0203563534,
-0.0150004644,
-0.0149462745,
0.063365221,
0.0031629584,
0.0259695537,
0.0255383421,
-0.0352208614,
0.0824451298,
-0.045225665,
0.0292975232,
-0.0289477073,
0.0422584638,
0.0156536866,
0.0100388722,
0.0137687288,
-0.0097436365,
0.0147735411,
-0.0124838324,
0.001620849,
-0.0014912133,
0.0582865439,
-0.0775927231,
-0.0040226565,
0.0496910177,
-0.0264682658,
0.0127841234,
0.0456725881,
-0.0095553799,
-0.0440216549,
0.0576394908,
0.0399951637,
-0.0151658366,
-0.0498628579,
-0.0378026068,
0.0196013078,
0.0507130325,
0.0128122307,
0.0260844603,
0.0073221494,
0.0192087479,
0.0108797085,
-0.0196322929,
0.0426493213,
1.934408427e-34,
-0.0393136777,
0.0000889388,
-0.014530384,
-0.0067429426,
-0.0065108575,
-0.032869447,
-0.0163472835,
-0.0131301638,
-0.0102184564,
-0.0131362611,
0.0138295228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13627v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13627v2 | InstructAlign: High-and-Low Resource Language Alignment via Continual Crosslingual Instruction Tuning | 2023-05-23T02:51:34 | 2023-10-24T08:08:33 | Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Tiezheng Yu, Willy Chung, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) that are tuned with instructions have
demonstrated remarkable capabilities in various tasks and languages. However,
their ability to generalize to underrepresented languages is limited due to the
scarcity of available data. Additionally, directly adapting new languages to
instruction-tuned LLMs can result in catastrophic forgetting, which leads to
the loss of multitasking ability. To address this issue, we propose
InstructAlign which uses continual crosslingual instruction tuning to enable
LLMs to align new unseen languages with previously learned high-resource
languages. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of InstructAlign in
enabling the model to understand low-resource languages with limited parallel
data while preventing catastrophic forgetting. Our work contributes to the
advancement of language adaptation methods, particularly for adapting
instruction-tuned LLMs to underrepresented languages. Our code is released on
https://github.com/HLTCHKUST/InstructAlign | [
-0.0197906662,
0.0781553239,
-0.0161287244,
0.0413159803,
-0.0167039651,
0.0429580472,
-0.0041757757,
-0.0553761125,
-0.0194033124,
0.0316918865,
-0.0970913172,
-0.041292049,
0.0084928274,
-0.034527529,
0.0221711062,
-0.0199428108,
0.0939195529,
-0.0545604974,
-0.0445461497,
-0.0045768712,
0.0047901776,
0.0340029262,
-0.0198230855,
-0.0095003862,
0.0191102643,
-0.0533801802,
0.0012410377,
0.0186495334,
0.022854453,
0.0062605445,
0.0003128476,
0.0094795059,
0.0235731136,
0.0415853113,
0.0000018386,
-0.0349663049,
-0.0097453622,
-0.039914351,
-0.0057552946,
0.0001449215,
0.0205625761,
-0.0494140461,
-0.0364913829,
0.0114743961,
-0.0060741073,
-0.0150822503,
0.0663223267,
-0.0250728372,
0.0364807621,
0.0780896917,
0.0068856124,
0.0080983918,
0.0254130531,
-0.0432983749,
0.0059459526,
-0.0284346081,
0.0120672984,
-0.0056566196,
-0.0384032652,
-0.0199108459,
-0.0400531851,
0.0548805669,
0.0280499943,
0.0198519453,
-0.0347854532,
0.0223240498,
-0.0044742879,
-0.0285548568,
-0.0209864881,
0.0307412855,
-0.0422521643,
-0.0409192294,
-0.0069196923,
-0.005511032,
0.0091269379,
-0.0385481194,
-0.0691259503,
0.0291620269,
0.023369886,
0.0159398299,
0.0740637779,
-0.0409826189,
0.045193471,
-0.0119702723,
0.0215263553,
0.0341155343,
0.0521190874,
-0.0264913142,
-0.0219721422,
0.0030934468,
0.0092114871,
-0.0057324013,
-0.0118496064,
0.0374439992,
-0.0679095238,
0.0383221097,
-0.057124868,
-0.0317046046,
0.0058577713,
-0.0226311684,
0.0680226237,
0.0718452483,
-0.0144407786,
0.0573140047,
-0.0440721884,
0.0560279638,
-0.030753158,
0.021067122,
-0.0460915156,
-0.0135993222,
-0.0217962265,
-0.0022031311,
-0.0142793357,
-0.0373973101,
-0.0305873435,
0.0140122119,
-0.001314106,
0.0781764984,
0.0036886407,
0.0137833683,
0.008397771,
-0.0392720215,
-0.0825900212,
-0.0060783369,
0.0290592685,
0.0736292973,
0.0027748761,
-0.0061368598,
-0.0040765577,
-0.0406463817,
-0.0234902352,
0.026307987,
-0.0328379534,
-0.0546626896,
0.0300247911,
0.0777749345,
-0.0317389555,
0.0096651856,
-0.0537273847,
0.0373768844,
0.0048691356,
-0.0651684776,
0.0064972038,
-0.052020479,
0.0614299066,
0.0176859722,
0.0058667962,
-0.055826541,
-0.0114515657,
-0.0045621512,
-0.0161525402,
0.0213144552,
-0.0080440007,
0.0286428798,
0.0366946757,
-0.0292597134,
0.0248892028,
0.0863542408,
0.0086885877,
-0.0467271246,
0.0009504427,
-0.0196248051,
-0.0360261537,
0.0658402443,
0.013665556,
0.0277286805,
-0.0224972926,
0.0080204876,
0.0758342892,
0.0219421983,
0.0673424155,
0.0123309297,
0.015982002,
0.0100268647,
0.0416255482,
-0.0009070422,
0.0064102351,
0.0449287035,
0.0404548645,
-0.0138503257,
-0.0514381304,
0.0137309097,
-0.0707574859,
0.0773571506,
0.0047600586,
0.0198903196,
0.0239988398,
0.0571131445,
-0.0594824366,
-0.0210450348,
0.0111051882,
0.0010066608,
0.00177954,
0.014016483,
0.0608947799,
0.0024561265,
-0.0329503864,
0.0475170128,
0.066211611,
-0.0264810286,
0.0243773013,
-0.0146051496,
0.0005996735,
0.0621076711,
-0.0031862971,
-0.0290243067,
-0.0597033948,
0.0170437433,
0.0583055653,
0.0369056202,
0.0563093908,
0.0066412389,
0.030950658,
-0.0585814863,
0.011554487,
-0.0141079677,
-0.0069396496,
0.0238731503,
0.008904756,
0.001299627,
-0.0099530146,
-0.0234559961,
-0.051247064,
0.0315361321,
-0.0986163914,
-0.0171593986,
-0.0216329191,
0.0165978614,
-0.0076992386,
-0.0032500082,
-0.0123524796,
-0.0092430264,
0.0230963621,
-0.0433389097,
0.0497129932,
0.022568373,
-0.0595462583,
-0.0091214068,
0.046530854,
0.0083748261,
-0.0426385961,
0.0210119225,
-0.0097785816,
-0.0699363127,
0.045117192,
-0.0072942041,
0.0547671579,
-0.0262080058,
0.048068773,
-0.0230872184,
0.0028551619,
-0.0237987339,
0.0420608521,
-0.004156094,
0.0226655249,
0.0114613473,
-0.0195483528,
-0.0141390469,
-0.0486220382,
-0.0223536007,
0.0142088421,
-0.0103805307,
0.0204964429,
-0.0052352156,
0.0300664231,
-0.0299373548,
-0.0221132711,
-0.071341671,
0.0664222836,
-0.0370491892,
0.0524293669,
0.027803544,
0.0238684509,
-0.0084526911,
-0.0331653878,
-0.0476058684,
0.0183043536,
-0.002864873,
0.0303492546,
0.0186370648,
-0.0097367289,
-0.0280820504,
-0.0255709216,
-0.0280239116,
-0.0026201017,
-0.0077322149,
-0.0348653123,
0.0043904665,
-0.0796039104,
0.0173688345,
-0.0151883736,
0.0253055748,
-0.0139309755,
-0.0196106229,
-0.0178732146,
0.0218194891,
0.0594437085,
0.0867779255,
-0.0514329225,
-0.0143388985,
0.0624767318,
-0.0037826838,
-0.0458533429,
0.0167570468,
-0.0040833512,
-0.0635720566,
-0.0448332727,
-0.009991046,
-0.0463195741,
0.0852675885,
-0.0279680435,
-0.0075903521,
-0.062604472,
-0.0511417873,
-0.0089771552,
-0.0052372017,
0.0054730671,
0.0417681485,
-0.0181734841,
-0.0163627416,
-0.0524125881,
-0.0609226786,
0.0583380535,
0.000442149,
-0.0308662448,
-0.040532846,
-0.0173660833,
-0.0300976541,
0.0191959534,
-0.0008706581,
0.0287311152,
-0.023577759,
-0.0354776345,
-0.0766599029,
0.0208385587,
-0.0098280068,
0.0020527481,
0.0478639305,
-0.0368895531,
-0.0190793779,
-0.0391363353,
-0.0436702073,
-0.0153019605,
0.0047326759,
-0.0008751003,
0.0090836314,
0.0052194679,
-0.0182018541,
-0.0852308124,
-0.031807255,
0.0664197728,
0.043537695,
-0.0107912337,
0.0320730582,
-0.0375170708,
-0.0248761084,
0.0385249592,
0.0150540713,
-0.0200531557,
-0.0721018612,
0.015870804,
0.0133109754,
0.0634358451,
-0.0253675971,
-0.0061220564,
0.00183886,
0.0532577112,
-0.0108292261,
-0.0153785795,
-0.0021889012,
0.0686025843,
-0.0250975359,
-0.0255093817,
0.0657004416,
-0.0064211502,
-0.0713444278,
0.0068272324,
-0.0190917682,
0.0328770913,
0.0413413458,
0.0416692048,
-0.0466874428,
-0.0213889107,
0.0097756032,
0.0012337638,
0.0529472195,
0.0214798301,
0.0013877478,
-0.1185880527,
-0.0258160494,
0.0536741018,
-0.0602003857,
-0.0255114399,
-0.0299751665,
-0.0020219667,
-0.0275518987,
0.0802416801,
0.0379121155,
-0.0012326825,
-0.0066678808,
0.0244413428,
0.0312289186,
-0.0394833647,
0.0093818214,
-0.0208487697,
0.0785580724,
0.0382439792,
0.0055322144,
0.0019454346,
-0.0588859133,
0.0613452308,
-0.0142974406,
-0.0239441525,
0.0134462109,
-0.0150460489,
0.0072299321,
-0.0326279886,
0.0315662138,
0.0431122668,
-0.0657475069,
-0.0108023547,
0.0301120281,
0.0769993663,
0.0104190214,
0.0174974538,
0.0418754779,
-0.0492654443,
-0.0051192692,
0.0443117619,
0.0140528055,
-0.0626179278,
-0.0098003391,
-0.0168303102,
-0.0175781604,
-0.0654891357,
0.0085723968,
0.0408003032,
-0.0405616313,
-0.0251062252,
-0.0108136162,
-0.0008034797,
0.0154600888,
0.0097857481,
0.0514324792,
0.0091212653,
0.0030874906,
-0.0292059444,
-0.0520989634,
0.039053645,
-0.043519102,
0.0252080113,
-0.0792874545,
-0.0466052294,
0.0005649457,
-0.0255853925,
0.0211686231,
-0.0004093722,
-0.0830366313,
-0.0919775367,
-0.0105197709,
0.0405694321,
0.0088448152,
0.0876051933,
0.0156650003,
-0.0224420205,
-0.0072601363,
0.0015730298,
-0.0219480097,
0.0430551991,
0.0156620611,
-0.0099903252,
0.0035058728,
0.0582180656,
-0.0498542637,
-0.009535756,
0.0473959818,
0.0457008108,
-0.0236937441,
0.0409757197,
0.0002555186,
-0.0022882433,
0.0177147351,
-0.0223055594,
-0.0006750575,
-0.043421343,
0.0106751649,
0.0040123062,
-0.0124177011,
0.0019514702,
-0.0324079655,
0.0396509208,
0.001019821,
0.0296028014,
0.0001949869,
0.049646873,
-0.0064701382,
-0.0429604277,
0.019493293,
-0.0086313142,
0.0221309531,
0.0223696027,
0.0388039313,
-0.0241382793,
0.0357660241,
-0.0152488882,
0.0377220884,
-0.0243187062,
0.021163689,
0.0128984908,
0.0072464147,
-0.0280374922,
0.0221627727,
-0.0111494204,
-0.0560458153,
-0.0045197736,
0.000387091,
0.0859982818,
-0.017724026,
0.0734845847,
0.0273757353,
-0.0098363124,
-0.0270070974,
0.0167881008,
-0.0221891999,
-0.0279652104,
-0.0112949116,
0.0194097273,
-0.0019898876,
0.0030096862,
0.0594879948,
-0.0102892695,
0.023464581,
-0.0044300612,
0.0527687706,
-0.017120067,
-0.0159186795,
0.004313421,
-0.0038343088,
-0.0472800024,
-0.0074828663,
0.0087851081,
-0.0719161332,
-0.0293895118,
0.0532532707,
-0.0068596778,
-0.0021073122,
-0.0029066994,
0.0326115973,
-0.041531425,
-0.007388534,
-0.0229570381,
-0.0037237406,
0.0098897377,
-0.0315023884,
0.0031869698,
-6.039919563e-33,
-0.0356468596,
0.0453826301,
0.0369604751,
0.0045311386,
-0.0284441691,
-0.003061817,
-0.0495376512,
0.0061709667,
-0.0187161583,
-0.0311353784,
0.0073201698,
-0.007339492,
0.0117188534,
0.0295880232,
0.066802457,
0.0095560988,
0.0157310776,
-0.0066984952,
-0.0147446385,
0.0445191972,
0.0407491289,
0.03733759,
0.0893798247,
-0.0235502888,
0.0134616941,
-0.0174711477,
0.0268642697,
0.0502120517,
-0.0246370938,
0.046227809,
-0.0031585116,
0.0394939594,
0.0155768842,
-0.0122341933,
-0.0430455431,
0.0166194104,
-0.0841050968,
-0.0115574859,
0.0375981964,
0.0371096805,
-0.0349734761,
-0.0578600578,
0.0364901125,
-0.0096149882,
-0.0301790964,
-0.0180313569,
0.0188551545,
-0.0366298109,
-0.0215181597,
0.0570493191,
-0.0712661669,
-0.0136637529,
-0.0098921023,
-0.0338896997,
0.016024394,
0.0182014909,
0.00086644,
-0.0290419552,
-0.066825211,
0.0149819721,
-0.0502308942,
0.0681809336,
0.1265408695,
0.0461270846,
0.0067493957,
0.0332943797,
0.0460802466,
-0.000646416,
0.072382383,
0.011094071,
0.0425377488,
-0.0268575344,
-0.0107690785,
0.012188999,
0.0242549423,
-0.0297416057,
-0.0536237471,
-0.0180664901,
0.0393246897,
0.0250357427,
0.0280454513,
0.0333357714,
-0.0073129851,
-0.0156886727,
-0.0245434381,
-0.0015241005,
-0.0419152863,
-0.0034078567,
0.025759181,
-0.0021015119,
0.0088281864,
-0.0087156743,
0.0535048321,
-0.0234639123,
0.0052804658,
0.0252453908,
0.005814583,
0.0003893285,
-0.0179341976,
0.0552154742,
-0.0577110574,
-0.0745772645,
-0.0303645432,
-0.0170504302,
0.024517199,
0.0232251305,
0.0711196885,
0.0112552894,
-0.048510395,
-0.0029017697,
-0.0621104687,
-0.0009566695,
0.0252215602,
0.0350534096,
0.0456883162,
0.0067287018,
-0.0130998176,
0.0390298069,
0.0246935841,
-0.0509772487,
-0.0353012681,
-0.0237725843,
-0.0136731034,
0.0163533464,
-0.029621046,
0.0048707784,
-0.0371692702,
-0.0111528523,
-0.0097309826,
-0.0659843385,
-0.0095392969,
0.0252458174,
2.547e-7,
0.0220556501,
0.0128957219,
0.017768845,
0.0107292701,
0.0262502693,
0.0043897303,
-0.0629036948,
0.0250342842,
0.0101149892,
0.0094504282,
-0.0024956171,
0.056246493,
0.0714153424,
-0.0063914331,
-0.0731864199,
0.0208192207,
-0.0384808443,
0.0667461008,
-0.0437181219,
0.0310890749,
-0.041775208,
0.0791996866,
0.0087791253,
0.0017161993,
0.0061325785,
-0.0353378505,
0.0476470627,
-0.0321653448,
-0.0236333609,
0.0109206326,
-0.0542074591,
0.0482285172,
-0.0279869922,
-0.0076034772,
-0.0232583266,
0.0294933897,
-0.0246488098,
0.061987903,
-0.0149174351,
-0.0199145935,
0.0286067799,
0.0325021222,
-0.0477404632,
-0.019838104,
0.0379454084,
-0.0323497765,
-0.0067327758,
-0.0030232761,
0.0047224388,
0.0292365942,
0.0282560773,
-0.0105916383,
-0.0271641724,
0.0048954161,
0.0516829714,
-0.0024734866,
-0.0496935919,
-0.0202205144,
-0.0280071627,
0.0590454414,
-0.0530781299,
-0.0441051796,
-0.0196818095,
0.0101758586,
0.0067890906,
-0.0375921652,
0.0121305063,
2.097978236e-34,
0.012502024,
-0.0166529864,
0.0409732908,
0.052952908,
-0.0049195113,
-0.0486193672,
-0.0283007957,
0.0220411196,
0.0020541199,
-0.0570431389,
-0.0350193083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13626v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13626v2 | Prompting and Evaluating Large Language Models for Proactive Dialogues: Clarification, Target-guided, and Non-collaboration | 2023-05-23T02:49:35 | 2023-10-14T06:36:05 | Yang Deng, Lizi Liao, Liang Chen, Hongru Wang, Wenqiang Lei, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational systems based on Large Language Models (LLMs), such as
ChatGPT, show exceptional proficiency in context understanding and response
generation. However, despite their impressive capabilities, they still possess
limitations, such as providing randomly-guessed answers to ambiguous queries or
failing to refuse users' requests, both of which are considered aspects of a
conversational agent's proactivity. This raises the question of whether
LLM-based conversational systems are equipped to handle proactive dialogue
problems. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of LLM-based
conversational systems, specifically focusing on three aspects of proactive
dialogue systems: clarification, target-guided, and non-collaborative
dialogues. To trigger the proactivity of LLMs, we propose the Proactive
Chain-of-Thought prompting scheme, which augments LLMs with the goal planning
capability over descriptive reasoning chains. Empirical findings are discussed
to promote future studies on LLM-based proactive dialogue systems. | [
0.0850377977,
0.0110839512,
-0.0376510955,
0.0370096974,
-0.0477644354,
0.001583991,
0.0183709078,
-0.0368740149,
0.0075579998,
-0.0431683138,
-0.0007737931,
-0.0483448394,
-0.041852653,
0.0632846579,
-0.0022707183,
-0.0445542298,
0.0328042507,
-0.0658177808,
0.0462918803,
-0.0043708324,
0.0138693042,
-0.0047219642,
-0.0289217196,
0.0662350133,
0.0010916227,
-0.0090770768,
-0.0725541264,
-0.0078857942,
-0.0146994367,
-0.0135701969,
0.0024684025,
0.0326066352,
0.0187467523,
0.0335605927,
0.000001818,
-0.0888649747,
-0.0008352528,
-0.0312047582,
-0.0276345368,
-0.0294026919,
-0.000412436,
0.0267905071,
-0.0261636339,
0.0317647569,
-0.0326563194,
0.0102506932,
0.0363891423,
0.0522467382,
0.0528703406,
0.044753585,
-0.001593493,
-0.0028390072,
0.0051325304,
-0.001284051,
0.0096270787,
-0.0736441836,
0.0072609815,
0.0206697565,
0.0260133352,
0.0356762744,
0.0072010951,
0.0243921001,
0.0094053391,
-0.0409152471,
-0.0265981779,
0.0161882024,
-0.0298089627,
-0.0484372489,
-0.0186600387,
0.0839301571,
0.0370856263,
0.0052428255,
0.011569716,
0.0005508352,
0.0031244922,
-0.0129289022,
-0.0290740822,
0.0431988053,
-0.011901563,
-0.006698688,
-0.009395632,
0.0049391189,
0.0177513864,
0.0174832512,
-0.0265379958,
0.0600933954,
-0.0297426153,
-0.0061434852,
-0.0049646818,
-0.0177696124,
-0.000715768,
-0.0829338804,
-0.0144757302,
0.0730822831,
-0.1103131995,
0.0448044091,
0.0116357431,
0.0418943651,
0.0013199855,
-0.0166912843,
-0.0030730602,
0.0414148197,
0.0083201369,
0.0605183542,
0.0236772783,
0.0327787213,
-0.0101217264,
-0.009146587,
-0.0301613864,
-0.0424201861,
-0.0490830988,
-0.0165179241,
-0.0569288321,
0.0263092611,
-0.0440155827,
-0.0273698103,
0.000508787,
0.0870734081,
-0.0022255941,
0.0424668789,
-0.0272637848,
-0.0045522139,
-0.0086015435,
-0.0279496424,
-0.067333132,
0.0167255402,
-0.0285482481,
0.0139344707,
0.022428954,
-0.0596060902,
0.0105875125,
0.0235439762,
-0.0169308707,
-0.0022064489,
-0.0310500674,
0.0727543384,
-0.0192084759,
-0.0274362862,
-0.0100313881,
-0.0340925194,
-0.0079499939,
-0.0803010464,
-0.0240146089,
-0.0365200751,
0.0031137804,
0.0240238048,
-0.0240563042,
0.0207014736,
0.0375330262,
0.0119507248,
0.0047527784,
0.056841325,
0.0046323487,
0.0310256947,
0.0310348142,
0.036709331,
-0.0498394631,
0.0730821788,
0.0351419039,
0.0434722416,
0.0290220976,
0.0111666992,
0.0239513945,
0.0115360385,
-0.0105493739,
-0.0031219989,
0.0030653968,
0.0356200673,
0.0060414402,
0.0029476432,
-0.0278327204,
0.0527682342,
-0.0432351753,
0.0237214733,
0.0753078237,
0.0523167141,
-0.0247790478,
0.0088033751,
0.0480293371,
0.0208758935,
-0.0160982255,
-0.0341282971,
-0.0464109741,
0.0282873306,
-0.0440538116,
-0.003217971,
-0.008810793,
-0.0052419128,
-0.0430511385,
-0.0548737645,
0.0276976507,
-0.0105379177,
0.0090943268,
0.027107833,
0.0428906456,
-0.0041903402,
-0.0250218697,
0.0082783941,
-0.0263441373,
-0.0337007865,
-0.0350862853,
-0.0599693507,
0.0343652554,
0.0860863328,
0.0695992932,
-0.0030182383,
-0.0549235381,
-0.0124210101,
0.0234444533,
0.0377703831,
0.0194842238,
-0.0297837406,
0.0127539271,
-0.0358443074,
-0.0223697703,
0.0000383976,
-0.010759877,
0.0049721468,
-0.006053952,
-0.0065299338,
-0.000563487,
0.0487625115,
0.017439004,
-0.0115379775,
-0.0048918738,
0.0224827658,
-0.004177785,
-0.0013299406,
0.0525045507,
0.0206886884,
0.0102464035,
0.0049617793,
0.0212734863,
-0.0007161181,
-0.02388395,
0.0444543473,
-0.0288579147,
-0.0321800709,
0.0080970889,
0.0278890096,
-0.0099465447,
-0.0305066276,
-0.0113444058,
-0.0539914109,
0.0209289398,
-0.024917176,
0.0118845925,
-0.0539185032,
0.0301393066,
-0.0006590668,
-0.0342041068,
-0.0204236824,
0.0453392752,
0.0072715618,
-0.0108551336,
0.0643175915,
0.0517398007,
0.0160987582,
-0.0529066175,
-0.0096931662,
0.0386807695,
0.025386367,
-0.0212262347,
0.0248366892,
0.0298555903,
-0.0507110655,
-0.0345716514,
-0.0980973244,
-0.0056693698,
-0.0267674141,
-0.0036119791,
-0.0066336324,
0.0314966179,
0.007148264,
-0.0146775162,
-0.0330757052,
0.0387485325,
0.049466487,
0.040659342,
0.0380867161,
0.0317299254,
-0.0541730598,
-0.0180650782,
0.0294569992,
0.0137535036,
0.0057898946,
-0.0052794637,
-0.0300596189,
-0.0552532896,
0.0171093531,
-0.038713146,
0.0423778519,
-0.0281876568,
-0.0383034945,
0.04647604,
-0.0194104929,
0.0430980437,
0.052922409,
0.0181009192,
0.0495627001,
0.0111973016,
-0.0446593054,
-0.0598287173,
0.042020876,
-0.0396149196,
-0.0392010882,
-0.0450941212,
-0.0135644414,
0.010677306,
0.0298572928,
-0.0068239304,
0.027110612,
-0.0531188697,
0.016052356,
0.0248827972,
-0.0415322445,
-0.0474279113,
-0.0246132351,
-0.0269096438,
0.0661337972,
0.0023917449,
-0.0264340173,
0.0812495574,
-0.0017565398,
-0.0283245817,
-0.0226234589,
-0.0291934852,
-0.0305454526,
0.0627248362,
0.0057650409,
0.0091328062,
-0.0114912121,
-0.0281933248,
-0.0298436247,
-0.0133301448,
0.01290581,
-0.0322955549,
0.0291424561,
-0.0816299096,
0.0030289167,
0.0063553983,
-0.0502012596,
-0.0716722682,
-0.0309425071,
-0.0406400673,
0.0113522401,
0.0029357162,
-0.0002272296,
-0.0226092432,
0.0565445498,
0.0352603719,
0.0300853811,
-0.0011290332,
-0.0180067848,
-0.0388708897,
-0.0113513703,
0.0335244909,
0.024276536,
-0.0031462002,
0.0114388466,
0.0918155909,
0.0552579537,
0.0273443405,
-0.0435589626,
-0.0044762255,
-0.0044880002,
0.025293326,
-0.0000018981,
-0.0201395079,
0.0232189167,
0.0571187325,
-0.0179416351,
-0.0330544077,
0.1281537265,
0.0388806686,
-0.0513785444,
-0.003405282,
-0.024848165,
0.0232730974,
0.002756844,
0.0274323784,
-0.0426188409,
-0.0335310996,
-0.0009575456,
-0.0168957245,
-0.049874384,
-0.0268648677,
-0.0224084854,
-0.1006935313,
0.0434269942,
-0.0222597234,
-0.0084320074,
-0.0014024882,
0.014021866,
0.0126819741,
0.0299023446,
0.0061599524,
0.0207501762,
0.0333150625,
-0.0341500007,
-0.0078428276,
-0.0143884858,
-0.0185200237,
0.0134106502,
-0.0181987137,
0.0678327158,
0.0898669139,
0.0225833748,
0.0520829745,
0.0089088753,
0.0478431545,
-0.013032645,
0.0092596542,
-0.0040928572,
-0.0128403455,
-0.001184259,
0.0171113927,
-0.020382015,
0.0369494297,
-0.0286246724,
-0.0169414133,
0.05454484,
0.0524125621,
-0.0649717227,
0.0331739001,
-0.0089661106,
0.0491411015,
0.0408400744,
0.0644235834,
0.0028216855,
-0.0478316136,
-0.0486797802,
-0.0343885385,
-0.0621740818,
0.0130415065,
-0.0107197361,
-0.00599579,
0.0136364587,
0.0052551776,
-0.0390578024,
-0.0587886572,
0.0301528033,
0.0292657968,
-0.010401926,
0.0293638259,
-0.0028364309,
0.0448071845,
0.0315669514,
-0.006813657,
-0.0141513236,
0.0136471372,
-0.0607537031,
-0.0156280808,
0.0321899168,
-0.0584426187,
-0.001703103,
0.0122808469,
-0.0586244799,
-0.0518650673,
-0.0352270193,
0.0380785763,
0.0364152975,
0.0327835381,
-0.0370917656,
-0.0593259595,
-0.0401762724,
0.0142462607,
-0.0094804959,
-0.0211509187,
0.0043710922,
0.0822301283,
0.0171461385,
0.0494619086,
-0.056159012,
0.0185908694,
-0.0233045109,
0.0297274292,
-0.0416450202,
-0.0805646479,
0.0068497662,
0.0052904463,
0.0334589221,
0.0198363699,
-0.0075738165,
0.0044742916,
0.0447805561,
-0.051752083,
-0.0366605893,
-0.0422110334,
0.0389021151,
-0.0252384637,
-0.0183825735,
0.03073759,
-0.0490597151,
-0.0338800289,
0.0096454648,
0.0043014428,
-0.0016552802,
0.0191802569,
0.0001029964,
0.0438979268,
-0.0114878984,
-0.0138517115,
0.0262213498,
0.0470502935,
0.0216463897,
0.0185532272,
0.1387891918,
0.0275517181,
-0.0564029031,
0.0004324563,
0.0382870585,
-0.0907653943,
-0.0790870488,
0.0613799021,
0.0854719281,
0.0330201536,
0.0412459336,
0.0027165988,
-0.0814583749,
0.0235502627,
-0.0157913715,
0.0458873212,
0.0588090345,
-0.0631013215,
0.0513512418,
0.024259422,
-0.0202866029,
0.0189005863,
0.0387674049,
-0.0007136146,
-0.0082546351,
0.0155036794,
-0.029022418,
-0.039880082,
-0.0261711106,
-0.0203472227,
0.0153164128,
-0.0238365326,
0.0377246849,
-0.0586565211,
-0.0262807868,
-0.0370401144,
0.0071498696,
-0.0033304351,
-0.0525952876,
0.0289173387,
0.0625869259,
0.0171650182,
-0.0382771045,
-0.0608369447,
0.0334201753,
-0.0423798338,
0.0022622375,
-0.0340351127,
-5.833259575e-33,
-0.0099325106,
-0.0433287658,
0.0615610033,
0.0124180885,
-0.0305603091,
-0.0462909862,
-0.0478192978,
0.004580962,
-0.0149317086,
0.0016333684,
-0.0334314257,
0.0353562161,
0.0094328318,
0.0085744075,
-0.0176422317,
-0.0248956345,
0.026254924,
0.0146475546,
-0.0125262719,
0.0425116606,
0.044040408,
-0.0045708925,
-0.0288824197,
-0.0524326675,
0.0355268084,
-0.0261807963,
-0.019031873,
0.0815918446,
-0.019859422,
0.0387169458,
-0.0181478225,
0.0445630886,
0.0275337379,
-0.0222078916,
0.0144752562,
0.021984579,
-0.0235323161,
-0.0209900346,
0.0447388627,
0.0016785957,
-0.0510241948,
-0.0065714796,
-0.02538733,
-0.0101718735,
-0.0252941679,
0.0406869277,
-0.0158167519,
-0.018594116,
-0.0336189903,
0.0028096936,
-0.0465559587,
0.0111462548,
-0.0161712281,
-0.0326324925,
0.0046312069,
0.0412958935,
-0.0130638992,
-0.0055029476,
0.006472474,
0.0279973727,
0.0144159738,
-0.0105482033,
0.0534812622,
0.0477386117,
0.0022057437,
0.026589185,
0.0081316018,
0.0399352759,
-0.0451493375,
0.0006537809,
-0.0620461591,
0.0470402688,
0.014637772,
0.0455878675,
-0.0541318655,
0.0292526018,
-0.0556540079,
0.0165267196,
0.0527329221,
0.0288817808,
0.0512922332,
0.0019024434,
-0.0559567139,
-0.0227592178,
-0.0362968631,
0.0182222947,
-0.0403010324,
-0.0360241048,
0.0348297246,
0.0124588478,
0.019966349,
-0.0298881587,
0.0371489711,
-0.015034656,
-0.0131138638,
0.0400139652,
-0.0303430296,
0.0114925839,
-0.0139195379,
0.0243646055,
-0.0453243703,
-0.0097548142,
0.0144925443,
-0.004083937,
-0.0127799138,
0.0270008817,
-0.0329118706,
-0.0037979039,
-0.0176155493,
-0.0106250383,
-0.0570427291,
0.0597464517,
-0.0568660423,
0.0130554149,
0.027145423,
-0.0162720382,
-0.0278418064,
0.09583278,
-0.0136789866,
-0.0470537134,
-0.0237543304,
-0.0034228552,
-0.0090196757,
-0.0153283542,
-0.0369090438,
-0.0045876391,
-0.0105906222,
0.0452296659,
0.0131432991,
-0.0453889668,
0.0120427543,
0.0111031989,
2.612e-7,
-0.0240520258,
0.0331440531,
-0.0056182239,
0.0371735804,
0.0402438082,
0.0595816523,
-0.0195755158,
0.0074476926,
0.0455365069,
-0.0047905524,
0.033059679,
0.0371775925,
0.0330403037,
0.0143915685,
-0.0930176377,
-0.0317816697,
-0.0430444442,
-0.0339499451,
-0.0581981875,
0.0195558369,
0.0858516693,
0.0511712916,
-0.0070844372,
0.0095450338,
0.0035386209,
-0.0345388874,
0.0321915038,
-0.0650595129,
-0.0347308517,
0.0179848764,
0.0516718552,
-0.0187182426,
0.0140014552,
0.0260508824,
0.0355973281,
0.0245489329,
-0.0447405614,
0.0725916773,
0.0229756478,
-0.0329863131,
-0.0198918339,
-0.0120433299,
0.0295332838,
-0.043590866,
0.0662725791,
-0.042301435,
-0.0411693342,
0.0342992544,
0.0262199827,
-0.0462892503,
-0.0336520113,
-0.0145518538,
-0.0282656644,
0.0041044788,
-0.0080888998,
-0.0110966144,
0.0251612458,
-0.0841040686,
0.0106897186,
-0.0486643054,
-0.0327796005,
-0.0707709566,
-0.0379784517,
0.0167729072,
0.032674849,
-0.0345767885,
-0.0006823107,
2.23074642e-34,
0.0409374274,
0.0038687268,
0.015224156,
0.0358251408,
0.0433035754,
0.0244160946,
0.0039282772,
0.0184634328,
0.0557185747,
-0.0745990053,
-0.0277341977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13623v1 | Validating Multimedia Content Moderation Software via Semantic Fusion | 2023-05-23T02:44:15 | 2023-05-23T02:44:15 | Wenxuan Wang, Jingyuan Huang, Chang Chen, Jiazhen Gu, Jianping Zhang, Weibin Wu, Pinjia He, Michael Lyu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | The exponential growth of social media platforms, such as Facebook and
TikTok, has revolutionized communication and content publication in human
society. Users on these platforms can publish multimedia content that delivers
information via the combination of text, audio, images, and video. Meanwhile,
the multimedia content release facility has been increasingly exploited to
propagate toxic content, such as hate speech, malicious advertisements, and
pornography. To this end, content moderation software has been widely deployed
on these platforms to detect and blocks toxic content. However, due to the
complexity of content moderation models and the difficulty of understanding
information across multiple modalities, existing content moderation software
can fail to detect toxic content, which often leads to extremely negative
impacts.
We introduce Semantic Fusion, a general, effective methodology for validating
multimedia content moderation software. Our key idea is to fuse two or more
existing single-modal inputs (e.g., a textual sentence and an image) into a new
input that combines the semantics of its ancestors in a novel manner and has
toxic nature by construction. This fused input is then used for validating
multimedia content moderation software. We realized Semantic Fusion as DUO, a
practical content moderation software testing tool. In our evaluation, we
employ DUO to test five commercial content moderation software and two
state-of-the-art models against three kinds of toxic content. The results show
that DUO achieves up to 100% error finding rate (EFR) when testing moderation
software. In addition, we leverage the test cases generated by DUO to retrain
the two models we explored, which largely improves model robustness while
maintaining the accuracy on the original test set. | [
0.0712892562,
0.040113546,
-0.0086276839,
-0.0249284897,
-0.001831102,
-0.002446699,
0.0214743447,
0.0318294391,
0.0062358961,
-0.1014827415,
0.0080093928,
0.006278832,
-0.0256623477,
0.0451627336,
-0.037941657,
-0.004250309,
0.0443309844,
0.0391477868,
-0.0146192973,
0.0392924249,
0.0550034605,
0.0176342074,
0.0148298964,
0.0398898646,
-0.0795030966,
-0.0111536887,
0.0208753403,
0.0319162421,
0.0194339436,
-0.0082007414,
-0.0199234076,
0.0517764203,
0.0092394259,
0.075378187,
0.0000018915,
-0.0428320505,
-0.0112225348,
0.0025678063,
0.0139981452,
-0.0190364234,
0.0837570429,
0.0067764395,
-0.0642500892,
0.0457165949,
-0.0201209001,
0.0457380675,
0.0579125583,
0.064509891,
0.1038923338,
0.055534564,
-0.0415081866,
0.021968374,
0.0168879312,
0.0339574553,
0.0034050643,
0.0233551692,
0.0523938872,
-0.0336947069,
0.0130046438,
-0.0244360566,
0.0103046065,
0.0450907275,
0.0103660105,
-0.0395953283,
-0.0059221745,
-0.0274309795,
-0.0068698246,
-0.0620792285,
-0.0156700946,
0.0284176394,
-0.015428911,
-0.018032182,
0.0070887767,
-0.0140726734,
0.0148834195,
0.0495697968,
-0.0116852829,
0.0069831493,
-0.0318549201,
0.0207089782,
-0.0281661041,
-0.0125515321,
0.0542752817,
0.0380513556,
0.0168567207,
0.0411006324,
0.0019033708,
-0.054441113,
0.020248998,
-0.0212185178,
0.0356674977,
-0.0286615286,
0.0553089306,
-0.0146376565,
-0.0137232346,
-0.0094237207,
-0.0503900759,
-0.0711916387,
0.023747053,
-0.0624171868,
-0.0068907086,
0.007465343,
-0.0343557,
0.0433794446,
0.0081995772,
0.0063571748,
0.0098055108,
0.0697886571,
0.0170474537,
0.0215095934,
-0.0265838914,
0.0087988339,
0.0277285669,
0.0077500013,
0.0056103058,
0.008709644,
-0.0444903821,
0.0295236353,
-0.0934999585,
0.0249273311,
0.0019042752,
0.0158561412,
0.031474147,
0.0428238213,
-0.0416819267,
-0.0152193904,
-0.0111068683,
0.0558121391,
0.001313169,
-0.022010019,
0.0400599837,
0.0289084911,
-0.0149517739,
0.0005049602,
0.0305664968,
0.0691640973,
0.0134385563,
0.0058568455,
-0.0306906104,
-0.0536645874,
-0.0423857942,
-0.0145274438,
0.018094847,
-0.0453011468,
-0.0208478794,
-0.0170654748,
-0.0190524906,
-0.0716016367,
-0.0145067153,
0.0054413527,
-0.0560101196,
0.066395022,
-0.017404737,
-0.017749453,
0.0470752195,
0.0586576648,
-0.0184513833,
0.0674773678,
-0.0085831964,
0.0535296611,
0.0662107542,
0.0056413254,
-0.0090314299,
0.0224547125,
-0.0060539837,
0.0067499285,
-0.0775551423,
-0.0197492931,
-0.0328568406,
-0.0594400391,
-0.0674470067,
0.0483751297,
-0.0273176078,
-0.0059589925,
0.0547636934,
0.0170297287,
-0.0166321583,
0.0061976654,
0.0374576747,
0.0053658723,
-0.0454383269,
-0.0161134303,
-0.0753681436,
0.0282766391,
-0.0318931937,
-0.0628313571,
0.0396088511,
0.0589229651,
-0.0084166257,
-0.0585238263,
-0.0284053776,
-0.0127410442,
0.0848627314,
-0.0200354178,
0.0014416955,
-0.0050950544,
-0.0491312593,
0.0168365631,
0.0174379218,
-0.0385843255,
-0.0023862203,
-0.0435540043,
0.0670655519,
0.0668015108,
0.03402799,
-0.0504339077,
0.0306286905,
-0.0526018776,
-0.0174327996,
-0.0134660043,
0.0068431264,
-0.0142171038,
-0.0670273304,
-0.0285181087,
-0.074914068,
0.0066781198,
0.0274183657,
-0.014239219,
0.0121988868,
0.0348743834,
0.0168150663,
0.0698516667,
0.0027173674,
0.0152837243,
0.1031366587,
-0.007186274,
-0.037375316,
0.0477463901,
0.0552964322,
0.0203895923,
-0.0001049201,
-0.0056694392,
0.030126268,
0.0381030813,
-0.0766731575,
-0.0396296084,
0.0031595351,
0.0526119135,
0.0701547489,
-0.0537475199,
-0.0131105147,
0.0420323648,
-0.000253916,
0.0205403436,
0.0410688668,
0.003125832,
-0.0338639431,
-0.0553119816,
-0.0151109872,
-0.0396913104,
-0.0009049048,
0.0030882801,
0.0503734946,
0.0058574243,
-0.04108328,
-0.0172633063,
-0.0780033991,
0.0204645023,
0.050228823,
-0.0161747392,
-0.0363298655,
-0.0588230826,
0.0493567251,
0.0115487371,
-0.0187949091,
-0.0283798687,
-0.0279733501,
-0.0819876343,
0.0007569599,
-0.0211842638,
0.0193718877,
0.0029097316,
0.0152066918,
0.0207987968,
0.0168509874,
-0.0420810394,
-0.023591293,
0.0324835964,
0.0585258044,
-0.0080653252,
-0.0190750007,
-0.034241505,
0.0117061324,
-0.0131902816,
-0.0573299192,
0.0381149128,
0.0083517479,
-0.0622387715,
0.0657820404,
0.0036315294,
-0.0508566909,
0.0101160351,
0.0039318562,
-0.034173999,
0.044905033,
-0.0002312488,
-0.0336851254,
0.0220671222,
0.0466597229,
0.0448013097,
0.0480757467,
0.0222895816,
-0.0267188158,
0.0127584152,
0.0217256825,
-0.0068387422,
0.0050892825,
0.0021959436,
0.001688055,
0.0199660026,
0.0066526169,
0.0086425962,
-0.0354531705,
0.0694842413,
-0.0346560292,
-0.0298315268,
-0.0200983044,
-0.074496679,
0.0133142192,
-0.0036769563,
-0.040220391,
-0.0391700864,
0.0684537515,
0.0083535537,
0.0316631459,
0.0248385333,
-0.0563234054,
0.0088973502,
-0.026002882,
-0.0347389206,
0.0348850042,
-0.0010055329,
0.0159732569,
0.0110328859,
-0.0419980623,
0.100142017,
-0.0426170602,
0.0097306995,
-0.0148842782,
-0.0114811398,
0.0113933254,
-0.0451094247,
-0.0293701347,
-0.058388304,
-0.0235683899,
0.0008468592,
-0.0234065168,
0.0267751832,
-0.050072819,
0.0065818918,
0.0068880673,
-0.0250060484,
0.0295279939,
-0.0274991598,
0.0084895287,
-0.01789473,
-0.0053252303,
-0.0144384569,
-0.0054400261,
-0.0098109394,
0.0094574401,
0.0895377398,
-0.0248341411,
-0.0491132215,
-0.0512793921,
0.038743671,
-0.0215477329,
0.0139451232,
0.0248166341,
0.0355446078,
0.0162253231,
-0.0301604271,
0.0570968688,
0.0332427844,
0.0321247876,
0.0078694439,
-0.0343743153,
0.015605608,
-0.0459041111,
0.0389976688,
-0.0242515486,
-0.0554562546,
-0.0259061642,
0.005433361,
0.0016974232,
-0.0456538238,
-0.008397663,
0.0313475356,
-0.0422006659,
0.0252600592,
0.0331575237,
-0.0293935593,
0.0033510912,
-0.0186395794,
-0.0140054114,
-0.0307557974,
0.0102495831,
-0.067350097,
0.0145945344,
-0.0262046084,
-0.0076351399,
0.0218745656,
-0.0195089113,
0.0084754946,
-0.065218471,
0.0119857201,
0.0378299095,
0.0109320525,
-0.0216719527,
-0.044511687,
0.0708918944,
0.024571117,
-0.0182188787,
-0.0049349316,
0.0611528642,
-0.007199645,
0.002184791,
-0.0097695803,
0.027962042,
0.0153779276,
-0.0551317185,
-0.0130403629,
0.0918191299,
0.0355971418,
-0.0057844594,
-0.0710782036,
0.0300387964,
0.0351598337,
0.0433242656,
0.0158787481,
-0.0636185259,
-0.0231206995,
-0.0569503307,
-0.0331316702,
0.0063007842,
-0.0238509607,
0.0065716822,
-0.0085331853,
-0.0607723854,
-0.0442654453,
0.0317648724,
-0.0258915666,
0.0033161337,
-0.0010260429,
-0.0149776088,
-0.0057480298,
0.0016709791,
-0.0224565621,
0.0073895669,
0.0451353788,
0.0519834757,
-0.0476108044,
0.068713367,
-0.0430873856,
0.0192101337,
-0.0215213187,
0.0171122998,
-0.0185357258,
-0.0589542054,
-0.0045552254,
0.0420028046,
0.0205161572,
-0.0295234546,
-0.0225000624,
-0.0222509112,
0.0425946862,
0.0990771726,
-0.0493449867,
-0.0395780504,
0.0927044451,
-0.0485435612,
-0.0127142193,
-0.0020014022,
-0.0435953103,
0.0069466354,
0.0253901649,
-0.0731848478,
-0.0603516996,
0.0212974343,
0.004792802,
0.0285293777,
0.0183025394,
-0.0182737242,
-0.0172523111,
-0.0164342523,
-0.0093671251,
0.0139999837,
-0.045889657,
0.0019851674,
0.0315804705,
0.0113640251,
-0.0342837498,
-0.0098337969,
0.0394884944,
-0.0049188198,
0.0182617027,
-0.0442886166,
0.0143418116,
0.0219005272,
0.0179770403,
0.0093468204,
-0.0061636763,
0.0014777897,
0.0321676768,
0.0528522357,
-0.015553413,
-0.0342120454,
0.0455621667,
0.0031425934,
0.0449442007,
0.0163513739,
0.0145390434,
-0.0076521235,
0.0356576815,
0.0012235998,
0.0244584922,
0.0422729217,
0.0055272714,
0.0051475274,
0.0062985695,
-0.018065501,
-0.0272302888,
-0.001006707,
-0.0374686718,
-0.053019736,
0.0003009708,
0.0037428804,
0.0015531463,
0.0099326493,
-0.0059426636,
-0.0583706349,
0.0111309094,
-0.0126327816,
-0.0755942687,
-0.0353243351,
0.0113677355,
0.0195915028,
0.0444276221,
-0.0210301168,
0.0254060719,
-0.0542793497,
-0.0663328692,
0.0223129932,
0.0003319454,
0.0236535855,
0.0324660577,
-0.0138005,
0.0592827499,
0.0377636962,
0.0093147131,
-0.0078078476,
-0.0491405874,
-0.0114361309,
-0.0180681366,
-0.006273407,
-5.817369095e-33,
0.0064542135,
-0.0051331203,
-0.0352643505,
0.0126177967,
0.0306675751,
-0.028065348,
0.0231072512,
-0.0182675961,
0.0420719385,
0.0116512766,
-0.0143458238,
0.0097360872,
-0.0144751528,
-0.0169793405,
-0.0152999619,
-0.0272404011,
0.0404465608,
0.0046910597,
-0.0536857545,
-0.0163326226,
0.0643358305,
-0.0097277723,
-0.0482366122,
-0.1133892387,
-0.0136614069,
0.0325636752,
-0.0706166327,
-0.0097865686,
-0.0639287904,
0.1128709167,
0.027099777,
0.0442307554,
0.0266253259,
-0.0295782164,
0.0059059039,
0.0630196705,
-0.0698697716,
-0.0317955874,
0.025426697,
-0.0151667269,
-0.0108528258,
-0.0250426345,
0.0606062189,
0.0052376655,
-0.023152899,
-0.0277975816,
0.0163742416,
-0.0152429948,
-0.0016205815,
-0.0689239651,
-0.0273556635,
-0.0017425691,
-0.0530936867,
0.0095192017,
0.0240937546,
0.0265852455,
0.0440824851,
-0.0255969763,
-0.048100248,
0.0292936396,
-0.003395481,
-0.0332883522,
0.0443119034,
-0.0090115238,
-0.0431190692,
0.0793276057,
-0.0546245426,
0.0089948801,
-0.0095441956,
-0.0002965321,
0.0099306386,
0.0598638654,
0.0503947064,
0.0637792498,
0.0214341562,
-0.0708186403,
-0.0619378909,
0.034820918,
-0.0123236682,
0.0267316271,
0.0014266047,
0.0028046193,
-0.0206934959,
0.0056725303,
-0.0358428508,
-0.0134870717,
-0.063737683,
-0.0454816632,
0.0199574623,
0.040549431,
-0.0556788296,
-0.0109367147,
-0.0148478448,
-0.0777968615,
0.01566438,
0.0234575216,
0.0003069435,
-0.0119479531,
0.0197032113,
-0.0090496577,
-0.0134021174,
-0.0050053541,
0.0574308001,
-0.0406934246,
0.0316941775,
-0.0262951106,
0.0472976826,
0.0603635982,
-0.060858544,
0.0059891655,
0.008228966,
0.0556792729,
0.0075064125,
0.0184946135,
-0.0114968745,
0.0388511829,
-0.00201028,
-0.0301480647,
-0.0008500911,
0.0296770409,
-0.0292369016,
-0.0280956365,
-0.0117630977,
0.0024372961,
0.0085852835,
-0.0111856936,
-0.015383794,
-0.0144075006,
0.0422884785,
-0.0584681705,
0.0069886325,
-0.0129340105,
2.718e-7,
0.0115365628,
0.0165133532,
-0.0026811329,
-0.0059123551,
0.0311506893,
0.0549661629,
0.0027220799,
0.0145137068,
0.003893364,
-0.0567039885,
0.0053542117,
0.0150173344,
0.0263073239,
0.0624943823,
0.0036042412,
-0.0316679068,
-0.0475757085,
0.01009853,
-0.0417669639,
0.06739714,
0.0407053307,
0.0765107423,
0.0587190948,
-0.0549536385,
-0.0021636894,
-0.0376246087,
0.0328478515,
-0.0116575565,
-0.0008223866,
-0.0261311177,
0.0502720475,
-0.0096217329,
0.0145271178,
0.019987179,
-0.0353750028,
0.0131009053,
-0.0055094212,
0.0516062863,
0.0089269346,
0.000700886,
-0.0076236655,
-0.0316974632,
0.0271544307,
-0.0034215457,
0.070641987,
0.0307098404,
-0.0119275572,
-0.0535626858,
-0.0233730786,
-0.0484967716,
0.0604543835,
-0.0009033265,
-0.036043562,
-0.0079180859,
-0.0084907115,
0.0267621018,
0.0117785614,
-0.0782755315,
0.0178041104,
0.0024563738,
-0.0138340592,
-0.0230046082,
-0.0080613,
0.0130635267,
0.0482400618,
-0.0194220413,
0.0146705937,
2.529465019e-34,
0.0197024625,
-0.0465513133,
0.0177577306,
-0.0655173883,
0.0300646257,
0.0150274001,
-0.0190577786,
-0.0162981823,
0.0179074071,
-0.0052110138,
0.0441855937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13617v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13617v3 | SPEECH: Structured Prediction with Energy-Based Event-Centric Hyperspheres | 2023-05-23T02:28:09 | 2023-09-18T10:19:10 | Shumin Deng, Shengyu Mao, Ningyu Zhang, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Event-centric structured prediction involves predicting structured outputs of
events. In most NLP cases, event structures are complex with manifold
dependency, and it is challenging to effectively represent these complicated
structured events. To address these issues, we propose Structured Prediction
with Energy-based Event-Centric Hyperspheres (SPEECH). SPEECH models complex
dependency among event structured components with energy-based modeling, and
represents event classes with simple but effective hyperspheres. Experiments on
two unified-annotated event datasets indicate that SPEECH is predominant in
event detection and event-relation extraction tasks. | [
-0.0332683064,
0.0477117449,
0.0043463446,
0.0692640394,
0.0090659065,
0.0143190082,
-0.027233718,
0.0001289573,
0.0065129111,
-0.044116877,
0.0008146454,
-0.0096201431,
-0.0417021737,
0.0770058185,
-0.002018122,
-0.0928195715,
0.0641013533,
-0.014624848,
0.0124581838,
0.01532216,
-0.0045929942,
0.0060768533,
-0.0431720428,
0.0148251168,
-0.0769205689,
0.0100329425,
-0.0256910454,
0.0030622233,
0.025955582,
-0.0475543067,
0.0287427492,
0.0412466079,
0.0411870591,
0.0365077779,
0.0000015456,
-0.0242722631,
0.0026955497,
-0.0253809411,
-0.0139662148,
0.0055132504,
-0.0428913981,
-0.0784966201,
0.0016059256,
-0.0463196822,
-0.0102861952,
-0.049794469,
0.0238179211,
0.043070551,
0.0098546576,
0.0631624758,
-0.0260053799,
-0.0112977959,
0.0515971072,
-0.0213188212,
0.0154340826,
-0.0199753679,
0.0144733209,
-0.0261355117,
-0.0422507301,
0.0316666663,
-0.0034760642,
-0.0112317139,
-0.0112711983,
0.0272454452,
0.0344293304,
0.0565314963,
-0.0729079545,
0.0212796889,
-0.0217111278,
0.0562531836,
0.0231403504,
-0.001220991,
0.0396280438,
-0.0279644728,
-0.0650980994,
-0.009960725,
-0.0552087873,
0.0305122305,
0.0232943464,
0.0374365747,
0.0392341949,
0.0446140878,
0.012480461,
0.0185582135,
0.0392988287,
0.093721725,
0.0087015433,
-0.0217894986,
-0.0375767238,
0.0135606686,
0.0047833631,
-0.0549323,
0.0075060544,
-0.0081262318,
-0.0146301119,
0.0161861274,
-0.0380798727,
0.0404248908,
-0.0279225241,
-0.101329565,
-0.0405542813,
0.03934443,
0.03821107,
0.0467279702,
0.0133516481,
0.0153268147,
-0.0263371393,
-0.0379228182,
-0.0228277612,
0.0105933491,
-0.017385602,
0.033179339,
-0.0285636745,
0.0499468893,
-0.0665345043,
-0.053261254,
-0.0216549616,
0.0030989943,
0.0062339338,
0.0165463127,
-0.0196313355,
0.0073880851,
-0.0409795381,
-0.0068739173,
-0.035857968,
0.0126079684,
-0.0384133719,
0.0017228387,
-0.0255277138,
-0.0282318685,
-0.0198237821,
0.0281551033,
0.0100299623,
-0.0092051709,
-0.0454810858,
0.0635584518,
0.0237371884,
-0.015776692,
-0.0451480597,
-0.052976422,
0.016039256,
-0.0156834386,
0.0366059393,
-0.0550075062,
0.0390481167,
-0.0192262847,
-0.0052388413,
-0.0068538431,
0.0446740985,
-0.0309314653,
-0.0261358842,
0.0590628684,
-0.0058639883,
0.0169352144,
-0.0018055174,
-0.0099756289,
-0.0037217124,
0.0856190547,
0.0552739911,
-0.0116746668,
0.0566445738,
0.0027258382,
-0.0232528932,
0.0348193273,
-0.0070584007,
0.0067499294,
-0.0275995545,
-0.0303850286,
-0.0121694654,
0.0223017223,
0.0626379177,
0.0060634566,
-0.0323762782,
0.0052287355,
0.0029786604,
0.0177222472,
-0.0624258779,
-0.0348707549,
0.0062794876,
-0.0504066013,
-0.0298050959,
0.057466615,
-0.0259166341,
-0.0021629927,
0.0054407343,
-0.0105212172,
0.0287423041,
-0.0427659191,
-0.041856572,
-0.0033600554,
-0.0047129886,
-0.0261483565,
-0.000060904,
-0.009456058,
0.0403610654,
-0.00998729,
-0.03492634,
0.1280602962,
0.0400046334,
-0.0363526568,
0.0268097296,
0.0318551585,
0.0108934669,
0.0435091928,
-0.0125350766,
-0.0551357716,
-0.0438712686,
0.0170105677,
0.0083358586,
0.0191481058,
0.0187161695,
-0.0327739529,
0.0552368537,
-0.0268717073,
-0.0061772233,
0.0047614956,
0.0068007759,
-0.0056054736,
-0.0012463575,
-0.0246371888,
-0.0057300371,
0.0498856679,
-0.0001859464,
0.0218179673,
-0.009329767,
-0.06419947,
-0.0217841938,
-0.0049119811,
0.0427780002,
-0.0022469163,
0.0038411515,
0.0061825095,
0.0679717287,
-0.080864802,
-0.0404318534,
0.0196772311,
-0.0612983666,
-0.065929316,
0.0267402995,
0.0234506447,
-0.007032014,
0.0117011638,
-0.0334011205,
-0.0465301313,
0.0134139489,
0.0075942539,
0.0520589985,
-0.0079370281,
-0.0069456464,
0.0284403991,
-0.0197132863,
-0.0178728458,
0.0536832176,
-0.0101332758,
0.0456785522,
-0.011144191,
-0.0205170289,
0.015616159,
-0.0423911177,
-0.0217700023,
0.0653340071,
0.0571448952,
-0.0315105096,
0.025285624,
-0.051656574,
-0.0398325846,
0.0360731594,
-0.0190014169,
0.0175030846,
-0.0139586302,
0.051054392,
0.0533068664,
0.0166894179,
0.0029862414,
0.0016251481,
-0.0029881822,
-0.0728870705,
-0.0231846888,
0.0155145461,
0.0035696924,
0.0191666577,
0.001776911,
-0.0306885857,
-0.0351026431,
-0.0583588816,
0.0618535616,
-0.0128735984,
-0.0488541424,
-0.0060956129,
0.0363201089,
0.0249741431,
0.0642283931,
-0.0109068342,
-0.0090839816,
-0.0276252739,
-0.0324980989,
0.0418484434,
0.0279679894,
-0.0295644365,
0.0172273796,
0.0000340216,
-0.0414142758,
-0.0439734235,
0.0105338274,
-0.0886833072,
0.060692545,
-0.0261243097,
-0.0117915524,
0.0211579911,
0.068913348,
0.0398614593,
0.0315932892,
-0.0304777399,
-0.0479911603,
-0.0249104798,
0.006901341,
-0.0102706114,
-0.0451176278,
-0.0525370724,
0.0438272059,
-0.0267756693,
-0.0244964659,
0.0691497773,
-0.0067866365,
-0.0142414449,
-0.0196400285,
0.0081234295,
-0.0321811922,
0.0528560169,
0.0024206368,
-0.0007752724,
-0.0140587809,
-0.0487812832,
-0.0025199626,
-0.0043669729,
-0.0017659005,
0.005571703,
0.0008777489,
-0.0188668799,
0.0053833327,
0.0132739814,
-0.0090810144,
-0.0465177074,
0.0108246384,
-0.0078973025,
0.0390796103,
-0.0342573225,
-0.0006942798,
-0.0361311473,
0.0018583678,
-0.007956963,
0.034805268,
-0.0174339004,
0.009281816,
-0.022847062,
0.1138974428,
0.04282628,
0.0121588856,
-0.019372141,
-0.0237252526,
-0.0221188851,
0.0569451302,
0.0472701676,
0.0377114192,
-0.0054121395,
0.0373492539,
0.0413111374,
-0.0134605458,
-0.0457377248,
0.0053452002,
0.0384561531,
-0.0660913289,
0.0248634089,
0.108580932,
0.017174894,
0.0164823793,
0.0338116512,
0.0615515262,
0.04303018,
0.0328582264,
-0.0127422828,
-0.017790826,
0.0092563825,
0.0058047026,
-0.009411782,
0.0104506994,
-0.0431051627,
0.0192689355,
-0.0515871048,
-0.0051875198,
0.015297357,
0.004286102,
-0.0329336189,
-0.0388968252,
0.0235163029,
-0.011459996,
-0.0436662883,
-0.0262264591,
0.0154326372,
-0.0326449275,
0.041636724,
-0.087101534,
-0.0491627157,
0.0188727062,
-0.037720602,
0.0316089727,
0.0076907296,
0.029203359,
-0.0394347273,
-0.0281400792,
0.0035271631,
-0.0067891353,
-0.0042590722,
-0.0150503498,
0.0058556898,
0.0037720767,
-0.0101000117,
0.0062296842,
0.0545861684,
-0.0200722925,
-0.0619722046,
-0.0129255299,
0.1581183672,
-0.0275662504,
-0.0039549223,
-0.0183660407,
-0.00232199,
0.0438679904,
0.0588010512,
-0.0181052089,
0.0298894234,
-0.0243484844,
0.0260600373,
0.0521875508,
-0.0388410538,
0.0053804154,
0.028657848,
-0.0163477194,
-0.0601061098,
-0.0463628583,
-0.0108881379,
0.0054287296,
0.0340871848,
-0.0407604054,
0.0043604001,
0.0485689268,
-0.0149772288,
-0.0174738057,
0.0646393821,
0.0155471815,
0.0095514078,
0.0099629555,
-0.0665723309,
0.0165754333,
0.0779206976,
-0.029365465,
0.0351575427,
-0.027957771,
-0.0521416664,
-0.0181717891,
-0.0135540077,
0.0090258271,
0.0488266908,
0.0161184464,
-0.0189841259,
-0.0478509478,
0.0010466704,
-0.0629668757,
0.0175781623,
0.0174493063,
0.0109494152,
-0.0089188349,
0.0453963764,
-0.0048792916,
0.0383635648,
-0.0448716208,
0.07018812,
-0.0402406603,
-0.0399509519,
-0.006413749,
-0.0310205501,
0.0848578662,
-0.0094545418,
-0.0126596978,
-0.0633953586,
-0.0191636514,
-0.037292067,
0.0283691306,
-0.031395793,
0.0364259258,
-0.003552227,
0.0360076725,
-0.0465353429,
0.0507117845,
-0.0485651568,
-0.0075304164,
-0.0634447113,
0.0193897933,
0.0544550121,
-0.0023867823,
0.0323879831,
0.0179064833,
-0.0059726657,
-0.008311227,
-0.0089351293,
-0.0164128859,
-0.0398529805,
-0.0165305883,
0.0480295829,
0.0365702994,
-0.0491259955,
-0.0545955673,
-0.0529921055,
0.0327599607,
0.0001389949,
-0.0245934669,
0.0235025883,
-0.0422306284,
0.0116758216,
-0.0337535143,
-0.0187713616,
0.0029347935,
0.0421480648,
0.0102240955,
-0.0022865972,
0.090595901,
0.0465631373,
-0.0359043665,
0.0435719825,
0.0561722256,
-0.0020675538,
0.0886517242,
0.0164207835,
0.0090967938,
-0.0282199755,
0.0069770496,
-0.003387958,
0.0772923827,
-0.0412100181,
0.0243438091,
-0.0622583441,
-0.0161311291,
0.0617033392,
-0.00760466,
-0.0059964224,
-0.0390477329,
0.0634167716,
0.0185791161,
-0.0031079347,
-0.0433516316,
0.0007074547,
0.00861667,
-0.0189857241,
-0.0320233442,
-0.0472811125,
-5.67303345e-33,
-0.0006622279,
-0.0224389751,
-0.0071030264,
0.0790613517,
-0.0286318362,
0.0566544719,
-0.0229271706,
-0.0003664244,
0.0168304835,
0.0191763006,
0.0141160488,
-0.0162365604,
0.0150503917,
0.002717417,
0.0261657182,
-0.0069474336,
0.0440434143,
-0.0271142796,
0.007098163,
0.039354343,
0.0495798253,
0.0586004667,
0.0777150393,
-0.0974193737,
-0.019693058,
-0.0065935529,
0.0222228076,
0.0224836208,
0.0664510801,
0.0201686621,
-0.0447825715,
0.0506474748,
0.0169088859,
-0.0407872014,
0.0005928555,
0.0244921651,
-0.0709880441,
-0.0239037909,
-0.0018916697,
0.0132160159,
-0.0431670472,
-0.0128687927,
0.0182450432,
0.0074792462,
-0.0024771458,
-0.0249125883,
0.0235514939,
-0.0052119563,
-0.043012429,
-0.0796050206,
-0.0486834571,
0.0504506938,
-0.0086254608,
0.0135850962,
0.0304332115,
-0.0176291578,
0.0317714736,
0.0355720967,
-0.0235203505,
0.0104974639,
-0.0489177182,
0.0428598486,
-0.0229057018,
0.0000025909,
-0.0156626757,
0.0792567506,
0.0506330244,
-0.0072861719,
-0.0179711375,
0.0663419813,
0.018911859,
0.0523164012,
-0.0459810197,
0.0062725311,
-0.0034540342,
-0.0185584165,
-0.0601563305,
0.0035870161,
0.0161674991,
-0.0273537058,
-0.017900506,
0.0281645209,
-0.0301419087,
-0.018183684,
-0.039433457,
0.0250987411,
0.0028382994,
0.022016542,
-0.0188972503,
-0.0052978066,
0.056411121,
0.0490099005,
0.0002599925,
-0.0171265379,
-0.004149294,
0.0300371628,
-0.0086624511,
0.0001708638,
0.0036070833,
0.0171218757,
-0.0522766709,
-0.0467149131,
0.0116933519,
-0.0123844706,
0.0304637887,
-0.0113792168,
-0.0228542276,
0.0515236333,
-0.0162901208,
-0.0221220367,
-0.0334076583,
-0.0384975858,
0.0100532873,
0.0011969765,
0.0389694236,
-0.0044170818,
0.0017411018,
0.0852268189,
-0.0108679682,
0.0385837294,
0.0018224643,
-0.0039117942,
0.0012925334,
0.0832895264,
-0.0176972412,
-0.02207358,
-0.0458060019,
-0.029507244,
0.0469206907,
-0.0382806063,
-0.0294800662,
0.0374875069,
2.284e-7,
0.0221807472,
0.0386460871,
0.0318386257,
0.00388755,
0.0416311957,
0.0131637743,
0.0060325214,
0.0221250001,
-0.0306161512,
-0.029772969,
-0.0264793597,
-0.0178836305,
0.0368974917,
0.0546247624,
-0.0824045688,
-0.0541666113,
-0.0521030389,
-0.0113496054,
-0.0643101111,
-0.0479303971,
0.0717577636,
0.0809568986,
0.0467517823,
0.0130802691,
0.009282494,
0.0265981592,
0.0425968282,
0.0059284195,
-0.0214481968,
0.0083176354,
-0.0822039545,
0.0160546321,
-0.0253910944,
0.0286698584,
-0.0348964892,
0.01713866,
0.0177219044,
0.0691044182,
0.0045163846,
-0.0243291389,
0.013174722,
0.0138536934,
-0.0488796569,
0.0131872073,
0.0554003678,
-0.0194823667,
-0.0172135141,
0.0031980465,
-0.0284090023,
0.0515686683,
-0.0316552185,
0.0152421854,
-0.0365561359,
0.0347280316,
-0.0029905485,
-0.0066497726,
-0.0136457495,
-0.0556620285,
0.0074160011,
0.059002541,
-0.0594772622,
-0.0274736322,
0.0178505573,
-0.075867489,
-0.0010603878,
-0.0240947139,
-0.0468006246,
2.036564167e-34,
-0.0041950936,
0.0174407065,
-0.0287987776,
0.0144434962,
0.006905165,
-0.0482206829,
-0.0129950456,
-0.0145407235,
0.0285181496,
-0.0385341346,
-0.0122971255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13614v1 | LLM-empowered Chatbots for Psychiatrist and Patient Simulation: Application and Evaluation | 2023-05-23T02:25:01 | 2023-05-23T02:25:01 | Siyuan Chen, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu, Kunyao Lan, Zhiling Zhang, Lyuchun Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empowering chatbots in the field of mental health is receiving increasing
amount of attention, while there still lacks exploration in developing and
evaluating chatbots in psychiatric outpatient scenarios. In this work, we focus
on exploring the potential of ChatGPT in powering chatbots for psychiatrist and
patient simulation. We collaborate with psychiatrists to identify objectives
and iteratively develop the dialogue system to closely align with real-world
scenarios. In the evaluation experiments, we recruit real psychiatrists and
patients to engage in diagnostic conversations with the chatbots, collecting
their ratings for assessment. Our findings demonstrate the feasibility of using
ChatGPT-powered chatbots in psychiatric scenarios and explore the impact of
prompt designs on chatbot behavior and user experience. | [
0.0866365433,
-0.0215273965,
-0.0346592516,
-0.0335252024,
-0.0371544771,
0.0001323838,
0.0312853865,
0.0359430835,
0.1144719645,
0.0151793472,
-0.0346633494,
-0.0239387192,
-0.008607449,
0.0326543376,
0.001297274,
-0.0673695803,
0.0018193147,
-0.0076205065,
0.0157895498,
0.0163032413,
-0.0053608073,
0.012948148,
-0.0988118201,
0.0796251372,
-0.0150818145,
-0.0126345772,
-0.0289206728,
0.0582567826,
0.0080759544,
-0.066546008,
-0.0359199382,
0.0125986338,
-0.0094131362,
0.0215095505,
0.0000019047,
-0.0181361549,
0.0065526478,
0.0088959895,
-0.0419935025,
-0.0814062133,
0.04892198,
0.0116138989,
-0.0140041141,
0.0468926765,
-0.0235565454,
-0.0114921546,
0.0245138872,
0.0508387871,
0.0718340352,
0.0382410511,
-0.0221116897,
0.0558741093,
-0.0000287122,
0.0149285924,
0.0334113836,
0.0032640882,
-0.0145317912,
0.0479426235,
0.1163612902,
-0.0319533087,
0.0112520363,
0.0160813201,
0.0097580627,
-0.0153845586,
-0.0112858238,
0.0447301753,
-0.0013134088,
-0.0590420738,
-0.0389425829,
0.0707820207,
0.0600420348,
0.0392346308,
0.0326803066,
0.0042000706,
0.0383462794,
-0.0153748766,
-0.0636674017,
-0.0048931665,
-0.0188290887,
-0.009191623,
-0.025045054,
-0.0031299787,
0.0223843511,
-0.0304821413,
0.04523867,
0.0033372676,
0.0203861427,
-0.0191523843,
-0.0151825044,
-0.0111859487,
-0.0016077078,
-0.0633781925,
0.0194982029,
0.0569058023,
-0.0905005634,
0.0024547481,
-0.0245028324,
-0.017311614,
0.0165276378,
0.0138122877,
-0.0109319724,
0.0523077436,
-0.0141795985,
0.0300402083,
0.0413045548,
0.0363615677,
0.0147047704,
0.041530069,
-0.0132095898,
0.003771825,
-0.0372557119,
-0.0160166007,
-0.0361754112,
0.0117227547,
0.0129584391,
-0.0408900008,
-0.0476680323,
0.0395398624,
0.0066483761,
0.0215941872,
-0.0040234472,
0.0204399507,
0.0087325908,
0.0320515409,
-0.0116157355,
-0.0317257568,
-0.0413946472,
-0.0073401039,
0.0354357995,
-0.1118056178,
0.008131193,
0.0105333384,
-0.0279436223,
-0.0005113553,
0.0091145262,
0.0964490697,
0.0121099306,
-0.0176912826,
0.0201418512,
-0.0528995357,
-0.0021789046,
-0.0068361885,
0.0540880933,
-0.0275279265,
0.0368413292,
-0.0012602262,
0.0104726357,
0.0102901515,
0.0343027301,
0.0245312434,
-0.0338674337,
0.0582906194,
-0.0634986535,
0.0073447567,
0.0237598438,
0.0494915545,
-0.0506389178,
0.0089222444,
0.0121519156,
-0.0071264491,
0.0165542308,
-0.0216296967,
0.0720066056,
0.027771255,
-0.0380421691,
-0.0371046327,
0.052889742,
-0.0160875879,
-0.005894932,
0.0871896446,
-0.0379507467,
0.0181610789,
-0.0486832075,
0.0441109762,
0.0598150603,
0.083316803,
0.0276858471,
0.0088427803,
-0.0199696422,
-0.0227127839,
0.0267406441,
-0.0144264735,
-0.0421783775,
0.053768754,
-0.0128680253,
-0.0318205245,
-0.0116092712,
-0.021493705,
-0.0335790552,
-0.012782109,
-0.0078755338,
-0.0338382088,
0.017991798,
-0.0003056381,
-0.0122101586,
0.0033598221,
-0.0099117821,
0.0417121798,
0.0184048265,
-0.0526282713,
-0.0589835346,
-0.0779361352,
-0.0063892719,
0.1215139478,
0.079773359,
-0.029578479,
-0.0465734489,
-0.0162846707,
-0.012978334,
0.0472555719,
0.034591455,
0.0204087142,
0.0003480665,
0.0001060489,
-0.0170498304,
0.013327972,
-0.0070173368,
-0.0111547709,
-0.0166800059,
0.0165672433,
-0.0585040934,
0.0019976478,
0.0257859845,
0.0456295982,
-0.030918289,
-0.0101791974,
-0.0199600682,
-0.019330889,
0.0321810171,
0.0397735685,
0.0144196246,
0.0055794059,
0.0180400442,
-0.0134007065,
-0.0351372175,
0.0492630936,
-0.0258639213,
-0.0200863425,
0.0242633,
-0.0245370008,
0.0025031422,
0.0206150059,
-0.0079481555,
-0.0078111961,
0.0014077189,
-0.0604634918,
0.0556166731,
-0.0173148643,
0.0200049337,
0.0192993898,
0.0133775109,
-0.0093894135,
-0.0353038609,
0.0141089717,
0.0047811717,
0.0559451543,
0.0291589014,
-0.0519297384,
-0.0351732634,
0.0025255277,
0.0281887762,
0.0004599821,
-0.0107572274,
-0.0256168693,
0.0058468487,
-0.0635682419,
-0.0043498366,
-0.1640445441,
-0.0093878619,
0.0230511464,
-0.0592552237,
0.0241715331,
0.0009026059,
-0.0288393572,
-0.017557079,
-0.034885373,
0.0381837748,
0.067771703,
0.027279513,
0.0318119824,
0.0040978249,
-0.0403724909,
-0.0399938636,
0.0281715635,
-0.0193626471,
0.0133057917,
0.0124092028,
0.0252812281,
-0.0358487107,
-0.0130024543,
-0.0534066185,
-0.0071835811,
-0.0105875907,
-0.0604389682,
0.0694958344,
-0.0112353228,
0.0181880929,
0.0190752931,
0.0088306405,
0.0289334226,
0.0290020499,
-0.0180379804,
-0.0198057164,
0.0012628314,
0.0041641095,
-0.0225542672,
-0.0178226996,
-0.0512448289,
0.0102844918,
0.0290758051,
0.0045890012,
0.0549959727,
-0.025394382,
0.0134901917,
0.02290041,
-0.017449541,
0.0311756618,
0.01592011,
-0.0444990732,
0.0340497829,
-0.0003246892,
-0.0179707967,
0.0581567623,
-0.0118202893,
-0.026529558,
0.0007650442,
-0.0436322652,
-0.0184312575,
0.0220040642,
-0.036648307,
0.0012085424,
0.0043164152,
-0.0186584443,
0.0044969409,
-0.0273738578,
-0.0266886801,
-0.0581119955,
-0.0269994307,
-0.0415767096,
-0.0241986848,
0.0138821946,
0.0015941357,
-0.0487232059,
-0.0199313723,
-0.04300832,
-0.0071453946,
-0.0124832159,
0.0038166631,
-0.0391567834,
-0.0227785166,
0.0227587707,
0.0343975909,
0.0083476827,
-0.0296280626,
-0.0084584849,
-0.0317993015,
0.0233319998,
0.0361779295,
0.0279776752,
0.0084526166,
0.0365542583,
0.052664604,
-0.0219538044,
0.0141328415,
-0.0058864541,
-0.0281389318,
-0.0088195801,
-0.010801387,
-0.006423295,
0.0171515215,
0.0350866243,
-0.0204872191,
-0.0053066276,
0.110362716,
0.0067638205,
-0.0289001297,
0.0268622376,
-0.0510702617,
-0.0068199672,
-0.0257160533,
0.0024623573,
-0.0460972823,
-0.0261194315,
0.0140873836,
0.0391457006,
-0.0545781329,
-0.0479370877,
0.0076151439,
-0.0548581444,
0.0205445103,
-0.0206163134,
0.012731486,
-0.021050239,
-0.0083241044,
0.0327876583,
0.0086009838,
0.0327810906,
0.0082436344,
0.0144320736,
-0.0093291402,
-0.0201863442,
-0.0886551514,
0.0085844975,
0.0658994466,
0.0107753752,
0.1051362455,
0.0557551235,
0.0496897586,
0.0071879141,
-0.0160274822,
-0.0087253014,
0.0711963996,
0.0380800292,
0.0060607148,
0.0322147422,
0.0222125016,
0.0127007803,
-0.0559317619,
0.0381994396,
-0.0296612978,
-0.0124885067,
0.0223238058,
0.0320120268,
-0.0727994815,
-0.0088990126,
-0.0516391546,
0.0655004382,
0.0489284471,
0.036412742,
0.0105928173,
-0.0551596582,
-0.0352887437,
-0.004690215,
0.0203936361,
0.0474291183,
-0.0500210263,
-0.0115051577,
0.0084125232,
-0.0227174945,
-0.0881499574,
-0.041797664,
0.0436801761,
-0.0022548365,
-0.0172477085,
-0.0267174393,
-0.0153314471,
0.0462511703,
0.0226733796,
0.001437558,
-0.0097728204,
0.0152127659,
-0.0333840102,
0.0034848654,
0.0333908387,
-0.0465520397,
0.0318686888,
0.0226614065,
-0.013725156,
0.0071298308,
0.0401064456,
0.0485206842,
0.0252069421,
-0.0367762968,
-0.0023872731,
0.0151114231,
0.0036407453,
0.0420418605,
-0.0341060683,
-0.0142333461,
-0.0051537682,
0.1014727727,
-0.0062106219,
-0.0130491788,
-0.0386067852,
0.0206245091,
-0.0042138426,
0.0142049026,
-0.0128609287,
-0.0468949601,
0.017102601,
0.0614499897,
0.0202878267,
-0.0100119533,
0.0012007053,
0.0283471625,
0.0187376607,
-0.0644772351,
0.0453923829,
-0.0374380834,
-0.0337441638,
-0.0349876322,
-0.0226612147,
0.0349634103,
-0.0161716808,
-0.08894521,
-0.0177651234,
-0.0094395718,
0.0106222453,
-0.0117662717,
-0.0382406898,
-0.0098089483,
-0.0118499752,
0.0029288672,
0.0536370724,
-0.0161255319,
0.0269503444,
0.0308249444,
0.0733161718,
-0.0135135818,
-0.0305238385,
0.0355254561,
0.0848900974,
-0.0779652297,
-0.1192376614,
0.0135945454,
0.0677309334,
-0.000926075,
0.0852831826,
0.0030897968,
-0.0517578572,
0.0362041853,
-0.0125433002,
0.0095146419,
-0.0017325619,
-0.0030539997,
-0.0220834594,
0.0147066796,
-0.0032452177,
-0.0428080745,
0.0069777127,
-0.0620507449,
0.0206196178,
0.0040770271,
-0.0328627862,
-0.0381953642,
-0.0136709251,
0.0014352615,
-0.0031396372,
-0.0011132071,
-0.0223205984,
-0.0215750691,
-0.0237675067,
0.0120364781,
0.0008179615,
-0.0515360646,
-0.0623916574,
0.0721858367,
-0.0063672434,
-0.0103882961,
-0.0013929254,
-0.0085480232,
0.0153858662,
-0.0298187453,
0.0085687041,
-0.0316069163,
-5.279663082e-33,
-0.0135084968,
-0.0373082794,
0.0422273465,
0.0153079452,
-0.0465522185,
-0.0269442778,
-0.0567560308,
0.0373633951,
-0.0026980634,
-0.0024514792,
-0.0258434489,
0.0407636911,
0.0035826711,
0.0097159743,
-0.0040332153,
-0.0301345754,
0.0394822434,
-0.0137187364,
-0.0267830323,
0.0242834333,
-0.0369368233,
0.0285036769,
0.0097921742,
-0.0813074633,
0.010978777,
-0.0165945701,
-0.0083489651,
-0.000797935,
-0.0023504687,
0.002802405,
-0.0008554286,
0.0232550073,
0.0270923898,
-0.0067821508,
-0.0047503044,
0.0301341042,
-0.0160332955,
-0.0278574917,
-0.0100158574,
0.0028576464,
-0.0758015215,
0.0112019358,
0.0036861678,
-0.0321560949,
-0.0135640567,
-0.0106345508,
0.0133750634,
-0.0266250595,
0.0136324726,
0.0226562563,
-0.006589341,
-0.0172452163,
-0.0190931521,
-0.0542106219,
-0.0253193546,
0.0572951101,
-0.0432659015,
-0.001002221,
-0.0245021582,
0.0184275117,
0.0134264845,
-0.0429086685,
0.0113030644,
-0.0230631698,
0.0319633558,
0.0448238291,
0.0388911963,
-0.0040755821,
-0.0755949691,
-0.0028935624,
-0.006712365,
0.0310766958,
0.0748705491,
0.0197832864,
-0.0135483732,
-0.0112874554,
-0.0116049331,
0.0169422682,
0.050177861,
-0.0071710423,
0.0251481924,
0.0248192977,
-0.0298351478,
0.0151572749,
0.009136186,
0.0116263926,
-0.0141848531,
-0.087366499,
0.0159518942,
-0.0187714323,
0.0010408319,
-0.070403859,
-0.0035060986,
-0.0002064532,
0.0119936569,
-0.0530774742,
0.0204627663,
0.033662647,
-0.0217238031,
-0.0477145948,
0.0154191209,
-0.0110143591,
0.0487657189,
0.0110836923,
0.0747247636,
0.019495381,
-0.0238380041,
-0.0123463972,
-0.0299413353,
-0.0074271504,
0.0062255827,
0.0752000958,
0.0238639116,
0.0016315819,
-0.0061644083,
-0.0152015835,
-0.0256799366,
0.0123678939,
-0.0151679143,
0.0199404415,
-0.0657166392,
0.0295220576,
-0.0266061723,
-0.0379042774,
-0.0398692228,
-0.0208862405,
-0.0536460765,
0.0155039765,
0.0222718492,
-0.0293368287,
-0.0224430244,
-0.0535979867,
2.685e-7,
-0.0177144706,
0.0334120244,
0.0052348734,
0.0269958451,
0.0620235503,
0.0356762111,
0.0161553249,
0.0547994524,
0.0250131134,
-0.0879399553,
0.0339404941,
0.0380121544,
0.0555560999,
0.0441009887,
-0.0577632785,
-0.0499927066,
-0.0501242056,
-0.0364292562,
-0.0198014323,
0.0015766085,
0.0915648416,
-0.0054738857,
0.0007516631,
-0.0277746841,
0.0132536162,
-0.0067113638,
0.0080164885,
-0.0640410706,
0.009584696,
0.0421422906,
0.0149415797,
0.0225581117,
0.0336780138,
0.0093807764,
0.0138852596,
-0.0399283469,
0.0051476974,
0.0389022455,
-0.0422824547,
-0.0517028533,
0.0145814503,
0.0245602224,
0.0103285313,
-0.012682694,
0.035785418,
-0.0872547328,
-0.0542654246,
-0.0428570583,
-0.0273621362,
-0.0528202467,
0.0668805912,
-0.0431788191,
-0.0398677997,
0.0460209399,
-0.0062796804,
0.0424668118,
0.0029803938,
-0.0361165181,
0.0156106362,
-0.0040688463,
-0.076360777,
-0.0568682998,
0.0063111982,
-0.0094039906,
-0.0426345058,
-0.0468276814,
0.0012984568,
1.757159376e-34,
0.0001438061,
0.0568817295,
0.0328901447,
0.0645451248,
0.0409775227,
0.0478469022,
0.0613515042,
0.0509471782,
0.0371655971,
-0.0340814739,
-0.0154010225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13602v2 | ReSee: Responding through Seeing Fine-grained Visual Knowledge in Open-domain Dialogue | 2023-05-23T02:08:56 | 2023-10-20T04:59:10 | Haoqin Tu, Yitong Li, Fei Mi, Zhongliang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating visual knowledge into text-only dialogue systems has become a
potential direction to imitate the way humans think, imagine, and communicate.
However, existing multimodal dialogue systems are either confined by the scale
and quality of available datasets or the coarse concept of visual knowledge. To
address these issues, we provide a new paradigm of constructing multimodal
dialogues as well as two datasets extended from text-only dialogues under such
paradigm (ReSee-WoW, ReSee-DD). We propose to explicitly split the visual
knowledge into finer granularity (``turn-level'' and ``entity-level''). To
further boost the accuracy and diversity of augmented visual information, we
retrieve them from the Internet or a large image dataset. To demonstrate the
superiority and universality of the provided visual knowledge, we propose a
simple but effective framework ReSee to add visual representation into vanilla
dialogue models by modality concatenations. We also conduct extensive
experiments and ablations w.r.t. different model configurations and visual
knowledge settings. Empirical, encouraging results not only demonstrate the
effectiveness of introducing visual knowledge at both entity and turn level but
also verify the proposed model ReSee outperforms several state-of-the-art
methods on automatic and human evaluations. By leveraging text and vision
knowledge, ReSee can produce informative responses with real-world visual
concepts. Our code is available at https://github.com/ImKeTT/ReSee. | [
0.040416725,
0.042429328,
-0.0148908049,
0.0623628385,
0.0094750375,
0.0060109058,
-0.0101730051,
0.026686931,
0.026076993,
-0.0960828438,
-0.0488274917,
-0.0011936411,
0.0076233475,
0.0743639246,
0.0430303775,
-0.1259315163,
0.0039508385,
-0.0281046294,
0.013583784,
-0.0030902266,
0.0643914863,
0.0058108182,
-0.0498977788,
0.0590277687,
-0.050106898,
-0.0275832471,
-0.0433429666,
0.0215946268,
0.0228378456,
-0.0136573352,
-0.024984004,
0.0342115797,
0.0603332259,
0.0037954154,
0.0000018319,
-0.0186358262,
0.0522644594,
-0.0129890153,
-0.0059878067,
-0.0150964065,
0.0057610772,
-0.0339171402,
0.0309859049,
-0.0201151948,
-0.0471871272,
-0.0054474422,
0.0753158182,
0.0523188189,
0.0921297222,
0.0355338901,
-0.0307446346,
-0.0186315719,
0.040634159,
0.0033541524,
0.0226633642,
-0.0399076752,
-0.0087158401,
0.0349199213,
0.0131855058,
0.01467878,
-0.0507704131,
0.0400118567,
0.0042619421,
-0.0408520326,
-0.00964888,
0.0387990251,
-0.0012625968,
-0.0305187739,
-0.0385906287,
0.1348957866,
0.0291256104,
0.0305655375,
-0.0267414674,
0.0148655688,
0.003403374,
-0.0084059648,
-0.0582324825,
-0.006517557,
-0.0105949249,
-0.001386203,
-0.0962932184,
0.024169784,
-0.0252849013,
-0.0002096861,
0.0119643472,
-0.017971091,
0.0002404033,
0.0132247414,
-0.0231623854,
-0.0133318314,
-0.0239708237,
-0.0561146364,
-0.0418118723,
0.0396428593,
-0.0290752668,
0.009696627,
-0.0449943505,
-0.0002691722,
-0.0001901023,
-0.0034114541,
0.0212016422,
0.0348055251,
-0.0480816588,
0.0635852814,
0.0028672991,
0.0415912122,
-0.0189185236,
0.017838411,
0.0079104239,
-0.0343832038,
-0.0414122939,
-0.017827861,
-0.0412760898,
-0.0266004726,
-0.0981987193,
-0.0544130616,
0.0084891226,
0.0279831495,
-0.0205821171,
0.0196080282,
0.0076979469,
0.0325992033,
-0.0098445304,
0.0056303963,
-0.0667260215,
0.0526006818,
-0.0384520739,
0.0162896812,
0.0187026206,
-0.0482945926,
-0.0006459948,
0.023949502,
0.0271612275,
-0.0058491579,
-0.0210061688,
0.0789942518,
-0.0550506003,
-0.0144933779,
-0.0024367173,
-0.0382650234,
-0.0556648411,
-0.048643522,
0.0036831337,
-0.0200013611,
0.0523010306,
-0.0045399312,
0.00452398,
-0.0132829407,
0.0164221115,
0.0012596482,
-0.0267908778,
0.1018066108,
-0.0322895981,
0.0122432355,
0.0314812586,
0.0266565997,
-0.0205646995,
0.0545020178,
0.0503993928,
0.010021355,
0.0419765376,
-0.0131315887,
0.0388197713,
0.0372430086,
-0.0004384694,
-0.0020986132,
-0.0196359735,
0.0183088537,
-0.0429578982,
0.0348935686,
0.0296476576,
0.0438137837,
-0.0430935919,
-0.0381024517,
0.0760185868,
0.0224385969,
-0.0043835491,
0.0099933334,
0.0169283524,
0.0335458256,
0.0247963443,
-0.0178882778,
-0.0247444306,
0.0782720596,
-0.0148671092,
0.0047549182,
0.0439925976,
0.0200513359,
-0.0305942055,
-0.0242598969,
0.003316906,
0.020555187,
0.0239981003,
0.0041368967,
0.0368646868,
0.0261060018,
-0.0408989377,
0.0062025348,
0.0184941776,
-0.0484833978,
-0.0201171171,
-0.0152526628,
0.0247737896,
0.0631376579,
0.023093557,
0.011931574,
-0.0088747824,
-0.0172712058,
0.0199120194,
0.0393224992,
0.0259027593,
-0.0080900043,
0.0600082017,
-0.0515047424,
-0.0340018086,
-0.0229644049,
-0.0267529078,
0.0131460754,
-0.0124954311,
-0.0189069137,
-0.0002993259,
-0.0220546275,
0.047357168,
0.0115570147,
0.0582771227,
0.0092298444,
-0.0407730229,
0.029408643,
-0.0004035613,
0.0106041189,
-0.0093723312,
-0.0200900547,
0.012780169,
0.0034643277,
0.0071267239,
0.0255768262,
-0.0210633744,
-0.0603734888,
0.0167211611,
-0.0485652983,
-0.0205072705,
-0.0046901843,
-0.0137146525,
-0.0358253121,
0.0225686152,
-0.0365735218,
0.020419661,
-0.0530721545,
-0.0109845167,
0.0405686796,
0.026548652,
0.0070733437,
0.0528036319,
-0.0176255815,
-0.005542872,
0.0317977145,
-0.003468852,
0.0190083515,
-0.0352264643,
-0.0171320233,
0.0119364876,
0.002920853,
0.032500267,
0.0017393044,
0.0001253178,
-0.0557302758,
-0.009917249,
-0.1101456955,
-0.0466334298,
-0.0002802037,
-0.0308656655,
-0.0076479758,
0.0052243681,
-0.0023477494,
-0.0475285165,
-0.0305384714,
0.0385037251,
0.01928447,
0.0008877938,
0.0236556157,
0.0172347371,
0.0169010758,
-0.0257810298,
0.017892262,
0.0375640765,
0.0752207935,
0.003360156,
0.0011783238,
-0.025734758,
-0.0248809569,
-0.0447601117,
0.0579514876,
-0.0291352998,
-0.056088049,
0.0353808887,
-0.0037662126,
0.0332248546,
0.0168309379,
0.0331484824,
0.032697089,
-0.0092338752,
-0.0585300103,
-0.0467621423,
0.0371920504,
-0.0012516304,
-0.0049443264,
-0.0333308876,
0.0030663798,
-0.021209849,
0.0225397758,
0.0019434544,
0.0392997079,
-0.0563437454,
0.0423845537,
0.0547001548,
-0.0864309967,
-0.0461341441,
-0.0006565592,
-0.0115219299,
0.0229744278,
-0.0559449233,
-0.0363888741,
0.0518298447,
-0.0545504503,
-0.0517365709,
0.0371269584,
0.0189926885,
-0.0043681134,
0.0771229863,
-0.007236653,
0.0216372106,
0.0031670991,
-0.0021653306,
-0.0431762077,
-0.0038222084,
0.0077835359,
-0.0057998244,
0.0680780262,
-0.0564285293,
-0.0014180318,
-0.003120593,
-0.0294480417,
-0.0366254449,
-0.0191980116,
-0.0301337633,
-0.017354548,
-0.0033198122,
-0.0434412807,
-0.0200046021,
0.0286107305,
0.0554091781,
-0.0012177475,
0.0179995522,
-0.0226513799,
-0.0185463019,
0.0556851476,
0.0561283864,
0.0680910051,
-0.046605546,
-0.0281505939,
0.0437329076,
0.057458315,
0.0150290253,
-0.0398936123,
-0.033926744,
0.0081115877,
0.0143298218,
0.0498499013,
-0.0069295517,
0.0144262882,
0.0630394891,
-0.0322960503,
0.0155875301,
0.0754063353,
0.0068393676,
-0.0225595925,
-0.0091883652,
-0.0047218273,
0.050648611,
0.0364529565,
0.0151605112,
-0.0937159956,
-0.0668770894,
-0.0172646903,
-0.030004574,
0.0167512558,
-0.020158885,
-0.0235648826,
-0.0861461386,
0.0439201333,
-0.0187272746,
-0.0251894984,
-0.0388490632,
0.045175191,
0.0295939893,
0.013765146,
-0.0024629883,
-0.0009409227,
0.0103267245,
-0.0080099292,
0.0013983438,
0.0309757441,
-0.0090929931,
-0.0016828448,
-0.0210722275,
0.0122201219,
0.0358306766,
0.0418206789,
0.0305928495,
-0.0579976998,
-0.0177256893,
-0.0123711033,
0.0266736764,
-0.0005884427,
0.084869571,
-0.0288430005,
-0.0333154202,
-0.0160229206,
0.005822449,
0.0165388491,
-0.0323321149,
-0.0023178714,
0.02582746,
-0.0440564714,
0.0199224744,
-0.0287466422,
0.0241341926,
0.0348183475,
0.0374452248,
0.0247479901,
-0.0360434577,
-0.0128780659,
-0.0235493761,
0.0118419314,
-0.0211772695,
-0.0339342542,
-0.0144900968,
0.0193159804,
0.029705286,
-0.0848114192,
-0.018962549,
0.0403262898,
0.048075784,
-0.0209170692,
-0.0178919584,
-0.0193326287,
0.0482143722,
-0.027876934,
0.0328653194,
-0.012289877,
0.0180485845,
-0.031820178,
-0.0274660084,
0.0122284815,
-0.0543417372,
-0.0145651121,
0.0288520455,
-0.0464130268,
-0.0392541587,
-0.0602837317,
0.0692429617,
0.0192883536,
0.0465215743,
0.0310086608,
-0.0580523983,
0.0394836999,
0.0320294611,
-0.0317038931,
-0.0069765183,
0.0273270942,
0.0249522682,
-0.0070745153,
0.0265039802,
-0.0386270732,
0.0011295405,
-0.0351467021,
0.0262157489,
-0.0459546112,
-0.0803154632,
-0.0029258172,
-0.0314562246,
0.0382581577,
-0.0049119573,
-0.0016856715,
-0.0191216301,
0.016545739,
-0.01296099,
-0.0141652394,
-0.0909676999,
0.0094387177,
-0.0281056035,
-0.0071996753,
0.0076740668,
0.0179689862,
0.0013001707,
0.0197248086,
-0.0353829302,
-0.0088670775,
0.0480404384,
-0.0094061401,
-0.0018876718,
0.0275122356,
0.0141983302,
0.037519224,
-0.0278560836,
0.0134728216,
0.0137884906,
0.1323543042,
0.00582712,
-0.0838996917,
0.0054493216,
0.0408266336,
-0.0238244068,
-0.0173462704,
-0.0128568606,
0.0500520058,
0.015791934,
0.046921514,
0.0212826114,
-0.0174677763,
-0.0052859657,
0.0039658402,
0.0726652369,
-0.0101889269,
-0.0518620685,
0.0733732134,
0.0296449475,
-0.0099616023,
0.003984435,
0.0555482171,
-0.0343219042,
0.0090099638,
-0.0162563808,
-0.0104675246,
-0.0525403284,
-0.0359604172,
0.0397866033,
0.0236704703,
0.0187410265,
0.055075027,
-0.0414633118,
-0.0466671363,
-0.0036443747,
0.0278428327,
-0.0068240715,
0.0069025732,
0.0504911877,
0.0183749106,
0.0190444309,
-0.0058623231,
-0.0284753703,
-0.0011229982,
-0.0376585238,
0.0141571146,
-0.0076685091,
-5.718385124e-33,
-0.0339982919,
-0.0473533273,
0.0359699279,
-0.0100627337,
-0.0256720241,
-0.0027260932,
-0.0329420343,
0.0147903236,
-0.0248651057,
0.036651738,
0.0216375347,
-0.0055239084,
-0.013393173,
0.0477461144,
-0.0344101302,
-0.0175460521,
0.0280748382,
0.0186515749,
-0.0187295843,
0.0245674327,
0.0397129357,
-0.0017902647,
0.03770601,
-0.0765534341,
0.0109772524,
0.0152673395,
-0.040101096,
0.0253153592,
0.0138007505,
0.0883343965,
-0.0428215936,
0.0464684479,
0.0009243948,
-0.0053982139,
-0.0265927799,
0.0440648384,
-0.0552034602,
0.0169018544,
0.0127946241,
0.0201816857,
-0.1040156409,
0.0398477428,
0.0279574078,
-0.0109326812,
0.0279651284,
-0.0231121872,
0.0393806174,
-0.0141869271,
0.0059472886,
0.0138149709,
-0.0412845016,
0.0117608039,
-0.0257393997,
-0.0846065581,
0.0096970284,
0.0583949834,
0.0618556365,
-0.0119899428,
-0.0490534008,
0.0332251973,
-0.0187724084,
-0.0253396817,
0.0646958351,
0.0295795705,
0.0055181454,
0.0793486089,
0.0125761824,
-0.0243348461,
-0.0344490744,
-0.0226694606,
0.0036037164,
0.076299727,
0.0098291887,
0.1032315344,
-0.0053173881,
0.012650447,
0.000530161,
0.0161890183,
-0.0576294214,
0.0614221543,
-0.0216590296,
0.025101345,
-0.0180040672,
0.0213665888,
-0.0411570705,
-0.0024932995,
-0.0527228899,
-0.0060973121,
0.0289091617,
0.0152453892,
0.0102326917,
0.0223556235,
0.0683056042,
-0.0423827916,
-0.0009206669,
0.0119532682,
-0.0112290066,
0.0581780933,
-0.0020629603,
-0.0272933263,
0.0029643858,
-0.0066177566,
0.1122440919,
-0.0119518759,
-0.0006617697,
0.0204176679,
0.025137879,
0.0183787178,
-0.041845791,
-0.0191687346,
-0.0253121685,
0.0504150093,
-0.035486009,
0.0066467635,
0.0029423491,
0.0050970525,
-0.0713826045,
0.0309417211,
-0.0332412124,
-0.0150487507,
-0.0194064435,
-0.0676194653,
0.0226799194,
-0.0022622682,
-0.0434209555,
0.0046867179,
-0.0055610333,
-0.0973135456,
0.0150929671,
-0.0407332554,
-0.0140780965,
0.0460974276,
2.497e-7,
0.0081542684,
0.006412223,
0.0226195697,
0.0188046917,
0.0319363251,
0.0713467374,
-0.023049742,
0.0299030878,
0.010082664,
-0.0754695907,
0.009957185,
0.0347139649,
0.0551985838,
-0.0169178769,
-0.0463796109,
-0.0262739565,
-0.0281792693,
-0.0296107084,
-0.0272979774,
0.0120972255,
0.0986234099,
0.0308344439,
0.0035156976,
-0.008258516,
0.0099415062,
-0.0232333317,
0.0790018737,
-0.0393723622,
-0.0035263489,
-0.0144180506,
0.0353233181,
-0.022110926,
-0.0035205327,
0.0295976195,
-0.0154727995,
-0.007167744,
0.0311349593,
0.0339947939,
-0.0346203521,
-0.054430522,
-0.0362848155,
0.0239330791,
-0.0029075649,
-0.0275270697,
0.0502637774,
-0.0376099423,
-0.0325891264,
-0.0120937536,
-0.0282666646,
-0.0211978629,
0.0001655975,
-0.0246098135,
-0.0605023913,
0.026182197,
0.0328036435,
-0.0303319041,
-0.0128673734,
-0.0835376307,
-0.0263451543,
-0.0174271744,
-0.0586048886,
-0.0390050747,
-0.037880037,
-0.0491823517,
0.0259800497,
-0.0287285764,
-0.0402872786,
1.716891577e-34,
0.002283345,
0.0041562812,
0.0066154385,
0.0216092672,
0.0364365131,
-0.0061212974,
-0.002696913,
-0.0221375059,
0.0365666263,
-0.0610071681,
-0.0228315517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13599v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13599v3 | Decoupled Rationalization with Asymmetric Learning Rates: A Flexible Lipschitz Restraint | 2023-05-23T02:01:13 | 2023-06-24T08:54:12 | Wei Liu, Jun Wang, Haozhao Wang, Ruixuan Li, Yang Qiu, YuanKai Zhang, Jie Han, Yixiong Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A self-explaining rationalization model is generally constructed by a
cooperative game where a generator selects the most human-intelligible pieces
from the input text as rationales, followed by a predictor that makes
predictions based on the selected rationales. However, such a cooperative game
may incur the degeneration problem where the predictor overfits to the
uninformative pieces generated by a not yet well-trained generator and in turn,
leads the generator to converge to a sub-optimal model that tends to select
senseless pieces. In this paper, we theoretically bridge degeneration with the
predictor's Lipschitz continuity. Then, we empirically propose a simple but
effective method named DR, which can naturally and flexibly restrain the
Lipschitz constant of the predictor, to address the problem of degeneration.
The main idea of DR is to decouple the generator and predictor to allocate them
with asymmetric learning rates. A series of experiments conducted on two widely
used benchmarks have verified the effectiveness of the proposed method. Codes:
\href{https://github.com/jugechengzi/Rationalization-DR}{https://github.com/jugechengzi/Rationalization-DR}. | [
-0.0243484229,
0.1013406143,
0.0062746922,
0.026222188,
0.0250975881,
0.0185695123,
-0.0000802179,
0.0146123935,
-0.0499899387,
0.0290162619,
0.0314622112,
-0.0039993906,
-0.014018462,
0.0277941003,
-0.0026953269,
-0.0881595165,
0.0402202196,
-0.0364889391,
0.0489890128,
-0.0474928729,
-0.0236781426,
-0.0157765057,
0.0102917897,
0.0095779495,
0.0565910451,
-0.0435440727,
-0.0108480295,
-0.0121473037,
0.0066183698,
0.0182185993,
-0.0305184387,
0.0030468584,
-0.0054752575,
0.0116366781,
0.0000023343,
-0.0352335386,
-0.0533611476,
-0.0315265544,
-0.0503075197,
-0.0165613182,
-0.0323302746,
-0.0348491073,
0.0136035904,
-0.0090721166,
-0.0560302474,
0.0701723322,
0.0181770865,
0.0338002965,
0.0576743633,
0.0468869284,
0.0139022404,
-0.047097709,
0.0205421839,
-0.012150825,
-0.0478822961,
-0.0222417358,
-0.0387243405,
0.0344003253,
-0.0418619961,
0.0134653049,
-0.034782961,
0.0117689418,
0.0543328337,
-0.0239282176,
0.0695509017,
0.0486095846,
0.0502250008,
-0.0149459969,
0.0212703403,
0.0557512604,
-0.0621234253,
-0.0414572321,
0.0252881628,
-0.0245589502,
0.0059079984,
0.0256404635,
-0.0355741903,
0.0162885562,
-0.0142304963,
0.0653492212,
0.0276886597,
0.0177617371,
0.0437925346,
0.0219202694,
-0.0126299066,
0.0260554776,
-0.0340985097,
-0.0083214352,
0.0153458742,
-0.0078005437,
-0.0760650039,
-0.0472646691,
-0.0032522979,
0.0601391979,
-0.0512579381,
-0.0019489331,
-0.0266705826,
0.0107999686,
-0.0151417851,
-0.0316210724,
-0.031108059,
-0.0309840348,
0.0868364573,
0.0316056758,
-0.0021495475,
0.0197698157,
0.0125694601,
0.0696039423,
-0.0302331988,
0.0437540859,
-0.0256064404,
-0.0341849849,
-0.0590365976,
0.058902435,
-0.0482405126,
0.0065853284,
-0.0475881584,
-0.0180775095,
-0.0795074105,
0.026028892,
0.0090462565,
0.0289535392,
-0.0253161658,
-0.0351038016,
-0.0435463563,
0.0156652741,
-0.0895127058,
-0.0087432293,
0.0191748794,
-0.0033113046,
-0.0112349503,
-0.0147796581,
-0.0283426512,
-0.0070948396,
-0.0261649434,
0.0415468439,
-0.0506660268,
0.034197133,
-0.0662848577,
-0.0480830632,
-0.0015367528,
-0.0611611009,
-0.0037677039,
-0.0180521589,
-0.0192559622,
-0.0240715742,
-0.0071305558,
-0.1089913622,
-0.0421351679,
-0.0320549831,
0.0015380641,
0.1052149758,
-0.0452484414,
-0.0094963079,
0.0195924304,
0.0371730775,
-0.0483465753,
0.1102662235,
0.023076782,
0.0210893992,
0.0522372127,
-0.0219054315,
-0.0133529026,
-0.0427462757,
0.0653361231,
0.0208023004,
-0.0459210724,
0.0005618356,
-0.0224875826,
0.0419091024,
0.0568267629,
0.0307369828,
-0.0495245196,
-0.0396412574,
0.0160786938,
0.0509859063,
0.0376982167,
0.0741536617,
0.0110404529,
0.0385634899,
-0.0432566628,
0.0783900097,
-0.0427947342,
0.0314330086,
-0.0098783085,
0.0047927955,
0.0022627015,
0.0140890889,
-0.053139355,
-0.0860351846,
0.0618402921,
-0.0341477431,
0.0367532708,
-0.0242909007,
0.0430239029,
0.0166157782,
-0.010141422,
0.006059133,
0.0001730006,
-0.0397422574,
0.0414703153,
-0.0410276875,
0.0669513792,
0.0186882019,
0.0063057975,
-0.0613555908,
-0.0054099318,
-0.0148599427,
-0.0118068177,
-0.016886469,
0.0355135426,
-0.0291369297,
0.0371359922,
-0.0357028171,
-0.0220646057,
-0.028960593,
0.0180044062,
-0.0218026973,
-0.0411094204,
0.0069469931,
-0.009700045,
-0.0371305235,
0.0430055298,
0.032685183,
-0.0301097594,
-0.0340890549,
-0.0158260986,
0.0100901853,
0.0405124091,
0.0466183797,
0.016879892,
-0.001450671,
0.0200916249,
-0.0239012428,
-0.0573052093,
0.053714674,
-0.069115445,
-0.0333002135,
0.0350377485,
-0.0174165312,
-0.0227727145,
0.0128416074,
-0.0201104581,
-0.0428524986,
0.0999363214,
-0.0004711013,
-0.0062006246,
-0.0282951482,
0.013150217,
-0.0139629142,
-0.0082082842,
-0.0126131922,
0.0650675073,
0.019200027,
-0.0077125048,
-0.0070916647,
0.0113133043,
-0.0044911732,
-0.0495966375,
0.0398011692,
0.0577795878,
-0.0216218755,
0.0201101229,
0.0047304616,
-0.0368334427,
-0.0200117938,
-0.0155045157,
0.0194749143,
-0.0252043903,
-0.0246524774,
0.0027857549,
0.0094153555,
-0.0385165736,
0.0364879109,
0.0057522277,
0.0146111976,
-0.0136165088,
0.0198831856,
-0.0097699128,
0.0427109525,
0.000523387,
0.0364964977,
0.0029039399,
-0.0391058587,
0.0235474389,
0.0308514014,
0.0172119569,
0.0268949252,
-0.0623148344,
0.0006550674,
-0.0200726949,
0.0345132202,
-0.0230402034,
-0.0288102496,
0.001587961,
0.0051382887,
-0.0136470282,
0.1158076823,
0.0117515409,
0.0456562713,
0.0240479615,
0.0179159213,
-0.0307502132,
-0.0020788549,
-0.0451850034,
0.0469948687,
-0.0445240885,
-0.0271651298,
0.0302671026,
0.0593368299,
-0.0268531144,
-0.0094705401,
-0.0779826194,
0.0770455375,
-0.0117111597,
-0.0430962257,
-0.0283854455,
-0.055445876,
0.0089954911,
0.0316440128,
-0.0410279967,
-0.0530527309,
0.0784471631,
-0.0044720359,
0.0231373589,
-0.0170296337,
-0.0195377506,
-0.0005830106,
0.0383572653,
-0.0141180307,
-0.0016912707,
0.0564284995,
-0.0026047011,
-0.0307528041,
-0.0612364784,
0.0589159653,
-0.0014379114,
0.081566669,
-0.0596151277,
-0.0002476653,
0.0053573535,
-0.0609480962,
-0.0088978345,
-0.0337481312,
0.0114820376,
0.0360640883,
0.0213631354,
-0.0202038847,
0.0135818738,
-0.001931529,
-0.0003453255,
0.0089093577,
-0.006088593,
0.0026495515,
-0.0010938394,
0.0226513706,
0.0424333885,
0.0484987833,
0.0216248184,
-0.061942175,
0.1057258472,
0.0538254678,
0.0316870064,
-0.0606699958,
-0.0409785956,
0.0050958809,
-0.0255822111,
-0.0177002512,
-0.0245476458,
-0.0133168325,
0.085741125,
-0.0031039189,
-0.0094167171,
0.0729147419,
-0.0391205847,
-0.0118564907,
0.0016413159,
-0.0193575881,
0.0708587691,
-0.0040478092,
-0.0087273745,
0.0095380945,
-0.0244570393,
0.0215535332,
0.0729010478,
0.040550746,
-0.0436197817,
0.0109505849,
-0.0785432085,
0.0420397967,
0.0221880637,
-0.0038802032,
-0.0082170861,
-0.0245395731,
-0.0333795324,
-0.0610287078,
-0.0330160074,
0.0269732084,
-0.0080692219,
0.0286633633,
0.0189766623,
-0.0242351498,
0.0489295423,
-0.0536981858,
-0.0294057876,
0.0377762094,
-0.0028649529,
0.0448215492,
0.0056416756,
-0.0477441736,
-0.0256678071,
-0.0275327638,
-0.0216625743,
-0.0202263836,
0.0464002378,
0.019488655,
0.0389301106,
0.0206289962,
0.0779412985,
0.027706556,
-0.0180870295,
-0.0154171987,
0.0404908918,
-0.0131415194,
-0.0498876795,
0.0053261155,
0.0295614991,
-0.0292323064,
0.0443012789,
0.0143845119,
-0.0090353535,
-0.1000477672,
-0.0122213764,
0.0275447331,
-0.0791439191,
0.0109953424,
-0.0266710036,
-0.0081570894,
0.0036672472,
-0.0458375067,
0.0083025806,
-0.0640955269,
0.0887665525,
-0.0236732252,
0.0441933237,
0.00509689,
-0.0089150015,
-0.0047391453,
0.0047126887,
0.0002702544,
-0.0177676119,
0.0052938964,
0.0189834181,
-0.0311885942,
-0.0793382823,
-0.0243141707,
-0.0058217496,
0.0330285281,
-0.0622297004,
0.0002906927,
0.0248235613,
0.0343594886,
0.0598817952,
-0.0143264327,
-0.0706214532,
0.0113644842,
-0.0036260569,
-0.0333499163,
0.0227612704,
0.064100489,
0.0263548903,
0.0071203336,
0.0577010289,
0.0130961873,
0.0287186056,
-0.0040054251,
0.0238815751,
-0.0773691088,
0.0080889864,
-0.007233059,
-0.0081103919,
0.0135406516,
-0.0016518992,
0.0163204651,
-0.0368384309,
0.0002021154,
0.0156786572,
0.0298481751,
-0.0366391987,
0.0234825891,
0.0025342396,
-0.0391956195,
0.0119090816,
-0.0406427756,
0.0107201086,
-0.0065698731,
-0.0067853671,
0.0177013222,
-0.0031665955,
0.020393895,
0.0042403336,
0.0146240965,
0.0382797904,
0.0058329199,
-0.0159949567,
0.0415041596,
0.0088637145,
0.0342839547,
0.0492232405,
0.0310389046,
-0.0131516922,
-0.0193440206,
-0.0852579549,
-0.0791020393,
0.0115088997,
-0.0166751109,
0.0293777343,
0.0182072744,
0.0456130989,
0.0116259539,
-0.0046803998,
0.0289707556,
0.0535390452,
0.0312697813,
-0.0462419689,
0.0029524483,
0.0186940115,
-0.0365678817,
-0.0061734854,
0.0660078526,
-0.0157380179,
-0.0053944788,
-0.0321203806,
0.0085434401,
-0.0448706187,
-0.0560908206,
-0.0209039524,
0.0285891443,
-0.0013090925,
-0.0062282202,
-0.026835531,
-0.0589133762,
0.0031641887,
0.0421277098,
0.0084479637,
-0.0035257244,
0.023916468,
0.0049802405,
-0.0592624359,
-0.0276862197,
-0.0264120605,
0.0677933246,
-0.0408754721,
0.0189187583,
-0.0049434644,
-6.488866937e-33,
-0.0171196163,
-0.0307587609,
-0.0079316581,
-0.0144495238,
-0.035176903,
-0.0024832936,
-0.0149709322,
-0.0007479262,
-0.0262250286,
0.0311659947,
-0.0315471403,
0.0198689029,
0.0112361936,
0.01978557,
-0.0299939569,
-0.0205752645,
0.058287967,
-0.0223192312,
-0.0242430307,
0.0142609002,
0.0296262316,
-0.0004031994,
0.0101444181,
-0.0581408665,
0.009470528,
0.0036825081,
-0.0425993018,
0.0808688924,
0.017823467,
0.0190420691,
-0.0041071405,
0.0020891575,
0.0080247549,
-0.0610202402,
-0.0230440907,
0.0392263979,
-0.1060738862,
-0.0209907908,
-0.0059258938,
-0.0345725343,
-0.0658414587,
-0.035458263,
0.0549427904,
0.0275423434,
-0.0053068092,
-0.0216207337,
0.0180632863,
-0.0110182101,
-0.0346968956,
0.009985893,
-0.004741034,
0.0562948063,
-0.0619995147,
0.0225149617,
0.0433043353,
0.0094343247,
0.0006102991,
0.0236909166,
-0.0238578394,
-0.0007154498,
0.0398765914,
0.0187437646,
0.0634984225,
-0.0168632381,
0.0115554919,
0.1042453647,
0.0382996984,
-0.0022319332,
-0.0605943128,
-0.0399631672,
-0.0266480576,
0.0440869443,
0.0721010715,
-0.000056288,
0.0575594269,
-0.0166969076,
-0.0431420766,
0.0159433559,
-0.016546499,
0.0395674743,
0.0284048636,
0.0540800914,
-0.0160298701,
-0.0146362353,
-0.0273858719,
-0.0381826907,
0.0010001921,
-0.0285270941,
-0.0182367135,
0.0150276534,
-0.0452750213,
-0.0203672256,
-0.0142801609,
-0.0437508412,
0.0579889826,
0.0318437852,
0.0086463848,
0.0140946405,
0.018503068,
-0.0041124602,
-0.0312210768,
-0.0248036124,
-0.0379194543,
0.0559651963,
-0.0006805568,
0.011038919,
0.0173632894,
-0.0148956403,
-0.0086788107,
0.0116644735,
-0.0271117538,
0.0443007387,
0.0017635091,
0.0460953787,
0.0410095938,
0.0075831488,
-0.0181788616,
0.0084281322,
0.0022867834,
0.0277675055,
-0.0059694592,
-0.0120027922,
0.0106076114,
0.0306720883,
0.003172107,
-0.0329966098,
0.0077736704,
0.0158162415,
0.0171060767,
-0.0746107548,
-0.020180814,
0.0292545706,
2.977e-7,
0.0035728361,
-0.0047217165,
0.0198570415,
-0.0516927987,
0.0164417382,
0.0314064659,
0.012060089,
-0.0358610637,
-0.025759913,
-0.0157705508,
0.0093965484,
0.043929711,
0.0478279851,
0.0552310124,
-0.04073897,
-0.0275548492,
-0.0536107644,
0.0048715589,
0.0146474689,
-0.0206294116,
0.0376793519,
0.0160487238,
0.0007584176,
-0.0335590616,
0.0364757851,
0.0000643122,
0.0206880271,
-0.0179010946,
0.0429710783,
0.0294499341,
0.063547574,
-0.0340390205,
-0.0131459376,
-0.019221019,
-0.0100849094,
0.0105610667,
-0.0244672988,
0.0703172535,
-0.0069377404,
-0.0382591188,
-0.0173512716,
-0.0443287976,
0.0274622198,
-0.0545255728,
0.0523194857,
-0.0245949309,
-0.032661844,
0.0037333714,
-0.0525208935,
-0.0443403348,
0.0196143407,
0.0004929327,
-0.0082765631,
0.0237719398,
-0.0142597612,
0.0004931352,
-0.0026617383,
-0.0766315088,
-0.0368107334,
-0.0090523809,
-0.0529604629,
0.0124969846,
0.0072144861,
0.0312418528,
0.0372690745,
-0.0561425909,
-0.0030352187,
2.493394103e-34,
0.0725342706,
-0.0149915451,
0.0191680416,
-0.0163927432,
0.0314112678,
0.0060059996,
0.0290207174,
-0.0151605755,
0.0652624369,
0.0078957751,
0.0023685158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13592v2 | Understanding Programs by Exploiting (Fuzzing) Test Cases | 2023-05-23T01:51:46 | 2023-06-12T00:56:21 | Jianyu Zhao, Yuyang Rong, Yiwen Guo, Yifeng He, Hao Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SE | Semantic understanding of programs has attracted great attention in the
community. Inspired by recent successes of large language models (LLMs) in
natural language understanding, tremendous progress has been made by treating
programming language as another sort of natural language and training LLMs on
corpora of program code. However, programs are essentially different from texts
after all, in a sense that they are normally heavily structured and
syntax-strict. In particular, programs and their basic units (i.e., functions
and subroutines) are designed to demonstrate a variety of behaviors and/or
provide possible outputs, given different inputs. The relationship between
inputs and possible outputs/behaviors represents the functions/subroutines and
profiles the program as a whole. Therefore, we propose to incorporate such a
relationship into learning, for achieving a deeper semantic understanding of
programs. To obtain inputs that are representative enough to trigger the
execution of most part of the code, we resort to fuzz testing and propose fuzz
tuning to boost the performance of program understanding and code
representation learning, given a pre-trained LLM. The effectiveness of the
proposed method is verified on two program understanding tasks including code
clone detection and code classification, and it outperforms current
state-of-the-arts by large margins. Code is available at
https://github.com/rabbitjy/FuzzTuning. | [
-0.0116518931,
-0.005964349,
-0.0383633003,
0.0481939539,
-0.0126472535,
0.0075272899,
-0.0362752974,
0.0209082589,
-0.0024112612,
-0.0429152586,
0.0074838893,
0.0223402325,
0.0107645132,
0.0452870354,
0.0183560569,
0.0017420381,
0.07619147,
-0.0250173695,
-0.0318786912,
0.0203870907,
-0.0218059756,
0.0275107045,
0.0151569936,
0.0259714387,
0.0102915047,
-0.0112020755,
-0.0181609206,
0.0739514977,
-0.0089879753,
0.0130659863,
-0.0392512567,
-0.0223920867,
0.0222372487,
0.0302907377,
0.0000024663,
-0.0327843316,
-0.0310338642,
0.0191911068,
-0.0291342456,
0.0505366549,
0.0164494235,
0.013260914,
0.0157705825,
0.0197489932,
-0.0080066379,
0.0138100255,
0.0303111915,
-0.0369691141,
0.0528931916,
0.0674984604,
0.0306303296,
-0.0189703126,
0.0013011,
0.0404858328,
0.0607873984,
-0.0144598568,
-0.0368269086,
0.0335507691,
0.0311639421,
-0.0052497592,
0.002581652,
-0.0032511954,
-0.0021535843,
0.0324371308,
-0.0205075014,
0.0359328762,
-0.0174319353,
-0.0078348741,
0.0119809862,
-0.0003657622,
-0.1178482398,
-0.0700700358,
0.0412900746,
-0.0252162162,
-0.0260600112,
-0.0186606776,
0.0011154012,
0.0196062326,
0.0101765068,
-0.0111321826,
0.0478640161,
0.0193254855,
0.021425711,
-0.035399083,
-0.0452200547,
0.0740846395,
-0.0215975158,
-0.0184938572,
-0.0219422039,
-0.0482108183,
0.0134882405,
-0.0504978113,
-0.0419959649,
0.0682462379,
-0.0209234096,
0.002386081,
-0.0452640019,
-0.035899803,
0.0448738784,
-0.0205962267,
-0.0101733664,
0.0416355692,
-0.0102396831,
-0.0020444449,
-0.0335389972,
0.0452347659,
0.0295117218,
0.0101253064,
-0.0191546585,
0.0576819479,
-0.0575175136,
-0.0099957837,
-0.0355045311,
0.0837147012,
0.0175994989,
0.0460035466,
-0.0103460168,
0.017188644,
0.0211642478,
0.079047285,
-0.0848869085,
-0.0168364216,
-0.029837897,
0.0473842099,
0.0172125697,
-0.0461433418,
-0.0430154726,
-0.0713068098,
-0.0767656937,
-0.030549245,
-0.0221168417,
0.001707844,
-0.0647556856,
-0.0293608084,
0.0211312752,
0.0638368651,
0.0384316742,
0.0004994062,
-0.0494983383,
-0.0805168748,
0.0469610617,
-0.008585385,
-0.0012570104,
-0.0812092498,
-0.0728607699,
0.0015559125,
0.0440404862,
0.0020566084,
-0.0064056669,
-0.040880546,
-0.0023942795,
0.0770385787,
-0.0173790734,
-0.0175419878,
-0.0012731433,
0.0317538641,
0.063215673,
0.0162172988,
-0.0193835162,
-0.0009503005,
0.0075873588,
-0.0328068137,
0.0099074058,
-0.0159764867,
0.0072483006,
-0.0031294853,
0.0106095709,
0.0275182389,
-0.0041702604,
-0.0165661369,
0.0373751856,
0.0114469854,
-0.0187874101,
-0.0197470076,
-0.0422300473,
0.0221164227,
-0.0402345061,
0.0337044224,
0.0815799162,
0.0705666244,
-0.0127803273,
0.0381143391,
-0.0516075939,
0.0133701069,
-0.0278967991,
0.0225282628,
-0.0296687316,
0.0101751024,
-0.0419319831,
-0.0340506434,
-0.0031496789,
-0.030496547,
-0.0063355826,
-0.036966607,
0.0039153765,
0.0214231033,
-0.0119557604,
0.0306351427,
0.0304841474,
-0.000890688,
-0.0396341011,
-0.0626060218,
0.009435189,
0.007242843,
0.0417891331,
-0.0818361044,
0.0082939444,
0.0214379076,
-0.0738744661,
-0.0539491922,
0.0128291762,
-0.0259343535,
0.0127503825,
-0.0152731938,
0.0197992902,
-0.0598075539,
0.0214716662,
0.0212867539,
-0.0295492839,
-0.0447002165,
0.0605779514,
-0.0324478783,
-0.0368496962,
0.0249075666,
0.0119568286,
-0.0520656481,
-0.011716689,
0.0210779328,
0.0032514718,
-0.0351870283,
-0.0640635714,
0.0188851748,
0.0409091711,
-0.0065448987,
0.0299209822,
-0.0428830348,
-0.0119371405,
-0.0000714921,
0.0147543596,
-0.021958774,
-0.0304150824,
0.03427637,
-0.0587877594,
-0.0180675276,
0.0648758337,
-0.0744879246,
0.0307295378,
0.0337655097,
0.0182878114,
-0.0008609236,
-0.0035598299,
-0.0360223278,
0.0694341958,
0.0188048538,
-0.0036660254,
-0.0145405307,
0.0428585969,
0.0383609384,
0.0193408672,
-0.0370387845,
-0.033089865,
-0.0472372286,
0.0068536517,
-0.0317995511,
0.0112521295,
-0.0370217562,
0.0162506308,
-0.0396062881,
0.0319779962,
-0.0042301174,
0.0328094997,
0.0221562665,
0.0094224904,
0.0232654568,
-0.0432635248,
0.0016182062,
-0.0224578604,
0.0079770554,
-0.0349390209,
0.0461927243,
-0.0016256745,
-0.0726648718,
-0.0131045999,
0.0174727291,
-0.0673591495,
0.0491928048,
-0.0207917951,
-0.0136749055,
-0.0613108911,
0.0941325054,
0.0037083973,
-0.0013874189,
-0.0216271281,
-0.0330987163,
0.0136948619,
-0.0038274333,
-0.0229852777,
0.0807721838,
-0.0062780506,
0.0171396714,
0.0312141925,
0.0047009462,
-0.0680130571,
0.0003496334,
0.0552435182,
-0.0304975063,
-0.014474513,
-0.0255983397,
0.0295074098,
0.0497267395,
0.0152193671,
-0.0058962307,
0.0025814301,
0.0489071719,
0.0095822327,
0.0177446883,
-0.00177364,
-0.0578194559,
0.0152388969,
0.0165429227,
-0.0099106235,
-0.0645704269,
0.0699096546,
-0.0570631959,
0.0142143536,
-0.0341939591,
-0.0218804739,
-0.0227253437,
0.0669934228,
-0.0000222082,
0.0224776901,
0.0076962123,
-0.0450583994,
-0.006158845,
-0.0132399891,
-0.0051672426,
-0.0388215892,
0.0469806269,
-0.0423386954,
-0.0223078355,
0.002348531,
-0.03421418,
-0.025997363,
-0.0260519274,
0.0094239274,
0.0066788686,
0.0125377225,
0.0090512699,
0.0189659931,
0.0109764924,
0.0081933206,
0.020818023,
0.0504781269,
-0.0301701259,
-0.0182429403,
-0.0465934537,
-0.0350250416,
-0.051848121,
0.0036464666,
-0.0109268334,
-0.0369278155,
0.0007788677,
0.0323913768,
0.0203808509,
-0.0461564548,
0.0005489865,
-0.0139670642,
-0.0631479174,
-0.0503567569,
0.0411363728,
0.0561494268,
-0.0455452949,
-0.0663721412,
0.0443336926,
0.0508713983,
-0.0017133823,
0.0676795468,
0.0014032013,
0.0274922587,
0.0626994222,
0.0735278875,
-0.0609536208,
-0.0487965457,
-0.0179122463,
0.0151962442,
-0.0197163019,
0.0156659298,
0.0058712163,
-0.1195694953,
-0.0137773044,
0.0065619275,
-0.0053236349,
-0.067181088,
-0.0086926175,
-0.0451266095,
0.0340580903,
-0.0490572415,
0.0180848688,
-0.0328754336,
0.0160175823,
0.0092476495,
-0.0034775953,
-0.0104284026,
0.0774213001,
-0.0044541368,
0.0274942033,
0.0558872521,
-0.0104027838,
-0.0202123821,
0.0210160762,
0.0535199568,
-0.039356377,
0.0527380034,
-0.0154265445,
0.0339169055,
0.0141057521,
0.0056456286,
0.0539386645,
0.0153553998,
-0.011959576,
-0.0133942552,
0.0148931053,
-0.0083226394,
-0.0582631007,
-0.0169032011,
-0.0156471524,
-0.0056040161,
-0.0014424671,
0.0109463092,
0.0946566314,
0.0005673424,
-0.0271419454,
-0.0485676713,
-0.0079618134,
-0.0138795106,
-0.0582424812,
-0.0111408299,
-0.0251733847,
0.003977119,
0.0025298179,
0.046785064,
-0.0038640362,
0.0093339235,
0.0320567265,
-0.0715935528,
-0.0072738701,
0.0055344105,
-0.0587571934,
0.0255655739,
0.0052668438,
0.0261909235,
-0.0273990873,
-0.0128475036,
-0.0045566075,
-0.0220561139,
-0.0490513258,
0.0367088057,
-0.1136152893,
-0.0256241541,
-0.0178568158,
0.0838609263,
0.0243411399,
0.0477396473,
-0.0455606356,
-0.0421706624,
-0.0042712325,
0.0416447222,
-0.0270026885,
0.0145248072,
0.0180923361,
-0.0492955893,
0.0250245836,
-0.0122787775,
-0.0205141418,
0.0310694315,
0.0219099838,
-0.0717905685,
-0.0554398969,
0.0224707369,
0.0302802809,
0.0665454492,
0.0749235004,
0.0715023354,
0.0080130529,
0.0404247716,
0.0341050439,
0.0273149312,
-0.0312325433,
0.0047970363,
0.0290438253,
0.0037058829,
-0.0213749204,
0.0307568591,
-0.0754095018,
-0.0534509718,
0.042432677,
0.0377121344,
0.0232674181,
0.003627873,
0.0443179868,
0.049026642,
-0.0258036815,
-0.018438777,
0.0305451956,
0.0185754802,
0.0779400617,
0.0192840286,
0.0062396158,
0.0249804426,
0.0847669095,
-0.0373640098,
0.0174152907,
-0.0377912261,
-0.0507684909,
-0.0039485595,
-0.0350615978,
-0.0039972714,
-0.0219758153,
0.0072791772,
0.025492765,
0.0479359962,
-0.0131699014,
0.0548591912,
-0.0209502447,
-0.0534033626,
0.0064275279,
0.0343347043,
-0.0311556812,
-0.0612084344,
0.0423485935,
-0.0108128535,
-0.001857451,
0.0135677904,
0.016494222,
-0.0427334309,
0.0175323989,
0.0107813179,
0.0104133403,
-0.0251569767,
0.0004031846,
-0.0514864549,
-0.0515725166,
-0.0230066646,
0.063189663,
0.0631959587,
0.0224921592,
0.0153026506,
0.0814330429,
0.0284866188,
-0.0026530987,
-0.0092742611,
-0.0101095177,
0.016289873,
-0.0548613742,
0.0054599242,
-5.99858257e-33,
-0.0321540013,
-0.0289571881,
-0.0365002118,
0.0106011676,
0.0121348836,
0.0154272271,
-0.059035223,
0.0089564044,
0.0024418302,
-0.0519359633,
0.0056954231,
-0.0011256584,
-0.0020695049,
-0.0527218804,
-0.0129007651,
-0.0042127343,
0.0194909442,
0.0540241934,
-0.0788265169,
0.0302390549,
0.0218457915,
0.0041410322,
0.01827549,
-0.0338509679,
-0.0381890237,
-0.0404435359,
0.0092736064,
0.0019409724,
-0.0174165238,
0.0740114897,
0.0245094616,
-0.0108008636,
-0.0035820929,
0.0064374898,
-0.0201717708,
-0.0454614908,
-0.0195790473,
-0.0564801171,
0.0327698141,
-0.0240474734,
0.0289125573,
-0.0396806523,
0.0662779585,
0.015045369,
0.0228289794,
0.0443206877,
0.050613936,
0.0230225176,
0.01263854,
-0.018453246,
-0.0378920138,
0.0155951213,
-0.0674853176,
-0.0037565127,
-0.010022887,
0.0261676759,
0.0117101166,
0.0430129431,
0.0023446046,
0.0025623462,
0.0136419972,
0.0606723055,
0.0557660684,
-0.0033898565,
-0.0037036857,
0.0332912169,
-0.0558420718,
0.0158023499,
-0.0287533775,
0.0316562317,
0.0620048344,
0.0114866812,
-0.0018702939,
0.001880188,
0.0788291022,
-0.0375471748,
-0.0259393845,
0.011969408,
0.036703147,
0.0294663329,
0.0290477648,
0.0180025809,
-0.0403780788,
0.0148453126,
-0.0448915027,
-0.004133597,
-0.0419718362,
-0.0150793828,
0.0231440123,
-0.0040048659,
-0.0514978953,
-0.0117911389,
0.0033106755,
-0.0362711735,
0.0213021506,
-0.0193977877,
-0.0238731746,
-0.0065408605,
-0.0491115414,
0.0148918312,
0.0179507863,
-0.1096937284,
0.0098830424,
-0.0428505577,
0.1121499613,
-0.0023882817,
0.0251894034,
0.0090527181,
-0.0233219769,
0.0252409559,
-0.0227093827,
-0.0207926203,
-0.0520922467,
0.0293416809,
-0.0032290341,
0.0305679534,
-0.0017050483,
0.003093573,
0.0037705745,
-0.0627707914,
-0.030879857,
0.040317338,
-0.0023174619,
0.0400402248,
-0.0432440303,
0.0028544464,
-0.0261897296,
0.0126119694,
0.0252835527,
-0.0460630171,
-0.0476594679,
0.0656013265,
3.196e-7,
0.0397343561,
0.0256212261,
0.0163994394,
0.053727828,
-0.0060788086,
0.0679030269,
-0.0320559256,
0.0513593405,
0.0088538621,
-0.0257340632,
-0.0227116365,
0.0005364905,
0.0131082237,
0.0267606247,
-0.05052118,
0.0178453736,
-0.0281442702,
0.0171702132,
-0.0711335987,
0.021911528,
0.0484013818,
0.0861388892,
0.0100313807,
-0.0096206265,
0.0570929758,
-0.026461035,
-0.0350180157,
0.0075524328,
0.0001903356,
0.0504888408,
-0.0729514807,
0.0155222444,
0.0014911602,
0.0091338335,
-0.040231254,
-0.0063226083,
-0.0381017067,
0.0602898635,
-0.0040934379,
0.0172072407,
0.0286153834,
-0.0362309143,
0.0362616703,
-0.0770003498,
0.028837949,
-0.0194862802,
-0.0044957208,
-0.0182771478,
-0.0228885822,
-0.0010394123,
0.0169677623,
-0.0085261157,
-0.0082049286,
0.040664129,
0.0053791427,
-0.0174180958,
-0.0145529918,
-0.0318345502,
-0.0492610931,
0.0183022469,
-0.0060702581,
0.0073057143,
-0.0166293755,
-0.0181662329,
0.0257439446,
-0.0090374304,
0.0204642825,
3.104180278e-34,
0.0516230203,
-0.0230050106,
0.0086940797,
-0.0355919227,
0.044488661,
-0.008328734,
-0.0530101806,
0.0354643799,
0.0055878325,
0.0269783363,
0.014583216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13589v1 | BiasX: "Thinking Slow" in Toxic Content Moderation with Explanations of Implied Social Biases | 2023-05-23T01:45:18 | 2023-05-23T01:45:18 | Yiming Zhang, Sravani Nanduri, Liwei Jiang, Tongshuang Wu, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL | Toxicity annotators and content moderators often default to mental shortcuts
when making decisions. This can lead to subtle toxicity being missed, and
seemingly toxic but harmless content being over-detected. We introduce BiasX, a
framework that enhances content moderation setups with free-text explanations
of statements' implied social biases, and explore its effectiveness through a
large-scale crowdsourced user study. We show that indeed, participants
substantially benefit from explanations for correctly identifying subtly
(non-)toxic content. The quality of explanations is critical: imperfect
machine-generated explanations (+2.4% on hard toxic examples) help less
compared to expert-written human explanations (+7.2%). Our results showcase the
promise of using free-text explanations to encourage more thoughtful toxicity
moderation. | [
0.064740099,
0.02361493,
-0.0303576291,
-0.019292891,
0.0208655968,
0.0146008329,
0.0457243584,
0.0069572623,
0.0248225033,
-0.0355020128,
-0.0004555188,
0.0559376366,
-0.0185880288,
0.0127258804,
0.0140254302,
-0.0454034582,
-0.0006339257,
0.0367982239,
0.0513025932,
0.0121423518,
0.07618431,
0.0103282984,
0.0129710268,
0.0442024805,
-0.0143631985,
0.0032762031,
0.040759977,
0.0344855301,
0.0445733219,
-0.0336058885,
0.0004849506,
0.0310335401,
-0.0097044175,
0.0150325317,
0.000001743,
-0.029753875,
0.0202609766,
0.0142238876,
-0.0202228967,
-0.0133104343,
0.054242257,
-0.005966695,
0.0249491315,
0.0460612178,
-0.0062815091,
0.0142058684,
0.058943633,
0.024991069,
0.0708280057,
0.0187002569,
-0.0334500112,
0.0302464589,
-0.0846122876,
0.0114044966,
0.0188450757,
0.0077095809,
0.0115413051,
-0.0523631759,
-0.0366213322,
0.007505028,
0.0134300236,
-0.0025574991,
0.0119457608,
-0.0395517796,
0.0178270265,
-0.0172092114,
0.0124798296,
-0.0647715777,
0.0217235368,
0.060355451,
0.0350666083,
-0.0452199727,
0.0215499736,
-0.0227694865,
0.0330189019,
0.0407703705,
-0.0476794541,
0.0033878842,
-0.0235002059,
-0.0197902434,
-0.0406834446,
0.0340217054,
0.0488480926,
0.0466420017,
0.1021759659,
-0.0054109986,
-0.0329187177,
-0.0181532763,
0.0054100659,
-0.0050381562,
0.0451784246,
-0.0052591586,
0.0444042273,
0.0131872771,
-0.0098277749,
-0.0108028352,
0.0085328287,
-0.0272499025,
0.0469514877,
-0.0716564283,
-0.0077563175,
0.0155809782,
-0.0388464481,
0.0526140295,
0.0231107213,
-0.037585143,
-0.0138069345,
0.0276842471,
0.0087450529,
0.0282474253,
0.0105249519,
0.0038808286,
-0.003912461,
-0.0407671519,
0.011784032,
0.0611111149,
0.0204921961,
-0.020733634,
-0.0758546069,
-0.002140926,
0.0153315281,
0.0325080603,
-0.0045136702,
0.0046142717,
-0.057208553,
0.019936258,
-0.099180378,
0.0207808502,
-0.009153544,
-0.0268300306,
-0.0260398984,
0.0251697917,
0.0082432749,
0.0036208327,
0.0162273664,
0.0518916696,
0.0557572357,
0.0376978666,
-0.0577719547,
-0.0416782089,
-0.0094591836,
-0.0087558338,
-0.0214274134,
-0.0278340038,
0.0241273772,
-0.0005677046,
-0.0191171914,
-0.0714552626,
0.0031036793,
0.0246356614,
-0.0234769061,
0.0486848988,
-0.0254266597,
-0.0165819637,
0.0340763964,
0.0530245006,
-0.0512161441,
0.057281673,
-0.0185088031,
0.0587880537,
0.0263113603,
-0.0093121827,
0.0107339984,
0.004340441,
0.0240835641,
-0.0012904743,
-0.0262561031,
0.0131223453,
-0.060135182,
-0.0083692586,
-0.0063087386,
0.0424328595,
-0.0144523382,
-0.000395299,
0.0642616376,
0.0146960057,
-0.0681815818,
0.0290498734,
0.0301115531,
0.0047932398,
-0.0236843098,
-0.027768312,
-0.0673747361,
0.0450819433,
-0.0155255599,
-0.0600824207,
-0.0026693388,
0.0520150997,
-0.0173884872,
-0.0516007505,
-0.0374590866,
0.0148807457,
0.0933193862,
-0.0090230433,
0.0048328377,
0.0381685384,
-0.0065794964,
-0.0008643268,
0.0689324439,
-0.0114543568,
0.0119205974,
-0.0340482071,
0.0606714413,
0.0564766824,
0.0128712701,
-0.0319135711,
0.0318267606,
-0.0661795065,
0.0491902195,
0.0135458205,
0.0466684438,
-0.0127424169,
-0.0618110225,
-0.0241862498,
-0.0405132547,
0.0088759465,
0.024894448,
-0.005775495,
0.041924879,
-0.0127705932,
-0.0072004893,
0.0045906133,
-0.047141891,
0.0291123036,
0.0711209103,
-0.0261110887,
-0.041847568,
0.0501480326,
0.0336016119,
0.0157850515,
0.001879739,
-0.0088759931,
-0.0154295601,
0.0101178326,
-0.0462703221,
-0.0051900381,
-0.0254072845,
0.0603282154,
0.0118253902,
-0.0685602278,
-0.0431270823,
0.0174746905,
0.0100817271,
0.0668366775,
0.004401674,
-0.017794868,
-0.0547554307,
-0.006941265,
-0.0651414394,
-0.0477818213,
-0.0191583894,
-0.0372830369,
0.0501260497,
-0.0008748439,
-0.0149318986,
0.0161759295,
-0.095753096,
-0.0187820867,
0.0253727268,
0.0065608793,
-0.0513207801,
-0.012259217,
-0.0174695402,
0.0060550398,
-0.0267189816,
-0.0384142511,
0.0173419192,
-0.028594872,
-0.0587282032,
-0.0366895832,
-0.0058322065,
0.0385362655,
-0.0096469522,
0.0139727024,
0.0094345482,
-0.0323808528,
-0.0332431793,
-0.0239292122,
0.0470549203,
0.0245871767,
-0.0179926101,
0.0007834518,
-0.032805834,
0.0025369513,
-0.0492707528,
0.0277150832,
0.0656403452,
-0.0195813905,
0.014928787,
-0.0161229409,
-0.0467824787,
-0.0450266078,
-0.0070351604,
-0.0542406365,
0.0182246994,
0.0226454269,
-0.0195920672,
0.0482779145,
0.0445075035,
0.0895586759,
0.0322781056,
0.0781571716,
-0.0191982519,
-0.0221375525,
-0.0161232147,
0.0069572846,
-0.0228580106,
-0.0417953469,
0.0152192162,
0.0470740758,
0.014144348,
0.005065822,
-0.0724888742,
0.0757199079,
-0.0656884164,
-0.0320859998,
0.0031999697,
-0.1020743772,
0.006396323,
0.009354624,
-0.0574797988,
-0.0283395573,
0.073153168,
0.0188466627,
0.0212712437,
0.0275706984,
-0.015780285,
-0.0212713704,
0.0185541864,
-0.0445700362,
0.0286267381,
0.0046943366,
0.0348729342,
0.002887601,
-0.0594522543,
0.1164081022,
-0.0282727126,
-0.0354165845,
-0.0394787751,
-0.0270927902,
0.0237285141,
-0.0185203794,
-0.0095530134,
-0.0708014816,
-0.0657973662,
-0.0411829799,
0.0482624136,
0.0070094066,
0.0043529533,
0.0147991963,
0.041378703,
-0.0285500903,
0.0187556148,
-0.0248106122,
0.0501115136,
-0.0488657169,
0.0018093069,
0.0221157819,
0.0634988695,
-0.0285634864,
0.0208252873,
0.0832451135,
-0.0314337462,
-0.0185120609,
-0.0133746751,
-0.0117075434,
-0.0199499503,
0.0169404391,
0.0474369042,
-0.0065087257,
0.0469512641,
-0.005345806,
0.0362304188,
0.0260540936,
-0.0057367976,
-0.0262062084,
-0.0001086912,
-0.0116046993,
0.0251197368,
0.0371232629,
-0.0127721606,
-0.0860958993,
-0.0264322124,
0.0011003471,
0.0487810969,
-0.0623481683,
-0.0525890552,
0.035132546,
-0.0560719073,
0.0162359364,
-0.0037201364,
-0.0144581525,
-0.0068844273,
-0.08065065,
-0.0050064116,
-0.0601173751,
-0.009390397,
-0.0262850672,
0.0502749309,
0.0050787381,
0.012878024,
-0.0433079191,
0.0106852204,
0.0013544011,
-0.0204104818,
0.0231942069,
-0.0057397094,
0.0196763799,
-0.0156858917,
-0.0159315504,
0.0641682744,
0.0221209973,
-0.0159163494,
-0.0161327049,
0.1005611792,
-0.0141642531,
-0.0105141364,
-0.0570669957,
0.0867691189,
0.0171622336,
-0.0107287178,
-0.0306151919,
0.0524717495,
0.0833462924,
-0.039303042,
-0.030373916,
0.0101821553,
0.0447934121,
0.0355891213,
0.0516639389,
-0.0542145781,
0.0263729598,
-0.0466932096,
-0.0036106044,
-0.0207993425,
-0.0880450085,
-0.0085569173,
0.0244919285,
-0.0379568078,
-0.0090898843,
-0.0087170675,
0.0438688844,
0.002348908,
0.0440817103,
-0.0634553283,
-0.0171046425,
0.0091654388,
0.0236812942,
0.0588451065,
0.0275695343,
0.0020029154,
0.0077218614,
-0.0267625526,
-0.0636989623,
-0.0047611971,
-0.0191675574,
0.0523341447,
-0.0186449643,
-0.0128685869,
0.0672114789,
0.0787779838,
0.0156192686,
-0.0028265691,
-0.0022907713,
-0.0553419814,
0.0317914113,
0.0778661594,
-0.0579221286,
-0.0327478088,
0.0309225023,
0.0147115514,
0.0305828322,
-0.0017840394,
-0.0307946112,
-0.0149514275,
0.0372133255,
-0.0373428054,
-0.055061128,
0.0307737626,
0.0249048658,
0.0107100196,
0.0214612726,
-0.0253455956,
0.0042951908,
-0.0186498687,
-0.0129397865,
0.0113499267,
-0.0340473354,
0.0246562529,
-0.0061093089,
0.0190950334,
-0.0623990707,
-0.0278871395,
0.0182456709,
-0.0253053792,
0.008635439,
-0.0351428427,
0.0292214267,
0.0461452864,
0.0096005974,
0.0224185884,
0.0124845635,
-0.0214843526,
0.0428076759,
-0.009804396,
0.0041336985,
0.0041924496,
0.014350256,
0.0267637782,
0.0203879513,
0.0292945057,
-0.0286201648,
-0.0047770813,
-0.0486302227,
0.0277503636,
0.0028463057,
-0.043642804,
-0.0221015085,
0.0177629851,
0.0348716043,
-0.0491986983,
0.0160106495,
0.0104340464,
-0.0162280072,
-0.0236458201,
0.0080398368,
0.028765507,
-0.0298700444,
-0.0091936998,
0.0063162581,
-0.0366424434,
0.0267322399,
-0.0052944059,
-0.0372169912,
0.0082067885,
-0.0071895234,
0.0117555698,
0.0381587073,
0.0001344083,
-0.0080750519,
-0.0980921686,
-0.0320977308,
-0.0267734099,
-0.012998187,
0.0255154409,
-0.0190846678,
-0.0168921519,
0.026028078,
0.0171549506,
-0.0032419837,
0.0136929294,
0.0236580893,
-0.0219431464,
-0.0037871734,
-0.0316939466,
-6.051474305e-33,
0.016266467,
-0.0672737062,
-0.0544494763,
0.0053863772,
0.0306977108,
-0.0243252441,
-0.002074016,
0.0200552978,
-0.0004883648,
0.0605439693,
0.002241638,
0.0077807154,
-0.0006987115,
-0.0368170291,
-0.0021195514,
-0.0532740206,
0.0531743653,
-0.0176624227,
-0.0494152196,
0.0238483902,
0.0025999458,
-0.0108535932,
-0.0266990941,
-0.0872190744,
0.0413532853,
-0.0014750753,
-0.0212694928,
0.0320680365,
-0.015666971,
0.0439956076,
0.0205280315,
0.0362576172,
0.0137236584,
-0.0107388645,
0.018675644,
0.0584910028,
-0.0670102984,
-0.0004566905,
0.0436714366,
-0.0438391306,
-0.0427231453,
-0.0096653244,
0.0592346638,
0.0122710867,
-0.0039439853,
-0.028954884,
0.0517869592,
-0.0019027514,
0.025253091,
-0.0440773852,
0.0017603858,
-0.0129013611,
-0.0596475117,
0.0157903433,
-0.022195071,
0.0376245342,
0.0154575408,
0.0496506393,
-0.0337090231,
-0.004221417,
-0.0364947841,
-0.0403065085,
-0.0023635463,
-0.0066603948,
-0.0003997977,
0.0487465113,
-0.0052283872,
0.1003668234,
-0.0829385594,
-0.0060355878,
-0.0193883553,
-0.0253866874,
0.0739286095,
0.0800148621,
0.0206032433,
-0.0923379883,
-0.0495263599,
-0.0050887447,
-0.0009979056,
0.0390120372,
0.0043045245,
-0.0430502295,
-0.064368695,
-0.0055265347,
-0.050292328,
-0.0704604313,
-0.0331595987,
-0.0228656027,
-0.0056970734,
0.0116899442,
-0.0790733397,
-0.0387023538,
-0.0339206718,
-0.0256312862,
0.0364280157,
0.0107608978,
0.041001372,
-0.0224757064,
0.0263012853,
-0.0356180035,
-0.0347204581,
0.0484511144,
-0.0326884054,
0.006330797,
0.0643127859,
-0.022604527,
0.0797872618,
0.0279405117,
-0.041560825,
0.0177880172,
-0.0268441904,
0.0426274687,
-0.0188509561,
0.0115907323,
-0.0023115603,
0.0405214056,
0.0104569225,
-0.0509177707,
0.045101475,
0.0622796007,
-0.001823783,
-0.0025695108,
-0.02966398,
0.0046884003,
-0.0082053393,
-0.0416991897,
0.0029321976,
-0.0088979667,
0.0378673449,
-0.0835724995,
0.0051179249,
-0.0478567891,
2.443e-7,
0.0321005993,
0.0334629044,
0.0211716816,
-0.0047421791,
0.0150974663,
0.0255168695,
0.050696779,
0.0233343672,
-0.0074418765,
-0.0464294106,
0.0105541153,
0.0608614422,
0.0218404029,
0.0408762135,
0.0113658533,
-0.0326777212,
-0.069588162,
0.0332083628,
-0.0357640572,
0.0172623526,
0.0156030608,
0.000306594,
0.0272484049,
0.0046642548,
-0.007914803,
-0.0118477475,
0.0331504755,
-0.0455668122,
0.0342751294,
0.0003297642,
0.0505887941,
-0.0132871261,
0.0101501625,
-0.0200613122,
0.0017304512,
-0.0419767313,
-0.0179018807,
0.0337635279,
0.0164266769,
-0.0203522649,
0.0044072266,
-0.0088643618,
0.0360816196,
-0.0388231464,
0.0428112112,
-0.0242683999,
-0.0258473065,
-0.0605137274,
-0.0309534557,
-0.0441930257,
0.0227612611,
0.0159438197,
-0.0212581977,
-0.0195722934,
-0.0235107783,
0.0148066264,
0.0336982459,
-0.0599248968,
-0.041694589,
-0.0208630115,
-0.0123384381,
-0.0563303307,
-0.0034252424,
0.0070177871,
0.0006265179,
0.0413894318,
0.0491511337,
1.749099549e-34,
0.0146447523,
-0.0319118686,
0.0248404313,
-0.0584423691,
0.0579629615,
0.0333919749,
0.0015022667,
-0.0390783101,
0.0357939415,
-0.0015302908,
0.001765499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13585v1 | Query Structure Modeling for Inductive Logical Reasoning Over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-05-23T01:25:29 | 2023-05-23T01:25:29 | Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Meng Han, Zhihao Fan, Haijun Shan, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Logical reasoning over incomplete knowledge graphs to answer complex logical
queries is a challenging task. With the emergence of new entities and relations
in constantly evolving KGs, inductive logical reasoning over KGs has become a
crucial problem. However, previous PLMs-based methods struggle to model the
logical structures of complex queries, which limits their ability to generalize
within the same structure. In this paper, we propose a structure-modeled
textual encoding framework for inductive logical reasoning over KGs. It encodes
linearized query structures and entities using pre-trained language models to
find answers. For structure modeling of complex queries, we design stepwise
instructions that implicitly prompt PLMs on the execution order of geometric
operations in each query. We further separately model different geometric
operations (i.e., projection, intersection, and union) on the representation
space using a pre-trained encoder with additional attention and maxout layers
to enhance structured modeling. We conduct experiments on two inductive logical
reasoning datasets and three transductive datasets. The results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method on logical reasoning over KGs in both inductive and
transductive settings. | [
0.0336416811,
0.0241772681,
-0.0159505941,
0.0280903447,
-0.0234299097,
0.0280299596,
-0.0389109328,
0.0026310028,
0.053764265,
-0.0121826436,
0.04278991,
0.0434234291,
-0.0166449342,
0.0384627841,
0.0210152958,
-0.029203793,
0.0261526164,
-0.0144805927,
0.013307686,
-0.0267810225,
-0.0200428274,
0.0234293845,
-0.0132565023,
-0.0106819952,
0.0031139867,
-0.024172226,
-0.0575169437,
0.0124887824,
-0.0122880675,
-0.0212287307,
-0.0418502428,
0.0214773696,
0.0340967588,
-0.0137177147,
0.0000018307,
-0.0254307464,
-0.0257430691,
0.0174939092,
-0.0650769025,
-0.0250155758,
-0.0489383303,
-0.0500595532,
0.0434301831,
-0.0149588315,
-0.0322706886,
-0.0283964798,
0.0330874734,
0.0377153531,
0.0752476305,
0.083337836,
-0.0115299635,
-0.0730497167,
-0.0027792274,
0.0029965586,
0.0471182838,
-0.0356058963,
0.018790178,
0.0300510749,
0.0067584575,
0.0238445476,
0.004998948,
0.011985478,
0.0298632663,
0.0081123905,
0.0234848484,
0.0090901051,
-0.0266727768,
0.007013171,
0.0073108729,
0.0827618912,
0.0085308012,
-0.0136400899,
-0.0004289973,
-0.0062759286,
-0.0053311577,
0.012350413,
-0.0261603054,
-0.0022181647,
-0.0266557913,
-0.0138352653,
-0.0106125101,
-0.0126070017,
0.0213348549,
-0.0260975864,
-0.0803769156,
0.09742935,
0.0046960418,
-0.032823652,
0.0147828683,
-0.0088002067,
0.0016502171,
-0.0449320823,
0.0150380647,
0.0657022297,
-0.0447482765,
0.0385678299,
-0.005626135,
0.0251596831,
-0.0107476506,
-0.0711066276,
0.0081697963,
0.047826115,
0.0336859375,
0.0699258447,
-0.0335226357,
0.0462847725,
-0.0036682175,
0.0760962442,
-0.0359989777,
-0.0113970339,
-0.0598651543,
-0.0130146192,
-0.0375380069,
0.0511607565,
-0.0137621202,
-0.0045020687,
-0.0054496638,
0.0646784157,
0.0211722162,
0.0465568155,
0.0220442861,
0.0151052903,
0.0098789185,
-0.0461519063,
-0.0661826804,
0.0165826846,
-0.0322981738,
-0.0103457319,
-0.0172055587,
0.0039157751,
-0.0250472426,
0.0051443153,
0.0373780765,
-0.0234271996,
-0.0197982378,
0.035817571,
0.0213173497,
0.0019287342,
-0.0654892921,
-0.073336184,
0.0343607217,
-0.0215351656,
0.0238732174,
-0.0295136087,
0.0883688256,
0.0161661152,
-0.0652718619,
-0.0378824733,
0.0014801938,
0.0317064412,
-0.0442893691,
0.0750512853,
0.0240605474,
0.0218700357,
-0.0198829621,
-0.0119436001,
-0.0372391306,
0.0623717047,
0.0150190732,
0.0245409328,
-0.0048940154,
-0.0099916635,
-0.0262449086,
0.0125441793,
0.0573146977,
-0.006043673,
-0.0172490571,
0.0638985038,
-0.0411943011,
0.0436563008,
-0.0496220849,
0.0300715957,
-0.0379020274,
-0.0256746504,
-0.0032151765,
-0.0060475236,
0.0063078455,
0.0051583936,
-0.0002885761,
-0.0045308853,
-0.0088292109,
0.012467904,
-0.0382698551,
0.0081686489,
-0.0526224002,
0.0050429562,
-0.0241904911,
-0.0168822613,
-0.021660151,
-0.0422036014,
-0.0003325758,
0.0164744239,
0.0329009257,
0.0443688631,
0.0959567726,
0.0235853884,
-0.0346861258,
0.0753135085,
-0.0072975308,
-0.0488582663,
0.0019183167,
0.017470276,
0.0050525446,
0.0456149578,
0.0566213652,
-0.0293660332,
-0.0280998517,
0.006779545,
0.0312305,
0.0002890179,
-0.0079432577,
-0.0193256568,
0.0048828949,
-0.039493598,
-0.057254307,
0.0073751789,
-0.034755379,
-0.008621457,
0.0247571412,
-0.01510935,
0.0280555207,
-0.0795761123,
0.0215220414,
0.0225451179,
-0.0194441229,
0.0071434882,
-0.0089329248,
0.0244877674,
-0.0001419463,
0.0114003075,
0.0256391615,
0.0363815352,
0.0440640152,
-0.024783561,
-0.0528439693,
-0.0020750389,
0.0031720726,
-0.0742607936,
0.053017728,
-0.0499964431,
-0.0396277085,
-0.0717567801,
-0.0707124621,
-0.027564669,
0.029092541,
-0.0361782238,
0.0488074683,
-0.0218747444,
-0.0406740494,
0.0149672749,
-0.0891461968,
-0.0409591608,
0.0973303095,
-0.0048185573,
-0.0138262073,
0.0058710799,
-0.0371283703,
0.0110749677,
-0.0218532346,
0.0161265656,
0.0005166053,
-0.0094325347,
-0.0192792937,
-0.0023545437,
-0.0271255989,
-0.0244651847,
0.0068223416,
-0.0497210324,
0.0020552159,
0.0099285915,
0.0089999717,
0.0021149297,
0.0204315744,
0.0230137277,
-0.0237610284,
-0.0457503088,
0.0132102501,
0.0107711162,
0.0274696276,
0.0208192039,
-0.0109703168,
-0.0003888888,
0.0325006843,
-0.0438071266,
-0.0459265485,
0.0664957017,
0.00333419,
-0.0137110362,
-0.0137003213,
0.0282760095,
-0.0418808572,
0.0118744532,
-0.0129406201,
0.02837703,
0.0145721016,
-0.0564801171,
-0.0215973798,
0.0521350056,
-0.0218185168,
0.0144248325,
0.0133329704,
-0.0348593928,
-0.0495595932,
0.0245962478,
-0.0514050871,
0.0090737874,
-0.0217501633,
-0.0262387395,
0.012421241,
0.0092807654,
0.0076681469,
-0.0024963359,
-0.0769850835,
-0.0004664849,
0.02288948,
0.0240015965,
-0.0439173803,
-0.0038729454,
0.0491342992,
0.0642450824,
-0.0192147736,
0.0162020288,
0.0814988092,
0.0222244188,
0.0110146618,
-0.0046323617,
0.0580441952,
-0.0507105887,
0.0644021705,
0.0360870808,
0.0234316196,
0.0004224283,
-0.0362886265,
-0.0403564274,
0.0311097726,
0.0461893752,
-0.0292762201,
0.0312298723,
-0.0074618128,
0.0265477225,
0.0135274725,
0.004484647,
-0.0517854467,
0.0249107052,
-0.005028015,
-0.0050236452,
-0.021465607,
0.0160700791,
-0.0079284776,
0.0230927709,
-0.0362362452,
-0.0290737413,
-0.0007656592,
-0.0037926857,
-0.0415656529,
-0.0288028754,
0.0153294289,
0.0355195925,
-0.0408573188,
-0.0147239733,
-0.0158962701,
0.0495217741,
-0.0053993291,
-0.0487859398,
-0.012247365,
0.0338753089,
-0.0010805083,
-0.0376541018,
0.0117495786,
0.008310793,
-0.0092929248,
-0.0615093336,
0.0093896482,
0.099518545,
0.0451293029,
0.0142931268,
-0.0338603146,
-0.0091150356,
0.0295819845,
0.0305115804,
0.0557301417,
-0.1170636863,
-0.0245347116,
0.0000040245,
0.0019990893,
0.0247711614,
-0.0586025417,
0.0096005471,
-0.1115369052,
0.009428856,
0.0324052386,
0.0149659701,
-0.0456869714,
-0.034464173,
-0.0338931903,
0.0049957321,
-0.0757550076,
0.0218474101,
0.012742403,
0.0071881795,
-0.0091703907,
-0.0062201745,
-0.0212079585,
-0.0130892741,
-0.0094943224,
-0.028238086,
0.0293848161,
0.0105935168,
0.0250610206,
-0.0750083253,
-0.0064304392,
0.0729936585,
-0.011211236,
-0.0309469216,
0.020331867,
0.0014082028,
0.0276963599,
-0.0069326912,
0.0216048136,
-0.0986981392,
-0.0110625951,
0.0297242627,
0.1116417199,
-0.046858605,
-0.0033443023,
-0.0329388492,
-0.0036334831,
-0.0189013164,
0.060131222,
0.0178613272,
0.0491205864,
-0.0553330444,
-0.0786434859,
0.027681848,
-0.042763453,
0.0099789808,
0.0624849573,
0.01617462,
0.022667814,
-0.0315961167,
-0.0155103514,
0.0656609535,
0.0050980109,
0.0126902163,
-0.0384723246,
0.072768189,
-0.0406956151,
-0.0861621648,
-0.0075821904,
-0.0238940995,
0.0094689867,
-0.0085182963,
0.0202217177,
-0.0184014626,
-0.008385892,
-0.0260251444,
-0.0102140885,
-0.0304476451,
-0.0572525598,
-0.0434370749,
0.0330156088,
0.011481666,
0.0470577441,
-0.0338990539,
-0.0071495315,
0.0406695269,
0.0124322055,
-0.0378590114,
-0.0243666768,
0.019967271,
-0.0365016833,
-0.0047899154,
0.0204002634,
-0.0366077013,
-0.0133951241,
-0.0092602242,
0.0625878796,
-0.0478687286,
-0.0315602757,
0.040735431,
0.0378143974,
0.0126973726,
0.0526872687,
-0.0027202743,
-0.0151205193,
0.0486315228,
-0.0503453016,
-0.024879057,
-0.0508255363,
0.0029077856,
0.0037119363,
-0.0220432151,
0.0293941051,
-0.0404006951,
-0.0123302694,
0.0303179547,
-0.0047549312,
-0.0084351907,
0.0323102027,
-0.0203215554,
0.0570278838,
-0.0244929139,
0.0007174499,
0.0298966728,
0.011705067,
0.0295939744,
-0.0335394144,
0.0452914201,
0.0568201803,
0.017449135,
-0.0655419976,
-0.0235674083,
-0.0371775776,
-0.0611684434,
0.0339526832,
-0.0286345333,
0.0179192349,
0.0289671104,
-0.0170390327,
-0.0043305182,
-0.0140535701,
0.0118212551,
0.0540944785,
0.0356972888,
-0.0247681029,
0.0460068993,
0.0258392114,
-0.0020766056,
-0.023934884,
0.0646390095,
0.0036687981,
0.0370421186,
-0.0266349223,
-0.0611632764,
-0.0368508548,
-0.0597704537,
-0.0293478258,
0.053286355,
-0.0096595706,
0.015838569,
-0.0358700901,
-0.062885955,
-0.0021744147,
-0.0056198249,
-0.0194921605,
0.0035267673,
0.0464795604,
0.0460602902,
0.0434462838,
-0.0548361056,
-0.0148875555,
0.0342300683,
-0.0665809959,
-0.0397153944,
0.013298451,
-5.478647459e-33,
-0.0220419783,
-0.014065301,
0.0512316003,
0.0161325652,
-0.0216909479,
-0.0367879644,
-0.0379585847,
-0.0237120967,
-0.0044017867,
0.004129583,
-0.0083381375,
0.0176584553,
-0.0026474327,
0.0331693776,
0.0188311879,
-0.0224927105,
0.0084803142,
-0.0033324386,
0.0110602472,
0.0040424536,
0.0175933577,
0.0110233268,
0.007411439,
-0.033723928,
0.011673375,
0.013512277,
0.0340936109,
0.054201331,
-0.0354378186,
0.0533493049,
0.0002219022,
0.0102382489,
0.021324344,
0.0011258028,
-0.007800322,
0.0032601831,
-0.1015979797,
-0.0400217474,
0.0143273976,
0.0232810806,
-0.0653865859,
-0.0218789726,
0.0538140908,
0.0043085013,
0.0748596787,
-0.0790873021,
0.0295828022,
-0.019730743,
-0.0512791947,
-0.016029112,
-0.0068243905,
0.0416909866,
-0.0280136261,
0.022354763,
0.0340749994,
0.0358220935,
0.0155531075,
0.0147415251,
-0.0420159847,
0.0177390985,
0.0128391292,
0.0008505666,
-0.0007208363,
0.0302453171,
0.0217492152,
0.0052048536,
-0.0003434842,
-0.0160880163,
-0.0766662434,
0.0772635415,
-0.0271503441,
0.0782980993,
-0.0002099555,
-0.0144949025,
-0.0085142385,
0.0152854072,
-0.1005324647,
0.011371444,
-0.0179162547,
0.0418392532,
-0.0059254896,
0.0233406499,
-0.0362543724,
-0.0451791957,
-0.038726043,
0.0080587445,
-0.0414180122,
-0.0259202365,
0.0141604068,
-0.0094146244,
-0.0074747121,
0.0080564814,
0.0141471913,
-0.0499704145,
-0.0231419001,
0.0297181346,
0.0265839919,
-0.0074730148,
0.0041117035,
0.0853269249,
-0.0074472018,
-0.006157876,
0.0139687555,
-0.0530368313,
0.0146678863,
0.0282705501,
0.0103937211,
0.0190398581,
-0.0108444812,
-0.0297034569,
-0.0449480005,
-0.0402446762,
-0.0305626858,
0.0238970686,
0.0415240787,
0.0770491809,
0.0163860284,
0.0342022814,
-0.0163305998,
-0.0007947884,
-0.0286862571,
0.0139406826,
0.0267813168,
0.0237033106,
-0.0089425351,
-0.0313720554,
-0.0336100049,
-0.0196357686,
0.0201933216,
-0.0518831015,
-0.0089708241,
0.050558906,
2.624e-7,
0.0534753539,
0.0339414887,
0.045120161,
0.1139203906,
0.0150879305,
0.0246375501,
0.0190527346,
0.0116172023,
0.0300527997,
-0.0427890942,
0.0412127897,
0.028274972,
-0.0028675161,
0.0404736213,
-0.0711685568,
-0.0160529315,
0.0086691966,
-0.0419263132,
-0.059382949,
0.0159877501,
0.121897921,
0.0219274275,
0.0285620801,
0.0257503986,
0.0099726561,
-0.0466545857,
0.055292245,
0.0468314774,
0.0154509582,
0.0119308466,
-0.0050738454,
-0.0042395252,
0.0003025108,
0.0732015967,
-0.0058486755,
0.03178991,
0.0165759921,
0.0507475883,
-0.0266717151,
-0.0214309972,
-0.0024512562,
-0.0494209751,
0.0178568903,
-0.0166706163,
0.1104724556,
-0.0599993132,
-0.0077849291,
0.0539743379,
-0.0310845803,
-0.0478248708,
-0.0276335999,
0.0238161124,
0.0064925323,
-0.0090915989,
0.0415532514,
-0.0201372337,
0.0431434587,
-0.0734704435,
0.0086116539,
-0.0118335979,
-0.0371840447,
0.018993035,
-0.012480516,
0.0290660914,
0.004280665,
0.0236524269,
-0.0074741538,
2.57221605e-34,
0.0206378195,
0.0071053957,
0.0003873299,
0.0034822302,
0.0681984499,
-0.0430729017,
-0.0090354867,
0.0068433583,
0.0302245375,
-0.1027418599,
-0.0199950784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13583v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13583v4 | Cross-Attention is Not Enough: Incongruity-Aware Dynamic Hierarchical Fusion for Multimodal Affect Recognition | 2023-05-23T01:24:15 | 2023-11-13T00:09:47 | Yaoting Wang, Yuanchao Li, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency, Peter Bell, Catherine Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS, eess.IV | Fusing multiple modalities has proven effective for multimodal information
processing. However, the incongruity between modalities poses a challenge for
multimodal fusion, especially in affect recognition. In this study, we first
analyze how the salient affective information in one modality can be affected
by the other, and demonstrate that inter-modal incongruity exists latently in
crossmodal attention. Based on this finding, we propose the Hierarchical
Crossmodal Transformer with Dynamic Modality Gating (HCT-DMG), a lightweight
incongruity-aware model, which dynamically chooses the primary modality in each
training batch and reduces fusion times by leveraging the learned hierarchy in
the latent space to alleviate incongruity. The experimental evaluation on five
benchmark datasets: CMU-MOSI, CMU-MOSEI, and IEMOCAP (sentiment and emotion),
where incongruity implicitly lies in hard samples, as well as UR-FUNNY (humour)
and MUStaRD (sarcasm), where incongruity is common, verifies the efficacy of
our approach, showing that HCT-DMG: 1) outperforms previous multimodal models
with a reduced size of approximately 0.8M parameters; 2) recognizes hard
samples where incongruity makes affect recognition difficult; 3) mitigates the
incongruity at the latent level in crossmodal attention. | [
0.0086892638,
0.0555034094,
-0.0212171413,
0.0254519396,
-0.0012789329,
0.0198433511,
0.0050324914,
-0.0230946243,
-0.0064080977,
-0.0627748147,
-0.0761326179,
-0.0184038952,
0.0195273589,
0.0213377923,
0.027686609,
-0.0790124014,
0.009283212,
0.0548304319,
-0.0080713071,
-0.0070391553,
0.0258184168,
0.0211431496,
-0.0080296705,
0.0463387631,
-0.0325851738,
-0.024629131,
-0.0142052332,
0.0455484912,
0.0618918389,
-0.0169552788,
0.0507036112,
0.0104039693,
-0.0036507959,
0.001470181,
0.0000021849,
0.0007153515,
0.0163354874,
-0.0112587651,
0.0413154662,
-0.0250606444,
0.0616029464,
-0.0176535584,
-0.0314766094,
0.0052036992,
0.003350348,
-0.0022170481,
0.0603090934,
0.067854777,
0.0354539119,
0.0360457227,
-0.0314465612,
-0.0056922827,
0.0270754211,
-0.0390355475,
0.035115499,
-0.0164468382,
0.003454824,
0.0085361535,
-0.0050369576,
-0.0506600663,
-0.0698348358,
-0.0025641997,
-0.0167324282,
0.0265492275,
0.0109048691,
0.0178463534,
0.0273661409,
0.006306014,
-0.0449138656,
0.0952175334,
-0.0632159114,
0.0189217795,
-0.0129496045,
-0.0108748227,
0.0197723284,
-0.0197219141,
-0.0119847441,
-0.0073272977,
-0.0152059561,
0.0209934805,
-0.0075558275,
0.0335544571,
0.0098241018,
-0.0128108757,
-0.011094505,
0.0142904762,
-0.0059081353,
-0.0091425851,
0.0000651422,
0.0084682209,
-0.0427788161,
-0.0315229334,
0.0134247998,
-0.021280393,
0.0078560533,
-0.0211375114,
-0.0597608648,
-0.0218110401,
-0.0072936374,
-0.0102606425,
0.0229039509,
0.0377628058,
-0.0770593733,
0.0557184331,
0.0364115052,
0.0298731215,
-0.0628189445,
0.023570314,
-0.0403407849,
-0.0283251759,
-0.0391748026,
0.0412301347,
0.0313501395,
0.0002436906,
-0.0479133315,
-0.066574201,
-0.0572954454,
0.0186505746,
-0.0513545424,
-0.0426729545,
-0.0278296936,
0.012899043,
-0.0214839336,
0.0046087289,
0.0020202217,
0.0633221269,
-0.000173221,
0.0502394252,
-0.024626568,
-0.0502139069,
-0.002781501,
0.0414768197,
-0.0024231814,
-0.0396048427,
0.0190065634,
0.087440066,
-0.0452056862,
-0.0267438404,
-0.0543741062,
-0.0132984947,
-0.050179027,
-0.0232706368,
0.0621528625,
0.0057999222,
0.0342619233,
-0.0319211744,
0.0229287036,
-0.0028715252,
-0.0127004301,
-0.0319423229,
-0.0088755032,
0.0732116029,
0.0199013855,
-0.025896227,
-0.0046633487,
-0.0082035149,
-0.0440395921,
0.0293185506,
0.0120237349,
0.0379278623,
0.0093095014,
0.0010940887,
-0.0115058012,
-0.0010009862,
-0.0113374274,
-0.0112454472,
-0.0300682876,
-0.0504304394,
-0.0272937492,
0.0236216336,
0.0963974819,
0.0306086279,
-0.0114645613,
-0.0296484884,
0.0489231236,
-0.0258881412,
0.020725701,
0.0266329311,
0.0019686674,
-0.0042462386,
-0.0486165769,
0.0244845953,
-0.0505870953,
0.0807380974,
-0.0647677854,
-0.0093466006,
0.0579705574,
0.0735218003,
-0.0197776649,
-0.0091979187,
-0.0055633127,
-0.0212981738,
0.0146246552,
0.0142054409,
0.0086392704,
-0.0106292311,
-0.0435178354,
0.0185958408,
0.0368238948,
-0.0388136804,
-0.0236430094,
-0.0018795878,
-0.0071939672,
0.0368788876,
0.0141723538,
-0.0369708985,
-0.0252913889,
-0.012964718,
0.0104727885,
0.0046369028,
-0.0466229729,
-0.0002209148,
0.0466163717,
-0.0488865227,
-0.0270259753,
-0.0320295841,
-0.0001310912,
0.0216570869,
-0.0617220625,
0.0443504229,
0.0004531617,
-0.0136120925,
0.0942825451,
-0.0089463992,
0.0032376566,
0.0200357661,
-0.0308449157,
0.0239005778,
0.0620851591,
-0.0151608074,
-0.0013832843,
-0.0068048155,
-0.0183541719,
-0.0409404933,
-0.0385967009,
0.0466287173,
-0.036178913,
-0.0372130983,
0.0495117269,
-0.0820256025,
-0.0020022013,
-0.0069705131,
-0.0425695702,
-0.0168722477,
0.0511681177,
-0.0392331816,
0.0207995325,
-0.0401639901,
0.0235602353,
0.0187236145,
0.0782145932,
0.00676117,
0.0499173291,
-0.0664177611,
-0.0157446992,
-0.004485318,
0.0045344904,
0.0133160325,
0.0256803278,
-0.0215040259,
0.0368915796,
0.0140160862,
0.0034575521,
-0.0508057848,
-0.0321691222,
-0.0444834009,
-0.0654011145,
-0.0999124274,
-0.0056717116,
0.0104850587,
-0.0271962471,
-0.010965257,
0.0382093415,
-0.0173319373,
-0.025666181,
-0.0215369482,
0.058165621,
-0.0178788733,
0.0341549441,
0.0051775551,
-0.0104137417,
0.0399557166,
-0.0635979325,
-0.0047938991,
-0.0216079485,
0.0449878573,
-0.0597379506,
-0.004375624,
0.0037126087,
-0.0523359962,
-0.0362593122,
0.0533646755,
-0.0066571068,
-0.0659624189,
0.0052180621,
-0.0036592542,
0.0688252524,
0.0522383898,
0.0235325359,
0.0220876858,
0.0273659825,
-0.0544190332,
-0.0059242533,
0.0598890334,
0.039662879,
0.0400610082,
0.0104317367,
-0.0163866077,
-0.0457598343,
0.0629711226,
0.0198228601,
0.0160262398,
-0.0548453107,
-0.0123154009,
0.0330169648,
-0.032813929,
0.0390908532,
0.0092281858,
-0.0267128944,
-0.0359578095,
-0.0350632332,
-0.0169535559,
0.0448445976,
-0.0106137516,
-0.0495274067,
-0.020914305,
0.0301322937,
-0.0111235008,
0.0160523653,
-0.0446130671,
0.0324518643,
-0.0061122994,
-0.0126948692,
-0.0560462736,
0.0001587664,
0.0106454259,
-0.0156157874,
0.074121289,
0.0201321319,
-0.0344049409,
-0.0112358071,
-0.0358105302,
0.0030029146,
-0.0675851107,
-0.0369643271,
-0.0295341499,
-0.0075182663,
-0.0023014322,
-0.0602494814,
-0.0251458697,
0.0339475386,
-0.0033430334,
0.0107540088,
-0.0271470584,
0.0206233375,
0.0486904047,
0.006663946,
0.0733176395,
0.0091616837,
-0.0075017856,
-0.0222104285,
0.0349450447,
0.0408377759,
-0.0077214707,
-0.0178492293,
0.0375051573,
0.0241930913,
0.0730138943,
-0.0445655808,
-0.0305230152,
0.046734944,
-0.0070376261,
0.0727550015,
0.053414654,
-0.0136145996,
-0.0644103065,
0.024408251,
-0.0007730551,
-0.0195019562,
0.0392510556,
-0.0134661375,
-0.0186713431,
-0.0765424669,
-0.0041741016,
-0.0016567806,
0.034174975,
0.0113763362,
0.0159313176,
-0.0705764666,
0.0122066047,
0.0222160351,
0.0063013057,
-0.0193054285,
0.0590652488,
0.043911919,
0.0107725104,
-0.0096305562,
-0.0439605936,
-0.0089013362,
-0.0166621041,
0.0186694935,
0.0384931415,
-0.0937059596,
0.0126513839,
-0.0088671017,
0.0376542993,
0.0083231889,
0.0748873278,
0.0230575949,
-0.0821951926,
0.0422722213,
-0.023848271,
0.0149741136,
-0.0090048993,
0.0275771618,
-0.0332205109,
-0.0293368977,
-0.0366668962,
0.0129011376,
-0.0146345217,
-0.0128447907,
-0.0735785663,
0.0811618343,
-0.0322148465,
0.0086476151,
-0.0781375989,
0.0341728367,
0.017475361,
-0.0016315607,
0.0059800991,
-0.0610574968,
0.004963893,
0.0149333496,
0.0344664119,
0.027857691,
0.0286116432,
0.0469663963,
0.0192145798,
-0.0483376905,
-0.0532248281,
-0.0451689363,
-0.0412936695,
0.0223826934,
-0.0236215461,
-0.0464419499,
-0.0846711844,
0.0274566449,
-0.0211490318,
0.0442234278,
0.0320397876,
0.0295814928,
-0.0078161061,
0.0367209651,
0.014444924,
-0.0313894637,
-0.0147094596,
0.0066093747,
-0.0289769098,
-0.0623135492,
-0.0081376033,
0.0122286687,
0.0012952951,
0.0175437704,
0.0258346461,
-0.0329485573,
0.0219971519,
0.0109233828,
0.0141455103,
0.0561700314,
0.0643009767,
0.0249957368,
-0.0092875352,
0.0289429724,
-0.0477409065,
0.0155844595,
0.0156981647,
0.0007873404,
0.0160246436,
-0.051322896,
-0.0162210744,
-0.0395375602,
0.0622951463,
-0.0153644048,
0.0030854926,
-0.017890228,
-0.0196521673,
0.0534106083,
0.0052687405,
-0.0601994917,
-0.0450585745,
0.0237392485,
-0.0030133377,
-0.0394941531,
-0.0057343091,
0.0124131804,
-0.0112571139,
-0.0214119367,
0.0328244418,
0.0541682728,
0.0159315206,
-0.0599884391,
0.0506667495,
0.0065669068,
-0.0115760854,
0.0018043617,
-0.0240876414,
-0.0213574357,
0.0757703558,
0.0100596529,
-0.0372098722,
-0.0360860676,
0.0564737692,
0.0172578245,
0.0803160518,
-0.0198820196,
0.0065240688,
0.0725522786,
-0.008703243,
0.0398987569,
0.0194217358,
0.0252390541,
-0.0125501109,
0.0230528004,
-0.0375109687,
-0.042794507,
0.0429227278,
-0.0191973578,
0.0016717043,
-0.0134881362,
0.0433402248,
-0.0657908171,
0.0124837589,
-0.0138668669,
0.0229595881,
-0.041868329,
0.0087224906,
0.0684240833,
0.0283108875,
0.0003009591,
0.0492572188,
-0.0328166708,
-0.0488301404,
0.0644779578,
-0.0203841459,
-0.0157466996,
0.0037267511,
0.0104227476,
0.053169407,
0.0192882903,
-0.0276894886,
-0.0305298138,
0.0047513307,
-0.0039076386,
0.018542055,
0.0161625948,
-6.56364748e-33,
-0.0237266179,
0.0212905165,
-0.0638055205,
-0.0281029604,
-0.0634171292,
0.0297174472,
-0.0374452248,
0.021587288,
-0.0064633293,
0.027113013,
0.0036835999,
0.0355365239,
-0.0005981519,
0.0195908099,
0.0439854525,
0.0169653036,
0.026556382,
0.0217788219,
-0.0008943883,
0.0156775098,
0.0548721962,
0.0222686604,
0.0747093335,
-0.1176861078,
-0.0301256105,
0.0245432034,
-0.055870872,
-0.0167643987,
0.0296190958,
0.0582192913,
-0.0172870085,
0.0564218871,
0.0105827283,
0.0572872087,
-0.0208199378,
0.0191819333,
-0.0239813011,
-0.008991044,
-0.0048526106,
0.006176244,
-0.0350651182,
-0.0657829121,
0.0503224954,
0.0080280965,
0.0162928887,
-0.0665202513,
0.0273038074,
-0.0129986536,
0.0365065672,
-0.0391045809,
-0.0570017472,
0.0093654133,
-0.0141335567,
-0.0135988081,
0.0039110184,
0.0377724618,
0.0670212582,
0.0397859029,
-0.0395595171,
0.0076102959,
-0.0664047077,
-0.018081706,
0.0322802998,
0.0118307425,
0.0076521537,
0.067271851,
0.0197402854,
-0.0074478872,
-0.0032401381,
0.0061480883,
0.019408254,
0.0327914804,
0.0222451594,
0.0830620602,
0.0397237875,
0.0078412201,
0.016984906,
0.032416027,
-0.0081648175,
0.0272540711,
0.0348436534,
0.0490111187,
-0.0088510169,
0.0385633036,
0.0405889787,
-0.0203908104,
-0.0428220406,
-0.0368948504,
0.0225218572,
0.0095448606,
0.0153416637,
0.0029725635,
0.0522935838,
-0.0024218678,
-0.0035743918,
0.0081248153,
-0.0053721783,
0.0717580169,
0.0138605805,
-0.0245020743,
-0.0040644733,
-0.0302649252,
0.0638724864,
-0.0233257655,
0.0440634154,
-0.0040086689,
-0.0088471342,
0.0558032058,
-0.0422107428,
-0.034608297,
0.0096205631,
0.0143578555,
-0.0185278989,
0.0300750379,
0.0142236259,
0.0175084844,
-0.0450535826,
-0.0162668787,
0.0021953678,
0.062374834,
-0.046513319,
-0.0441143848,
-0.002877027,
0.0488456488,
-0.0286442749,
0.0064153732,
-0.0293121748,
-0.1167034134,
-0.0122979702,
-0.0411234125,
-0.0279610977,
0.034910202,
3.062e-7,
-0.0081915036,
-0.0009057397,
-0.0037553455,
-0.0611335151,
0.0426527262,
0.054636199,
-0.0307806525,
0.0447326191,
0.0177944861,
-0.0436827578,
0.0314775258,
0.0073350985,
0.0535936244,
0.0018888408,
-0.0209235102,
0.0007208149,
0.0184009857,
0.0097220046,
-0.0021015292,
0.0015137004,
0.0518273003,
0.0892430991,
0.0276517048,
-0.0156981293,
0.0347727016,
-0.0165532026,
0.0549662448,
0.0127490275,
0.0018848958,
-0.0292848684,
0.0129740369,
-0.035154406,
-0.0169767309,
0.0032593186,
-0.0011849214,
-0.013893418,
0.0584169924,
-0.0037870049,
-0.0462800339,
-0.0763243958,
-0.0297371075,
0.0443464257,
-0.049478922,
-0.0232224166,
0.0361066163,
-0.0409495421,
-0.0325871147,
-0.0600365959,
-0.0362496637,
0.0004556153,
0.0580750331,
-0.0123448903,
-0.0451440103,
0.0069693993,
0.0168350805,
0.0054063387,
-0.0392490737,
-0.1044856459,
-0.0071940767,
0.052506391,
-0.0655808821,
-0.0127941435,
-0.0138096791,
0.0029485009,
0.0646787137,
-0.0098837102,
-0.0386183225,
2.350341491e-34,
0.0132549899,
-0.0298231393,
0.042814441,
-0.0364002474,
0.0044738874,
-0.0041893367,
-0.0688689575,
-0.0448171385,
0.0167985745,
-0.0463838838,
-0.0143207451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13582v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13582v3 | Translation and Fusion Improves Zero-shot Cross-lingual Information Extraction | 2023-05-23T01:23:22 | 2024-06-20T14:42:34 | Yang Chen, Vedaant Shah, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) combined with instruction tuning have shown
significant progress in information extraction (IE) tasks, exhibiting strong
generalization capabilities to unseen datasets by following annotation
guidelines. However, their applicability to low-resource languages remains
limited due to lack of both labeled data for fine-tuning, and unlabeled text
for pre-training. In this paper, we propose TransFusion, a framework in which
models are fine-tuned to use English translations of low-resource language
data, enabling more precise predictions through annotation fusion. Based on
TransFusion, we introduce GoLLIE-TF, a cross-lingual instruction-tuned LLM for
IE tasks, designed to close the performance gap between high and low-resource
languages. Our experiments across twelve multilingual IE datasets spanning 50
languages demonstrate that GoLLIE-TF achieves better zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer over the base model. In addition, we show that TransFusion
significantly improves low-resource language named entity recognition when
applied to proprietary models such as GPT-4 (+5 F1) with a prompting approach,
or fine-tuning different language models including decoder-only (+14 F1) and
encoder-only (+13 F1) architectures. | [
0.0149262063,
0.0311313998,
0.0482950211,
0.0726016536,
-0.0109294523,
0.0578738339,
-0.01011997,
-0.0129394494,
-0.0078828661,
-0.0402040221,
-0.0691962689,
-0.0227953754,
-0.0143084405,
-0.0307932738,
0.0241898522,
-0.01551414,
0.0276879072,
-0.0138680832,
-0.0208309684,
0.0194722824,
-0.0324544162,
0.0272269137,
0.0085715549,
-0.0080952579,
0.0191415306,
0.0185991656,
0.0059852903,
0.0283616446,
0.0664871037,
-0.0134666385,
-0.0220304541,
0.0208813418,
0.0062562684,
0.0732177347,
0.0000019438,
-0.0293162148,
-0.0410210341,
0.0203841254,
-0.0322229825,
-0.0042095981,
0.0268913098,
-0.0763791203,
-0.0433743447,
-0.0047899815,
0.0023205287,
-0.0851516202,
0.0632163063,
0.0419051945,
0.0190458465,
0.0940287709,
-0.0204601027,
-0.0482132882,
0.0508924238,
-0.0352960303,
0.0241367202,
-0.0651792809,
0.025338497,
-0.031300284,
0.000554919,
0.0292630326,
0.0101750931,
0.0388684347,
0.0182905495,
0.0231391024,
-0.003160266,
0.0574689843,
-0.0641098842,
-0.0301466845,
-0.0050713611,
0.0702374354,
-0.0360920094,
0.0099373553,
-0.001340074,
-0.0013364423,
-0.0237312485,
-0.0586049929,
-0.0205859784,
0.0139921913,
-0.010539066,
0.0254731532,
0.0670675114,
0.0007880612,
0.0350496806,
0.015675649,
-0.0426004119,
0.013701532,
0.0217705183,
-0.0141821448,
0.0365185626,
0.0464791134,
-0.0261453073,
-0.0360067077,
-0.0140065383,
0.0191143248,
0.0417184234,
0.0049938746,
-0.0351305641,
-0.0062668025,
-0.0037279697,
-0.0491950624,
-0.0047015124,
0.0593441501,
-0.025878232,
0.070648171,
-0.0649078116,
0.0210714117,
-0.048761081,
0.0391866714,
-0.0282598734,
-0.0685763583,
-0.0578468479,
0.0412944257,
-0.0193775371,
0.0123102339,
-0.0711351112,
-0.0020829488,
-0.0184448529,
0.021619048,
0.0319826156,
0.0143282721,
0.0272543319,
-0.0446747281,
-0.0255713817,
-0.0170054976,
0.001088448,
0.0587858707,
-0.0088634966,
-0.0199005529,
-0.0072062332,
-0.0875151157,
-0.0287459679,
-0.0075895842,
0.0112171834,
-0.0781636089,
0.037190333,
0.0903243423,
-0.0262619872,
-0.0822640061,
-0.0700025484,
0.0144280689,
0.017580444,
-0.0903321356,
0.018199224,
-0.0266249776,
0.0677676126,
0.0108087687,
0.0286512431,
-0.034148179,
0.0296511166,
-0.0114234015,
-0.0516369529,
0.083837904,
-0.0257309079,
-0.035855148,
0.0020921882,
-0.00804797,
0.0234350059,
0.0966713354,
0.0217163842,
-0.0016206189,
0.0199758653,
0.0058513759,
-0.0207159314,
0.056790825,
0.0190626159,
0.0347014517,
0.0012829844,
-0.0002474934,
0.0285908151,
-0.0265077483,
0.0563451499,
0.0157233644,
-0.0236529242,
0.0069752051,
0.0187339224,
0.0034981994,
-0.003051847,
0.0235782843,
0.0468573049,
-0.0158130527,
-0.0226819143,
-0.0043309173,
-0.0268352497,
0.0202374924,
-0.0096990429,
0.0105609931,
0.0454671495,
0.05834236,
-0.0428180397,
0.0111555662,
-0.0037730797,
-0.0252148695,
0.0078678178,
0.0188779049,
0.0661273524,
-0.0030985826,
-0.0539663397,
0.0354856215,
0.0564004332,
-0.0399020165,
0.0212515518,
-0.00754681,
-0.02275699,
0.0603758097,
0.0218232665,
-0.0128005082,
-0.0140147507,
-0.0076510441,
0.013052565,
0.0340539068,
0.0412088372,
-0.0090937242,
0.0623850264,
-0.042599503,
-0.0263743158,
0.0042968192,
0.0033476893,
0.0351525322,
-0.0085537015,
0.0318096764,
0.0248655789,
-0.0228165202,
-0.0449950285,
0.02298446,
-0.0698139071,
-0.0649801865,
0.0319851972,
0.0180833992,
0.0088390717,
0.0265290979,
-0.0167091619,
-0.0117432997,
0.0332595892,
-0.0475973636,
0.0017407459,
-0.014895997,
-0.0017130998,
-0.044453416,
-0.0043924055,
-0.0059288489,
0.00120409,
-0.0343684554,
-0.0432349816,
-0.045782268,
-0.0312567726,
0.0196087472,
0.0545903854,
-0.0312271137,
0.0292954668,
0.0204044562,
0.0152766062,
-0.0102094747,
0.0477542356,
-0.0004348689,
0.0128279245,
0.0060137934,
-0.0306662433,
0.0073517878,
-0.014317234,
-0.0252959076,
0.0519559346,
0.0156198516,
-0.0198334418,
0.007153458,
0.0340572074,
-0.0159920231,
-0.0219275914,
-0.1218836233,
0.037217889,
-0.0097713266,
0.0556208044,
0.0148520116,
0.0530853532,
-0.0154927392,
-0.0143297231,
-0.0126489373,
-0.0200629253,
-0.0200788733,
0.03147012,
0.0169000346,
0.0364098437,
0.0251084063,
-0.0072327168,
-0.001367316,
-0.0006364456,
0.0177068412,
-0.0008665,
-0.0252599269,
-0.0372659005,
0.0190325547,
-0.0298384055,
0.0359183252,
0.0177309047,
-0.0257481039,
-0.0336627662,
0.004979304,
0.0200564191,
0.0532928891,
-0.0366229862,
-0.0153907835,
-0.0010189749,
-0.0395768061,
-0.036944937,
0.045435939,
-0.0089232726,
-0.0313769132,
-0.028602941,
-0.0248087589,
-0.0288379062,
0.074839063,
-0.0408357792,
0.0090030301,
-0.0628773272,
-0.0248482432,
-0.0044823401,
-0.0088745393,
-0.0068029263,
0.0435314514,
0.0098475097,
0.0195959788,
-0.047993619,
-0.0009089817,
0.0642691031,
-0.0509250797,
-0.0342831798,
-0.0362876914,
0.0028217882,
-0.0548850782,
0.0077899117,
-0.0104312375,
0.0208538864,
0.0091093015,
-0.0294268653,
0.002616849,
0.0240742452,
-0.0017139296,
-0.0168685243,
0.0386360362,
-0.0261754636,
0.0176534168,
-0.0387275517,
-0.0199926384,
-0.0221542101,
-0.0115597751,
-0.033825621,
0.0220325813,
0.0061806664,
-0.0283737127,
-0.0474711284,
0.0098966425,
0.0512346923,
0.0913936421,
-0.0174832828,
-0.0132769775,
-0.0201446675,
0.0398183651,
-0.0048996741,
-0.0294983946,
-0.0166420024,
-0.0256856363,
0.0173365753,
0.0200521704,
0.0163028091,
-0.0153785944,
0.0166964028,
0.0019518583,
0.0306272525,
-0.0117034232,
-0.0365217403,
-0.0317889564,
0.0727469772,
-0.0435143597,
-0.0153686395,
0.1035227701,
-0.0027242494,
-0.0476350747,
-0.0407003909,
-0.0009554062,
0.0108826859,
0.0228634384,
0.0233560652,
-0.1039287448,
-0.0551872812,
0.0090751387,
0.0018775733,
0.0080174981,
-0.0286433566,
-0.0137880547,
-0.1303833723,
-0.0007638265,
0.0226645917,
-0.0645191967,
-0.0210329369,
-0.0709481537,
-0.0054051927,
-0.042860277,
0.0034749315,
-0.0332338363,
-0.0088910433,
-0.0154721355,
0.0139800394,
0.0451156273,
-0.0742263794,
0.0146159614,
-0.0201935191,
0.0167887602,
0.0454367436,
0.0365389064,
-0.0088878274,
-0.0163559951,
0.0242030434,
-0.0653023198,
-0.0391563922,
-0.0335326605,
0.0741199255,
-0.0397798307,
-0.0237346962,
0.0325528495,
-0.0051290328,
-0.0234517399,
0.0075950841,
-0.0035390013,
0.0772289038,
0.0314808302,
0.0397779234,
0.0351537466,
-0.0725381449,
0.0213597938,
0.0697328299,
-0.0028084756,
-0.0166544206,
-0.0033549285,
0.0139821703,
-0.0147846006,
-0.0637086034,
-0.0203209072,
0.0202601496,
-0.075129278,
-0.0869912207,
-0.0317284502,
-0.067560643,
0.0334737524,
0.0153969759,
0.0207808409,
0.0114820814,
-0.0218200944,
0.0143385204,
-0.0157642663,
0.0337959491,
-0.0388988256,
0.0097408891,
-0.077623941,
0.0019409681,
0.0095806299,
-0.0035793078,
-0.0092750276,
0.0208638012,
-0.0362767428,
-0.0654838532,
-0.0542309918,
0.0174920764,
0.0066951369,
0.0496243611,
-0.0173914172,
-0.0083438195,
0.0073930058,
0.0147985043,
-0.0455318056,
-0.015039253,
0.0561594665,
-0.0109677771,
-0.0056504072,
0.0403383821,
-0.0290725697,
0.0281422362,
0.026856523,
0.0136547713,
-0.0450677536,
-0.0192160606,
0.0045728609,
0.0155218309,
0.0536100119,
-0.0378537141,
-0.0126187354,
-0.0282636285,
0.0287695751,
-0.0255236235,
0.0178163219,
-0.035582833,
-0.0124610616,
0.0718061998,
-0.021977907,
0.0105098449,
0.0667676032,
-0.0081783701,
0.014462715,
-0.0518208444,
0.013784715,
-0.0045196307,
0.0538681932,
0.005562169,
0.0030497119,
-0.0148289436,
0.018442288,
0.041947037,
0.0471078306,
-0.0706285834,
0.0273908563,
0.0119021796,
0.0079549756,
0.0234213285,
0.0309340004,
-0.0152901802,
0.0166565161,
-0.0249862429,
0.0300037861,
0.0709880739,
-0.0247846358,
0.0965925083,
0.0170338899,
-0.0311340876,
-0.0249874946,
0.0037190274,
-0.022350505,
-0.0028913978,
-0.0176988989,
0.0140591189,
-0.0090464931,
0.0029770944,
0.0586244799,
0.0124238022,
0.0448641032,
0.0033736706,
0.0153619014,
-0.0321423449,
0.0071501178,
0.0271937344,
-0.0132876718,
-0.0212222952,
0.0300802831,
-0.0294053182,
-0.0495889857,
0.0097632846,
-0.03017403,
-0.0475529619,
0.0184547324,
0.0003962951,
0.0278523862,
-0.0102839908,
-0.0345771201,
-0.0504412167,
0.0010829242,
0.0380296372,
0.0007327879,
0.0258609708,
-6.53161232e-33,
-0.0309308805,
0.0479460433,
0.0230650213,
0.0105068916,
-0.0193268359,
0.0255431943,
-0.0337068811,
-0.0228063799,
-0.0294035915,
-0.0150111569,
-0.01445763,
-0.0263393484,
0.0444729514,
0.032248769,
0.0012086931,
-0.0158729218,
0.0312327091,
0.0359840021,
-0.029858524,
0.048539076,
0.0591257215,
0.0398483127,
0.1113958806,
-0.0501743071,
0.0398437493,
-0.0173833333,
0.0070765363,
0.0250642225,
0.0734786615,
0.0301153827,
-0.0228784923,
0.0037879681,
0.0130542535,
-0.059337467,
0.0099996887,
0.0157871488,
-0.1390393972,
0.0006652672,
0.0016200298,
0.0196250696,
-0.0248761475,
-0.0722254664,
-0.0083456431,
0.0010534674,
0.0337546058,
-0.0263295565,
0.0094981948,
-0.0381047018,
-0.0016420336,
-0.0065944004,
-0.0882612988,
0.0419386812,
0.0244413707,
-0.0113027422,
0.0886921585,
0.0599189363,
0.0398473255,
0.003646838,
-0.0736276656,
-0.0175345913,
0.0010132138,
0.024067454,
0.0371897519,
0.0248140581,
-0.0209852662,
0.0204322971,
-0.0020443199,
-0.037862502,
-0.0010888318,
0.0161340851,
0.0224181898,
0.020085644,
-0.0228469018,
0.035156101,
0.0240463801,
-0.0032950123,
-0.0898359343,
0.0212466903,
0.0036282907,
0.0168114416,
-0.0048725498,
-0.0078796316,
-0.0519673266,
0.0159185305,
0.0005887302,
-0.0527993515,
-0.0357046165,
-0.0160500817,
0.0047848602,
0.0190990437,
-0.0421591587,
0.0463026464,
0.0685622171,
0.0002126537,
-0.0296862405,
0.0371563062,
0.024725968,
0.0096351225,
-0.0172595158,
0.0163080078,
-0.0836926848,
-0.055222515,
0.0155954631,
-0.0066269408,
0.0096626729,
-0.0014972292,
0.0741580725,
0.0091773821,
-0.0628677458,
-0.0152317481,
-0.0604459122,
0.0470757373,
-0.0171172265,
0.0515831672,
-0.0026547255,
0.0193087962,
-0.0035942574,
0.0448399112,
0.0342950895,
0.0121607892,
-0.0098127089,
-0.0199214295,
0.0320538916,
0.0227604695,
0.0068894429,
0.0136287902,
-0.0075753257,
0.0126986848,
0.0026552307,
-0.0421709158,
-0.0135736587,
0.0204309206,
2.719e-7,
0.0465062559,
0.0002532587,
0.0155527508,
-0.0158713162,
-0.027781073,
0.0294350553,
-0.0254419129,
0.0301839169,
0.0133389765,
-0.0403533205,
-0.0091392417,
0.0337236971,
0.0486877151,
0.0436886474,
-0.0750882775,
-0.0065669813,
-0.012401267,
-0.0024585812,
-0.0512536392,
0.0070629613,
0.0080913194,
0.1018839926,
0.0123556536,
-0.0137879727,
-0.0072951019,
0.0085450253,
0.0721375346,
0.0008198211,
-0.0297029149,
0.0342805311,
-0.0060685463,
0.0894398019,
-0.0259148851,
0.0323552936,
-0.0421705171,
0.0154968826,
0.0040811906,
0.06949386,
-0.0253095869,
-0.031508632,
0.0177063234,
-0.0296048149,
-0.022543475,
-0.0207906142,
0.1053898782,
-0.0397181585,
-0.0003744462,
0.0350526273,
-0.0040422399,
0.0301351324,
0.0390017107,
0.0003913488,
-0.051582478,
0.0522581227,
0.0546354912,
-0.0124693662,
-0.0599533841,
-0.0499759577,
0.0212716311,
0.013076839,
0.0051281066,
-0.014621648,
-0.0049299183,
-0.0024729318,
-0.0185179673,
-0.0385416187,
0.0096618067,
2.476762694e-34,
-0.0184642188,
-0.0025752727,
-0.0050084786,
0.0252930447,
0.00871279,
-0.0196959805,
-0.0574150234,
-0.0028442617,
-0.0274221804,
-0.0388445556,
0.0162274912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13571v1 | Latent Positional Information is in the Self-Attention Variance of Transformer Language Models Without Positional Embeddings | 2023-05-23T01:03:40 | 2023-05-23T01:03:40 | Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Li-Wei Chen, Alexander I. Rudnicky, Peter J. Ramadge | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of positional embeddings in transformer language models is widely
accepted. However, recent research has called into question the necessity of
such embeddings. We further extend this inquiry by demonstrating that a
randomly initialized and frozen transformer language model, devoid of
positional embeddings, inherently encodes strong positional information through
the shrinkage of self-attention variance. To quantify this variance, we derive
the underlying distribution of each step within a transformer layer. Through
empirical validation using a fully pretrained model, we show that the variance
shrinkage effect still persists after extensive gradient updates. Our findings
serve to justify the decision to discard positional embeddings and thus
facilitate more efficient pretraining of transformer language models. | [
-0.0139083462,
0.0545918494,
-0.0139196087,
0.0356522836,
0.0347900726,
-0.0149350232,
0.0132969115,
-0.0280784555,
-0.0681954548,
-0.0003056361,
-0.0607329234,
-0.0490910374,
0.0396214724,
-0.0048984136,
0.0600333959,
-0.0318004191,
0.0132134771,
-0.0339150541,
-0.033757668,
-0.0123009207,
-0.0225513224,
-0.0340822376,
0.0143851032,
0.0528566279,
-0.0135821169,
-0.0178007577,
-0.0194277558,
0.0163621474,
0.0382975303,
0.0028597855,
-0.0114431893,
0.0796986073,
0.0188883953,
0.039611984,
0.0000018446,
0.0078061023,
0.0338974893,
-0.0145169841,
-0.0172857605,
0.0290676225,
-0.0049023167,
-0.0471634604,
-0.0380298272,
0.0015825883,
-0.0001900742,
-0.0612085834,
0.0755681843,
0.0238578692,
0.0258756094,
0.0409172475,
-0.0089965323,
-0.0322566815,
-0.0072260816,
-0.0683325008,
0.0029176523,
-0.0184898637,
0.0035432018,
-0.0379685797,
-0.0499096699,
0.0427363515,
-0.0641608238,
0.0548194423,
0.0320246257,
0.0034812787,
-0.0113506801,
0.0777839497,
-0.0096873408,
-0.0220199898,
-0.0090283984,
0.0445258059,
-0.0657524988,
-0.0546512231,
-0.0315359086,
0.0134127019,
0.0227540396,
-0.0055817971,
-0.0322322398,
0.0581337214,
0.0533315912,
0.0126393167,
-0.0131235952,
0.0247294251,
0.0207326394,
-0.0375635959,
-0.0523407049,
0.0316011906,
0.0148684913,
-0.0459257104,
-0.0514740236,
0.0101558929,
-0.0263734329,
-0.0285347756,
-0.0162523706,
0.0087651489,
0.0460960157,
0.0019656224,
-0.0468197241,
-0.0363935307,
-0.0129578784,
-0.0169279203,
0.075928174,
0.0302230231,
-0.0360717662,
0.0248645563,
-0.0212997105,
0.0754968524,
-0.0623290613,
0.0023380376,
-0.0427302644,
0.014788134,
0.0381586105,
-0.0227368306,
-0.0564310774,
-0.0192142352,
-0.0155477542,
-0.0247188751,
-0.0116051957,
0.0518463962,
0.0099622337,
-0.027329091,
0.0169414952,
0.0384220071,
-0.0609634072,
-0.0031370292,
0.028118033,
0.0395959355,
0.0085596517,
0.0027794829,
-0.00572612,
-0.0427409895,
-0.0728924498,
0.0385968983,
0.0220452007,
-0.0168022141,
-0.0304345042,
0.031000182,
0.0000940809,
-0.0496944264,
0.0235197321,
0.0506304801,
-0.0401544608,
-0.0455706157,
0.0308797453,
-0.043829523,
-0.0073127509,
0.0099579385,
0.0120205879,
-0.0379722305,
0.0037516332,
0.0170842838,
-0.0229603145,
0.0454238169,
0.0403240547,
0.0180813596,
-0.0051091705,
-0.0108322026,
0.0417821743,
0.0476532318,
0.0485761575,
0.0265578665,
0.0019813669,
-0.0503273234,
0.0123297879,
0.0263251849,
0.0428182222,
0.0040613771,
-0.0125386938,
-0.0350039341,
-0.0136703337,
0.0087898457,
0.0691303238,
0.0553762354,
-0.0193309393,
-0.0357113294,
0.1104698479,
0.0866068974,
0.0221934654,
0.0313024223,
0.0318591334,
0.0156600494,
-0.0191449188,
0.0127269858,
-0.0580173247,
0.0597082153,
0.011519081,
0.0108026639,
0.0070508528,
0.0423467383,
-0.0532543845,
-0.0281135067,
-0.0133637283,
-0.0170236081,
0.0116929114,
-0.0097616706,
0.0340511277,
0.0338322967,
-0.0367170386,
0.1213017851,
-0.0077241431,
-0.0392543189,
-0.0129886083,
-0.0071887891,
-0.0118111763,
0.0055272263,
-0.0114218602,
0.0095342081,
-0.0157583505,
-0.009767063,
0.046081312,
0.0304832924,
0.0252051186,
0.0497795567,
0.0217518881,
-0.0268436763,
-0.0216531046,
-0.0236438848,
0.0211989265,
0.0197857749,
0.0053592678,
-0.0077450755,
0.026678279,
-0.0304413401,
0.0139857335,
0.0284669492,
-0.0272987969,
-0.0150819058,
-0.0130910538,
0.0071722995,
0.0019718951,
-0.0206451602,
-0.0180466417,
0.0376220867,
0.0479441732,
-0.0258062594,
0.019406382,
0.0373060815,
-0.0557763875,
-0.01146321,
0.0127981156,
-0.009094933,
0.0033034154,
0.0375718661,
-0.0049636192,
-0.0379508398,
0.0507966466,
-0.0369289443,
0.0087711383,
-0.0094666248,
0.0297458433,
0.029371798,
0.0712597892,
-0.0197999664,
0.0215035994,
-0.0259764101,
0.0233213268,
0.0057940157,
0.0373921581,
-0.0011036638,
-0.034333393,
-0.0334952511,
-0.0038659456,
-0.0235621482,
0.0152617069,
0.0023539336,
-0.0345514342,
0.0147461537,
-0.0302787647,
-0.0600536801,
-0.0080077583,
-0.043351654,
0.0104391566,
0.0270418357,
0.0299928244,
-0.0083266757,
-0.0132460948,
-0.0073400717,
-0.0266284831,
-0.0118795764,
0.0164691769,
0.0277669318,
-0.0128992908,
0.004681698,
-0.0387158208,
-0.0269345902,
0.0196234416,
0.068764925,
-0.0281255022,
0.0045781825,
-0.0712072775,
0.0129230879,
0.0036209489,
0.0367685966,
-0.0182627607,
-0.0832228139,
0.0288388766,
0.002675113,
0.0941377208,
0.0813627392,
0.0280045923,
0.061104659,
0.0480089933,
-0.0160367358,
-0.0296348222,
0.0138386954,
-0.0707118511,
-0.0051781838,
-0.0464868844,
0.0011731483,
-0.0144509571,
0.1061159074,
-0.0087942099,
-0.0082572401,
-0.0912434608,
0.0022917541,
-0.0266918242,
-0.0082178395,
0.0135430396,
0.0244781263,
-0.0633126646,
0.0454169251,
-0.029334601,
-0.0588021316,
0.0491358452,
-0.0319960266,
-0.0287297629,
-0.005024238,
-0.0005713819,
0.0026212069,
0.037352588,
0.0443829969,
0.0177797303,
-0.0137931649,
-0.0330636539,
-0.0742213205,
0.0140496818,
0.0154100731,
-0.0176803302,
0.0484698378,
0.0098497216,
-0.0124421325,
-0.005190046,
-0.0129158702,
-0.0398577526,
-0.0337131508,
0.0169948507,
0.0062735099,
0.049550727,
-0.0455739461,
-0.0237901751,
0.0224372931,
0.057302881,
0.0657187253,
-0.0103074638,
-0.0064442889,
-0.012904577,
0.0234507192,
0.0276605245,
0.0174680669,
0.0317231491,
-0.0326318853,
0.0080669168,
0.041832298,
0.0311055146,
0.0134693068,
-0.0547324196,
-0.0180433206,
0.0359386392,
-0.0124592464,
-0.0170287304,
0.0142364586,
0.072417587,
-0.037123844,
-0.0352136493,
0.0875949264,
-0.0023272729,
-0.0084881252,
0.0183276981,
0.0239935797,
0.0397103541,
0.0219384339,
0.0124921277,
-0.0472947024,
0.0116163129,
-0.0010012313,
0.0152314445,
0.0519732945,
0.0195598677,
-0.0058873822,
-0.0618685074,
0.0331344791,
-0.0018097898,
-0.0076309582,
-0.0364575572,
-0.0138028655,
0.0002740919,
-0.004468658,
0.0174867325,
0.0032921042,
-0.0399793312,
-0.0274209622,
0.0366051085,
-0.0288507845,
-0.0542981811,
-0.0264492761,
-0.0181312766,
0.0123207783,
0.050658986,
0.0051684999,
-0.0277350191,
-0.0772350356,
0.0287212897,
-0.0252861548,
0.0022156092,
0.0453115404,
0.0327534266,
-0.0119227776,
-0.0310745407,
0.0070749205,
0.0015659197,
-0.036229644,
-0.0199251324,
-0.0681566298,
0.0359094143,
-0.0140958028,
-0.0413373001,
0.0114098312,
0.0051441155,
-0.0375149623,
0.0388370417,
0.0522283278,
-0.0406963453,
-0.0298590846,
-0.0331289433,
0.0648448393,
0.0131223379,
-0.0732329264,
0.0111103943,
0.0732199103,
-0.0975048766,
-0.0403437391,
-0.0299870148,
-0.0125343483,
0.0574385785,
-0.0198854357,
-0.028408369,
0.0024971596,
-0.0154123418,
-0.0422259755,
0.0468425937,
-0.0119602997,
-0.0028383606,
-0.0688292906,
0.0048584254,
0.0454598852,
-0.0031031368,
-0.030261619,
-0.0238916166,
-0.1185921803,
-0.0587944798,
0.0495713502,
0.0616335459,
0.0169971976,
0.0450873896,
-0.0231670719,
-0.0363060236,
0.0928836688,
0.0013366581,
-0.0168367717,
0.0595221408,
0.0520186312,
-0.0595791563,
0.0055511305,
0.0184838939,
-0.016865598,
0.0315394141,
0.0240529012,
0.0238474458,
-0.0181410611,
-0.0606590919,
0.0110644968,
-0.0649726316,
0.091775924,
-0.0035491253,
0.057255853,
-0.0241364073,
0.0160102211,
0.0000581409,
0.0185957514,
-0.0493570231,
-0.0396460891,
0.0499428771,
0.0209592097,
0.0126501648,
0.0394073837,
0.0091315871,
-0.0115769245,
-0.0022057027,
0.0220762081,
-0.0099271126,
0.0173242092,
0.0345834158,
0.0459185839,
0.0015927964,
0.0186563712,
-0.0147942919,
0.0228987727,
0.0237232707,
0.0246961061,
0.0108656818,
-0.001698526,
-0.0438352451,
0.0482280068,
-0.0846435279,
-0.0462631732,
-0.006020912,
-0.0370397009,
0.0353171751,
-0.0354859047,
0.0722968876,
-0.0164499767,
-0.0023381908,
-0.0145975454,
0.0196956005,
-0.0028346789,
-0.0284732301,
0.0245783217,
0.00540921,
-0.0180421006,
0.0255469792,
0.0696154386,
0.0333534144,
0.0150295161,
-0.0329641253,
0.0044224532,
0.002565105,
-0.0148235774,
0.0008797763,
-0.0206953939,
-0.027106978,
0.0101336082,
-0.0254462324,
-0.0776739642,
0.0025599883,
-0.0115261134,
-0.0035868192,
-0.0375531018,
0.0329612084,
0.0455431342,
0.0063552875,
-0.0057530194,
-0.0277559143,
-0.0116294296,
0.0481484309,
-0.020640431,
-0.0233278219,
-6.46426531e-33,
-0.0150021147,
-0.0140525782,
-0.0063159401,
-0.0212833621,
-0.0134460758,
0.0156232845,
-0.0407174863,
0.0143455677,
-0.0232538413,
0.0307468791,
-0.0232343376,
0.0195785649,
0.0126325311,
0.0380284414,
-0.007991204,
-0.0027101515,
0.0486818738,
-0.0101416577,
-0.0173661858,
-0.0085238554,
0.0164384618,
0.0274894331,
0.090492487,
0.0029261024,
-0.0092859417,
-0.0153728575,
-0.0000058659,
-0.0038495322,
0.0215787645,
0.055240836,
-0.0256367177,
0.0069123553,
-0.0008875299,
-0.078692615,
-0.0358759128,
-0.0015054359,
-0.0456991568,
-0.0387204215,
-0.0300835371,
0.0354337245,
-0.0537727624,
0.0073319748,
0.0783168003,
-0.0267101303,
-0.0124808624,
-0.0426016003,
0.027768407,
0.0222061463,
-0.0643273965,
-0.0258277748,
-0.0515410602,
0.0049204757,
-0.0041279509,
-0.0461744294,
0.0339339189,
0.0003616173,
0.0084436554,
-0.0045272643,
-0.0879577398,
-0.0035542711,
-0.0101788575,
0.0415482186,
0.0463201851,
0.0339092873,
0.0221961085,
0.0071405941,
0.0325137079,
0.0378811881,
-0.0415360704,
-0.0369557515,
0.0685812011,
-0.0195219684,
0.0218525622,
-0.0486155041,
-0.0078739431,
-0.0013577716,
-0.0274095237,
-0.0336099267,
-0.0509555377,
0.066169478,
0.0413505286,
0.0165635608,
-0.027064858,
-0.0379133001,
-0.0321272761,
-0.0282152388,
-0.0068346648,
-0.0211213641,
0.0257850941,
0.0200468581,
-0.0119980136,
-0.0010747679,
0.0619356893,
-0.0308270752,
0.0037492414,
0.0186272729,
-0.0027126775,
0.0440193675,
-0.0094233993,
0.0205857717,
-0.0495782681,
0.007807557,
0.0183533579,
0.0268079359,
-0.0022068808,
0.0172498021,
0.0192414317,
0.0518403873,
-0.061997354,
-0.0366363116,
-0.0237733014,
-0.0189523641,
-0.0024684139,
0.0299796313,
0.0643214807,
-0.0053622695,
-0.0103095332,
0.0466525257,
0.0094961431,
0.0280068759,
-0.0220398158,
0.0393703394,
0.0073700803,
0.0411232822,
-0.0307598561,
-0.0142278178,
-0.0713692233,
0.0787170604,
0.0317908116,
-0.0439900681,
-0.0295318197,
0.0084183114,
2.632e-7,
0.0541385934,
0.0196629856,
0.0298245307,
-0.0013467486,
0.0328234658,
0.0107284002,
0.0006348483,
0.0278311446,
0.0085721705,
0.0038220086,
0.0181257576,
0.0395098738,
0.0190557111,
-0.0012396429,
-0.0616677701,
-0.0257375315,
-0.082812503,
0.0425159968,
-0.0024576026,
-0.0350884274,
-0.0309216306,
0.1280039996,
0.0083855269,
0.0308474023,
-0.0016849501,
0.0164206456,
0.0794563591,
-0.0286068488,
0.0186957698,
0.0048739403,
0.0525426231,
0.0124845132,
-0.0307217576,
-0.0674111024,
-0.0275647882,
0.0057431492,
-0.0032554278,
0.0120878136,
-0.0158220381,
-0.0058151428,
-0.0006512316,
0.0055184225,
-0.0187319443,
-0.0712825581,
0.0315131284,
-0.1203062534,
-0.0278814472,
-0.0277450718,
-0.0350062326,
0.0259632785,
0.0218437389,
0.0064548948,
-0.0236907229,
-0.0041485983,
0.0322308429,
0.0142274369,
-0.0191973075,
-0.1068126038,
-0.0495219864,
0.0067026801,
-0.0431488827,
-0.0015554344,
-0.0678238422,
-0.0653154999,
0.0727171451,
0.0419062302,
-0.0160174612,
2.21478036e-34,
0.0060272836,
-0.0114221694,
0.0289320666,
-0.0063199387,
-0.0022459291,
-0.042225454,
0.0357334875,
0.007585194,
0.0148573043,
-0.0696929693,
-0.023739621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18323v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18323v1 | ReWOO: Decoupling Reasoning from Observations for Efficient Augmented Language Models | 2023-05-23T00:16:48 | 2023-05-23T00:16:48 | Binfeng Xu, Zhiyuan Peng, Bowen Lei, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Yuchen Liu, Dongkuan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Augmented Language Models (ALMs) blend the reasoning capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with tools that allow for knowledge retrieval and action
execution. Existing ALM systems trigger LLM thought processes while pulling
observations from these tools in an interleaved fashion. Specifically, an LLM
reasons to call an external tool, gets halted to fetch the tool's response, and
then decides the next action based on all preceding response tokens. Such a
paradigm, though straightforward and easy to implement, often leads to huge
computation complexity from redundant prompts and repeated execution. This
study addresses such challenges for the first time, proposing a modular
paradigm ReWOO (Reasoning WithOut Observation) that detaches the reasoning
process from external observations, thus significantly reducing token
consumption. Comprehensive evaluations across six public NLP benchmarks and a
curated dataset reveal consistent performance enhancements with our proposed
methodology. Notably, ReWOO achieves 5x token efficiency and 4% accuracy
improvement on HotpotQA, a multi-step reasoning benchmark. Furthermore, ReWOO
demonstrates robustness under tool-failure scenarios. Beyond prompt efficiency,
decoupling parametric modules from non-parametric tool calls enables
instruction fine-tuning to offload LLMs into smaller language models, thus
substantially reducing model parameters. Our illustrative work offloads
reasoning ability from 175B GPT3.5 into 7B LLaMA, demonstrating the significant
potential for truly efficient and scalable ALM systems. | [
0.0569587946,
0.0316344947,
-0.0074388809,
0.0406922773,
-0.035502106,
0.0059948056,
-0.0030231373,
-0.0159208216,
0.0432156585,
-0.050539773,
0.0032377581,
0.0193170086,
-0.0324424841,
0.0136245806,
0.0005256635,
-0.0276371315,
0.0614661314,
-0.0607519262,
0.0193755999,
-0.0041306084,
0.0319798924,
0.0311408956,
-0.0262390766,
0.0551910624,
0.0088492669,
0.0058650817,
-0.0440739729,
-0.0004625231,
-0.0005761762,
-0.0118589923,
-0.0065962179,
0.0138299447,
0.0103742909,
0.0703305677,
0.0000023889,
-0.0456847288,
-0.0186412744,
0.0266711973,
-0.0426694863,
0.0276224669,
-0.0178156476,
0.0261219405,
0.0049651968,
0.0417264551,
-0.0236073472,
-0.0253622513,
0.0297656022,
0.0187782496,
0.049692668,
0.0644762442,
-0.0072561204,
-0.00626184,
-0.0059226598,
-0.0287153237,
0.0117191393,
-0.0377433784,
0.0022242037,
-0.0280959141,
0.079260841,
0.0245615989,
0.0092278384,
0.0508362204,
0.0482126735,
0.0120056719,
-0.0421116054,
0.0281767137,
-0.0458012335,
-0.0074387286,
-0.0188018214,
0.0242366567,
0.0062066424,
-0.027096739,
0.0223236922,
-0.0016179078,
-0.0065550678,
0.0046255188,
-0.0519830957,
0.0110911783,
-0.0262498632,
-0.0006660204,
0.0211343784,
-0.0225162897,
0.0623501875,
0.0407659002,
-0.0575232133,
0.121125862,
0.0047322954,
-0.0037854149,
-0.0308645293,
-0.0047558262,
-0.0412849709,
-0.0715184137,
0.0006998483,
0.0735751539,
-0.0570917539,
0.0409973115,
-0.007221099,
-0.0007410532,
0.0246973876,
-0.0068514836,
0.0285460874,
0.0926988274,
-0.0323487073,
0.0744266883,
-0.0213605203,
0.0489892326,
-0.0339874141,
0.0339822583,
-0.0128563559,
-0.0271891095,
-0.0547562391,
-0.0240435824,
-0.0242565107,
0.0710756481,
-0.0432339311,
-0.0180136133,
0.0038176449,
0.0342871211,
-0.0071910336,
0.0078324769,
0.0001850399,
-0.0023641582,
0.0059318529,
-0.032943245,
-0.0723898783,
0.0590608455,
-0.0522226207,
0.0197136272,
0.0189357698,
-0.0997340679,
0.0013332901,
-0.0072333138,
0.0051974203,
-0.0287534855,
0.0197733082,
0.0912065655,
-0.0002245828,
-0.0256851632,
-0.032142736,
-0.0506676286,
0.0216171797,
-0.1034411341,
0.0057444279,
-0.0775373206,
0.0588417277,
0.0227341279,
-0.0377098545,
0.0135042025,
0.0085046524,
0.0296106897,
-0.040765848,
0.0494952127,
-0.0065252841,
0.0128054786,
-0.0084603615,
0.0184148606,
-0.0239863116,
0.0778378397,
0.0172689687,
0.0204952732,
0.0197004322,
0.0232336037,
0.0158851258,
0.0284291711,
0.0322530977,
-0.0027058963,
-0.011486182,
0.0305404346,
-0.0321975984,
0.0009952161,
-0.0352802388,
0.0406084582,
-0.0224873535,
0.0099643553,
0.0335298479,
0.0477388762,
-0.0225039143,
-0.0062746224,
0.0404550657,
-0.0015171777,
0.0182215851,
-0.0254259389,
-0.0581766106,
0.0600817725,
-0.0616371445,
0.0042288019,
0.0431117639,
0.0426260754,
-0.0243734792,
-0.0440984517,
-0.0312756561,
0.0116845798,
0.0011290185,
0.0506140441,
0.029277781,
-0.0226880498,
-0.0197139308,
0.0387326106,
0.0144011229,
-0.0506840684,
-0.0504681207,
-0.0809715912,
0.0416083969,
0.0698510334,
0.0689430311,
-0.0136568611,
-0.0369457714,
0.0113803959,
0.0150982412,
0.034273047,
0.0435456634,
0.0192523412,
0.0141263595,
-0.0457554534,
-0.0412192456,
-0.0043292176,
-0.0004381478,
0.0259575062,
0.0496323779,
0.001970584,
-0.0049302187,
-0.0143522732,
-0.0076976628,
0.0057200193,
-0.0193269122,
-0.0381981395,
-0.0060891523,
0.0106727434,
0.0442430563,
-0.0021564155,
0.0350905992,
0.025877025,
0.039764747,
-0.0035760696,
-0.0213249009,
0.0517326854,
-0.0376095176,
-0.0234581735,
0.0280486625,
0.0369425938,
0.0082549695,
-0.0009064014,
-0.0265930369,
-0.0605483502,
0.0334394276,
-0.0159523878,
0.0645391867,
-0.0368891358,
0.0123383878,
0.0054227794,
-0.0009658124,
-0.0000289381,
0.0382375047,
-0.0032369425,
0.0043813204,
0.0196022093,
0.0164443236,
0.0168335605,
0.0071209846,
-0.0245422143,
0.0164111294,
0.0061302423,
0.01975815,
0.0140070394,
-0.0073789991,
-0.0214959979,
-0.0084436554,
-0.0979110226,
0.0326138996,
-0.0125566721,
0.0009941106,
0.0039115902,
0.0423317775,
0.0040735644,
0.001554643,
0.0092456806,
-0.0127493497,
0.0195876416,
0.0496907048,
0.0015086223,
0.0170345288,
-0.030835364,
-0.0004219394,
-0.0186979007,
-0.0084952805,
0.0102082975,
-0.004161594,
-0.0164709706,
-0.0321550742,
-0.030864466,
-0.0673921257,
0.0259385575,
-0.0077072848,
-0.0195599962,
0.0412395634,
-0.0608422384,
0.0100026103,
0.0381267071,
-0.039933484,
0.0119838743,
0.0427209288,
-0.0161149763,
-0.0843427479,
0.0625523105,
-0.0031141257,
-0.0024526413,
0.0317965522,
0.0211943425,
-0.0340361707,
0.0438373946,
-0.0300144758,
-0.020640472,
-0.0480771177,
0.0091497805,
0.0232042037,
-0.0109489039,
-0.0286213849,
-0.027115263,
-0.0197808929,
0.0509741642,
-0.0253626127,
-0.0463845022,
0.0730057135,
-0.0270326808,
-0.0276250169,
-0.0545205027,
0.008364208,
-0.0211304054,
0.0780151337,
0.0036783156,
0.0111373942,
-0.0279433373,
-0.0144891618,
0.0026485831,
-0.0273320619,
-0.0128917247,
-0.0583155565,
0.0431463942,
-0.0750841722,
0.0443158373,
-0.0128041124,
-0.0436047241,
-0.0426757373,
0.0307180528,
-0.0678979009,
0.0172040351,
-0.0470759757,
-0.0471945219,
-0.0094271796,
-0.0084156524,
0.0694535375,
0.0594600178,
-0.0289114546,
-0.0015215673,
-0.0311714783,
-0.0162834376,
0.0099541042,
-0.0123777799,
-0.0092590284,
-0.0062760534,
0.0341963246,
0.0575974621,
0.0851102024,
-0.0365720801,
-0.025502773,
-0.0052013402,
0.037498787,
0.0052070012,
-0.0151914051,
0.030881146,
0.0491225161,
-0.1130428761,
-0.0186496489,
0.1133178249,
0.0398912728,
-0.0075225146,
-0.0131029077,
-0.0117667578,
0.056397941,
0.0249087643,
0.0599687733,
-0.1180939376,
-0.0657456666,
0.0428657942,
0.0134566855,
-0.0162356216,
-0.0214644745,
-0.0256363098,
-0.1295407563,
0.0228137411,
-0.0091010872,
-0.0056733857,
0.0234923717,
-0.0220449269,
0.0030908289,
0.0309787486,
-0.0114143416,
0.0367882773,
0.0274964944,
-0.0027017787,
-0.0007998229,
-0.0048330547,
0.0189937688,
0.0445741005,
-0.0130264908,
0.0181023367,
0.0277440045,
0.0130826682,
0.0151556805,
-0.0644421577,
0.0588637963,
0.0161852483,
0.0015497066,
-0.0450836346,
-0.0182839818,
-0.0055422732,
-0.0130748078,
-0.0072347135,
0.0226324815,
-0.028442366,
-0.01494449,
-0.0234500282,
0.119514145,
-0.0214027632,
0.0142092183,
-0.0265117642,
-0.0263524242,
-0.0285773333,
0.0653458312,
0.0029163181,
-0.0156764686,
-0.0624394901,
-0.0221525189,
-0.0890243053,
-0.0633861572,
-0.0086231399,
-0.0046342043,
0.0279995482,
0.0179308951,
-0.0193272494,
-0.0149850352,
0.0523020178,
0.0253573041,
0.0138150658,
0.0261895433,
0.0048719719,
0.0062343762,
-0.0395278856,
0.0328835659,
-0.0444374345,
0.0391512029,
-0.0067428756,
0.0135849733,
0.0131210955,
-0.0066532618,
-0.0113268243,
0.020720074,
-0.0351318419,
-0.0883352831,
0.0050067352,
0.048273731,
0.0350967869,
0.0260984767,
-0.0325118788,
-0.0430238806,
-0.0195752066,
0.0396279097,
-0.0533598177,
0.0011244187,
0.0125809675,
0.0253549982,
0.0207338724,
0.0398326665,
-0.0431481004,
-0.0139413346,
-0.0061944383,
0.0453713387,
-0.009670116,
-0.0198478829,
0.0001728192,
0.0451801606,
0.0007163638,
0.0004311674,
-0.0140589094,
-0.0172044337,
0.0118010361,
-0.0141169159,
-0.0179137681,
-0.051889766,
0.0362516195,
-0.0347467698,
-0.0124756433,
0.0101048741,
0.0048308414,
0.0223012809,
0.0121881897,
0.0279650576,
-0.0053424467,
-0.0460881405,
-0.0122670736,
0.0366016589,
-0.002315117,
-0.0054923394,
0.0056088609,
0.027506303,
0.0387779474,
-0.0811808556,
0.0684658661,
0.0411074571,
-0.0016456383,
-0.0516241975,
0.0121858846,
-0.0762742385,
-0.0815859884,
0.0498946346,
0.0880699605,
0.026348969,
-0.0162174981,
0.0392609648,
-0.0436319783,
-0.0174271148,
-0.0145102814,
0.0217057131,
0.0197112951,
-0.0291085895,
0.0453474559,
0.0474819057,
-0.0097548915,
-0.0046228804,
0.0363737829,
-0.0494923033,
0.0430821031,
0.0061249253,
-0.0136492504,
-0.0379532501,
-0.0302022286,
-0.0070622158,
0.0091485316,
-0.0292750392,
-0.0016124514,
-0.047414951,
-0.056416627,
-0.0520608649,
-0.0150519609,
-0.0333754681,
-0.0485265031,
0.0182598829,
0.0548101664,
0.0352163464,
-0.0392429493,
-0.0238977429,
0.0101562738,
-0.0346068181,
-0.0133432401,
0.0179356299,
-7.253662664e-33,
-0.0131408954,
-0.0164521076,
0.0684331954,
-0.0505800806,
-0.0040484988,
-0.0180668086,
-0.041955933,
-0.0054614418,
-0.025932014,
-0.003633192,
-0.0262215808,
0.0169692747,
0.0141504128,
0.0260193832,
0.0091541354,
0.0230794903,
0.0105161406,
0.0064032055,
-0.0356728919,
0.035149049,
0.0783113837,
-0.0170216877,
0.0110303145,
-0.0322011746,
0.001263835,
-0.0012930214,
0.0139739672,
0.0291615874,
-0.0806707218,
0.0467140824,
-0.0067748711,
0.0139863901,
0.0175495427,
-0.025898518,
0.0079064425,
0.0164270829,
-0.0644399822,
-0.0155571001,
0.0677231476,
0.0042498186,
-0.068975389,
-0.028568266,
0.0200765692,
0.0305314362,
-0.0016314853,
0.0025959858,
-0.0291133095,
-0.0145613914,
-0.0057515176,
0.0477661118,
-0.0434015989,
0.0135029927,
0.0017136192,
-0.0220609456,
0.0349163339,
0.0217834394,
-0.0083930986,
0.021175202,
-0.0398079492,
-0.0119998818,
0.0117742252,
0.0175670218,
0.0495023467,
0.0171898436,
-0.0076882839,
0.0322535113,
0.0363724008,
-0.0383557379,
-0.0268386472,
0.029115878,
0.0236632265,
0.0525164679,
0.0471071638,
-0.0224452447,
0.041229222,
-0.0045655621,
-0.0701855049,
-0.0072450833,
0.0472691171,
0.0562065504,
0.0610386543,
0.0220785942,
-0.0208036304,
-0.0322166309,
-0.0305203889,
0.0212639309,
-0.0582875684,
-0.0189564452,
0.0296830013,
0.0370612927,
-0.0225570668,
0.0175788831,
0.0324910581,
-0.0309906602,
-0.0166775659,
0.0153285284,
-0.0184045061,
-0.0075967736,
0.0071000624,
0.0539666638,
-0.0434849001,
0.0145168183,
-0.0102542285,
0.0102432519,
-0.009960237,
0.0174697153,
0.0219183955,
0.0463484265,
-0.0581617765,
0.008047956,
-0.0998975188,
0.0407285355,
-0.0401129946,
-0.01192002,
0.0334931687,
0.0211818088,
0.0074670077,
0.0644984916,
0.0026263646,
-0.0193400476,
-0.0422129519,
-0.0028052239,
-0.0033160718,
-0.0089311227,
-0.0177273192,
0.007680139,
-0.0479852892,
0.0009108976,
0.0089892829,
-0.0375742204,
-0.0188502409,
0.0418308079,
3.17e-7,
-0.0015172359,
0.0146977911,
0.0246858429,
0.0072278669,
0.0199577641,
0.0364975296,
-0.0235133022,
-0.0159418751,
0.039108213,
-0.0074708359,
-0.0405118428,
0.0406995341,
0.0586587042,
0.0204042979,
-0.0792502686,
-0.0076001654,
-0.049947381,
-0.0371076912,
-0.0687842742,
-0.0190646052,
0.0161936022,
0.0532717668,
0.0205453876,
-0.0168211032,
0.0129759219,
-0.0328983292,
0.0413754508,
0.010663324,
-0.0104402509,
-0.0166185386,
0.0248214807,
0.0488091223,
0.0252588801,
-0.0217919722,
0.0129794441,
0.0109652244,
-0.0411052927,
0.0734266192,
0.0014022067,
-0.0438543111,
-0.0081821615,
-0.0437437594,
0.006872694,
-0.0388239026,
0.1005568579,
-0.0005222113,
-0.020802401,
-0.0137269767,
0.0421690159,
-0.0207555164,
-0.0400080979,
0.0051385164,
-0.0595163144,
0.0226305667,
0.0043807128,
-0.0359424688,
-0.0132474964,
-0.0811476633,
-0.040114738,
-0.0335784964,
-0.0334140658,
-0.0391483791,
-0.0488365591,
0.0188077744,
-0.0276322942,
-0.081621781,
-0.0349716134,
3.380089466e-34,
0.0232230164,
0.000334339,
0.0296416506,
0.0613312759,
0.0241464488,
-0.010805646,
-0.0261695366,
0.0087727048,
0.038914144,
-0.0783773586,
-0.0475071184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13551v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13551v3 | How Fragile is Relation Extraction under Entity Replacements? | 2023-05-22T23:53:32 | 2024-05-07T16:22:07 | Yiwei Wang, Bryan Hooi, Fei Wang, Yujun Cai, Yuxuan Liang, Wenxuan Zhou, Jing Tang, Manjuan Duan, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Relation extraction (RE) aims to extract the relations between entity names
from the textual context. In principle, textual context determines the
ground-truth relation and the RE models should be able to correctly identify
the relations reflected by the textual context. However, existing work has
found that the RE models memorize the entity name patterns to make RE
predictions while ignoring the textual context. This motivates us to raise the
question: ``are RE models robust to the entity replacements?'' In this work, we
operate the random and type-constrained entity replacements over the RE
instances in TACRED and evaluate the state-of-the-art RE models under the
entity replacements. We observe the 30\% - 50\% F1 score drops on the
state-of-the-art RE models under entity replacements. These results suggest
that we need more efforts to develop effective RE models robust to entity
replacements. We release the source code at
https://github.com/wangywUST/RobustRE. | [
0.0821948424,
0.0477532148,
0.0074803443,
0.0830289871,
-0.0167449936,
0.0167761333,
-0.0256872736,
-0.0005597781,
-0.0358399339,
-0.0577944815,
-0.0076886457,
-0.0173077341,
-0.0038965906,
0.0189375952,
-0.0097689116,
-0.0574989393,
0.0494222194,
0.0009947617,
-0.0143109113,
0.0294051934,
-0.0149473995,
-0.0075627407,
0.0090267062,
-0.018757049,
0.0042873025,
0.0070271208,
0.0014247354,
0.0156015074,
0.0384196602,
-0.0229530856,
0.0251967553,
0.0567342453,
-0.0357376672,
0.0499760471,
0.0000018789,
-0.0402161554,
-0.0650612563,
0.0201923866,
-0.039668154,
0.0293898005,
-0.03102207,
-0.0060970928,
-0.0208835788,
-0.0277650896,
-0.0441741385,
-0.0535661429,
0.0414243564,
0.0503030121,
0.007225018,
0.0781973228,
-0.0143219447,
-0.0247983243,
0.0352577157,
-0.0155225666,
0.0198992211,
-0.0422747061,
0.0418051779,
-0.0292354785,
-0.0350231677,
0.0214959886,
-0.0112962928,
0.0059641954,
0.0048643569,
0.0159043018,
0.0261153113,
0.0349286683,
-0.0410308279,
-0.0061469884,
-0.0044413717,
0.0691257641,
0.0203510616,
0.0187517591,
0.0420798287,
0.0565300994,
-0.0112555185,
0.0390409753,
-0.0020456084,
-0.0139498431,
-0.0457872488,
0.0000311355,
0.0091796117,
-0.0099142278,
0.0375379249,
0.0018846984,
-0.039390143,
-0.0043468359,
0.0429009087,
-0.037489567,
-0.0220159087,
0.0216869917,
-0.0175394136,
-0.064801015,
0.0160798877,
0.0015160281,
-0.0305333603,
0.057834439,
-0.0688306019,
-0.0169920493,
-0.0183251407,
-0.0546617955,
-0.0252142698,
0.0247447733,
-0.0142562725,
0.0535924733,
-0.0432045348,
0.0280018896,
-0.0154614905,
-0.0130791198,
0.0247984752,
-0.0060506291,
-0.0399237648,
0.0076657464,
-0.0236670915,
0.0775577277,
-0.0258748606,
0.0050286017,
-0.0464478806,
0.0147616919,
-0.0297374688,
0.0247408971,
-0.0368223824,
0.019813858,
-0.0537309647,
-0.0038657903,
-0.0456441045,
0.0058018914,
0.0122424057,
-0.026511576,
-0.0062754788,
-0.0203570798,
0.0004800336,
-0.0761535391,
0.0151326433,
-0.0632663444,
-0.0058710612,
0.0965371579,
0.0391995348,
-0.0605896674,
-0.0571168065,
-0.0269299652,
-0.0045371191,
-0.0387832895,
-0.0148830898,
-0.039407324,
0.0106023783,
0.0007754712,
0.0071660248,
-0.0681935772,
0.0382919908,
-0.0203551333,
-0.0733416006,
0.0670927167,
-0.0167012457,
0.0080201682,
-0.0190327577,
0.0127766225,
0.0067925286,
0.0357526951,
0.030487977,
0.0071340413,
0.0764981955,
0.0074891355,
0.0156565867,
0.0308295246,
-0.0022526323,
-0.0140602635,
-0.0103621613,
0.0186767448,
0.0255891979,
-0.0184675511,
0.0395991392,
0.0687779114,
-0.012268357,
-0.0534197912,
0.0423732847,
-0.0162588209,
0.0002305201,
0.0522594191,
0.0673214644,
-0.0458597653,
0.0282610375,
0.0439438187,
-0.0690973103,
-0.011344769,
-0.0617186241,
0.0083109802,
-0.0301730596,
0.055453483,
-0.0078022908,
-0.0014061573,
0.0125263436,
-0.0000086827,
-0.04524884,
-0.0147873331,
0.0664818883,
0.0495918132,
-0.0354729407,
0.0420593433,
0.0298656058,
-0.0432520732,
-0.013981319,
-0.0187246762,
0.0034082341,
0.039656058,
0.071428895,
-0.024132533,
-0.0502444617,
0.0039476412,
-0.0546646491,
0.0124738403,
0.0488557965,
-0.0313599333,
0.0326312333,
-0.0054271752,
-0.0266767908,
0.0464249402,
0.0231582895,
0.0290778484,
0.0712450519,
0.0046119145,
0.0246192366,
-0.0352873318,
-0.0170678683,
0.0327211767,
-0.0247395709,
-0.0462510996,
0.0132872332,
0.0412903652,
0.0052632596,
0.0357620902,
-0.0390102006,
-0.0161195491,
0.043072544,
0.026005378,
0.0028848262,
0.0292254388,
-0.0495673344,
-0.0506703071,
0.017256299,
0.0138856471,
-0.0405560285,
-0.0092180902,
-0.0132640032,
-0.0101073729,
0.0004689508,
0.0032516152,
0.0698904321,
0.0117679844,
0.0608762205,
0.0142814415,
-0.0012302093,
-0.0374027155,
0.114650026,
0.0187714025,
-0.0120768519,
0.0273770634,
-0.0329592563,
-0.020146383,
-0.0420291312,
-0.051211305,
0.0127703818,
-0.031639114,
-0.0185164977,
0.0215763096,
-0.0197902285,
-0.0500104092,
-0.0245699231,
-0.0355826579,
0.0251480229,
0.0078265462,
0.0446820818,
0.0136755258,
0.0536304638,
-0.0210738704,
-0.0029847487,
0.0199005436,
-0.0464270525,
-0.0477962755,
0.0384525284,
0.0323159359,
-0.0022158371,
-0.0221037306,
-0.0282497741,
-0.0067341053,
-0.0388161093,
0.0855068564,
0.006506566,
-0.0528664738,
-0.0195842031,
0.1043404266,
-0.021954976,
0.0188584831,
0.0064192,
0.0093244156,
-0.0427841358,
0.0337267555,
0.0554622933,
0.0362398289,
-0.0249759424,
0.0677535385,
-0.0230314825,
-0.0395473875,
-0.0321379192,
0.0197053459,
-0.0069620945,
0.0061990744,
-0.0007260127,
-0.0288225636,
0.0092517547,
0.0482120253,
-0.0109195933,
-0.0107331555,
-0.0120311938,
0.0163967572,
-0.0014593771,
0.0014748308,
-0.0257579181,
0.0218023378,
0.0046041184,
0.0230506957,
-0.0516818762,
0.0005171147,
0.0614238605,
0.0043883282,
0.0115427384,
-0.0372305922,
0.0003284542,
-0.0511831455,
0.0452463403,
-0.0057119285,
0.0067273504,
0.0521734431,
-0.0531298742,
-0.0533379503,
-0.0084309038,
0.0213342346,
-0.033060912,
0.0581113175,
-0.0323169716,
0.0124329617,
-0.0113188056,
-0.0287661329,
-0.0552152768,
0.0012377817,
0.0114296274,
-0.0087230494,
-0.0171792489,
-0.0206349604,
-0.0218371786,
0.0068317549,
0.0122515168,
0.0049269437,
-0.0185048021,
-0.0453308038,
-0.0123840123,
0.08582858,
0.0564775802,
-0.0388804935,
0.0238758978,
0.0087230057,
0.0270190984,
0.0636816993,
0.0027542943,
-0.0467499681,
-0.032870926,
0.021260865,
-0.0233750623,
-0.0497832634,
-0.0076388172,
0.0163110755,
0.0088646952,
-0.0745233595,
-0.0358880274,
0.0710356086,
0.0132347569,
-0.0058343653,
0.0040932707,
0.0541068092,
0.02614142,
0.0315526128,
-0.0056318729,
-0.0826465562,
-0.0026282112,
0.0273996107,
-0.0073430487,
-0.003192273,
-0.0735732242,
0.013389254,
-0.1025949121,
0.001371488,
-0.0216479506,
-0.0927434936,
-0.0274366122,
-0.0368526876,
0.0459765829,
-0.0380736142,
0.0008439248,
0.0148013551,
-0.045989491,
0.037879955,
0.0084590344,
0.0046749553,
-0.0464583896,
0.0059203617,
-0.0598989539,
0.0442007706,
0.0739529952,
0.0206289943,
-0.0191441067,
0.0182073582,
-0.0200337972,
-0.0134408493,
-0.0276115686,
-0.0123975277,
0.1015936509,
-0.0266309325,
-0.0190991741,
-0.0167223457,
0.0060313228,
-0.0337971039,
0.0052422774,
0.0135573791,
0.0563499443,
0.0217249226,
-0.0182788316,
-0.0325865671,
-0.06413389,
0.0113366572,
0.0873225927,
0.011715333,
-0.0174295716,
-0.0389893651,
-0.029670883,
0.0040113232,
-0.0315059945,
0.008128318,
-0.0180015191,
-0.0700426102,
-0.0054447148,
-0.0787509382,
-0.0549269542,
0.043836575,
0.033191286,
0.0309491493,
0.0185235944,
-0.001389106,
0.0169477966,
-0.0638956055,
-0.0218499098,
-0.0292915907,
0.0132499393,
-0.0214391667,
0.0092873201,
0.0027465778,
0.0049119918,
-0.0125812031,
-0.0389478393,
-0.0456981398,
-0.0612737648,
0.0301585142,
0.0206702445,
0.035790313,
0.0346298665,
0.016161263,
0.0072937356,
0.0197322816,
0.0493900254,
-0.0472268872,
0.0199521966,
0.0429642759,
0.0307175629,
-0.007048578,
0.0325165093,
-0.0548033379,
-0.0068635801,
0.0378993601,
0.0422429666,
0.0004559957,
-0.0105233332,
0.0236080009,
0.0316507556,
0.0312580764,
0.0376301222,
-0.0080798529,
-0.0104887737,
0.0263335705,
-0.047084,
-0.007517532,
-0.0291988272,
0.0272000339,
0.0104592675,
0.0620449111,
-0.0336539932,
0.0009495452,
0.0322071575,
0.0822161287,
-0.0119738486,
-0.070585236,
0.0334191173,
0.0213110708,
0.0479512103,
-0.0186391957,
0.0079753865,
0.0109987836,
0.0599317588,
0.0449003465,
-0.0226732492,
-0.0086280154,
0.029411342,
-0.0328329317,
-0.0216619782,
-0.0327259749,
-0.0793893561,
0.0353901647,
-0.0273086652,
0.0333363898,
0.0225982182,
-0.0154349804,
0.0290877856,
-0.0231578723,
-0.012213598,
0.0029985991,
0.0103237042,
0.0165819135,
0.0387036726,
0.0329360925,
-0.0030502835,
-0.0271619316,
0.0523947626,
0.0606251433,
-0.0096997591,
0.1117416546,
0.0029474264,
-0.0320581086,
-0.0340526924,
-0.0000504986,
0.0088935895,
-0.03356231,
-0.0240054894,
-0.0365511291,
-0.0688183755,
-0.0541207045,
0.0586115159,
-0.0398324877,
0.00879551,
-0.0136777954,
-0.0305002332,
0.052304484,
0.0532758757,
0.0037197419,
-0.0222103093,
0.0154537046,
-0.0190892257,
-0.0530223697,
-0.0132086519,
-6.052375763e-33,
-0.0389466733,
-0.017020978,
0.0122601893,
-0.0220117923,
-0.0190102197,
0.0479703397,
-0.0376520976,
-0.001778925,
0.0009093967,
0.0164302345,
-0.0180721935,
0.0024113019,
0.0197024923,
0.0145013342,
-0.0331175923,
-0.0088403048,
0.0315494351,
0.021006953,
0.0109043382,
0.0040876707,
0.0390566401,
0.0541581474,
0.0711641014,
-0.0874252617,
0.0302470438,
0.0039245142,
0.0064708646,
0.0025730629,
0.0183307063,
0.0625136271,
-0.0290732589,
-0.0082092127,
0.014031413,
0.0018303015,
-0.0154224942,
-0.0152182495,
-0.1743231118,
-0.0191111509,
-0.0063407244,
0.0068214047,
-0.0327928253,
-0.0354655497,
0.0662325323,
0.011265289,
0.032764826,
-0.0314235128,
0.030733753,
-0.0427320749,
-0.040483851,
-0.052188389,
-0.0767790228,
0.0319067836,
0.0179275721,
0.0268453863,
0.013903779,
0.0035496734,
0.0250881985,
-0.0016036039,
-0.0630033314,
-0.0299566314,
0.0039082128,
-0.008001266,
0.0080939271,
-0.0058619897,
-0.0027225742,
0.0605406389,
0.0219358504,
0.0214890447,
-0.0005551919,
-0.0191904902,
0.0046389308,
0.0618989132,
-0.0246258769,
0.060534399,
0.0439267233,
-0.0076388568,
-0.0900307223,
0.049254477,
0.0184395853,
0.0139326127,
0.0211051293,
0.0120188221,
-0.0747488961,
0.0076581994,
0.0033985015,
-0.0086085051,
-0.0236658324,
-0.0494650006,
0.0281422567,
-0.0058481274,
-0.0303906817,
0.0523158088,
-0.0055129584,
-0.0508016758,
-0.0526261628,
0.0209707841,
-0.0184875224,
0.0074949688,
-0.0042852131,
0.0071569183,
0.0068045277,
-0.0286419895,
0.0042925738,
0.0186629035,
0.0064488645,
0.01465989,
0.0576991178,
0.0043054372,
-0.0847784132,
-0.0083463788,
-0.0289097857,
0.0069716382,
-0.0046824599,
0.0162538122,
0.0063340105,
0.0012277138,
-0.0025582891,
0.0085979132,
0.0783134773,
0.0124689117,
-0.0446113683,
0.0819470882,
0.0259536821,
0.0190644115,
0.0202650037,
-0.0300025977,
-0.0055347392,
0.0197366551,
0.019933518,
-0.0395155326,
-0.0011358184,
-0.0104307318,
2.654e-7,
0.0319097713,
0.0210323129,
0.04783535,
-0.0303639639,
0.0108535634,
0.0476950295,
0.0225102063,
0.0414398834,
0.0189739354,
0.0105395056,
0.0054320549,
-0.0279603433,
0.0137624806,
0.041863624,
-0.0727067515,
-0.0136502227,
-0.0555770807,
-0.0458314791,
-0.0583451651,
-0.0116140842,
0.020849606,
0.0644584224,
0.0479981788,
-0.0073790462,
-0.0487190075,
-0.0053775972,
0.0352209583,
-0.0352394693,
0.0025662447,
0.0338659473,
0.0027378569,
0.0190020166,
-0.0161183793,
0.0098235607,
-0.005747648,
0.0416875035,
0.0454426818,
0.0325059295,
0.0055631641,
0.0077877948,
-0.0131376889,
-0.0640719086,
0.0205800701,
-0.0323158614,
0.0722669661,
-0.0407100804,
-0.0198681075,
-0.0049365917,
-0.0453766137,
0.0121568721,
-0.0121946307,
0.0163734686,
-0.0039219358,
0.0314277112,
0.0068730642,
0.019713819,
-0.0632240251,
-0.0907850489,
0.0149845723,
0.0128665334,
0.0143915592,
-0.0316325873,
0.0007183991,
-0.0158658549,
-0.0094263116,
-0.0618264042,
0.0092259319,
2.688342035e-34,
-0.0146626225,
0.022561213,
-0.0082588578,
0.0468389913,
0.034985885,
-0.0514496155,
-0.0370042361,
0.0256336424,
-0.0304276329,
-0.0559733286,
0.0029282363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13547v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13547v3 | Self-Evolution Learning for Mixup: Enhance Data Augmentation on Few-Shot Text Classification Tasks | 2023-05-22T23:43:23 | 2023-11-27T15:10:00 | Haoqi Zheng, Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Zhiliang Tian, Xin Niu, Dongsheng Li, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.NI | Text classification tasks often encounter few shot scenarios with limited
labeled data, and addressing data scarcity is crucial. Data augmentation with
mixup has shown to be effective on various text classification tasks. However,
most of the mixup methods do not consider the varying degree of learning
difficulty in different stages of training and generate new samples with one
hot labels, resulting in the model over confidence. In this paper, we propose a
self evolution learning (SE) based mixup approach for data augmentation in text
classification, which can generate more adaptive and model friendly pesudo
samples for the model training. SE focuses on the variation of the model's
learning ability. To alleviate the model confidence, we introduce a novel
instance specific label smoothing approach, which linearly interpolates the
model's output and one hot labels of the original samples to generate new soft
for label mixing up. Through experimental analysis, in addition to improving
classification accuracy, we demonstrate that SE also enhances the model's
generalize ability. | [
0.0319932364,
0.035800565,
0.0194999892,
0.0094635161,
0.0046644104,
0.0280166324,
0.01385321,
-0.0182528049,
0.0333321169,
-0.0570182949,
-0.0330726393,
0.0261702742,
-0.037085779,
0.0290316679,
-0.001856598,
-0.0236317031,
0.0418339893,
0.006077358,
0.0319458321,
-0.0220625177,
0.0059298007,
0.0118614612,
-0.0078810202,
-0.0219665114,
-0.0027793394,
0.0038335144,
-0.0221598186,
0.0365108922,
0.0223744493,
-0.0107112769,
0.053572461,
0.0405852571,
0.0172572546,
0.0552790128,
0.0000020219,
-0.0835032016,
-0.0269137919,
0.0020837917,
-0.0625818819,
0.011555736,
0.081805177,
0.031517379,
0.0047046137,
-0.0130018042,
-0.0112518826,
-0.0181225594,
0.0285794865,
0.0693923905,
0.0652002022,
0.051858101,
-0.0102056963,
-0.0283913091,
0.0004134922,
-0.0473623611,
0.0840243548,
-0.0566710308,
0.0397999361,
-0.0302770641,
-0.0338098481,
0.0519158058,
0.0067594959,
0.0218201634,
0.0135690607,
0.0152389845,
0.0304325148,
0.0347661451,
0.0031598145,
0.0088195605,
-0.0259627625,
0.0261158329,
-0.0413486846,
-0.0119987112,
-0.0256229136,
-0.0511267781,
0.0610258952,
-0.0179138165,
-0.0062794848,
-0.0761939287,
-0.0173196625,
0.0304103494,
0.0186304767,
0.0204246081,
0.0034240016,
0.0327237472,
-0.0162111446,
0.0536968894,
-0.0220740754,
-0.0216648132,
-0.0059378152,
0.0091714449,
0.0389348157,
-0.0125491535,
0.0424469523,
0.0499839932,
0.0410855375,
-0.0051403856,
-0.0908606723,
-0.0724007636,
0.0248865299,
-0.062371958,
0.0312752724,
0.0045024781,
-0.0018829199,
0.0556738153,
-0.0094174789,
-0.0586027317,
0.0001811857,
0.0284948684,
-0.0508802608,
0.010473174,
-0.0499926768,
-0.0090234876,
-0.0519458577,
0.0498158261,
0.0223091524,
0.0180392899,
-0.0769352764,
0.0302842949,
0.0043634465,
-0.0139982533,
-0.0168461613,
-0.0049991733,
-0.0612808727,
-0.0004899967,
-0.006090885,
-0.0062512425,
-0.0038485753,
0.0003339205,
0.0111907171,
0.0115002729,
-0.0125959292,
-0.0418070443,
0.0500426665,
-0.0171767976,
0.0314998217,
0.0557487085,
-0.0146972528,
-0.0615705214,
-0.0591632947,
0.0219137669,
-0.0560654141,
-0.003144566,
-0.0351405405,
-0.0352333188,
0.0147309676,
-0.0285625998,
-0.0232290141,
-0.0265680961,
-0.0030880608,
-0.0389278717,
-0.0537112765,
0.0643730983,
-0.0637953952,
0.0015767167,
0.0903769657,
-0.0082091,
0.0140371434,
0.067420125,
0.0053627337,
-0.0104705868,
0.0402196646,
-0.003322273,
0.0652265921,
0.0298867021,
0.0301945806,
0.0184712876,
-0.0255128797,
-0.0040604323,
-0.0092769591,
-0.0067047258,
0.0262404811,
-0.0417960435,
-0.0353904441,
-0.0354626961,
0.0258721225,
-0.0411916934,
0.0648960322,
0.024139801,
-0.0047136229,
0.0210374668,
0.0005960332,
0.0155680031,
0.0296759065,
0.036757715,
-0.0623097792,
-0.0026104643,
0.0285661351,
0.0098920418,
-0.0561431274,
-0.0799551308,
0.0106913717,
0.0013432822,
-0.0102060391,
-0.0039042565,
0.0374807343,
0.0509565957,
0.0226262454,
0.0010401742,
0.0442487486,
-0.0098419907,
0.0022347812,
-0.0563122965,
-0.0115828281,
0.0689103976,
0.0127891479,
-0.0635896102,
-0.0747389048,
-0.0363521874,
0.0124468599,
-0.0011922349,
0.0308499336,
0.0025581417,
0.0329207778,
-0.01685738,
-0.0580539629,
-0.0427056141,
0.0170552675,
0.0065645799,
-0.0321915708,
0.0221356954,
0.0582190827,
-0.0292873699,
-0.0307921171,
0.0356893726,
-0.0279895533,
-0.0456261933,
0.0802011341,
-0.0017926116,
0.0096049197,
0.0114761498,
-0.013700013,
-0.0265463982,
0.0075004096,
-0.0058928016,
-0.0372453742,
-0.0283711925,
-0.0119439326,
-0.0754638091,
0.0694363266,
0.0321798809,
-0.0366140753,
-0.056900546,
-0.0644940212,
-0.0330634266,
0.0035458677,
-0.0113439756,
-0.0166624859,
-0.0616159998,
0.0251095295,
-0.0214530826,
0.0225065667,
-0.0276100151,
0.0782273114,
0.0261758212,
-0.000354114,
-0.0459419638,
0.0203977488,
0.0445778109,
-0.006322748,
-0.0266782604,
-0.0604591072,
-0.0210757088,
-0.0046799271,
0.0037973721,
0.0310070999,
-0.0553178638,
-0.0392425358,
-0.0324192792,
-0.0106236208,
-0.0074205068,
0.0096834097,
0.0261778347,
0.0162089672,
-0.0275399107,
-0.0390243679,
-0.0228892807,
0.0059173121,
-0.0361761115,
0.0005180661,
0.0288641267,
-0.0003489993,
0.0178297274,
0.0007634684,
0.0021567121,
0.0027467438,
0.0375168584,
0.0002356069,
-0.0163064431,
-0.0572043397,
-0.030436825,
-0.0238232724,
0.0097189732,
0.0185595732,
-0.0112412581,
-0.0497791991,
0.0146151781,
-0.0095293643,
0.0334811956,
0.0431523696,
-0.0121598206,
0.0046608457,
0.0098358644,
-0.0401163287,
0.0332141966,
-0.0173304658,
0.0249881763,
-0.0038184577,
-0.0228350516,
-0.0137097677,
0.0535461418,
-0.0477061942,
-0.0333429761,
0.0013986643,
0.0359065458,
0.0180867333,
-0.0321487784,
-0.0205895808,
0.0033352366,
-0.0214915257,
-0.0219161138,
-0.0332162492,
-0.0191370621,
0.0954433009,
0.0082535744,
-0.0097553972,
-0.0688664168,
-0.0340364128,
-0.0309698731,
0.013041256,
-0.0016185305,
0.0332197808,
-0.0152343586,
0.0248137321,
-0.0221744291,
-0.0173632167,
0.0188260917,
-0.0300657824,
-0.015822988,
0.0145878559,
0.0073922398,
0.0199193861,
-0.0323439315,
-0.0239215419,
-0.0543286912,
0.0205985904,
-0.0401825495,
-0.0359123535,
0.0150496624,
-0.0211381093,
0.002064574,
0.0013604058,
0.0967221111,
-0.0246862397,
-0.0394766219,
0.0010454195,
0.0041655288,
0.0446314961,
0.008749716,
-0.0367479026,
-0.0061479597,
0.0303772502,
-0.0117988167,
0.044449836,
-0.0078087058,
-0.0378211029,
0.0367921218,
0.0011481228,
-0.0130717782,
-0.0268511362,
-0.0321779326,
0.0196029283,
-0.0209022127,
-0.000528665,
0.0792287365,
0.0283405669,
-0.0391347222,
-0.0188546479,
-0.0502708703,
0.0145544969,
0.0511749312,
0.0617229976,
-0.0052189706,
-0.0143590979,
-0.0177047476,
0.0133884428,
0.0064542824,
-0.0041375333,
0.017009763,
-0.0833765119,
0.0344411619,
0.0139524657,
-0.0648995787,
0.0466105305,
-0.0135206645,
0.0184737239,
-0.0083988886,
-0.0045026299,
0.0015068442,
-0.0081389332,
-0.0069946162,
0.0463119894,
0.0276839174,
-0.0734978542,
-0.0435671285,
-0.0093414914,
0.0222559124,
0.0228330158,
0.0024307338,
-0.0284328163,
0.0032619401,
0.0604179576,
0.0244640056,
-0.0106939292,
-0.0032421213,
0.0750625879,
-0.0053785644,
-0.0031733902,
-0.0040869988,
0.0296282917,
0.0213218462,
0.0067171603,
0.0166297816,
0.0353905372,
0.0102233673,
0.0086158384,
-0.0595856085,
-0.0595862865,
0.0074737608,
-0.0012449526,
-0.0044472013,
-0.1039459258,
0.0250974298,
-0.014569384,
0.0018992688,
-0.063294813,
0.0345135145,
0.0735696256,
-0.0481123552,
-0.0810692087,
-0.0407608896,
-0.024194723,
0.0033322328,
0.062467061,
0.0042609456,
0.0287284777,
-0.0633925945,
-0.0283809751,
-0.0307195019,
-0.0343735293,
-0.0050577298,
-0.0210612006,
0.0071897977,
-0.016167365,
0.0380368829,
-0.0353947058,
-0.025318373,
-0.0127634536,
-0.0696881786,
-0.0682556406,
0.0279647093,
0.054635264,
0.0088556074,
0.057799235,
-0.0129305385,
-0.1017147377,
0.1106687188,
0.123986423,
0.0220971461,
0.0009757926,
0.0334497057,
-0.0156181576,
-0.009372768,
-0.0028486617,
-0.0506114364,
0.0416438207,
0.0507833511,
-0.0284685213,
-0.0349038653,
-0.0444054753,
0.0104636904,
-0.0116019016,
0.0101977792,
-0.0306670181,
0.0089162486,
-0.0090329405,
0.0605884939,
0.0360270664,
-0.0334513597,
-0.0202369001,
0.0044731265,
0.0208999906,
-0.0412027948,
0.0024852296,
0.0175199136,
-0.00023595,
0.034644831,
-0.0138792824,
-0.0390625075,
-0.0124465134,
0.0262859948,
-0.0003763164,
0.0267358143,
0.0059763687,
0.0179851893,
0.0696858764,
-0.0104616312,
-0.0039710328,
0.0212313235,
0.034221977,
0.0322058015,
-0.0430009253,
0.0157120097,
-0.0665306076,
0.0456125773,
-0.0871812478,
0.0102194464,
0.0202184599,
-0.0245235749,
0.0128824953,
0.014081602,
-0.0361135937,
-0.0195884705,
-0.0140055576,
-0.0161711294,
-0.0186030194,
-0.0248071942,
0.0056607202,
-0.0174202006,
0.041717425,
0.0623915307,
0.0417272672,
0.0366551764,
0.0004875387,
0.0115735466,
-0.0290983692,
0.0364489555,
0.0010540009,
0.0260028187,
0.0052623902,
0.0099437311,
0.001691186,
-0.0508768819,
0.0311034303,
-0.0239902046,
0.0100338394,
0.0328879803,
0.0250412803,
0.038679488,
-0.011354153,
0.0174549781,
-0.0155175691,
-0.0061623314,
0.0534504354,
0.0115126353,
0.045696009,
-6.558226981e-33,
-0.0174376145,
-0.0029364999,
-0.0160158686,
-0.0326029956,
0.0271740891,
-0.021957878,
0.0390325263,
0.0160667878,
0.0020093829,
0.0090403464,
-0.0384242609,
0.005666377,
0.0054705702,
0.0345723219,
0.0218192209,
0.0104467515,
0.0508726947,
0.0132398177,
-0.0106799314,
0.0110718776,
-0.0099513596,
0.0629009455,
0.0683779195,
-0.1032459065,
-0.0114891129,
0.0249331594,
-0.0166326985,
-0.0067505832,
0.0107335169,
0.0331546403,
0.0093573425,
0.0445227027,
0.0216628816,
-0.0109464144,
-0.0126915211,
-0.0660762638,
-0.0674736351,
-0.072941415,
-0.0747621804,
0.0103393812,
-0.0172948595,
-0.0104598505,
0.0393449143,
0.0267858822,
-0.0080775265,
0.0087188138,
0.0517894924,
-0.037055552,
-0.0172016937,
-0.0001306004,
-0.0028146235,
0.0348038711,
0.0041592824,
-0.0192932971,
0.038055189,
-0.0060495525,
0.0333146118,
0.0047022742,
-0.0796900019,
-0.0030505238,
0.0509759933,
0.005457358,
0.0013249613,
0.0359045193,
-0.0063891676,
-0.0050539235,
-0.0088960687,
0.0568714142,
0.0095154196,
-0.0506536439,
0.02857095,
0.0225508865,
0.0077925348,
0.0590982996,
0.0819889978,
-0.0486144759,
-0.0281849969,
0.0634340495,
0.0193872992,
-0.0500305593,
0.0213113781,
0.0326590948,
-0.0231812727,
-0.0084290383,
-0.0294886548,
-0.0028931899,
-0.0488448553,
-0.0256005954,
-0.0204380173,
0.066610679,
-0.0583124645,
0.0297516212,
0.0017119879,
-0.0301058386,
-0.0834258422,
-0.064158529,
-0.0385551006,
0.013411127,
0.0159284789,
-0.0054885386,
-0.0199856758,
-0.0631582439,
0.0147514204,
0.0253040865,
0.0096735694,
-0.0121759977,
0.0912560225,
0.0076369499,
-0.0770493001,
0.0219168961,
0.0135745434,
-0.0029003781,
0.0222264826,
0.0074601145,
-0.0080156038,
0.0167987812,
-0.0116216419,
0.0754902214,
0.0830356702,
0.0196947251,
-0.0290827844,
-0.0131413471,
-0.0042123334,
0.0130487774,
0.0033833652,
-0.003759806,
0.030048335,
-0.0216952804,
0.0085805068,
-0.0695709214,
-0.0109803295,
-0.0055690655,
2.77e-7,
0.0409088768,
0.0544594005,
-0.0125452122,
-0.0726906881,
0.040996559,
0.0787790567,
-0.0470317975,
0.014567229,
-0.0054862956,
-0.0167354215,
0.0367502719,
-0.014778398,
0.0282761846,
0.0186740216,
-0.0520009659,
-0.0128706368,
-0.0556908026,
0.0678528473,
-0.0303253029,
0.0027873621,
0.0366367809,
0.0840751082,
0.0691133514,
-0.0383105949,
0.009980225,
-0.0298212357,
0.0570647456,
0.0252266712,
0.0265347324,
0.0498364829,
0.0001969068,
0.0785976648,
-0.0171834249,
0.0140860071,
-0.0576094687,
0.0370753556,
-0.0045551504,
-0.0074949139,
-0.0470319428,
0.0189441424,
0.0326632708,
0.0424830504,
0.0177730266,
-0.0227792654,
0.0865097046,
-0.0738528222,
-0.0044021448,
-0.0368299037,
-0.0332101807,
0.0187519714,
0.0551003143,
-0.0179812666,
-0.0218230709,
0.0178785659,
0.0024034516,
0.0214079823,
-0.0607876666,
-0.10286244,
0.0064663333,
0.0116678653,
0.006934193,
0.0248740856,
-0.0449879989,
0.0461325049,
0.0661558956,
-0.0321857482,
0.0322499312,
2.132223234e-34,
0.0112866545,
0.0006127125,
0.0026014408,
-0.0091692349,
-0.0355793983,
-0.0047017992,
0.0146797905,
0.0203390066,
0.0093713021,
0.0051618265,
-0.0036649262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13535v1 | Improving Classifier Robustness through Active Generation of Pairwise Counterfactuals | 2023-05-22T23:19:01 | 2023-05-22T23:19:01 | Ananth Balashankar, Xuezhi Wang, Yao Qin, Ben Packer, Nithum Thain, Jilin Chen, Ed H. Chi, Alex Beutel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Counterfactual Data Augmentation (CDA) is a commonly used technique for
improving robustness in natural language classifiers. However, one fundamental
challenge is how to discover meaningful counterfactuals and efficiently label
them, with minimal human labeling cost. Most existing methods either completely
rely on human-annotated labels, an expensive process which limits the scale of
counterfactual data, or implicitly assume label invariance, which may mislead
the model with incorrect labels. In this paper, we present a novel framework
that utilizes counterfactual generative models to generate a large number of
diverse counterfactuals by actively sampling from regions of uncertainty, and
then automatically label them with a learned pairwise classifier. Our key
insight is that we can more correctly label the generated counterfactuals by
training a pairwise classifier that interpolates the relationship between the
original example and the counterfactual. We demonstrate that with a small
amount of human-annotated counterfactual data (10%), we can generate a
counterfactual augmentation dataset with learned labels, that provides an
18-20% improvement in robustness and a 14-21% reduction in errors on 6
out-of-domain datasets, comparable to that of a fully human-annotated
counterfactual dataset for both sentiment classification and question
paraphrase tasks. | [
0.0649161041,
0.0874637738,
-0.0219075046,
0.0238009896,
-0.0424660295,
0.0139163071,
0.0048726541,
-0.0086154193,
0.0338619538,
-0.072051473,
-0.0005526517,
-0.0087151369,
-0.0592157803,
0.0321694911,
0.0259649716,
-0.0255099181,
0.0562819764,
0.0050703879,
0.0265420824,
-0.032856416,
-0.0255930573,
0.006408839,
-0.0195950624,
0.0037727726,
-0.0237750392,
0.010246017,
0.0146078812,
0.034579739,
0.0432228968,
-0.0353125781,
0.0529862083,
0.0334320664,
-0.0008544852,
0.0547205918,
0.0000018376,
-0.0428494774,
-0.016617639,
0.0231487509,
-0.0364048108,
-0.0006582659,
0.0157495178,
-0.0247940794,
0.0041139005,
0.0036231023,
-0.062212754,
-0.0007227567,
0.0516402684,
0.035790395,
0.0506799184,
0.0655778646,
-0.0178892389,
-0.0223416481,
0.0026396094,
-0.0254085679,
-0.0160354991,
-0.0506486855,
0.0027399003,
-0.0063741668,
-0.030472571,
0.0309151635,
-0.00788425,
0.0237689074,
0.0348884054,
0.0223713461,
0.0001268551,
0.0117144845,
-0.0184212215,
-0.0198516455,
-0.0043178969,
0.0584279299,
0.0195625108,
-0.0404830016,
-0.0255316328,
-0.0640749261,
0.0406975374,
0.0423177928,
-0.0119603779,
-0.0090820137,
-0.0014700699,
0.0120456479,
-0.0058410345,
0.0330014341,
0.0301743057,
0.0276055634,
0.020239355,
0.0329136923,
0.0099224718,
-0.0246920027,
-0.0093563814,
0.0386524051,
-0.077860117,
0.0011301872,
0.0184982959,
0.0002396567,
-0.0220686682,
0.0077252025,
-0.0662721768,
-0.0720980614,
0.0598056205,
-0.0807252899,
-0.0052016377,
-0.0091420393,
-0.0343006104,
0.0381744504,
-0.0136238486,
-0.0088163605,
-0.0359733403,
0.0232217237,
-0.0283702835,
-0.0401312895,
-0.0194574054,
-0.0196521599,
-0.0298376661,
0.0370489806,
-0.0659170151,
0.037431702,
-0.0405307673,
-0.0100561166,
-0.0714135394,
0.0291210748,
-0.0030187597,
0.0485648662,
-0.044770848,
-0.0248505231,
-0.0077025597,
0.0087332437,
-0.0508506931,
0.0431690849,
-0.0072956365,
-0.0750109404,
-0.0084789619,
0.0023980064,
0.0030336401,
-0.038478177,
0.0211283229,
0.0913413018,
0.0134200584,
-0.0177306831,
-0.0220786743,
-0.0210680962,
-0.0342190228,
-0.0443892926,
0.0028144135,
-0.0416632593,
-0.0097077983,
-0.007865265,
-0.0064113308,
-0.0252698716,
0.017310923,
0.0045051756,
-0.0125585832,
0.0710698217,
-0.0158117339,
-0.06728369,
0.0342200585,
-0.0152046569,
-0.0068039848,
0.0592661276,
0.0310715884,
-0.0233075377,
0.0662605837,
0.0244140681,
0.0193867441,
-0.0185645502,
0.045312304,
-0.0105141001,
-0.0479907431,
0.0015983598,
0.0151366061,
-0.0286531486,
-0.0238830708,
0.0095915534,
0.0050804093,
-0.057795193,
0.0364994518,
-0.0567629077,
-0.0527193882,
0.0181383565,
0.0107424809,
-0.0016955761,
-0.02044883,
0.0313667133,
-0.0382371619,
0.0239613578,
-0.0590898767,
0.0221491363,
-0.0037628831,
0.0069792555,
0.0015478379,
-0.0754524171,
-0.0237616263,
0.0016362959,
0.0384082086,
0.0228412859,
0.0461748056,
0.0458278842,
-0.0282571707,
-0.0372850783,
0.0144898761,
-0.0369051285,
-0.0194543134,
-0.0246419329,
-0.0192676205,
0.0383833386,
0.0121583529,
-0.0665938631,
-0.0335157178,
-0.0016040808,
-0.0155771682,
0.0263019279,
0.0721436962,
0.0042090183,
0.036637079,
-0.0276800841,
0.0083509097,
-0.0335566923,
0.0490079671,
0.0074554211,
0.0442119278,
0.0115977321,
0.0116519975,
0.0076867146,
0.0055463477,
0.0254371464,
0.0079372125,
-0.0306078084,
0.0687431097,
0.0034476933,
0.0298224408,
0.0361001194,
-0.0133076645,
-0.0030291635,
0.035093274,
-0.0191618893,
-0.0396480449,
0.0078069232,
0.0018648821,
-0.0822718441,
0.0239858963,
-0.0195217039,
-0.0862589404,
0.0466679558,
-0.0743563399,
-0.0233309511,
0.0252791308,
-0.0367109962,
0.03823594,
-0.0380379893,
-0.0137118669,
0.0051908009,
0.0316607095,
-0.0202884953,
0.0528614782,
-0.007182146,
-0.0018131159,
-0.051340282,
0.0132185016,
0.019929342,
-0.0146061545,
-0.0098934192,
0.0023221949,
-0.0172497164,
-0.0197458882,
0.0020119012,
0.0037887583,
-0.0420934111,
0.0101968804,
-0.0537749156,
-0.0012626703,
-0.0120675648,
-0.0032779034,
0.0142921424,
-0.0149975587,
0.0044487328,
-0.0371745974,
-0.0037233676,
-0.0158866886,
0.0048058848,
0.0094505642,
0.0476167463,
0.0120697794,
0.0174380988,
-0.0513836183,
-0.0150683671,
-0.030597249,
0.0454914384,
0.0205680635,
-0.0045125159,
0.0033580102,
-0.0084226131,
-0.0104855569,
0.0446236171,
-0.0062981164,
-0.0394904092,
-0.0083171623,
0.0205864478,
-0.0114552425,
0.0329695009,
0.0154970344,
-0.0081950789,
0.0259117763,
0.0134380022,
-0.0186367482,
0.0341518149,
-0.0333651826,
-0.011288859,
0.0204365309,
-0.0328701101,
-0.0417158268,
0.0414465256,
0.0111935465,
-0.0432231203,
-0.0430876054,
0.0208010953,
0.001277363,
-0.0363689661,
-0.0073281797,
-0.0141372653,
-0.0133782215,
0.0303958543,
-0.0209351946,
-0.0218015965,
0.1035244167,
0.0113053545,
-0.0008459177,
-0.0489303358,
-0.0130606163,
0.0013501017,
0.0498546101,
-0.0042899083,
-0.000210874,
0.0244913921,
0.026554998,
-0.0151444348,
-0.0335750021,
0.0431679636,
-0.0099282758,
0.0062665096,
-0.0855247676,
-0.0112048248,
0.0032899065,
-0.0614174232,
-0.0452575274,
-0.0679975599,
-0.0149898045,
0.0054829665,
-0.0190716218,
-0.0216829069,
-0.0207676254,
-0.0337130018,
-0.0177517775,
0.0523418598,
-0.0231684502,
-0.0049439562,
-0.0044678063,
0.040912088,
0.052575428,
0.0486756787,
0.0548383743,
-0.0085680047,
-0.0238560382,
0.0290206019,
-0.003862831,
-0.0026592254,
-0.0066276765,
-0.0032565356,
-0.0273368936,
-0.0067982031,
-0.0161909908,
-0.0072914143,
0.0219109692,
-0.0354836211,
-0.0119057298,
0.06405285,
0.0346337184,
0.0135672372,
0.0093069682,
0.0071280962,
0.0048782211,
0.0382163823,
-0.0114267441,
-0.0346613042,
-0.0361586735,
-0.0164233912,
0.0035719441,
-0.0533382259,
-0.011496908,
-0.0077928607,
-0.135240227,
0.0439222008,
-0.016747592,
-0.042455636,
-0.0397773683,
-0.024141714,
-0.0196323842,
-0.0112894662,
-0.0172780026,
-0.0321593359,
0.0393384658,
0.0121302232,
-0.0066140625,
-0.0143519817,
-0.0672901124,
-0.0113409888,
-0.0063575031,
0.0247664768,
0.0508503541,
0.0196792483,
0.0038064187,
0.0282830223,
0.0645328239,
-0.065347217,
-0.0144135579,
-0.0007318461,
0.0903112814,
-0.0041647577,
-0.0075173196,
-0.0148045346,
0.0451040231,
-0.0254231542,
-0.0357922725,
0.0035380255,
0.035635896,
0.0217866488,
0.0191469658,
-0.0442472436,
0.0361433998,
0.0276750363,
0.0578324981,
0.001152726,
-0.050284069,
-0.0171958692,
-0.0168332625,
0.0170901064,
-0.0779556036,
0.0420260504,
-0.0179411024,
0.0395705365,
-0.0171007812,
-0.0688203201,
-0.0602581427,
-0.0228019357,
0.0247508101,
-0.0292347074,
-0.0110201901,
-0.0283621531,
0.0050924332,
-0.0474293493,
-0.0166728813,
-0.011283013,
0.0288838763,
0.0390093736,
-0.0333666764,
0.0476204194,
-0.0176066179,
-0.0454584658,
0.0393136889,
-0.0760926679,
-0.0696641505,
0.01871535,
0.0626238585,
0.0194071196,
0.033222653,
-0.027663419,
-0.0403426178,
0.0041652275,
0.112640731,
-0.0420686714,
-0.0026016564,
0.0842741802,
0.0388979912,
0.0133312894,
0.0375181586,
-0.0178311709,
0.007064966,
0.0413753204,
0.0342310145,
-0.0360112563,
-0.0373202525,
0.0115661025,
-0.0122835832,
0.0767277256,
-0.0154294521,
0.0265744198,
-0.0119780516,
0.0409452431,
-0.0479021631,
-0.0523157753,
-0.0101940352,
0.0160158426,
0.0049517993,
-0.0113329655,
-0.0419798419,
0.0244299993,
-0.0332543403,
0.0683491081,
-0.0068359738,
0.0293754637,
0.0502786785,
0.0294793453,
-0.0184183214,
-0.0098728715,
-0.0274046566,
0.0010080117,
0.0307716001,
0.0294688623,
0.0101818144,
0.0118480911,
0.0178180821,
-0.0269570667,
-0.0572785214,
-0.0279117897,
-0.1059312969,
0.0660156608,
-0.0747268647,
0.0530866049,
0.0208815094,
-0.019864317,
0.0149090942,
-0.0342043117,
-0.0363478996,
0.0135746673,
0.0372655801,
0.0151214469,
-0.0293151271,
0.0450715385,
0.0199650228,
-0.0038839236,
0.0406851508,
0.030500574,
-0.0064203031,
0.050552655,
-0.0197165478,
0.0008898737,
-0.0453302935,
-0.0485439375,
0.0119376052,
0.0291388314,
0.0178074148,
0.0404997133,
-0.0783775523,
-0.0654201508,
0.0528590642,
0.0227138568,
0.0496907867,
0.007492553,
0.0216243826,
0.0106729129,
0.0261198599,
-0.0293347929,
-0.0299668405,
0.0469419062,
0.0276601147,
0.0261855703,
-0.0705907792,
-6.056723255e-33,
-0.0142716132,
-0.052088581,
-0.0357441157,
-0.0569223389,
0.0370447934,
-0.0269146468,
-0.0074690278,
-0.0066691455,
-0.0232267492,
0.0380003043,
0.0051402193,
0.0243542958,
0.0242509246,
0.0526705049,
-0.0042262715,
-0.0281509608,
0.0631349832,
0.0129771344,
-0.0060162973,
-0.0037904463,
0.0018641019,
0.0140633835,
0.0718625709,
-0.1285270452,
0.0331347473,
-0.0287336968,
-0.0241813622,
0.0117931021,
-0.0486914217,
0.0465240143,
-0.0000215595,
0.0730905533,
0.0168953072,
0.0009598639,
0.0266883057,
-0.0503451005,
-0.055201754,
-0.0172825642,
0.0001245648,
0.0335493758,
0.0221217461,
-0.0270624645,
0.0261932965,
-0.00961217,
-0.0077090217,
0.0096861776,
0.0486549288,
-0.0564949401,
0.0270874836,
-0.0106675904,
-0.0702938139,
0.0153954942,
-0.004554749,
0.0255326685,
-0.0298556779,
0.0855257586,
0.0238872319,
0.0214371514,
-0.0449308529,
0.0091224955,
0.0298961625,
-0.0147102159,
0.0146836014,
-0.0019755797,
-0.0008224001,
0.0244281087,
0.0290211197,
0.0337328985,
-0.0060554179,
-0.0025831952,
-0.0059511559,
0.0021402086,
0.0631077886,
0.1928867251,
0.0904338136,
-0.0215037391,
-0.066510357,
-0.0028970803,
-0.0246874355,
-0.0443774126,
0.0340399072,
-0.0012409003,
-0.0282690246,
0.0028119672,
-0.0196418297,
-0.0681740493,
-0.023218561,
0.024769254,
0.0032006179,
0.0088819498,
-0.0602887683,
0.0450009555,
-0.0081087584,
-0.0405183248,
-0.0184799992,
0.0125286775,
-0.0219443776,
0.0054017091,
0.0333696567,
0.0174303073,
-0.0074057882,
-0.0113785397,
0.0452638902,
0.0383660085,
0.0138346786,
-0.0121581964,
0.0816380009,
0.0010904224,
-0.0851015747,
0.0285219084,
-0.0108256377,
0.057317201,
-0.0230366997,
-0.0177985579,
0.0204190854,
0.0095174685,
-0.0087998025,
0.0613967814,
0.0160614401,
0.0220020525,
-0.0203863662,
0.0191627145,
-0.0249914471,
0.0173362568,
-0.0043119085,
-0.0120821903,
0.0443362407,
-0.0183745734,
-0.0260432661,
-0.0719763041,
-0.0070407251,
-0.0080999909,
2.483e-7,
0.0455792025,
0.0376457162,
0.0380501784,
-0.0074345716,
0.0228406973,
0.0662181973,
-0.0025936689,
0.0025099777,
0.002209648,
-0.0005755576,
0.018481303,
0.012130958,
0.0165507626,
0.0289476458,
-0.0227683131,
0.0309000816,
-0.0626164302,
-0.0038512107,
0.0016857547,
-0.0074901446,
0.115353778,
0.1053532735,
0.0542756058,
-0.0086768903,
-0.00982734,
-0.0058470406,
0.0568276159,
-0.0195181854,
0.0148237934,
-0.0229414366,
-0.0285109561,
0.0117990291,
-0.0152762523,
0.0609000064,
-0.0357244089,
0.0186603889,
-0.0070958901,
0.0432122163,
0.0180868488,
-0.0634713769,
-0.0328085087,
0.0229056142,
0.0306931976,
-0.0414649583,
0.0670696869,
-0.0526797622,
-0.0182017982,
-0.0122870412,
-0.065476276,
0.0188331064,
0.0330383964,
-0.0399373733,
-0.0422174409,
0.0036554812,
0.0094935345,
0.0196637008,
-0.0214365069,
-0.0546723157,
-0.0261454824,
0.0289175268,
-0.0426773168,
-0.0271240659,
0.0024799556,
0.0254098959,
0.0298158973,
-0.039462015,
0.0330232531,
2.073116301e-34,
0.0781818032,
0.0133680915,
-0.0192824155,
-0.0244408175,
0.0268839691,
0.0211273842,
-0.0071928706,
0.0051980293,
0.051396694,
0.0254855435,
-0.0010942908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13534v1 | How Language Model Hallucinations Can Snowball | 2023-05-22T23:14:28 | 2023-05-22T23:14:28 | Muru Zhang, Ofir Press, William Merrill, Alisa Liu, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | A major risk of using language models in practical applications is their
tendency to hallucinate incorrect statements. Hallucinations are often
attributed to knowledge gaps in LMs, but we hypothesize that in some cases,
when justifying previously generated hallucinations, LMs output false claims
that they can separately recognize as incorrect. We construct three
question-answering datasets where ChatGPT and GPT-4 often state an incorrect
answer and offer an explanation with at least one incorrect claim. Crucially,
we find that ChatGPT and GPT-4 can identify 67% and 87% of their own mistakes,
respectively. We refer to this phenomenon as hallucination snowballing: an LM
over-commits to early mistakes, leading to more mistakes that it otherwise
would not make. | [
0.0396643654,
0.0421775244,
-0.0317868069,
0.0348370336,
-0.0434597582,
0.0409376509,
-0.0202726815,
0.012661282,
-0.0039160587,
-0.0531654358,
-0.0156670287,
-0.0409800634,
0.0251471587,
-0.0352139883,
0.0432982258,
-0.0268157925,
0.0605081283,
-0.0539742261,
0.0001408948,
-0.0356105976,
0.0122942952,
0.0070745931,
-0.0052651577,
0.0222964231,
-0.0041618939,
-0.0372866504,
-0.0151350722,
-0.0170988385,
-0.0162010547,
0.0198663771,
0.0073712803,
0.0787878856,
-0.0111446977,
0.0816794336,
0.0000015993,
-0.0460211225,
0.0166352093,
-0.022889033,
-0.0297538973,
0.0538253374,
-0.0084805321,
0.0150521798,
0.0132827843,
0.0477514043,
-0.0281623043,
-0.0304151028,
0.022914717,
0.0715631992,
0.0433297046,
0.0504299253,
0.013502541,
-0.0051249359,
0.0008405466,
-0.0081890067,
0.0593756288,
-0.0190709233,
0.0390157141,
0.0382197425,
-0.0230304673,
-0.0267190207,
-0.0164803099,
0.0215368699,
-0.0008757651,
0.0172168314,
-0.0392758511,
0.0333803222,
-0.045077838,
-0.0156619586,
0.0095624942,
0.0143060926,
-0.0050355159,
-0.0606067404,
0.0007006418,
0.0106370328,
0.0034089051,
0.0186380278,
-0.0429240614,
0.049250681,
-0.025749851,
-0.0079191281,
0.0244913809,
-0.0360570624,
0.0537543111,
0.0100371474,
-0.0132101374,
0.0908177719,
0.0055777668,
-0.0461734682,
0.0029903583,
0.0046822196,
-0.0150360968,
-0.0626186877,
-0.0159056261,
0.0322109982,
-0.0341770761,
0.0325955823,
-0.0102160834,
0.0581194609,
0.080235377,
-0.0678648576,
0.001829996,
-0.0014492295,
-0.041419372,
0.0533109531,
-0.017498849,
0.0466240272,
-0.02537583,
0.0382944979,
-0.0176582094,
-0.0335736498,
-0.0436650962,
-0.0559291467,
0.0030447405,
0.0121588642,
0.0162753202,
0.0159027651,
-0.0291313101,
0.015209889,
-0.0288225152,
0.0158214886,
-0.0413854159,
0.0277099423,
0.0139251165,
-0.0220193304,
-0.0554731749,
0.0364518054,
-0.0043380675,
0.0371292867,
0.0024935962,
-0.1073315293,
-0.041410815,
0.0176871438,
-0.0366302095,
0.0147783905,
-0.0021738335,
0.0257998444,
0.0196369942,
0.0074467291,
-0.0142355608,
-0.0336325131,
-0.0516425073,
-0.0678223521,
-0.0053528547,
-0.0794522166,
0.0195566248,
0.0288820788,
-0.020894615,
-0.0095966049,
0.0149326585,
0.0328385681,
-0.0661778599,
0.0676780045,
-0.0262327213,
0.0429227352,
0.0397924706,
0.0418615751,
-0.0190548766,
0.0732925087,
0.0093235252,
-0.006107037,
0.0081696045,
-0.0217879694,
0.092590794,
0.0226255432,
0.0114235869,
0.033156313,
-0.0011729297,
0.0019317664,
-0.0086154323,
0.0008053508,
0.0121619031,
0.0689337328,
-0.0084245158,
-0.0157616436,
0.0743598342,
0.050138101,
-0.0243736412,
-0.0030128502,
-0.0080510275,
-0.0411905274,
0.015898617,
0.0302385706,
-0.0512109473,
-0.0032976356,
-0.0617451034,
0.0010588242,
0.0386885144,
-0.0158952661,
-0.0149655053,
-0.0329026468,
-0.0357686281,
0.012867867,
-0.0052297362,
0.0171524491,
0.0139359301,
0.0098991701,
-0.0100302752,
0.0692919046,
0.0285700466,
-0.0233085249,
-0.0072255181,
-0.0724303275,
-0.0081837289,
0.0358039998,
0.0476536788,
-0.0185398906,
-0.0041584722,
-0.0283099227,
0.0209210161,
0.0582342111,
0.0742218494,
0.0043783095,
-0.0133945616,
0.0010105346,
0.0137869492,
-0.0152811492,
0.0630697161,
-0.0265400689,
-0.0156580303,
0.0029600835,
-0.005946666,
-0.0354448892,
-0.0246093608,
0.0342502855,
-0.0121798813,
0.005823175,
-0.0344197676,
-0.0413360484,
0.0100978212,
-0.0213428494,
-0.0080044977,
0.0402803645,
0.007670233,
0.0039790524,
-0.0703776404,
0.0174689982,
-0.0203631204,
-0.028971836,
0.0475928634,
-0.0119056692,
-0.0085673872,
-0.0076218881,
-0.0249860361,
-0.0357166603,
0.0122370915,
-0.0498765148,
0.0526545495,
-0.0364771076,
0.0389371179,
-0.0283196177,
0.0209059082,
-0.0258607455,
0.0847426504,
-0.0395133607,
0.0541737191,
-0.0117483782,
-0.0006198108,
-0.0156350881,
-0.0099891573,
0.0042915037,
0.0106192119,
0.0145683475,
0.0301474892,
-0.0136037553,
-0.0651031137,
-0.0694677681,
-0.0098237433,
-0.083414346,
-0.0097016683,
-0.0198359601,
0.0065102899,
0.0436498746,
-0.0270498898,
-0.0245207064,
-0.0031036083,
-0.014110758,
-0.0220697001,
0.0430604853,
0.0445375293,
0.0275342464,
-0.0133230863,
0.0090632075,
-0.0352398902,
0.0232532565,
-0.0460634269,
0.0203911848,
-0.0278120805,
-0.0182768181,
-0.0925523564,
0.0213577952,
-0.0785608515,
0.011646199,
-0.0250709988,
-0.01465951,
0.0159422196,
0.0008506437,
0.0003569832,
0.0476703905,
0.0236318838,
0.0544041581,
0.0744136199,
-0.0124609629,
-0.0405387245,
-0.0170679726,
-0.0029246798,
-0.0291938279,
-0.0180167444,
-0.053421177,
0.0107873045,
0.0666826665,
0.0312071666,
0.0187241733,
-0.0328568667,
0.0366776064,
-0.0402595922,
-0.0324631147,
0.0104221171,
-0.0316222906,
-0.0271651614,
0.0703034997,
-0.0250931662,
-0.0761562884,
0.0625066906,
-0.0350362286,
0.0027857004,
-0.0180575345,
-0.0134718828,
0.0046662092,
0.0475760475,
0.011079777,
-0.0089266058,
0.0149428397,
-0.018953016,
-0.0464447625,
-0.0346590281,
0.004351873,
-0.0587197952,
0.0517960899,
-0.0546032153,
0.0020117962,
0.00174684,
-0.0163368918,
-0.0568238497,
-0.0540774055,
-0.0416207127,
-0.0348572508,
-0.0440695062,
-0.0083218869,
-0.0168281663,
-0.0118495105,
0.0066079721,
-0.0063857334,
-0.0353353769,
-0.0164243933,
0.0008854672,
-0.000700366,
0.0740272328,
0.0075837467,
0.0525565408,
-0.0511552878,
0.0135986265,
0.0769368187,
0.0467929393,
0.0684153438,
-0.0038328858,
-0.0363997966,
0.0102244737,
-0.0065788249,
-0.0464476682,
0.0211889837,
0.0256122667,
-0.0375729129,
-0.0135551831,
0.0922874808,
0.0468370095,
-0.0312688909,
0.0045976057,
-0.0542966798,
0.0556237549,
0.0134817865,
-0.0119311977,
-0.0927784294,
-0.0110995453,
0.0021868334,
0.0099630915,
-0.0345004015,
0.0055063139,
-0.0245085768,
-0.0824544355,
0.0210096128,
0.0276051667,
-0.0354239792,
-0.009865785,
-0.0376239046,
0.0096289748,
0.0201021284,
0.0410243794,
0.0350767337,
0.0089493478,
-0.0041372306,
0.0226369016,
-0.0803688392,
-0.0326039009,
0.0580417253,
0.0055642049,
0.0753684267,
0.0628703237,
0.0210634321,
-0.0124076242,
-0.0584171042,
0.053812474,
-0.0047543366,
-0.0049430761,
-0.0270483233,
0.0482561924,
0.0289578177,
0.0103596682,
-0.011423355,
0.0043846844,
-0.0483377464,
0.0007021626,
0.0051041269,
0.0927735269,
-0.0370066985,
-0.0608002208,
0.0078101219,
0.0411849767,
-0.0028028018,
0.0675641447,
0.0192341413,
0.0069969771,
-0.0742467642,
-0.0402165391,
0.0091162929,
-0.0024902134,
-0.0503777936,
0.0654523596,
0.0851518735,
-0.0057290266,
-0.0402926877,
-0.0481227301,
0.007753863,
-0.0055778418,
-0.0119946757,
0.0669588298,
-0.0350140519,
0.0090765348,
-0.0015455744,
0.0196211915,
-0.044794444,
0.0010382158,
-0.011646417,
0.0074998536,
0.0199109428,
0.0114556402,
0.0137602119,
0.0035110957,
-0.0978342593,
-0.0695570558,
0.0294699185,
0.0114849033,
0.0412523858,
0.0342461839,
-0.0088659953,
-0.0507411622,
0.0048885155,
0.0247561205,
0.0012230729,
0.0395312198,
0.0128045743,
0.005403162,
0.0148940971,
0.0444910824,
-0.0213492494,
-0.0003544735,
0.0095871054,
0.0032428796,
-0.0549055673,
0.005598973,
0.0446369499,
-0.0141352862,
0.0338687785,
0.0131380288,
0.0195839945,
0.0064605721,
0.0016291137,
0.0022374527,
-0.0182847716,
-0.0024361454,
-0.0219576079,
0.0142487474,
-0.0246328581,
0.0060897646,
-0.0497002713,
-0.0443703458,
0.0046428032,
-0.0230463315,
-0.0177655183,
0.0418752395,
-0.0055943378,
0.0331074148,
-0.0108739063,
-0.0227651503,
0.008717305,
-0.0072015207,
0.054209888,
0.0208592303,
0.0641859174,
0.0050198594,
-0.0068923999,
0.0004669298,
-0.0317376256,
-0.0734773874,
-0.1233998835,
0.0158824548,
0.0028778259,
0.0547785871,
0.003091682,
0.0621358901,
-0.0258028489,
0.005815417,
-0.028681213,
0.005851096,
0.0380051322,
-0.0410339162,
0.0310663898,
0.0290156063,
-0.0381316207,
0.0047498075,
0.0876468867,
0.0001006052,
0.0610952452,
0.0070327017,
-0.0293105487,
-0.0102840085,
-0.0555897728,
-0.0409338325,
-0.0172532797,
-0.0152110578,
-0.0349213257,
-0.0718102232,
-0.0701056719,
-0.0346776471,
0.0158181284,
0.036392916,
-0.0342940427,
-0.0099429777,
0.0886676386,
0.0037851259,
-0.0300343335,
-0.0374353528,
0.0230478775,
0.0269202199,
0.0261204317,
-0.0099518066,
-6.178053006e-33,
-0.0028517812,
-0.0296921544,
0.0065258155,
-0.0151462974,
0.000512999,
-0.0125868227,
-0.0110512003,
0.039358411,
-0.0336549841,
0.0276825149,
-0.0142085915,
0.0566486344,
0.0159453694,
0.0189490747,
0.0425514318,
-0.0474418625,
0.0150953298,
0.0000368099,
-0.0362660252,
0.0108987251,
0.0400832035,
-0.0028103769,
0.044272162,
-0.0516479649,
0.0642482415,
-0.0239006747,
-0.0192589723,
0.0449824594,
-0.0785901695,
0.0224986058,
-0.0076950244,
0.0559784845,
0.0246375874,
-0.0289488658,
-0.0240432136,
0.004721534,
-0.0063320803,
-0.0357946083,
0.0422666073,
0.0197838955,
-0.033948034,
0.0044314517,
0.0433560647,
-0.0168987662,
-0.0058331038,
-0.0194219686,
0.0127007794,
-0.0250124615,
-0.0070031984,
0.04737271,
-0.0232251342,
-0.0027451869,
0.020834282,
0.0120547526,
-0.03319088,
0.0328983143,
-0.0122711565,
-0.0105750877,
-0.0742720738,
0.0091774529,
0.0144867329,
0.0035641985,
0.0607477315,
0.0082924012,
0.0001624403,
0.0649724677,
0.0668711141,
0.0360070765,
-0.0522343479,
0.0146599552,
-0.0088558337,
0.0313556939,
0.0712248608,
-0.0142715713,
0.0409227014,
-0.0146140167,
-0.0313637406,
-0.0303172972,
-0.0101477141,
0.0131985107,
0.0534823388,
-0.0226912908,
-0.0423763655,
-0.0555592142,
-0.0448352098,
0.0248414204,
-0.0444481522,
-0.0251902752,
0.0098051121,
0.0081567355,
0.0036565217,
-0.0245848298,
0.0155099668,
-0.0291041415,
-0.0187379513,
-0.0127483997,
-0.0171682052,
-0.0158113241,
0.0056744968,
0.0267356653,
-0.0207934994,
0.0087861251,
-0.0276163481,
0.0104828766,
0.030038204,
0.0251717512,
0.0184979085,
-0.0291964207,
-0.0634202212,
0.0072766654,
-0.0362882577,
0.028043313,
0.0026394497,
-0.0495367572,
0.0475055166,
-0.0105444789,
-0.0292045828,
-0.0267713517,
0.0449500568,
-0.0019391763,
-0.0374953039,
0.0250942856,
-0.0693307295,
-0.0036278202,
-0.0110618686,
-0.0174448229,
-0.0469240509,
0.0068290085,
0.0452771373,
-0.0510398746,
0.0059426902,
-0.0166450758,
2.392e-7,
0.0479885526,
0.0639058203,
-0.0168079063,
0.0274122488,
0.0583625771,
0.0389908962,
-0.0153986877,
0.0082404399,
0.0592151806,
-0.0216138251,
-0.0363847539,
0.019208204,
0.0649187714,
0.0727885067,
-0.0238087215,
-0.0214110371,
-0.0618733838,
-0.0059825499,
-0.0488789491,
-0.0124236355,
0.0352211855,
0.0594228469,
0.0374837369,
-0.012280467,
-0.0221597198,
-0.0494310372,
0.073793225,
-0.0005237059,
0.0078347092,
0.0366733707,
0.0477853604,
0.0214578155,
0.0294030104,
0.0773467645,
0.013275886,
-0.0445295684,
-0.0325933285,
0.005521534,
-0.0072117355,
-0.0511929952,
-0.0569959469,
-0.0178302769,
0.0319357328,
-0.0862604752,
0.0769612044,
-0.0279965214,
-0.0135782193,
-0.0303372182,
0.0132437088,
-0.0258491877,
0.038941402,
0.011842072,
-0.0286840145,
0.014462051,
-0.0019956795,
0.0471920222,
0.0181636289,
-0.0738439709,
-0.0254836679,
0.0116048744,
-0.0335627049,
-0.0431498513,
0.0023820135,
0.0414538868,
0.0214911848,
-0.0677360743,
0.0166367833,
2.129894285e-34,
0.0155289192,
0.0025449926,
0.0377241746,
0.0273208115,
0.0284130536,
0.0230834652,
0.0763910115,
0.029336093,
0.0192602072,
-0.0312645473,
-0.0190135613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13533v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13533v2 | Open-world Semi-supervised Generalized Relation Discovery Aligned in a Real-world Setting | 2023-05-22T23:12:57 | 2023-11-01T18:36:28 | William Hogan, Jiacheng Li, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Open-world Relation Extraction (OpenRE) has recently garnered significant
attention. However, existing approaches tend to oversimplify the problem by
assuming that all unlabeled texts belong to novel classes, thereby limiting the
practicality of these methods. We argue that the OpenRE setting should be more
aligned with the characteristics of real-world data. Specifically, we propose
two key improvements: (a) unlabeled data should encompass known and novel
classes, including hard-negative instances; and (b) the set of novel classes
should represent long-tail relation types. Furthermore, we observe that popular
relations such as titles and locations can often be implicitly inferred through
specific patterns, while long-tail relations tend to be explicitly expressed in
sentences. Motivated by these insights, we present a novel method called KNoRD
(Known and Novel Relation Discovery), which effectively classifies explicitly
and implicitly expressed relations from known and novel classes within
unlabeled data. Experimental evaluations on several Open-world RE benchmarks
demonstrate that KNoRD consistently outperforms other existing methods,
achieving significant performance gains. | [
0.0402098708,
0.040307954,
0.0034330215,
0.0919363499,
-0.0137276119,
-0.0035963007,
-0.025266232,
0.0127653377,
0.0542504229,
-0.0401268378,
-0.0290340371,
-0.0108595518,
-0.0268181451,
0.0372151956,
-0.0134800551,
-0.0336133093,
0.0350105837,
0.0135249672,
0.0200178903,
0.0502261035,
-0.0138725135,
0.0364564545,
-0.0104208253,
0.0070319991,
-0.0180696193,
-0.024966063,
-0.0246299431,
-0.0149646113,
0.0462056473,
-0.0396808609,
0.0327184424,
0.0382377207,
0.0065562208,
-0.0438200422,
0.0000017051,
-0.0666126236,
-0.0231544226,
-0.0235093422,
0.0089987163,
-0.0362877883,
-0.0089854142,
-0.0368742719,
0.0390634723,
-0.0055705304,
-0.0366983451,
-0.081558384,
-0.0013266028,
0.0525080673,
-0.0135193039,
0.0410740413,
-0.0320740677,
-0.0228879992,
-0.0299792401,
-0.0075208154,
0.0110987863,
-0.0332913846,
0.0497322343,
-0.0457863957,
0.0159011744,
-0.017585054,
-0.0186464395,
-0.0145677552,
-0.0045589516,
-0.0179902706,
0.0279655308,
0.0587433241,
-0.0824564323,
0.0144029036,
-0.0145181483,
0.1314067543,
0.0287984665,
-0.0121504376,
0.0425540544,
0.0217719637,
-0.0112205427,
0.0310255438,
0.0077965683,
0.0008340217,
-0.0407348536,
0.0373320542,
-0.0116846981,
0.0341980569,
0.0301346574,
0.006205997,
0.0011065629,
0.0680288672,
-0.0148639744,
-0.0470023006,
0.0338285118,
0.0165869445,
-0.0292343609,
-0.0147423539,
0.0249818787,
0.0234964266,
0.0327580757,
0.0294672847,
-0.004407452,
-0.0006885674,
-0.0208433829,
-0.0603205003,
-0.0196300056,
-0.0348853134,
-0.0211291686,
0.0683007985,
-0.0372653529,
-0.0396162011,
0.0062607289,
-0.0333683603,
-0.0131170629,
-0.0223650988,
-0.0504414104,
0.0253105666,
-0.0166928992,
0.0708015636,
-0.0514475442,
-0.0043512732,
0.0072294907,
0.0120960772,
-0.0162397083,
0.029470142,
-0.020614339,
0.013157784,
-0.0004146316,
0.0062058619,
-0.0102229454,
-0.0356924683,
-0.0156690218,
-0.0116814412,
-0.0737692863,
0.0046981317,
0.0058807875,
-0.0207714662,
0.0780751631,
-0.019430412,
-0.029424835,
0.0721844211,
-0.0042869393,
-0.0574240834,
-0.0399142765,
-0.053207133,
-0.009229064,
-0.0336002074,
-0.0067603067,
0.0013846582,
0.0060545239,
0.0489327796,
-0.0324648395,
0.0017057173,
0.0407938026,
-0.0091855219,
-0.0765543804,
0.0380038917,
-0.0134772342,
0.0180461761,
0.0063743275,
0.0318683647,
0.0392944776,
0.0383556187,
-0.0023578126,
-0.004818046,
0.0670621544,
0.0176320449,
0.035709925,
0.0206378344,
0.021289641,
-0.0072142649,
-0.0029741107,
0.0368983783,
0.0486504883,
-0.000584639,
0.0035467565,
0.0119036268,
-0.0057466635,
-0.0357670374,
0.0016395742,
-0.0076046386,
-0.0114103276,
0.0446693935,
0.0224828478,
0.0117063373,
0.011229733,
-0.0006161607,
-0.026473416,
-0.0211861227,
-0.0635917485,
0.0099617103,
-0.0445465073,
0.0297791343,
-0.0065068938,
-0.0061676037,
-0.0447139144,
-0.0285214726,
-0.0239943042,
-0.0163280033,
0.0920526758,
0.0439633019,
-0.023751257,
0.0349793211,
0.042485971,
-0.0219875444,
0.000189028,
0.0267267134,
0.0441010855,
0.0071196198,
0.058294706,
-0.0741066784,
-0.0263499599,
-0.027154332,
0.0083344793,
0.0384644344,
0.0250831731,
-0.0434257127,
0.0402811281,
-0.0135469167,
-0.0514189713,
0.0368548483,
0.0077209887,
-0.00751526,
0.0472624712,
0.0503282212,
0.0168561731,
-0.0550381728,
-0.0074077016,
0.0290748272,
0.0051567093,
-0.0199382957,
0.0523994863,
0.0338213444,
-0.0169934556,
0.015475885,
0.0009172599,
-0.0449343249,
0.0642914921,
-0.0320774689,
-0.0460375063,
0.0204135869,
-0.0501962453,
-0.0144540984,
0.0231947564,
-0.0294549242,
-0.0407418013,
0.0033800341,
-0.0228602551,
-0.0046185036,
0.0037380445,
0.0275990833,
0.0865010619,
-0.0069726612,
-0.0055791428,
0.0150446482,
-0.0170488227,
-0.0206888933,
0.0992402807,
0.0073384638,
0.0034371249,
-0.008632306,
-0.0950084254,
0.0094454316,
0.038120456,
-0.0117888106,
0.0049885684,
-0.0352093503,
-0.0290329885,
0.019821059,
-0.0118388636,
-0.0481994227,
-0.0123234475,
-0.0485428236,
0.016284341,
-0.0009690993,
0.0238438398,
0.0139842769,
0.0058551976,
-0.0227850545,
-0.0187219027,
0.0004144344,
-0.0053359685,
-0.0483532324,
-0.0245155171,
0.0573411547,
0.0343313925,
-0.0041605756,
-0.0088902162,
0.0107025607,
-0.0243425723,
0.0884640962,
-0.0025659078,
0.0189067647,
-0.0012241647,
0.0566152297,
-0.0420978963,
0.0303075574,
-0.0165991317,
-0.0044837152,
-0.0424395204,
0.00474738,
0.0094641801,
-0.0365907811,
0.002278347,
0.0145048331,
0.0209769811,
0.0081194248,
0.0075072874,
0.0243593343,
-0.0377261043,
-0.0155404322,
0.0099543799,
-0.0074932468,
-0.0184151828,
0.0480452515,
0.0043109953,
-0.0246513858,
-0.0004452255,
-0.0201147236,
0.0238098204,
0.0143219521,
-0.0638242587,
0.011324212,
0.0524068624,
-0.0051753237,
-0.0347558148,
-0.0149994539,
0.0409451649,
0.0018244738,
-0.0010189941,
-0.0352608189,
-0.0204428956,
-0.0404611677,
0.086880371,
-0.0108397556,
0.0221241042,
0.0408931822,
-0.0242013633,
0.0074180104,
-0.0407603867,
0.022629194,
0.015287606,
0.0310801808,
-0.0519313626,
-0.0006822972,
0.0205073822,
-0.073963888,
-0.0850712135,
-0.0388945676,
-0.0008333249,
-0.0178733319,
-0.0173942968,
0.0003337311,
0.0286426693,
0.0316717997,
-0.013346374,
0.0096793668,
-0.0058552101,
-0.0488965511,
-0.0151021751,
0.0674921423,
0.1266818792,
-0.0337178484,
-0.0604102761,
0.0231211092,
-0.0101537323,
0.0132146962,
-0.0300216991,
-0.0118235312,
-0.0025593636,
-0.00644601,
-0.0191721283,
-0.0458555706,
0.0248856638,
0.0160281863,
-0.0400943644,
-0.0198448114,
-0.0168490764,
0.1094502509,
0.0524358042,
-0.0370841846,
0.0142226145,
0.0013128996,
-0.0226146504,
0.0467311293,
0.0095979562,
-0.0396610685,
-0.0046468307,
-0.0269668736,
-0.0370646939,
-0.0027290643,
-0.0726668835,
-0.0105620846,
-0.0996928811,
-0.0101258336,
-0.012761117,
-0.0668253824,
-0.0117611736,
-0.044208657,
-0.0102196457,
-0.0340254046,
-0.0569313057,
-0.0245936215,
-0.0393322781,
0.0233648308,
-0.0282539595,
-0.0426751524,
-0.0221973378,
0.0086000962,
-0.0421070345,
-0.0187494829,
-0.0264886469,
0.0366423652,
-0.0215509143,
0.0348666757,
0.0226098765,
-0.0123702586,
-0.0068475408,
-0.0349389426,
0.1009697914,
-0.0282194708,
-0.0061927731,
-0.0527073592,
0.0423742048,
-0.0753628239,
0.0049986802,
0.0262450483,
0.0827300102,
0.0200869981,
-0.0236494634,
-0.0321562663,
-0.0463032983,
0.0467071608,
0.0498888157,
-0.0546857193,
-0.0079008387,
-0.0203621294,
0.0182935242,
0.0519329943,
0.001090235,
0.0274918973,
-0.0272118524,
-0.0467678793,
0.0120693622,
-0.0487421937,
-0.0345399491,
0.0375188254,
0.03673568,
0.0167691745,
-0.0066408673,
0.059848316,
-0.0129626906,
-0.1113182455,
-0.0002631026,
-0.016412966,
-0.0287327953,
0.0195553731,
-0.0159371495,
0.0294315517,
-0.0439197831,
-0.0253714062,
-0.0206108335,
-0.0047406545,
-0.0121656721,
-0.0390539654,
-0.0105075594,
0.0061836517,
0.057907749,
0.000864533,
0.0236285999,
0.0235203374,
0.0915432796,
-0.0524734817,
-0.0167387538,
0.0087337559,
-0.002956586,
0.0174140949,
0.0345773213,
-0.0209125038,
0.0130641824,
0.0440305248,
0.0022772218,
-0.0197450779,
-0.0267034192,
0.0126287956,
-0.011448239,
0.0984203592,
0.012494971,
-0.0058347755,
-0.0690150633,
0.0150641249,
-0.0476235114,
0.012087144,
-0.0217223372,
0.0438237451,
0.0287309308,
0.0211506113,
-0.0374072231,
0.0238774568,
-0.0253446102,
0.070106782,
-0.0419773087,
-0.0308454968,
0.0612942763,
0.0015817354,
0.0102977641,
-0.0214276537,
-0.0080842208,
0.0107134636,
0.0290181525,
0.0280977674,
-0.009617608,
0.0236645453,
-0.006779151,
0.0044901911,
0.0089783631,
0.009618572,
-0.0163089819,
0.0763754845,
-0.0378905982,
0.0716450438,
0.0521044806,
-0.0533636175,
0.0047115595,
-0.0122795776,
-0.0076865493,
0.0186080281,
0.0733887106,
-0.0387627408,
-0.031924583,
-0.0231196005,
0.0178376213,
-0.0643455461,
0.0628766268,
0.0702167228,
0.0011851313,
0.0597416125,
0.0304565504,
-0.0603165701,
-0.0368666276,
0.0180020332,
0.0528475605,
0.0194668975,
0.0047091739,
0.0400353558,
-0.0639440715,
-0.0487910658,
0.0306072533,
-0.0560168214,
-0.0257896278,
0.0145264957,
0.0200719051,
0.0234255567,
0.0273916777,
-0.0626108795,
-0.0453512371,
0.0106004262,
-0.0511082038,
-0.0038717911,
0.0066497591,
-5.785787236e-33,
-0.0249209385,
-0.069227986,
-0.0211863853,
0.0282767601,
-0.0136665218,
0.0776110888,
0.0041608396,
-0.0206591673,
0.0150947701,
0.0468618795,
0.0131662805,
0.0123152593,
0.0014584896,
0.0187081676,
0.0037301695,
-0.0144725237,
0.0043298351,
0.0252118018,
0.0185347032,
0.0025811626,
0.0576993152,
0.0779428408,
0.0722366646,
-0.1200836003,
-0.0085101891,
-0.036272537,
-0.0031190629,
0.0161056165,
0.0481946543,
0.0245847851,
-0.0527707264,
0.0502825826,
0.0322411358,
0.0059670918,
0.036153879,
-0.0271258857,
-0.1365371794,
-0.0204679798,
-0.0320042297,
-0.0191733129,
-0.0033956384,
0.0195604544,
-0.0007889525,
0.0250056759,
0.034851864,
-0.0279187728,
0.0814704821,
-0.0408312641,
-0.0153299011,
-0.0122489054,
-0.059974052,
0.0056809806,
0.0021016053,
-0.0121471174,
0.027235657,
0.0122940941,
0.0148472404,
-0.0219481234,
-0.0316145234,
-0.0355448909,
0.0026868973,
0.0070685144,
0.0206022486,
-0.0059929211,
0.0045567546,
0.0432697795,
-0.0034407706,
0.016121896,
-0.0357182398,
0.0022324196,
0.0000337323,
0.0325964317,
-0.0686217844,
0.0566764772,
0.0281050503,
0.0008502746,
-0.1027330086,
0.0160638504,
0.0300025642,
-0.0219562203,
-0.026485648,
-0.0132350344,
-0.0489758514,
-0.0112074232,
0.0276024491,
0.0089110481,
-0.0169938263,
-0.0068761571,
0.0105453152,
0.0147085506,
0.0055601341,
0.0238419622,
-0.0321721621,
-0.0296043567,
-0.0534442104,
0.0390483402,
0.0059323986,
-0.0081328014,
0.0035906238,
-0.017056765,
-0.0463689975,
-0.0538879186,
-0.0119444616,
0.0175944138,
0.0135870818,
0.0324529335,
0.0417834632,
0.013678465,
-0.0548543781,
-0.0072194585,
-0.0079879388,
-0.0003083285,
-0.0120502543,
0.0091136312,
-0.0092358561,
0.019155018,
-0.0038375892,
0.0921590328,
0.0530019961,
0.0317023322,
-0.0142973159,
0.0344662778,
0.0008198161,
-0.0130614471,
0.0351906307,
-0.0361885317,
0.0195701197,
-0.0022685861,
0.0278248992,
-0.0471791178,
0.0093805045,
-0.0359683521,
2.461e-7,
0.0181231927,
0.019611951,
0.0444898978,
0.039708972,
-0.001175544,
0.0444062278,
0.0305156689,
0.0627783537,
-0.0277846102,
-0.0038934834,
0.0247251131,
-0.0245221984,
0.000839035,
0.0381678753,
-0.0862816647,
0.0053923042,
-0.061908152,
-0.0794478953,
-0.0803105533,
-0.0347503647,
0.0697780624,
0.024558885,
0.0598192066,
0.0188742522,
-0.0370735787,
-0.0423950404,
0.0502258018,
-0.0339153558,
-0.013240695,
0.0440663584,
-0.008747167,
0.0304532759,
-0.0278271679,
0.0305056833,
-0.0253225137,
0.0303479824,
0.0308676288,
0.037196748,
-0.0147602651,
0.0214209538,
0.0196909346,
-0.0073245438,
-0.0153499665,
-0.0111006144,
0.0709745064,
-0.0442968234,
0.0255229976,
0.0341375098,
0.0203589927,
-0.0108154081,
0.0009128519,
0.0255308859,
0.0293730628,
0.0282274485,
0.0158808883,
-0.0079871742,
-0.0129228039,
-0.0731856897,
0.0232960861,
0.0626266524,
0.0215829927,
0.0355500691,
0.018996248,
0.0031547898,
0.0080797905,
-0.0299039353,
0.0377596393,
2.139992057e-34,
-0.0256615039,
0.0201708861,
-0.0396670699,
-0.0005347024,
0.0394116752,
-0.0585850403,
-0.0373751894,
-0.0181028955,
-0.0068361601,
-0.0274981298,
0.0366680697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13530v1 | The Grammar and Syntax Based Corpus Analysis Tool For The Ukrainian Language | 2023-05-22T22:52:47 | 2023-05-22T22:52:47 | Daria Stetsenko, Inez Okulska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper provides an overview of a text mining tool the StyloMetrix
developed initially for the Polish language and further extended for English
and recently for Ukrainian. The StyloMetrix is built upon various metrics
crafted manually by computational linguists and researchers from literary
studies to analyze grammatical, stylistic, and syntactic patterns. The idea of
constructing the statistical evaluation of syntactic and grammar features is
straightforward and familiar for the languages like English, Spanish, German,
and others; it is yet to be developed for low-resource languages like
Ukrainian. We describe the StyloMetrix pipeline and provide some experiments
with this tool for the text classification task. We also describe our package's
main limitations and the metrics' evaluation procedure. | [
0.0439591669,
0.0138194459,
-0.0222922508,
0.0018050917,
-0.0599879511,
0.0388566218,
0.0034405922,
0.0053541474,
0.0138408681,
-0.0532728806,
0.0126989344,
-0.0246625934,
0.0457328483,
-0.0077418662,
0.0276091062,
-0.0190836228,
0.0328248106,
0.0239255298,
0.0298247449,
0.0531153232,
0.0329480208,
0.034034539,
-0.0231138505,
0.0209971741,
0.0051486241,
0.0100736832,
0.0424427912,
-0.0185948741,
0.0055183526,
-0.0336033516,
0.0057813553,
0.0239838753,
-0.0438370034,
0.0460567474,
0.0000017064,
-0.0682956129,
-0.0245881993,
-0.0204648208,
0.0300293434,
-0.0061965813,
0.1032675207,
-0.0106523,
-0.037194673,
0.0163846649,
-0.0409332365,
-0.0232176427,
0.0217298381,
0.0200573262,
0.0290458594,
0.0810652003,
-0.0194499474,
-0.0460234284,
0.0077116163,
0.0315859951,
-0.0771648064,
0.0626167655,
0.0460795686,
-0.0483206548,
-0.0160757061,
0.0012363087,
0.0220605806,
0.0222313907,
-0.0300480239,
-0.0531541593,
0.0059130457,
-0.0070986697,
-0.0998093039,
-0.0297178514,
0.0204835478,
-0.0587610379,
-0.0029335108,
-0.0665975064,
0.0643400326,
0.0199435689,
0.0010010503,
-0.0021871668,
-0.0620376728,
0.0100290654,
-0.0329646431,
-0.0004493801,
0.0592098869,
0.0128377257,
-0.0175067503,
-0.0147040663,
0.0325225629,
0.056531921,
0.0147467004,
0.0262359716,
0.0349102095,
0.0079402858,
-0.0381024331,
-0.022511147,
0.0372933559,
0.0130741792,
0.011720934,
-0.0263446849,
0.0046822964,
-0.0725085735,
0.0391255878,
-0.0786023587,
-0.0269504786,
-0.0162757766,
0.0548086427,
0.0136618493,
-0.0547353439,
-0.0274355654,
0.0608519278,
0.0121341376,
-0.0413609371,
0.0039102538,
-0.0513341278,
0.0079112742,
-0.0476183705,
-0.0252968986,
0.0259204227,
-0.0036862476,
-0.0442337133,
-0.0028788466,
0.0353724025,
0.0474573821,
-0.0465535633,
0.0015573483,
0.0105276061,
0.052550178,
0.0081022903,
0.0023223627,
-0.0380286127,
0.0068036206,
-0.0670032725,
0.0051787649,
0.0450954139,
0.0869586691,
0.0171450172,
-0.0180037152,
-0.0053860764,
0.0123692444,
-0.0041694492,
-0.0358111896,
-0.0146076428,
-0.0157070663,
-0.0187201463,
-0.0404048674,
-0.0087120458,
-0.0339793116,
-0.0418289304,
0.0263871308,
0.0077895825,
-0.0360978693,
-0.0099333208,
0.0118189938,
0.0109199733,
-0.0055677611,
0.0193993971,
-0.0115027586,
0.0343090631,
-0.0561955795,
0.0298825633,
0.0216246173,
0.0335557982,
0.0203789808,
0.0660252646,
-0.0422039144,
0.014147223,
0.0151395397,
-0.0640838221,
-0.0314230844,
0.0091330651,
0.0205184482,
-0.0002271535,
-0.0183702148,
0.0073214043,
0.0286087468,
-0.0040674075,
0.0060365554,
0.0310980808,
0.0606319793,
0.075566031,
0.0481130071,
0.0432939902,
0.0106262947,
0.0036541035,
0.027866615,
-0.0114093106,
-0.0091062887,
-0.0064552422,
-0.0013484644,
-0.056523744,
0.0301097818,
0.0246625915,
-0.050450176,
-0.0118909366,
-0.0013285017,
0.0118480437,
-0.0440670624,
0.0575773567,
-0.0225530379,
0.0053299209,
0.0038475238,
0.0291062947,
-0.0520817265,
0.0038609628,
-0.005414051,
0.0109820794,
0.0281451009,
0.0366785079,
-0.0859376639,
0.0587461703,
-0.0287943985,
-0.0282290764,
0.0134243984,
-0.0271837153,
-0.0340461135,
-0.0168008897,
-0.0405338705,
0.0235680267,
-0.0148853213,
0.0240335558,
0.0075811595,
-0.0497665852,
0.0155122681,
0.0135199251,
0.0099037839,
-0.0353124365,
0.0369590297,
0.0235208441,
0.0075132344,
-0.0030155629,
-0.002606703,
-0.0083587524,
0.0190722011,
-0.0132049695,
0.0449320562,
0.0407930985,
-0.0323522016,
0.0302802194,
0.0282926708,
0.0343182497,
-0.0114832083,
-0.0032852062,
-0.0200504046,
-0.0055711884,
-0.0177520923,
0.0240304191,
-0.0219546333,
0.0799213424,
-0.0588520765,
0.0154489987,
-0.0391814262,
0.0429284833,
-0.018710006,
0.0228614155,
-0.0256171245,
0.0491009615,
0.036596667,
0.0368663259,
-0.0745373145,
-0.0417442359,
0.0541769899,
-0.0294150412,
-0.0321351551,
0.0022054177,
-0.0424981676,
-0.0176270828,
0.0528468266,
-0.0283231195,
-0.0235034041,
-0.041339092,
-0.0808621868,
0.022704374,
-0.0498919375,
0.0668063313,
0.013201491,
0.001835816,
-0.0079438146,
0.0021594288,
-0.0301687699,
-0.0212759282,
-0.0063443938,
-0.0236252584,
0.0615311973,
0.0057943384,
0.003947868,
-0.0282729045,
-0.0112798242,
-0.0166752692,
0.0245329961,
0.0387376249,
-0.0097044529,
-0.0334532559,
0.0445074067,
0.0170951989,
-0.0000960164,
0.0124156922,
-0.0774937421,
-0.0008198085,
-0.007898272,
0.0156383812,
0.0419559665,
-0.0190864988,
-0.0080621978,
0.0900182277,
-0.0040301941,
0.0340169929,
-0.0260960236,
-0.0242226347,
0.0572632626,
-0.0179571025,
-0.0151747474,
0.0389041603,
0.0110531319,
-0.0007038211,
-0.0401501097,
-0.0162733197,
0.0005152328,
-0.0497740768,
0.0540200919,
-0.0037661542,
0.0047546583,
0.0162853841,
0.0330699794,
0.0438001454,
0.0009426848,
0.0336607099,
-0.0337633416,
-0.0007854985,
-0.0765269548,
-0.0939556435,
-0.0566154495,
0.0369484462,
0.0400213674,
-0.0325303189,
-0.001727368,
-0.0506651588,
-0.0059786229,
-0.0341344476,
0.0673027337,
0.0267387051,
-0.0210645068,
-0.0396677889,
0.0085078692,
-0.0214424711,
0.0010368594,
0.022529982,
-0.1030351594,
0.0018685247,
-0.0071310718,
0.0056969398,
-0.0121429097,
0.0265641212,
-0.0456085205,
-0.0172221791,
0.0453229547,
-0.0135678174,
0.0236945506,
-0.0069907778,
0.0710579157,
-0.0171891954,
-0.0270096585,
-0.0324816778,
0.0078919157,
-0.0029102482,
0.0348688439,
-0.0266371761,
0.0293381792,
0.0161677487,
-0.0249669645,
0.0265037939,
-0.0411240309,
-0.0897919834,
-0.0093389973,
-0.0372963101,
-0.0564280748,
-0.0118678538,
0.0770049989,
0.0353869572,
-0.0241856538,
0.0083437366,
-0.018374024,
0.0323740132,
0.014629161,
0.0211074837,
-0.06574177,
0.0251294076,
-0.0075184247,
0.0041812728,
-0.071604155,
-0.0416842587,
0.0218239706,
-0.0633334666,
-0.0049621756,
-0.002813769,
-0.057132069,
0.0162393469,
-0.0333070159,
-0.0135378474,
-0.033109311,
-0.0651190057,
0.0085511962,
-0.0559998862,
0.0344892479,
0.0226580855,
-0.1057833582,
-0.038283471,
-0.0042104623,
-0.0154024446,
-0.0322073922,
0.0525132343,
0.0578774363,
-0.0694866478,
0.001206768,
-0.029258687,
-0.048137676,
-0.0373172723,
-0.0111132283,
0.0456873961,
0.0436832793,
-0.0078973258,
-0.0386446118,
0.0238853917,
0.0099828625,
-0.0070895744,
0.0410898142,
0.0439607762,
-0.0128983222,
-0.0150510734,
0.0169484187,
0.0105106495,
0.0184510816,
0.014507601,
0.0037866051,
0.0166959856,
-0.0413528718,
-0.0264765862,
-0.0119636552,
-0.0163641907,
-0.0187563617,
0.0496397093,
-0.013847433,
-0.0944293439,
-0.1208629832,
-0.0522541888,
0.0533676445,
0.0160063971,
-0.0123267723,
0.0313164778,
-0.025661543,
-0.0016357421,
-0.0354909599,
0.0304766726,
0.0741098672,
0.0241170842,
-0.0679522529,
-0.0105867814,
0.0197079312,
0.0043124845,
0.0107726138,
0.0084819486,
-0.0366136469,
-0.0374935418,
0.0193582829,
-0.0148180798,
0.012797121,
-0.021575762,
-0.0210655965,
-0.0292389356,
0.0126480842,
0.0244650412,
-0.0678740814,
0.0205711722,
0.026032988,
-0.0448198467,
-0.0063612796,
0.0127175134,
0.0172664803,
-0.0106370114,
0.0036247112,
-0.0421350859,
-0.0170659795,
0.0272089336,
-0.0006690935,
0.0101329591,
0.0753238872,
-0.0343871154,
-0.0394253246,
-0.0040171365,
-0.0385779515,
-0.0324732512,
-0.0187627021,
0.0172092412,
0.011066529,
0.024854701,
0.0195041727,
-0.0779995397,
0.0681782886,
-0.0152546447,
0.0277391914,
-0.0266493596,
0.0565870181,
0.0533607416,
0.0107682524,
-0.0260057878,
0.0052467575,
-0.0074153203,
-0.0210311133,
0.0001107887,
0.0382239893,
-0.0156676974,
-0.0347205102,
0.003098814,
-0.0268766545,
0.0314218812,
0.0385757834,
-0.0375689492,
0.0551126599,
0.0173028503,
-0.0252237208,
0.041403152,
-0.0541021526,
0.1225423291,
-0.0194194242,
-0.0193969309,
-0.0159893464,
0.0704580173,
0.0326638408,
-0.0020454049,
-0.0351165757,
-0.021412015,
-0.0495584011,
-0.0293345749,
0.0034575323,
-0.019378705,
-0.0170182474,
0.0609386712,
-0.0725372508,
-0.0328604542,
-0.0047704363,
0.005564332,
-0.0295712985,
0.0072801583,
0.0127230231,
-0.0752537325,
-0.004787859,
-0.0040751551,
0.0294173751,
-0.0285498891,
-0.0362223908,
0.0191122685,
0.0319714472,
0.0214658007,
0.0147697069,
-0.1077853814,
0.006020505,
0.0397229642,
0.007275769,
-0.0072127944,
-5.538965381e-33,
-0.025115665,
-0.0336635113,
-0.004550301,
0.0281334892,
0.0272942986,
-0.0644721389,
-0.0089350846,
0.0046343077,
-0.0052938624,
0.0194248538,
0.0121148834,
0.0117331641,
0.0082792277,
-0.0270966627,
0.0473411158,
0.0625459775,
0.0169271491,
-0.0095854793,
-0.019492615,
0.0031241672,
0.0833491459,
-0.0029608407,
0.1072587371,
-0.0441427827,
0.0339924917,
0.001693933,
-0.0200219732,
0.0081525808,
0.004611793,
-0.0014422999,
0.016215682,
0.0402456671,
0.0050796019,
0.0128546897,
0.0138705494,
0.0197795257,
-0.0160150751,
-0.0556395166,
0.0262717176,
0.0404091552,
0.0154546229,
-0.0209336951,
0.0283053312,
-0.0251086019,
-0.012963322,
0.0302490294,
0.072458677,
-0.0362787992,
-0.0119234798,
-0.039393194,
-0.059742149,
0.056694869,
-0.0291701611,
0.0191536918,
0.0211403146,
0.0499386825,
0.0213816501,
-0.0075485464,
-0.0214347746,
0.0036158557,
-0.028598519,
0.0527562164,
-0.0348781347,
-0.0287046637,
0.0117962416,
0.0468774475,
-0.0229168646,
-0.0138059771,
0.0288848989,
0.1129360199,
0.058191102,
0.009084926,
0.0373798981,
0.0461000614,
-0.0115554007,
-0.01238384,
-0.0903925747,
0.0002773746,
0.0402240567,
0.048985634,
-0.0287495628,
-0.0065079662,
-0.0154039208,
-0.0634938404,
0.0360368378,
-0.019159928,
0.0205262341,
-0.0073733539,
-0.025016252,
-0.0372062512,
-0.0069418624,
0.0218814295,
-0.0283769686,
0.0144114196,
-0.0385735817,
0.0201405212,
-0.0273108128,
0.0738255456,
-0.0087239724,
0.0531283431,
0.0338228382,
-0.0072109867,
-0.0080592856,
-0.023192456,
0.0459541231,
-0.0160140656,
0.0302414503,
0.0213368479,
-0.0458130427,
-0.0049831285,
0.0138532817,
0.0369839817,
-0.008296852,
0.0510938354,
-0.0360579416,
0.0151312482,
0.020641217,
0.0482242666,
0.0242410377,
-0.000144443,
-0.024962347,
-0.0061631473,
0.0383233167,
-0.0233882722,
-0.0347371027,
0.0062840777,
0.009835694,
0.0289349686,
0.0572668239,
0.0186724104,
0.0271583609,
-0.0546000414,
2.546e-7,
0.0860932097,
0.05035742,
-0.0244473442,
-0.0123694623,
0.0272830445,
0.033119671,
-0.0491338149,
0.0491531081,
-0.0184133463,
0.0289854258,
-0.0047289706,
-0.0370497257,
0.0407027118,
0.0226834789,
-0.0934918299,
0.0081200693,
-0.0336206444,
-0.0678248554,
-0.0339878723,
0.0389389843,
0.0427747779,
0.0702631623,
0.0422971658,
0.0184942223,
-0.0387021825,
-0.0647786632,
0.0225322135,
-0.0107028587,
-0.0279528666,
0.0389410034,
0.0573175959,
-0.0223336928,
0.0120270792,
0.0260472745,
-0.036906492,
0.0160392448,
-0.007926655,
0.0290177539,
-0.0139206238,
0.0339367129,
0.0585735068,
-0.0212427694,
-0.0130546167,
-0.0413319767,
0.0658392087,
-0.0165241659,
-0.0420356989,
-0.0089134807,
-0.0034058695,
-0.0032331883,
0.0072825742,
0.0264598355,
-0.0533502698,
0.0384001546,
0.0069518448,
-0.0709474534,
0.0051023266,
-0.04916263,
-0.0216441303,
0.0372380577,
-0.0243218951,
-0.039546486,
0.0232989434,
0.0333174616,
0.0198530518,
-0.0251470376,
0.033707846,
2.198143671e-34,
0.0322406068,
0.0360789411,
-0.0235328767,
0.0162557624,
0.0299331099,
0.0114458296,
0.0256706662,
0.0352222994,
0.0180976316,
-0.0513264537,
0.0076510995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13528v2 | Transfer-Free Data-Efficient Multilingual Slot Labeling | 2023-05-22T22:47:32 | 2023-11-12T10:17:53 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Slot labeling (SL) is a core component of task-oriented dialogue (ToD)
systems, where slots and corresponding values are usually language-, task- and
domain-specific. Therefore, extending the system to any new
language-domain-task configuration requires (re)running an expensive and
resource-intensive data annotation process. To mitigate the inherent data
scarcity issue, current research on multilingual ToD assumes that sufficient
English-language annotated data are always available for particular tasks and
domains, and thus operates in a standard cross-lingual transfer setup. In this
work, we depart from this often unrealistic assumption. We examine challenging
scenarios where such transfer-enabling English annotated data cannot be
guaranteed, and focus on bootstrapping multilingual data-efficient slot
labelers in transfer-free scenarios directly in the target languages without
any English-ready data. We propose a two-stage slot labeling approach (termed
TWOSL) which transforms standard multilingual sentence encoders into effective
slot labelers. In Stage 1, relying on SL-adapted contrastive learning with only
a handful of SL-annotated examples, we turn sentence encoders into
task-specific span encoders. In Stage 2, we recast SL from a token
classification into a simpler, less data-intensive span classification task.
Our results on two standard multilingual TOD datasets and across diverse
languages confirm the effectiveness and robustness of TWOSL. It is especially
effective for the most challenging transfer-free few-shot setups, paving the
way for quick and data-efficient bootstrapping of multilingual slot labelers
for ToD. | [
0.0495359041,
0.0260084979,
0.0091824587,
0.0547918975,
-0.0109465569,
0.0490203574,
0.0236238576,
-0.0589864068,
-0.0191682316,
-0.0257786866,
-0.0527808405,
-0.0181626379,
-0.0020876336,
0.0163650867,
0.0291310512,
-0.0495465696,
0.0174602345,
-0.0136499805,
0.0138603719,
0.0126618072,
-0.0037475026,
-0.0097625554,
-0.0541039631,
0.0253115892,
0.0079134535,
-0.0249749571,
-0.0127235847,
-0.0009798137,
0.0333667994,
-0.0112578226,
0.0359626114,
0.068664901,
0.002248521,
0.0214809328,
0.0000019347,
-0.0284770597,
-0.0002627378,
-0.0201452933,
-0.0625538677,
-0.0436245985,
0.0137606384,
-0.0246778522,
-0.0102546178,
0.0015704929,
-0.0086121056,
-0.0754661858,
0.075498566,
0.0387014076,
0.0549126826,
0.0669128522,
-0.0282891393,
0.0103747817,
-0.0053770686,
-0.0326464847,
-0.0010247061,
-0.0660118759,
0.0058037955,
0.0195026826,
-0.0149684763,
0.0284740813,
-0.0181893073,
0.0424817987,
0.0301959794,
-0.0382093601,
-0.0048058494,
0.0014715212,
-0.0396684483,
-0.0019577066,
-0.0355687477,
0.0953894183,
0.0137847001,
0.0137556372,
-0.0178269595,
-0.0121183209,
-0.006850977,
-0.0341979004,
-0.0405676365,
0.0202007275,
0.0020944751,
0.0007360601,
0.0421545915,
0.039410118,
-0.0145260887,
-0.0185840223,
0.0159611776,
0.0382649451,
0.015918199,
-0.0204620603,
0.0307659712,
0.0460021049,
0.0085463086,
-0.0542029552,
0.0086313784,
-0.0140271159,
-0.0479796976,
0.0271203425,
-0.0417424552,
-0.0515893772,
-0.0164775215,
-0.0231476054,
0.0075432966,
0.0338813737,
-0.0689472333,
0.0325222462,
0.0138595998,
0.0417697057,
-0.0183446612,
0.021469418,
-0.058875829,
-0.0566943362,
-0.0402411595,
0.0029585727,
-0.0534196012,
0.0153133804,
-0.0698540881,
-0.0001218101,
-0.0237663295,
0.0321289711,
-0.0115812626,
0.0117247719,
0.0160678383,
-0.0324537233,
-0.0284009799,
0.0143845621,
-0.0094553512,
0.057524208,
-0.0041009057,
0.0113058947,
-0.0001313246,
-0.0582797639,
-0.0510076806,
0.0483056232,
-0.0005109664,
-0.0709014237,
-0.0181913394,
0.0503429808,
-0.0437292829,
0.0026349588,
-0.0091578402,
0.0156268403,
-0.0422355235,
-0.0704281703,
-0.0112279411,
-0.0585483871,
0.0404944532,
0.0336185694,
0.020840982,
-0.0231819693,
-0.0029146643,
0.0115733435,
-0.0038658876,
0.0883681998,
0.0048819426,
-0.0271687899,
-0.0183171798,
-0.0286621861,
-0.0076006628,
0.0583246425,
0.039967116,
0.0068674078,
0.0417506248,
0.008650599,
-0.0053505516,
0.037794061,
0.0108562037,
-0.0017476288,
0.0546359718,
-0.0050530792,
0.0609906092,
-0.0226456653,
0.02054305,
0.0231133886,
-0.0369914547,
0.025985457,
0.0134775918,
0.0098504713,
-0.0137300026,
-0.0088852197,
0.0445484929,
0.0315397829,
-0.0321597494,
-0.0012650046,
-0.0280315857,
0.0344049037,
0.0378386714,
-0.0225304142,
0.0407063589,
-0.0208609067,
-0.0493872873,
-0.0240932088,
-0.0079599582,
-0.0229403116,
0.0134991417,
-0.0073240031,
0.0597037077,
0.023444185,
-0.0427989624,
0.087345928,
0.0263890401,
-0.0410572477,
-0.0317762196,
-0.0065622586,
-0.0583668016,
0.0189869665,
-0.0167689901,
-0.0299690869,
-0.086953178,
-0.0266831294,
0.0489068739,
0.0467275083,
0.0464032255,
-0.0266572498,
0.0604673401,
-0.0377336591,
-0.0321880728,
-0.0298047885,
-0.0329195298,
0.0234625936,
-0.0113945166,
0.0032697753,
-0.0165595114,
-0.0399673954,
0.0026397852,
0.0040667215,
-0.0036740014,
-0.0058923927,
0.0527342409,
0.0270337425,
0.0477554686,
0.0241034348,
0.0055522742,
-0.0369053595,
0.0141624175,
-0.0679940432,
0.0013184728,
0.0299210846,
-0.0705342516,
-0.0834357738,
0.0093134986,
-0.0232339147,
-0.0355909653,
0.0124429027,
-0.0704568475,
-0.0711097568,
-0.0034616953,
-0.0212108921,
-0.0492372327,
-0.038164258,
-0.0070413081,
0.0132243726,
0.0278024115,
-0.0156301316,
0.0351071842,
0.0276231151,
0.0134317949,
0.0426251031,
0.0068118372,
0.0448187329,
-0.0403202511,
-0.027829254,
0.01777477,
-0.0286743958,
-0.0292530339,
0.0268426519,
0.0372562818,
-0.0361390822,
-0.0038963933,
-0.1026268154,
0.0236879811,
-0.0280454345,
0.0465292819,
0.0241883192,
-0.0031254974,
0.0066681835,
-0.0242811348,
-0.0647845417,
-0.0341088995,
0.0143579021,
0.001246407,
0.0450803153,
0.0062674782,
0.0103174727,
-0.0018192373,
0.021745529,
0.0252335425,
0.0236437339,
-0.0311567523,
-0.0732439011,
-0.0568973944,
0.0041150334,
0.0131047796,
-0.0072613899,
0.0079470873,
-0.0210378543,
-0.0077630845,
0.046415031,
0.0164522473,
0.0220228173,
-0.0254536737,
0.0250171721,
0.0077496115,
-0.0354278684,
-0.0311685167,
0.0483999252,
0.0155001292,
0.0034091449,
-0.0399012379,
-0.0138314441,
0.003065221,
0.0633835122,
-0.0183825493,
0.0355723538,
-0.0608812198,
-0.0161692258,
-0.010052368,
-0.0422241949,
-0.0085023344,
0.0231496356,
-0.0343786739,
0.0047056698,
-0.0387978703,
0.0073082708,
0.0547347665,
-0.0042195222,
-0.0558943637,
-0.0679205209,
0.0007430576,
-0.0281508043,
0.054542847,
-0.0191450994,
0.0126633337,
0.0474118702,
-0.0650722533,
-0.0121744322,
0.0210148934,
0.018619284,
0.0035045745,
0.012771992,
-0.0522033125,
0.0175687093,
-0.0545358546,
-0.0892564207,
-0.0445003435,
-0.0131828561,
-0.0225872099,
0.0265916009,
-0.0100011462,
-0.0072525931,
-0.0152867297,
0.0137164956,
0.0383950733,
0.0633182749,
0.0021151262,
0.0308274888,
-0.0127201667,
0.0500246137,
0.0340405293,
0.0318574049,
-0.044375442,
-0.007283282,
0.0478290506,
0.0306825545,
-0.0126304235,
0.0022209464,
0.0283478424,
0.0188248251,
0.0681440011,
0.0019004543,
-0.0371852666,
-0.0145699456,
0.0794099793,
-0.0060165436,
-0.0322359204,
0.107852757,
0.0069757337,
-0.0370167978,
-0.0288017746,
-0.0023647575,
0.0045534084,
0.014916555,
0.0079793632,
-0.1180203632,
-0.0635767356,
0.0032571324,
0.0004530013,
0.0088749733,
-0.0175858662,
-0.0355865024,
-0.1103120297,
0.0340522416,
-0.0234550852,
-0.092983216,
-0.0006084492,
-0.0229815207,
0.0113013387,
-0.0317455605,
0.0189488828,
-0.0362925008,
0.049219992,
-0.0179495849,
0.054242,
0.0144252824,
-0.0345174037,
0.0118387984,
-0.0156045649,
0.056761194,
-0.0005606437,
0.0450914279,
0.0023525255,
0.0043843682,
0.0071100532,
-0.0150782708,
-0.0507906824,
-0.0146525279,
0.0697474852,
-0.0084594497,
-0.03269054,
0.0155298822,
0.0181284454,
-0.0462772511,
-0.0327316076,
0.0151901646,
0.0381390825,
0.0060238116,
0.058334209,
0.0437610745,
-0.0100408914,
0.0455593839,
0.0829278752,
0.0261259004,
-0.0642197803,
-0.0081800539,
-0.0347719677,
0.0018220552,
-0.100747928,
0.0192220099,
0.0120294522,
-0.0203024708,
-0.0258739106,
-0.0526508577,
-0.0457910858,
0.0281573217,
0.0311911851,
0.0190092865,
0.016573377,
0.0110668754,
-0.0151043348,
-0.0441971719,
-0.0170937199,
-0.0504729412,
0.0220170524,
-0.0466722921,
-0.0360826515,
0.0276923794,
-0.0077543622,
-0.0142557835,
0.0232855622,
-0.0699027777,
-0.0476640798,
-0.027157627,
0.0458327904,
0.0102818208,
0.0225587357,
-0.0020914935,
0.0053337584,
0.0038646944,
-0.0015584658,
-0.0207487103,
-0.0099396249,
0.0835533142,
0.0116031533,
-0.0034273688,
0.0498206317,
-0.0471335128,
0.0302946884,
0.0356116742,
0.0355431624,
-0.0172593277,
-0.0292452592,
-0.0068991478,
-0.0037069605,
0.0699269548,
0.0049194177,
-0.0477526747,
-0.0460613184,
0.0618466921,
-0.0239307955,
-0.0458978266,
-0.0604451895,
0.0169635378,
-0.0205126628,
-0.0115919942,
0.008690224,
0.0322304368,
0.0096988603,
0.0250832252,
-0.02140861,
0.0025542118,
0.0380498543,
-0.0032979862,
-0.0288974419,
0.0228236355,
-0.0468285754,
-0.0257857535,
0.0769938082,
0.0417726524,
-0.0102365175,
0.0581370518,
0.0237253569,
-0.0200690851,
0.0464087129,
0.0596419089,
-0.0022374971,
0.009098745,
-0.0099569364,
-0.0268632825,
0.0385643728,
-0.0037255462,
0.0842321888,
-0.003032556,
0.00929006,
-0.0213976,
0.055222474,
-0.0078869592,
-0.0274097715,
0.0159521829,
0.0012201821,
-0.0182357002,
0.0193016548,
0.0716095567,
-0.0255604088,
-0.0041782269,
0.0063401507,
0.0029244747,
-0.0509516746,
-0.0205443818,
-0.0141417151,
0.0061282134,
0.0008122905,
0.0218785908,
-0.0162354354,
-0.0486951992,
-0.0173496939,
-0.0241289567,
-0.0019846654,
0.0098804329,
0.0213040449,
0.0289673582,
-0.0010846588,
-0.0156781748,
-0.0441139489,
-0.0252209064,
0.0242489986,
-0.0080726296,
-0.0259282272,
-5.538748281e-33,
-0.0196781531,
0.000869179,
-0.0106205903,
0.0181296859,
0.0087803127,
0.0194872823,
-0.03119912,
-0.0077066319,
-0.0137522211,
0.0128145237,
0.0245725233,
-0.0167746563,
0.0461320095,
0.0600056387,
0.022690041,
-0.0208059493,
0.0306408871,
0.0166761875,
-0.0474884287,
0.0367385112,
0.0617388114,
0.0024138207,
0.1107502431,
-0.0431806743,
0.0553241149,
0.0087004742,
0.0107507855,
0.0315709896,
0.080998376,
0.0488870479,
0.0082288627,
0.0709381476,
0.0238399822,
-0.102435112,
0.0051150215,
0.0515204519,
-0.1120808497,
-0.0431303568,
0.0450709946,
0.0476584807,
0.0073763914,
-0.0384564698,
-0.0433254689,
0.0072672665,
0.007547827,
0.0087765753,
0.0110159852,
-0.021421317,
0.0214139223,
-0.0108678052,
-0.0770461708,
0.0081352741,
-0.0140232136,
-0.0522181652,
0.0413640663,
0.0923848376,
0.0153911654,
-0.0463775396,
-0.0537154153,
0.0109172231,
-0.051706247,
0.0117479339,
0.0505960435,
0.0343188569,
-0.0029047013,
0.0499450453,
0.0050008954,
0.0192418043,
0.0695012808,
0.0169907231,
-0.0334610939,
0.0085220765,
0.0201813877,
0.0342562832,
0.0212086774,
0.0452894606,
-0.0737410188,
0.0185145736,
0.0326690897,
0.0144658685,
0.0138131101,
0.0060004955,
-0.0277977027,
-0.0492597222,
-0.0170333162,
-0.0002942435,
-0.0227108523,
-0.0223152973,
0.0370956622,
-0.0085793249,
-0.0094391173,
0.0295302756,
0.0665397123,
-0.0149699114,
-0.0160769541,
0.0337778442,
0.0084369797,
0.0282150228,
-0.0120544219,
0.0062170131,
-0.0605422519,
-0.0587260239,
0.028351577,
0.0282793827,
0.0400219597,
0.0068801478,
0.073177442,
0.0054104417,
-0.0502632633,
0.0130940909,
-0.0428438708,
0.0534220301,
-0.0426939726,
0.0814291537,
0.0116063375,
0.0057857586,
-0.043297708,
0.0726626366,
0.0248775836,
-0.0258608609,
-0.0276369955,
-0.0455906801,
-0.0018293048,
0.0090144239,
-0.0228663348,
0.0105898865,
-0.0074421684,
0.00797778,
-0.0095105674,
-0.0247147828,
0.0088111209,
-0.0075337808,
2.645e-7,
0.0100670159,
0.0183237921,
0.0380830653,
-0.0078159506,
0.0245924089,
0.0449010506,
-0.0099617448,
0.045391839,
0.0049784831,
-0.0110979537,
-0.0185508095,
0.008474418,
0.0755572841,
0.0448944122,
-0.1128163859,
-0.0079224417,
-0.0170459393,
-0.0106230648,
-0.0129964016,
0.0453921743,
0.073194541,
0.0868069381,
0.0028504091,
0.0049229492,
-0.0187577438,
-0.040572159,
0.0187135916,
-0.0319039039,
-0.0114167891,
0.0245630592,
0.0092229564,
0.0106473705,
-0.0122029362,
0.0553667098,
-0.0199739337,
0.0248749722,
0.0354861133,
0.0457698405,
0.0160130635,
-0.0498869978,
-0.0410469733,
0.0074401014,
0.0026908091,
-0.0123349018,
0.0716012865,
-0.079719156,
-0.0472420715,
-0.0163908917,
-0.007592761,
0.0224387515,
0.0290434025,
-0.0006869598,
-0.0085562235,
0.0115603106,
0.0425253473,
-0.01903411,
-0.0280823987,
-0.0484511703,
-0.0296620354,
0.026653517,
0.0015282684,
-0.0335889012,
0.0042239456,
-0.0708491132,
-0.0200946219,
-0.0427831225,
0.0164413545,
2.130445069e-34,
0.019723583,
-0.0011673467,
0.0147331245,
0.0419751666,
0.0147865536,
-0.0246302523,
-0.0469962396,
-0.0071090432,
0.0214582141,
-0.0260303915,
-0.0126741575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13527v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13527v2 | Aligning the Norwegian UD Treebank with Entity and Coreference Information | 2023-05-22T22:44:53 | 2023-05-25T22:36:36 | Tollef Emil Jørgensen, Andre Kåsen | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper presents a merged collection of entity and coreference annotated
data grounded in the Universal Dependencies (UD) treebanks for the two written
forms of Norwegian: Bokm{\aa}l and Nynorsk. The aligned and converted corpora
are the Norwegian Named Entities (NorNE) and Norwegian Anaphora Resolution
Corpus (NARC). While NorNE is aligned with an older version of the treebank,
NARC is misaligned and requires extensive transformation from the original
annotations to the UD structure and CoNLL-U format. We here demonstrate the
conversion and alignment processes, along with an analysis of discovered issues
and errors in the data - some of which include data split overlaps in the
original treebank. These procedures and the developed system may prove helpful
for future corpus alignment and coreference annotation endeavors. The merged
corpora comprise the first Norwegian UD treebank enriched with named entities
and coreference information. | [
0.0612994842,
0.0216913447,
-0.0067728488,
0.0407686867,
-0.0215468202,
0.0169194397,
-0.0312622786,
-0.0457639433,
-0.0402943343,
-0.0320450813,
0.0096333539,
-0.0399922989,
0.0419011787,
-0.0727532059,
0.0120160794,
-0.0573665015,
0.0544436984,
-0.0030043756,
-0.0293524414,
0.0007321425,
0.0205514543,
0.0530504361,
-0.0245022401,
-0.0019762667,
-0.0299562346,
-0.0170309171,
-0.0007825313,
0.0240316074,
0.0558575913,
0.0046274075,
0.006788318,
0.0265410375,
-0.0388625227,
0.045425415,
0.0000017677,
-0.0570340417,
-0.0222500134,
0.0092181331,
-0.0576922111,
0.0197547693,
0.0340785272,
0.0250712726,
-0.0177327543,
-0.0306964852,
0.0443190336,
-0.0177024901,
0.0795415789,
0.0084909825,
0.0316385776,
0.0265925787,
-0.0072458046,
-0.0483071506,
0.0246270131,
-0.0171724986,
-0.1031366587,
0.0005572675,
0.0144040566,
0.0620484203,
-0.004557916,
-0.0144312689,
-0.0084517719,
0.0306384582,
-0.0290910304,
-0.0165832154,
-0.0013732944,
0.0137475394,
-0.079864949,
-0.0378770269,
0.0401014611,
0.0382960774,
0.0480299406,
0.000118567,
0.0474908613,
0.0168141834,
-0.0405851454,
-0.0431201309,
-0.0051128394,
-0.0321368352,
-0.0346026644,
0.0054848166,
0.0739940554,
-0.0014907242,
-0.0183452889,
-0.011780588,
-0.0347470082,
0.072466284,
0.0088322954,
-0.0234924983,
0.0489597619,
0.0015238697,
-0.0092518982,
-0.0580798052,
0.000269656,
-0.0460027866,
0.0046353238,
0.0292281806,
-0.0156025505,
-0.0271257702,
0.0338896103,
-0.0367247611,
-0.0111853229,
-0.0169203933,
-0.0397763513,
0.0070950636,
0.0378953926,
0.0385806933,
-0.018312037,
-0.0145193739,
-0.019530667,
-0.0144657576,
-0.0351718105,
0.0055292663,
-0.0525463894,
-0.0148882074,
-0.024342021,
0.0212917179,
-0.0538776219,
-0.0195391476,
0.0503657386,
-0.0088374997,
0.0416917987,
-0.0338940136,
-0.0285394117,
0.0089983018,
-0.0299608223,
0.03470321,
0.0080121504,
0.0011154386,
-0.0911880806,
-0.038342163,
0.0434651375,
0.0296721105,
0.0270889048,
-0.0471372195,
-0.0065400274,
-0.0093669053,
-0.0059063253,
-0.0148818437,
0.0299441013,
-0.000538787,
-0.0384300575,
-0.03544778,
-0.0265926495,
-0.0607813522,
0.0487146452,
-0.0006504008,
-0.0101107163,
-0.0473715477,
0.0167153534,
0.0005607405,
-0.0347722024,
0.0070529403,
-0.0477104187,
0.0055535394,
-0.0177603103,
-0.0362243168,
0.0372352861,
0.0005592037,
0.0039337408,
-0.0338313393,
0.0487931855,
-0.0208201911,
-0.0696485341,
0.0324236117,
0.0228381921,
-0.0180174038,
0.0325402394,
0.0094808042,
-0.0872182474,
0.0117265219,
0.0333890207,
0.0350995436,
0.0178730413,
-0.0146564264,
0.0089068869,
0.035973534,
0.0323016979,
-0.0227343384,
-0.0191468317,
0.0271476805,
-0.0091248741,
-0.0200642161,
-0.0383661725,
-0.0078444881,
0.0297958255,
0.0063872198,
-0.0252139177,
0.041514501,
0.0581168905,
-0.012881129,
-0.0170164946,
0.0152097363,
-0.0479374789,
-0.0093434621,
0.0125803547,
-0.0151599683,
-0.0139936702,
0.0397177599,
0.0157084242,
-0.0567970723,
0.0180381704,
0.0705002844,
-0.0227789301,
0.0116946576,
0.0423029326,
0.0306511074,
-0.1117372587,
-0.0115370424,
-0.0000921607,
0.0454526432,
0.0054943268,
-0.0514680296,
0.0157215446,
-0.0191623233,
0.0145110628,
0.0418327376,
-0.0183229838,
0.0693902373,
-0.0261341445,
0.0009022786,
0.0151113346,
-0.0313639864,
-0.0286219828,
0.0086270897,
-0.0261561535,
0.0325112268,
-0.0297445562,
0.028802434,
0.0424007475,
0.0843082145,
-0.0520535372,
0.0300138798,
0.0250837747,
-0.037895672,
-0.0105695743,
0.0550321899,
0.0109892888,
0.0148600135,
0.026375344,
-0.0325175039,
-0.0158957355,
-0.0123907216,
0.0075289994,
-0.0603886135,
-0.0096832188,
0.0086119454,
0.0310905855,
0.0305214617,
0.0271875411,
0.0064274557,
0.0038692737,
-0.0313886665,
0.0490876324,
-0.0014049889,
0.0257771444,
-0.017057972,
-0.0107971737,
0.0515184067,
-0.0398878083,
-0.0129886456,
0.0286276191,
-0.0134388125,
-0.0275001712,
0.0529893711,
-0.0224660039,
-0.0245419536,
0.0359216705,
-0.0253488664,
0.0112782661,
-0.0296018384,
0.1096431911,
0.0428031161,
0.0258649904,
-0.0201913621,
-0.0185614787,
0.0035264012,
0.0119135482,
0.028027324,
-0.018908916,
-0.003964846,
-0.0035579025,
-0.0205866247,
-0.0381064266,
-0.002818034,
-0.0038555136,
0.0035901449,
-0.0253525116,
-0.1400940418,
-0.0382016525,
0.0799469724,
-0.0366976894,
0.0426553451,
0.0168673992,
-0.0106931645,
0.0028382984,
0.0262293722,
0.0499199592,
0.0162496977,
-0.0448236205,
-0.0504559986,
-0.0125990454,
-0.047214698,
-0.0397603959,
0.0007731437,
0.0245781746,
0.023208933,
-0.0477339625,
-0.020407578,
0.0179615337,
0.073059842,
0.0059399768,
-0.0139963375,
0.0069527947,
-0.0274563637,
-0.0477610901,
-0.0057668183,
-0.0159570333,
-0.0407807082,
-0.0328344405,
0.0758249834,
-0.0258888006,
0.0056963209,
0.0111739533,
-0.0319660716,
-0.0205358937,
-0.0568538718,
0.0144520747,
-0.015837213,
0.0607551523,
0.0189111941,
0.0087130629,
0.0377330594,
-0.0635739714,
0.0037399621,
0.0318446793,
0.0390576832,
0.014374584,
0.0346229486,
-0.0444302298,
0.0242938958,
-0.0157360248,
-0.0296559483,
-0.0106959185,
0.0262149554,
-0.0206302963,
-0.0127358763,
0.0028723732,
-0.0186525658,
0.0146823712,
0.0296910144,
-0.0267541204,
0.0006282915,
0.0170241613,
0.0591702312,
-0.0484872833,
0.0487645976,
0.0090132859,
0.0067801285,
-0.0082104653,
0.0764737725,
0.003954276,
-0.0101368837,
-0.0343698151,
0.014719151,
0.0267833527,
-0.0391335115,
0.0380000956,
-0.0451378301,
-0.0848597959,
-0.0362420753,
0.0171881225,
-0.0038028478,
-0.0181329455,
0.0500456244,
0.041942697,
0.0353052467,
0.0047190832,
-0.0008819913,
0.0034840477,
0.031031169,
0.0157677308,
-0.0421271995,
0.0191807784,
-0.0020545963,
-0.0080481973,
-0.0043893037,
-0.0580519512,
0.0043739509,
-0.063247472,
0.0108318068,
0.0275918469,
-0.0611200258,
-0.0117140133,
0.0061639319,
-0.0039573526,
-0.0681217834,
-0.0291572027,
0.0297359489,
0.0020902175,
0.0298907943,
0.0344321504,
-0.055910904,
-0.0441342592,
0.0143068107,
-0.0457135737,
0.0408697799,
0.0779288709,
0.0851192027,
-0.0154840341,
-0.0011035298,
0.0321602747,
-0.0712606609,
-0.0157097857,
0.0165624507,
0.0103358645,
0.0045820829,
-0.0139241656,
-0.0627718493,
0.0429284908,
-0.0076931869,
-0.0054680803,
0.0113761239,
0.0379588306,
0.0306406356,
0.0533135645,
0.0206995383,
0.0170081221,
0.0294576474,
0.0062935823,
-0.0116761578,
0.0101570152,
-0.0004402282,
-0.0001508815,
0.0096530868,
-0.0221949127,
-0.0157704744,
0.0687574893,
-0.0748847425,
0.0025732243,
-0.0655184463,
-0.0601821803,
-0.0134241739,
0.0271213837,
0.0221901834,
0.0255362187,
0.0195500888,
-0.0371839628,
-0.0198210217,
-0.0108657451,
-0.0205265786,
0.0212158393,
-0.0083109159,
0.0163455494,
0.0357880779,
0.0817579776,
-0.0009661472,
0.0310827792,
-0.0304693468,
-0.0528016128,
0.0448704548,
0.0084630158,
0.0203241557,
0.0527868085,
-0.0111604352,
-0.0295159332,
-0.0490543805,
-0.0040450185,
-0.0257506445,
0.0298046451,
-0.0352937579,
0.0185182095,
-0.0055778865,
0.0076983492,
-0.0029182446,
0.0370997004,
-0.0180093944,
0.0127434656,
0.0120920548,
-0.0122183012,
-0.002755583,
0.0345131606,
-0.0036249366,
-0.0596497878,
0.0254959427,
-0.0546069667,
0.0355324484,
0.0015044782,
-0.0334052965,
0.0285234172,
0.0105743343,
0.0212739911,
0.0036655988,
-0.0192759503,
0.0463996679,
-0.0671735108,
0.0496334955,
-0.0180960931,
0.0235175118,
0.1008501351,
0.0701148808,
0.0208754409,
0.0119972387,
0.0087530976,
0.0323817767,
0.0154244211,
0.078076981,
-0.0363229439,
-0.0059923907,
-0.0419490412,
-0.0089432644,
0.0012308438,
0.0055266572,
-0.0065198666,
0.0412291326,
-0.0198209193,
-0.0526200682,
0.0492560416,
-0.0080069816,
0.1432642937,
-0.0532259159,
0.0199144222,
0.0142566022,
0.0060200975,
-0.0172689483,
-0.0378656574,
0.0208228678,
-0.0067601767,
-0.0079889912,
0.0253674965,
0.0056734737,
0.0030533539,
0.0204514116,
0.0208696034,
-0.0192435514,
-0.0201568268,
-0.0448477305,
0.0360035449,
-0.050019078,
-0.0384053066,
-0.0225251429,
-0.0825172886,
-0.0342332572,
-0.0174922869,
0.0203596912,
0.0217024144,
0.0322830155,
-0.0116024166,
0.0138952201,
0.0367578194,
-0.0301236361,
-0.0394175164,
-0.0008007249,
-0.0689934418,
-0.0338582546,
-0.0141775217,
-5.532655547e-33,
-0.0535064824,
0.0108968541,
-0.0088731674,
-0.0171566177,
-0.0175932385,
0.0080614574,
0.0416320004,
0.0064783851,
0.0022405146,
-0.005885208,
-0.0036074631,
-0.0083732447,
0.0248941556,
-0.0236719381,
0.003884709,
0.0152910156,
0.0078853536,
0.0151043115,
-0.0127928192,
-0.0161930155,
0.0558897741,
0.0072843735,
0.1392434984,
-0.0867154449,
0.091000475,
-0.0014915321,
-0.0095922938,
0.0288992021,
0.0617149323,
0.017248841,
-0.0111933146,
0.0258875731,
0.0032511684,
-0.0037732506,
-0.0072903633,
-0.0049486118,
-0.1152989343,
0.0000876225,
0.0759923458,
0.0649670064,
0.0015846927,
-0.0170929823,
0.0047257654,
-0.0382643491,
0.0108524598,
0.0512888804,
-0.0028336938,
0.016669767,
-0.0064282943,
0.0027365219,
-0.0635574013,
0.0204459764,
-0.008389188,
0.027353311,
-0.0049672672,
0.0499763377,
0.0083441772,
-0.0812923238,
-0.0865182951,
0.012747799,
0.0024896616,
0.0130225206,
0.0473999865,
-0.0349426642,
-0.0444841459,
0.017550569,
-0.0171292145,
0.005358425,
-0.0034187343,
0.0447315425,
0.0271749012,
0.0283509009,
-0.0000887838,
0.0975993052,
0.0578434281,
-0.0060804393,
-0.0365667939,
0.0137558579,
0.0230389144,
0.0462039039,
-0.0260608755,
-0.0189266093,
-0.0272825416,
-0.0539963469,
-0.0239327364,
-0.0938348398,
0.004811448,
-0.0579601489,
0.0299253818,
-0.0557034314,
-0.0186382551,
0.0308216456,
0.0272189509,
-0.0313440971,
-0.0575325601,
-0.0121146487,
0.0227450617,
0.0358970165,
-0.0404792204,
0.0438817926,
-0.017315425,
-0.029900264,
0.0315071866,
0.0077478127,
0.0128971152,
0.0109523945,
0.0309399813,
-0.0091662798,
-0.0330880806,
0.0238098502,
-0.0114698317,
0.0252267979,
-0.0491349921,
-0.0139365029,
0.0587381981,
-0.0097437752,
0.0236781761,
-0.0197763108,
0.0841349289,
-0.0173543245,
-0.0196356308,
-0.0290904734,
0.0151656372,
0.0060673216,
0.0009106335,
0.0169496629,
-0.0006302259,
-0.032002449,
0.0222785193,
0.0176730156,
0.0231494978,
-0.0235194135,
2.422e-7,
0.0564034432,
0.0112449452,
0.095279038,
-0.068141669,
0.0272436552,
-0.0599063598,
0.0074704178,
0.0666903481,
-0.0298952051,
-0.0295763873,
0.0091337264,
-0.0778471828,
0.0055777049,
0.0295887031,
-0.09413293,
-0.0360311046,
0.0041970247,
-0.0192572512,
-0.0705031678,
0.0234835651,
0.0308912601,
0.0619085282,
-0.0116326241,
-0.0241955165,
-0.0449554883,
0.0396959074,
-0.0116470186,
-0.0169123244,
0.0023437424,
0.003913118,
0.0321316086,
-0.0224975329,
0.0444329791,
0.0031010979,
0.0118001616,
0.0360448509,
0.0210387446,
0.017879216,
-0.0009423254,
0.0321663953,
-0.0359786302,
-0.0294596273,
-0.0070002736,
-0.0138805667,
0.0359948389,
-0.033641994,
-0.0522365533,
-0.0178353507,
-0.0448484868,
0.0890485793,
-0.0345356725,
0.0358591974,
0.0239478983,
0.0459606647,
0.0446699038,
0.0032609722,
-0.0461082458,
-0.0240620878,
-0.0605422668,
0.0646227002,
0.0212338213,
-0.025900621,
0.0311058536,
0.0188904498,
-0.0460403934,
-0.032831531,
-0.0146051403,
2.082429109e-34,
-0.017893305,
0.0208959617,
0.0078471545,
0.0125580225,
0.0229652487,
-0.0436657667,
-0.0128073785,
0.0539070144,
-0.041022595,
0.0084157027,
-0.0194251891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18322v1 | REFinD: Relation Extraction Financial Dataset | 2023-05-22T22:40:11 | 2023-05-22T22:40:11 | Simerjot Kaur, Charese Smiley, Akshat Gupta, Joy Sain, Dongsheng Wang, Suchetha Siddagangappa, Toyin Aguda, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A number of datasets for Relation Extraction (RE) have been created to aide
downstream tasks such as information retrieval, semantic search, question
answering and textual entailment. However, these datasets fail to capture
financial-domain specific challenges since most of these datasets are compiled
using general knowledge sources such as Wikipedia, web-based text and news
articles, hindering real-life progress and adoption within the financial world.
To address this limitation, we propose REFinD, the first large-scale annotated
dataset of relations, with $\sim$29K instances and 22 relations amongst 8 types
of entity pairs, generated entirely over financial documents. We also provide
an empirical evaluation with various state-of-the-art models as benchmarks for
the RE task and highlight the challenges posed by our dataset. We observed that
various state-of-the-art deep learning models struggle with numeric inference,
relational and directional ambiguity. | [
0.0206167847,
0.0843801796,
0.0130347274,
0.0878827274,
-0.0078504346,
0.0192539413,
0.0228608772,
0.0373280384,
0.0058498872,
0.0093325153,
-0.0351322219,
-0.017558828,
-0.0364297666,
0.0100178868,
-0.0041053644,
-0.0164715946,
0.0253721531,
0.0234419741,
0.0376969762,
0.0163750462,
0.0052796821,
0.0286399592,
-0.0193852205,
-0.0171534978,
-0.0555046536,
-0.0262771882,
0.0191951524,
-0.0031562559,
0.0348000303,
-0.0277054477,
0.0092638321,
0.0307946131,
0.0265186336,
0.0121143898,
0.0000016469,
-0.0459676571,
-0.0263202135,
-0.0014223537,
-0.0644368231,
-0.010189971,
-0.0238720849,
-0.0520795956,
0.0676198974,
-0.0077647995,
-0.0730610341,
-0.0468110666,
0.030646164,
0.0814301148,
0.0490639172,
0.0774288774,
-0.0253007114,
-0.0782598928,
0.0352905318,
-0.0867858678,
0.0172025748,
-0.0553380959,
0.0404955931,
0.013796052,
-0.0338130184,
0.0005061359,
-0.0002318907,
0.0212701652,
0.0422057733,
-0.0063739573,
0.0230741128,
0.0121301487,
-0.0769480541,
-0.0057180068,
-0.0183726605,
0.1091256142,
0.033154957,
0.0635451749,
0.032011155,
-0.0151987998,
-0.0062006689,
0.0375133231,
0.0264465343,
0.0159174409,
-0.0365218446,
-0.0064680423,
0.0020487052,
0.0027409673,
0.0448903963,
0.012082316,
-0.0356369801,
-0.0056037889,
-0.0369418412,
-0.0333769992,
0.0500057563,
0.0229133256,
-0.017415842,
-0.0172029473,
0.0221457351,
0.0091196774,
0.0186775923,
0.0269040298,
-0.0465119928,
-0.02978101,
-0.0212875642,
-0.0668513179,
-0.0224604215,
-0.0055072811,
-0.0127499038,
0.0868429169,
-0.0408975109,
-0.0159107503,
-0.0137846265,
-0.0303512961,
0.0089374529,
-0.0125883603,
-0.0056360825,
0.014365783,
-0.0418441407,
0.0702967346,
-0.0677840486,
-0.0238919873,
-0.058310166,
-0.0020521409,
-0.0325497836,
0.0700370967,
-0.0060646939,
0.0070224232,
-0.0047337022,
-0.0184891652,
-0.0254436359,
-0.0057083801,
-0.0468560942,
0.0202366542,
-0.0227208212,
-0.0050995462,
0.0093934629,
-0.0153148547,
0.0226898454,
-0.0607867502,
0.0144938501,
0.0880898312,
0.0314694755,
-0.0605933666,
-0.024926912,
-0.0554912239,
0.0521707498,
-0.0193676241,
0.0078618526,
0.0018413704,
0.0777104869,
0.0158696901,
-0.0514871404,
-0.0217484534,
0.0411080196,
-0.0267487578,
-0.0522139668,
0.0792576149,
-0.0047984156,
-0.02212134,
-0.0025879915,
-0.0098058721,
0.0243888721,
0.0513597354,
0.0359826796,
-0.002977696,
0.0629768744,
0.0428830199,
-0.0281837527,
0.0543572865,
0.0296482705,
-0.0474935956,
0.0347132571,
0.0480835997,
-0.01086915,
0.0133733181,
0.0616256185,
0.0190695934,
-0.0259680301,
-0.0748095214,
0.0126877706,
-0.0075776675,
0.0522248559,
0.031282641,
0.0045529208,
0.0191653036,
0.056586016,
-0.0336220972,
-0.0290592406,
-0.0035075811,
0.014590703,
0.0309598949,
-0.0325155742,
-0.0011655459,
-0.0080319941,
0.0036244832,
0.0074909539,
-0.0005708722,
-0.0360627249,
0.0191269722,
0.0696562603,
0.0018893295,
-0.0455237664,
0.0703931898,
0.0409639739,
-0.024565259,
-0.002313447,
0.0330731943,
0.0280133709,
0.0382694863,
0.0392931029,
-0.0574940853,
-0.0162100978,
-0.0213584304,
-0.0191593058,
0.0616248213,
0.0444674678,
-0.0221622717,
0.0452569127,
-0.0288883895,
-0.0240645595,
0.0358558036,
-0.0032977394,
-0.0163620394,
0.0490917787,
0.0108992625,
0.0107245464,
-0.0279791895,
0.0425830744,
0.037744917,
-0.0211225953,
-0.0232206248,
0.0234490298,
0.0235123597,
-0.000293721,
0.0459524952,
-0.0261228476,
-0.0149355978,
0.0335675143,
-0.0141522316,
0.0088656573,
-0.013152278,
-0.0412980244,
-0.0262706783,
-0.0018676741,
-0.0237860456,
-0.0612101853,
0.0071499846,
-0.0534698516,
0.0042572855,
-0.0394022539,
0.0085205631,
0.0266931057,
-0.0299444161,
-0.0455777459,
0.0446708016,
0.0378042981,
0.0243034288,
0.0817056447,
-0.0236505326,
-0.0125159333,
-0.0135441208,
-0.0143899638,
-0.0059323399,
-0.0249941107,
0.0150997136,
-0.0112056332,
-0.0344385616,
-0.0077920142,
0.0192046836,
0.0169208087,
-0.0385736674,
0.0088232737,
-0.0414155312,
-0.0167703629,
0.0150666265,
0.036245022,
-0.0168362893,
0.0151152154,
0.0055337702,
-0.0180651043,
-0.0137522081,
0.0043273605,
-0.0403171554,
-0.017428264,
0.0809011906,
0.0120843761,
-0.0169326663,
-0.0367484652,
-0.0508915484,
-0.0134353861,
0.0297653899,
0.0413390584,
-0.0101194577,
0.0150128352,
0.0160855651,
-0.0280895289,
0.0266983639,
-0.0101580713,
0.0563308634,
-0.0347122662,
-0.0110588586,
-0.0097670108,
0.0255101938,
-0.0001633034,
0.0976005718,
-0.0732706338,
-0.0007411559,
-0.0093372045,
0.0449851789,
-0.0217198078,
0.0522215739,
-0.0062670428,
-0.0020445222,
-0.023840202,
0.0220223293,
-0.0291975588,
0.0068892282,
-0.0215799939,
0.0292764381,
0.0246820282,
0.0198285393,
-0.0356099866,
0.0346517079,
0.0205105059,
0.0277682822,
-0.0448838696,
0.0093035474,
0.0580890253,
0.0158505905,
-0.0202274639,
0.0087187057,
-0.0005973398,
-0.0581236221,
0.0665411353,
-0.026904339,
-0.0129555529,
-0.0048751039,
-0.0239705443,
-0.0120100658,
-0.0160697158,
0.0436271578,
-0.0125105418,
0.0634425282,
-0.0260175299,
0.0555458479,
-0.0109544182,
-0.0345125049,
-0.0444778502,
-0.063031882,
0.0032940821,
0.0205667466,
0.0093990713,
-0.0261724349,
-0.0173913371,
-0.0146939792,
-0.0226406455,
0.0196753647,
0.0028870082,
-0.0281733181,
0.0005897828,
0.068776913,
0.0934296623,
-0.0017866283,
0.0514935665,
-0.0111519415,
0.0275879521,
0.0059188814,
-0.0063958555,
-0.005970309,
-0.0061076987,
-0.0084592877,
-0.0494510271,
-0.0545154102,
0.017076388,
-0.0253367368,
-0.02365347,
-0.0774060264,
-0.0312782414,
0.063884072,
0.0035268485,
-0.0013921699,
0.006112163,
0.0500943139,
-0.0102097718,
-0.0130226156,
0.034383215,
-0.12730138,
-0.031398885,
-0.0214777403,
-0.0213155299,
0.0503186397,
-0.0911576822,
0.0085705342,
-0.1071742773,
0.0317432247,
-0.0322589017,
-0.0402417071,
-0.0238234568,
-0.0518270321,
-0.0202951021,
-0.0380356945,
0.0117061855,
0.0115304561,
-0.0342775397,
-0.0060020918,
-0.0035671508,
-0.0050189015,
-0.0159782879,
0.0080863703,
-0.0406262875,
-0.0134812631,
0.0047835056,
0.0060910773,
-0.0195171647,
0.0058577536,
-0.039525453,
-0.0185529683,
-0.0628137365,
-0.0161202084,
0.0947385505,
-0.03230533,
-0.0544258989,
-0.0214042794,
0.013448718,
-0.0843635723,
0.0367966443,
-0.0024443036,
0.0076868148,
0.0114177223,
-0.025357496,
-0.0162214376,
-0.0189829804,
-0.03347883,
0.0679874122,
-0.0115085933,
0.0002527699,
-0.0396184325,
-0.0016401849,
0.0084060663,
-0.0631565005,
0.0464056171,
-0.0356433205,
-0.0267247837,
0.0061991364,
-0.0711382478,
-0.1064589024,
0.038078472,
0.0175402518,
-0.0212390963,
-0.0220268164,
0.0658369362,
0.0057792473,
-0.0847311541,
0.0205565151,
-0.0277546886,
0.005575215,
0.0140299266,
0.0210098457,
-0.0024709064,
-0.0137072857,
-0.0651051775,
0.0195492599,
-0.0445457622,
-0.0058210092,
0.0096644731,
-0.0118590528,
0.0208504125,
0.025417326,
-0.0224832818,
0.0420409553,
-0.0132579682,
0.0826854259,
-0.0825029463,
-0.0359407365,
0.0333672613,
0.0065810131,
0.0057231607,
0.0394629538,
-0.0711304024,
0.0145087847,
-0.0027836671,
0.0311786663,
-0.0435495153,
-0.0105365068,
-0.0244496651,
0.0030731661,
0.0469487943,
0.0525061339,
-0.0075452616,
-0.0614487603,
0.0193507858,
-0.045702368,
0.0019506919,
-0.0386922993,
0.0272654593,
0.0300505534,
0.007630528,
-0.0421768241,
0.0068445825,
0.0435326137,
0.0098100565,
-0.0197236314,
-0.0181038659,
0.0358070098,
0.0120765995,
-0.0025371201,
-0.0589056201,
-0.0066058245,
0.0173990335,
0.0326638892,
0.0184956007,
-0.0073075364,
-0.0040913685,
0.0291488804,
0.000068049,
-0.0102443695,
-0.028822016,
-0.0161063056,
0.0218598917,
-0.0065116328,
0.0524389334,
0.0380919464,
-0.0326227173,
0.0112988129,
-0.0390722118,
0.0181910992,
0.0309039224,
0.033198569,
-0.0185900182,
-0.0016386177,
0.0303550847,
0.0167975761,
-0.0374766029,
0.0074583995,
0.0717530474,
-0.0069526974,
0.0539278984,
-0.0008493347,
-0.0354475901,
-0.0410483554,
-0.0445087329,
0.0302217342,
0.0017905519,
-0.005567275,
0.0138340835,
-0.0597945563,
-0.0565531887,
0.0056535308,
-0.0057641226,
-0.0233042706,
0.0331794843,
0.0223682281,
0.0487367399,
0.0613634214,
-0.0442301519,
-0.016120214,
0.0317170285,
-0.0655259937,
-0.0288973749,
-0.0597168952,
-5.587585296e-33,
-0.0259335209,
-0.0076451623,
0.0223311596,
0.0011443889,
-0.0314522646,
0.0382579789,
-0.0319489576,
-0.0416948572,
-0.0423840098,
0.0462918244,
-0.0088816797,
0.0407570787,
0.0084440876,
0.0346616171,
-0.0115487417,
-0.038697917,
0.0136231789,
-0.02836225,
0.0218387209,
-0.0017087925,
0.0320117325,
0.0704803467,
0.0531865656,
-0.0893914104,
0.0107275518,
-0.0240927432,
-0.0235948712,
0.0231362525,
0.0269166809,
0.0451345742,
-0.0175001826,
0.0124807199,
0.0143665113,
-0.0378324687,
0.0126790944,
-0.0184544604,
-0.1404442787,
-0.0377810188,
-0.0393942893,
0.0299562737,
-0.0471481308,
0.0356397964,
0.0597477853,
0.0096877897,
0.0443497598,
-0.0444666259,
0.0181249641,
-0.0131323161,
0.001009296,
-0.0760789812,
-0.0413528271,
0.038315028,
0.033380609,
0.0200181343,
0.0269923117,
0.0391516425,
0.0034334287,
-0.0103446245,
-0.0379961692,
-0.0401835181,
-0.0204816964,
-0.0041773762,
0.0042945757,
-0.0074355141,
-0.0000320292,
0.0427383669,
0.0193205867,
-0.0100589264,
-0.005846078,
0.0093923248,
0.0122048482,
0.0605794974,
0.0043546115,
0.0255958885,
0.0299560968,
-0.0007250271,
-0.0900663584,
0.0190616194,
0.0485528596,
0.031069098,
-0.0310756508,
-0.0097854435,
-0.0373865664,
0.0044230651,
0.010401261,
0.0052393521,
-0.0156116793,
0.0047986112,
-0.0007899623,
0.0249310285,
0.0170111675,
0.074457705,
-0.0184170324,
-0.0427015275,
-0.0640297979,
0.0388514921,
0.0134956725,
-0.0078203576,
0.0292905811,
-0.0275377519,
-0.0384146869,
-0.0288978275,
-0.0132932151,
-0.0117690815,
0.010196384,
0.0077230032,
0.0637859255,
-0.0470640324,
-0.0353127532,
-0.0209002662,
-0.015646806,
0.0230748001,
-0.0172776412,
0.0330068544,
-0.0085802237,
0.0591944866,
-0.0013374271,
0.0231898259,
0.0292511713,
0.031749092,
-0.0400030315,
0.0109422673,
0.018074736,
0.0445572697,
0.0443779081,
-0.0220652968,
-0.0058831903,
0.0431710184,
0.018598821,
-0.050846871,
-0.0196056981,
0.0268968288,
2.279e-7,
0.0445625633,
0.0362157635,
0.0745129809,
0.0633659288,
0.0109919915,
0.0256307963,
0.038013991,
0.017476311,
-0.0404358879,
-0.0046196859,
0.042379573,
0.0106258839,
0.0276325196,
0.0081040487,
-0.0496504009,
-0.0504408292,
-0.0767248794,
-0.0299181212,
-0.0718117952,
-0.0185078643,
0.0382660478,
0.0546236224,
0.0498836264,
-0.0169576909,
-0.0307398215,
-0.058411736,
0.0430912934,
-0.0342682786,
0.0250528157,
0.0060922764,
0.0159307327,
0.0043176403,
-0.0130243078,
0.0412703045,
-0.0096946573,
0.0534026995,
0.0234555863,
0.046021685,
0.014629811,
0.0098174019,
-0.0067051365,
-0.0156525634,
0.0027292052,
-0.0097313663,
0.0523151979,
-0.0540570281,
-0.0044024261,
0.0036778711,
-0.0522333756,
0.0096090855,
0.0202618856,
0.0282693487,
0.0278648324,
0.0170032699,
0.0416160114,
-0.0202791933,
-0.0058776662,
-0.0528124012,
0.0421055108,
0.0641177297,
-0.0156945623,
0.0477754772,
-0.0186415743,
-0.0061476943,
0.0014345013,
-0.0062192096,
-0.0071921921,
1.672249424e-34,
0.0043635955,
-0.0108914813,
-0.0320848338,
0.0356926583,
0.074692376,
-0.0189143308,
-0.058971107,
0.0365502983,
-0.0178297795,
-0.0680283681,
0.0338179357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13523v1 | A Study of Generative Large Language Model for Medical Research and Healthcare | 2023-05-22T22:37:24 | 2023-05-22T22:37:24 | Cheng Peng, Xi Yang, Aokun Chen, Kaleb E Smith, Nima PourNejatian, Anthony B Costa, Cheryl Martin, Mona G Flores, Ying Zhang, Tanja Magoc, Gloria Lipori, Duane A Mitchell, Naykky S Ospina, Mustafa M Ahmed, William R Hogan, Elizabeth A Shenkman, Yi Guo, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is enormous enthusiasm and concerns in using large language models
(LLMs) in healthcare, yet current assumptions are all based on general-purpose
LLMs such as ChatGPT. This study develops a clinical generative LLM,
GatorTronGPT, using 277 billion words of mixed clinical and English text with a
GPT-3 architecture of 20 billion parameters. GatorTronGPT improves biomedical
natural language processing for medical research. Synthetic NLP models trained
using GatorTronGPT generated text outperform NLP models trained using
real-world clinical text. Physicians Turing test using 1 (worst) to 9 (best)
scale shows that there is no significant difference in linguistic readability
(p = 0.22; 6.57 of GatorTronGPT compared with 6.93 of human) and clinical
relevance (p = 0.91; 7.0 of GatorTronGPT compared with 6.97 of human) and that
physicians cannot differentiate them (p < 0.001). This study provides insights
on the opportunities and challenges of LLMs for medical research and
healthcare. | [
0.0661825463,
0.0356682613,
0.0072505665,
-0.0225712042,
-0.0282092411,
0.0121551724,
-0.0116281649,
0.0408373177,
0.0347146951,
-0.0229099859,
-0.00948912,
-0.0514996797,
-0.0028924772,
0.0540805534,
0.033808507,
-0.0475334153,
0.0375888236,
0.0149041377,
0.0428418517,
0.0027476766,
-0.0115500623,
0.0211709552,
-0.030401418,
0.0557045378,
0.0338477157,
-0.0189209152,
0.0504355133,
-0.022811478,
0.0066354144,
-0.0714843348,
-0.0284937508,
0.0420375206,
-0.0233070739,
-0.003111766,
0.0000020377,
-0.0557763278,
-0.0151205966,
0.0438374132,
-0.0131387347,
-0.0058892332,
0.0975767151,
-0.01752422,
-0.0333943628,
0.0346771181,
-0.043209713,
-0.0340504572,
0.0180469863,
0.075722605,
0.025203051,
0.075640142,
-0.0306351669,
-0.0467119962,
0.035334263,
-0.0266889222,
0.0359592028,
-0.0353513546,
0.0329961888,
0.0319262147,
0.0441029593,
0.0284794457,
0.0130869662,
0.0326566957,
-0.0338646993,
0.0345043018,
0.0277761016,
0.0650715232,
-0.0424001738,
-0.0196511634,
0.0038779471,
0.04278652,
-0.0126114041,
-0.0213540308,
0.0428599678,
0.0185165647,
-0.0070449989,
-0.0003057261,
-0.0348329395,
0.0309389699,
-0.0404512659,
0.0230841544,
0.023572661,
-0.0132937375,
0.0296339523,
-0.0254827347,
-0.0058596772,
-0.0268453322,
0.0461811423,
-0.0213057678,
-0.0170051735,
-0.0275476985,
-0.0272970814,
-0.0224080309,
0.0324455462,
0.0144660575,
-0.0425435007,
0.0198126193,
-0.0138439331,
-0.0148202572,
0.1002873555,
-0.084408924,
0.0034995743,
0.0038418705,
0.0166796111,
0.0290460605,
-0.0419719405,
0.0066048899,
-0.0420064479,
0.0063483003,
-0.0415274277,
0.017930977,
-0.0513101444,
-0.0373213664,
-0.0149979768,
0.0018724137,
-0.0347668231,
-0.0396345705,
-0.0988613963,
-0.0078891981,
0.0152247427,
-0.0262203254,
0.0234734677,
0.0339579023,
-0.034247838,
-0.0069393003,
-0.0085145244,
-0.0091105355,
0.0192218572,
0.0058451751,
-0.0324561968,
-0.0680820197,
0.0263902359,
-0.0024924388,
-0.0047729989,
-0.0000607863,
0.0190850906,
0.0745407119,
0.0060978499,
-0.0242840052,
-0.0048714275,
-0.0139151877,
-0.0337690935,
-0.0134153338,
0.0137237357,
-0.0720772892,
0.0415058583,
0.0064542042,
0.0184700005,
-0.0263639055,
0.0124609713,
0.0367792919,
-0.0508643165,
0.0421947911,
-0.0563278347,
0.0377459973,
0.0248082653,
0.0124398945,
0.0280849915,
0.0058009955,
0.038948983,
-0.0511400253,
-0.0180250369,
-0.0428840108,
0.0183097143,
-0.0030543488,
-0.0199583583,
-0.0490527526,
0.0025534388,
0.006012212,
0.0338562503,
0.0776838139,
-0.018188199,
0.1048426852,
-0.0169819053,
0.0028268925,
0.0260617919,
0.0511216149,
0.0390665941,
0.0520283207,
0.0217803847,
-0.0069668614,
0.0180286672,
-0.040010877,
0.0226590931,
-0.0078263488,
-0.0034685314,
0.0179437865,
0.0078537343,
0.021902658,
-0.0194802284,
-0.0111898314,
-0.0459986553,
0.0152573483,
-0.019655874,
-0.0506698079,
0.0272172447,
-0.0051796702,
-0.0599228516,
0.0207350682,
0.0499730594,
-0.0517156124,
-0.0066731875,
-0.0678818896,
-0.0203976724,
0.0744940192,
0.0674958006,
-0.0191730093,
-0.020092696,
-0.0262137819,
-0.02786351,
0.0486758277,
0.0020466754,
0.0069955564,
-0.0149803935,
-0.0502463281,
0.0112490365,
0.0435507409,
0.0098996032,
-0.0212012064,
0.0123484479,
0.0256329849,
-0.0043401299,
-0.0217213482,
-0.0199103411,
0.0341053978,
-0.0708399191,
-0.0133528067,
0.0047828476,
-0.0612823777,
0.0444802195,
0.0258899052,
-0.0199598894,
0.0482885987,
0.0186625794,
-0.0365515985,
-0.0315221772,
0.0114690922,
-0.0418347456,
-0.0410475284,
0.0088126585,
-0.054288011,
0.0179881025,
-0.033333689,
0.0058743488,
-0.0375534967,
-0.0313067921,
-0.0698157102,
0.0491483845,
-0.0223951973,
0.0166602023,
0.0240460914,
0.0163181238,
-0.0518664233,
0.0277084,
0.0105736731,
0.0045171632,
0.0249265376,
-0.0248585753,
0.0088817589,
-0.0268136412,
-0.0269654766,
0.0394913703,
0.0042752419,
0.0091583664,
-0.0237428006,
0.0289981663,
-0.0157846715,
-0.0614718869,
-0.1130657643,
0.0039181006,
0.0448938645,
0.0142816966,
0.0366576537,
0.0017255694,
-0.0155800581,
0.0242036432,
-0.042399507,
-0.0224742256,
0.0341241024,
0.0024708272,
0.020820111,
0.0196332708,
0.0003493808,
-0.0116435206,
0.0062551373,
-0.0392169282,
0.0315370969,
0.0400870927,
-0.0321263075,
0.0020036781,
0.0236394107,
-0.0058965376,
-0.0217260476,
0.0171944704,
-0.033740893,
0.0129286246,
-0.0112463394,
0.088333644,
0.0144902533,
0.0127310958,
-0.003337973,
0.0073068296,
-0.0054495074,
0.006572844,
-0.0014321456,
-0.0459593609,
-0.0438251607,
-0.0071849185,
-0.0785316974,
0.0042301216,
0.0603263862,
0.0392522775,
-0.0121401595,
-0.0536593832,
-0.0158314016,
-0.0413936861,
0.0277342107,
-0.0223219302,
0.0189365372,
-0.0445837267,
0.0189618692,
0.0121910293,
-0.0270330124,
0.0588927828,
-0.0203547273,
0.0342353322,
-0.1045972779,
-0.0058088391,
-0.0384556539,
-0.0040733069,
0.0026351637,
0.018207239,
0.0121903792,
-0.0207367912,
0.0263504237,
0.0358385295,
-0.0070886975,
-0.0502350219,
0.0565720387,
-0.0201682951,
0.0211916957,
0.0069256611,
-0.0159992706,
-0.026470447,
0.0012976532,
-0.023785742,
-0.0004837158,
0.0430541448,
0.0085098865,
-0.0490981415,
0.0277689584,
-0.0091514494,
0.0618713051,
-0.0006065156,
-0.0158751365,
-0.0019815082,
-0.0195492338,
0.0252872445,
-0.0113553209,
-0.0129081542,
0.0092249578,
0.0367904007,
0.0602093972,
-0.0097041475,
0.0289855022,
-0.0084789572,
-0.0042127478,
0.0095230518,
-0.0331495255,
-0.0110793607,
0.0170473009,
0.014532744,
-0.0402717665,
0.0000814395,
0.1209729016,
0.0269059669,
-0.059426479,
0.0207690112,
-0.0085376473,
-0.0185952298,
-0.023420915,
0.0132870618,
-0.0452226736,
-0.0288143344,
-0.0128601352,
0.0138659906,
-0.0494468808,
-0.0060886587,
0.0008245254,
-0.0500889011,
0.0170755535,
0.0159824193,
-0.0325454921,
0.0027209076,
-0.0458621196,
-0.0221185684,
-0.0063008466,
-0.002986785,
0.0111690247,
-0.0499732532,
0.0102685746,
0.0032327438,
-0.0970112234,
-0.0989020765,
0.0183778442,
-0.0027392409,
0.0988666639,
0.0421178229,
0.0361964032,
-0.0353666209,
-0.0151485577,
0.0418130942,
0.0039482396,
0.0113896932,
-0.017309878,
0.0610670075,
0.0201867167,
-0.0037377458,
-0.077517733,
0.0285956953,
-0.0510994978,
-0.0168624893,
-0.006718263,
0.0752428919,
-0.0326675363,
-0.0275671352,
-0.0525987968,
0.043491032,
0.0008537164,
0.0463921912,
-0.0198702291,
-0.0049832133,
-0.0345351622,
0.0081370678,
0.0332960263,
0.0057252464,
-0.0491800532,
0.0259347633,
-0.0136060361,
-0.0090648169,
-0.0576156676,
-0.0095441388,
0.0416580215,
-0.0285008475,
0.0361584798,
0.0556251854,
0.0244903117,
-0.0056570359,
-0.0465383008,
0.0395362601,
0.0284277629,
-0.0067004305,
-0.0763792098,
-0.0445663594,
0.0714756921,
-0.0175730269,
-0.0122079104,
0.0178044997,
0.0023120171,
-0.0172791518,
-0.002592324,
0.0330873989,
0.0186117776,
-0.039820265,
-0.0000262664,
-0.0228095837,
0.0105267465,
0.0420497544,
-0.0367571041,
-0.0213770848,
-0.0403165966,
0.0209699888,
0.0111658759,
-0.0150652602,
-0.0048462432,
0.0469586216,
0.0090276003,
0.0440896563,
0.0259468779,
-0.0061901645,
0.0177151114,
0.0534197986,
0.0162333306,
-0.032892298,
0.0324597843,
-0.0501809642,
-0.0308583491,
-0.0573389828,
0.066766344,
-0.0416135192,
0.0187945962,
0.0460051037,
0.0078844847,
-0.0375263542,
-0.0185165461,
-0.0922321007,
-0.0285920538,
-0.0224968921,
0.0548877828,
-0.0039386051,
-0.0071581239,
0.0430051014,
-0.0402032658,
-0.0199107137,
-0.0030083708,
-0.0480026491,
-0.0138135487,
-0.0043098577,
0.0537125096,
-0.0056021856,
0.0126162134,
0.0013575047,
0.0707925856,
-0.0248358026,
-0.0304535087,
-0.0157123562,
0.0399842896,
0.0449119695,
0.025215324,
0.052638825,
-0.0489323623,
0.0199869201,
-0.0488930792,
0.0442589708,
-0.0120380735,
0.014930469,
0.0195237771,
-0.0062981742,
-0.0299624838,
-0.0741292983,
0.1046836972,
0.0404642969,
0.0220290013,
0.0003912456,
-0.0437585972,
-0.0369331911,
-0.0266542267,
-0.0179079287,
-0.0143693518,
-0.0685191154,
0.0377631448,
-0.0631704107,
-0.0235465728,
0.0094385343,
-0.0040389309,
-0.0044978815,
-0.0410242192,
0.0437300839,
0.0316906497,
-0.0116761615,
-0.0288167968,
-0.0273819696,
0.0561311468,
-0.0159634929,
-0.0115478355,
0.0214772057,
-5.694556752e-33,
0.0261896029,
-0.0249383859,
0.0349076465,
-0.0403675698,
-0.0304553006,
0.0220640805,
-0.0339070447,
0.0023702127,
0.0096936338,
0.0414710827,
-0.0452350788,
0.0077314479,
0.0092328722,
0.0534206815,
0.0089793187,
-0.0009692142,
0.0336948633,
0.0200986061,
0.022876652,
0.0469368435,
-0.0233472716,
0.0470756404,
0.0617123395,
-0.0621591993,
-0.0147926193,
-0.0246000476,
0.0193239171,
-0.0194306504,
-0.016846275,
0.0487024449,
-0.0667561665,
0.0344633982,
0.0580301061,
-0.0186266713,
-0.0154970661,
-0.0020792012,
-0.0252975971,
0.0065385597,
0.0414985269,
-0.0423835851,
-0.0195031539,
-0.0474973023,
0.0555761755,
-0.0227820612,
-0.0489988104,
0.012919995,
0.0124147749,
-0.0388708673,
-0.0266555194,
-0.032384228,
-0.0581035614,
0.0580375977,
0.0340848267,
0.0223352276,
-0.0272541754,
-0.0190237109,
-0.0731482878,
0.0431696102,
-0.0003885056,
-0.0046856441,
0.0388784334,
0.0087170247,
-0.0163510814,
-0.0421676263,
0.0084552625,
0.0591920689,
0.0087048039,
0.0188817102,
-0.0458115079,
0.0022348063,
-0.0492555015,
0.0345819816,
0.0527291074,
0.0372844972,
0.0163848903,
-0.0685816184,
-0.0857005343,
0.02781027,
-0.0607084036,
0.0291721914,
0.0645918623,
-0.0282644741,
-0.040947929,
-0.0156878009,
-0.0187370367,
0.0203258526,
-0.0104268128,
-0.0208325349,
0.0493956283,
-0.0111169145,
0.0517760701,
-0.0016565283,
0.0222286191,
-0.0085083796,
0.0223788358,
-0.0303629767,
0.0175579451,
0.0127297174,
-0.0546381511,
0.0106652565,
-0.0494110286,
-0.0405036882,
0.0263888966,
0.0088338479,
0.0340459011,
-0.0112478789,
-0.0227659568,
-0.044930961,
-0.0530039147,
-0.0032559794,
0.0102172764,
0.00202953,
0.0002431219,
0.049639754,
0.0257053319,
0.0232646484,
0.0186724346,
0.0503127724,
-0.001260392,
-0.0153753078,
-0.0345868245,
-0.0180188864,
0.0054632835,
0.0216600746,
-0.0327110551,
0.0361445323,
-0.0348014571,
0.0568733588,
0.0318342075,
-0.0536582209,
-0.0090783797,
-0.0046401583,
2.811e-7,
0.0844680294,
0.0707219541,
-0.0166916512,
-0.0145513322,
0.0471988209,
-0.0063882391,
0.0206903629,
0.0309511591,
-0.0039275875,
0.0178263877,
0.011876286,
0.0000360164,
0.0355855227,
0.0176188387,
-0.083669357,
-0.0004324177,
-0.0883393884,
-0.023306042,
-0.0325472355,
-0.0239943676,
0.0685916319,
0.0691092461,
-0.0652421638,
-0.0250387322,
0.0351515524,
-0.0217254404,
0.0360994041,
-0.0501714684,
-0.0135850934,
0.0721686259,
0.0350373127,
0.0024434878,
0.0392638184,
0.0459994078,
-0.0111677321,
-0.0105887791,
0.0174603779,
0.1038129553,
-0.0590719692,
0.0316464156,
0.076908417,
-0.0147742378,
0.0150118433,
-0.0612110645,
0.0362381674,
-0.0369845666,
-0.0623438954,
-0.0048521138,
-0.0159891956,
-0.0263465177,
0.0582415611,
-0.0301568136,
-0.0324327014,
0.0191302858,
0.0244808644,
0.0134551479,
-0.040169917,
-0.0520955846,
0.0089076702,
0.0329973139,
-0.062787801,
-0.0274372734,
0.0178595353,
-0.0107754031,
0.0404215939,
-0.0522514544,
0.0156290401,
2.4412708e-34,
0.047887329,
0.0023052106,
0.0286286771,
0.0190971028,
0.0365730301,
0.0093105314,
0.0380882956,
0.0183838252,
-0.0039259135,
-0.0791927204,
-0.0054627424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13521v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13521v2 | CEO: Corpus-based Open-Domain Event Ontology Induction | 2023-05-22T22:26:47 | 2024-01-27T21:06:23 | Nan Xu, Hongming Zhang, Jianshu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing event-centric NLP models often only apply to the pre-defined
ontology, which significantly restricts their generalization capabilities. This
paper presents CEO, a novel Corpus-based Event Ontology induction model to
relax the restriction imposed by pre-defined event ontologies. Without direct
supervision, CEO leverages distant supervision from available summary datasets
to detect corpus-wise salient events and exploits external event knowledge to
force events within a short distance to have close embeddings. Experiments on
three popular event datasets show that the schema induced by CEO has better
coverage and higher accuracy than previous methods. Moreover, CEO is the first
event ontology induction model that can induce a hierarchical event ontology
with meaningful names on eleven open-domain corpora, making the induced schema
more trustworthy and easier to be further curated. | [
-0.0117707048,
0.0188563969,
0.0178223848,
0.0617067851,
-0.0059186085,
0.0110631436,
-0.0437697433,
0.0058771139,
0.0636310056,
-0.0454694293,
0.0308858622,
0.0185211394,
-0.0566821247,
0.0471361876,
-0.0086593041,
-0.0244821925,
0.0479582064,
0.0385354273,
-0.0626371503,
0.0311269052,
0.0325532779,
0.018413661,
-0.0014129225,
0.0272901636,
-0.0076488531,
0.0077539179,
-0.0325545035,
-0.036944136,
0.0113833807,
-0.0362991504,
-0.0058674463,
0.0432825126,
0.0512768701,
0.0284632612,
0.0000017456,
-0.0869108737,
-0.0251620971,
-0.0169655979,
0.0248475075,
-0.0254529566,
0.0006620043,
-0.0427010059,
0.0223751683,
-0.0279472694,
-0.011951807,
-0.014678577,
0.0382735096,
0.0690598488,
-0.0066457535,
0.0580997393,
-0.0264221709,
-0.0096846232,
0.0427617654,
0.0137469256,
-0.0204952378,
-0.0202891733,
-0.0171659384,
-0.0082592489,
-0.0226384774,
-0.0061490373,
0.0210989341,
-0.0311321747,
-0.0244168825,
0.0150717413,
0.034780141,
0.0186226368,
-0.0520463176,
-0.0252514239,
0.0087011205,
0.0389883444,
0.0078596985,
-0.0325279608,
0.0143335685,
-0.0088370098,
0.0016622497,
0.0198859237,
-0.0265065171,
0.0193990394,
-0.007407655,
0.0415293612,
0.0735613555,
0.046923589,
0.0002760773,
0.0139543684,
0.0133644175,
0.0825341418,
0.0095209815,
-0.0143284854,
-0.017267691,
0.0239848364,
-0.0208935365,
-0.0407606438,
0.0067568771,
0.0192467272,
-0.0333466902,
0.036848601,
-0.0256189182,
0.0393773429,
0.011555546,
-0.069705233,
-0.0219953377,
0.0340594836,
-0.0050859228,
0.0345127955,
0.0111511536,
-0.0161618926,
-0.0112325344,
0.0176705457,
-0.0007072872,
-0.0091386726,
-0.0663494691,
0.0600547157,
-0.0228908435,
0.0358268172,
-0.0241052359,
-0.0176299736,
-0.0234395359,
0.0043418496,
0.014973674,
-0.0102795092,
-0.0043990822,
0.0202072021,
-0.0456034318,
-0.0001725711,
-0.0477563962,
-0.0476953797,
-0.0460435972,
0.0047473381,
-0.0202072002,
-0.0211288445,
0.0006982757,
0.0012486865,
0.029807914,
0.0249412581,
-0.0693510696,
0.0182081871,
0.0167693943,
-0.0462477058,
-0.0826166496,
-0.0693793222,
-0.0189974457,
0.0130703673,
-0.010814582,
-0.0521464124,
0.0033770823,
-0.032116618,
0.0058515659,
-0.0385964476,
0.0278917179,
0.0155526139,
-0.0477791131,
0.0441612229,
-0.0728404075,
-0.0185656026,
-0.0117871994,
-0.0056606182,
-0.0193195902,
0.0460580811,
0.0325963199,
0.0281350669,
0.0869099721,
0.0462047495,
-0.0289422981,
-0.0090989769,
0.0183425397,
0.006794834,
0.0295820087,
0.0089503182,
-0.0235729665,
0.0465767235,
0.0376840346,
-0.0436879769,
-0.002329987,
0.0134345088,
0.0183836613,
0.0292363092,
-0.0287485905,
-0.0215565208,
0.0076902034,
0.0102743376,
-0.0402700119,
0.0064629256,
-0.0036325089,
-0.013826998,
0.0020058586,
-0.0019000525,
0.0440173745,
-0.0289650522,
-0.0174204614,
-0.0050838976,
-0.0213118047,
-0.0223545507,
-0.0487940013,
-0.0034928555,
0.0342320837,
0.0334829986,
0.0095828557,
0.0794746727,
0.0727437958,
-0.0580378249,
0.0217878968,
0.0168309081,
0.0270542838,
0.023329895,
0.0280280933,
-0.0589414127,
-0.0362931378,
0.0009150619,
0.0045386311,
0.0652734265,
0.0113626057,
-0.0500913523,
-0.0120704584,
-0.0334978029,
-0.0062783044,
0.0150113478,
0.0343938246,
-0.0019276532,
0.0231482387,
-0.023439642,
0.0056220135,
-0.0059061041,
-0.0253495406,
0.0420820639,
-0.0183913708,
-0.0409120321,
-0.0340750478,
0.0156281162,
0.0074125989,
0.0360907987,
0.0257166401,
-0.0056000832,
0.0334519185,
-0.0384145007,
-0.0486189052,
0.0556299351,
-0.0014084789,
-0.0377940238,
0.0496307239,
0.0018064782,
-0.0091805179,
0.0323149152,
-0.0287120212,
-0.0268562008,
0.0103794271,
0.0233993735,
0.0670676604,
-0.0504630357,
-0.0125670554,
0.003943786,
-0.0379202291,
-0.016917808,
0.0871146247,
-0.0047071166,
0.0163577925,
-0.0135397771,
-0.0080247624,
0.0449392349,
-0.0226145461,
-0.044959031,
0.0172542129,
-0.0119896689,
-0.004473926,
0.0481729619,
-0.0316992477,
-0.0924364626,
0.031529855,
-0.0749741495,
0.036753308,
-0.0047832807,
0.048293449,
0.0468850806,
-0.0017807151,
0.0091591319,
0.012721722,
-0.0105317878,
-0.0600273386,
-0.0549993329,
-0.0013062053,
0.0514464639,
-0.0124053927,
0.0068465783,
-0.028183423,
0.0189415421,
-0.0588894151,
0.0749426782,
0.0124812787,
0.013231474,
-0.0290946793,
0.0227550622,
-0.0143773993,
0.0223187432,
0.0329349674,
0.0186115466,
-0.0123510724,
-0.0036761526,
-0.0044856113,
0.0135509316,
0.0026423526,
0.0280646272,
0.0177127291,
-0.0132597992,
-0.0200583208,
-0.0176840741,
-0.0493542254,
-0.010500825,
0.0114212679,
0.008753879,
0.0222137067,
0.0439729504,
-0.0121044628,
-0.0435948037,
-0.0718156993,
-0.0343904682,
-0.0614138655,
0.0349262394,
-0.0324374288,
-0.0115874382,
-0.0566174574,
0.044396691,
-0.0291809198,
-0.0064089051,
0.0353539586,
-0.0091161737,
0.0361204818,
-0.0409901589,
0.0085922768,
-0.0608180389,
0.0775555074,
-0.0377099365,
0.0313380957,
0.0497740544,
-0.0607448481,
0.0070360852,
0.0174850188,
0.0170539096,
0.0003182224,
0.0269716159,
-0.0156735815,
0.0288959499,
0.037014965,
-0.0039759483,
-0.0467799343,
-0.0020013794,
0.0043246043,
0.0419125669,
0.0023672602,
0.0230590682,
-0.0267983805,
-0.008134787,
-0.025483897,
0.0215406902,
0.0418629125,
-0.0416571461,
-0.0137448441,
0.0590861104,
0.0179849137,
0.0166286863,
-0.0147409532,
0.0326149613,
-0.0208367743,
0.0283477753,
0.0488184653,
-0.0227298327,
-0.0287016705,
0.0271015279,
-0.000861162,
-0.0965421572,
-0.0112556908,
-0.0113664865,
0.0210984945,
-0.0222196523,
0.0002406929,
0.0862789378,
0.0657886267,
0.0036298374,
0.0373119265,
0.0261196513,
-0.0104996273,
0.0243041515,
-0.0302098673,
-0.0764923766,
-0.0354071222,
-0.024396617,
-0.0096614901,
0.0030330364,
-0.0657465532,
0.008765365,
-0.0652501062,
0.0078825681,
-0.0128707802,
-0.0265222769,
-0.0062954747,
-0.0596982129,
0.046206221,
-0.0660688952,
-0.03167326,
-0.0109485434,
0.0119829951,
-0.0209613033,
-0.0079871472,
-0.0667756349,
-0.0523309708,
0.0305799022,
-0.0608738065,
-0.0007260454,
-0.0371554345,
0.0577191524,
0.0057803621,
0.058847107,
-0.0310304184,
-0.0561548211,
-0.0057144663,
0.0205220133,
0.0410620049,
-0.0218888782,
0.0153330555,
-0.0170828588,
0.0542373247,
-0.0492519923,
-0.0361652188,
-0.0222015977,
0.0958513319,
0.0082378564,
0.0321456827,
0.0134147396,
-0.0201515108,
0.0231663994,
0.0226475559,
-0.0352828503,
0.0128205437,
0.0422125421,
0.0061164256,
-0.0038655573,
-0.0196667984,
-0.0088165691,
0.0226007756,
-0.0519951619,
-0.0971187949,
-0.0764173344,
-0.0777762979,
-0.0106035769,
-0.0107063483,
-0.0095124692,
-0.0054534799,
0.0159779079,
-0.0051665762,
-0.0400440544,
0.0972041413,
-0.0516497791,
-0.0259378459,
0.0149575025,
-0.0102805048,
0.0518849045,
0.0426705778,
-0.0263719186,
0.0290402938,
0.0037995868,
-0.0606778897,
-0.0100734932,
-0.044906009,
0.0056916582,
0.0221038945,
-0.0124516273,
-0.0007525973,
0.044855319,
-0.0010999831,
-0.0708606988,
-0.0406319797,
0.0257712677,
-0.0054589668,
-0.0035597594,
0.0570789278,
-0.0017760393,
0.0387219638,
-0.0525420643,
0.0774199441,
-0.0121519072,
-0.0127960034,
0.0413965993,
-0.0042406823,
0.0532704294,
-0.0376982875,
-0.0473639295,
-0.0807265267,
-0.0257621519,
0.0106335757,
-0.0034824996,
-0.0062521393,
0.0489023514,
-0.0332477055,
-0.0073459488,
-0.0262620449,
0.0589298904,
-0.0756505057,
0.0157869142,
-0.0397761576,
-0.0028284448,
0.038378641,
0.0140231177,
-0.007151572,
0.0217119772,
-0.0471227914,
-0.0077214884,
-0.0301730148,
-0.0267018545,
-0.0559260398,
-0.0017723847,
0.00416516,
0.0454675145,
-0.0107740005,
-0.0139409071,
-0.0261745658,
0.0594788082,
-0.0290284865,
-0.0057442132,
0.1055430248,
-0.0564718284,
0.0464888476,
-0.0341769084,
-0.0163962934,
0.0187225472,
0.0432136506,
-0.0078812437,
-0.0175850764,
0.0013544438,
0.0042224382,
-0.0326481313,
0.0053961519,
0.0544566438,
-0.0395120643,
0.0529077165,
0.0081269769,
0.0000546998,
-0.0286305193,
-0.016756542,
0.0794765502,
0.0612305179,
-0.0410258323,
0.0158300828,
-0.051735688,
-0.0121082077,
0.047550302,
-0.0254312567,
-0.035469044,
0.0194605999,
0.0623270497,
0.0226462502,
0.0377596393,
0.0070841801,
-0.0131116649,
-0.0244395584,
-0.0115861464,
-0.0089384466,
-0.0101247327,
-5.798729796e-33,
-0.0016584296,
-0.0383484662,
0.0188659672,
0.0668003634,
0.0104866736,
0.0022562293,
-0.0149102807,
-0.0037572486,
-0.0023596527,
0.026586337,
0.0022515804,
0.0120655037,
0.0095260916,
-0.0101359487,
0.0167958476,
-0.0264625158,
0.0080598481,
-0.0047258711,
-0.0010192966,
0.0020270215,
0.1031865478,
0.0247098934,
0.0657126084,
-0.0623265468,
0.0595747232,
0.0104629565,
0.0100600226,
-0.0020339419,
0.0909653381,
0.0568881743,
-0.0072591961,
0.0635626614,
0.0393297486,
-0.0437651128,
0.0174763724,
-0.0093531208,
-0.0497057177,
-0.0557238907,
0.0190381948,
-0.0140265999,
0.0118588638,
-0.0258551277,
-0.0057611805,
0.0075809392,
0.0348751433,
-0.0324229486,
0.0306952391,
-0.0076310709,
-0.0313090049,
-0.0663016587,
-0.0676708519,
0.0563923046,
0.0344652981,
-0.0181786064,
0.0338610224,
-0.0480308048,
0.031439662,
-0.0139277773,
0.0111337053,
0.0390979126,
-0.0424636006,
0.011742997,
-0.008247545,
-0.0622483194,
-0.0192223638,
0.0566133745,
-0.0534179993,
0.019890992,
0.0069105304,
0.0548027754,
-0.0178580508,
0.0642088577,
-0.0242293794,
0.0613549873,
0.0255280863,
0.0179072917,
-0.0672897846,
0.0602569431,
0.0104560452,
-0.0318233445,
-0.015385868,
0.0181035921,
-0.0349956751,
0.0017531223,
-0.0294148885,
0.083749935,
-0.0300519187,
-0.0142839085,
0.0042229746,
-0.0005022384,
0.0103509063,
0.0458088331,
-0.0531159341,
-0.0321305096,
-0.0080499062,
0.0041213995,
0.0293398984,
-0.0246531088,
-0.0218482427,
0.0209257696,
-0.0497975461,
-0.059915401,
0.0065956018,
-0.0555765554,
0.0317519158,
0.0107384501,
0.0520260558,
0.0074646957,
-0.0138183869,
0.0211339649,
0.0166004542,
-0.0544625521,
-0.024517592,
-0.0219064634,
0.0279214475,
0.0091375876,
0.0050716014,
0.0607652925,
0.0618347935,
0.0575345308,
-0.0013691894,
-0.0223797318,
-0.003480121,
0.056067165,
0.0006011635,
-0.0013971725,
-0.0285311248,
-0.0174669232,
0.0029694156,
-0.0117950905,
-0.0499279946,
-0.0383473337,
2.472e-7,
0.037117891,
0.0233999155,
-0.0136932591,
0.0787717625,
-0.0222731698,
0.0139195193,
0.0244084205,
0.0782311186,
-0.0243512094,
-0.0256888159,
-0.0165949129,
-0.019043332,
0.0131396521,
0.0627550259,
-0.0959360972,
-0.0574575104,
0.0223630555,
-0.0209701248,
-0.0615185425,
0.0067330711,
0.0777181536,
0.0571889915,
0.0437083542,
0.0112088872,
-0.0127746025,
0.0055257692,
0.0192343686,
0.0091005852,
-0.0639148876,
0.0317452997,
-0.0108671505,
0.0475102775,
-0.0507424101,
0.0599251613,
-0.0286232606,
0.0246933103,
0.0177559741,
-0.0003849999,
-0.032130383,
-0.0134402113,
0.000134271,
-0.0680897534,
-0.0025812096,
-0.0113005983,
0.0361753181,
-0.0426602103,
-0.010514183,
0.0314726755,
-0.0382874981,
0.0377713442,
-0.0238838457,
-0.0164317209,
-0.0214204825,
0.0017624641,
0.0100894831,
0.0364092328,
0.0016412239,
-0.0796021819,
-0.0040636668,
0.0783257931,
0.0153257223,
-0.0557373054,
0.0478761978,
-0.0569751598,
0.0089907283,
-0.0826705918,
0.0286309067,
2.071048395e-34,
-0.0233617239,
0.0704107955,
-0.01337454,
-0.001425195,
0.0478313304,
-0.0455520451,
0.0488941781,
-0.0403316133,
0.0506131053,
-0.0043399665,
0.0182872619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13516v1 | Scaling Speech Technology to 1,000+ Languages | 2023-05-22T22:09:41 | 2023-05-22T22:09:41 | Vineel Pratap, Andros Tjandra, Bowen Shi, Paden Tomasello, Arun Babu, Sayani Kundu, Ali Elkahky, Zhaoheng Ni, Apoorv Vyas, Maryam Fazel-Zarandi, Alexei Baevski, Yossi Adi, Xiaohui Zhang, Wei-Ning Hsu, Alexis Conneau, Michael Auli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Expanding the language coverage of speech technology has the potential to
improve access to information for many more people. However, current speech
technology is restricted to about one hundred languages which is a small
fraction of the over 7,000 languages spoken around the world. The Massively
Multilingual Speech (MMS) project increases the number of supported languages
by 10-40x, depending on the task. The main ingredients are a new dataset based
on readings of publicly available religious texts and effectively leveraging
self-supervised learning. We built pre-trained wav2vec 2.0 models covering
1,406 languages, a single multilingual automatic speech recognition model for
1,107 languages, speech synthesis models for the same number of languages, as
well as a language identification model for 4,017 languages. Experiments show
that our multilingual speech recognition model more than halves the word error
rate of Whisper on 54 languages of the FLEURS benchmark while being trained on
a small fraction of the labeled data. | [
-0.0028686172,
0.0737416223,
-0.0152444392,
0.0461305194,
-0.0046606101,
0.0007967694,
0.056027092,
-0.0018236511,
0.0220287722,
0.0128841661,
-0.0175188538,
-0.0535975955,
0.032849282,
-0.0252970103,
0.0329654478,
-0.0356617458,
0.0269795321,
-0.0862372965,
-0.0293016341,
-0.0044420036,
-0.0017220731,
0.0626085922,
-0.0097662508,
0.003099357,
-0.0328748487,
0.0056075118,
-0.0232017245,
0.0116343219,
-0.000587183,
-0.0148575176,
-0.0418643281,
-0.0015072798,
0.0023942909,
0.0853723958,
0.0000019677,
-0.0518347174,
0.0079208445,
-0.0174751058,
-0.0302964635,
0.05994156,
0.0512252524,
0.0049827923,
-0.0267513562,
-0.0019455339,
-0.0090203714,
-0.0325297974,
0.0348534733,
0.0209945142,
0.0065746065,
0.0385382921,
-0.0115215415,
-0.0698281825,
0.0210269634,
0.010110273,
-0.0265268553,
-0.0191615038,
-0.0120560909,
0.0036031844,
-0.0308106001,
0.0072997725,
-0.0196648855,
0.0615205765,
0.0098378872,
0.0029807023,
-0.03227745,
-0.0079243938,
-0.0578655638,
-0.0645234585,
-0.025232669,
0.0252807382,
-0.034229815,
-0.0575150885,
0.0235158987,
0.019776484,
-0.0518307202,
-0.0156013034,
-0.0028891878,
0.0051030284,
-0.0015258354,
-0.0091400063,
0.0299540162,
0.0271661673,
0.0209854003,
-0.0469685867,
0.0074289395,
0.0129670808,
0.0299617928,
-0.0270720255,
0.0253761522,
-0.0027994008,
0.013814928,
-0.0300908815,
0.0037069616,
-0.0333468691,
0.0009058959,
-0.0188347921,
-0.0150838904,
-0.03820071,
-0.0466293767,
-0.0485033542,
0.0323197581,
0.048664771,
-0.044719968,
0.0132004609,
-0.0304321703,
0.0003759103,
0.0062402771,
-0.0364723466,
-0.0088724745,
0.0179933589,
0.0095094182,
0.0306434203,
-0.0259971209,
-0.0188758597,
-0.0540400222,
0.012991162,
-0.0148570323,
-0.0017885633,
0.0385522284,
0.0027943032,
-0.0248844307,
-0.0439118706,
-0.0202020258,
-0.0704447776,
0.084436588,
0.0465834923,
0.0131347254,
0.0289283618,
-0.0560300313,
-0.112794444,
0.042623505,
0.0295804329,
0.0127011016,
0.0318657793,
0.0313878506,
0.1054888517,
-0.0273025706,
-0.0217316076,
-0.034441527,
0.0035918499,
-0.026818946,
-0.0449052192,
-0.0145958802,
-0.05903529,
0.0536137745,
0.0330904499,
0.019689614,
0.0107960431,
0.0276231784,
-0.0350973308,
-0.0010918492,
0.0491645634,
-0.0073556527,
0.0373046547,
0.1037510857,
-0.0080276616,
0.0328600258,
0.057871066,
0.0280341525,
-0.024794085,
0.0580833703,
-0.0293380078,
-0.0069891266,
0.0765099078,
0.0075059049,
0.0182031356,
-0.0027156724,
-0.0261304025,
0.0338895507,
-0.0121402228,
-0.0051722135,
0.0389144346,
-0.0148450769,
0.0108739045,
0.0560327582,
0.0627857298,
0.0345481001,
0.0255097114,
0.0299894195,
0.0144751156,
0.056404721,
-0.0664611831,
0.0204166137,
-0.0059672189,
0.0081307134,
0.0111793373,
0.0738011748,
0.0301308557,
-0.0441145599,
-0.0154484147,
0.0038285032,
-0.0560742095,
-0.0436669514,
0.001091314,
0.0469137169,
-0.0096175242,
-0.0152290538,
0.0177131463,
0.0564766191,
-0.0859906897,
0.0298594236,
0.0256905742,
0.0381965414,
0.0262807161,
-0.0007069555,
-0.0080296518,
0.0261711925,
-0.0473482013,
0.0151785575,
0.0718162507,
0.0290578827,
0.0120204752,
0.076598905,
-0.0691273883,
0.0203081984,
0.047762692,
-0.0258031152,
0.0411324017,
-0.0183458496,
0.022608459,
0.0221852381,
-0.0372292362,
-0.0153036676,
0.001396406,
-0.0314772725,
-0.0200426672,
0.0188114382,
0.0136851948,
0.0431691185,
0.0423652381,
-0.0273477398,
-0.0460098721,
0.0006084736,
-0.0367461517,
0.0304439515,
0.0202173833,
-0.0406066887,
0.007045811,
0.0501647666,
-0.0253804605,
0.0034644674,
0.0376636013,
0.0264933147,
-0.070252277,
0.0708469898,
-0.022281317,
0.0228691846,
-0.012056306,
0.0295870602,
0.0025718696,
0.0436160341,
0.0643782392,
-0.0040041562,
0.028825853,
0.0169881824,
0.0086239781,
-0.0333963409,
0.0510215238,
-0.0072791628,
-0.0782710165,
-0.0317688622,
-0.0214134697,
0.0408194475,
0.0125108734,
0.0045838142,
0.0251762439,
-0.0038816608,
-0.0842603222,
0.0004327206,
-0.0168830045,
0.0094204172,
-0.0445435196,
0.0457832478,
-0.0045627519,
-0.0303187706,
-0.0286273435,
-0.0211169366,
0.0080245994,
-0.032548409,
-0.0393436439,
-0.0375915654,
-0.0148361195,
-0.0139505854,
-0.0267146416,
0.0313380212,
0.0178616177,
0.024012344,
-0.0249451268,
-0.0460932218,
-0.02961253,
-0.018378498,
0.0234225877,
0.0148444073,
-0.0272305962,
-0.0381617956,
-0.0016700173,
-0.0037622419,
0.0002986258,
0.0112101045,
-0.0683342442,
-0.0116223413,
0.0358368047,
-0.0370789208,
0.0094046202,
0.0071315835,
-0.0394733325,
-0.0284017771,
0.0028136165,
-0.0587171391,
0.0072209011,
0.032226216,
0.0298516527,
-0.0448806435,
-0.0157032236,
-0.0228586476,
-0.0400817618,
0.0068835649,
0.0031792647,
-0.0258012861,
0.0491943359,
0.0145702418,
-0.0566452965,
-0.0001209612,
-0.0382712185,
-0.0504295789,
-0.0027549742,
0.0075911423,
-0.0120292008,
-0.0172741674,
-0.0045377412,
0.0353702717,
-0.0402968004,
-0.0371538997,
-0.0311427955,
0.0263900664,
-0.000956747,
-0.0412853509,
0.0214260351,
0.0190723184,
0.0133232567,
-0.0330952778,
-0.0420533083,
-0.0052502695,
0.0235104654,
-0.042588152,
-0.0381575339,
0.0082779014,
0.0164748169,
-0.007521037,
0.0333286673,
0.0253729224,
0.0164583419,
0.0399134494,
-0.0019280098,
-0.0231707674,
0.0294298138,
-0.0437418744,
0.0262839515,
0.0174538959,
-0.0258226283,
0.0349991247,
-0.027607616,
0.0554801263,
0.0087752575,
-0.0327165388,
0.0057708318,
0.0425468609,
0.0134611083,
-0.0179449525,
0.0063797906,
0.0563313738,
0.0050950507,
0.0446860492,
0.096573934,
-0.0364338122,
-0.0407341868,
-0.0062010312,
-0.0184527393,
-0.0413185321,
-0.0061406237,
0.0300010517,
-0.1227108836,
-0.0148113659,
0.0426821224,
0.0130623961,
0.0416241921,
0.0464700609,
0.0345329642,
-0.0758212432,
0.0015153125,
0.0431958549,
-0.0289099272,
-0.0250574909,
-0.0114609152,
-0.0466630049,
-0.0288103148,
0.0288023613,
0.0064037046,
-0.0138990842,
-0.0383488759,
0.0096597932,
-0.0265929494,
-0.0677346736,
0.034494441,
-0.0167103317,
0.0877647921,
0.0330760032,
0.0057263742,
-0.0930531919,
-0.0136938654,
0.005661096,
0.0002743837,
-0.0121659571,
-0.0223989375,
0.0369910076,
0.0453246161,
-0.0530505665,
0.0228662044,
0.0154843749,
-0.0183758717,
0.0125152767,
0.0542907976,
0.0466409661,
0.0356484987,
-0.0053432393,
0.0434668176,
0.0533294864,
-0.0102289766,
0.0331677794,
-0.0280178078,
-0.0665912628,
0.0036362042,
-0.0080438014,
0.0335610732,
0.0071506328,
-0.0725888014,
-0.0055663376,
0.0335094333,
-0.0670695379,
-0.0154222501,
0.0138127413,
-0.0370653681,
0.0154020926,
0.0790279731,
-0.0113293296,
0.0364244916,
0.0187145341,
-0.0609954968,
-0.0201456361,
-0.0098177819,
0.0464052483,
-0.0695189312,
-0.0140105346,
-0.0010151862,
-0.060097754,
-0.0093185119,
0.0356679782,
-0.0492146686,
-0.076655224,
0.0117405159,
0.0358524062,
0.0144106587,
0.0519057214,
-0.0060426551,
-0.0458736047,
0.037071228,
0.0143992538,
-0.0934632197,
0.0346697569,
0.0616637543,
0.0277974252,
-0.0293390378,
0.0368423685,
-0.0029236425,
0.0169720408,
0.0229173861,
-0.0249895416,
0.0013578861,
-0.0773382559,
-0.0458526686,
-0.0008994812,
-0.0282230377,
-0.0301399752,
0.0356609672,
-0.0811288431,
0.0080459658,
-0.0063316454,
0.0367816165,
-0.023318518,
0.0449989177,
-0.0151163777,
0.0201987531,
0.0169260669,
-0.029350372,
0.0176351797,
-0.0895541459,
0.0014780567,
0.0553224608,
0.0244369246,
0.0483539551,
-0.0243716091,
0.0077660931,
-0.0169695616,
0.0628001988,
0.0332109965,
0.0177891888,
-0.0286043361,
-0.0058667585,
-0.0189595427,
0.0357538387,
0.0310174692,
-0.004385584,
-0.0077698031,
-0.1014804021,
-0.0186825264,
0.0339189433,
0.0488943793,
0.0148272431,
0.0864783674,
-0.0053139119,
0.0013673066,
-0.034024097,
0.0325179473,
-0.0198725872,
0.0242281295,
-0.0521912128,
-0.0148412818,
-0.0545796715,
0.034300901,
0.0071834014,
0.0022445773,
0.0150040453,
0.043018166,
0.0465589538,
-0.0623545796,
-0.0075439345,
0.0082560685,
0.0243861955,
-0.0487756915,
0.0439885966,
-0.0379661396,
-0.0520051382,
0.0409197547,
0.0189947132,
-0.025362175,
-0.0266057868,
0.017705081,
0.0421932302,
-0.0040649492,
0.0089281807,
-0.0344924517,
-0.0121107893,
-0.0091118384,
-0.0224265791,
0.0099324994,
-5.59358546e-33,
0.0008464845,
0.0575500987,
-0.0322990566,
0.0169120003,
0.0063346806,
0.0083955117,
-0.0016472114,
0.040397618,
-0.0491630398,
0.0086266473,
-0.0045892079,
-0.017853925,
0.0216344092,
0.031215746,
0.0545356572,
0.0298752114,
0.0710060596,
0.0153403729,
0.006724149,
0.0361037552,
0.0636654124,
0.0250434764,
0.0692792833,
-0.0680025667,
-0.0110494858,
-0.0175742861,
0.0268878732,
-0.0636439323,
0.0515998565,
0.0608577095,
-0.0333301909,
0.0643160045,
-0.0355112813,
-0.0040191114,
-0.0044456269,
0.0188477766,
-0.0518304147,
-0.0073741274,
0.002994077,
0.0751801282,
-0.0017818781,
0.0010532486,
-0.0112730833,
-0.0100092757,
-0.0790013224,
0.0095452936,
0.0318943821,
0.0015745657,
-0.0277476776,
-0.0641495809,
-0.0622727089,
0.0253140237,
-0.0315568708,
-0.0173204243,
0.0308458153,
0.0280615054,
-0.0341700949,
-0.0101480586,
-0.0981570184,
0.0075902455,
-0.0134659819,
0.0552498698,
0.0056635002,
0.0017238397,
-0.0388970748,
-0.0205253046,
0.0596841276,
-0.0640807152,
0.0576674566,
0.0164702013,
0.0286504608,
-0.0213847719,
0.0343261585,
0.0600409769,
0.0015876875,
-0.0524558723,
-0.0408210307,
-0.0381688438,
0.0399698205,
-0.0393900461,
0.0377774015,
-0.0238084551,
-0.0311340857,
0.029310409,
-0.0440223403,
-0.0615604781,
-0.010539881,
0.0007014346,
0.0501839742,
-0.0048946575,
0.0167311337,
0.0023668038,
0.0610372946,
-0.0367708206,
-0.0054929345,
-0.006179776,
0.0094457269,
-0.0209521893,
-0.033817783,
0.0398197696,
-0.0474181436,
-0.0598523654,
-0.0122772064,
-0.0168678332,
0.0001481647,
-0.0470080748,
-0.0173543356,
-0.0177812111,
-0.0725452453,
0.0191295929,
0.0086286301,
-0.0015303437,
0.0180268083,
0.0323901996,
0.0459423289,
-0.0320465341,
0.0071138935,
0.0049194442,
0.0118480744,
-0.0381837487,
0.0193413086,
-0.0242053829,
-0.0065694186,
0.0305150021,
-0.0421477146,
0.0433443263,
-0.0504906736,
0.0096680056,
0.0335754901,
-0.0251251105,
0.008721929,
0.0273812432,
2.718e-7,
-0.0084736571,
-0.0321969315,
0.0251871012,
-0.004964842,
0.0019837727,
0.0359643325,
0.01997995,
-0.0104678916,
-0.0398477279,
0.0307927392,
-0.0399808399,
0.0042106621,
0.1333665997,
-0.0012854643,
-0.0405229963,
-0.0447007418,
-0.0583424792,
0.0558686145,
-0.0635820851,
-0.0009092671,
-0.0176876467,
0.1275099516,
-0.0005051444,
-0.014165746,
-0.0253332984,
0.0171021838,
0.0419641472,
-0.0142593477,
-0.034271583,
0.0195648111,
-0.0162453745,
0.0184368603,
-0.0149580901,
0.0135429371,
-0.0507751331,
0.0483873859,
0.0366727561,
0.0361771882,
0.0341590829,
0.0284962654,
0.0137443021,
0.0009521946,
-0.0654821768,
-0.0156023474,
0.0468994975,
0.016123224,
-0.0044625984,
0.0025978854,
-0.0191987772,
0.0147260102,
0.0178491641,
-0.0068281838,
-0.0248585623,
0.0428434648,
0.0385579616,
-0.0306589324,
-0.0146053294,
-0.0324648395,
0.0204494931,
-0.0009821076,
0.0043331855,
-0.0179757439,
0.0207681637,
-0.0224850737,
0.0330226161,
0.0385530517,
-0.0001820079,
1.873142557e-34,
0.0436397605,
-0.0319356471,
0.0272340383,
0.000712542,
-0.0272497647,
-0.0389521532,
0.0063532623,
-0.006652059,
-0.0141407894,
0.0009646296,
-0.0256833397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13514v2 | Small Language Models Improve Giants by Rewriting Their Outputs | 2023-05-22T22:07:50 | 2024-02-01T11:47:57 | Giorgos Vernikos, Arthur Bražinskas, Jakub Adamek, Jonathan Mallinson, Aliaksei Severyn, Eric Malmi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the impressive performance of large language models (LLMs), they
often lag behind specialized models in various tasks. LLMs only use a fraction
of the existing training data for in-context learning, while task-specific
models harness the full dataset for fine-tuning. In this work, we tackle the
problem of leveraging training data to improve the performance of LLMs without
fine-tuning. Our approach directly targets LLM predictions without requiring
access to their weights. We create a pool of candidates from the LLM through
few-shot prompting and we employ a compact model, the LM-corrector (LMCor),
specifically trained to merge these candidates to produce an enhanced output.
Our experiments on four natural language generation tasks demonstrate that even
a small LMCor model (250M) substantially improves the few-shot performance of
LLMs (62B), matching and even outperforming standard fine-tuning. Furthermore,
we illustrate the robustness of LMCor against different prompts, thereby
minimizing the need for extensive prompt engineering. Finally, we show that
LMCor can be seamlessly integrated with different LLMs at inference, serving as
a plug-and-play module to improve their performance. | [
0.0228298251,
0.0591028295,
0.0142753823,
0.0275467392,
-0.0154634435,
0.0146509102,
0.0401134565,
-0.0120075131,
-0.0093305912,
-0.0561204888,
-0.0170475133,
-0.0381346084,
0.0142337559,
0.0217819735,
0.0695028678,
-0.0272081513,
0.0055058333,
-0.0399534665,
-0.025700368,
0.0043372782,
-0.0124590676,
0.0381045491,
0.0018398029,
0.0601446815,
0.0276229735,
0.01881258,
-0.0209282693,
0.0314682685,
0.0085188085,
-0.0145358788,
0.0173598696,
0.0512236357,
0.0219162609,
0.0476467237,
0.0000021207,
-0.0521928445,
-0.0088490956,
-0.0159530193,
-0.0282894131,
0.0024575335,
0.0330355689,
-0.0188588575,
-0.008105644,
0.0436587706,
-0.0347647965,
-0.0110612046,
0.032808803,
0.0301943161,
0.0289312731,
0.093962647,
0.0132174762,
0.0094815483,
0.0113102561,
-0.0699626878,
0.0010999487,
-0.0138746714,
0.0030348438,
-0.0212055575,
0.0105900234,
0.0082552433,
0.0035567528,
0.0155930333,
0.0181805175,
0.0001799152,
0.0002236395,
0.0546887778,
-0.0124150245,
-0.0366155282,
-0.0213504545,
0.0633708313,
-0.0488179848,
-0.0271541625,
0.005376983,
-0.0373704657,
0.0022837489,
-0.0300304312,
-0.0427714214,
0.0420011021,
0.0080091599,
0.015421194,
0.0223758593,
-0.0251583233,
0.0372134894,
0.0264387131,
-0.0210623313,
-0.0062480494,
0.0344771631,
-0.0058263224,
-0.0180733968,
0.0185641386,
-0.0240285676,
-0.0782949328,
-0.0397898033,
0.0347949117,
-0.0694604144,
0.0078982208,
-0.084513925,
-0.0220695417,
0.0307673644,
0.0009622324,
0.0677112341,
0.0375316367,
-0.0104726246,
0.0145172877,
-0.0326780453,
0.0467644744,
-0.0038234985,
0.0050058658,
-0.0486660525,
0.007204459,
-0.0297388732,
-0.0005510984,
-0.0122470846,
0.0100729801,
-0.0732611194,
-0.0268419478,
-0.0472778156,
0.0276348479,
0.0073224669,
-0.0030526975,
0.029121846,
0.0181251671,
-0.0447433852,
-0.0193409417,
-0.0056933155,
0.0293249041,
-0.0181618687,
0.037678238,
0.0576798357,
-0.0790567547,
-0.028279582,
0.0225411858,
0.0353962034,
-0.0227366909,
0.0202262383,
0.0473470502,
-0.0233348161,
-0.0350518376,
-0.027400855,
-0.0497326478,
-0.0208060108,
-0.07758376,
-0.0289464574,
-0.0718077719,
0.0348533988,
-0.0072928723,
0.0013888659,
-0.0350256003,
0.0147852749,
0.0173193142,
-0.0140949311,
0.0504778475,
-0.0168058313,
-0.0042172531,
0.0214309432,
0.0071047614,
-0.0053908066,
0.0683337152,
0.0285090581,
0.0570941754,
0.0058657536,
0.0007845286,
0.0091539882,
0.0370830037,
0.0246811006,
0.001070942,
0.0020231083,
-0.0364600979,
-0.0101877721,
0.0234263651,
0.0501509123,
0.05431455,
-0.0159657877,
0.0463642403,
0.0954225659,
0.0218957346,
0.0176856834,
-0.0105014453,
0.0602834411,
0.0197423026,
-0.0442129485,
0.0021498688,
-0.0727939755,
0.0364420377,
-0.0382612608,
0.0359916165,
0.0758737624,
0.0762495399,
-0.035942547,
-0.033150401,
-0.0085795159,
-0.0256926864,
-0.0082930354,
0.0281402636,
0.0220449269,
0.0329089835,
-0.0674544126,
0.0277964324,
0.0343383662,
-0.0647600591,
0.0053874361,
-0.0421506315,
0.0502726324,
0.0675492361,
0.0408395939,
0.0374976434,
-0.0341621265,
-0.0127547747,
0.0116354069,
0.0791131184,
0.0485992543,
-0.0073691397,
0.0412578285,
-0.0669093207,
-0.0220327415,
-0.0175144579,
0.0272464789,
0.0244053118,
0.0268836841,
-0.014272185,
0.0525225997,
-0.0135672633,
-0.0259214155,
0.0355116688,
-0.0624433011,
-0.05871135,
0.0324633047,
0.0033747908,
0.0097337337,
-0.0158490166,
0.002264882,
0.0297969487,
0.0214471407,
-0.0467415154,
-0.0161256045,
0.0110835126,
-0.0511291623,
-0.0743879676,
0.0042048017,
0.0270298515,
0.027091004,
0.0066383262,
-0.0614345148,
-0.0526284315,
-0.0079012662,
-0.0181362871,
0.0245706402,
-0.0387956128,
0.0305257402,
0.0430075228,
0.0070015872,
-0.0258031432,
0.0586095192,
-0.0005201705,
0.0082058199,
0.0310482737,
0.0356705599,
-0.0192349926,
-0.047958374,
-0.0063346252,
-0.0187088978,
-0.0264189634,
0.013541176,
0.0371884145,
0.0313988738,
-0.0280551128,
-0.0336316675,
-0.0733724609,
0.031319771,
-0.0200642496,
-0.0007317743,
0.0227808505,
0.0170839988,
-0.0002048785,
-0.006911743,
-0.0353676565,
-0.0183686558,
0.0454453863,
0.0215520021,
0.0258489698,
0.0071381237,
-0.0043108626,
-0.0585653447,
0.0123934373,
0.0153612355,
0.0272988323,
-0.0171735995,
0.014002285,
-0.0431033336,
0.0466872156,
-0.0381894559,
0.0066520059,
-0.0036527696,
-0.0244880132,
0.0123946294,
-0.0337261073,
0.0690807477,
0.0416446924,
0.0004757791,
-0.0017041275,
0.0414871611,
0.0084041925,
-0.0628124774,
-0.0023253642,
-0.0166334286,
-0.0352557451,
-0.0059760059,
-0.0228232387,
0.0016861364,
0.075821273,
0.0110352021,
-0.003156719,
-0.065565303,
0.0383023284,
0.0101986621,
-0.0376204886,
-0.0211882796,
-0.0075202263,
-0.0140406694,
0.0244481657,
-0.0423224308,
-0.0701325834,
0.0589392111,
-0.0576017424,
0.0018221088,
-0.0148834689,
-0.0280100629,
-0.0363860875,
0.0470968224,
0.0152508346,
0.0143507998,
0.0341215096,
-0.0016734849,
-0.0688806102,
0.0125182411,
-0.0065616672,
-0.0220124628,
0.0526743904,
-0.0594251156,
0.0126076257,
-0.0201510973,
-0.0592105836,
-0.0694740936,
-0.0405707695,
-0.0307048373,
0.0012874958,
0.016084291,
-0.0219996329,
-0.0091020772,
-0.0140711488,
-0.0079446426,
0.0443181917,
-0.0254175961,
-0.0122642731,
-0.0254453272,
0.0376343764,
0.056717582,
0.0177526027,
0.0210433844,
-0.0559308007,
0.0468507968,
0.0484420955,
0.0481827259,
0.0178272594,
-0.0441246368,
0.0012744127,
0.0172082391,
0.0035912555,
-0.0137870088,
0.0540625229,
0.0858338475,
-0.0741641819,
-0.0308099221,
0.1371753365,
0.0099978549,
-0.0022607769,
0.0136562632,
0.0277399011,
0.0494963638,
0.0186941549,
0.0204019547,
-0.0575712807,
-0.0449015461,
0.0225420333,
0.0283104405,
-0.0131777218,
-0.0067760283,
-0.0478776954,
-0.163496986,
0.0258637071,
0.0401764102,
-0.0134114195,
-0.0093264263,
-0.0122859282,
-0.0253199898,
-0.0141583029,
0.0120261526,
0.0278557129,
-0.0237670131,
0.0110468576,
0.0227586087,
0.0152520034,
-0.0747712851,
0.0042808894,
-0.0451652296,
0.060873732,
0.0466692075,
0.0092235627,
0.0348569043,
-0.0042209611,
0.0458795801,
-0.0008657795,
0.0146864392,
-0.023932403,
0.0373160355,
0.0002906765,
-0.0081949886,
-0.0085086627,
0.0553453006,
-0.0286388192,
-0.0240280759,
-0.0084520802,
0.0089920405,
0.0012763719,
-0.0190645456,
0.0090283118,
0.0143450154,
0.0093785254,
0.0812574849,
0.0412309878,
-0.0337537378,
-0.0083651366,
-0.001830051,
-0.0204053354,
-0.0582251549,
0.0014887303,
0.010935043,
0.0128265042,
-0.0141779957,
-0.0876743421,
-0.0411291905,
0.0296861436,
0.0551010482,
-0.0072486191,
0.000327058,
-0.0447217152,
-0.0011947188,
-0.0308715403,
0.0412675701,
-0.0273110084,
0.0007535807,
-0.0573758148,
-0.0070815319,
0.0164140034,
-0.031052703,
-0.0037681831,
0.0270428956,
-0.1345475763,
-0.0912239254,
-0.0543822832,
0.0592496023,
0.0221715588,
0.0442561246,
0.0098457979,
-0.065228425,
0.0593388639,
0.0623113289,
-0.0313161016,
0.0347831994,
-0.0105614364,
-0.023872355,
-0.0041699423,
0.0375311114,
-0.0578721873,
0.0277838781,
0.0135238189,
0.0419816002,
-0.027256554,
-0.0272374731,
0.0219175313,
0.0073022014,
0.0144037232,
-0.071148634,
0.0061543663,
-0.0343488306,
-0.0041089067,
-0.0091121374,
-0.0081618978,
-0.0382402465,
-0.0069595254,
0.0133860158,
0.0040807105,
0.0116923004,
0.0051065139,
0.0132457977,
0.0750254765,
-0.0600422323,
-0.031494543,
-0.0256549008,
-0.0135558303,
0.0293370076,
0.0087098563,
-0.0297043342,
0.0279596746,
-0.0141935796,
0.024682492,
-0.0459354706,
0.0348157063,
0.009699272,
0.0237453394,
-0.0053789332,
0.0312005617,
-0.0500628725,
-0.0512907282,
-0.0520623848,
0.0399622731,
0.0679686517,
0.005814936,
0.0541453026,
-0.0085619558,
-0.0005581739,
-0.0414655171,
0.0216444079,
-0.0045714285,
-0.0361632966,
0.0469104275,
0.0161233339,
-0.0316775329,
-0.0155251874,
0.0954395831,
0.0200272053,
0.0386638232,
0.0200403724,
0.0469102748,
-0.0486116484,
-0.0335208178,
0.0226737391,
0.0053929468,
-0.0139952749,
0.0208222326,
-0.0237856787,
-0.0650825426,
-0.0062711039,
0.0118476087,
-0.0048827953,
-0.0142717473,
0.0352973938,
0.0313524902,
-0.0287723411,
0.0058735246,
-0.0313804038,
-0.0157333482,
-0.0070662466,
-0.020176867,
-0.0097636497,
-6.956162676e-33,
-0.0424829721,
-0.015604022,
0.0468401872,
-0.0363354944,
0.0068203076,
-0.003699942,
-0.0543045253,
-0.0070178835,
0.0072109476,
-0.0107046384,
-0.0139929773,
-0.0142898662,
0.004278257,
0.058668837,
0.0101823993,
0.0161662195,
0.0861217082,
0.0168775041,
-0.0298668444,
0.0216398705,
0.0352092534,
0.0287405513,
0.0037318764,
0.0008073482,
-0.0104330527,
-0.008991031,
-0.0546528809,
0.0249569286,
0.0121540856,
0.0492658839,
-0.0033846898,
0.0294161253,
0.0242229458,
-0.0357922502,
-0.0458710454,
0.026602786,
-0.0432868116,
-0.0033654172,
0.0215307176,
-0.0258199628,
-0.022758577,
-0.0402620733,
0.0304774586,
-0.0290298387,
-0.0066972915,
-0.0078271534,
0.0120198177,
-0.0234742556,
-0.0332058631,
-0.0358729176,
-0.055725798,
0.0077549163,
0.0059193391,
-0.0609404109,
0.0010810354,
0.0489940681,
-0.0067012347,
0.0107871052,
-0.026837429,
0.0192648415,
0.0270681195,
0.0782672316,
0.0622377172,
0.0357610509,
-0.0403632224,
0.0517828874,
-0.0071011526,
0.0002474042,
-0.0121408226,
0.006580974,
0.0166826975,
0.0711426735,
0.0418661796,
0.0596838519,
0.0319169387,
-0.0096820313,
-0.0550014749,
0.0556944124,
0.0429822616,
0.0045292126,
0.0215931144,
0.0039035359,
-0.0147958547,
-0.0260611195,
-0.0437986106,
-0.0127075985,
-0.0431209207,
-0.0062097982,
0.0472524464,
0.0814431384,
-0.01167743,
-0.0334591903,
0.0390916169,
-0.029393781,
0.0038946064,
0.0309426151,
-0.0347601101,
-0.025791496,
-0.0127721112,
0.0085893786,
-0.060460493,
-0.0370138474,
0.0514653847,
0.0228176881,
-0.0176070221,
0.025948165,
0.0274787508,
0.0318142623,
-0.0957537219,
0.0255356468,
-0.0591629222,
0.0517163351,
-0.0005368952,
0.0136349238,
0.0469745249,
-0.0026018324,
-0.0297984444,
0.0378008746,
-0.010387837,
-0.0252342913,
-0.0165113229,
-0.0084161554,
-0.0003719945,
0.0245416593,
-0.0192907955,
0.0071919961,
-0.0184208136,
-0.0072418954,
0.0679808706,
-0.0180761945,
-0.0305705834,
-0.0143790096,
2.784e-7,
-0.0127144158,
0.0271946546,
0.0011979538,
0.0327470414,
0.0066132867,
0.0421150103,
-0.0051447847,
0.0428361557,
0.0100317867,
-0.0127222482,
-0.007488641,
0.0081804963,
0.0618566759,
-0.001224394,
-0.0698371455,
0.0285421014,
-0.0785839483,
0.0300001875,
-0.0554748662,
-0.0498436652,
0.0265373066,
0.1028081998,
-0.0013417943,
-0.0423551835,
0.0184913762,
-0.0377060212,
0.0685689598,
-0.0143594369,
-0.0408999063,
0.0113195907,
0.0252666064,
0.0383088663,
-0.0130396429,
-0.0112462146,
-0.0399021879,
0.0059295399,
-0.0487476625,
0.0753306225,
0.0242921412,
-0.0279805604,
0.0060713445,
0.005828151,
0.008044038,
-0.0235082135,
0.0486847945,
-0.0627999082,
-0.000058893,
-0.0472022183,
-0.0071567656,
0.0025367348,
-0.0202230569,
-0.0425488129,
-0.0302507132,
0.0240931809,
0.0217932109,
-0.0084246993,
-0.0182977952,
-0.0702709258,
-0.0590290874,
0.0178509522,
-0.0513416715,
-0.038867183,
-0.0553109683,
0.0004895459,
0.0172169842,
-0.0623904467,
-0.0125597594,
2.801950349e-34,
0.0250757504,
-0.0109275226,
0.0282679778,
0.0286756679,
0.0047844136,
0.0049113636,
-0.0114059905,
0.0045157787,
0.0306413174,
-0.0722618699,
-0.0267455596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13512v2 | Can ChatGPT Detect Intent? Evaluating Large Language Models for Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-05-22T21:59:26 | 2023-08-17T19:23:20 | Mutian He, Philip N. Garner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, large pretrained language models have demonstrated strong language
understanding capabilities. This is particularly reflected in their zero-shot
and in-context learning abilities on downstream tasks through prompting. To
assess their impact on spoken language understanding (SLU), we evaluate several
such models like ChatGPT and OPT of different sizes on multiple benchmarks. We
verify the emergent ability unique to the largest models as they can reach
intent classification accuracy close to that of supervised models with zero or
few shots on various languages given oracle transcripts. By contrast, the
results for smaller models fitting a single GPU fall far behind. We note that
the error cases often arise from the annotation scheme of the dataset;
responses from ChatGPT are still reasonable. We show, however, that the model
is worse at slot filling, and its performance is sensitive to ASR errors,
suggesting serious challenges for the application of those textual models on
SLU. | [
0.0113811735,
0.0398462527,
0.0146060996,
0.042673409,
-0.0193626992,
0.0409324095,
0.0237170961,
-0.0083619859,
0.0367689691,
-0.0840549693,
-0.047266908,
-0.0601617582,
0.0015073096,
0.037425559,
-0.0050051077,
-0.0059116855,
0.0692199171,
-0.0517459735,
0.0361586772,
0.0129652349,
0.0045702155,
0.0118441358,
-0.017233042,
0.0473080985,
0.0042466661,
-0.0312284287,
-0.0392926782,
0.0095580891,
-0.013704868,
-0.0043275636,
-0.0045348136,
0.0420382619,
0.0294810478,
0.074918963,
0.000001991,
-0.0329285115,
-0.0026109521,
-0.0278595109,
-0.1088145897,
0.0058620009,
0.0234024636,
-0.0116591044,
-0.0080513451,
0.0167168286,
-0.0290390123,
-0.0339684933,
0.0338281915,
0.0224128719,
0.011312061,
0.0743475556,
-0.0075884378,
-0.002560026,
0.0280760508,
-0.0396391191,
0.0397594348,
-0.0679467991,
0.0208491832,
-0.0033404201,
-0.0184985083,
0.0131547851,
-0.0195854977,
0.0388897471,
0.0099510327,
-0.0115925269,
0.0040287571,
0.0232586861,
-0.0164791886,
-0.0420785137,
-0.0211451054,
0.0473529324,
-0.0277384296,
-0.0141359111,
0.0049116784,
-0.0322814323,
-0.0277568176,
-0.0424775593,
-0.0151375104,
0.0322814733,
-0.0052925893,
-0.003505833,
0.0438835621,
0.0158946943,
0.0408514477,
0.0121930372,
-0.0266669784,
0.0341957957,
-0.0073513263,
-0.0185301397,
0.0071476642,
0.0048067025,
-0.0140572358,
-0.0737261027,
-0.0373142399,
0.0140850721,
-0.0596820191,
0.0338217318,
-0.048034545,
0.0243766606,
0.0116644455,
-0.051462844,
0.0033629048,
0.080946289,
-0.0358264223,
0.0756677389,
0.0111671621,
0.0569426939,
0.0302470718,
0.0345514528,
-0.0539394431,
0.0156282187,
-0.0457709804,
-0.0106700538,
-0.0416914187,
-0.0056007579,
-0.0483204648,
-0.0436745174,
-0.0442305282,
0.0284868497,
0.0116757723,
0.0096803373,
0.0049502729,
-0.0300495457,
-0.0514046736,
0.0157960486,
0.0086166281,
0.0369423404,
0.0221092682,
0.0366097428,
0.0104298852,
-0.0924574882,
-0.030137198,
0.0340973213,
0.0032658516,
-0.029299669,
0.0132902302,
0.0410915613,
-0.0091128387,
-0.0865581483,
-0.0227166079,
-0.0020107836,
-0.0174104422,
-0.0844219849,
-0.0180324335,
-0.0128976908,
0.037910752,
0.0049182489,
0.0099286074,
-0.0134445745,
0.0069649955,
0.0032475665,
-0.0249888618,
0.0976596549,
-0.0107885925,
-0.0023033987,
-0.020904528,
0.0086404346,
-0.0094600208,
0.1027218625,
-0.0070754462,
0.0139817111,
0.0263178758,
-0.010419732,
-0.0062410804,
0.0344324,
0.0100446697,
0.0076966374,
0.0393335223,
0.0286870357,
0.0405296423,
0.0418943614,
0.0388992243,
0.026264796,
-0.0525059998,
-0.0237816758,
0.0436838716,
0.0652290359,
0.0007011233,
0.013574319,
0.0430706702,
0.0459031239,
-0.0081340242,
-0.0203476418,
-0.0573442914,
-0.0218090918,
-0.0363663435,
0.0049558706,
0.024956787,
-0.0127361976,
-0.0270925593,
-0.0250304099,
-0.024581451,
-0.0138653452,
0.0039772666,
0.0291582439,
0.0351295359,
-0.0123433303,
-0.0357419848,
0.0210113488,
0.03230986,
-0.0285546519,
-0.0248016492,
-0.0764692277,
0.0347717851,
0.044451613,
0.0292712878,
-0.032687787,
-0.062027175,
-0.0352345444,
-0.0171874315,
0.0105320886,
0.0334591232,
-0.0102044716,
0.077985011,
-0.048985824,
0.0104616405,
-0.0192697011,
0.018296849,
0.0470924973,
-0.0419527441,
-0.0048003965,
-0.0116698584,
-0.0164493583,
0.0029322638,
0.015322974,
-0.0326447338,
-0.0246656612,
0.0106970547,
0.0044767759,
0.0694394037,
0.0125314947,
-0.0122971805,
-0.0392650291,
0.0054329066,
-0.0147624267,
0.01159018,
0.036344178,
-0.0725161955,
-0.0837079957,
0.0312386621,
0.0305657629,
-0.0351009443,
-0.0050921408,
-0.039812319,
-0.0644884184,
-0.0112381401,
-0.0020910124,
0.0454648845,
-0.0638366714,
0.0064222948,
0.0122100133,
0.0243312046,
-0.006844969,
0.0491791852,
0.0205200221,
-0.0018020524,
0.0496233441,
0.0038109338,
0.054926917,
-0.0556746721,
-0.0246894173,
0.0121072391,
-0.0121795842,
-0.0169148054,
-0.006051485,
0.0206561405,
-0.0343928598,
0.0111436928,
-0.1261583567,
0.0073702973,
-0.0478893258,
-0.0095691634,
0.023268206,
0.0280043185,
-0.0105569027,
-0.0115199154,
-0.0057211155,
0.0104567045,
0.000965156,
0.0107168667,
-0.0026150504,
0.0028164985,
-0.017403122,
-0.0372739583,
0.0142391603,
-0.0139154559,
0.0467274711,
0.0200576708,
-0.0448557921,
-0.0431877784,
0.0561863855,
-0.0035269703,
0.0354357362,
-0.030638352,
-0.042789869,
0.000402,
-0.0232537221,
-0.017303016,
0.08613763,
-0.0022143887,
0.0455229878,
-0.0104402071,
-0.0036749127,
-0.0464360714,
0.0347428285,
0.0028414358,
-0.0068928441,
-0.0356051102,
0.0177323893,
-0.0157828759,
0.0808417499,
0.0066315448,
0.0088240998,
-0.0512553826,
-0.06371589,
-0.014715041,
-0.023967918,
-0.068423599,
0.0051401355,
-0.0241809823,
0.0456020832,
-0.0116578378,
-0.049258925,
0.0218434036,
-0.0598022863,
-0.0531109124,
-0.0629288107,
-0.0217718184,
-0.0302650966,
0.0851903111,
0.0231898017,
0.0197094642,
0.017388884,
-0.0246991105,
0.0081833061,
0.0115255257,
-0.0203854889,
-0.0084651718,
0.0293620583,
-0.0243609548,
0.0369607396,
-0.0380194746,
-0.0364289396,
-0.0528218001,
-0.0783368424,
-0.0475344174,
0.0046595922,
0.01907566,
-0.0029463267,
-0.0021984421,
0.0348286666,
-0.0029482741,
0.0685568526,
0.0021338486,
-0.0070490795,
-0.0170715116,
-0.0060064858,
0.0292844381,
0.0110794799,
-0.0237665176,
-0.0090137776,
0.052596543,
0.0346407034,
0.007960978,
-0.0129393162,
-0.0410724804,
0.0219034981,
0.0390686505,
-0.0067418995,
-0.0452143922,
0.0346713848,
0.0697249919,
-0.0434193909,
-0.0276083089,
0.1204705834,
0.0173954237,
-0.0391942374,
-0.027041737,
0.0120496536,
0.0127526103,
0.02175726,
0.0173176173,
-0.1208360493,
-0.0710477456,
0.0237592906,
-0.0113774389,
-0.002530253,
-0.0023065903,
-0.0286697764,
-0.0968329385,
0.0566355772,
-0.0148996441,
-0.0640518889,
0.0129319979,
-0.0127078462,
0.0073166504,
-0.0470928364,
0.0366633609,
0.0021141919,
-0.0063861026,
-0.0217638928,
0.0242355708,
-0.0234788544,
-0.0327157415,
0.0532914102,
-0.0092973607,
0.0912977457,
0.0366237611,
0.0237550829,
0.0200323183,
-0.0273339842,
0.0330238454,
-0.004064885,
0.0007890225,
-0.0181092434,
0.0554574542,
-0.0432696268,
0.0043534632,
0.028474763,
0.0182991475,
-0.0441587642,
-0.0137131782,
-0.0045329672,
0.0301866215,
-0.0496468358,
0.0054594479,
0.0312023852,
0.0028598707,
0.0343479626,
0.0979239345,
0.0272363182,
-0.0133633455,
-0.0625275597,
-0.0394412428,
-0.0001510955,
-0.0303307697,
-0.017443737,
0.0108690029,
0.0231336895,
-0.0464657769,
0.0169309191,
-0.0642701611,
0.0368063673,
0.0376185142,
-0.0056428444,
0.030450521,
0.0009657285,
0.0268306546,
0.0039733751,
0.0366887748,
-0.04049851,
0.024508819,
-0.0781972706,
-0.0269192867,
0.0197854228,
-0.0672609881,
-0.0334357657,
0.0208753292,
-0.1022449434,
-0.0375929475,
0.0295689702,
0.0198600963,
0.0328967422,
0.0587351322,
-0.061525397,
0.0026887364,
-0.0239985809,
0.0270586573,
-0.0381160676,
0.0186225493,
0.0606572628,
0.0387525745,
-0.0154106533,
0.0385520272,
-0.0162218753,
0.0177866668,
-0.0019993486,
0.011946273,
-0.0432844013,
-0.0214866828,
0.0264003724,
0.0168371964,
0.0775197297,
-0.016440317,
-0.0196648799,
-0.0462950096,
0.0200953782,
0.0151518304,
0.017386796,
-0.0439037718,
-0.0360478647,
0.0351766944,
-0.019329153,
-0.0219759513,
-0.0301943738,
-0.0485822856,
0.0045104194,
-0.035462074,
0.0092978347,
0.0417899266,
-0.0202740952,
0.0139343757,
-0.01884849,
-0.0250082947,
0.0403794162,
0.0234366115,
0.0423344858,
-0.007487955,
0.0904511735,
0.0179348569,
0.0112747252,
0.0184503887,
0.0314675421,
-0.0754056945,
-0.0713690147,
-0.0023151217,
0.0451490432,
0.0631037056,
-0.0278628767,
0.0317208506,
-0.0165071134,
0.0224454124,
-0.0343282335,
0.0629414096,
0.0002747326,
-0.0426157974,
0.0467314869,
-0.0048296717,
-0.0327751562,
0.0274608452,
0.0734513924,
-0.0044879653,
0.0380301476,
0.0462600738,
0.0131037496,
-0.0514844619,
-0.0294876602,
0.0155327711,
0.0174675249,
-0.0229990762,
0.0156073766,
-0.0294942223,
-0.0521090031,
-0.0285133254,
-0.0116227092,
0.0182429757,
0.0104481932,
0.0131643889,
0.0522483587,
-0.0269013848,
-0.0138395121,
-0.0376309194,
0.0061562578,
-0.0190411564,
0.0112261567,
-0.0184852816,
-6.297414172e-33,
-0.0237408727,
0.0470303707,
0.0384657159,
-0.0129164979,
0.020743778,
0.0219022315,
-0.0435015187,
0.003408079,
-0.0132153053,
-0.014112046,
-0.0114922682,
0.0212165453,
0.0299986247,
0.0296193007,
-0.0015371632,
-0.0517136194,
0.0567002296,
-0.0090217041,
0.0063507934,
0.005361496,
0.0366181731,
0.016323952,
0.0465540402,
-0.0226520188,
-0.0009253872,
-0.0081960177,
-0.0065880725,
0.0118416883,
-0.0089643365,
0.050483346,
-0.032398615,
-0.0001565226,
0.0200608224,
-0.0442312844,
-0.0033909767,
0.0158983991,
-0.0780212209,
-0.0247825552,
0.0404039174,
0.0516678803,
-0.0585699603,
0.0033259774,
-0.0106029352,
0.0003948922,
0.0011877188,
-0.023905104,
-0.0202047452,
0.0137481513,
-0.0284636263,
-0.0009608532,
-0.039588403,
0.0349421538,
-0.0260606483,
-0.029759394,
0.053073585,
0.0355361439,
0.0035117366,
0.0009285683,
-0.0720001459,
0.0025652645,
-0.0268001389,
0.0163053498,
0.0428701043,
0.0269835927,
-0.0131395124,
0.0651634932,
0.0363024734,
-0.024283791,
0.016219642,
0.0017426617,
-0.0030298724,
0.0193109196,
-0.0286427308,
0.0069036223,
0.0635329783,
0.0002096555,
-0.0478533916,
-0.0072160666,
0.0440173373,
0.0000473422,
0.0408029594,
0.024378093,
-0.0554912724,
-0.0168223158,
-0.0204890538,
-0.0259544365,
-0.0244690944,
-0.0102135967,
0.0668661296,
0.0267865155,
0.0243030954,
-0.0006485781,
0.0856367573,
-0.0328369848,
0.0197944343,
0.0155639835,
-0.0131845735,
-0.0059743365,
-0.0047992421,
0.0621004924,
-0.077744551,
-0.032412637,
0.0252224188,
0.0288265366,
0.0200163089,
-0.0084041255,
0.0357572362,
0.0295347944,
-0.0440476052,
-0.0126447631,
-0.0379630961,
0.0347367451,
-0.0408371203,
0.0568342134,
0.0655580014,
0.0061247475,
-0.0081708459,
0.0611959621,
-0.0064424658,
-0.0048092403,
-0.0462062769,
-0.0465274528,
-0.0157567803,
-0.0130453473,
-0.0415513627,
-0.0102824885,
0.0124400808,
-0.0258673411,
-0.0044881166,
-0.0569756776,
-0.0000073428,
0.0261631366,
2.714e-7,
0.0202123821,
0.0342408717,
0.0007344734,
0.0260154009,
0.0108338604,
0.044997409,
-0.02327751,
0.0021176971,
0.0116615221,
-0.0019670418,
0.0198362842,
0.017950803,
0.0406353436,
0.0013792235,
-0.0865209401,
-0.0025889096,
-0.0425346941,
0.0020577703,
-0.0181734897,
0.0185455121,
0.0582504794,
0.1507908851,
0.0007118194,
-0.0164597128,
0.0577991828,
-0.0473502465,
0.0343295448,
-0.0270353369,
0.01324757,
0.025731504,
0.0359585248,
0.0343195088,
-0.0129270395,
0.046981588,
-0.0010113072,
-0.0088319555,
-0.0229832269,
0.0690778419,
-0.0161503348,
0.001265472,
-0.0252919942,
0.0060622664,
0.0185581222,
-0.0653752238,
0.0908199921,
-0.0139710195,
-0.030441111,
-0.0384646542,
-0.0157583952,
-0.0076275263,
0.0167073533,
0.0446427763,
0.0184979662,
0.0149858948,
0.018722238,
-0.0414626636,
-0.0284241978,
-0.0792008266,
-0.0076569333,
-0.0258783642,
-0.0403158329,
-0.0123180356,
-0.0398713537,
0.0040178359,
0.069091633,
-0.0666563287,
-0.0212177671,
2.44344248e-34,
0.0526606552,
-0.0111483438,
0.0050249915,
0.0321351551,
0.0376112796,
-0.0108421603,
0.0179972425,
-0.0015532762,
0.0286819488,
-0.0681371838,
-0.0011779183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13507v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13507v3 | Multimodal Automated Fact-Checking: A Survey | 2023-05-22T21:52:24 | 2023-10-25T18:43:02 | Mubashara Akhtar, Michael Schlichtkrull, Zhijiang Guo, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Misinformation is often conveyed in multiple modalities, e.g. a miscaptioned
image. Multimodal misinformation is perceived as more credible by humans, and
spreads faster than its text-only counterparts. While an increasing body of
research investigates automated fact-checking (AFC), previous surveys mostly
focus on text. In this survey, we conceptualise a framework for AFC including
subtasks unique to multimodal misinformation. Furthermore, we discuss related
terms used in different communities and map them to our framework. We focus on
four modalities prevalent in real-world fact-checking: text, image, audio, and
video. We survey benchmarks and models, and discuss limitations and promising
directions for future research | [
0.0172333419,
0.0235334262,
-0.0104951337,
0.052096922,
-0.0399730653,
0.0005173552,
0.0222544204,
0.003849481,
-0.0340475738,
-0.0826558992,
-0.0125203291,
-0.0264253858,
0.0399682038,
0.0225943681,
0.0473451503,
-0.0508661941,
0.0557944402,
0.0081128366,
0.0518665276,
-0.0036105539,
0.0482719541,
0.0211555623,
-0.0538348742,
0.0410050936,
-0.0869798884,
-0.0402815603,
0.0222267099,
0.0115884952,
0.0361810774,
-0.0054698577,
-0.0171518456,
0.0357928425,
0.0419029929,
0.0572703369,
0.000001548,
-0.0074589998,
0.0127681475,
0.0160817932,
-0.0032760033,
0.0149106393,
0.0326857418,
-0.0286656525,
0.0038030732,
-0.0027941591,
0.0012220746,
-0.0151442727,
0.0586821474,
0.0448164567,
0.0968109667,
0.045736745,
-0.0011402996,
-0.0106724529,
-0.0374163352,
0.0278942138,
-0.0027237777,
-0.0120863914,
0.0103187785,
0.0273314361,
-0.0610300899,
0.0274742581,
-0.005580279,
0.0206064899,
-0.0119077265,
-0.0096150395,
-0.0498133972,
0.0246622581,
-0.0245300606,
-0.0465862416,
-0.0069574937,
0.0479105152,
0.0152052026,
-0.0098401979,
-0.0035291796,
0.0030438274,
-0.0075047775,
0.0571686253,
-0.0121583352,
0.0593788475,
-0.0478599593,
-0.023206519,
-0.0792264715,
-0.0290912036,
0.0388820879,
0.0156312454,
0.0737877563,
0.0190233421,
-0.0047530006,
0.0038870149,
-0.0264257938,
0.0042212503,
-0.0128112882,
-0.0511327162,
-0.0078635272,
0.0075920913,
0.0221508797,
-0.0082815848,
-0.0225642975,
-0.0332439803,
0.0589630008,
-0.0678156763,
0.0073351632,
-0.0102662928,
-0.0812039077,
0.048894763,
-0.0008944708,
-0.0036003424,
-0.0108115114,
-0.0059973379,
0.0357400328,
-0.0138127282,
-0.0074461326,
0.0205394849,
0.0137714902,
-0.0322991051,
-0.005149689,
0.0075295754,
-0.024945531,
-0.0439228825,
-0.0339996144,
0.0359924883,
-0.0413838476,
0.0085679814,
-0.0205174517,
-0.0262242593,
-0.0544920191,
0.0696863681,
-0.0265379548,
0.0437149778,
-0.0153613938,
-0.0306174662,
0.0219278578,
0.0409315936,
-0.0250956379,
0.0161848012,
0.0098457364,
0.008258651,
-0.0124842105,
0.0206610747,
-0.0322802104,
-0.0390436165,
-0.042543266,
-0.0606879629,
0.0090158088,
-0.0653173551,
0.0150254499,
-0.0198711045,
-0.029936716,
0.0230679158,
-0.0195414443,
0.0348716378,
-0.0336044766,
0.092762135,
0.0013371361,
-0.0024114465,
0.0744661465,
0.01830188,
-0.0105518159,
0.0432115234,
-0.0037613905,
0.0649145916,
0.0624188185,
0.0416334905,
0.0290219355,
-0.0153816454,
0.037403293,
0.0069708028,
0.04107555,
-0.0263207611,
-0.0247664154,
0.0123723326,
0.0298327021,
0.0569792315,
-0.0297879465,
-0.0433951207,
0.0878937989,
-0.0284686182,
-0.039619945,
-0.0578796603,
0.0458156951,
-0.0151133575,
0.0317779034,
0.0131086223,
-0.0338313803,
0.0625809804,
-0.0170930848,
-0.0051623154,
0.019475067,
0.0803920105,
-0.0029404708,
-0.0051144981,
-0.0253393408,
0.0019107466,
0.001178563,
-0.0091998735,
-0.0174583979,
0.0046286085,
-0.0431809388,
0.0221358836,
0.0211125594,
0.0084270528,
-0.0135672577,
-0.0378600769,
-0.0127380164,
0.0188264307,
0.0147608416,
0.0138885975,
0.0179667249,
-0.0272928607,
0.0399406478,
0.0148155801,
0.0487428941,
-0.0203879606,
-0.0246391799,
-0.0233025569,
0.0046591852,
-0.0436730124,
0.0339633264,
0.0211121626,
0.0443974547,
0.0274013951,
-0.0272788927,
-0.0261991024,
-0.0032901559,
0.0059281886,
0.0665978268,
0.0291640665,
-0.0444780849,
0.0259252172,
-0.0055224895,
0.0032031219,
-0.036325004,
-0.0199352819,
0.0200255848,
0.0358316824,
-0.0230266638,
0.0191710833,
0.0059511634,
-0.0020513621,
0.0360606723,
-0.0760152414,
-0.0638549179,
0.020662196,
-0.0176147688,
0.0427906998,
-0.0101192305,
-0.0402272828,
-0.0251693595,
-0.0559476167,
-0.0158868805,
0.0009942184,
0.0120537104,
0.0288438387,
0.0579681993,
-0.0286205895,
-0.0229908377,
-0.0003663957,
-0.0009137337,
0.0163656343,
0.0059813266,
-0.0077102743,
-0.0092782443,
0.0296308529,
0.0362556465,
0.0081496518,
-0.0363600627,
-0.0108692693,
0.0286176112,
-0.0684443414,
-0.0476256907,
-0.0062547959,
-0.031024605,
0.0226817317,
-0.0283803381,
0.0199116804,
-0.016959643,
0.0065414901,
0.0016178322,
-0.0125354882,
0.0427093096,
0.049389746,
-0.0049112071,
0.0243858565,
-0.0133908037,
0.0318117887,
-0.0010004438,
0.0319553912,
0.0317728855,
-0.0444870256,
-0.0494204275,
-0.0521649309,
-0.079193607,
0.0541315153,
-0.0374819003,
-0.0169877093,
0.031449575,
0.0472545885,
0.0233731326,
0.0183434524,
0.0409751981,
0.0222128425,
0.0387528874,
0.0336635336,
0.0271648746,
-0.0211114269,
0.0022730632,
0.008250217,
0.0293481164,
-0.0895200595,
0.0003496506,
-0.0002539813,
0.0534496941,
0.0265864469,
-0.0125715872,
0.0394088514,
-0.0032454657,
-0.0449043103,
-0.0047165109,
-0.01774114,
-0.0040650303,
0.0504954197,
-0.0460075848,
-0.0518359244,
0.0774674341,
-0.0251999944,
0.0429807678,
0.0206930004,
0.0075396663,
0.0256260019,
0.0141320936,
-0.0103559224,
0.0472278073,
0.0390452556,
0.0237427857,
-0.0220833551,
-0.0393785611,
0.0827127025,
-0.0180311073,
0.0132862134,
-0.0769924074,
0.0038547937,
0.0534018464,
-0.0382483713,
-0.0099460473,
-0.0866779983,
-0.0125034181,
-0.0554053783,
-0.0452960096,
-0.0427682996,
-0.0755102485,
-0.0247665606,
0.084296301,
0.0040197237,
0.0438080989,
-0.0140630128,
0.0359998532,
0.0360313468,
0.0462994166,
0.0350900851,
0.0520308651,
-0.0478535071,
-0.0401931666,
0.0804846361,
-0.0114456816,
-0.0027148637,
-0.0347882099,
-0.0513841808,
-0.0419257469,
0.0516826808,
0.0130774444,
0.005284817,
0.0617113374,
-0.0163713098,
0.0294973999,
0.0106848013,
-0.0031585114,
0.0185138099,
-0.0101201097,
0.0316914618,
-0.0303672627,
0.022173604,
-0.0351183154,
-0.0644697547,
-0.0213387161,
-0.0207714997,
-0.0147414971,
-0.0342556052,
0.0186221115,
-0.0317286365,
-0.0628164709,
0.0481869131,
-0.0176083073,
-0.0087570194,
-0.0535036698,
-0.0278171357,
0.0086243143,
0.0290419646,
0.0003943949,
0.0244762041,
0.0494981594,
-0.0310390852,
-0.0069279773,
-0.0054439213,
-0.0394069925,
0.0249298681,
-0.0347672552,
0.011807627,
0.0014433013,
0.024407452,
-0.0063515794,
-0.0684189126,
-0.0187880006,
0.0437692702,
-0.0223975442,
0.0040576225,
0.0674583241,
-0.0571586639,
-0.0210029278,
-0.0340453759,
-0.0119500235,
0.0719305649,
-0.0285338424,
-0.0462597832,
0.0413612165,
0.0039568017,
-0.0325518399,
-0.0433830246,
0.0325044356,
0.0284350216,
0.0253505316,
-0.0237813666,
0.0399039239,
-0.0034027533,
-0.002156947,
0.0006003269,
-0.0199028645,
-0.0507558137,
0.037663091,
0.0153721683,
-0.0255027395,
-0.0695331395,
0.0163562242,
-0.0260948651,
0.0376580618,
-0.0275904574,
-0.0249850061,
0.0226266235,
0.0129225552,
-0.0250166487,
-0.0108495057,
0.0021635676,
0.0545810126,
0.0239442531,
0.0013066059,
-0.0106930565,
-0.0245841816,
-0.0042833406,
0.0682141408,
-0.0848209932,
-0.0251613129,
-0.0077009993,
0.031677939,
0.0147774145,
0.0313366391,
0.0072576092,
-0.0105631249,
0.00343331,
0.0311921779,
-0.0248537902,
0.0453609601,
0.0044098906,
-0.0122026112,
-0.0048997193,
0.0038010073,
0.0078233462,
0.0174151734,
-0.0181551203,
-0.0319161043,
-0.0645422488,
-0.0076483074,
0.0270122886,
0.0174495503,
0.0317975543,
-0.0538128056,
0.0169186722,
-0.0308590587,
-0.0456227772,
0.0021744247,
-0.0385984071,
0.0281652827,
0.0407021865,
-0.0268801339,
-0.010286497,
-0.0077123241,
-0.00461498,
-0.0189437177,
0.0187102612,
0.0103315143,
-0.0440038592,
0.0499590039,
0.010693348,
-0.0113581223,
-0.0146970516,
-0.0079096155,
0.0213013515,
-0.0221594293,
0.0191106293,
0.0188292544,
0.0505925454,
0.0323277749,
-0.0458969511,
-0.0060683661,
-0.0418018065,
-0.031175565,
0.030641593,
-0.0231138598,
0.0438996889,
0.0474522598,
0.0231058393,
-0.0047190017,
-0.0337453485,
-0.0328896232,
0.0051147826,
-0.0353736244,
0.0053152288,
-0.0152834691,
0.0384074226,
0.0056803562,
0.0022714685,
0.0516545102,
0.0374243967,
-0.0340256691,
0.0440255627,
-0.0209699739,
-0.0740792826,
-0.0336790383,
-0.0203788411,
-0.0369315185,
0.0326256081,
0.0179335903,
0.0058319303,
-0.0927618146,
-0.0341809988,
0.0241330527,
0.0517684259,
0.0287866835,
0.0114592053,
-0.0088316407,
0.0917412639,
0.0417287052,
-0.0038202219,
-0.0206683595,
0.0103150057,
-0.0112936823,
0.0312799215,
0.0089911036,
-6.144619376e-33,
-0.0111666285,
-0.0926303267,
-0.0150954938,
-0.009104521,
0.0202755649,
0.0499138385,
0.0246474855,
-0.0063876039,
-0.0232422389,
0.0608656518,
0.0655189753,
0.0419575125,
-0.0105543258,
-0.0544387214,
-0.0160180647,
0.0052746562,
0.0275216252,
-0.0291482918,
-0.0610819459,
-0.0357040465,
0.050085701,
-0.0495323613,
0.0186099168,
-0.0755044073,
0.063475281,
-0.0047025704,
-0.0777632818,
0.0002632357,
-0.0225938205,
0.0247450992,
-0.0134039894,
0.0278916508,
0.0263499394,
-0.0082293553,
-0.0065208441,
0.0254315753,
-0.0348884463,
-0.0064574173,
0.0618395098,
0.0090925125,
-0.0560884178,
0.0380125269,
0.0327907726,
-0.0261112358,
-0.0260621216,
-0.0104892096,
0.0168959554,
0.0088332202,
0.0411530249,
0.0323601216,
-0.0395981036,
-0.0079485243,
0.0361902229,
-0.0242336504,
-0.0543495752,
0.0448848493,
0.0213599578,
0.0018219077,
-0.0894599035,
0.0266283825,
-0.0508406088,
-0.0252426304,
0.045039773,
-0.0423439629,
-0.039242357,
0.0625857934,
0.0144158211,
0.0378232002,
-0.0624762066,
0.0226602443,
-0.0189070012,
0.0377676785,
0.0534341931,
0.1437318772,
0.0053501651,
-0.0358445607,
-0.0312121715,
0.0145268748,
-0.0071859867,
0.0121822366,
-0.0072046746,
-0.0175102074,
-0.0219468344,
0.0108238487,
-0.0368418656,
0.0359874777,
-0.0441058576,
0.0035710796,
-0.0087831551,
0.0532142706,
0.0077618188,
0.061386317,
0.0004505286,
-0.0023580303,
0.0165967532,
-0.0283647422,
-0.0200504847,
0.0393571891,
0.015014315,
0.0152706988,
-0.0303807836,
0.0639125109,
0.0591887459,
0.0516634248,
0.0083726831,
-0.0057703885,
0.0535151698,
0.0181911662,
-0.0394362696,
0.0162635557,
-0.001903474,
0.0270976909,
-0.0072270366,
-0.0829172209,
0.0241598394,
0.0026636859,
-0.068393819,
-0.0318179838,
-0.0145469941,
0.0292304158,
-0.0153099475,
-0.0184414145,
-0.0361543633,
0.04391196,
-0.0277465228,
0.0240358934,
-0.0521141589,
-0.0728767291,
-0.0213773325,
-0.0740342215,
-0.0036987488,
0.0342099406,
2.409e-7,
-0.0079784887,
0.0535372458,
0.0138009693,
0.0049546664,
0.0529364832,
0.0501911305,
-0.0138970921,
-0.0257951897,
-0.0319148898,
-0.1161277592,
-0.0504666343,
0.0355329551,
0.0055053653,
0.045136068,
0.0450801253,
-0.0028946227,
-0.0028553959,
-0.0098106787,
-0.0313503444,
0.0107536027,
-0.0046166815,
0.0194711778,
0.0172422063,
-0.0449265689,
-0.0100416476,
-0.0022841413,
0.0833754465,
0.0736311525,
-0.0729526058,
-0.0426238328,
0.0356608629,
-0.0120056588,
-0.0068595032,
0.032249894,
0.0031436344,
-0.0940424651,
0.0249158852,
-0.0004444009,
0.0151317753,
-0.027412625,
-0.0513384715,
0.0007627198,
-0.0165174492,
-0.0226407517,
0.023414148,
0.0145839136,
-0.031966228,
-0.0670239702,
-0.0203103367,
0.0452600345,
0.0293260645,
-0.0003403177,
-0.0690511689,
0.0073684501,
0.017833354,
0.0356792547,
-0.0314293876,
-0.0360682346,
0.0014246956,
0.026442321,
-0.0502746068,
-0.0451589078,
0.0285471566,
-0.066417709,
0.0546714999,
-0.0478142351,
-0.0201338399,
1.478393646e-34,
0.0382605195,
-0.027120715,
-0.0044402471,
-0.0623754114,
0.0336131491,
0.0134138186,
-0.0509472378,
-0.066655457,
0.0284908488,
0.0182216167,
-0.0024789597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13504v1 | Neural Machine Translation for Code Generation | 2023-05-22T21:43:12 | 2023-05-22T21:43:12 | Dharma KC, Clayton T. Morrison | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, A.1 | Neural machine translation (NMT) methods developed for natural language
processing have been shown to be highly successful in automating translation
from one natural language to another. Recently, these NMT methods have been
adapted to the generation of program code. In NMT for code generation, the task
is to generate output source code that satisfies constraints expressed in the
input. In the literature, a variety of different input scenarios have been
explored, including generating code based on natural language description,
lower-level representations such as binary or assembly (neural decompilation),
partial representations of source code (code completion and repair), and source
code in another language (code translation). In this paper we survey the NMT
for code generation literature, cataloging the variety of methods that have
been explored according to input and output representations, model
architectures, optimization techniques used, data sets, and evaluation methods.
We discuss the limitations of existing methods and future research directions | [
0.003121828,
0.0675617158,
-0.021685997,
0.0277218129,
-0.0226633959,
-0.0244688392,
-0.0400526635,
-0.0054624081,
-0.004095945,
0.0118657807,
0.0234325118,
0.0234414972,
0.0152830658,
0.0311543867,
0.0454256274,
0.0044004046,
0.0073130075,
0.0098441094,
-0.0498806573,
0.0286370274,
-0.0186383892,
0.0318583623,
0.034727674,
0.0416423827,
-0.0005246685,
-0.0213586744,
0.0058690985,
0.0528571643,
-0.0013835507,
-0.0094179502,
0.0280903671,
0.0022248561,
0.0125890924,
-0.0157254767,
0.0000020834,
-0.0023931449,
-0.002890595,
-0.007240911,
0.0364539586,
0.0001577478,
0.0195092428,
-0.0396300629,
0.0021950961,
0.0433750339,
-0.0261062384,
-0.0259286072,
0.054080762,
-0.0377978459,
0.1006651372,
0.0661857203,
-0.0029796741,
-0.0158591773,
0.0078732446,
0.0022631574,
0.0123641165,
0.0094070155,
-0.017198205,
0.0299628284,
-0.0207612477,
-0.0073346384,
-0.002282883,
0.0262917019,
0.041880969,
0.0061349175,
-0.0010355624,
0.0422801301,
-0.0287853144,
-0.0247222986,
-0.0278061777,
0.0548356399,
-0.0979254916,
-0.0041619167,
0.0018924868,
-0.0159529019,
-0.0105237449,
-0.0685175583,
-0.0054188878,
0.0345566198,
-0.0148855308,
0.0205829386,
-0.0148505801,
0.0096393116,
-0.0067359987,
-0.0237253569,
-0.0209604651,
0.009092412,
0.0191119332,
-0.0191636607,
-0.0588607453,
-0.0342207812,
0.0217474066,
-0.0134149166,
0.051276762,
0.0486786291,
0.0119845578,
0.0187169276,
-0.0682651326,
-0.0226252936,
0.0005475368,
-0.0707114935,
0.0366663635,
0.0734567642,
-0.0123268282,
0.0126339607,
-0.052055534,
0.0731506422,
-0.0380851999,
-0.0099977376,
-0.0351489745,
0.0346168652,
-0.066436328,
0.0009357889,
-0.0593121946,
0.0595338643,
-0.0045440332,
0.0376191139,
-0.0269963704,
0.0218149405,
0.0263892766,
0.0449920148,
0.0147070773,
0.024192974,
-0.0724963918,
-0.0071986183,
0.0075687682,
-0.003552858,
-0.0093608508,
-0.0840082094,
-0.0197124761,
-0.0145460339,
-0.0004927741,
0.0239235647,
-0.046523232,
-0.0488104522,
0.0361808576,
0.1008345336,
0.0000555248,
0.0395013392,
-0.0611781031,
-0.038428355,
0.0290855672,
-0.0286906026,
0.032419242,
-0.0619028397,
0.009858964,
-0.0186829679,
-0.0314372703,
-0.0815702155,
0.0116021791,
0.0107590677,
0.0094307568,
0.0597359389,
-0.0700744241,
-0.0091298642,
0.0306454394,
-0.003106934,
0.0163853355,
-0.0061237318,
0.0785058364,
0.0249476042,
-0.0243330915,
-0.0442535318,
0.017863851,
0.0209382232,
0.0047721341,
-0.0108445697,
-0.0337423943,
0.0088169873,
-0.0034454474,
0.0267653018,
0.0142453443,
0.0397267453,
-0.0278256573,
-0.0065127285,
-0.0097831832,
0.0381025709,
0.0369214378,
0.0909893215,
0.0852195695,
0.0133549543,
-0.0194920991,
-0.0239398219,
-0.032817658,
0.0866621509,
0.0098088617,
0.0136066861,
0.0006340252,
0.0739486739,
-0.0045870957,
-0.0660177618,
0.0286554955,
-0.0452220999,
0.0397574529,
-0.0265296958,
-0.00980906,
0.005496813,
-0.0722641051,
0.0289264023,
-0.0364494361,
-0.0672364533,
0.0039347513,
-0.0519804955,
-0.0354260504,
0.0351329669,
0.0486049689,
-0.0276623573,
-0.0365225039,
0.0039946758,
-0.0557632782,
0.0142675182,
0.0001391825,
0.0096542509,
0.0189764183,
-0.071829699,
-0.0195805766,
-0.040275462,
-0.0182621349,
0.0594117902,
-0.0109486422,
-0.013598823,
0.0608909279,
0.0302054491,
-0.073260963,
0.0491462313,
0.0065288404,
-0.012742389,
0.0561733879,
-0.0002874611,
0.0204443838,
-0.0025665814,
-0.0296197534,
0.0214979444,
0.0246665142,
-0.0152820386,
-0.0481915511,
-0.021316614,
-0.0490062088,
-0.0460016169,
0.0400592349,
-0.0674831197,
0.0011575052,
0.0272303261,
-0.0321973003,
-0.0475232638,
0.0626483038,
-0.0481590778,
-0.0117579969,
-0.0095813442,
-0.011630726,
0.0026174069,
-0.0289182197,
-0.0196755975,
0.0565338619,
0.0178323239,
-0.0007864839,
0.0153943319,
0.0021800695,
0.0522265323,
0.0032127884,
0.0063243653,
0.00856434,
-0.0315336548,
0.0451790169,
0.0291524436,
0.0930306986,
0.0066551757,
-0.045151297,
-0.0183442663,
0.0473423228,
-0.0122436062,
0.0073997146,
0.0467114188,
0.0420555435,
0.0281789992,
-0.0283986628,
-0.0559476539,
0.0228615776,
-0.0246984828,
-0.0381693467,
0.0122304661,
-0.022621043,
-0.0211983956,
-0.0210997891,
-0.0362463668,
-0.0345554054,
0.024265185,
0.0020354667,
-0.0193745345,
-0.1128134057,
0.0447949246,
-0.0243001133,
0.0350931659,
-0.0105400858,
-0.0660754964,
0.0121500688,
-0.037833754,
0.0402245969,
0.0417142436,
-0.0337240547,
-0.0086357901,
0.0564871468,
0.0133586749,
-0.0418118536,
0.0523283891,
-0.0084408578,
-0.0090155397,
0.0179692116,
-0.0678880215,
0.0397399813,
0.0478695109,
0.0523452833,
-0.0192060918,
-0.0739718452,
0.0230928715,
0.0447908267,
0.0179406982,
0.0029123824,
-0.0380141512,
0.0018123076,
0.0443913005,
-0.0428205058,
-0.0676023886,
0.0655793324,
-0.0319639742,
0.0099187223,
-0.0393061377,
-0.0076642395,
-0.0467928797,
0.0357444882,
-0.0010696372,
0.0111000789,
0.0191756319,
-0.0547763556,
-0.0333402008,
0.0155435521,
-0.0341217928,
-0.0080273179,
0.0229776576,
-0.0369182639,
0.0049714763,
0.013581994,
0.0225208588,
-0.0173817575,
0.0123863127,
0.0513434522,
0.0025500022,
0.0221364759,
-0.0064073675,
0.0458840504,
0.0127295852,
-0.0176413115,
0.0393847711,
0.027382873,
-0.0251210257,
-0.0180707332,
-0.0429511294,
-0.0321731754,
-0.035917826,
-0.0439385474,
0.0122387055,
-0.0518151447,
-0.0331377797,
-0.006439188,
0.067682378,
-0.0944570303,
0.0043587908,
0.0112105189,
0.0080257664,
-0.0079507725,
0.0304334592,
0.0412935838,
-0.025031453,
-0.0219507832,
0.05558661,
0.0220302157,
-0.0416127406,
-0.0016956673,
0.0017429403,
0.0104947407,
0.0562141947,
0.0596145391,
-0.0245534703,
-0.0008124251,
-0.0307037551,
0.0759551302,
0.0373142846,
-0.0054904805,
-0.04907934,
-0.054858923,
0.0009200285,
0.0437827259,
-0.0566905141,
-0.0786767229,
-0.0043384386,
-0.0487983078,
-0.0249003619,
-0.0302501023,
0.027463425,
0.0250168648,
0.0205681194,
-0.0197631046,
0.0095317382,
0.0086616054,
0.0112570962,
-0.0313064493,
0.0356286503,
0.1214065701,
0.0358101241,
0.0415755585,
0.0139945876,
0.0295396354,
0.0063853152,
0.046162717,
-0.0207556915,
0.0166172385,
0.0237490609,
-0.0220635738,
0.0291074608,
0.0066752923,
-0.0477226041,
0.032531321,
0.0355437733,
0.0385107696,
-0.0110840788,
0.0033522549,
-0.0412589125,
-0.0058880718,
0.0183086526,
0.0072337436,
0.0581725538,
-0.0127713121,
-0.0134958262,
-0.0595548078,
0.0062414897,
-0.0858282,
0.018914273,
-0.0081145922,
-0.0227979925,
0.0186983235,
-0.0618125014,
-0.0246092156,
-0.0112297125,
0.0227460843,
0.0476470292,
-0.0807174221,
0.0830542594,
-0.0222670548,
-0.0557827689,
0.006882445,
-0.0082157338,
-0.0082326327,
0.0096468078,
0.0036879496,
0.0064198142,
-0.0376473516,
0.0206842627,
0.0177573264,
-0.0799370185,
-0.0441732593,
-0.0708841607,
0.0986088067,
0.0139625929,
0.0452860259,
-0.0474648513,
-0.0500380173,
-0.0522279218,
0.0175673999,
-0.0103917969,
-0.0279085487,
-0.0036035988,
0.0122712925,
0.0117145479,
-0.0093116239,
-0.0456994884,
0.0063742027,
0.0204624441,
0.0254732743,
0.0131766228,
0.0062799035,
0.0803602934,
0.0320644379,
-0.0098600648,
0.0117538879,
-0.0114794271,
-0.000847295,
-0.0134352176,
-0.0033757912,
-0.0058653285,
-0.0817489326,
0.0251548551,
0.0569953509,
-0.0076358444,
0.0457621515,
-0.0413947701,
-0.0404657684,
0.0323601551,
0.0102547593,
0.0062761712,
-0.0170069728,
0.0690134093,
0.0376168452,
0.0052305376,
-0.0188672636,
0.0311086569,
-0.0128646502,
0.0023368811,
-0.0270445608,
0.0340714976,
0.0178724192,
0.0554809347,
-0.0202600993,
0.0085755708,
-0.0067520346,
-0.0393068232,
-0.0398485027,
0.0015658471,
0.0413032584,
0.0694644824,
0.0123995468,
-0.0173703954,
0.0268598888,
0.0002438902,
0.0875167921,
0.0104226535,
-0.0408959948,
0.0043581235,
0.0194197707,
0.0154373934,
-0.0685662031,
0.0624842644,
-0.0288613718,
-0.0083259512,
-0.0186741352,
0.0063726651,
-0.0480154566,
0.0302239601,
-0.0035815153,
-0.0274482649,
-0.0200555325,
-0.0058495039,
0.0212309714,
-0.0375586599,
0.0069807377,
0.0699976906,
0.0514167473,
0.0188523326,
0.0215242915,
0.0603760667,
-0.0285022724,
-0.0066609508,
-0.0045941495,
0.0009881262,
-0.0107992776,
-0.0469728522,
-0.0734924152,
-5.811908557e-33,
-0.0242776107,
-0.0253028497,
0.0279335603,
0.011679125,
-0.0273487866,
-0.0376004279,
-0.0663073957,
-0.025808055,
0.0057129888,
-0.0712731704,
0.035752207,
0.0259496421,
-0.02719667,
-0.0159116071,
0.0493102893,
0.025212165,
0.0331852064,
-0.0075633978,
-0.0506365858,
0.0337188169,
-0.0387944505,
0.0265485365,
0.0508029126,
-0.0406608284,
-0.002885307,
0.0014605635,
0.0268939715,
0.0194559768,
-0.0049621365,
-0.0008087715,
0.0050006541,
0.0092289429,
0.0142190056,
-0.016055312,
-0.0350191519,
-0.0264194608,
-0.0339756981,
-0.0643082708,
0.0314239785,
-0.0061382432,
-0.0055320915,
-0.0576052666,
0.1064441949,
-0.0383389778,
-0.0253971424,
-0.0019888375,
0.039684251,
0.018029023,
0.0001692611,
-0.0291214343,
-0.0613339804,
-0.0018269123,
-0.0373051092,
-0.0333057083,
-0.0198204909,
0.0384631157,
-0.0235503055,
0.0177391432,
-0.0128436005,
-0.0060152547,
0.0188337825,
0.0688597187,
0.0480021872,
0.0039772335,
0.0316495225,
-0.0060162721,
0.0664095432,
0.0191251989,
-0.0393337384,
0.0307116099,
0.0559060127,
0.0000689742,
0.0766025558,
-0.005592477,
0.043050535,
-0.0115229599,
-0.0142067345,
0.0202201772,
-0.0312066674,
0.0253555942,
-0.0196948778,
0.0391505063,
0.0049524819,
0.0038999494,
-0.0241121501,
-0.0608405434,
-0.0351047367,
-0.0561331995,
0.0209515691,
0.0047533838,
-0.0350073949,
-0.0262068659,
0.0107236151,
-0.0171367601,
0.0673543811,
0.0095196925,
-0.0337333158,
0.0019217932,
-0.0082281185,
0.0144619169,
0.0303778201,
-0.0248284005,
0.013543644,
-0.0059176357,
0.0744776204,
0.0177897327,
0.0088327285,
0.0521877334,
0.0025035716,
0.0155573413,
-0.0541306995,
-0.0186778437,
0.0116944965,
0.0125850225,
-0.0219751056,
-0.0027665927,
-0.0092567923,
-0.0226158276,
0.0166749451,
-0.0294038486,
-0.0162837449,
0.0186153948,
0.0329943821,
0.0336721167,
-0.0644381642,
-0.0121009108,
-0.0621558987,
0.0436782315,
0.0314733163,
-0.024818914,
-0.0771056116,
0.0421016328,
2.744e-7,
0.0247574542,
0.021041669,
0.0239800811,
0.0560252666,
-0.0109432396,
0.0100160725,
-0.0344027095,
-0.0021726731,
0.0314178243,
-0.003044693,
-0.0136690196,
-0.0172180999,
0.0377475172,
0.0169239845,
-0.070769012,
0.0303035527,
0.0101967352,
0.0213942081,
-0.0586569309,
0.0211800318,
0.0747649819,
0.0493507721,
-0.020270545,
0.0146503821,
0.0032736056,
-0.0309668761,
-0.0102344928,
-0.0036232921,
0.0170943849,
-0.0066789705,
-0.0412297472,
0.0428554267,
-0.0534809604,
-0.026384078,
-0.0058432375,
-0.017872395,
0.0256173685,
0.0592502654,
-0.0201571081,
0.0252949037,
0.0624664165,
0.0046317657,
-0.0268920586,
-0.0180425104,
-0.004976003,
-0.0761673748,
0.0046683135,
0.0263203736,
-0.0204550903,
0.0269045476,
0.0177560467,
-0.0725230724,
0.0282083135,
-0.0191436112,
0.0020052651,
-0.0102301594,
-0.0105139855,
-0.0098212734,
-0.0293546822,
0.0076520471,
-0.0062712743,
-0.0029525273,
-0.0202930048,
0.0133145321,
0.0429130569,
-0.0065656141,
0.0068236971,
2.243678006e-34,
0.0143158464,
-0.0523886979,
0.0304441396,
-0.0058727586,
0.0377782248,
-0.0166266896,
-0.0726138577,
0.0341730192,
-0.0189427733,
-0.0039674132,
-0.0869967118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13499v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13499v2 | Learning Easily Updated General Purpose Text Representations with Adaptable Task-Specific Prefixes | 2023-05-22T21:31:03 | 2023-10-14T15:35:07 | Kuan-Hao Huang, Liang Tan, Rui Hou, Sinong Wang, Amjad Almahairi, Ruty Rinott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many real-world applications require making multiple predictions from the
same text. Fine-tuning a large pre-trained language model for each downstream
task causes computational burdens in the inference time due to several times of
forward passes. To amortize the computational cost, freezing the language model
and building lightweight models for downstream tasks based on fixed text
representations are common solutions. Accordingly, how to learn fixed but
general text representations that can generalize well to unseen downstream
tasks becomes a challenge. Previous works have shown that the generalizability
of representations can be improved by fine-tuning the pre-trained language
model with some source tasks in a multi-tasking way. In this work, we propose a
prefix-based method to learn the fixed text representations with source tasks.
We learn a task-specific prefix for each source task independently and combine
them to get the final representations. Our experimental results show that
prefix-based training performs better than multi-tasking training and can
update the text representations at a smaller computational cost than
multi-tasking training. | [
0.0250362493,
0.0157110002,
-0.0045946157,
0.0048448765,
-0.0256651733,
0.0094631417,
0.0160217136,
0.0075600166,
-0.0008732887,
-0.0782034025,
-0.0531784482,
-0.0407952964,
0.0045502498,
0.0280569512,
0.0415380858,
-0.0504178219,
0.0523347557,
-0.0108991405,
-0.0115656918,
0.0107164318,
0.0450545214,
0.0331503861,
0.0212040823,
0.0443419144,
0.0095059359,
-0.0258885752,
-0.0040243054,
-0.0151950754,
0.0150496364,
0.0183681995,
0.0359136462,
0.0405667387,
0.0566257238,
0.0256890375,
0.0000017232,
-0.0156039502,
-0.0328368917,
-0.0252130758,
-0.0208362341,
-0.0236846842,
0.0695510209,
-0.0179247987,
0.0128927305,
0.0017244435,
-0.027797658,
-0.0207748339,
0.045017451,
0.0530737862,
0.0526493192,
0.0902048573,
-0.0069102896,
0.0053708372,
0.0013754906,
-0.0637556389,
0.027289344,
-0.0429533385,
0.0215677805,
-0.0094174482,
-0.0165658891,
0.0687556565,
-0.017113762,
0.0072881784,
0.0074596805,
0.0250629652,
-0.0127884438,
0.0309106819,
0.01189702,
0.0293729287,
-0.0365750603,
0.0727036595,
-0.0749265254,
-0.0297378022,
-0.0041455505,
-0.0276284181,
-0.0168472938,
-0.0386274159,
-0.0514565334,
-0.0012597633,
0.0075165904,
0.0313934572,
0.0308623556,
0.0041041719,
0.0158323515,
0.0111295637,
-0.0258666929,
0.0230765808,
0.0017826019,
-0.0151179042,
-0.0012476526,
0.0307756457,
-0.0093469415,
-0.035604693,
0.010086243,
0.0115039591,
-0.0151468655,
0.0400769152,
-0.0827231109,
-0.0815918818,
-0.0136628468,
-0.0584800355,
0.0486150086,
0.0543515757,
-0.0238941275,
0.0433451943,
-0.0615349896,
0.0339906961,
0.0078462679,
0.0456926562,
-0.0434116684,
-0.0166047327,
-0.065277867,
-0.0162023231,
-0.0642937049,
0.0485006347,
-0.046846021,
-0.0218177289,
-0.0180503372,
0.0461284295,
-0.0186945274,
-0.0332734063,
0.0601647161,
0.013280808,
-0.0817920044,
-0.0238441769,
0.013513986,
0.0251248721,
-0.0307109412,
0.0479558557,
-0.0003317187,
-0.01220839,
-0.0349320136,
-0.0025851643,
0.0427464582,
-0.0430121161,
0.0001729032,
0.0453677401,
-0.0140252011,
-0.0365522616,
-0.0557835177,
-0.0143685052,
-0.0104666874,
-0.049907174,
-0.0311229117,
-0.035608083,
0.0427487642,
-0.001041844,
0.0027451359,
-0.0367544219,
-0.0077314866,
0.0313441902,
-0.0618559383,
0.0824440494,
0.0032173516,
-0.0300501529,
-0.0028474755,
0.0136391064,
-0.0130804386,
0.0802858695,
0.0020154265,
0.0511823595,
0.027479995,
0.0272781383,
-0.0396888293,
0.0299795326,
0.0307724867,
0.0031157751,
0.0273089949,
0.0070522521,
0.0416841507,
0.0053886715,
0.0177793298,
0.0119280666,
-0.0255237315,
-0.0092450734,
0.0652221441,
0.0227953196,
0.0128322141,
0.0233357623,
0.0739610419,
0.0230498835,
-0.0174385253,
0.0173857287,
-0.0331939273,
0.0079886932,
-0.0409439914,
-0.0119076362,
-0.0109894257,
0.0102488706,
-0.0590378568,
-0.0190268103,
0.0297399573,
-0.048138503,
0.0299939681,
-0.0086720381,
0.0498003066,
0.0261714403,
-0.0999124572,
0.0434784219,
0.0447642021,
-0.0397283323,
0.0161617883,
-0.0229976233,
0.0070438953,
0.050561469,
-0.0159052946,
-0.0520858541,
-0.0431511402,
0.0059023635,
0.0378255025,
-0.0220943093,
0.0202440545,
-0.0243447646,
0.0310715139,
-0.0471643284,
-0.0225067884,
-0.005604147,
0.0048612827,
0.012197623,
0.0015124222,
0.0105496105,
0.0409377813,
-0.0197069887,
-0.0273316465,
0.0393463336,
-0.0154274991,
-0.0353888981,
0.0297360849,
0.0114269899,
0.0034183767,
-0.0098211505,
0.0206234213,
0.0118110897,
0.0339852087,
-0.0282901563,
-0.0051226141,
-0.012800497,
-0.0616216138,
-0.0440597273,
-0.0112934588,
0.0211168099,
-0.0062883836,
0.0407014079,
-0.0519781075,
-0.0464962311,
-0.0135578085,
-0.0034767499,
0.0210338719,
-0.0059440932,
0.0042402134,
0.0216198396,
0.0014653853,
-0.0355725624,
0.0507810153,
0.0175003633,
0.0104038035,
-0.0144975819,
0.0079166824,
-0.0120820589,
-0.0260357596,
-0.0288997814,
-0.0151565047,
0.0141541576,
0.0053527933,
0.0163677819,
-0.0127883097,
-0.0223211348,
0.0045285146,
-0.0974940881,
0.0080364812,
-0.0475801006,
0.004550192,
0.0374569818,
0.0140007492,
0.0221019834,
-0.0345108025,
-0.053440243,
-0.0008657103,
-0.0172299221,
0.025510475,
-0.0010550123,
0.0170354284,
0.0541505106,
-0.023300156,
-0.0134412134,
-0.0029358664,
0.055339504,
-0.0197441671,
-0.0256690625,
-0.0689415112,
-0.0041220868,
0.0075650336,
0.0308202412,
-0.009422983,
0.0131468261,
-0.0235734805,
-0.0158467349,
0.0955249667,
0.0384814851,
0.0119984634,
0.0126090338,
0.0176970698,
-0.0096896263,
-0.0387852602,
0.0039440929,
-0.0329201408,
0.0013757054,
-0.0341471583,
-0.0085885879,
0.0124668963,
0.0564021841,
-0.0041026552,
-0.0288485382,
-0.0794063509,
-0.0080980491,
-0.0251859985,
-0.0316234156,
-0.0372522771,
-0.0004517423,
-0.0155964987,
-0.0219680648,
-0.0219247583,
-0.0336734466,
0.058404766,
-0.0228144787,
0.0016282538,
-0.0507997647,
-0.0261932295,
-0.02712157,
0.0863648057,
-0.0171335936,
0.0413966626,
0.0249620546,
-0.0318139717,
-0.0752909184,
0.0258247647,
-0.0034096639,
-0.0019231359,
0.0736330077,
-0.0187878404,
0.014156918,
-0.0184583496,
-0.0270657893,
-0.0211841781,
-0.0462877974,
-0.0130333547,
0.0354064181,
0.037418969,
0.0152899371,
-0.0400660932,
0.0255809221,
-0.0149475997,
0.0468451865,
-0.0367360003,
0.0075446651,
-0.0463549905,
0.0094639957,
0.0513261147,
0.006841368,
-0.0619671084,
-0.0377981141,
-0.034890946,
0.0282687023,
0.051919803,
-0.035842102,
-0.0382237621,
0.0114744306,
0.0445931703,
-0.0536132976,
-0.0170732588,
-0.0039852485,
0.0289326143,
-0.0455862395,
-0.0062020388,
0.0929929465,
0.013232152,
-0.0562924072,
-0.0040844507,
0.0162846018,
0.010015456,
0.0066218586,
0.0151444636,
-0.0839515477,
-0.0388666801,
-0.0133535154,
-0.0088019669,
0.0417767018,
-0.0164980665,
-0.0306929816,
-0.0923161432,
-0.0376162082,
0.0175025091,
0.0048336447,
-0.0065938155,
-0.0007425941,
0.0108915223,
-0.0055730781,
0.0167240538,
-0.0081845066,
-0.0054635489,
-0.0177140012,
0.0304958317,
-0.0115614878,
-0.024072228,
0.0191328935,
-0.0129017159,
-0.0127554154,
0.0296442192,
0.0034330455,
0.0189680867,
0.0070669451,
0.0059781601,
0.0055277906,
-0.0131124686,
-0.0185757633,
0.0596714914,
-0.0437169224,
0.0019883155,
0.0193688907,
-0.0088058291,
-0.0060661482,
-0.0213419199,
-0.0060300995,
0.0798781961,
-0.0202775858,
0.0123914704,
0.0032544804,
-0.0333864167,
0.0441538692,
0.0674324334,
-0.0181019753,
-0.0641173869,
-0.0210933816,
-0.0060665477,
-0.0092039201,
-0.0458409488,
-0.0491643026,
-0.0100710085,
-0.0507416837,
0.0271648597,
-0.0678409413,
-0.0316892341,
0.0733218268,
0.0605051182,
0.0037882852,
0.0149639742,
0.0212895554,
-0.0112385228,
-0.0598844774,
-0.0011588015,
-0.0390324444,
0.0235154368,
-0.0376112312,
-0.0363716856,
0.0662443638,
-0.0104032587,
-0.0297660362,
0.0248174649,
-0.1082764715,
-0.0338288993,
-0.0133644668,
0.0451550484,
0.0107100783,
0.0412656777,
-0.030740276,
-0.025211351,
0.0347275101,
-0.026826201,
-0.0274287146,
0.0193414558,
0.0503828302,
-0.0344511047,
-0.0131665887,
0.0449422523,
-0.0594512187,
0.0398565866,
0.0321437009,
0.0321335755,
-0.0009169987,
-0.0147697777,
0.011218234,
-0.0317518897,
0.0545111746,
0.0212511979,
0.0252069961,
-0.0491666459,
0.0297973268,
-0.0027368474,
-0.0229845364,
-0.0378059037,
0.0316541083,
0.0253592916,
-0.0240187105,
-0.0167858172,
0.034518756,
0.0082312385,
0.0128426356,
-0.0776250958,
-0.0276687499,
-0.0347943492,
0.0257451143,
0.0210270565,
0.0451457426,
-0.0204902198,
-0.0177549515,
0.0095659494,
-0.0126746586,
-0.0382461883,
-0.0024005244,
0.0393322334,
0.0121024568,
-0.0621218458,
0.0249541514,
-0.0634381026,
-0.0280760769,
-0.0384408087,
0.0090778265,
0.0240663532,
-0.0229265988,
0.0153645007,
-0.0060276496,
-0.0162483584,
-0.0261603463,
0.0319085643,
0.0204066634,
-0.0040373285,
0.0095853042,
-0.0010529241,
-0.0114426063,
-0.013902029,
0.1035954505,
0.0154826427,
0.0377432331,
0.0100620547,
-0.0082126008,
-0.0323578268,
-0.051614482,
0.016608594,
0.0397008657,
-0.0049410011,
0.0006737983,
-0.0092033548,
-0.0657711178,
0.0430547632,
-0.0469736643,
-0.0133698247,
0.0086442521,
0.0506973229,
0.041655764,
0.0075098784,
0.024470197,
-0.0415670387,
0.0061763949,
0.0272330344,
-0.0085037034,
-0.0055281855,
-5.817310688e-33,
-0.037786819,
0.0300216954,
-0.0000636311,
-0.025188284,
-0.0209971555,
0.0326210558,
-0.0196514074,
-0.0197704993,
0.0083260722,
-0.0142317675,
0.0051164469,
0.0042567514,
0.025909109,
0.0278425198,
-0.0194897652,
-0.0087689441,
0.0622917823,
-0.0044622044,
0.0081650233,
0.0463489518,
0.0693266317,
0.0606318936,
0.0919672102,
-0.0534607843,
0.0588771887,
-0.0140638053,
-0.0076410831,
-0.0137928799,
0.0559012704,
0.0677317753,
0.0028447818,
0.0586401187,
0.032766927,
-0.0609069131,
-0.0672900975,
0.0620541126,
-0.1203541458,
-0.0391264558,
0.0350819454,
-0.0235441849,
-0.0562412515,
-0.0058037285,
0.0124226827,
0.0045794556,
0.0354616083,
0.0064494968,
0.0400707908,
-0.0155164236,
-0.034647923,
-0.0173241124,
-0.0802623183,
0.0065187439,
0.0299124271,
0.0115819136,
0.0355763882,
0.0564711168,
0.0447798967,
0.0202324986,
-0.0512757041,
-0.0123759992,
-0.0220841113,
0.0614645891,
0.0036138066,
0.0401305221,
-0.0021397353,
0.0418151505,
-0.0345413908,
0.0281905066,
-0.0107378894,
0.0002088943,
0.0393125229,
0.0363521874,
0.0224582236,
0.0050304723,
0.0346945971,
-0.0335889272,
-0.0670348257,
0.0125535782,
0.052554477,
-0.0090949489,
0.0383771397,
0.0362423845,
-0.0019388174,
-0.0156546924,
-0.0299084317,
0.0355614461,
-0.0217845794,
-0.0381677374,
0.0399008915,
0.0485660806,
0.0008622411,
0.0866256431,
0.0588100031,
-0.0346136987,
-0.0198426284,
0.0108848279,
-0.010989855,
-0.0076976623,
0.0133897439,
0.0334140621,
-0.0306609794,
-0.0547493808,
0.0298266262,
-0.0140289143,
-0.0075572403,
-0.0084402543,
0.0862343684,
0.0190371946,
-0.0698574781,
-0.0156895183,
-0.0193023533,
0.0008541263,
0.0153205032,
0.0741331726,
0.0513745956,
0.0209776089,
-0.0100590819,
0.0463126004,
0.0301784892,
-0.0493064038,
-0.0097785247,
-0.0153066991,
0.0125003457,
0.0351458751,
-0.0314362608,
-0.0270704012,
-0.0250497796,
0.0130154546,
0.032118801,
-0.05657636,
-0.0065572145,
0.0188710783,
2.409e-7,
0.0353425853,
0.007901568,
-0.0056594228,
0.0071918811,
-0.0050732982,
0.0147289708,
-0.008626854,
0.0868371129,
-0.0116279721,
0.006438212,
0.0175951459,
0.0073678936,
0.0137836542,
-0.0155261401,
-0.0940973386,
0.00240248,
-0.049619846,
0.0519929305,
-0.0433581248,
0.0199535415,
0.0534762368,
0.1147294343,
0.0389063805,
0.0202297401,
0.0060699005,
-0.0177218504,
0.1069187894,
-0.0234008618,
0.0157122947,
0.0313399248,
-0.0116272643,
0.0413043946,
-0.0410732254,
-0.0023992134,
-0.036484044,
0.01518925,
0.0398760773,
0.0541935228,
-0.0347628556,
-0.0221683402,
0.0032571654,
-0.0132135767,
0.0076558623,
0.0103689497,
0.0838101804,
-0.0765293315,
-0.0079943528,
-0.0280240793,
0.0178592112,
0.0392223038,
-0.0304401647,
0.0395616665,
-0.0372515954,
0.0238593891,
0.0356972031,
0.0243659914,
-0.0280072391,
-0.1538104117,
-0.0097402325,
0.0332264453,
-0.0360286087,
-0.0116648553,
-0.0563148409,
-0.0186495241,
0.0449582115,
-0.0908482373,
0.0175153986,
2.221254763e-34,
0.004216603,
0.0080248797,
-0.0150296316,
0.0569063723,
-0.0015342842,
-0.0207039546,
0.0108362157,
0.0087641235,
0.0302468855,
-0.0674121752,
-0.0504990928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13484v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13484v3 | Flover: A Temporal Fusion Framework for Efficient Autoregressive Model Parallel Inference | 2023-05-22T20:58:09 | 2023-11-03T03:37:20 | Jinghan Yao, Nawras Alnaasan, Tian Chen, Aamir Shafi, Hari Subramoni, Dhabaleswar K., Panda | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Autoregressive models, despite their commendable performance in a myriad of
generative tasks, face challenges stemming from their inherently sequential
structure. Inference on these models, by design, harnesses a temporal
dependency, where the current token's probability distribution is conditioned
on preceding tokens. This inherent characteristic severely impedes
computational efficiency during inference as a typical inference request can
require more than thousands of tokens, where generating each token requires a
load of entire model weights, making the inference more memory-bound. The large
overhead becomes profound in real deployment where requests arrive randomly,
necessitating various generation lengths. Existing solutions, such as dynamic
batching and concurrent instances, introduce significant response delays and
bandwidth contention, falling short of achieving optimal latency and
throughput. To address these shortcomings, we propose Flover -- a temporal
fusion framework for efficiently inferring multiple requests in parallel. We
deconstruct the general generation pipeline into pre-processing and token
generation, and equip the framework with a dedicated work scheduler for fusing
the generation process temporally across all requests. By orchestrating the
token-level parallelism, Flover exhibits optimal hardware efficiency and
significantly spares the system resources. By further employing a fast buffer
reordering algorithm that allows memory eviction of finished tasks, it brings
over 11x inference speedup on GPT and 16x on LLAMA compared to the cutting-edge
solutions provided by NVIDIA FasterTransformer. Crucially, by leveraging the
advanced tensor parallel technique, Flover proves efficacious across diverse
computational landscapes, from single-GPU setups to distributed scenarios,
thereby offering robust performance optimization that adapts to variable use
cases. | [
0.004104455,
0.0923348591,
-0.0073908982,
0.0220410246,
-0.041336067,
0.0083997454,
0.0570730381,
-0.0465958975,
-0.0229567308,
0.0019579136,
0.0413712263,
-0.0245971307,
0.0164144691,
0.0502816066,
-0.0037974101,
-0.0392357968,
0.0198277477,
-0.0290417522,
0.0014317916,
-0.0507362932,
-0.0237969849,
0.0051043066,
-0.0058434233,
0.0193825942,
-0.0394373834,
-0.0287608113,
-0.0291722622,
0.0227499884,
0.0292750224,
0.0198371615,
-0.0001094891,
0.0417349935,
0.0278156865,
0.0528471842,
0.0000022453,
0.005683477,
-0.0327859595,
0.0163468048,
0.0056022815,
0.0301901363,
0.0127644073,
0.0087259514,
-0.0074665355,
0.017253045,
-0.0019226047,
-0.003947705,
0.0595326014,
-0.0025890924,
0.012881943,
-0.0064133303,
-0.0049942662,
0.0283378456,
0.0351924784,
-0.0599633008,
-0.0098469779,
-0.0653384179,
-0.0196449533,
-0.0427965559,
-0.0066354978,
-0.0608207248,
0.0030823853,
0.0513101853,
0.0597877577,
0.002723346,
0.0288289655,
0.0425583944,
-0.0011380455,
-0.025982311,
-0.0611039549,
0.0058515361,
-0.0412178114,
-0.0190630984,
0.0315616988,
-0.0040278751,
-0.0720270649,
0.023994118,
-0.033550933,
0.0254108813,
-0.0207937658,
0.0119458074,
0.0221392568,
0.0122111579,
0.0159874801,
0.0034909945,
-0.0519605242,
0.0395440757,
0.0394603983,
0.0608109199,
-0.0927793458,
0.009718053,
0.0036040097,
-0.0720221102,
0.0163854752,
0.0075495713,
-0.0471326038,
-0.0413371548,
-0.0470246114,
-0.050892435,
-0.0154111385,
0.0128523838,
0.067578204,
0.0327866003,
-0.0198165867,
0.0408326946,
-0.0427827798,
0.01238376,
-0.0686965808,
-0.068419151,
-0.021990234,
-0.0096905166,
0.0110054305,
-0.0312921889,
-0.0170419309,
0.0082046315,
-0.0587529838,
-0.0322506987,
-0.0612244159,
0.04262444,
-0.044380419,
-0.0349577144,
0.0015030267,
0.0442731269,
-0.0558418445,
0.0057024257,
-0.0137039823,
0.0045408811,
-0.0311106574,
0.0038766691,
0.0203519203,
-0.0711960867,
-0.0165746491,
0.0049909083,
0.000929068,
-0.0143517759,
0.014577969,
0.050884787,
-0.0041953991,
0.0014934401,
-0.0278156996,
-0.0422154106,
0.0403911322,
-0.0592210367,
0.0158282481,
-0.0423920751,
0.0340755209,
0.0167911258,
0.0235024039,
0.0589205921,
0.0005686501,
-0.007050111,
-0.0145384008,
0.049842909,
0.0220257398,
-0.0039567212,
0.0140178734,
-0.0191914029,
0.0112985475,
0.0533291623,
-0.0046821032,
0.0718772784,
-0.0019852316,
0.0244976152,
0.0211026073,
0.0151397632,
0.0259502847,
0.0070905071,
-0.05493173,
-0.0050423965,
-0.0103863673,
0.0060146595,
0.0531235859,
0.0074176653,
-0.01562782,
-0.0007792068,
0.0363909788,
0.0219271034,
-0.0214366242,
-0.0020956395,
0.073968336,
-0.0282404516,
-0.0238811113,
-0.0171506442,
-0.0562086627,
0.0768976212,
0.0011435666,
0.0123190926,
0.077374354,
0.100272797,
-0.0267893933,
-0.0164372642,
0.0192576256,
-0.0145993968,
-0.0534818321,
0.0002351973,
0.0634542257,
-0.0123897931,
-0.0474543273,
0.0080877673,
0.0272939485,
-0.0249178838,
-0.0601964667,
-0.0708251595,
0.0253599454,
0.0522706844,
0.0607560538,
0.0071204556,
-0.0366277099,
0.0437884331,
-0.0291270763,
0.0230149925,
0.0133238453,
0.0072482191,
0.0416863076,
-0.0099431863,
-0.0460502543,
0.0250038467,
0.0093002208,
0.0572982691,
0.0389142185,
0.0123583442,
0.014047496,
0.0096984077,
-0.0089408988,
-0.0130807264,
-0.0306526683,
-0.026835354,
0.0657166466,
0.0082447864,
0.0451841578,
-0.0188120939,
-0.0118195182,
0.0059351414,
0.0291886125,
-0.0238526948,
-0.0019157719,
0.0521954931,
-0.0411327593,
-0.0049154428,
0.0007965898,
0.0201314706,
0.0018982043,
0.0055504707,
-0.0648765564,
-0.067073144,
0.0791332796,
-0.0093685267,
0.0630955249,
-0.0187129509,
-0.0091707688,
0.0397042744,
0.0146347424,
0.0482183397,
0.012908482,
-0.0186710991,
-0.0403853655,
0.0117081469,
0.0190664865,
-0.0059327097,
-0.0159207154,
0.017710343,
-0.0145008229,
-0.0101549355,
-0.0462989584,
0.0353591591,
-0.0457482859,
0.0337400176,
0.0325870179,
-0.0610707439,
0.0386526957,
-0.0145928441,
0.0177288819,
0.0014939731,
0.0263185594,
0.0041267076,
-0.0188804362,
0.0364084132,
0.0238142628,
-0.0097680986,
0.0334491916,
-0.0225607343,
-0.0244502854,
-0.0528230183,
-0.002447739,
-0.0431057252,
0.0045653577,
0.0577653535,
0.0201082397,
-0.0369426645,
0.0288268365,
-0.0597185455,
-0.0145852705,
0.029770758,
-0.0343638249,
-0.0025036794,
0.013811172,
-0.0341828614,
0.0869716927,
0.0531756394,
0.0255074333,
0.0264499467,
-0.038261719,
-0.0370429754,
-0.0188782737,
0.0378373377,
-0.0366569608,
0.0089950776,
0.0201992858,
0.0059730732,
-0.0420787707,
0.0667279586,
-0.0176358148,
-0.0345149487,
-0.0439906493,
-0.011293903,
0.0218920894,
-0.0274166148,
-0.0188138783,
-0.0094530806,
-0.0106458459,
0.0027583747,
-0.0112577667,
-0.0937441662,
0.0506389849,
-0.0284252129,
0.0060755052,
0.0121267028,
-0.0191169381,
-0.0175343435,
0.0454488769,
0.0340154991,
0.0246807281,
-0.058460962,
0.0318918638,
0.0186577253,
0.065283753,
0.0169555154,
-0.0177360773,
-0.0122748688,
0.0002649758,
0.0126961432,
-0.0000924739,
-0.0256468467,
-0.0255381279,
-0.0090895221,
-0.0146372542,
0.0012605076,
-0.0213799737,
-0.0538401641,
-0.0293152388,
0.0037790136,
-0.0256750584,
0.0779834241,
-0.0538520217,
-0.018225221,
-0.0105322003,
0.0157379415,
0.0575664937,
-0.0449528061,
0.0297602434,
-0.0267121997,
-0.0046229982,
0.0415289141,
0.0996587425,
-0.0141764162,
-0.08268442,
-0.0210294873,
0.0289234705,
-0.0119848438,
-0.02461477,
0.0414912142,
0.0086337719,
-0.0521837771,
-0.0049398434,
0.0332832634,
-0.0034967086,
-0.0262246151,
-0.0116931293,
0.0615772642,
0.0464956164,
0.0122542176,
0.0174866989,
-0.0738931373,
-0.0175017491,
0.0475770123,
0.0125713143,
-0.0334288925,
0.0082551278,
0.0132271182,
-0.0776188523,
0.0897369608,
-0.0192263983,
0.0141399968,
-0.001095984,
-0.0667719916,
-0.0028867202,
-0.0018652122,
-0.0259368196,
0.0010441912,
0.0173328742,
0.0326817855,
0.0153214904,
0.0285447426,
-0.0098737329,
-0.0087554427,
-0.0016827028,
0.0244671125,
0.0224552769,
-0.0001662991,
-0.0018399407,
-0.0496961102,
0.0355635025,
0.0095073339,
0.0004383021,
-0.0183690507,
0.0137037886,
0.0110733146,
0.0115432804,
-0.0332323425,
0.0367724113,
-0.0226481892,
-0.0262338836,
-0.0496797003,
0.0816091076,
-0.0219713077,
-0.0195871033,
-0.0660945252,
-0.0373666286,
0.0294189043,
0.0455504432,
0.0090245027,
-0.0118964808,
-0.0724187195,
-0.0241994467,
-0.0141285686,
-0.0664681196,
0.0361075923,
-0.0557443686,
0.0346896164,
-0.0907514766,
-0.0045321472,
0.0518837832,
-0.0395353436,
0.0462586321,
-0.0256674867,
0.0159471594,
-0.0216574408,
-0.0275299773,
-0.0841616616,
0.0202031638,
0.0116999568,
0.0276378356,
-0.0509066358,
-0.0153238289,
0.039575208,
-0.0117195342,
-0.0530243367,
0.0901019424,
-0.1316347569,
-0.078385435,
0.012637781,
0.0481944978,
0.0242086928,
0.0330090597,
0.0150934216,
0.0403881483,
0.086816445,
0.0881541297,
-0.0415789112,
0.0112752048,
0.0174200702,
-0.0157607645,
-0.008480751,
-0.0024240853,
-0.0243814699,
0.0415027626,
-0.0050976314,
-0.0132134864,
0.0311136618,
-0.0272739753,
-0.040058855,
-0.005059001,
0.0478659905,
-0.0328557231,
0.0246144682,
-0.013825017,
0.0134046655,
0.0126743261,
0.0029932349,
-0.0650488138,
0.0246929321,
0.0055521117,
-0.0003502001,
-0.0097579081,
0.0048433118,
0.1033537313,
-0.0101596285,
-0.0206803512,
-0.0570492931,
-0.0034296121,
-0.0157332532,
-0.0010551562,
-0.0284845177,
0.0466839224,
-0.0128495051,
0.0189895816,
0.0422777869,
-0.0283263829,
-0.0133338803,
0.0113280397,
0.029481709,
-0.0172090139,
0.0060319598,
-0.0768810734,
-0.0467776731,
-0.0348589942,
-0.002381112,
0.0416503176,
0.0053129504,
0.0505141579,
-0.046211537,
0.0110649252,
0.0017508981,
0.036972329,
-0.0071517574,
0.0001525306,
0.0085763847,
0.0084705018,
-0.0159584954,
0.0004404125,
0.0527988225,
0.0032465528,
0.0365931578,
-0.0037518525,
-0.0308912322,
-0.0193789657,
-0.0590783134,
-0.0523154251,
-0.0043688454,
0.0072526108,
0.0171976369,
-0.0068572401,
-0.0375893824,
0.028460199,
0.0301681813,
-0.014660663,
-0.017077351,
0.0076626129,
0.0680371672,
-0.0038199099,
-0.0287175309,
-0.0218634773,
0.0506034382,
-0.010459844,
0.0052803908,
0.0102184583,
-7.330719257e-33,
0.0007690934,
-0.0036837938,
0.0210218299,
-0.026913505,
-0.0140563967,
0.0278969835,
-0.0341475904,
-0.0529937372,
0.0524876788,
0.0087980349,
-0.0059740515,
0.0295380633,
0.0233001485,
0.008317275,
0.0376126692,
0.0472400077,
0.0511804149,
-0.0036197747,
-0.0066123628,
0.0707813725,
0.0530873761,
0.0333419926,
-0.0035333449,
-0.0068082456,
-0.0558013543,
-0.0018289904,
0.0182334464,
-0.0019176482,
-0.0176576283,
0.0260406807,
-0.0324434973,
-0.0112714004,
-0.0262880363,
-0.0492244102,
-0.0163077861,
-0.00894948,
-0.086087577,
-0.0220116023,
0.0017260801,
-0.0348200761,
-0.0654259622,
-0.0300226901,
-0.0081266221,
0.0651610196,
-0.0096219014,
-0.0547864847,
0.0025901804,
0.0276498366,
0.0038531905,
-0.0728620812,
-0.0180183947,
0.0171260107,
-0.0022902989,
0.0393359065,
0.0695795342,
0.0331206471,
-0.0017274042,
0.0162856765,
-0.0322849415,
0.0180449355,
0.0166470762,
0.0442760177,
0.0678713471,
0.0537660122,
0.0413712785,
0.0195153821,
0.0091440631,
-0.0219693203,
-0.0454282686,
0.0361564085,
-0.0039010455,
0.0379825272,
-0.0039077182,
-0.014001349,
0.0673020333,
-0.0011859555,
-0.0606363527,
0.0260060206,
0.0444421582,
0.0113424668,
0.0597087033,
-0.0075418181,
0.0208894946,
-0.0059591574,
-0.0052129687,
-0.0505055524,
-0.0179103743,
0.0293214731,
0.0097059915,
0.0836304203,
-0.0216667019,
0.0171747357,
0.0467657112,
-0.015604727,
0.0106470967,
0.0251770187,
0.0053228615,
-0.0188481826,
0.0540979132,
0.0339739136,
-0.0208898038,
-0.0272458848,
-0.017993696,
-0.0163457301,
0.0120153613,
0.0130006149,
0.0059188097,
0.0493258275,
-0.0542437807,
-0.0076836888,
-0.0645891652,
0.0710388795,
0.0027999184,
-0.0034715852,
0.0475220121,
0.0193167459,
-0.0010738067,
0.0122608887,
-0.0247148145,
0.0568016618,
-0.0131198168,
0.0470066667,
-0.012859026,
0.0153336823,
-0.0385608375,
-0.0173997935,
-0.0569327474,
0.0126054576,
0.0154965119,
-0.0907249972,
-0.04277955,
0.0484918952,
3.027e-7,
-0.0264742635,
0.0115786139,
0.0414688848,
0.0231732596,
0.044950325,
0.0043186201,
0.0027567768,
0.0019065565,
0.0372996591,
0.0133367367,
0.0114222318,
0.0265037771,
0.0539363027,
-0.0048007616,
-0.0289403144,
-0.0022924896,
-0.092897743,
0.0375074372,
-0.0569479652,
-0.0610733069,
-0.0461814292,
0.0626802444,
0.0295646191,
-0.037325222,
0.082207486,
-0.0015218717,
0.0287978631,
0.010134453,
0.0163814351,
0.0083743641,
-0.0006460309,
0.0164099783,
-0.0163453538,
0.0155597785,
-0.0289177541,
0.0023343198,
-0.0663398579,
0.0428589061,
0.0124206133,
-0.0377873369,
0.0317252129,
-0.0187509153,
0.0089967567,
-0.0401012674,
0.073091045,
0.008418587,
0.0040039229,
-0.0668769628,
-0.0312727243,
0.0067082359,
0.0075788694,
0.0403667353,
0.0333353691,
0.028964499,
0.0091675352,
-0.0311521515,
-0.0060868445,
-0.0718315318,
-0.0211788081,
-0.0104121212,
-0.0952634588,
-0.0204951148,
-0.0823975876,
0.0003382461,
0.0303703118,
-0.0263151806,
-0.0405968688,
3.259828358e-34,
0.0411681794,
0.0108486526,
-0.0231077988,
0.02884195,
0.0127558568,
-0.0336827524,
-0.0387059115,
0.0235381443,
0.0060207965,
-0.0651811585,
-0.065077208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13478v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13478v2 | Automatic Readability Assessment for Closely Related Languages | 2023-05-22T20:42:53 | 2023-05-25T10:41:50 | Joseph Marvin Imperial, Ekaterina Kochmar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the main focus of research on automatic readability
assessment (ARA) has shifted towards using expensive deep learning-based
methods with the primary goal of increasing models' accuracy. This, however, is
rarely applicable for low-resource languages where traditional handcrafted
features are still widely used due to the lack of existing NLP tools to extract
deeper linguistic representations. In this work, we take a step back from the
technical component and focus on how linguistic aspects such as mutual
intelligibility or degree of language relatedness can improve ARA in a
low-resource setting. We collect short stories written in three languages in
the Philippines-Tagalog, Bikol, and Cebuano-to train readability assessment
models and explore the interaction of data and features in various
cross-lingual setups. Our results show that the inclusion of CrossNGO, a novel
specialized feature exploiting n-gram overlap applied to languages with high
mutual intelligibility, significantly improves the performance of ARA models
compared to the use of off-the-shelf large multilingual language models alone.
Consequently, when both linguistic representations are combined, we achieve
state-of-the-art results for Tagalog and Cebuano, and baseline scores for ARA
in Bikol. | [
0.0084119197,
0.0042033386,
-0.0268436484,
0.0590581708,
-0.0488075018,
0.0412073992,
0.041148752,
-0.0393918119,
0.0614096001,
-0.0181088522,
-0.0606805682,
-0.0065006725,
0.0562560856,
0.0412206948,
0.0086763371,
-0.0280507207,
0.0040455288,
-0.0172531437,
0.0398105159,
0.0009396312,
0.0258718841,
0.0306444522,
-0.0130844535,
0.051855918,
0.0196776595,
-0.0544588231,
0.0182367917,
0.0037077479,
0.0144538283,
0.0118193813,
-0.0213973727,
0.0219515506,
-0.0540014803,
0.0435740463,
0.0000019542,
-0.0166244432,
-0.0481918752,
-0.0149569325,
0.0320191793,
0.0446143374,
0.0770309493,
-0.0319583304,
-0.0158336181,
-0.0219835583,
0.0033138399,
-0.0325895138,
0.0411288664,
0.0670242235,
0.024842402,
0.0446197875,
-0.0228212699,
-0.0325768515,
0.0235732142,
0.0164350774,
0.0255084373,
-0.0068917195,
-0.0086460784,
0.0238952525,
-0.0100335609,
-0.0030704795,
-0.0235499348,
0.0470460691,
0.0097631719,
-0.0279082339,
-0.0185496155,
-0.0067953551,
0.0010921742,
-0.0247578397,
-0.0044930731,
0.0716685578,
-0.0425212681,
-0.0619148016,
-0.0152585097,
-0.0161783155,
-0.008696232,
0.0165500902,
-0.0215979256,
-0.0467398614,
-0.0243523624,
0.0210606698,
0.0626204088,
0.0178080462,
0.0527043752,
0.0010024486,
0.0281990506,
0.0525991954,
0.0168484244,
-0.0019907521,
0.008762408,
0.0421414971,
0.0034818167,
0.0306128822,
0.0711644664,
-0.0244634077,
0.010487441,
-0.0016883226,
-0.0126867127,
-0.0500794686,
0.018163627,
-0.0106406808,
0.0167954825,
0.0238014441,
-0.064406693,
0.0358967558,
-0.0568798296,
0.0386700332,
0.0175561756,
0.0028417157,
-0.0302505698,
-0.0100265332,
-0.0080559952,
0.008730839,
-0.0157547835,
0.0200639013,
-0.0470250808,
-0.0087072346,
-0.036184676,
-0.0315125473,
0.011313579,
-0.0248618536,
0.0088932421,
-0.0032041462,
-0.0497108139,
0.0033167405,
0.042911645,
0.0470238067,
-0.0429856479,
0.033106368,
-0.0019970618,
-0.0435987413,
0.0489187688,
0.0261085797,
-0.0061943778,
-0.0136403488,
0.0000359458,
0.0296935793,
-0.0181779005,
-0.0198924206,
-0.0621436536,
-0.0164127164,
-0.0279624313,
-0.0378534868,
-0.0123549215,
-0.0682641789,
0.0287425574,
-0.0273761768,
0.0640337914,
-0.0404427573,
-0.0418600067,
0.0000917968,
0.0084191291,
0.0512553044,
0.0171960853,
-0.0178303719,
0.0328698941,
0.0302989334,
0.0194477495,
0.0427998081,
0.0788066909,
-0.0018880804,
0.0666816235,
-0.0094136763,
-0.0498754419,
0.0018742791,
-0.0272645019,
0.0118412981,
0.0563517474,
-0.0478104353,
-0.0409867056,
0.0129397288,
0.0111656208,
0.0352773406,
-0.0026129906,
-0.0258446671,
0.0740744248,
0.0438472554,
0.0704360381,
0.0623379983,
0.0737964138,
0.0293878261,
-0.0046523251,
0.0687008426,
0.0220916625,
-0.012453814,
-0.0233672988,
0.036934413,
0.0431947559,
0.0346306302,
-0.0167738125,
-0.0761364177,
0.0352900736,
-0.0057200575,
0.0363920443,
-0.0161457546,
0.026944384,
0.0036959099,
-0.0430779792,
-0.0306182727,
0.0289153028,
-0.0867645964,
0.0333100483,
0.0197110474,
0.0536036156,
0.0525947921,
0.0257244948,
0.0025173954,
0.0198851004,
0.0300451647,
-0.0079404488,
0.0027110332,
0.0061327643,
-0.0016706327,
0.0620438345,
-0.053231068,
0.0243871715,
0.010930975,
0.0108115254,
0.0349701494,
-0.0412668996,
0.0535833277,
0.0244866926,
-0.0469934344,
-0.0799522921,
0.0217733942,
-0.0602862127,
-0.0148674045,
0.0280212387,
0.0255646408,
0.0053079263,
0.0659501702,
-0.0034473606,
-0.0150917545,
0.0000757877,
-0.049906902,
0.0246717557,
0.0319139697,
-0.0324263126,
-0.0370788872,
-0.0209810063,
-0.0960779861,
0.0124306399,
0.0255603176,
0.0024044004,
-0.0382733904,
-0.0069642398,
-0.0285154954,
-0.0087234369,
-0.0470683761,
0.0247002859,
-0.0388153382,
-0.0032137465,
-0.0460111201,
-0.0018035718,
0.026572926,
0.0301340651,
-0.0331269503,
-0.0374008827,
0.0303743538,
-0.0186789855,
-0.0383908823,
0.0203198213,
-0.0025058156,
0.0230535921,
-0.0069881761,
0.0571172871,
-0.0478810072,
-0.041511517,
-0.1355053633,
-0.0106197912,
-0.0150907589,
0.0039103492,
-0.0025041732,
-0.0081169615,
-0.0096788667,
0.0213950053,
0.005584409,
0.012536753,
-0.0185589381,
0.0104664303,
-0.0058902819,
0.0226413999,
0.0362995565,
-0.0516252704,
-0.0407724828,
0.0093933912,
0.0635208338,
0.0769417956,
-0.0161774457,
-0.05921584,
0.0128760561,
-0.0053818091,
-0.0539120436,
0.034098193,
-0.0378467627,
-0.0091473628,
0.0103643844,
0.0049272855,
0.0675933063,
-0.048813425,
0.0142545411,
0.048590485,
-0.0290415753,
-0.0273986291,
-0.0075882706,
0.0064651268,
0.027083043,
-0.0138521567,
-0.0539835803,
-0.0351384953,
0.0519488677,
-0.0060020084,
-0.0259364247,
-0.0398038328,
-0.00827788,
-0.0578603446,
-0.0702989474,
-0.0251561906,
0.0136559969,
0.0336443745,
0.045414608,
-0.0359403454,
-0.027361786,
0.101279065,
-0.0731516406,
-0.0212529339,
-0.0906960741,
0.0059210132,
-0.0640193745,
0.0436928757,
-0.023534283,
0.0332612954,
-0.0241104476,
-0.0680103526,
-0.0180084333,
0.0327805728,
0.0119780628,
-0.0034521914,
0.0582861938,
-0.0447122492,
-0.0296931714,
0.0293807611,
-0.0216956288,
0.0092993136,
-0.0028586043,
-0.0140327383,
-0.043879386,
0.0277814623,
-0.0106237223,
-0.019112397,
-0.0163653996,
0.0202418268,
0.0181995928,
-0.01324433,
-0.0054837484,
-0.0040875664,
0.0599243306,
0.0201428421,
-0.0160063133,
-0.0002649287,
-0.0324162878,
0.0057489914,
0.013744168,
-0.0116968565,
-0.0014107611,
0.007553061,
0.0349119045,
0.0100186504,
-0.0058895657,
-0.0219391435,
-0.0570019409,
0.0385452658,
-0.0873103216,
-0.0033074964,
0.073687084,
0.0080324691,
-0.0398914069,
-0.0002113842,
-0.0380151793,
0.0372519493,
-0.0375253968,
0.0180240963,
-0.0172817893,
-0.0255887508,
0.0287545994,
-0.0032950947,
-0.0184174571,
0.0011328264,
-0.0058956863,
-0.0744122863,
0.0094725499,
0.0256152526,
-0.0106460853,
-0.0702533051,
-0.0103007574,
-0.0320318379,
-0.0123763382,
0.0327519998,
-0.0101153553,
-0.0070625884,
-0.0187738314,
-0.0109084146,
-0.0161569882,
-0.0201764591,
-0.0170353446,
0.0052168937,
-0.0051426999,
0.0403401665,
0.0241358001,
-0.0200570393,
-0.0196379703,
-0.005314311,
-0.0210212041,
-0.0023477487,
-0.0404207334,
0.0269562416,
0.0056910459,
-0.0271759238,
-0.0241505299,
0.0269541834,
-0.0049088607,
0.0156353042,
0.0097897407,
0.0160128493,
0.0207337439,
-0.042120859,
0.0082273083,
0.0347968116,
0.0325726308,
0.0481090322,
0.0586075597,
-0.055421561,
-0.0248418935,
-0.0557678975,
-0.0100419102,
-0.0695070326,
-0.0612183474,
0.0365385972,
0.0003547264,
-0.0700415224,
-0.0790341571,
-0.1044536754,
-0.0098746354,
-0.0203180294,
0.0513540171,
0.0247606561,
-0.0006554439,
-0.0197587553,
-0.0397915095,
0.0155891692,
-0.0114743263,
0.023700241,
-0.0437327102,
0.0452228524,
0.0012920006,
-0.0243629832,
-0.0277761519,
0.0092629585,
-0.0633158013,
-0.0386657827,
0.0076699508,
-0.0187921599,
0.011509262,
0.0002505003,
-0.0086137922,
-0.0727034435,
0.0294440892,
0.0044447058,
-0.0549992211,
0.0204424094,
0.0408850498,
-0.037201263,
0.0129450914,
0.0320492424,
-0.0030761675,
-0.005505152,
-0.0155580239,
0.0048217215,
-0.007418015,
-0.0491022095,
-0.0364481919,
-0.0091624809,
0.0228926279,
-0.011175801,
0.0032918632,
-0.0759097561,
0.0187588688,
0.0118687199,
0.0381504968,
-0.04649188,
-0.0033987677,
0.0465341993,
-0.0196699351,
-0.0233216435,
0.0558586419,
0.0139177088,
0.0009424359,
-0.0095386049,
0.0609622151,
-0.0156782046,
0.0468000621,
-0.0338956751,
0.0262685437,
-0.0467294902,
0.0232229903,
-0.0425485633,
0.040944811,
0.0309328604,
0.0155043621,
0.0032842695,
-0.0068567609,
0.0141814938,
0.0387257263,
0.0246441234,
0.0211350098,
-0.0010443549,
0.0045801271,
0.0623981021,
-0.0474850647,
0.0918063521,
-0.0168718211,
0.0254613888,
-0.0739287212,
0.0498083718,
0.0115140351,
-0.014258788,
-0.030272536,
-0.0227528457,
0.0244654156,
0.010664992,
0.1124957502,
0.0194602702,
-0.0101167392,
0.0437230282,
0.0064370893,
-0.0138824545,
-0.032195311,
0.0119536519,
0.0395156927,
-0.0390126035,
-0.0239668824,
-0.0342245139,
-0.0622076131,
0.0225226674,
0.0193086863,
-0.0007861187,
0.0184595119,
-0.039517045,
0.0544436835,
-0.0357749686,
0.0444236957,
-0.0638837218,
-0.0071553341,
-0.022973448,
-0.0160254072,
0.019052038,
-5.682060512e-33,
-0.0194072966,
-0.038014695,
-0.0351117291,
-0.0034182118,
-0.0077970983,
0.0172531735,
-0.0644932687,
0.0178540237,
0.0059169158,
0.0635701567,
0.0200198498,
0.0040213787,
0.0220321417,
-0.003573179,
-0.0045003099,
-0.000826121,
0.0502307229,
0.0441695824,
0.0163804013,
0.0410264358,
0.0186567064,
0.0405204669,
0.0376796536,
-0.0985237584,
0.0802645385,
-0.0297495928,
0.0050370363,
-0.0326451026,
0.0334654599,
0.0660445839,
0.0036842506,
0.0449961051,
0.0279352777,
0.0107227499,
-0.0202939138,
0.0379776992,
-0.0745900795,
-0.0281961877,
0.0335716754,
0.0305644665,
-0.0399668217,
-0.0578940734,
0.0463938899,
0.0120162424,
0.0427377224,
-0.0635521263,
0.0479968637,
-0.036062818,
0.0075441925,
0.0015208835,
-0.0587818883,
0.0305672772,
-0.0373305567,
-0.001121707,
0.0815805271,
0.0725269616,
-0.0010941722,
0.02530591,
-0.0561002642,
0.0189479683,
-0.0199431684,
0.0448928922,
0.0580417514,
-0.0401827656,
-0.0464748479,
0.0575944521,
0.0007544134,
-0.0357439667,
0.0221659336,
0.0251433011,
0.0885435045,
-0.0021006435,
0.0338264257,
0.0657938495,
0.0129154241,
-0.021068776,
-0.0490104966,
0.056691844,
0.0049555884,
-0.00597212,
0.0251605026,
-0.0090380684,
-0.0671592504,
0.0021992999,
-0.0290889945,
-0.0278995633,
-0.0586914346,
-0.0534780994,
0.0258929748,
-0.0425826125,
-0.028522158,
0.0405493006,
0.0345575213,
-0.0398648456,
-0.004719195,
0.0433274247,
-0.035173621,
0.0314898938,
-0.0328007452,
0.0484816283,
-0.0104039321,
-0.0192540921,
-0.0457123816,
0.0258731917,
0.0314794704,
-0.0392624326,
0.0714911669,
-0.0082824007,
-0.0395483971,
0.0134761278,
0.0002020343,
-0.0126470001,
0.001280854,
0.0872916952,
-0.0071442598,
-0.0034321817,
-0.0237603541,
0.0347684249,
0.0167787187,
0.0204628501,
-0.0212779213,
-0.0418096334,
-0.012643856,
0.0076029133,
-0.0551850423,
-0.040817067,
0.0052874731,
-0.0231893864,
0.0164556671,
-0.0098051718,
0.0091858618,
-0.0008246299,
2.512e-7,
-0.0092105316,
0.015654942,
0.0325629748,
-0.0175878871,
-0.013310316,
0.0507670753,
-0.0039035615,
0.0384410769,
-0.000805654,
-0.0082493806,
0.0243871119,
0.0012818467,
0.1057762653,
0.01423427,
-0.1044348776,
0.0095742382,
0.0148171103,
0.0285992511,
-0.0308040399,
-0.0206791479,
0.0334576182,
0.0431229137,
-0.0052876296,
-0.0128961392,
0.0491877533,
-0.0554844327,
0.027150739,
-0.0433170199,
-0.0341431573,
0.036807593,
0.0881304517,
0.0400797501,
0.0105868764,
-0.0060243038,
-0.0233891979,
-0.0052291164,
0.04033022,
0.0424398445,
0.0199633334,
-0.0263137482,
0.0260179918,
0.0055789971,
-0.0345100239,
-0.0497518517,
0.0344603956,
0.0303160045,
-0.0204267409,
0.0290424433,
0.013470999,
-0.024535371,
0.0190288741,
-0.017244786,
-0.0512255169,
0.0167752597,
0.0396308526,
-0.085224092,
-0.0001107227,
-0.0048586982,
-0.0416816883,
0.031559594,
0.0074124811,
0.0109845269,
-0.011266022,
-0.0127249276,
0.0073608267,
-0.0797553584,
0.0244826544,
1.977456545e-34,
0.0396161936,
-0.0005371404,
0.0235182829,
0.0036355506,
0.0163141415,
-0.0058322158,
-0.0079229428,
-0.0351005681,
-0.0192509238,
-0.0417760387,
0.007103689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13477v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13477v2 | Look-back Decoding for Open-Ended Text Generation | 2023-05-22T20:42:37 | 2023-10-23T00:58:02 | Nan Xu, Chunting Zhou, Asli Celikyilmaz, Xuezhe Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a prefix (context), open-ended generation aims to decode texts that are
coherent, which do not abruptly drift from previous topics, and informative,
which do not suffer from undesired repetitions. In this paper, we propose
Look-back, an improved decoding algorithm that leverages the Kullback-Leibler
divergence to track the distribution distance between current and historical
decoding steps. Thus Look-back can automatically predict potential repetitive
phrase and topic drift, and remove tokens that may cause the failure modes,
restricting the next token probability distribution within a plausible distance
to the history. We perform decoding experiments on document continuation and
story generation, and demonstrate that Look-back is able to generate more
fluent and coherent text, outperforming other strong decoding methods
significantly in both automatic and human evaluations. | [
0.0057191658,
0.0511765927,
0.01508079,
-0.0268605221,
-0.0349409655,
0.001923713,
-0.037744727,
-0.0004101987,
-0.0782376453,
-0.0279120915,
0.0470220149,
-0.008776227,
0.0426310934,
0.061811246,
0.0122967158,
-0.0577466041,
0.0163622946,
-0.0149529185,
0.0073023443,
0.0104751596,
0.0060288804,
0.0129926316,
-0.0220020767,
0.039358072,
-0.0018713818,
-0.0234570745,
-0.0527231172,
0.0132034235,
0.0424195603,
-0.041648414,
-0.0033869266,
0.0184652228,
-0.0034847863,
0.0147723742,
0.0000017789,
-0.0423366874,
-0.0402360074,
-0.0112565253,
0.0169943571,
-0.0135757988,
0.0455197468,
-0.0332119726,
-0.0118902763,
0.0189586151,
-0.0017770409,
-0.0014598233,
0.0058005857,
0.066506587,
0.0573807992,
0.0718588829,
-0.0126097174,
-0.0359015092,
0.0355184563,
0.0065238955,
0.0421002135,
-0.00864763,
-0.0267134048,
-0.0115975123,
0.0054207845,
-0.0023015768,
0.0032670398,
0.0271280315,
0.0211034212,
-0.0272310302,
0.0129640568,
0.0735344291,
-0.0161042027,
0.0078079943,
-0.0101287793,
0.0527217388,
0.0305206981,
-0.0412319489,
0.0283183698,
-0.0360762142,
-0.0204470865,
-0.0176696107,
-0.0438715294,
0.0434683003,
-0.0394240692,
0.0106045632,
0.0729802027,
0.0103312451,
0.0007901107,
0.0061935401,
-0.0224104766,
0.0286406092,
0.0420339443,
-0.0131981187,
-0.0289873704,
0.0451774932,
0.0443780534,
-0.0494443737,
0.0662704185,
0.0445974022,
0.005257498,
0.0174069311,
-0.0701820329,
-0.0740805492,
0.0042737573,
-0.0237648468,
0.0137971137,
0.0267848819,
-0.0472069308,
0.0111262165,
-0.0135062039,
0.033601217,
0.011793891,
-0.0749480128,
-0.0205596834,
0.034778662,
-0.0413004868,
-0.0073216166,
-0.0625166222,
0.027046835,
-0.0322952494,
-0.0512735061,
-0.0087752156,
0.0481266007,
0.0604000315,
-0.0139097339,
-0.0232320391,
0.0169997755,
-0.0349949598,
-0.0149419978,
0.0342337675,
0.0201882347,
-0.0441014208,
-0.0159050412,
0.0463857874,
-0.0099097295,
-0.015453889,
0.0324544869,
0.0237779357,
0.0004407492,
-0.0613429658,
-0.0045666881,
-0.0428702086,
0.0054320558,
-0.0627084002,
-0.0450335108,
-0.0120540084,
-0.0172186214,
-0.0079549905,
-0.0610215403,
0.011289225,
0.0086365575,
-0.0092428578,
-0.0229803436,
0.0011668196,
0.005603455,
-0.0129496371,
0.0122505734,
-0.0421757177,
-0.0150094861,
0.0749352872,
0.0092323143,
0.0107746609,
0.0519980714,
0.0312807634,
0.0321944989,
0.0270478223,
0.0474106707,
0.0070701707,
0.0068518422,
0.0145799769,
0.0067819133,
-0.0099539934,
-0.0225333627,
-0.0309389792,
0.0558604561,
0.0512097962,
0.0336809047,
-0.0689315796,
0.0467357337,
0.0486715138,
0.0058836169,
0.0444583483,
0.0102889091,
0.0670167208,
0.0101326574,
-0.0361708179,
0.0776896104,
0.0143464599,
0.0059860051,
0.0166568421,
0.027584793,
0.0486204252,
-0.0156718362,
-0.0177692883,
-0.0179524943,
0.0247674417,
-0.0197056551,
-0.0120341033,
-0.0873747915,
0.0167414658,
0.041268833,
-0.0770122036,
0.0220253747,
-0.0116828019,
-0.0563921072,
0.0508568175,
-0.0023459939,
0.0541732498,
0.097094588,
0.0798428357,
0.0330671556,
-0.0245952606,
-0.0231911484,
0.0280246455,
0.0538894311,
0.0138424989,
-0.0141517492,
0.0151114045,
-0.0612522922,
-0.0266140588,
0.0151408957,
0.0139356237,
0.0206806008,
-0.0201183241,
0.0547004081,
0.0389094129,
-0.0200488903,
0.0175993014,
0.0414342508,
-0.0372083448,
-0.0037774122,
0.012414501,
-0.0009587154,
-0.0145196486,
0.0180837568,
-0.0095866909,
0.035976477,
0.0124253398,
-0.035651017,
-0.0316056535,
0.0355518498,
-0.0597279891,
-0.0531689748,
-0.0195140298,
-0.0444186516,
0.0180897247,
-0.0193598177,
0.0151046105,
-0.0736131594,
0.0276127122,
-0.0457841605,
0.0501427837,
-0.0338229798,
0.0174786393,
0.0326635651,
-0.0068382248,
-0.0208672658,
0.0402870774,
-0.0047076973,
-0.0079366136,
0.0116166389,
-0.0089164255,
0.0150495293,
-0.0410135873,
0.0240964517,
0.0265849866,
-0.0156044727,
-0.0142600453,
0.0551223643,
0.0156880617,
-0.031701345,
-0.0482132956,
-0.0776047409,
0.0067067752,
-0.0409978889,
0.0126941288,
0.0529277697,
-0.0003475576,
-0.0194711462,
0.0088830562,
-0.0203975309,
0.0109264087,
0.0230983291,
-0.0027397457,
0.0422890112,
0.0265486091,
0.0004941731,
-0.0071011493,
0.0085457647,
0.027430715,
0.0629240945,
0.0524794273,
0.003297345,
-0.0965300575,
0.0377874337,
-0.0204053558,
-0.0458986908,
-0.0151708452,
-0.000418205,
0.0375043601,
-0.0027727056,
0.1077191457,
0.0178794097,
0.0633111969,
0.0419877581,
0.0167771857,
-0.0194899645,
-0.0442866273,
-0.0221286416,
-0.0277635492,
0.0229856055,
-0.0020663117,
-0.0416758247,
0.0525627695,
0.0329487845,
0.0462562665,
0.036857713,
-0.05523948,
-0.0243787561,
-0.0151954126,
-0.0477821492,
-0.0095170997,
-0.0134439003,
-0.0338544473,
0.031662263,
-0.0011503561,
-0.0320031904,
0.0439059101,
-0.0120175956,
0.0205972046,
-0.0239821766,
0.0183547288,
-0.0121261263,
0.0472879224,
-0.0366336666,
0.015180381,
0.0190919992,
-0.055528637,
-0.0189572629,
0.0389223583,
0.0106182732,
-0.0194604527,
0.0271705408,
-0.0582230873,
-0.0103597315,
0.0011545245,
-0.0078058057,
-0.0539761037,
-0.036445044,
0.0257168822,
-0.0218975097,
0.0236614272,
-0.0070891092,
-0.0261798427,
0.0021454098,
0.0072131497,
0.0606138371,
-0.0390713215,
-0.0192442127,
-0.0164726358,
0.0836393237,
0.0679529607,
-0.0224413723,
0.0046865437,
-0.0687712803,
0.0217704456,
0.0496710911,
0.0102908239,
0.0212349817,
-0.0189508926,
0.0016812686,
0.0044247187,
-0.0317304693,
-0.0557518788,
0.0181809366,
0.0345042236,
-0.0407350995,
-0.0363354422,
0.0959009603,
0.0080439234,
-0.0578684472,
-0.0139237894,
-0.0238558445,
0.0711966977,
-0.0422442108,
-0.0074068019,
-0.0806825459,
-0.0104628177,
0.0142457141,
0.06657397,
-0.0045708995,
-0.0385315754,
-0.0217402838,
-0.0590617694,
0.0468436554,
0.038701646,
-0.0666716769,
-0.0299323164,
-0.0304460805,
-0.0561713912,
0.0336532705,
-0.0051773684,
0.0479943901,
-0.0024846334,
0.0335899815,
-0.0009439165,
-0.0404630676,
-0.0522763543,
-0.0536441579,
-0.0323444195,
0.036097303,
0.0827242211,
0.0237876195,
0.0387036838,
0.028095575,
-0.0016229904,
-0.055497393,
-0.0063451855,
-0.0171226542,
0.0417966954,
-0.0276504569,
0.0250793491,
-0.0254714414,
0.0215502474,
-0.0269080494,
-0.0125192078,
0.048591096,
0.0202767719,
-0.0426099114,
-0.0549344905,
-0.0183176044,
0.0152412979,
0.0413246974,
0.0679811612,
0.0312642604,
-0.0426594466,
-0.0547588132,
-0.0358903483,
0.0644500479,
-0.0924528539,
0.0618040785,
-0.0132233314,
-0.0129263196,
-0.0422719717,
-0.1393122971,
-0.0474322364,
-0.0068390905,
0.028770173,
0.0149870235,
0.0298797861,
-0.0218176618,
-0.048728805,
-0.065766193,
-0.0326744504,
0.0138684819,
-0.007687469,
-0.0729308501,
-0.0056626797,
0.0044382489,
-0.0549829006,
0.0100740176,
0.0529727526,
-0.0790147409,
-0.0558114275,
0.0192849915,
-0.0179169308,
0.0159933735,
0.0673273727,
0.0184016321,
-0.0376901999,
0.0348442905,
0.0268211905,
-0.0326114744,
0.0444237888,
0.0128287496,
0.0500118285,
-0.0137464935,
0.006675269,
-0.0450850427,
-0.0388615057,
-0.0248562917,
0.0448589288,
0.0111775938,
-0.0167390518,
0.0059567816,
-0.0045331921,
-0.0094541833,
-0.0591761023,
-0.0096203005,
-0.0374850594,
-0.0097570224,
-0.0248875562,
0.0183557291,
-0.0447058566,
0.0548982061,
0.0485484265,
-0.012808403,
0.0029260137,
0.0438275374,
-0.0333749503,
0.0236406457,
-0.0444864742,
-0.0021782832,
-0.0025075502,
0.0709570944,
0.0363078564,
-0.0095349969,
-0.0342196524,
-0.0091608567,
-0.036383871,
0.0331871174,
-0.037005268,
0.0482288301,
0.0381066464,
-0.002688386,
0.0411243476,
0.0320678428,
-0.0762255788,
0.0309387892,
-0.0034221173,
0.0077574751,
0.0413539559,
0.0329208449,
0.1020323038,
-0.0436034054,
0.0214592312,
-0.0194544122,
0.0550214238,
0.0058687758,
-0.0291286353,
-0.052036155,
0.0227359831,
-0.0041327029,
0.0197344143,
0.0677993372,
0.0128153143,
0.0021031024,
-0.0114961648,
0.0277609471,
-0.0375329666,
-0.0042030509,
0.0067900838,
0.0333146714,
0.0029403809,
-0.0207420681,
-0.019965779,
-0.0012647806,
0.0472053252,
0.0107046198,
0.0214218237,
0.0003571377,
0.0486777388,
0.039398808,
-0.0476110876,
0.0100463824,
-0.055275321,
0.0290786289,
-0.0278905481,
-0.0269254725,
-0.046573773,
-5.648313539e-33,
-0.0349611044,
-0.0322434455,
0.0214134976,
-0.0361203142,
-0.0660406724,
-0.0029061544,
-0.0843874514,
-0.0143995099,
0.0773795769,
0.0264361221,
0.0093037281,
-0.0029586318,
0.0201462768,
0.0193711892,
-0.0226906091,
0.0210296493,
0.0505734757,
0.0049383887,
-0.0595728047,
0.0644764006,
0.057350371,
0.0520339794,
-0.00981458,
-0.0109934323,
0.0125740077,
-0.0518972725,
-0.0078956531,
-0.0405279808,
0.0752840787,
0.0200192742,
-0.0116118742,
-0.0055127172,
0.0181912687,
-0.0061845034,
-0.0650101453,
0.0183020253,
-0.063563861,
-0.0225375928,
-0.0225357004,
-0.0041620652,
-0.0293421987,
-0.0379369594,
0.0128581766,
-0.0247187391,
-0.0063829031,
0.0016290188,
0.0291170031,
-0.0151983965,
-0.0438197181,
-0.0485910438,
-0.0531179123,
0.0457662344,
-0.0226562265,
-0.0141654937,
-0.0199599545,
0.0395228304,
0.0093013206,
-0.011555193,
-0.0164587237,
0.0513277836,
0.0079371864,
0.0208474603,
0.0355410837,
0.0040106298,
-0.0352276713,
0.0555392541,
0.0241857041,
-0.0103100101,
-0.0613956042,
0.0153105147,
-0.0014530541,
-0.0027034564,
-0.0157069098,
0.0305851307,
0.030369563,
-0.0287281778,
-0.0092540439,
0.0641795024,
-0.0225353576,
-0.0118665863,
0.0083098318,
0.0028656037,
-0.0202318765,
-0.006598738,
-0.0314995386,
-0.0273535363,
0.0058473167,
-0.0369231999,
0.0599096231,
0.0416633673,
-0.0173621196,
-0.0686969757,
0.048001688,
0.0171047952,
0.0347099937,
0.0487983339,
-0.0613499358,
0.014810116,
-0.023892235,
0.018847445,
-0.0012607459,
-0.0332899019,
0.0458273329,
0.0157111492,
0.020895524,
-0.0008349092,
-0.0115416003,
0.0388536006,
-0.0426809527,
0.0086628385,
-0.0337235704,
0.008996834,
-0.0055402555,
-0.0233162213,
0.0282013472,
-0.0336226113,
0.001435698,
0.0517286137,
0.0034910645,
0.0147928027,
-0.0141888019,
-0.0378933363,
0.0142529309,
0.0394358784,
-0.0422284082,
0.0222472399,
-0.0044108671,
0.0371273756,
0.0322597139,
-0.0526351146,
-0.0061362255,
0.033484064,
2.442e-7,
0.0032738624,
0.0377453789,
0.087073572,
-0.0067202784,
0.0102056582,
-0.0035393776,
-0.0134050623,
0.0395230837,
-0.0329828188,
0.0043758652,
0.0149742877,
-0.0206176508,
0.0650879964,
0.0012717326,
-0.1007392406,
0.0122712562,
-0.0470367186,
0.0049338811,
-0.0717190653,
-0.029819591,
0.0820873976,
-0.0042771576,
-0.0299582779,
0.0101244953,
0.056329716,
-0.000047601,
0.0716571286,
0.023944024,
-0.0116358055,
0.002382491,
0.0094334595,
-0.0277241059,
-0.0195475034,
-0.041699402,
-0.0417103656,
-0.0155314654,
0.0127515662,
0.0513071604,
0.0351433195,
-0.0658338368,
0.0518085361,
0.0076050437,
-0.0091958968,
-0.0243377183,
0.0314551927,
0.0088682612,
0.0056160144,
0.0012446614,
-0.0490342565,
0.0088345734,
-0.0029905385,
-0.022137776,
-0.0289399587,
0.0289782546,
0.0022116075,
0.0264634695,
-0.004091226,
-0.0571329705,
-0.029121086,
-0.0198516306,
-0.040444836,
-0.0158721171,
-0.0484413132,
0.0092108054,
0.0178096127,
-0.0337306,
-0.002231949,
2.041308159e-34,
0.0457140803,
-0.0250439793,
-0.0207987633,
0.0105810342,
0.0115440805,
-0.014872889,
0.0099099735,
0.0364029445,
0.014757474,
-0.0242365859,
-0.0406838618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13469v2 | MAILEX: Email Event and Argument Extraction | 2023-05-22T20:28:23 | 2023-10-21T02:15:22 | Saurabh Srivastava, Gaurav Singh, Shou Matsumoto, Ali Raz, Paulo Costa, Joshua Poore, Ziyu Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present the first dataset, MailEx, for performing event
extraction from conversational email threads. To this end, we first proposed a
new taxonomy covering 10 event types and 76 arguments in the email domain. Our
final dataset includes 1.5K email threads and ~4K emails, which are annotated
with totally ~8K event instances. To understand the task challenges, we
conducted a series of experiments comparing three types of approaches, i.e.,
fine-tuned sequence labeling, fine-tuned generative extraction, and few-shot
in-context learning. Our results showed that the task of email event extraction
is far from being addressed, due to challenges lying in, e.g., extracting
non-continuous, shared trigger spans, extracting non-named entity arguments,
and modeling the email conversational history. Our work thus suggests more
future investigations in this domain-specific event extraction task. | [
0.040980313,
0.0264638215,
0.0065983883,
0.0580394976,
-0.0472721495,
0.0474783108,
0.0107314717,
0.0018350246,
0.0305042267,
-0.0537354611,
0.0139161739,
-0.0079228552,
-0.0632496625,
0.0559212007,
-0.006347585,
-0.0569481961,
0.0115176234,
0.052446682,
0.030355759,
0.0614235476,
0.0401136689,
0.0119968411,
-0.0214306768,
0.029930396,
-0.0351645239,
-0.0106769791,
-0.0306607038,
-0.023601532,
0.0467020124,
-0.0058636256,
0.0303620137,
0.0236685704,
0.0255556311,
0.0141363498,
0.0000014136,
-0.0669331849,
-0.0388372578,
-0.0299522616,
-0.0410018526,
-0.0031275032,
0.0058620893,
-0.0068539591,
-0.0264257584,
-0.0048794951,
-0.0687007681,
-0.0170520525,
0.0206373148,
0.0512285233,
0.0118172076,
0.1194604486,
-0.0392937101,
-0.0151937138,
0.0345026255,
-0.0344844311,
-0.0036048687,
-0.0400454029,
0.0259319078,
-0.0355199873,
-0.0033382524,
0.0283628516,
0.0438038819,
-0.0041093333,
0.0169385243,
-0.0100575872,
-0.0261555873,
0.0373011567,
-0.0081699118,
-0.0046936665,
-0.016415365,
0.0657470971,
-0.0110080633,
0.0416332632,
0.0631897673,
-0.0057670292,
0.0134750847,
-0.028504746,
-0.0587099642,
-0.0003232345,
-0.0306641906,
0.0367599688,
0.024029566,
0.0256358609,
0.0098181944,
-0.0056457091,
0.0127755217,
0.0054357904,
0.0050665666,
-0.0011419159,
-0.0542080402,
0.0108215474,
0.023491567,
-0.047570847,
0.0316378735,
0.0139294164,
0.0059087276,
0.0347351357,
-0.0227243621,
0.0172331836,
0.0026249667,
-0.0841755345,
-0.024133997,
0.0077223163,
0.0413174927,
0.0432542749,
0.0152745843,
-0.0518313907,
0.0155150946,
-0.0176169463,
-0.0134086609,
-0.0234832726,
-0.1005053073,
0.0205422342,
-0.0290154256,
0.016544044,
-0.0563806221,
-0.0080317669,
-0.0440746471,
0.0202656463,
0.014270056,
0.0043300772,
-0.0375897549,
-0.0170049574,
-0.0436509922,
-0.0150565151,
0.0050465059,
0.0045351298,
-0.0682010576,
0.0444803424,
0.0423070639,
-0.0821488202,
-0.0454221293,
0.0012560399,
0.0493490882,
-0.0317161977,
-0.0500436835,
-0.0083159432,
0.0092786895,
-0.0780394226,
-0.0163000952,
-0.0598081462,
-0.0184634011,
0.0000644337,
-0.0219643582,
-0.0520244464,
0.0522534885,
-0.0186721385,
-0.0196729228,
0.0097299023,
0.0062587662,
-0.0120757064,
-0.0386545956,
0.0059344014,
0.0116507057,
-0.02307868,
0.0224031433,
0.0092186434,
0.0250808448,
0.0708481297,
0.0148547404,
0.0518124588,
0.06661053,
0.020040717,
0.0371354558,
0.0283545945,
0.0255209804,
-0.0334083401,
0.0429165997,
-0.0055414713,
0.0044069816,
-0.0155747514,
0.0181599371,
-0.0182909817,
-0.0484291837,
-0.0245413277,
0.0284034926,
0.0092782667,
-0.0415379554,
0.0086792819,
-0.0025575547,
0.00945176,
-0.0021115181,
0.02322766,
0.0024640125,
-0.0165214557,
-0.0043533803,
-0.00393232,
0.0006607376,
-0.0275838785,
-0.0317391492,
-0.0216411743,
0.003520254,
-0.0189290512,
-0.0374060944,
0.0033143042,
0.0753632411,
0.0336747281,
-0.0378424749,
0.058854185,
-0.001710251,
-0.0471391082,
-0.0501134098,
-0.0056642923,
-0.0215697307,
-0.0088719083,
0.0271197744,
-0.0303398874,
-0.0712291151,
-0.0357637778,
0.0669474304,
0.0272975825,
0.0508067533,
-0.0096618906,
0.0661386475,
-0.0201487448,
-0.0030741084,
-0.0009202744,
0.0027827385,
-0.037311282,
-0.002471125,
-0.0208886471,
0.0114212818,
0.0714027733,
0.0054170513,
0.0197017994,
-0.0161206443,
-0.0560054667,
0.0323609896,
-0.0134766409,
0.0412186198,
0.0430429019,
0.0014041701,
-0.0054571871,
0.0337876603,
-0.0466689728,
-0.0070666894,
0.035723038,
-0.0407679789,
-0.01738392,
0.0324938223,
0.0087838983,
-0.0594130494,
-0.0243377332,
-0.0946581513,
-0.0217413828,
0.005115224,
0.0054663722,
0.0464737117,
-0.0483459346,
-0.0304974318,
0.0293951426,
-0.0114373695,
-0.0291174632,
0.0439514779,
0.0116101932,
-0.0285589676,
-0.0420190804,
0.0008895759,
-0.0032888898,
-0.0259805731,
-0.0117166182,
0.0362831056,
-0.025262285,
-0.0301085133,
0.0204996075,
-0.0539725535,
-0.0809869766,
-0.0016671988,
-0.0916021764,
0.0633525029,
-0.0124114994,
0.1020029783,
0.0291694794,
0.0278501157,
-0.0160006322,
-0.0139380423,
-0.0322030708,
-0.0020450917,
-0.0132177817,
-0.0115632378,
0.0724171028,
0.0229135212,
-0.0174427219,
-0.0708663091,
0.0028599624,
-0.0529591888,
0.0440511666,
0.0069584399,
-0.0139439292,
-0.0325510129,
0.004882236,
0.0216816124,
0.0151273683,
-0.0262453984,
-0.0218286868,
-0.0281670503,
-0.0312980413,
0.0216168761,
0.0261484571,
0.0339368284,
0.0835746527,
-0.0599117056,
-0.0483381748,
-0.0360043533,
0.0411894284,
-0.074357979,
0.0009212773,
-0.0218799673,
0.0285519157,
0.0314733088,
0.0605766103,
-0.0234038793,
0.0108776949,
-0.0125463847,
0.0213735085,
0.0261727609,
0.0161066353,
-0.0116404146,
-0.0308231041,
-0.0140192937,
0.006087698,
-0.0328235514,
-0.0466348231,
0.066839546,
0.0196285341,
-0.0340572484,
-0.0564186908,
-0.0175470468,
-0.0309094451,
0.0764884204,
-0.0154284295,
-0.0070102387,
0.0312488284,
-0.0407500118,
0.0207041651,
-0.0010874069,
0.0329519697,
-0.0154108247,
0.0096259834,
-0.0240522455,
0.0122121926,
-0.0204954259,
-0.0028403539,
-0.0480161309,
-0.0243456438,
-0.0200244412,
-0.012633197,
-0.0279048216,
0.0291099753,
-0.0625592396,
0.0011095812,
-0.0442099236,
0.0255189613,
-0.0044114729,
-0.0076757036,
-0.0034066851,
0.0651594773,
0.0465340614,
0.0130688287,
-0.0302993506,
0.0214909799,
0.0143609904,
0.0806383342,
0.0025989665,
-0.015360049,
-0.0115780355,
-0.0175015684,
-0.0174727384,
-0.0672072992,
0.0228883028,
-0.0184045266,
0.0402337946,
-0.0549241789,
-0.0191217382,
0.0986730605,
0.0544912443,
-0.0200474244,
-0.0114236586,
0.0251151696,
0.0018004087,
-0.0253912248,
0.0191028286,
-0.0802522674,
-0.0320397839,
-0.0187130775,
-0.0253279991,
-0.0292492304,
-0.0250946656,
0.0174216423,
-0.0600328073,
0.0230710898,
0.0013410541,
0.008243423,
-0.0346268043,
-0.0871298015,
-0.0142295044,
-0.0034111089,
-0.0223995335,
-0.0281832069,
0.0164956003,
-0.015550592,
-0.0064215497,
-0.0257863794,
-0.075650081,
0.0004210786,
-0.0348564535,
0.0265664905,
0.0278232284,
0.0356275812,
0.0284026358,
0.0018425817,
0.0585851111,
-0.0620208122,
-0.0313400328,
-0.01067618,
0.0873738304,
-0.0261589084,
-0.0052860449,
-0.0361929946,
0.0547344461,
-0.0465919971,
-0.0258397777,
0.012509061,
0.0433599278,
-0.0149047291,
0.0152733065,
0.0175976194,
-0.0273825973,
0.0348398276,
0.0421141312,
0.0294936113,
0.0109387022,
-0.0445885397,
-0.0036530215,
0.0124105476,
-0.0420108847,
0.0452776887,
-0.0311840065,
-0.0094948588,
-0.0337118581,
-0.0812589899,
-0.0777563304,
0.00508855,
0.0210851263,
-0.0444637947,
-0.0317452811,
0.0153218275,
0.0135093033,
-0.0462929606,
0.0461945795,
0.011942259,
-0.0114041958,
-0.0063273329,
0.0038466931,
0.0228895005,
0.0455276333,
-0.0040207896,
0.0923328176,
-0.0666104779,
-0.0576336719,
-0.0341761522,
-0.0066566621,
0.0125593515,
0.0425737314,
-0.0209450759,
-0.0131127676,
-0.0321399756,
0.0369603448,
0.0229468048,
-0.0651720911,
0.0451106727,
0.0062651611,
0.0115684438,
0.0224594865,
0.0125455,
0.0573999397,
-0.0186005645,
0.0506459996,
-0.0471202284,
-0.0099159135,
-0.0134781692,
-0.0289897695,
0.0675036237,
0.0462468453,
-0.0498828515,
-0.0429740511,
0.0308176242,
-0.0403395891,
-0.0002589028,
-0.0328042656,
0.0026753277,
-0.0262606256,
-0.0180581156,
-0.00089374,
0.0329580791,
-0.0466580316,
0.0340421684,
-0.0338933244,
0.0137589052,
0.015758248,
-0.001851756,
-0.0236984957,
0.0014138486,
-0.0141755231,
0.006385026,
0.0129057802,
0.0168499593,
-0.0384213291,
0.0253939498,
0.0094874967,
-0.0037314752,
0.0019865681,
0.0207870342,
-0.0629418269,
0.0611631982,
-0.0206920467,
0.0170927364,
0.0608608611,
-0.0503118224,
0.0853760839,
-0.0180990044,
-0.0006196074,
-0.0051539196,
0.0606731437,
-0.0149058495,
0.008203743,
-0.0117904143,
0.0302252285,
-0.054649625,
0.0039741001,
0.0603935011,
-0.0629881471,
0.0663367808,
0.0220387094,
-0.0191320367,
-0.0595318563,
-0.0033084583,
0.0386976115,
0.0337295085,
0.0111818463,
-0.0047824867,
-0.0354986489,
0.023339672,
0.0347223431,
-0.0220821761,
0.0018162729,
0.0116484938,
0.0499830097,
0.064033851,
0.0070411842,
-0.0164043866,
-0.0315445848,
0.0155213242,
0.0258157719,
-0.0601568483,
-0.0285295993,
-5.123024786e-33,
0.0126848072,
0.0033018366,
-0.0051138182,
0.1046535447,
0.0085839331,
0.0247454438,
-0.0411475077,
-0.0157647207,
0.0186159201,
0.0050966702,
0.0176733453,
-0.004770319,
0.0201163143,
0.0235726219,
0.0127316797,
0.0082974732,
0.0535098575,
0.0069293436,
0.021976145,
0.0528696291,
0.0560176447,
0.0435878113,
0.0599137992,
-0.0535706058,
0.0458692871,
0.0214570444,
0.009084817,
-0.006104196,
0.1022493243,
0.069071196,
-0.0362119265,
0.0152978739,
0.036145933,
-0.0465936437,
0.0023291297,
0.0378857516,
-0.074835822,
-0.0440957323,
-0.0370894782,
-0.0314807631,
0.0166294202,
-0.0567652173,
0.0411588661,
0.028876802,
0.0268376619,
0.0022848167,
0.0198889431,
-0.003098072,
-0.0100346301,
-0.063950859,
-0.0636175126,
0.0565095432,
-0.0073214918,
-0.0212254617,
0.0313733295,
0.0207387265,
0.0270284321,
0.0516075455,
-0.0337075144,
-0.0276831556,
-0.0385022685,
0.005467182,
0.0172773469,
-0.0233171917,
-0.0141639719,
0.0397624038,
0.001189372,
0.027472537,
-0.026233051,
0.0407627821,
-0.0289814323,
0.0809694082,
-0.0143927326,
0.0599278435,
0.0292779785,
0.0006483361,
-0.0763519183,
0.0485819876,
0.047330454,
0.0154397618,
-0.0115547134,
0.0002688525,
-0.0306028482,
0.0386851877,
0.0258854516,
0.0354036316,
0.0007945268,
0.012245426,
-0.0001573833,
0.0171285365,
0.0102115599,
0.0693177134,
0.0354233757,
-0.0015223072,
-0.0261196289,
-0.000873738,
0.02273589,
-0.0137404231,
0.0143577456,
-0.028240012,
-0.0318764634,
-0.0323544331,
0.0169961937,
0.0042205015,
0.0234348606,
-0.0409529544,
0.0445538461,
-0.04999106,
-0.0297673531,
0.0067833946,
-0.0167245399,
0.0393540896,
-0.0233242121,
0.0420008488,
0.0007684694,
0.0199541785,
-0.0188564882,
0.0832248181,
0.0145784477,
0.0193585455,
0.0030894559,
0.0093236873,
-0.0185601879,
0.0038162752,
0.0104124667,
-0.0250168592,
0.0071320506,
0.0080625005,
-0.0009329346,
-0.0117394347,
0.0053002811,
-0.0003290451,
2.192e-7,
0.0327012986,
0.0431007408,
0.0566737093,
-0.0113439308,
0.0260094684,
0.0417245366,
0.0183179136,
0.0502614602,
-0.0108497748,
-0.0085937921,
-0.008314305,
-0.0065755867,
0.0412753895,
0.0462662652,
-0.0745680779,
-0.0713848397,
-0.0497241914,
-0.0233788565,
-0.0632673055,
0.0184778068,
0.1227466688,
0.0766229406,
0.0547331758,
0.03317203,
-0.0106026754,
-0.0279345233,
0.0229392536,
-0.0274682678,
-0.0540331528,
0.0296801664,
0.0174151454,
-0.0015935777,
-0.0429066047,
0.0093192682,
-0.0434209071,
0.0370921157,
-0.0348839127,
0.0836400986,
0.0077412473,
-0.0108589297,
-0.0002037944,
-0.0231554508,
0.0259080939,
-0.0440404788,
0.0501360297,
-0.0794753954,
-0.0231097378,
-0.015842678,
-0.031111056,
0.0281123444,
-0.0112064574,
0.0244642124,
-0.0196959171,
0.0547322109,
0.0214408953,
-0.0047960118,
0.0091834404,
-0.0955241993,
0.0216537658,
0.0448115915,
-0.0227165986,
-0.0154865906,
-0.0126217986,
-0.0511631221,
0.0057223551,
0.0097583178,
-0.0017182807,
1.694092382e-34,
-0.0241212975,
0.0019688411,
-0.0307504386,
0.0676237121,
0.0088138925,
-0.0066661877,
-0.0279375911,
0.0179379974,
0.0061749564,
-0.0351799242,
0.0234091207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13455v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13455v3 | Clembench: Using Game Play to Evaluate Chat-Optimized Language Models as Conversational Agents | 2023-05-22T19:56:10 | 2023-11-23T15:47:52 | Kranti Chalamalasetti, Jana Götze, Sherzod Hakimov, Brielen Madureira, Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has proposed a methodology for the systematic evaluation of
"Situated Language Understanding Agents"-agents that operate in rich linguistic
and non-linguistic contexts-through testing them in carefully constructed
interactive settings. Other recent work has argued that Large Language Models
(LLMs), if suitably set up, can be understood as (simulators of) such agents. A
connection suggests itself, which this paper explores: Can LLMs be evaluated
meaningfully by exposing them to constrained game-like settings that are built
to challenge specific capabilities? As a proof of concept, this paper
investigates five interaction settings, showing that current chat-optimised
LLMs are, to an extent, capable to follow game-play instructions. Both this
capability and the quality of the game play, measured by how well the
objectives of the different games are met, follows the development cycle, with
newer models performing better. The metrics even for the comparatively simple
example games are far from being saturated, suggesting that the proposed
instrument will remain to have diagnostic value. Our general framework for
implementing and evaluating games with LLMs is available at
https://github.com/clembench . | [
0.0525701046,
-0.0126058683,
-0.0692583248,
0.0692186877,
-0.0416375734,
-0.0137763619,
0.0163400024,
0.0008599914,
0.0417272262,
-0.0330675431,
-0.062111862,
-0.0245815758,
0.0225777458,
0.0262452532,
0.013088352,
-0.0316629224,
0.0311037526,
-0.0202592611,
0.0189631805,
0.0110629201,
-0.0167430639,
-0.0177795868,
-0.0258589555,
0.070498772,
0.0128706703,
-0.0237221029,
-0.0493978709,
-0.0035798638,
-0.0229274333,
-0.0086645922,
0.0035750077,
0.0127363503,
0.0188668258,
0.0099860393,
0.0000020901,
-0.0252763871,
0.0526077636,
-0.0335679203,
-0.0051164152,
-0.016122954,
0.0440332741,
0.0250971559,
-0.0147791784,
0.002490896,
-0.0522228591,
-0.041326277,
0.0258060247,
-0.0430167504,
0.0591561235,
0.0607768744,
-0.0052749976,
-0.0012417738,
-0.024165703,
0.0184493344,
-0.0073034484,
-0.0569604896,
-0.0217591375,
0.0421646014,
0.083603397,
0.0085577331,
-0.0152203897,
0.0444092974,
0.0158733651,
-0.0291583762,
-0.0390024595,
0.0364036411,
-0.0388721712,
-0.0405951813,
-0.0165068749,
0.0452743731,
0.0064812242,
-0.0096734576,
0.0149304653,
0.0211344901,
0.0288941264,
-0.0138527071,
-0.0290385168,
0.0185900554,
-0.0024131415,
-0.0241413638,
-0.0220988058,
-0.0017195949,
0.0254771188,
0.013168145,
0.0122706816,
0.0563600585,
-0.0316070281,
0.0077775246,
-0.0486359484,
-0.0031725375,
0.0002909937,
-0.0800837502,
-0.037561927,
0.0630777702,
-0.0793745071,
0.0622601099,
-0.0264108013,
0.0577998608,
0.0120437453,
-0.0497171395,
0.0095237438,
0.0552669987,
0.0121013299,
0.0684860423,
0.0350586958,
0.0550321117,
0.0313164853,
-0.0038886506,
-0.0292483419,
-0.0070574409,
-0.0344323888,
-0.0247205403,
-0.037521001,
0.0154517582,
-0.0353892744,
-0.0484408438,
0.0031007137,
0.0643202066,
-0.0080582183,
0.0583196059,
-0.0205240566,
-0.0200676415,
-0.0164353065,
0.0028183756,
-0.0397383049,
0.0111705763,
-0.0472268127,
0.0078356145,
-0.0039887358,
-0.1445609182,
0.0239453781,
0.0035515097,
-0.0150978379,
-0.0131803546,
-0.0204117298,
0.0832607821,
0.0172027349,
-0.0461338647,
0.0321323574,
-0.0137655456,
0.0039246413,
-0.1004795805,
-0.0182315484,
-0.0484650135,
0.0201776456,
0.0199579988,
-0.0096992282,
-0.0319210328,
-0.001272988,
0.0112181464,
-0.0047099711,
0.0701923296,
0.0147954859,
0.0358257145,
0.0378585234,
0.0328796096,
-0.0435935296,
0.0955357552,
0.0708959699,
-0.0038865863,
0.0322167277,
-0.0172867533,
0.0190293361,
0.0696106851,
-0.0319439322,
-0.0229235869,
0.021504581,
0.0155425407,
-0.0180104487,
0.0589458197,
-0.0304034967,
0.0280183256,
-0.0367300212,
-0.0031060381,
0.0788742453,
0.0750237703,
0.0195847433,
0.0035385995,
0.0391610041,
0.0265498403,
-0.0002435621,
0.0099622263,
-0.0136203906,
0.0202017613,
-0.0079403231,
-0.0061476757,
-0.0175449885,
0.0074819331,
-0.0100534093,
-0.0504083894,
0.0083539207,
-0.0073998244,
0.0462691672,
0.0395900197,
0.0196131002,
-0.015981555,
-0.0323606394,
0.0275351442,
0.0209271517,
-0.0432418883,
0.008610934,
-0.0915793255,
0.0286179502,
0.0788309723,
0.0680993199,
-0.0210875291,
-0.0514869541,
0.0107791908,
-0.0027016373,
0.0464845151,
0.0396856554,
-0.0095072668,
0.0185413919,
-0.0158479679,
-0.0130011979,
-0.0506499894,
0.0046496778,
0.0228934418,
-0.0213369094,
0.0126858279,
-0.0375735275,
-0.0033127016,
0.0074754399,
-0.0101544857,
-0.0281618573,
0.0056257867,
-0.0652298704,
0.0028399515,
0.0121642854,
0.0091186501,
-0.0079032052,
-0.0100393053,
-0.0034961656,
-0.0215180665,
0.0252361353,
0.0739006773,
-0.0103363683,
-0.0325562581,
0.034740705,
-0.0150738424,
-0.0099641532,
0.002389132,
0.0170028415,
-0.0033989118,
0.059857782,
-0.0286700092,
0.0594519153,
-0.0131560657,
0.0381571874,
-0.0729265586,
0.0046698586,
-0.0070709423,
0.0288139321,
0.0044272384,
0.017183071,
0.0042996188,
0.0102187283,
-0.0040822541,
-0.0439509936,
0.0110523319,
0.0534254909,
-0.0112884063,
-0.0029944037,
0.0214375444,
0.0127153974,
-0.057634335,
-0.0526227318,
-0.1011702195,
0.0012192803,
-0.0316880047,
-0.0054769428,
0.0452465415,
0.0187033415,
-0.0285047553,
0.00452124,
-0.0053738994,
0.0170344766,
0.0444233008,
0.0264726114,
0.0336849727,
0.0202903114,
-0.0365407392,
-0.0446990617,
0.0288404319,
-0.0058108284,
0.0300256517,
0.0000853161,
0.0014769088,
-0.0484203435,
0.0323716514,
-0.045709677,
-0.0017478986,
-0.041007638,
-0.0767577812,
0.0661999509,
-0.0009692875,
-0.0074687451,
0.0622880682,
0.0051986519,
0.0700300336,
0.0312441401,
-0.0691894144,
-0.0492963009,
0.0260074213,
0.0129605941,
-0.0187788121,
-0.0817644596,
-0.0424064025,
0.0052878791,
0.078227587,
-0.0036758564,
0.0375091061,
-0.0532739796,
0.0415165909,
-0.011233707,
-0.0468151234,
-0.0261949189,
-0.0077949292,
-0.0221133139,
0.0170424152,
-0.0169019699,
-0.0019194776,
0.0557870045,
-0.0370518863,
-0.0548604317,
-0.0291133728,
-0.0112994462,
-0.0181265343,
0.0766185075,
-0.0120636234,
-0.0091748256,
0.0009728345,
-0.0168205965,
-0.0361213274,
-0.0452448465,
0.0374589749,
-0.0403198004,
0.0034794956,
-0.0623799227,
-0.0048965672,
0.0236474536,
-0.0183690023,
-0.021540124,
-0.0220429376,
-0.0476254188,
-0.0124460096,
0.0188337322,
0.0095377499,
-0.0398875736,
0.0604381189,
0.0327711962,
0.0203930438,
0.0123252822,
-0.0151990196,
-0.040325433,
-0.0061201937,
0.0534293875,
0.047495272,
-0.0009357932,
-0.0195671674,
0.0722411573,
0.0197544415,
-0.0342755094,
-0.0288023632,
-0.0083261672,
-0.0040054047,
0.0430307984,
-0.0108676367,
-0.0433863252,
0.0394070446,
0.0600253306,
-0.0590556972,
-0.0275118053,
0.1022248268,
0.0090830363,
0.0125660077,
0.0216086004,
-0.0121830162,
0.027974477,
0.0129622305,
0.0243936945,
-0.0528145581,
-0.0178347323,
0.0072075156,
-0.0250385255,
-0.0137834037,
-0.0211139359,
-0.028270429,
-0.1189922392,
0.0149264056,
-0.0073997807,
-0.0369951986,
0.0288516451,
0.0149063515,
0.0096469512,
0.017283285,
0.050773073,
0.0103168515,
0.0126066199,
-0.0075168898,
-0.0208245888,
-0.0391038395,
-0.0266165491,
0.0327528007,
-0.0352124535,
0.0982108265,
0.0396591835,
0.0682426319,
0.0073176702,
-0.0058410806,
0.0260008946,
0.0238044187,
0.0095381001,
0.0107405707,
0.0052851578,
-0.0171792693,
-0.001064076,
0.0002075315,
-0.0184596591,
0.0096808234,
0.0041527711,
0.0140879164,
0.027577389,
-0.0279960968,
-0.0266360324,
0.0316878669,
0.0387656502,
0.0403043479,
0.0408729278,
0.0388546214,
-0.0516638681,
-0.0056430306,
-0.0179957673,
-0.0217016898,
0.0012073304,
-0.038680695,
-0.0185741279,
0.0528600477,
0.0192042124,
-0.0392663702,
-0.0818188637,
-0.0051698829,
0.0125727896,
0.0035634332,
0.0254778489,
0.0096523054,
0.0339305773,
0.0537149645,
0.0193897244,
-0.0175371021,
0.0199795496,
-0.0327096246,
-0.0148703605,
0.0330029838,
-0.0807040855,
0.016994888,
-0.0091719162,
-0.0318950266,
-0.0617979169,
-0.0017956737,
0.0550283045,
0.0277235378,
0.0319028236,
-0.0203530379,
-0.0528890789,
-0.0328662917,
-0.0140388329,
-0.0693254471,
0.0202057417,
0.0130090434,
0.0141946161,
0.0277362932,
0.027333837,
-0.0328041837,
0.0072650369,
-0.0375796594,
0.05409614,
-0.0380733348,
-0.0636809319,
-0.0061150454,
-0.0208236109,
0.0198116396,
-0.0009531657,
-0.0346705541,
0.0151962647,
0.0150015401,
-0.0393962525,
-0.0125760837,
-0.0343077742,
-0.0449172407,
-0.0188755747,
0.0198785327,
0.0342799202,
0.0046592001,
-0.0599927343,
0.0129792942,
0.022913143,
0.0354940519,
0.0224591494,
-0.0375164784,
0.0125834486,
0.0287589729,
0.0158685502,
0.0561949983,
-0.0251299199,
0.0387238339,
0.0138107659,
0.0498929843,
0.014000725,
-0.0685925037,
0.0278239269,
0.0322796553,
-0.0231318679,
-0.0401837826,
0.0630904213,
0.0718335882,
0.0815997198,
0.018765118,
0.0333218314,
-0.0185646471,
0.0213950295,
-0.0150420461,
0.0057560266,
0.0400775783,
-0.1195244193,
-0.0015902193,
0.0391515493,
-0.0262176991,
-0.0248303767,
0.032235615,
-0.0160324089,
0.0237685684,
0.0045838174,
0.0071193478,
-0.0158613492,
-0.0106679285,
0.0083054118,
0.0102154594,
-0.037780229,
0.017099198,
-0.0547416136,
-0.0543784462,
-0.0358882137,
0.0528150238,
-0.0139391804,
-0.0445435755,
0.0028559163,
0.03473581,
0.0190538764,
0.0118813068,
-0.0649164915,
0.008434087,
-0.044808466,
0.0265822653,
-0.0262908321,
-5.781281051e-33,
-0.0345281251,
-0.038394101,
0.0575368553,
0.0050448496,
-0.0102399895,
-0.0173155647,
-0.0893286616,
-0.0063401582,
-0.0317396633,
-0.0223504845,
-0.0143873403,
0.0127145285,
0.0003015453,
-0.0190639459,
-0.0235427115,
-0.0428392552,
0.014726866,
0.0252467226,
-0.0539920181,
0.0071748844,
-0.0115369316,
-0.0096019423,
0.0213534124,
-0.0441663191,
0.0237031206,
-0.0294607282,
-0.0164001863,
0.0385975428,
0.0204006247,
0.031305898,
0.0063483566,
0.0192638449,
0.022799192,
-0.0078936443,
0.0142248338,
0.0086424798,
-0.013231609,
-0.0279782489,
0.0491557308,
0.0529008172,
-0.0095934113,
-0.0126636792,
0.0196783952,
-0.0090146502,
-0.0578376129,
0.0307131112,
0.0187981464,
-0.0121338712,
-0.0322188251,
0.0520074815,
-0.0532587767,
0.0036839156,
-0.0415729284,
-0.0594305843,
0.0099454019,
0.0383487418,
-0.0069187558,
-0.0285066757,
-0.0484148413,
0.0512137637,
-0.0120041119,
-0.0101794843,
0.0974300876,
0.033969339,
0.0561249368,
0.0571673177,
0.021589281,
0.0590163805,
-0.0363725163,
-0.017341096,
0.0555829853,
0.0194344092,
0.0099098003,
0.0409165025,
-0.0689847767,
-0.0112887146,
-0.0117053669,
0.0060831425,
0.0914876536,
0.0382541008,
0.0254876148,
0.0327862315,
-0.0386844873,
-0.0175341219,
-0.0405631848,
0.0375056677,
-0.0095401499,
-0.0620306022,
0.0184452198,
-0.0283986852,
0.0080598146,
-0.0577714667,
0.0294046197,
-0.051985845,
-0.0344608463,
0.0160938744,
-0.0264169574,
0.0342209563,
-0.0044352221,
0.0417107716,
0.0030849157,
-0.022472566,
0.0070063383,
0.0176444892,
0.0119576659,
0.0318634883,
-0.0423854254,
0.0509711951,
0.0073755691,
-0.0104867117,
-0.0369242094,
0.0379044861,
-0.0244695731,
-0.0088630719,
0.0301936176,
-0.0206491407,
-0.0392690562,
0.0207441822,
0.012827009,
-0.0132105807,
-0.0314518064,
-0.0018532155,
-0.0377948247,
0.0015260648,
-0.0415890887,
-0.0174479298,
-0.0698220655,
0.0698494166,
0.0257191453,
-0.0082995677,
-0.0221812408,
-0.0231417082,
2.93e-7,
-0.0218511801,
0.0403278358,
-0.0442960188,
0.0235549789,
0.0281828046,
0.041093763,
-0.0585069135,
0.0090841139,
0.0216353573,
-0.0321019515,
0.0257143714,
0.0460015349,
0.0593566671,
0.0104013048,
-0.1052596048,
-0.0105618453,
-0.0465375222,
0.0111692175,
-0.0237836894,
0.0385153256,
0.0154172992,
0.0248244759,
0.0044507068,
0.0228932947,
-0.0138632515,
-0.0582248047,
0.0077247927,
-0.0824511126,
-0.0111424932,
0.0531831942,
0.0015273051,
0.0199101157,
0.0009068158,
-0.0186240245,
0.0264512803,
0.0366026871,
-0.0347391181,
0.0557779483,
0.0228579305,
-0.0076956819,
-0.022224877,
-0.0231232345,
-0.0222594384,
-0.0645452812,
0.0523345657,
-0.0533514321,
-0.0426975712,
-0.018301066,
0.0333207175,
-0.054756891,
-0.0428427979,
-0.0305445734,
-0.0403702743,
0.0174162369,
-0.0024265621,
-0.0464252718,
0.0090566073,
-0.0360101052,
-0.0246821195,
-0.0085964836,
-0.0438053571,
-0.054104168,
-0.0451694541,
-0.002622176,
0.0031675694,
-0.0626452863,
0.0270459261,
2.032608582e-34,
-0.0051212693,
-0.0014660041,
0.0151228094,
0.0292143933,
0.064135842,
0.0317912102,
0.0269203149,
0.0297651552,
0.0717502981,
-0.0267850682,
0.0111467447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13417v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13417v2 | VISIT: Visualizing and Interpreting the Semantic Information Flow of Transformers | 2023-05-22T19:04:56 | 2023-11-24T12:02:13 | Shahar Katz, Yonatan Belinkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent advances in interpretability suggest we can project weights and hidden
states of transformer-based language models (LMs) to their vocabulary, a
transformation that makes them more human interpretable. In this paper, we
investigate LM attention heads and memory values, the vectors the models
dynamically create and recall while processing a given input. By analyzing the
tokens they represent through this projection, we identify patterns in the
information flow inside the attention mechanism. Based on our discoveries, we
create a tool to visualize a forward pass of Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPTs) as an interactive flow graph, with nodes representing
neurons or hidden states and edges representing the interactions between them.
Our visualization simplifies huge amounts of data into easy-to-read plots that
can reflect the models' internal processing, uncovering the contribution of
each component to the models' final prediction. Our visualization also unveils
new insights about the role of layer norms as semantic filters that influence
the models' output, and about neurons that are always activated during forward
passes and act as regularization vectors. | [
0.0182485953,
0.0150593594,
-0.0319074094,
0.0196078252,
0.0117961988,
-0.0079206917,
-0.0168054048,
0.0019577204,
-0.0560237244,
0.0009912202,
-0.0484261326,
-0.0237781052,
0.0114452131,
0.0317655988,
0.02711647,
-0.0640864596,
0.0181121118,
-0.0098813595,
-0.0349148624,
0.0278811306,
0.0042802077,
-0.0040045548,
0.0010850641,
0.1012041941,
-0.0236825813,
-0.0268605147,
-0.0116854608,
-0.0068309032,
0.0170453731,
-0.0224996563,
-0.0351913497,
0.050689429,
0.0291082729,
0.0452266783,
0.0000022583,
-0.027483074,
-0.0067411135,
-0.0138510251,
-0.0278283674,
0.0208385531,
-0.0090850228,
-0.0197810307,
-0.015299635,
0.0013197534,
-0.0261638984,
-0.0553856529,
0.0713478699,
0.0637766793,
0.0691126883,
0.0365755819,
-0.0154893072,
-0.0395802967,
0.0119721238,
-0.0274860058,
0.0260189623,
-0.0251533668,
0.0111123594,
-0.0469192117,
-0.0536496826,
-0.0142338416,
-0.0759223998,
0.0361601114,
0.0173696391,
-0.0289476775,
0.0194435138,
0.0294806156,
0.0157097559,
-0.0482505336,
-0.0238298588,
0.0678358376,
-0.0696619302,
-0.0437248647,
-0.0317523144,
-0.0194765758,
-0.0084313797,
0.0210062806,
-0.0458619148,
0.0216449294,
0.0353685394,
0.0326525085,
-0.0314292237,
-0.001128098,
0.0319280326,
-0.051423531,
-0.0652744547,
0.0320795141,
0.0098843956,
0.0018251557,
-0.0417530388,
0.0084150145,
0.003396733,
-0.0330114327,
0.03897826,
0.0394025706,
0.0183758102,
0.0331529342,
0.0088316984,
-0.0517910495,
-0.00790268,
-0.0161338411,
0.0584746413,
0.0331908092,
-0.0479508638,
0.0051206886,
-0.006633414,
0.0640929714,
-0.0563941598,
0.0785875618,
-0.0162779875,
0.017841896,
-0.0138649093,
-0.0342459939,
-0.0664643422,
-0.010674553,
0.0137374541,
-0.0131965699,
-0.034437906,
0.0229613949,
0.0027969149,
-0.0365632735,
0.0390108004,
0.0144136967,
-0.0225000344,
0.0142286969,
-0.0393061489,
0.0550814904,
-0.0059577827,
-0.0015230774,
-0.0276827998,
-0.0458886027,
-0.0515159108,
0.0063108536,
0.0205602609,
-0.0190703981,
-0.0408098623,
0.0746179894,
0.0040974249,
-0.0482251234,
-0.00511094,
0.0114641069,
0.0101363575,
-0.0002330851,
0.0310335662,
0.0190352853,
0.0079076458,
0.0228717886,
0.0212936886,
-0.0417852439,
-0.0047037322,
0.0244847126,
-0.0149119953,
0.0359645933,
0.0132884504,
-0.0012953996,
-0.0202101916,
0.0006208133,
0.0133245802,
-0.0012141276,
0.0507019684,
0.0199163854,
-0.0204918608,
-0.0533736125,
0.0446975045,
0.0245819334,
0.0242281612,
-0.0354496203,
-0.0277652144,
-0.0567081869,
-0.0297684725,
0.0057483297,
0.0476931967,
0.0294349752,
-0.0283972826,
-0.0182181578,
0.0550452545,
0.058221858,
0.0626723617,
0.0365029648,
0.0575851314,
0.0206521284,
0.0050017163,
0.0219803825,
-0.0354624465,
0.0534455702,
0.0188361611,
-0.0066194492,
-0.0498834401,
0.0295244567,
-0.0146109452,
-0.0249508806,
0.0035856203,
0.0042062886,
-0.0093744546,
-0.0224839691,
0.0607598647,
0.058476761,
-0.0513769388,
0.0943707675,
0.0128965555,
-0.0689720586,
0.0062047951,
-0.0547014512,
0.0066075199,
0.0400725864,
0.0381242372,
0.0012129489,
0.0016820554,
0.0162259731,
-0.0377056003,
0.0237958934,
0.0036777651,
0.0440224409,
-0.0068414765,
-0.0327987075,
-0.0308305062,
-0.0175508074,
0.0128669683,
0.0304103047,
-0.0271101855,
-0.0255394336,
0.0270743687,
-0.048117049,
-0.0220011082,
0.042839516,
0.0097329589,
0.0163702648,
-0.0033311665,
0.012736869,
-0.0064157392,
0.0012971108,
0.0051605687,
0.0268101189,
0.0631104931,
-0.0079039494,
0.0314047784,
0.0610896163,
-0.0558308624,
0.0227233768,
0.0066629574,
-0.0548227429,
-0.0034809313,
0.038479805,
-0.0113304825,
-0.0377743803,
0.0423917174,
-0.0582595095,
0.0836036503,
-0.0286167506,
0.0030005598,
0.0001815551,
0.0583824553,
-0.0197801031,
0.0404918827,
0.0093792789,
0.0121390726,
0.0100249145,
0.0148366261,
0.017704675,
0.0106292777,
-0.006656338,
0.0010304076,
-0.0246286243,
-0.0319842435,
-0.0054341233,
-0.039123293,
-0.035868153,
0.0338046849,
-0.0242160764,
-0.0275275242,
-0.0172173958,
0.0032415313,
0.0267901346,
0.0000054057,
0.0192741938,
-0.0161369741,
-0.003516082,
0.0293361284,
-0.0031227225,
-0.0174534861,
0.0350767449,
-0.0169845968,
-0.0021131269,
-0.0385944098,
-0.0295140836,
-0.0320345685,
0.0846069902,
0.0343849584,
-0.0019753007,
-0.0509909764,
0.0022284735,
0.0035180226,
0.0075437427,
-0.0074149985,
-0.0614088923,
0.0332242996,
-0.0120116789,
0.0643920824,
0.0206655413,
0.0281101204,
0.0779004619,
0.0918202698,
-0.0151683008,
-0.0309802406,
0.0114991507,
-0.0598911457,
0.0126202218,
-0.0538559034,
-0.0134864813,
0.0181090683,
0.1291414052,
0.011432413,
-0.010579058,
-0.0670958534,
-0.0209458247,
-0.0139158843,
0.0150587661,
0.0110028405,
-0.0069696065,
-0.036966797,
0.0422166996,
-0.0026648794,
-0.0502883978,
0.0703563765,
-0.027802093,
-0.0207516979,
-0.007522257,
0.0179223027,
-0.0326825492,
0.0812265053,
0.0392922089,
0.0008174315,
-0.0052681938,
-0.0478311591,
-0.0348025523,
0.0397723764,
0.0078536803,
-0.0322907045,
0.0438917018,
-0.0173784364,
-0.0356603302,
-0.0084095364,
0.0351030305,
-0.0493013151,
0.0035059194,
-0.0190575123,
-0.0180824976,
0.0918488204,
-0.0384263769,
-0.0425476879,
0.0112136621,
0.035976287,
0.0398341194,
0.0198464971,
-0.0147670833,
-0.0086096134,
0.0125066163,
0.0151029471,
0.0235631447,
0.0263138115,
-0.0388952419,
-0.0104212873,
0.0499232896,
-0.0096637858,
0.0020857025,
-0.0531577654,
0.0022083777,
0.0330220051,
-0.0088901967,
0.0155694922,
0.011894892,
0.0280139484,
-0.0654941872,
-0.0287903938,
0.0978068039,
0.0462728925,
-0.0870123208,
0.0336480625,
-0.0072884746,
0.0028365406,
0.0341318622,
0.0285099037,
-0.0715452954,
-0.0121108312,
-0.0194967408,
-0.0148270335,
0.0160032753,
-0.0061122882,
-0.0057981564,
-0.0579777174,
0.0342026092,
-0.03393187,
-0.0294059236,
0.0072036427,
-0.0416284353,
0.0050162892,
-0.0111522842,
-0.0032081166,
-0.0075289859,
-0.000156771,
0.0011515383,
0.0156099703,
0.0085310498,
-0.0149378264,
0.0190862734,
0.0087017817,
-0.0077143572,
0.0646445975,
0.0224669408,
-0.0217494685,
-0.0842906237,
0.0340145789,
-0.0218457803,
0.0421704985,
0.0012932296,
0.0651193857,
0.0172788333,
-0.0337256901,
-0.0348378383,
-0.018716557,
-0.0075488961,
-0.0334471203,
-0.0601886734,
0.071647957,
-0.0357564762,
-0.05473952,
-0.0179261249,
0.0080613168,
-0.0304171406,
0.0414472669,
0.0703619346,
-0.0317500122,
-0.0211547986,
-0.0537078269,
0.0667369291,
-0.0296888109,
-0.1010570899,
0.0322599001,
0.0399014764,
-0.090118207,
-0.0198740698,
-0.0002487426,
0.0242566466,
-0.0137011539,
0.0249296837,
-0.0585421473,
0.0405229926,
-0.0238056928,
-0.0351252332,
0.0637586191,
-0.0095464,
0.0087555386,
-0.048056189,
-0.0326867327,
0.0361889116,
-0.0049476963,
-0.0431532636,
0.0431733914,
-0.0938296169,
-0.0258280225,
0.057475742,
0.0440503955,
0.0123268301,
-0.0288628805,
-0.0176711958,
-0.0380208306,
0.045233611,
0.0067401361,
-0.0212069415,
-0.010324005,
0.0169123523,
-0.0476170592,
-0.0123677012,
-0.0012016672,
-0.005209907,
0.0429086164,
0.0037630515,
0.0212887265,
-0.0208161008,
-0.0438530482,
0.0467960984,
-0.026026981,
0.1074988171,
0.0337994248,
0.0260301493,
-0.0163959879,
0.0150247831,
-0.0020573279,
0.0172860175,
-0.0561227761,
-0.0332984999,
0.0382200517,
-0.0319331586,
-0.0021902414,
0.0361126997,
-0.0336546563,
0.0035851339,
-0.0294098295,
0.0266648084,
-0.0072590923,
-0.0296385791,
0.0125387991,
0.0238371063,
0.0088559911,
-0.0201269705,
-0.021792626,
0.0174079519,
0.0456903763,
0.0541176088,
0.0155599909,
0.0102352742,
-0.0253630057,
0.014031454,
-0.078257069,
-0.0257740095,
0.0189230964,
-0.0218848158,
0.0286492649,
-0.026653152,
0.0636070892,
-0.0048565087,
0.0227818936,
-0.0016033362,
0.0329463854,
-0.0303753149,
-0.0416287743,
0.0444155894,
-0.0104651274,
0.0094693722,
-0.0368878134,
0.0873516351,
-0.0288248882,
0.0176774897,
-0.0131084779,
-0.0115919625,
-0.0143600488,
-0.0213604365,
0.0152497739,
0.0055317329,
-0.0153933521,
0.0076000993,
-0.0551078096,
-0.084642157,
0.0180888139,
-0.0358326845,
0.003640203,
-0.0414681658,
0.0424860828,
0.0226034839,
-0.0043585398,
-0.0333567634,
-0.0030857578,
0.0090079578,
-0.0189807415,
-0.0036662181,
-0.0281414334,
-6.717704096e-33,
-0.0182595234,
-0.0751442984,
0.0067750476,
0.0136860153,
-0.0400919057,
-0.0148967113,
-0.0712724924,
0.0006711838,
-0.0298031121,
0.034622442,
-0.0114223212,
0.0358902775,
-0.0060579176,
0.0447700284,
-0.0175224245,
-0.0369677432,
0.0591506436,
0.0079413839,
-0.0088625923,
0.0386506654,
0.0132376617,
0.0453883596,
0.1084246114,
-0.035554152,
0.0021706875,
0.0140455933,
-0.0006185042,
0.0116661442,
-0.0319628119,
0.0389692821,
-0.027950462,
0.0368305668,
0.0120584415,
-0.0735100284,
-0.0466999635,
-0.0061646798,
-0.0453913212,
-0.0344058909,
0.0088000353,
0.0432620943,
-0.0499452092,
-0.0229930971,
0.0716061741,
-0.0132392254,
0.0128265116,
-0.0405569077,
0.0519231297,
0.0182575043,
-0.0384388119,
-0.0349475965,
-0.0346233957,
-0.0062152604,
-0.0508663394,
-0.023102032,
0.032926783,
0.0354930423,
-0.0000565079,
0.019799564,
-0.0637136698,
0.040478684,
0.0212868303,
0.0281895623,
0.0500093885,
0.0395740643,
0.027747184,
0.0273915827,
0.0007660587,
-0.0249298811,
-0.0396010168,
0.0007507709,
0.0602328368,
0.0435176827,
0.0153067792,
-0.0629209802,
0.0097122071,
-0.0181985945,
-0.0320864059,
-0.0175887961,
-0.0656820163,
0.0934470445,
0.031075174,
0.0004010844,
0.0311316941,
-0.0124758845,
-0.0221338812,
-0.0239374712,
-0.0275312606,
-0.0232122373,
-0.0029953076,
-0.0139585333,
-0.0213852134,
0.0120698847,
0.0070594922,
-0.0163322017,
-0.0042698234,
0.0229621623,
-0.0166320279,
0.0354638323,
0.0026639914,
0.0068702954,
-0.0095053976,
-0.0040826579,
0.0186733957,
-0.0049720122,
0.0160901099,
0.0291949883,
0.0280046314,
0.0211366117,
-0.0245712996,
-0.0125660999,
-0.0491796136,
-0.0204043984,
-0.0223146901,
0.0223549791,
0.0385485403,
0.0149706192,
-0.0498795658,
0.026539322,
0.002327336,
0.0312780701,
-0.0185554326,
0.0483653285,
0.0045035174,
0.0483902134,
-0.0675555915,
-0.0466761105,
-0.0633456931,
0.0547831133,
0.1003954411,
-0.0801631436,
-0.0468293242,
0.0037643479,
2.971e-7,
0.0906442776,
0.0503976159,
0.0440595895,
0.0710281059,
0.0278106667,
-0.0052614976,
0.0143877137,
0.0175883807,
0.0261362065,
-0.0100417184,
0.0163622536,
0.0254086182,
0.022517439,
0.0170263369,
-0.0649438351,
-0.0393953621,
-0.063617371,
-0.0104572289,
-0.011425809,
0.0224500336,
0.0468615964,
0.0918255448,
-0.0169675909,
0.0082830014,
0.026629068,
0.0075812214,
0.0532027408,
-0.0382941999,
0.052994553,
-0.0018500391,
0.0293305721,
-0.0242433865,
-0.0035282238,
-0.0061428011,
-0.0308553223,
0.0082395989,
-0.01224468,
0.0363797843,
-0.0242048595,
-0.0469952896,
0.0001335284,
0.0080470005,
0.0060467236,
-0.0558797456,
0.0125495987,
-0.0905109942,
-0.0328231044,
0.0039632735,
0.0205028933,
-0.0152994348,
0.0185529366,
-0.0052573867,
-0.010471548,
0.010738153,
0.0109611982,
-0.0122770676,
-0.0120549034,
-0.0662082732,
-0.0350741968,
-0.0223750733,
-0.0496572517,
-0.00691379,
-0.0819027573,
-0.0739874467,
0.0375441983,
0.0215506647,
-0.0151541708,
2.515899539e-34,
0.0339175612,
-0.0095222984,
0.0219238736,
0.0231909584,
0.0361380577,
-0.0206339322,
0.0797384605,
0.0223422274,
0.0089618023,
-0.0845560133,
-0.0391242653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13413v1 | Syntactic Knowledge via Graph Attention with BERT in Machine Translation | 2023-05-22T18:56:14 | 2023-05-22T18:56:14 | Yuqian Dai, Serge Sharoff, Marc de Kamps | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although the Transformer model can effectively acquire context features via a
self-attention mechanism, deeper syntactic knowledge is still not effectively
modeled. To alleviate the above problem, we propose Syntactic knowledge via
Graph attention with BERT (SGB) in Machine Translation (MT) scenarios. Graph
Attention Network (GAT) and BERT jointly represent syntactic dependency feature
as explicit knowledge of the source language to enrich source language
representations and guide target language generation. Our experiments use gold
syntax-annotation sentences and Quality Estimation (QE) model to obtain
interpretability of translation quality improvement regarding syntactic
knowledge without being limited to a BLEU score. Experiments show that the
proposed SGB engines improve translation quality across the three MT tasks
without sacrificing BLEU scores. We investigate what length of source sentences
benefits the most and what dependencies are better identified by the SGB
engines. We also find that learning of specific dependency relations by GAT can
be reflected in the translation quality containing such relations and that
syntax on the graph leads to new modeling of syntactic aspects of source
sentences in the middle and bottom layers of BERT. | [
0.0377456211,
-0.0006136363,
-0.0033771358,
0.0530712083,
-0.0240706932,
-0.0062462962,
-0.0072388002,
-0.0071985098,
0.0234668385,
-0.0339617208,
-0.0281483736,
-0.0031445508,
0.0091488492,
0.03411844,
0.0648975596,
-0.0635103136,
0.028937852,
0.0281015392,
0.0060800971,
0.0145184118,
0.0206428748,
0.0142781911,
0.0503414273,
0.0296438839,
-0.0459152982,
0.0076165795,
0.0169820618,
0.0679960027,
0.0241922624,
-0.0101471618,
0.0044543683,
0.0461286753,
0.0002953941,
0.0406115018,
0.0000018959,
-0.0414090008,
-0.0401448011,
0.0021350197,
-0.0031381357,
0.0041333614,
-0.0108729349,
-0.0527081937,
0.0149420025,
0.0235480014,
-0.0294792727,
-0.0080020493,
0.0458122157,
0.0174598508,
0.0779405162,
0.0618878417,
-0.0317812227,
-0.026172163,
-0.006583354,
-0.0353133343,
-0.0039883028,
-0.038820371,
-0.0322987884,
0.0197624508,
-0.0216809101,
-0.0082436157,
-0.0350015908,
0.0408333689,
0.0347536653,
-0.023508748,
0.0608345941,
0.0196761284,
-0.0707458034,
0.0055460623,
-0.0004988157,
0.0852413327,
-0.0304241721,
-0.0407183841,
-0.0190832373,
0.0106178597,
0.006387657,
-0.0135470377,
-0.0519890152,
0.0067617442,
-0.0130393347,
0.0186579004,
0.0042723399,
-0.0126969004,
0.0270878784,
-0.0506514423,
-0.0172671136,
0.0594951659,
0.0136469956,
-0.0063011963,
-0.0136579918,
0.0299497247,
-0.0748416856,
-0.0368249565,
0.0356456041,
0.0018425784,
-0.0102588814,
0.013339567,
-0.0577560924,
-0.0455820598,
-0.011769007,
-0.0489985012,
0.0332293771,
0.0487311371,
-0.0335065089,
0.0144454213,
-0.0309527218,
0.0825317204,
-0.036327742,
0.0205764323,
-0.0738007575,
0.0019977223,
-0.0401789285,
0.0295645092,
-0.0812030435,
0.0227418933,
-0.006917607,
-0.0331331864,
-0.0376418456,
0.026138477,
0.0219917689,
0.015673073,
0.0341048762,
0.0171335656,
-0.0708462894,
-0.0282183923,
0.0114810541,
0.0402118266,
-0.0094817569,
-0.0386788212,
0.0068434319,
-0.0302280858,
-0.0427220501,
0.0549765229,
0.0499100313,
-0.0304181203,
-0.0249612834,
0.0669288635,
0.0206959397,
-0.0244720168,
-0.0253838003,
-0.0088756345,
-0.0512049086,
-0.0301577132,
0.0247183386,
-0.0515195131,
0.0191460401,
0.0160891861,
-0.0206437949,
-0.0097041111,
0.0367265604,
-0.0167726092,
-0.0297487434,
0.0164693799,
0.0098715043,
-0.0258590896,
-0.0015561895,
-0.0324697644,
-0.0405323543,
0.0286278334,
0.045388516,
0.0379936509,
0.0136327641,
-0.0042716078,
-0.0138820345,
0.0220268723,
0.0283561368,
0.0373888202,
-0.0263546836,
-0.0206654463,
-0.0135730235,
0.0061935154,
0.0472658239,
0.0722690374,
-0.0205151513,
-0.0008207693,
0.071589537,
0.0065067713,
0.0169896986,
0.0503580011,
0.0629440621,
0.0464025922,
-0.0386129245,
0.059075024,
-0.0505064502,
0.03727879,
0.0077026305,
0.0291324537,
0.0155938081,
0.0008819083,
0.0069456287,
-0.0262692273,
-0.0162881576,
-0.04106557,
0.0403371565,
-0.0374177247,
0.0319413915,
0.0500675924,
-0.0635679066,
0.0821962729,
0.0104329064,
-0.0571267642,
0.0050817137,
-0.0086648464,
-0.0378909856,
0.0602518059,
0.0464638472,
0.0344332196,
-0.065112628,
-0.018393334,
-0.042019479,
0.0295722038,
0.0202677045,
0.0248050485,
0.0439208336,
-0.0393212549,
-0.0197333731,
-0.0523533225,
0.0019478517,
0.0256662164,
-0.0250770394,
-0.0337279215,
0.0388752483,
-0.0884291157,
-0.0397650488,
0.0192384683,
0.0427575074,
-0.0007943822,
0.0059842151,
0.0131930616,
0.0195654668,
0.0055416357,
-0.0078637991,
0.0330393985,
0.0093285898,
-0.050146997,
-0.0012128538,
0.0565686412,
-0.0557037704,
-0.0848722085,
-0.0029195698,
-0.0363135561,
-0.0008468278,
0.005540445,
-0.015289099,
-0.072527498,
0.0197578706,
-0.1054596826,
0.0638464317,
0.0022189729,
0.0064833513,
-0.0049295868,
0.0261561833,
-0.0078857709,
0.0701190159,
0.0013492536,
-0.0066657858,
-0.0055036331,
0.0100067016,
0.0559545308,
-0.0248341709,
0.0320199244,
0.005253036,
0.0196920522,
0.0128377071,
0.07698825,
0.0340279937,
-0.0514685288,
0.0063402434,
-0.1033813283,
0.0200370345,
-0.043737065,
0.0584756285,
0.0645093918,
0.0387776792,
0.0066740485,
-0.0173787382,
-0.0353650227,
0.0218035858,
-0.0130155087,
-0.0090434644,
0.0393205285,
0.0026023036,
-0.0104920631,
-0.046413824,
-0.0114650419,
-0.0079815118,
0.0536273047,
0.0502593741,
-0.0360895023,
-0.0285418648,
0.0456114486,
-0.0322376937,
0.0155990859,
0.0319443792,
-0.0773478076,
0.0010860073,
-0.0115576973,
0.0603242218,
0.067781724,
-0.0169984214,
0.0129955327,
0.041719269,
-0.0164539423,
-0.0397297442,
0.0135414731,
-0.0341267064,
0.0072778254,
-0.0190445036,
-0.0491117388,
0.0438475274,
0.0459300205,
0.0269114263,
-0.0160013754,
-0.0799978748,
-0.0243355352,
-0.0026276531,
-0.0008115078,
0.0307399221,
-0.0092333416,
-0.020002082,
-0.0104993451,
-0.0491155721,
-0.0506728105,
0.0806184635,
-0.0394394696,
-0.0200426932,
-0.0303312633,
0.0356922969,
-0.025602622,
0.0457747318,
0.0517321788,
0.0417654291,
-0.0332274735,
-0.0632517189,
-0.0357538462,
0.023991378,
0.0384344533,
0.0053664213,
0.012374606,
-0.0584709235,
0.0076049645,
0.0084839603,
-0.0019410434,
-0.0137639837,
0.0296063945,
0.0009076653,
0.0234135259,
0.0272242725,
-0.0260036625,
0.0205396581,
-0.0165546685,
0.0202350393,
0.0451501533,
-0.0335312225,
-0.002231268,
-0.013996481,
0.041080121,
-0.0017000868,
-0.014639724,
0.018864939,
-0.0272401217,
-0.0093100481,
0.020160893,
0.0179468095,
0.0009270219,
-0.0502461158,
-0.0105746305,
0.0107778488,
-0.0025443418,
-0.0831280872,
-0.0127175376,
0.0634707287,
-0.0693365186,
-0.0340554863,
0.0986937433,
0.0278510693,
-0.0048026452,
0.0081198616,
-0.026250571,
0.0543409996,
0.0108296992,
0.0205964558,
-0.0764758661,
-0.0280242842,
-0.0151994582,
0.0309548341,
0.0249774661,
-0.0091297282,
-0.0169892628,
-0.0738666654,
0.0248508118,
0.0390286595,
-0.0053616804,
-0.0490130149,
-0.0118173854,
-0.0111500043,
0.0247900039,
0.0218329374,
-0.0313221999,
0.0226673875,
0.0080200499,
0.0185384993,
-0.0210582968,
-0.0364103392,
-0.0085046832,
-0.0408753641,
-0.0046514864,
0.0640619919,
0.0628946647,
0.0012115939,
0.0083827805,
0.033948388,
0.0016868599,
-0.0050534853,
-0.0004458695,
0.0537567139,
-0.0011890731,
-0.0131074237,
-0.0029017678,
-0.0136308223,
-0.0157235283,
0.0204247758,
-0.0218868144,
0.0506850071,
-0.0107733244,
-0.0124469651,
0.0237103757,
-0.0190502219,
-0.0304646604,
0.0303359032,
0.0790324509,
-0.0216917731,
-0.0298190303,
-0.0431876741,
0.0303011313,
-0.1140391231,
0.0222819708,
0.0328433588,
-0.048448775,
-0.0434629619,
-0.1026340425,
-0.0762032866,
0.013972288,
0.0205178577,
-0.0084533868,
-0.0113400239,
0.030846471,
-0.0102925431,
-0.0024584967,
0.028559966,
-0.0071935789,
-0.0170904137,
-0.031518735,
-0.0138251279,
-0.0076219887,
-0.0063888524,
-0.0000623028,
0.0190510601,
-0.0557641797,
-0.0664055422,
-0.016476579,
0.0458875112,
0.0144700222,
0.0571544953,
-0.0507012531,
-0.0140345059,
-0.021277247,
0.0062776757,
-0.0146558098,
-0.0097446721,
0.0480744876,
-0.0094372015,
0.0139706861,
0.0550961941,
-0.0414855443,
0.0029141027,
-0.0002286685,
0.0690020323,
0.0016596664,
-0.0502869301,
0.0504315123,
0.0504033677,
0.0233808737,
-0.0134887146,
0.0302194525,
-0.0254758187,
0.0105473176,
-0.0296076015,
-0.0008164004,
-0.0677839443,
-0.0025701991,
0.0227105953,
-0.0017556438,
0.0031513732,
-0.004933848,
-0.0292621702,
-0.0019262026,
-0.0112287002,
0.0163435079,
-0.0296880305,
-0.0114423232,
0.0262065567,
0.0061512203,
-0.0308409333,
-0.0169488192,
0.0284386799,
0.0107777584,
-0.0305454247,
0.036552079,
0.017098831,
-0.0329777859,
-0.0021521875,
0.0202649422,
-0.0293486994,
0.0029593376,
-0.0300606061,
-0.0147100063,
0.0829853565,
-0.0200789981,
0.130982548,
-0.0259383041,
-0.0084855305,
-0.0225706156,
0.0841480792,
0.0104068676,
-0.0577920415,
0.0006548145,
-0.0171647537,
-0.0045231101,
0.0250679087,
0.0810495093,
0.0233831555,
0.0008747737,
0.0014754346,
-0.0453990772,
-0.047370933,
-0.0183226801,
0.0074168839,
-0.0296768248,
0.0047258693,
0.0335533917,
-0.0204172526,
-0.073070161,
0.0306974202,
-0.0082408665,
0.0161828604,
-0.0243817549,
0.0468188189,
0.0706748068,
-0.0185939185,
-0.0336116739,
-0.045496285,
0.0266950503,
0.0000502491,
0.0158576854,
-0.029171275,
-6.095575915e-33,
-0.0367837846,
-0.0560664311,
-0.0410898961,
-0.006841185,
-0.0259031244,
0.0127998907,
-0.086798735,
-0.0241013635,
-0.0113579631,
0.0412910208,
0.0065433276,
0.0228458308,
0.0010672038,
0.0229330268,
-0.0067794062,
-0.0206698086,
0.0515608862,
0.0180022251,
-0.0415876396,
0.0463373177,
0.0364412963,
0.0370479152,
0.0891835466,
0.0057951286,
0.0123736197,
-0.0209528152,
-0.0000168355,
0.0081835808,
0.0263867583,
0.0338443927,
0.0264208261,
0.0498698056,
0.032302931,
0.0079894876,
-0.0446337685,
0.0049533444,
-0.060837768,
-0.0355610549,
-0.0010132567,
0.0257778037,
-0.0587230437,
-0.0363962054,
0.0893587396,
-0.0354075395,
0.0116301877,
-0.0275262929,
0.0134025216,
-0.0218532607,
-0.0421024524,
-0.0172200799,
-0.0634388551,
0.0129343942,
-0.0144491363,
-0.017384382,
0.0068700518,
0.0617260672,
-0.0146139618,
-0.0284100585,
-0.0112472065,
-0.0016978217,
-0.0504245311,
0.0383050404,
0.0401995294,
0.0058624288,
-0.0103259571,
-0.0012404977,
-0.0211615413,
-0.0177138709,
0.0129574789,
-0.0139890807,
0.0225998238,
0.035336677,
0.0337464549,
-0.0065474752,
-0.0385381207,
-0.0062882504,
-0.0694019571,
0.0237913933,
0.0074496041,
0.059457209,
-0.0081466595,
0.0241598506,
-0.0116182072,
-0.0317704491,
-0.0260009505,
0.0037903471,
-0.0123375673,
-0.028383309,
0.0022228819,
-0.024842985,
-0.013211064,
-0.0105167776,
0.0553866848,
-0.0054273354,
0.0212298464,
0.0371291637,
-0.0307297371,
0.0284416638,
0.0034598326,
0.0667674318,
-0.0488315225,
0.0028347932,
0.00894986,
0.0175021626,
0.0149658164,
0.004041248,
0.0636055097,
0.0151995048,
-0.0264605284,
0.0102590835,
-0.0916568562,
-0.0182560924,
-0.0532019772,
-0.024749957,
0.0391564816,
-0.0113808401,
-0.0152414013,
0.0794919953,
0.0176269636,
0.0538467765,
-0.0377552547,
0.0330401585,
0.0011082334,
0.0602043793,
-0.0743111446,
-0.0068352902,
-0.0287370551,
0.0777491778,
0.0222393386,
-0.0470804311,
-0.0524755977,
-0.0094128046,
2.758e-7,
0.092896089,
0.0704559684,
0.029189596,
0.0052431533,
0.0105600152,
0.0374954119,
-0.0259111039,
0.0529532805,
0.004365514,
0.0124481432,
0.0231045168,
0.0098001333,
0.0155952889,
0.0117628295,
-0.074260056,
0.0248691477,
-0.0731881633,
-0.0136604207,
-0.0239693187,
0.0018566145,
0.0630098656,
0.0530469641,
-0.0112033123,
0.0278932769,
0.0069669229,
-0.0545430258,
0.0680145547,
0.0036217587,
-0.0525184833,
-0.0000236607,
0.0357541777,
0.0223241989,
-0.0597802028,
-0.00397101,
-0.0249007158,
0.0034848789,
0.0261452589,
0.039531149,
-0.012709382,
-0.002324905,
0.0199766662,
-0.0146290381,
0.0116379755,
-0.0479151383,
0.0393825248,
-0.0579049811,
-0.0394349955,
0.0332046263,
-0.0378930122,
0.0352647416,
-0.0081553841,
-0.0149074197,
-0.0651593208,
-0.0007049912,
0.0333801731,
-0.0216356888,
-0.018274568,
-0.0162103474,
-0.0363346562,
0.0316275321,
0.0013530755,
-0.017539734,
-0.0253179707,
0.0005854677,
0.0055399747,
-0.0155901536,
-0.008306792,
2.763245132e-34,
0.0362997875,
-0.0268250834,
0.0387491174,
-0.0128405783,
0.0513260439,
-0.046331659,
-0.0470179878,
0.0105197737,
0.0282394346,
-0.0439122505,
-0.0341624916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13412v1 | Element-aware Summarization with Large Language Models: Expert-aligned Evaluation and Chain-of-Thought Method | 2023-05-22T18:54:35 | 2023-05-22T18:54:35 | Yiming Wang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic summarization generates concise summaries that contain key ideas of
source documents. As the most mainstream datasets for the news sub-domain,
CNN/DailyMail and BBC XSum have been widely used for performance benchmarking.
However, the reference summaries of those datasets turn out to be noisy, mainly
in terms of factual hallucination and information redundancy. To address this
challenge, we first annotate new expert-writing Element-aware test sets
following the "Lasswell Communication Model" proposed by Lasswell (1948),
allowing reference summaries to focus on more fine-grained news elements
objectively and comprehensively. Utilizing the new test sets, we observe the
surprising zero-shot summary ability of LLMs, which addresses the issue of the
inconsistent results between human preference and automatic evaluation metrics
of LLMs' zero-shot summaries in prior work. Further, we propose a Summary
Chain-of-Thought (SumCoT) technique to elicit LLMs to generate summaries step
by step, which helps them integrate more fine-grained details of source
documents into the final summaries that correlate with the human writing
mindset. Experimental results show our method outperforms state-of-the-art
fine-tuned PLMs and zero-shot LLMs by +4.33/+4.77 in ROUGE-L on the two
datasets, respectively. Dataset and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/Alsace08/SumCoT. | [
0.0678052381,
0.0040483787,
0.0357529372,
0.0065698866,
-0.0272677504,
0.0079596518,
-0.0204896573,
-0.0112867979,
0.0084209433,
-0.0563704297,
-0.0092154546,
0.0030487534,
0.0072293966,
0.0110932495,
0.0060483394,
-0.0490396619,
0.012060714,
-0.0166089516,
0.0333205611,
-0.0176190473,
0.055715695,
0.0174080469,
0.0359766483,
0.0098678386,
0.0115383016,
0.0223155972,
0.0006839163,
0.0084779104,
0.0585093684,
-0.0089618657,
-0.0015747208,
0.0666080415,
0.0419181176,
0.0199488625,
0.0000020398,
-0.0299445502,
-0.0033505459,
0.0078093437,
0.0284160692,
0.0228465293,
0.0133084888,
-0.0617461838,
0.0225266851,
-0.0131384758,
-0.009777721,
0.0180931035,
0.0020152514,
0.0717197731,
0.0940171182,
0.0916095749,
-0.0164497569,
0.0017202565,
0.0621239543,
-0.0148316734,
0.0047862339,
-0.0375824049,
0.01475247,
0.0085493401,
-0.0052117528,
0.0032591212,
0.0313016884,
0.0298999585,
-0.0018539461,
-0.0228205994,
0.013713751,
0.0132911187,
-0.052354157,
-0.0107820332,
0.0094537707,
0.0580732524,
0.0216858685,
-0.0063337428,
0.0374084562,
0.0110623874,
0.0034400441,
0.0301260035,
-0.0682292879,
0.0416855067,
-0.0235878248,
0.0000219748,
-0.0013444661,
0.0249095578,
-0.0083379289,
0.0611845516,
-0.0108999833,
0.0491666347,
-0.0134804854,
-0.0131285181,
-0.0267415121,
0.042235285,
-0.0046108374,
-0.0632729232,
0.0026979407,
0.028730059,
-0.0142989056,
-0.0384213142,
-0.0494968444,
-0.0768848732,
0.0134200202,
-0.0467804484,
0.0039165877,
0.0093170544,
0.0121954922,
0.0540528521,
-0.0087332092,
-0.0168678313,
0.0154232411,
-0.0031038241,
-0.0360003859,
-0.0119957849,
-0.0292226262,
0.0151082268,
-0.0067758947,
0.0666161329,
-0.0186133683,
-0.0269442908,
-0.0298307929,
-0.0094053904,
-0.0205687769,
0.0152150253,
-0.0403449237,
0.0099101486,
-0.0068799034,
-0.0291374493,
-0.0249426086,
0.0356924646,
-0.0377790369,
-0.0103759151,
0.0384320095,
0.0109621147,
-0.0227813832,
0.0315943621,
-0.0068511069,
0.0070858728,
-0.0098353494,
0.0174484272,
-0.0486840233,
-0.0111181727,
-0.0145717235,
-0.0448503792,
-0.0081106676,
-0.069380261,
0.0223253202,
-0.1078809276,
0.0160743389,
0.0113414489,
-0.0148588661,
-0.0377984382,
-0.0094361054,
0.0310096499,
-0.0673385635,
-0.0065594865,
-0.0389185511,
-0.0068449983,
0.0364305191,
0.0161206275,
0.0182209238,
0.0712684542,
0.0578338578,
0.0682641342,
0.0280169286,
0.0375326313,
0.0201797299,
-0.0045722821,
0.0031910941,
0.0360051058,
0.0226320662,
-0.0084600188,
-0.0773294568,
0.0329882838,
0.0334229283,
0.049608279,
-0.0404683091,
0.036690928,
0.0873489454,
0.0322443694,
-0.0053558312,
0.0193525311,
0.0173182003,
0.0530170761,
0.0596043468,
0.0943295211,
-0.0173577182,
0.0705362707,
-0.0607326515,
0.0429885313,
0.0869932473,
0.0323144719,
-0.0417527854,
-0.0310361758,
0.0067768353,
0.0229700822,
-0.0020731138,
0.0053563146,
0.0226014163,
-0.0115727158,
-0.023067072,
0.0489680842,
0.0217379946,
-0.0576876737,
0.0219456702,
0.0015331574,
0.029049648,
0.0250010658,
0.0343493745,
-0.0230252929,
-0.0035730847,
-0.0134602319,
0.0325811133,
0.0407151058,
0.0234736837,
0.0103381043,
-0.0504003465,
-0.0452433191,
-0.0478621386,
-0.0468513146,
0.0180120282,
-0.0090218578,
-0.016927084,
-0.0255866628,
0.0394881256,
0.0182605851,
-0.0785790011,
0.0136749772,
-0.0210859608,
0.0233870205,
-0.0176121425,
-0.0178765431,
-0.0157893077,
0.0402838737,
-0.0148588791,
0.0146660833,
0.0026180269,
-0.0191461202,
-0.0057314131,
-0.0210410804,
-0.0193057377,
-0.0278386418,
0.0195033178,
-0.1169937253,
-0.0167576857,
0.0296649169,
-0.0295251701,
-0.0681487322,
0.002734405,
-0.0577734746,
-0.0265930742,
-0.0399408154,
-0.0091348318,
0.028244976,
-0.0109870741,
-0.025324868,
0.0630436838,
-0.0240752604,
-0.0044237012,
0.0629787371,
-0.0510668866,
-0.0068814866,
-0.0378168225,
-0.0310467388,
-0.0103025679,
0.0225636195,
0.0370755866,
0.0566121414,
0.0078286305,
-0.0299605411,
-0.0499414392,
-0.0950847715,
0.0063352911,
-0.0165109187,
-0.0002404223,
0.0415708125,
-0.0152507117,
-0.0018857029,
0.0266238675,
-0.0546750352,
0.006549133,
0.0028022444,
0.0170613825,
0.0294590853,
0.0265160836,
0.0509133264,
-0.0370460264,
-0.0128561212,
-0.0061728735,
0.0410998352,
0.0227552224,
-0.0420241356,
-0.0223878529,
0.0307340901,
-0.0568602346,
-0.048953291,
-0.0144254547,
-0.0026113864,
-0.0210523158,
-0.006683494,
0.0192139875,
0.0245068204,
0.0410904363,
0.0269669089,
0.056443844,
0.020877488,
-0.0068442556,
-0.0032171581,
-0.0335758626,
0.037890587,
0.010874847,
-0.04038468,
0.0160319451,
0.0212979112,
0.0100153694,
0.0017076778,
-0.0303496178,
0.0478543825,
0.0019516456,
-0.0238776579,
-0.0574314855,
-0.0190276466,
0.0178492703,
0.0696561709,
-0.0411414914,
-0.018534217,
0.0701773539,
-0.0177847836,
0.0430782028,
-0.0357252471,
-0.013066953,
-0.0716685057,
0.0075674136,
-0.0116386926,
0.0237859432,
-0.0191949904,
0.0171000604,
-0.0779081956,
-0.0135752894,
0.0506677441,
-0.0252824053,
0.0842123628,
-0.0187652707,
0.0187653974,
-0.039591182,
-0.0130267954,
0.0112478258,
-0.0447537005,
-0.0297034401,
0.0344483778,
0.0422140881,
-0.0357104354,
-0.0489312373,
0.0117450319,
0.0906129479,
0.0546683818,
-0.0479368232,
-0.0179123264,
-0.0074982769,
0.0567918196,
0.0597827323,
-0.0013766184,
0.0425998606,
-0.0487751327,
0.0099388007,
0.0738347247,
-0.0056234854,
-0.0000135812,
0.022433294,
-0.0160712637,
0.0048755812,
-0.054170806,
-0.0072946334,
-0.027701987,
0.0510129891,
-0.0497026294,
0.0106236869,
0.0992730856,
0.0155153098,
-0.0763455182,
-0.0329671912,
0.0144949136,
0.0439966135,
0.0022209147,
0.0044124564,
-0.0752377883,
-0.0096027963,
0.0103102755,
0.0202971529,
0.0114149312,
-0.0435712188,
0.003828268,
-0.0661656857,
0.021630263,
0.0093702152,
-0.0385379083,
-0.0183340292,
-0.0172337275,
0.0173375383,
0.0029945299,
-0.0217251685,
0.0141142951,
-0.0098651722,
0.0041299239,
0.0013197279,
-0.0624751598,
-0.0028221982,
-0.0181438476,
-0.0337696709,
-0.0089431647,
0.022718573,
0.0550543182,
-0.0273034535,
0.015594678,
0.0092883408,
-0.0011491118,
0.000575328,
-0.0033732634,
0.0792028457,
-0.026924789,
0.0216584299,
-0.0361015536,
0.0458626114,
0.0351695605,
-0.0041235397,
-0.0041092029,
0.0250041392,
-0.0085395332,
-0.0286463257,
-0.0589348152,
0.04607445,
-0.0136841517,
0.0802420303,
0.0395531878,
-0.0097072292,
-0.0234156325,
-0.03731535,
-0.0131168989,
-0.0518197864,
-0.0597673282,
0.0045289714,
-0.0161413569,
-0.0218410734,
-0.0758475214,
-0.0650315359,
0.0011466902,
0.0018262697,
-0.005769968,
0.0036224849,
-0.0185580514,
-0.0109083857,
-0.0154217919,
0.0230682418,
0.0020898078,
-0.0089684231,
-0.0151334153,
-0.0001776466,
0.0292613395,
-0.0368831344,
-0.0248125922,
0.044908151,
-0.0879864544,
-0.0515577644,
-0.046280086,
0.0334209241,
0.0225997586,
0.0479373597,
0.0244497936,
-0.0612495728,
0.0685435683,
0.0514531769,
-0.002639595,
0.0434605405,
0.0151179675,
0.0235956963,
-0.0141509688,
0.0241625048,
-0.05024058,
0.0326820947,
-0.0183265042,
0.0568466224,
-0.0120043727,
-0.0492185913,
0.002901437,
0.0197612178,
-0.0058981106,
-0.0425917879,
0.0127514536,
-0.0226551984,
-0.0206637103,
-0.0198982619,
-0.0340726003,
-0.0437147468,
0.019072799,
-0.0333359912,
-0.003186041,
0.0095796697,
0.0901486948,
0.0118629672,
0.0306156985,
-0.0634689331,
-0.0056318264,
-0.0363284387,
-0.0252398197,
-0.0344636999,
-0.0071168942,
-0.0671890825,
0.0003734512,
-0.0516081788,
-0.0130150514,
0.0163906366,
0.0029478276,
0.0435116924,
0.0039719194,
0.0093478756,
0.0241459534,
-0.1102819443,
-0.0157084893,
-0.0555327907,
0.0095444247,
0.0531626865,
-0.0359672904,
0.0729978085,
-0.0293946601,
-0.0193548277,
-0.03240465,
0.0364008322,
0.0061283777,
0.02732886,
-0.0145929791,
0.021928452,
0.0041644839,
0.0051025334,
0.0981031135,
-0.0260673612,
-0.0099433921,
0.0325332731,
-0.0375142507,
-0.0208963938,
-0.0474380739,
-0.016491022,
0.0485306121,
0.0133904684,
-0.0408238545,
-0.0692804903,
-0.0164948534,
0.0403580666,
-0.002188704,
0.0065549714,
-0.0391724408,
0.0320454314,
0.0456690788,
-0.0025457386,
0.023407368,
-0.0379909389,
-0.0275291149,
-0.0004232086,
-0.0233803708,
-0.0097814268,
-6.646560974e-33,
-0.0235632416,
-0.0217121616,
-0.0058158925,
0.0241394844,
-0.0199756473,
0.0426782221,
-0.0640623569,
0.0004841525,
-0.004646441,
0.0508562215,
-0.0165120736,
-0.005276911,
-0.000125434,
0.0320573822,
-0.0023100756,
0.0322861522,
0.0191076193,
0.0032615955,
-0.0418883972,
0.0352483541,
0.0345865898,
0.0021279824,
0.0695522949,
-0.0513039641,
0.0531377345,
-0.0363527462,
-0.0373127125,
-0.017020233,
0.0611920878,
0.0079195835,
-0.0019220486,
0.0210125539,
0.0380549394,
-0.0453443564,
-0.045040451,
-0.0132060694,
-0.0447638854,
-0.0227431245,
0.0555494316,
-0.0852864012,
-0.0405706167,
-0.0187264737,
0.043765001,
-0.0011466433,
-0.0039073266,
-0.0651061833,
0.0648775548,
-0.0303362012,
-0.0262710247,
-0.0825806782,
-0.0206188299,
0.0361498594,
-0.0247251485,
-0.0062772767,
0.0164357889,
0.0279880222,
0.0065106987,
0.000684565,
-0.0586613715,
0.0505011752,
0.0428811274,
0.0399777256,
0.046888005,
-0.0239182394,
-0.0232259221,
0.0685226619,
-0.0107840467,
0.0121627217,
-0.0577010699,
0.0146637075,
0.0019744895,
0.0149547746,
0.0506472625,
0.0636242554,
0.0241859481,
0.0490499176,
-0.0534300655,
0.0817629173,
-0.0072376011,
0.0394667611,
0.0373814628,
-0.00480123,
0.0126022296,
-0.0210761614,
-0.0222814921,
0.0196762551,
-0.0246102139,
-0.0179361943,
-0.0351903848,
0.0228961352,
-0.03665521,
0.0082378546,
0.0268233251,
-0.0097668935,
0.0080267796,
0.0295083225,
-0.048718255,
0.0616331846,
0.0218101554,
-0.0209217481,
-0.0626055524,
0.0351827033,
0.0092806481,
0.0211133435,
0.0013564732,
0.0126804169,
0.0587237664,
-0.0085188709,
-0.0084908353,
-0.0063281907,
-0.02193789,
0.0072015813,
-0.040410962,
-0.011743959,
-0.0161813423,
0.0061477432,
0.0014208432,
0.0252827909,
-0.003065692,
0.0167708267,
0.0095586693,
0.003288338,
0.0301131625,
0.0190467574,
0.0086362408,
0.0291835833,
-0.0102055436,
-0.0308592953,
0.0553356111,
-0.0206401814,
-0.0101541039,
-0.0099451737,
2.78e-7,
0.0203768592,
0.0294534191,
0.0170506947,
0.0139336586,
-0.0163327642,
0.0299593881,
-0.0184836481,
0.0619519204,
0.0175344143,
-0.0501920506,
0.0444398858,
0.0683777928,
0.0506443046,
0.0334435739,
-0.104271315,
-0.0447736084,
-0.0822709724,
-0.0277346633,
-0.0394008085,
-0.0248475298,
0.0273351837,
0.0251103733,
-0.0026143007,
-0.0170281325,
-0.0032400053,
-0.020165639,
0.0681465864,
-0.03683348,
-0.0506792329,
0.0384883881,
0.0838569254,
0.0085815936,
-0.0218151957,
-0.002708131,
-0.0164634753,
-0.0291177481,
0.0694888011,
0.039848201,
0.0274779182,
-0.0019121643,
0.0224283859,
-0.0108992243,
0.0364282094,
0.0084009189,
0.0449373908,
-0.0386807509,
-0.025375545,
-0.0389833078,
-0.0438436754,
-0.0160969626,
0.0039845421,
-0.0139888758,
-0.0191349518,
0.0490404554,
-0.0171332657,
-0.0060416991,
0.0028490592,
-0.0467401445,
-0.0508639291,
0.0387997702,
-0.0114654219,
-0.0578049161,
-0.0251883008,
-0.0318257436,
-0.0122120809,
-0.0896957815,
0.0051832921,
2.812946732e-34,
0.0902028456,
-0.00830431,
-0.0421463586,
0.0162088424,
0.0189158507,
0.0019244547,
-0.0509069376,
-0.0201118756,
0.0136791021,
-0.0752350464,
0.0012960287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13408v1 | Modular Domain Adaptation for Conformer-Based Streaming ASR | 2023-05-22T18:49:35 | 2023-05-22T18:49:35 | Qiujia Li, Bo Li, Dongseong Hwang, Tara N. Sainath, Pedro M. Mengibar | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Speech data from different domains has distinct acoustic and linguistic
characteristics. It is common to train a single multidomain model such as a
Conformer transducer for speech recognition on a mixture of data from all
domains. However, changing data in one domain or adding a new domain would
require the multidomain model to be retrained. To this end, we propose a
framework called modular domain adaptation (MDA) that enables a single model to
process multidomain data while keeping all parameters domain-specific, i.e.,
each parameter is only trained by data from one domain. On a streaming
Conformer transducer trained only on video caption data, experimental results
show that an MDA-based model can reach similar performance as the multidomain
model on other domains such as voice search and dictation by adding per-domain
adapters and per-domain feed-forward networks in the Conformer encoder. | [
-0.0169030167,
0.0192143302,
0.0029258425,
-0.015339327,
0.0293642897,
0.0075285123,
0.0475368723,
-0.0356068313,
-0.0394699648,
-0.0202431306,
-0.058333151,
-0.0534721762,
0.021701647,
0.0481395125,
0.0004928,
-0.0411163755,
0.0066353069,
-0.0439072214,
-0.015178062,
-0.0324723087,
-0.0015377838,
-0.0073902165,
-0.0406483896,
0.010820007,
0.0109006278,
0.0525197089,
-0.0108621623,
-0.0053383783,
0.0214383956,
-0.0062422967,
-0.0230386984,
0.0053365342,
0.0868479609,
0.016119102,
0.0000017841,
-0.0124048358,
-0.06362544,
0.014947569,
-0.0256134402,
-0.023417566,
0.0134183196,
-0.0374655239,
-0.0112682981,
0.0600591525,
-0.0144792283,
-0.0670663565,
0.0754790753,
0.0168574899,
0.0023590056,
0.0682376921,
-0.0236059688,
-0.0709524527,
-0.0062776143,
-0.0203467906,
-0.084121801,
-0.0501998812,
0.0160591267,
0.0185665488,
0.0096036252,
-0.0274993889,
-0.067471683,
0.0469742268,
0.0031205767,
-0.0025634312,
0.0176746063,
-0.0219967999,
0.0241003633,
-0.0254510306,
-0.0072613619,
0.0203858595,
0.0713385269,
-0.0117426338,
0.0075130113,
0.0061117555,
-0.0110422121,
0.0299310815,
-0.0177127384,
-0.010356375,
0.0031778093,
-0.0190329328,
-0.0332104936,
0.0039505349,
-0.0038132456,
-0.0295878332,
-0.0622350499,
0.000349084,
0.0056182146,
0.0147909876,
-0.0012823906,
-0.0049719191,
-0.0073857703,
0.0173666514,
0.054356169,
-0.0149451392,
-0.0237363353,
-0.0123152165,
-0.0815254524,
-0.0644498989,
-0.0654863045,
-0.0173041336,
0.0454616807,
0.0475853495,
-0.0148842596,
-0.0040336917,
0.000462334,
0.0579600334,
-0.0243259538,
0.0136913229,
-0.0361661538,
-0.0399759486,
-0.0678456202,
0.013794817,
-0.0396926887,
0.0407942832,
-0.0467141457,
-0.032800775,
-0.0139030665,
0.0481709875,
-0.0079969279,
-0.0402574874,
0.0290123839,
-0.0299232509,
-0.0617093481,
-0.0345763527,
-0.0011603477,
0.1132647768,
-0.0040285848,
0.0691124201,
0.0059894933,
-0.0550106429,
-0.0194512904,
0.0219585709,
0.0726239756,
0.0078220041,
-0.0047495468,
0.0522614531,
-0.0119138341,
-0.0052049533,
-0.0184064992,
0.0318822972,
-0.0236524697,
-0.006681317,
0.0723988488,
-0.0151132112,
0.0499885641,
0.008463107,
0.0203075036,
-0.0772737041,
-0.0232907049,
-0.0521457158,
0.0456605777,
0.0632458851,
-0.0032628747,
-0.0045502628,
0.0202521812,
-0.0277386028,
-0.0244158469,
0.0775360316,
0.0321357921,
-0.0371167213,
-0.0129703349,
-0.0475430042,
0.002624027,
0.0377170146,
-0.0462281443,
0.0154577699,
-0.0087461015,
0.0028810729,
0.0687846839,
0.0035996509,
0.0122839184,
-0.0073013403,
-0.005663442,
-0.0276978798,
0.0319937542,
-0.015608727,
0.0874990523,
-0.0313436203,
0.0227544121,
-0.0096939178,
-0.0131984204,
0.0415894277,
-0.0054037124,
0.0230949093,
0.0199118238,
0.0076126498,
-0.0128717814,
0.0699630231,
-0.0467014611,
-0.009356509,
-0.0004942643,
0.0226498693,
-0.0105131259,
0.0183368791,
0.0721797198,
0.0237644203,
-0.0295241401,
0.035606388,
-0.0074977381,
-0.0267154314,
0.0491840653,
-0.0262392201,
-0.0140691027,
0.0068149567,
0.0096564163,
-0.0385748409,
-0.0522101559,
-0.0247908272,
0.0704320967,
0.0254843738,
0.0234786365,
0.009530196,
0.0485165529,
-0.0543992557,
-0.0293816999,
0.0369730592,
0.019761363,
0.1035521626,
-0.0347962119,
0.0217857417,
-0.0190332234,
-0.0078758597,
0.0420946665,
-0.0062748021,
-0.031622868,
0.0060913153,
0.041314099,
0.0138093829,
0.061091911,
0.0294580162,
-0.0442439094,
-0.0296699088,
0.0139305508,
-0.0240830947,
-0.0198047608,
0.0562772565,
-0.0419849865,
0.0260657202,
0.0220109299,
-0.0551481433,
0.0485957079,
0.0281988569,
0.0309899021,
-0.0778772235,
0.0427743942,
-0.0196399167,
0.0494877808,
-0.0159284994,
0.04859538,
0.0276485663,
0.0428475849,
0.0572090372,
-0.0459620617,
0.0512903482,
-0.0430328399,
-0.0330720507,
-0.0246412531,
-0.0014851351,
-0.0375101417,
-0.010212034,
0.0087488433,
-0.0296065807,
0.0027467103,
-0.0191998463,
-0.0422498398,
0.0112501103,
-0.0287896749,
-0.0086880811,
-0.0274924859,
-0.027416084,
0.054254327,
-0.0233945679,
0.0615775436,
0.0060971417,
-0.0137257753,
0.0219357219,
-0.0120827537,
-0.0112182125,
0.0339906365,
-0.0525724217,
0.0226282608,
-0.0295959543,
0.0159023777,
-0.0073388591,
0.0222407207,
-0.0102675427,
-0.0298420619,
-0.0294317994,
-0.0598491579,
-0.0477979779,
0.0248007886,
0.0435204171,
-0.0290038474,
-0.0219533332,
-0.016336266,
0.0218982119,
-0.0025255417,
0.021596428,
-0.0132660391,
0.0013755172,
0.0160608925,
-0.0191998687,
-0.0156855658,
0.0067542964,
0.0205677524,
0.0365000553,
-0.0114966491,
0.0522302799,
-0.0139003024,
-0.0173130538,
-0.0244179145,
0.0029224991,
-0.054684557,
0.0121334158,
-0.0007110766,
-0.0320710465,
0.0046753087,
-0.0319728106,
-0.0183805376,
-0.0309160743,
0.0171144027,
-0.0279843714,
-0.0007617967,
-0.0467966311,
-0.0587609261,
-0.0241609998,
-0.0281816646,
-0.0101099517,
-0.0091736587,
0.0048571955,
-0.0126580214,
0.0501685925,
-0.0465571135,
-0.0257782806,
0.0288546477,
0.0406089909,
-0.0162019376,
0.0916720629,
-0.0472187772,
-0.0033358368,
-0.0292507969,
-0.0210631136,
0.0053096861,
0.0591319762,
-0.0075910655,
0.0387454331,
-0.0113687487,
-0.0529812612,
-0.1166510507,
0.0182092059,
0.032347016,
0.062776342,
0.0035544599,
0.0281918067,
-0.0487439632,
0.047646068,
0.0287120715,
0.0823637173,
-0.0309582669,
-0.0233315974,
0.0361545309,
-0.0262908302,
0.0463082008,
-0.0493894406,
-0.04349171,
-0.0146481348,
0.0488592274,
0.0171995014,
-0.0022232083,
-0.0005175029,
0.0672416389,
-0.0048801107,
0.0288621336,
0.0858155042,
-0.0173387285,
-0.019306697,
-0.0496017709,
-0.0164569579,
0.0147245117,
0.0279265121,
0.0063939174,
-0.0502293818,
-0.0317948721,
0.0444825664,
-0.0023625316,
0.0489990637,
0.0493781716,
-0.0415453762,
-0.0289816987,
0.0325364769,
0.0139638018,
-0.0507228412,
-0.064408645,
-0.038486395,
-0.0176605992,
-0.0404177159,
0.0462057628,
-0.0306913424,
-0.0350671597,
-0.037156105,
0.0471089035,
-0.0557491183,
-0.0557676479,
-0.0468201861,
-0.04054524,
0.0844878182,
0.032184314,
-0.0169674177,
-0.0281605329,
-0.0279239453,
0.024100313,
-0.0209366828,
0.016859388,
-0.0147403236,
0.0081403125,
0.0057628704,
-0.0027908203,
0.0636546016,
0.010584617,
-0.0341632701,
0.0071518132,
0.027295975,
0.0366592929,
-0.0260083321,
0.0077277506,
-0.0009361256,
-0.0020629417,
-0.0234846734,
0.0456737056,
-0.0191528872,
-0.0070734816,
0.0232889373,
0.0159739871,
-0.0052345949,
0.0065555684,
0.0280442405,
-0.042547334,
-0.0279866643,
-0.057229057,
-0.0001453744,
0.0560710132,
0.0191921946,
0.0521630533,
0.0438941829,
-0.0211218242,
0.0243095532,
0.0333050527,
-0.0054070461,
-0.0091108866,
-0.0447355248,
0.0122631164,
-0.0745170861,
-0.019103311,
0.0614931956,
-0.0631839633,
-0.0059946398,
0.0049098372,
-0.0315886661,
-0.0321669579,
0.0079547679,
-0.0221827757,
0.0173146762,
0.0741928816,
-0.0457438789,
0.0010814918,
-0.0139380815,
-0.0142719317,
-0.0223851297,
0.0461202897,
0.0708658174,
-0.0600718558,
-0.0267454069,
0.0026800695,
-0.0365513898,
0.0443744436,
-0.015391944,
-0.0008382733,
0.0338987075,
-0.0068016169,
-0.0215799958,
0.0067309532,
0.0304464977,
0.037298765,
-0.0302911997,
-0.0343907923,
0.0546348169,
0.0001335203,
0.0638859048,
-0.0336809084,
-0.0269544814,
0.0044509429,
0.0215268731,
-0.0119705386,
0.0602312982,
-0.0207919553,
-0.0189370047,
0.0171367768,
0.0759675056,
0.0290853679,
-0.0027612359,
-0.0030697931,
-0.0153766861,
0.0487059243,
0.0287540425,
0.0872924328,
0.0184617825,
-0.0260778014,
0.0207153521,
-0.0068842941,
0.0083961478,
0.0113837635,
0.0425977968,
-0.0468643866,
0.0084241638,
-0.0361326262,
0.0429209247,
-0.0077075353,
-0.0053069722,
0.0488579459,
0.0373569168,
0.0270231646,
-0.036341887,
0.0218174886,
-0.0130899502,
0.0178859029,
0.0693974048,
-0.0157643612,
0.0140127363,
0.0257719066,
0.0325801857,
-0.0176241323,
0.0479738675,
-0.0320977233,
0.0499340631,
-0.0190014131,
-0.0752639472,
-0.016726004,
-0.0172980633,
-0.044476714,
-0.0068931533,
0.0118064452,
-0.0321963504,
0.0313870572,
-0.0620749667,
0.0187137257,
-0.0324272886,
-0.0224307105,
-0.0259561688,
-0.0219514724,
-0.0092173405,
0.0270053372,
-0.0789696947,
0.0221377648,
0.0230539907,
0.0590818599,
-5.827525734e-33,
-0.0484733656,
0.0523124002,
0.0100505836,
-0.0160321295,
-0.0339943953,
-0.040842738,
0.008575662,
0.0214001276,
-0.0185408443,
-0.0356611535,
0.0038240224,
0.0276896432,
0.0446681753,
0.014423239,
0.0005482601,
-0.0303417407,
0.1089921221,
-0.0272134561,
0.0056215837,
-0.0335333124,
0.0040114718,
0.0208273772,
0.0325049348,
-0.0363219976,
-0.0631234348,
0.056936156,
-0.0141288564,
-0.0117023615,
0.0238979086,
0.0537766591,
0.0471208766,
0.0346311554,
-0.0079831686,
-0.0539743826,
-0.021028176,
0.0169852786,
-0.0873824283,
0.0312647372,
-0.0110120503,
0.0807625502,
0.0544136614,
-0.0471378975,
0.0170114506,
0.0173523817,
-0.0175763667,
-0.0434082448,
0.0449266434,
-0.0497421548,
-0.0028855994,
0.0104248673,
-0.0022988324,
0.016983686,
0.0065152952,
0.0044391556,
0.0407028422,
0.0870454088,
0.0132156014,
-0.0670225397,
-0.0557407439,
0.0610378198,
0.0282610152,
0.0319958441,
0.0198455583,
0.0020469606,
-0.022566732,
-0.0050586062,
0.0244939681,
-0.0954331383,
0.0420032926,
-0.0654882416,
0.0277103763,
-0.0028070128,
0.0156478137,
0.0432887115,
0.0264532845,
-0.050853435,
-0.0017874438,
0.0063298936,
-0.0346915573,
0.0149673866,
0.0068398416,
0.0261161607,
-0.0086409226,
0.030013578,
-0.0284304805,
0.0182177611,
-0.0239572842,
-0.0125257801,
0.045506306,
0.0023855388,
0.0132505288,
-0.0145079559,
0.0743047968,
-0.0575424954,
0.0406099558,
-0.0046491204,
0.0200184081,
0.0036751409,
0.0120011931,
0.0064173588,
-0.0124552501,
-0.0455715545,
0.0867471918,
0.0355128497,
-0.0419797897,
-0.0196214952,
0.0141285229,
0.0704842657,
-0.0728011429,
-0.0281665642,
0.0170513391,
0.0139686288,
0.0228533279,
0.0623352379,
0.0255620163,
0.0030358124,
-0.007113101,
0.009749379,
-0.0295136105,
0.0038790051,
-0.0195973571,
0.0303228721,
0.0267127659,
0.0320683941,
-0.0488698296,
0.0090875002,
0.0086712828,
-0.0386768579,
0.0141681638,
-0.0095643969,
-0.0357315019,
-0.0070606829,
2.643e-7,
-0.0344672203,
0.0019761042,
0.0112912226,
-0.0769849494,
0.0333555453,
-0.0009005821,
-0.0387569778,
0.0194269009,
0.0320119038,
0.031492915,
0.0186336152,
-0.0093211234,
0.0501545258,
-0.022616528,
-0.0892491639,
-0.0135741755,
0.0141063947,
0.0290479064,
0.0208894834,
-0.0146184238,
-0.0139218606,
0.0906952843,
-0.0283028018,
-0.0237930566,
0.0205159951,
0.0068834955,
0.0305626579,
0.0094138663,
0.0399811156,
-0.0074087675,
-0.0335178338,
0.0012959779,
-0.0483298562,
0.021193523,
-0.0458573513,
0.0498795137,
0.004453545,
0.0224431325,
-0.0071089771,
-0.0325956084,
0.0070345253,
0.087273702,
-0.0234549996,
0.0317693278,
0.0592262,
-0.0257286467,
-0.0393611044,
-0.0449173674,
-0.0766561404,
0.0040323017,
-0.0336362347,
0.0206291433,
0.023734007,
0.0096996659,
0.0080211833,
0.0149208521,
-0.047516726,
-0.0140710808,
0.0637270659,
-0.0472401679,
-0.0558948964,
0.0185026042,
-0.0325775221,
-0.0237935372,
0.0275036506,
-0.0225560367,
-0.0225302298,
1.668707903e-34,
0.0274977367,
-0.0169544723,
0.0063454616,
-0.0083169406,
-0.0078677814,
-0.0366467573,
0.0060915295,
0.0187495314,
-0.0324198194,
-0.0697874203,
-0.021095898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16333v1 | Text Generation with Speech Synthesis for ASR Data Augmentation | 2023-05-22T18:45:20 | 2023-05-22T18:45:20 | Zhuangqun Huang, Gil Keren, Ziran Jiang, Shashank Jain, David Goss-Grubbs, Nelson Cheng, Farnaz Abtahi, Duc Le, David Zhang, Antony D'Avirro, Ethan Campbell-Taylor, Jessie Salas, Irina-Elena Veliche, Xi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Aiming at reducing the reliance on expensive human annotations, data
synthesis for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has remained an active area of
research. While prior work mainly focuses on synthetic speech generation for
ASR data augmentation, its combination with text generation methods is
considerably less explored. In this work, we explore text augmentation for ASR
using large-scale pre-trained neural networks, and systematically compare those
to traditional text augmentation methods. The generated synthetic texts are
then converted to synthetic speech using a text-to-speech (TTS) system and
added to the ASR training data. In experiments conducted on three datasets, we
find that neural models achieve 9%-15% relative WER improvement and outperform
traditional methods. We conclude that text augmentation, particularly through
modern neural approaches, is a viable tool for improving the accuracy of ASR
systems. | [
-0.0092585823,
0.0699077472,
0.0223318897,
-0.003664773,
0.0346549451,
-0.0269104801,
0.0343493521,
-0.0009848761,
-0.0006948108,
-0.0260490421,
-0.0457085483,
-0.0267454591,
0.0226118062,
0.04894723,
0.0583996698,
-0.0309717525,
0.0069155674,
-0.0374926366,
-0.0297631137,
-0.0129355174,
0.0182075649,
0.0296580102,
-0.0244723633,
0.0193144158,
-0.0330330022,
0.045595929,
-0.0242693052,
0.0120888418,
0.0424007811,
-0.0112770787,
-0.0303953346,
-0.0026213829,
0.0393712185,
0.0538075902,
0.0000019595,
-0.0226417556,
0.0065029226,
0.0190006923,
-0.074454464,
0.0397487432,
0.0449424535,
-0.0193638019,
-0.0133815203,
0.0547620356,
-0.0163333546,
-0.0217711087,
0.0444957651,
0.0454433523,
0.0370565616,
0.0814224258,
-0.0141486712,
-0.0297823232,
0.049169559,
-0.023822587,
0.003296695,
0.0363107435,
-0.0309441593,
-0.0229098648,
-0.0090674134,
0.0212845001,
0.0149297668,
0.0499770828,
0.0571703464,
-0.0109745255,
0.0416486971,
0.0292296614,
-0.011054107,
-0.0121042738,
-0.0202289317,
0.0494452827,
0.0017895201,
-0.0446191803,
0.0030052718,
-0.0192023758,
-0.0183570683,
-0.0488057993,
0.0078593362,
0.0379017964,
0.00900234,
0.0291205086,
-0.0120375734,
0.0077570109,
0.0394077152,
-0.0079651885,
-0.0102636935,
-0.0080411937,
0.0117453206,
-0.0368802175,
-0.003767618,
-0.0163687188,
0.031212803,
-0.0297464635,
0.0704312101,
0.0206487514,
0.0057884548,
-0.0008050388,
-0.0831479952,
-0.0792532563,
0.0017879148,
-0.043420393,
0.0345915109,
0.0257125273,
-0.0433674827,
-0.0461998135,
-0.0269906577,
0.0353529155,
-0.0010834684,
0.003728149,
-0.0251908377,
0.0129576512,
0.0050061336,
0.0042665876,
-0.035393402,
0.0351641998,
-0.0676941797,
-0.0528685115,
-0.0735397711,
0.0084415451,
0.0267688148,
-0.0014862414,
0.0496810861,
0.0246614423,
-0.0642366186,
-0.032917656,
0.0236955713,
-0.0129475649,
0.0239435211,
0.0481666885,
0.0182059929,
-0.0405366756,
-0.0007520971,
0.0291654207,
0.0509032644,
-0.0040772134,
0.0163228344,
0.0517768823,
-0.0426382981,
-0.0195991509,
-0.0708179697,
-0.0193097368,
-0.03168495,
-0.0174553208,
-0.0347583257,
-0.0450218618,
0.0372905172,
-0.0360491909,
-0.0435225293,
-0.0253541209,
0.0305435099,
0.0024114125,
0.0377178118,
0.0460770614,
-0.1004681215,
-0.0001292315,
0.0525232367,
-0.0274866652,
0.0537483543,
0.0058872364,
0.0854648426,
0.0326008275,
-0.0201943927,
-0.0303559136,
-0.0047803349,
0.0606514774,
0.0116623733,
-0.0035698349,
-0.0104050748,
-0.0420205705,
-0.0240920894,
0.0447837338,
0.0586655885,
0.0530103631,
-0.0299012661,
0.0043958789,
0.0605532788,
0.0062372857,
0.0490476228,
0.0515987054,
0.0576255359,
0.0298107807,
0.0095945541,
-0.0370253175,
-0.0053535132,
0.0038406542,
-0.005850255,
0.0337682851,
0.059179239,
0.0264615268,
-0.0346575044,
-0.0687321723,
0.0137885064,
-0.0433670469,
0.0088519109,
0.0166732408,
0.0302418284,
0.0434306338,
-0.0452647805,
-0.0158019047,
0.0107917516,
-0.092625618,
0.0695860982,
-0.0153654311,
-0.0166271813,
0.0827036649,
0.0265876222,
-0.0235777218,
-0.0047103097,
-0.0266020447,
-0.0289861746,
0.0996417552,
-0.0091897743,
0.0368046798,
0.0564454198,
-0.0942631587,
0.0168170482,
-0.0048405272,
-0.0091564041,
0.0636040419,
0.0017566399,
0.0439892188,
0.0467090607,
0.0142287603,
-0.0438711233,
0.0221727453,
-0.0682380646,
-0.0360540971,
0.0442127362,
-0.0191861875,
0.0142459339,
0.0626977831,
-0.036227826,
0.012652752,
0.0123443007,
-0.0444618724,
-0.0398738012,
0.0336025618,
-0.066858165,
-0.0511256494,
0.0220073741,
-0.0134050343,
0.0452531986,
0.0209431108,
0.0093649533,
-0.0882124379,
0.0214357637,
-0.0720696002,
0.024263069,
-0.0364732593,
0.0406163111,
0.0707923025,
0.0146464529,
0.0225799792,
-0.0312805064,
0.0327233486,
-0.0174335502,
0.0107045295,
0.0287650507,
0.0145823592,
-0.0635190308,
0.0059248325,
-0.0001561104,
-0.004224678,
0.032666944,
0.0162618402,
0.0030219557,
-0.007858674,
0.0110538695,
-0.0784185529,
-0.0159297157,
-0.007055677,
0.0134540955,
0.0237370338,
0.0211939067,
0.0173684657,
-0.0118775405,
-0.0553920083,
-0.0441529192,
0.0107104005,
-0.0278874375,
-0.0221128128,
0.0072667608,
-0.0058723153,
-0.0261312034,
-0.0032337389,
0.0181726627,
0.0015162008,
0.04790828,
-0.0454627685,
-0.0546569563,
0.0006153149,
0.0155169936,
0.0422725491,
0.0038483187,
-0.0512164161,
0.0011703722,
-0.0041016866,
0.0425667539,
0.0090545639,
0.0286958627,
-0.0197720453,
-0.002232064,
0.0300516915,
-0.0498976707,
0.0035084051,
-0.0096449731,
0.0476146527,
-0.0046320613,
-0.0256874301,
0.02063559,
0.0156061919,
0.0320361368,
0.0193428416,
-0.0421140678,
-0.0137087051,
0.0096291853,
-0.0750408322,
-0.0052188467,
-0.0439448468,
-0.0434869006,
0.0093514808,
-0.0032892635,
-0.0306557845,
0.0062989448,
-0.087336868,
-0.0412747189,
-0.0352541395,
-0.0412094742,
-0.0138176372,
-0.0115923174,
0.0326315388,
0.0323839113,
-0.0322717577,
-0.0097481115,
0.0149382818,
0.0325971432,
-0.0225870591,
-0.044802472,
0.0222513918,
-0.0195210911,
0.0111190742,
-0.0035751623,
-0.0259108655,
-0.0440805592,
-0.0090683652,
0.0029024731,
0.0110183172,
0.0187328663,
-0.0632665008,
0.0198207013,
-0.0158266928,
0.0136640724,
0.107116282,
-0.0144224484,
0.0203169435,
-0.0428972654,
0.0131833917,
0.0259457305,
0.0063221785,
-0.0238090456,
-0.0228834096,
0.00911541,
-0.0233134944,
0.0396683998,
-0.0027477059,
-0.0814764872,
-0.0317678116,
-0.0010883213,
0.0067831944,
0.0153538547,
-0.0027711322,
0.034710139,
-0.0434513353,
0.0063043889,
0.0845839605,
0.0062450431,
0.0144222314,
0.0022855382,
0.0287587047,
0.0093920641,
-0.0094536534,
-0.0010135201,
-0.0702542067,
-0.0184253436,
0.0152610121,
0.045237042,
-0.0037577979,
0.0341041945,
-0.0447730757,
-0.1097504422,
0.0222421438,
0.0384597965,
-0.0589417927,
-0.0117947813,
-0.0085623227,
-0.0546866022,
0.0137434844,
0.036355868,
0.0169397667,
-0.0075447462,
-0.0101473955,
0.0623503625,
-0.0648693815,
-0.0760354251,
-0.0744967461,
-0.0286744945,
0.0857535303,
0.0450202599,
0.0289317165,
-0.0276058894,
-0.0451791883,
0.0395316891,
0.0198079515,
0.0330541693,
0.0060460554,
0.0594083332,
0.0140904328,
-0.0245651323,
0.0098863197,
0.0621943511,
0.0016170408,
0.0096683893,
0.0319754183,
-0.0098109078,
-0.0181902684,
0.0073191952,
0.0116157429,
0.0204515625,
-0.0200826991,
0.0235103723,
0.0141885076,
-0.0594008416,
0.0131665561,
0.0029282141,
0.0463364013,
-0.111293532,
-0.0192417223,
0.0204165578,
-0.04802607,
-0.0518359505,
-0.0853714943,
-0.0373680107,
0.0079898946,
0.019698767,
0.0125407968,
-0.0106818154,
-0.0027739631,
-0.015918348,
-0.0203429274,
0.0164694525,
-0.0304012317,
0.0244168136,
-0.0379790217,
-0.0547100604,
-0.0086859409,
-0.0995344222,
0.0087375222,
0.0175188892,
-0.0333004221,
-0.0618712418,
0.024898516,
0.0198671352,
0.0156690739,
0.059035033,
-0.0208185036,
-0.0584133491,
0.0767076015,
0.0867584497,
-0.0304892827,
0.0303223059,
0.0390890501,
0.0281559732,
-0.0061952425,
-0.0158343893,
-0.0116583975,
0.0405362025,
0.0003713499,
0.0056401324,
0.0002146026,
-0.030132331,
0.0141231976,
0.0599358417,
0.0145645868,
-0.0631901845,
0.0387615226,
-0.0557300821,
0.0173485596,
-0.0398312621,
0.0537699126,
-0.0686174035,
0.0158012547,
0.0499621332,
0.0578214563,
-0.0106713204,
0.0197281074,
-0.0248581786,
-0.0198827311,
-0.0204257425,
0.013753539,
-0.0113901123,
0.0496517122,
0.0281515867,
0.0259270873,
-0.0361016244,
0.0368930921,
0.0050385529,
-0.0039137872,
0.0022204833,
0.0018858159,
0.0199217759,
-0.0043050791,
-0.0071177022,
0.0544681549,
-0.0426329151,
-0.0065566408,
-0.0720208436,
0.0479968563,
0.0106730172,
0.0298214834,
0.0789603516,
-0.0205201339,
0.0297664385,
-0.0218914989,
0.0184914023,
-0.021118341,
-0.0037753338,
-0.0065304637,
-0.0213180352,
-0.0309692342,
0.01264829,
0.0489560738,
0.0065486515,
0.0399637036,
-0.022920059,
0.0321829282,
-0.0259652045,
-0.044249095,
-0.0282414872,
0.0138615035,
-0.03146521,
-0.0322224982,
0.0154889692,
-0.0913105011,
0.018658381,
0.0260155201,
0.0099198744,
-0.0256578028,
0.0274631754,
-0.0614156909,
-0.0448875651,
0.0407137536,
0.0165133849,
-0.0014588822,
-0.0223686676,
-0.0233056843,
0.0035583226,
-5.889347553e-33,
-0.0202127025,
0.0295690484,
0.0189942215,
0.0035057496,
-0.0687076524,
0.0034596049,
-0.0275832731,
0.000717709,
0.0374721624,
-0.0113935443,
-0.0132557955,
-0.0153114349,
0.0336322524,
0.0655288175,
-0.0370484553,
0.0145102395,
0.1048159376,
-0.0264569707,
0.006378164,
0.0216712318,
0.0321922824,
0.0091707604,
0.0227403287,
-0.0647474602,
-0.026017407,
-0.004489725,
-0.0275670122,
-0.0324828178,
0.0277110357,
0.024297595,
0.001079622,
0.0778800026,
-0.0203141756,
-0.0222306289,
-0.0097431215,
0.041453436,
-0.0426755026,
-0.0048672045,
-0.0070408839,
0.0296369363,
-0.0566861704,
-0.0231184382,
0.0587682389,
-0.0329128392,
-0.0354836062,
0.0281678606,
0.0239133779,
-0.0356001183,
0.0137539795,
-0.0857055113,
-0.0287003685,
0.0215839744,
-0.0016567745,
0.0052604168,
0.0300745983,
0.0350469388,
-0.0291524082,
-0.0210998002,
-0.0849927068,
0.0319272652,
0.0552566908,
0.0145071056,
0.0193087868,
0.0336164273,
-0.0171190891,
0.0161726307,
0.0627800375,
-0.0215537082,
-0.0222857948,
0.0206302851,
0.0440205894,
0.0112848356,
0.0693770275,
0.0759588033,
0.0601156838,
-0.0274596028,
-0.0109826792,
0.0114762932,
-0.0163118355,
-0.0526149794,
0.0272339322,
0.0069288341,
-0.0188159794,
-0.0004471753,
-0.0590969734,
0.0123032536,
-0.0181187689,
-0.0241159089,
0.0670153424,
0.0460628234,
-0.0121449484,
0.0039712628,
0.0087056272,
-0.0174129382,
0.0297636818,
-0.0240373127,
-0.0318881273,
-0.0099173523,
-0.0134410821,
-0.0103808856,
-0.0542621873,
-0.0397316664,
0.0812793374,
0.0526734069,
-0.0055067912,
-0.0225052331,
0.016716104,
0.0627189428,
-0.0509532653,
0.0324177593,
-0.0129867699,
0.0504869148,
0.0388534702,
-0.031118609,
0.029530393,
-0.0298065636,
-0.0239723828,
0.0379897803,
-0.0054082242,
0.0422032252,
0.0093168868,
-0.0120050963,
0.0328060165,
0.0200150609,
-0.0440186709,
0.0313463658,
0.0197722167,
-0.029809732,
0.0300406683,
-0.048597917,
-0.0139833372,
-0.013727352,
2.607e-7,
-0.0331407711,
0.0076659224,
0.064207755,
-0.0209860671,
0.0116081573,
0.0062957569,
0.0122259157,
0.0124161504,
0.0012421366,
0.0291084964,
0.0016050916,
0.0135590369,
0.070268169,
0.0003420832,
-0.0522586517,
-0.0304531883,
-0.0888624787,
0.0292028598,
-0.016433198,
-0.0059450758,
0.0080811065,
0.0312428661,
-0.0017570881,
-0.0590477213,
0.0362786278,
-0.0275289249,
0.0395148844,
-0.0093923556,
0.00504955,
-0.0057714852,
0.0013844061,
0.0048597176,
-0.0335391015,
0.0196539797,
-0.0553997271,
0.0091453213,
0.0276889503,
0.0117838029,
-0.0259141214,
0.0021200168,
0.0108632036,
0.039120283,
-0.0193994753,
-0.0014732714,
0.0456977785,
-0.0187440794,
0.0065491819,
-0.0153589314,
-0.0481956564,
0.0092538428,
-0.0111039458,
-0.050900925,
0.0089648757,
0.007536435,
0.0307997279,
0.0147130955,
-0.012043912,
-0.0567754917,
-0.0311603975,
-0.0025418669,
-0.0610090755,
-0.0006875787,
-0.0736162513,
0.0256688483,
0.0125000328,
-0.0213234909,
-0.0055444119,
1.852293029e-34,
0.0177699588,
-0.0142452996,
0.0365758538,
-0.0372395143,
0.0027894557,
-0.0143208094,
0.0304131955,
0.025338307,
0.001440754,
-0.0490253493,
-0.0554782711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13406v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13406v3 | DADA: Dialect Adaptation via Dynamic Aggregation of Linguistic Rules | 2023-05-22T18:43:31 | 2023-12-06T00:19:24 | Yanchen Liu, William Held, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing large language models (LLMs) that mainly focus on Standard American
English (SAE) often lead to significantly worse performance when being applied
to other English dialects. While existing mitigations tackle discrepancies for
individual target dialects, they assume access to high-accuracy dialect
identification systems. The boundaries between dialects are inherently
flexible, making it difficult to categorize language into discrete predefined
categories. In this paper, we propose DADA (Dialect Adaptation via Dynamic
Aggregation), a modular approach to imbue SAE-trained models with
multi-dialectal robustness by composing adapters which handle specific
linguistic features. The compositional architecture of DADA allows for both
targeted adaptation to specific dialect variants and simultaneous adaptation to
various dialects. We show that DADA is effective for both single task and
instruction finetuned language models, offering an extensible and interpretable
framework for adapting existing LLMs to different English dialects. | [
0.0239517968,
0.0550069362,
-0.0207247213,
0.0058083725,
-0.0142697133,
0.0208369009,
0.0091539416,
-0.0407701433,
-0.0218800902,
-0.0769777223,
-0.0688544661,
-0.0396251492,
0.0208538827,
-0.000536196,
0.0352458209,
-0.0476431698,
0.0544370599,
-0.0477190576,
-0.0366949327,
-0.0305907018,
0.0351231508,
0.0298363212,
-0.0007133308,
0.0253903698,
0.0198161229,
0.0115919905,
-0.0036330693,
0.0037952648,
0.0176768005,
0.0383835696,
0.0485947207,
0.0380897522,
0.0099172872,
0.0237753429,
0.0000017804,
-0.0289497506,
-0.0283556338,
-0.0271533728,
-0.0066345353,
0.0234396197,
0.0661006644,
-0.0222717524,
-0.0489111766,
0.0491836034,
-0.0077859499,
-0.0377921835,
0.070263207,
-0.0025722657,
0.0588604733,
0.0675599873,
-0.0159600116,
-0.0462374203,
0.0389978364,
-0.0176878013,
-0.0793415532,
-0.0005543238,
0.0230222512,
-0.0321582071,
-0.0050012837,
-0.0369337238,
-0.0151474839,
-0.0015603697,
-0.0238175616,
0.0054683634,
-0.0710323974,
0.0095268413,
-0.036980018,
0.0352453031,
-0.0393331684,
0.0300150458,
-0.0433080196,
-0.0475197472,
-0.0141296526,
0.0061718458,
-0.0099372976,
-0.0149047449,
-0.0262654163,
-0.0127409408,
-0.0030959777,
0.0189554822,
0.0243528672,
-0.0142562939,
0.0092412615,
0.0095808851,
-0.0441901051,
0.0580274872,
0.0435581841,
-0.0077661066,
-0.0268062335,
0.0184138659,
0.0097432593,
-0.0197861865,
0.0166772995,
0.0151776113,
-0.024356395,
0.0236386098,
-0.0448060855,
-0.0134406155,
0.0028410044,
-0.034596771,
0.0498198755,
0.0454556122,
-0.0200745035,
0.0125627872,
-0.0076242941,
0.0119830128,
-0.0051076058,
0.0415277034,
-0.0465717614,
-0.0264175907,
-0.0783807784,
0.0335127003,
-0.0351983272,
0.0175905414,
-0.0161839928,
0.0368993841,
-0.0334145352,
0.0180981029,
-0.0277759787,
-0.0063122348,
0.051696986,
-0.0347603522,
-0.0619033426,
-0.0499505624,
0.0309271961,
0.08109276,
-0.0108821522,
0.0395634882,
-0.0127261765,
-0.0644980296,
0.022325499,
0.0180072691,
0.0057075862,
-0.0169222988,
-0.0153921414,
0.0062058163,
-0.0288318675,
-0.0240407363,
-0.0952482894,
0.0243839491,
-0.0682281107,
-0.0336946696,
-0.0191730112,
-0.0597148165,
0.0288776439,
-0.0422564447,
0.0331117846,
-0.0590625778,
-0.0423700176,
-0.0366552249,
-0.0010148553,
0.0160722453,
0.0039121285,
0.0204214584,
0.0267461669,
-0.038121406,
-0.0032230385,
0.0991776437,
0.0288243927,
-0.0315574668,
0.0197951384,
-0.0078724017,
-0.0407147221,
0.0707831904,
-0.0056844377,
0.0560720973,
-0.068776764,
-0.0351062678,
-0.0053037922,
-0.0421874784,
0.0256369319,
0.0706665963,
0.0126097193,
-0.0077354629,
0.0460432172,
0.0120105753,
0.0516727827,
0.0102565121,
0.0572249554,
0.0374342613,
-0.0135060409,
0.0130731035,
-0.0223084167,
-0.0269710012,
-0.054540474,
0.0152031565,
-0.0318063423,
0.1105948985,
-0.0412476696,
-0.018330073,
-0.0303256437,
-0.0158678629,
0.0084883915,
0.0217250772,
0.0495018475,
0.0048975735,
0.0141083607,
0.0419658981,
0.0569955222,
-0.0099292407,
0.0199498702,
-0.0350806154,
-0.0038310806,
0.0521946587,
0.0022699295,
-0.0109105669,
-0.0416495949,
0.0059478809,
0.0399986431,
-0.0023450437,
0.0715175048,
-0.0272862539,
0.0519116968,
-0.0622132681,
0.0084801186,
0.0349443704,
0.0401447192,
0.0431760922,
0.0015814884,
-0.012757007,
-0.0214475021,
0.0105600804,
-0.0249367282,
0.0047649746,
-0.0082363626,
0.0018760243,
0.0393705517,
0.0009539096,
0.0229518078,
0.0203635599,
-0.0340115689,
-0.0165807791,
0.012551791,
-0.0301128682,
0.0312795006,
0.0680480376,
-0.0144839622,
-0.0550718606,
0.0350995883,
0.0356353857,
-0.0022594638,
-0.0304757785,
-0.0203460511,
-0.0776719674,
0.0377385318,
-0.0665739402,
0.0448752642,
-0.0325056054,
0.0367147736,
-0.0300851222,
0.0189811848,
-0.0186156686,
0.025529651,
-0.0058594095,
-0.0425597467,
0.0073166382,
-0.0094515514,
-0.0067095426,
-0.0306837242,
-0.0113851652,
0.0120829148,
-0.0197600871,
0.031422548,
0.0013279796,
-0.025300758,
-0.008055375,
-0.0714423731,
-0.0468592197,
0.0094969124,
-0.0450913198,
0.0709850267,
0.0290824827,
0.0390690565,
-0.037029285,
-0.022717746,
-0.0131678795,
0.0173240192,
0.0100235976,
0.0317037329,
-0.0252167266,
0.0053579556,
0.0011738761,
-0.0539833084,
-0.0308274552,
-0.027142195,
0.0218374766,
-0.0775600746,
-0.0254109595,
-0.0571907312,
-0.0246090367,
-0.0212001372,
0.0542710423,
0.0032820117,
-0.0665141866,
-0.0439425074,
-0.0320267156,
0.0853201374,
0.0507217012,
-0.0174773466,
-0.0060108625,
0.0671357587,
-0.0575232767,
-0.0253611691,
0.0186456274,
-0.0087429592,
-0.0281881467,
-0.077322267,
-0.0393730327,
-0.0341119729,
0.0867346078,
-0.0080946162,
-0.0386254676,
-0.0776558146,
0.0105015356,
-0.0227766838,
0.0059261462,
0.0241434127,
0.0060027167,
-0.0350499749,
-0.0066831186,
-0.0440201014,
-0.0285783485,
0.0773086771,
-0.0442436375,
-0.0231250469,
-0.0640374199,
-0.0402669571,
-0.0478827022,
-0.0127708502,
-0.0199952852,
0.038301006,
0.0299634673,
-0.0327336378,
-0.0470650718,
-0.0201544445,
0.0298181847,
-0.0159363449,
0.101311028,
-0.0592770055,
-0.0046816561,
-0.0190758593,
-0.0393322743,
0.0066798632,
-0.0181226395,
-0.0457584001,
0.029916117,
-0.0024209025,
-0.0294861905,
-0.0441360176,
-0.0045350743,
0.0232582297,
0.047745876,
-0.0477016382,
0.0235870238,
-0.0203895364,
0.0003108081,
0.0622294284,
0.1007663906,
-0.0444350429,
-0.0010413635,
0.0805984214,
-0.0350156911,
0.0401904956,
0.0053672483,
-0.0128465882,
0.0356995501,
0.0595488548,
-0.0178961121,
-0.0151442327,
0.0586224124,
0.0513440706,
-0.033378277,
-0.0228676479,
0.0999454856,
0.0233431626,
-0.0320453793,
-0.0029430664,
-0.0293762032,
0.0894065723,
0.0256730318,
0.0423283577,
-0.0311772842,
-0.031314496,
0.0077882893,
0.0156946033,
0.0068261945,
0.0270065796,
-0.0392533578,
-0.1044154912,
-0.0022030638,
0.0424135253,
-0.0246174317,
0.0439954549,
0.0037740688,
0.0199496225,
-0.0348830894,
0.0289910175,
-0.0177130178,
-0.0068293512,
-0.0312156081,
0.0513958484,
-0.0389360487,
-0.0718197525,
-0.0036846611,
-0.0360622145,
0.0598926097,
0.0025757931,
-0.022303246,
-0.0413103551,
-0.0416138284,
0.0468329117,
-0.0487806611,
-0.014427173,
0.0021020707,
0.0122251036,
0.0246254075,
-0.0040811547,
0.0131093301,
0.0038915495,
-0.0273585487,
0.0168083105,
0.0042686183,
0.0704425946,
0.0215854309,
0.0247605368,
-0.000701839,
-0.0209007617,
-0.009354881,
0.0140110226,
0.0086724544,
-0.061672505,
-0.0065912106,
-0.0254528616,
-0.0380850993,
-0.0170615278,
-0.0049583274,
0.0635566413,
-0.0344691351,
-0.042107828,
-0.0511650592,
-0.0128876697,
-0.00911476,
0.0483226292,
0.0572459623,
-0.0052999947,
0.0497047678,
-0.0296406969,
-0.0260674357,
0.0141440844,
-0.034107063,
0.0377561823,
-0.0594863743,
-0.0105622346,
0.0850093886,
-0.0158635117,
0.0168488286,
-0.0428559706,
-0.0422620103,
-0.1005021706,
0.0225411244,
0.0306197293,
0.0187549032,
0.0495256372,
-0.0452040695,
-0.0753594786,
0.0071149962,
-0.0261911768,
0.0369963497,
0.027245773,
0.0698273554,
-0.0234026276,
-0.0182123948,
0.0292229895,
-0.0688451007,
0.0481893122,
-0.0010061179,
0.0060100905,
-0.0497594848,
-0.0273243729,
0.0071017384,
-0.0296232626,
-0.0096934224,
-0.0187065806,
-0.0222666394,
-0.0230932534,
0.0295415483,
0.0174070783,
-0.0038113075,
-0.0148633644,
-0.0121540949,
0.032494206,
-0.0403234772,
-0.0118548945,
0.0419277214,
0.0030465694,
0.0474581905,
-0.0210386775,
0.0224793386,
0.0177747682,
0.0322759673,
0.0065412177,
0.0348900221,
-0.0038483397,
0.0510219187,
0.012938899,
0.0383965597,
-0.018763518,
0.0394050516,
-0.0304090008,
-0.0211490188,
-0.0335210934,
0.027367888,
-0.0380803011,
0.0155315092,
-0.0289439056,
0.0199247673,
0.0479602367,
0.0014509629,
0.0879913941,
0.0275928322,
0.0093656937,
-0.0546626076,
0.0085104322,
-0.013406489,
-0.020144416,
0.0394265093,
0.0030095458,
-0.0065300846,
0.0089857886,
0.0438082851,
0.0078354292,
0.0177618563,
-0.0042921207,
0.0381418094,
-0.0031118651,
-0.0332518518,
0.0115586091,
0.036383085,
-0.0195714235,
0.0012054066,
-0.0285163652,
-0.0505862497,
0.0168565456,
-0.0062444462,
0.0333928689,
-0.0293082204,
-0.0095140608,
-0.0053240182,
-0.0182945486,
-0.0171759166,
-0.0360330343,
-0.0198882576,
0.0050667571,
0.0113575561,
0.000481153,
-6.113715629e-33,
-0.0489242189,
0.0220730938,
-0.0175150987,
-0.0345997922,
-0.0158753898,
-0.0055896719,
-0.0180998966,
0.0155368298,
-0.0102324216,
-0.0118746618,
-0.0095973834,
0.0167335607,
0.0211547781,
0.0335718021,
0.0212841891,
0.0207970496,
0.0502361171,
0.0008536505,
0.0047581159,
0.0038247753,
0.0205405559,
-0.004266697,
0.0525065288,
-0.0269209575,
0.0041636648,
0.0360924304,
-0.0264262799,
0.0207681283,
-0.0013639735,
0.1017833725,
0.0051103421,
0.0727863684,
0.0205097105,
0.016426824,
-0.0476233251,
0.0237650406,
-0.0467136428,
-0.0070931013,
0.0143969506,
0.0313994288,
0.0469348803,
-0.0365155414,
0.0487324782,
-0.0028496908,
-0.0005426563,
-0.0119011709,
0.0108225988,
-0.0408832729,
0.0073604691,
-0.0087556802,
-0.0462040156,
0.0418680646,
0.025998963,
-0.0078813937,
0.0279509779,
0.0074391151,
0.0196477417,
-0.0151226632,
-0.0109081334,
0.0113762245,
0.0082466668,
0.0552923791,
0.0630383641,
0.0050668954,
-0.0380858034,
-0.0040519992,
0.0191225447,
0.0151825482,
0.0238499455,
-0.0276644081,
0.0647835582,
0.0099123549,
0.0404515229,
0.064094156,
0.0072360765,
-0.0326709151,
-0.0186868403,
0.0230560433,
0.0716134012,
0.0227597952,
-0.0082389824,
0.0480038933,
-0.0181928389,
-0.0369539112,
-0.0353886411,
0.0245258287,
-0.0172547512,
-0.012774189,
0.0335074477,
-0.0183508079,
-0.0010023308,
0.009883102,
0.0499084331,
-0.0401653014,
-0.0196857937,
0.0040124459,
-0.0063142898,
0.005444963,
-0.0142536657,
0.0629682168,
-0.0269289855,
-0.0550146699,
0.0331596695,
0.0031157818,
-0.0184404384,
-0.0007324841,
0.052031979,
0.0478649065,
-0.0766733587,
0.0205098595,
-0.003359607,
0.0244058501,
-0.0097123794,
0.0591825806,
0.0275413468,
0.0186172463,
0.0154489111,
0.0247401185,
0.0211454146,
-0.0170095135,
-0.024098536,
0.0046676965,
-0.0036636682,
0.0730188265,
-0.0203383826,
0.0135518545,
0.0084990943,
-0.0350966305,
0.0075132642,
-0.0136169,
-0.0000383102,
0.0076320609,
2.549e-7,
0.0250814557,
0.0357221253,
0.0081330929,
-0.0391658843,
0.0539180301,
0.0025765968,
-0.0384905189,
-0.0008863211,
0.0286436733,
0.0192146339,
-0.0069214916,
0.0166923944,
0.0839529112,
0.0466009974,
-0.0655605346,
0.0092336498,
-0.0418647453,
0.0632563457,
-0.0312043186,
0.0245280657,
0.0529237166,
0.1089134514,
-0.0009211394,
-0.0087527903,
-0.0151834032,
-0.0600566082,
0.0326215848,
-0.0019945288,
0.0066425516,
0.0521576889,
0.0129489386,
0.0128306625,
-0.0155756157,
-0.0114127211,
-0.0299366303,
0.0904617906,
-0.050480336,
0.0608437769,
-0.0337824449,
-0.0008927485,
0.0178585537,
-0.0179634392,
-0.0259924214,
-0.0161305033,
0.057725437,
-0.0484487303,
-0.0014494343,
-0.0158280041,
-0.0022848113,
0.0030863467,
-0.0284066759,
-0.0309651885,
-0.0194905866,
0.0143946167,
0.0437306352,
-0.0345758982,
-0.0353699401,
-0.0692033991,
-0.0349772833,
0.0783643797,
-0.0306071509,
-0.0296829473,
0.0175478309,
0.0163756926,
-0.0167195145,
-0.0906883031,
0.0302235521,
2.35105092e-34,
0.0344745852,
-0.0068796272,
0.0147267217,
0.0533445813,
0.0145635214,
-0.02120509,
-0.0509096198,
0.0162741933,
0.0135067804,
-0.0787917599,
-0.0275037475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13403v1 | GATology for Linguistics: What Syntactic Dependencies It Knows | 2023-05-22T18:34:12 | 2023-05-22T18:34:12 | Yuqian Dai, Serge Sharoff, Marc de Kamps | cs.CL | cs.CL | Graph Attention Network (GAT) is a graph neural network which is one of the
strategies for modeling and representing explicit syntactic knowledge and can
work with pre-trained models, such as BERT, in downstream tasks. Currently,
there is still a lack of investigation into how GAT learns syntactic knowledge
from the perspective of model structure. As one of the strategies for modeling
explicit syntactic knowledge, GAT and BERT have never been applied and
discussed in Machine Translation (MT) scenarios. We design a dependency
relation prediction task to study how GAT learns syntactic knowledge of three
languages as a function of the number of attention heads and layers. We also
use a paired t-test and F1-score to clarify the differences in syntactic
dependency prediction between GAT and BERT fine-tuned by the MT task (MT-B).
The experiments show that better performance can be achieved by appropriately
increasing the number of attention heads with two GAT layers. With more than
two layers, learning suffers. Moreover, GAT is more competitive in training
speed and syntactic dependency prediction than MT-B, which may reveal a better
incorporation of modeling explicit syntactic knowledge and the possibility of
combining GAT and BERT in the MT tasks. | [
0.0408804081,
0.0116625363,
-0.0236838404,
0.0573866777,
-0.0330869816,
-0.006531796,
-0.0227005538,
-0.0020432225,
0.0889614746,
-0.0096874088,
-0.011743702,
-0.0456810296,
0.0122262239,
0.022559071,
0.0457554273,
-0.0601389669,
0.0375057273,
0.0274826474,
-0.0014194073,
-0.0196430143,
0.0219376963,
0.0127262753,
0.0408197977,
0.0067356783,
-0.0459793173,
-0.0058203475,
0.0094885947,
0.0438542701,
-0.0203426443,
-0.011141248,
0.0260032713,
0.0528973043,
0.0183720607,
0.0683097392,
0.000001951,
-0.0423774756,
-0.0032761565,
-0.016188791,
0.0160521902,
0.0045763049,
-0.0251498595,
-0.0294908788,
0.0273729283,
0.0073289233,
-0.0441196747,
-0.0313358456,
0.0527086444,
0.0041668555,
0.0368139185,
0.0761410818,
-0.036854621,
-0.0618540123,
0.0097690551,
-0.0486496314,
0.0173721425,
-0.0438487455,
-0.0025181363,
0.0136469305,
-0.0192133281,
-0.0279326662,
-0.0372636691,
0.0286630969,
0.0226198472,
0.0409400128,
0.0254618321,
0.0628153905,
-0.0544807129,
0.0073135104,
0.0097626597,
0.0894866288,
-0.0392374136,
-0.046290271,
-0.0249834713,
0.006802435,
0.0015301927,
0.0208084695,
-0.0439901128,
-0.0120204296,
-0.0386493616,
0.0291037615,
0.0251269992,
-0.0352894366,
0.0336081162,
-0.0321322531,
-0.036163386,
0.0869096518,
0.0090099676,
-0.0383488387,
0.037072625,
0.0277130883,
-0.0656756982,
-0.0254434329,
0.0119889295,
-0.0149311293,
-0.0019136101,
0.0308097769,
-0.0125407716,
-0.0404171385,
-0.0007991744,
-0.0718475804,
0.0139147919,
0.0314041041,
-0.0328553468,
0.0306146704,
-0.043680355,
0.0678860918,
-0.0323774591,
0.0092385057,
-0.0511423945,
0.0156184779,
-0.0561657622,
-0.0007135434,
-0.0889263749,
0.0334613062,
0.0257562976,
-0.0195240006,
-0.0264035314,
-0.0038265968,
0.012200579,
0.0176941976,
0.013210997,
0.0039731557,
-0.063568525,
-0.0073728678,
-0.0031563339,
0.0458443388,
-0.0284339581,
-0.0294537172,
-0.0585881919,
-0.0312836841,
-0.0452587269,
0.0339031108,
0.0292085093,
-0.0314955339,
-0.0085355667,
0.05452355,
0.0101604341,
-0.0329572558,
-0.0223229472,
-0.000493016,
-0.0184640959,
-0.0685934275,
0.0441525467,
-0.0590871051,
0.0343970768,
0.0399113297,
0.0102413427,
-0.0037628824,
0.0127684539,
0.0040313983,
-0.0454122573,
0.0407440141,
0.0476367511,
-0.0095010316,
0.0172128137,
-0.0351063721,
-0.0395858623,
0.0310023576,
0.010747551,
0.0090596545,
-0.0126071721,
-0.0231765825,
-0.0191287994,
0.0348837487,
0.0301244557,
0.0205874685,
-0.0133464755,
-0.0102145728,
-0.0198545177,
0.0244324319,
0.0312807597,
0.0569356754,
-0.0156036681,
-0.0202148296,
0.0677415431,
0.0362597667,
0.0151427034,
0.0459701717,
0.0493966378,
0.0195910074,
0.003705543,
0.0758466721,
-0.0648181513,
0.0130541436,
-0.0112487944,
0.0279011708,
-0.0244421698,
-0.0112730255,
-0.005486208,
0.0053894818,
-0.0083981566,
-0.0291754622,
0.0392661504,
-0.0514176004,
0.0411078073,
0.0343177915,
-0.0706163347,
0.0574455932,
0.0223213658,
-0.0155268544,
-0.0067734192,
0.0135024078,
-0.0379588008,
0.0385310054,
0.0121137565,
0.0024351673,
-0.0810000822,
0.0027900357,
-0.0390408039,
0.0265019387,
0.0465130806,
0.0303824991,
0.0020961144,
-0.0361618325,
0.00295247,
-0.0114927795,
-0.0034554421,
0.0571142174,
-0.0102869216,
-0.0057424917,
0.0081550479,
-0.0466859676,
-0.0516593605,
0.0147625655,
0.0241894834,
-0.0156832319,
0.0003891916,
0.011552453,
0.0409409292,
0.0001837048,
-0.0047781705,
0.0322200581,
0.0224186536,
-0.0336021185,
-0.0066719786,
0.0400852226,
-0.0711550862,
-0.0516128391,
0.0132155893,
-0.037532758,
0.0068636793,
0.0205232166,
-0.0191807821,
-0.0730858073,
0.0492541902,
-0.0821436271,
0.0816125199,
-0.0097822947,
-0.0001243454,
0.0064298543,
0.0322290212,
0.0088923303,
0.0881767571,
0.0010599684,
0.0204025563,
-0.0138441892,
0.0012929277,
0.0457345508,
-0.0074154739,
-0.0002632017,
0.0135236951,
0.0428506806,
-0.0072916639,
0.031049788,
0.0172223169,
-0.0554021932,
0.0106880227,
-0.1060428098,
0.022123551,
-0.0307250619,
0.0558565333,
0.0192190595,
0.0315436535,
-0.0006972714,
-0.039090652,
-0.0618206374,
0.0482989997,
-0.0127882147,
0.0127200596,
0.0068874904,
-0.0185525641,
-0.0006337701,
-0.0257273763,
-0.0361363143,
-0.0303153545,
0.0433999822,
0.0376005322,
-0.0666977465,
-0.0120104495,
0.0115579385,
-0.039246615,
0.039742589,
0.0151474625,
-0.0672899336,
0.0028870187,
-0.0155638931,
0.0643706545,
0.0313490555,
-0.0389111899,
-0.012509576,
0.0264678709,
-0.0045086876,
-0.023011785,
0.0275578797,
-0.0487920977,
0.0050920416,
-0.0298688244,
-0.0272516701,
-0.02935992,
0.0659061968,
0.0258212201,
-0.022280179,
-0.0960714146,
-0.0150606716,
-0.0021442657,
0.034409862,
0.0333032012,
-0.0045578424,
-0.0228010602,
-0.0181928612,
-0.0485161506,
-0.0458268672,
0.0886834264,
-0.0121417446,
-0.0356807709,
-0.0361193381,
0.0417490043,
-0.0304328632,
0.0685579032,
0.0956065282,
0.0125860581,
0.0087215519,
-0.0846407488,
-0.0509898961,
0.0108919814,
0.0515188947,
0.0002558727,
0.0108497646,
-0.0331389643,
0.0110225482,
0.0068674535,
-0.0003193612,
-0.0085468041,
0.0279012434,
-0.0248615425,
0.0443144217,
-0.0026398855,
-0.0296608862,
0.0134794209,
-0.0177697893,
0.0085164364,
0.0608683489,
-0.0306557175,
0.0037748935,
-0.0212128274,
0.0561989136,
-0.0075245304,
-0.0148815149,
-0.0246927422,
-0.0384601839,
-0.0203366391,
0.0079357456,
0.0196413901,
0.0074022175,
-0.0474023409,
-0.0095457602,
0.0168340337,
-0.0371932685,
-0.0783314556,
-0.0306605212,
0.0133931795,
-0.0476378426,
0.0112860128,
0.0738288984,
0.0184106734,
-0.0571954101,
0.0003141053,
0.0025951697,
0.0576160178,
0.0477846079,
0.0118067712,
-0.0678018183,
-0.0178999007,
-0.0276121944,
0.011282512,
0.0344849005,
-0.0310405251,
-0.0275034215,
-0.0825801194,
-0.0052187424,
0.0236221943,
-0.0335156657,
-0.0175842308,
-0.0191514511,
-0.0088803191,
0.0089876233,
-0.0035122943,
-0.0299131479,
0.00386454,
-0.0045525436,
0.0237959921,
-0.028308155,
-0.0134903705,
0.0305828247,
-0.0275423713,
0.0099929646,
0.0432983674,
0.0433543511,
-0.0504448302,
0.018396087,
0.0537417904,
0.0011115719,
-0.0104168188,
-0.0227807201,
0.0641288385,
0.0221551117,
0.0001516388,
-0.0013889134,
-0.0204029847,
-0.0159541685,
0.0387086421,
-0.0088137081,
0.1090319678,
-0.0011600382,
-0.0429785363,
0.0513349995,
-0.0211762991,
-0.0375103913,
0.0144932298,
0.055380173,
-0.0285690129,
-0.0379172936,
-0.0139456159,
0.0514870137,
-0.0864527076,
0.0121898735,
0.0425956547,
-0.0555054285,
-0.0410984382,
-0.0758179054,
-0.0483226888,
0.0249079447,
-0.0027157182,
0.0228909068,
0.0017716688,
0.0596170649,
-0.0018233435,
-0.0241268594,
0.0505579114,
0.0116857011,
-0.0204154495,
-0.0118219871,
-0.0323261917,
0.0195202809,
-0.0309483055,
0.0058748652,
0.0142974351,
-0.0461768582,
-0.0598508306,
-0.0175752658,
0.0435528271,
0.0151035637,
0.0504971184,
-0.0470978506,
-0.0278109331,
-0.0256258994,
-0.0189609062,
-0.0133998161,
-0.0047001163,
0.0378662348,
-0.0422761552,
0.0013485284,
0.0437690839,
-0.0004205114,
0.0153434668,
0.0033071055,
0.0295835268,
0.0101631656,
-0.0313324742,
0.0480875783,
0.0494346097,
0.0575858131,
0.0020226894,
0.0215712339,
-0.0556215271,
0.0088207107,
-0.0013600729,
0.0104562026,
-0.0420263261,
-0.0280630924,
0.0305404533,
0.0290368255,
-0.0183845703,
-0.047767505,
-0.0268302169,
-0.0059609897,
-0.0049555362,
-0.0087360805,
-0.0023745249,
0.0017800933,
0.0486079492,
-0.0204701591,
-0.0248066839,
-0.0132628288,
0.0061239363,
0.0137305846,
-0.0338325314,
0.041714903,
0.0167216435,
-0.0168329012,
-0.0028986919,
-0.0155879743,
-0.0167008676,
-0.0124304518,
-0.0246806163,
-0.001369767,
0.0832991675,
-0.0512733012,
0.1021464393,
-0.0546851121,
0.0172223505,
-0.0206908491,
0.0445093811,
-0.0030565113,
-0.0374268517,
0.0067218286,
0.0033506304,
0.0064709,
0.0335753933,
0.0866685286,
0.0370575674,
0.0080650384,
0.0172048826,
-0.0549314097,
-0.0259574298,
-0.0277388729,
0.0021827309,
-0.0017057132,
-0.0087319706,
0.0485295691,
-0.0263517015,
-0.0782592073,
0.0202957653,
-0.0192133058,
0.0219461899,
-0.0188808143,
0.0454806238,
0.0603525341,
0.0038776284,
-0.0480979644,
-0.042193111,
0.045796901,
-0.0082057863,
-0.0036793463,
-0.0106783882,
-6.287844914e-33,
-0.0051482441,
-0.0683533549,
-0.0246660095,
0.0195686761,
-0.0489794686,
0.0206996556,
-0.0587545633,
-0.0066795163,
-0.0408110358,
0.0246770438,
-0.0263107661,
0.0329948515,
-0.0051098634,
0.0188098513,
0.0310795568,
-0.0059442096,
-0.0035070591,
-0.0076988316,
0.0068988269,
0.0444295257,
0.0275804978,
0.0366817266,
0.1261490434,
-0.0016831141,
0.0183850322,
-0.0516192801,
0.0190136991,
0.011795097,
-0.0359887443,
0.0238826592,
0.0045409477,
0.0604319014,
0.0564745329,
0.0004777506,
-0.01928881,
0.011805444,
-0.0864548981,
-0.0750495717,
0.029062435,
0.0325563699,
-0.0372746214,
-0.0093078539,
0.0741118789,
-0.038370125,
0.047330156,
-0.0291723199,
0.0392447524,
0.0071957484,
-0.0465108976,
0.0276500341,
-0.0544680618,
0.0203036387,
-0.0039845025,
-0.0056146709,
0.0307668503,
0.0540632829,
-0.0128995003,
-0.0309858918,
-0.0039504073,
-0.0080689788,
-0.0422985815,
0.0509751216,
0.0158755388,
0.0257481784,
-0.0091443099,
0.0117433742,
-0.0109521803,
-0.0056523881,
0.0001548375,
-0.0215187538,
0.0241718665,
0.0195058603,
0.0286717527,
-0.0420861579,
0.0102219414,
0.0033707335,
-0.0741268173,
-0.0289338287,
0.0635962412,
0.0698988959,
-0.0108549353,
-0.0058117108,
-0.0075561842,
-0.0302975439,
-0.0113839917,
-0.0185633395,
-0.0196029674,
-0.0349100716,
-0.0241941512,
-0.0360106379,
0.0302110519,
0.007802112,
0.0289796162,
-0.0115839001,
0.0201069973,
0.0212671366,
-0.0212607756,
0.0241061281,
-0.0038065314,
0.0798859894,
-0.0493118465,
-0.0045321765,
-0.0264509767,
0.0184617173,
0.0170444828,
0.0235338043,
0.0714142993,
0.0066082897,
-0.0107433507,
-0.0228477586,
-0.081735611,
-0.0312370919,
-0.0450521484,
0.0178167503,
0.0462495908,
0.0256856978,
0.0073437672,
0.0311177559,
0.0506412387,
0.0352462791,
-0.0671824813,
0.0245348066,
0.0131280096,
0.0695692971,
-0.0546693914,
-0.0204357412,
-0.0262611099,
0.0592058264,
0.0122675253,
-0.0288441945,
-0.0429789796,
0.009475722,
2.875e-7,
0.0764560625,
0.0545983836,
0.0082688779,
0.0310547445,
0.0158611555,
0.0125042405,
-0.0449265055,
0.0530137457,
-0.0080521842,
0.0102387872,
0.0468762293,
0.0143444873,
0.0295790918,
0.0227638055,
-0.1181603149,
-0.0163456853,
-0.0492759012,
-0.0019530115,
-0.0306909438,
0.0031048285,
0.0286253784,
0.0638669878,
0.0147417337,
0.0196078829,
-0.0365708955,
-0.0411950722,
0.0674002469,
0.0125759318,
-0.023687169,
0.0025757868,
0.0185607579,
0.0121156517,
-0.0595540293,
0.0488528945,
-0.0264256969,
0.0161395129,
0.0234468617,
0.038210962,
-0.0223746188,
0.0035750016,
0.0464763269,
-0.0005674126,
-0.0069242362,
-0.0606701374,
0.0303493422,
-0.0494771861,
-0.0458112918,
0.0540831909,
-0.0228802711,
0.0280503239,
0.0238520764,
0.0084131006,
-0.048858162,
0.0058702137,
0.0291357115,
-0.0307657868,
-0.0255680755,
-0.028609613,
-0.0214516483,
0.0598786399,
0.0006671044,
-0.0295603629,
-0.0301834941,
-0.0371954106,
0.0240905862,
-0.0016629098,
0.0058413851,
2.564739722e-34,
0.0258754585,
-0.0381024666,
0.0283528995,
-0.0132957622,
0.0183700249,
-0.0565426685,
-0.0394694433,
0.0375398621,
0.0273379143,
-0.0518088341,
-0.024199523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13401v1 | A study of conceptual language similarity: comparison and evaluation | 2023-05-22T18:28:02 | 2023-05-22T18:28:02 | Haotian Ye, Yihong Liu, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | An interesting line of research in natural language processing (NLP) aims to
incorporate linguistic typology to bridge linguistic diversity and assist the
research of low-resource languages. While most works construct linguistic
similarity measures based on lexical or typological features, such as word
order and verbal inflection, recent work has introduced a novel approach to
defining language similarity based on how they represent basic concepts, which
is complementary to existing similarity measures. In this work, we study the
conceptual similarity in detail and evaluate it extensively on a binary
classification task. | [
0.0060047628,
0.0552825257,
-0.0469649471,
0.0407201573,
-0.0571908392,
0.0481186509,
-0.02429533,
0.0241942815,
-0.0670498684,
-0.0627783462,
-0.0061019817,
-0.0572054498,
0.0467695631,
-0.0002758093,
0.0317685343,
-0.0652326643,
0.0018420435,
0.0387554951,
-0.0325270519,
0.027601691,
0.0281940941,
0.0119715715,
0.0221217703,
0.029293431,
0.0175722614,
0.0015505491,
0.018821435,
-0.0314159915,
0.006879875,
-0.0203464516,
-0.016748609,
0.035671629,
-0.0122118145,
0.0214494299,
0.0000017539,
-0.0804451555,
-0.0035498466,
-0.017298704,
0.0259153321,
0.0098302662,
0.0537331626,
-0.0012241353,
0.0055678729,
-0.0046617095,
-0.0042552669,
-0.0568186529,
0.0674791709,
0.0346875452,
-0.0031942937,
-0.0203497335,
-0.0196374822,
-0.0245485101,
-0.0185979493,
0.0362430103,
-0.0054214601,
0.0633985549,
0.0056326357,
0.0206636488,
-0.0228643902,
-0.0231453292,
0.010953973,
-0.0014415195,
-0.0059842137,
0.0394089781,
-0.0152835874,
0.0153370155,
-0.024316255,
-0.0386353433,
0.0395330936,
-0.0048144623,
-0.0451512076,
-0.0875978991,
-0.0326720588,
0.0058955289,
-0.0202588588,
0.0281071924,
-0.042152904,
0.03519734,
-0.0301222634,
0.0464265794,
0.0447292402,
0.0747748986,
-0.0091487709,
0.0096540591,
-0.0181474872,
0.0604858175,
0.017530378,
-0.0080635995,
-0.0266021956,
-0.010160435,
-0.0149405617,
-0.0124179283,
-0.035367921,
0.0108198896,
0.0349000357,
-0.0194394719,
-0.0050860289,
-0.0131623326,
0.0753417835,
-0.0884665325,
0.0812490955,
0.0198857002,
-0.0355564132,
0.010003305,
-0.0265324917,
0.0435737073,
0.0341149308,
-0.0078627542,
-0.0357992128,
-0.0248699151,
-0.0823795795,
-0.0162822697,
-0.0336075723,
0.0077202441,
0.0698008984,
0.0026024368,
-0.0286641046,
0.0212090276,
-0.0445185639,
-0.0106310267,
-0.0360104442,
-0.0269931331,
-0.0052637327,
0.0201545209,
-0.0382964872,
-0.0253462177,
-0.0305704717,
0.0269902796,
-0.0651089251,
-0.0907247812,
0.061234992,
0.0392441563,
-0.0405923612,
0.0265130028,
-0.0043029287,
-0.0168720651,
-0.0098221814,
0.0145168267,
-0.0448184609,
0.0036019932,
0.0146261789,
-0.0101978658,
-0.0598397367,
-0.092489697,
0.0018994072,
0.0348765925,
0.001517663,
-0.0336318575,
-0.030366715,
-0.001475555,
0.0012484598,
0.1051303446,
-0.0115011362,
-0.001615466,
0.0372239463,
0.0217607412,
0.0084257079,
0.0147321802,
-0.0111981723,
-0.0459192768,
0.060326606,
0.0126768723,
-0.0272111073,
-0.0026887986,
-0.0592108741,
-0.0014146819,
-0.0442409515,
0.008125714,
0.0013044177,
0.0138196517,
0.0430165231,
0.0570703857,
-0.0236359295,
0.0352311097,
0.0194662791,
0.0907362327,
0.0094351955,
0.0211043824,
0.0225794278,
0.0436607599,
-0.0211331062,
0.0036220306,
0.0046730991,
-0.0299539845,
0.0257079601,
0.0021638626,
0.0072437669,
0.0399369523,
-0.0034234126,
-0.0064712502,
-0.0307448991,
-0.0057862634,
0.0373528786,
-0.0346668735,
-0.0110383732,
0.0268791448,
0.029409416,
0.047160361,
0.0436015613,
-0.020492414,
-0.0171767622,
-0.0239382759,
-0.0473122261,
0.0146036977,
-0.0256950967,
0.007153491,
0.0261306372,
0.0187945869,
-0.0302611534,
0.046436999,
0.0293890182,
-0.0212205425,
-0.0119196502,
-0.0389055088,
0.0424418673,
0.0113682393,
0.0195713658,
0.0269704591,
-0.0280840881,
0.0311217066,
0.0302631408,
-0.0008105564,
-0.0269485787,
0.0332543701,
0.0369422063,
-0.0063077402,
-0.0086779743,
0.0329771787,
0.0494013615,
-0.0145714646,
-0.0097467434,
0.036751464,
-0.0211847071,
-0.0510873422,
-0.0249248892,
0.0381245278,
-0.0033964657,
-0.011034552,
0.0541300438,
-0.0545771569,
0.0165175889,
0.0349981263,
0.0256316196,
0.0075438209,
0.0224207044,
-0.0212746207,
0.0953104049,
-0.0672154427,
0.0809612796,
-0.0739576295,
-0.0276792031,
-0.0631920174,
0.044367861,
0.0246006493,
0.0712992847,
-0.095229812,
-0.0524901338,
0.0903761089,
0.0026337199,
-0.0237089358,
0.0358776227,
-0.0000929457,
-0.0122531876,
0.0058457176,
0.0030337616,
-0.0081103137,
0.024655804,
-0.0665316954,
-0.0244129412,
-0.0051869,
0.020262463,
0.0551304035,
0.0136314901,
-0.003137731,
-0.0146521935,
0.0066887392,
-0.0139681408,
0.0075203134,
0.0377998054,
0.0315306075,
-0.0429051369,
-0.0624797046,
0.0048368587,
0.0130699622,
0.018590169,
0.06426052,
0.0079669124,
-0.0178507268,
-0.0367627293,
0.024398895,
-0.0359451026,
0.0010665704,
-0.0048984289,
-0.0393612534,
0.0245549008,
0.0366301499,
-0.0153012061,
-0.0645599812,
0.0154788643,
-0.0008177607,
0.1000752151,
0.0124592008,
-0.0308670681,
-0.0663429722,
-0.0296949986,
0.0193007495,
0.0069658891,
-0.053457167,
0.0212274361,
0.0245708916,
0.0440760702,
-0.0228038672,
-0.0112725282,
0.0176851768,
-0.0661444217,
0.0407292359,
-0.0808302686,
-0.0654275343,
-0.006204477,
0.0250307973,
0.005432711,
-0.0432104059,
0.0604610555,
-0.0355065353,
0.0228708964,
-0.0752211213,
-0.0406714343,
-0.0595196635,
0.0452091172,
0.0027090532,
0.0317615606,
0.0327443779,
0.0042216638,
-0.0304072294,
0.035198655,
0.0687252358,
0.0157796834,
0.0767704993,
-0.0331096873,
0.013744466,
0.0182503704,
-0.0444771126,
-0.0256728977,
0.0341178998,
0.0039633834,
0.0140802627,
0.0314241461,
0.0162939969,
-0.0040480196,
0.0625251085,
0.0021501691,
-0.0073188171,
0.0505777933,
-0.0194399878,
-0.0056238496,
0.006836534,
0.0019570051,
-0.026052488,
-0.0135959517,
0.0221052486,
0.0371128954,
0.0008164831,
-0.0052667754,
0.0090619251,
-0.004320689,
0.0149400616,
0.0239671301,
-0.0518578626,
-0.0457136519,
0.0176146738,
-0.005750292,
0.0169163402,
0.0022794101,
0.0721395686,
0.0617018119,
-0.0046640625,
0.0462680571,
-0.0568604618,
0.053636279,
0.0343639739,
-0.0141585246,
0.0121602621,
0.0079841223,
0.0211462583,
-0.0047137956,
-0.0401326343,
0.005010624,
-0.0014190744,
-0.0454866402,
-0.0009820035,
-0.010625273,
-0.0814916119,
-0.0674066246,
-0.0749109611,
0.0021508127,
0.0139546394,
-0.0440100655,
0.0088729672,
-0.0120727448,
-0.0013476157,
0.0074615725,
-0.0496684685,
-0.0273233261,
0.005137281,
-0.0246252287,
-0.0230759718,
0.0046759057,
0.0273421407,
-0.042049773,
0.0194789879,
-0.0060306625,
-0.1094251275,
-0.0359824337,
0.0120182168,
-0.0007091417,
0.0391101167,
0.0172394998,
-0.0278943628,
-0.0054271817,
-0.0261963438,
-0.0314044841,
0.0021517221,
0.032526724,
-0.0502996333,
-0.0383362807,
-0.0133118769,
-0.0086000869,
0.0340184569,
0.0754239634,
0.0698391721,
0.023381643,
-0.0055085658,
-0.0063416604,
-0.0028043508,
0.0349477492,
-0.0322171412,
0.0130279697,
-0.0075080129,
-0.0214229133,
-0.0569997244,
-0.0319434702,
-0.0341622122,
-0.0556872226,
-0.0117329629,
0.0215313993,
0.013171142,
-0.060590893,
-0.0773544163,
0.0052433666,
0.0527809076,
-0.0045372988,
-0.0254960656,
-0.0458657444,
0.0295675974,
0.0333543345,
-0.0417270586,
-0.0290601272,
-0.0467624627,
-0.0235475581,
0.0154481297,
-0.0362264179,
0.017069418,
-0.0099963825,
0.0318799987,
-0.0281402785,
0.0509830974,
0.0209057201,
-0.0160894003,
0.0043326356,
-0.008408729,
-0.0058752545,
0.017664168,
0.059345562,
0.0073488341,
0.0556652136,
-0.0077019492,
-0.0215094946,
-0.057015501,
-0.0544021577,
0.0404861495,
0.0172442328,
0.0281292535,
-0.0175836459,
-0.0638084188,
-0.0279082917,
-0.0527747981,
0.0118832765,
-0.0443395637,
-0.0157382544,
-0.0211018976,
0.0120969452,
0.0532596968,
-0.0289879031,
0.000415081,
-0.0039451811,
0.0205677059,
0.0681811273,
0.0327317603,
0.0349496529,
0.0588198267,
-0.010762332,
-0.0170124862,
-0.0269037429,
0.0023880948,
-0.0532218553,
0.0056274249,
-0.0378708169,
0.0001413394,
0.0398944207,
0.0164785869,
-0.0333640426,
0.0422942042,
0.0077363867,
-0.0605146587,
-0.0050750743,
-0.0100308042,
0.0372282043,
-0.0355411172,
0.0245357025,
-0.0579457693,
-0.0116733406,
-0.0003898387,
-0.0042122807,
-0.0352119468,
-0.0403694585,
0.0392055698,
0.0288730618,
-0.0147888567,
0.0102088051,
0.0549019799,
-0.007553271,
0.0079685077,
-0.033656165,
-0.0463991165,
-0.0152317919,
0.0155366734,
0.0553822331,
0.0439070091,
-0.0050072558,
0.0167605132,
-0.0573256426,
-0.0391544476,
0.0103598433,
-0.0150430975,
0.0188446771,
0.036611516,
0.0757351741,
0.0665755644,
0.0084900949,
-0.0098147383,
-0.0153304581,
-0.0288638547,
-0.0197361223,
0.0025923257,
-0.0508465134,
-5.434006959e-33,
-0.0129087381,
-0.0436963961,
-0.0176219773,
0.0109408908,
0.0206964109,
-0.0126624685,
0.0113490103,
-0.0122948065,
-0.0446823649,
0.0205211025,
0.0503791161,
-0.0166925844,
0.0068649119,
-0.0116417771,
0.0362188369,
0.0330917798,
-0.0005808083,
0.0172967892,
-0.0321121402,
-0.0279137604,
0.064025335,
-0.0281544775,
0.0626930296,
-0.0330814719,
0.0393194929,
-0.0236818399,
0.010060613,
0.0089349616,
0.0346025266,
0.0483333059,
-0.016903,
0.0725693628,
0.0433488414,
0.001614316,
0.004620295,
0.0075876834,
0.0094297333,
-0.09104155,
0.0139181409,
-0.0002897488,
0.0352530777,
0.0293135364,
0.0443185829,
-0.0372114889,
-0.0270971376,
0.0088011101,
0.055801034,
-0.0060592219,
-0.0046437578,
0.0037815536,
-0.0732200295,
0.0319805332,
-0.0017476118,
0.0178242978,
0.0226471666,
0.033251144,
-0.0573610552,
-0.0252272077,
-0.0921586379,
0.0521318577,
-0.0069159414,
0.0416555703,
0.0289308876,
0.0081817722,
0.0074342773,
0.0367384218,
0.0186135005,
-0.0777211115,
0.002392529,
0.0382764041,
0.0384844579,
-0.0075115147,
0.0178209543,
0.0500174277,
0.0888160393,
0.0015055233,
-0.0223153271,
0.029429473,
0.0143350512,
0.0492677018,
-0.0302171707,
0.0295377094,
-0.0558635183,
-0.0574425831,
-0.0429089703,
-0.0307435896,
-0.0274180099,
-0.0349649936,
0.0484722145,
-0.0629682839,
0.0026009579,
0.0278556384,
0.0050028409,
-0.0179385152,
-0.047091864,
-0.0260269903,
-0.0044828276,
0.0294272453,
0.0261313934,
0.022537455,
-0.038339451,
-0.0384991206,
-0.0138560729,
0.0219489373,
0.0217251815,
0.0074707936,
0.0485023558,
-0.0296482593,
-0.0429972485,
0.0163219683,
0.0214224458,
-0.089320004,
-0.0299920905,
0.0094058802,
-0.0265990421,
0.020772526,
0.0244783349,
-0.0251338165,
0.0505555421,
-0.0682789311,
-0.0122092478,
-0.0054016844,
-0.0371723063,
0.0258102156,
-0.0120721217,
-0.0027816081,
-0.0676485375,
-0.0112828547,
0.0338466205,
0.0075790803,
-0.0125564095,
-0.0195228793,
2.601e-7,
0.054999087,
0.0148315309,
-0.0115740551,
0.0145225432,
-0.0064963461,
0.0146354875,
0.0053286818,
0.0026300147,
-0.0019111681,
0.0187121611,
0.0087476503,
0.0194233377,
0.0195050519,
0.0397741757,
-0.0451265052,
-0.0106212543,
-0.037156269,
-0.0706687197,
-0.0477617569,
-0.0014717937,
0.0470234789,
0.0615214258,
0.0191426091,
-0.0146072423,
-0.0404373333,
-0.0297796,
-0.0053605628,
-0.0428850539,
0.0455874428,
0.0509126149,
0.0195236076,
-0.0296006054,
0.0091683157,
0.0685303956,
0.0089813424,
0.0132476818,
0.0406377949,
-0.0389449149,
-0.0343636572,
0.0250290465,
-0.0195872504,
-0.0194634944,
-0.0244488511,
-0.1462808549,
0.0402972922,
-0.0010249335,
-0.0196942408,
0.0263318736,
-0.0091328844,
0.0297583137,
0.0634408742,
-0.0055490779,
-0.0868879333,
0.0109674111,
0.0434407778,
-0.0391755626,
-0.0427488275,
-0.0149299838,
-0.0046975748,
0.0336414129,
-0.0258609001,
-0.0241447929,
-0.0059067272,
0.0154526662,
0.0823291242,
-0.02112519,
0.0324613079,
2.312634295e-34,
-0.0141163096,
0.028394144,
0.0510266274,
-0.0057882671,
0.0137241362,
0.0008829669,
0.016384365,
0.0791925788,
-0.0132338647,
-0.008261079,
0.0312859863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13395v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13395v2 | BioDEX: Large-Scale Biomedical Adverse Drug Event Extraction for Real-World Pharmacovigilance | 2023-05-22T18:15:57 | 2023-10-20T15:51:45 | Karel D'Oosterlinck, François Remy, Johannes Deleu, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder, Klim Zaporojets, Aneiss Ghodsi, Simon Ellershaw, Jack Collins, Christopher Potts | cs.CL | cs.CL | Timely and accurate extraction of Adverse Drug Events (ADE) from biomedical
literature is paramount for public safety, but involves slow and costly manual
labor. We set out to improve drug safety monitoring (pharmacovigilance, PV)
through the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP). We introduce BioDEX, a
large-scale resource for Biomedical adverse Drug Event Extraction, rooted in
the historical output of drug safety reporting in the U.S. BioDEX consists of
65k abstracts and 19k full-text biomedical papers with 256k associated
document-level safety reports created by medical experts. The core features of
these reports include the reported weight, age, and biological sex of a
patient, a set of drugs taken by the patient, the drug dosages, the reactions
experienced, and whether the reaction was life threatening. In this work, we
consider the task of predicting the core information of the report given its
originating paper. We estimate human performance to be 72.0% F1, whereas our
best model achieves 62.3% F1, indicating significant headroom on this task. We
also begin to explore ways in which these models could help professional PV
reviewers. Our code and data are available: https://github.com/KarelDO/BioDEX. | [
0.0619016774,
0.0576281585,
0.0236975681,
-0.009934702,
-0.0074639111,
0.0263864435,
-0.0381118357,
0.0206084587,
0.0544184931,
-0.0622191764,
0.0387505181,
-0.0013019246,
-0.040965721,
0.0735288337,
0.0168645754,
-0.0046083881,
0.0184733048,
0.0351097398,
0.0482283719,
0.0333552696,
0.0328230634,
0.0293638911,
0.0001878101,
0.0356225595,
0.023736367,
-0.0024308178,
0.0421529971,
-0.034430705,
0.0487373918,
-0.0758058727,
0.0177709311,
0.0050753197,
-0.0175530668,
-0.0071238489,
0.0000015682,
-0.0440630987,
-0.0006463612,
0.0376984328,
-0.0054603755,
-0.0571202226,
0.0494580083,
-0.0807863921,
-0.008215351,
0.011520897,
-0.0446495451,
-0.053179998,
0.01951598,
0.0547939725,
0.0224818476,
0.0714117587,
-0.0221612789,
-0.0163198449,
0.0190534089,
0.0264371596,
0.0164349247,
-0.0435513034,
0.0585893206,
-0.0136306472,
0.0478523746,
0.003007734,
0.0273579285,
0.0187288336,
-0.0283617526,
-0.0012485739,
0.0204802752,
0.0337579586,
-0.0341922939,
-0.0270256344,
-0.0231787823,
0.0835167542,
-0.0140357288,
-0.0018314326,
0.0400435403,
-0.0009391026,
-0.040374998,
-0.0023106697,
-0.0108144116,
0.0053555984,
-0.0542002991,
0.0143122803,
0.0351057909,
0.0209307577,
0.0010854228,
-0.0021083413,
0.013383721,
0.0454584137,
-0.0047396403,
-0.0300463475,
0.0311348494,
0.0163106546,
0.0166559443,
-0.0182891507,
0.069829464,
-0.0253797881,
-0.0285538211,
0.0277116299,
0.0067939903,
-0.0497391783,
0.0665052906,
-0.1281547546,
-0.0094806477,
-0.0205900874,
-0.0061709895,
0.0433523506,
-0.0053702458,
-0.0356752463,
0.0084436452,
0.0021787735,
-0.0172134321,
0.0224781539,
-0.0342049152,
-0.0048679654,
-0.0218271278,
0.0142292008,
-0.0086983256,
0.0110717881,
-0.0506787039,
-0.0278348085,
-0.038791582,
0.0131558832,
0.0193384066,
0.0504203402,
-0.0437213294,
0.0031261335,
0.0029606705,
0.0037193047,
0.0001282662,
-0.0021405998,
-0.020480549,
-0.0057913815,
0.0128276488,
-0.0254328344,
0.0409570597,
-0.0018109492,
0.0196003579,
0.0900292248,
0.0258856304,
-0.006854705,
-0.0306612067,
-0.0538217165,
-0.0032854199,
-0.0158725511,
-0.0157687869,
-0.0333311781,
0.0579462014,
-0.0170924775,
0.0003319706,
-0.0522864833,
-0.0046644039,
0.008555185,
-0.0652243942,
0.0618630722,
-0.0428022407,
-0.0138828978,
-0.0129909664,
-0.0110905496,
-0.0029610361,
0.0141072115,
0.0224973243,
-0.0186501462,
0.0385248959,
0.0200678222,
0.0331767648,
0.0164735373,
-0.0078607295,
-0.0566766746,
0.028357923,
0.0277927611,
-0.0086693391,
0.0316163376,
-0.0133590819,
0.0363869555,
0.007569422,
-0.0063605015,
0.0043266593,
0.0640592277,
-0.0153074274,
-0.008774722,
0.026226867,
0.0019058324,
-0.0165848397,
-0.0327057093,
-0.0393979698,
-0.014889393,
-0.0111227622,
0.0045767212,
0.0101788519,
0.0023010834,
0.0106777847,
0.0105918534,
-0.0358826965,
-0.0070044193,
-0.0002597312,
-0.0142778596,
0.0213267375,
-0.0069539878,
-0.0634758472,
0.0379911996,
0.0474672019,
-0.0148145556,
-0.0034765652,
0.0147378156,
-0.0138893239,
0.0817953348,
0.0429342203,
-0.0248398446,
-0.001072836,
-0.0325292498,
-0.0323598087,
-0.0054625813,
-0.0010821035,
-0.0382103696,
0.03203886,
-0.0011292995,
-0.0048233625,
0.0567861274,
0.0166395009,
-0.0472052656,
0.0148714818,
0.0107254451,
-0.0231160056,
0.0007549216,
-0.0966157019,
0.051459942,
-0.0317227133,
-0.0682160035,
-0.0006790449,
-0.0141537376,
0.0170790274,
0.0092758052,
0.0178918857,
0.0184557065,
0.0527287386,
-0.0723029748,
-0.0440332405,
0.0044281222,
0.0364021957,
-0.0308471862,
0.0286290459,
-0.0654951558,
-0.016997166,
0.0039209742,
-0.0745280683,
-0.0152639924,
0.0015586744,
-0.0288184397,
-0.0140738552,
0.0216913801,
0.0057138642,
0.0541511402,
-0.0045919889,
-0.0294817556,
0.0188519042,
0.0159323104,
0.015077264,
-0.0323839635,
-0.0929444507,
-0.0148911569,
-0.0374909528,
0.0087572811,
0.0220827144,
0.0099397441,
0.0294484664,
0.0300380774,
-0.00495139,
-0.0461060666,
0.027725894,
-0.031612549,
-0.0064576501,
0.0234253984,
0.0409617759,
0.0317049623,
-0.0080256369,
-0.0110642845,
-0.0318566859,
-0.0219162796,
-0.0514932498,
0.0083447406,
0.0155889932,
0.0366783775,
0.062011797,
0.0240657106,
-0.0494677201,
-0.013964003,
-0.057840623,
0.0504554883,
0.0192762986,
-0.0680245087,
-0.047704462,
0.0217903983,
-0.0093661984,
0.0265858918,
0.010398997,
0.0000997801,
0.0009865703,
0.0028342362,
-0.0024273715,
0.0436688736,
-0.0202499796,
0.022481259,
0.0250964239,
0.0047038249,
-0.0105994185,
0.00613706,
-0.0767442212,
0.0122202551,
0.0422833376,
-0.0481574051,
0.0404990464,
0.0456307828,
0.016396882,
-0.0040587317,
-0.0134735378,
0.005154734,
-0.0487606376,
-0.0015414665,
-0.0090928767,
-0.0228112098,
-0.0115543129,
0.022955412,
0.0051572602,
-0.0325279012,
0.0789807066,
0.0309357271,
0.0328695178,
-0.106799081,
-0.0008218506,
-0.0345661417,
-0.0049885386,
0.0216490012,
0.0188756194,
0.0175123829,
-0.0088523617,
0.0540301241,
0.0056052268,
0.0282192118,
-0.0275315363,
0.0462085605,
-0.04679396,
0.0477382317,
-0.0074199894,
-0.060523212,
-0.0187991876,
-0.0447469838,
-0.0482037403,
-0.0175141431,
0.0070897788,
-0.0112494351,
-0.0527147949,
0.0390649885,
-0.0267792828,
0.0344870985,
0.0032048589,
-0.0404482,
0.0221818574,
-0.0164910965,
0.0746716857,
-0.0546530597,
0.0372734778,
-0.0109071266,
0.0479390845,
0.1258559376,
0.026820356,
0.041300673,
-0.0086093368,
0.0273126643,
-0.0079158479,
-0.0633686036,
0.0077884025,
0.0204098504,
0.0062921345,
-0.06182025,
0.0047658836,
0.0825426057,
0.0273448508,
-0.0421981923,
0.0323235244,
0.0048095915,
-0.092322886,
-0.019575052,
0.030199429,
-0.0405072942,
-0.0278272275,
-0.0267158914,
0.0346034989,
-0.0275404416,
-0.0776664838,
-0.0097013023,
-0.0444533676,
0.0278338809,
0.0042500012,
-0.0224839784,
-0.0698757172,
-0.057276655,
-0.0075808973,
-0.0537583716,
-0.0149462819,
0.0041800397,
-0.0212179292,
-0.0063214679,
0.0110661266,
-0.0913643613,
-0.0880161747,
0.0424915664,
-0.0380431302,
0.000937669,
0.0310367178,
0.0265951697,
0.0011076918,
0.0195520706,
0.0026376473,
-0.0321825519,
-0.0215602033,
-0.0031362048,
0.095256336,
-0.013021511,
-0.0027365237,
-0.0784486383,
0.0665169954,
-0.0656647831,
-0.0029644971,
-0.0134883849,
0.0816271156,
-0.0238521546,
-0.0408350676,
-0.0652481988,
0.0382043049,
0.0212034322,
0.0593121275,
-0.016766306,
-0.0049114511,
-0.0618040189,
-0.0023101675,
0.0036946095,
-0.0638089031,
-0.0462666377,
-0.0048428923,
-0.0242842771,
-0.0230200943,
-0.082174629,
-0.0255610775,
0.0589467473,
-0.0103124091,
0.0141170695,
-0.0215081573,
0.0501601137,
-0.0130540719,
-0.0140945045,
0.0663829669,
0.050169684,
0.0197767634,
-0.0184086952,
-0.0202849526,
0.0513663776,
0.0821239129,
-0.0168593265,
0.0811997727,
-0.0201226491,
-0.0691063851,
0.0035399031,
0.0098347059,
0.0247583818,
-0.0108681163,
-0.0184535123,
-0.0223383307,
0.0263952538,
0.0602376573,
-0.0266844407,
-0.0724050775,
-0.0204477459,
0.0010850815,
0.0009382334,
-0.0032498357,
-0.0252115857,
0.01353643,
-0.0227563046,
0.0251752976,
-0.0464230627,
-0.0016021281,
0.0496639088,
0.0280719288,
0.0119106462,
-0.0140040331,
0.0092744213,
-0.0718461573,
-0.0075318795,
0.0043156655,
0.0103345169,
-0.0202850532,
0.0455514416,
0.0137027716,
-0.0455073938,
-0.0327131674,
0.0642252266,
-0.0616881922,
-0.0235421248,
-0.0443440899,
0.0059061456,
0.013736194,
0.0214319229,
0.0755926669,
-0.0220044255,
0.0091222869,
-0.0266102776,
-0.028528953,
0.0478937738,
-0.0258330889,
-0.0056625623,
-0.0087101143,
0.0214422476,
-0.0234713592,
0.0439953469,
-0.0725865141,
-0.0105409948,
-0.0432765111,
0.011822571,
0.0476980358,
-0.0404985137,
0.0512216575,
-0.0436030403,
0.0061920569,
-0.0308423601,
0.0525887385,
0.0209980123,
0.0320651047,
0.0502617732,
0.01640388,
-0.0341839157,
-0.0338794962,
0.099473387,
0.0245610718,
0.0293619186,
0.0178874936,
-0.0723181367,
-0.0199076459,
-0.0245153271,
-0.0060567749,
0.0085825026,
-0.0635714009,
0.01249809,
-0.0781635419,
-0.0267323647,
0.0290521458,
0.0181045532,
-0.0059633339,
-0.0039884876,
0.0151248192,
0.0337948203,
0.045796752,
-0.0257380772,
-0.0398065336,
0.0468436144,
0.0145162614,
-0.0192182958,
-0.0433674008,
-5.029603107e-33,
0.034096662,
-0.0422528796,
-0.018762717,
0.0112157976,
0.0413018055,
0.0161072649,
-0.0381424315,
-0.0075555956,
0.0338706709,
0.0584817342,
-0.0059086131,
-0.001653963,
0.0084064966,
0.0029273878,
0.035283912,
-0.0292926338,
0.017257059,
0.0087979157,
0.0246719718,
0.0038462307,
0.0359155796,
0.088990055,
0.0516120978,
-0.0870706886,
0.0449518338,
0.0250939131,
0.0377845615,
-0.0243893918,
0.0182046182,
0.0511797071,
-0.035891749,
0.0457755364,
0.0306079555,
-0.0410678312,
-0.0300704706,
-0.0243234374,
-0.0463585518,
0.0001394704,
-0.0033677863,
-0.0231926404,
-0.011071533,
-0.0001255044,
0.0746684819,
0.0055855671,
-0.0384367704,
0.0026540665,
0.039504122,
-0.0101416474,
-0.0315281339,
-0.0628842339,
-0.0522208624,
0.0477345288,
0.0038943742,
0.0162638351,
0.0199010596,
0.0397632234,
-0.0142218266,
0.0331180021,
-0.0268569477,
-0.0284399744,
-0.0280997455,
0.0194391217,
-0.0068382542,
-0.057060767,
-0.0277611464,
0.0561804473,
-0.0085811336,
0.0149060749,
0.0068935743,
-0.0020264869,
-0.0627324432,
0.0482899547,
0.0084333075,
0.0298816003,
0.0667400062,
0.0059335716,
-0.0857786909,
0.0611761808,
-0.0518271066,
0.0600646287,
0.0068600895,
-0.0312101897,
-0.0545792431,
-0.0117764296,
0.0192553569,
0.0439025089,
-0.0067059188,
0.0204958897,
-0.0059464108,
0.0006188427,
0.0010991063,
0.0182751026,
-0.0368581861,
-0.0301510971,
-0.0142394388,
-0.0150836818,
0.0266645923,
-0.0085192258,
-0.0112259667,
-0.0299410913,
-0.0588427819,
-0.0054592411,
-0.0170167368,
-0.0046141823,
0.0136000784,
-0.0006310376,
0.0337699018,
-0.0073760608,
-0.0435439199,
-0.0006761299,
0.0013458331,
0.0279594753,
0.0192041006,
0.067748338,
0.028002318,
0.0340463556,
0.0233241711,
0.0487609059,
0.0203866661,
0.022715915,
0.0054110065,
-0.0001264242,
0.0324661396,
0.0192322489,
-0.0300034657,
0.0015036311,
-0.0290187281,
0.046379514,
0.025272835,
-0.0407140851,
0.0098055322,
-0.0217716638,
2.456e-7,
0.0915073678,
0.0274490491,
0.0294745583,
-0.0062419809,
0.0436497182,
0.0297607649,
-0.0010040364,
0.0405013524,
-0.0301150139,
-0.0163022112,
0.0079285074,
-0.0289351773,
0.0079049524,
0.0484904163,
-0.0569612347,
-0.0417180955,
-0.0675690398,
-0.0448095277,
-0.058746729,
-0.0431360975,
0.0514039584,
0.048727762,
-0.0274191983,
-0.0133395437,
0.0013740336,
-0.0313651823,
0.0125595108,
-0.0222120136,
-0.0175150987,
0.0289078988,
0.0502163768,
0.0152733503,
-0.0089408746,
0.0408486836,
-0.0361917727,
-0.0117444405,
-0.0082656611,
0.0697763041,
-0.0481672399,
0.0231899135,
0.020843273,
-0.0609125234,
0.0292867664,
0.0128308199,
0.0311306622,
-0.0153001174,
-0.0324644223,
-0.0234980211,
-0.0038574419,
0.001488816,
0.0355825759,
-0.0227694996,
-0.0414896123,
0.062287841,
0.0188405383,
0.0139775723,
-0.0125158029,
-0.0895935073,
0.0011166284,
0.0560947359,
-0.0098523339,
-0.0319254845,
0.0501304604,
-0.008128766,
-0.0004946337,
-0.0581989661,
0.0062493957,
2.100280782e-34,
0.0322625972,
0.0245156195,
-0.0078937234,
0.0174412094,
0.0496863127,
0.0000502657,
-0.0179569982,
-0.0195676871,
-0.010575328,
-0.0463698059,
-0.0214576852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13388v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13388v2 | The neural dynamics of auditory word recognition and integration | 2023-05-22T18:06:32 | 2023-12-05T21:20:16 | Jon Gauthier, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Listeners recognize and integrate words in rapid and noisy everyday speech by
combining expectations about upcoming content with incremental sensory
evidence. We present a computational model of word recognition which formalizes
this perceptual process in Bayesian decision theory. We fit this model to
explain scalp EEG signals recorded as subjects passively listened to a
fictional story, revealing both the dynamics of the online auditory word
recognition process and the neural correlates of the recognition and
integration of words.
The model reveals distinct neural processing of words depending on whether or
not they can be quickly recognized. While all words trigger a neural response
characteristic of probabilistic integration -- voltage modulations predicted by
a word's surprisal in context -- these modulations are amplified for words
which require more than roughly 150 ms of input to be recognized. We observe no
difference in the latency of these neural responses according to words'
recognition times. Our results are consistent with a two-part model of speech
comprehension, combining an eager and rapid process of word recognition with a
temporally independent process of word integration. However, we also developed
alternative models of the scalp EEG signal not incorporating word recognition
dynamics which showed similar performance improvements. We discuss potential
future modeling steps which may help to separate these hypotheses. | [
-0.0329906568,
0.0261718798,
-0.014683025,
-0.0600119531,
-0.010184058,
0.0109382579,
-0.032774806,
-0.0032347552,
0.0049947607,
0.0147053674,
-0.0060185483,
-0.0406211279,
0.0971755907,
0.0784403831,
0.0150142089,
-0.0005087652,
0.009430063,
-0.0499873422,
0.0238834247,
-0.0286128502,
-0.0137987062,
-0.0328539498,
-0.0865711793,
0.0048394063,
0.0235911198,
0.0385930203,
-0.0179536883,
-0.0209852215,
-0.0016514789,
0.000042707,
-0.0465664826,
0.0507385954,
-0.0185664948,
0.0222170744,
0.0000014745,
-0.0442642905,
0.0519589409,
-0.0166932773,
-0.0093044564,
-0.0367708169,
0.0038139569,
0.0410511605,
-0.0378886126,
-0.0308225621,
0.0157552697,
0.0253453124,
0.0640715435,
0.0466645174,
-0.0504343137,
-0.003398865,
-0.0160023067,
0.0111299027,
0.0601687394,
-0.0111027192,
0.0402371287,
-0.0064464025,
0.0469712242,
-0.0529851504,
0.0293678716,
-0.0377695076,
-0.0430567004,
0.0028315219,
0.0052496991,
0.0487651788,
0.070495382,
0.1028051749,
0.0260650907,
-0.0161098558,
-0.0618966073,
0.0223819632,
0.0232816283,
-0.0403685495,
0.0168571938,
0.0225156751,
-0.0171239451,
0.0415801816,
-0.0331933498,
-0.0166639686,
-0.0322070681,
0.0155093335,
0.0107660517,
-0.0218240172,
0.0320128016,
-0.0079364683,
0.022530159,
0.0942426026,
0.0381350853,
-0.0695683882,
0.0319917426,
-0.009165585,
0.0022866761,
-0.0225285962,
0.0274409261,
0.0144170355,
-0.0082591688,
0.0007900824,
-0.0049515334,
-0.0079336222,
-0.0129954992,
-0.0672337636,
-0.0040951236,
0.0258614551,
-0.0017942043,
0.0403925739,
-0.0154283363,
-0.0082967766,
-0.0096426103,
-0.0463078804,
-0.000006757,
0.059889961,
-0.0247866139,
-0.0112757394,
0.0112020886,
-0.0070456616,
-0.0102437632,
-0.0964153558,
-0.0262889974,
-0.0151457563,
-0.0104862163,
-0.0585617162,
-0.0104279006,
0.0021066298,
-0.021497922,
0.0027943575,
-0.030623069,
-0.0058378833,
-0.0225258153,
0.0301217251,
0.0019463811,
0.0188740361,
-0.0235589333,
-0.0152413361,
0.0354156308,
-0.0068270769,
-0.0296009649,
0.0245155785,
-0.011311329,
-0.0219150465,
-0.0042469203,
0.0008336874,
-0.0223407168,
0.0481923148,
-0.0048572849,
-0.0163736213,
-0.0096109631,
-0.0144702541,
-0.0316639692,
-0.0124241132,
0.0019163684,
0.0043918006,
-0.031738881,
0.0536777526,
-0.0122281509,
0.0132532353,
0.0746726841,
0.0248628482,
0.004692974,
0.02419791,
0.0360764414,
-0.0175066534,
-0.0339191481,
-0.0378850251,
-0.002484588,
0.0321041159,
-0.0379459821,
-0.0155414557,
-0.0691515654,
-0.0917377472,
-0.0080225309,
0.0481727161,
0.0570408665,
0.0195601936,
-0.0300651193,
-0.0119620906,
0.0835463256,
0.0348107256,
-0.0410480276,
-0.0234780591,
-0.0178165995,
0.0078947442,
0.005494108,
0.0155824302,
-0.040310353,
0.0400204249,
0.0090759499,
0.0079851858,
0.047155384,
0.0081681591,
0.0402497388,
-0.0086588133,
0.0139956977,
-0.0145787625,
-0.0015074217,
0.0206953138,
0.040229056,
-0.0350239798,
-0.0401333235,
-0.00788897,
0.0250855181,
0.0190564059,
0.0612163879,
-0.0098416544,
0.0260700211,
0.0340204127,
0.0256620478,
0.006904983,
0.059244018,
0.012585042,
-0.0180163365,
0.0567550771,
-0.0182895102,
0.0219769776,
-0.0058082617,
0.0028775691,
-0.004352815,
0.0434776396,
0.0210283957,
0.0446308665,
-0.0443042256,
0.0185336806,
-0.0274948645,
0.052142106,
0.0045047025,
0.008246067,
-0.0081731118,
-0.0509727299,
-0.0413224623,
-0.0310458355,
0.0373130776,
-0.0432535671,
-0.0510611124,
0.0305371881,
-0.019657407,
0.0080898236,
-0.0216671322,
0.0307055302,
0.0009098741,
0.0386633649,
0.0225323047,
0.0000194833,
-0.0011718342,
-0.0065061962,
0.087725386,
-0.0582556166,
-0.0071213096,
-0.0442456566,
0.0127495909,
-0.014282248,
0.0030115019,
0.0025505056,
0.0499128699,
-0.0187714249,
0.0133183077,
-0.004114158,
-0.0006594695,
0.003528188,
0.0054298611,
0.018412495,
-0.0156951603,
-0.0303255301,
0.0528003722,
-0.0271868259,
-0.0457973629,
-0.0204648916,
-0.1072262824,
-0.0493577644,
-0.0007325417,
-0.0797229931,
-0.05247958,
0.0760576501,
0.0035217088,
0.0100205261,
-0.0108649982,
-0.0329758301,
0.0444695279,
0.004029755,
0.0034179457,
0.0015611151,
0.045111306,
-0.056132067,
-0.0396787785,
-0.0446508788,
-0.0274106786,
0.0103303082,
-0.0084112762,
0.0276153814,
0.0157646034,
-0.0569566227,
-0.0291436035,
-0.0132487463,
-0.0046213204,
0.0266730003,
0.0118653858,
-0.0050226278,
0.0042313477,
-0.026670279,
0.1054331809,
0.0526179634,
0.048194997,
-0.0120941512,
0.0593473576,
-0.0404501818,
0.0365109146,
-0.0019702008,
-0.0290474258,
0.0619453453,
0.0133796707,
-0.0116890837,
0.008429748,
0.0775853395,
0.0641397238,
-0.0105718374,
-0.0039206487,
-0.0075393822,
-0.0565009266,
-0.0677081272,
-0.0220971461,
-0.0520186499,
-0.0988634899,
0.0825637206,
-0.0096817268,
-0.0484201275,
0.0845416486,
-0.0285312347,
-0.0027774635,
-0.0112846056,
0.0109025193,
0.049237024,
-0.026721254,
0.0453100316,
-0.0030286899,
-0.0190968495,
-0.0173770487,
-0.0302205831,
0.0133176623,
-0.0056142337,
-0.0427960716,
-0.0007120588,
-0.010865937,
-0.004635111,
0.036065869,
0.0454925299,
-0.050907407,
0.0012009394,
-0.0320138447,
-0.0140853394,
0.0209514834,
-0.0095994649,
-0.0051844427,
0.0208179541,
0.0173762497,
0.0178788193,
-0.0387519039,
-0.0417178459,
-0.0084500741,
0.0546473488,
0.0410376452,
0.0037797028,
0.0242252462,
-0.0217691995,
-0.013253402,
0.0063779997,
0.0822710916,
0.0559753552,
-0.0105571654,
-0.0067060529,
0.0118842246,
-0.0347357914,
0.0067915735,
0.0746909827,
-0.0458674431,
-0.0069675935,
0.0105091622,
0.0861837044,
0.0016711972,
-0.0669044629,
-0.0110779414,
-0.0388759375,
0.0007902216,
-0.0122800777,
0.0083369892,
-0.0162772257,
0.0173951723,
0.0061940495,
-0.0091897696,
0.010368349,
0.017612271,
-0.0262385551,
0.0036643217,
0.0096658701,
0.0393363871,
0.031149812,
0.0268220771,
-0.0200059414,
0.0091902809,
0.0493977517,
0.0124380654,
0.0158131216,
-0.0217017122,
0.0361097082,
0.026843043,
0.0176375788,
-0.0067178332,
0.0016702672,
0.0175421927,
0.0919672921,
0.0139290793,
-0.0031713846,
-0.0661765859,
-0.0266216919,
0.0280449931,
-0.0294335596,
-0.0331828706,
0.0049462155,
-0.000487076,
0.0234113205,
0.009122747,
-0.0483411103,
0.0131478701,
-0.0086860778,
-0.0830225199,
-0.0129996976,
0.0481609032,
-0.029969465,
-0.036936298,
-0.0076564839,
0.0672284439,
-0.0089081833,
0.0375436097,
0.0618836135,
-0.0601808503,
0.0199432932,
0.0454607345,
0.0270749107,
0.0186805986,
-0.0478517488,
0.0046677059,
0.0097273095,
-0.0474962741,
-0.0428739265,
-0.0046364949,
-0.0267234277,
0.0367848873,
0.0847697556,
0.0583056696,
0.0385561101,
-0.0484204926,
-0.0232296214,
0.0003278706,
0.0306429192,
0.0015335926,
-0.0217507444,
0.0092301061,
-0.0194770545,
-0.0578585491,
-0.0316471122,
0.0321529172,
-0.0385929942,
-0.049168352,
0.0759640038,
-0.0786045715,
0.0328425206,
-0.0378463455,
-0.0293271784,
-0.0760260895,
0.0180569924,
-0.0241983756,
0.0106809475,
0.0724996999,
-0.0216128863,
0.0293077063,
-0.0006189824,
-0.0255813375,
0.0134851234,
0.0307163298,
-0.0118000433,
-0.0228875466,
0.0120420326,
-0.0120520536,
-0.0020900269,
-0.0092071602,
0.088445738,
-0.0494472831,
0.0452639796,
-0.0523255356,
-0.0364501588,
0.0428782478,
0.047995735,
0.035396412,
-0.0718501955,
0.052187264,
0.0517450199,
-0.0290136412,
-0.0140923411,
-0.0045029367,
-0.0448373482,
0.0135563919,
-0.0481765568,
-0.016997138,
-0.0604430847,
0.0210777149,
0.0018065419,
0.0174226984,
0.0224645324,
-0.0467218645,
0.0179096721,
0.0371640176,
0.0546156652,
0.0147609934,
-0.0374745205,
-0.0136374906,
-0.0322314128,
-0.0407970808,
-0.024025185,
0.0846594051,
0.0507179424,
0.0102641797,
-0.0231260285,
0.000560616,
-0.0054082251,
0.0327615775,
-0.0201455336,
-0.0293113533,
-0.0225710776,
0.0330877118,
0.0478165038,
0.0244858898,
0.0161884744,
0.0027778076,
0.0369327553,
-0.0061735199,
-0.0068305219,
-0.0230454784,
0.0254992507,
-0.0048862887,
-0.0203365255,
-0.0218036324,
0.0686072782,
-0.0746018663,
-0.0223077498,
-0.0229903776,
-0.0262688156,
0.017785145,
0.0136232944,
0.0513830371,
-0.0504754931,
-0.007912307,
0.0083417175,
-0.0466079973,
-0.0266307518,
0.0297958404,
0.002265227,
-0.0140373409,
-0.0150685096,
0.0156314895,
-5.607233317e-33,
0.0074292668,
-0.0263343044,
-0.0060561844,
0.0387152545,
-0.0376295894,
0.0041941274,
-0.0333577134,
0.0190826897,
0.0760629997,
0.0043872856,
-0.0006538592,
0.0266328976,
0.0230351705,
-0.0031097275,
0.0230585653,
-0.00777093,
-0.013424092,
-0.0235607699,
0.0080511468,
-0.0283228811,
0.051853776,
0.016473148,
0.0268790834,
-0.0105060851,
0.0245443285,
0.0558509044,
-0.0033673879,
0.0103595527,
0.0175353047,
0.0180927087,
-0.0775482729,
0.0688229129,
0.0279352572,
-0.0141325705,
-0.0064352779,
0.0514174029,
-0.0103416732,
0.0145352557,
0.0324879847,
0.0007810623,
-0.0083694132,
-0.0091186557,
0.0635154918,
0.0001720741,
-0.0053841318,
0.0127449147,
0.0511404313,
-0.0323232114,
-0.0683653504,
0.0109251402,
-0.0621546917,
-0.002053661,
-0.0147730773,
0.0173133109,
0.0350897424,
-0.0005376239,
-0.0196355432,
-0.0217280611,
-0.0268116575,
0.0209468007,
-0.0022599981,
0.0199695323,
0.0172841903,
0.0430040024,
0.0221875515,
0.0583655871,
0.1307115853,
-0.014113863,
-0.0179029983,
-0.0232639574,
0.0433271229,
0.0036252595,
-0.0085870931,
-0.0258269235,
0.0589813255,
-0.0179325119,
0.0113404747,
0.0099679809,
0.0621339791,
-0.0106422948,
0.0270721409,
0.013243543,
-0.0630725548,
-0.0121358735,
-0.0291634426,
0.0183889233,
-0.0609691367,
0.0076040411,
0.0364701897,
-0.0355298631,
0.0374000557,
-0.017868517,
0.0334498733,
-0.0045205555,
0.0439004339,
-0.0556777976,
-0.0078165373,
0.0091834459,
0.0272724368,
-0.0079795364,
0.0006921437,
0.0110265603,
0.0194485523,
0.0036502888,
-0.0123694446,
-0.0342389531,
-0.1030520722,
0.0146303931,
-0.0330012403,
0.0144184018,
-0.0168015286,
-0.0546692014,
0.1102401465,
-0.008910493,
0.0594276823,
-0.0375524685,
-0.006944166,
-0.0511056483,
-0.0090459837,
-0.0138885481,
-0.0098465644,
-0.0054180701,
-0.0407499112,
0.0525088944,
-0.003383293,
-0.0060982965,
-0.0006748698,
-0.0104831951,
-0.0279126521,
-0.0567033216,
-0.0336948447,
0.0571640134,
2.744e-7,
-0.034360569,
0.0444075502,
-0.0131125739,
0.0083196163,
0.0816752315,
-0.0196022633,
0.011876761,
0.0067842826,
0.0299656857,
-0.0386200063,
-0.0042465008,
0.0174983721,
0.0202249065,
-0.0392264426,
-0.0234862585,
-0.1306843311,
-0.0126971472,
0.0826107338,
-0.0324657969,
-0.0167241748,
0.0249502379,
-0.0501279086,
-0.0097857639,
-0.0423828252,
0.0276347026,
-0.0244116578,
0.0668693632,
0.0050221751,
0.0170954634,
-0.0049913563,
-0.0101615479,
-0.0570246354,
-0.0073325117,
0.0591984428,
0.0062369243,
0.0059019993,
0.0312768295,
0.017765766,
0.0028245626,
0.0092170434,
0.0048431326,
0.0125381192,
-0.0023651689,
-0.011036207,
0.0385151394,
-0.0470202751,
-0.0743050352,
-0.0119997766,
-0.0546498559,
-0.0545162633,
0.0184118412,
0.026506627,
-0.0458917953,
-0.0435891189,
-0.0306998361,
0.0330561213,
-0.0254893061,
-0.0462494381,
0.004795243,
0.0797457621,
-0.0791484788,
-0.0146856671,
-0.0508510247,
-0.0261649229,
0.0403282717,
-0.0290858373,
-0.0223974865,
1.719292387e-34,
0.0110843573,
-0.035131745,
0.0303313844,
0.0278064981,
-0.0178185292,
-0.0411785953,
0.0404923372,
-0.020451501,
0.0530341305,
-0.0926195532,
-0.0155409724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13386v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13386v2 | Can LLMs facilitate interpretation of pre-trained language models? | 2023-05-22T18:03:13 | 2023-10-20T13:24:00 | Basel Mousi, Nadir Durrani, Fahim Dalvi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Work done to uncover the knowledge encoded within pre-trained language models
rely on annotated corpora or human-in-the-loop methods. However, these
approaches are limited in terms of scalability and the scope of interpretation.
We propose using a large language model, ChatGPT, as an annotator to enable
fine-grained interpretation analysis of pre-trained language models. We
discover latent concepts within pre-trained language models by applying
agglomerative hierarchical clustering over contextualized representations and
then annotate these concepts using ChatGPT. Our findings demonstrate that
ChatGPT produces accurate and semantically richer annotations compared to
human-annotated concepts. Additionally, we showcase how GPT-based annotations
empower interpretation analysis methodologies of which we demonstrate two:
probing frameworks and neuron interpretation. To facilitate further exploration
and experimentation in the field, we make available a substantial ConceptNet
dataset (TCN) comprising 39,000 annotated concepts. | [
0.0079696523,
0.0161587857,
-0.0313162059,
0.0912906304,
0.0147417849,
0.0403240956,
-0.0010963012,
0.0066448404,
-0.0259445496,
-0.063327089,
-0.0821181461,
-0.0184718445,
-0.0057118675,
0.0335363522,
0.0528429896,
-0.0538158379,
0.0436445773,
-0.0212226491,
0.0003941394,
0.0215838142,
0.0155434888,
0.014126719,
0.0004713173,
0.0766403452,
-0.0053673596,
-0.0460173786,
-0.0209426582,
-0.0069186338,
-0.0093556857,
-0.0132771786,
-0.023317419,
0.0757678673,
0.0734367892,
0.0688326135,
0.0000021112,
-0.0195379704,
-0.001293136,
-0.0106117465,
-0.0640528947,
0.0686908886,
0.0572817586,
-0.0276690405,
-0.0017528351,
-0.0524516627,
-0.0303618778,
-0.0391854532,
0.0561629385,
0.0100853676,
0.0385716744,
0.0313134938,
0.0007245065,
-0.0167531576,
0.0181542616,
-0.0246350635,
0.0273040254,
-0.0468868054,
0.003454325,
0.0532860048,
-0.0292249918,
0.0154552674,
-0.0318686292,
0.0288738646,
0.0183755103,
0.0100055961,
-0.0013049472,
0.0361640304,
-0.0182584971,
-0.0225317199,
0.0041503366,
0.049723804,
-0.0138461823,
-0.0258785654,
-0.0311153065,
-0.0214271508,
-0.0146792056,
-0.007260262,
-0.0475540794,
0.0155585986,
0.0207023509,
0.037484061,
0.0295630582,
0.0157415699,
0.0618459471,
0.0164070576,
-0.0434684567,
0.0659596771,
-0.0066253361,
0.0353660285,
-0.0224568713,
0.0233764779,
-0.0350857303,
-0.0267237406,
0.0047920463,
0.0067468742,
0.0376460627,
0.0492904149,
0.0067410986,
0.0016117729,
0.0185258146,
-0.0404523835,
0.0466689393,
0.0396523066,
-0.0477794074,
0.03823651,
-0.0235351585,
-0.0033606719,
-0.0344725028,
0.0110345827,
-0.041995924,
0.0040906561,
-0.0478011072,
-0.0372523367,
-0.0312434137,
-0.0036989998,
-0.0163184758,
-0.0148665933,
-0.0264187008,
0.039626956,
-0.0002481668,
-0.0399631187,
-0.0251605175,
-0.0056890761,
-0.0272458959,
-0.0052681444,
-0.0294479933,
0.0004795241,
-0.0194534864,
0.0350220986,
-0.0068667675,
-0.0808148533,
-0.0289099682,
0.0247429628,
-0.0177665595,
-0.0408059247,
-0.0179363899,
0.0575734228,
0.0202302765,
-0.0439136513,
-0.0653826967,
-0.0328732654,
-0.0119546466,
-0.0197827257,
0.0035218305,
-0.0634598807,
0.0305310506,
0.025570998,
-0.0007444326,
-0.0450728089,
-0.0164681599,
-0.018132614,
-0.0290489402,
0.0803233609,
-0.065780431,
-0.0055138273,
0.0037939264,
0.0327823162,
-0.0279538166,
0.0613868944,
0.0279280413,
0.0309775192,
0.010060329,
-0.017692456,
-0.0249801874,
0.0470029116,
0.0194444843,
-0.0114303678,
-0.0350431278,
-0.0156864896,
-0.0083172303,
0.0060877115,
0.042551592,
0.0085216779,
-0.0596234389,
-0.0010329589,
0.0466858707,
0.109893851,
-0.0016695893,
0.0188116506,
0.0447477773,
0.0003245019,
0.0433134995,
-0.0165197868,
-0.0612891652,
0.0186515134,
-0.0261747353,
-0.0143308872,
0.004876886,
-0.0021196685,
-0.0153000867,
-0.0339077413,
-0.0145122493,
-0.0054605287,
0.0296980459,
-0.0110072996,
0.0633505732,
0.0093695801,
0.0082681589,
0.0631725788,
0.0543433167,
-0.01999381,
0.0380563959,
-0.0724682882,
0.0211720243,
0.0605550557,
0.0306063909,
-0.0508477502,
-0.0362764634,
0.0092198728,
-0.0102849044,
0.0269517805,
0.0157594513,
-0.0095274355,
0.0286287684,
-0.0226153806,
-0.0037675076,
-0.0230594017,
0.0338706486,
0.0274686664,
0.0052095829,
-0.0363416858,
0.006864341,
-0.0747161433,
-0.0329775661,
0.0317980573,
-0.0141531983,
0.0192351397,
-0.0245568603,
-0.0144303367,
0.0122380508,
0.0296261124,
-0.0062272539,
0.0127545306,
0.0160718355,
-0.0319671035,
0.0255428199,
0.0042801718,
-0.0636616722,
-0.0471305922,
0.0097461175,
0.0106567927,
-0.0373892263,
-0.0205928069,
-0.0416738689,
-0.0050087455,
0.0102947215,
-0.0112275304,
0.0861868188,
-0.0888716504,
-0.0352477841,
-0.0066312291,
0.0283714253,
-0.0204567909,
0.0550083145,
-0.0105140191,
-0.0325059928,
-0.0048693656,
0.0241337214,
0.0198266692,
-0.0131584443,
-0.0314994715,
-0.0120751671,
0.0214550328,
-0.0050317477,
0.0055352435,
0.0113484804,
-0.0388083234,
0.0307373796,
-0.0926205739,
-0.0019080509,
-0.0206464995,
0.0202977806,
0.0684365779,
-0.0185136534,
-0.0030655998,
0.0059933946,
0.0025309897,
0.0193807241,
-0.0121607408,
0.0139397047,
0.0189009774,
0.011669049,
-0.0039591943,
-0.0608939752,
-0.0217271131,
-0.036223799,
0.0762888864,
-0.0041388539,
-0.0371394418,
-0.0336285047,
0.0265783556,
-0.019698225,
-0.0090451622,
-0.0199914258,
-0.0337534361,
0.0366411917,
-0.0408745296,
-0.0123820109,
0.0354406238,
-0.0209876131,
0.1042464077,
0.0646409467,
-0.0087377271,
-0.0461280756,
-0.0412251428,
-0.0046620034,
0.0064772158,
-0.0580410622,
-0.0092530949,
-0.0148237199,
0.1116713583,
0.0330289155,
-0.0120990127,
-0.0540081076,
0.004209144,
-0.0505843461,
-0.0234953985,
-0.0732484534,
0.0153700784,
0.0007136166,
0.0651855543,
-0.0253943652,
-0.054667864,
0.0662453473,
-0.0378345773,
-0.028064657,
0.0123978471,
-0.028211657,
-0.0299333725,
0.0834812596,
0.0256288089,
0.0157921892,
-0.0103594279,
-0.0181763601,
-0.0397782512,
0.0311638974,
-0.0228580646,
-0.0108889025,
0.0468745716,
-0.0427872725,
-0.01469169,
0.0113648819,
0.037285801,
-0.0284698438,
0.0183858313,
-0.029713396,
0.0284364466,
0.056849815,
0.0090168733,
0.0106536373,
0.0252710208,
-0.0057768943,
0.0437970646,
-0.0038577539,
-0.0043832166,
-0.0352242664,
0.0128710028,
0.0114502069,
-0.0181935374,
0.0424007252,
-0.0276240092,
-0.0084751854,
0.0640200898,
-0.0434319824,
-0.0343661904,
-0.063192524,
0.0484881289,
0.0147328582,
-0.0359503701,
-0.0263492763,
-0.0000672846,
0.0219868626,
-0.0882434845,
-0.0115724504,
0.142403245,
0.0339233465,
-0.0820355415,
0.0331550762,
0.0002367363,
0.0178454295,
0.0183454063,
0.0068271407,
-0.076888077,
-0.0238801297,
-0.0228894055,
-0.0073659751,
0.0372514613,
-0.0212816447,
-0.0090700341,
-0.0416849926,
0.034905415,
0.0091065941,
-0.091079466,
0.0199434049,
-0.0238470472,
-0.0059674424,
-0.0265119914,
0.0255495664,
0.0205852184,
0.0094206845,
0.0312349629,
0.0152260847,
-0.0366784632,
-0.0511756614,
0.0379236899,
-0.0300758798,
0.0715342462,
0.0561845079,
0.0122864265,
-0.0285143647,
-0.0026975023,
0.0347899422,
-0.0293133724,
0.0265827831,
-0.0039180778,
0.0258945525,
-0.0185434185,
-0.0078933481,
0.0193657428,
0.0186523758,
-0.0511047766,
-0.0663909614,
-0.0192128364,
0.0619060993,
-0.0256946683,
-0.0028121991,
0.0145187322,
-0.0133447116,
0.0009915065,
0.0852455273,
0.0781720951,
-0.0219392609,
0.0015301927,
-0.0272988118,
0.0067997538,
0.0170273297,
-0.0660185292,
0.006734129,
0.0193592403,
-0.0086231912,
-0.0165898371,
-0.0476200953,
0.0438910723,
-0.0148605397,
0.0030009854,
0.0145141594,
-0.0087383259,
-0.0278084353,
-0.0536613539,
0.0974697396,
-0.0203894991,
-0.0260378737,
-0.0539515801,
-0.0654189289,
0.0162621308,
-0.031900689,
-0.0445319973,
0.0121297939,
-0.0800575465,
-0.0482781865,
0.0252213329,
0.0367788449,
0.0182544999,
0.0309935436,
-0.0058357855,
-0.0559904911,
0.0383573584,
0.0198027249,
-0.0307176113,
0.0079184324,
0.0054908837,
0.0318718143,
0.0045387116,
0.0211275928,
-0.0280005578,
0.0498262756,
0.013830292,
0.0316193998,
-0.0369014218,
-0.0397147276,
0.015172896,
-0.014689697,
0.0861328021,
-0.0085663721,
-0.0021472846,
-0.0599193014,
-0.0254892595,
-0.0082792267,
0.0169484057,
-0.0533387698,
-0.0371378846,
0.0194940679,
-0.0424425639,
-0.0212048143,
-0.0019791359,
-0.0128008919,
0.0266200658,
0.0029051371,
-0.0011203354,
0.0435080528,
0.0024762994,
0.000038404,
0.0167355314,
-0.0054053543,
0.0126996571,
-0.0635831058,
0.0152161857,
-0.0251383353,
0.0343777351,
0.0185580011,
-0.0009925764,
-0.0349298567,
0.0804804116,
-0.0381310247,
-0.0616748296,
-0.0025286884,
0.0191731863,
0.0238995142,
-0.0192000177,
0.0565237477,
-0.0505863912,
0.0040501854,
-0.0214870628,
0.048421178,
-0.0064786612,
-0.0252858754,
0.0370344445,
0.0196472183,
-0.0183724295,
-0.0126218172,
0.0694235936,
0.0004174726,
0.041682262,
0.0122842668,
-0.0174417552,
-0.0078825448,
-0.0164525025,
0.0152620943,
0.0245847143,
-0.0364642665,
0.027536815,
-0.0395111516,
-0.0807269886,
-0.0082698744,
0.0345911793,
-0.0195721798,
0.0092400387,
0.0382683426,
0.0484890193,
-0.0137815811,
0.0018027318,
-0.0120625012,
-0.0031898387,
-0.0110321641,
-0.0161270034,
-0.012745264,
-6.569566094e-33,
-0.054884702,
-0.0333401635,
0.0130940825,
0.0087052509,
-0.0122848917,
0.0102661587,
-0.0624127388,
0.0251929574,
0.0071180309,
0.0285836812,
0.0240875557,
0.0144054033,
0.0022911993,
0.0064946176,
-0.0111792795,
-0.0048856256,
0.0222779568,
0.0097796097,
0.0135789961,
0.0318616703,
0.0441353545,
0.0351011753,
0.0925895125,
-0.0526979044,
0.0532646812,
0.0141888885,
0.0072558415,
0.0218024179,
0.0016392234,
0.0598042384,
-0.0637719035,
0.0180127174,
0.0365631059,
-0.0231973622,
-0.0323234349,
-0.024119366,
-0.0615640953,
-0.026813712,
0.0509615317,
0.0267063268,
-0.0238398481,
-0.0277419798,
0.04444924,
-0.0242375433,
0.0100832833,
0.0129351588,
0.0328039341,
-0.0114044938,
-0.0103691025,
0.0035358644,
-0.0736902729,
0.0157985762,
-0.0251019243,
0.0108862482,
0.0546347573,
-0.0131423483,
-0.0214226563,
0.0400990956,
-0.0822321475,
-0.0037804449,
-0.0080248928,
0.0315406397,
0.0869472697,
0.0493203998,
0.0163481981,
0.0682180375,
0.0136664314,
-0.0312170442,
-0.0578800812,
0.0201860014,
0.0950964764,
0.0346284099,
-0.0071336734,
-0.0021361317,
0.0046326793,
0.0199989323,
-0.0436853245,
0.0168100689,
-0.0285380594,
0.0162338372,
0.029878756,
0.018882012,
0.0138599901,
-0.026561752,
-0.0578935221,
-0.0758174211,
-0.0358110331,
-0.0599285401,
0.0200602822,
-0.0623899288,
-0.0361542553,
-0.0110514574,
0.0393014662,
-0.0364566892,
0.0068750447,
0.0098179979,
-0.0004638362,
-0.0055283494,
0.0148761775,
0.0277936067,
-0.0390309617,
-0.0514363088,
0.0231049638,
-0.0365350246,
0.0459333435,
0.0128338067,
0.0446564704,
0.0143011268,
0.0184582006,
0.0060813497,
-0.0337009542,
-0.0539789386,
0.0054907845,
0.0107853385,
0.0381364301,
0.0017213593,
-0.0283918399,
0.0443235151,
0.036495287,
0.0029397642,
-0.0021872851,
0.0140345832,
-0.0064366111,
0.0186904725,
-0.0504783392,
-0.0138133401,
-0.0105912872,
0.0096656,
0.0712186322,
-0.0416029282,
-0.019045677,
0.0064029475,
2.669e-7,
0.1188158095,
0.0583693981,
0.0080948845,
0.0199825168,
0.0539826937,
0.02247582,
-0.0108901029,
0.0127464971,
-0.0116918748,
-0.0503386632,
0.0280692782,
0.0627878532,
0.0105235111,
0.0202288944,
-0.0266879927,
0.0199223049,
-0.0326192416,
0.0275665969,
-0.0284697674,
0.0121110752,
0.0418891311,
0.1024939269,
0.0091928262,
0.0029760564,
0.0277468394,
-0.0291378722,
0.067338489,
-0.0687187836,
0.0074162981,
0.0229312312,
0.0159192327,
0.0287991203,
0.0114230951,
-0.0001433124,
0.020678889,
0.0034234747,
0.0108936056,
0.0620563738,
-0.0372201838,
-0.0097046355,
-0.0211713519,
-0.01693267,
0.0019772288,
-0.09163104,
0.0588197708,
-0.0835031942,
-0.021434145,
-0.0326922536,
0.0287077446,
-0.0388823375,
0.0022343122,
-0.0114532616,
0.0019576368,
0.0299047977,
-0.004797183,
-0.0227173977,
-0.027754005,
-0.0603121854,
-0.026467843,
0.0103989365,
-0.0398489721,
-0.0164875332,
-0.0330377445,
-0.0275690146,
0.0290926285,
-0.0161384009,
-0.005250067,
2.312491262e-34,
0.0111234654,
0.0101833306,
0.0192201678,
0.0594985262,
0.0375961401,
0.0116931982,
-0.0026678124,
0.0080548888,
-0.012058137,
-0.0910957456,
-0.0140281366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13309v1 | Evaluating Factual Consistency of Texts with Semantic Role Labeling | 2023-05-22T17:59:42 | 2023-05-22T17:59:42 | Jing Fan, Dennis Aumiller, Michael Gertz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated evaluation of text generation systems has recently seen increasing
attention, particularly checking whether generated text stays truthful to input
sources. Existing methods frequently rely on an evaluation using task-specific
language models, which in turn allows for little interpretability of generated
scores. We introduce SRLScore, a reference-free evaluation metric designed with
text summarization in mind. Our approach generates fact tuples constructed from
Semantic Role Labels, applied to both input and summary texts. A final
factuality score is computed by an adjustable scoring mechanism, which allows
for easy adaption of the method across domains. Correlation with human
judgments on English summarization datasets shows that SRLScore is competitive
with state-of-the-art methods and exhibits stable generalization across
datasets without requiring further training or hyperparameter tuning. We
experiment with an optional co-reference resolution step, but find that the
performance boost is mostly outweighed by the additional compute required. Our
metric is available online at https://github.com/heyjing/SRLScore. | [
0.0371168293,
-0.0094381534,
0.0434043482,
0.0038630094,
-0.0523171946,
0.010428329,
0.0098936222,
-0.0653828755,
-0.0277400687,
-0.0634178892,
0.0212595724,
-0.0348793119,
0.0279582199,
0.0318739861,
0.0040719933,
-0.0280150622,
0.0267379042,
0.027650699,
0.019707866,
-0.0035386404,
0.0240425132,
0.0317154229,
-0.0133883012,
0.038422633,
-0.0606502779,
0.0040146168,
0.0437619239,
-0.0087525574,
0.0850596428,
0.0195999146,
-0.0024221311,
0.0336804688,
-0.0075266198,
0.0098402286,
0.0000020842,
-0.0505449213,
-0.0232318155,
0.016844498,
0.010449212,
0.0161995851,
0.045848757,
-0.0037971588,
0.0184909105,
0.0021801728,
-0.0276319459,
0.0046321503,
0.0255989712,
0.0297679622,
0.1017367989,
0.067172125,
0.000774872,
0.0014087517,
-0.0102316737,
0.0111337034,
-0.0050537246,
0.0040173572,
-0.0176629405,
0.0720605254,
-0.0146177271,
0.004060396,
0.0271677505,
0.0172723606,
0.0269587133,
-0.0422450006,
0.0121058831,
0.0318937525,
-0.0244063735,
-0.0195803922,
0.0523520261,
0.0346591435,
0.0276400317,
-0.0093443515,
0.0171900783,
0.006688213,
-0.0006251595,
0.0252547208,
-0.016743958,
0.0775488764,
-0.0165726598,
0.0134973526,
0.0281505305,
0.0370200202,
-0.0005850749,
0.0117804781,
0.0028109697,
0.0603549071,
0.0063489517,
-0.0361242332,
-0.0304351598,
0.0269585066,
-0.0321067348,
-0.0571253225,
0.0083506256,
0.0090914126,
-0.0538241081,
0.0081447065,
-0.0810416043,
-0.010588021,
0.0240633469,
-0.0469861999,
-0.0120083559,
0.0127874576,
-0.021485975,
0.0032941902,
-0.0096918624,
0.0587402955,
0.0626599789,
0.0038901363,
-0.0446888842,
-0.0072226077,
-0.0369354002,
0.0169430394,
-0.0150885331,
0.0351668037,
-0.0143991951,
-0.0127391526,
-0.0624286346,
-0.0151397875,
-0.0248640161,
0.0489811487,
0.0247357264,
0.0215766411,
0.0010606589,
0.0223528016,
-0.0225864928,
0.0211144257,
-0.0296466593,
-0.0280015338,
0.0139870187,
0.0019459294,
0.0000911502,
0.0094666118,
0.0044359341,
0.0020630846,
-0.0010702801,
0.00348166,
-0.0214185752,
-0.009227518,
-0.0291511286,
-0.064201057,
-0.0301074851,
-0.0938655138,
-0.0409056358,
-0.0844402313,
-0.0004412794,
-0.0035802824,
-0.0280719623,
-0.0267028455,
0.0254822895,
0.0576402172,
-0.0277782548,
0.0149342883,
-0.0147184711,
-0.0109289689,
0.0099353697,
0.0093128672,
0.0096107405,
0.0327631459,
0.0388784967,
0.0474734455,
0.0472923182,
0.0603131726,
-0.0104898149,
-0.0133071057,
-0.0095719863,
-0.0148147466,
0.05839983,
-0.0092350086,
-0.0017689347,
0.0144869527,
0.0292529315,
0.0458466895,
-0.0156032592,
-0.0075393738,
0.0520378612,
-0.0189524051,
-0.0070439423,
0.0107340701,
0.077838175,
0.0415311866,
0.0263877213,
0.0640858784,
-0.0295012873,
0.0194204375,
-0.0022082129,
0.0428887606,
0.0453191102,
0.0308229905,
0.0091206813,
-0.0705152601,
-0.0172319617,
-0.0196427759,
-0.0165858567,
-0.0192377791,
0.0147853084,
0.0169654507,
-0.0336024761,
0.0479101129,
0.0336620212,
-0.0844481513,
0.0422752611,
0.0122465957,
0.0248940997,
0.0408778898,
0.0371235274,
-0.0281844847,
-0.0198368654,
-0.0080365818,
0.0094449632,
0.0566504598,
0.0214679204,
-0.0139338113,
-0.009504959,
-0.0366699435,
-0.0003398374,
-0.0165649951,
0.0133220199,
0.0015676611,
0.007633727,
-0.0172214471,
0.056678988,
-0.0392619558,
-0.0760530457,
0.0410779379,
0.0143599492,
-0.0147405146,
0.0216642935,
-0.0034923013,
-0.013088908,
0.0433488861,
-0.0519304276,
0.0302149039,
-0.0105835628,
-0.0308166873,
-0.0053476347,
0.0113272602,
-0.0340668038,
-0.0419053547,
0.0440985523,
-0.0512096249,
-0.0367514938,
0.0461067073,
-0.0392336249,
-0.0507027321,
0.0165093672,
-0.0695021003,
-0.0876743346,
-0.0409665257,
-0.0103779621,
0.0504246056,
-0.0186443329,
-0.0320426077,
0.0825263783,
0.0182131678,
0.0151243089,
0.0278599672,
-0.0137437657,
0.0169138238,
-0.0362800583,
-0.0121494215,
-0.0211312268,
-0.0160509143,
0.0167518016,
0.0875438824,
0.0243982878,
-0.0010633294,
-0.0107392818,
-0.0558330603,
0.0026806351,
-0.0396678224,
0.013370052,
0.068407774,
-0.0224211514,
0.0167563614,
0.0364069715,
-0.0582812689,
-0.0516449586,
0.0361528695,
-0.029252883,
0.0455795228,
-0.0089837313,
0.0318317525,
-0.0387827791,
0.0151672075,
0.0016916074,
0.0443669446,
0.0581018962,
0.0318431817,
-0.0281674545,
0.0153282583,
-0.0581772663,
-0.0400976688,
0.0409066081,
0.0024883905,
-0.0105501683,
0.0502665676,
0.0328971557,
0.0204985626,
0.0534322634,
0.0019071527,
0.0325512029,
0.0050982093,
-0.0112355296,
0.0008286323,
-0.026770398,
0.0192239415,
0.0181649812,
-0.0839454904,
0.0491851941,
0.0352711305,
0.0279858056,
-0.0248258729,
-0.023491865,
0.0066943695,
-0.0567261502,
-0.0141626839,
-0.0314820185,
-0.0132921534,
-0.0069971397,
0.0244665332,
-0.0443688855,
-0.008223353,
0.0788786784,
-0.0684613436,
0.0214200858,
-0.0788269639,
-0.0114217652,
-0.0314599536,
0.0315603837,
0.028166879,
0.0470348597,
-0.0088065937,
0.0443013757,
-0.031418331,
-0.0004625783,
0.0895153657,
-0.018609846,
0.0384460129,
-0.0587810688,
0.0175180566,
-0.0211906284,
-0.0055210921,
-0.0407019742,
-0.0267921183,
0.0085844919,
0.0183396004,
0.0178399161,
-0.0168504547,
-0.0444950238,
-0.0213229712,
0.0544892699,
0.0322045088,
-0.0212343689,
-0.0124141844,
-0.0031324588,
0.0404701047,
0.0597712845,
0.0249174759,
0.0346401148,
0.0130922114,
-0.0008946355,
0.0503074601,
-0.0364069678,
-0.0005089647,
0.0072886925,
-0.015517992,
-0.0116040492,
-0.0716725886,
0.0079909805,
0.0033317322,
0.0387213565,
-0.0291647092,
-0.0387421325,
0.1159586683,
0.0360661931,
0.0168466028,
-0.0011713287,
0.0306042228,
0.0189378932,
0.0063156113,
-0.0067202928,
-0.0647270381,
-0.0009614888,
-0.0130414693,
0.0340160616,
-0.0194844045,
-0.0448702648,
-0.0248320661,
-0.0841008872,
0.0494698472,
-0.0124014113,
-0.0242030639,
-0.0249575879,
-0.0243053939,
0.0043412284,
-0.0187874008,
0.0001837074,
0.027362708,
-0.0090053072,
0.026637312,
0.0218366086,
-0.0609441325,
-0.0084436052,
0.0040431614,
-0.0468914434,
0.0213487465,
0.0513819754,
0.0434735194,
0.0153352004,
0.011899096,
-0.0047770282,
0.0137842335,
-0.0365979262,
0.0194160286,
0.0605410226,
-0.0227116495,
0.0074317819,
-0.0172832217,
0.0311111975,
0.0215790197,
-0.0335769244,
0.0129333045,
0.0085051293,
0.0098472862,
-0.0143614402,
-0.0180860367,
0.053211987,
0.0005709392,
0.0908062831,
0.0366508998,
-0.0067744134,
-0.0279768258,
-0.0441396311,
0.0034267702,
-0.0955445543,
-0.0620746724,
0.0092148194,
-0.0261186454,
-0.0275449809,
-0.1088656634,
-0.0401428901,
-0.0109669128,
-0.0206516162,
-0.0346811973,
-0.0453302115,
0.0228927843,
-0.0231372304,
-0.0580923259,
-0.0306199286,
-0.0333173946,
0.0259593148,
-0.0058345483,
-0.0212233048,
0.021405451,
-0.0434574336,
-0.0158731993,
0.0161811523,
-0.0207684096,
-0.0263563227,
0.0108040851,
0.0307656266,
0.0143826073,
0.0326078907,
-0.008001145,
-0.001829199,
0.056772586,
0.0662894547,
-0.0385905914,
0.0376741588,
-0.0051947311,
0.00872292,
-0.0128586786,
0.0114531424,
-0.0489836298,
0.0343380086,
-0.042308677,
0.0339332111,
0.0135135883,
-0.0341109782,
0.0392174907,
0.0602258183,
0.0168354325,
-0.039936386,
0.0466325618,
-0.0347992666,
-0.0445660874,
-0.0469773859,
-0.0518462211,
-0.0422518812,
0.0543173775,
-0.0148426648,
0.0236455258,
-0.0028047299,
0.0475293174,
-0.018136112,
0.0224552471,
-0.0156356934,
-0.0328653678,
-0.0350086242,
0.0169551894,
-0.0433505587,
-0.0378362425,
-0.0653834939,
-0.0295454059,
-0.0324843451,
0.0207267236,
0.0016952147,
-0.0180904977,
0.0454153717,
0.0010485416,
0.0211479999,
0.0122458423,
-0.0635814965,
0.0421909019,
-0.0797770694,
-0.0089541394,
0.0386231095,
-0.02046551,
0.0707056969,
-0.0615754649,
-0.0004050056,
-0.0148978913,
0.0382165238,
0.0463720374,
0.0011680535,
-0.0508458205,
0.0029713791,
-0.0019589644,
-0.0114994776,
0.0919567719,
-0.0064754393,
-0.0108353412,
0.0069595105,
-0.0518058687,
-0.0506281815,
-0.0789912045,
-0.0899726078,
0.0117209814,
0.0028245728,
-0.0446553603,
-0.0828516111,
-0.0355613008,
0.0208748318,
0.0566468574,
0.0463915542,
-0.0116391964,
0.0278323814,
0.0258911233,
0.0042378637,
0.0269204825,
-0.0455682501,
-0.0106875282,
-0.0264827404,
0.0103735877,
-0.0280043259,
-6.164239478e-33,
-0.0471195616,
-0.0571154021,
-0.0066163121,
0.0023830752,
-0.0242621265,
0.0366104878,
-0.0326594748,
-0.0059377635,
0.0289275888,
0.0520651266,
0.0484302528,
-0.0245870408,
0.0110224374,
0.0385965817,
-0.022412654,
-0.0091926707,
0.0467013828,
0.0259235296,
-0.0800976306,
0.0146157471,
0.0569192357,
-0.0316219702,
0.0470172092,
-0.0782677084,
0.0682150498,
-0.0189872663,
-0.0308546573,
0.0136516215,
0.01540945,
0.0167889986,
0.0215073209,
0.0616401695,
0.0211898983,
-0.0680208653,
-0.0262007825,
0.0055703041,
-0.0710004121,
-0.0418390483,
0.0564088486,
-0.0475959368,
-0.0582247525,
-0.0146042025,
0.0153933922,
-0.0053531826,
-0.0021933701,
-0.0499538146,
0.0563480631,
-0.0323717929,
0.000958914,
-0.0737966523,
-0.0520179644,
0.0359328277,
-0.0157002062,
-0.0258961171,
-0.0416978747,
0.0398394093,
0.0067559429,
-0.0340565257,
-0.049846027,
0.0271748006,
-0.0278359894,
0.0415564366,
0.0513145998,
0.0051856469,
-0.0266071092,
0.0743448809,
-0.0338823274,
0.0149124768,
-0.0712451115,
0.0000591519,
-0.0272383448,
0.0213969201,
0.0287543852,
0.0862500519,
0.0203762725,
0.0162960328,
-0.0775128528,
0.1008234546,
0.0043073753,
-0.0008207575,
0.0201067962,
-0.0528330505,
-0.0079211937,
-0.0220925845,
-0.054496225,
0.064894937,
-0.021372607,
-0.0182912499,
-0.0104986886,
0.0078396853,
-0.0747061968,
0.0052880184,
-0.0061086598,
-0.0094325189,
0.0343179964,
0.004940026,
-0.0569138005,
-0.0122081134,
-0.0131819202,
-0.0182698425,
-0.0236203112,
0.0305331387,
0.0126863904,
0.0348536223,
-0.0041418811,
0.0095178932,
0.0437847748,
-0.0050909719,
-0.0093625048,
0.0455218703,
-0.0252814777,
0.0484261736,
-0.025346471,
0.0098092183,
-0.0065322593,
-0.0144447396,
-0.0276436154,
0.0119000953,
-0.0113804303,
0.0114206113,
-0.0047614514,
0.0155556919,
0.0174045991,
0.0146542275,
-0.0286937766,
0.0398545749,
-0.0237834919,
0.0022795752,
0.0215893965,
-0.0211378429,
0.0045581567,
-0.003605824,
2.648e-7,
0.031906981,
0.0277749505,
0.0496187769,
0.027809348,
-0.0269853435,
0.0341653712,
0.02790148,
0.0433639698,
0.0168453548,
-0.0414748378,
0.0172028597,
0.0388787575,
0.0323537998,
0.0594058707,
-0.0622353628,
-0.0246252418,
-0.0840312392,
-0.0484741591,
-0.0193985105,
-0.0045801331,
0.0853457525,
0.0159627739,
0.0002256857,
-0.0122995973,
0.017172657,
-0.0178295858,
0.045465149,
0.003332515,
-0.0482523553,
0.0185883883,
0.085991405,
-0.0226631854,
0.006936722,
-0.0053285249,
-0.0084600868,
-0.0200850144,
0.0403728187,
0.0227019247,
0.0485149622,
-0.0035165031,
-0.0011020794,
-0.0321684591,
0.03029125,
-0.005233739,
0.0501952507,
-0.0419265926,
-0.0107171955,
-0.0295810103,
-0.0447395407,
0.0396679826,
-0.0004141103,
0.0139880776,
-0.0355714336,
0.0703490451,
-0.0058085676,
-0.005086191,
-0.0005745312,
-0.0136835892,
-0.0960127264,
-0.0011141793,
-0.0088207498,
-0.0283104572,
-0.0018321323,
-0.0112860017,
0.0050085834,
-0.0660082102,
0.0032618497,
2.549607758e-34,
0.0632369593,
0.0071457885,
-0.0162994601,
-0.0568401068,
0.0564657599,
0.0037180425,
-0.052630838,
-0.0063998881,
-0.0007047053,
-0.0139371669,
0.0004531036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13304v1 | RecurrentGPT: Interactive Generation of (Arbitrarily) Long Text | 2023-05-22T17:58:10 | 2023-05-22T17:58:10 | Wangchunshu Zhou, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Peng Cui, Tiannan Wang, Zhenxin Xiao, Yifan Hou, Ryan Cotterell, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The fixed-size context of Transformer makes GPT models incapable of
generating arbitrarily long text. In this paper, we introduce RecurrentGPT, a
language-based simulacrum of the recurrence mechanism in RNNs. RecurrentGPT is
built upon a large language model (LLM) such as ChatGPT and uses natural
language to simulate the Long Short-Term Memory mechanism in an LSTM. At each
timestep, RecurrentGPT generates a paragraph of text and updates its
language-based long-short term memory stored on the hard drive and the prompt,
respectively. This recurrence mechanism enables RecurrentGPT to generate texts
of arbitrary length without forgetting. Since human users can easily observe
and edit the natural language memories, RecurrentGPT is interpretable and
enables interactive generation of long text. RecurrentGPT is an initial step
towards next-generation computer-assisted writing systems beyond local editing
suggestions. In addition to producing AI-generated content (AIGC), we also
demonstrate the possibility of using RecurrentGPT as an interactive fiction
that directly interacts with consumers. We call this usage of generative models
by ``AI As Contents'' (AIAC), which we believe is the next form of conventional
AIGC. We further demonstrate the possibility of using RecurrentGPT to create
personalized interactive fiction that directly interacts with readers instead
of interacting with writers. More broadly, RecurrentGPT demonstrates the
utility of borrowing ideas from popular model designs in cognitive science and
deep learning for prompting LLMs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/aiwaves-cn/RecurrentGPT and an online demo is available at
https://www.aiwaves.org/recurrentgpt. | [
0.0377699099,
0.0014320759,
-0.0111489119,
0.0173084941,
-0.0610961504,
-0.0107406583,
0.0217186417,
0.0077398573,
0.0423587002,
-0.0154972924,
-0.011626075,
-0.0547751151,
0.0303452667,
0.0645700246,
0.0204102434,
-0.0699412897,
-0.0004054519,
-0.0207370799,
0.0160941575,
0.0024394579,
0.0070137633,
0.0107820509,
-0.0084639955,
0.0353532918,
-0.0046221353,
-0.0558307469,
-0.0444580838,
-0.0080655068,
-0.0024340176,
-0.0284581669,
-0.0069089606,
0.0137285767,
0.0389511399,
0.0643581301,
0.0000020655,
-0.0338647366,
0.0225023385,
-0.0197694041,
0.0011577061,
0.0069060083,
0.0540477708,
0.0279177781,
-0.0315175653,
-0.0041878177,
-0.0286223404,
0.0123360734,
0.054138124,
0.0662511587,
0.0578428805,
0.0812043846,
-0.0043149744,
-0.0228674226,
0.0250885431,
-0.0415441394,
0.0839819834,
0.0250118449,
-0.0001128938,
-0.0292088091,
0.0562525764,
0.0264037102,
-0.0241636652,
0.0411814004,
0.0550963432,
-0.0232265051,
0.0325705521,
0.0681503937,
0.024561815,
-0.009009433,
-0.0258859787,
0.0281139836,
-0.0056038662,
-0.0230824947,
0.0109542543,
0.0123959593,
0.0036544539,
-0.0143983662,
-0.0600744486,
0.0247424282,
-0.0151191698,
0.0058613271,
-0.0086180558,
-0.0072124605,
0.0227165595,
-0.0170661304,
0.0292981528,
-0.0027176305,
0.036031954,
-0.0265866164,
-0.0441250615,
-0.0119473087,
0.0211139005,
-0.0864094198,
0.0273144171,
0.0668272674,
-0.0073229419,
0.0035825251,
-0.0433275588,
0.0032502441,
0.0015453685,
-0.0326509513,
0.0491651855,
0.0138151878,
0.0125810998,
0.0226047561,
-0.0170495939,
0.0514043719,
-0.0386490934,
-0.0220743194,
-0.0043849195,
0.0415007509,
-0.0408335999,
-0.0525910929,
-0.0451414399,
0.0316989496,
-0.0270408876,
-0.046867393,
-0.06072478,
0.0417829603,
0.0291442554,
0.0246103425,
0.0138978446,
0.0285097547,
-0.0496547371,
0.0005781238,
-0.0370026864,
-0.0023065375,
-0.0347142592,
-0.0371490642,
0.0338718705,
-0.0329990089,
-0.0074370448,
0.0133031914,
0.0346752182,
-0.0146297449,
-0.021396935,
0.0845885649,
-0.0248582698,
-0.0160594918,
-0.0408523604,
-0.0448248014,
-0.016809674,
-0.0512465984,
0.0256832018,
-0.0543742701,
0.0191891659,
-0.0250190888,
-0.0142749297,
-0.0544510968,
-0.0052646594,
0.0416007899,
0.010785019,
0.0526288822,
-0.0206817035,
-0.0239736177,
0.056804806,
0.0209852867,
0.0341259129,
-0.0116859348,
0.0871777236,
0.0739237592,
0.0149277635,
0.002634939,
0.0664227158,
0.0340866335,
-0.0168341193,
-0.0199446995,
-0.0150866499,
-0.0431736633,
-0.015953768,
0.0745303631,
-0.0200529862,
0.0603341796,
-0.0067543169,
-0.0019526347,
0.0765888989,
0.0464152806,
0.03101613,
0.0859978199,
0.060118109,
0.0136606684,
-0.0138631845,
0.0216311701,
-0.0216605235,
0.0839237347,
0.0061795171,
0.0341585129,
0.0055612973,
0.0175723974,
-0.0071076937,
-0.0305818003,
0.0059263846,
-0.0197643358,
0.0309396759,
-0.0326632038,
0.0167843346,
0.0402253866,
-0.0595282465,
-0.0192087721,
-0.0025184292,
-0.0779088065,
0.0177498236,
-0.0283880774,
0.0596591458,
0.1275207251,
0.0537793078,
-0.0175474919,
0.0145536801,
-0.0352463573,
-0.0200528,
0.0693089142,
0.0172105711,
0.0149214799,
-0.0186631083,
-0.0404778235,
0.0052142609,
-0.0261367522,
-0.0224819183,
0.058394447,
0.0001927674,
0.0452144146,
0.0163215939,
0.0263978317,
-0.0329922363,
0.0174423996,
-0.0659181625,
-0.0636418238,
-0.003071412,
-0.0193414036,
-0.0007045065,
0.0175663158,
-0.014456816,
0.0122312168,
0.0192396492,
-0.0451377109,
-0.0596272126,
0.0198049732,
-0.0757893994,
-0.0190303493,
0.0135901067,
-0.0425974093,
0.0276846141,
0.0033219068,
-0.0001158264,
-0.052197203,
0.0340489931,
-0.0704325363,
0.0398968793,
-0.0425997302,
-0.0053936043,
0.0293846875,
0.0098877028,
-0.0059904763,
0.0272443965,
0.0104897385,
-0.0250293054,
0.0264033638,
0.0408582315,
-0.0002187314,
-0.0482170433,
-0.0119768688,
0.0331309885,
0.0216804072,
-0.0037691973,
0.0367605053,
0.0281764958,
-0.0373702087,
-0.0479420498,
-0.0729866177,
-0.0025977406,
0.0059479317,
-0.0252860822,
0.007301826,
0.0328880474,
-0.0154703837,
0.007742323,
-0.0900669917,
-0.0100209704,
0.0035537684,
0.0084276339,
0.0446655042,
0.0020997236,
0.0056078243,
-0.0305767767,
0.000406473,
0.0008409209,
0.039018292,
0.0533948764,
-0.0256217234,
-0.0615222827,
0.0009901981,
-0.0229461212,
0.0171603635,
-0.0178221669,
-0.0421243384,
0.0198932681,
-0.0287416354,
0.0974795446,
0.0667726472,
0.035428673,
0.0349046811,
0.0247019362,
-0.0431524329,
-0.0062593482,
0.0322626606,
-0.0294527318,
-0.0124232089,
0.0259476304,
-0.0197724923,
0.0272084437,
0.0639228672,
0.0324159265,
0.0045707133,
-0.0434246548,
0.0386509895,
0.0003582589,
0.0004000301,
-0.0100332741,
-0.0162386633,
-0.0446149223,
0.0170339104,
-0.0061338088,
-0.0526983291,
0.0597420707,
-0.0494267121,
-0.0267189499,
-0.0170608386,
0.0030763913,
-0.027492851,
0.0661691651,
0.0155406203,
0.0130701279,
0.011552358,
0.005609395,
-0.0211089402,
0.0128400605,
0.0040506367,
-0.0178640969,
-0.0075105829,
-0.026037395,
-0.0118771931,
0.0045238109,
-0.0134875337,
-0.0291615408,
0.003120746,
-0.0010659568,
-0.0401126482,
0.0269708522,
-0.0470430218,
-0.0021385024,
-0.0068515781,
0.0538748987,
0.0643462166,
-0.0283758026,
-0.0175482556,
-0.0200437456,
0.0331343152,
0.0510625578,
-0.0126206018,
-0.041739624,
-0.030069964,
0.0124395853,
0.0351429321,
-0.0428827628,
0.0080561405,
-0.0302435253,
0.0159655809,
-0.0142747425,
-0.0211308077,
-0.0135231698,
0.0171415526,
0.0271959808,
-0.0792790502,
-0.0414900072,
0.1102698892,
0.0194398668,
-0.0551973283,
-0.0080798566,
0.0118368035,
0.0402131006,
-0.0135025624,
0.0278829783,
-0.0721311644,
-0.0093340501,
0.0159624554,
0.0052149193,
-0.0067281439,
-0.0264085997,
-0.0463681407,
-0.0667929128,
0.0362830646,
0.0136133479,
-0.0078906035,
-0.0002735483,
-0.0063412623,
-0.0505576655,
0.0535979904,
-0.0235369895,
0.0199224222,
-0.0046396144,
0.0027525283,
-0.0339993797,
-0.0302716661,
0.028728934,
-0.0072944909,
0.0003185014,
0.051922407,
0.0830637515,
0.0679253191,
-0.0019595195,
-0.0484935753,
-0.0074333032,
0.0253977571,
0.0290350225,
0.0009557761,
0.021413492,
-0.001680979,
-0.0038594876,
-0.0416063145,
0.051051233,
-0.017867431,
-0.020473076,
0.0409220755,
0.0418884084,
-0.0255653411,
-0.0331211947,
-0.0233416352,
0.0176271871,
0.0266874935,
0.0568462797,
0.0262668002,
-0.0720286593,
-0.0691213459,
-0.0455931127,
0.0108335372,
-0.0544154011,
-0.0652161315,
-0.0432418212,
0.011687018,
-0.01191629,
-0.0907385498,
-0.0588007271,
0.0021736482,
0.0115452148,
0.0221267175,
0.0035437373,
0.0221709833,
0.0026779242,
-0.0352643095,
-0.0303272065,
-0.0476580374,
-0.0009227978,
-0.0543874539,
-0.0112911211,
0.0224993639,
-0.079998292,
0.0124801621,
0.042177666,
-0.0983356908,
-0.051682543,
0.0171387941,
0.0364837348,
0.0246686209,
0.0425692126,
0.0092079835,
-0.0292774178,
0.0575234704,
0.013077653,
-0.0162044242,
0.027653642,
-0.0010836989,
0.06113616,
0.007823769,
-0.000907695,
-0.0186167657,
0.0004927742,
0.0114093628,
0.0008484836,
0.0241104141,
-0.0369917005,
-0.0068715396,
-0.0046431515,
-0.0134028187,
-0.0272875428,
0.0056996495,
-0.0343537517,
0.0067962892,
-0.0293970797,
0.0176366325,
-0.043427892,
0.0123702073,
0.0117215877,
-0.0097235693,
-0.0121924113,
-0.0228051469,
-0.0117081758,
-0.0107734092,
-0.0421931557,
-0.0005620572,
-0.0114010563,
0.005191532,
0.0354656912,
-0.0010345281,
-0.0069819051,
0.0324643813,
-0.0599270165,
0.0245248359,
-0.0008116097,
0.065762341,
0.0210101008,
-0.0250298642,
-0.0049919267,
0.0439262167,
-0.0539433993,
-0.0256648939,
-0.0074047535,
0.0695499703,
0.0366761833,
0.0257775988,
0.0062782299,
-0.058033403,
0.0185284279,
-0.0150373718,
0.0548471622,
0.0306452215,
-0.054278519,
-0.0403792411,
0.0147972861,
-0.0205434076,
0.0019685349,
0.0749374628,
-0.0150539307,
0.0095609017,
0.0325369574,
-0.0034042422,
-0.0493547022,
-0.0274164565,
-0.0154573377,
-0.0048129642,
0.0279222466,
-0.012571346,
-0.0220220461,
-0.0453722738,
0.0652737245,
0.0198427923,
-0.0060828552,
-0.0304408744,
0.0619636588,
0.0200515147,
-0.0261288229,
0.009847342,
-0.0056712995,
0.0469762869,
-0.0135839283,
-0.0603038818,
-0.0542235635,
-5.761865191e-33,
-0.0181046147,
-0.0429453515,
0.0146109564,
0.046574939,
-0.0697076395,
-0.0229394548,
-0.0514864959,
-0.0099850697,
0.0648307353,
0.0025981227,
-0.0344861858,
0.0044308291,
0.0008201244,
0.0555969663,
-0.0055769309,
-0.023343483,
0.0560213029,
0.0116748363,
-0.0304765478,
0.0711132884,
0.0487939939,
0.0388270281,
0.0229913648,
-0.0498990491,
0.0410034508,
-0.0534842908,
-0.0094183432,
-0.0173583385,
-0.0103941979,
0.0369345881,
-0.0679765269,
0.0450173579,
0.0168336537,
-0.0336720087,
-0.0112105543,
0.070286192,
-0.0418776833,
-0.0395387672,
-0.0140935304,
-0.0037093295,
-0.0683205128,
-0.0742188767,
0.0301105641,
-0.0247980468,
-0.0022913008,
0.0079423962,
0.0451453254,
-0.0076758983,
-0.01160035,
-0.028240243,
-0.0660625547,
-0.0193637125,
-0.0019918915,
-0.0356729887,
-0.0104666427,
-0.0100989258,
0.0116315437,
0.0074959905,
-0.083406575,
0.0145132691,
0.0256477874,
0.0445045196,
0.0056114905,
0.0202043355,
0.0241724625,
0.0358504467,
0.0242260452,
0.0113689657,
-0.0662232041,
0.0415070504,
-0.0023559579,
-0.0173308887,
0.0602699593,
0.0482485332,
0.0346247442,
-0.013672648,
-0.0055014137,
0.0160801653,
0.0108487839,
0.0206113346,
0.0495700315,
0.0059025567,
-0.0106978025,
-0.0151408389,
-0.0047839223,
0.0080915391,
-0.0207916871,
-0.0491596758,
0.0278333165,
0.0121584982,
0.0116516128,
-0.0381770842,
-0.0097463569,
0.0105231497,
0.00754984,
0.0097112842,
-0.0119964862,
0.0338813663,
-0.0025886381,
-0.0080194604,
0.0122876838,
0.0161976758,
0.0231146552,
0.0212545432,
0.0019921872,
0.0274345875,
0.009231179,
0.0697842538,
-0.0654076636,
0.0006347265,
-0.0277960431,
0.0580716692,
0.0244983099,
0.003557462,
0.008008034,
-0.0182599146,
-0.0307005029,
0.0481001809,
-0.0127473315,
0.0004652199,
-0.0365262106,
-0.0266762096,
-0.0179610532,
-0.0083714398,
-0.037877731,
0.0185533892,
-0.0351141244,
0.0526557788,
0.0298153833,
-0.0709848106,
0.015380349,
0.0093738567,
2.762e-7,
-0.0439650305,
0.0266132113,
0.0637911633,
0.0231229942,
0.0481581576,
0.0137787573,
0.0115077207,
0.0358143933,
0.0117933555,
-0.0234264825,
-0.0028647596,
0.0276568793,
0.0370033607,
-0.0098004779,
-0.1176958755,
0.021350177,
-0.0946142673,
0.0172799192,
-0.0530527979,
-0.028303219,
0.0679562986,
0.0457052849,
0.0571231134,
-0.0134348199,
0.0370584801,
-0.043245431,
0.0674641505,
-0.0394448265,
0.0111150136,
-0.0134556927,
0.0167196151,
0.0246529486,
-0.021107221,
-0.0566946976,
-0.0150049739,
-0.0377601273,
-0.019112153,
0.0526292324,
0.0124521395,
-0.0166721288,
0.0203797966,
0.0148122916,
-0.0141387424,
-0.0282227341,
0.0406492837,
-0.0295166578,
-0.0013074304,
0.0087083168,
0.0307527259,
-0.0481479801,
0.0105515542,
-0.0529192351,
-0.0315476358,
-0.0007214763,
-0.0007296734,
0.003185038,
0.0268818028,
-0.0635730997,
-0.0090086432,
-0.0388172939,
-0.0635452345,
0.0123622818,
-0.1011494175,
-0.0047164871,
0.0105280029,
-0.0810399726,
-0.0087109609,
2.46787784e-34,
0.0157586038,
-0.0202887896,
0.0137806041,
0.0158783775,
0.0324093997,
0.0324771255,
0.0775354579,
0.0238046572,
0.0512446128,
-0.0671283305,
-0.0759953186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13303v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13303v3 | Towards Unsupervised Recognition of Token-level Semantic Differences in Related Documents | 2023-05-22T17:58:04 | 2023-10-20T12:27:41 | Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatically highlighting words that cause semantic differences between two
documents could be useful for a wide range of applications. We formulate
recognizing semantic differences (RSD) as a token-level regression task and
study three unsupervised approaches that rely on a masked language model. To
assess the approaches, we begin with basic English sentences and gradually move
to more complex, cross-lingual document pairs. Our results show that an
approach based on word alignment and sentence-level contrastive learning has a
robust correlation to gold labels. However, all unsupervised approaches still
leave a large margin of improvement. Code to reproduce our experiments is
available at https://github.com/ZurichNLP/recognizing-semantic-differences | [
0.0256769136,
0.0579376593,
-0.0184056759,
0.048524458,
-0.0805562586,
-0.0030636794,
0.0271938164,
0.0112208733,
-0.0101026054,
-0.0714264065,
-0.0098669119,
0.0486923531,
-0.0001063913,
-0.0086474586,
-0.005019879,
-0.0763795972,
0.0720925033,
-0.008094538,
0.0261016842,
-0.0127832554,
0.0161333252,
-0.0091900388,
-0.0297322255,
-0.0052727298,
-0.042103257,
-0.050579261,
0.0018587126,
0.0031671785,
0.0430675671,
-0.0026904745,
0.0228717402,
0.0705193654,
0.0089874147,
0.089425534,
0.0000017937,
-0.076186657,
-0.046545811,
0.0002910982,
0.036554452,
0.0098561235,
0.0522548929,
-0.0241207927,
-0.0020541458,
-0.009881719,
-0.0138329826,
-0.0521361642,
0.0332989581,
0.0481459647,
0.0246933065,
0.0375071988,
-0.0092499144,
0.0132693006,
0.0124531938,
0.0194207169,
-0.0057333168,
-0.0317431241,
-0.0043353019,
0.0020184477,
-0.0477199256,
0.0106160315,
-0.030487448,
0.0245987736,
-0.0346661396,
-0.0149028348,
0.005972744,
0.0225750748,
-0.0560488217,
0.0381962545,
-0.0208306815,
0.0337946266,
-0.0357872881,
-0.03651217,
0.0106982943,
-0.00534898,
-0.0086689666,
0.0259313062,
-0.0112566417,
-0.0028524303,
-0.033667516,
0.0278421845,
0.0497698784,
0.0322947688,
0.0167375747,
0.0238462146,
0.0166341402,
0.0217972826,
0.0344724022,
-0.0426106863,
-0.0531035364,
-0.0035470158,
-0.0157846957,
-0.0403730609,
0.0422627553,
0.0207308456,
-0.0252712835,
-0.0141465226,
-0.0675258487,
-0.1235125437,
0.029485371,
-0.0295994543,
0.0004279085,
-0.0230167024,
-0.0856025293,
0.087012887,
-0.044683814,
0.0848991498,
0.0198246483,
0.0211270694,
-0.0081254654,
-0.020466473,
-0.0460461043,
-0.0148046296,
-0.0337801166,
0.0248942561,
-0.0653881505,
-0.027562933,
0.0204163752,
-0.0324875452,
-0.030289093,
0.0294065867,
-0.0438453592,
-0.0742065609,
-0.0456652306,
0.0075226217,
-0.0068730284,
-0.0556134954,
-0.052164223,
0.012897918,
-0.0303288251,
-0.0311254282,
0.0066417553,
0.0181732941,
0.0085026231,
-0.01397759,
-0.0304356385,
0.0958628654,
-0.0139329499,
0.0223868992,
-0.0284490455,
-0.0039147441,
0.0422522016,
-0.0101186661,
-0.0082257753,
-0.0892893001,
0.0316056646,
-0.0001084014,
-0.0160344448,
-0.0327109322,
-0.0058316048,
0.0014360072,
-0.0214657784,
0.0735637471,
-0.0123126023,
-0.0244157147,
0.0507782809,
-0.0314677507,
-0.0038298164,
0.0265729018,
-0.0004649755,
-0.0402208716,
0.1177069172,
0.0107698115,
-0.0048415363,
-0.0258682109,
-0.027559381,
0.0048840321,
-0.0284537878,
-0.0163182467,
0.0789796934,
0.0173747502,
0.0233567636,
0.05608714,
-0.0088592982,
-0.0409684218,
0.0044401465,
0.07227505,
-0.0195849333,
0.0038496021,
0.0163626987,
0.0099900272,
-0.0026162257,
0.066814214,
0.0031807411,
-0.0389574952,
0.0075799911,
0.0107955942,
0.0228478443,
0.0058782725,
-0.0189386159,
-0.0156331379,
-0.033799503,
-0.0011575881,
0.0216326695,
-0.0890206397,
0.0553552173,
0.0285916086,
-0.0305168889,
0.0156233301,
0.0329001695,
-0.0365538336,
0.0097443126,
-0.0204734951,
0.0188383441,
0.035554748,
0.0074225832,
-0.082810469,
0.0344306454,
0.0100292936,
-0.0236265566,
0.0766537189,
0.0257712789,
0.0002264661,
-0.0122594293,
-0.0386830084,
0.0072905412,
-0.0645064712,
0.0237946138,
-0.0170474891,
0.0142659005,
0.0228708871,
0.0222766772,
-0.0649453402,
0.0019752204,
0.0643958524,
-0.0040423269,
-0.0221356414,
-0.009593688,
-0.0030091854,
0.0081957588,
-0.01723806,
0.0072662071,
-0.004187928,
-0.0341853201,
-0.0395189114,
-0.0191691034,
0.0026494057,
0.0072547784,
-0.0421138145,
0.034135092,
-0.0749707222,
-0.0255698655,
0.0687157512,
-0.0699012578,
-0.0343992859,
0.0303807445,
-0.0196433775,
0.0606036671,
-0.0127348341,
0.0486957729,
-0.0189500749,
0.0005407855,
-0.0712261125,
0.0670157969,
0.0172634125,
0.0416348875,
-0.0179761667,
0.0028641527,
0.0320286006,
0.0012208945,
0.021785751,
0.0159350503,
0.0153228668,
0.0028330982,
0.0062032752,
-0.0107193012,
-0.0334843546,
-0.0117883524,
-0.0628273636,
0.0223177802,
-0.0106732063,
0.0330599211,
0.052340392,
0.0026695717,
0.0034151922,
-0.0441324562,
0.0076977368,
-0.0147806713,
-0.016982127,
-0.0104540782,
0.0747520402,
-0.0280320961,
0.0276848525,
-0.081931822,
-0.0286745243,
-0.0132094594,
0.0244683623,
0.011406065,
-0.0606237836,
-0.0467801578,
0.0167368241,
-0.010296938,
0.0582870729,
0.0068228599,
-0.0188260097,
-0.0143706175,
0.0240367372,
0.0670231506,
0.0472182222,
0.0397745781,
0.0318831392,
0.043460317,
-0.02273608,
-0.0799626708,
-0.0060504358,
-0.002554791,
0.0468050763,
-0.0035976348,
-0.0248875935,
0.0426398031,
0.0461408384,
0.0151713984,
-0.0110379197,
-0.0105894832,
0.0151222106,
-0.0395794511,
-0.0045543197,
-0.0184090361,
-0.0090268245,
0.0125350859,
0.0224906709,
-0.0273349788,
-0.0342118964,
0.0598276928,
-0.0306997988,
0.0642926171,
-0.0996083617,
-0.0061174287,
-0.0546399094,
0.0329285376,
-0.003878705,
0.0185788218,
-0.047748547,
-0.0461144038,
-0.0199273787,
-0.0091269361,
0.0315419249,
0.0012858671,
0.0374420807,
-0.061759945,
-0.0037539389,
-0.0148371421,
-0.0134722507,
-0.0018993965,
-0.0515604354,
-0.0306972861,
0.0323247686,
0.0343257599,
-0.0034104679,
-0.0259857383,
0.0174422748,
-0.0267777387,
0.0733370185,
0.0024298918,
-0.0190366302,
-0.0263295546,
0.0425623991,
0.0171105675,
-0.0658502728,
0.022514157,
-0.0226651877,
0.0108375568,
0.0164234992,
0.0144207468,
0.0066543263,
0.0046870424,
-0.0271142945,
0.0012167391,
-0.069525443,
0.0019745994,
-0.0389305353,
-0.0008808572,
-0.0451725833,
-0.0088246875,
0.0895349979,
0.0635400265,
-0.0223492552,
-0.0073077064,
-0.0716342553,
-0.0230187755,
0.0143501339,
-0.0042954804,
-0.0140389819,
-0.0191503465,
0.0302353557,
-0.0015943113,
-0.0109377364,
0.024539208,
0.0245077498,
-0.0733265281,
-0.0050250571,
0.0069207489,
-0.0787012577,
-0.0154183824,
-0.0305663049,
0.040204864,
0.0262750015,
-0.0069719083,
0.0001052147,
-0.0114458455,
-0.0161869861,
-0.0118899196,
-0.035507869,
-0.02251756,
-0.027586922,
-0.0473306514,
-0.0073354705,
0.0427417234,
0.0121685397,
-0.0094816172,
-0.0461785197,
0.0779910162,
-0.0162665807,
0.0078507727,
-0.041844409,
0.0576502942,
-0.0071013421,
-0.0078187138,
-0.0319639444,
0.0287019722,
0.015602285,
-0.0271149427,
0.019613469,
0.0096223867,
0.0124371219,
-0.0074078697,
-0.0544028059,
0.0114593906,
0.0072204578,
0.0421644785,
0.0037975176,
-0.0002433727,
-0.0595100038,
-0.005183768,
0.0557805561,
0.0147733232,
0.0119846733,
-0.0216240343,
-0.033979468,
0.0093949595,
-0.0842881948,
-0.0132021597,
-0.033747036,
-0.0113412337,
0.0139465975,
0.0004373514,
-0.0425428338,
-0.0407292545,
-0.0406232961,
0.0254862346,
0.0032463043,
0.025711827,
-0.0432266667,
-0.026920693,
0.0339785144,
0.0365240611,
-0.0438043214,
-0.0190687981,
-0.038195502,
-0.0322166681,
0.0362142585,
-0.0574376918,
0.0040115197,
0.057755813,
-0.0346444361,
-0.0096092094,
0.0010020724,
0.0481322519,
-0.0297689196,
-0.0014955227,
0.0315633714,
-0.0087342337,
-0.0015696769,
0.0103732627,
-0.0362711549,
0.0154470345,
0.0480755977,
0.032921996,
-0.0023543579,
0.023720704,
0.0014501478,
-0.0134135429,
0.1183291152,
0.0361055173,
0.021921711,
-0.0328700207,
0.0174971353,
-0.003429082,
-0.0584386438,
0.0104265027,
-0.0362032205,
-0.0517078303,
0.0012064882,
-0.0402912572,
0.0959803984,
-0.0176484194,
0.0311530083,
0.0010625125,
0.0060796132,
0.0295062065,
0.0583922081,
-0.0383958444,
0.0007307676,
-0.0452158265,
-0.0320620537,
0.0264787283,
0.0385979749,
-0.0234700497,
0.0574875772,
0.0335466377,
-0.0026646391,
-0.0166015569,
0.00387482,
-0.0471675657,
0.0186062176,
0.0122831427,
-0.0142667098,
0.036626257,
-0.050566148,
-0.0051668091,
-0.0199420638,
-0.037858732,
-0.0067638592,
0.0226297975,
0.0237257387,
0.018862145,
0.0252247471,
0.0044034268,
0.0014074735,
0.0360479429,
0.0761638284,
-0.0201148428,
0.0055123297,
0.0030699782,
-0.0189925041,
-0.0139993317,
0.0290364344,
0.0496712998,
0.023147596,
0.0239432212,
-0.0163350534,
-0.0196067374,
-0.0075542042,
0.0265889745,
0.0318299346,
0.0379265696,
0.0701537132,
0.0356807336,
0.0721153766,
-0.0141371358,
-0.0576722845,
-0.0341801941,
0.0440591611,
0.0256000906,
-0.0505175553,
-0.0588739216,
-5.838863377e-33,
-0.0408878252,
-0.0390429124,
-0.0623824,
0.0308696628,
0.0017638918,
0.0273823328,
-0.0279771388,
-0.0377008468,
0.0014560119,
0.0611508004,
0.036230009,
0.0362579152,
0.0240446366,
0.0000631563,
-0.0042466875,
-0.0142463325,
0.0817666352,
0.0469380915,
0.0025939513,
-0.0268235374,
0.0489028506,
-0.0001010865,
0.0301694945,
-0.1085682213,
0.0366661996,
-0.0388244204,
0.0296125375,
0.0169282947,
0.0387763605,
0.0210351218,
0.0120036406,
0.0131086996,
0.0102429567,
0.0183477718,
-0.0435322709,
-0.0022952366,
-0.0680927709,
-0.0567946956,
0.0161080509,
0.0155671155,
-0.0272749458,
-0.0677196234,
-0.0130079938,
0.0082383705,
-0.0158465374,
-0.0284981467,
0.104447946,
-0.0057128435,
0.0096511552,
-0.0129138008,
-0.0985672027,
0.052115459,
-0.0330168158,
0.0602765158,
0.0144422799,
0.026212329,
0.0136241252,
0.0396554992,
-0.0472401083,
0.0153773632,
0.0013772877,
0.0285989866,
0.019163182,
0.019523479,
0.0069679371,
0.0421169028,
0.0044852961,
-0.0293078255,
0.0570077598,
0.0221529827,
0.0043032416,
-0.0085251862,
0.0724480152,
0.014463285,
0.0312514529,
0.0178810526,
-0.0368471704,
-0.0061964202,
-0.0648327619,
0.0295896325,
0.01271208,
0.0417338759,
-0.0313710272,
0.0177779961,
-0.0200160928,
-0.015094758,
-0.0387708396,
0.0058019841,
0.0255567878,
-0.018078493,
-0.025154544,
-0.0320278369,
-0.0144365849,
-0.0085019954,
-0.0361378528,
-0.0082604699,
0.0180536453,
0.0290348399,
-0.0196045488,
-0.0111399293,
-0.0305976029,
-0.0608131997,
0.0003962974,
0.0616178773,
0.067664437,
-0.0072723422,
0.0457713082,
-0.0292168036,
-0.0714430884,
0.0311838016,
0.019911617,
-0.0217139591,
-0.0641517341,
-0.0641980171,
-0.0239798035,
-0.0031734472,
-0.0137958359,
0.060606014,
0.0498593226,
-0.0199054889,
0.0048605683,
-0.011102559,
-0.0629219636,
0.0344131961,
0.0011251861,
0.0210830476,
-0.0206290931,
0.0238114595,
0.050648734,
-0.0033404022,
0.0150637645,
0.0269622318,
2.44e-7,
0.0144625865,
0.0501053073,
0.0537053049,
-0.0296988394,
0.025711365,
0.0244418327,
-0.004432668,
0.0300345365,
0.0085155293,
0.0585152432,
-0.0437032357,
0.007332826,
0.0588802584,
0.0187144428,
-0.0213300157,
0.0239214934,
-0.0606356487,
-0.04677191,
-0.0627727434,
0.0026558097,
0.0590286069,
0.0325138308,
0.0218555424,
0.023399625,
-0.0232241675,
-0.0409697443,
0.0261025745,
-0.0442327894,
0.0000321779,
-0.0029762515,
0.0040908121,
-0.0038966148,
0.0278473422,
0.0604483411,
-0.0275411215,
0.0080178138,
0.0725224763,
0.0191830825,
-0.0005050378,
0.0479380339,
-0.0395212881,
0.0073918588,
0.0131945591,
-0.0492720604,
0.0436259061,
0.0057275784,
0.0040728729,
-0.0622481033,
-0.0232392661,
0.0229234193,
0.043161951,
-0.0020989229,
-0.0724185109,
0.0625201687,
0.0342997983,
0.0452468172,
-0.0419607125,
-0.0590371229,
-0.016756257,
0.0168958083,
-0.0013855109,
0.0038779988,
0.02648063,
0.0440971591,
-0.0179769322,
-0.0176967867,
0.0061507816,
2.007246832e-34,
0.0392339565,
0.0190495905,
-0.0097464276,
-0.0300606843,
0.0284427423,
-0.0016146974,
-0.0110288439,
0.0128780073,
0.0073205121,
-0.0320091583,
0.0540665686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13302v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13302v2 | Language-Agnostic Bias Detection in Language Models with Bias Probing | 2023-05-22T17:58:01 | 2023-11-20T14:31:26 | Abdullatif Köksal, Omer Faruk Yalcin, Ahmet Akbiyik, M. Tahir Kilavuz, Anna Korhonen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) are key components in NLP, but they contain
strong social biases. Quantifying these biases is challenging because current
methods focusing on fill-the-mask objectives are sensitive to slight changes in
input. To address this, we propose a bias probing technique called LABDet, for
evaluating social bias in PLMs with a robust and language-agnostic method. For
nationality as a case study, we show that LABDet `surfaces' nationality bias by
training a classifier on top of a frozen PLM on non-nationality sentiment
detection. We find consistent patterns of nationality bias across monolingual
PLMs in six languages that align with historical and political context. We also
show for English BERT that bias surfaced by LABDet correlates well with bias in
the pretraining data; thus, our work is one of the few studies that directly
links pretraining data to PLM behavior. Finally, we verify LABDet's reliability
and applicability to different templates and languages through an extensive set
of robustness checks. We publicly share our code and dataset in
https://github.com/akoksal/LABDet. | [
0.022764584,
0.0898395702,
-0.0241681244,
0.0551122315,
-0.0043264544,
0.0265665967,
0.0209407192,
-0.0217268653,
0.0398784913,
-0.0500567742,
-0.0296941791,
-0.0369370654,
-0.0104819098,
-0.005774755,
0.0147574823,
-0.0337225497,
0.0579596981,
0.0437103622,
0.0455539785,
-0.0592869483,
0.0314366668,
0.0198924225,
0.017094329,
0.0172406211,
-0.0355491638,
0.0387838371,
0.0286688749,
0.0136906793,
0.0285866484,
-0.0179784074,
0.0553179421,
0.0667430311,
-0.0262788646,
0.0267132018,
0.0000019062,
-0.0398755185,
-0.0166918747,
-0.0192666277,
0.0425233468,
0.0076162196,
0.1030001119,
-0.0213536602,
-0.0125300577,
0.0312198941,
-0.0605343617,
-0.0212846939,
0.0349310711,
0.0181178544,
0.0548256487,
0.0603778958,
-0.0268573482,
0.0100854142,
-0.0769959241,
-0.0297856759,
-0.0160959568,
-0.0246596262,
0.0604656525,
-0.0434382111,
-0.0873818621,
-0.0232507084,
-0.0223438367,
0.0075909658,
-0.0004454695,
0.0278451424,
-0.0146629019,
0.0143548232,
-0.0311432816,
-0.0336282998,
0.0093137175,
0.0294829868,
-0.0011602184,
-0.0415641144,
0.0048958645,
-0.0151757589,
0.0082462598,
0.0098644067,
0.0223369356,
-0.0114132697,
0.0242903028,
0.0453421772,
0.0600778311,
0.0147132585,
0.0414102338,
0.0490869693,
-0.0132584656,
0.0522442944,
0.0033628482,
-0.0323142745,
0.0139425984,
0.0641644746,
0.0564901307,
-0.0373160429,
0.0303193647,
-0.0119584752,
0.0005646814,
0.0107464828,
-0.0306386538,
0.006020498,
0.021199923,
-0.0784958005,
-0.0133736981,
0.0165417697,
-0.0574384071,
0.046066884,
-0.0028230078,
-0.0236453936,
-0.0123638865,
0.0008010554,
-0.020132998,
-0.0246063266,
-0.0136539489,
0.012908536,
-0.0040819803,
-0.0253004581,
0.0133677535,
0.0380003601,
-0.0324142687,
-0.0205089841,
-0.0543614924,
0.0311945137,
-0.0071985596,
-0.0247850623,
-0.0109668681,
0.0345117636,
-0.03440281,
0.0655501857,
-0.0577376336,
0.0021154224,
-0.0818575546,
-0.062429186,
-0.0095458226,
0.0043965727,
-0.0203318782,
-0.0476326831,
0.0250277855,
0.0126481345,
0.0374948904,
-0.0191862285,
-0.0321709402,
0.0071969228,
0.0127126016,
-0.0605882704,
0.0154050589,
-0.0489802584,
0.0450738035,
0.0168275256,
0.0301392525,
-0.0142932599,
-0.0000154175,
0.0102518871,
-0.0557127818,
0.0564800575,
0.0170861632,
0.0117080072,
0.0057263784,
-0.002707626,
0.0014748805,
0.1136228144,
-0.046574682,
0.0003210705,
0.070792079,
-0.0280968044,
0.027521709,
0.0608767346,
0.0336168706,
0.0156286247,
-0.0341316611,
-0.0063865101,
-0.0068142731,
-0.0584853739,
0.0513657182,
0.0047622728,
-0.0030483229,
-0.0355756208,
0.0371105559,
0.0148520609,
-0.0422258414,
0.0298135187,
-0.007084318,
-0.0094430139,
0.0000366614,
0.0257620513,
-0.0532146618,
0.002997641,
-0.0551199503,
-0.0509746224,
-0.016454855,
0.0691808239,
-0.0332653858,
-0.0134744132,
-0.0227300227,
0.0044968282,
0.0538254566,
0.010448331,
0.0351870395,
-0.0026675924,
0.0034327607,
0.0768654123,
0.0598892793,
-0.0532234833,
0.0433894172,
-0.014760213,
0.0030133787,
0.0398059562,
-0.0150316339,
-0.0443710722,
-0.0032491593,
-0.0092056198,
-0.007001292,
0.0448071845,
0.1022711918,
-0.0157956537,
0.0148743484,
-0.0252780262,
-0.0146107133,
0.0071096974,
0.052952636,
0.0287463386,
0.0694161505,
0.0475463234,
-0.0087929387,
-0.0573778339,
-0.0290248413,
0.0195314605,
0.0003299584,
-0.0118515035,
-0.009485147,
0.0053498712,
0.0339588113,
0.0394574627,
-0.0419706218,
-0.0341628641,
0.0029963385,
-0.0139256222,
-0.0020663512,
0.0268808529,
-0.0317507498,
-0.0460613407,
0.0056155496,
-0.0317980871,
-0.0588434339,
0.0556255504,
-0.0424750559,
-0.0047770524,
0.0402316228,
0.0120910183,
0.0575601496,
-0.0244474504,
-0.0228149928,
-0.0532827638,
0.0214255359,
-0.0205162875,
0.0552655533,
-0.0094358372,
0.0039660605,
0.0015560505,
-0.0335729718,
0.0339679345,
-0.0036431227,
-0.0628258288,
0.0342685431,
0.0177386329,
-0.0205911435,
0.0621079765,
-0.0058684777,
-0.0193660501,
-0.0268301666,
-0.1021993905,
-0.0152513962,
-0.0353444181,
0.0120157339,
0.0291383993,
0.0051546921,
-0.0274218414,
-0.0059097228,
-0.0591605343,
-0.0441543013,
-0.0097263064,
0.0354597084,
0.0247931387,
-0.0280662347,
0.0234763976,
-0.0529530719,
-0.0034542251,
-0.0342264883,
0.031080246,
0.0072853463,
-0.032357201,
-0.0187662449,
-0.0088882307,
-0.0412325077,
0.0214215741,
-0.0132511472,
-0.0551693216,
-0.0114385663,
0.01109765,
0.0028712519,
0.0698524714,
0.0040055788,
-0.0027302145,
0.063050732,
-0.0028686472,
-0.0445683487,
-0.0180076789,
-0.0415196791,
0.0467780866,
-0.0278019235,
-0.0630204231,
0.0060804221,
0.0728258118,
0.0047207521,
-0.0247504283,
-0.0424516015,
0.0281887781,
-0.0493258238,
-0.0043386095,
0.0001871093,
-0.0134118758,
0.0203976203,
0.016939206,
-0.0279560592,
-0.0477553979,
0.0489821583,
0.0013401536,
0.0151080433,
-0.0463302322,
-0.0063160593,
-0.0367088206,
0.0301590059,
0.0017950439,
0.0122190425,
-0.0145766754,
0.0028795812,
-0.0162286926,
-0.0342003666,
0.0160285085,
-0.0208776742,
-0.0330073014,
-0.0065144286,
-0.0112771485,
-0.006359451,
-0.0410408899,
-0.0323119089,
-0.0681442171,
-0.0533534698,
-0.0079223737,
0.0102128265,
-0.0343276933,
0.0377067812,
-0.0206136927,
-0.0057529807,
-0.0076770089,
-0.0149815334,
0.0189363137,
0.0265375152,
0.0122795505,
-0.001605446,
-0.0327289104,
0.0525816157,
-0.0165604912,
-0.0248246677,
0.003336852,
0.0353866443,
0.0188599974,
-0.0012714543,
0.0112227555,
0.0487291217,
-0.0086144675,
-0.0099896099,
-0.072519742,
0.0383829176,
-0.0291179772,
0.0332794301,
0.1042169482,
-0.0002664737,
-0.0662052184,
-0.0049594692,
0.0120740552,
0.0149790104,
0.0451723151,
0.0177138019,
-0.0658514649,
0.0060935388,
0.0212520752,
-0.0104897646,
-0.0277200677,
-0.0143083362,
-0.0194916464,
-0.1379346848,
-0.0109034944,
-0.0077550574,
-0.0199513249,
-0.010735618,
-0.0420552231,
0.0171017535,
-0.0405023843,
0.0062395395,
-0.0520036109,
0.030857021,
0.0221543945,
-0.0025936516,
-0.0714237168,
-0.0758578554,
0.0343427323,
-0.0391771756,
0.0645227432,
0.0364649184,
0.0571545325,
-0.0337181352,
-0.0084050596,
0.0872728229,
-0.0101350881,
-0.0306968149,
-0.0624788068,
0.0636699349,
-0.0463262685,
-0.0553043894,
0.0163396858,
0.0168407802,
0.0002718226,
0.0310587566,
-0.0114590339,
0.0214728098,
0.0477131866,
-0.0599377677,
0.0010737214,
-0.0077899215,
0.0096116913,
0.0868871808,
0.0055152741,
-0.0416891053,
-0.003807982,
-0.0153747909,
0.0185869709,
-0.0147278002,
-0.0471862741,
0.0117168175,
-0.0161710326,
-0.0444855615,
-0.0266595669,
-0.0552687757,
0.0130354352,
0.0206715055,
0.0069957683,
-0.0110742049,
0.0057909749,
-0.0232660901,
-0.021202663,
0.0579284914,
-0.0282193143,
0.020633623,
0.0220331438,
-0.0695393905,
0.008376128,
-0.0186687261,
-0.0086303409,
-0.0331238993,
-0.0347783118,
-0.04555282,
0.0706633031,
0.0482779182,
0.0113067692,
0.0602833927,
-0.0280943606,
-0.0695481449,
0.0567957424,
0.0374202281,
-0.0317033529,
0.0190476421,
0.040477965,
0.0096916175,
0.027812399,
0.0221512895,
-0.0235234294,
0.0319087952,
0.0575205348,
-0.0143736275,
-0.0368065462,
-0.0285014827,
-0.0183716919,
-0.0210976712,
0.0822560564,
-0.0152041698,
0.0013944312,
-0.0665742308,
-0.0394281261,
-0.0108599942,
-0.0473809764,
-0.0084425788,
-0.0504818335,
0.0253835432,
0.0019426014,
-0.0418501608,
0.0090826536,
-0.0631199703,
0.0227406379,
-0.0318253078,
0.0410274491,
0.0458977446,
0.0504071824,
0.0056618988,
0.011753669,
0.0041125962,
0.0308442842,
-0.0017225323,
0.0014863863,
-0.0004331332,
0.0079317158,
0.0216619093,
-0.0116558969,
0.0366038494,
-0.0166808441,
-0.0413080119,
0.0195575133,
-0.0143410182,
0.0247832034,
0.0577243418,
-0.0800842568,
0.0536924489,
-0.0002015798,
-0.0067052389,
0.013252642,
-0.007028766,
0.0107571697,
-0.0463601574,
0.0209946036,
-0.0110680405,
-0.0463962778,
0.0452236757,
0.0503890254,
0.0046269596,
0.049988322,
0.0246903952,
-0.0303428527,
0.0006569335,
-0.0001087099,
0.0786561295,
-0.0328931287,
-0.0418792926,
0.0036307923,
-0.0807223469,
-0.0634578839,
-0.0087412316,
-0.0080326498,
0.013835893,
0.0107744709,
-0.0164652131,
0.0775706321,
-0.0421689637,
0.0240806658,
-0.0371897146,
-0.0110449288,
-0.0169406421,
-0.0104019055,
-0.0018502725,
-6.862820343e-33,
-0.0150759965,
-0.0148473373,
-0.0420323834,
-0.0096836183,
0.0074721472,
0.0172424279,
-0.0276937913,
0.0224743709,
-0.0373442471,
0.0381522402,
0.0006606204,
0.0305785742,
0.0207605883,
-0.0156145245,
-0.0071080322,
-0.0368028507,
0.0578244179,
0.0252400339,
-0.0087142484,
0.0066037495,
-0.0210299455,
0.0257811341,
0.0816408694,
-0.0723320991,
0.0489633679,
0.0080685224,
-0.0203653518,
0.0230624098,
0.0453470387,
0.0024004811,
-0.0240602363,
0.0562058017,
0.0359267481,
0.0067831399,
0.0117837414,
0.0110792425,
-0.0274968948,
-0.0492552146,
0.0015660507,
0.0431037843,
0.0295666587,
0.0047902912,
0.0126849534,
-0.0156283844,
-0.0666740537,
0.0354549326,
0.0471759103,
0.0209182724,
0.041683659,
0.0081070587,
-0.0291520227,
0.0338568911,
0.0066428925,
0.0323701128,
0.008737376,
0.028947359,
0.0434649773,
0.0396398865,
-0.0307273734,
0.003436388,
-0.0022998664,
-0.0057847043,
0.0147122908,
-0.0110909119,
0.0262411162,
0.0796858743,
0.063426666,
0.0875233933,
-0.0201486815,
-0.0247069728,
0.0558968894,
-0.0362957306,
0.0275648907,
0.0922794342,
0.0108339237,
-0.0151505759,
-0.0287415665,
0.0084165838,
0.0850824341,
-0.0048126471,
0.0448526405,
-0.0290346164,
-0.0233537834,
-0.0426843688,
-0.0276873987,
-0.0895591527,
-0.0244034212,
0.015796015,
0.0123344101,
0.0270949956,
-0.0359604135,
-0.0131811127,
0.0261484794,
-0.0376446508,
-0.0307088438,
0.0460982285,
-0.0188562162,
-0.0231468193,
0.0206219945,
0.0088239983,
-0.0561566427,
-0.0205785185,
-0.0252533481,
0.0301365592,
0.0206758101,
-0.0066188839,
0.019657081,
0.0208882112,
-0.0603687987,
0.0065382817,
-0.0416029133,
0.0184398852,
-0.020789519,
0.0447674356,
0.0359463543,
0.0104934555,
-0.0170319937,
0.0072564278,
0.0600649342,
0.0401200391,
-0.024337329,
-0.0047745141,
-0.0332255848,
0.0388476774,
-0.0134590371,
-0.0379242562,
-0.0002201993,
0.0053700493,
0.0244745072,
-0.0337808579,
-0.0097029619,
-0.0531021357,
2.676e-7,
0.0094364481,
0.0688206106,
-0.0289086532,
0.0149851805,
0.0049757096,
0.048021242,
-0.0220213924,
0.0338698849,
-0.0005104035,
0.00143697,
-0.0251772087,
0.023739215,
0.0239577126,
0.0674686283,
-0.0900456309,
0.0150575759,
-0.0347587466,
0.0476442501,
-0.0163632259,
0.0024511677,
-0.0179222841,
0.0704698116,
0.05742006,
0.0068392744,
-0.0242495947,
-0.0138975317,
0.0505704395,
-0.0613246672,
-0.0239989199,
0.009193249,
0.001738805,
0.0133279273,
0.020497743,
0.0248281881,
-0.0199471787,
0.0303868353,
-0.0111416411,
0.0266984161,
0.0183457602,
-0.0183400903,
-0.0114028137,
0.0028916209,
-0.0265815165,
-0.0861898884,
0.051299233,
0.0098847123,
-0.01469485,
-0.0911548063,
-0.0155059118,
-0.0199084729,
0.078102082,
-0.0002064213,
-0.0364902206,
0.0194229335,
0.019959107,
-0.0089204162,
-0.0435216501,
-0.0700410903,
-0.0483364798,
-0.0451747067,
-0.0120815411,
-0.0382830612,
0.0386135727,
0.0424708687,
-0.0116754137,
-0.0064321538,
0.0389690474,
2.468188703e-34,
0.0421271883,
-0.0273884926,
-0.0000261903,
-0.0174899381,
0.0558360331,
0.0103229899,
-0.0447054096,
-0.0079865223,
0.0320694633,
-0.0181887727,
0.0219508559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13300v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13300v4 | Adaptive Chameleon or Stubborn Sloth: Revealing the Behavior of Large Language Models in Knowledge Conflicts | 2023-05-22T17:57:41 | 2024-02-27T17:08:49 | Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Renze Lou, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | By providing external information to large language models (LLMs), tool
augmentation (including retrieval augmentation) has emerged as a promising
solution for addressing the limitations of LLMs' static parametric memory.
However, how receptive are LLMs to such external evidence, especially when the
evidence conflicts with their parametric memory? We present the first
comprehensive and controlled investigation into the behavior of LLMs when
encountering knowledge conflicts. We propose a systematic framework to elicit
high-quality parametric memory from LLMs and construct the corresponding
counter-memory, which enables us to conduct a series of controlled experiments.
Our investigation reveals seemingly contradicting behaviors of LLMs. On the one
hand, different from prior wisdom, we find that LLMs can be highly receptive to
external evidence even when that conflicts with their parametric memory, given
that the external evidence is coherent and convincing. On the other hand, LLMs
also demonstrate a strong confirmation bias when the external evidence contains
some information that is consistent with their parametric memory, despite being
presented with conflicting evidence at the same time. These results pose
important implications that are worth careful consideration for the further
development and deployment of tool- and retrieval-augmented LLMs. Resources are
available at https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/LLM-Knowledge-Conflict. | [
0.0571095981,
0.0686956346,
-0.0518174171,
0.0484095439,
-0.0490285158,
-0.002281921,
-0.0460183546,
-0.0152421128,
-0.018804552,
-0.0702223927,
-0.0379093736,
0.0025587142,
-0.0106528597,
-0.0204940289,
0.027630575,
-0.033901915,
0.0699696392,
-0.0092696864,
0.0087822946,
-0.0261856019,
-0.0061578127,
-0.0217768755,
0.0374802202,
0.0221434142,
0.0024875682,
0.0094811646,
-0.0033293951,
-0.0080667278,
-0.003205104,
-0.0258390196,
0.0068586264,
0.0357773826,
0.0211843215,
0.1162658259,
0.0000020841,
-0.0614004992,
-0.0245669838,
-0.0006345316,
-0.0480464548,
0.0182791557,
0.0252024438,
-0.0173788983,
0.0024272229,
-0.0158597045,
-0.0376059413,
-0.0426159166,
0.0336948037,
0.0270454902,
0.0329446867,
0.0577902459,
0.0156964008,
0.0053533958,
0.0288899411,
-0.0346794799,
-0.0029912696,
0.0011052301,
0.0563559458,
-0.000262109,
0.0032987501,
0.0404538251,
-0.0021411639,
0.0502774306,
0.0154029308,
0.0133103076,
-0.0395031683,
0.007577138,
-0.0306438338,
-0.0187650025,
0.0141342524,
0.0151855731,
0.0228099637,
-0.0575441793,
-0.0223942269,
-0.0026113081,
0.0267309025,
0.0825650692,
-0.0704828873,
0.0567900427,
-0.0139583554,
0.0022648151,
0.0065513612,
-0.0302833561,
0.0612633079,
0.0247721113,
-0.0255732778,
0.0505968332,
0.0157249905,
-0.0466850623,
0.0025772052,
-0.0003978773,
-0.0152867585,
-0.0617687181,
-0.0179147776,
0.035266079,
-0.009198511,
0.0572664291,
-0.0052424478,
-0.0403250828,
0.0500302203,
-0.0862253234,
0.0267181564,
0.0031847754,
-0.0503504798,
0.0405910984,
-0.0382133536,
0.0174695235,
-0.0527903363,
0.0191431995,
-0.0050124135,
-0.0026205152,
-0.0503976531,
-0.0372191854,
0.0124401422,
0.0261503048,
0.0264927931,
0.0276263971,
0.0107233524,
0.0277210735,
-0.0401116312,
0.0514198802,
-0.0408075117,
-0.0172702465,
0.0060011609,
-0.0128297349,
-0.0584901385,
0.0606910735,
-0.0262215212,
0.0258904304,
-0.0127583668,
-0.0566383675,
-0.027144555,
0.0014617488,
-0.0220801122,
-0.0401783884,
-0.0006784079,
0.0533812828,
-0.0056360145,
0.0007380183,
-0.040067073,
-0.0263245441,
-0.0137649421,
-0.0636602193,
0.0055796732,
-0.0631067157,
0.0351003073,
0.0294739194,
-0.0130231353,
-0.0486252531,
-0.0060102404,
-0.0063743666,
-0.053177733,
0.0460808203,
-0.0261984784,
-0.0048910482,
0.0403097421,
0.0204159636,
-0.0147099243,
0.070369117,
-0.0123044485,
-0.0157072414,
0.035763748,
0.0005895434,
-0.0340944231,
0.0056289444,
0.0197352059,
0.0044074059,
-0.0434337482,
0.0118751274,
0.0583698079,
0.0132422335,
-0.0047873342,
0.0553845279,
-0.0470650941,
-0.0678604022,
0.0566988736,
-0.0167477969,
0.0070947595,
0.0135459341,
0.0062821736,
-0.0363221355,
0.0219652988,
0.0481717214,
-0.0458836108,
-0.0074280188,
-0.0743262172,
0.0035845607,
0.0152776232,
0.0241569076,
-0.0291455053,
-0.0317122601,
-0.0314450227,
0.0013829868,
-0.0001747413,
0.0121804746,
0.0526442043,
-0.003955917,
0.0102900201,
0.0526088104,
0.0214428753,
-0.026742164,
-0.0269688256,
-0.043414358,
0.0143635385,
0.0043667224,
0.0576449856,
-0.0518389307,
-0.034188658,
0.0200683009,
-0.0292975679,
0.0225130692,
0.0710956678,
0.0049597863,
-0.0269104503,
-0.0410701744,
-0.0161555931,
-0.0465114675,
0.0203881152,
0.013694739,
0.0525482818,
0.0254246388,
0.0173182338,
-0.0239444338,
-0.0266714282,
0.0240895674,
-0.0267604906,
-0.0161730442,
-0.0608615987,
-0.0287172496,
0.0354989618,
-0.0012108268,
-0.0217782594,
0.030253185,
0.0574199744,
-0.00439549,
-0.0253144391,
0.0532901697,
-0.0325439274,
0.0013312241,
0.0574315451,
0.0429339036,
0.0007895251,
-0.0470834188,
-0.0000909163,
-0.0457156748,
0.0488720462,
-0.0178349707,
0.1050834879,
-0.0253135096,
0.0606576279,
-0.0314297341,
-0.0069229458,
-0.0427479744,
0.0611272156,
0.0080475481,
0.0176829956,
0.0025897613,
-0.0088045904,
0.0057488712,
-0.0043460396,
-0.0473050252,
0.0490182787,
0.0149345146,
0.0354033299,
0.0223344006,
-0.0856463015,
-0.0493213646,
-0.0419943258,
-0.0623353533,
-0.0027498845,
0.0073613431,
0.0029045723,
0.0001253361,
-0.0372256674,
-0.0043008709,
0.0048145936,
0.0107800569,
0.0144769028,
0.0022566502,
0.0729613826,
-0.0074306568,
0.0317123979,
0.0248136465,
-0.0393335707,
-0.0096622081,
0.0059700147,
0.0639348179,
0.007526902,
-0.0149859264,
-0.0609821305,
0.044171609,
-0.0550593957,
0.0322698094,
-0.0396674089,
0.0160612371,
0.0336589292,
-0.0193086602,
0.0250339527,
0.044646237,
-0.0155669115,
0.0179584809,
0.1037783027,
-0.0278043654,
-0.1037931964,
-0.0173185244,
0.0107256938,
-0.0852875262,
-0.0272193812,
-0.0106846588,
0.00358598,
0.056736771,
-0.0208714716,
-0.0219297353,
-0.0047777342,
0.0377348885,
-0.0084942905,
-0.0312959291,
0.0062589319,
-0.0639385208,
-0.0172999091,
0.0338275023,
-0.0171021745,
-0.061862357,
0.0663501695,
-0.0315388627,
0.0253156945,
-0.0214099027,
0.0315010175,
-0.0337727219,
0.0706904903,
-0.0010580968,
-0.0064577921,
0.0311589576,
0.0115771815,
-0.0522889197,
-0.0322458781,
0.0187720824,
-0.039622616,
0.0350265093,
-0.0554075353,
0.0179433674,
-0.0099949427,
-0.0166284516,
-0.0587764829,
-0.0153667545,
-0.0234187245,
0.0005223257,
0.0045673749,
-0.0046598217,
-0.0320143364,
-0.0234122761,
0.061253082,
0.0125041772,
0.0066826832,
-0.0082648173,
-0.0173243023,
-0.0052071242,
0.0250799172,
0.0560022593,
0.0570229888,
-0.0301180016,
-0.0037156476,
0.0696154162,
0.0280377474,
-0.046305906,
-0.0274129547,
-0.0452594981,
0.0199877005,
-0.0474335141,
-0.0434167013,
-0.0186825413,
-0.0004838762,
-0.0674635768,
0.0213177279,
0.0844192654,
0.0350731649,
-0.0630354732,
-0.0138704842,
-0.0524315014,
0.0132348314,
0.0368427709,
0.0146473106,
-0.0772090629,
0.0057212701,
0.0193649605,
-0.0272366777,
-0.0349794067,
-0.0199879128,
-0.0276060794,
-0.1364252716,
0.0015291838,
0.0256367177,
-0.0002597186,
0.0087304916,
-0.0228516571,
0.0088221505,
0.0188627746,
0.0263215452,
0.0299807265,
-0.0355660245,
-0.0024452345,
-0.0141049707,
0.0035850233,
-0.0419906639,
-0.0094979061,
-0.0250329096,
0.0481018797,
-0.0056487499,
-0.0122868931,
-0.0038837742,
-0.0151971485,
0.0453906842,
-0.011417022,
0.0070739728,
-0.0284632053,
0.0181825645,
-0.0024786002,
0.0220290814,
0.0092081716,
-0.0234792084,
0.0094798226,
-0.0094722575,
0.0263845287,
0.0638777092,
-0.0194496438,
-0.0114778895,
0.0076028728,
-0.0080839274,
-0.0271112323,
0.0913387686,
0.0203214716,
0.0194190666,
0.0029613911,
-0.0079240119,
-0.0117364433,
0.0471654609,
-0.0198751204,
0.0281080455,
0.0181227867,
0.0291437544,
-0.0666246861,
-0.0336056724,
0.0136650344,
0.0241144132,
0.0302148256,
0.0338479914,
-0.0085044736,
-0.0373636819,
-0.0497368537,
0.0343125612,
-0.042899847,
-0.0209037643,
-0.0246910732,
0.0043285573,
0.0035722749,
-0.0168585274,
0.0128277438,
0.0368723869,
-0.0460380763,
-0.0929408446,
0.0081802644,
0.0306683257,
0.0389758237,
0.0431758463,
0.0216742456,
-0.0524268821,
-0.0122361081,
0.0318876766,
-0.0040711551,
0.0365320556,
0.0319664367,
0.0031960758,
-0.016409196,
0.0360712372,
-0.0413760357,
-0.0395654403,
0.0324388854,
0.0216538552,
-0.0293981545,
-0.0412535816,
0.0381256528,
0.0252917968,
0.0084635755,
0.0109465392,
-0.0042455592,
-0.0196483154,
0.0164652523,
-0.0446456559,
-0.0265054554,
0.0181333832,
-0.0237627141,
-0.010173697,
-0.0067161694,
0.0140399328,
0.0067424173,
0.0162341259,
0.0530049093,
-0.0179677866,
-0.017514566,
0.007873618,
-0.0076810811,
0.0393415652,
0.0247248281,
-0.0278455,
0.0371132232,
-0.0149208289,
0.0679226965,
-0.0319109522,
0.0719399601,
0.0217840113,
-0.0233079474,
-0.0271921623,
-0.0018158857,
-0.0726244524,
-0.0851122439,
0.0467875302,
0.0121523188,
0.0447590947,
-0.0528207794,
0.0732084364,
-0.0494010709,
-0.013042693,
-0.0367304645,
-0.0246831998,
0.0179203395,
-0.0166230109,
0.0320392475,
0.0294629764,
-0.04104371,
0.0429425165,
0.0659460723,
-0.0131906839,
0.0597334243,
-0.0373999663,
0.000692939,
0.001331097,
-0.050369963,
0.0118081775,
0.0157756042,
-0.0273000486,
-0.0152848167,
-0.0829393491,
-0.0544385873,
-0.0148272412,
-0.0120973298,
-0.0374809094,
-0.0352977589,
-0.0290848725,
0.068863675,
0.0158184804,
-0.0044374643,
-0.0032349711,
0.0437524952,
-0.0016964606,
0.0079205623,
-0.0115544712,
-6.311664837e-33,
-0.0167035945,
-0.0140750324,
0.0126287322,
-0.0534436107,
0.0058233072,
0.0113154184,
-0.007955906,
0.0158226881,
-0.0762807354,
-0.0200862866,
-0.0104307914,
-0.0014292974,
0.0189330615,
-0.0220247079,
0.0392526612,
0.0096258549,
0.0384613127,
0.0346778519,
-0.0212753061,
0.0055141021,
0.0744016767,
-0.0059250914,
0.0575517528,
-0.0511996783,
0.078506507,
0.0035393089,
0.0358995572,
0.0104823792,
-0.0501795076,
0.0542184338,
-0.0037702299,
0.0574894845,
0.0252841506,
-0.0274418592,
-0.0198263321,
-0.0396710373,
-0.0404266976,
-0.0329097249,
0.079987295,
0.0034906866,
0.0166063998,
-0.0380767211,
0.0561540462,
-0.0240525864,
-0.0141236847,
-0.000165399,
0.0089804903,
-0.0372521617,
-0.0415744819,
0.0268530995,
-0.0544678308,
0.0234846883,
0.0185419954,
0.0160885006,
-0.0039831507,
-0.0121678635,
0.0220050439,
0.0199409649,
-0.0864926726,
0.0197359845,
0.0362862349,
0.0371744111,
0.0660712048,
0.0206307583,
-0.0010388463,
0.0677480921,
-0.0098874187,
0.0509344786,
-0.004793372,
-0.0229057651,
0.0318078399,
0.0417547151,
0.0344600528,
0.0238728896,
0.0042419173,
0.0053392961,
-0.0069504622,
-0.011629249,
0.0575400926,
0.0594971254,
0.0484608933,
0.0373068266,
-0.0323857665,
-0.0369339474,
-0.0421818681,
-0.010945227,
-0.0356026515,
-0.0086828591,
0.0183633454,
0.0366222262,
0.0332763419,
0.0080606565,
0.028356187,
-0.0156122185,
-0.0156335905,
0.0291180573,
-0.0032531908,
0.0013371977,
-0.0124750296,
0.0261389557,
-0.0448783003,
-0.0082909223,
0.0057551074,
0.0085797384,
-0.0059396508,
0.0332607552,
0.0230201017,
-0.0096109686,
-0.0645850077,
0.0180835221,
-0.0416857228,
0.0054652798,
-0.0197928362,
-0.0744961947,
0.064255707,
0.0498465523,
0.0135692973,
0.0189595167,
0.0532849953,
-0.0220634993,
-0.0629523844,
0.0349651314,
-0.0117933024,
0.0087452075,
0.016003307,
0.0151355518,
-0.0019463438,
0.0394087024,
0.015049859,
-0.0259656962,
0.0080839256,
-0.0237207171,
2.799e-7,
0.0525381081,
0.0443353653,
0.0161927566,
-0.0131611228,
0.0297640096,
0.0214310754,
-0.0519451052,
-0.0214778725,
0.0104577951,
-0.0381317772,
-0.0274878759,
0.0496764034,
0.0385551266,
0.0507345833,
-0.02412875,
-0.0083017694,
-0.0658007562,
-0.0129383523,
-0.0559488684,
0.0006806544,
0.0464864969,
0.0671095848,
0.021842774,
0.0182800777,
-0.0441195965,
-0.0917796195,
0.0860273018,
-0.0274313204,
-0.0143724447,
0.0250066314,
0.036317423,
0.0261525773,
0.0102780936,
0.0195187815,
0.0189603288,
0.0200627763,
-0.0514201485,
0.0333497711,
0.0216464251,
-0.0193388611,
-0.0113432035,
-0.01501696,
-0.0199522655,
-0.0948743448,
0.0687733293,
-0.0484801605,
-0.0444915853,
-0.0148509555,
0.010186526,
-0.0038105529,
0.0127263218,
-0.0055684983,
-0.0134233795,
0.0207561888,
-0.0065458673,
0.0322505422,
-0.0263837501,
-0.0894902423,
-0.0535603277,
0.0553115942,
-0.0587904863,
-0.0692403167,
-0.0258846935,
-0.0388438776,
0.0015932079,
-0.0562970974,
0.0018684982,
2.55812573e-34,
0.0523902997,
0.0059552914,
0.0269619301,
0.0203149859,
0.0406448022,
-0.0121402955,
-0.0059382329,
0.0564186051,
0.0079888403,
-0.0744978189,
0.0083502131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13299v1 | Measuring Inductive Biases of In-Context Learning with Underspecified Demonstrations | 2023-05-22T17:56:31 | 2023-05-22T17:56:31 | Chenglei Si, Dan Friedman, Nitish Joshi, Shi Feng, Danqi Chen, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-context learning (ICL) is an important paradigm for adapting large
language models (LLMs) to new tasks, but the generalization behavior of ICL
remains poorly understood. We investigate the inductive biases of ICL from the
perspective of feature bias: which feature ICL is more likely to use given a
set of underspecified demonstrations in which two features are equally
predictive of the labels. First, we characterize the feature biases of GPT-3
models by constructing underspecified demonstrations from a range of NLP
datasets and feature combinations. We find that LLMs exhibit clear feature
biases - for example, demonstrating a strong bias to predict labels according
to sentiment rather than shallow lexical features, like punctuation. Second, we
evaluate the effect of different interventions that are designed to impose an
inductive bias in favor of a particular feature, such as adding a natural
language instruction or using semantically relevant label words. We find that,
while many interventions can influence the learner to prefer a particular
feature, it can be difficult to overcome strong prior biases. Overall, our
results provide a broader picture of the types of features that ICL may be more
likely to exploit and how to impose inductive biases that are better aligned
with the intended task. | [
0.0244894344,
0.0225455891,
-0.0092009194,
0.028968459,
-0.0450717211,
0.0460400432,
0.004634399,
-0.0112867132,
0.026096154,
-0.0709092766,
-0.0273370352,
0.0046619242,
0.004942276,
-0.0316663757,
0.036618311,
-0.0734647289,
0.04260391,
0.0138378842,
0.0279806536,
0.000856443,
0.012376274,
0.0000775175,
-0.0157233421,
0.0474760607,
-0.0322275423,
-0.0148056634,
0.0162263718,
0.0083308192,
-0.0240425505,
-0.0303898938,
0.0155409044,
0.0456317179,
0.0280068554,
-0.0126912044,
0.0000019976,
-0.0577658303,
-0.0070721782,
-0.0176569186,
-0.0059595187,
-0.0035418877,
0.0734022036,
-0.013302967,
0.001428952,
0.0335973427,
-0.0519633964,
-0.0278421026,
0.043270532,
0.0866795555,
0.019496426,
0.0849542096,
-0.0115335993,
-0.0048539615,
-0.0200949982,
0.0050910949,
0.0553501993,
-0.0101010222,
0.0068506678,
-0.0490049459,
-0.0060158204,
-0.0047028656,
-0.0209599398,
0.0177002996,
0.0195787419,
0.0564583875,
0.0131320134,
0.0318836868,
-0.0575316176,
0.0043860809,
-0.0380741023,
0.0223688688,
0.0021610628,
-0.053319741,
-0.027335234,
-0.0349298939,
0.0465366431,
0.0040433798,
-0.0505495407,
-0.010969826,
0.0135216396,
0.0282286666,
0.0370354056,
0.0077063376,
0.0310391579,
0.0176031999,
0.0170731135,
0.0503840111,
-0.0069688782,
-0.0605286732,
0.0343899652,
0.0595565252,
-0.0369724594,
-0.0223227963,
-0.0400360264,
-0.0242726579,
-0.0036994738,
0.0432697125,
-0.0469124131,
-0.0091515733,
0.0080054672,
-0.0421661511,
0.0113282381,
0.0159458686,
-0.0167470798,
0.0321407169,
-0.0339473747,
0.0320547968,
0.0010204756,
0.0388304442,
-0.0153356846,
0.0239647776,
-0.0618614033,
-0.025255369,
-0.0232821833,
0.0296904296,
0.0449209884,
-0.0177599341,
-0.0103715416,
0.0130413705,
-0.0291300565,
-0.0015288546,
-0.0215918347,
-0.0147023508,
-0.0254217889,
-0.0119006224,
-0.0287531763,
0.0307750981,
-0.0097741587,
0.0481218472,
-0.0222376511,
-0.0536045171,
-0.0221707486,
0.026588846,
0.0012183802,
-0.0156896226,
0.0133270854,
0.052473709,
-0.0123751508,
-0.0904595256,
-0.0438041314,
0.001388086,
-0.0167683177,
-0.0509180538,
0.0011530179,
-0.0712531954,
-0.0200193971,
0.0307265557,
0.0127680376,
-0.0407506898,
-0.0022814695,
0.0167532936,
-0.0379997119,
0.0642258897,
0.0233964305,
0.0112315398,
0.0135532059,
-0.0239699315,
-0.0216486957,
0.0777900368,
0.0189595185,
-0.0153139569,
0.0055252961,
0.0232350752,
0.021261042,
0.0410012491,
0.0095365532,
0.0341598019,
-0.0406060852,
-0.0082895588,
0.0055143312,
0.0263171121,
0.0162159894,
0.024638962,
-0.0218410306,
0.0292560644,
0.0843939334,
0.0383445844,
-0.0007889833,
-0.0085146138,
-0.0015360753,
0.0274436232,
0.015491914,
0.0235320646,
-0.0542161241,
-0.006828011,
-0.0383486263,
0.0145611875,
0.0232471898,
-0.0241205711,
-0.0168180633,
-0.0559088439,
-0.0280376468,
-0.0063604326,
0.0427757166,
0.0191680267,
0.039068643,
0.0547586791,
-0.0555327088,
0.0217804331,
0.0230462831,
-0.0426942334,
-0.0053837011,
-0.0478925891,
-0.0000120129,
0.0476624519,
0.0321617723,
-0.0358389914,
-0.0119989663,
-0.0228899401,
0.031089684,
0.0680697039,
0.0312915407,
-0.017753318,
-0.0300360527,
-0.0191988498,
-0.0298147202,
-0.0255696289,
0.0550877228,
-0.0135017131,
0.0413847156,
0.0017337563,
-0.0059092529,
-0.044874832,
-0.036170233,
0.0417585708,
-0.0268891715,
-0.0850784406,
-0.030017117,
0.008309192,
0.0225091819,
0.0119489217,
0.0006334417,
0.0004804683,
0.0112702791,
-0.0121606495,
0.0033884475,
0.0224164203,
-0.057457123,
-0.0817253441,
0.0064464612,
-0.0477391332,
-0.0250761379,
-1.53e-7,
-0.0429705605,
-0.010886576,
-0.0184879377,
-0.0516053475,
0.0925693959,
-0.0077624684,
-0.0017046724,
-0.0257746186,
-0.0336411297,
-0.0328944139,
0.0408839844,
-0.0074548405,
-0.0105846785,
0.012656102,
-0.0034546671,
-0.0254347548,
0.0084751723,
-0.0154220071,
0.0172952022,
0.0159671213,
0.0087436335,
0.0301320981,
0.0224150326,
-0.0664887652,
-0.025842879,
-0.1427481174,
-0.0046760323,
-0.0396531336,
-0.0183507297,
0.0303615443,
-0.0088616377,
-0.0197255649,
-0.0212502368,
-0.0151040424,
-0.0531400293,
-0.0240916945,
0.0397611372,
0.032262601,
0.010910782,
0.0045898673,
-0.021833213,
0.002948649,
-0.0332018957,
0.0596279837,
0.0169191528,
-0.0164449364,
-0.0363432243,
0.0463810749,
0.0322612301,
0.0013225265,
0.0023990292,
-0.001478281,
0.0310043767,
0.0061742226,
0.005528396,
0.0797238499,
-0.009357987,
0.0419918895,
0.0223972835,
0.0428850837,
-0.0659053326,
0.0095020989,
-0.0242563467,
-0.0207819585,
-0.0473639593,
0.0039776224,
0.0090907654,
0.0524253324,
0.0122944945,
-0.0158615112,
-0.0690800622,
0.0292146951,
-0.0197212212,
-0.0219119247,
-0.0098853279,
-0.0239809547,
-0.0252928194,
-0.0187374428,
-0.0144696375,
-0.0697884038,
0.055982016,
-0.0097074136,
0.0129034985,
-0.0800473392,
0.0050101508,
-0.0295059644,
0.0472731702,
0.0133126229,
0.0027271286,
0.0003330555,
-0.0249494705,
-0.0651957542,
0.0195687655,
0.0133951511,
-0.0157756209,
0.0709077567,
-0.0244262945,
0.0146970423,
0.0545491576,
-0.052695591,
-0.0512120351,
-0.0647359565,
-0.0138593102,
-0.0043555303,
-0.0306952409,
0.0004922694,
0.018224135,
-0.048919417,
0.0189621709,
0.0354409479,
0.0139996456,
-0.0315033942,
0.0107173212,
-0.0318854973,
0.0116475988,
0.0178126115,
0.00458598,
-0.0299613252,
-0.0163232498,
0.0324664824,
0.0731828287,
-0.0078910617,
-0.0223208033,
0.0176340565,
0.0188456606,
-0.049587369,
-0.001325551,
0.0200853627,
0.0580286942,
-0.059862718,
0.0031781341,
0.1043605581,
0.0123401545,
-0.0934979245,
0.0355230346,
0.0412380397,
0.0379459411,
0.0425102338,
-0.0096586561,
-0.0635178834,
-0.056028869,
0.0061567309,
0.0042434684,
-0.0319440477,
-0.0073753526,
-0.0178140216,
-0.1598180383,
-0.0030683447,
0.028389642,
-0.0412283987,
-0.0129626095,
-0.0431839488,
0.0064750165,
-0.027795244,
0.0458749384,
-0.0225625969,
-0.0333926715,
0.0107982578,
0.0285386574,
-0.0300281011,
-0.1209319085,
-0.0009400464,
-0.0066733072,
0.0273002461,
0.0652874932,
0.0054410165,
-0.0264809169,
0.0019516281,
0.0612975918,
0.0154887252,
0.0218536723,
-0.0301471446,
0.0758920908,
-0.0245722402,
0.002980788,
0.0152561972,
0.059288606,
-0.0328671187,
-0.0118784476,
0.0039633405,
0.0565740168,
0.0122638913,
-0.0030402008,
-0.0058229831,
-0.0186945703,
0.0495144241,
0.0876219049,
0.0309295263,
-0.072100766,
-0.0090509141,
-0.0322014205,
0.0071661887,
0.0333378538,
-0.0503708199,
0.0007927271,
0.0040846476,
-0.0072152843,
-0.0541637056,
-0.0564790815,
0.0398417152,
0.0213563051,
-0.0003935633,
0.0297860429,
-0.0299564581,
0.0046972469,
-0.0238477848,
0.0551901609,
0.0151370466,
-0.0045785089,
-0.0232566837,
-0.0466106683,
0.0003717336,
-0.0404384173,
-0.0230497643,
-0.0102726826,
-0.0413458943,
-0.0725710467,
0.0308966041,
0.0474503413,
0.0120995529,
0.0823915824,
0.0234428402,
-0.0450825803,
0.0811403915,
0.06820032,
-0.0028883109,
0.024081612,
0.0261051077,
-0.0024686635,
0.0051258546,
0.0279004499,
-0.0183315985,
0.010673482,
0.0314311683,
0.0390271656,
-0.0111302128,
0.0017409436,
0.0466192327,
-0.0047606593,
0.1045370474,
-0.023519922,
-0.0282672197,
-0.0261317473,
-0.0076697408,
0.0083923992,
-0.0267530326,
-0.0345020071,
-0.0135489423,
0.0063353078,
0.0342555344,
-0.0415309146,
-0.0085908128,
-0.0149171986,
0.02563986,
-0.0080962833,
0.0290539376,
0.0376326069,
-0.0209694728,
0.0020513802,
0.0201700814,
-0.03551526,
0.0148607753,
-0.0015077505,
0.0127589731,
0.0179013927,
0.0331676304,
0.0287774224,
0.0052192798,
-0.003783385,
0.0237290319,
-0.0679395273,
-0.0081627201,
-0.0585378967,
0.0452109501,
0.0158624798,
-0.0584638305,
0.0550435297,
-0.0592725724,
0.0134597663,
-0.0122350631,
-0.0110568432,
-0.0214832276,
-0.0209689625,
0.0213310421,
0.0229448471,
-0.0428958088,
0.0200047623,
0.0677058697,
0.0036027825,
0.0752536282,
-0.0048126602,
0.0125096291,
-0.0256420355,
-0.0239239633,
0.0750674829,
0.0295464806,
0.004883247,
0.028168764,
-0.0501949303,
-0.0480826125,
-0.0078916028,
-0.0139484061,
0.009484007,
-0.0418198518,
0.0416643396,
0.0653011799,
-0.0520638004,
-0.0061610602,
-0.0171052571,
-0.0468295887,
0.0080518527,
-0.0312530287,
-0.0233092401,
-6.348206548e-33,
-0.0209825896,
-0.0202198271,
-0.0074846228,
0.048891332,
-0.0040668887,
-0.0031957978,
0.0044364622,
0.0435885005,
-0.006026194,
0.0218112152,
-0.013329302,
0.0264585484,
0.0075104078,
0.0170834772,
0.0279021561,
-0.031473998,
0.0592593364,
0.0005893577,
-0.0462413393,
0.0102691241,
-0.0039689564,
0.010877193,
0.078622967,
-0.1005700678,
0.0426311493,
-0.0062396713,
-0.0233904626,
-0.0005723475,
-0.0285690986,
0.0362400375,
-0.0007498449,
0.0809489638,
0.0297265798,
-0.0422483347,
-0.0041476786,
0.0326829813,
0.0035886669,
-0.0477935039,
0.0267507639,
0.0335098393,
0.0044933152,
-0.0227596629,
0.0600890256,
-0.0085875671,
-0.0743516982,
-0.0134131424,
0.0418271981,
-0.0136717334,
0.0076709432,
-0.0075651831,
-0.073033236,
0.014709481,
0.0117583256,
0.0104332026,
0.0171540733,
0.046170339,
-0.021613501,
0.013524075,
-0.0439648964,
0.0314684138,
0.0198619124,
0.0328892209,
0.0431440137,
-0.0014205006,
0.0173287261,
0.0649342835,
0.0098471427,
0.0510604568,
0.0178517513,
-0.0474907048,
0.0512202345,
0.018581083,
0.0221662316,
0.0688189119,
0.0693524554,
0.0239755213,
-0.0050482955,
-0.007499313,
0.0232171584,
-0.0198738165,
0.0452924743,
0.0058764056,
-0.0971368253,
-0.0294083562,
-0.0502699912,
0.0083661471,
-0.0124839358,
-0.0531967171,
0.035343729,
0.0264918469,
-0.0032963839,
0.015137407,
-0.0081287296,
-0.0305664353,
-0.0490251444,
0.0221262816,
-0.0273637641,
0.0293033496,
-0.0070210807,
-0.0080376873,
-0.0617402233,
-0.0243010912,
-0.0344247594,
0.0187940188,
0.0280448366,
0.003362189,
0.0616702288,
0.041903913,
-0.0860968307,
-0.0161866397,
-0.0022894859,
-0.003544444,
0.0036411763,
-0.0262925066,
0.053718362,
0.0308509879,
-0.0199960656,
0.0261709914,
0.0127818324,
-0.0405658558,
-0.0051120254,
-0.0211462099,
-0.0456088036,
-0.0024081203,
-0.0253432784,
-0.0328283273,
0.0015986331,
-0.0103269555,
0.0036846166,
-0.0522986129,
-0.0315897614,
0.0213800576,
2.758e-7,
0.0141009353,
0.0819796994,
-0.03113438,
-0.013689464,
0.0224230699,
0.0593655929,
-0.0231936667,
0.0184476804,
0.0266963094,
-0.0371900424,
0.0154911876,
0.0285735484,
0.0458491109,
0.0093470998,
-0.1147860587,
-0.0192571729,
-0.0298290774,
0.0654788911,
-0.018787032,
0.0021708012,
0.0563973263,
0.0648637414,
0.0297937952,
0.0050581037,
-0.0153681012,
-0.0489819534,
0.0696724951,
-0.0585500114,
-0.0024052288,
-0.0168182179,
-0.0097622676,
0.0368233211,
0.0194408242,
0.0327235684,
-0.0170061216,
0.0099169351,
-0.0175297391,
0.0318673402,
-0.0045702914,
-0.0451454818,
-0.0018919669,
0.0533490777,
-0.0129171144,
-0.044888366,
0.0532432422,
-0.0736081898,
-0.0111197401,
-0.0525758006,
0.0295787752,
-0.036012698,
0.0396864712,
0.0068877637,
-0.0161467604,
0.0054254541,
0.0275285523,
0.0020414211,
-0.0267954227,
-0.0584057681,
-0.038372837,
0.0515213609,
-0.0294284094,
-0.0324643962,
-0.0160808731,
0.0657856241,
0.0019618301,
-0.0441327877,
0.0162590295,
2.517502987e-34,
0.024826549,
-0.0160497725,
0.0722530186,
0.0290316995,
0.0002203767,
0.007853616,
0.0173428617,
0.0140814204,
0.0641269013,
-0.0530655272,
0.0298753381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13298v1 | DiffusionNER: Boundary Diffusion for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T17:56:12 | 2023-05-22T17:56:12 | Yongliang Shen, Kaitao Song, Xu Tan, Dongsheng Li, Weiming Lu, Yueting Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose DiffusionNER, which formulates the named entity
recognition task as a boundary-denoising diffusion process and thus generates
named entities from noisy spans. During training, DiffusionNER gradually adds
noises to the golden entity boundaries by a fixed forward diffusion process and
learns a reverse diffusion process to recover the entity boundaries. In
inference, DiffusionNER first randomly samples some noisy spans from a standard
Gaussian distribution and then generates the named entities by denoising them
with the learned reverse diffusion process. The proposed boundary-denoising
diffusion process allows progressive refinement and dynamic sampling of
entities, empowering DiffusionNER with efficient and flexible entity generation
capability. Experiments on multiple flat and nested NER datasets demonstrate
that DiffusionNER achieves comparable or even better performance than previous
state-of-the-art models. | [
0.0204082318,
0.0297851078,
0.0198179912,
0.0086466679,
0.026389366,
0.0223091654,
0.0074006636,
-0.0076588737,
0.0076647792,
0.0339366086,
-0.0013959541,
-0.0281717684,
0.0010154919,
0.0096183745,
0.0375747941,
-0.0450295284,
-0.0050117825,
-0.0090199932,
0.0172086526,
0.0174811892,
-0.0382786505,
0.0113495886,
-0.0087446468,
-0.0176495891,
-0.0164298695,
0.0312021244,
-0.0372817777,
0.0308326185,
0.053534504,
-0.0955630019,
0.0027516081,
0.0265683811,
0.0075525884,
0.0260019023,
0.0000019658,
-0.0473135747,
-0.029261753,
0.0252150744,
-0.014271711,
-0.0455586426,
0.0605302528,
-0.0302666686,
0.0026593525,
-0.0125206299,
0.0146564394,
-0.0304342955,
0.0389848985,
0.1088216379,
0.0391605534,
0.0458897091,
-0.0203094296,
-0.0659435019,
0.0285602603,
-0.0278150346,
0.0277956948,
-0.0649237111,
0.0372683331,
-0.0069935089,
-0.0079277642,
-0.0107816895,
-0.0194650553,
0.0068369154,
0.0087222541,
0.0054978644,
0.0567459166,
0.0649241209,
0.0168096125,
-0.0125978068,
-0.0151300654,
0.106155701,
-0.0184552744,
0.0261074323,
0.0565698855,
-0.0098854592,
-0.0276787896,
-0.0063485787,
-0.0195967928,
-0.0109415073,
-0.0415665321,
0.0094378358,
-0.0349551179,
0.0049173925,
0.0411847383,
-0.0115067046,
-0.0085156607,
-0.0046811556,
0.0186647773,
-0.0419979468,
0.0150150806,
0.0193901602,
0.0375411287,
-0.0420748666,
0.0544752777,
0.0434293263,
0.0124600735,
0.0318122171,
-0.0407503545,
-0.0339804217,
-0.0164969005,
0.0192248356,
-0.0094193714,
-0.006494463,
0.0304558147,
0.0291192457,
-0.0733035877,
-0.0418700837,
-0.0453371927,
-0.036802642,
0.0205222145,
-0.0278430711,
-0.0070154192,
0.0130228521,
-0.0435183533,
0.0651585534,
-0.0432124436,
-0.0296444427,
-0.0407845154,
0.002890324,
-0.0090636369,
0.0100740688,
0.0341541246,
0.0036608607,
-0.0213778056,
-0.0304562449,
-0.0106801577,
0.003820509,
-0.0375542864,
-0.0259079207,
0.0282645579,
0.015175622,
-0.0137371635,
-0.0323868915,
0.0562947541,
-0.0292523615,
0.0319155306,
0.0642365813,
0.0087672928,
-0.0649971664,
-0.0666106492,
-0.0093368525,
0.019352017,
-0.0277674235,
0.0229681041,
-0.0371724181,
0.0418816395,
-0.0206566174,
-0.017286038,
-0.0262827855,
0.033460997,
-0.0115742562,
-0.0436143726,
0.0773915723,
-0.0703522637,
-0.0219425578,
0.0576569811,
-0.007236992,
0.0832404122,
0.0327021256,
0.0509916171,
-0.0063673751,
0.0154503779,
0.0349496119,
-0.0201158766,
0.0182922091,
0.0640115663,
-0.0133001162,
0.0058686915,
-0.0260786526,
-0.0454825722,
0.0431097448,
0.0416688137,
0.0519301817,
-0.0296758618,
-0.0314595848,
0.0326646976,
0.0347930677,
-0.0308202077,
-0.0144670596,
0.0317187123,
-0.0086557074,
-0.0257672984,
0.0110920416,
-0.0014961497,
0.0167160966,
0.0230063591,
0.023055248,
0.0046993853,
0.0531546436,
-0.0473835729,
-0.0149538228,
0.0425152816,
-0.034036871,
0.0295528229,
-0.0030541201,
0.0684156194,
0.0484981947,
-0.0740352646,
0.079852581,
0.027826678,
-0.0430240259,
0.0182058755,
-0.0045274543,
0.0431774482,
0.0448735729,
0.0348696224,
-0.0341427103,
-0.0573947653,
-0.0451798141,
-0.0175793599,
0.0478365272,
-0.0100608198,
0.0016632372,
0.0377538502,
-0.0584745407,
-0.0100414278,
0.0564972498,
0.0144534046,
0.0456446148,
0.0093288291,
0.0357535183,
0.038951572,
-0.0423112623,
-0.0458763763,
0.0426885746,
-0.0581839271,
-0.0101405447,
0.0330052115,
0.014593102,
-0.0086600622,
0.0579862297,
-0.0128174508,
-0.0380202867,
0.0191330388,
-0.0332039073,
-0.0279561002,
-0.0188245587,
-0.0225847587,
-0.045474194,
-0.0191770699,
-0.0477540791,
-0.0246902909,
-0.0126974629,
-0.0331563614,
-0.0505679436,
-0.0188723188,
0.0194409415,
-0.0171324611,
-0.0317185335,
0.0005910862,
0.0433903113,
0.0375678651,
-0.009665614,
0.0802805796,
-0.0233813468,
0.0154555794,
-0.009114855,
0.046064239,
-0.0375864543,
-0.0488395244,
-0.0305545367,
-0.0195846148,
-0.0011471726,
-0.0486731902,
0.0026815997,
-0.0178319775,
-0.0458953492,
-0.0274765119,
-0.0487661399,
-0.0001389727,
-0.0073602134,
0.014170357,
0.0011941997,
0.0457633361,
-0.0058059655,
-0.0140473861,
-0.0113548944,
0.0030038976,
-0.0115688359,
-0.0251834169,
0.0282174721,
-0.0060691568,
-0.0408613868,
0.0208162535,
-0.0028240005,
-0.0181214623,
0.0092640268,
0.0319952555,
-0.0698259622,
-0.0587156899,
0.043883726,
-0.0217879787,
0.0219115224,
0.0000096083,
0.0558855049,
0.0120029589,
0.042556636,
0.0431053266,
0.0382669792,
0.0112859886,
0.0600849763,
-0.0621744171,
-0.0126831857,
-0.0050755795,
0.046650514,
-0.0427402034,
0.0782767162,
-0.0122854523,
-0.0709958002,
0.024017008,
0.0648511723,
-0.0362185203,
0.0232093241,
-0.0243216343,
-0.0062667285,
-0.0006193492,
-0.0273338333,
-0.0171875246,
0.0112522533,
-0.042326957,
-0.0030539059,
-0.0422752947,
-0.015948195,
0.0516061299,
-0.0505654588,
-0.0283095781,
-0.0230901428,
-0.0013197074,
-0.0257632062,
0.016850153,
0.0129251787,
0.0245208312,
0.0462334752,
-0.0909559205,
-0.0043549426,
0.052771531,
0.0011141007,
-0.0149233583,
0.0280404631,
-0.0038068965,
0.0348582081,
0.0054668887,
0.0215972085,
-0.0469189994,
-0.0091509707,
0.0184708349,
0.0129015977,
-0.0641392916,
-0.0177234747,
-0.0088429637,
0.0201912522,
0.0047540264,
0.0207398254,
0.0222539324,
-0.010300382,
-0.0431175306,
0.0720373914,
0.0463902615,
0.0434047729,
0.0192953274,
-0.0220246911,
-0.0085706953,
0.0075090476,
-0.0071346317,
-0.0006078155,
0.0036831088,
-0.0142505672,
-0.0275297649,
-0.0271922257,
0.0299451742,
-0.0157768205,
0.0784953907,
-0.0148169287,
-0.0029832814,
0.0863324553,
-0.0045391568,
-0.0095453169,
-0.0198344402,
0.0495822802,
0.0500908606,
0.0203598607,
-0.0068880604,
-0.0786222517,
-0.0031689275,
0.0068384036,
0.0076167444,
0.0074119545,
-0.0812114775,
0.0061685941,
-0.1140070707,
0.0381261371,
-0.0092849489,
-0.0447310582,
0.0274703186,
-0.0585427098,
0.013905121,
0.0106821992,
0.0173563361,
-0.0246165507,
-0.0103721321,
-0.0216633715,
0.0302193128,
0.0419324636,
-0.085873954,
-0.0384468287,
-0.0557295233,
0.0452834964,
0.0195912011,
0.026557181,
-0.0205619708,
-0.041007258,
0.0200995952,
-0.0369089916,
-0.0353964791,
-0.0073735286,
0.0682823285,
0.0006049825,
-0.0333437957,
-0.0306521133,
0.0013384438,
-0.0179934632,
-0.0078717191,
-0.0043607038,
0.0486572087,
0.0016885167,
-0.0137686552,
-0.0001652697,
-0.0156731121,
0.0605467334,
0.0665941387,
0.0316579267,
-0.0189651866,
-0.0164047852,
0.0201045852,
0.0383089446,
0.0038874089,
-0.0319554545,
0.0288166627,
-0.0766334608,
-0.0943891406,
-0.0537909903,
-0.0543327294,
0.032141529,
0.0930875689,
0.0190257356,
0.0373968743,
0.0471495241,
-0.0278305486,
-0.0445646569,
-0.0010632565,
-0.0072358684,
0.0055312724,
-0.0138092916,
-0.0298046656,
-0.0053147092,
0.0066455263,
-0.0401188247,
0.0438830853,
-0.0644368753,
-0.0711738095,
-0.0173826814,
0.0075516072,
0.0192558095,
0.0358416811,
-0.0255188607,
-0.0158955697,
0.0872711167,
0.0300097633,
-0.016011361,
-0.011058135,
-0.0070349649,
-0.0049739582,
-0.0233238116,
0.018712109,
-0.0261462871,
0.0494329445,
0.0154352915,
0.0380131751,
-0.0508315749,
0.0204567779,
-0.0228921026,
-0.0038382076,
0.023947686,
-0.0145349372,
0.0385237187,
-0.0644975603,
0.0269265044,
0.0061449879,
0.0273051262,
-0.0257493854,
-0.0325641781,
0.0499256589,
-0.0013613601,
-0.0084392764,
0.0251079965,
0.0147897787,
0.0265333802,
-0.0510322079,
-0.0133379782,
-0.0125820609,
0.0646998733,
0.0370205902,
-0.0244515464,
0.000424227,
0.0463738926,
0.0591539703,
0.0550023392,
0.0140627809,
-0.0018750216,
0.0094108954,
0.0142069682,
-0.0450079218,
-0.020342635,
-0.0255863126,
-0.0058934898,
-0.0611421429,
0.0497180298,
0.0156575795,
0.0343953297,
0.0558903851,
0.0034210926,
0.0074449945,
0.0256003439,
0.0018607207,
-0.0146652032,
-0.0178295448,
0.0300994534,
0.0065330332,
-0.0092114629,
-0.0081817238,
0.0577315316,
-0.0015544367,
0.0412817448,
-0.0189073421,
0.0291661825,
-0.0475407504,
-0.0176940616,
-0.0063693007,
-0.0326083675,
0.0009527709,
0.0330503583,
-0.0085010407,
-0.0649084151,
0.0260010753,
-0.0526292287,
0.0056776991,
0.0036338391,
0.0285151154,
0.0065417578,
0.0046632015,
0.0037797736,
-0.0131014828,
0.023599036,
0.0158676617,
-0.0548808724,
-0.0164772198,
-6.567289308e-33,
-0.0365741514,
-0.0370623991,
0.0365362801,
-0.0256304722,
-0.043779619,
-0.0061886883,
-0.050606437,
-0.0043013473,
0.0258718245,
0.0007262852,
-0.00855105,
0.0137429563,
0.0375695303,
0.0184543896,
-0.0348655842,
-0.0357328281,
0.0904153585,
0.0120942919,
-0.0014582644,
0.0288238022,
0.0206235144,
0.0851219445,
0.056658417,
-0.105621241,
0.0226700883,
-0.0049435943,
-0.0026191031,
-0.011522349,
0.1034746468,
0.0216600467,
-0.0232807882,
-0.0090344353,
0.011288465,
-0.0472883172,
-0.011139648,
0.0021730119,
-0.1769471616,
0.0274500791,
-0.0545104295,
0.0261887275,
-0.0455416478,
-0.0222976804,
0.0742780566,
-0.0011721583,
0.0318841524,
0.0272855051,
0.0415105335,
-0.0011510586,
-0.0092911413,
-0.0145532349,
-0.0575519986,
0.0538672507,
0.012813583,
0.0492004976,
0.0323304348,
-0.0712649077,
0.0246325787,
-0.0228274669,
-0.1002016738,
-0.0238002036,
0.0402510092,
-0.0273874942,
-0.000676048,
0.0289057475,
-0.0033297031,
0.0260750353,
0.0539196655,
0.0131381471,
-0.0172989871,
-0.0139394822,
0.0066508595,
0.0327780172,
-0.0352841876,
0.0063769156,
0.0192793645,
-0.0559962168,
-0.071374163,
0.0416338108,
-0.0184248313,
0.0031612671,
-0.0023434598,
-0.0284213237,
-0.0167539697,
0.0231184624,
0.0132415146,
-0.0238538217,
-0.0243720729,
0.0020174396,
0.0106388833,
0.053473074,
-0.0610077865,
0.0177664161,
0.0185221899,
0.0153801832,
-0.041966252,
-0.022195369,
0.0719872341,
0.0179513078,
0.0090223709,
-0.0461247265,
-0.0465296246,
-0.0519765429,
-0.0066067181,
0.0281592701,
-0.0102058705,
-0.0038292648,
0.0343030132,
-0.0374398716,
-0.0695487708,
0.0199493542,
-0.0196400508,
0.0576342605,
0.0037449887,
0.0488321446,
0.0084904376,
-0.0402604304,
-0.0074136797,
0.0054941215,
0.0467878804,
0.0119301742,
0.0078732651,
0.0751601905,
0.0283210091,
0.0494729802,
-0.0331577249,
-0.0167041905,
-0.0004549509,
0.0029793093,
0.0503903143,
-0.0711519122,
0.0017008383,
0.0160172805,
2.771e-7,
-0.006826093,
-0.006000156,
0.0222392697,
0.0068570701,
0.008160647,
-0.0141960653,
0.0386639126,
0.0412431918,
-0.0219576862,
-0.0587032959,
0.0037074506,
-0.0248820446,
0.0013358636,
0.0237140469,
-0.1351717263,
-0.061422471,
-0.0023173185,
0.0166844185,
-0.040021643,
0.0227223113,
-0.0069953641,
0.0458845906,
-0.0092281327,
-0.0240901019,
-0.0077330433,
-0.0119473469,
0.0569835342,
0.0451814234,
0.0546144806,
0.0411706418,
0.0172831789,
0.0194118731,
-0.0361946411,
0.023734618,
-0.0324160419,
0.0388703384,
0.0090856673,
0.02805648,
-0.0006751266,
-0.0050189979,
0.018857494,
-0.0183655955,
0.0177561324,
-0.0110612893,
0.0520650521,
-0.0157422312,
-0.0110221924,
-0.0089569492,
-0.0421381257,
-0.0149205737,
0.0177870132,
0.0033363833,
-0.0192670021,
0.014571893,
0.0208605696,
-0.0270384047,
0.005141302,
-0.0654264539,
0.048457846,
-0.0133424895,
-0.0259715673,
-0.0204250589,
-0.005612236,
-0.0464946926,
0.0096994424,
-0.0296929292,
-0.0036069895,
2.479998747e-34,
0.0013979052,
0.0041493229,
-0.0263598748,
0.0496688336,
0.008504183,
-0.0293277223,
-0.0677643195,
0.0071870205,
-0.0261841584,
-0.0672965273,
-0.0091319634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13297v2 | Investigating the Role of Feed-Forward Networks in Transformers Using Parallel Attention and Feed-Forward Net Design | 2023-05-22T17:56:09 | 2023-05-25T17:01:13 | Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the key role of Feed-Forward Networks (FFNs) in
transformer models by utilizing the Parallel Attention and Feed-Forward Net
Design (PAF) architecture, and comparing it to their Series Attention and
Feed-Forward Net Design (SAF) counterparts. Central to the effectiveness of PAF
are two main assumptions regarding the FFN block and the attention block within
a layer: 1) the primary function of the FFN block is to maintain isotropy among
token embeddings and prevent their degeneration, and 2) the residual norm
computed in the attention block is substantially smaller than the input token
embedding norm. To empirically validate these assumptions, we train PAF
variants of two large language models (RoBERTa-large and bert-large-uncased).
Our results demonstrate that both assumptions hold true in the PAF design. This
study contributes to a deeper understanding of the roles and interactions
between FFNs and self-attention mechanisms in transformer architectures. | [
0.0114017846,
0.0338396132,
-0.0099761477,
0.0266126767,
-0.0169378947,
-0.0079249358,
0.056009721,
-0.0285396539,
-0.0494953617,
0.0031702281,
-0.0420675762,
-0.0429592691,
0.0022647665,
0.000227465,
0.0685190707,
-0.0233398471,
0.0651086196,
-0.0151683902,
-0.0270412192,
-0.0050243461,
-0.0017562179,
-0.0259673093,
0.0034526302,
0.0505069457,
-0.0424122065,
-0.0162240956,
-0.0150869908,
-0.0099406354,
0.0131590515,
0.0137367509,
-0.0207359642,
0.0440966263,
0.0082207816,
0.0325595066,
0.0000017565,
-0.002468915,
0.0177821014,
0.0112822177,
-0.0166198835,
0.0269203577,
0.0154303005,
0.0091013443,
-0.0337589048,
0.018409133,
0.0184862427,
-0.0704943091,
0.0706567094,
0.0941261202,
0.0577238575,
0.0605167076,
-0.0203163847,
-0.0701859295,
0.0641996488,
-0.0425893143,
-0.0622327849,
0.0096216071,
0.0194412917,
-0.0502777807,
-0.0300947521,
-0.0194280874,
-0.0400739275,
0.0659291223,
0.0534776971,
0.0017176957,
0.0178114437,
0.0382402018,
-0.0445725694,
-0.0267430022,
0.0000103325,
0.0446526632,
-0.0570953228,
-0.0212568901,
-0.0293064937,
0.0165294241,
-0.002173139,
0.0073709134,
-0.0468568914,
0.0267902724,
0.0292973462,
0.0224377625,
0.021532679,
-0.0035703764,
0.0420552976,
-0.0276092514,
-0.0545413122,
0.0212085806,
0.0364479795,
-0.0519704521,
-0.0103620114,
-0.0112857828,
-0.0276830141,
-0.0204457659,
0.06064675,
0.0309766252,
0.0086224405,
0.0211067498,
-0.0295709278,
-0.0534991175,
-0.0105602751,
-0.0466234572,
0.0401294157,
0.0373384766,
-0.0515340231,
-0.0265036672,
-0.0723641142,
0.0758952573,
-0.0683471709,
0.0476605892,
-0.0457869545,
0.014846772,
-0.0013466208,
-0.0139715215,
-0.0780450851,
0.0521868728,
-0.0234298892,
-0.0600566529,
-0.0233101491,
0.0463145189,
0.0183588769,
-0.0079367012,
0.0364841893,
0.0186906736,
-0.026187459,
0.0131557463,
0.030144386,
0.0579331182,
-0.0201772638,
-0.0197697636,
0.0136724077,
-0.04425193,
-0.0385003164,
-0.0007322417,
-0.0039119557,
-0.0146630332,
-0.0130717307,
0.0700710639,
-0.0028084752,
-0.0234540682,
-0.0369678773,
0.0349216536,
-0.0189624615,
-0.0232878216,
0.0472863577,
-0.0167689174,
0.009170346,
-0.0015979504,
0.0083232233,
0.030761756,
0.0075578941,
0.0474990867,
-0.002384282,
0.0354990736,
0.0222935248,
-0.0204858687,
0.0200942624,
-0.0169052966,
0.0114683099,
0.0480876081,
0.028563289,
0.0044717756,
-0.0107028997,
-0.0477903076,
-0.0217510555,
0.0325406305,
0.0351303108,
-0.0076454142,
-0.0448910072,
-0.0347226337,
-0.0026334713,
0.0315651186,
0.0160682444,
0.0829428509,
-0.0153604411,
-0.023504518,
0.0753548667,
0.0433362499,
0.0687157065,
0.09481024,
0.0386938527,
-0.020112358,
0.0022174851,
0.0339239314,
-0.0293356143,
0.050581377,
0.0314304903,
0.0152378315,
0.011131159,
0.0348138027,
-0.0600140356,
-0.0245116837,
-0.0025451304,
0.0072645335,
-0.0068769371,
-0.0323284119,
0.0454076715,
0.0473170355,
-0.0690215454,
0.0812353268,
-0.0244206861,
-0.0386567563,
0.005263079,
-0.0526593551,
-0.0199706163,
0.0099592032,
0.0366358608,
-0.0110013941,
-0.0305887647,
-0.0109321345,
-0.0037151228,
0.0374423452,
0.0487971753,
0.0431540608,
-0.0148614654,
-0.0392558314,
0.007865875,
0.0206170641,
-0.0079101948,
0.0261109322,
-0.0417890362,
0.0007291125,
-0.0063359318,
0.0056922617,
-0.0074159135,
0.0305516869,
0.0083903763,
0.0084290719,
0.0016373975,
0.0253648758,
0.0355340391,
0.0160145313,
-0.0121151339,
0.0428966582,
0.0481998697,
-0.0386399403,
-0.0119174682,
0.0356319249,
-0.0908750594,
-0.021039525,
0.0235508271,
-0.0235383734,
0.008620915,
0.0752100796,
0.0093244091,
-0.0575942025,
0.0512283593,
-0.0988332257,
0.0732370913,
-0.042619057,
0.0311623625,
0.0048646312,
0.0268294495,
0.0004061365,
0.0141954273,
-0.0179033317,
0.0368156321,
-0.0046295626,
0.0343518667,
0.0080030123,
-0.0381113552,
-0.057973858,
0.0163949579,
-0.0626588911,
-0.0106445681,
-0.0200683065,
-0.0520265996,
-0.0095170867,
-0.0312183164,
-0.027147539,
-0.0114910314,
-0.0306683015,
0.0340236165,
0.0024907126,
0.0245637819,
0.0209474862,
-0.0032034309,
-0.0300255939,
0.0218952801,
-0.029804375,
0.0251457375,
0.0344510563,
-0.0196631029,
-0.0535643846,
-0.0125154871,
-0.0626613945,
0.0010592126,
0.0740292743,
-0.0134172244,
-0.0029641122,
-0.0482682213,
-0.0365979224,
0.0124798184,
0.0499635637,
-0.0028759823,
-0.075973019,
0.0191023778,
-0.02174812,
0.0490619503,
0.0433555618,
0.0148953879,
-0.0031590734,
-0.0111709414,
-0.0061991042,
-0.0284291208,
0.0363626629,
-0.0349744521,
0.03297773,
-0.0171251353,
0.0230977088,
0.0306766145,
0.0821351409,
-0.0374588892,
-0.0134024033,
-0.0607205667,
-0.0367919281,
-0.0011379269,
-0.0310653448,
0.0419879258,
-0.0350515731,
-0.0416369475,
-0.0274442993,
-0.0183407366,
-0.0309141632,
0.0558277518,
-0.0412880853,
-0.0250371695,
-0.0220521018,
0.022596946,
-0.0154119693,
-0.0069486201,
0.0246736035,
0.0128626497,
-0.0276935883,
-0.082654953,
-0.0308901612,
0.0334563404,
-0.0229854267,
-0.0092373034,
0.0906230062,
0.037186224,
-0.0204837844,
0.0003277563,
-0.0238923952,
-0.0437913612,
-0.0243150294,
-0.018809868,
0.0567420237,
0.0469184779,
-0.0150769148,
-0.0727353394,
0.0476510264,
0.0038711082,
0.0507862829,
-0.0296221115,
0.0047818688,
-0.0161746964,
0.0541251339,
-0.005054682,
0.0070428643,
0.054494638,
-0.0341080278,
0.0057702381,
0.0277864654,
0.0471604466,
0.0026196053,
-0.0497550145,
-0.0148884607,
0.0262828115,
-0.0498628952,
-0.0088037858,
-0.0231000688,
0.0199071188,
-0.0487293415,
-0.0329976529,
0.0869619474,
0.0004275459,
-0.0432725847,
0.0222739503,
0.0092915427,
0.0140639869,
0.0133416783,
0.0472008735,
-0.017066773,
-0.0040246802,
0.0092863925,
0.004978443,
0.0292870943,
0.0025454611,
0.016122479,
-0.0785004199,
0.0172761232,
0.0029791926,
-0.0409523137,
-0.0486876629,
-0.0203850549,
-0.0114225987,
-0.0028678793,
0.0374547914,
0.008648823,
-0.0106342044,
-0.0564905629,
0.0358466171,
-0.0120402463,
-0.0040411828,
-0.0232771095,
-0.0531812087,
0.0441151448,
0.0428832322,
-0.006543979,
-0.0276639573,
-0.088370204,
0.0311361402,
-0.0176278185,
0.0273305047,
0.000020812,
0.0238898229,
-0.0052173785,
-0.0337723531,
-0.0226671137,
-0.0338407308,
-0.0414254963,
-0.0003269615,
-0.0615079105,
0.0716919526,
0.0035555896,
-0.0414234586,
-0.0297318473,
0.0175675303,
-0.0312465467,
0.0416188538,
0.0454665422,
-0.048521366,
-0.0363318138,
-0.0098212361,
0.0293224324,
-0.0795119703,
0.00846643,
0.0052028028,
0.0380907618,
-0.0725978017,
-0.0350439362,
-0.0012663795,
0.0000204658,
0.0412521958,
0.0207525343,
-0.060119465,
0.0465973765,
0.0030964713,
-0.0128044318,
0.0142328842,
0.0163888261,
0.0059033446,
-0.0732185245,
0.0244455021,
0.041087836,
-0.0219015535,
-0.018689448,
-0.0270539038,
-0.0599483289,
-0.0176545084,
0.0500786491,
0.0411355048,
0.0090210494,
0.0080489218,
-0.029762039,
-0.0508237369,
0.0535114184,
0.0104749724,
-0.0473298542,
-0.0056070914,
0.0459986515,
-0.0475999638,
0.02765714,
0.0229172315,
-0.0073678973,
0.0410029739,
0.0301808994,
0.0459669568,
0.0300511699,
-0.0160984062,
-0.0056760963,
0.0043247165,
0.0512572341,
0.0147567363,
0.0280429479,
-0.0351752974,
0.0654493868,
0.0028562285,
0.0445106812,
-0.0427463017,
0.0007109962,
0.0246970598,
0.0135016534,
-0.0038856829,
-0.0027754141,
0.0142217856,
-0.0008984405,
0.0085590687,
0.0445700362,
-0.0196295604,
-0.0066129514,
0.0036757397,
0.0317483954,
-0.0338125676,
-0.0517383665,
0.033568576,
0.0107189268,
-0.0315064415,
0.0378004536,
0.0220219661,
0.0230092108,
-0.0486059636,
0.031403318,
-0.0549806766,
0.0043920237,
-0.0238450989,
-0.0197593141,
0.0314781144,
-0.0188868586,
0.0197230671,
-0.0007401358,
0.001098411,
-0.0094512524,
-0.0229766481,
-0.023934111,
-0.006791837,
0.0360915288,
0.0246545449,
0.0108040413,
-0.0470292978,
0.0219214577,
-0.0320991464,
-0.0074312966,
-0.018754296,
0.011806475,
-0.0421702079,
-0.0130622359,
-0.0100293411,
0.0101313228,
-0.0256981868,
-0.030023545,
-0.0171728339,
-0.0791200697,
-0.0065889419,
0.0026562829,
0.0100336969,
-0.0146626756,
0.0168643054,
0.017228039,
0.0280147176,
-0.0361821614,
0.0316273682,
0.0087530194,
0.0000094944,
-0.0101256715,
-0.0108308541,
-5.841737461e-33,
-0.0113995941,
0.0188727491,
0.0067924694,
-0.0175398905,
-0.0585662574,
0.021571923,
-0.0328751542,
-0.0175204482,
-0.0318372771,
0.0118698291,
-0.0439231396,
0.0094939349,
0.0087524559,
0.0461338311,
0.0127991028,
-0.0317791142,
0.0696222559,
-0.0076935501,
0.0222010631,
0.009314171,
0.0034997754,
0.0402500816,
0.0567826629,
0.0121924952,
-0.0488715358,
-0.0075874361,
0.0001483898,
0.0243838429,
-0.0239395276,
0.0724914521,
-0.0153183406,
0.0383134112,
0.0179470591,
-0.0771827847,
-0.0396646634,
0.0675989166,
-0.0793302134,
-0.0248738751,
0.0014586214,
0.0336127542,
-0.0320713595,
-0.0165366456,
0.0892951563,
0.013686615,
0.0028463227,
-0.0325611122,
0.0113029694,
0.0256418623,
-0.0269525442,
0.0077125365,
-0.0407351367,
-0.0093823103,
0.0050789732,
-0.0105903642,
0.0395829603,
0.0267454218,
-0.0191595256,
0.0018637282,
-0.0630250201,
0.0041113207,
-0.0161750708,
0.0379141048,
0.0463865511,
0.0550889708,
0.0009656042,
-0.0123597197,
0.0691712797,
-0.004909473,
-0.0375503413,
-0.0403035581,
0.065446578,
0.0126170926,
0.0915183797,
-0.0480376855,
0.0276939403,
-0.0226866081,
-0.0315257981,
-0.0564974137,
-0.0046702083,
0.083032757,
0.0446642414,
0.0080776643,
0.0027292557,
-0.0093067279,
-0.0073642395,
0.0041839201,
-0.0414291248,
-0.0109766209,
0.02675993,
0.0023715575,
0.0041314815,
0.0274341889,
0.0319995582,
-0.0446381457,
0.0387771614,
0.0019555939,
0.0251119472,
0.0556000844,
-0.0173359811,
0.0156114604,
-0.0810613558,
-0.0199692082,
-0.001471863,
0.0299237054,
-0.0143127767,
-0.0127360169,
0.0339082517,
0.0349335633,
-0.0646347478,
-0.0440275632,
-0.0339156277,
-0.002723776,
0.0063075013,
0.0606306829,
0.0480488464,
-0.003343595,
0.0027211905,
0.0116215423,
-0.0101959994,
0.0183945559,
-0.0162835456,
0.0577052347,
0.037084341,
0.0441716984,
-0.0108068371,
-0.0081346435,
-0.0564423539,
0.0859202519,
0.0379095823,
-0.0825925916,
-0.0379689187,
0.054509256,
2.532e-7,
0.0606942028,
0.0430057347,
0.0620252863,
-0.0196748804,
0.0352498516,
-0.0025620665,
0.007836163,
0.0521021336,
0.0273470767,
0.0605963357,
0.0153850596,
-0.0068299277,
0.0137719186,
0.0110180285,
-0.1167734489,
-0.0533336066,
-0.0947017893,
0.056851536,
-0.0086834971,
-0.0023045335,
0.0138079915,
0.0889670029,
-0.0286714751,
-0.0121830413,
-0.0078520924,
-0.014000372,
0.0160375647,
0.0096453493,
0.0275808852,
0.0081179393,
0.0098093357,
0.0047478103,
-0.0246007144,
0.0205717403,
-0.0075999554,
0.029817095,
-0.0057159457,
0.0141472705,
-0.007080663,
-0.0687634945,
0.019312188,
0.0150488773,
-0.0178025719,
-0.0609919429,
0.0229826588,
-0.0936311856,
-0.0265640896,
0.0229094382,
-0.0231831316,
0.014559947,
-0.0054134391,
-0.0103696287,
-0.0090055205,
0.014131627,
0.037693359,
-0.0072405748,
-0.0044345586,
-0.0772892013,
0.0036449777,
0.021456413,
-0.071699366,
-0.0109271593,
-0.0751050562,
-0.0454627201,
0.0691249743,
0.0223984513,
-0.0413411334,
2.16670333e-34,
0.0148302233,
-0.0290340874,
0.0341496393,
0.0281375293,
-0.0395951606,
-0.0350565575,
0.0378365591,
0.0134313069,
0.0122020813,
-0.0798264071,
-0.0567267984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14387v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14387v4 | AlpacaFarm: A Simulation Framework for Methods that Learn from Human Feedback | 2023-05-22T17:55:50 | 2024-01-08T04:46:56 | Yann Dubois, Xuechen Li, Rohan Taori, Tianyi Zhang, Ishaan Gulrajani, Jimmy Ba, Carlos Guestrin, Percy Liang, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have seen widespread adoption
due to their strong instruction-following abilities. Developing these LLMs
involves a complex yet poorly understood workflow requiring training with human
feedback. Replicating and understanding this instruction-following requires
tackling three major challenges: the high cost of data collection, the lack of
trustworthy evaluation, and the absence of reference method implementations. We
address these challenges with AlpacaFarm, a simulator that enables research and
development for learning from feedback at a low cost. First, we design LLM
prompts to simulate human feedback that are 50x cheaper than crowdworkers and
display high agreement with humans. Second, we propose an automatic evaluation
and validate it against human instructions obtained on real-world interactions.
Third, we contribute reference implementations for several methods (PPO, DPO,
best-of-n, expert iteration, and more) that learn from pairwise feedback.
Finally, as an end-to-end validation of AlpacaFarm, we train and evaluate
eleven models on 10k pairs of real human feedback and show that rankings of
models trained in AlpacaFarm match rankings of models trained on human data. As
a demonstration of the research possible in AlpacaFarm, we find that methods
that use a reward model can substantially improve over supervised fine-tuning
and that our reference PPO implementation leads to a +10% improvement in
win-rate against Davinci003. We release all components of AlpacaFarm at
https://github.com/tatsu-lab/alpaca_farm. | [
0.0599894375,
0.0644709766,
-0.0050597391,
0.0364303887,
-0.0240303539,
0.006671207,
-0.0110391211,
0.0100032361,
0.0226906035,
-0.0356059335,
-0.0649015382,
-0.0317477621,
0.0217114333,
-0.0026537708,
0.0641268417,
-0.0646379367,
0.028479822,
-0.0708314627,
0.0052265879,
-0.0115948627,
0.0277080145,
-0.0140055092,
-0.035211511,
0.0707190409,
0.0019935721,
0.0182826892,
-0.0406667814,
0.0022071288,
0.00601582,
-0.0241128001,
0.0300151538,
0.0882623196,
-0.0046345326,
0.0436184481,
0.0000021171,
-0.0273230635,
0.0155723235,
0.0019118686,
-0.0167380832,
0.0306403656,
0.0254856087,
0.0407535136,
-0.0319648385,
0.0359851457,
-0.0408756807,
0.008219908,
0.0460951291,
0.0164925065,
0.1061901823,
0.0623740703,
0.0149009367,
0.0142768146,
0.0310669262,
-0.0291247405,
0.023177918,
-0.0655056983,
0.0132715879,
-0.0035527209,
0.0457733572,
0.012649552,
0.0202073809,
0.0182724521,
0.0289655477,
-0.0168712996,
-0.0009741033,
0.0448527262,
-0.0413294733,
-0.0332954451,
-0.0482015163,
0.0980483219,
-0.0108253704,
-0.0224568732,
-0.004499448,
0.0196267087,
0.0177806988,
-0.0145879751,
-0.0465083495,
-0.0162869822,
0.0044179098,
0.0020351487,
-0.0252232701,
0.0016873948,
0.0098939957,
0.0174369756,
0.0251657385,
0.0410556048,
0.0017407221,
-0.0317342468,
0.0215229783,
0.0211884268,
-0.0281934161,
-0.0533027872,
0.0334354192,
0.021511998,
-0.0518695824,
-0.0019884394,
-0.041172225,
-0.011447221,
0.0306706186,
-0.0528996959,
0.0391219966,
0.0255828705,
-0.0265864935,
0.0554233305,
-0.0115355523,
0.035452798,
-0.0009234481,
0.0328168795,
-0.0007145673,
0.0154649792,
-0.0721064806,
0.0048971111,
-0.0443337522,
0.010245149,
-0.0005752452,
-0.0174779352,
-0.0279827844,
0.0131185502,
-0.0280346237,
0.0392596647,
0.0219098348,
0.0073952368,
-0.0242990591,
0.0047296174,
-0.0212954395,
0.0276155788,
-0.0511751734,
0.0075121815,
0.0203560498,
-0.0703981444,
-0.0184925292,
0.003442785,
-0.0244238172,
0.0032472105,
0.0107670669,
0.0682806373,
-0.0050291424,
-0.0052279863,
-0.0032957292,
-0.0192608088,
-0.003174227,
-0.0573612489,
-0.0255301073,
-0.074568361,
0.0420142412,
-0.0102279661,
-0.0126491785,
-0.0162842274,
0.0287620686,
0.0327156596,
-0.0386850573,
0.0771251768,
-0.0043380223,
0.005074319,
0.0227968954,
-0.0040671732,
-0.0469474904,
0.0498430803,
0.0516005047,
0.0506429039,
0.0324104577,
0.0058324072,
0.063538067,
0.0786609203,
0.0321211815,
0.0222543776,
0.0071100434,
0.0039929436,
0.0026754437,
0.0474167615,
0.0153882988,
0.0592692904,
-0.0385784023,
-0.0012049729,
0.0883743241,
0.0419685505,
-0.0304320864,
0.0076985471,
0.0089256726,
0.0456252098,
0.0347555876,
-0.0288119335,
-0.0736860782,
0.0314128548,
-0.0459236465,
0.0095394766,
0.0297185369,
-0.008322062,
-0.0198229291,
-0.0376419015,
-0.010096143,
0.007361677,
-0.0041356906,
0.0229049437,
0.046491731,
-0.0053410381,
-0.0668463409,
0.0061460948,
0.0275155362,
-0.0511372201,
-0.0324770808,
-0.0787754357,
0.0347723886,
0.076731354,
0.059087757,
-0.0056445957,
-0.0062562712,
-0.0351498872,
-0.0138985049,
0.0219272897,
0.0341124609,
-0.0134014282,
-0.034743987,
-0.0322034173,
-0.0342565477,
0.0414041318,
-0.0066835559,
0.0374539085,
0.0613867268,
-0.0364557579,
-0.0203047041,
-0.0016644332,
-0.0436111167,
0.0291700084,
0.0021049415,
-0.0270921811,
-0.0266870167,
-0.0052667023,
0.02156353,
0.0106807817,
-0.0046809781,
0.0089914566,
0.0161577165,
0.0106871296,
0.0087050982,
-0.0026958503,
-0.0429297797,
-0.0243885312,
0.0463101938,
0.0009577337,
-0.0334229693,
0.0588095561,
-0.0312556922,
0.0008053227,
-0.000308704,
-0.0226287823,
0.0245406199,
-0.0387719423,
0.0151248025,
-0.0144317849,
-0.0085616345,
-0.0311596822,
0.0134512773,
-0.0039956076,
-0.0113447607,
0.0048761684,
0.0211782698,
0.0034639915,
-0.0508368276,
-0.0293554179,
0.0271670837,
-0.0023879369,
0.0495711043,
0.0163113903,
0.0424331836,
-0.052496817,
-0.0442161039,
-0.119355157,
0.00226997,
-0.0300715696,
0.0117583033,
0.0211293381,
-0.0146018555,
-0.0217178743,
-0.049787797,
-0.0225411784,
-0.0289889928,
-0.0228925776,
0.0099496944,
0.021461742,
-0.0041208765,
-0.020167619,
-0.0793973729,
-0.0086966325,
-0.0033573771,
0.0120611526,
-0.0022957192,
-0.0046319468,
-0.0578290485,
0.0145798754,
-0.0065201619,
0.0558787957,
-0.0114275012,
-0.0653096437,
0.0497197583,
-0.0030806698,
0.0280723833,
0.0589079745,
-0.0058034472,
0.018716488,
0.0190550536,
0.0169732478,
-0.0859180242,
0.0189633239,
-0.009868511,
-0.0589131117,
-0.0221081413,
-0.0000667824,
-0.0061088391,
0.0829528347,
0.0055364873,
0.0078626592,
-0.0600427613,
-0.0055535166,
-0.0198965427,
-0.0279039647,
-0.0651161447,
-0.0145540312,
-0.0520373993,
-0.003792326,
-0.037534669,
-0.0650856942,
0.1010987982,
-0.0440759733,
-0.0319730267,
-0.0529808328,
-0.0007803023,
-0.0019406272,
0.0465428047,
-0.0007896619,
-0.0202142447,
-0.0100591024,
-0.0029482921,
-0.0230788086,
0.0024694151,
0.0214854591,
-0.0549078733,
0.001099154,
-0.0601869673,
0.0085623134,
0.0040606963,
-0.0377524309,
-0.0469918847,
-0.0235747937,
-0.0648113936,
0.0123398667,
0.0336013511,
-0.0393904895,
0.0052685225,
0.0180942062,
0.0450920239,
0.0465652086,
-0.033017192,
-0.0153842475,
-0.0318352133,
-0.0007706681,
0.0565960556,
-0.0053020129,
-0.0161936432,
-0.0539368466,
0.0069057848,
0.0517387167,
0.0751610175,
-0.016673848,
-0.0356642269,
0.0008689851,
0.0338887945,
-0.020296419,
0.0196126457,
0.0405052267,
0.0635573119,
-0.0548435152,
0.01366458,
0.1149176136,
0.026742531,
-0.0702168569,
0.0040192441,
-0.0109579368,
0.0536206514,
0.0230430532,
0.0489021651,
-0.0976944119,
-0.0574050359,
0.0231216699,
0.063942425,
0.0178740621,
-0.0287308414,
0.0115890661,
-0.1344902813,
0.0403382555,
0.0004613241,
-0.0364588089,
0.0205611289,
-0.0456559546,
0.0073682917,
-0.0355217867,
0.0059189461,
0.0239227917,
0.0183023419,
0.0035263612,
0.0125821829,
-0.0290070828,
-0.0222265236,
0.0534589961,
-0.0493356958,
0.0735965371,
0.1027717441,
0.0087261535,
0.0201109685,
-0.0527325049,
0.0417805351,
0.0393587686,
-0.001874755,
-0.0116150752,
0.0474815853,
-0.0249406528,
-0.0181163326,
-0.0113515947,
0.0560093895,
-0.0387258679,
0.0176488422,
0.0375983492,
0.04779239,
0.0004588265,
-0.005781298,
-0.0067157862,
0.0002039523,
0.0284872185,
0.0522309877,
0.0301363915,
-0.0684129894,
-0.04134335,
-0.045937039,
-0.030826699,
-0.0471227318,
-0.0585167594,
-0.0320836492,
0.021100644,
0.0008869342,
-0.0680285543,
-0.0460990332,
0.053907197,
0.0201305225,
-0.0042371089,
-0.0439051688,
0.0046336735,
0.0044468609,
0.0045476914,
0.0419820473,
-0.0217781607,
0.0433926508,
-0.0787206888,
-0.0413454473,
0.0279306974,
-0.0129068326,
-0.0113117006,
0.0469454005,
-0.0954749584,
-0.0783609301,
-0.0139206955,
0.1003814042,
0.0221878532,
0.0510326214,
-0.0411591716,
-0.0560676157,
-0.0067152418,
0.0328780562,
-0.0460052341,
-0.0047202073,
0.0329015553,
0.0146626877,
0.001688491,
0.0115825916,
-0.0292972699,
0.0183295552,
-0.0016511789,
0.0367062129,
-0.0182476901,
-0.0446822755,
0.0338432267,
0.0081957821,
0.0543077588,
-0.0328169875,
-0.049170576,
-0.0227550697,
0.0086563984,
0.0024493842,
-0.0201859418,
-0.0685666874,
0.0118730133,
-0.0153176505,
-0.039160993,
0.026834907,
-0.03199514,
-0.0161542967,
0.0229245033,
-0.0112267127,
0.0051975781,
0.0082361754,
0.037149895,
0.033842694,
0.0088070305,
-0.0073442981,
0.0101109026,
0.0078101209,
0.0442807227,
-0.0017756467,
0.078587532,
0.0182465594,
-0.0349794477,
0.0296161361,
0.0454159491,
-0.0388656296,
-0.0503579304,
-0.0377425253,
0.0698648468,
0.0561850481,
0.020990992,
0.0423126742,
-0.0422484726,
0.0028992416,
-0.0079232026,
0.0227773283,
-0.0525602177,
0.0062298789,
-0.0057424982,
0.0445421673,
0.0051445095,
0.0218691826,
0.0699395835,
0.0046183029,
0.0189718977,
-0.0099895867,
0.0027400912,
-0.0434652157,
-0.0087726898,
0.0178429056,
0.0005370399,
-0.0341418684,
0.0110135749,
-0.0210427977,
-0.0452858582,
-0.0567148551,
0.0478841886,
0.0023054187,
-0.0176772494,
0.052288454,
0.0432856753,
-0.0359858982,
0.0136185968,
-0.0417734645,
-0.0082958443,
0.0136772254,
-0.0360696837,
-0.0270897783,
-6.404521544e-33,
-0.0346316174,
-0.050336767,
0.0293573216,
0.0036284805,
-0.0287397578,
-0.0332490951,
-0.0427557603,
0.0309336223,
0.01708032,
0.0087106656,
-0.0163225532,
-0.0014136703,
0.0225198604,
-0.0149168912,
0.0244439933,
-0.0031404882,
0.047793854,
-0.0364477411,
-0.0424186848,
0.0238466766,
-0.0141677717,
0.0152647393,
0.0244106911,
-0.0670445561,
0.0670439303,
-0.0158352591,
-0.0350251049,
0.0181254167,
-0.0270543508,
0.0522666499,
-0.012224148,
0.0216265135,
-0.0114494273,
-0.0401649438,
-0.0170360468,
0.0155750317,
-0.0446372256,
-0.0145641072,
-0.0028051394,
0.0071878056,
-0.059014786,
0.016793672,
0.0444520824,
-0.0137140509,
-0.022990549,
0.0258619525,
0.0254291221,
-0.0158514176,
-0.0260097776,
0.0585198104,
-0.0380824469,
0.0196635164,
-0.0244417619,
-0.0700822324,
0.0146204671,
0.0277887098,
-0.0291780047,
-0.028201567,
-0.0579081513,
0.0303502083,
0.0335623585,
0.0284313541,
0.0659251958,
0.0098698419,
0.0173119009,
0.0494499132,
0.0258694999,
0.0103791934,
0.0002383154,
-0.0409083404,
0.0356813669,
0.0409234129,
0.0675537735,
0.031311322,
0.0071426788,
-0.0078684334,
0.0026523967,
0.0306077804,
0.014433465,
0.0374632403,
0.0251349732,
0.0182516258,
-0.0726200342,
-0.0062659774,
-0.0288957153,
-0.0115140034,
-0.014646777,
-0.036604058,
0.0395206697,
0.0234601758,
-0.0190226976,
-0.0223475955,
0.0229750071,
-0.0325933956,
-0.0125455493,
-0.0082582776,
-0.0137128066,
0.0528272688,
-0.0063754204,
-0.0077573527,
-0.0585016645,
-0.0053697061,
-0.0139094098,
0.0285666902,
0.0307955537,
0.0072068567,
0.0237283744,
0.0199406184,
-0.052782882,
0.0115571897,
-0.037566036,
0.0463227965,
-0.0012512305,
0.0011140491,
0.012263637,
-0.0280865654,
-0.0126206847,
0.0742491111,
-0.0283840504,
-0.0247426331,
-0.0372457132,
0.0069539365,
-0.0052887443,
-0.0155789386,
-0.0385046862,
0.0121840155,
-0.0286876746,
0.0033227808,
0.0099225752,
-0.0091885496,
-0.0181980636,
-0.0164394863,
2.759e-7,
-0.0184436459,
0.060988348,
0.0470699556,
0.0153893325,
0.0014555677,
0.0670290589,
-0.04577896,
0.0315004177,
0.0101230154,
-0.0251326468,
0.0132847195,
0.0528432392,
0.0819924027,
0.009225742,
-0.0980273858,
-0.0301790703,
-0.0812019855,
0.0043878499,
-0.0392268896,
-0.0342669338,
0.0158267412,
0.0576952957,
0.0335993096,
0.0148822544,
0.0193708651,
0.0014539539,
0.0534058996,
-0.0141385086,
-0.0264515541,
0.0126686376,
0.0458573587,
0.0039175712,
-0.0050935592,
0.0044391952,
-0.0036857324,
0.0043498487,
0.0048516644,
0.0711960569,
-0.0311765783,
-0.0182991624,
0.0029946929,
-0.0338922106,
0.021402549,
-0.0562453829,
0.0281291436,
-0.0342474766,
-0.0016659587,
-0.0429245159,
0.0440810062,
-0.0502854735,
0.0225205012,
-0.0387317538,
-0.0143822581,
0.014479273,
0.0018485432,
-0.002350749,
-0.0149445077,
-0.0370486379,
-0.0336371735,
-0.0130340941,
-0.0339089148,
-0.0610385537,
-0.045843821,
-0.0100408774,
-0.0263258666,
-0.0336746313,
0.0055603036,
2.287995521e-34,
0.053879194,
-0.018495243,
0.0319779776,
0.0632909387,
0.0511680581,
0.0113094412,
0.033234112,
0.0188190211,
0.0590992421,
-0.0173898097,
-0.0375725441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18569v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18569v2 | Fairness of ChatGPT | 2023-05-22T17:51:56 | 2024-05-05T19:15:30 | Yunqi Li, Lanjing Zhang, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Understanding and addressing unfairness in LLMs are crucial for responsible
AI deployment. However, there is a limited number of quantitative analyses and
in-depth studies regarding fairness evaluations in LLMs, especially when
applying LLMs to high-stakes fields. This work aims to fill this gap by
providing a systematic evaluation of the effectiveness and fairness of LLMs
using ChatGPT as a study case. We focus on assessing ChatGPT's performance in
high-takes fields including education, criminology, finance and healthcare. To
conduct a thorough evaluation, we consider both group fairness and individual
fairness metrics. We also observe the disparities in ChatGPT's outputs under a
set of biased or unbiased prompts. This work contributes to a deeper
understanding of LLMs' fairness performance, facilitates bias mitigation and
fosters the development of responsible AI systems. | [
0.0383197367,
0.0545719899,
-0.0381485745,
0.0175828524,
-0.0507224388,
0.0123127364,
0.0488683283,
-0.0039632162,
0.0397218503,
-0.0444206558,
-0.0186580382,
0.0588115975,
-0.0134968776,
-0.0169918723,
0.0005963647,
-0.024991909,
0.0289318226,
0.0041096671,
0.0382599756,
-0.0357883312,
0.0291347001,
-0.0234974492,
-0.003776178,
0.0480129384,
-0.0342284255,
0.0042274729,
0.0198597033,
0.0065866881,
0.0280878432,
-0.0168441273,
0.0168431886,
0.0364930481,
-0.028158566,
0.0406094566,
0.0000020029,
-0.067694746,
-0.0213952381,
0.0098655252,
-0.0323726945,
0.0071192668,
0.0169686135,
0.0403451696,
-0.0144403884,
0.0447365232,
-0.0348787978,
0.0742864758,
0.0211129952,
-0.0137115838,
0.0152743263,
0.0111889606,
0.018600028,
0.0389243364,
-0.0029126352,
-0.0092606964,
0.024404129,
-0.0537233427,
-0.0129520027,
-0.0069036437,
-0.0277075041,
-0.0415462367,
-0.0078466134,
0.0130451852,
0.023965843,
-0.0072129178,
0.0111738192,
0.003152584,
-0.0398587249,
-0.0163630769,
-0.0211306456,
0.041910395,
0.0255205091,
0.0272846948,
-0.0042142863,
-0.0297111832,
0.0814156458,
-0.0187156219,
-0.0390389636,
0.0639418662,
-0.0384593047,
0.0085899606,
-0.0008049486,
0.0484871566,
0.0142234378,
0.0432958417,
-0.0079676928,
0.0544225611,
-0.020808937,
-0.0410477966,
0.0160482507,
0.0708638728,
0.0565246083,
-0.0214543212,
0.0159190185,
0.0296725631,
-0.067602843,
-0.0043513277,
0.0193806551,
0.0141107561,
0.0580035597,
-0.0040829191,
0.0192112867,
0.0208795369,
0.0019001387,
0.0100952368,
0.0078512253,
0.0660866573,
0.0068885847,
0.0951599553,
-0.0086596478,
0.0013001875,
-0.0175842959,
0.0176932234,
0.0351433456,
0.0166871976,
-0.023763407,
0.0721651316,
-0.0543526709,
0.0041053537,
-0.0960004404,
0.032309819,
0.0294723064,
0.0237468649,
-0.0094327694,
0.0166749377,
-0.0413522497,
-0.0523110591,
-0.0321706533,
0.0184897389,
-0.0041519515,
-0.0429450907,
-0.0249758884,
0.0174025744,
-0.0495238416,
-0.0051022144,
0.0034677533,
0.1305897832,
0.0346187726,
-0.0316622555,
-0.0275326185,
-0.0396419987,
0.0173165519,
-0.0508143306,
0.0004054206,
-0.0383673459,
-0.0045330739,
-0.0356351733,
-0.0106797377,
-0.01084683,
-0.0171275809,
-0.0085516525,
-0.0202844143,
0.0504104383,
-0.0011307377,
0.0062587392,
0.0183236301,
0.0711227879,
-0.0799069181,
0.0302942228,
0.04067057,
0.048469644,
0.067371279,
0.0059337821,
0.0557787977,
0.0149071421,
-0.0053368742,
0.0275792498,
0.024810819,
0.0408841781,
-0.0361754,
0.040676184,
0.0200852565,
0.0400682837,
-0.0078043486,
0.0081565622,
0.0280873999,
0.0720843747,
0.0042254669,
-0.0059329839,
-0.0286478791,
-0.018470129,
-0.0340400748,
-0.0057835821,
-0.0778549761,
0.025712736,
-0.0142264115,
-0.0210775249,
-0.0150283081,
0.04774867,
-0.035820093,
-0.0379756354,
0.0065671443,
-0.0007891813,
0.014824586,
0.0631346554,
-0.0161702186,
-0.0431375951,
-0.0111298505,
-0.0104365489,
0.0179451462,
-0.0195525587,
-0.0172544457,
-0.1311206818,
0.0384104326,
0.0631635264,
0.025794616,
-0.0376385339,
-0.0146627305,
-0.0315995179,
-0.031016238,
0.0190010425,
0.0417373292,
-0.020387562,
-0.0288109891,
-0.027401628,
-0.0783897936,
0.0150323734,
-0.0126342047,
0.0600678995,
0.0093567511,
0.0317601524,
-0.0236349907,
-0.0355502814,
-0.0255661551,
0.0522833653,
0.0028659634,
-0.0281036403,
-0.0021222681,
-0.0037382753,
0.0386799276,
0.0135471569,
-0.0196580123,
-0.0052266996,
-0.0071940715,
0.0276516583,
-0.0078585166,
-0.0338967778,
-0.0251239128,
0.0377481617,
0.00469387,
-0.0634207875,
-0.0042497208,
0.0262035113,
-0.0323652998,
0.0435329936,
-0.0063499692,
0.0304837171,
-0.0272764023,
-0.0087083504,
0.0155062918,
-0.0534755699,
-0.0206574425,
-0.0664887056,
0.0136899827,
-0.0111064296,
-0.0334359035,
0.0023115831,
-0.0384290144,
0.0092342477,
-0.0275897458,
-0.0118113784,
0.0260220319,
-0.0065440866,
0.0331225097,
0.0350407474,
0.0409371741,
-0.0265694633,
-0.0127640367,
-0.0652721599,
0.00456075,
-0.0051230351,
-0.0099174539,
-0.0388506018,
0.0055333297,
-0.0145694213,
-0.0025845373,
-0.0346126482,
-0.0635942593,
0.048135329,
0.0258608032,
0.0185699966,
-0.0057376008,
-0.0248807762,
-0.0393738598,
-0.0134339631,
-0.0097898198,
0.0118638277,
0.0583072491,
0.0103769898,
-0.0310920849,
0.0011717705,
-0.0377237387,
-0.0093867807,
-0.0058754641,
-0.0115041323,
0.0365792736,
0.044484973,
-0.0582745448,
0.0868022293,
0.0365547463,
0.0668793768,
0.0733504146,
0.0182456095,
-0.05713287,
-0.0111236526,
0.0372916162,
-0.0258254632,
0.0151547864,
-0.0371757485,
-0.0152337113,
0.0193607528,
0.0215289313,
-0.0056889937,
-0.026814118,
0.0598965287,
-0.0391437523,
-0.0681091398,
-0.0539047383,
-0.0365049206,
-0.0279516969,
0.0436231531,
-0.0059069563,
-0.08375974,
0.0392427966,
0.006204519,
0.0582766831,
-0.0404536501,
-0.0274347216,
-0.0447422601,
0.0264429525,
-0.0416514687,
-0.004189596,
-0.042491287,
-0.0285972636,
-0.0531969555,
-0.029016573,
0.0804233998,
-0.0603984073,
0.0223917793,
-0.0213688482,
-0.0270757135,
-0.0579523072,
-0.0586973131,
-0.0542141944,
-0.0618695244,
0.0163194444,
0.0149576552,
0.0269413795,
-0.0145792197,
-0.0232719164,
-0.0301889349,
0.0335105434,
0.0024976288,
-0.0250124335,
-0.0286841802,
0.0062807933,
-0.0638305321,
-0.0090180365,
0.014847599,
0.0785207972,
-0.0237188898,
0.0171633251,
0.0418201387,
0.0443414338,
0.0039210301,
0.0267004929,
0.014318374,
0.0254573692,
-0.0286786649,
0.0242716074,
0.0292098038,
0.0318505652,
0.0009394722,
0.0238734353,
0.0745599195,
-0.0014695675,
-0.053247612,
0.0187379643,
-0.0213117395,
0.0090552494,
0.0241977386,
-0.0230313335,
-0.1157981977,
-0.0095649445,
0.0253503043,
0.0860962719,
-0.0889593437,
-0.0724999085,
0.0236587413,
-0.0649523288,
0.0572444946,
-0.0048800227,
0.0040878258,
-0.0410428308,
0.0027713852,
-0.0093196472,
-0.0508773476,
0.0459769629,
-0.01299119,
0.0263100658,
0.0068309684,
0.031528715,
-0.0309596825,
0.0432546027,
0.0610257313,
-0.0727738068,
0.043691311,
0.0654155761,
-0.0021595543,
-0.0332254283,
-0.0102323899,
-0.0071484959,
0.0284509193,
-0.0167502891,
0.0221084394,
0.0357105397,
-0.0282739382,
0.020056678,
-0.0669113845,
-0.0017697387,
0.0161292162,
0.0288045295,
0.0755300671,
0.0513178147,
-0.0301719885,
-0.0214570574,
-0.0611760728,
-0.0243910681,
0.0029791072,
0.0667889193,
0.008198794,
-0.0165273268,
-0.0037794977,
-0.0456639193,
-0.0201175474,
-0.0080334945,
-0.0266598016,
0.022858033,
-0.016032774,
0.0150943194,
-0.0122682378,
-0.0604859032,
-0.0109431297,
-0.0039176671,
-0.002678321,
-0.0670671985,
-0.0365901664,
0.0124220829,
-0.0045778505,
0.0106127504,
-0.0154893175,
0.0285309404,
-0.001749384,
0.0077633057,
-0.0627237633,
-0.0025706582,
0.0033740769,
0.0036020237,
0.0163448937,
-0.0180198308,
0.0318597853,
0.0415576175,
0.0310157388,
-0.0035429834,
-0.0019054012,
0.031809248,
0.0736998245,
0.0722059533,
0.0185077079,
0.0253434312,
0.0640726462,
-0.000049514,
-0.0090063279,
-0.0263267737,
-0.0493509658,
0.0040779077,
0.0339648612,
0.0050378549,
-0.011664087,
-0.0348525085,
0.0073571894,
0.0372200236,
0.0405648835,
-0.0394745283,
-0.0424815491,
-0.0006161111,
-0.0151261333,
0.0029733507,
-0.0205002781,
-0.004704494,
-0.0329188034,
0.0234307759,
0.0159292538,
-0.0248581171,
0.0102715874,
-0.0274703596,
-0.0170859396,
-0.0531134568,
0.0747682005,
-0.0259263813,
0.0458699726,
-0.0128114577,
-0.0175610185,
-0.0211875197,
0.0165953487,
0.0198611673,
0.0286937077,
0.0310905706,
0.0277967304,
0.0073312628,
0.0594562329,
0.0027512996,
0.0464006327,
-0.0559175946,
-0.0633920133,
0.010917468,
0.0578956418,
0.0211054068,
0.0602476783,
-0.0368809253,
0.0126801152,
0.0158712529,
0.0284178406,
-0.0057049631,
-0.0062484853,
0.0250317995,
0.0206199046,
0.0028249584,
-0.0151932454,
-0.0249038655,
0.0333240256,
-0.0332607403,
0.0602232665,
-0.0839857534,
-0.0133612212,
0.0116564613,
-0.0681320429,
0.0314907618,
-0.0260376818,
0.0198249593,
-0.0797471777,
-0.0766912624,
-0.0179614741,
-0.0433145724,
0.0362962075,
0.0252006818,
-0.0287310723,
-0.0367515646,
0.0465180501,
0.0150373122,
-0.0215440933,
-0.0007131197,
-0.0275140814,
-0.0382106975,
-0.030800296,
-0.0012142238,
-5.384642441e-33,
-0.0108926678,
-0.0563990027,
0.0151333734,
0.0232343338,
-0.0248132646,
-0.0247656833,
0.0294938274,
0.0148873571,
-0.0559384935,
-0.0010661955,
-0.0205517467,
0.007404231,
-0.0064168312,
-0.0227224473,
0.0532803535,
-0.0653444007,
-0.026236305,
-0.0053968099,
-0.0227851644,
0.0228174422,
-0.0677491501,
-0.0073788827,
0.0212251246,
-0.0581880212,
0.0755392537,
0.007471439,
-0.0048299939,
0.029478576,
-0.07653182,
0.0555272959,
0.036171291,
0.0880376697,
0.0378426015,
-0.0309086014,
0.0113413557,
0.0335916243,
-0.0059270766,
-0.0190903526,
0.0086039947,
-0.0280978009,
0.0127098439,
-0.0311700162,
0.028016353,
0.0246443208,
-0.0912331492,
-0.0347204916,
0.0346078053,
0.0011125935,
0.0279396959,
-0.0117418384,
-0.0178818367,
0.0233701244,
-0.0603001751,
0.0117263896,
-0.0347986147,
-0.0045721997,
0.012015488,
0.0447224416,
-0.019678684,
0.0056017432,
-0.0178868156,
-0.0628513396,
0.0459805392,
-0.0088789351,
-0.0310874842,
0.0553303994,
0.038939856,
0.0456026047,
-0.0409703553,
-0.0874844342,
0.0077226427,
0.0216164924,
0.0591860041,
0.0533870868,
-0.0014451824,
-0.0224913582,
-0.077772148,
0.0402527563,
0.0494409055,
0.0278371219,
-0.0101119056,
-0.0281682033,
-0.1122210771,
-0.013898599,
0.0001725597,
-0.0576882586,
-0.0098052705,
0.0007632297,
0.0547422096,
-0.0163918864,
0.006931114,
-0.0139805209,
0.016350491,
-0.0335025974,
0.0402218737,
0.0109115513,
0.0205591302,
-0.0177626573,
-0.0196161438,
-0.0071452968,
-0.0662466958,
-0.018559698,
-0.0016587568,
0.0201502368,
0.0565145239,
0.0081951031,
0.0108177653,
-0.012689935,
-0.0213683601,
0.0064097587,
-0.001490847,
0.0514340252,
0.0085560083,
-0.0396621302,
-0.0108255465,
-0.0071724262,
0.0167437401,
-0.0159705784,
-0.0115729272,
-0.0075590382,
-0.0550671592,
0.008772959,
-0.0239065792,
-0.0089295721,
-0.0285098068,
0.0042651622,
0.0225100014,
0.0176798441,
0.0166808218,
-0.0400016606,
-0.0223602448,
-0.0459433161,
2.602e-7,
0.0012877631,
0.0107503803,
-0.0132388556,
0.017781714,
-0.0322801955,
0.062154036,
0.0044777459,
0.061651513,
0.0294385422,
0.0062272628,
0.0435934477,
0.0306177642,
0.0154175432,
0.0240980759,
-0.0077471011,
-0.0634903312,
-0.0587494336,
-0.001067088,
-0.0374691822,
0.0468198657,
0.0489678048,
-0.0007077019,
0.0298718475,
-0.024340732,
0.016350532,
-0.0128855612,
-0.0228088424,
-0.0420357548,
0.0187444445,
0.0003700914,
0.0579403341,
-0.0129223624,
0.0312215611,
0.0608726367,
0.0301388707,
-0.0076378351,
-0.0309971087,
0.0472342446,
-0.0038361745,
-0.0078581637,
-0.0176258795,
-0.0431016833,
0.038261272,
-0.0278015118,
0.0438848659,
0.0541592948,
-0.0203403812,
-0.0714129508,
0.0042752791,
-0.0678878501,
0.0622927137,
0.0207274165,
-0.0013084572,
-0.000786751,
0.0131555246,
0.0210433267,
0.0109036341,
-0.0373271964,
0.0102920299,
-0.0213888101,
-0.0076638656,
-0.0886763036,
0.0442873202,
0.0307054054,
0.0055750897,
-0.0090109902,
0.02389073,
2.25561157e-34,
-0.0212248508,
-0.0131620541,
0.0376155153,
-0.0065497379,
0.0478333011,
0.0731279626,
-0.0078753298,
-0.0360078067,
0.0162530933,
0.0227780733,
-0.0147715816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13286v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13286v2 | How do languages influence each other? Studying cross-lingual data sharing during LM fine-tuning | 2023-05-22T17:47:41 | 2024-05-21T11:47:13 | Rochelle Choenni, Dan Garrette, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual large language models (MLLMs) are jointly trained on data from
many different languages such that representation of individual languages can
benefit from other languages' data. Impressive performance on zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer shows that these models are capable of exploiting data
from other languages. Yet, it remains unclear to what extent, and under which
conditions, languages rely on each other's data. In this study, we use TracIn
(Pruthi et al., 2020), a training data attribution (TDA) method, to retrieve
the most influential training samples seen during multilingual fine-tuning for
a particular test language. This allows us to analyse cross-lingual sharing
mechanisms of MLLMs from a new perspective. While previous work studied
cross-lingual sharing at the level of model parameters, we present the first
approach to study cross-lingual sharing at the data level. We find that MLLMs
rely on data from multiple languages from the early stages of fine-tuning and
that this reliance gradually increases as fine-tuning progresses. We further
study how different fine-tuning languages influence model performance on a
given test language and find that they can both reinforce and complement the
knowledge acquired from data of the test language itself. | [
-0.0027714167,
0.0332173929,
-0.0557204559,
0.099011071,
-0.0333808325,
0.0335339569,
0.0394615829,
-0.0039634393,
-0.0531488508,
-0.0161147453,
-0.0935461149,
-0.0371175408,
0.0254191179,
-0.0197217707,
0.0416351445,
-0.0156122111,
0.0141950436,
-0.0534784682,
-0.0366489142,
-0.039318651,
-0.0070996508,
-0.0043209321,
0.0504724123,
0.001707391,
0.01936833,
0.0227800496,
0.0251107085,
-0.0054122382,
0.0234634932,
0.0200542342,
-0.023868436,
0.0379096083,
0.0047922009,
0.0446227118,
0.0000019546,
-0.0485514998,
0.0010351056,
0.0003961796,
-0.0099887811,
0.0206543393,
0.0178754069,
-0.0455041938,
0.0062935939,
-0.0260833632,
-0.0141491359,
-0.0246954858,
0.0708886683,
0.0002294287,
-0.0015616324,
0.069659099,
-0.0017563812,
-0.037201602,
-0.0116951857,
-0.0511987805,
0.0295591671,
-0.0286997966,
0.0273935199,
0.0187433511,
-0.0523148514,
-0.0138000585,
-0.0522231124,
0.0349325873,
0.0217761546,
0.0282662846,
-0.052703809,
0.0221916735,
-0.0110570611,
-0.0231831074,
0.0174487382,
0.0591991469,
-0.0367265046,
-0.028649129,
-0.0104318652,
-0.0169386826,
0.0040637269,
0.0179860573,
-0.0351923183,
0.0409559645,
0.0241173487,
0.025289882,
0.0472856611,
-0.0235977806,
0.0584451444,
-0.002424299,
-0.0507075824,
0.0394724272,
0.0090172049,
-0.0167476386,
0.0178497378,
0.0322162844,
0.0085931793,
-0.0456951521,
-0.0318869092,
-0.0241412912,
0.0117519973,
0.0054778233,
-0.0210605916,
-0.0250002854,
0.0215472225,
-0.0055249687,
0.0571250692,
0.0092343548,
-0.04779502,
0.0304537155,
-0.031979125,
0.0259977672,
-0.0020448305,
0.0420383252,
-0.0530004017,
-0.052738905,
-0.0344649963,
0.0179529451,
0.0143062435,
-0.0041635614,
-0.0117303729,
0.0272052065,
-0.0345450118,
0.0111857941,
-0.0238512792,
-0.0093874978,
-0.0112385266,
-0.0465621352,
-0.0405322425,
0.0201140214,
0.0351685248,
0.0585290454,
-0.0519541688,
0.0197629239,
-0.0005063837,
-0.0748082399,
-0.0106184464,
0.0182506535,
-0.013838972,
-0.0649660006,
0.0477107428,
0.0770868063,
0.0087830164,
-0.0174344108,
-0.0183503106,
-0.0210949071,
0.0024820347,
-0.100088574,
0.0294912104,
-0.0478591174,
0.0395302996,
0.0447493941,
0.0374871269,
-0.0351903439,
-0.0354762413,
-0.0329991989,
-0.0601726212,
0.0639638975,
0.0025026191,
0.011839659,
-0.0101740398,
-0.0255555362,
-0.0031026339,
0.1076593846,
0.0309554562,
-0.0013709139,
0.0330527388,
-0.0385926403,
-0.0221304148,
0.0622897781,
0.0245456137,
0.0472554564,
-0.0358345956,
-0.0000165945,
0.0339044742,
-0.0072045,
0.0306307264,
-0.0116466479,
-0.0364452787,
0.0148010962,
0.0511013009,
0.0163808763,
0.0409707315,
0.0249968488,
0.0292866863,
-0.0582782589,
-0.0074421563,
0.0437036902,
-0.0457372479,
0.0290256422,
0.0132666491,
-0.003879237,
-0.0074449303,
0.0720035583,
-0.0313000269,
-0.003367028,
-0.0005378498,
-0.0182739571,
-0.0005985806,
0.0201606732,
0.0543868355,
0.0147808772,
0.0212877244,
0.0516824462,
0.0644944236,
-0.0287075602,
0.0159578081,
-0.0241508577,
-0.0005718167,
0.0133054713,
-0.0321488082,
0.003611974,
-0.0049299528,
-0.0163423028,
0.0500617959,
0.0022122294,
0.0652459487,
-0.0015335181,
0.0390682556,
-0.0381208807,
-0.0113180233,
-0.0404455476,
0.0054489393,
0.0756790042,
-0.0451690406,
0.0463578925,
0.0041668927,
-0.0223114174,
-0.0572341532,
0.0092261583,
-0.0571807139,
0.0018137454,
0.0081371125,
0.0135867056,
0.0164323561,
-0.0074754427,
-0.0471968502,
-0.0202750117,
-0.0019073037,
-0.0277931299,
0.0207113605,
0.0416260026,
-0.0164917242,
0.0012250125,
0.0223083384,
-0.0213408675,
0.0018000588,
0.0085473675,
-0.020113105,
-0.0373235717,
0.0383939818,
0.0308415648,
0.0287221558,
-0.0300044734,
0.0092228446,
-0.0541257001,
0.0309121013,
-0.01594452,
0.0244831983,
0.0127522796,
0.0310129169,
0.0103770904,
-0.0010422313,
0.0325967371,
-0.0163202733,
-0.0184916258,
0.068643108,
0.0071791802,
0.0141200218,
0.0131685371,
0.0199267771,
-0.0074106911,
-0.0024854664,
-0.0560981147,
-0.0018958298,
-0.0382648297,
0.0243807305,
0.0236612465,
0.0027483485,
-0.0118774623,
-0.0085403873,
-0.0463744849,
-0.0045865225,
0.0119552733,
0.0520445891,
-0.0010110026,
0.0299159437,
0.001840369,
-0.0236296039,
-0.0263197348,
0.0299870092,
0.0763065666,
0.0013665842,
-0.0033439561,
-0.0721624196,
-0.0074001537,
-0.0531782284,
0.0081773996,
-0.0209380258,
-0.0510828122,
-0.0063055409,
0.0003268069,
-0.0091180159,
0.0780703351,
-0.0509844348,
-0.009076654,
0.0774866566,
-0.018504383,
-0.0473258831,
-0.0078187697,
0.0175020173,
-0.0338618197,
-0.0709726214,
-0.0348056257,
-0.0217772331,
0.0683103949,
-0.0227370579,
-0.0356882326,
-0.04975776,
0.0181517303,
-0.0229685754,
-0.0343746617,
-0.0054559154,
0.0260263458,
0.0007224904,
0.0593024492,
-0.0172417648,
-0.0795593485,
0.0458474793,
-0.0255090035,
-0.0133667821,
-0.0129887396,
0.0005930852,
-0.046835985,
0.0279200096,
-0.0071411454,
0.0320315249,
-0.0100805834,
0.0081719784,
-0.0479592793,
-0.0022067262,
0.0680229738,
0.0010171883,
0.0303881038,
-0.0156439636,
-0.0138765909,
-0.0147853419,
-0.0503957085,
0.0184237696,
0.0119786458,
-0.0323928595,
0.0151194101,
0.0071687791,
-0.020092709,
-0.004370857,
-0.043152336,
0.0473697223,
-0.0035718677,
-0.0202604774,
0.0240274221,
-0.0035285803,
-0.0379907228,
0.0298631154,
0.004096149,
0.0227595903,
-0.0676733479,
0.0077436147,
-0.018168563,
0.0340237953,
0.0348888412,
0.0016188063,
0.0241613053,
0.0331091285,
0.0172135998,
-0.0339661837,
-0.0122941276,
0.0539791547,
-0.035613969,
0.0157402977,
0.0554117747,
-0.0193792637,
-0.0448413901,
-0.0022896207,
-0.0367951356,
0.0096728029,
0.0320782438,
0.034212172,
-0.0914703161,
-0.0285584312,
0.0069258469,
-0.0026966264,
0.0096447244,
-0.0086128116,
0.0068890667,
-0.1255505532,
-0.0021223039,
0.0161928702,
-0.0829120204,
-0.0325864814,
-0.0205366984,
-0.0018652231,
-0.0400122851,
0.0455249064,
-0.0353004187,
-0.0066390513,
-0.0213996898,
0.0028880797,
0.0513108894,
-0.0800267756,
0.0225351527,
-0.0572041385,
0.036896687,
0.0420664437,
0.0375154838,
-0.0371719673,
-0.0023269008,
0.0310937669,
-0.0229811352,
0.0057492978,
-0.0259724334,
0.0390851423,
0.0278545171,
-0.0411622599,
0.0518151633,
0.023294257,
0.0055568065,
0.0100832237,
0.0073232781,
0.0581384487,
0.0160702374,
-0.0388718657,
0.0574266464,
-0.0388757512,
0.0030568959,
0.051923342,
0.0492729917,
-0.0370569155,
-0.0005525068,
-0.0180282556,
-0.0431918502,
-0.0031696523,
-0.0359525047,
0.0249390155,
-0.0447073244,
-0.0366203338,
-0.0277977623,
-0.0535158478,
0.0287950467,
0.0084632998,
0.0431157798,
0.0251120292,
-0.0503560007,
-0.0279557481,
0.0119000403,
0.0497201569,
-0.0475726984,
0.0108407866,
-0.0384094715,
-0.0315213874,
0.0327571966,
-0.0514591523,
0.018007366,
-0.0019219846,
-0.0731550828,
-0.0815576538,
0.000742397,
0.0522737876,
0.0182109997,
0.0660848469,
0.0332018286,
-0.0897017866,
0.0257035084,
0.0137140863,
-0.0266158357,
0.0335426703,
0.055917196,
-0.0335275494,
-0.0044260961,
0.0650620908,
-0.0484525524,
-0.0038666171,
0.0683597028,
-0.019601224,
-0.0084629618,
0.0012519505,
-0.0139811914,
0.0211347267,
0.0361924097,
-0.031845741,
-0.0619206913,
-0.0364064798,
0.0385209471,
-0.0145652052,
-0.016951913,
-0.0231319927,
-0.035236042,
0.0142245023,
0.024551332,
0.007688941,
0.0032258909,
0.0255973041,
0.0116425473,
-0.0708755031,
0.0339050964,
0.0195882879,
0.0171764549,
0.0404147543,
0.0481635556,
0.0290128868,
0.0378573909,
0.0254634749,
0.0398975685,
-0.0218509622,
0.0315032192,
0.0252238605,
0.0086734286,
-0.0194664989,
0.0155318761,
-0.0484159552,
-0.0791374147,
0.0149781508,
-0.0259171277,
0.0836578682,
-0.0496162847,
0.089967601,
-0.0132136419,
-0.0150600988,
-0.0258659665,
0.0304070916,
-0.0258937199,
-0.0067227809,
-0.0008539145,
-0.0067256321,
-0.0338046849,
0.0125212939,
0.0956224576,
0.0134389931,
0.0529482812,
-0.0446418934,
0.0129740806,
0.0194742754,
0.010294307,
0.0394482352,
-0.0068125757,
-0.0096294526,
-0.0075969212,
-0.0357177667,
-0.0914280936,
0.0033141549,
-0.0231616236,
0.0024677236,
0.0154906968,
-0.0181393027,
0.063417092,
-0.0228476766,
0.0182284471,
-0.0402547307,
-0.015663106,
0.0481561571,
0.0077927955,
0.030050328,
-6.345103243e-33,
0.0041121775,
0.0343162641,
-0.0162271056,
0.0377828777,
0.0138544645,
0.0116445981,
-0.0170953944,
0.0068316231,
-0.0379369259,
0.0032729567,
-0.0094989939,
-0.0200534035,
0.022163922,
-0.0050307605,
0.0431973785,
-0.0336212739,
0.0223069768,
-0.0076628346,
-0.01791141,
0.0287331957,
0.0367181748,
0.0343476646,
0.1141804606,
-0.0338185243,
0.0452256352,
-0.0122406296,
0.0019687179,
0.0033315856,
-0.0407932326,
0.0549482703,
0.007976409,
0.0420121625,
0.0342778005,
-0.0609322488,
-0.0341754779,
-0.0299551561,
-0.0562134609,
-0.0526392795,
0.0473776385,
0.0241753161,
0.000585494,
-0.0394259989,
0.0491379984,
-0.026236346,
-0.0025898449,
-0.0418272279,
0.0140099265,
-0.0331361815,
-0.0098187225,
-0.0085747791,
-0.0629904121,
-0.0000626643,
0.0016056827,
0.0079265609,
0.0907295346,
0.0224421378,
0.0074154604,
0.0220097993,
-0.030452529,
0.0292993691,
0.0163793471,
0.0437078178,
0.0895962715,
0.036611557,
0.0164096933,
0.041029077,
0.0588902235,
0.0269287135,
0.0466934219,
-0.0049493033,
0.0679028407,
0.01971131,
0.0290161986,
0.0886874273,
0.023445785,
-0.0230822619,
-0.0933700874,
-0.0102694761,
0.0181415547,
-0.0052280859,
-0.0093811788,
0.003122929,
0.0026133962,
-0.0475507453,
-0.0805366188,
-0.0428857394,
-0.0416162796,
-0.0200654119,
0.0131055545,
-0.0081207696,
-0.0180397537,
0.015213497,
0.0749047548,
-0.0449541323,
-0.067974329,
0.0010481837,
-0.0091459015,
0.0084786741,
0.0092206784,
0.0049578715,
-0.0535449535,
-0.0586340018,
-0.0267280396,
-0.0176696833,
0.0396665484,
0.0200095177,
0.098129347,
0.0085499957,
-0.032372389,
0.0100383302,
-0.0394719206,
-0.0092313141,
0.039012976,
0.0330045596,
0.0222588591,
0.0271998327,
-0.008986583,
0.027908301,
0.0707210302,
-0.0174671784,
-0.0527327247,
-0.015343124,
-0.0149264876,
0.0159639157,
-0.0271964949,
-0.0125758518,
-0.040349029,
-0.0090723522,
0.0720299482,
-0.005291922,
-0.0270391293,
-0.0096281702,
2.66e-7,
0.0293769501,
0.0162397493,
-0.0267636348,
0.0039422684,
0.009886737,
0.0274006147,
-0.0623154715,
0.0247309189,
0.0440465137,
-0.0255453866,
-0.0327640958,
0.042759113,
0.0561300777,
0.0403257534,
-0.0529851951,
0.0192249175,
-0.0271895751,
0.004897845,
-0.0358369984,
-0.014258394,
-0.0689921379,
0.0805300772,
0.0128026791,
-0.0118362196,
0.0083337063,
-0.0231378935,
0.051972717,
-0.1020986289,
-0.0161455441,
0.034188956,
0.0054525496,
0.0103560043,
-0.0213460531,
0.0359102339,
-0.0259559862,
0.0289550219,
-0.0180356726,
0.024791548,
0.025690563,
0.0117464969,
0.0007832891,
-0.0243387818,
-0.0420248955,
-0.0639888421,
0.0569212213,
-0.0392762534,
-0.0426875539,
-0.0252114534,
0.0467143133,
-0.0199183393,
0.0699059665,
-0.0539880916,
0.0137478393,
0.0487252362,
0.0148962559,
0.019626813,
-0.0322342329,
-0.0328943767,
-0.0357951894,
0.0073608914,
-0.0288696475,
-0.0499614105,
-0.0252046306,
-0.0669744089,
0.0092450464,
-0.0468067601,
0.0251016133,
2.126085638e-34,
0.0105175301,
-0.0157063752,
0.038178999,
-0.0017883547,
0.0320686512,
-0.0427821055,
-0.0010547364,
0.034619391,
-0.0320020653,
-0.040603254,
0.0009287209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13282v1 | Is Fine-tuning Needed? Pre-trained Language Models Are Near Perfect for Out-of-Domain Detection | 2023-05-22T17:42:44 | 2023-05-22T17:42:44 | Rheeya Uppaal, Junjie Hu, Yixuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is a critical task for reliable
predictions over text. Fine-tuning with pre-trained language models has been a
de facto procedure to derive OOD detectors with respect to in-distribution (ID)
data. Despite its common use, the understanding of the role of fine-tuning and
its necessity for OOD detection is largely unexplored. In this paper, we raise
the question: is fine-tuning necessary for OOD detection? We present a study
investigating the efficacy of directly leveraging pre-trained language models
for OOD detection, without any model fine-tuning on the ID data. We compare the
approach with several competitive fine-tuning objectives, and offer new
insights under various types of distributional shifts. Extensive evaluations on
8 diverse ID-OOD dataset pairs demonstrate near-perfect OOD detection
performance (with 0% FPR95 in many cases), strongly outperforming its
fine-tuned counterparts. We show that using distance-based detection methods,
pre-trained language models are near-perfect OOD detectors when the
distribution shift involves a domain change. Furthermore, we study the effect
of fine-tuning on OOD detection and identify how to balance ID accuracy with
OOD detection performance. Our code is publically available at
https://github.com/Uppaal/lm-ood. | [
0.0207912177,
0.0703434423,
0.0216978658,
0.0579897054,
-0.0067555085,
0.0199748166,
-0.0232350118,
0.0484619178,
-0.0526422001,
-0.0545897856,
-0.0350464284,
-0.0432878695,
0.0182992239,
0.0355419815,
0.0108431438,
-0.0107285744,
0.0189677905,
-0.0142588438,
0.0001133146,
0.0229948089,
0.0112983435,
-0.0048231347,
-0.0051374119,
0.0249876194,
0.0209519602,
-0.0289654732,
0.0233284961,
0.0419443175,
0.0055007846,
-0.0046386872,
0.045611538,
0.0325562805,
0.01408868,
0.0483003259,
0.0000020258,
-0.039322298,
-0.028950423,
0.0041497815,
0.0038510368,
0.0266765933,
0.0474930927,
-0.045022361,
-0.0388352759,
0.0374233872,
-0.0272002779,
-0.0196206141,
0.0604758672,
0.0439772308,
-0.0138217863,
0.1090405583,
-0.0299168173,
0.0217973776,
0.0200472735,
-0.0319070779,
-0.0475993045,
-0.0210233256,
0.0457044728,
-0.0246041771,
-0.0444460027,
-0.0096903993,
-0.0268768668,
0.0036629669,
-0.0183867849,
0.0242575891,
-0.0386603624,
0.0198447481,
-0.0243223049,
0.0121026328,
-0.0284217428,
0.0620663352,
-0.0825566053,
-0.0325567164,
0.0099729914,
-0.0330680273,
0.007536924,
0.0336758047,
0.0135079017,
0.01731411,
0.0024457001,
0.0321202464,
-0.0270082187,
0.0306229591,
0.0246276539,
0.0124328658,
-0.054456871,
0.0419441685,
0.0037675339,
-0.0258407723,
-0.00571782,
0.0151893981,
-0.0784927532,
-0.0380562842,
0.023915261,
-0.012287776,
0.0458453968,
0.0044783573,
-0.0949254036,
-0.0322512053,
0.0059967483,
-0.0523441806,
0.0710909367,
0.0119802961,
-0.0564906113,
-0.0010640334,
-0.0170100257,
0.0378042534,
-0.0241929553,
0.0554734245,
-0.0250171013,
0.0166603047,
-0.0084702382,
0.0101057086,
-0.0265344176,
-0.0101233646,
-0.0281023495,
-0.0418595076,
-0.0074544456,
0.0235722698,
0.0210736133,
-0.0452515446,
-0.0168519542,
0.0080417255,
-0.0129367979,
-0.0125728427,
0.0163542051,
0.0340458043,
0.0086298948,
0.0202904101,
-0.0263354797,
-0.0666816309,
-0.038646508,
0.0664827377,
0.0022161568,
-0.0049015745,
-0.0031509553,
0.0701625422,
0.0168083943,
-0.0560922027,
-0.018857263,
-0.0076566269,
-0.0387107469,
-0.0263010338,
0.0231146347,
-0.058910802,
-0.0533960573,
0.0136911031,
0.0126658194,
-0.0675599203,
0.0214634445,
0.0210458189,
-0.0288272593,
0.0187221747,
-0.043528121,
0.016798215,
-0.0276767556,
-0.0231053364,
0.0374981426,
0.0980998948,
0.0112332171,
-0.0010583034,
0.0543252379,
0.0087522855,
0.0464539751,
0.0755341947,
0.0129394531,
0.0697454289,
-0.0043926053,
-0.010510454,
0.0001639234,
-0.0206933543,
0.0750411451,
-0.0182389487,
0.0060598953,
-0.0291304197,
0.0759256631,
0.0169489086,
0.0373090766,
-0.0336853117,
-0.0008422578,
0.0443958826,
-0.0477240384,
0.0273446552,
-0.0469353981,
-0.0430168957,
-0.0234683398,
-0.0062663965,
0.0048967437,
0.0308724623,
-0.0025350088,
-0.017753927,
-0.0201542955,
-0.017489003,
-0.02076637,
0.0076179905,
0.0598091148,
0.0353074484,
-0.028670907,
0.0707900301,
0.0319738835,
-0.0053931568,
-0.0185915809,
-0.0416883938,
-0.0296989586,
-0.0116229886,
0.0380813852,
-0.0391479991,
0.0256069675,
-0.0057193022,
0.0323970579,
0.0592741296,
0.0164227057,
0.0343814604,
0.0225827899,
-0.0468605831,
-0.0519349985,
0.0047248644,
0.0586086996,
-0.0106993318,
0.0376725495,
0.0275722202,
0.0403122008,
-0.0922538787,
-0.0165868495,
0.0461604074,
0.0053630015,
-0.003867304,
-0.0021916355,
0.0265417397,
0.0001389691,
-0.0047501829,
-0.0196679849,
0.0028778031,
0.0039852774,
-0.0026263383,
-0.0064090379,
-0.0228574239,
-0.021809306,
-0.0164340362,
0.0285879951,
-0.0054433905,
0.0274231397,
0.0281431749,
-0.0335473493,
0.0096395425,
0.0161791164,
-0.0391278304,
0.0336519964,
-0.0412917882,
0.0403612219,
-0.0391209535,
0.060117662,
-0.019342564,
0.0640554279,
-0.0104736648,
-0.0066505582,
-0.0026367083,
0.0246598851,
0.0512175821,
0.0033853685,
0.00176268,
-0.0068003153,
-0.0580295809,
0.0222705081,
0.0099037616,
0.0084427483,
-0.0141226985,
0.0091493959,
-0.0338052288,
0.0038041293,
-0.0607190132,
0.0205887612,
0.0680825785,
0.0276919194,
-0.0440099388,
-0.0232452638,
0.0017155254,
-0.0278819911,
0.0123928096,
0.0098121939,
0.025192406,
-0.0294253267,
-0.0057838857,
-0.0011222576,
0.0045942464,
-0.0165588483,
0.0702923536,
-0.0129650841,
-0.0507009439,
-0.0841895044,
0.0811498463,
-0.025206862,
0.0530893654,
-0.0017079292,
-0.0481621101,
-0.038717825,
0.0000429817,
0.0202709716,
0.0414785855,
0.0070115896,
-0.0047955071,
0.0508061312,
0.0032473733,
-0.0347715542,
-0.0311644953,
-0.02487625,
-0.0211349204,
-0.0098366803,
0.0196962748,
0.049527023,
0.0505287759,
0.0033292994,
-0.0059756413,
-0.0042235483,
-0.0201990623,
-0.0311054252,
0.0010060428,
0.0112051833,
0.0058324547,
-0.0211402867,
0.0585097149,
-0.00563257,
-0.0559330769,
0.0525489077,
-0.0340180434,
0.0183006749,
-0.0770802647,
-0.0290930085,
-0.0397612974,
-0.0185953006,
-0.0129889213,
0.0103992149,
0.0481413491,
-0.0503255203,
-0.0398217253,
-0.0135827884,
-0.0217567496,
-0.0085106194,
0.0636294782,
-0.0054892544,
0.0149551257,
-0.007963947,
-0.0322819464,
-0.0371952988,
-0.1080058888,
-0.0007721171,
-0.0217284616,
-0.0237809382,
-0.0407755338,
-0.0292480681,
0.0474773534,
-0.04207002,
0.0581000596,
-0.0383664258,
0.0129268849,
-0.0172480401,
0.0673678294,
0.0443546958,
-0.0441683307,
0.0199614055,
-0.0407598987,
-0.040162921,
0.0271997638,
-0.00576552,
-0.0022029046,
-0.0086536882,
-0.0006123351,
0.0515577868,
-0.0000352968,
-0.0335386209,
0.0345462672,
0.0588434786,
-0.0319458134,
-0.0429718532,
0.0943184793,
0.0079226634,
-0.0523410626,
-0.0122078806,
0.0003801233,
0.0396426246,
0.0112432409,
-0.024820758,
-0.0939313099,
-0.0622218698,
0.009691027,
0.0102734957,
-0.0074028666,
0.0054875072,
0.0007138417,
-0.1099635214,
0.0119502097,
0.0221925583,
-0.0375404544,
-0.0568581149,
-0.0093980059,
0.0393818803,
0.0122921048,
-0.0085818935,
-0.0328097381,
-0.0361884311,
-0.0087669408,
0.0136755705,
-0.0060748165,
-0.0850876272,
0.0116016436,
-0.0555816777,
-0.013250147,
0.1063716486,
0.0267040227,
-0.013719338,
-0.0221231859,
0.0464592874,
-0.0702352673,
-0.0064851413,
0.021046767,
0.0774758831,
-0.0114485892,
-0.0045763259,
0.0002882367,
0.0062388135,
-0.0451181568,
0.0107378494,
0.0009709749,
0.0244992189,
-0.0258312058,
-0.0628610551,
-0.019142,
0.0219503287,
0.0409806184,
0.048949156,
0.0225631744,
-0.042754136,
-0.0492918789,
-0.0275596883,
0.0191428866,
0.0095253913,
0.0293830801,
0.0205449834,
0.0136563927,
-0.1037787572,
-0.069280833,
-0.0095652705,
-0.0308705363,
0.0087056011,
0.0217779502,
-0.0003253679,
-0.0263897479,
0.0062270346,
-0.051251743,
0.0311235934,
-0.045793727,
0.0258730203,
-0.074753724,
0.0210143086,
0.0310645532,
-0.0073764292,
-0.0282019973,
0.0383490771,
-0.0796847194,
-0.0682970956,
0.0069567589,
-0.0103437165,
0.021576317,
0.0307387635,
-0.0546877608,
-0.039312344,
0.0806194544,
0.0654195622,
-0.0296228584,
0.0235584509,
0.0385081545,
-0.0777758136,
0.0081584668,
0.0315693244,
-0.0193228293,
0.0305170622,
0.0423091277,
-0.0379336029,
-0.013174043,
-0.0472066812,
0.0031305358,
-0.0166991483,
0.101599738,
-0.0008187626,
-0.0579359196,
-0.0171933826,
-0.006755752,
0.0181583688,
-0.0199310612,
-0.0284025446,
0.0265384298,
0.0449923426,
0.0343351364,
-0.0149510056,
0.0488341972,
-0.0110968705,
0.0409638695,
-0.0271938648,
0.0178879909,
0.0457798019,
0.0292137004,
0.047798939,
0.0140827512,
0.0089168418,
0.0303084105,
0.0064671929,
0.0260304604,
-0.0005548347,
0.0561562479,
0.0028029524,
0.0040414822,
-0.0092871469,
0.0348025113,
-0.0389489084,
0.0070449268,
-0.0564449541,
0.0135703981,
0.0339702033,
-0.037611641,
0.0290840752,
-0.0107355323,
0.0048928089,
-0.0364848599,
0.0267695487,
-0.0262385402,
-0.0280384067,
0.0148266032,
-0.0102911927,
-0.0501375124,
0.0005390289,
0.0740433559,
0.0370069519,
0.0388748534,
0.0027089103,
-0.0253199972,
0.0007393438,
0.0207406543,
0.0432996824,
0.0237762239,
-0.0172872208,
0.026684884,
-0.0242760498,
-0.0779350698,
-0.0029257601,
-0.0460109562,
0.0044761267,
0.0264981743,
0.0142979315,
0.0614629202,
-0.0178102404,
0.0033637709,
-0.0504807457,
-0.0168748833,
0.0030077975,
-0.0271251332,
-0.0258463249,
-6.083676238e-33,
-0.0005393582,
-0.0244342536,
-0.0461719409,
-0.0226364862,
0.016920235,
0.0067814183,
-0.0121063776,
-0.0094577456,
-0.0342322886,
0.003317426,
0.0095451232,
0.0465374142,
0.0306751039,
0.015436383,
-0.0619070604,
-0.0298827328,
0.0449131839,
-0.0079045463,
-0.0418841727,
-0.0101797925,
0.0301038958,
0.0444413759,
0.0635164157,
-0.0545770004,
-0.0152279595,
-0.0241859239,
-0.0341205671,
0.001531163,
0.0376613624,
0.052123934,
-0.0044330009,
0.0573259629,
0.0230074003,
0.0007708097,
-0.0310667939,
0.0443085544,
-0.0550154038,
0.0067414348,
-0.0072648004,
0.036103636,
0.0514956526,
-0.0024153204,
0.0600759313,
-0.0083011892,
-0.0107883485,
-0.0416227579,
0.0516117252,
-0.0267141201,
-0.0080861012,
-0.0152296331,
-0.0600784756,
0.0509047806,
0.0233799871,
-0.0361129828,
0.0285084452,
0.0240718033,
0.0287834518,
-0.0017601491,
-0.0204145182,
0.0168037862,
0.0321259573,
0.0347803682,
0.0276284218,
0.05188483,
-0.0258756746,
0.0403365791,
-0.0360570736,
-0.0047139507,
0.0090933144,
-0.0344100855,
0.0770038366,
0.0136647169,
0.0073738643,
0.0263211746,
0.0555533543,
-0.0413070135,
-0.0833820477,
0.0269628298,
-0.0542452931,
-0.046080865,
0.0367429666,
0.0017032196,
-0.079073377,
-0.0278123468,
0.0002563918,
-0.0389349945,
-0.0251323115,
-0.0314348675,
0.0462315306,
0.0018080489,
-0.016901955,
0.0314145759,
0.018336121,
-0.0758201256,
-0.0131653147,
0.0362049192,
-0.048360873,
0.0130580906,
-0.0230354257,
0.0103912046,
-0.0146624232,
-0.0206359774,
0.0248052701,
0.0070144059,
0.0026459298,
-0.021850355,
0.059920378,
0.0171186551,
-0.0785172656,
-0.0052405978,
-0.0282907002,
0.0161431599,
0.027779229,
0.1123414859,
0.0179066546,
-0.0053013829,
-0.018750798,
0.0419470109,
0.0351005234,
-0.0106652156,
-0.011568957,
0.0298362151,
-0.0061853379,
0.0238691717,
-0.0513433255,
-0.0236020591,
-0.0135973403,
0.0200063698,
0.0329304934,
-0.0565022007,
-0.0144293811,
-0.0204747487,
2.556e-7,
0.0826650634,
0.0238681436,
0.0198821872,
-0.0078974431,
-0.0121071124,
0.0453001745,
-0.0054176413,
0.0386053436,
0.0034899001,
-0.004522074,
0.0058147525,
-0.0076297852,
0.032793995,
-0.0021170271,
-0.1041341424,
0.0211977493,
-0.0438361242,
0.0079786787,
-0.0397799797,
-0.0341139883,
-0.0113609601,
0.1152945533,
0.0259704851,
-0.0363330357,
0.0102064274,
-0.0656632185,
0.0575917289,
-0.0080408268,
0.0348935015,
0.0151159279,
-0.0011243646,
0.0211671572,
0.0205811299,
0.0219016634,
-0.0124591375,
0.0351484604,
0.0388468467,
0.0447944216,
0.0035589987,
0.001729738,
-0.0298302453,
0.0018131116,
0.0209015515,
-0.0581425875,
0.0648242235,
-0.0446947329,
-0.0276431795,
-0.031543117,
-0.0315476581,
-0.0493675731,
0.0179464985,
-0.0293573737,
-0.0066900915,
0.0397091098,
0.0386836939,
-0.002011023,
-0.0175631996,
-0.0642443076,
-0.0546120368,
0.0221552439,
-0.0105327806,
-0.0135712782,
-0.0216872618,
-0.0040112971,
0.0404991396,
-0.0606020615,
0.0359030999,
2.651105955e-34,
0.0234373286,
0.0019779457,
-0.0211068802,
-0.0057196338,
0.0111357076,
-0.0120334141,
0.0253621489,
-0.0028306728,
-0.0124097979,
-0.0196891967,
0.0406741761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13281v1 | LM vs LM: Detecting Factual Errors via Cross Examination | 2023-05-22T17:42:14 | 2023-05-22T17:42:14 | Roi Cohen, May Hamri, Mor Geva, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | A prominent weakness of modern language models (LMs) is their tendency to
generate factually incorrect text, which hinders their usability. A natural
question is whether such factual errors can be detected automatically. Inspired
by truth-seeking mechanisms in law, we propose a factuality evaluation
framework for LMs that is based on cross-examination. Our key idea is that an
incorrect claim is likely to result in inconsistency with other claims that the
model generates. To discover such inconsistencies, we facilitate a multi-turn
interaction between the LM that generated the claim and another LM (acting as
an examiner) which introduces questions to discover inconsistencies. We
empirically evaluate our method on factual claims made by multiple recent LMs
on four benchmarks, finding that it outperforms existing methods and baselines,
often by a large gap. Our results demonstrate the potential of using
interacting LMs for capturing factual errors. | [
0.0772822946,
0.0435090028,
-0.0069791973,
0.0719165877,
-0.0732264072,
0.017412506,
-0.0009850366,
-0.0147440601,
0.0204008501,
-0.0710052773,
0.0014588839,
-0.0297971759,
0.0376404151,
-0.0078690862,
0.0042149276,
-0.0033478215,
0.0798756704,
0.0017753894,
0.0377266519,
-0.0033564037,
0.0351015031,
0.0413740352,
-0.0384016484,
0.0025086829,
-0.0580678992,
-0.0322819017,
-0.0057043084,
0.0035403336,
0.0194989871,
-0.0116694942,
0.0044818087,
0.0625320226,
-0.0146339191,
0.1035882533,
0.0000019506,
-0.0465751328,
-0.0075575565,
0.0182996914,
-0.0347833335,
0.0422186367,
0.02901599,
-0.0086158887,
-0.0041995286,
0.0060920427,
-0.0287125167,
-0.0213269666,
0.0062753395,
0.0393625423,
0.077284947,
0.0725814104,
0.0110751064,
0.0192232132,
0.0176231042,
-0.004831132,
0.0015943714,
-0.0247655716,
0.0225253217,
0.0243385099,
-0.0164933968,
0.0141033046,
0.0109490473,
0.0216788724,
0.0313930921,
-0.0459285118,
-0.0319811478,
0.006261637,
-0.0297439285,
-0.0127134034,
-0.0044789338,
0.0356646515,
0.033568047,
-0.0430785343,
-0.0118781636,
-0.0205558874,
0.0136096142,
0.0311029255,
0.0069331927,
0.0422320664,
-0.0563441068,
-0.013085749,
0.0246177446,
-0.0320928916,
0.0289098211,
0.0468111858,
0.0282462463,
0.0691167712,
0.0039715394,
-0.0758513585,
-0.0168908369,
0.0261581708,
0.0239685718,
-0.0597635768,
-0.0059519345,
0.0161086414,
-0.0479484014,
0.0396147296,
-0.0467727259,
0.0120844869,
0.0845646784,
-0.0607914329,
0.0192939434,
-0.028941527,
-0.0517737828,
0.0680626333,
-0.0074804272,
0.0564489663,
0.0072482242,
0.0067644003,
0.0131324157,
-0.0324078165,
-0.000914457,
-0.0071336711,
0.0087103471,
0.0278556179,
-0.0352959521,
0.0281170309,
-0.0173457395,
-0.0073757172,
-0.0216424074,
0.0471058376,
-0.000469102,
-0.0192821417,
-0.0019837699,
-0.0163423996,
-0.0695421025,
0.0079131443,
0.0027659137,
0.0350380279,
-0.0123068802,
-0.0947492495,
-0.0169813801,
0.0244111735,
-0.0450447649,
-0.0027989941,
-0.0060572252,
0.0113131842,
0.0073088757,
-0.008474228,
-0.0367049351,
-0.0462269932,
-0.0429532193,
-0.064815782,
-0.0554565117,
-0.0802382082,
0.0256590787,
-0.0243658572,
-0.0189014692,
-0.0206406228,
0.0242255647,
0.0651554018,
-0.0448027253,
0.0498017371,
-0.0259328503,
0.0042808983,
0.0185957178,
0.0091414489,
-0.0020593016,
0.0332460776,
0.0268415008,
-0.0072101075,
0.0605611838,
0.0468446389,
0.0374873765,
0.0101487562,
0.007689578,
0.0210469496,
0.0501674563,
-0.0152305244,
-0.0227359608,
0.0430047512,
-0.0120268259,
0.0849636644,
-0.0120590189,
-0.0368138775,
0.0792185441,
0.0147704994,
-0.0058357343,
0.0102213481,
0.0627824143,
-0.0205814634,
0.0360916108,
0.0282812845,
-0.0361616984,
0.0049430477,
-0.0515052676,
-0.0148404269,
0.0087523106,
0.0456745699,
0.0177430119,
-0.0817353204,
-0.0296535604,
0.0142949903,
0.0023446509,
-0.0123156421,
0.0106501961,
0.0365641452,
-0.0104891462,
0.0371104106,
0.0431276262,
-0.0827593505,
-0.0103558414,
-0.0417837501,
0.0317331515,
0.034455739,
0.0708727166,
0.002900403,
-0.0111751342,
-0.0131734721,
0.0010614494,
0.0860913321,
0.1046954319,
-0.0138316434,
-0.0042261677,
-0.0069162282,
-0.0058112848,
-0.0109196892,
0.0495615564,
-0.030084027,
0.0316808634,
0.0044179694,
0.0171077903,
-0.0464397073,
-0.0120132435,
0.0487784296,
-0.0224446841,
0.0126777412,
-0.0029346638,
0.0011008545,
0.0004435662,
0.014935948,
-0.0139066773,
0.0044103721,
0.0165182818,
0.0235487707,
-0.0182332937,
0.0057765367,
0.0260764081,
-0.0298691709,
0.0388671383,
-0.0086324988,
-0.0411150232,
0.0244389102,
-0.0295805186,
0.0031605202,
-0.0183677822,
-0.032069508,
0.0083751082,
-0.0593229719,
0.0375871733,
-0.0043340912,
-0.0087042637,
-0.0119365957,
0.0653365999,
-0.0180480909,
0.0254056212,
-0.0091028009,
0.0013194382,
0.0114723584,
-0.0326635353,
-0.022487741,
-0.0002801118,
0.0177425873,
0.0369161069,
0.0247291531,
-0.0058762436,
-0.0395759009,
-0.0284972042,
-0.0727921948,
0.0027657347,
-0.0286666825,
0.0167021044,
0.0190127343,
-0.0149566671,
-0.006827496,
-0.0188355055,
0.0124459891,
-0.0405360833,
0.0186945423,
0.0035148524,
0.0677567497,
-0.0169904549,
0.0190532673,
-0.0535528138,
0.0286560319,
-0.0459675975,
0.0268654339,
0.0314619392,
-0.0014120708,
-0.0563669242,
-0.0066097784,
-0.0781880692,
0.0206843372,
0.002198772,
0.0120626362,
0.0206672996,
0.0357674994,
-0.0156526268,
0.0373491682,
0.0315435082,
0.033704225,
0.0241691545,
-0.0222628899,
-0.0450236127,
0.0100723132,
0.0072577228,
0.0098286858,
-0.0053664888,
-0.0467200615,
0.0425382629,
0.0398102179,
0.0132875927,
-0.0099958014,
-0.0238755662,
0.0130813709,
-0.0405209735,
-0.0263349786,
0.0329985693,
-0.002560307,
-0.0227074493,
0.038702976,
-0.0414369777,
-0.0296371542,
0.0877366588,
-0.0797310695,
0.0345478989,
-0.0382206962,
0.0006840324,
-0.0260948688,
0.0382616483,
-0.0313921794,
0.0161364302,
0.0230586715,
-0.0012459052,
-0.0076271039,
-0.0254617408,
0.0888283998,
-0.0531057827,
0.0582386591,
-0.0980728194,
0.0305782184,
0.0294315182,
-0.04378343,
-0.0448389351,
-0.0898609832,
0.0085089309,
-0.0279483832,
-0.0440824255,
0.0049983966,
-0.0539038964,
-0.0301385857,
0.0243855994,
0.0310764685,
0.0181511268,
-0.0158378091,
-0.0116396556,
0.0151766567,
0.025994556,
-0.016214082,
0.043724861,
-0.0257718284,
0.0059224367,
0.0752899796,
-0.0493775643,
0.0187101364,
0.0160437506,
-0.0548409112,
-0.0256013498,
-0.021357106,
-0.0387303457,
-0.0125122294,
0.0219884813,
-0.0761409849,
-0.0192167014,
0.0871688873,
0.0488157049,
-0.0001596138,
-0.0103878509,
-0.019513851,
-0.0037492765,
0.0114430757,
0.0083048595,
-0.0853969604,
0.0106143635,
-0.0078851422,
-0.0036296612,
-0.0194399189,
-0.0197394937,
-0.0134362988,
-0.1213762909,
0.0525684878,
0.0069661578,
0.0343388319,
-0.0661538094,
-0.0230104197,
0.0300752297,
0.0146047659,
0.0290725492,
0.0360407978,
0.0097466838,
-0.0034418844,
-0.000812508,
-0.0481797457,
-0.0164945815,
0.0269215424,
-0.0218166895,
0.0328107923,
0.0236232225,
0.0408482403,
0.0069485381,
-0.0563222617,
-0.0078928946,
-0.0009553412,
-0.0251307879,
-0.0252579805,
0.0386851057,
-0.0268611498,
-0.0003434424,
-0.0372090638,
-0.0107559152,
0.0433592759,
-0.0360268913,
0.0107958457,
0.050086651,
-0.0233159512,
-0.0104467226,
0.0037933777,
0.0238542985,
0.0179946534,
0.0570152365,
0.0171737429,
0.0220552944,
-0.046931006,
-0.0611653961,
-0.0343057923,
-0.03599995,
-0.0472712852,
0.0346420556,
0.050969813,
-0.0122902226,
-0.0775861293,
-0.0443618447,
-0.0336533189,
0.0051402478,
-0.0114877922,
-0.0028918912,
0.0439962149,
-0.0109730018,
0.0023138546,
-0.0244538318,
-0.0505064726,
0.0419094823,
0.0181868486,
0.0329799689,
0.0149758356,
-0.0024979156,
0.006991683,
-0.0099570826,
-0.0518560112,
-0.0619034879,
-0.0063438308,
0.0140073681,
0.0164920054,
0.0623049363,
-0.0685136616,
-0.0172653291,
0.013695999,
0.0175806843,
-0.0280788206,
0.0475469902,
0.03701666,
-0.0234614592,
0.0028215561,
0.0214788169,
-0.0323713943,
-0.0105827805,
-0.0241744258,
0.0558168814,
-0.0744790882,
-0.0666243136,
0.0472420976,
0.0244046208,
0.0758888945,
0.0302679557,
0.0289792772,
-0.0391317643,
0.0123652155,
-0.0237774663,
-0.0530287996,
0.0041872449,
0.027485488,
-0.0212432742,
-0.0111961821,
-0.0274249166,
0.0162211359,
-0.0507997312,
0.0397372097,
-0.0303927939,
-0.0060916962,
-0.0031298348,
0.026545668,
-0.0112774186,
-0.0452115908,
-0.0258378312,
0.0103370296,
-0.0233322885,
0.0511942394,
0.0151245492,
0.0511108153,
0.0089871287,
-0.0156012317,
-0.0019175134,
-0.0256615076,
-0.0603186972,
-0.0022766942,
-0.0232101027,
0.0194705985,
0.0529490188,
0.0203641113,
0.055088181,
-0.0154886609,
-0.0266406778,
0.000474844,
0.0112158973,
0.0111779459,
-0.0634722486,
0.0315251909,
0.0110389236,
-0.0230887607,
0.0060568452,
0.0435923524,
-0.0198078863,
0.0659099966,
0.0183745082,
-0.0427882597,
-0.0510873906,
-0.0829717293,
-0.0247147046,
-0.0271830074,
-0.0146964714,
-0.0108614098,
-0.1061351895,
-0.0610670596,
0.0259653553,
0.0536719225,
0.031500753,
0.0059537003,
-0.0168523379,
0.0920158103,
0.0319298021,
0.0021989802,
-0.0804168209,
0.0240476783,
0.0207431577,
0.0076283882,
-0.0286413748,
-6.117062849e-33,
-0.0460001491,
-0.054087013,
0.000715694,
0.0202401243,
-0.027668938,
0.0136834681,
-0.0389076546,
-0.0001101963,
-0.0411983244,
0.0603229441,
0.0168991555,
0.0568050146,
0.0151165631,
-0.0144962594,
-0.0125441272,
-0.0296026934,
0.0412335731,
0.0116938185,
-0.0356136858,
-0.0113732852,
0.0150391795,
-0.0304744001,
0.0287576318,
-0.0680411756,
0.0717580244,
-0.0070120879,
-0.0458339974,
0.0472696312,
-0.1181531772,
0.0715794042,
0.0197878294,
0.0558400452,
0.0041344641,
-0.0044067129,
-0.0006898416,
0.008076841,
-0.0425300747,
-0.0047309515,
0.0613019615,
-0.0031764519,
-0.0316601992,
0.0155637404,
0.0140867457,
-0.0000674352,
-0.0066319145,
-0.0082291448,
0.0247946121,
-0.0259362273,
0.004511734,
-0.0097837811,
-0.0561555959,
0.0259383265,
0.0146727776,
-0.0212793574,
-0.0206043068,
0.0411733948,
0.0250456464,
-0.0145965042,
-0.0917794406,
0.0107158897,
-0.0517903604,
-0.016972445,
0.0297624785,
-0.0515984483,
-0.0230172165,
0.0639704168,
-0.0332450867,
0.0224228669,
-0.0442761295,
0.0336200967,
-0.0021270257,
0.0177493468,
0.0578322746,
0.1089226007,
-0.0146589726,
-0.0040883422,
-0.0578241609,
-0.0190012064,
0.0319958776,
0.0441945419,
0.0124914236,
-0.036335744,
-0.0432478748,
0.0045396783,
-0.0609125309,
0.0022385619,
-0.0294977762,
0.0110614318,
0.010462366,
0.0249710903,
-0.0020746908,
-0.0205729455,
-0.0307597723,
-0.0224275906,
0.0037603211,
0.0004127068,
-0.0281935818,
-0.019962782,
-0.0083183236,
0.024117833,
-0.0353806168,
0.0163798817,
-0.0015630102,
0.0370131768,
0.0155956578,
-0.0034271723,
0.0506560542,
-0.010377828,
-0.0681355745,
0.0138739273,
-0.020386247,
0.036517702,
-0.0204932764,
-0.0301286671,
0.0288207904,
-0.0039438261,
-0.045016516,
0.029658746,
-0.0036230483,
0.0066466937,
-0.0752744153,
-0.008743424,
-0.0208913647,
0.0124244699,
-0.0188826621,
0.0026015621,
-0.0196916889,
0.0234397184,
0.0277158096,
-0.0334784985,
0.0128964456,
0.0399617366,
2.616e-7,
0.0325389989,
0.0424488112,
0.0164175499,
0.0205381699,
0.0191624425,
0.0441265851,
-0.0158388112,
0.0266725961,
0.0070765768,
-0.0483099669,
-0.017162703,
0.0214027595,
0.080609709,
0.0518240072,
-0.0489790961,
0.0086100865,
-0.0766907334,
-0.0269006006,
-0.0366425812,
-0.0193867926,
0.0398732536,
0.0356805958,
0.0470096506,
0.0103312433,
-0.0279470179,
-0.0155519294,
0.0633277744,
0.0334358811,
-0.0597233698,
0.0078330701,
0.064903155,
-0.0234421995,
0.0167639032,
0.0356099308,
-0.0115515767,
0.0199513268,
-0.0180402417,
0.0376571529,
0.0109673636,
0.002177486,
-0.0637322664,
-0.0168514214,
0.0143730771,
-0.0421249792,
0.0501986332,
0.0214149002,
0.0208418649,
-0.0611786358,
-0.0153073594,
0.0279094577,
0.0320957489,
0.0041099484,
-0.0740736872,
0.0046243565,
0.0192190949,
0.0264058653,
-0.0065322039,
-0.0321643949,
-0.0270436555,
0.01824921,
-0.0262903385,
-0.0549046099,
0.0311279148,
-0.0178248566,
0.0101133641,
-0.0564366691,
0.0278660152,
2.335319959e-34,
0.0399600714,
-0.0121870218,
0.0393699296,
-0.0077076033,
0.077991873,
0.0561002977,
-0.0056272708,
-0.0054874169,
0.0096290279,
-0.0288123842,
0.0109015265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13276v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13276v2 | Evaluating ChatGPT's Performance for Multilingual and Emoji-based Hate Speech Detection | 2023-05-22T17:36:58 | 2023-05-23T03:39:44 | Mithun Das, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Hate speech is a severe issue that affects many online platforms. So far,
several studies have been performed to develop robust hate speech detection
systems. Large language models like ChatGPT have recently shown a great promise
in performing several tasks, including hate speech detection. However, it is
crucial to comprehend the limitations of these models to build robust hate
speech detection systems. To bridge this gap, our study aims to evaluate the
strengths and weaknesses of the ChatGPT model in detecting hate speech at a
granular level across 11 languages. Our evaluation employs a series of
functionality tests that reveals various intricate failures of the model which
the aggregate metrics like macro F1 or accuracy are not able to unfold. In
addition, we investigate the influence of complex emotions, such as the use of
emojis in hate speech, on the performance of the ChatGPT model. Our analysis
highlights the shortcomings of the generative models in detecting certain types
of hate speech and highlighting the need for further research and improvements
in the workings of these models. | [
0.0616420694,
0.058150325,
-0.0332845189,
0.0342251621,
-0.0170049239,
0.0566133186,
0.0487911254,
0.0346571617,
0.0418063141,
-0.0588621497,
-0.0095449695,
-0.0394371115,
-0.0158049073,
0.0386014841,
-0.0110704424,
-0.0422775112,
0.034192685,
0.0406589881,
0.0249706339,
-0.0239688661,
0.0815058276,
0.0134997712,
-0.0031848087,
0.0576353893,
-0.0847085044,
0.0185168125,
0.0216437541,
-0.0061393739,
0.022769073,
0.0158245414,
0.0363245308,
0.0436087959,
-0.0105678905,
0.0838821456,
0.0000017898,
-0.031170873,
0.0159193873,
0.0005097991,
0.0058199423,
-0.030128805,
0.1166122407,
-0.029253779,
-0.0457604676,
0.0469361581,
-0.0110381525,
0.0027066416,
0.0751207545,
0.0526021607,
0.032451041,
0.0683417022,
-0.0162464343,
-0.0199019164,
0.0342050716,
0.0147798359,
0.005273459,
0.0389798991,
0.0198188312,
-0.0440101326,
-0.0570674762,
-0.0230631251,
-0.0126252994,
0.023202125,
0.0221879147,
0.0213027671,
-0.0093778772,
-0.0139464661,
-0.0261292998,
-0.0477514639,
0.0053949947,
0.0198117606,
-0.0708856881,
0.0098908925,
-0.0104306405,
0.0142198121,
-0.0269070417,
-0.0254052635,
-0.0266361162,
-0.0095992601,
-0.0169222914,
0.0054974775,
-0.0071246503,
0.0255221687,
0.0445153788,
0.0598547906,
0.0234491974,
-0.0085994294,
0.0187334754,
-0.0252340771,
0.0003080467,
-0.0081392685,
-0.0417993441,
0.011078909,
0.0352064557,
-0.0021733479,
-0.009074158,
0.0166619048,
-0.0481071509,
-0.0436722524,
0.0145822624,
-0.0850507021,
-0.003210854,
0.0540956631,
-0.024513565,
-0.0086197192,
-0.010826909,
0.071059376,
-0.0000876362,
-0.0001146133,
0.0077404436,
-0.0179641526,
-0.0205552913,
0.0154037336,
0.0001785072,
-0.0146021852,
-0.0043229768,
0.0262950938,
-0.0754625276,
0.0018128436,
-0.0357873403,
-0.0268486943,
-0.0218494441,
-0.0164633133,
-0.0048559904,
0.009873135,
-0.0139270928,
0.0100282654,
-0.0456628688,
-0.0012316901,
-0.0322346091,
-0.093901962,
0.024696501,
0.0324619263,
-0.0296482462,
-0.0246635117,
0.0322737619,
0.0686789528,
0.0370080434,
-0.0311716851,
-0.0241060872,
-0.0318196751,
-0.04438008,
-0.0636800304,
0.0194486957,
-0.080395557,
0.0250504017,
0.0049797324,
-0.0174950901,
-0.0269224327,
0.016161494,
0.0139108514,
-0.0490330048,
0.0618120842,
0.0109062623,
-0.0201463159,
0.0204879623,
0.0352174826,
0.0014580585,
0.0614163652,
0.0139330821,
0.0366898626,
0.0554683134,
-0.0064286888,
0.0113548916,
0.0787092149,
0.0267587155,
0.037701156,
-0.027432166,
-0.0055561289,
-0.0397560447,
-0.0378615931,
-0.0014319516,
0.0525182113,
-0.0074811173,
-0.0733394325,
0.0518555604,
0.082931608,
-0.0300013032,
0.0361889414,
0.0454286635,
0.010165453,
-0.0163734425,
-0.0207779743,
-0.0481376275,
-0.0338495225,
-0.0566972494,
-0.0410771891,
0.0182583369,
0.068474941,
-0.0228334907,
-0.0457697436,
-0.023303194,
-0.0231135562,
0.0505923741,
-0.0397302248,
0.0259924121,
-0.0092925541,
-0.0218087174,
-0.0185235348,
0.0609802753,
-0.0497268401,
0.0000140283,
-0.0577986613,
0.0130963046,
0.0742742941,
0.0322625786,
0.0141587676,
0.005717569,
-0.0465108342,
-0.0514446869,
0.0653988421,
-0.0015430476,
0.0102755278,
0.0052654631,
-0.0362342373,
-0.0104510691,
0.0511333346,
0.0071071619,
0.0295370929,
0.059235353,
0.0441069342,
0.0021447728,
0.033460509,
-0.0177800022,
0.0047338125,
0.0144620296,
-0.0055713365,
-0.0156276636,
0.0101724537,
0.0519949012,
0.0229305495,
-0.031415958,
-0.0422478728,
-0.0065553021,
-0.0098126512,
-0.0438805558,
0.0281254351,
-0.051927615,
-0.0381148122,
0.026964495,
-0.0365101472,
-0.0061586369,
0.0666064173,
-0.0108286059,
0.0256572496,
0.0731743798,
-0.0329567567,
0.0016908051,
-0.026881991,
-0.0409079082,
-0.0566229634,
0.0336397439,
0.0097027728,
0.054295145,
-0.0209828056,
0.0049036802,
0.0152505692,
-0.0045227217,
0.0466240272,
0.0399874188,
-0.0692593306,
0.0059773587,
-0.0319292992,
0.0242342483,
0.0144519955,
0.0209216364,
-0.0122641232,
-0.0083202431,
-0.1310158372,
-0.0022745179,
-0.0269055627,
-0.0275614653,
0.0213076547,
0.0131287668,
-0.0257877279,
0.0254225545,
-0.0369506888,
-0.0331423543,
0.0745276734,
0.0318288468,
-0.0218891948,
-0.0791613013,
-0.0452876128,
-0.0416258126,
-0.0123346196,
0.0050714617,
0.0112263039,
0.0081581399,
-0.0590376332,
0.0699941665,
-0.0065532429,
-0.0282327887,
0.0157697238,
-0.0091025187,
-0.08793284,
0.0323679149,
0.0273345709,
0.0198402163,
0.0325848199,
0.0567657389,
0.1080982834,
-0.0314603895,
-0.0203678496,
-0.0384463854,
0.0085116904,
-0.0253778957,
0.0185360238,
-0.0113732265,
-0.047527466,
-0.0254746526,
0.083123371,
0.0450491197,
0.0060552638,
-0.0856865197,
0.024375936,
-0.0641158968,
-0.0433165096,
-0.0336256549,
-0.0350329503,
-0.0074262531,
-0.0418857709,
-0.0295754354,
-0.0738890097,
0.0372500941,
0.0013445428,
0.0027479373,
-0.0331520475,
-0.0184880737,
0.0016966938,
0.0570331961,
0.0041656438,
0.0491572171,
-0.0310412422,
-0.0006118286,
0.0138077717,
0.0017197515,
0.0141176609,
-0.0467585884,
-0.0371751264,
0.0210922491,
0.0079184407,
0.0257481635,
-0.0268858541,
-0.0616094097,
-0.0335696936,
-0.0305225514,
-0.0277599413,
0.0531495586,
-0.0172516052,
-0.0035690488,
0.048719801,
0.0137147177,
-0.0359399803,
-0.0190204196,
0.0056923507,
0.0366972238,
-0.016944129,
0.0003347193,
-0.0366708077,
0.0264782123,
0.0019607153,
-0.0147714084,
0.0769901723,
-0.0013862901,
0.0102980807,
-0.010830339,
0.0245103929,
0.0158835612,
0.0341533944,
-0.0058626197,
-0.0301542003,
0.0316314884,
0.0032360558,
0.0082200365,
0.0875883102,
0.0151378242,
-0.0085530961,
0.0097483424,
0.0076430338,
0.0394506827,
-0.0085871499,
-0.024828963,
-0.0851162896,
-0.0105844848,
-0.0189139247,
0.0267654676,
-0.0874545425,
-0.0035409792,
0.0113206841,
-0.077337347,
0.0271206144,
-0.003507131,
-0.0455080755,
-0.0284929741,
0.0046497714,
0.0236336291,
-0.0046919254,
0.0446094982,
-0.0353990756,
0.0228680242,
-0.0098304041,
0.0084473416,
-0.0731366351,
-0.0129054664,
0.0328965336,
-0.0252176542,
0.0461369306,
0.0495880283,
0.0508239232,
-0.0166290645,
-0.011731904,
0.031843286,
0.0215208232,
-0.0155582819,
-0.0614951178,
0.0585295558,
0.0121327657,
-0.0375393406,
-0.0374450348,
0.0206746124,
-0.0167050362,
0.0178171322,
0.0001832407,
0.013531073,
0.0359359793,
0.0008012362,
-0.062115062,
0.0311631672,
-0.0094993254,
0.078843981,
0.0196110494,
-0.0658441558,
-0.0124568539,
-0.0561771877,
-0.0009973153,
-0.0422143638,
-0.1031348929,
-0.028812347,
-0.0203325059,
-0.0394362397,
-0.0484202765,
-0.0404985584,
0.0042017158,
0.0009324815,
0.000122945,
-0.0356115811,
-0.0316098146,
-0.0021578388,
-0.0245463401,
0.0002304102,
0.0137933493,
0.0472329557,
-0.0168382861,
0.0215729009,
-0.0196423624,
-0.0227425192,
-0.022495456,
0.0215808488,
-0.0653948933,
-0.0394866914,
0.0720601976,
0.0749785155,
0.017861167,
-0.0022534726,
-0.0356931575,
-0.0399416573,
0.0432338528,
0.0589005984,
-0.0154957967,
-0.0050110756,
0.0624829419,
-0.0034511345,
0.0043146899,
0.0021520087,
-0.0027247225,
0.0589393228,
0.0217398293,
-0.0395681635,
-0.0407984443,
0.0068561262,
-0.0174983907,
0.0074580279,
0.0367324129,
-0.0034410048,
-0.0607886463,
-0.0181590114,
-0.0261742938,
-0.0046328786,
-0.0195991322,
-0.0438435897,
-0.017674027,
-0.0076709725,
0.0092784539,
-0.0458971746,
-0.0520470105,
-0.0371484756,
-0.0025023457,
-0.0221891068,
0.0160571691,
0.0284953099,
0.0404521078,
0.0243717674,
0.0299002398,
-0.0324836746,
0.0418346934,
0.0006414717,
-0.0336853676,
-0.0161823258,
0.0272349082,
-0.0172471553,
-0.0155057814,
0.0544056892,
-0.0139656141,
0.0327455476,
-0.0153052034,
-0.0603640564,
0.0140390499,
-0.0047994996,
-0.0130609134,
0.0543096028,
-0.0184645653,
0.0079971123,
-0.0335637145,
-0.0086503727,
-0.018564878,
-0.0355106033,
-0.0098156407,
0.0041123037,
-0.0272489674,
-0.0250056628,
0.0459970944,
-0.0231551547,
0.0630982295,
0.0425625145,
-0.0332936086,
-0.0185882691,
0.0202786885,
0.0429774635,
0.0042757872,
0.0041119019,
0.0403675102,
-0.0597238839,
-0.0412117355,
-0.0173755176,
-0.0455922931,
0.0560854338,
0.0177153237,
0.0241926145,
0.0749506578,
-0.018142296,
0.0484299436,
-0.0037275273,
-0.000498805,
-0.041211281,
-0.0571314618,
0.0262353588,
-5.713296336e-33,
-0.0115093542,
-0.0285356436,
-0.0174208153,
-0.0189057291,
-0.0030255371,
-0.0185476802,
0.0274737813,
0.0407427289,
0.013380303,
0.0120144319,
0.0129458727,
0.0105223581,
0.0103713572,
0.0155012161,
-0.025405366,
-0.0244864225,
0.0278114174,
-0.0217784941,
-0.003565951,
0.0142247546,
0.0608937666,
0.0039192033,
0.0278556459,
-0.0573358573,
0.0392237864,
-0.0287475474,
-0.0336672477,
-0.0023006878,
0.0172073469,
0.0874290913,
-0.0255602188,
0.0954106078,
0.0308961067,
0.0002466582,
-0.0075485413,
0.0334354192,
-0.0280213803,
-0.0215834174,
0.0409013554,
0.0308309533,
0.0007127916,
-0.0016103801,
0.034549877,
0.0036632365,
-0.0588475689,
-0.0305322707,
0.0152789094,
-0.0299296305,
0.0232952926,
-0.0389561094,
-0.0710870922,
0.0345858224,
-0.0205008537,
-0.0150068011,
-0.0059920875,
0.0511534028,
0.0251494944,
-0.0004638966,
-0.0219031014,
0.0198967997,
-0.0062829209,
-0.020271033,
0.0034719324,
-0.0059240023,
0.0164053272,
0.0761475638,
0.0094374772,
0.0022229946,
-0.0299197268,
0.0182092544,
0.0423504189,
0.0427406989,
0.0708966106,
0.053132765,
0.0229539257,
-0.0600070991,
-0.0515889153,
0.0018094048,
0.0850957334,
0.0031744777,
0.0340034142,
-0.0200386364,
-0.073897168,
-0.0221551359,
-0.0078613069,
-0.0483018644,
-0.0228470173,
-0.0601432808,
0.032920938,
-0.0256847497,
-0.014576639,
-0.0475515872,
0.0341888778,
-0.0310010388,
-0.0056679281,
0.0336714946,
-0.0551856682,
0.0106791928,
0.0245992262,
0.0524933003,
-0.0306102596,
-0.0067732697,
0.0085877972,
-0.0288376939,
0.021029776,
-0.0036962382,
0.0415934138,
0.031505689,
-0.0707805529,
0.0104154237,
-0.0109653026,
0.0775095597,
-0.0224365965,
0.0371612124,
0.0027438982,
0.0234609265,
-0.0231789891,
-0.0277653318,
0.0320008807,
0.0067731999,
-0.0357144922,
0.0075635351,
-0.0493797958,
0.0100221178,
-0.0080070412,
-0.0053763408,
-0.020124279,
-0.01729903,
0.0172594376,
-0.0648978353,
0.009868701,
-0.0429245383,
2.429e-7,
-0.0035043191,
0.0281625744,
0.0083441325,
0.0167663172,
0.0227960441,
0.0469415747,
0.0295127127,
0.0123904031,
0.0177678857,
0.0227168482,
-0.030254785,
0.0451981798,
0.0253907144,
0.0524472073,
0.0058798068,
0.0033859729,
-0.0654236302,
0.0088463528,
-0.0380520634,
0.0265585519,
0.0007316535,
0.0962214246,
0.0630881414,
-0.0320663005,
-0.0130376071,
-0.0126613257,
0.0250104554,
-0.0473567955,
-0.0284173954,
-0.0276092254,
0.0577386022,
0.0212571695,
0.0334886461,
-0.0125069441,
0.0107294675,
-0.0049460037,
0.0260096248,
0.0377611928,
0.0190244131,
0.0174841192,
0.022696726,
-0.0247362424,
-0.0195118822,
-0.0581471212,
0.0420644246,
0.0009327005,
-0.0000170747,
-0.074762553,
-0.0044793617,
-0.0120195802,
0.0687781945,
-0.0395421423,
-0.0407342985,
-0.0044551976,
0.0384861752,
-0.0193024073,
0.0011060709,
-0.0478939898,
0.0006333051,
-0.0167522859,
-0.0313695483,
-0.0568967462,
-0.0434693769,
0.0029786972,
0.030470863,
0.0437689759,
0.0259784423,
1.847892846e-34,
0.0286716484,
-0.0231660083,
-0.0016451281,
-0.0272734798,
0.0471670777,
0.0172048099,
0.0175077785,
0.0136612402,
0.0449407585,
-0.005436494,
-0.0012327742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14386v1 | Let GPT be a Math Tutor: Teaching Math Word Problem Solvers with Customized Exercise Generation | 2023-05-22T17:36:14 | 2023-05-22T17:36:14 | Zhenwen Liang, Wenhao Yu, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Peter Clark, Xiangliang Zhang, Ashwin Kaylan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present a novel approach for distilling math word problem
solving capabilities from large language models (LLMs) into smaller, more
efficient student models. Our approach is designed to consider the student
model's weaknesses and foster a tailored learning experience by generating
targeted exercises aligned with educational science principles, such as
knowledge tracing and personalized learning. Concretely, we let GPT-3 be a math
tutor and run two steps iteratively: 1) assessing the student model's current
learning status on a GPT-generated exercise book, and 2) improving the student
model by training it with tailored exercise samples generated by GPT-3.
Experimental results reveal that our approach outperforms LLMs (e.g., GPT-3 and
PaLM) in accuracy across three distinct benchmarks while employing
significantly fewer parameters. Furthermore, we provide a comprehensive
analysis of the various components within our methodology to substantiate their
efficacy. | [
0.0081793964,
0.023664875,
-0.0098624025,
0.0197801944,
-0.0475887097,
-0.0096566603,
0.0222565364,
-0.0028240702,
-0.0150559656,
-0.0214201845,
-0.022950314,
0.0182668716,
-0.0479054414,
-0.0276279394,
0.029393876,
-0.0594829731,
0.0320280008,
-0.0157647394,
0.013833574,
0.0094797239,
-0.0183390994,
0.0050116945,
-0.0423630662,
0.0114559866,
-0.0043816618,
-0.05534973,
-0.0033748769,
-0.070950821,
-0.0149635142,
-0.0417043902,
0.0322971269,
0.0504985191,
0.0455286801,
0.0294246059,
0.0000024452,
-0.0278155189,
-0.0268496536,
0.0071945759,
-0.0352985598,
0.0505316406,
0.0337329619,
0.0567478314,
0.010510168,
0.0278474279,
-0.0635015368,
0.0333870314,
0.0052810204,
0.0085936645,
0.0736361593,
0.0530239791,
0.0060115377,
0.0394147076,
-0.0023688627,
-0.000363012,
0.0776172876,
-0.0532135554,
0.001290108,
0.1005571112,
0.067805469,
0.0172406752,
-0.0810539797,
0.0427189022,
0.0512369536,
0.0313917212,
0.0055738683,
0.003770418,
-0.0145233963,
0.0416637212,
-0.014824111,
0.0282285716,
-0.0140847703,
0.0228560176,
-0.0466111489,
-0.0124722086,
0.0160430837,
0.0605894662,
-0.0712596849,
0.0148255108,
-0.0039631929,
0.007596591,
-0.0101246694,
-0.0233145617,
0.0100253085,
0.0228433143,
-0.0047997856,
0.042517934,
0.0361485742,
-0.0451062322,
-0.0063165715,
0.02243842,
-0.0286027715,
0.0125254923,
0.0496996939,
0.0576700121,
0.0151164718,
0.0396700576,
-0.0513266623,
-0.0704617128,
-0.0221181493,
-0.0112821748,
0.0610881746,
0.0783897191,
0.0413041376,
0.0181684569,
-0.0000423675,
0.0561585501,
0.016096063,
0.0055502541,
-0.0399623848,
0.0494784601,
-0.0617296733,
-0.0469058789,
-0.0552406758,
0.0370978452,
0.0005393453,
-0.0092149992,
-0.0425342955,
0.0117018074,
0.0004183753,
-0.0106642507,
0.0166139491,
-0.0080269007,
-0.0149812484,
-0.0233913139,
-0.0493914187,
0.0171725005,
-0.0350036658,
0.008337996,
-0.0206129085,
-0.0462416485,
-0.0073439199,
-0.0127693033,
-0.0329578482,
-0.0441811308,
0.0516428649,
0.054367926,
-0.0488123856,
-0.0457226038,
-0.0137469508,
-0.0127017992,
0.025946822,
-0.078838475,
0.0019797345,
-0.0758244917,
0.0352970324,
0.0010618026,
0.002495009,
-0.0020708905,
0.019159738,
0.0109284595,
0.0259874947,
0.0730235502,
-0.0050824364,
0.0149971666,
0.0562092029,
0.0205986127,
-0.0097330911,
0.0614971966,
0.0836418346,
-0.0351168029,
-0.0025061388,
-0.0632622465,
0.0141673665,
0.0424007811,
0.0021533302,
0.0097224526,
0.0191896595,
-0.0174518786,
0.0367232971,
0.0356670991,
-0.0360311419,
0.0222991444,
-0.037320409,
0.0635971203,
0.0525775217,
0.055964835,
-0.0128143765,
0.0584534332,
0.0196479131,
-0.0066684964,
0.0489437729,
0.016220184,
-0.0773544759,
0.0088195736,
-0.0161932223,
-0.0097164819,
-0.006933399,
0.0186963342,
-0.0052559497,
-0.053228613,
-0.0230450314,
0.0100389319,
0.0092357639,
0.0266160425,
0.0782538056,
-0.0164463762,
-0.0100188255,
0.0675214902,
-0.0012026677,
-0.047217086,
0.0230328962,
-0.0510283187,
0.0361710079,
0.0155414948,
0.0887711197,
-0.0452276357,
-0.0390491113,
0.0120934071,
-0.0113043236,
0.0008189157,
0.0398302376,
0.0130130081,
-0.0309434384,
-0.0525493808,
-0.0107943267,
-0.0390614793,
0.0138561558,
-0.0185548719,
0.0808157474,
0.0148443663,
0.0359734148,
-0.0462800302,
-0.0254106931,
0.0246852729,
-0.106677644,
-0.0815106556,
-0.0183760859,
-0.0163508523,
-0.0003216868,
0.0115889246,
0.0353943668,
0.0254570805,
0.0034688774,
-0.013234688,
0.0086820954,
-0.0251950193,
-0.0616710335,
0.001284852,
0.0740224123,
-0.0443847626,
0.0024371031,
0.0176861268,
-0.0055588284,
-0.037196245,
0.0236646943,
-0.0408559218,
0.0410123952,
-0.0329189636,
0.0329007879,
0.0213704538,
-0.0384731591,
0.0062765875,
0.0457539931,
0.0503201522,
0.0489252806,
0.0061148033,
0.0064684316,
0.0006091497,
-0.0348648094,
0.0002525522,
-0.0115065463,
-0.0012269081,
0.0051332591,
-0.0101688541,
0.0215161778,
-0.0801870078,
-0.0108226947,
-0.0074312161,
0.0219619963,
0.0220467877,
0.0571028553,
0.0232562646,
-0.0079261363,
-0.0260986779,
0.0061937529,
-0.0569410697,
-0.0397337973,
-0.0158055145,
-0.0209973156,
-0.0174758974,
0.0090089245,
-0.0151363192,
-0.0550842322,
-0.0133919958,
-0.0464630015,
-0.0095438464,
0.0359597057,
0.0445626006,
-0.025722973,
0.0680540502,
-0.0099532632,
0.0225952175,
-0.0063854922,
-0.0172822718,
0.0343014598,
-0.0314519443,
0.0744028986,
0.0432846434,
-0.0124422265,
0.061148528,
0.0366584994,
-0.054568734,
-0.0618085675,
0.0279989131,
-0.0368148871,
-0.0337052904,
-0.0178703293,
-0.0570405908,
-0.0191932488,
0.0365946926,
0.0258251559,
-0.030046517,
-0.0609193407,
0.0310809594,
-0.018365534,
0.0148172723,
-0.0437709205,
0.0144690368,
-0.0105310306,
-0.0475306436,
-0.0000870384,
-0.0368161835,
0.0580656193,
-0.0050815856,
-0.0171341896,
-0.0601394884,
0.0193290506,
-0.0302086826,
0.0037086527,
0.023417579,
-0.0202650372,
-0.0596203655,
0.0137575231,
-0.0503242612,
0.0096819168,
0.0396548286,
-0.0495042466,
0.0282080509,
-0.0819884464,
-0.0301139932,
-0.0001780794,
-0.02671008,
-0.0268033333,
0.0490864478,
-0.0112406639,
0.011493545,
0.0016327453,
-0.0335556529,
-0.017134862,
-0.0216925647,
0.0328480825,
0.0116718244,
-0.0501440242,
-0.0192019809,
-0.0061435518,
0.0034169268,
0.0350998156,
0.0217288379,
0.0099518178,
-0.0758425295,
0.021405112,
0.0181411617,
0.075017184,
-0.0140999611,
0.0198461153,
0.0389159508,
0.018618023,
-0.0465711839,
0.0149724698,
0.0431389213,
0.0412620716,
-0.0947267413,
-0.0125631373,
0.0884330049,
0.0577598289,
-0.0052643758,
-0.0077088051,
-0.0195266213,
0.0053400993,
0.0104031507,
0.0379056185,
-0.0624991208,
-0.0133681148,
-0.0240698718,
0.0439481027,
-0.0025697942,
-0.00709006,
-0.0344704166,
-0.1343959868,
0.0099622654,
0.0587669984,
-0.0261759479,
0.0078245485,
-0.021952251,
-0.0280853678,
-0.0104112457,
-0.0041723941,
0.003442147,
-0.02248534,
0.0614559948,
0.0317452885,
-0.0003637685,
-0.0393655524,
-0.0031602329,
0.0162014943,
-0.0047469167,
0.0248375423,
-0.0279721431,
-0.0425540023,
-0.0729979947,
0.001908683,
0.0333323218,
-0.0254952032,
0.0032397562,
0.0277146567,
-0.0172242299,
-0.0069976561,
-0.0215954073,
0.0856253132,
-0.0309038926,
-0.0203907993,
0.071610257,
0.1119249091,
0.0040151104,
0.0104824798,
-0.0169590097,
-0.0273983143,
0.0363828838,
0.0671748891,
0.0328997634,
-0.0448059328,
0.0111996988,
-0.0259889681,
-0.01554952,
-0.0343442224,
-0.0124460943,
0.0270608123,
-0.0122062508,
0.0402062386,
-0.0091180261,
-0.0487425439,
0.0905338749,
0.0331768394,
0.0117265433,
0.0333668366,
-0.0209140964,
0.0257294625,
-0.0192899741,
0.0395577177,
-0.0233605783,
0.0159654021,
-0.0657879561,
-0.0344752185,
-0.0070516542,
-0.0271985438,
-0.0064123468,
0.0398927443,
-0.0979014784,
-0.0423392542,
-0.0104121463,
0.0472634695,
0.0188719667,
-0.0122882994,
0.0304316375,
-0.0047039245,
-0.0232650507,
-0.0035577479,
-0.0646849573,
0.0080459276,
-0.0147575475,
-0.0060450705,
0.0312781446,
-0.0277765598,
0.0226045102,
-0.0064428584,
0.0093255527,
0.0588793196,
-0.0272531193,
-0.004044041,
0.0387806669,
0.0294705704,
-0.0047395006,
-0.0001524367,
0.0204980783,
-0.0274300743,
0.001454763,
-0.0454790071,
0.0040260172,
-0.0562791005,
-0.0217206031,
-0.0079367151,
-0.0225221533,
0.0122558763,
-0.0214675236,
-0.0174425431,
0.0333285294,
-0.0117483204,
0.0654188767,
-0.0178295728,
-0.0241170209,
0.0599548221,
-0.0380722061,
0.0215339642,
-0.0149126621,
-0.0103954459,
0.0215850174,
0.0245505627,
0.0950736478,
-0.0042002951,
0.0132456245,
-0.0212038718,
-0.0332325995,
0.0109928567,
-0.0638032109,
-0.0516259894,
0.0555083677,
-0.0243448392,
-0.020196639,
-0.0228214227,
-0.0688771829,
-0.0180545449,
0.0050682439,
-0.0078420211,
-0.0108265514,
-0.0024067238,
0.0435147993,
0.0443586782,
0.0575990155,
-0.0531081408,
0.0420874283,
0.0090335207,
0.0480403751,
0.001950996,
-0.0150937177,
-0.0327929109,
-0.0225064941,
0.0525064208,
0.0043620779,
0.0235472042,
0.016689945,
-0.0705931112,
-0.0612700991,
-0.0439166427,
0.0143450983,
-0.0160989165,
-0.012165227,
0.0729764625,
0.0693464279,
-0.1142744198,
-0.0197159834,
0.0144810267,
0.0649736226,
-0.0347465649,
-0.0520549081,
0.0013651809,
-5.987718063e-33,
-0.0246887077,
-0.0614324771,
0.0743038803,
0.0210588258,
0.0118046403,
-0.0259683486,
-0.0259001032,
0.0366518684,
0.0190572962,
-0.0060286159,
-0.0051933359,
-0.0066743237,
-0.0064445264,
0.0123583954,
-0.006533152,
0.0220889561,
0.0093897171,
-0.0094716214,
-0.0208923947,
-0.0187636316,
-0.0171853825,
0.0121424822,
0.0824589357,
-0.0495001301,
-0.0061944313,
-0.0014417359,
-0.0035089224,
-0.013215472,
-0.0429794639,
0.0370289981,
-0.0279618148,
0.0255241022,
-0.0032192916,
-0.0642053261,
-0.0133136967,
-0.0188121758,
-0.0126688639,
-0.0432736166,
0.0214116611,
-0.0043148617,
-0.0595177226,
-0.0511602461,
0.0104349572,
-0.0126654515,
-0.0549910851,
-0.0185637027,
0.0449360833,
-0.0305506159,
-0.0077361106,
0.0373601541,
-0.0362864509,
0.0128941303,
-0.0204637088,
-0.0289311912,
0.0252418481,
-0.0108288759,
-0.025529556,
-0.0307784826,
0.0120432805,
0.0382917374,
0.1133618802,
0.0417557992,
0.0257973094,
0.0112645356,
-0.0117273154,
0.0030687491,
-0.0091057671,
-0.0559314601,
0.004422124,
-0.0216218196,
0.0444578081,
0.0354787223,
0.1070743725,
0.0247418713,
0.0396318249,
0.0246850867,
-0.0261441227,
0.0263548139,
0.0174454935,
-0.0075705349,
-0.0052679568,
-0.0154916197,
-0.0277451035,
-0.0054837931,
-0.032233078,
0.0191407949,
-0.0310162622,
-0.0369515903,
0.0541370772,
-0.0232019164,
-0.0128029352,
-0.028522715,
0.0076895854,
0.0011034388,
-0.0281710252,
0.0018958796,
-0.0095512327,
0.0235609952,
-0.0133609381,
-0.00549899,
-0.0479446128,
-0.0243278109,
-0.012405159,
-0.0021958866,
0.0047106575,
0.0002344296,
-0.0013566745,
0.0338954777,
-0.0300977081,
-0.0009944505,
-0.0553135462,
-0.0183428954,
0.0596224964,
-0.0145783769,
0.0201386046,
0.019943269,
-0.0207802784,
0.0411240235,
-0.0126615437,
-0.0683784112,
-0.0124395723,
0.0112368604,
-0.0230291989,
-0.0091185486,
0.0049187853,
-0.0052883793,
-0.0164867491,
-0.001964293,
0.0239346456,
-0.0359089151,
0.005632909,
0.0078336727,
3.007e-7,
0.0413090475,
0.0253469273,
0.0015088731,
0.004498431,
0.0038439771,
0.0204543918,
-0.0100139901,
-0.0297560934,
0.0202686731,
-0.0088881571,
0.0180589166,
0.0686263144,
0.0406886674,
0.0520830415,
-0.0306891166,
0.0094554955,
0.0243399721,
0.0232767202,
-0.0757388994,
0.0364928134,
0.04519777,
0.0268217567,
0.0611380301,
0.0027884496,
-0.0161885358,
-0.0342455916,
0.0462251194,
-0.0392802656,
-0.0284063462,
0.0190416053,
-0.0183471926,
0.0119298147,
-0.005884394,
-0.0200156849,
-0.0298125148,
0.0208958853,
0.0135293314,
0.06833639,
0.0292285345,
0.0058141379,
0.0050375662,
0.0149602704,
-0.0405718759,
-0.0389110036,
0.0323459394,
-0.049277667,
0.0054003811,
0.0374029055,
-0.0036210578,
-0.0456407592,
0.0079012709,
-0.0323362872,
0.0297488198,
0.0188722052,
0.0100646075,
-0.007899587,
-0.010420803,
-0.0185344703,
-0.0111893052,
-0.0109705301,
-0.0686538741,
-0.0166261904,
-0.0830495581,
-0.0223962069,
-0.0197161604,
-0.0214815829,
0.0115467627,
2.635043009e-34,
-0.0002041768,
-0.0087415902,
0.0662225708,
0.046197962,
0.0123366769,
0.00731795,
0.016675299,
0.0451148599,
0.0600257218,
-0.0521063842,
-0.0361812077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13272v2 | CLASS: A Design Framework for building Intelligent Tutoring Systems based on Learning Science principles | 2023-05-22T17:35:05 | 2023-10-26T01:25:23 | Shashank Sonkar, Naiming Liu, Debshila Basu Mallick, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a design framework called Conversational Learning with Analytical
Step-by-Step Strategies (CLASS) for building advanced Intelligent Tutoring
Systems (ITS) powered by high-performance Large Language Models (LLMs). The
CLASS framework empowers ITS with two key capabilities. First, through a
carefully curated scaffolding dataset, CLASS equips ITS with essential
problem-solving strategies, enabling it to provide tutor-like, step-by-step
guidance to students. Second, by using a dynamic conversational dataset, CLASS
assists ITS in facilitating natural language interactions, fostering engaging
student-tutor conversations. The CLASS framework also provides valuable
insights into ITS' internal decision-making process which allows seamless
integration of user feedback, thus enabling continuous refinement and
improvement. We also present a proof-of-concept ITS, referred to as SPOCK,
which is trained using the CLASS framework with a focus on introductory
college-level biology content. A carefully constructed protocol was developed
for SPOCK's preliminary evaluation, examining aspects such as the factual
accuracy and relevance of its responses. Experts in the field of biology
offered favorable remarks, particularly highlighting SPOCK's capability to
break down questions into manageable subproblems and provide encouraging
responses to students. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/luffycodes/Tutorbot-Spock. | [
0.0752211362,
-0.0172843598,
-0.0216435716,
0.0197131839,
-0.024115812,
0.0103645679,
0.0404177047,
-0.0404482149,
0.0325262994,
-0.057264626,
-0.0011076066,
0.0374393538,
-0.0257926229,
0.0359868668,
-0.0158095658,
-0.0847774595,
0.0323320031,
-0.0151677402,
0.0323219523,
0.0193326361,
0.0330345742,
-0.0107983304,
-0.0648696199,
0.0536418371,
0.0184101909,
-0.0412642509,
-0.0444326773,
-0.0315687209,
0.0007085692,
-0.0266957935,
0.0266952291,
0.0518456064,
0.02694555,
0.0317623578,
0.0000021472,
-0.0486608893,
0.0047385171,
-0.0069494122,
-0.043586947,
0.0044633378,
0.038239453,
0.0635063872,
-0.0018398664,
0.0091841854,
-0.0662386045,
0.0149021046,
0.0478798226,
0.0271029174,
0.0773942247,
0.0363795049,
0.0261879768,
-0.0344951227,
0.0338953324,
0.0375013463,
0.0324257687,
-0.0026110308,
0.0292244256,
0.0700214207,
0.0606705807,
0.0390524492,
-0.0338514261,
0.0452892855,
0.0130173098,
-0.0737251416,
0.0329059884,
0.0096558165,
-0.0094929207,
-0.0313816853,
-0.0282697752,
0.0774914101,
0.0413750149,
-0.0026903693,
-0.0298529807,
0.0060820198,
0.0443178639,
0.0353022553,
-0.1008622274,
0.0229333714,
-0.0002292681,
0.0011886429,
0.0069014132,
-0.0462393314,
-0.0181483272,
0.0427210554,
0.0181958694,
0.009835667,
-0.0210696068,
-0.0099007729,
-0.0271640755,
0.021132173,
0.045811601,
-0.0241133925,
0.0212509967,
0.0919101164,
-0.0401283242,
0.0289305635,
0.0069190357,
-0.0220588185,
0.0249877013,
-0.013014053,
0.008394599,
0.040476352,
-0.0038560084,
0.0180881079,
0.0235228818,
0.0166535825,
0.0359517485,
0.0176274981,
-0.0038953943,
0.0268419459,
-0.080132544,
-0.0013779128,
-0.0290885046,
0.0549646839,
-0.0092514949,
-0.0152141592,
-0.0432427041,
0.0321988314,
-0.0035527463,
0.0370879844,
-0.0382348523,
0.0031396276,
-0.0030015304,
0.0232922081,
-0.0407163352,
0.0590340532,
-0.0186030865,
0.0044062547,
0.0204337202,
-0.0749009922,
-0.0033099968,
-0.0105620353,
-0.0023283784,
0.0125567317,
0.0029272893,
0.0465981402,
-0.0328750461,
-0.0396937542,
-0.0123265563,
-0.0563014932,
0.0070077395,
-0.0364032574,
-0.0173282679,
-0.0612666421,
0.0083631659,
0.0294440668,
0.0111747412,
0.0035093774,
0.0335976854,
0.0233549327,
-0.011152871,
0.0435365178,
-0.0355129205,
-0.0078382296,
0.0517629944,
0.0322602652,
-0.0190870594,
0.0382099971,
0.0212155897,
-0.0169576332,
0.0119019868,
-0.0498663001,
0.0350412056,
-0.0165351145,
-0.0091590891,
-0.0278159864,
0.021701524,
0.0080850841,
0.0235852879,
0.0580430105,
-0.045176439,
0.0024550895,
-0.009194917,
0.0341609344,
0.0476797335,
0.0569808111,
-0.0545860976,
0.0616382733,
0.0157781001,
0.0448753759,
0.0596525371,
0.0020192864,
-0.0297022238,
0.0262969974,
-0.0461176559,
-0.0113664903,
-0.0022167596,
0.0112645244,
0.0002661969,
-0.0689299554,
-0.007398387,
0.0142565658,
0.0171032697,
0.0393068492,
0.0523625351,
-0.0143986121,
-0.0217637084,
0.0147086522,
0.032693319,
-0.0497785471,
-0.0138003239,
-0.0533188805,
0.06646014,
0.0946182534,
0.057550855,
-0.0631215498,
-0.0515167899,
-0.0062432527,
0.0516414195,
0.0296776555,
0.0513238609,
-0.0505874455,
-0.0062208893,
-0.0357486121,
-0.0252699591,
-0.019023791,
-0.008995139,
-0.0320096947,
0.0153104719,
0.001412964,
-0.001824195,
0.0457205772,
-0.0713039041,
0.0410037078,
-0.0400615335,
-0.0169717316,
-0.0567061938,
-0.0201826915,
0.0158182383,
0.0354075842,
0.0206302088,
0.0085991742,
0.0392512381,
0.0209123027,
0.004553121,
0.0001095773,
-0.0370367728,
-0.0497581959,
0.0557715222,
-0.0274656266,
-0.0333236232,
0.0109121799,
-0.0102327559,
-0.0279150531,
0.0197967589,
-0.0537580922,
0.0278186016,
-0.0052656294,
0.0240259599,
-0.0530749857,
-0.0255388319,
-0.0261026714,
-0.0059896535,
0.0584873892,
0.0315708257,
0.0243067108,
0.0027925379,
-0.0064431028,
-0.0597868487,
0.0023001649,
-0.0119703636,
0.0062471353,
-0.0038964984,
0.0193915181,
-0.0071593393,
-0.1100837812,
-0.0052457079,
-0.0421987176,
0.0054388489,
0.0336955115,
0.0083887102,
-0.0131231304,
-0.0061973818,
0.0130241411,
-0.0329117887,
-0.0184820332,
0.0324918516,
-0.0073910309,
0.0059840633,
0.0247217268,
0.0356857218,
-0.0365329795,
-0.0573152564,
0.0075533502,
-0.0538971946,
0.023068862,
0.073622331,
-0.0057195644,
-0.0462712832,
0.0416909307,
-0.0152017074,
0.0183431916,
0.0020456163,
-0.0467399694,
0.0608187541,
-0.0424432755,
0.030582225,
0.0815663561,
0.0139063979,
0.0429966599,
0.0338636972,
-0.046333082,
-0.0664172918,
0.0328172036,
-0.0366537124,
-0.0164124109,
-0.0322521627,
-0.0125648649,
-0.037563704,
0.0591164082,
-0.0095841298,
-0.0268382523,
-0.0238989741,
0.0348566808,
0.0256805271,
0.0143926041,
-0.0206750669,
-0.0015166108,
0.0192817077,
-0.0152072143,
0.005781129,
-0.0323040448,
0.1081989706,
0.0092962114,
-0.0261766892,
-0.0518592224,
-0.009781505,
-0.0123253455,
0.0193270538,
-0.0055316659,
0.0069318758,
-0.0391455218,
-0.0036132981,
0.0122766085,
0.011327967,
0.0178557429,
-0.0452922806,
0.0060345102,
-0.0946519896,
-0.0409703664,
0.0280446094,
-0.0191819873,
-0.0462779328,
0.0376946405,
-0.0674720705,
-0.0156134851,
-0.0008560895,
-0.0430526473,
-0.0730606318,
-0.03720342,
0.0464073792,
0.0200697184,
-0.0305427574,
-0.0228983164,
-0.0182418264,
-0.0241132937,
0.0126568526,
0.021457376,
0.0240293872,
-0.0243915059,
0.1353832632,
0.0516247414,
0.0099167256,
0.0000454004,
0.0042629489,
-0.0078907907,
0.0424229689,
-0.0157728121,
0.0127191637,
0.0458904281,
0.0344315842,
-0.104074508,
-0.0199016556,
0.125700295,
0.0265496876,
-0.043166548,
-0.0105857123,
-0.0663751662,
-0.0218055192,
0.0102673983,
0.0552910343,
-0.0705684647,
-0.0416878685,
-0.0378553495,
0.0184987821,
-0.0189766195,
-0.0432480425,
-0.0120839942,
-0.0650019571,
0.0399662592,
0.0286296662,
-0.0622108057,
-0.0165074263,
-0.0818909705,
-0.0158289503,
0.0020777883,
-0.0024869253,
0.0102395779,
-0.0193869453,
0.0195416901,
0.0147260074,
-0.0342480242,
-0.0408222713,
0.0135028949,
-0.0057450416,
0.0387612619,
0.0264179483,
0.0265992172,
-0.003555994,
-0.0095779384,
0.0106898956,
0.0073039546,
-0.0223273188,
-0.0272646751,
0.0343031511,
-0.0141697377,
0.0021012605,
-0.0757845864,
0.0633869767,
-0.0086579453,
-0.0194132142,
0.0460229814,
0.0882967487,
-0.0319516659,
0.0049638818,
-0.0555789396,
0.031537082,
0.0240309127,
0.067659013,
0.0449145585,
-0.046808701,
-0.0148303257,
-0.0462222993,
-0.0036006744,
-0.0138841718,
-0.0276325531,
0.0248018131,
-0.0211884566,
0.0485232472,
-0.0229817536,
-0.0476020575,
0.0802745894,
-0.0072216354,
0.0177671555,
0.0244935174,
0.0265608318,
0.0330382884,
-0.026944574,
0.0245052613,
-0.0092151221,
0.0000626155,
-0.0924242288,
-0.0750864595,
0.0411392041,
-0.0375137925,
0.008899793,
0.0202526096,
-0.0032386922,
-0.072418429,
-0.0144413421,
0.0401724651,
0.0147553207,
0.0364486985,
0.0431882441,
-0.0560333207,
-0.0024364439,
0.007443266,
0.0225407779,
-0.0352625847,
-0.0113971671,
0.0396769494,
0.0300129242,
-0.0005371114,
-0.0016741689,
-0.0057890224,
-0.0126295239,
0.0230142791,
-0.044222828,
-0.0348196551,
0.0310734604,
0.0203958191,
0.0374362767,
0.0209328011,
-0.0260037147,
-0.0285833143,
0.0283364989,
-0.0389384739,
-0.0184478462,
-0.0331490226,
0.0155056249,
0.0124484645,
-0.0108255204,
0.0354445502,
-0.0026553716,
-0.0566998906,
0.0229699593,
-0.0084165242,
0.0782087818,
-0.0046476508,
-0.0241943188,
0.047375448,
-0.002590182,
-0.0243206192,
-0.0175969061,
0.0338199399,
0.0383318514,
0.0190495364,
0.1081569567,
0.0297601596,
-0.0166209061,
0.0222817268,
-0.0011923561,
-0.0448903777,
-0.0418499559,
-0.0065108626,
0.0568758324,
-0.0317453444,
0.0260813311,
-0.0035228438,
-0.0476950966,
-0.0005276523,
-0.0139582818,
0.0552513711,
-0.0276379287,
-0.0439882018,
0.0382837243,
0.0225243121,
0.0223389994,
-0.0053798468,
0.025776213,
0.0016495964,
0.0418143235,
0.0099133691,
-0.0380833335,
-0.0237032026,
0.0025780364,
0.0327964127,
0.0376262479,
0.01147612,
0.0058750357,
-0.0227967165,
-0.0178159215,
-0.0495828465,
0.0212087296,
-0.025175713,
-0.0283374954,
0.0533054322,
0.033676777,
-0.0295285285,
-0.05174293,
-0.0250734966,
0.0745042413,
-0.0234798547,
-0.0507296808,
-0.0256374385,
-5.711691418e-33,
-0.0172497705,
-0.059064962,
0.0430621207,
0.076970011,
0.0041035698,
-0.0063432623,
-0.0474335216,
0.0224466864,
-0.0175629817,
0.0448136441,
0.0116793774,
0.0122136455,
-0.0022262076,
0.0231711436,
0.0216631368,
0.0116231162,
0.0391877294,
0.0094001051,
-0.0010387375,
0.0370334797,
0.0213700291,
0.0287325662,
0.038534835,
-0.0488304198,
0.0201591011,
-0.0308610927,
0.0394591466,
0.0193056539,
-0.039755147,
0.0156504586,
-0.0203039106,
0.0538135767,
0.0050509367,
-0.0226458535,
-0.0119032841,
0.0463540703,
-0.0587548874,
-0.0537478402,
0.0057445285,
0.0144657521,
-0.045785252,
-0.0301792435,
0.0282302722,
-0.0344038904,
-0.0409454033,
-0.0044980478,
0.0588824749,
-0.0392105356,
-0.0027057226,
0.0136626381,
-0.0715084672,
-0.0090058483,
-0.0586251877,
-0.0638800636,
0.0132223405,
0.0306419674,
-0.0120261507,
0.0047650682,
-0.0048235264,
0.087165527,
0.0664905906,
0.0209384505,
0.0356738754,
0.0091784364,
0.0088275885,
0.0429530106,
0.0502786152,
-0.0083099725,
0.0052497578,
0.0077178208,
0.0049639153,
0.0340435766,
0.0621603094,
0.0126644354,
-0.0211151633,
0.0237976238,
-0.0829735771,
0.0330043398,
0.0831637308,
0.0124440501,
-0.0123619232,
-0.0146037787,
-0.0298700053,
-0.0189507585,
-0.0379416272,
0.0229620673,
0.0115546379,
-0.0285949167,
-0.0076952204,
-0.0391277596,
-0.0085873976,
-0.0189085174,
-0.0065140883,
-0.0272788983,
-0.0511633232,
0.0040128091,
-0.0012429716,
0.0184740331,
-0.0316117629,
-0.0202000272,
-0.0524684377,
-0.0356218703,
0.0289328378,
-0.0451827869,
0.0208046809,
0.0093578128,
-0.0038862061,
0.0195290726,
0.0087516271,
-0.0103481421,
-0.0478804745,
-0.0193563886,
0.0402287319,
-0.0086869281,
-0.0029664342,
0.0294614602,
-0.0208128188,
0.0829844773,
0.0029735048,
-0.003734566,
-0.0279286988,
-0.0189430416,
-0.0025535889,
-0.0275075696,
-0.0409179181,
-0.03461257,
-0.0432281084,
0.0187784694,
-0.0218119174,
-0.0697018132,
0.0004283041,
-0.0078173904,
2.765e-7,
0.0273014288,
0.0787668526,
-0.0008262561,
-0.0409997664,
0.0068541621,
0.0272002704,
-0.0043887231,
-0.0192084238,
0.0281677879,
-0.0203417633,
-0.0117852334,
0.0131163495,
0.0227745008,
0.0145202549,
-0.0866529346,
-0.0708492547,
-0.0160010997,
-0.0331519283,
-0.0424970947,
0.0250020586,
0.0634700432,
0.0105874073,
0.0084797423,
0.006028309,
-0.0048547364,
-0.0194311254,
0.0094743269,
-0.0228146221,
0.0001873414,
0.0595642254,
-0.0184512027,
-0.0007822187,
0.0236423612,
0.0152707156,
0.0134055996,
-0.0058624661,
-0.0448481217,
0.0230073743,
-0.0047356836,
-0.0029032282,
0.0440628603,
0.0087372726,
-0.0080070607,
-0.0354415216,
0.0036176115,
-0.0665227249,
-0.0278557763,
0.0260503627,
-0.0109957159,
-0.0498380549,
-0.0110343872,
-0.0435070246,
0.0013731915,
0.0064655822,
-0.0268174857,
-0.0375320949,
0.0032368496,
-0.0252342075,
-0.017580986,
-0.0273723658,
-0.0552965179,
-0.0573107824,
-0.0378753319,
-0.0421823077,
-0.011548155,
-0.0276984386,
0.0117409267,
2.225389656e-34,
0.0055979267,
-0.0080995737,
0.0535806939,
0.0528558493,
0.0198119953,
0.017795613,
0.0118605355,
0.0393703803,
0.062007647,
-0.0564418845,
-0.0413747393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13269v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13269v4 | Chain-of-Knowledge: Grounding Large Language Models via Dynamic Knowledge Adapting over Heterogeneous Sources | 2023-05-22T17:34:23 | 2024-02-21T07:44:48 | Xingxuan Li, Ruochen Zhao, Yew Ken Chia, Bosheng Ding, Shafiq Joty, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present chain-of-knowledge (CoK), a novel framework that augments large
language models (LLMs) by dynamically incorporating grounding information from
heterogeneous sources. It results in more factual rationales and reduced
hallucination in generation. Specifically, CoK consists of three stages:
reasoning preparation, dynamic knowledge adapting, and answer consolidation.
Given a knowledge-intensive question, CoK first prepares several preliminary
rationales and answers while identifying the relevant knowledge domains. If
there is no majority consensus among the answers from samples, CoK corrects the
rationales step by step by adapting knowledge from the identified domains.
These corrected rationales can plausibly serve as a better foundation for the
final answer consolidation. Unlike prior studies that primarily use
unstructured data, CoK also leverages structured knowledge sources such as
Wikidata and tables that provide more reliable factual information. To access
both unstructured and structured knowledge sources in the dynamic knowledge
adapting stage, we propose an adaptive query generator that allows the
generation of queries for various types of query languages, including SPARQL,
SQL, and natural sentences. Moreover, to minimize error propagation between
rationales, CoK corrects the rationales progressively using preceding corrected
rationales to generate and correct subsequent rationales. Extensive experiments
show that CoK consistently improves the performance of LLMs on
knowledge-intensive tasks across different domains. | [
0.0291247815,
0.058576569,
-0.0107316934,
0.0139159802,
-0.0498916954,
0.0046723695,
-0.0326886624,
-0.0012416343,
0.0020258129,
-0.0568249635,
0.0211420003,
-0.0181367043,
-0.0142961163,
0.0187693145,
0.0153048355,
-0.044420585,
0.0237576477,
-0.058380764,
0.0181661434,
-0.0251483005,
-0.0221229605,
0.0521013848,
-0.0288653839,
0.0073767174,
-0.0099872584,
-0.0334113762,
-0.0396097489,
0.0017225159,
-0.0094350101,
-0.0108855246,
0.0076936493,
0.0539035238,
0.0363447852,
0.0105634984,
0.0000024856,
-0.0398560241,
-0.0301989075,
0.0142441709,
-0.0498881973,
-0.0152885551,
-0.0183605384,
0.019756943,
0.034193486,
0.0214884896,
-0.0480089001,
0.0108888457,
0.0176339466,
0.0234314948,
0.0552556999,
0.0432186872,
0.0036681399,
-0.0467400849,
0.0143298432,
0.0094741527,
0.0121440105,
-0.0418396629,
0.0135041634,
0.0683006272,
0.0311521795,
-0.000781649,
0.0076217433,
0.0055137668,
0.0106186867,
-0.0486789607,
0.0340062305,
0.0214179605,
-0.0110346945,
0.0034991752,
0.0167334713,
0.074676536,
0.012494484,
-0.0418804996,
0.0198982246,
-0.0040179347,
0.0119055649,
0.0531814471,
-0.05973313,
0.0426027663,
-0.0153800799,
-0.0151662743,
0.0030062716,
-0.0269280691,
0.0258922279,
0.0233540926,
-0.0573691353,
0.0969098508,
0.01373237,
-0.0197599065,
-0.0127784926,
-0.0215610825,
-0.0200474355,
-0.0847201571,
-0.0182170905,
0.0717965588,
-0.0747450888,
0.031379085,
-0.0333526544,
0.0171146989,
0.0412723795,
-0.0438088216,
-0.0251718611,
0.0271906294,
0.0261602569,
0.05460684,
-0.0071014506,
0.0209895913,
-0.0187739488,
0.0082846098,
-0.0388079472,
-0.0386084579,
-0.09822613,
-0.0181979649,
-0.003967098,
0.0667271391,
-0.0832971334,
-0.0050469544,
-0.0066193934,
0.0283760354,
-0.0071542794,
0.0134639116,
0.0208252296,
0.0321840681,
0.012681948,
-0.0353731997,
-0.0734569207,
0.0396806784,
-0.0264425706,
0.0331331901,
0.0515930653,
-0.0123212738,
0.0104738194,
-0.008643263,
0.0264092851,
-0.0030268566,
0.0116000632,
0.0358728878,
-0.0171802826,
0.0376948304,
-0.0745439529,
-0.0930947885,
-0.0069510303,
-0.0560457818,
-0.0267365985,
-0.0758580416,
0.040880058,
0.0306167193,
-0.04559277,
-0.0502964593,
0.009594148,
0.0439833142,
-0.0612246096,
0.0364803039,
-0.0490478016,
0.0257878825,
0.0284549855,
0.015220589,
-0.004340501,
0.0909273028,
0.0083577074,
0.0137530044,
0.0207138974,
0.0075314054,
-0.0373420157,
-0.0447624139,
0.0243144184,
0.0262296423,
-0.0188425668,
0.0512545295,
-0.0109847728,
0.0116441874,
-0.0178732276,
0.0321464427,
-0.0147771472,
0.0263930112,
0.0594346188,
0.0070489822,
0.0176037569,
0.0212983023,
0.0339822732,
0.0047580549,
-0.0077728587,
0.0257727988,
-0.0495353267,
0.0466104932,
-0.0310367532,
0.0101588452,
0.0112658869,
0.0576495305,
-0.0169950631,
-0.0490999594,
0.0188601166,
0.0223897882,
-0.0102527943,
0.048866909,
0.0232670028,
0.0192027427,
-0.0415794589,
0.0951814055,
0.0217467621,
-0.0530426353,
0.0234091152,
-0.0087988786,
0.0401937142,
0.0681162551,
0.0437822975,
-0.044604972,
-0.0408877134,
-0.005075831,
0.026223192,
0.0191685241,
0.0228431076,
-0.0338246226,
-0.0333209634,
-0.0473395772,
-0.0553141832,
-0.0083810622,
0.0197622292,
-0.0129449191,
0.0186191555,
0.0168688782,
0.0207380112,
-0.0724096671,
-0.010534131,
-0.0016103807,
-0.0202529207,
-0.0013341421,
-0.0193430521,
-0.0111682294,
0.0016516168,
0.0421856977,
0.0085997134,
0.0547046661,
0.0192520246,
-0.0159209371,
-0.0861431807,
0.0173869263,
-0.0362981483,
-0.0080445651,
0.0549437366,
-0.0094847726,
-0.0085101556,
-0.0803891346,
-0.0356231555,
-0.0546784699,
0.0354961306,
0.0098704239,
0.0178956185,
-0.038485229,
0.0049292208,
0.0064816852,
-0.0458613187,
-0.0369811207,
0.100158602,
0.0192174166,
-0.0382598639,
0.036961399,
-0.0210737959,
-0.0032957031,
-0.0171166472,
0.052628912,
0.0027850019,
-0.0128432065,
0.0139726466,
0.0200089552,
-0.0162562914,
-0.0577442572,
-0.0092039816,
-0.0339276269,
0.0104060853,
-0.0178714711,
-0.0099680759,
0.0192247089,
0.007589662,
0.0233219434,
0.0339318551,
-0.0535542779,
0.030411575,
0.022595292,
0.0133108124,
0.0133274226,
0.0314431302,
-0.0030329539,
0.0085754646,
-0.0023746646,
-0.0253565311,
0.0568407066,
-0.0013661701,
0.0329363085,
-0.0508971736,
0.0286119115,
-0.0787833109,
0.0059405048,
0.0138386469,
0.0126284398,
-0.0041862507,
-0.0197721366,
0.0189598519,
0.0369417369,
0.0105990758,
-0.0325721838,
0.0566776618,
-0.0286040604,
-0.0490529016,
0.0121329594,
-0.0164743364,
0.0253616404,
-0.0195772406,
-0.0293423571,
0.0273458306,
0.0142160589,
0.0117554218,
-0.0146495113,
-0.0720437169,
0.0322750285,
-0.0101582343,
-0.0076415245,
-0.0491937213,
-0.0604867153,
0.0331490077,
0.0737888739,
0.0022706403,
-0.0099145239,
0.0665083081,
-0.0117912842,
0.0520790257,
-0.0335867852,
0.0115441298,
-0.0318765305,
0.0555425398,
-0.0279188585,
0.0291431602,
0.0045902682,
0.0204157345,
-0.0624474362,
-0.0784486234,
0.0459944531,
-0.0361277014,
0.0821558312,
-0.0860352069,
0.0165550802,
0.0071736909,
-0.0325336866,
-0.0404989682,
0.0005805709,
-0.0172809511,
0.0124272518,
-0.0015684367,
-0.0042039901,
0.005589467,
-0.0145718167,
0.053709548,
0.0007102133,
0.0011650175,
-0.0062773647,
0.0017094056,
0.0307401586,
0.0678403825,
0.025816381,
0.0276417341,
-0.0024782466,
0.0449584648,
0.0669700876,
0.0450873375,
-0.0437505357,
0.0126153687,
-0.0079504913,
0.0072100456,
-0.026187839,
-0.0195295215,
0.0120304739,
0.0204521436,
-0.0492718108,
0.0058285301,
0.1009366214,
0.0355143547,
-0.0196170583,
-0.0100527732,
-0.0383667946,
0.052663032,
0.0162772648,
0.0472445674,
-0.0855714157,
-0.0060202125,
-0.0018307919,
0.014405868,
0.003243804,
-0.0604843572,
0.0036394359,
-0.1493305862,
0.0275874641,
0.0056312853,
0.0028195125,
-0.0281194374,
-0.0318548977,
-0.0129565904,
0.0202911217,
-0.019690685,
0.0695981234,
0.009496904,
-0.0093545867,
0.039526362,
-0.0062888111,
-0.0382940806,
0.0153914187,
-0.0126072457,
0.0189010687,
0.0213040486,
0.0513933711,
0.0241543837,
-0.0821276456,
-0.010791814,
-0.0043268725,
0.0042201327,
-0.0277233999,
0.0332294963,
0.0303448252,
0.019296011,
-0.0152616426,
0.0340875313,
-0.0398757085,
-0.031058602,
0.0252135433,
0.1267421395,
-0.0188070145,
0.0000144451,
-0.0165234152,
-0.0153188705,
-0.0065161157,
0.0671585649,
0.0109801823,
0.0234398674,
-0.033902254,
-0.0097338744,
-0.0391607098,
-0.0526305102,
-0.0135044996,
0.0468627997,
0.0000398666,
0.0250074137,
-0.062985152,
0.0030447675,
0.0340807624,
0.045273114,
0.0099933865,
0.0428134836,
0.0374486111,
-0.0123897549,
-0.0418582186,
-0.0139273964,
-0.044042334,
0.0075999186,
-0.0007807966,
0.0032234413,
0.0236813892,
-0.0578857176,
0.0052608266,
-0.0270369444,
0.0104691004,
-0.0688598007,
-0.0153468028,
0.0365940407,
0.0271661412,
0.0250479709,
-0.010652774,
-0.0394309871,
0.0205977522,
-0.0023510403,
-0.0596422963,
-0.0119950688,
0.0067863087,
-0.0099991383,
-0.0019897379,
0.0575774126,
-0.0682057813,
-0.0097019086,
-0.0189234763,
0.0546182543,
-0.000316529,
-0.0322066545,
0.0509847105,
0.0201490652,
-0.0310451128,
-0.0022561399,
-0.018370444,
-0.0075058895,
0.0285664964,
-0.0490861163,
-0.0308400113,
-0.0133219687,
0.0442280658,
-0.0081250314,
-0.032958854,
0.0292821396,
-0.0307378173,
-0.004618417,
0.0270846803,
-0.0093954271,
-0.0129920403,
-0.0075018653,
0.0126249949,
0.0570116006,
-0.0307516064,
-0.0145388842,
-0.0326211713,
-0.013085464,
0.0468611382,
-0.0226320624,
0.0491443239,
0.0307519995,
-0.0307164378,
-0.0455769226,
-0.015255373,
-0.0693565235,
-0.0857518688,
0.0152066685,
-0.0081697339,
0.023312429,
0.0062193102,
0.0572437905,
-0.0201449525,
-0.0377395079,
0.0057056844,
0.0325932018,
0.0671201646,
-0.0262550712,
0.0133438157,
0.0410227664,
-0.031127708,
0.0103737572,
0.0810443684,
-0.0165243298,
0.0258086752,
-0.0097921407,
-0.0417491607,
-0.0265708622,
-0.0601921007,
-0.0326398835,
-0.0044540577,
-0.0362485535,
-0.0033659884,
-0.0835118666,
-0.070727028,
-0.0069160773,
0.0037632461,
-0.0015755824,
0.0036700275,
0.0332810357,
0.0822671428,
0.040176563,
-0.034570992,
-0.0328101516,
0.0658587292,
-0.0465760157,
-0.0024448195,
0.0154596502,
-7.119899488e-33,
-0.0100158034,
-0.0477036722,
0.0521207824,
-0.0394284837,
-0.0239708424,
-0.032820262,
-0.024102537,
-0.0185459815,
-0.0168916173,
0.0232101362,
-0.013570087,
0.0222412609,
0.0021741083,
0.0145817148,
0.0210242178,
-0.025453236,
0.0345618054,
0.0344772004,
-0.0115594314,
0.0374228731,
0.0626830384,
-0.0016125244,
0.0065017398,
-0.0706167519,
0.0066601355,
0.0242406465,
0.019079335,
0.0367404558,
-0.0283875577,
0.0485688411,
0.0101044141,
0.0412396602,
0.0058440911,
-0.0481884107,
-0.0180028938,
-0.0202765167,
-0.0896809623,
0.0116439033,
0.0272793677,
-0.0354016833,
-0.0075788843,
-0.0454719402,
0.0273012873,
0.0257179327,
0.0212126672,
-0.0415250883,
0.01957836,
-0.0407222249,
-0.0349568538,
-0.0206210371,
-0.0347140357,
0.0204257686,
0.0006341573,
0.007718056,
-0.0565940514,
0.0439317897,
0.0187199861,
0.0006738184,
-0.0704375654,
0.0316489302,
0.0060998183,
0.0242795646,
0.0608986169,
-0.0368736796,
-0.0068505555,
0.0348053314,
-0.017787911,
0.011210979,
-0.0425252654,
0.0354911163,
-0.041177392,
0.0774041563,
0.0471919328,
0.0501406081,
0.0184751675,
-0.0097118784,
-0.1088229269,
0.026115315,
-0.0576608479,
0.0557903387,
0.0333330184,
0.0074031432,
-0.012704974,
-0.0294355527,
-0.0490000099,
0.0546685755,
-0.0324556082,
-0.017027,
0.0214616098,
0.0002636128,
-0.0461223722,
-0.0428646617,
0.0091623226,
-0.0333206058,
-0.00714682,
0.0463250466,
-0.0029996715,
-0.0269246716,
-0.0129238153,
0.023626145,
-0.0152348252,
-0.0024950423,
-0.0024761313,
0.0046104956,
-0.0033818267,
0.0465460196,
-0.002593433,
0.016759349,
-0.0212300103,
0.0054480922,
-0.0393386409,
0.0167177413,
0.0004784385,
-0.012287369,
0.0279059988,
0.0499904938,
0.0036563801,
0.0210003089,
0.0205140058,
-0.0196939409,
-0.0050104321,
-0.0264910236,
0.0151680885,
0.0150083518,
0.0068038772,
-0.01704726,
-0.0242536068,
-0.0170091763,
0.0202756785,
-0.0446059965,
-0.0247065648,
0.0344546176,
3.218e-7,
0.0195834059,
0.03038981,
0.0117201684,
0.0294896513,
-0.0121192681,
0.0203786921,
0.0132534569,
-0.0142159685,
0.0300792716,
-0.0800152048,
-0.0105236508,
0.048153758,
0.023316564,
0.066664882,
-0.0721099228,
-0.0653190389,
-0.0138353193,
-0.0638564229,
-0.0429522283,
-0.0107851299,
0.0415853001,
0.0212026983,
-0.0055704736,
-0.0192816518,
0.0124556096,
-0.0306822378,
0.0381910466,
0.0298172813,
-0.0058491901,
0.0150184855,
0.0583558083,
-0.042791117,
0.0312881097,
0.065498732,
-0.0301060211,
0.0033157135,
-0.0428459607,
0.0329457149,
0.007797109,
-0.0135707529,
-0.0215546265,
-0.0817059502,
0.0516341925,
-0.0659617782,
0.086119853,
-0.0293943044,
0.0033372487,
0.0333516188,
-0.0343756415,
-0.0334341303,
-0.0026794558,
-0.0201346613,
0.004711051,
0.0159552898,
-0.0055922829,
0.0375478044,
0.0259162616,
-0.0456789993,
-0.026057722,
0.0325744934,
-0.0223524645,
-0.0287747886,
-0.0073254807,
-0.0307624545,
0.0152784111,
-0.0480240919,
0.0280087925,
3.179383218e-34,
0.0292714592,
0.0356972255,
0.0198594276,
0.0208970848,
0.0641029626,
-0.0062293205,
-0.0240980368,
-0.0015907653,
0.0406310931,
-0.0926814303,
-0.0230471566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13267v1 | Enhance Reasoning Ability of Visual-Language Models via Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T17:33:44 | 2023-05-22T17:33:44 | Yueting Yang, Xintong Zhang, Wenjuan Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained visual language models (VLM) have shown excellent performance in
image caption tasks. However, it sometimes shows insufficient reasoning
ability. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) emerge with powerful
reasoning capabilities. Therefore, we propose a method called TReE, which
transfers the reasoning ability of a large language model to a visual language
model in zero-shot scenarios. TReE contains three stages: observation,
thinking, and re-thinking. Observation stage indicates that VLM obtains the
overall information of the relative image. Thinking stage combines the image
information and task description as the prompt of the LLM, inference with the
rationals. Re-Thinking stage learns from rationale and then inference the final
result through VLM. | [
0.0424137451,
0.0457430445,
0.0014932854,
0.0749581158,
-0.0427938737,
0.0367700756,
0.0059840842,
0.0132331736,
-0.0091816224,
-0.0852963552,
-0.0063754893,
-0.026866246,
-0.0019464276,
0.0417955071,
0.0105315857,
-0.093799755,
0.0191555191,
-0.0549742654,
0.0420350619,
0.0021619238,
0.0206630398,
0.0068550296,
0.0123453103,
0.0311803296,
-0.0056114066,
-0.0342381857,
-0.0057294383,
0.0072824531,
0.00040673,
-0.028538825,
-0.0784888119,
0.0286090747,
0.0663639605,
-0.0129176071,
0.0000018353,
-0.0261503793,
0.0090193516,
-0.0123722572,
-0.0068247039,
-0.0094123837,
0.0200779624,
-0.0428175069,
0.0122565646,
-0.0010046664,
-0.0358944461,
-0.0269277599,
0.0633707717,
0.0570830144,
0.0670141056,
0.0368328504,
-0.0177350882,
-0.0717186481,
-0.019724397,
-0.0162825193,
0.0296743698,
-0.052049458,
0.0055859992,
0.0898611471,
0.0038647789,
0.0045361379,
-0.0359108932,
0.0329569504,
0.0209947973,
-0.0528858155,
-0.0163351838,
0.0462834835,
-0.016330868,
-0.0523528755,
-0.0072949743,
0.0648176521,
-0.0389760621,
0.0092303632,
-0.0302509181,
-0.0171582829,
-0.0050617489,
-0.0041448008,
-0.0561926886,
0.0687605813,
0.011094166,
0.0146003058,
-0.0203489456,
0.0030618259,
-0.0123523138,
0.0198979005,
-0.044855617,
0.0079357736,
0.0004103221,
0.0393731147,
-0.0358906649,
0.0246658474,
-0.0765257701,
-0.0717431009,
-0.0350018702,
0.051156573,
0.0022017118,
0.0313738994,
-0.0223840084,
-0.0062506641,
-0.0259099491,
-0.0408477336,
0.0293565374,
0.0065927212,
-0.0422426015,
0.0933686271,
-0.045878958,
0.0640339404,
-0.0176182315,
0.0404588506,
-0.0354055054,
-0.0307361744,
-0.0474838428,
-0.0228312444,
-0.0415701829,
0.0181728471,
-0.0562063381,
-0.0530802235,
-0.0108995587,
0.0108375316,
0.0032197558,
-0.0136323376,
-0.0025558053,
0.0115508912,
0.0108166244,
-0.0535645224,
-0.0565766729,
0.0503695197,
-0.0021558402,
0.0216453522,
-0.0451389551,
-0.0225296654,
0.003370746,
0.0510773845,
0.049126301,
-0.0133986939,
-0.0022084834,
0.0549466684,
-0.0219146572,
-0.0186598301,
-0.0272303894,
-0.0140280286,
-0.0477094278,
-0.0477386564,
0.0197760575,
-0.0455451645,
-0.0347433202,
-0.0219183397,
0.0056815562,
-0.0060984213,
0.004458975,
0.0195349045,
-0.0457245223,
0.1149274185,
-0.0436178297,
0.0007147436,
-0.0132253096,
0.0096501913,
0.0171175823,
0.0542753413,
0.0134747205,
0.0447496623,
0.007042808,
-0.0009125732,
0.0292825177,
0.0111713577,
-0.0212693103,
-0.0212513302,
-0.0619270317,
0.0062748617,
-0.0188364498,
-0.0026064967,
0.008156972,
0.0400810577,
-0.031397026,
0.0223311707,
0.0662622526,
0.0468161255,
-0.0010781883,
-0.0098214885,
0.0472402014,
0.0144962771,
-0.0279904343,
0.0007374898,
-0.0453379937,
0.0782059208,
0.005521182,
0.0194847248,
-0.0419198573,
-0.0050045578,
-0.0369709842,
-0.0454135612,
-0.0324889906,
-0.0337286666,
0.0075468062,
0.0126353391,
0.0622163378,
0.0280788485,
-0.035247419,
0.0170271117,
0.0029178304,
-0.0210490208,
-0.0177978408,
-0.0452564172,
0.0281697921,
0.0560811013,
0.0193776228,
-0.0001902829,
-0.0389984176,
0.0144534623,
0.0361472033,
0.0547647178,
-0.0060334187,
0.0112117622,
-0.0030055877,
-0.0358477756,
-0.0515364818,
-0.0285440795,
-0.0020146922,
0.0069064703,
-0.0196394678,
-0.0090699065,
0.0181499254,
0.0047251633,
-0.0408352055,
0.0300377551,
0.0546609238,
-0.0191677511,
-0.025055835,
0.0267361663,
-0.0189008303,
0.0014632652,
-0.0067431922,
0.019383505,
-0.0093257222,
-0.0181078725,
-0.0184305031,
0.0322893411,
-0.0789935738,
-0.0611507446,
0.0354875438,
-0.0474551469,
-0.0060735336,
-0.0218166318,
-0.0204795357,
-0.032276269,
0.0076136454,
-0.0159142558,
-0.0050717928,
-0.0701634958,
0.0072897412,
-0.0262177978,
0.003099208,
-0.0152442353,
0.0754259154,
0.004692412,
-0.039931491,
0.0314040594,
0.0096606724,
0.0089185238,
-0.0205682609,
-0.0331027806,
0.0248121787,
0.0108546987,
0.0143324686,
0.0064429278,
0.0494836457,
-0.041819308,
0.0045695943,
-0.0911797509,
-0.0553407744,
-0.0205762293,
-0.0219194181,
0.0133458795,
-0.0251038112,
0.018485222,
-0.043561399,
-0.0214354973,
0.0408613682,
0.0012118276,
0.018132735,
0.0551494658,
0.0046567959,
0.0069823242,
-0.0056736255,
0.0181158166,
0.0225804448,
0.0779129639,
0.0332728624,
-0.0267609395,
-0.0296006408,
0.0465078913,
-0.044567097,
0.0167887975,
0.0069648894,
-0.01859992,
0.0235415976,
-0.0272374246,
0.0157918539,
0.0659128428,
-0.0079890117,
0.0186921749,
0.0275102388,
-0.0248734858,
-0.0161170177,
-0.0038336283,
0.0068183471,
-0.0640506595,
-0.0045611346,
-0.001951235,
-0.0406425968,
0.0536676571,
-0.0486063175,
0.0148747796,
-0.0756813064,
0.0534875281,
-0.0140779456,
-0.0125438729,
-0.0596654788,
-0.0263277292,
0.0055987597,
0.035369277,
-0.0550753362,
-0.064691253,
0.0344301388,
-0.0534261428,
-0.0306311082,
0.0035880229,
0.0111291939,
-0.0459702946,
0.1275879443,
0.0342693068,
0.0134570152,
-0.0052242214,
-0.002385854,
-0.0252436046,
-0.0187824797,
0.0278951973,
0.0071116444,
0.05714285,
-0.0773752332,
0.0281063933,
-0.0362755321,
0.0011224252,
-0.0318011418,
-0.0167131778,
-0.0664763749,
-0.0024889249,
-0.0630373433,
-0.0048440946,
-0.0001902889,
0.0648342818,
0.0459850766,
0.0238018818,
0.0159259494,
0.0091190664,
-0.014495411,
0.0198422801,
0.0489981361,
0.0326101929,
-0.0348380841,
-0.0255821534,
0.0667649955,
0.0345206819,
-0.0053443983,
0.0036291564,
-0.0722554177,
0.02671583,
-0.0069755078,
0.0495775566,
-0.0106701795,
0.0297321547,
0.0484806783,
-0.0514967777,
0.0147541147,
0.0934661701,
0.0121719139,
-0.0385207459,
-0.0324106589,
-0.0011501833,
0.0294100102,
0.039756909,
0.0180753395,
-0.0862487033,
-0.0550446808,
-0.0323101841,
-0.0479790792,
0.0252764933,
-0.0019328701,
-0.0625013858,
-0.1065343469,
0.0665289238,
0.0083670495,
0.0020641643,
-0.0293148793,
0.0422386676,
-0.0180131141,
0.0150236227,
-0.0321143344,
-0.014543375,
-0.0084725097,
0.006270369,
0.0061593023,
0.0220329668,
-0.0110789202,
0.0308583844,
-0.0565024354,
-0.0112665091,
0.0477246903,
0.0376569256,
0.0111328317,
-0.0391280428,
0.0150566008,
0.003908297,
0.0276338011,
-0.0043351743,
0.0628715381,
-0.0040756301,
-0.044035051,
0.0286374483,
0.0053193769,
-0.017080659,
-0.0335809886,
-0.0169578809,
0.0508421138,
-0.0140409991,
-0.0326543674,
0.0099593783,
0.0174151752,
-0.0403088853,
0.0433732606,
0.0389130004,
-0.0137463044,
-0.0293272994,
0.0023571199,
-0.0447804853,
-0.0465670116,
-0.0574774705,
0.0195780005,
0.0038853914,
-0.0098929023,
-0.0565613173,
-0.0007385946,
0.0509146862,
0.0692842975,
-0.0115429629,
0.0128715383,
0.0300117228,
0.015415784,
-0.027680302,
0.054469429,
-0.0605092496,
0.0275608487,
0.0044264309,
0.0130916564,
0.0597128198,
-0.022010332,
-0.019018935,
-0.0276118163,
-0.0291621201,
-0.0151893441,
-0.0514696054,
0.0731151402,
0.0194828194,
0.0428923592,
0.0133512449,
-0.0419879295,
-0.003217468,
-0.0095399078,
0.0356137939,
0.0149012823,
0.0026254018,
-0.0115012722,
0.0098787183,
0.0297405943,
-0.0052705011,
0.0437469743,
0.0413610861,
0.0052435133,
-0.0295900907,
-0.0032741821,
0.0118044969,
0.0219835564,
0.0321692936,
0.0050746705,
0.008311145,
-0.0196901094,
0.024704881,
-0.0093128122,
-0.0243648347,
-0.0819247961,
0.0277865604,
-0.002204428,
0.0235812441,
0.0201946758,
-0.0394055806,
-0.0178104732,
-0.013137768,
0.0093083642,
0.0103094336,
0.0351695903,
0.0087836254,
0.0025655827,
0.0103590488,
-0.0008013123,
-0.0037149412,
-0.0314545184,
0.031958513,
0.00038978,
0.0737843141,
0.041435644,
-0.0368261188,
-0.0382021964,
0.0269239042,
-0.0170354825,
-0.0759883896,
-0.0109152244,
0.045044452,
0.0744143203,
-0.0016767443,
0.0117897782,
-0.002739622,
0.0057698376,
0.0151248956,
0.0507357642,
0.015817998,
-0.0665381253,
0.0593896694,
0.0278140865,
-0.0089876316,
-0.0052052313,
0.0473065674,
0.0187902916,
-0.0028852497,
-0.0159776248,
-0.0170183126,
-0.0175575968,
-0.0194670428,
-0.0052398453,
-0.0234563164,
0.0031919016,
0.0763602555,
-0.0265513286,
-0.070538871,
-0.0089527424,
0.017695535,
0.0009966728,
0.0308111794,
0.0322687924,
0.0320137404,
0.0285424814,
-0.0059228209,
-0.0170242097,
-0.0123036606,
0.0080362437,
0.0535998084,
-0.015559338,
-5.567702544e-33,
-0.0252662655,
-0.0695684925,
0.0663628802,
-0.0238989722,
-0.0030826805,
0.025097318,
-0.0571868084,
0.0132475747,
-0.0107565625,
0.011258211,
0.0387228243,
-0.0075442931,
0.010412287,
0.0323794112,
0.0017028247,
0.0110044945,
0.0087248255,
0.0119049111,
0.0055764415,
-0.0147798536,
0.0083413124,
-0.0189336296,
0.0402002372,
-0.0340225138,
-0.0238817763,
0.0193368644,
-0.0090480139,
0.0298227705,
0.0150172273,
0.060736075,
-0.0116319368,
-0.0344976075,
0.0284195114,
-0.0223005917,
-0.0413991474,
0.0342675,
-0.035831362,
-0.0077476427,
0.0612009019,
0.0297542121,
-0.0687908754,
0.018840896,
0.0078250859,
-0.0121493442,
0.0208144132,
-0.0214174204,
0.0458233543,
-0.0375921316,
0.013090332,
0.0358637795,
-0.0578265637,
0.0201021507,
0.0015939559,
-0.0200161021,
0.0483753122,
0.0258352626,
0.0032746135,
0.0473639108,
-0.0129127204,
0.0200863164,
0.023091644,
0.006243974,
0.1071878895,
0.0465266965,
0.0002848222,
0.0625365376,
0.0002658603,
-0.0070615951,
-0.0658675507,
0.0021903743,
0.0243699383,
0.0794879422,
0.0755277798,
0.0282048322,
0.0191892665,
0.0342645831,
-0.0344036035,
-0.0236693528,
-0.0746699125,
0.0767734125,
0.0318118371,
0.0361662358,
0.0356603749,
-0.0114754979,
-0.0540061072,
-0.0007563815,
-0.0566201061,
-0.009550753,
0.0426654257,
0.0185204223,
-0.0230788514,
0.0412310958,
0.0746892169,
-0.032281965,
-0.0028590821,
0.006618415,
-0.0347631276,
0.0452739894,
-0.0286470503,
0.0154555663,
-0.0407864936,
-0.0280501191,
0.047136806,
-0.0037445195,
-0.0051607983,
0.0209108684,
0.0638813525,
-0.0038471075,
-0.0258655623,
-0.0120338127,
-0.0504823066,
-0.0355593786,
-0.0371305309,
0.050047528,
0.0273196269,
0.0374636464,
-0.0675752386,
0.0247248206,
0.0092734611,
-0.0479831472,
-0.0191849805,
-0.0247674417,
-0.0024107336,
0.0182558298,
-0.0314513668,
-0.0064392067,
-0.0262160525,
-0.0306214597,
0.0014906576,
-0.0524393693,
-0.0155847631,
0.041197136,
2.486e-7,
0.0352720097,
0.0364003181,
0.0062532374,
0.0085960058,
0.0083283316,
0.05829373,
-0.0254909564,
-0.0315730684,
0.0145736784,
-0.0297416486,
0.026584303,
0.049749054,
0.0219165515,
-0.0281681623,
-0.0397326499,
0.0483626947,
-0.0447471663,
-0.0308138188,
-0.0450512245,
-0.02318912,
0.0915205553,
0.0835944489,
-0.0257071871,
-0.0278726108,
0.0367136411,
-0.0935522839,
0.0766077116,
-0.0105563095,
0.0078476872,
-0.0241367146,
-0.0074008168,
0.026296379,
-0.0375627466,
0.0314688198,
0.0136449737,
-0.0166715849,
0.0262014419,
0.0300592463,
-0.0526215211,
0.0325202085,
-0.0303156245,
0.0395423025,
-0.0199907385,
-0.0304738637,
0.0941834524,
-0.0841704458,
-0.0268019717,
-0.0138980234,
-0.0108456183,
-0.0080800187,
0.0126206735,
-0.0029313501,
-0.0163145438,
0.029296916,
0.0379863493,
-0.0427650847,
-0.0302294753,
-0.0993688852,
-0.0240780208,
-0.0102405185,
-0.0193881616,
0.0027310618,
-0.060458824,
-0.0189009756,
0.0502812341,
0.0112042939,
-0.0341226496,
1.816515183e-34,
0.0163820889,
-0.0117086619,
0.0001638664,
0.0326817371,
0.0428959467,
0.0108404951,
-0.028926339,
0.0019417292,
0.0080832457,
-0.0771213695,
-0.0196280722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13264v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13264v2 | Prompting is not a substitute for probability measurements in large language models | 2023-05-22T17:33:17 | 2023-10-23T14:12:59 | Jennifer Hu, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompting is now a dominant method for evaluating the linguistic knowledge of
large language models (LLMs). While other methods directly read out models'
probability distributions over strings, prompting requires models to access
this internal information by processing linguistic input, thereby implicitly
testing a new type of emergent ability: metalinguistic judgment. In this study,
we compare metalinguistic prompting and direct probability measurements as ways
of measuring models' linguistic knowledge. Broadly, we find that LLMs'
metalinguistic judgments are inferior to quantities directly derived from
representations. Furthermore, consistency gets worse as the prompt query
diverges from direct measurements of next-word probabilities. Our findings
suggest that negative results relying on metalinguistic prompts cannot be taken
as conclusive evidence that an LLM lacks a particular linguistic
generalization. Our results also highlight the value that is lost with the move
to closed APIs where access to probability distributions is limited. | [
0.037717443,
0.0735673681,
-0.043913532,
0.0409832895,
-0.0640116334,
0.0119879311,
-0.013973793,
-0.0077278982,
-0.0308435056,
-0.0285777207,
-0.0364769697,
-0.0837962031,
0.0169898849,
0.0063157626,
0.0483704507,
-0.0175163336,
0.035623271,
-0.0622278601,
0.0578709543,
-0.0032152433,
-0.0087208645,
-0.006095856,
-0.0215193741,
0.0453265868,
0.0222879183,
-0.0013559548,
-0.0012956189,
-0.0531009212,
-0.0297867861,
-0.0358507335,
-0.037718486,
0.0462137274,
-0.0036241747,
0.0283364635,
0.0000016546,
-0.0853989795,
0.0397930518,
-0.0248974599,
-0.0220202357,
0.0054727499,
0.0445304699,
-0.026747087,
0.0013917472,
0.0084502921,
-0.0355887003,
-0.0102629159,
0.0405611433,
-0.0022890319,
-0.0317878313,
0.0024517388,
0.0055474136,
0.0171646271,
0.0253872517,
-0.015044935,
-0.0147339953,
0.0102194576,
0.0175886191,
0.0140832951,
0.0105431201,
0.0024764219,
-0.0117468061,
0.0611756109,
0.028943399,
0.018454792,
-0.0410744287,
0.0359540842,
-0.0077681099,
-0.0803830698,
-0.0163754635,
0.0153889656,
0.0610964634,
-0.0083545577,
-0.028071763,
-0.0154468426,
0.0138643533,
0.0494297929,
-0.0297914501,
0.0621703006,
0.0116704805,
0.0030144071,
0.0152643854,
0.0306928121,
0.0252014324,
0.0126116145,
-0.0200100243,
0.116822727,
0.0256210044,
-0.0286322739,
0.0148394695,
0.0092709633,
-0.0049950499,
-0.0597834215,
-0.0197772812,
0.0008445932,
-0.0256079193,
0.0528037809,
0.0013109777,
0.0383357815,
0.0465636477,
-0.033080779,
0.0600854382,
0.0283416789,
-0.0459212027,
0.0296011213,
-0.0136311464,
0.032388214,
0.0221349299,
0.023064496,
-0.026775483,
0.0277245753,
-0.0193544347,
-0.0246797279,
-0.008246867,
-0.0248755757,
0.0137914335,
-0.0386268348,
-0.0385986045,
0.027544219,
0.0144598531,
-0.0183535665,
-0.0061226236,
-0.0062948647,
-0.0181068052,
-0.0068970765,
-0.0967062488,
0.0157086011,
-0.0175116733,
0.0343847834,
0.0037576172,
-0.0598045774,
0.0027626858,
-0.0122133968,
-0.0120309293,
-0.0210860632,
-0.0078713577,
0.0659134164,
-0.0033324598,
-0.0392713174,
-0.0172218829,
-0.0164762754,
-0.0552288219,
-0.0699757189,
-0.0124949375,
-0.0572670661,
-0.0210237522,
0.0385932401,
-0.001752342,
-0.0323867947,
0.0077112704,
-0.0074943225,
-0.0328436568,
0.0668034628,
0.0349118151,
0.0427333936,
-0.0203090664,
-0.0053477255,
-0.0123010939,
0.0856513456,
0.0147827733,
0.0072246101,
0.0324397832,
0.0129909348,
-0.0191868376,
0.0667809024,
-0.0185644701,
0.007154386,
-0.0467871204,
-0.0151230861,
0.0011020141,
0.0172285493,
0.0364816263,
0.069364354,
-0.0088789463,
-0.0001079569,
0.0822452679,
0.0730094388,
0.0210302714,
-0.0137305334,
0.0710677207,
-0.0040065465,
0.020596467,
0.0520419627,
-0.047285784,
-0.0130706942,
-0.0337643102,
0.0363530219,
0.0431563444,
0.0014003515,
0.002455272,
-0.0346056558,
-0.0201619565,
0.0023086844,
0.0212438293,
0.0100617399,
0.0572700799,
0.02270489,
0.012599756,
0.0142249512,
0.0409292765,
-0.016771581,
-0.0027483096,
-0.0728062838,
0.0435382687,
0.0463466048,
0.0261797495,
0.0073693758,
0.0099500334,
0.0334093086,
-0.0131845688,
0.0641356558,
0.0483176708,
-0.0090959296,
0.0330335796,
0.0052500642,
0.0125313569,
0.0104882289,
0.0357831232,
0.0063389735,
0.0078674024,
0.0052553108,
0.0038263022,
-0.0657432154,
-0.0045070425,
0.0475604422,
-0.0364714377,
-0.0114059662,
-0.0432504192,
-0.0047769602,
0.0084047737,
-0.0130792037,
-0.0159208514,
0.0537036434,
0.0150284413,
-0.0087150093,
0.0054300767,
0.0084567023,
-0.052625224,
0.0147840194,
0.061303474,
0.038024839,
0.0026837485,
-0.0379073322,
0.0413284302,
-0.0149083268,
0.0337551311,
-0.0365697034,
0.0784510896,
-0.0401941687,
0.0323238559,
-0.0457129218,
0.0041120555,
-0.0329590701,
0.0602522008,
-0.0020730356,
0.040552374,
-0.0010704187,
0.0139780371,
0.0044651809,
-0.0667137429,
-0.0605582483,
0.0006462842,
-0.0048303683,
0.0153389769,
0.0414468236,
-0.0149266291,
-0.0608522072,
-0.0252282042,
-0.0893068761,
-0.0137242973,
-0.0046234899,
0.0191532578,
0.0123137366,
-0.0071722646,
-0.0503141284,
0.0102586476,
0.0068277093,
-0.0407159179,
0.0052368166,
0.0683518499,
0.0217059609,
0.0054396745,
-0.0187497921,
-0.0367091782,
-0.010597622,
-0.0250005592,
0.041820582,
0.0197397247,
0.020514315,
-0.0514417477,
0.0452412888,
-0.0605059527,
-0.0055663744,
-0.0042316099,
-0.0290617049,
0.0441346392,
-0.0197503623,
0.0680480227,
0.0212446097,
0.0095750708,
0.0412512608,
0.0732047483,
-0.0432293713,
-0.0459665135,
-0.0372769535,
-0.0301103964,
-0.0440753698,
-0.0451302119,
-0.0537768565,
-0.0309446622,
0.0627584755,
0.0359742865,
0.000905606,
-0.0272298865,
0.0354662798,
-0.0481956676,
-0.0523780398,
-0.0146546029,
0.0045161732,
-0.0339988954,
0.0930444822,
0.00403145,
-0.0856660232,
0.0706990361,
-0.06024836,
-0.0029974899,
-0.0145645859,
-0.015583192,
0.0101478221,
0.0969497561,
0.0129710445,
0.0016587782,
0.0350939259,
-0.0174013618,
-0.0612112731,
0.0038907549,
0.0126242591,
-0.0291439835,
0.0405501649,
-0.085533604,
0.0126541965,
0.0473509729,
-0.0092485603,
-0.0401086286,
-0.0461676754,
-0.052600462,
0.0235036593,
-0.0091972072,
-0.0203204527,
0.01138118,
0.0395202525,
0.0443889573,
-0.0039062584,
-0.0150530608,
-0.0128832972,
-0.0144671574,
0.009107382,
0.0545228161,
0.0188005008,
0.0272174105,
-0.0433679447,
0.0211231634,
0.006354698,
0.0303213727,
0.0452193134,
-0.0498464666,
-0.0042529055,
0.0147036361,
-0.0023078958,
-0.0284309648,
0.0504212566,
0.0156947765,
-0.0357001536,
-0.0006793392,
0.1131539196,
0.0353467539,
-0.0149535546,
0.0146990083,
-0.0166546013,
0.0473271832,
0.0262903702,
0.0163822304,
-0.0776550248,
-0.0151657555,
0.0137162209,
-0.0180873983,
-0.0531410165,
-0.034286648,
-0.0260767452,
-0.1226937994,
0.0171245988,
-0.0304257907,
-0.0378944129,
-0.0082349433,
-0.0282631367,
0.0394329429,
0.022284342,
0.0373958088,
0.0285965875,
-0.03647862,
0.0159993116,
-0.0001203477,
-0.0304197818,
-0.0744404122,
0.0161875263,
-0.0434941277,
0.0500169694,
0.0555546246,
0.0087754074,
-0.0272242613,
-0.0424675494,
0.0173448529,
-0.0183372386,
-0.0031752563,
0.0068848832,
0.000232413,
0.0316485167,
-0.0096252942,
-0.0212853458,
-0.018261319,
0.0154160066,
-0.0093372026,
-0.0093148788,
0.0546647906,
-0.0344604254,
-0.0476524122,
0.0063165324,
0.0217395034,
0.0114008095,
0.0732435063,
0.0500199683,
-0.0437329113,
0.0024412824,
-0.0243289154,
-0.0030105046,
0.0513496026,
-0.0594576783,
0.0141216991,
0.0331222117,
-0.0212477762,
-0.0641010776,
-0.0473056361,
0.022521317,
0.0235998686,
0.0170267057,
0.0130822686,
0.0135901244,
-0.0130901439,
-0.0213786252,
0.0326488949,
-0.0323497131,
0.0029675318,
-0.0611553863,
-0.0099654496,
0.0463379212,
-0.0144483978,
-0.046340324,
0.031653475,
-0.0728993714,
-0.0818364993,
0.0030450064,
0.0161906574,
0.0364529304,
-0.0281738695,
-0.0199156944,
-0.05944971,
0.0407945476,
-0.0096320109,
-0.0458596312,
0.0410083234,
0.011798406,
0.010543948,
0.0061490275,
0.0461283661,
-0.0059797401,
0.0078032035,
0.0001424133,
0.0670633018,
-0.0114708142,
-0.0567672588,
0.0166255459,
0.0341429338,
0.0712621734,
-0.0240382757,
-0.0086930133,
-0.0413137935,
-0.0285504609,
-0.0006242807,
-0.0106736971,
-0.0133287543,
-0.0164339617,
0.0440025032,
0.0262270886,
-0.0352532603,
-0.0435744412,
-0.0280041657,
0.0377104022,
0.0130332587,
-0.0004845864,
0.0435638689,
0.0047238525,
0.0366769694,
-0.0026199101,
0.0020687876,
0.0466731153,
-0.039319437,
0.0388576649,
0.0045862384,
0.0523279682,
0.0021328009,
-0.0224811193,
-0.0098094037,
0.0091570299,
-0.0727764741,
-0.0679165199,
0.0403452851,
0.0579943024,
0.0153039712,
-0.0432720855,
0.0314255506,
-0.0487043113,
0.0213783402,
-0.0390178747,
0.0008900494,
0.0135432482,
-0.0292275697,
0.0605925918,
0.0129763121,
-0.0334749967,
0.0151261231,
0.0589626282,
-0.011045496,
0.0223534536,
-0.0167452656,
-0.0255736355,
-0.0097394977,
-0.0549565107,
0.0045494847,
-0.002904715,
-0.035382811,
0.0137667544,
-0.0925800875,
-0.0736785233,
-0.0221669562,
0.0377258845,
-0.0080138361,
-0.0443497002,
0.0136500234,
0.0813887417,
-0.0196056999,
0.0173144639,
-0.0386126749,
-0.0153381256,
0.004920979,
0.0195344314,
-0.0537567697,
-6.090845652e-33,
-0.0310221538,
-0.030162137,
0.0123238871,
-0.0330247842,
0.0053456058,
-0.0242450982,
-0.0443627052,
0.0545939766,
-0.0127780112,
0.0090487022,
-0.0242357813,
0.0130878789,
0.0250375904,
0.0019608557,
0.0412550829,
-0.0200422853,
-0.0044689868,
-0.001665462,
-0.0265714396,
-0.0416731015,
0.0216187686,
0.0085494881,
0.0404339321,
-0.0308848061,
0.0768876746,
0.02022296,
0.0137176327,
0.0028621685,
-0.0219008699,
0.0441899449,
-0.0436023548,
0.0486080833,
0.0265704673,
-0.0354286954,
-0.0204717219,
0.0188715812,
-0.0181733631,
-0.0391745009,
0.0844909623,
-0.0097475164,
-0.0086652841,
0.0094794864,
0.0083635934,
-0.013452014,
-0.0443615802,
0.0241282973,
0.0232521351,
-0.0297487192,
-0.0006116721,
0.0174079929,
-0.05131777,
0.0134649985,
0.0209414959,
-0.0014005476,
0.0215402246,
-0.0078713996,
-0.0199794713,
-0.0132046249,
0.005267282,
0.0324936919,
0.0101938322,
0.0474892333,
0.0700186267,
0.0458399244,
0.0115958191,
0.0697235912,
0.0028986309,
-0.0139412899,
0.0018459958,
0.0033720576,
0.0813069567,
0.0077708047,
-0.0030230661,
0.0178529639,
-0.0048288121,
0.0207374208,
-0.0065606469,
-0.033110477,
0.041866798,
0.0215569288,
0.0429820269,
-0.0018886215,
-0.0297562424,
-0.0492198914,
-0.0638257042,
-0.039714586,
-0.031455297,
-0.0254722051,
0.0388337448,
-0.0194095355,
0.0111495741,
-0.0270227995,
0.0166110825,
-0.0176769383,
-0.0535961464,
0.0063537112,
-0.0195134021,
0.0254971627,
-0.0139582818,
0.0522845872,
-0.0607453734,
0.0118178008,
-0.0103665208,
0.027828278,
0.0018112668,
0.0138045447,
-0.0295910425,
0.0093453843,
-0.0695550144,
-0.0089931525,
-0.0471319109,
-0.0001107879,
-0.0012878011,
-0.0129277436,
0.0625357032,
0.0082857944,
-0.0189969689,
-0.0126970904,
-0.0125102662,
-0.0101732304,
-0.0412414074,
0.0186760351,
-0.0277026277,
0.0123100234,
-0.0397832468,
-0.0317133553,
-0.0345831513,
0.0535546839,
0.0310491119,
-0.0159432609,
-0.0031643573,
0.0264593605,
2.532e-7,
0.0839639977,
0.0535702072,
-0.0117826099,
0.0485930517,
0.0005274565,
0.0102460813,
-0.0581669323,
-0.0238627493,
0.0602826104,
-0.0217394289,
-0.0108694155,
0.0280218665,
0.0554905869,
0.0347531922,
-0.0732993111,
0.0021423125,
-0.0718932748,
0.0174269881,
-0.0322173126,
0.0069619715,
0.044246085,
0.0826229081,
0.0054037501,
-0.0092059551,
-0.0215867329,
-0.1022604033,
0.0444938913,
-0.0448756702,
-0.0034434639,
0.0195696466,
0.0270474683,
0.0235941466,
0.019854553,
0.0418539643,
0.024724422,
0.0252830274,
-0.0119485473,
0.025443064,
0.0337834992,
0.0124493381,
-0.0190782491,
-0.0009725009,
-0.0048690587,
-0.0646593571,
0.0562922545,
-0.0524134114,
-0.0284836441,
-0.015369135,
0.0400323793,
-0.0203099847,
0.021638399,
-0.032799229,
-0.051203683,
0.017963618,
0.0221891683,
-0.0064022862,
-0.001967506,
-0.0488620996,
-0.0341812856,
0.0030706795,
-0.0290395189,
-0.0975251496,
-0.0355922207,
-0.0087158466,
0.0142407613,
-0.0813310817,
0.0070009981,
2.214972067e-34,
0.0477494746,
0.0237123352,
0.0257192925,
-0.0039279358,
0.0527767204,
-0.0067026867,
0.0586147532,
0.0359387733,
0.0181566607,
-0.1054604277,
-0.0096167158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13256v2 | TaskWeb: Selecting Better Source Tasks for Multi-task NLP | 2023-05-22T17:27:57 | 2023-12-04T04:35:55 | Joongwon Kim, Akari Asai, Gabriel Ilharco, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work in NLP has shown promising results in training models on large
amounts of tasks to achieve better generalization. However, it is not
well-understood how tasks are related, and how helpful training tasks can be
chosen for a new task. In this work, we investigate whether knowing task
relationships via pairwise task transfer improves choosing one or more source
tasks that help to learn a new target task. We provide TaskWeb, a large-scale
benchmark of pairwise task transfers for 22 NLP tasks using three different
model types, sizes, and adaptation methods, spanning about 25,000 experiments.
Then, we design a new method TaskShop based on our analysis of TaskWeb.
TaskShop uses TaskWeb to estimate the benefit of using a source task for
learning a new target task, and to choose a subset of helpful training tasks
for multi-task training. Our method improves overall rankings and top-k
precision of source tasks by 10% and 38%, respectively. We also use TaskShop to
build much smaller multi-task training sets that improve zero-shot performances
across 11 different target tasks by at least 4.3%. | [
0.0112898182,
0.0178442169,
-0.0000296496,
-0.0013714574,
-0.0222466663,
-0.0008284991,
0.0287514124,
-0.0037908582,
-0.0407918878,
-0.0558884777,
-0.07114169,
-0.0077503319,
-0.0356957614,
-0.0109328851,
0.0327338912,
-0.051665999,
0.0457547121,
-0.010068913,
-0.0197378416,
0.0427919216,
-0.0184387118,
0.0203377157,
-0.0400216356,
0.0453577377,
0.0144651551,
-0.0187488534,
0.0105393864,
0.0104274182,
0.0432751216,
-0.0203443319,
0.0177222583,
0.0595385395,
0.0163179375,
-0.0287696775,
0.0000017849,
-0.0428423285,
-0.0300237685,
-0.0199768506,
-0.0389543623,
-0.0328169428,
0.0140018268,
-0.0064242599,
0.0116969142,
0.0030883981,
-0.0305086263,
-0.01778703,
0.0442255996,
0.0800961107,
0.0459029227,
0.0852143317,
-0.01414504,
0.0316228643,
0.0005707062,
-0.0455872267,
0.0417925343,
-0.0558444522,
0.0144386441,
-0.0047635213,
-0.0211276039,
0.0380630605,
-0.0072319875,
-0.0050654276,
-0.0064518382,
0.0039345361,
0.0442041494,
0.0005770469,
-0.0435005538,
-0.0217286833,
-0.0246520191,
0.0851320326,
-0.0556805953,
-0.0073725837,
-0.0102318451,
-0.0023312997,
0.010608769,
0.0189781748,
-0.0743081719,
-0.0172668826,
0.0075443964,
0.0073309252,
0.0000230247,
0.0060445801,
0.0083323177,
0.0048180562,
0.025622949,
0.0285734162,
-0.016979672,
-0.0043771602,
0.0668891668,
0.0428452976,
-0.0419146307,
-0.0265920497,
0.0014348264,
-0.0148351034,
-0.0640902743,
-0.0045463787,
-0.0386570282,
-0.0494634174,
-0.0137707666,
0.0026446613,
0.0978639945,
0.0349189043,
-0.0389396921,
0.0421025604,
-0.0336737186,
0.0350036696,
0.0008899727,
0.0113516469,
-0.0394573547,
-0.0061652497,
-0.1084274948,
0.0355326571,
-0.0119248098,
0.0509124547,
-0.0374265015,
-0.0065459572,
-0.0194506161,
-0.0001717821,
-0.0502908006,
-0.0482718199,
0.0919654891,
0.0337142088,
-0.0830234811,
0.0187256187,
-0.0021528511,
0.0459839441,
-0.0284735579,
0.0614357702,
-0.0008648529,
-0.0088998545,
-0.0591319427,
-0.0067995754,
0.0272542238,
-0.0770208538,
0.0159357935,
0.0555553362,
-0.0306843631,
-0.0325958319,
-0.0173522979,
0.0197164696,
-0.0133437449,
-0.0284876116,
0.0404702984,
-0.0155419204,
0.0473500229,
-0.0238060448,
0.0198966879,
0.0151451128,
-0.001065311,
0.0181582626,
-0.028180236,
0.0850329101,
0.0319999307,
-0.0065729921,
-0.0187710132,
-0.0213229004,
-0.1163743287,
0.0762077346,
-0.0057332902,
0.0165410303,
0.0240498446,
0.0071844221,
-0.0131159341,
-0.0115440534,
0.001139877,
0.0086726118,
0.0389653333,
-0.0121204359,
0.0330261439,
-0.0204470772,
0.0763976946,
-0.0177512486,
-0.0270399153,
0.0211827904,
0.0431851409,
0.0246414077,
0.0270957015,
-0.0139235891,
0.0405679271,
0.0158281103,
-0.0236981064,
0.0061202408,
-0.0702112168,
0.0611997433,
-0.0022968021,
-0.0373851955,
0.0008783307,
0.0452898368,
-0.0287955292,
0.0033772124,
0.0197607279,
-0.0105192913,
0.0145361284,
-0.0124382079,
0.0678776577,
0.0431064218,
-0.0274692699,
0.0392707027,
0.0478765108,
-0.0284784827,
0.0044088173,
-0.0284372233,
-0.0095824143,
0.0372631326,
-0.0108738784,
-0.045195993,
-0.0506041646,
-0.0141446758,
0.0220227502,
-0.0185176432,
0.017737912,
-0.0343363993,
0.0650453717,
-0.0292564351,
-0.0206165444,
-0.039175313,
0.0197102819,
-0.0134227145,
0.0099575752,
-0.0082018804,
0.0067242063,
-0.0353931896,
-0.000504587,
0.0292604752,
-0.0179048758,
-0.0134144863,
0.0403175801,
0.0061152931,
0.0147883855,
-0.0042657228,
-0.0015605616,
0.004605317,
0.0086149918,
-0.0386833027,
-0.0221265145,
0.018524114,
-0.0240286384,
-0.0447979979,
0.0175592862,
-0.0250685476,
0.0175059997,
0.0782892704,
-0.0522164814,
-0.0242907163,
0.0203202702,
0.0083465911,
-0.0129222469,
0.0330668315,
0.0034367214,
0.0150135858,
0.0054931617,
-0.0341275111,
0.0442954972,
0.0474537015,
-0.0255378801,
-0.0018063155,
-0.0403398164,
-0.0372019261,
-0.0303774215,
0.0214119293,
0.0132120373,
-0.0256070122,
-0.009250938,
0.0057454342,
0.0271834787,
-0.074422732,
0.0017564788,
-0.0985053629,
0.0583809167,
-0.0150874164,
0.0322570987,
0.0496512838,
-0.0085680857,
0.028262848,
-0.0233219359,
-0.0274493992,
0.0039144843,
-0.040529985,
0.0107068857,
0.0100426814,
0.0018097928,
0.0518996976,
-0.0462970026,
-0.0215166509,
-0.0159753468,
0.0419785231,
-0.0259581674,
-0.0157969333,
-0.0329778306,
0.0647779331,
0.0062258542,
0.0051785633,
0.0048244623,
0.008290994,
-0.0293156449,
-0.0130395247,
0.0302692167,
0.0594996139,
-0.0429105684,
0.0213000067,
0.0387674905,
-0.0170043372,
-0.0419740342,
0.0308027137,
0.0001396452,
-0.0163219608,
-0.015913412,
-0.0248968396,
0.0053914269,
0.0629142448,
-0.0107007306,
-0.0340777077,
-0.054830052,
0.0203683991,
-0.0320475176,
-0.0015534759,
-0.0341577865,
0.0305553004,
-0.0129805803,
-0.0207453035,
-0.0499015376,
-0.0072567002,
0.0330089293,
0.0320331641,
0.0036404275,
-0.0826452374,
-0.0020458498,
-0.0225765817,
0.0604681075,
-0.0191319212,
0.0017451242,
0.0472930819,
-0.0050844303,
-0.0585709102,
0.0332727991,
0.0246769413,
0.0031597035,
0.0445689447,
-0.0488808043,
0.0075778924,
-0.0376138315,
-0.0574771613,
-0.0103257354,
-0.0009186459,
0.0089662494,
0.0295863897,
0.0022318135,
0.0001370287,
-0.0397245213,
-0.0497516245,
0.0324283578,
0.0461473837,
-0.0175582208,
-0.0163652804,
-0.0189988874,
0.0332068838,
0.0455180295,
0.0433743894,
-0.0190382581,
-0.0120137492,
-0.0147633487,
0.0413784161,
0.0974418744,
0.0073089735,
0.0048705023,
0.0026981318,
0.0358587652,
-0.0377036706,
-0.045691099,
0.0047732531,
0.0848791972,
-0.0349784866,
0.0126607539,
0.0635060593,
0.0166442487,
-0.0318022855,
0.0172856823,
0.0117121553,
-0.0405731313,
0.0249696132,
0.0257769674,
-0.04874501,
-0.0610832088,
0.0064485287,
0.0105913933,
0.0194282234,
-0.0500234924,
-0.007637728,
-0.1161634177,
0.006410148,
-0.0078603867,
-0.0282990206,
0.030922113,
-0.0553271547,
0.044139348,
-0.064246051,
0.0036237629,
-0.0274579916,
-0.0070036338,
0.0014409103,
0.0487906784,
0.0171869528,
-0.0559619144,
0.0502601303,
-0.0628228039,
0.0318483673,
0.0371695124,
0.0246214718,
-0.0080141146,
0.0208761673,
-0.0007733061,
0.020082267,
0.0130959954,
-0.0081807841,
0.0946581885,
-0.0078705205,
-0.0080659008,
0.0126748718,
0.0122193415,
-0.061452087,
-0.0229899045,
0.0251029674,
0.0824330673,
0.0234053154,
-0.0211627949,
0.0017248151,
-0.0430757292,
0.0228483435,
0.055893667,
-0.0137516288,
-0.0539802611,
0.0015459087,
-0.0078392746,
-0.0470181964,
-0.0855197906,
-0.0187800936,
0.0105197607,
-0.0306245554,
0.0050390395,
-0.1059765965,
-0.030079538,
0.0737682134,
0.0364493579,
0.0109670963,
0.0103381835,
0.0110802809,
0.0098092649,
-0.0601211973,
0.040539477,
-0.0039428668,
0.0044944957,
-0.0095387045,
-0.0322826505,
0.0476249047,
0.0136663849,
-0.0012456148,
-0.0026463827,
-0.1001357734,
-0.0215379838,
-0.0480184667,
0.0653168857,
0.0135839898,
0.0051332135,
-0.0186665598,
-0.0343122371,
-0.0493954867,
0.0015847705,
-0.0665602311,
0.0177538991,
0.0489937067,
-0.0344232097,
-0.006663464,
0.029150093,
-0.0428197384,
0.0431566834,
0.0125523694,
0.0390439481,
0.0266952962,
0.0468264222,
0.0008218432,
-0.0013415623,
0.0750280693,
0.0233138539,
-0.0144331409,
-0.0379207879,
-0.01354999,
-0.0061340854,
-0.0128540397,
-0.0605781451,
0.036902871,
0.0239294041,
0.0106191849,
0.0058063935,
0.0256887153,
0.0086283656,
0.0158990454,
-0.0929313004,
-0.0116455201,
0.0078041954,
-0.0145050157,
-0.0075637395,
0.039942842,
-0.0167089384,
-0.0418191068,
0.062669456,
0.0228948649,
-0.0156042678,
0.0140782632,
0.0287851747,
-0.0008168394,
-0.0034508447,
0.0391550809,
-0.0664261132,
-0.0162845422,
-0.0210950114,
-0.024982715,
0.0545615032,
-0.0370405167,
0.0960592255,
0.0375244878,
-0.0042745769,
-0.027795691,
0.0427843444,
0.0039303396,
0.0405639149,
-0.0246090833,
0.0212045703,
0.0127878813,
0.0038708088,
0.0913369581,
-0.0231194757,
0.0426062159,
0.0130864745,
-0.0027738847,
-0.0344154835,
-0.0263620764,
-0.0033821205,
0.0021261983,
0.0118300728,
0.0272865593,
-0.0044816355,
-0.0382707529,
0.0260199253,
-0.0767819062,
0.0079239402,
-0.0160421655,
0.0471539274,
0.0412828848,
-0.0200313665,
-0.0277097877,
-0.0243906938,
-0.0626571849,
0.0132900793,
0.0140515063,
-0.0214184094,
-5.693751538e-33,
-0.0285477731,
0.0026955884,
0.0012456946,
-0.0127234515,
0.0018892551,
0.0156773236,
-0.0205097869,
-0.0050227568,
-0.0261191465,
0.0103891296,
-0.0155849708,
-0.0086393151,
0.029211117,
0.0105360514,
0.0454749204,
-0.0107279895,
0.0608230121,
-0.0093573732,
-0.0254078414,
0.0142105632,
0.060089346,
0.0437072404,
0.0916393772,
-0.0425202772,
0.0177854486,
0.0691128448,
-0.0036915177,
-0.0149770472,
0.0293657873,
0.0459511131,
0.0172057468,
0.0596495457,
0.0429072268,
-0.1043847576,
-0.0167284105,
-0.0014413295,
-0.068179585,
-0.0468394682,
0.008569628,
-0.021592889,
-0.0477678664,
-0.0172525644,
-0.0002388692,
0.0312020537,
0.018621508,
-0.0526819266,
0.0243262053,
-0.0466289334,
-0.0117988149,
-0.0014279571,
-0.0700761899,
-0.0222840346,
-0.0025039304,
-0.0314167552,
0.0282625873,
0.0644797161,
-0.0247198585,
-0.033006683,
-0.0378627256,
-0.0052000103,
-0.0317605361,
0.0467764772,
0.0103361486,
0.0061445734,
-0.0211458895,
0.0586759448,
-0.0004001022,
0.0097495243,
0.0249162149,
-0.0292277616,
0.0127947163,
0.084253408,
0.0297803991,
0.0077894586,
0.0352111384,
0.0233530588,
-0.0688963309,
0.0263007134,
0.0634305775,
0.0250750445,
-0.0000588575,
0.0358332582,
0.0004991736,
-0.0157099087,
-0.0192527287,
0.0184354782,
-0.0200429261,
-0.0285139754,
0.0458727144,
0.0322612673,
0.0030334147,
0.0473374613,
0.0263710264,
-0.0382677615,
0.0192314591,
0.0130831506,
-0.045816835,
0.0150944283,
0.0143607426,
-0.0342195816,
-0.0697774664,
-0.0383673757,
0.044310648,
0.0368808471,
0.0340055265,
0.0003188125,
0.068607606,
-0.0127404481,
-0.0413293354,
-0.0090307845,
-0.0446847565,
0.0264238771,
0.0175478496,
0.076720804,
0.017274417,
0.0091797952,
-0.0299459286,
0.0617891103,
0.0416657887,
-0.0411346927,
-0.021207992,
0.0207679607,
0.0102297571,
-0.0118607013,
0.0002078323,
-0.0111723114,
-0.018357873,
-0.0321298204,
0.0072733462,
-0.0436173454,
-0.0593913235,
-0.0170860365,
2.49e-7,
0.0090925982,
0.0481545515,
-0.0290102195,
0.0161834825,
-0.0003077622,
0.0427624099,
-0.0221352559,
0.0649382472,
0.0120123867,
-0.018821368,
-0.0402647443,
0.0255644694,
0.0401196666,
0.0303796325,
-0.0561890826,
-0.0507784784,
-0.0199242216,
0.0197991561,
-0.0170250144,
-0.0227609184,
0.0122848768,
0.0580961183,
0.0238454584,
0.0067242202,
0.0233290754,
0.0095495777,
0.0520222969,
-0.0372993946,
0.0011156863,
0.0060656499,
-0.0269079115,
-0.0138911568,
-0.0300244391,
0.052981969,
-0.0495590605,
0.0113703078,
0.0434983037,
0.0622366555,
-0.0217670389,
-0.0297615305,
-0.0067312289,
0.0362984389,
0.0177861582,
-0.001061518,
0.0900065377,
-0.0808864087,
-0.0375402756,
0.0064810258,
-0.0161170363,
0.0428741351,
-0.0295669828,
-0.0081506455,
0.0149023486,
-0.0054488559,
0.0143945906,
0.0350217558,
-0.0615882874,
-0.067045778,
-0.0302112419,
0.0532040149,
-0.0195171945,
-0.0369412452,
-0.0068997969,
-0.0597907305,
-0.0026106481,
-0.0811011046,
-0.0095460862,
1.874910734e-34,
-0.0116952285,
0.0329973064,
0.0568891987,
0.0266410224,
-0.0022067262,
-0.0173393153,
-0.0873009637,
-0.0213604122,
0.0169830006,
-0.0276910756,
-0.0222937204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13252v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13252v2 | "According to ...": Prompting Language Models Improves Quoting from Pre-Training Data | 2023-05-22T17:25:24 | 2024-02-26T20:50:33 | Orion Weller, Marc Marone, Nathaniel Weir, Dawn Lawrie, Daniel Khashabi, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) may hallucinate and generate fake information,
despite pre-training on factual data. Inspired by the journalistic device of
"according to sources", we propose according-to prompting: directing LLMs to
ground responses against previously observed text. To quantify this grounding,
we propose a novel evaluation metric (QUIP-Score) that measures the extent to
which model-produced answers are directly found in underlying text corpora. We
illustrate with experiments on three corpora (Wikipedia, PubMed, and the U.S.
legal tax code) that these prompts improve grounding under our metrics, with
the additional benefit of often improving end-task performance. Furthermore,
prompts that ask the model to decrease grounding (or to ground to other
corpora) indeed decrease QUIP-Score, indicating the ability of LLMs to increase
or decrease grounded generations on request. | [
0.045245856,
0.0893876925,
-0.0056978841,
0.0160364974,
-0.0383038484,
0.0248587728,
-0.0098568359,
0.006869833,
-0.0049789301,
-0.0733323172,
-0.0247149933,
0.0086831832,
-0.016831385,
-0.0061045773,
0.0239075739,
-0.0102166953,
0.0631613284,
-0.018276345,
0.0014721353,
-0.0260943528,
-0.0116074141,
0.0167509653,
-0.0038519516,
0.025067281,
-0.0028047827,
-0.0318263099,
0.0186752602,
-0.0068869065,
0.007796925,
-0.005814834,
0.0232710578,
0.0705437809,
-0.0092157703,
0.056522198,
0.0000017582,
-0.0642474368,
0.0073149758,
0.0086225141,
-0.0734008774,
0.0236423034,
0.023833679,
-0.0115743298,
0.0034451361,
0.013765092,
-0.0722016394,
-0.0248898305,
0.0152378986,
0.0430901423,
0.0609253123,
0.0681960136,
0.0128205586,
-0.0276145227,
0.0320931301,
-0.0194477271,
0.0357541591,
-0.016990548,
0.0304233078,
0.0348073207,
-0.035146635,
0.0322518833,
0.0017825204,
0.0429718308,
0.0427136868,
-0.0308027845,
0.0328805074,
0.031895496,
-0.057026621,
0.0029235212,
-0.0028575412,
0.0677689016,
0.0304210708,
-0.0642797276,
-0.0118957944,
0.009581795,
0.0186518729,
0.0344472788,
-0.0514686741,
0.0231512729,
-0.0065229884,
0.0210619159,
0.036440704,
-0.0270081069,
0.041149538,
0.032638967,
-0.0028328954,
0.0883901194,
0.0222403593,
-0.0297766458,
0.0704675838,
0.0488080569,
0.0026536945,
-0.0791825503,
-0.0128626311,
0.0134426281,
-0.0334660225,
0.0185908619,
-0.0318609215,
-0.0006084369,
0.0542141311,
-0.0414430946,
0.0146671236,
0.0299453605,
-0.0410574488,
0.0372062698,
-0.0468650199,
0.0171365533,
-0.0303680189,
0.0441114604,
-0.0320570469,
0.004477981,
-0.0576878451,
-0.0191214643,
-0.0083970968,
0.0168657359,
-0.042327106,
0.0041107801,
-0.0119461436,
0.0208074562,
-0.0177016705,
0.0062500122,
-0.0198216494,
0.0295725688,
-0.0272343233,
0.0080534741,
-0.0475216061,
0.0207414404,
-0.0241156872,
0.0445339717,
0.0009056848,
-0.0707834363,
-0.0376294814,
0.0062996284,
-0.0241267718,
-0.0108073214,
0.0260597896,
0.0548365377,
0.0069196112,
-0.010350544,
-0.0454256572,
-0.0221244991,
0.0035279319,
-0.0658995137,
0.0223515537,
-0.0553451516,
0.0169284921,
0.018341653,
-0.0192309525,
-0.042038057,
0.0053322068,
0.0398898125,
-0.0593492128,
0.0550829768,
-0.0302925538,
0.0086553264,
0.0085530793,
0.0086006857,
-0.0157286935,
0.094259657,
0.018851148,
-0.0291489512,
0.0449482985,
0.0113995951,
-0.0031914874,
0.0062660151,
0.0710315257,
0.0573142916,
-0.0114999339,
0.0199736413,
0.0148799252,
-0.0006515138,
0.0424443893,
0.038981311,
-0.0210122801,
-0.0067456602,
0.0854857862,
0.0502680279,
-0.0452878661,
-0.004462711,
0.0399665385,
-0.0375881493,
0.0037801901,
0.0480445623,
-0.0775070935,
0.0006777316,
-0.0509022847,
0.0097228056,
-0.0003507158,
0.0252005234,
-0.0304055642,
-0.0179748144,
0.0014875997,
-0.0027842447,
0.0062062857,
0.0253495481,
0.0017634683,
0.0396640189,
0.0027417305,
0.0799534991,
0.0470201448,
-0.0320299864,
0.0232572351,
-0.0588930696,
0.0208335314,
0.0238095708,
0.0269278903,
0.0114992,
-0.0197238419,
-0.0412723534,
0.0367176123,
0.0670048818,
0.0309923179,
-0.04633509,
0.0284140687,
0.0070730434,
-0.0367142633,
-0.035063602,
0.0299571659,
-0.004144087,
0.0313393734,
-0.0054073911,
0.0203788001,
-0.0611135699,
-0.0312391538,
0.0707943812,
-0.0629166439,
-0.0186286531,
-0.022309782,
-0.0065877195,
0.0233296733,
0.0175683852,
0.0011033985,
0.0192733221,
0.0383554026,
-0.0107294209,
-0.0088748382,
0.0100947637,
-0.0110381888,
-0.0146412682,
0.0402500927,
-0.0115007199,
-0.0189688057,
0.0063644098,
-0.0339627825,
-0.0245368555,
-0.0122669581,
-0.0195524488,
0.0577353723,
-0.0359188393,
-0.0088616516,
-0.0246580783,
-0.0056412988,
-0.0348891877,
0.0652674288,
-0.0137736574,
0.0321316831,
0.0483999364,
0.0021488771,
0.0156882051,
-0.0089838728,
-0.0096251927,
-0.0117440596,
0.0232218113,
0.0007799253,
0.0346850976,
0.0070554027,
-0.0708863437,
0.0096269203,
-0.0807103738,
-0.0010059862,
-0.0442117602,
0.0115243392,
0.0390079133,
-0.023190394,
-0.0213140957,
-0.0317512304,
-0.0463075601,
-0.045423802,
0.0384912156,
0.0398930684,
0.0205462109,
0.009210051,
0.0344211496,
-0.0312830918,
0.0014944973,
-0.0217349119,
0.0526575744,
0.0193407051,
0.0058488226,
-0.0969229788,
0.0397581048,
-0.0466602892,
0.0068129678,
-0.0034216957,
-0.0024577933,
0.0184002928,
0.0282187201,
0.014382787,
0.1023686826,
0.0155015215,
-0.0089461459,
0.0544643588,
0.0242471434,
-0.0803831443,
-0.0104228733,
-0.0327995084,
-0.0212028585,
-0.0456216708,
-0.0364351422,
0.0158351567,
0.0248796213,
0.0043313252,
-0.0206309352,
-0.0499316528,
0.068945013,
-0.0246917848,
-0.040452268,
0.0016495705,
-0.0101764537,
-0.0184321869,
0.0649126247,
-0.0191032663,
-0.0592321418,
0.0781064555,
-0.0278265104,
0.0163737722,
-0.0463264771,
0.0273866188,
-0.0058459095,
0.0283187814,
-0.012328105,
0.0010053708,
0.0175852738,
-0.0061752433,
-0.0521631055,
-0.0046073417,
0.0192728117,
-0.0315110199,
0.0694659576,
-0.04256602,
0.0194821376,
0.0170998201,
-0.0367403217,
-0.0754487887,
-0.0528794192,
0.0001594638,
0.0145164412,
-0.0243367795,
0.005153643,
-0.0199458711,
-0.0314149596,
0.0468775891,
0.0348961242,
-0.0308578946,
-0.0102728559,
-0.0074575469,
0.0073468275,
0.0785876662,
0.006599878,
0.0605259724,
-0.0194704998,
0.0172533207,
0.0576160215,
0.0506701805,
0.021825105,
-0.0083105527,
-0.003517417,
0.0085481005,
-0.024020765,
-0.0170738958,
-0.0000277236,
0.0391421057,
-0.023201989,
-0.035071604,
0.0961258486,
0.0270147081,
-0.0406875946,
-0.0007772346,
-0.016232878,
0.0620917976,
0.0349807553,
0.0216034763,
-0.090423122,
0.0039294539,
-0.0038806784,
0.0328630246,
-0.0061093993,
-0.0533115827,
-0.0095186913,
-0.138221547,
0.0186048187,
-0.0117749823,
-0.0148504237,
-0.0343818553,
-0.0696807355,
0.0256549139,
0.002530745,
0.0194860157,
0.0036547268,
0.0012729578,
0.0147784641,
0.0374045447,
0.0223748479,
-0.0840042904,
0.0085312901,
-0.0196289681,
0.060601376,
0.0686280057,
0.0127318231,
0.000229064,
-0.0487521589,
-0.0152120274,
-0.0339678302,
-0.0331669152,
-0.0261320099,
0.072867088,
-0.0031372493,
0.0015066245,
-0.0115865702,
0.0316299275,
-0.0145238815,
0.0001804319,
-0.0099612279,
0.0615873709,
-0.0154952174,
-0.0016948454,
-0.0097970162,
0.0206412617,
0.031823419,
0.08185862,
0.044523757,
-0.0228778906,
-0.0054837917,
-0.0492906943,
-0.002619718,
-0.0547379106,
-0.0442269519,
0.0429037809,
-0.0155099379,
0.0040187133,
-0.0939323753,
-0.0481051132,
-0.0041104481,
0.0210580211,
0.0297747497,
0.0250781644,
0.0017330354,
-0.0282695759,
-0.0006572133,
0.0221558362,
-0.0429272503,
-0.0227601975,
-0.0399003178,
-0.0330592543,
0.0415003859,
0.0175916106,
-0.0235575624,
0.0045310268,
-0.0698691383,
-0.0758488849,
0.0183903296,
0.0543689877,
0.0350734964,
0.055620417,
-0.0192141887,
-0.0149775036,
0.0434908308,
0.0182082914,
-0.0609051324,
0.0374033041,
0.0326909013,
-0.014758205,
0.003718866,
0.0435007513,
-0.040719863,
0.0092531266,
0.0442447886,
0.0261118971,
-0.0299043804,
-0.0174183045,
0.0350991637,
0.0208691172,
0.0394731686,
-0.0187947471,
0.0215448979,
-0.0191934966,
0.0115806824,
-0.0176069327,
-0.0173412468,
-0.0254683401,
0.0117190434,
0.0241652727,
-0.0113383178,
0.0012522292,
0.0207431614,
-0.0340472795,
0.0634783804,
-0.0444460623,
-0.0310903415,
0.0111228935,
0.0254938919,
0.012052672,
0.0004504333,
-0.0301172324,
-0.0039819428,
0.008775793,
0.058655329,
-0.0208051708,
0.0444601104,
0.0507896394,
-0.0099727046,
0.0186172519,
0.0069656936,
-0.1153149307,
-0.0310624205,
-0.0066537829,
0.0033365407,
0.0313941538,
-0.0245429054,
0.0645325258,
-0.0126661817,
-0.0243858472,
-0.0029601716,
-0.0007833391,
0.0346153006,
-0.0211206153,
0.0317705274,
-0.0053192456,
-0.0222860835,
0.0293749738,
0.0634722337,
0.0267098509,
0.0775328428,
-0.002902264,
-0.0213059969,
-0.0331577472,
-0.0535422415,
-0.0213620383,
-0.0290510245,
-0.0276732966,
0.0272157062,
-0.0754563659,
-0.0884068757,
0.0042950734,
0.0134789534,
-0.0016581288,
-0.0149197932,
0.0222978983,
0.0839508548,
0.0035940856,
-0.0291388892,
-0.0540730618,
0.0403607413,
0.0078343926,
-0.0039418475,
-0.0479812846,
-6.382265028e-33,
-0.0386009552,
-0.0361620821,
0.009166074,
-0.0030922256,
-0.0282584243,
0.0067156064,
-0.0317947865,
-0.0031212589,
-0.0580398925,
0.0232723132,
-0.024555482,
0.0356634744,
0.0070034168,
-0.0025196003,
0.013146623,
-0.0427807085,
0.0386000238,
-0.0423791818,
-0.0399059951,
0.0244257674,
0.0155094862,
0.0137865348,
0.0775317028,
-0.0533724651,
0.0790288597,
-0.0161726084,
0.0097083002,
0.012283843,
-0.0464448519,
0.0482519269,
-0.0257697981,
0.047463309,
0.0223529804,
-0.0441632681,
-0.008852683,
0.0269597955,
-0.0736965537,
-0.0327513292,
0.0562320761,
-0.0051732371,
-0.0095586833,
-0.0019765045,
0.0303212386,
-0.0125247631,
-0.0195715241,
-0.0127767911,
0.0229564905,
-0.0443103909,
-0.024018418,
-0.0006987057,
-0.0550916754,
0.0021086235,
0.0160266031,
-0.001779423,
-0.0172809307,
0.0541619286,
0.0024866303,
0.0165039264,
-0.0428109244,
0.0046075969,
0.0019187932,
0.0172984879,
0.0352426842,
-0.0280814841,
0.0072816228,
0.0696551502,
-0.0104232673,
-0.0020387182,
-0.036650572,
-0.0318137556,
0.0548225157,
0.0059349425,
0.0520611852,
0.0530862808,
-0.0051188804,
-0.0048282109,
-0.1020992026,
0.0072223986,
0.0303019211,
0.0211988278,
0.0143651636,
-0.0272343364,
0.0049787685,
-0.0222629942,
-0.0472415537,
-0.0433776192,
-0.0132083297,
-0.0342432968,
0.0146613736,
-0.0041276179,
-0.0320013538,
0.0035973883,
0.0249246098,
-0.0384672247,
-0.0247787647,
0.0521625876,
-0.0208531767,
-0.0028879873,
0.0071961037,
0.0199207515,
-0.0756501332,
0.0227255318,
0.0158022866,
0.014719883,
0.0357959233,
0.0024681375,
0.0468913466,
-0.0178302526,
-0.0669943467,
0.015744321,
-0.0315793119,
0.0537332073,
0.0230681375,
0.0103997998,
0.0440292023,
0.0169495605,
0.0131819583,
0.0191145912,
0.0266388115,
-0.0089008296,
-0.0556294397,
-0.0060730097,
0.0021447323,
0.0428098589,
-0.0393472426,
-0.0169888064,
-0.0212363862,
0.0699496046,
-0.01808336,
-0.0659678727,
-0.0172566213,
0.008509215,
2.517e-7,
0.0646368861,
0.0489463918,
-0.0022042592,
0.0025695798,
0.005432663,
0.0159464628,
-0.0203416944,
0.0090979803,
0.041169107,
-0.076548472,
-0.0443197004,
-0.0020161222,
0.0382130519,
0.0403271876,
-0.0979059488,
-0.0161182303,
-0.0918880925,
-0.0092611108,
-0.0296012759,
-0.0251444373,
0.0008680128,
0.0596289933,
0.0018076788,
-0.0051832208,
-0.0051186834,
-0.0419158675,
0.0760710314,
-0.0139714582,
-0.0234430283,
0.0148140285,
0.041747421,
-0.0132562313,
0.0106931049,
0.0600439198,
-0.0235470217,
0.0206911396,
-0.0264342576,
0.0316103026,
0.0084747626,
-0.0419939719,
-0.0496844426,
-0.0339770652,
0.0304870345,
-0.0792151541,
0.0657803267,
-0.001425611,
-0.01590004,
-0.0451703891,
-0.0390238874,
-0.0171601456,
0.0349876545,
-0.0254360288,
-0.0497764535,
0.0205157623,
0.0051437756,
0.030151464,
-0.0043606749,
-0.0724038035,
-0.0321946107,
0.0015050225,
-0.0224898923,
-0.0712532103,
0.0090118553,
-0.0244692434,
0.0009179332,
-0.0450756922,
0.029714413,
2.532765587e-34,
0.0285627414,
0.0062597785,
0.041716069,
0.0277982596,
0.0257024523,
0.0068425625,
0.0358825028,
-0.0118316254,
0.0192861091,
-0.0587114953,
0.0015737775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13246v1 | Interactive Natural Language Processing | 2023-05-22T17:18:29 | 2023-05-22T17:18:29 | Zekun Wang, Ge Zhang, Kexin Yang, Ning Shi, Wangchunshu Zhou, Shaochun Hao, Guangzheng Xiong, Yizhi Li, Mong Yuan Sim, Xiuying Chen, Qingqing Zhu, Zhenzhu Yang, Adam Nik, Qi Liu, Chenghua Lin, Shi Wang, Ruibo Liu, Wenhu Chen, Ke Xu, Dayiheng Liu, Yike Guo, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Interactive Natural Language Processing (iNLP) has emerged as a novel
paradigm within the field of NLP, aimed at addressing limitations in existing
frameworks while aligning with the ultimate goals of artificial intelligence.
This paradigm considers language models as agents capable of observing, acting,
and receiving feedback iteratively from external entities. Specifically,
language models in this context can: (1) interact with humans for better
understanding and addressing user needs, personalizing responses, aligning with
human values, and improving the overall user experience; (2) interact with
knowledge bases for enriching language representations with factual knowledge,
enhancing the contextual relevance of responses, and dynamically leveraging
external information to generate more accurate and informed responses; (3)
interact with models and tools for effectively decomposing and addressing
complex tasks, leveraging specialized expertise for specific subtasks, and
fostering the simulation of social behaviors; and (4) interact with
environments for learning grounded representations of language, and effectively
tackling embodied tasks such as reasoning, planning, and decision-making in
response to environmental observations. This paper offers a comprehensive
survey of iNLP, starting by proposing a unified definition and framework of the
concept. We then provide a systematic classification of iNLP, dissecting its
various components, including interactive objects, interaction interfaces, and
interaction methods. We proceed to delve into the evaluation methodologies used
in the field, explore its diverse applications, scrutinize its ethical and
safety issues, and discuss prospective research directions. This survey serves
as an entry point for researchers who are interested in this rapidly evolving
area and offers a broad view of the current landscape and future trajectory of
iNLP. | [
0.0676558018,
-0.0036276658,
-0.0356547907,
0.012904712,
-0.0562023595,
0.009972021,
-0.0128491549,
0.0143560003,
0.070102796,
-0.065079622,
-0.0386492275,
0.0289946012,
0.023156533,
0.059066087,
-0.0088086603,
-0.1055026725,
0.0215195753,
0.0048513329,
0.0337803066,
0.0456737168,
0.0190977044,
0.0314875245,
-0.0407732464,
0.0536311977,
-0.0240326803,
-0.0005450719,
-0.0174073819,
-0.0266060513,
-0.0073047848,
-0.0483321846,
-0.0217921026,
0.0255720802,
0.0375265107,
0.0205888208,
0.0000023628,
-0.0519661307,
0.0239824671,
0.0012332116,
-0.0259024519,
-0.0375018977,
0.0651190728,
0.0238716919,
-0.0029398804,
-0.0094468473,
-0.0578501597,
0.0034316657,
0.0488333888,
0.0393106043,
0.0780021325,
-0.0069689662,
-0.0112970276,
0.005278409,
-0.0315109156,
0.0357625857,
-0.011319818,
0.0094070816,
0.0141600939,
-0.0213825237,
0.0449530147,
0.0026407791,
0.0215905514,
0.0129897231,
0.0269676261,
-0.0423609465,
0.0539286509,
0.0209469516,
-0.0071488172,
-0.0678907931,
-0.0420371257,
0.0517651513,
-0.0132092051,
-0.0044465587,
-0.0182748567,
-0.0110058021,
0.0157189555,
0.0302577447,
-0.0201342329,
-0.0036948461,
-0.0152122416,
0.0066730063,
-0.0400412343,
0.0485145673,
0.009858869,
0.033057373,
0.0341676734,
0.0568206534,
0.0008535202,
-0.0329828337,
0.0278016627,
0.0104236044,
-0.0003507686,
-0.0511654168,
0.0210307427,
0.0418019369,
-0.0534435883,
0.064886272,
-0.0322827995,
0.0016917307,
0.0452375226,
-0.0823428929,
0.0469409861,
0.0147034749,
0.0217294805,
0.0429599211,
0.0033035618,
0.032487344,
0.0015901183,
-0.0179825649,
0.017325798,
0.0256010145,
-0.0500863381,
-0.0261094198,
-0.0049951351,
0.0384557545,
-0.0688949376,
-0.0254821517,
0.0077119335,
0.0445867516,
-0.0265444517,
0.0394377187,
-0.0158326253,
0.0496773906,
0.0019396245,
0.0385969467,
-0.102807343,
-0.011612637,
-0.0519375764,
0.005770619,
-0.0365776196,
-0.0565615222,
0.0451456867,
-0.0061673531,
0.0183816366,
0.0061510121,
-0.0291407444,
0.0847665146,
-0.000871955,
-0.0200067814,
-0.011186243,
-0.0519677699,
0.0219903272,
-0.0321470574,
-0.020616876,
-0.0494759195,
0.032021042,
-0.0121927373,
-0.0313348509,
-0.0532241389,
0.0100963442,
0.0541028492,
-0.0020241344,
0.0991557539,
-0.0494045466,
-0.0310940444,
0.0280134398,
0.0120765502,
0.0421565995,
0.0268778224,
0.0253881793,
-0.0033378219,
0.0222361106,
0.0082449382,
-0.0027044881,
0.0178586785,
-0.0320428647,
-0.0372676328,
-0.0160346106,
0.0030152032,
-0.0380163565,
0.029179357,
-0.0379900336,
0.0342792124,
-0.0322305225,
0.0102885272,
0.040963538,
0.0749257207,
-0.0136732832,
0.011283813,
0.0343301222,
0.0358734056,
0.0225531869,
0.0050546955,
-0.0123536885,
0.0315114371,
-0.0169996917,
-0.0292928591,
-0.0223721936,
0.0137310829,
0.023870755,
-0.1009551585,
-0.0216288418,
0.0157500692,
0.0782878995,
0.0158918928,
0.0184476878,
0.0167373065,
-0.0079723243,
-0.0283251461,
0.0377186239,
-0.0184532069,
0.0039959233,
-0.042682156,
-0.0029807219,
0.1203435287,
0.0615014136,
-0.030334143,
-0.0034041959,
-0.0050043049,
-0.0522877388,
0.0736780539,
-0.0079855546,
-0.039159175,
-0.0405147038,
0.0114023779,
-0.0322977528,
0.001937769,
0.0031636604,
0.0455221236,
0.0196342375,
-0.0059157996,
-0.0092005348,
0.0393398181,
-0.0090938201,
0.0451027378,
0.0002800599,
-0.030111732,
-0.0273276754,
0.0130602131,
0.0219476726,
0.0369003229,
0.01595979,
-0.001921806,
0.0152185028,
0.0274644997,
-0.0188063383,
0.0336294435,
-0.0053074132,
-0.009280026,
0.0187648814,
-0.0229521971,
-0.0003884367,
-0.0008186175,
0.0150047112,
-0.0197457243,
0.0190689936,
-0.0585714765,
0.0467425473,
-0.0410102941,
-0.0116939852,
-0.01904702,
-0.0166909918,
-0.0659059733,
0.0554243289,
0.000957243,
0.0042057284,
0.0268730838,
0.0123560801,
0.0015316575,
-0.0140413921,
-0.0319231115,
0.0146331443,
0.0222757217,
-0.0074632517,
0.0409851968,
0.0259311907,
-0.0517030172,
-0.0077747721,
-0.0763359293,
-0.0325542279,
-0.0074642315,
-0.0034809455,
0.0272124298,
0.0082296059,
-0.0203770623,
-0.0605977289,
-0.0005211528,
-0.0174831767,
0.0210236609,
-0.0118047474,
0.0510434657,
0.0165104419,
0.0107458886,
-0.0425821804,
-0.0009383591,
-0.002702856,
0.0305153877,
0.0777128339,
-0.0557506904,
-0.0554828346,
-0.0426072814,
-0.0526973791,
0.042413637,
0.0223607812,
-0.0038032639,
0.0613185167,
0.0114951273,
0.0113940239,
0.0369454138,
0.002804718,
0.0822950825,
0.0314639546,
-0.0190228168,
-0.0694166794,
0.0175317079,
-0.0328943729,
0.0415648893,
-0.0266929623,
-0.0066073979,
0.0421776623,
0.0528436601,
0.0300536919,
0.0128926989,
-0.039812319,
0.0432058498,
-0.0375569649,
-0.0503618643,
-0.0446911491,
-0.0557672232,
-0.0469401926,
0.0428552479,
-0.0066935997,
-0.0441131927,
0.0815719292,
-0.0208970644,
-0.0078230118,
-0.0801816136,
0.0026360229,
-0.0218551457,
0.0660522282,
0.0124962488,
0.0033811557,
0.04242884,
-0.0417930968,
0.0205462016,
-0.0006171123,
0.0041860128,
-0.0464648455,
-0.0148626612,
-0.0604588725,
0.0047278451,
0.0354141593,
-0.020941006,
-0.0386321805,
-0.0192682389,
0.004988886,
-0.0180167127,
0.0140536902,
-0.018517876,
0.0253932066,
-0.013908159,
0.0455879569,
0.0274132397,
0.046430219,
-0.0287837014,
-0.0464039855,
0.0034946799,
0.0481009781,
0.0386363529,
-0.0004187252,
0.0528212972,
0.0425790623,
0.0492995828,
-0.0030940152,
-0.0219991859,
-0.0175084881,
0.0528501607,
0.0217135511,
-0.0577975623,
0.001360148,
0.0376173481,
0.0040094284,
-0.0968322977,
0.0134532778,
0.1202453598,
0.0811210871,
-0.038679067,
0.0061004898,
-0.0083552189,
-0.0160680469,
0.0344533138,
0.0286821853,
-0.0320452712,
0.00133153,
-0.0131413061,
-0.0012861342,
-0.0332647525,
-0.0575490482,
0.0076963217,
-0.1122633219,
0.0316966735,
-0.0335344784,
0.0219430961,
0.005675917,
-0.0631131977,
0.0387512632,
0.0167020652,
0.0025071916,
-0.033227127,
-0.0121876588,
-0.001051782,
-0.010618506,
-0.0241837054,
-0.0262302719,
0.0183370113,
-0.0167357437,
0.0324029289,
0.06673792,
0.0559053496,
0.0046243551,
-0.0249402355,
-0.0008527995,
0.001918777,
0.0519997142,
-0.0521566942,
0.0346266069,
0.0192462336,
0.0017521451,
-0.1007999629,
0.0081022186,
0.0270460397,
-0.0108343195,
-0.0241454523,
0.0777482539,
-0.0560364947,
0.0547952764,
-0.0249492675,
-0.0068017109,
0.0418597348,
0.0201718863,
0.0162810851,
-0.0733263195,
-0.0312420074,
-0.0295836143,
-0.0004252681,
0.0014594515,
-0.0728139803,
0.0187424179,
-0.007684113,
-0.0349758826,
-0.0877013355,
-0.0656575114,
0.0434815697,
0.0136309955,
0.0225829091,
-0.0014475863,
0.0623276532,
-0.0154257566,
0.0044417242,
0.0206687897,
0.0035765201,
0.0094957072,
0.0284308735,
-0.0242922064,
-0.0069166101,
-0.0523379557,
-0.0030304627,
0.0087997094,
0.028480852,
-0.0445450172,
0.0031839595,
0.039860934,
0.0170120895,
0.0634383634,
-0.0439678431,
-0.046542123,
0.0279515702,
-0.0279960539,
-0.063199684,
-0.0109025948,
-0.044693321,
0.0401858613,
0.0074497014,
-0.0099288961,
-0.0018790758,
0.0101300804,
-0.0312464423,
-0.0108395796,
-0.0410020016,
-0.056137789,
0.0449517556,
0.0211321041,
0.03502829,
-0.0125051709,
-0.0192627963,
-0.0134412386,
-0.0269255079,
-0.0256839506,
-0.0562208593,
-0.0411882028,
-0.0067352802,
-0.0192649886,
0.038376648,
-0.0005427027,
0.0330766886,
-0.0350954458,
0.0366925821,
-0.012582412,
0.0335090533,
0.0387945063,
-0.0003892079,
-0.0015539128,
0.0472997464,
-0.0026707875,
0.0363365188,
-0.0482512116,
0.0277094916,
0.0128889503,
0.062516287,
0.0019941325,
-0.0473528132,
-0.0284551065,
0.0315235369,
-0.035589803,
0.0088968072,
0.0006969527,
0.0567509048,
0.0022976906,
0.0123437485,
0.0267599989,
-0.0736335143,
0.0035354802,
0.0335368328,
-0.0135193439,
0.0197564233,
-0.0835551172,
-0.001939488,
0.0054472974,
-0.0354491174,
-0.0403124467,
0.0043176189,
-0.0431073718,
0.0136039732,
-0.0171519257,
-0.0206424985,
-0.0544629395,
-0.0103255305,
0.0094795655,
0.0377709344,
-0.0219402891,
0.0295256898,
-0.0458730124,
-0.0218750909,
-0.0042716824,
0.0191537589,
-0.024408225,
-0.0329796001,
0.0713158399,
0.0223650038,
0.0192334633,
-0.0115055861,
-0.0213202573,
0.0122642349,
-0.0331239104,
-0.0389922597,
-0.0239878371,
-6.111433701e-33,
-0.0607053563,
-0.091372855,
0.0231532957,
-0.0080943303,
-0.0382425115,
-0.0372202247,
-0.0370553844,
0.0270676892,
-0.0063307029,
-0.0091195144,
-0.0034091137,
-0.0251995232,
-0.0033711384,
-0.0066554854,
0.0147976382,
-0.0196367018,
0.0300783701,
-0.0141372876,
-0.0105571747,
-0.0064602485,
0.0389046147,
-0.0145267649,
0.0182722714,
-0.0911268741,
0.0726203173,
0.0367814042,
-0.0200209804,
0.0148790926,
-0.0110403867,
0.0521956459,
-0.0461870916,
0.0637505427,
0.028627295,
-0.0238791984,
-0.011079276,
0.08463604,
-0.0756663382,
-0.0316328891,
0.0188398678,
0.0484025329,
-0.055669263,
0.0159453321,
0.0592191517,
-0.0198102035,
-0.0165645815,
0.0346946344,
0.0522042662,
-0.0206604321,
0.0064642094,
0.0281733703,
-0.0701479986,
0.0290017836,
-0.0380000509,
-0.0160973985,
0.0011167722,
0.0230844598,
0.0125227179,
-0.016075829,
-0.0851788744,
-0.008334606,
-0.0110967867,
-0.0295946747,
0.045080658,
0.0067115864,
0.0452285931,
0.0680005401,
-0.016017165,
-0.0088410322,
-0.0614679642,
0.0079688942,
0.0142256077,
0.052288346,
0.0614066795,
0.0471619442,
-0.0024746109,
0.0076487404,
-0.0096098464,
0.0109846862,
0.0293379147,
0.0489269309,
-0.0232393444,
0.0323727243,
-0.0585994534,
0.0024597764,
-0.0375757925,
0.0072449772,
-0.0109351967,
-0.0706291273,
0.0238903333,
-0.0136665516,
-0.0143085783,
0.0045798891,
-0.0346841626,
-0.0073405923,
-0.0221091751,
-0.0109267654,
0.0177377705,
0.0335799679,
0.0009302702,
-0.0131814713,
-0.0069138589,
0.0254808087,
-0.0135215754,
-0.0207800176,
0.009355085,
-0.0108979521,
-0.0230610911,
0.0342470706,
-0.0276057795,
0.0249462575,
-0.0085758483,
0.0610117055,
0.0450006947,
0.0101385573,
0.0554291531,
-0.0255535934,
-0.0652283132,
0.0126835695,
0.0265448298,
-0.0101606874,
-0.0128654474,
-0.0303017013,
-0.0378248915,
-0.0279883202,
-0.0158156808,
0.0016889538,
-0.0290701725,
0.0191899035,
0.0024919526,
-0.0242506787,
0.0124540953,
0.0116134277,
2.99e-7,
0.0254713651,
0.0434225313,
0.0300533734,
0.0033320833,
0.0373965576,
0.0183562413,
0.0018443769,
0.0288851392,
-0.0222584587,
-0.0510356762,
-0.0082581444,
0.0153806638,
0.0117513286,
0.0513452291,
-0.1031323373,
-0.0267819744,
-0.0070451228,
-0.0083862906,
-0.0642833188,
0.0493588708,
0.0884106234,
0.0253573339,
0.0149480654,
0.016764082,
-0.0136429034,
-0.0313756354,
-0.0052952659,
-0.0289574638,
0.0031907724,
-0.0181292854,
0.0028919235,
0.0174663439,
0.0064879041,
0.0262803473,
-0.0161591303,
0.0187465437,
0.00203685,
0.0479057357,
-0.0003304993,
-0.0254133157,
-0.0062441519,
-0.017576823,
0.0117287645,
-0.0502340533,
0.073711358,
-0.0232969113,
-0.0169358682,
-0.0035906129,
0.0233095884,
-0.0346796103,
-0.0081713945,
-0.0310440529,
-0.0433089584,
0.019789502,
0.0053222692,
-0.029941773,
-0.0149089005,
-0.0692284703,
-0.0382983126,
-0.0347254165,
-0.0652806684,
-0.0031494382,
-0.0631326288,
0.0239240993,
0.0174123216,
-0.0464611575,
0.0101485243,
2.59952563e-34,
-0.0384588838,
0.0290059093,
0.045713678,
0.0470128171,
0.0483014286,
0.0598023236,
-0.0179027263,
0.0476065539,
0.0617048033,
-0.0652182773,
0.0058152867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13245v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13245v3 | GQA: Training Generalized Multi-Query Transformer Models from Multi-Head Checkpoints | 2023-05-22T17:16:38 | 2023-12-23T17:55:11 | Joshua Ainslie, James Lee-Thorp, Michiel de Jong, Yury Zemlyanskiy, Federico Lebrón, Sumit Sanghai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-query attention (MQA), which only uses a single key-value head,
drastically speeds up decoder inference. However, MQA can lead to quality
degradation, and moreover it may not be desirable to train a separate model
just for faster inference. We (1) propose a recipe for uptraining existing
multi-head language model checkpoints into models with MQA using 5% of original
pre-training compute, and (2) introduce grouped-query attention (GQA), a
generalization of multi-query attention which uses an intermediate (more than
one, less than number of query heads) number of key-value heads. We show that
uptrained GQA achieves quality close to multi-head attention with comparable
speed to MQA. | [
0.0061947647,
0.0727822408,
0.0204439312,
-0.0122064389,
0.0101855053,
0.0533809625,
-0.0043255356,
0.0039775833,
-0.0293566324,
-0.0242935959,
-0.0113577824,
-0.0187667441,
0.0006722579,
-0.04306335,
0.0395281278,
-0.0309931077,
0.050258562,
-0.0235255845,
-0.0406249426,
0.0055902563,
-0.0091646947,
0.0399047062,
-0.0074486942,
0.04082302,
0.0020827597,
-0.0130397631,
-0.0459396541,
0.0354374647,
0.0205380134,
-0.0036868097,
-0.0210873764,
0.0879495665,
0.0212915819,
0.0212612841,
0.0000019453,
-0.0211158767,
-0.0297251921,
0.0099638738,
-0.0283491649,
0.0427252725,
0.0102320965,
-0.020856509,
-0.0196364745,
0.0054784566,
0.0056974767,
-0.0098995268,
0.0570555516,
0.0143538173,
0.044060234,
0.0533154942,
-0.0058912169,
-0.0640738755,
0.0029854255,
-0.0367383622,
-0.0043052095,
-0.0698558837,
0.0021955883,
0.0070741186,
-0.0121370247,
-0.0268754493,
-0.0179775897,
0.0507878885,
0.0218573119,
0.0227596816,
-0.0403022282,
0.0148878265,
-0.0505605862,
-0.0059611714,
-0.0130297123,
0.0380363464,
-0.063833423,
-0.0231139995,
-0.028565865,
0.0088473354,
-0.0188773256,
-0.0298421253,
-0.0344950072,
0.0099304738,
-0.0334904902,
0.0150648355,
0.0362855382,
0.0243901629,
0.0138144223,
-0.0190380663,
-0.0721865818,
-0.0057341713,
0.0126388809,
-0.0070910454,
0.0025730238,
0.0310487635,
-0.012387828,
0.0049657053,
-0.0181226879,
0.0171181075,
-0.0053951512,
0.0131657962,
-0.024010282,
-0.0128602795,
-0.0015862474,
-0.0688563436,
0.0316086337,
0.0789811313,
-0.0388012864,
0.0384675004,
-0.002765748,
0.0205932502,
-0.0360308401,
0.0397429615,
-0.044081267,
-0.0128355883,
-0.0083783939,
0.0019453857,
-0.0553618632,
-0.0000203324,
-0.0041720807,
0.0119884666,
0.0146544892,
0.0207162835,
0.0447870791,
-0.0447720736,
0.0537947603,
-0.013238823,
-0.0855559334,
-0.0236896034,
0.0633556247,
0.0644045174,
-0.0173689313,
-0.0144463349,
-0.0036750741,
-0.12462008,
-0.0693418682,
0.028047055,
0.0206648875,
-0.048703935,
-0.0206442941,
0.0234857351,
-0.0464068651,
-0.0425379463,
-0.0457602032,
0.0081898374,
0.0095185442,
-0.0310547147,
-0.0018029117,
-0.0199375693,
0.0591739789,
0.0130824866,
0.0204781685,
-0.0161172878,
-0.0229947791,
0.0125025865,
0.0053319256,
0.0322549045,
0.0577219985,
0.0260307118,
0.011674528,
-0.0102517502,
-0.007198744,
0.1299470365,
0.0114675295,
0.0067204293,
-0.006166982,
-0.0304801296,
-0.0180425998,
0.0580834746,
0.0087202098,
0.0377795026,
-0.0179433841,
-0.0203733649,
0.038741488,
-0.00717847,
0.0463799015,
0.0452361628,
-0.0473032482,
0.0027093024,
0.0388501436,
-0.0244001895,
0.0621386506,
0.0033875548,
0.0396486744,
0.0189850256,
-0.0125739872,
0.0291347168,
-0.0412684865,
0.0588770732,
-0.010303326,
0.0234497525,
0.0333063453,
0.0534349233,
-0.028888043,
-0.0076003545,
0.0010618189,
0.017611051,
-0.0362822227,
0.009582229,
0.0566906892,
0.0188378412,
-0.0888504684,
0.0321067832,
0.0175361298,
-0.0538306199,
0.018392032,
-0.0469720215,
-0.0187938213,
0.0239608344,
0.0412246548,
0.0322385691,
-0.0229302514,
-0.0131598106,
0.0311450586,
0.0005429882,
0.0270641875,
0.0116776321,
0.0434074961,
-0.0758833736,
-0.0072538457,
0.029458914,
0.0191016048,
0.0440846607,
0.0140369814,
-0.0026612007,
0.0051878188,
-0.0325879492,
0.0425351486,
0.0319211148,
0.0278085973,
0.0039771195,
-0.0253517386,
0.0145823704,
0.017716324,
-0.0166582149,
-0.0160996616,
0.0041826777,
0.0371720605,
-0.0407076739,
0.0310379546,
0.0131831495,
-0.0224456545,
-0.067788139,
-0.0083539309,
0.0090835989,
-0.0057781646,
0.0335838944,
-0.0183993652,
-0.0289570317,
-0.0178185031,
-0.0414330922,
0.0478734933,
-0.038009204,
0.0260934271,
0.018076349,
0.0361460298,
-0.0368084684,
0.0539163761,
-0.01831696,
-0.0059363213,
0.0345010981,
-0.0592900887,
-0.0103603667,
-0.0454026759,
0.000103418,
0.0481360927,
-0.040576417,
0.0009058748,
-0.0165703185,
0.0000220184,
0.0192332268,
-0.0203693826,
-0.0438658111,
-0.022739429,
-0.0549383424,
0.0443301424,
-0.0056791333,
0.0497067682,
0.0027699592,
-0.0135686323,
0.0007245396,
-0.0484021828,
0.0010949968,
0.0147650866,
-0.0300356671,
-0.0118178958,
-0.0257360544,
0.0130247157,
-0.037808381,
-0.0014348634,
0.0780237243,
-0.0171255171,
-0.093280077,
-0.0569323711,
-0.0193288438,
0.0266217459,
0.0071051004,
-0.0123250019,
-0.04640444,
0.0042038616,
-0.0313917175,
0.0581530295,
0.0860233605,
0.0311416592,
-0.0249619726,
0.0199896265,
-0.0246572178,
-0.0697598681,
0.0345740877,
-0.0032989809,
-0.0579684712,
-0.0434194654,
-0.0368231647,
0.0172643494,
0.0605700724,
0.0076605235,
-0.0071647041,
-0.100426808,
-0.0214535743,
0.0095077427,
-0.0346640423,
-0.019227732,
0.026774263,
-0.0212188214,
0.0195924062,
-0.0013498918,
-0.0268906988,
0.0798558146,
-0.0418746471,
-0.0447785109,
-0.022447722,
0.0393627472,
-0.0437793657,
0.0539804436,
-0.0346069969,
0.0418209657,
0.0097405678,
-0.0712013692,
-0.044796437,
0.0496515073,
0.0026243485,
-0.015568696,
0.0669164509,
-0.0230606496,
0.0128706601,
-0.0434159189,
0.0002000474,
-0.0202441309,
0.0401113741,
-0.0375165045,
-0.004596048,
0.0216658413,
-0.0084601082,
-0.0397078507,
0.0523124114,
-0.0003606733,
0.0511437617,
-0.0139518343,
0.0121986046,
0.0020112183,
0.0062121293,
0.0234377608,
0.0422287658,
-0.020379236,
-0.0552633554,
0.009968129,
0.0407779738,
0.035258051,
0.0100057703,
0.0066916952,
0.0112413457,
0.0577176474,
-0.0061771045,
-0.0068566706,
0.0219364855,
0.0347838812,
-0.0592513457,
-0.0088900579,
0.0771824345,
0.0225764494,
-0.0385401361,
0.0012876203,
-0.0215386618,
0.0361254737,
-0.004726524,
0.0313048698,
-0.0780771002,
-0.0625186414,
0.0156356171,
0.0521814451,
0.0383378118,
0.0264713522,
-0.0160488337,
-0.0781967044,
0.0472681858,
0.0174227115,
-0.03744727,
-0.0180586185,
-0.047446616,
-0.0249077491,
-0.0496925525,
0.0017582179,
0.0565124005,
0.018725425,
-0.0159897767,
0.0293965954,
0.0265990552,
-0.068209134,
0.0203562528,
-0.0145873856,
0.0056186263,
0.0648154914,
-0.0119978841,
0.009862111,
-0.040058475,
-0.0020050909,
-0.0484738052,
-0.0132697755,
0.0094379671,
-0.0017635566,
-0.0556441993,
-0.0125390962,
0.0188765954,
0.0008734541,
-0.0502592586,
0.0310436655,
-0.0333629362,
0.0509265251,
0.0164442975,
-0.004170421,
-0.0064844061,
-0.0103663476,
-0.0211367738,
0.0545735545,
0.028389059,
-0.0206447188,
-0.0219816975,
-0.0344233699,
0.0379969887,
-0.081893675,
-0.0015420909,
0.0495524146,
0.0189418029,
-0.076631844,
-0.0190074425,
0.01031835,
0.0269544683,
0.0453486852,
-0.0140744923,
-0.0060305535,
0.0000112187,
0.0225057025,
-0.0534712821,
0.0273634866,
-0.0178967528,
0.0161479358,
-0.0983342379,
-0.010239522,
0.0246821772,
-0.0086805886,
-0.0151288742,
0.0652684942,
-0.0850760937,
-0.0435921028,
0.0079057971,
0.0347155482,
0.0158986971,
0.0146253351,
-0.0390505344,
-0.022140339,
-0.0630215406,
0.0178525466,
-0.038662266,
0.040140532,
0.0333187766,
-0.0626610667,
-0.0330052711,
0.035505522,
-0.0254077446,
0.0233472697,
-0.0515123941,
0.0493777357,
-0.0294908453,
-0.0412792191,
0.0403741263,
0.0083648115,
0.0402301438,
-0.0024604818,
0.03368669,
0.0074408748,
0.0477050506,
0.017393833,
-0.0101864878,
-0.040977966,
-0.0043868218,
0.0161245354,
-0.0167951453,
0.0054979995,
0.0174805298,
0.010333945,
0.0098786168,
-0.033800859,
0.0171715617,
-0.0190062616,
-0.0055900672,
0.0361840464,
-0.0281738583,
-0.0320433341,
-0.0004266538,
0.0288434904,
0.0252907537,
-0.0584978238,
0.0246446058,
0.0226953663,
0.011628639,
0.0154468985,
0.0059308298,
-0.0305808298,
-0.0066720871,
-0.0432548523,
-0.0812571198,
0.0349156559,
0.0262587685,
0.0717896447,
0.0512831062,
0.0074574971,
-0.0176601484,
0.0435111895,
-0.006791384,
-0.0146645103,
0.0253147408,
0.0150796911,
0.0046422435,
0.0068487469,
0.0614838004,
-0.0033880565,
0.0380932167,
-0.0299209245,
-0.0025263932,
-0.0289125852,
-0.0705758035,
-0.0189351123,
0.0026797974,
0.0045658867,
-0.0112207485,
-0.0303708632,
-0.0155030033,
-0.0034657503,
-0.0438178442,
0.0125501901,
-0.0287033822,
0.0263443179,
0.0448128618,
-0.0312489998,
-0.056389533,
-0.0176470634,
-0.0197049789,
-0.0052823182,
-0.0082206912,
0.0115855793,
-6.364911793e-33,
-0.0380782411,
0.0375278182,
-0.005286999,
-0.0744363293,
-0.0397542194,
-0.0154478978,
-0.039541658,
-0.0301574878,
-0.0428693071,
-0.0235585906,
-0.0024321871,
0.0120411227,
0.029105695,
0.0047198972,
-0.0062087988,
0.0027360944,
0.0706624091,
0.025219541,
-0.0343159698,
0.0161922071,
0.0191994589,
0.0307983793,
0.0877049565,
0.0681487247,
-0.0468758568,
0.0056629442,
-0.0444777012,
-0.0160877742,
-0.0263154153,
0.0644440055,
0.0101844799,
0.0217441712,
0.0143395653,
-0.0707345158,
-0.025360221,
-0.0283596609,
-0.0998888463,
0.0328462273,
-0.0135610988,
0.0504965447,
0.0231399871,
-0.0155596193,
-0.0009901404,
0.0075692134,
0.0440490134,
-0.0503689982,
-0.0010431851,
-0.0140494788,
-0.0632931888,
-0.0200666524,
-0.0004837234,
0.0438602231,
-0.0076562264,
-0.0014774372,
0.0211236179,
0.0841147751,
-0.0077673602,
0.0372654796,
-0.0343088061,
0.0318528563,
0.0514969826,
0.0528948307,
0.0611660182,
0.0188894384,
-0.0146255242,
-0.0065401159,
0.0076481448,
-0.0471553765,
-0.0439243689,
0.0185131188,
0.0494575575,
0.0106433555,
0.0052812826,
0.0027452805,
0.0075938096,
0.0033773447,
-0.0634560138,
0.0145921763,
-0.0002042845,
0.0756326392,
0.0358649455,
0.0378359891,
-0.0530248061,
-0.0260407571,
-0.0339801311,
-0.0269729514,
-0.0227935575,
-0.0090639973,
0.0306065045,
0.0315933004,
-0.0501317829,
0.0313693844,
0.1125496775,
-0.0117204459,
0.0409360193,
0.0425617509,
-0.025639642,
0.0586227216,
-0.0212287363,
0.0594640672,
-0.010540612,
-0.0002824874,
0.0704441369,
-0.0080898171,
-0.0051083723,
-0.0068853842,
0.021549033,
0.0521701612,
-0.0641275942,
-0.0282712951,
-0.0237451624,
0.0036684342,
-0.0384081416,
0.0605992153,
0.0477245562,
0.0093291039,
0.0077540302,
0.0741077065,
-0.0277480949,
0.0050405404,
-0.0345161557,
-0.0014855786,
0.0270709842,
0.0582302026,
-0.0119794272,
0.0091102626,
-0.0492420308,
-0.0023263278,
0.0520261042,
-0.0218511932,
-0.0456792824,
0.0844534636,
2.621e-7,
0.0628212988,
0.0176359788,
0.0377473235,
0.0298262164,
-0.0214771423,
0.0000285529,
0.0049890107,
0.0277444441,
0.0088968277,
-0.0057685603,
-0.01219978,
0.0232189875,
0.0344385691,
0.004693985,
-0.0865122229,
-0.0485966243,
-0.0252238624,
0.0450967476,
-0.0513491482,
-0.0538446531,
0.0158928428,
0.1083985269,
-0.0509629324,
0.0219202396,
0.0362772979,
0.0525282547,
0.0342203602,
0.0130367549,
-0.0284540877,
0.0392548926,
0.0140319411,
0.0017781932,
-0.0077508278,
0.0092159277,
-0.0154190259,
0.0214618314,
0.0170642342,
0.0720349178,
-0.0184865259,
-0.0563577674,
0.0238370467,
0.0095754489,
-0.0276962351,
-0.0529571809,
0.0789335519,
-0.0371190123,
-0.01466549,
0.0108787185,
-0.0501459204,
0.0178629663,
-0.0206552558,
-0.0177205149,
0.007401431,
0.0309074074,
0.0437458344,
-0.0155642219,
-0.0254209507,
-0.0758416578,
-0.0180302989,
-0.0157554522,
-0.0340813026,
-0.0268639848,
-0.0329865851,
-0.0399100669,
0.001618347,
-0.0243899357,
-0.0273272227,
2.426235263e-34,
0.0520889126,
-0.0239078682,
0.0071332962,
0.0406550243,
0.0250112787,
-0.0514575504,
-0.0096823061,
0.0142354462,
-0.0133641222,
-0.0770778731,
-0.048234418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13242v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13242v3 | MAGE: Machine-generated Text Detection in the Wild | 2023-05-22T17:13:29 | 2024-05-21T04:21:53 | Yafu Li, Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Wei Bi, Zhilin Wang, Longyue Wang, Linyi Yang, Shuming Shi, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved human-level text generation,
emphasizing the need for effective AI-generated text detection to mitigate
risks like the spread of fake news and plagiarism. Existing research has been
constrained by evaluating detection methods on specific domains or particular
language models. In practical scenarios, however, the detector faces texts from
various domains or LLMs without knowing their sources. To this end, we build a
comprehensive testbed by gathering texts from diverse human writings and texts
generated by different LLMs. Empirical results show challenges in
distinguishing machine-generated texts from human-authored ones across various
scenarios, especially out-of-distribution. These challenges are due to the
decreasing linguistic distinctions between the two sources. Despite challenges,
the top-performing detector can identify 86.54% out-of-domain texts generated
by a new LLM, indicating the feasibility for application scenarios. We release
our resources at https://github.com/yafuly/MAGE. | [
0.0633323267,
0.0361075252,
-0.0026994362,
0.0873886123,
-0.0682226419,
0.0110585056,
0.0088823792,
0.0305702668,
0.0300875083,
-0.0437460728,
-0.0036754683,
-0.0036410468,
-0.020072367,
0.0445819758,
0.0363649987,
0.0374948718,
0.0085009001,
-0.0051816837,
0.0154964384,
0.0237861723,
0.0404078923,
0.0424147397,
0.0262865592,
0.0235749763,
-0.0049338532,
-0.0248246156,
0.0268251542,
0.0385851115,
0.0324850716,
0.0028028197,
0.0067668403,
0.0405662246,
-0.0030861201,
0.1039757133,
0.0000018039,
-0.0320953391,
-0.0040714801,
-0.0098611061,
-0.0040841466,
-0.0003592963,
0.0747695267,
-0.0361745358,
-0.0347922407,
0.0263216086,
-0.0335711539,
0.0158818364,
-0.0065709651,
0.0267333891,
0.0501467511,
0.1037788689,
-0.0340325125,
0.0176275577,
0.029571915,
-0.0010553574,
-0.01365586,
-0.0107991807,
0.0390414819,
-0.0248145424,
0.0076657557,
0.0172781758,
0.0307064876,
0.0164361876,
-0.0043307012,
-0.0552742779,
-0.0145674786,
-0.0037717263,
-0.0110515598,
-0.0181677062,
-0.0285420567,
0.037074022,
-0.0505761206,
-0.0736509115,
0.0593403615,
-0.0204686299,
0.0154224019,
0.0333427303,
0.0125580849,
0.0743520632,
-0.0506540984,
0.0091965022,
0.0090953968,
0.0053849365,
0.0152361272,
0.0573193505,
0.0164138936,
0.0278062988,
0.0222596843,
-0.0395475626,
-0.0060756621,
0.0068654083,
-0.0075092446,
-0.0595689937,
0.0657983348,
0.0118510118,
0.0093004955,
-0.0287294891,
-0.0873889402,
-0.0705256462,
0.0330900662,
-0.0482112505,
0.0200206898,
-0.0040595261,
-0.0210232604,
0.0467460081,
-0.0432114266,
0.0486432947,
-0.0231835973,
-0.0001161816,
-0.0124295419,
0.00062763,
0.0047822664,
-0.0034449033,
-0.0099115558,
-0.0072010932,
-0.0504169427,
-0.0159224141,
-0.0317597315,
0.0229326393,
0.0198696796,
0.0114094773,
-0.035652291,
-0.0300609339,
-0.0200251304,
-0.0287693497,
0.0129126357,
-0.016576279,
-0.0027109988,
0.02184912,
0.0069733532,
-0.0577125438,
-0.0058902209,
0.0772619918,
0.0174519271,
-0.0068617654,
0.0110061076,
0.0502140597,
0.0043631522,
-0.0338149965,
-0.0490596294,
-0.0690683722,
-0.008167305,
-0.0522416197,
0.007325456,
-0.0662542135,
-0.0397119708,
-0.0146356691,
-0.0027930557,
-0.056516353,
-0.0022720578,
0.0666056871,
-0.0273432154,
0.0033951967,
-0.0306036845,
0.0070176488,
0.0577021427,
-0.0060553891,
-0.0123935482,
0.0487361811,
0.0175083205,
0.0881691799,
0.0638451651,
0.0323179588,
0.0559632108,
0.0642855465,
0.0149279004,
0.0083325133,
-0.0155283036,
-0.0254193433,
-0.0273496825,
0.0019465765,
0.0303790607,
0.0600981936,
0.0015772212,
-0.0254367739,
0.0830854401,
0.0399179086,
-0.021800736,
0.0102926986,
0.0749565363,
0.051633466,
0.0036297615,
0.0059875576,
-0.0158514455,
-0.0234604869,
-0.0510095544,
-0.0273207333,
-0.0018454066,
0.0485671312,
0.0062120846,
0.0066299578,
-0.020307295,
-0.0338575728,
-0.0341657102,
-0.0339918248,
0.0311371181,
0.0398185961,
-0.0299665239,
-0.0258097686,
-0.008250054,
-0.0532600656,
0.0215285122,
-0.0504731238,
0.0610905103,
0.0560364909,
0.0661383942,
0.0063991342,
0.0749014765,
-0.0298517831,
0.0095315436,
0.0869599283,
0.0033238358,
-0.019549014,
-0.0326377675,
-0.0334956273,
-0.0100780642,
-0.0047871852,
0.0237373263,
-0.0126484074,
0.0466722026,
0.0035860511,
0.0386855714,
-0.0342845879,
-0.045091413,
0.0555035584,
-0.0423304811,
0.0048500253,
-0.0039188098,
-0.0002317229,
-0.0088142315,
0.0159296636,
-0.0376427621,
0.0019991035,
0.0313749202,
-0.0506287217,
-0.0150212869,
-0.0195904411,
0.0082881358,
-0.0061599342,
0.0327947475,
-0.0502809212,
-0.0238366555,
0.0412688889,
-0.0071020252,
0.0052299341,
0.0011546785,
-0.0419806652,
-0.0250307508,
-0.0854981914,
0.0241214987,
-0.0163509715,
0.0140514178,
-0.0118275769,
0.0822275206,
-0.0152618624,
-0.0261478648,
0.0358247198,
-0.0083564697,
0.042998597,
0.0072378488,
0.0024777881,
-0.0290672686,
-0.0140624531,
0.0217671022,
0.0368300267,
0.0131820263,
-0.0073673432,
-0.0248319935,
-0.0420780964,
0.004619889,
-0.025799958,
0.0165086314,
0.0565363057,
-0.0066716312,
-0.0213967022,
0.0109546036,
-0.0202263892,
-0.0235577971,
0.0548649654,
0.0158075541,
0.043174088,
-0.0367842279,
0.0250805616,
-0.0129607925,
0.0263843909,
-0.008982542,
0.0587947108,
0.0525030158,
-0.0503908731,
-0.0738891512,
0.0373314619,
-0.0082425782,
-0.0232830364,
-0.0055760108,
-0.0203832258,
-0.0460347123,
-0.0305623934,
0.0214819554,
0.0649047121,
0.0396440886,
-0.0029608433,
0.0184642337,
0.0405744426,
-0.0162367877,
-0.036352396,
-0.0029761028,
0.0278897267,
0.0002518634,
-0.0337395035,
0.0681126192,
0.0274641532,
-0.0013025749,
0.003775818,
0.0036531128,
0.0454486869,
-0.0257809851,
-0.0373264849,
0.0066732103,
-0.0490061752,
-0.0191406365,
0.0376398787,
-0.0312067438,
-0.0720169842,
0.0468360595,
-0.0402775407,
0.0326889791,
-0.0393338278,
-0.0184885468,
-0.0334919021,
-0.0029474469,
-0.0119434884,
0.0527864397,
0.0050928826,
-0.000459485,
-0.0164459925,
0.0118770553,
0.0276613683,
-0.0115594547,
0.0377877951,
-0.0441366546,
0.0091470787,
0.0004863174,
-0.0089250254,
-0.0571008995,
-0.0640400946,
-0.0183197279,
-0.0310784988,
0.0043980754,
-0.0311075859,
-0.0243573971,
-0.0296498872,
0.0065355352,
0.0551515445,
-0.0212672595,
-0.0041816267,
-0.0239552297,
0.0799593329,
0.0314943157,
-0.0461000316,
0.0294358265,
-0.0550568923,
-0.0246727969,
0.0660338178,
-0.0129031371,
0.005073552,
0.0209771525,
-0.0110215303,
-0.0009092548,
0.0087461201,
0.0080930097,
0.0006670207,
0.0229191091,
-0.0352117866,
-0.0204282477,
0.0891729817,
0.0244161393,
-0.0546043329,
-0.0283207651,
-0.0199102014,
0.0177798588,
0.003399946,
0.003301905,
-0.0864466578,
-0.02756669,
0.0171766821,
0.011614888,
-0.0354597792,
-0.0097264256,
-0.0093327723,
-0.1045577079,
0.0360769816,
0.0094367787,
-0.0076413774,
-0.053638611,
-0.0060249101,
-0.0291544627,
0.0305046421,
-0.0263168067,
-0.0110410759,
-0.0171689857,
0.0014082855,
-0.0105096297,
-0.0127538769,
-0.0604106523,
-0.0272224527,
-0.0601096787,
0.0020198303,
0.0787663832,
0.0426872745,
-0.0066319951,
-0.0347328745,
0.0192800984,
-0.0252795182,
-0.0309194382,
-0.0107671609,
0.0557763129,
-0.0102097001,
0.0068855388,
-0.0105017023,
0.0605747737,
-0.0210892651,
0.0063477485,
0.0641927868,
0.0438182913,
0.0212630704,
-0.0563393049,
-0.0334887616,
0.0241995621,
0.034632504,
0.0723315403,
0.0336100943,
-0.0493597239,
-0.0587249584,
-0.0401632525,
0.0044663162,
-0.0636647567,
-0.0511303172,
-0.0007500357,
-0.0026876512,
-0.0270911381,
-0.1129662469,
-0.005102756,
-0.0372879133,
0.0067894845,
0.0246501621,
-0.0060812416,
-0.0175847802,
-0.0144527042,
-0.0343936346,
-0.0186840836,
-0.0657851994,
0.0263878908,
-0.0641665459,
0.0142188622,
0.0201629419,
-0.0494654104,
-0.0104775047,
0.0626902506,
-0.0995169953,
-0.046116665,
0.0034150369,
-0.0131425587,
0.0223418642,
0.0306892954,
-0.0340990312,
-0.0430310331,
0.0884933993,
0.0476300716,
-0.0649829805,
0.0369498804,
-0.0058091092,
-0.0357084312,
-0.0142162517,
0.0160796903,
-0.0346318558,
0.0401561894,
0.0269694813,
-0.0475496762,
-0.0056658094,
-0.0188430678,
0.0104528777,
0.026063541,
0.0109294439,
-0.0311043356,
0.0088257696,
-0.0451880433,
-0.0353913866,
-0.0256880112,
-0.0246805865,
-0.0458666943,
0.020051688,
0.0345004648,
-0.001758505,
0.0022401146,
0.0424492285,
-0.0259289164,
0.0406781621,
-0.007504506,
-0.0108606303,
-0.0175868273,
0.0806586295,
0.0099267298,
-0.0224320348,
-0.0006375455,
0.0385593474,
-0.0310290195,
0.0469789281,
-0.0103027839,
0.0508244261,
0.0109731192,
-0.0435123928,
0.0337306894,
0.0219421983,
-0.0557117611,
0.013439415,
-0.0505268201,
0.0184641834,
0.0695269182,
-0.0178095922,
0.0668744147,
-0.0341693722,
-0.0193514377,
-0.0305938888,
0.0182134453,
0.0052022156,
-0.0321935304,
-0.0458588786,
-0.0106472597,
-0.0405659042,
0.0292435698,
0.092966415,
0.0523541421,
0.0303577203,
0.0233929381,
-0.0358625762,
-0.0439195745,
-0.0163878035,
0.0138065778,
-0.022496989,
-0.0209591519,
0.0062370175,
-0.0670973435,
-0.0276444312,
0.0481917597,
0.0177965797,
0.0275597293,
0.0082420129,
-0.0079362802,
0.0760127008,
-0.0112677841,
0.0382838547,
-0.0631058961,
0.0333163328,
0.0007823978,
-0.0270467978,
-0.0094306329,
-5.394934997e-33,
-0.0012749722,
-0.0834697485,
-0.0245500654,
-0.0124644572,
0.0162906889,
0.0188960433,
-0.0196318198,
-0.0379556715,
0.0130049223,
0.0291229244,
0.0123797888,
0.0206587911,
0.0046577659,
0.0215391796,
-0.0227798093,
0.0128112575,
0.0550794341,
-0.0237029716,
-0.0308534149,
0.0326863304,
0.031084558,
0.007383767,
-0.0246078819,
-0.0695460513,
0.0117727974,
-0.0614051409,
-0.040081948,
0.0084721632,
-0.0080402,
0.0481525473,
-0.0332816057,
0.0148090953,
0.0247133095,
0.0227602422,
-0.018304145,
0.0376702882,
-0.0156505238,
0.0223541949,
-0.0223928168,
-0.0155772595,
-0.0021415171,
-0.0643827394,
0.0531816408,
-0.0173514858,
-0.0189804062,
0.0199496485,
0.0606032796,
-0.0248885024,
0.0059807473,
-0.0408695266,
-0.0576462112,
0.0372236595,
0.0197023023,
0.0063286228,
0.0311386622,
0.0559168495,
0.0129761482,
0.0414115638,
-0.0685766339,
0.0401165485,
-0.0273546763,
0.0015231961,
0.0037967938,
-0.001779379,
-0.0307737365,
0.0521523878,
-0.0087370984,
0.0098047806,
-0.0117478035,
0.0196167212,
-0.0168984737,
0.0161070656,
0.0784289166,
0.1329248399,
0.0193123817,
-0.0190001652,
-0.070353806,
0.0625374094,
0.003009093,
-0.0426284596,
0.0184007455,
-0.0362907425,
-0.0409499891,
0.0127236666,
0.0180023666,
-0.0431016721,
-0.0319095999,
0.0070049688,
0.0352935866,
0.0315907188,
-0.0359631404,
-0.0097336266,
0.0082714567,
-0.0459594987,
0.0053205765,
0.0248676687,
-0.0473288409,
-0.0106337154,
0.0128999185,
0.0465852544,
-0.0376472548,
-0.0123318546,
0.0275390074,
0.0127484426,
0.0125300558,
0.000304646,
0.0583065338,
0.0101818554,
-0.0621618852,
0.0304415654,
-0.0114947548,
0.0373338349,
0.0173144974,
0.0253146123,
0.0009628555,
-0.0397048183,
0.0024501029,
-0.0036224215,
0.023533348,
-0.0066880994,
-0.0262657646,
0.011277739,
-0.011302093,
0.0197697934,
-0.0344549157,
-0.0073395888,
-0.0345761329,
0.0385121703,
0.0368042476,
-0.0683635473,
0.0342316218,
-0.0438745655,
2.423e-7,
0.0191901568,
0.0273956321,
0.0469491668,
-0.0116595626,
0.0199221987,
0.0467980802,
-0.0135784522,
0.0390371643,
-0.0335599966,
0.0029747759,
-0.0127452547,
-0.0048405156,
0.0599555783,
0.0133480774,
-0.0880150646,
0.0625795871,
-0.0631048828,
-0.0009212799,
-0.0793101266,
-0.0177107751,
0.0332745202,
0.0411253348,
0.0186165776,
-0.0376942158,
0.0084824897,
-0.0967535153,
0.0613340437,
0.0007495244,
-0.0188698471,
0.0025041555,
0.0489277616,
0.0168359373,
-0.0093643935,
0.0011690053,
-0.0248270165,
0.0183629636,
0.0312733166,
0.0664199814,
0.043747209,
0.036952436,
0.0025355844,
-0.0322675034,
0.013804242,
-0.0414395742,
0.0496324115,
0.0214234516,
0.010555625,
-0.0439189263,
-0.0227669124,
-0.0537973121,
-0.0039508189,
-0.0417452939,
-0.0101387762,
0.0177194159,
0.0150340935,
0.0191286653,
-0.0089541711,
-0.0425468758,
-0.0162494089,
-0.0481353216,
-0.0576591752,
-0.0004847987,
-0.0674147382,
0.0048115868,
0.0260466449,
-0.0461878963,
0.0505613796,
2.277956294e-34,
0.0306288619,
-0.020842975,
-0.0256756116,
0.0145442551,
0.0355554596,
0.0099940551,
0.0010423121,
-0.0067064459,
-0.0248306058,
-0.0116503825,
0.0339784361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13235v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13235v2 | SPARSEFIT: Few-shot Prompting with Sparse Fine-tuning for Jointly Generating Predictions and Natural Language Explanations | 2023-05-22T17:06:41 | 2023-05-23T09:26:37 | Jesus Solano, Oana-Maria Camburu, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Explaining the decisions of neural models is crucial for ensuring their
trustworthiness at deployment time. Using Natural Language Explanations (NLEs)
to justify a model's predictions has recently gained increasing interest.
However, this approach usually demands large datasets of human-written NLEs for
the ground-truth answers, which are expensive and potentially infeasible for
some applications. For models to generate high-quality NLEs when only a few
NLEs are available, the fine-tuning of Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) in
conjunction with prompt-based learning recently emerged. However, PLMs
typically have billions of parameters, making fine-tuning expensive. We propose
SparseFit, a sparse few-shot fine-tuning strategy that leverages discrete
prompts to jointly generate predictions and NLEs. We experiment with SparseFit
on the T5 model and four datasets and compare it against state-of-the-art
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques. We perform automatic and human
evaluations to assess the quality of the model-generated NLEs, finding that
fine-tuning only 6.8% of the model parameters leads to competitive results for
both the task performance and the quality of the NLEs. | [
0.0417916141,
0.0467240997,
0.0036482585,
0.0234751198,
0.0071018669,
-0.0103817936,
0.0305046756,
-0.0222207252,
-0.0334996954,
-0.0608793199,
-0.0109379441,
-0.0226163883,
0.0030594564,
0.036171563,
0.0426614322,
-0.0436417162,
0.0358707495,
-0.0410348736,
0.0133032259,
0.0122593632,
-0.0016292342,
0.0319629647,
-0.0065224748,
0.0703819394,
0.0136108641,
-0.0073935133,
-0.0400442518,
0.0209963676,
-0.0058954735,
-0.0247870423,
0.0131185623,
0.0800249502,
0.0382189713,
0.0246697683,
0.0000023152,
-0.0287014842,
-0.0082181785,
0.013815525,
-0.0866180435,
0.0398123078,
0.0084268777,
0.0074187885,
0.0136063267,
0.0155903529,
-0.0089367814,
0.0020178594,
0.0706225261,
0.0470316671,
0.076343812,
0.0671225339,
0.0109027568,
0.0034083875,
-0.0339703076,
-0.0314549133,
0.0121560991,
-0.0574599132,
-0.029911289,
-0.0571667291,
-0.0036489717,
0.0415228158,
0.0268583857,
-0.0062150368,
0.0197506268,
-0.018472461,
0.0083219577,
0.0291086659,
-0.0065834643,
-0.0439700037,
-0.0449588895,
0.0705950782,
-0.0025470499,
-0.0395141952,
-0.0111246137,
-0.0446872078,
-0.0135103613,
-0.0073930346,
-0.0199975856,
-0.0060834093,
0.0340888835,
0.0017751585,
-0.0194080006,
-0.0003078466,
0.0416874252,
0.0242067948,
-0.0102774883,
0.0443452038,
-0.0016466652,
-0.0094541432,
-0.026418373,
-0.0184856486,
-0.0099252835,
-0.0725810751,
-0.0352055281,
0.050322488,
-0.0857352763,
0.0014987808,
-0.047381185,
-0.0011206616,
0.027513383,
0.0238480717,
0.0804396868,
0.0383114442,
-0.0271747895,
0.0393760949,
-0.0312580056,
0.050872229,
0.0316893347,
0.003639733,
-0.0246683005,
0.0184070524,
-0.0481898561,
-0.0122717489,
-0.0288477503,
0.013128289,
-0.0351794176,
-0.0344837978,
-0.0256998036,
0.0065624127,
-0.0124559915,
0.0301315915,
0.0163166579,
0.0404378511,
-0.0524997972,
-0.0354002304,
-0.0469352193,
0.0125964116,
-0.0553875118,
0.0144799221,
0.0523631498,
-0.0804327503,
-0.0415774658,
0.0114129456,
-0.0070916819,
-0.0134819821,
0.0027943049,
0.0510911644,
0.0059311385,
-0.0198279414,
-0.0460083932,
-0.0547003336,
-0.0250314325,
-0.0632261112,
-0.0193574112,
-0.0513879023,
-0.0035633577,
-0.0085685402,
0.0095185386,
-0.0453658365,
0.0088613247,
0.007188248,
-0.0419463664,
0.0938201621,
-0.0540439002,
0.0157064144,
-0.0136754271,
0.0017489097,
0.0045385514,
0.0589091815,
0.0149660902,
0.0448070876,
0.020950811,
-0.0235848241,
0.0159921367,
-0.0058332719,
0.0246625654,
0.003790664,
-0.0202097055,
-0.0007552294,
-0.017122183,
0.0278986041,
0.012690872,
0.0253875665,
0.0042492361,
0.0140516991,
0.0699455589,
0.0509403646,
0.0251848754,
-0.0123758987,
0.0745522678,
0.0384578146,
-0.0074786204,
-0.0109072542,
-0.0831791684,
0.0466144681,
-0.0691682175,
-0.001355744,
0.0331625119,
0.0219358467,
-0.050444752,
-0.0416407101,
-0.0015423286,
-0.0253874399,
0.0033519191,
0.0342683867,
0.0365207195,
-0.0097173573,
-0.0599835142,
0.0340717398,
0.0347472541,
-0.0156768803,
-0.0390892327,
-0.061252635,
0.0545063689,
0.076140292,
0.0137930568,
-0.0046958728,
-0.0515229404,
-0.0271558352,
0.0287713557,
0.0312789828,
0.0704644546,
0.0015095322,
0.029260315,
-0.0349715203,
-0.0500338525,
-0.0438207239,
0.0378218666,
0.0146538531,
0.0198148657,
-0.0084504737,
0.0384021625,
-0.0134119997,
-0.0565007925,
0.0428064354,
-0.0072729494,
-0.0352129117,
0.042748224,
0.003940539,
0.0251660608,
0.0421571881,
-0.0084750261,
0.0252171829,
0.0254613552,
0.0041317302,
0.0078842388,
-0.0138846887,
-0.0544041581,
-0.0045221876,
0.0191357657,
0.0219100751,
0.0072440458,
0.0090590017,
-0.0547944866,
-0.0461780839,
-0.0133118052,
-0.0250370987,
-0.0097536119,
-0.0480371602,
0.0105010085,
-0.0082850652,
-0.0032682435,
-0.0301383361,
0.0349243954,
0.0277005937,
0.0023235895,
0.0203684717,
0.0205642805,
0.0086462004,
-0.0410724729,
-0.0295852199,
-0.0064142626,
-0.0244707614,
-0.0096350275,
0.0200519692,
0.0488331169,
-0.0319230184,
0.0121303415,
-0.070359394,
-0.003192405,
-0.0341541804,
-0.0223379973,
0.0213348102,
-0.0051595359,
0.0026719649,
-0.0290698484,
-0.030391423,
0.0165416431,
0.0261743926,
0.0056877062,
0.0290623102,
0.0122173158,
-0.0164780114,
-0.0537553802,
-0.0035136316,
-0.0065499358,
0.0379128158,
0.0265453141,
0.0059294095,
-0.073109068,
0.0426467583,
-0.0187048372,
0.006802815,
-0.0072615333,
-0.0603236072,
0.033022292,
-0.0041460842,
-0.01427624,
0.0430012606,
0.0113436356,
0.0299999956,
0.053094998,
0.0517237633,
-0.0609977022,
0.0056581902,
-0.035118565,
-0.0576247014,
-0.0039937366,
-0.003501066,
0.0066814278,
0.0585716255,
0.0019319355,
0.000545815,
-0.0924583003,
0.045757886,
0.0192744527,
-0.0109719671,
-0.036909543,
-0.0254641213,
0.0009014733,
0.0896589458,
-0.0191175174,
-0.0626287982,
0.1116199046,
-0.0477729999,
-0.0046182214,
-0.0072135534,
-0.0308434628,
-0.0123167802,
0.0298411269,
-0.0102388049,
0.0142971119,
0.0640478507,
0.0094627095,
-0.0455953814,
-0.0419516489,
0.0116392169,
-0.0000090708,
0.0270660538,
-0.0445763953,
-0.0018678551,
0.0015663906,
-0.0202026945,
-0.0342421047,
-0.087380074,
-0.0512149036,
0.0307980441,
0.0007786409,
-0.031111585,
0.0126771452,
-0.0201785117,
0.0296456236,
0.0459161885,
-0.0066926023,
-0.00576329,
-0.0194693413,
-0.0062691816,
0.0605912395,
0.0423538014,
0.0326661617,
-0.0425207168,
0.0387715586,
-0.0029849447,
0.0248195827,
0.021545656,
-0.0546965636,
0.0012979495,
-0.000280596,
-0.0006021892,
0.0031822247,
0.0676331669,
0.0827283561,
-0.0656512305,
0.0134484004,
0.1390695125,
0.0167175867,
-0.0377116203,
0.022003442,
0.0115616815,
0.051665727,
0.0346387997,
0.0245070308,
-0.0812948868,
-0.0556616858,
0.0037189769,
0.0514707528,
0.0013906549,
-0.0043786908,
-0.0131763332,
-0.1244452298,
0.0320596695,
-0.003773541,
-0.0034059668,
-0.0030342832,
-0.0520399511,
-0.0119791646,
-0.0010664794,
-0.0006695796,
0.0005486091,
0.0255269166,
0.0080635222,
0.019929165,
-0.0098106461,
-0.0870388672,
0.0646144822,
-0.0559818745,
0.0730183348,
0.0704967305,
-0.0095104827,
0.0027777352,
-0.0218633935,
0.0119225569,
0.0148897404,
0.0490552299,
0.0013003086,
0.0429590829,
0.0050232601,
-0.0165795684,
0.0085248584,
0.040961355,
-0.0297840741,
-0.0170822497,
-0.0067640436,
0.0601918958,
-0.0323451012,
-0.0217398331,
0.0105817309,
0.0096967844,
0.0283061638,
0.091557458,
0.0537096597,
-0.0356813334,
-0.0426750928,
-0.0121758878,
-0.0158604681,
-0.0512287207,
-0.0413401388,
0.0005929736,
0.0297739562,
-0.0149456812,
-0.048342336,
-0.0348343104,
0.0531328358,
0.0343650766,
0.0139817679,
-0.021998927,
-0.028180426,
0.0192591399,
0.0008175396,
0.0730186626,
-0.0040292842,
0.0180801935,
-0.0654759407,
-0.0147464555,
0.0405983888,
-0.0424564295,
0.0118358303,
0.0097026927,
-0.0492039435,
-0.0581851229,
-0.0257808566,
0.0754639953,
0.0231851656,
0.0544128716,
-0.0386043452,
-0.0897739381,
0.0603468865,
0.0691250786,
-0.0486395024,
-0.0232016966,
0.0294213593,
-0.0229804944,
-0.0184841696,
0.0481410697,
-0.0452724136,
0.0015128364,
0.0217879247,
0.0220253281,
-0.0115880556,
-0.0704230219,
0.0390801094,
0.0074911742,
0.0647831038,
-0.0523722395,
-0.0233593155,
-0.0186704099,
0.003011853,
-0.0191127956,
-0.0175512917,
-0.0496281758,
0.0176989902,
-0.0070636589,
-0.0189579893,
0.021006098,
-0.0520647205,
-0.0302705579,
0.0517210029,
-0.0341386907,
0.0110244462,
0.0308042672,
-0.0094532594,
0.0183815751,
0.0180897713,
-0.0157875083,
0.0246212799,
-0.0276459865,
0.0199282896,
-0.0071998616,
0.0725485981,
0.0243780781,
0.0160656404,
-0.0303609483,
0.0539687425,
-0.0557479151,
-0.085169144,
-0.0344044976,
0.0222738311,
0.0216645747,
0.0023063433,
0.0256757047,
-0.0223503374,
-0.0055171167,
-0.0165756829,
0.0617585815,
0.0149547551,
-0.011101963,
0.033303678,
0.0453618541,
-0.031797599,
0.0154975345,
0.0819260105,
0.0197462905,
0.0362729281,
0.0151814055,
0.0024894669,
-0.0238141175,
-0.0059299567,
-0.0054954831,
0.0562699996,
-0.023549648,
0.0220720973,
-0.0427378453,
-0.0482107028,
-0.0136543978,
0.0187360905,
-0.003164253,
-0.0141414097,
0.0413655862,
0.0637041554,
-0.0311970655,
0.0194543097,
-0.0356812663,
-0.0299363825,
-0.0028934286,
-0.0028660896,
-0.0365786143,
-7.055528683e-33,
-0.0277534947,
-0.029124245,
0.014035318,
-0.0170481615,
-0.0030150246,
-0.004727202,
-0.0510474518,
0.0089215348,
-0.0420559272,
0.0229226872,
-0.0287599768,
-0.0063132616,
0.0135349901,
0.0226226673,
0.0111126089,
-0.0201915875,
0.0529729761,
-0.0141316447,
-0.0441140644,
0.0403438918,
0.0190622229,
0.0105318343,
0.0410251357,
-0.0451820008,
0.0483343229,
0.0422933437,
-0.0371442735,
0.0163494218,
-0.0306544472,
0.0467439331,
-0.023772791,
0.0155680776,
-0.0021925315,
-0.0494043157,
-0.0172523465,
0.0098421294,
-0.0216172431,
-0.0265562981,
0.0219065174,
-0.0382166989,
-0.0167043991,
-0.036602594,
0.0187507123,
-0.0388314091,
-0.0217322297,
0.0042810785,
0.0205515996,
-0.0101760346,
-0.0057670954,
-0.021191746,
-0.0392434224,
0.0106126964,
-0.0307169594,
-0.0595069118,
-0.0000056145,
0.0504800901,
-0.0323226824,
0.0512730516,
-0.0308246054,
0.008772471,
0.0551205277,
0.037997853,
0.0676878691,
0.0004971132,
-0.022477217,
0.0600251667,
0.0121231396,
0.0126689738,
-0.0619502105,
0.0004051619,
0.020227639,
0.0560961664,
0.0825390145,
0.0526649766,
0.0362599045,
0.0262765307,
-0.0458936058,
0.0340654477,
-0.0223123934,
0.0490144752,
0.058799725,
-0.0019833022,
-0.0291035194,
-0.0339225233,
-0.0561619103,
-0.0344031192,
-0.0444201045,
-0.0320558101,
0.0270269345,
0.014466078,
-0.057290405,
-0.0125578456,
0.0251678098,
-0.0393024795,
0.0508625507,
0.0133216986,
-0.02486353,
-0.0031440489,
-0.0031245954,
0.0051932489,
-0.0340943187,
0.0055705844,
0.0304786153,
0.0252604447,
0.0267307386,
0.0154591184,
0.0271023847,
0.041516725,
-0.031169774,
0.0176118165,
-0.0498762056,
0.0146820629,
-0.0151000964,
0.0044907378,
0.0149077214,
-0.0044414438,
-0.0403225459,
0.0365833603,
-0.0185358822,
-0.0359782316,
0.0059073516,
-0.0082481233,
0.0015964654,
0.0084045883,
-0.0275416654,
-0.0105256764,
-0.0387527049,
-0.004526922,
0.0460061021,
-0.0004356732,
-0.0164141264,
0.0139356237,
2.904e-7,
-0.015849093,
0.0290560592,
0.0021661364,
0.0033970771,
0.0043017967,
0.0676803291,
-0.0042321207,
-0.009023319,
0.0066758348,
-0.0482733287,
0.0345046595,
0.0271605495,
0.0613907389,
0.0083547812,
-0.0550467484,
-0.0155683914,
-0.0815889984,
-0.0158697497,
-0.0696354434,
-0.0180631708,
0.066791147,
0.1034940407,
0.0113003803,
-0.0112532983,
0.0193796493,
-0.0204821788,
0.0207621586,
-0.0459772311,
0.0012178075,
0.0074092355,
0.0522734337,
-0.0152048673,
-0.0073004216,
0.0062554684,
-0.0294938032,
0.0001801516,
-0.043136131,
0.0892717317,
-0.0163893513,
-0.0231523663,
-0.018469587,
-0.0157815292,
0.0077033732,
-0.0649612471,
0.0720100254,
-0.0643534958,
-0.0277529899,
-0.0306234825,
-0.0066763461,
-0.0389631689,
0.0089988671,
-0.0473665372,
0.0086054513,
0.007209111,
-0.0127264513,
-0.0038980651,
-0.0107552623,
-0.0803946108,
-0.0294092782,
0.0133223515,
-0.0264762249,
-0.0022018948,
-0.0272032153,
-0.0324187838,
0.037235748,
-0.0503280908,
0.0152314063,
2.80359145e-34,
0.0263843611,
0.0070084911,
0.0279568192,
0.0178762898,
0.0343118832,
0.0435295776,
-0.0107927667,
-0.0093626827,
0.0642399862,
-0.0707293227,
-0.0291693732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13230v2 | To Repeat or Not To Repeat: Insights from Scaling LLM under Token-Crisis | 2023-05-22T17:02:15 | 2023-10-05T14:58:02 | Fuzhao Xue, Yao Fu, Wangchunshu Zhou, Zangwei Zheng, Yang You | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent research has highlighted the importance of dataset size in scaling
language models. However, large language models (LLMs) are notoriously
token-hungry during pre-training, and high-quality text data on the web is
approaching its scaling limit for LLMs. To further enhance LLMs, a
straightforward approach is to repeat the pre-training data for additional
epochs. In this study, we empirically investigate three key aspects under this
approach. First, we explore the consequences of repeating pre-training data,
revealing that the model is susceptible to overfitting, leading to multi-epoch
degradation. Second, we examine the key factors contributing to multi-epoch
degradation, finding that significant factors include dataset size, model
parameters, and training objectives, while less influential factors consist of
dataset quality and model FLOPs. Finally, we explore whether widely used
regularization can alleviate multi-epoch degradation. Most regularization
techniques do not yield significant improvements, except for dropout, which
demonstrates remarkable effectiveness but requires careful tuning when scaling
up the model size. Additionally, we discover that leveraging mixture-of-experts
(MoE) enables cost-effective and efficient hyper-parameter tuning for
computationally intensive dense LLMs with comparable trainable parameters,
potentially impacting efficient LLM development on a broader scale. | [
0.0246205796,
0.1064247265,
0.0032194341,
0.024653649,
0.0123855369,
0.0166826434,
0.0133969048,
0.0374492668,
-0.0205314197,
-0.0292182099,
-0.0326510929,
-0.0311645791,
0.0037302668,
0.0136148492,
0.0262045246,
-0.046081271,
0.0304149203,
-0.0381512716,
-0.0059403428,
-0.0256638341,
0.0316593088,
0.0005439214,
0.0500131361,
0.0368683785,
-0.0352677666,
0.0148301981,
0.010228212,
0.031194197,
0.0034277691,
-0.0124724293,
-0.0074571273,
0.059835881,
0.0493111573,
0.0510495864,
0.0000019429,
-0.0457534157,
-0.0117078004,
-0.00826455,
-0.0441458896,
0.0590569526,
0.0255985502,
-0.0029531231,
0.0023325952,
0.0332385972,
0.0087005058,
-0.0186679643,
0.0408724807,
0.0523958094,
0.0421899855,
0.092350848,
0.0001485589,
0.010581187,
0.0539754294,
-0.0375360809,
-0.0278765541,
-0.0474506207,
0.0336484872,
-0.0099308006,
-0.0162477251,
-0.0067857732,
-0.0070863497,
0.0089253159,
0.0120555116,
0.0208173208,
0.0042395308,
0.0422588922,
-0.0367806144,
-0.0143554416,
-0.0250477977,
0.053375259,
-0.056689661,
-0.0245936438,
-0.0044534639,
-0.0086346958,
-0.0141691007,
-0.027878629,
-0.0468050577,
0.0075175362,
0.0391118638,
0.0383473597,
-0.0185927097,
-0.0362508968,
0.0626310036,
0.0378826931,
-0.0410014652,
0.011747973,
0.0218576603,
0.0030256456,
-0.0087853279,
0.0126908962,
-0.0400173888,
-0.0280915573,
0.0117713539,
0.02191169,
-0.0267005675,
0.0216020457,
-0.0476620421,
-0.0400150456,
0.0308872648,
-0.0222747829,
0.0286315978,
0.017733248,
-0.029291397,
0.0418807045,
-0.004217763,
-0.0085200826,
0.0042030951,
0.0335077159,
-0.041290652,
-0.0084865494,
-0.0258027222,
0.0092979595,
-0.0326430462,
0.0324599221,
0.0378181338,
0.0032816422,
-0.02143047,
0.0093414467,
0.0229378399,
0.0043436368,
0.0164650846,
0.0023638625,
-0.0436601713,
-0.022332862,
0.0098286625,
0.0403639227,
-0.0402779169,
0.0184096396,
0.0123784486,
-0.0643611029,
-0.0262330603,
0.040722914,
0.0099200867,
-0.0096728401,
0.026665926,
0.0417810418,
-0.0147354668,
-0.034377221,
-0.0533861667,
0.00185304,
-0.0140420189,
-0.0479501598,
-0.063105315,
-0.0623831302,
0.0352623463,
0.0088867769,
0.0117140179,
-0.05633175,
0.0010904218,
-0.0134320231,
-0.0412135907,
0.0336542837,
-0.0701207966,
0.0034348064,
0.0265870821,
0.0092952745,
-0.0105506005,
0.083069928,
0.0255068336,
0.0254611615,
0.0486021191,
0.0015628805,
-0.0214004125,
0.0542870015,
0.0239397548,
0.0625475794,
-0.0350210257,
-0.015667269,
0.0210603345,
0.0427945964,
0.0478004254,
0.0794195533,
-0.0509384908,
-0.0140428338,
0.0595946945,
0.0420820676,
0.0035634954,
0.0304527767,
0.0004487563,
0.0062525207,
0.0164365321,
-0.0042023305,
-0.0476014428,
-0.0203076135,
0.0150535917,
-0.0206158217,
0.0560108237,
0.0648427159,
-0.0486839339,
-0.0524719693,
-0.0214703698,
-0.0158032738,
-0.0443695746,
0.0094106412,
0.0668693185,
-0.0403541476,
-0.0026867127,
0.0688465238,
0.0349778347,
-0.0439305119,
0.027245257,
-0.059222687,
-0.010360999,
0.0576334111,
0.0362859517,
-0.0320661254,
-0.0276365485,
-0.0139514189,
0.0472580455,
0.0072196419,
0.0361836925,
-0.0038663091,
0.040016897,
-0.0539518185,
-0.0521890856,
0.022759106,
-0.0045990902,
0.0170049127,
0.0274663605,
0.0346730724,
0.035233859,
-0.0618493706,
-0.0507895201,
0.0435577855,
-0.0435505882,
-0.0121059855,
0.0087581724,
-0.0101663899,
0.0098015247,
-0.0031953652,
-0.0211616866,
-0.0056068045,
0.0382546335,
-0.0272571053,
-0.0271360967,
-0.0281343497,
-0.060324382,
-0.0068589738,
0.0672833696,
0.0109345708,
0.0255532712,
-0.0063075935,
-0.0617995784,
-0.0575813092,
0.0059017921,
-0.0182304271,
0.0924957395,
-0.0395118184,
0.0327657945,
-0.0277574956,
0.047432404,
-0.0305109359,
0.0153081315,
-0.0267906431,
-0.0034284019,
-0.0083149252,
-0.0025316223,
0.029508166,
-0.0260703228,
-0.0412531085,
-0.0177772734,
-0.0111644259,
0.0555903539,
0.0213829428,
0.0095561026,
-0.0415179916,
-0.0306326672,
-0.0898282453,
-0.0179998707,
-0.0432194062,
0.0061357375,
0.0017254066,
0.0084855994,
-0.0291148052,
-0.0167997964,
-0.0049882615,
-0.0020127802,
-0.0324378982,
0.0228013843,
0.0115339104,
0.0121744536,
-0.0250982959,
-0.0303385369,
-0.0374416411,
0.0244901348,
0.0534872375,
-0.0404913016,
-0.0194462314,
-0.073979035,
0.0096010612,
-0.0445376411,
0.0140794506,
-0.0090058902,
-0.0162091441,
-0.0006881587,
-0.0182130914,
0.0509110801,
0.0239826124,
0.0100317365,
0.0416838937,
0.0579371862,
0.0269293655,
-0.0713638365,
-0.0082424395,
0.0201876368,
-0.0285744797,
-0.0420180075,
-0.0061042206,
-0.0111277895,
0.0456406735,
-0.0352034569,
-0.0086341714,
0.0048161633,
-0.0109219188,
-0.0165219922,
-0.0261758585,
-0.019004954,
0.0086722644,
-0.0188830998,
0.0464697368,
0.0107024144,
-0.0800058469,
0.0441167988,
-0.0229141917,
0.0183924381,
0.0119047519,
-0.0311513301,
-0.0351051725,
0.0191193651,
-0.0058935708,
0.0148783028,
-0.0306820422,
-0.0222512148,
-0.0429185368,
0.0028082507,
-0.0136041995,
-0.0117320865,
0.0478074215,
-0.0204182733,
0.0315223746,
-0.024360342,
-0.0483293869,
-0.0392336659,
-0.0211034454,
-0.0280853566,
-0.0195099767,
0.0234383903,
-0.0147456266,
-0.0556665994,
0.0056212218,
-0.0028558902,
0.0520358123,
-0.0140418988,
0.0015929068,
0.0037733929,
0.0647005439,
0.0380514748,
0.0183780249,
0.022023337,
-0.0439526848,
0.0271615498,
0.0535480604,
0.0661245957,
-0.0529018827,
-0.0519851968,
-0.0139103038,
0.0495826229,
-0.0296496693,
-0.011028314,
0.0265337825,
0.0437641479,
-0.0495078415,
-0.0038527423,
0.0983354375,
0.0066181193,
-0.0805343986,
0.0180253834,
-0.0107414452,
0.1098064855,
0.0149084171,
0.0256739911,
-0.049498979,
-0.0248149522,
0.0191939771,
0.0070898123,
0.0315434039,
-0.0047583673,
-0.003749955,
-0.059139207,
0.0033790348,
0.0179466456,
-0.0345544554,
0.0204105135,
-0.0636391714,
-0.0131767485,
-0.0307943374,
0.0828163326,
0.0188708138,
-0.0082007116,
-0.0160871781,
0.0485182926,
-0.0020483797,
-0.0664581433,
0.0211282074,
-0.0462263413,
0.0582886375,
-0.0041013397,
0.0048382096,
-0.0097073223,
-0.032069277,
0.0723295584,
0.0260630995,
0.0074731102,
-0.0272413436,
0.0466356948,
-0.0135306045,
-0.0136533771,
0.0302318893,
0.0136299413,
-0.0099281147,
-0.0101684602,
0.0178106185,
0.0606350712,
-0.0096189249,
-0.0274764337,
-0.0113825668,
-0.0626602471,
-0.0265869945,
0.0598574206,
0.0320534967,
-0.0465352647,
-0.0232158266,
-0.0201778319,
-0.0301759224,
-0.0364903547,
0.0062204562,
0.0221892409,
-0.0019737105,
-0.0303465743,
-0.0090078069,
-0.0051844507,
0.0189008154,
0.0454638563,
-0.0008690155,
0.0198468361,
-0.0254230965,
0.0226789042,
-0.0372214355,
0.0581344329,
-0.0540299341,
-0.0080456082,
-0.0956300572,
-0.0041858871,
0.0084140562,
0.0029542879,
0.0002548922,
-0.0037910882,
-0.1379833817,
-0.0615745597,
-0.014012631,
0.0338576548,
0.0138037913,
0.0486373939,
0.0325218663,
-0.1068305597,
0.0705743954,
0.039415285,
-0.0336070806,
-0.0101412721,
0.0254763383,
-0.0190636944,
-0.0082496889,
0.0410124213,
-0.0428926013,
0.0140572842,
0.0376351178,
0.0396996848,
-0.0164814778,
-0.007907181,
-0.0219742563,
0.0317222849,
0.0296801496,
-0.0645830855,
-0.0126620997,
-0.0133551201,
0.0104296673,
0.0157009792,
0.0131779807,
-0.0182596594,
0.0236374438,
0.0108747035,
0.0020530885,
-0.0297615789,
-0.0107164467,
0.0171114616,
0.0132909277,
-0.0247862358,
0.0154411718,
-0.029553296,
-0.0153530668,
0.059422262,
-0.0072763744,
-0.0197573639,
0.006997434,
0.0066862493,
-0.0044356515,
-0.0464168712,
-0.0172924567,
-0.0006877697,
0.0390910357,
-0.0294306818,
0.0454378687,
-0.0480238274,
-0.061230991,
-0.0400259867,
0.0201905388,
0.0521246828,
-0.0104029356,
0.0609909073,
0.0115339449,
-0.002862127,
-0.034109965,
-0.0139219649,
-0.0257431176,
-0.0208826941,
0.0241411254,
-0.0005811348,
-0.0488257669,
0.0645852834,
0.1021439955,
0.0279791765,
0.0236662813,
0.0159889162,
0.0135645159,
-0.0255614761,
-0.005884164,
0.0202808939,
0.0373816043,
-0.0374919586,
-0.0360846259,
0.0006142134,
-0.0709126592,
-0.0112931607,
-0.0339100622,
-0.0037173864,
0.0215785913,
0.0227829646,
0.0530702844,
-0.0232092515,
0.0322744399,
-0.002147465,
0.0012781199,
0.0556653999,
-0.0310313981,
0.0428686254,
-6.676469223e-33,
0.0266148988,
0.0279915594,
0.0057945168,
-0.0216470174,
-0.0117205884,
0.0229906812,
-0.005709602,
-0.0054819379,
-0.0147447027,
-0.0242403876,
-0.0487658307,
-0.0030433598,
0.0174482018,
0.0534275025,
0.0229966473,
0.0137173086,
0.0595420673,
-0.0239884779,
-0.002417567,
0.0376214087,
0.0123376288,
0.0467770658,
0.0647185072,
-0.0167186186,
-0.0262745488,
0.041113317,
-0.0099841161,
0.0142988758,
0.0526991896,
0.0262368154,
-0.0397291891,
0.0842651501,
0.0380649306,
-0.0465383269,
-0.0424816646,
-0.050757084,
-0.0702638328,
-0.0132372696,
-0.0004945262,
0.005948999,
0.0152447876,
-0.012946954,
0.0603524558,
0.002332089,
-0.0274584237,
-0.012522527,
0.0317829289,
-0.0017433837,
-0.078623876,
-0.0266973395,
-0.0233622603,
0.0511465333,
-0.0048239324,
0.0314577892,
0.0130498381,
-0.0041392576,
-0.0115134008,
0.0442232229,
-0.0508137904,
0.0060571996,
0.0247787368,
0.0705951974,
0.05645293,
0.0416530892,
-0.0168723315,
0.0607846156,
0.0169789307,
0.0153413219,
0.000348063,
0.0209084526,
0.0839050487,
0.0246085841,
0.0297299139,
0.007732769,
0.0463318676,
-0.0623444133,
-0.0685787201,
0.0311037991,
0.0215196647,
0.0313631929,
0.0140527813,
0.0530793369,
0.0087380344,
-0.0438729525,
-0.0235796832,
-0.0259990096,
-0.0338643007,
-0.0171402786,
0.0039063692,
0.0332171805,
-0.0348137654,
-0.0021220369,
0.0278674103,
-0.0489716865,
-0.0568296984,
0.0145489899,
0.0020835323,
0.0117338095,
0.0134216715,
0.0277641714,
-0.0636232197,
-0.0665237457,
0.0024035603,
-0.0127262464,
0.0137077132,
-0.024378486,
0.0385337137,
0.0160056818,
-0.0758524239,
-0.0172893927,
-0.0275665857,
-0.0160070173,
0.0483175181,
0.0401790515,
0.0367640369,
-0.0125202518,
0.0184487142,
0.0367476121,
0.0196978766,
-0.0112000108,
-0.0155589394,
-0.0215816498,
0.0227851197,
0.0139293429,
-0.0250538737,
0.0050271195,
-0.051666081,
-0.0229189023,
0.0468460917,
-0.0740088895,
-0.0388413072,
-0.0174860992,
2.55e-7,
0.013784145,
0.0608331449,
0.0139111318,
-0.0427086093,
0.0026016894,
0.0063841417,
-0.0299954787,
0.0059585753,
-0.0238498896,
0.0066399085,
0.039752081,
0.0325684808,
0.0540891811,
0.0276371147,
-0.0794757828,
-0.0149428034,
-0.0835222006,
0.045223821,
-0.0643015951,
-0.0057689245,
0.0069760322,
0.134600237,
0.0235523693,
-0.0564746372,
0.0122211827,
-0.0479229242,
0.0449319445,
-0.0437814929,
0.0101115238,
0.0370930322,
0.0545710847,
0.0530831032,
0.0041163708,
-0.0077577177,
-0.0348539837,
0.00204485,
0.0068176594,
0.053318169,
-0.0137867639,
-0.0098955519,
0.0251874924,
-0.0007720226,
-0.0002404398,
-0.0625809059,
0.0724036768,
-0.0053554801,
-0.0003132724,
-0.0458825268,
0.0139099257,
-0.0464004241,
0.0364870913,
-0.0492803156,
-0.0251177233,
0.0664885715,
0.0336119868,
-0.0146674309,
-0.041399844,
-0.0896821916,
-0.0134362606,
-0.006279462,
-0.0583165661,
-0.0528752916,
-0.0523261204,
-0.0045761541,
0.0267141536,
-0.0301051512,
0.00341888,
2.559181149e-34,
0.0683709234,
-0.0423948243,
0.0064769164,
0.0224190224,
0.0114910472,
-0.0137193659,
0.0139236432,
0.0150180105,
-0.0320878252,
-0.0867076889,
-0.0204450004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.01753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01753v1 | Preconditioned Visual Language Inference with Weak Supervision | 2023-05-22T16:57:52 | 2023-05-22T16:57:52 | Ehsan Qasemi, Amani R. Maina-Kilaas, Devadutta Dash, Khalid Alsaggaf, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans can infer the affordance of objects by extracting related contextual
preconditions for each scenario. For example, upon seeing an image of a broken
cup, we can infer that this precondition prevents the cup from being used for
drinking. Reasoning with preconditions of commonsense is studied in NLP where
the model explicitly gets the contextual precondition. However, it is unclear
if SOTA visual language models (VLMs) can extract such preconditions and infer
the affordance of objects with them. In this work, we introduce the task of
preconditioned visual language inference and rationalization (PVLIR). We
propose a learning resource based on three strategies to retrieve weak
supervision signals for the task and develop a human-verified test set for
evaluation. Our results reveal the shortcomings of SOTA VLM models in the task
and draw a road map to address the challenges ahead in improving them. | [
0.0161867253,
0.0720215589,
-0.0111306924,
0.0491166189,
-0.0144088315,
0.0208676979,
0.0073488648,
0.0243797712,
0.0316168331,
-0.0352038816,
-0.0230894107,
-0.0098112216,
0.0019797678,
0.0200928897,
0.0309228804,
-0.068075791,
0.0121465754,
-0.017732257,
0.001238129,
0.0021220248,
0.0193327032,
0.0156280864,
-0.0018859974,
0.0249410365,
-0.0349028148,
-0.020668637,
0.0173805207,
-0.0012847993,
-0.0040113716,
-0.0295548495,
-0.0283980202,
0.0564156026,
0.0663298294,
-0.0892890617,
0.0000020517,
-0.017727958,
0.0324536152,
-0.0210944228,
0.044318039,
0.011658323,
-0.0163654089,
-0.0840675533,
0.0361156166,
-0.0294474941,
-0.054466445,
-0.0119529497,
0.0398361608,
0.0720641166,
0.0526293814,
0.0017283717,
-0.030598687,
0.0007136544,
-0.0275190491,
-0.0071309586,
0.0162496977,
-0.0651923344,
0.0054958481,
0.0459474772,
0.0073072063,
-0.0288689919,
-0.0486190319,
0.0369091071,
0.0580395684,
-0.0260256156,
-0.0372328535,
0.0353151299,
-0.0108405957,
-0.0474986471,
-0.0196631476,
0.0819044337,
0.0103036361,
-0.0473336354,
-0.0038222126,
-0.0062608742,
0.0170198809,
0.0502227396,
-0.0334008895,
0.0471987836,
-0.0038392842,
0.0287959687,
0.0114823105,
0.0176856406,
-0.0203325618,
0.0163159072,
0.0429948159,
0.0100494074,
0.009723166,
-0.0025022011,
-0.0126745207,
0.0432107449,
-0.0926930159,
-0.0157139022,
-0.0303864907,
0.0278558582,
-0.0035796978,
-0.0099172089,
-0.0469470173,
-0.0081505999,
-0.0271347594,
-0.010255415,
0.0355536565,
-0.0027527213,
-0.0534361899,
0.0588079132,
-0.0493096262,
0.0277465712,
-0.0295772515,
0.032958407,
-0.0036756692,
0.0101736058,
-0.0158986282,
0.0023005465,
-0.0382285789,
-0.0005728831,
-0.0804938301,
-0.0302382428,
0.004682193,
-0.0122272186,
-0.0329013802,
-0.0162370317,
0.003020379,
0.0477352813,
-0.0080352928,
-0.0181666892,
-0.0542130247,
0.000078392,
-0.04163846,
0.0452114753,
-0.0433262885,
-0.020339584,
-0.0249828827,
0.0438795201,
0.0324962661,
-0.0353307314,
-0.0099454653,
0.0403332002,
-0.0282860547,
-0.0060624122,
-0.0691143125,
-0.0518678539,
-0.0011525701,
-0.0241224337,
0.021962788,
-0.0478624478,
-0.0124546569,
-0.023259772,
0.001782508,
-0.0165092666,
-0.0191998277,
-0.0047581368,
-0.0143849468,
0.0954122692,
-0.0219272636,
-0.0050083697,
-0.0284582954,
0.0270697959,
0.0102721211,
0.0661942363,
-0.0501436368,
0.0351580568,
0.0177314822,
0.0112350378,
0.0314046293,
0.0060100364,
0.0218092576,
0.0189192928,
-0.0618779808,
-0.0152144004,
0.0037459475,
-0.0202333014,
0.0374398194,
0.0346463323,
-0.0438188724,
-0.0152981421,
0.0648446977,
0.0741736889,
-0.0122865709,
-0.003124302,
0.0766872466,
-0.0185216628,
-0.0090468712,
0.0428640246,
-0.0794983506,
0.052031219,
-0.0177260339,
-0.0159753785,
-0.0573470481,
-0.0035519141,
-0.0379137024,
-0.0550788864,
0.0007045622,
-0.012357384,
-0.0044013271,
-0.0076634651,
0.0240769908,
0.0597468428,
-0.0272423718,
-0.0155173279,
0.0297576133,
-0.0616644137,
-0.0043161996,
-0.0238666609,
0.0650344342,
0.0334932171,
0.0316147469,
-0.0123073924,
0.0242187958,
0.028076943,
0.0652850494,
0.0292313825,
0.0125264702,
0.013107867,
0.0163815822,
-0.0086771082,
-0.0145542827,
-0.022736283,
0.0315928347,
-0.0081343232,
0.0215404835,
-0.0190088097,
-0.0166764539,
-0.0284259357,
0.019550737,
0.034179274,
0.0470769815,
0.0039231614,
-0.0488032624,
0.0546860546,
-0.0051673045,
-0.0228493586,
0.0096922759,
-0.0043844092,
-0.0229437035,
-0.042403888,
-0.0051120585,
0.0367287397,
-0.0734981149,
-0.0651942417,
0.0059494618,
-0.0842331499,
-0.0412599631,
-0.0009719148,
-0.0188944377,
-0.0102266911,
0.0645934269,
0.0312834457,
0.0201737508,
-0.0645926073,
-0.0309690759,
0.0199988838,
0.0113734752,
0.0142389638,
0.0818509236,
-0.0211602133,
-0.0225759838,
0.0107757999,
0.0285509508,
-0.0109591885,
-0.0179747175,
-0.0128278304,
-0.027943885,
-0.0188571233,
-0.0041525057,
-0.0073230932,
0.0562220849,
-0.032560166,
0.0315185562,
-0.0739995986,
-0.0561219379,
-0.0283648223,
-0.0222169776,
0.0131438011,
-0.0313364007,
0.0068634413,
-0.0344978236,
0.022021573,
0.0464576371,
-0.0265340414,
0.0154296141,
0.0557961762,
-0.0338645615,
0.0228557847,
-0.0198073573,
-0.0077760019,
-0.0023957195,
0.0661319569,
0.0355145335,
0.0232997965,
-0.0272329822,
0.0391586795,
-0.0243601147,
0.0632892773,
-0.0032924365,
-0.0222815797,
0.0299277697,
-0.035711661,
0.0366995148,
0.0963664651,
-0.0319427513,
0.0423971638,
0.0109275365,
-0.0266318675,
-0.0178602543,
-0.0229470115,
-0.0161655191,
-0.0174369011,
0.0094313323,
0.0012276985,
-0.0300283413,
0.0625855178,
-0.0441511013,
-0.0002274412,
-0.1019707322,
0.031203039,
-0.0031063966,
-0.0363370143,
-0.0405580662,
-0.0200695731,
0.0293914713,
0.0426169708,
-0.0527861789,
-0.0667449459,
0.0793725997,
-0.0144526614,
0.0101428991,
0.0375556052,
0.0030039614,
-0.0344548784,
0.1026662067,
0.0217689183,
-0.0187534224,
-0.0096193328,
-0.0017146964,
-0.0577512868,
-0.0209073331,
0.0413423143,
0.0392710678,
0.0389495231,
-0.1127402559,
0.0293858908,
-0.0145128965,
-0.0155279422,
-0.0193705093,
-0.0284657646,
-0.0178218894,
-0.0131681841,
-0.0393431894,
-0.0112425257,
0.0198014509,
0.0424367785,
-0.0151549671,
0.0125713507,
0.0195439048,
0.0108594215,
-0.0298595764,
0.0071479473,
0.0653421655,
0.0029733258,
-0.0333868191,
-0.0411437415,
0.0275718719,
0.0652978644,
0.0181836672,
-0.0220944565,
-0.0574194528,
0.0802712366,
0.0020003379,
0.0534080304,
0.019596789,
0.0313113667,
0.0534476824,
-0.0338815562,
-0.0040961266,
0.0512948111,
0.0085763922,
-0.0255086813,
-0.0100023225,
0.0158836711,
0.0412945375,
0.0443825871,
-0.003046354,
-0.0821168795,
-0.047917407,
-0.0205318127,
-0.0140896104,
0.0228205398,
-0.0412923768,
-0.0184227265,
-0.0953040048,
0.0723594204,
-0.0331650637,
-0.0270078164,
-0.0224889871,
-0.0186664015,
0.0111560281,
-0.024211701,
-0.0327857211,
-0.0173125062,
-0.0085258922,
0.0360538922,
-0.0095075099,
0.0274541546,
-0.0146445278,
0.024719784,
-0.0599925257,
-0.0051493375,
-0.0230255555,
0.0132612577,
0.0252992902,
-0.0900233313,
0.0262498464,
-0.0500034019,
0.013817301,
-0.0232021529,
0.0206748359,
-0.0047350549,
-0.0452477559,
-0.0007065278,
0.068895705,
0.0048405523,
-0.0618896969,
-0.0296475552,
0.0497935377,
-0.0177351311,
-0.0549554564,
-0.0002647212,
0.0063594682,
-0.0008369613,
0.0403331742,
0.0767034814,
-0.0187498461,
-0.0570132695,
0.0326870345,
-0.0162698943,
-0.0392598398,
-0.0483604819,
-0.0308703054,
0.0170801058,
-0.0328044184,
-0.0694895312,
0.0017062959,
0.030367149,
0.0751006901,
-0.0125014987,
-0.0370482206,
0.0136755127,
-0.0248691197,
-0.0322728343,
0.1105623096,
-0.0584958419,
-0.0017103009,
-0.0288628545,
0.011963251,
0.0283645913,
-0.0322617181,
-0.0140800998,
0.0019363782,
-0.0116062323,
-0.0218707919,
-0.0390027426,
0.0878568515,
0.0129527207,
0.0338157229,
-0.019003978,
-0.0393380746,
0.0015689093,
0.0484886877,
0.0147057064,
0.0276442133,
-0.0127566671,
-0.053791713,
0.028508544,
0.0263761077,
0.0107014859,
0.0605778806,
0.0522175282,
0.0348412283,
-0.0153946225,
0.0251887664,
0.0289655998,
0.0021913063,
0.0547528937,
-0.0203003213,
0.0244606789,
-0.0526225381,
-0.0126494598,
0.016644761,
-0.006608306,
-0.0751965269,
0.0508099087,
0.0064078593,
0.0419247821,
0.0045563728,
-0.0340288319,
-0.0043123709,
0.0453080051,
-0.0148365358,
-0.0066564283,
0.0665697381,
-0.0096214339,
-0.0244232956,
0.0110197254,
0.0217777304,
0.0064809145,
-0.0436061472,
0.0574810877,
0.0001969291,
0.0751745924,
0.0577507392,
0.002787583,
-0.0183918681,
0.0224774927,
-0.0065773679,
0.0074719829,
0.0019323174,
0.0595737956,
0.0499204919,
-0.0526151359,
0.0258984603,
-0.0036256369,
-0.0122586405,
0.0389879011,
0.0464036837,
0.012102142,
-0.0512040034,
0.0765413567,
0.029283721,
0.0087358411,
0.01556738,
0.0306882765,
-0.0395879745,
0.0247654784,
-0.0186001044,
0.0010341265,
-0.0223712418,
-0.0395460241,
0.0351245925,
-0.0260833912,
-0.0006374323,
0.0699420869,
-0.0392874852,
-0.0723608583,
-0.034249492,
0.0640500188,
-0.0271819644,
0.0635059699,
0.0227307584,
0.0427255109,
0.0262025371,
-0.0287405029,
0.0145700909,
-0.0331547372,
0.0060686413,
0.0017508686,
-0.0291798431,
-6.838434712e-33,
-0.0259929411,
-0.0488780476,
0.0373201631,
-0.0069131362,
0.0263939425,
0.0262108967,
-0.0326321311,
0.0093864808,
-0.0096172774,
0.0277571045,
0.0258095358,
-0.0071052448,
0.0024937622,
0.0265280977,
-0.0097628832,
-0.0380324461,
-0.0097445836,
0.0361288413,
-0.022473922,
-0.0102302339,
-0.0107347118,
-0.0152590116,
0.0456196778,
-0.0519144721,
-0.0082443357,
0.0187658444,
-0.0094921049,
0.0380434692,
-0.0004471657,
0.0267227851,
-0.0218873788,
-0.0318623669,
0.0241838749,
0.0190904811,
0.0071633789,
0.0559508912,
-0.0837455615,
-0.048492264,
0.0781132579,
-0.015867075,
-0.1137169302,
0.0323524326,
0.0046230089,
0.0219786502,
0.006122299,
0.0181655884,
0.051473204,
-0.0092714084,
0.0299258009,
0.0276820697,
-0.0372224674,
0.006261711,
-0.0238593947,
-0.0318008848,
0.0288301595,
0.0019112409,
-0.0168687254,
-0.0024573787,
0.0002798712,
0.0209231246,
-0.0106191086,
-0.0029402964,
0.0727047399,
0.0040129567,
0.0051578651,
0.0424673855,
-0.0339940339,
-0.0246322658,
-0.0787290335,
0.0005922726,
0.0220207535,
0.0853200704,
0.0491441786,
0.0169950537,
0.0227269437,
0.0550463721,
-0.0419803001,
-0.0081034219,
-0.0758491457,
0.0826325715,
-0.0238198061,
-0.0005167025,
0.0048016286,
-0.0138060246,
-0.0375360288,
-0.0380393341,
-0.0409655571,
0.0112029044,
0.0457359292,
0.0240301602,
-0.05212586,
0.044682283,
0.024624221,
-0.0246062763,
-0.0066633034,
-0.0039661224,
-0.0004367309,
0.0116299829,
-0.0041724443,
0.0200197455,
-0.0327927954,
-0.0296275876,
0.0633838698,
-0.0109843621,
0.0122600589,
-0.0075204857,
0.0634090677,
0.0085321013,
-0.0166693274,
-0.0082981968,
-0.0412835032,
-0.0046607442,
-0.0061001349,
0.0126462616,
0.0359494425,
0.0419826321,
-0.0376221687,
0.0054463735,
0.0110236546,
-0.0072913915,
-0.0284011811,
-0.0220166389,
-0.0163384359,
0.0231545381,
-0.0170296337,
-0.0141894696,
-0.02483638,
-0.0124671096,
0.0072470028,
-0.0738394037,
-0.005191186,
0.049109485,
2.757e-7,
0.0145980818,
-0.0044248416,
0.012405714,
-0.0201243497,
-0.0103978468,
0.0279544592,
0.0054087695,
-0.0007859896,
-0.0019936494,
-0.0682236627,
0.0242494289,
0.0778347403,
-0.0015779465,
-0.0075811539,
-0.0077658119,
0.0544165559,
-0.0502650626,
-0.0435920171,
-0.0377872586,
-0.0306175817,
0.0812891945,
0.0201777276,
-0.0016725495,
-0.0231738873,
0.0366912149,
-0.0720566809,
0.0437358283,
-0.0231328756,
-0.0024929405,
-0.0515006334,
0.0049604378,
0.0151174264,
-0.0107100541,
0.0496637933,
0.0079932315,
-0.0242459457,
0.0180238802,
-0.0010578446,
-0.0255049206,
0.0006407587,
-0.0298691522,
-0.0044747381,
-0.0142734461,
0.0002020617,
0.1199944988,
-0.0524379611,
-0.0053971894,
0.0156610366,
-0.0208814628,
-0.018544523,
0.012721071,
-0.0156625286,
-0.0128388368,
0.0363904722,
0.045640748,
-0.009208587,
-0.0473035648,
-0.0782775879,
-0.0025890442,
0.0015385661,
0.0110198036,
-0.0025349797,
-0.0294279791,
0.0167295765,
0.0348773822,
-0.0213370416,
-0.0640827194,
2.025808852e-34,
0.0165920369,
0.0002186956,
0.0185974967,
0.0127295991,
0.046752058,
0.0032896022,
-0.0281223953,
0.0082771415,
0.0100600207,
-0.0404840708,
-0.0080016563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13225v2 | Multi-Task Instruction Tuning of LLaMa for Specific Scenarios: A Preliminary Study on Writing Assistance | 2023-05-22T16:56:44 | 2023-10-09T07:55:26 | Yue Zhang, Leyang Cui, Deng Cai, Xinting Huang, Tao Fang, Wei Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Proprietary Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have garnered
significant attention due to their exceptional capabilities in handling a
diverse range of tasks. Recent studies demonstrate that open-sourced smaller
foundational models, such as 7B-size LLaMA, can also display remarkable
proficiency in tackling diverse tasks when fine-tuned using instruction-driven
data. In this work, we investigate a practical problem setting where the
primary focus is on one or a few particular tasks rather than general-purpose
instruction following, and explore whether LLMs can be beneficial and further
improved for such targeted scenarios. We choose the writing-assistant scenario
as the testbed, which includes seven writing tasks. We collect training data
for these tasks, reframe them in an instruction-following format, and
subsequently refine the LLM, specifically LLaMA, via instruction tuning.
Experimental results show that fine-tuning LLaMA on writing instruction data
significantly improves its ability on writing tasks. We also conduct more
experiments and analyses to offer insights for future work on effectively
fine-tuning LLaMA for specific scenarios. Finally, we initiate a discussion
regarding the necessity of employing LLMs for only one targeted task, taking
into account the efforts required for tuning and the resources consumed during
deployment. | [
0.053561043,
0.0277171899,
-0.0093495687,
0.023861533,
-0.035367921,
0.014160254,
0.0259184167,
-0.0089460136,
0.0171730034,
-0.0707297623,
-0.069413662,
-0.0510928296,
0.0005740104,
-0.0001827953,
0.0312429816,
-0.0299901143,
0.0499796048,
-0.0484620482,
-0.005990135,
-0.0029854295,
0.0174845196,
0.0114817452,
-0.03771054,
0.0459846966,
0.0157620944,
-0.0414364003,
-0.0218948908,
-0.0007673483,
-0.0205959063,
0.002824601,
0.0385161452,
0.0395801701,
0.0439759232,
0.0123123396,
0.0000020784,
-0.037296623,
0.01146995,
-0.0207817145,
-0.0095284618,
0.0466057584,
0.0626563728,
-0.0005857669,
-0.0604873225,
0.0614361875,
0.0029866146,
0.0087861968,
0.0445736609,
0.0222585239,
0.0596291609,
0.0922898799,
0.0143089592,
-0.0005272263,
0.024628127,
-0.016938448,
0.0101152891,
-0.004067102,
0.0066264151,
-0.0034677163,
0.0501367487,
0.0007371745,
-0.0282535627,
0.035578575,
0.030575512,
-0.03457205,
-0.0028475476,
0.0399776995,
-0.0145597616,
0.0086744279,
-0.0407222286,
0.0371386036,
-0.0105066346,
-0.0071224645,
0.0013825474,
-0.0096907318,
-0.0200589485,
-0.0264867153,
-0.0273221824,
0.0430940501,
0.0046202382,
0.0145462872,
0.0398775786,
-0.0378263555,
0.0144966813,
0.0083382558,
0.0174248498,
0.0477711521,
0.0011146475,
-0.0357198864,
-0.0133993421,
0.0181803033,
-0.0011023064,
-0.0473950058,
0.0311321504,
0.0692533031,
-0.023445189,
0.0249540582,
-0.0900905803,
-0.0233095326,
0.018434599,
-0.0384815484,
0.1333995908,
0.0664310902,
-0.0326743014,
0.001831959,
-0.0315866396,
0.0670409128,
-0.0232665166,
0.0402125269,
-0.0211018603,
0.0436931849,
-0.048923444,
0.0003035534,
-0.0305214282,
0.0237152446,
-0.0387985446,
-0.0157201476,
-0.0315894783,
0.0538974106,
0.0269194841,
0.0020597442,
0.0308199339,
-0.0180993825,
-0.0543924943,
0.0068311016,
0.0021283978,
-0.0117585845,
-0.0185751747,
0.0396708176,
0.012655207,
-0.0515320972,
0.0106687825,
0.022710165,
-0.010954909,
-0.0272316094,
0.0390277505,
0.0809129924,
-0.0433639809,
-0.0371087678,
-0.0690109953,
0.001893593,
0.0142298304,
-0.075413473,
0.0124865239,
-0.0605968274,
0.0357170738,
0.0013774141,
0.0013457333,
0.0033799962,
0.013562629,
0.0240232032,
0.0034129771,
0.0293725897,
0.0177785251,
0.0120010395,
0.048848249,
-0.0027704486,
-0.0049207998,
0.0532725304,
0.0505264811,
0.0363559723,
0.0165327694,
-0.0016828472,
-0.015508824,
0.0601105914,
-0.0229386669,
-0.0070523098,
0.0149351712,
-0.0090048499,
-0.0047270278,
0.0254788902,
0.0479719415,
0.0400164127,
0.0054520876,
0.0273891594,
0.0899856538,
0.0440695137,
0.0176319182,
0.0088004125,
0.0450406112,
0.0169351269,
0.0240780171,
0.0391315967,
-0.0785473064,
0.0484025888,
0.001593033,
0.0150248278,
-0.0037446457,
0.0427919775,
-0.0286468696,
-0.0459347367,
-0.0062445886,
-0.0140028,
-0.0521539673,
-0.0012299226,
0.0286534652,
-0.0265581124,
-0.075065501,
-0.0038369338,
0.0220751185,
-0.0492214896,
-0.0120508475,
-0.0682994649,
0.002734896,
0.0855094194,
0.0500372127,
-0.0188714955,
-0.072828047,
0.0051971409,
0.0365298204,
0.0387762114,
0.0176889542,
0.0039035543,
0.0041275802,
-0.0530834757,
0.0002609749,
-0.0398064815,
0.0201438889,
0.0109174866,
0.0445177518,
-0.0013932098,
-0.0049730237,
0.0189618487,
-0.0464614034,
0.0688756779,
-0.0357252918,
-0.031829603,
-0.0181201044,
0.0014887808,
0.0181523208,
-0.0018507733,
-0.0381858796,
-0.0036140895,
0.0206386205,
-0.0559273027,
0.0276017915,
-0.003740608,
-0.0624908656,
-0.0132318791,
0.0298012272,
0.0194550417,
0.0161293633,
0.0432347618,
-0.0211431552,
-0.0517789684,
-0.025786778,
-0.0314542204,
0.0242169909,
-0.0166637432,
0.0218607299,
-0.0121994875,
-0.0288119502,
-0.0144006219,
0.0166584719,
-0.0096760066,
-0.0104083661,
0.0046427245,
0.0304456037,
-0.0156477373,
-0.004225614,
-0.0440947078,
-0.00303576,
0.0053405869,
0.0253525954,
-0.0301931053,
0.0441675708,
-0.0278327018,
-0.07161396,
-0.0850471407,
0.0557074659,
-0.0212550815,
0.0308622494,
0.0645115972,
-0.0146214701,
-0.0222118478,
0.0046984074,
-0.0263086911,
0.0049951631,
0.0064255479,
0.0054314448,
0.0375063382,
-0.0031951326,
-0.0436806567,
-0.0541797318,
-0.0083271181,
-0.0085501019,
-0.0468459241,
0.0069849351,
-0.0293097552,
-0.0748751536,
0.065652892,
-0.0099826697,
0.0386361554,
-0.0182916783,
-0.067905806,
0.0227259938,
0.0000998528,
0.0753772035,
0.1068680063,
-0.0379537232,
0.0127096931,
0.0863074511,
-0.0003283891,
-0.0161780566,
0.0103896502,
0.0084567079,
-0.0173235778,
-0.0039709769,
-0.0442656092,
-0.0266026203,
0.0731272027,
-0.0062913415,
0.0034382523,
-0.0476688035,
-0.0301501546,
-0.0453849435,
-0.010260609,
-0.0056979554,
-0.0020248503,
-0.0465578362,
0.0008621034,
-0.0473640338,
-0.0884425044,
0.0435476601,
-0.0386437923,
-0.024814453,
-0.0253903139,
-0.0265548397,
-0.0546766184,
0.0391967557,
0.0004484066,
0.0147953872,
-0.0177327711,
-0.0138440812,
-0.0482779033,
0.0276366509,
-0.0016012432,
-0.0040733544,
0.0515823849,
-0.0784960538,
0.0036034239,
-0.0352346823,
-0.0420069098,
-0.0198026877,
0.0061276834,
0.0008012146,
0.0096232677,
0.0298248064,
-0.0310765095,
-0.0277788471,
-0.0116560785,
0.0241478514,
0.0864619464,
-0.0451899506,
0.0055534961,
-0.0622988604,
-0.0113899782,
0.0252994876,
-0.0200803839,
-0.0362115055,
-0.0628116503,
0.0062257578,
0.0256189276,
0.0510282889,
-0.0292162187,
-0.012208743,
0.0029304109,
0.0321186744,
-0.0416458733,
-0.0301858876,
0.0339161679,
0.1091259941,
-0.0670380071,
-0.031000901,
0.0963769555,
0.0254853629,
-0.0450201146,
-0.0003306894,
-0.0033050694,
0.020624768,
0.0150129097,
0.0583116449,
-0.0574419387,
-0.0245277211,
0.0234175678,
0.0572164133,
-0.0114659676,
0.0049905661,
-0.0351502299,
-0.0907123163,
0.0307754297,
-0.0056556943,
-0.0199137032,
0.00395473,
-0.0375631712,
-0.0063872635,
0.0049445909,
0.0136480341,
0.015216317,
-0.0297621861,
-0.0078247515,
0.0256425254,
0.0018867686,
-0.0481718406,
0.0257662609,
-0.0141696474,
0.0824864954,
0.0508079678,
0.005815458,
0.0097565856,
0.0043830522,
0.0180097949,
0.0249706339,
0.0322059281,
-0.0052728592,
0.0178511031,
-0.0182745904,
-0.0035979676,
-0.0254156087,
0.0443261042,
-0.0318368226,
0.0172022078,
0.0156350415,
0.0501826182,
-0.0326090604,
0.0043681986,
-0.0153714521,
-0.0275600124,
0.0130277174,
0.0524639599,
0.0229138657,
-0.0647000819,
-0.0548625402,
-0.0273587629,
-0.0292212125,
-0.0760775879,
-0.0048950696,
0.0023074672,
-0.0597659983,
-0.0100321304,
-0.0587791689,
-0.0611504763,
0.0411006808,
0.0221918877,
0.035412658,
0.0046276376,
0.0320705883,
-0.022938475,
-0.0482854098,
0.0044595911,
-0.0182186551,
0.0494580157,
-0.1082798615,
-0.0445167199,
0.0224626139,
-0.0103895012,
0.0082163876,
-0.003380503,
-0.0824007094,
-0.0761888102,
0.022143079,
0.0721656457,
0.0171342269,
0.0230941437,
0.0048623066,
-0.0712755471,
0.0047576567,
0.0174886324,
-0.0173801742,
0.0632853806,
0.0264799539,
-0.0270314645,
0.013769296,
0.0144682312,
-0.0164295956,
0.0377768688,
0.0115762083,
0.0221205913,
0.0216133837,
-0.0147803752,
-0.0125138331,
0.0177036654,
-0.0136803016,
-0.0289622452,
-0.0071989316,
-0.0639528781,
0.0423220657,
-0.0103058629,
0.0110015972,
-0.0489951782,
-0.0012541122,
-0.002516788,
-0.0102956416,
0.0054087318,
-0.001917892,
-0.0117812604,
0.0292592533,
-0.0452701673,
0.0634024888,
-0.0253383964,
0.044517111,
0.028614955,
0.0304817427,
-0.0361687168,
0.0333148241,
-0.0091078719,
0.0368707739,
0.0001940812,
0.0594073758,
-0.0136719951,
0.003631528,
-0.0187485833,
0.0590978116,
-0.0530170277,
-0.0109434249,
-0.0300535075,
0.0498966686,
0.0616745129,
0.0003568981,
0.0513512008,
-0.0279006623,
0.0189551488,
-0.0204874426,
0.0456750691,
0.0113622369,
-0.0216261614,
-0.0032086815,
0.0090572573,
0.0270984937,
-0.0180111155,
0.0930346549,
-0.0064335121,
0.0796618909,
0.0114991805,
0.0280762911,
-0.0427107997,
-0.0458278172,
0.0444315113,
0.0168251228,
-0.0181799736,
-0.0268366635,
-0.0168322232,
-0.0463729911,
-0.0048536211,
0.0112102842,
-0.0186026096,
-0.0631038919,
0.0146383718,
0.0280668195,
-0.0047789635,
-0.0181210972,
-0.0476803482,
-0.0166975688,
-0.0227548033,
-0.0064752963,
0.0061539263,
-6.214799695e-33,
-0.0408174992,
-0.0143766906,
0.04818267,
0.0203245059,
-0.0090145534,
0.0175681505,
-0.0260173008,
0.0048025842,
-0.0015594427,
-0.023201609,
-0.0311540663,
0.0067109331,
0.0199088436,
0.0030280596,
0.0148598999,
0.0593640879,
0.0358128585,
-0.039209988,
-0.0430888087,
0.0295613147,
0.0366860032,
0.028539516,
0.0574043989,
-0.0270300116,
0.024144711,
-0.034885902,
-0.0127836214,
0.0080062235,
-0.0366735868,
0.0488416068,
-0.029436186,
0.0504788794,
0.0232118275,
0.0036514166,
-0.0215238724,
0.0393824242,
-0.0285633467,
-0.0250720419,
0.0275854673,
0.0092934323,
-0.0172390901,
-0.0635392293,
0.0152632948,
-0.0087691555,
-0.0288426839,
0.00871774,
0.0226825606,
-0.0144184874,
-0.0011606015,
0.028044628,
-0.0816525146,
0.0061618965,
0.014629283,
-0.0630397797,
0.0005982613,
0.0032545743,
0.0008547824,
-0.0429316871,
-0.0395203456,
0.0210566353,
0.0369099751,
0.0637430102,
0.0588186048,
0.0350819454,
-0.0237510782,
0.0279688425,
-0.0080508469,
0.0276531093,
-0.0028152058,
0.0029635539,
0.0333346203,
0.0294577777,
0.0205815863,
-0.0030808058,
-0.005753085,
0.0055038212,
-0.0412851982,
0.0163988024,
0.0710032582,
0.0035384921,
0.0338025726,
0.0017052878,
-0.0406842567,
-0.0262196306,
-0.0105987424,
0.0196433961,
-0.0110935802,
-0.0307348389,
0.0660233274,
0.0162392017,
-0.0071599046,
-0.0178593956,
0.0224750433,
0.0036490327,
0.0042891381,
-0.0048571802,
-0.042368412,
0.0744259432,
-0.0113914758,
0.0062525393,
-0.1017228439,
-0.0651754364,
0.0183742344,
0.0079358472,
0.0239356924,
0.0240820143,
0.0276686102,
0.0500256754,
-0.065297395,
0.0233582761,
-0.0570136011,
0.036517486,
0.0492480211,
0.023906881,
0.0230657402,
-0.04391234,
-0.0129251182,
0.073950395,
0.0125932554,
-0.0243846141,
-0.0459700972,
-0.0201635566,
-0.033598125,
0.0201630853,
-0.0405666418,
0.0210925043,
-0.044743862,
0.0312140677,
-0.0263838693,
-0.0480397791,
-0.0020271058,
-0.0209296513,
2.678e-7,
0.0153832911,
0.0424649976,
0.0200983547,
0.0499699451,
0.0083690323,
0.0120740635,
-0.0426203199,
0.0329112671,
-0.0045896722,
0.0093016541,
-0.007158393,
0.0496957861,
0.0375964791,
0.0147135574,
-0.0427854918,
0.0002888591,
-0.0520471446,
0.0385934189,
-0.0606494546,
-0.0171112195,
0.0225409362,
0.0565259829,
-0.0080488017,
-0.0339888558,
-0.005489361,
-0.0311661363,
0.0365931727,
-0.0088668466,
-0.0119155813,
0.0201425366,
0.0015784247,
0.0395071656,
-0.0431607366,
-0.0150322774,
-0.0122834714,
-0.0141512752,
-0.0467770435,
0.1133727133,
-0.018794097,
0.0156613588,
0.0776491463,
0.0231994223,
-0.0454138406,
-0.0351348296,
0.0719925985,
-0.0224562567,
0.0018748501,
-0.0175842606,
0.0475455634,
-0.0025928768,
-0.0308852755,
-0.0367059559,
0.0215435904,
0.0141600072,
-0.0012550316,
-0.0451510102,
-0.0335406661,
-0.0425689109,
-0.0298740957,
-0.0064169401,
-0.0029098978,
-0.0533113442,
-0.1070281491,
-0.0033414816,
-0.0090350667,
-0.0792393163,
-0.0075067817,
2.586915469e-34,
-0.0177025981,
-0.034093231,
0.0333614796,
0.053629186,
-0.0044292263,
0.0138604939,
-0.0009520266,
0.0264353063,
0.006649171,
-0.0592929311,
-0.0367459022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13214v1 | Logical Reasoning for Natural Language Inference Using Generated Facts as Atoms | 2023-05-22T16:45:50 | 2023-05-22T16:45:50 | Joe Stacey, Pasquale Minervini, Haim Dubossarsky, Oana-Maria Camburu, Marek Rei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | State-of-the-art neural models can now reach human performance levels across
various natural language understanding tasks. However, despite this impressive
performance, models are known to learn from annotation artefacts at the expense
of the underlying task. While interpretability methods can identify influential
features for each prediction, there are no guarantees that these features are
responsible for the model decisions. Instead, we introduce a model-agnostic
logical framework to determine the specific information in an input responsible
for each model decision. This method creates interpretable Natural Language
Inference (NLI) models that maintain their predictive power. We achieve this by
generating facts that decompose complex NLI observations into individual
logical atoms. Our model makes predictions for each atom and uses logical rules
to decide the class of the observation based on the predictions for each atom.
We apply our method to the highly challenging ANLI dataset, where our framework
improves the performance of both a DeBERTa-base and BERT baseline. Our method
performs best on the most challenging examples, achieving a new
state-of-the-art for the ANLI round 3 test set. We outperform every baseline in
a reduced-data setting, and despite using no annotations for the generated
facts, our model predictions for individual facts align with human
expectations. | [
0.0115687903,
0.0872315243,
-0.0127481958,
0.0509482436,
-0.0186270867,
0.0230099764,
0.023954507,
-0.0291344561,
0.0227621198,
-0.0108469184,
0.0458299704,
0.0178319979,
-0.0222474281,
0.0620930493,
0.0201849639,
-0.0298038945,
0.0313986987,
-0.0208319593,
0.0370684303,
0.0066402853,
0.0021155805,
0.0057388749,
0.003542142,
0.0322295204,
-0.0554441214,
-0.0116431173,
-0.021646155,
-0.0120603284,
-0.0139978006,
-0.0066904104,
-0.0201128218,
0.0426483266,
0.0342882723,
0.0215257592,
0.0000021042,
-0.0189076327,
0.0118957832,
0.0093290377,
-0.0908063129,
-0.0200436618,
-0.0166777167,
-0.0228814259,
0.0092920968,
-0.0419887528,
-0.0332077742,
-0.0040855892,
0.0480614565,
0.0640725493,
0.0331708975,
0.0472165346,
-0.0107667428,
-0.0443948545,
-0.0169466175,
-0.0084271105,
0.0084817931,
0.0004700889,
0.0063201636,
0.029101003,
-0.0230772104,
0.0019322177,
-0.0055770222,
0.0223420206,
0.0377304032,
0.0028602849,
-0.0153213721,
0.0319304951,
-0.0503856242,
-0.0400619134,
0.0328430012,
0.0934865475,
0.0088758199,
-0.0321523808,
-0.0082232654,
0.000996548,
0.0213614721,
-0.0073839216,
-0.0019539623,
0.0493011288,
-0.0270957649,
0.0292415097,
0.0698598921,
0.0204829127,
0.0517192818,
0.0221827738,
-0.0186923388,
0.0791517347,
-0.0121687232,
-0.0085290587,
-0.0089066746,
0.012785784,
-0.0546726473,
-0.0056243311,
0.0272904281,
-0.0034672632,
0.0103976652,
0.053759817,
-0.0267213453,
0.0065547037,
0.0045869248,
-0.0731446967,
-0.0009011286,
0.0348793454,
-0.0313619934,
0.0534180962,
-0.0358504355,
0.008445357,
0.0060412488,
0.0261092987,
-0.006262945,
-0.0176868867,
-0.0440310985,
-0.0014072667,
-0.0125626847,
0.0574881658,
-0.0364602283,
0.0045821294,
-0.0144689279,
-0.0278862454,
-0.0443147384,
0.0189198721,
0.0078321714,
0.0273990966,
-0.0492013581,
-0.0041636932,
-0.0336494781,
0.0149116842,
-0.067106314,
0.0302346665,
-0.0177712198,
-0.0582001507,
-0.0289292987,
-0.0069301394,
-0.008573018,
-0.0038298424,
-0.0162367579,
0.087322183,
0.0290580634,
-0.0022510274,
-0.0623518452,
-0.0569315068,
-0.0008112932,
-0.0375575945,
0.0294720195,
-0.0405952595,
0.0462997742,
-0.0158319101,
-0.0327712111,
-0.072987102,
-0.0097673843,
-0.0004308918,
-0.0211872049,
0.089198038,
-0.0274448972,
-0.0425563902,
-0.016359672,
0.0235111229,
0.0163341016,
0.0877107009,
0.0180291422,
0.0313329808,
0.020967558,
0.0313572995,
-0.0200325381,
0.0053107692,
0.0520973727,
-0.0054569282,
0.0064381235,
-0.0261914749,
-0.0435076617,
0.0233027786,
0.046582222,
0.0034752022,
-0.0148208607,
-0.0595960096,
0.0337380469,
0.0081871832,
0.0108766761,
0.055854857,
0.0290812794,
0.0117816702,
0.0018691489,
0.003303844,
-0.053007219,
0.0308416616,
0.0044404878,
-0.0014033992,
-0.0351922698,
0.029740205,
-0.0042834287,
-0.0711486265,
-0.0068095843,
-0.0112214927,
0.0051117414,
0.0013048035,
0.0656139478,
0.0207111947,
-0.0236945394,
0.1070951298,
0.054043036,
-0.0626599416,
0.0043744249,
-0.0405879095,
0.0631955788,
0.0403172672,
0.0384308547,
-0.0350545645,
-0.0475724936,
0.0079306532,
-0.0135105038,
0.0528928824,
0.0116457865,
-0.0099262595,
0.0729873106,
-0.0249356441,
-0.0029661499,
-0.0308851544,
0.0412240662,
0.0265101288,
-0.0087209307,
-0.0387300849,
0.0077498704,
-0.045448225,
-0.0081153903,
0.048599381,
-0.0041396786,
-0.0265974961,
-0.0029571424,
0.0235349704,
0.0361007266,
-0.0132853724,
0.0103290165,
-0.0118415952,
0.0206359569,
-0.0395884924,
-0.0065744603,
0.0241149161,
-0.0071335644,
-0.0865211263,
0.0157749839,
-0.0569147542,
-0.0222640559,
-0.0198963117,
-0.1005993634,
-0.016193876,
0.0161358304,
-0.0404997878,
-0.0132646924,
-0.026126029,
-0.0657317713,
0.0298534874,
0.0043380861,
-0.0043589855,
0.0779474452,
-0.0241963938,
-0.0189353358,
0.0142946383,
-0.0109762335,
0.0377523489,
-0.0384014845,
0.0019891441,
0.002455676,
-0.0121028833,
-0.0246803947,
0.0064322888,
-0.0072965561,
-0.0173505321,
0.0213424601,
-0.0472958311,
-0.0182759352,
-0.0000646131,
-0.0082761217,
0.0230739694,
-0.0149117401,
0.0099858399,
-0.0180238727,
-0.0028809912,
-0.0407580473,
-0.0218933634,
-0.0119549735,
0.0605189838,
-0.0218081512,
-0.0041783233,
-0.0306919608,
-0.0252118204,
-0.0552593507,
0.0529474802,
0.0160156675,
0.0023498994,
-0.0393899083,
-0.0230083987,
-0.0541380346,
0.0456447974,
-0.0102224229,
-0.0324284993,
-0.0014540158,
-0.0241022073,
-0.0201707333,
0.0986198932,
-0.019801395,
0.0358105786,
0.0388432108,
-0.0369026512,
-0.0522722788,
0.0372018926,
-0.0270171277,
0.0831238329,
-0.0003295765,
-0.077164799,
0.0108747641,
0.0504696108,
0.0181626249,
-0.0148184262,
-0.0589136779,
0.0480425134,
-0.0105683198,
-0.0462387279,
-0.0181758832,
0.0144997202,
0.0259722006,
0.0413899533,
-0.0357409194,
-0.0206669495,
0.1125630215,
-0.001534664,
0.0153767001,
-0.0480057932,
0.000293262,
-0.0382618234,
0.0718142986,
0.0296819005,
-0.0192292426,
0.0081871469,
0.0026980059,
-0.0159905981,
-0.0099293049,
0.0108169504,
0.0093357479,
0.0464585498,
-0.0693799481,
0.004124424,
0.0178745631,
-0.0163223092,
-0.046217978,
-0.023101151,
-0.015830135,
-0.002134572,
-0.0177633483,
-0.0221218225,
-0.0293337218,
-0.0255812965,
0.0041771242,
0.021718422,
-0.0078484016,
0.0151797924,
-0.0251170974,
0.0064040176,
0.0277183298,
0.0209804252,
0.0351500697,
0.0177921709,
0.0254820287,
0.059709128,
-0.0032524844,
0.0146768447,
-0.0628980026,
0.0414301865,
-0.0090594282,
-0.0076449178,
-0.0002167142,
-0.0010156654,
0.0585435815,
-0.0967219472,
-0.0437771678,
0.0910747871,
0.0108146584,
0.0596236885,
0.0126089025,
-0.0049623149,
0.0415540896,
-0.0254936367,
0.0443923473,
-0.0644482002,
-0.0641038418,
0.0095433081,
0.0015933722,
-0.0134480521,
-0.0290177967,
-0.0060189585,
-0.0717455745,
0.0442909077,
-0.0260819755,
0.0098636076,
-0.036686942,
-0.0765577778,
-0.011568889,
-0.0556874946,
-0.0242064744,
-0.0074507333,
0.0278334301,
0.0239030756,
0.008674792,
0.0006311371,
-0.0040024943,
0.0553107932,
-0.0093393559,
0.0451063626,
0.0506496429,
0.0409120843,
-0.0223667696,
-0.0358418114,
-0.0292795915,
0.0024110384,
-0.0198801439,
-0.0164597593,
0.0789196715,
0.0321080275,
-0.0140672168,
-0.0405246317,
0.0346072912,
-0.0034267157,
-0.0443316326,
-0.0021826392,
0.0507714525,
-0.0171551481,
-0.044101771,
-0.0335556753,
0.0378188454,
-0.0097898925,
0.1202774718,
0.0501071028,
-0.0085402625,
-0.0551580042,
-0.0524166822,
0.0014005102,
-0.0749069601,
0.0080132522,
0.0300293006,
-0.0098222131,
-0.0529517904,
-0.0488056429,
-0.0454114266,
-0.0062583648,
0.0418870822,
0.0086262757,
-0.0313955098,
0.053262677,
-0.0142209409,
-0.0143768089,
0.0673033521,
-0.0247763731,
-0.0192531627,
0.0416730531,
-0.0069937394,
0.0203904249,
-0.015802823,
-0.0357975625,
0.0536520928,
-0.0523186363,
-0.019144373,
0.0284863804,
0.0710378438,
0.0289796945,
0.051607538,
-0.0236721374,
-0.0183699187,
0.0114201847,
0.0306066852,
0.0056419447,
-0.0316898562,
0.040669553,
-0.0123917069,
0.0165483486,
0.0468251966,
-0.0059870873,
0.0401825458,
-0.0063741826,
0.0279611945,
-0.0547704957,
-0.0011984481,
0.025065165,
-0.0061502112,
0.0118226493,
0.0168860108,
-0.0192914438,
-0.0350712128,
-0.0064794184,
-0.022021424,
-0.0008658822,
-0.0508905314,
0.0346510708,
-0.0129299182,
0.0230571851,
-0.0270400178,
-0.0387143716,
-0.0042351573,
0.0128922844,
-0.0096325595,
-0.0169923212,
0.0366428122,
0.0218723547,
-0.0328588746,
-0.0248198379,
-0.0427406952,
0.0436384529,
-0.0277825706,
0.0576460399,
-0.041312445,
0.0449087285,
0.068340756,
-0.0142455231,
-0.0544747412,
-0.0144990943,
-0.0452798232,
-0.0073867156,
-0.0016684755,
0.0479092672,
0.0134918364,
-0.0188814178,
0.0122256679,
-0.0435343534,
0.0042507639,
0.028791761,
0.0413790829,
0.0056689382,
-0.0109151909,
0.0389644466,
0.0032350069,
-0.011335562,
-0.0596913844,
0.0587781556,
0.0151831545,
0.0384002253,
-0.0208275765,
-0.0263006389,
-0.0438948125,
-0.0326028466,
-0.0325822085,
0.019073952,
-0.0105173467,
0.0147253098,
-0.0472173318,
-0.060477525,
-0.0105114393,
0.0483593307,
0.0360571519,
-0.0116642127,
0.0254207887,
0.0571805313,
0.017165849,
-0.0864595771,
-0.0097314836,
0.0066273203,
-0.0132422885,
-0.0187865384,
-0.0415828116,
-6.58334803e-33,
-0.0447293632,
-0.0233037807,
0.0072218319,
-0.0130320312,
-0.009080261,
0.0048074233,
-0.0695900843,
-0.0531006381,
-0.0572518967,
0.0550758652,
0.0317188092,
0.0420880876,
0.0138510149,
0.0263074916,
0.0054829945,
-0.0822571367,
0.045456849,
0.0433686562,
-0.0093456553,
0.0082917316,
0.047902748,
0.025946565,
0.0420436896,
-0.0520568602,
0.0215089377,
0.0221246146,
-0.001409748,
0.0407146178,
-0.0602865778,
0.019698577,
-0.0014521581,
0.0273342282,
0.0275628809,
-0.0550837032,
0.014562984,
0.0032386831,
-0.0966527835,
-0.059141919,
0.0593200028,
0.0078551192,
-0.0301292147,
-0.0146421054,
0.0570411533,
0.0183079187,
0.0340389535,
-0.0206047818,
0.0354541428,
-0.0100066457,
0.0105808498,
-0.0075156302,
-0.0510530248,
0.0194646884,
-0.0106890444,
-0.0147699891,
0.0065166564,
0.0341672823,
0.0039704549,
-0.0071167704,
-0.0862014294,
-0.0102223177,
0.0303453021,
0.0055428222,
0.0549326465,
-0.0255084746,
-0.006676273,
0.0702002794,
0.0360773169,
-0.0007695184,
-0.0936462581,
0.0144978315,
0.0131882653,
0.0736530274,
0.0324331298,
0.0099504953,
0.0427535437,
0.0359302796,
-0.1022479832,
-0.0049098786,
0.0387547724,
0.0442339592,
-0.0157697704,
-0.0169969797,
-0.0826949105,
-0.0249125045,
-0.0311859846,
-0.0120436987,
-0.030285798,
-0.0177221633,
0.0007152319,
-0.0351265036,
-0.0513960198,
0.0103759579,
0.011129424,
-0.0253801607,
0.0265091602,
0.0186037701,
0.0089436779,
-0.0171266682,
0.0164948702,
0.0388789512,
-0.02394633,
-0.0094297947,
0.013726715,
-0.0104116527,
0.0289956369,
0.0220731981,
0.0584641844,
-0.0188505445,
0.020627588,
-0.011330815,
-0.0557772592,
-0.0296432432,
-0.0315262489,
0.027722314,
0.0383122899,
0.0752467662,
-0.0223086234,
-0.0043195128,
0.0449147411,
0.0608877614,
-0.0301812943,
0.0185520053,
0.014305288,
0.0346335918,
-0.0232243557,
-0.0416480564,
-0.0470857024,
-0.0328703336,
-0.0137466751,
-0.0855089054,
0.001411361,
0.0315697864,
2.793e-7,
0.0381621681,
0.0368381776,
0.0344418772,
0.0268975385,
0.0100717591,
0.0609358288,
0.0068842145,
-0.0097859669,
0.0136014968,
-0.0410876758,
-0.0010764847,
0.0549703911,
0.0248487089,
0.048269175,
-0.0553588085,
0.0020859849,
-0.0043203332,
-0.0572349541,
-0.049750641,
-0.015893383,
0.0820177719,
0.0948489308,
0.055273626,
-0.0149029549,
0.034434814,
0.0052214852,
0.0188480895,
0.0028255992,
-0.0329471678,
-0.0105765704,
0.0758700073,
0.001916516,
0.006272153,
0.0448450446,
-0.0238926876,
-0.0049526631,
-0.0317108706,
0.0510224439,
0.002516241,
-0.0054318751,
-0.0378844589,
-0.0537659563,
0.0224917848,
-0.0007272779,
0.0520692728,
-0.0569990613,
-0.0548239276,
0.0154928183,
-0.0260697585,
0.010662511,
-0.0139125753,
0.0051279073,
-0.0022973537,
0.0045089466,
-0.0017203577,
-0.0564360879,
-0.0107061202,
-0.0336416438,
-0.0407843702,
0.0194551032,
-0.0545169264,
0.0059369737,
-0.0201868229,
-0.0200729668,
0.0584370196,
-0.0606818236,
-0.0024522368,
2.610586986e-34,
-0.0008649389,
0.0139145479,
-0.0045509022,
0.0231737848,
0.065910615,
-0.0050717313,
-0.0250404589,
-0.0085772788,
0.018394161,
-0.0272599123,
-0.0285249744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13204v1 | Improving Isochronous Machine Translation with Target Factors and Auxiliary Counters | 2023-05-22T16:36:04 | 2023-05-22T16:36:04 | Proyag Pal, Brian Thompson, Yogesh Virkar, Prashant Mathur, Alexandra Chronopoulou, Marcello Federico | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | To translate speech for automatic dubbing, machine translation needs to be
isochronous, i.e. translated speech needs to be aligned with the source in
terms of speech durations. We introduce target factors in a transformer model
to predict durations jointly with target language phoneme sequences. We also
introduce auxiliary counters to help the decoder to keep track of the timing
information while generating target phonemes. We show that our model improves
translation quality and isochrony compared to previous work where the
translation model is instead trained to predict interleaved sequences of
phonemes and durations. | [
-0.0013111718,
0.0457471795,
0.009990965,
-0.0254333951,
-0.0020390986,
-0.0022913546,
0.0394945964,
-0.0004635483,
-0.073888354,
0.0188111831,
-0.0410887823,
-0.086395368,
0.0308510624,
-0.0075127902,
-0.0100981463,
-0.0780267864,
0.0186748058,
-0.0036978768,
-0.0488673784,
0.0012984156,
-0.0201823935,
0.0243129749,
-0.0397093408,
0.0107633956,
-0.0177876819,
-0.009649938,
0.0035906164,
-0.0098496871,
0.0488096699,
0.0005813165,
-0.0224537048,
0.0257114172,
0.0313461497,
0.0536592864,
0.0000015832,
-0.0177569054,
-0.0422212966,
0.0353675969,
-0.0386343598,
0.0021949045,
0.0252584126,
-0.0445286445,
-0.0388828255,
0.0481312163,
-0.0104420139,
-0.0239211414,
0.0387274995,
-0.008989336,
0.0257059205,
0.0592708699,
-0.0114041045,
-0.0490899123,
-0.0193572696,
-0.046032507,
-0.0159934331,
-0.0170882437,
-0.037115328,
0.0264429264,
-0.0332495086,
-0.016353067,
-0.0239409395,
0.06906645,
0.0003143262,
-0.012057418,
0.0093157105,
0.0005185205,
-0.001855262,
-0.0250621028,
-0.0408099517,
0.0208176989,
-0.0213104207,
0.0178773347,
-0.0052568247,
0.0165349897,
-0.0255133435,
-0.0264468174,
-0.0467651822,
0.0069571044,
0.0280342493,
-0.0200414248,
0.0058552609,
0.1031554192,
0.0115424953,
-0.0677488372,
0.0064656101,
-0.0034227089,
0.0481013171,
-0.0284168981,
-0.0325361341,
0.0001646344,
0.025324041,
-0.0104210498,
0.0471578911,
0.0301686656,
0.0078781424,
0.0328752212,
-0.0316511579,
-0.0219190009,
-0.0303394366,
-0.0265426971,
-0.0006204983,
0.0734820589,
-0.0321400873,
-0.0081566405,
0.0098185614,
0.0723469406,
-0.0211243182,
-0.0521017089,
-0.0722492635,
-0.0244317949,
-0.0256529115,
0.0203855373,
-0.0371260457,
-0.0376831293,
-0.0286934283,
0.0011099657,
-0.0558733419,
0.0273265168,
0.0434320644,
0.0130846305,
0.0676673502,
-0.0289775841,
-0.074075073,
-0.0396649018,
-0.0075431243,
0.0685927644,
0.0046232231,
0.0074666315,
-0.0213185698,
-0.0718494654,
-0.0173989646,
0.0035544701,
0.0276089106,
-0.0311923921,
-0.0400991887,
0.1011523083,
-0.0298823081,
0.0049535395,
0.0069207307,
-0.0247328356,
-0.0741809234,
-0.0196930468,
-0.0170242563,
-0.0634020567,
0.0268912539,
-0.0119716795,
0.0175131857,
0.0197387021,
-0.0066487058,
-0.0163221825,
0.0528429374,
0.0187751725,
0.0311682243,
0.0494020954,
0.0333812498,
-0.0101512624,
0.0029535212,
0.0499330238,
0.0591426603,
-0.0129993707,
0.0292375218,
-0.0136401476,
-0.0134503543,
0.09902253,
0.0046649338,
0.0290498547,
-0.0232062563,
-0.0168852042,
0.0460233055,
-0.0034918212,
0.0155905858,
0.0269000903,
0.0140753463,
0.0057411701,
0.0630326942,
-0.03018279,
0.0194424074,
0.0396668464,
0.0884720236,
-0.0117327506,
-0.034175057,
0.0335625783,
0.0494538806,
0.0364344381,
0.0766487196,
-0.0017872772,
0.0456153154,
0.0469273329,
-0.0404280573,
-0.0202489719,
-0.0078778993,
-0.0183322541,
-0.0216132104,
-0.0321532302,
0.0292314496,
0.0267121773,
-0.0500531085,
0.1192942262,
-0.0312660746,
-0.0329605453,
0.0230049286,
0.0211461894,
-0.0767144859,
0.052319143,
0.0145853208,
0.016343927,
-0.0265900102,
-0.0321490802,
-0.0125437984,
0.0653945208,
0.0616360791,
-0.0248349421,
0.0409794524,
-0.0366069041,
-0.0107551627,
0.0841721594,
-0.0046121306,
0.0235869735,
0.0005075515,
0.0404149964,
0.0284730326,
0.0096563576,
-0.0249048416,
0.003857343,
-0.0689669102,
-0.0406400785,
-0.0135243963,
0.0065174317,
0.0257887896,
0.0387592502,
0.0004829126,
0.00740891,
0.0337323993,
-0.0403869152,
0.0070736855,
0.0882741809,
-0.0387656353,
-0.0227647908,
0.0615712032,
0.0005151752,
-0.0003619415,
0.030273525,
0.016225569,
-0.0780256167,
0.0273759998,
-0.0517282449,
0.044087261,
-0.0155446185,
0.0574935526,
-0.0014019806,
-0.01199455,
-0.0062658298,
-0.0128204133,
-0.0352406837,
0.0061014281,
0.0343424864,
-0.0038900359,
0.0122644491,
-0.0312028639,
0.0082380585,
0.0428580418,
-0.0082069533,
-0.0091451164,
0.0164221767,
-0.0435950719,
-0.0343036912,
-0.0578230284,
-0.04219402,
0.0077708159,
0.0120557565,
0.0385431759,
-0.0063886265,
0.0335085206,
0.0229088701,
-0.0161840804,
-0.0481346697,
-0.0615698695,
0.0343785584,
-0.0395946465,
-0.0433064215,
0.0412049294,
-0.0364835225,
-0.0124015212,
0.0136973588,
0.0332003944,
0.0090323063,
-0.0159329511,
-0.055557251,
-0.0448122397,
-0.0129601285,
0.0014180954,
0.0235283189,
0.0036263466,
-0.0439047627,
-0.0067638098,
0.0366910845,
0.0649203882,
-0.0025445113,
0.0047219051,
-0.0166341215,
0.0204416756,
-0.0493850559,
-0.030017823,
-0.0145300422,
-0.0380514748,
-0.038061846,
-0.0243991725,
-0.0367920846,
-0.0286702681,
0.0548432507,
0.0246623047,
0.01623304,
-0.0595765859,
-0.0445192121,
-0.0248686019,
-0.0286947917,
0.0611639768,
-0.0055855894,
-0.0322817117,
0.0005876758,
-0.0170261711,
-0.0503831692,
0.0307207778,
-0.0651912913,
-0.0497467034,
-0.0209767334,
-0.0029766613,
-0.0177964922,
0.0249799378,
-0.0156543553,
0.0070811841,
-0.0529097281,
-0.0171639826,
-0.0464622565,
0.032394778,
0.0106999706,
-0.0672077835,
0.0236674566,
-0.0269289929,
-0.0391255207,
-0.0088644857,
0.0016840531,
-0.0483952612,
0.0003076179,
-0.0183026791,
0.0029112888,
-0.0173733775,
-0.0265418105,
-0.0240970552,
0.0394975059,
0.0211189501,
0.0328574143,
-0.0108701428,
0.0191979613,
-0.0070097172,
0.0293826256,
0.0196073409,
0.0023934266,
-0.0297523309,
-0.0313145667,
0.0570903532,
-0.0354095735,
0.0444005057,
0.0148664052,
-0.044705458,
-0.0175816882,
0.0135718454,
0.0275264941,
-0.0145285409,
-0.0005675512,
0.0187654756,
-0.0054574283,
0.0200181287,
0.1180014163,
0.0150155229,
-0.034455236,
-0.0049391524,
-0.0069992309,
0.0185450912,
-0.0047887056,
0.0151699884,
-0.0276998747,
0.000428488,
0.006777884,
0.0346985795,
0.0346230827,
0.0626090467,
-0.030506691,
-0.0946930423,
0.0048140194,
0.0679072291,
-0.0029546849,
-0.0287787691,
0.0009809117,
-0.04592067,
-0.0498511977,
0.0334958695,
0.0069939382,
0.0024700561,
0.0002734319,
0.0573877394,
-0.0203254111,
-0.0396745428,
-0.0040200376,
-0.0279047899,
0.0702245981,
0.07029403,
0.0220056996,
0.0126614198,
-0.0348791517,
0.0205507912,
-0.0076783895,
-0.018124368,
0.020968264,
-0.0057841316,
0.0069827079,
-0.0260450486,
0.0383549221,
0.0166746564,
0.0010815825,
0.0252953433,
-0.0093401195,
0.062479306,
-0.0029834802,
0.056377463,
0.0278267357,
0.0249086078,
-0.0033818253,
0.0275198109,
-0.0224674605,
-0.0339922346,
0.0653621331,
0.0349110849,
0.0130811008,
-0.0605643243,
-0.0466813147,
0.0341688991,
-0.0472708531,
-0.1077890843,
-0.0744211972,
-0.0120890811,
-0.0121243056,
0.0544455163,
0.0289110877,
0.0056859516,
0.0030072983,
0.0175687876,
-0.0348598436,
-0.0022247082,
-0.0117447814,
0.0357449353,
-0.0535834134,
-0.0173157398,
-0.0011796821,
-0.0258625485,
0.0168510694,
0.0621157736,
-0.0637879372,
-0.0497909151,
0.0143113444,
0.0227713306,
0.0250544734,
0.0926176235,
-0.0136584826,
0.0101128276,
-0.0298890397,
-0.0392247476,
0.001979199,
0.0166142657,
0.011237354,
-0.0062764254,
-0.0146369012,
0.0150045482,
-0.0479139015,
0.04521548,
-0.0348945484,
0.0200549569,
-0.0522569716,
-0.0367053375,
0.0273995493,
0.0044991076,
0.0424537621,
-0.037845213,
0.0605695285,
0.0167280864,
0.0263765957,
-0.0114293341,
0.0308666397,
-0.0374140553,
-0.0006038331,
0.0297070388,
0.02399626,
-0.0017237636,
-0.008474052,
-0.0525993705,
-0.0788027123,
0.0145126255,
-0.0042476235,
-0.0296502598,
0.0331754982,
-0.0188106075,
0.0246888958,
-0.0119121801,
0.0007837124,
-0.0053832014,
-0.0091281459,
0.006469504,
-0.0072810701,
-0.014713522,
0.0618065372,
0.0006099872,
0.0015387355,
0.0038689743,
0.0212196391,
-0.022038905,
-0.0698186159,
0.0425823629,
-0.0543231405,
0.0876690969,
0.0072554532,
0.0285076853,
-0.0152467042,
0.036860507,
-0.0308044553,
-0.0225165114,
-0.0273511261,
-0.0056005013,
-0.0126370843,
0.0178956147,
0.058150813,
-0.0314282142,
0.0011717953,
-0.0140574099,
-0.0049185203,
0.0047766571,
-0.0112498756,
-0.0356291234,
-0.0861263201,
-0.0139303189,
-0.0435607135,
-0.0281127114,
-0.0479783528,
0.0285736322,
-0.0059236186,
0.0351971053,
-0.0160615072,
0.0164806359,
0.0065090768,
-0.0459424779,
0.0199216958,
-0.0039505982,
-0.0165017713,
0.0082591558,
0.0097634848,
-0.0256066583,
-5.082435701e-33,
-0.0503896326,
-0.0188647173,
0.0218628403,
-0.0216128547,
-0.081714794,
0.0287628137,
-0.0175658427,
-0.0010160208,
0.0232806094,
-0.0212922618,
0.0085577909,
0.0073503745,
0.0294612329,
-0.0108829783,
0.0187057983,
0.0301099345,
0.0686706528,
-0.0164471902,
-0.0230083689,
0.0073247515,
0.0175775755,
0.0286840145,
0.0451870412,
-0.0164568126,
-0.0093255229,
0.003046761,
-0.0128664011,
0.023803195,
0.0641722605,
0.0367754921,
0.0321306922,
0.0204729345,
-0.0188273843,
-0.0793584734,
-0.0469068699,
0.0396712907,
-0.0777080208,
0.0121692689,
0.0302517563,
0.0941495299,
0.0566445701,
-0.0355949663,
-0.0308166221,
-0.0421487056,
-0.0245070569,
-0.0130076353,
0.0036103239,
-0.0851881728,
-0.0461572111,
-0.0164845753,
-0.0114450362,
0.030630054,
-0.0042331046,
-0.0224672947,
0.0643974245,
0.0803260356,
0.0182144754,
-0.046717938,
-0.0567839704,
0.0362222008,
0.0283148326,
0.0785322189,
0.0677775368,
0.0075498386,
-0.0143061578,
0.0095102768,
0.0505226441,
-0.057335306,
0.0393133759,
0.0349321067,
0.008963557,
-0.0064618629,
0.0725422055,
-0.0300356913,
0.0584113449,
-0.006875373,
0.0079567945,
0.0366854072,
-0.0154164555,
-0.0131787462,
0.0337338261,
0.0421185307,
0.0157451015,
0.034476839,
-0.0347066559,
-0.0047692657,
0.0100557022,
-0.0327975824,
-0.007564303,
0.037980441,
0.0191825498,
0.0172774233,
0.1038711742,
0.0038136698,
0.0519093759,
-0.0288862661,
-0.0280431509,
0.0237776916,
-0.0462634787,
0.0294720475,
0.0054958463,
-0.0201660451,
0.0628022254,
0.0124959191,
0.0082764458,
-0.0127069755,
-0.0254115574,
0.0698065013,
-0.0331826583,
-0.0120775541,
-0.0391226783,
0.0002122869,
-0.0041769291,
0.015367385,
0.0342219844,
-0.0040512094,
-0.0260310769,
0.0266125854,
-0.0329935439,
-0.0237844065,
0.0239104927,
0.023623893,
0.0302643161,
0.040678367,
-0.0654371157,
0.0259162653,
0.0023120341,
0.0220962055,
0.0361457802,
-0.0169369318,
-0.0342231542,
-0.0044338228,
2.383e-7,
0.0046891752,
0.00878416,
0.0498644225,
0.0123592662,
0.0288297143,
-0.0400510244,
-0.0393020958,
0.035285484,
0.0190755408,
0.0298425499,
0.0416744836,
-0.0204028115,
0.096519962,
0.0333904549,
-0.0295094177,
-0.1059495062,
-0.0402383991,
0.0196981449,
-0.0085075153,
-0.0013497412,
-0.0181332454,
0.0693505853,
-0.0223782677,
-0.0107577387,
-0.0002716235,
-0.0063752276,
0.039444264,
0.0185754132,
-0.0206139889,
-0.0197631102,
0.02896934,
-0.0111456634,
-0.0472662523,
-0.0096743554,
-0.0691640675,
0.0293194279,
0.0379885659,
0.0810695663,
-0.0129446918,
-0.0484857932,
0.0135768699,
0.0219065957,
-0.0682824552,
0.0518542454,
0.0274714027,
-0.0131847886,
0.0143578881,
0.0083597805,
-0.0601455458,
0.0571303181,
-0.0354489721,
-0.0048378855,
-0.0247974619,
0.0469445139,
0.0582232662,
0.0182273127,
-0.0050513651,
-0.0045302245,
-0.0500703529,
0.0078778919,
-0.0428221188,
-0.0497312881,
-0.0161687657,
-0.0437390916,
-0.0246783774,
0.0107014738,
-0.0120097045,
2.021942348e-34,
0.0473248847,
-0.0220001265,
0.0093206959,
0.0136914589,
0.0022380971,
-0.0624057613,
0.0258508213,
0.0366751105,
0.0190629717,
-0.0397178754,
-0.0469133072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13199v1 | Knowledge-Retrieval Task-Oriented Dialog Systems with Semi-Supervision | 2023-05-22T16:29:20 | 2023-05-22T16:29:20 | Yucheng Cai, Hong Liu, Zhijian Ou, Yi Huang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing task-oriented dialog (TOD) systems track dialog states in terms
of slots and values and use them to query a database to get relevant knowledge
to generate responses. In real-life applications, user utterances are noisier,
and thus it is more difficult to accurately track dialog states and correctly
secure relevant knowledge. Recently, a progress in question answering and
document-grounded dialog systems is retrieval-augmented methods with a
knowledge retriever. Inspired by such progress, we propose a retrieval-based
method to enhance knowledge selection in TOD systems, which significantly
outperforms the traditional database query method for real-life dialogs.
Further, we develop latent variable model based semi-supervised learning, which
can work with the knowledge retriever to leverage both labeled and unlabeled
dialog data. Joint Stochastic Approximation (JSA) algorithm is employed for
semi-supervised model training, and the whole system is referred to as that
JSA-KRTOD. Experiments are conducted on a real-life dataset from China Mobile
Custom-Service, called MobileCS, and show that JSA-KRTOD achieves superior
performances in both labeled-only and semi-supervised settings. | [
0.0642377064,
0.0288511235,
-0.0088394145,
0.0297139976,
-0.0041127279,
-0.0090902876,
0.0360334963,
-0.0107001867,
0.0416016355,
-0.0664908513,
-0.0488795415,
-0.0464727655,
-0.0585910901,
0.0404048115,
-0.0079232072,
-0.0276510026,
0.0470361635,
-0.0221660659,
0.0363479033,
0.0031958371,
0.0228947438,
0.0033643043,
-0.038531445,
0.0267164726,
-0.0427013896,
-0.0320516229,
-0.0266135857,
-0.0221943054,
-0.0205499362,
-0.0076577808,
0.0601527877,
0.0341547579,
0.0233830865,
0.0052880296,
0.0000020624,
-0.0575143471,
-0.0253529251,
-0.006013548,
-0.0715708733,
-0.0417902619,
0.0052987169,
0.0364022776,
0.0026756541,
0.0233394485,
-0.0454943255,
-0.031840656,
0.0265003387,
0.0567520075,
0.0382123962,
0.0356912315,
-0.0006964702,
0.0267530084,
-0.0258580279,
0.0086266417,
0.0263065901,
-0.0760160685,
0.002904091,
0.0506032929,
0.0075226584,
0.0373523086,
0.0324142836,
0.0256844983,
-0.0189895015,
-0.0469662137,
0.0110352682,
-0.0113858469,
-0.0310795475,
0.0164274387,
-0.0135690309,
0.1082715839,
0.0773881078,
-0.0041481261,
0.0149809793,
0.0363112018,
-0.0411351807,
0.0171136092,
-0.0653071702,
-0.0644021928,
-0.0405793935,
-0.0082229134,
-0.0556057356,
0.0228543766,
-0.0291428007,
-0.0045114737,
-0.0221820846,
0.0519721135,
-0.0212284029,
-0.0843913332,
0.0324520804,
-0.0141417542,
0.0039469977,
-0.0126802931,
0.0369093977,
0.009193996,
-0.0116031421,
0.0255973674,
0.0209644027,
-0.0567651466,
-0.0069991392,
-0.0375701785,
-0.0395659395,
0.0058554104,
-0.0345173068,
0.0870940238,
0.0240896512,
0.0219509117,
0.0248035658,
-0.0150162932,
-0.0447951593,
-0.02385314,
-0.0783507228,
-0.0050926269,
-0.0442053676,
0.0898059532,
-0.0275115315,
-0.0135857724,
-0.0164231695,
0.0190816019,
0.0077809244,
-0.0233576931,
0.0088418499,
0.0573894717,
-0.0313725211,
0.0188480746,
-0.0372962207,
0.0253085494,
-0.0293495264,
0.0429194979,
-0.0167873483,
-0.0077228444,
-0.0143438447,
-0.0007109685,
0.0438058712,
-0.0182481036,
-0.0453268327,
0.0418624319,
-0.0437845401,
-0.0218249299,
-0.0120174503,
-0.0106912879,
-0.0380372554,
-0.0180799607,
-0.0223892275,
-0.0028550257,
0.0235753339,
-0.0171623603,
-0.0338547118,
-0.0034538831,
0.0293874443,
0.0379469991,
0.005290302,
0.0586102419,
0.0106590977,
-0.0158573836,
0.027681008,
0.0125361746,
-0.0356285386,
0.0353483409,
0.0073628845,
-0.0042897328,
0.0570143908,
0.0127330804,
0.0057035824,
-0.0306046829,
0.0415983237,
0.0047881301,
0.0563593246,
0.0679517686,
0.0052097342,
-0.0207411237,
0.0073871175,
0.0305998474,
-0.0447494872,
0.0120280599,
0.0417989194,
0.0493401401,
0.0026417174,
-0.0106313694,
-0.0097378604,
0.0564275756,
0.0176677071,
-0.0207449105,
0.0090855863,
0.0008792163,
-0.0538047403,
-0.0044055092,
0.0351885855,
-0.017216647,
-0.0586794913,
-0.0464130826,
0.0037129668,
-0.0173917934,
0.002075271,
0.0420793481,
0.0783564895,
0.0106754107,
-0.0313173234,
0.040699061,
-0.0030757729,
-0.033765804,
-0.0550659113,
-0.0485704169,
0.0547978282,
0.0396238305,
0.0344897993,
-0.0836043507,
-0.0369878151,
-0.0443963222,
0.0269991271,
-0.0025912807,
0.0058822897,
-0.0231110435,
0.0175595991,
-0.0425206907,
-0.0144471377,
0.0109369932,
-0.0084586106,
0.0119301314,
-0.0277071036,
0.0379614979,
0.030743923,
-0.041115988,
0.0322635844,
-0.0213116929,
0.0585739315,
-0.0295829102,
0.0534085445,
0.0273404755,
0.047611028,
0.0411741063,
-0.0071401638,
0.000564918,
0.0197832454,
0.0051341336,
-0.0108066751,
-0.0005775146,
-0.0509344935,
-0.0642017126,
0.004513504,
0.0258438066,
0.0082571916,
0.0007583223,
-0.0003015047,
-0.0574632399,
0.0257642455,
-0.0254821125,
-0.016160341,
-0.0725092143,
-0.0155207207,
0.0431686044,
-0.0099209761,
-0.0502470024,
0.0449273214,
0.0206573531,
0.0086944578,
0.022823235,
0.0084553761,
0.0252844188,
-0.0392186567,
0.0026297232,
-0.0038212331,
-0.0218265448,
0.0539765023,
0.0270193238,
-0.0075185914,
-0.026029475,
-0.031102851,
-0.1118662432,
0.01621259,
-0.0231615752,
0.0228656977,
-0.0151966829,
0.0233044457,
0.0118578095,
-0.033340428,
-0.0181271713,
-0.0097597102,
0.0465553142,
-0.0076759853,
0.0022485226,
0.0266633332,
0.0154476296,
-0.0718165636,
0.0249141771,
0.00230193,
0.0235026851,
-0.0128004113,
-0.0209540445,
-0.0137633029,
0.0033251089,
-0.0562432706,
0.035039153,
-0.0281799175,
-0.0170539636,
0.0288089234,
0.0149352113,
0.027865123,
0.0328978784,
0.015866857,
0.0420756862,
-0.0285294447,
-0.032927718,
-0.1022009104,
0.0664904788,
-0.0112769846,
-0.0488907844,
-0.0022819627,
0.0218153242,
0.0452420302,
0.0461894721,
0.0245389026,
0.0055678179,
-0.0261621159,
0.0232129861,
0.0108749438,
-0.0295551028,
-0.0389764048,
0.0354005918,
-0.0108240908,
0.0311719012,
-0.022199722,
-0.0102868946,
0.0843097344,
0.0335448086,
-0.0252526272,
-0.070725888,
-0.0376696885,
-0.0264504626,
0.0546918809,
-0.0353174731,
0.0111051062,
0.0320890993,
-0.0392467529,
-0.0092095546,
0.0075262305,
0.0127358362,
-0.0626458898,
0.0267444775,
-0.0134077445,
0.0469741821,
0.012871542,
-0.0726458803,
-0.0406478196,
-0.0134138623,
0.0034899351,
-0.0111182304,
0.0154550942,
0.0131356129,
0.0016059887,
0.0116374902,
0.024008397,
0.0256335177,
0.0204829648,
-0.0095804473,
-0.0128026269,
0.0450410321,
0.0523873754,
0.024522258,
-0.0326485336,
-0.002328967,
0.0678336546,
0.0602619797,
0.0655479506,
-0.0552109815,
0.0281289481,
-0.0275372118,
0.0243962035,
-0.0162928607,
-0.0174878612,
0.0154204275,
0.0460192673,
-0.0133941667,
-0.0259007085,
0.1067142412,
0.0326806791,
-0.0065946672,
-0.0418339781,
-0.0562329553,
-0.000994438,
0.0118544688,
0.0620679334,
-0.0839728788,
-0.0402003936,
-0.0133368103,
0.050328292,
-0.0110880435,
-0.0383958519,
0.0120308297,
-0.0672972798,
0.0375574306,
-0.0181565564,
-0.042634774,
-0.0444964617,
-0.0325110368,
0.0235448293,
0.0201577246,
0.0014642748,
0.023946356,
-0.0022592915,
-0.003457167,
0.0344998352,
-0.0299756508,
-0.0057025058,
0.0425547771,
-0.0005162802,
0.0209159758,
0.0495089851,
0.0347041637,
0.0445134677,
0.0124809602,
-0.0221576877,
-0.0114818709,
-0.004237345,
-0.0176922418,
0.0402329415,
-0.0316115506,
-0.0103280125,
-0.0447930992,
0.0503415614,
-0.0067613763,
0.0126781538,
0.0385362133,
0.0481951199,
-0.0629178509,
0.0152315069,
-0.0149044516,
-0.0069494247,
0.0596760586,
0.0533851013,
0.0116049144,
-0.0437010005,
-0.053643886,
-0.0071594655,
0.0098520191,
-0.006116447,
0.021956997,
-0.0255148523,
0.0062507275,
0.024638446,
-0.0827490985,
-0.0490795597,
0.0342595465,
0.0316885486,
-0.0124555789,
0.0268526189,
0.0436710119,
-0.0078201257,
-0.0110939816,
-0.0141606359,
-0.0423105471,
0.0057838941,
-0.0385996737,
-0.0224229544,
0.0386926644,
-0.0411854386,
-0.02929819,
-0.0401516594,
-0.0417417139,
-0.0398803316,
-0.0565631315,
0.060305357,
0.0122495443,
0.012584188,
-0.0100401603,
-0.0110496646,
0.0129378429,
0.0282253977,
-0.0776371583,
-0.057975959,
0.0452072844,
0.0256454851,
-0.0148344561,
0.0306124706,
-0.0589146465,
0.0241750218,
-0.036281988,
0.0117128566,
-0.053444054,
-0.0758020878,
0.0123470565,
0.0056989952,
0.0530320741,
0.0973361656,
-0.0066854749,
-0.0644052327,
0.0718643665,
0.0153755648,
-0.0200456176,
-0.0538747422,
0.0110844448,
-0.0441004336,
-0.0303403456,
0.0097019868,
-0.0128058121,
-0.0164173134,
0.0533112772,
0.0036631841,
-0.0045548193,
0.0449566729,
0.0064635854,
-0.0004294327,
-0.0279360954,
-0.0045624292,
0.0448999405,
0.0599659234,
0.0620470084,
0.0112391748,
0.0691461787,
0.0086908331,
-0.0396741033,
0.0158877131,
-0.0105106942,
-0.0540485792,
-0.0864290819,
-0.0159358811,
0.0082636951,
0.0254984926,
-0.0248829145,
0.0147226099,
-0.0115996888,
0.0150271794,
-0.029214846,
0.0343522504,
0.0181962959,
0.0247464851,
0.0236085746,
0.0274546333,
-0.0138490386,
0.0425567366,
0.0835806578,
0.0322314389,
0.0243445635,
-0.0282314289,
-0.0478644669,
-0.0664169267,
-0.0074761016,
0.019527439,
0.0660143718,
-0.0265961513,
0.0113367243,
-0.0115803899,
-0.0233126264,
0.0146202538,
-0.0106402021,
-0.0513011776,
-0.0237246603,
0.0719812736,
0.0526579581,
-0.0045076823,
-0.006921472,
-0.0497240759,
-0.0376383401,
0.0095049357,
-0.0059732436,
0.0109784082,
-6.06437756e-33,
-0.0274759345,
-0.0157997068,
0.0134852594,
0.0238643158,
0.000231914,
-0.0143487453,
-0.0296593625,
0.0157893598,
-0.020683039,
0.0078197652,
-0.0237640738,
-0.0219291914,
0.0076147579,
0.0334258229,
-0.0247419812,
-0.0366898365,
0.0423984341,
-0.0129264621,
0.0248828754,
0.0040616761,
0.0662761107,
0.058789406,
0.0274046566,
-0.0677411556,
0.0544774197,
0.0041270372,
0.0469732806,
0.0187038779,
0.0414865576,
0.0588930659,
-0.0054135909,
0.0449027233,
0.0093056178,
-0.030783549,
-0.0114268539,
0.0379056446,
-0.0919686258,
-0.0474688411,
0.0129563846,
0.0020917805,
-0.018488843,
0.0330243744,
-0.0185175817,
0.0115889004,
0.0229579136,
0.0235840101,
0.0309881866,
-0.0093208747,
-0.0318766497,
-0.0493882447,
-0.0274630301,
0.0115918303,
-0.0330161266,
-0.0479597151,
-0.0056860833,
0.0603988767,
-0.0029932761,
-0.0354347453,
-0.0341179296,
-0.0259729233,
-0.0314728469,
0.0280491449,
0.0126170181,
0.0366617478,
0.0055245343,
0.0562779829,
0.0136241969,
-0.0026918165,
-0.0635466576,
-0.0682217777,
-0.0476025231,
0.0434973687,
-0.0209498908,
0.0092107831,
0.0017166488,
-0.0161010306,
-0.0697516501,
0.0112142796,
0.0503852814,
0.0456606075,
0.0048939986,
0.022545252,
-0.0733195096,
0.0060191792,
-0.0445124581,
0.0536347553,
-0.0462090708,
-0.0398984589,
0.06825836,
0.0119895963,
-0.0321842767,
-0.0319114514,
0.0232559536,
-0.0202739369,
-0.0230246074,
0.0238831118,
0.0133747235,
-0.0035032607,
-0.033772409,
0.0255266465,
-0.0777620375,
-0.0298729725,
0.0125538204,
0.0073923189,
-0.0283004865,
0.0209299698,
-0.0153764719,
-0.0378174521,
-0.0517889,
0.010447639,
-0.0323563106,
0.0360289216,
-0.0488366894,
0.0231889635,
0.0295340642,
0.0005217478,
-0.0063700094,
0.096232295,
-0.0172370411,
-0.0186441429,
-0.0409428775,
-0.0720577165,
0.0202521905,
-0.0261250418,
-0.0240154881,
0.0001633254,
-0.0069763372,
-0.0271159336,
-0.0549866892,
-0.01068212,
0.022626698,
0.0348618329,
2.744e-7,
0.0072042895,
0.0277203526,
0.0042278059,
0.0250170566,
0.008602893,
0.056362763,
0.0129349809,
0.0045073768,
0.0371193103,
-0.0562587418,
0.0191236958,
0.0212953035,
0.0493598692,
0.018091606,
-0.1097304374,
-0.0538541488,
-0.0221593156,
-0.0146200098,
-0.0398536064,
-0.0392910168,
0.0804434046,
0.0534258448,
-0.0070726159,
0.0047564697,
-0.0271053016,
-0.0380220711,
0.047512535,
0.0293220859,
0.0013101669,
0.0442583226,
0.1006245613,
0.0056485268,
-0.0030974299,
0.025653271,
-0.0245287437,
0.0452940129,
0.0364926644,
0.0588924512,
0.0130592268,
-0.0448409133,
0.0022897574,
0.0093852878,
0.0124996556,
0.0096128471,
0.0859765038,
-0.037239626,
0.0127206668,
-0.0071952161,
-0.0095032277,
-0.0509945005,
-0.0161544904,
-0.0064978222,
-0.0130501483,
0.0313094407,
0.023584554,
-0.0077818288,
0.0248425175,
-0.0618872419,
0.0249487422,
0.0286286697,
-0.0278164539,
-0.0180433169,
-0.0307713319,
0.0179881491,
0.0223925654,
-0.0010419509,
0.0068974658,
2.162252063e-34,
0.0424818993,
-0.0131752817,
0.0057630097,
0.0605458021,
0.0267737787,
-0.019156795,
-0.012013752,
-0.0405132435,
0.0744199082,
-0.0655039847,
0.0034189865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13198v1 | Multilingual Holistic Bias: Extending Descriptors and Patterns to Unveil Demographic Biases in Languages at Scale | 2023-05-22T16:29:04 | 2023-05-22T16:29:04 | Marta R. Costa-jussà, Pierre Andrews, Eric Smith, Prangthip Hansanti, Christophe Ropers, Elahe Kalbassi, Cynthia Gao, Daniel Licht, Carleigh Wood | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | We introduce a multilingual extension of the HOLISTICBIAS dataset, the
largest English template-based taxonomy of textual people references:
MULTILINGUALHOLISTICBIAS. This extension consists of 20,459 sentences in 50
languages distributed across all 13 demographic axes. Source sentences are
built from combinations of 118 demographic descriptors and three patterns,
excluding nonsensical combinations. Multilingual translations include
alternatives for gendered languages that cover gendered translations when there
is ambiguity in English. Our benchmark is intended to uncover demographic
imbalances and be the tool to quantify mitigations towards them.
Our initial findings show that translation quality for EN-to-XX translations
is an average of 8 spBLEU better when evaluating with the masculine human
reference compared to feminine. In the opposite direction, XX-to-EN, we compare
the robustness of the model when the source input only differs in gender
(masculine or feminine) and masculine translations are an average of almost 4
spBLEU better than feminine. When embedding sentences to a joint multilingual
sentence representations space, we find that for most languages masculine
translations are significantly closer to the English neutral sentences when
embedded. | [
0.0429722406,
0.0678971261,
-0.0263264086,
0.0254749171,
0.0019043096,
0.0270572007,
0.0561566427,
-0.0248918477,
-0.0159942992,
-0.0462419093,
-0.0151595389,
-0.0771937743,
0.0557633005,
-0.0363805816,
0.0577540882,
-0.0340552069,
0.0278975628,
0.0253536012,
0.0129084876,
-0.0396334529,
0.0145978518,
0.0607524887,
0.040640045,
0.0398599617,
-0.01083495,
-0.0126742804,
0.0370356515,
0.0451850891,
0.0459005348,
0.0186074935,
0.0427666716,
0.0337447599,
-0.0037643521,
0.0359459333,
0.0000017887,
-0.0558095612,
0.0203951541,
0.0202473328,
0.0207718797,
-0.0194988772,
0.0710597187,
-0.0478103049,
-0.0125895832,
-0.0000965842,
0.0059591662,
0.005050634,
0.0424647816,
0.0200585332,
0.0206685569,
0.0346664898,
-0.0113109183,
-0.0368685052,
-0.050413873,
-0.0366494581,
0.0041536153,
-0.0052114599,
-0.004496051,
-0.0418792963,
-0.0689654946,
0.0152800325,
-0.0224994272,
0.0219823644,
-0.0009464205,
-0.0001099503,
-0.0063031563,
0.0078130029,
-0.0335607231,
-0.0526260138,
0.045509655,
0.0579164959,
-0.0033523471,
0.0146981562,
-0.0068689403,
0.0170879345,
0.0140709151,
0.0133270118,
-0.0058442326,
0.02837638,
-0.0101585258,
-0.0231099855,
0.0043504154,
-0.0093272282,
0.0236870833,
0.0213429295,
-0.0134906834,
0.0311894156,
0.0390171707,
-0.0391490422,
0.0334458798,
0.0206673648,
0.0061509572,
-0.0283654463,
0.0346576087,
-0.0407197028,
-0.0098004974,
0.0002582835,
-0.0143689085,
-0.0353859328,
0.0329312459,
-0.089351289,
-0.0178120062,
0.0424147546,
-0.0154994838,
0.0099139577,
-0.0038531404,
0.0521372221,
-0.0102759935,
-0.0171388034,
-0.0448823124,
-0.0683482587,
-0.0173588693,
-0.0011692434,
-0.0022003669,
-0.0273738261,
-0.0021716652,
0.0488838628,
-0.0658502504,
-0.0031906713,
-0.0473647751,
0.0068469741,
-0.0097665815,
0.0072554331,
-0.0219713897,
0.0123496503,
-0.0207038186,
0.0657838285,
-0.053074237,
-0.0088332165,
-0.0484708212,
-0.0778214857,
0.0168108083,
0.0318783,
-0.0090317782,
-0.0763621181,
-0.000270156,
0.0241848286,
0.0141117014,
-0.0222549587,
0.0099122422,
-0.0275094528,
-0.0507204607,
-0.0634199604,
0.0068023922,
-0.0751622915,
0.055268921,
0.0074260049,
0.0377539918,
-0.0702133477,
0.0035188296,
0.0211801492,
-0.0432890803,
0.0550970919,
0.0837592259,
-0.0056597483,
0.0374843515,
-0.0146687618,
0.0092532104,
0.0882963389,
0.0229119025,
0.0006633264,
0.0590886176,
0.0073812539,
-0.0357295349,
0.056754265,
-0.0029597017,
0.0455990173,
-0.0292420667,
0.0303933453,
0.0054569985,
0.0599008501,
0.0961459801,
0.0246188734,
0.001745261,
-0.0181204509,
0.0569796972,
0.0625194609,
0.0018499888,
0.0536223799,
0.037894886,
0.0067573027,
-0.0242378619,
0.0067767007,
-0.076111652,
0.0002962408,
0.0257998798,
-0.0526495613,
-0.0051104538,
0.0515426435,
-0.0260085315,
-0.0080811633,
-0.0015732589,
0.0154396771,
0.0063072871,
-0.01969794,
0.0046672835,
0.0109916683,
0.0223793499,
0.0870189965,
0.0255339779,
-0.0676298961,
0.006955802,
0.0026354257,
-0.0181273371,
0.0540872067,
-0.017395895,
-0.0087526795,
-0.0243316479,
-0.025360005,
-0.0320302472,
0.0308805685,
0.055712387,
0.0112897735,
0.0725548565,
-0.0377605967,
-0.0039220187,
0.0365511291,
0.023312103,
0.0395454429,
0.0179558676,
0.0725087374,
0.0405122414,
-0.0474788919,
-0.0681740418,
0.019079078,
-0.0092298351,
0.0029716294,
0.0461861081,
0.0216918904,
0.0151192527,
0.0207605585,
-0.0352194719,
-0.0288591981,
-0.0144493431,
-0.029663261,
0.006842385,
0.0584812835,
-0.0357057266,
-0.0309637897,
0.0361107811,
-0.0897783563,
-0.0841324627,
0.0255597159,
-0.0409606062,
-0.0037066108,
0.0442370959,
-0.0376722366,
-0.0325618386,
-0.0146169085,
-0.0028150857,
-0.0031895107,
0.0433825776,
-0.014612616,
0.0307585131,
0.0002198999,
-0.0007254604,
-0.0328534618,
-0.0570298508,
0.0215667002,
-0.0655224249,
-0.0194326043,
0.0100405468,
0.0079870746,
0.0041064215,
0.0535545908,
-0.0073465127,
-0.0216531213,
-0.0363971554,
-0.071173355,
-0.0051829019,
-0.0101587232,
0.0169587042,
0.0136568369,
0.025611857,
0.0008653014,
-0.0062897513,
-0.0444003083,
-0.0404708087,
-0.0101132803,
0.0402911864,
0.0353018269,
-0.022072969,
0.0326134153,
-0.0083059967,
-0.0217750017,
-0.0401601195,
0.0701672807,
0.006874484,
-0.0019602461,
-0.0346303657,
-0.0267691668,
-0.0527428985,
-0.0372382775,
0.0000648242,
-0.0306162015,
-0.008323526,
0.0426705033,
0.0681899339,
0.0524538755,
-0.0026283595,
-0.0075130458,
0.0436522998,
-0.010722816,
-0.0298556946,
-0.0085368967,
0.0342639387,
0.027532151,
0.0060870927,
-0.0963750258,
0.0010817365,
-0.0136755873,
0.0042124819,
-0.0478326492,
-0.0582927056,
0.0029217345,
-0.0256537795,
-0.0278518721,
-0.0648990124,
0.0220713858,
0.0248818975,
0.0374733172,
-0.0403156765,
-0.0143118966,
0.0443764143,
-0.0008243204,
-0.0061150906,
0.0000122634,
-0.0070322892,
-0.0644494817,
0.0145825427,
-0.0092941262,
0.025926955,
0.018844327,
-0.0064020269,
-0.0766877979,
-0.0025546958,
0.0336764455,
-0.0257122647,
0.0517938249,
-0.0253454316,
-0.0190951172,
-0.0204093661,
-0.0473872386,
0.0017738865,
-0.0371739045,
-0.0158927646,
-0.0010431511,
-0.0094853099,
-0.0282476693,
-0.0449761786,
-0.0387710966,
-0.0065399441,
0.020321684,
-0.047128275,
0.0027131136,
-0.0032523901,
0.0176251587,
-0.0017440143,
0.0107815256,
0.0211860053,
-0.0420732014,
-0.0047377646,
0.0206550043,
-0.0563168526,
-0.0090934196,
-0.0064134989,
0.0034482256,
0.0340920575,
-0.0083450107,
-0.0430354252,
-0.0342538133,
0.0504575446,
-0.0404461361,
0.0293162707,
0.1064304262,
0.00534443,
-0.0575978272,
0.0096279392,
-0.0215492677,
0.0396986976,
0.0435132198,
0.0202359576,
-0.0865124092,
-0.0006427345,
0.0349046253,
0.0073695648,
0.0068737995,
-0.0341999941,
-0.0309512969,
-0.1000534818,
0.0115170516,
0.0353875943,
-0.0396617875,
-0.0368661433,
0.0078635495,
-0.0237825662,
-0.048623208,
0.0369220041,
-0.021137191,
0.0112489546,
0.0073897592,
-0.0192844532,
-0.0182650443,
-0.0480484068,
0.0268976986,
-0.0810364261,
0.0071711955,
0.0060891467,
0.112773478,
-0.0143077457,
-0.0091862734,
0.0221661758,
-0.0078070462,
-0.0221565682,
0.0021560579,
0.0543513112,
-0.0296556614,
-0.0191115011,
-0.0506076589,
0.0128395678,
0.012383597,
0.0128223421,
0.0101426793,
0.0209399834,
0.038011156,
0.0018153102,
-0.0189499762,
-0.0226614643,
-0.0139320157,
0.0699291155,
0.0021259515,
-0.0343739949,
-0.0119729852,
-0.0562815629,
0.0265229028,
0.0059912573,
-0.0542492494,
0.0043942598,
-0.0152712017,
-0.0513630249,
-0.0382979475,
-0.0778230801,
-0.014027576,
0.0002931468,
0.0107253334,
-0.0751267448,
-0.0264791884,
-0.0001555253,
-0.0375548787,
0.0473779589,
-0.0300571434,
0.0523983538,
0.0027088188,
0.0226225909,
-0.0198006406,
-0.0296161138,
0.0020950949,
0.0166607369,
-0.0271588191,
-0.0583276078,
0.0158255193,
0.028744122,
0.0141848037,
0.0610469058,
-0.0103066135,
-0.0647414401,
0.0390251614,
0.0455926359,
-0.0167726018,
0.0162190385,
0.0248643011,
0.0339255817,
-0.0050395606,
0.0684728697,
-0.0254538357,
-0.0067512137,
-0.0162755102,
-0.0040524988,
0.006199318,
-0.0516012236,
-0.0052521667,
0.0216312874,
-0.0154662663,
-0.0621168874,
0.0233117249,
-0.0391133986,
-0.0090850722,
-0.0144566689,
-0.0487051569,
0.0072166189,
-0.0310459733,
0.0439365022,
0.0146124763,
-0.0046318509,
0.0355747677,
0.0028379837,
0.0163538642,
-0.0230628811,
-0.0179067794,
0.0256457794,
0.0442269258,
-0.0198169742,
0.049586013,
0.0188923869,
-0.0042730486,
-0.0443430208,
0.0476697236,
-0.0142662339,
-0.0088281287,
-0.0013091523,
0.0249796361,
-0.0068469332,
0.0050319452,
-0.0268822834,
0.0124632958,
0.003967606,
-0.0565177016,
0.04430677,
-0.0247026365,
0.0875259042,
0.02745343,
-0.026116306,
0.0109118745,
0.02028488,
-0.0056545851,
0.0083201313,
0.0125739127,
-0.0119783729,
0.0055017979,
-0.0009601479,
0.0478494614,
0.0195636768,
0.0343880467,
0.003620317,
-0.053407941,
-0.0249529406,
-0.0107297329,
-0.0155733731,
-0.0438623913,
-0.0134542016,
-0.0332067907,
-0.0870131478,
-0.0647929087,
0.0162967723,
-0.0386983119,
0.0191374794,
0.0201504063,
-0.004024257,
0.0423924141,
-0.0217361618,
-0.0441296436,
-0.0369754322,
-0.0000686725,
-0.0205061492,
-0.0065840622,
-0.0404755995,
-5.993523536e-33,
-0.0263516065,
0.0075645265,
-0.0542599857,
-0.0790596977,
-0.0378896669,
-0.0007004245,
0.0002301398,
-0.0012148084,
-0.0000827775,
0.056755811,
0.0072885016,
0.0354692712,
0.0151573047,
0.0097076539,
0.0224883836,
0.0318802148,
0.0661007538,
0.0302795377,
-0.0257420354,
-0.0106103374,
0.0295333564,
0.0163298622,
0.0772390813,
-0.0460555181,
0.077848725,
-0.0049207965,
-0.0161286313,
0.0242740866,
0.0238598883,
0.0157436486,
0.0032225719,
0.0787552223,
0.0095520383,
0.0074705048,
0.0066897706,
0.0490121618,
-0.0971616805,
-0.0439494662,
0.0147825964,
0.0582798533,
0.0363032073,
-0.082667321,
0.0262293145,
0.0038309838,
-0.0175010338,
-0.0414572135,
0.0691890195,
0.0038000061,
0.0368925817,
0.002282327,
-0.0454693586,
0.025573872,
-0.0416598283,
0.0491429381,
0.0050589996,
0.0673206821,
-0.0064597963,
0.0233632922,
-0.0630872548,
0.0229527261,
-0.0552201234,
-0.0035204759,
0.0006851028,
-0.0014255178,
0.0032121332,
0.0144873615,
0.0367202684,
0.0290145203,
-0.0284742452,
-0.0608372353,
0.038215328,
-0.0461774878,
0.0182471536,
0.0935746282,
0.0414261371,
-0.0025519079,
-0.0656413063,
-0.010480742,
0.0181713682,
0.0464295968,
0.0096305432,
-0.017752029,
-0.045462016,
-0.0385926589,
-0.0447820723,
-0.0624788031,
-0.0153230662,
-0.021226678,
0.0000079705,
-0.0172763448,
-0.0172190629,
0.0199468732,
0.0303196218,
-0.0465923622,
-0.021624485,
0.0242419448,
-0.0387654305,
-0.0185439214,
0.0542716049,
0.0313278735,
-0.0230730884,
-0.012109004,
0.0124896439,
0.0345016085,
0.0352245197,
-0.0073831803,
0.0527517162,
0.027330745,
-0.0830496177,
0.0045981016,
-0.0270118229,
-0.0203390215,
-0.0238264203,
0.0394930094,
0.0257972069,
0.0281371605,
-0.0179860312,
0.0065275547,
0.0669671819,
0.0545854643,
-0.0326212756,
0.0190003999,
0.01129092,
0.045831047,
-0.0332806483,
-0.0007990587,
-0.0232995227,
-0.0171672665,
0.0909772366,
-0.0486197621,
-0.0179984011,
-0.05927331,
2.56e-7,
0.0100819105,
0.0509477146,
-0.0013668499,
0.0022222169,
0.0440772623,
0.038381815,
0.0182879809,
0.0583760217,
0.0243774373,
0.0290970765,
-0.0176348034,
0.0222238805,
0.0290046949,
0.0664920285,
-0.061438866,
0.0113822194,
-0.0659895837,
0.0151956473,
-0.0149451001,
0.0373934098,
-0.0055919001,
0.1133770868,
0.0534645133,
0.0065482603,
-0.0169010069,
-0.0076790634,
0.067792736,
-0.0155563829,
-0.0008167882,
-0.006000597,
-0.0139973145,
0.015486653,
0.0075499113,
0.0249875858,
0.0177617315,
0.0314742886,
0.0266693346,
0.016028868,
-0.0379619002,
0.0283133984,
-0.0216725729,
-0.0133469701,
-0.0497162081,
-0.0580850244,
0.0480864048,
0.0130604254,
-0.0597849376,
-0.0494734868,
-0.0327700153,
0.0379579179,
0.0831164569,
0.0004166311,
-0.0366381668,
0.0380840711,
0.0367606729,
-0.0114719551,
-0.0127651803,
-0.0503123626,
-0.0446711667,
-0.0005094241,
-0.0009396966,
-0.0254197419,
0.0104939882,
0.0320096985,
0.0170947742,
-0.0496262386,
0.0422789194,
1.985339245e-34,
0.0277880337,
0.0338199846,
-0.0001341573,
-0.0348067917,
0.0215390828,
-0.0356912091,
-0.0280971117,
-0.0143914558,
0.0590470806,
0.013221425,
-0.005133539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13197v1 | Challenging Decoder helps in Masked Auto-Encoder Pre-training for Dense Passage Retrieval | 2023-05-22T16:27:10 | 2023-05-22T16:27:10 | Zehan Li, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recently, various studies have been directed towards exploring dense passage
retrieval techniques employing pre-trained language models, among which the
masked auto-encoder (MAE) pre-training architecture has emerged as the most
promising. The conventional MAE framework relies on leveraging the passage
reconstruction of decoder to bolster the text representation ability of
encoder, thereby enhancing the performance of resulting dense retrieval
systems. Within the context of building the representation ability of the
encoder through passage reconstruction of decoder, it is reasonable to
postulate that a ``more demanding'' decoder will necessitate a corresponding
increase in the encoder's ability. To this end, we propose a novel token
importance aware masking strategy based on pointwise mutual information to
intensify the challenge of the decoder. Importantly, our approach can be
implemented in an unsupervised manner, without adding additional expenses to
the pre-training phase. Our experiments verify that the proposed method is both
effective and robust on large-scale supervised passage retrieval datasets and
out-of-domain zero-shot retrieval benchmarks. | [
-0.0059228973,
0.0552712642,
-0.0098073417,
0.0577489175,
-0.0167433303,
0.0259858146,
0.0423766002,
0.0339269526,
-0.0084690312,
-0.0565550253,
-0.0089392671,
-0.0459306203,
-0.0107945567,
0.0868046209,
0.0066199913,
-0.0405692719,
0.0207889378,
-0.0369836837,
0.0238317475,
0.0068319966,
-0.0095010577,
0.0030149329,
0.0028981501,
0.0288734809,
0.0090249088,
0.0163130648,
0.0125391623,
-0.0003757194,
0.0328070335,
-0.0574278012,
0.0306943916,
0.0001801587,
0.0523427278,
0.0090556685,
0.00000212,
-0.0499623939,
-0.0500354171,
-0.0016882455,
-0.0351710208,
-0.011957176,
0.0156238507,
-0.013249103,
0.0348787718,
-0.0154786399,
0.0037953292,
-0.0610946901,
0.034112379,
0.0350432582,
0.0321691632,
0.0593999848,
-0.0342495292,
-0.0340931006,
-0.0033013348,
-0.0131951943,
0.0018651169,
-0.071110025,
0.0377300717,
-0.0479959212,
-0.0508515462,
0.0303536505,
-0.0367879197,
0.0327907242,
-0.0105648311,
0.0154978614,
0.0552729256,
0.0363737941,
-0.0054911366,
0.0339041241,
-0.0015423556,
0.0482137576,
-0.026532989,
-0.0302424897,
-0.0153261274,
-0.0199077968,
-0.0314757302,
-0.01564564,
-0.0228373818,
0.0145266391,
0.0100413905,
0.0227528866,
-0.0370602794,
0.0766145587,
0.0078335293,
-0.0044407337,
-0.0793610215,
-0.0223468374,
0.0056187897,
0.0022981653,
-0.0100855026,
-0.0098652449,
-0.0545772836,
-0.0037069055,
0.0543008409,
0.0119949318,
0.0495883301,
-0.0059248763,
-0.0157623049,
-0.0664805993,
-0.0520369299,
-0.0026663411,
0.0138798803,
0.0545033887,
-0.0415608026,
0.0367743969,
-0.0273251459,
0.0702848509,
0.032675121,
0.0315845311,
-0.0304976515,
-0.022671435,
0.0028811635,
-0.0234485213,
-0.075077042,
0.0735291019,
-0.0448329188,
0.0096836863,
0.0140948249,
-0.0287216324,
0.0298989359,
-0.0168921556,
-0.0323894694,
0.0189790893,
-0.0360918492,
-0.0430392139,
0.0219831653,
0.0222313516,
-0.0106149986,
-0.0173113588,
-0.0014474862,
-0.0012059042,
-0.0414594561,
0.0119880838,
0.0454487167,
-0.0178202633,
0.0295234993,
0.0242578033,
-0.037345726,
-0.0787022859,
-0.036548268,
0.0017874596,
-0.0132609829,
0.0002402458,
-0.0297447052,
-0.0205748174,
0.0460224859,
0.0094447276,
0.0218438767,
-0.0408187434,
0.0075454521,
0.0167487171,
-0.0108427033,
0.0600670576,
0.0057569523,
-0.0299744252,
0.0317149423,
0.0454835407,
0.030947797,
0.0469072312,
0.0337411948,
0.0454957746,
0.0370226875,
0.0111566978,
0.0033001569,
0.0303654093,
0.0014194394,
-0.0065241647,
-0.0034639339,
-0.0160458498,
0.0163788218,
-0.035868682,
0.0547311828,
0.0292882808,
-0.0669018999,
-0.0392354317,
0.0249450617,
0.0618527606,
-0.0022538842,
-0.0090268385,
0.0452722684,
0.0290916432,
0.002498223,
0.0317236073,
0.0150340982,
0.0043279533,
-0.0093415231,
-0.0054699406,
0.0327653438,
0.0248326324,
-0.0287536718,
-0.0234583206,
0.0301967189,
-0.0205743182,
-0.0251632668,
0.0024724174,
0.075231187,
0.0161632635,
-0.078655161,
0.020851424,
0.0237999931,
-0.0379401483,
0.0357918181,
-0.0262043532,
-0.0259826165,
0.0239738636,
0.0805642456,
-0.0863212198,
0.0047333357,
0.0054970551,
-0.019166939,
-0.0219652895,
-0.0199537389,
-0.021532543,
0.0445139445,
-0.0880437121,
-0.0213131066,
-0.0130799683,
0.0010464984,
0.0417198017,
-0.0207585208,
0.0520257391,
0.0210251287,
-0.0370593891,
0.0055997032,
0.0365781002,
-0.0095516872,
-0.0582442917,
0.0078139184,
0.017903557,
-0.0181217864,
0.0324825533,
-0.0329581834,
-0.008654369,
0.0419195108,
-0.068396464,
-0.003335597,
0.0047935392,
-0.0976517051,
-0.0334545597,
-0.01064815,
-0.0083306516,
-0.0017830333,
0.0658239722,
-0.0045856419,
-0.0422695875,
-0.0380433165,
-0.0034708087,
0.0383655652,
-0.003855302,
0.0309677552,
0.0196517799,
0.0116685471,
-0.0705356821,
0.0608398505,
0.0005823335,
0.0178759135,
0.0037673838,
0.016164992,
0.031204313,
-0.0273052808,
-0.0325530805,
0.0163408536,
-0.0104335556,
-0.0181509368,
0.0445292108,
-0.036093168,
0.0351395532,
-0.0156109119,
-0.0612380765,
-0.0417985171,
-0.0376488082,
0.0032925452,
0.0020974255,
0.038808655,
-0.0252455696,
-0.02152366,
0.0268215686,
-0.0277286433,
0.0103171933,
-0.0065304115,
0.0060259271,
0.0240495503,
0.014709821,
-0.0200064294,
-0.0219768994,
0.0042134249,
0.0553474575,
-0.0275674034,
-0.0735847205,
-0.0425828062,
0.0416779406,
0.0491639599,
0.0263432786,
-0.0330159329,
-0.0142622432,
-0.0111192269,
-0.026877597,
0.020276906,
0.0356373489,
0.0054268856,
0.0282271057,
0.0283571351,
-0.030252317,
-0.0735660717,
0.0321708582,
-0.0083365403,
-0.0142056951,
-0.0262475051,
-0.0195884015,
0.0274044164,
0.0418354608,
0.0208520163,
0.0110301571,
-0.0436280742,
-0.0328585804,
-0.01344469,
-0.0374717712,
-0.0392892882,
-0.0240698215,
-0.0181832369,
0.0459748097,
-0.018611908,
-0.0135010658,
0.0294737369,
-0.0573093668,
-0.0336511396,
-0.0470170081,
0.014559133,
-0.0556383096,
0.1139608473,
0.0161160678,
0.0280486643,
0.0474093743,
-0.0920964107,
-0.0014619339,
0.0379992425,
0.0009165557,
-0.0365227126,
-0.0010410384,
-0.0109577887,
0.0188987404,
-0.003769655,
-0.0235056616,
-0.0410672501,
-0.0501731522,
-0.0106659485,
-0.0245308466,
0.0280435458,
-0.0097863441,
-0.010965785,
0.0539732687,
-0.0065034311,
0.0649024472,
0.0106989807,
-0.0006890083,
-0.035539262,
0.0610536225,
0.0303079691,
0.0034736283,
-0.0085391356,
-0.0219650324,
0.0377923846,
0.0241095517,
0.0104599381,
-0.0047964961,
0.025790602,
0.0315578282,
0.0699781105,
-0.039216157,
0.0131604522,
-0.0171083491,
0.0633595288,
-0.0473619923,
-0.0457421727,
0.1039679497,
0.0288410485,
-0.0662898347,
-0.0498351604,
-0.0166519061,
0.0088325245,
-0.0039323019,
-0.0061863908,
-0.0605171584,
-0.0155150304,
0.0300345812,
0.0375339426,
0.0127654141,
-0.0250188988,
0.0055930568,
-0.097951673,
0.0500243045,
0.0321225636,
-0.0068354225,
-0.0838128999,
-0.0539982878,
-0.0198641345,
0.0054679327,
0.0143493647,
0.0095037594,
0.0004572992,
-0.0289520491,
0.0013007293,
-0.0014531043,
-0.0262641013,
-0.0084101288,
-0.0337396413,
0.0093777636,
0.0344747715,
0.0135636535,
-0.000643297,
0.0317064077,
-0.0018555466,
-0.0643432364,
-0.0057931012,
-0.0081150271,
0.0993897021,
-0.0472479686,
-0.0135732517,
-0.0118513238,
0.0121790394,
0.0149795506,
-0.038456019,
-0.0292439759,
-0.009583151,
-0.0136416163,
0.0083068628,
-0.0219816379,
0.0015836202,
-0.0068061687,
0.0687322915,
-0.0056660851,
0.0175310988,
-0.0050822566,
-0.0232562087,
0.049343884,
-0.0624601841,
-0.0469379947,
0.0288504343,
-0.0013279006,
0.0054642642,
-0.066113174,
-0.0270655416,
0.0141364466,
0.0443808362,
-0.0051657376,
0.0203731768,
-0.0157749187,
-0.0214428641,
-0.0500779152,
0.0218575634,
-0.0664543733,
-0.0112969829,
-0.0641923323,
-0.0152094988,
0.0195262209,
-0.0305918679,
-0.0257134698,
0.0126450993,
-0.0174137,
-0.0421046838,
0.0098362314,
0.0183313806,
0.015870735,
0.044164259,
-0.0196630191,
-0.0717585236,
0.1114239469,
-0.023657592,
-0.0643951669,
0.0271437448,
0.0187754184,
-0.029975431,
-0.0613040365,
0.0111005828,
-0.0516544022,
0.029098656,
-0.0044925618,
0.0153596969,
0.0080527877,
-0.0423028655,
0.0153680947,
0.0065873633,
0.0591410771,
0.008475503,
0.0319289565,
-0.0547166392,
0.020137148,
-0.0273737554,
-0.0095042055,
-0.0323669575,
0.0242935736,
0.0475576036,
-0.0191785656,
-0.0446859933,
0.0724919438,
0.0230180398,
0.0146717681,
-0.0322124064,
0.0121357841,
-0.0187617932,
-0.008610812,
0.000635375,
0.0117165502,
-0.0205743071,
0.0058159386,
-0.0004971984,
0.0502779,
-0.0166205466,
0.0259845015,
0.0012198319,
-0.0046327934,
-0.0174047146,
0.0211739782,
-0.0653181151,
0.0145469345,
-0.043547295,
-0.0150012467,
0.0506310575,
-0.0444604158,
0.0310505591,
-0.0007191745,
0.0056153727,
-0.014228845,
-0.0436486043,
0.0311314482,
0.0112912999,
-0.005707134,
0.020319974,
-0.0164496452,
0.056361232,
0.0794217885,
0.044024244,
0.0553196892,
0.0260067042,
-0.0079025729,
-0.02453731,
0.0055786367,
0.0604027025,
0.0807033852,
-0.0165536478,
-0.0109372716,
-0.0094067864,
-0.0267219692,
0.0774102956,
-0.0356355608,
0.0168721769,
0.0016613204,
0.013505809,
0.0077524562,
-0.0113844676,
-0.0069326991,
-0.0125542721,
0.0113583812,
0.0454498082,
0.0085434848,
-0.0190243032,
-6.300538783e-33,
-0.0531800762,
0.0287086871,
-0.0145737436,
0.0028866036,
-0.0317501724,
0.0387852713,
-0.0167816021,
-0.0240447987,
0.0120723341,
-0.0061777215,
-0.008694781,
-0.0135555109,
0.0252289232,
0.009957226,
-0.0613224134,
0.0079368707,
0.0673363209,
-0.006254972,
-0.0388368964,
0.012694546,
0.0408426523,
0.0636913255,
0.0180341937,
-0.045684848,
-0.0114335902,
-0.0552956909,
0.0116259251,
-0.0041127591,
0.0678782016,
0.0113399019,
-0.032278318,
0.0111156404,
0.0167151038,
-0.0059349304,
-0.0273171887,
-0.0049046553,
-0.1170356423,
-0.0158544313,
-0.0425729789,
0.031906765,
0.0322494097,
-0.0397804342,
0.0286516957,
-0.0153825143,
0.0234310888,
-0.0221834425,
0.0290971044,
0.0098647885,
0.0218765419,
-0.0625495613,
-0.0452296175,
0.0499590077,
-0.0318082497,
-0.0169193167,
0.0873398036,
0.0304827709,
0.0741257668,
-0.0132058142,
-0.0502907634,
-0.0001277833,
-0.0216034334,
0.0675983578,
-0.0234158337,
0.0337336138,
-0.0238870755,
0.0697118044,
0.0323481187,
-0.036258582,
-0.0265400317,
0.0236889627,
0.0524157099,
-0.0102755316,
0.0088795805,
0.0189831741,
0.0277246013,
-0.0267050508,
-0.0809918568,
0.0664701462,
-0.0449968353,
-0.0063734148,
0.0425034426,
0.0586299188,
-0.0543958023,
-0.0095227314,
-0.0292467941,
-0.0238767099,
-0.0089588426,
0.0174560566,
0.0309232827,
0.0331514329,
-0.0560809933,
0.0048581287,
0.0909809768,
-0.0118452273,
0.0178903677,
-0.023145359,
0.0113084447,
0.0730582848,
-0.0216835067,
0.0572717413,
-0.0026020329,
-0.0295285266,
0.0436530709,
-0.046528019,
0.0060031861,
-0.0265003107,
0.028314082,
0.0157851987,
-0.0707664639,
-0.0185965579,
-0.0011325052,
-0.02199338,
0.0303093456,
0.0418198332,
-0.0011035958,
0.036890585,
0.0057824138,
0.0637217909,
0.0192118566,
0.0261763427,
-0.0384041667,
0.0089909015,
0.0029699109,
0.0069440803,
-0.0187202115,
0.0206063241,
-0.018864207,
0.0281494446,
0.0362615846,
-0.0358484238,
-0.0149729019,
0.026163213,
2.667e-7,
0.0370147713,
-0.0037371393,
0.0772560388,
-0.0065952376,
-0.024158014,
0.0234975778,
0.0046193344,
0.0272202548,
0.0337913185,
-0.023606291,
0.0184927378,
0.0410262048,
0.0000145322,
-0.0058135618,
-0.0821175128,
-0.0025312621,
0.0422550254,
-0.0610393733,
-0.0418698043,
-0.0052840784,
0.0658637434,
0.066977337,
-0.0094717229,
0.0282012466,
0.0078459736,
-0.0500569977,
0.0579942651,
0.0066449568,
-0.0081828646,
0.0509576835,
0.02709236,
0.0342194065,
-0.0360685326,
0.0127203641,
-0.0036067753,
0.0552350469,
0.0712573826,
0.025155047,
-0.0097642913,
-0.048135899,
0.0102777919,
0.0351942703,
-0.0249428526,
-0.0191466343,
0.0890291855,
-0.0305670761,
-0.0075206622,
0.0010802866,
-0.0645674616,
0.0169378854,
-0.0306909382,
0.0252059754,
-0.0587659813,
0.0577620305,
0.0317386054,
0.0302860383,
-0.0241737179,
-0.1244347915,
-0.0010396986,
-0.0311866309,
-0.0296298191,
0.0126872314,
-0.0131274555,
-0.0234090835,
-0.0109490668,
-0.0840184987,
0.0133652883,
2.641390908e-34,
0.0006529899,
-0.0071259299,
-0.0132280132,
0.017565947,
0.063859351,
-0.0492619015,
-0.0078280475,
0.0327957161,
-0.0276461728,
-0.0870545506,
-0.0265614912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13194v2 | SEAHORSE: A Multilingual, Multifaceted Dataset for Summarization Evaluation | 2023-05-22T16:25:07 | 2023-11-01T22:29:53 | Elizabeth Clark, Shruti Rijhwani, Sebastian Gehrmann, Joshua Maynez, Roee Aharoni, Vitaly Nikolaev, Thibault Sellam, Aditya Siddhant, Dipanjan Das, Ankur P. Parikh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reliable automatic evaluation of summarization systems is challenging due to
the multifaceted and subjective nature of the task. This is especially the case
for languages other than English, where human evaluations are scarce. In this
work, we introduce SEAHORSE, a dataset for multilingual, multifaceted
summarization evaluation. SEAHORSE consists of 96K summaries with human ratings
along 6 dimensions of text quality: comprehensibility, repetition, grammar,
attribution, main ideas, and conciseness, covering 6 languages, 9 systems and 4
datasets. As a result of its size and scope, SEAHORSE can serve both as a
benchmark to evaluate learnt metrics, as well as a large-scale resource for
training such metrics. We show that metrics trained with SEAHORSE achieve
strong performance on the out-of-domain meta-evaluation benchmarks TRUE
(Honovich et al., 2022) and mFACE (Aharoni et al., 2022). We make the SEAHORSE
dataset and metrics publicly available for future research on multilingual and
multifaceted summarization evaluation. | [
0.025286993,
0.019309897,
0.0324623473,
0.0159650315,
-0.0058869263,
0.010681604,
-0.0172580853,
-0.0429027081,
-0.0306262001,
-0.0286179055,
-0.0514331274,
0.003967708,
0.0480800159,
-0.0189162809,
0.0155096306,
-0.0912769064,
0.0211451668,
-0.0061780051,
-0.0239120256,
0.0139759062,
0.0497530065,
-0.002662468,
0.0095467418,
0.0452909879,
0.0073980964,
0.0044953451,
0.0247894265,
-0.006329638,
0.0726672933,
-0.0185742658,
0.0206933599,
-0.0121365627,
-0.0013267496,
0.0257583577,
0.0000017044,
-0.0347933806,
-0.0222944729,
-0.0174438674,
0.0385526679,
0.0284603648,
0.0632669181,
-0.0388339125,
0.0277748592,
-0.0082087331,
-0.005388157,
-0.0003083054,
-0.0011585355,
0.0324224532,
0.1253958195,
0.0431861654,
-0.0106830131,
-0.0289554894,
-0.021615183,
-0.0217144564,
-0.0723131076,
-0.013422465,
-0.0256570447,
0.0266904123,
-0.0342346877,
-0.0359977782,
-0.0028390223,
0.0230198912,
0.0100658946,
0.0108291656,
-0.0206643604,
-0.0003538446,
-0.0922621414,
-0.0190344211,
0.0306055695,
0.0992029831,
0.0119656771,
-0.0052685416,
-0.003288161,
0.020555472,
0.002784203,
-0.0356649868,
-0.0491547287,
0.0399283022,
-0.001546909,
0.0253093652,
-0.0353121087,
0.0525693707,
-0.0023062378,
0.0380548276,
0.0011505551,
0.0170683824,
0.0009540246,
0.0079371873,
-0.0284385588,
0.0147358067,
-0.0284179058,
-0.0054765842,
0.010883512,
0.01627771,
-0.0158338025,
-0.0260473639,
-0.0458615795,
-0.066120401,
0.0377621055,
-0.0450234078,
0.0163635798,
0.0044559119,
-0.0192743391,
0.0444490165,
-0.0144263506,
0.0178656522,
0.0427476764,
0.0271280482,
-0.0389095657,
-0.0352792628,
-0.0331639014,
0.0409411639,
-0.0326451026,
0.0468003303,
-0.0006000424,
0.0013915077,
-0.0752828419,
-0.0192282479,
-0.0266703945,
0.0130513823,
0.0097362297,
-0.0047321804,
0.0125184748,
0.0063281055,
-0.0116911149,
0.0408522859,
-0.0701108426,
-0.0130776186,
0.0285099279,
0.0204891209,
-0.0221260656,
0.0348301232,
0.000909323,
0.0122954939,
0.0256430283,
0.0326220952,
-0.0197826605,
-0.0206738841,
-0.037729688,
-0.0421674326,
-0.0270223394,
-0.0682382584,
-0.0344009325,
-0.0736389607,
0.0034513264,
-0.0077771638,
-0.0130578214,
-0.0032890479,
-0.0103900013,
0.0295841675,
-0.0000385172,
0.0124877067,
-0.0257444046,
-0.0143562378,
0.0094154309,
0.0058212578,
-0.0030935141,
0.0376905836,
0.0503570549,
0.0534761287,
0.0562691949,
0.0543760546,
-0.0006624992,
0.0190967731,
0.0181488339,
0.02099053,
0.0276629403,
-0.0147165107,
-0.0332802571,
0.0023354082,
0.0339903682,
0.0684478506,
-0.0579833835,
0.0225777924,
0.046842251,
0.0287043639,
0.0217439178,
0.0207731351,
0.0596344396,
-0.0029351062,
0.0476020202,
0.0578737371,
0.0075058271,
0.0361803211,
-0.0069402759,
0.0647036955,
0.0944845974,
0.0615083501,
-0.0135247344,
-0.0705410689,
0.030910233,
-0.0220551789,
0.0010254878,
-0.0100103235,
0.0259674359,
0.0310929976,
-0.0163374543,
0.0398535356,
0.0058199838,
-0.0904309824,
0.0270981248,
-0.0065837679,
0.0188436545,
0.0498157851,
0.0258805286,
-0.0303305592,
-0.0022722781,
-0.0202939417,
0.03102584,
0.0086010462,
0.0264830906,
-0.0355783142,
0.0448021963,
-0.0548986271,
-0.0152518274,
-0.0124444282,
0.0037469559,
-0.003548282,
-0.0256915838,
-0.0105399918,
0.0387994871,
-0.0484316014,
-0.058859352,
0.024438886,
0.0175627936,
0.0080602635,
-0.0042041433,
-0.0012946136,
0.016845068,
0.0460769758,
-0.0186609365,
0.0085308794,
0.0165669303,
-0.0554592721,
-0.0140331332,
0.0297860634,
-0.0251250938,
-0.0325414129,
0.0358923562,
-0.090550974,
-0.0140299546,
0.035531994,
-0.0392934866,
-0.0514991023,
0.0426909104,
-0.0440616459,
-0.0128847538,
-0.0411956161,
-0.001976927,
0.0135553218,
0.0160811823,
-0.0027564245,
0.045501478,
0.0005115923,
0.0064535323,
0.0339383967,
-0.0629256666,
0.0425916724,
-0.007614885,
-0.0120672099,
-0.0028822513,
-0.0051229056,
0.0411079377,
0.0564035103,
0.0390334167,
-0.0354769304,
0.00648693,
-0.1083210111,
0.015012051,
-0.0359000899,
0.0163606759,
0.0510133393,
0.011972311,
0.008556311,
-0.0000865489,
-0.0193984937,
-0.0486153364,
0.0158613212,
-0.0057037887,
0.0364182703,
0.0149922371,
0.0625677481,
-0.0677971542,
-0.0278930757,
0.0170167107,
0.0670365393,
-0.0155468984,
0.0014770636,
-0.0020382227,
-0.0047875843,
-0.0449340455,
-0.0501471348,
0.019078562,
0.0013754895,
-0.018475987,
0.0207482819,
0.0410660952,
0.0386818647,
0.0303124376,
-0.0109782843,
0.055738885,
0.0293081217,
-0.0258733854,
-0.0073342826,
-0.0035105392,
0.0163784865,
0.0267475583,
-0.0029448124,
0.0227357429,
0.0226342976,
0.0139326081,
0.002711178,
-0.0235396046,
0.0334623978,
-0.0300929155,
-0.0203797258,
-0.0552110597,
0.0056591164,
-0.0013426502,
0.029712813,
-0.0250754952,
-0.0110876746,
0.081434913,
-0.0202789661,
-0.0012125237,
-0.0646966621,
-0.0043237107,
-0.0583048724,
0.0217776615,
-0.0200338252,
0.0415500849,
-0.007442357,
0.0157591309,
-0.0422968268,
-0.0388345495,
0.0777764767,
-0.0007414322,
0.0806035921,
-0.0344640315,
-0.0200490281,
-0.0333459899,
-0.0290808603,
0.0058665946,
0.0007598426,
-0.0397884399,
0.0000372003,
-0.0026098096,
0.0084192306,
-0.041530259,
-0.0187691841,
0.0788394734,
0.0472104028,
-0.0340637043,
-0.0157256424,
0.0140978806,
0.0561695807,
0.0542756394,
0.0216291808,
0.0369945355,
-0.0370697342,
0.0356360376,
0.0187997185,
0.0035960719,
-0.0211710948,
0.0047156485,
-0.0137756635,
-0.0003306297,
-0.0382123888,
0.0270105898,
-0.0225265827,
0.074120149,
-0.0308110341,
0.0052592577,
0.0881287828,
0.0060897307,
-0.0348198041,
-0.0192267019,
0.0039208094,
0.0363947265,
0.0125717493,
-0.0209585801,
-0.0557974018,
-0.0383501016,
-0.0181417838,
0.020325372,
0.0459813848,
-0.0051685362,
-0.0049148891,
-0.0702736899,
-0.0121833272,
0.0107129999,
-0.1045927033,
-0.0520631038,
-0.0333197117,
-0.008658451,
-0.0585017689,
0.0284240544,
-0.015390778,
-0.0098465914,
0.02230292,
-0.0044237007,
-0.0660856962,
-0.0034792947,
-0.0093397591,
-0.0537934341,
-0.0137103098,
0.0385715663,
0.0508427694,
-0.0183835551,
0.0079476926,
0.034741953,
-0.0202034563,
-0.047901392,
0.0319097154,
0.0779647455,
0.0033731048,
-0.0008009964,
-0.0475341678,
0.0349457413,
0.0006276018,
-0.0120631121,
0.0341469161,
0.0164335333,
0.0497434177,
-0.020863425,
-0.0472948477,
0.0412896872,
-0.0459501147,
0.067388162,
0.0358319394,
-0.0229429007,
-0.0146125033,
-0.0369442739,
-0.0231628288,
-0.0900873542,
-0.0374328718,
0.0269407276,
-0.0176508743,
-0.0069697588,
-0.0965108946,
-0.0833139867,
0.0045416448,
-0.0114984,
-0.0092722792,
-0.017604135,
-0.0213702768,
0.0234412123,
-0.0309782624,
0.0195914414,
-0.0097185159,
0.0161642712,
-0.0378455184,
0.0133969774,
0.0384578407,
-0.0298703834,
-0.0167236198,
0.0482599437,
-0.0373844579,
-0.0335040614,
-0.038986858,
0.0658608973,
0.0143237934,
0.0563311093,
0.0186722856,
0.0028089322,
0.0435244441,
0.0118831545,
-0.0030095819,
0.013820162,
0.0524552502,
0.0474997349,
-0.0151194707,
0.0428068191,
-0.0585524887,
0.0274476819,
-0.037083406,
0.0356569774,
-0.0069277342,
-0.0189911034,
0.0168864112,
0.0257463921,
0.0149514582,
-0.0479378887,
-0.021654563,
-0.0269413125,
-0.0336451046,
-0.0210978109,
-0.0293672699,
-0.0278729573,
0.0524132811,
-0.0068302113,
0.0129592754,
-0.0163333509,
0.0604214482,
0.0035012141,
-0.0023103978,
-0.0044123977,
0.0253798217,
0.0045086653,
-0.019736547,
-0.075666897,
0.0026218703,
-0.0626356751,
-0.0444745012,
-0.0448381156,
-0.0203855466,
-0.0188545603,
-0.0212721433,
0.0291014798,
0.0024334593,
0.0050562117,
0.0594950877,
-0.0517383292,
0.0619727783,
-0.0428407788,
-0.0040192776,
0.0580622107,
-0.0167086739,
0.1027647853,
0.0216500387,
-0.0264049862,
-0.0320650376,
0.0507043935,
0.0195792839,
-0.0079233143,
-0.0699342787,
0.0102681005,
0.00179149,
0.0008337601,
0.0898371935,
-0.0765157863,
-0.0007083399,
0.016376067,
-0.0209238697,
-0.0411738046,
-0.0331251882,
-0.0544828959,
0.0316115804,
0.0115489783,
-0.0457017682,
-0.0699740052,
-0.0340168588,
0.0166355632,
0.034120325,
0.0113467518,
-0.0028220068,
0.0312526748,
0.0215707216,
0.0077841491,
0.0229062531,
-0.0437849835,
-0.0526376069,
-0.004966558,
0.0033248884,
-0.0243520159,
-5.109603212e-33,
-0.023282418,
0.0342868567,
-0.0286322981,
0.0015840509,
-0.0336664543,
0.0072805374,
-0.0520445518,
0.0047502741,
-0.0162480883,
0.0277682599,
0.0089406092,
-0.0039537903,
0.0096763177,
0.0396465547,
0.012492951,
0.026518587,
0.030149743,
0.0089787627,
-0.0733738169,
0.03936195,
0.0244105738,
0.0072790631,
0.0656514987,
-0.0396426283,
0.0362096615,
0.0078569399,
-0.0493150279,
-0.0208176915,
0.0560657643,
0.0520104803,
0.0000033996,
0.0452462807,
0.0317370631,
-0.040997047,
-0.0460645854,
-0.0253974088,
-0.0654508024,
-0.0485302322,
0.0303076673,
-0.0265188497,
-0.0720911324,
-0.0372676551,
0.0435972176,
-0.0337874219,
0.0027835863,
-0.0358970463,
0.0758736208,
-0.0597847216,
-0.017125858,
-0.0749284625,
-0.0247037727,
0.0175666884,
-0.0491023548,
-0.0354710072,
0.0180648863,
0.0654631034,
-0.0158453211,
0.0116294911,
-0.0264734998,
0.059192434,
-0.0158439949,
0.0195438787,
0.0397587642,
0.007537948,
0.0034089396,
0.0720478594,
-0.0015864155,
-0.0103222635,
-0.0028012285,
0.0096412618,
0.0077584586,
0.0060317083,
0.0378059261,
0.0788949057,
-0.0049280133,
0.0255274307,
-0.0511043854,
0.0989577919,
-0.0123862531,
0.0011518592,
0.0071154069,
-0.0293124095,
0.0211150758,
0.0097535634,
-0.0386126302,
-0.0041178679,
-0.00837705,
-0.0065786568,
-0.0253203791,
-0.0035856955,
-0.0235391445,
-0.0438336842,
0.0080449376,
-0.0323265642,
0.0178740397,
0.0358708985,
-0.0348609015,
0.0136888456,
0.0479667187,
-0.011130387,
-0.0006508527,
0.0442356169,
-0.0012491238,
0.0470245294,
0.0275565255,
-0.0260367617,
0.1075606272,
0.0176964048,
-0.0364705548,
0.0396260954,
-0.0088277142,
0.0017850471,
-0.0513226278,
0.0255671814,
-0.0355125554,
0.0139203649,
-0.0194858983,
0.0269406363,
-0.0113396766,
0.0007921523,
-0.0113870865,
0.0037717861,
0.036652714,
0.0353644527,
-0.0207160413,
0.012503555,
-0.02982031,
-0.0143257789,
0.0400098041,
-0.0322970152,
-0.0142263956,
-0.014238338,
2.225e-7,
0.0475555062,
0.0074751093,
0.0408195667,
0.0066998079,
-0.0189599972,
0.0404181406,
-0.0312214959,
0.045836065,
-0.0080983285,
0.0112602841,
0.03218982,
0.0287030768,
0.0441307798,
0.0303884577,
-0.1047151834,
-0.0126707219,
-0.0594094917,
-0.0534432046,
-0.008353061,
-0.0383190364,
0.0622667447,
0.0823654085,
-0.016183408,
-0.0000692863,
-0.0116134603,
-0.0232577939,
0.0480126515,
-0.0220361594,
-0.0305006355,
-0.000257633,
0.0345836207,
0.010943858,
-0.0140185766,
-0.0483013354,
-0.0220851973,
-0.0266047586,
0.084618181,
0.0263029821,
0.0383321457,
-0.0425197966,
0.0100273313,
-0.0074763745,
0.0172402728,
0.0016565468,
0.0355787501,
-0.0265574213,
-0.0099334642,
-0.0409647152,
-0.0239751823,
0.0367099904,
0.0356473438,
-0.025092138,
-0.0553846434,
0.066914022,
-0.0002830422,
0.0023829543,
0.0105760563,
-0.0529114939,
-0.0739141032,
0.0197246373,
0.0243566446,
-0.0243286416,
0.0054261424,
-0.0228179768,
0.0147523228,
-0.0948286951,
0.0163217131,
1.658821238e-34,
0.1112735495,
-0.0446821041,
-0.0175443534,
-0.0407878458,
0.0291695222,
-0.0603205711,
-0.0265341997,
-0.0392336063,
0.0040690536,
-0.0075890189,
0.002571031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13192v2 | SimCSE++: Improving Contrastive Learning for Sentence Embeddings from Two Perspectives | 2023-05-22T16:24:46 | 2023-10-20T13:07:23 | Jiahao Xu, Wei Shao, Lihui Chen, Lemao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper improves contrastive learning for sentence embeddings from two
perspectives: handling dropout noise and addressing feature corruption.
Specifically, for the first perspective, we identify that the dropout noise
from negative pairs affects the model's performance. Therefore, we propose a
simple yet effective method to deal with such type of noise. Secondly, we
pinpoint the rank bottleneck of current solutions to feature corruption and
propose a dimension-wise contrastive learning objective to address this issue.
Both proposed methods are generic and can be applied to any contrastive
learning based models for sentence embeddings. Experimental results on standard
benchmarks demonstrate that combining both proposed methods leads to a gain of
1.8 points compared to the strong baseline SimCSE configured with BERT base.
Furthermore, applying the proposed method to DiffCSE, another strong
contrastive learning based baseline, results in a gain of 1.4 points. | [
0.0113106137,
0.0445054695,
-0.0004971962,
0.0584077798,
-0.049564492,
0.0153786475,
-0.0187446158,
-0.0431838632,
0.0106702875,
-0.0432803258,
0.0086841332,
-0.0313453116,
0.0018471627,
0.0340741873,
0.0414943099,
-0.0550156906,
0.033114925,
0.0294798743,
0.0104953004,
-0.0065505388,
0.0269762948,
0.000677661,
0.0038298387,
-0.0017853031,
-0.0068555907,
-0.017816361,
-0.0138803413,
0.0305337235,
0.0546300672,
-0.0248639025,
0.0437353812,
0.0227824897,
0.0289490521,
-0.0034019144,
0.0000017286,
-0.0292302407,
-0.0026398653,
-0.005632685,
0.0006508816,
0.0397665016,
0.0351070538,
-0.0389022827,
0.0048550889,
0.0369837917,
-0.0061055277,
-0.0103998976,
0.030100245,
0.0887334049,
0.06303069,
0.0829267949,
-0.0127071021,
-0.0515198894,
0.0310009606,
-0.0297554489,
-0.0331438147,
0.0090230787,
0.0297747329,
-0.0180167779,
-0.0195733495,
0.0347125717,
-0.0085640056,
0.0202579834,
0.0333414078,
0.0226864647,
0.0113748936,
0.0253262967,
-0.0398988836,
0.0166773181,
-0.0180328004,
0.0896814317,
0.0014984931,
0.0286300667,
-0.013297352,
-0.012595037,
-0.0061249537,
-0.0255510863,
-0.0003902319,
-0.0101693403,
0.0522133894,
0.0389709845,
0.0675278157,
0.0111905243,
0.0269718021,
-0.003108249,
-0.0050354716,
-0.0638029948,
0.0498273522,
-0.0674546286,
-0.0003167181,
0.0300926343,
-0.0561323315,
0.0107169421,
0.033610858,
-0.0297451839,
-0.0131675731,
-0.0060181865,
-0.0222063232,
-0.0602263585,
-0.0028470119,
-0.0568025112,
0.0139211239,
0.0279411785,
-0.04144172,
0.0200264547,
-0.0141089866,
0.0490697995,
-0.0054423753,
0.0160045344,
-0.0210515521,
-0.0133812409,
-0.0200385787,
0.0071178237,
-0.025869729,
0.0483119711,
-0.0395288728,
-0.0619253591,
-0.0125568453,
0.0176210962,
-0.01587989,
0.019797869,
0.0439229719,
0.0231934413,
-0.0138611831,
0.0100322971,
0.0003042603,
0.03017148,
-0.0402581654,
-0.0124827586,
-0.0205769893,
-0.0236334633,
-0.0331214815,
0.0098416572,
0.0164147522,
-0.0254293997,
-0.0034044287,
0.0342233405,
0.0011735481,
-0.0744113028,
-0.0259709172,
0.0170606673,
-0.0464790687,
-0.0576248541,
-0.0311671123,
-0.0492454208,
-0.0021792133,
-0.0015816529,
0.0010267241,
-0.0418927222,
0.0174715947,
0.000510196,
-0.0496787019,
0.0927486569,
-0.0009599928,
-0.0427295603,
-0.0440239049,
0.0137320198,
-0.0014326567,
0.0603771657,
0.0178796221,
-0.0274871327,
0.0290551018,
0.0480820872,
-0.0034398574,
-0.0184035748,
0.0075534182,
0.0097388653,
-0.0225963313,
0.0114902966,
0.0117619308,
0.0461732596,
0.0345472805,
0.0759879798,
-0.0307712741,
-0.0424671546,
0.0501859784,
-0.0065070633,
0.039010223,
0.0286093038,
0.0273713637,
0.0385000035,
-0.0478507541,
0.0254877713,
-0.0259724353,
0.0012954186,
0.0175634958,
0.0350631289,
0.0609511249,
0.0261394624,
-0.0374368131,
-0.0124593582,
-0.0305040516,
-0.0491650738,
-0.003060485,
-0.0196074788,
0.0371451564,
-0.0027407617,
-0.056874752,
0.034159191,
0.0253521595,
-0.063063249,
-0.0461226441,
0.0182676557,
0.0128385453,
0.0986203253,
0.0408407412,
-0.0066937627,
-0.0287157707,
-0.0372540541,
-0.0243515838,
0.07275296,
0.0272267982,
-0.0084191822,
0.0554019548,
-0.0473740511,
-0.0508817174,
-0.0264827646,
0.0223405603,
-0.0125495233,
-0.0107525103,
0.011148734,
0.0334225148,
-0.02691531,
0.0056037973,
0.0247889049,
-0.0270345155,
0.002131138,
0.0089540388,
0.0351537615,
0.0042984262,
0.0487191789,
-0.0184698105,
0.0045804214,
0.0409914106,
-0.0567592382,
-0.0079818694,
-0.0001278351,
-0.0806468129,
-0.1234319583,
0.0408138707,
-0.0616314709,
-0.0053857123,
0.1110907942,
-0.0444523804,
-0.013547671,
0.0095807128,
-0.0509773679,
0.027304573,
-0.0403889194,
0.0052859616,
0.0420671068,
0.0401731655,
0.0100206966,
0.0761604086,
-0.052350942,
0.0158701073,
0.0045364741,
0.0488362163,
0.0043251072,
-0.0532738827,
-0.0592808276,
-0.0135188075,
0.0262515284,
0.0102764051,
0.0041302093,
0.0032829354,
-0.0347818993,
-0.0039749285,
-0.0683116838,
0.0083026048,
-0.0364491083,
0.009017963,
0.0403546318,
0.0053151585,
0.0061962632,
-0.0090602385,
-0.0352899432,
-0.038879443,
-0.0388680696,
0.0358757153,
0.0497904904,
-0.0046452074,
-0.0134904673,
-0.0089718942,
0.0009226603,
-0.0159897972,
0.0660417601,
-0.080793865,
0.0065527526,
-0.0578473657,
0.0790728033,
-0.014031657,
0.0052460292,
0.0156537741,
-0.0489069857,
-0.0192567017,
0.0042089531,
0.0563910827,
0.0346692242,
0.0090688476,
0.0388145521,
0.0130082779,
-0.0021241254,
-0.006009121,
0.0014373019,
-0.0253564306,
0.0953900814,
0.0012839723,
-0.0178904161,
-0.0375288017,
0.082506679,
-0.0082858447,
0.0024993774,
-0.0473102964,
-0.0019079876,
0.006563596,
0.0097692581,
0.0212338455,
0.0126707768,
-0.0381905697,
-0.0479566753,
-0.042641744,
0.0021782131,
0.0725772753,
-0.0225932244,
-0.0052985861,
-0.0715174899,
-0.0062958184,
-0.0100093819,
0.0083581135,
-0.0160099156,
0.0166391395,
0.0020238934,
-0.0165192261,
-0.0264316332,
-0.0360300727,
0.0271819979,
-0.0126305521,
0.0027868517,
-0.0051791528,
-0.0028992738,
-0.0190044586,
-0.0676546842,
-0.0294973869,
-0.0849149227,
-0.0245072655,
0.0389692411,
0.0256646965,
-0.0275947601,
0.0173479896,
-0.031331066,
-0.0346001759,
0.035272941,
-0.0069692163,
0.0134000722,
-0.019818604,
0.1037046984,
0.0636441857,
0.0246137604,
0.0106983352,
-0.0156602114,
0.0235206131,
0.0204215534,
0.0203774553,
-0.0186031424,
-0.0393786803,
0.0010735047,
0.0115160765,
-0.0153666241,
-0.0159597602,
0.0011750821,
0.0156833623,
-0.0139942104,
-0.0391981788,
0.1214576885,
0.0082132258,
-0.0110943904,
-0.0050538755,
0.0101711769,
0.0375992544,
0.0221301652,
-0.0362377465,
-0.0650804266,
-0.0419552773,
-0.0081396112,
0.0052420162,
0.016987009,
-0.0046135345,
-0.0159073677,
-0.1071355641,
0.0041309791,
0.0167717878,
-0.0026912435,
-0.0534863248,
-0.0107038505,
-0.0006629089,
-0.0253108051,
0.0565306172,
-0.0116358232,
0.0016047993,
-0.0018453801,
0.0217291359,
-0.0126103526,
-0.072714366,
-0.010263348,
-0.0598395988,
0.0532471091,
0.0635482445,
0.0280812941,
0.010500568,
-0.0518517531,
0.0101010809,
-0.0698589981,
-0.0401222259,
-0.0106567517,
0.0730732232,
-0.062279202,
-0.0215090383,
-0.0180766191,
0.0133465687,
-0.0446915925,
-0.0090285521,
-0.0449575931,
0.0778759718,
0.0075069042,
0.0055197775,
-0.0185042359,
0.0186473429,
0.0119264359,
0.0934438556,
0.0287438445,
-0.0385589562,
-0.0234208927,
0.0010993908,
0.0139226103,
-0.0480363294,
0.0134734157,
0.0011745838,
0.0351982675,
0.0198877081,
-0.077775836,
-0.0970133841,
-0.0117829926,
0.0163085293,
-0.0344115049,
0.0335083827,
-0.0831565857,
-0.0037874891,
-0.037207175,
0.0001724882,
-0.0071970336,
0.0313837752,
-0.0140179135,
-0.0062537598,
0.0282863192,
-0.0054309978,
-0.0400660038,
-0.0474879928,
-0.0836590081,
-0.071126543,
-0.0202204976,
0.0396210775,
-0.0001883444,
0.054305166,
-0.0184750818,
0.0004449774,
0.056456469,
0.0501337051,
-0.0331312679,
0.0043081804,
0.0774081051,
-0.0219975226,
0.016139796,
0.0597196706,
-0.0097779715,
-0.0280787367,
0.0162910707,
0.073417291,
-0.0185154919,
-0.0236370005,
0.0074261082,
-0.0208756514,
0.0949541852,
-0.0076308632,
-0.0145368995,
-0.0277113467,
0.0259693321,
-0.0443367139,
-0.0103140706,
-0.0526731275,
0.0495363139,
0.011073675,
0.0242782086,
-0.0443596169,
0.0323165953,
-0.0306934696,
0.0135595957,
-0.0275852866,
-0.0035794382,
0.0348950028,
-0.0135606993,
-0.0022711135,
0.0148603255,
-0.0244221184,
-0.0181770809,
-0.0017752212,
-0.0044466523,
-0.0111096939,
0.0144412406,
0.0081423149,
-0.0103159528,
-0.0017837825,
0.0440881141,
-0.0358430482,
0.0364313498,
-0.0489134677,
-0.0144761298,
0.0415875427,
-0.0203017015,
0.0596111529,
-0.0020716998,
-0.0193650424,
-0.0164105073,
0.0318647511,
-0.0177475773,
0.0055616773,
0.024040971,
0.0181941371,
-0.0234500282,
0.0220590737,
0.0632729158,
-0.0132855251,
0.0382730775,
0.0008057415,
-0.0138611998,
-0.0428727269,
-0.0088239554,
0.0318633765,
0.0351931453,
-0.0104968576,
0.0169976894,
-0.0329641588,
-0.0817629769,
0.0650001168,
0.0092474511,
0.0017346482,
0.0140609648,
0.0381014906,
0.0113294255,
0.0003190757,
0.0142786987,
-0.0108158989,
0.0028928409,
0.0150095774,
-0.032197535,
-0.0298988502,
-5.965991622e-33,
0.0152990185,
0.024334766,
-0.0415744595,
-0.0421553329,
-0.026697984,
0.0332331359,
-0.0292015504,
-0.0093942285,
-0.0106401555,
0.0379727818,
0.0150480745,
0.0252214205,
0.0027538997,
0.0332138352,
-0.0465464666,
-0.0331869237,
0.063447699,
0.0067392946,
-0.0131070688,
-0.008483964,
0.0233339798,
0.0675298572,
0.0741847306,
-0.0672836676,
-0.0048156246,
-0.0118198851,
0.0176103786,
0.0302749705,
0.0534021184,
0.0490761213,
-0.0315373875,
0.0487627052,
0.0234743115,
-0.0105929701,
-0.0196608584,
-0.0009316058,
-0.0712323412,
-0.0200490858,
-0.012849954,
-0.00871424,
-0.0538158156,
-0.0405568667,
0.0220852345,
-0.0050440193,
0.0032183083,
-0.0176974032,
0.0236128159,
-0.0254198834,
-0.0074287471,
0.0018144604,
-0.0637913942,
0.0324765258,
0.0122307744,
-0.0168345608,
-0.002684921,
0.0235326383,
0.0321450382,
0.0325499773,
-0.0263319463,
-0.0061303517,
0.0242610946,
0.0313791782,
0.0003472582,
-0.0052842153,
-0.0264481027,
0.0649577901,
-0.0065927068,
-0.0332149677,
0.0493561104,
-0.04827106,
-0.0145122865,
0.0351329632,
0.0576477908,
0.1065139771,
0.0253668372,
0.0257358402,
-0.0650845692,
0.0125248181,
0.0083557395,
-0.0022437063,
0.0345317908,
0.0257355981,
-0.0525469482,
-0.0164253265,
0.0118891094,
-0.0401149504,
-0.0192120764,
-0.0319477357,
0.0403559804,
0.02911162,
-0.0214785524,
0.0338124782,
0.0021298374,
-0.0504209734,
0.0036909303,
0.0471171476,
-0.0411080793,
-0.0163465068,
0.0263776854,
-0.0005475835,
-0.0668828934,
-0.0048843389,
-0.0069480794,
0.0247566756,
-0.0330566317,
-0.0321785063,
0.056860961,
0.0075166039,
-0.0679882318,
-0.0144635588,
-0.0131986877,
-0.0263228863,
-0.0499837585,
0.0487423688,
0.0314177014,
0.0002869109,
-0.0292776618,
0.0717158541,
0.028434623,
0.0304225776,
-0.0254663303,
-0.0037922133,
0.0180682503,
0.0258728787,
0.0035845481,
-0.0044621094,
-0.0187380128,
0.0260889865,
0.0124474708,
-0.0726765394,
-0.0157762617,
-0.0163336508,
2.399e-7,
0.019192623,
-0.0039095609,
0.031924542,
-0.014360128,
0.0058628893,
0.0576746427,
-0.01538911,
0.043226216,
-0.0312472731,
0.0233383626,
0.0383176096,
0.0208046008,
0.0360593908,
-0.016744988,
-0.0931351259,
0.030669298,
-0.0709601864,
-0.0266358554,
-0.0292922985,
-0.0053101834,
0.087251015,
0.1128714532,
0.0343429185,
0.0077022617,
-0.0027753955,
-0.0063487119,
0.0571318045,
-0.0203576256,
-0.0350469016,
-0.0541312248,
-0.0298978966,
0.0101912916,
0.0011704598,
-0.0029858735,
-0.018292401,
0.0577074811,
0.0093677314,
0.02725311,
0.017859377,
-0.0426352061,
-0.0124732163,
0.0036645602,
-0.0061012711,
0.009967586,
0.0776631534,
-0.0275958125,
-0.0046842815,
-0.0463404693,
-0.0757611766,
-0.0071678353,
0.0488793775,
-0.0087089855,
-0.050238736,
-0.0141640287,
0.020391386,
-0.0098943673,
-0.021027552,
-0.0841495469,
-0.0021691041,
0.0241154544,
-0.0192233585,
-0.0401296839,
-0.0120760575,
0.0220373049,
0.0665749237,
-0.0397517532,
0.0127447136,
2.296414769e-34,
0.054289978,
0.0021667173,
0.01223798,
0.03491145,
-0.0005094912,
-0.0293788109,
-0.0182673633,
-0.0643225461,
0.0451072156,
-0.0347126089,
-0.0036702789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13191v1 | Taxonomy Expansion for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T16:23:46 | 2023-05-22T16:23:46 | Karthikeyan K, Yogarshi Vyas, Jie Ma, Giovanni Paolini, Neha Anna John, Shuai Wang, Yassine Benajiba, Vittorio Castelli, Dan Roth, Miguel Ballesteros | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Training a Named Entity Recognition (NER) model often involves fixing a
taxonomy of entity types. However, requirements evolve and we might need the
NER model to recognize additional entity types. A simple approach is to
re-annotate entire dataset with both existing and additional entity types and
then train the model on the re-annotated dataset. However, this is an extremely
laborious task. To remedy this, we propose a novel approach called Partial
Label Model (PLM) that uses only partially annotated datasets. We experiment
with 6 diverse datasets and show that PLM consistently performs better than
most other approaches (0.5 - 2.5 F1), including in novel settings for taxonomy
expansion not considered in prior work. The gap between PLM and all other
approaches is especially large in settings where there is limited data
available for the additional entity types (as much as 11 F1), thus suggesting a
more cost effective approaches to taxonomy expansion. | [
0.050448779,
0.013706387,
0.0111530665,
0.0010565922,
0.0403989516,
0.0674807876,
-0.0162867997,
0.0386983827,
0.0235306583,
-0.0649069995,
-0.0219696686,
0.0156404208,
-0.0367927477,
0.0182240233,
0.0429118276,
-0.0610720553,
0.0277609583,
-0.0027790985,
0.0104258172,
0.0466403775,
-0.0129633294,
0.0160223618,
0.0026467443,
-0.0006333244,
-0.0211772397,
0.0224394649,
-0.0447352976,
0.0344127752,
0.0511846095,
-0.0339254588,
0.0124336155,
0.0179801472,
0.0368944854,
0.0490643047,
0.0000018156,
-0.0463911742,
-0.0659323335,
0.0149274133,
-0.0369209237,
-0.0254892632,
0.0276521221,
-0.0155700408,
0.0366530828,
-0.0099588763,
0.0106497807,
-0.0907194316,
0.040724095,
0.0701805353,
0.0175547171,
0.0769747794,
-0.0094824322,
-0.0342194736,
0.0101201395,
-0.0171020646,
-0.0140137188,
-0.048873093,
0.0495004617,
-0.0021063287,
-0.0044948906,
0.0404370166,
0.0172826219,
-0.0129713975,
-0.0247056149,
0.0266564991,
0.0423934273,
0.0443791896,
-0.0114692226,
-0.0150631424,
0.0135876182,
0.0647163391,
0.0071741776,
0.0072349296,
0.0557797886,
-0.0240796525,
0.0051542828,
-0.0316378996,
-0.0127049619,
-0.0184908025,
-0.0458304435,
-0.0200241376,
-0.0003281171,
-0.0053195297,
0.0127880741,
0.012772141,
-0.0007216604,
-0.0090379985,
-0.0044820183,
-0.0542429797,
0.0125962012,
0.0072624744,
-0.009137054,
-0.0439909324,
0.0199036617,
0.0136422245,
0.0421015061,
0.0525490381,
-0.0421585627,
-0.0065256068,
0.0316994227,
-0.0403247029,
-0.0277971979,
-0.0060349805,
-0.0139289992,
0.0658006296,
-0.0400199331,
-0.0274425615,
0.0025878241,
0.0456389375,
0.0120560424,
-0.0176907964,
-0.0817859098,
0.0123752607,
-0.0509316027,
0.0457597636,
0.0231812615,
0.0168994498,
-0.0549326427,
-0.0051514236,
0.0035537833,
0.0176278539,
0.0329771787,
-0.0109837791,
-0.0086764805,
-0.0030126784,
-0.0022475452,
-0.0002273734,
-0.0260276664,
0.0476360656,
-0.0062418249,
-0.0322232246,
0.002296882,
-0.0415004119,
0.0480131507,
-0.0271054134,
0.0168398935,
0.0273631737,
0.0405986793,
-0.1302340627,
-0.0959826186,
0.0036878579,
-0.0095978817,
-0.0284724031,
0.0015211826,
-0.010631863,
0.0274058618,
-0.0170136038,
0.0074272538,
-0.0136333499,
0.0094757546,
-0.0229521021,
-0.0473806784,
0.0999146625,
-0.0980393142,
-0.0085002733,
0.0542802587,
-0.0070520081,
0.0120906327,
0.051338397,
0.037555106,
-0.0070558577,
0.0289205201,
-0.0032897396,
0.0125030046,
0.0254815463,
0.0121012321,
-0.021924099,
0.0411596783,
-0.0100491419,
-0.0140306121,
-0.0144719863,
0.0070745428,
0.007375754,
-0.0067751002,
-0.0014448622,
0.0061067147,
-0.0025490962,
-0.0037849781,
0.0000740299,
0.022464212,
0.0076260734,
-0.003066486,
-0.0190638546,
-0.0116642462,
-0.0055594491,
-0.0377344191,
0.0203068163,
0.0197773613,
0.0304315984,
-0.0307627115,
-0.0176817123,
-0.0256650411,
-0.0059509054,
0.007756691,
0.0048317667,
0.0861395374,
0.0307911634,
-0.0261444859,
0.0655857623,
0.0391123444,
-0.0185428187,
0.0166727267,
-0.032804545,
0.0336605795,
0.0381290875,
0.0240174085,
-0.0759760365,
-0.0588445812,
-0.0421441495,
-0.0301272944,
0.0328176469,
0.0446490236,
-0.0252959523,
0.0168716162,
-0.0458904169,
-0.0050656856,
0.0410335436,
0.0361833274,
0.047085464,
0.0304762777,
0.0335411653,
0.028797213,
-0.0788545087,
-0.0235771742,
0.0456196889,
-0.016244987,
-0.03457205,
-0.0052767005,
0.0423560925,
0.0008297807,
0.0608534254,
-0.0236637071,
-0.0507373586,
0.0295559373,
0.004958062,
-0.0346529521,
-0.0374950208,
0.0385814868,
-0.0038554957,
0.0254775174,
0.0320437253,
-0.0235975198,
-0.0184851345,
-0.0587188676,
-0.0456379801,
-0.0224472173,
0.0207288228,
0.0109187374,
-0.0291539207,
0.0163049083,
0.0172159187,
-0.0011645583,
-0.0431541167,
0.0688025281,
-0.0034392409,
0.0222376864,
-0.0089333085,
-0.0417470373,
-0.0208004247,
-0.0168820154,
-0.0196277201,
-0.0063854698,
-0.0311327614,
-0.0296461824,
0.0089361081,
-0.0095484555,
-0.073361814,
0.0155127868,
-0.0840663314,
-0.0081782602,
-0.002272242,
0.0333329514,
-0.0005104592,
0.0312866047,
-0.0347057246,
-0.0148725845,
0.025985416,
0.0018284107,
-0.0319660082,
0.001858467,
-0.0010735412,
0.0100258915,
-0.0128524164,
-0.003803761,
0.005066494,
-0.0331674442,
0.0280961171,
0.0295530036,
-0.0809061155,
-0.0546059161,
0.0100873448,
-0.0343358889,
0.0092868339,
0.0117949005,
0.0388475135,
-0.0445825309,
0.0145642674,
-0.045637209,
-0.0201871544,
-0.026230447,
0.0013814238,
-0.0089089405,
0.0047958554,
-0.0482050031,
0.0436393619,
0.0018235222,
0.0096205501,
-0.019863788,
-0.0742506012,
0.0073962691,
0.0638746247,
-0.06358964,
0.0048654792,
-0.0420301482,
-0.0271204244,
-0.0072578355,
-0.0305640362,
-0.0217941664,
0.0192343276,
-0.0111055933,
0.0193905365,
-0.0193931982,
-0.0209940802,
0.0412799455,
-0.0444285944,
0.001278356,
-0.0186278298,
-0.00914336,
-0.0475028455,
0.0625346527,
0.0242234375,
-0.0058440496,
0.0775386095,
-0.0622801036,
0.0161672477,
0.0362188704,
-0.0042934492,
-0.0263467561,
0.0630454719,
0.0115658762,
0.0613336824,
-0.026702581,
-0.0054590674,
-0.026770981,
0.0041469303,
-0.0318103917,
0.0089846561,
-0.0323156863,
0.0036434003,
-0.0125850616,
0.0339302979,
-0.0157157835,
0.0883564726,
0.0326744542,
-0.0072315489,
-0.0368198566,
0.03793687,
0.0282503758,
0.0074158525,
-0.0229359139,
0.0005133507,
-0.0239043757,
-0.0037453992,
-0.0263205394,
-0.0147718079,
-0.0032761428,
-0.0018735599,
0.004774475,
-0.0745124593,
0.0052226945,
-0.0144666731,
0.0147020966,
-0.0262486041,
-0.0059657064,
0.0871691406,
0.028467495,
-0.0263237972,
-0.0363014415,
-0.0008280069,
0.0173972752,
0.051566653,
0.0244415496,
-0.0843454376,
-0.0311780497,
0.0422721468,
-0.0040665567,
-0.0048454418,
-0.0540063716,
-0.0023903763,
-0.0903246701,
0.0219944417,
-0.0280953664,
-0.0789534748,
0.0348655432,
-0.0856099054,
0.0177715253,
-0.0289170835,
-0.0621711202,
-0.0370850638,
-0.0107687423,
-0.0092919869,
0.0499739163,
0.0055801952,
-0.0597749501,
-0.0029201563,
-0.0336171538,
0.0442186743,
0.0184544735,
0.0172286704,
-0.0272888653,
0.0002716976,
0.0400874801,
0.0073524807,
-0.0144414268,
-0.0084885797,
0.0889154822,
-0.0453631207,
0.0107681043,
0.0526139848,
-0.0285378583,
-0.0202189051,
-0.0143463844,
0.0515602566,
0.0422908626,
0.0177094433,
0.0363792479,
-0.0363208093,
-0.063569881,
0.0117966598,
0.0582696013,
0.0218674913,
0.0055400166,
0.0028309517,
0.0152782556,
-0.0262966696,
-0.0085301464,
0.0329497084,
0.00190213,
-0.0828264132,
-0.085120976,
-0.0278026387,
-0.0305163767,
0.0606261604,
0.0331714638,
0.01775961,
0.0018210789,
0.0142881833,
0.0256849267,
-0.0722528249,
0.0306023471,
-0.0300423503,
0.011496135,
-0.0340765603,
-0.0437624343,
0.0127086882,
-0.0104641989,
-0.0577907227,
0.0011288486,
-0.0673487559,
-0.0435330085,
-0.0080417283,
0.0242116321,
0.0149850529,
0.0472294204,
0.0282507595,
-0.0344481543,
0.007430776,
0.0662043169,
-0.0084210522,
-0.0179337747,
-0.0001586035,
0.0081479736,
-0.0115657644,
0.0118968999,
-0.0569537058,
0.026944682,
0.0231203306,
0.0312859267,
-0.0406300575,
0.0167799145,
-0.0161758903,
0.0071408176,
0.0631466359,
-0.0196835082,
-0.0285162199,
-0.0799410045,
0.0266409609,
0.022195233,
-0.0001825122,
-0.0175978541,
-0.0157805812,
0.0175737925,
0.0167402886,
-0.0149723124,
0.0432172976,
-0.0195113011,
0.0492705628,
-0.0583751984,
-0.0187616255,
0.015839288,
0.0413753353,
-0.0134752337,
-0.0625000745,
-0.0196309257,
0.0436393507,
0.0476832613,
0.0178162139,
-0.0110987714,
0.0079117408,
-0.0031178235,
0.0141876461,
-0.0463779047,
-0.0056087878,
-0.0313264504,
0.0045468742,
-0.0443556905,
0.099177815,
0.0065499535,
0.0139107844,
0.0458268672,
-0.0051054256,
-0.0411927775,
0.0138560263,
-0.0055286475,
0.0137115018,
-0.0504350588,
0.0278247166,
0.0077199629,
-0.0268264711,
0.0041558761,
0.0506467372,
0.0314318202,
0.0517734252,
-0.0429362543,
-0.0295343623,
-0.0276151374,
-0.0026411484,
0.0060240738,
0.0049411794,
-0.0072339717,
0.0415455624,
-0.0250415411,
-0.0505481996,
0.0368322767,
-0.0547375828,
-0.0009390068,
0.0297055859,
0.0366731919,
-0.0020116703,
0.0080638537,
-0.0448718667,
-0.0492896512,
-0.0120552778,
0.0327127017,
-0.0335707478,
0.0119431186,
-5.993800144e-33,
-0.0484151356,
-0.0135394698,
0.0138266571,
-0.0398507565,
-0.0084743202,
0.0390620269,
0.011959496,
0.0071279844,
0.0312629715,
-0.0375442579,
-0.0065240175,
0.0031354716,
0.0422569923,
-0.00099119,
0.0104575241,
-0.0306714196,
0.0788355172,
0.0201041065,
-0.0031025102,
0.009561819,
0.01885451,
0.0740924999,
0.0870800391,
-0.0931493789,
0.0576846525,
0.0321977027,
-0.0367264822,
-0.0296620671,
0.0505070537,
0.0654171184,
-0.0129041132,
-0.0053400351,
0.0470082834,
-0.0436835811,
0.0133767091,
0.0112341158,
-0.1473817527,
0.0487546958,
-0.0528001785,
0.0669267103,
-0.0266968794,
-0.0152561124,
0.0135946749,
0.0221785735,
0.0334670283,
-0.0030601346,
0.049302049,
-0.0455481485,
0.004653444,
-0.0259308051,
-0.025349861,
0.0590534583,
0.027407134,
0.0444820784,
0.0463486835,
0.0070334538,
0.0124775358,
0.0353090651,
-0.0706124008,
-0.006914671,
0.0814100802,
-0.0284942482,
0.0078430129,
0.0515431985,
-0.0272953883,
0.0295209028,
0.0255414136,
0.0007515408,
-0.0401557982,
-0.0359950326,
-0.0026917448,
0.0288044363,
-0.0318174139,
0.0415464938,
0.0740096346,
-0.0324390419,
-0.0378939509,
0.0254180953,
-0.0058488622,
-0.0193176456,
-0.0167914946,
0.0031586071,
-0.0439627804,
0.023932578,
-0.0203297809,
-0.030056905,
-0.0592256747,
0.0087273596,
0.0385375246,
0.0548956245,
-0.0422751494,
0.0396255143,
0.0172761157,
-0.0145159168,
-0.072470732,
-0.0123990998,
0.0525646806,
0.038363006,
-0.007854443,
-0.0297896564,
-0.0444027334,
-0.0837460458,
0.0420297123,
-0.0069567561,
0.0168155897,
-0.0307547078,
0.0999739096,
-0.0150611652,
-0.0604986772,
0.0131640742,
0.0201467257,
0.0069611063,
-0.0025835615,
0.0309329219,
0.0208892319,
-0.0069734361,
0.0036219812,
0.0342487432,
0.0911336988,
-0.013483867,
0.0174702536,
0.0062633851,
0.0134769091,
0.0241690613,
-0.0043078754,
0.0040642214,
0.035180103,
-0.0466667674,
-0.0136836134,
-0.0582996085,
0.0131953461,
-0.0003741768,
2.556e-7,
0.0153058851,
0.0105086789,
-0.0016042588,
-0.0426162966,
-0.008008224,
0.0117479134,
0.0393961221,
0.0685901344,
-0.0195020381,
-0.0191543531,
0.0059722555,
-0.030441964,
0.0047497302,
0.0117455879,
-0.089732945,
-0.0400213003,
-0.0051660845,
0.0199884083,
-0.0733201131,
0.0473277122,
0.0285354536,
0.0658204406,
0.0276938081,
-0.0177336093,
-0.0125906523,
-0.0001208316,
0.0312174559,
-0.0008894159,
0.0325375982,
0.0343521275,
0.0310633555,
0.1256687194,
-0.0286639053,
0.0510495827,
-0.0121928556,
0.0371622108,
0.0244964957,
0.0292672832,
-0.0140988184,
0.0398174115,
-0.0082000298,
0.0012432099,
0.0208880808,
-0.0277175773,
0.0648514628,
-0.0219682194,
0.0093380278,
0.0058350181,
-0.0423489884,
0.0015850384,
-0.0024543791,
0.0003170149,
0.0046236762,
0.052512493,
0.0223666262,
-0.0202070829,
-0.0522772931,
-0.0918451622,
0.0519262962,
0.030290287,
-0.0168450493,
0.014272999,
-0.0064671966,
0.0078939041,
0.0013041752,
-0.0662070289,
-0.0152461072,
2.132524913e-34,
-0.0185498316,
0.0121961702,
-0.0324259177,
0.038262371,
-0.0081308847,
-0.0435918346,
-0.0375431702,
-0.0015057642,
-0.0401302688,
-0.0419282131,
0.0094816843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13186v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13186v3 | SCITAB: A Challenging Benchmark for Compositional Reasoning and Claim Verification on Scientific Tables | 2023-05-22T16:13:50 | 2023-10-23T07:19:30 | Xinyuan Lu, Liangming Pan, Qian Liu, Preslav Nakov, Min-Yen Kan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current scientific fact-checking benchmarks exhibit several shortcomings,
such as biases arising from crowd-sourced claims and an over-reliance on
text-based evidence. We present SCITAB, a challenging evaluation dataset
consisting of 1.2K expert-verified scientific claims that 1) originate from
authentic scientific publications and 2) require compositional reasoning for
verification. The claims are paired with evidence-containing scientific tables
annotated with labels. Through extensive evaluations, we demonstrate that
SCITAB poses a significant challenge to state-of-the-art models, including
table-based pretraining models and large language models. All models except
GPT-4 achieved performance barely above random guessing. Popular prompting
techniques, such as Chain-of-Thought, do not achieve much performance gains on
SCITAB. Our analysis uncovers several unique challenges posed by SCITAB,
including table grounding, claim ambiguity, and compositional reasoning. Our
codes and data are publicly available at https://github.com/XinyuanLu00/SciTab. | [
0.0347022563,
0.0747764707,
0.0288159903,
0.0044043357,
-0.0431136079,
0.015547011,
0.0144159412,
-0.0006331196,
0.0041586845,
-0.0256106816,
-0.0342501774,
-0.0029840299,
0.0168282147,
0.0364854261,
0.0214119535,
0.0268234834,
0.0572649054,
0.0011257547,
0.0306798089,
0.0048456835,
-0.0208479539,
-0.0076726079,
-0.0586031303,
0.0209132768,
-0.0266269818,
-0.0169546399,
0.0197938383,
-0.0253969654,
0.0317475274,
-0.0390000865,
0.0155894989,
0.0962954685,
0.012247283,
0.0595591404,
0.0000018906,
-0.0011093991,
-0.0059101665,
0.0479577556,
-0.0359766819,
0.0069535356,
0.0238247048,
-0.0127336849,
0.0126532605,
0.0039567375,
-0.0277981814,
-0.0049061789,
0.0176507495,
0.0622167028,
0.0425137505,
0.0598300174,
0.0060099061,
-0.0506285317,
-0.0024621007,
-0.0011764697,
0.023309214,
-0.0239906348,
0.0491474122,
0.0129036149,
-0.0067783599,
0.0041079312,
0.0325604528,
0.0368236415,
0.0121631641,
-0.0184983127,
-0.0109870825,
0.0778993815,
-0.0499416292,
0.0043682493,
0.0234949794,
0.1051507443,
0.0445245653,
-0.0525307246,
0.0132393343,
-0.0037578826,
-0.0049016904,
-0.0013133693,
-0.0067144623,
0.045008786,
-0.0192917399,
-0.0303364061,
0.018335117,
0.0252067987,
0.0149573805,
0.0041190982,
-0.001238603,
0.0842137188,
-0.0083087543,
-0.0580480583,
0.0220931824,
-0.0014196381,
0.0518407561,
-0.0809306204,
0.0119161727,
0.0055519235,
-0.0253662784,
0.0166400168,
-0.0024105711,
-0.0220299847,
0.0552341864,
-0.0337170251,
0.0134878112,
0.0433388129,
-0.0307343043,
0.0735378638,
-0.0509388261,
-0.0224185083,
-0.0389026664,
0.0315290727,
0.0215869881,
-0.0055987709,
-0.0519318581,
0.0114757596,
-0.0189173985,
0.0101491148,
-0.0327233337,
0.0140474485,
-0.0328303166,
-0.0685822517,
-0.0263284761,
0.0558302253,
-0.0113501418,
0.033235874,
-0.0215845127,
-0.013388467,
-0.0392897613,
0.0327108353,
-0.0094462149,
0.007235378,
-0.0049866964,
-0.0673863068,
-0.0510909036,
-0.023499744,
-0.0213793628,
-0.0017284463,
0.0482538752,
-0.0067086862,
-0.010364973,
-0.0001391508,
-0.0093921758,
-0.0487927683,
-0.0235633589,
-0.1044313759,
0.0346609093,
-0.0286974236,
0.0714413524,
-0.0065988521,
-0.0024136188,
-0.0414099395,
0.007363392,
0.0517830774,
-0.0227934364,
0.0716786608,
-0.021584304,
-0.0342616178,
-0.0159575492,
0.0160713978,
-0.0409481786,
0.0459612496,
0.025743328,
0.0030678913,
-0.028282864,
0.0233079419,
-0.0178881474,
-0.0455966108,
0.0746897683,
-0.0035381475,
0.0568646342,
0.0413065515,
-0.0142696453,
0.0494447611,
-0.0467414297,
0.0232344754,
-0.0253855567,
-0.0014224192,
0.043303594,
-0.0070324601,
-0.0349076018,
0.0179954041,
0.0339537933,
-0.0426975451,
0.048240032,
0.0025467477,
-0.0466262288,
0.0591343008,
-0.0415390395,
-0.0106388628,
0.0270221438,
0.0234975014,
0.0092335269,
-0.0407587774,
-0.0108988052,
0.0137761757,
-0.0220145006,
-0.0114718005,
0.0375493765,
0.014934578,
-0.0551540852,
0.0148363961,
0.0421553813,
-0.0530293211,
-0.0413104631,
-0.0027624897,
0.0432892106,
-0.0099570807,
0.0399074256,
-0.0531448163,
-0.0276165213,
-0.0235916842,
0.0573952422,
0.0361132957,
0.0601615384,
-0.0434268638,
-0.0098106181,
-0.0014877964,
-0.0182331223,
-0.0106991027,
0.0494827852,
-0.018227445,
0.0493582934,
0.0142835472,
0.0037744208,
-0.0400994569,
-0.0352587141,
0.0371682197,
0.0200251583,
0.0072763329,
-0.0228127502,
-0.0137005933,
0.0609475859,
-0.0001776497,
-0.0044021057,
0.0441175923,
0.0467472561,
-0.0089610722,
-0.0247495789,
0.0019417293,
-0.0020711212,
-0.0312239658,
0.0460039303,
-0.0285238754,
-0.0798739046,
-0.0207807682,
-0.0348433442,
-0.02103086,
0.0059092524,
-0.0151907764,
-0.0457222611,
-0.0040774406,
-0.043776311,
0.0107454993,
-0.0060515404,
0.0335637853,
0.0879460424,
0.0017377487,
0.0275432952,
0.0018914239,
-0.0608413666,
0.0424504727,
-0.0386114493,
0.0132085383,
-0.0026635129,
0.0149826352,
-0.0086339638,
0.0157261882,
-0.0315252021,
-0.0605213568,
0.0125927376,
-0.0612754188,
0.0188079327,
-0.0085887685,
0.0147408554,
0.0063960264,
-0.0565849058,
0.0211462043,
0.0091470806,
-0.0327862836,
-0.0243089702,
-0.0364584774,
0.0062432229,
0.058971554,
0.0153308753,
0.0163315684,
-0.0212536585,
0.0012207764,
-0.0727871805,
0.0401233286,
0.0301386956,
-0.0177590735,
-0.0046849893,
-0.0544219427,
-0.0115737608,
0.0075673196,
-0.0283131003,
0.006906305,
0.0294803716,
0.0129482076,
-0.002464141,
0.0590949133,
-0.0097417952,
0.0069390247,
0.0427225642,
0.0230240114,
-0.0164443273,
0.0416081175,
-0.0125473551,
0.0349357352,
0.0197491478,
-0.0482181869,
0.0275873393,
0.0417071022,
-0.0213371571,
-0.007035119,
-0.05209288,
0.0297396202,
-0.008378515,
-0.0186445415,
0.0023440672,
0.0394618139,
-0.0013569708,
0.0165018644,
-0.0001434646,
0.0103241578,
0.0695772618,
-0.0611677766,
0.0085544111,
-0.0542474799,
0.0176770668,
-0.0168583095,
0.0291471295,
0.0024004339,
0.0075776931,
0.0316658728,
0.0493140779,
-0.0302868839,
0.0037114329,
0.0334473923,
-0.0127904797,
-0.0092871645,
-0.0380067863,
0.0312211197,
0.0018359699,
-0.0368852057,
0.0105087478,
-0.0506472997,
-0.0479794033,
0.0314562954,
-0.003014242,
-0.038697511,
-0.0741544068,
-0.0504699126,
0.0485591106,
0.0500814728,
-0.0111466441,
-0.0125667565,
-0.0099758152,
-0.0112596247,
0.0261747818,
-0.0053912858,
0.0601794198,
-0.0156008396,
-0.0098731611,
0.0828091651,
-0.0393118076,
0.0101025673,
-0.0273739565,
-0.0223583467,
-0.0303737428,
-0.0201360267,
0.0236560646,
0.0110359723,
-0.0028243989,
-0.0461965948,
-0.0007390017,
0.0645768493,
0.0136271501,
0.0308932643,
0.0013771997,
0.0382200703,
0.0009491213,
0.0160270594,
0.0210254751,
-0.1332922429,
-0.0273611695,
-0.0059269187,
-0.0207383521,
-0.0025288691,
-0.0556851141,
-0.0351959951,
-0.0841905028,
0.0431953222,
-0.0300920568,
-0.051396735,
-0.0796541125,
-0.0479975827,
0.005762666,
-0.0189051013,
-0.027251469,
0.0301406644,
0.0062756813,
0.0071830032,
0.0225551706,
-0.0221226178,
-0.071577318,
0.0483333506,
-0.0385546871,
0.043995522,
0.0008797319,
0.043495886,
-0.0176033434,
-0.0601725914,
-0.0058115679,
-0.0062239612,
-0.0385435894,
0.0253364649,
0.0654595122,
-0.0148748104,
0.0225401521,
-0.0003130065,
0.0349820293,
-0.042025499,
-0.0182804894,
-0.0002489533,
0.0740945488,
0.0019012659,
-0.0461522974,
-0.0202301927,
0.0472349524,
0.0082341349,
0.1010472625,
0.0066498104,
0.0505988523,
-0.045575656,
-0.0184496399,
-0.0386416577,
-0.0608437508,
-0.0129770096,
0.0572854541,
0.0176539775,
0.0109191528,
-0.0577369966,
-0.0036751111,
0.0433017053,
0.0545251407,
-0.0450456925,
0.012231824,
0.0095428526,
-0.0012076625,
-0.0229154136,
0.0376845784,
-0.0639063194,
0.0328605995,
-0.0233866796,
-0.041044347,
0.0488572903,
-0.0109751364,
-0.0430842675,
0.0435004123,
-0.033280395,
-0.0307796393,
-0.0401076078,
0.0234356765,
0.024887979,
0.0196024422,
-0.0293214023,
-0.0046723983,
-0.0063173864,
0.0304283909,
-0.0372930653,
0.0017396413,
0.0241854712,
-0.0556768738,
0.0040825559,
-0.0111774644,
-0.0247923508,
-0.0013308238,
0.0064973803,
0.0341797993,
-0.0163074788,
0.0113267368,
0.0568209291,
0.0336251371,
0.0355950929,
0.0079030236,
-0.0142227625,
-0.0205925573,
0.0199759062,
-0.0367192551,
-0.0393984392,
-0.0079816822,
0.0100364638,
-0.0054251491,
-0.0338094719,
-0.0201193523,
-0.0351993851,
-0.0188447796,
0.0282986462,
-0.0155023178,
-0.00872353,
0.0527465716,
-0.0070275939,
0.0549676828,
-0.0477967039,
-0.0396738984,
-0.0307091791,
-0.0270824581,
0.0359807946,
-0.005198414,
0.0159478057,
0.0776596293,
-0.029967688,
-0.0245803539,
-0.0064372937,
-0.0997716561,
-0.0189018641,
-0.0216969997,
0.0022651209,
0.0052395826,
0.0193282571,
0.0038797068,
-0.0596700944,
-0.0361409709,
0.0110436929,
0.0101729678,
0.018640846,
0.0105332742,
0.0609437935,
0.0012885083,
-0.0296037886,
-0.009048393,
0.0635556579,
0.0571923777,
0.0708177313,
0.0229415167,
-0.0239553228,
-0.0351684131,
-0.0466044322,
-0.0933732614,
0.0179192983,
-0.0035061978,
-0.0137634529,
-0.0869268477,
-0.0208098497,
0.0435172096,
0.0611914843,
-0.000924511,
0.0213620104,
0.0143504059,
0.0542076677,
0.0264566243,
-0.0426056087,
-0.0137935011,
0.0239789337,
0.0135132475,
-0.0365827717,
-0.020169802,
-6.553776266e-33,
-0.016501952,
-0.0364385284,
0.0137047553,
-0.0034841078,
0.0268415399,
0.0197285451,
-0.0735133067,
-0.0349777862,
-0.0242421385,
0.0862997174,
-0.0038743587,
0.0564952455,
0.0049990886,
-0.0284939148,
0.0112106903,
-0.0364371017,
0.0487398915,
0.0014550672,
-0.042428121,
0.016768543,
0.0210198592,
-0.0047528166,
0.0374154076,
-0.083636269,
0.0529152937,
0.0203169286,
-0.009635644,
-0.0178218819,
-0.1019360572,
0.0153121082,
-0.0414797515,
0.0024419257,
0.0107615599,
-0.0466000438,
0.0082354741,
-0.0357866473,
-0.1074688807,
0.0019114348,
0.0129249394,
-0.0347626582,
-0.0380015597,
0.0200964008,
0.0012540312,
0.0084149884,
-0.0014397108,
-0.0515922755,
0.0133088641,
-0.0248872433,
0.0166530181,
-0.0591641404,
-0.0408721641,
0.0215756129,
0.0001228604,
0.0225494392,
-0.0058598295,
0.0200891551,
0.0166162178,
0.0477470867,
-0.0667712763,
0.0356857702,
-0.0245657917,
-0.0270364434,
0.0076580122,
-0.0803092569,
0.0048271073,
0.041596476,
-0.0033416182,
0.0379667729,
-0.0541031733,
0.0139000639,
-0.0431968495,
0.0424800962,
0.1102496758,
0.0521178283,
0.0357785821,
0.0121633234,
-0.0964547843,
0.0127337556,
0.0229125246,
0.0007489996,
-0.0032714878,
-0.0229345392,
-0.0236825328,
-0.000164903,
-0.0255680662,
-0.0046791327,
-0.0184732005,
0.0348768756,
-0.0047646281,
0.0014861078,
0.009532758,
0.0305252317,
-0.0070733167,
0.002215767,
-0.0092214532,
0.042217426,
0.0100430539,
0.0053333631,
0.0224388,
0.0306742545,
-0.0693674088,
0.0134772584,
0.0353310741,
0.020534588,
0.0583935045,
0.0234496668,
0.074489668,
0.0008881741,
-0.0372569375,
-0.0117590632,
-0.0465627573,
0.0270497166,
0.0231783818,
-0.0027316227,
0.025746597,
0.0388711281,
0.0155197661,
0.0367366597,
0.0091534071,
0.052945707,
-0.0018277277,
0.0593170151,
-0.0070275161,
0.0160375498,
0.0037313853,
-0.0114463363,
-0.0101226885,
0.0006232519,
-0.0143010877,
-0.0696756467,
0.0309367273,
0.0387313664,
2.687e-7,
0.0654300004,
0.0438738391,
0.015201984,
-0.0092413714,
-0.0015493986,
0.0305063445,
-0.0163710881,
-0.0140710222,
-0.0243277475,
-0.082047537,
-0.0093670618,
-0.0095920013,
0.0358968265,
0.0486092195,
-0.0513720661,
-0.0434186459,
-0.0741941631,
-0.022670269,
-0.049740728,
-0.0134431925,
0.0215248745,
0.0287526287,
0.0021441423,
-0.0117890956,
0.0079258,
0.0010043816,
0.0674160346,
0.0188862383,
0.0442215316,
0.0258508325,
0.0630818903,
-0.0216261651,
0.0030749124,
0.0490736291,
-0.0503403097,
-0.0064462861,
-0.0165801663,
0.0359382071,
0.0164229982,
0.0387333557,
0.0058491039,
-0.0438577794,
0.0252846517,
-0.0655110031,
0.077260375,
-0.0755743235,
-0.0161949396,
0.0245811008,
-0.0355121233,
0.0220375489,
0.0310665146,
0.0287893359,
0.0119001009,
0.0084884232,
-0.0237792525,
0.0172527637,
0.0172141101,
-0.0794688314,
-0.006526276,
0.030562466,
-0.0381391682,
-0.0263913497,
0.030836504,
-0.0206140876,
0.0157289058,
-0.0728617385,
-0.0449292921,
2.571701541e-34,
0.0453691036,
-0.0175828766,
0.0388301834,
-0.0311445948,
0.077481173,
0.0127487155,
-0.0005998112,
-0.0363418385,
-0.0032311922,
-0.0648746341,
-0.0189990513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13179v2 | Teaching Probabilistic Logical Reasoning to Transformers | 2023-05-22T16:08:20 | 2024-02-09T17:29:19 | Aliakbar Nafar, Kristen Brent Venable, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In this paper, we evaluate the capability of transformer-based language
models in making inferences over uncertain text that includes uncertain rules
of reasoning. We cover both Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) and generative
Large Language Models (LLMs). Our evaluation results show that both generations
of language models struggle with reasoning over uncertain text. We propose a
novel end-to-end fine-tuning approach, Probabilistic Constraint Training (PCT),
that utilizes probabilistic logical rules as constraints in the fine-tuning
phase without relying on these rules in the inference stage. To assess the
effectiveness of PCT, we utilize the related corpora and, additionally, create
a new and more challenging benchmark that, unlike the previous ones, uses
instance-specific rules. Our study demonstrates that PCT improves the
transformer-based language model's intrinsic reasoning and makes their
probabilistic logical reasoning process more explicit and explainable.
Furthermore, PCT equips these models to effectively handle novel situations,
including higher reasoning depth, new domains, and complex probabilistic
structures. | [
0.0781607181,
0.0881973654,
0.0022568817,
0.0164818857,
-0.0183532964,
0.0215030964,
0.0181468558,
-0.0087206308,
-0.0337258764,
-0.0490985774,
-0.0017710679,
-0.0410192981,
-0.0110091371,
0.0198241882,
0.0271609798,
-0.0521380045,
0.0373043045,
-0.0307837706,
0.0322047658,
0.0089069493,
-0.0021061683,
0.0129514523,
-0.0214132145,
0.0114606377,
-0.0344821997,
0.0185328089,
0.0209407024,
-0.0185678862,
0.044103615,
-0.0033106501,
-0.0036341602,
0.0508720502,
0.0112463655,
0.020921072,
0.0000019984,
-0.0506607741,
-0.0457924828,
-0.025330916,
-0.0071537327,
-0.0326449275,
0.0133994063,
-0.0049800286,
-0.0312186349,
0.0158315524,
-0.0395544283,
-0.0161379129,
0.0491929501,
0.0946061239,
0.0233690366,
0.0728279054,
-0.0146677503,
-0.0510588177,
0.0069035813,
-0.0371914096,
0.0095536262,
-0.0679859743,
0.0263537802,
0.0171593726,
0.0000872381,
-0.0067272629,
0.0093873711,
0.0091265328,
0.051865384,
-0.0100332825,
-0.0329932757,
0.0501113497,
-0.0468173511,
-0.0502474047,
0.0032426298,
0.0443886742,
-0.0052691167,
-0.0438449718,
-0.0233046636,
-0.0153266797,
-0.0172452237,
0.0365311578,
0.0110537643,
0.0764692426,
-0.015838882,
0.0424871407,
0.0019187803,
0.0240889713,
0.0327842087,
0.0229611341,
-0.0730606616,
0.1030421853,
0.0125320349,
-0.0108807748,
0.0321728736,
0.0070624058,
-0.0483605117,
-0.0259282608,
0.0069683604,
0.0341909565,
-0.0305228215,
0.0430881269,
-0.0254943222,
0.008306928,
0.0051263259,
0.0004004849,
0.0046424991,
0.0347304381,
0.0115818912,
0.0653486177,
-0.0382788144,
0.0301611423,
0.003687599,
0.0469821356,
-0.0047375816,
-0.0134997042,
-0.0480135307,
-0.0133406054,
-0.0343821272,
-0.0077907643,
-0.0017812096,
-0.0142625207,
-0.0353365354,
-0.0016551367,
0.0079803849,
0.0184097309,
0.028312698,
-0.0012651087,
-0.0469816811,
-0.0697420761,
-0.058851786,
0.0251911841,
-0.037078768,
0.0228237864,
0.0018861652,
-0.0489478447,
-0.0153521607,
0.0010690737,
-0.0246740188,
-0.0403192192,
0.0056286063,
0.0516675077,
-0.0173306894,
-0.028080944,
-0.0336388014,
-0.0020142393,
-0.0329444297,
-0.0789865032,
0.0051812092,
-0.0567387678,
-0.0268577542,
0.0008176758,
0.0279941112,
-0.0444689617,
0.0255286284,
-0.002133444,
-0.0274477173,
0.1100662574,
0.0169404708,
-0.0167521965,
-0.0146075105,
0.0201245863,
0.0128081972,
0.07292483,
0.0395048335,
-0.0069314446,
0.0058599799,
0.002928274,
0.0122670922,
0.0135275312,
-0.0128097478,
-0.0191584304,
-0.0026188483,
-0.018625468,
-0.0079576392,
0.0202510599,
0.0049498421,
0.0756700933,
-0.0261698645,
-0.0074867294,
0.0520333908,
-0.0175507609,
0.0211035032,
0.0053215865,
0.0386316888,
-0.009819258,
0.0102948826,
0.0085384585,
-0.0858198851,
0.0245939996,
-0.0121430885,
0.0216783267,
-0.0325517394,
0.0262737293,
-0.0073073856,
-0.063397266,
-0.0303711519,
-0.0201031603,
0.0066125183,
-0.009013731,
0.0951853469,
0.0383003838,
-0.0430013537,
0.0801960751,
0.0336152092,
-0.0571261458,
-0.0120201642,
-0.046521768,
0.0207673404,
0.004409838,
0.0320192203,
-0.0406197943,
-0.0289526116,
-0.0211324934,
0.0032999592,
0.0680988804,
0.0342993475,
0.0217889845,
0.0115130385,
-0.0572010018,
-0.0255305208,
0.0210608579,
0.0228420813,
0.011864936,
0.0387847461,
-0.0096339174,
0.0307931695,
-0.0378516093,
-0.0007566532,
0.0537303276,
0.0007587401,
-0.0044846828,
0.0042146458,
0.0069477535,
-0.0028444866,
-0.0271407962,
-0.0258105844,
0.009593063,
0.0232036281,
-0.014637568,
-0.046448648,
0.026551351,
-0.06727878,
0.0075615905,
0.0470261276,
-0.0482795388,
-0.0659204945,
-0.013210902,
-0.0543403849,
-0.0149094723,
-0.0228690878,
-0.0134250866,
0.016607644,
-0.0428771451,
0.006474473,
0.0112046972,
-0.0218409244,
-0.037323527,
0.0915780589,
0.0072290413,
0.0102521461,
0.011553443,
0.0171142817,
0.0200815294,
-0.0238007903,
-0.0140246125,
-0.018806709,
-0.0397550724,
0.0070602703,
0.0337635651,
0.0196105614,
-0.0319744162,
-0.062254969,
-0.0127245393,
-0.0087646572,
-0.019386081,
0.0108055742,
-0.0196328759,
-0.0143307131,
-0.010091885,
-0.0106881466,
-0.0167794116,
-0.0020653289,
-0.0097693391,
0.0005341093,
0.0297117271,
-0.0069546588,
0.0048451982,
-0.0090692323,
0.009822241,
-0.0209535919,
0.0451099612,
0.0396318734,
0.0358209871,
-0.0641078651,
0.050175216,
-0.0262243748,
0.0256955475,
-0.0187009256,
-0.0432802886,
0.013571199,
-0.0223862045,
0.0497491136,
0.0721477643,
0.0204435773,
0.0118677225,
0.0833719075,
-0.0047331639,
-0.0213022567,
0.0349913463,
-0.0452451035,
-0.0484725609,
-0.0674706474,
-0.0203340035,
-0.0227164216,
0.0594595335,
-0.0282180551,
-0.0419271775,
-0.0852458104,
0.0449852496,
-0.0176373012,
-0.0125206206,
0.0149707627,
-0.0113976318,
-0.0083320467,
0.0476148836,
-0.0150360186,
-0.042127531,
0.0831629857,
-0.0204018038,
0.0225813743,
-0.0666700378,
0.0023962241,
-0.0311889723,
0.0431855321,
0.0231203623,
-0.0044516847,
0.0435282737,
-0.0120092425,
-0.076696977,
0.0079521919,
0.0460147932,
-0.0201059002,
0.0258728657,
-0.0610953197,
0.015047635,
-0.0052275672,
-0.0328692794,
-0.0593200177,
-0.0255803987,
-0.0496087708,
0.0040056584,
0.0064255744,
-0.0220044423,
-0.0430095233,
0.024771804,
-0.0096114287,
0.0221714433,
-0.0105494354,
-0.0332959853,
-0.0220015384,
-0.0064800144,
0.045620434,
0.0371231139,
0.048576314,
-0.0303955395,
-0.0307211392,
0.0288751163,
-0.0099298265,
-0.0117601659,
-0.0358091779,
0.0255691782,
0.012977778,
-0.0152022215,
-0.0115012061,
0.0197992455,
0.0397715531,
-0.0477860309,
-0.0232522581,
0.1326098591,
0.0457904339,
0.0020661971,
-0.0249621328,
-0.0306397695,
0.0426315591,
0.0129256239,
0.0461689681,
-0.0848004892,
-0.0597681403,
0.021990262,
0.0009775417,
0.0075722085,
-0.0365230255,
0.0046897484,
-0.1076466218,
-0.0022713267,
-0.0319635645,
-0.0224256236,
-0.0459163822,
-0.0365275219,
-0.0099274367,
-0.042563498,
0.0225931518,
-0.0083219539,
-0.0212494545,
0.0074211764,
0.0304367989,
-0.0022737223,
-0.0513755009,
0.0097544026,
-0.0460222028,
0.0401488692,
0.0454141013,
-0.0034362476,
-0.0076830527,
-0.0319977365,
-0.005080055,
-0.0061533223,
-0.013765106,
-0.0006523793,
0.0202775355,
0.0147304665,
-0.0093252426,
0.0009730426,
0.0121307392,
-0.015455314,
-0.0457773395,
-0.0205913354,
0.055425588,
-0.0022892086,
-0.039542038,
0.0090994798,
0.0185843166,
0.0110634174,
0.0808614641,
-0.0038760556,
0.0035500708,
-0.0418955162,
-0.0713174567,
0.0019305266,
-0.030475786,
-0.0077849501,
0.0146443276,
0.0102938265,
-0.052759774,
-0.0439712517,
-0.0024790713,
0.013835771,
0.0347270034,
0.0117295627,
-0.0478601456,
0.0590866096,
0.013647506,
-0.046932213,
0.0336578004,
-0.0303482451,
0.0152245872,
-0.0395072214,
0.0234372895,
0.0408804901,
-0.0241991635,
-0.0293459427,
0.0441401079,
-0.0840621591,
-0.0771479607,
0.0022023555,
0.0535966605,
0.0318950899,
0.0246324632,
-0.0280567668,
-0.0620091446,
0.0108811967,
0.043822404,
-0.0096464083,
-0.0118736438,
0.0732637495,
-0.0326993726,
0.014393393,
0.0310887266,
-0.0425915942,
0.0187803842,
0.0372551233,
0.0510650575,
-0.0336003527,
-0.04452461,
0.0333864056,
-0.0188788455,
0.0415921621,
-0.0223325901,
-0.0289794002,
-0.0314568877,
0.0440050848,
-0.0178845078,
-0.0107804276,
-0.0106037231,
0.0210117195,
0.0332059413,
-0.0138629563,
-0.0043743951,
0.0148152206,
0.007016174,
0.0504764318,
0.0308869425,
-0.0015316523,
0.0547254421,
-0.0358330123,
0.0403900519,
-0.0391082466,
0.0109933857,
0.0114207845,
0.0295924637,
0.0497731082,
0.0006399757,
0.0669624209,
0.0582089499,
-0.0201707724,
-0.0265500918,
-0.0386482403,
-0.0714613199,
-0.039364133,
0.0219478868,
-0.0058048428,
0.0321271457,
-0.0167971216,
0.0509303808,
-0.0642392933,
-0.0086967945,
0.0037274538,
0.0357827172,
0.0513684265,
-0.0008325207,
0.0616862625,
0.0030599288,
-0.0098731564,
0.0164498873,
0.0691325739,
0.0025735458,
0.0437789261,
-0.026821766,
-0.0194184631,
-0.031544935,
-0.024738187,
-0.0338992178,
0.0132520543,
-0.0038109645,
0.0268265978,
-0.0431554243,
-0.0633286834,
-0.0110041462,
0.0259794574,
0.0140561853,
-0.0170240737,
0.0159405712,
0.0745588019,
-0.0033030519,
-0.0247586556,
-0.0107040135,
-0.0148663707,
0.0373299941,
0.0195336454,
-0.0378532745,
-6.745332621e-33,
-0.0085315872,
-0.0440930612,
0.0187704116,
-0.0287898518,
-0.0232908148,
-0.024011666,
-0.0328922607,
-0.0168635659,
-0.0155777028,
0.0543203503,
-0.0086343084,
0.0331053212,
0.0172851067,
0.0337820575,
-0.0129896356,
-0.0135505805,
0.0209487602,
0.0395391509,
-0.0388413519,
-0.0154118501,
0.042276565,
0.0163468476,
0.0673234612,
-0.0067152469,
0.0010971868,
0.0288832765,
-0.0300418697,
0.0685339421,
-0.037292026,
0.0594277717,
-0.006506321,
0.0104365647,
0.010765125,
-0.0444701202,
0.0085922172,
0.021222055,
-0.1155517101,
-0.0343972407,
0.0173695404,
0.016924696,
-0.0062364801,
-0.0311092194,
0.0239482578,
-0.0000485272,
0.0064509972,
-0.0341563672,
0.0369809605,
-0.0386861749,
-0.010310675,
-0.0535359085,
-0.0563257635,
0.0438186377,
0.0068482077,
-0.0159639362,
0.0025698694,
0.006080599,
-0.0033965483,
0.0117422109,
-0.0318684839,
0.0272597224,
0.0250927377,
0.0479364432,
0.0551005974,
0.0228196625,
-0.0392766967,
0.0431856662,
-0.0468161181,
-0.0178394578,
-0.0671849921,
-0.0155282049,
0.0229797866,
0.0389797688,
0.037159387,
0.02697278,
0.0234782416,
0.0135482233,
-0.1066840962,
0.0052703428,
0.0085660899,
0.0745976791,
0.0472072139,
0.0151215522,
-0.0285662096,
-0.0162979625,
-0.0488976613,
0.0234436672,
-0.0235099699,
0.0006526963,
-0.0027529295,
0.0160560887,
-0.0388600118,
0.003236731,
0.0181680527,
-0.043648053,
-0.0336141326,
0.0256091841,
0.0007955672,
-0.0198062453,
-0.0397824943,
0.0472529866,
-0.0323546752,
-0.0114352172,
0.0549392067,
-0.0160736181,
-0.0073780762,
-0.0035924998,
0.0690717846,
0.0146340905,
-0.0711690038,
0.0074577336,
-0.028934801,
0.0288692527,
-0.0084981564,
0.0539762788,
0.0277474355,
0.0654318109,
-0.0025740764,
0.0176760107,
0.0029355937,
0.0006916558,
-0.0266716462,
0.0512994267,
0.0286784917,
0.0288228318,
-0.0076799248,
-0.0026280151,
-0.0413538255,
0.0186269507,
0.0046972637,
-0.0477867648,
-0.0172130615,
0.0473738723,
2.798e-7,
0.0947144479,
0.0649219453,
0.0259536691,
0.046881672,
0.008526477,
0.0419560075,
0.005217121,
-0.0248271264,
0.0389448293,
-0.0070858207,
-0.0067943432,
0.0484917574,
0.0561870225,
0.0452386066,
-0.0706794411,
-0.0202165022,
-0.0261840317,
-0.0294230524,
-0.0093534635,
0.0048204134,
0.1147737503,
0.1210533157,
0.0187738985,
-0.0049665454,
0.0214522593,
-0.036016155,
0.0450007096,
-0.028094165,
0.0165857542,
0.0426008254,
0.0233028959,
0.0046075727,
-0.000790885,
0.0458286181,
-0.0117145563,
0.0076180017,
-0.0310718417,
0.0662340373,
0.0015376828,
-0.0030516505,
-0.0020632248,
-0.0284487363,
0.0044316184,
-0.0587774962,
0.0782285482,
-0.1216192022,
-0.0279326215,
0.0362711251,
-0.0136892619,
-0.0376561917,
0.004528759,
-0.011244921,
-0.0504634753,
0.004418496,
0.0043221945,
0.0145060346,
-0.0167485867,
-0.0951848999,
-0.0151066463,
-0.0031072467,
-0.0278610177,
-0.0512305312,
0.0003321058,
-0.0332753025,
0.0424416363,
-0.0547879376,
0.0022104525,
2.766253433e-34,
0.0409134515,
-0.0023881427,
-0.0265105441,
-0.0101816589,
0.0631505251,
0.0063032545,
-0.0050873761,
0.0161166042,
0.0115578882,
-0.0944752172,
0.0078643626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13175v2 | Discovering Universal Geometry in Embeddings with ICA | 2023-05-22T16:04:44 | 2023-11-02T16:03:33 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Momose Oyama, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study utilizes Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to unveil a
consistent semantic structure within embeddings of words or images. Our
approach extracts independent semantic components from the embeddings of a
pre-trained model by leveraging anisotropic information that remains after the
whitening process in Principal Component Analysis (PCA). We demonstrate that
each embedding can be expressed as a composition of a few intrinsic
interpretable axes and that these semantic axes remain consistent across
different languages, algorithms, and modalities. The discovery of a universal
semantic structure in the geometric patterns of embeddings enhances our
understanding of the representations in embeddings. | [
-0.0056044701,
0.0570581853,
-0.0175259225,
0.0819272995,
-0.0092144059,
0.0426783077,
0.0049602943,
-0.0004535807,
0.009142126,
-0.0374963246,
-0.0351060703,
-0.0181120727,
0.0083292164,
0.0226854756,
0.0198456701,
-0.0723266006,
0.0048552006,
-0.0078145489,
-0.0031965612,
-0.0183993243,
-0.0111104818,
-0.0225324817,
-0.0126191853,
0.0253752004,
-0.0824576244,
-0.0356152877,
-0.0086495494,
-0.0499474145,
-0.0070939832,
-0.0376376882,
-0.0602962337,
0.0221544821,
0.0433535203,
-0.0093271034,
0.0000018758,
0.0100335404,
-0.0059040962,
0.0166642666,
0.0530150868,
0.0074229403,
-0.0034870051,
-0.0373283587,
0.0047346968,
-0.0556226894,
-0.0408812463,
-0.0057007927,
0.0658456162,
0.0751105994,
0.000025118,
0.0289337467,
-0.0352469534,
-0.0623579137,
-0.0193940271,
-0.0265734978,
-0.0166741218,
0.0172006693,
0.0095654866,
-0.0166668668,
-0.0731592327,
0.0275709145,
-0.0799790919,
0.0104016624,
0.0042310595,
0.0215808861,
0.0327720754,
0.0716683343,
0.0118194073,
-0.0281928219,
-0.0025468706,
0.1308009475,
0.0029014696,
0.0149381422,
0.0138097964,
-0.016454421,
-0.0108316997,
0.0316480622,
-0.0504433513,
-0.0026973786,
0.032880988,
0.052288454,
-0.0207250807,
0.0077280262,
0.0165118761,
-0.0701007396,
-0.045175299,
0.0120062772,
0.0423497856,
-0.0224488806,
-0.0119527997,
0.0158640016,
0.0037330964,
0.030351216,
0.0006723827,
-0.0044181342,
0.0639015809,
0.0029121588,
0.0132557284,
0.0002802482,
0.0084742904,
-0.0299264956,
0.0745676681,
-0.0152571974,
-0.0050086868,
0.0533280186,
-0.0223637745,
0.0377777703,
-0.041087307,
0.0838554204,
-0.0443067811,
0.0406081304,
-0.0088128923,
-0.0085146874,
0.0239590034,
0.0183783397,
-0.0164923631,
-0.0505563989,
0.0230750311,
0.0340890102,
-0.0330060534,
0.0041439887,
0.0115677156,
0.0586889908,
-0.0011748619,
0.0119575011,
0.0069982368,
0.0110740988,
-0.0259829983,
0.0105598262,
-0.0951267481,
0.0061933692,
0.0035355361,
0.039414078,
0.0333007686,
0.0190005992,
-0.0376316048,
0.076567553,
-0.0005818012,
-0.0309990719,
0.0018304019,
-0.0065240129,
-0.0274558794,
-0.0029720459,
0.0720780194,
-0.0344607607,
0.0443112515,
-0.0347098634,
0.022175204,
-0.0614344999,
-0.0115036964,
-0.0328318886,
-0.0550843924,
0.0806055143,
-0.0166811347,
0.0043925629,
0.0206304863,
0.0103786131,
0.0515406504,
0.0440137684,
0.0215677246,
0.0237524286,
0.0480470657,
-0.026083773,
0.0133157792,
0.0159124546,
0.0052686329,
-0.0094581023,
-0.0527652875,
-0.016378399,
0.0304816011,
-0.0056264442,
0.004336636,
0.0248308405,
-0.0179993678,
-0.0525264554,
0.0237167515,
0.0788781419,
-0.0146193272,
0.0110785551,
0.0732278153,
0.0031435047,
0.0077404315,
0.0424025096,
-0.0394954309,
0.0099940831,
0.0670087188,
-0.0133209052,
0.0130874151,
-0.0001075998,
-0.0392650515,
-0.031895224,
0.0078112409,
-0.0432393886,
-0.0051795458,
-0.0246542934,
0.0524737574,
0.0070039583,
0.020474907,
0.0135259712,
0.0376144052,
-0.0471085832,
-0.02877203,
0.0490316413,
0.0576590076,
0.0039192974,
0.0053982525,
-0.0354225188,
0.0095868167,
0.040380273,
0.0023702695,
0.0289703477,
-0.0356270373,
-0.0339935496,
0.0204151217,
-0.0224034488,
-0.0475196987,
-0.0005819725,
0.0358516537,
0.0539675951,
-0.0327052064,
0.0054346812,
0.0048943013,
-0.0258625336,
0.0046666935,
0.0454218686,
-0.016684914,
-0.0353590585,
0.0107048331,
0.0452279113,
0.0094490619,
0.0101373019,
-0.0187249798,
0.0021277962,
0.0754373521,
-0.0584228374,
-0.0094156461,
0.0365868993,
-0.0348216556,
-0.015240646,
0.0263697896,
-0.1310729235,
0.0053130658,
-0.0194704402,
-0.0185054857,
-0.0234611388,
0.0536549836,
-0.0206702165,
-0.0025123663,
0.0013244454,
-0.036619667,
-0.0177642796,
0.0526450016,
-0.0227232929,
0.0318417735,
-0.008230269,
0.0153437313,
0.0076978379,
0.0038415147,
0.027909413,
0.0027488968,
-0.0134595688,
0.0477036759,
0.0244946573,
-0.0149469124,
-0.0048370035,
0.016934244,
-0.0240955632,
-0.016509708,
-0.0732605159,
-0.0549780317,
0.0029768371,
-0.0048962301,
0.0416026413,
-0.0398972631,
0.0100459345,
-0.0495555773,
-0.0254062656,
0.0114153484,
-0.0635693818,
0.0224103276,
0.019349752,
-0.0286181811,
-0.0125615718,
-0.0221380629,
-0.0206563529,
-0.017417198,
0.1022437587,
0.0460763909,
0.0118806809,
-0.0120181572,
-0.0196377188,
-0.0410177596,
0.0074996892,
-0.0164664648,
-0.0346855894,
0.0315062813,
-0.0330246612,
0.0190440342,
0.0535918623,
-0.0122798681,
0.0469866581,
0.0620553717,
-0.0259559155,
-0.0254988372,
-0.0227212403,
-0.0464759879,
0.0916820616,
0.01016594,
-0.036851462,
-0.0039342535,
0.076295875,
0.0353831761,
0.0056813671,
-0.0585960597,
0.0157284997,
-0.0372791961,
-0.0270602442,
-0.0664294809,
-0.0071613821,
-0.0065685236,
0.0059543005,
0.001475273,
-0.0407463089,
0.0108599821,
-0.038103193,
0.0075188498,
-0.0084411809,
0.0126509303,
-0.0479410365,
0.0712500066,
-0.0029819056,
0.0121608917,
-0.0104115149,
-0.0147633441,
0.0133850956,
0.0380155221,
-0.0111637264,
-0.027861828,
0.0147289671,
-0.0120359985,
-0.0275341701,
0.0001531353,
-0.0238500778,
-0.0186869316,
-0.0499807596,
-0.0004288929,
-0.0355448611,
-0.0046847826,
-0.0199548826,
0.010536382,
0.0219062604,
0.0151405502,
-0.0114715584,
-0.0274185762,
0.0085236011,
-0.0210635029,
0.0729967281,
0.022506237,
-0.010463953,
-0.022197457,
-0.001155023,
0.0090642925,
0.0497735441,
-0.0234319326,
0.0349952541,
-0.0418112688,
0.046892859,
-0.015841566,
0.0562426373,
-0.0357839651,
-0.0334713012,
-0.0062917257,
0.0165056977,
-0.0190143399,
0.0634605363,
0.029046189,
-0.0927565768,
0.0010670333,
-0.0038612958,
-0.0208497308,
0.0253758486,
0.0031027396,
-0.032174591,
-0.0163890626,
-0.0264906567,
-0.0400130078,
0.0503836684,
-0.0190375559,
-0.0004056917,
-0.0770160407,
0.0331989937,
0.005921334,
-0.0087762177,
-0.0576317832,
-0.0271644276,
0.0066535934,
0.0182255358,
-0.0091855284,
-0.0533609502,
0.0059641777,
-0.0027138013,
0.0122031327,
-0.0493501164,
-0.0214085113,
-0.0216961075,
0.0056085219,
-0.030232992,
-0.0194043089,
0.0781526268,
-0.0164117776,
-0.0745694488,
-0.0037763549,
-0.0264962427,
0.0069444566,
-0.0118028875,
0.0687314048,
0.0238609798,
-0.0364078395,
0.0234804545,
-0.0009362324,
-0.0208776649,
-0.0094590886,
-0.0240800995,
0.0996808186,
-0.0064497865,
-0.0277635157,
-0.0684123263,
-0.0038250654,
-0.0042776307,
0.0303858668,
0.0451343916,
-0.0383634418,
-0.0099635385,
-0.0127110751,
0.0665750504,
0.0267459638,
-0.0338654444,
0.0087022809,
0.0146482941,
-0.0407340564,
-0.0986044183,
0.0055203368,
0.0152373463,
0.0565413684,
0.0571891591,
-0.0220307112,
-0.0087020881,
-0.0271026269,
-0.038342867,
0.037223313,
-0.049868606,
-0.0082434621,
0.0098339571,
0.0168935638,
0.0554689281,
-0.0390974097,
-0.0467246659,
-0.023332255,
0.037969701,
-0.0520500094,
0.0081454441,
0.0164526571,
-0.0073705274,
0.0422024392,
-0.0206356104,
-0.0230665151,
0.0747238472,
-0.0019970501,
-0.0035591291,
0.0346096493,
0.0364378206,
-0.0346161909,
0.0120427888,
0.0263254326,
-0.0078026378,
0.0388534777,
0.0130933765,
-0.0029391141,
0.0117194373,
-0.0226721019,
0.0031889714,
-0.0033549641,
0.0556223467,
0.0356914587,
0.0338992514,
-0.0423990786,
-0.0085839415,
-0.0107850395,
-0.0066695111,
-0.0352644511,
0.0218608323,
0.029958019,
-0.0078221373,
-0.0300963819,
0.016290389,
0.0115635721,
0.0034735217,
-0.0066105435,
-0.0170076713,
0.0471156165,
0.0022624363,
-0.0615469515,
0.0592087358,
-0.0002986469,
0.0352943838,
-0.070364736,
-0.015203964,
-0.0152608603,
-0.0051404494,
-0.012052631,
-0.01873569,
-0.0964140818,
0.0477359518,
-0.0281394254,
0.01652845,
0.0038126986,
0.0224576071,
0.0656128079,
-0.0165344886,
0.0382393561,
0.0183270946,
0.0057616201,
0.0286081415,
0.0077261385,
0.0030474635,
-0.0130222021,
0.0899747685,
-0.0091975974,
-0.0174349602,
-0.0056232009,
0.0583938807,
-0.0507245958,
0.0156016005,
-0.0417876355,
-0.0113887377,
-0.0313288271,
0.0485726818,
0.0620795004,
0.0485518351,
-0.0285308771,
0.0182969216,
0.0012817027,
-0.0335114002,
-0.0011649458,
0.0197925419,
-0.0372124352,
0.0617565326,
0.0333523117,
0.0568576977,
0.0061852252,
0.0124828285,
-0.0107565671,
0.0126977926,
-0.0407928862,
-0.0290645678,
-0.0002204471,
-6.178320431e-33,
-0.0112178102,
-0.0144461077,
-0.0377814844,
0.0381133892,
-0.0409654863,
0.0330945589,
-0.01944164,
0.005375531,
0.0028305352,
0.0591649897,
-0.0058751511,
-0.0069793058,
-0.0049043223,
0.0081416108,
0.0126962783,
-0.0040744408,
-0.0053603514,
-0.0085425172,
-0.0198388435,
0.0222017523,
0.0619653501,
0.0299118459,
0.0808961019,
-0.1130921841,
0.0064519881,
0.0220209192,
0.0122396536,
0.004577551,
0.0289957169,
0.0472275428,
-0.0908567384,
-0.0046132593,
0.0317059308,
0.0226351134,
-0.0280145984,
0.0489541404,
-0.0396238975,
-0.0414635576,
-0.0089463461,
0.0280251671,
-0.0872868896,
-0.0447585806,
0.045472648,
-0.0486421213,
-0.0005214814,
-0.0234508552,
0.0626158044,
0.0113509595,
0.0203686636,
0.0482904837,
-0.046891816,
0.0001412396,
-0.0417541191,
0.0221699886,
0.0651051849,
-0.0320560299,
0.0295547377,
0.0350806303,
-0.0196915548,
0.0398610197,
-0.0473402366,
-0.0026096683,
0.0224573538,
-0.0046455436,
0.0280412603,
0.0894866958,
0.0492719412,
-0.1012874097,
-0.0020839458,
-0.0517162196,
0.0406968258,
0.0291706808,
0.0229163747,
0.0343032666,
-0.0035804862,
0.0025528718,
-0.0511454679,
0.011725408,
-0.0620414466,
-0.0209372994,
0.0162355416,
-0.0155665101,
-0.0490210839,
0.0132005773,
-0.0315099247,
-0.0382905938,
-0.0166624673,
-0.0172068384,
0.0321596377,
0.0097067971,
-0.0416637883,
0.0256350972,
0.0067981849,
-0.0445227996,
-0.0036363385,
0.0378884077,
-0.0213730056,
0.0493607782,
0.0131033491,
-0.0374756269,
-0.0045422302,
-0.0160329752,
0.0185491685,
-0.0366585962,
0.0370117351,
-0.023255229,
0.0408014357,
0.0238948539,
-0.0291584134,
-0.0305867922,
-0.0064623188,
-0.1074916124,
-0.0034131536,
0.0025021459,
0.0459769368,
0.0334236994,
-0.0547474585,
0.0238655135,
0.0220421441,
0.083069481,
-0.0226856414,
-0.0582739115,
-0.005053123,
0.060364075,
-0.0391308554,
-0.0372064635,
-0.0211375505,
-0.0134178009,
0.0802471712,
-0.0775770023,
-0.0030739638,
0.0299836993,
2.602e-7,
0.0184649248,
0.0447900817,
0.0025240828,
-0.0380258374,
0.0671695396,
0.027916301,
-0.0341193527,
0.0359141752,
-0.0354435593,
-0.0004812933,
0.00853136,
0.0495579205,
-0.0219921712,
0.0038953125,
-0.0537991971,
0.0712921023,
-0.0198253226,
-0.0010456417,
-0.0226551741,
-0.0070592249,
0.0295581073,
0.0886339396,
-0.002047929,
-0.0122510158,
-0.0123606157,
-0.0083734998,
0.053850539,
-0.0305441599,
0.0426368788,
-0.0265556201,
-0.0280207228,
0.0041422625,
0.0115071833,
0.0012878933,
0.0146337058,
0.0326396413,
0.0408026353,
0.0224789865,
-0.0295447502,
0.049461998,
0.0097687338,
0.0200097244,
0.0005761083,
-0.0439594761,
0.0874686241,
-0.0442056209,
-0.0648314953,
-0.0723017901,
0.0090491436,
0.0197338611,
0.0602060743,
-0.0014411653,
-0.0113148494,
0.0170138776,
0.0103546605,
-0.0232331362,
0.0001590428,
-0.0619424544,
0.013585127,
-0.0107844146,
-0.035932377,
0.0287954789,
-0.0272567179,
-0.0192355439,
0.0589521937,
-0.0408114269,
-0.0055723274,
1.95235446e-34,
-0.0396640599,
-0.003384619,
-0.0009613619,
0.0152625209,
-0.0108110104,
-0.0622007512,
0.0623793527,
-0.0202917717,
-0.0177191626,
-0.0655680448,
-0.0002700896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13172v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13172v3 | Editing Large Language Models: Problems, Methods, and Opportunities | 2023-05-22T16:00:00 | 2023-11-30T08:55:24 | Yunzhi Yao, Peng Wang, Bozhong Tian, Siyuan Cheng, Zhoubo Li, Shumin Deng, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG | Despite the ability to train capable LLMs, the methodology for maintaining
their relevancy and rectifying errors remains elusive. To this end, the past
few years have witnessed a surge in techniques for editing LLMs, the objective
of which is to efficiently alter the behavior of LLMs within a specific domain
without negatively impacting performance across other inputs. This paper
embarks on a deep exploration of the problems, methods, and opportunities
related to model editing for LLMs. In particular, we provide an exhaustive
overview of the task definition and challenges associated with model editing,
along with an in-depth empirical analysis of the most progressive methods
currently at our disposal. We also build a new benchmark dataset to facilitate
a more robust evaluation and pinpoint enduring issues intrinsic to existing
techniques. Our objective is to provide valuable insights into the
effectiveness and feasibility of each editing technique, thereby assisting the
community in making informed decisions on the selection of the most appropriate
method for a specific task or context. Code and datasets are available at
https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit. | [
0.0229226463,
0.068087168,
-0.0151449377,
0.0625257194,
-0.0430776887,
0.0105732959,
-0.0376161933,
-0.0090688979,
-0.0121851284,
-0.065060094,
-0.0688377023,
-0.0094853872,
-0.0006059322,
-0.0040804595,
0.0372974537,
-0.054459963,
0.0665674508,
-0.0315284245,
-0.042220667,
0.0152013237,
-0.01478549,
-0.0145854084,
-0.0015602966,
0.0208357107,
0.0318680815,
-0.0123495599,
-0.0089060897,
0.0524878465,
0.0116396202,
0.0026277164,
0.0262410529,
0.0492467061,
0.0122848228,
0.0202611033,
0.0000019376,
-0.0487718396,
-0.0498151183,
0.0133641027,
-0.0075954287,
0.0558158383,
0.0348569155,
0.0076825577,
-0.0542665012,
0.011198937,
-0.0360598788,
0.0265266933,
0.0474262461,
0.0059783203,
0.0800051168,
0.1001847386,
0.0088903084,
0.0021904835,
0.0051734718,
-0.0257886853,
-0.0188556332,
-0.0363629535,
0.0464425497,
0.0205100086,
-0.0160409398,
-0.0193953943,
-0.0366072282,
0.0323089883,
0.0099117029,
-0.0313400961,
0.0044435053,
-0.0219574701,
-0.0283737145,
0.0055358782,
-0.0036293555,
0.0383057445,
-0.0161915906,
-0.0123514058,
-0.0221431926,
-0.0142741054,
0.0096152332,
0.0134010762,
-0.0495333374,
-0.004038956,
0.0384058654,
0.0232499149,
-0.0026038685,
-0.087920323,
0.0405979976,
0.0176384263,
-0.024630446,
0.0654689223,
0.052132111,
-0.0217225403,
-0.0295105055,
-0.0064515467,
-0.0111034047,
-0.0609639809,
-0.0073610279,
0.0447313599,
-0.0226971563,
0.0215873737,
-0.056789387,
0.0031079024,
-0.0020316725,
-0.0287040025,
0.0821830332,
0.0313241333,
-0.0286775045,
0.037459366,
-0.0205525514,
0.0211781319,
0.0013941012,
0.0246177893,
-0.0381749943,
0.0243773144,
-0.0222960338,
0.0186818019,
-0.0451412015,
0.0021433569,
-0.0303258672,
0.0539691336,
-0.0534958057,
0.0295936987,
-0.0112900743,
0.0423429944,
0.0059372713,
-0.0265472028,
-0.0240276325,
-0.0203574654,
-0.0113508366,
0.0155385984,
0.0183764677,
0.0066796895,
0.0028927058,
-0.0567503795,
-0.005794846,
0.0081244707,
-0.0221477002,
-0.035549745,
0.0094202822,
0.0893706083,
0.0101048183,
-0.0081237964,
-0.0684034079,
-0.0197044276,
0.0120462421,
-0.0542363822,
-0.0068626609,
-0.071403645,
-0.0227891374,
-0.0285393074,
0.0014969088,
-0.0805549473,
-0.0071227816,
-0.0256127045,
-0.0059633413,
0.0821254775,
-0.0414374806,
0.0155164655,
0.01881014,
0.009957361,
-0.0133904899,
0.076636374,
0.0596582405,
-0.0000834537,
0.0675778538,
-0.0115072364,
0.0174689312,
0.075182654,
-0.0099508371,
0.0318228602,
-0.0554315895,
0.0154226525,
0.0001462049,
0.0223804675,
0.0184590314,
0.0122245625,
-0.0213800333,
0.00350425,
0.0756329075,
0.0172812343,
0.0382363275,
0.0255190618,
0.0522266105,
-0.0476665422,
0.030094726,
0.0130174551,
-0.0642620176,
0.0007743158,
-0.0117040742,
0.0300010964,
-0.0175516736,
0.0484275445,
-0.002588094,
-0.0645115525,
-0.0322505273,
0.0243814066,
-0.0079755411,
0.0017037878,
0.0392566733,
0.0291604251,
-0.0276120175,
0.0892502889,
0.0234708898,
-0.0467833243,
-0.0023220452,
-0.0767589808,
-0.0057235686,
0.0464350022,
0.0551589131,
-0.0673406124,
-0.090485312,
-0.0015346034,
0.0099148471,
0.0155701358,
0.0555689856,
-0.0245971475,
-0.0120321736,
-0.0483611748,
-0.0207303502,
-0.0296028275,
0.0360987,
0.0010435279,
0.0516221896,
-0.0252528321,
0.0184910912,
-0.051386252,
-0.0256361533,
0.0210966133,
-0.0636240765,
-0.0162935592,
0.0145628871,
-0.0056275167,
0.0297784675,
-0.0109078689,
-0.0228380803,
-0.0097265849,
0.0151788928,
0.0171041321,
-0.0155028272,
-0.0014537758,
0.0068849432,
-0.0044083372,
0.0735005066,
-0.0124248173,
-0.0326007195,
0.037426047,
-0.0806278139,
-0.0081529263,
-0.0047635529,
-0.0544630773,
0.0304930564,
-0.0259302929,
0.0609210618,
-0.0206819866,
-0.0133658219,
-0.0396410339,
0.019803945,
-0.0172020756,
-0.0270137358,
0.0493713059,
0.0026574023,
-0.0135659054,
-0.0340099111,
-0.0026882838,
0.0217408147,
0.0083939675,
0.0018145188,
-0.0002694993,
0.0281452108,
-0.0501813442,
-0.048838269,
-0.0562654212,
0.0081033492,
-0.0249220617,
0.0404730104,
0.0405978076,
0.0229185279,
-0.034632951,
0.0112799117,
-0.0023738919,
-0.0045386902,
-0.008636971,
0.0264052097,
0.0313946158,
0.0089768888,
-0.0688507557,
-0.0691168979,
0.0034733252,
0.0029681025,
0.0296670608,
-0.0473763719,
-0.0514071956,
-0.0736957416,
0.0481448174,
-0.0494984053,
0.0265447367,
0.0098729702,
-0.0260725506,
-0.0219334774,
-0.0088625709,
0.0578185879,
0.0383247584,
-0.0347041786,
0.0380287915,
0.0812498853,
-0.0421975777,
-0.0304319263,
0.0166633725,
0.0087696388,
-0.0324845575,
-0.0516995564,
-0.0394175723,
-0.0145187909,
0.0573096313,
-0.0232208818,
-0.0330438949,
-0.0070983353,
0.0270922501,
-0.0084475968,
-0.0272135083,
0.0068864846,
0.0128319971,
-0.0296429135,
0.0442366302,
-0.0214791577,
-0.0807007402,
0.0422402211,
-0.0264076013,
0.0252726488,
-0.0280002505,
-0.0364725403,
-0.0682057738,
0.0383500904,
0.0022708105,
-0.0090670027,
-0.0186331403,
-0.0217106249,
-0.067320548,
-0.0329258777,
0.0354865119,
-0.0272170734,
0.0881076008,
-0.0860458463,
0.0113261351,
-0.0137077821,
-0.02091695,
-0.0253403634,
0.0079917619,
-0.0291950181,
0.0175425168,
-0.0197429825,
-0.0312188435,
-0.0336171649,
-0.0310195889,
0.000090178,
0.0335514434,
-0.0161020234,
-0.0121309906,
-0.0260456428,
0.0157327428,
0.0424262248,
0.0499351546,
0.0475257784,
-0.0388149098,
0.010610871,
0.053003557,
0.006099402,
-0.0383356214,
-0.051827509,
0.0013712324,
0.0357969925,
-0.0861010104,
-0.0008345522,
0.0044787335,
0.0577303581,
-0.0664716437,
-0.0206256397,
0.1029471681,
0.0265251528,
-0.0238440856,
0.0333385058,
-0.0506227314,
0.0398986191,
0.0451450236,
0.0415030308,
-0.0691246018,
-0.0289359391,
0.0317138471,
0.0256699659,
-0.0104381191,
-0.0099889319,
-0.0351213254,
-0.1016863585,
0.0570716411,
0.0278918631,
-0.0019682529,
-0.026144173,
-0.0188404135,
0.0207236893,
-0.0315882303,
0.0550374277,
0.0183833335,
-0.0215417892,
-0.0120566348,
-0.0215342864,
-0.0343569182,
-0.0441646352,
-0.0148334801,
-0.0230489112,
0.0684938505,
0.0516511761,
0.0073940293,
0.0089975875,
0.0070801466,
0.0906095579,
0.0426495895,
0.0068870648,
-0.0378339253,
0.0248273071,
0.0153744025,
0.0058890092,
0.031701792,
0.0330196545,
0.0113276439,
-0.0434906706,
0.0187333021,
0.0781060755,
-0.0226933695,
0.0127244657,
-0.0171394534,
-0.0217383411,
-0.0151016135,
0.0381142795,
0.0528986752,
-0.019279426,
-0.0060278298,
-0.0693583339,
-0.0429556556,
-0.0278622042,
-0.0230521914,
-0.0179415718,
-0.0415309407,
0.0158516336,
-0.0489649214,
-0.0189025979,
0.0324039422,
-0.0174198616,
0.0396153182,
0.0090788528,
-0.0043004397,
-0.0142545374,
-0.0282384977,
0.022881832,
-0.0696228221,
0.0251980461,
-0.053034991,
-0.0088608423,
0.0306991078,
-0.0180688202,
0.0050473916,
-0.0129572945,
-0.0836441964,
-0.087839663,
-0.0088782003,
0.0645394027,
0.0200563259,
0.0740700737,
-0.0012313445,
-0.0817605704,
0.0100980476,
0.0192646291,
0.0026817315,
0.0491681136,
0.0399458706,
0.0119231027,
-0.0008011314,
0.0533282943,
-0.049961634,
-0.0120476447,
0.0604546331,
0.0406906046,
-0.0284340698,
-0.0652421042,
0.0160522088,
0.0335526057,
0.0024372917,
0.0102961911,
-0.0007574018,
-0.0210170075,
0.0641678497,
-0.0405133516,
-0.020773394,
-0.0360699929,
0.042886667,
0.0092751393,
-0.0113252886,
-0.0170216542,
0.0145413242,
-0.040441718,
0.0432792567,
-0.0324406773,
0.0592729747,
-0.0111394459,
-0.0130149797,
0.036370419,
0.0162109956,
0.0068915826,
0.0366535038,
0.0079874946,
0.0275251139,
0.0148426015,
0.0237861257,
0.0093362629,
0.0122118965,
-0.0460360534,
0.0310991742,
-0.0506902672,
-0.0428186506,
-0.0403367691,
0.0490013249,
0.0796170905,
0.022028558,
0.0513414629,
-0.0185994338,
-0.0424097553,
-0.0182766728,
0.0399821661,
0.0203159042,
0.0021955927,
0.0112313107,
0.0076013058,
-0.0131922252,
0.0141195217,
0.0370627493,
0.0034784856,
0.0961571187,
-0.0076360521,
-0.0030027176,
-0.0434175953,
-0.0518955365,
0.0219143871,
-0.0398040563,
-0.0281886775,
-0.0287004169,
-0.0367708504,
-0.0748860762,
0.0104940301,
0.0301290713,
-0.0260767844,
-0.0113847461,
0.0011421072,
0.0341052078,
0.0086764134,
0.015458839,
-0.012644303,
-0.0219436865,
0.0229932629,
-0.0378227048,
-0.0032726894,
-5.403441168e-33,
-0.0314855874,
-0.0256150439,
0.0461825542,
-0.0009092993,
-0.0365166217,
-0.0295883138,
-0.0203162525,
0.003447576,
0.020440964,
-0.0031431061,
-0.0191283524,
0.0106713576,
0.0092110019,
-0.0088283811,
-0.0054987543,
0.0055477694,
0.0594599433,
0.0383965857,
-0.0295217633,
-0.0196443647,
-0.0209671017,
0.0363803208,
0.0841996297,
-0.0485286713,
0.0129678585,
0.0286798645,
-0.0390649587,
0.0471062064,
-0.0402057804,
0.0582520254,
0.0081781372,
-0.0064785196,
-0.0006241339,
-0.046229586,
-0.0585938953,
-0.0371352173,
-0.0310016759,
-0.0037594931,
0.0163818169,
0.0463077128,
-0.0114844134,
-0.0692835674,
0.0481712073,
0.0101120826,
-0.0286783837,
-0.038915731,
0.0175835639,
-0.0601690114,
0.0124243572,
0.0028928807,
-0.0720377639,
0.05210476,
0.0004564331,
-0.0084431628,
0.0207005795,
-0.0067331623,
0.0119938301,
0.0083110407,
-0.0240141135,
0.0055265795,
0.0667645335,
0.0668895021,
0.0843725726,
-0.0033620645,
-0.019121388,
0.0265615061,
0.0015383464,
0.0054240921,
0.0107625006,
-0.0147118475,
0.0001998466,
0.0447924435,
0.0341703817,
0.0425737649,
-0.0048725246,
0.0076702051,
-0.0681430325,
0.0338740274,
-0.0157079622,
0.0360801592,
-0.0277682077,
0.0515293553,
0.0296835862,
0.0351570621,
-0.0377163962,
0.0246362202,
-0.0303512942,
-0.0359998085,
0.0212353524,
-0.00969938,
-0.0247901846,
-0.0129928216,
0.0120393885,
-0.0537417009,
-0.0384863354,
-0.0078598121,
-0.0107994564,
0.0557210445,
-0.0030227636,
0.0097188875,
0.0000249879,
-0.01060565,
0.0032693984,
-0.0112849325,
0.0240430329,
-0.0240622498,
0.0360244475,
0.052570004,
-0.0637320876,
0.0235663,
-0.019786587,
0.0215218253,
0.0092207873,
0.0522812009,
-0.0049779485,
-0.0183461234,
-0.0020025768,
0.0559963696,
0.0409782007,
-0.0155450273,
-0.0099714845,
0.0359552801,
0.0192893818,
0.0250648782,
-0.0211112741,
0.0087219989,
-0.0188002232,
0.0267086178,
0.0323294662,
-0.0259757526,
-0.0192104466,
0.0039875335,
2.541e-7,
0.0602447726,
0.0492668636,
0.0194632914,
0.0353427492,
0.0066715628,
0.0211678594,
-0.047066208,
0.001202072,
0.0237690583,
-0.01169015,
0.0221650936,
0.0181987658,
0.062362764,
0.0014597476,
-0.0687097982,
0.0073602991,
-0.0287072044,
0.0228877775,
-0.0299689658,
-0.0310584903,
0.0112946946,
0.0930417255,
0.015291878,
-0.0161522161,
-0.0278483331,
-0.0228119064,
0.0400606804,
-0.0661640242,
-0.0433330275,
0.0567300953,
0.0386172421,
0.0169277564,
0.0009223985,
-0.026604509,
-0.0365199968,
0.0088013737,
-0.0257363636,
0.0873228982,
-0.003100794,
0.0139216129,
-0.0033496933,
-0.0024241221,
-0.0014280467,
-0.0118266307,
0.04055053,
-0.0231630933,
-0.0104562212,
-0.0486398935,
-0.0061541046,
-0.0038599961,
0.0188502185,
-0.0470893979,
-0.0063968762,
0.0322277993,
0.0354091525,
0.0191284511,
-0.0595637597,
-0.0394863933,
-0.0304250959,
0.0035343852,
-0.0212966204,
-0.0665609613,
-0.0198310092,
0.0142803742,
0.0111773359,
-0.0724920183,
-0.013163981,
2.589963259e-34,
0.0546525121,
-0.018789554,
0.01869094,
0.0750483349,
0.0519712232,
-0.0135533772,
-0.0250028856,
0.0227952953,
-0.0012960789,
-0.0627267286,
-0.0138093447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13169v2 | A Pretrainer's Guide to Training Data: Measuring the Effects of Data Age, Domain Coverage, Quality, & Toxicity | 2023-05-22T15:57:53 | 2023-11-13T14:50:06 | Shayne Longpre, Gregory Yauney, Emily Reif, Katherine Lee, Adam Roberts, Barret Zoph, Denny Zhou, Jason Wei, Kevin Robinson, David Mimno, Daphne Ippolito | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretraining is the preliminary and fundamental step in developing capable
language models (LM). Despite this, pretraining data design is critically
under-documented and often guided by empirically unsupported intuitions. To
address this, we pretrain 28 1.5B parameter decoder-only models, training on
data curated (1) at different times, (2) with varying toxicity and quality
filters, and (3) with different domain compositions. First, we quantify the
effect of pretraining data age. A temporal shift between evaluation data and
pretraining data leads to performance degradation, which is not overcome by
finetuning. Second, we explore the effect of quality and toxicity filters,
showing a trade-off between performance on standard benchmarks and risk of
toxic generations. Our findings indicate there does not exist a
one-size-fits-all solution to filtering training data. We also find that the
effects of different types of filtering are not predictable from text domain
characteristics. Lastly, we empirically validate that the inclusion of
heterogeneous data sources, like books and web, is broadly beneficial and
warrants greater prioritization. These findings constitute the largest set of
experiments to validate, quantify, and expose many undocumented intuitions
about text pretraining, which we hope will help support more informed
data-centric decisions in LM development. | [
0.0090577574,
0.0880381986,
-0.0158416051,
-0.0159819946,
-0.0011993335,
0.0171211753,
0.0231197048,
0.008304107,
-0.0227507632,
-0.0617431737,
-0.0387181342,
-0.035359066,
0.0130236177,
0.0283005498,
0.0148048149,
-0.0419391431,
0.0527178459,
-0.0309116412,
-0.0086278254,
-0.0076659438,
-0.0157385226,
0.014958269,
-0.0072921827,
0.0404533148,
0.005215426,
-0.0157140382,
0.0084793651,
-0.0026090071,
-0.0339297876,
-0.0483835228,
0.0413643681,
0.0769028217,
0.0358633734,
0.0050945375,
0.0000023326,
-0.043938756,
-0.0031066502,
-0.0058637653,
-0.0558748469,
0.039006073,
0.0590638109,
-0.0250613559,
-0.0001403139,
0.039925009,
-0.0454266295,
-0.0611307658,
0.0239040889,
-0.0014002405,
0.0506056696,
0.0707607046,
-0.0129780276,
-0.0069218907,
0.0377796851,
-0.0263972972,
-0.0191442408,
-0.0305159166,
0.0163000375,
0.0069484166,
0.0035159278,
-0.0018332778,
-0.0360580236,
0.0486758538,
0.0169877671,
0.0332986489,
-0.0037579143,
0.0259216279,
0.0017854068,
-0.0428153872,
0.0003216709,
0.0488234498,
-0.0047715427,
-0.0370417684,
-0.0338899083,
-0.0043151835,
-0.0310728196,
-0.019923415,
0.0180261414,
0.0327431597,
-0.0008817026,
0.0455301143,
0.0114870872,
0.0202300828,
0.0460045934,
-0.0102011785,
-0.0318839401,
0.0423350744,
0.0025046491,
-0.0513263494,
0.0271094572,
0.0395656154,
-0.0099287778,
-0.031026544,
-0.0112376884,
-0.0410440192,
0.0282928962,
0.0193846673,
-0.0805044323,
-0.0670718774,
-0.0041972003,
-0.0234008264,
0.0096512353,
0.0311661996,
-0.0255064331,
0.0138476212,
0.0122450516,
-0.021493338,
0.0350645036,
0.0126891211,
-0.0401002765,
0.0168666374,
-0.0269880518,
-0.002528839,
-0.0366060399,
0.0199803077,
-0.0137376031,
0.0016472691,
-0.0207032729,
0.0006835265,
0.020172745,
-0.0564650521,
0.0146226529,
0.0004374061,
-0.0382463112,
0.0041994662,
-0.0168096665,
-0.0029217892,
-0.0168644395,
0.047673475,
-0.016391227,
-0.1085153967,
0.002813261,
-0.0135687431,
-0.0052739093,
-0.0524776615,
0.0257562157,
0.0485494062,
-0.0233534593,
-0.0386959016,
-0.0943244398,
-0.0050876047,
-0.0059087342,
-0.0524510592,
0.0135799795,
-0.0162524823,
0.0182631332,
0.0356159061,
0.0288245641,
-0.0714809671,
-0.0266874768,
0.0003901341,
-0.0537192263,
0.0579676032,
-0.0336077958,
0.0351208337,
-0.0051692701,
-0.0092587378,
0.0069350759,
0.1080333814,
0.0251528826,
-0.0299525876,
0.0253856797,
-0.0369627289,
-0.01601661,
0.0503040999,
0.0317415223,
0.0201051086,
0.0062918756,
0.0022527552,
-0.0195156094,
-0.0276097879,
0.0350712501,
0.0136891929,
-0.0448984243,
-0.0087544052,
0.0789037272,
0.0092205154,
0.0313349254,
0.0247393139,
0.0286494009,
0.0176427513,
0.0328554511,
0.0049648392,
-0.0372675285,
-0.0474039763,
-0.0227309223,
0.0014356159,
-0.0142893186,
0.0342172384,
-0.0410903841,
-0.0475988574,
-0.0121696331,
-0.0171374846,
0.0301698744,
-0.0086605158,
0.056904953,
0.0487589985,
-0.0672500059,
0.0497506894,
0.0280428138,
-0.0754398108,
0.0177878309,
-0.0063350443,
0.0088266097,
0.0534769557,
0.0552397631,
-0.0038273598,
-0.0042751115,
0.0063503915,
0.0578726307,
-0.0127833197,
0.0652592555,
0.0013217153,
0.0693522617,
-0.0668975711,
-0.0429147668,
0.0095934104,
0.0369843915,
0.0045787762,
0.020959517,
0.0213927906,
0.0027460549,
-0.0631770566,
-0.0566394441,
0.058560513,
-0.0361577235,
-0.0303052012,
-0.0195976924,
-0.0061040241,
0.0229058452,
-0.0079833139,
-0.0402760692,
0.0089186877,
0.0303171687,
-0.0139606092,
0.0287465714,
0.003060393,
-0.0606205128,
-0.0100753335,
0.0017127265,
-0.0250198133,
0.0056285537,
0.0551575087,
-0.0281206444,
-0.0108882356,
0.0140166208,
-0.0070967786,
0.0380843729,
-0.0233924091,
0.0563018806,
-0.031637419,
0.001071967,
-0.0213915184,
0.0364630111,
0.0040280712,
-0.0105694178,
-0.016216768,
-0.0067177741,
0.0304199457,
-0.0132674882,
-0.0437298492,
0.0015795371,
-0.0309238248,
0.0413372777,
0.035551127,
0.0201674011,
-0.0228408054,
0.0229533762,
-0.0412711948,
-0.0137899099,
-0.0440123007,
0.0184176378,
-0.0041550994,
-0.026231626,
-0.0275133681,
-0.0083231507,
0.0012590323,
-0.027483847,
-0.0215553734,
0.0272939447,
-0.0121726738,
-0.0083315969,
0.0118212989,
-0.0464374237,
-0.0207271446,
-0.0010727707,
0.0734177828,
-0.0076945839,
-0.0252464227,
-0.0323084369,
0.0877802148,
0.0226522014,
0.0405004174,
-0.0071625551,
-0.0405184589,
0.0295700654,
0.0108022336,
0.0220942926,
0.0349600688,
-0.0033662689,
0.0206961296,
0.0518837199,
0.0134542864,
-0.0523657687,
0.0043120999,
-0.0297092684,
-0.0607518591,
-0.0570732877,
-0.0160688199,
0.0294590294,
0.0660723671,
-0.0129318498,
-0.0141589614,
-0.0842738375,
0.0207252111,
-0.054294996,
-0.0195170548,
-0.0258606654,
-0.0175921228,
0.0010621663,
0.0453154556,
-0.0309964642,
-0.0689990371,
0.0578400567,
-0.0153132388,
-0.0081454264,
-0.0588766411,
-0.0038305784,
-0.0125094326,
0.0287031215,
-0.0005941179,
-0.0050866571,
0.0706712529,
-0.0197569821,
-0.0585437864,
0.0509171709,
0.047249604,
-0.0250322558,
0.0370976217,
-0.0446162038,
0.0220841505,
0.0055837184,
-0.0429366864,
-0.0454863124,
-0.0553972498,
-0.004647071,
-0.0175176486,
0.0471272133,
0.0190736577,
-0.028759947,
0.0093170842,
-0.0342253596,
0.044355873,
0.0054641222,
-0.0092077339,
0.0067230794,
0.0063566174,
0.0116678197,
-0.03328906,
0.0046346816,
-0.0450176969,
0.0128217693,
0.0119744362,
0.0223355182,
-0.0102419173,
-0.0486590043,
0.0441567451,
0.0676819086,
0.012619826,
-0.008729348,
0.0360193588,
0.0313532464,
-0.0479355231,
0.0044229035,
0.0961396545,
0.028195763,
-0.040965911,
0.0202409644,
0.0259129573,
0.0336739495,
-0.0024712901,
-0.0163422711,
-0.0885900781,
-0.0279887728,
0.0087032076,
0.0527665652,
-0.0027709042,
-0.0039348942,
-0.0139805591,
-0.1119616032,
0.0161361583,
0.027406523,
-0.0141529106,
0.0009254731,
-0.0450059325,
-0.0500945114,
-0.0405058861,
0.0465678498,
0.0268515497,
-0.0330736227,
0.0083577177,
0.0551621951,
-0.0372214764,
-0.1249600053,
0.0255477428,
-0.0451055989,
0.0446559563,
0.068801932,
-0.0030353349,
-0.0118484991,
-0.0098806964,
0.0223726053,
-0.0407597981,
-0.0048503387,
-0.0081099467,
0.0830071718,
-0.0115432786,
-0.0132089546,
0.0107534556,
0.020021636,
-0.0371736996,
0.0046646758,
-0.0084038842,
0.0270056482,
-0.0035162515,
-0.0362433717,
-0.0165864415,
-0.0092852404,
-0.0083221355,
0.0947397351,
0.0200245846,
-0.0549314618,
-0.0103301816,
-0.0198053718,
0.0448066033,
-0.0716254711,
-0.0274989679,
0.0488222055,
-0.0415392332,
-0.0513033345,
-0.050075084,
-0.0430368893,
0.0223599058,
0.0018143837,
0.0229960382,
0.0011962926,
0.0079096816,
-0.0129911443,
-0.0290651135,
0.0719475746,
-0.0112734297,
0.0085657621,
-0.1020948812,
-0.040457543,
0.016628582,
-0.0068227663,
-0.0156142414,
0.0177915394,
-0.0570106916,
-0.0603008196,
0.0477703325,
0.0393887572,
0.0244346671,
0.0374290384,
-0.0082584675,
-0.0627415702,
0.0344209559,
0.0320360251,
-0.0504967123,
0.0292472206,
0.0748585165,
-0.0549004041,
0.0050506964,
0.0067190467,
-0.0371156037,
0.0230981726,
0.0119581018,
-0.0022923083,
-0.0022872302,
0.0076841661,
0.0304268524,
-0.0017255543,
0.052647084,
-0.0180349424,
-0.0282893237,
-0.0402242169,
0.0209543835,
-0.0155499615,
0.0097401831,
-0.0470065102,
-0.0117846131,
0.0511259921,
0.0352458656,
-0.0288111474,
0.032336019,
-0.0139194084,
0.0765392929,
-0.0298349783,
0.0399058461,
-0.0062881862,
0.0447072424,
0.0621375628,
0.0148553941,
-0.0128526483,
-0.0000593202,
-0.0255340803,
0.0017829326,
-0.0310019162,
0.0228219591,
-0.0037065616,
0.0343121849,
0.0127298599,
0.0211048499,
-0.0484122112,
-0.0068870038,
-0.039330475,
-0.0574377105,
0.040388763,
-0.0386065915,
0.0875889808,
-0.027574297,
0.0375605114,
-0.0448305421,
0.0090541514,
0.0146824308,
0.0011989869,
0.0005435346,
0.0050341021,
-0.0530238412,
-0.0016628162,
0.1059795842,
0.0593887791,
0.0530790314,
0.0072184918,
0.0071896673,
0.005856025,
-0.0139094545,
0.0166734084,
0.032936424,
-0.0389078595,
-0.0123399673,
-0.0586856566,
-0.0480770804,
-0.0091592614,
-0.0217837393,
0.0162800122,
-0.0009592522,
0.0341641977,
0.0399667397,
-0.052258838,
0.005892687,
-0.0398057103,
-0.0382103212,
0.007609115,
-0.0020270457,
-0.0477745458,
-7.069450209e-33,
0.0073829866,
0.0601289906,
0.0150776133,
-0.0404519998,
-0.0105658229,
0.0029212234,
-0.0170210358,
0.0081822872,
-0.0486685745,
-0.0080435174,
0.0101570878,
0.0139496159,
0.0199325159,
0.0317501761,
-0.0285764784,
-0.0127320895,
0.0845200196,
-0.0198984873,
-0.0181760266,
-0.0273302533,
0.0039038712,
0.0471582599,
0.0490850955,
-0.0632908493,
-0.0015704187,
-0.0104131587,
-0.0166987926,
-0.0276375134,
0.0199454483,
0.054245986,
-0.0123185907,
0.062785916,
0.0084750429,
-0.0468370281,
-0.0252575036,
-0.0225211103,
-0.096156016,
-0.0017568463,
0.0199467987,
0.0401953012,
0.0247520134,
-0.0148343127,
0.0212349389,
0.0275702663,
-0.0238399711,
-0.0122674126,
0.0156854074,
-0.023033699,
-0.0244704001,
-0.0293377545,
-0.0320081562,
0.0350364782,
-0.0146413045,
-0.0212336723,
0.0440875106,
0.0621265881,
0.0062650922,
0.0298012532,
-0.0576815046,
0.0369501486,
0.0486811511,
0.0394693352,
0.058934845,
0.0024579421,
0.018507503,
0.0596378893,
0.0077181919,
0.0283741597,
0.0090010865,
0.0125627331,
0.0857902318,
0.0316346064,
0.0022473584,
0.0112305693,
0.059102755,
-0.0582249686,
-0.0539651476,
0.0212196931,
-0.0218552556,
0.0090126051,
-0.013509891,
0.0049370038,
-0.0454448499,
-0.0642449483,
-0.0517342053,
-0.0038005842,
-0.0130999777,
-0.010922865,
0.0450437106,
0.0175831206,
-0.0080326516,
-0.019680934,
0.0330485851,
-0.0231576897,
-0.0326038487,
0.0178169161,
-0.0379742831,
0.0211302452,
-0.0205731634,
0.0416314527,
-0.0512078628,
-0.041610308,
0.0417266116,
-0.0253545158,
0.0158282127,
-0.0088947369,
0.025103204,
0.0443739146,
-0.0627185032,
-0.019063564,
-0.0176756624,
0.0270873643,
0.044400841,
0.0498315766,
0.0459948108,
0.050930202,
0.000676566,
0.0530788116,
0.0253368989,
-0.0048141945,
-0.0479419082,
-0.009355613,
0.0213814825,
0.0178897064,
0.0272842683,
-0.0457270406,
-0.025077235,
0.0105917417,
0.1004517674,
-0.0559891984,
-0.0366507247,
0.0083805611,
2.88e-7,
0.0730091259,
0.0510778055,
0.0162624456,
0.0211251453,
-0.0059352182,
0.0373587906,
-0.0216259193,
0.0137637137,
-0.0073766727,
0.0215705633,
-0.0175401382,
-0.0033412767,
0.0756135583,
0.0483061932,
-0.0652066916,
-0.0526701212,
-0.0475057065,
0.0156096201,
-0.0553111807,
-0.0154740233,
0.0313911028,
0.0895325169,
-0.0110529447,
-0.0091223577,
0.0010977525,
-0.0422621928,
0.053672228,
-0.0597911254,
0.0052723922,
0.0456978455,
0.0148399286,
0.0314162038,
0.0073902183,
0.0314766541,
-0.0586266331,
0.0062267873,
-0.0011150938,
0.0376965478,
-0.0006824312,
-0.0557601638,
0.0065663373,
0.0088405916,
-0.0534221902,
-0.0087382011,
0.0740253255,
-0.0413338244,
-0.0348731615,
0.0159446318,
-0.0535504892,
0.0271087289,
0.0105325626,
-0.0300242566,
-0.0047143176,
0.0283572227,
0.039226409,
0.010278549,
-0.0354101956,
-0.0506310575,
-0.0024800834,
0.0053965682,
-0.0033785219,
-0.060576912,
-0.0353678167,
0.0206566565,
0.0451664813,
-0.0647351444,
0.0323214792,
2.773710016e-34,
0.0530866235,
-0.0367195942,
0.0354080088,
0.0074710497,
0.0262416191,
-0.0271346066,
0.0372244269,
0.0112968246,
-0.0295023844,
-0.0496654883,
0.0127883554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13168v2 | LLMs for Knowledge Graph Construction and Reasoning: Recent Capabilities and Future Opportunities | 2023-05-22T15:56:44 | 2024-02-22T10:15:25 | Yuqi Zhu, Xiaohan Wang, Jing Chen, Shuofei Qiao, Yixin Ou, Yunzhi Yao, Shumin Deng, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG | This paper presents an exhaustive quantitative and qualitative evaluation of
Large Language Models (LLMs) for Knowledge Graph (KG) construction and
reasoning. We engage in experiments across eight diverse datasets, focusing on
four representative tasks encompassing entity and relation extraction, event
extraction, link prediction, and question-answering, thereby thoroughly
exploring LLMs' performance in the domain of construction and inference.
Empirically, our findings suggest that LLMs, represented by GPT-4, are more
suited as inference assistants rather than few-shot information extractors.
Specifically, while GPT-4 exhibits good performance in tasks related to KG
construction, it excels further in reasoning tasks, surpassing fine-tuned
models in certain cases. Moreover, our investigation extends to the potential
generalization ability of LLMs for information extraction, leading to the
proposition of a Virtual Knowledge Extraction task and the development of the
corresponding VINE dataset. Based on these empirical findings, we further
propose AutoKG, a multi-agent-based approach employing LLMs and external
sources for KG construction and reasoning. We anticipate that this research can
provide invaluable insights for future undertakings in the field of knowledge
graphs. The code and datasets are in https://github.com/zjunlp/AutoKG. | [
0.0520238914,
0.0255682524,
-0.0085195154,
0.0805146843,
-0.0475735702,
0.0234746356,
-0.0160957072,
-0.007872426,
0.0938273743,
-0.0240043998,
0.0044810926,
0.0208820086,
-0.0646968782,
0.0056098006,
0.0236291569,
0.0021029313,
0.0209931284,
-0.0074076988,
0.0223572198,
-0.0136690168,
0.0003404208,
0.0423410311,
-0.0037208386,
-0.006466323,
-0.0172830187,
0.0051516029,
0.0021582767,
-0.0291632302,
0.0366135389,
-0.0492598303,
-0.0233293697,
-0.0074106501,
0.0144493598,
0.0157834981,
0.000001743,
-0.0466443263,
-0.0003083151,
0.0001882687,
-0.0619528703,
-0.0153642716,
-0.0299963392,
-0.0278617628,
0.0333955325,
-0.0117858304,
-0.0701961666,
-0.0662899688,
-0.0027717361,
0.0220825765,
0.0122384401,
0.0655211508,
-0.0131874401,
-0.0528152585,
0.0160900913,
-0.0198480599,
0.0009974353,
-0.0498348922,
0.0566666611,
0.0295082666,
0.0243924074,
0.0122427372,
0.0075008217,
0.0383002199,
0.0368101895,
0.0039644809,
0.0167255625,
0.063912563,
-0.0375806727,
-0.0069718855,
-0.0090530263,
0.1161449552,
0.0306199845,
0.0124422302,
0.0212408919,
0.0108275544,
-0.0052008224,
0.0411938913,
-0.0340680256,
0.0370985568,
-0.0428461358,
0.0121365348,
0.0182205867,
-0.0422142446,
0.0487064086,
0.0169376433,
-0.0253336076,
0.076809518,
0.0086273765,
-0.0205293614,
0.0333947763,
0.0163019206,
-0.0446836464,
-0.06210991,
-0.0117535489,
0.0669931993,
-0.0008878224,
0.0547202267,
-0.0065850881,
0.0265173651,
0.0057269013,
-0.0267502796,
-0.0061999462,
0.0052335928,
0.0181591064,
0.0829038471,
-0.0468499102,
0.0425417274,
-0.0288717747,
0.028467821,
-0.019108044,
-0.0537734032,
-0.0709780231,
0.0121576339,
-0.0085705277,
0.0637756661,
-0.0079660676,
-0.0233835578,
-0.0193482451,
0.060065046,
0.0061750761,
0.0316867381,
0.0319139771,
-0.0003189149,
0.0136411907,
-0.0317889601,
-0.0588039011,
0.0232796576,
-0.0524287596,
0.0188433137,
-0.0197327696,
-0.0277620982,
-0.0238619316,
0.011222356,
0.0397652872,
-0.0498607308,
0.0205280744,
0.0829418302,
0.0299871173,
-0.0194942299,
-0.0325523242,
-0.0416228957,
0.0210510325,
-0.0845101699,
0.0177102182,
-0.0518136658,
0.0696122572,
0.034478616,
-0.0389379002,
-0.0260968935,
0.0409789532,
-0.0160009675,
-0.0664211959,
0.0504472256,
-0.0285319816,
0.0321208239,
-0.0065676132,
-0.0045033842,
-0.0384329259,
0.0521396548,
0.0403957926,
0.0313280672,
0.0631886199,
0.020142341,
-0.0285008401,
0.0447277911,
0.0149084376,
0.0027630674,
0.0452003926,
0.047655385,
-0.028482426,
-0.0028534194,
-0.0043314262,
0.0623945519,
-0.0228271261,
-0.0137235215,
0.0469074696,
0.0261896923,
0.0061260541,
-0.0058575748,
0.0524496324,
-0.0144479731,
0.0127718356,
-0.0151517177,
-0.0473853573,
0.0196115151,
-0.0467799865,
0.0310609024,
-0.0095574409,
0.0239800662,
-0.0103109665,
-0.022388503,
-0.0184189361,
-0.0081234863,
0.0371883027,
0.029437108,
0.0835925192,
0.0066585117,
-0.0287983157,
0.0258176755,
0.041928038,
-0.0153005095,
-0.0042540217,
-0.032067854,
0.0411984883,
0.0443650819,
0.0596911088,
-0.0013613824,
-0.0340868123,
0.0267139729,
0.0023759566,
0.0045365328,
0.0329392925,
-0.0519235097,
-0.0045237248,
-0.0397083797,
-0.0389968455,
-0.0112113981,
-0.0204318985,
0.0047145942,
0.0647650436,
0.0259023663,
0.0176188778,
-0.0587506704,
0.0011832552,
0.0199277066,
-0.0350919366,
-0.025798928,
-0.0114315562,
0.0004699916,
0.0252220035,
0.0238533895,
-0.0020332448,
0.0094601195,
0.0500668287,
-0.0270507745,
-0.0291581154,
0.0055385726,
0.0150660435,
-0.079539448,
0.0533034988,
0.0012898311,
-0.0168313961,
-0.012030879,
-0.0493133441,
-0.0171780381,
0.0201313291,
0.0164431185,
0.0653064251,
-0.0263977777,
-0.0240908023,
0.0263850205,
-0.0311890952,
-0.0006882112,
0.0932712704,
0.0124526564,
-0.0221718624,
0.0214672182,
0.0197372865,
-0.0268667303,
-0.0123287737,
-0.0000249441,
0.0185273327,
0.0246101264,
-0.0068900329,
0.0208058022,
-0.0151815237,
-0.0639917329,
-0.0144802788,
-0.1038757414,
0.0540065095,
-0.0060320203,
0.033371184,
0.0137840537,
0.005616318,
-0.0033283059,
0.012147136,
-0.0180006418,
0.0355994478,
-0.0017853748,
0.0231612958,
0.0337456279,
0.0168142077,
0.0109559195,
-0.0350317173,
-0.0098106833,
-0.0309197959,
0.0369355045,
0.0372206233,
-0.0164705198,
-0.007354355,
0.0404042713,
-0.0562823527,
0.0147577329,
-0.0354792513,
-0.0065967715,
-0.0125299934,
-0.0483676158,
0.0374146402,
0.058467444,
-0.0373909958,
0.032909058,
0.0170054641,
-0.0123719042,
-0.0403029136,
0.0296927672,
-0.059472613,
-0.0022711998,
-0.054863926,
0.0033393109,
-0.0198726375,
0.0117367823,
0.008874272,
-0.0048395325,
-0.0432164408,
0.0224009175,
0.0072365813,
0.037795309,
0.0224099681,
0.0179586224,
0.0120024448,
0.0212237407,
-0.0326653756,
-0.004797962,
0.0786551237,
0.0004354194,
-0.0012975887,
-0.0036639441,
-0.0114304665,
-0.0605514459,
0.09465947,
0.0106228311,
-0.0161928385,
-0.0179280099,
0.0343062878,
-0.0304419696,
0.0098478859,
0.0162438639,
-0.0182444621,
0.0372582525,
-0.0573602021,
0.0288138967,
0.017057607,
-0.0056267078,
-0.0261768848,
-0.0321352407,
-0.0566493049,
0.0042372849,
-0.0054505318,
0.0113865314,
0.0148768974,
0.0169269908,
0.0075154416,
-0.0104873339,
-0.0161046926,
0.001665124,
-0.0333329476,
0.0418612137,
0.0791980028,
-0.020335786,
0.0116190864,
-0.0170741845,
0.0375886597,
0.0486463271,
0.000783143,
-0.0132437339,
-0.0098187188,
0.0009188947,
-0.0252772756,
-0.0303282663,
-0.0020523497,
-0.006173369,
0.0578799695,
-0.0446486101,
0.0173285771,
0.1091002375,
0.0056112073,
-0.0159753039,
-0.0060895956,
0.0363369882,
0.0232192036,
0.0165143069,
0.0040598591,
-0.0863552094,
-0.0363845117,
-0.017092362,
0.0056387233,
0.0168559514,
-0.0670522004,
0.0005313986,
-0.1142225787,
0.0305261351,
0.005241727,
0.0082733585,
-0.0485926792,
-0.0384538807,
0.0212849025,
-0.0234800223,
-0.0560851507,
0.0166795757,
-0.0222287029,
0.0239078347,
0.0029027362,
-0.0100634787,
-0.0335184075,
0.0494581871,
-0.041320838,
0.0473504663,
0.0046631158,
0.0186257511,
0.0217105336,
-0.0036655432,
-0.0196994562,
-0.0193582997,
-0.0313412286,
-0.0133008752,
0.050249014,
-0.0160095803,
0.0042911023,
-0.0362281203,
0.030632304,
-0.0458518043,
0.00616549,
0.0511200652,
0.1045043096,
0.0014296036,
-0.071200259,
0.0048610489,
-0.0123424549,
-0.0350484438,
0.0757990032,
0.0088047236,
0.0367921144,
-0.0408424735,
0.0005562299,
-0.0198310576,
-0.037992347,
-0.022983741,
0.0100165671,
-0.0515551753,
0.0325477161,
-0.0446798913,
-0.0741663799,
0.0699478462,
0.0175679494,
-0.0008031846,
0.0213665478,
0.0541379862,
0.0047314516,
-0.0294059273,
0.0124256769,
-0.0390350446,
0.005937682,
0.0208421107,
-0.0377929099,
0.0286776107,
-0.0151065933,
-0.0135472054,
0.0259355903,
-0.0812275782,
-0.0765659511,
-0.0405678563,
0.023873996,
0.0238836017,
0.0727321431,
-0.0133817848,
0.0118329655,
0.0094324471,
-0.0008874044,
-0.0597249083,
-0.0040482231,
-0.002378402,
0.0103972703,
0.0263835154,
0.0544453748,
-0.0778033063,
0.0113865752,
0.0104340622,
0.0631904602,
-0.0826566443,
-0.0425877012,
-0.0015851503,
0.0495388173,
-0.0052671246,
0.0172729194,
0.0083394302,
-0.0499294139,
-0.0070046168,
-0.0371851176,
-0.0287446845,
-0.0353265628,
0.0086224396,
0.0070413952,
-0.0097454134,
-0.0068147611,
-0.0347770751,
0.024748534,
0.0312900916,
-0.0089346226,
-0.0344321728,
0.0144103281,
-0.0134668332,
0.0568353571,
-0.0414363071,
-0.0246971622,
0.0297206417,
0.0064048623,
0.0216832198,
-0.0436062366,
0.0359971859,
0.0295743756,
-0.0548933037,
-0.0159958191,
-0.0093211252,
-0.0677780658,
-0.0375367887,
0.0231763795,
0.0479483232,
0.0563061759,
0.0075289356,
0.0479885079,
-0.042519547,
-0.020199867,
0.0089672692,
0.0229202844,
0.0075502559,
-0.0059214677,
0.0549100563,
0.0268140342,
-0.042121198,
-0.005181795,
0.060472507,
0.0109428996,
0.0734474957,
0.0227164719,
-0.0360743888,
-0.0428770445,
-0.0413850173,
-0.0189628117,
0.002889144,
-0.0083291968,
0.0144220581,
-0.0707110614,
-0.071495831,
-0.0009494672,
-0.000652591,
-0.033842776,
-0.0132719334,
0.0129338289,
0.0505281389,
0.0441306569,
-0.0382972173,
-0.0560793355,
0.0187536571,
-0.0452560596,
0.0031205688,
0.0012903183,
-5.972547574e-33,
-0.0299317818,
-0.0135543346,
0.051261317,
0.0319128521,
-0.0405358821,
0.0064672385,
-0.0694201291,
-0.0271504819,
-0.0536390506,
0.0183394756,
0.0029436252,
-0.0025993264,
-0.0051094354,
0.0060370867,
0.0008116051,
-0.0267341211,
-0.0164647792,
-0.0069601364,
0.0195276812,
0.0318681486,
0.0217046477,
0.0127273714,
0.0281964298,
-0.0389448442,
0.0103954189,
-0.0320071168,
0.0493616574,
0.0305110719,
0.002543136,
0.0481732897,
-0.0253519397,
0.0233685076,
0.018260086,
-0.0062965788,
0.0322042741,
-0.0154434247,
-0.1139890105,
-0.0447614379,
0.0307766497,
-0.0142570809,
-0.0532080978,
-0.029378375,
0.0141512444,
-0.0055400124,
0.0425129533,
-0.0449312329,
0.0418148451,
-0.0107222693,
-0.0184178632,
-0.0510035045,
-0.0306232981,
0.0315136984,
0.0121498657,
-0.0029717358,
0.0243436284,
-0.0245286562,
0.0166631527,
0.017061891,
-0.0610091686,
0.0107003292,
-0.0087474762,
-0.0428598709,
0.0476845764,
-0.0139046246,
0.0183914974,
0.0422824733,
-0.005659237,
-0.0171344467,
-0.0719344094,
0.0270406324,
-0.0244903285,
0.0816271305,
-0.0184239075,
0.011189919,
-0.032786496,
-0.0075884229,
-0.0987793207,
0.0005928653,
0.0653382838,
0.0410289206,
-0.0028696819,
0.0020317207,
-0.0262795743,
-0.008788174,
-0.0190161709,
0.0020014206,
-0.0118375318,
-0.0422101244,
0.012932051,
-0.0209024362,
0.0109704789,
0.0033137572,
-0.00243451,
-0.0630353615,
-0.0067268754,
0.0496851653,
-0.0166150331,
0.0008463312,
-0.0082072448,
0.0391942672,
-0.0820637345,
-0.0006592014,
0.00563015,
-0.0194268879,
0.0013044007,
0.043004889,
0.0014969122,
-0.009728957,
-0.0081462469,
-0.0224501733,
-0.0696921498,
0.0014960798,
-0.0252155531,
-0.027702,
0.0194327589,
0.0652039573,
0.0019202122,
0.0118609564,
0.0496895462,
0.0207372233,
-0.0163657144,
0.0453721173,
0.0225200579,
-0.0123282159,
-0.0128615052,
-0.0101776812,
-0.0428574681,
0.0239120163,
-0.0301040877,
-0.054314442,
-0.0026913672,
0.0280485861,
2.564e-7,
0.0486772433,
0.0386604294,
0.0188965052,
0.0601195917,
0.0086434847,
0.0090160351,
-0.0148891155,
0.0047453251,
-0.0070541874,
-0.0340295024,
0.0187240094,
0.0658678636,
-0.001277648,
0.0664361715,
-0.0564380474,
0.010435666,
-0.0382590666,
-0.0715422556,
-0.0667006671,
-0.0062626945,
0.069204323,
0.045957379,
0.0601163767,
0.0133690927,
-0.0312780142,
-0.0827407688,
0.0467313305,
0.0156887174,
-0.0252599698,
0.0335156061,
0.0159281716,
0.0295829158,
-0.0318478756,
0.0614457093,
0.0280419644,
0.0315760151,
-0.0002549792,
0.0511860512,
-0.0057147788,
-0.0155867264,
0.0041539157,
-0.072886318,
0.0260229502,
-0.0552006066,
0.1166267395,
-0.0586415753,
-0.0243723635,
0.0426303707,
-0.0380130783,
-0.0151326265,
-0.0480796285,
-0.0044265804,
-0.0012404057,
0.0258606728,
0.0122819673,
-0.0270753615,
-0.0259467773,
-0.0800713524,
0.0294013079,
0.0101699531,
-0.0406090617,
-0.0623711124,
0.0028973136,
0.000972562,
-0.0029919823,
-0.0386808217,
0.0140421279,
2.188685763e-34,
0.0051098871,
0.012514702,
-0.0271232408,
0.0153206708,
0.0642578155,
-0.0203224216,
-0.039929308,
0.0048595648,
-0.0091680484,
-0.1115279198,
-0.0020825914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13160v2 | Can ChatGPT Defend its Belief in Truth? Evaluating LLM Reasoning via Debate | 2023-05-22T15:47:31 | 2023-10-10T17:34:15 | Boshi Wang, Xiang Yue, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have shown impressive
performance in complex reasoning tasks. However, it is difficult to know
whether the models are reasoning based on deep understandings of truth and
logic, or leveraging their memorized patterns in a relatively superficial way.
In this work, we explore testing LLMs' reasoning by engaging with them in a
debate-like conversation, where given a question, the LLM and the user need to
discuss to make the correct decision starting from opposing arguments. Upon
mitigating the Clever Hans effect, our task requires the LLM to not only
achieve the correct answer on its own, but also be able to hold and defend its
belief instead of blindly believing or getting misled by the user's (invalid)
arguments and critiques, thus testing in greater depth whether the LLM grasps
the essence of the reasoning required to solve the problem. Across a range of
complex reasoning benchmarks spanning math, commonsense, logic and BIG-Bench
tasks, we find that despite their impressive performance as reported in
existing work on generating correct step-by-step solutions in the beginning,
LLMs like ChatGPT cannot maintain their beliefs in truth for a significant
portion of examples when challenged by oftentimes absurdly invalid arguments.
Our work points to danger zones of model alignment, and also suggests more
careful treatments and interpretations of the recent findings that LLMs can
improve their responses based on feedback. | [
0.0212832354,
0.0427601151,
-0.0066401367,
0.0619101115,
-0.0696370974,
0.0102786515,
-0.031600032,
-0.035257116,
0.0096172951,
-0.0411721952,
-0.0213399157,
-0.0259819608,
-0.0130845131,
-0.0003233819,
0.0037120474,
-0.035765864,
0.0555401146,
-0.0228173677,
0.0507631861,
-0.0397426076,
0.0122570191,
-0.0131329773,
-0.0084762648,
0.0187822357,
-0.0250472985,
-0.0366579369,
-0.0250990074,
-0.0061952434,
0.0091897706,
-0.0377120189,
-0.0037628335,
0.031041421,
0.0161373392,
0.088913478,
0.0000019526,
-0.0261966158,
0.0059573813,
-0.0064539928,
-0.0693155602,
0.0133289406,
0.001729448,
0.041365888,
0.0019222274,
0.0166636053,
-0.0404318012,
0.0253412034,
0.0205864366,
0.0949996114,
0.0773075521,
0.0685844272,
0.0211617574,
-0.0307792593,
0.030700881,
-0.0116276955,
0.00496575,
-0.0378670096,
0.0003300964,
0.0696627274,
0.0042862748,
0.0381956697,
-0.0075314292,
0.0192343872,
0.0480720289,
0.0102810916,
-0.0628645793,
0.0153740477,
-0.087051563,
-0.0127346534,
0.0185180195,
0.0388892405,
0.0303739253,
-0.0427821502,
0.0020443986,
0.0097929155,
0.0153279155,
0.0221495107,
-0.05749337,
0.0312337875,
-0.0322807394,
-0.0026917686,
0.0207332447,
-0.0090015363,
0.02447097,
0.0115459152,
-0.0059229746,
0.0855237991,
-0.0139930882,
-0.0513025746,
0.0235481635,
-0.0017551919,
-0.0340944044,
-0.0650646314,
-0.0309183486,
0.0404048264,
-0.00814596,
0.0506247021,
-0.0158187207,
0.0542657971,
0.0359694138,
-0.0609210134,
0.0029894358,
0.0543450601,
-0.0091331592,
0.0573211052,
-0.0218580198,
0.0178826675,
-0.0268451162,
0.0363167189,
0.0301144049,
-0.0269781277,
-0.0332801677,
-0.0424594581,
-0.0289325118,
0.0262966491,
0.0147433793,
0.0178625882,
-0.0187571738,
0.003240685,
-0.0415686779,
0.0496572405,
-0.0158270001,
0.0025161074,
0.0137277916,
-0.0394133106,
-0.0939377621,
0.0450286791,
-0.0317895338,
0.0152353318,
0.0279072169,
-0.0701799244,
-0.0223895945,
0.0168026835,
-0.0416753106,
-0.0202232022,
0.0263291132,
0.0364067331,
-0.0099442517,
0.0315780006,
-0.028438108,
-0.0249665435,
-0.0204332098,
-0.088809073,
0.0190555025,
-0.0682079345,
0.0244010855,
0.0094285356,
-0.0199107081,
-0.0153381201,
0.0188156255,
0.0335481577,
-0.0019374621,
0.0688818395,
0.0101910736,
-0.0042856121,
0.0334855057,
0.0430257842,
-0.0734150335,
0.0365351737,
0.0091550015,
0.0045830831,
0.0084034288,
-0.0072283787,
0.020446714,
0.0111357812,
0.0207668338,
-0.0078927446,
0.0082598254,
0.0428326651,
-0.0298356507,
0.0372882895,
-0.017445175,
0.0385695919,
-0.0554192029,
-0.0347463675,
0.0703852773,
0.0622917041,
0.0053221942,
0.0161566567,
0.001311586,
-0.0400862657,
0.0398902968,
0.027404435,
-0.057170514,
0.0231113732,
-0.0391395949,
-0.0040693162,
0.0135914031,
0.0183945671,
-0.0127469618,
-0.0299349315,
-0.011718398,
0.0255011246,
0.0042304979,
0.0194365364,
0.0089044329,
-0.0316378549,
-0.0051580137,
0.0439060815,
0.0084497575,
-0.033539582,
-0.0381805561,
-0.064751707,
0.0359318629,
-0.0092782844,
0.0478050858,
-0.0030719431,
-0.0606351048,
-0.0090769771,
0.0370726101,
0.0528286062,
0.111792773,
0.0179161765,
-0.0312186759,
-0.0245635509,
-0.0125166494,
-0.0420557819,
0.0113063008,
0.0139363315,
0.0044206535,
0.0084585333,
0.0086283069,
-0.0088741034,
0.0355908573,
0.007569449,
-0.0143066905,
-0.0010664025,
-0.0487528481,
-0.022376826,
0.0329888389,
-0.0154224159,
0.0031474717,
0.0122990888,
0.0122720366,
0.0114914784,
-0.0353623331,
0.0557507053,
-0.0741581842,
-0.012933013,
0.0561065003,
-0.0486629717,
-0.0526492819,
0.0065115015,
-0.0435760319,
-0.0236436352,
0.0178608242,
-0.0127936155,
0.0060832794,
-0.0214154664,
0.0131276622,
0.0110820737,
-0.0373148285,
-0.0192956124,
0.0932944193,
0.0134875691,
0.0207456611,
-0.0270503648,
0.0228093155,
0.0349156708,
-0.0698057562,
-0.0102994535,
0.0115948608,
0.0087656435,
0.0079762209,
0.0300590713,
-0.0252101216,
-0.0590457506,
-0.0230023563,
-0.097017996,
0.0042831143,
-0.0061979895,
0.0396102183,
0.0190898236,
-0.0452970117,
0.001801535,
0.0055487202,
-0.070602566,
0.0104420101,
0.0467638671,
0.0046547363,
0.0447967984,
-0.0349321701,
0.0127532119,
-0.0204888843,
0.0184038952,
-0.0255341288,
-0.0134573467,
-0.0033882342,
0.0302923117,
-0.0335786156,
-0.0232577994,
-0.082246758,
0.0307179689,
-0.0232056156,
-0.0112620378,
0.0677043647,
0.0301407687,
0.0009878844,
0.0726510659,
0.0286789984,
0.0061560781,
0.0135832457,
-0.0181466863,
-0.0615079254,
0.0410830267,
-0.0048891176,
0.0121079618,
-0.0207721796,
-0.0214826092,
-0.0083626006,
0.066167146,
-0.0162540898,
0.0330845118,
-0.0526395813,
0.0524133705,
0.0025856039,
0.0128625538,
-0.0212582294,
-0.0271178521,
-0.0275387187,
0.0531984754,
-0.03138607,
-0.0261066519,
0.0499780774,
-0.0320751779,
0.0175839495,
-0.0439768247,
0.0089122113,
-0.0215922762,
0.0613356493,
-0.0073885527,
-0.0167517625,
-0.0058980617,
0.0204207692,
-0.027429942,
-0.0341455787,
0.0629049912,
-0.0563952997,
0.0638419911,
-0.0353576541,
-0.0006326595,
-0.0242004525,
-0.0527380221,
-0.0714186803,
-0.0092551028,
-0.0586904958,
-0.0092386017,
-0.0188701134,
-0.0113061201,
-0.0361892842,
-0.0302187447,
0.0386774354,
-0.0097165238,
0.0066675358,
-0.019425733,
-0.0041449331,
-0.0155449705,
0.0264108647,
0.0680658668,
0.0592856184,
-0.0239847153,
0.0336158797,
0.0876201689,
0.0106419381,
0.008830755,
-0.0257203802,
-0.0458560102,
-0.0146288704,
0.0213966817,
-0.0149855418,
-0.0031776775,
0.0730775967,
-0.0460163131,
-0.0053424309,
0.0935484171,
0.0338523947,
0.0414563902,
-0.0123567907,
-0.0800300613,
0.0474938676,
0.0079767816,
-0.0035552569,
-0.1084926501,
-0.0291476529,
0.027547339,
-0.0059234314,
-0.0336108729,
-0.0332859755,
-0.0174035709,
-0.11390239,
0.0230957773,
0.0248057358,
0.0095620742,
0.0157696232,
-0.0182830002,
0.019887777,
-0.0002288386,
0.0353596061,
0.0248308573,
0.0287023429,
0.0167043749,
0.0068889498,
0.0038468463,
0.0198812876,
0.0781697482,
-0.0006677773,
0.0496484153,
-0.0027142188,
0.0342910402,
0.0031066521,
-0.0791831538,
0.0615650229,
0.0366787873,
-0.0212142896,
-0.0072089015,
-0.0261032451,
-0.0114013143,
0.0104271648,
-0.0385957249,
0.0244438425,
-0.0125505673,
-0.0385818258,
0.0360561907,
0.0783337057,
-0.034496557,
-0.022224227,
-0.0065021706,
0.0495976172,
-0.0443380103,
0.079023391,
0.032212656,
0.0190129373,
-0.0505322553,
-0.0577519871,
-0.0246818103,
-0.0230367407,
-0.0440474376,
0.018671304,
0.0752421618,
0.0658448413,
-0.049902264,
-0.0390319899,
-0.0166387968,
0.0235258862,
-0.0406851359,
-0.0308361724,
-0.0021617468,
0.0148105975,
0.0014118392,
0.0507566072,
-0.0571634099,
0.004272602,
-0.0422894992,
0.0409571938,
-0.0036242383,
-0.0246069375,
-0.0189086292,
0.0262712538,
-0.0376164988,
-0.0648761764,
-0.0106716631,
0.0448931493,
0.0329098701,
0.0199375357,
0.0074299225,
-0.0020085869,
-0.0099720601,
-0.0047817454,
-0.0246286057,
0.0017490672,
0.0589823276,
0.0196871478,
0.0105627654,
0.0130205518,
0.0091395061,
0.0175943989,
0.0110656964,
0.0424823686,
-0.0493333712,
-0.0290036313,
0.0412515737,
0.0180845745,
0.0209684893,
0.0652243495,
0.0041284859,
0.0141860507,
0.0224148296,
-0.013503517,
-0.0211390983,
-0.0027467834,
-0.0195880495,
-0.0138102695,
-0.0410810225,
0.0162122417,
-0.0300626345,
-0.0282835457,
0.047873985,
-0.0047742142,
-0.0093047312,
0.012060578,
0.0145313106,
-0.0098424396,
-0.0258938223,
-0.0237545054,
0.0229894649,
-0.0146465106,
0.0669826418,
-0.0023031684,
0.0942035541,
0.0375805497,
0.0082128402,
0.0344003476,
-0.0215220358,
-0.0805332959,
-0.0906748921,
0.0340027399,
0.0149157504,
0.0224101897,
0.014965375,
0.0073743439,
-0.0567499809,
-0.013210508,
-0.0010906948,
-0.0073269447,
0.0269549433,
-0.0192530379,
0.0417931303,
0.0327630341,
-0.0348630883,
-0.0399779305,
0.042705223,
-0.0488888808,
0.0385315716,
0.0063922293,
-0.0072506848,
-0.0307118855,
-0.0738303736,
-0.0063485233,
0.001778604,
0.0013680577,
0.0018567158,
-0.072908245,
-0.0623898469,
-0.0325630978,
0.0425429679,
0.0045199916,
-0.0177619476,
0.0078304661,
0.07662642,
0.0013856532,
-0.0083519444,
0.014595978,
0.0424540751,
0.0066389008,
0.0157185979,
-0.0256550964,
-5.978873203e-33,
-0.0236090701,
-0.0294169504,
0.0448139831,
-0.006091238,
-0.002899437,
-0.0305369198,
-0.02770916,
0.0391018353,
-0.053018868,
0.0373764709,
-0.0086940741,
0.0280382168,
0.0020358786,
0.0075713424,
-0.032165952,
-0.0330583565,
-0.0020357727,
0.0141577302,
-0.0558796376,
0.0057285978,
0.0457911976,
-0.0565126464,
0.0327940471,
-0.0569659062,
0.0369570963,
-0.000601935,
0.0015290078,
0.0259280875,
-0.0958020315,
0.0522325151,
0.0001526448,
0.0136435768,
0.0137804002,
-0.030960083,
0.0161065701,
0.0230261367,
-0.0016466052,
-0.0342790037,
0.0714560598,
-0.0118940109,
-0.0620989949,
-0.0059525343,
0.0396639034,
0.0101015009,
-0.0152474167,
-0.0133713335,
-0.0273144916,
-0.0097772684,
0.0013641632,
-0.0003613049,
-0.0551628284,
0.0297905076,
-0.0112143969,
-0.0435860157,
-0.0375861712,
0.0070164548,
0.0054725865,
-0.0047852942,
-0.0677517727,
-0.0047896462,
0.0228277463,
-0.0205039792,
0.0734612495,
-0.0323624611,
0.0164488293,
0.0711515024,
-0.0222164989,
0.0273079313,
-0.0664013177,
-0.0241882913,
-0.0164336339,
0.0515310913,
0.0793042257,
0.0188305918,
0.0372371785,
0.0282928348,
-0.0689815506,
-0.0183438379,
0.0292048771,
0.0449419245,
0.021398697,
0.0085403565,
-0.024478361,
0.0330941007,
-0.0617396906,
0.0337091088,
-0.0439821035,
-0.0315787457,
0.009804707,
-0.0005929595,
-0.0070579359,
-0.0312937759,
0.0140307834,
-0.0110723898,
0.0100595597,
-0.0122086396,
-0.013229331,
-0.0295386389,
-0.0026661088,
0.048310589,
-0.031534858,
0.0038092099,
-0.0088354591,
0.0112229111,
0.004619801,
0.0005809467,
0.0423196405,
-0.0122584915,
-0.034402404,
0.0048333327,
-0.0502474308,
0.0411637425,
-0.0247184113,
-0.0243085194,
0.0608911589,
0.021502234,
-0.0103398543,
0.0004048814,
0.0048660161,
-0.0305898208,
-0.061213091,
0.007684418,
-0.0289482214,
-0.0037834502,
-0.0209974982,
0.0037287516,
-0.0234013889,
-0.0014535279,
0.0107765635,
-0.0522066467,
0.0016623214,
0.0139731187,
2.607e-7,
0.0198245887,
0.0356182419,
0.0199626423,
0.0156488884,
0.0377578288,
0.0469336957,
-0.0235787779,
0.0093900142,
0.0223447438,
-0.0881718248,
-0.031167347,
0.0495232791,
0.0504336171,
0.060290318,
-0.0198546387,
-0.0049754428,
-0.0911685377,
-0.0296731163,
-0.0217660554,
0.0218274519,
0.0722422004,
0.0750604719,
0.0062438506,
0.0068527013,
0.0161162913,
-0.0225534197,
0.0903512836,
-0.0052352576,
-0.0187758561,
-0.0134135699,
0.0380491056,
-0.0170158781,
0.0106973751,
0.0246284921,
0.0455131568,
-0.0035426049,
-0.0319582745,
0.0677280203,
0.0016771008,
-0.0542104989,
-0.0575187951,
-0.0378301032,
-0.0047502173,
-0.066695407,
0.0570129082,
-0.076288633,
-0.0377312601,
-0.029895477,
0.0035233598,
-0.0357747898,
0.0210806169,
0.0176288038,
-0.0425609313,
0.0106823863,
0.0170744415,
0.0038839886,
0.009880919,
-0.0626642853,
-0.0299650058,
0.0108982436,
-0.0578955226,
-0.0468184762,
-0.0239747055,
0.0025401141,
0.0373674072,
-0.0115603413,
0.0035118675,
2.187290552e-34,
0.0230694767,
-0.0277850926,
0.0353393443,
-0.004341607,
0.0572968349,
0.0271722376,
0.0142765073,
0.0078058545,
0.041758921,
-0.0330916196,
-0.0054057473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13144v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13144v2 | Response Length Perception and Sequence Scheduling: An LLM-Empowered LLM Inference Pipeline | 2023-05-22T15:36:06 | 2023-05-28T08:22:19 | Zangwei Zheng, Xiaozhe Ren, Fuzhao Xue, Yang Luo, Xin Jiang, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of AI,
demonstrating unprecedented capacity across various tasks. However, the
inference process for LLMs comes with significant computational costs. In this
paper, we propose an efficient LLM inference pipeline that harnesses the power
of LLMs. Our approach begins by tapping into the potential of LLMs to
accurately perceive and predict the response length with minimal overhead. By
leveraging this information, we introduce an efficient sequence scheduling
technique that groups queries with similar response lengths into micro-batches.
We evaluate our approach on real-world instruction datasets using the
LLaMA-based model, and our results demonstrate an impressive 86% improvement in
inference throughput without compromising effectiveness. Notably, our method is
orthogonal to other inference acceleration techniques, making it a valuable
addition to many existing toolkits (e.g., FlashAttention, Quantization) for LLM
inference. | [
0.023589097,
0.0762871727,
-0.0250878669,
0.0680393875,
-0.0327599905,
0.0054608565,
0.0020329447,
-0.0086453632,
0.0406492203,
-0.0397896357,
-0.0095292833,
-0.0649487376,
-0.0097943749,
0.0206173174,
0.0076294448,
-0.0167751294,
0.0486905053,
-0.052321054,
-0.0161349345,
-0.000289364,
-0.0106043927,
0.0146267945,
-0.0114476541,
0.0474946797,
0.0370368063,
-0.0152260261,
-0.0385651775,
0.0121200448,
-0.0152586158,
-0.021033667,
0.0033307765,
0.0398763753,
0.0259748418,
0.0213176254,
0.0000020718,
-0.0360310264,
0.0212955177,
-0.0109099662,
-0.0434033833,
0.0362806246,
-0.007847948,
0.0063861036,
0.0116560934,
0.0570042133,
-0.022124432,
0.0140574835,
0.05382571,
-0.0434658602,
0.0060310047,
0.0456306078,
0.0065368069,
-0.0139070312,
0.0177858714,
-0.0343834199,
0.0261503626,
-0.0329967141,
0.0114322882,
-0.0406568125,
0.0515104942,
0.0061687473,
-0.023674123,
0.0365977213,
0.0394721068,
0.0053486843,
-0.0399241894,
0.0125790602,
-0.0305377524,
-0.0140383001,
-0.0287229307,
0.047271952,
-0.0293848999,
0.0017610326,
0.0262525007,
-0.0126440395,
0.0105498312,
-0.0272698384,
-0.0279325005,
0.0213701408,
-0.0241386816,
0.0090215327,
0.0223831739,
0.0015942992,
0.0170748401,
-0.0022585969,
-0.0549753457,
0.0786039308,
0.0145225525,
0.0158818401,
-0.0664868057,
-0.0204059407,
0.0086751217,
-0.056987416,
-0.0192970801,
0.0596349239,
-0.0469972081,
0.0299214628,
-0.05469184,
-0.0070752394,
0.0082014753,
-0.0284677539,
0.0499904826,
0.0683666542,
-0.0166738909,
0.0229552016,
-0.0346474349,
0.0646940321,
-0.0339426883,
-0.0069049443,
-0.0603625774,
0.0051444066,
-0.010205999,
0.0108995494,
-0.0117486939,
0.0389129072,
-0.0679636747,
-0.0096478639,
-0.0616226755,
0.046943821,
0.0103889862,
0.0172892101,
0.0011194417,
-0.0108639179,
-0.0411681682,
0.0156372655,
-0.0496315211,
0.030733915,
-0.0355827771,
0.0137530686,
-0.0225561745,
-0.0951234698,
-0.0325004309,
0.0161880534,
-0.0127264606,
-0.0275251567,
0.0341967307,
0.1040800214,
-0.0121303303,
-0.0295674372,
-0.0683936477,
-0.0445374101,
0.0160311218,
-0.049491439,
0.0139301596,
-0.0675143674,
0.0526161082,
0.0211491622,
-0.0095163593,
0.0218556281,
0.0138349682,
0.0187385585,
-0.0076069823,
0.0652911812,
0.032351844,
0.0169919748,
0.00088348,
0.0041664555,
0.0115852673,
0.0954776704,
0.0452788882,
0.052047573,
0.0371495187,
0.0074869362,
0.01049974,
0.0612892844,
0.00254554,
-0.0275164135,
-0.0349589512,
0.015937129,
0.0049912399,
0.0013752519,
0.0362660661,
0.0296722427,
0.0205228887,
-0.0467717387,
0.0089894161,
0.0784596205,
-0.0246538594,
-0.0181284565,
0.0591176264,
0.0203440692,
-0.0134820072,
0.0001666428,
-0.051879257,
0.0591147542,
0.0172967613,
0.0125757661,
0.0758683607,
0.0599197298,
-0.0396190621,
-0.0376819372,
-0.0147863301,
0.0003085104,
-0.0651630312,
0.0530054644,
0.0235100593,
-0.0218701344,
-0.053208515,
0.0419847928,
0.0265381448,
-0.0046611093,
-0.0418267213,
-0.0869832635,
0.0184620507,
0.0781390369,
0.0407195464,
-0.0401778929,
-0.0338402241,
0.0550680757,
-0.0233481545,
0.0300777797,
-0.0067130169,
-0.0192851275,
0.0273119826,
-0.025969021,
-0.02513377,
0.0147614973,
0.012319495,
0.0302248914,
0.0681107491,
-0.0064959163,
0.0303922333,
-0.0423980579,
-0.0294589214,
0.0313681774,
-0.0289315972,
-0.0713479295,
0.0287283398,
0.0131037151,
0.0445323251,
-0.0217532348,
0.0005316782,
0.015932383,
0.0209761169,
-0.0394413881,
0.015128226,
-0.0233131442,
-0.0300505385,
-0.0400845408,
0.030589072,
0.015852781,
0.0163529497,
0.0240973551,
-0.0791409388,
-0.0471670777,
0.034744028,
-0.026349362,
0.0315162204,
0.0099816844,
0.0229225531,
0.0149750207,
0.0075016073,
-0.0098965783,
0.022649955,
-0.0280883182,
-0.0060005169,
0.022098925,
0.0191088784,
-0.0164936353,
-0.0184393879,
-0.0379822627,
0.006044372,
-0.0163559467,
-0.0096891494,
-0.0221457724,
-0.0326925404,
-0.014942633,
0.0087011484,
-0.0775902495,
0.021034969,
-0.0006169371,
0.0571142174,
-0.0134420367,
0.0372525454,
0.0089638354,
-0.03434176,
-0.0115877278,
-0.0078811198,
0.0100747151,
0.0356448442,
0.0110990675,
0.007512473,
-0.0658065006,
-0.0571416765,
-0.0255538095,
-0.0342920907,
0.0393935926,
-0.0230015367,
-0.0389071479,
-0.0379227847,
-0.0093192672,
0.0146890339,
0.0556203276,
-0.0412579402,
-0.0490211733,
-0.0047540925,
-0.036062099,
0.0114909541,
0.101342611,
0.0042147813,
-0.0212116409,
0.0408289358,
0.0054948735,
-0.0378352925,
0.0378034078,
-0.0110807512,
-0.0473788269,
-0.0142757278,
-0.046957083,
-0.0114002693,
0.0900805146,
-0.0042639943,
-0.008290438,
-0.0440407507,
-0.0249644872,
0.035116937,
-0.014782913,
0.0067780172,
0.0042565404,
-0.0105472934,
0.0291643087,
-0.0190117937,
-0.0869720802,
0.0722126886,
-0.0447924472,
0.0111636491,
0.0058437255,
-0.0212661941,
-0.0232768245,
0.0743730962,
0.0256945342,
-0.0062171305,
-0.0412172526,
-0.0020401222,
-0.0566750765,
0.0178087931,
-0.0240937192,
-0.0570224524,
0.0758221373,
-0.0678161383,
0.005932699,
-0.0428496078,
-0.0169270467,
-0.066539444,
0.0075149685,
-0.037279591,
0.0052045039,
0.0257480517,
-0.0497854427,
-0.0109361727,
0.0136016831,
-0.0026753347,
0.0642097071,
-0.0272928998,
0.0265954938,
-0.0193467885,
0.0146056842,
0.0411609523,
-0.0069361194,
-0.0139481099,
-0.0127154617,
0.0309706312,
0.0486277714,
0.0635398105,
0.0135895871,
-0.0402687192,
-0.0166491028,
0.0385889634,
-0.0018390344,
-0.002271601,
0.0830898508,
0.0211388897,
-0.0775680766,
-0.018201299,
0.1005290598,
0.0238749813,
-0.0398679972,
0.0000916169,
0.0214217696,
0.0231327601,
0.0378177539,
0.0553264096,
-0.0893513188,
-0.0600864701,
0.0144870598,
0.0305525288,
-0.0157885626,
-0.0159439892,
-0.0125573874,
-0.1198168024,
0.0177254714,
-0.0255670343,
-0.0118647078,
-0.0369732529,
-0.0445930101,
0.0005572448,
0.0353184231,
-0.0100856405,
0.0252401959,
-0.0052429582,
-0.0124860555,
0.0235248841,
0.0180578567,
-0.0025472634,
0.0492592864,
0.0060209748,
0.0454532653,
0.0466229282,
0.0094632898,
0.0196298286,
-0.0225594323,
0.0254941862,
-0.0330628268,
0.007851107,
-0.0229447354,
0.0381043702,
-0.0117251715,
-0.0094818044,
0.0112864841,
0.0160630215,
-0.0240286887,
0.0136040095,
0.0331923068,
0.0900151581,
-0.0231682844,
-0.0107334908,
-0.0606254674,
-0.0337490141,
0.00082728,
0.0672249869,
0.0195704121,
-0.0146355163,
-0.0412540995,
-0.0253528468,
-0.0554395318,
-0.0622920729,
-0.0140443919,
-0.0042659584,
-0.0253721122,
-0.0167076271,
-0.0108736996,
0.0180799235,
0.0085779317,
0.001989217,
0.0120654013,
-0.0169041008,
0.0269103851,
-0.0067915395,
-0.0852920189,
0.0074991155,
-0.0384719148,
0.0291981418,
-0.0820287764,
0.0045768945,
0.0285222419,
0.0102821644,
-0.0173187684,
0.0414666794,
-0.1376624256,
-0.069552429,
-0.0384997092,
0.0569399595,
0.0191481262,
0.0280069485,
0.0094691152,
-0.0216573775,
0.0183390956,
0.0546668582,
-0.0241818018,
0.0262234583,
0.0035555058,
-0.0035526026,
-0.0130596738,
0.0248569474,
-0.0472081229,
0.0498741083,
0.0008969249,
0.0125071639,
-0.0265763197,
-0.0574205928,
-0.0265446845,
0.0219553933,
0.017604731,
0.0096371472,
0.0012399177,
0.0122821266,
0.0626851544,
0.0129554644,
-0.0130634038,
-0.0450808667,
-0.0010289822,
0.0008726473,
-0.0124564283,
0.0197130553,
-0.0513728075,
0.0081694825,
-0.0199865159,
-0.0030418986,
0.005743877,
-0.0044318824,
0.0004452931,
0.0306866989,
-0.0256399661,
-0.0059564901,
0.0268339515,
0.0270981267,
0.0469197445,
-0.0234226491,
0.0174967665,
0.0105395885,
0.035462711,
-0.0361257754,
0.0057096574,
-0.0461707376,
-0.0471725836,
-0.0162963923,
0.0093502318,
0.0275474451,
-0.0317633599,
-0.0033115873,
-0.0011647453,
0.0192344245,
-0.0310886316,
0.0310397353,
-0.011303206,
-0.0126132797,
0.0560564622,
0.0487095304,
-0.0021403027,
-0.0142158354,
0.0708379224,
-0.0061937054,
0.0314649157,
0.0174723044,
-0.0439634435,
-0.0223380104,
-0.0746096075,
-0.002237468,
-0.0037081512,
0.0018391142,
0.0074601909,
-0.0329215154,
-0.0602035113,
-0.008142815,
0.019180892,
0.0062284493,
-0.0172468293,
0.0218170062,
0.066286847,
0.0416985564,
-0.0434874482,
-0.0388961062,
0.0264882948,
-0.021044353,
-0.0216411985,
-0.0069614905,
-6.2823076e-33,
-0.0209753979,
-0.0451433733,
0.0260142833,
-0.0103825638,
-0.0044460385,
0.0270757917,
-0.0352475792,
-0.0240361206,
-0.0369266495,
-0.034804333,
-0.0247135535,
0.0410281047,
0.0196250509,
0.0111294361,
0.0418738946,
-0.00253344,
0.0351737104,
0.009548936,
-0.0153000336,
0.0277631618,
0.0159816723,
-0.0072282245,
0.0287334304,
0.00378699,
-0.0349720381,
-0.0061131087,
0.0592357926,
0.0165129285,
-0.029532833,
0.0597508997,
-0.0185003784,
0.042536214,
0.0230593123,
-0.0402966738,
0.0000528466,
0.0200308971,
-0.0486114547,
-0.0387521051,
0.0425659306,
0.017221611,
-0.0108141992,
-0.0315615982,
0.0233164914,
0.0355157182,
-0.0227991771,
-0.0408243239,
0.0218346827,
-0.0158607624,
-0.0023631833,
-0.0326735675,
-0.0266089812,
0.0325134918,
0.0152860833,
-0.0012360067,
0.0597279519,
0.0526826903,
0.0220108647,
0.0190517455,
-0.0198496971,
0.0102127641,
0.0194465648,
0.1125397235,
0.097560063,
0.06753546,
0.0154455351,
0.0000908919,
0.0279268939,
-0.0099667087,
-0.0184575692,
0.0325143673,
0.0116380863,
0.0136313979,
-0.0103811128,
0.0149603644,
0.0571879148,
0.0236422122,
-0.073098518,
0.0140137719,
0.0509333014,
0.0522123575,
0.0455702804,
-0.0159675907,
-0.05204105,
-0.0284006763,
-0.0292134192,
0.0119219171,
-0.0583821796,
0.0081893895,
0.0290431138,
0.0195595827,
0.0041473205,
-0.0116026057,
0.0517680794,
-0.0334245227,
-0.0082901753,
0.0218258239,
-0.0054443721,
0.003844593,
0.0074778558,
0.0448442549,
-0.0236030612,
-0.0509111509,
0.0216850918,
-0.0348388962,
0.0239475034,
0.0020248822,
-0.0212979931,
0.010640271,
-0.0506712906,
-0.0206811577,
-0.0588128157,
0.0027118691,
-0.0187962055,
0.0175350048,
0.0462626778,
0.0143502057,
0.0092885429,
0.0524685308,
-0.0302191414,
-0.0259774309,
-0.0110402917,
-0.0214855429,
-0.0037829278,
0.0248202421,
-0.0664447397,
-0.0114689069,
-0.0618202537,
0.0277394317,
-0.0180157591,
-0.0846651196,
-0.0391467027,
0.0327020809,
2.868e-7,
0.0036790571,
0.0023645617,
0.0356646702,
0.0958677754,
0.0060031079,
0.0211009681,
0.0382716171,
0.0207838081,
0.0367182083,
-0.014481795,
0.020996524,
0.0258769952,
0.0359942243,
0.0120872362,
-0.0754326507,
0.0066289334,
-0.0208127294,
0.0361802652,
-0.0719852448,
-0.0259232093,
0.0305265579,
0.1016806513,
-0.0041243266,
-0.0141703859,
0.0097705498,
-0.0211999584,
-0.0183125865,
0.0169618353,
-0.0007334817,
0.0264877584,
0.0077601545,
0.0128970686,
-0.0035488931,
0.0344750248,
-0.0141437259,
0.0114878938,
-0.059916731,
0.0760155097,
0.0007817976,
-0.0248305667,
0.0160138607,
-0.0364012383,
0.0037724639,
-0.0426218882,
0.0790974796,
-0.0059698522,
0.002123618,
-0.0334903747,
0.0125201745,
-0.0054444787,
-0.0474622585,
0.0126534915,
0.026056271,
0.0234879218,
0.029870661,
-0.0626257658,
0.0021274232,
-0.076398544,
-0.0537994839,
0.0056192614,
-0.0591151267,
-0.0520883501,
-0.0847780332,
-0.0045747203,
-0.0172421858,
-0.0414882042,
-0.0034944597,
3.046022007e-34,
-0.0008164651,
0.0027584971,
0.0127769271,
0.081372574,
0.0166987367,
-0.0256519411,
-0.0276765469,
0.0397137813,
0.0373234637,
-0.098047629,
-0.0507841259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13142v1 | Better Sampling of Negatives for Distantly Supervised Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T15:35:39 | 2023-05-22T15:35:39 | Lu Xu, Lidong Bing, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distantly supervised named entity recognition (DS-NER) has been proposed to
exploit the automatically labeled training data instead of human annotations.
The distantly annotated datasets are often noisy and contain a considerable
number of false negatives. The recent approach uses a weighted sampling
approach to select a subset of negative samples for training. However, it
requires a good classifier to assign weights to the negative samples. In this
paper, we propose a simple and straightforward approach for selecting the top
negative samples that have high similarities with all the positive samples for
training. Our method achieves consistent performance improvements on four
distantly supervised NER datasets. Our analysis also shows that it is critical
to differentiate the true negatives from the false negatives. | [
0.0213352181,
-0.0036623483,
-0.0279727615,
-0.0021933811,
-0.0125437928,
0.0510970019,
0.0027767422,
0.0297255926,
0.0448839627,
-0.0389211625,
-0.0465811789,
-0.0095026279,
0.0003638422,
-0.0081460429,
0.0238361489,
-0.0198705718,
-0.0121534243,
0.0094852913,
-0.0033166567,
0.0208274443,
-0.0022462157,
-0.0067248633,
-0.0394591987,
-0.0249612909,
-0.002120449,
0.0338975303,
-0.0034114018,
0.0078967186,
0.0530406311,
-0.0990221128,
0.0170141403,
0.0148351761,
-0.0504683405,
0.0212413557,
0.0000016631,
-0.0617921501,
-0.0391199812,
0.0232042708,
-0.0298935492,
-0.0728463233,
0.02907582,
-0.0580813847,
0.0128075844,
0.0112125399,
-0.0033607453,
-0.051626049,
0.0388946496,
0.0877997354,
0.0296098515,
0.0531973876,
0.0018365626,
0.0159120634,
0.0117847789,
-0.0092562754,
-0.0000065023,
-0.0151734063,
0.0482573807,
-0.0065297172,
0.0214837957,
-0.0139383385,
-0.0219682287,
-0.0159166623,
-0.0186110754,
0.0155942049,
0.0083669443,
0.0501152538,
-0.0290868338,
0.0127551621,
0.0018814114,
0.0819449723,
-0.0038900438,
-0.0105115743,
0.0683465376,
-0.0424222089,
-0.0446466319,
-0.019675063,
-0.0264253188,
-0.0004763319,
-0.0316466652,
0.0273089949,
-0.0007476722,
0.0299333557,
0.0012773072,
-0.0032275699,
0.0169849806,
0.0045526037,
-0.0010050562,
-0.073942557,
0.0463165417,
0.0539502539,
-0.0084764799,
-0.0056748884,
0.0939147919,
-0.0027962835,
0.0366856605,
0.005538424,
-0.0043585435,
-0.0120207397,
0.0202901624,
-0.0373295657,
-0.0150268348,
-0.0002597438,
0.0078016063,
0.0459377579,
-0.0544254892,
-0.0437896736,
0.0305890869,
-0.0089288298,
0.0441042855,
-0.0079129525,
-0.0848230347,
0.0250270162,
-0.0395547301,
0.0719351023,
-0.0012383548,
0.0173132345,
-0.0268122312,
-0.0253979284,
-0.0380338728,
-0.0080575161,
0.020759115,
-0.0024857589,
-0.0024043622,
0.0134839844,
-0.0115629574,
0.0226771813,
-0.0117035545,
0.0016308123,
-0.066247128,
-0.0298583135,
0.0038211835,
-0.0223396998,
0.0387043431,
-0.0346871726,
0.0108002443,
0.0705229416,
0.0541507415,
-0.0856601149,
-0.0625789538,
0.01316672,
0.0021744312,
-0.0043390649,
-0.0153211458,
0.0231855251,
0.0002056034,
0.0018266115,
0.0089068152,
-0.0357368812,
0.0119381463,
-0.0013288615,
-0.0366893858,
0.0558442734,
-0.0536788218,
-0.0239470098,
0.0328660123,
-0.0179961976,
-0.0107743628,
0.0448147729,
0.0448126197,
0.0035478857,
0.038190145,
0.0492983758,
0.0046306159,
0.001099739,
0.0499460101,
-0.0119547881,
-0.0093381451,
0.0083883982,
-0.0369057246,
-0.015516324,
0.0129207913,
0.006479295,
-0.0073752482,
-0.0235114712,
0.0402601212,
-0.0055832653,
-0.0337578543,
-0.0423973426,
-0.0182527509,
0.0225769822,
-0.0264042951,
-0.0422502719,
-0.0400166698,
0.0261037331,
-0.0474802107,
0.0111281043,
0.0097750602,
0.0110655837,
-0.0092822183,
0.0247196481,
0.0004136591,
-0.0185214672,
0.0030950913,
-0.0046447981,
0.0804818273,
-0.0041486369,
-0.0548470728,
0.0519027263,
0.0512435213,
-0.0081575317,
0.021918539,
0.0241933875,
0.0695395842,
0.0177510306,
-0.0065062884,
-0.0498552844,
-0.0477391854,
-0.0511007085,
-0.0573585257,
0.0516716838,
0.0258910749,
-0.0188624207,
0.0350939371,
-0.0224336926,
-0.0311667807,
0.0757639706,
0.0087153148,
0.0140524963,
0.0240919739,
0.0766273737,
0.0438947603,
-0.0387790129,
-0.0696904734,
0.0495337956,
-0.0191846229,
-0.0252075754,
0.0155693833,
0.0474236719,
0.0386099368,
0.0303712301,
-0.0094012003,
-0.0347241126,
0.0229531396,
-0.0467329174,
-0.0350964554,
-0.0530754216,
0.0003515323,
-0.0626576692,
-0.0110621126,
-0.0330114737,
0.0211405512,
0.0278540105,
-0.0404286347,
-0.0486125164,
-0.0029513345,
0.0012788397,
-0.0013953616,
-0.0289883297,
0.0271799956,
0.0247585215,
-0.0040108636,
-0.0346553735,
0.0529950708,
-0.0064725317,
0.0305278208,
-0.0131343706,
-0.0260816161,
0.0148230698,
-0.0420167036,
-0.0580999702,
-0.0180393364,
-0.011781171,
-0.052192796,
0.0367610864,
0.0087028835,
-0.0807278529,
0.0039449371,
-0.074542284,
0.0070454073,
0.0017814167,
0.0324918292,
0.0186377652,
0.0062806718,
-0.0239296947,
-0.0372991934,
-0.0018891334,
-0.0214107521,
-0.024536578,
0.019585263,
0.0390862226,
0.0163236223,
-0.0007319059,
0.0229821224,
0.0009454004,
-0.0236755069,
-0.0018332612,
0.0052743503,
-0.0672126263,
-0.0828725919,
0.043384105,
-0.0495362692,
0.0037884801,
0.0325565189,
0.0350849889,
-0.0178130474,
0.0369156413,
-0.059912812,
0.0314218029,
-0.006319603,
-0.0334586725,
-0.0004779149,
0.0347245261,
-0.0298330616,
0.0080865975,
-0.0290666427,
0.092862092,
0.0148349581,
-0.0438843183,
-0.0065557295,
0.066290319,
-0.0138431406,
-0.0005974683,
-0.0287644472,
0.013094401,
-0.0495002195,
-0.0096870475,
0.0149647072,
0.0290955584,
-0.0113585433,
0.0029927099,
-0.0254985653,
-0.0499824136,
0.0670402944,
-0.0246146787,
-0.0145194763,
-0.0216457564,
0.0156196374,
-0.0110489894,
0.0407629758,
0.0284439996,
-0.01450474,
0.0638654232,
-0.0578121468,
0.0336773023,
-0.0166944209,
0.0394121706,
-0.0094801076,
-0.0150579028,
0.0075177872,
0.043741446,
-0.0302127227,
-0.0245248713,
-0.0545439385,
-0.0106655043,
-0.0205893982,
-0.0067927465,
-0.0349092856,
0.0381449014,
-0.0168446992,
0.0945511907,
-0.0249740668,
0.0526680611,
-0.0212209802,
-0.019835813,
-0.0270579159,
0.0257680584,
0.0234325659,
-0.0305945817,
0.0368498676,
0.0104589341,
-0.0209110435,
-0.0182816833,
0.0190960243,
0.0159029327,
0.0251995344,
-0.0080419984,
0.008981254,
-0.0756554827,
-0.0029580351,
-0.020881379,
0.0102329571,
0.0090304948,
-0.0063904477,
0.114149496,
0.0081385477,
-0.0226098094,
0.0050528874,
0.024249265,
-0.0141370595,
0.0235010423,
-0.0057948744,
-0.0317039862,
-0.028252963,
-0.0119698979,
0.0193200875,
-0.0139202783,
-0.0956808925,
0.0169165339,
-0.1287428886,
-0.0160285942,
-0.0203092303,
-0.0517166816,
0.0089066112,
-0.0742214322,
0.0133373812,
-0.0665649176,
-0.0406738669,
-0.0292054284,
-0.0061436412,
0.0018022088,
0.0360132195,
0.0119550331,
-0.0170927383,
-0.0069820094,
-0.0539714918,
0.0365468711,
0.0324896723,
0.0409983285,
-0.0197750609,
0.0062413085,
-0.0136770699,
-0.0619582236,
-0.0162200499,
-0.0307366177,
0.0843110904,
-0.0061282991,
-0.0261502955,
-0.0197464246,
-0.0141151631,
-0.0362068787,
0.002549506,
0.0398501568,
0.0662012175,
-0.0253880266,
-0.0004675903,
-0.0028214031,
-0.006516417,
0.054898832,
0.0655734465,
-0.0210904032,
-0.0249624401,
0.0033891851,
0.0773517489,
0.0064205518,
0.0037747447,
0.0301899556,
-0.0042838324,
-0.0685837567,
-0.0138822692,
-0.0780541003,
-0.0709244013,
0.0677551702,
0.1004007012,
0.0240029395,
0.01406141,
0.0554952696,
0.0322441645,
-0.0371399,
0.011792575,
-0.0336533077,
-0.0020895433,
-0.0127963498,
-0.0450251587,
0.0550734811,
0.0368103869,
-0.0436343998,
-0.0127549376,
-0.0510636903,
-0.03190111,
-0.0088297287,
0.0205769874,
0.0147608472,
0.0370038636,
-0.0026426949,
-0.0098021515,
0.0584598854,
0.0654589832,
-0.0447825231,
-0.035244599,
0.0060755978,
-0.0198811945,
0.0004190906,
0.0274445564,
-0.0348884128,
0.0502820238,
0.0485512465,
0.0412419364,
-0.0566602573,
-0.0138423685,
-0.0188582875,
0.0219989326,
0.0849799588,
-0.0184070226,
-0.0286606476,
-0.0379388444,
0.0280426033,
0.0194879789,
0.0381308235,
-0.0082445303,
0.0056246254,
0.005581893,
0.0133527983,
-0.0374833457,
0.0694271177,
-0.0358234793,
0.0261921696,
-0.0551381633,
0.0127259158,
0.0270087365,
0.0606401116,
-0.0219571963,
-0.0326570943,
-0.0173983537,
0.0061120642,
0.0879700854,
0.0391083397,
-0.0408285633,
0.0338290744,
0.0011197078,
0.0600028262,
-0.0016129105,
0.0005104033,
-0.0400589556,
0.0562557057,
-0.0492603593,
0.049978625,
0.0290772002,
-0.0236876253,
0.0558984578,
0.0007220355,
0.0195405502,
0.0164759327,
-0.0136747919,
-0.0185533892,
-0.0199066103,
0.0066924109,
0.0066669732,
0.0012335745,
0.0256583467,
0.0654816702,
-0.0039199386,
0.0301748067,
0.0189804826,
-0.0175695978,
-0.0252658613,
0.0004350062,
0.0387237146,
-0.0167418867,
-0.0113740237,
0.0214445721,
-0.0183106754,
-0.0478013121,
0.0639513358,
-0.0531931072,
-0.0138539383,
0.0129922675,
0.0351589881,
-0.0423459001,
-0.0248627961,
-0.03263399,
-0.0301864557,
0.0176377371,
-0.0005434102,
-0.0251044109,
-0.0441036597,
-5.519139199e-33,
-0.0372742265,
-0.0280534979,
-0.0114714988,
-0.0001175341,
-0.0174556188,
0.0006507706,
0.0129397437,
-0.0525070429,
0.0413516536,
-0.0217257515,
-0.003145983,
-0.0086084902,
0.0319229253,
0.0230790433,
-0.0017271008,
-0.0482092388,
0.0619204305,
0.0056943172,
-0.0066909203,
0.0338451676,
0.0323654674,
0.0868444294,
0.0729998872,
-0.0922536775,
0.0444685258,
-0.0087192236,
-0.0030986858,
-0.0023146628,
0.1176490635,
0.0448244289,
-0.0145824058,
-0.0136860488,
0.0164376721,
-0.0747766569,
0.00704015,
-0.0667401254,
-0.1121412888,
-0.0166556649,
-0.0247626118,
0.0508250222,
0.038531594,
0.0299584251,
0.0190333128,
-0.0151248574,
0.0225568376,
0.0618472584,
0.0243669525,
-0.0355112515,
-0.0257381704,
-0.039279215,
-0.0470242836,
0.0449958406,
0.0100586656,
0.0417191647,
0.0310365763,
-0.0278024431,
0.0127425939,
-0.0072376314,
-0.0449352302,
-0.0150537053,
0.0529175587,
-0.0190384518,
0.0045440001,
0.0243978929,
0.0100400792,
0.0608422346,
0.0387574919,
-0.0109827956,
0.0369635783,
-0.0211525578,
-0.000154245,
-0.0172313154,
-0.0157482214,
0.0471487939,
0.0594326109,
-0.0322280787,
-0.0634953156,
0.0363926776,
0.0008578702,
-0.0084561473,
0.0045487536,
-0.0374308974,
-0.0585353188,
0.0031842487,
0.0186046343,
-0.0557180531,
-0.0161904134,
-0.0061650476,
0.026753135,
0.0330672115,
-0.082307972,
0.0703818202,
0.0025570823,
-0.0211201105,
-0.0595760308,
-0.0086661568,
0.0564413629,
-0.018389022,
0.0030849008,
-0.0578250438,
-0.0504674837,
-0.0467625409,
0.0056089824,
-0.0105060749,
0.0314947814,
-0.0396607518,
0.0706071854,
-0.0275308341,
-0.0724088326,
-0.0074160132,
0.0297953598,
0.0434767902,
-0.0092953136,
0.0257053524,
0.0084995721,
-0.0130972853,
0.0001939062,
0.0366026573,
0.0691568106,
-0.0334060825,
0.0007122948,
0.0540755838,
0.0427726917,
0.0255129207,
-0.0292153917,
-0.02763425,
0.0196899679,
-0.0056610503,
0.006049227,
-0.0668881387,
-0.0034166831,
-0.0158545338,
2.318e-7,
-0.0270453151,
0.0076274648,
0.0232334342,
-0.0276847407,
0.0019602459,
0.0250814836,
0.0039081257,
0.0436023436,
-0.0205032118,
0.0321076661,
0.0157019813,
-0.0470395535,
-0.0111527322,
0.0578463636,
-0.08187031,
0.0030141673,
0.015946351,
-0.0437291116,
-0.0324149728,
0.0235822033,
0.0285909344,
0.0588752441,
0.0199956708,
-0.0281761847,
-0.036346063,
-0.0521774665,
0.0375787243,
-0.0019619423,
0.0507334918,
-0.0065928665,
0.0235885177,
0.0012036926,
-0.0297184568,
0.0779674724,
0.0031541598,
0.0092036426,
-0.0028499144,
0.0290775355,
0.0104356362,
-0.0029853596,
-0.0111577557,
-0.0258271247,
0.0401897952,
0.0147984056,
0.0763786882,
-0.0744984522,
0.0037427985,
0.0085684638,
-0.0349866189,
-0.0218302067,
0.0187171921,
0.0078051882,
0.0059736804,
0.0385978892,
0.0342882648,
-0.0030977759,
-0.0095925257,
-0.0292764176,
0.0648741946,
0.0082699209,
0.052045878,
-0.0369259454,
0.0183966104,
0.0050979429,
0.0213207304,
-0.0406796597,
0.0039137071,
1.532806063e-34,
-0.013578508,
0.0106103616,
-0.0368556716,
0.0005853241,
-0.0244595017,
-0.0052742083,
-0.0244642254,
-0.0323251486,
-0.0195238795,
-0.0236482937,
0.0269408766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13140v1 | Extrapolating Multilingual Understanding Models as Multilingual Generators | 2023-05-22T15:33:21 | 2023-05-22T15:33:21 | Bohong Wu, Fei Yuan, Hai Zhao, Lei Li, Jingjing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual understanding models (or encoder-based), pre-trained via masked
language modeling, have achieved promising results on many language
understanding tasks (e.g., mBERT). However, these non-autoregressive (NAR)
models still struggle to generate high-quality texts compared with
autoregressive (AR) models. Considering that encoder-based models have the
advantage of efficient generation and self-correction abilities, this paper
explores methods to empower multilingual understanding models the generation
abilities to get a unified model. Specifically, we start from a multilingual
encoder (XLM-R) and propose a \textbf{S}emantic-\textbf{G}uided
\textbf{A}lignment-then-Denoising (SGA) approach to adapt an encoder to a
multilingual generator with a small number of new parameters. Experiments show
that the proposed approach is an effective adaption method, outperforming
widely-used initialization-based methods with gains of 9.4 BLEU on machine
translation, 8.1 Rouge-L on question generation, and 5.5 METEOR on story
generation on XLM-R$_{large}$. On the other hand, we observe that XLM-R is
still inferior to mBART in supervised settings despite better results on
zero-shot settings, indicating that more exploration is required to make
understanding models strong generators. | [
0.0059030601,
0.032424368,
-0.0072198641,
0.0491285995,
0.0074913884,
0.0351740271,
0.0492572784,
-0.0330788232,
-0.0343350321,
-0.0276943259,
-0.0147753153,
-0.0537662692,
-0.0345204957,
0.0547864921,
0.0269260369,
-0.0331171043,
0.0224871226,
-0.0367787778,
-0.0193514116,
-0.0239347406,
0.0097809173,
0.0514175184,
0.021974327,
0.0265973322,
0.02726743,
-0.0232494026,
-0.0226426274,
0.0150461989,
0.0258767698,
-0.0339218117,
-0.0244041104,
0.0330654047,
0.0566953756,
0.0484754443,
0.0000024619,
-0.0489995405,
-0.0571167134,
-0.0128885107,
-0.0079623042,
-0.026352955,
0.0129360547,
-0.0794066638,
0.0321025401,
0.0075354381,
-0.0262633469,
-0.0151501223,
0.0124301258,
0.00447695,
0.0609744973,
0.0521052033,
-0.0172733124,
-0.054022532,
-0.0321781114,
-0.0158814173,
-0.010839235,
-0.0424456224,
-0.0079572657,
0.0369430184,
-0.0408101268,
0.0072092768,
-0.0319461077,
0.0466469489,
0.0476659387,
-0.0105006639,
0.0120351613,
0.030367855,
0.0330106989,
-0.0568075106,
-0.0105123371,
0.0535075516,
-0.0540269017,
-0.0275812615,
-0.0013550838,
-0.0031438707,
-0.0372605622,
0.0317666829,
-0.0477513,
0.0292845517,
0.0030690152,
0.0053511397,
0.0499608815,
-0.0005119301,
0.0285776723,
0.0111061912,
-0.0156270694,
0.018830549,
0.0250247456,
-0.0026205198,
-0.031608101,
-0.0011705671,
-0.0310864206,
-0.0459882505,
0.0179707352,
0.0503818244,
-0.0090685571,
0.0353309251,
-0.0474591777,
-0.0623072051,
-0.0145159019,
-0.0104653239,
0.0108791683,
0.0493977666,
0.012466778,
0.045659069,
-0.0487247817,
0.0494486019,
-0.0151743339,
-0.0140795046,
-0.0631951541,
-0.0412724167,
-0.0018564572,
-0.0215534028,
-0.0581680872,
0.033251483,
-0.0785047412,
0.0022248661,
-0.0322167836,
0.0409797728,
0.0253020339,
0.0016254075,
-0.0303116459,
-0.0295248255,
-0.0595684461,
-0.0323318318,
0.0193807222,
0.0204048939,
-0.0211928636,
-0.028506536,
0.0108182169,
-0.0471133851,
-0.0320889391,
0.0146188056,
0.0148293823,
-0.0306267533,
-0.0018341708,
0.0529315025,
-0.0453214832,
0.0021414121,
-0.0326206423,
-0.0429876745,
0.0231873114,
-0.0601667613,
0.0300682634,
-0.0483115204,
0.0560293831,
0.0243107658,
0.0162624158,
-0.0355474502,
0.0158384591,
-0.0010065066,
-0.0118386429,
0.0458207838,
-0.0106147062,
0.0074340915,
0.045882348,
0.0077415807,
0.0035241325,
0.0973482504,
0.0080004819,
-0.0085114334,
0.0355838239,
-0.0018735834,
0.0110638523,
0.0382718742,
0.0207110196,
-0.0086283293,
0.0100343805,
-0.0142024988,
-0.004802356,
0.0131344879,
0.0375308543,
0.01136328,
-0.0395099968,
0.0178499725,
0.0423279777,
-0.0172953121,
0.0069130659,
0.052557122,
0.0933158398,
-0.0215269551,
-0.0342529714,
0.0551099963,
0.0298432987,
0.0486631207,
-0.0186411794,
0.0197825152,
0.0012203782,
0.0606424659,
-0.044697769,
-0.055952616,
-0.0013634608,
0.0052438797,
-0.0006823873,
0.0148284361,
0.0575205013,
0.0327425599,
-0.0569663458,
0.0244246144,
0.0076577477,
-0.0496276878,
0.0649147928,
-0.0313033089,
0.0371472873,
0.01927015,
0.050120499,
0.0088713812,
-0.0351716802,
-0.0293779857,
-0.0233708657,
0.0603642873,
0.0088898148,
-0.0085943993,
0.029518066,
-0.0835320354,
-0.0241894107,
-0.0564631261,
-0.0078796335,
0.0699514821,
-0.0583439544,
0.0344567299,
0.031969849,
-0.0395737998,
-0.0236682892,
0.0274787676,
-0.104759708,
-0.0285614077,
0.0007016599,
0.0089755878,
-0.00664814,
0.0299895257,
0.0081723435,
-0.0148222717,
0.0118470443,
-0.0678823888,
0.0072389725,
0.0531439297,
-0.0670951903,
-0.0897081494,
-0.0156638324,
-0.0457932018,
-0.0091574676,
0.0231657922,
-0.0245221686,
-0.0732395723,
0.0235170722,
-0.0017999784,
0.007214434,
-0.0709874779,
0.0135785313,
-0.0021641438,
0.043482542,
-0.010614682,
0.0496921502,
-0.0027091356,
0.0273177363,
0.0605475754,
-0.0066023828,
0.0475356393,
-0.0150858313,
-0.0365189016,
0.0375186689,
-0.0032919506,
-0.0181623101,
0.0431121066,
0.0400883257,
-0.0166831687,
-0.0225741155,
-0.0443062633,
0.0127801718,
-0.0490670279,
-0.0043435814,
0.076613903,
0.0353612751,
0.003040731,
-0.0031863754,
-0.0452332795,
-0.0252581798,
0.049419038,
-0.0060805427,
0.0244373623,
0.0117575834,
0.0151776578,
-0.0011157853,
0.0225402359,
0.0201671198,
0.0532982014,
0.0005217526,
-0.0247435607,
-0.0730738267,
0.0124227591,
-0.0414222628,
-0.0197533034,
-0.0264613181,
-0.0432086699,
0.0082098525,
-0.00833287,
0.040950492,
0.0185726825,
0.0046700034,
0.0559229814,
0.0283055548,
0.0041787336,
-0.0621472523,
0.0228351504,
-0.0272144135,
0.0160394348,
-0.0227561891,
-0.0527963266,
0.0138290394,
0.083526209,
0.0209304895,
-0.0188831389,
-0.0756578445,
0.0079849483,
-0.0100023458,
-0.0676473379,
-0.0685232133,
0.0110063283,
0.0319560319,
0.0523764901,
-0.0296863709,
-0.0061310888,
0.0790594667,
-0.0398131683,
-0.033826936,
-0.0597669333,
-0.0101235509,
-0.0357186683,
0.032545168,
0.0111460937,
0.0743805096,
0.0054380465,
-0.0166000035,
-0.0608440638,
0.0220891573,
0.033650551,
-0.0154597238,
0.0063061453,
-0.055253502,
-0.034337461,
0.0194536336,
-0.0191542897,
-0.055269707,
-0.0276714452,
0.0281705614,
0.0073462226,
0.0091529097,
0.0291014202,
-0.0300029814,
0.0350348428,
0.0219043139,
0.0315088667,
-0.025683336,
0.0020304364,
-0.0140655469,
0.070556283,
0.0673723817,
0.0017780544,
0.0131148715,
-0.0818363726,
0.105035685,
0.0149337631,
-0.0024337133,
-0.0268430766,
0.0214442443,
0.0244478676,
0.0345541947,
0.0015295311,
-0.0159230679,
-0.0334285386,
0.0717258379,
-0.0344024971,
-0.0428621471,
0.11242605,
0.0070993965,
0.0051610246,
-0.0130347246,
-0.0411123894,
0.0681044087,
0.0243706405,
0.0178410318,
-0.0831822976,
0.0041293208,
-0.0138765462,
0.0040265047,
0.015405816,
0.0029306742,
-0.0395601764,
-0.0956473798,
0.0434282459,
0.0175717138,
-0.0686569661,
-0.0221273955,
-0.0137695484,
-0.0339846015,
0.0010079768,
0.0227504261,
0.0049960413,
0.0215888061,
0.0194346309,
0.0323798582,
0.0186381843,
-0.0707725137,
-0.0253060386,
-0.0114057558,
0.0118913027,
0.0232455824,
0.0526684076,
0.0040726713,
-0.0121951737,
0.0092761526,
-0.0210188143,
0.0078217359,
-0.0331111141,
0.0048342631,
-0.0002804331,
-0.0147380503,
0.0334473923,
0.0456415676,
-0.0039532455,
-0.0151178287,
-0.0040495959,
0.0433967747,
-0.0184495598,
-0.0360392481,
-0.0081209447,
0.000001428,
0.0005640293,
0.0770630613,
0.0460690558,
-0.0346756615,
-0.0093303677,
-0.0250186007,
0.0281875748,
-0.0833049566,
0.0207437333,
0.0478115119,
-0.0209688935,
-0.0186115615,
-0.0440482646,
-0.0841359049,
0.0080121802,
0.0347093828,
0.0105828298,
0.0211428721,
-0.0244559105,
-0.0241536647,
-0.0048365085,
-0.0031968276,
-0.0111324163,
-0.040491268,
0.0081479969,
-0.0176475234,
0.0005536017,
-0.0632597581,
-0.028592879,
0.0269117802,
-0.041211389,
-0.0693731904,
-0.0065840003,
0.0702398196,
0.021705823,
0.0610588081,
0.013911413,
-0.0210449807,
0.0503379591,
-0.0378302485,
0.0308832414,
0.0074607357,
0.0041784141,
0.0096510621,
-0.0236166194,
0.0345942751,
-0.0294624027,
0.0374681279,
-0.0101579828,
0.0583496802,
-0.0324943215,
-0.0330786481,
0.0368208922,
0.0389272682,
-0.0046780016,
-0.0554249324,
0.0032497309,
-0.0580644011,
-0.0024290273,
-0.0366066322,
-0.0127375918,
-0.0548019521,
0.0156648159,
0.0316640995,
-0.0418480672,
-0.0252615903,
0.0415114276,
-0.0309442058,
0.0028517607,
-0.0428980179,
-0.0070892917,
-0.014976576,
0.0074635679,
-0.0103358747,
0.0190088395,
-0.0207377505,
0.0123635884,
0.0112218522,
0.0271235183,
-0.0144313062,
0.082215637,
-0.0115250545,
0.0125688696,
0.0216411166,
0.0263965689,
-0.0467763767,
-0.0270117391,
-0.0272321105,
-0.0057564569,
0.0695351437,
0.0065109781,
0.0943831131,
0.0096755549,
0.0008852055,
0.0082448358,
0.0764947161,
0.0417713486,
-0.0542871952,
0.031683106,
-0.0119215762,
-0.0115580764,
-0.0031743289,
0.0899441019,
-0.0009718087,
0.0423419215,
0.0083827013,
0.0274227858,
-0.0510183573,
0.0101139406,
0.0242433883,
0.0106775807,
0.0104739703,
0.0267064068,
-0.0156354923,
-0.0514185317,
0.0099172024,
-0.002901386,
0.0018385639,
-0.0085333502,
0.0222196132,
0.0782042742,
-0.0385468863,
0.0035946092,
-0.0536438748,
0.0315036848,
-0.024327321,
-0.0132043948,
0.0136295464,
-7.145948443e-33,
-0.0361707918,
-0.0226006489,
0.0045179431,
-0.0531361923,
0.0000297981,
-0.0134699382,
-0.0492849685,
-0.035575591,
-0.0094416421,
0.0021209542,
0.0206508432,
-0.0174057949,
0.0000263841,
0.0362269841,
-0.0212143641,
-0.0022981674,
0.0658955574,
0.0093526356,
-0.0149022173,
0.0220240764,
0.0495009683,
0.0608528033,
0.0621079654,
-0.0403863862,
0.0158686377,
-0.0533577092,
-0.0225635488,
-0.0031756489,
0.0319946408,
0.0377646647,
-0.0310576875,
0.0356273986,
0.0337936878,
-0.0619733483,
-0.0254000165,
-0.0339695066,
-0.0849039778,
-0.0371130407,
0.03103479,
0.0151512669,
-0.0572087243,
-0.0426489376,
0.0327710994,
-0.0267322753,
0.0233524367,
-0.0043512159,
0.0366693363,
-0.005175747,
0.0072088479,
-0.0385608897,
-0.0654373914,
0.010645668,
-0.0341067798,
-0.0275709536,
0.0426022001,
0.1170117334,
-0.0018528545,
0.0358260497,
-0.052324485,
-0.0106538087,
-0.0094143664,
0.0156503618,
0.0826119781,
0.0316746011,
-0.0075855688,
0.0230131838,
-0.0166607536,
-0.0067598643,
-0.0158684626,
0.0158408787,
0.0089155501,
0.0192188788,
0.0133681512,
0.0693457201,
0.0273245052,
0.005539441,
-0.0787205473,
0.0683740526,
-0.0195206292,
0.0134660788,
0.0366449393,
-0.0131354341,
0.0209791958,
-0.0056837779,
-0.0749736875,
-0.064448297,
-0.0304783676,
-0.0377972387,
0.0313465968,
-0.0031733508,
-0.0464743376,
-0.0328701027,
0.0662339851,
-0.0189024694,
-0.0056888969,
0.013396115,
-0.0389385484,
-0.0177471675,
0.0010648787,
0.067442283,
0.0009617836,
-0.0394036286,
-0.0085118134,
0.0212652814,
0.0150344381,
0.0033624838,
0.0146299936,
0.0116127068,
-0.0303226151,
0.0090348395,
-0.0662347525,
0.0396986492,
-0.012295723,
0.0143113453,
-0.005531447,
-0.0028709052,
-0.0327886865,
0.0162660722,
0.0370089486,
0.0053377319,
-0.0181226153,
0.0192794874,
0.0108174393,
0.0559260808,
-0.0416095741,
0.0065866159,
-0.0018257978,
-0.0101073841,
0.0632572994,
-0.0485393219,
-0.0104260016,
0.0403321795,
3.074e-7,
0.0401371866,
0.0190989431,
-0.0111308228,
0.0035764896,
0.0093255956,
0.0338854641,
-0.0190163851,
0.0213275012,
0.0098021459,
-0.0226935279,
-0.0083963927,
0.0370422341,
0.0494110845,
0.0309308395,
-0.0462337583,
-0.0160911307,
-0.0566849448,
0.0162251424,
-0.0128800329,
0.028221814,
0.0487664528,
0.0537780523,
-0.0393023863,
0.0045018876,
-0.0112697342,
-0.0110217007,
0.092624642,
0.0031206515,
-0.0424726866,
0.0290922206,
0.025841184,
0.0330133401,
-0.0104951225,
-0.0133227492,
-0.030019097,
0.0267174207,
0.0330061018,
0.061055541,
0.0018983493,
-0.0139432624,
0.0527895093,
0.0201771986,
-0.0211479105,
-0.0882904157,
0.0525666587,
-0.0290914774,
-0.0194862857,
-0.0030728013,
-0.0328961834,
0.009260118,
0.0371128283,
-0.0512697697,
-0.0302589014,
0.0503697582,
0.0310446061,
-0.0115341609,
-0.0030122565,
-0.0419816673,
-0.0144251091,
0.0001587975,
-0.0448376052,
-0.0053808293,
-0.0267699659,
-0.0487902462,
0.0184550099,
-0.0563132875,
0.0006838812,
2.548442824e-34,
0.0271504205,
-0.0177098755,
-0.0145374853,
0.0331361033,
0.0302960165,
-0.04042615,
-0.0231903903,
0.0180248022,
0.002153446,
-0.068395175,
-0.0297143888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13137v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13137v2 | EMNS /Imz/ Corpus: An emotive single-speaker dataset for narrative storytelling in games, television and graphic novels | 2023-05-22T15:32:32 | 2023-05-25T16:17:24 | Kari Ali Noriy, Xiaosong Yang, Jian Jun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | The increasing adoption of text-to-speech technologies has led to a growing
demand for natural and emotive voices that adapt to a conversation's context
and emotional tone. The Emotive Narrative Storytelling (EMNS) corpus is a
unique speech dataset created to enhance conversations' expressiveness and
emotive quality in interactive narrative-driven systems. The corpus consists of
a 2.3-hour recording featuring a female speaker delivering labelled utterances.
It encompasses eight acted emotional states, evenly distributed with a variance
of 0.68%, along with expressiveness levels and natural language descriptions
with word emphasis labels. The evaluation of audio samples from different
datasets revealed that the EMNS corpus achieved the highest average scores in
accurately conveying emotions and demonstrating expressiveness. It outperformed
other datasets in conveying shared emotions and achieved comparable levels of
genuineness. A classification task confirmed the accurate representation of
intended emotions in the corpus, with participants recognising the recordings
as genuine and expressive. Additionally, the availability of the dataset
collection tool under the Apache 2.0 License simplifies remote speech data
collection for researchers. | [
0.0046283668,
0.0137035251,
-0.0130747119,
-0.008627939,
-0.0000731427,
0.0226170588,
0.0047666854,
-0.0175010338,
-0.042929098,
-0.0065765185,
-0.030218713,
0.0084908698,
0.0222545043,
0.0509404801,
-0.0030918205,
-0.0791250244,
-0.0132095134,
0.0414307192,
0.0857250765,
-0.0029960249,
0.0308030285,
0.0733928978,
-0.0526352115,
0.0517148338,
-0.040821746,
-0.0310164988,
-0.0151437493,
0.0486980863,
0.0474991053,
-0.0199803784,
0.0207335595,
-0.0113261528,
0.0341344438,
-0.0322702006,
0.0000019978,
-0.0277597066,
-0.0055972715,
-0.0370949432,
-0.001594751,
0.0065593715,
0.0692242905,
0.0341779068,
-0.0056096483,
0.0141546698,
0.0111030098,
-0.0312426407,
0.0725663081,
0.0322755836,
0.0771818087,
0.0487970896,
-0.0278760474,
-0.0012022036,
-0.0396713167,
-0.0036259538,
-0.0153628485,
0.0651740283,
-0.0303000789,
-0.0122426189,
0.0526600182,
-0.0911014006,
-0.0128535591,
0.016958952,
-0.0260606743,
0.0053665931,
-0.0089962287,
0.0192871913,
-0.0232695602,
-0.021664355,
-0.0026058436,
0.0585609153,
0.0574528761,
0.0417319797,
0.024040252,
-0.0045916876,
0.0041623209,
0.0004094595,
0.0018679332,
-0.0055918666,
-0.0041161203,
-0.0077238311,
-0.0440144539,
0.0660814568,
-0.0137091773,
-0.0015083007,
0.0446732976,
-0.0133599797,
-0.0049169911,
0.0146660767,
-0.016045073,
-0.0517427772,
-0.0008936979,
-0.0448750407,
0.0133333169,
-0.012631977,
-0.0072531765,
0.0198694114,
-0.0301700402,
-0.0127855623,
-0.0372748189,
-0.0281815585,
-0.0031976823,
0.0298732016,
-0.0086311083,
-0.0149464132,
0.0555561408,
-0.0010369389,
0.0647572353,
-0.0273184311,
-0.0061129327,
0.033671435,
-0.017276125,
-0.0066213137,
-0.0352305919,
0.0170107521,
-0.0316743068,
-0.0423819534,
-0.0783294514,
-0.0217621531,
-0.0332880467,
0.0174595565,
-0.0458159745,
0.0105819469,
-0.0053945836,
0.0115682594,
-0.0030996304,
0.0162463523,
-0.061145395,
0.0549299046,
0.0325495042,
-0.0629598647,
0.0078537986,
-0.0088019632,
0.0408086739,
0.0054985727,
0.0507822745,
-0.002647086,
0.025066942,
-0.0390407369,
-0.0435136333,
0.0038334224,
-0.0237014573,
-0.0383522399,
-0.023626158,
-0.0292337351,
0.0336754099,
-0.0177170858,
0.0215085484,
-0.0020267209,
0.0043922476,
-0.0136804329,
0.0339680314,
0.0078254649,
-0.0065073245,
0.0312684774,
0.0438480601,
0.0042610271,
0.0233744122,
0.0074708587,
0.0891930014,
-0.0007181949,
0.0272560809,
-0.0322834514,
0.0346800908,
0.0212524794,
-0.0301560499,
0.0028464685,
-0.0279416069,
-0.0361697748,
-0.0248016696,
0.0863577649,
0.0417864248,
0.0059223394,
-0.0291232225,
-0.021699097,
0.0762684271,
0.0919821039,
0.0044904142,
0.0116449175,
0.0120445816,
0.0541866384,
0.0307665076,
-0.0117006525,
0.0269907936,
0.0121233854,
0.0423566625,
-0.0223292485,
-0.0182244871,
0.0086533986,
-0.0238514487,
-0.0176909342,
-0.0213703122,
-0.0165113471,
-0.0109512936,
0.0137696844,
-0.0334925018,
-0.0083676986,
-0.0227419958,
0.0093609653,
0.0196730923,
-0.1249082237,
0.01115565,
-0.0053335335,
0.0195930526,
0.0649871528,
-0.001966997,
-0.0104422364,
-0.0204629488,
-0.045075994,
-0.0330037102,
0.025723448,
-0.0302577093,
-0.0170767251,
0.0704788342,
-0.065196082,
0.04841749,
-0.0322062634,
-0.0025816583,
0.0195397586,
-0.0946271271,
0.0363432616,
-0.0188994985,
-0.0026997663,
-0.0056746672,
0.0001441347,
-0.0497096181,
-0.0362549238,
-0.0217985772,
0.0050187004,
-0.0013384027,
0.0289111305,
-0.0609812774,
-0.0294035226,
0.0279354416,
0.0151497917,
-0.0001373745,
0.0971053168,
-0.0423622578,
0.0027589924,
0.0128211752,
-0.0920361429,
0.0162338708,
0.0002048341,
0.0135677345,
-0.0298557226,
0.0427608117,
-0.052871529,
0.0394145437,
-0.011916372,
-0.0035533551,
-0.0184110589,
0.047019247,
0.0354904309,
-0.035625048,
0.0034057877,
-0.0047655138,
-0.0040629576,
-0.0343072787,
-0.0248565283,
-0.0484562181,
0.0079714656,
0.0323688947,
0.023408236,
-0.012519679,
-0.0203721486,
-0.0548448302,
-0.0778165907,
-0.0490224697,
-0.0911713094,
-0.000578541,
0.0204355884,
-0.0114608761,
0.0032883906,
-0.0021142233,
-0.0758564696,
0.0244325325,
-0.0555100292,
-0.0243202075,
0.0085301325,
-0.042083893,
-0.0119878231,
0.0115556112,
0.0006647672,
-0.0232353657,
0.0281080101,
-0.0301381238,
0.0208728611,
-0.0035993981,
0.0079284608,
0.0031468484,
0.0149766486,
-0.0126769794,
0.0042408933,
-0.0114262942,
-0.0851040706,
0.0005474832,
0.0321002156,
0.0382762849,
0.0029504998,
0.0045775902,
0.0334326066,
0.0182076804,
-0.0581799969,
-0.0319662392,
0.0149810631,
0.0282776672,
0.0728798807,
-0.0473790616,
-0.0330669507,
0.0130131617,
0.0297633354,
0.0304541383,
0.0475514755,
-0.0261684414,
-0.0030336,
0.0349489748,
-0.0309947971,
0.0355807133,
-0.0629976988,
-0.0213911142,
-0.0078184241,
0.0044051148,
0.0034357223,
0.0161487926,
-0.0292304382,
-0.0732340738,
-0.04004924,
-0.0263156053,
0.0022194632,
0.0434650816,
-0.0885286331,
0.0137191219,
0.0321784876,
-0.021266086,
-0.0011894413,
-0.0656290352,
0.0248082113,
-0.0474662222,
-0.0208282396,
-0.0100223897,
-0.0413868912,
0.0392844006,
0.0082032308,
0.0219504088,
-0.0317381471,
-0.0168797784,
-0.0400131606,
0.0210272335,
-0.016863618,
-0.0250459332,
-0.0038265421,
0.0212116018,
0.0106117539,
-0.0107841101,
-0.0050427727,
0.0136600165,
-0.0071382229,
0.0462257527,
0.0433583707,
-0.0038036159,
-0.0281507391,
0.0827395841,
0.0220320057,
-0.0147214755,
-0.0027138253,
-0.0093783876,
0.0354660787,
0.0262592863,
0.0018490381,
0.0062574004,
-0.0242020134,
0.050701946,
-0.0408562608,
0.0518352352,
0.0750366524,
-0.0091824504,
-0.0050937347,
0.0156705212,
-0.017307438,
0.0185195059,
0.0168190375,
0.0161651168,
-0.0517566763,
0.0127173821,
0.0598705113,
0.0604478568,
-0.0344907939,
-0.0282233544,
-0.0270883422,
-0.0933903679,
0.0494447947,
0.0202202238,
0.0051187347,
-0.0053854152,
-0.006318986,
-0.0053105219,
0.0194625072,
0.0040565967,
-0.0246638078,
0.0057698991,
-0.0086321123,
0.0294943545,
-0.0447044857,
-0.011210206,
0.0235395152,
-0.0373130962,
0.0942924544,
-0.0207799505,
0.1085379943,
-0.0221950412,
-0.0196278654,
-0.0749630108,
0.031345509,
0.0006289847,
0.0176363494,
0.0340954028,
-0.023012165,
-0.0045859311,
-0.0238954071,
0.0705708936,
0.0243292898,
-0.0117410142,
0.0049171736,
0.0187457427,
-0.0378894955,
-0.0015072712,
-0.0175321624,
0.0529985055,
0.048623316,
0.0208939388,
0.0284391157,
-0.0523941964,
0.0103224777,
0.0363659188,
0.0592054278,
-0.0021016113,
-0.0276156459,
0.0244831294,
0.0180981699,
-0.0328656137,
-0.0551880263,
-0.0665245429,
0.0191406496,
0.043692708,
0.0030638289,
-0.055768542,
0.0035033624,
0.0109343091,
-0.0236082636,
0.0361448005,
0.0258887354,
0.0224718768,
0.005140557,
-0.0095083648,
0.0306374598,
-0.0369154848,
0.0133260032,
0.0068298937,
-0.0007987784,
-0.0375944264,
0.0451132134,
-0.0057759755,
0.0122129498,
0.0207775403,
0.037938226,
-0.0749932602,
0.0556335747,
-0.0046689091,
-0.0737274811,
0.0409788229,
0.0372230634,
0.0491703115,
-0.0149881802,
-0.0115435673,
-0.002214584,
0.0460864045,
-0.0186373405,
-0.0057324558,
0.0261408426,
-0.0519831479,
-0.0341934487,
0.0387828723,
0.0273660868,
-0.0370482728,
-0.0034472158,
-0.0580260493,
-0.006871155,
-0.0460659042,
0.0289337616,
-0.0405607745,
-0.0075611337,
-0.0098645482,
0.0461832024,
-0.0365796685,
-0.0508292802,
-0.0427774452,
-0.0508406572,
-0.0208966285,
0.0483064912,
0.0369487703,
-0.0439828299,
-0.0320760012,
0.0508764051,
-0.010557821,
0.037593469,
-0.0488778539,
0.0355775841,
-0.0025738897,
-0.0002735949,
0.0140061164,
-0.0503760278,
0.0394324549,
0.0387385488,
-0.0038809036,
0.0459640324,
0.0049914857,
-0.0076340833,
0.0214331355,
-0.0072314357,
0.0480979234,
-0.0052499976,
0.043016497,
-0.0090770358,
-0.0033672326,
-0.0341333039,
-0.0145283742,
-0.0195920467,
-0.002995248,
-0.0573814325,
0.0204628445,
-0.0127215153,
-0.0738924146,
0.0839164332,
-0.0025320041,
-0.0009151936,
-0.0372561552,
0.0093226582,
0.037201073,
-0.038211558,
0.0046179653,
-0.0090435203,
-0.073438853,
-0.0368259549,
0.0766285583,
-0.0114436476,
-0.008933505,
-0.053398516,
0.01748427,
-0.0001997015,
-0.0049818596,
0.0475366004,
-0.0095599452,
-0.0208478551,
-0.066895999,
0.0052835615,
0.0200908501,
-5.583434699e-33,
-0.0008925874,
0.0176027827,
-0.038831614,
0.0252336152,
-0.0803985074,
0.0133109149,
-0.0202736575,
0.0267074108,
0.0162540581,
0.071633704,
-0.0318512917,
0.0312543176,
0.0032563724,
0.0054177772,
-0.0271954332,
0.0016584549,
0.0180608183,
0.0094168875,
-0.0392521024,
0.0179096479,
0.0361166075,
0.0411801822,
0.0538101345,
-0.0980396792,
-0.0065750084,
0.0205866918,
-0.0377439298,
-0.0384322032,
0.083602041,
0.0172790978,
0.028406892,
0.0736539215,
-0.0223575067,
0.0120720249,
0.0086430004,
0.0086133601,
-0.0045347111,
-0.0378340557,
0.0021142019,
0.0085988753,
-0.0246549398,
-0.0386364311,
0.0135563817,
0.0371091515,
-0.0264817178,
-0.0394181721,
0.0262098964,
0.0028091171,
0.0594122671,
-0.0495447367,
-0.0365354419,
0.0067883991,
-0.0513177104,
-0.0478553288,
-0.00331337,
0.0650940165,
-0.0148913665,
-0.0288179629,
-0.02758082,
0.0358983278,
-0.0365317389,
-0.0159603301,
0.0035499514,
-0.0076261079,
0.0192720797,
0.1098387167,
0.0329373553,
-0.0187035482,
-0.0171697251,
0.0661878809,
0.0332204476,
0.031010272,
0.039031215,
0.0497906022,
-0.0448109061,
-0.027635606,
0.0175900534,
0.0223407205,
0.0489808731,
-0.0091196084,
0.0111684715,
0.0362989195,
-0.0231383648,
-0.0128614204,
-0.0478628278,
-0.0235937163,
0.0103947315,
-0.0224830341,
0.0238934793,
-0.0543262549,
-0.0091612283,
-0.0221449751,
0.003270953,
-0.0107503906,
0.0215008594,
-0.018128613,
-0.0499821231,
0.0380387753,
-0.002409128,
-0.0030512523,
0.042634476,
0.0185581408,
0.0731959194,
0.0442897454,
0.1091372669,
-0.0079160407,
-0.0578231215,
0.0830403045,
-0.0425343029,
0.0008311893,
0.0216217563,
0.0576939732,
-0.0225205813,
-0.0353915691,
-0.019616466,
-0.0211055856,
-0.0227616187,
-0.0132242395,
-0.0141427433,
0.0588150136,
0.0173818935,
-0.0379626006,
-0.0284024738,
0.0307664946,
-0.0523368753,
0.0265470129,
0.0092429621,
-0.0278007891,
0.0619402379,
-0.0003028719,
-0.0128436396,
-0.0111156106,
2.924e-7,
-0.0692267716,
0.0248048455,
0.0474856384,
-0.008422697,
0.0125346538,
0.0462825149,
-0.0037818863,
0.0367833637,
0.0474180058,
-0.0540389828,
0.0383367501,
-0.030735774,
0.0842151567,
0.0219642706,
-0.0991560221,
-0.0084218979,
-0.0699273869,
0.0032016598,
-0.0144269941,
0.023206532,
0.1039777398,
0.0345783047,
0.0526591986,
-0.0100810807,
0.03141018,
0.0141691035,
-0.0134986257,
-0.0784162283,
-0.0128404796,
-0.0066152406,
-0.0289515965,
-0.0428426266,
-0.0176781323,
-0.0416862555,
0.0009105366,
0.0245561656,
0.0130241625,
0.0588796623,
-0.0219859779,
-0.0155085661,
0.0283517689,
0.0569819808,
-0.0860331357,
0.0184291769,
0.021382492,
-0.03307385,
-0.0615382865,
-0.0169058796,
-0.011735877,
-0.0108259544,
0.0341205932,
-0.0392057821,
-0.0292593762,
0.0214789379,
0.0043411404,
0.0011349602,
-0.0048188413,
-0.0537633151,
0.0142001593,
0.0052414858,
-0.0401332527,
-0.0484366976,
-0.0007417338,
0.0040690796,
-0.0003077033,
-0.0486175418,
0.0058897282,
2.244949239e-34,
-0.0353871584,
-0.0004517033,
-0.0136742769,
0.0348893106,
0.0374060236,
0.0059182825,
0.0390854925,
0.0109362137,
0.0445147827,
-0.0485598259,
0.0058889543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13120v1 | Partial Annotation Learning for Biomedical Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T15:18:38 | 2023-05-22T15:18:38 | Liangping Ding, Giovanni Colavizza, Zhixiong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Motivation: Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key task to support
biomedical research. In Biomedical Named Entity Recognition (BioNER), obtaining
high-quality expert annotated data is laborious and expensive, leading to the
development of automatic approaches such as distant supervision. However,
manually and automatically generated data often suffer from the unlabeled
entity problem, whereby many entity annotations are missing, degrading the
performance of full annotation NER models. Results: To address this problem, we
systematically study the effectiveness of partial annotation learning methods
for biomedical entity recognition over different simulated scenarios of missing
entity annotations. Furthermore, we propose a TS-PubMedBERT-Partial-CRF partial
annotation learning model. We harmonize 15 biomedical NER corpora encompassing
five entity types to serve as a gold standard and compare against two commonly
used partial annotation learning models, BiLSTM-Partial-CRF and EER-PubMedBERT,
and the state-of-the-art full annotation learning BioNER model PubMedBERT
tagger. Results show that partial annotation learning-based methods can
effectively learn from biomedical corpora with missing entity annotations. Our
proposed model outperforms alternatives and, specifically, the PubMedBERT
tagger by 38% in F1-score under high missing entity rates. The recall of entity
mentions in our model is also competitive with the upper bound on the fully
annotated dataset. | [
0.0555584542,
-0.0065316414,
0.0481165685,
-0.041407112,
0.0390129201,
0.0638805702,
0.0170012228,
0.0207027085,
0.0619080663,
-0.029636601,
-0.0398131236,
0.0009813155,
-0.0354633592,
-0.0201583188,
0.0423240513,
-0.0112160817,
0.034601517,
0.0329068564,
0.051961042,
0.0155729335,
-0.024719594,
-0.0133800488,
-0.0321066007,
0.0169982035,
0.0168646537,
0.0095707979,
0.0245361943,
-0.0029959595,
0.0706163421,
-0.0755300447,
0.0369612202,
0.0293711741,
-0.0368134379,
0.0388524644,
0.0000017413,
-0.0408135504,
-0.0567759685,
0.0531299077,
-0.0247336458,
-0.0154075697,
0.0099442778,
-0.0222858433,
0.0150795775,
-0.0086463643,
-0.0078527639,
-0.0574886277,
0.0563706271,
0.0651250109,
0.0075676162,
0.0470623076,
0.0025775786,
0.0149580082,
0.0436124653,
0.01030441,
0.0273310877,
-0.0226734616,
0.0605799071,
0.0085908789,
0.0146537768,
0.0225055628,
0.0239656568,
0.0233543105,
-0.0296764486,
0.0384876765,
0.0741832331,
0.0555822439,
-0.0206913892,
-0.029328784,
0.0164283141,
0.0730257556,
0.0015464915,
-0.0146396132,
0.0663449094,
-0.0057226876,
-0.0406373478,
0.0120846266,
-0.0294685662,
-0.0268473327,
-0.043359071,
-0.0106202606,
0.0052617434,
-0.0164246317,
0.0442818291,
0.0015515264,
0.0150345461,
-0.0037459065,
0.0091695683,
-0.0434119813,
0.0033786015,
0.0209763665,
-0.0203526486,
-0.0221466478,
0.0579345338,
0.0274331234,
0.0106905429,
0.0118414592,
0.0041135359,
-0.0419479683,
0.0696828216,
-0.0448420309,
-0.0372824967,
-0.0027034716,
-0.0441410765,
0.052896753,
-0.0653492659,
-0.0370409861,
-0.0188355334,
0.0449161679,
0.0357722677,
-0.0103528732,
-0.0649528131,
0.0008526862,
-0.0217531845,
0.0763261914,
0.0218551755,
-0.007317883,
-0.0612530895,
-0.0340169966,
-0.0162459295,
0.0331317671,
0.0181409996,
0.0068568164,
-0.0359346233,
0.018346129,
0.0089020291,
0.0138968863,
0.0005027129,
-0.0216961913,
-0.0521411076,
-0.0364053734,
-0.010804899,
-0.0365036353,
0.0239946265,
-0.0456539877,
0.0351638421,
0.0255962424,
0.0392736793,
-0.1070959643,
-0.0269235075,
0.0047099083,
0.016066594,
-0.0452589281,
0.0116445385,
-0.0044086236,
0.0398585349,
0.022435965,
0.0128888693,
-0.0499740057,
0.0176604576,
-0.0157757532,
-0.0215468518,
0.0944700316,
-0.1046729237,
-0.0594239086,
0.0227755457,
0.0057170046,
0.0066476227,
0.0197625402,
0.013363733,
-0.0505311303,
-0.0222531203,
0.0018183411,
-0.0050789928,
-0.0243786387,
0.0423224308,
-0.0656228215,
0.0378664508,
-0.0143704871,
0.0298010819,
0.0562915392,
0.0014304538,
0.0340992175,
-0.0145875001,
-0.0266568325,
-0.0108751431,
0.0280669685,
-0.0094984025,
0.001207286,
0.040875949,
0.0055639334,
0.0205322783,
-0.0196150858,
-0.0182025451,
0.0287324414,
-0.0108596617,
0.0341956839,
0.017595442,
0.0216649361,
-0.002061472,
0.0190585461,
-0.0100169685,
-0.0161455832,
-0.034866102,
0.0030271579,
0.0854337811,
-0.0123275295,
-0.0522156693,
0.0879033804,
0.0707314312,
-0.0319966562,
0.0282734912,
0.0069593634,
0.0055071404,
0.0382768698,
0.0276118685,
-0.0736831948,
-0.0642980039,
-0.0465953834,
-0.0434431024,
0.0146453464,
0.0120588914,
-0.0160929244,
0.0224706773,
-0.0451442823,
-0.0100978483,
0.0255176052,
0.0456164144,
0.0009503054,
0.0031393603,
0.0105394991,
-0.005074901,
-0.0577550307,
-0.0211532731,
0.0430088043,
-0.066481173,
-0.0174556822,
-0.0340471901,
-0.0047513349,
0.0154724289,
0.0438614301,
-0.0191952512,
0.0147040393,
0.0591551624,
-0.0339327902,
-0.0301512647,
-0.0487186834,
0.0299268421,
-0.0565514117,
0.0352313779,
-0.0079641994,
-0.0197785962,
-0.0318449549,
-0.0184729937,
-0.026611926,
-0.0560485087,
0.0175422058,
0.0182913337,
-0.0149391405,
0.0233269334,
0.0168422423,
-0.0125521421,
-0.0271746945,
0.0430197828,
-0.0228810273,
0.0640625879,
0.0103784427,
-0.062444903,
0.0160477683,
-0.0370682925,
-0.0350887291,
-0.0134257786,
-0.0047763088,
-0.0609392561,
-0.0193527564,
-0.0247971211,
-0.0681599453,
-0.0021065066,
-0.0889384449,
0.0130740507,
0.0388329402,
0.0305476841,
-0.0032863948,
0.0430304222,
0.0069538108,
-0.0438227877,
0.0222563446,
-0.0318331681,
-0.0662844703,
-0.0015083232,
0.0288316496,
0.0274131652,
-0.0078108571,
-0.0086650988,
0.0146846352,
-0.0566755682,
0.0240436532,
0.018123582,
-0.0785204321,
-0.00019225,
0.0133686522,
-0.0406288169,
0.0046362025,
0.0236654952,
0.0277085137,
-0.0098592993,
0.0377994366,
-0.0451127104,
0.0262396149,
-0.0125019336,
0.0232619029,
0.0041998462,
0.0158886202,
-0.0563211963,
0.0393285267,
-0.0320614874,
0.0290534552,
0.0185537059,
-0.034323819,
-0.0012787984,
0.0517400876,
-0.0298713315,
0.0088715982,
-0.0389321409,
0.0052028149,
-0.010097567,
0.0057135243,
-0.0118838074,
0.0599810667,
-0.0431797877,
0.0114230653,
-0.0055608745,
-0.0215207692,
0.0941743106,
-0.026216289,
-0.0010863793,
-0.0273769144,
0.0150075611,
-0.0236708634,
-0.0411554314,
0.0344795138,
0.0088619143,
0.0327184983,
-0.0581265166,
0.0231088996,
0.0654946044,
0.0037724152,
-0.0420980006,
-0.0138597991,
0.0235735141,
0.0453409255,
-0.0094809439,
0.0013033564,
-0.0213165749,
0.0062279147,
-0.0523049496,
0.0217809398,
-0.0041312426,
-0.0182416458,
-0.0149292015,
0.0388089828,
-0.0031227355,
0.0534642413,
0.0263982955,
-0.0121426582,
-0.0311586075,
0.0073458347,
0.0336916,
-0.0271815974,
0.0126857124,
-0.0169746876,
-0.0140808094,
0.0463326015,
-0.005356939,
-0.0034143643,
0.0095800851,
-0.0115865581,
0.0140434057,
-0.0591856129,
0.0103248302,
-0.0082182391,
0.048841767,
-0.0038059903,
0.007972749,
0.0879975036,
0.028999418,
-0.040014863,
-0.0139993792,
0.0251629464,
-0.0084470669,
0.0113690114,
0.0284199286,
-0.107968837,
-0.023284601,
-0.0094047142,
0.0083248317,
-0.0280151721,
-0.0979232118,
0.0178640615,
-0.0590644963,
0.0186945181,
-0.0138598429,
-0.084394455,
0.0194601025,
-0.0779661313,
-0.0006284146,
-0.05043336,
-0.0448671468,
-0.0188991539,
-0.0239689741,
0.0112087466,
0.0410842933,
-0.0333350115,
-0.0977508202,
-0.0020697529,
-0.0417446494,
0.0737808943,
0.0229732264,
0.0389887281,
-0.0096004698,
0.0118266009,
-0.003810483,
-0.0019991836,
-0.0278576259,
-0.0327689983,
0.0984691158,
-0.029560376,
-0.0205951761,
-0.0093880566,
-0.00129938,
-0.01103763,
-0.0244857408,
-0.01526275,
0.0759061053,
-0.0043979171,
0.0228468459,
-0.0197124407,
-0.012391814,
0.0178492349,
0.0655791014,
0.0071326783,
-0.0095326435,
-0.0268836096,
0.0573222078,
0.0572199374,
-0.0123598613,
0.0290926415,
0.0049964199,
-0.0993629396,
-0.0413419455,
-0.0393428914,
-0.0379669182,
0.0723909587,
0.0141599774,
0.0224724039,
0.0330103599,
0.0186847057,
0.0042573167,
-0.0461007394,
0.0437262803,
-0.0067594838,
-0.0155673567,
-0.0129433433,
-0.056842085,
0.0656228438,
0.0068092193,
-0.0206287038,
0.0043716389,
-0.0209143329,
-0.0416309536,
-0.0132007999,
0.0508797094,
0.0110260714,
0.0199691374,
0.0066526076,
-0.0309757702,
0.015270235,
0.0685444698,
-0.0397623554,
-0.0323852003,
-0.0079410356,
-0.0041968036,
-0.0328369401,
0.0053622555,
-0.0253722519,
0.004838252,
0.0211927649,
0.0650107935,
-0.0174208079,
0.0028706938,
0.0490272567,
0.0335544497,
0.0725046694,
-0.0342416056,
0.0062084151,
-0.0538275167,
0.0070009665,
0.0403555147,
0.0478673577,
-0.0214714464,
-0.0000581406,
0.0325542837,
0.0163431261,
-0.022932684,
0.0272846594,
-0.0363446735,
0.0453139395,
-0.026626233,
0.0043908302,
0.0189587567,
0.0133196143,
0.01749813,
-0.0503058918,
-0.0014371293,
0.0238507949,
0.0431003645,
-0.0024134659,
-0.010242668,
0.0101493029,
0.0002147492,
0.0535568818,
-0.0399099924,
-0.0159119684,
-0.0413805358,
0.0335008614,
-0.0625226051,
0.0897815675,
0.0448561609,
0.0236143414,
0.0520127006,
-0.0002116486,
-0.0300291292,
-0.0049091899,
0.0299859699,
-0.0372305773,
0.0255861115,
0.0734561458,
0.0117366603,
-0.0212474279,
0.0046561044,
0.0517909601,
0.029663574,
0.08929912,
-0.0037585038,
-0.0437819622,
-0.0453373268,
0.0095391329,
0.0021875952,
0.00410181,
-0.0369093306,
0.003333126,
-0.0300884638,
-0.0353075862,
0.0587271824,
-0.0267753638,
-0.0580062568,
-0.0086768875,
0.0289621986,
-0.0143367928,
0.0068889791,
-0.0537971854,
-0.0260535572,
0.0050361818,
0.0284637604,
-0.0412215367,
-0.0011761128,
-6.00066797e-33,
-0.0186514687,
-0.0609291606,
0.0025895208,
-0.0119257886,
-0.0074788071,
0.0147490893,
-0.0321053974,
-0.0248863138,
0.0147472648,
0.0076937727,
0.0027009912,
-0.003983404,
0.0172500778,
-0.0013935708,
0.01796747,
-0.035450805,
0.0517634861,
0.0282741468,
0.0123312296,
0.0124826673,
0.0285161566,
0.0799577162,
0.0631459653,
-0.0982790142,
0.0447959267,
0.0237388946,
0.0075420663,
-0.0133762481,
0.037016023,
0.0515850261,
-0.0541758314,
-0.0078873327,
0.0030830225,
-0.0228546187,
-0.0091873566,
-0.036577858,
-0.1486232281,
0.0277734715,
-0.0334259905,
0.0017480912,
-0.012071738,
-0.0367884114,
0.0112018222,
-0.021712983,
-0.0028854692,
0.0038890142,
0.0591840483,
-0.0080620172,
-0.0542816073,
-0.0759436861,
-0.0526207164,
0.0526299737,
-0.0136771556,
0.0566974096,
0.0237619001,
-0.004754425,
0.0105180042,
0.0474585481,
-0.0546336584,
-0.0273711625,
0.0341207422,
-0.0331609696,
-0.0048783915,
-0.0089939814,
0.0052711121,
0.0520656109,
0.0596673153,
-0.0086098853,
0.0070418133,
0.0038611952,
-0.0290718526,
0.0104282983,
0.0135226585,
0.0216451157,
0.0417389348,
-0.0039185691,
-0.067497015,
0.0216605514,
-0.031246271,
0.02021618,
-0.0133377155,
0.0159744322,
-0.0244558454,
0.0139818098,
0.0007714682,
-0.023760505,
-0.0240259338,
-0.0312135089,
0.0085129766,
-0.0106185367,
-0.0668187886,
0.0594714731,
0.0085477233,
-0.0231767446,
-0.0536285713,
-0.0192606002,
0.068351768,
0.0311846714,
-0.0225806311,
-0.0281653721,
-0.0505044907,
-0.050184764,
0.0197292101,
-0.020499507,
0.0457449704,
-0.0189557672,
0.0583826564,
-0.0481597148,
-0.033006575,
-0.0231045764,
0.0111073423,
0.0052307253,
-0.0110824425,
0.0246914383,
0.0215596128,
0.0021437875,
0.0088462122,
0.0318946242,
0.0564205535,
0.0235761572,
0.0114298332,
0.0156853776,
0.0187955201,
0.0006961403,
-0.0153524159,
-0.0127703324,
0.0019121602,
0.0331276059,
-0.02826472,
-0.069500871,
0.0077846446,
-0.0226487257,
2.594e-7,
0.0745493919,
0.0186813455,
0.0211911984,
-0.0768870786,
-0.0227722712,
-0.004411201,
0.0127633503,
0.0076494408,
-0.0225284323,
0.0080350805,
0.0356267765,
-0.0416847095,
0.0064511988,
0.0138528114,
-0.096485801,
-0.0525136814,
-0.0612696223,
-0.0304809809,
-0.0241702478,
0.0028205921,
-0.0065166685,
0.0256392732,
-0.0116186226,
-0.0079091424,
-0.0044194511,
-0.0062166094,
0.0646569207,
-0.0145722423,
0.002511665,
0.0626079366,
0.0374308899,
0.0583574213,
0.0127735017,
0.0326808132,
-0.0251103826,
-0.0124942493,
0.0391433463,
0.0493772738,
-0.0083026979,
0.0049548843,
0.0415543132,
0.0013198053,
0.0519538,
-0.0120776901,
0.0350864306,
-0.0757832751,
-0.0230725296,
0.03332581,
-0.0342872962,
-0.0125774052,
0.0472630076,
-0.0124407243,
0.0069216872,
0.0364795476,
0.0135847023,
-0.0175249521,
-0.0235128831,
-0.0562673248,
0.0142027084,
0.0759172365,
-0.0112005882,
-0.0364303552,
0.0207722504,
-0.0001352732,
0.0094690183,
-0.0779303387,
0.0008708943,
2.071268801e-34,
0.0179227553,
-0.0184397623,
0.0048219934,
0.0789009109,
-0.0161801092,
-0.0317575447,
-0.0392447896,
0.0023889085,
-0.006073202,
-0.033290945,
0.0154152941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13119v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13119v2 | Ambiguity Meets Uncertainty: Investigating Uncertainty Estimation for Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-05-22T15:18:15 | 2023-06-10T03:27:31 | Zhu Liu, Ying Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word sense disambiguation (WSD), which aims to determine an appropriate sense
for a target word given its context, is crucial for natural language
understanding. Existing supervised methods treat WSD as a classification task
and have achieved remarkable performance. However, they ignore uncertainty
estimation (UE) in the real-world setting, where the data is always noisy and
out of distribution. This paper extensively studies UE on the benchmark
designed for WSD. Specifically, we first compare four uncertainty scores for a
state-of-the-art WSD model and verify that the conventional predictive
probabilities obtained at the end of the model are inadequate to quantify
uncertainty. Then, we examine the capability of capturing data and model
uncertainties by the model with the selected UE score on well-designed test
scenarios and discover that the model reflects data uncertainty satisfactorily
but underestimates model uncertainty. Furthermore, we explore numerous lexical
properties that intrinsically affect data uncertainty and provide a detailed
analysis of four critical aspects: the syntactic category, morphology, sense
granularity, and semantic relations. The code is available at
https://github.com/RyanLiut/WSD-UE. | [
0.0146738682,
0.0357004702,
-0.0051125726,
0.030949939,
-0.0265351888,
0.0235102084,
-0.0477498211,
-0.0012573146,
-0.0351464376,
-0.0356952921,
0.0061019277,
-0.0493082479,
0.0637463704,
-0.0055074901,
-0.021127725,
-0.0166702941,
0.0893038437,
-0.0155527862,
-0.0388506539,
0.0009183435,
-0.0221805368,
0.0030650389,
-0.0024225244,
-0.0199934486,
-0.0462760702,
0.010096224,
0.0255332422,
0.0407467782,
0.0218006279,
-0.0243192166,
0.0125034107,
0.043360088,
0.0188489594,
0.0657186508,
0.0000021382,
-0.0757414177,
-0.0574957728,
-0.008107949,
-0.0359065644,
-0.0294201039,
0.0539214648,
-0.008114744,
0.0091014104,
-0.017707875,
0.0025843431,
0.0296454746,
0.0258516837,
-0.0509802289,
-0.0070474255,
-0.0201446488,
-0.0004733813,
-0.0315232873,
-0.028391609,
0.0084789665,
0.01121502,
-0.041082684,
0.0132515915,
-0.0071045612,
-0.0361102,
-0.0266184937,
-0.0535806753,
0.0546962582,
-0.0073210206,
0.0613992102,
-0.009386098,
-0.0207970291,
0.0155331567,
-0.0387579985,
0.0058600176,
0.0188431088,
0.0171821304,
-0.0044866088,
-0.0131143117,
-0.017180467,
-0.0241979193,
0.0640248284,
0.0341691487,
0.0026915076,
-0.012648006,
0.0005387388,
0.0113930879,
0.0383432135,
0.0277357791,
0.0554576069,
-0.0009679581,
0.0932704061,
-0.0225011837,
0.0097367736,
0.0141980788,
-0.0015072381,
-0.0210582092,
-0.005891134,
0.031991072,
-0.0117055345,
-0.0421906002,
0.0475242212,
-0.0425925329,
-0.0639546812,
0.0357820578,
-0.0581737384,
-0.0353784524,
0.0187628753,
0.0257825181,
0.0365126878,
0.0260127503,
-0.0017140722,
0.0564517267,
-0.0006040089,
-0.0478767827,
-0.0195351057,
-0.0513617471,
0.0428491011,
-0.04763541,
0.0248642415,
-0.043432828,
-0.007447144,
-0.0714082345,
-0.0152535941,
0.0004213644,
-0.0045827352,
-0.0013012544,
-0.0011250392,
-0.0751350969,
-0.0075148395,
-0.0442309305,
0.0013550131,
-0.0140391113,
0.0012018709,
-0.0478371009,
-0.0247410946,
0.0170736574,
0.0142743764,
-0.0161141977,
-0.0202866141,
0.0115146572,
0.0462714098,
-0.0098605305,
-0.0463305265,
-0.0358606018,
-0.0355613604,
-0.0623068959,
-0.0037508325,
-0.0454895422,
-0.0446182154,
-0.0353588238,
0.0291756205,
0.0291304942,
-0.0695439801,
-0.0015937638,
-0.0386964716,
-0.0230233781,
0.1249415427,
-0.0523900352,
-0.0063253739,
0.0276804976,
0.0201185923,
0.0019753925,
0.0592081845,
0.0459008068,
0.0410951115,
0.0489417054,
0.0640638545,
-0.066170834,
-0.0131516233,
-0.0344292,
-0.0058755782,
-0.027831167,
-0.0038155937,
-0.0573168397,
0.0418491773,
0.0125402743,
0.0626613796,
-0.0199302305,
-0.0134071195,
0.0282167345,
0.0184542704,
-0.0082199518,
-0.0620290302,
0.0116980551,
0.026983643,
0.0134573085,
-0.024774693,
-0.0193143338,
-0.0352903157,
-0.0367385522,
0.0323786251,
-0.0316083059,
0.0190926231,
0.0366224758,
-0.0687858835,
-0.0531753227,
-0.0526423231,
0.0434764847,
0.0347685553,
0.061032366,
-0.0013444133,
-0.0095729381,
0.0239811502,
0.032604225,
-0.0108257756,
0.0363348462,
-0.0620636865,
0.0148500577,
0.0711154863,
0.0426445752,
-0.0400748998,
-0.0501446836,
-0.001231831,
-0.0281576365,
-0.0038917463,
0.0082075614,
-0.0193748213,
0.0287874527,
-0.0486381911,
-0.0276275259,
0.0309891794,
0.0198968612,
-0.0253601745,
0.0294440296,
0.0254320595,
0.024859596,
-0.0960375145,
-0.0054231849,
0.0315582007,
0.017313689,
-0.0174870603,
-0.0180973187,
-0.0106657287,
0.028764898,
0.0009600167,
-0.0226647127,
0.0044874703,
0.0148434713,
-0.0098644504,
-0.004463206,
-0.0277518705,
-0.0108763035,
0.0028571265,
0.0457540713,
0.018067589,
-0.0541578121,
-0.0093015917,
-0.0295984726,
-0.0299360882,
-0.0129551534,
-0.014809927,
-0.0333095752,
-0.0556171983,
0.0398909338,
-0.02813223,
0.0074620447,
-0.0727403015,
0.0470395796,
0.0000900902,
0.0112730032,
-0.0247839205,
0.0585658886,
0.0329861082,
0.0431027263,
-0.0335932449,
-0.0116781713,
-0.0215062387,
0.0040589049,
0.0298552401,
0.0069490289,
-0.0623447262,
-0.043827638,
-0.0220490079,
0.0112875672,
-0.0194896106,
0.0173249878,
0.0102670994,
0.0508305281,
-0.0166349523,
0.0081276521,
0.0352486037,
0.0394561999,
-0.0217142422,
0.0046496838,
0.0266018454,
-0.0240308326,
0.0302022453,
-0.0467438363,
0.0041721035,
0.0007285733,
0.0258172732,
0.0148838973,
-0.072562702,
-0.0381310582,
0.0588380955,
-0.0841924325,
-0.0201485585,
0.0377894044,
-0.047340326,
-0.0068374956,
0.0011573235,
0.0209319983,
-0.0063978299,
0.0144552486,
0.0496079363,
0.080266282,
-0.0466793813,
-0.0004146967,
0.0041656834,
-0.0115905982,
-0.0108172828,
-0.0279340092,
-0.021716062,
-0.0136981374,
0.0432866588,
0.0364032276,
-0.0123118991,
0.0092341201,
0.0375451818,
-0.0754001737,
-0.0149317598,
-0.0157773457,
0.027951384,
-0.0061115045,
0.0500437841,
-0.0103522399,
-0.0477785282,
0.0671947151,
0.0059890775,
0.0390058272,
-0.0737002939,
-0.0136596486,
0.0137703642,
0.0307333712,
-0.0361286774,
0.0340219326,
0.0304431077,
0.005579066,
-0.065300554,
-0.0472070388,
0.0790314823,
-0.0582784228,
0.0190585181,
-0.0974729359,
0.0406063236,
0.0199984722,
0.0188898928,
-0.0305710975,
-0.0137016522,
-0.0379154198,
0.0167921316,
0.0878043026,
-0.0166608021,
0.0270016659,
0.0143305724,
-0.0136067122,
0.0157557856,
0.0210988615,
-0.0562957153,
-0.0187088214,
0.008403535,
0.0359661952,
-0.013100463,
0.0653071031,
-0.0345989577,
-0.0318983421,
-0.0157175791,
-0.0229398701,
-0.0427225865,
-0.0322070941,
-0.0040240926,
0.0501433499,
-0.0387789905,
-0.0353560597,
0.0290596355,
0.0814678818,
-0.0168439653,
-0.0330269262,
0.1477616131,
0.058721222,
-0.00423573,
0.0025755803,
-0.0051618149,
0.010561116,
0.0035406209,
-0.0158835445,
-0.0305937752,
-0.0700660348,
0.0110412454,
0.0094961887,
0.0210692938,
-0.0281286892,
0.0009747262,
-0.0319905169,
0.0224915762,
-0.0006433127,
-0.0511128306,
-0.0012571681,
-0.0093391296,
0.0293317065,
-0.0286435876,
0.0408358239,
-0.0225361269,
-0.0020880834,
0.0229775887,
0.0149139632,
-0.013357115,
-0.060051918,
0.0012995776,
-0.0211256072,
0.0582370088,
0.0278365575,
0.0042524636,
0.0151334014,
0.012845167,
-0.0137844458,
-0.0890458226,
-0.0237974748,
-0.0330648124,
0.0170896892,
0.0221261941,
0.0173487682,
-0.0069134547,
-0.0337744839,
-0.0576429181,
-0.019201884,
-0.0577678457,
0.0063377456,
-0.0359854437,
0.005277568,
-0.0210140124,
-0.047421854,
0.0056728986,
0.0623201877,
-0.0452583134,
0.0047792988,
-0.0255056974,
-0.0089422995,
0.0284288451,
0.0221791398,
0.0236079115,
0.0085751005,
-0.0479393266,
-0.0119914496,
-0.0683659464,
-0.0493415669,
-0.0008225216,
0.0072363615,
-0.0173852984,
0.0297157429,
0.0217685495,
0.0016060309,
-0.0863286108,
0.0098796869,
0.0090525746,
0.0627658218,
-0.0144738359,
0.0006408999,
0.0478316136,
0.0124522001,
-0.0308288988,
0.1059482768,
-0.0621123575,
-0.0388651006,
0.0497659147,
0.0069433632,
0.0290687028,
0.0034025488,
-0.0468367487,
-0.0153618036,
0.0349278413,
0.0297661833,
0.0164545439,
0.0197796188,
0.0197854154,
0.0687256381,
-0.0202519409,
0.0398301072,
-0.0218329299,
0.0091187125,
0.0017613295,
0.0019868575,
-0.046657905,
-0.0560991205,
-0.0125546614,
0.0247750804,
0.0609679297,
-0.0529402383,
-0.0266403593,
-0.0099021317,
-0.0547430888,
-0.0015586057,
-0.0115499347,
0.0140885664,
-0.0049976408,
0.0305383652,
-0.0477405228,
-0.0338195711,
0.0712992251,
0.017220635,
0.0039400309,
0.0238448977,
-0.0458774865,
0.0408628359,
-0.0177304614,
-0.0167137627,
-0.0152061572,
0.0404085889,
-0.0016971595,
-0.0078137722,
0.0029517186,
0.0227858368,
0.0166586991,
-0.0040376931,
-0.0185155366,
-0.0343083814,
0.007343736,
-0.0255160574,
-0.0279215574,
-0.0190125462,
0.0481132194,
0.0316876173,
-0.0082002711,
0.0673307106,
-0.0150609864,
0.0144223878,
-0.0129850246,
0.0436306968,
0.0272128917,
0.0584918857,
0.0495253541,
0.0103068426,
0.0047385306,
0.0309949536,
0.0546000265,
-0.0137749203,
0.0304328538,
-0.0106770871,
-0.0819837898,
-0.018583063,
-0.0069318246,
-0.029023828,
0.0606602281,
-0.0073858015,
0.0312085953,
-0.0633535907,
-0.0648146793,
0.0510834828,
0.0189942438,
0.032983847,
0.0035310416,
0.0559703708,
0.0515299328,
0.0055281776,
-0.0074792979,
-0.0290567782,
-0.0592830665,
-0.0123598864,
-0.0162289217,
-0.0330293886,
-6.200004629e-33,
-0.0152328089,
-0.0347314887,
-0.0450361446,
-0.0763283223,
-0.0095442133,
0.0077236081,
-0.0016831061,
-0.0169127043,
-0.0054058181,
0.0279634222,
0.0253150128,
0.0393924974,
0.0373042263,
0.0128686121,
0.0044135978,
-0.0082398597,
0.0615965798,
0.0162839983,
-0.0004522228,
-0.0445824377,
0.0582104437,
0.0265265722,
0.0503812619,
-0.0375778042,
0.0567204244,
0.0331713967,
-0.0185503904,
0.0301510114,
0.0452907532,
0.0282269791,
-0.0122402096,
0.08666154,
-0.0022553122,
0.0383414254,
-0.0238952879,
-0.0718137026,
-0.0966304764,
-0.0537546985,
0.0261095446,
0.0252083503,
-0.0398338772,
0.022916751,
0.0360404961,
-0.0029151989,
-0.0458059013,
0.0095005929,
0.0227378905,
-0.0328975916,
-0.0478912294,
-0.064785853,
-0.0203266144,
0.0437701121,
0.0020513602,
-0.0429024883,
0.0440436266,
-0.0477725752,
-0.0056067854,
-0.0363964178,
-0.0404016189,
-0.0006808683,
-0.0294809826,
0.033379063,
0.0593602359,
0.0324633121,
-0.0263415575,
0.0209667366,
-0.0122745438,
-0.0472442806,
0.0456985645,
-0.0052310829,
0.0102807917,
0.0065512666,
0.012900413,
0.0715755746,
0.0544611178,
-0.0046773166,
-0.0339134187,
0.0245491602,
0.0219906215,
0.0423481092,
0.0149300266,
0.025676623,
-0.0673799217,
-0.0336651541,
-0.0871216729,
0.0007539853,
-0.0108065177,
0.0038930739,
-0.0076191723,
-0.0195628442,
-0.0363465697,
0.0297704637,
-0.0043069068,
-0.0112653915,
-0.0046650269,
-0.0205057077,
0.0201699566,
0.0134472866,
0.0249191094,
0.0296250843,
0.0359642617,
-0.0234966073,
0.003578112,
0.0597067364,
-0.0123095429,
0.0133490162,
-0.0305288769,
-0.0069479253,
-0.0197807681,
0.0326477922,
0.0169038009,
-0.0012652234,
-0.0344612859,
-0.0558645464,
0.0387587734,
0.0022156499,
-0.0029580418,
0.030877104,
0.0307021793,
0.0105139455,
0.0252940971,
-0.0169687606,
-0.0097870016,
0.0212860852,
-0.039830517,
0.0046809064,
0.0263703801,
-0.0200426877,
0.0205992684,
-0.0113940462,
0.0024292325,
-0.008875493,
2.886e-7,
0.0865401849,
0.074271746,
-0.0445893072,
0.0805539861,
-0.0012643533,
0.0081810215,
0.0318152346,
-0.0296578147,
-0.0490985215,
-0.055305928,
-0.0122343851,
0.0064517865,
0.0191388801,
0.0575503223,
0.0213434044,
-0.0291362833,
0.0264839176,
0.0725461692,
-0.0159300342,
0.0314443111,
0.101594165,
0.0889187753,
-0.0034259479,
-0.0101765441,
-0.0506634749,
-0.0219177324,
0.0258007497,
-0.0474245735,
-0.0048818528,
0.0328267626,
0.0415965468,
-0.0155674713,
0.0470014364,
0.0515247807,
-0.0393011384,
-0.0345222615,
0.0211407039,
0.0200551301,
-0.0293575712,
0.0337548703,
-0.018183209,
-0.023779856,
0.0420317687,
-0.0276262518,
0.0427319854,
-0.0495582521,
-0.013781717,
-0.0033328794,
0.0136469165,
0.0119973999,
0.0553574041,
0.0077611087,
-0.0524903089,
0.0061275093,
-0.0045498842,
0.0245196912,
-0.0593449213,
-0.0393396802,
-0.0067990473,
0.0268337056,
0.0119704148,
-0.0279566702,
0.0304801427,
-0.0273433309,
0.0449032299,
-0.0899151117,
-0.01464835,
2.442267445e-34,
0.0681585446,
0.0050120619,
-0.0224655289,
-0.0020992837,
0.030944718,
-0.0066496939,
0.0103745786,
0.0146623002,
0.0077003646,
-0.0030427463,
0.0262656938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13117v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13117v3 | AVeriTeC: A Dataset for Real-world Claim Verification with Evidence from the Web | 2023-05-22T15:17:18 | 2023-11-08T11:53:55 | Michael Schlichtkrull, Zhijiang Guo, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing datasets for automated fact-checking have substantial limitations,
such as relying on artificial claims, lacking annotations for evidence and
intermediate reasoning, or including evidence published after the claim. In
this paper we introduce AVeriTeC, a new dataset of 4,568 real-world claims
covering fact-checks by 50 different organizations. Each claim is annotated
with question-answer pairs supported by evidence available online, as well as
textual justifications explaining how the evidence combines to produce a
verdict. Through a multi-round annotation process, we avoid common pitfalls
including context dependence, evidence insufficiency, and temporal leakage, and
reach a substantial inter-annotator agreement of $\kappa=0.619$ on verdicts. We
develop a baseline as well as an evaluation scheme for verifying claims through
several question-answering steps against the open web. | [
0.0398984924,
0.0550147481,
0.0178558324,
0.02154392,
-0.0298188813,
0.0293486472,
0.0057825479,
-0.0338099822,
0.0071886955,
-0.050587777,
0.0183047466,
0.0316798426,
0.0284945779,
0.0437606312,
0.0136363329,
0.0028380712,
0.0069547649,
0.029036602,
0.0731168389,
0.0001857912,
0.0079447199,
0.035563156,
-0.0541970618,
0.0597468913,
-0.0405165367,
-0.0401192158,
0.0225670338,
-0.0150592225,
0.0477666855,
-0.0395648517,
-0.0079393964,
0.0217931513,
0.0058007105,
0.0492002368,
0.0000017394,
-0.0551416352,
0.0126789277,
0.041896902,
-0.0755510479,
0.0301038567,
-0.0337461457,
0.0454147905,
0.0144408783,
0.0187494904,
-0.0185386818,
-0.0299639292,
0.0375951417,
0.0333918408,
0.079862088,
0.0662174076,
-0.0139579363,
-0.0265993495,
0.0102433916,
0.0052008894,
-0.0228226017,
0.0001042875,
0.0421303697,
0.0220760908,
-0.0216808636,
-0.0235904604,
0.0554004423,
0.0254105255,
-0.002099955,
-0.0298010763,
-0.0424749777,
0.0351291113,
-0.0826501399,
-0.007038747,
0.0142737366,
0.0518444851,
0.0610502437,
-0.0365251191,
-0.015116767,
-0.0094597032,
0.0252362024,
0.0402418785,
-0.0029847373,
0.094665803,
-0.0301229935,
-0.0121612661,
-0.0037258244,
0.0376663804,
0.0093423491,
0.0126608014,
0.0204972699,
0.0610066541,
-0.0167723596,
-0.0441290997,
0.0231490955,
0.0272361208,
-0.0060215821,
-0.0925886482,
0.0075256685,
-0.0121889692,
0.0080851773,
0.0080949189,
-0.0114233578,
0.0258869343,
0.0757184848,
-0.0699338093,
0.0291676689,
-0.0013362929,
-0.0736625716,
0.0666636154,
-0.0460525379,
-0.0160245094,
-0.0122794341,
-0.0346760042,
0.035146594,
-0.002449143,
-0.040034011,
0.0219765045,
0.0215504467,
0.036378894,
-0.0396137051,
0.0275527257,
-0.0389067456,
0.0041597299,
-0.0173147041,
0.0806183815,
0.0016177066,
-0.011643515,
0.0224758703,
-0.0225942153,
-0.0742718056,
0.0010749907,
-0.0194154456,
0.0662613064,
-0.0128456689,
-0.0538010187,
-0.0030036566,
0.0199578386,
0.0416175611,
0.0094350353,
0.0163169112,
0.0050904332,
0.020029109,
-0.0004286855,
-0.034257818,
-0.0664339066,
-0.008990895,
-0.0286805648,
-0.0542516112,
-0.0426802821,
0.0330140889,
-0.0150417201,
-0.0282859262,
0.0242249463,
-0.0159145631,
0.0542340651,
-0.0230232086,
0.0516661145,
-0.0498911813,
-0.0284482688,
0.0227862801,
-0.032818269,
-0.0038689533,
0.0208018217,
0.0228476953,
0.0563946553,
0.050852403,
0.0675880164,
0.0013902988,
-0.011177727,
0.0428153016,
-0.0004410251,
0.090890415,
0.0683667585,
0.0064889775,
0.0201888774,
-0.0294716042,
0.0136248078,
-0.0372146741,
-0.0358652361,
0.0687031522,
0.0173316449,
-0.027772516,
-0.032771267,
0.0224310961,
-0.031685438,
0.0415698104,
-0.0409792699,
-0.0361858755,
0.0011065333,
-0.0757705569,
-0.0204001497,
0.0113912877,
0.0336943232,
0.0116284722,
-0.068082422,
-0.0308160689,
-0.0051227864,
-0.0460348055,
0.0227928851,
-0.0023376169,
0.0107735852,
-0.022169238,
-0.0176397413,
0.03590459,
-0.0352240503,
-0.0421933271,
-0.0317457393,
0.0488947444,
-0.0075266678,
0.0363501944,
-0.0158187766,
0.0047459202,
-0.0524011143,
0.0556233376,
0.0407777093,
0.0442206003,
-0.0212937705,
0.0030423342,
0.005439017,
-0.016502073,
-0.0469345711,
-0.0001764024,
-0.0054403339,
0.0371999517,
0.0170217212,
-0.0148895429,
-0.0298445914,
-0.0151618011,
0.0222818162,
0.0311974082,
0.0082558366,
0.0035309496,
0.0067235981,
0.039689891,
0.0427172668,
-0.008458443,
-0.0010419457,
0.0276192259,
-0.0000139382,
-0.0421289876,
0.020879345,
0.0643645227,
-0.024950292,
0.0400687829,
-0.0755604059,
-0.0413492694,
-0.0051643481,
-0.0376446694,
-0.0134183001,
-0.0623930059,
-0.0001212971,
0.0122611793,
-0.040884763,
-0.0334854163,
0.0221966933,
0.0199047644,
0.0133191701,
0.0722617954,
0.0046435003,
0.0108523117,
-0.0425481088,
-0.0349172615,
0.025794493,
-0.0071794726,
-0.0253163353,
-0.0062222634,
-0.0231937747,
0.0044405283,
0.0316697955,
-0.0438929871,
-0.0402010493,
0.040415708,
-0.0698642284,
0.020781666,
-0.0005045144,
0.0184733346,
-0.0012623406,
-0.0256379638,
0.0083631454,
0.0000592361,
-0.0124633871,
-0.0241476819,
-0.0084371949,
0.0293458793,
0.0715593994,
0.0108708162,
0.0141779585,
-0.0139463646,
-0.0105490936,
-0.0177311283,
0.0366155319,
0.0600212738,
-0.0068784715,
-0.0578725412,
-0.0161423907,
-0.067830503,
0.0081765074,
-0.0044104396,
0.0097383931,
0.0286030564,
0.021705009,
-0.0665488169,
0.0484740883,
0.0212485362,
-0.0138508854,
0.0247213654,
0.0366376676,
-0.0223657973,
-0.0079283994,
-0.0051042959,
0.0144200604,
-0.0063313111,
-0.0319832489,
0.0242462531,
0.0142847495,
0.0119293388,
-0.0035661152,
-0.0220710784,
0.0105965585,
-0.0248313099,
-0.0109426696,
0.0083296606,
-0.0209080148,
-0.0090986025,
0.0734376237,
0.006231416,
-0.026317101,
0.0795919448,
-0.0342113785,
0.0260684695,
-0.0244444273,
-0.0084161069,
-0.0048179589,
0.0456703231,
-0.0132210609,
-0.0065462221,
0.0272854082,
0.0207686368,
0.0320313461,
-0.0336503647,
0.088612318,
-0.0290265922,
0.0006332392,
-0.0276887398,
0.0455803126,
-0.0121849133,
-0.0308487099,
-0.0262954906,
-0.0872125104,
-0.021076994,
-0.0278615132,
-0.0464014001,
-0.0074613229,
-0.0771041811,
-0.0394061171,
0.0393885411,
0.0488426946,
0.0164409634,
-0.0181418136,
0.0068249772,
-0.001123119,
0.0041099386,
0.0510851406,
0.0337625891,
0.0311917663,
-0.0444581285,
0.0760658532,
-0.032302931,
0.0194785334,
-0.015026913,
-0.0535864271,
-0.0340608321,
-0.0285903085,
0.0301935673,
-0.0278701391,
0.0146650495,
-0.0421676524,
0.0192891378,
0.0402734801,
0.0154780447,
0.0244181026,
-0.0095084859,
0.01853678,
-0.0216497239,
0.0315379761,
-0.0065369485,
-0.1410296708,
0.0008418313,
-0.0379127078,
-0.0066306558,
-0.0289566722,
-0.0475410596,
-0.0081932265,
-0.0954908356,
0.0526749715,
-0.0296284873,
0.017458465,
-0.0115304086,
-0.0753221586,
0.02927831,
-0.0341078527,
-0.0167861953,
-0.0089656813,
0.0340685695,
0.0034137887,
0.0259081703,
-0.02448407,
-0.023277266,
0.064814277,
-0.0160663594,
0.0239994098,
0.0153051754,
0.0287387799,
-0.0120981457,
-0.0477375351,
-0.0149448942,
-0.0072871423,
-0.051374238,
0.0147478851,
0.0821933672,
-0.0252186898,
0.0052099945,
-0.0056526912,
0.0276010465,
-0.0368336923,
-0.0119344294,
0.0502477549,
0.0503332019,
-0.0119171627,
-0.0084122475,
-0.0104578584,
0.0003996872,
0.0019184127,
0.0657968447,
-0.02892261,
0.037891183,
0.0073981779,
-0.0219419021,
-0.0467125587,
-0.0423262753,
-0.0201120935,
0.0563658997,
0.0177186001,
-0.0238109883,
-0.087410152,
-0.015916016,
0.0054692496,
0.0395385884,
-0.0307942256,
-0.0435352102,
0.0466304012,
0.0278359335,
-0.0385654792,
0.0414222032,
-0.0629062131,
0.047230009,
0.0285912044,
0.019008033,
0.0353321955,
-0.0206650943,
-0.0441285372,
0.0456114002,
-0.0263444465,
-0.0320467837,
-0.0198197104,
-0.002342836,
0.016182052,
0.0612952784,
-0.0267805494,
0.0061869435,
0.018019041,
0.0304635055,
-0.0265085194,
-0.0112623032,
0.0365987644,
-0.0168217365,
-0.0071882419,
-0.0235314071,
-0.039448075,
0.0078541758,
-0.0150168827,
0.0179889873,
-0.0338558517,
-0.0091460822,
0.0532849059,
0.0348702632,
0.0460036211,
0.0111872861,
-0.0267733578,
-0.041411642,
0.0329213999,
-0.0190751012,
-0.020622069,
-0.0019367244,
0.0277270954,
-0.0261334348,
-0.0543719679,
-0.0189189631,
0.0110437917,
-0.0436149463,
0.0092296163,
-0.0322711393,
-0.0208229311,
0.0472773239,
0.0680991411,
-0.014637081,
-0.0370930545,
-0.0522162206,
-0.0317857862,
-0.0079400474,
0.0458893254,
0.0013216482,
0.0092192991,
0.049602896,
0.0031878371,
0.0402235277,
-0.0078538004,
-0.0646991208,
0.0062772147,
-0.0336119607,
0.0012919678,
0.0077399658,
0.0128200138,
0.0327961706,
-0.023474196,
-0.0315665789,
0.0323612019,
-0.0132994587,
-0.0020873996,
-0.0214769617,
0.0259149335,
0.0025863005,
-0.0610357374,
0.0329171233,
0.0201391317,
-0.0158471689,
0.0363866016,
-0.020827096,
-0.0558688268,
-0.0358384885,
-0.0774173513,
-0.0645447001,
0.0543773398,
0.0148277273,
-0.085463658,
-0.0562925898,
-0.0439560078,
-0.0182494298,
0.0481059514,
0.0224280804,
0.0644043088,
-0.0340929963,
0.0486064926,
0.0638238564,
-0.0409775525,
-0.0319263786,
0.0282641836,
0.0026398685,
0.0075497362,
-0.0130329914,
-5.866601737e-33,
0.0014091585,
-0.0409444086,
-0.0086840233,
0.0059839636,
0.0103071081,
0.0522763729,
-0.0179618541,
-0.0369879641,
-0.0532159731,
0.0602330752,
0.0109217418,
0.0572115742,
0.0265452303,
-0.019910479,
0.0255397782,
-0.0144440997,
0.0364688672,
-0.0006144902,
-0.0341835022,
0.0188302454,
0.0401393101,
-0.0578010678,
0.0548524931,
-0.0710797235,
0.096754387,
-0.001633644,
-0.061679963,
0.0226476267,
-0.0411100499,
0.0487335399,
-0.0214518476,
0.0437140688,
0.0183994155,
-0.0119829038,
0.0336259417,
-0.0124832792,
-0.0833524168,
0.0074240672,
0.0481887497,
-0.030842891,
-0.0474181175,
0.0408989415,
0.0199652128,
0.0124538029,
0.0321210772,
-0.0199059881,
0.0458177589,
-0.0505396277,
0.0138625251,
-0.043708913,
-0.0333134793,
0.0307039563,
-0.0189803261,
0.0023597786,
-0.0459369831,
0.0302398242,
0.0240745731,
0.0034518391,
-0.0842733681,
0.024311224,
-0.0586688407,
-0.0532363728,
0.0340111963,
-0.0694192126,
-0.0261001308,
0.0323526636,
-0.0225489102,
0.0332391672,
-0.014901137,
0.0213408507,
-0.0369221233,
0.0420247838,
0.0358227268,
0.0919137448,
0.0091933925,
0.0123270759,
-0.0888432264,
0.0233320836,
0.0454354249,
-0.0058554318,
0.019880224,
-0.0548874922,
-0.0500541255,
0.0185303036,
-0.0238009263,
0.0041461755,
-0.0363263078,
0.0472321361,
-0.0111703463,
0.0290989988,
-0.0133583369,
0.0719282255,
-0.0092266435,
-0.029722929,
0.033636678,
0.0065324181,
0.0155040519,
0.0013849884,
0.0083074858,
-0.0051410543,
-0.0557159819,
0.0540014692,
-0.0213668942,
0.0288048889,
0.0248391088,
-0.0009162098,
0.0685253367,
-0.0234722774,
-0.0396506377,
0.017906623,
-0.0125667881,
0.0198559985,
-0.0296246987,
-0.0518675037,
0.0365273766,
0.0367910042,
0.0082159452,
0.0128613589,
-0.0211830437,
0.0179070309,
-0.0467966162,
-0.0293648783,
0.0044785831,
-0.0073380349,
-0.0156865679,
-0.0153364539,
0.0149156973,
0.01594452,
-0.0133910663,
-0.0431055017,
0.0297473855,
0.0474513024,
2.468e-7,
0.0440013073,
0.0083048623,
0.0045668134,
0.0168273151,
-0.001157396,
0.0135905519,
0.0428002179,
0.0016303279,
0.0036795528,
-0.0958976373,
0.004257293,
-0.0052482486,
0.0254666787,
0.0560583733,
-0.0222559683,
-0.0511779413,
-0.0426282398,
-0.0520713441,
-0.0726769716,
-0.019546736,
0.0575218536,
0.0203441065,
0.0495708473,
-0.0005669129,
-0.010142345,
-0.003629863,
0.0276109539,
0.0430970155,
-0.0378520451,
-0.0036189454,
0.0553124025,
-0.0132869873,
-0.0055551818,
0.0439482331,
-0.041523248,
0.0160354674,
-0.0197608396,
0.0348857418,
0.0074412045,
-0.0109904213,
-0.0534264669,
-0.0655051917,
0.042790439,
-0.0173571408,
0.0576311946,
-0.0165629219,
-0.0246729068,
-0.0392469689,
-0.0415550917,
-0.006177512,
0.0290987696,
0.0281149037,
-0.0018107195,
0.0210827868,
-0.0374080203,
0.0179622602,
0.003983784,
-0.0455634445,
0.0098524652,
0.0531075522,
-0.0288426187,
-0.0517466962,
0.0803082511,
-0.0298711322,
0.0496910997,
-0.060718365,
0.0085146036,
1.806179557e-34,
0.008466674,
-0.0050896201,
0.0160095152,
-0.0386094376,
0.068837896,
0.0240082797,
0.0012931075,
-0.0319450572,
0.0174693987,
-0.0268459823,
-0.0102388216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13112v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13112v2 | Rethinking the Evaluation for Conversational Recommendation in the Era of Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T15:12:43 | 2023-11-03T02:49:46 | Xiaolei Wang, Xinyu Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jingyuan Wang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The recent success of large language models (LLMs) has shown great potential
to develop more powerful conversational recommender systems (CRSs), which rely
on natural language conversations to satisfy user needs. In this paper, we
embark on an investigation into the utilization of ChatGPT for conversational
recommendation, revealing the inadequacy of the existing evaluation protocol.
It might over-emphasize the matching with the ground-truth items or utterances
generated by human annotators, while neglecting the interactive nature of being
a capable CRS. To overcome the limitation, we further propose an interactive
Evaluation approach based on LLMs named iEvaLM that harnesses LLM-based user
simulators. Our evaluation approach can simulate various interaction scenarios
between users and systems. Through the experiments on two publicly available
CRS datasets, we demonstrate notable improvements compared to the prevailing
evaluation protocol. Furthermore, we emphasize the evaluation of
explainability, and ChatGPT showcases persuasive explanation generation for its
recommendations. Our study contributes to a deeper comprehension of the
untapped potential of LLMs for CRSs and provides a more flexible and
easy-to-use evaluation framework for future research endeavors. The codes and
data are publicly available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/iEvaLM-CRS. | [
0.0561501049,
0.0070291045,
-0.0041008759,
0.0459601991,
-0.0272710714,
0.0037005083,
0.0140424622,
-0.018475011,
0.0474942848,
-0.0184506942,
-0.0476302728,
-0.0018992986,
0.0004014514,
0.0269530956,
-0.0079194624,
-0.0395002216,
-0.0157523062,
-0.0414850786,
0.0109895198,
0.0078633707,
0.0254051127,
0.0174256507,
-0.0061439793,
0.0745315254,
0.0333872736,
-0.0019648795,
-0.0207615308,
-0.0089335497,
-0.0205331035,
-0.0087534124,
-0.0031609398,
0.0385171212,
0.0471992083,
0.0007316023,
0.0000024214,
-0.0369665176,
0.0271666888,
-0.0226889271,
-0.0376186743,
0.0103295268,
0.0492455699,
0.087450847,
0.0010664732,
0.0135788033,
-0.0234961901,
0.0395037644,
0.0335818306,
0.0479023233,
0.0591166243,
0.0450191759,
-0.0118137812,
0.0025761493,
-0.0157144144,
-0.0029855336,
0.0455399938,
-0.0363014303,
-0.0140908537,
0.038801197,
0.0420609787,
0.0230502561,
0.02537743,
0.002204471,
0.0062404713,
-0.0576374531,
0.0478339046,
0.0347570032,
-0.0413590111,
-0.0448727421,
0.004283587,
0.0908942595,
0.0143024456,
-0.0277095549,
0.0003863213,
0.0219475646,
0.0005485357,
-0.0179832149,
-0.048755236,
-0.0325607918,
0.0034398378,
0.0310912374,
-0.0233657192,
0.0307019707,
0.0592593811,
0.0286964551,
0.0222039558,
0.0648121908,
0.0016296249,
-0.0317523517,
0.0111466739,
-0.0092615001,
0.0003865323,
-0.086293444,
-0.0036664428,
0.015295594,
-0.1072672233,
0.0124010183,
-0.0025686265,
0.069748953,
0.0023305146,
-0.063681215,
0.0343940519,
0.0497493111,
0.0049634874,
0.0667782351,
0.0260693375,
0.0473976657,
0.0162965506,
-0.0067742895,
-0.0318566673,
-0.0144207282,
-0.0408240743,
-0.0064833607,
-0.0026707265,
0.0009337143,
-0.0475524887,
-0.051626835,
-0.030573627,
0.0375584625,
-0.0104945609,
0.0230180304,
0.0116714435,
0.032933481,
0.0103849452,
0.0093969228,
-0.0955709517,
0.0051926249,
-0.0565996803,
0.0149767557,
0.029678423,
-0.0767537951,
0.0242961701,
0.0422712229,
-0.0200901628,
-0.0260142293,
-0.0068240375,
0.0393976048,
0.0088647017,
-0.0222803317,
-0.0003957648,
-0.0243553035,
-0.0042846845,
-0.0660438016,
-0.056370303,
-0.0520007722,
0.0322270431,
0.025229644,
0.0031613184,
-0.0226067118,
0.0111790765,
0.0358200409,
-0.0189942811,
0.0925593674,
-0.0189266838,
0.0274401195,
0.0238119625,
0.0293814261,
-0.043562945,
0.0310913473,
0.0346000455,
0.0578927472,
0.0525333658,
-0.0204350501,
0.0434112772,
0.0022593751,
-0.0097277649,
0.0206594374,
-0.0039888239,
0.0272945557,
-0.0622660033,
0.0585359223,
0.011266713,
0.0407610089,
-0.0532406382,
0.0036465395,
0.0781976432,
0.0570414998,
0.0246473402,
0.047538694,
0.056890361,
0.0588593334,
-0.0039347974,
-0.0132838981,
-0.0270219352,
0.0466672964,
-0.0449616425,
-0.030722484,
0.0641229525,
-0.0064567421,
-0.0256216209,
-0.0487599336,
0.024660239,
-0.0298775081,
0.0491874889,
0.0166033506,
-0.0023276128,
-0.0167170353,
-0.0312720798,
0.0158952493,
0.0551621467,
-0.0519244038,
-0.0150568169,
-0.0525481105,
0.0737715736,
0.1477824748,
0.0664052814,
0.0104138348,
0.0010143964,
-0.0020865139,
0.0112125101,
0.0147611341,
0.0431759544,
-0.0134331323,
0.0083243018,
-0.0482544936,
-0.0388829783,
-0.0039405995,
-0.0185427815,
0.021888949,
0.0121575296,
-0.0228556413,
0.0091292886,
-0.0511834174,
-0.0429568365,
-0.0177437961,
-0.0217578951,
0.0002344477,
-0.0116347587,
-0.0098537803,
0.0303027127,
0.0070373421,
0.0261884704,
0.0196167659,
0.0100114662,
0.0050736861,
-0.0143457539,
0.0310461987,
-0.035407681,
-0.0146856122,
0.0052945586,
-0.0233679544,
-0.0029512334,
0.0134411212,
0.001378486,
-0.0389784239,
0.0115450807,
-0.0270463582,
0.0593924299,
-0.0455616973,
0.0029701998,
0.0030501788,
0.0230768248,
-0.0281908307,
0.0418334678,
0.0332080461,
0.0150631936,
0.0238986425,
0.004110645,
-0.0002762506,
-0.0513542518,
-0.0165639631,
0.0015760354,
0.0188508276,
-0.0010962465,
0.0242324509,
0.0055071791,
-0.0483307466,
-0.0192262419,
-0.1280162781,
-0.0055788057,
0.0003469063,
-0.003386816,
-0.0057914145,
0.0363510959,
0.0051794713,
-0.0227061231,
-0.0613866672,
0.0030649602,
0.0118033746,
0.004684425,
0.0243186522,
-0.005857477,
-0.0428082347,
-0.0533100851,
0.0176176038,
0.0017521479,
0.0600545667,
0.0075734896,
0.0221941024,
-0.047047507,
-0.0127060395,
-0.0368447714,
-0.0219882857,
-0.0165598821,
-0.0181802288,
0.006233166,
0.0212078411,
0.0195897352,
-0.0009988849,
0.0298577473,
0.0651459619,
0.0285139047,
0.0000690499,
-0.0751773864,
-0.0018633161,
-0.0081967711,
-0.0096111242,
-0.0610598996,
-0.047917977,
0.0031599172,
0.0198372472,
-0.0301488806,
0.0355963707,
-0.0637903288,
0.0304766372,
0.029596474,
-0.0078207413,
-0.0544938408,
-0.0349906199,
-0.0239741858,
0.0702985227,
-0.0070203478,
-0.0406710915,
0.0713049173,
-0.0699806139,
-0.035575062,
-0.0258521903,
-0.0422251299,
-0.0329663306,
0.0167598985,
-0.0112924101,
0.0117182415,
-0.0185722187,
-0.0065226848,
0.0175816696,
-0.0242508482,
0.0228461977,
-0.0439445749,
0.0230036024,
-0.0325581729,
-0.0028595971,
0.0486585125,
-0.0250917058,
-0.0339744948,
-0.0733255967,
-0.0425743051,
-0.0117656458,
0.0305196419,
-0.0160433259,
-0.0292368922,
0.0167031698,
0.0243556239,
0.0194351207,
-0.0040831352,
-0.0264137369,
0.0013574678,
0.0094574783,
0.0501034707,
0.017835727,
0.0011388336,
0.0172105748,
0.0753841847,
0.0319564566,
0.0056799874,
-0.022393303,
-0.0580139086,
-0.001174741,
0.012725574,
0.0149216214,
-0.016902931,
0.0332665034,
0.0315801613,
-0.006421173,
-0.0081260568,
0.1287287772,
0.0308334772,
-0.0752756521,
0.0279617384,
-0.0243169349,
0.0471828431,
0.0176913477,
0.0282124653,
-0.0704042017,
-0.0314990729,
0.0075651435,
0.0417019203,
-0.0048049008,
-0.0240277834,
-0.0112107703,
-0.0909544453,
0.0449577533,
-0.0146704121,
-0.0072604017,
0.0109507013,
-0.0619094856,
-0.0153274154,
-0.0199295841,
0.0282344688,
0.0028716899,
0.0061361729,
0.0093403868,
0.0069151837,
-0.0551296137,
-0.0413519554,
0.0726061761,
-0.0247326177,
0.0586861186,
0.0631985888,
0.0575752482,
0.036433585,
-0.0304894932,
0.017670121,
0.0176864006,
-0.0036199135,
-0.0065971771,
0.0334890895,
0.0008224068,
0.0059946296,
-0.0556639582,
0.0233229585,
-0.0142468084,
-0.0401124954,
0.0111398455,
0.041903995,
-0.0700747147,
0.0257333554,
0.0006952945,
0.0402456708,
0.0485813096,
0.1014516801,
0.065780215,
-0.0604822375,
-0.0077359257,
-0.0469156355,
-0.0303000044,
0.0011497927,
-0.0506149121,
-0.0231416412,
0.0345939137,
0.0035659301,
-0.0441516005,
-0.0342934877,
-0.0024628523,
-0.0038684327,
-0.0168926753,
0.0233158935,
-0.0170479957,
0.0087705124,
0.0478168465,
0.0432366952,
-0.0164535623,
0.03095752,
-0.0273174569,
0.0034792293,
0.0171034317,
-0.0743845403,
-0.0078369072,
0.0048681782,
-0.0296153091,
-0.0330745131,
-0.0455003344,
0.0280332565,
0.0297557805,
0.0495099127,
-0.0453269407,
-0.090507172,
-0.0075780256,
0.0100507503,
-0.0425686166,
-0.0253295917,
0.0033782383,
0.0590770431,
0.0213859603,
0.0397310555,
-0.0303120557,
0.0153100695,
-0.0325689763,
0.0163598265,
-0.0237606764,
-0.0575515181,
0.0099326568,
0.0132764587,
0.0440849066,
0.0029760492,
0.0216731634,
0.0039588087,
0.0105452472,
-0.0366670676,
-0.0383845158,
-0.055943165,
-0.0050708652,
0.0206487365,
-0.0154648097,
0.000078733,
-0.0258431528,
-0.0555612631,
0.0215275083,
-0.0038270114,
0.0107876901,
0.0020997275,
-0.0504450649,
0.0154933333,
0.0067007113,
-0.0208156966,
0.0145220244,
0.0056957435,
0.0334139764,
-0.0058265864,
0.0836691186,
0.0066687451,
-0.0405357853,
0.022527691,
0.0429091938,
-0.0295861457,
-0.0612965748,
0.0138221793,
0.0613242835,
0.0208504163,
-0.0229322333,
0.0595271103,
-0.0340173282,
0.0142003484,
-0.028360147,
0.0370977856,
-0.0039763651,
-0.0491258577,
0.0383762605,
0.0317912474,
-0.038428653,
0.0285480134,
0.0732423291,
-0.0258496031,
-0.0168790855,
0.0043881293,
-0.0424112752,
-0.0314712711,
-0.0218680464,
-0.0118826032,
0.0517373495,
-0.0203560386,
-0.0305960421,
-0.0336803235,
-0.0460611992,
-0.0335923098,
-0.0156821478,
-0.0170777496,
-0.0428365506,
0.0458195135,
0.0799214691,
-0.024721561,
0.0096058771,
-0.0608547963,
-0.018620152,
-0.0380267352,
0.0009440386,
-0.0413980633,
-6.759912425e-33,
0.0088050338,
-0.032583382,
0.0307899974,
0.023385454,
-0.0185143724,
-0.0293954425,
-0.050397478,
0.0100719761,
0.0314985588,
0.0222808961,
-0.0121529046,
-0.0033076315,
0.0071073216,
0.0362837315,
-0.0259095691,
-0.0509204045,
0.0485248268,
0.0383778773,
-0.0454027392,
0.0538478829,
0.0368432552,
-0.0038647386,
-0.0086581903,
-0.0873394161,
0.049383238,
-0.0235422812,
-0.0218399316,
0.0115937544,
-0.0012868495,
0.0775842518,
-0.0332345106,
0.0496472307,
0.0102221062,
-0.0431706049,
0.0163266752,
0.0297223553,
-0.0209520739,
0.0128213707,
0.0705354363,
-0.0042835432,
-0.0280658547,
-0.0153615708,
0.0045874277,
-0.0084515801,
-0.0273716636,
0.0291327294,
0.017646499,
-0.0249295365,
-0.027660897,
0.025351746,
-0.0232496783,
0.0252982937,
-0.0456976779,
-0.068856068,
0.0122951688,
0.0526467748,
-0.0333992168,
0.0246732123,
-0.0205428749,
0.0447296724,
-0.0106646232,
-0.003376981,
0.0473678038,
-0.0226830896,
-0.0275149997,
0.0613578446,
0.014422304,
-0.0134598929,
-0.0411600396,
-0.0199163873,
-0.0421840437,
0.0646618158,
0.0282473825,
0.0442160293,
-0.0251221005,
0.0197102576,
-0.0235797465,
0.0405565538,
0.0149559071,
0.0098438645,
0.0442746878,
0.0342360064,
-0.0660220608,
-0.0302370135,
-0.0447841473,
-0.0058114864,
-0.0553102419,
-0.0677106157,
0.0316947401,
0.0054744356,
-0.0076299291,
-0.0171096567,
-0.0048155072,
-0.0545378998,
-0.0123336082,
0.0204562284,
-0.0323384516,
-0.0177179128,
0.0092670964,
-0.0208222605,
-0.0289913975,
0.000387255,
0.0298412852,
-0.0070483149,
-0.0005656583,
0.0157679208,
0.0143763004,
0.0051550814,
-0.0178300068,
-0.0004289764,
-0.0382565334,
-0.0087658381,
-0.0420961492,
0.0066981376,
0.0325448215,
0.0009487825,
-0.0598972552,
0.0475562364,
-0.01625848,
0.0323624723,
-0.0095715383,
-0.0840844139,
-0.0099430038,
-0.0037540409,
-0.0238434914,
-0.0197184719,
-0.0334506594,
-0.0389252938,
0.0433828607,
-0.0352684222,
-0.0170143694,
-0.0350586213,
3.07e-7,
-0.0183156505,
0.046881333,
-0.0212118104,
-0.0316980742,
0.028115008,
0.0404346883,
0.008722269,
0.025301395,
0.0223979428,
-0.0132160196,
0.0338640884,
0.019433016,
0.0817314759,
0.017198585,
-0.0580193885,
-0.0131195607,
-0.0981696174,
-0.0287506953,
-0.0538573079,
-0.0036566246,
0.0447858088,
0.0615253635,
0.0368292145,
0.0060955966,
0.0065706056,
-0.0323462561,
0.036433693,
-0.1025409847,
-0.0450908169,
-0.0048773275,
0.0651786849,
0.006121675,
0.0208917279,
-0.0059117107,
-0.0190107543,
0.0044755386,
0.003759949,
0.0599753745,
0.0132958824,
-0.0486242436,
-0.0318020321,
-0.0109832892,
0.0204397645,
-0.0796741247,
0.0571050793,
-0.0342619903,
-0.0402405076,
-0.0381773561,
-0.0140035758,
-0.0345734283,
0.0161057524,
-0.0222894773,
-0.0168504547,
-0.0063617611,
-0.0048721698,
-0.0162839796,
-0.0052924869,
-0.0500358753,
-0.0080727162,
0.0073095243,
-0.0490252078,
-0.0546594597,
-0.0530617684,
0.0090497471,
0.0216916595,
-0.0516938195,
0.0345958173,
2.558231111e-34,
0.0361754894,
0.0378813669,
0.0248177219,
0.0098079769,
0.0718466043,
0.035044834,
0.0279315021,
0.0110578667,
0.0497490615,
-0.0637651309,
0.0063658822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13108v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13108v3 | Debiased Automatic Speech Recognition for Dysarthric Speech via Sample Reweighting with Sample Affinity Test | 2023-05-22T15:09:27 | 2023-06-27T13:19:19 | Eungbeom Kim, Yunkee Chae, Jaeheon Sim, Kyogu Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Automatic speech recognition systems based on deep learning are mainly
trained under empirical risk minimization (ERM). Since ERM utilizes the
averaged performance on the data samples regardless of a group such as healthy
or dysarthric speakers, ASR systems are unaware of the performance disparities
across the groups. This results in biased ASR systems whose performance
differences among groups are severe. In this study, we aim to improve the ASR
system in terms of group robustness for dysarthric speakers. To achieve our
goal, we present a novel approach, sample reweighting with sample affinity test
(Re-SAT). Re-SAT systematically measures the debiasing helpfulness of the given
data sample and then mitigates the bias by debiasing helpfulness-based sample
reweighting. Experimental results demonstrate that Re-SAT contributes to
improved ASR performance on dysarthric speech without performance degradation
on healthy speech. | [
-0.0552154258,
0.0294508878,
-0.0121893836,
-0.0053300415,
0.0165385175,
0.0047984575,
0.0379392393,
-0.0123820994,
0.0005710882,
0.0128273508,
-0.0416408814,
-0.010947031,
0.0427875631,
-0.0151697882,
0.0167978238,
-0.0459767096,
0.0234704707,
-0.0198856965,
0.0454901755,
-0.0728641227,
0.0336640067,
-0.0258020163,
-0.078971684,
0.0269684587,
-0.0026320596,
0.0373700596,
0.0523669831,
0.023785606,
0.0252061691,
-0.0262679458,
0.0217788033,
0.0262769219,
0.0206142832,
0.0156285055,
0.0000018565,
-0.034178704,
0.0048684748,
-0.0186944026,
-0.0464002453,
-0.0402828567,
-0.0143893519,
0.0153598581,
0.0132880909,
0.0303008687,
0.0145826293,
-0.0494616814,
0.0331428833,
0.0360667966,
0.0003336688,
0.0172272455,
-0.0073715746,
-0.0293071382,
0.0063952585,
-0.0328453407,
-0.0243516266,
-0.0049646241,
0.0190470647,
-0.0193828158,
-0.0411163643,
-0.0759698749,
-0.0081132753,
0.0528480336,
0.0112748863,
0.0365956128,
0.0385441892,
-0.0119108809,
-0.0355262756,
-0.0198173448,
0.0040467973,
0.0711567327,
-0.0081214411,
0.0263394881,
0.0088578938,
-0.0410245545,
-0.014445479,
0.0031442142,
-0.0192406066,
-0.0087667322,
0.020160418,
-0.0122161675,
-0.0057629007,
0.0623238273,
0.0417641699,
0.0007249857,
-0.0050501982,
0.0368142501,
-0.0051917145,
-0.0137542048,
0.0238326155,
0.0089102639,
0.0127212619,
-0.0163514968,
0.0842228755,
-0.0005888905,
-0.0456333011,
-0.0031905971,
-0.0047792001,
-0.0736610293,
0.0098780012,
0.0064903111,
-0.0136926388,
0.0309446249,
-0.0550224632,
-0.0248836502,
-0.0062309057,
0.0083573209,
0.0108024105,
0.0230507776,
0.0419030339,
0.023477219,
0.0250007529,
0.0336116105,
-0.0024193707,
0.0455477498,
-0.0095508201,
0.0294473916,
-0.0742365569,
0.0142438002,
-0.0395811722,
-0.052120842,
0.0325139649,
0.0417045392,
-0.0856811628,
0.0109727224,
-0.0043744249,
0.0468345471,
0.00563453,
0.0471004285,
0.0193911586,
-0.084829621,
0.0330800526,
-0.0065161712,
0.0299885739,
-0.0460844412,
-0.0076433304,
0.0580489002,
0.0465106033,
-0.0040619601,
-0.0576848276,
0.006815108,
-0.0257801097,
-0.0140944785,
-0.0219605044,
-0.0659900159,
0.0063205282,
0.016393546,
0.0172064435,
-0.075184986,
-0.0317321718,
-0.032259021,
0.0391796343,
0.0607102737,
0.0164913721,
0.008661788,
0.0815039799,
-0.0199798252,
-0.0000317213,
0.0530653559,
0.0295306798,
-0.0343931168,
0.0099059958,
-0.0108895143,
0.0247229841,
0.0288670603,
0.0156537779,
0.0277696084,
-0.0331104733,
-0.0198152829,
-0.0417490564,
0.0299329758,
0.0671753734,
0.0426207744,
-0.0235403217,
-0.0608512908,
0.0589472018,
0.0424710289,
0.0610409267,
0.0248158667,
-0.0451649837,
-0.0125480834,
-0.0531012043,
0.0084258961,
-0.0148783149,
0.0205905735,
0.0101899384,
-0.0085476553,
0.0289969333,
0.0401634127,
-0.0264510121,
-0.0181972161,
0.0038471376,
-0.0125365509,
0.0074708597,
0.0680942386,
0.0241247099,
-0.031736102,
0.007052667,
0.0264355,
0.0259931684,
-0.0439146645,
0.0599577688,
-0.0511703119,
-0.0074337623,
0.0003382553,
-0.0108385449,
-0.046424225,
-0.0033610435,
-0.0657130927,
-0.0438282453,
0.0034626671,
-0.0143392663,
0.0351374298,
0.0788939297,
-0.0586141236,
-0.0558437034,
0.0483116582,
-0.0235920213,
0.0634437725,
-0.0230024215,
0.0414550416,
-0.0129682599,
-0.0226675384,
-0.000600883,
0.0257577375,
-0.0137981074,
-0.0486249849,
0.0489611551,
0.0268466976,
0.0653654784,
-0.006659281,
-0.0524027944,
-0.0234279651,
-0.0196402948,
-0.0023527062,
-0.0404098965,
-0.0072875321,
-0.0999342054,
-0.0399523713,
0.0244755354,
-0.0746125132,
0.006908406,
0.0409087501,
0.0271894578,
-0.0560071804,
0.0434523635,
-0.0241872538,
0.0024235584,
-0.0614117496,
0.0221618842,
0.0212877691,
0.0489159711,
-0.0122173484,
0.0009450597,
0.0112681193,
-0.0169958714,
-0.0350984186,
-0.0286520869,
0.0104411012,
-0.1241217256,
-0.0289503355,
-0.016769316,
-0.0287389886,
0.0486230776,
0.0431979671,
-0.0368585326,
0.007331315,
0.0215121061,
-0.0218764842,
0.0061192331,
-0.0467511453,
0.0154831167,
-0.0360903144,
0.0561331995,
-0.0040553459,
-0.0464571901,
-0.0361554548,
-0.0813682601,
0.0170290451,
0.0200034194,
-0.0104317944,
0.0067591676,
-0.0177516956,
-0.0007813025,
-0.016974505,
-0.0120660774,
-0.0097865704,
0.0208324231,
-0.0568282567,
-0.0139983092,
0.0141455261,
0.0275895707,
0.0225517526,
0.0109841414,
-0.0185425989,
-0.0151427956,
0.0676606968,
0.0187261142,
0.0538908541,
-0.0046509169,
-0.0167842675,
0.0310363192,
0.0177823473,
-0.0384441465,
-0.0018446684,
-0.018419927,
0.0760587081,
0.0190504305,
-0.0027511839,
-0.0170340277,
0.012306869,
0.0488378145,
0.0194051918,
-0.0531130508,
-0.0399700813,
0.0008498593,
-0.0350728147,
-0.0335129239,
-0.048784025,
-0.0340636075,
-0.0175963175,
-0.0079766922,
-0.0391368456,
0.0555546992,
-0.0175446402,
-0.0300593302,
-0.039992664,
-0.0395068377,
-0.0054993583,
-0.0423557423,
-0.0537246242,
0.0047419108,
-0.0278200153,
-0.0489572287,
-0.0291510634,
-0.0156752989,
0.0382642671,
-0.0558238067,
0.0840557367,
-0.009237743,
0.0069898944,
-0.0532575883,
-0.0321366042,
-0.0357535966,
0.0337836407,
-0.0072509716,
0.0271925479,
-0.0022897262,
-0.0239614341,
-0.013580733,
0.0076055396,
0.0258410666,
0.0572812743,
-0.0193707217,
0.0120492214,
0.0048754863,
0.0098014986,
0.0022644829,
0.0089836,
0.0082777571,
-0.0234732181,
0.0001340265,
-0.0297457129,
0.0613419525,
0.0106057199,
-0.0734587312,
0.0076937694,
0.019614676,
-0.0224094596,
0.0391076654,
0.0098989215,
0.0098307291,
0.0035524704,
0.0638345852,
0.0392655022,
-0.0284363292,
-0.0729030743,
-0.0014262896,
0.0128688999,
0.0394394808,
0.0068347729,
-0.0322083123,
-0.0718619525,
-0.0357302055,
0.0272026062,
0.0535288453,
-0.0166096427,
-0.0317192972,
0.019483747,
-0.0392186195,
0.0231666826,
-0.009939556,
-0.001335692,
-0.0115448721,
-0.0044398457,
0.0165868718,
-0.0574719533,
0.0996445939,
-0.0173683204,
0.0195452739,
-0.031279929,
0.0699562803,
-0.097564131,
-0.0639082268,
-0.0085068867,
-0.038625434,
0.0794723183,
0.0631921217,
-0.0103681209,
-0.0179320872,
-0.0704750568,
0.0036154781,
-0.0367470197,
-0.0321216993,
-0.0114786299,
0.0377587005,
0.0041094935,
-0.030242471,
0.0212439299,
0.0497749187,
-0.0633058548,
0.0317642167,
-0.0069274269,
0.0230348185,
-0.0443765521,
0.0257360023,
-0.0137642873,
-0.0193071906,
0.0369246379,
0.0478899032,
0.013509714,
0.002650986,
-0.0059724348,
0.0112249991,
0.0535049736,
0.007036801,
0.0307315625,
0.0148274833,
-0.0050007896,
-0.059709847,
-0.0380872488,
0.0156582668,
-0.004750066,
0.0448087938,
0.0071669705,
0.021967439,
-0.0363983847,
0.0500624105,
-0.0063770306,
0.0191438496,
0.0148053411,
0.0789503008,
-0.0433408171,
-0.0114745526,
0.0029138376,
-0.0222215597,
-0.0309328754,
0.0026350198,
0.0260839295,
-0.0546102524,
0.0832248852,
-0.0290824268,
0.0186714083,
0.0251192432,
-0.0386141911,
-0.0962594226,
0.1001384258,
0.046574343,
-0.0534853302,
0.0315697119,
0.0677751079,
-0.0109199556,
-0.0257179104,
0.0271744374,
-0.0432854556,
0.0428874753,
-0.0049894038,
0.0052928543,
-0.0236253161,
-0.0867020339,
-0.0428066142,
0.0634299889,
0.0499184951,
-0.0152330501,
-0.0063939118,
-0.0385642275,
0.0534733012,
0.0327968895,
0.0725995526,
-0.0232908968,
0.00114592,
0.029285416,
0.0016277968,
-0.0306462254,
0.0307404827,
-0.0460175648,
-0.0463075973,
-0.0069659175,
0.1368795037,
0.0228494871,
0.026027903,
-0.00342357,
0.0181759316,
-0.0015436434,
0.0596788749,
0.0410725027,
0.0230401047,
-0.0023248377,
-0.0172349997,
0.0294458345,
0.0004540618,
0.035286136,
-0.0082905022,
-0.0122633819,
0.0106174322,
-0.0147902658,
-0.0380289033,
-0.0316119976,
0.0243622679,
0.004121264,
0.03117631,
0.0305173043,
-0.0404479504,
-0.0390007421,
-0.0417105556,
0.0696666017,
0.049048055,
-0.0091439988,
0.0049478207,
0.0631681681,
0.0338622928,
-0.0498919897,
0.0177635271,
-0.041997496,
0.0087258508,
-0.0178594422,
-0.0714954138,
0.0328320116,
-0.0107193459,
-0.0451609679,
-0.0136860544,
0.0245060213,
-0.0592404269,
0.0179166477,
0.0196518023,
0.0662061423,
-0.0219436809,
0.0014795942,
-0.0208001137,
-0.0590553023,
-0.0033898121,
0.0294492487,
-0.0532543696,
-0.0470143072,
-0.0086520612,
0.0298559368,
-5.822406823e-33,
0.0087297587,
0.0182436761,
-0.0227244087,
-0.0486018956,
-0.001904726,
0.0209205337,
-0.004443571,
0.0295022745,
0.0087701837,
0.015155429,
-0.0082221748,
0.0049909782,
0.0422773659,
0.0078654783,
-0.0434104614,
-0.0301829576,
0.0791663378,
0.0131125189,
0.0007080257,
0.0043983958,
-0.0059853951,
0.0367957056,
0.0184164848,
-0.049949795,
-0.0281421542,
0.0143236574,
0.0113580897,
-0.0370573513,
0.0423097871,
0.0151668359,
-0.0068233898,
0.0438645184,
-0.0064906743,
-0.0271045342,
0.0191604849,
0.0132062919,
-0.0606002025,
-0.0001304949,
-0.0502493083,
0.0118540367,
-0.010100184,
0.0069295196,
0.0698154867,
0.0345587395,
-0.046044603,
-0.0328187682,
0.0447254628,
-0.0149490088,
-0.0060510198,
-0.0410136469,
0.0314579122,
0.0585255288,
-0.0112652285,
-0.0035287766,
0.037800651,
-0.0381838046,
-0.016381314,
-0.000397778,
0.0125327306,
-0.006733221,
0.0078051216,
-0.0001283587,
0.0182086695,
0.0297540575,
0.0056017414,
0.0398183987,
0.041751124,
-0.0328634121,
0.0513569377,
-0.0527140088,
0.0276380312,
-0.0018794164,
0.0092322091,
0.0660456419,
0.0294575281,
-0.0110637899,
-0.050483685,
0.0128714005,
0.034044072,
0.0163053945,
0.0209862255,
0.0433961786,
-0.0533850566,
0.0008392619,
-0.0376083553,
-0.0129708042,
-0.0063272957,
0.0017204684,
0.0283831265,
0.0084099844,
-0.0247077178,
0.0465476103,
0.0459802374,
-0.0392459445,
0.0024386614,
0.0001563655,
0.0222164318,
-0.031784378,
0.0185165871,
-0.0154587058,
-0.0191252604,
-0.0027743233,
0.04719745,
0.0816449523,
0.0137933875,
-0.0326070525,
0.0134182228,
0.0405281708,
-0.050646726,
-0.0046292925,
0.0266236998,
0.047455553,
0.0080956407,
0.0740569159,
0.0160983969,
-0.0201888122,
-0.0093500754,
0.0284198951,
-0.0418621004,
0.009685359,
-0.0278094877,
0.0241113324,
0.0078138337,
0.0668575019,
-0.0556247458,
-0.0186025389,
0.0543204993,
-0.0371001959,
0.0449269228,
-0.0434226282,
0.0106617762,
-0.0499955155,
2.634e-7,
-0.047219824,
-0.0025459791,
0.0529072993,
-0.0551381223,
-0.0055990182,
0.018122701,
-0.0016930535,
0.0045184405,
-0.0173458047,
0.0114099281,
0.003964439,
0.0297356658,
0.0246576834,
0.010091546,
-0.0467556007,
0.020087406,
-0.0738379955,
0.0863947868,
0.0196395237,
0.0020409622,
-0.0530035868,
0.0299899951,
-0.0412539169,
-0.098419562,
0.0350120403,
-0.0178111121,
-0.0208184719,
-0.0023607402,
0.0601183586,
0.00704015,
0.0525267683,
0.008016807,
0.041218821,
0.0432739072,
-0.0175907258,
0.0530155636,
-0.0307430848,
0.0095398324,
-0.0647178739,
-0.0617371537,
0.0313172787,
0.0466249101,
0.0148274219,
0.0136322035,
0.0059260083,
-0.012042582,
-0.0168169104,
-0.0336428732,
-0.0576746762,
-0.024472015,
0.0624401569,
-0.0058033238,
0.024193855,
-0.0206320044,
0.0147533342,
-0.0106929066,
-0.0305859093,
-0.0674064681,
0.027828183,
-0.0159657113,
-0.0616309717,
-0.0166813452,
0.0006939662,
0.0087261191,
-0.0228642561,
-0.0257553011,
0.0022532963,
1.76247998e-34,
0.022140732,
0.0166934803,
-0.0128750484,
-0.0410484932,
0.0086284261,
-0.0584828109,
0.0140380301,
0.0173602346,
0.0211384259,
0.0008611999,
-0.0527839512
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.