id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14772v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14772v3 | A Question Answering Framework for Decontextualizing User-facing Snippets from Scientific Documents | 2023-05-24T06:23:02 | 2023-12-01T00:11:04 | Benjamin Newman, Luca Soldaini, Raymond Fok, Arman Cohan, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many real-world applications (e.g., note taking, search) require extracting a
sentence or paragraph from a document and showing that snippet to a human
outside of the source document. Yet, users may find snippets difficult to
understand as they lack context from the original document. In this work, we
use language models to rewrite snippets from scientific documents to be read on
their own. First, we define the requirements and challenges for this
user-facing decontextualization task, such as clarifying where edits occur and
handling references to other documents. Second, we propose a framework that
decomposes the task into three stages: question generation, question answering,
and rewriting. Using this framework, we collect gold decontextualizations from
experienced scientific article readers. We then conduct a range of experiments
across state-of-the-art commercial and open-source language models to identify
how to best provide missing-but-relevant information to models for our task.
Finally, we develop QaDecontext, a simple prompting strategy inspired by our
framework that improves over end-to-end prompting. We conclude with analysis
that finds, while rewriting is easy, question generation and answering remain
challenging for today's models. | [
0.0468303747,
0.0194884893,
0.0157730374,
0.0124581438,
-0.0244761892,
0.0086610904,
-0.0041870866,
-0.0010276432,
0.0146864969,
-0.0348899141,
-0.0274940822,
0.0387463979,
-0.0071614236,
0.0348394178,
0.0130425198,
-0.082360886,
0.0309588984,
-0.027346598,
0.0395099819,
0.0013327129,
0.0240600929,
0.0060705687,
-0.0158440638,
0.0229075681,
0.0505110808,
-0.0618321896,
-0.038168367,
0.0072246687,
0.0377197526,
-0.020772865,
0.0071813813,
0.0422444269,
0.012319034,
0.0176175833,
0.0000019955,
-0.0349568315,
-0.0288737621,
0.0205896888,
-0.0296449717,
0.0252053384,
0.0275687501,
-0.0097638043,
0.0209706798,
0.0008813344,
-0.0588184074,
-0.0281648245,
0.0463906489,
0.025859192,
0.0715763122,
0.0509866253,
-0.0051115011,
-0.0025233252,
-0.0043750475,
0.0141426129,
0.0569240041,
-0.005602567,
-0.0009816473,
0.0199615136,
0.0707844347,
0.0594731346,
0.0181755666,
0.0649265721,
0.0269523356,
-0.0336398669,
0.0338879302,
0.0442582928,
-0.0233626775,
-0.017317621,
-0.0338439569,
0.0997676179,
0.0361425579,
-0.0181602146,
0.0355290323,
0.0190087147,
-0.0003876197,
0.0580992661,
-0.1002694517,
-0.0002114827,
0.0016419233,
-0.0323931687,
0.0179605689,
-0.0194845293,
0.0161186326,
0.0227828845,
0.0010067145,
0.0395422317,
0.0277596042,
-0.0281771682,
-0.0445527211,
-0.0094436482,
0.0089106113,
-0.0683730319,
0.0518635996,
0.0664336532,
-0.0096590202,
0.0008022203,
-0.0488518327,
-0.0411264189,
0.0263208319,
0.0052961148,
0.0026072518,
0.0110130114,
-0.0188688487,
0.0577733852,
-0.0238054562,
0.0058683911,
-0.012319874,
0.0114320116,
-0.0252969898,
0.0150366863,
-0.0282923449,
-0.0360500328,
-0.0573533252,
-0.0134621551,
-0.0732533857,
-0.0156113636,
0.0170154385,
0.0381624848,
0.0519906841,
0.0173765086,
-0.0298476759,
0.0234751143,
-0.0441718102,
-0.0144368066,
0.0099966927,
0.0449988209,
-0.0300377626,
-0.0234377999,
0.0526781008,
-0.0559007004,
-0.0422404222,
0.0066831326,
0.0309104212,
-0.024267707,
-0.0342927538,
0.0586252883,
-0.0067646545,
-0.0206731744,
0.0169108585,
-0.0551697239,
0.0116834166,
-0.0170844793,
-0.0021625371,
-0.0500116982,
0.0539442971,
0.0363364629,
-0.0283583198,
-0.0567612052,
0.011565865,
0.0421926714,
-0.0319034234,
0.0883571282,
-0.0765533894,
-0.0094202599,
0.0578758456,
0.0134770507,
0.0005781031,
0.0173389353,
0.0272094179,
-0.0135732358,
0.033400204,
-0.0154590122,
0.0280960165,
-0.0005238398,
0.0115586184,
-0.0242562629,
0.0048029143,
0.0332965888,
0.0079951258,
0.0310478434,
0.0219165534,
0.0471512452,
-0.0276841689,
0.002694461,
0.0261703543,
0.0679727718,
-0.0018796426,
0.0030353363,
0.0279191863,
0.0169064701,
0.0252887066,
0.0352360494,
-0.0389253832,
0.0500867292,
-0.0094533125,
0.0283044092,
0.0029654403,
0.0069833337,
-0.0035255414,
-0.0243254118,
0.0081820041,
0.0252495632,
0.0018450358,
-0.0062031029,
0.0436042696,
0.0387011506,
-0.0306495912,
-0.0035204261,
0.0135827726,
-0.0611806773,
0.0247821994,
-0.022843359,
0.0515841581,
0.0736172944,
0.0805934817,
-0.0424039587,
-0.0005497825,
-0.0235747695,
0.0073461132,
0.007177413,
0.0468185432,
-0.0393191837,
-0.0032659436,
-0.0428808779,
-0.0186477713,
-0.0568818189,
0.0006640445,
0.0039804792,
0.0086423736,
-0.023340838,
0.0396934636,
-0.0521336421,
-0.0061552194,
0.0526664704,
-0.0576195456,
-0.0384667888,
-0.0261690915,
-0.0103935907,
-0.0271516126,
0.0264438335,
-0.0009321758,
0.0590843149,
0.046816323,
-0.0321625546,
0.0194105227,
0.0415725522,
-0.009682266,
-0.0630695075,
0.0117421113,
-0.0588341877,
0.0024973906,
0.0042092032,
-0.0072523183,
-0.0547582321,
0.0213847477,
-0.0355099216,
0.015345295,
-0.0314281248,
-0.0192889683,
0.0376705043,
-0.0192807354,
-0.0533892922,
0.0365414992,
0.0325365476,
0.0211423915,
0.0385154784,
-0.0189603623,
-0.0002051721,
-0.0708049983,
-0.0151978908,
-0.0086149676,
-0.0030520088,
-0.0217522532,
0.0199939702,
0.0028461304,
-0.052355703,
-0.011943371,
-0.069118984,
0.0104691768,
-0.0171808209,
0.0352771394,
0.0545030013,
0.0403122865,
-0.010105907,
-0.0454322174,
-0.0333015136,
-0.0242608655,
0.0068103462,
0.0177942254,
0.0514452308,
0.0240599439,
0.0380446762,
-0.0643534958,
-0.0092969099,
-0.035842251,
0.0427036695,
0.0423575789,
-0.0137365451,
-0.0681366846,
0.0097424118,
0.0128514618,
-0.0213014428,
-0.0017846581,
0.0095119933,
0.0304757375,
-0.0273793954,
0.0720761269,
0.1064884737,
-0.0111530665,
0.0231933538,
0.0352773592,
-0.0284623355,
-0.0578537397,
0.0116200605,
-0.0054092812,
0.03671683,
0.0273420457,
-0.0228108466,
0.0546581186,
0.0597175397,
-0.0186994653,
0.0150688346,
-0.0042817979,
0.0786086842,
-0.0195264164,
-0.005956497,
-0.0349543765,
-0.0161759034,
0.0108269732,
0.0663226992,
-0.0114668095,
-0.0187850744,
0.0848654285,
-0.0157826375,
-0.0247485675,
-0.0534824356,
0.0120421499,
-0.0116599277,
0.0277423542,
-0.0149794649,
0.020136904,
0.0112741822,
-0.0036978663,
-0.0404934511,
0.0123337833,
-0.0209361948,
-0.0207321737,
0.0031561512,
-0.0772619471,
-0.0080495477,
-0.0144799389,
-0.0190402046,
-0.0157714076,
-0.0183077566,
-0.0218574647,
0.0081751086,
-0.0099212294,
-0.032655444,
-0.0388335064,
0.0061264592,
0.0496277884,
0.0564639941,
-0.0534441508,
-0.0146004697,
-0.0425415784,
0.0760861784,
0.0799968168,
-0.0077338465,
0.0168363396,
-0.0726066083,
0.0465652309,
0.0573620014,
0.0272165947,
0.0111313714,
0.0156569015,
-0.0330290422,
-0.0023783615,
-0.0478980169,
-0.017029807,
-0.0088763861,
0.0599200092,
-0.0813646987,
-0.0468252227,
0.100212872,
0.043141488,
-0.0520678274,
-0.0167380236,
-0.0622516535,
0.000489668,
-0.0010812583,
0.0594918542,
-0.1051895097,
-0.032639008,
-0.0088080578,
0.0259031728,
0.0347450823,
-0.0223747268,
-0.0135555826,
-0.0380418859,
0.0470432378,
-0.0009413,
-0.0519494079,
-0.0230385084,
-0.0466153882,
0.0063190809,
0.0177458599,
-0.0263201483,
0.0490824915,
-0.0157346912,
0.0349391773,
0.0038742295,
0.0122472225,
-0.0354802385,
-0.0410038792,
-0.0060082087,
0.0040971152,
0.0762178376,
0.0176494494,
0.0285924394,
0.0013392767,
-0.0230833497,
-0.0428335667,
-0.0161206387,
-0.0166729558,
0.0486544147,
0.0032807761,
-0.0009069707,
-0.0371381827,
0.076413393,
-0.0219778735,
-0.0412800275,
0.0539558493,
0.0277237762,
-0.0221288688,
-0.0195191354,
-0.0795732588,
-0.0034689561,
0.0083932718,
0.0925090909,
0.0591808893,
-0.0298845451,
-0.0873943865,
-0.0535139963,
0.0354152098,
-0.0697594285,
-0.0072494112,
-0.0149486335,
-0.0020601696,
0.0155481724,
-0.0912326425,
-0.0367095284,
0.0746618807,
0.0118537974,
0.0185581502,
-0.0003007028,
0.0096864039,
-0.0170498975,
-0.0561710224,
0.0301996917,
-0.0232159887,
0.0173304416,
-0.0119984411,
-0.0394605063,
0.0385868475,
-0.0071923849,
-0.0077250269,
-0.000794082,
-0.0222293586,
-0.0531567074,
-0.0063557904,
0.0552477539,
0.0283976328,
0.0039385441,
-0.014734569,
-0.0374171771,
0.02008483,
0.0163545739,
-0.0287336521,
-0.0048519648,
-0.0113303326,
0.0372819602,
-0.020308068,
-0.0009328244,
-0.0323256105,
-0.0284296349,
-0.0377439,
0.0329144187,
-0.0595904775,
-0.0525296293,
0.0334805883,
0.0201008134,
-0.0014466218,
0.0032720049,
0.0544715002,
-0.0098278373,
-0.0080821272,
-0.0275079925,
-0.0176278763,
-0.0561631918,
0.0255107582,
0.0020053117,
0.0011412216,
0.0405844413,
0.0125732534,
-0.043561127,
0.0124037452,
-0.0571454614,
0.0237164423,
0.0532428883,
0.0205282588,
0.0317373537,
-0.0149117513,
-0.0149530722,
-0.0136516532,
-0.0382706374,
0.0516362078,
-0.0020740435,
0.0704595074,
0.0338428132,
-0.0399457999,
0.0125824697,
0.0340682417,
-0.1101337522,
-0.0228182003,
-0.0024854227,
0.0126895094,
-0.0117601668,
0.0096182665,
0.0491363853,
-0.0099373329,
-0.0251896698,
-0.0000916321,
0.0657745004,
0.0434509218,
-0.0136382673,
0.043734502,
0.0323050059,
0.0160725508,
-0.0191698801,
0.0887570232,
-0.0019196359,
0.0387993343,
-0.0047627841,
-0.0108840819,
-0.062767975,
-0.0260490086,
-0.0167149678,
0.0253460649,
-0.0106827682,
-0.0192430671,
-0.0333687067,
-0.0261859372,
-0.0012368895,
0.0391435735,
-0.0099369399,
-0.0041742465,
0.0316584855,
0.042870447,
-0.0155185414,
-0.0827946141,
-0.0284356661,
0.0938554034,
-0.0375942215,
-0.0949110091,
-0.0578959025,
-5.883035516e-33,
-0.0308811981,
-0.0395313501,
-0.0031422528,
0.0095701627,
-0.0114133498,
0.0119518526,
-0.0888584927,
-0.0206741802,
0.0168944448,
0.0130445668,
-0.0143096754,
-0.000683082,
-0.0086416574,
0.0126321809,
-0.0255294554,
0.0032855333,
0.0528624691,
0.000523894,
-0.0280843619,
0.0443997942,
0.0185502749,
0.0364659689,
0.0236147009,
-0.0493662842,
0.0449620932,
-0.0416032784,
-0.0072214454,
0.0023288366,
0.0039991946,
0.0324330814,
-0.0557689629,
-0.0171428546,
0.010864065,
-0.0032081443,
-0.0305454358,
0.0957650989,
-0.0991211236,
0.0080879116,
0.0142946169,
-0.0028561032,
-0.0792149976,
-0.0514498241,
0.0202526581,
-0.0341023616,
0.0430104397,
0.0056131906,
0.0532652773,
0.0009041131,
-0.0079230918,
-0.0085115116,
-0.0462911986,
0.0222647432,
-0.0409370027,
-0.0383480042,
0.0222679544,
0.0942772105,
-0.0173860285,
0.0029310388,
-0.0145975277,
0.0295374542,
0.0670494288,
0.0193363018,
0.0309887081,
0.0257579368,
0.0191527735,
0.0424357168,
0.0201781467,
-0.0391154736,
0.0063117025,
0.0023764491,
-0.0062801484,
0.0175087117,
0.0297315996,
0.0276256967,
0.015849309,
0.0547845177,
-0.0393318608,
0.0711635873,
-0.0268003903,
0.0169542562,
0.0106029911,
0.0095537445,
0.0252168849,
-0.004728789,
-0.0174277294,
-0.0061567421,
-0.0135397641,
-0.0339495987,
0.0180420037,
-0.0368234888,
-0.0703714788,
-0.0319046341,
0.007584393,
-0.0293526091,
0.0141894668,
0.0135163264,
-0.01383851,
0.0534362793,
-0.0053254473,
-0.0158737898,
-0.0461302996,
0.0214099307,
0.025133729,
0.0147701157,
0.0241136495,
0.0238365792,
-0.0060217958,
-0.0142059922,
-0.0362011939,
-0.0091631245,
-0.013301569,
0.0321526937,
-0.0063075484,
0.0171240345,
0.0075516626,
0.0176074989,
-0.0139467679,
0.0341940932,
0.0112576429,
0.0137673421,
-0.0571085475,
-0.0196159706,
0.0074423808,
0.021118721,
-0.029003296,
-0.0008758389,
-0.0100726476,
0.045725219,
-0.0194434263,
-0.0454338416,
0.0079218168,
0.0263771527,
2.57e-7,
0.0618328303,
0.0346542783,
0.0758729279,
-0.0196388979,
0.0142381182,
0.0180145577,
0.0169216413,
0.0172048826,
0.0218614992,
-0.0074787182,
-0.0049992641,
0.0056447657,
0.0212223511,
-0.0041760462,
-0.1267881244,
-0.0187772438,
-0.0757945031,
-0.0257384386,
-0.0468128808,
-0.0197645668,
0.0385708399,
-0.029868247,
-0.040909972,
-0.0003918356,
-0.0019719135,
-0.0215597786,
0.0461338833,
-0.0188432466,
0.003903839,
0.0439274535,
0.0102329105,
0.0135930236,
0.0132946773,
-0.0065724826,
-0.0141677549,
-0.0079720141,
0.0231987014,
0.0555952787,
0.0053834282,
-0.0111156087,
-0.001824708,
-0.0069342381,
0.0449035317,
-0.0642812848,
0.0424689837,
-0.0536477678,
-0.028137438,
-0.0222719721,
-0.0523810759,
-0.0176132172,
-0.0030090925,
-0.0246086661,
-0.0501235723,
0.0354712121,
-0.0243333355,
-0.0204356797,
-0.0166725907,
-0.0435441509,
-0.0508310981,
0.0160022639,
-0.0066843079,
-0.0234371256,
-0.0496240444,
-0.0105375266,
-0.0325893871,
-0.0484382771,
-0.0158147514,
2.273454059e-34,
0.0231800061,
0.0049941819,
-0.0072313305,
0.0588082261,
0.030585859,
-0.0202827677,
0.0132904248,
0.0194076095,
0.0420831703,
-0.0776123554,
-0.0361564718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14771v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14771v2 | David helps Goliath: Inference-Time Collaboration Between Small Specialized and Large General Diffusion LMs | 2023-05-24T06:22:14 | 2024-02-14T17:45:41 | Xiaochuang Han, Sachin Kumar, Yulia Tsvetkov, Marjan Ghazvininejad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Diffusion-based language models are emerging as a promising alternative to
autoregressive LMs: they approach the competence of autoregressive LMs while
offering nuanced controllability at inference time. While autoregressive LMs
have benefited immensely from scaling and instruction-based learning, existing
studies of diffusion LMs have been conducted on a smaller scale. Starting with
a recently proposed diffusion model SSD-LM, in this work we first explore
methods to scale it from 0.4B to 13B parameters, proposing techniques to
improve its training and inference efficiency, and to finetune the model to
follow instructions. Armed with a more powerful, general purpose diffusion LM,
we introduce the primary contribution of this work -- SSD-2 -- an approach to
easily ensemble at inference time a large general-purpose diffusion LM with
smaller, but specialized and contextualized diffusion LMs. We show that SSD-2
facilitates novel ensembles with 100x smaller models that can be customized and
deployed by individual users. We find that compared to autoregressive models,
the collaboration between diffusion LMs is more effective, leading to
higher-quality model responses due to their ability to dynamically incorporate
bi-directional contexts. | [
0.008903495,
0.0544070415,
-0.0034700267,
0.0425664745,
-0.0175220966,
0.0074439533,
0.0274580661,
-0.0416241549,
-0.0002786035,
-0.0007283412,
-0.0672099143,
-0.0817690641,
0.001417588,
-0.0014191549,
0.0320103839,
-0.0233867131,
0.013724084,
-0.0546679832,
-0.0683567449,
-0.0399227627,
0.004585952,
0.0177964214,
0.0188159533,
0.0279520359,
0.0353182666,
0.0005414163,
-0.0034331244,
0.0168809798,
0.0147240283,
-0.0135523789,
0.0069722175,
0.0576241724,
0.0888848901,
0.0118995337,
0.0000019798,
-0.0237235893,
-0.0078099212,
-0.0146255391,
-0.0150916344,
0.0160392467,
0.0455281734,
-0.0085317753,
0.0067020678,
0.0199798979,
-0.007441143,
-0.0134476535,
0.0496520475,
0.0033134338,
0.0448084064,
0.0750143081,
0.0015940395,
-0.0736737847,
0.0048550298,
-0.0667403191,
0.0132481912,
-0.0386192687,
0.0413556024,
0.0139449229,
0.005883696,
0.0080624018,
-0.0503299348,
0.0467165112,
0.0024859963,
-0.0058600758,
0.0331981666,
0.0479210392,
0.0448460467,
-0.0198938902,
-0.0112679983,
0.0853578523,
0.0210313518,
-0.0075954185,
0.0149776107,
-0.0260202829,
-0.0442514904,
0.032571651,
-0.043856848,
0.0091345711,
0.0289358404,
0.0622748621,
0.0171878859,
-0.0101271532,
0.0703713968,
0.0174704231,
-0.0218781829,
0.044490017,
0.0059206756,
-0.0068158447,
-0.0032231079,
0.0212743916,
-0.0091930898,
-0.0305587612,
-0.0017999493,
0.0215042569,
-0.0014437784,
0.016963724,
-0.0393764712,
-0.0316628106,
0.0133645153,
-0.0109318579,
0.0793683678,
-0.0031122388,
0.048007194,
0.0541335717,
-0.0141296126,
-0.0145537145,
-0.0496928468,
-0.0301493816,
-0.0373049639,
-0.0100666052,
-0.0368294604,
0.0175565146,
-0.0097604254,
0.0052268305,
-0.0030143228,
-0.0031753106,
-0.0603845455,
0.0377525836,
-0.0071425387,
-0.0203196276,
0.0373467132,
-0.0006584955,
-0.0333639681,
-0.0284382291,
0.0067148982,
0.0408375002,
-0.0380736031,
0.0102596711,
0.009769896,
-0.0174429752,
-0.0330322906,
0.0310184415,
0.0058810823,
-0.0109860674,
-0.0086720465,
0.041311685,
-0.0101932641,
-0.0227119755,
-0.0261693783,
-0.0067904373,
-0.0213154294,
-0.0621158481,
-0.0022093889,
-0.0934124663,
0.0406355411,
-0.003716911,
0.0208224654,
-0.0487843044,
0.0061731869,
-0.0102906618,
-0.0539482608,
0.0530959405,
0.0068498277,
0.0367858261,
0.0296170339,
-0.0067083696,
0.0013192128,
0.092219837,
0.0365878865,
0.0099436129,
0.0045338594,
0.0148826819,
0.011633534,
0.0139689986,
0.0459442511,
0.0464985818,
-0.0182911847,
-0.0237174891,
-0.0125282267,
0.0338501446,
0.0506332442,
0.0763392225,
-0.0366796628,
-0.0374367647,
0.0848414898,
0.0612049624,
0.0288474038,
-0.0152280293,
0.0725586638,
0.0129207587,
-0.0459730402,
0.0086487355,
-0.005166356,
0.0143260891,
0.0144693814,
0.0021160592,
0.0598534532,
0.0362968557,
-0.0609387681,
-0.0326563641,
0.0017900638,
-0.0198547505,
0.03497779,
0.0312293209,
0.0545914248,
-0.0112474952,
-0.0392218605,
0.0587757267,
0.0208540168,
-0.0422093645,
-0.0062245182,
-0.064417854,
0.0635312796,
0.0696523637,
0.0378538445,
-0.0062148743,
0.0234390125,
-0.0250154566,
0.0547440536,
0.0239917785,
0.0230743904,
0.017823223,
0.0248418245,
-0.0642246902,
-0.0122794462,
0.0184819307,
0.0176411327,
0.0222429503,
0.0039478643,
-0.0063929404,
0.011236175,
-0.0124134123,
-0.0179901402,
0.0097935582,
-0.0727618337,
-0.0241492111,
0.018668551,
-0.0167641435,
0.0212881267,
-0.0282684509,
-0.0233596135,
-0.0023188049,
0.0011033474,
-0.0266643651,
-0.0476582572,
0.0048357588,
-0.0712787062,
-0.0579456016,
-0.0229040347,
0.0066308901,
-0.0007989659,
-0.0187009871,
-0.0564630516,
-0.0268292278,
0.0427062996,
0.0025948775,
0.0200810544,
-0.0671042874,
-0.0009616873,
0.0156333763,
0.0482231677,
-0.0019337939,
0.0421960577,
-0.0491485037,
-0.0036793656,
-0.0147543242,
0.0358748883,
-0.0281909239,
-0.0212623291,
-0.0178349465,
-0.036345128,
0.0263288524,
0.0219060946,
-0.0287617072,
-0.0110714482,
-0.0281325057,
-0.0304749738,
-0.05883554,
0.0075875204,
-0.0594411008,
-0.0070227562,
0.0160708874,
0.017978847,
-0.0046405424,
-0.0016980905,
-0.002508247,
-0.0053646308,
-0.004284081,
0.0298730023,
0.0170611683,
-0.0051311506,
-0.0023105689,
-0.0601214059,
-0.0221129432,
0.013389457,
0.0571318343,
-0.0371262915,
-0.0017978441,
-0.0424082875,
0.0019550356,
-0.0061798887,
0.0105256643,
-0.0312470645,
-0.0359270461,
-0.0047576497,
-0.0299484711,
0.0441393852,
0.0660133362,
0.0135658337,
0.0442321263,
0.0487790219,
-0.0146745862,
-0.0422257334,
0.0205294881,
-0.0357628204,
0.0018146966,
-0.0403663367,
-0.0246251635,
-0.0322859697,
0.0689078271,
0.0000434514,
-0.0254113413,
-0.0241876636,
-0.0225202423,
0.0184647683,
-0.0232402422,
-0.0121381832,
-0.0202590283,
-0.0234265961,
-0.0174404085,
-0.0226420648,
-0.0686753318,
0.0697812364,
-0.0374780409,
-0.0094788922,
-0.0432449169,
-0.0731525943,
-0.0338445045,
0.0348946564,
-0.0206020027,
0.0022041961,
-0.0145948511,
-0.0087968707,
-0.0285656583,
-0.0012940257,
0.0289080255,
-0.009761312,
0.0621762201,
-0.0432037041,
0.0336453244,
-0.0008414853,
0.0017723195,
-0.0306727514,
-0.0749932528,
-0.0136689013,
-0.0006297987,
-0.0066603282,
-0.0157413781,
-0.0091445101,
0.0242086258,
0.0015190877,
0.0114161847,
-0.0136194881,
0.0059091575,
0.0021648838,
0.025652064,
0.0539921038,
0.0218820721,
-0.0249808133,
-0.0827419385,
0.058054734,
0.0347498506,
0.0525940917,
-0.0096379546,
-0.0545870177,
-0.0013501832,
-0.0071314164,
0.0069479784,
-0.0075688283,
0.0073695257,
0.102093026,
-0.0409259945,
0.0035105541,
0.1075889841,
-0.0091541354,
-0.0710428581,
-0.0187758598,
0.0210082699,
0.0767426714,
-0.0104778409,
-0.0012829319,
-0.0452703238,
-0.0355443247,
0.0008580695,
0.0237885434,
0.0234277453,
-0.0124895964,
-0.0131397704,
-0.0616415218,
0.0314266346,
0.0468658432,
-0.0174279902,
0.0180334579,
-0.0613501482,
0.0048523066,
-0.0080302572,
0.0157438852,
-0.0130925858,
-0.0195405781,
-0.0045144223,
0.025138678,
-0.0261922665,
-0.0734014064,
0.0150087569,
-0.057938695,
0.0398641154,
0.07048475,
-0.0057784533,
0.027175352,
-0.0499832705,
0.0543267354,
-0.0299580079,
0.0156300999,
-0.0220638271,
0.0410331748,
-0.0287785288,
-0.0050009117,
0.0150929866,
0.0545634814,
-0.0480343103,
0.0123905092,
-0.0233304836,
0.0920259506,
-0.0144978492,
-0.0379299,
-0.0289599374,
0.0070636347,
0.0610058568,
0.0798347667,
0.0552763604,
-0.0557026938,
-0.0301314648,
-0.0085621579,
-0.0165997464,
0.0075118239,
-0.0399613418,
0.001848045,
-0.0030122863,
-0.0671392977,
-0.0628219992,
-0.0240616128,
0.0276553147,
0.0546136908,
-0.0230341218,
0.063144587,
-0.0003291821,
-0.0268328749,
-0.035840068,
0.0261687599,
-0.0278536752,
0.0416338407,
-0.0221984703,
-0.0135030476,
0.0543691739,
0.0222903658,
-0.0058496287,
0.0100329891,
-0.1230455711,
-0.1167467013,
-0.0167398714,
0.0302010477,
0.0180503875,
0.0508233458,
0.0061742319,
-0.0626107603,
0.0875718966,
0.0286488403,
0.043887306,
0.0346783586,
0.0449218117,
-0.0095275966,
-0.0022372883,
0.0568243228,
-0.0370185971,
0.0501785241,
0.0166686084,
0.051350072,
-0.0617515929,
0.0247556064,
-0.0394135974,
-0.0608701706,
0.0234926157,
-0.0083842101,
0.0083948579,
-0.0302238017,
0.0117790224,
0.0013731596,
-0.0080365296,
-0.0641426146,
-0.0062902644,
0.0437277183,
-0.0352934636,
-0.0159049761,
-0.0105974628,
0.0264336132,
0.0245876685,
-0.0358744673,
0.0423839167,
0.0050607449,
0.022884205,
0.0397072844,
0.0357689224,
-0.0207865499,
-0.0018228637,
-0.0080526704,
0.0099774431,
0.0153855281,
0.037163388,
-0.0096336305,
0.0089338394,
-0.0435778163,
0.008287413,
-0.0692878664,
-0.0440539941,
-0.0374915972,
0.0347574912,
0.0673885867,
0.0201729611,
0.0542381816,
-0.0046726703,
0.0093061309,
-0.0380437113,
0.0418446511,
-0.0447297022,
-0.0038878145,
0.0571479611,
0.0284736771,
-0.0204553213,
0.0492264219,
0.0740452707,
-0.0255829245,
0.0172042977,
0.0068321782,
0.003547387,
-0.00257018,
-0.0148550244,
-0.026652528,
0.0004897983,
0.00673716,
0.0280753952,
-0.0060768258,
-0.0877485648,
-0.0246248506,
0.009056136,
-0.017448293,
-0.0307440907,
0.0341353528,
0.0544393025,
0.008040606,
0.0338414684,
-0.0473179519,
0.0183625259,
-0.0018547116,
-0.0194484778,
-0.0074873324,
-7.234866509e-33,
-0.0174648985,
-0.0043479707,
0.007742723,
-0.0513795726,
-0.0177093223,
-0.0162595622,
-0.0424179621,
0.0114191957,
-0.0303336736,
0.0052711782,
-0.0140260337,
0.0433543287,
0.0136414459,
0.0463888273,
0.0066302712,
0.0212334823,
0.0752288252,
-0.023710968,
0.0025602253,
0.0278464276,
0.0275861118,
0.0605150275,
0.0286455173,
-0.0270146001,
0.0060327784,
-0.0188688673,
0.0202505793,
0.0140418196,
0.0071192537,
0.0232048742,
-0.033683233,
0.0350777842,
0.0187037904,
-0.0074372119,
-0.0635561869,
0.0111538563,
-0.0668832064,
-0.0170543157,
0.004957472,
-0.0447273254,
-0.0540530644,
-0.0069786105,
0.0786666125,
0.0225104596,
0.0174080506,
-0.0194261018,
0.0136050656,
-0.0027879854,
-0.0261712633,
0.0063276165,
-0.0014187819,
0.0416024104,
0.0183084849,
-0.000937282,
0.0076707741,
-0.0284522399,
-0.0115239369,
0.0595974177,
-0.0652850121,
-0.0210305005,
-0.0025620954,
0.0337861441,
0.0654381961,
0.0386076979,
0.0263110157,
0.0432033688,
0.0021360209,
0.0244718045,
-0.0310053471,
-0.0129097449,
0.0288668834,
0.0534293652,
0.0102705723,
0.0105405403,
0.0011613909,
-0.0000452771,
-0.0532756746,
0.0062907664,
0.0233136825,
0.0180994049,
0.0415054187,
0.0515791401,
-0.0225669034,
-0.0263324995,
-0.0275916997,
-0.0171008669,
0.0032085297,
-0.037406005,
0.0083079841,
0.0359848924,
-0.0281543545,
-0.0153808342,
0.0425103158,
-0.0358062834,
-0.0560746379,
-0.0118836164,
0.0046584858,
0.0061372472,
0.0350868478,
0.0198499765,
-0.074141033,
-0.0081823086,
-0.011069119,
0.0146760792,
-0.0278190263,
0.00629461,
0.0009336657,
0.0240414012,
-0.0604251139,
-0.0173012074,
-0.03829889,
-0.0145575255,
-0.0329787098,
0.0291460678,
0.0229595285,
0.0176402479,
-0.0080120647,
0.0691369325,
-0.0241162404,
-0.0192656368,
0.0045596501,
-0.048155129,
-0.0182638075,
0.0412601754,
-0.0489550754,
-0.0017608736,
-0.0195159782,
0.0230319742,
0.0869587883,
-0.0450941287,
-0.0253861286,
0.0330861434,
2.73e-7,
0.034186434,
0.0090436814,
-0.0198898036,
0.018235378,
0.0352811776,
0.0285341367,
-0.0525125042,
0.0210527331,
0.0167574603,
-0.0480751395,
0.0279602297,
0.0649800226,
0.0761821344,
-0.0028275126,
-0.0674454868,
-0.0120301833,
-0.0656463876,
0.0564495996,
-0.0169212967,
-0.0654089451,
0.0030823706,
0.0950276628,
0.0272760224,
-0.0055981972,
0.0054229335,
-0.012725804,
0.0719612241,
-0.0262119919,
0.0072547947,
0.0195936579,
0.009161138,
-0.0099704564,
-0.0349008404,
-0.0093438802,
-0.0232333243,
0.0376582518,
-0.0501088314,
0.061935842,
-0.012321108,
-0.056053184,
0.0205473714,
0.012315752,
0.0050992537,
-0.036408253,
0.0580003336,
-0.0498704091,
-0.0004155929,
-0.0175937302,
-0.0166859012,
-0.0358399302,
0.0516218878,
0.0102892928,
-0.0446596928,
0.0278026275,
0.0034336043,
-0.0155143738,
-0.0204357319,
-0.1168161929,
0.0121381972,
-0.0061273663,
-0.0866042152,
-0.0456430167,
-0.038822785,
-0.0009954569,
0.0021119104,
-0.0021781968,
0.0037964277,
2.238851821e-34,
0.078232199,
-0.0343931243,
-0.0162191894,
0.0512035079,
0.003506263,
-0.030402964,
-0.0663835108,
0.0139835579,
0.0372825898,
-0.1090815887,
-0.0290910657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14770v2 | Using Natural Language Explanations to Rescale Human Judgments | 2023-05-24T06:19:14 | 2023-11-14T18:30:28 | Manya Wadhwa, Jifan Chen, Junyi Jessy Li, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of large language models (LLMs) has brought a critical need for
high-quality human-labeled data, particularly for processes like human feedback
and evaluation. A common practice is to label data via consensus annotation
over crowdworker judgments. However, annotators' judgments for subjective tasks
can differ in many ways: they may have different qualitative judgments about an
example, and they may map those to a labeling scheme in different ways. We show
that these nuances can be captured by natural language explanations, and
propose a method to rescale ordinal annotations and explanations using LLMs.
Specifically, we feed annotators' Likert ratings and corresponding explanations
into an LLM and prompt it to produce a numeric score anchored in a scoring
rubric. These scores should reflect the annotators' underlying assessments of
the example. The rubric can be designed or modified after annotation, and
include distinctions that may not have been known when the original error
taxonomy was devised. We explore our technique in the context of rating system
outputs for a document-grounded question answering task, where LLMs achieve
near-human performance. Our method rescales the raw judgments without impacting
agreement and brings the scores closer to human judgments grounded in the same
scoring rubric. | [
0.0436123684,
0.024867015,
0.0177361649,
0.0247002635,
-0.0009168081,
0.0236526784,
-0.0150580136,
-0.0273018088,
-0.0168959554,
-0.0752990693,
-0.0455806367,
0.0113331452,
0.0052886526,
-0.0260296706,
0.0230815094,
-0.0591439642,
0.0039215321,
-0.0297395233,
0.0378924794,
0.0103461603,
0.0319480635,
0.0120804869,
0.0043205773,
0.0262401924,
0.0080457078,
0.0106081711,
-0.0151915476,
-0.0053476011,
0.0149925901,
0.0019931314,
0.0005340797,
0.0526543632,
0.0138536515,
0.0087240674,
0.0000016688,
-0.0236085393,
0.0392836519,
0.0074067605,
-0.0034178027,
0.0190364309,
0.0384767875,
0.0261535328,
0.0255120434,
0.0053915312,
-0.0385362841,
-0.0198652707,
0.0329939388,
-0.0005450929,
0.108841151,
0.0197362266,
0.015141923,
-0.0407855362,
-0.0527383685,
0.0000561295,
-0.0107261557,
-0.045262862,
-0.02035347,
0.057561595,
0.0201687478,
0.051203128,
0.0022094154,
0.0059284596,
0.0250952393,
-0.022335181,
0.0507846624,
-0.000085679,
-0.0307892933,
0.0032547314,
0.0160431899,
0.0699139163,
0.0271291453,
-0.0226923767,
-0.0384379327,
0.0028844825,
0.0233265776,
0.0095078275,
-0.0368809216,
0.0218269899,
-0.0123678595,
0.0119933942,
-0.0017932019,
0.0402528755,
0.0185581446,
0.012797717,
0.0104100173,
0.0852815136,
-0.0092008496,
-0.0297704712,
0.0031297142,
0.0144203482,
-0.0527986214,
-0.0401835069,
0.030087363,
0.0464732796,
-0.0136929639,
0.0179654434,
-0.0140097952,
0.0027019989,
0.0271604154,
-0.0551150031,
0.0339477435,
0.0063798688,
-0.0028472536,
0.0590464547,
0.0051332158,
0.0683446303,
0.0388142243,
0.0274887234,
-0.0638678521,
-0.0087566059,
-0.0459708199,
-0.0138858063,
-0.0112811839,
0.0070690233,
-0.0138900131,
0.03998027,
-0.0539896414,
-0.0117417295,
-0.0368279181,
-0.0021645795,
0.0592355728,
0.0322598852,
-0.0003199866,
-0.0017858021,
-0.0838471949,
0.0524091907,
-0.0821067765,
0.018087633,
0.0199307036,
-0.0230991654,
0.0125753749,
0.0167018417,
0.0051190224,
0.0052512847,
0.0033334428,
0.033276055,
0.0275203083,
0.0062589375,
-0.0136404522,
-0.0371983796,
-0.0050928369,
-0.0477595478,
-0.0264330376,
-0.0436571576,
0.0325672552,
0.0186815895,
-0.0127069177,
-0.0131367808,
0.0197118819,
0.0395820849,
-0.025127532,
0.0912289917,
-0.0527045503,
0.0037252954,
-0.0053540687,
0.0054366374,
-0.0085497461,
0.0243873894,
0.0409299992,
-0.013191429,
0.0552914664,
-0.0334625915,
0.0476061068,
0.0106810741,
-0.0079332097,
-0.0464488007,
0.0090125408,
0.0229888558,
-0.0311335325,
0.06887687,
0.0335030109,
0.0662107244,
-0.0062234877,
-0.011074801,
0.0563545302,
0.092714861,
-0.0252415538,
0.0076630898,
0.0208806116,
-0.005240995,
0.0073988847,
0.0372923836,
-0.0576731712,
0.0483400226,
-0.033652205,
-0.0047287038,
0.02956127,
-0.0126086911,
-0.0220577773,
-0.1007332578,
-0.040028885,
0.006109918,
0.0110283159,
0.000929986,
0.0362766795,
0.0201783199,
0.0186769553,
0.0175821465,
0.0330745354,
-0.0789882913,
0.0615262948,
-0.0582557879,
0.0366378464,
0.0997074023,
0.0511213206,
-0.0282829981,
0.0060096877,
0.0081333211,
-0.0126498556,
0.0135461222,
0.0557084121,
-0.0481515937,
-0.0532723144,
-0.0222677346,
-0.0137395402,
-0.0115899025,
-0.0033668401,
-0.0126668699,
0.0144076636,
-0.0497763194,
0.0058271526,
-0.0922354236,
-0.0829018354,
0.0209070891,
0.0202522986,
-0.054843504,
0.0017812049,
-0.010202202,
0.0120077636,
0.0561933517,
0.008597685,
0.0417158268,
0.0169677176,
-0.0060827238,
-0.0304300692,
-0.0065629194,
-0.0123015391,
-0.0159992408,
0.0217505023,
-0.022299584,
-0.0183082391,
0.0301564969,
-0.0487747975,
-0.0346395597,
-0.0219323263,
-0.0385459363,
-0.0265754275,
-0.0201813579,
-0.0292799398,
0.0189402439,
-0.0302690528,
-0.0762487054,
0.048942361,
0.0050010928,
0.0314825401,
-0.0254642684,
-0.0405470431,
-0.0047096196,
0.0183527023,
-0.0315756649,
-0.0085067293,
0.0217322595,
0.0390881225,
0.0434860326,
-0.0103875343,
-0.0442141183,
-0.0112482468,
-0.0909272805,
-0.0141352797,
-0.0256750695,
0.0379127152,
0.0379220843,
-0.016749179,
0.0266497973,
-0.025388198,
-0.0750103742,
-0.0113594728,
0.0133084627,
0.0342675708,
0.0601210743,
0.0138323205,
0.011731307,
-0.0573492311,
-0.0327331498,
-0.0331216194,
0.023240054,
0.0599609911,
0.0365440473,
-0.1135946363,
0.001630416,
-0.0753230676,
-0.0005533069,
0.014099516,
-0.0275618471,
0.0376527011,
0.0076499446,
0.0096277418,
0.0661996305,
-0.0019950932,
0.0500732139,
0.0708617419,
0.0186518822,
-0.0397574306,
-0.0291771088,
-0.0264241509,
-0.0504878387,
-0.0064314315,
-0.0466200635,
0.0035212883,
0.0663654953,
0.0023450144,
-0.0061809062,
-0.0521896482,
0.0346386246,
-0.0475162268,
-0.0238513835,
-0.0448102094,
-0.0131495437,
-0.0044983672,
0.0573766306,
0.0013299074,
-0.0404549725,
0.0964104384,
-0.005737585,
0.0014259494,
-0.0505232289,
0.01404652,
-0.039180059,
0.0384228192,
0.0003604509,
-0.0150136854,
-0.0287268795,
0.0114500085,
-0.0103285471,
-0.0173769444,
0.0373156816,
-0.0412821583,
0.0085466402,
-0.0732703656,
-0.0090460489,
-0.007359385,
-0.0122219836,
-0.0122678699,
-0.0394963101,
-0.0558592118,
0.0357099213,
0.0175313782,
-0.0116573833,
0.0121198893,
-0.0028884369,
0.0278129727,
0.0044296607,
-0.0281214621,
-0.0099777849,
-0.0114101646,
0.0458668657,
0.0241788365,
0.0440700427,
0.0557475053,
-0.004430579,
-0.0038612946,
0.0544262752,
0.0291206595,
-0.0044413731,
-0.0257800277,
-0.015031361,
0.0258488357,
-0.0465925373,
-0.0012158925,
0.0114967516,
0.0576501191,
-0.0655128136,
-0.0087680696,
0.1274543703,
0.0346605964,
-0.0437862501,
-0.0005723848,
-0.0272379369,
0.0180043485,
0.0295945182,
0.0113370931,
-0.0503909998,
-0.0358042009,
-0.0124099087,
0.0601420328,
0.0195915308,
-0.017684428,
0.02621972,
-0.1113831624,
0.0297145061,
-0.0054848902,
-0.0443823561,
-0.0095658749,
-0.0828727335,
0.018604273,
-0.0178960487,
-0.0026723375,
0.034070719,
0.0237059575,
0.0315140337,
0.03131634,
-0.0059999973,
-0.0208301172,
0.0728835389,
-0.0788160563,
0.0752075538,
0.0434546694,
0.038160488,
-0.00156324,
-0.062017519,
0.0100359498,
0.0101111224,
0.0213761311,
0.0155225713,
0.0369352698,
-0.0004029717,
-0.0078102467,
-0.067587696,
0.0128559507,
-0.0310761537,
0.0058624246,
-0.012426476,
0.076525189,
0.0119445203,
-0.0072732768,
-0.0123723298,
0.0226802565,
-0.0276355557,
0.0766023919,
0.0327285081,
-0.059292417,
-0.0286434125,
-0.0335127302,
0.0084251016,
-0.0297222119,
-0.0892832279,
0.0305184629,
0.0142940572,
-0.0370701924,
-0.0590883903,
-0.0725372732,
0.0518084727,
0.0141230188,
-0.000396354,
-0.0443619229,
0.0252820272,
0.0245071072,
-0.000545333,
0.0434518866,
-0.0174251683,
0.0000244977,
-0.0132799642,
-0.0140702147,
0.0307956245,
0.0185824204,
-0.0125389528,
0.0119543318,
-0.0256160535,
-0.0127695519,
0.0005824392,
0.0634320676,
0.0166113377,
-0.0081819557,
0.0060936892,
-0.1009406745,
-0.0273035765,
0.030018881,
-0.0425699279,
0.0032393723,
0.0086042872,
0.0706529096,
0.0117738042,
0.0363936685,
-0.0433574393,
-0.0108452337,
-0.0120802065,
0.0319360681,
-0.0215131156,
-0.0685155541,
0.0433790609,
0.0074708732,
0.0209790431,
-0.0236583352,
0.0114636999,
0.0015406705,
-0.012931522,
-0.0367598459,
-0.060423173,
-0.0239954516,
0.008013498,
-0.0070845815,
-0.0309655257,
-0.0181992091,
0.0043691825,
-0.0232004952,
0.0390515998,
-0.0395931378,
-0.0118351495,
0.0420085751,
0.0098479772,
-0.0461016074,
-0.0007577362,
-0.0441826135,
-0.0189577136,
-0.0247138515,
0.0452478938,
0.0079326872,
0.0543402322,
0.0055292528,
0.0090944376,
-0.0066054855,
0.0336774439,
-0.049888324,
-0.0200473461,
-0.0198948532,
0.0086525884,
0.0026358829,
0.036909759,
0.0419444591,
0.0271148235,
-0.0263147615,
-0.0079925442,
0.0062624048,
0.0108222812,
-0.0108863013,
0.044323951,
0.0321196616,
-0.009360089,
-0.0072704265,
0.048492562,
-0.0127080362,
-0.0130986115,
-0.013746771,
-0.0500560552,
-0.017081501,
-0.0100500239,
-0.0275082104,
0.0098146349,
-0.0090394067,
-0.0097458251,
-0.0755728334,
-0.0609407052,
-0.0062987371,
0.0759798661,
-0.0123448018,
-0.0198246967,
0.045228783,
0.0366743989,
-0.0424149334,
-0.0348966531,
-0.0376209356,
0.0111312307,
-0.0328339711,
0.0085389679,
-0.0383868329,
-5.812937482e-33,
-0.0444563329,
-0.0592593886,
-0.0130477073,
0.012504017,
0.0210944805,
-0.0187004991,
-0.0055632833,
0.0428072326,
0.0095334398,
0.0546453632,
-0.0039304541,
-0.0000137999,
-0.0025030267,
-0.0083653172,
0.0310145803,
-0.0742629096,
0.0179559346,
-0.0303119142,
-0.0405849591,
0.0384736955,
0.0316763259,
-0.0422906168,
0.0750911459,
-0.0842200145,
0.1066044718,
0.0331307091,
-0.0238494482,
0.0408311598,
-0.0081259431,
0.0423734747,
-0.0098077049,
0.054315839,
0.0256238617,
-0.0242843404,
0.0003764999,
0.0371897444,
-0.0823860168,
-0.0074065397,
0.0371136442,
0.0385362804,
-0.0757666379,
-0.0098245442,
0.0553810224,
-0.0086494721,
-0.0448929742,
-0.0069457921,
0.0568643436,
-0.0253770873,
0.021890061,
-0.0190593805,
-0.0057130298,
0.0165140927,
-0.010073591,
-0.0333764851,
-0.0145867253,
0.0099186366,
-0.0342152975,
0.0356211849,
-0.0397633947,
-0.0056202416,
-0.0117976768,
0.0275495388,
0.0529587865,
-0.0072768135,
-0.0255787093,
0.0570944995,
0.0334358588,
0.0237698294,
-0.0542804264,
-0.0480094068,
-0.0058069858,
-0.0022718327,
0.1205402911,
0.0614526533,
0.0212273877,
0.0563867055,
-0.0341063775,
0.0404600054,
-0.0294634681,
0.0232634898,
0.0102929818,
0.0027353182,
-0.0599658452,
-0.0110635431,
-0.0631994158,
-0.0338878483,
-0.0632604659,
0.0078918189,
0.0153284324,
-0.0378379039,
-0.0397942699,
-0.0094210161,
0.0038554899,
-0.0348835737,
0.004767892,
0.0027921419,
0.0122504961,
0.0293715578,
-0.0065417532,
-0.0345602594,
-0.0152323935,
0.0478536747,
-0.003657785,
0.0196015593,
0.0260068681,
0.0149597488,
0.0066933278,
0.0071549886,
-0.026403524,
0.0001010909,
-0.0344382413,
-0.0190526843,
-0.0297660697,
-0.0242341161,
0.035828162,
0.0093756095,
-0.0264628548,
0.0449122451,
0.0107895825,
0.022106763,
-0.0088820634,
0.0086312182,
0.0089868689,
-0.034188021,
-0.0197212286,
0.0059543252,
-0.0030509476,
-0.0165443756,
-0.0343210921,
-0.014333698,
-0.0101519655,
0.0276847724,
2.281e-7,
0.0653871074,
0.0538191982,
0.0228265021,
-0.0162651017,
0.0062314174,
0.037844453,
0.0377976745,
0.0058556474,
0.0446385555,
-0.0684335232,
0.0125012863,
0.0172124002,
0.0400097892,
0.0449014865,
-0.0614730157,
-0.0188387688,
-0.0319537632,
-0.0186363254,
0.0183394589,
-0.014065708,
0.0966207385,
0.0382889844,
0.0283645261,
-0.0024788673,
-0.032353539,
-0.0439778827,
0.0340648592,
-0.0114964424,
-0.009337822,
0.0053343866,
0.0677116439,
0.0078892335,
0.0223891325,
0.0298678651,
0.0204259492,
-0.0213461258,
0.0471613146,
0.0446237996,
-0.0274478253,
-0.0464039296,
-0.0459613055,
-0.0452610999,
0.0252170432,
-0.0569919497,
0.0500605702,
-0.0293998271,
-0.0354889594,
-0.0156723447,
-0.01323626,
-0.0267787818,
0.0088908616,
-0.0185180698,
-0.03429766,
0.021394752,
0.011693486,
0.0173600987,
-0.0290087499,
-0.0450642444,
-0.038099844,
0.0150060728,
-0.0298332125,
-0.0514683463,
-0.0020549465,
0.0118753081,
0.0014589536,
-0.051234778,
-0.0031225588,
1.767402822e-34,
0.0517962016,
0.0069337264,
0.0325354785,
0.026752077,
0.0543657392,
0.035402216,
-0.0236660577,
-0.0194312222,
0.0715099648,
-0.0730623603,
-0.0163706467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14766v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14766v3 | Allies: Prompting Large Language Model with Beam Search | 2023-05-24T06:16:44 | 2023-10-19T05:02:39 | Hao Sun, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Yan Zhang, Daxin Jiang, Linjun Yang, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advance of large language models (LLMs), the research field of LLM
applications becomes more and more popular and the idea of constructing
pipelines to accomplish complex tasks by stacking LLM API calls come true.
However, this kind of methods face two limitations: narrow information coverage
and low fault tolerance. In this work, we propose a novel method called ALLIES.
Given an input query, ALLIES leverages LLMs to iteratively generate new queries
related to the original query, enabling an iterative reasoning process. By
iteratively refining and expanding the scope of the original query, ALLIES
captures and utilizes hidden knowledge that may not be directly obtainable
through retrieval. We take zero-shot open-domain question answering (ODQA) as
an application scene and evaluate ALLIES on the widely-used benchmarks, such as
NQ, WebQ and TriviaQA. The experimental results demonstrate that ALLIES
significantly outperforms other zero-shot baselines, indicating its
effectiveness in tackling those challenges. Our code is available in
https://github.com/microsoft/SimXNS/tree/main/ALLIES. | [
0.0137902135,
0.0576098859,
-0.0049041724,
0.0590446368,
-0.0375234224,
0.001217232,
0.0046292949,
-0.0018339849,
0.0232248046,
-0.0423008874,
-0.0331898257,
-0.0120249949,
-0.0559760928,
0.0131192217,
-0.0013633716,
0.0016854131,
0.031446863,
-0.0376754887,
-0.0109185399,
-0.0295410324,
-0.0290463697,
0.0298292898,
-0.0201362632,
0.0034905183,
0.0399703942,
-0.0332346335,
-0.011371824,
0.0284127686,
-0.0396832041,
-0.0231265686,
-0.0026741996,
0.0120552806,
0.0353526883,
0.0491480529,
0.0000020004,
-0.0599533841,
-0.0362002142,
0.0216714833,
-0.0586136319,
-0.0079489285,
-0.0185927581,
0.0344289169,
0.0338396691,
0.0282850247,
-0.0516721159,
-0.0175977089,
0.0315842293,
-0.0165464468,
0.0782091096,
0.0521113127,
0.0266800467,
-0.0184297003,
-0.0182919931,
0.0058502005,
0.0321887806,
-0.0806399286,
0.0185127612,
-0.0183349494,
0.0581495725,
0.0253024101,
-0.0063602244,
0.0453842022,
0.0360930189,
0.0030066401,
-0.0334395543,
0.0200018231,
-0.0502360947,
0.0039767334,
0.0015917225,
0.0797170028,
0.0141895628,
0.010957567,
-0.003983214,
0.0261494387,
-0.0328582637,
0.0167498402,
-0.0799322054,
0.018650189,
0.0018271528,
-0.0301604848,
-0.0193735715,
-0.0163476709,
0.0409372896,
0.0177912861,
-0.0461945124,
0.1174647212,
0.0195492059,
-0.0097823041,
-0.0153468112,
-0.0362994894,
-0.0177361872,
-0.0644946843,
-0.0241523497,
0.091364041,
-0.0751603395,
0.0416570492,
0.0082198763,
0.0042976923,
0.0434623659,
-0.0102177849,
0.0156501029,
0.046561569,
0.0008091521,
0.0977212638,
-0.0266637355,
0.0503202453,
-0.0233198311,
-0.012479092,
-0.0703679249,
-0.068126142,
-0.0553655475,
-0.045047123,
-0.0245827157,
0.0695026815,
-0.0525865965,
-0.0373902768,
0.0010622268,
0.0339426324,
0.020613851,
-0.0036123458,
-0.0166017134,
0.0160195474,
-0.0002335036,
-0.0041559925,
-0.0131844496,
0.0645435974,
-0.040022105,
-0.02870344,
-0.0009712793,
-0.0820461214,
-0.0375535265,
0.0031862713,
-0.0062966384,
-0.0164587479,
0.0149253784,
0.0836048424,
0.0173181351,
-0.0427592956,
-0.0116478531,
-0.0437775478,
0.0291096736,
-0.0602723472,
0.0226524901,
-0.0873767287,
0.0330009796,
0.0160827357,
-0.0259817373,
-0.0081648091,
0.026530182,
0.0445996709,
-0.0170304738,
0.0564477928,
-0.0172882248,
0.0233340599,
0.0295698736,
0.0259407759,
-0.0021994226,
0.1039623022,
-0.0152859809,
0.0001461871,
0.0628098249,
0.0245124102,
0.0100163901,
0.0157266017,
0.0236846544,
0.0172480252,
-0.0023771883,
0.0641786531,
0.0272522345,
0.0316409692,
-0.0244551115,
0.0076473164,
-0.0187119301,
-0.0138849914,
0.0048416737,
0.0503869429,
0.0246257186,
-0.0215299465,
0.038469445,
0.0243659895,
0.0049744458,
-0.0228023063,
-0.0364425965,
0.035552457,
-0.0601798557,
0.0102162994,
0.0189566929,
0.0301601999,
-0.0583921298,
-0.0149394767,
-0.0161572099,
0.0237134341,
-0.0543191023,
0.0543305762,
0.0688388646,
0.0307208952,
-0.0273860674,
0.0668904781,
0.0279656146,
-0.0335471742,
0.0040138951,
-0.0432491042,
0.0472037345,
0.0431583673,
0.0862312317,
-0.0524615385,
-0.043734096,
0.0263735093,
0.0143615035,
0.0163433906,
0.0030314641,
-0.0060440768,
0.0276552681,
-0.0294135157,
-0.0267082527,
-0.0179976746,
0.0134753771,
-0.0131157003,
0.0599371344,
-0.0106898574,
0.0010715744,
-0.0668327957,
0.0192080438,
0.010788912,
-0.0593444332,
-0.0293485653,
0.0359024219,
-0.0132481018,
-0.0033129011,
0.0223537143,
0.0033770066,
0.0264895502,
0.0473140553,
-0.0306532159,
-0.0610896684,
-0.0148419673,
-0.0349243842,
-0.0162927508,
0.0454132743,
-0.0168063827,
-0.005531664,
0.0070120939,
-0.0471397601,
-0.033787623,
0.0397418551,
-0.0216405988,
0.0243730042,
-0.0403569117,
-0.0114686387,
0.0060953675,
-0.0191643685,
-0.0510650426,
0.0496335812,
0.0102816625,
0.0354856625,
-0.0146193579,
-0.0025299489,
0.0054268274,
-0.024932215,
-0.0038050218,
0.0230386201,
-0.02090431,
0.0045053316,
-0.0218164753,
-0.0039476566,
-0.0426055938,
-0.0073960228,
-0.1096157283,
0.0540827811,
-0.0291790701,
0.0217853375,
0.0114822835,
0.0657937154,
0.0002446302,
-0.0183324702,
-0.0125683174,
0.0226155706,
0.0212445203,
0.0333490595,
0.0267429575,
0.0282144323,
-0.0270167552,
0.0037109249,
-0.028186515,
-0.0246240981,
0.0683681294,
-0.0137556633,
0.0194330178,
-0.0317854322,
0.0021864837,
-0.0506124347,
0.0233868603,
-0.000972195,
0.0149731506,
0.0116528086,
-0.0703901201,
-0.0007543468,
0.0409443527,
-0.0110531263,
-0.0249387268,
0.0232117809,
-0.0185508374,
-0.0613759123,
0.0127834175,
-0.025509404,
-0.0522425734,
-0.0146166431,
0.0102995047,
0.0283841696,
0.0137214893,
-0.0362192951,
-0.0169772096,
-0.0262965634,
0.0157333687,
0.0027055545,
0.0101140356,
-0.0595375746,
0.012875583,
0.0246285573,
0.0182447322,
0.0048450897,
-0.026908135,
0.0553160571,
-0.0195936803,
-0.0025504862,
-0.0448834412,
-0.0032282297,
-0.0833730921,
0.0898169801,
-0.0245007575,
0.0368318148,
-0.0139288632,
-0.0383381955,
-0.0178414974,
-0.0214633383,
-0.006562632,
-0.0321667343,
0.0515424572,
-0.052139122,
0.0222605113,
-0.0125783989,
-0.0152864484,
-0.0385495611,
-0.0356666818,
-0.0569801293,
0.0552248508,
-0.0624909066,
-0.0242726933,
-0.0148703307,
-0.0322767496,
0.0176960696,
0.0149977542,
-0.0308378711,
-0.0058834744,
-0.0255149174,
0.0318078287,
0.0366039164,
0.0193337388,
0.0259007849,
-0.0031317875,
0.0187531207,
0.0621337518,
0.0691767037,
-0.0022098676,
-0.0043914681,
-0.0070414385,
0.0421684049,
-0.0506484024,
-0.0062563666,
0.00441453,
0.0342376269,
-0.0519336984,
-0.0155890314,
0.0930102766,
0.0514322072,
-0.0185917523,
-0.0139681343,
-0.0404705144,
0.0150115741,
0.051198937,
0.0513397828,
-0.119360432,
-0.0540329888,
0.0160065833,
0.0348033123,
0.0143670058,
-0.0380889624,
-0.025484575,
-0.1561834663,
0.0172369257,
-0.0212917086,
-0.0241872445,
-0.010242098,
-0.0465951636,
0.0096203638,
0.0235991739,
-0.0203731395,
0.0457370095,
-0.0156963021,
0.001419773,
-0.0245337281,
0.0425660871,
-0.0223269109,
0.04678813,
-0.0383493118,
0.0307062156,
0.0566567928,
0.0212238021,
0.0219346602,
-0.0243444238,
0.0077975816,
-0.041283872,
0.0155102834,
-0.0493472256,
0.0141649395,
0.0049184561,
-0.0102180112,
-0.0078956392,
0.035414461,
-0.0527354777,
0.0068265824,
0.0141335698,
0.0846810415,
-0.0276861005,
0.0122580715,
-0.0113598648,
-0.0115229851,
0.0039197174,
0.0939384699,
0.0044751512,
-0.0008209781,
-0.0322370715,
-0.0252008103,
-0.0442770459,
-0.0156711172,
-0.0357027464,
0.0164162256,
0.0115579003,
0.0300848205,
-0.031624727,
0.0181410573,
0.0431884155,
0.0548437238,
-0.0154602258,
0.0008479055,
-0.0230981987,
0.0187502578,
-0.0410399623,
0.0147845084,
-0.0619480051,
0.024943538,
-0.0217604078,
0.0334368832,
0.0347326137,
-0.032546021,
-0.0265579429,
0.0185505748,
-0.053976953,
-0.044219058,
0.0029576074,
0.0371254757,
0.0244857743,
0.0113324048,
-0.0450997837,
-0.0381416082,
0.0422293097,
0.06027041,
-0.0558617935,
0.0130021563,
0.0122359786,
-0.0108995577,
0.008271724,
0.0582148954,
-0.06974601,
-0.0191008355,
0.0031079315,
0.0689012334,
-0.0128594404,
-0.0181048475,
0.0275465008,
0.0360183194,
-0.0076982472,
0.0231319927,
-0.0133894449,
-0.0027994425,
0.0558855608,
-0.0138329137,
-0.0280520283,
-0.0356427692,
0.0195374526,
-0.0090921707,
-0.0578852929,
0.0261752196,
0.003931961,
-0.0180752948,
0.0620795302,
-0.0343497954,
-0.0038641165,
0.0291448757,
-0.0057819956,
0.0420023687,
-0.0189437177,
0.0045226803,
0.0328533165,
-0.0139483865,
0.0540322326,
-0.0274236016,
0.0346841328,
0.0324626118,
-0.0231382176,
-0.042209357,
0.0192887262,
-0.0918805897,
-0.1241053194,
0.0339705832,
0.0484434068,
0.0550102293,
0.0206489377,
-0.0015349507,
0.0001532055,
-0.0118620489,
0.0017063051,
-0.0385825709,
0.0091011329,
-0.0289636534,
0.0487774611,
0.0558580682,
0.0021354277,
0.005561342,
0.0758318454,
-0.0230280794,
0.0459493101,
0.0126550505,
0.0107418625,
-0.0253271833,
-0.0416541398,
0.0208130591,
0.0333240554,
-0.0257242471,
0.003490983,
-0.0516539551,
-0.0336218327,
-0.0031821241,
-0.0112259295,
-0.0402368419,
-0.0136130964,
0.0470023602,
0.0893150643,
0.0388404392,
-0.0332163945,
-0.0478346609,
0.0395926088,
-0.0531059243,
-0.0286233164,
0.0187487621,
-6.636742657e-33,
-0.0299459286,
-0.0378812551,
0.0434461609,
-0.0031870115,
-0.0076811481,
0.0065786741,
-0.0339899287,
-0.0213226248,
-0.0368148014,
-0.0233953912,
-0.0244319625,
0.0369810387,
0.0095484657,
0.0232928656,
-0.0121658659,
-0.0417485721,
0.0067930236,
0.0004416197,
-0.0147336638,
0.0037257827,
0.0527810678,
0.0273773558,
0.0133830048,
-0.0366666876,
-0.0013827564,
-0.0256072897,
0.0192519426,
0.0909208208,
-0.0208236612,
0.0513500422,
0.0138340071,
0.044657819,
0.0120320814,
-0.0570299178,
0.0034492912,
0.0053284457,
-0.0817109123,
-0.0213423651,
0.0280034896,
-0.0201282036,
-0.0428145975,
-0.0170596242,
0.0151453484,
-0.0039969999,
0.038670633,
-0.0257124081,
-0.0044786879,
-0.0079702754,
-0.0080287335,
-0.0239365827,
-0.0100577082,
0.015858883,
0.0016234193,
-0.0280972198,
-0.0085534444,
0.0501247421,
0.0076062568,
0.0355243981,
-0.0295665283,
0.0148776546,
-0.0122487331,
0.0473216511,
0.0504019633,
0.0243931841,
0.023362834,
0.0267046224,
0.0070461282,
-0.0285168793,
-0.0195969902,
-0.0197770149,
-0.0072309845,
0.0234240871,
0.0313571095,
0.0047978773,
0.0049484484,
0.0449942686,
-0.0738565251,
-0.002186154,
0.0023407543,
0.0546058826,
0.0218824036,
0.0009949112,
-0.0091758175,
-0.0029740895,
-0.0468207076,
0.0100102676,
-0.0574035682,
-0.0118042966,
0.0164481904,
0.0160959959,
-0.0097551309,
-0.0051736073,
0.0374997333,
-0.0481950231,
0.0207494926,
0.0694767311,
0.0129270116,
0.000745383,
-0.0016602071,
0.0582416132,
-0.0216512382,
0.0133692194,
0.0085093472,
-0.0069700074,
-0.025320746,
0.0286803059,
-0.0143112727,
0.0206710566,
-0.0389443263,
-0.0232951511,
-0.053381864,
0.0039185933,
-0.0445872694,
0.0095953811,
0.0287776832,
0.0333428234,
0.0000248739,
0.0616576709,
0.0163280554,
0.009785655,
-0.0271894131,
0.000392408,
-0.0030337002,
0.0101693282,
-0.0282761827,
0.009598976,
-0.0274816174,
-0.0039438242,
-0.0340830646,
-0.059367571,
-0.0115338489,
0.0534381196,
2.8e-7,
0.0262874439,
0.0195671879,
-0.0145310387,
0.0972685292,
0.0006169872,
0.0265390836,
-0.004861977,
-0.0019147709,
0.0228949413,
-0.0170422141,
-0.0265441779,
0.0580236912,
0.0213030893,
0.0365059786,
-0.1157626733,
0.0049664765,
-0.0206602868,
-0.0392704345,
-0.0539026037,
-0.0443385243,
0.031292215,
0.0754104853,
0.0048834723,
-0.0262253694,
0.0047198422,
-0.0550609864,
0.0357450247,
0.0360512882,
-0.0421937257,
0.0204318203,
-0.0037003558,
0.0226714145,
0.0187812299,
0.0014943391,
-0.0000171036,
0.023715511,
-0.0066997376,
0.0533368625,
0.0044967649,
-0.0502457395,
-0.0210447311,
-0.060876485,
0.0190970078,
-0.0316822231,
0.1086750105,
-0.0056400867,
-0.0108144684,
0.0047454629,
-0.0115407426,
-0.0241036452,
-0.0134873185,
-0.0096472306,
-0.0100962343,
0.0180782694,
0.0082658082,
-0.0217800699,
0.0339452289,
-0.0612960756,
-0.0203515571,
-0.0287913885,
-0.0417994447,
-0.0179976709,
-0.0163560901,
-0.0213968474,
-0.0225919373,
-0.0548526868,
-0.0057033249,
2.845405299e-34,
0.0194499213,
0.0150177302,
0.0051695509,
0.0575949065,
0.0252877828,
-0.008428487,
-0.039592009,
0.0016750457,
0.0482458137,
-0.098990187,
0.0042456142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14763v1 | Clever Hans or Neural Theory of Mind? Stress Testing Social Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T06:14:31 | 2023-05-24T06:14:31 | Natalie Shapira, Mosh Levy, Seyed Hossein Alavi, Xuhui Zhou, Yejin Choi, Yoav Goldberg, Maarten Sap, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The escalating debate on AI's capabilities warrants developing reliable
metrics to assess machine "intelligence". Recently, many anecdotal examples
were used to suggest that newer large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and
GPT-4 exhibit Neural Theory-of-Mind (N-ToM); however, prior work reached
conflicting conclusions regarding those abilities. We investigate the extent of
LLMs' N-ToM through an extensive evaluation on 6 tasks and find that while LLMs
exhibit certain N-ToM abilities, this behavior is far from being robust. We
further examine the factors impacting performance on N-ToM tasks and discover
that LLMs struggle with adversarial examples, indicating reliance on shallow
heuristics rather than robust ToM abilities. We caution against drawing
conclusions from anecdotal examples, limited benchmark testing, and using
human-designed psychological tests to evaluate models. | [
0.049526982,
0.0306299329,
-0.0415917374,
0.0416862406,
-0.0520155393,
0.0275193285,
0.0173328407,
0.0093727773,
0.0494020544,
-0.0342069566,
-0.0633395985,
-0.0545091406,
0.019159941,
0.0032534925,
0.0808983669,
-0.0169330649,
0.0229759235,
-0.0183278453,
0.0375699289,
-0.0190562811,
-0.0300792344,
0.0045343996,
0.0036510157,
0.0336684771,
-0.00458002,
-0.0110737514,
-0.0028920912,
-0.0299327392,
0.0142170833,
-0.0310710426,
0.0047317902,
0.047118552,
-0.0136536723,
0.0750070065,
0.0000020676,
-0.0419348329,
0.0252870582,
-0.0019188231,
-0.0097393151,
0.0155943902,
0.0475502163,
-0.0026909565,
0.0122238873,
0.031571649,
-0.0653738081,
-0.0028992731,
-0.0052341199,
0.081011869,
0.0320934877,
0.0863543525,
-0.0126777897,
-0.0150820846,
0.0443217047,
-0.0415063351,
0.0240460355,
-0.067928955,
0.0241598915,
-0.0411746725,
0.0258751865,
-0.0041319286,
0.0199113563,
0.0070337551,
0.011279691,
0.0033790546,
-0.0400600284,
0.039903529,
-0.0133679099,
-0.0030208291,
0.004215369,
0.0663533807,
0.031277705,
0.0219328143,
0.0056743403,
0.0279269647,
0.024174083,
0.0211006757,
-0.0373381823,
0.0103545636,
-0.0018761397,
-0.0227092728,
0.029908685,
0.0100821154,
0.0239304546,
0.0133968377,
-0.0024338844,
0.0563216694,
-0.021566201,
-0.0243504718,
0.0408862755,
-0.0046179765,
-0.0572772734,
-0.0606311783,
-0.0234086309,
0.0347220823,
-0.0012128918,
0.0059435773,
-0.0434638672,
0.0224614944,
0.0154760387,
-0.0579757802,
0.0383806266,
0.0394761562,
-0.0071981493,
0.0253126007,
-0.0097430572,
0.0618539006,
-0.0105172405,
0.0499109589,
-0.0066827163,
-0.0047136093,
-0.0406740196,
-0.0158792604,
-0.0094505334,
0.039752543,
0.0052618072,
-0.0111724753,
-0.0262218472,
0.0040390971,
-0.0108642066,
-0.0244516134,
-0.0136704603,
0.0028502473,
0.0235397834,
-0.0042464077,
-0.0501098447,
0.0189648513,
-0.0310378298,
-0.0087646805,
-0.0058589485,
-0.0745428726,
-0.0232718512,
-0.014308434,
-0.0053786221,
-0.0372201875,
0.0150145218,
0.0709304139,
0.0069984142,
-0.0530883707,
-0.0337099396,
0.0049619814,
-0.0117147285,
-0.1026774645,
0.0468498953,
-0.0172610451,
0.0199227612,
0.0119297793,
-0.0328690484,
-0.0390770286,
0.0114306584,
0.0099974377,
-0.0931537002,
0.0553419814,
0.0414922647,
0.0108130733,
0.0025626388,
0.0262704752,
0.0096354662,
0.0145751471,
-0.0038520973,
0.0003605561,
0.0133646075,
0.026125446,
0.0266241655,
0.0301250964,
-0.0123004029,
-0.0215533581,
0.000001572,
-0.022223331,
-0.0067829629,
0.0216899421,
0.0047783242,
0.0869642645,
-0.0296645258,
-0.0586661622,
0.0773508623,
0.0771447271,
-0.0376530401,
0.0506772771,
0.0206555538,
0.0204621274,
0.035803847,
0.027284272,
-0.1125508547,
0.0549113005,
-0.0865470618,
-0.0500318259,
0.0153557714,
0.0207500961,
-0.047065109,
-0.0249748603,
-0.0231068507,
0.0209767111,
0.0394872651,
-0.0052466635,
-0.0016593973,
-0.0379156508,
-0.0270415973,
-0.0101356898,
0.0087347813,
-0.0086120674,
-0.0346832462,
-0.0774665102,
-0.0056914478,
-0.0056838416,
0.0344000719,
-0.0136427656,
-0.0385333896,
-0.0041577532,
-0.0110544981,
0.0629806072,
0.1053640768,
0.0087374756,
-0.0176882371,
-0.0319072902,
0.0200543106,
-0.0418400504,
0.0157658253,
0.0392663181,
-0.0272009671,
0.0062361346,
-0.0002250375,
-0.0244270414,
-0.0155366054,
0.0140321618,
-0.0247603208,
-0.0235473234,
-0.0442125648,
0.0232463609,
0.0372763164,
0.0127514191,
-0.0103729619,
0.0065851491,
0.0006305073,
-0.00753788,
-0.0106626274,
0.0428555943,
-0.0350634493,
0.0021685215,
0.0295998007,
-0.0116938036,
-0.047253795,
0.0832660422,
-0.0129124084,
-0.0184182357,
0.0386203863,
-0.0475185402,
0.0008902751,
-0.0285412967,
0.0126345949,
-0.0348532535,
0.0310781635,
0.0018398605,
0.0870305225,
-0.0161438901,
-0.0077006361,
-0.0165777113,
-0.027636826,
0.0209011994,
-0.0119025409,
-0.0456219502,
0.015652502,
0.0100488486,
-0.0234312657,
-0.0010231404,
0.0011009171,
-0.0135715315,
-0.0375169255,
-0.1084520593,
-0.0148669379,
0.001879436,
0.0044398983,
0.0099148089,
-0.0350250565,
-0.0039881272,
0.0338546149,
-0.0510844216,
0.048117239,
0.0278540123,
0.0244303718,
0.0286217146,
-0.0173384398,
-0.011892423,
-0.0139465071,
0.0144202542,
-0.066806525,
0.0037211904,
0.0329078957,
-0.0270697959,
-0.0289637595,
0.0401770696,
-0.0779615492,
0.0539714061,
-0.0455715656,
-0.0806726292,
0.0219693109,
-0.0032984442,
0.0031673033,
0.1159930825,
-0.0110897962,
0.0158773176,
0.0319523551,
0.0118843736,
-0.0229704641,
0.0394089706,
0.0039666137,
-0.0066007944,
-0.0449379124,
-0.0427319109,
-0.026952168,
0.0710502416,
0.0125423213,
-0.0022296943,
-0.0654406026,
0.045680441,
-0.0084800879,
-0.0189161804,
-0.0164762028,
0.0012918686,
-0.0032098959,
0.0207820907,
-0.0236475971,
-0.0158033408,
0.0873461664,
-0.021669887,
-0.0053017857,
-0.0349708349,
-0.0187268071,
-0.0288928244,
0.0890864208,
0.0258711912,
0.0174528658,
0.0581562184,
-0.0057732668,
-0.0738254637,
-0.02154251,
-0.0515002236,
-0.0043537579,
0.0077946833,
-0.0268879328,
-0.0265155919,
0.0085988669,
-0.031878408,
-0.0279983245,
-0.0210797377,
-0.051319994,
0.0160192512,
0.0101916557,
-0.0413293317,
-0.0321114287,
-0.0187017359,
0.0441863798,
0.0297660679,
-0.0344422534,
-0.0092996564,
-0.0227973871,
-0.0022624987,
0.0323915407,
0.0169271622,
0.0697263479,
-0.0186684541,
0.0304687209,
0.0451039039,
0.0104647838,
0.0365218148,
-0.0094411634,
-0.0026483578,
0.0074545895,
0.0411507972,
-0.0435914323,
0.0176991355,
0.0518792272,
-0.0330722705,
-0.0023004187,
0.1167586893,
0.0176300183,
-0.0076378924,
-0.0030165559,
-0.0057934592,
0.0158297326,
0.0341697037,
0.0223318301,
-0.0227640793,
-0.0154234935,
0.0076127928,
0.0000765508,
-0.0295128636,
-0.0755197331,
-0.0046131648,
-0.1157270893,
0.0408873707,
-0.0255877413,
-0.0483698547,
-0.011916887,
-0.0118384697,
0.02902833,
-0.0019006826,
0.0213545356,
-0.0038497483,
0.0394295566,
-0.0116524836,
-0.0178013407,
-0.0155154634,
-0.0380971506,
0.0868365318,
-0.0329099223,
0.094864212,
0.0222458746,
0.1031384021,
-0.0193770397,
-0.062718302,
0.0820104778,
0.0453990474,
0.0250660069,
-0.009743643,
0.0718678385,
-0.0109495763,
0.0079375375,
0.0010505628,
0.0330070257,
-0.0250475947,
0.0424850136,
-0.0369021855,
0.0551235378,
-0.0211435538,
-0.0322775804,
0.0338416398,
0.0432402194,
-0.0224032216,
0.0944568589,
0.0333463401,
-0.0241760518,
-0.0411315672,
-0.0041778553,
-0.0078256046,
-0.0132379727,
-0.0591911562,
0.0483301654,
0.0379563943,
-0.0205185898,
-0.0513118953,
-0.0807940513,
0.0102664847,
0.0117178066,
0.0220113993,
-0.0354257002,
0.0212105419,
0.0121351024,
0.007728341,
0.0286987647,
-0.0233622491,
0.0031766766,
-0.0087697059,
0.0115831178,
0.0240135025,
-0.0392392129,
-0.0061511192,
-0.0033100261,
-0.0103407539,
-0.0676467717,
0.0154797575,
0.0340384096,
0.0279376023,
0.0110168308,
-0.0333047286,
-0.0465539396,
0.0039861896,
-0.0105728861,
-0.0222590119,
0.052678939,
0.0317696035,
0.0398540199,
0.0062494148,
0.067858696,
-0.0071897358,
0.029558925,
0.0324329175,
-0.0010174183,
0.0211079326,
0.006543126,
0.0148157952,
0.0298078004,
0.0397094265,
0.0349801332,
0.0094194757,
-0.0069837435,
-0.0415981188,
-0.027588591,
-0.0039963578,
-0.0403426476,
-0.0396976471,
0.0398252942,
0.0546979271,
-0.0203323346,
-0.0801691711,
-0.0064619123,
0.0460020788,
-0.0221075341,
-0.0063950787,
-0.0439908244,
0.0232092217,
0.0030485096,
0.0216317326,
0.0019532412,
0.0231761653,
-0.0153401615,
0.0244801678,
-0.0008921968,
0.095151253,
0.0278978739,
-0.0340106413,
-0.0164103676,
0.0211176928,
-0.0964901373,
-0.0954301879,
0.025198672,
0.0164957177,
0.0198151451,
-0.012984396,
-0.0056221811,
-0.0656009093,
0.0138836792,
0.0080145858,
-0.0197056364,
-0.0094152801,
-0.0182345472,
0.0107458616,
0.0071349405,
-0.0115936706,
0.0161068588,
0.0437771492,
-0.0273673981,
0.0302414596,
0.0285047051,
-0.021052219,
-0.0284512676,
-0.0142365983,
0.0229401216,
0.0327912085,
-0.0044820076,
0.0318744555,
-0.0655623898,
-0.0527159683,
0.0144838644,
0.0047327415,
-0.0094716074,
-0.0283502955,
0.0123886364,
0.0733398572,
-0.0186534375,
-0.0058846991,
0.0047903033,
-0.0152529655,
-0.0364644937,
-0.0224314202,
0.0011837872,
-6.840848149e-33,
-0.0083952881,
-0.0102916257,
-0.0015810532,
0.0122887809,
-0.0250580143,
-0.0198960342,
-0.0552990809,
0.0143141337,
-0.0391650535,
0.0202238578,
-0.0385629572,
0.0405918323,
-0.0123421466,
-0.0104337325,
-0.0211832188,
-0.0179939438,
0.0001756114,
-0.0531814173,
-0.0243538637,
-0.0039899386,
0.0119420551,
-0.0022779959,
0.0369480699,
-0.0848241374,
0.0376620777,
0.016640801,
0.0218312126,
0.0260117818,
-0.0232407097,
-0.0124429865,
-0.0192841627,
0.0094669517,
0.036664471,
-0.0371515267,
0.0201261267,
0.03419476,
-0.0354332216,
-0.0471590348,
0.0202035271,
-0.0370602906,
-0.0125123672,
-0.0340712108,
0.0185112711,
-0.0376566127,
-0.0429414622,
0.0127651356,
0.0107292021,
0.0141159054,
0.049797032,
0.0363196172,
-0.0405674204,
-0.013843541,
-0.0144833215,
-0.0095313061,
-0.0127742654,
0.0208602585,
-0.0051854555,
-0.0158748291,
-0.0704513863,
-0.0003939062,
-0.0172126722,
-0.0064196456,
0.0273919366,
-0.0532227494,
0.0112303188,
0.0777784213,
0.0653648525,
0.0448279977,
-0.0311125107,
-0.0226595122,
0.0433063023,
0.0467541963,
0.0779891983,
0.0190706849,
-0.0098338295,
-0.0321811996,
-0.0417318344,
-0.0014208535,
0.0487736575,
0.0199056976,
0.0534284338,
-0.0178006925,
-0.040321745,
-0.0054154163,
-0.0151260141,
-0.0670933202,
-0.0546186902,
-0.0070194728,
0.0110044768,
-0.0116982879,
0.0122195315,
-0.0386310145,
0.035181649,
-0.0377729423,
0.0382652469,
0.0091083264,
-0.0110087795,
0.0225921217,
0.0132563561,
0.0210848339,
-0.05252821,
-0.0127421096,
-0.040815644,
0.0364983566,
0.0403032117,
-0.0041161436,
0.031667456,
0.0174389444,
-0.0183781143,
-0.0127761504,
-0.0440517515,
0.0347548015,
0.0146313598,
-0.0206578542,
0.0254817978,
0.0184530783,
0.001834009,
-0.055788938,
0.0107198479,
-0.0108635528,
-0.0637229234,
0.0444493666,
-0.0104058739,
-0.0266838055,
-0.0240481142,
-0.0305963308,
-0.0084236581,
0.0057355086,
0.0267434325,
-0.0448997691,
-0.0041561546,
-0.0086713405,
2.931e-7,
-0.0239700023,
0.0967447236,
-0.0286289491,
-0.031807784,
0.035783235,
0.0622782409,
-0.0127134351,
0.0239760634,
-0.0009902634,
-0.0266264789,
-0.0145640615,
0.0561041571,
0.0652542859,
0.0455317385,
-0.06207975,
-0.0075737871,
-0.0133290831,
-0.0376667865,
-0.0275740419,
0.0177674703,
0.0135537647,
0.0713892505,
0.0340756103,
-0.0103099691,
-0.0080049084,
-0.0680480599,
0.0242103022,
-0.0243040621,
-0.0105788857,
0.0096603818,
0.0454953909,
0.0142129948,
0.00099998,
0.0565152951,
0.0382367298,
0.023705475,
0.0035820859,
0.0444931313,
-0.0040205796,
-0.0493046865,
-0.0073657697,
0.0046797176,
-0.0111726495,
-0.0801801831,
0.0659154058,
-0.0887792259,
-0.0953590125,
0.0329832211,
0.0448915549,
-0.0215528421,
0.0205345098,
0.0379789881,
-0.0121015897,
0.0166780651,
0.0101456176,
-0.041901052,
0.0116685182,
-0.0877551809,
0.0280015096,
0.0004538144,
-0.0164030418,
-0.0573238097,
-0.0199663956,
-0.0152810821,
0.0402185954,
-0.0369690061,
-0.0040627997,
2.554994139e-34,
0.0268539712,
-0.0250338297,
0.035437353,
-0.0303908177,
0.0669067726,
0.0160713531,
-0.003110691,
0.0211177282,
0.0324637704,
-0.0941879749,
-0.0191970896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14761v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14761v3 | UniChart: A Universal Vision-language Pretrained Model for Chart Comprehension and Reasoning | 2023-05-24T06:11:17 | 2023-10-10T23:39:25 | Ahmed Masry, Parsa Kavehzadeh, Xuan Long Do, Enamul Hoque, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Charts are very popular for analyzing data, visualizing key insights and
answering complex reasoning questions about data. To facilitate chart-based
data analysis using natural language, several downstream tasks have been
introduced recently such as chart question answering and chart summarization.
However, most of the methods that solve these tasks use pretraining on language
or vision-language tasks that do not attempt to explicitly model the structure
of the charts (e.g., how data is visually encoded and how chart elements are
related to each other). To address this, we first build a large corpus of
charts covering a wide variety of topics and visual styles. We then present
UniChart, a pretrained model for chart comprehension and reasoning. UniChart
encodes the relevant text, data, and visual elements of charts and then uses a
chart-grounded text decoder to generate the expected output in natural
language. We propose several chart-specific pretraining tasks that include: (i)
low-level tasks to extract the visual elements (e.g., bars, lines) and data
from charts, and (ii) high-level tasks to acquire chart understanding and
reasoning skills. We find that pretraining the model on a large corpus with
chart-specific low- and high-level tasks followed by finetuning on three
down-streaming tasks results in state-of-the-art performance on three
downstream tasks. | [
-0.0185564104,
0.048897706,
-0.0067292806,
0.0293860342,
-0.0039169877,
0.0442833528,
-0.0267714206,
-0.0396409482,
0.029031679,
0.0365731977,
-0.0188171398,
0.0210061967,
0.0162468776,
0.0584367961,
0.0079665761,
-0.1040534228,
0.0120079778,
-0.0101848124,
0.0509517454,
0.0140014105,
-0.0071545434,
-0.0031890245,
-0.0150622027,
0.0241472162,
-0.0150066782,
-0.0519219041,
0.0027704772,
0.0186059531,
-0.0025585378,
-0.0653609782,
-0.0291623343,
0.0038848487,
0.0609336421,
-0.0266131759,
0.0000019763,
-0.0142701361,
-0.0082185566,
-0.0084148562,
-0.0174725428,
-0.0616356507,
0.0182810817,
-0.0893045068,
0.0357304029,
-0.0027464393,
-0.0657504499,
-0.0102750855,
0.0480672307,
0.0051077078,
0.1040684506,
0.0215288643,
-0.0215572137,
-0.0175828151,
-0.0359332673,
-0.0371207781,
0.0146379862,
-0.0623175092,
-0.0225091055,
0.0631270409,
0.0376980603,
0.0345685482,
-0.0695536435,
0.0474394411,
0.0297839139,
0.0405707769,
0.0073031303,
0.0273483787,
-0.009493554,
-0.0387763977,
-0.0136882924,
0.1051414236,
0.003109894,
-0.0094535891,
0.0045981002,
0.0025403725,
0.012662488,
0.0261240639,
-0.0831800252,
0.0072121723,
-0.0235461872,
-0.0143546471,
-0.0129095232,
0.0052536684,
-0.0043185661,
-0.0175173357,
-0.0345956199,
-0.0089419605,
-0.0482572503,
-0.0178534836,
0.0237886906,
0.0260577872,
-0.0301202703,
-0.0513165817,
0.0026385759,
0.051802218,
0.0076931394,
0.0036423304,
-0.0195157919,
-0.0375241414,
-0.0249920785,
0.0094472533,
0.0367580168,
0.0172394831,
-0.0251115318,
0.0699716806,
0.0052022422,
0.0187665541,
0.0014598349,
-0.0043059778,
-0.0345238186,
-0.0163337328,
-0.0274595767,
-0.0175246745,
-0.0605634674,
-0.0299680196,
-0.0485651605,
-0.035618294,
0.0048619234,
0.0107108764,
-0.0094569111,
0.0212225728,
0.0155407656,
0.0134036187,
-0.0341310799,
-0.0063904529,
-0.0382406302,
0.0600351021,
-0.0762249827,
0.011705122,
-0.0269844811,
-0.0216050129,
-0.0240677428,
0.0393483974,
0.0428155549,
-0.0108692246,
0.0085653383,
0.0676498935,
0.0075126784,
-0.0057761217,
-0.0246256664,
-0.053704448,
0.0006736646,
-0.0179223213,
0.0297314115,
-0.0529787727,
0.0294457003,
-0.0138268145,
-0.0057611694,
-0.0152837345,
-0.0008315507,
0.0237726979,
-0.0368362479,
0.0773585439,
-0.030560283,
-0.0046013012,
-0.0216110703,
-0.028066501,
-0.0259077344,
0.0635299087,
0.0482812002,
0.0201631635,
0.0317983069,
-0.0336592272,
0.0022376855,
0.0374652967,
0.019092083,
-0.053680446,
-0.0218533743,
0.033006873,
-0.0710948259,
0.0053293705,
0.0412477031,
0.0169138722,
-0.0384432338,
-0.026470406,
0.0345796458,
0.0613520667,
0.0542909428,
-0.0138338767,
0.0202335157,
0.0001208016,
0.0255337898,
0.0013984003,
-0.0329930298,
0.0601534918,
0.0713589117,
0.0602313876,
-0.0554964766,
-0.0320827588,
-0.0035544639,
-0.0606015772,
0.0044526444,
0.0101404693,
0.0211243592,
0.0175072066,
0.032605648,
0.0613663159,
-0.0272590481,
0.0089676799,
-0.0124531332,
-0.0171510726,
-0.0066966135,
0.0387736559,
0.0242709275,
0.0458317958,
0.0329491533,
-0.0153480424,
0.000876751,
-0.0130493222,
0.0240599047,
0.0165944844,
0.0262449943,
-0.0240326449,
-0.0290972777,
-0.0379693061,
-0.0385794491,
-0.0187377445,
0.0066998703,
0.0269511845,
-0.0193881933,
-0.0015832954,
-0.0434618294,
-0.0981353447,
-0.0002275544,
-0.0045454749,
0.0211476721,
-0.0425399877,
-0.0047344626,
0.0054593203,
-0.0116952937,
0.0216606576,
-0.0188286547,
0.0510668345,
-0.0022859734,
-0.0277581811,
0.0128698675,
0.0543393046,
-0.045587752,
-0.0718725473,
0.0159189757,
-0.0820187852,
-0.0570494533,
0.0075135925,
-0.0433381274,
-0.0366186164,
0.0324441604,
-0.0660241395,
-0.0177486353,
0.0024058414,
-0.0614081249,
0.0256486759,
-0.0017577374,
-0.018979786,
0.0499329232,
0.0112868166,
-0.0013201225,
-0.0188130885,
0.0434128493,
0.0323644541,
-0.0167747028,
0.0394339077,
0.0489085838,
-0.001095943,
0.0068972167,
-0.0007688057,
0.0056164246,
-0.0301206186,
0.0294791479,
-0.0697850809,
0.0037188914,
-0.000651049,
0.0275844336,
0.0208228044,
-0.0099993786,
-0.0360360481,
-0.0750245452,
-0.0311991461,
0.0357654914,
-0.0078355754,
-0.0125349769,
0.0564911254,
-0.0259791445,
0.0180933941,
-0.0140674394,
-0.0048096371,
-0.0180405863,
0.0348076038,
0.0723135769,
0.0090068458,
0.0201457646,
0.0062680277,
-0.0509497225,
0.0057870033,
0.0176801868,
0.0191495847,
0.0423169248,
-0.0047981129,
0.0663191378,
0.0622959957,
-0.0248697158,
0.0507709421,
-0.0134326909,
-0.035763938,
-0.0196945071,
0.0204714164,
-0.0275567826,
0.0008649697,
-0.0001220982,
-0.0055374606,
-0.0010582807,
0.090120405,
0.018593207,
0.0047466708,
-0.0320748203,
0.0276044458,
-0.0051279725,
0.0296965372,
-0.0907707587,
0.0165080875,
0.0126998369,
0.0549521707,
-0.025851503,
-0.0401824415,
0.0578548312,
-0.0121833272,
-0.024559604,
-0.0252441596,
-0.0103031313,
-0.0518521629,
0.0644664168,
0.0044534411,
-0.0097451136,
-0.0153706996,
-0.0515000522,
-0.0527378954,
0.0112008909,
0.0471705124,
-0.0287623685,
0.0042740372,
-0.0685351491,
-0.0031416451,
-0.0155663062,
0.0088557759,
-0.0215698592,
0.0063733761,
-0.0418070666,
-0.0095423665,
-0.0039174198,
0.0045311064,
-0.0266514644,
-0.0085134357,
0.0181492437,
0.0091861207,
-0.0094939368,
-0.004766589,
-0.0291043948,
0.0435691476,
0.0240511745,
0.0476961732,
-0.0068158768,
-0.0417028069,
0.0124750668,
0.045846682,
-0.0041311667,
0.0088627515,
-0.0307995994,
0.0425807834,
-0.033897914,
0.0090557048,
0.0201227106,
0.0189727768,
0.0388315506,
-0.0514660776,
0.0053808368,
0.0574234948,
0.0202782247,
0.0209602956,
-0.008796311,
0.0276379511,
0.0242624916,
0.0225317031,
0.0229204278,
-0.1101120487,
-0.0334777497,
-0.0060288743,
0.0432192944,
0.0544695444,
-0.0474437475,
-0.0247861072,
-0.1000849456,
0.0493938811,
0.0116147306,
-0.0146815404,
-0.0120434752,
-0.0574236549,
-0.0282973144,
-0.0072918711,
-0.0338404104,
-0.0255445521,
-0.0005704717,
0.0401531234,
0.030977888,
-0.0694863796,
-0.0142983403,
-0.0023920061,
-0.026612727,
-0.0680477321,
0.0144091435,
0.0639320165,
-0.0073534497,
-0.0124603482,
-0.0258363206,
0.0016059502,
0.0114499154,
0.0005078125,
0.0548397079,
0.013171697,
-0.0512215309,
-0.0121641578,
0.0498125739,
-0.0557454526,
-0.0101686902,
-0.010291785,
0.0411105081,
-0.016353393,
-0.0190883223,
-0.0379799977,
0.0350820571,
-0.0127774617,
0.0390762277,
0.0646225512,
0.0317391083,
-0.0451551266,
-0.0577632375,
0.0309237167,
-0.1081810668,
-0.0212037563,
0.0055854633,
0.0297560971,
-0.0241711289,
-0.0719882622,
-0.0309393667,
0.0509520657,
0.0456610695,
-0.0080519458,
-0.042506896,
0.0701812655,
-0.0349279642,
-0.0743564218,
0.0773745924,
-0.0206227414,
0.0437494963,
0.0174317136,
-0.0449790992,
-0.0130481878,
0.0287964344,
-0.0421171002,
0.0243254118,
-0.0768529475,
0.0141121438,
-0.0287847929,
0.0332268588,
0.0206644721,
0.0263430681,
-0.0193297435,
0.0190774389,
0.0245644078,
0.0585764199,
-0.0325249732,
-0.0287206694,
-0.0057359957,
0.0044792681,
0.0026373563,
-0.0230978616,
-0.0212084148,
0.0368865989,
0.0022387707,
0.0297027491,
-0.0169168022,
0.0284083299,
0.0194560681,
0.0185722746,
0.012585979,
0.0339534357,
-0.0168151744,
-0.0079728365,
-0.0583853461,
-0.0014842848,
-0.0249590129,
-0.0266027506,
0.0010273108,
0.0213261396,
0.0107852677,
-0.0167408362,
0.0158288646,
0.0213392265,
-0.0120977815,
-0.0529301055,
0.0272069108,
0.0343650319,
-0.007806432,
-0.0306871124,
0.0138254017,
-0.0050971783,
-0.0106805749,
-0.0200262535,
0.0491911918,
0.041793488,
0.0252506901,
0.0228772126,
0.0129418513,
-0.0081501482,
0.0193590261,
-0.0661412179,
-0.0626080111,
0.0292347856,
-0.0027998379,
0.0197799169,
-0.0338862278,
-0.0131686432,
0.0012719285,
0.0038731708,
0.0181802362,
0.0308149531,
-0.0097470945,
0.0018975674,
0.0716409236,
0.0156821683,
-0.0029415649,
-0.0961539,
0.0833237693,
-0.0144925313,
0.0015988511,
-0.0332511552,
-0.003846691,
-0.0537489206,
0.006674984,
-0.0036595881,
-0.0243470911,
0.0216212589,
0.0447280742,
-0.0371721983,
-0.0977471322,
0.0192782283,
0.0383732542,
0.0051867357,
0.0307952277,
0.0404902361,
0.0377321914,
0.0376011394,
-0.0063812356,
0.0058962749,
0.0314180441,
-0.0263099819,
-0.0138883414,
-0.0452807285,
-5.520074819e-33,
-0.0172151979,
-0.0363477953,
0.0483952388,
-0.0123349829,
-0.0053032651,
-0.0081243422,
-0.054246109,
-0.0240849201,
0.0073489426,
0.0241272785,
0.027451776,
0.0192569401,
-0.0015147554,
0.0038311949,
-0.0088097639,
-0.0251065884,
0.0469660088,
-0.0104448758,
-0.0345750563,
-0.0250337329,
0.0403497964,
0.0354922675,
0.0206268225,
-0.0760090798,
0.0259401836,
0.017587183,
0.0054381401,
0.0133004999,
0.0722163022,
0.0299387407,
-0.0001589039,
0.0165142883,
0.0194814652,
-0.0164398123,
-0.0635188669,
0.0788032636,
-0.1214442551,
-0.0747925267,
-0.0078899926,
0.0523327813,
-0.049506776,
0.0159272663,
0.0516321324,
-0.0036219077,
0.0282850396,
-0.0438270681,
0.0552909225,
-0.0273638945,
0.0087310765,
0.0096077444,
-0.0019644385,
0.0283336975,
-0.047195524,
-0.0352255404,
0.0440023169,
0.0803975239,
0.0105428267,
0.0469648838,
-0.0253966022,
0.0567472652,
-0.0106417742,
-0.067733407,
0.0353818014,
-0.0125333583,
0.033050973,
0.0399205275,
-0.0216350183,
-0.0198714733,
-0.0552592911,
0.052155491,
0.0156050874,
0.0597547963,
0.053470064,
-0.0125312516,
0.0413133875,
0.0055593052,
-0.0322186984,
0.0527018756,
-0.054885488,
0.0417334661,
-0.0785156563,
0.0291220304,
-0.0141304489,
-0.0292636566,
-0.0024019566,
-0.0099203819,
-0.0230698548,
0.0104976567,
0.0317656435,
-0.0071196402,
0.0069866306,
0.0467903242,
0.0032769172,
-0.0453485698,
-0.0067561851,
-0.0050985673,
0.0332222991,
0.0115921022,
0.0182759166,
-0.0080634914,
-0.0299086012,
0.0275120512,
0.0539794266,
-0.0114876833,
0.0298831519,
0.0126843844,
0.0335104056,
0.0085756434,
-0.0548882969,
-0.0236741342,
-0.0119973961,
-0.0150193712,
-0.0032944265,
-0.0010348228,
0.0407359488,
0.0452551097,
-0.0481829345,
0.0436584912,
-0.0101778889,
0.0004409375,
-0.0501973704,
-0.0027908892,
-0.0467480682,
0.0372533388,
0.0032218012,
-0.0480089672,
-0.0071410607,
-0.0236483943,
0.0068728575,
-0.0730787516,
-0.0137550663,
0.0099636242,
2.587e-7,
0.0671865791,
0.017721517,
0.0775368586,
0.0620033257,
0.025315363,
0.0151636489,
-0.0627924129,
-0.011633629,
0.0032165681,
-0.0445136651,
0.0147525324,
0.0375177041,
0.0273234397,
0.0520182289,
-0.0363878049,
-0.0055529024,
-0.0046038255,
-0.013899778,
-0.0453209616,
0.0317338407,
0.1019900069,
0.0362886302,
-0.0204316508,
0.0069335643,
0.0189639814,
-0.0559094884,
0.0642381385,
0.0004158215,
0.0085155135,
-0.0441989116,
-0.0164752956,
0.0167037807,
-0.0004865745,
0.0213974491,
-0.0163673256,
0.0041052173,
0.0521760434,
-0.0018011165,
0.0050356323,
0.0481481329,
-0.0220936108,
0.0028795176,
0.0059258081,
-0.0074353199,
0.0587615743,
-0.1017225608,
-0.0760290697,
0.0098132109,
-0.0411477648,
0.0267244894,
0.0190276485,
0.0182143711,
-0.0275702793,
0.0024686574,
0.0557561181,
0.0091362195,
0.0399174578,
-0.0352354124,
-0.0208649915,
0.0510380194,
-0.0067507611,
-0.0148182483,
-0.0261860266,
0.0253464542,
0.0123673473,
0.0293679852,
-0.0388892964,
2.025446561e-34,
0.033751376,
-0.0219993759,
0.0016034734,
-0.0118637206,
0.0636124909,
-0.0642969459,
0.018178815,
0.0238724519,
0.0401142947,
-0.0654089302,
-0.022077281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14760v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14760v2 | Bi-Drop: Enhancing Fine-tuning Generalization via Synchronous sub-net Estimation and Optimization | 2023-05-24T06:09:26 | 2023-10-22T11:46:33 | Shoujie Tong, Heming Xia, Damai Dai, Runxin Xu, Tianyu Liu, Binghuai Lin, Yunbo Cao, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have achieved remarkable success in natural
language understanding. However, fine-tuning pretrained models on limited
training data tends to overfit and thus diminish performance. This paper
presents Bi-Drop, a fine-tuning strategy that selectively updates model
parameters using gradients from various sub-nets dynamically generated by
dropout. The sub-net estimation of Bi-Drop is performed in an in-batch manner,
so it overcomes the problem of hysteresis in sub-net updating, which is
possessed by previous methods that perform asynchronous sub-net estimation.
Also, Bi-Drop needs only one mini-batch to estimate the sub-net so it achieves
higher utility of training data. Experiments on the GLUE benchmark demonstrate
that Bi-Drop consistently outperforms previous fine-tuning methods.
Furthermore, empirical results also show that Bi-Drop exhibits excellent
generalization ability and robustness for domain transfer, data imbalance, and
low-resource scenarios. | [
0.0457404926,
0.0533001348,
-0.0138375489,
0.0381859802,
-0.0240645744,
0.0165625475,
0.0168279018,
-0.0349080041,
0.0003538441,
-0.0463649333,
-0.0846752077,
-0.0389581248,
0.0047229258,
0.0467864946,
0.0053725103,
-0.0594030581,
0.0733908862,
0.0012080576,
-0.0051473244,
0.0085219759,
0.0129756602,
0.0432297401,
-0.0278021246,
0.0103533464,
0.0317732356,
-0.028260516,
-0.0033613027,
0.0491867103,
0.0240588095,
0.0197257269,
0.0273870807,
0.0516856387,
0.0551742055,
0.0296569243,
0.0000022123,
-0.0452495068,
-0.0254840199,
0.0050792899,
-0.0576057322,
0.0161178876,
-0.0028454226,
-0.025054818,
-0.0085954117,
0.0157750547,
-0.0096634477,
-0.0395873412,
0.025950918,
0.0264626183,
0.0515033528,
0.0723201185,
-0.0040499149,
-0.0241285656,
-0.0135917133,
-0.0661982372,
-0.0588358715,
-0.0832713768,
0.0285683386,
0.0168415643,
-0.0351529568,
-0.0638019741,
-0.0245083701,
0.0211810526,
0.0157209244,
0.0132721746,
-0.010551543,
0.000970793,
-0.041605942,
-0.0554122329,
-0.0279419497,
0.093685016,
-0.0852060616,
-0.0081009269,
-0.01821029,
-0.0642840862,
-0.0166508835,
0.0072630197,
-0.0181076899,
-0.0327288434,
0.0169402696,
0.02135274,
0.0000448302,
-0.0010768877,
0.0538505688,
0.0233868547,
-0.0348451473,
0.0347366408,
-0.0078531234,
0.0047984989,
0.0081538288,
0.0060280785,
-0.0494261049,
-0.0478008203,
0.0217805337,
0.0270751417,
-0.0217064414,
0.0262681898,
-0.04701671,
-0.0600644797,
-0.0257085543,
-0.0031665324,
0.0490868054,
0.0465876833,
-0.013210319,
0.0369125418,
0.0093518151,
0.0306535475,
0.0085454918,
-0.003662331,
-0.0524403192,
-0.0028734312,
-0.0183977652,
-0.0111028133,
-0.0942350924,
0.0339734182,
-0.054290548,
-0.0364479721,
-0.0418164283,
0.0049909889,
0.0215955209,
-0.032487087,
0.0307800826,
-0.0214015972,
-0.0741672292,
-0.022027541,
0.0357067883,
0.0363827422,
-0.0276780818,
0.0404765718,
-0.0167995188,
-0.0750366822,
-0.0312620401,
0.000958605,
0.0286495443,
-0.0232008584,
0.010852132,
0.0494021177,
0.0090061985,
-0.061355602,
-0.0898465365,
-0.0006195959,
-0.0070579099,
-0.0819897428,
-0.011681471,
-0.0168118868,
0.0460680835,
-0.0248056743,
0.0257255901,
-0.0632325038,
-0.0261537209,
-0.0205535311,
-0.0286326874,
0.0625904724,
-0.0797565058,
-0.0257764291,
-0.0182366911,
-0.0192717072,
0.0222290792,
0.1062766239,
0.0354912989,
0.0224481542,
0.0417416431,
-0.0144184167,
-0.047144834,
0.0435088761,
0.0407912917,
-0.0106830085,
-0.0178621933,
-0.0036572311,
0.0095430575,
0.040959172,
0.0298329908,
-0.0005913666,
-0.0170108434,
0.0024541125,
0.0494361445,
0.0329203866,
0.0645307377,
0.0470234677,
0.0647614077,
0.0330785587,
-0.0116755422,
0.0140294721,
-0.0449458174,
-0.0067776539,
0.024315631,
-0.0146110561,
-0.0015501308,
0.0401867926,
-0.0516828448,
-0.0523031466,
0.0056602992,
-0.0052159983,
-0.0157536156,
0.0292524379,
0.0607098341,
0.0634740219,
-0.0237690173,
0.0506098866,
0.0464253798,
-0.0059221033,
0.0326826163,
-0.0430813469,
-0.0130296666,
0.0656733587,
0.0136624314,
-0.0344236195,
-0.0229168255,
0.0103353551,
0.0700997338,
0.0055355513,
0.043935664,
-0.0087152319,
0.0431696773,
-0.0570919104,
-0.0297120716,
0.0012168466,
0.0003615187,
0.0156016741,
-0.0040891785,
-0.0077784336,
0.0212666038,
-0.0364916064,
-0.0224157739,
0.0288028549,
-0.0366374105,
0.0099407099,
0.0054504271,
0.0294446144,
0.0188995712,
0.0166367646,
-0.0163671039,
-0.0274450853,
0.0223199707,
-0.0035885805,
-0.0059903827,
-0.0291807633,
-0.0196675397,
-0.0075859632,
0.0189298391,
0.0310773738,
0.0021144643,
0.0370608866,
-0.0673260614,
-0.0313567705,
0.0138362125,
0.0065014376,
0.0509617254,
-0.0458351336,
0.0005871319,
-0.0153550589,
0.0448404551,
-0.0014781965,
0.004230734,
0.0043914118,
-0.01984418,
-0.0437387004,
-0.0101556582,
0.0131034525,
-0.0422519557,
-0.0161047541,
0.0422389098,
-0.0341341347,
-0.0035349189,
-0.0355193838,
0.0126954839,
-0.0389872193,
0.0103412317,
0.0074602803,
0.0146933822,
-0.0530628115,
0.0409618132,
0.033063177,
0.0502971075,
-0.0115509126,
-0.0383771472,
0.050677862,
0.0330219865,
-0.0391466282,
-0.0221000127,
-0.0083284322,
0.0251901038,
0.0245331153,
-0.0159194078,
-0.028355848,
0.0203502607,
0.0459970459,
0.0065771332,
-0.0090866294,
-0.0361176804,
-0.0008866544,
-0.0396294706,
0.0590152293,
-0.0022085251,
-0.0584861711,
-0.0403296016,
0.005188623,
-0.0197197814,
0.0565915257,
-0.023007663,
0.0256490652,
0.0483299643,
0.0032712719,
-0.0277901795,
0.0154676931,
-0.0259909425,
0.0015360464,
-0.0236461107,
0.0322466679,
-0.0219243392,
0.088419877,
-0.0045391358,
-0.01122812,
-0.0480810329,
0.006228914,
-0.0173904598,
-0.0338331051,
-0.0040067537,
0.0005173284,
-0.0039894236,
0.0065403217,
-0.033110328,
-0.0389335826,
0.0596957915,
-0.0217493549,
-0.0095678782,
-0.0582735091,
-0.0208391771,
-0.0312622525,
0.0130724525,
0.0079607358,
0.0017383482,
0.0252582971,
-0.0356345177,
-0.0316572003,
0.0062835761,
-0.010576034,
0.0011533238,
0.0162754506,
-0.0230161007,
0.0174001921,
-0.0123680048,
-0.0261596106,
-0.0161891934,
-0.0430556946,
-0.0627086163,
0.0139709888,
0.0189081132,
-0.0355203599,
-0.0257317144,
0.0140120173,
-0.0242216885,
0.0654520169,
-0.0097034192,
0.0065988908,
-0.0422662795,
0.0354278088,
0.0504043475,
0.0241684057,
-0.0190321524,
0.005793775,
0.001904409,
0.0170881655,
0.0098823989,
-0.0132134799,
-0.0707683265,
0.0167046655,
0.0396622345,
-0.0160356518,
-0.0213696379,
-0.0173868313,
0.0220101345,
-0.0772600174,
-0.012540997,
0.1159912348,
0.0111758895,
-0.0369715914,
0.0032095299,
0.003580322,
0.0427159928,
0.0280438382,
0.0361492522,
-0.0561464876,
-0.0656874701,
0.0098514752,
0.033951968,
0.0342782773,
-0.0137005588,
-0.0434113331,
-0.0891308486,
0.0223363098,
-0.0065182499,
-0.0421946459,
-0.003641882,
-0.010146914,
0.031902492,
-0.0089861257,
0.0662345886,
-0.0045978078,
-0.0143754371,
-0.019167196,
0.0447578616,
-0.0253552664,
-0.0711049736,
0.0183113236,
-0.0120876208,
0.0205209032,
0.0533873066,
0.0143243251,
-0.0123815015,
0.0352945626,
0.1016939282,
-0.0600587726,
0.0007717863,
-0.059138272,
0.061795935,
-0.0372123569,
-0.0216921847,
0.0180611964,
0.0235775895,
-0.0064634443,
-0.0077908067,
-0.0302573498,
0.0582436062,
-0.0040687411,
-0.0422044024,
0.0057725548,
0.0038561267,
0.0240062587,
0.0373870134,
0.0333190374,
-0.060624931,
0.0307964664,
0.0199127942,
0.005399181,
-0.0453037284,
0.0102419732,
-0.0050928444,
-0.0202183239,
-0.0179800931,
-0.0207354221,
-0.0104544526,
0.0121953152,
0.0115151349,
0.0281868223,
0.0096020009,
0.0562765636,
0.0183538161,
-0.0335483812,
0.024434343,
-0.021321414,
0.011517223,
-0.0362807736,
-0.0225544591,
0.0836172029,
-0.0362868868,
-0.0457450077,
0.0167600475,
-0.0841098949,
-0.0578384511,
0.011390958,
0.0341416374,
0.0161259323,
0.0890229866,
-0.0490160957,
-0.0959409028,
-0.0095515102,
0.030368099,
0.0058072251,
0.0116275093,
0.0436289124,
-0.0608043969,
-0.0112668816,
0.0452372469,
-0.0479324274,
0.0423624068,
0.0600887127,
-0.0041745743,
0.0039873342,
-0.0298122987,
-0.0199520215,
-0.0091552716,
0.0671517998,
-0.0017972803,
0.0093782013,
-0.0549733751,
0.0418704972,
0.0294868052,
0.004836143,
-0.065952383,
0.0080187172,
0.0304937158,
-0.0350027867,
-0.0287161916,
0.015319882,
-0.0040742476,
-0.0138184251,
-0.0325648412,
0.0149267782,
0.0154681792,
0.0318472199,
0.0270553734,
-0.0048909495,
0.0160283241,
0.0274149999,
0.0289724804,
0.0020492421,
-0.0295117088,
0.0066933148,
0.0434066467,
0.0282133147,
-0.0729892403,
0.0265888982,
-0.0203984678,
-0.0439659357,
-0.0322395153,
0.0316959135,
0.048089873,
-0.0274572503,
0.0219133813,
0.0305635147,
-0.0124421446,
-0.0241182409,
0.0559945703,
-0.0180194043,
-0.003363112,
0.0335043967,
0.009888161,
-0.0268869326,
0.0610937998,
0.0353968143,
0.0128975231,
0.053188961,
0.019553721,
0.0066982908,
-0.042328272,
-0.0218609422,
-0.0202524345,
0.0479714274,
-0.0307901688,
0.030161716,
-0.0287819412,
-0.0873975158,
0.0047190702,
-0.0138302427,
0.0014217979,
0.028086124,
0.0482842475,
0.0496526547,
0.0073639201,
-0.0049483161,
-0.0056117112,
-0.0282999445,
0.0033886277,
-0.0035356898,
0.03170304,
-7.117652824e-33,
-0.0288817603,
0.013399153,
-0.0089048976,
0.0208132099,
-0.0344080552,
0.0064646159,
-0.0188032556,
-0.0453555174,
-0.0607149862,
-0.0059169377,
-0.0025106,
0.0347787887,
0.0425731465,
0.0047445996,
-0.0546344034,
0.0077965641,
0.0913041756,
-0.0256362855,
-0.0192490462,
0.00812581,
0.0031810144,
0.0843245536,
0.1018566564,
-0.0351273306,
-0.0134055912,
-0.0125868144,
-0.0072761704,
0.0544331372,
-0.0065381336,
0.0278723557,
-0.0061849202,
0.0538763292,
0.0213727616,
-0.008231095,
-0.035023436,
0.0320497714,
-0.1170945913,
-0.0305270012,
0.0225390922,
0.030859055,
-0.0287655108,
0.0088316808,
0.0410559885,
0.0197913721,
0.0060688108,
-0.027529126,
0.0387006067,
0.0056896,
-0.0425328352,
-0.0081257345,
-0.055380661,
0.0274359658,
0.0053200084,
-0.0474922769,
0.036837358,
0.0283319931,
0.0085749477,
0.0055959509,
-0.0428836457,
-0.0234714802,
0.0415625386,
0.0549692623,
0.0396654457,
0.0200330056,
-0.0259633847,
0.0218021162,
0.0166932605,
0.0051452983,
0.0504181385,
0.0125152348,
0.0736340135,
0.0078633055,
-0.0219363421,
0.0166222695,
0.0599923544,
-0.015695719,
-0.0910536423,
-0.0444446728,
-0.0308609065,
0.0566346012,
0.0076624542,
0.0240971297,
-0.0007785307,
0.0028378323,
-0.034683235,
-0.0573252589,
-0.0336061232,
-0.0239725746,
0.0177495759,
0.0231675971,
-0.0333819352,
0.0207193419,
0.0161050502,
-0.0545548126,
-0.0069935233,
0.0239416901,
-0.0048832214,
-0.0003566377,
0.0013876534,
0.0310422461,
-0.0474755168,
-0.0441824161,
-0.0046460372,
0.0288130194,
0.0273931287,
-0.0264470801,
0.0534645356,
0.0326854214,
-0.005136393,
-0.0199407674,
-0.0313861482,
0.0104130665,
-0.0062994584,
0.0834097192,
0.0460242555,
0.0284412783,
-0.0259755217,
0.0750852227,
0.0265576784,
-0.0408878773,
-0.0018687963,
0.0173222646,
0.0429906696,
0.0325435735,
-0.0386057347,
-0.0167953316,
-0.0093312487,
-0.0035279519,
0.0125532225,
-0.0720835775,
-0.0230540149,
0.0247928966,
2.946e-7,
0.058961872,
0.02273532,
0.0143039692,
0.0042902068,
0.0176933482,
-0.0050916467,
-0.0329263844,
-0.0080415374,
0.033875607,
0.0172804091,
0.0435799696,
0.0362855233,
0.0388222858,
-0.0336221941,
-0.1035585999,
0.0149384392,
-0.0512478836,
0.060042385,
-0.0438988283,
-0.0203917902,
0.0044543343,
0.0911475047,
0.0345203429,
-0.0325223692,
-0.0011543994,
-0.0164022949,
0.0306522921,
0.0026549471,
0.0128245968,
0.0264913123,
0.0024340816,
0.0817292556,
-0.0174059328,
0.0300127361,
-0.0397524573,
0.0576695018,
0.0056864736,
0.0449432954,
-0.0226928815,
0.014031373,
0.0112485746,
0.0270071868,
0.0007755767,
-0.0161792319,
0.0851612762,
-0.1052372605,
-0.0109600304,
-0.0355514698,
-0.0051239729,
-0.0152908275,
-0.0057089357,
-0.0244191661,
-0.0001351713,
0.0253812224,
0.0288047772,
-0.0282913875,
-0.0672120377,
-0.0806380063,
0.0010141078,
0.0293936096,
-0.0425726287,
-0.0164914317,
-0.02064161,
-0.0448794216,
0.0484518632,
-0.0236391407,
0.0007977637,
2.385235536e-34,
0.0471204743,
-0.0185790937,
0.0279728975,
0.0314098299,
-0.010393207,
-0.0093525425,
-0.0428376645,
-0.0063543525,
-0.0227219556,
-0.0511876009,
-0.0151482653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14757v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14757v2 | Psychological Metrics for Dialog System Evaluation | 2023-05-24T06:02:32 | 2023-09-16T02:35:44 | Salvatore Giorgi, Shreya Havaldar, Farhan Ahmed, Zuhaib Akhtar, Shalaka Vaidya, Gary Pan, Lyle H. Ungar, H. Andrew Schwartz, Joao Sedoc | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present metrics for evaluating dialog systems through a
psychologically-grounded "human" lens in which conversational agents express a
diversity of both states (e.g., emotion) and traits (e.g., personality), just
as people do. We present five interpretable metrics from established psychology
that are fundamental to human communication and relationships: emotional
entropy, linguistic style and emotion matching, agreeableness, and empathy.
These metrics can be applied (1) across dialogs and (2) on turns within
dialogs. The psychological metrics are compared against seven state-of-the-art
traditional metrics (e.g., BARTScore and BLEURT) on seven standard dialog
system data sets. We also introduce a novel data set, the Three Bot Dialog
Evaluation Corpus, which consists of annotated conversations from ChatGPT,
GPT-3, and BlenderBot. We demonstrate that our proposed metrics offer novel
information; they are uncorrelated with traditional metrics, can be used to
meaningfully compare dialog systems, and lead to increased accuracy (beyond
existing traditional metrics) in predicting crowd-sourced dialog judgements.
The interpretability and unique signal of our psychological metrics make them a
valuable tool for evaluating and improving dialog systems. | [
0.0666042566,
0.0385072492,
-0.0300500952,
-0.0011609939,
-0.0224063843,
0.0203801878,
-0.0103214532,
0.0109767029,
0.0481328145,
-0.0374218002,
-0.0832562819,
-0.0166445076,
0.0179806408,
0.0484365709,
0.0048808055,
-0.1100509018,
-0.0170096401,
0.0266345832,
0.0476341136,
0.0230239704,
0.0564172603,
0.0146388467,
-0.020712588,
0.0834558979,
-0.00845668,
-0.0139153758,
-0.0201536734,
0.0343640484,
0.0431906581,
-0.0220602863,
0.0228179116,
0.0496055409,
-0.0275045838,
0.0202012565,
0.0000018268,
-0.0438223816,
0.0388158001,
-0.0249616336,
-0.0194589645,
-0.0085524768,
0.0727786422,
0.0148886945,
-0.0018783384,
0.0216430277,
-0.0318419635,
-0.0222871751,
0.0487724543,
0.0557758622,
0.0642765537,
0.0438421927,
-0.0174615663,
0.0205252785,
-0.0186050981,
0.0085880114,
-0.0113569964,
-0.0515135862,
-0.016971264,
-0.0002491531,
0.0151565522,
-0.0450589322,
0.0159407929,
-0.0045047356,
-0.0005681225,
-0.0439968966,
0.0154268919,
-0.0126436315,
-0.0296550263,
-0.0571216233,
-0.0002199972,
0.0980716199,
0.0333767422,
0.0065570194,
0.0151730319,
-0.0084963292,
0.0221081153,
-0.0264623333,
-0.0301223658,
-0.0068743881,
-0.0008170368,
-0.0383674055,
-0.0473315865,
0.0384350643,
-0.0285030771,
0.0209531225,
0.0381026901,
0.0285101403,
-0.0209501795,
-0.021564927,
0.0000576879,
0.0075308788,
0.0106584085,
-0.0771916285,
0.0013964724,
0.0001791358,
-0.036242418,
0.003468951,
-0.0376784056,
0.0051453197,
0.0261193905,
-0.0230991468,
-0.0365145728,
0.010740771,
-0.0030520211,
0.0445146225,
0.064942278,
0.049157545,
0.0287440196,
0.0251527876,
-0.0332421772,
-0.0204557944,
-0.0648718998,
0.012221559,
-0.0045738034,
-0.0214378778,
0.011110465,
-0.0236494578,
-0.0291346479,
0.0244946275,
-0.0615278147,
-0.0148840519,
-0.0033255254,
0.0077899811,
-0.0041810796,
-0.0078775575,
-0.0455481261,
0.0112508964,
-0.0629966259,
0.0171722881,
0.0418996699,
-0.0666322112,
0.0103367707,
0.0322045945,
0.0261361804,
0.0095114149,
0.0173443276,
0.0321627334,
0.0340636596,
-0.005042477,
0.0139524499,
-0.0095018819,
-0.023116339,
-0.060123004,
-0.0528990105,
0.0098887682,
0.0460410379,
-0.0096213231,
-0.0246764161,
-0.0026624675,
0.0074562086,
0.007037058,
0.0104237786,
0.0436141714,
-0.0092218285,
-0.0069991304,
0.0210603438,
0.044165384,
-0.0470194444,
0.0364024006,
0.027805388,
0.0322133973,
0.0603899546,
-0.0324545428,
0.049271971,
0.0238036681,
-0.0264495853,
-0.024094902,
0.0569786131,
0.0000815172,
-0.0365642868,
0.0394214913,
0.0229656864,
0.0540716872,
-0.0401588082,
-0.0552667528,
0.0520120412,
0.086737223,
-0.0250470582,
0.028458612,
-0.0054539535,
0.03747629,
0.0432567671,
-0.0002675618,
-0.0118086301,
0.0451300927,
-0.0135849668,
-0.0422846861,
0.0518745333,
0.0044958559,
-0.0027619738,
-0.0546136685,
-0.0144393155,
-0.012392533,
0.0210506395,
-0.0092124902,
-0.0176900364,
0.0019406492,
-0.0231497288,
-0.0184073951,
0.0075638709,
-0.0540433414,
-0.0230365284,
-0.0375024751,
-0.0093328357,
0.0792203099,
0.03202077,
0.0086505739,
-0.0201434903,
-0.0207110606,
-0.0379331186,
0.0248764735,
0.0325431526,
-0.0102845272,
0.0427209809,
-0.0455233678,
0.0103239836,
0.0533679314,
-0.0035145308,
0.0003523892,
-0.0290351734,
0.0166740362,
-0.0111346338,
0.0046171849,
0.0049528987,
-0.0119846454,
0.0080205826,
0.0043174019,
0.0060317889,
0.0174079817,
0.0738253444,
0.0214340501,
-0.0100510847,
-0.0202265792,
0.0000653054,
0.0133291716,
-0.027953444,
0.0746896863,
-0.0321413986,
-0.0078933313,
0.0215782262,
-0.0297566447,
-0.0242132042,
0.0290502179,
-0.0064309384,
-0.0120764421,
0.0353833027,
-0.0682439953,
0.0143288886,
-0.0123912022,
0.0169472937,
-0.0215140097,
0.0273767393,
-0.0053721936,
-0.0090071075,
0.0014551048,
0.0008624122,
0.0180928968,
-0.0258064698,
0.0084061977,
-0.0342913307,
-0.0077723442,
0.0270269737,
0.0062667737,
0.0203496274,
0.0165427048,
-0.0256617591,
-0.091645427,
-0.0483788028,
-0.1076065451,
-0.0130265765,
0.0017060561,
-0.0142588103,
0.0268064402,
-0.0296820402,
-0.0044725854,
0.0004710356,
-0.046851337,
0.0218250155,
0.0197923966,
0.0106792822,
0.0441752076,
0.0121550802,
-0.0215499289,
-0.0593767278,
0.0191758536,
0.0037178334,
0.0285520703,
0.0190016329,
0.0385693163,
-0.0453863665,
0.0200100187,
-0.061869286,
0.0059307688,
-0.0226398408,
-0.0981990099,
0.0331042148,
0.0489921607,
0.0119139068,
0.0532266684,
0.0767054185,
0.0354232751,
-0.0287697539,
0.012506092,
-0.0519857146,
-0.0082726283,
0.0148346229,
0.0221205857,
-0.0107840421,
-0.067883417,
0.0258810073,
0.0161587615,
0.006247188,
0.0522610843,
-0.061255917,
0.0229153335,
0.0231586136,
-0.065423198,
-0.0063641197,
-0.0297861211,
-0.0132422205,
0.0387740321,
-0.0016630488,
-0.0444506891,
0.0684243441,
-0.012194776,
-0.0183638297,
-0.0104437163,
-0.0425617844,
-0.0455537774,
0.0455508307,
-0.0252631083,
0.010511823,
0.0293993857,
-0.0075606634,
-0.0299033578,
-0.0356795602,
0.0397599526,
-0.0483356714,
0.0052144188,
0.002728167,
-0.0401430391,
0.0153220659,
-0.0541718379,
-0.0091461921,
-0.0430159159,
-0.0280660521,
-0.0334189199,
0.0741411597,
-0.0493244939,
-0.0277223401,
-0.003916115,
0.0320971087,
-0.0288963597,
0.0166904666,
-0.0239041634,
0.0156035013,
-0.0221970584,
0.0786417723,
0.07418935,
0.0333358124,
-0.001129133,
0.0510165989,
0.055082377,
0.0308350194,
-0.0147184916,
-0.0029429963,
-0.0193782002,
0.003137829,
0.0491754338,
0.0044121752,
-0.0095760189,
0.0537983403,
-0.0070787771,
0.0152288871,
0.0997275859,
0.011396504,
-0.048746787,
-0.011200713,
-0.045407746,
0.0460712239,
0.0040394315,
-0.0127539672,
-0.0242346935,
-0.0280865282,
0.0115498668,
0.0385960527,
-0.0375229418,
-0.036990609,
0.0081641721,
-0.0492988899,
0.0217878483,
0.0001223821,
0.0019201491,
-0.0701065883,
-0.0201782137,
0.0118610002,
-0.0221255887,
-0.0002875238,
-0.0242661573,
0.0225405134,
-0.0012220724,
0.0099270875,
-0.0748006925,
0.0197596811,
0.0725988299,
-0.0289503336,
0.087784715,
0.0392042585,
0.0760341659,
0.0256985314,
-0.0464711785,
-0.0324545689,
0.0334262028,
-0.0087246336,
0.0162798073,
0.0750239491,
-0.0183825027,
-0.0044890321,
-0.0803420991,
0.0122502698,
-0.0061692735,
0.0064562852,
0.0028092803,
0.0178030748,
-0.0249015745,
-0.0127445059,
-0.0272678975,
0.0435730778,
0.04719726,
0.0762084648,
0.040039897,
-0.0704402551,
-0.0247113071,
-0.0182435289,
0.0428450145,
-0.0119192582,
-0.036897134,
-0.0202899836,
0.0202861987,
-0.0546119437,
-0.0742920786,
-0.0728819072,
-0.0285077672,
0.0182531606,
-0.0228781141,
-0.036864426,
0.0197188575,
0.0130539956,
0.0148896025,
0.0192356743,
0.0158412494,
0.016027974,
-0.0579901338,
-0.0148959355,
0.0191957839,
-0.0389614776,
-0.0054413336,
0.0439029559,
-0.0090927258,
0.0026317919,
0.0265322626,
0.0291385967,
0.0183934085,
0.0024916125,
0.0154223656,
-0.0403636545,
-0.0254891887,
0.0270205326,
-0.0232457072,
-0.0006252223,
0.0551357679,
0.0896721408,
-0.0189776607,
0.0282733068,
-0.0291047711,
0.0062493966,
-0.0350932553,
-0.0220040772,
-0.0283129569,
-0.1017251685,
-0.0033174672,
0.0391993709,
0.0150722722,
0.0118049448,
-0.0239993464,
0.0060384599,
-0.013997443,
0.0022841294,
0.00346021,
-0.0709909722,
-0.0556219034,
-0.015197535,
-0.0185662247,
-0.0143546145,
-0.0190042891,
-0.0350700319,
0.0001538318,
0.0410989448,
0.0083611533,
-0.0026504465,
0.0419698469,
-0.0229442213,
0.0048042587,
-0.0229186509,
-0.0071964283,
-0.0048871865,
0.0351775922,
0.0142808324,
0.0762772709,
0.0106549561,
-0.0363881364,
0.0640719458,
0.0644418597,
-0.0471095927,
-0.0309677515,
0.002715481,
-0.0053770575,
-0.0110078054,
0.0343063734,
0.0599072762,
-0.0294959676,
0.024801448,
-0.0218056142,
0.0356193669,
-0.014552217,
-0.0333959199,
-0.0219623595,
0.0110332342,
-0.031202307,
-0.0009333672,
0.0372065306,
-0.0538666435,
0.023638906,
-0.031294886,
-0.0386424325,
-0.0337130949,
0.0012576738,
-0.0145291323,
-0.0004366603,
0.0291148089,
-0.0006915965,
-0.1085680127,
-0.0274903234,
0.0031137867,
0.0052916263,
0.0066047325,
-0.0192045346,
0.0440959707,
0.0442389846,
-0.0264440272,
0.0214057118,
-0.0368086211,
0.0102305356,
-0.0486067235,
0.0218822937,
-0.0186925326,
-5.563758026e-33,
0.0109472414,
-0.0490322784,
-0.0332386345,
0.021771431,
-0.0204138737,
-0.040271271,
-0.0418674797,
0.0391794518,
-0.0225651786,
0.0525715426,
-0.0064471057,
0.0223113503,
-0.0100632329,
-0.0175132956,
-0.0096333809,
-0.0424205847,
0.017960785,
-0.0030317763,
-0.0362286046,
0.0416271649,
0.0394569188,
-0.0329602771,
0.0256962646,
-0.0995119065,
0.0444514491,
0.0039402139,
-0.0187752414,
-0.0067665172,
0.054079093,
0.038206026,
0.0157452915,
0.0699631944,
0.0108355349,
-0.0201763771,
-0.001204405,
0.0302187037,
0.0143764438,
-0.0432732776,
0.0035429399,
0.0167651325,
-0.0325142071,
0.0053960499,
0.0083406791,
0.0025949217,
-0.0384612009,
-0.0302322935,
0.0043889349,
0.0102174869,
0.0587573312,
-0.0038972034,
-0.0151288519,
0.0169872232,
-0.0480314977,
-0.083298184,
-0.0073062703,
0.0820825845,
-0.0002083864,
0.0017210037,
-0.0410205983,
0.0217873231,
-0.0557744652,
-0.0263804998,
0.0283530708,
-0.0223348048,
0.0384707041,
0.0890944824,
0.0492248833,
0.0627784505,
-0.0554983653,
-0.0383793376,
-0.0129730972,
0.054932788,
0.0574561879,
0.0736862645,
0.002593036,
-0.0299746208,
0.006481397,
0.0620772988,
0.0470722839,
0.0219950695,
-0.0175992828,
0.0176806096,
-0.0571293123,
0.0249066018,
-0.013668539,
-0.03333316,
-0.0285655279,
-0.0306965951,
0.0225518476,
-0.0257927962,
0.0147079015,
-0.0727031752,
0.0022190432,
-0.0375191979,
0.0215059202,
0.0397931933,
-0.0318022668,
0.0289501864,
0.035007298,
-0.0242760368,
0.004394142,
0.0275482982,
0.0519430339,
0.0705592483,
0.0752830878,
-0.0243875924,
-0.0203907918,
0.0168373976,
-0.0283116773,
-0.0115102446,
-0.0101719927,
0.0645279139,
-0.0447105877,
-0.0575415567,
-0.0068194838,
-0.010174687,
-0.0417422615,
-0.0121773696,
-0.0228137504,
0.0428779274,
-0.0475063547,
-0.0092371413,
-0.0051275524,
-0.0071374201,
-0.0482756309,
-0.0290962998,
-0.0086205164,
-0.0876321942,
0.0146052614,
0.0014203029,
0.0004996146,
-0.0344385877,
2.59e-7,
-0.0364034809,
0.0502032936,
0.0228658076,
-0.0109856976,
0.0283422526,
0.0984511524,
0.0088393344,
0.0237790886,
0.0257008988,
-0.0630189404,
0.0249952246,
-0.0211977027,
0.08097969,
0.0159888808,
-0.0746257082,
-0.0290608332,
-0.0507081337,
-0.0008752066,
0.0296865553,
0.026951896,
0.0995263979,
0.0428710282,
0.0180991106,
-0.0047076894,
0.0161956511,
0.0166288801,
0.0032048009,
-0.0639805347,
0.0212228037,
0.0329161957,
0.0574125648,
-0.0599342249,
0.0299324766,
0.015926376,
-0.0078130821,
-0.0076824725,
0.0096477121,
0.0521667935,
-0.0116369221,
-0.074862279,
-0.0132535752,
0.016918391,
0.0061523258,
-0.0591439046,
-0.0041446011,
-0.0266305003,
-0.0642450452,
-0.0602563657,
-0.0353396721,
-0.0457495339,
0.0491225608,
-0.0059922575,
-0.0547991693,
0.0367872752,
0.0083701517,
-0.0134764453,
0.0071673626,
-0.0673968047,
-0.0013272393,
-0.0305093993,
-0.0443359576,
-0.0687139332,
-0.0235554576,
0.0214946046,
0.0188660584,
0.0018421767,
0.0176437441,
1.573614887e-34,
-0.001442743,
-0.0111856889,
0.02181351,
0.0316449665,
0.0692962632,
0.0107542612,
0.0114896465,
0.0002736883,
0.0650265813,
-0.0377253145,
0.0228333976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14755v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14755v2 | Don't Take This Out of Context! On the Need for Contextual Models and Evaluations for Stylistic Rewriting | 2023-05-24T05:58:17 | 2023-10-23T17:11:30 | Akhila Yerukola, Xuhui Zhou, Elizabeth Clark, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most existing stylistic text rewriting methods and evaluation metrics operate
on a sentence level, but ignoring the broader context of the text can lead to
preferring generic, ambiguous, and incoherent rewrites. In this paper, we
investigate integrating the preceding textual context into both the
$\textit{rewriting}$ and $\textit{evaluation}$ stages of stylistic text
rewriting, and introduce a new composite contextual evaluation metric
$\texttt{CtxSimFit}$ that combines similarity to the original sentence with
contextual cohesiveness. We comparatively evaluate non-contextual and
contextual rewrites in formality, toxicity, and sentiment transfer tasks. Our
experiments show that humans significantly prefer contextual rewrites as more
fitting and natural over non-contextual ones, yet existing sentence-level
automatic metrics (e.g., ROUGE, SBERT) correlate poorly with human preferences
($\rho$=0--0.3). In contrast, human preferences are much better reflected by
both our novel $\texttt{CtxSimFit}$ ($\rho$=0.7--0.9) as well as proposed
context-infused versions of common metrics ($\rho$=0.4--0.7). Overall, our
findings highlight the importance of integrating context into the generation
and especially the evaluation stages of stylistic text rewriting. | [
0.0282730274,
0.0083160037,
-0.0193564165,
0.0075983922,
-0.0766287819,
-0.0012790329,
-0.0107295848,
0.0225016661,
-0.0480942875,
-0.0412504412,
-0.0555652268,
-0.0106915832,
0.0231869631,
0.0147981597,
0.0145206852,
-0.0753219649,
-0.0225056633,
0.032583788,
0.0484280735,
0.0053370218,
0.065197967,
0.017357396,
0.0394811928,
0.0286749825,
-0.0108142849,
-0.0065786792,
0.0256483778,
0.080330804,
0.0170494467,
-0.0166538935,
0.0306564849,
0.0475131087,
-0.0229123142,
-0.0014729637,
0.0000021257,
-0.0440452062,
-0.011335751,
-0.0327277333,
0.0505271628,
0.0267154127,
0.0975183398,
-0.0007915008,
-0.0197465215,
-0.0015241961,
-0.026530087,
0.0249780826,
0.0441102311,
0.031740196,
0.0569253787,
0.0963847414,
-0.0373933949,
-0.0327249169,
-0.0224418268,
-0.0014267382,
-0.0063604456,
0.0033302668,
0.0128037091,
-0.0046967641,
-0.0334745161,
0.0117750196,
0.0054802382,
0.0284586791,
0.0118486676,
-0.0369410291,
0.025183931,
-0.021052802,
-0.0114813438,
0.0471792743,
0.0067489487,
0.0268820748,
0.015199434,
-0.0482754149,
-0.0018685252,
0.0142074591,
0.003061136,
-0.007430017,
-0.0566482991,
-0.0076954369,
0.0038517187,
0.0133876521,
0.0185391568,
0.0446131788,
-0.0062295902,
0.023158811,
0.042016089,
0.0294194408,
0.0286949184,
-0.0303248391,
-0.0452120006,
0.0167434346,
-0.0221207328,
-0.0618840717,
0.0135675017,
-0.0209385306,
-0.0194380749,
0.0072067026,
-0.0823791623,
-0.0299606808,
0.018443713,
-0.0676652938,
0.0458363183,
-0.0066644899,
0.0219165552,
0.0236018561,
-0.0231643245,
0.0246278066,
-0.0019344769,
-0.0027649314,
-0.0643982366,
0.0251880046,
-0.0183002688,
-0.0057289372,
-0.0212460905,
0.0077410229,
0.0043640118,
-0.0040241373,
-0.0561634302,
0.0191640481,
-0.0041932133,
-0.0563162565,
-0.0195515174,
0.0180266723,
-0.0182415713,
0.005443838,
0.0085385293,
-0.0049511399,
-0.0145178922,
0.0325636715,
-0.0071690893,
0.0195267983,
0.0062062284,
0.0541790426,
0.0129556134,
-0.0483945534,
-0.0195370372,
0.0249536857,
-0.0347568393,
0.0027136635,
-0.040012937,
-0.0307083763,
-0.047473263,
-0.0132678365,
-0.0534115061,
-0.064886421,
-0.0005708407,
-0.0131012499,
-0.0074915998,
-0.02899375,
-0.0190596394,
0.0257694237,
-0.0302952901,
-0.0099421833,
0.0368486382,
-0.0008569916,
0.0085965581,
-0.0025698827,
-0.0076995427,
-0.0025653273,
0.0296369512,
0.0612330511,
0.0532849319,
0.0011072498,
0.0125370994,
0.0057089538,
-0.0278898142,
0.0309905279,
-0.0719347671,
-0.0045174053,
0.0059363521,
0.0520202927,
0.057243038,
0.0849402547,
-0.0427092761,
-0.0069699981,
0.1106755435,
-0.0160146728,
0.0664126649,
0.0208650511,
0.0656574667,
0.0202921499,
0.0008400423,
0.0575201288,
-0.0121146878,
0.0137882289,
-0.065187037,
0.0390603617,
0.0018625853,
-0.0003021057,
0.0078480896,
-0.049272161,
0.005772884,
0.037377391,
-0.0008740908,
-0.0519343168,
-0.0224773642,
0.0691602752,
-0.0668383613,
-0.0766241401,
0.0079583982,
-0.0841222182,
-0.0035045214,
0.0042590862,
0.0136751635,
0.120918557,
0.0757053792,
0.0053671822,
0.0239958223,
0.0043682819,
-0.0229155477,
0.0089001358,
-0.0003160497,
-0.0094452249,
0.0090642264,
-0.0341073982,
0.0275486186,
-0.0274118204,
0.0086240796,
0.0130901188,
-0.0073449411,
0.0290017445,
0.0067066723,
-0.0170236677,
-0.0182982143,
0.0586243905,
0.0385874957,
-0.0562189221,
-0.0024977536,
0.023339333,
0.0089877071,
-0.0157826543,
-0.034784358,
0.0112845609,
-0.0330659561,
-0.0325879008,
-0.0258327499,
0.0488633849,
-0.0845450535,
-0.0647194237,
-0.0002540257,
-0.0548644811,
-0.0003298962,
0.0083347578,
-0.0017450965,
-0.0279239882,
0.0289035682,
-0.0386700444,
0.0366078056,
-0.0445284992,
0.0344596915,
-0.0420348048,
0.0010002065,
-0.0536471456,
0.0251707677,
0.0360536166,
-0.0296644624,
0.0068713985,
-0.0229689591,
-0.0216553789,
0.0076094805,
-0.026960833,
-0.0318008885,
0.020074727,
-0.0047255796,
0.0224983562,
0.0107088778,
-0.0450047255,
-0.0632717386,
-0.0823353231,
-0.0004971614,
-0.0240692254,
0.0070573553,
0.0829434246,
0.0017370187,
-0.010342571,
0.0453428216,
-0.022097094,
-0.0396807939,
-0.0406531096,
0.0241411068,
0.0608958453,
-0.0186376441,
-0.0364034809,
-0.0636702031,
-0.0148141086,
0.0045410306,
0.0549980067,
0.0024090777,
-0.012039491,
-0.0184902437,
0.0749768242,
-0.0097082285,
-0.0726147816,
0.0113953613,
-0.0536014624,
-0.0008048233,
0.0027887844,
0.0863261744,
0.0622540154,
0.0644816384,
0.0064038052,
0.0260421019,
-0.0064923153,
0.0153935486,
-0.0435754396,
-0.0296761338,
0.010193713,
0.0044017322,
-0.0854051933,
0.0588571727,
0.0166966897,
0.0382118635,
-0.0036300884,
-0.0331207179,
0.0058797146,
-0.0262872409,
-0.0445765741,
-0.0112320492,
-0.0475203767,
-0.0188957825,
-0.017641319,
-0.0278078634,
-0.0108426679,
0.0513628498,
0.006130232,
-0.0056728092,
-0.0119069805,
-0.0261772014,
-0.0291078314,
0.0309138093,
-0.031900838,
0.0185504239,
0.025843164,
-0.0092455735,
-0.0494090691,
-0.0441048667,
0.0620290227,
0.0012656817,
0.0234050155,
-0.0494089685,
-0.0030511788,
0.0397433788,
-0.0226251055,
0.0003439579,
-0.0498567745,
0.0090506533,
-0.0164730642,
0.0431714207,
0.0067018112,
0.0233829357,
-0.007919075,
0.0161197633,
0.032324899,
-0.0292010382,
-0.0241371635,
0.0173311513,
0.0424942374,
0.0274786707,
-0.0036994002,
0.0185787547,
-0.0028563845,
0.0389559194,
0.0615123585,
-0.0280705541,
-0.0262040943,
-0.0270472001,
0.0070113065,
-0.010992079,
-0.012277863,
-0.0468083359,
-0.0076471418,
0.0526759401,
-0.0640272796,
-0.0067002997,
0.080593504,
-0.0003469105,
-0.0087549873,
0.0020655906,
0.0099538118,
0.0644260719,
-0.0037231834,
-0.0023584205,
-0.0591656789,
-0.0324355476,
0.0333131216,
-0.0001803208,
-0.0478022285,
-0.017381696,
-0.0016096974,
-0.0393943973,
0.0127263116,
0.0013730276,
-0.0546027943,
0.0406708494,
-0.0064543867,
0.0168064907,
0.0145300459,
0.0001736316,
0.0295255538,
-0.0233483445,
-0.0012515245,
-0.043410521,
-0.0299500264,
-0.0112657556,
-0.0490477942,
-0.0207955856,
0.0138642192,
0.0120252948,
0.0573858842,
0.0229187291,
-0.0082524857,
0.0189661961,
-0.0464287512,
0.0044876831,
-0.0085129831,
0.0646750182,
-0.00330994,
0.0351452492,
-0.0584708564,
0.0347215682,
0.0242906827,
-0.0235339589,
0.0065204478,
-0.0104331682,
0.0022422713,
-0.0360738784,
-0.0283568054,
0.0203996971,
0.0136130508,
0.0534163639,
0.0668476149,
-0.0455869026,
-0.0470863767,
-0.023067981,
0.01118722,
-0.0674811751,
-0.0304701701,
-0.0472663566,
-0.0523063168,
-0.0265063308,
-0.1417794079,
-0.0245834161,
-0.0205475837,
0.016086217,
0.0159950964,
-0.0125868414,
-0.0593271889,
-0.0538107827,
-0.0285602715,
-0.0242279004,
0.0124983853,
0.0560467429,
-0.0079846187,
0.0172253717,
-0.0407388248,
-0.0349288024,
0.0245378669,
-0.0036092135,
-0.0319605097,
-0.0529516116,
0.0257834177,
0.0172175933,
0.0126865851,
-0.0175058153,
0.0048644659,
-0.0506366566,
0.0328109041,
0.0429776236,
0.0184765588,
0.082706593,
0.0386021957,
0.0430755019,
0.0408808962,
0.0520199835,
-0.0024679881,
0.0274456553,
0.0579341799,
0.030385904,
0.0109226117,
0.0101873735,
0.0362302549,
0.0170528647,
-0.0127066793,
-0.0067632119,
0.0081400406,
-0.0171567332,
0.0008286914,
-0.0612681434,
-0.0314118676,
-0.0244057104,
-0.0042978246,
0.0198637638,
0.0717594475,
-0.0522305071,
0.0026083195,
-0.0295316651,
-0.0063560624,
-0.0534701161,
0.0122113405,
0.035310939,
0.0392846726,
0.0087780003,
0.0501307696,
-0.0290971044,
0.0115604317,
-0.0233331006,
0.0133473752,
0.0099801812,
-0.0027413049,
0.0455211699,
-0.0162887983,
-0.0411643721,
0.0600066893,
-0.0536571257,
0.0506093502,
-0.013076853,
-0.0243089292,
0.0069413064,
-0.0169512071,
0.1004456654,
-0.0176213719,
0.0027073342,
0.0020027615,
0.0702379942,
0.0068052872,
-0.0254055094,
-0.0391997546,
0.0088953627,
-0.007902083,
-0.0048550563,
0.0656785816,
-0.069214724,
0.007706082,
0.0075297579,
-0.0022229068,
-0.0203292798,
-0.0159272123,
0.0231330581,
0.0251668729,
0.03064139,
-0.0515415259,
-0.0541558936,
-0.0260509271,
0.0675819591,
-0.020898452,
0.037948411,
-0.015772149,
0.0082452176,
0.046534121,
-0.0039730174,
0.0020711427,
-0.0211442281,
0.0465263315,
0.0093976427,
-0.0080024116,
-0.0443302952,
-6.053668439e-33,
0.0146928374,
-0.0149762696,
-0.033422038,
0.0437595546,
-0.0638673231,
0.0012746315,
-0.0469925515,
0.0268524904,
0.0413273349,
0.051855877,
-0.01425594,
-0.0043460852,
-0.0143820355,
0.0101228924,
-0.0092980256,
0.0294533409,
0.0485413224,
0.0290350989,
-0.0654353648,
-0.007133604,
0.0570538007,
-0.0048384196,
0.0429880023,
-0.0785488337,
0.008808285,
-0.0391778499,
-0.0622962266,
-0.0304631535,
0.0272807702,
0.006450071,
0.0097310748,
0.0265427586,
0.0283944532,
0.0075104977,
-0.0205746163,
0.0656031966,
0.0098636849,
-0.0346615091,
0.0453969799,
-0.004485731,
-0.0276200864,
-0.0659552664,
0.0609177575,
-0.0070886463,
-0.0299153067,
-0.0024840045,
0.0456470624,
-0.0171322022,
0.0101823444,
-0.0511999466,
-0.0786012933,
0.0225215051,
-0.0044150297,
-0.020502679,
-0.0024924825,
0.0319287255,
-0.0136997085,
0.0301076118,
-0.0294139497,
0.0378143154,
-0.1061090529,
0.0013798262,
-0.0431467518,
0.0032981799,
0.0275382549,
0.0632459819,
-0.0186608583,
0.0822366551,
-0.0305011198,
0.0085304789,
0.0181800462,
0.0159220789,
0.0435691141,
0.0949667022,
0.0231136847,
-0.0179932285,
0.007173466,
0.0334253758,
-0.0062722834,
-0.026941143,
0.0284330864,
0.0585788228,
-0.0352382474,
-0.041359555,
-0.0250123013,
-0.0292961039,
-0.0254309159,
-0.0051238462,
0.001337966,
-0.0099148881,
-0.0250305366,
-0.0475586988,
-0.030457234,
-0.0123320688,
0.0049449573,
-0.0184118263,
-0.0698384792,
0.0826255605,
0.0018477819,
-0.0222934727,
0.0125912633,
0.030925544,
0.0475624576,
0.0514991507,
0.0188302994,
-0.0317898765,
0.0947685167,
0.03503979,
-0.059122026,
-0.0165477935,
-0.0015683812,
0.0192348231,
-0.004551833,
-0.061647404,
0.0055617215,
0.0360657126,
0.0037765396,
-0.0116317505,
0.0547597222,
0.0159499981,
-0.0421869121,
-0.0269847158,
0.0159566812,
0.0094662327,
-0.0315933675,
-0.0052752318,
0.0068658264,
-0.0408829413,
0.0267861076,
-0.0509774536,
-0.0302506406,
-0.0140350144,
2.837e-7,
0.0443213135,
0.0622285418,
0.0209521372,
-0.0243028495,
0.0177841391,
0.0409767367,
0.0258454792,
0.0187736303,
0.0122746658,
-0.0113263419,
0.0448563546,
-0.0065246476,
0.0616700538,
-0.0198780764,
-0.0908892527,
0.0394830108,
-0.0823585838,
0.0040158187,
-0.0176180676,
-0.0099144531,
0.0772080123,
-0.0115494942,
0.040721789,
-0.0239703506,
0.0143309822,
-0.013392237,
0.0480340943,
-0.0648449361,
0.0172575973,
-0.0007898829,
-0.0062141521,
-0.0427104682,
0.0236536767,
0.0018495602,
-0.0066479314,
-0.0313620754,
0.0429849736,
0.0544712543,
0.0151020326,
0.0013949445,
0.0127238464,
-0.0031045806,
0.0027465846,
-0.0670108572,
0.0447649844,
0.0184585303,
-0.0287829693,
-0.0505384803,
-0.0302731246,
0.0291036926,
0.0481665321,
-0.0022025162,
-0.0585883819,
0.0331290141,
0.0144388992,
0.0303315092,
-0.0310310051,
-0.0614459813,
-0.0603452809,
0.0077913455,
-0.0093517443,
-0.0142644858,
-0.0324991308,
0.0280608926,
0.0141412113,
-0.0434024446,
0.0155084925,
2.484821029e-34,
0.0550243482,
-0.0342534371,
0.0505467132,
-0.0038404646,
0.0148546631,
0.0281237345,
-0.002587511,
0.0267519727,
0.0125838742,
-0.0702208206,
-0.0046622646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14751v1 | DialogVCS: Robust Natural Language Understanding in Dialogue System Upgrade | 2023-05-24T05:53:38 | 2023-05-24T05:53:38 | Zefan Cai, Xin Zheng, Tianyu Liu, Xu Wang, Haoran Meng, Jiaqi Han, Gang Yuan, Binghuai Lin, Baobao Chang, Yunbo Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the constant updates of the product dialogue systems, we need to retrain
the natural language understanding (NLU) model as new data from the real users
would be merged into the existent data accumulated in the last updates. Within
the newly added data, new intents would emerge and might have semantic
entanglement with the existing intents, e.g. new intents that are semantically
too specific or generic are actually subset or superset of some existing
intents in the semantic space, thus impairing the robustness of the NLU model.
As the first attempt to solve this problem, we setup a new benchmark consisting
of 4 Dialogue Version Control dataSets (DialogVCS). We formulate the intent
detection with imperfect data in the system update as a multi-label
classification task with positive but unlabeled intents, which asks the models
to recognize all the proper intents, including the ones with semantic
entanglement, in the inference. We also propose comprehensive baseline models
and conduct in-depth analyses for the benchmark, showing that the semantically
entangled intents can be effectively recognized with an automatic workflow. | [
0.0672338456,
0.047383368,
-0.0348753259,
0.0607195646,
-0.0308667626,
0.0021281668,
-0.0189264212,
-0.0037174658,
0.0314919241,
-0.070304513,
-0.0240540076,
-0.0274722036,
-0.0148862163,
0.060141664,
-0.0230241977,
-0.0315134414,
0.0811630264,
-0.0191500727,
-0.0048863804,
0.0106319375,
-0.0062299976,
0.0007887589,
-0.0006986694,
0.0296559166,
0.0228188746,
-0.0334688574,
-0.0377442874,
0.0209357124,
-0.0052403328,
-0.0089419764,
0.0103784585,
0.0535417609,
0.0320604332,
0.0380932465,
0.0000019276,
-0.0972713381,
0.0014154664,
-0.0317901,
-0.1061157808,
-0.0039902083,
0.0153212687,
0.0091810916,
0.0118934158,
0.0236176923,
-0.0127963098,
0.0209658332,
0.0026972976,
0.0601381212,
0.0813307017,
0.0594470873,
-0.0132539151,
-0.0217987373,
0.0001490806,
-0.0099250767,
0.0077996873,
-0.1130668893,
0.0254880879,
0.0263059549,
-0.0103583075,
0.0394038446,
0.0134275239,
0.0241548605,
0.0028996747,
-0.0284610204,
-0.0309933592,
0.0036478259,
0.0383681431,
-0.0258573983,
-0.0356695279,
0.0932399258,
0.0209335256,
0.0315634869,
-0.023001045,
-0.0207814369,
0.0124577861,
-0.0567279197,
-0.0151774688,
-0.0470173694,
-0.0156348683,
-0.0299966484,
0.0019806977,
-0.0149319861,
0.0130124222,
0.016496053,
-0.0153680257,
0.0360136591,
-0.0019308424,
-0.0244194251,
0.0179133881,
-0.0455053076,
-0.0026095936,
-0.0793046206,
0.0075328057,
0.040763516,
-0.060455434,
0.044558797,
-0.0403085873,
0.0118485726,
0.0146012679,
-0.0608233996,
-0.0697454289,
0.0395564027,
-0.0194785725,
0.0879578739,
0.0118775079,
0.0489088558,
0.0083885035,
0.0115379132,
-0.0380253196,
-0.0198681559,
-0.0749531388,
-0.0014603476,
-0.089575015,
0.0411113128,
-0.0677999854,
-0.0229280218,
-0.0100172441,
0.0352666602,
0.0062476806,
0.0282044876,
-0.0217814669,
0.0154854534,
-0.0493737422,
-0.0068329526,
-0.0530480817,
0.0461404733,
-0.0139343766,
0.0241601411,
-0.0204944257,
-0.0469266698,
-0.0097344415,
0.0113968616,
-0.0084512196,
-0.0218716562,
-0.0168004893,
0.0405970216,
-0.0238995887,
-0.0553602651,
-0.0437003449,
-0.0460660942,
-0.0226536542,
-0.0211490728,
-0.05236746,
0.0013037805,
0.0263804365,
-0.021924803,
-0.012461598,
-0.0384716392,
-0.0095727937,
-0.0167440549,
-0.0156787485,
0.1009499207,
-0.0408934839,
-0.0076216087,
0.0321634747,
0.014281637,
-0.021776028,
0.0640135258,
0.0101966253,
0.011046946,
0.031951692,
0.0080418205,
0.0057584569,
0.0042038192,
-0.020527225,
0.0129331779,
0.0087492624,
0.0522532016,
-0.0099960165,
0.0156086907,
-0.0139776487,
0.0418554395,
-0.0365641378,
-0.0497897081,
0.0563200042,
0.0066117779,
-0.0111233238,
-0.020793533,
-0.0307813175,
0.0579879992,
-0.0078906221,
-0.0040367409,
-0.0126500772,
-0.0034894727,
-0.0175592396,
-0.0163190458,
-0.0074936119,
-0.047621876,
-0.0324129276,
-0.08116965,
-0.0083846562,
-0.0138359005,
0.0297660865,
-0.0254274625,
0.048528377,
0.0096838977,
-0.042443376,
-0.0001935696,
0.0096327793,
-0.0104979863,
-0.0133266384,
-0.0491158627,
0.0166256353,
0.0808539987,
0.0396608263,
-0.0285753515,
-0.0493207537,
-0.0563311242,
-0.0385003462,
0.0251388811,
0.0426993594,
-0.0436405465,
0.0387706719,
-0.0423383601,
-0.0353060551,
-0.024846375,
-0.0003644052,
0.023750145,
-0.0505878739,
-0.0298098288,
0.0040626391,
0.0315404646,
0.0148780085,
0.0096373782,
0.0118808262,
0.0079043042,
0.0421171859,
0.0081568789,
0.0721580759,
0.0429178737,
0.0023286399,
-0.0349508636,
0.0249012765,
-0.0101603298,
-0.0553117692,
0.0411337838,
-0.0203454308,
-0.0708149746,
0.0479702353,
0.0514517836,
-0.0375369936,
-0.0255161338,
-0.0534633659,
-0.0673923939,
0.0091326088,
-0.0271587409,
0.0131298918,
-0.0559567958,
0.0088407369,
-0.0093051735,
-0.0090402905,
-0.0323523879,
0.0378432237,
0.0116340546,
-0.0245519802,
0.0362315848,
0.0532472618,
0.0735598654,
-0.0156168453,
-0.0145817017,
0.0457349904,
-0.0271331184,
0.0008779356,
-0.0026403824,
-0.0086316876,
-0.0238020942,
-0.0081995511,
-0.0858838335,
-0.0276291259,
-0.0171526838,
-0.0031575635,
0.0225583836,
0.0210957061,
0.0134984264,
-0.0447290801,
0.0077813542,
0.0320475288,
0.0117599042,
0.0095885526,
0.050349921,
0.0294712819,
-0.0181935914,
-0.0387060121,
0.0383025371,
-0.0026229613,
0.0054166489,
0.0093916673,
-0.0219379738,
-0.0929955095,
-0.0082699228,
-0.0420789905,
0.0365744382,
-0.0269285012,
-0.0326214768,
-0.0117134685,
0.0400122143,
0.0182544272,
0.0358720459,
0.021335667,
0.0284696035,
0.0265418254,
0.0170440469,
-0.0443485864,
0.0545001477,
-0.0108533734,
-0.0345377438,
-0.0748013705,
0.0193370413,
0.0397517122,
0.0465461016,
0.0169465672,
0.0128592486,
-0.0648177341,
-0.0320951156,
-0.0158632956,
-0.0348535441,
-0.0486451574,
-0.023428876,
-0.0364919379,
0.0673256889,
-0.0114189051,
-0.0442843921,
0.0905738249,
-0.020954553,
-0.0277410112,
-0.0837782845,
-0.028991174,
-0.0214465316,
0.079792507,
-0.0341324434,
0.0272490755,
0.0355442129,
-0.0428178273,
-0.0291433986,
-0.014445195,
-0.0120883081,
-0.0210113786,
0.0804301724,
-0.0554643422,
0.034074083,
-0.0001735221,
-0.0333910435,
-0.0622488558,
-0.0437289476,
-0.0161474086,
-0.0011010848,
0.0193109941,
-0.002636902,
0.0018063047,
0.0104299858,
-0.008893121,
0.0858922899,
0.0114422273,
-0.0132861715,
-0.041402895,
0.0160112232,
0.0539681278,
0.0253248569,
-0.0188901108,
-0.000526897,
0.0522160903,
0.0259886254,
0.0119230608,
-0.0345181488,
-0.0196990296,
-0.0065045515,
0.0015018666,
0.0044646603,
0.0184652768,
0.0144256903,
0.0550308637,
-0.0119110635,
0.0021724731,
0.1244942173,
0.0316775069,
-0.0180681031,
-0.008347366,
-0.0176040102,
-0.0036594945,
0.0450351499,
0.0162110887,
-0.0886992738,
-0.057186611,
0.009645137,
0.0282484889,
0.028613979,
0.0023694499,
-0.0169723686,
-0.0792760551,
-0.002178194,
-0.0334808379,
-0.0323869996,
-0.0080817016,
-0.0200928655,
0.0188073143,
-0.0048249811,
0.0368332006,
0.0090591991,
0.0432375781,
-0.0361464843,
0.0124240378,
-0.0095015988,
-0.0326768421,
0.037535321,
0.017996138,
0.0588040501,
0.0251304395,
0.0283785276,
0.0373548903,
-0.0159090254,
0.0339947343,
-0.0343383737,
0.0074990969,
-0.0166249499,
0.0677943006,
0.006598223,
0.0015273327,
0.0339372605,
0.0041296599,
-0.0343532711,
-0.0038907665,
0.0259435885,
0.0100846197,
-0.0353270844,
0.0008396485,
0.0157203339,
-0.0035528291,
0.0307939034,
0.0729720965,
0.0053492016,
-0.0399237983,
-0.0089423964,
-0.0249411557,
0.0127857123,
0.0133443233,
0.0303556453,
-0.0044858488,
-0.0216903985,
-0.0131844385,
-0.0682222545,
-0.0554684959,
-0.007981942,
0.0271623451,
0.0263970736,
0.008037949,
0.0390603989,
0.0314000286,
0.0100514814,
-0.0157019291,
-0.0098489886,
0.0225170627,
-0.0372891612,
-0.0069409972,
0.0393915474,
-0.0019263809,
-0.0505928621,
0.0431611054,
-0.0570404977,
-0.05827149,
-0.024157906,
-0.0013909171,
0.0290404409,
0.0672790706,
-0.0394735038,
-0.0190891027,
-0.060698133,
0.0090065552,
0.0116561642,
-0.0126633123,
0.0391559005,
0.0783232823,
-0.0334142894,
0.0344155803,
-0.0560298078,
-0.0011107454,
-0.0070721931,
0.0216398574,
-0.0582271442,
-0.1154945716,
0.0194915496,
0.0033803496,
0.0228825994,
0.0387558378,
0.0087535977,
-0.0217256937,
0.0622130372,
0.0473849997,
-0.0358303115,
-0.0214300752,
-0.0093731703,
-0.0109008467,
-0.0503173284,
0.0054923296,
0.0017216385,
-0.0182992779,
0.0486261994,
0.0175908785,
-0.0599135421,
0.0383780003,
0.0392942578,
-0.0090243435,
-0.0233795345,
-0.0210773721,
0.0275616199,
0.0217554234,
0.024742743,
0.0038390378,
0.1002036035,
0.0298015811,
-0.0179274622,
0.0049089207,
0.0169354752,
-0.0694503933,
-0.0408357717,
0.0080287345,
0.0007693218,
0.0125025455,
0.0299519394,
0.0405701287,
-0.022103576,
0.0090534352,
-0.0238963142,
0.0609920658,
-0.0086326376,
-0.0222383328,
0.0494553261,
0.0093485033,
-0.0228497982,
0.0302431602,
0.0330934674,
-0.0246130861,
0.0621683374,
-0.035272561,
0.0241283625,
-0.0748796985,
-0.0269762836,
-0.0012959628,
0.0537111349,
-0.0046832077,
0.0372940078,
-0.0427759625,
-0.0166557096,
0.0087235766,
0.0053847027,
0.0243117809,
0.0081681469,
0.051751975,
0.060605932,
0.0179516785,
-0.04016646,
-0.0134547884,
-0.0227400586,
0.0186886098,
0.0232667048,
-0.0685466602,
-5.474948693e-33,
-0.022223331,
-0.0046843817,
-0.007565103,
-0.0109950639,
0.0045825965,
-0.0209318977,
-0.0474593826,
-0.0276102964,
-0.0335358046,
-0.022573879,
0.0078983204,
0.0277946442,
0.0115862479,
0.0016252563,
-0.0049056397,
-0.0429611132,
0.0991883129,
-0.0088706436,
0.0053046537,
0.0465323105,
0.0772873685,
0.0069129565,
0.0455291495,
-0.0846853331,
0.0266847629,
0.0172977392,
0.0239700992,
0.0799935013,
0.0015527034,
0.0418305695,
-0.0051998124,
0.0425398573,
0.0106844911,
-0.0333121568,
-0.0082243299,
-0.0207967423,
-0.0345806517,
-0.0239728019,
0.0108022178,
0.0153213516,
-0.0136492122,
0.0187614039,
0.0401560515,
0.0093018999,
-0.0055172783,
0.0147505729,
0.021087978,
-0.0082284212,
-0.0200189985,
0.0042431592,
-0.047385402,
0.0035387289,
-0.0367843956,
-0.0403788015,
-0.0275062323,
0.051998008,
0.0246952195,
-0.0155837452,
-0.0587177053,
-0.0157278907,
-0.0083436044,
-0.0027555737,
0.048960086,
0.0132578006,
-0.0100019621,
0.0400321223,
0.0064587248,
0.0046010157,
-0.0176491737,
-0.0171081666,
0.0013834203,
0.0461491123,
0.0283492599,
0.0446011126,
0.0394685715,
-0.0200535674,
-0.037584912,
0.0052524377,
0.02944085,
0.0392039903,
-0.0185088255,
0.0552138947,
-0.0243841056,
-0.0086904429,
-0.0401705056,
0.0106559256,
-0.0370552875,
-0.0157596599,
0.0348678119,
0.013673313,
0.0035532806,
0.0039965389,
0.0411662869,
-0.0245486218,
-0.0388346575,
0.0152829019,
0.0093741044,
0.0013059416,
0.0199593231,
0.0158988908,
-0.0142793423,
-0.0478332005,
0.0623676926,
0.041872751,
0.02109796,
-0.0200280249,
0.0091246841,
-0.0252579711,
-0.0494563319,
0.0063988375,
-0.0325080268,
0.0328127779,
-0.0777058005,
0.0307139866,
0.0271138549,
0.0175801869,
-0.0199556872,
0.1072249115,
-0.021920206,
-0.0194008946,
-0.0755096376,
-0.0154087869,
0.0321987607,
0.0088459216,
-0.008230852,
-0.0085870158,
0.032386031,
-0.0071625835,
0.0100383526,
-0.0325690061,
0.0138615193,
0.0034664485,
2.668e-7,
-0.0012249199,
0.0366452336,
0.0357062705,
0.0012760458,
0.0460573211,
0.0769197568,
-0.0245730113,
0.023667099,
0.0082726022,
-0.044956211,
0.0262729973,
-0.0070184013,
0.0274327509,
0.0280574802,
-0.0699477792,
-0.0226647984,
-0.0754157007,
-0.0334894955,
-0.0668963566,
0.027868446,
0.1393823773,
0.0894490182,
0.0198793579,
-0.0066462797,
0.0130928438,
-0.0422604755,
0.0189407524,
-0.0100862263,
0.0234536882,
0.0204790588,
0.0327643938,
0.0167287122,
0.0197902713,
0.0342854634,
0.0160730872,
0.0340599902,
-0.0179988332,
0.0690118894,
-0.0214474052,
-0.0316278823,
-0.0488943979,
0.0179291498,
-0.0051994468,
-0.0270032566,
0.0602207668,
-0.0464083888,
-0.0106341764,
-0.0246946514,
0.0046790857,
-0.0072020241,
0.0039822054,
0.0214335192,
-0.0010361201,
0.0114644868,
-0.0144252004,
-0.0152498335,
0.0044203023,
-0.0951854959,
0.0342940614,
-0.0319224894,
-0.0424290486,
-0.0273994822,
-0.0384832658,
0.0329671986,
0.0267704446,
-0.0256366897,
0.0238813162,
1.919362099e-34,
0.0325321332,
-0.019129388,
0.0085610067,
0.0272966046,
0.0262657646,
0.0032317243,
0.0159555171,
-0.008503912,
0.0241190325,
-0.062582463,
-0.0073233154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14750v1 | Mastering the ABCDs of Complex Questions: Answer-Based Claim Decomposition for Fine-grained Self-Evaluation | 2023-05-24T05:53:11 | 2023-05-24T05:53:11 | Nishant Balepur, Jie Huang, Samraj Moorjani, Hari Sundaram, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | When answering complex questions, large language models (LLMs) may produce
answers that do not satisfy all criteria of the question. While existing
self-evaluation techniques aim to detect if such answers are correct, these
techniques are unable to determine which criteria of the question are satisfied
by the generated answers. To address this issue, we propose answer-based claim
decomposition (ABCD), a prompting strategy that decomposes questions into a
series of true/false claims that can be used to verify which criteria of the
input question an answer satisfies. Using the decomposed ABCD claims, we
perform fine-grained self-evaluation. Through preliminary experiments on three
datasets, including a newly-collected challenge dataset ObscureQA, we find that
GPT-3.5 has some ability to determine to what extent its answer satisfies the
criteria of the input question, and can give insights into the errors and
knowledge gaps of the model. | [
0.0436663516,
0.0522574186,
-0.0155198025,
0.0568801947,
-0.0516678691,
0.0212798342,
-0.0242498685,
-0.0134591125,
0.0367138125,
-0.0544072464,
0.0126672052,
-0.0095751658,
-0.0082289614,
-0.0076070554,
0.026805399,
-0.0334610231,
0.0577673577,
-0.0139412712,
0.0419219658,
-0.0370241366,
0.0053223432,
0.0098536182,
-0.011851917,
0.014440137,
-0.0233885534,
-0.0496325567,
-0.0055779172,
-0.0257718693,
-0.0084673865,
-0.0177493263,
0.0116503267,
0.0876522735,
-0.0080126459,
0.0549500696,
0.0000019453,
-0.0740736425,
0.0133387018,
0.0145623665,
-0.0463190265,
0.0754969046,
-0.0138697727,
0.0665022135,
0.016909102,
0.0371177681,
-0.0479058102,
-0.0450008214,
-0.0016220546,
0.0630318895,
0.0993783623,
0.0630539209,
0.0214676205,
-0.0322094262,
0.0083351741,
-0.0070321076,
0.010628568,
-0.0497962199,
0.0171457753,
0.0074669006,
0.0090336287,
0.0198603719,
-0.0159825701,
0.0114965811,
0.0447030738,
0.0078819795,
-0.040269915,
0.0131420186,
-0.0435210764,
-0.0018056979,
0.0135073001,
0.0269557312,
0.0439557619,
-0.0614386015,
-0.0224033389,
-0.0065275705,
0.0369292311,
0.0424670689,
-0.0281645823,
0.0333043225,
0.0088166995,
-0.0131501518,
0.0374780037,
0.0357499532,
-0.0090769744,
-0.0010644122,
-0.0295096487,
0.1014619544,
0.0002031014,
-0.0763538182,
-0.0144271683,
-0.0006171266,
-0.0177667234,
-0.0886381865,
-0.0065250858,
0.0428056195,
0.0051014279,
0.0044250125,
-0.0240871757,
-0.0019235235,
0.077834785,
-0.0282378271,
-0.007259116,
-0.0040120794,
-0.0310929939,
0.0415435247,
-0.0265635047,
0.0787230879,
-0.0016949159,
-0.0404736809,
-0.0420536734,
-0.0239401925,
-0.0193255618,
-0.036226064,
-0.0576837659,
0.0741256177,
-0.0147806434,
0.0294692218,
-0.0309931878,
-0.0086612888,
-0.0378888659,
0.0278574005,
0.0003797352,
0.015665032,
0.0214482918,
-0.022136325,
-0.0646704137,
0.0392845944,
-0.0533871949,
0.0213145781,
-0.0101419408,
-0.0450162776,
-0.0151219238,
0.0106261689,
0.0102582853,
-0.0073452387,
0.0086185262,
0.0085194539,
0.0003688732,
-0.0120337503,
-0.0157914888,
-0.0514683537,
-0.026603166,
-0.0571347401,
-0.0335190333,
-0.081357047,
0.0304802563,
0.0030851006,
-0.0095433518,
-0.003681045,
0.0076138168,
0.0523533151,
-0.0027243397,
0.0314592347,
0.0121470783,
0.0351876207,
0.0497355089,
0.023066489,
0.0235015973,
0.0361783653,
0.0224521253,
0.0424745008,
0.0318864211,
-0.0214772653,
0.0477111563,
0.0119205257,
0.0501796566,
0.0126515226,
0.0550310388,
0.064598687,
-0.0165455025,
0.009214987,
-0.0264180843,
0.0522823557,
-0.0064838408,
-0.0362298191,
0.055078499,
0.0652037114,
-0.0005525348,
-0.007852003,
0.026498707,
0.0031362907,
0.0607170314,
0.0587444976,
-0.0352644697,
0.0059987134,
-0.0744786635,
-0.019503979,
0.0231279004,
0.0379463099,
-0.0011557337,
-0.0699428916,
-0.0018080559,
0.0299316738,
-0.0037796032,
0.0513757728,
0.0153960362,
0.0136075765,
-0.0017158055,
0.0065582916,
0.004389436,
-0.0532893986,
0.0133512989,
-0.070924446,
0.0621660985,
-0.0279049221,
0.051083833,
-0.0207852647,
-0.0104082096,
-0.0056460118,
0.0161605328,
0.0197587777,
0.0854034796,
-0.0189214386,
-0.0285553522,
0.0073302942,
-0.0244198013,
-0.0134164821,
0.021579409,
-0.0507208854,
0.0290855858,
-0.0137224775,
0.0160669256,
-0.0586976893,
-0.0028368211,
0.0235018265,
0.0162043106,
-0.0520846397,
0.0225245114,
0.0096560251,
0.0151875652,
0.0346472152,
0.0104471184,
0.0294269379,
0.0084299333,
-0.0053257202,
-0.0465778969,
-0.0296893064,
0.0002097789,
-0.0512479432,
0.0039959899,
-0.03513344,
-0.0393965878,
0.043879021,
-0.0315234251,
-0.0571569614,
-0.008889107,
-0.0358457454,
-0.0124000134,
-0.0636810213,
-0.0158516504,
0.0088528069,
-0.0164163653,
-0.0473550893,
0.0650010258,
0.0135556143,
0.0319175944,
-0.015881015,
-0.0049853208,
0.0363464989,
-0.0248110928,
-0.0260399543,
-0.0180396214,
-0.0140079251,
0.0165957995,
0.0569119118,
-0.0068796766,
-0.0383593291,
-0.0051932195,
-0.078344211,
0.0012072443,
-0.0184108652,
0.0335159302,
0.026413817,
-0.0084679835,
-0.0025858777,
-0.0164099,
-0.0753275156,
-0.0410433672,
0.0279185046,
0.0084205149,
0.0438380539,
-0.0108391689,
0.0476150438,
-0.0166537054,
-0.0044820108,
-0.0371916033,
0.0171778556,
0.0027455329,
0.0247082394,
-0.0336034,
-0.0044704094,
-0.0468357243,
0.0292539261,
0.0223739371,
-0.032460086,
0.0135205071,
0.0080107115,
-0.0149436649,
0.0225064084,
0.0202260856,
0.0075433594,
0.029970374,
0.0029928042,
-0.056797877,
0.0360838026,
-0.0218804963,
0.0021738943,
0.0069863717,
-0.0729312226,
0.0535204038,
0.0537870824,
0.0353938788,
-0.0296962094,
-0.0795561448,
0.0175974425,
-0.0621828921,
-0.0212327279,
-0.0080528278,
0.0112479664,
-0.0057024537,
0.0533546656,
0.002879075,
-0.0417656042,
0.085812673,
-0.0479751192,
-0.0112361992,
-0.0343864299,
-0.0034879115,
-0.045172371,
0.0875227898,
0.0080723111,
0.0100763403,
0.0495502539,
-0.0050162673,
-0.0392542332,
-0.0213693641,
0.0172618758,
-0.0532091297,
0.0235426314,
-0.0326069072,
0.0064866678,
-0.0090703694,
-0.0454247147,
-0.0360364653,
-0.0844424143,
0.0261112098,
-0.0059110238,
-0.0537817627,
-0.0057316804,
0.0067520444,
-0.0263601709,
0.014465766,
0.0215611439,
-0.0264390577,
0.0012860721,
-0.0172601398,
0.0731525272,
0.0750789195,
0.0579144768,
0.0499666929,
0.0016760525,
0.0194676891,
0.0674216226,
-0.0000435655,
0.0556453764,
0.0187929142,
-0.0298074204,
0.0148236174,
-0.0337182768,
-0.0094254361,
0.0122428238,
0.0487341061,
-0.071573548,
-0.0093326559,
0.1080708206,
0.045480866,
0.0159117822,
0.0072797043,
-0.0231451932,
0.0148452213,
0.0150590707,
0.0450573042,
-0.1130940393,
-0.0057625351,
-0.0210201014,
0.0034572401,
-0.0425171107,
-0.0026183748,
0.0006072812,
-0.1350200027,
0.0737146065,
-0.001434295,
-0.0163714737,
-0.0077403421,
-0.0371551067,
0.0088155027,
0.0158024561,
-0.0071418476,
0.0341929235,
0.0018589377,
0.0080305515,
0.0170894023,
-0.0598478727,
-0.0011455851,
0.0549314804,
0.0120202806,
0.0465343557,
0.0397217423,
0.0031719985,
-0.0279902108,
-0.0298424512,
-0.0000621637,
-0.0667566136,
-0.0375746377,
-0.0041988054,
0.0080558332,
0.0212373119,
-0.0055034999,
-0.0219045635,
0.0141982716,
-0.0208631456,
-0.0058435085,
0.0610609278,
0.121292986,
-0.044411134,
-0.0491941944,
-0.0109278588,
0.0055763922,
-0.0222132076,
0.0915722251,
0.0406369083,
-0.0075382097,
-0.051234059,
-0.0310433097,
-0.0251104906,
-0.039936617,
-0.0421720706,
0.0519586243,
0.0720042735,
0.0105941147,
-0.0766407922,
-0.066846244,
0.0223705657,
-0.0062381979,
-0.0371316187,
0.0137105817,
0.0185390934,
0.0057754433,
-0.0433728248,
0.0291974004,
-0.0407749452,
0.0263401866,
-0.0249182377,
0.0030988338,
0.0405447483,
-0.0249921326,
-0.0105394302,
0.0213251617,
-0.035528522,
-0.0347437151,
-0.013035465,
0.0405156612,
0.0181709286,
0.0113475323,
-0.033887811,
-0.0733819827,
0.0290334113,
0.0086032134,
-0.0129238125,
0.0360437743,
0.0151837589,
-0.0300036334,
-0.0267357305,
0.0378888547,
0.0026298924,
0.0348972306,
-0.0104733929,
0.0326188989,
-0.0273911245,
-0.0513320453,
0.0674042106,
0.0513136759,
0.0176718086,
0.0226599369,
0.0426835343,
-0.0222754758,
0.0173627287,
-0.029926002,
-0.0319796316,
-0.0335798636,
0.0014978766,
0.0071061114,
-0.0423570015,
0.0065254774,
-0.0327331237,
-0.0373260453,
0.0181346685,
-0.0773224682,
0.0069184359,
0.0299096964,
0.0201955661,
-0.0104939025,
-0.0344847441,
-0.008402409,
-0.013969413,
-0.0019127036,
0.0402885526,
-0.0011114761,
0.0655175522,
0.0122873178,
0.0197031256,
0.0128452843,
0.0155488392,
-0.0540890172,
-0.0496129952,
-0.0309503749,
0.024843799,
-0.0041584857,
0.0269841813,
0.0224334951,
-0.0186803322,
-0.0178396683,
-0.007330135,
-0.0166315921,
-0.0005499302,
-0.0126999514,
0.0571101382,
0.0307744816,
-0.031332761,
-0.0175589602,
0.0561483167,
0.0180376321,
0.0515528768,
0.0193139035,
0.0070087323,
-0.0322996452,
-0.075836502,
-0.029119201,
0.0145041933,
-0.0204341393,
0.0147756832,
-0.0913740471,
-0.066154778,
-0.0271030422,
0.0495888665,
0.0199328996,
-0.0036954386,
0.0265191905,
0.0488063321,
0.0083199749,
-0.0563366488,
-0.0497794859,
0.0416593626,
-0.0291611999,
-0.011646118,
0.0101373922,
-6.531048083e-33,
-0.0334999748,
-0.0544157848,
0.0378846936,
-0.0267473161,
0.0149230184,
-0.0007825171,
-0.0213720873,
-0.0066539291,
-0.0303746853,
0.0407250337,
-0.0222810805,
0.0131459069,
-0.0027137173,
0.0473626144,
0.0099252099,
-0.015923718,
0.0325484313,
-0.0166043434,
-0.0545375049,
0.0319128819,
0.0059791338,
-0.0348291956,
0.0386416428,
-0.0451939031,
0.0404876173,
-0.0128700742,
-0.0332684144,
0.0353397205,
-0.0927247554,
0.056351658,
-0.0278772563,
0.0295497552,
0.0325506851,
-0.0294123422,
0.019652633,
0.0280216467,
-0.0751951337,
-0.0472412147,
0.0490514226,
-0.0318561047,
-0.0637541115,
-0.0039744708,
0.0182614774,
-0.0104586389,
-0.0073029692,
-0.0031665203,
0.0042839996,
-0.0082953665,
0.0441405214,
-0.0336040333,
-0.0252169613,
0.0298115872,
-0.0064325761,
-0.0280545168,
-0.0136872483,
0.0474248081,
-0.0063812109,
0.0153882224,
-0.007551956,
0.0098837754,
0.0141322734,
0.0213737246,
0.0259110387,
-0.0411501452,
-0.0235271715,
0.0345250219,
0.003506229,
0.0063004731,
-0.0195871238,
0.0030587176,
-0.0081603145,
0.0252950285,
0.0999645218,
0.0361473039,
0.009110447,
0.0089448802,
-0.0660059825,
0.0368912704,
-0.0070584305,
-0.0125805922,
-0.0023887909,
-0.0552539118,
-0.029059954,
-0.0172729064,
-0.0781796798,
0.0040769433,
-0.0474075861,
0.036168687,
0.0288784876,
0.0105761075,
-0.0398292989,
0.0081715211,
0.0181083158,
-0.0437496379,
-0.0036590504,
-0.0317230225,
-0.0081093805,
0.0125293797,
0.0225741249,
0.0607505701,
-0.0225604232,
0.0623400137,
-0.0068638208,
-0.0232014079,
0.0163780935,
0.0204410106,
0.0129237222,
0.0148265436,
-0.0596476719,
0.0221661758,
-0.0183690302,
0.0366275124,
-0.0347752236,
-0.0314415209,
0.0259316545,
0.0258282833,
-0.0002812952,
0.0079733264,
-0.0114287315,
-0.0179534554,
-0.0738586262,
0.0272732507,
-0.0006776094,
0.0028244376,
-0.0029752916,
0.0101977019,
-0.0002029256,
0.0226672366,
0.0133462138,
-0.0193804502,
0.0123882489,
0.0287668779,
2.534e-7,
0.0432817824,
0.0469484851,
-0.0043597952,
0.042434644,
0.0175770018,
0.0457942896,
0.0029082564,
0.0220782422,
0.0409059934,
-0.0232797656,
0.0031527611,
0.0126722716,
0.0479282476,
0.0527968146,
-0.0633568689,
0.0327000357,
-0.0304724053,
-0.0536210611,
-0.0421969928,
0.005702408,
0.0919476971,
0.0565884039,
0.0175608769,
-0.0066912468,
-0.0312961563,
-0.0158889256,
0.0554095618,
0.0154515812,
-0.0348433442,
0.0276558846,
0.0423188396,
-0.0185722131,
0.0438800827,
0.0352684595,
-0.0123407906,
0.0196544416,
-0.0066004461,
0.0717093423,
-0.0004699526,
-0.0408913419,
-0.0594101325,
-0.0256146621,
0.0223194305,
-0.073723495,
0.0775173455,
-0.0472488441,
-0.0183540508,
-0.0510975868,
-0.0111512663,
-0.0204628017,
0.0334638283,
-0.0095239338,
-0.0094234701,
0.015289587,
0.0102571901,
0.007889593,
0.0174751095,
-0.0543667749,
-0.0284970328,
0.0254351869,
-0.0348288678,
-0.0320375487,
-0.0088537009,
0.0037981928,
-0.0025192453,
-0.0796922296,
0.0025421127,
2.450439197e-34,
0.0163054951,
-0.0038583211,
0.0176467504,
-0.0178061109,
0.0418139882,
0.026585741,
-0.012825449,
0.0137186749,
0.0076641017,
-0.072836861,
-0.0269316062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14740v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14740v2 | ECHo: A Visio-Linguistic Dataset for Event Causality Inference via Human-Centric Reasoning | 2023-05-24T05:21:13 | 2023-10-23T10:35:30 | Yuxi Xie, Guanzhen Li, Min-Yen Kan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduce ECHo (Event Causality Inference via Human-Centric Reasoning), a
diagnostic dataset of event causality inference grounded in visio-linguistic
social scenarios. ECHo employs real-world human-centric deductive information
building on a television crime drama. ECHo requires the Theory-of-Mind (ToM)
ability to understand and reason about social interactions based on multimodal
information. Using ECHo, we propose a unified Chain-of-Thought (CoT) framework
to assess the reasoning capability of current AI systems. Our ToM-enhanced CoT
pipeline accommodates various large foundation models in both zero-shot and
few-shot visio-linguistic reasoning. We use this framework to scrutinize recent
large foundation models such as InstructGPT and MiniGPT-4 on three diagnostic
human-centric tasks. Further analysis demonstrates ECHo as a challenging
dataset to expose imperfections and inconsistencies in reasoning. Our data and
code are publicly available at https://github.com/YuxiXie/ECHo. | [
0.0026863674,
0.0315865092,
-0.0290076528,
0.0529759601,
-0.0521588959,
0.0317516029,
0.0252822582,
0.0071939519,
0.0212130174,
0.0014290961,
0.0212415475,
-0.0227734689,
0.0037219154,
0.0545992926,
0.0346486978,
-0.0462374762,
0.008526762,
-0.0073525184,
0.0030130621,
0.0163677763,
-0.0039096861,
0.0418813266,
-0.0289696325,
0.0148117887,
-0.0330860503,
-0.0051334454,
-0.0425616167,
0.0161812305,
0.0643622354,
-0.0402958952,
-0.0317392498,
0.044552546,
0.0469758511,
0.0203509051,
0.0000020111,
-0.0426506139,
0.0345314033,
-0.0101136975,
-0.0227879062,
-0.041196838,
-0.0596992187,
-0.0011210641,
0.0226701386,
0.0009093947,
-0.024518501,
-0.0046903836,
0.0199385602,
0.0471550561,
0.0287746247,
0.0791858956,
-0.030420322,
-0.044316534,
0.0142755844,
-0.0297940653,
0.0400221571,
-0.022702029,
0.0198587086,
0.0190639459,
0.0741871819,
-0.0447550677,
-0.0040752953,
-0.0079430956,
0.0355267078,
0.0193800293,
-0.0214144289,
0.0291444883,
-0.0183210075,
-0.0302284453,
0.0242417865,
0.1088772491,
0.0743718892,
-0.0240212232,
-0.0074312431,
0.0242980663,
0.0059042675,
0.0281645712,
-0.0197279323,
0.0381577052,
-0.0372919887,
-0.0131855588,
0.0200952422,
0.0323936939,
0.0213337503,
0.0195909869,
-0.0005838785,
0.043017894,
-0.0081873015,
0.0103219338,
-0.0189386085,
0.0075223683,
-0.0287078191,
-0.0387303047,
-0.0363586806,
0.0086952848,
-0.0656069815,
0.0081382291,
-0.0236973371,
0.0517432615,
-0.0190265607,
-0.0006443069,
0.0484890789,
0.0421643481,
-0.0081158839,
0.0540874265,
0.0075794263,
0.0137733314,
-0.0510662161,
0.0379740931,
-0.0114180399,
-0.0129573755,
-0.0685353056,
0.0299100485,
-0.0184323713,
0.0255103745,
-0.0142476475,
-0.0073123397,
0.0084254239,
0.0076818052,
-0.0274991356,
-0.0150507195,
-0.0301641002,
0.0021910509,
-0.0069693667,
0.0102880653,
-0.026224561,
0.0152850552,
-0.0833407864,
0.0366021879,
0.0057553654,
-0.0432124659,
-0.0340192728,
-0.0171639994,
0.0292016715,
-0.0264229998,
0.015029707,
0.0423415527,
0.0080561675,
-0.0219831858,
-0.0241614673,
-0.0594751462,
0.0268276781,
-0.0740630776,
0.0049747173,
-0.0399099961,
0.0082464209,
0.0220968705,
-0.0260622948,
-0.0015559937,
-0.0118840588,
0.0115034934,
-0.0672650784,
0.0778467804,
-0.0220038183,
-0.0083585363,
-0.0207848307,
0.0363138206,
0.0252158679,
0.0482067019,
0.0218814537,
0.0483962297,
0.0168303493,
0.0466347151,
0.0164323114,
0.0085989395,
0.034985207,
0.033322718,
-0.0378593244,
0.0075976765,
-0.0351670235,
0.0364972986,
0.0008322507,
0.002285036,
-0.0340971947,
-0.0262815151,
0.02938007,
0.0275094677,
-0.0423093475,
-0.0474512018,
0.0853854045,
-0.0183119643,
-0.0094377846,
-0.0044659418,
-0.0531199053,
0.0515795052,
-0.0291244779,
-0.0367462896,
-0.0336183235,
-0.0104264161,
-0.0517397746,
0.0037095053,
-0.0092907054,
0.015875278,
0.0107818246,
-0.000262183,
0.026000917,
0.0147514753,
-0.0194743779,
0.0079434952,
0.0046277023,
-0.0282238908,
-0.02519642,
-0.0344131105,
0.0299531426,
0.0335512608,
0.0624729358,
-0.0252637956,
-0.0643910542,
-0.0101807751,
0.0612703636,
0.0149820829,
0.0065510157,
-0.0201445743,
0.004697497,
-0.0189587269,
-0.0025549154,
-0.0062973439,
0.0063231345,
0.0443130508,
-0.0093214791,
-0.0099334782,
-0.0362171866,
-0.0098323906,
0.0375840887,
0.0112820109,
-0.0166658331,
0.0249133464,
-0.055136472,
0.0209828075,
0.0487436019,
0.0080425162,
0.0022388091,
-0.0206229389,
0.0189067982,
-0.0121048344,
-0.0332291275,
0.0689498112,
-0.0227932557,
-0.0519171357,
0.0053093103,
-0.0656102896,
-0.0481254384,
0.0191064421,
-0.0485546254,
-0.0278181471,
0.0464774892,
-0.0333058909,
-0.0255547445,
-0.0158340335,
-0.0261351056,
0.0185685921,
0.0066934116,
0.0356110707,
0.0780517608,
-0.0175244194,
-0.010197836,
-0.0038228719,
0.0440141298,
0.0488702282,
-0.0446207225,
0.0290772244,
0.0003036796,
0.0080618262,
-0.0395133421,
0.0363203771,
-0.0161417034,
-0.0412522331,
0.0328607522,
-0.0909378827,
0.0063491059,
-0.0061946483,
-0.0199842453,
-0.0134095214,
0.0126833497,
-0.0123718409,
-0.0051027494,
-0.0015876306,
0.0068311719,
0.0007647869,
0.0035264604,
0.0211883374,
0.0019528024,
-0.0072187819,
0.009906034,
0.0131600723,
-0.0622058399,
0.0527091213,
0.0224491805,
-0.0027028203,
-0.0179600548,
0.0136531405,
-0.0225845873,
0.0514113978,
-0.029418394,
-0.0411955714,
0.0229393933,
0.0052588019,
-0.0089750728,
0.0752103254,
-0.0339245759,
0.0280299224,
0.0029072098,
-0.0328558348,
-0.0011949756,
0.0247926787,
-0.001222325,
0.0386288092,
-0.033195775,
-0.0490302481,
-0.0584863611,
0.0332158357,
0.0012772597,
0.0184855461,
-0.0748290569,
0.0113822697,
0.0288044717,
-0.0366386324,
-0.0145706329,
-0.0547219291,
-0.0066914824,
0.0617561676,
-0.0278368723,
-0.0001876027,
0.0639863983,
-0.0032471886,
0.0253833998,
-0.0045356047,
0.0225177109,
-0.0389469638,
0.0934987292,
0.0364332721,
0.0021952079,
0.0113485176,
-0.0089106495,
-0.0754628032,
-0.0202328842,
0.0427426361,
0.0215348899,
-0.02160489,
-0.0702213049,
0.0133246081,
0.0021680093,
-0.0445935652,
-0.0327055454,
-0.0220607724,
-0.0380751789,
-0.0130316447,
-0.0460712798,
-0.0183444582,
-0.0313021615,
-0.0028045888,
0.0212499481,
0.0004877122,
0.0037266714,
0.0012098588,
-0.0188434608,
0.0393313579,
0.0440865159,
-0.0300950073,
-0.0043702624,
-0.0065719844,
0.0273647625,
0.0490484014,
0.0243305471,
-0.0086038858,
-0.0527281426,
0.0488246121,
-0.023291273,
0.0613885149,
-0.0263795145,
-0.0012490102,
0.0652376488,
-0.0110716112,
0.0016395628,
0.0789912865,
0.0027771564,
-0.0353958867,
0.0209321249,
0.0381403416,
-0.0169037823,
0.0322240852,
-0.0050746142,
-0.0882471204,
-0.0454319157,
0.0398869254,
-0.0179296043,
-0.0278753024,
-0.1056873724,
-0.0090051908,
-0.0850454047,
0.0806887299,
-0.0377800874,
0.0187886097,
-0.0127166491,
-0.0459107719,
0.0470308587,
-0.0228903145,
-0.050081566,
-0.0090443715,
0.0234241635,
0.0188521724,
-0.0322395377,
-0.0011445502,
-0.0129863489,
0.0802053884,
-0.0159638543,
0.0591367595,
-0.0071901325,
0.0414205976,
-0.0096520679,
-0.0172266196,
-0.0115942443,
0.002748556,
0.0078252302,
-0.0073195114,
0.0679755285,
-0.0259108692,
0.0006007656,
-0.0321239531,
0.0876111612,
-0.0293663908,
-0.0530407913,
-0.0052011656,
0.081301339,
-0.0473680235,
-0.0076066069,
-0.0367817283,
0.0297446139,
-0.0236683413,
0.0656694472,
0.006086268,
-0.0133787161,
-0.0132031841,
0.0479428582,
-0.029792089,
-0.0331122056,
-0.0501800627,
-0.018017929,
-0.0037219392,
-0.0550354086,
-0.0169809144,
-0.0384135731,
-0.0112083675,
0.0572612099,
-0.0309802424,
-0.0166171566,
0.0255128983,
0.0027069238,
-0.0441643931,
0.0489044525,
-0.0349414721,
0.0299824122,
0.0307120681,
0.04410116,
-0.0225773994,
-0.0334148668,
-0.011068102,
0.0382315218,
-0.0575148501,
-0.0197349079,
-0.0067547471,
0.0285513531,
0.027857177,
0.0549340956,
-0.0211668666,
-0.0258529019,
0.0115470663,
-0.01759414,
-0.0547295325,
0.045036424,
-0.0046528424,
-0.0119748227,
-0.005048736,
0.0499953367,
-0.0152081838,
0.0559383444,
0.0272505619,
0.0133255553,
-0.0546303615,
0.0342149325,
0.0161552187,
-0.0069573629,
0.0602917485,
-0.0152536994,
-0.0035631368,
-0.0407218523,
-0.0126997652,
-0.0396072082,
0.0023739242,
-0.0375059247,
0.0478631668,
-0.0012467565,
-0.0075535425,
-0.0399174392,
-0.0947219655,
-0.0437755547,
-0.0116586043,
0.0041636815,
-0.009303811,
0.0371532552,
0.0313267075,
0.0107053313,
-0.0108154118,
0.0162155367,
0.0078997519,
-0.0381331146,
0.0489421487,
-0.0134025114,
0.0959484056,
0.0789015964,
-0.0065074912,
0.0088171242,
0.0298098288,
-0.0626453757,
-0.0163541399,
0.0307151768,
-0.0186969917,
0.0445462875,
0.0147984307,
-0.028765589,
-0.044077225,
0.0250363797,
0.0484813973,
0.0434077717,
-0.00669243,
-0.0285653248,
0.0002796488,
0.034029875,
-0.0066915373,
0.0555694103,
0.0490874946,
-0.0047336151,
0.0312371906,
0.0214280542,
-0.0199754331,
-0.0253642183,
-0.0257434621,
0.0214479771,
0.0476687513,
-0.0036317445,
0.0189303048,
-0.1051806435,
-0.0677762553,
-0.0128669506,
0.0011115038,
-0.0027613931,
0.0402532145,
0.0309303533,
0.0405560769,
0.0141721182,
-0.0208974108,
0.024980884,
0.011703345,
-0.0604705401,
-0.0182902887,
0.0078981034,
-6.472409282e-33,
-0.0319662802,
-0.0142027596,
0.0328949615,
0.0488312021,
-0.0130206998,
0.0145364581,
-0.0425972752,
-0.0195322465,
-0.0171868261,
0.0473789349,
0.0003932339,
0.0726943687,
-0.0037739822,
-0.0035505658,
-0.0215974692,
-0.015617013,
-0.0033808942,
0.0017158759,
-0.0231891405,
0.0323564298,
0.0329915211,
-0.0123758977,
0.0307550337,
-0.1120048463,
-0.0085779773,
-0.0095055513,
-0.0233991016,
0.0441362485,
0.0002768454,
0.0011818149,
-0.0040788502,
0.0153030157,
0.0352878384,
-0.0296856947,
0.038363535,
-0.0040786555,
-0.0549396835,
-0.0396167673,
0.0538018458,
-0.0153293898,
-0.0793962106,
-0.0299845114,
-0.04944795,
-0.0053066541,
0.0035984176,
-0.0264800992,
0.0299067087,
-0.0122534623,
0.0763761625,
0.0296673309,
-0.0532110445,
0.0171883777,
-0.042151846,
-0.0473125763,
-0.0138313137,
0.0049303286,
0.0054233922,
-0.0349028111,
-0.0677002892,
0.0140930824,
-0.0671304539,
-0.0541163348,
0.0418421067,
-0.036988683,
-0.0078428779,
0.0516518243,
0.0582606196,
-0.004036726,
-0.0528037027,
0.0221888032,
-0.0025172872,
0.1077974364,
0.0373579524,
0.0640844107,
-0.0085182432,
0.0122109987,
-0.107996136,
0.0142586203,
0.0264876597,
0.0812825859,
0.0266256481,
-0.0226446483,
-0.0347935632,
-0.0161484256,
-0.0149737671,
-0.0557228848,
-0.0279816445,
0.0086233085,
0.0076215514,
-0.009692369,
0.0135023799,
-0.0007511752,
0.0524781644,
-0.0233825613,
0.0525050834,
0.0313895419,
-0.0255609229,
0.0274996478,
0.0073628142,
0.0448046997,
-0.0326310769,
-0.0025495994,
0.059860602,
0.0206070486,
0.0607907549,
-0.0019490008,
0.0452466756,
0.026932003,
0.0271579511,
-0.0337931067,
-0.0440242179,
0.0000088935,
-0.0237456355,
-0.0274021402,
0.025983287,
0.0569806658,
-0.0235046241,
-0.0116182277,
0.0048447773,
0.0136831179,
-0.0114970654,
-0.0397404358,
-0.0332855396,
-0.018269198,
-0.0170181617,
-0.0263364837,
-0.0249521937,
-0.0002476939,
0.0186671782,
-0.040841382,
-0.0151884565,
0.0198193677,
2.884e-7,
-0.0062755258,
0.0441389121,
0.0247996133,
0.0453992784,
0.0268693771,
0.0580536053,
-0.010634941,
0.0603763834,
0.0046760822,
-0.0678245425,
0.0330244377,
0.0563482717,
0.0247638002,
0.0395328924,
-0.0225926358,
-0.0034635086,
0.0112156263,
-0.0587130785,
-0.0543829277,
-0.0012364009,
0.0664738491,
0.0513068885,
0.0807861462,
-0.0205061994,
0.0319362842,
0.0043856115,
0.0355803482,
-0.0092288032,
-0.0172914583,
-0.0264575109,
-0.0110770827,
0.0088533815,
-0.0127701666,
0.0783592761,
0.0236336123,
-0.0053878278,
-0.0233663395,
-0.0326300859,
-0.047220666,
-0.0318101831,
-0.0525784232,
-0.0504803397,
-0.0142460782,
-0.0490037091,
0.0875572115,
-0.0354982764,
-0.0819601342,
0.0618356951,
-0.0287851915,
-0.0006743828,
-0.0111651281,
0.0482336991,
-0.0101204012,
-0.00372839,
0.0229530409,
-0.0190347061,
-0.0187736154,
-0.0832203999,
0.002167552,
0.0204071049,
-0.0133076692,
-0.0347880535,
-0.0082398327,
-0.0069634309,
0.0581639074,
-0.0655113384,
-0.0166645795,
2.730111803e-34,
0.0199682619,
0.0237736609,
0.0014056861,
-0.0498194098,
0.0699830204,
-0.047718063,
-0.0617111102,
0.0008123883,
0.0447796248,
-0.1000967622,
-0.0053826412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14739v1 | Trusting Your Evidence: Hallucinate Less with Context-aware Decoding | 2023-05-24T05:19:15 | 2023-05-24T05:19:15 | Weijia Shi, Xiaochuang Han, Mike Lewis, Yulia Tsvetkov, Luke Zettlemoyer, Scott Wen-tau Yih | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) often struggle to pay enough attention to the input
context, and generate texts that are unfaithful or contain hallucinations. To
mitigate this issue, we present context-aware decoding (CAD), which follows a
contrastive output distribution that amplifies the difference between the
output probabilities when a model is used with and without context. Our
experiments show that CAD, without additional training, significantly improves
the faithfulness of different LM families, including OPT, GPT, LLaMA and
FLAN-T5 for summarization tasks (e.g., 14.3% gain for LLaMA in factuality
metrics). Furthermore, CAD is particularly effective in overriding a model's
prior knowledge when it contradicts the provided context, leading to
substantial improvements in tasks where resolving the knowledge conflict is
essential. | [
0.0111140544,
0.0335349776,
0.0096683651,
0.0287311599,
-0.0370233245,
0.0136791477,
-0.0309193265,
-0.033140976,
-0.0545312129,
-0.0366490111,
-0.0487891994,
-0.0078877173,
0.05268782,
0.0121768471,
0.0091798333,
-0.0530369617,
0.0346515849,
-0.0259888172,
0.0003992645,
0.0011669254,
-0.0043365806,
0.0046043126,
-0.0034735561,
0.0291737523,
-0.0002436101,
-0.0233055279,
0.0014525416,
-0.0029803962,
0.0385252461,
0.0013630462,
0.0043660481,
0.0434279963,
-0.0029767014,
0.0490202531,
0.0000021296,
-0.0347792804,
-0.0160512626,
-0.0335713029,
-0.0260670353,
0.0288577694,
0.0492634587,
-0.0428464524,
0.0022727593,
0.0039165034,
-0.0317788646,
-0.0001193093,
0.0189778246,
0.0775467977,
0.0483868681,
0.0754675195,
0.0018373565,
-0.0406838283,
0.0393653996,
-0.0290069431,
0.0031114621,
0.0025977476,
0.0156580117,
0.0195265841,
-0.0239747521,
-0.0007533731,
-0.0129083749,
0.0614369735,
0.0306442641,
0.0275051724,
0.0012721658,
0.0652027875,
-0.0326835774,
-0.003287504,
0.0435721278,
0.0415414944,
0.0002816739,
-0.0717708692,
-0.0269901957,
0.0040093781,
-0.0198464412,
-0.0360592604,
-0.0371124484,
0.0493640117,
-0.0317874476,
0.0674057975,
0.0742987916,
0.0238913335,
0.0258087814,
0.0147312563,
-0.0346697159,
0.0560381114,
-0.0064126649,
-0.0254343674,
-0.0058759586,
0.0464262925,
-0.0037121742,
-0.0682881549,
-0.0006199761,
0.0122575527,
-0.0195476115,
-0.0042899083,
-0.0494708531,
-0.0200261939,
0.0253672618,
-0.045072075,
-0.0379659832,
0.0438725911,
-0.0578200221,
0.0230180006,
-0.0191623028,
0.0153018162,
0.0346630886,
0.0801780075,
-0.0501235612,
-0.0011796755,
-0.010488335,
0.0027589796,
-0.0137141971,
0.0108792242,
-0.0353494957,
-0.0072446656,
-0.0358845405,
0.0114182662,
0.0041192533,
0.0073062917,
-0.0016578361,
0.0117412079,
-0.0328770094,
-0.0134102656,
0.0091617079,
0.027026277,
-0.0131173506,
0.0220185835,
0.0181862321,
-0.0607275851,
-0.0410048105,
0.009596874,
-0.0203197822,
-0.0105664879,
-0.0166380685,
0.0234055761,
-0.0423086509,
-0.0408401191,
-0.0403275751,
-0.0010107873,
-0.0291091893,
-0.0729225874,
-0.020897897,
-0.0638508946,
-0.0134858349,
-0.0034000187,
-0.0086105177,
-0.0359111056,
-0.0089885844,
0.0047478606,
-0.0302398149,
0.0612990484,
-0.0172995292,
-0.0176773891,
0.0440910384,
0.0384192318,
-0.0146453325,
0.0706996694,
0.0068371939,
0.0422511771,
0.0078284107,
0.045445621,
-0.006899714,
-0.0012748615,
0.018395327,
-0.0003314972,
-0.0086548179,
-0.0321368277,
-0.033409331,
-0.0199946165,
0.0773817375,
0.0549695753,
-0.0564978234,
-0.0133529585,
0.1027528569,
0.0150194811,
0.0272718631,
-0.0142366393,
-0.0030214235,
-0.0076384642,
0.0051546586,
0.0857956484,
-0.0875701979,
0.0330319442,
-0.0434012637,
0.0535788201,
0.0711239278,
0.0279828459,
-0.025611829,
-0.044364661,
0.0047061462,
-0.0140243629,
0.0083960062,
0.0065156776,
0.0214888826,
0.031240169,
-0.0536768958,
0.006901423,
0.0159596708,
-0.0366787799,
0.0103933234,
-0.0442306101,
0.0583436601,
0.0577869043,
0.0716531426,
-0.0192112066,
0.0150023634,
0.0034782572,
-0.004503964,
0.0609197617,
0.0121999774,
0.0014785316,
0.0366468243,
-0.0440117121,
-0.0176868197,
-0.0055483864,
0.0501863807,
0.0073429244,
0.0046417066,
0.0055035055,
0.0041942829,
-0.0177431311,
-0.0204408877,
0.0459997915,
0.0019651526,
-0.0296625961,
-0.028342614,
-0.0209317692,
0.0035459944,
0.0045708725,
-0.0176073741,
0.0282113217,
0.0239646398,
-0.0506089292,
-0.0005910965,
0.0303844865,
-0.0931941047,
-0.0651974007,
0.0331553668,
-0.0385094546,
0.0092091979,
0.0124467611,
-0.0010578237,
-0.0305376053,
0.0236001052,
-0.0477235578,
0.0772829205,
-0.0627324134,
0.0064521516,
0.0118023306,
0.0413876474,
-0.0115363961,
0.1088931113,
-0.0473675244,
-0.0319749601,
0.0325690098,
0.0042590476,
-0.028674718,
0.0019348321,
0.0068772091,
-0.0059779491,
0.0335680991,
0.0140896831,
0.0021307617,
-0.0024435518,
-0.0244542733,
-0.0093443692,
-0.0572979152,
0.0073823635,
-0.0527338944,
-0.0094877137,
0.0573834106,
-0.0108597837,
0.0027081668,
0.0057530301,
-0.0297561977,
-0.0269833151,
0.0177173223,
0.0111283753,
0.0063445838,
0.0177464895,
0.0152204512,
-0.0516640469,
-0.0140783647,
0.0210327581,
0.0359077863,
-0.0262000952,
-0.0476459824,
-0.0654975101,
0.0780558214,
0.0007600202,
-0.0139105637,
-0.0194659829,
-0.0056063933,
0.0039043257,
-0.0112215867,
0.0738979653,
0.0626819581,
0.017749425,
0.0262534078,
0.0881629139,
0.0103523592,
-0.0214746278,
-0.0368962176,
-0.0064028148,
-0.0003648775,
-0.0053139618,
-0.0695172921,
0.009469782,
0.048707772,
0.0616119727,
0.0256838892,
-0.0615814812,
-0.0003224661,
-0.0121776136,
-0.0428338349,
0.0040093735,
-0.0389506221,
-0.0240211766,
0.0641570762,
-0.0421023555,
-0.0344028845,
0.0887044296,
-0.0426243432,
0.0200321171,
-0.0360913239,
-0.0215091705,
-0.0121860914,
0.0007549425,
0.0076053231,
0.0016145664,
-0.012301214,
-0.0242163893,
-0.0196452606,
-0.025480492,
0.0218172465,
-0.0455067754,
0.0971178859,
-0.0478692874,
-0.0017432944,
-0.0047822935,
-0.0048882752,
-0.0543110482,
-0.0176671073,
-0.025733022,
-0.0009853098,
-0.0085809296,
0.0301882643,
-0.0434840359,
-0.005815323,
0.0380294137,
0.0675152317,
-0.0211263523,
-0.021650821,
-0.0055751069,
0.0324024446,
0.0432844944,
0.0166498218,
0.0771427825,
-0.0530207306,
-0.0025511878,
0.0877259746,
0.0243125651,
-0.0012137722,
-0.0278676953,
-0.0008367499,
0.0068003093,
-0.0102190878,
-0.0158390012,
0.0167879108,
0.0601404496,
-0.039140489,
-0.0219436437,
0.1079033986,
0.0155839361,
-0.0663646683,
-0.0121529782,
-0.039634794,
0.0678367391,
-0.0043623885,
-0.0201211795,
-0.1015889347,
-0.0386225097,
0.0180688296,
0.042265743,
-0.0127776563,
-0.0194298439,
-0.0117023829,
-0.0710497424,
0.0243971422,
0.0394034125,
-0.0245414861,
-0.0531483404,
-0.0478805862,
0.012032398,
-0.0348602831,
0.0536066182,
0.0229877848,
0.0057344157,
-0.0050128978,
0.0154124154,
-0.0226814765,
-0.0434038006,
0.0016103082,
-0.0130513133,
0.0453014299,
0.0800801814,
-0.003259103,
-0.0081916917,
-0.038851317,
-0.0018174305,
-0.0465888791,
0.0025784278,
-0.0034509292,
0.0484055951,
-0.0271778759,
0.0317216069,
-0.0133090941,
0.0353343263,
-0.0266232584,
-0.0526718497,
-0.0249223653,
0.0133954156,
-0.0160487592,
-0.037150126,
-0.0238867719,
0.0426715389,
-0.0081405723,
0.0979979485,
0.0564855635,
0.0087064328,
-0.0445835181,
-0.0551971756,
0.0437818021,
-0.0323206596,
-0.0118403137,
0.0252788309,
0.0162724555,
-0.0375933535,
-0.0904814675,
-0.0524355695,
-0.0044705407,
-0.0088054677,
-0.0121663092,
0.0209671501,
-0.0167418662,
-0.0276843365,
-0.0394698568,
-0.0102020167,
-0.0367426276,
-0.0004832546,
-0.0120651908,
0.021679692,
0.0148471296,
-0.061024487,
0.0149211632,
0.057078097,
-0.0924220383,
-0.076502271,
0.030712299,
0.0238228124,
0.0322935991,
0.0977721736,
-0.0010050233,
-0.0217466448,
0.0373814031,
0.0329442061,
0.0096353944,
0.0714534968,
0.0173288211,
-0.0051087937,
0.0195185672,
0.0298084263,
-0.0335995704,
0.0240672752,
-0.0034003118,
0.0225810409,
-0.0302073602,
-0.018602835,
0.050303705,
-0.0196567066,
0.0107541801,
-0.0332537889,
-0.0074839359,
-0.0313014165,
-0.0104528554,
-0.0320073068,
0.014134055,
0.002059031,
0.0038351263,
0.0287285931,
-0.0087383902,
0.0002556546,
0.028720228,
-0.030389579,
0.0185206309,
-0.0442979485,
-0.0235770177,
0.0061707161,
0.0186117943,
-0.0192574188,
-0.0135933151,
-0.0765985176,
-0.0061796755,
-0.0202888586,
0.0446369536,
-0.0171734858,
0.0219119769,
0.0216739196,
-0.0336809903,
-0.0186668318,
0.0258134156,
-0.0964047536,
0.0112031419,
-0.0579411127,
-0.0186349489,
0.0359162837,
-0.0269818641,
0.0843120813,
-0.045447927,
0.0245516859,
-0.0245913956,
0.0272012614,
0.0494233929,
0.000466604,
-0.0330902301,
0.0190368649,
0.0050382297,
0.0034811422,
0.0989501402,
-0.036465358,
0.0354508348,
0.0036183365,
-0.003401971,
-0.043170508,
-0.0676328167,
-0.0567321032,
0.0639086515,
-0.017589774,
-0.0230759829,
-0.0478180759,
-0.04663473,
0.01560973,
0.0134077724,
0.0221332368,
-0.043723058,
0.018167505,
0.0417596959,
-0.0021606558,
-0.0345768556,
-0.0121954596,
-0.0020554378,
0.0546119288,
0.0147274947,
-0.0045340937,
-6.784691111e-33,
-0.0236091986,
-0.0002812222,
-0.0012948882,
-0.013918329,
-0.0189585388,
0.0027448649,
-0.0589416511,
0.0080377581,
-0.0272896457,
0.0171815418,
-0.0145757794,
0.0462203436,
0.0248516127,
0.0319131128,
-0.0051776371,
0.0174633581,
0.0529429317,
0.0014644216,
-0.0495352782,
0.0217202585,
0.0371777415,
-0.0120038725,
0.0430025719,
-0.0691421926,
0.0434899218,
-0.0208684634,
-0.0314717926,
0.0021037697,
-0.0147159314,
0.0260282494,
-0.0710284486,
0.0301004909,
0.039682027,
-0.0223971251,
-0.0582559928,
-0.0112040173,
-0.0857165009,
-0.0165407769,
0.0479100235,
-0.0071682525,
-0.0500896908,
-0.0346889347,
0.0306534395,
0.0066888793,
-0.0014209722,
-0.0352399759,
0.0158774313,
-0.057591062,
-0.0271335579,
0.0157960244,
-0.0404378287,
0.0109430952,
-0.0023398763,
-0.0201223958,
0.027664924,
0.0152509054,
-0.0163648669,
0.008391019,
-0.0882680938,
0.0516398363,
0.0276094675,
0.0310945772,
0.061099112,
0.0054080142,
-0.0236111414,
0.0826747641,
0.0351566561,
-0.0256322119,
-0.0604649708,
-0.0431136899,
0.0248760786,
0.0136942053,
-0.0005603452,
0.058934316,
0.0536629707,
-0.0198750515,
-0.039031066,
0.0406378098,
-0.0121666053,
-0.000937799,
0.061942514,
0.0244706608,
-0.0377434455,
-0.0434964821,
-0.014639236,
-0.0112295588,
-0.0230204817,
-0.0036760489,
0.0075680991,
0.0432173125,
-0.0052648643,
-0.0309549756,
0.02751421,
-0.0139956968,
0.0548590347,
0.0387799479,
-0.0407644026,
0.0099001098,
0.0095931944,
-0.0100638131,
-0.0239800625,
0.052220203,
0.0309377685,
0.0163862798,
-0.0159723163,
0.0196562354,
0.0502732918,
0.01086115,
-0.0447164699,
0.0116955182,
-0.0251162425,
0.0325694606,
0.0183272846,
-0.0093271844,
0.0256346688,
0.0040647048,
-0.011870808,
0.0205484796,
-0.0255204123,
0.025067728,
-0.0313353054,
0.0274586137,
0.0040765274,
0.0392037295,
-0.035581246,
-0.0098000662,
-0.0091339583,
0.010840212,
0.0525368266,
-0.0556523465,
-0.0229895487,
0.0360611528,
2.723e-7,
0.0420245305,
0.0314293317,
0.0548955277,
-0.0057541952,
0.0227119718,
0.0334277526,
-0.0113660051,
0.0338881724,
0.0225817468,
-0.0469754599,
-0.007411622,
0.0446657352,
0.0714345723,
0.0579301529,
-0.0422617309,
-0.0347220749,
-0.0415676087,
-0.0073656188,
-0.0307607893,
-0.0458382182,
0.0554370396,
0.0937628523,
-0.0099337548,
-0.0177519675,
0.0301012415,
-0.0075221453,
0.0490662679,
-0.0158036295,
0.00117403,
0.0044416427,
0.0008612213,
-0.0009265479,
0.0169422571,
0.0092923632,
-0.0052014822,
-0.0473079234,
0.0120073911,
0.0507322997,
0.0220891554,
-0.0726192296,
0.0076666703,
0.0284219608,
0.0227210838,
-0.0500341654,
0.0514490791,
-0.0266513824,
-0.0060916278,
-0.000831829,
-0.0652548224,
0.0102928076,
0.0003718073,
0.0088823801,
-0.0338947177,
0.0312769674,
-0.0038562778,
0.0522833541,
-0.044563733,
-0.080776535,
-0.0592290126,
0.0177537072,
-0.0293279737,
-0.0209643506,
0.0040331488,
-0.0080556124,
0.0292717945,
-0.0944391415,
0.0163779911,
2.762375909e-34,
0.0554822572,
-0.0095721101,
0.0131939156,
0.0367283784,
-0.0006563534,
-0.0169652514,
0.0291608572,
0.0056391833,
0.0178544894,
-0.0541136228,
-0.0207918007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14735v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14735v3 | Centering the Margins: Outlier-Based Identification of Harmed Populations in Toxicity Detection | 2023-05-24T05:15:36 | 2023-12-01T19:45:25 | Vyoma Raman, Eve Fleisig, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The impact of AI models on marginalized communities has traditionally been
measured by identifying performance differences between specified demographic
subgroups. Though this approach aims to center vulnerable groups, it risks
obscuring patterns of harm faced by intersectional subgroups or shared across
multiple groups. To address this, we draw on theories of marginalization from
disability studies and related disciplines, which state that people farther
from the norm face greater adversity, to consider the "margins" in the domain
of toxicity detection. We operationalize the "margins" of a dataset by
employing outlier detection to identify text about people with demographic
attributes distant from the "norm". We find that model performance is
consistently worse for demographic outliers, with mean squared error (MSE)
between outliers and non-outliers up to 70.4% worse across toxicity types. It
is also worse for text outliers, with a MSE up to 68.4% higher for outliers
than non-outliers. We also find text and demographic outliers to be
particularly susceptible to errors in the classification of severe toxicity and
identity attacks. Compared to analysis of disparities using traditional
demographic breakdowns, we find that our outlier analysis frequently surfaces
greater harms faced by a larger, more intersectional group, which suggests that
outlier analysis is particularly beneficial for identifying harms against those
groups. | [
-0.0080733811,
0.0369172618,
-0.0419580378,
-0.0217521377,
0.0039510587,
0.0308341086,
0.0812387615,
-0.0128952507,
0.0187604222,
-0.0378160439,
0.0144229447,
0.0309059825,
-0.0061467905,
0.0034195085,
0.004652543,
-0.0342176259,
0.0154376831,
0.0237982441,
0.0494186841,
-0.0038642744,
0.0296016857,
0.0208811089,
0.0434507355,
0.059716627,
-0.0189100057,
-0.0309684314,
0.0645164326,
-0.0039276034,
0.0610026158,
-0.0292279515,
0.0262762774,
0.0125697711,
0.0238107517,
0.038558878,
0.0000018705,
-0.0289865918,
0.0066188821,
0.0108738532,
0.0238057189,
-0.0530378707,
0.0406134799,
-0.050803449,
0.0113126785,
0.0612871125,
-0.0015435455,
0.0186653696,
0.030337587,
0.0004258414,
0.0107749039,
0.0163955111,
-0.0280076358,
0.0047741667,
0.017655896,
0.0301286876,
0.0016440415,
0.0486429334,
0.0432567485,
-0.0601057895,
-0.0432411022,
-0.0744058713,
0.0011220613,
0.025586376,
0.028794745,
0.0263585113,
0.0240547322,
0.0121877603,
0.0410147831,
-0.0461640954,
0.0365011916,
0.0851414949,
-0.02945159,
0.0394608751,
0.0004180929,
0.0082429284,
0.0152097857,
-0.0084804539,
-0.0276369844,
0.0313902646,
-0.0105021335,
-0.0232421551,
-0.0168906711,
0.0757166594,
0.0409061499,
0.0326163545,
0.0037292831,
0.0299302582,
-0.0043615755,
-0.0110942554,
-0.0154256159,
-0.0306793936,
-0.0121641541,
0.0214947164,
0.0417161025,
-0.0027645305,
-0.0229110662,
-0.005947209,
-0.0182617456,
-0.0277364124,
0.036822319,
-0.0266586356,
0.0581104569,
0.0340571776,
-0.0707141161,
-0.0168054719,
0.045675721,
0.0106930202,
0.0146541838,
0.0595499687,
-0.0040232339,
0.0160757005,
0.0185163021,
0.0226771943,
0.0256489404,
0.0043279668,
-0.0116906296,
0.0440440252,
-0.0254371036,
0.0068250545,
-0.1011104882,
-0.0185889322,
-0.0410190709,
0.0104931379,
-0.0311887618,
0.0154928584,
0.0215306953,
-0.0297671687,
-0.0739185065,
0.0237535276,
0.0044378866,
-0.0319132805,
-0.0027112723,
0.032761354,
-0.0164030939,
-0.0452408567,
-0.0141648613,
0.0739248693,
0.0254554488,
-0.0314429253,
-0.0457740463,
-0.0381070264,
-0.0149018914,
-0.0044095153,
-0.0084095262,
-0.0237809345,
-0.0059841322,
0.005637567,
-0.0062770941,
-0.1060785279,
-0.0091273356,
-0.0052042655,
-0.0301657822,
0.0660020262,
0.0326474123,
0.0049240291,
0.0797498897,
0.0407165736,
-0.0274062175,
0.0452635475,
0.0334998667,
0.0045709503,
0.0379069448,
-0.0042870096,
0.0136535643,
0.0047212914,
0.0208711531,
0.0295131691,
-0.0560312495,
0.0279726554,
-0.0055651367,
-0.0255403202,
0.0035974139,
0.0258732662,
0.0290085487,
-0.0251207333,
0.0581069328,
0.0776910186,
-0.0446044877,
0.0110527128,
-0.0031924152,
0.0040816707,
-0.0690222681,
-0.0594300851,
-0.0695051923,
-0.0199146867,
-0.0104513811,
-0.0761782452,
0.0008829662,
0.0306983404,
-0.0388888791,
-0.0147680677,
-0.0499829985,
-0.0000486179,
0.079328768,
-0.0263092779,
0.0123601379,
-0.0034544112,
0.0118543766,
-0.0585619546,
0.0311697144,
0.0102244392,
-0.0106131015,
-0.0589299165,
-0.0023162721,
0.0413624458,
0.0061538066,
-0.0261033978,
0.0416296646,
-0.0563250221,
-0.0186679531,
-0.019346565,
-0.0171004012,
-0.0112903779,
-0.0154106086,
0.0103435256,
0.0073731062,
0.0258343723,
0.0121034086,
0.0210358109,
0.0159761664,
0.0300776362,
0.0009020637,
-0.0502423272,
-0.041292157,
0.0602988191,
-0.0051555587,
-0.0334309749,
-0.0120070921,
0.032356929,
0.0538833737,
-0.01970434,
-0.036868915,
-0.0135931158,
-0.0351320729,
-0.0120230317,
-0.0358620659,
0.0023211008,
-0.0141969202,
0.0439585745,
0.0158360712,
-0.0571456142,
0.0066320025,
0.046847254,
0.0081133358,
0.0314731821,
0.0494293831,
-0.0275037009,
-0.0600144826,
0.0033778071,
-0.0225458182,
-0.0112734418,
0.0177019797,
-0.0271122549,
0.0745879933,
-0.0336156599,
-0.0282640904,
-0.0239852834,
-0.0525306612,
0.0149898091,
-0.0389061682,
0.0005159751,
-0.0766555145,
-0.0498002321,
0.0162706822,
-0.0056028571,
-0.034276206,
0.0032119956,
0.0465248786,
-0.0435847417,
-0.0011911317,
-0.030394895,
-0.0200095866,
-0.012244571,
0.012503217,
-0.0228406601,
-0.012037117,
0.0286418572,
-0.0503516458,
0.0265137646,
0.0619177781,
-0.0209651366,
-0.0136864223,
0.0078317355,
-0.0229828618,
-0.0215650983,
-0.0442317463,
0.0714822263,
0.0291046742,
-0.0490279458,
0.0210299585,
-0.0659217685,
-0.0427115187,
-0.0049526491,
-0.0173115991,
-0.0211490225,
0.0299666263,
0.0550372303,
0.0242444929,
0.0612321012,
0.0513515025,
0.1294646859,
0.0711007416,
0.0531891026,
0.0053463583,
-0.0038579637,
-0.0399743207,
0.016272489,
0.0120148715,
-0.0959522054,
-0.0347071253,
0.0329658724,
0.0228324216,
-0.036789462,
-0.0176252369,
0.0605870299,
-0.0512114875,
-0.0379679054,
-0.0253527313,
-0.0586691909,
-0.0142361391,
-0.0041227215,
-0.0539325811,
-0.0542247705,
0.0426202081,
0.0383562557,
0.0445943363,
0.0208187625,
-0.0347308964,
-0.0046945391,
0.0095612109,
0.0198532715,
0.0140397716,
-0.0404329114,
-0.0008477553,
0.0180875584,
-0.0119986171,
0.0112234792,
-0.0180158131,
0.0305538643,
-0.0463906713,
-0.0044551021,
0.0274387859,
-0.039826151,
-0.0386187173,
-0.0451258272,
0.0023169047,
0.02156353,
-0.0079868753,
-0.0256132223,
-0.0260762218,
0.0078620054,
0.0121662403,
0.0229897592,
-0.00840005,
-0.0045533353,
0.0160012003,
-0.0430709198,
0.0067117675,
-0.0748756751,
0.0531928875,
-0.0327268131,
0.0349692404,
0.0455119461,
-0.0196645707,
0.0016270662,
0.006486041,
0.0060552782,
-0.0138399797,
0.0105367424,
0.0355075262,
0.014463787,
0.0288859643,
0.026715206,
-0.0054893573,
0.0524296016,
0.0161971971,
-0.0163401347,
0.0661713555,
-0.001744746,
0.0002725578,
0.030617509,
-0.0330797695,
-0.0690852404,
0.0332685001,
0.012371433,
0.0754103214,
-0.1066192761,
-0.0681059882,
0.0369211622,
-0.03801376,
0.0570018403,
-0.0052410848,
-0.0447486192,
-0.0459618159,
-0.0202006623,
0.0351675227,
-0.020627873,
0.0280613489,
-0.0326540731,
0.0253855325,
-0.0362085663,
-0.0111458497,
-0.0739937797,
-0.0204232279,
0.0071747024,
-0.012510797,
0.0222669709,
-0.018233439,
0.0215403643,
-0.0434757471,
0.0313171856,
0.0654119775,
-0.048509676,
-0.007896767,
-0.0193073079,
0.0656267405,
0.0035579759,
-0.0043587824,
-0.0518534407,
0.0566321202,
-0.0118585369,
0.0017452494,
0.0195647012,
0.035560891,
-0.0221542437,
-0.043983072,
-0.0548910424,
0.0019317145,
0.034099374,
0.0421450846,
0.0126192933,
-0.0046947054,
0.0166789833,
-0.0855335593,
-0.0213983674,
0.0213906448,
-0.0368036442,
0.0403443985,
-0.0137656648,
-0.0791442171,
0.001010704,
-0.0047519626,
-0.0108194575,
-0.0063831564,
0.0287661701,
-0.0588302426,
-0.0322135016,
0.0076122978,
-0.0418144353,
0.0426849201,
0.0338737555,
0.0201358646,
0.0611615963,
0.0199656636,
-0.0433663651,
-0.0066216975,
-0.0440728478,
-0.0024372488,
-0.0029070738,
-0.045044452,
0.0765887126,
0.0088198408,
0.0177671574,
0.0100535946,
-0.0392425247,
-0.0402977131,
0.0680161193,
0.0576801449,
0.0183702596,
-0.0051672715,
-0.002828636,
-0.074656561,
0.0012753652,
0.0036528662,
-0.0015344846,
0.0543771535,
0.0605505221,
-0.0442810319,
-0.1163345948,
0.0497789271,
-0.0037174155,
-0.0212235898,
0.0530721396,
0.0043262956,
-0.0431686677,
-0.0121142622,
-0.0358559117,
0.0148728406,
-0.0323154628,
0.0456957109,
-0.03644697,
0.0367157161,
0.0281489715,
-0.0613521896,
0.0352230817,
-0.0374051556,
0.0225623064,
-0.0834925696,
0.0429839715,
0.0102451984,
0.0407827944,
0.0247600973,
0.0114005832,
0.0020578534,
0.0317956321,
-0.052796945,
0.0236228965,
-0.000976268,
-0.0192378908,
0.0081286244,
0.0356933028,
-0.022548683,
-0.0138741601,
-0.0045740488,
-0.0176129658,
-0.0312327556,
-0.0169968866,
-0.0462771207,
0.028877398,
-0.0295730159,
0.0030215101,
-0.0183042139,
-0.0330791138,
-0.0001800824,
-0.0243568644,
-0.02558407,
-0.0003200325,
0.0146329179,
-0.0043125842,
0.0153901419,
0.0133658741,
0.0169825107,
0.0491360687,
-0.0044412818,
-0.0737509951,
0.025264034,
-0.0102267833,
0.0181880407,
0.0167591758,
0.0096721826,
0.0043241568,
-0.0496734753,
-0.055991143,
0.00918236,
-0.013791631,
0.0379564948,
0.0302221049,
-0.0349588916,
0.0310769565,
-0.0253004935,
-0.0596647672,
0.0154942274,
0.0242396742,
-0.0545849092,
-0.0428992622,
0.0177774709,
-5.216634911e-33,
-0.0203661826,
-0.0765271559,
-0.0705329552,
-0.0523295552,
0.0081142392,
-0.020918889,
0.0381087251,
-0.0120707573,
-0.0086664679,
0.0252939947,
0.0298550148,
0.0335727967,
-0.0112042679,
-0.0176455919,
-0.006499609,
-0.0405951478,
0.0043969029,
-0.0070338161,
-0.0065774648,
0.0138126342,
0.001080259,
0.0246528797,
-0.0091756219,
-0.1119783148,
0.0489536747,
-0.0104693053,
-0.0196335446,
0.0075714486,
-0.0185807478,
0.0311789494,
0.0341609605,
0.0881190747,
0.0309858266,
0.0058840429,
0.0340445191,
0.0584470034,
-0.0405481569,
0.0205735285,
-0.0133849112,
-0.0448441766,
0.0122851599,
-0.0684036389,
0.0214342941,
0.0180552173,
-0.039113678,
-0.0532684661,
0.0558039546,
-0.0408948287,
0.0602420494,
-0.0068992744,
-0.032724198,
0.0025793363,
-0.0498384051,
0.0430327579,
-0.0532715209,
0.0198034234,
0.0433528349,
0.0467173532,
-0.054737363,
-0.0076886648,
-0.030290233,
-0.0668539181,
0.0116514945,
0.0261096843,
0.004566439,
0.0232003722,
0.0153657207,
0.0284153093,
-0.0494261682,
-0.0670153871,
0.0176750105,
-0.0037115661,
0.0211679954,
0.019780105,
0.0055906675,
-0.0371293239,
-0.0666327253,
-0.0074624517,
0.0157835912,
-0.0362029523,
0.0206662882,
-0.0426473878,
-0.0762926936,
-0.0138882687,
-0.0043007024,
-0.0757187977,
-0.0190172642,
0.018446723,
0.008762788,
-0.0052500563,
-0.0203162823,
0.0128931561,
-0.0093136784,
0.0060339528,
0.0187754855,
-0.0143460529,
0.0251189992,
0.0034373736,
-0.0045151687,
0.0153196314,
-0.0225235559,
0.0119559243,
-0.0041252458,
-0.0149080306,
0.0540036783,
-0.0099901156,
0.0906862691,
0.0025492129,
-0.0339355953,
-0.0037779103,
0.029295342,
0.061672572,
0.0332080461,
0.0587016679,
0.0138733955,
0.0184410233,
0.0151523063,
0.0098655969,
0.0396014675,
0.0356510393,
-0.0113374097,
0.0156524871,
-0.0780954286,
-0.0045106872,
-0.0086627482,
-0.0404219106,
0.0381111912,
0.0415551141,
0.0404382236,
-0.0592438653,
0.0030669689,
-0.0930528939,
2.489e-7,
0.0350025743,
0.0345000774,
0.0189335868,
0.0258632749,
0.0217645168,
0.0075148949,
0.070724465,
0.0648687109,
0.0442805514,
-0.022588728,
0.0381010957,
0.0641084611,
-0.0031246042,
0.0335380323,
0.0197941437,
0.0333365127,
-0.0481606051,
0.0193172526,
-0.0571978241,
0.0326188132,
-0.0037909455,
0.0464480035,
0.0166695248,
-0.0065053045,
-0.0091416752,
-0.0385773517,
0.010046158,
-0.0620713979,
0.0278380308,
0.0118199242,
0.0442372113,
0.032244686,
0.0216649026,
0.0479147173,
0.0099900076,
0.0254186429,
-0.0044726357,
0.0108996239,
-0.0452030525,
-0.0069824881,
0.0048112101,
0.0170792378,
0.0070117419,
-0.0449600928,
0.0564448275,
0.0121928118,
-0.0024077606,
-0.0352584943,
-0.020921791,
-0.0441051684,
0.0544334985,
-0.0108689722,
0.0085432045,
-0.0111524202,
0.0491907075,
-0.0046089026,
0.0553533137,
-0.0624096766,
-0.0204061624,
0.025086198,
-0.0381254181,
-0.0665223077,
0.0136947902,
0.0474400893,
-0.0090827094,
-0.0098405946,
0.0154874753,
2.314986662e-34,
0.0086078839,
0.0430983193,
-0.0223271605,
-0.0656388178,
0.0134696374,
0.0264877696,
0.0066522602,
-0.0546499565,
0.0167752746,
-0.0305514839,
0.0145100839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14734v2 | Advancements in Arabic Grammatical Error Detection and Correction: An Empirical Investigation | 2023-05-24T05:12:58 | 2023-11-09T16:10:59 | Bashar Alhafni, Go Inoue, Christian Khairallah, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is a well-explored problem in English with
many existing models and datasets. However, research on GEC in morphologically
rich languages has been limited due to challenges such as data scarcity and
language complexity. In this paper, we present the first results on Arabic GEC
using two newly developed Transformer-based pretrained sequence-to-sequence
models. We also define the task of multi-class Arabic grammatical error
detection (GED) and present the first results on multi-class Arabic GED. We
show that using GED information as an auxiliary input in GEC models improves
GEC performance across three datasets spanning different genres. Moreover, we
also investigate the use of contextual morphological preprocessing in aiding
GEC systems. Our models achieve SOTA results on two Arabic GEC shared task
datasets and establish a strong benchmark on a recently created dataset. We
make our code, data, and pretrained models publicly available. | [
0.0384293757,
0.0773172602,
0.0052731093,
0.0332446657,
-0.0423663631,
0.0358317383,
0.0067916685,
-0.0235562418,
-0.0712579936,
-0.0686422884,
-0.004460223,
-0.0869371369,
0.0725804418,
-0.0423963107,
0.042246636,
-0.0143278539,
0.0508620255,
-0.0280891955,
-0.0350021645,
0.0150029426,
0.040094547,
0.0275585465,
-0.0252150372,
0.037692599,
-0.0577809624,
-0.0292054005,
-0.0050486303,
0.0183285754,
0.0207569674,
-0.0059661358,
0.0496221483,
0.0825375021,
-0.0344912261,
0.041721575,
0.0000017886,
-0.0422218367,
-0.0211921372,
-0.0257497933,
-0.0109118922,
0.0145527711,
0.0131814564,
-0.0522528924,
-0.0801124498,
0.0155570442,
-0.0032818168,
0.0103308083,
0.0612545833,
0.043806497,
0.0373964012,
0.0838018954,
0.0048570205,
-0.0402855724,
0.0290970225,
-0.0057731196,
-0.0307719149,
0.0303724296,
0.028026551,
-0.018129155,
-0.0377961583,
0.0039898478,
-0.0471264459,
0.0209662709,
-0.0042570867,
-0.0390932076,
-0.0545413978,
-0.0503987633,
-0.027914051,
-0.0447459072,
-0.0101702595,
0.0055202763,
-0.0472381115,
-0.0408015363,
-0.0221440494,
0.0036905804,
0.0352617539,
-0.0226442814,
0.0199168418,
0.0417140834,
-0.0329544842,
0.0194475818,
0.0806775242,
-0.0558133982,
-0.0016271831,
-0.0155595792,
-0.0487620644,
0.0299518835,
0.0242739543,
-0.0506218299,
-0.0375090763,
0.0589694679,
-0.0199678354,
-0.0506658033,
0.0516597219,
-0.01336163,
-0.0449486002,
-0.0263364408,
-0.0644245222,
-0.08521384,
-0.0036495915,
-0.0384409986,
0.0540161729,
0.0211731177,
-0.0439216644,
-0.0232971013,
-0.0164242014,
0.0233111829,
0.058906924,
0.0379728302,
-0.0223954115,
0.0038866298,
-0.0132984687,
0.0258419979,
-0.0439567082,
0.0184320137,
-0.055105906,
0.0458613485,
-0.0788870156,
-0.0002775053,
-0.0033449435,
0.0309567191,
0.0189255644,
-0.0413330123,
-0.0672010258,
-0.0214154888,
0.0118259462,
-0.0029880276,
0.0291322358,
0.0490004122,
-0.0163027998,
-0.0853078961,
-0.0128129069,
0.0195997618,
0.0485591628,
0.0199906677,
0.0052845585,
0.009244536,
-0.0078381067,
-0.0953436196,
-0.0393291824,
0.0057353186,
-0.0381858535,
-0.0162461344,
-0.0808665082,
-0.0600582398,
0.0049161687,
-0.01610508,
-0.0063535585,
0.0188039131,
0.0011369381,
0.0060859616,
0.0273203831,
0.089791961,
-0.0020405676,
-0.0064959694,
0.0195473004,
-0.0061512133,
0.0514473803,
0.0207968466,
0.0236711558,
-0.05951849,
0.0389661342,
0.0154232169,
0.0385023318,
0.0295739528,
-0.0382558182,
-0.0206982046,
0.014339746,
-0.0470111035,
-0.0015007035,
0.0520019755,
0.0304481573,
0.0434681028,
-0.009279958,
0.0070907678,
0.0498397239,
0.0158852078,
0.0138544356,
0.0263947789,
0.0504821017,
-0.0226411503,
0.0016626053,
0.0435359254,
-0.0021152417,
-0.0305786841,
-0.0409026183,
0.0133310342,
-0.0175928511,
0.0888065249,
-0.0038968013,
-0.0677095056,
-0.0129231447,
-0.0176706854,
-0.0030924678,
-0.0290840324,
0.0774077252,
0.0373142138,
-0.0626936555,
0.0078520123,
0.0104630133,
-0.0702082068,
0.0011059318,
-0.0261322986,
-0.0087761069,
0.0130274808,
0.0283116046,
-0.0043815072,
-0.0675655603,
-0.0166389588,
-0.0251116157,
0.0316546746,
0.0413007364,
-0.0193328485,
0.0096682729,
-0.0464716852,
-0.0120111201,
0.0506242961,
0.0247338824,
-0.010573552,
-0.0002874663,
0.034072578,
0.0147830211,
0.0089720581,
-0.0382172503,
0.0401261486,
0.0125973122,
0.016903596,
-0.0251701605,
-0.0046655755,
0.0320478268,
0.0306578837,
-0.0343189761,
0.0037885492,
0.0033493892,
-0.0202127416,
-0.028619986,
-0.0071633481,
-0.0462891534,
-0.0711750016,
0.0432798341,
-0.0139443353,
-0.0432273932,
0.018703077,
-0.0317648649,
-0.0444804318,
0.0214616563,
-0.0238790698,
0.0356834158,
-0.0668954253,
0.0953097045,
0.02670593,
0.0405192226,
0.0006777219,
0.0011468068,
-0.0127960891,
-0.0003468428,
-0.0121621499,
-0.0240624212,
0.0106009645,
-0.0294495914,
-0.0186708905,
-0.0088983448,
-0.0024207521,
0.0197205096,
0.0449112095,
0.0025293813,
-0.0057064439,
-0.0422181487,
-0.0737144649,
-0.0283886287,
-0.0588111468,
0.0788688436,
0.0014708403,
0.0154036237,
-0.0141431568,
-0.0427191593,
0.0217433032,
0.0256227255,
0.0416065715,
-0.0055688862,
0.0665764809,
-0.0299243201,
-0.0070411353,
-0.0640652031,
0.0090990346,
0.0019753152,
0.0102040265,
0.0346785784,
-0.0358332247,
-0.0459104888,
-0.0101995962,
-0.0160975624,
0.0643428341,
0.0441664681,
-0.0495536812,
0.0175315607,
-0.0068712076,
0.0846605226,
0.0055946726,
0.0024098374,
0.0113536622,
-0.0082298024,
-0.047012955,
0.0064884783,
-0.0073162401,
-0.0163347777,
-0.0352286845,
-0.0536403917,
-0.0113876872,
0.0223104432,
0.0738284886,
-0.0249434095,
-0.0396825224,
0.0031681217,
0.0010329379,
-0.005419943,
0.0239627622,
0.0276177861,
-0.0054430817,
0.0108850366,
0.0492836051,
-0.0220385976,
-0.0154942414,
0.0215768684,
-0.0216282848,
-0.0101023894,
-0.0126023786,
0.0103312004,
-0.0154358922,
-0.0276061688,
0.012293282,
0.0222531538,
0.0199079476,
-0.0643155798,
-0.0604631416,
0.0207447652,
0.0458232313,
-0.0053487048,
0.0287697148,
-0.1018199846,
0.0104519604,
0.0035783101,
-0.0505171679,
0.0123667186,
0.0016382061,
-0.0121123521,
-0.0336731225,
0.0311703514,
-0.0221337434,
-0.0346759669,
0.0066028382,
-0.028007362,
0.0758600533,
0.027469445,
-0.0202986207,
-0.0050303494,
0.0184503905,
-0.0190210976,
0.0075892452,
0.0236896481,
-0.0033836726,
-0.0045895875,
0.0665860698,
-0.0676112846,
0.0059010587,
-0.0478223637,
-0.004911188,
0.063077569,
-0.0506390966,
-0.0560068898,
-0.0391941294,
0.0124600194,
-0.0495254397,
-0.0252824333,
0.0923303962,
0.0295400377,
-0.0055203666,
-0.0000804957,
0.0240719412,
-0.0484342463,
-0.0224006455,
-0.018649146,
-0.0720111057,
-0.009619615,
0.0633232296,
-0.0003476997,
-0.0053151408,
0.0107392371,
0.0453675352,
-0.1061673537,
0.0345045514,
0.0110056968,
-0.0335968174,
-0.081798844,
0.0143154953,
0.0125899846,
0.0004806342,
0.0329298973,
0.0007196729,
-0.0030927125,
0.0118742967,
0.0507714339,
-0.0245891213,
-0.0960194096,
-0.0310477503,
-0.0211733412,
0.0306657329,
0.0535637438,
-0.0010562876,
-0.001099285,
-0.0298899114,
0.0482727475,
-0.0304970834,
-0.0417111181,
0.0182540957,
0.0086867716,
-0.0158754494,
-0.022577906,
-0.036911834,
0.0042298357,
-0.0570761636,
0.0157655012,
-0.0222461447,
0.0430471748,
0.0021348612,
0.0358940624,
0.035421215,
0.0020331282,
-0.0032917641,
-0.0096547101,
-0.0103301965,
-0.027208522,
-0.0425265655,
-0.0402176529,
-0.0168168731,
-0.0506967679,
0.0078954007,
0.0053690905,
0.0002406157,
0.0063464129,
-0.0901358649,
-0.0709412098,
0.0045939726,
-0.0106882434,
0.0244516004,
-0.042330429,
0.0025131416,
-0.0056901611,
-0.0023585148,
-0.046608936,
0.0206757188,
0.0123721678,
-0.0880136266,
0.0125571629,
0.0009575593,
0.0030307099,
0.023280751,
-0.0141301043,
-0.0566629916,
-0.0190264843,
0.0334779173,
0.0095117241,
-0.0020991494,
-0.0067257923,
-0.0135345627,
-0.0311266407,
0.0255359206,
0.030591622,
0.0019320699,
0.0479583405,
0.0423377082,
-0.0415786728,
-0.0311302282,
0.0314966179,
0.0390636623,
0.0139063299,
0.0102809342,
0.0141453799,
-0.0329396911,
-0.0332731083,
0.0419600047,
-0.0165776052,
0.051148843,
-0.0182145089,
0.0211738832,
-0.0572282448,
0.0201270767,
-0.0190540571,
0.0117188031,
-0.0184108503,
0.0336582027,
0.0339713395,
0.0266068745,
-0.0103163393,
0.0012768342,
-0.0387148745,
-0.0165575091,
-0.0414120182,
0.0379690938,
0.0222365446,
-0.0011859486,
0.0167123657,
0.0250964165,
0.0332323015,
-0.047089655,
0.0157746337,
0.0357967131,
-0.0238354802,
0.0220102146,
0.010577389,
0.0423403792,
0.0240195729,
0.0402707867,
0.0052906461,
0.0551002212,
-0.0466685109,
0.0601383187,
0.1027687341,
-0.0002818858,
0.0679822639,
-0.0148557918,
-0.0027723417,
-0.0161622111,
0.0632004738,
-0.0171468537,
-0.0249146186,
-0.0216341205,
-0.0216437243,
-0.0020087715,
-0.0029828059,
0.0609423518,
-0.0278523676,
0.0181607958,
0.0239376854,
-0.0417097844,
-0.0098713264,
-0.0318905711,
0.0119639095,
-0.0435067639,
-0.0393728316,
-0.0045180353,
-0.015694499,
-0.0807875767,
-0.0067232908,
0.0504234806,
0.0418385454,
0.0171880871,
-0.0046496699,
0.0567331724,
-0.0040845028,
-0.0095804324,
-0.043299444,
-0.0165254809,
0.0083830394,
-0.0197508093,
-0.0101777446,
-5.218072321e-33,
-0.0298366584,
-0.005664607,
-0.0328691304,
0.008686373,
0.0158906039,
-0.0123184696,
-0.019729251,
0.007406076,
0.0543077923,
0.0445764475,
-0.0113019161,
0.0407128744,
0.0302462745,
0.0222017374,
0.096383661,
0.02196352,
0.0721193328,
0.0145809883,
-0.0016427642,
-0.0210286342,
0.0224592146,
0.0560217276,
0.1386747807,
-0.0210834648,
0.0312881209,
0.0025186895,
-0.0358911194,
0.0160852708,
-0.0156850964,
0.0557177477,
0.0219257884,
0.0616619252,
-0.007969249,
-0.010780232,
-0.0299334042,
-0.0215337463,
-0.0860116854,
-0.0076994328,
-0.0262490716,
0.0716120154,
-0.0086868871,
-0.002579791,
-0.0065484247,
-0.0184915904,
-0.0221842062,
0.0300537292,
0.0055152723,
-0.0240770411,
0.0339139067,
-0.0172056705,
-0.0849251598,
0.0388056152,
-0.0077580996,
-0.0024486338,
0.0346486568,
0.0272142496,
-0.0058874632,
-0.0387296118,
-0.0359399021,
-0.0078886664,
0.0241857693,
0.0345595181,
0.0206503365,
-0.0103275971,
-0.1112837866,
-0.0266949069,
0.0099346936,
-0.0416925028,
0.046411667,
0.0417675488,
-0.0134211462,
-0.03584769,
0.0218561962,
0.0437486209,
0.046709273,
-0.0200844947,
-0.0322372541,
0.008328517,
-0.0438546427,
0.0513619855,
-0.0128457453,
-0.0154893622,
-0.0335052907,
-0.0226362646,
0.0115882447,
-0.0320351087,
0.0063901083,
0.0183997415,
0.0196689982,
0.0203755461,
0.0016301573,
0.0719544515,
-0.0201747678,
-0.0009289598,
-0.0047492776,
-0.0274227727,
-0.0047790087,
0.0046136603,
-0.0326728746,
0.0310290027,
-0.0386451967,
-0.0413108952,
0.0336413383,
0.0466419458,
0.0053447965,
-0.0043612402,
0.0505843163,
0.0677547306,
-0.0925322026,
0.0349084772,
-0.0121257035,
0.0496429056,
0.0056000305,
0.049676992,
0.0278030392,
-0.0267258566,
0.0016261783,
0.0182405133,
0.0160687119,
-0.0135326935,
-0.01617245,
-0.0208390448,
-0.0456102751,
-0.0081539406,
0.0089781135,
0.0108707808,
-0.0453845486,
-0.0019060621,
0.0178072918,
-0.0164251421,
-0.0011034367,
-0.0172473863,
2.544e-7,
0.0397291631,
0.0273793638,
0.0462071523,
-0.0125745805,
-0.0185328387,
-0.0008257569,
0.0040010684,
0.0441946536,
-0.0051032095,
0.0953851789,
0.0384360589,
-0.0413648002,
0.0413985439,
-0.0069387457,
-0.0294545665,
-0.0565346666,
-0.0283631459,
0.0356165767,
-0.030772496,
-0.0273711998,
0.0585601255,
0.0875094384,
-0.0237201881,
-0.0177473649,
-0.0205098353,
-0.0347628221,
0.0458826646,
-0.0040790052,
-0.0160539467,
0.0275103841,
0.084898293,
-0.0041945097,
0.0432911888,
0.0246525127,
-0.0360843055,
-0.0153970998,
0.0181366205,
0.0294530299,
0.0038032921,
0.0344261527,
-0.0030646396,
0.0275547821,
-0.0293055307,
-0.0287353806,
0.0218524039,
-0.0126473447,
0.030801272,
0.0286370721,
-0.0190387946,
0.0231983811,
0.0003751001,
-0.0201662537,
-0.010680208,
0.004766535,
0.0742470771,
0.0341141522,
-0.028999988,
-0.0404180884,
0.0447792523,
0.0320845284,
0.0310464781,
0.0017818983,
0.0314891785,
-0.0090865782,
-0.0005312337,
-0.0042118137,
-0.0349624939,
2.194821522e-34,
0.0533138402,
0.0048753684,
0.0354124233,
-0.0031003805,
0.0260422062,
-0.0046624686,
-0.0151424361,
0.0185816474,
-0.0306925811,
-0.0097136488,
-0.0197224114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14728v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14728v2 | SenteCon: Leveraging Lexicons to Learn Human-Interpretable Language Representations | 2023-05-24T05:06:28 | 2023-06-01T20:55:25 | Victoria Lin, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although deep language representations have become the dominant form of
language featurization in recent years, in many settings it is important to
understand a model's decision-making process. This necessitates not only an
interpretable model but also interpretable features. In particular, language
must be featurized in a way that is interpretable while still characterizing
the original text well. We present SenteCon, a method for introducing human
interpretability in deep language representations. Given a passage of text,
SenteCon encodes the text as a layer of interpretable categories in which each
dimension corresponds to the relevance of a specific category. Our empirical
evaluations indicate that encoding language with SenteCon provides high-level
interpretability at little to no cost to predictive performance on downstream
tasks. Moreover, we find that SenteCon outperforms existing interpretable
language representations with respect to both its downstream performance and
its agreement with human characterizations of the text. | [
0.0031690111,
0.0629876405,
-0.0113521647,
0.0627003387,
0.0279810634,
0.0209542532,
0.0093638012,
-0.0175936297,
0.0114558693,
-0.043580316,
-0.0287661348,
-0.0259409882,
-0.0133762956,
0.0797795877,
-0.0044051553,
-0.0583854616,
0.0283818729,
-0.0010971742,
0.0079654707,
0.0325408615,
-0.0082975384,
0.0189923123,
-0.013775168,
0.0523279645,
0.0046021966,
-0.0431591906,
-0.009742314,
-0.0077925301,
0.0003950564,
0.0025801165,
0.005992983,
0.0407266691,
0.0449243598,
0.0537619777,
0.0000019489,
-0.0067772232,
-0.0125290239,
-0.026569359,
-0.059239842,
0.0153682828,
0.0402350165,
-0.035563048,
-0.0081111044,
-0.0526816808,
-0.0019163328,
-0.0113183716,
0.0342013016,
0.0563308299,
0.0767039806,
0.0472639352,
-0.0064587696,
-0.0333372243,
0.02018198,
-0.0118418857,
0.0037270046,
-0.0460217819,
-0.0169132818,
-0.0031550361,
-0.0353894532,
0.04394418,
-0.0603394769,
0.0273190998,
0.0343414582,
-0.0234650243,
0.0177703686,
-0.0010268787,
-0.004726734,
-0.036055062,
0.01485305,
0.0990053639,
-0.0128314979,
0.0046457611,
-0.0310318191,
-0.0404681936,
0.0211721063,
-0.0055528875,
-0.0044652061,
-0.0266659651,
0.0457063951,
0.0409444347,
-0.0033924496,
0.0267881602,
0.0473906919,
0.0167584401,
-0.0234628431,
0.0626110211,
-0.0295660626,
0.0342932828,
-0.0011621983,
0.0186230894,
0.0132806329,
0.0007239922,
0.0267602243,
-0.0150326211,
-0.023533728,
0.0270210728,
-0.0137614831,
-0.0034827932,
-0.0042052385,
-0.0554887764,
0.0244933218,
0.0171327237,
-0.0433585867,
0.0487072729,
-0.0375117287,
0.0325113498,
-0.0519556031,
0.0188503843,
-0.0096263047,
-0.0421160869,
-0.0660927296,
-0.0340832807,
0.0088056438,
0.006246719,
-0.0362708531,
-0.0283525009,
-0.0332098976,
0.0080465637,
-0.0306765623,
-0.019241089,
-0.0019804589,
0.0342462696,
-0.0651784465,
-0.0242098402,
-0.024546776,
0.0032610318,
-0.0419612378,
0.0271159746,
-0.0051045413,
-0.0172760747,
-0.0154410601,
0.0226937588,
0.0037693025,
-0.0301768687,
-0.0286492463,
0.0583109483,
0.0161959771,
-0.0318698995,
-0.0242948234,
-0.0427835621,
-0.0024792731,
-0.0090924352,
0.0034351475,
-0.0170670059,
0.0103988303,
-0.0354782045,
-0.0020767362,
-0.06379392,
-0.0075373845,
-0.0244646687,
-0.0263685193,
0.0865368545,
0.0095844828,
-0.0529499613,
-0.0166033134,
0.0240886509,
0.0007324445,
0.0735205039,
0.0196828078,
0.0730840042,
0.0315699726,
-0.012588108,
0.0009080992,
-0.0043899408,
0.0275955405,
-0.0175309591,
-0.0083519816,
-0.0147958025,
-0.0768323988,
0.0323258489,
0.0910186693,
-0.0005711356,
-0.0139314216,
-0.0431859754,
0.0195080582,
0.0224158205,
0.0740985051,
0.0483322479,
0.0276589878,
0.0562534146,
-0.039891094,
-0.0161340069,
-0.0511916168,
0.0495882295,
-0.0040749745,
-0.0351464786,
-0.0081338128,
-0.0236686114,
-0.0107118022,
-0.0312038604,
0.0249375571,
-0.0129824281,
0.0523227826,
-0.0185146723,
0.0495938249,
0.0063117165,
-0.0159180593,
0.0857900754,
0.026561223,
-0.0505115427,
0.0185030177,
-0.0270885359,
0.0199531,
0.084162727,
0.0201826729,
-0.0339783393,
0.0206264388,
-0.0220461283,
0.0141490782,
0.0472207889,
0.0130268494,
-0.0110909073,
0.0786717907,
-0.0287583508,
-0.0436095968,
-0.0050141294,
0.0105019957,
0.0124607962,
-0.0176232681,
-0.0143465875,
0.0184401441,
-0.0233943779,
-0.0386205651,
0.0378154628,
0.0202222709,
-0.033754997,
0.0099086976,
0.0015997987,
0.0516140126,
0.0254120193,
0.0216799211,
-0.0120709296,
-0.005402361,
-0.0318740308,
-0.0736003146,
0.0222892407,
-0.0676222965,
-0.0264814626,
-0.0108930534,
-0.0531791933,
-0.024233181,
0.0614830442,
-0.0339300185,
-0.0243847724,
0.0425738841,
-0.0767022744,
0.0060760346,
-0.0425741524,
-0.0387229212,
-0.0172589347,
0.0362749733,
0.0101376893,
0.0498274006,
-0.0378820449,
-0.0426672883,
-0.02755896,
-0.0423646495,
0.002537864,
0.009901558,
0.0227299891,
0.0010070741,
0.0335541889,
0.0068647075,
0.0145280529,
0.0032411744,
-0.0399766676,
0.0002538462,
-0.0329660997,
-0.0035615144,
-0.0238144137,
-0.0142056672,
0.0129778227,
-0.0085773943,
0.0376901738,
-0.0226427764,
-0.040130306,
0.01094021,
-0.0432555862,
0.0207973476,
0.0267555863,
-0.0145162968,
-0.0020807532,
-0.0388792977,
-0.0224342421,
-0.0110873869,
0.0655877143,
-0.0032860206,
0.0062970761,
-0.0197781026,
-0.0010854068,
0.010481135,
0.0047243903,
0.0117575508,
-0.0445865989,
-0.0176252797,
-0.009854123,
-0.0510443226,
0.0255891588,
0.0046966975,
0.1041749641,
-0.0062411665,
0.0074651875,
-0.0534032285,
-0.0133001031,
-0.0073528215,
0.0360686928,
-0.0183545873,
-0.0464339554,
-0.0004056772,
0.0819697753,
0.0055606687,
-0.009673954,
-0.0631235987,
0.0118615143,
-0.0397172309,
-0.069354251,
-0.0430177376,
0.0014176195,
-0.0143084731,
0.0436348952,
-0.0177571345,
-0.0296879243,
0.0781954527,
0.0013255932,
-0.0252698082,
-0.0366177671,
0.0083177062,
-0.0434410647,
0.0703867674,
-0.0064344006,
0.0129295578,
-0.0507297926,
-0.0642861053,
-0.0214618165,
0.0098013887,
-0.0060750232,
-0.00954632,
0.0519482791,
-0.0278738849,
-0.0067953914,
0.0150897885,
-0.0205877852,
-0.0176284853,
-0.0379213244,
-0.0206782706,
0.0268852152,
0.0393359847,
-0.0216780771,
-0.0476309583,
-0.0545523129,
0.0121124946,
0.0107318601,
-0.0082613584,
-0.0215108655,
-0.0169495046,
0.0093607204,
0.0247390252,
0.0370516777,
0.0199569613,
0.0001093289,
0.0155904461,
0.0654443875,
-0.0588217787,
-0.0181581844,
-0.0431008711,
0.0505461842,
0.0181888398,
-0.030269986,
-0.0353532694,
-0.0333820321,
0.0762572736,
-0.0899234489,
-0.0024610807,
0.0839757472,
0.0215215422,
-0.0240123011,
0.033904355,
-0.0378763899,
-0.0046743634,
0.0133744804,
0.0090649789,
-0.0331224203,
-0.0641698614,
-0.0078759762,
0.0212088209,
0.0138497772,
-0.0473263636,
-0.0036660391,
-0.0342217013,
0.0264056511,
-0.0152241942,
-0.0228267517,
-0.0346892327,
-0.0255061071,
-0.0207175612,
-0.0419417769,
0.0127304317,
0.0142152961,
0.0348358266,
-0.0075077531,
0.0057101939,
-0.0371751748,
-0.0104761627,
0.0651834831,
-0.0108160861,
0.0426361598,
0.064323619,
0.0446503237,
-0.0177360121,
-0.0339904167,
-0.0133111114,
-0.0212381277,
0.009320477,
-0.0047703311,
0.0758790448,
-0.0026245755,
-0.0352623016,
-0.0205530282,
0.0528994538,
-0.0611036532,
-0.015015211,
-0.0252340753,
0.065912433,
0.0019713633,
-0.0188136492,
-0.0433388986,
-0.0155721214,
0.0284003969,
0.0835556388,
0.0497539937,
-0.0495906658,
-0.0348433293,
-0.0580964722,
-0.0015233923,
-0.0588703081,
-0.0528790057,
0.0027468945,
0.0362306833,
-0.0258153882,
-0.0315016732,
-0.0698391572,
-0.0063110394,
0.0079604257,
-0.0162824672,
-0.0131998528,
-0.0040595448,
-0.0175510775,
-0.0639464483,
0.0503514074,
-0.0046695163,
0.0066866986,
-0.0158227906,
-0.0547227636,
0.013012168,
-0.0306490697,
-0.0342467651,
0.0413149782,
-0.0123983948,
0.0046838988,
0.0333128795,
0.0175868906,
0.022595793,
0.0344427861,
-0.024973657,
-0.0659991503,
0.0455583371,
0.0021508553,
-0.0564467721,
0.0021166194,
0.0708504766,
0.0133085744,
0.0072969217,
0.0567368716,
-0.0509264581,
0.0616872385,
-0.0148831578,
0.0079799332,
-0.0148145873,
-0.0440076254,
-0.0077578351,
-0.0479435995,
0.024146419,
0.0032371497,
-0.0093997801,
-0.0424762554,
-0.0239902902,
-0.0277619082,
0.0134176137,
-0.0468835533,
0.0334197842,
0.0437256582,
-0.0513164438,
-0.0150655545,
-0.0224388689,
-0.0141000934,
-0.020194333,
0.0098928269,
0.024099363,
0.0447624512,
0.0281953104,
-0.0203728154,
0.0324884057,
-0.0347406603,
0.0386870615,
-0.0432209559,
0.057016708,
0.0100393016,
0.0661465228,
0.00150036,
-0.0152551979,
-0.0408292562,
0.036187131,
-0.0650820136,
-0.0448212065,
-0.0008066474,
-0.0031434686,
-0.0173955131,
-0.0022292759,
0.0328540169,
-0.0106757125,
0.0082393801,
-0.0030579334,
0.0380578153,
0.0058231135,
-0.036873024,
-0.0150228757,
0.011448184,
-0.0318631046,
0.0005580775,
0.0740158185,
0.0068347589,
0.013166598,
-0.0359351337,
0.0100841904,
-0.0621126667,
-0.0173914302,
0.0242351256,
0.0475752801,
-0.0151175261,
0.0244391579,
-0.0305381995,
-0.054864347,
0.0544310771,
0.0000308585,
0.0131487846,
-0.0015373146,
0.0244207475,
0.0410945043,
-0.0172403101,
-0.0122160334,
-0.0622840561,
0.0235100742,
-0.0001572589,
0.0088678347,
0.0101046609,
-6.166621324e-33,
-0.0228948891,
-0.0165486559,
-0.0385639481,
-0.0001430949,
-0.002987267,
0.0339274332,
-0.0665663481,
0.0198734365,
0.0000615327,
0.0506978519,
0.0434215106,
0.0498940945,
0.0092860544,
0.0451590903,
0.0258981343,
-0.0478915423,
0.0634424612,
0.0284324251,
0.008852982,
0.0480892099,
0.1159081087,
0.0492931306,
0.0480359904,
-0.0761950314,
0.0730612576,
0.0244945176,
0.0071449731,
0.0092403572,
0.0304988381,
0.0555582829,
-0.0406867899,
0.0437619947,
0.0293176752,
-0.0558972619,
-0.0414561704,
0.0187266339,
-0.0677686632,
-0.026488604,
-0.0096708601,
0.0457095467,
-0.0847709626,
-0.0315531194,
0.0534017868,
0.0000461545,
0.032137841,
-0.0460778587,
0.0383246429,
-0.0195314847,
-0.0151992794,
0.013539562,
-0.0711339563,
0.0242695622,
-0.0320838653,
-0.0170111302,
0.0414490104,
0.040469788,
0.0075267144,
0.0429455973,
-0.0852529928,
-0.0538445413,
-0.0550895818,
0.0101074316,
0.0496218503,
-0.0145209748,
-0.0245337095,
0.1105168089,
0.0248759463,
-0.0569100529,
-0.0644403994,
0.0150027229,
0.0216870308,
0.0338477641,
0.0302340481,
0.0587871075,
0.0133638484,
-0.0093653882,
-0.0296824072,
0.0133964522,
0.0136768268,
0.0064568059,
0.0377865545,
0.0497572832,
-0.079978101,
-0.0175379831,
-0.0001184795,
-0.0114682345,
-0.0356207043,
-0.0303228069,
0.018132465,
-0.0446666367,
-0.0381864645,
0.0231573563,
0.0525324643,
-0.0474878363,
0.0028402684,
0.0316536166,
0.0023781182,
-0.0044594463,
0.0204367265,
0.0365638956,
0.0012112821,
-0.0108787622,
0.0157052092,
-0.0067934454,
0.043253962,
-0.0059746373,
0.0523317568,
0.0105823316,
0.0020630651,
-0.0194220617,
-0.0333238654,
-0.0331758149,
-0.0288637821,
0.0693958998,
0.0237433948,
0.0039144233,
-0.0513154678,
0.054106608,
0.0156662669,
0.0077319727,
-0.0098974472,
0.0253712796,
0.0179964546,
0.0272123925,
-0.0532357879,
-0.0682727545,
-0.0247352477,
-0.0207544286,
0.0355322845,
-0.0916054472,
0.0001508965,
0.0078883916,
2.49e-7,
0.0541655086,
0.0150154931,
0.0149833467,
-0.0162053425,
0.0547155365,
0.065416798,
0.0330318846,
0.0434080213,
-0.0355960466,
-0.0206425376,
0.0044264439,
0.0331833325,
0.0309770852,
0.0281921383,
-0.0549532399,
0.0039191004,
-0.0086441701,
0.024074778,
-0.0160531793,
-0.0035628485,
0.0947309956,
0.1250283569,
0.0368921049,
-0.0096926922,
0.0726490468,
-0.0008521383,
0.0355169661,
-0.0352055691,
0.0339464359,
-0.0056517031,
0.0176837835,
0.0726960599,
0.0109767951,
0.0032402729,
-0.0172305088,
0.0178119615,
0.0159464758,
0.056003876,
-0.0343874693,
-0.0386211649,
-0.0333229005,
-0.0302005932,
0.0325451493,
-0.0285957828,
0.0418077074,
-0.0467577651,
-0.0461454652,
-0.0201810636,
-0.0004734699,
0.0126106935,
0.0249502342,
0.0021368354,
0.0214026459,
0.0173559487,
0.0074621905,
-0.0485357158,
0.0062693842,
-0.0821827576,
-0.0203270596,
-0.048655428,
-0.0592054799,
0.0275705308,
-0.0368741974,
0.0229685772,
0.0531989634,
-0.0418633036,
-0.0242499802,
1.65965453e-34,
0.0146097047,
0.0356808417,
0.0240998659,
0.0337849557,
0.0240648352,
0.004725704,
0.0116843088,
-0.0001779746,
0.0437416025,
-0.0261313375,
-0.0192149747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14726v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14726v2 | In-Context Demonstration Selection with Cross Entropy Difference | 2023-05-24T05:04:00 | 2023-11-27T19:53:27 | Dan Iter, Reid Pryzant, Ruochen Xu, Shuohang Wang, Yang Liu, Yichong Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) can use in-context demonstrations to improve
performance on zero-shot tasks. However, selecting the best in-context examples
is challenging because model performance can vary widely depending on the
selected examples. We present a cross-entropy difference (CED) method for
selecting in-context demonstrations. Our method is based on the observation
that the effectiveness of in-context demonstrations negatively correlates with
the perplexity of the test example by a language model that was finetuned on
that demonstration. We utilize parameter efficient finetuning to train small
models on training data that are used for computing the cross-entropy
difference between a test example and every candidate in-context demonstration.
This metric is used to rank and select in-context demonstrations independently
for each test input. We evaluate our method on a mix-domain dataset that
combines 8 benchmarks, representing 4 text generation tasks, showing that CED
for in-context demonstration selection can improve performance for a variety of
LLMs. | [
-0.0268526692,
0.030858716,
0.0160804391,
0.031421829,
-0.0493291505,
0.0240217354,
0.057755325,
0.0180127062,
-0.0439869314,
-0.0825141221,
-0.0220078193,
-0.0446423441,
0.0080046291,
-0.0305825714,
0.0737329349,
-0.0362330005,
0.0105490601,
-0.0369529352,
-0.0394223779,
0.0198668595,
-0.0135453762,
-0.001842288,
-0.0235860329,
0.027193753,
0.0053271591,
-0.0202199109,
-0.0146432035,
0.0419007614,
0.0324683227,
-0.0434099846,
0.0040992936,
0.0637065992,
0.0253780875,
0.0474717319,
0.0000018997,
-0.0468071401,
-0.0097197369,
0.0296127722,
-0.0219220668,
0.0232095774,
0.0338768587,
-0.0034980376,
-0.0296352692,
0.026448302,
-0.0202209558,
-0.0216637161,
0.042856805,
0.0342286974,
0.0112281777,
0.0596801713,
0.0050657061,
-0.0016397531,
-0.0079271439,
-0.0615585782,
0.0276165828,
-0.0142483441,
0.0087832753,
-0.0260957628,
0.0249183439,
-0.0273233354,
-0.0060957428,
0.0196154173,
0.0447770543,
-0.0011676425,
-0.0279640704,
0.0638172776,
-0.0217164513,
0.0408853665,
-0.0037526486,
0.0505380109,
-0.0507134832,
-0.0228702128,
0.016360566,
-0.0469622202,
-0.0139475418,
-0.0261749122,
-0.050764367,
0.0034511876,
0.0197341833,
0.0051119714,
0.0161491428,
0.0081656985,
0.0215036832,
0.0389021039,
-0.0298063103,
0.0220129024,
0.0131667545,
-0.0403076112,
-0.0080632549,
0.0219145752,
-0.0428927653,
-0.073741436,
-0.0453603379,
0.0102347545,
-0.0549389832,
0.0110313455,
-0.0654436201,
-0.0615375005,
0.0219471641,
-0.0000635683,
0.0720290244,
0.0135412691,
0.0261984132,
0.0061360481,
-0.037902087,
0.0795337111,
0.0273972396,
0.0631765053,
-0.0158861838,
0.0449530445,
-0.0495519899,
0.0184612703,
-0.0295347981,
0.0095902132,
-0.0366262086,
-0.0259226374,
-0.0431578197,
0.004270291,
-0.0214055944,
0.0101367859,
0.0033194749,
-0.0258577373,
-0.0661197007,
0.0128837312,
0.035026554,
-0.0040235911,
-0.0308790002,
0.0142308054,
0.0558794439,
-0.059771508,
-0.0344072208,
0.0331956036,
0.007853155,
-0.032299716,
-0.0052898047,
0.0611673035,
-0.0283408742,
-0.0699849203,
-0.0407088548,
-0.0265827272,
-0.0108619649,
-0.0875804275,
0.0098586585,
-0.0791080818,
-0.0029962959,
0.0076887137,
0.0108978925,
-0.0340886638,
-0.0135763688,
-0.0003902987,
0.0318127275,
0.0217200872,
0.0193091389,
-0.0193938687,
0.0164254364,
0.0094413394,
0.0091136908,
0.1217662171,
0.0270042382,
0.021695938,
0.0128117055,
0.0258004554,
-0.0103217866,
0.0264609735,
0.048247207,
0.031933818,
-0.0531837456,
-0.0007654756,
-0.0024280951,
0.0586911812,
0.0457502455,
0.006884512,
-0.0599285029,
0.0527284592,
0.0531909689,
0.0348775014,
0.046586968,
-0.0472531393,
0.059561152,
-0.003104412,
-0.0181473382,
0.0377963036,
-0.0258289948,
0.0256508924,
-0.0000890767,
0.0531610213,
0.0876452997,
0.0016008181,
-0.037084341,
-0.0201530606,
-0.0040571541,
-0.0085472325,
-0.0114735886,
-0.0013010091,
0.0312493928,
0.0339833274,
-0.0608096793,
0.0154336104,
0.0353346951,
-0.0579509437,
0.0121556018,
-0.042801369,
-0.0012814228,
0.0576186366,
0.0546874143,
-0.0156384092,
-0.0113993054,
-0.030856967,
0.0430944003,
0.0541843325,
0.0419618785,
-0.0035273465,
0.010896869,
-0.0296181571,
-0.0208276119,
-0.0517086424,
0.0329497382,
-0.0143617895,
0.0239640512,
0.0266785901,
0.0573605932,
-0.0566209592,
0.0097569572,
0.0473746769,
-0.0661038607,
-0.0310147498,
0.0174473859,
0.0179076474,
0.020863317,
-0.0205143541,
-0.0451678373,
0.0101923598,
0.0085649854,
-0.0371243693,
0.027622547,
0.0174845718,
-0.0315253176,
-0.1005785316,
-0.009805941,
-0.0263021495,
0.0038949053,
0.0009565278,
-0.0386622399,
-0.0229880475,
-0.0038051722,
-0.0125383241,
0.0594307221,
-0.056622766,
0.0167066567,
-0.001732602,
-0.0104824863,
-0.0567034967,
0.0588553026,
0.001032175,
0.0324087888,
0.029287409,
0.0226731077,
-0.0085742474,
-0.0329404213,
0.0127688311,
0.0150144203,
-0.01245239,
0.0235806573,
-0.0067089032,
0.0563558005,
-0.0244726706,
-0.0272012409,
-0.0556789637,
0.0463942848,
-0.0571558438,
0.0529096052,
0.0176034197,
0.0112319682,
-0.0011379793,
0.0255878232,
-0.0100433212,
0.0128703034,
0.0030316261,
0.0198901575,
0.0271624345,
0.0356611721,
0.0069461209,
-0.0203700531,
-0.0055759456,
0.0202831812,
0.0813868269,
-0.0194307584,
0.0731606111,
-0.0434528776,
0.0783373788,
-0.0014490564,
-0.0057232757,
0.0123018222,
-0.0238783099,
0.0425025672,
-0.0058665713,
0.0114146313,
0.0416669324,
0.0036169903,
0.0298201218,
0.0019372009,
0.006706357,
-0.06036596,
-0.0180646945,
0.0101088518,
0.0260705613,
-0.0206026491,
-0.0086003309,
0.0085643269,
0.0319147743,
0.0063498956,
0.0099746305,
-0.0531138778,
0.0283895023,
-0.0278113894,
-0.0318954401,
-0.0325282253,
0.02103341,
-0.0140802851,
0.0084390026,
-0.0232857913,
-0.0591724627,
0.0657503456,
-0.0443684496,
0.0198352076,
-0.0315569825,
0.0287701357,
-0.0150245195,
0.037454661,
-0.0125108026,
0.0129186595,
0.0021552199,
-0.0207226444,
-0.0345535837,
0.0061047776,
0.017620977,
-0.0084879864,
0.0355138704,
-0.0394647606,
0.0085470891,
-0.025134122,
-0.0542373583,
-0.0363743939,
-0.0367255062,
0.0133205978,
0.02698051,
0.0040188809,
0.0054614213,
-0.0049742097,
-0.0010730415,
0.0197025165,
0.0622149408,
-0.0166550279,
-0.02621199,
-0.0377864204,
0.0105290711,
0.0409060679,
0.0175102428,
0.0052221916,
-0.0651210994,
0.0221086107,
0.0227819905,
0.0757886395,
0.0282290149,
-0.0445164107,
-0.0117164934,
-0.0040746224,
-0.0408236161,
-0.0000251066,
0.0589042604,
0.0779745057,
-0.0539789647,
-0.0311724208,
0.0992824063,
0.0192263406,
-0.0327742659,
0.0305524096,
0.0336380042,
0.0406432748,
0.0111468779,
0.0412396006,
-0.0835362598,
-0.0380080491,
0.0197831448,
0.0293768439,
-0.0278506484,
0.0039138915,
-0.0088026589,
-0.1334258914,
0.0617985055,
0.0267812014,
-0.0633843318,
-0.028053239,
-0.0214497726,
0.0282105282,
0.016181739,
0.0250228364,
0.0084239328,
-0.033645805,
0.0027234002,
0.0259336196,
0.0545818768,
-0.1324038059,
-0.0071632322,
-0.0417256318,
0.0118476152,
0.0460518748,
0.0047679991,
0.0243514404,
-0.0299683716,
0.0224851388,
-0.0626341999,
0.0333436765,
-0.0325706787,
0.043450363,
0.0234527513,
0.0009778898,
0.0262568593,
0.0309017226,
-0.0115543045,
-0.0191927291,
-0.0242743026,
0.0370178409,
-0.0109227942,
-0.009837999,
0.024695605,
-0.022722315,
0.052486103,
0.0297402665,
0.0648666844,
-0.0314672031,
-0.0566716306,
-0.0392346531,
-0.0038418903,
-0.0647059307,
0.0281209163,
-0.0096670305,
0.0192661323,
-0.0449596308,
-0.0589203611,
-0.0196866374,
0.0320785865,
0.1088529527,
-0.0242331643,
0.0142994169,
-0.0430115908,
-0.0040358938,
-0.0380885713,
0.0157315172,
-0.001550715,
0.0532558113,
-0.0641269162,
-0.0062410738,
0.0271528792,
-0.0403104164,
-0.0241753906,
0.0143868132,
-0.0926130489,
-0.089746967,
-0.0299886297,
0.0266924798,
0.0170125607,
0.0634222552,
-0.0007468716,
-0.0704821721,
0.0772056431,
0.0563026853,
-0.0152966613,
0.0441788472,
0.031199351,
-0.0351905674,
-0.0196718015,
0.0350721069,
-0.0182264987,
-0.0008524858,
0.0454669669,
0.0293365493,
0.0027889551,
-0.0221487787,
0.011146686,
-0.0150396843,
0.025199322,
-0.0435595773,
-0.0418975241,
-0.0229380913,
0.0168946385,
0.0018804907,
0.002797578,
-0.0320024565,
-0.0330807902,
-0.0210992396,
0.0017869434,
-0.0106647508,
0.038607534,
-0.0093562016,
0.0387241803,
-0.0569991916,
0.0308414828,
-0.0094992071,
0.0399824977,
0.019687986,
0.0084776888,
-0.0149088008,
-0.0188169759,
-0.0208342709,
0.0385433696,
-0.0514381677,
0.0495138206,
0.0378586315,
0.0273929127,
-0.000903437,
0.0380125605,
-0.0405352078,
0.0200517327,
-0.0534706004,
0.0077692471,
0.066340141,
0.0109545449,
0.0761807784,
-0.0361004211,
-0.0073999641,
-0.0103856707,
0.0520444252,
-0.0250251442,
-0.0313374512,
-0.009633746,
0.0253534876,
0.0104672732,
-0.0010005243,
0.0982612669,
0.0317690335,
0.0157056209,
0.0145007912,
0.0391163826,
-0.0463872999,
-0.0189125631,
0.0480822027,
0.010226409,
0.0166065264,
0.0052940613,
-0.0284088068,
-0.0600931793,
-0.0190715604,
0.0118991965,
-0.0242597945,
-0.001685335,
0.0517806038,
0.049636703,
-0.0206009969,
-0.0097397156,
-0.0352054648,
-0.0193063337,
0.0342285819,
-0.0343989171,
-0.0318234041,
-6.308534349e-33,
-0.0320894867,
-0.0156705696,
0.0250682421,
-0.0147683341,
-0.0295822527,
0.0019055727,
-0.0668844655,
0.0239305571,
0.0171713904,
0.0193526279,
-0.0201580543,
-0.0197068267,
0.0102186929,
0.0267060734,
-0.0210409109,
-0.0158950351,
0.0642217547,
-0.0289081,
-0.0489018708,
0.0459663495,
0.0200587604,
0.0016391134,
0.0428162627,
-0.0426025018,
-0.0035247831,
0.0158152729,
-0.044449456,
-0.0427952558,
-0.0274639055,
0.025415672,
0.0043555642,
0.0172931105,
0.0138081526,
-0.058999829,
-0.0416111089,
-0.0019847734,
0.0057866978,
-0.0157375373,
-0.023759665,
0.0088319862,
-0.051268518,
-0.0499463119,
0.0348869897,
-0.0271676499,
-0.039000459,
-0.0114903953,
-0.0069311857,
-0.0009972373,
-0.0296444502,
-0.0438371263,
-0.0726262704,
0.0425144359,
-0.0106054153,
-0.0573624708,
0.0300156977,
0.0172170736,
-0.0051183114,
-0.0201299004,
-0.0286054295,
0.0175788216,
0.0633356795,
0.0396180078,
0.0631241128,
-0.0026290067,
-0.0004177819,
0.058819823,
-0.032691855,
0.0199084952,
0.0527191311,
-0.0191014595,
0.0521279164,
0.0452707931,
0.0203670021,
0.0671360195,
0.0818136558,
-0.0131431893,
-0.0849988759,
0.0252952129,
-0.0019415183,
-0.036828313,
0.0613094456,
0.0058698589,
-0.0390688479,
-0.0153679224,
-0.0381145291,
-0.017126821,
-0.0212045461,
-0.0324564427,
0.056014251,
0.0433249921,
-0.0350049958,
-0.022488011,
0.0438815244,
-0.0309779849,
-0.0278713964,
0.0251332577,
-0.0439322479,
0.0420066714,
0.0006412732,
-0.0235235896,
-0.0311765168,
-0.0686776489,
0.0321698301,
0.0527669415,
0.0397140421,
-0.0241935644,
0.043665342,
0.0248539988,
-0.0522510372,
0.0175340232,
-0.0390941501,
0.0468905121,
0.0161537416,
-0.031239653,
0.018260492,
-0.0252876934,
-0.011032613,
0.0327428393,
-0.0130165098,
-0.0928436592,
-0.01323226,
0.0388578773,
-0.0066884994,
0.0339857489,
-0.0162168015,
-0.0037772804,
-0.0125443581,
-0.0155570926,
0.0631309748,
-0.0213452969,
-0.0294473469,
0.0195599645,
2.623e-7,
0.0088004973,
0.0413399078,
-0.0213124398,
0.0341198184,
0.0359209478,
0.0285556316,
-0.0258784872,
0.0155445719,
0.0044199023,
-0.0079429178,
0.0014149183,
0.0062611601,
0.1036603972,
0.0186320208,
-0.0627314597,
0.0009721501,
-0.0323930942,
0.0441518798,
-0.0477989353,
-0.0352567211,
0.01309493,
0.0574434102,
-0.0387508795,
-0.0015690061,
0.0409114286,
-0.0274717268,
0.0537360124,
-0.0116991969,
0.0343842059,
0.0253705569,
-0.0371492431,
0.0119770085,
0.0207610149,
0.0190044865,
-0.0449345708,
-0.0144707793,
-0.0133716501,
0.0330123678,
0.0141583625,
-0.0226327442,
0.0084292479,
0.0022771312,
0.0201329459,
-0.0515950695,
0.051409658,
-0.0743250996,
0.0062123309,
-0.0186143778,
0.0231769364,
-0.008936258,
0.0125894081,
-0.0261781942,
-0.0035768456,
0.0187205207,
0.0273463093,
-0.0187075287,
-0.0303524882,
-0.0247748513,
-0.0582872257,
0.026209835,
-0.0502153672,
-0.0165250935,
-0.0634885132,
-0.0056333407,
0.0039197113,
-0.0474612005,
-0.0196775217,
2.712192172e-34,
0.014160227,
-0.0184800029,
0.0154076898,
-0.0000952446,
0.0025519875,
0.0075653181,
-0.0118840532,
-0.0092335483,
0.0074180355,
-0.0321889296,
-0.005820605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14725v1 | AMELI: Enhancing Multimodal Entity Linking with Fine-Grained Attributes | 2023-05-24T05:01:48 | 2023-05-24T05:01:48 | Barry Menglong Yao, Yu Chen, Qifan Wang, Sijia Wang, Minqian Liu, Zhiyang Xu, Licheng Yu, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | We propose attribute-aware multimodal entity linking, where the input is a
mention described with a text and image, and the goal is to predict the
corresponding target entity from a multimodal knowledge base (KB) where each
entity is also described with a text description, a visual image and a set of
attributes and values. To support this research, we construct AMELI, a
large-scale dataset consisting of 18,472 reviews and 35,598 products. To
establish baseline performance on AMELI, we experiment with the current
state-of-the-art multimodal entity linking approaches and our enhanced
attribute-aware model and demonstrate the importance of incorporating the
attribute information into the entity linking process. To be best of our
knowledge, we are the first to build benchmark dataset and solutions for the
attribute-aware multimodal entity linking task. Datasets and codes will be made
publicly available. | [
0.0128386924,
0.0205875635,
-0.0197727084,
0.0037355851,
0.0223534629,
0.0147376852,
0.0090564303,
0.0039029471,
-0.0161458664,
-0.0729967803,
-0.0358169042,
0.052505821,
-0.0094779488,
0.0286017116,
0.0757182762,
-0.0363020711,
0.0251576994,
0.0209953059,
0.0043619578,
0.024239894,
0.0543062873,
0.0354261734,
-0.0008469002,
0.0122364303,
-0.0545345806,
0.0147709986,
0.0022976133,
0.0214472078,
0.0321703516,
-0.0438585803,
-0.0345808715,
0.03830323,
0.0012321161,
0.0297351386,
0.000001693,
-0.0246982798,
0.002232509,
-0.0023197532,
0.0123490673,
-0.048960384,
0.0559898764,
-0.0203526914,
0.0498189293,
-0.0314547084,
0.0103147822,
-0.0384264626,
0.0410585217,
0.0867816806,
0.0571113229,
-0.0048445207,
-0.0337896831,
-0.0569181852,
0.0319297351,
-0.020479029,
0.0088100638,
-0.0337923616,
-0.0184951499,
0.0061366227,
0.0249411371,
0.0590144731,
-0.0183349159,
0.1050135568,
-0.0257776882,
0.0245244708,
0.0303297807,
0.0236831028,
-0.0036275103,
-0.0052336054,
-0.006250402,
0.1378729045,
0.0063398834,
0.0069894246,
-0.0071872207,
0.0191237424,
0.0033643206,
0.0117482292,
-0.0322309248,
-0.0227348078,
-0.0151537219,
-0.0350148566,
-0.0737599134,
0.0112577947,
0.020514477,
-0.0136841191,
0.0509102196,
-0.0198574569,
0.0023058627,
0.0225239787,
0.0062484806,
0.0325459614,
-0.0236305706,
-0.0449927524,
-0.0205004867,
-0.0199663155,
-0.0041365884,
0.0217189491,
-0.0602969639,
-0.0218703058,
0.0124528166,
-0.0067121275,
0.0136699472,
-0.0356096998,
-0.0342410617,
0.0581092015,
-0.0549887456,
-0.0284494348,
-0.0342354998,
-0.0273595229,
0.0103076557,
-0.0255078096,
-0.0691013858,
-0.0096986173,
-0.0148802148,
-0.004165994,
-0.0201708935,
-0.0321060419,
-0.0392159447,
-0.0248846207,
-0.0375511944,
0.0770203918,
-0.0053936872,
0.0035563218,
-0.0115104672,
-0.0030063619,
-0.0614921674,
0.039304439,
-0.05258248,
0.0205426421,
-0.0385009535,
0.0398847125,
0.0447525978,
0.0212306473,
0.0150720049,
-0.0473148637,
-0.0033402164,
0.0732308254,
0.0072471215,
-0.0070191137,
-0.0262543503,
-0.1117125601,
0.0195254032,
-0.0524078645,
0.007207118,
-0.0362395495,
0.0642207637,
0.0162867364,
-0.0118992738,
-0.0532335155,
-0.0017768709,
0.0067585986,
-0.0624815449,
0.1285872757,
-0.0199494679,
-0.0317496657,
0.0229301862,
0.0125440247,
0.0187408291,
0.0343448073,
0.0056092665,
0.0161276162,
0.0402591266,
0.0334861949,
-0.0226326659,
0.0169016197,
0.0247879103,
-0.0166255161,
0.0127048213,
0.0053663501,
-0.047865618,
0.0290906951,
0.0293362476,
0.0293030012,
-0.0257704388,
-0.043646276,
0.062062934,
-0.0160557479,
0.0193726812,
0.0175200682,
0.0260165334,
-0.0024649985,
-0.0198568385,
-0.0608592667,
-0.0379681513,
0.1033077687,
-0.016289277,
0.0048179976,
0.0232003946,
0.0526439473,
-0.0265610497,
0.0205201097,
0.0333553255,
-0.0239529889,
-0.0065409825,
-0.0019166793,
0.0243794806,
-0.0053431238,
-0.0265596434,
0.0488552712,
-0.0006703783,
0.0070393379,
-0.0204885434,
0.0100839976,
-0.0201390702,
0.0601083562,
0.0376259871,
0.0266069658,
-0.0361410938,
-0.0500340313,
0.0293663722,
0.0121120671,
0.0063624475,
-0.0424522571,
-0.0266111363,
-0.03752793,
-0.0426229052,
-0.0066509349,
-0.0156108402,
-0.0122950887,
0.0035657019,
0.0531243309,
0.0286924429,
-0.0242961105,
0.0383269452,
0.0002198037,
0.0728498697,
0.0317620113,
-0.0368791856,
0.0447711349,
-0.0283932071,
0.0365063027,
0.0094312578,
-0.0266656261,
0.0064871022,
-0.0157490838,
-0.0277712289,
0.0595414527,
0.039644219,
-0.0226283278,
0.016418837,
-0.0712247416,
0.0041776313,
-0.0371724144,
-0.0141556645,
-0.0553397797,
0.0136288907,
0.0247696731,
0.0178892054,
0.0076787579,
0.0093701892,
0.0415115356,
0.0369493663,
-0.0210306384,
0.0483457744,
-0.0067566321,
-0.0221908595,
-0.006009018,
0.0056931782,
0.0103540299,
0.0066286488,
-0.0525717027,
-0.0031076837,
0.0310093276,
0.0244116224,
0.0225904267,
-0.0274338163,
-0.0408077426,
0.02665166,
-0.0641558468,
-0.026350081,
0.0357895568,
-0.0120207537,
-0.0555243231,
0.006922015,
0.0287558567,
-0.0372971967,
-0.0219889712,
0.0351582207,
-0.0187946931,
0.0078164292,
0.0283327904,
0.0632617474,
0.0221626256,
-0.0301272664,
-0.0200338289,
-0.0068644793,
0.0572181456,
0.0116004813,
-0.0315115936,
-0.0526529551,
-0.0173000861,
-0.051786378,
0.0132033359,
-0.0058749006,
0.0409790203,
-0.0091033941,
0.0101215839,
0.0332988054,
-0.0034253628,
-0.0470372401,
-0.0039214976,
0.0093242032,
-0.0140017252,
-0.0807821527,
0.0183422752,
0.0309962332,
0.0237847064,
0.0097736334,
-0.0055402233,
-0.0063103545,
0.0165268984,
-0.0429961719,
-0.0032704987,
-0.0380207673,
0.0134090297,
0.0441738218,
-0.0100740269,
-0.03736021,
0.0181574859,
0.051958371,
0.0132269468,
-0.0166956261,
-0.0022239583,
0.0236871094,
-0.0197205618,
0.0310334936,
0.0303302687,
0.0392123163,
0.0018050323,
0.0734325349,
0.0248097219,
0.0174525809,
0.0099363597,
0.0230543427,
-0.0286033135,
0.0689399615,
0.0481664687,
0.0272978228,
0.0485600047,
0.0012594779,
0.046535328,
-0.0049505192,
-0.0136587908,
0.048830092,
-0.0141176349,
-0.0517395809,
-0.0355938673,
-0.0380375385,
-0.0195388831,
-0.03735644,
0.0486668386,
0.0147171691,
-0.0199097861,
0.0354886837,
-0.0580029637,
0.0328391604,
0.0356827155,
0.0853619352,
-0.0197194144,
-0.0242790245,
-0.0081849592,
-0.0057819942,
0.0286328606,
0.0183614381,
-0.0273371674,
-0.0263942368,
-0.0174087249,
0.0032507803,
-0.0025786734,
-0.0403167903,
-0.0065860143,
0.0313134342,
-0.0253988113,
0.0442795716,
0.0649522319,
0.0301575828,
-0.0584069118,
-0.0343252942,
0.0608084165,
0.0085291797,
0.019809261,
0.023741452,
-0.1152173504,
-0.0731104463,
-0.0291286502,
-0.0362610482,
0.0414072834,
-0.0316585377,
0.0045336611,
-0.1025741696,
0.0007251634,
-0.0539913885,
-0.0276305098,
-0.0798198804,
-0.0048362575,
0.0120180929,
-0.0341138579,
-0.0057670381,
-0.0134931374,
-0.0061225225,
0.0135821858,
-0.020014314,
0.030140426,
-0.0193742272,
0.0374634899,
-0.0893441737,
0.0444539525,
0.0243321098,
0.0222910233,
0.005548486,
-0.0038285914,
-0.0229665004,
0.0130427666,
-0.0215494186,
-0.0064956285,
0.1039244235,
-0.0532735772,
-0.0101397745,
0.0022102252,
-0.0100476006,
0.0333241671,
0.014648933,
-0.0339090824,
0.0463189967,
0.0197156351,
0.0006558014,
-0.0432573967,
-0.0295536444,
-0.0067038168,
0.0278394427,
-0.035850171,
-0.0374636799,
-0.0108224591,
0.0023931968,
0.01615192,
-0.0064325971,
-0.018980911,
0.0316071585,
-0.0850691125,
-0.016055556,
-0.1151204705,
-0.0295623075,
0.0313300341,
0.0710111931,
0.0348526984,
0.0107809426,
-0.0102423765,
0.0366113484,
-0.0730773956,
0.0394134,
-0.0026348368,
0.0413455814,
0.0053014639,
-0.0028860541,
0.0793270543,
-0.0213370509,
-0.0002040531,
0.0300000086,
-0.0483318008,
-0.0043383655,
-0.0508398898,
0.0289638881,
0.0159343537,
0.0356885046,
-0.0092671523,
-0.0764462277,
-0.0273655467,
0.0178678352,
-0.0447934344,
-0.0252066627,
-0.01126887,
0.0362595469,
-0.0055520553,
0.0339883193,
-0.0721591413,
0.0009155852,
-0.0364273675,
0.0175126288,
-0.0327897556,
-0.0320181698,
-0.0271440186,
0.0116949687,
-0.0123038255,
-0.0333163403,
0.0371903963,
-0.0218626,
0.0199368503,
0.0274674576,
-0.025021933,
-0.048913002,
0.0300941225,
0.0011261204,
0.0408394337,
-0.0255299285,
0.0091434084,
0.0523461476,
0.0497670919,
-0.0752047151,
0.0160693154,
0.0202517118,
-0.0156447496,
-0.0318328664,
-0.0073676356,
0.0092215184,
0.0213773921,
0.0138847027,
0.0298264194,
-0.0572116487,
0.0465763994,
0.0148138804,
-0.0073319972,
-0.0487329848,
0.0578471646,
0.0426708907,
0.0451035462,
-0.009652094,
0.0396152474,
0.0300395768,
0.006655118,
0.060278818,
-0.028730968,
-0.0354283154,
0.0332244709,
0.0448536724,
-0.0111206649,
0.0022201105,
0.0689549372,
0.0202881675,
0.0159552321,
0.0327400491,
0.0457805432,
-0.0149183851,
0.0529677123,
-0.0342325605,
-0.0297054816,
-0.0660299063,
-0.0042788591,
0.0197724067,
-0.0012036045,
-0.0054139099,
0.0067079808,
-0.0438449122,
-0.0650526583,
0.0188815147,
-0.0213461388,
-0.0066198334,
0.0304909181,
0.0469562225,
0.0232009552,
0.0795924366,
-0.0235534385,
0.001577807,
-0.0640363321,
-0.0002881254,
0.012089951,
-0.0081590088,
-5.190608364e-33,
-0.0486913025,
-0.0221319646,
0.0054252325,
-0.0186217278,
-0.0156382583,
-0.0167391058,
0.0149677591,
-0.0133507177,
-0.0460335203,
-0.0104461247,
0.0233605504,
-0.0303939674,
-0.0075667514,
-0.00515192,
0.0367042311,
-0.0146799786,
0.031394694,
0.0040219976,
-0.0037064573,
0.0330366306,
0.0196545422,
0.0235707872,
0.0378834344,
-0.0631295368,
0.0513339788,
0.0587142557,
-0.0517221093,
0.0059765726,
0.0479242951,
0.0717670918,
-0.0093522724,
0.0407714099,
0.0104027865,
-0.0410509333,
-0.0035138009,
-0.0212369319,
-0.1390250921,
0.0122303236,
-0.0049358066,
0.0397421233,
-0.0176040959,
0.0206010733,
0.0445181429,
-0.0170321949,
0.0398250595,
-0.007908483,
0.0523427874,
-0.0181450397,
-0.0168219525,
-0.0722115189,
-0.0502254218,
0.0490105078,
0.0014206899,
0.0148635237,
0.0515170954,
-0.0132912863,
0.035447374,
0.0085557615,
-0.0570549928,
0.0116448989,
-0.0363709107,
-0.0141441589,
0.042546723,
0.0019064714,
0.0038334606,
0.0668925196,
0.0200382974,
0.0082372027,
-0.0128655061,
0.0731003284,
0.0239496659,
0.0397276506,
0.02319449,
0.0921433344,
-0.0127498722,
-0.0111390213,
-0.0249528978,
0.024436824,
0.0050259768,
0.034480501,
-0.0218804535,
0.0146718575,
-0.0120181516,
-0.0002295941,
-0.0260752831,
0.0113079734,
-0.0502826907,
-0.0254468657,
0.0055100163,
0.0141939772,
-0.0248546507,
0.0749850646,
0.0391627029,
-0.0087153595,
-0.0625624806,
-0.0083099008,
0.0008146171,
0.0516811237,
0.0098775234,
-0.0408017524,
-0.0216142777,
-0.0024248699,
0.0441218689,
-0.0234319717,
0.0147655476,
-0.013152143,
0.0753983408,
-0.0081385747,
-0.0681126341,
-0.0013578052,
0.0133687248,
-0.0376451649,
-0.0506215096,
-0.0514303036,
0.0198271628,
-0.0038071084,
-0.0632904619,
-0.0022392501,
0.0451908484,
0.0126044862,
-0.0139202606,
0.0009068287,
0.0153337372,
-0.0139145115,
-0.0275428705,
0.0119492495,
-0.0173484012,
-0.0965987518,
-0.0027095263,
-0.0952565745,
-0.020362284,
0.0284849834,
2.399e-7,
0.0318165869,
0.0372894481,
-0.0168921147,
-0.0015949043,
0.0051882174,
0.0274750069,
0.0359118804,
0.0343610793,
-0.0022604684,
-0.041902978,
0.0038631344,
-0.0027287363,
-0.0030890736,
0.0159079675,
-0.0411083996,
-0.0215076953,
0.0141848531,
-0.0033566877,
-0.0460341573,
-0.024745848,
0.0364391431,
0.0512782857,
-0.0093947593,
0.0046976842,
0.0028006888,
-0.0146550192,
0.0674255565,
-0.0099202823,
-0.0009735866,
-0.0394045264,
0.0390046611,
-0.0006365906,
-0.0666746646,
0.0367057696,
-0.0204954967,
-0.0105483942,
0.0613723621,
0.0237003211,
-0.0142029254,
-0.026484048,
-0.0032619264,
-0.0440257825,
-0.0145125072,
0.0026931295,
0.0729444399,
-0.0353902876,
-0.0108335493,
-0.0048733377,
-0.039540153,
0.0305962507,
-0.0146284858,
-0.0098900655,
-0.0298157874,
0.0369229652,
0.007283703,
-0.0259043891,
-0.0233066045,
-0.1166868284,
-0.0136757893,
0.0412223637,
0.0231210124,
-0.0156835001,
0.0094718859,
-0.0609194413,
0.0108712194,
-0.0564779714,
-0.0380767956,
1.729272954e-34,
0.0130281951,
-0.0055309027,
-0.0053275693,
0.0018682745,
0.0552840643,
-0.0515170656,
-0.062517032,
-0.021891728,
0.0082557099,
-0.0497176349,
-0.0119419405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14724v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14724v2 | I Spy a Metaphor: Large Language Models and Diffusion Models Co-Create Visual Metaphors | 2023-05-24T05:01:10 | 2023-07-14T16:09:46 | Tuhin Chakrabarty, Arkadiy Saakyan, Olivia Winn, Artemis Panagopoulou, Yue Yang, Marianna Apidianaki, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC | Visual metaphors are powerful rhetorical devices used to persuade or
communicate creative ideas through images. Similar to linguistic metaphors,
they convey meaning implicitly through symbolism and juxtaposition of the
symbols. We propose a new task of generating visual metaphors from linguistic
metaphors. This is a challenging task for diffusion-based text-to-image models,
such as DALL$\cdot$E 2, since it requires the ability to model implicit meaning
and compositionality. We propose to solve the task through the collaboration
between Large Language Models (LLMs) and Diffusion Models: Instruct GPT-3
(davinci-002) with Chain-of-Thought prompting generates text that represents a
visual elaboration of the linguistic metaphor containing the implicit meaning
and relevant objects, which is then used as input to the diffusion-based
text-to-image models.Using a human-AI collaboration framework, where humans
interact both with the LLM and the top-performing diffusion model, we create a
high-quality dataset containing 6,476 visual metaphors for 1,540 linguistic
metaphors and their associated visual elaborations. Evaluation by professional
illustrators shows the promise of LLM-Diffusion Model collaboration for this
task . To evaluate the utility of our Human-AI collaboration framework and the
quality of our dataset, we perform both an intrinsic human-based evaluation and
an extrinsic evaluation using visual entailment as a downstream task. | [
0.0503608622,
0.0440468155,
-0.0212260857,
0.0435898937,
-0.0318639725,
0.0176316947,
-0.0066417651,
-0.0095578469,
0.0045992313,
-0.0114198476,
-0.0243496858,
-0.004650719,
0.0428739339,
0.0207676739,
0.035663791,
-0.1053290442,
-0.0363716111,
-0.0341847241,
-0.0166237094,
-0.0186967421,
0.0011659689,
0.0382340029,
-0.0050021154,
0.0491632186,
-0.0469593331,
-0.0385505445,
0.0025045918,
0.0469078384,
0.0435685031,
-0.0314894356,
-0.0720074996,
0.004692696,
0.0565015376,
-0.0093005979,
0.0000020002,
-0.0168320108,
0.0478454977,
-0.0046427408,
0.0426602103,
-0.0128553826,
0.0776496306,
-0.023917634,
0.0030022776,
-0.0285575297,
-0.0172997192,
0.0707492456,
0.0665061995,
0.0561289042,
0.1027683243,
0.0269639324,
-0.0170247294,
-0.0590784699,
0.0022555594,
-0.0299899112,
0.011067084,
0.0072933869,
-0.0008546741,
0.0435609557,
0.0158959217,
-0.0022538954,
-0.0320086144,
0.0554962456,
0.0328243002,
-0.0001811339,
0.0051404112,
0.0596343651,
0.0341777205,
-0.0256405622,
-0.0138197588,
0.066036202,
-0.0002091369,
0.0050253556,
-0.0067750681,
-0.0099311154,
-0.0008361145,
0.0760927498,
-0.0458769463,
-0.0156438258,
0.0150829982,
0.0401611701,
-0.0097847758,
-0.0084432689,
0.0039763143,
-0.0018961382,
0.0033533908,
-0.0179112405,
0.0187273677,
0.0087614171,
-0.0032099441,
0.0118705947,
-0.0218265839,
-0.0824392736,
-0.0013835457,
0.0075398744,
0.0149503415,
0.0343249626,
-0.0262660366,
-0.0501609445,
-0.0050428268,
-0.0536167547,
0.0964140967,
0.0050424901,
-0.0028980186,
0.0694116876,
-0.031764809,
0.0208807383,
-0.0482828319,
0.0365414843,
-0.0677391887,
-0.0136683509,
-0.0521075688,
-0.0261894241,
-0.0609368905,
0.0188298803,
-0.0268157069,
-0.0622536428,
-0.0449595191,
-0.0020798473,
-0.0413689539,
0.0057719708,
-0.0043483838,
0.029469328,
-0.0230735745,
-0.0123558221,
-0.0775570869,
0.0037599492,
-0.0222145971,
0.0168077294,
-0.0113471067,
0.0171275716,
0.0027405655,
0.0261628479,
0.0167467445,
-0.0264335219,
-0.0045907069,
0.080298163,
-0.0269828718,
0.0092224404,
-0.0087981932,
-0.0193278193,
0.0194695387,
-0.0390305147,
0.0018983965,
-0.0555442348,
0.0185714252,
-0.010770754,
0.0316369608,
-0.0642764568,
0.0100128055,
0.0132789332,
-0.0378358327,
0.0581944324,
-0.0058528376,
0.0204964988,
0.026688043,
0.0087657943,
-0.0520823449,
0.0356387496,
0.0679378286,
0.1081823483,
-0.0120296851,
-0.004934628,
0.0041789506,
0.0078626508,
0.0163997412,
0.0250348914,
-0.0554964505,
-0.0086849714,
-0.0383050814,
0.0642778426,
0.0076644812,
0.0935187712,
-0.0391995087,
0.0115584573,
0.0873850957,
0.0804861337,
0.0301937535,
0.0054834955,
0.0795696303,
0.0194712542,
-0.003682341,
-0.0217529126,
0.0287075043,
0.0378877893,
0.0435472466,
0.0080639506,
0.0130201159,
0.0449570157,
-0.0264956709,
-0.0203874689,
0.0038878003,
-0.0126159629,
0.0176669713,
-0.0150559777,
0.0325033367,
0.0315269344,
-0.0576348305,
0.0076225805,
-0.0293779727,
-0.0294298548,
-0.0192297939,
-0.0428845175,
0.0505784042,
0.1007948071,
0.0393352807,
0.024755368,
0.0438014418,
-0.0148353083,
0.034897577,
0.04926081,
-0.0269685499,
0.009609011,
-0.0362923667,
0.0063157254,
0.0118082175,
-0.0162453111,
-0.0111949658,
0.0271214116,
-0.050110165,
0.0562696382,
0.0027875025,
-0.0119380169,
-0.054608874,
0.0362761542,
0.0070678331,
0.0148156965,
-0.0161011107,
0.0223688036,
0.0119449748,
0.0151483957,
-0.0408726409,
0.0065403199,
0.0075106076,
-0.0539035127,
-0.077152729,
0.0608488247,
-0.0298132915,
0.0037117715,
0.0178413354,
-0.1119939238,
-0.0069942866,
-0.0197002459,
0.0030278107,
-0.0113413483,
0.0424794368,
-0.0508118719,
0.0469786599,
-0.0150931012,
-0.0349935628,
0.0164376087,
0.0059249476,
0.0114133544,
0.0486150421,
-0.0036906672,
-0.0170757826,
-0.0342793353,
0.0136107821,
-0.0083752898,
0.0273571294,
0.0188356712,
-0.0168109015,
0.049701754,
0.0181335472,
-0.0163419507,
-0.0071323565,
-0.0526363067,
-0.0310603175,
-0.090858236,
-0.0276312307,
0.0114060519,
-0.0306157805,
-0.0084783211,
-0.0337368734,
-0.0264801495,
0.0099631092,
-0.0171788037,
0.0061916374,
-0.0394418314,
0.0034091894,
0.042848289,
-0.0100996429,
-0.0160767063,
-0.0108132027,
0.0124860825,
-0.0012205873,
0.0930620581,
0.0596091449,
-0.0109936306,
-0.0231348127,
-0.0063574333,
-0.0405809842,
-0.0370564945,
-0.0015659878,
-0.0341403782,
0.0346079245,
0.0065060905,
0.0695495307,
0.051605016,
0.0104952818,
0.04531518,
0.0350509398,
-0.0388101414,
-0.0327758603,
0.0042044055,
0.0139231393,
0.017957963,
0.0163910836,
-0.0339924395,
0.0125755789,
0.0471894369,
0.0076287352,
0.0110194692,
-0.0618234053,
0.065093793,
0.0005899753,
-0.0539595298,
-0.0384874009,
-0.0401358791,
-0.0009824586,
0.0246025417,
-0.0226281323,
-0.0479679853,
0.0543053709,
-0.0527581275,
-0.0097012315,
-0.0016777422,
-0.0163175929,
-0.025803769,
0.0696546957,
-0.0249396283,
0.033694502,
-0.0118679386,
0.0287784394,
-0.0016648434,
-0.022157887,
0.0265832953,
-0.0253198817,
0.0325150974,
-0.0482533798,
0.004326826,
-0.0107256733,
0.0142075056,
-0.0298429187,
-0.0275679585,
-0.0364875086,
-0.0273597147,
-0.0148581648,
-0.0077045532,
-0.0283875484,
0.013735815,
0.0128955133,
-0.0200023595,
0.0153739173,
-0.0206684135,
-0.0105580194,
0.0201756041,
0.0706090927,
-0.003772581,
-0.0577681437,
-0.0550375506,
0.0271455515,
0.0122201629,
-0.0383673236,
-0.0093879988,
-0.0881380588,
0.0076491577,
-0.0266958233,
0.03715083,
0.011055938,
-0.0061506717,
0.0686023012,
-0.0097833537,
0.0181834381,
0.0545584597,
0.0254280027,
-0.0235857256,
0.0039930786,
0.0007776621,
0.0468175225,
0.0033530367,
0.0065785074,
-0.0855892152,
-0.0236318652,
-0.003001652,
-0.0291713066,
0.0142671773,
-0.0217312891,
-0.0139156878,
-0.0766097829,
0.0783572271,
0.0172622073,
0.0250187796,
-0.0016786673,
-0.0137225175,
-0.0075769434,
0.0355424657,
-0.0280755721,
-0.0582415685,
0.0054431111,
0.0136107579,
0.0037667446,
0.0569355302,
-0.0209531896,
-0.010024501,
-0.0223165322,
0.0002238205,
0.0224477872,
0.0616681539,
-0.0009799148,
-0.0688170269,
-0.0209658816,
0.0223285463,
0.0129798204,
0.0036083499,
0.0384626836,
0.0022797247,
-0.0163055323,
-0.0287756044,
0.0221666526,
-0.0236027744,
-0.0277724527,
0.0119994823,
0.0636052862,
-0.0213016439,
-0.0184119046,
-0.0644527376,
0.0130512882,
0.0040624151,
0.0639148057,
0.069735162,
-0.0610335432,
-0.0026712532,
-0.0268575009,
0.0207518004,
-0.0232880339,
-0.0600592569,
-0.0315599404,
-0.0281704459,
-0.009711626,
-0.0986436829,
0.0091694435,
0.0144790644,
0.0754488632,
0.0317877159,
0.0111335246,
-0.0517911725,
-0.0143581256,
-0.0450501032,
0.0635888427,
-0.0131844366,
0.0456169248,
-0.0030689645,
-0.0222324636,
0.0025335366,
-0.0261169318,
-0.0350939408,
0.0677440912,
-0.099044852,
-0.0403449833,
-0.0407408662,
0.0370351821,
0.0196438134,
-0.0019344361,
0.0024117399,
-0.0506623723,
0.089329794,
0.0603107251,
0.0262791403,
0.0005531451,
-0.0220570657,
0.0026976932,
0.0243506916,
0.0062774648,
-0.014808665,
0.0286958907,
0.0358935781,
0.0221298467,
-0.0013696704,
0.0249990616,
0.0071483124,
-0.0068635759,
-0.0266640224,
-0.0340028964,
-0.0127812019,
-0.0229987893,
-0.0051584542,
-0.0137811182,
-0.0379524082,
-0.0582687333,
0.0078040324,
0.0409284383,
-0.0102836275,
-0.007605169,
-0.0432117991,
0.0241901837,
0.0074522495,
0.0107166991,
0.0119682075,
0.0376568176,
0.044963751,
0.0002407914,
0.016779203,
0.0012363897,
-0.0313612521,
-0.0715653896,
0.0451676697,
0.0074168942,
0.0282431766,
0.0295088217,
-0.0204688311,
-0.0238517988,
0.0697667748,
-0.0081738504,
-0.0777702481,
0.0021261277,
0.0462036654,
0.0601562336,
0.0189210027,
0.0390688851,
-0.0412933864,
0.0076813349,
0.0143791158,
0.0319472961,
-0.0257066414,
-0.0045415568,
0.0072219963,
0.0086820554,
0.0195178762,
-0.024209952,
0.0176775195,
-0.0909357145,
0.0096709691,
-0.0088863196,
-0.03756392,
-0.0202316549,
0.0023403391,
0.0043937722,
-0.0124090584,
0.0511869155,
0.0416000262,
-0.0611726679,
-0.091184698,
0.0185751282,
0.0244871993,
-0.0119034918,
0.013776497,
0.03901463,
0.0457822196,
0.0157348365,
0.0063368175,
-0.030917922,
0.0216838922,
-0.0525681973,
-0.008378081,
-0.0322995596,
-5.965582035e-33,
-0.0517609306,
-0.0424564444,
0.0090781329,
-0.0111893835,
-0.0250715129,
0.0020236697,
-0.0541730151,
-0.0171431117,
0.0371122099,
0.0470728949,
0.0135055678,
-0.0283265188,
-0.0072338674,
-0.0060738055,
0.0087707387,
0.0434846245,
0.0357368626,
0.0143624516,
-0.0570139997,
0.0015099819,
0.019025078,
0.0021377055,
-0.0006577115,
-0.0722688213,
-0.0224215072,
0.0158728193,
-0.0127285672,
-0.0221177172,
0.0405285992,
0.0516253076,
-0.0232943706,
0.0195985455,
0.0142406728,
0.0319832005,
-0.00143543,
0.0185234454,
-0.0312112346,
-0.0394814685,
0.0374592617,
-0.03950385,
-0.0722694695,
-0.0240804702,
0.0536380857,
-0.0118414229,
-0.0063975202,
0.0087961908,
0.0693879351,
-0.0152546354,
0.0012589532,
0.0130370753,
-0.0521420501,
-0.0008945703,
-0.0476785302,
-0.0302710086,
0.0080692368,
-0.0030698266,
0.0275381785,
0.0556107648,
-0.0730933994,
0.0465866402,
-0.0162091535,
-0.0318022072,
0.0577911101,
0.0160098355,
0.0379123203,
0.0815085471,
0.0189926382,
0.0129156876,
-0.0413802676,
0.0236595087,
-0.0032823931,
0.0610587411,
0.032688912,
0.021803502,
0.0209560227,
0.0072011473,
0.0032305815,
0.048191648,
-0.0485906713,
0.0059023714,
0.0402121879,
0.0281523317,
-0.0055516679,
0.021820927,
-0.0367742851,
-0.0281520542,
-0.015885409,
-0.0543904752,
0.0039507831,
-0.0145365782,
-0.0156027991,
0.0178182945,
0.0078079798,
-0.0019358558,
-0.0244778041,
-0.0524558239,
-0.0193268061,
0.0490910076,
-0.0153273549,
-0.0014743403,
-0.0049039172,
-0.0215313956,
0.0375003144,
0.0552194417,
0.035078343,
0.001473797,
0.0292045884,
0.0043591163,
-0.0438683368,
-0.0135990735,
-0.0353444256,
-0.0244841073,
-0.0217247643,
-0.0691320449,
0.0099361101,
0.0139941061,
-0.0550417677,
-0.0102567617,
-0.013460733,
-0.0125796553,
-0.0099250143,
-0.0025568849,
-0.0413486548,
-0.0054010674,
-0.0490667038,
-0.0022751158,
-0.0385358557,
-0.0335993282,
0.077875644,
-0.0752670914,
-0.0417374261,
0.0014211452,
2.794e-7,
0.0292920135,
0.0298312567,
0.0049068495,
0.0634121448,
0.0094501525,
0.0374597572,
-0.0518483073,
0.0151618449,
-0.0000898223,
-0.0261595473,
0.0320090465,
0.0508228056,
0.0271857716,
0.006530182,
-0.0781361908,
0.0603180714,
-0.0359822959,
0.0063553476,
-0.0577875376,
0.0036390694,
0.0876702219,
0.0306625888,
0.0535662659,
-0.0265111644,
0.0160293188,
-0.0445730723,
0.0845643729,
-0.0620037541,
0.0187450275,
-0.0242757481,
0.0069195954,
-0.0197424162,
-0.0160956737,
0.0101155462,
0.023786379,
-0.0139678381,
0.0612489879,
-0.0028476948,
-0.0238596275,
0.0070464998,
-0.0235289298,
0.0043581105,
-0.0005651416,
-0.0477612987,
0.0452174582,
-0.040776927,
-0.0406408533,
-0.0316474736,
-0.0119994571,
-0.0060144849,
0.049634669,
-0.0184800047,
-0.0558334552,
0.0091222823,
0.0325241536,
-0.0111790961,
0.0185366049,
-0.0508989319,
0.0067736474,
-0.022128908,
-0.0376426131,
-0.0011366766,
-0.0584586784,
0.0348971747,
-0.023416359,
-0.0349694788,
-0.0208279509,
2.029414084e-34,
0.0309333242,
-0.0292211995,
0.0054802233,
0.042636279,
0.0889099613,
-0.0007603608,
-0.0135675576,
-0.0002345418,
0.0153653659,
-0.0708710998,
-0.0215876698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14719v1 | CuRIAM: Corpus re Interpretation and Metalanguage in U.S. Supreme Court Opinions | 2023-05-24T04:47:55 | 2023-05-24T04:47:55 | Michael Kranzlein, Nathan Schneider, Kevin Tobia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most judicial decisions involve the interpretation of legal texts; as such,
judicial opinion requires the use of language as a medium to comment on or draw
attention to other language. Language used this way is called metalanguage. We
develop an annotation schema for categorizing types of legal metalanguage and
apply our schema to a set of U.S. Supreme Court opinions, yielding a corpus
totaling 59k tokens. We remark on several patterns observed in the kinds of
metalanguage used by the justices. | [
0.0366077349,
0.0304689556,
-0.0147779398,
0.0011475896,
-0.0313529521,
0.0518958457,
-0.012730917,
0.0323815234,
-0.0259505399,
-0.0863186792,
-0.022282226,
0.0038900338,
0.0029910703,
-0.0637299418,
-0.0093043391,
-0.0337236933,
0.0261649508,
-0.0068091275,
0.0965699255,
0.0195886586,
0.0392464511,
0.0207205396,
-0.0184340384,
0.044768028,
-0.0246288385,
-0.0256678611,
0.0233162306,
0.0004889277,
-0.0303892866,
-0.0062265806,
-0.0327588767,
0.0610113516,
-0.0329571925,
0.0330735222,
0.0000014557,
-0.0489541441,
0.0348467641,
-0.0224423651,
0.016499823,
0.0042404346,
0.0120895403,
-0.0644718334,
-0.0469620861,
0.0006927958,
-0.0509579964,
-0.0077018812,
0.0379121676,
0.0029421882,
0.0051608291,
0.0534919463,
-0.0112094898,
-0.0046765315,
0.015095477,
-0.0356173068,
-0.0088298284,
0.0184787512,
-0.0023071987,
0.0469244979,
0.0071567926,
-0.0264728069,
0.0629867166,
0.0375878178,
-0.009783715,
-0.056315992,
-0.0700839013,
-0.028225312,
-0.0858613253,
0.0162230693,
0.0459640026,
-0.0190244466,
0.101229243,
-0.0462796129,
0.0154593373,
0.0514437035,
0.0457783453,
0.0264677648,
0.0040762662,
0.0895482004,
-0.0351811759,
0.0052830507,
0.0410474353,
0.0174864251,
-0.0186178163,
0.0236097369,
-0.0466800593,
0.0665138587,
-0.0221692193,
-0.0127033349,
0.0038096511,
0.0304276608,
-0.0109532746,
-0.0433792472,
0.0413040891,
-0.0005887731,
0.021812642,
0.0317591615,
-0.0179298855,
-0.0657244325,
0.0670947805,
-0.0497215651,
0.0569371395,
0.0287982207,
-0.0633270293,
0.0819576755,
-0.0069800154,
-0.0251950398,
0.0110696638,
-0.0042693233,
-0.0108533222,
-0.011880096,
-0.023185024,
-0.0113752391,
-0.0457475409,
-0.0054647443,
-0.0702382252,
-0.004128858,
-0.0191536937,
-0.0056789061,
-0.0230853874,
0.0389795713,
-0.0233579017,
-0.0702865273,
-0.0270493366,
0.0029844609,
-0.0156527385,
-0.0142772747,
-0.0331504121,
0.0280437749,
-0.0237325374,
-0.0349532254,
0.0294630118,
0.0577562526,
-0.0242165811,
-0.029095877,
-0.0497981235,
0.0670768768,
-0.0087462608,
-0.0076729185,
0.0217604004,
-0.0622296073,
-0.0463508666,
-0.0191186182,
-0.0330122486,
-0.0393007919,
0.0128975315,
-0.0001300385,
0.0347748064,
-0.0518479161,
0.0298648756,
0.0151213389,
0.0259790085,
0.0415171124,
-0.0273936335,
-0.0620965958,
-0.0326385014,
-0.0128756408,
0.0056798747,
0.0095560178,
0.0001421933,
0.005975279,
0.0321895443,
-0.00120165,
-0.0366363674,
0.0327091813,
-0.038982477,
0.0283928458,
0.0027638394,
-0.0050964504,
-0.030940976,
0.0061784643,
-0.0002400849,
0.0622400455,
0.0091999164,
0.011563085,
-0.0056879441,
0.099995628,
0.0021588479,
0.0337465927,
0.0008133001,
-0.0069284923,
0.0586820729,
0.0032960996,
-0.0276475921,
-0.0064944867,
-0.023592433,
-0.0035987732,
-0.0698780566,
-0.0281244647,
0.0025950859,
-0.0678458288,
-0.0035882359,
-0.0216775537,
-0.0145322569,
-0.0191007461,
0.0251822751,
0.0112833977,
0.0272850767,
0.0172966849,
0.0437093005,
-0.0297318771,
-0.0444988906,
0.023945339,
-0.0057309135,
0.0284241736,
0.0116355894,
-0.0056097563,
-0.0016964072,
-0.0239374433,
0.045250468,
0.0765543804,
0.0170513168,
-0.0053733974,
-0.0475554019,
-0.009939665,
-0.0038891854,
0.0431897901,
0.0765626654,
0.0084241712,
-0.0623548254,
0.0188108366,
0.0089874975,
-0.0339399204,
-0.0085380701,
0.0073938807,
0.028340742,
-0.0013906476,
-0.0048579383,
-0.0112208212,
0.0274647176,
0.0207975693,
0.0033222558,
0.0207198504,
-0.0050072628,
-0.019770192,
0.0359971449,
0.0854543447,
-0.0007634506,
0.0686144829,
0.0623619743,
-0.0452034324,
-0.0083085103,
-0.0527751371,
0.0174545217,
-0.0395391211,
-0.0007951917,
-0.0483126193,
0.0718708262,
-0.0529487394,
0.0126970196,
-0.0029202458,
-0.015735494,
-0.0412403494,
0.0073084864,
0.0009213252,
-0.0262926891,
0.0029427942,
-0.0649527013,
0.0468219146,
-0.0024665676,
-0.0540744364,
-0.0021633625,
0.0147259422,
-0.0138724996,
0.0185416564,
-0.0197123792,
-0.0298192035,
-0.0242930129,
-0.0305556618,
-0.0263295732,
-0.0392916389,
0.0365420692,
0.0347421579,
-0.0192915518,
0.0077003222,
-0.015546754,
0.0345138125,
-0.0596162602,
-0.034449175,
-0.0157490522,
0.0152420234,
0.0024933349,
0.0481358618,
-0.0164535791,
-0.0088659218,
-0.0447244309,
-0.0002226902,
0.0022710047,
-0.068927899,
-0.0450177714,
0.0380316563,
-0.0019634156,
-0.02723925,
-0.0169402305,
-0.0060514016,
0.0304667056,
0.0210475549,
-0.0328192189,
0.0120083988,
0.0318653807,
0.0572044179,
0.0265602022,
0.0147134578,
-0.0188135169,
-0.0275303032,
0.0463741198,
0.0385220274,
-0.0312296543,
0.0006094792,
0.0405707359,
0.0141492868,
-0.0170607306,
0.0154546248,
-0.0313217156,
0.0067826561,
-0.060501758,
-0.0167037584,
0.0045064124,
-0.0298491977,
-0.0339493863,
0.0683588982,
0.0247410312,
0.0030907451,
0.0089903222,
-0.0152793908,
0.0461701602,
-0.0514992699,
0.0127270035,
-0.059192501,
0.0557667017,
-0.0521233119,
-0.013814318,
-0.0059298323,
-0.0747642219,
0.0571742132,
0.0047560246,
0.0522834249,
-0.0225785524,
0.1023883671,
-0.0195001401,
0.0588421896,
-0.0279613975,
-0.0300913248,
0.0117834928,
0.0211431012,
-0.0273106843,
0.0164637454,
0.029974483,
-0.0020352385,
-0.0291004051,
0.0281359982,
-0.0356017426,
0.0015667123,
0.0090623181,
0.0214611609,
-0.0274222773,
0.0214942116,
-0.008469373,
0.0255522151,
-0.0160147231,
0.0094798859,
-0.0115503203,
0.0305981766,
-0.0304092914,
-0.0017043239,
0.011254237,
-0.021853419,
0.0529524162,
-0.0440281518,
-0.0482748337,
-0.0263959505,
0.0092593767,
-0.0306307878,
0.0215199683,
0.0668853968,
0.0086484291,
-0.0544557199,
-0.0078636147,
-0.0177413709,
0.0179696716,
0.0226553436,
0.0154915582,
-0.1265800893,
0.027411053,
-0.0068577039,
-0.0201902501,
-0.0103937201,
-0.0434879288,
0.0045202384,
-0.069580391,
0.0450466797,
0.0186454169,
-0.0210990664,
0.0061872588,
0.007659507,
0.0324313492,
0.0058724363,
-0.0294759199,
0.0280658528,
-0.0244536735,
-0.0047525787,
0.0535955951,
-0.038967751,
-0.0139452945,
-0.0306122284,
-0.0030287437,
0.0166925658,
0.0000057094,
0.0554719791,
-0.0302832257,
-0.0060103135,
0.053515736,
-0.053298831,
-0.0049738544,
-0.0078512682,
-0.0311710481,
0.0301968791,
-0.0225690939,
-0.0220757201,
0.0374126844,
0.0009659354,
0.0023693603,
0.0603988655,
0.0396346636,
-0.0800988376,
0.0374938212,
-0.0118422369,
-0.0252508149,
0.0263812654,
0.0183800515,
0.0388814174,
-0.0009822126,
-0.0310155228,
-0.0424829274,
0.0044160997,
-0.041640956,
-0.0435241163,
-0.0124561451,
-0.003694942,
-0.0613680072,
-0.0700982511,
-0.0418252982,
-0.0018482757,
0.0493998155,
0.042885527,
0.033271905,
0.0557318293,
-0.0090171527,
-0.0351836719,
0.0320836455,
-0.054682415,
-0.0067034932,
0.0226098467,
-0.0479458421,
-0.0327278264,
0.052022066,
-0.0081118252,
-0.0003429117,
0.0259124469,
-0.0158493742,
0.0285064038,
-0.0124606779,
0.0269032903,
-0.0251295175,
-0.046198152,
-0.0360217839,
0.0043422109,
-0.0085270815,
-0.024635924,
-0.0149341309,
0.0490651168,
-0.0388119258,
-0.0202240441,
-0.0077517121,
0.0381953716,
0.0316703431,
-0.0155594507,
0.0143903801,
-0.0448248163,
0.029442668,
0.0305303577,
0.0162106939,
-0.0175952446,
-0.0076093464,
0.0041390811,
0.0141037516,
-0.0308620725,
-0.0307021346,
-0.0040875133,
-0.0054673292,
-0.0017069258,
-0.0116785793,
-0.0708463863,
-0.0369741693,
0.0476232283,
-0.0033189801,
0.0660294816,
-0.000101021,
0.114016436,
0.0613646358,
0.0271232203,
-0.0289276727,
-0.0115973391,
0.0069221649,
0.0872326344,
-0.0298757311,
0.0742871612,
-0.0004221788,
0.0086430311,
-0.0036745949,
-0.0003680967,
0.019721739,
0.0480839238,
-0.0229577925,
0.0060772011,
0.0112581495,
0.0193363316,
0.0499489792,
-0.0483593382,
0.0795521364,
-0.0208917223,
-0.0165132303,
-0.0224394277,
0.0437852889,
0.0124956528,
-0.0070650475,
0.014723124,
0.0038773464,
0.0080545824,
-0.0138493506,
0.0020151061,
-0.0619790815,
0.0002912937,
0.0386203974,
0.0007719729,
-0.0272298269,
-0.0476964042,
-0.0564104132,
0.0188951045,
0.0122821275,
-0.058299806,
-0.0779045224,
-0.0106367301,
-0.0199374054,
0.0303968024,
0.0249745715,
0.0118288212,
-0.0278781988,
0.0445710868,
0.0354231596,
-0.0010129755,
-0.0744202584,
0.0089271506,
-0.0143361948,
0.0177306496,
-0.0517276376,
-4.848821627e-33,
-0.01292344,
-0.0483511984,
0.0119541893,
0.0414118357,
-0.0089297015,
-0.0299927834,
-0.0271277074,
0.0297688674,
-0.0169106238,
0.0135303102,
-0.0504604541,
0.017684333,
0.0350481868,
-0.0111451186,
0.0569511428,
0.0127000371,
0.005371924,
0.02712542,
-0.011286566,
0.0027323822,
0.0534333773,
-0.0337851346,
0.0720951781,
-0.0874637365,
0.0585519522,
0.0561861061,
-0.0459607467,
-0.0496635959,
-0.0345192142,
0.0405119695,
-0.0322543569,
0.0413458385,
-0.0010508498,
-0.0114735113,
0.0015934088,
0.0421098396,
-0.0478176214,
-0.0064326352,
0.039521873,
0.0179880019,
0.0390488729,
-0.0230479967,
-0.0134415338,
0.0075952453,
-0.0642000884,
0.0329533406,
0.0293838792,
-0.0511227399,
-0.0382962227,
-0.051147256,
-0.0695044473,
0.078798309,
-0.0054973182,
0.0358521938,
0.0520579554,
0.0170233771,
-0.0133586554,
0.0018507479,
-0.0764263645,
0.0394126624,
-0.0480868034,
-0.0017220096,
-0.000843181,
-0.0839017555,
-0.0295297448,
0.0098725762,
-0.0088205263,
0.0594740249,
0.0076762969,
0.0658891052,
0.0411274321,
0.0296247844,
-0.0012800245,
0.0504625216,
0.0251598842,
-0.047406815,
-0.0173361264,
-0.0495376736,
0.0136360871,
0.0670513362,
0.017596513,
-0.047432933,
-0.0361699052,
-0.0162025969,
-0.0294040218,
-0.0581459403,
0.0197034366,
0.0108319847,
-0.0278369747,
-0.0278900396,
0.0356450267,
-0.0065570162,
0.0005400608,
-0.0177362952,
-0.010930595,
0.032953538,
-0.0246330556,
0.0492998175,
-0.0174721181,
-0.0106558744,
-0.0253197271,
-0.0268560797,
0.0031857197,
-0.00952804,
0.0299769677,
-0.001935974,
0.08111839,
-0.0651113167,
-0.0587449446,
-0.0134894848,
0.0197892152,
0.0291664116,
0.0113746589,
0.0016109822,
0.0341016836,
0.0347602628,
0.0586814843,
-0.0100183394,
0.0277928729,
0.0031814389,
-0.036194507,
0.0064094495,
-0.0048968177,
-0.022675585,
-0.0021276705,
0.0038441292,
0.0292445589,
0.0731637627,
0.0385662913,
0.0075501939,
0.0347722173,
0.0176042486,
2.215e-7,
0.1359387189,
0.0427953973,
0.0049862037,
0.0086474884,
0.0154618667,
-0.0020905845,
-0.0211010594,
0.0099768415,
0.0577687956,
-0.0201118086,
0.0199116543,
-0.0538992509,
0.0357900187,
0.037618041,
-0.0697612241,
-0.0172839258,
-0.0556080677,
-0.0141364699,
-0.0444885939,
0.0656804964,
0.0310125165,
0.0575184301,
-0.0105452174,
-0.0122654429,
-0.0504607968,
0.0110018756,
0.0356485173,
-0.0335420705,
-0.0182462987,
0.0050644372,
0.0901601091,
-0.0584481992,
-0.0171259735,
0.0483307578,
-0.0104867304,
0.0238053128,
-0.0252912771,
0.0175474901,
0.0149859963,
0.0801598057,
-0.0144381989,
-0.0200523082,
-0.0102714729,
0.0083313631,
-0.009569454,
0.0165321548,
-0.0386771262,
-0.0698617548,
-0.0256858543,
0.0322828963,
0.0186656099,
0.0616596974,
-0.0463707484,
-0.0113393823,
0.0229763314,
-0.0015096328,
0.0054105367,
-0.0649246201,
-0.0142175257,
0.0578931794,
-0.0059857741,
0.0051195822,
0.003623002,
-0.0149984173,
0.0158068668,
-0.0619261898,
-0.0081793498,
1.587718753e-34,
0.0240926836,
-0.0412835963,
0.0592828803,
0.0500100777,
0.0005350268,
0.0206119753,
0.0454867482,
0.0098741995,
0.0018746414,
-0.059007939,
0.0349887945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14718v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14718v5 | Leftover Lunch: Advantage-based Offline Reinforcement Learning for Language Models | 2023-05-24T04:42:17 | 2024-04-20T00:34:59 | Ashutosh Baheti, Ximing Lu, Faeze Brahman, Ronan Le Bras, Maarten Sap, Mark Riedl | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) is the most prominent
method for Language Model (LM) alignment. However, RLHF is an unstable and
data-hungry process that continually requires new high-quality LM-generated
data for finetuning. We introduce Advantage-Leftover Lunch RL (A-LoL), a new
class of offline policy gradient algorithms that enable RL training on any
pre-existing data. By assuming the entire LM output sequence as a single
action, A-LoL allows incorporating sequence-level classifiers or human-designed
scoring functions as rewards. Subsequently, by using LM's value estimate, A-LoL
only trains on positive advantage (leftover) data points, making it resilient
to noise. Overall, A-LoL is an easy-to-implement, sample-efficient, and stable
LM training recipe.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of A-LoL and its variants with a set of four
different language generation tasks. We compare against both online RL (PPO)
and recent preference-based (DPO, PRO) and reward-based (GOLD) offline RL
baselines. On the commonly-used RLHF benchmark, Helpful and Harmless Assistant
(HHA), LMs trained with A-LoL methods achieve the highest diversity while also
being rated more safe and helpful than the baselines according to humans.
Additionally, in the remaining three tasks, A-LoL could optimize multiple
distinct reward functions even when using noisy or suboptimal training data.
We also release our experimental code. https://github.com/abaheti95/LoL-RL | [
0.0215926785,
0.0956813022,
0.0178751815,
-0.0261244457,
-0.047024291,
0.0279663,
-0.0058882162,
-0.0253941882,
-0.0392123908,
-0.0077923671,
-0.0154095348,
-0.0556729324,
0.0252296329,
0.0175439771,
0.0121256951,
-0.0315595716,
0.0310371574,
-0.018094724,
0.0366345569,
-0.0228138864,
-0.0002122512,
0.027445849,
-0.02701387,
0.0576795824,
0.0314648263,
-0.0020697727,
-0.0173711479,
0.0079319095,
0.0532461293,
-0.0330603048,
0.0278417077,
0.0515910834,
0.015382397,
0.0380133726,
0.0000021396,
-0.0629602075,
-0.0519380495,
0.00672162,
-0.006169321,
-0.0483204946,
0.0160515327,
0.0091253724,
-0.0279393401,
0.0348014496,
-0.0167601537,
-0.0001021748,
0.0682728887,
0.0156952403,
0.0162826404,
0.1012314111,
0.0221346673,
-0.0123235872,
0.0302750748,
-0.0504108816,
0.0432664864,
-0.0163443349,
0.0164132789,
-0.0465968922,
-0.0248813704,
-0.0600938648,
-0.0128228897,
0.0187161956,
-0.0015430076,
-0.001978691,
-0.0038947721,
0.0498386733,
-0.0081766183,
-0.0511330925,
0.0081762392,
0.0843519494,
-0.0805986375,
-0.0136111202,
0.0303325672,
-0.0409062468,
0.0040085358,
-0.0386103056,
0.0043048155,
0.0658916086,
0.007939308,
0.0651526302,
0.0347378068,
-0.0242292341,
0.029433433,
0.0261856839,
0.0230573639,
0.0589690059,
0.002528216,
-0.0444367193,
0.0228586961,
0.0314243063,
-0.0465752631,
-0.0439438708,
-0.0211099871,
0.0332425199,
-0.0613619797,
0.0450353473,
-0.0585648194,
0.0160057787,
0.0119151995,
-0.0255613681,
0.0723362789,
0.0630232915,
-0.0039688577,
-0.0045927535,
-0.0075260391,
0.0582599565,
0.0091930954,
0.0267026853,
-0.0172671452,
0.0355247296,
-0.0249524731,
0.0072044865,
-0.0041247248,
0.0413799584,
-0.0231551509,
-0.0076370751,
-0.063112624,
0.0192160718,
-0.032538224,
0.0504326187,
0.0335814133,
-0.0074363011,
-0.0786203519,
0.0185676459,
-0.0501418188,
0.0132414438,
0.0081248041,
0.0013223316,
0.0397483036,
-0.065234229,
-0.0009631443,
0.0132084256,
0.0128544178,
-0.0080362121,
0.017501615,
0.0654198155,
-0.014601158,
-0.0453122035,
-0.0140516916,
-0.0329102911,
-0.0023584783,
-0.0848404914,
-0.0136366421,
-0.0654651895,
0.0091133732,
-0.0401416942,
-0.0053031538,
-0.0424899682,
0.023157604,
0.0250375252,
-0.0177293569,
0.0238869917,
-0.0047489633,
0.0169674624,
0.0154255889,
-0.0304691046,
-0.0123231169,
0.0785114467,
0.0429782756,
0.0035574073,
0.0187812969,
0.015388404,
-0.0132421656,
0.0246774871,
0.0570318922,
0.0110960091,
-0.0561928824,
-0.0160792135,
-0.0170201603,
0.047163561,
0.0387294777,
0.0146326972,
-0.016117774,
0.0386264399,
0.0858856738,
0.0142960241,
0.0134795392,
-0.0119945323,
0.0105475634,
0.0420736149,
-0.0440265536,
-0.008249592,
-0.0477943867,
0.0316249914,
-0.0362354703,
0.0528650247,
0.0335636474,
0.0465472117,
-0.022239482,
-0.0416260213,
0.0035804133,
-0.0275736973,
-0.0094489064,
0.0286435839,
0.0435694791,
0.0033266046,
-0.051199615,
-0.0114798527,
0.0483870432,
-0.0240102187,
0.0295312162,
-0.0366056114,
0.0506534912,
0.0782775581,
0.0446147397,
0.0095183542,
-0.0729081035,
-0.0524310172,
-0.0415979251,
0.0611457825,
-0.0013341799,
-0.0034935463,
0.0016096885,
-0.0640560314,
-0.0467526577,
0.0293406472,
0.0013073442,
0.0338321701,
0.0437256657,
0.0153013384,
0.0054781083,
0.0128658023,
-0.0864465162,
0.0343281813,
-0.019986026,
-0.0188721791,
0.026157409,
0.0192436129,
0.032269951,
-0.0181794316,
-0.0158184245,
0.0033031721,
0.0041246745,
-0.0083781248,
-0.0118242297,
0.0188442413,
-0.0601677746,
-0.0466725826,
0.0261762273,
0.0082001844,
-0.0028480801,
0.0443293266,
-0.0355606414,
-0.0265351571,
-0.0329851098,
-0.0159316286,
0.0009345376,
-0.0322236679,
0.0367517285,
0.0055608763,
-0.0064185117,
-0.0480372608,
0.0396187603,
-0.0534391217,
0.036262311,
-0.0219967049,
0.0061595617,
-0.0356703028,
-0.0615902357,
-0.0318522453,
0.0095278239,
-0.0164220575,
0.0300480463,
0.0299325753,
0.0726065412,
-0.0479601137,
-0.0112890881,
-0.0307793655,
0.0129791871,
-0.0380951725,
0.0319599509,
0.0431244224,
-0.0149341403,
-0.0113072926,
-0.0169499256,
-0.0493340604,
-0.0047635217,
0.0291197337,
0.0055249301,
0.0388099588,
0.0039524361,
-0.0036093947,
-0.0427538939,
-0.0002169043,
0.0251951031,
-0.0085967164,
-0.0438777655,
0.0335280411,
-0.0457697399,
-0.0386497006,
-0.0598851703,
0.016902389,
0.0029697625,
-0.0421385504,
-0.0006225336,
-0.0082306461,
0.0366181135,
0.0859914497,
0.0297886003,
0.0044539892,
0.0634068176,
0.0212473758,
-0.0811263844,
0.0070519303,
-0.0379547887,
-0.0056461138,
-0.0455264971,
-0.0023476991,
-0.0195833724,
0.074513495,
-0.0140044503,
0.02816201,
-0.0679824576,
0.0018814821,
0.010552519,
-0.0325848982,
-0.014493837,
0.0196589809,
-0.0606694594,
0.0064711492,
-0.0385802053,
-0.0854271054,
0.0883656591,
-0.0216752253,
-0.008815309,
-0.0546264946,
-0.0229190551,
0.0106236944,
0.0111198286,
0.0039845346,
0.0358695798,
-0.0146789961,
-0.0085082874,
-0.0585529841,
-0.0257975943,
0.0569450855,
-0.0506212488,
0.0283048321,
-0.0536214747,
0.0105781425,
-0.0255901963,
-0.0226322562,
-0.0743815303,
-0.0306863282,
0.0031966295,
-0.0227358341,
-0.0080271857,
-0.0271085631,
-0.0177848469,
0.0175811518,
0.0097580515,
0.0592256561,
-0.0279217493,
0.0087986635,
-0.0234884359,
0.0201256219,
0.09038008,
0.0081747109,
0.0102354046,
-0.0205619354,
0.0063285693,
0.0120425718,
0.0262412485,
-0.0116930781,
0.0116173923,
0.0157639645,
0.0635145679,
-0.0557050481,
-0.0040055462,
0.0557339638,
0.0235478729,
-0.0370916799,
-0.0366676487,
0.1163597032,
0.0071138139,
-0.0721733123,
-0.0026220302,
0.0070738909,
0.0583514497,
0.0068541048,
0.0127502345,
-0.0355247445,
-0.0051369341,
0.0200417601,
0.0557152852,
-0.0309531596,
-0.0032554204,
-0.0327485539,
-0.1472261697,
0.0099759465,
0.0234169997,
-0.0706757829,
-0.0022258009,
-0.0061147646,
0.0011779855,
-0.0234167185,
0.0332765058,
0.0408208258,
-0.0042394768,
0.003380886,
0.0278199855,
0.0104442248,
-0.0652963966,
-0.0319401063,
-0.0453343429,
0.0806551725,
0.1276143938,
0.0224525612,
0.0198412258,
-0.0448721908,
0.0219499301,
0.0128259948,
0.0036370796,
-0.0053078169,
0.0153677147,
-0.0287557766,
-0.0102777239,
0.0015590719,
0.0643420592,
-0.0037723964,
0.0197773967,
-0.0114940973,
0.0487030409,
-0.0006650682,
0.0130820852,
0.019163508,
0.0133008389,
0.0484911464,
0.0357312709,
-0.0203181449,
-0.0612488613,
-0.0099568488,
0.014331134,
-0.0176619496,
-0.0365084857,
-0.0072775944,
0.0076549682,
-0.0346397497,
-0.0229985826,
-0.0649696216,
-0.0590735227,
-0.0234489795,
0.0724019781,
-0.0194831081,
-0.0302075278,
-0.0196961444,
0.0396325178,
-0.0415547825,
0.01576907,
-0.0285218339,
0.0209817924,
-0.0441437289,
-0.0244043916,
0.0016851276,
-0.0227948874,
-0.0066115339,
-0.0306778513,
-0.0564967096,
-0.0824132785,
0.006008747,
0.0667798519,
0.0161009524,
0.0961313993,
0.0073350756,
-0.0381136797,
0.0776823685,
0.0439825729,
-0.0260033924,
0.0226458237,
0.0424627326,
-0.0034912645,
0.0121765202,
0.0457600877,
-0.0417534709,
-0.0041691782,
0.0120322434,
0.0638968572,
0.005602791,
0.0101318862,
0.0099590924,
-0.0213598516,
0.0512392111,
-0.066858165,
-0.0355480611,
-0.025395114,
0.0306388345,
0.010796614,
-0.0337107517,
-0.0186315943,
-0.0117971823,
0.0359386839,
-0.0000590897,
0.0067276405,
0.0000909095,
-0.0028204706,
0.0272087827,
-0.0152667109,
-0.0069242911,
-0.0127224065,
0.044325199,
0.028201649,
0.0407506861,
-0.0180938225,
0.0196316298,
-0.003617523,
0.0307472646,
-0.0109119955,
0.0635941401,
0.0296452865,
0.0389080159,
0.0171488654,
0.0111504011,
-0.0140148839,
-0.0285893511,
-0.067861855,
0.0000727192,
0.0805005506,
0.0163551942,
0.0884519443,
-0.013511206,
-0.0098244892,
-0.0231225621,
-0.0002992168,
-0.0716063231,
-0.0306522604,
0.0211962871,
0.0048704264,
-0.0111684911,
-0.0031619845,
0.0796794742,
0.0116424561,
0.017401915,
-0.0217266604,
0.0522238128,
-0.0280758608,
-0.0229324959,
0.0013171792,
0.031290248,
-0.0326416716,
-0.038514182,
-0.0106171155,
-0.0478811227,
-0.0226253122,
0.0247101411,
0.0027068793,
0.0091541912,
0.0422786623,
0.0191310626,
-0.0606850311,
0.0114479046,
-0.0776868165,
-0.0135131553,
-0.0180971287,
-0.0122774383,
-0.0114988619,
-6.690794826e-33,
-0.0223159753,
-0.0355305225,
0.0234183446,
-0.0185178425,
-0.0431365743,
0.0041079717,
-0.0004814373,
-0.0024063364,
0.0283854045,
-0.0121954316,
-0.015575151,
-0.0152950305,
0.0203731433,
0.0476960205,
0.0140569806,
-0.019767167,
0.0312772878,
-0.0102894576,
-0.0562645644,
0.0268938392,
0.0322198346,
0.0245990381,
0.0490751453,
-0.0037918342,
0.0323422775,
-0.0017757521,
-0.0386463255,
0.015567068,
-0.0195316672,
0.0368709899,
0.0198141914,
0.0082501564,
0.0009821234,
-0.0269114617,
-0.0199626777,
-0.0168414675,
-0.0500106774,
-0.0251927059,
-0.0009270975,
0.000615176,
-0.0505244881,
-0.0236387141,
0.0365571566,
-0.0113888895,
-0.0242453422,
0.0151154846,
0.0061678509,
-0.0302568004,
-0.0553089492,
-0.0149620511,
-0.0426829793,
0.0154504059,
0.0097593805,
-0.0175334811,
0.0093472535,
0.0319266468,
0.0019855555,
0.0043442734,
-0.0376491398,
0.0438095443,
-0.0057624113,
0.0241263714,
0.0981278494,
0.0250353813,
0.0258748382,
0.0194453746,
-0.0077623688,
-0.0289977882,
0.0422416478,
0.0079428311,
0.036007829,
0.005206597,
-0.0074135363,
0.0332816839,
0.0514678769,
-0.0134297563,
-0.0340789519,
0.0426454134,
0.0227513034,
0.006370212,
0.0314088576,
0.0144442422,
-0.0418470167,
-0.0147424387,
-0.0543320514,
-0.048752632,
-0.0328385383,
-0.0543594584,
0.0342096202,
0.0707013682,
-0.026538685,
-0.02916882,
0.0091862101,
-0.0042508021,
-0.0111869834,
0.0267056897,
-0.0270225536,
-0.0148934349,
-0.0131020127,
-0.0170595255,
-0.1075866371,
-0.0512230583,
0.0010977256,
-0.0342732519,
-0.0206590202,
0.0149821155,
0.0262734462,
0.0433554426,
-0.0639987737,
0.0410889946,
-0.0323061794,
0.0517841913,
0.0098828627,
0.0318031572,
0.0628751293,
-0.0604809448,
-0.0021078349,
0.0865799189,
0.0226265583,
-0.0214670878,
-0.0393644981,
-0.0115626473,
-0.019538546,
0.0157157537,
-0.0322949104,
0.0261658356,
0.001624012,
-0.0010689531,
0.0060205646,
-0.0181717984,
0.0065153451,
0.0057125189,
2.88e-7,
-0.0371278301,
0.0364115275,
0.0330722742,
0.0180232935,
0.0010536454,
0.0166346598,
-0.0244862102,
0.0208922271,
0.0053596031,
0.0476519689,
0.0426825806,
-0.0127078714,
0.0592328496,
0.0256594364,
-0.0392256826,
0.005162606,
-0.0944187865,
0.0222458411,
-0.0430312604,
-0.0401477776,
-0.0083024539,
0.0672641844,
0.025378434,
-0.0073915888,
0.0293258503,
0.032453306,
0.0454443246,
-0.0179308858,
-0.0174352098,
-0.0247386489,
0.0286572687,
0.0116636008,
-0.0280452929,
-0.0391312391,
-0.0201401152,
0.0223186594,
-0.0606852435,
0.079358913,
0.0141761983,
-0.0446365848,
-0.0138980383,
0.0186293442,
0.0317774639,
-0.052576419,
0.0419936664,
-0.0664665624,
0.0001382712,
-0.0072659715,
-0.0071016122,
-0.0193803869,
0.0097754104,
-0.0564287491,
-0.0250678081,
0.0267350525,
0.0189859904,
0.0263695419,
-0.0175344907,
-0.0482947342,
-0.0186389685,
0.0342521779,
0.023321772,
-0.0692356229,
-0.0451825149,
0.0466757864,
-0.0176875982,
-0.0433280841,
-0.0203191116,
2.635938864e-34,
0.0100873932,
-0.0317742266,
0.0056840405,
0.0045424495,
-0.0280511845,
0.0197941083,
0.0115491562,
0.0064916592,
0.0426056087,
-0.0149567677,
-0.0289430432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14717v1 | Exploiting Correlations Between Contexts and Definitions with Multiple Definition Modeling | 2023-05-24T04:38:29 | 2023-05-24T04:38:29 | Linhan Zhang, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Yuxin Jiang, Bing Li, Wei Wang, Xin Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Definition modeling is an important task in advanced natural language
applications such as understanding and conversation. Since its introduction, it
focus on generating one definition for a target word or phrase in a given
context, which we refer to as Single Definition Modeling (SDM). However, this
approach does not adequately model the correlations and patterns among
different contexts and definitions of words. In addition, the creation of a
training dataset for SDM requires significant human expertise and effort. In
this paper, we carefully design a new task called Multiple Definition Modeling
(MDM) that pool together all contexts and definition of target words. We
demonstrate the ease of creating a model as well as multiple training sets
automatically. % In the experiments, we demonstrate and analyze the benefits of
MDM, including improving SDM's performance by using MDM as the pretraining task
and its comparable performance in the zero-shot setting. | [
0.0079381419,
-0.0095606847,
-0.013694359,
0.03471753,
-0.0422748327,
-0.0014342767,
0.0226659141,
-0.0113078682,
-0.0675614029,
-0.058552701,
-0.0408993289,
-0.0209662169,
-0.007799027,
0.0292307083,
0.0004005393,
-0.0349496789,
0.0983848721,
0.0085430136,
-0.0301138964,
0.0170162655,
0.0362634324,
0.0133816274,
0.0093917176,
0.0022274314,
-0.0790032074,
-0.0148266209,
-0.0100698564,
-0.0012115445,
0.0067064702,
-0.0591532104,
-0.005796609,
0.0620061494,
0.0778122172,
-0.0119007295,
0.0000019578,
-0.0724821761,
-0.0497845672,
-0.0206216648,
-0.0309064444,
-0.0593462735,
0.0571092553,
-0.0142720081,
0.0528879464,
-0.0081702713,
-0.0526429303,
0.0139143104,
0.0220301114,
0.0449017696,
0.0579122193,
0.0332845002,
-0.0175693445,
-0.1105553657,
-0.0352856293,
-0.0023793411,
0.0221705679,
-0.0652891919,
0.0354086161,
0.0672456697,
-0.0373784006,
-0.0127220508,
-0.0229368079,
-0.0024216978,
-0.0173686352,
0.0552630946,
0.0232623182,
0.0065621063,
-0.000176146,
-0.0498081371,
0.0021641182,
0.0817469582,
0.0241181292,
-0.0040667448,
-0.019019492,
0.0004994924,
-0.0137968762,
0.01833882,
-0.0329743512,
-0.0202994402,
-0.00708701,
0.0031390884,
0.0015628999,
0.0154392887,
0.003212281,
0.044286631,
-0.0562536567,
0.0085439347,
-0.0123308543,
-0.0296811704,
-0.0260473918,
-0.0343776569,
-0.0254606046,
-0.0369747914,
-0.0232465863,
0.0186638068,
-0.034884885,
0.0618307218,
-0.0723628625,
-0.0779697299,
0.0614736751,
-0.0225393344,
0.0124646751,
0.0045146272,
-0.0171301384,
0.0806961954,
0.0070908251,
0.0153292939,
0.0104980906,
-0.0343453139,
-0.0463642254,
-0.0032293145,
-0.0831385702,
0.0047538304,
-0.049029544,
0.0458775312,
-0.0147653092,
-0.0377208106,
-0.0642501563,
0.0191984139,
-0.0060110954,
-0.0272638761,
-0.0177732259,
0.0214067716,
-0.0703918263,
0.0457818061,
0.0094213812,
-0.017183926,
-0.0748029351,
0.0476047099,
-0.0124360612,
-0.0578010119,
-0.0174919367,
0.0473619848,
0.0101170968,
-0.0275205504,
-0.0002418113,
0.0558054484,
0.0087717921,
-0.0720477477,
-0.0018256605,
-0.0878470987,
-0.048261039,
-0.0178095028,
-0.04312592,
-0.0609047711,
0.0404702872,
-0.002956501,
0.0084067397,
-0.0187430233,
-0.0158692673,
0.0040719882,
-0.0100317374,
0.1091579944,
-0.0389129408,
0.017779259,
0.0488181934,
0.0490313508,
-0.0021828646,
0.0861290395,
0.0094693061,
-0.013419603,
0.0616100542,
0.0201312583,
-0.0110444343,
0.0157396514,
-0.008348532,
-0.0217466652,
-0.0262549538,
0.0049449056,
0.0062987087,
0.04765746,
0.0113934185,
0.0159843192,
-0.0622268803,
0.0190791413,
0.024286177,
0.0720026642,
0.0565291606,
-0.0313557461,
0.074363023,
0.0168019552,
-0.0007009079,
-0.0178759377,
-0.0174615346,
-0.024618309,
-0.0160071217,
0.0079984227,
-0.0094468603,
-0.0039266855,
-0.0317198262,
-0.0058930023,
-0.0136734648,
-0.0388782434,
-0.0164264273,
-0.0066546099,
0.0626798198,
0.0102159008,
-0.0062444122,
0.0622465238,
0.0184105765,
-0.0237910766,
0.0239129383,
-0.0392565019,
0.0182728935,
0.0364187323,
0.0422878191,
-0.0219497457,
-0.0359797478,
-0.0154607436,
0.025909273,
0.0323724225,
0.0290499702,
-0.0229209233,
0.0207012352,
-0.0393250547,
-0.0279393736,
-0.0457459651,
0.0080802515,
0.0220033899,
0.0254879799,
-0.0006485856,
0.0183668006,
-0.0065677701,
0.0156687871,
0.0466485135,
0.0009257622,
-0.0074506118,
-0.0131147876,
-0.003132185,
0.0590875335,
0.0385446511,
-0.0365908369,
0.0014703157,
0.0370537974,
-0.0210701879,
0.0175235868,
0.0370545425,
-0.045111727,
-0.0084157782,
-0.0005942198,
-0.0324675851,
0.0069321333,
-0.0033717952,
-0.0210254602,
-0.0557805151,
0.0018618315,
0.0194208343,
0.0278846212,
-0.0531693064,
-0.0028458498,
0.001911469,
0.041013509,
-0.0210633297,
0.0946892872,
0.0267241672,
0.0021950395,
0.0132877128,
0.0369868018,
0.0158244744,
-0.0156446565,
-0.0376652628,
-0.0345355533,
-0.0167676061,
0.0070142709,
0.0257060025,
0.0038547239,
-0.0746326968,
-0.0007600443,
-0.0811974555,
0.026531782,
-0.0039152578,
-0.0105996206,
0.0361544043,
0.0077021918,
-0.0095757172,
-0.0246229246,
-0.0077548148,
0.0162752289,
0.0105179651,
0.0273207072,
0.0283084381,
0.0323502496,
-0.0344406515,
-0.02772112,
0.0168314241,
-0.0195451025,
0.0325085148,
-0.0000219615,
-0.0444696546,
0.0000956857,
0.0592992194,
-0.0467189848,
0.0150461039,
-0.0154092861,
0.0139345508,
0.0406229459,
-0.0173105355,
0.0070889965,
0.0117988288,
0.044758752,
0.0469765104,
0.0406593755,
-0.0420054235,
-0.0350006819,
-0.0010856552,
-0.0090956278,
0.0166177657,
0.0155720422,
-0.0020330262,
-0.0079303561,
0.0433966666,
0.0501240715,
0.0189322457,
0.0024105178,
0.0327440389,
-0.0009443831,
-0.0347629003,
-0.0617158413,
0.0008534658,
-0.0442308113,
0.0665495247,
-0.0379161872,
-0.0253351573,
0.047611922,
0.002797537,
0.0043902504,
-0.0339822918,
-0.0027758898,
-0.011175829,
0.0717678592,
-0.041797094,
0.0155812651,
0.0034906443,
-0.0133426432,
-0.0431209318,
-0.0561956353,
0.0515356213,
-0.0396885872,
0.0589786507,
-0.0657931417,
0.0137270717,
0.0059410874,
0.0109297456,
-0.0618727021,
-0.0213229675,
-0.0425725169,
0.019625606,
-0.0064939372,
0.037811745,
-0.0193164181,
0.00701431,
-0.0003347741,
0.0112790503,
0.0207353495,
-0.0112558911,
-0.0308041796,
0.0165452249,
0.0431528874,
0.0159356855,
-0.0489531867,
-0.0298582017,
0.0600511655,
0.017795559,
0.0093785748,
0.0257742628,
-0.032352414,
0.0187048875,
-0.0039328746,
-0.0359465331,
-0.0319251195,
0.0242476854,
0.0140352258,
-0.0140672708,
-0.0128690721,
0.1226712987,
0.0387622006,
-0.0581369773,
-0.0158886723,
-0.0320462771,
-0.002993854,
0.0363127179,
-0.0075015579,
-0.1281840652,
-0.0713032261,
-0.0251618773,
-0.010657751,
0.0227158908,
-0.0164089799,
-0.0469050221,
-0.0496820733,
-0.0260742325,
-0.0253195688,
-0.0754379705,
0.0327158198,
-0.0305243544,
0.0244971476,
-0.0167855285,
0.0203631558,
-0.0249332301,
0.0175642036,
-0.0226879567,
-0.0060906354,
0.004567862,
-0.0653675571,
0.0832109451,
-0.0168520268,
0.0368023068,
0.0729644373,
0.0187786203,
0.0011520534,
0.0024474573,
0.0047262572,
-0.0228551719,
0.0273231566,
-0.025579419,
0.0408054478,
-0.049652867,
0.0123857325,
0.019979598,
-0.0141605148,
-0.0315676518,
-0.044779554,
-0.002689264,
0.0256452207,
-0.0273045935,
0.009861609,
-0.0194904488,
0.0250310153,
0.0247135218,
0.0990804061,
0.0214677136,
-0.0130834617,
0.0210901126,
0.0557627976,
0.007670274,
-0.0263605267,
0.0068835318,
-0.028238887,
-0.0609328523,
-0.0167131796,
-0.0372227356,
-0.035172116,
0.0518468022,
0.045332104,
0.0320857167,
0.062347427,
-0.0400889739,
0.0203817748,
-0.0587064028,
0.040694315,
-0.0151845459,
0.0151350079,
-0.0335193388,
-0.032862857,
0.0512473993,
-0.006755047,
-0.0353896469,
0.0704604983,
-0.0531415939,
-0.0302007589,
0.0057777353,
0.0307158139,
0.0324922651,
0.0467473045,
-0.0205137264,
0.0074916566,
-0.0020710577,
0.0015987131,
-0.0205451362,
0.0078074452,
0.0215569157,
0.0077021131,
-0.0086754439,
0.0182462838,
-0.0432019234,
0.060706649,
-0.0192823634,
0.012327943,
-0.0785574168,
-0.0316469148,
0.0424452536,
-0.0153393317,
0.0526999123,
-0.0350350924,
0.0022634694,
-0.0212776214,
-0.0253367387,
-0.0384960175,
-0.0558618121,
-0.0081867781,
0.0088442545,
-0.0157750696,
-0.0511455983,
0.0040317895,
0.0023410062,
-0.056193348,
-0.0155434618,
0.0056006536,
-0.0197407808,
0.0545580126,
0.004378641,
-0.019384902,
0.0030312901,
-0.0185022429,
0.0032219507,
-0.0232261922,
-0.0180532057,
-0.019804325,
0.085196875,
0.0055531324,
0.0263596363,
-0.0235608127,
0.021610735,
-0.0258051232,
-0.0055370918,
0.0032346041,
0.0132996915,
0.0550408289,
-0.0065928171,
0.0375725217,
0.0115984958,
0.0050888355,
-0.0088626165,
0.0651374385,
-0.0150390686,
-0.02957974,
0.0566045158,
0.0365473628,
-0.0011578719,
-0.007212481,
0.0601339005,
-0.0683164671,
0.0479415618,
-0.0198726468,
-0.0138713429,
-0.0503251031,
0.0278897695,
0.0612374432,
0.0577749908,
-0.0182282105,
0.0148188658,
-0.07248009,
-0.03567864,
0.0538101308,
0.0058507803,
0.0177933481,
0.0626369119,
0.0742737204,
0.0824456215,
0.003213224,
-0.0095927631,
-0.0208180379,
-0.0065111709,
0.0037192937,
-0.0165349655,
-0.0122331381,
-6.036232184e-33,
-0.0491997562,
-0.0279992111,
0.0173216872,
-0.0222211294,
-0.0272926483,
0.018998852,
-0.0282268263,
-0.0066369749,
-0.0316237696,
-0.0110892095,
0.0016878375,
0.0285322983,
0.0172594134,
-0.0251402277,
0.008662967,
-0.0121742003,
0.0284025446,
-0.0141563658,
0.0104386723,
-0.0079082418,
0.0619239025,
0.0365188904,
0.0481487289,
-0.0244250055,
0.0377658568,
0.0078512756,
-0.0111331027,
0.0149793439,
0.0271237735,
0.0506280735,
-0.0173049439,
0.0453999899,
0.0479287617,
-0.0165967252,
-0.0207110979,
0.0314944498,
-0.0512859263,
-0.0685638487,
0.0611656159,
0.009656487,
-0.0351469554,
0.0132068051,
0.0279475935,
-0.0194707885,
0.018388804,
0.0476240776,
0.0674097389,
-0.0064228261,
-0.0585183203,
-0.0055247014,
-0.059087202,
0.027793441,
0.0056294664,
-0.048693303,
0.0088083539,
0.0126414793,
0.0148430001,
-0.0253555514,
-0.0274677183,
0.0467775203,
-0.0147286644,
0.0036106389,
0.0326715633,
0.0579861179,
-0.001153331,
0.0671477169,
-0.007899316,
-0.0396238193,
0.0221955851,
-0.0330493487,
0.0082546687,
0.0658041686,
-0.0321110114,
0.0767505541,
0.0589196309,
0.0001717508,
-0.0336805172,
0.0094671967,
0.0325468965,
0.0644128695,
-0.0019293826,
-0.008853565,
-0.0148269506,
0.0070795687,
-0.0460910238,
0.0300173126,
-0.0558999479,
-0.0278680436,
0.0594723597,
0.0132699516,
-0.0112334499,
0.001414457,
0.0296658128,
-0.0397264473,
0.0291960835,
0.0323616043,
-0.0073980372,
-0.0053150295,
-0.0134804361,
0.0048698583,
-0.0014057877,
-0.064858757,
0.0045675342,
0.0270742048,
0.0190632213,
0.0107489973,
0.0317864083,
-0.0327060893,
0.0031521262,
-0.0185000151,
0.0011975642,
-0.0344898477,
-0.0517400131,
-0.0283679366,
0.0437269136,
0.0392981991,
-0.0180451721,
0.0147517594,
0.0495348088,
-0.0342004858,
-0.0438674428,
-0.0449300781,
-0.019185558,
0.056602668,
-0.0240746271,
-0.0014772406,
-0.0069431695,
-0.0586658232,
0.0642233789,
-0.0106613655,
-0.010175053,
-0.0074746069,
2.698e-7,
0.0523566566,
0.0291800573,
-0.0258013085,
0.0398994572,
0.0071881865,
0.0161139667,
-0.0275536776,
0.0187124982,
-0.0298923273,
-0.0240971446,
0.0263391528,
0.0271733683,
-0.0107211089,
-0.0012642661,
-0.0683375672,
-0.0416221805,
-0.0106496885,
0.0675381497,
-0.0415648445,
0.0032384403,
0.0892764255,
0.070784539,
0.0071075819,
-0.0067638038,
-0.0592570826,
-0.0102430452,
0.048137106,
-0.0141058145,
0.0295063332,
0.0241961628,
-0.0048740795,
0.0151521713,
0.0028196878,
0.0587278083,
-0.0276066605,
0.0138049442,
0.0090389838,
0.0562007204,
-0.0328186341,
-0.0072304131,
-0.0056310329,
0.0031923281,
-0.0305649284,
-0.0186503474,
0.0676458478,
-0.0617247671,
-0.0109481923,
-0.0632156879,
-0.0529013835,
0.0201906525,
0.0171502288,
0.008654533,
-0.032162562,
0.0025817601,
0.0059270817,
0.0021902714,
-0.0393996388,
-0.1033624709,
0.0295072794,
0.0436316691,
-0.0555868931,
0.0054596071,
0.0042162635,
-0.042048268,
0.0477812737,
-0.0557014719,
-0.0165593401,
1.885756736e-34,
0.0190291274,
0.0213123206,
0.0331764854,
0.0410802439,
-0.0021291627,
-0.0388013087,
-0.0775818676,
0.0173948519,
0.0278431121,
-0.0633062869,
-0.0119162388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14716v1 | GlobalBench: A Benchmark for Global Progress in Natural Language Processing | 2023-05-24T04:36:32 | 2023-05-24T04:36:32 | Yueqi Song, Catherine Cui, Simran Khanuja, Pengfei Liu, Fahim Faisal, Alissa Ostapenko, Genta Indra Winata, Alham Fikri Aji, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Yulia Tsvetkov, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the major advances in NLP, significant disparities in NLP system
performance across languages still exist. Arguably, these are due to uneven
resource allocation and sub-optimal incentives to work on less resourced
languages. To track and further incentivize the global development of equitable
language technology, we introduce GlobalBench. Prior multilingual benchmarks
are static and have focused on a limited number of tasks and languages. In
contrast, GlobalBench is an ever-expanding collection that aims to dynamically
track progress on all NLP datasets in all languages. Rather than solely
measuring accuracy, GlobalBench also tracks the estimated per-speaker utility
and equity of technology across all languages, providing a multi-faceted view
of how language technology is serving people of the world. Furthermore,
GlobalBench is designed to identify the most under-served languages, and
rewards research efforts directed towards those languages. At present, the most
under-served languages are the ones with a relatively high population, but
nonetheless overlooked by composite multilingual benchmarks (like Punjabi,
Portuguese, and Wu Chinese). Currently, GlobalBench covers 966 datasets in 190
languages, and has 1,128 system submissions spanning 62 languages. | [
0.0468732156,
0.1025996432,
-0.0280548166,
0.0272582881,
-0.044004906,
0.0022972843,
0.027141178,
-0.0052468018,
-0.0037568032,
-0.028302053,
-0.0008106368,
-0.0237631667,
0.0307305604,
0.0307667572,
0.0172472801,
-0.0873263851,
0.0370160826,
0.0058102808,
-0.0085790167,
-0.0033071195,
0.0327675082,
0.0249509364,
-0.020246977,
0.0506895594,
-0.0342047922,
0.0111625455,
0.04377966,
-0.0471895151,
-0.000082142,
-0.0222624466,
0.0001248916,
0.040996097,
-0.0552608632,
0.0534576774,
0.0000018729,
-0.0749893561,
0.0040769316,
-0.0146003375,
-0.0212243833,
0.0031012238,
0.0620135479,
-0.0410333276,
-0.0408763625,
0.0201960504,
-0.0418694653,
-0.0151228337,
0.0678823888,
-0.0191377215,
0.0161567722,
0.0451746695,
-0.006384572,
0.0048107221,
0.0125153465,
-0.0106415506,
-0.0641144887,
-0.0344460383,
-0.0246116538,
-0.0058411779,
0.0083750803,
-0.0456070416,
-0.0285464451,
0.0471140258,
0.0154896006,
-0.0128587885,
0.0224195328,
0.0111038852,
-0.0770139843,
-0.0509385318,
0.0092815291,
0.062900126,
-0.0034364755,
-0.0301133543,
-0.0270462744,
-0.0002986887,
-0.0254854262,
-0.0387039743,
-0.0313343927,
0.0403234065,
-0.002687898,
0.0322084054,
0.0493335761,
0.0470400043,
0.030619856,
0.029262051,
0.013355826,
0.0701906085,
0.0098086195,
-0.0170249119,
0.0209012534,
0.0535484478,
0.0009245171,
-0.0254085921,
0.0364688449,
-0.020269746,
-0.0462634303,
0.0034195834,
0.016678961,
-0.0557487458,
0.0312643424,
-0.0359751135,
0.0165627152,
0.0344030783,
-0.0234474521,
0.0394537933,
-0.0032088524,
0.0455087088,
-0.0011803146,
-0.0461605936,
-0.0194036607,
-0.0556060374,
-0.0179673973,
-0.0013159018,
0.0026155503,
-0.0005459881,
-0.084357664,
0.0080842674,
-0.0577147715,
-0.0109628588,
-0.0321559198,
0.0064112614,
0.0399234109,
0.007877415,
-0.0294213966,
0.0246009845,
-0.0040064915,
0.0523369908,
-0.0587304644,
-0.0181497782,
-0.0340041853,
-0.0815561786,
0.0372264273,
-0.005121863,
-0.028553294,
-0.0183220319,
0.0351590626,
0.078804709,
0.026657505,
-0.0161769595,
-0.0447955467,
-0.0033039155,
-0.0053920615,
-0.0646056905,
-0.0265208185,
-0.0601136647,
0.0452278741,
0.0210172478,
0.0458399206,
-0.016940156,
-0.0061227242,
-0.0060368204,
0.0027508491,
0.0486667566,
-0.0140381362,
-0.0192214027,
0.0187813304,
-0.0136271426,
0.0100043435,
0.0953223929,
0.0233756676,
-0.0447121486,
0.1004175991,
0.0024306236,
-0.0331163332,
0.0475278273,
0.0052052881,
0.014393881,
0.0042399885,
0.001809487,
-0.0042121792,
0.0160546396,
0.0162652917,
0.0252270438,
0.0182418227,
0.0096218688,
0.0292122234,
0.0775442645,
0.010976783,
0.0222777929,
-0.0346147493,
-0.0189601835,
-0.0304224081,
-0.0489290543,
-0.0039722421,
-0.0011234597,
-0.0110295061,
-0.0062563792,
0.0092256675,
0.042504482,
-0.0177710485,
-0.0315265618,
-0.0170866214,
0.0146436393,
0.0281355176,
-0.0191397071,
0.0489222594,
-0.0111977821,
0.0179248229,
0.02910785,
0.0560342371,
-0.0731915608,
0.0308478251,
-0.0245714467,
-0.0324303731,
0.0413982645,
0.0285501145,
-0.0133491363,
0.0125752818,
0.0128228758,
-0.0061495248,
0.0745149925,
0.0262678489,
-0.0182089992,
0.0484012999,
-0.0106503572,
-0.005380956,
0.0363248512,
0.0024786729,
0.0123123415,
0.0526580885,
0.058254905,
-0.018401077,
-0.0546670146,
-0.0267915186,
0.0353650674,
-0.0440066494,
0.0165268425,
0.0208646003,
-0.0084221801,
0.0120614255,
0.0636659116,
-0.0286690909,
-0.0087740701,
-0.0030464213,
-0.0558485128,
-0.01492,
0.0456313267,
-0.0128313648,
-0.0237934645,
0.0330911651,
-0.0883088112,
-0.0175302066,
0.0558647066,
-0.0060079675,
-0.0404461101,
0.0463623852,
-0.0058629117,
0.025120208,
-0.0304268636,
0.0302100386,
-0.0316586308,
0.0205169301,
-0.0266975276,
0.0521040037,
-0.0006639422,
0.0413862541,
0.0011592418,
-0.0234452877,
0.0345108397,
-0.0427671708,
-0.0420505404,
0.0581719168,
0.023821678,
-0.0026736171,
0.0567395873,
0.0336500481,
-0.059515655,
0.030404428,
-0.1047080383,
-0.0006364001,
-0.0286801811,
0.0244524553,
0.0105542615,
0.0464968756,
-0.0168775506,
-0.0146325408,
-0.0205416549,
-0.0274126902,
0.0438230485,
0.0301617421,
0.0321963094,
-0.0119866161,
0.0202791337,
-0.0471357144,
-0.0362148993,
0.0323386453,
0.0189575218,
0.0132338703,
-0.0491327941,
-0.0154112177,
-0.0266049523,
-0.0255473461,
0.0354360417,
-0.0027949556,
-0.0257993527,
-0.0126205031,
0.0371666141,
-0.0084813256,
0.0333940834,
-0.0166348852,
-0.0016606132,
0.0193450917,
0.0035291915,
-0.0591401942,
-0.0115063433,
0.013342361,
0.0140717747,
0.0005136352,
-0.0213377979,
0.0336561315,
0.0605716556,
-0.0025355583,
-0.0246195346,
-0.025041813,
-0.028513778,
-0.0958345309,
-0.0385369807,
-0.0583710931,
0.0168160424,
-0.0243782103,
0.0415555462,
-0.0255100243,
-0.0425600745,
0.0523451641,
-0.0134962164,
-0.0003598412,
-0.0598372743,
-0.0183504447,
-0.0452186428,
0.055734355,
-0.0210369546,
0.0232839491,
-0.0196299907,
-0.050836958,
-0.0031987384,
0.0285728797,
0.0462337546,
-0.0213627052,
0.0215657596,
-0.0562453307,
0.0139835821,
-0.0409570225,
-0.0767996535,
-0.0221745186,
-0.005263722,
-0.0381080508,
0.0210606698,
0.0571611822,
-0.030419318,
-0.0146177784,
0.0255525298,
0.0340659432,
0.0440404192,
0.038425874,
0.0078963712,
0.0013928852,
-0.0072746789,
0.0028363448,
0.0071213744,
0.0428709202,
0.0003662381,
0.0169139039,
0.0399305224,
0.0815329179,
0.0116590336,
0.0202117413,
0.0187964067,
0.0521908887,
-0.0331818275,
-0.0305299684,
-0.0362217613,
0.0555253811,
-0.016756596,
0.0179515593,
0.0883208215,
0.0136060109,
-0.0356498696,
0.0239684954,
-0.0116183599,
0.0202431176,
0.0331502929,
0.014258123,
-0.1172586009,
-0.0384615101,
0.0233699549,
-0.0077751107,
-0.0356254429,
-0.0370564424,
-0.0062845126,
-0.1309140176,
-0.0023886673,
-0.0199066866,
-0.0268770959,
-0.0102323908,
-0.0447753146,
-0.0333507545,
-0.0378340706,
0.0350061692,
-0.0358010121,
0.0097052362,
-0.000652134,
0.01378877,
-0.0868982002,
-0.0346989632,
0.037569236,
-0.0582486093,
0.0327521712,
0.0404867344,
0.025612589,
-0.019021472,
0.0084186709,
0.0310926549,
0.0008095642,
-0.0208965782,
-0.0256314427,
0.0371309519,
0.0099727064,
-0.0426940434,
-0.0314662978,
-0.0058916425,
-0.0346322805,
0.039131511,
0.0065371683,
0.0705653727,
0.0340691172,
0.031750042,
-0.0038598941,
-0.0215060655,
-0.00408726,
0.0506243743,
-0.0122130243,
-0.054310333,
-0.0228608195,
-0.0268340372,
-0.017492637,
-0.0668480694,
-0.0569859371,
0.0511892289,
-0.0441182442,
-0.0543830916,
-0.0574350953,
-0.0755548105,
0.0308351498,
0.0068258247,
0.0125254262,
0.0156549457,
0.012733872,
0.0005790342,
-0.0427619964,
0.0278042126,
-0.0009465779,
0.0433173366,
-0.0625807121,
-0.0242053792,
0.0056920554,
0.0325941704,
-0.0124284467,
0.0361794904,
-0.0515909642,
-0.0572562702,
-0.0060082283,
0.0113294274,
0.0208384562,
-0.0082993284,
-0.0056352136,
-0.050122913,
0.0056753908,
0.0220987853,
-0.0229031332,
0.0062129027,
0.0223530121,
-0.0276097748,
0.0065806275,
0.0398941301,
-0.0045906538,
-0.003005055,
-0.0172596723,
0.0491146706,
-0.0057427688,
-0.0098694423,
0.0063303723,
0.0261893813,
0.0412179492,
-0.0730755627,
-0.050460048,
-0.0475257821,
-0.0205472019,
0.0052682892,
-0.0267088618,
-0.0196900088,
-0.0184835512,
0.0291328896,
0.0334956311,
-0.0393084474,
0.0782914609,
-0.0172104333,
-0.0071383589,
-0.0546766967,
0.0505892076,
0.0196810719,
0.0232939888,
-0.0092198132,
0.0205336548,
0.0051079891,
0.0027800507,
-0.0012380667,
0.0537403636,
-0.0314649381,
0.0025355916,
0.0064185187,
0.015689265,
0.0315159485,
0.0215808451,
0.0050921883,
-0.034839727,
0.0164234433,
0.0257986002,
0.1133691818,
-0.0055081705,
0.082328856,
0.0203913413,
-0.0083420807,
-0.0172054265,
0.0001511616,
-0.0141620049,
-0.0388682075,
-0.0263565332,
-0.0156674087,
-0.0357042439,
0.0167563371,
0.0765202641,
-0.0001520036,
0.0145833045,
0.0309614837,
0.0103558656,
-0.0016785106,
-0.0284749456,
-0.0039385175,
-0.0066860504,
-0.0137852188,
0.0271925665,
-0.0761234313,
-0.0709914118,
-0.0169312004,
0.008726906,
0.0020720121,
0.0013235322,
0.019238919,
0.0259999782,
0.0175195299,
-0.0259008259,
-0.0694334283,
-0.0090711527,
-0.0253700316,
-0.0041165869,
0.0191506092,
-6.192243427e-33,
0.0097206095,
0.0102228243,
-0.0094482172,
0.0070734806,
-0.009214201,
0.0136451609,
0.0000863536,
0.0138554126,
-0.0570925474,
0.0328238904,
-0.0447756201,
0.0076878541,
0.0315548033,
0.022566935,
0.0448855422,
0.0085744588,
0.0040176651,
0.0335146375,
-0.0232284945,
-0.0056288312,
0.0562220924,
0.031273935,
0.1269995868,
-0.0390249826,
0.0604013167,
0.0277822912,
0.0032115837,
0.0370120518,
0.0473181009,
0.0331443436,
-0.030622514,
0.0902702659,
0.0366181172,
-0.0526810363,
-0.0137457279,
-0.0299888197,
-0.0859063715,
-0.0268559735,
0.0314716101,
0.0596497506,
-0.0225272421,
0.0218139105,
0.000233768,
0.0075083673,
-0.0668629035,
0.0250108782,
0.0160119776,
-0.0066781277,
0.0233740192,
0.0036807568,
-0.0424585044,
0.0476587899,
-0.012113872,
0.0392483138,
0.0039120512,
0.0423783325,
-0.0265574139,
-0.0057591777,
-0.0802473649,
0.0053052716,
-0.008863546,
0.0740981176,
0.0871309713,
-0.0294867903,
-0.0129053872,
0.0624523312,
0.0435165241,
-0.0375713482,
0.0480260067,
-0.0074015227,
0.0320619494,
-0.0196347926,
0.0447379425,
0.0709307343,
0.0628241077,
-0.0237219464,
-0.0592750013,
0.0152498996,
0.0541010723,
0.0289740916,
-0.025309857,
-0.0043623652,
-0.0558042414,
-0.0383114628,
-0.0278253444,
0.0110088093,
-0.0330218971,
0.0081879972,
0.0453148484,
-0.0115830144,
0.0094137536,
0.0244326051,
0.0129992757,
-0.0458001867,
-0.0325033069,
0.0087402742,
0.0414245501,
0.0035189586,
0.0148335341,
0.0430445038,
-0.0888895094,
-0.0218089018,
-0.0646327063,
0.0499823801,
0.0058488552,
-0.0332261771,
0.0230359323,
-0.0077204602,
-0.0677540004,
0.0176640674,
-0.0403924808,
0.0532271378,
-0.0288902093,
0.0473505333,
0.0208603907,
-0.017868882,
-0.0281398948,
0.0169969611,
0.0311713982,
0.003229615,
-0.0436381884,
-0.003886973,
0.0051596509,
0.0059605641,
-0.0089339325,
-0.0195613056,
-0.0646254495,
0.0132842725,
0.0170890763,
-0.0277584083,
-0.0090619475,
-0.0284747966,
2.594e-7,
0.0423298143,
0.0332811661,
0.0436192229,
0.0236042775,
-0.0146322921,
0.0184249543,
-0.032673277,
0.0350136869,
-0.0253672767,
0.0347791351,
-0.0642910004,
-0.0009472206,
0.0728952214,
0.0523275696,
-0.0947006345,
-0.0213392023,
-0.0629144311,
-0.0113079604,
-0.0404653959,
0.0009841758,
-0.0273441188,
0.0715405717,
0.0065493658,
-0.020912379,
-0.0252622273,
-0.0360071622,
0.0311496742,
-0.0254963208,
-0.0177154616,
-0.0051141256,
0.015946595,
0.036750555,
0.014450592,
0.001084106,
-0.050356511,
0.0315031298,
0.0020831963,
0.037092112,
-0.0204330608,
-0.0178484693,
-0.0016892201,
-0.0154670505,
-0.0476137884,
-0.0286025461,
0.0497887582,
0.0606535673,
-0.0283110738,
-0.0077656647,
0.0160375889,
0.0080594905,
0.0341209807,
-0.037419647,
-0.0381335728,
0.0165195633,
0.0519457683,
-0.0364459455,
-0.0525517315,
-0.0602502972,
-0.0386345871,
0.0047998615,
0.0123749431,
-0.0313444845,
0.0070047029,
0.0199893657,
0.0055013541,
-0.0339362323,
0.0105171343,
2.124203469e-34,
0.0297421869,
0.0268021673,
0.0528830104,
0.0139722098,
0.0317838937,
-0.0029268889,
-0.0165141914,
-0.021478476,
-0.0226996541,
0.0088213477,
-0.0074703232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14711v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14711v3 | Gender Biases in Automatic Evaluation Metrics for Image Captioning | 2023-05-24T04:27:40 | 2023-11-03T00:50:25 | Haoyi Qiu, Zi-Yi Dou, Tianlu Wang, Asli Celikyilmaz, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Model-based evaluation metrics (e.g., CLIPScore and GPTScore) have
demonstrated decent correlations with human judgments in various language
generation tasks. However, their impact on fairness remains largely unexplored.
It is widely recognized that pretrained models can inadvertently encode
societal biases, thus employing these models for evaluation purposes may
inadvertently perpetuate and amplify biases. For example, an evaluation metric
may favor the caption "a woman is calculating an account book" over "a man is
calculating an account book," even if the image only shows male accountants. In
this paper, we conduct a systematic study of gender biases in model-based
automatic evaluation metrics for image captioning tasks. We start by curating a
dataset comprising profession, activity, and object concepts associated with
stereotypical gender associations. Then, we demonstrate the negative
consequences of using these biased metrics, including the inability to
differentiate between biased and unbiased generations, as well as the
propagation of biases to generation models through reinforcement learning.
Finally, we present a simple and effective way to mitigate the metric bias
without hurting the correlations with human judgments. Our dataset and
framework lay the foundation for understanding the potential harm of
model-based evaluation metrics, and facilitate future works to develop more
inclusive evaluation metrics. | [
0.0136950193,
0.1094076708,
-0.0085992813,
0.0091906982,
0.02634928,
0.0260596517,
0.037899863,
-0.0132932896,
-0.0371691547,
-0.0558532774,
-0.0526534505,
-0.0257569253,
0.041803062,
0.034288656,
0.0108858692,
-0.0784099028,
0.0105241975,
0.0106220171,
0.0273697358,
-0.0169759355,
0.0134125892,
0.0207470357,
0.0092097213,
0.0747345388,
-0.0108227124,
-0.0093378192,
0.0740146041,
0.0072427173,
0.0154824741,
0.0046871752,
0.013359,
0.0708798245,
0.0107284794,
0.0113840802,
0.0000016592,
-0.0458110236,
0.0215260331,
0.0076426752,
0.0111809066,
-0.0019412907,
0.0557258464,
-0.0131362546,
-0.0208205022,
0.0011690516,
-0.02537282,
-0.0072356653,
0.0461784676,
0.019456869,
0.0612004623,
-0.0011118178,
-0.0017108036,
0.0034698555,
-0.0743841901,
-0.0517279804,
-0.0020373068,
-0.0119680027,
-0.0064821388,
0.0307822432,
-0.043712642,
-0.0208884105,
-0.0367119759,
0.0219208635,
0.0088712424,
-0.0091712903,
0.0266048964,
0.0584837683,
-0.0153391007,
-0.0607645102,
-0.0161055196,
0.0692041218,
0.0258794334,
0.0367444493,
-0.0126689384,
-0.0171557758,
0.0266359542,
-0.0008337042,
-0.0408319607,
0.0577623807,
0.0170489065,
-0.008949562,
-0.0503825769,
0.016257992,
0.0088171326,
0.0470346399,
0.0137890801,
0.0226548482,
0.0143054044,
-0.001890854,
0.00242154,
0.0392940342,
-0.0277994443,
-0.0601210333,
0.0222100038,
-0.0382779874,
0.0048745186,
-0.0105715469,
-0.039203696,
-0.0230130609,
0.0159087721,
-0.0320650861,
0.0007567854,
0.0216414277,
-0.0070207636,
0.015726313,
-0.015537479,
0.067456007,
0.0326283723,
0.0091358507,
-0.0392928086,
0.0266827233,
-0.0302324221,
-0.0221190471,
0.0034409373,
-0.0089394217,
-0.0276527666,
-0.0099813966,
-0.0712881014,
-0.0365123414,
-0.0757429898,
-0.0009488165,
0.0150073711,
0.0864412561,
-0.0430235825,
0.0311587024,
-0.044473093,
0.0157969575,
-0.0495730415,
0.0102975229,
-0.0024715627,
-0.0493139364,
-0.0058953762,
0.0072552548,
-0.0022526996,
-0.003643879,
0.0032333687,
0.0481492542,
-0.0358718596,
-0.024126742,
0.0084910635,
-0.0516671911,
-0.0448775999,
-0.0597474016,
-0.0085220607,
-0.0519191884,
0.0107534975,
0.0059302454,
0.0042385971,
-0.0332129225,
-0.0113110375,
0.0252843946,
-0.0072484221,
0.0707120597,
0.0660055205,
-0.0059004482,
0.0632283986,
0.0404114649,
-0.0487056188,
0.0947173685,
0.0646838099,
0.0217302851,
0.0299704392,
0.0182368383,
0.0058362302,
0.0434401818,
0.0250254516,
0.0106109967,
-0.0261217542,
0.0053835297,
-0.0283159371,
0.0553265549,
0.119513236,
0.0201213174,
-0.0227431525,
0.0181048196,
0.0709533542,
0.0573642366,
-0.0154216895,
0.0379163101,
0.0680321679,
-0.0141200423,
-0.0223228913,
0.0383177958,
-0.0517399646,
0.0303044692,
0.0400991105,
-0.0179217625,
-0.0120952763,
0.038350191,
-0.021551311,
-0.0560679846,
0.0207721014,
0.0057982043,
0.0073742396,
-0.0142035913,
0.0011347543,
0.0578291006,
-0.0249781217,
0.0556043535,
-0.021922512,
-0.0708725527,
0.0284159184,
-0.0550829209,
0.0054281061,
0.0632352382,
0.0352503583,
0.0276558902,
-0.0116162887,
-0.0186651889,
-0.0389832407,
0.0424457155,
0.0355803184,
-0.0007189067,
-0.0089603197,
-0.0529843271,
-0.032700032,
0.0191247873,
0.03716176,
0.0410552025,
0.0347624831,
0.0490061678,
0.0568644926,
-0.0324627012,
-0.0840873793,
0.0322268121,
0.0392794274,
-0.0429552458,
0.0163268056,
0.014107055,
0.0057232887,
0.0304647982,
-0.050186839,
0.0157752484,
-0.029162202,
0.0112224203,
-0.0189294219,
0.0628869906,
-0.0811913908,
-0.0053990986,
-0.012456635,
-0.1020482406,
-0.0643416718,
0.0184569489,
-0.0154866325,
-0.0161893684,
0.0480759069,
-0.0197528265,
-0.0256305374,
-0.0674425662,
-0.0068558366,
0.0153613957,
0.0141811017,
-0.0064293407,
0.0306751262,
-0.0131030641,
-0.0237407051,
0.0479190052,
-0.0228224043,
-0.015403674,
-0.0749141425,
-0.042988386,
-0.0051359264,
0.0031091494,
0.0358945355,
0.0530205145,
0.0330348685,
-0.0509494245,
-0.0056743259,
-0.0686183646,
-0.0143373674,
-0.0105907675,
-0.0072716218,
-0.0032848925,
-0.0071791336,
-0.0222949889,
-0.0349364839,
-0.0136488918,
-0.0360976271,
0.0265664309,
0.0267028604,
0.0429396778,
-0.0007863561,
0.0193337295,
-0.038417425,
-0.0160965677,
-0.0085578933,
0.0667585358,
0.0613556169,
0.0408097729,
-0.03254335,
-0.0031176079,
-0.0386982448,
-0.0101711312,
0.0095532378,
-0.0272128917,
0.0390092246,
0.0526530705,
0.0287110303,
0.0831132606,
0.0230511185,
0.0505810082,
0.042406477,
-0.0097613744,
-0.039694149,
-0.0161180198,
0.0151784085,
-0.0417243466,
0.0583944023,
-0.0813137218,
-0.0154824043,
0.0142459041,
-0.0076238816,
0.0102423336,
-0.077560477,
0.0651194453,
-0.062696591,
-0.0863445699,
-0.0466731414,
-0.0096078776,
0.0037765347,
0.0324976034,
-0.0367140248,
-0.0668841824,
0.0274328198,
-0.0131331459,
-0.0218668915,
-0.0021467844,
0.026361404,
-0.0243961066,
0.0676431954,
-0.008339975,
0.044402834,
0.0130679412,
-0.0013446719,
-0.06432008,
-0.0365360528,
0.0402937979,
-0.0399240255,
0.0265201814,
-0.0565423705,
-0.0086877393,
-0.0041574542,
-0.0370671153,
-0.0335143432,
0.0005832996,
-0.0070596347,
-0.0086704465,
-0.0087337755,
-0.019340558,
-0.0048724487,
0.0381153971,
-0.0003389733,
0.0103768213,
-0.0333616138,
-0.0014821707,
0.0073204124,
0.0106964996,
0.0534262769,
0.0204827264,
-0.0133744162,
-0.0337207802,
-0.0155203771,
0.0084911129,
-0.0015245023,
0.0229930915,
-0.0214051213,
0.0417184532,
0.0246893652,
-0.0157771949,
0.0118343867,
0.01534242,
0.0375949703,
-0.0432065986,
0.0085911136,
0.0934722796,
0.0121585662,
-0.0549908802,
-0.0218568034,
0.0244557261,
0.0372916646,
0.0110046379,
-0.0108455289,
-0.0592623241,
-0.0137811415,
0.009298997,
0.0288950223,
-0.0206328332,
-0.0164282396,
-0.0337219089,
-0.1146362647,
0.0468935035,
0.0270549469,
-0.0560270101,
-0.0411347412,
0.0167595837,
-0.0270226933,
-0.0361650139,
0.0149643011,
-0.0115885511,
-0.0047908062,
0.0507296845,
0.0084002623,
-0.0219026413,
-0.0455769971,
0.0342604704,
-0.0642561242,
0.0354848132,
0.0725575164,
0.0331645384,
-0.0055936738,
-0.0375748463,
-0.0367492102,
0.004170333,
0.0112203062,
-0.0126132555,
0.0346534178,
-0.0634972453,
-0.0261246823,
-0.0342550017,
0.0322714597,
0.0400194749,
0.0194235239,
-0.0158304181,
-0.0060262545,
0.0154129202,
-0.0090755867,
-0.0638495982,
0.0269462373,
0.0115052052,
0.0847410113,
0.0362679325,
-0.0264664721,
-0.0227016062,
-0.0223193187,
0.0137448348,
-0.0574827306,
-0.0242222119,
0.0035805888,
0.0063468302,
-0.0396165922,
-0.0661193579,
-0.0562947765,
0.0193580333,
0.0034696879,
0.0059493701,
-0.0747710913,
-0.0098283067,
0.0380761921,
-0.0666110069,
0.0457645319,
-0.0362563878,
0.013717439,
0.0009585128,
-0.0170234386,
0.0101241851,
-0.018660672,
-0.050664328,
0.0714229047,
-0.0369295813,
-0.0152162509,
0.0023705428,
0.0746032223,
0.0218534991,
0.0581303798,
0.0234727934,
-0.0142014399,
0.0354673453,
0.0424295887,
0.001580982,
0.0349022299,
0.036887642,
-0.0028044693,
-0.0192320738,
0.0249784682,
-0.0376157016,
0.015078363,
-0.0229122639,
0.0125814499,
-0.0008974854,
-0.0346085578,
0.0002669755,
-0.0002716033,
-0.0096271597,
-0.099717997,
0.023860069,
-0.0372347422,
-0.0380587503,
-0.0150484527,
-0.0273473039,
-0.0439840779,
-0.0219647158,
0.0368480943,
0.0551632531,
-0.022412166,
-0.0226718839,
-0.0373275392,
0.0297793411,
-0.0047283433,
-0.0017480346,
0.0239696316,
0.0090380674,
-0.0278747939,
0.0017050046,
0.0038885549,
-0.0433940962,
-0.0424339361,
0.0235898327,
0.016421413,
0.0423775315,
0.0213833209,
0.0351719931,
-0.0036650463,
0.0412691608,
-0.0221916791,
0.0177490748,
-0.040847268,
0.0371357724,
0.0437297374,
-0.0332918391,
0.0563704893,
-0.0175264589,
0.00470924,
0.0314148962,
-0.0148632238,
-0.0051197135,
-0.0142635098,
0.0216914564,
-0.0052193291,
0.0284343734,
-0.0283642616,
0.0577352978,
0.0080391057,
0.0551860034,
-0.0484541506,
-0.0636386201,
-0.0213401411,
-0.0306772646,
0.0049897898,
-0.0415354371,
0.0063484791,
-0.0015764692,
-0.0704609081,
-0.0601322725,
-0.0174423195,
0.0312179774,
0.0286565684,
0.0208699405,
0.0575328022,
0.0434207954,
-0.0500897393,
-0.0177924428,
-0.0209292397,
-0.0394980721,
-0.0308670308,
0.0336646587,
-0.0288654454,
-5.382650713e-33,
-0.0666637346,
-0.0473632962,
0.0112614473,
-0.0294000003,
-0.0389687419,
0.0127551081,
-0.0164376218,
-0.0095545743,
0.0525278933,
0.0175013412,
0.0049217213,
-0.0146305161,
0.0263659731,
0.0017994947,
0.0371446609,
0.006964881,
0.0790231004,
-0.0067503816,
-0.05415757,
-0.0221257117,
-0.0221599117,
-0.0031981228,
0.0353177115,
-0.035223525,
0.0838164613,
0.0076909838,
-0.0445268601,
-0.0148026673,
0.0317045189,
0.0318402462,
-0.0093739545,
0.0398874208,
0.0068462309,
-0.05392652,
-0.0075591239,
0.0481903814,
-0.0597392321,
-0.0314111039,
0.036355678,
0.0483520143,
0.0051526069,
-0.002693553,
0.0248235017,
0.0084859468,
-0.0745641962,
-0.0241678059,
0.0629006028,
-0.0019728346,
0.0841043368,
0.0351764262,
-0.0248128995,
0.0040844441,
-0.0442099832,
-0.0257559419,
0.0292312521,
0.0061193048,
-0.0176654775,
-0.0228453949,
-0.0297047328,
0.0405659638,
0.0264256783,
0.0166580714,
0.0895832777,
0.0490095876,
0.0126658622,
0.0243341774,
0.0407388099,
0.0037336214,
-0.0347327031,
-0.0721595511,
0.0278997961,
-0.0101092895,
0.0480345041,
0.0510376245,
0.0553683229,
0.0150505817,
-0.015522168,
0.0288211256,
-0.0270812567,
0.0325383395,
0.0054271459,
-0.0058134878,
-0.0404359363,
-0.0099753533,
-0.0454675779,
-0.0744382441,
-0.0291785691,
-0.0342944451,
0.0300823413,
0.0173008684,
-0.0385168791,
0.0262048673,
0.0132590644,
-0.0341034085,
0.0040166676,
-0.0223120563,
-0.0218368582,
-0.0210179798,
0.0099724913,
-0.0213216394,
-0.022977626,
0.0105281267,
0.0479759052,
0.0684148148,
0.0296537634,
0.0061398428,
0.0063171973,
0.0295172613,
-0.0326567926,
0.0076162941,
-0.0303773377,
0.0095963776,
-0.0278247111,
-0.0059824348,
0.0201556254,
0.0296302829,
-0.0617848076,
-0.0238704048,
0.0045160707,
0.0307103842,
-0.0328939036,
-0.0056787366,
0.0056727501,
0.0389652401,
-0.0403714515,
0.0118789747,
0.0096598901,
-0.0158525072,
0.0283112917,
-0.0442084894,
-0.0367453843,
-0.0167514663,
2.285e-7,
-0.0059626368,
0.0395003408,
0.0366613194,
0.03726504,
0.0097889267,
0.0455735326,
0.0169876311,
0.0308347512,
0.0424351841,
0.0172936935,
0.0413740091,
0.0271707792,
0.0013936604,
0.003183678,
-0.0266669616,
0.0038047347,
-0.0904242173,
0.0391721763,
0.01383432,
-0.0273152385,
0.0196669381,
0.0105319908,
-0.0007324801,
-0.0177367069,
0.0045832046,
-0.0641578957,
0.0645450875,
-0.0124339033,
0.0268018916,
-0.0198056214,
0.0216043312,
0.0318420939,
-0.0067289346,
0.0414898321,
0.0044878898,
-0.0159619078,
0.0802240968,
0.0205118936,
-0.0139781097,
0.0093892608,
-0.0371314436,
0.0468280017,
-0.0124354735,
-0.0471245386,
0.0494959764,
-0.0295669585,
-0.0227745324,
-0.0563872345,
-0.0345898867,
0.0137453554,
0.0743213668,
-0.0500676408,
-0.0595345497,
0.0164915975,
0.0413184725,
0.0388192683,
-0.025976995,
-0.0648388043,
-0.0271178652,
-0.0116741266,
-0.0137825049,
-0.0493676774,
-0.0570805818,
0.0184037704,
-0.0021478354,
-0.056200128,
-0.0100542717,
1.634266493e-34,
0.018806329,
0.0164014399,
0.0268333331,
-0.0323794335,
0.0022090634,
0.0242309608,
-0.0139475195,
-0.033453051,
0.0417423658,
0.0028914302,
-0.0239425767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14710v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14710v2 | Instructions as Backdoors: Backdoor Vulnerabilities of Instruction Tuning for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T04:27:21 | 2024-04-03T09:15:15 | Jiashu Xu, Mingyu Derek Ma, Fei Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | We investigate security concerns of the emergent instruction tuning paradigm,
that models are trained on crowdsourced datasets with task instructions to
achieve superior performance. Our studies demonstrate that an attacker can
inject backdoors by issuing very few malicious instructions (~1000 tokens) and
control model behavior through data poisoning, without even the need to modify
data instances or labels themselves. Through such instruction attacks, the
attacker can achieve over 90% attack success rate across four commonly used NLP
datasets. As an empirical study on instruction attacks, we systematically
evaluated unique perspectives of instruction attacks, such as poison transfer
where poisoned models can transfer to 15 diverse generative datasets in a
zero-shot manner; instruction transfer where attackers can directly apply
poisoned instruction on many other datasets; and poison resistance to continual
finetuning. Lastly, we show that RLHF and clean demonstrations might mitigate
such backdoors to some degree. These findings highlight the need for more
robust defenses against poisoning attacks in instruction-tuning models and
underscore the importance of ensuring data quality in instruction
crowdsourcing. | [
0.0522450991,
0.0874523073,
-0.0151651185,
0.0488566272,
-0.0349357799,
-0.006118102,
0.0164184216,
-0.0188245904,
-0.0202785116,
-0.0532851554,
-0.0213350542,
0.016498344,
0.0140930116,
-0.0032798322,
0.0726684928,
-0.0133608002,
0.0739917234,
-0.0377290882,
-0.037490312,
-0.0057673403,
-0.0004890732,
-0.0081374133,
0.0010216861,
0.0415846445,
0.0055434569,
-0.0156170139,
-0.0322319753,
0.0403397046,
0.033467412,
-0.0245429855,
0.0098164361,
0.0538314767,
-0.0069440892,
0.0382362045,
0.0000019212,
-0.0254425369,
-0.0246358719,
0.0380193032,
-0.0652117208,
0.0334487855,
-0.0001378273,
-0.0108089149,
-0.0319977477,
0.0162480287,
-0.020212248,
0.0075526247,
0.0321677029,
0.0499527045,
0.0792093799,
0.1063566506,
0.0118240053,
-0.0098692672,
0.0323921517,
-0.0204896592,
0.027317645,
-0.0329107493,
0.0295960829,
-0.0524062403,
-0.0084475065,
0.0574462935,
-0.0193903707,
-0.0101740481,
0.016918743,
-0.0005458376,
-0.0146488966,
0.0106079653,
-0.0377226844,
-0.021292638,
-0.0382186137,
0.0723401755,
-0.0248379782,
0.0051768073,
-0.0072834608,
0.0048930352,
0.0191315226,
0.0158338845,
0.0128131388,
0.048676502,
0.0163779259,
0.0054946076,
0.0204607695,
-0.0433156714,
0.0424439721,
-0.0057264594,
0.0563877113,
0.0577523336,
0.0090552242,
-0.0357775986,
-0.0039493507,
-0.0199963916,
-0.0315111019,
-0.0651871413,
-0.0240716357,
-0.0013306653,
-0.0141832177,
0.031499844,
-0.0898297727,
-0.0291360896,
0.0239219107,
-0.0252466425,
0.0863146931,
0.0245346762,
-0.0091287987,
0.0129271662,
0.0008849503,
0.0122100087,
-0.0077381833,
0.0740779564,
0.0107677029,
0.0387036167,
-0.0515258946,
0.0083587803,
-0.0234999433,
0.0157271475,
-0.0316952243,
0.0124463299,
-0.018749604,
0.0034309309,
-0.0531962551,
0.0080627101,
-0.0034099601,
0.0172213763,
-0.0335232429,
0.0378854349,
-0.0131767699,
-0.0189450495,
-0.0288921688,
-0.0080256267,
-0.0041745938,
-0.0903884843,
-0.0364423729,
-0.0085587157,
-0.0441925712,
-0.0176959392,
-0.0010633999,
0.0859853774,
0.0266693737,
-0.0045877835,
-0.0621082969,
-0.092131868,
-0.0109805968,
-0.025045095,
0.0173797999,
-0.0612730421,
-0.0054931575,
-0.023157578,
-0.0032029706,
-0.0561826378,
0.0158356931,
0.0284837671,
-0.06453944,
0.0633310601,
-0.0134326657,
-0.011291299,
-0.0004417469,
0.0257690046,
-0.0058909589,
0.0558416806,
0.0147433607,
0.0216771848,
0.0488940142,
-0.0255631953,
0.0373792164,
0.0161265377,
0.0408218987,
0.0377435349,
0.0068148328,
0.0161736812,
0.0279200077,
-0.0185228027,
-0.006618219,
0.0495979674,
-0.0202893857,
-0.0405118242,
0.0915554911,
0.0101885768,
-0.0429756232,
-0.0030076548,
0.0221860558,
0.014634775,
-0.0020208005,
0.0016255673,
-0.0838560611,
-0.0077560446,
-0.0615373179,
-0.0353499167,
0.0099577624,
0.0125990119,
-0.0037890214,
-0.0178151447,
-0.0058963853,
0.0111356806,
0.0034082646,
-0.0083936406,
-0.0058701332,
0.0660298914,
-0.013272075,
0.0023956033,
0.0389331505,
-0.0225749128,
-0.0253954958,
-0.058268711,
-0.0452961363,
0.0533416383,
0.0586425997,
0.0089502968,
-0.006997711,
-0.039253246,
0.0150434766,
0.0093762362,
0.0243497677,
-0.0181030836,
0.0027764989,
-0.0032166054,
-0.0318752378,
-0.0216928776,
0.0171115976,
0.0083937366,
0.042536892,
-0.01278394,
-0.0119622247,
0.0204126481,
-0.0725051016,
0.0412849709,
-0.0149257593,
-0.0585249886,
0.0044393288,
0.0317046382,
0.018867664,
0.001971775,
-0.0167840421,
0.0173739046,
0.0310248621,
0.0415513851,
0.017652832,
-0.0342686847,
-0.0080396747,
-0.0088485749,
0.0210439283,
-0.0378671549,
-0.0166295543,
0.0443457738,
-0.0451834351,
-0.0060427114,
0.0400280245,
-0.0470445789,
-0.001809087,
0.0203818716,
0.0007946372,
-0.0026384376,
0.0305177346,
-0.0022718443,
0.0192887355,
-0.0053539625,
-0.000468597,
-0.0000319003,
0.0292378552,
-0.0004447209,
-0.0324441046,
-0.0252779815,
-0.0207885634,
-0.0280482192,
0.028611308,
0.0039018798,
0.0103514837,
-0.0624371171,
0.0102628721,
-0.0255429931,
0.0010835611,
-0.013609211,
0.0314360298,
0.0402384028,
-0.0189544521,
-0.0130765308,
-0.0153407743,
-0.0051842029,
-0.0388346612,
-0.0389305949,
0.0373733602,
0.023293687,
0.0021599603,
-0.014314591,
-0.0082193287,
-0.0085723214,
-0.0156385992,
0.0460073762,
0.0042325826,
0.0397762768,
-0.0503345393,
0.0132683907,
0.0102071092,
0.0382522717,
0.0057003968,
-0.0710251555,
0.0376613699,
0.0398235843,
0.0039785705,
0.1032504216,
-0.0158644393,
0.0638923422,
0.0559182353,
0.0052798563,
-0.0326186158,
-0.0020540359,
-0.0040956526,
-0.0338611342,
-0.0492727011,
-0.0225911289,
-0.0045612636,
0.0749069229,
0.0240927264,
-0.0415574908,
-0.037469551,
0.0427842326,
-0.0314671881,
-0.0466871485,
-0.0163334776,
-0.0173942242,
-0.0283379648,
-0.0144110806,
-0.0302950889,
-0.0824099407,
0.0826051235,
-0.0237154197,
0.0288761333,
-0.0399230048,
-0.0098052165,
0.0146258222,
0.0193686187,
0.0027044758,
0.0076431422,
0.0492090657,
0.0011310461,
-0.0429059044,
0.0203123596,
0.049190525,
-0.0144811189,
-0.0151272938,
-0.0271023344,
-0.0302093644,
-0.0152518256,
-0.0428343378,
-0.0585299395,
-0.0621937774,
0.0168334618,
0.0052805776,
0.0762932152,
-0.045036044,
-0.0203050133,
-0.0640582517,
0.0323565006,
-0.0140384929,
-0.0267934967,
-0.024275668,
-0.0387893729,
-0.0149036637,
0.0636007488,
-0.0713133886,
-0.0059636808,
-0.0345367715,
0.0119076623,
0.085213922,
0.0586532876,
0.0092634428,
-0.0273525845,
0.0251656584,
0.0137919569,
-0.0009197751,
0.0016556542,
0.0341500267,
0.0815632939,
-0.0425022654,
-0.0305942446,
0.0496632755,
0.0146517055,
-0.0114512658,
0.0207861811,
0.0424359217,
0.0272666048,
0.0262430087,
0.0229459479,
-0.0937321782,
-0.0224497244,
0.0295662843,
0.0829066783,
-0.0372650325,
-0.0329232849,
-0.0154457586,
-0.1483214945,
0.0324539319,
-0.0026041719,
-0.0452244766,
-0.0143127628,
-0.0683691055,
-0.0014431347,
-0.0038844978,
0.036946293,
-0.0340171754,
-0.0077866237,
0.0179590248,
0.0330216922,
0.0142598245,
-0.0644138232,
0.0451063849,
-0.0278438143,
0.0897130519,
0.0750391409,
-0.0101444973,
-0.0110923415,
-0.0189937819,
0.0243737902,
0.004575029,
-0.0096007548,
0.0103369784,
0.0977136791,
-0.022900261,
-0.0232894905,
0.0141147375,
0.0597100779,
-0.0398854166,
-0.0068722675,
0.0010576191,
0.0521401837,
0.0169414245,
-0.0208785441,
-0.0362570211,
-0.0283048451,
0.048349347,
0.0590348318,
0.0278875194,
-0.0622451231,
-0.012818859,
-0.0862477198,
-0.0127872881,
-0.0684501901,
-0.0702123418,
0.0500105359,
-0.0291899722,
-0.0700424761,
-0.0659481511,
-0.0396596529,
0.0313539989,
0.0204014108,
0.0481019132,
-0.0389488749,
0.005691926,
0.0068196175,
-0.0274558421,
0.0390821099,
-0.0334728584,
0.0342313871,
-0.0988535434,
-0.06740807,
-0.0046225088,
0.0134118646,
-0.0169125218,
0.0259111375,
-0.0986574143,
-0.0844890326,
0.0332522206,
0.0768566281,
0.0162243862,
0.0431334227,
-0.0274320245,
-0.0398305617,
0.0492797755,
0.0532609895,
-0.017464092,
0.0052106893,
0.0657964349,
-0.034109626,
0.0195293091,
0.020645231,
-0.0266249292,
0.0167850871,
0.1067282483,
0.0038167133,
-0.0151065709,
0.0215922259,
0.0265445765,
0.0543754101,
0.0663162768,
-0.0133299911,
0.0060348418,
-0.0002309798,
0.0047904006,
-0.0090472642,
-0.0242528785,
-0.0223301463,
0.0126218935,
0.0111486968,
-0.0143931229,
0.0225750972,
0.0089971321,
0.0249528177,
0.0160477664,
-0.0558263436,
0.0343708284,
0.0639306679,
0.040097557,
0.0612741522,
0.0455200411,
0.0041856966,
0.0223474111,
0.0093401084,
0.033505965,
0.0157872904,
0.01653485,
0.0222508237,
0.0206305217,
0.0119635481,
0.0282621291,
-0.0688778684,
-0.0313704014,
-0.0074277278,
0.0112373438,
0.0023338471,
-0.0064147869,
0.0053619496,
-0.0099435989,
-0.0031675419,
-0.0274506882,
-0.0112758093,
-0.0248710215,
-0.0393239893,
0.0002068013,
0.0059047905,
-0.0112505965,
0.0318842307,
0.0819498897,
0.012268221,
0.1023388654,
-0.0109223034,
-0.0029126143,
-0.0184828378,
0.0023305584,
0.0114509463,
-0.0105959941,
-0.013535426,
0.0073407753,
-0.0173237137,
-0.095407322,
-0.0551669188,
0.0121270148,
0.0432898588,
0.0295209158,
0.0188287497,
0.0120560341,
-0.014373742,
-0.0127655789,
-0.072578378,
0.0251417607,
0.01510181,
-0.0528413095,
0.0110516008,
-6.154694832e-33,
0.0161241237,
-0.0336357653,
-0.0199161861,
-0.0054015112,
0.0375056937,
-0.0078289993,
-0.0258082058,
0.0055119083,
-0.0267143585,
0.0137097724,
-0.0121460911,
0.0150747672,
0.0009804693,
0.0401237644,
0.0091694649,
-0.0340828672,
0.0147286784,
-0.0405929573,
-0.0333068371,
0.0412697196,
0.0593140312,
-0.0062048333,
0.0413916595,
-0.0572096854,
0.0511943884,
-0.0063113957,
-0.018526854,
0.0055238404,
-0.0672612041,
0.0587716661,
0.0112565812,
0.027429821,
-0.0063103242,
-0.0499368757,
-0.0222276486,
0.0142609403,
-0.0170767568,
-0.0274259225,
-0.033012379,
-0.0014152859,
-0.0567933954,
-0.0518635549,
0.0453905314,
0.0018591698,
-0.0169682242,
-0.0037676021,
0.0104518654,
-0.0066620577,
0.0035415015,
0.015244293,
-0.0446426682,
0.0013989479,
-0.0314880051,
-0.0342420489,
0.0074882163,
-0.0151647301,
0.0271206275,
-0.0300495513,
-0.0557905734,
0.0363728888,
0.0523732342,
0.0297389105,
0.0383988321,
0.0065006083,
0.0183357559,
0.0408468433,
0.0275486074,
0.0331438109,
0.0125370063,
0.0325705186,
0.0080560325,
0.065366134,
0.0270754937,
0.0134934904,
0.0583083481,
-0.0309731755,
-0.0311612729,
0.00045578,
-0.0090213427,
0.0039143385,
0.0074375928,
-0.0047477745,
-0.0700498894,
-0.0049789213,
-0.024660062,
-0.0476164222,
-0.023522893,
-0.0087409467,
0.0280309785,
0.0130373174,
-0.0431534834,
-0.0005359142,
-0.0083287284,
-0.0587991402,
-0.0157736689,
-0.0074562044,
-0.0071536093,
-0.0098330639,
-0.0074022473,
-0.0115754465,
-0.041783113,
-0.0029385572,
0.0087028984,
-0.0425917543,
0.0664943904,
0.0168079194,
0.0561391637,
0.038156677,
-0.067386508,
-0.0047681159,
-0.0428776816,
0.0637322813,
0.0372046009,
0.0106897252,
0.0234894883,
-0.0048349933,
-0.001577577,
0.0225890465,
0.0349632166,
0.0185878985,
-0.0442746058,
0.0461284481,
-0.0276231822,
-0.0099277496,
0.0033589147,
-0.0011734387,
-0.0222086385,
0.0409573019,
0.0259146169,
-0.0580620356,
-0.0159048978,
-0.0219457932,
2.753e-7,
-0.0002286763,
0.0420457982,
0.0296776518,
0.0336427242,
0.0226990618,
0.0607942194,
-0.0255987961,
0.070558466,
-0.0071219192,
-0.0502916947,
-0.0480787642,
0.0026684641,
0.0494367704,
0.0303681716,
-0.057994511,
0.0033039136,
-0.0692093,
0.0472524911,
-0.0519286394,
-0.0039851535,
0.008753852,
0.0781304017,
0.0370040052,
-0.012346467,
-0.0058555529,
-0.0069254939,
0.003607447,
0.0024515486,
0.00820971,
0.0146761052,
0.0196344871,
0.0474130921,
0.0063362848,
0.0265704263,
-0.0664466098,
-0.0245384742,
-0.0570058934,
0.0272803586,
-0.012138553,
-0.0414997004,
-0.0425805487,
-0.0610358603,
0.0000622803,
-0.0041313893,
0.0710743517,
-0.0090451865,
-0.0167011246,
-0.012285688,
-0.0033048026,
-0.0153390681,
0.0285353195,
-0.026051579,
-0.0000074425,
0.0007030711,
0.0121319927,
0.0035548476,
-0.0012023619,
-0.0655357465,
0.0027276794,
-0.025500508,
-0.0081110736,
-0.0674640238,
0.0049113487,
0.0154546956,
-0.0075057317,
-0.0132002272,
-0.029506065,
2.579858141e-34,
0.0006000365,
-0.0376093537,
0.0408445485,
-0.0112733636,
0.0450325757,
-0.0041553089,
-0.0154662197,
-0.0078681782,
0.0077634258,
-0.0282107964,
-0.0521602668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14707v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14707v2 | SciFix: Outperforming GPT3 on Scientific Factual Error Correction | 2023-05-24T04:24:16 | 2023-10-12T21:13:09 | Dhananjay Ashok, Atharva Kulkarni, Hai Pham, Barnabás Póczos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Due to the prohibitively high cost of creating error correction datasets,
most Factual Claim Correction methods rely on a powerful verification model to
guide the correction process. This leads to a significant drop in performance
in domains like scientific claims, where good verification models do not always
exist. In this work, we introduce SciFix, a scientific claim correction system
that does not require a verifier but can outperform existing methods by a
considerable margin -- achieving correction accuracy of 84% on the SciFact
dataset, 77% on SciFact-Open and 72% on the CovidFact dataset, compared to next
best accuracies of 7%, 5%, and 15% on the same datasets respectively. Our
method leverages the power of prompting with LLMs during training to create a
richly annotated dataset that can be used for fully supervised training and
regularization. We additionally use a claim-aware decoding procedure to improve
the quality of corrected claims. Our method outperforms the very LLM that was
used to generate the annotated dataset -- with Few-Shot Prompting on GPT3.5
achieving 58%, 61%, and 64% on the respective datasets, a consistently lower
correction accuracy, despite using nearly 800 times as many parameters as our
model. | [
0.0331742279,
0.054477822,
0.0307454746,
0.0220545102,
-0.0169099532,
0.0037594484,
-0.0110570397,
0.0129848495,
0.009143685,
-0.0278314408,
-0.0014988966,
0.0103213694,
0.0439428948,
0.0128123006,
0.0295237079,
-0.0138660548,
0.0615022257,
0.0198158808,
0.0945957005,
-0.0161391944,
-0.0378256738,
0.0043872814,
-0.0507420525,
0.0070877899,
-0.0325994305,
-0.0348152593,
0.044085972,
-0.004454317,
0.0642009974,
-0.0585023351,
0.0531943589,
0.0538514368,
0.0048607895,
0.0950274318,
0.0000018439,
-0.0589438938,
-0.0003433945,
0.0690739602,
-0.0539412014,
0.067900084,
-0.0059294729,
0.0041142404,
-0.0064364183,
0.0147439959,
0.0037125719,
-0.0196333788,
0.072193265,
0.0362510942,
0.0376830325,
0.0741865039,
0.0007520764,
-0.0141371321,
0.047709275,
0.0012149697,
0.0083780754,
-0.0168859642,
0.044138208,
0.0256026145,
-0.0179130994,
0.0051887594,
0.0073169791,
0.0432825685,
-0.0033609392,
-0.0047475873,
-0.0124505609,
0.0447184294,
-0.0369824767,
-0.0161526129,
-0.021522712,
0.0281917322,
0.0364435241,
-0.0352418311,
-0.0297803059,
-0.000664287,
-0.0101595102,
-0.0034870233,
-0.0228116289,
0.0446372814,
-0.0141747138,
0.0059526488,
0.026477024,
-0.025010312,
0.01503966,
0.0100548984,
0.005074902,
0.0530561991,
0.0145657379,
-0.0680457652,
-0.0014897315,
0.0296137799,
0.0590719432,
-0.0615383685,
0.0341986977,
-0.0241621006,
-0.0006955212,
-0.0038377044,
-0.0303846132,
-0.0060433256,
0.0828257725,
-0.0275983866,
0.0222093686,
0.0078745978,
-0.0693737641,
0.0392837785,
-0.0313034542,
0.0223302487,
0.0116490871,
0.0443463661,
0.0564207733,
0.0004940963,
-0.0252548307,
-0.0191992503,
0.0234127678,
-0.0008053357,
-0.0173910428,
0.0536852106,
-0.0757913217,
-0.0610945821,
-0.0028595256,
0.0455494486,
0.0050492091,
0.015411404,
-0.0381206647,
-0.0207565427,
-0.0471867658,
0.0520788617,
0.0247316975,
0.0331145227,
0.0047851503,
-0.0722784176,
-0.0335442312,
0.0220347457,
0.0022329947,
-0.0062701614,
0.0094051128,
-0.0136495773,
0.01942637,
-0.0350939035,
-0.0205725413,
-0.0207596701,
-0.0104216374,
-0.0675848871,
-0.0142799439,
-0.0319234803,
0.009015548,
-0.0230573695,
0.0121654952,
-0.0241312142,
0.0021848206,
-0.012448377,
-0.0346819274,
0.04476263,
-0.0823799074,
-0.0182111952,
0.0386147723,
-0.0160994455,
0.0167265218,
-0.0081783542,
0.0244912468,
-0.021489406,
0.0269637108,
0.0006267891,
0.018606469,
-0.0343803354,
0.0251071751,
-0.0156833269,
0.0662514716,
-0.0013269578,
-0.0131632192,
0.0422419161,
0.0248402264,
0.032397639,
-0.0330238342,
-0.0302023366,
0.0485965945,
0.0164300669,
-0.0166887548,
-0.0275219511,
0.0079464698,
-0.036945764,
0.0461641587,
-0.0009345743,
-0.0727962554,
0.0221750028,
-0.0488052927,
-0.0167798214,
0.0381373465,
0.0168061983,
0.0126827266,
-0.0523662046,
-0.0169045944,
0.0115008168,
-0.0472883098,
-0.0167494435,
0.0234609917,
0.0092503512,
0.0046367832,
0.0098888399,
0.0336851403,
-0.0461860187,
-0.0296832193,
-0.0427167453,
0.0451298095,
0.0129840039,
0.0299831126,
-0.0173064917,
-0.0268020071,
-0.0273755882,
-0.0099374196,
0.0520745367,
0.0743192956,
0.000758927,
0.0072065764,
-0.02380744,
-0.0171973668,
-0.0351473019,
0.0563031957,
0.0024662577,
0.06609644,
0.0016349196,
0.010028189,
-0.0212054644,
-0.0358636752,
0.0233132225,
-0.0245827604,
-0.0311217923,
0.0025782518,
-0.030115094,
0.0554621704,
0.0155907944,
-0.030996887,
0.0069536236,
0.0109495325,
0.0174761023,
-0.0432886668,
0.0146821169,
0.0588697866,
-0.0308454577,
0.044010397,
-0.065347895,
-0.0444689356,
0.0164504405,
-0.0498197302,
0.0007425155,
-0.0489518493,
-0.0302020237,
-0.0165765639,
-0.0534010679,
-0.0104762921,
-0.0074509829,
0.0001409039,
0.0001867721,
0.0273293648,
0.0157277714,
0.0115347672,
-0.0212381631,
-0.0211720169,
0.017911993,
-0.047828909,
-0.0006943802,
-0.0141672501,
-0.0004051926,
-0.0186646543,
0.0162967518,
-0.0405077301,
-0.0264300238,
0.037573792,
-0.0400856547,
0.0136726676,
0.0073505817,
0.0233028792,
-0.0114700356,
-0.0464278646,
-0.0106548509,
-0.0053828605,
-0.000516041,
-0.0255943425,
0.0269274879,
0.000546077,
0.0458551012,
-0.0235015936,
0.0039407653,
-0.059751831,
0.0179830007,
-0.0419628657,
0.0085299984,
0.0569565706,
-0.0679939836,
-0.0856495947,
0.0100715347,
-0.0394215807,
-0.0007798097,
0.0049997503,
0.0079152482,
0.0292289089,
0.0133074289,
-0.0602442063,
-0.0058946791,
0.0081312899,
-0.0231738985,
0.0243240185,
0.0374689139,
-0.0396408439,
0.0039375476,
-0.0116075687,
-0.0255079661,
0.0116585586,
-0.0205390062,
0.0271158125,
0.0282182936,
0.0042599123,
-0.0066946866,
-0.0186043382,
0.004420314,
0.0071143345,
-0.0270126835,
0.0700689927,
0.0293034371,
-0.0067914766,
0.052130606,
-0.0168567691,
-0.0836189985,
0.1012405157,
-0.0230782386,
0.003807707,
-0.0458898582,
0.0085382164,
0.0072181453,
-0.0124220122,
-0.0004923258,
0.0151790679,
0.0490577519,
-0.0055644563,
0.0145547325,
-0.0120580969,
0.0436084792,
-0.0078207795,
-0.012096501,
-0.0447455794,
0.0431231968,
-0.0017578856,
-0.0337183215,
-0.01299401,
-0.0262733977,
-0.0224023517,
-0.0110748494,
-0.0479381643,
-0.04581156,
-0.094956778,
-0.0550193861,
0.0285180137,
0.0646975636,
-0.0183143374,
-0.0044932077,
-0.0111438604,
-0.0386818014,
0.0146695748,
0.0519144163,
0.0573486164,
-0.0241139773,
-0.0302512683,
0.0801936612,
-0.0492664725,
0.0457789414,
-0.02009123,
-0.044567924,
-0.02523317,
-0.0380634293,
0.0172468424,
-0.0110214762,
0.0513538644,
-0.0648601726,
0.0224348065,
0.0774431974,
0.0119812619,
0.0150379138,
-0.001438797,
-0.0142338052,
-0.0219515618,
0.0239829235,
-0.00162908,
-0.1284733713,
-0.011510537,
-0.0251181703,
0.0014975877,
-0.0221312474,
-0.0330033451,
-0.0111886421,
-0.0763775036,
0.1009192169,
0.0468228906,
-0.003101906,
-0.0598765612,
-0.0671411902,
0.0163893662,
-0.0005596501,
-0.0027569723,
0.0175423007,
0.0390741974,
-0.0116503937,
0.0129870716,
-0.03059333,
-0.0813882574,
0.0356158055,
-0.0402702838,
0.0391922519,
0.0381463207,
0.0298586059,
-0.0226001032,
-0.0523572415,
-0.0185152236,
0.0106398687,
-0.0374582149,
0.0089652082,
0.0837306082,
-0.0000467487,
0.0144360429,
-0.0109429266,
0.045955658,
-0.0052791182,
-0.0076932479,
0.000886108,
0.0916675776,
-0.0396782421,
-0.030185109,
-0.0183082242,
-0.0068976972,
-0.0078310864,
0.0551134646,
0.0036099607,
0.0586424731,
-0.0372149087,
-0.0555020534,
0.0153066954,
-0.0151998326,
0.0127762305,
0.062874563,
-0.0180430822,
-0.048061762,
-0.0679140985,
0.0137658315,
0.0306815505,
-0.0104392078,
0.0002819357,
-0.0336812399,
0.0054625524,
0.0076276436,
-0.0339527912,
0.0368567295,
-0.0437929705,
0.0351809859,
-0.0041675582,
-0.0097286133,
0.0424418934,
0.0335676596,
0.0089676101,
0.0349766091,
-0.0006416637,
-0.0599391386,
-0.059681356,
0.0483776219,
0.0227519069,
0.0408020951,
-0.0026459526,
-0.031254258,
0.0192505792,
0.0932601169,
-0.0093071293,
0.0300896466,
0.0024551337,
-0.0414675325,
-0.0277864709,
-0.0395003594,
-0.0058117737,
0.0039600693,
-0.0221435372,
0.0305099003,
-0.0334344469,
-0.0486298613,
0.0684552565,
0.0756235272,
0.0945183039,
-0.0275718048,
0.0036347415,
-0.0308107138,
0.0077311648,
-0.0128792245,
-0.0074069002,
-0.0125501724,
0.0327057056,
0.0091589754,
-0.0099840518,
-0.0192155093,
-0.0284870714,
-0.0852683857,
0.0339530185,
-0.0829661563,
0.0074747009,
-0.0129449992,
0.020574471,
0.0193257518,
-0.0271534882,
-0.0285472814,
-0.0183734167,
0.0046954015,
0.0379975475,
0.0212124791,
0.0052724015,
0.0336948,
0.0401684679,
-0.0018905005,
-0.0528878085,
-0.0768253654,
-0.023446694,
-0.0608144328,
0.0415888242,
0.0321633108,
0.0557479896,
0.0214269292,
-0.0525733791,
-0.0334999524,
-0.0229848232,
0.0419166125,
-0.0006987877,
0.0088107893,
0.0523964763,
-0.0017106676,
-0.0243255701,
-0.0288500767,
0.0169568975,
0.0341246352,
0.0910557359,
-0.0511742681,
-0.0459228642,
-0.0180938747,
-0.0921428427,
-0.0656562075,
-0.0114539582,
0.0126084918,
-0.030382771,
-0.055056829,
-0.0379147045,
0.0312099289,
0.0491771922,
0.0246269032,
-0.0142587377,
-0.0108379656,
0.0320482329,
-0.0192137714,
-0.0840783119,
0.0008228896,
0.0138736153,
0.020155197,
-0.0329385884,
-0.0212348979,
-5.95030869e-33,
-0.0188344326,
-0.0336458869,
-0.0006149815,
0.0331440903,
-0.0060305661,
0.0189610459,
-0.0398162194,
-0.0399000645,
0.0070257545,
0.0842430294,
0.0211196691,
0.0405298546,
0.0120663205,
-0.0210930556,
0.0402147807,
0.0032004358,
0.0635781363,
0.0073503028,
-0.0168318022,
-0.013776687,
0.0226881411,
0.0065135639,
0.0897266045,
-0.1217799261,
0.0506753661,
0.055440627,
-0.0332368948,
0.0103671048,
-0.0786691159,
0.0398774482,
0.0231841449,
0.0277513377,
-0.0022443861,
-0.0245709419,
-0.0009870419,
-0.0568393506,
-0.0612371415,
0.0215622652,
0.0217781607,
-0.0274138562,
-0.0111037381,
0.0121899983,
0.0177344251,
-0.0012740403,
-0.030178044,
-0.0436291918,
0.0310492665,
-0.0628474802,
0.0008780758,
-0.0724114031,
-0.0380380154,
0.0444032066,
0.0095990747,
0.0299969558,
-0.0332411639,
0.0289870165,
-0.0087597426,
0.0733398795,
-0.04282327,
0.0185320061,
0.0209297612,
-0.0196648594,
0.0043178778,
-0.0519342087,
-0.0409901217,
0.054421667,
0.0039415578,
0.0171298236,
-0.0192619674,
0.0242221691,
-0.0386415645,
0.0246551763,
0.0518776588,
0.103285104,
0.0469271243,
-0.0230873358,
-0.0801316798,
0.0394450091,
-0.0017037742,
-0.009044094,
-0.0152470646,
-0.0130270757,
-0.0139235435,
0.0175345559,
-0.0333408564,
0.0183669552,
-0.0126792304,
0.0427216291,
-0.0066280067,
0.0079580136,
-0.0019887697,
0.0562750325,
-0.0182190314,
-0.0305952393,
-0.0105270809,
-0.0204358865,
0.0120534739,
0.0183611475,
-0.0039835554,
-0.0044800951,
-0.039766293,
0.0047492352,
0.0027553039,
0.0287183672,
0.0439938977,
-0.0109259402,
0.0426263921,
-0.0001151046,
-0.0607025176,
0.0390087068,
-0.0021183873,
-0.0031799928,
0.0100216288,
-0.0087922039,
-0.0007965215,
-0.0063653938,
0.0265230983,
0.0088281911,
-0.0152913025,
0.045310732,
-0.0182808712,
0.0084499577,
-0.0058602975,
0.0345152207,
-0.0057791583,
-0.0203351136,
0.0216204617,
-0.0340853296,
-0.0071302899,
-0.0670250207,
0.0298882406,
0.0246731266,
2.6e-7,
0.0303713009,
0.0569155142,
0.0250210725,
-0.0297285002,
0.0224937405,
0.0223170072,
-0.0138913011,
0.0190928392,
0.0211784728,
-0.0694504902,
0.0029599455,
-0.0235524178,
0.045007892,
0.0147195961,
-0.0602556467,
-0.0493362658,
-0.0156865679,
-0.0560675859,
-0.0654663295,
-0.0040263264,
0.0120734982,
0.0171458255,
0.0294603594,
-0.0266366005,
0.0309425723,
0.0042411275,
0.0538722426,
0.0243283641,
-0.0068277139,
0.0224660616,
0.0660937354,
-0.0028795628,
0.0310918614,
0.0479691103,
-0.06144787,
-0.0013947926,
-0.0234971922,
0.0783773735,
-0.0024351794,
0.0152059384,
-0.0252131149,
0.0121958787,
0.0354930684,
-0.0237140674,
-0.0209872816,
-0.0189198721,
-0.0124774873,
-0.0337621421,
-0.0482703559,
0.0115824239,
0.0431878045,
-0.0222272668,
0.0095960805,
0.0185459461,
-0.0231790543,
0.0403368995,
-0.0112349894,
-0.0525303595,
0.0008422548,
0.0279403068,
-0.0444150083,
-0.0538319349,
0.058128316,
-0.0231849235,
0.0214532577,
-0.0730319992,
0.0076156226,
2.21419996e-34,
0.0587578714,
-0.0159735419,
0.0144809615,
-0.0112054069,
0.0570808724,
0.0307650007,
0.0447364934,
-0.0014630584,
0.0042894999,
-0.0016563913,
-0.0047290316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14705v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14705v2 | Mixture-of-Experts Meets Instruction Tuning:A Winning Combination for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T04:22:26 | 2023-07-05T17:24:43 | Sheng Shen, Le Hou, Yanqi Zhou, Nan Du, Shayne Longpre, Jason Wei, Hyung Won Chung, Barret Zoph, William Fedus, Xinyun Chen, Tu Vu, Yuexin Wu, Wuyang Chen, Albert Webson, Yunxuan Li, Vincent Zhao, Hongkun Yu, Kurt Keutzer, Trevor Darrell, Denny Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sparse Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) is a neural architecture design that can be
utilized to add learnable parameters to Large Language Models (LLMs) without
increasing inference cost. Instruction tuning is a technique for training LLMs
to follow instructions. We advocate combining these two approaches, as we find
that MoE models benefit more from instruction tuning than dense models. In
particular, we conduct empirical studies across three experimental setups: (i)
Direct finetuning on individual downstream tasks devoid of instruction tuning;
(ii) Instructiontuning followed by in-context few-shot or zero-shot
generalization on downstream tasks; and (iii) Instruction tuning supplemented
by further finetuning on individual downstream tasks. In the first scenario,
MoE models overall underperform dense models of identical computational
capacity. This narrative, however, dramatically changes with the introduction
of instruction tuning (second and third scenario), used independently or in
conjunction with task-specific finetuning. Our most powerful model,
FLAN-MOE-32B, surpasses the performance of FLAN-PALM-62B on four benchmark
tasks, while using only a third of the FLOPs. The advancements embodied
byFLAN-MOE inspire a reevaluation of the design principles of large-scale,
high-performance language models in the framework of task-agnostic learning. | [
0.0499397442,
0.0695079565,
0.0041791047,
0.025874326,
0.0017550627,
0.0158669502,
0.0466047935,
-0.0415177345,
-0.034817826,
-0.0274198633,
-0.0536371246,
-0.0458912924,
-0.0037192306,
-0.0133080473,
0.0544350222,
-0.0119131384,
0.0301391035,
-0.0517341532,
-0.0244333521,
-0.0239131749,
-0.0169295259,
0.0134879425,
-0.0065203095,
0.0297671203,
0.0170398988,
0.0083672395,
-0.0020839318,
0.0114698308,
-0.0085830474,
0.0136108538,
0.0006199669,
0.0462353081,
0.0509687774,
0.0464760028,
0.000002163,
-0.0047559505,
0.0187016483,
0.0003404114,
-0.0482644476,
0.0402139798,
0.0365811922,
0.0128319962,
-0.0157509558,
-0.0017209256,
0.0128577435,
-0.032535769,
0.0856175423,
0.0123882554,
0.0250256788,
0.1047533751,
0.005025703,
-0.0025257906,
0.0609997362,
-0.0471304357,
0.0016467735,
-0.0542154647,
0.0122639267,
-0.0031180095,
-0.0061832271,
0.0298421327,
-0.0228621773,
0.0303200204,
0.019169772,
0.0311128851,
0.0002363033,
0.0433194265,
-0.0087135527,
-0.0312311016,
-0.0233219676,
0.0473015495,
-0.0615866259,
0.0100333244,
-0.024370851,
-0.0119106015,
-0.0130038382,
-0.0136820907,
-0.0383752808,
0.0341002382,
0.0316163003,
0.015375779,
0.0277061146,
-0.0183532685,
0.0774395913,
0.037826553,
-0.0428040884,
0.0177964345,
0.0230390355,
-0.0001889776,
-0.0149867991,
0.0113569908,
-0.0529617406,
-0.0245736558,
-0.0206403881,
0.0369844064,
-0.0383977033,
0.0075104064,
-0.0328073725,
-0.021043513,
-0.0012813036,
-0.0070596379,
0.0962595791,
0.065661408,
-0.0186525546,
0.0517974719,
-0.0482814573,
0.0228746627,
-0.0276575144,
0.0278083384,
-0.03891927,
0.0124593535,
-0.0408737473,
0.0167092793,
0.0106510706,
0.0482982695,
-0.0379667208,
-0.014155074,
-0.0254491251,
0.0295256469,
-0.0044463254,
0.0068535679,
0.0133471591,
-0.0122168921,
-0.055902034,
-0.0308540463,
-0.0061621903,
0.0571908914,
-0.0205724295,
0.0498950481,
0.0289461315,
-0.0573863685,
-0.0212711245,
0.0146371722,
-0.0038359952,
-0.0337486193,
0.0564550124,
0.0477126576,
-0.0417310372,
-0.0480911508,
-0.0320862085,
0.0257332493,
-0.0083984649,
-0.0844721645,
0.0095172329,
-0.0668328926,
0.0540611222,
-0.0130060557,
0.0127528794,
-0.0495076478,
0.0009703318,
0.0057135257,
-0.0591782555,
0.0373709947,
-0.021460671,
-0.0000626677,
0.0134923775,
0.0132653862,
-0.0161999464,
0.0642803684,
0.0133868586,
0.038933672,
-0.0082160067,
0.0218980759,
-0.027847724,
0.0217342936,
-0.0119639467,
0.026400188,
-0.0030642713,
-0.0076635927,
0.0055133491,
0.012683819,
0.0566928163,
0.064572148,
-0.0357136093,
0.00745069,
0.0550095737,
0.0288891289,
0.004149565,
0.0346466303,
0.0535606593,
0.0050756694,
0.0013610857,
0.0190931465,
-0.0614262633,
0.0223095845,
-0.0238801055,
0.0039909845,
0.0625237897,
0.0517660752,
-0.071333535,
-0.0300552417,
0.0120812394,
-0.0039690915,
-0.0522530228,
0.0465856493,
0.0631090254,
-0.0290014185,
-0.0500632674,
-0.0035837567,
0.046102915,
-0.0131111648,
-0.0166825075,
-0.0815315396,
0.0055310279,
0.05357733,
0.0162242763,
-0.0413946658,
-0.0483231656,
-0.0190314036,
-0.0020414116,
0.0216862448,
0.0369493999,
0.005189646,
0.0477715656,
-0.0664201677,
-0.0045019365,
-0.0416357368,
0.0370339975,
0.0349085256,
0.0240628123,
-0.0119467434,
0.0238022562,
0.0152318459,
-0.0409549102,
0.0345344171,
-0.0375799537,
-0.0388071574,
0.0082616014,
0.0020012695,
0.0145109361,
-0.0142612653,
-0.0419321172,
0.0236433502,
0.0064513381,
-0.0289743226,
0.0296660904,
-0.0514382981,
-0.082591489,
-0.0014996864,
0.0300403014,
0.0252637565,
0.012276086,
-0.0155561119,
-0.031341292,
-0.0607340299,
0.0138984751,
-0.0172574446,
0.0246885251,
-0.0349883549,
0.018311305,
0.0041765585,
0.0157321244,
-0.0306034219,
0.0579592101,
-0.0276670139,
-0.0086443983,
0.0131813446,
0.0220108479,
-0.0247900039,
-0.034000095,
-0.0503105223,
-0.0316261873,
0.0133140329,
0.0460462384,
-0.0076218098,
0.009018193,
0.0058602891,
-0.0619879216,
-0.0883100778,
0.0402147844,
-0.0475033,
-0.0027728709,
0.0071179164,
0.0077014216,
0.013776565,
0.0105410349,
-0.0039451667,
0.0074442942,
-0.0232674684,
0.0307865497,
-0.0106305229,
0.0266609974,
-0.021346705,
-0.0580042116,
-0.0595420673,
0.0075295866,
0.0193521231,
-0.0367809534,
0.0061075841,
-0.0480673313,
0.0292898268,
0.0064193239,
0.015638601,
-0.0232586153,
-0.0195637066,
0.0014566019,
-0.0513965115,
0.0717737749,
0.0967596322,
-0.0312516801,
0.0151181016,
0.0544593707,
0.0015325506,
-0.0174493995,
0.0382718071,
0.0079267705,
-0.0354987048,
-0.0285587106,
-0.0137057798,
-0.0383738242,
0.0758889169,
-0.0297178309,
-0.0317596607,
-0.0573461652,
-0.0172343887,
0.0077225422,
-0.0335610136,
-0.0154531533,
0.0051055676,
0.0040047313,
0.0049342643,
-0.0401370749,
-0.0412239358,
0.0375010297,
-0.0039738342,
-0.0005309886,
-0.0231608879,
-0.0258635301,
-0.0234053172,
0.0179468207,
0.015811678,
0.026412487,
-0.029947184,
0.0036098426,
-0.0770742148,
0.0113663441,
-0.0102841165,
0.0129108271,
0.0642214045,
-0.0483799987,
0.0099144112,
-0.0233665556,
-0.0425680429,
-0.0042648478,
-0.0152392983,
-0.0343246199,
0.0541533381,
0.0591761023,
-0.0209773127,
-0.0403191224,
-0.0051698876,
0.0301978718,
0.0669167787,
-0.0058637997,
-0.0001687976,
-0.035884995,
-0.0007410275,
0.0167931076,
0.0125269089,
0.017528031,
-0.0559096001,
0.0094458768,
0.0073020365,
0.053362295,
-0.0392920822,
-0.0493921749,
0.0253945943,
0.0325337276,
-0.0016844261,
-0.0447163843,
0.0365200527,
0.0899228081,
-0.0792321488,
-0.0061110682,
0.085110873,
-0.0043937587,
-0.0581618696,
-0.0077656414,
0.0468147732,
0.0412918739,
0.022143729,
0.0489000119,
-0.0402162895,
-0.0245392341,
0.0022979572,
-0.0080449376,
0.0108787734,
0.0033597681,
-0.0050892341,
-0.0955386981,
0.0039572194,
0.0266224667,
-0.0150842778,
-0.0191314332,
-0.0393353328,
-0.0086432248,
-0.0196228232,
0.0428158268,
0.0109330239,
-0.0089407088,
-0.0270277243,
0.0311934501,
0.0442546085,
-0.0814649612,
0.0407878235,
-0.0438662991,
0.0778187066,
0.0522608012,
-0.0314446613,
-0.0133462362,
-0.0163791105,
0.0270083062,
0.0122942738,
0.0206555966,
0.0132836225,
0.0204209927,
-0.0032819093,
-0.0187943038,
-0.0046305717,
0.0043776119,
0.0035664414,
0.0001594981,
-0.0104566654,
0.0640334561,
0.0000366934,
-0.0067222808,
0.0206525195,
-0.0421059094,
-0.036565084,
0.0452027731,
0.0186152384,
-0.0529645048,
-0.0252489988,
-0.028775664,
-0.0509648174,
-0.0483373292,
-0.0043829232,
0.0141215902,
-0.0067830388,
-0.0426043533,
-0.0123729259,
-0.0077826665,
0.0276409816,
0.0583143793,
0.0196086783,
-0.00429493,
0.0181488972,
0.0045393729,
-0.0206029695,
0.0395521745,
-0.044423487,
-0.0049426598,
-0.096485436,
-0.0459668562,
0.0313512497,
-0.0105153508,
0.0148749081,
-0.0163103491,
-0.1241985336,
-0.0869335532,
-0.0101903025,
0.0715829656,
0.013022582,
0.0314974971,
0.0038330704,
-0.0916584432,
0.0467603691,
0.0156314094,
-0.0515029989,
0.0283406749,
0.0354957134,
-0.0501758568,
-0.0094944816,
0.0347355194,
-0.0140716033,
0.0275219828,
0.070508495,
0.0319468789,
-0.0360963233,
0.0196636915,
-0.0164338537,
-0.0290599018,
0.0096886046,
-0.025964126,
0.0103252102,
-0.0336691998,
0.0193524379,
0.0186516698,
0.0243134759,
-0.0371506698,
-0.0386737064,
0.0466656052,
0.0063960236,
0.0018221309,
0.0140832057,
0.0567811877,
0.0349725708,
-0.0371313877,
0.0129616763,
-0.0136105279,
-0.0019433816,
0.0192930195,
0.0204109959,
-0.0472248755,
0.0255318023,
-0.0012548459,
0.0275531132,
-0.0287286695,
0.0457051769,
-0.000663436,
-0.0035245151,
-0.0592126846,
0.0328381658,
-0.0665350854,
-0.0723171085,
-0.0219281483,
0.0351540409,
0.0872654095,
-0.0386532582,
0.0161973704,
0.0073832255,
-0.0179234724,
-0.0293407179,
-0.0140193691,
-0.0184280891,
-0.0016987127,
0.0036824069,
0.0561764501,
0.0110754622,
0.0232551619,
0.0784448162,
0.0322141871,
0.0226872955,
0.0306330733,
0.0323661827,
-0.0270941872,
-0.0120069981,
0.0095524937,
0.0490554497,
-0.0324789099,
0.029839173,
-0.0001023731,
-0.0614455231,
-0.0399474017,
-0.0186693091,
0.0312461294,
-0.0111034065,
0.0164241064,
0.0258674733,
-0.0328241996,
-0.0100400979,
-0.0212458372,
-0.0203198902,
0.0433714204,
0.009603559,
-0.0167791806,
-7.07745606e-33,
-0.0110260267,
0.0389347263,
0.0385063514,
-0.0359987803,
0.0045219082,
-0.0075557595,
-0.0282413792,
0.0138912015,
-0.0678317323,
0.0019159766,
-0.0437830649,
0.0079140849,
0.0074432846,
0.0400832295,
0.0197047591,
0.0059818313,
0.082133472,
-0.0066049481,
0.0004426546,
0.03256955,
-0.0047092712,
0.0083378516,
0.0470026881,
-0.0283061285,
-0.0242595784,
0.00594156,
0.0045879376,
0.0056649814,
-0.0032514427,
0.0311607923,
-0.0335609727,
0.0354907177,
0.0168145318,
-0.0073768827,
-0.0418409519,
-0.0277881883,
-0.0642637536,
-0.0169353448,
0.0287751574,
-0.0321258344,
0.0057370942,
-0.058763992,
0.0488290116,
0.0154051324,
-0.0066962126,
-0.0418922268,
0.0017478311,
-0.0268837232,
-0.0515792146,
0.0080766659,
-0.0433120579,
0.0244599227,
0.0254361946,
-0.0172571372,
0.0456182547,
-0.0317890011,
-0.023152668,
-0.0148540474,
-0.0476311855,
0.0011945792,
0.0184655637,
0.1000933126,
0.0527896956,
0.062458124,
0.008265635,
0.0301104262,
0.0336683169,
0.0432313755,
-0.0147709912,
0.0057097226,
0.0654110536,
0.0495960675,
0.0247692894,
-0.0262311585,
0.0517826863,
0.008704056,
-0.0695751384,
-0.0352637284,
0.035255678,
0.0458265319,
0.0770310462,
0.0267122779,
-0.0226464719,
-0.0422224551,
-0.0388094075,
0.0075187432,
-0.0541159771,
-0.0044555459,
0.0027592375,
0.0435915031,
0.0004182496,
-0.0205039009,
0.0419118553,
-0.0465962887,
0.0309747923,
-0.0253214613,
-0.012260424,
0.0287772324,
-0.0018371914,
0.03416612,
-0.1164775193,
-0.0779850408,
0.0092236344,
0.0072433567,
-0.0098059084,
0.017778853,
0.0479108058,
0.0320106745,
-0.0554588661,
-0.0471478291,
-0.037948247,
0.000688185,
0.047458753,
0.0732600167,
0.0242063068,
0.0269769356,
0.0043665119,
0.0493546911,
-0.023663206,
-0.0091718324,
0.0018283402,
-0.0071605914,
0.0038970385,
0.0245628208,
-0.0226206668,
0.0232565776,
-0.0562251657,
-0.0043972027,
0.0110069402,
-0.0595379919,
-0.0450918935,
0.013832584,
2.789e-7,
-0.0096509708,
0.0277477317,
-0.013193367,
-0.0138293859,
-0.0010446821,
0.013077246,
-0.0143682929,
-0.0151178986,
0.011372338,
-0.0313915759,
0.0276390519,
0.0662625954,
0.0311994683,
0.0020158584,
-0.0678154901,
-0.010233813,
-0.0045093093,
0.0651830137,
-0.0478984304,
-0.03587256,
-0.0130327912,
0.126123026,
0.0145091191,
-0.016772991,
0.0240215845,
0.00280328,
0.0464676768,
-0.0094747758,
-0.0033300924,
0.0372905768,
0.0192747992,
0.0502653085,
-0.0214311536,
0.0370376036,
-0.0081627909,
0.0366584174,
-0.0117276385,
0.1015555561,
-0.0243204292,
-0.0095856423,
0.0240063369,
-0.0049319137,
-0.0116875581,
-0.0254645608,
0.0706499368,
-0.0567686632,
-0.0152414292,
-0.0113517214,
0.0119172381,
0.0002080132,
-0.0051715192,
-0.0321681686,
-0.0046125622,
0.0110250134,
0.0234143566,
-0.0292813051,
-0.0129211694,
-0.0750522465,
0.0084584141,
0.0398913138,
-0.0531257056,
-0.057876125,
-0.0518115684,
-0.016543109,
0.0411126316,
-0.0189781953,
-0.0049202242,
2.866954728e-34,
0.0455685854,
-0.0154764876,
0.0332359411,
0.0298288167,
0.0278651994,
-0.019773677,
-0.0842634961,
0.0140752783,
0.0188804194,
-0.1022631526,
-0.0382646061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14702v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14702v3 | DecipherPref: Analyzing Influential Factors in Human Preference Judgments via GPT-4 | 2023-05-24T04:13:15 | 2023-10-28T01:03:15 | Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Hassan Foroosh, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human preference judgments are pivotal in guiding large language models
(LLMs) to produce outputs that align with human values. Human evaluations are
also used in summarization tasks to compare outputs from various systems,
complementing existing automatic metrics. Despite their significance, however,
there has been limited research probing these pairwise or $k$-wise comparisons.
The collective impact and relative importance of factors such as output length,
informativeness, fluency, and factual consistency are still not well
understood. It is also unclear if there are other hidden factors influencing
human judgments. In this paper, we conduct an in-depth examination of a
collection of pairwise human judgments released by OpenAI. Utilizing the
Bradley-Terry-Luce (BTL) model, we reveal the inherent preferences embedded in
these human judgments. We find that the most favored factors vary across tasks
and genres, whereas the least favored factors tend to be consistent, e.g.,
outputs are too brief, contain excessive off-focus content or hallucinated
facts. Our findings have implications on the construction of balanced datasets
in human preference evaluations, which is a crucial step in shaping the
behaviors of future LLMs. | [
0.0485698767,
0.038033925,
-0.0031677259,
0.0157987159,
-0.051763773,
0.0072074635,
-0.0502273031,
-0.0342196412,
-0.0148291653,
-0.0458809622,
-0.0382505246,
-0.010342312,
0.0439104103,
0.0240570474,
0.0027937673,
-0.084879443,
0.0069654821,
-0.0242778156,
0.0259312317,
0.0158310514,
0.0315825902,
0.0297665913,
0.0132430568,
0.0676471442,
0.0329167694,
-0.0092986012,
0.0156383831,
-0.0301960576,
0.0354713127,
-0.0133549962,
-0.0017549696,
0.0554420464,
-0.0062597813,
-0.0048123007,
0.0000021229,
-0.0467197448,
0.0369612835,
-0.0154379187,
0.0201400369,
0.0639764443,
0.0494619943,
0.0149359619,
-0.0016121528,
-0.0108017549,
-0.0280140303,
0.0089471303,
0.0091937445,
0.0417540744,
0.0559333004,
0.0330584608,
-0.0041970722,
-0.0279433299,
0.0029642298,
-0.0335803181,
-0.0170123912,
-0.0389915034,
0.0026234118,
-0.0414290167,
-0.001348665,
0.0177051816,
0.020581577,
0.0096653244,
0.0061256778,
0.0127386674,
0.0153136337,
0.0291495416,
-0.0515055396,
-0.0047872975,
-0.0013415825,
0.0937708989,
0.0331759714,
-0.0373483263,
-0.0368385166,
-0.0398424417,
0.0260926299,
0.0195825044,
-0.0368734375,
0.0409047455,
-0.0049569644,
0.0450848006,
-0.0137609309,
0.0395409875,
0.0061002881,
0.0422184952,
-0.013911549,
0.0866871476,
-0.0077809705,
-0.023565812,
0.0110526662,
0.0309731103,
-0.0441340804,
-0.0614641346,
0.0223753359,
-0.00271007,
-0.0413418896,
0.0036060922,
-0.032124877,
0.0003993478,
0.0270417593,
-0.0810598508,
0.0101935305,
0.0180575754,
-0.02718536,
0.0286764689,
0.0190194398,
0.0637337789,
0.0025402734,
0.0220152829,
-0.052145686,
0.0044364119,
-0.0084353015,
0.0083576478,
0.0071701482,
0.0398470275,
-0.0153427115,
-0.0313683897,
-0.0393362232,
0.0048494316,
-0.0409138426,
0.0018330534,
0.043383792,
0.0426870584,
-0.0171094798,
0.0011196416,
-0.0751804188,
0.0474545583,
-0.0446910262,
0.0121073462,
0.0170071274,
0.0005485839,
0.0337071791,
0.0197874028,
-0.0075008906,
-0.0231757984,
-0.0193449948,
0.022216266,
-0.0024344607,
-0.0136736687,
-0.0353976451,
0.000154295,
-0.0200827233,
-0.050613638,
-0.0370709784,
-0.0708379075,
-0.0062246337,
0.0247500185,
-0.010301671,
-0.0503263101,
-0.0089510763,
0.031954892,
-0.0582497194,
0.0278041195,
0.0122287385,
0.0142392172,
0.023582831,
-0.0046670628,
-0.0026908731,
0.0532528199,
0.0542426035,
0.1021974832,
0.0657722354,
0.0140331779,
-0.0053595225,
0.023060292,
-0.0277858954,
-0.0124685243,
-0.0409258604,
0.0154046174,
-0.0500499271,
0.0425375663,
0.0568192862,
0.0861587971,
-0.0036267345,
-0.00060573,
0.1019053087,
0.0543886572,
0.0067218649,
-0.0031388982,
0.0412359349,
0.0481839254,
0.0078212842,
0.077970244,
-0.0168500338,
0.0324094072,
-0.001622872,
0.0358967781,
0.0656436831,
0.031966269,
-0.0093109729,
-0.0603707209,
-0.0065830387,
-0.0098465933,
0.0225596521,
-0.0010698705,
0.0352999978,
-0.0126124695,
-0.0507095568,
0.0219384953,
0.0288661197,
-0.0525520556,
0.0182431266,
-0.0545513779,
0.0493993834,
0.0948604271,
0.0509692021,
0.0093428371,
0.0381723531,
0.0252548382,
-0.043201372,
0.0392148644,
0.0633021519,
-0.0284904838,
-0.0279212799,
-0.0481425151,
0.0069045294,
-0.0104935914,
0.0248762593,
0.0112599544,
0.0135006178,
-0.0073967655,
0.0207146015,
-0.0321622454,
-0.0486380905,
0.0156921782,
0.0246903524,
-0.013285432,
-0.021154739,
0.014194035,
0.0398897529,
0.0193716008,
-0.0038546361,
0.0384586751,
0.0161265507,
0.0156662334,
0.0015015054,
0.0131328292,
-0.0102843484,
0.0221344978,
0.0146902278,
-0.0449467562,
-0.0214694962,
0.0529229417,
-0.0171400718,
-0.01128555,
0.0056502987,
-0.0379071981,
0.0224446394,
-0.0367987268,
-0.00042977,
0.0025300172,
-0.0243858285,
-0.0334986933,
0.0766106844,
0.0081965337,
-0.0076547423,
0.0149661452,
-0.0323538706,
-0.001542211,
-0.040909268,
-0.0221024901,
0.0416680723,
0.0262707863,
0.0245079584,
0.0437105596,
-0.0099235578,
-0.0343089104,
-0.0140762171,
-0.1126498878,
-0.0106913121,
-0.0078574661,
-0.0095707672,
0.0193718616,
-0.0228966698,
0.0041769934,
0.0206376575,
-0.0366855115,
-0.0363360718,
-0.0161710475,
0.0209742114,
0.0147938384,
0.0146249142,
0.0490138382,
-0.0589469336,
-0.017156288,
-0.008599367,
0.0331893265,
0.0173071735,
0.0106268786,
-0.0463907942,
0.0508516692,
-0.0509228893,
-0.0292767547,
0.0097221471,
-0.0308909751,
0.0213270988,
-0.0025119029,
0.034013696,
0.0859781727,
0.0534039587,
0.0406992808,
0.0887981281,
0.0124361971,
-0.0371924043,
-0.0261231046,
-0.0419171192,
0.0044734543,
0.0021286763,
-0.033107806,
0.0347382538,
0.041152671,
0.0288132839,
0.004253766,
-0.0601857118,
0.0152014624,
-0.0381159969,
-0.0067005199,
-0.0358869657,
-0.0294956509,
-0.0449791364,
0.0819866285,
-0.009342704,
-0.0457388721,
0.0874030814,
-0.015468115,
0.0523351952,
-0.0678909868,
0.0030632487,
-0.0620686635,
0.0375633501,
0.0025883203,
0.0089257499,
-0.0217435826,
0.0109289028,
-0.056602791,
-0.0124300495,
0.0303727612,
-0.0307741873,
0.0731389299,
-0.0867555067,
-0.0072212187,
0.0144384606,
-0.0446743295,
-0.0043843319,
-0.0500662215,
-0.0389538221,
-0.0018164812,
0.0848454162,
-0.0097568026,
-0.0042753601,
-0.0061597312,
0.0446962938,
0.0129539901,
-0.0189984813,
-0.0061542238,
0.0047093602,
0.0458661504,
0.0938974023,
0.0238681436,
0.0289544687,
-0.012146295,
-0.0197910331,
0.0524617545,
0.0191032775,
-0.0095787067,
-0.011759378,
-0.0267436318,
0.0317878239,
-0.0289376806,
-0.0076813204,
0.043754328,
0.0474011675,
-0.031332992,
0.0248531066,
0.1036696285,
0.0341986082,
-0.0799561366,
0.00948893,
0.0067669735,
0.0259636082,
-0.0098027634,
0.0071257334,
-0.0411210544,
-0.0197265483,
0.0114803603,
0.0473030098,
-0.0075094616,
0.0199471656,
-0.0025605126,
-0.1201058254,
0.0259591602,
0.0068197399,
-0.0380373634,
0.0001407642,
-0.0549781695,
0.0051909606,
-0.0551567115,
0.0239938181,
0.0150038768,
-0.0088677071,
0.0152537553,
-0.0102936877,
-0.023239065,
-0.0304279644,
0.0460273512,
-0.0224842764,
0.0206070878,
0.075206995,
0.0570696555,
-0.007838768,
-0.0404784568,
0.0093284724,
-0.0338991582,
0.000256969,
0.0086149108,
0.052823469,
-0.026663987,
0.0173045192,
-0.0843346417,
0.0222569611,
-0.0018058686,
-0.0149832638,
-0.0016128776,
0.0374684781,
0.0133568281,
-0.0445255451,
-0.0282071531,
0.015272784,
-0.0319052264,
0.0884590223,
0.0350150466,
-0.0644373447,
-0.0254317354,
-0.0383747295,
0.0096285138,
-0.0471425988,
-0.0587782152,
-0.0147045245,
0.0011980952,
-0.0442236252,
-0.0875604972,
-0.0643182993,
0.0070426906,
-0.0286720376,
0.0262417793,
-0.0017452399,
0.0303120632,
0.013263532,
-0.004095335,
0.0426054038,
0.0073658945,
0.0121531496,
-0.0786518604,
-0.0267678872,
0.0473606102,
-0.048903659,
-0.0073768455,
0.0246971063,
-0.0251065306,
-0.0546375103,
-0.0245666597,
0.0636755675,
0.0303709786,
0.0044490723,
0.0032068945,
-0.0569689833,
-0.0114634586,
0.0364655964,
-0.0503086448,
0.0268509816,
-0.0115689822,
0.0434801467,
-0.0005398444,
0.0289698243,
-0.0312044378,
0.0107533243,
-0.0469320193,
0.0212836284,
-0.0027240082,
-0.0852054358,
0.0364765488,
0.0253788568,
0.0183818284,
-0.0357143395,
0.0158739686,
-0.0425307304,
-0.0385757834,
-0.0205769427,
-0.0202941205,
-0.0394217484,
0.0009061368,
0.0262822118,
0.0135377236,
-0.0381714925,
0.0244537182,
-0.0115227439,
-0.0013440821,
-0.0439313725,
-0.0185223911,
-0.0067097419,
0.0099991132,
0.0023609367,
-0.0036621816,
-0.065975979,
-0.0376057476,
-0.0592692606,
0.0449433699,
0.0196806695,
0.0579893105,
0.0260576457,
-0.0238735043,
0.025144672,
0.0580290891,
-0.0585344993,
-0.0229358561,
-0.0297703519,
-0.0034345929,
0.0129753398,
-0.0462332107,
0.079313308,
-0.0187154822,
-0.0112121291,
-0.034582261,
0.0345156938,
-0.0172108747,
-0.0049756332,
-0.0320389755,
0.0322305299,
-0.0260624345,
-0.0053189485,
0.10606388,
-0.0045818789,
-0.0233239122,
-0.0025288223,
-0.0485063642,
-0.0277415849,
-0.0469233096,
-0.0327065736,
0.0612799786,
-0.0279122628,
-0.0245573446,
-0.1013040617,
-0.0432035513,
-0.0207348503,
0.0184512082,
0.0275372714,
-0.0429004021,
0.0330083631,
0.0591560341,
-0.030429339,
0.0027776558,
-0.0513173938,
-0.0217715353,
-0.0516592078,
0.0188464411,
-0.0441809855,
-6.533545273e-33,
-0.026185412,
-0.0372979268,
-0.03261685,
0.0112263998,
-0.0048741051,
-0.0289908294,
-0.0291084982,
0.0177981239,
-0.0139279403,
0.0078186542,
-0.0000635905,
-0.0037113146,
0.0032129602,
0.0029985625,
0.0360452682,
-0.0020011812,
0.0320254229,
-0.0012560663,
-0.0606180988,
0.011416289,
0.059679836,
-0.0429688804,
0.0134878727,
-0.0430521332,
0.0494258516,
0.0018291308,
-0.0281727239,
-0.0192879047,
-0.0333300531,
0.0696213543,
-0.007899154,
0.0506208651,
0.0261314418,
-0.0358576588,
-0.0138106113,
0.0165388156,
-0.0270977765,
-0.0154140694,
0.0611868314,
-0.0150919324,
-0.0120765343,
-0.0357162915,
0.0240304247,
-0.0054104184,
-0.0367142148,
-0.0078514088,
0.0728141665,
-0.0349293947,
-0.0152294356,
-0.0102454415,
-0.0379767902,
0.008779401,
-0.0114946431,
-0.0169274155,
0.0116801923,
0.0297566317,
-0.0314284042,
0.0609555133,
-0.0680749342,
0.0711643174,
0.0150920758,
0.0248570312,
0.0492040627,
-0.0359215401,
-0.0036781486,
0.0636557117,
0.0239277296,
-0.0105180219,
-0.0474423133,
-0.0386930555,
-0.0050775348,
0.04117864,
0.023520438,
0.0404393338,
0.0458599366,
-0.0084194113,
0.0020000178,
0.0554822534,
-0.014075567,
0.0108994739,
0.0361236073,
0.0330862254,
-0.0454266779,
-0.0205628369,
-0.0173437577,
0.0002032302,
-0.0478131287,
-0.0254578535,
0.0096973823,
-0.0136605157,
-0.030151559,
-0.0228096936,
0.0029817165,
-0.0309119727,
-0.000980255,
0.0198965017,
-0.0695809573,
0.0499785058,
0.0077187708,
-0.0166365113,
-0.0670114383,
0.047493659,
-0.0092929089,
0.0235082582,
0.0064827348,
0.0351236314,
0.0153062809,
0.0007843662,
-0.0037721028,
0.008362364,
-0.0150192818,
-0.0313244574,
0.0017563547,
-0.0338708796,
0.0264120772,
0.0130580207,
-0.024907643,
0.0265708957,
-0.0247444641,
-0.0080007622,
-0.034141928,
-0.0301100761,
0.0069822529,
0.0066496544,
-0.038152609,
-0.0069222907,
-0.0099087665,
0.0141927721,
0.0182722192,
-0.0120091056,
-0.0286467746,
0.0226983018,
2.759e-7,
0.0422614925,
0.0647546351,
0.0124991359,
0.0346016213,
-0.0113406172,
0.0437395796,
0.0077840229,
0.0056730388,
0.0403457992,
-0.0109717278,
0.0121475495,
0.0261212513,
0.0544027686,
0.0213328023,
-0.088943623,
0.0014550595,
-0.0526626222,
-0.0194522347,
-0.0370173641,
-0.0239839535,
0.0746354833,
0.0534906648,
0.0304669607,
0.0119207157,
0.0029567718,
0.0175394844,
0.0597938038,
-0.06042137,
-0.0051922188,
0.0111138718,
0.0277916733,
-0.0114915296,
-0.0411279351,
0.005512224,
-0.0085255932,
-0.0297606047,
0.0781567395,
0.0647372827,
0.0105508137,
-0.0578599349,
-0.0089088697,
-0.0168988425,
0.0158074182,
-0.0809678957,
0.0641628504,
-0.0377270505,
-0.0511341505,
-0.0066655567,
-0.0119934306,
-0.0011091923,
-0.0062151719,
-0.0275065321,
-0.0188065041,
0.0003783104,
-0.0109587656,
0.0064563169,
-0.0160732865,
-0.0371840931,
-0.0421240516,
0.0199110825,
-0.0300640091,
-0.0719033703,
-0.0592433736,
0.0144860307,
0.0214874987,
-0.0706703365,
0.0122347828,
2.200950393e-34,
0.0754116997,
0.0003170702,
-0.0037709996,
-0.0375700668,
0.048495777,
0.0039422126,
0.0137388129,
0.001062216,
0.0266589746,
-0.0604989044,
-0.0223648436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14701v1 | Modeling rapid language learning by distilling Bayesian priors into artificial neural networks | 2023-05-24T04:11:59 | 2023-05-24T04:11:59 | R. Thomas McCoy, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans can learn languages from remarkably little experience. Developing
computational models that explain this ability has been a major challenge in
cognitive science. Bayesian models that build in strong inductive biases -
factors that guide generalization - have been successful at explaining how
humans might generalize from few examples in controlled settings but are
usually too restrictive to be tractably applied to more naturalistic data. By
contrast, neural networks have flexible representations that allow them to
learn well from naturalistic data but require many more examples than humans
receive. We show that learning from limited naturalistic data is possible with
an approach that combines the strong inductive biases of a Bayesian model with
the flexible representations of a neural network. This approach works by
distilling a Bayesian model's biases into a neural network. Like a Bayesian
model, the resulting system can learn formal linguistic patterns from a small
number of examples. Like a neural network, it can also learn aspects of English
syntax from a corpus of natural language - and it outperforms a standard neural
network at acquiring the linguistic phenomena of recursion and priming.
Bridging the divide between Bayesian models and neural networks makes it
possible to handle a broader range of learning scenarios than either approach
can handle on its own. | [
-0.0128823947,
0.051799614,
-0.0373107642,
-0.0160078425,
-0.0266630203,
0.0388104171,
-0.0432744063,
-0.01282073,
-0.0245051011,
-0.0146192471,
-0.0037311937,
-0.0279469285,
0.02277169,
0.0080057504,
0.0192664266,
-0.073905699,
0.0354020558,
-0.0256768018,
0.0670309886,
-0.0381692573,
-0.0132832825,
-0.0092409244,
-0.0555388555,
0.0295885,
-0.0198009592,
0.0175890177,
-0.0349696167,
-0.0426658206,
-0.0344797485,
0.0125690801,
0.014643522,
0.0197030902,
0.0355775543,
0.0168853533,
0.0000018201,
-0.0607459247,
0.0359320529,
-0.0389470123,
-0.0341849178,
-0.0408169441,
0.04633338,
0.0054801442,
-0.0064018662,
-0.0232949425,
-0.0700956434,
-0.075781621,
0.0473579317,
-0.0270179417,
-0.0114249568,
0.0749526173,
0.0076052509,
-0.0360494964,
0.0147491572,
0.007994771,
0.0562128872,
-0.0363526046,
0.0090708137,
-0.0250668246,
0.0253072977,
-0.0314033292,
-0.0392730758,
-0.0151102077,
0.0395228043,
0.0623497441,
0.0319683366,
0.072882086,
0.0100983428,
-0.0364312828,
-0.038581863,
0.0121892206,
-0.0708577931,
-0.0580244809,
-0.0024083923,
-0.0119763538,
0.0436695032,
0.0300045572,
-0.0541526005,
0.0875408649,
-0.0214756988,
0.0461951531,
0.0276915561,
-0.0601928234,
0.04113153,
0.0190577731,
0.0214753021,
0.1070657447,
0.0191024505,
-0.0086950837,
0.0304442123,
0.0034962709,
0.0215664338,
-0.0061452929,
-0.0346154682,
0.0234145336,
0.0117413849,
0.0423639566,
-0.0347853899,
-0.0165322181,
0.0338485613,
-0.0683153346,
0.0010645943,
0.0281026512,
-0.0273126848,
0.0269835237,
-0.0346884057,
-0.034729749,
0.0117567573,
0.0185383167,
-0.031576138,
0.0070888707,
-0.0509888157,
-0.0083929636,
-0.0335777737,
0.0075965249,
0.0110624051,
0.0247677285,
-0.0327652916,
-0.0019470399,
0.008474553,
-0.0145288669,
0.0178202204,
0.001404968,
-0.0514484681,
-0.0015386909,
-0.0317389853,
-0.0165253188,
-0.082347326,
0.0581917763,
0.0017232206,
-0.0300828908,
-0.0050492086,
-0.0187414251,
0.0370447524,
0.0083387857,
0.0053259209,
0.0549965091,
-0.0084108179,
-0.0330624133,
-0.0535264462,
-0.0003617725,
0.0149697382,
-0.0235074852,
0.0488497429,
-0.0365272835,
0.0313766897,
-0.0067295777,
-0.0107842973,
-0.0832456797,
-0.0148441326,
0.0070082252,
-0.0370908119,
0.0615546405,
-0.0194261577,
0.0134329675,
0.050633397,
-0.0177050084,
0.0163707137,
0.0555060916,
0.0218418147,
-0.0155957742,
-0.0121688535,
-0.0183363296,
0.004487393,
0.025322726,
0.0018476672,
-0.0124857016,
-0.0569878891,
-0.0499454066,
0.0241416451,
0.028185444,
0.0360013023,
0.0106379874,
-0.0406322069,
-0.0177951921,
0.0624330863,
0.024701057,
-0.0221163239,
0.0405814089,
0.0885392129,
-0.0056637349,
0.0137071088,
0.0021138224,
-0.0591867492,
0.0141066108,
-0.0124357836,
0.0052234926,
-0.0245724916,
0.0221566949,
-0.0107469829,
-0.0277817175,
0.0229439065,
-0.011642254,
0.036143709,
0.0159356054,
0.0588959083,
0.0654489994,
-0.0009215783,
0.0372989662,
0.0754500106,
-0.0164512116,
0.0170177389,
-0.0221757032,
0.0366867632,
0.0168724656,
-0.0192678422,
-0.044635158,
-0.0053472696,
0.0165997371,
-0.0376508422,
0.0133804642,
0.0690535083,
0.0056471918,
0.0096028829,
-0.025122337,
0.002451953,
0.0232968833,
0.0361838304,
0.0170605611,
-0.0287519805,
-0.0136493789,
-0.021467166,
-0.0152810477,
-0.0404750332,
0.0501034819,
-0.0289419908,
-0.051229354,
0.0018126406,
-0.0164496265,
0.0578882508,
-0.0238745492,
0.0255798586,
0.0181938,
0.0410179459,
-0.0019043298,
-0.0025865061,
0.0254499521,
-0.0467575938,
-0.0229653195,
0.0386741124,
-0.0603879243,
0.0096236719,
-0.0046388982,
-0.0137728769,
-0.0434452705,
0.0260845125,
-0.0293522459,
0.0415260158,
0.0039488785,
0.0414311625,
-0.0095608104,
0.0318582207,
0.0111925798,
0.0614904128,
-0.000965966,
-0.008709331,
-0.0284663644,
-0.0270211343,
-0.0342663787,
-0.0417315103,
-0.0020977953,
-0.059514042,
-0.0166354347,
-0.0045714537,
0.0171222407,
-0.0222643949,
-0.0760473087,
0.0407502316,
-0.0764513984,
-0.0016796787,
0.004976688,
0.0021544448,
0.0155055765,
0.0021852364,
0.0030696401,
-0.0082291467,
-0.0668590218,
0.0371808968,
0.008958824,
0.0313718803,
0.012820893,
-0.0004888109,
-0.0486944318,
-0.0402484052,
-0.0174473878,
-0.0362005383,
0.0324875079,
0.0428385548,
0.0161646176,
-0.0406662785,
-0.0150689548,
0.0096183615,
0.0422504283,
-0.001667036,
-0.044850789,
0.0423699468,
-0.0470010675,
-0.0119538894,
0.0953909084,
0.004962591,
-0.0207348727,
0.0691861138,
0.0027857597,
-0.0349121131,
0.0042932178,
-0.0800053105,
-0.0111806281,
-0.0350144729,
-0.0375867859,
-0.0394151434,
0.0847219899,
0.0291536134,
-0.0148905013,
-0.0525717251,
0.0687242299,
0.0153163131,
-0.033982221,
-0.0255369954,
-0.05672957,
-0.0410114974,
0.0341588855,
-0.0296127629,
-0.0572764389,
0.0473863333,
0.0323844887,
0.0103053069,
-0.0454292223,
0.0208027773,
0.0133330282,
0.0113996183,
0.0710450485,
-0.0024780612,
0.0568702146,
0.0103076678,
-0.0667105094,
0.0378479399,
0.0272984616,
-0.0015145788,
0.0422195904,
-0.0710547417,
-0.0268785506,
0.0392618477,
0.0088435421,
-0.0539685525,
-0.0156580452,
-0.0384155847,
0.0191300642,
-0.0077148653,
-0.0046228687,
-0.0046706982,
-0.0339706391,
0.0115507562,
0.0595803298,
0.0265542865,
-0.0173610691,
-0.0203626342,
-0.0074374806,
0.015987033,
-0.0134483268,
0.0164324883,
-0.005708951,
0.0108607123,
0.0257451963,
0.0751168206,
0.0406900384,
-0.054107178,
0.0567783639,
0.0036697539,
-0.0532374978,
-0.0070690853,
0.0999775231,
-0.0216626693,
-0.0465763807,
-0.0492457747,
0.078657113,
0.0111341365,
-0.0758985132,
0.0287554506,
0.0044645583,
0.0064583714,
0.0181765165,
0.0170139335,
-0.0572091825,
-0.0180636514,
0.0122032082,
-0.0019339179,
-0.013544051,
-0.0519437976,
0.0144925863,
-0.0813416243,
-0.0167947784,
0.0483912751,
-0.05216562,
0.0422937237,
-0.052575238,
-0.0078687835,
-0.0067800297,
0.0017942421,
0.0163364932,
-0.0088858334,
0.0108589455,
0.0138043789,
0.0097975628,
-0.0746417791,
0.0314636864,
-0.0370000079,
0.0511165559,
0.008550561,
-0.0097809285,
-0.0468269959,
-0.0235527381,
0.0279395543,
0.0289589874,
0.0045492351,
0.0227909144,
0.0339947343,
0.0295924172,
0.0013732545,
0.0168248899,
0.0617068671,
-0.0574251413,
-0.0133154951,
0.0279710721,
0.089673005,
0.0027130074,
-0.0185056012,
0.0165572725,
-0.0021714095,
-0.0143725462,
0.0435309932,
0.0571571626,
-0.0572305322,
0.0149416653,
-0.0108844899,
-0.0057162475,
0.0009217043,
-0.0630436316,
0.0727085024,
0.0129312687,
-0.0612888895,
-0.0967299417,
-0.0245798286,
0.0066137128,
0.0259605534,
0.0596420206,
-0.0210839193,
0.0486535691,
-0.0110886712,
-0.0104482248,
0.0437136777,
-0.0118006784,
-0.0518699512,
-0.0470628627,
-0.0430212878,
-0.0223507714,
-0.0799372941,
-0.0141853057,
-0.0297942683,
-0.0411460176,
-0.0661853477,
0.0551281907,
0.0875246599,
0.0255032144,
0.0326989926,
0.0029440597,
-0.080354318,
0.0149230203,
0.0049369354,
-0.0023777671,
-0.0253267065,
0.0035980609,
-0.0183566585,
0.0236384273,
0.0090480596,
-0.0320509635,
0.0403203107,
0.0082410593,
0.0012649262,
-0.0218998436,
-0.0038409065,
0.0709019601,
-0.0025038084,
0.0699875578,
-0.0401617475,
-0.0107351793,
-0.035216324,
-0.0356542729,
0.0118624531,
0.0033021714,
-0.0128267119,
-0.0142982071,
0.0090513155,
0.0715563372,
-0.0048293904,
-0.040308889,
-0.0023901397,
0.0243923236,
-0.0237852279,
-0.016228741,
0.0674366951,
0.0472321101,
0.020410575,
0.0013528777,
0.0061745439,
0.0331898183,
-0.0600527339,
0.0414399058,
-0.0016545405,
0.0355467312,
0.0169278104,
0.0230462924,
-0.0607053861,
-0.0505369678,
-0.0563701205,
-0.0637668222,
-0.0154058794,
0.0315559432,
0.0719095096,
-0.055921562,
-0.0082031786,
-0.0814769045,
0.0397570357,
-0.002787085,
-0.0024607633,
0.0079375729,
-0.0445267819,
0.0049794214,
0.0336150639,
-0.0111414837,
-0.0102862064,
0.0670833513,
0.0020822838,
0.0392314233,
-0.0191595256,
0.0187173318,
-0.0276016612,
-0.0181807205,
0.0204930287,
0.0213409998,
-0.0062753027,
0.0166175086,
-0.0205444209,
-0.0526807196,
-0.0187764429,
0.0222284757,
0.04098095,
-0.0277539846,
0.0556029715,
0.0197351035,
-0.0698852092,
-0.0350845158,
-0.0171772689,
0.0376265943,
0.014352724,
0.0130622312,
-0.0231052022,
-6.110078576e-33,
0.026205048,
0.0011549866,
-0.0122321993,
-0.0250730328,
0.0217765942,
-0.0370681919,
0.0091254506,
0.0302705262,
-0.0068344958,
0.042729076,
-0.0222531967,
0.0017117549,
0.0143126454,
0.0163084958,
0.0639723837,
0.0168745797,
0.012232963,
-0.0499196537,
0.0019155869,
0.0004680871,
0.0153323626,
0.0074908943,
0.0615110584,
-0.0127462186,
0.0275377985,
-0.0186959952,
0.0073314877,
0.0355415493,
-0.0039829314,
0.0127967633,
-0.0019122689,
0.0320517793,
0.0412513688,
-0.0175641254,
-0.0233668759,
0.0308500323,
-0.0769236758,
-0.0379909687,
0.0182493124,
0.0304742903,
-0.0127365813,
-0.0038048236,
0.0849987119,
-0.0296800453,
0.0070185037,
0.0299877208,
0.0490000881,
-0.0421175882,
-0.0481707677,
0.006578526,
-0.0536003485,
-0.0072272988,
-0.0009993886,
0.0098045841,
0.0139463972,
-0.0000300074,
-0.0712975189,
-0.0496499762,
-0.034421213,
0.0327441432,
0.0248213112,
0.0096846484,
0.0191421174,
0.0222324319,
0.0384264998,
0.0549906418,
0.0984809846,
0.014802048,
0.0068209395,
-0.013213478,
0.0425734669,
-0.0032643825,
0.0156333894,
0.0165646914,
0.0785464719,
0.007936934,
-0.0597462654,
-0.0234669875,
0.0688225254,
0.0442032814,
0.0113202268,
-0.0054108021,
-0.0436688475,
-0.0179511979,
-0.040303871,
0.0009718449,
-0.0069558793,
-0.0089096352,
-0.000379825,
-0.008725876,
0.0215858258,
-0.0501714721,
-0.0003954362,
-0.0015930095,
0.0417112894,
0.0140358713,
0.0248559304,
-0.0002279061,
0.0078077093,
-0.0041861036,
-0.0490030572,
-0.0427306332,
-0.0243803728,
0.0012208226,
0.0222916659,
0.0511805229,
0.0204857327,
0.024116559,
-0.0142775755,
0.0007254485,
-0.0490595512,
-0.0346941203,
0.0664139614,
0.0139382249,
0.0648017973,
0.0184574835,
-0.0074758227,
0.0023860321,
0.0376549587,
-0.0304797217,
-0.0118527636,
-0.0020223868,
-0.0265148729,
0.0322883502,
-0.0210665837,
-0.023268031,
-0.0178963747,
-0.0085223271,
0.02288232,
-0.0630075559,
-0.0015339588,
0.0583014116,
2.661e-7,
-0.0186598189,
0.0101935631,
-0.0191319808,
0.0085187275,
0.0418377146,
0.0046163537,
-0.0028641059,
-0.0078852717,
-0.0057391659,
-0.0295799896,
0.0195222311,
0.0294018257,
0.0136990696,
0.0218649469,
-0.0906264335,
-0.0737772211,
-0.0411544517,
0.0484058484,
0.0059676133,
-0.0109449774,
-0.0076182145,
0.0662902072,
0.0357853249,
-0.0056633474,
0.0240544882,
-0.0533295982,
0.042724546,
-0.0130690774,
0.0446717776,
0.0014500691,
-0.0253288578,
0.0046596811,
-0.0241134856,
0.0638270527,
-0.008427388,
0.0253044162,
-0.0334560797,
0.0204696897,
-0.0135946563,
-0.0045479266,
0.0283081215,
0.0010597509,
-0.0140723241,
-0.0409860164,
0.0280897133,
-0.115957506,
-0.0388576798,
0.0095017832,
-0.0309793353,
0.0059777368,
-0.0291436426,
0.0201788396,
-0.0336604044,
-0.010354789,
0.0045053465,
0.013128317,
-0.0066041984,
-0.0695970729,
-0.0149408756,
0.0657939091,
-0.0540897064,
-0.0282717701,
-0.0193642788,
-0.0582710914,
0.0242667068,
-0.0126657505,
0.0310031697,
1.861374871e-34,
0.0119277844,
-0.0309224185,
0.0248751361,
0.0238924194,
0.0057814592,
-0.0406498052,
0.0125394175,
0.0415992551,
0.1155631989,
-0.052007053,
-0.0103912363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14696v1 | SELFOOD: Self-Supervised Out-Of-Distribution Detection via Learning to Rank | 2023-05-24T04:01:27 | 2023-05-24T04:01:27 | Dheeraj Mekala, Adithya Samavedhi, Chengyu Dong, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep neural classifiers trained with cross-entropy loss (CE loss) often
suffer from poor calibration, necessitating the task of out-of-distribution
(OOD) detection. Traditional supervised OOD detection methods require expensive
manual annotation of in-distribution and OOD samples. To address the annotation
bottleneck, we introduce SELFOOD, a self-supervised OOD detection method that
requires only in-distribution samples as supervision. We cast OOD detection as
an inter-document intra-label (IDIL) ranking problem and train the classifier
with our pairwise ranking loss, referred to as IDIL loss. Specifically, given a
set of in-distribution documents and their labels, for each label, we train the
classifier to rank the softmax scores of documents belonging to that label to
be higher than the scores of documents that belong to other labels. Unlike CE
loss, our IDIL loss function reaches zero when the desired confidence ranking
is achieved and gradients are backpropagated to decrease probabilities
associated with incorrect labels rather than continuously increasing the
probability of the correct label. Extensive experiments with several
classifiers on multiple classification datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of our method in both coarse- and fine-grained settings. | [
-0.0037891276,
0.0179860629,
0.0199240539,
0.0666405335,
0.0362141691,
0.0290021971,
-0.0467173941,
0.0018915334,
0.0267838258,
-0.0287308209,
-0.0441767834,
0.0359925739,
-0.0035181141,
-0.0169253107,
0.0107127968,
0.0156112602,
0.0110643385,
0.0165263005,
0.0076398007,
-0.0123027442,
0.0030275427,
-0.0011913436,
0.0074430355,
-0.0301661044,
0.0006648719,
-0.0330446586,
0.0093295733,
0.0757721439,
0.0410214812,
-0.0241901968,
0.0392886251,
0.000038028,
-0.0031131695,
0.0415105782,
0.0000022351,
-0.0385706909,
-0.0587327592,
-0.0049542664,
-0.0010079764,
0.005659455,
-0.0168327708,
-0.0175243597,
-0.0209860839,
-0.0152131673,
0.002449984,
0.0166581459,
0.046429038,
0.0756164938,
0.0144680496,
0.037376415,
-0.0115828793,
0.0306681842,
0.0379954167,
-0.0597984903,
0.0267270561,
-0.0655211136,
0.0208662841,
-0.0249866452,
-0.0519129783,
0.0155183831,
-0.0267777871,
0.0484967306,
0.0251895878,
-0.004654434,
0.0408371873,
0.0419250913,
-0.0019684965,
0.034969233,
-0.0232985877,
0.0790540129,
-0.0604440235,
-0.0069419569,
0.0139084579,
-0.0628826991,
0.0465585291,
-0.0174096581,
0.0071588564,
0.0271327142,
0.0099613313,
0.0239150282,
-0.0109780217,
0.0832180828,
0.0240068249,
0.032959953,
-0.0113779884,
0.0467739142,
-0.0259320494,
-0.0442943722,
-0.0027282364,
0.0189422164,
-0.0419170074,
0.0020955424,
0.0324734636,
-0.0115406672,
0.0298182759,
-0.000736577,
-0.0320665203,
-0.0236284751,
0.0430063158,
-0.0487505421,
0.0359863788,
-0.0490284301,
-0.0427870005,
0.0409961753,
0.0194861609,
0.0167466924,
-0.0045560496,
0.0976166949,
-0.0243871324,
0.0124752261,
0.0282624066,
-0.0225798842,
0.0073469537,
0.049743548,
0.0257743355,
-0.0129175298,
-0.0412030779,
-0.030169744,
-0.0474071503,
0.0011281433,
0.0347443186,
0.0568537563,
-0.0632775575,
0.0023070034,
-0.0083186505,
0.0174280349,
0.0300104395,
0.0125106554,
0.0028909335,
0.0136357415,
-0.0195143875,
0.0330223925,
-0.0264760554,
0.0141949439,
0.0119814705,
0.0261281934,
0.0062815831,
-0.0228544995,
-0.0202278513,
-0.0399129987,
-0.0515170842,
-0.0301453378,
0.0139306849,
-0.0510732941,
-0.0390322246,
-0.017625194,
0.0358578265,
-0.006480183,
0.0147568369,
0.0082992362,
-0.0048428699,
0.0072108717,
-0.002207183,
-0.0365029275,
0.0518190339,
0.0218028091,
0.0326054953,
0.0735522881,
-0.0049858317,
0.01867426,
0.0185372792,
0.0289540794,
0.0300654937,
0.0398163423,
0.0214106217,
0.0065965303,
-0.0031169935,
-0.0228302013,
-0.0058767232,
0.0271132644,
0.0817387179,
-0.0121458564,
-0.0019346126,
-0.0681713894,
0.0393774733,
-0.0404834449,
0.0498271808,
-0.0569068231,
-0.0425925218,
0.0008088088,
-0.0640906319,
0.0338120461,
-0.0209591556,
0.0379797854,
0.0042946716,
-0.0456821397,
0.0673583969,
-0.0317014754,
-0.0124999303,
-0.044472266,
0.0113867214,
-0.010391375,
-0.0466046408,
0.0029867569,
0.0572726652,
0.0568617173,
0.0301888995,
0.0286120642,
0.0195012987,
0.0216951612,
-0.0022063674,
-0.0304444786,
-0.023180943,
0.0385095514,
0.0396544971,
-0.0733996332,
0.0410017371,
-0.0020871472,
-0.0053890105,
-0.0164660625,
-0.002788841,
-0.002038023,
0.0143924868,
-0.0484342352,
-0.0206397884,
-0.0435023569,
0.0094180517,
0.0253433604,
-0.0300239697,
0.0332458876,
0.0327206701,
-0.1072379798,
-0.0160083398,
0.0129405698,
0.0136045078,
-0.0580553263,
0.065921545,
0.0173271839,
0.0113911713,
-0.0034272594,
-0.003168124,
-0.0027278701,
0.0538016967,
-0.0183474552,
-0.050867822,
-0.0895833224,
-0.0207922328,
-0.0170668997,
0.0266597383,
-0.0458544903,
-0.0190809257,
0.0398813672,
-0.0517202951,
0.0096515669,
0.0112310294,
-0.0266060904,
-0.0306973066,
-0.0594508424,
-0.0214366838,
0.0373588018,
0.0297319833,
-0.0383744948,
0.0971480906,
-0.0074808691,
0.0387396738,
-0.0144949667,
-0.0128876586,
0.0342352688,
-0.0275468864,
0.016943939,
0.0002561714,
-0.0581891499,
0.0344091989,
0.0088722333,
0.0096429847,
-0.0133948186,
-0.0051347851,
-0.0084570209,
-0.002080963,
-0.0125147868,
0.003046924,
-0.0003401954,
-0.0042023836,
0.0111378627,
-0.0468818136,
-0.0192085411,
-0.0097228382,
-0.0012883064,
-0.0012366108,
0.0374234281,
0.0039075105,
0.0394572578,
0.0375133529,
-0.0305553749,
-0.0306501575,
0.0636574104,
-0.0066249394,
-0.0171358455,
-0.0678532198,
0.040912699,
-0.0220874865,
0.018272724,
0.0030079701,
-0.0051103737,
-0.0337366238,
-0.0150550315,
-0.036582049,
0.0738241524,
0.0131193306,
-0.0233187694,
0.0620504245,
0.005230024,
-0.0374284871,
-0.0169296302,
0.0088196388,
-0.0038373887,
0.0372648574,
0.0086625898,
-0.0194788389,
-0.0065531307,
0.0103146797,
0.0050907629,
0.0224330444,
-0.0418180898,
-0.00024852,
-0.0395526513,
-0.0385035127,
0.0059330659,
0.0058208494,
0.0096411947,
0.0147925764,
-0.0155280856,
0.0434110835,
-0.0036330794,
0.0174758043,
-0.065275982,
0.0031324967,
-0.0043475274,
-0.0012636426,
-0.0021070633,
0.0438076928,
0.0371521451,
-0.0430182554,
-0.0418348201,
-0.0100086126,
0.0507003181,
-0.0087932209,
-0.0305111054,
0.0170537028,
-0.0067209844,
-0.018014092,
-0.0440276675,
-0.0173382163,
-0.0635873973,
0.0517131202,
-0.0232332088,
-0.0235625952,
0.006647401,
-0.0222652592,
-0.014644227,
-0.027158143,
0.0605830289,
-0.0454171561,
-0.0270676389,
0.0082372297,
0.0992417037,
0.0252319761,
-0.0608666502,
0.0332294442,
-0.0417502411,
-0.0338478126,
0.0672126412,
0.0378620885,
0.0315475203,
0.0064251795,
-0.0124474177,
0.0281431302,
-0.0019754588,
0.0092855552,
0.0173653979,
-0.0090145636,
-0.0394126773,
-0.016784342,
0.0381820053,
0.0186657514,
-0.0655063689,
-0.0100369323,
-0.0031385303,
0.0101321572,
0.0150244944,
-0.0182042569,
-0.0690277219,
-0.010166619,
-0.0011658305,
0.0273979288,
-0.0151190003,
-0.0108243236,
0.0323017016,
-0.0922127888,
0.0364310518,
0.0028178184,
0.0005683798,
-0.0190642402,
-0.0277315024,
-0.0082066581,
0.0018621978,
-0.0304261912,
-0.0211695563,
0.0194998831,
-0.0215324555,
0.0234922171,
0.0106245764,
-0.0420964584,
0.0133264987,
-0.0371537618,
0.0034411128,
0.0503915139,
0.0399883091,
-0.020719273,
-0.0231534559,
0.0468170457,
-0.1002744511,
-0.023216201,
0.0128135309,
0.0879007503,
-0.0253801867,
0.0049317176,
0.0077461097,
0.0335838459,
-0.0322020352,
0.0418308228,
-0.0260633286,
0.0463504568,
-0.0144742532,
-0.0355615318,
-0.0520490222,
-0.0049901125,
0.0374906547,
0.0084384251,
-0.0394838192,
0.0021292814,
-0.0306744128,
-0.0272614453,
0.0568478592,
0.0413465165,
0.0532740653,
0.0949734151,
0.0289366785,
-0.1337067932,
-0.0520380549,
-0.0230139848,
-0.0764367208,
0.0183886923,
-0.0035102195,
-0.0110505102,
-0.0538491979,
-0.0058923992,
-0.0623088628,
-0.0274404604,
-0.0109481178,
0.0090581784,
-0.001530239,
0.0468446426,
0.0726801679,
-0.0028137935,
-0.0516896285,
0.0618798621,
-0.0313235857,
-0.0546513498,
-0.0205631815,
0.0265881568,
0.0138816508,
0.0166550633,
-0.0328759179,
-0.0356772393,
0.1054855362,
0.1286134869,
-0.0308054164,
-0.0011442194,
0.0252430867,
-0.0830875859,
-0.0114322687,
0.0291101635,
-0.0466081277,
0.029951591,
0.0053507895,
-0.044053711,
-0.0259216428,
-0.0427975021,
0.0155451987,
-0.0298923906,
0.0457252711,
-0.0147782378,
-0.0275693312,
-0.0216599926,
0.0618369132,
-0.0006452541,
-0.0366515815,
0.0060806293,
0.0357608087,
0.0647430643,
0.0071640038,
-0.0188957639,
0.0829130337,
0.055004824,
0.0319368914,
-0.036840573,
-0.0227505378,
0.049827572,
0.0121298889,
-0.0290897265,
-0.0003922202,
-0.0014455096,
0.0030063763,
0.0325510092,
0.0614146404,
0.0121512664,
0.002965475,
0.0403833166,
0.017649265,
-0.0172692798,
0.0229173284,
-0.0508269444,
0.0313946046,
-0.0627797619,
-0.0080560669,
0.0320966244,
-0.001908352,
-0.010060668,
-0.008443174,
-0.0216399543,
-0.0472432412,
-0.0034578789,
-0.0095078396,
-0.0279091708,
-0.010868446,
0.0048190262,
0.0091662081,
0.0331346616,
0.0549989305,
0.0529195443,
0.0018581562,
-0.0193374325,
-0.0292220563,
-0.0152221238,
0.0323626772,
0.0137858884,
0.048329588,
0.0020735841,
-0.0248077884,
0.0252269879,
-0.0364034586,
0.0193667542,
0.0255113803,
0.0120282229,
0.0159082878,
0.024475215,
0.0850953534,
-0.0069909007,
-0.0043306556,
-0.0172289982,
-0.0240599122,
-0.0237256102,
-0.0519737005,
-0.0099503137,
-6.564640772e-33,
-0.001843987,
-0.063412562,
-0.0508745238,
0.0215467121,
0.0229364093,
0.0396231525,
0.0059413174,
-0.0399880521,
0.0083029307,
0.0486882888,
0.0072979536,
0.039065633,
0.0111872209,
0.0071634063,
0.0213839151,
-0.0308634117,
0.0174916387,
-0.0151528921,
-0.0173329823,
0.0367971696,
0.0330062024,
0.0353548564,
0.0507608317,
-0.1115190014,
-0.0138221942,
0.0064452728,
-0.0602291524,
-0.0184334107,
-0.0140341055,
0.0275745001,
-0.0202627219,
0.0420350358,
0.0244489964,
-0.0468630604,
0.0119587937,
0.0157518908,
-0.0584476404,
-0.0261478238,
-0.0785996169,
0.007529933,
0.0288999397,
0.0031661831,
0.0614664443,
0.0033935262,
-0.0125905545,
-0.0599996932,
0.0681125373,
-0.0074232649,
-0.0045542484,
-0.0882393643,
-0.0129087744,
0.0340214521,
-0.0125619648,
-0.0463218763,
0.010248173,
-0.0017010869,
0.0385024585,
0.0290550292,
-0.0514854752,
0.0053529926,
-0.0214390941,
0.0403486192,
0.0229614321,
-0.0056948098,
-0.0647336245,
0.062166933,
-0.0112103494,
0.015751509,
0.0484566614,
-0.0705479756,
0.0324535184,
-0.0048743691,
0.0262303986,
0.0509144291,
0.0836250484,
-0.0164585579,
-0.1129329279,
0.0617058836,
-0.0430339612,
-0.0672676563,
-0.0022962929,
0.0205446072,
-0.0575080365,
-0.0115839867,
0.0150632598,
-0.0604681633,
-0.0192682967,
0.0097709941,
0.016255362,
0.0288723689,
-0.0201672297,
0.0419880226,
-0.015345972,
-0.0597810186,
-0.0891729593,
0.0013294187,
-0.0058851661,
0.0176906418,
0.001968737,
-0.0143625317,
-0.0172023419,
-0.0064725038,
0.0330853872,
0.0086927963,
0.0061492845,
0.007382879,
0.1002013013,
0.0135246599,
-0.041967757,
-0.0093807839,
-0.0040699057,
-0.0130307702,
-0.0263684597,
0.048215922,
-0.0158908684,
-0.0342869945,
-0.0114931446,
0.0437003523,
0.0299418475,
0.0682715699,
-0.0269318111,
0.0378319025,
-0.0366263576,
0.0052548209,
-0.018585192,
-0.0069752242,
0.0087876767,
-0.0212404337,
0.029500654,
-0.0779165775,
0.0013396327,
-0.0062617315,
2.963e-7,
0.0426018983,
0.0078383535,
0.000789576,
-0.04253814,
0.0167980865,
0.0550417528,
-0.0212835278,
0.0774926841,
-0.0061369408,
-0.0848501101,
0.0307662301,
-0.0170298461,
-0.0027103703,
0.0135417199,
-0.0874142647,
-0.0048467387,
-0.0260116477,
0.0063221226,
-0.0262685865,
-0.0519830361,
-0.0042569092,
0.0823083445,
0.0139965704,
-0.063148506,
0.0367172845,
-0.03941999,
0.0304648038,
0.0332847498,
0.0462577492,
-0.0264036283,
0.0441553257,
-0.0083887568,
0.0131349433,
0.038422484,
-0.029288359,
0.0104138758,
0.0467085242,
-0.0340509489,
-0.0352190919,
-0.0344976783,
-0.0082584899,
0.0474500805,
0.0166957136,
-0.0591003448,
0.0323693119,
-0.0326768197,
-0.0426808372,
-0.008371911,
-0.0417686105,
-0.0183031317,
0.0631638914,
0.0013410568,
0.002081987,
0.0267064627,
-0.0026325698,
0.002610004,
0.0128676519,
-0.0560098514,
-0.0073934882,
0.019223433,
-0.0109896166,
-0.0209657215,
-0.0056672599,
0.0137258349,
-0.0116476966,
-0.0631402284,
-0.0030992874,
2.5699608e-34,
0.0495967679,
-0.0048744832,
-0.0220711045,
-0.0308111012,
0.0168385208,
-0.0051650302,
-0.050434947,
-0.008948111,
-0.0094145518,
0.0215742216,
-0.0025388445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14695v2 | A Causal View of Entity Bias in (Large) Language Models | 2023-05-24T03:59:18 | 2023-10-26T19:02:27 | Fei Wang, Wenjie Mo, Yiwei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Entity bias widely affects pretrained (large) language models, causing them
to rely on (biased) parametric knowledge to make unfaithful predictions.
Although causality-inspired methods have shown great potential to mitigate
entity bias, it is hard to precisely estimate the parameters of underlying
causal models in practice. The rise of black-box LLMs also makes the situation
even worse, because of their inaccessible parameters and uncalibrated logits.
To address these problems, we propose a specific structured causal model (SCM)
whose parameters are comparatively easier to estimate. Building upon this SCM,
we propose causal intervention techniques to mitigate entity bias for both
white-box and black-box settings. The proposed causal intervention perturbs the
original entity with neighboring entities. This intervention reduces specific
biasing information pertaining to the original entity while still preserving
sufficient semantic information from similar entities. Under the white-box
setting, our training-time intervention improves OOD performance of PLMs on
relation extraction (RE) and machine reading comprehension (MRC) by 5.7 points
and by 9.1 points, respectively. Under the black-box setting, our in-context
intervention effectively reduces the entity-based knowledge conflicts of
GPT-3.5, achieving up to 20.5 points of improvement of exact match accuracy on
MRC and up to 17.6 points of reduction in memorization ratio on RE. Our code is
available at https://github.com/luka-group/Causal-View-of-Entity-Bias. | [
0.0290265828,
0.0497469641,
-0.0006621737,
0.0821743086,
-0.0050937282,
0.0478127636,
0.0142071592,
-0.0034740455,
0.0165738203,
-0.0543726347,
-0.0185830072,
-0.0088638207,
-0.0164687429,
-0.0151343225,
0.020498652,
-0.0581014045,
0.0656154677,
0.0065862439,
0.0116126267,
-0.0166107304,
0.0055814227,
0.0178939626,
-0.0124266343,
-0.013907739,
0.0148401195,
0.0006038133,
0.0221613534,
0.0269136764,
0.0285648536,
-0.0331473425,
0.0001825304,
0.0420476161,
-0.0089645348,
0.0360816494,
0.0000022155,
-0.0521200858,
-0.0805375353,
-0.0063024801,
-0.0347972624,
0.0287786014,
-0.0158263668,
-0.0195674542,
0.0170688443,
0.0066265003,
-0.0302330181,
-0.0622098856,
0.0284678489,
0.0672951862,
0.0117171686,
0.1020706296,
-0.0225262437,
-0.0234176237,
0.0234987922,
-0.0285837147,
0.0243587866,
-0.0330254026,
0.0277476329,
0.0005402019,
-0.0391871482,
-0.0056872224,
-0.0444702767,
0.0208573416,
0.0357485637,
0.0521206148,
0.0272701327,
0.0438559018,
0.0027800296,
0.0054269,
0.0037726809,
0.0947679281,
0.026709009,
-0.0206373502,
0.0145335943,
-0.0107841082,
0.0004174383,
0.0394832119,
0.0027729191,
-0.0154510979,
-0.0368184447,
0.0317126624,
0.0288336892,
-0.0198739544,
0.0531379655,
0.0426918156,
-0.048682753,
0.0557483174,
0.0536997132,
-0.0516241118,
0.0095270835,
0.0605583712,
0.0099453228,
-0.033502385,
0.0025005841,
0.0054493886,
-0.0270789396,
0.0483687483,
-0.0425874852,
-0.0221906677,
-0.0107004354,
-0.0387973748,
0.0025706429,
0.0642899424,
-0.0069523975,
0.0561041422,
-0.0422464237,
0.0383014716,
-0.0330594815,
0.0429593846,
-0.0231495183,
0.0124069899,
-0.016822245,
-0.0068227542,
-0.0372417085,
0.0248549823,
-0.0111615518,
0.0101185925,
-0.037312787,
0.0200397745,
0.0006304751,
-0.0204381011,
-0.011910053,
-0.006533158,
-0.0239912588,
-0.039412763,
-0.0252625309,
0.0413518324,
-0.0501996167,
0.0195174869,
-0.049390357,
-0.0738364756,
-0.0314414203,
-0.017710194,
-0.0051942924,
-0.0732928365,
-0.0099977329,
0.0908895433,
-0.0078883013,
-0.0651250631,
-0.0494872667,
-0.0246145148,
0.0235276073,
-0.0573972687,
-0.0106323017,
-0.0278162472,
0.042393107,
0.021579342,
0.0206448808,
-0.0427172333,
0.0118845487,
-0.0132111786,
-0.0801472515,
0.0623709969,
-0.0247943401,
-0.0008373404,
-0.0021891643,
0.0319145136,
0.01884019,
0.0788716525,
0.0312118456,
-0.0688184053,
0.0333506539,
-0.0049969875,
-0.0441784896,
0.0476012193,
0.0482968688,
-0.0012284843,
0.0108711878,
-0.0078900587,
0.0191097949,
-0.005973998,
0.0767633989,
0.0130012054,
-0.0454001911,
-0.0280335136,
0.0771927088,
-0.0229478162,
0.0013611671,
0.0290947892,
0.0269205589,
-0.0280627459,
0.0030631376,
0.0525957383,
-0.0614551194,
-0.0005828636,
-0.039111279,
0.0053946581,
0.0273532271,
0.026214486,
-0.026164541,
-0.0197417792,
0.043854896,
0.0291788187,
-0.0260591861,
0.0198758785,
0.0601930581,
0.0110463202,
-0.0555537455,
0.1095785052,
0.0485685654,
-0.0329293013,
0.0212164652,
-0.0044488935,
0.0044441228,
0.0440627299,
0.0614227764,
-0.0337673649,
-0.0458773002,
0.0204198211,
-0.0227796752,
0.0262158383,
0.0351645201,
0.012925338,
0.0376776233,
-0.0648084059,
-0.0662429631,
0.0426090509,
0.0107816253,
0.0352500156,
0.0660126433,
0.0210990738,
0.0271028168,
-0.03199609,
0.0054035061,
0.0396409668,
-0.0153113585,
-0.0538528152,
-0.0237595178,
0.0276087783,
0.0439046137,
0.0376417749,
-0.0205052663,
-0.0262570307,
0.0124362325,
-0.0138050299,
0.008600086,
0.0353508778,
-0.068306081,
-0.0321393684,
0.0112038432,
-0.0166531261,
-0.0231674295,
0.0059770532,
-0.0299960654,
-0.0461879596,
-0.0043836227,
0.0038732311,
0.0781387687,
-0.0166103281,
0.0166896433,
0.0081743244,
0.005229421,
-0.0510555729,
0.0538281463,
0.0014393785,
-0.0072943382,
0.0272713955,
-0.0189257953,
-0.0064634834,
-0.0302354377,
-0.0180696044,
0.0168909244,
0.0320548788,
-0.027631497,
0.0281179696,
-0.0280240737,
-0.0792464688,
-0.0043923943,
-0.0903951228,
0.0016002813,
-0.0106152808,
0.0367312655,
0.0350138657,
0.0472275726,
-0.0316260345,
-0.035067644,
0.0052552163,
-0.0203193985,
-0.026978584,
0.0237394385,
0.0099649783,
0.0075647109,
-0.0180963762,
-0.0202343334,
-0.0117127402,
-0.0436579958,
0.0318304896,
0.0380503908,
-0.0321080759,
-0.058998771,
0.0629982427,
-0.0158781577,
0.0116786845,
-0.0062885527,
0.005655488,
-0.0195925068,
-0.0059553022,
0.0582689829,
0.0606423914,
-0.0260919202,
0.0120379552,
0.0387834981,
-0.0252942163,
-0.0941608101,
0.0136019038,
-0.0132632731,
-0.0199070144,
-0.0305152331,
-0.0318825096,
-0.0116977952,
0.0651866272,
-0.009373622,
-0.0155384662,
-0.0377578996,
-0.0027194442,
-0.0147372577,
-0.0088651935,
-0.0279596467,
0.0028890942,
-0.0186778996,
0.0034874452,
-0.074271284,
-0.0490994975,
0.0806790292,
-0.0092732208,
0.0062353252,
-0.0246532224,
0.0456997342,
-0.0242922436,
0.0394280814,
0.0246222932,
0.0132427178,
-0.0074898438,
-0.0422627069,
-0.087471582,
0.0086925477,
0.0350394137,
-0.0003136042,
0.035473045,
-0.0589789227,
0.0353041254,
-0.0162422415,
-0.0321149752,
-0.0447669774,
-0.0126545522,
-0.0169602092,
-0.0242979582,
-0.0263784528,
0.0049519041,
-0.0009115179,
-0.0253565013,
0.003386457,
0.029829083,
-0.0267278459,
-0.0074583711,
-0.0136931241,
0.0312494934,
0.0178663693,
-0.0211155172,
0.0211657938,
-0.052805528,
0.0065251435,
0.0289496705,
0.0242578983,
-0.0503656976,
0.0001956691,
0.0238651372,
0.0192943551,
-0.0561050139,
-0.0090074269,
-0.0134373298,
0.032297831,
-0.0682416037,
-0.00117886,
0.1273571551,
-0.0037476413,
-0.063633509,
-0.0210023541,
0.0294638276,
0.0527584292,
0.0101305256,
0.0083502913,
-0.0875788033,
-0.0290854666,
0.0032613736,
0.0156911928,
0.0007473515,
-0.0565909147,
-0.0093367528,
-0.1274187863,
-0.0321764462,
0.025744155,
-0.0577174574,
-0.0282887071,
-0.0077151703,
0.0017235031,
-0.0298614744,
0.0352848656,
0.0243317671,
-0.015030697,
0.0154648665,
0.0084595187,
0.0107613476,
-0.0305187013,
-0.0130622257,
-0.0449623987,
0.0524819046,
0.0563776232,
-0.0135379471,
0.0068100956,
0.0383268856,
0.027633097,
0.0080701793,
-0.0264574364,
-0.0167848468,
0.0817911178,
-0.0483045466,
-0.0122142164,
-0.0023816365,
0.0219036974,
-0.0260660965,
0.0118504222,
-0.0033546831,
0.0452611409,
0.0209172927,
-0.010155743,
0.0014944578,
-0.0165146254,
0.0035667361,
0.0792577043,
0.014594622,
-0.0165717266,
-0.054707896,
-0.0017850564,
0.0050027492,
-0.0285316333,
0.0156562012,
-0.0048117102,
-0.0331706032,
-0.0138158388,
-0.0377670601,
-0.0861269161,
0.0207036827,
0.0191356223,
0.032478705,
0.0503015295,
0.0231248438,
-0.0168513972,
-0.0501859002,
0.0405166447,
-0.060628619,
0.0070337807,
-0.0381748341,
-0.0306817461,
-0.0192816816,
-0.0250385255,
-0.0049563283,
-0.0152793694,
-0.0822065398,
-0.0652039722,
0.0032552413,
0.0495824479,
0.0220158268,
0.1138017923,
0.0122635234,
-0.0557730347,
0.007957492,
-0.0030286002,
-0.037217997,
0.0236373916,
0.0075508682,
0.0045457343,
0.0088953869,
0.0323230587,
-0.0351473801,
0.0008826662,
0.0581603721,
0.068672061,
-0.052564133,
-0.0185834747,
0.0048389561,
-0.0042373659,
0.0604433827,
-0.0249058269,
0.0235418659,
-0.0588324592,
0.0494374633,
-0.0375265926,
0.0003121237,
-0.025791062,
0.0008997944,
0.0298648775,
0.0093029933,
-0.0318842344,
-0.0235473812,
-0.0259686373,
0.0164742433,
-0.007028467,
0.0057646581,
-0.0004989147,
0.0072722463,
0.039341148,
-0.0090041533,
0.0003198774,
0.0641548112,
0.031112615,
0.0446401909,
-0.0015504532,
0.0742445216,
0.038888447,
-0.005288031,
-0.0061513735,
-0.0163675826,
-0.0617395118,
0.0155944368,
-0.0093620727,
0.0291361157,
0.0522316247,
-0.0481010117,
0.0629904196,
-0.0310693365,
-0.0001789823,
0.0023260771,
0.0223002899,
0.0101463636,
0.0280297697,
0.0440475941,
0.0166075118,
0.0016597213,
0.0346749462,
0.0909601301,
0.0406809449,
0.0769903883,
-0.0079955468,
0.0026013772,
-0.0206267294,
-0.05042376,
0.0224412121,
0.002281894,
-0.0494472235,
-0.0003544891,
-0.0648274198,
-0.086335808,
-0.0127937552,
-0.0178227797,
0.0101969726,
-0.0179302767,
0.0245565623,
0.0228628125,
-0.0398885123,
-0.0333579667,
-0.011840364,
0.0192991085,
-0.0312557146,
-0.0353793092,
-0.0044268421,
-6.969038012e-33,
-0.0628538132,
-0.0410851687,
0.0275506191,
-0.0250086077,
-0.0146069694,
0.0405907556,
-0.0337803811,
-0.0007859477,
-0.0200286806,
0.019403683,
-0.0174306612,
0.0368754491,
0.0165107623,
0.0020526843,
-0.0146749653,
-0.0153420996,
0.0388647318,
0.0033919613,
-0.0116429459,
0.0120117059,
0.009144797,
0.070842579,
0.0579363704,
-0.0771259889,
0.0532545038,
-0.0175078325,
-0.0000820258,
0.02500958,
0.0000417114,
0.020985296,
-0.0195110925,
0.006742964,
0.0439212695,
-0.0213772934,
-0.0046164677,
0.0118890069,
-0.1459958851,
-0.0290762968,
0.0369201601,
0.0309577398,
-0.0192957725,
-0.0235681254,
0.0319963582,
-0.0011317321,
0.0209081266,
-0.0387024134,
0.0231915023,
-0.0165643264,
-0.0210327897,
-0.0103073427,
-0.0680841208,
0.03701666,
0.0078561809,
0.0314796045,
0.0280666277,
-0.021889044,
0.0175370723,
0.0280396007,
-0.0204226524,
-0.0149272634,
0.0226777922,
-0.0072781914,
0.0314893425,
0.0643509328,
0.0062901969,
0.0473520048,
0.0094637712,
-0.0152530316,
-0.042640619,
-0.0356231108,
0.0249990392,
-0.0091944886,
-0.0098312711,
0.0544182658,
0.0577713028,
0.032416679,
-0.0888663009,
0.0242440179,
-0.0026526975,
0.0242156032,
0.0076479642,
-0.0074320077,
-0.0721139982,
-0.0212554671,
-0.0252764691,
-0.0314902253,
-0.0437579378,
-0.0341972336,
0.0263179019,
0.0046762219,
-0.0300377738,
-0.0319856778,
0.0294085182,
-0.0518095419,
-0.0161016062,
0.0352274291,
-0.0013561524,
-0.020069126,
-0.0149156274,
0.0263672564,
-0.0686750859,
-0.0298437364,
0.006614476,
0.0009408574,
0.0157128442,
0.0121924179,
0.0354654193,
-0.031227883,
-0.0663177148,
-0.011629195,
-0.0381651521,
-0.022853883,
0.0033136299,
0.0239128284,
0.0475321934,
0.0241498873,
0.0104278941,
0.0394031964,
0.0700085163,
0.0027915577,
-0.0090391031,
0.0196078364,
0.0034652145,
0.0259280652,
-0.0113364505,
0.0043911859,
0.0309768002,
-0.0190328341,
0.0109548215,
-0.051975973,
-0.0065982579,
-0.0154227773,
2.887e-7,
0.0505524091,
0.0432343259,
0.0305632018,
0.0256664846,
-0.005939364,
0.0223374795,
0.0225665197,
0.0392016806,
0.0176321901,
0.0095149437,
0.0554588251,
0.043819584,
0.053499613,
-0.0079380674,
-0.0992382988,
-0.0326594338,
-0.0244907867,
0.0146130892,
-0.0467416048,
-0.021187542,
0.057031136,
0.0596229807,
0.0344293676,
-0.0034956424,
-0.0155262817,
-0.0126421414,
0.0591363311,
-0.0582180023,
0.0224392843,
0.0369658135,
0.0058598365,
0.0277990568,
-0.0240104981,
0.0593432821,
-0.0144401323,
0.0166975483,
0.0118466085,
0.0415317379,
-0.0015511742,
-0.0166197885,
-0.0363862962,
-0.0305564217,
-0.0054463781,
-0.0637582168,
0.0578016602,
-0.0110056661,
-0.0199204702,
0.0320915096,
-0.0409931503,
-0.0286163501,
-0.0003672664,
0.0212936345,
-0.0305324197,
0.0327294506,
0.0152421994,
-0.0168499053,
-0.017294351,
-0.0863312706,
-0.027965283,
-0.000479005,
0.0155713568,
-0.0567441098,
-0.0006763515,
-0.0293924063,
0.00346771,
-0.0342152193,
-0.000682421,
2.82338131e-34,
-0.0169284511,
-0.0045962054,
0.0270478614,
0.0346187688,
0.031546142,
-0.0311463047,
-0.0357923433,
0.0113051627,
0.009504253,
-0.0778498352,
0.013185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14693v1 | Have Large Language Models Developed a Personality?: Applicability of Self-Assessment Tests in Measuring Personality in LLMs | 2023-05-24T03:53:43 | 2023-05-24T03:53:43 | Xiaoyang Song, Akshat Gupta, Kiyan Mohebbizadeh, Shujie Hu, Anant Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Have Large Language Models (LLMs) developed a personality? The short answer
is a resounding "We Don't Know!". In this paper, we show that we do not yet
have the right tools to measure personality in language models. Personality is
an important characteristic that influences behavior. As LLMs emulate
human-like intelligence and performance in various tasks, a natural question to
ask is whether these models have developed a personality. Previous works have
evaluated machine personality through self-assessment personality tests, which
are a set of multiple-choice questions created to evaluate personality in
humans. A fundamental assumption here is that human personality tests can
accurately measure personality in machines. In this paper, we investigate the
emergence of personality in five LLMs of different sizes ranging from 1.5B to
30B. We propose the Option-Order Symmetry property as a necessary condition for
the reliability of these self-assessment tests. Under this condition, the
answer to self-assessment questions is invariant to the order in which the
options are presented. We find that many LLMs personality test responses do not
preserve option-order symmetry. We take a deeper look at LLMs test responses
where option-order symmetry is preserved to find that in these cases, LLMs do
not take into account the situational statement being tested and produce the
exact same answer irrespective of the situation being tested. We also identify
the existence of inherent biases in these LLMs which is the root cause of the
aforementioned phenomenon and makes self-assessment tests unreliable. These
observations indicate that self-assessment tests are not the correct tools to
measure personality in LLMs. Through this paper, we hope to draw attention to
the shortcomings of current literature in measuring personality in LLMs and
call for developing tools for machine personality measurement. | [
0.0122988103,
0.0228251386,
-0.0532088988,
0.0268706642,
-0.0343427733,
0.0156860352,
0.0205466095,
-0.0176309198,
-0.0016586558,
0.0039009075,
-0.0566825904,
0.0071323677,
-0.0106323715,
-0.0008985698,
0.0377612971,
-0.0179961808,
0.0596396029,
-0.020273786,
-0.0012235242,
-0.0323568992,
-0.0561640114,
-0.0049723159,
0.0123225478,
-0.0074895923,
0.0315335169,
-0.0330650173,
-0.0107509214,
-0.0267883912,
0.0333375633,
-0.0109388707,
-0.0259070285,
0.0360993035,
0.0133627728,
0.0226364415,
0.0000019211,
-0.0568641238,
0.0103058843,
0.0040416657,
-0.0089582829,
0.0086533548,
0.0634351671,
0.0873042122,
-0.0144019388,
0.0312937684,
-0.0484064557,
-0.0130291553,
0.0166417677,
0.016749125,
0.0219965931,
0.0574784242,
0.0089590028,
-0.008746746,
0.0102596907,
-0.0044973157,
0.0165580865,
0.0348874629,
0.0000741166,
-0.0307290815,
-0.0082625197,
0.0164064001,
0.0080691613,
-0.0270028971,
0.0200274177,
0.042085018,
-0.0418842994,
-0.0160522629,
0.0138949119,
-0.0146537572,
0.0060691913,
0.0221610852,
0.0350224376,
-0.0030433484,
-0.0130471103,
-0.0230750628,
0.0555370785,
0.0326554924,
0.017025562,
0.0416915603,
0.0311087612,
-0.0448169596,
0.04306072,
0.0434911624,
-0.0102141881,
-0.0249465313,
-0.0289923754,
0.0810476914,
0.0029982605,
-0.0182614774,
-0.0082115037,
-0.0129301017,
0.0220226012,
-0.0376022123,
-0.0260316599,
0.0279049054,
-0.0082351416,
-0.0043541016,
-0.0318736285,
0.041631978,
0.0394448563,
-0.0621992759,
0.0374955945,
0.0206615198,
-0.0373730808,
-0.0174333472,
0.0241620056,
0.0805463791,
0.0075820643,
0.06074512,
-0.0579387322,
0.0129850702,
-0.0304202773,
-0.0056322543,
0.0424914062,
0.0241330247,
0.0534582287,
0.0046477299,
-0.0795055628,
0.0549554788,
-0.0386302061,
-0.0095003406,
-0.0079875076,
-0.0036765218,
0.0407494232,
0.0195251685,
-0.0779712945,
-0.0078728646,
-0.0395346582,
-0.0169293769,
-0.008998042,
-0.0286603104,
0.04645155,
-0.0026722467,
-0.0104624974,
-0.0276659932,
0.0715631768,
0.0902712122,
0.0340846889,
-0.0413785018,
-0.0074342084,
-0.0127497641,
0.0113905808,
-0.0709416866,
0.0400761217,
-0.0320231915,
0.004586284,
0.0341410115,
-0.0124263186,
-0.0248994529,
-0.0032129704,
0.0298419148,
-0.0047131297,
0.0203582887,
0.0342376009,
0.0342635438,
-0.01598683,
-0.0112951733,
-0.0041722623,
0.0309561826,
0.0216488261,
-0.0058213761,
0.0538569465,
-0.0641770512,
0.0329658128,
0.0258400813,
-0.0510661826,
-0.0053191036,
-0.0174051039,
0.0111477692,
0.0050858832,
0.0008783698,
0.0456506722,
0.0509495437,
0.003910101,
-0.0094205458,
0.076164566,
0.0470601991,
0.0049373661,
0.03339421,
0.010393397,
-0.0025475931,
0.0397514999,
0.0521617085,
-0.0446337126,
0.0259345602,
-0.0318507329,
0.0362582654,
-0.0134907393,
0.0336394943,
-0.0036858059,
-0.0543489158,
-0.0229520239,
-0.0113710389,
0.0369924009,
0.0463062376,
0.0074516148,
-0.0492562316,
0.0069521042,
-0.0227844603,
0.0070817145,
-0.0530177355,
-0.0557883531,
-0.1034898534,
0.0323378108,
0.0813105032,
-0.0020238366,
-0.0152395638,
-0.0141389193,
0.0300032422,
-0.0630067438,
0.0294588059,
0.0775251761,
-0.028143771,
-0.0117786331,
-0.0029741779,
0.0380539335,
0.0086686602,
-0.0105969664,
0.006207977,
-0.0278691892,
0.0187261235,
-0.0127829006,
0.0321955122,
-0.019346837,
0.0143385138,
-0.0709333941,
-0.0384506471,
0.0026168171,
0.012628179,
0.0435820967,
0.0146328043,
-0.0146270376,
0.0237594191,
0.0387978666,
-0.0020589125,
-0.0081812497,
0.0219342597,
-0.0199951865,
0.0181136299,
0.0150888152,
0.0230503548,
-0.01540682,
0.0420267209,
0.0326290503,
-0.0038763417,
-0.0095923599,
-0.0224847123,
0.0018760656,
-0.0127729103,
0.0569979474,
-0.0538170747,
0.0544455647,
-0.0243904106,
0.0459974781,
-0.0242136084,
0.0428063199,
0.0223708414,
0.0024007196,
0.0032604092,
-0.0534305498,
-0.0443003103,
0.0171909463,
0.0098833656,
0.0324121118,
0.0006924145,
-0.0022895096,
-0.0471499972,
-0.0437920578,
-0.0631667003,
0.0066631134,
0.0304899085,
0.0111680357,
0.0167613532,
-0.0216691755,
-0.034883175,
0.0089935781,
-0.0234930106,
0.0255603436,
0.0543166324,
0.0495295078,
0.0442991927,
-0.0272643194,
-0.0337147489,
-0.0285090525,
-0.0060489252,
-0.0504822657,
-0.0011724518,
-0.0338459983,
0.101451464,
-0.0371245034,
0.0368890613,
-0.0558886006,
0.002308883,
0.0031941566,
-0.0447370596,
0.0687312782,
-0.0146846296,
-0.0038756325,
0.1144223511,
0.0465775467,
0.0377768092,
0.0586148649,
0.0213492885,
-0.0255009234,
-0.0253029875,
-0.0008918809,
0.004096088,
-0.0231501423,
-0.0886113793,
-0.0169962011,
0.044523824,
-0.0058832299,
0.0038773182,
-0.0162449945,
0.069515489,
0.0214151554,
-0.0366772935,
0.0427475087,
0.0310408864,
-0.0410390347,
0.0680155903,
0.029706182,
-0.0387625247,
0.0632038042,
-0.0112569286,
0.0174764954,
-0.0087659704,
-0.0522235595,
-0.0080759553,
0.085011825,
0.0199283101,
-0.0278335549,
0.0473509803,
0.0274764746,
-0.0785972476,
-0.0481354855,
-0.0012897255,
-0.0410176255,
0.0222310871,
0.0046152244,
-0.0502044111,
0.0280982293,
-0.0329943448,
-0.0423270464,
-0.0327428579,
-0.0234165508,
-0.0018541611,
0.034772329,
-0.0543448329,
-0.0224735774,
-0.0367734358,
0.0601076595,
-0.0432689898,
-0.0284926128,
-0.0021498741,
0.0027029568,
-0.0039258632,
0.0594694801,
0.0624276735,
0.0673732758,
-0.0345905498,
0.0103753516,
0.0056790723,
-0.010208983,
0.0148708085,
-0.0107657984,
0.0038033873,
0.0168058667,
-0.0174849816,
-0.0082315765,
0.0320298299,
0.006479736,
0.0107693542,
-0.0070411344,
0.0981021449,
0.0110664489,
0.0223888587,
0.029300835,
-0.0009978631,
-0.0111275967,
0.0479022264,
0.0680574179,
0.0088424375,
0.0163250454,
-0.0228283815,
0.0134110982,
-0.0665815175,
-0.0080711916,
-0.007787542,
-0.1138211563,
0.0091788424,
-0.0178124253,
-0.0667195618,
-0.0172998384,
-0.0195985418,
0.0044339062,
-0.031261798,
0.0180409029,
-0.0050871298,
-0.0179527923,
-0.0127959624,
-0.0211269446,
-0.0357405767,
-0.0101975994,
0.0927611515,
-0.0247588325,
0.0422429144,
0.018405946,
-0.0042422474,
-0.0455410406,
-0.0527497418,
-0.0447895899,
0.0132330181,
0.0265526716,
0.025116371,
0.0207910445,
-0.0261513777,
0.0059485394,
-0.0791347995,
-0.0418874584,
0.0039079869,
0.0245140325,
0.0065370197,
0.0277107861,
-0.0025009417,
-0.0803633854,
-0.0291645974,
-0.0065120049,
-0.0093094315,
0.0529506654,
-0.0161877517,
-0.0845003799,
-0.0105861658,
-0.0244578924,
-0.0276726559,
-0.0066664973,
-0.1022429317,
-0.0048753791,
0.0352355205,
-0.0080985874,
-0.0508909114,
-0.0919864699,
-0.0289031547,
0.0094841421,
-0.0220352449,
-0.0432026349,
0.0166918691,
0.0231474265,
-0.0517838076,
-0.0290744472,
0.0147938933,
0.0022249802,
-0.0580289997,
-0.017031759,
0.0658959523,
-0.0310784895,
-0.0171223916,
0.0208025314,
-0.0297576357,
-0.0443073101,
0.0657656565,
0.0327511504,
0.0218669958,
-0.0098941224,
0.0397320762,
-0.0350472406,
0.0295021832,
-0.0044981334,
-0.0124224043,
0.0845007971,
-0.0049183406,
0.0334491469,
-0.0141889164,
0.0090379259,
-0.0214785263,
0.0137140192,
-0.0119040795,
-0.042669896,
-0.0169405881,
-0.1140706539,
0.0035760333,
0.0497338697,
-0.0080127306,
0.0008294222,
-0.0046761557,
0.0143023841,
-0.0082823467,
-0.030810969,
-0.0149506638,
0.009494829,
-0.07598079,
-0.0026409992,
-0.007953926,
-0.0078796782,
-0.0589187555,
-0.0204767771,
0.0160196535,
-0.0065800059,
0.0179903209,
-0.0038853777,
0.0461535379,
-0.0288926251,
0.0230688304,
-0.0197344143,
-0.0071050492,
0.0034435084,
0.0645029619,
0.0188565645,
0.0827412605,
-0.0451729931,
0.012181541,
-0.02591292,
0.0660577416,
-0.0898994058,
-0.0285768807,
0.0135737099,
-0.0088350493,
-0.0135048283,
-0.0048290417,
0.0314272977,
-0.0271919332,
0.0214713365,
-0.0458303802,
0.0191279929,
-0.0095253708,
0.0007772951,
-0.0064618755,
0.0166175924,
-0.0079508238,
-0.0205445141,
0.0286297388,
0.0381051935,
-0.0065379348,
-0.0225986373,
-0.011170066,
-0.0496079512,
0.0132246856,
-0.0088086314,
0.0052661439,
-0.0170688052,
-0.0564520732,
-0.0643128455,
-0.096670568,
0.0459238552,
0.0544279628,
0.0338337421,
-0.0460832492,
-0.0069031212,
0.0566332154,
-0.0091452468,
-0.035785716,
-0.0292228889,
0.0062680505,
-0.061043743,
0.0092763994,
-0.0336781219,
-5.787121422e-33,
-0.0315095745,
-0.0098956907,
0.0259274766,
-0.0245990586,
0.0165563263,
-0.0602763146,
-0.0020851055,
0.0538383722,
-0.0689550936,
-0.0318913311,
-0.0380007811,
-0.0167560149,
0.0190519411,
-0.0370693393,
0.0357478186,
0.001067986,
0.0202908535,
-0.0415380336,
-0.0138489464,
-0.0196676608,
0.0102888392,
-0.0321021155,
0.0546402708,
-0.0541625917,
0.0194356348,
-0.0562547147,
0.0140989143,
-0.0208575558,
-0.0362243913,
0.0528710112,
0.0038309935,
0.0370150805,
0.0402946547,
-0.0213345699,
-0.0072508655,
0.0223681945,
0.021339871,
-0.0701459795,
-0.010458136,
0.0093162721,
0.006465958,
-0.0689945519,
-3.2e-8,
-0.0142403971,
-0.0859545916,
-0.0325962342,
0.0375704393,
-0.0081317509,
0.0414512344,
0.0661913902,
-0.0139606828,
-0.0220046956,
0.0091096908,
-0.0227710549,
-0.0318003967,
-0.0046512443,
-0.0158491936,
-0.0089669852,
-0.0411061682,
0.084082894,
-0.0352884047,
-0.0110556195,
0.0418792963,
0.0169057567,
0.0212190766,
0.0273408219,
0.0851706341,
0.0654094741,
0.039631784,
-0.0124838268,
0.0307653267,
0.0714054853,
0.0383760221,
0.0336184911,
0.0074855117,
-0.0138700558,
0.0018429401,
0.0250302572,
0.0900613591,
-0.0576454066,
0.0455121025,
-0.0099148508,
-0.0682130754,
-0.0174419023,
0.0060159378,
-0.0394132473,
-0.0279193558,
-0.0453773662,
0.0247773528,
-0.040262077,
-0.000268782,
-0.038478341,
0.0634517521,
-0.0567224771,
-0.026279591,
0.0128088975,
-0.0789365023,
0.0602428839,
-0.0030805902,
-0.0298548155,
-0.0219905432,
-0.0075216251,
-0.007201137,
0.0483939983,
0.051342506,
0.0251477137,
-0.0309606604,
0.0032490417,
-0.0646138862,
-0.0083720936,
0.0293557122,
-0.0337523557,
-0.0069239,
-0.0107103204,
0.0041754181,
0.0076185749,
0.0038539574,
-0.0121505121,
-0.0322151966,
-0.0176001061,
-0.0784950629,
0.0137508167,
0.017728515,
0.0053966376,
0.0345728546,
0.0003834731,
-0.0564825796,
0.0502250344,
0.0161559433,
-0.0037928142,
0.0212567747,
-0.0008020048,
2.651e-7,
-0.043196898,
0.0483688526,
-0.0194979552,
0.0699407086,
0.0211596526,
0.064041242,
-0.0021103912,
-0.0007312192,
0.0464483313,
-0.016424058,
0.001270906,
0.0348553732,
0.0072009251,
0.031665761,
-0.0091343755,
0.0082573909,
-0.0072912448,
0.0398043916,
0.002454343,
0.0261151195,
0.0602807775,
0.0383884907,
0.0143344803,
-0.0038825711,
-0.0231850091,
0.0135277435,
-0.0048686569,
-0.0064997282,
-0.0050477525,
0.0051156143,
-0.0469150431,
0.0024684444,
-0.0058057029,
0.059670262,
0.026352765,
-0.0009134415,
-0.044061061,
0.0536306985,
0.0051411269,
-0.0363291763,
0.0091119967,
0.0165905543,
-0.0130680501,
-0.0082449084,
0.0506155491,
-0.0124896672,
-0.0440390706,
-0.0484909974,
0.0022407318,
-0.0226244815,
0.0387173109,
-0.015974829,
-0.0090834303,
0.0321163721,
0.0077995169,
-0.0242538378,
0.0044492576,
-0.0268609505,
0.0108065037,
-0.0080693169,
-0.0507375523,
-0.1013201252,
-0.0219447762,
0.0179170202,
0.055759266,
-0.0390908867,
-0.0059522162,
2.206045197e-34,
-0.0213242285,
0.0667172596,
0.0021692691,
-0.0196818598,
0.0395090953,
0.0258324016,
0.0068458887,
0.0209269505,
0.0348336473,
-0.0591672175,
-0.0246324632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14688v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14688v1 | ExpertPrompting: Instructing Large Language Models to be Distinguished Experts | 2023-05-24T03:51:31 | 2023-05-24T03:51:31 | Benfeng Xu, An Yang, Junyang Lin, Quan Wang, Chang Zhou, Yongdong Zhang, Zhendong Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The answering quality of an aligned large language model (LLM) can be
drastically improved if treated with proper crafting of prompts. In this paper,
we propose ExpertPrompting to elicit the potential of LLMs to answer as
distinguished experts. We first utilize In-Context Learning to automatically
synthesize detailed and customized descriptions of the expert identity for each
specific instruction, and then ask LLMs to provide answer conditioned on such
agent background. Based on this augmented prompting strategy, we produce a new
set of instruction-following data using GPT-3.5, and train a competitive
open-source chat assistant called ExpertLLaMA. We employ GPT4-based evaluation
to show that 1) the expert data is of significantly higher quality than vanilla
answers, and 2) ExpertLLaMA outperforms existing open-source opponents and
achieves 96\% of the original ChatGPT's capability. All data and the
ExpertLLaMA model will be made publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/OFA-Sys/ExpertLLaMA}. | [
0.0779136494,
0.0335034244,
-0.0111246929,
0.0407163128,
-0.0282985289,
-0.0098360963,
0.0261164308,
-0.0278306976,
0.0451218337,
-0.0344922505,
-0.0329776742,
-0.0178607237,
-0.0399119407,
0.0121033182,
0.0066371309,
-0.0252004806,
0.0373112671,
-0.0471103042,
0.0572208799,
-0.032457605,
0.0168824755,
0.0243263263,
-0.0093030045,
0.0386522748,
0.0031618406,
-0.0428008437,
-0.0155318528,
-0.0264830012,
0.0028686465,
0.0033403588,
0.0331092775,
0.0727610365,
0.0180936344,
0.0294018015,
0.0000019356,
-0.0532908775,
-0.0159592573,
-0.0169242024,
-0.0502932966,
-0.002655226,
0.0065655694,
0.0477814898,
-0.007651356,
0.0287354831,
-0.0608676709,
0.0052173017,
0.0224484317,
0.0255996641,
0.1009449735,
0.0834323466,
0.0189880729,
0.001237275,
0.0523469858,
-0.0172268823,
0.0242108479,
-0.0533841662,
0.0060058655,
0.0187228043,
0.0178736597,
0.0488289073,
0.0142054344,
0.0302389804,
0.0216884464,
-0.0204440001,
0.0254477505,
0.0330409855,
0.0014879183,
0.018584948,
-0.0293384437,
0.0871372148,
0.0158984084,
-0.0039685178,
-0.0131549267,
0.0119690103,
0.0302237254,
0.0121078994,
-0.0388985351,
0.0286279861,
0.0035607945,
-0.0095245019,
0.0352733433,
0.0140667213,
-0.0203619562,
0.011247809,
-0.018401498,
0.0626482815,
0.0169119425,
-0.0372223631,
0.0001633482,
-0.0020591938,
-0.0366405323,
-0.0755430982,
0.0028704929,
0.0392722078,
-0.0786648691,
0.019980222,
-0.022284111,
0.0053413678,
0.0046251779,
-0.0058287266,
0.0039298781,
0.0384770408,
-0.0108888093,
0.0529396608,
-0.000422031,
0.051764749,
0.0093852589,
0.0097176917,
-0.0549196079,
-0.0243568923,
-0.0709908456,
-0.0202698279,
-0.0489494614,
0.0293079261,
-0.011997778,
-0.0040696776,
-0.0308739543,
0.0317390226,
-0.0222347565,
0.0342123695,
0.0178676974,
0.0295175537,
-0.0323165022,
-0.0154947629,
-0.0647660717,
0.0322982781,
-0.0598639399,
0.0062381332,
0.0022576342,
-0.0697879642,
0.0058732782,
0.031613823,
-0.0186128095,
-0.0195549857,
0.0319905244,
0.0641866773,
-0.018569462,
-0.0094986148,
0.0105410563,
-0.0320748799,
0.0103544183,
-0.0702608228,
-0.0099803461,
-0.0686598271,
0.0461242944,
0.0045797578,
-0.0053420966,
-0.0181056913,
0.0042928983,
0.0283692572,
-0.0141418278,
0.048914317,
-0.039311897,
0.0306254569,
0.0412736014,
0.0063387672,
-0.0306550954,
0.0357424393,
0.0216209441,
0.0165037867,
0.0327394493,
-0.0309083071,
0.03686684,
0.0352404527,
0.0028218413,
0.0082879914,
0.0230767149,
0.0531791374,
-0.0095414883,
0.0317682549,
0.0074019618,
0.0497881584,
-0.016566392,
-0.0289480295,
0.0640247017,
0.0602208637,
-0.0167979561,
0.0328770503,
0.0314013958,
0.033744324,
0.0219676197,
0.0304675493,
-0.05774213,
0.0300080162,
-0.0411816426,
0.0040272353,
0.019387437,
0.0169399921,
-0.0333675034,
-0.0250805169,
0.0361546725,
0.0039254525,
-0.0266118739,
0.0596549325,
0.0163712855,
-0.0247650594,
-0.0308583081,
0.024161702,
0.0184298698,
-0.0225171614,
-0.0162212141,
-0.0832851827,
0.0361059941,
0.0745747611,
0.0371408388,
-0.0014214809,
-0.0407663696,
-0.0397102572,
-0.0007925432,
0.027426308,
0.0266929753,
-0.0228877813,
-0.0239202976,
-0.0485393256,
-0.02694631,
-0.0115444781,
-0.0058583715,
0.0408166088,
0.034935236,
0.0030239464,
0.0165373534,
-0.0007926588,
-0.0227851216,
-0.0059630624,
-0.0223712306,
-0.0529488809,
0.0038192426,
-0.0122731691,
0.0273363944,
0.0332317948,
-0.0122244237,
0.0132270288,
0.0225809701,
-0.0026934389,
-0.0264985226,
-0.02580994,
-0.0626145974,
-0.0122662056,
0.0453345962,
-0.0444683805,
-0.0335446671,
0.0095865903,
-0.0302985813,
-0.0459451117,
-0.0193052944,
-0.0242865477,
0.040912915,
-0.0390301272,
-0.0039603566,
0.0280233771,
-0.0299335495,
-0.0459304377,
0.073529169,
0.027785128,
0.0142139494,
0.0574541949,
0.027690785,
0.0058870823,
-0.0743306652,
-0.0045575346,
-0.0053568725,
0.0369491279,
0.0328905806,
0.0373736694,
0.0259896386,
-0.0730903223,
-0.0532842614,
-0.1288716346,
0.0259876251,
-0.018160535,
0.0106174285,
0.038312763,
-0.0088853762,
-0.0227104723,
-0.012508383,
-0.1095223352,
-0.0074845003,
0.0328288488,
0.0053427531,
0.0222181994,
0.0138776442,
-0.0173538886,
-0.0356842466,
-0.0025758187,
-0.0133886896,
-0.0064639645,
0.0353246182,
0.0167485587,
-0.0623282194,
0.0012138359,
-0.0371932015,
0.050921388,
-0.0044170083,
-0.0377269685,
0.0272516292,
-0.0399899594,
0.0215420648,
0.0529390052,
0.0274933614,
0.0191477276,
0.0264002532,
-0.0081299562,
-0.0736559406,
0.0389899798,
-0.0257195942,
-0.0646545365,
-0.011157603,
-0.0244616624,
0.0033986832,
0.0245022587,
0.0111391731,
-0.0219638385,
-0.059949521,
0.0107666999,
0.0153498091,
-0.008609253,
-0.0152936745,
0.0090517588,
0.0004200176,
0.02424163,
0.0040420904,
-0.0512810573,
0.0970793217,
-0.0194505882,
-0.0208588354,
-0.0537145026,
-0.0421463959,
-0.0418458655,
0.0464843735,
-0.0104452381,
0.0225229803,
-0.0112336129,
-0.0106005082,
-0.064850986,
0.0088827191,
0.0197499637,
-0.0443568565,
-0.0056888894,
-0.0478997603,
0.0111739188,
0.016355671,
-0.0211291835,
-0.0520055704,
-0.0415632427,
-0.0492780022,
0.0178650171,
0.0324070491,
-0.0113656353,
-0.0206403285,
0.0018815522,
0.0256903078,
0.0197836272,
-0.0299728625,
0.0066554728,
-0.0394321643,
0.0226396825,
0.0742338598,
0.0300053991,
-0.0329444744,
-0.037119668,
0.0422766246,
0.0363067128,
0.0196973924,
-0.0218073055,
-0.0165861268,
-0.0102623859,
0.0414974988,
-0.047605738,
-0.0228411779,
0.0265617147,
0.014572164,
-0.0401773378,
0.0237317216,
0.1398329437,
0.0272262581,
-0.0655207187,
-0.0235939529,
-0.0023935204,
0.0221816469,
0.0059545678,
0.0503802747,
-0.0809844434,
-0.0389107876,
-0.0287321322,
0.0128471907,
-0.0034479466,
-0.0112614417,
-0.0202060677,
-0.1346992701,
0.0233240724,
-0.0089745373,
-0.0388544686,
-0.0284311082,
-0.0027148728,
-0.0076302225,
-0.0052051204,
0.0198401716,
-0.0050029797,
-0.006095971,
0.0095689446,
0.0165898707,
-0.0006225528,
-0.0263660494,
0.0587838143,
-0.0191980451,
0.1107660532,
0.0900547728,
-0.0042618476,
-0.0125758303,
-0.0388042815,
-0.0143653648,
0.0018809007,
0.0092636188,
0.0140219862,
0.0434773974,
-0.0450539514,
-0.0036024498,
-0.0277084913,
0.0394288711,
0.0024063354,
0.0481712483,
0.0671078414,
0.0744347572,
-0.0125214895,
0.0025647169,
-0.0024395138,
0.001160324,
0.0272363275,
0.0923530236,
-0.0035022902,
-0.0469509959,
-0.0179296825,
-0.0449359193,
-0.0015753127,
0.0255020037,
-0.033160951,
0.0300731566,
-0.0003563015,
-0.0186396111,
-0.0541220941,
-0.0630099103,
0.0690794215,
0.0161106214,
0.019679796,
0.0133500379,
-0.028111035,
0.0262672268,
0.0153331487,
0.0454461612,
-0.0533801876,
0.0166662466,
-0.106975466,
-0.0475060046,
0.0429665856,
-0.0346716605,
-0.0079390453,
0.0147816977,
-0.0447862744,
-0.063918829,
-0.0259464514,
0.0499550514,
0.0271097999,
0.0488222577,
-0.0213518105,
-0.0543004349,
0.0380562395,
0.0067218225,
-0.0638134703,
-0.0192253143,
0.0303741507,
0.0252850875,
-0.0101401908,
0.0358039364,
-0.0361997709,
0.0139182713,
-0.0011583657,
0.0144246407,
-0.0453997515,
-0.0623803921,
0.0440804288,
0.0420302302,
0.0104442919,
0.0170523375,
0.0037166912,
-0.0190517623,
0.03172585,
-0.0213303268,
-0.0244781822,
-0.0278440975,
-0.0053937524,
0.0101226754,
-0.0498065576,
0.0507451594,
-0.012989698,
-0.023156831,
-0.0036930812,
-0.0304729175,
0.0032695022,
0.0100197326,
-0.0039884178,
0.0276082754,
-0.0090307286,
-0.0284127127,
0.00285178,
0.0438220799,
0.0491142608,
0.011005736,
0.084845081,
0.0234835353,
-0.0247628931,
0.0242095329,
0.0242455583,
-0.0642103255,
-0.0970935002,
-0.0058432501,
0.0961398855,
0.0567207485,
0.0176604632,
0.0415713005,
-0.035627313,
0.0104999049,
-0.0255560279,
0.0154192084,
0.0328841098,
-0.0199016761,
0.0442250371,
0.0251500402,
-0.0084754582,
-0.0001070914,
0.0793491304,
0.0017517481,
0.0330669992,
0.0017606617,
-0.0056682271,
-0.0451942869,
-0.0158486683,
0.0079002986,
0.00479818,
-0.0075564659,
0.0374722406,
-0.0218527857,
-0.0452558063,
-0.0636651069,
0.0171500817,
-0.0224227309,
-0.0255747549,
0.0558004901,
0.0570235178,
-0.0342213027,
-0.043079827,
-0.0475286804,
0.003761349,
-0.0124602169,
-0.0350762755,
-0.0337040722,
-6.206188464e-33,
-0.014781313,
-0.0400281064,
0.0412365273,
-0.0268426482,
0.0010506563,
-0.0194032844,
-0.0176861733,
-0.0031804286,
-0.0302277301,
0.001390274,
-0.0382205658,
0.0019832982,
0.0132568916,
0.0127574522,
0.0121331522,
-0.022474099,
0.0322451815,
-0.0030209345,
-0.0169605669,
0.0610703975,
-0.0007559147,
-0.0087318374,
0.0452534594,
-0.0745844916,
0.0494985692,
-0.0481928289,
-0.008102918,
0.0399542153,
-0.0374407917,
0.0511954054,
-0.0203820933,
0.0340793841,
0.0065291924,
-0.0477022119,
0.0131914755,
0.0123120164,
-0.0281183068,
-0.0639486909,
0.0356779285,
-0.0319501013,
-0.0392616205,
-0.0320259444,
-0.0104823839,
-0.0351378396,
0.0010885589,
-0.000537453,
0.0470982231,
-0.0060785622,
0.0140693188,
0.0129469298,
-0.025215162,
0.0140461074,
-0.0219686311,
-0.0235626958,
-0.0128510669,
0.0387125239,
0.0059304577,
-0.0421098806,
0.0127187315,
0.0324284583,
0.0696033165,
0.020291768,
0.0604415648,
0.0087161558,
-0.0112766558,
0.007534029,
0.0179710407,
0.0036085662,
-0.0040623709,
-0.0401588716,
-0.0306531377,
0.0314292759,
0.0486975573,
0.0276024155,
0.0106815547,
0.0148750069,
-0.0358207673,
0.0365206525,
0.0834693611,
0.0233970247,
0.0190432873,
-0.0339607932,
-0.0656375885,
-0.0144498972,
-0.039918717,
0.0251320545,
-0.0356483348,
-0.06140735,
0.0390547067,
-0.0062566386,
-0.0005715874,
-0.0347584151,
0.0157654937,
-0.0440007448,
-0.0092135444,
0.0149193732,
-0.0340094641,
0.01912494,
-0.0090543469,
0.0298225228,
-0.0563356206,
-0.0040661907,
0.0276340209,
-0.0354598425,
-0.0004318997,
0.0425141566,
-0.0044586901,
0.0125706019,
-0.043221157,
0.0123361778,
-0.0286065526,
0.0215779226,
-0.0208491236,
-0.0304714758,
0.0162979346,
0.0074765058,
-0.0078665419,
0.0527185835,
-0.0078248233,
0.0014691905,
-0.042740982,
-0.039040789,
0.0105062658,
-0.0050650728,
-0.0462026335,
0.0370180458,
-0.023267772,
-0.0079588825,
-0.0145204784,
-0.0027132726,
-0.0010270526,
-0.022618467,
2.63e-7,
-0.0140888011,
0.0391841196,
0.0041465242,
0.0466344096,
-0.0055049155,
0.0345902257,
-0.0105169844,
0.0315873362,
0.043789871,
-0.0256824661,
0.0247306302,
0.0409021713,
0.0410817079,
0.027806351,
-0.1054379269,
-0.0544964187,
-0.0485100672,
0.002402182,
-0.0638300627,
0.0204117037,
0.0984922573,
0.0871817172,
0.0160599388,
0.0103683788,
-0.0003201639,
-0.0369675271,
0.029444715,
-0.0365087911,
-0.0112754116,
0.0422933102,
0.0696920678,
0.0089374846,
-0.0184219331,
0.0489828177,
0.024327714,
0.0139487321,
-0.0138127068,
0.086835973,
-0.0105035491,
-0.0068198871,
0.0035887375,
-0.0146175958,
0.0038589705,
-0.0423512012,
0.0720614344,
-0.028202435,
-0.0241994206,
-0.0298197158,
-0.0229120702,
-0.0525548682,
-0.0104456609,
-0.0328622535,
-0.0549462475,
0.0103822956,
-0.0027706509,
-0.0203633327,
-0.0020636946,
-0.0552557334,
0.0113423653,
0.0084843049,
-0.0377764702,
-0.0786157176,
-0.0028406417,
0.0084133428,
0.0122836391,
-0.0458453447,
0.0430663638,
2.365169709e-34,
0.0267621949,
0.0163510796,
0.0251736958,
0.047837425,
0.0521955341,
0.0159459226,
-0.0164755546,
0.0120443655,
0.0638147518,
-0.0823189989,
-0.0381447263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16340v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16340v3 | Segmented Recurrent Transformer: An Efficient Sequence-to-Sequence Model | 2023-05-24T03:47:22 | 2023-10-23T01:44:58 | Yinghan Long, Sayeed Shafayet Chowdhury, Kaushik Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformers have shown dominant performance across a range of domains
including language and vision. However, their computational cost grows
quadratically with the sequence length, making their usage prohibitive for
resource-constrained applications. To counter this, our approach is to divide
the whole sequence into segments and apply attention to the individual
segments. We propose a segmented recurrent transformer (SRformer) that combines
segmented (local) attention with recurrent attention. The loss caused by
reducing the attention window length is compensated by aggregating information
across segments with recurrent attention. SRformer leverages Recurrent
Accumulate-and-Fire (RAF) neurons' inherent memory to update the cumulative
product of keys and values. The segmented attention and lightweight RAF neurons
ensure the efficiency of the proposed transformer. Such an approach leads to
models with sequential processing capability at a lower computation/memory
cost. We apply the proposed method to T5 and BART transformers. The modified
models are tested on summarization datasets including CNN-dailymail, XSUM,
ArXiv, and MediaSUM. Notably, using segmented inputs of varied sizes, the
proposed model achieves $6-22\%$ higher ROUGE1 scores than a segmented
transformer and outperforms other recurrent transformer approaches.
Furthermore, compared to full attention, the proposed model reduces the
computational complexity of cross attention by around $40\%$. | [
0.0205324162,
0.0328887552,
0.0269534513,
0.0163359512,
-0.0081865238,
-0.0072336998,
-0.0209702533,
-0.0222733244,
-0.0508848727,
-0.0257970653,
-0.0169135425,
-0.0451387241,
0.020536745,
0.0516448393,
-0.0019822503,
-0.0978035629,
0.0217502881,
0.00723009,
-0.0213245731,
0.0308561437,
0.0163508393,
-0.0116423089,
0.0380206145,
0.0299593303,
0.0200704373,
0.0144130299,
-0.0104239564,
-0.0299375169,
0.0483489521,
-0.0320222452,
-0.0062412126,
0.0285575762,
0.0340390578,
0.0272034854,
0.0000020754,
-0.0045218775,
-0.0128344605,
-0.0054853288,
0.0132151451,
0.0165801141,
0.0413422994,
-0.0430799685,
0.0130439484,
-0.0067674704,
-0.0112582408,
0.0024600758,
0.0281924028,
0.0890872926,
0.0707618892,
0.0670196861,
0.0010814217,
-0.0793043151,
0.0732021928,
-0.0727245957,
0.016349392,
-0.0351922512,
0.0048395582,
-0.0198487174,
-0.0107463794,
0.0117913093,
-0.0279039275,
0.0609591715,
0.0501736663,
-0.0049763601,
0.0385697521,
0.034218397,
-0.0136133339,
-0.016850207,
0.009082634,
0.0353782661,
-0.0501569994,
0.002266726,
0.023932552,
0.0212271661,
0.011383025,
-0.0438556895,
-0.0800341591,
0.0333395563,
0.0223712511,
-0.0005780841,
-0.0155761782,
0.0363884605,
0.0019231545,
0.0155541301,
-0.0471553281,
-0.0247147419,
-0.0166341476,
0.0081600007,
-0.0628632978,
-0.0051901909,
-0.0246916488,
-0.0494270884,
0.0103428997,
0.0754665658,
0.0130216163,
-0.0016743691,
-0.0607985742,
-0.0751156807,
-0.009923744,
-0.0239233002,
0.0235004388,
0.0275779627,
0.0227956176,
0.0298985709,
-0.0219482183,
0.0322574489,
-0.037906345,
0.0248135347,
-0.0363284834,
0.0060053621,
-0.0350037403,
0.0004164158,
-0.0110747311,
0.0615036339,
-0.0224719699,
-0.0133651877,
-0.0459076874,
0.0338791385,
0.012451455,
-0.0360145047,
0.01066727,
0.015227274,
-0.0525214151,
0.0072274092,
0.007284407,
0.0474452302,
-0.0074189994,
-0.0502706505,
0.0563636832,
-0.0116870133,
-0.0446600616,
0.0052951588,
0.0194994919,
-0.0094277253,
-0.0154638635,
0.0260797702,
-0.0232236013,
-0.045568645,
-0.020260023,
-0.0337687954,
-0.0359886438,
-0.0517126508,
0.0184318125,
-0.0471776389,
0.0161142088,
-0.0136941941,
-0.0272660684,
0.0297506414,
0.0062554241,
0.0431969911,
-0.0359304994,
0.0194367506,
0.0397266932,
-0.041344028,
0.0226964895,
0.0159602482,
0.0492559224,
0.0325311534,
0.0611714832,
0.0697937086,
-0.0151033364,
0.0085089635,
-0.0178438276,
0.0146537749,
0.0321249142,
-0.0029759204,
-0.0258335304,
-0.0314453319,
-0.0569071956,
-0.0014119387,
0.0449511781,
0.0325518027,
-0.0252203345,
-0.0108634811,
0.0731180981,
0.0268199015,
0.0284066945,
0.0473078005,
0.0061971522,
0.0283645149,
-0.0272101369,
0.0102750426,
-0.0343600735,
0.1072499603,
-0.0092774834,
0.0451362878,
0.0552244522,
0.0239466261,
-0.0330054983,
-0.0224931408,
0.016151784,
0.0032553535,
0.0074872747,
0.0054356493,
0.0358690023,
0.0187741593,
-0.0445783846,
0.0681477711,
-0.0262929294,
-0.0652805343,
0.014986,
-0.036799971,
-0.0095380107,
0.0075994977,
0.0484527275,
-0.0356215946,
-0.0380490497,
-0.0365017503,
-0.0059742006,
0.0333318524,
0.0083410786,
0.0104804579,
-0.0295299347,
-0.0674505904,
-0.0259482954,
-0.0207245816,
-0.0346123949,
0.0023414623,
0.0043630134,
0.0002889639,
0.0403211936,
-0.0186394509,
-0.0098559307,
0.0142571451,
0.002216243,
-0.0151117789,
0.001226654,
-0.0174862277,
0.0416387133,
0.0080102673,
0.0173296854,
0.0327608436,
0.0542724654,
-0.0448100269,
-0.0239793751,
0.0034524407,
-0.0542505756,
-0.0085277464,
0.0292495564,
-0.027275959,
0.0105769215,
0.0494662896,
-0.0564685501,
-0.0382128656,
0.0473818816,
-0.0508654639,
-0.0096132094,
-0.0217238944,
0.0005002518,
0.0514833443,
0.0416534431,
-0.0093460828,
0.0506366789,
-0.0564073548,
0.0090720756,
0.0047848034,
-0.0301300362,
-0.0383316614,
-0.0256679785,
-0.0145829003,
-0.0086552184,
-0.0311294813,
0.0023200286,
0.0345018357,
-0.0265655462,
-0.0122507839,
-0.0324686468,
-0.0365420505,
-0.0061334204,
-0.0140175335,
0.0238553435,
0.0161567833,
0.0279996917,
0.0420271456,
-0.0051646936,
-0.049605526,
-0.020913722,
-0.0004094084,
0.0269241873,
0.0346053392,
-0.0007113797,
0.0314942263,
-0.0413486101,
-0.0393184945,
0.0099937674,
0.048109863,
-0.0066648689,
-0.0595910363,
-0.0027468163,
-0.0168505292,
-0.0113473283,
-0.0134216538,
-0.0131961936,
-0.0215194039,
-0.0398228467,
-0.0276703276,
0.0505167916,
0.04873164,
0.0661414042,
0.0236165263,
-0.0045466856,
-0.0234914348,
0.0027055161,
0.0332690291,
-0.0396249145,
0.026650846,
0.005022143,
-0.026023576,
0.0337571241,
0.0835399628,
-0.0332977511,
0.0222263616,
-0.0208331458,
-0.027362626,
-0.0009205942,
-0.0168203432,
0.0024088398,
-0.0244967118,
-0.0234749727,
-0.003999271,
-0.0280783307,
0.0170629527,
0.0360671729,
-0.0002309772,
-0.0000759699,
-0.0437620841,
0.0189917609,
-0.0543898754,
0.0539044216,
0.0251639895,
0.0119311251,
-0.0008837042,
-0.0110135637,
-0.0209061876,
0.0031980067,
-0.0103587983,
-0.0224825926,
0.1241952255,
-0.0084258821,
0.0139337098,
-0.0444936864,
-0.0069360905,
-0.0281570591,
0.0066024233,
0.0012700991,
0.023607634,
0.0369827673,
-0.0250791814,
-0.0879262462,
0.0476428904,
0.0662301555,
0.0746041462,
-0.0292097349,
-0.0095790597,
0.0076353587,
0.0699526295,
0.0436328202,
0.0183047783,
0.0108188149,
-0.0481215045,
0.0030584424,
0.062027175,
0.0524403192,
-0.0231789444,
-0.0141648687,
-0.0305311345,
-0.0025388508,
-0.0461505242,
0.0108493641,
0.0017917319,
0.0298208892,
-0.0924338549,
-0.0084204394,
0.0838262141,
0.0014315791,
-0.0462422706,
-0.0239153281,
0.0374745913,
-0.0091714505,
0.0125899203,
0.0015116732,
-0.0503905267,
-0.0259186998,
-0.0029191053,
-0.0011344384,
0.040543355,
-0.0316723697,
-0.0016243373,
-0.0681618378,
0.0403084792,
-0.002600882,
-0.0658726841,
-0.0342806429,
-0.0237014741,
-0.007840733,
-0.0101015745,
0.0022911876,
0.0199535042,
-0.0207682531,
-0.0207578819,
0.0253674462,
-0.0305124894,
0.0030114788,
-0.0108222896,
0.0041739116,
-0.0486235954,
0.0606169254,
0.0244580768,
-0.0089095077,
-0.0013571426,
0.0196956825,
-0.0141817443,
-0.0071884585,
0.0217032731,
0.064110145,
-0.0115554146,
-0.0001290517,
-0.0200299136,
0.0212466437,
-0.0197995473,
-0.0109835519,
-0.044949986,
0.0340742804,
0.0124930926,
-0.0241560955,
-0.0783245713,
0.0173393711,
-0.047902137,
0.0437123068,
0.0241404213,
-0.0193013828,
-0.0222454835,
0.0060586133,
-0.0025051972,
-0.0768590942,
-0.0528798029,
-0.0111322273,
0.0133070778,
-0.0866347328,
-0.0901932046,
-0.0433211103,
-0.0171757247,
0.0033361639,
-0.0137060005,
-0.061621096,
0.0230835769,
-0.0075269295,
-0.0687417611,
0.0170595925,
-0.0221715905,
-0.0100805052,
-0.0600834042,
0.0273519158,
0.0469505414,
-0.0207722243,
-0.0360227637,
0.0258973185,
-0.1454768479,
-0.021073956,
0.0055189305,
0.053882923,
0.008851408,
0.0306091923,
-0.0022916745,
-0.0014768897,
0.0762017965,
0.0313628204,
0.001434566,
0.0245724879,
0.0196694471,
-0.0189560056,
-0.0125304339,
0.0040843496,
-0.0566913597,
0.0522264615,
0.0029596102,
0.032583598,
-0.0383170061,
-0.0441449657,
-0.013293379,
-0.0261043143,
0.0100533785,
0.024948936,
0.0517183989,
0.0142919375,
0.011185769,
0.0354655944,
0.0134669933,
-0.0410116613,
0.0038544857,
0.0014189528,
-0.0090205884,
0.0063894722,
0.0643601418,
0.029842278,
-0.0361653455,
-0.0296128541,
0.0022976357,
-0.0379509777,
-0.0241174009,
-0.0294911768,
0.0202850513,
-0.0455412902,
-0.0485385694,
-0.0159389768,
0.015777044,
-0.0074488451,
0.038931381,
0.030435998,
0.0415105596,
-0.0182343833,
0.057823658,
-0.1051849276,
0.0280065071,
-0.0525951907,
-0.0189525131,
0.0343942456,
-0.0349784307,
0.0558184795,
0.0082420642,
0.0038691824,
-0.0485347547,
0.0175290834,
0.0144881839,
-0.0134382341,
0.0020825865,
0.0303487014,
0.0091747344,
-0.0062052235,
0.0897091627,
-0.0512174591,
0.0095156273,
0.0290931128,
-0.0004557765,
-0.0293103773,
-0.0275524911,
-0.0217564609,
-0.0001408882,
0.0031620422,
-0.0224220268,
-0.0263196863,
-0.0274651442,
0.0968484581,
-0.0302858911,
0.0360092968,
-0.0204944983,
0.0416235104,
0.019849997,
0.0127867963,
-0.0041669104,
-0.0106300479,
0.0326781459,
0.0105672982,
-0.039053794,
-0.00519562,
-6.625412361e-33,
-0.0160466414,
0.0044678194,
-0.026814105,
0.0180308986,
-0.0540739857,
0.0220417008,
-0.0754222795,
-0.0186974164,
0.0011789245,
-0.0122875236,
-0.0140487244,
0.0121566365,
0.0074994564,
0.0413347036,
0.0377154239,
-0.0143070351,
0.0811152831,
0.0148872724,
-0.0165361594,
0.0530840941,
0.031893108,
0.0190739427,
0.0670677796,
-0.0060234843,
0.0084095141,
0.0114008691,
-0.006940241,
-0.0268787984,
0.0376475751,
0.0460291803,
-0.020812938,
0.0129095735,
0.0360741727,
-0.0720120817,
-0.0624065362,
0.0245025922,
-0.0999000371,
0.0063597471,
-0.0234738328,
-0.031003058,
-0.0391519405,
-0.0296783298,
0.0631927624,
0.0168324001,
0.049429521,
-0.0638205707,
0.0415270142,
-0.0222910941,
-0.0697645545,
-0.0735079274,
-0.0307596512,
0.0209029578,
-0.030766977,
-0.0487590842,
0.0379068851,
0.043715708,
0.0034452737,
0.0544582456,
-0.0948387608,
0.0236902889,
0.0306272358,
0.0797146708,
0.0518246442,
0.0177838225,
-0.0026875362,
0.0168914087,
-0.0033634263,
0.0008056349,
-0.0250409506,
0.0125583299,
0.0260581095,
0.01572036,
0.0582138337,
-0.0138986595,
0.0557760112,
0.0157208387,
-0.041735217,
0.0301629622,
-0.0099918498,
0.0940850899,
0.0388766155,
0.0368927717,
0.0266030859,
0.0162773412,
0.0225517396,
0.0182270054,
-0.0443397015,
-0.0063456628,
-0.0070330114,
0.0578034408,
-0.0038953607,
0.0514149815,
0.0424940288,
-0.000723199,
0.021663893,
0.0126677928,
0.0295085162,
0.0435119309,
0.0045397463,
-0.0229533613,
-0.0459077284,
0.0560481139,
0.0337239914,
-0.0026420814,
-0.0447088666,
0.0016589545,
0.0605174787,
0.0434820615,
-0.0344525129,
-0.034073405,
-0.012839538,
0.0335239545,
-0.0281097684,
0.0929387137,
0.0212683901,
-0.0044776513,
-0.0162825361,
0.0760916099,
-0.0412691906,
-0.0126225259,
-0.0135586215,
0.0451174825,
0.036045365,
0.0325618163,
-0.0162899178,
-0.0071607661,
-0.0427909456,
0.0374748558,
0.0029178998,
-0.0495886765,
-0.0314109772,
0.0227856319,
2.893e-7,
0.0383877866,
0.0152538884,
0.0588378049,
0.005744033,
0.010266616,
0.0396713577,
0.0273101218,
0.0534704514,
0.023537457,
0.0104723154,
0.010605799,
0.013775181,
0.0340278037,
0.0117428154,
-0.0800902843,
-0.0378110334,
-0.0868164822,
-0.0094986875,
-0.001167719,
-0.0286127198,
0.0085737864,
0.1026275307,
0.0169872306,
-0.001753893,
0.0228288248,
-0.0111886477,
0.0316294543,
0.0190770235,
-0.0469878912,
0.0138531271,
0.006825103,
0.0306712314,
-0.0362982191,
-0.0357162878,
-0.0470273383,
-0.0085325576,
0.0259372164,
0.0405357182,
-0.0150738377,
-0.046333719,
0.0242624488,
0.0119765848,
0.0168382395,
-0.0004869932,
0.0309030768,
-0.1009497344,
-0.0140082231,
-0.0114574786,
-0.010478057,
0.0315358564,
-0.0263279174,
0.0037439838,
-0.0343966447,
0.040831089,
-0.0057874536,
-0.0133393155,
0.0012954932,
-0.1060294583,
-0.0285193752,
0.0036188683,
-0.025234418,
0.0057632467,
-0.0715559348,
-0.0239397287,
0.0133790318,
-0.0006670344,
-0.0509451702,
2.763761936e-34,
0.0682116002,
-0.0069087027,
-0.0304422658,
0.0195812751,
0.0085735777,
-0.0125762885,
-0.0364296436,
-0.0092799393,
-0.0015935218,
-0.0779823735,
-0.0476234742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14682v1 | TACR: A Table-alignment-based Cell-selection and Reasoning Model for Hybrid Question-Answering | 2023-05-24T03:42:44 | 2023-05-24T03:42:44 | Jian Wu, Yicheng Xu, Yan Gao, Jian-Guang Lou, Börje F. Karlsson, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hybrid Question-Answering (HQA), which targets reasoning over tables and
passages linked from table cells, has witnessed significant research in recent
years. A common challenge in HQA and other passage-table QA datasets is that it
is generally unrealistic to iterate over all table rows, columns, and linked
passages to retrieve evidence. Such a challenge made it difficult for previous
studies to show their reasoning ability in retrieving answers. To bridge this
gap, we propose a novel Table-alignment-based Cell-selection and Reasoning
model (TACR) for hybrid text and table QA, evaluated on the HybridQA and
WikiTableQuestions datasets. In evidence retrieval, we design a
table-question-alignment enhanced cell-selection method to retrieve
fine-grained evidence. In answer reasoning, we incorporate a QA module that
treats the row containing selected cells as context. Experimental results over
the HybridQA and WikiTableQuestions (WTQ) datasets show that TACR achieves
state-of-the-art results on cell selection and outperforms fine-grained
evidence retrieval baselines on HybridQA, while achieving competitive
performance on WTQ. We also conducted a detailed analysis to demonstrate that
being able to align questions to tables in the cell-selection stage can result
in important gains from experiments of over 90\% table row and column selection
accuracy, meanwhile also improving output explainability. | [
0.0377448946,
0.0199959558,
-0.0172156505,
0.0119927749,
-0.044474192,
0.0511938334,
-0.0003104062,
0.0124196503,
-0.0018439993,
0.0024352367,
-0.0105478689,
-0.0040605213,
-0.0237049963,
0.0042201593,
0.0113831097,
0.0239700601,
0.0671830103,
0.0198311824,
-0.0210202467,
0.0205110665,
0.0284153782,
0.0003964808,
-0.0351200365,
0.0057557011,
-0.0024087399,
-0.0091340384,
-0.0360964872,
-0.0181385875,
0.000713582,
0.0158408545,
0.021759117,
0.0702876598,
0.0135176005,
0.0185761303,
0.0000017927,
0.0046711816,
-0.0571716242,
-0.017759718,
-0.0582661442,
-0.0347964019,
-0.0082678078,
0.0178578068,
0.0295663103,
-0.0098509211,
-0.0482330881,
0.0041263406,
0.0123755531,
0.0731567889,
0.0322306566,
0.0147779994,
0.0222158581,
-0.0309354141,
0.0159075204,
0.0405545272,
0.0776059031,
-0.032857582,
-0.0003569128,
0.0420007147,
0.0458139591,
-0.0177181792,
0.0392177776,
0.0369141325,
0.0459579192,
-0.0176858585,
-0.0009760116,
0.0193549246,
-0.044433888,
0.025664147,
0.0225820839,
0.1115766987,
0.0505377017,
-0.0475825444,
0.0162617154,
0.0061869617,
0.0292775743,
-0.0053719678,
-0.0448565297,
-0.0168974977,
-0.0359087326,
-0.0220157076,
0.0298471209,
0.021584928,
-0.0153505923,
-0.0000181075,
-0.0364387929,
0.0709787682,
-0.0263506565,
-0.0551908985,
0.0062555079,
-0.0149563188,
0.0036043192,
-0.0218617003,
0.0370505303,
0.0683410093,
-0.0238941144,
0.0274653267,
0.0106455283,
-0.0352808572,
0.031688299,
-0.0288756918,
-0.0256268494,
0.040441066,
0.0029795102,
0.0431108214,
-0.0308460072,
0.0222175717,
-0.0226466861,
0.0252994094,
-0.0463700853,
-0.0396718495,
-0.0452989563,
-0.0077300547,
-0.030123258,
0.032203842,
-0.0571237914,
-0.0105309384,
0.0317610763,
-0.0029347595,
0.0152780013,
0.0293282382,
0.0016997519,
0.0226715133,
-0.024075808,
0.0085092168,
-0.0334384218,
0.0080994023,
-0.0804000869,
0.012299099,
-0.0021967103,
-0.0443512313,
-0.0362782106,
-0.0180389304,
0.031625241,
-0.0353804976,
0.0189988371,
0.0471428707,
-0.0577543266,
0.0027947705,
-0.0063645169,
-0.0387136005,
-0.0353245623,
-0.0481217019,
-0.0057163895,
-0.027425101,
0.0566581078,
0.0210464466,
-0.0284609739,
-0.0084928069,
0.0151143558,
0.0763000175,
-0.0158929564,
0.0524695702,
0.0031618944,
-0.0091143204,
-0.003924238,
-0.0006389476,
-0.0223105177,
0.0576318912,
0.0160011686,
0.0096569257,
0.0019552531,
-0.0055316552,
-0.0207793042,
-0.0187389255,
0.0429466441,
-0.0172022283,
0.0400112793,
0.0995610878,
0.0131137613,
0.0378848016,
-0.0496809334,
0.0062571694,
-0.0218414869,
0.0188093428,
0.0269501861,
0.0463168211,
0.0161512848,
0.0390015878,
-0.0368008092,
-0.0082425224,
0.0549194068,
0.0257223826,
-0.0220597945,
0.0613188259,
-0.0236939527,
0.0190643147,
0.0290392898,
0.0255951844,
-0.0244861469,
-0.0501762703,
-0.019684216,
0.0350474194,
-0.0275874268,
0.0209297352,
0.0215760469,
0.0254720598,
-0.0513229147,
0.0294668693,
0.0229574852,
-0.0682443753,
-0.032377094,
-0.0129519841,
0.0900686234,
0.0324553736,
0.0505448505,
-0.084473148,
-0.0371243954,
-0.0005586273,
0.0204708371,
-0.006945617,
-0.0032350658,
-0.0387576036,
-0.0121949092,
-0.0274475086,
-0.0253532566,
0.0012766524,
0.0028797423,
-0.0472882614,
0.0152495475,
0.0180280749,
-0.0164638516,
-0.0827619806,
0.0083855363,
0.0437841378,
0.0706935525,
0.0129446825,
-0.027400896,
0.0090188012,
0.018277334,
0.0262814034,
0.0228031948,
0.0129571781,
0.0278260838,
-0.0214644205,
0.0106121358,
0.0002537693,
-0.0602759272,
-0.049698934,
-0.0045027724,
0.0295583084,
-0.0448214673,
-0.0060933246,
-0.0265483335,
-0.0384737216,
-0.0366296023,
-0.0284134168,
-0.0369366184,
-0.0250038616,
-0.023017874,
0.0068527651,
-0.0227123797,
-0.0429736674,
0.0974444896,
0.0091009531,
0.0229612645,
-0.0175760798,
-0.0824135616,
0.0129170818,
-0.0229783393,
0.0377049595,
0.0055168355,
-0.0288228523,
0.0074933884,
-0.0017823575,
-0.0019427064,
-0.0728440955,
-0.0005647071,
-0.066564478,
0.0529353619,
-0.048996523,
0.018985441,
0.0394733623,
0.014692477,
0.0036767975,
-0.0225930363,
-0.0679029971,
0.0198360495,
-0.0035155644,
0.0143970195,
0.049347207,
0.0115982024,
0.0427451022,
-0.0381231345,
-0.0217280742,
-0.0114104105,
0.0477782004,
-0.001374962,
-0.0032152208,
0.0250945352,
-0.0366696604,
-0.0199080389,
-0.0163246132,
0.0073805088,
-0.0013943398,
-0.0002179279,
-0.032827165,
-0.0214776099,
0.0553052463,
-0.0393590592,
-0.005293177,
-0.0130485538,
0.0092962924,
-0.0476012081,
0.0557744689,
-0.0042488053,
0.0479169637,
0.0373847634,
-0.0535943545,
0.0325229466,
0.0285661928,
-0.0177920517,
0.0032245596,
-0.0400613658,
0.0408314392,
0.0164237991,
0.0211735182,
-0.0684135929,
0.0481922999,
0.0140006952,
0.0482945777,
-0.0481663644,
0.0111987768,
0.049617108,
-0.0039332411,
0.0124413697,
-0.0687271506,
0.0175801534,
-0.0579959713,
0.0636279881,
-0.0176093597,
-0.0215381086,
-0.003636352,
-0.0012359751,
-0.0265499558,
-0.0114943618,
-0.0041885935,
-0.0348531567,
0.0850924626,
-0.0353550166,
0.0264637712,
-0.0091021173,
-0.0358062685,
-0.0173227638,
-0.0216237195,
-0.0130397147,
0.0072541903,
0.0001743198,
-0.0109747425,
-0.0122502614,
-0.0017552412,
0.0521192253,
0.023532318,
-0.0384026021,
0.0022119433,
-0.0370740891,
0.0795708001,
0.04434558,
0.0294236261,
0.0057209684,
-0.0035425846,
0.0370305069,
0.0684404597,
0.0115957418,
-0.0241581798,
0.0335893594,
0.0142708588,
0.0126068229,
-0.029328404,
0.004195787,
0.018561922,
0.0415147394,
-0.073975578,
-0.0179056339,
0.0554172881,
0.0577234589,
0.0212183744,
-0.0214447863,
-0.0245066918,
0.016762618,
-0.008761487,
0.0678241625,
-0.0875199288,
-0.050100226,
0.0020576359,
-0.0021433206,
0.0073232059,
-0.0509492457,
0.0239643529,
-0.0568134859,
0.0117032193,
-0.038225852,
-0.0726416185,
-0.0716159418,
-0.0331147499,
0.0362164788,
-0.0204666499,
0.0152339619,
0.0572983362,
-0.0039782305,
0.0297576338,
0.0069992547,
-0.0278038848,
0.0128454044,
0.0108622862,
-0.035075441,
-0.006626769,
0.0568717532,
0.0227541234,
-0.000690296,
-0.0324229226,
-0.0295332205,
-0.0678118169,
0.0140208472,
-0.0080774184,
0.0392885804,
0.0186008364,
0.0039037014,
-0.0427111723,
0.0305084959,
-0.0305727012,
-0.0113921007,
0.0330184586,
0.0741513744,
-0.0241359416,
-0.0010571945,
0.0067840633,
-0.0023683673,
-0.0118367821,
0.0841023251,
0.0302960388,
0.0226308685,
-0.0806517452,
-0.0070228614,
-0.0632354096,
-0.0825958103,
0.0355024338,
0.0368333384,
0.0154444063,
0.0520135984,
-0.0653681979,
-0.033818692,
0.0773137957,
0.0303292647,
-0.0284611434,
0.0506730564,
-0.0554051027,
0.0048400499,
-0.0502621233,
0.0009813692,
-0.0315902643,
0.0127390157,
0.0225567706,
-0.001855489,
-0.0100058485,
-0.0612376295,
-0.0263550635,
-0.0052911863,
-0.0178142302,
0.0004968758,
-0.0145720895,
0.0074495766,
0.0111263162,
0.0034998625,
0.007712096,
0.0015254222,
0.0118313571,
-0.0143437386,
-0.0624551848,
-0.0290348455,
0.0013435226,
-0.0365967005,
-0.0045064632,
0.0408303179,
-0.0266737267,
-0.0266454779,
0.004400223,
0.062007457,
-0.0262049623,
0.0335214175,
0.0369690731,
-0.0303327031,
-0.0362087898,
0.0934052542,
-0.0615557283,
-0.0229081586,
0.0487314761,
-0.0131535931,
-0.0372204967,
0.0252585001,
0.0028889258,
-0.0134893665,
-0.0365947224,
-0.0029274754,
0.0156239774,
-0.0017138754,
0.0622903928,
-0.0416138433,
0.0089646205,
0.0442334525,
0.0007523852,
-0.0144780073,
-0.0320144109,
-0.0287027098,
-0.0130963009,
0.0039449767,
0.0531633608,
-0.0078680897,
0.0386485681,
0.0266578067,
-0.0474648774,
-0.029848218,
0.0410636216,
-0.1097678617,
-0.0306661222,
0.0069888239,
-0.0100652138,
-0.0138584943,
-0.0015074383,
0.006700444,
0.0333158858,
-0.0345756859,
0.0447341241,
-0.0040490916,
0.0583974533,
0.0238523502,
0.0429048575,
0.0144013632,
-0.0083306944,
-0.0086819539,
0.0319788009,
-0.0037067311,
0.0330584273,
0.0089954427,
-0.0348903127,
-0.0391755253,
-0.0126821306,
-0.0049091484,
0.032428164,
-0.0100087319,
-0.022146754,
-0.0324359611,
-0.0100436164,
0.0545267314,
0.0283856336,
-0.0536739454,
0.0064299777,
0.0368482471,
0.0628606454,
0.0650926977,
-0.0601765253,
-0.029879896,
0.034412235,
-0.0259356909,
-0.0151333846,
-0.0044220984,
-6.142267652e-33,
-0.0103296703,
0.0078690397,
0.0076019275,
-0.0641462505,
-0.0005758669,
0.0020298411,
-0.0379599147,
-0.0547558367,
-0.0498750843,
0.0210999623,
-0.0349840708,
0.0308360793,
0.0068250839,
-0.002855723,
-0.0326189883,
-0.072418645,
-0.0136436848,
-0.0113448417,
-0.015279673,
0.0308811832,
0.0343082212,
0.0162167381,
0.0015582322,
0.0225357395,
0.0530494563,
-0.0108481348,
0.0280657001,
-0.0011870983,
-0.0381049775,
0.050414335,
-0.0284835044,
0.0018088872,
0.0534959249,
-0.0383975208,
-0.0093769263,
0.0338464938,
-0.1479640454,
-0.0443049856,
0.0119593078,
-0.0153327473,
-0.0744021833,
-0.026637204,
-0.0061387592,
-0.0022854742,
0.0257839616,
-0.0328654163,
0.0221260991,
-0.0204054732,
0.0039824373,
-0.0351648852,
-0.0177884679,
0.0087158578,
-0.0400201194,
0.0073400401,
-0.0080571491,
0.0693926215,
0.0220483541,
0.0121096419,
-0.0410955995,
-0.0094241016,
0.017076632,
0.0021901755,
0.0244451649,
-0.0256480779,
-0.0011893723,
0.0302167218,
0.0121633541,
-0.0224753488,
-0.0628313795,
-0.0035280141,
-0.0647990853,
0.0512736998,
0.1037019417,
0.0197696853,
0.0299170148,
0.048971694,
-0.0803015456,
0.0454042964,
0.0172227621,
0.0494342335,
-0.0135800578,
-0.0147404997,
-0.0425251536,
-0.0012629543,
-0.0382542722,
0.0286287349,
-0.0391574949,
-0.0006986568,
0.0147483181,
-0.0341662243,
-0.0013302311,
0.0253410842,
0.0139392428,
0.0264701769,
0.0202576518,
0.0380917676,
-0.0015666147,
0.0148444902,
0.0207087547,
0.0446954407,
-0.0369956493,
0.007602728,
0.0288751628,
-0.0386114754,
0.0102179656,
0.0269506574,
0.0444859415,
-0.0134164719,
-0.0344301537,
-0.0137520786,
-0.0430919044,
0.027865909,
-0.003542044,
-0.0048834356,
0.0231102686,
0.0417195372,
0.0139888711,
0.0556711964,
0.0273696464,
0.0020012544,
-0.0379371792,
-0.0150865829,
-0.0211757552,
-0.0127010848,
0.0270703882,
0.0143027231,
-0.034941718,
0.0275594704,
-0.062034376,
-0.068537809,
0.0209585223,
0.072063528,
2.329e-7,
0.0669682026,
-0.012605885,
0.0355193913,
0.0324956216,
-0.0064838245,
-0.0005522284,
0.0273069683,
-0.0045170705,
-0.0128914546,
-0.0470512919,
0.0223755427,
0.026464399,
0.0454838127,
0.0322422236,
-0.0338220038,
-0.0395419784,
-0.0564092584,
-0.0314540267,
-0.0650520474,
-0.0054039476,
0.0789928138,
0.055736132,
-0.0612839349,
-0.0012131215,
-0.0279619675,
-0.0132193789,
0.0180846117,
-0.0128816525,
0.048896011,
0.0326860212,
0.0336483307,
-0.0608016774,
-0.0010298702,
0.062823616,
-0.0072792638,
0.0136459656,
0.0110233147,
0.0201311,
0.0036867184,
-0.0243947636,
-0.0317041762,
-0.066651985,
0.0434498563,
-0.0817104653,
0.1493569165,
-0.0264412072,
0.0120275803,
0.074186042,
0.0033988045,
0.0066398601,
-0.0153803565,
0.0335677974,
-0.0122129302,
0.025464708,
0.0140140522,
0.0002465908,
0.0216295552,
-0.0758650824,
-0.0057136226,
0.0134915411,
-0.0110648908,
-0.0079041496,
-0.0266674049,
-0.0392254703,
0.0031763166,
-0.0709187835,
-0.0363715813,
2.088819023e-34,
0.0126119126,
-0.0129889743,
0.0364827998,
0.0399516076,
0.04612289,
-0.0285588652,
0.0337761343,
-0.0324769765,
0.0341152437,
-0.1121401563,
-0.0049937195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14681v2 | Emergent inabilities? Inverse scaling over the course of pretraining | 2023-05-24T03:42:43 | 2023-11-15T18:47:42 | James A. Michaelov, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Does inverse scaling only occur as a function of model size, or can it also
occur over the course of training? We carry out an exploratory study
investigating whether the performance of language models on specific tasks can
decrease (while general performance remains high) during training on the
language modeling task. We find 8 tasks on which Pythia 12B (Biderman et al.,
2023) shows decreased performance over the course of training. Five of these
tasks (TruthfulQA-MC1, TruthfulQA-MC2, Hindsight Neglect, Memo Trap, and
Pattern Match Suppression) additionally show a consistent relationship whereby
larger language models show a greater decrease in performance the more they are
trained, despite showing standard (positive) scaling overall. This highlights
the importance of testing performance at all relevant benchmarks any time
models are trained on additional data, even if their overall performance
improves | [
-0.0068400884,
0.0502015427,
-0.0162005946,
-0.008823026,
-0.0045961915,
0.0146611007,
0.0521157496,
0.037106812,
-0.01721544,
-0.0170790069,
-0.0672801137,
-0.050462842,
-0.0146747623,
0.0283736605,
0.0404069573,
-0.0171243642,
0.05455314,
-0.05339716,
-0.0134449694,
-0.0014818636,
-0.020973986,
-0.0291541126,
0.0087857954,
0.0286285877,
-0.013080786,
-0.0000944483,
0.0129576605,
-0.030810738,
-0.038540069,
-0.040120665,
0.0000449245,
0.0504004247,
0.0326620042,
0.0224149246,
0.000001918,
-0.0405119285,
0.0572709143,
-0.0180376582,
-0.0289753452,
0.044416476,
0.0343577676,
-0.006156269,
0.0182853434,
0.036206238,
-0.0105845388,
-0.0346295908,
0.0426266976,
0.0612489134,
0.0196963791,
0.0656900927,
0.0114139644,
-0.002569855,
0.0292892531,
-0.0523831844,
-0.0287395045,
-0.0273875725,
0.0190203469,
0.003254679,
-0.0444897301,
-0.0322411582,
0.0111023905,
-0.0029537545,
0.0326167978,
0.0515625253,
0.0008922839,
0.07505472,
0.0146166487,
-0.0673334971,
0.0074936403,
-0.0295621268,
-0.0188517105,
-0.0448868088,
-0.0251976587,
-0.0210129227,
-0.0038030334,
0.0021300481,
-0.0580651835,
0.0261239409,
-0.0087774657,
-0.0002654204,
0.0044289767,
0.0024390526,
0.0772414133,
-0.0103058685,
-0.0141112637,
0.0291279424,
0.0195027944,
-0.0529881343,
-0.0226418935,
0.010746954,
-0.0471994765,
-0.0388576239,
0.041497197,
0.0193310119,
-0.0109090395,
-0.0087429089,
-0.0356049649,
-0.0406574048,
0.0124166673,
-0.0369020961,
0.0573594905,
0.0288683474,
-0.0122038554,
-0.0074079493,
-0.0539274625,
0.0735729337,
-0.0239254069,
0.0591529608,
-0.0208401941,
0.0111215599,
-0.0195152164,
-0.0044632656,
-0.0404861309,
-0.0008628007,
-0.0018179436,
-0.0078542167,
-0.0397249758,
-0.0016779348,
-0.0263387151,
-0.0338934176,
-0.0141992951,
0.0187810622,
-0.0543797836,
0.0247662365,
-0.0328892544,
0.0464315526,
-0.0242621042,
0.0237309858,
-0.0043343995,
-0.0379903577,
-0.0426926166,
-0.0084743239,
-0.0195875671,
-0.0117537063,
0.0429747142,
0.043850895,
-0.0041677277,
-0.0567199998,
-0.0466292091,
0.0313007385,
-0.0204847399,
-0.0781759694,
-0.0041016671,
-0.014683919,
-0.0438872762,
0.0348101445,
0.0005976695,
-0.0299200658,
0.0050803083,
0.0283199195,
-0.0198206268,
0.0454816483,
0.0198311526,
0.0250432584,
0.0226544496,
0.0215689465,
-0.0134457294,
0.0607968867,
0.0023853788,
-0.0103216013,
-0.0030472446,
-0.029107891,
0.0173209682,
-0.0018456393,
0.0666325912,
0.0377346836,
-0.0015577292,
-0.0051755309,
0.0237011462,
0.0147050405,
0.0712093189,
0.0304760728,
-0.0146035841,
-0.0166155025,
0.0548801757,
0.0626907721,
-0.0331277177,
0.0586112738,
-0.0001647892,
-0.0593853444,
0.0029256337,
0.029693706,
-0.0816610679,
0.0197404623,
0.0249005649,
0.0160402562,
-0.000611039,
0.0333213843,
-0.0426165685,
-0.0506185144,
-0.0471464284,
-0.0012075783,
-0.0002161162,
-0.0003923246,
0.0531628691,
0.0185326971,
-0.0301598292,
0.0422573201,
0.0212716423,
-0.0616906844,
0.0183298364,
-0.0702951252,
-0.0124658672,
0.0000356994,
-0.0101024918,
-0.0526302122,
-0.0121992696,
0.0167287458,
-0.038292259,
0.0354722701,
0.0623225421,
0.0009726614,
0.0284559298,
-0.0375021957,
0.0166604873,
-0.0248790216,
0.0103263278,
-0.0116221905,
0.0238823686,
0.0290064253,
0.0263438951,
-0.0115115829,
-0.0344284847,
0.0467803553,
-0.07592576,
-0.0277135074,
-0.0339025632,
-0.0248503573,
0.032005731,
-0.0224708598,
-0.0243286919,
0.0104319844,
0.0200083982,
-0.030953927,
0.0027627642,
0.022732554,
-0.0913191363,
-0.0006102711,
0.0209149364,
0.0487694442,
0.0367753729,
0.0705042109,
0.0115846749,
-0.0466307998,
0.0456347205,
-0.0030657938,
0.0865449831,
-0.0170084909,
0.0339694358,
-0.0408233069,
0.0408877954,
-0.0033975642,
0.0335371643,
-0.0294196624,
0.0274167079,
0.0020395748,
-0.0183749851,
0.0190404188,
-0.017975606,
-0.0410150252,
0.0213615447,
0.005919158,
0.0358840264,
0.0193228032,
-0.0526012145,
-0.0205828231,
0.01098275,
-0.0501902401,
0.0044535687,
-0.0301197097,
0.0381331444,
0.0394129641,
-0.0098609142,
-0.0311269164,
-0.027668355,
0.0152700162,
-0.0070944973,
0.0168938208,
0.0692303181,
0.0208553262,
0.0064484943,
-0.0030541895,
-0.0512773767,
-0.0370162353,
0.0083793821,
0.0517940111,
0.0080669662,
0.0138941128,
-0.0475748144,
0.0775443316,
-0.0004644602,
0.0235713255,
-0.0168770757,
-0.0665833503,
0.0427465178,
0.032794293,
0.0350995511,
0.0805844665,
-0.0160819273,
0.0400559939,
0.0917021483,
0.0343671851,
-0.0107750911,
-0.0032384659,
-0.0021970815,
-0.0254151598,
-0.0469704829,
-0.0135881836,
-0.0187829453,
0.0935465619,
0.011097529,
-0.0097637754,
-0.0497086383,
-0.0104625048,
-0.0218988098,
-0.0240190662,
0.007211179,
-0.0263920203,
-0.0115539795,
0.060893178,
-0.0018339281,
-0.0764127448,
0.0280306023,
-0.0041776341,
-0.0206679888,
-0.0280857701,
-0.0191447567,
0.0232296269,
0.0569046848,
0.0428139009,
0.0089934487,
0.03707055,
-0.0666334406,
-0.0660160854,
-0.0303901006,
-0.0034304811,
-0.0205190722,
0.0313571505,
-0.0238558855,
0.0073162573,
0.0111669051,
-0.0418969207,
-0.0389967449,
0.0263386779,
0.0044504623,
0.0024207721,
0.0005371466,
-0.0312725492,
-0.0528485738,
0.0039680717,
0.0474029183,
0.0369869173,
-0.0162498429,
-0.0110942731,
0.0247123372,
-0.0099436017,
-0.0093085906,
0.0240026768,
0.0608769208,
-0.0803284347,
-0.0035107527,
0.0320130326,
0.063839823,
0.0350712761,
-0.030871518,
0.0056237783,
-0.0142266583,
-0.0436712205,
-0.0462584645,
0.0131227626,
0.0380569845,
-0.0500802174,
-0.0574539378,
0.0790823922,
0.0055104187,
-0.0225208756,
0.0406729169,
-0.0363290906,
0.0867113173,
0.0785674229,
-0.0195837524,
-0.026066266,
0.0082837632,
-0.0040706517,
0.0266450625,
-0.005196162,
-0.0254660957,
0.0392475724,
-0.0851328373,
-0.0081622852,
0.0163171254,
-0.0442119949,
-0.0022255115,
-0.0363579206,
-0.0078467261,
-0.0364431813,
0.0830383673,
0.0171315651,
-0.0388147272,
0.0272285957,
0.0281505268,
-0.0034932455,
-0.0244886689,
0.0314795934,
-0.0467940271,
0.0485925898,
0.0254610498,
-0.0100222463,
-0.0138841253,
-0.0073820464,
0.0669995323,
-0.0161480848,
0.0287233219,
-0.00022786,
0.0777254105,
0.0591266416,
-0.042443689,
-0.0240074173,
-0.0364792757,
-0.0213467143,
-0.0482591055,
-0.0445961542,
0.0150698954,
0.0205574036,
-0.0449754708,
-0.0032594723,
-0.0058918297,
-0.0309703518,
0.0722272769,
0.0621703379,
-0.0180669576,
-0.0629174933,
0.0390660949,
0.0370595679,
0.0009870792,
-0.0371242911,
0.0704883635,
0.0363997594,
-0.0164932646,
-0.0679645017,
-0.0348859094,
0.0215226524,
0.0489355102,
-0.0220483057,
-0.0125769898,
-0.0203133374,
-0.0094409948,
-0.0275375154,
0.0248476509,
0.0425461568,
-0.0178493001,
-0.0823880062,
0.0027939584,
0.012753862,
-0.0034336608,
-0.0272299536,
-0.0150130466,
-0.1262814999,
-0.0277986005,
0.0554805659,
0.0146534359,
0.0397631191,
0.0347002782,
0.0309193693,
-0.0184358563,
0.0391691625,
-0.0070530339,
-0.0265132412,
0.0530554652,
0.036604315,
-0.0427735858,
-0.0061689029,
0.0448297188,
0.0179242305,
0.0171468128,
0.0285109393,
0.0290582087,
0.0173925702,
-0.0060383314,
-0.0006155922,
0.0315449238,
0.0328428745,
-0.0028734088,
-0.0208254382,
-0.0093047023,
-0.0059910682,
0.0182184633,
0.0164465569,
-0.0100136474,
0.0041302443,
0.020781979,
0.0475868359,
-0.003571454,
-0.0275968872,
-0.0148012107,
0.0282959808,
-0.0325629525,
0.0230017044,
-0.0150436331,
0.0181453954,
0.0528608188,
0.0177000072,
-0.0413810723,
-0.0023978041,
-0.0328828096,
0.0411878601,
-0.0106273554,
0.0135198729,
-0.0224066395,
0.0087805809,
-0.0274698175,
0.01636637,
-0.0907515958,
-0.0448123328,
-0.0180667639,
0.0175642874,
0.0412202179,
-0.0538145266,
0.0530654714,
-0.0208667926,
0.0172264092,
-0.0146060549,
-0.0164585169,
-0.0221606251,
0.0060153585,
0.010188546,
-0.0003366501,
-0.0015329242,
0.0054296637,
0.0780547783,
0.0086664306,
0.094878234,
-0.0000737957,
0.0246051922,
0.0056760004,
-0.0459521785,
-0.0154898185,
0.0193283353,
-0.0429683663,
-0.0088987937,
-0.0339592025,
-0.0854940042,
-0.0225881767,
0.0134727759,
0.0321536288,
-0.0366833583,
-0.0123951556,
0.0196066722,
-0.0268395785,
-0.057161618,
-0.0032271075,
0.0325380601,
0.0548888221,
0.0141553441,
0.021955926,
-6.318553234e-33,
-0.0315560624,
0.0257290751,
0.0428790078,
-0.0246135183,
0.002442725,
0.014902276,
-0.0499057993,
0.0046565128,
-0.065645352,
0.005487802,
-0.0166854691,
0.0254784655,
0.0062631057,
0.0166712627,
0.0100611486,
-0.0119994748,
0.0321496725,
-0.0267862082,
-0.0047694733,
0.050472308,
0.0531786196,
0.0145301176,
0.0985594392,
-0.0404086597,
-0.0380013026,
0.0239703413,
-0.0177783668,
-0.0113141965,
-0.0324786976,
0.0317229591,
-0.026554672,
0.018915927,
0.025419835,
-0.0558990613,
-0.0288623571,
-0.039681185,
-0.0262153056,
-0.0159691572,
-0.0062055108,
0.0086075878,
-0.0014866979,
0.0094282012,
0.0954743922,
-0.0025396247,
-0.027229378,
-0.0050122715,
-0.010559164,
-0.0386650488,
-0.0305564273,
0.0437734239,
-0.0935109481,
0.0042403671,
0.0193860419,
0.0106920023,
-0.0176773984,
-0.0420913212,
-0.0156926699,
-0.0130486209,
-0.0480103716,
-0.0304739568,
0.0352191478,
0.0605656765,
0.0224622395,
0.0696273148,
-0.0189376529,
0.0457257703,
0.0802612081,
0.0354826711,
0.0197822787,
-0.0392666049,
0.058388073,
0.0402743481,
0.0455868952,
-0.0195345916,
0.0620186776,
-0.0265141875,
-0.0544494353,
-0.0061096791,
0.0000563543,
0.0323008746,
0.0138651114,
0.0140905567,
-0.0335154645,
-0.0299303662,
-0.0376745388,
-0.0106214862,
-0.0217500143,
-0.0107740387,
0.0093831439,
-0.0118757263,
0.0068274285,
0.0267502218,
-0.0005292609,
-0.0384234227,
-0.0106133409,
-0.0123119652,
-0.0321718566,
0.0129451016,
-0.0064112875,
0.0360100828,
-0.0840011761,
-0.0133384429,
-0.0301657543,
0.0698815659,
0.0350964777,
0.0055316794,
0.0004542001,
0.0119794067,
-0.0947088972,
-0.0195273124,
-0.0558756329,
0.0019995885,
0.0808439031,
-0.0006972867,
0.0471659899,
-0.0069129872,
-0.0107016806,
0.0385164805,
0.0269570425,
-0.0607836992,
-0.0623231716,
0.0259506069,
0.0341051817,
0.0359309018,
-0.0180657506,
-0.0214355774,
-0.0579489805,
0.0424567759,
0.0542937964,
-0.046240963,
-0.0389122851,
0.0017311377,
2.604e-7,
0.0448273867,
0.0363421179,
0.001930619,
0.014892133,
-0.0201881994,
0.0455173776,
-0.0597262681,
0.0171379838,
0.0053075277,
0.0333265066,
-0.0164562538,
0.0416708961,
0.0279778205,
0.0188233387,
0.0202814229,
0.0073009608,
-0.1255246103,
0.0002943797,
-0.0362727121,
0.0334821045,
-0.0408424847,
0.0464059077,
0.0163617805,
-0.0495005213,
0.030672254,
-0.0696348399,
0.056111455,
-0.0105762267,
0.0699100196,
-0.0090403929,
-0.0310219415,
0.0508563556,
0.0151409544,
0.0399914905,
-0.0122907236,
0.0115660969,
-0.0353451222,
0.0047175996,
-0.0317523032,
0.0180413015,
-0.0229611434,
0.0223077331,
0.001817675,
-0.0905384272,
0.0413276739,
-0.0244017057,
-0.0101021165,
-0.0366783477,
-0.011278945,
0.0093138441,
0.024613075,
0.0080434941,
0.0054677273,
0.0575190037,
-0.0147965988,
0.0120245786,
-0.0481443182,
-0.0937533826,
-0.0169912558,
0.0461039469,
-0.0346723348,
-0.0292907041,
-0.0441740453,
-0.0080426969,
0.0318648331,
-0.0472610556,
0.0001280977,
2.354449752e-34,
0.0170610379,
-0.0387100838,
0.0090577798,
0.0323080868,
0.025220478,
-0.0179666672,
0.0305688605,
-0.0244222041,
-0.0354630351,
-0.039246358,
-0.0229505692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14676v1 | GRILL: Grounded Vision-language Pre-training via Aligning Text and Image Regions | 2023-05-24T03:33:21 | 2023-05-24T03:33:21 | Woojeong Jin, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Yu Cheng, Yelong Shen, Weizhu Chen, Ahmed Hassan Awadallah, Damien Jose, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generalization to unseen tasks is an important ability for few-shot learners
to achieve better zero-/few-shot performance on diverse tasks. However, such
generalization to vision-language tasks including grounding and generation
tasks has been under-explored; existing few-shot VL models struggle to handle
tasks that involve object grounding and multiple images such as visual
commonsense reasoning or NLVR2. In this paper, we introduce GRILL, GRounded
vIsion Language aLigning, a novel VL model that can be generalized to diverse
tasks including visual question answering, captioning, and grounding tasks with
no or very few training instances. Specifically, GRILL learns object grounding
and localization by exploiting object-text alignments, which enables it to
transfer to grounding tasks in a zero-/few-shot fashion. We evaluate our model
on various zero-/few-shot VL tasks and show that it consistently surpasses the
state-of-the-art few-shot methods. | [
0.0178022888,
0.0469541326,
0.0314635262,
0.0268208329,
-0.0078011053,
-0.0052887653,
0.0222174414,
-0.0208388418,
-0.0149247162,
-0.0549575053,
-0.0291585997,
-0.0003739036,
0.0061931508,
0.0098502925,
0.0244888701,
-0.0232337471,
0.0353375115,
-0.0140251368,
-0.0210270546,
0.0178329591,
0.0531669669,
0.017853627,
-0.0074252831,
0.0213455986,
-0.0105881207,
-0.0341053568,
-0.0085323555,
-0.0011181311,
0.0430167317,
-0.0066007483,
-0.0178279374,
0.0498584583,
0.0542719811,
-0.0150449798,
0.0000016225,
-0.0118266623,
0.0090574585,
0.0064973487,
0.005891161,
-0.0202809535,
-0.0219015013,
-0.0433902666,
0.0138665978,
0.0057187877,
-0.0470001027,
-0.0449225008,
0.0681604221,
0.0630551353,
0.069821842,
0.0340958536,
-0.021236321,
-0.0297512747,
0.0043579349,
-0.0159304198,
0.0508100092,
-0.0389986634,
-0.0101850368,
0.0520681702,
-0.0376865901,
-0.0197929051,
-0.0485137329,
0.0389110334,
0.0370603316,
-0.015009881,
0.0187755376,
0.0642865822,
-0.0718356669,
-0.0112002864,
-0.0073921322,
0.1117195338,
-0.0025306253,
-0.0411434583,
-0.0410976782,
-0.0004221279,
0.0137433466,
-0.0356853791,
-0.0458267331,
0.0434121378,
0.017606236,
0.0350718759,
-0.0420581549,
-0.0061924225,
-0.0135152312,
0.0082161799,
0.0065662921,
0.0184020344,
0.0051640533,
0.0274408646,
-0.0098126698,
0.0453193411,
-0.0372788757,
-0.0520041622,
-0.0495901555,
0.0368655547,
-0.0127484938,
0.0130234547,
-0.0555925816,
0.0036842069,
-0.0282011069,
-0.0280458797,
0.0431469679,
0.0362496041,
-0.0654592961,
0.0695817247,
-0.0398863405,
0.0533363335,
-0.0190327875,
0.0373278111,
-0.0185259338,
-0.0097595938,
-0.0063054473,
-0.0026150257,
-0.0541826561,
0.0162553675,
-0.0591174774,
-0.0418872274,
0.0020135536,
0.0081033744,
-0.016468592,
-0.0046614232,
-0.0140816234,
0.0454857834,
-0.0338453054,
-0.0311262272,
-0.0072724288,
0.061804425,
-0.0424664095,
0.0276719648,
-0.0175646022,
-0.0316530466,
-0.0285327043,
0.0496010482,
0.0467890799,
-0.0242596697,
-0.0149538089,
0.007351046,
-0.0637331232,
-0.0432519428,
-0.0449902974,
0.0017926081,
-0.0126880854,
-0.0497034304,
0.0055716485,
-0.0572893657,
0.0041993521,
-0.0057780682,
-0.0259226281,
-0.0191269182,
0.0080236513,
0.0206890684,
-0.0035980949,
0.091469191,
0.0030567963,
-0.0238212366,
-0.0112093771,
-0.0041889572,
0.0323955864,
0.0655045882,
-0.0291289017,
0.0122658201,
-0.0067430059,
0.0203126688,
0.0186465774,
0.0053814123,
0.0318893008,
0.0229574945,
-0.0692212731,
0.0125313327,
-0.0130909933,
0.0086426064,
0.0486779213,
0.0057807514,
-0.0327752642,
-0.0129195163,
0.0814097375,
0.0486635081,
-0.0531009808,
-0.024281282,
0.0356087349,
0.0090380516,
-0.0084083891,
0.0011921147,
-0.0819068402,
0.063473478,
-0.0231557731,
0.022775447,
-0.0330352075,
0.0140537564,
-0.0608380027,
-0.02729409,
0.0077731456,
-0.0080209179,
0.0126237785,
0.0010691325,
0.0355439074,
0.0261135213,
-0.06468492,
0.0411702916,
0.0019873464,
-0.0239078645,
-0.0008967682,
0.0136188483,
0.0361378603,
-0.0002716555,
0.0141709847,
0.0241796728,
-0.0639712662,
-0.0059411922,
0.0963380039,
0.0852246955,
-0.015433969,
0.0137290228,
0.0197644308,
-0.0365128294,
-0.0525406823,
-0.0450991131,
0.0040049595,
-0.005279419,
0.0259458534,
0.0057607568,
0.0193060283,
-0.0514086522,
0.0211396292,
0.0303674098,
0.037086647,
-0.0087394016,
-0.0388404913,
0.0503962189,
-0.013981957,
-0.0190929174,
-0.0277704466,
-0.0146197854,
-0.0066572139,
-0.0342509709,
-0.0132105099,
0.0325319171,
-0.0427484661,
-0.0314508975,
0.0336733982,
-0.0483167171,
-0.0263611134,
0.0109265717,
-0.0298167672,
-0.0162827522,
-0.0113790724,
0.0143190185,
0.0048192162,
-0.0396037623,
-0.0156388097,
0.0083050448,
0.0138180582,
-0.0218396597,
0.0531108864,
-0.0254591126,
-0.0150677431,
-0.0201195497,
-0.0030897318,
0.0298620425,
-0.0150342919,
-0.0113668879,
-0.0306866262,
-0.0132079348,
0.0149633642,
0.0255977269,
0.0528902225,
-0.052736342,
0.023974197,
-0.1077805161,
-0.0247191228,
-0.0371395387,
-0.0167701691,
0.0282998458,
-0.0213831346,
0.0223839823,
-0.0550743677,
-0.0753339753,
0.0323039368,
0.0244163144,
-0.0172833186,
0.0655308142,
0.0016571993,
0.0016205553,
-0.0271416511,
0.0237002559,
0.0214552768,
0.0506694466,
0.0076826457,
-0.0031246715,
-0.0185074452,
0.0397832096,
-0.0575732961,
0.0683033615,
-0.0043129106,
-0.02616987,
0.0007649555,
-0.0102960812,
0.0332659297,
0.0886047035,
-0.0253809262,
0.021954665,
-0.0145428469,
0.0041639949,
-0.0316796042,
0.0008984464,
0.0070998077,
-0.0506393947,
-0.0174616687,
0.0450431406,
-0.0325350799,
0.0402939804,
-0.0270054955,
0.0072852038,
-0.0933351815,
0.0433184281,
0.0040076571,
-0.0134206237,
-0.0611838661,
0.0401480496,
0.0133128082,
0.0293066986,
-0.078236416,
-0.0741290525,
0.0425520763,
-0.0367958806,
-0.0211521648,
-0.0079622101,
-0.0075337496,
-0.0145018762,
0.0679036677,
0.0052837483,
0.0240988713,
-0.0056744595,
-0.0195450429,
-0.0803973377,
-0.0531777963,
-0.01033381,
0.0219409019,
0.101250194,
-0.0308604222,
0.0479447693,
-0.0492963977,
-0.0482259206,
-0.0472578555,
-0.0354053266,
-0.0342978537,
0.0135934548,
-0.0829686821,
-0.0087527931,
-0.0440201871,
0.0132394871,
0.0191019773,
0.0419560969,
-0.0219409186,
0.0070778038,
-0.021647349,
0.0080910288,
0.0758106336,
0.0364068635,
-0.0365836285,
-0.0092446646,
0.0283544753,
0.0494862944,
0.0542072542,
0.0027782351,
-0.0278710965,
0.0240374003,
0.0273568705,
0.0245002247,
0.0236646589,
0.026904244,
0.0838206783,
-0.0128309634,
-0.0264724884,
0.0707228258,
0.0258785915,
-0.0052992688,
-0.0181951374,
-0.0095995283,
0.0206590295,
0.048133783,
0.0347925015,
-0.0706379712,
-0.0531061999,
-0.0217384957,
-0.0198187567,
0.0692277774,
-0.0130908899,
-0.0430691428,
-0.1097934917,
0.0202983748,
0.0187324192,
-0.0842953622,
-0.0622065775,
0.0503259003,
-0.0222936105,
-0.0038642595,
0.0038473664,
-0.018101329,
0.0185253583,
0.0084052887,
-0.0058822902,
0.056009464,
-0.0266844071,
0.0355107412,
-0.0572412349,
-0.003253065,
0.0423474163,
-0.0045498428,
-0.0014071343,
-0.0578794889,
0.0053825136,
0.00295408,
0.0087810103,
0.0294812284,
0.0219290555,
-0.0360046253,
-0.0701505691,
0.0395195112,
0.0532380082,
-0.0324182175,
-0.0151238376,
-0.0269781929,
0.0194344651,
0.0033255643,
0.0074476777,
0.0108300317,
0.0315790996,
0.015495983,
0.0372499228,
0.032585226,
-0.0195958186,
-0.0432785824,
0.0026250586,
-0.0213181935,
-0.0568023883,
-0.0289078988,
-0.0101601835,
0.0307998471,
0.0073981457,
-0.0783054903,
-0.0156419612,
0.0719461367,
0.0891134515,
-0.0176662244,
-0.0383950435,
0.0043503307,
-0.0050007193,
-0.0560283102,
0.0694371685,
-0.0356898457,
0.0287898686,
-0.0508198477,
0.0049105985,
0.0410659648,
-0.0208383873,
-0.0187298954,
0.0065745991,
-0.072229825,
-0.0326710679,
-0.0398787707,
0.0792285576,
0.0068527814,
0.0625655577,
-0.0147620235,
0.0013173462,
0.0224234182,
0.0330823958,
0.0010405072,
0.0455699787,
-0.0121886842,
-0.0544283576,
0.0164537225,
0.0319556631,
-0.0245742351,
0.0107509047,
0.04833588,
0.0192050748,
-0.0194257312,
0.029763788,
0.0275438596,
-0.0042591384,
0.0592403747,
0.0036155127,
0.0430050083,
-0.0178263858,
0.0070681423,
0.0025633639,
-0.0191358849,
-0.073194772,
-0.0160549283,
0.0034719883,
-0.0077344617,
0.0255927742,
0.0065844324,
-0.0103248591,
0.0783358216,
-0.0000562777,
-0.0569491386,
0.0158262271,
-0.0138580203,
0.0030847043,
0.0362779945,
-0.0112828119,
0.0067822617,
-0.0074186171,
0.0457755774,
-0.0128969019,
0.0742637441,
0.0394182354,
0.0020614774,
-0.0427924842,
0.0290638693,
-0.0060056369,
-0.0110378359,
-0.0334689319,
0.0509300567,
0.0407986566,
-0.0173604693,
0.0057726861,
0.0091824047,
-0.0279048719,
0.0064836447,
0.04398828,
-0.0185765903,
-0.0556739047,
0.0442346931,
0.031911388,
-0.0059097246,
-0.0065288683,
0.0565460287,
0.0286790654,
0.0325659811,
-0.0175820552,
0.0224375017,
-0.0304861758,
-0.0136720212,
0.038490206,
-0.0003651375,
0.013439971,
0.0766050741,
-0.0565417446,
-0.0517232753,
-0.013680133,
0.0412299186,
-0.048497241,
0.0376965627,
0.0573556237,
0.0541571267,
0.0224946737,
-0.0174061153,
0.0062528457,
-0.0288722422,
-0.0024606795,
-0.0033063807,
-0.0064096893,
-5.665176372e-33,
-0.0632359907,
-0.0314288586,
0.065321207,
-0.0247872826,
-0.0197050348,
0.0354453288,
-0.022036653,
0.0242604464,
-0.0348962285,
0.0072168182,
0.0286041964,
0.0160945076,
0.0009192175,
0.0422409587,
-0.0414569788,
-0.0243028719,
0.0254113134,
-0.0042967885,
-0.0097368984,
-0.0201870333,
0.0127601707,
0.0151415691,
0.0640794337,
-0.0181147214,
-0.0301427767,
0.0246132538,
-0.0355936699,
0.0254719425,
0.0100565515,
0.0446814485,
0.008492792,
-0.0107218297,
-0.0024738899,
-0.0194479544,
-0.027828021,
0.0115719577,
-0.0814092085,
-0.0251192544,
0.0422358885,
0.0481792651,
-0.0528261401,
0.0392753407,
0.0148279537,
-0.0386181585,
0.0439104699,
-0.0189656503,
0.0385462642,
0.0021071474,
0.0081315124,
0.0099195102,
-0.0651945546,
-0.0202940069,
-0.0140855135,
-0.0485082753,
-0.0037960524,
0.0191052742,
0.0182182621,
0.0245667007,
-0.041713357,
-0.0074739615,
-0.0113359187,
0.0149740512,
0.0901082531,
0.0392874666,
-0.0043936023,
0.0548287146,
-0.0183264352,
-0.042803634,
-0.0647752509,
0.0073511926,
0.034550909,
0.0295669939,
0.0269375816,
0.0547260642,
0.0059769438,
0.0470130071,
-0.0573276691,
0.0050424202,
-0.0596105456,
0.0837469324,
-0.0268648174,
0.009217673,
0.011856012,
-0.0099775726,
-0.036697261,
-0.02122177,
-0.0415965579,
-0.0092297168,
0.068118751,
0.0251451842,
-0.0477893017,
0.0441261828,
0.078727819,
-0.0243884772,
0.0200215951,
0.0739813372,
-0.0229758378,
0.0328729898,
-0.0049386406,
0.0159538947,
-0.0560795069,
-0.0032303042,
0.0385223106,
0.0105554936,
-0.0174614564,
0.0250140168,
0.0668771863,
0.0289752763,
-0.0539665744,
0.0145394234,
-0.0396738388,
0.003481203,
-0.013332488,
0.0643781647,
0.0188309308,
0.0240173116,
-0.0509567931,
0.0413777754,
-0.0054570669,
-0.058947742,
0.0177680701,
-0.0156083107,
-0.0139314383,
0.0335509889,
-0.0007098633,
0.0179412998,
-0.0322930068,
-0.0098378034,
0.0150422752,
-0.0456762537,
-0.0055091265,
0.038611576,
2.301e-7,
0.0245019607,
-0.0170048829,
0.0458175912,
0.0126456106,
-0.0154692084,
0.0520511791,
-0.0083244322,
0.0264474936,
-0.0182280298,
-0.0540519617,
0.0103274509,
0.0567719005,
0.0100860288,
-0.0335322134,
-0.0409312099,
0.0706054196,
-0.0539613403,
-0.0151012167,
-0.0269856732,
-0.0244051069,
0.0140759004,
0.0863729045,
-0.0163991582,
0.0035536557,
0.0516120978,
-0.0696316436,
0.0549053252,
-0.0093149114,
-0.0060804463,
-0.0285336897,
-0.0399390385,
0.0028792946,
-0.0253812745,
0.0154003287,
0.0059558228,
0.0034376278,
0.0305235982,
0.0318099856,
-0.0411535762,
0.0041971561,
-0.0518063605,
0.0180836283,
-0.0156747643,
-0.0385620333,
0.0804050043,
-0.0759121776,
-0.0112048071,
-0.0289456137,
-0.0420321524,
0.0054040249,
0.0183420274,
-0.0062320959,
-0.0338664316,
0.0110997185,
0.0628980845,
-0.0297558289,
-0.0398609713,
-0.0728260949,
-0.0281502325,
0.0222196914,
0.0111615481,
-0.0047462159,
-0.0288675111,
-0.034376625,
0.0354520753,
-0.0076407725,
-0.0584762692,
1.57336188e-34,
0.0036348409,
-0.011538242,
0.0225594528,
0.0120938299,
-0.0011374095,
0.0038996011,
-0.036093127,
-0.0186310671,
0.0134003125,
-0.0196137037,
-0.0044829934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14672v1 | Quantifying Character Similarity with Vision Transformers | 2023-05-24T03:25:33 | 2023-05-24T03:25:33 | Xinmei Yang, Abhishek Arora, Shao-Yu Jheng, Melissa Dell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Record linkage is a bedrock of quantitative social science, as analyses often
require linking data from multiple, noisy sources. Off-the-shelf string
matching methods are widely used, as they are straightforward and cheap to
implement and scale. Not all character substitutions are equally probable, and
for some settings there are widely used handcrafted lists denoting which string
substitutions are more likely, that improve the accuracy of string matching.
However, such lists do not exist for many settings, skewing research with
linked datasets towards a few high-resource contexts that are not
representative of the diversity of human societies. This study develops an
extensible way to measure character substitution costs for OCR'ed documents, by
employing large-scale self-supervised training of vision transformers (ViT)
with augmented digital fonts. For each language written with the CJK script, we
contrastively learn a metric space where different augmentations of the same
character are represented nearby. In this space, homoglyphic characters - those
with similar appearance such as ``O'' and ``0'' - have similar vector
representations. Using the cosine distance between characters' representations
as the substitution cost in an edit distance matching algorithm significantly
improves record linkage compared to other widely used string matching methods,
as OCR errors tend to be homoglyphic in nature. Homoglyphs can plausibly
capture character visual similarity across any script, including low-resource
settings. We illustrate this by creating homoglyph sets for 3,000 year old
ancient Chinese characters, which are highly pictorial. Fascinatingly, a ViT is
able to capture relationships in how different abstract concepts were
conceptualized by ancient societies, that have been noted in the archaeological
literature. | [
0.0112122018,
0.0702872202,
-0.0216776617,
0.0383668542,
-0.031082999,
0.039990142,
0.0318460278,
0.0677566156,
0.0392960496,
-0.0226099975,
0.0246754345,
-0.0513007343,
0.0890188366,
-0.0188191179,
0.004696216,
-0.0572743565,
0.0134711266,
-0.0010288475,
-0.0493298359,
0.016626507,
0.0027713319,
-0.002598241,
0.0270653348,
0.0161069501,
-0.0235823784,
-0.0118616512,
-0.020277461,
0.0257800967,
0.0518158004,
-0.009190293,
-0.0409822986,
0.0447284989,
-0.0030132183,
0.1033977941,
0.0000017759,
-0.0825514495,
-0.0318717025,
0.0005499827,
-0.0175214037,
0.0132128568,
0.0446254872,
-0.0217972025,
-0.068509914,
-0.0225857403,
0.0211447757,
-0.0291448515,
0.1255147308,
0.0208520833,
-0.0317761526,
0.0462650806,
-0.0354909077,
-0.0548454784,
-0.0087152394,
-0.0179431904,
0.0091912812,
0.0455670431,
0.033957161,
0.0467991158,
-0.0377890095,
0.0048607793,
-0.0372625999,
0.0563100576,
-0.05328428,
-0.0149128782,
-0.0361762382,
0.0150184147,
-0.036459025,
0.0004554741,
0.0227104817,
0.046852231,
-0.0358795077,
-0.031091731,
0.03021501,
-0.0013261447,
-0.0458186418,
0.0424091145,
-0.0010219433,
-0.0094524138,
-0.0642397925,
0.0178329088,
-0.0141930198,
-0.0017492567,
0.0087610753,
-0.0085987691,
-0.0517925397,
-0.0325434729,
0.0221273564,
-0.0315729789,
-0.02668049,
-0.0119772227,
-0.0112609174,
-0.0343251824,
-0.00095636,
0.0313550942,
0.0316965096,
-0.0089129079,
-0.0127330115,
-0.0408914983,
0.0137670534,
-0.0106131835,
0.050294254,
0.0656803697,
-0.056754481,
0.0165063217,
-0.0596110187,
0.0762486085,
-0.0315258913,
0.0330480896,
-0.0060650269,
-0.0115679903,
-0.0484405756,
-0.0189008117,
-0.0235410947,
-0.0410668403,
0.0338172428,
0.0128043219,
-0.0180874802,
0.0140358442,
0.0093610184,
0.0257272627,
-0.0176021587,
-0.0585199594,
0.0084360419,
-0.0212346595,
-0.0549245849,
0.0042111129,
0.021011088,
-0.005369077,
-0.0680141076,
-0.0386944637,
0.02145648,
0.0347646177,
0.0620512255,
0.0070095812,
0.0194267854,
0.0847658813,
-0.0390134193,
-0.0188174956,
0.0001870542,
0.0273292623,
-0.0293334424,
-0.0032956856,
-0.0039616651,
-0.0545050241,
0.0051670233,
-0.0229984988,
0.0022778213,
-0.0261378344,
-0.0090257432,
-0.0029244546,
-0.0062500997,
0.0767164379,
-0.0158822332,
-0.0026792921,
0.0377623998,
-0.019503165,
-0.0104777683,
-0.031086795,
0.0594817549,
0.0194060188,
0.0485003628,
-0.0049893977,
-0.00185529,
0.038400244,
-0.0311640128,
-0.0145175774,
-0.0143515682,
-0.0140223214,
0.0780682862,
0.0306412,
0.0168183465,
0.0556961708,
-0.0426465198,
-0.04925365,
0.0456368923,
0.1081074327,
0.0641673729,
-0.003430719,
-0.0069183484,
0.0007282417,
0.0120714735,
-0.0075844508,
-0.005067823,
0.004466746,
0.0390318371,
-0.0069821267,
-0.0259039085,
0.0432541631,
-0.0092145018,
0.0025266481,
-0.0237834379,
-0.022242507,
0.005351787,
-0.0357764326,
0.0599793121,
-0.0037955148,
-0.0421929173,
-0.0321831852,
-0.0149041452,
-0.0307730865,
-0.0462125167,
-0.0317166485,
0.0188598651,
0.0739468634,
0.0828855261,
-0.018581083,
0.0701933354,
0.0237626713,
-0.0260337982,
0.047771655,
0.0058241207,
-0.0214830451,
0.009437561,
-0.0735810846,
-0.0049492954,
0.054038249,
-0.0189476945,
0.0440774821,
-0.0086201252,
0.0535981953,
0.0320468359,
-0.02136687,
-0.0372720063,
0.0456556045,
-0.0405697115,
-0.0145965545,
-0.0579518676,
0.0608528554,
-0.0292776879,
-0.0027747471,
-0.0364267118,
0.0103215249,
-0.0180597957,
-0.0464481451,
0.0037217452,
0.037283279,
0.012089082,
0.0395890549,
0.0720483065,
-0.1002287492,
0.0092140008,
0.0051279622,
0.0245762467,
-0.0123260953,
0.0046473574,
-0.0504010618,
0.0516519919,
-0.0364403427,
0.0458178185,
-0.0525207929,
-0.0057828291,
-0.0417265147,
0.0650952756,
0.0328272209,
0.0041647642,
-0.0113554709,
-0.053686399,
0.0611904673,
-0.0183065347,
0.0014230643,
-0.0251363516,
0.0140231159,
0.0005485083,
-0.0176827367,
-0.0023362914,
-0.0136772878,
-0.0796339363,
-0.0256755129,
-0.0102568818,
-0.0231520832,
0.0214369111,
0.0201038085,
-0.0046130293,
0.0126829939,
-0.0431931317,
-0.0132706817,
0.0051253513,
-0.0332885124,
-0.0075596403,
0.0848621055,
-0.0462142862,
-0.0353847258,
-0.0253770221,
-0.0152862882,
-0.004381828,
0.0565188453,
0.0632741898,
-0.0871233344,
-0.0591523312,
-0.0208905768,
-0.0184436515,
0.0100207655,
-0.048961442,
-0.0094792405,
0.0205374882,
-0.0114262532,
0.0051853489,
0.0209954008,
-0.0057273018,
-0.0387072153,
0.0368600748,
-0.0101871612,
-0.0169744082,
-0.0432571433,
0.0042476733,
0.0050182617,
-0.0103559913,
-0.0457515791,
-0.028903665,
-0.0130939651,
-0.0452730879,
0.0193564333,
-0.0563327521,
-0.0143187335,
0.0325727277,
0.010804737,
-0.0179203991,
-0.0386049002,
-0.0089373598,
0.0310755,
-0.0327618197,
-0.0213251282,
0.011534459,
-0.0084949611,
0.0228473824,
0.0056044771,
0.0172227267,
-0.0510824695,
0.0457851142,
0.044580467,
0.0189561304,
0.0500409529,
-0.0290851891,
-0.0500438623,
0.0663964003,
0.0674566329,
-0.0575960353,
0.051562231,
-0.0141358878,
0.0625154153,
-0.0311261471,
-0.0053449282,
-0.0217385199,
-0.0007695175,
-0.0307613425,
-0.0190633591,
0.017495241,
-0.0619373173,
-0.0300398245,
0.0767734647,
0.0055904314,
0.053454075,
0.0520712286,
0.0028958169,
-0.004231215,
0.0477357842,
-0.0271598287,
0.0190419629,
0.0129465852,
-0.0240276381,
0.0124587975,
0.0196132474,
0.0266027916,
-0.0333766192,
-0.0017578205,
0.0005359694,
0.0066793575,
-0.0084222397,
-0.0173203349,
-0.0598267727,
0.0049562077,
-0.0116236266,
0.0432023667,
0.0583231412,
0.0302919354,
-0.034979146,
-0.0077143745,
-0.026564151,
-0.0043377979,
0.017797403,
-0.0341524519,
-0.1250452846,
0.014605091,
0.0220591687,
0.0103800753,
-0.0089787524,
-0.0527527779,
0.0014055786,
-0.0667515174,
-0.0124992328,
0.0161164682,
-0.0519971512,
-0.0466286577,
-0.018411709,
0.0304056164,
-0.0188315753,
-0.0923256502,
0.0050836625,
-0.0171954613,
-0.0089842025,
0.0159404278,
-0.04135089,
0.0153027438,
-0.026228983,
-0.0567037798,
-0.0109902732,
0.0210880116,
0.0644889474,
0.0216375254,
-0.0649222508,
-0.0296996925,
-0.0036651436,
0.0299652703,
0.0046258173,
0.1449495703,
0.0543309934,
-0.0283897147,
-0.0102762319,
-0.0108946795,
-0.024108544,
-0.0236257724,
-0.0043009468,
-0.0257589649,
-0.0026606761,
0.0028587619,
0.0417696349,
-0.0397719033,
-0.0217025299,
0.0130882831,
-0.0123055084,
-0.0199602358,
-0.0244999751,
-0.0227007829,
0.0596857555,
-0.0041302652,
-0.0696336776,
0.0136263315,
-0.0341463238,
-0.0465580001,
-0.0758958533,
-0.0075696632,
-0.0205922294,
0.0465424992,
0.0319529772,
-0.0529278368,
0.0271000415,
0.015606747,
-0.0890180618,
-0.0316586122,
-0.0435530096,
0.0063897595,
-0.0368461348,
0.0012131003,
-0.007807062,
-0.0195731819,
0.0080066063,
-0.0105525274,
-0.0856006742,
-0.0391467921,
0.0534804501,
-0.0203288868,
0.0164279584,
0.0152979288,
0.0236576367,
-0.0255378317,
0.0050087399,
0.00774041,
0.0685063526,
0.0178180225,
-0.0293358248,
-0.0344838873,
-0.0316697359,
0.0014642043,
-0.0200605895,
-0.0070274165,
-0.0012387243,
-0.0348240212,
-0.0403871648,
-0.0501538105,
0.0097225336,
0.0111606196,
-0.0122230584,
-0.0298623852,
0.0377090834,
-0.0195978135,
0.0272771306,
0.002845072,
0.0261613075,
0.0033570065,
-0.0403796136,
-0.0037048056,
0.0225705206,
-0.009523022,
0.0202812199,
-0.0051892102,
0.0264556557,
-0.0411862768,
0.0168409515,
0.0165650547,
0.0735232532,
-0.0200157259,
0.0235173143,
0.0311148018,
0.0570340641,
0.0031439841,
0.0837913454,
-0.0007777007,
0.0000729004,
0.0116562676,
0.0355609842,
0.0298829731,
0.0185257252,
-0.0382567793,
-0.0771721527,
-0.0109440321,
-0.008991803,
0.0503588133,
-0.0300852284,
0.0417181291,
-0.0477216989,
-0.0189252514,
-0.0160747692,
-0.0235929471,
0.010457729,
0.0096129272,
-0.069857128,
0.0287035108,
-0.0163550619,
0.0352978073,
0.0716910139,
-0.0222501364,
0.0342123918,
-0.00238516,
-0.0534398332,
-0.0096869813,
0.0060159629,
0.0441548042,
-0.0455445871,
-0.0212411229,
-0.04585547,
-0.0451758355,
-0.0545010827,
0.0540376753,
0.0003640191,
-0.0092388708,
0.0487205572,
0.0042425771,
-0.0191709958,
0.0013450253,
0.026174549,
-0.0031017333,
0.011834044,
-0.0216288902,
-0.0104971984,
0.0190425236,
-5.036864724e-33,
0.0110088428,
-0.0317179076,
-0.0110273687,
0.0085544782,
-0.0010367291,
0.0057638506,
-0.0117085362,
0.0098720295,
-0.0425184816,
0.001484488,
0.024405634,
0.0012656362,
0.0234615114,
-0.0174381286,
0.0121936221,
0.0208921358,
0.026936831,
0.0068717054,
0.0086490372,
-0.0415690802,
0.0582023822,
-0.0057943631,
0.0572458617,
-0.1040255651,
0.0229262449,
-0.0002144528,
0.0092960577,
-0.0195330568,
0.0470202155,
0.0518355556,
0.004448181,
0.009185276,
0.0122681987,
0.0459083468,
-0.012051017,
0.0218473729,
-0.0821918249,
-0.0081321923,
-0.077787742,
0.0651776642,
0.0242547635,
-0.0046749189,
-0.0432367399,
-0.0383210033,
-0.0103457179,
-0.0174326096,
0.0486809127,
-0.030282585,
-0.0148711596,
0.0038180533,
-0.0307080429,
0.0484602265,
-0.0192488953,
0.0130219935,
0.0367890857,
0.0376207381,
0.024624059,
0.0439553186,
-0.0799223632,
0.0506343581,
0.0242461339,
0.0075291796,
-0.0097620329,
0.0492103361,
0.0080228494,
0.0332229212,
0.0591717288,
-0.0098964991,
0.019643547,
-0.0222951844,
0.0414338186,
-0.0449505039,
0.0095100272,
0.078403838,
0.0600993112,
-0.0269871745,
-0.0553354211,
0.0134128323,
-0.0185199734,
0.0085417787,
-0.0063846097,
0.0494688824,
-0.0201971885,
0.0133348899,
0.0068117701,
-0.0029272237,
0.0038806838,
0.0012672761,
-0.0104454141,
-0.0043013063,
0.0205573346,
0.0345034264,
0.0011205433,
-0.0499323159,
-0.0202519502,
-0.0264841188,
-0.0148537494,
0.0288109872,
-0.0119305653,
-0.0188140143,
-0.0186381042,
-0.0378485359,
0.0551941022,
0.0442895815,
0.031214226,
-0.016193511,
0.0334917046,
0.021004932,
-0.0840712413,
0.0154552301,
0.0404315777,
-0.0799073428,
0.0096177049,
-0.0004515742,
0.020481525,
-0.0186775792,
0.0435177535,
-0.0431407392,
0.0685556009,
-0.0204357393,
0.000423575,
0.0244053602,
-0.034776438,
-0.0297317505,
0.007571042,
0.023448322,
-0.0316634588,
0.0470604748,
0.0465603136,
-0.039469175,
0.0089936452,
-0.0051513403,
2.629e-7,
0.0602378361,
0.0272483062,
0.0905694589,
-0.013920527,
0.0219908915,
0.0134611912,
-0.0115820272,
0.0188025497,
-0.0138801346,
-0.0159785282,
0.0697804242,
0.0048166285,
0.0823646113,
0.0153878573,
-0.0248706024,
0.0439188331,
-0.0176107027,
-0.0363181755,
-0.0191744585,
0.0237045847,
-0.0101751443,
0.0360472873,
-0.0457344614,
-0.032623183,
0.0168359354,
-0.0049275043,
0.0371147096,
-0.0223437063,
0.0385169014,
0.0009559492,
-0.0095969988,
-0.0619020537,
-0.0311464481,
0.0669154748,
0.008743031,
0.0073452839,
0.077015236,
-0.0335225165,
-0.0227324776,
0.0558214188,
-0.01849344,
-0.016086325,
-0.0022222721,
-0.0403355584,
0.0380999893,
0.0674700737,
0.008301137,
0.0066804267,
-0.0068271807,
0.0396683253,
0.0523781776,
0.0254859645,
-0.0288044345,
0.0394050069,
0.0420624539,
0.0124185961,
0.0110040726,
-0.049645979,
0.0018515411,
-0.0267967507,
0.0161738824,
-0.0538034663,
-0.0271110088,
-0.0152398702,
0.0329773687,
0.0055706361,
-0.0048472383,
2.293822712e-34,
-0.0204616394,
-0.0220374353,
-0.0174259357,
0.0058642104,
-0.0041129566,
-0.0279614199,
0.0181562025,
0.0181545075,
0.0037980089,
-0.0435296893,
0.0046423506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14671v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14671v2 | A Survey of Diffusion Models in Natural Language Processing | 2023-05-24T03:25:32 | 2023-06-14T18:36:33 | Hao Zou, Zae Myung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This survey paper provides a comprehensive review of the use of diffusion
models in natural language processing (NLP). Diffusion models are a class of
mathematical models that aim to capture the diffusion of information or signals
across a network or manifold. In NLP, diffusion models have been used in a
variety of applications, such as natural language generation, sentiment
analysis, topic modeling, and machine translation. This paper discusses the
different formulations of diffusion models used in NLP, their strengths and
limitations, and their applications. We also perform a thorough comparison
between diffusion models and alternative generative models, specifically
highlighting the autoregressive (AR) models, while also examining how diverse
architectures incorporate the Transformer in conjunction with diffusion models.
Compared to AR models, diffusion models have significant advantages for
parallel generation, text interpolation, token-level controls such as syntactic
structures and semantic contents, and robustness. Exploring further
permutations of integrating Transformers into diffusion models would be a
valuable pursuit. Also, the development of multimodal diffusion models and
large-scale diffusion language models with notable capabilities for few-shot
learning would be important directions for the future advance of diffusion
models in NLP. | [
0.0241895691,
0.0299832337,
-0.0294057634,
0.0028164315,
-0.0630910248,
-0.0043520639,
0.0077172397,
-0.0172867253,
-0.0101432465,
-0.0491056032,
0.0256916005,
-0.0517745875,
-0.0008456758,
0.0027194754,
0.0196086001,
-0.0573098399,
0.0302476883,
0.0034526018,
-0.0312796086,
-0.005392909,
0.0076196599,
-0.0131907761,
0.0136511736,
0.0174299926,
-0.0362359583,
-0.0094416067,
-0.0106004337,
-0.0099646356,
0.0280103981,
-0.0192895792,
-0.0152019178,
0.0221899226,
0.0444641225,
-0.0116708409,
0.0000020802,
0.0095915571,
-0.0253351107,
0.0082770064,
0.0540968403,
-0.0509357899,
0.0878511891,
-0.0320227668,
0.0036682307,
0.0244773757,
-0.0304800477,
-0.0225595906,
0.066575028,
0.0486613438,
0.069018051,
0.0753294304,
-0.0379975401,
-0.0807669908,
0.0405642241,
-0.0243661944,
0.0079703936,
-0.0095604779,
0.0331679545,
0.0398586504,
-0.0181164313,
0.0161889754,
-0.0771056786,
0.025058439,
-0.0083261924,
-0.0032205768,
0.0764670447,
0.0354758278,
0.0517045669,
-0.0315418243,
-0.048574768,
0.0500810221,
-0.0253657885,
-0.0051331581,
0.040373411,
-0.0062144389,
-0.0366582312,
0.0723877698,
-0.0478176959,
-0.004163879,
0.0237107705,
0.0462136492,
0.0111427363,
-0.0025807975,
0.0165414084,
-0.0033540181,
-0.0188910682,
0.02607527,
0.0347953662,
-0.0126661649,
-0.0336747281,
0.0030106732,
0.016456116,
-0.0430285223,
0.0190341603,
0.0262262076,
0.0090475762,
0.0234953929,
0.0015194794,
-0.0490121916,
0.0136110792,
-0.0620726086,
0.0264025014,
-0.0107940603,
0.046078153,
0.0278829336,
-0.0335020348,
0.0111925602,
-0.0679587349,
-0.0384513177,
-0.0274416581,
0.0066488385,
-0.0709764063,
-0.0100681065,
-0.0177138727,
0.0474653021,
-0.0008173266,
-0.0254897308,
-0.0775846466,
0.0400616676,
-0.0033398811,
-0.0484802127,
0.0280302558,
0.0233743005,
-0.0084583266,
0.0014726131,
-0.014615071,
0.0675507039,
-0.0302241407,
0.0088503538,
0.014061545,
0.0260071158,
-0.0155740995,
0.0196344778,
0.0584513173,
-0.021188695,
-0.0228002686,
0.0614361092,
0.0102429967,
-0.0145846084,
-0.03075427,
-0.0249556545,
-0.0330859348,
-0.0418848656,
0.0354184695,
-0.0880066827,
0.003880841,
0.0114658233,
0.0204822849,
0.0147664789,
0.0016110503,
0.0291200075,
-0.0223001596,
0.0461731926,
0.0126231443,
0.0065453025,
0.0418173485,
-0.0193823334,
0.0284988377,
0.0757221207,
0.0095673725,
0.0315410756,
0.0260734782,
-0.0192450248,
-0.0087574702,
-0.00210046,
0.0130981402,
0.0084210923,
-0.0134244999,
-0.0501817465,
-0.0163828712,
-0.0090361163,
0.0257262979,
0.0659731179,
-0.0516817048,
-0.0140576111,
0.0293291397,
0.0554949716,
-0.0082452418,
0.0015079625,
0.0760048777,
-0.0020035184,
-0.0630445853,
0.0122787347,
0.0617954694,
0.0308021996,
0.0453864262,
-0.0256852116,
0.0174120143,
0.0400731526,
-0.0410656892,
-0.0406017043,
0.0117535572,
-0.0333315805,
0.0627061427,
-0.0654289648,
0.0650591329,
0.0360212885,
-0.0239703432,
0.0363133848,
-0.0073227268,
-0.0260682777,
-0.0020136286,
-0.0452183448,
-0.0045189448,
0.057842005,
0.0455039814,
0.0028576236,
0.0139045641,
-0.04572016,
0.0101267062,
0.0102625759,
0.0244871154,
0.0070507415,
-0.0419316478,
-0.0339313,
-0.0135393431,
0.033562243,
0.0244530067,
0.0129008796,
-0.0397411622,
0.0258562136,
0.0216093529,
-0.0148138506,
-0.0059201168,
0.0208875258,
-0.034581814,
-0.0013864365,
0.0305049364,
-0.0206624381,
0.0528531484,
0.0172568616,
-0.0058028097,
0.000366304,
0.0086016664,
-0.0399631076,
-0.0829642564,
0.0580734499,
-0.0283277687,
-0.0463708192,
-0.0025698142,
-0.0523175187,
0.0214647576,
0.0161589887,
-0.0389441587,
-0.0371997282,
0.0479574725,
-0.0512104221,
0.0409249961,
-0.0350370184,
0.0109195244,
0.0235583335,
0.0292124785,
-0.0253103878,
0.0717230365,
-0.0123957405,
0.0196706485,
-0.0189127866,
0.0269145183,
0.0160337947,
0.0209192224,
-0.0384720378,
-0.0119234156,
0.0105547076,
0.004695755,
0.0390051156,
-0.0559910573,
-0.0264020339,
-0.0249232072,
-0.0547941662,
0.0062383139,
-0.0336465463,
0.0070148176,
0.016118871,
0.0242038704,
0.0311192106,
0.0237116739,
-0.0186897721,
0.0374971852,
0.0212523509,
0.0252705161,
0.0353224166,
-0.0433396511,
-0.0130983293,
-0.0335291401,
-0.0398028903,
-0.0182797797,
0.0790567175,
0.0042857449,
-0.0243057013,
-0.0428204685,
-0.0090858927,
-0.0168716256,
0.009318104,
-0.0312863365,
-0.0380324312,
-0.0095182918,
-0.0170843601,
0.1000130549,
0.0095974486,
0.0512541458,
0.059094891,
-0.0249063279,
-0.0326541774,
-0.0119897034,
-0.0085736588,
-0.0925115421,
0.0516059361,
-0.0311646163,
-0.0416987874,
0.006986673,
0.0863491222,
0.0271954481,
-0.0433780216,
-0.034934029,
-0.0247140713,
-0.0440308489,
-0.0318871737,
0.0152299209,
-0.016770469,
-0.014664501,
-0.0306327958,
-0.0225799605,
-0.0468161553,
0.0589825474,
-0.0049917223,
0.0438556746,
-0.054920651,
-0.0330698378,
-0.0384780727,
0.028771501,
0.0393796526,
0.0148252798,
-0.0022324009,
-0.0068180426,
-0.0027305423,
0.020389298,
0.0173484143,
-0.0086867344,
0.0214616265,
0.0154093578,
0.0345159955,
0.0206443947,
0.0196133945,
-0.0102288667,
-0.0926800072,
0.0209131334,
0.0050133467,
0.0133637106,
-0.0126261506,
-0.0024599568,
0.0377732702,
-0.0027260093,
0.0003983116,
0.012965112,
-0.0210984536,
-0.0265481379,
0.0701561198,
0.0619539209,
-0.0373458154,
-0.0087606953,
-0.0125481905,
0.0272734519,
0.0460941978,
0.0374464281,
0.004898943,
-0.0611451119,
-0.0150576215,
-0.0296835564,
-0.0306515582,
-0.0271106064,
-0.0093587274,
0.0395727456,
-0.0175582692,
-0.0199906956,
0.0775171518,
0.0094404146,
-0.0305586532,
0.0133802658,
0.052029673,
0.0385916568,
0.007713099,
-0.0212575141,
-0.0611436442,
0.0012556586,
-0.0218850747,
-0.0348744094,
-0.0213178359,
-0.0316393748,
0.0147335296,
-0.0830499679,
0.0483765379,
0.0087964926,
0.0220690928,
0.016752746,
-0.0927823558,
-0.0069557256,
0.0046946094,
-0.03921609,
-0.0512526408,
-0.0187775455,
-0.001357298,
0.0285203885,
0.0019063826,
-0.0582155325,
-0.0149341775,
-0.0286169127,
0.0301165357,
0.0513285957,
0.0327347741,
-0.022509383,
-0.0590708628,
0.0276691839,
-0.0110415723,
0.0087750675,
-0.0269181337,
0.0433330759,
-0.0076055122,
-0.0136493118,
-0.008346919,
-0.0080484478,
-0.0362434909,
-0.0158387404,
-0.0428434312,
0.1078354642,
-0.0217282455,
-0.0611051284,
-0.049133826,
0.0062165535,
0.0332328379,
0.0499737822,
0.0173660573,
-0.0452423319,
-0.0460581668,
0.0095003154,
0.0489363745,
-0.0089894375,
-0.0493313074,
-0.0242340155,
-0.0118593024,
-0.0954939499,
-0.1069586426,
-0.0027633018,
-0.0279021524,
0.0399425253,
-0.0100726802,
0.0313702859,
0.0680682585,
-0.0583326854,
-0.0511905774,
-0.0305043906,
0.0147652198,
0.0139492871,
-0.0090796929,
-0.0080867223,
0.0773164034,
0.0090183672,
-0.0493082069,
0.0037232132,
-0.1353407502,
-0.0937261209,
-0.0060134954,
0.0364024974,
0.0133245802,
-0.0027023393,
-0.0151205799,
-0.0269136913,
0.0715727061,
0.049881056,
0.0167562515,
0.0031316865,
-0.0077083865,
-0.0270460546,
-0.0030150688,
-0.0001314258,
-0.0049635088,
0.0760696307,
-0.0284800734,
0.033616703,
-0.0423589498,
0.0343856141,
0.0062040272,
-0.0421200842,
0.0443536267,
0.0175083578,
0.006176441,
-0.0434143506,
-0.023994064,
-0.0347247161,
-0.0138557274,
-0.0483537018,
-0.0205102116,
0.0390076973,
0.017013602,
-0.0541027635,
-0.0080413362,
0.0043160454,
0.0169756338,
0.0092607662,
0.0214780737,
0.0163294189,
0.0092144748,
-0.0016731754,
0.0289103463,
0.0171551909,
-0.038431745,
0.0088035539,
-0.0007173326,
0.0064580785,
0.0478182547,
0.0027753187,
0.0099834464,
-0.0249148179,
-0.0012884769,
-0.0843824223,
0.0187912285,
0.0004651918,
0.0220680255,
0.0327591747,
0.0024603233,
0.0673696101,
-0.0188822206,
0.0079249907,
0.0088282414,
0.0229734853,
-0.0056066746,
-0.0066297487,
0.0430678166,
0.0206053313,
-0.0219534393,
0.0037839259,
0.0660817027,
-0.0464468114,
0.020807568,
-0.0075342655,
-0.0469148718,
-0.0328116678,
0.0082670068,
-0.0410310589,
-0.0221928507,
0.0504602641,
0.0288054105,
-0.041343268,
-0.0658266619,
0.0259598866,
-0.0274000969,
0.0293651652,
-0.0194474496,
0.0472590178,
0.0822524652,
0.0185007453,
0.0182569921,
-0.0744778812,
0.0347370021,
-0.0529600196,
-0.0162611529,
0.0016419829,
-6.924538204e-33,
-0.0014947848,
-0.0421866812,
0.0116778994,
-0.0129534109,
-0.0652510375,
0.0053464561,
-0.0239697024,
-0.0082759447,
-0.0030824486,
0.0308417045,
0.0149939926,
0.043208085,
-0.0010196865,
0.0347748213,
0.009704479,
0.0153328897,
0.067288518,
-0.0242407694,
0.0289100427,
0.0251949187,
0.0479153246,
0.0393641554,
0.0478295311,
-0.0150165269,
0.0029099083,
0.0116298515,
0.01132912,
-0.0126927113,
0.0423496254,
0.0383916646,
-0.0293420814,
0.0389525332,
0.0548432022,
-0.0471782535,
-0.022895366,
0.039924182,
-0.0577586778,
-0.0301249996,
-0.0094735557,
-0.0065500438,
-0.0332446098,
-0.0230034422,
0.0971356407,
-0.0080301836,
-0.0091939932,
0.0161786266,
0.0568509288,
0.0081201931,
0.0064580757,
-0.0148224486,
-0.0558738895,
0.0423073955,
-0.0163501836,
0.0243098065,
0.0143621918,
0.0121651459,
0.0032762685,
0.0541796535,
-0.092261754,
0.0217913222,
-0.0137214782,
0.0432611592,
0.009493785,
0.0052227816,
0.0362858661,
0.0596776158,
0.0193426814,
0.0382227749,
-0.0104131773,
0.0322905071,
-0.0032604923,
0.0380273946,
0.0133628231,
0.0114523526,
0.0339147411,
-0.0335859023,
-0.0546835437,
0.0143172722,
-0.0254062675,
0.0338451155,
0.0562932715,
0.0097826524,
-0.0195898898,
-0.0096598584,
-0.0106109204,
-0.0278556347,
0.0228841361,
-0.0448457301,
0.0019581506,
0.0425719656,
-0.0077557731,
0.0203251336,
0.0458687507,
-0.0382227339,
-0.0438252762,
-0.0128948269,
-0.0191780776,
0.0497269556,
0.0176130701,
0.0223191492,
-0.0674251318,
-0.0303701051,
-0.0245347712,
0.0485569015,
-0.0068361526,
-0.0183962565,
-0.0042597353,
0.0269344747,
-0.0696798488,
-0.0175323375,
-0.0237586908,
0.004086616,
-0.0285413489,
0.0242128652,
0.0075761043,
0.0189531296,
-0.0385139547,
0.055894617,
0.0344980992,
0.0213701334,
0.0251912083,
0.0064694188,
-0.0125515992,
0.0278526824,
-0.0431041494,
-0.0064600264,
-0.0245544296,
0.0734212324,
0.063315846,
-0.0888961479,
-0.0297855362,
0.02035385,
2.922e-7,
0.040235877,
0.0462978333,
0.0144710997,
0.0067357221,
0.0358267762,
0.015825253,
0.0198021196,
0.0234137811,
0.0181436352,
-0.0321737714,
-0.0042764284,
0.0213962942,
-0.022615267,
0.0026466686,
-0.0935054868,
0.0176112559,
-0.0489763916,
0.0228308216,
-0.0045031914,
-0.0147705488,
0.0470467284,
0.0672258288,
0.0052809422,
0.009447231,
-0.0190411117,
0.0196914822,
0.1026971564,
0.0049433885,
-0.0177548062,
0.0238163043,
0.0024869032,
-0.0265931599,
0.0021104596,
0.0104345931,
-0.036963094,
0.0111165699,
0.0205911994,
0.0013088326,
-0.0228412803,
-0.0300668795,
0.0355284996,
0.0087876329,
-0.0075968108,
-0.026225958,
0.0597670525,
-0.0605367497,
-0.0299893077,
-0.064457491,
-0.0899571553,
0.0128603829,
0.0485995412,
0.0152421324,
-0.0588732101,
0.0117293708,
0.0085951397,
0.025911767,
-0.0311632734,
-0.07968577,
0.0342798047,
-0.0142097594,
-0.059085235,
-0.0432045944,
-0.0274142288,
-0.0156645291,
0.0240789726,
0.0008337642,
-0.0159913972,
2.557898666e-34,
0.0771589577,
-0.0045389785,
-0.008170913,
0.0099316379,
0.0093013691,
-0.0043334421,
-0.0569947511,
0.0146497125,
0.0255772881,
-0.0907417163,
-0.0348028615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14663v2 | You Are What You Annotate: Towards Better Models through Annotator Representations | 2023-05-24T03:06:13 | 2023-10-22T17:10:54 | Naihao Deng, Xinliang Frederick Zhang, Siyang Liu, Winston Wu, Lu Wang, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annotator disagreement is ubiquitous in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. There are multiple reasons for such disagreements, including the
subjectivity of the task, difficult cases, unclear guidelines, and so on.
Rather than simply aggregating labels to obtain data annotations, we instead
try to directly model the diverse perspectives of the annotators, and
explicitly account for annotators' idiosyncrasies in the modeling process by
creating representations for each annotator (annotator embeddings) and also
their annotations (annotation embeddings). In addition, we propose TID-8, The
Inherent Disagreement - 8 dataset, a benchmark that consists of eight existing
language understanding datasets that have inherent annotator disagreement. We
test our approach on TID-8 and show that our approach helps models learn
significantly better from disagreements on six different datasets in TID-8
while increasing model size by fewer than 1% parameters. By capturing the
unique tendencies and subjectivity of individual annotators through embeddings,
our representations prime AI models to be inclusive of diverse viewpoints. | [
0.0511472337,
0.0304685403,
0.0037588098,
0.059443295,
-0.0268192235,
0.045737002,
0.0005224951,
-0.0583472848,
0.0031685261,
-0.0899522975,
-0.023140287,
-0.0122572817,
-0.0177158713,
-0.00735413,
-0.0052029267,
-0.0732681453,
0.0318218023,
0.0149378376,
0.0572042391,
0.0171729401,
0.0293739084,
-0.0061737993,
-0.016998481,
0.0823612511,
-0.0534690693,
-0.0248752441,
0.0063719479,
-0.0158019084,
0.0160972942,
-0.0183684565,
0.0200825594,
0.0471060649,
0.0275550671,
0.0915628746,
0.0000017909,
-0.0180142876,
0.0077398196,
0.0040855315,
-0.0381849557,
-0.0034971936,
0.0133938882,
-0.0071250009,
0.0170685202,
-0.018003324,
-0.0376576595,
-0.0048396108,
0.0345159546,
0.0849006623,
0.0868045613,
0.0636277571,
0.0245006774,
-0.0124828098,
-0.0337958187,
-0.0140033029,
-0.0329818316,
-0.0368401408,
-0.0107513862,
0.0343393534,
-0.0312303174,
0.0154090989,
-0.0264095608,
0.028843645,
0.0060667498,
-0.0190919321,
0.0149642946,
0.0008546644,
-0.0511580929,
-0.0400506333,
0.0082859145,
0.0765739828,
0.024938887,
-0.0369477272,
-0.0331313349,
-0.0195399802,
0.0095428498,
-0.0221566055,
-0.0339967944,
0.0229513589,
-0.006031998,
0.0297261775,
0.0332077779,
0.0262670368,
0.0350669138,
-0.0123391561,
-0.011403041,
0.0558226258,
-0.0246523302,
-0.0273411795,
0.0291693211,
0.0265689828,
-0.0486217812,
-0.0169486813,
0.0027506554,
0.0050487262,
-0.0186640415,
0.0296536647,
-0.0430241749,
-0.0381793678,
0.0203549191,
-0.0796294585,
0.0110038053,
0.0289518759,
-0.0335193574,
0.0598034412,
0.0122589115,
-0.0179892108,
-0.0060252445,
0.0278639477,
-0.0324926935,
-0.0440570451,
-0.0787735209,
-0.0109710675,
-0.0213010795,
0.0292445775,
-0.0113071734,
-0.0189182237,
0.0040647699,
0.0119257923,
-0.0719812363,
0.0108624808,
0.0117651066,
0.0192383956,
-0.0066488907,
0.016800683,
-0.0353891402,
0.003617828,
-0.0519935004,
0.0116092516,
-0.0084013203,
-0.0624057315,
-0.0193070136,
0.0224514101,
-0.0199100915,
-0.0238970201,
-0.0137135154,
0.0166361332,
0.029599499,
-0.0201590527,
-0.0171459299,
-0.0140914274,
-0.0135662733,
-0.0430142172,
0.0016476373,
-0.039527256,
0.0409277007,
-0.0042278566,
0.0195946191,
-0.0653854981,
0.0015185862,
0.003749239,
-0.0130113447,
0.1102745831,
-0.0223496463,
-0.054885529,
0.0554991663,
0.0165011361,
-0.0203277338,
0.0742053166,
0.0014185989,
-0.0387348048,
0.0518024601,
0.0232772958,
0.0097288676,
-0.0316400267,
0.006400872,
-0.0217612572,
0.0196927134,
0.0139376689,
-0.0271086078,
0.0279126298,
0.0186881479,
0.0353806615,
-0.0319783166,
-0.0564090945,
0.0250838026,
0.0534648038,
-0.0247701891,
0.0017615188,
0.0327721387,
0.008137852,
0.0056797704,
-0.0091598891,
-0.0183785278,
0.0214363597,
-0.0146145923,
-0.033649426,
0.0123003172,
-0.0186868478,
-0.0164596383,
-0.0632802397,
-0.0418793783,
-0.0096983062,
0.0066090194,
0.0045096041,
0.0003496519,
0.0018518101,
0.0106049562,
0.0447165519,
0.0198825952,
-0.0422658101,
-0.0448862724,
0.0044643846,
0.0356720239,
0.0237469152,
0.0212462544,
-0.0593850389,
-0.0659335703,
-0.0499325991,
0.0071795853,
0.0405936986,
0.104783915,
-0.0438273698,
0.003492801,
-0.0570796169,
-0.0336524434,
-0.0294979531,
0.0512680225,
0.0107662659,
-0.0023237411,
-0.0387079976,
0.0146861766,
-0.0234872643,
-0.0526087321,
0.0634350702,
-0.0139670027,
-0.0219628699,
0.0047343858,
0.0208771639,
0.0602266714,
0.0493067838,
-0.0013401668,
0.0238195993,
0.0139445923,
-0.0335967094,
-0.0302403606,
0.0352901816,
-0.0255089924,
-0.0354679823,
0.0337318629,
-0.0462875701,
-0.0265665296,
-0.001217461,
-0.0543684326,
-0.0382419415,
-0.0012082547,
-0.037192408,
0.0112187248,
-0.0273046568,
-0.0187199079,
-0.0056959013,
-0.0020463911,
-0.0442424789,
0.0430974662,
-0.024176769,
0.0040698792,
0.0027390064,
-0.0090816272,
0.0479257032,
-0.0155778145,
-0.0642849803,
0.0091846054,
0.0240061954,
-0.0020679096,
0.0460172594,
-0.0323867202,
-0.0374023356,
-0.003077538,
-0.0935812667,
-0.0117191402,
-0.0298534166,
-0.002025611,
0.0189014506,
-0.0656892732,
0.0205358211,
-0.0281790234,
-0.000868383,
-0.0328021348,
-0.024604436,
0.0220053531,
0.0418890789,
0.0033094934,
0.0072810305,
-0.0533869788,
0.0028318088,
-0.030214021,
0.0322038196,
-0.0028091534,
-0.0465739667,
-0.0509852804,
-0.0340834931,
-0.0210293718,
0.0462032408,
-0.0065492098,
0.0260593444,
0.0538868196,
0.0252726544,
-0.0212984625,
0.0479046106,
0.0022635863,
0.0954314843,
0.0809981599,
-0.0050368588,
-0.0802059248,
0.0230674986,
0.0207773596,
0.0534022599,
-0.0300088469,
-0.0231223851,
0.0087958202,
0.0760839656,
-0.0121283187,
-0.0238577165,
-0.0806243122,
0.0428843275,
-0.0408518761,
-0.0137320664,
-0.0010288379,
-0.0221422426,
0.0001231306,
0.0494542159,
-0.0334263295,
-0.0056436751,
0.1037931219,
-0.0288676564,
0.0181173719,
-0.0488432907,
0.0105211874,
-0.0398123972,
0.0493808277,
-0.026172597,
-0.005081831,
0.020886438,
0.0059034289,
-0.0109620579,
0.016912939,
0.0555322282,
-0.0177788474,
0.0453908779,
-0.0371133275,
0.0053074942,
0.0032496681,
-0.0252209306,
-0.0410884582,
-0.0398909785,
-0.0565547533,
0.0252189171,
0.0159765258,
0.0169075876,
-0.0238998327,
-0.0312412623,
-0.0225787517,
0.0194031466,
0.0225877706,
-0.0069133486,
-0.0161507092,
-0.0209042113,
0.0031510578,
0.046943441,
0.0681349337,
0.0163720381,
0.0473948717,
0.0244842358,
-0.0073156781,
-0.0082814386,
-0.0520287305,
-0.0326464809,
0.0201014318,
-0.051400058,
-0.0415121503,
-0.0275992565,
0.0591679029,
-0.0655993074,
-0.0110121993,
0.1079800278,
0.0507940464,
-0.0337728225,
-0.0042950925,
-0.0277428776,
0.0256039649,
0.0570589267,
0.0033334428,
-0.0562244654,
-0.0343328677,
-0.0007729342,
0.0139577771,
-0.0080587622,
-0.0378810279,
-0.0120607428,
-0.1000418216,
0.02442169,
0.0027850748,
-0.0148624079,
-0.010005556,
-0.015680138,
-0.0167161599,
-0.0319025815,
0.026174698,
-0.027959818,
0.0390176028,
0.0308517274,
0.0344442874,
-0.0372088514,
-0.0472008325,
0.030840259,
-0.0271070842,
0.0917776898,
0.0180185623,
0.0468251444,
0.0208064616,
-0.0034628306,
0.0368541814,
0.0159679409,
-0.0150986826,
-0.0193070527,
0.0576985851,
-0.0097257169,
-0.0126038967,
0.0029480257,
0.0205824785,
-0.0327298976,
-0.0393981747,
-0.0077275736,
0.0618511215,
-0.0326193571,
0.0330724008,
-0.0221434757,
0.010832781,
0.0007882899,
0.0812904611,
0.0580258407,
-0.0144607844,
-0.0327055492,
-0.0409162901,
0.0333104581,
-0.0431276672,
-0.0189248845,
0.0101722321,
0.0234287642,
-0.0257396717,
-0.0508211032,
-0.0821741521,
0.0137244659,
0.0261443313,
0.01784686,
-0.0160048101,
0.0181996375,
-0.0080462964,
-0.0046780249,
0.0509648733,
-0.0114283049,
-0.0136995818,
0.0085182637,
-0.0158246048,
0.0154327778,
0.0270744953,
-0.0301977135,
0.0323762149,
-0.0460143797,
-0.049393747,
0.0012340699,
0.0525608286,
0.0144582549,
0.066459991,
-0.0251635965,
-0.0664554983,
-0.0399701484,
0.0091120508,
0.0371283963,
-0.0198144913,
0.0539493561,
0.0381486192,
-0.001020494,
0.0588430092,
-0.0272301417,
-0.0040902281,
-0.0027032085,
0.0319531038,
-0.0581078641,
-0.032495074,
0.0431588106,
-0.0008375033,
0.0415706635,
0.0167516489,
0.0033685223,
-0.0559742488,
-0.0033409258,
-0.0080488035,
-0.0549330041,
-0.0300444979,
0.0164969768,
0.001224867,
-0.0841901898,
-0.0264667477,
0.0253546406,
-0.0006135571,
0.0545268431,
-0.0327410325,
0.0148403775,
0.0670296624,
-0.00599004,
-0.056898687,
0.0044871415,
-0.0309799109,
0.032662835,
-0.0013332497,
0.0263414383,
0.0112101315,
0.0384832546,
0.0096037919,
0.0111328261,
-0.0058442084,
0.0047140326,
-0.0613290891,
-0.0268611349,
-0.0099670514,
0.0490494817,
0.0385041982,
-0.0296713784,
0.0544911772,
-0.0183277484,
-0.018999815,
-0.0031280429,
0.0231951028,
0.0268788822,
-0.0332232118,
0.0645707175,
0.0220750514,
-0.0269051343,
-0.0276875179,
0.0559377186,
-0.0410772823,
0.0475986339,
-0.011182487,
-0.0481966287,
-0.0691845343,
-0.0228848178,
0.0097394083,
0.0681598634,
-0.0221923999,
0.0537979826,
-0.0628689304,
-0.0328055806,
-0.001316094,
0.018192403,
-0.0164821204,
0.0105518568,
-0.0037418245,
0.0432215557,
-0.005786777,
-0.0179274157,
-0.0378362052,
-0.0068621165,
0.009669465,
-0.0059659826,
-0.0469888039,
-5.768230493e-33,
-0.032050252,
0.0115138795,
-0.0201007184,
0.0168011375,
0.0020855467,
-0.0154306171,
-0.0175220277,
0.0262020864,
-0.0386053957,
0.0347200781,
0.0054884148,
0.0415178761,
0.0141527103,
0.0082544563,
0.0371411592,
-0.0377792828,
0.053251408,
0.0087449942,
-0.0283403713,
-0.0177909043,
0.0559680723,
-0.0094366902,
0.0508423224,
-0.1124946475,
0.0798434839,
0.0104498127,
-0.0040066829,
0.0443721786,
-0.0074687218,
0.0648372769,
-0.0180421546,
0.0626355559,
0.025211677,
-0.0260176435,
-0.0059124301,
-0.0227245465,
-0.0642318428,
-0.0420090072,
0.0084299622,
0.0398102961,
-0.0322837122,
-0.0506662726,
0.0360347927,
0.0061072246,
0.0236639343,
0.0174541883,
0.030854499,
-0.0231132209,
0.0243916735,
0.0144807287,
-0.0658731461,
0.0434773415,
-0.0517913476,
-0.0486709066,
0.0463181697,
0.0330816358,
0.0232700724,
0.0105679939,
-0.0953279212,
-0.0201728977,
-0.0220127627,
-0.0044342717,
0.0460038669,
-0.0183191132,
-0.0283847861,
0.0738813952,
-0.0037865557,
0.0125355609,
-0.0284892228,
-0.0436064042,
-0.0174005721,
0.0310435183,
0.0229030326,
0.0517489463,
0.0058382615,
0.0041448534,
-0.0278455969,
0.0054348526,
0.0502474084,
0.0083197858,
0.0262770541,
0.0190192461,
-0.0588724203,
-0.0013337309,
-0.0585311912,
-0.0774148107,
-0.0291022565,
0.0208853781,
0.0255255047,
0.0073332256,
-0.035604801,
0.0350795351,
0.0071854768,
-0.0536023453,
-0.0031331412,
0.0207293481,
0.0129129775,
-0.0211968198,
0.0315362215,
0.0153077412,
-0.0316987559,
-0.0029953194,
0.0044425963,
-0.005096178,
0.0300389174,
-0.0214278568,
0.1036725789,
-0.0172316208,
-0.0460181907,
-0.0135995662,
-0.0361345597,
0.0102442401,
-0.0402442254,
0.0167760644,
0.0381633304,
0.0461414233,
-0.038059622,
0.0285032317,
0.0251605846,
0.0353711173,
-0.0054262071,
-0.0040119453,
-0.0312776677,
-0.019697316,
0.0146384025,
-0.0262054261,
0.03156396,
0.0246061515,
-0.0012460777,
-0.0307819284,
-0.0028016511,
0.0064909132,
2.342e-7,
0.0826307759,
0.043100141,
0.0339142233,
-0.0272864886,
0.0325662903,
0.0561847016,
-0.0268085152,
0.0163225606,
-0.0343175307,
-0.0621452965,
-0.0207104925,
0.0285897385,
0.024563469,
0.0661111847,
-0.0287916418,
-0.0308830533,
-0.0434836298,
0.0160154868,
-0.0155899953,
-0.0326930322,
0.099331215,
0.1026085988,
0.0148800937,
0.0184494779,
-0.0175436866,
0.0159486122,
0.0622723661,
-0.0098780235,
0.0141611723,
0.0165798068,
0.0593257286,
0.0097443238,
0.0243089199,
0.0310214516,
-0.0034414602,
0.0274199769,
0.0149784936,
0.0523992665,
-0.0149819832,
-0.046832595,
-0.0379483104,
0.0057810619,
0.0198636558,
-0.0377306603,
0.0467315167,
-0.035809163,
-0.054398343,
-0.069565095,
0.0042353482,
0.0150499893,
0.0873183087,
0.010486234,
-0.004805868,
0.0100798616,
-0.0076636588,
-0.0420683846,
-0.0101697464,
-0.0957856178,
-0.0321911946,
-0.0175993871,
-0.0358575881,
0.0435302109,
-0.002447292,
0.0028537787,
0.0531099588,
-0.0306853801,
0.0223137476,
1.724595772e-34,
0.0423876494,
0.0137047395,
0.0090791984,
0.036155697,
0.0482334606,
-0.0002547183,
-0.0079776021,
-0.0018289265,
0.0163426511,
-0.0023170083,
0.0017380307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14660v1 | Complex Mathematical Symbol Definition Structures: A Dataset and Model for Coordination Resolution in Definition Extraction | 2023-05-24T02:53:48 | 2023-05-24T02:53:48 | Anna Martin-Boyle, Andrew Head, Kyle Lo, Risham Sidhu, Marti A. Hearst, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Mathematical symbol definition extraction is important for improving
scholarly reading interfaces and scholarly information extraction (IE).
However, the task poses several challenges: math symbols are difficult to
process as they are not composed of natural language morphemes; and scholarly
papers often contain sentences that require resolving complex coordinate
structures. We present SymDef, an English language dataset of 5,927 sentences
from full-text scientific papers where each sentence is annotated with all
mathematical symbols linked with their corresponding definitions. This dataset
focuses specifically on complex coordination structures such as "respectively"
constructions, which often contain overlapping definition spans. We also
introduce a new definition extraction method that masks mathematical symbols,
creates a copy of each sentence for each symbol, specifies a target symbol, and
predicts its corresponding definition spans using slot filling. Our experiments
show that our definition extraction model significantly outperforms RoBERTa and
other strong IE baseline systems by 10.9 points with a macro F1 score of 84.82.
With our dataset and model, we can detect complex definitions in scholarly
documents to make scientific writing more readable. | [
-0.033548627,
0.0745697469,
-0.0022906938,
0.0390171036,
-0.0414657146,
0.006430727,
0.0311644841,
-0.0085568354,
-0.0509444475,
-0.0235570669,
-0.0344877169,
0.0362287164,
-0.0008983568,
0.0187211167,
0.0189082976,
-0.0300340839,
0.045426961,
-0.0364512689,
0.0196933113,
0.021223193,
0.0247644987,
-0.0088738203,
-0.0003427651,
-0.0053790128,
-0.0063675507,
-0.0797701553,
0.0429518074,
-0.032236632,
0.0602291115,
-0.0416167676,
-0.0179787222,
0.0557811856,
-0.0239382721,
0.0305851027,
0.0000017028,
-0.032776285,
-0.0727548227,
0.0346445888,
-0.0204433873,
0.0085750148,
0.0375491641,
-0.0870304927,
0.0098611871,
-0.0569990315,
-0.0282186214,
0.0103588337,
0.0167824589,
0.0005515905,
-0.0141618643,
0.0017096859,
-0.0240569077,
-0.0657927692,
0.0422030687,
0.0084010717,
0.0067236056,
-0.0340802297,
0.0371803381,
0.0279026926,
-0.0133939758,
0.0363242589,
-0.0053642406,
0.0328181721,
0.0059787114,
-0.007735624,
0.0205306821,
0.0045116697,
-0.008523359,
0.017980041,
0.0092376675,
0.0556260273,
0.0065318951,
-0.0176752359,
0.0332690068,
-0.0003024172,
-0.0006138201,
0.0756381229,
-0.0597711354,
-0.0052533587,
-0.0625143573,
-0.0265483987,
0.0409024134,
0.0186915565,
0.0268964358,
0.0324610956,
-0.0685352013,
0.0530125126,
0.0258389711,
-0.0364822447,
-0.0171502829,
-0.0299530979,
-0.0808198899,
0.0112217804,
0.0642883331,
-0.0174668152,
0.0504198559,
0.0297525432,
-0.0736588985,
-0.124932304,
-0.0022378238,
-0.0050501786,
0.0073580961,
0.0097447764,
0.0039366568,
0.013775995,
-0.0208701584,
0.0348520726,
-0.0319293439,
0.0235100202,
-0.0169597808,
0.0386442617,
0.0045624012,
-0.0105361585,
-0.0227690954,
0.0077932938,
-0.0041651139,
-0.0261928346,
-0.0338931493,
-0.0165015962,
-0.0415317714,
0.0289145876,
-0.0655976236,
-0.065114677,
-0.0435431227,
-0.0240416918,
0.0417849049,
-0.0156160891,
-0.0314790308,
-0.0164907724,
-0.0077700634,
-0.0098375361,
-0.0307247639,
0.0498877801,
0.0152320322,
-0.030543847,
-0.0302612465,
0.0325570516,
0.0381196178,
-0.0115125906,
0.1076648235,
-0.0624452904,
0.0191234834,
-0.023144478,
-0.0178058166,
-0.0515158996,
0.073924534,
0.0304756127,
-0.0087104365,
-0.0693976432,
0.0083516538,
0.0236427169,
-0.0015137774,
0.0741366446,
-0.0478914939,
-0.0142970942,
0.0141022755,
0.0182412006,
-0.0142904036,
-0.0102844769,
0.0358096696,
-0.041178979,
0.0621907599,
-0.0008617105,
0.0177765265,
0.0323884226,
0.0071962834,
-0.0475410596,
0.0047935424,
0.0108154155,
0.0088769654,
0.0537993051,
0.008177097,
0.0314632058,
-0.074207224,
-0.0261521693,
-0.0326652825,
0.0682846531,
0.061792545,
-0.0051106964,
0.0060506877,
0.0119418036,
0.0760308355,
0.0019122298,
-0.0194684919,
-0.0373961329,
0.0067684012,
0.0471430309,
-0.0411900952,
-0.0126120476,
0.0443139374,
-0.0206341613,
-0.0156002408,
0.0069609131,
-0.0438987091,
-0.0312357172,
0.0812662095,
-0.0105175059,
-0.0098407483,
0.0434224308,
-0.0254038442,
-0.0230488442,
0.0343507342,
0.0217867699,
-0.0052595497,
0.0179401375,
0.0580121987,
-0.0876747146,
-0.0375398546,
0.0413029529,
0.0099701704,
0.0548659787,
-0.0174386594,
-0.0210660491,
-0.0160277151,
-0.0318943523,
-0.0123968339,
0.0063866405,
0.0130380066,
-0.0016903488,
0.0048611318,
0.0225504059,
0.0091246367,
-0.0218572021,
-0.047897391,
0.0547643453,
-0.0172539186,
-0.0290577766,
-0.0275967754,
-0.0216635708,
0.0148560796,
0.0001303788,
-0.0106987385,
0.04514388,
0.0298369471,
-0.0892826989,
0.0470062234,
0.0141101545,
-0.0242171045,
-0.0157715697,
0.041200038,
-0.070435822,
0.0253568366,
0.0090507725,
0.0219348539,
-0.0234781802,
0.0272475127,
-0.0058274413,
-0.0132018598,
0.0058240797,
0.0019348282,
0.021620743,
0.0168416202,
-0.0325365737,
0.0535936989,
0.0311374534,
0.0409674644,
0.0591489896,
0.0003541723,
-0.0096429866,
0.0487614423,
0.0161143187,
-0.025331879,
0.0154467961,
-0.0451410599,
0.0099459942,
-0.0135185402,
-0.0089854812,
-0.0562297776,
0.025996957,
0.0359149314,
-0.005120378,
0.0724473968,
0.0321819298,
-0.0492237881,
0.0099279629,
0.0208899248,
0.0478017703,
-0.0001277983,
-0.0188622177,
-0.041725859,
0.0585092306,
0.02382043,
-0.040741872,
-0.0344149694,
-0.0266089197,
-0.0489696115,
0.0232177544,
0.0605612248,
-0.0272786934,
-0.0277296118,
-0.0004158515,
0.032439243,
-0.0216308534,
-0.0273128636,
0.0313952304,
0.0182295777,
-0.02276095,
-0.0087832185,
0.0395582318,
-0.0075723734,
0.0126925474,
0.0010139233,
-0.050030943,
-0.0414373502,
-0.0197030567,
0.017049659,
0.0767607391,
-0.0010455832,
0.0109472517,
0.0454667732,
0.0324373469,
-0.0315504447,
0.017182095,
0.0379871428,
0.0356124006,
-0.0278532598,
-0.0058216061,
-0.0132356463,
-0.0013252181,
-0.0525405109,
0.0350262187,
-0.0136609329,
-0.0193761177,
0.0120055834,
-0.0056860973,
-0.0288972948,
-0.0706187338,
0.0332012847,
-0.0675332397,
-0.0101116616,
-0.0077617001,
-0.0271814689,
0.0416968577,
-0.0689712688,
-0.00995446,
0.0188043285,
0.0468373597,
-0.0279244129,
0.0069738175,
-0.0350639112,
0.0355549231,
-0.040525455,
0.0213283598,
-0.0093172779,
0.0106388927,
0.0066803605,
0.0190148391,
0.0305448584,
-0.0428462438,
-0.0227812137,
0.0119594699,
0.0299129728,
0.0450784639,
-0.0196068063,
-0.0084819086,
-0.0533321127,
0.0178708099,
0.0440915748,
0.0040106522,
0.0023372415,
-0.0685797706,
0.018431928,
0.0234155972,
-0.056896966,
0.0133593827,
0.0186480992,
-0.0361342393,
0.028615918,
-0.0626789182,
-0.0193560999,
-0.0028132652,
-0.032391347,
-0.0406640433,
0.0037223345,
0.0659491271,
0.0192086231,
-0.0208682381,
-0.0349999033,
-0.0272967275,
0.0241672453,
-0.0200687554,
-0.0238849055,
-0.1390888244,
0.0069070538,
0.0141945668,
-0.003823906,
0.0416553617,
-0.0298589729,
0.0180642586,
-0.0067349793,
0.0006932732,
0.0143949259,
-0.057720948,
-0.002549178,
-0.0110959746,
0.0261676554,
0.0045598769,
-0.037575312,
0.0356341749,
-0.0432449654,
0.0048276838,
-0.0202453379,
-0.0496744737,
-0.0347191542,
-0.0645670146,
-0.0459369086,
-0.0598142594,
-0.0218002182,
0.0344416648,
-0.0268310532,
0.0228210855,
-0.0023871658,
-0.0231091287,
-0.0268936772,
-0.0143297138,
0.0218823794,
0.0013816596,
-0.0038536801,
-0.0213307422,
0.0589169599,
-0.0920892209,
-0.0498654656,
0.0352539085,
0.0330048203,
0.0200243685,
0.014370529,
-0.0602699406,
0.0109027,
-0.0314680561,
0.0342932157,
0.0118566528,
0.0036025629,
-0.0430756472,
0.0110649541,
0.0361867733,
-0.0616733097,
-0.0346888229,
-0.036316257,
-0.0187290441,
-0.0474451818,
-0.0396900028,
-0.0124817016,
0.0318540856,
0.0313869566,
0.0360710621,
0.0354675688,
0.0051571298,
-0.0244834442,
-0.0701281726,
0.0239756797,
-0.0158548243,
0.0037895562,
-0.0189385917,
0.0151489973,
-0.0285142772,
0.0363047607,
-0.0411764309,
0.037482433,
-0.0021142256,
-0.0302789547,
0.0228792001,
0.0181210004,
0.013577207,
0.0098139225,
-0.027898021,
0.0235545002,
0.0028753639,
0.0412398763,
-0.0159956254,
-0.0074722725,
0.0038546571,
-0.014440896,
-0.0123059237,
-0.0110699218,
0.0079181232,
0.0017447283,
-0.0251710266,
0.0174758285,
-0.0737498105,
-0.0060630715,
0.0425775871,
0.0303565953,
0.0027964055,
-0.0133294631,
0.0042945514,
0.0009157303,
-0.0145018175,
-0.0689812154,
-0.0220774859,
-0.0156040918,
0.0464269966,
0.001991299,
-0.0162281096,
-0.0105721485,
0.0348832421,
0.0358425975,
-0.0001187691,
0.023063438,
0.0692830756,
-0.0074024256,
0.0399485566,
0.0253122896,
-0.0086191073,
0.023584336,
-0.014400457,
-0.0557867736,
0.0201988276,
-0.0127836429,
-0.023787016,
0.0556820817,
-0.0019009707,
0.0001057962,
-0.0052121156,
-0.045908533,
-0.0272436924,
-0.0076288353,
-0.0043462617,
0.0231070034,
0.06129108,
0.0651974455,
-0.0578937121,
-0.0319881178,
-0.0318707116,
0.034221936,
0.0190604664,
0.0616407171,
0.012857371,
0.0493892804,
0.0144321751,
-0.0753841773,
0.0607655831,
-0.0166469384,
-0.002686434,
-0.0026677561,
-0.0174622275,
-0.0380037613,
0.0299890321,
-0.0436315313,
0.019083159,
0.0014951391,
-0.0153682111,
-0.0683465302,
0.0105381971,
0.1071359143,
0.0302360076,
-0.0214720927,
0.0164674371,
0.0073613892,
0.0349523872,
-0.0108607598,
-0.0554558523,
0.0024224319,
0.0637284741,
-0.0104326755,
-0.0774118304,
-0.04317794,
-4.996563634e-33,
-0.0150255505,
-0.0336914547,
-0.0131270783,
0.0361445099,
-0.0434622914,
0.0386389308,
-0.0325306803,
-0.0176703352,
0.0357121415,
0.0377828255,
0.0096517215,
0.0296009183,
0.0000973327,
-0.0410921387,
0.0257792026,
0.022626197,
0.0320791975,
-0.0044895094,
-0.019721346,
-0.0141452504,
0.0459701531,
0.0543493256,
0.075284332,
-0.0915303752,
0.0307627022,
-0.0199501384,
0.0330939032,
-0.0517248623,
0.027865544,
0.0620877407,
-0.0322897658,
0.0156218428,
-0.0009745749,
0.0036593559,
-0.0374340825,
0.0333292037,
-0.0732349232,
-0.004239162,
0.0128152817,
0.0258873943,
-0.0446732342,
-0.0677931309,
0.0520002283,
-0.0200289395,
-0.0256750323,
-0.0117359683,
0.0698482916,
-0.022969164,
-0.0278941914,
-0.0429095402,
-0.0727573782,
0.054944735,
-0.0184855461,
0.0390041582,
0.0666260272,
-0.0098528443,
-0.0089894757,
0.031338837,
-0.0036909783,
-0.0010351001,
0.0055382457,
0.0367488787,
-0.0281922761,
-0.007493583,
0.0457709432,
0.0316897333,
0.0388883501,
-0.037591029,
0.0630391687,
-0.0036174534,
0.0421825908,
0.0580717325,
0.0319817774,
0.0485299155,
0.1106463373,
0.0627960116,
-0.0083830375,
0.0088367704,
-0.0181311667,
0.0461980738,
-0.0216026381,
-0.0048121912,
-0.0336816572,
0.0130450586,
0.0065509682,
0.0040604137,
-0.0187933557,
-0.0055809929,
0.0145982243,
-0.0421209335,
-0.0453225374,
0.0683312565,
0.0277227163,
-0.0339454785,
-0.0555299893,
0.012257182,
0.0225838572,
0.0648222268,
-0.0287863035,
-0.0171755943,
-0.026003303,
-0.0453786924,
-0.01943391,
0.015435948,
0.0486661121,
-0.017799003,
0.0141913211,
-0.0129050389,
0.0125313364,
-0.0293721836,
0.0196605194,
-0.0663644448,
0.0199538767,
0.0229894351,
0.0425027944,
0.0182429105,
0.0522836484,
0.0098606721,
0.037890438,
0.0250396617,
-0.0347232968,
0.0372537486,
-0.0030930659,
0.0363611579,
0.0208383258,
-0.0351685025,
0.0021758494,
-0.0215552635,
0.0348476581,
-0.0455255322,
0.0244494472,
0.0047707073,
2.478e-7,
0.0691602081,
0.0710063726,
0.0666957125,
0.0266383626,
-0.0109595722,
-0.0331958421,
-0.0026438918,
0.0116612883,
-0.0200551394,
0.0255982503,
0.0169921201,
-0.0227661468,
0.0071405359,
0.0220180731,
-0.0677822232,
-0.0177138839,
-0.0026249413,
-0.0167834423,
-0.057199724,
-0.004383591,
0.0648172051,
0.0079827523,
-0.0254910849,
0.0287282504,
-0.0212923642,
-0.0359371118,
0.0263372902,
-0.0006118861,
0.042933058,
0.0590429455,
0.0358290374,
-0.0142393801,
0.0111466041,
0.0441025794,
-0.0046603074,
0.0303388648,
0.060463272,
0.0480212532,
0.0322275572,
0.0693586767,
-0.0131160077,
-0.048392579,
0.0202125013,
0.0291132722,
0.0238230005,
-0.0663516596,
0.0056038457,
-0.0362320244,
-0.0970993787,
-0.0056059044,
-0.0038424591,
0.032157775,
-0.0081890738,
0.0353822261,
0.0314213708,
-0.010762969,
-0.0079027796,
-0.0418762155,
0.0065028016,
0.0449577533,
-0.0338152125,
0.0314548165,
-0.0391820595,
-0.0408116505,
-0.0127892653,
-0.030923456,
-0.0556329936,
2.538076893e-34,
0.0373334773,
-0.0361835957,
0.0271416903,
0.0987228379,
-0.0150917526,
-0.0235009566,
-0.0707963407,
0.0407049917,
-0.0125799365,
-0.0577525906,
0.0220521316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14659v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14659v2 | InteractiveIE: Towards Assessing the Strength of Human-AI Collaboration in Improving the Performance of Information Extraction | 2023-05-24T02:53:22 | 2023-11-17T17:31:52 | Ishani Mondal, Michelle Yuan, Anandhavelu N, Aparna Garimella, Francis Ferraro, Andrew Blair-Stanek, Benjamin Van Durme, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learning template based information extraction from documents is a crucial
yet difficult task. Prior template-based IE approaches assume foreknowledge of
the domain templates; however, real-world IE do not have pre-defined schemas
and it is a figure-out-as you go phenomena. To quickly bootstrap templates in a
real-world setting, we need to induce template slots from documents with zero
or minimal supervision. Since the purpose of question answering intersect with
the goal of information extraction, we use automatic question generation to
induce template slots from the documents and investigate how a tiny amount of a
proxy human-supervision on-the-fly (termed as InteractiveIE) can further boost
the performance. Extensive experiments on biomedical and legal documents, where
obtaining training data is expensive, reveal encouraging trends of performance
improvement using InteractiveIE over AI-only baseline. | [
0.0778549835,
0.014171565,
0.0075344183,
-0.0168415662,
-0.0340935364,
0.0452344418,
0.0156178437,
0.0074658385,
-0.0260887817,
-0.0444245115,
-0.0298302136,
-0.0082391221,
-0.0452921726,
0.0045067356,
0.0064431913,
-0.0570930392,
0.0199666768,
-0.0056070709,
0.0110388044,
0.0281117056,
-0.0115984157,
-0.0034865662,
-0.0210338198,
0.0035995201,
-0.0325213298,
0.0062754317,
-0.0224182401,
-0.0174186062,
-0.0072285305,
-0.0021383082,
0.008754503,
0.0354411453,
0.0035310611,
-0.03728671,
0.0000017206,
-0.0596200041,
-0.0237881597,
0.0297573507,
-0.0610546246,
-0.0253046136,
-0.0179867838,
-0.0449218713,
0.0228370316,
0.0172215998,
-0.0483890772,
-0.0242391825,
-0.0207965467,
0.0578680374,
0.0379393473,
0.0498016737,
-0.0154301357,
-0.0087229013,
0.0412045047,
0.0002643894,
0.0444967411,
-0.0264899917,
0.0142739555,
-0.0024175956,
0.0575185493,
-0.0083812131,
0.0608245432,
0.0401276536,
0.0565616451,
-0.0270976033,
0.0274928939,
0.0379701219,
-0.05255026,
-0.0309761763,
-0.0367467403,
0.094175227,
0.031048758,
0.0013863619,
0.0230742935,
0.0073703607,
0.0386413895,
0.0717716515,
-0.0390102118,
0.0055184322,
-0.0696382821,
-0.0526327342,
0.07003548,
-0.0205612648,
-0.0131923538,
0.0099856583,
-0.0170464925,
0.0344871059,
0.0036156997,
-0.0518844388,
0.0257240403,
0.0266497675,
-0.0130745955,
-0.0434358716,
0.0188688878,
0.0828121305,
-0.0107218279,
0.0044487421,
-0.0383794382,
-0.0742430016,
0.017200252,
0.0052582994,
0.0099333804,
0.0132083986,
-0.0141684432,
0.0722366422,
-0.038332656,
0.0286042951,
-0.0197126865,
0.0096653113,
-0.0330101736,
-0.0123521788,
-0.0565519743,
-0.0350570939,
-0.0598011799,
0.075554654,
-0.0284126531,
-0.0216560941,
0.0284729507,
0.0403314382,
0.0219838805,
0.0217633955,
-0.0105426088,
0.0256088898,
-0.044376839,
0.0064928625,
-0.0236305315,
-0.036161948,
-0.0657026768,
-0.0069479528,
0.0152696762,
-0.044172775,
-0.0070343097,
0.0419196896,
0.0302205738,
-0.0329538696,
0.0128096398,
0.0649284124,
-0.0379977748,
-0.0161465909,
-0.0064678169,
-0.0652741641,
0.0364419296,
-0.0448635183,
0.0011809984,
-0.0389891118,
0.0585547797,
0.0314569734,
-0.0619015507,
-0.028078394,
0.0096090725,
0.0221978594,
-0.0150349569,
0.062390361,
-0.0275168885,
0.0011974922,
0.080979608,
0.0094051166,
-0.0144356536,
0.0358673297,
0.0319918767,
0.0188753232,
0.0408845171,
0.0420696251,
0.0515132733,
0.0084064761,
0.0397515222,
-0.0087612364,
0.0259216521,
0.0504819043,
0.007486748,
0.0282509085,
0.0152378595,
0.0652643666,
-0.0246913861,
0.0055571222,
-0.0010757676,
0.0205504131,
0.0023978956,
0.0304229576,
0.0773853213,
0.0104775,
0.0333854891,
0.0567488149,
-0.0275753718,
0.0109791979,
0.0098666037,
0.0337294415,
-0.025849022,
-0.0196357071,
-0.0167928003,
-0.0409153551,
-0.0068772365,
0.0051798956,
-0.0443725102,
0.0000171758,
0.0330288224,
0.0138176763,
-0.033309903,
0.0209348332,
0.0177243948,
-0.0343113169,
0.0104769468,
-0.0172091536,
0.0572683066,
0.0199222248,
0.0622162856,
-0.0504397154,
-0.0597657561,
-0.0026438939,
-0.0220542345,
0.0320480615,
0.0417916477,
-0.0616065636,
0.0139152836,
-0.0327669866,
-0.0103161372,
-0.0182808191,
-0.0054959278,
0.0193712339,
0.0412721373,
-0.0082699414,
0.0279484671,
-0.0245462861,
-0.02256025,
0.0718467236,
-0.0304019507,
-0.060662169,
0.0075636795,
0.0233603455,
0.0102628041,
0.0079499306,
-0.0307323951,
0.0035184936,
0.0373257212,
-0.0570014305,
-0.0129181063,
-0.0019946005,
-0.0590048209,
-0.0115022566,
-0.0214458704,
-0.0366540365,
-0.0139168277,
-0.0357073434,
-0.0079768635,
-0.024622323,
-0.0467996672,
-0.026034927,
0.0052451603,
-0.0282492153,
-0.0254122559,
0.0573392436,
-0.0062200986,
-0.0482631698,
0.0735071972,
0.0313504487,
-0.0218054596,
0.0488018543,
-0.014199839,
0.0176023059,
-0.0420109518,
0.0582512021,
-0.01183121,
-0.0026838854,
-0.0170458388,
0.0285538454,
0.0118090846,
-0.0734469742,
-0.0426349193,
-0.1270507872,
0.0111283707,
-0.0352830254,
0.0610958636,
0.0409993529,
0.0100571765,
-0.0342509858,
-0.0194522459,
-0.0626709908,
-0.0640716255,
-0.0191211961,
0.007092128,
0.0670978725,
0.0663153157,
0.0490752384,
-0.0214206111,
0.0276624989,
-0.0337544158,
0.0176191702,
0.08896029,
-0.045644898,
-0.0434723236,
0.001712832,
-0.0045293644,
0.0041352538,
0.0151561247,
-0.0069034104,
0.0139731513,
-0.0197132006,
0.0437966399,
0.0850482807,
-0.0109508289,
0.0479973555,
0.0123504121,
0.0294098109,
-0.0648574308,
0.0377729721,
-0.0177032463,
0.0495186634,
0.0085262163,
-0.0078289239,
0.0443125665,
0.0341380686,
0.0097272443,
0.01152285,
-0.0082845967,
0.0380047597,
-0.0046388158,
-0.0220011193,
-0.0605908744,
-0.016206814,
-0.0033414776,
0.0506990775,
-0.0131134707,
-0.0301232897,
0.086071156,
0.0157633871,
0.0092533864,
-0.073851414,
0.016510196,
-0.0535074174,
0.028668778,
-0.0144937513,
0.0015916226,
0.0168304034,
-0.0337779932,
-0.0442211851,
-0.002134044,
0.0113467108,
-0.0000309254,
-0.0100718029,
-0.0675915405,
0.0193399973,
-0.0023502011,
-0.0395740457,
-0.0651759207,
-0.0257398523,
0.0173038412,
0.0414414071,
0.0247770809,
-0.0002315892,
0.0037945472,
-0.016715819,
0.045331765,
0.0566721186,
-0.0248653051,
-0.0362288505,
-0.0103915976,
0.1186218858,
0.043425642,
0.007036834,
0.0041081831,
-0.0455205478,
0.0303050559,
0.0513803773,
0.0391898118,
0.0457393453,
0.0199659392,
-0.0007857083,
-0.030195849,
-0.0550338328,
0.007138011,
-0.0032458461,
0.0195599254,
-0.0524789095,
-0.0414198227,
0.1020266935,
0.0660723597,
-0.0401691683,
-0.0212816838,
-0.0259878356,
0.0304703526,
-0.0009539286,
0.0709846094,
-0.0524214953,
-0.0122249769,
-0.0077184658,
0.0577364713,
-0.029089855,
-0.0327151828,
0.0157218575,
-0.0541799851,
0.0397435389,
-0.0326904356,
-0.0231425166,
0.0114767794,
-0.0484946519,
0.0164770093,
0.0191002712,
-0.0216125213,
0.0135580776,
-0.0220593251,
0.0227334071,
0.043037761,
-0.0317107327,
-0.0213497467,
-0.0230034627,
-0.0184539314,
-0.0151447803,
0.0582910515,
0.0173240993,
-0.0143389525,
-0.0010649534,
0.0114546008,
-0.045257818,
0.0232330319,
-0.0274948645,
0.0792966858,
-0.0250728596,
0.0122753577,
-0.0236168839,
0.0690135136,
-0.0432642996,
0.0478796996,
0.0604958087,
0.0409502052,
-0.0474853069,
-0.0018586165,
-0.0183960814,
-0.0454371683,
-0.0033899273,
0.0744249523,
0.0509702228,
-0.0247507393,
-0.0365089774,
0.0182971358,
-0.0001844865,
-0.0694902837,
0.0090436488,
-0.0151357772,
-0.0341169499,
0.0054347157,
-0.1309813857,
-0.0829427987,
0.0561670475,
0.0828941539,
0.0047842888,
-0.0148190372,
-0.008027113,
0.0026215455,
-0.0314582586,
0.0127050197,
0.0089329481,
-0.0309760999,
-0.0702115446,
-0.0266084224,
0.0145583274,
-0.0137673449,
-0.0360510312,
0.0025572502,
-0.0198416673,
-0.0257704016,
0.0128478659,
0.0306003913,
0.022258494,
0.0427291282,
-0.0175016336,
-0.0025077371,
0.0784590691,
0.045841001,
-0.0658613071,
-0.0318531618,
0.0115623605,
-0.053738717,
-0.0110090291,
0.0193896703,
-0.0385869816,
0.0124473004,
0.0073287976,
0.0017113722,
-0.0249980018,
-0.0107090594,
0.0603925958,
0.0468223244,
-0.0058352035,
-0.0056085633,
0.0085083982,
-0.0147920689,
0.0324954577,
-0.0220876057,
-0.0346994661,
-0.0204950795,
0.0194405038,
-0.010051297,
-0.0069222781,
0.0070792004,
0.0473223552,
-0.0273384955,
0.0471268781,
-0.0289369114,
-0.0065008914,
-0.0214814041,
0.0477576293,
-0.0008360505,
-0.0438221768,
-0.0183370784,
0.015483018,
0.0063587776,
0.0755365193,
-0.0224329829,
0.0655236244,
0.033610072,
-0.0017831736,
0.0069494159,
0.0325509273,
-0.0635346174,
-0.0411227345,
-0.01609548,
0.0219304729,
-0.0010213127,
-0.0063108704,
-0.0194101781,
-0.0394449346,
-0.0282920972,
0.0196529943,
0.0189351216,
0.0135958679,
0.0272863619,
0.0416163132,
0.0297974125,
0.0033903806,
0.0093132891,
0.0614207834,
-0.0044277725,
0.0448455848,
-0.015305859,
-0.0173901021,
-0.0623371825,
0.009143386,
0.0179010555,
0.0094008427,
-0.0230506305,
0.0242563635,
-0.0456160903,
-0.0188928209,
0.0008206973,
0.0196827799,
-0.0205337368,
0.0040491717,
0.0390214063,
0.0708802342,
0.0140572051,
-0.032768216,
-0.0586055629,
0.045211833,
-0.0201690365,
-0.0292873122,
-0.0160251781,
-6.298411138e-33,
-0.0265367627,
-0.054166723,
0.0182763617,
0.0167391915,
-0.0070295557,
0.0119132921,
-0.0449397787,
0.0005949519,
-0.0080257589,
0.0151463645,
-0.0375690758,
-0.0035618106,
0.0057734684,
-0.0168884788,
0.0018975562,
-0.0260154679,
-0.0010082424,
-0.0107404608,
-0.0472106487,
0.0236250609,
0.0251941551,
0.0430000722,
-0.0173123255,
-0.0748256072,
0.0240930095,
-0.0132559203,
0.0250292514,
0.0185519904,
0.0233640615,
0.0481771752,
-0.0058474666,
-0.0154772764,
0.0529801622,
-0.0134271318,
0.030736357,
0.0544563383,
-0.1333985478,
-0.0497136191,
-0.0196323041,
-0.0252647512,
-0.08830221,
-0.0502995439,
0.0251268093,
-0.0175450388,
0.0465566851,
0.0123178037,
0.0477226526,
-0.0018636868,
-0.0152411964,
-0.0552294888,
-0.0667969286,
0.0180571079,
-0.0112021202,
-0.0141835064,
0.0043142186,
0.0367287062,
-0.0074288235,
-0.0227780603,
-0.0003891273,
-0.043510206,
-0.0068689929,
0.0152548039,
0.0265339054,
-0.0288608409,
-0.0234287065,
0.0120197553,
-0.0006178534,
-0.0063262768,
-0.0237907618,
-0.0511901453,
-0.029695373,
0.0385277197,
0.0206324607,
-0.0055942312,
0.0133255841,
0.0502478331,
-0.0575795732,
0.0830097497,
0.0173437726,
0.0622303188,
-0.0411408432,
-0.0320850909,
-0.07433144,
0.0312666371,
0.0012275232,
0.0134312985,
-0.0261639133,
-0.0356977992,
0.0186791513,
0.0018540052,
-0.0510653257,
-0.0218494739,
-0.0049449443,
0.0097422916,
0.046485249,
0.0149827292,
-0.0087527344,
0.028474234,
-0.0186926089,
-0.0442518704,
-0.0550977997,
-0.0084969737,
0.0151967853,
0.041307088,
0.0310788378,
0.0126107708,
0.050884001,
-0.0185316671,
-0.049913317,
-0.0221935101,
-0.0267485641,
0.0434446707,
0.0130476011,
-0.0145492712,
0.0187781304,
0.0255955365,
-0.026625501,
0.0200801734,
0.0110720182,
0.0035024981,
-0.0554018505,
-0.0002692381,
-0.0036029683,
0.0229452699,
-0.0322909057,
0.0077740247,
-0.0248370096,
0.0138633726,
-0.0039942199,
-0.0309703276,
0.0042534331,
0.0176773034,
2.543e-7,
0.0539707243,
0.0544106252,
0.0726078749,
0.015771091,
-0.0026389901,
0.0160682276,
0.0149983056,
0.0032579768,
-0.0156684648,
-0.0011027353,
0.0553476252,
0.0116457436,
0.0131989792,
0.0354654491,
-0.0775057822,
-0.0059666741,
-0.0295333564,
-0.0232795049,
-0.052798491,
-0.0170783829,
0.0605425611,
0.0089821704,
-0.0316060297,
-0.0185659211,
-0.0273289047,
-0.0321188383,
0.031934604,
0.0312005542,
-0.0093095321,
0.0494767055,
0.0572672412,
0.0187385231,
-0.0054957317,
0.0555181392,
-0.0263402779,
0.0107460516,
0.0164657347,
0.0273915604,
0.0025381795,
0.0179729629,
0.0169252884,
-0.0429772995,
0.0604431778,
-0.0583685301,
0.0668957457,
-0.0790114701,
0.0085905036,
-0.0090582091,
-0.0423418805,
-0.0130657554,
-0.0374995247,
-0.0003694348,
0.000646454,
0.0547241718,
0.0055224034,
-0.0300347731,
0.0024430682,
-0.0585752204,
0.0172207858,
0.0233250633,
-0.0118888328,
0.0018987494,
-0.0111974459,
-0.028454138,
-0.0210072473,
-0.0569798499,
-0.0153844357,
2.164441192e-34,
0.0099319052,
0.0146572273,
-0.005998835,
0.0789890289,
0.0430469252,
-0.0115974778,
-0.0319401696,
-0.0079796389,
0.0200785585,
-0.0629609302,
0.0129045788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14658v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14658v3 | Evaluate What You Can't Evaluate: Unassessable Quality for Generated Response | 2023-05-24T02:52:48 | 2024-05-05T17:47:48 | Yongkang Liu, Shi Feng, Daling Wang, Yifei Zhang, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs (large language models) such as ChatGPT have shown remarkable language
understanding and generation capabilities. Although reference-free evaluators
based on LLMs show better human alignment than traditional reference-based
evaluators, there are many challenges in using reference-free evaluators based
on LLMs. Reference-free evaluators are more suitable for open-ended examples
with different semantics responses. But not all examples are open-ended. For
closed-ended examples with unique correct semantic response, reference-free
evaluators will still consider it high quality when giving a response that is
inconsistent with the facts and the semantic of reference. In order to
comprehensively evaluate the reliability of evaluators based on LLMs, we
construct two adversarial meta-evaluation dialogue generation datasets
KdConv-ADV and DSTC7-ADV based on KdConv and DSTC7-AVSD, respectively. Compared
to previous meta-evaluation benchmarks, KdConv-ADV and DSTC7-ADV are much more
challenging since they requires evaluators to be able to reasonably evaluate
closed-ended examples with the help of external knowledge or even its own
knowledge. Empirical results show that the ability of LLMs to identify
unreasonable responses is insufficient. There are risks in using eference-free
evaluators based on LLMs to evaluate the quality of dialogue responses. | [
0.0621044002,
0.0330623686,
-0.001856872,
0.0335685983,
-0.0329407007,
-0.0088897403,
-0.0109231696,
-0.0104839094,
-0.0165446792,
-0.0772095099,
-0.0447525829,
-0.0308852773,
-0.002771985,
0.0201820806,
0.0226740204,
-0.0060301796,
0.0435552187,
0.0055046636,
0.03225182,
-0.0057152794,
-0.0049707843,
-0.0141943879,
-0.011409848,
0.0277895872,
0.0177822616,
-0.0156927668,
-0.0411770567,
0.007511144,
0.0386165529,
0.0018133201,
0.0139292469,
0.0442473516,
-0.0208967067,
0.0642623603,
0.0000019062,
-0.0299114287,
0.0183202643,
-0.0012581514,
-0.0341469869,
0.0165934972,
0.0295008626,
-0.0001331079,
-0.0146221165,
0.01517851,
-0.0573554486,
-0.0357893184,
0.0290827956,
0.0267168954,
0.1040895805,
0.0969423428,
0.0158627499,
-0.0085245352,
0.0029217803,
-0.0340682864,
0.0101925796,
-0.0672774836,
0.0061787851,
0.0166913066,
-0.0165302623,
0.0125667723,
0.0122854989,
0.0108039165,
0.0370611325,
-0.0214070324,
-0.0184753537,
0.0083451187,
-0.0817175508,
-0.0204732046,
-0.0130113224,
0.0861210525,
0.0378068201,
-0.0213351566,
-0.008653299,
-0.0022699053,
0.0206160732,
-0.0142905666,
-0.0353324823,
0.0185562391,
0.0040444946,
0.0058265678,
-0.0421969891,
0.0057988693,
0.0079229213,
0.0234205388,
0.0164468102,
0.0384439379,
0.0135039426,
-0.032303568,
-0.0032907543,
-0.0004971047,
-0.0259915665,
-0.057131689,
-0.0487285107,
0.0342191905,
-0.0585994236,
0.0176404845,
-0.0674773902,
-0.0084714284,
0.05964531,
-0.0468443409,
0.0469660163,
0.019247219,
-0.0117848907,
0.0079113841,
-0.0213261396,
0.0785853863,
-0.0093154721,
0.0610424988,
-0.0331925675,
-0.0120248487,
-0.0448276028,
-0.0071031284,
-0.0014792955,
0.0239375662,
-0.0460171625,
0.0028319331,
-0.0647762567,
0.0215775911,
-0.0020652919,
0.0271345545,
-0.0202280432,
0.0222920328,
-0.0037197911,
0.0126949735,
-0.06325984,
-0.014746693,
-0.0288015045,
0.0134153869,
0.0409493186,
-0.090883866,
-0.001985576,
0.0576151945,
-0.0454440787,
-0.0271941405,
-0.0132772047,
0.0952798128,
-0.0020187746,
-0.001764807,
-0.0207500383,
-0.0198914055,
-0.0516366549,
-0.1058392525,
0.0248913504,
-0.0290097855,
0.0050337669,
-0.0086768903,
-0.0651313886,
-0.0139070125,
0.0044891494,
0.0137677193,
-0.0006238627,
0.0434987061,
0.0130172502,
-0.0056703729,
-0.0017722704,
0.0183913987,
-0.0148494253,
0.0640261844,
0.0229629576,
0.0256353468,
0.0065552858,
-0.001792207,
-0.0012226534,
-0.0032572504,
0.0614842623,
0.0101011116,
-0.0013250744,
0.0360045582,
-0.01996696,
0.0226898529,
0.0074916766,
0.0893948898,
-0.0463572145,
-0.0505506396,
0.0512806289,
-0.0336462669,
-0.00296477,
0.0108610941,
0.0688763484,
0.0193289407,
0.0212895032,
0.039731238,
-0.0585381575,
0.0388662815,
-0.0212164875,
0.010476701,
0.066267468,
0.0069387741,
-0.03234924,
-0.0656770021,
0.0035495178,
0.0114731314,
-0.0049518533,
-0.0158451237,
0.0020967671,
0.0117650582,
-0.0369163565,
0.0214952137,
-0.0225078873,
-0.0490867868,
-0.0244781692,
-0.0888179243,
0.0309427846,
0.0379091538,
0.0692161322,
0.0107316915,
-0.0528369732,
-0.0162317064,
-0.006829049,
0.0676496848,
0.0820140392,
-0.0024914308,
0.019255003,
-0.0666168332,
-0.0151827,
-0.0493852906,
0.0001647597,
0.0478126518,
-0.0108743189,
-0.0073257345,
0.0380688943,
-0.0509664714,
0.0018796873,
0.033685755,
0.025020862,
-0.0147328973,
0.011263473,
-0.0080327597,
0.0736694261,
0.0154751223,
0.0012681484,
0.0339527391,
0.017510049,
-0.0010885058,
-0.0141675835,
0.0064131999,
-0.0491461083,
-0.0630685464,
0.0366879925,
-0.0495921038,
-0.0214264374,
0.0208582971,
-0.0553306937,
-0.0636697561,
0.0340157151,
-0.0193103626,
0.006303092,
-0.075741291,
-0.0014040761,
0.0180264004,
0.029299235,
-0.0453795157,
0.0819025114,
-0.0162357334,
0.0337003656,
0.0379408598,
0.028527271,
0.0562927127,
-0.0350734629,
-0.0228612777,
0.0202271678,
-0.029430734,
0.0399610996,
0.0263616014,
0.0293220133,
-0.0485375859,
-0.0556000918,
-0.0593745857,
0.0277563706,
-0.0298601687,
0.0445275418,
0.0331594497,
-0.024320798,
0.0182976052,
0.0276694484,
-0.0708686113,
0.0115150372,
0.0516150892,
0.0192243699,
0.0440629572,
0.0234157704,
0.0032309096,
-0.0451492034,
0.0188599229,
0.0206300803,
0.0517585389,
-0.0062682894,
0.0439325497,
-0.0278910026,
0.0063651362,
-0.0692791045,
0.0218046382,
-0.0106945019,
-0.0708686858,
0.0571040623,
0.0387548357,
0.0117171286,
0.0328825712,
0.0441042669,
0.0155366184,
0.0189183652,
0.0044699376,
-0.0650385544,
0.0061847307,
0.0060910261,
-0.0126960995,
-0.0199675672,
-0.0226180255,
0.003211793,
0.0392922834,
0.0329490565,
0.0026780809,
-0.054093305,
0.0596694797,
0.0338626616,
-0.0703748167,
-0.0036915331,
0.012711091,
-0.051508408,
0.0223750323,
-0.0278257038,
-0.027376296,
0.0757566392,
-0.0472448245,
-0.0259779654,
-0.0184730273,
0.0050383247,
-0.0227958933,
0.0273475498,
-0.0134109557,
-0.0000746809,
-0.0071352106,
0.0109675089,
-0.0663690716,
-0.041908063,
0.0293065049,
-0.0494200699,
0.0458892584,
-0.0207359213,
0.0092509314,
-0.025185978,
-0.0068621761,
-0.0987523571,
-0.0337692872,
0.0231478754,
0.0145965451,
0.0002359338,
0.0176366605,
-0.0482263118,
0.0017619184,
0.0028637189,
0.0053326911,
-0.0311830658,
0.0141711133,
-0.0216859337,
0.0381109193,
0.0545581654,
0.0181819778,
0.0211185142,
-0.0212274436,
0.0481854156,
0.0568235256,
-0.0294286069,
0.0429683179,
-0.0313649587,
-0.0295603294,
-0.017054148,
0.0099596465,
0.0012746732,
0.010481731,
0.0291791447,
-0.0249001849,
-0.0121451952,
0.0965415537,
0.0086196531,
0.026246462,
-0.0004769134,
-0.0299699213,
0.0344725065,
-0.0044867261,
0.0055491431,
-0.0759059042,
-0.0159460939,
-0.0126725463,
0.0251107942,
-0.0406362638,
-0.0107064433,
-0.0299091991,
-0.0998672992,
0.0212753806,
0.005199071,
-0.0701140985,
-0.0252330266,
0.0333897173,
0.0072631454,
-0.0154002085,
0.0731743798,
0.0293020178,
0.0351430848,
0.0217184275,
0.0170632098,
-0.0004598433,
-0.0393727757,
0.0172492974,
-0.0003326943,
0.0864121616,
0.0712873414,
0.0591114573,
0.0254225899,
-0.0357774496,
0.051622849,
-0.0352936126,
-0.0042066136,
0.0157990418,
0.0499938391,
0.0031173178,
-0.0052311337,
-0.0253282432,
0.0229245201,
-0.018627746,
0.0041854028,
0.0005126555,
0.0109075923,
-0.0404633321,
-0.0165022686,
-0.0228841584,
0.0463945195,
0.0208926722,
0.0835512578,
0.0489917547,
-0.0245499462,
-0.0599952526,
-0.0094085941,
-0.0023169618,
-0.0761819184,
-0.0127273584,
0.0724268928,
0.0156783238,
0.0013097959,
-0.0923612416,
-0.0825398192,
-0.0264973324,
0.0150384409,
-0.0434628502,
-0.0116543667,
-0.0705947205,
-0.0168128032,
0.0022757275,
-0.0074325739,
-0.0184418634,
-0.0036595489,
-0.0277349111,
0.0045343083,
0.0362270065,
-0.0506934486,
-0.0156743564,
0.0556875467,
-0.0393556245,
-0.072634846,
-0.0246863607,
0.0671664178,
0.0228886958,
0.0390686691,
-0.0112311505,
0.0048495191,
0.0255837515,
0.0301571786,
0.0025838094,
0.0114096738,
0.0475560687,
0.0278572999,
-0.0172365364,
0.0265810806,
-0.0227355435,
0.0479826145,
0.0413598232,
0.0238545872,
-0.0019635141,
-0.0506990142,
0.030413758,
0.0423590876,
0.0351090357,
-0.0083825467,
0.0110405879,
0.0117753418,
0.0033967046,
-0.010937836,
-0.014181097,
-0.0529417731,
-0.0171917565,
-0.0110310344,
-0.0225765649,
0.0076296297,
-0.0397240333,
-0.0664235502,
0.0657131076,
0.0241338965,
0.0173554029,
-0.0091636237,
0.04631963,
0.0034832139,
-0.0089546572,
-0.0303869434,
0.0140543077,
0.0116641335,
0.0335762985,
0.0150484201,
0.0644148663,
0.0299640782,
0.02148013,
0.0603301115,
0.0309092794,
-0.0618860051,
0.0204687864,
-0.0175849777,
0.023683602,
0.0119969556,
0.0647319406,
0.040688701,
-0.0093444046,
0.0218748823,
-0.0353040546,
0.0480887704,
0.0262920391,
-0.0254452042,
0.0418931358,
0.0025346938,
-0.0277567767,
0.0117163789,
0.0536787808,
-0.002145448,
0.009515224,
-0.0098892543,
0.0281108059,
-0.085294731,
-0.0613815524,
-0.0397771113,
-0.0363833718,
0.0075238878,
0.0155521166,
-0.0591124594,
-0.0611650087,
-0.0126412865,
0.0660755634,
0.0132732475,
-0.0007678873,
0.0182042886,
0.0503690392,
-0.0108074425,
0.0032347424,
-0.0534416772,
0.0068632448,
-0.011630768,
-0.016286606,
-0.0276181959,
-6.338226601e-33,
-0.0488036945,
-0.0450020432,
0.0528533347,
-0.0372787416,
-0.0449882075,
-0.0231209937,
-0.0431696437,
-0.0018345211,
-0.0218947325,
-0.0034176256,
0.0063196146,
-0.0045668432,
0.0042959438,
0.0343518481,
-0.0389913209,
-0.0663848296,
0.0313223414,
-0.0006461375,
-0.046273645,
0.0230300277,
0.0286562722,
-0.0099884886,
0.0122302938,
-0.0603355616,
0.0412285626,
-0.0042403606,
-0.0304451548,
-0.0111465044,
-0.0395640619,
0.0451022238,
-0.0086154677,
0.035837058,
0.0173316542,
-0.0107356496,
-0.0175919533,
-0.0154543817,
-0.0433977135,
-0.0321513265,
0.0553622432,
0.0004623709,
-0.0382986926,
-0.034811262,
0.0466454104,
-0.0321857259,
-0.0090611028,
0.0060335868,
-0.0086844899,
-0.0318255424,
-0.0261765551,
0.0040533021,
-0.0438944101,
0.0345149599,
0.0058472673,
-0.0440717973,
-0.0305838976,
0.0671882108,
-0.0052914075,
-0.0275328923,
-0.024922492,
0.0036990014,
0.0014146114,
-0.0121588632,
0.0726969615,
0.0160044059,
0.0043920041,
0.0706550926,
0.0016971502,
0.0023197338,
-0.0128868781,
-0.0354297236,
-0.0110953962,
0.050681062,
0.0326764397,
0.0960329697,
-0.0182896387,
-0.0063776593,
-0.0574276857,
0.0390722938,
0.0026940245,
0.0327058434,
0.0332982205,
-0.0159357078,
-0.0178059228,
0.0145873185,
-0.0363223553,
-0.0233148765,
-0.0267520901,
-0.0556019172,
0.04686822,
-0.0063881148,
-0.0258559249,
-0.0679406673,
0.0364842676,
-0.0444342531,
0.0503927805,
0.0386068188,
-0.0405799635,
-0.0260689687,
-0.0213996693,
-0.0012557182,
-0.0344766825,
-0.0202286877,
0.0547618046,
0.0275039226,
0.0015930102,
0.0060692295,
0.019024564,
-0.0145174917,
-0.0307704918,
0.0190807525,
-0.0295278579,
0.0847606063,
-0.0403550677,
-0.0296709202,
0.001354018,
-0.0218040254,
-0.0469259098,
0.0313286446,
-0.0350038223,
-0.0115408236,
-0.0049013156,
0.0018239688,
0.023252286,
0.0242116936,
-0.0721365884,
0.0249909684,
0.0042031794,
-0.0257468503,
0.0201072339,
-0.0322647393,
0.01705187,
0.0022111735,
2.618e-7,
0.0109921927,
0.0189851224,
0.0459165573,
0.0231190864,
0.0353567526,
0.0339805,
-0.0039942474,
0.0339983739,
-0.0231589228,
-0.0297794547,
0.0202948544,
0.0030063186,
0.0738535076,
0.0315368399,
-0.042770002,
0.0366758518,
-0.101541996,
-0.0400934927,
0.0128377806,
0.0055059553,
0.0453558676,
0.0672285557,
-0.0169346202,
0.008404104,
0.0048764236,
-0.0342613123,
0.0610787384,
-0.0092854146,
-0.0350637659,
0.030150298,
0.0659884885,
-0.0055384152,
0.0376464687,
0.0286908336,
0.0223049782,
-0.0057749324,
0.0144466255,
0.0725927204,
0.0184868425,
-0.0756253153,
-0.005028931,
-0.0338489786,
0.0252857339,
-0.0168276969,
0.0622671135,
-0.0503960252,
-0.0418337658,
-0.0287156161,
-0.0379461236,
-0.0132263899,
0.019174533,
-0.0147026367,
-0.0027390854,
0.0143486159,
0.0047571892,
-0.0198123753,
0.0131803164,
-0.0344043598,
-0.0252754614,
-0.0307912584,
-0.0595991276,
-0.0589902624,
-0.0134722209,
0.0244648643,
0.0326428786,
-0.0270697139,
-0.0212277919,
1.890037763e-34,
0.0497177429,
-0.0359955914,
0.0270254146,
-0.0382590368,
0.0138219027,
0.0178368445,
-0.0133748762,
-0.0010287341,
0.0335732624,
-0.0381188206,
-0.019479163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14652v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14652v3 | Denoising Bottleneck with Mutual Information Maximization for Video Multimodal Fusion | 2023-05-24T02:39:43 | 2023-05-31T08:20:33 | Shaoxiang Wu, Damai Dai, Ziwei Qin, Tianyu Liu, Binghuai Lin, Yunbo Cao, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Video multimodal fusion aims to integrate multimodal signals in videos, such
as visual, audio and text, to make a complementary prediction with multiple
modalities contents. However, unlike other image-text multimodal tasks, video
has longer multimodal sequences with more redundancy and noise in both visual
and audio modalities. Prior denoising methods like forget gate are coarse in
the granularity of noise filtering. They often suppress the redundant and noisy
information at the risk of losing critical information. Therefore, we propose a
denoising bottleneck fusion (DBF) model for fine-grained video multimodal
fusion. On the one hand, we employ a bottleneck mechanism to filter out noise
and redundancy with a restrained receptive field. On the other hand, we use a
mutual information maximization module to regulate the filter-out module to
preserve key information within different modalities. Our DBF model achieves
significant improvement over current state-of-the-art baselines on multiple
benchmarks covering multimodal sentiment analysis and multimodal summarization
tasks. It proves that our model can effectively capture salient features from
noisy and redundant video, audio, and text inputs. The code for this paper is
publicly available at https://github.com/WSXRHFG/DBF. | [
0.0091725942,
0.0336203501,
0.0546129569,
0.038814351,
-0.0042103301,
-0.0202572104,
-0.0139685534,
0.0036301112,
-0.0292180926,
-0.0801745728,
-0.0268595312,
-0.0084339473,
0.0078597618,
0.0194440447,
0.0208906382,
-0.0557009913,
0.0145944078,
0.022970438,
0.0365436785,
-0.01127904,
0.0526015051,
0.0079851877,
-0.0139260963,
0.0033997658,
-0.0660611317,
0.0098824818,
0.0172861107,
0.0239703897,
0.0630313307,
0.0042824168,
-0.0248295292,
0.0406243503,
0.0446565337,
-0.0330044664,
0.0000022317,
-0.0191567801,
-0.0166692529,
-0.0014918778,
0.0532857142,
0.0023635719,
-0.0126247508,
-0.0138137769,
0.000543871,
-0.0098525584,
-0.0037084993,
-0.0029377691,
0.0469858162,
0.062430013,
0.0295673031,
0.0359165967,
-0.0585456379,
-0.0575588122,
0.0365789644,
-0.0254328363,
0.0102392919,
-0.0384494253,
-0.0159266107,
-0.0135438731,
-0.0045226524,
-0.0710054189,
-0.0350753516,
0.0408117026,
-0.0128006591,
-0.0023475939,
0.0580264106,
0.0007051711,
0.000152888,
-0.0477442704,
-0.0065637277,
0.0564887859,
-0.029234007,
0.0320475586,
-0.0078290533,
0.0184262414,
-0.0075989859,
-0.0235467348,
-0.0328021497,
-0.007873049,
-0.0037576046,
0.0255293809,
-0.0525474176,
0.0423337296,
0.0306188706,
0.0001574197,
0.0024857137,
-0.0571410395,
0.0153899444,
0.0205951147,
-0.0089560468,
-0.0003619812,
-0.0325646587,
-0.0163476877,
-0.0007584298,
0.0030279972,
0.0136394249,
-0.0420254655,
-0.0345738642,
-0.0340307914,
-0.0230960287,
-0.0156294852,
-0.0133824581,
0.0146113476,
-0.0363025293,
0.0914978087,
0.0082162386,
-0.0088886293,
-0.0149669452,
0.0222756714,
-0.0198116172,
-0.0305318814,
-0.0392322503,
0.0280166753,
0.0549251027,
0.0637613535,
0.0073752441,
-0.0404060595,
-0.0279671457,
-0.0272031147,
-0.0756675974,
0.0210877638,
-0.0487834886,
0.0384499654,
0.0168962441,
-0.0468637086,
-0.0165030677,
0.0464846455,
-0.0272444319,
0.0644656196,
-0.0027890643,
-0.0367391557,
0.0096652685,
0.0429271273,
0.0099534132,
-0.0195741225,
0.0162031837,
0.0368446112,
-0.0561602674,
-0.020764472,
-0.0560815297,
-0.0011239628,
-0.0521894544,
-0.0537621975,
0.0211315937,
-0.0361589044,
0.0488033593,
-0.0099345986,
0.0248282105,
-0.0334316753,
0.0067989808,
-0.0269584898,
-0.0195503067,
0.089087151,
-0.0184659325,
-0.0235589668,
0.0314061083,
0.0116713727,
-0.0003559309,
0.0639374927,
0.0133219333,
0.0391950049,
0.0268517192,
0.0291740634,
0.0099488636,
0.0102813169,
-0.0255313739,
0.032067284,
-0.0740979537,
-0.0526724905,
-0.0164385829,
-0.0336649008,
0.0478305519,
0.0853943303,
-0.0080823917,
-0.006280689,
0.0481484272,
-0.0049096472,
0.0000717654,
-0.0306033604,
-0.0302400347,
0.0259512961,
0.0019055955,
0.0348870493,
-0.0090002045,
0.0870325044,
-0.027228279,
0.0138818324,
0.1290846765,
0.0750288591,
-0.0526884757,
-0.0359792262,
0.0074347598,
-0.0358854979,
0.0054967487,
0.047281649,
0.0599542558,
-0.0006001304,
-0.0554461144,
0.0071555614,
0.0109786205,
-0.0252146199,
0.0269257333,
-0.0025720075,
0.0177998263,
0.0192981437,
0.009956304,
-0.0622159801,
0.0165915396,
-0.0231029652,
-0.0136303129,
-0.0214081798,
-0.0106287487,
0.003118444,
0.053018935,
-0.0722614005,
-0.0856049359,
0.0015924587,
0.0125394212,
-0.001819621,
-0.0482578687,
-0.0041721389,
0.0123819299,
0.035448011,
0.0236062203,
0.0149043621,
0.0879501775,
0.0172661841,
-0.0302794334,
-0.0003731117,
0.0475780517,
0.0326993316,
-0.0428748429,
0.0080976104,
0.057776887,
-0.0303538051,
0.0005544966,
0.0075518205,
-0.0626611039,
-0.0231591053,
0.062527217,
-0.0573801063,
0.0297852792,
0.032480415,
-0.0243956242,
-0.0478574745,
0.0391719714,
0.0017200388,
-0.0051856614,
-0.0524139442,
0.0074820495,
0.0366317742,
0.0034091726,
0.0148081919,
0.038961906,
-0.0495092161,
-0.0304585807,
-0.0214435775,
-0.0223863386,
0.0063065984,
0.0063927318,
-0.0358122252,
-0.0164168794,
-0.0331351906,
0.0291341599,
0.0184205323,
-0.0387577638,
-0.0191892777,
-0.0391255543,
-0.0708219633,
-0.0166041106,
-0.0191097725,
-0.0190204158,
-0.0326167122,
0.0146656241,
0.0313523412,
-0.04320338,
-0.0130220503,
0.0153587526,
-0.0143086547,
0.0085888561,
-0.027639769,
0.0633862093,
0.0490782745,
-0.0434463806,
-0.0073198439,
0.0428121872,
0.0237201508,
-0.0298911035,
-0.0802786574,
0.0529375263,
-0.0213511381,
-0.0289524458,
0.0566479117,
-0.0357648954,
-0.0152273448,
-0.0127733061,
-0.037182983,
0.0419777334,
-0.0061518634,
0.0105508845,
0.0294786934,
0.0157079007,
-0.0076217726,
0.0147157554,
0.0408324338,
-0.0031328974,
0.0576106384,
0.0093204286,
0.0228675772,
-0.0510163195,
-0.0016175485,
0.0042315177,
0.0169753302,
-0.0304801278,
0.0001415239,
0.0203951001,
-0.0284520108,
-0.058605779,
0.0064216238,
-0.0037827983,
-0.0015130799,
-0.0433727764,
-0.0129270945,
0.0288273934,
-0.0054670116,
-0.016682988,
-0.0084874108,
-0.0124309985,
-0.0171804763,
0.0047786124,
0.0088933716,
0.0144418078,
-0.0134801446,
0.0212517697,
-0.0733128637,
-0.0183777921,
0.0297935195,
-0.0096362596,
0.0712096766,
-0.0053657563,
0.0145074576,
-0.0089879315,
-0.0122075826,
0.0116235539,
-0.0287946854,
-0.036642462,
-0.0126199778,
-0.0236004516,
0.0030319139,
-0.0423780568,
-0.02636379,
0.0385140814,
0.0141989263,
0.0162541997,
-0.0003078705,
0.0090498263,
0.1022835672,
0.0429149047,
0.0400758833,
-0.0408126004,
-0.0423180982,
-0.0081282174,
0.0521942526,
0.0240572523,
-0.0148053374,
-0.0213783029,
0.0083426358,
0.0402218476,
0.0666589513,
-0.0075327242,
0.033742547,
0.059311606,
-0.0224065296,
0.0800130144,
0.056899406,
-0.0332532711,
-0.0723258033,
-0.0195288435,
0.0302655771,
0.0257150196,
0.0585002154,
-0.0424450226,
-0.0269534141,
-0.0932946876,
-0.0132823642,
-0.0290897787,
0.054017663,
0.0550211854,
-0.0324173085,
-0.0468897596,
0.0272582583,
0.0175965521,
-0.0271786321,
-0.0359870084,
-0.0018706858,
0.0241049286,
-0.0091441311,
-0.0103186723,
-0.0404511504,
0.0180527065,
-0.0145251015,
0.0171304699,
0.0259764772,
-0.0769974068,
-0.0255677924,
-0.0265965927,
0.0147900796,
0.0396537557,
0.0235381946,
-0.0492796227,
-0.0455780551,
0.0384577103,
-0.0203608591,
-0.0018799364,
-0.0175598133,
0.0533954911,
-0.0328852311,
-0.0221511051,
0.0068478296,
0.010047921,
0.0198774748,
-0.0235958528,
-0.0113307759,
0.0100846775,
-0.0186897498,
0.0184065029,
-0.0330346972,
0.0545578599,
0.0014473526,
0.0427078046,
-0.0130537581,
-0.0368486494,
0.0311217196,
0.0321623348,
0.0022099658,
-0.016457716,
0.0203526411,
-0.0093539646,
-0.0091951452,
-0.0477351993,
-0.0354784802,
-0.0124444868,
0.0261050016,
-0.013693464,
-0.004834496,
0.0322685838,
-0.0294056572,
0.0269952193,
-0.0331334546,
0.0364764631,
0.0317264646,
-0.0037697002,
-0.0612938963,
0.0465512089,
0.0054058898,
-0.036466606,
-0.0112549067,
0.0572121218,
-0.0465554371,
-0.0543898903,
-0.04889559,
0.0420130603,
0.0068800976,
0.0531439111,
0.0320871919,
-0.0276451893,
-0.0116155474,
0.0242265109,
-0.0076707643,
0.0430547521,
0.0415108241,
-0.0558004417,
-0.0330329984,
0.0172888078,
-0.0626445115,
0.0393076167,
-0.0188229829,
-0.0275226738,
-0.0515638627,
-0.0191681534,
-0.0308248699,
-0.038503889,
0.0623721331,
-0.0405933969,
0.0309502427,
-0.0426606908,
-0.0420507304,
0.031473767,
0.0042249481,
-0.0669652224,
0.0034768542,
0.0081418548,
-0.0275627207,
0.0008286652,
0.043443948,
0.0365121812,
-0.0179912578,
-0.0290013365,
-0.0180398338,
-0.0061922558,
-0.0407228768,
-0.0480832681,
0.0215432718,
0.0308295432,
0.0381643921,
0.0240851976,
-0.0234734919,
0.0194177665,
0.0467171818,
0.003904959,
-0.0226265416,
-0.0012017201,
0.0397557952,
0.0364467092,
0.0379885696,
-0.0332103521,
0.0075213592,
0.0516733676,
-0.0213594548,
0.0329768695,
0.0363296159,
-0.0077520772,
-0.0737450048,
0.0413945243,
0.0142724691,
-0.0158647876,
0.0175254438,
-0.0100988727,
0.0113144433,
0.0234009586,
0.0750040784,
-0.0523253307,
0.0155111132,
-0.0097661456,
0.0449063964,
-0.0501900539,
-0.015996648,
0.0290779527,
0.1100753695,
0.0048414976,
0.0335487798,
-0.0342410021,
-0.0268791635,
0.0199487992,
-0.0406039469,
0.0051282039,
0.010882658,
0.0368803516,
-0.0059508337,
-0.0023639689,
-0.0041462844,
-0.0041843634,
-0.0760215223,
0.0053733233,
0.0117114624,
0.0446322709,
-6.791586855e-33,
-0.003281509,
0.0001455676,
-0.0270529389,
0.0014500007,
0.0004875626,
0.0255908277,
0.0048984052,
0.0310128722,
-0.0301763695,
0.0293773469,
0.0187894832,
0.0220149904,
0.0131112877,
0.0380674414,
-0.0170090534,
0.0176034421,
0.0330777504,
-0.0106006972,
0.0308995955,
0.0073782038,
0.0405410156,
0.0103006912,
0.0437942855,
-0.0979268327,
-0.0217091721,
-0.002933139,
-0.0977343619,
-0.0033298933,
0.0234271176,
0.0191983376,
-0.0217731316,
0.0266114455,
0.0168018229,
-0.0353655331,
-0.0407040045,
-0.0114277545,
-0.046939481,
-0.0006724941,
0.0202729236,
-0.0233276747,
-0.0917136595,
-0.0227019526,
0.0879981518,
0.0062922067,
0.0042176046,
-0.0505714566,
0.0543304235,
-0.0198302157,
-0.017601585,
-0.058274243,
-0.038136214,
0.0357069187,
-0.0274180993,
-0.0525091216,
0.0453667194,
-0.005542811,
0.0384385921,
-0.0138793001,
-0.0680455938,
0.0326347873,
-0.0395398512,
0.0418525413,
0.0541150831,
0.0138549935,
-0.0282180272,
0.0869961381,
0.0082535213,
-0.0507290922,
0.007145897,
-0.0133815408,
0.0053566704,
0.0674837306,
0.0339942463,
0.0487840138,
0.0554092415,
-0.0021232099,
-0.0389866494,
0.0564710051,
-0.0286525954,
0.0377980471,
0.0149707152,
0.0452391915,
0.025025459,
-0.0030103684,
-0.0197747629,
0.0233107209,
-0.0330089368,
0.027674526,
-0.0263442546,
0.0354142375,
0.018688865,
-0.0073790574,
0.0468586087,
0.0119346771,
0.0642688423,
0.0329312235,
-0.0149905132,
0.0465318002,
0.0163783822,
-0.0626608208,
-0.0377281196,
0.0044406392,
0.0458253771,
-0.0058172564,
-0.0173863247,
0.0010403668,
-0.0095156897,
0.0511034876,
-0.0100375544,
-0.0233059358,
-0.0023089955,
0.0295371488,
0.0133572053,
0.044685334,
0.0225842483,
-0.0002684402,
-0.0398805402,
0.036835257,
-0.0382322185,
0.0547035225,
0.0128723737,
-0.0039897282,
-0.0016464664,
0.010935396,
0.0187642667,
0.0162584707,
-0.029486049,
-0.1139762774,
0.0336242057,
0.0064388532,
-0.0191151425,
0.0399612598,
2.987e-7,
-0.0134933293,
-0.0023522668,
-0.0064526703,
-0.0432642698,
0.006122875,
0.0912351981,
0.0129626412,
0.0121440068,
0.0186120234,
-0.0833950937,
0.0137859704,
0.0429175198,
0.0151781067,
-0.0085507883,
-0.0348276459,
-0.0085204318,
-0.0187345184,
-0.0170063954,
0.0043736636,
0.0150624895,
0.0163524318,
0.1206151173,
0.0284918379,
-0.0297244266,
0.0294272956,
-0.0205460712,
0.0451536626,
0.0054902551,
-0.0230455045,
-0.0021399788,
0.0528597236,
-0.0163609646,
-0.0338705145,
0.0002370775,
-0.0162653346,
-0.0421681516,
0.0619837083,
0.0269369371,
-0.0320900902,
-0.0704234168,
-0.0142141916,
0.0866615176,
-0.0425849333,
0.0360596366,
0.0633541793,
0.0143992901,
-0.038921006,
-0.0439595953,
-0.0412708372,
0.0424121022,
0.0041857366,
0.0275167823,
-0.0367510393,
-0.0145225888,
-0.0070910207,
0.0058782035,
-0.0729591995,
-0.0814481974,
0.0029979041,
0.0221371315,
-0.0411126278,
0.0058881962,
0.0009422619,
-0.0384092033,
0.0160948522,
-0.0563158728,
-0.0626881793,
2.193390955e-34,
0.0366366096,
-0.0381895639,
-0.0003769715,
-0.0468148924,
-0.0186466407,
0.0006972082,
-0.1477216035,
-0.0238285866,
-0.0142320069,
-0.0104431435,
-0.0056732208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14651v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14651v2 | Revisit and Outstrip Entity Alignment: A Perspective of Generative Models | 2023-05-24T02:39:20 | 2024-02-24T06:48:20 | Lingbing Guo, Zhuo Chen, Jiaoyan Chen, Yin Fang, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recent embedding-based methods have achieved great successes in exploiting
entity alignment from knowledge graph (KG) embeddings of multiple modalities.
In this paper, we study embedding-based entity alignment (EEA) from a
perspective of generative models. We show that EEA shares similarities with
typical generative models and prove the effectiveness of the recently developed
generative adversarial network (GAN)-based EEA methods theoretically. We then
reveal that their incomplete objective limits the capacity on both entity
alignment and entity synthesis (i.e., generating new entities). We mitigate
this problem by introducing a generative EEA (GEEA) framework with the proposed
mutual variational autoencoder (M-VAE) as the generative model. M-VAE enables
entity conversion between KGs and generation of new entities from random noise
vectors. We demonstrate the power of GEEA with theoretical analysis and
empirical experiments on both entity alignment and entity synthesis tasks. | [
0.0134695228,
0.1036973372,
-0.0051160385,
0.0206968356,
-0.0002699091,
0.002574052,
-0.0122251874,
-0.0332204513,
0.0109796934,
0.0214665532,
0.0354703106,
-0.012659736,
-0.0137270242,
0.011558421,
0.0764169544,
-0.0218206514,
0.0431853607,
0.0618307814,
-0.033173494,
-0.0271976739,
0.0038254436,
0.0077350233,
-0.0032120838,
0.0054097408,
-0.0239493866,
-0.001723985,
-0.0414936468,
0.0016546036,
0.0637584254,
0.0079133846,
-0.024585899,
0.0176644474,
0.0056297244,
0.0305103883,
0.0000018794,
-0.0326086059,
-0.0049960315,
0.0101845805,
-0.0317034386,
-0.0331785902,
-0.0368193053,
-0.0473818816,
-0.0034237874,
-0.0016330435,
-0.01353948,
-0.0841159448,
0.0641498342,
0.0279150698,
0.0219951961,
0.0658382624,
-0.023529442,
-0.0456902385,
0.058461871,
-0.058547914,
0.0214716475,
-0.0648104623,
0.0246156733,
0.0083873654,
-0.0545847081,
-0.0033505023,
-0.0317547247,
0.0583296418,
0.0210201424,
-0.0203041658,
0.0639234483,
0.058195971,
0.0380560942,
0.0055280756,
0.0077518537,
0.074879609,
-0.0181706846,
-0.0124704977,
0.0154780382,
-0.0077432217,
0.0282904021,
0.0311405919,
-0.0047414531,
-0.0108750258,
0.0003770224,
0.0011608398,
-0.0323375612,
-0.0193742756,
0.0493294373,
-0.0494152121,
-0.0025057932,
-0.0482594855,
0.0603435263,
-0.0252737217,
-0.0445189662,
0.0126515469,
-0.0156141184,
-0.0578658693,
-0.0287673585,
0.0243901424,
-0.0388754755,
0.0154185509,
-0.0969721153,
-0.0143548343,
-0.001188266,
0.0024038681,
-0.0217542052,
0.0251389053,
0.0453756824,
0.0541597009,
-0.038982071,
0.0274086855,
-0.049849581,
-0.0160972588,
-0.0407517143,
-0.0418490805,
-0.0250874031,
-0.0099972729,
0.0103534637,
-0.0023746695,
-0.0144143682,
-0.0380998105,
-0.0570273958,
0.0461473726,
-0.003099598,
0.108871229,
-0.0115793012,
0.0641234294,
-0.0221067071,
-0.0103228446,
-0.0224132985,
-0.0099935168,
-0.052483853,
0.0122933527,
-0.0106290122,
0.014644416,
-0.0011483685,
0.0063855592,
0.0278363284,
-0.0317788981,
-0.0213829949,
0.0719829574,
-0.0031060269,
0.02501438,
-0.0396380164,
-0.0018789655,
0.0211442318,
-0.0268055443,
-0.0147453649,
-0.0215114392,
0.0816309452,
0.0012615706,
-0.0327838473,
-0.0835485533,
-0.0037855937,
-0.0398352258,
-0.0395247564,
0.0802177191,
-0.0085814213,
0.022368513,
0.0525509082,
-0.0244088415,
0.0442297831,
0.0022540509,
0.0481018126,
-0.0279919077,
-0.0013875137,
-0.0086345058,
-0.0304726586,
0.0294979494,
0.0567957424,
-0.0386919565,
0.0278854743,
-0.0014945581,
-0.0122191962,
0.0796154737,
0.0285673793,
0.0290303957,
-0.013991545,
-0.0255015548,
0.046693515,
-0.0035545651,
0.00437997,
0.0558363199,
0.0364017263,
-0.0104429843,
-0.0402805433,
-0.0042778584,
-0.0403126888,
0.0495859161,
-0.0278764945,
0.028835319,
0.0261326786,
0.0414564461,
-0.0311792456,
0.0076829768,
0.0356785357,
-0.0118686389,
-0.0222395714,
-0.0339030586,
0.0136340242,
0.0103078745,
-0.0369332358,
0.0126024699,
-0.0032529829,
-0.0274373256,
0.0231658313,
0.02324472,
-0.0039153686,
0.0454305075,
0.0544245206,
0.0220590476,
-0.0564934202,
-0.0114278272,
-0.0695456564,
0.0490770936,
0.039864108,
-0.0310905855,
-0.0273125283,
-0.062095046,
-0.0736070573,
-0.0249434151,
-0.0148268463,
0.0314362533,
0.0222485829,
0.0260942709,
0.0320428945,
-0.0566076823,
0.0341401994,
0.0400600061,
-0.0630593449,
0.0221954957,
-0.0199260786,
0.056430459,
0.013983991,
0.0374199413,
-0.0112232137,
0.0199833773,
0.0294923298,
-0.0271229818,
-0.0120899091,
0.0188424643,
0.0018975256,
-0.0403341241,
0.0345496163,
-0.04230804,
-0.0253088064,
-0.0263619144,
-0.0350257456,
-0.0609305464,
0.0162371267,
-0.0065554101,
0.0157077312,
0.0002864671,
0.0158585832,
0.0289289914,
0.0171567388,
-0.0045048497,
0.0949505568,
-0.0119710239,
0.0101692462,
0.0386959352,
0.0418193489,
0.0624405779,
-0.0209562033,
-0.0247186292,
-0.0168462656,
0.0257628355,
0.0136961751,
0.0331253372,
-0.0613725595,
-0.0236700848,
-0.0351354256,
-0.0879869312,
0.0330511443,
0.0114974827,
0.0189252198,
0.026712805,
0.0257524159,
0.0020988947,
0.0177993253,
-0.0556906238,
0.0202963687,
-0.0011424368,
-0.0183486193,
0.043048583,
-0.0301246848,
-0.0158736184,
-0.0025871007,
0.0059055677,
-0.0168606732,
0.0481915362,
0.0285608191,
0.0168351904,
-0.0385112315,
0.0263481438,
-0.0554358512,
0.023532223,
-0.0106215021,
-0.0018119517,
0.0100905951,
0.0545220487,
0.0949275568,
0.012604448,
-0.0014297256,
0.0345943272,
-0.0148484614,
0.0119755436,
-0.0463700816,
0.0080560995,
-0.0315847583,
0.0130037526,
-0.0148363477,
-0.0261336006,
-0.0352977253,
0.025016861,
0.034760572,
-0.0023426437,
-0.0861100331,
0.0702555254,
0.0660474822,
-0.019214021,
0.0057495157,
0.0223536287,
0.0127865747,
-0.0193951521,
-0.0803938285,
0.0108037908,
0.0691156685,
-0.005100064,
0.0302145705,
0.0298942029,
0.0314954743,
0.0132528171,
0.0234762765,
0.032613229,
0.0447356775,
0.0101996111,
-0.0244711656,
-0.0681317747,
0.0667632073,
0.044292815,
-0.021560736,
0.0221819673,
0.0304426942,
0.030031113,
0.0066831619,
-0.0055583166,
-0.0765946507,
0.0119345821,
0.0577311777,
0.0371387117,
0.057698667,
-0.0271267351,
-0.0606262013,
-0.0052965563,
-0.0032854339,
-0.0254791547,
0.0216336884,
-0.0066707139,
-0.0299037248,
0.0640441626,
0.0688984394,
-0.000941573,
-0.0051852209,
0.0149868801,
-0.0161220096,
0.014702322,
-0.0158060957,
0.0046676537,
-0.0112126004,
-0.0092805699,
-0.0248726625,
-0.0331853479,
0.0013561965,
-0.0112833325,
0.0310549363,
0.0309674665,
0.0199265126,
0.0638259202,
-0.0092517454,
0.0287659019,
0.0039042782,
0.0367812663,
0.0064085666,
0.0199879762,
0.0106252255,
-0.0761302412,
0.0205456782,
-0.0355610326,
0.0146394623,
0.0275746547,
-0.0587239675,
0.0088502681,
-0.1030866429,
-0.0245373156,
0.0067860344,
-0.0277748089,
-0.0556653962,
-0.010867578,
0.0135211628,
-0.0282309782,
0.0052366857,
-0.021675311,
0.0493761823,
0.0029019027,
0.0170558598,
0.0396839902,
-0.068642132,
-0.0539946929,
-0.0812273473,
0.1050504893,
0.0624863766,
0.0528324433,
0.0057690311,
-0.0152148493,
-0.070301801,
-0.0129858758,
-0.0264760386,
0.0455653705,
0.0566280037,
-0.0295386799,
-0.0332764387,
-0.0048306077,
0.031990286,
-0.0154841822,
0.0107500479,
0.0034490782,
0.0391658321,
0.0142906094,
-0.0060638748,
-0.0160432681,
-0.0397868194,
0.0114300707,
0.0595389605,
0.0003775728,
0.00103115,
0.0091260206,
-0.0206215251,
0.0685510263,
-0.0503601618,
0.0041558044,
0.0354811661,
-0.0205058698,
-0.0235366467,
-0.0492170155,
-0.0633713007,
0.0212048162,
0.0161705762,
0.0696047395,
0.0285801347,
0.0181383658,
-0.0660947189,
-0.0402783267,
-0.0318681374,
-0.0035517884,
-0.0240889806,
0.0192186907,
-0.046269495,
0.0047842376,
-0.0354388878,
-0.0344775505,
-0.0225273203,
-0.0632255599,
-0.0785786659,
-0.0253936127,
0.0002130301,
0.0003183274,
0.0794644803,
-0.0353804044,
0.0079301838,
0.0535809211,
0.040606156,
-0.0136770401,
-0.0134284953,
-0.046815712,
0.0050526056,
-0.0208516736,
0.0133944508,
-0.0542486757,
-0.0076492708,
0.0267955996,
0.0316365846,
-0.0353565179,
-0.060761679,
0.0094153984,
0.0112039046,
-0.0325509608,
-0.037422806,
-0.006531022,
-0.0551237874,
-0.0101912785,
0.014050629,
-0.021811856,
-0.0247485396,
-0.0565831549,
0.043868795,
0.0305810031,
-0.0011479271,
0.0514635406,
0.0479726717,
0.021850558,
-0.0472758226,
-0.0599300601,
-0.0207064524,
0.0190270059,
0.0225019045,
-0.0010405042,
-0.0085216518,
0.0516759939,
0.0287155062,
0.0307274871,
-0.0474277996,
0.0009436138,
0.0359775387,
0.0339652151,
-0.0070679844,
0.0030648625,
-0.0248918906,
-0.0154304095,
-0.0539745651,
0.0628039315,
0.0682675317,
0.0075557088,
0.0507563464,
-0.0179384984,
0.0069130789,
0.004310519,
0.0278565399,
-0.0155797908,
-0.0213833302,
0.0293554012,
-0.0111162057,
-0.010633844,
0.0001047389,
0.0492467023,
0.0015188202,
0.0704391003,
-0.0830910131,
-0.0139767528,
-0.0735866949,
-0.0266958605,
0.0789675042,
-0.0290363301,
-0.018389266,
-0.0031475155,
0.0004714589,
-0.0506169461,
0.0096640391,
0.028495146,
-0.0397533402,
0.046056889,
0.0120767485,
0.0319844447,
-0.0253471211,
-0.0219903104,
0.0185857024,
0.0219119173,
-0.0234345868,
-0.0423405766,
0.0003634129,
-5.709482591e-33,
-0.0453858264,
-0.0166218169,
0.033491984,
-0.058767017,
-0.0493152887,
-0.0286875535,
-0.050870575,
-0.0144097256,
-0.0173467901,
0.0011397547,
0.0133514004,
-0.0004783894,
-0.0237110369,
0.013817369,
0.0072686472,
-0.0366800651,
0.0620606802,
-0.0021514283,
0.0014551174,
0.0109448489,
0.0058152601,
0.0220754202,
0.0330388881,
-0.0883610323,
0.0375114456,
-0.021190282,
-0.0079910401,
-0.0244276021,
0.0163608491,
0.0307855159,
-0.0131707117,
0.0110307373,
-0.0065096007,
0.0017025361,
0.0093747936,
-0.0386263728,
-0.1057035848,
-0.0352750681,
-0.0092571629,
0.0298582651,
-0.024612559,
-0.0439485274,
0.0684008077,
-0.0102913259,
0.0387862809,
-0.0073831012,
0.0623068362,
0.0030451471,
-0.032377068,
-0.0615291968,
-0.0681642368,
-0.0092049222,
-0.0246030148,
0.0006009167,
0.0022061155,
-0.0749920979,
0.066147171,
-0.0403669998,
-0.0825021267,
0.0042804796,
-0.0237045474,
0.0000598313,
0.0595807694,
0.0209280569,
0.0135269938,
0.0267313588,
-0.0014714365,
-0.0479623191,
-0.0480821654,
0.0167934094,
-0.0286662392,
0.022192223,
-0.0119621251,
0.0711279213,
-0.018407369,
-0.0206026025,
-0.0702302158,
0.0656411201,
-0.0392664671,
0.0038337517,
-0.0041793571,
0.0212300401,
-0.026886018,
-0.0059643895,
-0.0298292004,
-0.0581965931,
-0.013962877,
-0.0519640259,
0.0132119395,
-0.0094334381,
-0.0387331992,
-0.001931917,
-0.0020523204,
-0.0554188453,
-0.0385568216,
0.0414740145,
0.0135754151,
0.0038799744,
-0.0151860677,
0.0134303179,
-0.0442144983,
-0.0339930728,
0.0527461581,
-0.0035392258,
0.0157315936,
0.0450209491,
0.0214440618,
-0.0063406094,
-0.0246358123,
0.0053923139,
-0.0143712768,
-0.0181956328,
-0.0286972336,
-0.0404488519,
0.0358117744,
0.017432116,
-0.003472453,
-0.0466346219,
0.0737451464,
0.0392000265,
-0.0003374559,
0.0107190358,
0.0286044143,
0.0201003216,
-0.028830871,
0.01459397,
-0.0281704292,
-0.0138514396,
0.0227272287,
-0.0727279931,
-0.0176728927,
-0.0107892109,
2.609e-7,
0.0457500741,
-0.0265192501,
0.077666536,
0.0148816556,
0.000202345,
0.0282495562,
0.015390276,
0.0489867479,
-0.0370133109,
-0.017379174,
0.0571397506,
0.0142587516,
0.0025741167,
0.0187437367,
-0.0290299132,
0.0228619408,
-0.0164803602,
0.022570923,
-0.0236810632,
0.0443282463,
0.0311142728,
0.0708848014,
0.0334114134,
0.0354480222,
0.0162359662,
-0.0127776144,
0.0527513735,
0.016414687,
-0.0167536419,
0.0523891822,
0.0404376127,
0.0172703695,
-0.0352963582,
0.0439367667,
-0.0142780039,
0.0311278198,
0.052573707,
0.0126278233,
-0.0114970664,
0.0163286272,
-0.0634881556,
-0.0297237486,
-0.0027077543,
-0.0176283587,
0.0295389369,
-0.040292602,
-0.0257886909,
0.0259841308,
-0.0579442605,
0.0557303987,
0.0267340243,
0.0345322601,
-0.0070705977,
-0.0308610648,
0.0214835182,
0.0444931388,
-0.0202120654,
-0.0465733595,
0.0328744091,
-0.0001108725,
-0.0526326708,
-0.0071296999,
0.0104531348,
-0.0417090021,
0.0500233658,
-0.0068631438,
0.000322888,
2.009058747e-34,
-0.0349619538,
0.0243671406,
0.0001799629,
-0.0129204467,
0.0117121935,
-0.0639944673,
-0.0001409157,
0.0192201044,
-0.0177437849,
-0.0393015407,
-0.027295148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14647v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14647v3 | Scientific Opinion Summarization: Paper Meta-review Generation Dataset, Methods, and Evaluation | 2023-05-24T02:33:35 | 2024-06-16T03:44:52 | Qi Zeng, Mankeerat Sidhu, Ansel Blume, Hou Pong Chan, Lu Wang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinions in scientific research papers can be divergent, leading to
controversies among reviewers. However, most existing datasets for opinion
summarization are centered around product reviews and assume that the analyzed
opinions are non-controversial, failing to account for the variability seen in
other contexts such as academic papers, political debates, or social media
discussions. To address this gap, we propose the task of scientific opinion
summarization, where research paper reviews are synthesized into meta-reviews.
To facilitate this task, we introduce the ORSUM dataset covering 15,062 paper
meta-reviews and 57,536 paper reviews from 47 conferences. Furthermore, we
propose the Checklist-guided Iterative Introspection approach, which breaks
down scientific opinion summarization into several stages, iteratively refining
the summary under the guidance of questions from a checklist. Our experiments
show that (1) human-written summaries do not always satisfy all necessary
criteria such as depth of discussion, and identifying consensus and controversy
for the specific domain, and (2) the combination of task decomposition and
iterative self-refinement shows strong potential for enhancing the opinions and
can be applied to other complex text generation using black-box LLMs. | [
0.0269768722,
0.0023086674,
0.0308586098,
-0.0280728247,
-0.0179821216,
-0.0024205921,
0.0162209552,
-0.0537576303,
-0.0430171974,
-0.0478466935,
-0.0370166861,
0.0059860959,
0.0158966817,
0.02183038,
-0.0122338887,
-0.0586157665,
0.0013768821,
0.0119357882,
0.0375397652,
0.0074432655,
0.0168853551,
-0.0243249852,
-0.0115696006,
0.024950074,
0.0736566707,
-0.0153428903,
0.0087543093,
-0.0017120731,
0.0556542501,
-0.0428321511,
0.0045960727,
0.0360571966,
-0.0033968226,
0.0470735542,
0.0000015829,
-0.0341335796,
-0.021545168,
-0.0080856523,
0.0472060814,
0.019761445,
0.063856706,
-0.0049899719,
0.0017100188,
0.0309288595,
-0.0189021453,
-0.0301017165,
0.0064251539,
0.0567752048,
0.0581849627,
0.0503856353,
-0.0076891403,
-0.0090847863,
-0.0381856412,
-0.0269237831,
-0.0116996514,
0.0445043966,
-0.0043858481,
-0.0148630701,
-0.0240061246,
0.0467758328,
0.0372078642,
0.0069225943,
-0.0117525943,
-0.0547688566,
0.0188790616,
0.0113488613,
-0.0459071212,
0.0033010684,
0.0066774082,
0.0742180422,
0.0138558242,
-0.0115597993,
0.0371535495,
0.0158295482,
0.0088778324,
0.0189154185,
-0.0565119721,
0.0669268444,
0.0044052517,
0.010358599,
-0.0233785994,
0.0431219526,
-0.0029277971,
0.0104692513,
0.0130857835,
0.0684027523,
-0.0136624854,
-0.0536264591,
-0.0200125799,
0.0106961122,
0.008167685,
-0.0458047502,
-0.0325672254,
0.0098379031,
-0.0129124355,
-0.0157438237,
-0.0185828805,
-0.048867669,
0.0464803167,
-0.0266366974,
0.0691091865,
-0.0397305526,
0.0028540781,
0.0389140099,
0.0229406748,
-0.046733778,
0.0162832048,
0.0094896676,
-0.0406129323,
0.0248090867,
-0.0435251258,
-0.0016866936,
0.0079263775,
0.036196854,
-0.0302522797,
0.0220637135,
-0.0687050372,
-0.018358022,
-0.011149276,
-0.0139397644,
0.0348936282,
0.0126159778,
0.0217922088,
-0.002084933,
-0.0282068159,
0.0506882779,
-0.0290913396,
0.0196524765,
0.043233633,
0.0528528877,
-0.0185216032,
0.0419080481,
-0.0018588785,
0.0116918404,
-0.005719142,
0.0181762073,
-0.0097777601,
-0.025682427,
0.0080659585,
-0.0277831648,
-0.0312805139,
-0.065667592,
0.0466702096,
-0.0659384578,
0.0031761783,
-0.0361979268,
-0.0345060229,
0.0060842764,
0.0032952547,
0.0161344483,
0.0060265441,
0.0560413636,
-0.0981441289,
-0.0233139563,
0.0502103455,
0.0035233274,
0.0077572581,
0.0126945423,
0.0276809391,
0.017814111,
0.0321025029,
-0.0063525815,
0.0115382746,
-0.0579599328,
0.0304941796,
-0.0049954401,
0.0243538674,
-0.0395363607,
-0.0714208856,
0.0090337172,
-0.0209460352,
0.0569550656,
-0.0029840344,
0.0484817512,
0.0374177992,
0.0362269282,
-0.0476026945,
0.004827139,
-0.0088065211,
0.017190123,
0.0398258381,
0.0425856784,
0.0062457318,
0.0517346635,
-0.0026042259,
0.030809816,
0.0592153594,
0.0528083704,
-0.0135097308,
-0.0707105026,
0.0003634706,
-0.0029436557,
0.0040854919,
-0.0236042887,
0.0326649174,
0.023062041,
-0.0325017311,
-0.003790244,
0.0247926004,
-0.0767936409,
0.0075412756,
-0.006934633,
0.0468976721,
0.0157525819,
0.0275476184,
-0.0430961624,
-0.0533108115,
-0.0232489333,
0.0360136703,
0.0513341762,
0.0413038321,
-0.0081372941,
-0.0440036282,
-0.0279802699,
-0.0422720648,
-0.0345907845,
0.0151837785,
-0.0177013483,
-0.0321889482,
-0.0518645495,
0.0324840136,
-0.0150908409,
-0.0770922229,
0.0267286841,
-0.0112695117,
-0.0083589405,
0.0374034084,
-0.0260180309,
0.0355891138,
0.0450387821,
-0.0283194836,
0.0397067517,
0.0695380196,
-0.0417774767,
-0.0304532964,
0.049069237,
0.0345453992,
-0.0366804413,
0.0373275615,
-0.1091122031,
-0.0117703676,
0.0249117613,
-0.0488986932,
-0.0688702911,
0.0382815078,
-0.0101716435,
-0.0533905998,
0.0020434598,
-0.0008255717,
0.0001941075,
0.0029176089,
-0.0479161665,
0.0316358469,
-0.0059097004,
0.0105119096,
0.0425966084,
-0.0826815516,
0.0004779353,
0.0017608289,
-0.0363255516,
0.0001578926,
0.0293254182,
-0.01163112,
0.058018636,
-0.0004786412,
-0.0183430165,
-0.0221700985,
-0.0915409997,
0.0102025494,
0.0075908704,
0.0135153187,
0.051726874,
-0.0267391242,
0.0295880865,
0.0248403829,
-0.0226695929,
0.0046180272,
0.0320266001,
-0.0035341193,
0.0806667656,
0.0032283079,
0.0287230723,
-0.0702331811,
-0.0314480476,
-0.0228904523,
0.0204086844,
0.0383141041,
0.0177801307,
-0.0314717628,
0.0318963192,
-0.0353596359,
-0.0323101133,
-0.0000418406,
0.0160129759,
0.0310534649,
0.0108026126,
0.0436213464,
0.0436101593,
0.043598175,
-0.0028361164,
0.0956084803,
0.0271249488,
-0.0093411664,
-0.02380253,
-0.0216121431,
0.0255326573,
0.0207772329,
-0.0442588441,
0.0766037107,
0.0670439452,
-0.0227585398,
-0.0025800276,
-0.0124646248,
0.0242365468,
-0.0124630025,
-0.0011726591,
-0.0088459002,
-0.0239048786,
-0.0141597651,
0.0543277301,
0.0041472008,
0.0054500885,
0.0550115965,
-0.0093759112,
0.0290171988,
-0.0859778598,
0.0104761589,
-0.0629615262,
0.00143738,
-0.011066041,
0.0060207457,
0.0190292243,
0.0489669777,
-0.0354735143,
-0.0529975072,
0.0285014249,
-0.0100411996,
0.0353660099,
-0.0560966097,
0.0140671097,
-0.029673174,
-0.0124005917,
0.0349678136,
-0.0152964275,
-0.0094389375,
0.011581636,
0.0485530123,
-0.0224835761,
-0.0440002047,
-0.0062796609,
0.0449666269,
0.0300445464,
-0.0318416804,
-0.0246866699,
-0.0218820795,
0.0342196152,
0.0683783814,
-0.0137398932,
0.0693529025,
-0.0123633081,
0.0291329455,
0.0610724911,
0.0268825833,
0.0169353001,
-0.0183847677,
-0.0683946088,
-0.0219784174,
-0.0793804377,
0.0073531475,
-0.0367219634,
0.0615466759,
-0.0251462348,
0.0154203298,
0.104308553,
0.0183621347,
-0.0534598567,
-0.0383750796,
-0.0166127812,
0.0212717,
0.0154596092,
-0.000212064,
-0.0354044363,
0.0082235374,
-0.0297826491,
0.0475584306,
-0.0092703886,
-0.0362249427,
-0.0121841021,
-0.059957616,
0.0054403679,
0.0107572004,
-0.0162351131,
-0.0150398947,
-0.0509796627,
-0.0105530098,
-0.017935954,
0.0080493866,
0.0359582715,
-0.0285190791,
0.0114009492,
0.0313126184,
-0.0379216373,
-0.0274592489,
-0.0031848943,
-0.0329442397,
0.0306828227,
0.0229541697,
0.0269283876,
-0.0055246707,
0.0322298072,
0.0914566964,
0.0124380523,
-0.0353496186,
0.0024161243,
0.0695261732,
0.0082942201,
0.010796777,
-0.0211058091,
0.0393620431,
-0.0450496674,
-0.0096577592,
0.0558208488,
0.0354065448,
-0.0132265016,
-0.0175936259,
-0.0823956206,
0.042853076,
-0.0308280401,
0.0837715343,
0.0141157666,
-0.0320509225,
-0.0463690422,
-0.0065017561,
-0.0072955964,
-0.0623661913,
-0.0066967513,
-0.0103960717,
-0.0089480793,
0.0007422759,
-0.0860828534,
-0.0411322303,
0.0162756089,
0.0109719904,
0.0015792138,
-0.0080589987,
0.0449386872,
0.0062844139,
-0.0578454323,
-0.0089916252,
0.0174425654,
-0.037737526,
-0.0175643936,
-0.021127183,
0.0802027211,
0.0220329035,
-0.0007552584,
0.0178969949,
-0.0323578827,
-0.0552868471,
-0.0306579955,
0.0708404481,
0.0236368161,
0.0251754988,
0.0399819575,
-0.012380898,
0.02008643,
0.0359289572,
0.0354752988,
-0.0138690732,
0.0129079921,
0.0228910018,
-0.0185091123,
-0.0233199857,
-0.009088642,
0.0360743664,
-0.0324894749,
0.0022437093,
-0.0609915368,
-0.0301964004,
0.033375062,
0.0330466516,
0.0141048674,
-0.0536414124,
0.0619195141,
-0.0375083275,
-0.0064761573,
-0.0530943237,
-0.0101580974,
-0.0492837355,
0.0360239223,
-0.0285947081,
-0.0130057903,
0.00940294,
0.0613463074,
-0.0571412146,
0.0330930389,
-0.0394213125,
0.0832686797,
-0.0342973471,
0.0103979092,
-0.0055380082,
-0.0303763822,
-0.0404862911,
-0.0006480482,
-0.0445775017,
-0.0201661829,
0.0240740757,
-0.006641624,
0.0409215651,
0.0276300162,
-0.0308491271,
0.0452848002,
-0.0966113955,
0.0223272275,
-0.0426406525,
0.014063946,
-0.0161443353,
0.023466967,
0.0708905607,
-0.0245439112,
-0.0333837308,
-0.0258497577,
0.049122531,
0.0024122547,
0.0467053242,
0.0112873726,
0.0051291478,
-0.0257546827,
-0.0487698391,
0.0938731059,
-0.0269624051,
-0.0177219659,
0.0407166146,
-0.0346744806,
-0.0650485307,
-0.0468039848,
-0.0601145774,
0.0104725026,
0.0103731416,
-0.0284598731,
-0.0545114614,
-0.0042641987,
0.0470151491,
0.0278390124,
0.0573345423,
-0.0323188454,
0.001919809,
0.0244598351,
0.0074194646,
0.0101376222,
-0.0337425247,
0.007308051,
-0.0332300961,
-0.03709599,
-0.0061596292,
-5.351363829e-33,
-0.0261936579,
-0.0482797548,
-0.0231238231,
0.0080988975,
-0.0049189189,
0.0129034361,
-0.0861971453,
0.021148026,
0.0305450074,
0.0399796814,
-0.0120275356,
0.000828654,
-0.0071318569,
0.0398311429,
0.0338737182,
0.0095802229,
0.0571435653,
-0.0235821325,
-0.0333820879,
0.044216875,
0.0156476591,
-0.0069212737,
0.0267733298,
-0.0336817577,
0.0595916286,
0.0096891606,
-0.0344549306,
0.0009255508,
0.0052917381,
0.0371849313,
-0.0144019825,
0.0314380638,
0.0298973862,
-0.0454069935,
-0.0280890018,
0.0172566064,
-0.0567412078,
-0.0100192092,
-0.0044100238,
-0.0626577213,
-0.0575123988,
-0.0093896287,
0.0471599363,
-0.0102917096,
-0.0371244103,
-0.0150622148,
0.0544204414,
-0.0515322872,
-0.0182254724,
-0.0765255839,
-0.0245757829,
0.0172548797,
-0.0317917131,
0.000620637,
0.0044208434,
0.0317917503,
-0.0239888187,
0.0365814529,
-0.0218812507,
0.0669396892,
0.0404863209,
0.0332642607,
-0.0040934035,
-0.0266150609,
0.0385454558,
0.0544330329,
0.0047011827,
0.0551911481,
-0.0264750905,
0.0202023648,
-0.0250515845,
0.0076172706,
0.02599358,
0.0620827004,
0.0392800532,
0.021025816,
-0.0680010244,
0.0635919943,
0.0036118231,
0.0140747726,
0.0513944775,
-0.0177831966,
0.0656359047,
0.0014867592,
-0.0031743008,
-0.0391412079,
0.0173841752,
-0.0139227547,
-0.0285243113,
0.0104976147,
-0.075602293,
-0.0477606654,
0.0066528879,
-0.0354712941,
0.0103077022,
0.0240668226,
-0.0230693482,
0.0336396359,
0.028808929,
-0.0544401631,
-0.0624042898,
0.0301531218,
-0.0001536249,
0.0464656018,
0.003784314,
0.0024603182,
0.0474477857,
-0.0303587299,
-0.05468693,
0.0138944238,
0.0014301804,
0.0421512537,
-0.0118190395,
0.0383291058,
-0.0281439759,
0.012447672,
0.017449405,
0.0147006689,
-0.0033199713,
0.0188934691,
0.0093629267,
0.0531518795,
0.0068838266,
0.0440406352,
0.0143189896,
0.016858492,
0.0035784633,
0.0111214686,
0.014860006,
-0.0345769189,
0.0014309608,
-0.0292066522,
2.344e-7,
0.0481106788,
0.0561083332,
0.0320675038,
-0.0258644577,
0.0241622701,
0.0166898984,
0.0023696902,
0.0296983421,
0.0046161585,
-0.0304051768,
0.0461227074,
-0.002256491,
0.0129040238,
0.0351569317,
-0.0800718516,
-0.068234317,
-0.0563953668,
-0.0357770287,
-0.0151996044,
0.0000952262,
0.042412404,
0.0260827355,
-0.0424801558,
-0.0098413546,
-0.0432882607,
0.0213877689,
0.054527171,
-0.0274980962,
-0.0210514441,
0.0510700345,
0.0312409289,
-0.056344144,
-0.0223449897,
-0.0219810344,
-0.0204487015,
-0.0160695985,
0.0153283905,
0.0326521061,
0.0560804754,
-0.0365816467,
0.0592659228,
0.0166952256,
0.0575483218,
0.0153369829,
0.0247168057,
-0.0849232376,
-0.0566957779,
-0.0829444751,
-0.0412506349,
0.0153534301,
0.049982097,
-0.0249176305,
-0.0079231793,
0.0397098847,
-0.0479319282,
-0.0072295959,
-0.0020970721,
-0.0559815541,
-0.0393055119,
0.0590227135,
-0.0267909113,
-0.0377043784,
0.0068544615,
-0.0255168173,
0.0105092432,
-0.0672852546,
0.015608971,
2.011774093e-34,
0.1035287827,
-0.043364685,
-0.0298532695,
-0.0103065167,
0.0014241651,
-0.0104827173,
-0.060769558,
-0.0269322917,
0.0184952337,
-0.035852693,
0.0121932896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14645v1 | Iteratively Improving Biomedical Entity Linking and Event Extraction via Hard Expectation-Maximization | 2023-05-24T02:30:31 | 2023-05-24T02:30:31 | Xiaochu Li, Minqian Liu, Zhiyang Xu, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical entity linking and event extraction are two crucial tasks to
support text understanding and retrieval in the biomedical domain. These two
tasks intrinsically benefit each other: entity linking disambiguates the
biomedical concepts by referring to external knowledge bases and the domain
knowledge further provides additional clues to understand and extract the
biological processes, while event extraction identifies a key trigger and
entities involved to describe each biological process which also captures the
structural context to better disambiguate the biomedical entities. However,
previous research typically solves these two tasks separately or in a pipeline,
leading to error propagation. What's more, it's even more challenging to solve
these two tasks together as there is no existing dataset that contains
annotations for both tasks. To solve these challenges, we propose joint
biomedical entity linking and event extraction by regarding the event
structures and entity references in knowledge bases as latent variables and
updating the two task-specific models in a hard Expectation-Maximization (EM)
fashion: (1) predicting the missing variables for each partially annotated
dataset based on the current two task-specific models, and (2) updating the
parameters of each model on the corresponding pseudo completed dataset.
Experimental results on two benchmark datasets: Genia 2011 for event extraction
and BC4GO for entity linking, show that our joint framework significantly
improves the model for each individual task and outperforms the strong
baselines for both tasks. We will make the code and model checkpoints publicly
available once the paper is accepted. | [
0.0345618948,
0.01538515,
0.0163798444,
-0.0245470461,
0.0109989503,
0.0687283203,
-0.0331080332,
-0.0033124201,
0.0605913736,
-0.0164714083,
0.013078087,
0.0203399956,
-0.0208052695,
0.0460449643,
0.0169839971,
-0.0371442363,
0.0249230023,
0.0573827587,
0.0181096997,
0.0147565706,
-0.0007902714,
0.0197257809,
-0.0202063099,
0.0051387334,
0.0063465931,
0.0276706759,
0.0086172167,
0.0025652247,
0.0719210729,
-0.046513468,
-0.0049630497,
0.0040769908,
-0.0147751858,
0.0113014141,
0.0000018014,
-0.0584938265,
-0.0447293594,
0.0255103018,
-0.0480272807,
0.0032797514,
-0.0198966675,
-0.047987178,
0.0247681234,
-0.0379428491,
-0.0065903291,
-0.068862386,
0.050100293,
0.0477093048,
0.0164273772,
0.0433194116,
-0.0144974031,
-0.0211706925,
0.0351252034,
-0.0444716327,
-0.0001670201,
-0.0559188575,
0.0738954619,
-0.029884629,
0.0139882937,
0.0085416231,
0.0212303679,
0.0287782978,
-0.010875646,
0.0426594876,
0.0036245899,
0.0538339131,
-0.007964259,
-0.0193306897,
0.014578769,
0.0733564049,
0.0178463347,
-0.0210999902,
0.0777727365,
0.0114910016,
-0.0328471959,
0.0429728441,
-0.0357873291,
-0.0307824872,
-0.0487766936,
-0.0064252042,
0.015749855,
-0.0369185843,
0.0302416962,
0.0089778239,
0.0104190893,
-0.0120533202,
0.0061477674,
-0.0063316687,
-0.0009330689,
0.0278024059,
-0.0096968887,
-0.0232911333,
0.0598905794,
0.0191182494,
-0.0253996644,
0.0408654436,
-0.0137687186,
-0.0042372718,
0.0147849414,
-0.0406756029,
-0.0721293986,
-0.0061427006,
0.004658428,
0.0554948747,
-0.0406742468,
-0.0399879478,
-0.0473059453,
0.0089642061,
-0.0021951478,
-0.0268104486,
-0.0479621999,
0.0218740646,
-0.0126807056,
0.0358158015,
-0.0343205109,
0.0219045635,
-0.0462313294,
-0.0227964614,
-0.0021352156,
0.0326821357,
-0.0019051203,
-0.0081702443,
-0.070338957,
0.003979926,
-0.0002834674,
0.0057052965,
-0.0360655151,
-0.0022594538,
-0.0337508991,
-0.040897347,
-0.0193000212,
-0.0267821718,
0.0226177014,
-0.0285177398,
-0.0003885384,
0.0524387434,
0.0240995921,
-0.0122307232,
-0.065790534,
-0.0370084867,
0.0146697043,
-0.0159834903,
-0.0098626018,
-0.0234099049,
0.0425392948,
0.0046749236,
-0.011739579,
-0.0439745635,
0.0132079851,
-0.0352181792,
-0.0797935277,
0.090091683,
-0.0564398207,
-0.0335770659,
0.0605671443,
0.0141523164,
0.0006120609,
0.0413921624,
0.0379670262,
-0.0439403839,
0.0301005971,
0.0418066643,
-0.0250638742,
0.0181468166,
0.0528648347,
-0.0405949727,
0.0596388467,
-0.0008508108,
0.0032140429,
0.0348196179,
0.0261480846,
0.0085349241,
-0.0294940993,
-0.0044566323,
-0.0127106225,
-0.0112168528,
-0.0044851401,
-0.0271238443,
0.0304209422,
-0.0487155579,
-0.0016589401,
0.0053086472,
-0.0093892664,
-0.0031114779,
0.0123981042,
0.0070659211,
-0.0053239493,
0.0235568658,
-0.0071642413,
-0.0038917987,
0.0236174818,
-0.0166887846,
-0.009315718,
0.0082293572,
0.0850049257,
-0.0194357857,
-0.0248958599,
0.0863779187,
0.0656206012,
-0.0030835525,
0.0238431692,
-0.0026638652,
-0.0090538217,
0.0032682223,
0.0319999084,
-0.0502540134,
-0.058218915,
-0.0171809215,
0.0135562634,
-0.0153062139,
-0.0187568292,
-0.0565438196,
0.0187632516,
-0.0220970735,
-0.0166580081,
0.025015261,
0.011419192,
-0.0219769143,
0.0232670046,
0.033005815,
0.0098536694,
-0.0003663221,
0.0078535117,
0.048708722,
-0.0780675858,
-0.0143304449,
-0.0329755619,
0.009985134,
0.0178580191,
0.0038073696,
-0.0050294236,
0.0089746583,
0.0615617409,
-0.0477088094,
-0.0223905686,
0.0134715922,
0.048875954,
-0.0593067333,
0.0214615967,
-0.0161795039,
-0.0244930591,
-0.0191137604,
-0.0735927895,
-0.0383363403,
-0.0078124339,
0.0185358487,
0.0149887772,
0.0073470096,
0.0061281938,
0.0290456936,
-0.0307455957,
-0.0533679835,
0.0494260341,
-0.0106338561,
0.0198305417,
-0.001393054,
-0.0390692167,
0.0143450815,
-0.0350177623,
-0.040902514,
0.0291070677,
0.0387803689,
-0.0463104658,
0.0203466043,
-0.0369368531,
-0.1001751646,
-0.002398134,
-0.0829724744,
0.0518738329,
0.0181400348,
0.0563968793,
0.0449480116,
0.0343898572,
-0.0108033428,
-0.0142031815,
0.0146114621,
-0.0471303388,
-0.0484074503,
0.0109007629,
0.0197103955,
0.0681589469,
-0.0015316494,
-0.0505290627,
0.0007683428,
-0.058802668,
0.0367053933,
0.0192902107,
-0.0756971389,
-0.0221885256,
0.0154566895,
-0.0176314265,
0.0046008904,
-0.0060710236,
0.046617806,
-0.0121983252,
0.0188247636,
0.0453418046,
0.0635657609,
-0.0255787838,
0.0597847216,
-0.001096865,
-0.0367319174,
-0.0351117849,
0.0311543941,
-0.0565992966,
0.0087251393,
-0.014704451,
-0.0234941952,
0.0072530694,
0.0202375259,
-0.0021657764,
-0.0133522796,
-0.0482924879,
-0.0071410616,
-0.0069517246,
0.0091716293,
-0.0205203667,
-0.0004261568,
-0.0248809252,
0.0134924967,
-0.0362458788,
-0.0092935227,
0.0806581229,
0.0355623402,
0.0180969834,
-0.0333641917,
0.0314209647,
-0.0225690417,
0.0299746841,
0.0064855576,
0.0114185233,
0.0066351239,
-0.0325795636,
0.0018013441,
0.0669863001,
0.0242484417,
-0.0399309546,
0.0326846093,
-0.0413401686,
0.0710153654,
0.0346043743,
-0.0075628283,
-0.0201601498,
0.0293561667,
-0.0178939905,
0.0109011522,
-0.0232949983,
0.023255283,
-0.0527342185,
0.0190345328,
0.007049846,
0.026015928,
0.0322376303,
-0.0349355415,
0.0062830485,
0.0281841084,
0.048824653,
-0.0335093029,
-0.006224005,
-0.0087037915,
-0.0131140361,
0.0482121296,
0.0432991572,
0.0039608167,
0.0196949225,
-0.0081443256,
0.0111407991,
-0.0771866217,
-0.0298213698,
-0.0105629815,
0.0222532675,
-0.0508851111,
-0.0048259012,
0.0989020988,
0.0343369432,
-0.0391208306,
0.0144010084,
0.0158614404,
-0.0294544995,
-0.0080146566,
0.0305796694,
-0.0624289475,
-0.0122417854,
-0.008805139,
0.0122219827,
0.0050286581,
-0.086108394,
0.0101075619,
-0.0391876437,
0.0072190114,
-0.0119821662,
-0.0362572037,
-0.0498556197,
-0.0873528123,
0.0566861853,
-0.0740683004,
-0.0395460613,
-0.0009405001,
0.0164370425,
0.0303901825,
0.0128302174,
-0.0096036121,
-0.1137170494,
-0.0017121646,
-0.0483122393,
0.0561905764,
0.0239709131,
0.032142166,
0.0130712241,
0.045322299,
0.0001561022,
-0.0422036462,
-0.0575472675,
-0.0179712139,
0.0806590021,
-0.0022051558,
-0.012960596,
-0.039883744,
0.0461221114,
-0.0046988414,
-0.0366671905,
-0.0253093652,
0.0664694384,
0.0127473585,
0.017155841,
-0.0136471828,
-0.0438494273,
0.0142168626,
0.0652634799,
-0.013530382,
-0.007679583,
0.0170379467,
0.0164509919,
0.0622680672,
0.0085054152,
0.0140168266,
0.0232362244,
-0.0944503397,
-0.0269613322,
-0.0586456992,
-0.0556198657,
0.0597044118,
0.0387993492,
-0.0060539781,
0.0403456874,
0.0312712565,
-0.0085739633,
-0.0478771441,
0.0614223145,
-0.0046818196,
0.0131146228,
0.0074330503,
-0.054754097,
0.0517662168,
0.0325554907,
-0.0390615799,
0.0666671693,
-0.0216337554,
-0.0351872966,
-0.0215016063,
-0.0215522461,
0.0176576562,
0.0368723236,
0.0047161803,
-0.0267278682,
-0.0081623243,
0.0233634673,
-0.0276493691,
-0.0047862646,
-0.0276628044,
0.021837689,
-0.0290805157,
0.018184619,
-0.0396742746,
-0.0033784406,
-0.0152409961,
0.0730518848,
-0.054138083,
-0.035495434,
0.0240360014,
0.0393099785,
0.0593985841,
-0.0394222885,
-0.0271028765,
-0.0743734539,
0.0068368651,
0.0218788441,
0.022277765,
-0.0244253632,
0.0184683073,
0.0235040467,
0.0335937105,
-0.0293225143,
0.0432305485,
0.0051259282,
-0.0069202613,
-0.0766048804,
-0.0054661883,
0.0289440937,
0.0167147759,
0.0406785682,
-0.0218692217,
-0.0020658476,
0.0063355998,
0.0356960259,
0.0147015117,
-0.0656656846,
0.0033277585,
0.042074196,
0.0336606912,
-0.0016055215,
-0.0125069451,
-0.0307933055,
0.0446352437,
-0.0097885374,
0.0197958183,
0.0451883078,
-0.0087185362,
0.0839634687,
-0.0005864076,
-0.0328722559,
-0.0007678957,
0.0112924073,
-0.0093824416,
0.0459442362,
0.0484589711,
0.00984086,
-0.0115537765,
-0.0052751368,
0.0688108727,
-0.0052484311,
0.1416350901,
-0.0301865488,
-0.0406500213,
-0.0320745148,
-0.0218408667,
0.0112949209,
0.0035951179,
-0.0368620455,
-0.0143309431,
-0.040646635,
-0.0235651806,
0.053046789,
-0.0249938909,
-0.0638148263,
0.0024774102,
0.0547883362,
0.0224772636,
0.0263137762,
-0.0269714538,
-0.0018772652,
-0.0040994678,
0.0045399088,
-0.0589414388,
-0.0107929558,
-5.608807745e-33,
-0.0326255821,
-0.0164300967,
0.0008762969,
0.0228557736,
-0.0138646076,
0.0267376173,
-0.0258494392,
-0.0455881506,
0.0052463897,
0.0121703399,
0.0082080904,
-0.0009373997,
0.0049178782,
-0.0204844028,
-0.0160171632,
-0.0334913991,
0.03204979,
0.0186711047,
-0.0003194442,
0.0232667457,
0.0490071587,
0.0756034926,
0.0660072491,
-0.090213351,
0.0534866527,
0.0434310064,
-0.0118908826,
-0.0097242212,
0.0414768569,
0.0498396382,
-0.0120943217,
0.0145964855,
0.024307264,
-0.0655927956,
-0.0001282464,
-0.0374019817,
-0.1570089012,
0.0023977433,
0.0112883141,
-0.0027591665,
-0.0197261404,
-0.043950893,
0.0378679223,
0.0012446479,
0.0282868631,
-0.0340184569,
0.0304665118,
-0.0208778959,
-0.0353794098,
-0.0675593689,
-0.0334222578,
0.0496534556,
-0.0030684005,
0.0458740778,
0.0156388227,
-0.041848246,
-0.0075598028,
0.049845621,
-0.0209801812,
-0.016633451,
-0.0050294385,
0.0027913977,
-0.0232777316,
-0.0081269331,
0.018625848,
0.037996687,
0.008450699,
-0.040069133,
-0.0461988896,
0.0193162207,
-0.0166690126,
0.0076587382,
-0.0218453575,
0.0370874666,
-0.0050958786,
0.0251278598,
-0.1444763243,
0.066412732,
-0.0016545452,
0.0195168946,
-0.0487171933,
0.009194308,
-0.0070525841,
-0.0040196218,
-0.0597816519,
0.0551518127,
-0.0045026895,
-0.0087323897,
-0.0072826813,
0.0107962377,
-0.0276428126,
0.0694292039,
-0.02090404,
-0.0139505155,
-0.0284621902,
0.0012887198,
0.0467136428,
-0.0004770969,
-0.0064126621,
-0.0047333427,
-0.0682439953,
-0.0201856215,
0.0425805673,
-0.0253040958,
0.0335525982,
-0.0070336112,
0.0092294719,
-0.0210788324,
-0.0289152544,
0.0133891543,
0.005146231,
-0.0113304034,
-0.0162375774,
0.0009101407,
0.0308943596,
0.0172350053,
0.019543631,
0.0139074456,
0.0812132359,
0.0483294055,
0.0130929258,
0.0179977026,
0.023356339,
0.0246745776,
-0.016814528,
-0.0120376842,
0.0078800889,
0.0250628684,
-0.0137012098,
-0.0448180661,
-0.0233078767,
-0.0043218569,
2.561e-7,
0.0995214805,
0.00984558,
0.020727789,
0.0250725523,
0.0081860377,
-0.0176452696,
0.0232853554,
0.0123305442,
-0.0097824382,
-0.0242634527,
0.0172171779,
-0.0013955273,
-0.0098509584,
0.0101851057,
-0.0758643597,
-0.0634790435,
-0.0325515717,
-0.0102121001,
-0.0126361717,
-0.0099800434,
0.0442646816,
0.0451434106,
0.0131950537,
0.0089382958,
-0.0230373535,
-0.0146471197,
0.053903725,
-0.0172210168,
-0.0154909529,
0.0582065061,
-0.0011562101,
0.0414153077,
-0.0257439539,
0.076221101,
-0.0306074284,
-0.0072013419,
0.0388974175,
0.0622724593,
-0.0045719342,
0.0163697172,
0.0314680822,
-0.0227382407,
0.0267228521,
0.0099206055,
0.0680980384,
-0.0630282611,
-0.0349303372,
0.0650835782,
-0.0364902355,
0.0444341078,
-0.0116422232,
-0.013702156,
-0.0174286626,
0.0392548963,
0.0011119941,
0.0344903804,
-0.0202274397,
-0.0968035981,
0.0156511031,
0.0765584037,
-0.0274592079,
-0.0515908413,
0.0477863885,
-0.0292950086,
-0.0002659425,
-0.0852589384,
-0.0043416689,
2.212571946e-34,
-0.0180922132,
0.0227326751,
-0.0328820162,
0.046022851,
0.0214907546,
-0.0571495742,
-0.0457209982,
-0.0085394681,
-0.0192122106,
-0.0545807034,
0.0111449938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14635v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14635v2 | CMOT: Cross-modal Mixup via Optimal Transport for Speech Translation | 2023-05-24T02:13:48 | 2023-05-25T08:55:41 | Yan Zhou, Qingkai Fang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end speech translation (ST) is the task of translating speech signals
in the source language into text in the target language. As a cross-modal task,
end-to-end ST is difficult to train with limited data. Existing methods often
try to transfer knowledge from machine translation (MT), but their performances
are restricted by the modality gap between speech and text. In this paper, we
propose Cross-modal Mixup via Optimal Transport CMOT to overcome the modality
gap. We find the alignment between speech and text sequences via optimal
transport and then mix up the sequences from different modalities at a token
level using the alignment. Experiments on the MuST-C ST benchmark demonstrate
that CMOT achieves an average BLEU of 30.0 in 8 translation directions,
outperforming previous methods. Further analysis shows CMOT can adaptively find
the alignment between modalities, which helps alleviate the modality gap
between speech and text. Code is publicly available at
https://github.com/ictnlp/CMOT. | [
-0.0235452652,
0.0359965414,
0.0059125731,
0.0052180057,
-0.0573892929,
-0.0279114526,
-0.0056840088,
0.0059805135,
-0.0797850564,
-0.0229642242,
-0.0294230878,
-0.0419276692,
0.0516756512,
0.0297212992,
0.0155436946,
-0.0528706796,
0.0429820307,
-0.0184226576,
-0.054610163,
0.004901187,
0.0196478087,
-0.0017136668,
-0.0435416363,
0.0070199021,
-0.0142253265,
-0.0033025544,
-0.0350290984,
0.0325726457,
0.0502809472,
-0.0099084442,
-0.0212391745,
0.005512326,
0.0318202451,
0.0609575137,
0.0000020262,
-0.011428168,
-0.0366274789,
0.0077147409,
0.0073360992,
-0.0096858097,
0.0573745742,
-0.0133291846,
-0.0401895605,
0.0623423904,
0.0133859441,
-0.0024091057,
0.0861355513,
0.047311265,
0.0448607542,
0.1033051163,
-0.0209410116,
0.0008472284,
-0.0112745762,
-0.0402821526,
0.0483770669,
-0.0520829633,
-0.0199152213,
-0.0033816746,
-0.0136343343,
0.0090239514,
-0.0425453559,
0.0570707284,
-0.0337019861,
0.0065996614,
-0.0105057536,
0.0105927717,
0.0104275392,
-0.015866382,
-0.0641090646,
0.1021429822,
-0.00002982,
0.0051392629,
0.0047980305,
0.0065740324,
-0.0175825972,
-0.0409596823,
-0.0203129463,
-0.0188333448,
0.0027251157,
-0.0124744456,
-0.0198539402,
0.0322179757,
0.0302291904,
-0.0434391461,
-0.0508925989,
-0.0325974524,
0.0434235744,
-0.0256024152,
-0.0210712403,
-0.0145163368,
0.0342240259,
-0.0342096537,
0.0626289994,
0.0108350376,
-0.02432351,
-0.0209245663,
-0.0426848494,
-0.0622458905,
-0.0294502266,
0.026315121,
0.0102559607,
0.1047304422,
-0.031042967,
0.0066015283,
-0.0253679249,
0.0252974462,
-0.0702357963,
0.0318573862,
-0.0407674015,
-0.0240652189,
-0.0285791215,
0.0230079684,
-0.0127839018,
-0.040050894,
-0.0842090771,
-0.0235529374,
-0.0430236533,
-0.0081345355,
0.0170958266,
-0.0159148108,
0.0466815308,
-0.0166016817,
-0.0809731483,
-0.0370774604,
0.0138913244,
0.0515291728,
0.0198068358,
0.027308302,
0.0013968076,
0.0133528579,
-0.0302801505,
0.0362451822,
0.0408292264,
-0.0295523815,
-0.0233439561,
0.1182774305,
-0.0471274294,
0.0025403474,
0.004137693,
0.0143712284,
-0.0375417396,
-0.0479897112,
-0.0002559962,
-0.0428021923,
0.0344021358,
-0.0127212619,
-0.0022185247,
0.0166022796,
-0.0064087543,
-0.013345209,
-0.0108223232,
0.0792895928,
0.0141246011,
0.0070857606,
0.0516454279,
0.0016538189,
-0.0266438983,
0.0372248776,
0.0561811365,
0.015519035,
-0.0162214916,
-0.0142198633,
-0.0220507011,
0.0595918782,
0.0390836485,
0.0263672341,
-0.0258714147,
-0.0227094349,
0.0372439325,
0.079590939,
0.045328673,
0.0656689554,
-0.0468682609,
-0.0048134476,
0.0416299812,
-0.0044684564,
0.0831007734,
0.0115776742,
0.03162691,
0.0310463812,
-0.0651829317,
-0.0050579095,
0.0121313538,
0.0190238934,
-0.0387423113,
-0.0090994108,
0.0932964161,
0.070837535,
-0.010935287,
-0.0012405691,
0.0238279421,
-0.0236971304,
0.0087984903,
-0.0424415506,
0.0220054537,
-0.0027728721,
-0.0561447777,
0.0487293415,
0.0150806149,
-0.0722140372,
0.0182317272,
-0.0001506124,
-0.0467569679,
0.0095036607,
-0.0175843239,
0.0022056124,
-0.0389969051,
-0.0224590134,
-0.0008181654,
0.0556850657,
0.0105093848,
0.025416879,
0.0526011027,
-0.041442018,
-0.0188007075,
0.0330812037,
-0.0218041465,
0.0267109815,
-0.0374873243,
0.0669074059,
0.0461758599,
-0.0434828885,
0.0402790569,
0.0172907319,
0.0162582472,
0.0362248197,
0.0299580395,
0.0365993008,
0.0466509387,
0.0123269567,
0.001730499,
0.0188431181,
-0.0029112289,
-0.0412215069,
-0.0065483972,
0.0575121418,
-0.0726309568,
-0.0264254306,
0.0583509915,
-0.062307898,
0.0107144117,
0.0157109965,
-0.0136282137,
-0.0744315758,
0.0531040542,
-0.0203233697,
0.0282105245,
-0.0204515699,
0.0172365364,
0.0380628482,
-0.0083907051,
0.0194215849,
0.0343634412,
0.0169280395,
0.0062365052,
0.0433654226,
-0.0044645886,
0.0236992259,
-0.0253967158,
0.0117021324,
0.0595150515,
0.0043277997,
0.0381886289,
0.0204794146,
0.0202050842,
-0.0007628222,
-0.0571957715,
-0.1132289767,
0.0300209858,
-0.0011785394,
0.0382178649,
0.0498377383,
0.0559695028,
0.0028361445,
-0.0011041181,
-0.0380279236,
0.009486055,
0.0174228121,
-0.0285955817,
-0.0040223142,
0.0110694701,
-0.0202920362,
0.0115939276,
0.0279203504,
0.0181046836,
-0.0137306172,
-0.0346708633,
0.0012572373,
-0.0584852323,
0.0027275998,
0.0123577872,
0.0194451027,
-0.0043089134,
-0.0516140275,
-0.0116451252,
0.0248670317,
0.0318487547,
-0.0044862852,
0.0286444258,
-0.0458398387,
0.001841314,
-0.0549430661,
-0.0516071096,
0.0172888543,
0.0034579611,
0.0310252234,
-0.0542876311,
-0.0315433219,
-0.0186702684,
0.0734455511,
0.0044661239,
0.0349641219,
-0.0585633963,
-0.0368358977,
0.0192123894,
-0.0160728581,
-0.01090525,
0.0041349586,
-0.0385666899,
0.0115796449,
-0.0394795761,
-0.002871017,
0.0268730279,
-0.1172188967,
-0.0228286833,
-0.081410937,
0.006891124,
-0.0389475636,
0.0055715665,
-0.0573310442,
0.0306590311,
-0.0430574343,
-0.0644567832,
-0.05383927,
0.0041970303,
0.0119815078,
-0.0251778644,
0.022736486,
-0.0218527839,
0.0160742812,
-0.0367411152,
-0.0432381146,
-0.0091656595,
-0.0147127798,
0.0182589125,
-0.0200249031,
0.0163298789,
-0.0659007952,
-0.0669529662,
0.0181486476,
0.0385450348,
0.0511014238,
-0.0225277245,
0.0279141497,
-0.0129390322,
0.0703842789,
-0.0060290229,
0.0529904515,
-0.0236876458,
-0.0060534403,
-0.0070412168,
0.0030976813,
0.0637938753,
0.0028233908,
-0.0374982469,
-0.0041972636,
0.0235801078,
0.0261713397,
-0.0279949233,
0.0015303957,
0.098764047,
-0.0045540421,
0.0195085537,
0.0649274886,
-0.0288885292,
-0.02402764,
-0.0134004541,
0.0237678364,
0.0389901847,
-0.0047548292,
0.0177799203,
-0.0643583834,
-0.0552751534,
0.0361781418,
0.0108566703,
0.0346996225,
0.0312901884,
-0.0287533384,
-0.0744887292,
0.0004609363,
0.0740889758,
-0.0566183366,
-0.0635360628,
-0.0079527237,
-0.0277731717,
-0.0014736727,
0.0894483328,
0.0026747363,
0.0016615923,
-0.0298754238,
0.0447844826,
0.0674019307,
-0.0382093452,
-0.024457179,
0.0026120306,
0.0941320509,
0.0205237083,
0.0356945023,
-0.006582479,
-0.0308309402,
0.0318629742,
0.0054158592,
0.002939482,
0.0010469566,
-0.0053557376,
-0.0222493522,
-0.0113738375,
0.0326069072,
0.027230816,
-0.0174494032,
0.0224287808,
0.021604633,
0.0495600291,
0.016115075,
0.0388495624,
-0.0013542381,
0.016620839,
0.0205932502,
0.0458850637,
-0.0248155612,
-0.029472284,
0.0014228976,
-0.0144222202,
0.0072162705,
-0.0395990387,
-0.016051067,
-0.000570182,
-0.0080351643,
-0.0562255718,
-0.0714758486,
-0.0064640557,
-0.0150473826,
0.0784949064,
0.0346642248,
0.0258479603,
-0.0339881815,
0.0218910612,
-0.0365203768,
0.0134725375,
-0.0469775386,
0.0418117829,
-0.0733162165,
0.0307705142,
-0.0063083409,
-0.0692250058,
-0.0014568188,
0.0090415059,
-0.0865485594,
-0.0930704921,
-0.030917909,
-0.0370133258,
0.0196040459,
0.081914112,
-0.0323916003,
-0.0042371745,
0.0443517864,
-0.0036516343,
-0.0740015432,
0.0104333749,
0.0388416275,
-0.0448946431,
-0.0026188619,
0.0061827158,
-0.0341663063,
-0.0165608209,
-0.002682115,
0.0484355092,
0.0127246222,
-0.0284726564,
0.0290038027,
0.0167570431,
0.0148576377,
-0.0123277232,
0.0203593615,
-0.0176262818,
0.0342676789,
0.0046253693,
0.019577194,
-0.0250179954,
0.0018725132,
0.0455243811,
0.0098193819,
0.0291844923,
-0.0162773971,
-0.009749338,
-0.0459739938,
0.0253955889,
0.0437830538,
0.0183873214,
0.0480374359,
0.0313709565,
0.0171029884,
0.0136098815,
0.0127751268,
0.0216335729,
0.0373363718,
-0.0605197772,
0.0387669802,
0.0150178391,
0.0038286573,
0.0121711995,
0.0380286276,
-0.0294020008,
0.0216030404,
-0.0210788921,
0.0368715823,
0.0428414866,
0.0192925073,
0.0841304809,
0.0032181181,
0.0220663119,
-0.0207693465,
0.0497247092,
-0.0458236001,
0.0287556034,
-0.0187933911,
-0.0270369928,
-0.0030732797,
0.0441951603,
0.048106581,
-0.0349393114,
0.0219919123,
-0.0197703,
0.0102581438,
-0.0375339724,
0.0040135956,
0.0217890162,
-0.0261582732,
-0.0325969718,
-0.0323106088,
0.0118387584,
-0.0415444784,
0.0626109168,
-0.0188855976,
0.0190566964,
0.0065126093,
-0.0038970634,
0.0564058013,
-0.0342231058,
0.0463087782,
-0.003925133,
-0.0435342863,
0.0417655632,
-0.0136662815,
0.003870616,
-6.189992356e-33,
-0.0227106586,
0.0190716032,
0.0165748745,
-0.0545633808,
-0.0465737134,
0.0073454683,
-0.0200243574,
0.0029499796,
0.0163428858,
-0.0294010621,
-0.0086131934,
-0.0062767244,
0.0284440573,
0.013962388,
-0.0122425137,
0.0404718518,
0.057447467,
-0.0218980107,
-0.0423185453,
0.0193616878,
0.0435126498,
0.0210428592,
0.0373699628,
-0.0637002662,
-0.02244954,
0.0110950293,
-0.0329958051,
0.0247154385,
0.0120474342,
0.0074275122,
-0.0085362531,
-0.0045153662,
-0.0148454653,
0.0138465278,
-0.0094494224,
0.0159007218,
-0.0487759598,
0.0104548261,
0.010142778,
0.0342919566,
-0.0302594956,
-0.0479230136,
0.0198991522,
-0.0337771364,
-0.0228403956,
-0.0086636841,
-0.0100688981,
-0.0189009849,
-0.0091160173,
0.0103739994,
-0.0541398637,
0.0330473669,
-0.0289406218,
-0.0356093384,
0.0625086948,
0.0336410515,
0.0127634965,
-0.0685249045,
-0.0400426723,
0.0498260669,
-0.0384806357,
0.0454169512,
0.072871834,
0.0027781387,
-0.0115353419,
0.0335572399,
0.0376923643,
-0.0650389493,
0.0587822869,
0.0104190549,
0.0194714237,
-0.012137386,
-0.0131456833,
0.0527850725,
0.0068991701,
-0.0498917885,
-0.0281920433,
0.0259234589,
0.0090336977,
-0.0281436723,
0.0074478835,
0.0417192951,
-0.0283604208,
0.03675396,
-0.0484273322,
-0.0247870795,
-0.0189948846,
-0.0369178839,
0.004451083,
0.023528235,
-0.0330939256,
-0.0591304898,
0.0983089283,
0.0184943117,
0.0036105709,
-0.0318531096,
-0.0195615161,
-0.0044010971,
-0.0457803123,
0.0266637783,
-0.0405620039,
-0.0725702867,
0.0624850728,
-0.0048442516,
0.0234551653,
-0.0468115807,
-0.0033446972,
0.034853749,
-0.0426436067,
0.0016676508,
-0.0372968093,
0.0050051142,
-0.0162110366,
0.0125501016,
0.0419878624,
-0.0010166194,
-0.0197790563,
0.0034158467,
-0.0059180693,
0.0357600041,
-0.0209801607,
-0.0264377613,
0.0240809526,
0.0396168381,
-0.0672872961,
0.0186163597,
-0.0145062869,
-0.0243802555,
0.0484089628,
-0.032019563,
-0.0394657031,
0.0346538611,
2.88e-7,
-0.006780304,
0.0180317815,
0.0335420929,
-0.029542299,
0.008975938,
0.0359750018,
-0.0530554466,
0.0081703421,
0.0071500884,
-0.0348410644,
0.0323323198,
-0.0310018957,
0.0920081809,
0.0131546743,
-0.0697432235,
-0.0027013274,
-0.0158067513,
0.0100162076,
-0.0021564821,
0.0306507275,
0.0159197338,
0.0830482915,
-0.0366867743,
0.0021021061,
0.0204556044,
-0.0162900873,
0.0526159927,
-0.0206647646,
-0.0193129536,
-0.0288587995,
-0.0149705131,
-0.0218943805,
-0.0591290146,
-0.0180404801,
-0.0105068963,
0.0256279409,
0.0588793121,
0.0385224745,
-0.0201560985,
-0.0716159418,
-0.0169020314,
0.044134289,
-0.0435183644,
0.0389633961,
0.007894177,
0.0125155505,
-0.011253736,
-0.0690960661,
-0.0369755775,
0.0463500246,
0.0082624983,
-0.0079460237,
-0.0120563321,
0.0088056233,
0.0194168203,
0.0124570485,
-0.0114505133,
-0.0350512713,
-0.0166344363,
0.0008133392,
-0.0449896865,
-0.0246164631,
-0.0254801679,
0.022839034,
0.0491613857,
-0.0170634612,
-0.0384689532,
2.462832168e-34,
0.0119735589,
-0.0488098301,
0.0209206305,
-0.0531737842,
0.0188554768,
-0.0358481929,
0.0136686992,
0.001352862,
-0.028958194,
-0.0284016617,
-0.0711560696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16339v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16339v2 | Don't Trust ChatGPT when Your Question is not in English: A Study of Multilingual Abilities and Types of LLMs | 2023-05-24T02:05:03 | 2023-10-24T04:38:52 | Xiang Zhang, Senyu Li, Bradley Hauer, Ning Shi, Grzegorz Kondrak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional natural language
understanding abilities and have excelled in a variety of natural language
processing (NLP)tasks in recent years. Despite the fact that most LLMs are
trained predominantly in English, multiple studies have demonstrated their
comparative performance in many other languages. However, fundamental questions
persist regarding how LLMs acquire their multi-lingual abilities and how
performance varies across different languages. These inquiries are crucial for
the study of LLMs since users and researchers often come from diverse language
backgrounds, potentially influencing their utilization and interpretation of
LLMs' results. In this work, we propose a systematic way of qualifying the
performance disparities of LLMs under multilingual settings. We investigate the
phenomenon of across-language generalizations in LLMs, wherein insufficient
multi-lingual training data leads to advanced multi-lingual capabilities. To
accomplish this, we employ a novel back-translation-based prompting method. The
results show that GPT exhibits highly translating-like behaviour in
multilingual settings. | [
0.0420696959,
0.0250414405,
-0.013885593,
0.0707094967,
-0.0484482273,
0.0418414921,
0.0201152395,
-0.0185282044,
0.041637592,
-0.0321627781,
-0.0603325889,
-0.0559863374,
0.0048725549,
-0.0102743255,
0.0275918432,
-0.0294833574,
0.0653106719,
-0.0334632546,
-0.020616712,
-0.0155966906,
-0.0143891219,
0.0136058172,
-0.0003063476,
0.0393502116,
0.0298835728,
-0.0139150191,
0.0179197993,
-0.0285513699,
0.0037928666,
-0.0192877427,
-0.0201918427,
0.0256881844,
0.0204947926,
0.0697924867,
0.0000019353,
-0.0600017719,
-0.0007506224,
-0.0022996939,
-0.0063903076,
-0.0095055997,
0.0360946357,
-0.0356855989,
-0.0018832966,
0.0085043898,
-0.0578632243,
-0.0244514309,
0.0327284709,
0.0312159602,
0.0326739997,
0.0732103065,
0.0014145097,
-0.0281442329,
0.0119390534,
-0.0223592669,
0.0380298346,
-0.0589636937,
-0.0044578672,
0.0094380388,
-0.0057539274,
0.011610277,
-0.0104681756,
0.0518318936,
0.0313127227,
0.0191502217,
-0.051339183,
0.0313417837,
-0.0514285415,
-0.0448913649,
-0.0253888946,
0.0452055633,
0.0033720306,
0.0062169195,
-0.0268924404,
0.0165677797,
-0.0175179504,
-0.0013006016,
-0.0538505018,
0.028782079,
-0.0214214493,
0.0080349902,
0.0314831957,
0.012902556,
0.0365594849,
0.0072193295,
-0.0249841344,
0.0757408142,
0.0162294284,
-0.0338542834,
0.0313608684,
0.0513822287,
-0.0270153861,
-0.0310928207,
0.0047079832,
0.0055465046,
-0.0423035882,
0.0321764313,
0.0352133214,
0.0051405909,
0.0368550159,
-0.0558808558,
-0.018889267,
0.0475264639,
-0.0551162697,
0.0587015264,
-0.0340538733,
0.0918878689,
-0.0331043117,
0.0302440189,
-0.0368185006,
-0.0397445858,
-0.077103138,
-0.0214007683,
0.0055294824,
0.0016883133,
-0.0293558985,
-0.0110816518,
-0.0618411191,
0.0076518147,
0.0195557345,
0.0079726558,
0.0175275169,
-0.0208671838,
-0.0478615761,
-0.0014740149,
-0.0492568985,
0.045155216,
-0.0281172488,
-0.0048730955,
-0.0166430287,
-0.0726165846,
-0.0063793515,
0.0200959481,
-0.0414829887,
-0.0297780484,
-0.0024819532,
0.0915369987,
-0.0041179638,
-0.0201956332,
-0.0400694683,
0.0159043539,
-0.0089100571,
-0.0983094275,
0.0333511345,
-0.0464643873,
0.0531135388,
0.0333175994,
0.0238695163,
0.0075505534,
0.0067286678,
0.0032233021,
-0.0144345015,
0.0820928887,
0.0197222158,
0.0036754266,
0.0275519285,
-0.0021852241,
-0.0381112769,
0.0923808739,
-0.0084671983,
-0.022222802,
0.053638611,
-0.0095184539,
-0.0191281531,
0.0650599822,
-0.031766206,
-0.0049905144,
-0.0035331531,
0.0234280061,
0.0214426294,
0.0149061447,
0.023208458,
0.0312570296,
-0.0207833797,
0.006911533,
0.0286463518,
0.0840377584,
0.0044330927,
0.0536156558,
0.0527364165,
-0.002457682,
-0.0081596579,
0.0480876863,
-0.0553932749,
-0.0022342037,
-0.0240478702,
0.0016193124,
-0.0120305317,
0.0529998131,
-0.0191884693,
-0.0324535221,
-0.0169442724,
0.0060947458,
0.0281837005,
-0.0050186324,
0.0497228578,
0.0092636868,
-0.0116532557,
0.0179239605,
0.0197916925,
-0.0281766597,
-0.0045740264,
-0.0661271065,
-0.0129255634,
0.039926067,
0.004417276,
-0.0010349203,
-0.0143609261,
-0.0261054654,
0.0032899322,
0.0615385175,
0.0596030802,
0.0049148207,
0.0288849678,
-0.0369951688,
-0.0146037051,
-0.0149267055,
0.0038685198,
0.0455062389,
0.0057331189,
0.0320965499,
0.0089591909,
-0.0455119871,
-0.037465319,
0.0274963398,
-0.0579905733,
-0.0324256308,
0.0131119797,
-0.0136103304,
0.0165927634,
0.0131904306,
0.0026185408,
-0.0076121376,
0.004593384,
-0.0349185653,
-0.0163466856,
0.0534688309,
-0.0301675219,
-0.0696129128,
0.0333162993,
-0.0405448154,
-0.0417649746,
-0.0004586906,
-0.0454411022,
-0.0477316789,
0.0054783979,
-0.0112679424,
0.0396555625,
-0.0481803082,
0.0075989263,
-0.0106548499,
-0.0003397361,
-0.0149482265,
0.0723366439,
0.0081459014,
0.0458232537,
0.0202278327,
-0.0174978916,
0.0392417796,
-0.0250280891,
-0.0304637495,
0.0811043084,
0.002511614,
0.0032460315,
0.034170907,
0.0453605764,
-0.0703144744,
-0.0096664382,
-0.0971018076,
0.0402726866,
-0.0295440704,
0.0450168401,
0.0400658995,
0.0083338944,
-0.0304137524,
-0.0264366735,
-0.054473564,
-0.0287182108,
0.0496275201,
0.0389980525,
0.0420095623,
-0.0034142013,
0.0223732311,
-0.0274933763,
0.0082124174,
-0.011105475,
0.030700149,
0.0240277797,
-0.03575873,
-0.0504804738,
0.0199132767,
-0.0480046198,
0.0045375456,
-0.0314987935,
-0.0430038832,
0.028792074,
0.0063559799,
0.0389626361,
0.0493668467,
-0.01999126,
-0.0187614486,
0.0415962599,
0.0064877491,
-0.0585318729,
0.0207225811,
-0.0151478415,
-0.0605293401,
-0.0354264863,
-0.0413811617,
0.0145391682,
0.0653267056,
0.0117743546,
-0.0035549002,
-0.0405712985,
-0.0059619755,
-0.0491105877,
-0.0213398058,
-0.0450895429,
0.0408624783,
0.003892157,
0.0581205562,
-0.0217667967,
-0.0549220741,
0.0679223835,
-0.0237320922,
-0.0360272899,
-0.0842983723,
-0.0155604398,
-0.0543506593,
0.0636483207,
-0.0056044874,
0.0211936738,
-0.0063465475,
-0.0534640774,
-0.0469706953,
0.0058004139,
0.0198429935,
-0.0192632508,
0.0314535871,
-0.0329886079,
-0.0112572229,
-0.0102765188,
-0.0253551826,
-0.0367205404,
-0.0261263959,
-0.0173706301,
0.013108504,
0.0205822941,
-0.011200821,
-0.031095,
0.0050798426,
0.0540063158,
0.0271681361,
-0.0274764076,
-0.00356628,
-0.0260555334,
-0.0112250568,
0.0068167415,
0.0054984228,
0.0213811137,
-0.0473163016,
0.0427125506,
0.0318127349,
0.008903902,
-0.0115622478,
-0.0103568519,
0.0104454719,
0.018791372,
-0.0322206914,
-0.0604508594,
-0.0155501654,
0.0743647218,
-0.0537938438,
0.0054422673,
0.1242432818,
0.0304236803,
-0.0634030029,
-0.0212001055,
-0.0478483811,
0.0264603067,
0.0594028234,
0.0156478472,
-0.0822251439,
-0.0250837114,
-0.0140234586,
-0.0080247726,
-0.0035816473,
-0.0062075094,
-0.0453620479,
-0.120651491,
0.0222951584,
-0.0023375431,
-0.0660406947,
-0.0027465916,
-0.0409435928,
-0.0106847705,
-0.0226515662,
0.0529632308,
-0.0282649491,
-0.0131821968,
0.0064510088,
0.0338805877,
-0.0288269687,
-0.0618615709,
0.0145549579,
-0.0456031859,
0.0193526503,
0.0679543614,
0.0309892893,
-0.011568469,
-0.0208930951,
0.0342577621,
0.0161162131,
0.0190749839,
-0.018815523,
0.0179539789,
0.0132745914,
-0.0042978358,
-0.0189781394,
-0.0122260535,
-0.0379806086,
0.0281966757,
0.0460261032,
0.0854431391,
-0.0130753657,
-0.0081606396,
0.0152350487,
0.0120064365,
-0.0020447816,
0.0731083453,
0.0214141011,
-0.0173074584,
-0.0348948836,
-0.0433973968,
-0.0142583773,
0.0057754442,
-0.052343592,
0.0550088584,
-0.0198219195,
-0.0302194655,
-0.0435697399,
-0.0615469888,
0.0393147022,
-0.0017859446,
0.0112858601,
0.01889183,
-0.0281979181,
-0.0025478324,
0.0265768245,
0.0565088354,
-0.0183516908,
-0.004451328,
-0.037276037,
0.0045323288,
0.0624999031,
-0.0205124635,
-0.019073952,
0.0210037716,
-0.0578414239,
-0.0726528689,
-0.0440615788,
0.0348820649,
0.031323418,
0.0491736531,
-0.0071833562,
-0.0086452737,
-0.0117956931,
0.019076487,
-0.0169982854,
-0.0152636934,
0.0410342216,
0.0473728552,
0.0007570906,
0.0430122428,
0.004728294,
0.0045573143,
-0.005451832,
0.0503216311,
-0.02179664,
-0.0155869946,
0.0341372043,
0.0402638651,
0.0523880534,
-0.0305896159,
-0.0104205692,
-0.027423637,
-0.0092336284,
-0.0115609011,
-0.0166942887,
-0.0276795235,
-0.0024671035,
0.0446311235,
-0.0160830598,
-0.0015359815,
-0.0127061456,
-0.0521604195,
0.0007410686,
-0.0448600501,
0.0256236065,
0.017382279,
-0.0086841332,
0.0153419273,
0.021853691,
-0.0122050783,
0.0190696102,
0.0153903263,
0.0400691889,
-0.0192692932,
0.0712560788,
-0.0023141271,
0.0132987285,
0.0204295013,
-0.0010985482,
-0.0613587983,
-0.088028565,
0.0374752618,
0.0580167547,
0.0761967748,
-0.0263965055,
0.0691664815,
-0.0035850753,
-0.0028506124,
-0.0066435058,
0.0307797566,
0.0089595132,
-0.0266216025,
0.0388192609,
-0.0176463593,
-0.0384726413,
-0.0203071237,
0.07696601,
-0.0226858258,
0.0099665811,
-0.0122754993,
-0.016178932,
-0.03020145,
-0.0394262634,
0.0203222726,
-0.0093258051,
-0.0125192273,
0.0309238285,
-0.0412313007,
-0.0808746815,
-0.0398750603,
-0.0054242886,
0.0069258511,
-0.0413874984,
0.0107707847,
0.1177242696,
-0.0189890526,
-0.0274776202,
-0.0411655791,
-0.0218550321,
-0.000285583,
-0.0139174704,
-0.0242938437,
-6.392573379e-33,
-0.0212523583,
-0.0097066546,
0.0341064483,
-0.0174969342,
0.0082359631,
0.0013762562,
-0.0247010011,
0.005992285,
-0.0207155216,
0.0022603939,
-0.0315134116,
0.0054759481,
0.0268531684,
-0.0142530873,
0.0229167845,
-0.0285583306,
0.0258369483,
-0.0007250929,
-0.0229631998,
0.0125758788,
0.0198686942,
0.0340967216,
0.1197901443,
-0.0386702791,
0.0884940028,
-0.0113652544,
0.0126672667,
0.031249566,
-0.0049901684,
0.0589182302,
-0.0434427783,
0.0429567024,
0.0546552055,
-0.065628238,
-0.0141103035,
0.0071977759,
-0.0464049689,
-0.0458917245,
0.0726148635,
0.0164384171,
-0.0177303422,
-0.0164402612,
0.0296867713,
-0.0411669575,
-0.0168895368,
0.0038892927,
0.035170909,
-0.0127221709,
0.0021678412,
0.01745365,
-0.0501240604,
0.0278993789,
-0.012834291,
0.0142835695,
0.0080562532,
0.067260012,
-0.04078288,
0.011568347,
-0.0381489731,
0.0117844595,
0.0032495738,
0.0099007273,
0.0726663098,
-0.0037797163,
-0.0016304947,
0.0587314069,
0.016518537,
0.0090634814,
-0.0090353582,
-0.0375689194,
0.0201602113,
0.0221997444,
0.0248352084,
0.0463067442,
0.0253869575,
0.0022703195,
-0.0896549374,
0.0255390331,
0.0481834523,
0.024394691,
0.0102198962,
-0.0073718922,
-0.022176262,
-0.017742129,
-0.0385036506,
-0.0086204428,
-0.0127744991,
-0.0483797714,
0.027726857,
-0.0278058834,
0.0005290301,
-0.0211883467,
0.0572529547,
-0.030231487,
-0.0161537379,
-0.0062677711,
-0.0185154453,
-0.0071963547,
0.0094526066,
0.0887557343,
-0.0588622615,
-0.0266797729,
-0.0457298011,
0.0042746458,
0.0136068342,
-0.0062803519,
0.0288766325,
-0.0064323889,
-0.064629145,
-0.0041599097,
-0.0588916503,
0.0357397273,
-0.0254150592,
0.0423292033,
0.0453906171,
-0.0137394741,
-0.0189707782,
0.0622566231,
0.019241143,
-0.008918779,
-0.0454390012,
-0.00486136,
-0.016672207,
0.0477095433,
-0.0510079674,
-0.0079702353,
-0.0119783022,
0.0093908962,
0.0477157235,
-0.048996713,
-0.0184593573,
0.0008013339,
2.736e-7,
0.0605647936,
0.0452528857,
-0.0215285569,
0.0404007025,
0.0162352417,
0.0241874363,
-0.0615958087,
0.0140017867,
0.0235044546,
-0.0183219165,
-0.0188976564,
0.0437298119,
0.0546527319,
0.0440045223,
-0.0893294737,
-0.0265608728,
-0.0503071398,
0.0039237277,
-0.0610337444,
0.0335652418,
0.0339085571,
0.0758810863,
-0.0253572725,
0.0033185028,
-0.0358318128,
-0.0770764798,
0.0736586303,
-0.047457844,
-0.0365154929,
0.0173246879,
0.0550843142,
0.062951684,
0.022134589,
0.0305725168,
0.0026331977,
0.0190557595,
0.0185125284,
0.0724989399,
0.0148066059,
0.0005695631,
0.0186650623,
-0.0061212829,
-0.0078394767,
-0.0679299384,
0.0667892024,
-0.0560220629,
-0.0395762399,
-0.036014542,
0.0336590856,
-0.036439307,
0.0685133636,
-0.0277652908,
-0.0366161764,
0.0378807224,
0.0317906141,
-0.0272547659,
-0.0173283238,
-0.0343769006,
-0.0068877647,
-0.0055959416,
-0.032049261,
-0.0398654602,
-0.0122893313,
0.0142696239,
0.012328078,
-0.0286373887,
0.009799025,
2.315658668e-34,
0.0458066277,
0.011687018,
0.0293706693,
0.026793886,
0.0666092485,
-0.0112040816,
0.0081236232,
-0.004861888,
-0.0128289415,
-0.0276096053,
-0.0087714652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14630v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14630v1 | Testing Causal Models of Word Meaning in GPT-3 and -4 | 2023-05-24T02:03:23 | 2023-05-24T02:03:23 | Sam Musker, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Large Language Models (LLMs) have driven extraordinary improvements in NLP.
However, it is unclear how such models represent lexical concepts-i.e., the
meanings of the words they use. This paper evaluates the lexical
representations of GPT-3 and GPT-4 through the lens of HIPE theory, a theory of
concept representations which focuses on representations of words describing
artifacts (such as "mop", "pencil", and "whistle"). The theory posits a causal
graph that relates the meanings of such words to the form, use, and history of
the objects to which they refer. We test LLMs using the same stimuli originally
used by Chaigneau et al. (2004) to evaluate the theory in humans, and consider
a variety of prompt designs. Our experiments concern judgements about causal
outcomes, object function, and object naming. We find no evidence that GPT-3
encodes the causal structure hypothesized by HIPE, but do find evidence that
GPT-4 encodes such structure. The results contribute to a growing body of
research characterizing the representational capacity of large language models. | [
0.0475124083,
0.0274329204,
-0.0483022258,
0.0198751278,
-0.0609103702,
0.0058837924,
-0.009434225,
0.0401916392,
-0.0013648187,
-0.065703705,
-0.0058867009,
-0.0324771777,
-0.0152803827,
0.0260821898,
0.040873792,
-0.0594420992,
0.0382693149,
-0.0160634238,
0.0136137251,
0.0034694741,
-0.0302680284,
-0.0066948449,
-0.0176712256,
0.0567401014,
-0.0347694308,
0.0010526446,
0.0134005342,
-0.0243671387,
-0.0652923286,
-0.0575865805,
-0.0345511958,
0.0541976839,
0.0398224182,
0.0480609722,
0.0000021308,
-0.0706694871,
0.0209155437,
-0.0170422159,
-0.0225248113,
0.0052197301,
0.033722572,
-0.0170163158,
0.0034635752,
-0.0471882746,
0.0141963568,
-0.0137109328,
0.0713589117,
0.0603666417,
-0.0144116832,
0.0199808404,
-0.0201060791,
-0.0579606071,
0.0505045019,
-0.024851853,
0.0729346871,
-0.0085127084,
0.0308658611,
0.0238739066,
0.0219268482,
-0.0121629583,
-0.0473152846,
-0.0147742378,
0.0162336063,
0.0651674494,
0.0193060935,
0.0341750756,
0.0166259427,
-0.0260318685,
0.0284203775,
0.0402055271,
0.0473651364,
-0.0255175624,
-0.0249708761,
-0.0138690118,
0.0051785461,
0.0739520937,
-0.042851381,
0.0302434005,
0.0137442462,
-0.0042302385,
0.024011815,
-0.0237050466,
0.0233623348,
0.0390505418,
-0.0066264747,
0.0774421617,
0.0311808866,
-0.0501224399,
0.0171347577,
0.0137806265,
-0.0163165666,
-0.027050199,
-0.0215921029,
0.0009173169,
-0.0052772951,
0.0412259437,
0.0250665955,
0.0514730737,
0.0212534294,
-0.0665979609,
0.0323134884,
0.0372407921,
-0.0073694079,
0.0342740491,
-0.0470289886,
0.0802929252,
-0.0475439541,
0.0254901033,
-0.0274980124,
0.0375365578,
-0.0738654211,
-0.0528042689,
-0.0202280078,
0.0173076764,
-0.0247484799,
-0.0379077271,
-0.0071290755,
0.0086390628,
-0.0156577043,
-0.0486767888,
-0.0272531118,
0.0096167596,
-0.0150169097,
0.0045956303,
-0.0877087191,
0.0219642259,
-0.0537967607,
0.052445069,
-0.0446704403,
-0.0619432181,
-0.0016186089,
-0.0270267762,
0.0155393928,
-0.0432836153,
-0.0147173647,
0.0776701346,
0.0311699994,
-0.0515125915,
-0.0190748163,
-0.0408193991,
-0.0050849952,
-0.0188837983,
0.0068492219,
-0.043840453,
-0.0359270349,
0.0340538435,
0.02703958,
-0.0402518511,
-0.0044785906,
-0.0115854656,
-0.0775430351,
0.0388408937,
0.0169578809,
0.037314374,
-0.011171083,
0.0102863843,
-0.0309524201,
0.0371456668,
0.015839329,
0.0133241042,
-0.0212625358,
-0.0360468924,
-0.0138315437,
0.0004376047,
-0.0189766195,
-0.0087716561,
-0.0435544588,
-0.0478340387,
0.0220243186,
0.0531853773,
0.0222519059,
0.0341089815,
-0.0322746672,
0.0055308412,
0.0696212649,
0.064537324,
-0.0009082186,
-0.0014275202,
0.0461169966,
-0.0386494696,
0.0112441452,
0.0295632761,
-0.0628302693,
-0.0157945734,
-0.0204966478,
-0.0111889839,
-0.0219391212,
-0.0353739262,
-0.014720262,
0.0380415656,
-0.0286194086,
0.0416440032,
-0.0004349786,
-0.0396194234,
0.0249646194,
0.0074480912,
-0.0317372754,
0.0085046813,
0.0296492465,
-0.0245326683,
0.0082746958,
-0.0531919822,
0.0241602007,
0.0691368878,
0.0408628099,
0.0121527947,
-0.0092031527,
-0.0131740682,
-0.0308677834,
0.0499170311,
0.0337504111,
0.009370829,
-0.0442911536,
0.0196411442,
-0.0104778223,
-0.0325210392,
0.0127409324,
0.044291351,
-0.0076052113,
-0.0254066903,
0.0078621479,
-0.0141366534,
0.018852694,
0.0363781378,
0.0169258714,
-0.0257033315,
-0.0722955838,
0.0147787761,
0.0346955694,
0.0164800677,
-0.0248726662,
0.0383763127,
0.0006877534,
-0.0106476499,
-0.0001961117,
0.0039714216,
-0.0571876988,
0.0316471048,
-0.0054372544,
-0.0268909801,
0.0169004779,
0.0169854332,
0.0425052382,
-0.054083854,
0.0362919345,
-0.0541547723,
0.0930036828,
-0.0337639377,
0.0024999676,
-0.0327014551,
-0.0047113523,
-0.0311413687,
0.0916459411,
0.0282863509,
0.0350019857,
-0.0359266885,
0.0441100299,
0.0169138517,
-0.0226380266,
-0.0222757291,
0.0343445353,
0.0315088071,
-0.0047187037,
0.0595057011,
-0.0379909761,
-0.0566748567,
-0.0146688949,
-0.0593874678,
-0.0142912371,
0.0255700797,
-0.0207561478,
0.0245993454,
-0.0306831375,
-0.0090439562,
0.0081524467,
-0.0037005255,
0.0019732763,
-0.0061792489,
0.0914224088,
-0.0016214559,
-0.0433910117,
-0.0329629146,
-0.0038199115,
-0.0214389786,
-0.0664278343,
0.0317287147,
0.0312796943,
-0.0368054882,
-0.0055634417,
0.0493836217,
-0.0159077477,
-0.0067513725,
0.0204328559,
-0.0103865592,
0.0511699729,
-0.0095878672,
0.0744659975,
0.0219025407,
0.002245144,
0.0761185586,
0.0401966609,
-0.0500715524,
-0.0322942957,
-0.0437211171,
-0.0418131538,
-0.0142490445,
-0.0032715953,
-0.0336475074,
-0.0320949443,
0.0567070767,
0.0508246534,
0.010215939,
-0.0675308928,
0.0333140418,
-0.0302962605,
-0.0276097488,
-0.0463913605,
-0.0609504543,
-0.0593901128,
0.0361374244,
-0.0280294493,
-0.0481881872,
0.0275054164,
-0.0016169683,
0.0007944746,
0.0073830518,
0.035556484,
-0.0034796353,
0.1029878408,
0.0480142012,
0.0168282222,
0.0197307095,
-0.0645997599,
-0.0494758785,
-0.004951153,
0.0232301541,
-0.015495576,
0.0132560693,
-0.0485229343,
0.0104406578,
0.0161279012,
-0.0021086596,
-0.0226807818,
-0.0087410072,
-0.0314558744,
0.0335036404,
-0.0101037035,
0.0339752287,
0.017642986,
0.0345744789,
0.0252715889,
-0.0008315338,
-0.002985775,
-0.0019449145,
-0.0229922738,
-0.015310715,
0.0081984447,
-0.0300466195,
0.0300682671,
-0.0049969563,
-0.0109872352,
-0.0090581933,
-0.0055953236,
0.0107119903,
-0.0303547531,
0.0681578666,
0.0222104713,
-0.0403419994,
-0.0647592247,
0.0075941361,
0.0176267643,
-0.0386132784,
0.0181184597,
0.0952557251,
0.0299799349,
-0.060467761,
0.0335362405,
0.0168483872,
-0.0115361484,
0.0362208039,
-0.0336918719,
-0.0712047517,
-0.0175666735,
0.0091644702,
-0.0611498505,
-0.0488199703,
-0.0462188236,
0.0021235484,
-0.1145105213,
0.0061820336,
-0.0230414644,
-0.0386698917,
0.0174867976,
-0.0369585343,
0.0270250179,
0.016715657,
-0.01030083,
0.0145659558,
-0.0269291941,
0.0163623318,
-0.0023706132,
0.012089734,
-0.0192469191,
0.0153548848,
0.0124349594,
0.0275627654,
0.0418066569,
0.0191814415,
-0.0637751222,
-0.0507763997,
0.0489475466,
-0.016863618,
0.0292313918,
-0.0151206125,
-0.0018374565,
0.0161147509,
0.0040240139,
-0.0295659434,
-0.0021174501,
-0.0020385145,
-0.0479161441,
-0.0271048266,
0.0802121162,
-0.0201032739,
-0.0185280144,
0.001017483,
-0.0147987921,
-0.0376866125,
0.0736633465,
0.0487494506,
-0.0251100585,
-0.0066688685,
0.0144973919,
0.0254397206,
0.0822172388,
-0.0553645045,
-0.0352494046,
-0.0019647446,
-0.0226417668,
-0.0402254649,
-0.0380077995,
0.0210572015,
0.0001094032,
0.0479281098,
0.0232794676,
-0.0518691503,
-0.0140692461,
-0.0129110795,
0.0593852699,
0.0062182262,
0.0052018417,
-0.0510442443,
-0.0512362197,
0.0109726293,
-0.0329972543,
-0.0148638515,
0.0234528631,
0.0046245931,
-0.0390282124,
0.0464672111,
-0.0151041755,
0.0317399651,
-0.0184471533,
0.0043888534,
-0.0472307131,
-0.0031424249,
-0.0186830908,
-0.0181364492,
0.025566332,
-0.0214866679,
0.0248669349,
0.0038405003,
0.0260913018,
-0.0083343536,
0.0690232813,
0.0113332067,
0.0348069295,
0.0289796852,
-0.0036656777,
0.0539367087,
0.0230573583,
0.0824483633,
-0.0103383735,
0.023561405,
-0.0329496004,
-0.0508093126,
-0.0158516038,
-0.0081900451,
-0.0229580887,
0.0069988328,
0.0549575016,
0.0310638975,
-0.0465478115,
-0.0903126672,
-0.0189099927,
0.0400204621,
-0.0013732518,
-0.0107869124,
0.0117449975,
-0.0115279919,
-0.003221256,
0.0413548574,
-0.0007035297,
0.0191201884,
-0.0475134291,
0.0206686966,
-0.0210129451,
0.0906615853,
0.027760176,
-0.0055513899,
-0.0080408147,
-0.0174739901,
-0.070048444,
-0.0544582233,
0.0426496789,
0.0109899733,
0.0373578183,
-0.0519643612,
0.0194245875,
-0.0686539114,
0.0029342808,
-0.0088687129,
0.0037106541,
0.0258544162,
-0.0091630081,
0.0320913903,
0.0352337137,
-0.0007918174,
-0.0468328521,
0.0191484001,
-0.0127155464,
0.0528530367,
-0.005274917,
-0.0377496406,
0.0016824019,
-0.0208108295,
0.0181852952,
0.020403143,
0.0046851155,
0.0386510752,
-0.1048310921,
-0.0213549845,
-0.0335985087,
-0.0134641733,
0.0467071868,
-0.0288022291,
0.0511037186,
0.0465409234,
-0.0118651446,
-0.0306691993,
-0.0038038583,
0.0111125484,
-0.0327397883,
0.0200253241,
-0.017360298,
-6.31364628e-33,
-0.0317554474,
-0.0048093344,
0.005669706,
0.0188490711,
-0.0479256697,
0.0028880257,
-0.0334670767,
0.0344379097,
-0.0071528144,
0.0237549208,
-0.0025489402,
-0.0064310599,
0.0116515122,
-0.0287465807,
0.0415645503,
-0.0116904089,
0.0283309817,
0.0245834589,
-0.0340180025,
0.0109459674,
0.0605077036,
-0.0122914743,
0.073246032,
-0.0092584938,
0.0575614497,
0.0284740198,
0.0180906784,
-0.021225227,
-0.0271475501,
0.0402909778,
-0.0429603159,
0.065769963,
0.0740709081,
-0.0526275933,
0.0076684547,
0.0416756235,
0.0010355893,
-0.0635657236,
0.0983811766,
-0.0004524776,
0.0013872852,
-0.0540821627,
0.0389819145,
-0.0453300737,
-0.0696195588,
0.0449613556,
0.0305216927,
0.0050505381,
-0.0245898552,
0.0387314782,
-0.0762886032,
-0.0108157657,
0.009976021,
-0.0056578415,
0.0297941994,
-0.027915936,
-0.0268209483,
-0.0032535831,
0.0220329892,
0.0330894031,
-0.0120831402,
0.0187022574,
-0.0125111509,
0.057660453,
0.0236946605,
0.0732348189,
0.024301298,
0.0313769355,
-0.026136227,
-0.0090497853,
0.0299848281,
0.0298868101,
0.0189504251,
0.0096228505,
0.0540173389,
-0.0341207571,
0.0124033689,
-0.032994844,
0.0118162083,
0.0511556752,
0.0448821299,
-0.0128259528,
-0.0241499357,
-0.029058665,
-0.0713345036,
-0.0291005019,
-0.0448692627,
-0.0331961736,
0.0514834784,
-0.0372605324,
0.0298873074,
0.0242357589,
0.035453856,
-0.0322012529,
-0.0215637293,
0.0105747823,
-0.0456492826,
0.0246958099,
0.000427584,
0.0095409816,
-0.0477648675,
-0.0320704468,
-0.0048360005,
0.0384573638,
0.0032979955,
0.0133489538,
-0.0188399181,
-0.0168242957,
-0.0287874136,
-0.0094216214,
-0.062913999,
-0.0840557888,
0.0095283156,
-0.0906777978,
0.0761311576,
0.0240453705,
-0.0113266213,
-0.0156879462,
0.0242461432,
-0.0181658845,
-0.0260738507,
-0.0371700525,
-0.0592529289,
0.019093316,
-0.0092058675,
-0.013448433,
-0.0159096867,
0.0406367742,
0.0753282681,
-0.0143060768,
-0.0197667852,
-0.0201257002,
2.988e-7,
0.0644893497,
0.0616572462,
-0.0002621553,
0.05542567,
0.0292449445,
-0.0093279434,
-0.0185468793,
0.0166290961,
0.0226249211,
-0.0100885034,
-0.0138401026,
0.0222436227,
-0.011121084,
-0.0152892424,
-0.0519151464,
0.0336979218,
-0.0092375996,
0.0395403244,
-0.0477332734,
0.0580482036,
0.0744438618,
0.0376305208,
0.0226550791,
-0.0178498421,
-0.0573082753,
0.0053163329,
0.0662724003,
-0.0693997815,
0.0160807539,
-0.0353832133,
-0.0145629244,
0.0024986996,
0.028321784,
0.0718490928,
0.0427248068,
0.0080426773,
0.028092796,
0.0009954319,
-0.0095349709,
0.0062291427,
-0.0286394134,
-0.0467274413,
0.0118273078,
-0.0572904088,
0.0609096289,
-0.0165420417,
-0.0445803963,
0.0378225595,
-0.0426716171,
0.0051114406,
0.0328924283,
-0.0069346861,
-0.0340296514,
-0.0184874441,
-0.0082504079,
0.0127445841,
-0.0090247802,
-0.0279292427,
0.0093049845,
0.0379611626,
0.0043990859,
-0.0689131841,
-0.0342557952,
-0.020456152,
0.0055455444,
-0.0729714558,
-0.0333532356,
2.413875813e-34,
0.0002802045,
0.0061395508,
0.0672377646,
-0.0207063742,
0.0283066202,
-0.0092637381,
0.0678512156,
0.0349920094,
0.0252932049,
-0.0713649988,
0.0033176956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14628v2 | Getting MoRE out of Mixture of Language Model Reasoning Experts | 2023-05-24T02:00:51 | 2023-10-20T05:16:29 | Chenglei Si, Weijia Shi, Chen Zhao, Luke Zettlemoyer, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While recent large language models (LLMs) improve on various question
answering (QA) datasets, it remains difficult for a single model to generalize
across question types that require distinct reasoning abilities. We provide
empirical evidence that state-of-the-art LLMs suffer from poor generalizability
on reasoning types beyond those seen in the prompt. To remedy this, we propose
a Mixture-of-Reasoning-Experts (MoRE) framework that ensembles diverse
specialized language models. We specialize the backbone language model with
prompts optimized for different reasoning categories, including factual,
multihop, mathematical, and commonsense reasoning. Our key insight is to
leverage agreement among the specialized experts to select the best answer for
each question, or to abstain from answering. This gives MoRE higher accuracy
than any single specialized model on a collection of 12 QA datasets from four
reasoning types. Beyond generalizability, the interpretable design of MoRE
improves selective question answering results compared to baselines without
incorporating inter-expert agreement. This framework is also more interpretable
and useful to human consumers of QA outputs. Our human study confirms that
presenting expert predictions and the answer selection process helps annotators
more accurately calibrate when to trust the system's output. We release all
code and data to facilitate future work. | [
0.0803347155,
0.0397901237,
0.0085431002,
0.0250704605,
-0.008579459,
0.0035414908,
0.0313554406,
-0.0095586432,
-0.0023783252,
-0.0388141088,
-0.03488959,
0.0066425796,
-0.017136272,
-0.0031450684,
0.0225178301,
-0.0395674743,
0.0316852927,
-0.0537106171,
0.0510973744,
-0.0481106676,
0.0096638836,
0.0327164456,
-0.0158784539,
0.0468309298,
0.0081022251,
-0.0342444815,
0.0145753548,
-0.0166651085,
0.01137444,
0.0366981849,
0.0328235067,
0.0943535119,
0.0241287667,
0.0296697207,
0.0000019372,
-0.0281208307,
0.0068291896,
-0.014643739,
-0.0623482913,
-0.0135473674,
-0.0502814576,
0.0632844493,
0.0538788587,
0.022271866,
-0.0482954569,
0.0385640375,
0.0243716743,
0.0048685507,
0.0771269053,
0.0306609403,
0.0270028599,
0.00282353,
0.0024008523,
0.0060552796,
0.018696649,
-0.0339013711,
0.0101069631,
0.0676525682,
0.0241929963,
0.0226148646,
0.0027534699,
0.031585522,
0.0261942483,
0.0015503926,
0.0237086192,
0.0238852277,
-0.0034633221,
-0.0166047104,
-0.0181415528,
0.0954708606,
-0.0013016971,
-0.0220305715,
-0.0311207529,
0.0069479691,
0.018588122,
0.010538524,
-0.0379272699,
0.0271298215,
-0.0158889759,
-0.0197115932,
-0.0117186699,
0.0256285947,
0.006590052,
0.0407585613,
-0.0285130236,
0.1016322523,
-0.0023571951,
-0.0062673623,
0.0141837588,
0.0245925542,
-0.0339560509,
-0.0606829226,
-0.0023400402,
0.0428333655,
-0.0626210421,
0.0262252577,
0.0047320402,
-0.0070855431,
0.0361040346,
0.0014662893,
0.0058303741,
0.0285104215,
-0.0060152034,
0.0869284347,
0.0068633081,
0.0179053582,
-0.01106322,
0.0392462239,
-0.0396402068,
-0.0509173274,
-0.0601071194,
-0.0307871383,
0.0026739403,
0.0453675352,
-0.0129961995,
0.0065533384,
-0.0274245031,
-0.0007944198,
-0.0290819015,
0.0175351128,
0.038362693,
0.0543870889,
-0.0225485433,
-0.0445757173,
-0.0600798614,
0.0500229299,
-0.085402742,
0.0436807312,
0.0379328839,
-0.070598565,
-0.0039137504,
0.0240625795,
-0.0190191176,
-0.0350103751,
0.0171252172,
0.0141443573,
-0.034406174,
0.0019498469,
0.0112889633,
-0.0374952219,
0.0098716449,
-0.0596824549,
-0.0237250179,
-0.0914688259,
0.0709627569,
0.0147813875,
-0.0051836623,
-0.0498148091,
-0.0027087813,
0.0146468999,
-0.0153907416,
0.0598212481,
-0.048615206,
0.0162856039,
0.0383647308,
0.0233004652,
-0.0683677495,
0.071053572,
0.0002612342,
-0.0037733559,
0.0462467931,
0.0104803573,
0.0336975306,
-0.0003312372,
-0.0045518861,
-0.0065717548,
0.0213206653,
0.0874980986,
-0.0158003289,
-0.0021032989,
0.0231209546,
0.0497809239,
-0.0072723022,
-0.0540918559,
0.031441886,
0.0607897043,
-0.0246475432,
0.0424354896,
0.0167603996,
0.0242318604,
0.0577745512,
0.0093294485,
-0.0254083183,
0.0420518555,
-0.0615078956,
-0.0173949134,
0.0125769107,
0.0335050672,
-0.0473850444,
-0.0312682651,
-0.0072759786,
-0.0011169369,
-0.0170246791,
0.0663093999,
0.0063927877,
-0.0279089101,
0.0069270642,
0.0564147122,
0.014641217,
-0.0496117286,
0.0008776556,
-0.0510296002,
0.074328281,
0.0510720126,
0.0138648329,
-0.0356617942,
-0.0464414246,
-0.0242571067,
0.0082396921,
0.0042981301,
0.017587075,
-0.0201734323,
0.0216572601,
-0.0531276464,
-0.0254414845,
-0.0203501191,
-0.0074046697,
0.0225184001,
0.043489337,
-0.0019439922,
0.001278106,
-0.0543120578,
0.0153081184,
0.0088151442,
-0.0483938046,
0.0026350811,
-0.01597251,
-0.0140443025,
0.0070113107,
0.0120756477,
-0.0042870007,
0.0228651948,
0.0041888873,
-0.0071659787,
-0.0429706462,
-0.0063985405,
-0.0592761971,
-0.0282967594,
0.0430276021,
-0.0241089296,
-0.0528692156,
-0.0104480134,
-0.0523515902,
-0.0329848602,
-0.0218871757,
-0.0196973216,
-0.017474778,
-0.0364274308,
-0.0580475442,
0.0061651403,
-0.0204245877,
-0.039465528,
0.0651558712,
-0.0161571559,
-0.000433551,
0.0274740104,
-0.0019334422,
0.0162656661,
-0.0493065901,
-0.0135149872,
0.0130302589,
0.0218460336,
0.0325721651,
0.0422565006,
-0.00927829,
-0.0769190863,
-0.033381328,
-0.0871320441,
0.0009078323,
-0.0188531373,
-0.001712304,
0.0104620196,
-0.0152924294,
-0.0003189549,
-0.0056596464,
-0.0972598866,
-0.0305368919,
0.0083563551,
0.020907307,
0.0201983172,
0.0135614676,
0.026921954,
-0.0329215899,
-0.0249767583,
-0.0166392531,
0.0581457578,
0.0164394584,
0.0222477652,
-0.0518611297,
-0.044207003,
-0.0936329663,
0.0106475316,
-0.0058087171,
-0.0069994498,
0.009289355,
-0.015591301,
0.0060489876,
0.0698697865,
0.012448756,
-0.0256576091,
0.0445086174,
0.0149631258,
-0.0691353381,
0.0291607864,
0.004293242,
-0.0055735712,
-0.020785097,
-0.0326174796,
-0.0252352916,
0.0298979804,
0.0089741256,
-0.0213321988,
-0.0659538507,
0.0378352553,
0.003868883,
-0.0223943926,
-0.05980644,
-0.010904273,
0.0102235284,
0.0837124512,
-0.0247587394,
-0.0076546515,
0.1066240892,
0.0142487092,
-0.0144019835,
-0.0531279407,
-0.0052222465,
-0.0753790438,
0.0293257833,
-0.04986725,
0.0049882024,
-0.0194541384,
0.0146938059,
-0.0562637523,
-0.0486411527,
0.0066644247,
-0.0593922623,
0.0399111807,
-0.0448823422,
0.0038850603,
0.014857728,
-0.0452525094,
-0.0391553864,
-0.0313073695,
-0.0734412298,
0.0237671174,
-0.0079084933,
-0.0128850238,
-0.0168733429,
-0.0225523263,
0.0280467141,
-0.0133797955,
-0.0345978178,
-0.0031663317,
-0.005792845,
0.0501290858,
0.0510221198,
0.061527662,
0.0137871932,
-0.0229802188,
0.0339509659,
0.058044605,
0.012043329,
-0.0345694721,
-0.0276501663,
-0.0097081009,
0.0418350399,
-0.0274648629,
-0.0212381445,
0.0217600781,
0.0678292066,
-0.0445337705,
0.0270967539,
0.1178663,
0.0459662974,
-0.0267417803,
-0.0238134693,
-0.0417039096,
0.039840892,
0.0261769406,
0.0515732169,
-0.0743882284,
-0.0580566712,
-0.0094314283,
0.0313871987,
0.0020233656,
-0.0382299498,
-0.0000873981,
-0.0798488408,
0.012079468,
-0.0175322816,
-0.0222123265,
-0.0158019532,
-0.0467002429,
0.0049970937,
-0.0233149901,
0.0088486876,
0.0158638917,
0.0158953182,
0.019838348,
0.0390724912,
-0.0195456278,
-0.0245551318,
0.0642806068,
-0.0178857166,
0.0285997409,
0.0534142442,
0.0089082187,
-0.022408314,
-0.0624031313,
-0.0086414209,
-0.0107741607,
0.021677468,
-0.0046574101,
0.0411397554,
-0.0266037192,
0.0103027131,
-0.0314195491,
0.0372705162,
-0.0174555145,
-0.0067338306,
0.0410531014,
0.0740588829,
0.0029906714,
-0.0155874165,
-0.0342174768,
0.0160654485,
-0.0096118087,
0.0981245637,
0.0233226959,
-0.0426322743,
-0.0187944937,
-0.0634534582,
-0.0444823951,
-0.0111892093,
-0.0265948698,
0.0334808081,
0.0646193847,
-0.0050637107,
-0.0333876014,
-0.0313225798,
0.0662544519,
0.0180469658,
-0.0289928727,
0.010561334,
-0.024621116,
0.0465294719,
0.0081073958,
0.0516480319,
-0.055141516,
0.0130117517,
-0.0523514338,
-0.0016216015,
0.0126999756,
-0.0218793601,
-0.0306884013,
-0.0111843031,
-0.0548298098,
-0.0532499477,
-0.0230660532,
0.0755592287,
0.0273846891,
0.0088248095,
0.0022196274,
-0.0728362948,
0.0444497913,
0.0205759332,
-0.032406155,
-0.0125801554,
0.0404440202,
0.0058892099,
-0.0015437144,
0.0312192235,
-0.0464545898,
0.0042285086,
0.0195881221,
0.0194735769,
-0.0426596813,
-0.0389344469,
0.0206694584,
0.0151284616,
-0.016027458,
0.0240588263,
0.0146583822,
-0.0030047388,
0.0081950091,
0.0061303806,
-0.0295631643,
-0.0143679762,
0.0128609482,
0.0192509796,
-0.0904293805,
0.027046008,
0.0122405244,
0.0063757985,
0.0236274265,
-0.0158522464,
0.0347228944,
0.030629091,
0.0052309218,
0.0088566011,
-0.0220244788,
-0.0594232641,
-0.0221471898,
-0.0088363569,
0.0580511726,
0.0257007089,
0.0533487536,
0.0246540252,
-0.037803065,
-0.0113253985,
0.0020225693,
-0.0924962014,
-0.1093663126,
0.0243793596,
0.0520416498,
0.0150936535,
0.0211912226,
0.0049359174,
-0.016178092,
-0.0216480028,
-0.0192005169,
-0.0013971537,
0.0411511399,
0.0069122883,
0.0562963821,
0.0181275848,
-0.0211735722,
-0.0061689219,
0.0701977238,
-0.0451161265,
0.0126374774,
-0.003473554,
-0.0271702595,
-0.0336693116,
0.0017421939,
-0.0295951888,
0.0148878219,
0.0071411198,
0.0233259201,
-0.0650919303,
-0.0329626091,
0.0144714173,
0.0053731641,
-0.0155930119,
0.0036819428,
0.0282050725,
0.0547246747,
-0.0014614229,
-0.0309139099,
-0.0152567448,
0.0218559839,
-0.0211617928,
0.0035214035,
-0.0493231751,
-6.460001939e-33,
-0.0018032579,
-0.024610769,
0.0019165933,
-0.0722339153,
0.0442695543,
0.0005501501,
-0.0102460543,
0.0183571316,
-0.0665381327,
0.0120138992,
-0.0503094532,
0.0119556924,
0.0033801841,
0.018265279,
0.0096495971,
-0.0255643371,
0.0227398574,
-0.003801011,
-0.0296010859,
0.0209223386,
0.0184819829,
0.001090553,
0.0512543283,
-0.0343234874,
0.0469371602,
0.005120385,
-0.0000814785,
0.0442538746,
-0.0625512451,
0.0643021837,
-0.0035479241,
0.045039624,
0.0257582646,
-0.0607753322,
-0.0049033612,
0.0264819991,
-0.0508967042,
-0.0344509482,
0.051351659,
-0.0335480869,
-0.075353384,
-0.0275523216,
0.009693047,
-0.0080450131,
0.0207575411,
-0.0581609048,
0.041057013,
-0.0310316514,
0.0140306987,
-0.0137359332,
0.0304970425,
0.0204161778,
-0.0390771441,
-0.0027489518,
-0.0129685039,
0.0719520897,
-0.0075060236,
0.0355065465,
-0.0269204658,
0.002937603,
0.0349278562,
0.0138010532,
0.0662916005,
-0.0059764576,
-0.0146196354,
0.0479598865,
0.0029249089,
-0.0119496593,
-0.0498414822,
-0.0278758388,
-0.026068842,
0.0567052886,
0.0953025967,
0.045429185,
0.0069069145,
0.0102887293,
-0.0587564185,
0.0377568901,
0.0368554033,
0.0231024865,
0.0467564836,
-0.0069197617,
-0.0390762016,
-0.0166916158,
-0.0713417977,
0.0116630895,
-0.0431628264,
-0.02699643,
0.0168650225,
-0.0124186659,
-0.0430461429,
0.003757864,
0.0230498891,
-0.0451193713,
-0.0145381493,
0.060575597,
-0.0133189056,
0.0079215383,
0.0294525493,
0.0480324589,
-0.0457161069,
0.0385981202,
0.0149573972,
-0.0293362811,
-0.0039674593,
0.0300148837,
0.0300242808,
-0.017929133,
-0.0339322798,
-0.0055333115,
-0.0326437354,
0.0098230513,
-0.0116868662,
0.0019632403,
0.0357711352,
0.0497961938,
-0.0015631915,
0.0242807474,
-0.0173918977,
0.0125561589,
-0.0130662136,
-0.0130207092,
-0.0072599906,
0.0183349326,
-0.0277138352,
0.0094318446,
-0.0189265534,
-0.0279490612,
-0.0359153859,
0.016700441,
-0.006054373,
0.0274325479,
2.435e-7,
0.0488899648,
0.0401783548,
-0.0004223842,
0.0148057872,
0.0069792909,
0.0379843153,
0.0075379023,
0.0058615245,
0.0529714003,
-0.0685714707,
-0.0021754254,
0.0601284504,
0.0429731831,
0.0514774546,
-0.06378337,
-0.0107246963,
-0.0484031402,
0.0076762773,
-0.040853247,
-0.0099293031,
0.0667743608,
0.0847500265,
0.0190697312,
-0.0071473368,
-0.0128538879,
-0.0283217523,
0.0406969339,
-0.0345617905,
0.0121143041,
0.0345413759,
0.09414009,
-0.0034419775,
0.0425640978,
0.0551072098,
0.0230140295,
-0.0107819941,
0.0054104794,
0.0617606305,
-0.014911131,
-0.0413701124,
-0.0251665413,
-0.0239941757,
0.0378876925,
-0.0798943862,
0.0823578686,
-0.0184724834,
-0.0298193265,
-0.0291601159,
-0.0227650814,
-0.0131283356,
0.0323466621,
-0.0286291018,
-0.0073009264,
0.0071562123,
-0.002341185,
-0.0113857053,
0.0157355908,
-0.0515040532,
-0.0248326436,
-0.0014953519,
-0.0472572297,
-0.0582321696,
-0.0068459483,
-0.0076584821,
0.0035480217,
-0.0846673772,
0.0141903898,
1.967456578e-34,
0.020157909,
0.0194734279,
0.0342022479,
0.0514055528,
0.0403804183,
-0.0009658778,
-0.0134840207,
-0.0196177308,
0.0571935363,
-0.0516393855,
-0.0204664283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14627v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14627v2 | Enabling Large Language Models to Generate Text with Citations | 2023-05-24T01:53:49 | 2023-10-31T15:04:35 | Tianyu Gao, Howard Yen, Jiatong Yu, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a widely-used tool for
information seeking, but their generated outputs are prone to hallucination. In
this work, our aim is to allow LLMs to generate text with citations, improving
their factual correctness and verifiability. Existing work mainly relies on
commercial search engines and human evaluation, making it challenging to
reproduce and compare different modeling approaches. We propose ALCE, the first
benchmark for Automatic LLMs' Citation Evaluation. ALCE collects a diverse set
of questions and retrieval corpora and requires building end-to-end systems to
retrieve supporting evidence and generate answers with citations. We develop
automatic metrics along three dimensions -- fluency, correctness, and citation
quality -- and demonstrate their strong correlation with human judgements. Our
experiments with state-of-the-art LLMs and novel prompting strategies show that
current systems have considerable room for improvement -- For example, on the
ELI5 dataset, even the best models lack complete citation support 50% of the
time. Our analyses further highlight promising future directions, including
developing better retrievers, advancing long-context LLMs, and improving the
ability to synthesize information from multiple sources. | [
0.0588430986,
0.0252689235,
0.0089466451,
0.0362047702,
-0.0281552151,
-0.0223914571,
0.0148639148,
0.0164713562,
0.0329407528,
-0.0568543598,
0.0133925797,
-0.0109003047,
-0.0174473021,
-0.0024254248,
0.0275439378,
-0.0101694167,
0.0065375776,
-0.0105000269,
0.0502304323,
-0.0112809325,
0.0155228339,
0.0317027085,
0.0212342944,
0.0330434628,
0.0274296664,
-0.022306731,
0.0101480614,
-0.0005581727,
0.0228005815,
-0.0179300848,
0.0311151315,
0.0444005951,
-0.0108571919,
0.0380532369,
0.0000018391,
-0.0567145534,
0.003271559,
0.0094358027,
-0.0056657591,
0.026066253,
0.0560480878,
0.0071671144,
0.0165244229,
0.0274562966,
-0.044143144,
0.0082573919,
0.011254143,
0.0063603767,
0.0774094462,
0.0354699492,
0.0125150848,
-0.0364663713,
0.0348667726,
-0.0098319408,
0.0108786924,
-0.0260122605,
0.0267429091,
0.0414184742,
0.0418818966,
0.0547131896,
0.0455346182,
0.0394633412,
-0.0010443588,
-0.0436384007,
0.0421366803,
0.0007796623,
-0.0205455609,
-0.0036060046,
0.0271495655,
0.0512664914,
-0.0010868004,
-0.0440095887,
0.0232896637,
0.011177226,
-0.0099196481,
0.0477959067,
-0.0326305926,
0.0461270809,
-0.0016420683,
-0.0227535255,
0.0251555499,
-0.0238238107,
0.0221546534,
0.0255962051,
0.0105283968,
0.0484410152,
0.0314231999,
-0.0223004241,
0.0090867318,
-0.0019133595,
0.0137855448,
-0.0680058375,
0.0164478645,
0.0454958752,
-0.0456068888,
-0.018610768,
0.0018082499,
-0.0115070827,
0.067810379,
-0.0285229981,
-0.0221139733,
-0.012118767,
-0.0335957743,
0.0557701848,
-0.0354833864,
0.0088686887,
-0.0347619057,
-0.0374258831,
-0.0153712053,
-0.0415934809,
-0.0259171501,
0.0095987525,
-0.0134971365,
-0.0072502228,
-0.045206219,
-0.0013396348,
-0.0525155962,
0.0087829372,
-0.0295022614,
0.0264521576,
0.0145535879,
-0.0130711216,
-0.0102836872,
-0.0046743788,
-0.0453494005,
0.0066246549,
-0.0299969874,
0.0328081362,
0.0168177094,
-0.0353604369,
0.0055570295,
0.014189166,
0.0383803248,
-0.017563764,
0.0311963242,
0.032010328,
0.0045890487,
-0.0002276661,
-0.0513385981,
-0.0490244068,
0.0008760167,
-0.058560513,
-0.012196973,
-0.1010059863,
0.0422770306,
0.0403412692,
-0.0144510577,
-0.0565278679,
0.0130878808,
0.0527798571,
-0.0191035047,
0.0189631451,
-0.0432259254,
0.0124290055,
0.0440033972,
-0.0045191599,
0.0355568752,
0.0351430848,
0.0301262718,
0.0147585804,
0.071843043,
0.0267792828,
0.0328293405,
0.0192327891,
0.0281135533,
0.0313925631,
0.0252206083,
0.0107214367,
-0.0357761607,
0.0316686779,
0.0195205361,
0.0782208741,
-0.0116463741,
-0.0018946907,
0.0431436114,
0.0222405791,
-0.0181670077,
-0.0051028561,
0.0581415035,
-0.0031608844,
0.0281977355,
-0.0431020819,
0.000950121,
0.0202036444,
-0.0193250738,
0.0218522623,
0.0725083947,
0.0459292382,
-0.0065406226,
-0.0172811747,
-0.0145413522,
0.0071274759,
-0.0322034508,
0.0075122784,
0.0227920245,
-0.0129600596,
-0.0270489417,
0.0572965555,
0.0103756981,
-0.0479422696,
0.0453714468,
0.0048636817,
0.0625829473,
0.0366737098,
0.0509104393,
0.008082089,
0.0411577187,
-0.0387066975,
0.0009174275,
0.061876528,
-0.0026213443,
-0.0227342006,
-0.0138912974,
-0.0202933308,
-0.030448366,
0.0151650589,
0.0024190522,
-0.0417568572,
0.0407922417,
0.0009812628,
0.0463455506,
-0.0847282484,
-0.0679712147,
0.0217300709,
-0.053330455,
-0.0140081206,
-0.016086597,
-0.014300785,
0.0112885432,
0.0354098342,
-0.0255047418,
0.031868536,
0.0446495004,
-0.0276011229,
-0.0205535125,
0.0131640984,
0.0292460248,
0.0261203051,
0.0629897043,
-0.0377319157,
0.0068033594,
-0.0025028372,
-0.0190332308,
-0.0368435085,
-0.0157412458,
-0.0259244125,
0.0118700871,
-0.0319803469,
0.0206035133,
0.0039644856,
-0.0036740489,
-0.0367355309,
0.0864082426,
0.0121577699,
0.0560839549,
0.0458957031,
-0.0182479676,
0.0244332999,
-0.0373597518,
-0.0433056168,
-0.0039657713,
-0.0015954048,
0.0136723919,
0.0765264556,
-0.0032376859,
-0.0597824305,
-0.0011567801,
-0.0668705329,
0.006810037,
-0.0047378764,
0.0025159598,
0.0194285288,
0.0160531197,
0.0036863922,
0.0149196768,
-0.0283082742,
-0.0252559651,
0.0171247441,
0.0187417008,
0.0377364866,
0.0168692917,
0.0154882297,
-0.0578419976,
-0.0100578303,
-0.00779622,
0.038129352,
0.0443313979,
0.0430917107,
-0.0827156082,
0.0249908082,
-0.0436996482,
-0.0031773089,
0.0013265759,
0.0097809937,
-0.0040797321,
-0.0150357662,
0.048335243,
0.0458399355,
0.0418494642,
-0.0238739122,
0.040423926,
0.0042782412,
-0.0719464719,
-0.0202923287,
-0.0262788422,
-0.0297919419,
-0.0121991327,
-0.0708666593,
0.0134263011,
0.0089669004,
0.0016770023,
0.0071184444,
-0.0085799992,
0.0197218843,
-0.0031099841,
0.0153573407,
-0.054359924,
-0.0043946309,
-0.0119913528,
0.0694951639,
-0.0108757801,
-0.0093905972,
0.0509408116,
-0.0454561785,
0.0049400064,
-0.0278118495,
0.010874222,
-0.0298144221,
0.0230744872,
0.0180734973,
0.0050702603,
0.0023774724,
0.0312279835,
-0.031751141,
0.0080401469,
0.0423468165,
-0.0563847572,
0.0384793505,
-0.0274598915,
0.0274661034,
-0.0023333558,
-0.026286779,
-0.0315395966,
-0.0383366086,
-0.0442928225,
0.0118143316,
0.0388654657,
-0.0367431864,
-0.0249572005,
-0.029028127,
0.0973741263,
0.0220288001,
-0.0159359463,
-0.0362839513,
-0.0204135459,
0.0559965186,
0.0706844181,
-0.0154782366,
0.0450142846,
-0.025898343,
-0.0137814926,
0.0472622812,
0.023030106,
0.0147818346,
-0.0221167319,
-0.0599999279,
0.0259215739,
-0.0527416617,
0.0105442004,
0.004940269,
0.0219856221,
-0.0411105044,
-0.0252729543,
0.1103124768,
0.0339217372,
-0.0587795265,
-0.0365255326,
-0.0612265542,
0.0115658846,
0.0268255826,
0.0486149713,
-0.1061131284,
-0.0134377806,
-0.0158780124,
0.0312710442,
0.0049355621,
-0.0281305145,
0.0175620466,
-0.1467476189,
0.0414704531,
0.0040359562,
0.0375770777,
-0.0327698365,
-0.078873992,
0.0157111809,
-0.0234217234,
-0.0309533831,
0.0524130166,
-0.0174857471,
0.0057894858,
0.0113670556,
0.0219553541,
-0.0582005307,
0.0297313184,
-0.0717061087,
0.0279997289,
0.022006847,
0.0514188558,
-0.0137921777,
-0.056982629,
0.0053642439,
-0.0560272746,
-0.047654938,
0.0037348254,
0.0114672063,
-0.0016859689,
0.0221944898,
-0.0214856006,
0.0187057946,
-0.0087780654,
-0.0105961384,
0.0488315448,
0.0769272968,
0.017972026,
0.0205761734,
-0.0290456787,
0.0025541589,
0.0148146842,
0.0888127759,
0.0218133945,
-0.0219730027,
0.0018340048,
-0.026376253,
0.0092848055,
-0.0445637815,
-0.0612849221,
-0.0056964434,
-0.0425259955,
0.027229853,
-0.0913119018,
-0.0324692316,
-0.0019355662,
-0.0129799983,
0.0312945507,
0.0176882148,
0.0097593768,
-0.0108373556,
-0.041356802,
0.0257818233,
-0.0392220654,
0.0229409784,
-0.0493474193,
0.030689314,
0.0162629001,
-0.0360785052,
-0.024356747,
0.0376999639,
0.0096526816,
-0.0384041071,
-0.0193018448,
0.0167232323,
0.0209738333,
0.0144128334,
-0.0388151743,
-0.0432513356,
0.0270199012,
0.0450256281,
-0.0176050216,
-0.0071313889,
-0.0198107287,
-0.0147113148,
-0.0116236014,
0.0117583591,
-0.084808372,
0.0139490841,
-0.066889748,
0.0537310988,
-0.0256599784,
-0.06812682,
0.035362523,
0.0394081585,
0.0226940494,
-0.0304862875,
0.0173653103,
-0.0102294693,
-0.0158419479,
-0.0317041054,
-0.0393104106,
-0.0052993274,
0.0409825183,
-0.014647847,
-0.0148914512,
0.0114046885,
0.0553966351,
-0.0302152205,
0.0554106049,
-0.0231065042,
-0.0097102709,
-0.0267584249,
0.0613917969,
-0.0096877366,
-0.0363108069,
-0.0314861685,
-0.0390070193,
-0.0233566873,
0.0596462227,
-0.0153169977,
0.0367052667,
0.0139292432,
-0.0346477889,
0.025011234,
-0.0031435387,
-0.089160189,
-0.0048281499,
-0.0386191867,
-0.0430127569,
0.0545683652,
-0.0079374788,
0.085041143,
-0.0308261532,
-0.0471496657,
-0.0214708839,
0.0173126888,
0.0166708324,
-0.0051347241,
0.010737841,
0.0186173376,
-0.0329259522,
0.025721509,
0.0600299947,
0.0236161686,
0.0045913672,
-0.0124980984,
-0.05255007,
-0.0301717054,
-0.0335681438,
-0.0705146343,
0.0183001086,
-0.0147201344,
-0.0240419153,
-0.0543985255,
-0.0471014678,
0.0136952624,
0.0320209749,
-0.0084356526,
-0.0060363715,
0.0093736043,
0.0547501221,
-0.002726858,
-0.0184325129,
-0.0830939338,
0.0730782449,
-0.0428810976,
-0.0307559315,
-0.0379688665,
-6.281808015e-33,
-0.0153975738,
-0.0497040749,
0.0042980048,
-0.0329093523,
0.0018534161,
0.0060637584,
-0.065204367,
-0.0175558086,
-0.0610904619,
0.0242413413,
-0.0135959005,
0.0091326209,
0.0013835166,
0.0123945288,
0.0356812626,
0.0230152346,
0.0267433766,
0.0133022256,
-0.0418280922,
0.0270715039,
0.0747271925,
-0.0133548202,
0.009308815,
-0.0905227885,
0.0758752301,
-0.0430575311,
-0.0250839535,
0.0316135138,
0.0224538706,
0.0606336482,
-0.0126577513,
0.0476381071,
0.0097032227,
-0.0499116294,
0.0102097597,
-0.0016799514,
-0.0754191577,
0.0247831289,
0.0367146544,
-0.0603749827,
-0.0322169662,
-0.0399825871,
0.0251275264,
-0.0168502145,
-0.0239684619,
0.018271748,
0.0752091929,
-0.031463787,
-0.0031759322,
-0.0648732707,
-0.0351380557,
0.0178783536,
0.015095829,
0.0280102137,
-0.0318788327,
0.0915235728,
-0.0080485744,
0.1056440324,
-0.0664749071,
0.0345961526,
-0.0259556472,
0.0354605615,
0.0332157686,
-0.0207846444,
0.000028813,
0.0441119336,
-0.0332126394,
-0.0354270041,
-0.0078012832,
-0.0555025265,
-0.0169538204,
0.0454678051,
0.062742129,
0.1169282198,
-0.0096774269,
0.0219809879,
-0.0652518198,
0.0497099124,
-0.0050839083,
0.0511189848,
0.0301587209,
-0.0259134043,
-0.0084475558,
0.0029778192,
-0.0225391239,
-0.0109176654,
-0.0334098861,
-0.0086699873,
0.0016806793,
0.0117879082,
-0.0258429665,
-0.0035677149,
0.0314314291,
-0.0172126088,
-0.025935756,
0.0796150491,
-0.0277733523,
0.0160765611,
0.0145349121,
0.0156275667,
-0.0705013052,
0.0081655793,
-0.0173597466,
0.0098848231,
-0.0040378962,
0.0177531466,
-0.0079834284,
-0.0082758982,
-0.0499676801,
-0.0034254803,
-0.0288309399,
0.0257445797,
-0.0384903774,
-0.0600618683,
-0.0067683491,
0.0284552872,
0.0187948234,
0.0176303387,
0.0380871668,
0.0240019429,
0.0033794013,
-0.0424676687,
0.0356169119,
0.0271797106,
-0.0076536462,
0.0157373659,
-0.02022513,
0.0703103542,
0.0017696996,
-0.0435073115,
0.0063464898,
-0.0158108436,
2.562e-7,
0.0343956985,
0.0261425339,
-0.0137518663,
0.0148851965,
-0.005605306,
0.0262777116,
0.0153799243,
0.0193457287,
0.0443959422,
-0.0055624815,
-0.0309995543,
-0.0100293914,
0.0455571599,
0.034537591,
-0.0700762123,
-0.0559900776,
-0.0650852248,
-0.0384168141,
-0.0287046041,
-0.0201976914,
0.0105482768,
0.0256786514,
0.0084385751,
0.0017759508,
-0.0370139219,
-0.0645153746,
0.0685308054,
-0.0190259665,
-0.0285513252,
0.0295662954,
0.0731338114,
0.0172813516,
0.0330614336,
-0.0037997065,
-0.0361797363,
0.0262669418,
0.0095746247,
0.040614631,
0.0357465073,
-0.0041772411,
-0.0093492307,
-0.0651014,
0.0328705348,
-0.0842265785,
0.0367364101,
-0.0102388682,
0.0290507786,
-0.0395142883,
-0.0940937698,
-0.0084434412,
-0.0083785979,
-0.0396850742,
-0.0444728099,
0.0003063835,
-0.0240604617,
0.027074961,
-0.0232478902,
-0.0228224248,
-0.0464669205,
0.0397868678,
-0.0218704212,
-0.0764172748,
0.0034095105,
-0.03997593,
-0.0051155142,
-0.0632782206,
0.0454325303,
2.109038674e-34,
0.0529517308,
0.0043268935,
-0.0028571771,
0.0198164787,
0.0509305783,
0.0170398764,
-0.0488728918,
0.0090812193,
0.0159489997,
-0.0578626841,
0.0041756388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14625v1 | KNN-LM Does Not Improve Open-ended Text Generation | 2023-05-24T01:48:33 | 2023-05-24T01:48:33 | Shufan Wang, Yixiao Song, Andrew Drozdov, Aparna Garimella, Varun Manjunatha, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we study the generation quality of interpolation-based
retrieval-augmented language models (LMs). These methods, best exemplified by
the KNN-LM, interpolate the LM's predicted distribution of the next word with a
distribution formed from the most relevant retrievals for a given prefix. While
the KNN-LM and related methods yield impressive decreases in perplexity, we
discover that they do not exhibit corresponding improvements in open-ended
generation quality, as measured by both automatic evaluation metrics (e.g.,
MAUVE) and human evaluations. Digging deeper, we find that interpolating with a
retrieval distribution actually increases perplexity compared to a baseline
Transformer LM for the majority of tokens in the WikiText-103 test set, even
though the overall perplexity is lower due to a smaller number of tokens for
which perplexity dramatically decreases after interpolation. However, when
decoding a long sequence at inference time, significant improvements on this
smaller subset of tokens are washed out by slightly worse predictions on most
tokens. Furthermore, we discover that the entropy of the retrieval distribution
increases faster than that of the base LM as the generated sequence becomes
longer, which indicates that retrieval is less reliable when using
model-generated text as queries (i.e., is subject to exposure bias). We hope
that our analysis spurs future work on improved decoding algorithms and
interpolation strategies for retrieval-augmented language models. | [
0.0523745045,
0.0725862086,
-0.0043421825,
0.0013182063,
-0.0541894585,
-0.0230204705,
-0.0278916173,
0.044534184,
-0.0507448502,
-0.0400688984,
0.0002975387,
-0.0388605334,
0.0105434041,
0.0017880126,
0.0501360968,
-0.0432932824,
0.0339765362,
-0.0141653754,
0.0081955399,
0.0228515528,
-0.0177820027,
0.011665334,
0.0069066347,
0.0577357262,
-0.013929734,
0.014380903,
-0.0200722292,
0.0367169157,
-0.0290582366,
-0.025066467,
0.0059249741,
0.0472779274,
-0.0069703194,
0.0243953895,
0.0000018889,
-0.0110103302,
-0.0014377664,
-0.0081584845,
0.0008501307,
0.0296575297,
0.0726727024,
-0.0186514109,
0.0058338884,
0.0424320363,
-0.0226654354,
-0.009287185,
0.0341346413,
0.0295651443,
0.0207102485,
0.0474846959,
0.0051197466,
0.0051874169,
0.0432327762,
-0.0155819934,
0.0420941338,
-0.0160150211,
0.0069089816,
-0.021610735,
0.005249144,
0.0268654041,
0.0099897673,
0.0495016165,
0.0057183886,
-0.0047423625,
0.0298589095,
0.0515681766,
-0.0109176608,
-0.0173408575,
-0.0180306192,
0.0453814119,
-0.02893975,
-0.0374496393,
0.0045147482,
-0.0010690205,
0.0052033295,
0.0114262132,
-0.0501617752,
0.0308021903,
0.0061457008,
0.0080839582,
0.0311445035,
0.0237053335,
0.0349004716,
0.025371315,
-0.0683654845,
0.0723285824,
0.0404225886,
-0.056579113,
-0.0251151547,
0.0044057239,
-0.0281599741,
-0.0249115713,
0.0095779179,
0.0147574292,
0.0094593717,
0.0263383556,
-0.0439664274,
-0.0475227572,
0.0293642487,
0.0022829983,
0.0400022157,
0.0631921515,
0.0261074211,
-0.0201568007,
-0.0199610628,
0.044487305,
0.0067316294,
0.0299643334,
-0.0457708091,
0.0318605974,
-0.0218824651,
-0.0555047244,
-0.0271690991,
0.0209000856,
-0.0465622507,
-0.0182344839,
-0.0104703894,
0.0320940949,
0.0463232882,
-0.057397984,
0.0187509228,
0.0294367466,
-0.0452390462,
0.0034440989,
-0.0194598492,
0.0173036121,
-0.0232658815,
0.0237209704,
0.0432910174,
-0.0828558579,
-0.0384250656,
0.0121003734,
0.0128342761,
-0.0232075807,
-0.0024272241,
0.0371526405,
-0.0164044909,
-0.0487712473,
-0.004664483,
-0.0672453269,
-0.0179099534,
-0.0347303897,
0.0236997213,
-0.0814910308,
0.0142939016,
0.0203402098,
-0.0285743438,
-0.0267986897,
0.0046018711,
0.042341359,
-0.0544485897,
0.0290243551,
-0.0447555967,
0.04480296,
0.0101511581,
-0.0035905531,
0.0318853855,
0.0536204465,
0.0271701012,
0.0085389689,
0.0350317545,
0.0063603478,
0.0069059487,
0.0287573058,
0.0380543657,
0.0019743068,
-0.0279099736,
-0.0266053379,
-0.0160629377,
0.0352586247,
0.0558794551,
0.0817753375,
-0.0565427616,
0.006905071,
0.0245228298,
0.0489890091,
0.0271066297,
-0.0171322022,
0.0459632017,
0.0289796479,
-0.0032317862,
0.0552135147,
-0.0163052585,
0.0081647346,
-0.0090609137,
0.0501184724,
0.0663857758,
0.0236098766,
-0.0081822881,
-0.0468324274,
-0.0130238151,
0.0013649244,
0.0248626098,
-0.0440744571,
0.0168573931,
0.0523917973,
-0.0718870014,
0.0814868957,
0.0127740866,
-0.0739747658,
0.0317781754,
-0.0721510351,
-0.0151368016,
0.091958046,
0.0930317342,
0.0253226236,
0.0088059455,
0.0303320345,
-0.0427333303,
0.0445011705,
-0.0055680368,
0.0211290568,
-0.0084505891,
-0.0626921654,
-0.0060943896,
0.0014766677,
0.0280222017,
0.0050716684,
0.0207810532,
0.0141560417,
0.0646526366,
-0.0835447311,
0.0117088994,
0.0475586094,
-0.0546323247,
-0.0194790158,
0.0118051069,
-0.0087062232,
-0.0156344716,
0.0262957681,
-0.0138964001,
0.0732864588,
0.0466341786,
-0.0379450619,
-0.0111879846,
0.0013500224,
-0.0433893688,
-0.0715926662,
0.0096741049,
0.0002930138,
0.0274910033,
0.0074933819,
0.0047113216,
-0.0454861857,
0.034623418,
-0.0440930799,
0.0691707656,
-0.0697167516,
0.0360160619,
0.0000276548,
0.0058080512,
-0.0696161687,
0.0357142165,
-0.0181073099,
0.0418273993,
0.0067328513,
0.003959273,
0.0019113241,
-0.0266143642,
-0.0020054553,
0.0160959121,
-0.0315062292,
-0.0042505874,
0.0254359338,
-0.002363723,
-0.016752921,
-0.0455397256,
-0.0809003785,
-0.0064713326,
-0.0317330807,
0.0087001994,
0.0036932337,
0.0500749275,
-0.010863835,
0.0143636037,
-0.01123136,
-0.0247831289,
0.0626886338,
0.0251074377,
0.0334763229,
0.0298112016,
-0.0135860294,
-0.0293024648,
-0.0377087817,
0.0097874478,
0.0715654865,
-0.0037979237,
0.0385732651,
-0.0441526845,
0.0611507185,
-0.0387360975,
-0.0393552296,
-0.0157753732,
-0.0495731421,
0.0135827353,
-0.0508507378,
0.0405112468,
-0.0194333214,
0.0519478582,
-0.0085485531,
-0.0001787166,
-0.0399694778,
-0.0618905723,
-0.0188417807,
-0.0399992503,
-0.0247474629,
0.0125456806,
-0.0458458848,
0.0367675722,
0.059092205,
0.0222964659,
0.0037735242,
-0.0554205067,
0.0184603538,
-0.0062749283,
-0.0492331944,
-0.0305533558,
-0.0087362183,
-0.0242975187,
0.0409069397,
-0.0252190214,
-0.0589390472,
0.0729569942,
-0.0409475602,
0.0193656012,
-0.0290381685,
0.0198291522,
-0.0281870011,
0.0350656323,
-0.0050897733,
0.0093519986,
-0.0206580944,
-0.0464280695,
-0.0349985361,
0.0203318149,
-0.0317391865,
-0.0589633808,
0.0625128299,
-0.0214128643,
-0.0148871439,
0.0250099078,
-0.0315897241,
-0.0483817905,
-0.0624758117,
-0.0015930645,
-0.0201891903,
0.0819828659,
0.0037424106,
0.0117163304,
0.0352477767,
0.0143927597,
0.0040288218,
-0.0365450718,
-0.0104686758,
-0.0078578144,
0.0347004384,
0.0484109968,
-0.0261572171,
0.0049520596,
-0.0154874548,
-0.0067803268,
0.0350945294,
0.0424833484,
0.037662778,
0.0112776197,
0.0091422107,
0.0420378707,
-0.0072577633,
-0.0469483547,
0.0438804738,
0.0098705078,
-0.0321763381,
-0.0313426144,
0.1049165726,
0.0366405584,
-0.0247529931,
-0.0016130747,
-0.0155900726,
0.0837978274,
-0.009248117,
0.0261007957,
-0.0576656424,
-0.0085554179,
0.0332104601,
0.0544961989,
-0.0402841605,
-0.0101646893,
-0.0161212552,
-0.13741678,
0.0344632156,
0.0317626558,
-0.0199826024,
-0.0356280468,
-0.0570413992,
-0.0386336148,
0.0461225361,
0.0064083585,
0.0754525289,
-0.018100528,
0.0475036353,
0.0282736197,
-0.0181145389,
-0.0869104341,
-0.0699906275,
-0.0345798172,
-0.0013133892,
0.0743516758,
0.0161840171,
0.0081316894,
-0.0498490036,
0.0006718703,
-0.0155615089,
0.0316171572,
-0.0106210485,
0.0350795649,
-0.0051259072,
0.0042516445,
-0.0436802246,
-0.0178573932,
-0.0435112827,
-0.0118691269,
-0.0349502824,
0.0194281489,
-0.0268863216,
0.0046066362,
-0.0474275053,
0.0001186755,
0.0242059324,
0.0800251886,
0.0401225314,
-0.0232680105,
-0.0251936186,
-0.0293747187,
0.0584253371,
-0.0765962601,
0.0108347153,
0.0152102364,
0.011401007,
-0.0070938985,
-0.0907618925,
-0.0396311395,
-0.0232233573,
0.0545052588,
-0.0042436104,
0.0182770081,
-0.047121767,
-0.0092469659,
-0.0614918284,
-0.0186087117,
0.0044508418,
0.0079146549,
-0.0674512535,
0.0226092022,
0.0269640442,
-0.0418362543,
-0.0172370207,
0.0269508008,
-0.0354517251,
-0.0631276369,
-0.0134315509,
0.0391961448,
0.0267138425,
0.0400880836,
0.0093935085,
-0.0361845903,
0.0602997467,
0.0849400014,
-0.0348526388,
0.0310786851,
-0.0144252805,
-0.0270204078,
-0.0129470881,
0.0223482642,
-0.0498905666,
-0.0145596685,
-0.0192180183,
0.0725617334,
0.0369635224,
-0.0667223334,
0.0232879743,
0.0248000789,
0.0475882106,
-0.0339001752,
0.0324242003,
-0.0023646599,
0.0057038013,
-0.0320548564,
0.002233638,
-0.0458036177,
0.0106007317,
0.0287564304,
0.0185521115,
-0.0240641497,
0.00560972,
-0.0091023929,
0.0721902028,
0.0147332801,
-0.0278464574,
-0.0693845525,
0.0014122369,
0.0197282266,
-0.0068817777,
-0.0261278413,
-0.012970455,
-0.0335366204,
0.027126627,
-0.0345872343,
0.002363336,
0.0025889499,
0.0067656962,
-0.0231720638,
0.0276489928,
-0.0756900981,
0.0139489658,
-0.021591004,
-0.0243781395,
0.0319742411,
0.0124917887,
0.0554246418,
-0.0305202492,
0.0143225128,
-0.019963989,
-0.0056531378,
0.0245104134,
-0.0351265147,
0.003155903,
0.0158612225,
-0.0350203253,
-0.0272305161,
0.0805095434,
0.0282436721,
0.0337991714,
-0.0388181694,
-0.0224033576,
-0.0198735613,
-0.0032755411,
-0.0053242389,
0.0433972552,
0.0029569466,
-0.0027945829,
-0.0496332124,
-0.0474051945,
0.0511227064,
0.0089427028,
0.0080753984,
-0.0213027112,
0.0530620106,
0.0831780732,
-0.0205383152,
-0.0187773835,
-0.0424756557,
0.017756667,
-0.0488377921,
-0.0335038938,
-0.0342959352,
-6.529214311e-33,
-0.0400028266,
-0.0137046333,
-0.0060438393,
-0.0207259059,
-0.0502186269,
-0.0181047488,
-0.0441070609,
0.012119052,
0.0252470113,
-0.0017597829,
-0.0322888866,
-0.0033878207,
0.0125566553,
0.0266710259,
0.000671615,
0.0190319996,
0.0452009887,
0.001455389,
-0.0410262533,
0.011998523,
0.0268489029,
0.061498858,
0.0141827725,
-0.0015886597,
-0.0115940832,
-0.0304768849,
0.0070302263,
-0.0413023159,
0.0109140417,
0.0514964089,
-0.0183376037,
0.0504796579,
0.0279607847,
-0.0148124211,
-0.0261801239,
0.010875158,
-0.048395548,
-0.001239949,
0.0174323265,
-0.0025867717,
-0.021735806,
-0.0645618364,
0.0618533455,
-0.020795742,
-0.0561714508,
0.0280299149,
0.0080234427,
-0.0206929389,
-0.0443147905,
-0.0304288026,
-0.0234643612,
0.0232394263,
0.0226141922,
-0.0112759052,
-0.0125463139,
0.0489972569,
0.0076788226,
0.0157369338,
-0.0308645032,
0.0522837453,
0.0244450308,
0.0834329203,
0.0296231825,
0.0431770086,
0.0154979676,
0.0355894119,
0.017395068,
-0.0330769531,
-0.0219851509,
-0.0000466743,
0.0477008745,
0.0146692293,
0.0170213729,
0.0475210026,
0.039489679,
-0.0510894172,
-0.0077420431,
0.0453206114,
-0.0178184304,
-0.0095836716,
0.0536938608,
-0.0033646,
-0.0358210169,
-0.0373733677,
-0.0489506014,
-0.0267948247,
-0.0316755772,
-0.0481057651,
0.0494613834,
0.0512977391,
-0.0237961039,
-0.0323188901,
0.0551138148,
-0.0236465912,
-0.0069042975,
0.0298113246,
-0.0555681065,
0.01741088,
-0.0468938239,
0.0131841544,
-0.0253927149,
-0.0296649728,
0.0394085571,
0.0089383852,
-0.0299687181,
0.0021633927,
-0.0293714479,
0.0216617044,
-0.0543360896,
-0.0166246407,
-0.0232000239,
0.0277541988,
0.0153437825,
-0.0364011601,
0.0439524092,
0.0019317949,
0.0010694728,
0.0150036383,
0.0031252387,
0.0152956611,
-0.0133775836,
-0.0435178019,
0.0075770169,
0.0294196215,
-0.0365878418,
0.0168536995,
-0.0403459966,
0.0124564487,
-0.0103247548,
-0.0534292795,
-0.029166393,
0.0311253201,
2.726e-7,
0.0418620929,
0.040993154,
0.06290894,
0.015310646,
0.007128661,
-0.0135455793,
0.0150319617,
0.0069764503,
-0.0044490565,
-0.0193061493,
-0.0086909579,
-0.020445196,
0.0486914441,
-0.0239941161,
-0.0990000442,
0.0083393371,
-0.065485023,
0.0355734937,
-0.037329711,
-0.010907948,
0.0665133148,
0.0676937699,
-0.0186168607,
-0.0047551529,
0.0128402906,
-0.0519294366,
0.0742992833,
0.008704762,
-0.0296904184,
0.0120876553,
0.0582873113,
0.032908529,
0.0342818722,
0.0056629218,
-0.02857586,
0.0034976131,
0.0338269919,
0.0266740099,
0.0212045498,
-0.0561071113,
0.0145583702,
-0.0082502328,
0.0046472265,
-0.0704020113,
0.0786504745,
-0.0020614979,
0.0041945898,
0.0213566888,
-0.0524062552,
0.008157663,
0.003358955,
-0.0317962132,
-0.0294066984,
0.0372901969,
0.0259988066,
0.0339814983,
-0.0124139301,
-0.07237757,
-0.0337562747,
-0.0353841819,
-0.0534036532,
-0.0441782475,
-0.0650766268,
0.0159226507,
0.0105101308,
-0.0344472043,
-0.0152834514,
2.819570596e-34,
0.0486513712,
-0.013601603,
0.0189557243,
0.0030246188,
0.026172474,
-0.0039770487,
0.0381065905,
0.052268628,
-0.0020640476,
-0.1098298654,
-0.0297507979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14623v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14623v2 | Self-Checker: Plug-and-Play Modules for Fact-Checking with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T01:46:07 | 2024-04-01T03:23:23 | Miaoran Li, Baolin Peng, Michel Galley, Jianfeng Gao, Zhu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact-checking is an essential task in NLP that is commonly utilized for
validating the factual accuracy of claims. Prior work has mainly focused on
fine-tuning pre-trained languages models on specific datasets, which can be
computationally intensive and time-consuming. With the rapid development of
large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-3, researchers are now
exploring their in-context learning capabilities for a wide range of tasks. In
this paper, we aim to assess the capacity of LLMs for fact-checking by
introducing Self-Checker, a framework comprising a set of plug-and-play modules
that facilitate fact-checking by purely prompting LLMs in an almost zero-shot
setting. This framework provides a fast and efficient way to construct
fact-checking systems in low-resource environments. Empirical results
demonstrate the potential of Self-Checker in utilizing LLMs for fact-checking.
However, there is still significant room for improvement compared to SOTA
fine-tuned models, which suggests that LLM adoption could be a promising
approach for future fact-checking research. | [
0.0308495853,
0.0300836768,
0.0190221127,
0.0477957092,
-0.059778139,
0.007847717,
0.0263535604,
-0.0162081309,
0.0408559144,
-0.070506908,
-0.0169031154,
0.0009096005,
-0.0018186019,
0.0407719575,
0.010817254,
0.0368084759,
0.0768804029,
-0.0056358338,
0.0364518762,
-0.0145857166,
0.007869835,
0.0342686698,
-0.0263554621,
0.0156189986,
-0.0528234281,
-0.036972139,
0.0274237487,
-0.0189518239,
0.0048073195,
-0.0345264189,
0.0342445411,
0.0486603491,
0.0266514905,
0.0833320245,
0.0000019344,
-0.041161783,
-0.0005028328,
0.0385812037,
-0.0796301737,
0.045738928,
0.0199085381,
0.0039878795,
-0.0379957482,
0.0246283337,
-0.026245892,
-0.0260635298,
0.0360948481,
0.0249657352,
0.0829227865,
0.0848807469,
0.0010007034,
-0.0020444042,
0.0190804228,
-0.0099796429,
-0.0259928834,
-0.0320680179,
0.0389359593,
0.030077612,
-0.0260607116,
0.0332332253,
0.0155104864,
0.0322589278,
0.0388072245,
-0.014503113,
-0.0526026152,
0.0330717526,
-0.0637037531,
-0.0006127753,
-0.0321841538,
0.0246723909,
-0.0048540705,
-0.0729328096,
-0.0167259071,
-0.0183195677,
-0.0234180987,
0.0093926257,
0.0113664009,
0.0420807227,
-0.0294370651,
-0.002869942,
0.0266036559,
-0.0188970342,
0.0295108557,
0.0245975591,
0.0189376865,
0.0768018663,
-0.0016679486,
-0.0527465194,
0.0069444245,
0.0210739728,
0.0131992707,
-0.0783985406,
-0.0303531587,
0.0087701045,
-0.0180075429,
0.015491927,
-0.0233664773,
0.0353998765,
0.0645956621,
-0.0601095296,
-0.0012502174,
0.0191434901,
-0.0746420249,
0.0746974051,
-0.0303055234,
0.0253822207,
0.0129452711,
-0.0175506361,
0.04544672,
-0.0221388638,
-0.0132665746,
0.021897465,
-0.0305299591,
0.0137415882,
-0.0232059509,
0.0149863018,
-0.0395600908,
-0.004458033,
-0.0344416909,
0.0545135066,
0.0018939016,
-0.0241280757,
-0.0027460482,
-0.0281579178,
-0.0591590479,
0.0303863678,
-0.0060171881,
0.0022823552,
-0.0177728571,
-0.0772785768,
-0.0064597372,
0.0054655639,
-0.0154288262,
-0.0096032368,
0.0339394957,
0.000012513,
0.0241925884,
-0.0359977186,
-0.0455292687,
-0.0068315417,
-0.0299539417,
-0.1101333648,
-0.0404427387,
-0.0914648473,
-0.0008684047,
-0.0040167817,
-0.0109596979,
-0.0017563821,
-0.0156158917,
0.0290152598,
-0.0060474235,
0.059661828,
-0.0032997131,
0.0087354528,
0.01704075,
-0.0077459742,
0.0207043607,
0.0714336708,
0.0041560666,
0.0104237637,
0.0615219288,
0.0227963589,
0.0262697842,
0.0092354231,
0.0290089343,
0.0221409854,
0.0343570001,
0.0154277608,
-0.0026045921,
-0.0076129823,
-0.0166121796,
0.0473298058,
-0.0129241701,
-0.0171303432,
0.0655099377,
0.0113544641,
0.0281958897,
-0.0086124195,
0.0760840327,
0.0002892296,
0.0437307246,
-0.0046928735,
-0.0655762181,
0.0390041769,
-0.0302014984,
-0.0117899803,
0.0090508265,
0.0775538608,
-0.0097040692,
-0.0484645478,
-0.0393133722,
0.0019312324,
-0.0321653523,
0.0256980993,
0.0119159147,
-0.0043434016,
-0.0250932425,
0.0306781959,
0.0392797403,
-0.0469631404,
-0.0379804224,
-0.0789777562,
0.0304515343,
0.0227579437,
0.0678560212,
-0.0091883559,
-0.0131132482,
-0.0343336836,
0.0194342844,
0.0564544909,
0.0767116919,
0.0030942718,
0.0049588783,
0.0110922977,
0.0061084344,
-0.0395599641,
0.0557914749,
-0.0051558111,
0.0858359039,
0.0182150248,
-0.0083794203,
-0.0129748276,
-0.0322504975,
0.0263710208,
-0.0228825565,
-0.021715289,
0.0037604249,
0.0070597329,
0.0085515045,
0.00055173,
-0.02968782,
-0.0221125651,
0.0193969142,
0.0100153089,
-0.0049660164,
-0.0125280861,
0.0112271924,
-0.0435752496,
0.0386654474,
0.0086159017,
-0.0644207075,
0.0222425573,
-0.037582472,
0.0011144176,
-0.027219303,
-0.0181182437,
0.0183896292,
-0.0689012632,
-0.0173169766,
-0.0054017226,
0.0301174019,
0.0148289027,
0.0605775826,
0.0077931108,
0.0116705513,
-0.0119422283,
0.0277428105,
0.0334738605,
-0.0108857611,
-0.0464796387,
0.0062411386,
0.0051534106,
0.0251576733,
0.0209907033,
-0.0001584564,
-0.0168360025,
0.0048754062,
-0.1006323025,
0.0132536925,
-0.0230019707,
0.0073957318,
0.0244359467,
-0.010987048,
-0.0151625853,
0.0111258719,
0.0084123043,
-0.0070703705,
0.0354896002,
0.0156285707,
0.0518632755,
-0.0340850465,
0.0070630871,
-0.0339043774,
0.0252926629,
-0.0347559229,
0.0129332775,
0.0323802121,
-0.0152009688,
-0.0369900353,
-0.0014780427,
-0.0586280897,
0.0441638008,
0.007401837,
-0.0383774415,
0.0328218676,
0.0290180296,
0.0389706492,
0.0693386793,
0.0075870217,
0.0084937764,
0.0432343557,
-0.0006900756,
-0.0238902196,
0.0349315107,
-0.0156252943,
-0.0260594841,
0.0138457697,
-0.0115522835,
0.049092494,
0.0512168631,
0.0129575329,
-0.0319492742,
-0.0198590048,
0.0381107703,
-0.0220022406,
-0.0002336529,
0.0335617848,
0.0057467152,
-0.0187231041,
0.0481273048,
-0.0180024914,
-0.0378099307,
0.0864720196,
-0.0537790917,
0.0071114851,
-0.0240345243,
-0.0302587654,
-0.0245194212,
0.0367742367,
-0.0092473002,
0.0153631764,
0.0055696797,
0.0170004573,
0.0028390069,
-0.0291224606,
0.0679691285,
-0.0299042854,
0.0491490848,
-0.0505908206,
0.049572777,
0.0268552452,
-0.0642313808,
-0.0339237712,
-0.08491835,
-0.0427325778,
-0.0155170197,
-0.0636608824,
-0.0201615691,
-0.0464369878,
-0.0000833465,
0.0391732864,
0.0783113986,
0.0044695172,
-0.0159526616,
0.024913162,
0.002432934,
0.0035157709,
0.0220700707,
0.0572956838,
0.0225391779,
0.0083761076,
0.0699574128,
-0.0383363217,
0.0137247238,
-0.0404255874,
-0.0447251461,
-0.0199289452,
-0.039861057,
0.0263172481,
-0.0112041449,
0.0389884263,
-0.0692618489,
-0.0240516774,
0.0867257491,
0.0144542577,
0.0045425822,
-0.004602592,
0.0290318877,
-0.0068404828,
0.0316954628,
0.0331322812,
-0.1167639866,
-0.025318237,
-0.0266333725,
-0.0309714526,
-0.0331453718,
0.0042955377,
-0.0389514901,
-0.1181606948,
0.0707881972,
-0.0203827415,
-0.0059626554,
-0.0388011821,
-0.0322058015,
0.0075538233,
-0.005987613,
0.0021571785,
0.0227487963,
-0.0019712723,
-0.0208465997,
-0.0111718196,
-0.0519883111,
-0.0621435456,
0.0959823132,
-0.0304063912,
0.0606203452,
0.0257895738,
0.0122765228,
-0.0034233846,
-0.0164729934,
0.0229580812,
-0.0057679676,
-0.0498631448,
0.0021163716,
0.0374905393,
-0.0365341194,
-0.0097183259,
-0.0061969887,
0.0003234337,
0.0232835524,
-0.0153060555,
-0.0142554836,
0.0489972718,
-0.0000629308,
-0.0299647227,
-0.0022015518,
0.0289466623,
0.0064123571,
0.0865493938,
-0.0059143803,
0.0238770321,
-0.0203242041,
-0.0231266171,
-0.0464344099,
-0.013242743,
-0.0716210529,
0.0415865481,
0.0013309405,
-0.0193378832,
-0.0555398278,
0.0126999943,
0.0217242576,
0.0142618855,
-0.045341149,
-0.0147315748,
0.0321980193,
0.019317871,
-0.0153446691,
-0.0010442643,
-0.0662851185,
0.0213711858,
-0.0059866849,
-0.0044444622,
0.0708615929,
0.0002376572,
0.0034781634,
0.0416028053,
-0.0787824914,
-0.0532234833,
-0.0021790259,
0.0209036451,
0.0243316498,
0.0578985661,
-0.0589483976,
-0.0036633243,
0.0189528391,
0.0718249157,
-0.0683338642,
0.0323066078,
0.0124420729,
0.0039032374,
0.0023618382,
0.0112391477,
-0.024566561,
0.0209537204,
-0.0020928753,
0.0113950297,
-0.0260125138,
-0.0414372981,
0.0676566735,
0.0254086182,
0.0484796427,
-0.0078517059,
0.0211701617,
-0.047196243,
-0.0028297971,
-0.0158045609,
-0.0414472111,
0.0040601008,
0.0163766574,
-0.0323077179,
-0.0259900484,
-0.0339314081,
-0.018522393,
-0.0562284961,
0.0452059098,
-0.0153046222,
-0.0169497207,
0.002535664,
0.0009147975,
0.001074588,
-0.0406581499,
-0.0438501835,
-0.0013704612,
-0.0075974735,
0.0199971851,
-0.0154637704,
0.0307672769,
0.0195629485,
-0.0047077849,
0.0207798462,
-0.021279756,
-0.0662602633,
-0.0023787799,
-0.0424717665,
0.033208888,
0.0660552531,
0.0047926796,
0.026376117,
-0.0514051281,
-0.0417627171,
-0.0193302911,
-0.0068736076,
0.0075969766,
-0.0005773432,
0.0367274359,
0.0155032016,
-0.0400110483,
0.0009258832,
0.0420082025,
0.0177159086,
0.0715692788,
0.0459128655,
-0.032987006,
-0.0525194034,
-0.0776064172,
-0.0607908815,
-0.0177835505,
-0.0011290166,
-0.0038108774,
-0.0818709731,
-0.0741850138,
-0.0172841847,
0.0558251403,
0.0066725104,
0.0122073786,
-0.0169695076,
0.087557666,
0.038728144,
-0.0083459234,
-0.0387868546,
0.0210899506,
-0.0022593501,
-0.0054641999,
0.0189607311,
-6.479878813e-33,
-0.0290232915,
-0.0584426112,
0.0376874469,
0.0060225059,
0.004121562,
0.0264247637,
-0.0244194791,
-0.0149642974,
-0.0433063582,
0.0488029011,
0.0089363372,
0.0452991873,
0.0148102026,
-0.0210447591,
-0.0249670018,
-0.0001481709,
0.0545258112,
0.0060230982,
-0.0499794185,
-0.0048509734,
0.0188438613,
-0.0499898903,
0.0567715839,
-0.0484838858,
0.0257550068,
-0.0055513973,
-0.050398808,
0.0265574735,
-0.0676088855,
0.0640855134,
0.004034956,
0.0432740487,
0.0346956439,
-0.0273417048,
0.0408239998,
-0.0195152424,
-0.08016105,
-0.0131062819,
0.0442732126,
-0.0242475364,
-0.0038698255,
0.0399268866,
0.0393736027,
-0.0295430664,
-0.0198576599,
0.010339018,
-0.005968044,
-0.0170124844,
0.021845337,
-0.0027712607,
-0.0736312345,
0.0389185771,
0.0269626994,
-0.0059127552,
-0.0321455933,
0.012624721,
-0.0005898387,
-0.0072952979,
-0.0677222684,
0.0115863979,
-0.0148686953,
0.0147041734,
0.0507026352,
-0.0446705781,
-0.0318103284,
0.0437826738,
-0.0179069769,
0.0274996459,
-0.0471035242,
0.0141077796,
0.014674197,
0.0254407004,
0.0400183015,
0.1247448772,
0.0185421258,
-0.0200670473,
-0.0621932745,
0.0100699207,
0.0573592298,
0.0216798205,
0.0048693344,
-0.0298853628,
-0.0453779362,
-0.004472971,
-0.0263161305,
0.041888155,
-0.0382515974,
-0.0068390393,
0.0152324596,
0.039526999,
-0.0084476089,
0.0261964928,
-0.0026737524,
-0.0390877835,
0.0086353375,
0.0113404924,
-0.0441086628,
-0.0113029229,
-0.0039088321,
0.0285484996,
-0.0587359108,
0.031531062,
-0.0282190423,
0.0418189541,
-0.0044116536,
0.000783322,
0.0467983596,
0.0333921798,
-0.0887884945,
0.0422678813,
-0.0345608369,
0.0429748148,
-0.015775118,
-0.0204387084,
0.0207899772,
-0.0005643017,
-0.0100618107,
0.0140488036,
0.0041010561,
-0.0163768586,
-0.0363860391,
0.0105238473,
-0.0044587599,
0.0266344361,
-0.0245143324,
0.0026466632,
-0.0402657539,
0.0127242841,
0.009767049,
-0.0672223717,
0.0145847043,
0.0101256138,
2.637e-7,
0.01041942,
0.0671519041,
0.0001212946,
0.0062583038,
0.0225632377,
0.0360472649,
0.005537048,
-0.0095161656,
-0.0027316292,
-0.058237683,
-0.0437705554,
0.0516943708,
0.0400592722,
0.0626974404,
-0.0369652212,
0.0422399864,
-0.0702431872,
-0.0145608373,
-0.0472905897,
-0.0354500487,
-0.0072091762,
0.057558842,
0.035269469,
-0.0098351846,
-0.0051692906,
-0.0441558547,
0.0652287304,
0.0468504243,
-0.0765201896,
0.0221151188,
0.0435134582,
0.0404886678,
0.0103205424,
0.0222733505,
-0.0269546807,
0.0062377201,
-0.0498348586,
0.0678680092,
0.0274002682,
0.0062313615,
-0.0254695397,
-0.0344059169,
0.0030487946,
-0.060579069,
0.0718037933,
-0.0370268635,
-0.0149785243,
-0.0830793902,
-0.0016598738,
-0.0003145341,
0.0251060929,
-0.0312055312,
-0.0456623249,
0.0088389665,
-0.0051274318,
0.0077408743,
-0.0137257129,
-0.018992167,
-0.0346372351,
0.0191835556,
-0.0224775244,
-0.0748335347,
0.032047227,
-0.0254659653,
0.0485517867,
-0.065728493,
0.0278058853,
2.363638352e-34,
0.0315515697,
-0.0031640548,
0.0157085713,
-0.0278596357,
0.0674757287,
0.0447131246,
-0.0103577832,
-0.0254727602,
0.0005045127,
0.0045748968,
-0.0042234813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14622v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14622v1 | EXnet: Efficient In-context Learning for Data-less Text classification | 2023-05-24T01:40:57 | 2023-05-24T01:40:57 | Debaditya Shome, Kuldeep Yadav | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large pre-trained language models (PLMs) have made significant progress in
encoding world knowledge and spawned a new set of learning paradigms including
zero-shot, few-shot, and in-context learning. Many language tasks can be
modeled as a set of prompts (for example, is this text about geography?) and
language models can provide binary answers, i.e., Yes or No. There is evidence
to suggest that the next-word prediction used by many PLMs does not align well
with zero-shot paradigms. Therefore, PLMs are fine-tuned as a
question-answering system. In-context learning extends zero-shot learning by
incorporating prompts and examples, resulting in increased task accuracy. Our
paper presents EXnet, a model specifically designed to perform in-context
learning without any limitations on the number of examples. We argue that
in-context learning is an effective method to increase task accuracy, and
providing examples facilitates cross-task generalization, especially when it
comes to text classification tasks. With extensive experiments, we show that
even our smallest model (15M parameters) generalizes to several unseen
classification tasks and domains. | [
0.0260384195,
-0.0261073168,
0.0234242845,
0.0447360501,
-0.0132014006,
0.0192701872,
0.0413713194,
0.0018971505,
-0.0013309651,
-0.0833390132,
-0.0420732573,
-0.0409336202,
-0.0248798095,
0.0137906987,
0.0126158129,
-0.0111053381,
0.0486367829,
-0.0128094582,
0.0235446319,
0.0119892731,
0.00731275,
0.0127914771,
-0.0030775773,
0.0223050527,
0.0323927514,
-0.0195195787,
-0.0430769175,
0.0111742308,
-0.0121632069,
-0.0192355271,
0.0512777194,
0.039658621,
0.0261976663,
0.0155905662,
0.0000017794,
-0.0604974218,
0.0120625542,
-0.0257787853,
-0.0561317094,
-0.0377624109,
0.0151828947,
0.0181076583,
0.0437603928,
0.0366347022,
-0.0445394441,
-0.0416955203,
0.0451341979,
0.0343959741,
0.0519737862,
0.0868615732,
-0.004886528,
0.0097102281,
0.0093538119,
-0.0298026819,
0.0663969517,
-0.0148942815,
0.033734519,
-0.0480334833,
0.0127676139,
0.0458006561,
0.0067042965,
0.030279994,
0.0141871143,
0.0278552044,
-0.0192537662,
0.0453888737,
-0.0132195298,
-0.0164399017,
-0.0149231851,
0.0977928862,
-0.0239312574,
-0.0575184822,
-0.0088603366,
-0.0217989236,
-0.0050443541,
-0.0122749023,
-0.0471776873,
0.0126166334,
0.0077830926,
0.0040918803,
0.0018193725,
0.041223634,
-0.0069028982,
0.0307430793,
-0.0241954811,
0.0539733134,
-0.018993834,
-0.0292522926,
0.0007112498,
0.0077080098,
-0.0399937816,
-0.0775440112,
-0.0395767577,
0.0772292688,
-0.0110844998,
0.0108508449,
-0.0460274071,
-0.0254895538,
0.0354703367,
-0.0467302874,
0.0318135805,
0.0265458673,
-0.0196118355,
0.0744848177,
-0.035405796,
0.0037782998,
0.0112035628,
0.0170214828,
-0.0398938246,
-0.0292408876,
-0.0410964563,
-0.0096232593,
-0.0527541637,
0.0281367302,
-0.0417662784,
-0.0182003509,
0.0042473357,
0.0436232537,
0.0275409855,
0.0075766258,
0.0052916543,
0.0253240056,
-0.026723234,
-0.0115111405,
-0.0434888229,
0.0128335832,
-0.0357791707,
0.0407596231,
-0.025688583,
-0.0486087129,
-0.0304564182,
0.0104708327,
0.0446856804,
-0.0195974894,
0.0350709036,
0.0395723842,
-0.0201385152,
-0.072522983,
-0.0060213697,
-0.0187719762,
-0.0024126007,
-0.0693858564,
-0.0305671412,
-0.0559234582,
-0.0003838543,
0.0349652693,
-0.043736767,
-0.0111153349,
0.0088065583,
0.0756700635,
-0.0188268553,
0.0870759934,
-0.0026098446,
-0.0122422446,
0.0350741409,
0.0074436916,
0.0059186155,
0.0670581311,
-0.0144055299,
0.0110494522,
0.0359041281,
0.0384968519,
0.0471293628,
0.0131356409,
0.0413293615,
0.0128867226,
-0.0073963697,
0.0613415986,
0.0267998409,
0.0003601024,
-0.0282280333,
-0.0011964838,
-0.0070246235,
0.0028438345,
0.0496948026,
0.0416390486,
0.0028181996,
-0.0044545312,
0.0347042382,
0.03651518,
-0.0041372944,
-0.0448269583,
-0.0370351598,
0.0180615373,
-0.0492491275,
-0.004985455,
0.0231968816,
-0.0306658652,
-0.0747725442,
-0.0466281399,
-0.0103786867,
-0.0287691709,
0.0069009028,
0.0450222753,
0.0665773377,
0.0191018619,
-0.0664487332,
0.0176937263,
0.0234182663,
-0.0255170297,
-0.0288278963,
-0.0412650593,
0.0693511665,
0.0061836489,
0.0221934039,
-0.0627465025,
-0.0333203226,
-0.0418451577,
0.0756780207,
0.0370163061,
0.0267293416,
-0.0282246694,
0.0218065269,
-0.0309095066,
-0.0186566599,
-0.0075276289,
0.0000093293,
-0.0129587036,
0.0324948169,
0.0395779088,
0.0375578031,
-0.023903748,
-0.0015634225,
0.0278535113,
-0.0218279772,
-0.0619856231,
0.0245681461,
0.0136531387,
-0.0027564648,
-0.0020295035,
-0.0031571758,
0.0018398039,
0.0368731432,
-0.0197800007,
-0.0147437211,
-0.0319853537,
-0.0507804193,
-0.0779892579,
0.016416382,
0.0202416312,
0.0134650292,
0.0119684786,
-0.0288214013,
-0.0436507985,
-0.0339088477,
-0.0078472933,
0.055493243,
-0.0691968724,
-0.0208864901,
-0.0083297249,
0.0207148921,
-0.0526167713,
0.0524626896,
0.0501144789,
0.0485046692,
-0.0055335383,
0.0051640454,
0.0367707051,
-0.0124343717,
-0.0364096537,
-0.0076316665,
-0.0103790099,
0.0005624832,
0.0142207239,
0.0372064188,
-0.0235972069,
0.0408376008,
-0.1129842848,
0.0193101447,
-0.0418506414,
0.0084991409,
0.0352392569,
0.0212776139,
-0.0048045134,
-0.0595948845,
-0.0596415251,
0.0244903639,
0.0268388875,
0.0146444822,
0.0524729453,
0.0186352301,
0.0179611184,
-0.0212275349,
-0.0025609108,
-0.007839201,
0.067763783,
-0.0128436135,
-0.0011448492,
-0.0372289196,
0.0441272892,
-0.0434204563,
0.0442695543,
-0.011629384,
0.005123381,
-0.0259876214,
-0.050958626,
-0.0269720852,
0.0458024889,
-0.0111192381,
0.0015341606,
0.0139528988,
0.0318693593,
-0.0601489581,
0.0106452117,
-0.0240501594,
0.0026132786,
-0.0012993624,
0.0352916531,
-0.0172021855,
0.0436053425,
0.0133871548,
-0.0381259918,
-0.0378969088,
0.0392335691,
0.0117835673,
-0.0012572302,
-0.0756255016,
0.0077198399,
0.0101690721,
0.043593403,
-0.0215554554,
-0.0343550481,
0.0488313697,
-0.006745317,
-0.0288110599,
-0.0624740683,
-0.0366916507,
-0.0372732691,
0.0490953848,
0.0114595741,
0.0234364364,
0.0486020595,
-0.0041598212,
-0.0535409972,
-0.0405095331,
-0.0259588268,
-0.0189354736,
0.0516313426,
-0.0136467665,
0.024478253,
-0.0386390015,
-0.0379812941,
-0.0721848309,
-0.0634084493,
-0.0323546417,
0.028729558,
-0.0573291145,
0.0300600212,
-0.0032797619,
0.0185479484,
0.0306458604,
0.0815286264,
-0.0256582778,
-0.0286441538,
-0.0237547532,
0.0805453286,
0.0494894385,
0.0102109667,
-0.0277037229,
-0.0188143793,
0.030774923,
0.0380707867,
0.0020359287,
-0.0072013363,
-0.0090741217,
-0.0200090967,
0.0298153367,
-0.0336459912,
-0.0172801651,
0.0377944708,
0.0474992543,
-0.0349735282,
-0.0288449824,
0.1277017742,
0.0604919754,
-0.052343864,
-0.0220988169,
-0.0123882815,
-0.013436636,
0.051141791,
0.0516372994,
-0.0625856072,
-0.0679621398,
-0.0225797109,
-0.0238826443,
0.0046199132,
-0.015953714,
-0.0313226916,
-0.1008797809,
-0.0073029823,
-0.0283679981,
-0.0481822975,
-0.0068350225,
-0.0322692208,
0.0021770473,
0.0213077012,
-0.0507983081,
-0.0013899198,
-0.0098167788,
-0.004469078,
0.0037674634,
0.0015984067,
-0.0439161509,
0.0397749618,
-0.0209762827,
0.0127607044,
0.0528840497,
0.0142625598,
-0.0154335033,
0.0049710898,
0.0356251784,
-0.0444169305,
0.0092241261,
-0.0191794708,
0.0648836941,
-0.0237301923,
0.0028967434,
0.0041942261,
0.0119108362,
-0.0593902096,
-0.0072910027,
0.0307664629,
0.0717388466,
-0.0253668409,
0.0069178888,
-0.026278669,
-0.0261380356,
0.0404254682,
0.0821540207,
-0.0003043036,
-0.0549573228,
-0.0474611335,
-0.030829763,
-0.0375954844,
-0.0304981843,
-0.0052792844,
-0.0149301495,
0.0205376055,
0.0164270233,
-0.0442751087,
-0.0387243442,
0.0534553751,
0.0483856909,
-0.0093938503,
-0.0020169674,
-0.000258811,
0.0144198984,
-0.0580881983,
-0.0130807851,
-0.0247627776,
0.0264101177,
-0.0349948406,
0.0052526752,
0.0847147331,
-0.0506345071,
-0.0155506851,
0.0103496481,
-0.0809398964,
-0.0431155823,
-0.0425125621,
0.023842385,
0.0210085269,
0.0291192215,
-0.0166695975,
-0.0395199992,
0.1281057,
0.0313837677,
-0.0237896293,
0.0030418548,
0.0364876762,
0.0175437964,
0.0074051046,
0.0494451933,
-0.0349354222,
0.0370754786,
0.0387576297,
-0.0105323289,
-0.0684853345,
-0.0022717142,
0.0106978798,
-0.0435321927,
0.0528534204,
0.0155996606,
-0.0279690828,
-0.0278681368,
0.0361204334,
-0.0050408305,
-0.0145788528,
-0.0293601546,
0.0164700933,
0.0026358678,
-0.034725152,
-0.0198845677,
0.0391073637,
-0.0403970592,
0.0328002535,
-0.0056339479,
-0.0115255704,
0.0334101133,
0.0190404225,
0.0242219288,
-0.0014132928,
-0.0357355662,
-0.0062328256,
0.0097020511,
0.0264407005,
-0.0376059003,
0.0652883723,
0.0069244187,
-0.0068008839,
-0.037989147,
0.0280059855,
-0.0823111236,
-0.0136196036,
-0.0531800501,
0.026352983,
0.0310452357,
-0.021153586,
-0.0166613385,
-0.0109401923,
-0.0121698715,
-0.0320225134,
0.028900601,
0.0009123168,
-0.024599554,
0.0358114131,
0.0298511405,
-0.0236053709,
0.0390145816,
0.0882944465,
0.0215275064,
0.0208560452,
0.0279991589,
0.0020462836,
-0.0469704792,
0.044564683,
0.0493042693,
0.042203702,
0.0108859763,
0.0501608625,
-0.0226353314,
-0.0704397261,
0.0309427734,
-0.006914814,
-0.0289286412,
-0.0076938989,
0.0425955057,
0.036389254,
0.0289983451,
-0.0210204516,
-0.0377177484,
0.0306085609,
-0.0159105528,
-0.0120952316,
-0.028398538,
-5.939444918e-33,
-0.0040378473,
-0.0322633386,
0.0276937727,
0.0105622495,
0.0368360989,
0.0072107916,
-0.0325308219,
0.0002500569,
-0.0240643099,
-0.0056707622,
-0.0186702572,
0.0062702131,
0.0028191139,
0.0518159904,
-0.0185348056,
-0.0325997956,
0.0269515216,
-0.024244519,
0.0039694398,
0.034788698,
0.0371925421,
0.0372417271,
0.0346317813,
-0.0253165066,
0.033442121,
-0.0340660848,
0.0016869239,
0.0368859768,
0.0076770387,
0.0362062119,
-0.0295928661,
0.0574234612,
0.0466801859,
-0.043321263,
-0.0098994859,
0.069041878,
-0.0940966383,
-0.0538357385,
-0.0228144191,
-0.02160942,
-0.0329970121,
0.0043172329,
-0.0117182005,
-0.0188910086,
0.0221061148,
0.008342294,
0.0582043342,
-0.0042975871,
-0.0060847867,
-0.0279194769,
-0.0363299809,
-0.0048376103,
0.0072610737,
-0.0403634422,
-0.0168499984,
0.0838424042,
0.0105882203,
0.0256026462,
-0.0765264407,
0.0068864231,
0.002359879,
0.0071483175,
0.0195307601,
0.0300967023,
-0.0204960722,
0.0403389819,
-0.0032276229,
-0.0148058832,
-0.0207001287,
0.0055280016,
0.0221398585,
0.0046099899,
0.0216967352,
0.0684561133,
0.0632384047,
0.0103353392,
-0.0979016572,
0.0193780884,
-0.0037730825,
-0.0031190885,
0.026402561,
-0.0373177715,
-0.0309384577,
-0.033825729,
-0.0257578325,
-0.009291485,
-0.0517297387,
-0.0201301705,
0.0512107685,
0.0314998515,
0.0016179429,
0.0241163708,
0.0477950647,
-0.0584559627,
-0.0167463273,
0.0387256071,
-0.0053244047,
0.0038168838,
0.0197297912,
0.0125274919,
-0.0664999038,
-0.000087206,
-0.0013335957,
0.0146467052,
-0.0193802156,
0.015222976,
0.0662372112,
0.03201342,
-0.0861002728,
-0.0236341972,
-0.0115528982,
0.0135799916,
0.0041492567,
0.060823366,
0.0017572477,
0.0383050665,
-0.0116202356,
0.073344402,
-0.0172931869,
-0.0630887821,
-0.0166533664,
-0.0403382555,
-0.0002185466,
0.0116648627,
-0.0268442016,
-0.0128287692,
-0.033613611,
0.0256122891,
0.009548842,
-0.0601644889,
0.0175788254,
0.0417049676,
2.438e-7,
0.0518188588,
0.03749194,
-0.0016285147,
0.014255628,
0.0124029294,
0.0505628698,
0.0042554438,
0.0524049401,
0.0026295625,
0.007499476,
0.0154983634,
0.0388410538,
0.0069804755,
0.0138030732,
-0.1020473391,
-0.0032957976,
-0.0207952373,
-0.007368336,
-0.0371789187,
0.0058782469,
0.0750004202,
0.0813094303,
0.021063704,
-0.0077911192,
-0.0139341839,
-0.0564911887,
0.069718577,
0.0005886537,
0.0218094978,
0.0104603488,
-0.0089279963,
0.0183402691,
0.0003409362,
0.0235425662,
-0.0256868582,
0.0226788223,
0.0124968635,
0.0526129939,
-0.0044322731,
-0.0481158346,
-0.0012821973,
0.0013282499,
0.0282511301,
-0.0490606502,
0.1331561804,
-0.0963843986,
0.0050058179,
-0.0114521049,
0.0134009756,
-0.0036804022,
0.0178940427,
0.0153109608,
-0.0161946267,
-0.0038066648,
0.0262192413,
-0.0173567887,
-0.0033478015,
-0.0980286822,
-0.0319359452,
0.0022970645,
-0.0231970251,
-0.0231731012,
-0.0298771169,
0.0027282406,
0.0452165268,
-0.0518516302,
0.0248114467,
2.271073682e-34,
0.0039636865,
-0.0022391912,
0.0046609165,
-0.0021608104,
-0.0272369385,
0.0010303863,
-0.0056027519,
-0.0246355981,
0.0675476417,
-0.0713560656,
-0.0189998765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14618v1 | Abductive Commonsense Reasoning Exploiting Mutually Exclusive Explanations | 2023-05-24T01:35:10 | 2023-05-24T01:35:10 | Wenting Zhao, Justin T. Chiu, Claire Cardie, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Abductive reasoning aims to find plausible explanations for an event. This
style of reasoning is critical for commonsense tasks where there are often
multiple plausible explanations. Existing approaches for abductive reasoning in
natural language processing (NLP) often rely on manually generated annotations
for supervision; however, such annotations can be subjective and biased.
Instead of using direct supervision, this work proposes an approach for
abductive commonsense reasoning that exploits the fact that only a subset of
explanations is correct for a given context. The method uses posterior
regularization to enforce a mutual exclusion constraint, encouraging the model
to learn the distinction between fluent explanations and plausible ones. We
evaluate our approach on a diverse set of abductive reasoning datasets;
experimental results show that our approach outperforms or is comparable to
directly applying pretrained language models in a zero-shot manner and other
knowledge-augmented zero-shot methods. | [
0.030726159,
0.0465146974,
0.0113917226,
0.039041698,
-0.010078988,
0.0296671744,
0.0105987201,
0.0016564913,
0.0185090695,
-0.044690121,
0.0333511122,
0.01836285,
-0.0093490621,
-0.0278821159,
0.0195764359,
-0.0460618809,
0.0418846942,
0.0192364175,
0.0123420805,
0.0075950534,
0.0126422942,
0.0361847989,
-0.0168958716,
0.0525617488,
-0.0054738466,
0.0042281384,
-0.019900782,
-0.0102365883,
0.0098055843,
0.0344994403,
-0.0119092669,
0.0320314355,
0.0439619049,
0.018143883,
0.0000018297,
-0.0217972267,
0.0115839513,
0.0035290085,
-0.027146928,
-0.0406670868,
-0.0275640991,
-0.0104263071,
0.0439260304,
-0.0103774276,
-0.003800194,
0.0149430912,
0.0356769487,
0.057804469,
0.0703667328,
0.061789766,
-0.0018631141,
-0.0189240277,
-0.0451500416,
0.0013572125,
0.0713536814,
-0.044722259,
0.0123044373,
0.0091751516,
-0.0037685689,
-0.0284078084,
-0.0250441693,
-0.0113591375,
0.0344589762,
-0.0115612065,
-0.0198351983,
0.0238016509,
-0.0457221828,
-0.0412653498,
0.0076477914,
0.0794194415,
0.0301553328,
-0.044175975,
0.0028976279,
-0.0012413389,
0.0138119925,
0.035424117,
-0.0364514105,
0.0020706872,
-0.0105989072,
0.0225609634,
0.0278635956,
-0.0193422213,
0.0327814743,
0.0394862629,
-0.0162442308,
0.0580305457,
-0.0099660503,
0.0073224767,
-0.009754925,
0.0206673592,
-0.048733376,
-0.0299977344,
0.0073023057,
0.0825220793,
-0.0332858115,
0.0119010219,
-0.0115923379,
-0.0169073138,
0.0168607756,
-0.0296040755,
0.0071833883,
0.0288680848,
-0.0333089046,
0.0851932764,
-0.0239798296,
-0.0076654269,
-0.0201460328,
0.0519228652,
-0.0157457218,
-0.0200576875,
-0.0687408894,
-0.0028603151,
-0.0015643931,
0.01492377,
-0.0504588597,
0.0197505318,
0.002077993,
-0.0379112698,
-0.0321997255,
0.0085464818,
0.0040990845,
0.0558819622,
-0.0557905473,
-0.0477984585,
-0.0102580898,
0.0391373038,
-0.0669048503,
0.0693857074,
0.0280756559,
-0.0162695106,
-0.0556420647,
0.0087164305,
0.0657283366,
-0.0365046449,
-0.0131067382,
0.0094541842,
0.0037052315,
0.0171938203,
-0.077875793,
-0.0469189659,
0.0119341491,
-0.0453152992,
-0.0447071679,
-0.0144446678,
0.0279414114,
-0.0174453389,
-0.0048019197,
-0.0237667784,
0.0056129671,
0.0023305081,
-0.0468904488,
0.0852334425,
-0.06206166,
-0.0242845304,
0.0026603711,
0.0266529974,
-0.0332460627,
0.0828906223,
-0.0061938702,
-0.0219286326,
0.0177216064,
-0.0096551543,
0.0430148244,
-0.0439261682,
0.0385078117,
0.0012720821,
0.0299300179,
-0.0098702954,
-0.041457396,
0.0115328263,
0.0425958522,
-0.0124331908,
-0.0312643461,
-0.0245413706,
0.0061204862,
0.0611522011,
-0.0525063872,
0.0125019308,
0.0626531467,
0.0078454185,
-0.0193191301,
0.0555794761,
-0.048554603,
-0.0019296784,
-0.0659015402,
-0.0366980359,
0.0010898112,
-0.0239340961,
-0.0305738226,
-0.0277527533,
0.0119557055,
-0.0225552712,
0.0375098288,
0.0114635983,
0.0756399333,
0.0328396037,
-0.0222097635,
0.0687489286,
0.0451466925,
-0.0654417053,
0.0116243325,
-0.0228015017,
0.0311359502,
0.0315467492,
0.0369101167,
-0.0353376456,
-0.0378498286,
-0.0304192491,
0.0396137126,
0.036534138,
0.0282288175,
-0.0176113602,
0.0613461398,
-0.0502756387,
-0.0285039768,
0.0019470839,
0.0337168612,
0.0012446922,
-0.0117836902,
-0.0315711349,
0.0178941581,
-0.0500485376,
0.0008980788,
0.0397767983,
-0.0309354104,
-0.0503969081,
-0.0155970342,
0.0038205949,
0.0190803595,
0.020349415,
0.0302559808,
-0.0077208239,
0.0104625728,
-0.0368397832,
-0.0367091149,
0.0280632246,
-0.0163661651,
-0.0738411844,
0.0338079222,
-0.0315493308,
-0.0497145653,
0.017639054,
-0.0594336949,
-0.0624470934,
0.0210629143,
0.0033688298,
0.0528679118,
-0.0375365876,
-0.0629843846,
-0.0038747694,
-0.0204300974,
-0.0005836246,
0.0951481909,
-0.0058070491,
0.0233342703,
-0.0132724931,
-0.0350073799,
0.0345720649,
-0.033630956,
-0.0104387365,
-0.0367475376,
-0.0221570171,
-0.000676524,
0.0284389276,
-0.0099896705,
-0.0452908687,
0.0488259718,
-0.0881301537,
-0.0040238039,
-0.0198815186,
-0.0262865461,
-0.0054889116,
0.0041869301,
0.0326057673,
-0.0256435983,
0.0104053682,
-0.02560753,
-0.0224312413,
0.0096278684,
0.0250428021,
0.0038615607,
-0.011791883,
-0.0255264323,
0.0003606244,
-0.0320078619,
0.0346184932,
0.0160986241,
0.0581876636,
-0.0288978741,
0.0032013394,
-0.0260139816,
0.0321282186,
-0.0090135159,
-0.0130685456,
0.0189196207,
-0.0340160318,
-0.0805192143,
0.0504274033,
-0.0533181764,
0.0439857058,
0.0252933726,
-0.0018197077,
-0.0469208509,
0.0276317596,
-0.0341164768,
-0.026055526,
-0.0249966159,
-0.0088382242,
-0.0586036742,
0.0658344179,
0.0087422756,
-0.034293931,
-0.1065548211,
-0.0150342975,
-0.002993078,
-0.021768637,
-0.0567291528,
-0.0164511297,
0.0092167109,
0.0786343589,
-0.0500464663,
-0.0172365252,
0.085818924,
0.0043571424,
0.0144589311,
-0.0143088661,
0.0210516099,
-0.0116835395,
0.0423151702,
-0.028227834,
-0.004704887,
0.0238305628,
-0.0095646195,
-0.0114646116,
-0.0449823551,
0.0261025932,
0.021662293,
0.011434312,
-0.0444398597,
0.016196331,
-0.0050292327,
0.002196976,
-0.0354960337,
-0.0662648305,
-0.0229603816,
-0.0119306343,
-0.017959686,
0.0011519252,
-0.0548019037,
-0.0036836949,
0.018410055,
0.0361093394,
0.0140044214,
0.0062729539,
-0.0286530126,
-0.0173187461,
0.0230876096,
0.0316897035,
-0.0116449464,
0.0116817644,
-0.0150181903,
0.0516473018,
0.0552860834,
-0.0097451666,
-0.00630333,
0.0229932014,
-0.0037270766,
-0.0209098905,
-0.0001202611,
-0.0118247112,
0.0543672852,
-0.0683581084,
-0.0009338279,
0.0977297202,
0.0445248261,
-0.0223372355,
0.0133237727,
-0.009808559,
-0.003735889,
0.0179765783,
-0.0021562525,
-0.0871094465,
-0.0676967204,
0.0067891101,
0.0107474383,
0.0158989839,
-0.0675993562,
0.0095199458,
-0.1054222733,
0.0115977852,
-0.0023598669,
-0.0362523012,
-0.0302162729,
-0.0821321085,
0.0214436427,
-0.0468387865,
-0.0400324836,
-0.0158002675,
0.0502795614,
-0.008122595,
0.0284135621,
-0.003759715,
-0.0634219721,
0.0357624851,
-0.0188947488,
0.003142277,
0.0038556312,
0.053259749,
0.0009110743,
-0.0486222357,
-0.0277808923,
-0.0322743505,
0.0177519526,
-0.0145033989,
0.0429242328,
-0.002652802,
0.0000542045,
0.0122077288,
0.0752296299,
-0.0711736307,
-0.0602413937,
-0.0050734594,
0.0971410424,
-0.0248195305,
-0.0123569118,
0.002648816,
-0.0062543172,
0.028317919,
0.1034569666,
0.0404886082,
0.0206363164,
-0.0274843555,
-0.0341929644,
-0.0486113317,
-0.0565884151,
0.0054235426,
0.0072300276,
0.027169738,
-0.05487388,
-0.0132489931,
-0.0269512646,
0.0643183663,
0.0317066945,
0.0093995258,
0.0144620147,
0.0015036308,
-0.0010021263,
-0.0003594774,
0.0661685765,
-0.0093073174,
-0.0164973903,
0.0664071068,
-0.0103236316,
-0.0094666742,
-0.0007798871,
-0.0098199304,
0.024925448,
-0.0056943474,
-0.0620578341,
-0.0252322741,
0.026032608,
0.0248194039,
0.0631442666,
-0.0342460871,
-0.0597137958,
-0.0198575109,
0.0139624551,
0.0128824394,
-0.0326941051,
0.0513827577,
-0.0220924746,
0.0183004756,
0.0575404279,
-0.0217262246,
0.0138121983,
0.0032219903,
0.0499781631,
-0.0497025065,
0.056998089,
0.0268214829,
-0.0323220044,
0.0355616696,
-0.0395321473,
0.0031557078,
-0.0401604846,
-0.0190889593,
-0.0147520751,
-0.0249240361,
-0.0217905864,
0.0488481373,
0.0293456912,
-0.0399230085,
-0.0044903927,
-0.0368277356,
-0.0611183457,
0.0500902347,
-0.0417200364,
0.0068593868,
0.0921625271,
-0.0214056727,
-0.0175391156,
-0.0191572998,
-0.017743906,
-0.0037438984,
-0.0186477862,
0.0287311468,
-0.0066605872,
0.0698643103,
0.0544963889,
0.0311417915,
-0.0179184638,
-0.0516635329,
-0.047611963,
0.0010966473,
0.0269941743,
0.0651659593,
0.0588990599,
-0.0431895293,
0.0365530401,
0.0279500764,
-0.0227564387,
0.0189146977,
0.086246796,
0.0406904407,
-0.0286188461,
0.0237885565,
0.0241868533,
-0.0223073531,
0.0216515884,
0.0758659616,
-0.0361909159,
0.0489502586,
-0.0172104631,
-0.038925007,
-0.02830825,
-0.0184411164,
0.0214394536,
0.0872016102,
0.0189798977,
0.0439682454,
-0.0493628047,
-0.0757449418,
-0.0347261801,
-0.0069897529,
-0.012827904,
0.0160324667,
-0.0026652238,
0.0477502495,
-0.0066718291,
-0.05252387,
-0.0153476708,
0.0074261227,
-0.0448379554,
0.0133827599,
-0.0307387561,
-6.604147668e-33,
-0.0110643916,
-0.0474970601,
-0.0073906644,
-0.0095757889,
0.0383593291,
-0.0193776619,
-0.0563052855,
-0.0306405053,
-0.0193144921,
0.0555939861,
0.0025020817,
0.0200555436,
0.011821582,
0.0262569133,
0.0289422162,
-0.0167067423,
0.0064484677,
0.0431140251,
-0.0179891586,
0.0153246969,
0.0590900406,
0.0160115547,
0.0683430284,
-0.0539704897,
0.0748182535,
-0.0100438884,
-0.0275400821,
0.0334203057,
-0.034580525,
0.0489837714,
-0.0017623305,
0.0482118726,
0.0171370506,
-0.0112837963,
0.0180532634,
0.0313437358,
-0.0533673242,
-0.040433418,
0.0504738353,
-0.0082105072,
-0.0609071814,
-0.0280245729,
0.0044881981,
0.0088933054,
0.0225420464,
-0.0111760953,
0.0562385432,
-0.0268183146,
-0.0120263891,
0.0129499603,
-0.0324617475,
0.0193535425,
-0.0485849679,
-0.0404347964,
-0.0166011602,
0.0254398715,
-0.0202189479,
-0.0114760371,
-0.0211445037,
-0.0195607338,
0.0215824377,
-0.0129152853,
0.0339577235,
-0.03466608,
-0.021188505,
0.0492918901,
-0.0404660404,
-0.0228879526,
-0.0550252311,
0.0146396467,
-0.0133819226,
0.0709181353,
0.0546280146,
0.0403493345,
0.0649276823,
0.033835683,
-0.0780533403,
0.0225567296,
-0.0395295285,
0.0544991493,
0.0278942324,
0.0217532404,
-0.0415301621,
-0.0261818804,
-0.0311809815,
-0.0457340777,
-0.0274088439,
-0.0052364087,
0.0118649444,
0.0200424045,
-0.0676107854,
0.0523859225,
0.0298281852,
-0.041249752,
0.0079130773,
0.0223620553,
0.008408309,
-0.0397057608,
0.0184497479,
-0.0167922676,
-0.0192106944,
-0.0196190309,
0.0396420397,
0.0042648087,
0.0391084887,
0.0088811358,
0.0855131,
-0.0048086811,
0.0126448832,
-0.0084075136,
-0.054826159,
-0.0133298878,
-0.0373907238,
0.0226781815,
0.0455453657,
0.056837555,
-0.0175701138,
0.0240951646,
0.0088007329,
0.0222055018,
0.001545412,
-0.0026599444,
-0.0158932786,
-0.0148867369,
-0.0066637136,
-0.0232551489,
0.0200630706,
-0.08335042,
0.023798706,
-0.0481838956,
-0.0049005593,
0.0320385359,
2.491e-7,
0.0203673635,
0.0154409437,
0.0167052392,
-0.0407251976,
0.0065949187,
0.059757296,
0.0067053344,
0.0026265173,
-0.0121370051,
-0.0526475012,
-0.0006052006,
0.0547249354,
0.0544364192,
0.0458014049,
-0.0388542973,
-0.0140658757,
-0.0041454667,
-0.0152242128,
-0.044834394,
-0.0053005433,
0.0815393552,
0.0499181747,
0.0536367334,
-0.0179236624,
0.0370439328,
-0.0678157508,
0.0317170173,
0.0046050511,
-0.0002706533,
-0.0040197438,
0.0652119517,
0.007887681,
0.0163339451,
0.03750569,
-0.0191431176,
-0.012079699,
0.0018001312,
0.0635604486,
-0.0585542545,
-0.0434271209,
-0.02125879,
-0.0218491592,
0.0344279557,
-0.0266901441,
0.0886173025,
-0.0362298675,
-0.0290293992,
0.0249520447,
-0.0156288464,
0.0083232243,
0.0077161267,
0.0169917401,
-0.0075533991,
-0.0056380718,
0.0078299074,
-0.0187537372,
-0.0381544121,
-0.0773580819,
-0.0274996366,
0.0089472132,
-0.0178624634,
0.00217932,
0.0482677929,
-0.0447530486,
0.0485559925,
-0.0804614723,
-0.0019208934,
2.222581326e-34,
-0.007717832,
0.0203017425,
0.0139418906,
0.0278379023,
0.0565683618,
0.0322094746,
-0.0331948064,
-0.0103207827,
0.0379162207,
-0.039917659,
-0.0064366478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14617v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14617v2 | COMET-M: Reasoning about Multiple Events in Complex Sentences | 2023-05-24T01:35:01 | 2023-10-23T06:49:57 | Sahithya Ravi, Raymond Ng, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Understanding the speaker's intended meaning often involves drawing
commonsense inferences to reason about what is not stated explicitly. In
multi-event sentences, it requires understanding the relationships between
events based on contextual knowledge. We propose COMET-M (Multi-Event), an
event-centric commonsense model capable of generating commonsense inferences
for a target event within a complex sentence. COMET-M builds upon COMET
(Bosselut et al., 2019), which excels at generating event-centric inferences
for simple sentences, but struggles with the complexity of multi-event
sentences prevalent in natural text. To overcome this limitation, we curate a
multi-event inference dataset of 35K human-written inferences. We trained
COMET-M on the human-written inferences and also created baselines using
automatically labeled examples. Experimental results demonstrate the
significant performance improvement of COMET-M over COMET in generating
multi-event inferences. Moreover, COMET-M successfully produces distinct
inferences for each target event, taking the complete context into
consideration. COMET-M holds promise for downstream tasks involving natural
text such as coreference resolution, dialogue, and story understanding. | [
0.0084716836,
0.0686625764,
0.0086832922,
0.0647136718,
-0.0434839539,
0.0089385314,
-0.0253692009,
-0.0230481196,
0.0681185052,
-0.0192786381,
0.008666086,
0.0178548712,
-0.0169759784,
0.0121771554,
-0.0060176961,
-0.0529875755,
0.0578904748,
0.014438563,
-0.0064920029,
0.0267169457,
0.0194420125,
0.0464161448,
-0.0365767255,
0.055446282,
-0.0332559347,
-0.0343290307,
-0.0069060898,
-0.0033985297,
0.0627685934,
-0.0205238387,
-0.0054669864,
0.0334977508,
0.0680265203,
-0.0018443915,
0.0000014971,
-0.041004017,
0.0172684956,
-0.0310977492,
-0.0033777286,
-0.0008548078,
0.005680338,
-0.0245488621,
0.0313467495,
-0.0238650646,
-0.0183904953,
0.0268780272,
-0.0004583348,
0.0749671534,
0.0537743084,
0.0400584005,
-0.0146911126,
-0.051141981,
-0.0467826501,
-0.0210479274,
-0.014102729,
-0.0904141217,
0.0153178424,
0.0230138935,
0.0073247626,
-0.0315158106,
0.0005543301,
0.0001108836,
0.0393527187,
0.0007777877,
-0.0608553924,
0.078586109,
-0.0606301688,
0.0034397249,
0.0007315681,
0.0855601504,
0.0323851667,
-0.0103305373,
-0.0116867078,
-0.0051797656,
0.0115770139,
-0.0135319391,
-0.0234608781,
0.0221655425,
-0.0203458201,
0.0237914342,
0.0379512161,
0.0023009204,
0.0086769508,
0.0420880206,
0.010335899,
0.0551718101,
-0.0088170031,
0.019366676,
-0.004728768,
0.0170907583,
-0.0582390539,
-0.0182766058,
0.0384238176,
0.0436156616,
-0.0525839701,
0.0313685797,
-0.0689767674,
0.0295099448,
-0.0032660696,
-0.0808576196,
-0.0057672318,
0.0506967604,
-0.0061518871,
0.0575196035,
-0.0131831048,
-0.0155057237,
-0.0221613217,
0.0012426856,
-0.020595327,
-0.0244164579,
-0.0288826991,
0.042463515,
-0.0310440082,
0.0289169773,
-0.0452743433,
-0.0136420084,
-0.0393271111,
0.0030039237,
0.0234469306,
-0.0130335242,
-0.0128090745,
0.0258622579,
-0.0694506615,
-0.0387838855,
-0.0240625869,
0.0164736174,
-0.086610727,
0.0656234026,
0.0040394156,
-0.017254645,
-0.0560920686,
0.0029650896,
0.0433152989,
-0.0428656973,
-0.0288078077,
0.0357248224,
-0.0414607562,
-0.0080349874,
-0.0669355765,
-0.0446283892,
-0.0064495304,
-0.0170571152,
-0.0858857706,
-0.0330293328,
0.0439984389,
0.0080534294,
-0.0344988294,
-0.0147408005,
0.0297481138,
0.0195778515,
-0.0248163268,
0.0435702391,
0.0206991062,
-0.0114742648,
-0.0124545144,
0.0442462824,
-0.0189045891,
0.0660226941,
0.022650132,
0.003463329,
0.036573384,
0.0570778176,
-0.020001879,
0.0016405436,
0.0262400676,
-0.002260467,
0.0275278147,
0.0027368066,
-0.0425172634,
0.0562867224,
0.0504354462,
-0.0068883672,
-0.0478628539,
-0.0360442027,
0.0402721949,
0.0537937358,
-0.036243476,
0.0107636042,
0.0277326293,
0.0007645639,
-0.0178713445,
0.0400475599,
-0.0539253056,
0.0098856036,
-0.0074748709,
-0.0332928561,
-0.0055913995,
-0.010704739,
-0.0166750345,
0.0152544826,
0.0147348074,
-0.0115743047,
-0.0049365889,
-0.0067112288,
0.0187510606,
0.0198074449,
-0.0405955203,
0.0610595755,
0.0223116633,
-0.0699400976,
0.0201004017,
-0.0011300775,
0.0029492953,
0.0290389452,
0.0283425674,
-0.0368321128,
-0.0744878203,
-0.0147680016,
0.0386923179,
0.0354808867,
0.0408552252,
-0.0334696434,
0.078512013,
-0.0397740826,
0.0126391994,
0.003639726,
0.0080684237,
-0.012859094,
0.0317247026,
-0.0175769348,
-0.0077571031,
0.0024793497,
0.0367179923,
0.0362109691,
-0.0115475664,
0.0007275405,
-0.0210034177,
0.0023460311,
0.0270107165,
-0.009231681,
0.0331314094,
-0.0347375534,
0.0166792087,
-0.0173086803,
-0.0068464391,
0.0689366758,
-0.0277747549,
-0.116075635,
0.0356961526,
-0.0276354086,
-0.0831141174,
0.0127749816,
-0.0550945923,
-0.0447882153,
0.0200382899,
0.0086924341,
0.0242612902,
-0.0364541821,
-0.0436363705,
0.0252370164,
0.0070259827,
0.0206008423,
0.1059538722,
-0.0158827659,
-0.0213181004,
0.0023834913,
-0.000819432,
0.0090014413,
-0.0243798122,
-0.0068716267,
-0.0348628573,
0.0022913418,
-0.0260101557,
0.0157655496,
0.0075847809,
-0.0657861158,
0.0103431987,
-0.0691823736,
0.0378272645,
-0.0043723793,
0.0270359963,
0.0356900096,
0.0297232438,
0.0035593654,
-0.0190450195,
0.0134061212,
-0.0533242859,
-0.0278599169,
-0.0045552216,
0.0543430187,
0.010947559,
0.0008667862,
-0.0329190008,
0.0117782289,
-0.0785807818,
0.0580018163,
-0.0011661984,
0.0175344367,
-0.0229004659,
0.0269315019,
0.0015080135,
0.039232038,
-0.0205725785,
-0.0343552753,
0.0250851493,
-0.0110199554,
0.0468307771,
0.0793775544,
-0.0131710097,
0.0484661199,
0.0083277607,
-0.0593453906,
-0.043168027,
0.04292766,
-0.0291947387,
0.0199902691,
-0.0141382543,
0.0005454238,
-0.0115266051,
0.0456093736,
0.0150464587,
-0.0003434558,
-0.0543004349,
-0.0265887901,
0.0137411701,
-0.009090296,
-0.0146175353,
-0.0031019642,
-0.0232771691,
0.0249199476,
-0.039067544,
0.0161459614,
0.0925888792,
0.0033714487,
-0.002209466,
-0.0320480168,
0.0130770151,
-0.0480334722,
0.0700127929,
-0.0338038318,
-0.0026085156,
-0.0148134194,
-0.0476842523,
-0.0345476866,
0.0141569721,
0.0387930498,
0.0220786091,
0.0255053304,
-0.0609022118,
0.0130079817,
-0.020318307,
-0.0193982646,
-0.0415984131,
-0.0667421967,
0.000762078,
-0.0263812523,
-0.0358126871,
0.0061017177,
-0.0482377447,
-0.0139035331,
0.0161436256,
0.0349613838,
0.0008569939,
-0.008537895,
-0.0258595981,
0.070946835,
0.0227018576,
0.054278668,
0.00711306,
-0.023396004,
-0.0015151784,
0.0506633855,
0.0423768237,
-0.0112719601,
-0.0131434631,
0.0419715904,
0.0023829124,
-0.0224014074,
0.0033951141,
0.0105177397,
0.0915683508,
-0.0613192171,
-0.0057433662,
0.0543549769,
0.024611894,
-0.0012897848,
0.0213630497,
0.0105943382,
0.0265799947,
0.0012825353,
-0.0011123089,
-0.0650890395,
-0.0643311217,
-0.0049301484,
-0.048456762,
-0.0088349693,
-0.082221821,
-0.0113400817,
-0.0676738769,
0.0115012787,
-0.0237605385,
-0.0740379095,
-0.0296337623,
-0.0235684682,
0.058036346,
-0.0149445068,
-0.0165838357,
0.0113430452,
0.0177703276,
-0.006902284,
-0.0195194837,
-0.0162295084,
-0.0821291283,
0.0416472033,
-0.0407387987,
0.0101088956,
0.0017385758,
0.0428136438,
0.0268243905,
0.0065627997,
-0.0061007543,
-0.0539898872,
-0.0262274668,
-0.0072211702,
-0.0120008988,
-0.0079242429,
-0.0050571635,
-0.0265627578,
0.1102803051,
-0.0525374375,
-0.0747692809,
0.0022012873,
0.0743267313,
0.005457764,
-0.0232162941,
-0.0048189005,
0.036127571,
0.0243245121,
0.0881233737,
0.0355373286,
0.0332940221,
-0.0362708941,
0.0125699146,
-0.0036417372,
-0.0735637844,
-0.0010486962,
0.0148001555,
0.0130588999,
-0.0263261199,
-0.0168716721,
-0.0512947105,
0.0260521229,
0.0338045359,
-0.0153852524,
0.0070544826,
0.0274799429,
0.0198231582,
-0.016132094,
0.0848401263,
-0.0493524857,
-0.0040029953,
0.0414307788,
0.0279975198,
0.013001442,
0.0446783826,
-0.0452163927,
0.1030083895,
-0.0620243102,
-0.0338873863,
-0.0511819273,
0.0115139447,
0.0151466941,
0.0425054468,
-0.0419489518,
-0.0115428139,
-0.0447783954,
0.0053917207,
-0.0503768809,
-0.0053856019,
0.0160132069,
0.0244978629,
0.0034895828,
0.0652510449,
0.0036718179,
0.0180013869,
-0.0255799647,
0.0894452631,
-0.0583059564,
-0.048821006,
-0.0054563303,
-0.0429586396,
0.0087843249,
-0.0111551899,
0.0216864515,
-0.0472102463,
-0.0015683153,
-0.0297310296,
-0.012345436,
-0.0132170022,
0.0290274024,
-0.0081645846,
-0.0237151124,
-0.0460196771,
-0.0066703507,
-0.0218670331,
0.0080211125,
-0.0163697544,
-0.0158951487,
0.0926081613,
0.0065364214,
0.0075917444,
-0.0448352695,
-0.044165507,
-0.0183491502,
-0.0415357724,
0.023778731,
-0.0139402356,
0.0411133282,
0.0732126608,
-0.0220575258,
0.0099050635,
-0.0360219143,
-0.0543466508,
0.0522979051,
0.0017405431,
0.0358737893,
0.0611636899,
-0.0001143452,
0.0419998914,
-0.0025203063,
0.0085791601,
0.022178879,
0.067167066,
-0.0083474601,
-0.0149069494,
0.0472364426,
0.0131000131,
0.0041901851,
0.0218456443,
0.0421804525,
-0.0707147196,
0.0614621229,
-0.006563839,
-0.0101220412,
-0.0331234969,
-0.0702043474,
-0.0210337061,
0.0483503528,
0.0165089909,
0.0361464918,
-0.0716933459,
-0.0113206403,
0.0270927548,
0.0234249029,
0.0118322819,
0.00402048,
-0.0072056125,
0.052008152,
0.0309766419,
-0.0618637763,
0.0170448888,
0.0153301619,
-0.0451418012,
-0.0294164661,
-0.0746952221,
-5.661231119e-33,
-0.0457707532,
-0.0244166553,
0.0151880626,
0.0117995497,
-0.0270116311,
-0.004644298,
-0.0689428076,
-0.0338424705,
-0.0313759223,
0.0285705365,
0.009784163,
0.0340335593,
0.0095799398,
0.0167893507,
-0.0077914875,
-0.0307505913,
0.0219500605,
0.0310956817,
-0.0312674493,
0.0194071587,
0.0504320972,
0.0093519539,
0.0679561719,
-0.0202427413,
-0.0105758281,
-0.0071721906,
-0.0103999153,
0.0470541976,
0.0129786115,
0.0270346999,
-0.0077263988,
0.0282186735,
0.0158183146,
-0.0152941784,
0.0225213245,
0.0320499986,
-0.1009388193,
-0.0521385297,
0.0577415712,
0.0140836975,
-0.0412302576,
-0.0331976041,
0.0102210362,
0.021696642,
0.0682560056,
-0.0107242353,
0.0367687941,
-0.0255530644,
0.0039217249,
-0.0315428376,
-0.0363878496,
0.0313355327,
-0.0167827625,
-0.0362467356,
-0.0400772206,
0.0308859795,
0.0065599578,
0.00223137,
-0.0253636036,
-0.0071581164,
-0.0350860842,
0.0145192342,
-0.007450297,
-0.0286888275,
-0.0178211983,
0.0547060035,
-0.0350507572,
-0.0287705623,
-0.0726615116,
0.0345324315,
0.0114129661,
0.0545259789,
-0.0057655661,
0.0870882645,
-0.0123354774,
0.0431982093,
-0.0751485825,
0.0426371694,
0.0450471751,
0.0368826799,
0.0101976851,
0.0028338113,
-0.0141323199,
-0.0005729771,
-0.0314872898,
-0.0184587277,
-0.0186135639,
0.0174785852,
0.0020511793,
-0.0324423872,
0.0095221605,
0.0636461899,
0.0351545177,
-0.0153777283,
-0.0078887641,
0.0282129757,
-0.0072663911,
-0.0134701747,
0.0058112596,
0.050602477,
-0.0202952195,
-0.0223099738,
0.0349073894,
-0.0019054917,
0.0388219431,
0.006859222,
0.0430078618,
-0.0347822346,
0.0232128296,
-0.0203659646,
-0.0291704368,
-0.0026284107,
-0.0607751235,
-0.0078313798,
0.0346258022,
0.0482561961,
-0.0071468884,
0.0232017692,
0.0007593057,
0.0347461514,
-0.0101994528,
-0.0009137461,
0.0145607023,
0.0284758862,
-0.0061983713,
-0.0008594135,
-0.0252660643,
-0.0304643791,
-0.0076154904,
-0.0445705615,
-0.0184685383,
0.0579707213,
2.162e-7,
0.0216886438,
0.0158322193,
0.0444553979,
0.0369523056,
-0.0135819437,
0.0379875787,
-0.0034197937,
0.0380447954,
-0.0000043472,
-0.0352350362,
-0.0002282607,
0.0594272241,
0.0373797342,
0.050543163,
-0.0527552702,
-0.0120133692,
-0.0661508217,
0.0026378979,
-0.0558057129,
-0.0442992747,
0.1112580597,
0.0482899509,
0.0571072958,
-0.0122679984,
0.0147377905,
-0.0173295122,
0.0422710441,
0.0052969707,
-0.044731494,
0.0070651313,
-0.0173595548,
0.012616734,
-0.0175476242,
0.0552312098,
0.0009583131,
0.0056510875,
-0.007347838,
0.0631819218,
-0.0021532674,
-0.0224482547,
0.0007724459,
-0.0297290329,
0.0077398755,
-0.0071883164,
0.0817428231,
-0.0776394978,
-0.0155631509,
-0.0066903215,
-0.0167561285,
-0.0079072434,
-0.0178179704,
0.0080773402,
-0.0227699112,
0.0175458025,
0.0233021267,
-0.024300389,
-0.0204539206,
-0.0888212845,
-0.0078561138,
0.0516710393,
-0.0408036709,
-0.0011512666,
-0.0047856583,
-0.0684185326,
0.0308416709,
-0.0797492117,
-0.0159519371,
1.533418146e-34,
-0.013157988,
-0.0007921202,
-0.0184886511,
0.0333620347,
0.0544963777,
-0.0190273859,
0.005894484,
-0.0097191958,
0.0337964594,
-0.0371553525,
-0.0075200899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14616v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14616v2 | Exploring Affordance and Situated Meaning in Image Captions: A Multimodal Analysis | 2023-05-24T01:30:50 | 2023-10-24T11:30:07 | Pin-Er Chen, Po-Ya Angela Wang, Hsin-Yu Chou, Yu-Hsiang Tseng, Shu-Kai Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper explores the grounding issue regarding multimodal semantic
representation from a computational cognitive-linguistic view. We annotate
images from the Flickr30k dataset with five perceptual properties: Affordance,
Perceptual Salience, Object Number, Gaze Cueing, and Ecological Niche
Association (ENA), and examine their association with textual elements in the
image captions. Our findings reveal that images with Gibsonian affordance show
a higher frequency of captions containing 'holding-verbs' and 'container-nouns'
compared to images displaying telic affordance. Perceptual Salience, Object
Number, and ENA are also associated with the choice of linguistic expressions.
Our study demonstrates that comprehensive understanding of objects or events
requires cognitive attention, semantic nuances in language, and integration
across multiple modalities. We highlight the vital importance of situated
meaning and affordance grounding in natural language understanding, with the
potential to advance human-like interpretation in various scenarios. | [
0.0067506665,
0.0297381356,
-0.0528554097,
0.0222454388,
0.0205948595,
0.0070421598,
-0.0096155992,
-0.0046423697,
-0.0174760222,
-0.0818986967,
-0.0388963073,
0.0176086202,
0.0401657261,
0.0170317534,
0.0230736546,
-0.0549720526,
-0.0189501904,
0.0283619948,
-0.0108550647,
0.0276433118,
0.0070839976,
0.0245610103,
-0.0067004031,
0.0341571383,
-0.0449338034,
-0.0034387226,
0.00292107,
0.0103422683,
0.0108971521,
-0.0641222149,
-0.023166189,
0.0397552773,
0.0384928547,
-0.0309403092,
0.0000017736,
-0.0349537991,
0.0543644726,
-0.0286034606,
0.027409954,
-0.0061713778,
0.0476302803,
-0.0315276869,
0.0360019915,
-0.0491143577,
-0.0254241172,
0.0028555472,
0.0867598057,
0.0156991724,
-0.0078348462,
-0.0337276906,
-0.0278381314,
-0.0333455242,
-0.0002165819,
0.02631782,
0.0065595689,
0.0365740992,
-0.0097143911,
0.0466799438,
0.0070468578,
-0.0085302489,
-0.082540445,
0.0291182362,
-0.002511549,
-0.0044265641,
0.030135164,
0.0575023666,
-0.0180766471,
-0.0638294816,
0.0027217439,
0.0570220537,
0.0572007485,
0.0049618655,
-0.0277703516,
-0.0005900278,
-0.0108594541,
0.0394216366,
-0.0472038239,
0.0626062527,
0.0018705745,
0.0328930318,
-0.005420527,
0.0193231665,
-0.0323904008,
0.0314534642,
0.0219813976,
0.0422037691,
-0.0010591518,
0.0378136225,
-0.0272124317,
0.0035316146,
-0.0330288485,
-0.0382869393,
0.0109082023,
0.010403147,
0.0573881492,
0.0311469361,
-0.0250165425,
-0.0443002358,
0.0249460358,
-0.0160903055,
0.0165221542,
0.0007179628,
-0.0841034204,
0.0399589315,
0.0090632625,
0.0175842624,
-0.0120369494,
-0.0201447345,
-0.0159523245,
0.0516733304,
-0.0239784345,
-0.029711809,
-0.0051049325,
0.0116744386,
-0.0581997111,
-0.0601189062,
0.0295602027,
0.0031109015,
0.0103745079,
-0.0309838671,
-0.0770394802,
0.044461783,
-0.0300463308,
0.0321771763,
-0.0216490291,
0.0283117332,
-0.0232563857,
0.0466220416,
-0.0651491061,
-0.0721902698,
0.0150789451,
0.0290167592,
0.0204789024,
-0.0385852046,
-0.0400376692,
0.0025771004,
-0.0067257634,
-0.0508662201,
-0.0054239538,
-0.052900549,
-0.0349861793,
0.0070037763,
-0.0088885212,
-0.0273995772,
0.0207741,
0.0217758957,
0.0144768329,
-0.0630179048,
0.0091145281,
0.0282418765,
-0.0127193145,
0.0806467086,
0.0061641345,
0.0071733054,
0.0245145168,
-0.0014456423,
-0.0021160641,
0.0431841165,
0.0218722131,
0.015272568,
0.0263229292,
-0.0088368077,
-0.0382038057,
-0.0176270436,
-0.0163699742,
0.000509683,
-0.0005742286,
-0.0096242595,
-0.0027442677,
0.0009022467,
0.0520886816,
0.0031045426,
-0.0024831186,
0.0143178152,
0.1163027659,
0.1102614105,
-0.0457104966,
-0.0041428711,
-0.0227521081,
0.0121567016,
-0.0044208905,
0.014439906,
-0.0427933671,
0.0812722445,
0.0142724039,
-0.00046629,
0.0016855899,
0.0050040018,
-0.0131025137,
0.0034970951,
-0.0301679466,
0.0238025188,
0.0260069575,
-0.0710768551,
0.0043574506,
-0.000598231,
0.0106593166,
0.0153293703,
0.0163344927,
-0.0648500919,
-0.0125144348,
0.0056799743,
0.0057513411,
0.015355939,
-0.0217462182,
0.0152018564,
-0.0125681572,
-0.0135617424,
0.0547130033,
0.0774985775,
-0.0320891775,
0.0410509892,
-0.0207353495,
-0.0067839855,
-0.0055866935,
-0.049296245,
0.0135621615,
0.0061149029,
-0.0924991071,
0.0481931157,
0.0005404441,
0.0063920179,
-0.029433446,
0.0278956145,
0.06830699,
0.0005267545,
-0.075929895,
0.0429858416,
-0.0184334815,
0.0019381751,
0.0043003988,
0.0175782051,
-0.0277463421,
0.0047092922,
0.0224711187,
0.0911222473,
-0.0263887383,
0.0102246078,
0.0147523647,
-0.1133212596,
-0.0223802142,
-0.0165399592,
0.0191955138,
-0.027546702,
0.0454447046,
-0.0710198879,
0.0304752439,
-0.0515927486,
-0.0328661576,
-0.0203226879,
0.0476138778,
0.0259024799,
0.0504416525,
-0.0114907483,
0.0035167073,
-0.0511394106,
-0.0092075737,
0.0171092767,
-0.0290432274,
-0.0173647311,
-0.012985263,
0.0217001792,
0.0099493619,
0.0172803812,
-0.0151416026,
-0.080571644,
0.0368468203,
-0.1021228656,
-0.0247393977,
-0.0172111429,
-0.009505148,
0.030884631,
-0.0451009944,
0.0035466799,
-0.0257247109,
0.018577693,
0.0006062785,
-0.0623837225,
0.0547286868,
0.0403829813,
-0.0003830093,
-0.0127802789,
-0.0077707986,
0.0057378821,
-0.0236075614,
0.0879682004,
0.037223503,
-0.0477208085,
0.0040902724,
-0.0095783239,
-0.033719182,
-0.0392276645,
0.0011304751,
-0.0151179181,
0.0421028063,
0.0346279927,
0.0211313758,
0.032483831,
-0.0005392875,
0.0775469542,
0.0309514627,
-0.0340228155,
-0.0138347922,
-0.0288346764,
0.0293941107,
-0.0366006643,
0.0454456881,
-0.0374362394,
0.0138927093,
0.0264772549,
0.0010307677,
0.0212532599,
-0.045985464,
0.0420571566,
-0.0263894051,
-0.0638880208,
-0.0385076702,
-0.0015927167,
-0.0108602,
0.0657610521,
-0.0351049565,
-0.0309784599,
0.01937861,
0.0238643028,
-0.0461146459,
0.0076530599,
0.0164293405,
0.0091888309,
0.0900215805,
0.0241075363,
0.0344692953,
0.035055548,
-0.0659336597,
-0.0099440785,
-0.0152057242,
0.0249463618,
-0.0018379705,
0.0658951402,
-0.0220240559,
-0.0071592699,
0.0117780278,
-0.008439878,
0.0033856248,
-0.0079842154,
-0.0266904403,
-0.0174313579,
-0.0458391607,
0.0296536945,
0.0021348675,
0.0103433719,
0.0280831698,
-0.0268375073,
0.0144053278,
-0.0059641162,
-0.0075896839,
0.0203341115,
0.0454272889,
0.0274182949,
-0.0383653454,
0.0043340274,
-0.0162421614,
0.0282091945,
-0.0484895371,
-0.0097643416,
-0.0433710925,
0.0539291836,
0.0144415088,
-0.008707759,
-0.050647065,
0.0020271575,
0.056256257,
-0.0167424027,
0.0207922123,
0.0400218368,
0.0191234089,
-0.0234742053,
0.0262288135,
-0.0284517258,
-0.0040025087,
0.0552693829,
-0.0109322602,
-0.0321202949,
-0.0126839643,
-0.0309705101,
-0.0511763468,
0.0158968866,
-0.0523221605,
-0.0297923256,
-0.0788371041,
0.0420273431,
-0.0203109253,
-0.0944911316,
-0.0285965949,
-0.0369509086,
0.0312972814,
0.0348376706,
-0.0057540103,
0.0117973341,
-0.0349804237,
0.0287865214,
0.0285679568,
0.0482952967,
0.0161069352,
-0.0287932698,
-0.0389096811,
-0.0290890336,
-0.0401982814,
0.0424769484,
-0.0272254515,
-0.0542309657,
-0.0186847672,
-0.0194152463,
0.0303635541,
-0.00340131,
0.0309335925,
-0.0279587768,
-0.0327093303,
-0.0138818258,
0.0339408033,
0.0072375112,
-0.0601905957,
-0.0626088977,
0.0707316101,
-0.0149039766,
0.0333129913,
-0.0230827276,
0.0240957905,
0.0082899621,
0.0116507756,
0.0740801916,
-0.0265555829,
0.0131996321,
0.0045602904,
-0.0007816202,
0.0211969782,
-0.0205505341,
0.0233690497,
-0.0141103016,
-0.0452181436,
-0.0708082393,
-0.0230029505,
0.0273291357,
0.0108535187,
0.0280474294,
-0.0305710603,
0.0067472258,
0.0099794306,
-0.0754777119,
0.0838177204,
0.0053065452,
-0.0150241135,
0.0294562113,
0.0037336906,
0.0778487548,
-0.0561907589,
-0.0138131296,
0.0198887549,
0.0247100387,
-0.0463571064,
0.0052537494,
0.018386703,
0.0143681355,
-0.0252033044,
0.0576641187,
-0.0428748503,
0.0090090577,
0.044389911,
-0.0007062716,
0.0333530232,
-0.0144367842,
0.0046971152,
0.000022268,
0.0296494402,
-0.0233751107,
-0.0018702658,
-0.0089368001,
0.0312574133,
-0.016163554,
-0.0144261662,
-0.0013544931,
-0.019611463,
0.0455284342,
-0.0394867547,
0.0356899798,
-0.0372221954,
-0.0407420471,
0.0156047177,
0.0008050116,
-0.0005184762,
0.0140530122,
-0.0123417061,
0.0623215809,
-0.0371150412,
-0.0278902445,
-0.0002618781,
0.0355538428,
0.0100250803,
0.0347267464,
0.040676564,
-0.0824261457,
-0.0462525375,
0.0419482253,
-0.0084135476,
0.0132173486,
-0.0377780758,
0.0293394197,
-0.0013775413,
0.0613435395,
0.0286467727,
-0.0276546627,
-0.0599217117,
0.0451075956,
0.0398786068,
0.0199158341,
0.0265795216,
0.0213454627,
0.0519363321,
-0.0784832314,
0.0274038073,
-0.0336035006,
-0.0065047257,
0.0362253673,
0.0207212791,
0.0158255734,
-0.0828163251,
0.0698876604,
0.0199504532,
0.0070470241,
0.0141845215,
0.0131138209,
-0.0790551901,
0.0152212409,
0.0356850736,
-0.0285235159,
0.004846348,
0.0265446249,
0.020850556,
0.0024036716,
-0.0011743117,
0.0504047312,
-0.0469833016,
-0.0781100392,
0.0173511989,
-0.0004838661,
0.0277605876,
0.0366706215,
0.075626336,
0.0267991759,
0.0364221297,
-0.0097820573,
-0.0165708382,
-0.0022421777,
-0.0579368919,
0.0480612107,
-0.0339551307,
-5.878882347e-33,
-0.0338890702,
-0.0582301207,
-0.0153890243,
0.0612798631,
-0.0224038791,
0.0149694681,
-0.0632021353,
0.0352051631,
0.014244305,
0.0544852726,
0.0111447107,
-0.0182457156,
0.0003973026,
0.0219036713,
0.0385049433,
-0.0179186705,
-0.0073523154,
0.0072585708,
-0.0303267781,
-0.0205662902,
0.0756718218,
-0.012288468,
0.0679687038,
-0.036757648,
-0.0000182257,
0.0407893546,
0.0058420645,
-0.0001197435,
0.0513623767,
0.056542743,
-0.0410276204,
0.0698396713,
0.0383893885,
-0.0168245565,
0.0111208847,
0.0671223998,
-0.0244841594,
-0.0644516051,
0.0829402506,
0.0497061573,
-0.0304914787,
-0.0170738604,
0.023488367,
-0.0346192159,
-0.0227974467,
0.0039438331,
0.0588401183,
-0.0099699199,
0.0126386704,
-0.0114207789,
-0.0527995192,
-0.0193854943,
-0.0286140125,
-0.0148126762,
0.0432212427,
-0.0339536592,
0.0090785082,
0.039379213,
-0.0424208902,
0.0351462178,
-0.0806470439,
0.0009998444,
0.0732553527,
0.0408479534,
0.0186248291,
0.0464770235,
-0.0341828018,
0.0073046084,
-0.059966132,
0.0435552411,
0.0432053916,
0.0449550264,
-0.0011898347,
-0.0126298917,
0.0056244195,
0.0140404841,
0.004854904,
-0.0057780743,
-0.0597478077,
0.0710087344,
0.0299168304,
0.0393672548,
-0.0108999945,
0.0314515866,
-0.0535085388,
-0.0573200397,
-0.0529142097,
-0.0129237594,
-0.0075840177,
-0.065110296,
-0.0318510681,
0.0364784189,
0.0476250798,
-0.020104859,
-0.0189848952,
-0.0492812246,
-0.0007206034,
0.056799721,
-0.0030885616,
-0.0145497499,
0.0343054794,
-0.0168115124,
0.0151038636,
0.0366072245,
0.0747933611,
-0.0090718167,
0.0217717644,
-0.0079230247,
-0.0149832042,
-0.026637312,
-0.0063046915,
-0.059945818,
-0.0046491027,
-0.0238964017,
0.0518192463,
0.0380339026,
-0.0670385435,
-0.0040012384,
0.0189426877,
0.0073649166,
-0.0321016796,
-0.0438893326,
-0.0583844446,
0.0151667083,
-0.0472889394,
0.023163734,
-0.0278769992,
0.0204789303,
0.0543104969,
-0.0621680133,
-0.0379555263,
0.0482954197,
2.673e-7,
0.0607944168,
0.060126882,
0.0008157326,
-0.00019787,
0.0365773514,
0.0237475727,
-0.0050956374,
0.0555607192,
-0.0175651964,
-0.086059697,
0.0067340615,
0.0120408945,
-0.001352063,
-0.0227372218,
-0.0322742537,
-0.0048008002,
-0.0324860699,
0.0135240117,
-0.0509393029,
0.0197229255,
0.0547616296,
0.016839087,
-0.0189924072,
0.0032686323,
-0.0209676381,
-0.058889538,
0.0236231014,
-0.0260614585,
0.044223126,
-0.0405630022,
-0.01057842,
-0.0037556475,
-0.0318299383,
0.0163968988,
-0.002670032,
-0.0108439066,
0.0881648436,
-0.03196235,
-0.0278571844,
0.0019240853,
-0.0320797786,
0.0216312036,
-0.023151217,
-0.0611410029,
0.0626483113,
-0.0497844368,
-0.0489227138,
0.0108128712,
-0.0250168089,
0.005791741,
0.0292071607,
-0.0425161421,
-0.0554957539,
0.0198363401,
0.0060994918,
-0.0205742233,
-0.0314831249,
-0.0674581677,
0.0015720875,
0.031151507,
0.0109620336,
-0.0034526081,
-0.0129049337,
-0.0257508904,
0.0607595332,
-0.0314687304,
-0.042953752,
1.435451368e-34,
0.0025145169,
-0.031541802,
0.0515710264,
-0.0028800648,
-0.0086592343,
-0.0029932654,
-0.0115346517,
0.0058188476,
0.0270032063,
-0.0589219704,
-0.0063599553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14613v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14613v2 | Selectively Answering Ambiguous Questions | 2023-05-24T01:25:38 | 2023-11-15T02:15:02 | Jeremy R. Cole, Michael J. Q. Zhang, Daniel Gillick, Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Bhuwan Dhingra, Jacob Eisenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Trustworthy language models should abstain from answering questions when they
do not know the answer. However, the answer to a question can be unknown for a
variety of reasons. Prior research has focused on the case in which the
question is clear and the answer is unambiguous but possibly unknown, but the
answer to a question can also be unclear due to uncertainty of the questioner's
intent or context. We investigate question answering from this perspective,
focusing on answering a subset of questions with a high degree of accuracy,
from a set of questions in which many are inherently ambiguous. In this
setting, we find that the most reliable approach to decide when to abstain
involves quantifying repetition within sampled model outputs, rather than the
model's likelihood or self-verification as used in prior work. We find this to
be the case across different types of uncertainty and model scales,and with or
without instruction tuning. Our results suggest that sampling-based confidence
scores help calibrate answers to relatively unambiguous questions, with more
dramatic improvements on ambiguous questions. | [
0.09328679,
0.0507357083,
-0.0246485192,
-0.0019426822,
-0.0168538559,
0.0076102237,
-0.0112479832,
0.0052589085,
0.0106731066,
-0.0369356237,
-0.0110821407,
-0.0617235154,
-0.02382176,
0.0170473456,
0.0222153757,
-0.0253351014,
0.055778861,
-0.0343847871,
0.029470047,
-0.0201575458,
0.0055483952,
0.0034730118,
0.0211065654,
-0.0026307318,
-0.0111616747,
-0.0204260368,
-0.0060405121,
0.0110818548,
-0.021201035,
0.0049661235,
0.0379711576,
0.0404131524,
-0.0021293089,
0.0342020169,
0.00000183,
-0.0367687382,
-0.0039680754,
-0.0155469803,
-0.0575672239,
0.0012593634,
-0.0055490709,
0.0204165559,
0.0539657362,
0.0477865934,
-0.0420144796,
0.0115910973,
0.0415099487,
0.0068081678,
0.0381276198,
0.0334601589,
0.032814879,
0.0376383178,
0.0048658634,
-0.02491083,
0.0196326915,
-0.0613901988,
0.0141346604,
0.0137770893,
-0.019826211,
0.0474831052,
-0.02373413,
0.0615499839,
0.0398124158,
-0.0027066246,
-0.014389907,
0.0235628337,
-0.0170727316,
-0.0257146303,
-0.0121755721,
0.037638925,
0.018841438,
-0.0313827097,
-0.0150634535,
-0.0369073115,
0.0125354575,
0.0334707126,
-0.0385718122,
0.0248025414,
0.0042394637,
-0.0339953452,
-0.034949109,
0.0217808131,
0.0049020508,
0.0212056804,
0.0212265309,
0.0772895738,
-0.0031848268,
-0.025033392,
0.0329858214,
-0.0011699178,
-0.0591135845,
-0.0874685124,
0.0091430796,
0.0758966953,
-0.052584935,
0.0378352664,
-0.0302393846,
-0.0043228106,
0.0554081649,
0.0022348282,
0.0087838266,
0.0431564935,
0.0023914962,
0.0453349464,
0.0034514985,
0.0212460998,
-0.0007935773,
0.008635927,
-0.0322550684,
-0.0340088308,
-0.0185332224,
-0.0528430305,
-0.0715125278,
0.0415944904,
-0.0189653561,
-0.0019616007,
-0.0160623137,
0.0334864035,
-0.0183105525,
0.025020007,
0.007295467,
0.0455585048,
-0.0628548637,
-0.0132321725,
-0.0379665866,
0.0242463574,
-0.0616066791,
0.0505541675,
0.0098726684,
-0.0858963728,
-0.024239039,
-0.0107390918,
-0.0162053723,
-0.0193846226,
0.0070566381,
0.0266686771,
-0.0081681842,
-0.0285704285,
0.0060821068,
-0.0435056649,
-0.0488830209,
-0.0639308691,
-0.0306949057,
-0.0501735285,
0.0059402161,
0.0278511569,
-0.0053961142,
-0.028555287,
0.0123253707,
0.0189958196,
-0.0255282447,
0.0600802451,
0.020600887,
0.0297084544,
0.0105928015,
0.0077095041,
-0.0347991548,
0.0587736964,
0.0386552885,
0.019091038,
0.0511178561,
0.0023322995,
0.0441816673,
-0.0027139995,
0.0321084224,
-0.0059246053,
0.0149549032,
0.058014743,
-0.0431905761,
-0.0082164183,
0.0044958661,
0.0753193647,
-0.0163329076,
-0.0655635074,
0.0532817878,
0.0161757432,
-0.054384917,
-0.0459727161,
0.0402773432,
0.0072914399,
0.0398739502,
0.0436503477,
-0.0692251325,
0.0269662533,
-0.0176244192,
0.0231072847,
0.0019762467,
-0.0057058246,
-0.044287689,
-0.0575990416,
-0.0144214556,
0.0065162289,
0.0224580579,
0.0837986991,
0.0329788439,
0.017663382,
-0.0135729164,
0.0532532632,
-0.0073366696,
-0.0208033603,
0.0095469328,
-0.0407205559,
0.0847194418,
0.0018451993,
0.0355845541,
-0.0011289344,
-0.0519012325,
-0.0288935453,
0.0464171395,
0.0095554125,
0.0734707341,
-0.0205416977,
0.0741324648,
-0.0049605747,
-0.0065954961,
-0.0118407197,
0.0231794976,
-0.0189513583,
0.0516539551,
0.0071801669,
0.0073509789,
-0.0955600217,
0.017463835,
0.0188422166,
0.0051910761,
-0.0228395052,
0.0103853811,
-0.026169382,
0.0316117592,
-0.0109475311,
0.0126475627,
0.0318800807,
0.0398146771,
0.0241419133,
-0.041364599,
-0.054334946,
-0.0326316208,
-0.0013562103,
0.0250622183,
0.0015044009,
-0.0786226839,
0.0388196856,
-0.0326982327,
-0.046117831,
-0.0167227853,
-0.0400635973,
0.0028005948,
-0.0630339533,
-0.004495108,
-0.0062374142,
-0.0092819044,
-0.0600921847,
0.0425310507,
-0.0083533321,
0.0501984432,
-0.0103888391,
0.021696711,
0.0124423457,
-0.0447544679,
-0.0272460785,
-0.0237861946,
-0.0191326868,
0.0075126244,
0.0542960167,
-0.0056793788,
-0.0502239726,
-0.0433069691,
-0.0404497981,
0.0045626806,
-0.0217096396,
0.0104975272,
0.0232457276,
0.0142268864,
-0.0018182999,
-0.0484470613,
-0.044347927,
0.0085972073,
0.0269272141,
0.0287052281,
0.0127824936,
-0.0046117245,
0.0229513831,
-0.0415888354,
-0.0032094177,
-0.0000329842,
0.0033957108,
-0.0096803922,
0.002749139,
-0.0566295199,
0.0283285584,
-0.0399109684,
0.0226441156,
0.0073831314,
-0.0218652841,
0.0111966133,
0.0272582639,
-0.0403308682,
0.0597275682,
0.0028979946,
0.0011558275,
0.0495635606,
-0.0050663701,
-0.0637772232,
0.0410771556,
-0.0440841801,
-0.043186564,
-0.0035262166,
-0.0606202632,
0.0017535629,
0.0430879183,
0.034041293,
-0.025945494,
-0.0385468826,
0.0062927608,
-0.0325281061,
-0.0467432737,
-0.0210437961,
-0.0249891765,
-0.0186570752,
0.0705275983,
-0.0098464508,
-0.0472539328,
0.0910731778,
-0.0016238402,
-0.0135778654,
-0.0548246093,
0.0175398774,
-0.0032258346,
0.0469223671,
-0.0020557805,
0.002527727,
0.0405857526,
-0.0229034144,
-0.0640875474,
-0.0593596771,
0.0306914989,
-0.0438740999,
0.037767332,
-0.040734183,
0.0065575009,
-0.0023825085,
-0.0119003085,
-0.0739889666,
-0.0398666374,
-0.0184759609,
0.0142086083,
-0.0167343915,
0.0101333708,
-0.0005482406,
0.0086754514,
0.0204521455,
-0.0006283066,
-0.0578355789,
-0.0293793324,
-0.0291039459,
0.0684651434,
0.0950420052,
0.0412538983,
0.0404692926,
-0.0255557038,
-0.0156916287,
0.0602654666,
0.0151207708,
0.0413116477,
-0.0285376571,
-0.0084267547,
0.051547844,
-0.015377203,
-0.0025496036,
0.0651474521,
0.0886649936,
-0.0312386435,
-0.0461861901,
0.1124261692,
0.0588136166,
0.0360417888,
-0.0094115129,
-0.0286736451,
0.0522458516,
0.0090472884,
0.0364850722,
-0.067504935,
-0.0320087485,
-0.0055294293,
0.0162320398,
-0.0292922892,
-0.0079243472,
-0.0138410889,
-0.0741963685,
0.0351931043,
-0.0104669482,
-0.0559855513,
-0.0323161632,
-0.0461422615,
0.0272333585,
-0.0031114779,
0.0432918184,
-0.0051573035,
-0.0147339394,
0.0115838507,
0.034433499,
0.0039866264,
-0.0281210821,
0.0359270349,
-0.0339465737,
0.0505402982,
0.0569165573,
0.003133703,
-0.0139890937,
0.0048447312,
-0.0031431806,
-0.0429718271,
-0.0393276773,
-0.0040858733,
0.0436311699,
0.0200787988,
0.0019001001,
0.0013592292,
0.0112443343,
-0.0099291764,
-0.0000268769,
0.014381269,
0.0396398641,
-0.0239215568,
-0.0324967839,
-0.0328449234,
-0.0098303063,
0.0112197222,
0.1127977222,
0.0395927913,
-0.0179624502,
-0.035230834,
-0.0180538893,
0.0232129507,
-0.023350371,
0.0295811221,
0.0398961231,
0.0194678046,
0.0154087106,
-0.048965726,
-0.0759054348,
0.0395000316,
-0.0015415754,
-0.0092835706,
0.0072996686,
0.0680685192,
-0.0040632738,
-0.019523222,
-0.0047110254,
-0.0504734442,
0.0333647765,
-0.0126556968,
0.012881415,
-0.0042928201,
-0.0198176652,
-0.0160128474,
0.0547404401,
-0.112843655,
-0.0358238257,
-0.0025206185,
0.0351994783,
0.032074742,
0.0030360103,
-0.0460247248,
-0.0592180379,
-0.0051989574,
-0.0129032265,
-0.0083304876,
0.0148026804,
0.0362419412,
0.0286713596,
-0.0099138869,
0.0642537549,
-0.0589843802,
0.0020796452,
0.0536169969,
0.0386845581,
-0.0421110503,
-0.06800282,
0.0364974439,
0.0071419198,
-0.0154261803,
0.025294954,
0.0363478251,
-0.0115283746,
0.0136972815,
0.014394707,
-0.0038320476,
-0.0426074602,
0.0109802922,
0.0233160127,
-0.0570502542,
-0.0210185554,
-0.0238408074,
-0.0336648896,
0.0587650985,
-0.0468004234,
-0.0548953041,
0.0217207596,
-0.0162383001,
-0.0065995185,
-0.0232962798,
-0.0422861092,
0.0195104554,
-0.0105237709,
0.0383281969,
0.0579312257,
0.036054343,
0.0092136525,
-0.0235918369,
-0.0325511023,
-0.0282803029,
-0.101552099,
-0.047144372,
-0.0042385692,
0.0232188497,
-0.0108226929,
0.0020507043,
0.0320580043,
-0.0206781961,
-0.0130193951,
-0.0265051331,
-0.0105027789,
0.0654609129,
-0.0024930972,
0.0788076371,
0.0330241174,
-0.0065097315,
0.0386316888,
0.0672181994,
-0.0080486787,
0.0515635349,
0.0003782644,
-0.0226116497,
-0.0237534214,
-0.01424307,
-0.0067579984,
0.0400462672,
-0.0059770425,
0.0344624296,
-0.0494403057,
-0.0653907135,
0.0235467516,
0.0196934137,
-0.0026682084,
-0.0406954736,
0.0208070818,
0.0749800205,
0.0369382687,
-0.0518630147,
-0.0409160592,
0.0246703289,
0.011897997,
0.0019067636,
-0.0727975443,
-6.464433552e-33,
-0.0160565618,
-0.0334217399,
-0.0127997659,
-0.0437762402,
0.0277625266,
0.0100924354,
-0.0458606891,
-0.0109702423,
-0.0718867257,
0.0112181455,
-0.048352357,
0.0274157133,
0.0192664005,
0.0396391414,
0.0175644383,
-0.0284968223,
0.0251254067,
0.0035626355,
-0.050069049,
0.008947066,
0.0191893075,
-0.019821208,
0.025832491,
-0.0284832306,
0.0615713894,
-0.0004910884,
-0.0279368702,
0.0392234735,
-0.0390424989,
0.0789216384,
-0.0268213339,
0.0464102924,
0.0012831495,
-0.0341053382,
-0.0234157853,
0.0009644578,
-0.1011874005,
-0.0807342529,
0.0541770458,
-0.0067173052,
-0.0787850246,
0.0115812737,
0.042015966,
-0.0195774306,
0.0096118553,
-0.0148298824,
-0.0024979005,
-0.0137231601,
-0.025624752,
-0.0431591235,
0.0069565447,
0.008464667,
0.0060946145,
-0.0486243591,
-0.0166490581,
0.0540564656,
-0.0164550729,
0.0091147833,
-0.0208504703,
-0.0141259627,
0.0369513072,
0.0313858762,
0.0202479642,
-0.0086533166,
-0.0185465477,
0.023739811,
-0.0191990621,
-0.0565752238,
0.0186866764,
-0.0291034412,
-0.0030557523,
-0.0051118862,
0.0489641614,
0.0525502414,
0.022103902,
0.0075811506,
-0.0434145108,
0.0112640532,
0.0266734567,
0.0458677448,
0.0365070216,
-0.0110111423,
-0.0470772348,
-0.0388836004,
-0.0788279325,
-0.0017860964,
-0.0411814451,
-0.0041574193,
0.0510362163,
0.0102282949,
-0.0302318241,
0.0292987078,
0.0451929383,
-0.0483310111,
-0.0253674667,
0.0081926659,
0.0025639429,
0.0192410853,
0.0501678512,
0.0732682422,
-0.0199958198,
0.0431464724,
0.0296909194,
-0.0402997285,
-0.0493313447,
0.0271244347,
0.0296391454,
0.0114116389,
-0.0578906722,
0.0163250491,
-0.0174886156,
0.0492898673,
-0.0222246293,
-0.0064085964,
0.0315791145,
0.0375720523,
-0.010251319,
0.0333931781,
-0.0300017577,
-0.0310937688,
-0.0456497148,
0.0202448945,
-0.0199659504,
0.0294233374,
-0.0381935351,
0.0036175782,
-0.020446483,
0.0040544905,
-0.0325902142,
-0.0348874964,
-0.0063012401,
0.04369146,
2.424e-7,
0.064370662,
-0.0034632978,
0.0018271621,
0.0802243203,
0.0046475544,
0.0237354785,
0.0022353386,
0.0176362395,
0.0434313565,
-0.0450429916,
-0.0246856716,
0.0109546436,
0.0347797908,
0.0435839333,
-0.0176107641,
0.0032419676,
-0.0338414051,
0.0284997988,
0.0227907076,
0.0131009603,
0.0412498899,
0.0921102688,
0.0095570674,
0.0037758101,
-0.0342739038,
-0.0347428136,
0.0499767177,
-0.0039962349,
0.0079892417,
0.0418641157,
0.0480754636,
0.0078759762,
0.0525698215,
0.0682551265,
-0.0138286306,
-0.0076308586,
0.0035664735,
0.0597673617,
0.0123566641,
-0.0289100092,
-0.0456941016,
-0.0350003913,
0.0482565239,
-0.0930146798,
0.0869984552,
-0.0672367141,
-0.0128022954,
-0.0155448327,
0.0119523574,
-0.0135570178,
0.0294261724,
0.0024491923,
-0.0181093067,
0.0123925172,
0.0255121719,
0.0398358926,
-0.0271930136,
-0.0403761603,
-0.0164090116,
-0.0612485781,
-0.0220211297,
-0.0533319823,
0.012649077,
0.0073218332,
0.0024204648,
-0.0883603469,
0.0013582914,
2.081054332e-34,
0.0543607622,
-0.0009455206,
-0.0019682371,
0.0284974743,
0.0090002306,
-0.0098276949,
-0.0223570615,
0.0040651751,
0.0397295691,
-0.054523427,
-0.0328532234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16338v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16338v3 | Think Before You Act: Decision Transformers with Working Memory | 2023-05-24T01:20:22 | 2024-05-28T19:03:33 | Jikun Kang, Romain Laroche, Xingdi Yuan, Adam Trischler, Xue Liu, Jie Fu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Decision Transformer-based decision-making agents have shown the ability to
generalize across multiple tasks. However, their performance relies on massive
data and computation. We argue that this inefficiency stems from the forgetting
phenomenon, in which a model memorizes its behaviors in parameters throughout
training. As a result, training on a new task may deteriorate the model's
performance on previous tasks. In contrast to LLMs' implicit memory mechanism,
the human brain utilizes distributed memory storage, which helps manage and
organize multiple skills efficiently, mitigating the forgetting phenomenon.
Inspired by this, we propose a working memory module to store, blend, and
retrieve information for different downstream tasks. Evaluation results show
that the proposed method improves training efficiency and generalization in
Atari games and Meta-World object manipulation tasks. Moreover, we demonstrate
that memory fine-tuning further enhances the adaptability of the proposed
architecture. | [
0.0130255157,
-0.0041188863,
-0.0279360097,
-0.0255970061,
0.0122997528,
0.0154839503,
-0.0124203544,
-0.0034903965,
-0.0213686638,
0.0039764182,
-0.0746339113,
-0.0034267802,
-0.0016588427,
0.0046751858,
0.0277251042,
-0.0565043017,
0.0361765511,
-0.0064671552,
-0.0376582146,
-0.0118441926,
-0.0546688959,
-0.0815131292,
-0.0204785522,
0.0315826684,
-0.0187658276,
-0.0113734202,
-0.0267605688,
-0.0373509154,
0.0431184247,
-0.0378697142,
0.0170044173,
-0.0063434364,
0.0431226604,
-0.001956074,
0.0000019545,
-0.0209885724,
0.0233275648,
-0.034730237,
-0.0249752533,
-0.0824496225,
-0.0102148,
0.0283687338,
-0.0182484761,
0.031533055,
-0.0527545623,
-0.0635359585,
0.0721734613,
0.0372240208,
0.0320910551,
0.0364488289,
-0.0040868293,
0.0020403406,
0.0157404467,
-0.0081836591,
0.0079962807,
0.000841825,
0.0222602021,
0.0116813295,
-0.0147475731,
-0.0202251486,
-0.0464527942,
-0.0043656309,
0.0488432683,
0.040450599,
0.0071183108,
0.0176119674,
0.0222409647,
-0.0180238504,
-0.0198722016,
-0.0283695012,
-0.0198476743,
-0.0080776419,
0.0056890207,
0.0146837784,
0.0557071716,
-0.0278610289,
-0.0197077245,
0.053229332,
-0.0297111534,
-0.0207429323,
-0.0678831413,
-0.0134269372,
0.0192806814,
-0.0187682882,
-0.009605932,
0.0117949601,
-0.0096386578,
-0.0175200254,
0.0548390262,
0.0079435324,
0.012166312,
-0.0127225704,
0.0173499789,
0.0610666648,
-0.048015438,
-0.0114676487,
-0.0207633283,
0.0163964517,
-0.0080137104,
-0.0443627499,
0.0547442511,
0.0158526693,
0.0055304626,
0.0084588164,
-0.0340484418,
0.0459207147,
-0.0480794385,
0.0236043762,
-0.0408655182,
0.0132800257,
-0.0946900398,
-0.0259671323,
-0.0101783145,
0.0676085651,
0.0075748782,
-0.018001467,
-0.0266382489,
0.04943664,
-0.0070364475,
0.0130955139,
0.0197393522,
0.0397530347,
0.0095302509,
0.0471766479,
-0.083655633,
0.0033599974,
-0.0275371168,
0.0226423033,
0.0359512269,
0.0275007058,
-0.0199195519,
-0.0138299409,
-0.0272053275,
0.0073078591,
0.0495341793,
0.1188696921,
-0.0189035553,
-0.0321496576,
-0.0575704202,
0.046648439,
0.0567737408,
-0.0194703154,
0.0780190006,
0.0016454358,
0.0238340478,
-0.0028904236,
-0.0147262095,
-0.0055900365,
-0.0016885402,
0.0049674949,
0.0136011401,
0.0374130495,
0.0145267993,
-0.0241444428,
0.0470281281,
-0.013286476,
-0.0448057912,
0.0137273353,
0.0596406385,
0.0261467732,
-0.0420328453,
0.0230421666,
0.0213476457,
0.0158659611,
-0.0392874554,
-0.0631973371,
0.0255567599,
-0.0404561199,
0.0028305142,
0.0085958168,
0.0120247994,
0.0150002744,
-0.042282775,
0.0018920868,
0.068446748,
0.0086027142,
0.0261960104,
0.0306586679,
-0.0070441584,
-0.0071580512,
0.0332581699,
-0.0191746429,
-0.0660065114,
0.1166358069,
0.0075218291,
-0.0113247111,
-0.0833519027,
0.0555537529,
-0.0372492671,
-0.0271232724,
0.0381387658,
-0.0255930144,
0.0043746582,
0.0132476874,
0.0223437827,
0.0102982894,
-0.0765965804,
0.0319799222,
-0.0142811872,
-0.0084632896,
-0.0242172629,
-0.0915168971,
0.0143372128,
0.0340868346,
0.016838422,
-0.0697274879,
-0.0184632223,
-0.0214531571,
-0.0118298549,
0.029033063,
-0.0288934633,
-0.0000886351,
0.0439880416,
-0.0236356985,
-0.0477789789,
-0.0179082621,
0.0076193311,
0.0479181223,
0.0689013302,
-0.0182053,
-0.0242898408,
0.0432323776,
0.0329978056,
0.0095126908,
-0.0086052502,
-0.0304391682,
0.0018757511,
-0.011662025,
0.0023034697,
-0.0472596325,
-0.0143402265,
-0.0228973962,
0.0210702308,
-0.0294878874,
-0.0262871813,
0.0288135614,
-0.0678030699,
0.0552869365,
0.001417422,
-0.0355347171,
0.0307456627,
0.0341257527,
0.0022511766,
-0.0490390249,
-0.0462146215,
0.0013341678,
0.0432694852,
0.0067512449,
0.0585922115,
0.0015401803,
-0.0244827215,
-0.0033884479,
0.0371419117,
-0.0246788766,
-0.0446597673,
-0.0656895563,
-0.0129350489,
-0.0059441775,
-0.0536400229,
0.0120180734,
0.0280374568,
-0.0065327007,
0.0241828207,
0.0102455663,
-0.043810565,
-0.041346807,
-0.0436235406,
-0.0105519556,
0.0113540841,
0.0190872047,
0.0050381268,
-0.013434533,
-0.0292263571,
0.0054020146,
-0.001153017,
-0.008344423,
0.0601433888,
-0.0021114398,
0.0220381115,
0.0249685682,
0.000865191,
0.013328542,
-0.017629046,
-0.0070836749,
0.0203201044,
-0.0069630677,
-0.022042511,
0.0075063012,
-0.039661929,
0.0451421104,
0.0082289511,
0.038199652,
-0.0219860021,
-0.0188256036,
0.0315837972,
-0.008682033,
0.0034240014,
0.0927948803,
0.0061289747,
-0.0041529271,
0.099702023,
-0.0000236945,
0.0060405303,
0.0191723909,
-0.0119551523,
-0.0342816971,
-0.0441269465,
0.0394523852,
-0.0057089385,
0.0587938316,
-0.0187295098,
0.0293369386,
-0.044260107,
-0.0410980843,
0.0043369578,
-0.080233112,
-0.0169612113,
0.0072448514,
-0.0307028648,
-0.0296763629,
-0.0443330333,
-0.0132645434,
0.0240008067,
0.0440318771,
0.0014773689,
0.0397761725,
0.0366846249,
0.0135888625,
0.0235612597,
0.0179096144,
-0.0154642519,
-0.0310226623,
-0.0100829909,
-0.0443178639,
-0.0320442766,
-0.0143106366,
-0.0308905113,
0.0147316502,
-0.0525068603,
-0.0347074978,
-0.014678767,
-0.0620311722,
-0.0585133098,
0.094739452,
-0.0095038982,
-0.0051314416,
0.031130556,
-0.0540994368,
-0.0955514684,
-0.0326850824,
0.0777110308,
0.0361223593,
-0.0238806847,
-0.0399678722,
-0.0205480289,
-0.0241604391,
0.0176390633,
0.062620014,
0.0261782985,
-0.0567313917,
0.0343677588,
0.0565974154,
0.0348781012,
-0.0181212071,
-0.0528333075,
0.0353649408,
0.0074771624,
-0.0180714168,
0.0058091884,
0.022275798,
0.0051486972,
-0.0355949327,
-0.0242055953,
0.0420543626,
0.0165028758,
-0.0351566561,
-0.0253458656,
-0.0582846366,
-0.0112253632,
0.0356330387,
0.0465986542,
0.0163686145,
-0.0281576253,
0.0039919303,
0.0081454068,
-0.0195806604,
-0.0073372172,
0.0387564339,
-0.0637419149,
0.0016085249,
-0.0134516824,
-0.0021787917,
-0.0098941103,
0.0064018071,
-0.0516729131,
-0.0257345606,
0.0024303482,
0.0150266569,
-0.0262200534,
-0.0357685126,
0.0504607297,
0.0131516391,
0.0069970605,
-0.0056416118,
-0.0102094337,
-0.0235306788,
0.063901417,
-0.0177586023,
-0.016702041,
-0.0488883741,
-0.0138390986,
0.0493319668,
0.0517581962,
-0.0141215362,
0.0595435686,
-0.0012041441,
-0.0124204857,
-0.0397633873,
-0.0142198065,
0.0197887588,
-0.0636097491,
0.0060353619,
0.0355125815,
-0.0282581747,
-0.0043565966,
0.0296445116,
-0.0414859802,
-0.0129059115,
0.046997346,
-0.0424986258,
-0.0377953276,
-0.0405283719,
0.0013638502,
-0.0067037377,
-0.0200190935,
-0.0348287225,
0.0091243228,
0.0315584727,
-0.028684238,
-0.0241928399,
0.0102671133,
0.0401465334,
0.0444939025,
0.0534977242,
-0.0525148548,
0.0277274679,
0.0380224176,
-0.0688667521,
-0.0299396366,
-0.0017022477,
-0.0177565031,
-0.0697550848,
-0.0191668831,
0.0490787365,
-0.0591010191,
0.0030795678,
-0.003655066,
-0.061765112,
0.0160264317,
0.0427755825,
0.1076068431,
0.0272379182,
0.0003270269,
0.0427133217,
0.0061321207,
0.0441488549,
0.0622518882,
0.0213193651,
0.06314224,
0.0594250299,
-0.0041147727,
0.0003834501,
-0.0057611889,
-0.0520533323,
0.0019048312,
0.023419017,
0.0050947834,
-0.0386687666,
0.0982307494,
0.0130290547,
-0.049823124,
0.0373375341,
-0.031923946,
0.0060228598,
-0.0197827499,
0.035547886,
0.032773681,
0.0556630716,
-0.0424233153,
-0.0040083919,
0.032636378,
0.041551847,
0.0339150764,
0.0230971593,
0.0633632243,
-0.0509489626,
0.0301851742,
0.0023264361,
0.0188419577,
0.0087603284,
-0.0371296816,
0.0373020731,
-0.0027435541,
-0.0065149898,
0.0094501618,
0.0306432489,
0.0155292358,
0.0627917424,
-0.0040250015,
-0.0285044927,
-0.0643061474,
0.0506157987,
-0.0628143176,
-0.080600597,
0.0267237946,
0.025103908,
0.0417168811,
-0.0417692773,
-0.019421326,
-0.0211079232,
0.0347084813,
-0.0169150308,
-0.0427954197,
0.0130458251,
0.0338177532,
-0.0127398679,
0.0322728269,
0.0039068488,
-0.0425388105,
0.0335231274,
-0.0295695588,
0.0651289895,
-0.052178748,
0.01021419,
-0.0304171089,
-0.0703961775,
0.026926497,
-0.0129299713,
-0.0122562787,
-0.0600694567,
-0.0446606353,
-0.012566803,
-0.0300691258,
0.0396998264,
0.0351986736,
-0.0404466316,
0.0133752422,
0.0021667052,
-0.0094735334,
-0.071845673,
0.013135287,
-0.0621065572,
0.0642672032,
0.0474397652,
-0.0052638911,
-5.866877979e-33,
-0.0010081438,
0.0353951491,
0.0696625412,
-0.024818182,
0.0034809001,
-0.026489554,
-0.0273254514,
-0.0133974478,
-0.0104727987,
-0.0225359984,
-0.0209063031,
0.0156208249,
0.0194844827,
-0.0078970548,
0.0648297668,
-0.0364449024,
0.0373653285,
0.0156635474,
-0.0290439297,
0.004218075,
0.0530249439,
0.0459814221,
0.0447616763,
-0.0164567418,
-0.0561020337,
0.0521346405,
-0.0004703953,
0.0090437932,
-0.0293374192,
0.0179968849,
-0.014788894,
-0.0259563439,
0.0211985633,
-0.062621057,
-0.015930919,
0.0067550945,
-0.0893176347,
0.0056435424,
-0.0255181286,
-0.0056271278,
0.0115927178,
-0.025137987,
0.0294449944,
0.019417692,
-0.0386916175,
-0.0013336705,
0.0226243846,
-0.0469283015,
-0.018519409,
0.0088891238,
-0.0176269971,
-0.0330046974,
0.0285915453,
-0.0214721151,
0.0021141965,
0.0434103198,
-0.0318808667,
0.0042465245,
-0.0900537074,
0.038538564,
-0.0367064327,
-0.0101019368,
0.0061609824,
0.0864273161,
0.0456119403,
0.0659831315,
0.0366598368,
-0.0108822053,
-0.0190078765,
0.001255052,
0.0098030763,
0.0529918037,
0.0120425392,
-0.0250342973,
0.083140865,
-0.0442703813,
-0.0221737176,
0.0208009128,
-0.0109923184,
0.0877865255,
0.0073843556,
-0.0024101133,
0.0016990829,
-0.0036926868,
0.0183252264,
0.0294639841,
-0.0033300766,
-0.0091846269,
0.0280941352,
0.0332939029,
0.00982673,
0.0050352267,
0.0181936175,
-0.0123692779,
0.0527897365,
0.0099797798,
0.021225607,
0.0381653495,
-0.016498372,
-0.0313126706,
-0.0427475199,
-0.0606490038,
-0.0083725024,
0.0102607412,
0.0042655673,
0.0513224229,
-0.0068159672,
0.0650166571,
-0.0205676202,
-0.015691027,
-0.0377516821,
0.0198147297,
0.056349095,
-0.0348956622,
0.0015117754,
0.0201952048,
-0.0031797928,
-0.0279045142,
-0.0700023696,
-0.0335733294,
-0.0269839317,
-0.0061730668,
-0.0257845223,
0.0547604971,
0.0541376136,
-0.0021167351,
-0.0668943077,
0.0625258833,
-0.0146952122,
-0.078927435,
0.0135653401,
0.0029296582,
2.86e-7,
-0.0462507047,
0.0007567917,
-0.018860532,
-0.0032329825,
0.0086907046,
0.028715089,
-0.0338721685,
0.0028028626,
0.0457485691,
-0.0214497559,
0.0224042162,
0.1092615277,
0.0187341478,
-0.0145939151,
-0.0684907362,
-0.0938258618,
0.0571781397,
-0.011602262,
0.0001300027,
0.0269728377,
0.0024189146,
0.0599162281,
0.0629254803,
-0.0192100592,
0.0314314961,
-0.0053535327,
0.0596105866,
-0.0417614318,
0.0855815709,
-0.0348936617,
0.0053464486,
0.0076968633,
-0.0043134121,
0.0430141948,
0.0089492863,
-0.0033118797,
-0.055797264,
0.0213304721,
-0.015052232,
-0.0185634308,
-0.0004635268,
0.0425892584,
-0.0022018116,
0.0553625636,
0.0441952348,
-0.0772168338,
-0.0278868694,
0.0435752049,
0.0024064758,
0.0201664995,
-0.0379928946,
0.0085521806,
0.0038515266,
-0.0418174379,
-0.0456597097,
0.0243952051,
0.0194132403,
-0.0569133312,
0.0186467245,
0.0540597327,
-0.0407784395,
-0.0700335875,
-0.0446269549,
-0.0051185321,
0.0242721476,
-0.0449918769,
-0.0396136679,
2.009805369e-34,
-0.0053918809,
0.0149004683,
0.042254746,
0.0375636332,
0.0110669695,
0.0080018928,
0.0415268429,
0.003559208,
0.0029006673,
-0.0095392372,
-0.0137260994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14610v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14610v4 | This Land is {Your, My} Land: Evaluating Geopolitical Biases in Language Models | 2023-05-24T01:16:17 | 2024-04-02T02:55:33 | Bryan Li, Samar Haider, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do the Spratly Islands belong to China, the Philippines, or Vietnam? A
pretrained large language model (LLM) may answer differently if asked in the
languages of each claimant country: Chinese, Tagalog, or Vietnamese. This
contrasts with a multilingual human, who would likely answer consistently. In
this paper, we show that LLMs recall certain geographical knowledge
inconsistently when queried in different languages -- a phenomenon we term
geopolitical bias. As a targeted case study, we consider territorial disputes,
an inherently controversial and multilingual task. We introduce BorderLines, a
dataset of territorial disputes which covers 251 territories, each associated
with a set of multiple-choice questions in the languages of each claimant
country (49 languages in total). We also propose a suite of evaluation metrics
to precisely quantify bias and consistency in responses across different
languages. We then evaluate various multilingual LLMs on our dataset and
metrics to probe their internal knowledge and use the proposed metrics to
discover numerous inconsistencies in how these models respond in different
languages. Finally, we explore several prompt modification strategies, aiming
to either amplify or mitigate geopolitical bias, which highlights how brittle
LLMs are and how they tailor their responses depending on cues from the
interaction context. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/manestay/borderlines | [
0.0581655465,
0.0559311546,
-0.0324389376,
0.0248960555,
-0.047041256,
0.0083795469,
0.0617073849,
-0.0112218075,
0.0470826328,
-0.0386054181,
-0.0047677141,
-0.0506481044,
-0.0026639963,
-0.0271748751,
0.0105656367,
-0.075758867,
0.0403073281,
-0.0301562008,
0.0518173724,
-0.0345622785,
-0.0279551744,
-0.0103788739,
0.0057036672,
0.0177437812,
-0.034024436,
0.0072710719,
-0.0160883442,
-0.0199574418,
0.0146443294,
-0.0436460637,
0.0117391841,
0.0559156425,
-0.0404894017,
0.0038352252,
0.0000019793,
-0.0509323403,
0.0090607749,
-0.0301918965,
0.0145752979,
0.0268115662,
0.0402963012,
-0.0007681478,
0.021442635,
0.0048418576,
-0.0606526509,
-0.0372666828,
0.0299261604,
0.0254286435,
0.0483263917,
0.0320841074,
0.0069168475,
0.0108849024,
-0.0390851423,
-0.0285571422,
-0.0111375684,
-0.0041923695,
0.0308621116,
0.0119722448,
-0.0371876955,
0.0167279392,
-0.0223850422,
0.0186692607,
0.0260379054,
0.0240525324,
-0.0675392747,
-0.003704079,
-0.0344124511,
0.033954788,
0.0167960618,
0.0386747085,
0.0271327049,
-0.017914962,
-0.0003961385,
0.0097172605,
0.0046926155,
0.0349041931,
-0.0281969979,
0.0238058679,
0.0130638201,
0.0093135042,
0.0209188424,
0.0013261586,
0.0004407568,
0.0154718896,
-0.0378908291,
0.1003322378,
-0.0097058536,
-0.0307043996,
-0.017694544,
0.0388519913,
0.0167843346,
-0.0926797688,
0.0053717745,
0.0471439138,
-0.0483439416,
0.0057211756,
-0.0137274452,
0.0290262569,
0.0325460359,
-0.0352278166,
0.0147101302,
0.0063840705,
-0.0821654722,
0.0531075709,
0.0078371,
0.0414200425,
-0.0125984717,
0.0474503562,
0.0030470514,
-0.0486029685,
-0.0208975114,
-0.0145357745,
0.0122890202,
-0.0059525706,
0.027137395,
0.0542933457,
-0.0150892148,
-0.0119731165,
-0.0510610715,
0.0323396064,
-0.0499644354,
-0.0040381355,
-0.0158817135,
-0.0202753246,
-0.069765456,
0.0386176668,
-0.0674383342,
0.0268450081,
-0.0095495181,
-0.058943063,
0.0136957858,
-0.0089984993,
-0.0223484449,
-0.0082660653,
-0.0050687231,
0.0601245835,
-0.007725724,
0.0119907316,
-0.0235220008,
-0.0445104167,
0.0157015733,
-0.0536017194,
0.0244408399,
-0.0760113373,
0.0424498953,
0.0090559041,
-0.0174222216,
-0.0567983538,
-0.0098256068,
-0.000902806,
-0.0214413125,
0.0375415497,
0.0186199639,
0.0376704298,
0.060908623,
0.0388022885,
-0.0066876621,
0.0737773627,
-0.0018185894,
0.0111616198,
0.0705189183,
-0.015642738,
0.0123939086,
0.0029484686,
-0.0059776176,
0.0268137325,
-0.0548212677,
0.0338985547,
0.0034995633,
-0.0077045588,
0.0333073139,
0.0564700887,
0.0007640523,
-0.0455903448,
0.0575098842,
0.0698965862,
-0.0621833652,
0.002342518,
-0.0014899404,
0.0101490747,
-0.0165658128,
0.0416790769,
-0.0414703339,
-0.0062141251,
-0.0302295368,
-0.0185176991,
0.0168590713,
0.0669735223,
-0.0328249373,
-0.0266612805,
0.007790775,
0.0128074549,
0.0234468561,
0.0547526404,
0.0389500335,
-0.0180183146,
0.0387662537,
0.054012537,
0.0349353068,
-0.0423928648,
0.0028552001,
-0.0001739507,
0.0380356871,
-0.0193332806,
-0.0155762499,
-0.0431733578,
-0.0360994935,
-0.0454106592,
0.0471679904,
0.0344406962,
0.100281775,
-0.0235991795,
-0.0109382793,
-0.0229206737,
-0.0460809916,
0.0038394178,
0.0169536509,
0.0247241613,
0.0410473421,
0.035788741,
0.0101076989,
-0.0183618944,
-0.0055066603,
0.0287532732,
0.0008424635,
-0.0161033385,
-0.0182994343,
0.0289689321,
0.0191698875,
0.0162256826,
-0.0148837967,
-0.0081759188,
0.0099354498,
-0.0148434937,
0.0217336081,
-0.0142198838,
-0.0383020043,
0.005897766,
0.0431415252,
-0.0153403673,
-0.0278065298,
-0.0351432115,
-0.031857308,
-0.0220571607,
0.0206404161,
0.0217736047,
0.0195875745,
0.0062287035,
0.0006468249,
-0.0506208986,
-0.0114521189,
-0.0615671277,
0.0417040773,
0.0093835341,
0.0371806286,
0.035906937,
-0.0117726326,
0.0566324405,
-0.0116611728,
-0.0337880328,
0.0319212526,
-0.0109483767,
-0.0072481679,
0.0200995822,
-0.0324618593,
-0.0300082341,
-0.0215487666,
-0.0902590379,
-0.018454561,
-0.0311264638,
-0.010096998,
0.0238697659,
-0.0328384116,
-0.0198768023,
-0.0076397401,
-0.0535367653,
-0.0396217816,
0.0025193926,
0.0601698384,
-0.0013577554,
-0.0046382891,
0.0593756288,
0.0040200818,
-0.0015161898,
-0.0262202881,
0.0504041389,
-0.0172929242,
0.0131237917,
-0.0614102371,
-0.0045605488,
-0.0651715621,
0.0197763555,
-0.0436703116,
-0.0325239599,
0.0313924514,
0.0131577784,
0.0196460169,
0.0705861077,
0.0020842098,
0.0092302915,
0.1077028066,
-0.0588071197,
-0.0716028735,
-0.0048006168,
-0.0210579149,
-0.0229252949,
-0.0209906679,
-0.0523599945,
-0.0161515549,
0.0764416456,
0.0300886016,
-0.0026114457,
0.0014132494,
0.0265631936,
-0.0915009305,
-0.0369597338,
-0.0352760926,
-0.0053054029,
0.0079143075,
0.110300146,
-0.0133096213,
-0.0390468575,
0.0802749097,
0.0029571929,
0.0324065089,
-0.0164077245,
0.0144967949,
-0.0213144235,
0.1027621701,
-0.0094749937,
0.014389568,
0.0185565483,
-0.0230920184,
-0.0743134096,
-0.0750006735,
0.0109131346,
-0.0259001181,
0.0322652571,
-0.0641218945,
-0.0323314443,
-0.0355546139,
-0.0360403843,
-0.0269534849,
-0.0130545599,
-0.0105890408,
0.0045894012,
-0.0242753103,
-0.0104372073,
0.048691038,
0.028194081,
0.049970258,
-0.0059828945,
-0.0191153642,
0.0163810831,
0.0023364713,
0.0261052623,
0.0457203388,
0.0566597767,
0.0075461809,
0.0089004617,
-0.0183431953,
0.0124925636,
0.0172304511,
-0.0019347694,
0.0530292317,
0.0166853145,
0.037634436,
-0.0339234322,
-0.0269868281,
-0.0098581733,
0.073181279,
-0.0634179786,
-0.000849682,
0.0798797607,
0.0554636382,
-0.0245813914,
0.0012951915,
-0.0499041677,
0.0040316982,
0.0470068641,
0.0176309776,
-0.077008456,
0.0288922172,
0.0148779117,
-0.0667045861,
-0.0796665475,
-0.0365602784,
-0.0052423305,
-0.1476997435,
0.0149392029,
0.0114244046,
-0.0350886881,
-0.0228291377,
-0.0106845349,
-0.0083379541,
0.0177857839,
0.0167796463,
0.003717585,
0.0193912908,
-0.009183228,
0.0261807926,
-0.0447677895,
-0.0380927436,
0.0231958199,
-0.029489534,
0.0440916754,
0.012566925,
0.0245819893,
-0.0052240863,
-0.0378441662,
0.0521880649,
0.0234139357,
-0.0322073214,
-0.0058196769,
0.0095740017,
0.0441563725,
-0.0306537393,
-0.0028067604,
-0.0020892692,
0.030785989,
-0.0164101366,
0.0458052382,
0.0581936352,
-0.0329300985,
0.0238494482,
0.0325828567,
-0.0022783198,
0.0300877299,
0.0186311956,
0.0315947272,
-0.0246615894,
-0.0387046337,
-0.0662968531,
-0.0059148916,
-0.0255217925,
-0.0371421576,
0.0613475256,
-0.0049174647,
-0.0441352576,
-0.0318971239,
-0.0898832753,
0.0296702012,
0.0037148295,
0.040430028,
-0.0162077732,
0.0312592499,
-0.0154730985,
-0.0211116616,
0.0624274835,
-0.0446842648,
-0.002556999,
-0.0186087545,
-0.0162573196,
-0.0110353772,
-0.0012028883,
-0.0042342972,
0.0205180217,
-0.0297756176,
-0.0334910899,
0.0465469174,
0.0203699004,
0.0221212786,
-0.0052158176,
-0.0144683737,
-0.0458994322,
0.0321808867,
0.0137501648,
-0.0099572055,
0.0064327097,
0.0096519692,
0.0271975882,
0.0117993522,
0.0346376225,
0.0115475226,
0.0062906202,
0.0690253377,
-0.0166661348,
-0.0738776401,
-0.0224702898,
-0.0073302835,
-0.0358544365,
0.113506794,
0.0007579949,
-0.0198877696,
-0.0293038543,
-0.0170567092,
-0.02879983,
-0.0294081513,
0.0267794449,
-0.025431307,
0.0127065834,
-0.0098825032,
-0.0158802122,
-0.0216579121,
-0.0056336122,
0.0125276214,
-0.0049876329,
0.0040169759,
0.0014662931,
0.0571444891,
0.0189777426,
0.0256715603,
-0.0314220265,
0.0485657901,
-0.0010135717,
0.0379322395,
0.0043081795,
0.0610450469,
0.0295677111,
-0.0092474585,
0.0045064874,
-0.0154673569,
-0.0387629867,
-0.0730785877,
0.0190249812,
0.0085747214,
0.0725267008,
-0.0459225066,
-0.0191730745,
0.0306457821,
-0.0166400149,
-0.0041046254,
-0.0216015242,
0.0311328061,
-0.0829415545,
0.0492651798,
-0.0002059363,
-0.036152456,
0.0532256961,
0.0707240105,
0.0010122374,
0.0498650968,
0.034353897,
-0.0352452137,
-0.0035404703,
-0.0178136788,
0.0398779586,
0.003019423,
-0.0616996288,
-0.0019730693,
-0.0976217091,
-0.0745875686,
-0.0057100919,
0.0244483631,
-0.0093231359,
0.0076025347,
0.0075883586,
0.0584791303,
-0.0230180286,
0.0025334249,
-0.0567885265,
0.0334792994,
-0.027364105,
-0.0220065489,
0.0041717533,
-6.065107468e-33,
-0.0183972009,
-0.0501592942,
0.0114786383,
-0.051260937,
-0.0027404914,
-0.0306686964,
-0.0330377072,
0.0415786207,
-0.0553304553,
0.0154462568,
-0.0215231758,
-0.0078179222,
0.0219108388,
0.0050785234,
0.029426327,
-0.0523391031,
-0.0052025085,
0.0329018235,
-0.0238264203,
0.0128629226,
0.0421239994,
-0.0153647261,
0.0431361943,
-0.0991540179,
0.0364604928,
0.036225602,
0.0225060023,
0.0127189746,
-0.0321331397,
0.0312584527,
-0.0501528494,
0.0511381812,
0.0322595835,
-0.0178436544,
-0.0132329743,
0.0247267503,
-0.0228812583,
-0.0647547245,
0.0318813883,
0.0196347963,
0.0248965677,
-0.0438602492,
-0.0020264036,
-0.0063126748,
-0.0336469635,
0.0139084095,
0.0353494771,
-0.0170909315,
-0.0176345818,
0.0171771478,
-0.0359481238,
0.0247806665,
0.0017480927,
0.0114398925,
-0.0296460278,
0.0629724637,
0.0226565916,
0.0246748161,
-0.0777503997,
0.02139966,
0.0423630737,
0.0439537801,
0.0479128994,
0.0146252606,
0.0163214989,
0.0534986183,
0.0279687066,
0.0523836575,
-0.0167332347,
-0.0336571895,
0.0291956849,
-0.007773079,
0.041728206,
0.0771839768,
0.0066437693,
-0.0422191322,
-0.0635867864,
-0.0095509347,
0.0385506302,
0.0016062683,
0.0047580032,
-0.0294082277,
0.0336142182,
-0.0441645756,
-0.0572458841,
-0.064623706,
-0.0305122156,
-0.0127537679,
0.0452921242,
-0.0180814378,
0.02758638,
0.0396915078,
0.0561468825,
-0.0150625939,
-0.0252825972,
-0.0059479307,
0.0091158813,
0.0167826451,
0.0057370341,
0.0288468953,
-0.0290198736,
0.0128828399,
-0.0433636457,
-0.0200359523,
0.0096893925,
0.0231424812,
0.0020284916,
-0.0253703631,
-0.0741181225,
-0.0132385576,
-0.0358698517,
0.0251838528,
-0.0168072339,
0.0165797509,
0.0245966464,
0.0179245193,
0.0042256038,
0.0029039755,
0.0390992835,
-0.0569240004,
-0.0173460189,
-0.008994529,
-0.0747811273,
0.0223461147,
0.0030053991,
-0.0111098411,
-0.0301674586,
0.0627673492,
0.0061365739,
0.020362068,
-0.0088136662,
-0.007116423,
2.584e-7,
0.0238208584,
0.0582561046,
-0.0047124503,
-0.014336721,
-0.0009780148,
0.0383696705,
-0.0182089899,
0.014799797,
0.0109913768,
-0.0283956937,
-0.0241853036,
0.0205067284,
0.0610359311,
0.055304952,
-0.1231168509,
0.0103867333,
-0.0198504236,
0.0030450143,
-0.060455963,
0.028901618,
0.0378451608,
0.0070209228,
0.0331339352,
0.0019159669,
-0.033693511,
-0.0106462585,
0.049018506,
-0.0598865785,
-0.0203506462,
0.0372718275,
0.0656357557,
-0.0457139984,
0.0309205316,
0.0555558093,
0.0213202257,
-0.0270853806,
-0.0377198011,
0.0464601256,
0.0252868794,
-0.0118197724,
-0.0605958365,
-0.034359321,
-0.0057368022,
-0.1217245832,
0.0386997052,
-0.0243801065,
-0.0203837994,
-0.0208268724,
0.0275093131,
-0.0298660845,
0.0843132511,
-0.0197800603,
-0.0367309861,
0.0013767668,
0.0295188501,
0.02898895,
0.0226017423,
-0.0376882777,
-0.0504838116,
0.0185212418,
-0.0218062792,
-0.0268807281,
-0.0002609608,
0.0300923996,
0.0021558106,
-0.0161953401,
0.0170255862,
2.227077133e-34,
-0.0002007813,
0.0091469558,
0.0069610924,
-0.018635001,
0.0652603805,
0.011532411,
0.0109859016,
0.0079662791,
-0.0018103804,
-0.039897386,
0.028502645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14603v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14603v2 | OpenPI2.0: An Improved Dataset for Entity Tracking in Texts | 2023-05-24T00:57:35 | 2024-01-25T18:15:31 | Li Zhang, Hainiu Xu, Abhinav Kommula, Chris Callison-Burch, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much text describes a changing world (e.g., procedures, stories, newswires),
and understanding them requires tracking how entities change. An earlier
dataset, OpenPI, provided crowdsourced annotations of entity state changes in
text. However, a major limitation was that those annotations were free-form and
did not identify salient changes, hampering model evaluation. To overcome these
limitations, we present an improved dataset, OpenPI2.0, where entities and
attributes are fully canonicalized and additional entity salience annotations
are added. On our fairer evaluation setting, we find that current
state-of-the-art language models are far from competent. We also show that
using state changes of salient entities as a chain-of-thought prompt,
downstream performance is improved on tasks such as question answering and
classical planning, outperforming the setting involving all related entities
indiscriminately. We offer OpenPI2.0 for the continued development of models
that can understand the dynamics of entities in text. | [
0.0371016003,
0.0724560022,
-0.0026773263,
0.0094884103,
0.0001988685,
0.004592733,
-0.0202095639,
-0.0124606313,
0.0009359182,
-0.0524827205,
0.003354223,
-0.0216638111,
-0.0040623909,
0.0207496937,
0.0238368679,
-0.0638006404,
0.0574001074,
-0.0192245021,
-0.0244857967,
0.0265951101,
0.0554483272,
0.0346113071,
-0.0227114744,
0.0453343391,
0.0232087895,
-0.0099445051,
-0.0323860943,
0.0033167582,
0.0629516095,
-0.0315122493,
0.0028846916,
0.0934491456,
0.0224750899,
0.0054992037,
0.000001992,
-0.0555325747,
-0.0107420199,
-0.0241748076,
-0.0434564427,
0.0225327443,
-0.0098456908,
0.0003152113,
0.002041375,
-0.0248131976,
-0.0262080431,
0.0256983154,
0.0086405389,
0.0229760669,
0.0641579032,
0.0683334023,
0.0055981469,
-0.0028379832,
0.0207370408,
-0.012191752,
-0.0107661858,
-0.0474043489,
0.0269656386,
-0.0653232634,
-0.0096326703,
0.0534936935,
0.014785788,
0.0123779001,
0.0068646865,
-0.0119153373,
0.0248450823,
0.0337728336,
-0.0404282026,
0.0188917592,
-0.0012157838,
0.0835598484,
0.0433578119,
-0.0366576985,
0.016901141,
-0.0082868794,
0.0045863357,
0.000282832,
-0.048389595,
-0.0168276466,
-0.0258971006,
0.0137126287,
0.0457207598,
0.0052605299,
0.0200411268,
0.0423177332,
0.0003163418,
0.0308176633,
0.0176047273,
-0.0288206041,
-0.0011852726,
0.0351087525,
-0.021307392,
-0.0924269333,
0.0269788466,
0.0134122074,
-0.0120391706,
0.030565463,
-0.0397951119,
-0.0298817512,
0.0000654378,
-0.0633200556,
-0.0181935374,
0.0054618455,
-0.0166851096,
0.078658402,
-0.0024093322,
0.0135497479,
-0.0161223561,
-0.0075385254,
0.0067393631,
-0.0098794326,
-0.0752639249,
0.0117688114,
-0.0464378037,
0.0598103032,
-0.0072131362,
-0.0087516243,
0.0098528778,
0.0147143509,
0.0015031371,
-0.0066789989,
0.0031785395,
0.0259154793,
0.0041990806,
-0.0019802344,
-0.0259890649,
0.0420432985,
-0.0996774063,
-0.0105320672,
0.0041821147,
-0.0358549878,
-0.0075995978,
-0.0289308392,
0.0145571241,
-0.0368958861,
-0.0165868346,
-0.0052866754,
0.019728912,
-0.0488533676,
-0.0523000546,
-0.0182543602,
-0.0028684684,
-0.0214089882,
-0.0425413623,
-0.0668112859,
0.027029857,
-0.0060619703,
0.0105801653,
-0.06396842,
0.0029440569,
0.0353496149,
-0.040376842,
0.0484201387,
-0.0623809993,
-0.009513502,
-0.0075733839,
-0.0000507887,
0.0483382456,
0.0838591754,
0.0540531091,
-0.0163483527,
0.0539930388,
0.0330238119,
-0.0216322728,
0.0295537487,
0.0092109581,
0.0193387233,
0.0201412197,
0.0365161672,
-0.0435978621,
0.0434177518,
0.0111528058,
0.0249910653,
-0.0033697314,
-0.0369452275,
0.0652352199,
0.0307283401,
-0.0019825939,
-0.0020790754,
0.0201019999,
0.0021282495,
0.0111851934,
0.0107658645,
0.0038069533,
0.0243655033,
-0.0279609244,
-0.0229496397,
-0.00171972,
-0.0099232122,
-0.0336270817,
-0.0212995689,
-0.0033306431,
0.0428814963,
0.0030594538,
0.0092068082,
0.0474481247,
0.0350797065,
-0.0188806187,
0.0538659506,
0.036999207,
-0.0699661672,
0.0168620888,
0.0084339669,
0.0535070449,
0.098436974,
0.0616656989,
-0.0301276706,
-0.0469591282,
-0.0343962125,
0.0597751886,
0.0401704721,
0.012866796,
-0.038755741,
0.0040908316,
-0.0367763601,
-0.0199471191,
0.0101866638,
0.0075485329,
-0.0011256076,
0.0511417985,
-0.007089227,
-0.0149568897,
-0.0173328333,
-0.0255394019,
0.0548751727,
0.0066225384,
0.0112160575,
-0.0291092899,
0.0111404508,
-0.0112712113,
0.0399626978,
0.0181610193,
-0.0200598892,
0.0220964011,
-0.0224449895,
0.0133623304,
0.0200978871,
-0.0004865976,
-0.0001879541,
0.034305878,
-0.0020264622,
-0.0341042057,
0.0181067847,
-0.0181024671,
-0.0426604524,
-0.0195770375,
-0.0357987434,
0.0238781124,
-0.0126621444,
0.0044230386,
0.0160618965,
0.011373993,
-0.0558784567,
0.0802371874,
-0.0119387079,
0.0208876245,
0.0350438468,
0.01924932,
0.0204442013,
-0.0236979499,
-0.0335207097,
0.0270882808,
0.0474785753,
-0.0353808515,
0.0584051497,
-0.0091836629,
-0.0631483272,
-0.0117598278,
-0.1076635644,
0.0177396704,
-0.0472498797,
0.0467994958,
0.0340278633,
0.0307113379,
-0.0143523617,
-0.0014035103,
-0.0192908831,
-0.0343407653,
-0.0449895114,
0.0074659204,
0.0481136702,
0.0155718792,
0.0075309356,
-0.0670116767,
-0.010623903,
-0.0416016169,
0.0256804097,
0.0273932926,
-0.0535463914,
-0.0622263253,
0.035505522,
-0.0400376506,
0.024772007,
-0.0027265884,
-0.0069630193,
0.0292713959,
0.0238459818,
0.0703740194,
0.0573830567,
0.0109883016,
0.0533524267,
0.0037734392,
-0.0343150273,
-0.0624501407,
0.0185456313,
0.0082895486,
0.0381792933,
-0.0260004029,
-0.0280604623,
0.0192269441,
0.0643925667,
-0.0155149419,
-0.0234337542,
-0.0906798616,
0.0004224971,
-0.0388541035,
-0.0163327791,
-0.0271920618,
0.0058593079,
-0.0406123064,
0.0351542346,
-0.0427722968,
0.0128938146,
0.0799487606,
-0.0226858016,
-0.0017841182,
-0.0303359237,
0.0079015018,
-0.054738909,
0.0566369258,
0.0110358875,
-0.0118673882,
0.0013175481,
-0.0207589511,
-0.046004504,
0.0517501719,
0.0056567285,
-0.0206648409,
0.0655798391,
-0.066768676,
0.0362914205,
0.0232284609,
-0.010550539,
-0.019277649,
-0.0387598202,
-0.0437406152,
0.0262143183,
0.0118542593,
-0.0245266706,
0.0088093393,
0.0014128647,
0.0029437512,
0.0406865329,
-0.0071004797,
-0.0237507224,
-0.026355708,
0.0087623755,
0.0748591274,
0.0098245265,
-0.0017594129,
-0.0243821889,
0.0220026206,
0.0463444293,
0.0496790037,
-0.0165981166,
-0.0436327793,
-0.0017550384,
0.0232119225,
-0.0996180624,
-0.0220209658,
-0.0175579712,
0.0574504212,
-0.0628845096,
-0.0504262783,
0.1071608067,
0.0350010432,
-0.0288003962,
0.003547017,
0.0037264165,
0.0558524579,
0.022957202,
-0.0052374047,
-0.0728867874,
-0.0582045205,
0.0015187957,
0.0168568492,
0.0044623115,
-0.086639598,
0.0254274886,
-0.0818395019,
-0.0067945244,
-0.037661124,
-0.050788749,
0.0262796599,
-0.0355206616,
0.0368751697,
-0.0277073197,
-0.0355266631,
-0.0060534244,
0.0145155052,
0.0187528692,
0.0384201035,
-0.0561971702,
-0.0060509541,
0.030458102,
-0.0485322028,
0.0246558916,
0.0943561718,
0.0220798869,
-0.0006884302,
-0.028182352,
0.0046885004,
-0.0442356989,
-0.0141070914,
-0.0038158279,
0.0561188795,
-0.05429741,
-0.0230170209,
-0.0613418482,
0.01759848,
-0.0314859077,
-0.0202960297,
0.0247863568,
0.0514038578,
-0.0103848334,
0.0124467844,
-0.0190960001,
-0.0079162391,
-0.0199211724,
0.0709127262,
0.027931463,
-0.0558180064,
0.0028556364,
-0.0374099985,
0.0072328984,
-0.0544447228,
-0.0478968509,
-0.006672651,
-0.0157474224,
0.0001316649,
-0.1032620296,
-0.0704829767,
0.0716147944,
0.014769543,
0.0254590902,
0.0364569426,
0.0090354625,
-0.009267251,
-0.034454558,
0.0416341387,
-0.0351910293,
0.0228223633,
-0.0321080796,
-0.050692413,
0.0305720214,
0.0337390415,
-0.0220264271,
0.0673560947,
-0.1186362952,
-0.0362262316,
-0.0033664485,
0.019449804,
0.0197666101,
0.0213196259,
-0.0411586687,
-0.059663374,
-0.0506411754,
-0.0206961744,
-0.0320448056,
0.0182167441,
-0.0044461475,
0.039293129,
-0.0167012401,
0.0491622426,
-0.0321475603,
-0.0209202804,
-0.0002932374,
0.0761163682,
-0.0658005551,
-0.0523353405,
0.017288141,
-0.0252247993,
0.0176011194,
-0.0049145208,
-0.041249916,
-0.0540613867,
0.0061257174,
0.0033932463,
-0.0281488225,
-0.0364311673,
0.0172198471,
0.0144692985,
-0.0175008755,
-0.0418531708,
0.0628518611,
-0.008378326,
-0.0015699533,
-0.0580090769,
-0.0221229009,
0.0363405086,
0.056904301,
-0.0106550558,
0.0161584541,
-0.0142692458,
0.0089448038,
-0.0112748314,
0.0508962981,
-0.0025955851,
0.0356398821,
0.0320745781,
-0.0165356472,
0.0428192616,
0.0155683169,
-0.0695432425,
-0.0026820123,
-0.0024942562,
0.0541559197,
0.0428325944,
-0.003278103,
0.0984561592,
-0.0044926787,
-0.007354246,
0.0142401503,
0.0220845137,
0.0205117315,
-0.0016283999,
0.0008848354,
0.037725307,
0.0072938064,
0.0116428621,
0.0831774846,
0.0065291715,
0.0770962164,
0.0103097921,
-0.0007090137,
-0.0367492512,
0.0021326949,
-0.0326346569,
0.0503489748,
0.0057204841,
0.0205542333,
-0.0719920248,
-0.0153957009,
0.0203268379,
-0.011365667,
-0.0149269244,
-0.0099830031,
0.0717142969,
0.0040141167,
-0.0211891998,
-0.0183872394,
-0.062593013,
0.0120898848,
-0.0072407029,
-0.0267501958,
-0.0463569425,
-6.364529757e-33,
-0.0614799671,
-0.0100800321,
0.0107546253,
0.012204594,
-0.0526570082,
0.0187872369,
-0.0548149347,
0.0019661123,
0.0012137278,
0.0108240303,
-0.0050464892,
0.0528993942,
0.0065906066,
0.0012230232,
0.0101935947,
-0.0680314824,
0.0408779941,
0.0073905513,
-0.0266285166,
0.0011126749,
0.0545867682,
0.023152221,
0.0915769711,
-0.0585303754,
0.0807162151,
-0.0127261439,
-0.0172387939,
0.0126739712,
0.0048208223,
0.0485563502,
-0.0002409296,
0.0159547254,
0.0283188615,
-0.0488624237,
-0.0227368772,
0.0006117182,
-0.0913629085,
-0.0245064907,
0.0224020127,
0.0299964547,
-0.0432046726,
-0.0390346311,
0.0305466671,
0.0086827995,
0.0333652012,
0.0388243943,
0.0606177039,
-0.0294315983,
-0.007902828,
0.0053502019,
-0.0444240719,
0.0470415391,
-0.0341747031,
-0.0137941865,
-0.0081356606,
0.0281466898,
0.0238271076,
0.0074079535,
-0.0671846271,
-0.0089262258,
0.0141093964,
0.0090937158,
0.0190710686,
-0.0336521901,
-0.0046036588,
0.0780708417,
0.0155828213,
0.0158996079,
-0.051721707,
-0.0063264952,
0.0219978224,
0.0263240561,
0.0576986559,
0.046230454,
-0.0186191015,
0.0463558175,
-0.0646586493,
0.048864603,
0.0095109278,
0.0354784988,
0.0066224067,
-0.0127519555,
-0.0524474159,
-0.0113706216,
-0.0192914754,
-0.0102419285,
-0.0226400513,
-0.000168763,
0.0265787747,
-0.0053839735,
-0.0186999589,
0.0216534901,
0.0084920349,
-0.016083641,
-0.0295737125,
0.0276131276,
-0.0112673724,
0.0461701602,
0.0181881022,
-0.003588106,
-0.0640950724,
0.0209292024,
0.0201472212,
0.0114152068,
0.0367584303,
-0.0015665537,
0.0269519854,
-0.0263469946,
-0.0483842902,
-0.0184383616,
-0.0358075462,
0.0086715808,
-0.0778803825,
0.0032177502,
0.0309590939,
0.0008703072,
-0.0069430582,
0.0730816722,
0.0551065579,
-0.0012777612,
-0.0252696294,
-0.0058291727,
0.0220132675,
0.0002513723,
-0.0047896528,
-0.0121278875,
0.0078063146,
0.0231617615,
-0.0113185337,
-0.0308395158,
-0.0023617623,
0.0265261251,
2.629e-7,
0.0615453236,
0.0401894748,
0.0594437383,
0.0018015775,
-0.0078233229,
0.0227419063,
-0.0085305739,
0.0215410236,
-0.0028404142,
-0.0444244854,
-0.0031480805,
0.0202388391,
0.0441599861,
0.0169108417,
-0.1228985935,
-0.0601423606,
-0.0394268595,
0.018108679,
-0.0728731006,
-0.0234813932,
0.0302923527,
0.0394449309,
0.0467851348,
0.026325237,
-0.0114028798,
0.0104761245,
0.0541987196,
-0.027364511,
0.0090140318,
0.0167763997,
0.0184958335,
0.022936644,
-0.0291221812,
0.0052663884,
-0.014003776,
0.015729459,
0.0502435938,
0.0309789553,
-0.0061227954,
-0.0255411305,
-0.0345167816,
-0.0595187582,
0.0142010693,
-0.0471331403,
0.0735767186,
0.0150418961,
-0.0101674395,
-0.0078941416,
-0.0177085232,
0.0048574773,
0.0066246283,
0.0260716043,
-0.046428699,
0.0070137815,
0.0035661273,
-0.0056406814,
-0.0394080207,
-0.102350533,
-0.020268552,
-0.0117849708,
-0.0168884117,
-0.0053696171,
-0.0354443155,
-0.0095743388,
-0.0357378833,
-0.0503892899,
-0.0032114945,
2.177944454e-34,
-0.0096930126,
0.0327477679,
0.0022449021,
0.0588297844,
0.0434690602,
-0.0100166816,
-0.0280933008,
-0.0406104438,
0.0279026069,
-0.0665039495,
-0.0109706242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14600v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14600v3 | Learning Semantic Role Labeling from Compatible Label Sequences | 2023-05-24T00:46:02 | 2023-10-19T22:34:41 | Tao Li, Ghazaleh Kazeminejad, Susan W. Brown, Martha Palmer, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Semantic role labeling (SRL) has multiple disjoint label sets, e.g., VerbNet
and PropBank. Creating these datasets is challenging, therefore a natural
question is how to use each one to help the other. Prior work has shown that
cross-task interaction helps, but only explored multitask learning so far. A
common issue with multi-task setup is that argument sequences are still
separately decoded, running the risk of generating structurally inconsistent
label sequences (as per lexicons like Semlink). In this paper, we eliminate
such issue with a framework that jointly models VerbNet and PropBank labels as
one sequence. In this setup, we show that enforcing Semlink constraints during
decoding constantly improves the overall F1. With special input constructions,
our joint model infers VerbNet arguments from given PropBank arguments with
over 99 F1. For learning, we propose a constrained marginal model that learns
with knowledge defined in Semlink to further benefit from the large amounts of
PropBank-only data. On the joint benchmark based on CoNLL05, our models achieve
state-of-the-art F1's, outperforming the prior best in-domain model by 3.5
(VerbNet) and 0.8 (PropBank). For out-of-domain generalization, our models
surpass the prior best by 3.4 (VerbNet) and 0.2 (PropBank). | [
0.0287963822,
-0.0042005396,
-0.0033528211,
0.0356912427,
-0.0245804451,
0.015216941,
-0.0193822067,
-0.0425977036,
0.0031790915,
-0.0464640781,
-0.0457806364,
-0.0704329535,
-0.0466431677,
0.014906588,
0.011950477,
-0.0149349095,
0.0520997569,
0.0391963571,
0.0357498266,
0.0279808603,
0.0074927928,
0.0345081538,
-0.0119773354,
0.0440634117,
-0.0472800732,
-0.0134642245,
0.0232604332,
-0.0059393486,
0.0538870804,
0.003919139,
0.0232276917,
0.0261509493,
0.0374764204,
-0.0064113764,
0.0000018948,
-0.0503768772,
-0.0318624862,
-0.0190107748,
-0.0235578194,
-0.0420631617,
0.0381514244,
0.0119073931,
0.0154282069,
-0.003630918,
-0.043373473,
-0.0382448323,
0.0661760941,
0.0334833562,
0.043879386,
0.0695258752,
-0.0155910365,
0.0286995042,
-0.0076964111,
-0.0626416802,
-0.004606056,
-0.0114944018,
0.0092614423,
0.0218123794,
-0.0326967016,
0.0041401866,
-0.0260957871,
0.0235163514,
0.0406913422,
-0.016264325,
-0.0047836215,
0.0195999239,
0.0117685609,
-0.0566986278,
0.0293631796,
0.0942487568,
-0.0170362629,
-0.0222936086,
0.0102610933,
-0.0199626349,
0.0260634162,
0.0418711342,
-0.0111722201,
0.0346697308,
-0.016437849,
-0.0013789446,
0.0491008386,
0.0011642262,
0.0295085181,
-0.0310720466,
-0.003649083,
0.0638851225,
-0.0231747851,
-0.0170169175,
0.0110426489,
0.0021986531,
-0.0525057167,
-0.0201480798,
0.0200135391,
-0.0239168108,
-0.0283920076,
0.0846872628,
-0.0629364401,
-0.0460610315,
-0.0081274929,
-0.0045160707,
0.0049368101,
0.0202887915,
-0.025000846,
0.012225152,
-0.0215948299,
-0.0113133285,
0.0021173647,
0.055677481,
-0.0536060371,
-0.0323423073,
-0.0750749931,
-0.0140681341,
-0.0457475893,
0.0341168754,
-0.0471651182,
-0.0461941324,
-0.0338872038,
-0.0175170414,
-0.0239854492,
0.0181308128,
0.0560306832,
-0.0022133263,
-0.0679212511,
0.004653234,
0.009956182,
0.0350267366,
0.0008372103,
0.0190977324,
-0.0114205582,
-0.0170508418,
-0.0329481959,
-0.0029631301,
-0.0087661985,
-0.0437776335,
-0.038335301,
0.047125455,
-0.0151076959,
-0.0187044628,
-0.0364219174,
-0.1089587286,
-0.0419167206,
-0.025695391,
-0.0136155467,
-0.058463037,
0.0296213608,
-0.0025330887,
0.0231544152,
-0.061281994,
0.0243313164,
0.0148918098,
-0.0193954166,
0.0824546516,
0.0224067923,
-0.0293059517,
-0.0258639846,
0.041223757,
-0.0257985853,
0.0565435998,
-0.0134266214,
-0.0048484299,
0.0442356095,
0.0268887542,
-0.0412909389,
0.0304796174,
0.0143768545,
-0.018418476,
0.0456617475,
-0.0308697391,
0.1012115031,
-0.0107771456,
0.031537585,
-0.012473708,
-0.0466170236,
-0.0510873608,
0.0350860432,
0.0187092423,
0.0156588033,
-0.0548993163,
0.0797241181,
0.0251334757,
-0.0045106481,
0.0040324973,
-0.0384921841,
-0.0010480181,
0.0507557876,
-0.0279612336,
-0.0676539615,
-0.0092345662,
0.0101788603,
-0.0479370765,
0.0108428532,
-0.0509378463,
0.0026929306,
0.0014487982,
0.0558200404,
0.0583140068,
-0.0316945314,
0.0552290827,
0.0518346168,
-0.0473054461,
-0.0010128277,
0.0204597358,
-0.0096844714,
-0.0141196875,
0.0078229178,
-0.0648815706,
-0.0574980751,
-0.0108863832,
0.0213952977,
-0.0191437323,
0.0330731831,
-0.0628490299,
0.0292010978,
-0.05069682,
-0.0366128795,
0.009437223,
0.021788992,
0.0326535329,
0.0007678309,
-0.027426457,
0.0330028348,
-0.0267814659,
0.0050790994,
0.038843967,
0.0018848625,
-0.0131131029,
0.0149131715,
0.0119826449,
0.0566911213,
0.0226063076,
-0.0090173073,
0.025788242,
0.0206362586,
-0.040279083,
-0.0325575508,
0.038423378,
-0.0684452876,
-0.0598273613,
0.0636047497,
-0.0150275314,
-0.0304512177,
0.0535274185,
-0.0395694934,
-0.0557843596,
-0.0025368033,
0.0051296409,
0.0173544306,
-0.0048189247,
-0.0232381113,
0.0304265991,
-0.0020784184,
-0.0469586588,
0.0500809215,
0.0193977617,
0.013540497,
0.0069174157,
0.0248125512,
-0.004949322,
-0.0161548108,
0.0025671502,
0.0009105067,
-0.0329778604,
-0.0374394171,
0.0261824876,
-0.0228484608,
-0.0315786935,
0.0202296451,
-0.0465475246,
0.0048977984,
-0.0336087793,
0.0377638601,
0.0382221341,
0.0018662723,
0.0312361494,
-0.0273516458,
-0.0339908637,
0.0233939216,
-0.0279702265,
0.0029981406,
0.0094908029,
0.013638312,
-0.0282714237,
-0.0242444724,
-0.0115445498,
-0.0312839225,
0.004045526,
-0.0071281767,
-0.0145517923,
0.0056554228,
0.0211812351,
0.0209982954,
0.0304569248,
-0.0438540429,
0.0272392035,
-0.0348131694,
0.0128675299,
-0.0268549677,
0.0026618857,
-0.0568680502,
0.0480517447,
0.0247670487,
-0.0006668011,
-0.0313982479,
-0.001815623,
0.0024062144,
-0.0074574361,
-0.0704825893,
0.0189775396,
0.0260875281,
0.0885014907,
-0.0189125519,
-0.0026886947,
-0.0198658761,
-0.0272000525,
-0.0515712164,
-0.0661221743,
-0.0117416829,
-0.0269473288,
-0.0239883438,
0.0123984199,
-0.0407040045,
0.0056454106,
0.0448554307,
0.0082263201,
-0.0371184237,
-0.0543704033,
-0.0207859706,
-0.0297985394,
0.0806168467,
0.0314851999,
0.0443257317,
0.0388705954,
-0.0461910293,
-0.0762198269,
-0.0049991915,
0.0517103635,
-0.0028718542,
0.0452897623,
-0.0637048781,
0.0140318945,
-0.0331245065,
-0.0470165089,
-0.005145106,
-0.0754850805,
-0.0083276611,
0.0274349209,
-0.0039220462,
-0.0191112738,
0.0051873806,
-0.0122255776,
-0.0281542335,
0.0267842989,
0.0276227817,
0.0115922289,
-0.0269114748,
0.0539769493,
0.0437857173,
-0.003365549,
-0.0339447558,
0.0104442965,
-0.0097299516,
0.0400910936,
-0.0220922381,
-0.0333484374,
0.0093180137,
0.0309888199,
0.0462605655,
-0.0383904055,
-0.0408706814,
0.0082022855,
0.0413989611,
-0.0536366664,
0.0135011859,
0.0969702899,
0.0471077971,
-0.0468820855,
0.0248750374,
0.0100918179,
-0.0111039588,
0.028519379,
-0.0059662834,
-0.0635883957,
-0.0437911861,
0.0000726581,
0.0009736059,
0.0011292138,
-0.0328114964,
-0.0126986913,
-0.123533465,
0.0362064019,
0.0086466363,
-0.0417196453,
0.0163246486,
-0.0263198037,
0.0045845257,
-0.0626488924,
-0.0336003564,
-0.0206987578,
0.0047398801,
-0.009716806,
0.0342586674,
0.0194798522,
-0.0297627375,
0.0193466693,
-0.0685424656,
0.0757203773,
0.0212372877,
0.0211585518,
0.0291040353,
0.002864016,
0.0295027066,
-0.0231817607,
-0.0392852388,
-0.0176367294,
0.0311051644,
-0.0285753496,
-0.0234229062,
0.0243126862,
0.0629810691,
-0.0852464885,
-0.0211562142,
-0.0123324832,
0.0495696887,
0.0102221016,
0.0453399643,
0.0149241481,
-0.0222531334,
0.0428254902,
0.0521480665,
-0.0154938502,
0.0033720583,
-0.005864399,
-0.0084685311,
-0.0102361478,
-0.0186707843,
-0.0226138085,
-0.0009644993,
-0.0313813277,
-0.0371738523,
-0.0524417721,
-0.0509269983,
0.0378081426,
0.056875594,
0.0079995506,
0.0395452976,
0.0332053192,
-0.0229483806,
-0.0891952962,
-0.0055197864,
-0.0449854881,
0.0397568792,
0.0188721009,
-0.0129198432,
0.0479659364,
0.0007632237,
-0.0386433788,
0.025482554,
-0.0260062944,
-0.0319474228,
-0.0049971798,
0.0178866871,
0.0235875584,
0.0633983463,
-0.0337730981,
-0.0005068058,
-0.0352616124,
0.036072623,
-0.03616805,
-0.005122547,
0.0282900017,
-0.031450782,
-0.0117241619,
0.0351827331,
-0.0257058349,
0.0183088407,
0.0218730494,
0.0396826975,
-0.0281788185,
-0.0226020534,
0.0479513481,
0.0052110134,
0.0450512394,
0.018039722,
0.0225075185,
-0.0549514331,
0.0215441622,
-0.0139920628,
-0.0439845361,
-0.0361032598,
0.0303343944,
0.056981843,
-0.013283018,
-0.0051434278,
0.0142076649,
0.034748558,
0.0430337451,
-0.0005006515,
-0.0087724123,
0.0411199778,
-0.0024112675,
-0.0145124709,
0.0004262498,
-0.0045298599,
0.0194527637,
0.037987072,
0.0046304418,
0.0021750689,
0.0013834276,
0.0130541176,
0.0095247235,
-0.0087853875,
0.0259240419,
-0.0372613072,
-0.0014215901,
-0.0379153676,
-0.0125969695,
0.0484501421,
-0.0636956766,
0.0797457099,
-0.0509273596,
-0.0058745821,
-0.0188328996,
0.015913032,
0.007800472,
-0.0143742068,
0.0688981041,
0.0221688878,
-0.0193132292,
0.0052065607,
0.1035032868,
0.007657934,
0.0413334966,
0.0017185337,
-0.0276062563,
-0.0384460948,
-0.0401922725,
0.0558355078,
0.0344835594,
-0.0232905727,
0.002262363,
-0.0642961189,
-0.0550393872,
-0.0106553324,
0.005989098,
0.0028009885,
0.0349424817,
0.0583204627,
0.0478117466,
0.0246202424,
-0.0055844476,
-0.0351705737,
-0.0564379729,
-0.0072256527,
-0.0197350141,
-0.039703358,
-5.809219981e-33,
-0.0448534787,
-0.0076160231,
0.0044039059,
0.0235041473,
-0.0047663758,
0.0470145904,
0.0007319634,
0.0116148572,
0.0243283417,
0.0439090468,
0.0266135298,
0.0072367629,
0.0342426114,
0.0093615474,
0.0379251726,
-0.0221101753,
0.0550487116,
0.0028530976,
-0.0051769684,
0.0020526887,
0.047454834,
0.0081990752,
0.071795553,
-0.0961951464,
0.0543955825,
0.028978359,
0.0070187105,
0.0218509249,
0.0122219697,
0.0563796796,
0.0385657959,
0.0591772385,
0.0285809189,
-0.0965812132,
-0.0203800164,
0.0671257898,
-0.1392100304,
-0.0257142466,
0.0333294906,
0.0078432141,
-0.0360946022,
-0.0311811399,
0.0076956325,
0.012945665,
0.0332817286,
-0.0100896442,
0.0305038616,
-0.0008659897,
-0.0089240884,
-0.0423911959,
-0.0613244399,
0.0165368728,
0.003927358,
-0.0386829562,
0.0068516615,
0.038947951,
0.0192566533,
-0.0106116924,
-0.0495558754,
-0.0064575607,
-0.1116109714,
0.0678611025,
0.0615703389,
0.0497117452,
-0.033035934,
0.0144347642,
-0.0214380082,
-0.0181410518,
0.0150561621,
0.012262797,
-0.0209591556,
0.0723789707,
0.001157079,
0.0493673012,
0.0517235771,
0.0346099287,
-0.0442553163,
0.0104218451,
0.0585144721,
0.0209841914,
-0.0262210127,
0.0071380488,
0.0023637926,
-0.0303299781,
-0.0518034957,
0.0063691819,
-0.005717752,
-0.0126578473,
0.0255562421,
-0.0003482145,
-0.0056346701,
0.0801309422,
0.0136556644,
-0.0426188894,
-0.0043086563,
0.0232674051,
0.0355637781,
0.0220787935,
-0.004007427,
0.004191454,
-0.0506175086,
-0.0406430624,
0.0340009369,
-0.012443861,
0.016967494,
-0.001001299,
0.0526813008,
0.0014021546,
-0.0252861921,
-0.0142962243,
-0.0454293415,
-0.0090984497,
-0.003119746,
0.0998329446,
0.0597057976,
0.000492061,
-0.0366423465,
0.0073724338,
0.0256686639,
-0.0354922973,
-0.0021132466,
-0.0117356349,
-0.0122351414,
-0.0326217189,
0.0019895372,
-0.0265713241,
0.0071662073,
0.0035818524,
0.0396809466,
-0.0259894375,
0.0017192917,
-0.0041420725,
2.685e-7,
0.0779993907,
-0.0231777839,
0.0142589882,
0.0134142311,
0.0116769634,
0.0396508574,
-0.0093480656,
0.0848156512,
-0.0437950566,
-0.0665516853,
0.0109701855,
0.0063593746,
0.0103378873,
0.0060414164,
-0.0811000988,
-0.0280004889,
-0.0167792849,
-0.0086719291,
-0.0232949015,
0.0309227463,
0.08854983,
0.1019932553,
0.0411031023,
-0.0242782161,
0.0082611451,
-0.0571270585,
0.0441633873,
-0.0070833624,
0.0072268592,
0.0234185588,
0.0171142872,
0.0035511593,
0.0204003453,
0.0602824837,
-0.0223752987,
0.0114830351,
0.0156125212,
0.0569912605,
-0.0127048334,
-0.0113395918,
-0.0384753756,
0.0121473456,
0.01676373,
0.006101313,
0.0539427251,
-0.0729923174,
-0.0457071401,
0.0043178895,
-0.0303554181,
0.052437678,
-0.0242130533,
0.0530982614,
0.0045088707,
0.0377049223,
0.0221122168,
0.0087376768,
-0.0365433097,
-0.0928786397,
-0.0399684533,
0.0229308009,
-0.0047280085,
-0.0131785488,
0.0104078222,
0.0076027052,
0.006089536,
-0.0772730038,
-0.044579979,
2.647188253e-34,
-0.0070690904,
-0.002173671,
0.0159782898,
0.046004355,
0.010143199,
-0.0218432751,
-0.0592961647,
0.0483375899,
-0.0327812843,
-0.0215392355,
-0.0083579626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14599v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14599v2 | Bridging Continuous and Discrete Spaces: Interpretable Sentence Representation Learning via Compositional Operations | 2023-05-24T00:44:49 | 2023-11-05T06:03:59 | James Y. Huang, Wenlin Yao, Kaiqiang Song, Hongming Zhang, Muhao Chen, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional sentence embedding models encode sentences into vector
representations to capture useful properties such as the semantic similarity
between sentences. However, in addition to similarity, sentence semantics can
also be interpreted via compositional operations such as sentence fusion or
difference. It is unclear whether the compositional semantics of sentences can
be directly reflected as compositional operations in the embedding space. To
more effectively bridge the continuous embedding and discrete text spaces, we
explore the plausibility of incorporating various compositional properties into
the sentence embedding space that allows us to interpret embedding
transformations as compositional sentence operations. We propose InterSent, an
end-to-end framework for learning interpretable sentence embeddings that
supports compositional sentence operations in the embedding space. Our method
optimizes operator networks and a bottleneck encoder-decoder model to produce
meaningful and interpretable sentence embeddings. Experimental results
demonstrate that our method significantly improves the interpretability of
sentence embeddings on four textual generation tasks over existing approaches
while maintaining strong performance on traditional semantic similarity tasks. | [
0.0106641557,
0.0816979632,
-0.0083277095,
0.0429378115,
-0.0179617684,
0.0213557109,
0.0287595876,
-0.0548401661,
-0.0307748988,
-0.0302284583,
0.0092244651,
-0.005440508,
-0.0091859177,
0.0415325873,
0.0086796004,
-0.0466872938,
0.0313035548,
0.0440015867,
-0.0266766008,
0.026311582,
0.0160361268,
0.0066955844,
-0.007945342,
0.0609022491,
0.0173863005,
-0.0304392166,
-0.0087530799,
-0.013508983,
0.0483581945,
-0.0196109228,
0.0392807946,
0.024477141,
0.0768247396,
0.050695572,
0.0000015961,
-0.0114460848,
-0.0426672101,
-0.0155160865,
0.0000369225,
-0.0174704082,
0.0187334288,
-0.0909288004,
0.0205878541,
-0.0010042083,
-0.0234174617,
0.0027713373,
0.0280500669,
0.044662565,
0.0614165366,
0.0774698257,
-0.0247381385,
-0.0348725617,
0.0032249789,
-0.0213184524,
0.0182209518,
0.0298489369,
-0.0065875244,
0.0162247531,
-0.0333109312,
-0.003264141,
-0.0596584044,
0.008809587,
0.0614174455,
-0.0148429386,
0.0447987355,
0.0627950132,
-0.001930863,
0.0071371165,
-0.0014884686,
0.0811734945,
-0.0375766791,
-0.0088962857,
0.0116380844,
-0.0086515984,
-0.0166228656,
-0.0637328476,
-0.0446038432,
0.0245532803,
0.021101879,
0.0377351567,
-0.0233516637,
0.029292183,
0.0128055625,
0.0336215831,
-0.048839502,
0.0189526994,
0.0280302837,
-0.0164244194,
-0.0236609094,
0.0240922347,
-0.044126682,
0.0051758154,
0.005540431,
0.0206437595,
-0.0423189886,
-0.0051268158,
-0.0678488016,
-0.0086619034,
-0.0044587194,
-0.03755261,
0.0466108359,
0.0387145765,
0.0327430777,
0.0069231037,
-0.0547350645,
0.0535620116,
-0.0147887459,
0.022628326,
-0.0627662167,
0.0104828859,
-0.0861125067,
-0.0312687568,
-0.0192056987,
0.0283080097,
-0.0202563405,
-0.0702658966,
-0.0536497086,
0.0722301155,
-0.0082108313,
0.0134156179,
-0.0245214384,
0.0253395736,
-0.0340596996,
-0.0012747033,
0.0196542796,
0.0093423007,
-0.0200501159,
0.0371120535,
0.0127502903,
0.0156958066,
-0.0349623896,
0.0321756341,
0.039539732,
-0.0363722146,
-0.0345978923,
0.0323933028,
-0.030746391,
-0.031810239,
0.0146369059,
-0.0474118553,
0.004971046,
-0.040875867,
0.0050374875,
-0.0306047294,
0.0661352649,
-0.0014659157,
-0.0201309081,
-0.0405385606,
0.0152831497,
0.0076588872,
0.007813409,
0.0434055254,
-0.0007456175,
-0.0409174599,
-0.0276814625,
0.0118292207,
0.0333012827,
0.0501353256,
0.0453312248,
0.0382403918,
-0.0050426493,
0.0243431479,
-0.0250297394,
-0.0276111756,
0.0181213021,
0.0031599649,
-0.0270170309,
0.0036390214,
-0.0001920592,
0.0594982728,
0.0392775349,
0.027527269,
-0.0560042299,
0.0094799837,
0.0400129743,
-0.0189264901,
0.0358421169,
0.0316314027,
0.0956609696,
0.0246851221,
-0.051306285,
0.0468387753,
-0.0317897983,
0.0427949578,
0.0099290246,
0.0206386559,
-0.0058011948,
0.0292911418,
-0.0174612384,
-0.0277539957,
0.0222027488,
-0.0322813578,
0.0271228645,
-0.0474591665,
0.0087340586,
0.0174866151,
-0.0681148097,
0.0562922955,
-0.0184823535,
-0.0991622955,
0.0130729908,
0.002859425,
0.0015571526,
0.0734088272,
0.0304772984,
0.0045123124,
-0.0040228409,
-0.0243125502,
-0.0074550891,
0.0368358381,
0.0139655871,
-0.010160136,
0.0256134514,
-0.0657640845,
-0.0321817175,
-0.0496409722,
0.017841354,
-0.0144158797,
-0.0081854016,
0.0000383848,
0.0602374896,
-0.0254856497,
0.0069543682,
0.0404034816,
0.0177687388,
-0.01377948,
0.0259353314,
0.0212952793,
-0.0154584581,
0.0040289657,
0.0056898417,
0.0380132012,
0.0086625628,
-0.0581600405,
-0.0883576348,
0.0448973291,
-0.0642806739,
-0.1274355501,
-0.0071931519,
-0.0677547082,
0.0037191308,
0.0061441204,
-0.0802781507,
-0.0373435616,
0.0371666588,
-0.0745568648,
0.0256342907,
-0.0375235379,
-0.0208228584,
0.0346345752,
0.0212487616,
-0.0119772647,
0.0668558404,
-0.0214772113,
0.0030679905,
-0.0124204354,
-0.0049046325,
0.0279526338,
-0.0164034702,
0.0039214315,
-0.03292346,
0.0159479771,
0.0162456054,
0.0203050766,
0.0167425759,
-0.0279438458,
-0.0544848144,
-0.0935768634,
0.0107855788,
-0.019574834,
0.0084926086,
0.0628224313,
0.0388750434,
0.0451907292,
0.0101527497,
-0.0443105064,
-0.0073705856,
-0.0056302971,
0.0234904233,
0.0756537244,
-0.0163113233,
-0.0424559489,
-0.0077606281,
-0.003033685,
-0.028514361,
0.08484447,
-0.0488944165,
0.0123838643,
-0.0197468512,
-0.019570563,
-0.0167949982,
-0.0281909555,
-0.0003046015,
-0.0218157936,
0.0026729465,
-0.0045635132,
0.0455870181,
0.0542751178,
0.0269482955,
0.1004320607,
0.0346026644,
0.014247383,
-0.0212831311,
-0.0021927773,
-0.0467570126,
0.0435491577,
-0.0007142228,
0.001072454,
0.0121258833,
0.0470501184,
0.0151820304,
-0.0186088737,
-0.0387448445,
0.0275273342,
-0.0059040999,
-0.0165779945,
-0.0514562093,
-0.0145796025,
-0.0011592192,
-0.0073548029,
-0.034896113,
-0.0083658239,
0.058220055,
-0.0179635417,
-0.0124356905,
-0.0309428405,
-0.0263517424,
-0.0588799194,
0.0282001458,
0.0251195841,
0.0295846593,
-0.0157290567,
0.0003798706,
-0.0378800593,
0.0364848748,
0.0209154561,
0.0035229956,
0.0071817543,
-0.0077535226,
-0.0125414804,
-0.0233727582,
-0.0250322279,
-0.0418115929,
-0.0411979444,
0.0063614571,
0.0177616887,
0.01894968,
0.0000258124,
-0.0335700959,
-0.0412515774,
-0.0014540358,
-0.0041296859,
-0.0227585658,
-0.0094934739,
-0.0422718525,
0.0745574906,
0.0625949949,
0.0306810811,
0.0049311765,
-0.0382893234,
0.0426820219,
0.0429883972,
-0.0239602309,
0.0090635698,
-0.0471034721,
0.0272868946,
-0.0267819315,
-0.0088306302,
0.0099154599,
-0.0009126592,
0.0539946035,
-0.0489997156,
-0.0341902077,
0.0862768218,
0.0416983925,
-0.010129883,
0.0272926036,
0.0259099603,
0.033143267,
0.019993538,
0.0154616665,
-0.0804659873,
-0.0262134895,
-0.0119000487,
-0.0296212826,
-0.0061457711,
-0.0138163641,
-0.0358972736,
-0.0600063987,
0.0187484529,
0.0137985703,
-0.025887873,
-0.0535715222,
-0.003638434,
-0.0417108908,
0.0082046147,
-0.0219717193,
-0.0102779604,
0.003849427,
0.0219594948,
-0.0160076693,
0.0007022266,
-0.040674556,
-0.0351931714,
0.0023187939,
-0.0263442267,
0.0590067916,
0.0526212938,
0.0440965407,
-0.0324043781,
0.0118567916,
-0.0546964221,
-0.0292972289,
0.0079135438,
0.0554344319,
-0.0251638629,
0.0031649824,
-0.0127016632,
0.068969816,
-0.0473774113,
-0.0417453945,
0.0010589658,
0.0425614305,
-0.0036513947,
-0.0262143239,
-0.0448846444,
0.0243265647,
0.0223901104,
0.0764160529,
0.0676442385,
-0.0449722596,
-0.0469261557,
-0.0166029073,
-0.0042841686,
-0.0826099738,
0.0094344476,
-0.0028383655,
0.0585244447,
0.0380699113,
-0.058496207,
-0.0724283531,
-0.0184683818,
0.0058936714,
-0.0188486278,
-0.0065582725,
-0.0213130694,
-0.0439890213,
-0.0589091331,
-0.0115877939,
-0.0009961772,
0.0464809686,
0.0502269901,
0.0359919332,
0.0216321852,
-0.0063259318,
-0.0499400683,
-0.0566204861,
-0.0892164111,
-0.0394008644,
-0.0386803709,
0.0097943647,
0.0049467166,
0.0388702452,
0.0087592434,
0.008393365,
0.0535627864,
0.027046198,
-0.0387830399,
0.0108874459,
0.051714547,
0.0281100497,
0.0284802392,
0.0475258417,
-0.034044344,
0.0212390628,
-0.012077502,
0.0421865061,
-0.0011323981,
-0.0139444685,
0.0146620497,
-0.06383764,
-0.0206273682,
0.0031542114,
0.0172297712,
-0.0102206077,
0.0177777,
-0.0481453761,
-0.0179100186,
-0.0656357929,
-0.0029255536,
0.0227782764,
0.0277152024,
-0.02145111,
0.0241077747,
0.0199602656,
0.0271829367,
-0.0028168813,
0.0218722336,
0.0321255811,
-0.0168489255,
-0.0183030237,
0.016628271,
-0.0586267672,
0.0122362822,
-0.029178597,
0.0081394324,
-0.0239112619,
0.054895144,
0.0228486806,
-0.0008528716,
-0.0348304845,
0.0319260582,
-0.0816753507,
0.0463403687,
-0.0290898625,
-0.0078091035,
0.0403263234,
0.0117621366,
0.0294712726,
-0.0254159234,
0.0141747212,
0.0154365823,
0.0792056471,
-0.0121385055,
-0.0479137115,
0.0205451623,
-0.0039794329,
-0.0106001506,
-0.0315706581,
0.0665773749,
-0.0046832287,
0.0428832397,
-0.0199830234,
0.0264954064,
-0.0496746749,
-0.0315957032,
0.0265033059,
0.0604444332,
0.0178093333,
0.0261872951,
-0.0159752052,
-0.0216201898,
0.0297173485,
0.0028387809,
0.0200678259,
0.0087426221,
0.0095306495,
0.0180617981,
-0.0191552509,
-0.0236570574,
-0.0410067663,
0.0179588292,
-0.0113838529,
-0.0485567711,
-0.0621083528,
-5.651592066e-33,
-0.0233474635,
-0.0253066551,
-0.0083725071,
-0.0130067728,
-0.0641925037,
0.0045964578,
-0.0434476361,
-0.0242422167,
0.0471867323,
0.0298194308,
0.0517106168,
0.0109392926,
-0.0143591594,
0.0574295148,
-0.0116121517,
0.0152397975,
0.0700659007,
0.0113540776,
-0.0151437623,
0.0152712921,
0.0499376617,
0.0388002805,
0.0082989177,
-0.039221637,
-0.0106281294,
-0.0165830869,
-0.0108342106,
0.000297656,
0.0180171765,
0.0443918742,
-0.018717967,
0.0305241365,
0.0273122527,
-0.0020265039,
-0.0318221115,
0.0340898633,
-0.0573108718,
-0.0083948337,
-0.0066087628,
-0.0018198772,
-0.058402501,
-0.0807105005,
0.0468912795,
-0.0277223848,
0.0372292362,
-0.0603913628,
0.0288877208,
-0.0077840202,
-0.007501496,
-0.0444332249,
-0.1046670228,
-0.0036744166,
-0.0337945409,
0.0040604696,
0.0144207301,
0.0550038107,
0.021472251,
0.0078119664,
-0.0468563475,
-0.0165577848,
-0.0308048371,
0.0222553834,
-0.0006007275,
-0.0106381765,
-0.0142744863,
0.0607282817,
-0.0271931011,
-0.0658141822,
-0.0275246575,
0.0481264405,
0.0132335722,
0.0454602763,
0.0262578074,
0.0536106192,
0.0192884542,
-0.003418416,
-0.0551566221,
0.0277920906,
-0.0385172628,
-0.0289236624,
0.0515382141,
0.0152354902,
0.0010511434,
-0.0007283717,
-0.0105736926,
-0.031940531,
-0.0331577584,
-0.0327542312,
0.0393320173,
0.0256070755,
-0.0120186564,
-0.0095642759,
0.0320552997,
-0.0514942966,
-0.0027391887,
0.0343668647,
-0.0477278046,
0.0234915763,
0.0341212377,
0.0041103722,
-0.0232455637,
-0.0349849723,
0.0389905311,
0.0480919182,
0.0149416709,
-0.0068873158,
0.0882602111,
-0.003273336,
-0.0151866106,
0.0032332379,
-0.0439222194,
-0.0191990361,
-0.063543126,
0.0227078684,
0.0170967244,
0.035474278,
-0.0554328337,
0.0345027968,
-0.0210580416,
0.0298636444,
-0.0221037921,
-0.0339394845,
0.0171238426,
0.0786508173,
-0.045298811,
-0.0192788225,
-0.0101198079,
0.0217388421,
0.0277406145,
-0.0518985614,
0.0010475361,
-0.0120547106,
2.281e-7,
0.0374909341,
0.0096922768,
0.0493506789,
0.0046051727,
0.026550144,
0.0170346461,
0.0101367645,
0.065582417,
-0.041057054,
0.0372506604,
0.0562586635,
0.0226161275,
0.0418030582,
-0.0069449623,
-0.0370186642,
0.0608280562,
-0.0870488733,
-0.0250501167,
-0.0483748205,
-0.0179058742,
0.1543277651,
0.069548063,
0.0018641077,
0.0162776597,
0.0399913117,
-0.0040761754,
0.1000154987,
0.0120961014,
0.0146386428,
-0.0156523548,
-0.0097898385,
0.0105754863,
0.0127013382,
-0.0341384634,
-0.0086434903,
0.0288393293,
0.0045566252,
0.0536177419,
0.0169019625,
-0.0241904631,
0.004145137,
0.0110221272,
0.0080004632,
-0.029439481,
0.0604436733,
-0.1052410603,
-0.0248388555,
-0.0133508807,
-0.0118570961,
0.0184314996,
0.0241282973,
0.006669201,
-0.0185177103,
0.0125227896,
0.0387218408,
-0.0055650738,
0.0007022297,
-0.0713015348,
-0.0464133546,
0.005710484,
-0.0446076877,
0.0114598405,
-0.0723732337,
0.0110387038,
0.0445891097,
-0.0294464603,
-0.0283283945,
2.196960371e-34,
0.0202435646,
0.0086839655,
0.0241133757,
0.0132536767,
0.0343865305,
-0.0115226759,
0.0146683045,
0.0017580278,
0.0273166802,
-0.0571062192,
-0.0118930712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14597v1 | Voices of Her: Analyzing Gender Differences in the AI Publication World | 2023-05-24T00:40:49 | 2023-05-24T00:40:49 | Yiwen Ding, Jiarui Liu, Zhiheng Lyu, Kun Zhang, Bernhard Schoelkopf, Zhijing Jin, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While several previous studies have analyzed gender bias in research, we are
still missing a comprehensive analysis of gender differences in the AI
community, covering diverse topics and different development trends. Using the
AI Scholar dataset of 78K researchers in the field of AI, we identify several
gender differences: (1) Although female researchers tend to have fewer overall
citations than males, this citation difference does not hold for all
academic-age groups; (2) There exist large gender homophily in co-authorship on
AI papers; (3) Female first-authored papers show distinct linguistic styles,
such as longer text, more positive emotion words, and more catchy titles than
male first-authored papers. Our analysis provides a window into the current
demographic trends in our AI community, and encourages more gender equality and
diversity in the future. Our code and data are at
https://github.com/causalNLP/ai-scholar-gender. | [
0.039205797,
0.072852239,
-0.0362924263,
-0.0300189052,
-0.018199876,
-0.002853323,
0.0816077441,
-0.039723821,
0.0021118976,
-0.0269965827,
0.0157793108,
0.0198369473,
0.0235747993,
0.0451944359,
0.007115914,
-0.0101794573,
-0.001345929,
0.0292853005,
0.084604688,
-0.0288001094,
-0.017090261,
0.0155247608,
-0.0100490479,
0.0565084629,
0.0466808788,
-0.0720025674,
0.0290080663,
0.0114751356,
-0.012594535,
-0.0189317726,
0.0361231975,
0.0212216713,
-0.009331407,
0.0320649147,
0.0000019296,
-0.0521234348,
0.0191005468,
0.0516261868,
0.0113569116,
-0.0060381754,
0.0228357445,
0.0142493583,
-0.0373144224,
0.0067090681,
-0.0319460072,
-0.0173213817,
0.0202551913,
0.0291265771,
-0.0306455083,
0.0029201731,
-0.009964413,
0.0322094671,
0.0418977551,
0.0073641031,
0.0087435748,
0.0177970249,
-0.0181062948,
-0.03503111,
0.0209958442,
-0.0125804534,
0.0041981749,
0.0462690927,
-0.028446395,
-0.0282872953,
0.0145422919,
0.0871492773,
0.0032989122,
-0.0367370807,
0.0104559092,
0.0091159241,
0.0728991032,
0.0056986031,
0.0425830111,
0.0209139604,
0.0147772636,
0.0300486814,
-0.0400810689,
0.0203127339,
-0.0106801698,
-0.0598778091,
0.0172559731,
-0.0140758883,
0.0128717907,
0.0634024218,
-0.0013838123,
0.0622716844,
-0.0193101466,
-0.0239961762,
0.0297507681,
-0.0235512387,
0.0562363602,
-0.0285757221,
-0.0061365338,
-0.0092090573,
0.0170803349,
-0.0355932787,
0.0041233595,
-0.0403943323,
0.0042719115,
-0.0197547283,
0.0076174946,
0.0005733853,
0.0493520014,
0.0279082879,
0.0097785275,
0.0138315996,
-0.0030783997,
0.0210237373,
0.0121255349,
-0.0025797854,
-0.0524048284,
-0.0237283316,
-0.0064792959,
0.0012723842,
0.0482804142,
-0.0197597891,
-0.0358457863,
-0.0019699973,
-0.0590691939,
-0.0052381074,
-0.0149968341,
0.0467464812,
-0.0149165532,
0.0166161824,
0.0432441682,
0.0147716422,
-0.0510262884,
0.0394976921,
-0.0047836518,
-0.0469280034,
-0.0056864545,
0.0266731121,
0.0154171074,
-0.0199606419,
0.0314735323,
-0.0120701278,
0.0235954933,
-0.0465952531,
-0.0016323591,
-0.0230135322,
0.0209773313,
-0.0496535227,
0.0512473248,
-0.0532874875,
0.0214098748,
0.0546845868,
0.0339922644,
-0.0766771808,
-0.0263031684,
-0.0136053609,
0.0237265807,
-0.0011634346,
-0.0033250349,
-0.0004044123,
0.0818248838,
0.0096136723,
-0.0162070859,
0.0272117723,
0.0789293274,
0.0076905205,
0.0401947349,
0.0175779704,
0.0298785698,
-0.0089591863,
0.0172287729,
0.0473900996,
0.0292595737,
0.0156994089,
-0.0462518334,
0.0407293029,
0.0446329527,
-0.0122711556,
0.0164732486,
0.0265881587,
0.0329654925,
0.0899054781,
-0.0043829898,
0.0924878344,
0.0124019356,
-0.013024033,
0.0349793434,
-0.0305924397,
-0.0187987536,
0.0340213105,
0.0046133562,
-0.0275872741,
-0.0304747149,
0.0354963988,
-0.0256687421,
-0.0495618246,
0.0157561712,
0.0029708825,
0.0084562972,
0.0022485321,
0.0346303582,
0.0129313888,
0.0227401089,
-0.0560432374,
-0.0279212035,
-0.0632556155,
-0.0272706058,
-0.0242693834,
0.0357084982,
0.0026826884,
0.0206521023,
-0.0506329909,
0.0124030085,
-0.0394658409,
-0.0204816777,
0.0241427943,
-0.0063313232,
0.034564428,
-0.0146195395,
-0.0015365316,
0.0004033319,
-0.0055536898,
0.0059682559,
0.0111458702,
0.0312080123,
0.0701503605,
-0.0044707139,
-0.0058996044,
-0.0707881153,
0.0075419806,
-0.0301520284,
-0.025618704,
0.0290486906,
-0.0319213942,
0.0376266502,
0.0396695845,
-0.0553637221,
0.0208014175,
0.0312752798,
-0.0112414071,
-0.0418674797,
0.0554914959,
0.0559031703,
0.0636069104,
-0.0151337041,
-0.0951179639,
-0.0407993682,
0.0049825357,
0.0019164644,
0.0123126665,
0.0946335047,
-0.012391326,
-0.0233615004,
0.0452823713,
-0.0052151913,
-0.0098080235,
0.0121750552,
-0.0055458816,
0.0123791723,
-0.0373240821,
-0.0320697017,
0.018511666,
-0.0444941595,
-0.0186402835,
-0.0229432676,
-0.0359692052,
0.0290562306,
0.0008936364,
0.0113204652,
0.0276904013,
-0.0595504045,
-0.0310714729,
-0.0267368257,
-0.0504107028,
-0.014458837,
0.0130803781,
-0.0154472133,
-0.0435608663,
-0.0121337222,
-0.0233157668,
0.0064112954,
0.0210182574,
-0.0373145975,
-0.0335922316,
-0.0080949822,
0.0321308598,
0.0120093916,
0.0356367938,
-0.0590883121,
-0.0141373202,
-0.0588387139,
0.0182235017,
0.1036335081,
0.00018687,
-0.0080349976,
0.0223314296,
-0.03978597,
-0.0149090821,
-0.0442520268,
0.012839959,
0.0025680102,
0.0070125004,
0.0057561249,
0.0904090032,
-0.0051717297,
0.0526575223,
0.0497392565,
0.0243597142,
-0.0178318117,
0.0063668368,
0.031741146,
0.0426299572,
0.0403671004,
-0.0593336411,
0.049798809,
-0.0258895196,
-0.0268037189,
-0.0054368605,
0.0100295711,
0.0463471077,
-0.0319234952,
-0.0182165783,
0.0070352652,
-0.0065747853,
0.0257148724,
0.0517087243,
0.0090178158,
-0.0217831321,
0.0231429543,
-0.0049854377,
0.0060693594,
-0.0491635352,
-0.0231405832,
-0.036857035,
0.0378108881,
-0.0440290868,
0.003446674,
0.0274287611,
0.0383471921,
-0.0712923184,
-0.0278507322,
-0.0050051128,
-0.0014900815,
0.002198915,
-0.0079189511,
0.0025351571,
-0.0003123581,
-0.0277342573,
0.0172384437,
-0.0316879377,
-0.0129683372,
0.0035840597,
0.0437795855,
-0.0522934012,
-0.0558613651,
-0.0316563547,
0.0670405105,
0.0233152658,
-0.0181791913,
-0.0365200378,
-0.015724225,
-0.0131455027,
0.0709466487,
-0.0050291778,
0.0022381621,
-0.0170612894,
-0.0305241775,
0.0073826783,
0.002921222,
0.0355893858,
-0.0318065807,
-0.0147716589,
0.0372722782,
-0.0604344793,
-0.0416187122,
-0.0147820739,
-0.0044421204,
-0.0391570777,
0.0256476123,
0.073681064,
0.0077663185,
-0.093231976,
-0.013329166,
-0.0451505408,
0.0269010346,
0.0299169626,
0.0280662645,
-0.0434823222,
0.0489964746,
0.0257249828,
-0.0062709292,
-0.0669183731,
-0.0372059867,
-0.0219491217,
-0.0771534219,
0.0023676024,
-0.0091126338,
-0.039284274,
-0.0018305255,
-0.0474415198,
-0.0114311893,
0.0028578357,
-0.0174043737,
-0.0019885926,
-0.0180050377,
0.0260308478,
-0.0068331067,
-0.0546861328,
-0.012204811,
0.0045144749,
-0.0712619573,
0.0523630381,
0.0350256637,
0.1000957862,
-0.0626721233,
-0.000308582,
-0.0559736304,
0.0316595547,
0.0030878722,
-0.0067131906,
0.0371998847,
-0.0459548235,
0.0075489995,
-0.0692896172,
0.0333592705,
-0.0049426844,
0.0266525485,
0.0591553748,
0.0073244302,
-0.003427556,
-0.0147167081,
-0.0852412507,
-0.0252137277,
0.0103556253,
0.0069696885,
-0.00989909,
-0.0293555688,
-0.0565725006,
-0.0231069233,
0.0547202788,
0.0317958072,
-0.0557202026,
-0.0606878251,
0.0046171215,
-0.0180240162,
-0.0225907024,
-0.0791344717,
-0.0172664635,
-0.0078645553,
0.0167846866,
-0.0502430685,
0.0402599312,
0.0209450349,
-0.0857943892,
-0.0053173113,
0.0142717781,
0.0206493046,
0.0133399107,
-0.0141279455,
0.0097624464,
-0.0017946585,
-0.0170981977,
0.0164433196,
0.0246145613,
0.0018232407,
0.0246841609,
0.0529721454,
0.0190017298,
-0.0051685339,
-0.0121589042,
-0.0385299064,
0.0221730731,
0.0507239066,
-0.0025622759,
0.0281408839,
0.0408495739,
-0.0226188153,
-0.0076250276,
-0.0122784441,
-0.0222653374,
-0.0129261278,
0.0071469094,
-0.0462991334,
-0.0244204942,
-0.0209793448,
-0.0095740445,
0.0205635633,
0.0036240362,
-0.0403317101,
0.0404388085,
0.0165122431,
-0.0149601698,
-0.0139158759,
0.0036933012,
-0.0134577518,
-0.0483095981,
0.0120896362,
0.0143497903,
0.0082116257,
0.0595988594,
0.0045089386,
-0.0007640675,
-0.0553565212,
0.0553155541,
-0.0185597949,
0.0923682153,
-0.0149238277,
-0.0096704066,
0.0055753659,
0.0127059147,
-0.0256416164,
0.0416908935,
0.0211129393,
0.0111979898,
0.0016224877,
-0.0145249926,
-0.0080126552,
0.0303390902,
-0.1036564112,
-0.0720122382,
0.0249160901,
0.0064275609,
0.0038596801,
0.0186196491,
0.0545314774,
-0.0081971865,
0.0206846204,
0.0075080344,
0.0226032846,
0.0108016869,
0.0248469561,
-0.0022028014,
0.0077141612,
0.0066958442,
-0.0238299426,
0.0485717915,
0.0382637829,
0.0395761617,
0.0107470537,
-0.0283782836,
0.0115470141,
-0.0498125851,
-0.0004523809,
0.0098033883,
0.0364993028,
-0.007948705,
-0.0584435612,
-0.0238973219,
0.0392205417,
-0.0435488373,
0.0138451383,
-0.0579854026,
-0.0247071814,
0.0360397249,
0.0064953328,
-0.0613963753,
-0.0496587381,
-0.0029116366,
-0.0562047958,
-0.0486452691,
-0.0240922756,
-5.783165883e-33,
0.0028269428,
-0.0560689867,
-0.0045593772,
0.0122218989,
-0.0486605018,
0.0149078527,
-0.031544216,
0.032926444,
-0.0306167658,
0.0494179763,
-0.0819613039,
0.0467494838,
0.0004744682,
-0.0050044362,
0.0440082923,
0.033717487,
0.0308513921,
0.0123696681,
-0.0243507009,
0.0186793543,
-0.0657577068,
-0.005194881,
-0.0216503199,
-0.1073219478,
0.1027469859,
-0.0186558515,
-0.0064542843,
-0.0575821623,
-0.0084066242,
0.024796119,
0.0214616992,
0.0469288751,
0.0030785203,
-0.0100935204,
0.0095181484,
0.0140771652,
-0.0660036728,
-0.0194659326,
-0.0061864266,
0.0161810424,
0.0169103779,
-0.0435192361,
0.0438474491,
0.0338823125,
-0.0627862066,
-0.0396381877,
0.1134759411,
0.0305435341,
0.0395755731,
-0.0366933122,
-0.072529912,
0.002891694,
-0.0757293776,
0.0294562727,
0.0153518924,
0.0337250344,
-0.0125472415,
0.0310153961,
-0.0989231244,
0.0381712429,
-0.0591755919,
-0.0003321694,
0.0022506809,
-0.0347957835,
0.0462228768,
0.0167540405,
0.068546325,
0.0616277084,
-0.0391852893,
-0.0557773598,
0.0418316238,
0.0122334929,
0.0437282212,
0.0475093387,
0.0276913792,
0.0094064483,
-0.0344409458,
-0.0307938401,
0.0348350033,
0.0182568971,
0.0223655105,
-0.0023632864,
-0.0885279998,
-0.0302523952,
0.0169613659,
-0.0658107996,
0.0125564868,
-0.017491756,
-0.0334427804,
-0.0327030905,
-0.0279983748,
-0.0044023758,
-0.0377287008,
-0.067761682,
-0.0513406731,
0.03145089,
0.0006399426,
0.0265870262,
0.0216915496,
-0.0133582037,
-0.0729336515,
0.0029435328,
-0.0399496518,
0.0822390392,
0.0665316954,
0.0324659199,
0.0100914687,
0.0227983203,
-0.0475277118,
-0.0559940003,
-0.0152172735,
-0.0057573779,
0.0278458297,
0.015476984,
-0.0252026096,
0.0351006053,
0.0172602665,
-0.029146919,
0.0601696819,
0.0689472333,
-0.0008717702,
-0.0062860595,
-0.0327066407,
0.0033877504,
-0.005802942,
-0.0431323908,
-0.0396793224,
0.0498353429,
0.0283328407,
-0.0762097016,
-0.0272818878,
-0.0726850852,
2.629e-7,
0.0011143961,
0.0538287498,
0.0014713217,
0.017109707,
0.0295134,
0.0287120081,
0.0130666867,
0.0324322917,
0.0583406352,
0.0577972867,
0.0065279067,
0.0348191597,
-0.021657221,
0.0035937221,
-0.0592481792,
-0.0196654908,
-0.1041139066,
-0.006191676,
-0.0204435159,
0.0431475379,
-0.0150631415,
-0.0270760022,
0.0419757105,
0.01205594,
-0.0254642554,
-0.0100071253,
0.0064007351,
0.0048059151,
0.0758787319,
0.058726158,
-0.038516365,
-0.0058904556,
-0.0016570521,
0.005380556,
0.007389355,
-0.0144591779,
0.0062978105,
0.004793291,
-0.0057782116,
0.0625964254,
0.0624061041,
0.0283544082,
-0.0017645361,
-0.058216773,
0.0580078512,
0.0132687818,
-0.0821666643,
-0.0598751307,
-0.0190672707,
-0.0304720365,
0.0892248005,
-0.0241670609,
-0.0065309554,
0.0096986778,
-0.0008908575,
-0.0108362716,
-0.0047603375,
-0.014133581,
-0.0112836221,
-0.0108127883,
0.0042800852,
-0.0507062748,
-0.017074205,
0.0157007799,
0.04761976,
-0.0387622938,
0.0410445258,
2.11061503e-34,
0.008392415,
0.007981116,
-0.0078337779,
0.0535906851,
0.0268473066,
0.0064171697,
-0.0155822691,
-0.0185516197,
0.0541173182,
0.0387425162,
-0.0061271167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14596v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14596v2 | Increasing Probability Mass on Answer Choices Does Not Always Improve Accuracy | 2023-05-24T00:27:00 | 2023-10-31T22:07:10 | Sarah Wiegreffe, Matthew Finlayson, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | When pretrained language models (LMs) are applied to discriminative tasks
such as multiple-choice questions, they place probability mass on vocabulary
tokens that aren't among the given answer choices. Spreading probability mass
across multiple surface forms with identical meaning (such as "bath" and
"bathtub") is thought to cause an underestimation of a model's true
performance, referred to as the "surface form competition" (SFC) hypothesis.
This has motivated the introduction of various probability normalization
methods. However, many core questions remain unanswered. How do we measure SFC?
Are there direct ways of reducing it, and does doing so improve task
performance?
We propose a mathematical formalism for SFC which allows us to quantify and
bound its impact for the first time. We identify a simple method for reducing
it -- namely, increasing probability mass on the given answer choices by a)
including them in the prompt and b) using in-context learning with even just
one example. We show this method eliminates the impact of SFC in the majority
of instances. Our experiments on three diverse datasets and six LMs reveal
several additional surprising findings. For example, both normalization and
prompting methods for reducing SFC can be ineffective or even detrimental to
task performance for some LMs. We conclude with practical insights for
effectively prompting LMs for multiple-choice tasks. | [
0.0124066286,
0.0232796352,
-0.0072908835,
0.0261580106,
-0.0314448364,
-0.0047637965,
0.0065478268,
-0.0099403411,
-0.0069943615,
-0.0285302904,
-0.0251049474,
-0.0777026415,
0.023808077,
0.0132126417,
0.0116682174,
-0.0481905006,
0.0471582972,
-0.0442616343,
0.0107073057,
-0.0139307715,
-0.0045802058,
-0.014259669,
0.0010035363,
0.0188036524,
0.0082158968,
0.0055334088,
-0.0033314214,
-0.0127093289,
-0.0166625399,
-0.0291152354,
-0.0036701907,
0.104822278,
-0.0004095193,
0.0207226202,
0.0000021293,
-0.0729055107,
0.0062233182,
-0.0440669581,
-0.0146100102,
0.0185503084,
0.0040087719,
0.0205729678,
0.031819243,
0.0261669606,
-0.0269252956,
-0.012760181,
0.0498489514,
0.0053162361,
-0.0149720041,
0.0335762165,
0.0140850293,
0.0158165284,
0.0016565321,
-0.0002715412,
0.0413821228,
-0.0261898655,
0.005546201,
-0.0062179361,
-0.0334422514,
0.0036244767,
-0.0194041878,
0.0221561845,
0.0017549405,
0.0230298396,
0.0232328866,
0.0708058849,
0.0274595767,
-0.0101131219,
-0.0017467691,
0.0742017254,
-0.010256934,
-0.0307210051,
-0.039720457,
-0.0377452448,
0.0140265161,
0.0742183253,
-0.0276878029,
0.0296451896,
-0.0106201014,
0.0195260663,
0.0106852381,
-0.0037090669,
0.0153738568,
0.0247210916,
-0.0063641076,
0.0724388212,
0.0233167671,
-0.0251445193,
0.0416161828,
0.0381257497,
-0.0524530374,
-0.0621074475,
0.0370489061,
0.0004948323,
-0.0326022953,
0.024012031,
-0.0454829447,
-0.0357998982,
0.027783053,
-0.0530415997,
0.0542244464,
0.0201369878,
-0.0131602846,
0.022764029,
0.0020243439,
0.0555265881,
0.0109985676,
0.0433085822,
-0.1005118415,
0.0223211199,
-0.0048839496,
0.0044518639,
-0.0353046358,
0.0281410441,
-0.0368891843,
-0.0228045192,
-0.0441594906,
0.0158571284,
0.0065573314,
-0.0383621082,
0.0010179791,
0.0261716954,
-0.0237060804,
0.0174341984,
-0.0674252734,
0.0559153929,
-0.0405509248,
0.0551110059,
0.0061327037,
-0.0475211404,
-0.0128386654,
-0.0198638663,
0.026003696,
-0.0336136892,
0.0042835376,
0.0064544277,
-0.0453301556,
-0.0435008705,
-0.0109848147,
-0.0451016165,
-0.0244630985,
-0.0245462153,
-0.0158604868,
-0.0557250269,
0.0123766875,
-0.0075451941,
-0.0028297999,
-0.0090295225,
-0.0043888465,
0.0225006696,
-0.0199441202,
0.0991410762,
0.0195891261,
0.0071613635,
0.0591845587,
0.0212665983,
0.0139755346,
0.0715465471,
0.0185529608,
0.0093724858,
0.0489044748,
-0.0315471552,
0.0278722104,
0.0456675887,
0.0187942851,
0.0031579148,
0.0173046123,
-0.0004969047,
0.0482611544,
0.0272129625,
0.0408257879,
0.0353423916,
-0.0282649565,
-0.0438719206,
0.0759129673,
0.0833443776,
-0.0435526334,
-0.060226623,
0.0134209199,
-0.0121041257,
0.0013187927,
0.0553553998,
-0.0544660389,
-0.0404190272,
-0.0706394464,
-0.0010922994,
0.0367401727,
-0.0115776341,
-0.0368614867,
-0.0519246794,
-0.0220340006,
-0.01058299,
0.0344678685,
0.0409335382,
0.0480227806,
-0.0022633122,
-0.0144754574,
0.056823656,
-0.0015971948,
-0.0470806472,
0.0395242013,
-0.0662400499,
0.0491665341,
0.0097342255,
0.0123402216,
-0.02753089,
-0.0473771095,
0.0263154153,
-0.0051934915,
0.0223141126,
0.07178092,
-0.0326591842,
0.034495607,
-0.0230539404,
-0.0288109425,
0.0419304669,
0.0103827929,
0.0079260822,
0.0254849903,
-0.0161816347,
0.0073562292,
-0.0625390559,
-0.0003019814,
0.0394923873,
0.0142540354,
-0.0630793571,
0.0102397772,
0.0023547206,
0.0307043046,
-0.0096259275,
0.0208329912,
0.0242621955,
0.0083896713,
-0.0192603506,
-0.0081941877,
-0.0411558375,
-0.073211886,
-0.0119775059,
0.0436915196,
0.0252986383,
0.0230610911,
0.034052331,
-0.0298466776,
-0.030701939,
-0.007730573,
-0.0102717578,
0.0321228728,
-0.0271343011,
0.0102072945,
-0.0066432506,
0.026243316,
-0.087329261,
0.0668684393,
0.0072378586,
0.0386321023,
0.0021190741,
0.0212343484,
0.0140776355,
-0.0408073738,
-0.021175079,
-0.020327745,
-0.0015683532,
0.0166850332,
0.0463148244,
-0.0060097962,
-0.0702443719,
0.0239663869,
-0.0979437232,
-0.0136871394,
-0.0048680278,
0.0170067102,
0.0177205577,
0.0293209758,
-0.0201755948,
-0.0202925876,
-0.0159170572,
-0.0420211591,
0.0109008355,
0.0810087323,
0.0188906435,
-0.0143181002,
0.0081367092,
-0.0363441817,
-0.0324854106,
-0.0185059626,
0.0390172489,
0.0214458965,
0.0379911363,
-0.0523245819,
0.0711490363,
-0.0366177335,
0.0267765466,
0.0111879371,
0.0108833695,
0.0040802374,
-0.0357113816,
0.0672441125,
0.0735868216,
-0.0050566909,
0.0106480187,
0.0812660158,
0.0170245543,
-0.0876269415,
-0.024982661,
-0.0263451599,
-0.0622147806,
-0.0301756952,
-0.0636663288,
0.0145047652,
0.0720183477,
0.0402218811,
-0.0188528448,
-0.0342323706,
0.0292118527,
-0.0538711175,
-0.0103770243,
-0.0554053672,
-0.0168883763,
-0.0288323071,
0.0757707506,
-0.0003539373,
-0.0662482604,
0.0784852877,
-0.0440034941,
0.0186104868,
-0.0758972317,
-0.0056739827,
0.011650078,
0.0612391569,
-0.0020622755,
-0.0033593341,
0.0514977053,
-0.0350643806,
-0.071340099,
-0.0353245437,
0.0206939448,
-0.0505121797,
0.069144696,
-0.0870884359,
0.0226603933,
-0.0222227108,
-0.0324215963,
-0.0385499522,
-0.0601380244,
-0.0287718754,
0.0081784772,
-0.0284495167,
0.0185384322,
0.0235609654,
0.0256407652,
0.0018826231,
0.0286297631,
-0.0352708586,
-0.0198474638,
0.0066213696,
0.0817539096,
0.0423375592,
0.0752528459,
0.0212809741,
-0.0087171542,
-0.0002911995,
0.0353809856,
0.074974671,
0.0181541108,
-0.0013775886,
0.0120846331,
0.0436951406,
-0.0286176614,
-0.0285725147,
0.0359627157,
0.0561635122,
-0.0291081071,
-0.0190316997,
0.1249501333,
0.0295835584,
-0.0122571206,
-0.0069932118,
0.00610981,
0.0328598842,
0.0111466367,
0.0110187633,
-0.0365416259,
-0.0253813416,
-0.0183300208,
0.0038974585,
0.0063683325,
-0.0189558603,
0.0145729166,
-0.0977126136,
-0.0149592254,
-0.0034284226,
-0.0678654611,
-0.0341719724,
-0.0781205595,
0.0118793966,
-0.0145349083,
0.0175408032,
-0.0020736579,
0.0036384321,
0.0198596232,
0.0326917693,
-0.0066630212,
-0.0645146444,
0.0124081224,
-0.0523560569,
0.0146258958,
0.0469420515,
-0.0139183877,
-0.0217397101,
-0.0436030626,
0.0417907313,
-0.0378906205,
-0.0138162477,
-0.033504542,
0.0057915379,
0.0396128558,
0.0114979371,
-0.0049661179,
0.0036397027,
-0.0137766749,
-0.0274842009,
0.0157105774,
0.0772431195,
-0.0164517388,
-0.0177017134,
-0.0172220152,
-0.0075856149,
0.0291833747,
0.0939628631,
0.0184001829,
-0.0426241197,
0.0013557407,
-0.0364277065,
0.023680523,
0.0187961143,
-0.0407791957,
0.0097896969,
-0.0277364552,
-0.0019844337,
-0.0451510176,
-0.0430666022,
0.0426187143,
0.0316619352,
0.0002299052,
0.018463565,
-0.0056522158,
0.0143459933,
-0.0112551609,
0.0745967403,
-0.05451262,
0.0212203581,
-0.0032675799,
-0.0186243933,
-0.0056612636,
-0.0106171044,
-0.036666818,
0.0002383498,
-0.0510407612,
-0.0358812734,
-0.0063920957,
-0.0022153461,
0.0207649637,
0.0047028237,
0.0035052428,
-0.0655694678,
0.0651554465,
-0.0395727754,
0.0193455499,
0.0219334438,
0.0024097194,
0.015494951,
-0.0206518322,
0.0165212993,
-0.0118270842,
-0.0058575426,
0.0410351306,
0.0561516732,
-0.0344266854,
-0.0570013262,
0.0144292805,
0.0358110294,
0.1051760763,
-0.0020935268,
0.0061262469,
-0.0468950905,
-0.00004529,
-0.0024212825,
-0.0109375268,
0.0021062263,
-0.0200379957,
0.0414742529,
-0.0341704935,
-0.0277256779,
-0.0032703092,
-0.039254576,
0.0470418446,
-0.0207625721,
-0.0268514361,
0.0696709752,
0.0036755821,
0.0288298223,
-0.008414533,
-0.0347866006,
-0.0065357806,
0.0061995205,
0.0424864925,
-0.0059596691,
0.0510438085,
-0.0277376957,
-0.0114848223,
-0.0057093361,
-0.0172873605,
-0.067028515,
-0.0407927036,
-0.0238500275,
0.0520194471,
0.0155827682,
-0.035306219,
-0.0037321839,
-0.0069807237,
-0.0014524098,
-0.0589088127,
-0.0212727841,
0.0241644196,
-0.0030268312,
0.0576524213,
0.0146898413,
0.0023383282,
-0.0071525886,
0.0750843659,
-0.0068880082,
0.0304053165,
-0.0230236333,
-0.024664795,
-0.0146631962,
-0.008325669,
0.0118180262,
0.0775497034,
-0.0499218963,
-0.0092740068,
-0.0841770023,
-0.0549630113,
-0.0031965738,
0.0455086753,
0.0191949941,
0.0190889388,
0.0401907898,
0.0718665421,
-0.0573310554,
-0.0280896444,
-0.0064332448,
0.0410473198,
-0.0506679267,
-0.0176647324,
-0.039429903,
-6.427417235e-33,
-0.044221025,
-0.012614537,
0.0176055245,
-0.0176899023,
0.0004322203,
0.0189585239,
0.003999644,
0.0319044963,
-0.0425248072,
-0.0045907814,
-0.0462450497,
-0.0035352285,
0.0243344605,
0.0244988259,
0.0197396483,
-0.0446594842,
0.0203158241,
-0.0276626814,
-0.0545358695,
-0.0185816772,
0.0029797931,
-0.008229956,
0.0608013272,
-0.028072577,
0.0195122361,
0.0237600505,
0.0040921196,
0.0380078331,
-0.0229003634,
0.0448035561,
-0.0298575312,
0.0678345263,
0.0190027338,
-0.0474267825,
-0.0212274361,
0.0809175819,
-0.0527654141,
-0.0596074201,
0.0352398753,
0.0169623364,
-0.0250864942,
-0.0098762829,
0.0255594999,
-0.0039522783,
-0.0289027784,
-0.0127425985,
0.030863855,
-0.0101215811,
-0.037755236,
0.0018675309,
-0.0112930266,
0.0040208977,
0.0207455158,
-0.0190801639,
0.0082244808,
-0.0059086266,
0.0118019842,
0.0023278838,
-0.0107403928,
0.029848909,
0.017368516,
0.0714658275,
0.0503250249,
0.0638684109,
-0.0314938426,
0.0339410827,
0.0415567756,
-0.0203151349,
0.0166972894,
-0.039570678,
0.0491730869,
-0.0194124281,
0.0348239504,
0.028745722,
0.0604162887,
0.0407071598,
-0.0538722686,
0.0681325793,
0.0044792602,
-0.0118149789,
-0.0038005111,
-0.0239923559,
-0.0167694371,
-0.0563533194,
-0.0843760371,
0.018610293,
-0.0501840264,
0.027698515,
0.0316464864,
0.0022673889,
-0.0102204075,
-0.0005516714,
0.0383315571,
-0.0226802155,
-0.0489541329,
0.0093588252,
0.0610388145,
0.0002663962,
-0.0100255348,
-0.0080291163,
-0.0234621558,
0.0094211427,
-0.0183022618,
-0.0193944797,
-0.0117440466,
0.0269042961,
-0.0073207524,
-0.0135438349,
-0.059967,
-0.0122017795,
-0.0419827029,
-0.0668990538,
0.0111775445,
0.0324572138,
0.0565067455,
0.0136954542,
-0.0036948924,
0.0041639139,
0.0028775453,
-0.0252757911,
-0.0512382612,
-0.0119784614,
-0.0147033939,
0.0466891229,
-0.0161064472,
0.0182573255,
-0.0223565195,
-0.025438454,
0.0499171056,
-0.0309206434,
-0.0215172544,
0.0314340256,
2.75e-7,
0.0627672598,
0.040840786,
-0.0242289416,
0.0214681178,
-0.0266440548,
0.0619606674,
0.0183402598,
0.0075197518,
0.0401559882,
-0.0127771357,
0.0116442684,
0.0020052227,
0.0129436897,
0.0391864143,
-0.0733084306,
-0.0373554453,
-0.0135909626,
0.0349582471,
-0.021155186,
0.0028048593,
0.0299369674,
0.0927267224,
0.0277935192,
-0.038392432,
-0.02499271,
-0.0433605276,
0.0269828234,
-0.0372900479,
0.0196886379,
0.0416514501,
0.0014594049,
-0.0268537067,
0.0220924392,
0.0762183219,
-0.0222242605,
-0.002203238,
0.0436638966,
0.0467615202,
-0.0108349416,
-0.0319585428,
-0.0776022226,
-0.0085136201,
0.006232278,
-0.053678669,
0.0710248351,
-0.0244587846,
0.0288078319,
-0.0521576554,
-0.0120703494,
-0.0117978901,
0.0617132261,
0.0077220979,
-0.0369981676,
0.0002017441,
0.0019328117,
0.0260636415,
-0.0074758241,
-0.0595081709,
-0.014923946,
0.0242715348,
-0.0359098166,
-0.065052405,
-0.0076422188,
-0.0406122915,
0.0183133297,
-0.0395755582,
-0.0283834152,
2.567975086e-34,
-0.0012802572,
0.0046053235,
0.0576301143,
0.01254615,
0.0022508146,
-0.0094413338,
0.0311512835,
-0.0083077513,
0.0211368371,
-0.1059629917,
-0.002976279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14592v2 | Meta-Tuning LLMs to Leverage Lexical Knowledge for Generalizable Language Style Understanding | 2023-05-24T00:17:36 | 2024-06-06T03:20:45 | Ruohao Guo, Wei Xu, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language style is often used by writers to convey their intentions,
identities, and mastery of language. In this paper, we show that current large
language models struggle to capture some language styles without fine-tuning.
To address this challenge, we investigate whether LLMs can be meta-trained
based on representative lexicons to recognize new styles they have not been
fine-tuned on. Experiments on 13 established style classification tasks, as
well as 63 novel tasks generated using LLMs, demonstrate that meta-training
with style lexicons consistently improves zero-shot transfer across styles. We
release the code and data at http://github.com/octaviaguo/Style-LLM . | [
0.0217901617,
0.0276694968,
-0.0067493818,
0.0490608066,
-0.0141424062,
0.0011193673,
-0.0046031573,
0.018285837,
-0.0485016666,
-0.053805463,
-0.0882715061,
-0.0163760372,
-0.0147382608,
0.0122251073,
0.0451281443,
-0.0169095546,
0.0016592131,
-0.0091681425,
0.026829591,
0.0004098186,
0.037411198,
0.0468514599,
0.0009323836,
0.017619703,
0.0288516823,
-0.042994272,
0.0070375409,
0.048195444,
0.0296173207,
0.0243252739,
0.0509280451,
0.0548173338,
0.0213324521,
0.024919847,
0.0000015441,
-0.0344917998,
0.0258411653,
-0.0733854026,
0.0329411849,
-0.0221992638,
0.0598019361,
-0.0080404785,
-0.0045853001,
-0.0089513147,
-0.0205359384,
-0.0574970171,
0.0449699834,
0.0402419642,
0.06713368,
0.0953905359,
-0.0066663991,
-0.0646552518,
0.0125369364,
-0.0299842749,
0.0377099514,
-0.0055015129,
0.0233521815,
-0.045008,
-0.0155876474,
0.0143638644,
-0.0028860467,
0.0274641067,
-0.024703417,
-0.019158164,
0.0074506369,
-0.0161202569,
-0.0717901662,
0.0688825101,
-0.0109813772,
0.0563519262,
0.0334898978,
-0.0285775475,
-0.0082189133,
0.0112310117,
0.0283173881,
0.0246588178,
-0.0552317277,
-0.0048589688,
-0.0141895451,
0.0016899356,
-0.0259299707,
-0.0162865017,
0.0253858939,
0.0334103294,
0.0266886223,
0.0454845764,
0.001635646,
0.0020595866,
-0.0194401331,
-0.0152040636,
-0.0062973746,
-0.0379050262,
-0.001469886,
0.0138494968,
0.0243470576,
0.0122355307,
-0.0324041881,
-0.0089940587,
0.0058487691,
-0.0146399178,
0.104831107,
-0.0182783026,
-0.0027200303,
0.0055464054,
-0.0014579633,
0.013737727,
-0.0115771871,
0.0248584654,
-0.0328900144,
0.0010274012,
-0.0908581689,
-0.0370817445,
-0.0117066223,
-0.0199794173,
0.0509834252,
0.0230258293,
-0.0293668881,
0.00287596,
0.0143459272,
-0.0070260572,
-0.0016036122,
-0.0015910168,
-0.0126320748,
-0.0283899456,
0.013151682,
0.0330199338,
0.0027056993,
0.0370970294,
0.0075875805,
0.0024515085,
-0.0095730657,
0.030143315,
0.0193879269,
-0.0446356833,
0.0215091743,
0.0114791123,
0.0021616917,
-0.0367591232,
-0.0828069597,
0.0066679092,
-0.0220874231,
-0.0526623353,
0.0162940156,
-0.07121443,
-0.0206227787,
-0.0188809931,
0.0190463848,
-0.039115604,
-0.0222000908,
0.0022672818,
-0.0193798393,
0.0478450321,
0.0028512634,
-0.0078376727,
0.0160420723,
-0.0031721648,
0.0001092587,
0.0663931146,
0.0513246544,
0.0367084444,
0.0187432542,
-0.018127799,
0.0196378641,
0.0509080328,
0.0030836593,
0.0419602171,
-0.0564796664,
-0.0646175146,
0.0273496192,
0.0427837782,
0.0604342595,
0.0042052865,
0.0011575139,
-0.021119684,
0.0968563408,
0.0052804407,
0.0414745808,
0.0209943205,
0.0587042868,
0.0176146273,
0.0270112921,
0.0173100512,
-0.0297769364,
0.0033646093,
-0.0295021366,
0.0188124869,
-0.0365425199,
-0.0242800917,
-0.0460341386,
0.0138799045,
-0.0176750924,
-0.0028292439,
-0.0444835238,
-0.0041649048,
-0.0015127499,
0.045578897,
-0.0105670551,
0.0050304718,
0.0279668234,
-0.0692443401,
-0.0091785407,
-0.0250964575,
-0.0128835011,
0.0882299989,
0.0218992643,
-0.0106745623,
-0.027084332,
-0.0338683613,
0.0314766467,
0.0326686092,
0.0024898432,
-0.0322294272,
0.0770433173,
-0.0465361997,
0.0282563567,
-0.0399152562,
0.0096993493,
0.0096189464,
-0.032759361,
0.004116849,
-0.0028554248,
-0.0722398013,
-0.0194816571,
0.0485144034,
-0.0502603874,
-0.0687376037,
0.0247857552,
0.0038712614,
-0.0244747587,
-0.0017930062,
-0.0408854559,
-0.0320690833,
-0.0275638774,
-0.0767093077,
0.0118176136,
0.0533967167,
-0.021573117,
-0.0650966093,
0.0347188823,
-0.041123677,
-0.01559503,
0.0272699054,
-0.0485242903,
-0.0631176978,
-0.0004797813,
0.010962368,
0.0408699363,
-0.0595779978,
-0.0089138178,
-0.0245296154,
0.0170994308,
-0.037272606,
0.0268819723,
0.0067826859,
-0.0115878368,
-0.0100562666,
-0.0277696121,
-0.0037721593,
0.0256768428,
-0.0187638793,
-0.0052220267,
0.0394307077,
0.0344265588,
-0.0151315695,
0.0360011458,
-0.0495689437,
-0.0752880126,
-0.0727720186,
0.0098572671,
-0.0313951671,
0.0333564878,
0.014788961,
-0.0153123643,
-0.0415818021,
0.0193603598,
-0.062288437,
-0.0019249389,
-0.0331259035,
-0.009157273,
0.0505897254,
-0.0002326708,
-0.0079056183,
-0.0298496708,
-0.0224854127,
0.0044214875,
0.0584207252,
-0.0287505388,
0.0583714768,
-0.0125769498,
-0.0170256514,
-0.0241308641,
-0.0331280902,
-0.0083283558,
-0.0484012328,
-0.0093596233,
-0.0484372601,
-0.0031849504,
0.0259324852,
0.0507571399,
-0.0148001742,
0.0283093229,
-0.0134637449,
-0.0349557064,
-0.0163967088,
0.0443919934,
0.0022220903,
-0.0484721698,
-0.0444025025,
0.0273906421,
0.0535710007,
0.0206202306,
-0.0128849233,
-0.0463953763,
0.0205054693,
0.0714713559,
-0.0529085286,
0.0454759896,
0.0404815041,
-0.035676457,
0.0053556114,
-0.0055409856,
-0.0207835156,
0.0260502528,
-0.0374795124,
-0.0328432173,
0.0444761291,
-0.0350766182,
-0.049968902,
0.0367175527,
-0.017618509,
0.0304650497,
0.0149608785,
-0.0508214757,
-0.0444203131,
-0.0463714078,
0.0577447116,
-0.0080815842,
0.0586089678,
-0.0118906936,
0.020383453,
-0.0006112382,
-0.0184811782,
-0.0317969881,
-0.027251564,
-0.021262005,
0.0021839023,
-0.0202609543,
-0.0262208171,
0.0189245343,
-0.042323228,
-0.0145023819,
0.0416449681,
-0.0420482047,
-0.0287843887,
-0.0016283623,
0.0174351912,
0.0427265018,
0.0035462829,
-0.052162461,
-0.0231993999,
-0.0076239621,
-0.0072150668,
-0.0075598517,
0.056177184,
-0.0630448908,
0.0179046132,
0.0681298375,
-0.0562256835,
-0.0261526126,
-0.0001365736,
0.0501776189,
-0.0489583276,
-0.0155362776,
0.1153789014,
0.0359902494,
-0.0728164092,
-0.0372771844,
-0.0179395471,
0.0409285277,
0.0336630456,
0.0362349376,
-0.0569887646,
-0.0562808998,
-0.018457029,
0.0296881646,
-0.0005010794,
-0.0145407459,
-0.0370896682,
-0.0445162691,
0.0103581138,
0.0291979313,
-0.0682047457,
0.0162323359,
0.0019055664,
0.0212156363,
-0.0039033548,
-0.0056322739,
-0.0115629397,
-0.0551335588,
-0.0331420116,
0.0152869793,
-0.0222771205,
-0.058409404,
-0.0022929746,
-0.0280157924,
0.0615779608,
0.0506652035,
0.0616005622,
-0.0458480082,
-0.03498495,
0.0368379653,
-0.0000481245,
-0.0004954764,
-0.0178034995,
0.0618293695,
-0.0295708068,
0.0039021967,
0.0072381576,
0.0333164707,
-0.0411004014,
0.0093617989,
0.0299415588,
0.0234908275,
-0.0269223675,
-0.0252134278,
-0.0155264726,
-0.0061317086,
0.0243628118,
0.0350536183,
0.06536939,
-0.0642278939,
-0.0201908145,
-0.0706775635,
-0.0063917995,
-0.0554764047,
-0.0430753231,
0.0095088407,
0.0061110687,
0.0050823665,
-0.0678884163,
-0.016660504,
-0.0060427678,
0.0336863957,
0.0238396823,
0.0094155688,
-0.0501365848,
-0.0024291046,
-0.0648399964,
-0.0133047625,
-0.0383733511,
0.0195290241,
-0.0340453759,
-0.0222249776,
0.0610789657,
-0.0705786049,
0.0296353381,
0.0232771169,
-0.0805774182,
-0.0728902221,
0.0097840959,
0.054081846,
0.0108760726,
0.0334218442,
-0.0019938743,
-0.1050097644,
0.0410260819,
0.0760653615,
0.0629498735,
0.0307276826,
0.0838898495,
0.0006356086,
-0.0081874849,
0.0549332425,
-0.011033698,
0.0457043573,
0.0420146361,
0.0107460972,
-0.020854434,
0.0008576181,
0.0053188163,
-0.0159171522,
0.0185859315,
-0.0289804991,
0.0163214877,
-0.0267218668,
-0.0198845547,
-0.0045001074,
-0.0333261937,
-0.0346466601,
-0.0308448225,
0.0283029061,
-0.0236892197,
-0.026434591,
0.00000918,
-0.0245382134,
0.0514872931,
-0.0466251038,
0.0393839963,
0.010369516,
0.0335389264,
-0.0200930927,
0.0306361299,
-0.0139078926,
0.0491822734,
0.0180785563,
0.040018037,
0.012634879,
0.0353851765,
0.0254518725,
0.0153532745,
-0.0185318459,
0.0246368926,
-0.0780250952,
0.0187022723,
0.008274693,
-0.00535774,
0.06174393,
-0.0198110305,
0.0607000887,
0.0011340546,
0.0246873237,
-0.0309484433,
0.0669347122,
-0.0021206799,
-0.0049410425,
-0.0142752472,
0.0387881473,
-0.0061510694,
-0.024532536,
0.0608927384,
0.0057334388,
0.0113606434,
0.010829825,
0.0039397688,
-0.0168905575,
-0.0185848214,
0.0142436028,
0.0095727826,
0.06958621,
0.0088666761,
-0.0423664413,
-0.0632616505,
0.0743996873,
-0.0358844623,
0.022443708,
-0.0122081554,
0.0078802016,
0.0451770462,
0.0020936751,
-0.0044028959,
-0.0518208444,
0.0094391443,
0.0396743976,
0.0052113193,
-0.0084204944,
-5.270125047e-33,
-0.0287234168,
-0.0261559263,
-0.0125534916,
0.0530941412,
-0.0418066233,
-0.016676601,
-0.0411036536,
-0.0088724056,
-0.0119305141,
0.0141573139,
-0.0577495433,
0.0184572972,
-0.0080076521,
0.0422060341,
0.0324111991,
0.0034877844,
0.0510445982,
0.0254607629,
-0.0491991043,
-0.0069135278,
0.078090325,
0.0288743097,
0.1174894124,
-0.015573239,
0.0068478743,
-0.0280721486,
-0.0369132236,
0.0076463269,
0.039358288,
0.0095067378,
0.0243244004,
0.0634699017,
0.0196748599,
-0.022419408,
-0.0189858098,
-0.0138863428,
-0.0321586579,
-0.0513675287,
0.0200159159,
0.0053108381,
0.0189923756,
-0.0577517599,
0.0611870475,
-0.0196936484,
0.0233130325,
-0.0119970813,
0.0632170811,
-0.0258054864,
-0.0150546189,
-0.0465750545,
-0.0396212451,
0.0173854083,
-0.0141261593,
-0.0207120664,
0.0320858844,
-0.0117551461,
-0.0141144311,
-0.0100239711,
-0.0409460254,
0.0186159126,
-0.0328341946,
0.0380763188,
0.0020616786,
0.0806168541,
-0.0205121674,
0.0675356835,
-0.010978967,
0.0749048591,
-0.0044536246,
0.0359886289,
0.0797269195,
0.0150219006,
-0.0333315469,
0.093567051,
0.0072248122,
-0.003307638,
0.0297700986,
0.0318834893,
0.0508665591,
-0.0033520826,
0.0031379447,
0.0065431637,
0.003530988,
-0.0359905623,
-0.0549698919,
-0.0511996299,
-0.007665372,
0.005635886,
-0.0125345262,
-0.0361535363,
0.0023551669,
0.0008740867,
0.0382216088,
-0.0144054499,
-0.0413329229,
0.0146779129,
-0.058694344,
0.0630996972,
-0.0070824348,
-0.0150678065,
-0.0158742312,
-0.0101585668,
0.0187395997,
0.0245556347,
0.0256351419,
0.0008255573,
0.1039272845,
0.064605467,
-0.0603498407,
-0.0243143681,
-0.0086127501,
0.0228877701,
-0.0107512306,
-0.0107534975,
-0.0081504053,
0.0088258963,
-0.0198247284,
0.0469557084,
0.0125208059,
-0.0419436321,
-0.0078467792,
-0.0171376988,
-0.0009827877,
0.0418457203,
-0.0587889701,
-0.012710684,
-0.017787043,
-0.0441711098,
0.0331527404,
-0.0485104136,
0.010327802,
-0.0095833233,
2.304e-7,
0.0328830853,
0.0228756871,
-0.0024565745,
0.063256681,
0.0267224666,
0.0470002033,
-0.0040216609,
0.0408111252,
0.0100209815,
-0.032119479,
0.0170523748,
0.0518141985,
0.0704933554,
0.0132791391,
-0.1142800227,
0.0382031873,
-0.0512878262,
0.038594339,
-0.0333813392,
-0.0125012221,
0.0397307836,
0.0229150485,
0.0557382852,
-0.0406870469,
0.0351459794,
-0.0396247134,
0.0732590854,
-0.031864915,
0.0196209867,
0.040003404,
0.0041042031,
-0.0162698142,
0.0049954723,
-0.004630174,
-0.0109983636,
0.0086136824,
-0.0181357209,
0.0782744661,
-0.0086531518,
0.0010815071,
0.0243765134,
0.0135991052,
0.0012449069,
0.0015178878,
0.0546639711,
0.0291659106,
-0.0307956524,
-0.0886629522,
-0.0046466892,
-0.0102570746,
0.0243110154,
-0.028391704,
-0.0149629461,
0.0512797944,
-0.0027519159,
-0.0369873382,
-0.024094535,
-0.0779246315,
-0.0474804044,
0.0191063117,
0.0029470709,
0.0058822343,
0.0143874399,
-0.0178213045,
0.0032394712,
-0.0757659599,
0.0226748195,
1.693041784e-34,
0.025972493,
-0.0113660051,
0.0108879786,
0.0580648743,
0.0047631552,
0.0222038571,
-0.0168873444,
0.0207246989,
0.0173036084,
-0.0605469272,
0.0130203702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14591v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14591v3 | ALGO: Synthesizing Algorithmic Programs with LLM-Generated Oracle Verifiers | 2023-05-24T00:10:15 | 2023-12-08T00:12:58 | Kexun Zhang, Danqing Wang, Jingtao Xia, William Yang Wang, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Large language models (LLMs) excel at implementing code from functionality
descriptions but struggle with algorithmic problems that require not only
implementation but also identification of the suitable algorithm. Moreover,
LLM-generated programs lack guaranteed correctness and require human
verification. To address these challenges, we propose ALGO, a framework that
synthesizes Algorithmic programs with LLM-Generated Oracles to guide the
generation and verify their correctness. ALGO first generates a reference
oracle by prompting an LLM to exhaustively enumerate all the combinations of
relevant variables. This oracle is then utilized to guide an arbitrary search
strategy in exploring the algorithm space and to verify the synthesized
algorithms. Our study shows that the LLM-generated oracles are correct for 88%
of the cases. With the oracles as verifiers, ALGO can be integrated with any
existing code generation model in a model-agnostic manner to enhance its
performance. Experiments show that when equipped with ALGO, we achieve an 8x
better one-submission pass rate over the Codex model and a 2.6x better
one-submission pass rate over CodeT, the current state-of-the-art model on
CodeContests. We can also get 1.3x better pass rate over the ChatGPT Code
Interpreter on unseen problems. The problem set we used for testing, the
prompts we used, the verifier and solution programs, and the test cases
generated by ALGO are available at https://github.com/zkx06111/ALGO. | [
0.0026690506,
0.0399146676,
-0.0328004584,
0.0400017686,
-0.0259023514,
-0.0308715254,
-0.054862339,
0.0228219498,
0.057104934,
-0.0068527274,
-0.0100226961,
0.0510412902,
-0.0066196718,
0.0242836773,
0.0391204283,
0.0195225254,
0.0275525972,
-0.048553925,
-0.0340821072,
-0.0057506384,
-0.0079838159,
0.0234771967,
0.0224355515,
0.0369300842,
0.0656841621,
-0.0103240283,
-0.0218028557,
0.0114209335,
-0.0305538233,
-0.0278320983,
-0.0333944373,
0.0352401435,
-0.0509632751,
0.0084993793,
0.0000024688,
-0.0269363914,
-0.0254685655,
0.0601865426,
-0.0223942269,
0.0340841264,
-0.0141994478,
0.0211321674,
-0.0132958367,
0.0169470888,
-0.0157963037,
-0.010729366,
0.0308660809,
-0.0348492451,
0.0869411454,
0.0729423761,
0.0247812308,
0.0157300048,
0.0421264693,
0.0489646979,
0.0321539976,
-0.0227007233,
-0.0238069985,
0.0298315566,
0.0627926365,
0.0006616643,
0.0264838468,
0.0010496815,
0.0397797488,
0.0074888039,
0.0174756423,
-0.0013424602,
-0.039949622,
-0.015953334,
-0.0110927764,
0.0177453086,
-0.0377763063,
-0.0994250849,
0.0184813384,
0.0225706119,
-0.0370606259,
-0.0121037494,
0.0062000104,
0.0390781127,
-0.0162057821,
-0.0133430967,
0.0501893051,
-0.0353712365,
0.0334021561,
-0.0077581657,
-0.0261398517,
0.0569591485,
-0.0025431328,
-0.0228497609,
-0.013089044,
-0.014275413,
0.0108377701,
-0.0751104504,
0.0119389892,
0.0553213693,
-0.056708578,
-0.016877966,
-0.0123366499,
-0.0109868003,
0.0348375849,
-0.0299766921,
0.0251680333,
0.0406997278,
-0.0192658417,
-0.0222459622,
-0.0479970984,
0.0670076981,
-0.0284797791,
0.0338630527,
-0.0284616277,
0.0299555473,
-0.0009113922,
-0.0079399915,
-0.0379232541,
0.0536197983,
-0.0037835289,
0.0634150133,
-0.0313282013,
0.0281728599,
-0.0425874777,
0.0802702457,
-0.0372361727,
-0.0374374203,
0.0312323887,
-0.025416702,
0.0027205856,
-0.075133808,
-0.0233516432,
-0.0469305404,
-0.0220866054,
-0.0651594028,
0.0150799593,
0.0562428534,
-0.0567580909,
0.0160600897,
0.0549371541,
0.0886859074,
0.0135286981,
0.018873658,
-0.0453670695,
-0.0439662002,
0.0329125449,
-0.0710140467,
-0.0067175599,
-0.1021703705,
-0.0006905833,
0.0049804263,
-0.0160442125,
-0.0103058731,
0.0026211801,
0.0091671329,
0.0461051278,
0.0372036323,
-0.0115502588,
0.0330047645,
-0.0210713055,
0.0359021612,
-0.0043828273,
0.0352800786,
0.0568759032,
0.0013028432,
-0.0182859711,
-0.0345263556,
0.0395630971,
0.0321118571,
-0.0056463485,
-0.0147548877,
-0.0030914189,
0.0456931181,
0.0314484723,
-0.0009241318,
-0.0703041255,
0.0782412663,
-0.0087644076,
-0.0166151542,
-0.037136443,
0.0189637486,
-0.0005399446,
0.0392406099,
0.0603310503,
0.0274598785,
0.0397774838,
-0.0313062444,
-0.0380158275,
0.0329042301,
-0.0698855966,
0.0090904552,
-0.0181899741,
0.0432360731,
0.0160602126,
-0.0542463213,
-0.0199318621,
0.0234573875,
-0.0344688334,
-0.0010267932,
0.0306989923,
-0.0033381598,
-0.0516979881,
0.0037912389,
-0.0128631303,
-0.0682941899,
-0.0599444881,
-0.0651517808,
0.0848756433,
0.0141101405,
0.0840725154,
-0.0187658574,
0.0559598804,
0.014603395,
-0.0173743367,
-0.0274993423,
0.0341856107,
-0.0068454961,
-0.0484441631,
-0.0313546993,
-0.0069938139,
0.0105307885,
-0.002697916,
0.0595768467,
0.0544625744,
-0.0296381507,
0.0152804237,
-0.0333647877,
-0.066579327,
0.0217555705,
-0.0236918703,
-0.0161640253,
0.0321527719,
0.0043328083,
0.0476972386,
-0.0100494744,
-0.0304075144,
0.0356641784,
0.0401277728,
-0.0059922948,
-0.0048708594,
-0.0616955534,
-0.0061776587,
0.0254291873,
0.0028183004,
-0.0494546369,
-0.0471319221,
-0.0079284711,
-0.0391474329,
0.003867035,
0.0174700934,
0.0019031951,
-0.009007372,
-0.0129837804,
0.0377153158,
-0.0335480608,
-0.0332466289,
0.0150427483,
0.0353665166,
0.0402623601,
-0.0147851128,
0.0173967518,
0.0494363457,
0.0068657952,
0.0186736304,
-0.026050875,
0.0147216599,
-0.0343683846,
0.0428174883,
-0.018531207,
0.0724442825,
0.0046746228,
-0.0257619135,
-0.0916671455,
0.0841106102,
-0.0006709911,
0.0183440614,
0.0115353968,
0.0128979133,
0.0146930143,
0.0301271435,
-0.0181599781,
-0.0058422685,
0.0195790473,
0.0054721306,
-0.0080788312,
-0.0398858339,
-0.088165231,
-0.0020813944,
0.000063798,
-0.0399175659,
0.0321967304,
-0.0170114152,
0.0131748114,
-0.078915447,
0.100384295,
0.0148402816,
0.0123318387,
-0.0298689362,
-0.0098478068,
0.0195322391,
-0.0369036235,
-0.0404504575,
0.0305057764,
-0.0227128845,
-0.0056700702,
0.0629293919,
0.0182012115,
-0.0496166609,
0.0220340211,
0.0497521237,
-0.0233257674,
0.049799595,
-0.0178496428,
0.0378452949,
-0.0007371404,
-0.0260999519,
-0.0155165633,
-0.0099407639,
-0.0154848583,
0.0516913608,
0.0244193971,
-0.0266633835,
-0.0463625863,
-0.0185374487,
0.0466463678,
-0.0222269446,
-0.0978212804,
0.0321934111,
-0.0548850857,
-0.0198559146,
-0.0120312274,
-0.0296033714,
-0.0328959487,
0.0507022738,
-0.0004222118,
0.0169839226,
0.0214944519,
-0.001760173,
-0.0100360895,
-0.0163610727,
-0.0145618105,
-0.0795264989,
0.0675678775,
-0.04292842,
0.0077440203,
0.0028027059,
-0.0328092054,
-0.0724010617,
0.0488713942,
-0.0362339988,
-0.002616365,
-0.0258378107,
-0.0089314086,
-0.001740042,
0.031738814,
-0.0041984227,
0.0041035446,
0.0283705089,
-0.0215080082,
0.0018705447,
-0.0605952106,
-0.0484043024,
-0.0438480861,
0.0060829669,
0.0085690869,
0.0168438796,
0.0302322637,
0.0270345192,
0.0489658862,
-0.0673601478,
-0.0185578763,
0.0197947118,
-0.0369196646,
-0.0264494978,
0.064085938,
0.0139816236,
-0.0426888503,
0.0020953103,
0.0337380357,
0.0019267125,
-0.0413457304,
0.0144638997,
0.0004751656,
0.0510501303,
0.0434271358,
0.0952320695,
-0.1395416856,
-0.0241523385,
0.0156403799,
0.0104939276,
-0.0446415916,
0.0178560466,
-0.0405955724,
-0.1297509372,
0.0678494424,
0.0285628904,
-0.0143305259,
-0.0058954908,
-0.0358399153,
-0.0293838661,
-0.0192531738,
-0.0250001587,
0.0720963329,
-0.0014333881,
-0.0083664777,
-0.0375241712,
-0.0460569784,
0.0180070624,
0.0711143464,
0.0245976876,
-0.010290565,
0.0516843461,
-0.0085655656,
0.0145180784,
-0.0311539154,
0.0098932832,
0.0130306026,
0.0078135543,
-0.0434153825,
-0.00498677,
0.002099707,
0.0032574432,
0.0078681093,
0.0072627924,
-0.0602267385,
-0.0084886253,
0.0540955253,
0.0453961939,
-0.0072302101,
-0.0269791447,
-0.017839957,
-0.0039905133,
-0.0259920098,
0.0276677161,
0.0034178109,
0.0440458879,
-0.0336889327,
-0.0667775646,
-0.0441941619,
-0.0515062958,
-0.064296931,
-0.0316813327,
-0.0341777466,
0.0038057321,
0.0099326838,
0.0736583546,
0.0318902172,
0.0231829248,
0.0276718065,
-0.050397791,
0.0137658995,
-0.0314060114,
-0.0455207601,
-0.0079532256,
-0.0762441382,
0.0603948906,
-0.0217364039,
-0.0057323668,
0.0058366298,
-0.0175990406,
-0.0067912033,
0.0673677176,
-0.0401901118,
-0.0444966964,
-0.0288997777,
0.0580595024,
0.0291146953,
-0.0127719985,
-0.0568476655,
0.0289297625,
0.0017876088,
0.0536286868,
-0.0109750116,
0.0045496393,
-0.0232051313,
-0.063651666,
0.0308762249,
-0.0434148386,
-0.0571178384,
-0.0082189376,
0.0272700768,
-0.0249503516,
0.0162262581,
0.0188167766,
0.0470233113,
0.0866656154,
-0.0243760552,
-0.0153547116,
-0.0321585648,
0.0021371967,
-0.0195372142,
0.009292935,
-0.0229066927,
-0.0352551714,
0.0547643825,
-0.0313463695,
-0.0370326936,
0.0697709695,
-0.0254384689,
-0.0549288578,
0.0494582355,
0.0366243124,
0.0504311323,
-0.0171056446,
0.0447719321,
0.091489315,
-0.0260474812,
0.0100791585,
0.0060325549,
0.0242663492,
0.0298749451,
-0.0053674853,
0.0189509764,
0.0077064736,
0.0336230658,
-0.0284970812,
0.0123782437,
-0.0078657214,
-0.0758977383,
-0.0179128461,
0.041147843,
0.0328167677,
0.0603264496,
-0.0194651373,
-0.0408207402,
0.0142588085,
-0.0282241758,
0.0258870553,
-0.0138422837,
-0.0166542381,
0.0190383866,
0.0316073336,
0.0138147194,
-0.056755729,
0.0648226067,
-0.0048204525,
0.0121466629,
-0.0169432014,
0.0001802139,
-0.0539371558,
-0.0324975029,
0.0106870076,
-0.0165680293,
-0.0326283164,
-0.0659067929,
-0.0188762806,
-0.0581424423,
-0.0154870972,
0.0214508474,
0.041167628,
0.0129973236,
0.0396453552,
0.0633381531,
0.0461867377,
-0.0071980502,
-0.0108510721,
-0.029605357,
-0.0179186016,
-0.0491073579,
0.0107852006,
-5.841471138e-33,
-0.0343495756,
-0.0233098473,
0.0260930136,
0.0001394575,
0.0279838312,
-0.0369430818,
-0.0543441698,
0.0315311551,
0.0415671319,
-0.0270146523,
0.0343788192,
-0.0005090729,
0.0026994424,
-0.060309384,
0.0182080921,
0.0391591378,
0.0244414266,
0.0094759073,
-0.0695284754,
-0.0191257466,
-0.0343418755,
-0.0429062732,
-0.0173326209,
-0.0314837173,
-0.0142488275,
-0.0127768144,
-0.0019839013,
-0.0063166004,
-0.0569480322,
0.0685516521,
0.0356402397,
0.0218174346,
-0.0292276945,
-0.0120935449,
0.0049125026,
-0.0158064403,
0.0049627414,
-0.0243065022,
0.0486534573,
-0.0094919717,
-0.0056267553,
-0.0586983562,
0.0591755845,
0.0092290239,
-0.0600081161,
0.030889025,
-0.0269433204,
-0.0168043505,
0.0148004126,
-0.0213233177,
-0.0208970625,
0.0292365216,
-0.0268053096,
-0.0156294238,
0.0053739711,
0.026840359,
-0.042941615,
-0.0021724552,
0.0529691279,
0.0133760562,
0.0442823917,
0.0076113148,
0.0651989877,
-0.0253672805,
-0.0089305947,
0.0059189922,
0.0633158311,
-0.0049412809,
-0.0314112939,
0.0472472683,
-0.0062650214,
0.0463102944,
0.0165659264,
0.0232980382,
0.0216142684,
0.0033694631,
-0.0227689985,
0.0338702314,
-0.0176500976,
-0.0038501369,
0.0277861636,
-0.0097198104,
-0.0449808352,
-0.0052528693,
-0.0215159152,
0.0042976802,
-0.0522117577,
-0.0271335319,
0.0294748545,
0.033183936,
-0.0189574268,
-0.0077762809,
-0.0115778837,
-0.0403646939,
0.0180110298,
0.0124258045,
-0.0452969819,
-0.0171137471,
0.0020236878,
0.018995164,
0.0213102158,
-0.0299454164,
0.0048670731,
-0.0396977812,
0.0611390956,
0.0211482588,
0.0111443559,
0.011317648,
-0.0627874285,
0.026983723,
-0.0503229797,
0.0043842071,
0.0068650884,
-0.0131753609,
-0.0059651732,
-0.0117975576,
0.0334031656,
0.0555449016,
-0.014618949,
-0.0267530885,
-0.0111550214,
0.0351731256,
0.0343919061,
0.0298234224,
0.0013175425,
-0.0154913636,
-0.0395294577,
0.0158609375,
0.0125256656,
0.0367043316,
-0.0511152074,
0.0363664441,
3.304e-7,
-0.0304277092,
-0.0040613431,
0.0055256402,
0.0658330023,
-0.00532335,
0.0310051441,
0.0302658491,
-0.0178447124,
0.0000200767,
-0.0321246684,
-0.035949558,
0.0456719808,
0.0618170425,
0.000036279,
-0.0221611578,
0.06269411,
0.0097365398,
-0.0182366353,
-0.0548296012,
0.0037030729,
0.0518260561,
0.0221384466,
-0.0104810633,
0.0052334485,
0.0193713065,
-0.0498230644,
-0.0129319923,
-0.0223250873,
-0.0147504434,
0.0432685018,
-0.0393628813,
0.0185693502,
0.0168906469,
0.0276784301,
0.0051480741,
-0.0130375586,
-0.0113846688,
0.0763653889,
0.0248497594,
0.0560387932,
0.0704574212,
-0.0479069538,
0.0019779117,
-0.0479760133,
0.0452661701,
0.0521040186,
-0.0080089718,
-0.0446808822,
-0.0206053481,
-0.0511531122,
-0.030844165,
-0.0322048478,
0.0407295637,
-0.0042877477,
-0.021781506,
-0.0173498821,
-0.0258803442,
0.0121348463,
-0.0345634706,
-0.0040489691,
-0.0113142347,
-0.0330670476,
-0.0150529435,
0.0247235578,
-0.0054928288,
-0.0319315307,
0.0367576554,
3.290343686e-34,
0.0404861681,
-0.0140532982,
0.0193906166,
0.058985047,
0.0726470649,
0.0105058076,
-0.0283037424,
-0.0045095049,
-0.0214047022,
0.0238582548,
-0.0166872311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14590v2 | RE$^2$: Region-Aware Relation Extraction from Visually Rich Documents | 2023-05-24T00:07:40 | 2024-06-04T01:32:18 | Pritika Ramu, Sijia Wang, Lalla Mouatadid, Joy Rimchala, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current research in form understanding predominantly relies on large
pre-trained language models, necessitating extensive data for pre-training.
However, the importance of layout structure (i.e., the spatial relationship
between the entity blocks in the visually rich document) to relation extraction
has been overlooked. In this paper, we propose REgion-Aware Relation Extraction
(RE$^2$) that leverages region-level spatial structure among the entity blocks
to improve their relation prediction. We design an edge-aware graph attention
network to learn the interaction between entities while considering their
spatial relationship defined by their region-level representations. We also
introduce a constraint objective to regularize the model towards consistency
with the inherent constraints of the relation extraction task. Extensive
experiments across various datasets, languages and domains demonstrate the
superiority of our proposed approach. | [
0.0474980958,
0.0298705343,
0.0177881047,
0.069970347,
0.0265341979,
0.0027415946,
-0.0151598211,
-0.0111516677,
0.0560481325,
-0.0158613864,
-0.0441915952,
-0.0202214867,
0.0047581457,
0.0275053307,
0.0272554681,
-0.0991511866,
0.0062497775,
0.011697392,
0.0029712347,
0.0514807329,
0.0343263187,
0.0161116887,
0.0146047743,
-0.0134206256,
-0.0427377373,
-0.0049021845,
-0.0021692619,
0.0446956567,
0.0122763915,
-0.0633829683,
-0.0074851024,
0.0212254953,
0.0466411784,
-0.0354617164,
0.0000017105,
-0.0013789146,
-0.010419149,
0.0063003385,
0.0089187929,
-0.0126347402,
-0.0079955142,
-0.0822066441,
0.028679207,
-0.0382360257,
-0.0336519107,
-0.0748199448,
0.0422959514,
0.0703387186,
0.0402647294,
0.0597676113,
-0.0442686714,
-0.0299164988,
0.0325080678,
-0.076424107,
0.0343502164,
-0.031004414,
0.0137904901,
-0.0059083239,
-0.0204803701,
0.0026219683,
-0.0480718985,
0.0050604884,
0.0288389046,
-0.0394786708,
0.0581312701,
0.0600147843,
-0.0151748238,
0.0036320584,
0.0035421671,
0.1422512084,
0.0102113355,
0.0042258617,
0.0094751054,
0.0100059193,
0.0036380363,
0.0613732152,
-0.0205257125,
-0.0345755555,
-0.0094184801,
0.0011881209,
-0.023933081,
-0.0045364234,
0.0371483788,
-0.0105961962,
-0.0068409927,
0.0530941822,
-0.0254108235,
-0.0362764411,
0.0133853992,
0.0242876261,
-0.005984833,
-0.0434203446,
0.024174856,
0.0458855703,
-0.0021800301,
0.0226356033,
-0.0333447196,
-0.0014122766,
-0.0395004675,
-0.0283017904,
-0.0287361182,
-0.0467790999,
-0.0078123556,
0.0654288456,
-0.0065346239,
0.033881586,
-0.0340049081,
0.0204815958,
-0.0347074233,
0.0144106727,
-0.0033087733,
0.0188799687,
-0.0660145581,
0.0204820614,
-0.0382290073,
-0.0450124964,
0.0036629168,
-0.0057879058,
-0.0304001495,
0.0319074281,
0.014804462,
0.045838505,
-0.023560496,
-0.0343917385,
0.0062077842,
0.0127448197,
-0.0075705443,
-0.0293010585,
-0.0240069162,
0.0107717132,
-0.0186259225,
0.0118185151,
0.0720224082,
-0.0480436645,
-0.0298655704,
0.0510955527,
0.0273230057,
-0.0316539444,
-0.0033465566,
-0.0284830071,
0.0140283974,
-0.034817826,
0.0394699574,
-0.0149852214,
0.0350124873,
-0.0073065325,
-0.0265593417,
-0.0385616422,
0.0410287641,
-0.0258795843,
-0.0649717301,
0.0366794057,
-0.0175331701,
0.0101314839,
0.0277760327,
0.0115402732,
0.0482055098,
0.0638757274,
0.0518210307,
0.0470489822,
0.0212944075,
0.0122792646,
-0.0107118739,
0.042175889,
0.0429075025,
-0.0079952488,
-0.0032888581,
0.0332595445,
-0.0157888569,
0.0160957538,
0.0509709083,
0.0171590764,
-0.0405082814,
-0.0508760177,
0.0372334532,
0.0123602012,
0.0090870624,
0.0449458584,
0.0367163718,
0.0194677245,
-0.0323604606,
0.0198635105,
-0.0871994793,
0.0166047681,
0.0390898027,
0.0177313108,
-0.0145784887,
-0.0212310422,
-0.0242171679,
0.0131338732,
0.0233038608,
0.0092926249,
0.0101616718,
0.0174369328,
0.0926151946,
0.0481494069,
-0.03119196,
0.0607488826,
0.0263534877,
-0.005840322,
0.0036547529,
0.0540234782,
0.0135226483,
0.0122760227,
0.0221083667,
-0.0413085222,
-0.0253389832,
-0.0062967478,
0.0196537953,
0.0077981716,
0.0551148094,
-0.0306354798,
0.0486982502,
-0.0164026693,
-0.05719487,
0.0039728624,
-0.0218626428,
-0.001392136,
0.0590983778,
-0.0016908678,
0.0256122071,
-0.0459455512,
0.0141509185,
0.0143005624,
0.0271745231,
-0.0153624201,
-0.0292715766,
0.0496699698,
-0.0225024726,
0.0129384417,
-0.0165740754,
-0.0118897054,
0.0262733102,
-0.0318361521,
0.0401994586,
-0.0043983054,
-0.0583524518,
-0.044184301,
0.0055968366,
-0.0071182973,
-0.0521322601,
-0.0254634302,
-0.0376893952,
-0.0198095273,
0.0381783247,
-0.0419759154,
0.0724123195,
0.021303976,
-0.0336051621,
0.0462432057,
0.0207655616,
-0.0260203406,
0.078791067,
-0.0040744995,
-0.0013744874,
0.0196079593,
-0.004559671,
-0.0221828874,
-0.0159656201,
0.0121797277,
-0.0183799006,
0.0147752333,
-0.0431883186,
0.0036560351,
0.0099830432,
-0.0614132956,
0.0093725454,
-0.0434699208,
-0.0098455399,
0.0026606354,
0.0345327035,
0.0050662728,
0.0016531203,
-0.0071320576,
-0.0671077445,
-0.0471968204,
-0.0042424421,
-0.0319463238,
-0.0150829926,
0.0475495718,
0.0034815012,
0.0023142989,
-0.031033529,
-0.0221891366,
-0.0039966423,
0.0675400719,
0.0402960517,
-0.044253502,
0.0094940905,
0.066917628,
-0.0250831451,
0.0615842268,
-0.0202768836,
0.0127648916,
-0.0186400507,
-0.0439282656,
-0.0061997417,
0.0731813759,
-0.0246303957,
0.0517467409,
-0.0328113623,
-0.0143466713,
-0.0344272368,
0.0192035101,
-0.0281887297,
0.0690474734,
-0.0006647494,
-0.0300210677,
-0.0314458869,
0.0628090873,
-0.0305560399,
0.012011637,
-0.0136963753,
-0.02775307,
0.0349000506,
0.0139253959,
-0.0082815746,
0.0014164895,
0.0444722101,
0.0072539328,
-0.1041806191,
-0.0357558057,
0.0462184362,
-0.0150217963,
-0.0381591022,
0.049200248,
0.0353935361,
-0.0559646562,
0.1115082875,
0.046767883,
0.0127949752,
-0.0079311086,
-0.0654926822,
-0.0452567041,
-0.0213112868,
0.0110024111,
0.0245102532,
0.036037825,
-0.0285183173,
0.0261442885,
-0.0284408815,
-0.0315868109,
-0.0106070191,
0.0134014254,
-0.0142143713,
0.0145308524,
-0.0078341477,
-0.0161879249,
-0.0014666378,
0.0379348658,
0.006154798,
0.0307240933,
-0.0366686843,
-0.0191585235,
-0.0074517084,
0.108348757,
0.0908688456,
0.0471488498,
-0.024936229,
-0.0232040919,
0.0018012547,
0.0479947776,
-0.0364503413,
-0.0145910634,
-0.0165769756,
0.0232827719,
-0.0144565552,
-0.0030891572,
0.0178088881,
-0.0169676524,
0.033038564,
-0.0837707743,
-0.0311687216,
0.0605253726,
0.0268001948,
-0.0543467738,
-0.0420378372,
0.0246897973,
0.0374020189,
0.0394767262,
0.0403758436,
-0.0513843149,
-0.0174031928,
-0.03278777,
-0.0463445485,
0.0677602962,
-0.0461472012,
0.0068047079,
-0.0662797987,
0.0204032939,
-0.0081063341,
-0.069441244,
-0.0565541238,
-0.0358493812,
0.0268192254,
0.0042938497,
-0.0225447621,
-0.0191067606,
-0.0329544879,
-0.0421324559,
-0.0043615042,
-0.0214427672,
0.0120426547,
-0.0133240595,
-0.052642975,
-0.0043153893,
0.0248756427,
0.0396597646,
-0.0046370449,
-0.0036937189,
0.0113189844,
0.0283573996,
-0.0123207951,
-0.0225019772,
0.0706516877,
-0.017237369,
0.004018099,
-0.036114715,
-0.0247916058,
-0.0298326425,
-0.0058184606,
-0.01925979,
0.0498993061,
0.007716557,
-0.0396372341,
-0.006130938,
0.0086853122,
0.010434906,
0.0080407625,
0.055454012,
0.009753189,
-0.0659223497,
-0.0212079678,
0.0497630425,
-0.0591580048,
0.0099104922,
-0.0014074863,
-0.0419302881,
-0.0041934233,
-0.0361411534,
-0.046923954,
0.0255138148,
-0.0096189799,
-0.0030717575,
-0.0214766748,
0.0614893697,
-0.0319652297,
-0.0566079132,
0.0544675663,
-0.0068537109,
0.0056191012,
0.0150853032,
-0.0100123454,
-0.0225272533,
-0.0609125607,
-0.0034685566,
-0.0201761108,
-0.0675428659,
-0.0096785817,
-0.0395300426,
0.0307178665,
0.0042338832,
0.07721214,
-0.0211474076,
-0.0178482328,
0.015271876,
0.0146449413,
-0.041809395,
-0.0194009617,
-0.0117150126,
-0.0424894616,
-0.004925123,
0.019733293,
-0.0303823669,
0.0240259562,
0.0698746741,
0.0181656852,
-0.0526178144,
-0.0559243485,
-0.0141552901,
-0.0200640131,
0.0493522696,
0.0353008956,
0.0239526741,
-0.0529560335,
0.0189821087,
-0.008543727,
0.0076494804,
-0.0476185121,
0.0331168398,
-0.0056170495,
0.021266669,
-0.0032044922,
-0.0167600252,
0.0125888092,
0.0204376113,
-0.0161694568,
-0.0027457839,
0.0002007245,
-0.010233094,
0.0424090065,
0.0185921416,
-0.0185790807,
0.0146700423,
0.0024533935,
0.04653541,
-0.0096710268,
0.0214738343,
0.0202872399,
-0.0259022638,
-0.0197886061,
-0.0028671317,
-0.0299070086,
0.0195447356,
-0.0477847457,
-0.0196054801,
0.0373313576,
-0.0457426719,
0.0287245661,
0.0107333539,
0.0058864192,
0.03012513,
0.0674041882,
-0.0330326259,
-0.0352151059,
0.0296745971,
0.035510201,
-0.0069201938,
0.0435950309,
0.0531157255,
0.023299763,
0.0129402196,
0.023186665,
-0.0394193456,
-0.026942702,
-0.0042072469,
0.0257087648,
0.0378716588,
-0.0286517125,
0.0344520621,
-0.0409827903,
-0.0675191805,
0.0016609445,
-0.0189343635,
-0.0186742004,
0.0673520789,
0.0377871543,
-0.0002851471,
0.0386870541,
-0.0349434726,
-0.0382426754,
0.0419607349,
-0.0377576947,
-0.0129422806,
-0.0181684885,
-5.549382097e-33,
-0.0446209274,
-0.0758501887,
0.0101485811,
-0.001300035,
-0.0842232406,
0.0593942031,
-0.0685717762,
-0.025297394,
-0.0327855982,
0.0395045653,
-0.023423275,
0.013900023,
-0.0071198894,
0.0203851387,
-0.0210232139,
-0.0268486664,
0.0027934001,
0.0206525289,
0.0309114121,
0.0555451848,
-0.0099732075,
0.0425369777,
0.0691004395,
-0.0931713954,
0.0083093783,
-0.0084455721,
0.0138699031,
0.023999963,
0.0250249561,
0.0458277948,
-0.0120446282,
-0.028643325,
0.0362316929,
-0.0297358893,
0.0002069403,
0.046006754,
-0.1374455094,
-0.010471724,
-0.0513803661,
-0.0074760914,
-0.0530530512,
0.0158644933,
0.0431380607,
0.0128857773,
0.0970196053,
-0.0731252059,
0.0764490068,
0.0060840985,
-0.0560755245,
-0.0378772654,
-0.0370737016,
0.0469667315,
-0.0046816464,
-0.0094750095,
0.0329374596,
-0.0228772406,
0.0262418576,
-0.0130085284,
-0.0369198583,
-0.0288119931,
-0.0123318927,
0.0226492155,
0.0007826668,
0.0331808701,
-0.0052080108,
0.0407836139,
-0.0002605572,
-0.0113726361,
-0.0383691005,
0.000868101,
0.0262720101,
0.0780160949,
-0.0591306016,
-0.0137058925,
0.000127151,
0.014266327,
-0.1022689193,
0.0121595999,
-0.0212749485,
0.0569430068,
-0.0599937662,
-0.0259456579,
-0.0043179835,
-0.0149009349,
0.026972387,
-0.0042262478,
-0.0300262924,
-0.0140804723,
-0.0062219845,
0.0268212128,
0.0235096421,
0.0642932728,
0.0010696747,
-0.034749534,
-0.0223115589,
0.0370765999,
0.0118632251,
0.0289804563,
0.0109399101,
-0.0160743743,
-0.0309941527,
-0.0193630345,
-0.0021571678,
-0.0140940519,
0.0133467363,
0.0330085903,
0.0716508776,
-0.0201956816,
-0.0457963049,
-0.0366820619,
-0.0575505085,
-0.0196005367,
-0.0340689607,
0.0468623079,
0.0294389501,
0.014282817,
-0.0350692719,
0.0678067282,
0.012813706,
0.0234212112,
-0.0275110006,
0.0489882044,
0.00368906,
0.0733961165,
0.0201493464,
-0.0298829209,
-0.0217424966,
0.0042641666,
0.0490019657,
-0.0468350053,
-0.0195299145,
0.0054844297,
2.401e-7,
0.0415275618,
0.0431419164,
0.0673131645,
0.0326474272,
0.0273404811,
0.0217325054,
0.0206850357,
0.0537525006,
-0.0232138354,
0.0163837094,
0.0478341058,
0.0312617682,
0.011252109,
0.0272901654,
-0.0936395526,
0.0210686289,
-0.0762589276,
-0.0578032024,
-0.0357763059,
-0.0308259465,
0.0294579268,
0.0366371386,
0.0029102175,
0.0016099932,
-0.0176223423,
-0.0191619005,
0.0576100536,
-0.0303819217,
0.0454564616,
0.0485232733,
-0.0158179011,
-0.0240218379,
-0.0591379143,
0.022428995,
-0.0168895721,
0.0220321883,
0.0248352606,
0.0579643324,
-0.0409569107,
0.0156527162,
-0.0043400358,
-0.0246428754,
0.0040931217,
-0.038201917,
0.0336720347,
-0.0513332747,
-0.0021609874,
-0.0044197608,
-0.0232694466,
0.0086026965,
-0.0320130028,
0.0254054852,
0.0101331705,
0.0343620107,
0.0338563286,
-0.060292583,
-0.0108194733,
-0.0754791871,
-0.0160702784,
0.037134435,
0.005007437,
-0.0002001906,
-0.0233661868,
-0.0199876539,
-0.0079306709,
0.0239379592,
-0.0246983524,
1.958839654e-34,
-0.0302608032,
0.0202873796,
-0.0286629442,
0.0328398347,
0.0534304716,
-0.0832098424,
-0.0502995215,
0.001011534,
0.0115622208,
-0.055446092,
0.0265422538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14588v1 | Evaluating end-to-end entity linking on domain-specific knowledge bases: Learning about ancient technologies from museum collections | 2023-05-23T23:53:58 | 2023-05-23T23:53:58 | Sebastian Cadavid-Sanchez, Khalil Kacem, Rafael Aparecido Martins Frade, Johannes Boehm, Thomas Chaney, Danial Lashkari, Daniel Simig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | To study social, economic, and historical questions, researchers in the
social sciences and humanities have started to use increasingly large
unstructured textual datasets. While recent advances in NLP provide many tools
to efficiently process such data, most existing approaches rely on generic
solutions whose performance and suitability for domain-specific tasks is not
well understood. This work presents an attempt to bridge this domain gap by
exploring the use of modern Entity Linking approaches for the enrichment of
museum collection data. We collect a dataset comprising of more than 1700 texts
annotated with 7,510 mention-entity pairs, evaluate some off-the-shelf
solutions in detail using this dataset and finally fine-tune a recent
end-to-end EL model on this data. We show that our fine-tuned model
significantly outperforms other approaches currently available in this domain
and present a proof-of-concept use case of this model. We release our dataset
and our best model. | [
0.0217016395,
0.03868182,
-0.0151550397,
-0.000487444,
-0.0121953888,
0.0338087454,
0.005722105,
-0.0000395805,
0.0497626625,
-0.0479752086,
0.0142957801,
0.0629956573,
-0.0017582728,
-0.0033262565,
0.0178907365,
-0.0121354461,
0.0023844605,
0.0284408797,
-0.019297637,
0.0089305462,
-0.0178674404,
0.0331096724,
-0.033419054,
0.0132534029,
-0.0030561883,
0.0203364883,
-0.0082160309,
0.0159452632,
0.0611198097,
-0.0366742797,
-0.028734697,
0.0249942057,
0.0028323473,
0.0295476373,
0.0000019599,
-0.0736189112,
-0.050716415,
0.0031317805,
-0.0243590977,
0.0129258716,
0.0585050248,
0.0213852972,
0.0150747942,
-0.0383290872,
-0.0060204961,
-0.0084880507,
0.0231198631,
0.0167845376,
0.0164802372,
0.0421191193,
-0.0009790554,
-0.0250344649,
0.0350597948,
-0.030085722,
-0.0218658745,
-0.0402847379,
0.0448461063,
0.0043061264,
0.0226043798,
0.0144093288,
0.0021439842,
0.0657771006,
-0.0193784423,
0.0267588031,
0.0150397876,
0.0016467355,
-0.0533374995,
0.0190913361,
0.0215235837,
0.0748251453,
0.0756516606,
-0.0206011217,
0.0576149598,
0.0341921709,
-0.0139616486,
0.041897051,
-0.0327852517,
-0.0244349092,
-0.026733052,
0.0070131868,
0.0177341402,
-0.0133236544,
0.0429898128,
0.0262298789,
0.0202090908,
-0.0015025854,
0.0085445372,
0.0105428323,
0.0042255637,
0.0207519438,
-0.026753623,
-0.0387632214,
0.0127373673,
0.005174567,
-0.0042677899,
0.031875968,
0.0060330457,
-0.0061066216,
0.0107727749,
0.0061305803,
-0.0708742514,
-0.0042150854,
-0.0135469297,
0.0576489568,
-0.0227412451,
-0.0389055796,
-0.0149150621,
-0.0659113973,
0.0377682634,
-0.0462223664,
-0.0492168888,
0.0322978757,
-0.0177437253,
0.0047025271,
-0.0254398771,
0.0039411183,
-0.0161768757,
-0.0528347492,
-0.0088363765,
0.0680878088,
-0.0308352001,
-0.0496320128,
0.0170508884,
-0.0079176277,
-0.0612926856,
-0.0006374838,
-0.0491353087,
-0.0082757212,
-0.0409514569,
-0.0169299189,
0.0137718786,
-0.0238836836,
-0.0043981946,
-0.0522701815,
0.0089323148,
0.0647848397,
0.0556831323,
-0.0506104045,
-0.0769039169,
-0.0358453952,
0.0255395789,
-0.0407725722,
0.0280218385,
-0.0552712046,
0.0532713532,
0.0198475793,
0.0075978329,
-0.0696314499,
-0.0007300578,
0.0085553881,
-0.0783745274,
0.0608764216,
-0.0030806933,
-0.0062695495,
0.0286381058,
-0.0048347134,
0.0187950078,
0.0342118964,
0.0669929534,
-0.0039857575,
0.0805986077,
0.0773653015,
-0.0258580744,
0.016815478,
0.053014718,
0.0091949543,
0.0137184635,
0.0048165652,
-0.0587661862,
0.0188468508,
-0.0043005981,
0.0370988101,
-0.0210525822,
-0.0264781732,
0.0107015502,
0.000899332,
0.0145081151,
0.0220938418,
0.0306865033,
-0.0071521257,
0.0275880396,
-0.0590431243,
-0.0229603201,
0.0119200405,
-0.019918263,
-0.0143092172,
0.0312363226,
0.0453182943,
-0.0009869335,
0.0093551381,
-0.0025051755,
-0.0051383781,
0.0488224924,
0.0277362652,
0.0732857361,
-0.0064198668,
-0.0202339515,
0.0743876174,
0.02957974,
-0.0080440147,
-0.0119142169,
0.0037664995,
0.0175982192,
0.0483874567,
0.0652667657,
-0.012957246,
0.0032596388,
-0.0244655386,
0.0475085936,
0.0861707032,
0.0112162437,
-0.0419892333,
0.0214800928,
-0.023981858,
-0.0248504262,
-0.0008944397,
-0.0033604943,
-0.0205464847,
0.0278232619,
0.0533597283,
0.026005432,
-0.1122733057,
0.0435081981,
0.0426044948,
-0.0498463884,
0.0289010592,
-0.042368941,
0.0355592817,
-0.0511315763,
0.0545302853,
0.0308529958,
-0.0150770172,
0.0512160733,
-0.0089600999,
0.0034208954,
-0.0032823388,
0.0548868366,
-0.0217403676,
0.0355670974,
-0.0628679767,
-0.0140524944,
0.0004885343,
-0.0059260475,
-0.0485002212,
-0.0048313322,
0.0134440018,
0.0705442801,
0.0074097728,
0.0067806588,
0.0001473854,
-0.009139617,
-0.049615521,
0.0941731557,
-0.0032089883,
0.0203283783,
0.0199987739,
-0.0325530805,
0.0106912358,
-0.016393451,
-0.0892631188,
-0.0350571834,
0.0275458582,
-0.0231620166,
0.0426172875,
-0.0403995104,
-0.0790188089,
0.0052125962,
-0.0637989044,
0.0389568247,
0.0045424262,
0.0291356482,
0.0123436404,
-0.0056364438,
-0.0220405646,
0.0205551442,
0.0190035403,
-0.0113947773,
-0.0453195795,
0.0020491094,
0.0387294777,
0.002223518,
-0.0149512161,
-0.0401932076,
-0.0098177362,
-0.0261793472,
0.0535451956,
0.0377776325,
-0.0464837737,
-0.0182344671,
0.0064395331,
-0.0306009185,
-0.0088902321,
-0.0276802499,
0.0427954905,
-0.0175962839,
0.0088139055,
0.0193715002,
0.0160142314,
-0.0530046485,
0.0048102043,
0.0138614047,
-0.0329458378,
-0.0559211336,
0.0218188614,
-0.0087921927,
0.0652285442,
-0.0051193307,
-0.0021915252,
-0.0161510613,
-0.0020131993,
-0.0459823832,
-0.0034279381,
-0.0141292736,
0.0058747055,
0.019236546,
0.0305027384,
0.0316154249,
0.0250544008,
0.0207364596,
0.046766635,
-0.0115644457,
0.0085211182,
0.0056892652,
-0.0014088638,
0.0323166959,
-0.008102295,
0.0361459516,
-0.0376239046,
0.0438602343,
0.0282102432,
0.0054636225,
0.0274318084,
-0.0425430201,
-0.0108660953,
0.0892310739,
0.0178708341,
-0.022387363,
0.0531303622,
0.0065003843,
0.051479429,
0.024756413,
-0.0038587651,
-0.0027167068,
0.0292454027,
-0.0622440539,
0.0075416942,
-0.0326114371,
-0.041616261,
-0.0273024905,
0.0236379523,
0.0041452539,
-0.0298671797,
0.034777537,
-0.039010819,
-0.0003093189,
0.0487866588,
0.0361170396,
0.0014184164,
0.0236880481,
0.0404972956,
-0.0127797462,
0.0131877214,
0.0346169546,
-0.0062912339,
-0.0037991388,
-0.0136185195,
0.0023575276,
-0.1060223803,
-0.0299742743,
-0.024345547,
-0.0097257867,
-0.0518790595,
0.0244970508,
0.0837792903,
0.0507427379,
-0.0275819115,
0.003519715,
0.0337758511,
-0.0151977465,
0.0099723469,
0.0125526935,
-0.1103622839,
-0.0368378796,
-0.0010695304,
-0.0071921181,
0.0284149963,
-0.1218838394,
0.0115247732,
-0.1056414321,
-0.0243516676,
-0.0438123047,
-0.0316953175,
-0.0446270518,
-0.0683043227,
0.0293756165,
-0.0760097653,
-0.0555427894,
-0.0007232426,
-0.0094430046,
0.0259334631,
-0.0145893618,
-0.0066128895,
-0.0352018774,
0.0585403219,
-0.0815906152,
0.0474816896,
0.0487225465,
0.0849666297,
0.0148696592,
0.0144835077,
-0.0094605964,
-0.023015568,
-0.0418661647,
-0.0041555353,
0.0804872736,
-0.0346190855,
0.008569832,
0.0060791858,
0.0157722812,
-0.0281324517,
0.0018276214,
0.000811416,
0.033430703,
0.0487123951,
0.0570131727,
-0.0161588155,
-0.0240445342,
0.0303897038,
0.0584077947,
-0.0179369096,
-0.0103636952,
0.0141719766,
-0.0376280881,
0.0082228202,
-0.0041662818,
0.0056157461,
0.0064877314,
-0.0548258126,
0.01480434,
-0.1104533747,
-0.0764132291,
0.0447640941,
0.0194147974,
0.0029948761,
0.014642261,
0.0069561843,
0.0105293067,
-0.0738186985,
0.0430515297,
-0.0565013997,
0.0153244557,
-0.0010005736,
0.0014532023,
0.019461764,
-0.0161803309,
-0.0277494155,
0.0196182225,
-0.0846524686,
-0.0457229204,
-0.0031478421,
-0.0323289596,
0.0154806217,
0.0592650585,
-0.0464073941,
-0.0208539478,
0.0186048653,
0.0217795167,
-0.0411802866,
-0.0300734323,
-0.0104805902,
0.0409019515,
-0.0026061262,
0.0454784445,
-0.0591752306,
-0.0076851477,
-0.0338765495,
0.0931411758,
-0.0436580591,
-0.0601670295,
-0.0084408103,
0.0151312007,
0.0498798937,
-0.037615899,
-0.01414287,
-0.0120161576,
0.0089664906,
0.0315884613,
-0.0006037664,
-0.0182656199,
0.0340954363,
-0.0144124907,
0.0050400905,
-0.0316910185,
0.0219356529,
0.0273805521,
0.0409284271,
-0.057699766,
0.0267977752,
0.0063137533,
-0.0135666477,
-0.0120605268,
0.0028423974,
0.0130097168,
0.0291161668,
0.0330105536,
0.0682672039,
-0.0213012304,
-0.0005614468,
0.0138831865,
0.0120975981,
0.0236131605,
0.006794625,
-0.016871715,
0.0054967357,
-0.0069838162,
0.0260531195,
0.058307942,
0.0027200268,
0.1185427681,
-0.0183282588,
-0.0299282372,
0.0149675505,
0.0243902355,
-0.0037674359,
-0.0151285846,
-0.0080834897,
0.0166745335,
-0.0022754748,
0.05226136,
0.0324462093,
-0.0265499279,
0.0713022947,
0.0395490639,
-0.0234404802,
-0.0410933718,
-0.0160632432,
-0.0114834299,
-0.0328760371,
-0.0052486188,
-0.0147479428,
-0.0632166341,
-0.0523119941,
0.0198255405,
-0.0264816247,
-0.0280359555,
-0.0004195664,
0.0302909222,
-0.0073300945,
0.0268885121,
0.0031603936,
-0.0553779565,
-0.0228139274,
-0.0165258124,
-0.0274225585,
-0.0206788201,
-5.770150957e-33,
-0.0328679793,
-0.0287014414,
0.0413755067,
0.0102592893,
-0.0008210072,
-0.0173499007,
-0.0043723825,
-0.0313245356,
-0.0767097399,
-0.0094211316,
-0.0199284703,
0.0034461597,
0.0076765455,
-0.0196172092,
-0.0154753728,
-0.0306857005,
0.0286910962,
0.0238710176,
-0.0368867889,
0.0088327685,
0.0781100392,
0.032162793,
0.0726131871,
-0.0748856142,
0.0609320253,
0.0045747315,
-0.0240152143,
0.0122583508,
0.0496942028,
0.0724694431,
-0.0036726734,
-0.0053858422,
-0.006684301,
-0.0685704127,
0.0171637535,
-0.0322090127,
-0.1354393363,
-0.0202469733,
-0.0227761213,
0.0234047491,
0.0657482445,
0.0011410781,
0.0089046676,
0.028660398,
0.0413688086,
0.0159097333,
0.047513362,
-0.0115990983,
-0.0237103384,
-0.0695569888,
-0.0260917153,
0.0584165901,
0.0041474835,
-0.0013703161,
0.0639350489,
-0.0090946984,
-0.0029901881,
0.0249442551,
-0.066956751,
0.0129383393,
0.0322105512,
-0.0355196036,
0.0193294901,
-0.0690098181,
0.0249218792,
0.0268965755,
-0.0157692302,
-0.0197693221,
-0.0074734418,
0.048752144,
0.0012102113,
0.0058566956,
-0.0349397883,
0.0567851588,
0.0021131807,
0.0252850186,
-0.0531945378,
0.0349149145,
0.0475776866,
0.0448943637,
-0.0351934507,
-0.0203751139,
-0.0237806477,
-0.0099125011,
-0.0556196123,
0.0144543648,
0.0020420726,
-0.0398830399,
-0.0133944089,
0.0049928948,
-0.0452708043,
0.0315468609,
-0.024979692,
-0.0346820988,
-0.0830624029,
0.0463788398,
-0.0065661627,
0.0163141135,
0.0110649513,
-0.0271588136,
-0.0900109187,
0.0036219277,
0.0350338668,
-0.0129072005,
0.0058075311,
-0.0331468582,
0.0082230931,
-0.0039726659,
-0.0323632434,
0.0097176274,
0.0107414806,
-0.0429443866,
-0.0540993474,
-0.0246418249,
0.0292430148,
0.0082396511,
0.0193179566,
-0.0073518371,
0.078151159,
-0.0024033941,
0.0099700578,
0.0359111279,
0.0338646248,
-0.0153476307,
0.0080536706,
-0.0139944525,
0.0016363522,
0.0058333585,
0.0192677546,
-0.0648104697,
-0.0073680216,
-0.0069336551,
2.766e-7,
0.0451115854,
0.0256877523,
-0.0066745169,
0.0568037294,
-0.0212135874,
-0.0025695364,
0.0361267477,
0.0424018577,
-0.0174551755,
-0.0160479378,
0.0054011862,
-0.0285280962,
0.0340350866,
0.0353314765,
-0.0951596275,
-0.0596913323,
0.0191981513,
-0.0155187249,
-0.0262372326,
-0.0063247317,
-0.0046805912,
0.0094874771,
0.0391074046,
0.0014153072,
-0.031893447,
-0.0232460033,
0.0319627225,
-0.0421955623,
-0.0210807677,
0.0068210661,
0.0272592064,
0.0410543457,
-0.0267147534,
0.0418400168,
-0.0205244049,
0.0575280264,
0.025384197,
0.0184371173,
0.0397617668,
-0.0195656642,
0.0089926664,
-0.065063186,
0.0031965363,
0.0229229834,
0.0537834466,
0.0082380846,
0.0209031943,
0.049084913,
-0.0318824016,
0.0303546656,
-0.0230365917,
-0.0126887616,
-0.0421777479,
-0.0086119752,
-0.0006055885,
0.0109563787,
0.0156467501,
-0.0835354254,
0.0053553786,
0.0444733091,
-0.0170797855,
-0.0536733642,
0.0260512568,
-0.0432762802,
-0.0471214578,
-0.0475538597,
-0.0276058596,
2.488396185e-34,
-0.016800588,
-0.0258293319,
-0.0613892712,
0.033305008,
0.0227977782,
-0.0458759442,
-0.0489672646,
-0.0281325802,
-0.0053713834,
-0.0547620095,
-0.003505426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14587v1 | Contextualized Topic Coherence Metrics | 2023-05-23T23:53:29 | 2023-05-23T23:53:29 | Hamed Rahimi, Jacob Louis Hoover, David Mimno, Hubert Naacke, Camelia Constantin, Bernd Amann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The recent explosion in work on neural topic modeling has been criticized for
optimizing automated topic evaluation metrics at the expense of actual
meaningful topic identification. But human annotation remains expensive and
time-consuming. We propose LLM-based methods inspired by standard human topic
evaluations, in a family of metrics called Contextualized Topic Coherence
(CTC). We evaluate both a fully automated version as well as a semi-automated
CTC that allows human-centered evaluation of coherence while maintaining the
efficiency of automated methods. We evaluate CTC relative to five other metrics
on six topic models and find that it outperforms automated topic coherence
methods, works well on short documents, and is not susceptible to meaningless
but high-scoring topics. | [
-0.0248201191,
0.0176393706,
0.0137960818,
0.0287763458,
-0.0330692828,
-0.0039846506,
-0.0095730778,
-0.0371939465,
-0.0534687974,
-0.0275324024,
-0.0200789627,
-0.0168104321,
-0.0038116302,
0.0245976057,
0.0035200994,
-0.0352626406,
0.0230724569,
-0.0173609387,
0.0151350359,
0.03775765,
-0.0268055703,
-0.0174886435,
-0.0167269837,
0.0373854116,
0.0092671355,
-0.0676765442,
-0.0037484628,
0.0120912511,
0.023198938,
-0.0457484573,
0.0061645661,
0.0276736822,
-0.0126493005,
-0.0134859141,
0.000001977,
-0.0282860044,
-0.017343808,
-0.0250033922,
0.0079460097,
0.0190972909,
0.0291779954,
-0.0412550569,
0.0280794017,
-0.0150147937,
-0.019472735,
0.0729472414,
-0.030391749,
0.0868472084,
0.0594166107,
0.0564646423,
-0.0176253058,
-0.0038776321,
0.0683646128,
-0.0190301072,
0.0260958057,
-0.054900974,
-0.0154412165,
0.0270236544,
-0.0184659399,
0.0566153564,
-0.0122111598,
0.0304637998,
0.0170951672,
-0.0298792552,
0.0618508011,
0.0123916641,
-0.0473189726,
-0.0306870881,
-0.0067683994,
0.0666244254,
0.0283123329,
0.0133842928,
0.0506875329,
-0.0198118202,
-0.0098390719,
-0.0152061749,
-0.0400738753,
0.0228337627,
-0.014492969,
0.0305817574,
0.0687020048,
0.0140895378,
0.0439729095,
0.0149410767,
0.0427962169,
0.0832334012,
0.0014849838,
-0.0198831074,
-0.0443288907,
0.0161956865,
-0.011309905,
-0.0320707485,
0.0188287068,
0.0392648429,
-0.0207323842,
-0.0154091893,
-0.0152331898,
-0.014280065,
0.0489793345,
-0.0459981859,
-0.0069672531,
0.0059181359,
-0.067686446,
0.0755928233,
0.0112818433,
0.0094425436,
0.0200045221,
-0.0177873299,
-0.0318361074,
-0.024789596,
-0.0188268442,
0.0280846022,
0.0033915869,
0.035081163,
0.0225584097,
-0.0501425862,
-0.0286502689,
0.0327496305,
-0.0301517751,
0.0082909903,
-0.0356140584,
-0.0061968113,
-0.0226614811,
-0.0113002956,
0.0062070587,
0.016360078,
-0.0586688146,
0.0250813086,
-0.0038165539,
0.0242330804,
0.0105937682,
0.0712528229,
-0.0210305564,
0.0067013754,
-0.0097175511,
0.0196054224,
0.018118117,
-0.0332901776,
-0.0648725703,
-0.0509722903,
-0.0232534893,
-0.0263177585,
0.0202599242,
-0.088833943,
-0.0341925174,
-0.0066626631,
-0.0029430427,
-0.0140118254,
-0.0302078538,
-0.0085163331,
0.00192989,
0.009246218,
-0.0334586874,
0.0175122954,
0.0795126706,
0.0388132781,
0.0198668949,
0.056264367,
0.0178092401,
0.0470534489,
0.0585802644,
0.0433267243,
-0.0194271691,
-0.0245556626,
-0.0105033079,
0.0036401441,
0.0246730857,
-0.0124571035,
-0.0108863851,
0.0299699809,
0.0377290025,
0.020622205,
-0.0397065617,
-0.0192296375,
0.0244214982,
0.0885016397,
0.0652292296,
-0.013007029,
0.0151796937,
0.0228344761,
0.0169193614,
0.0456064753,
0.0066487021,
0.0322104506,
-0.0073367157,
0.0200719573,
0.0656733513,
0.0104836076,
-0.0362643301,
-0.0657589436,
-0.0256637763,
-0.0116748521,
-0.0357223786,
-0.0355473533,
0.0404177755,
-0.0134005062,
0.0378886759,
0.0206472427,
0.0352268741,
-0.0280422289,
0.0208634995,
0.023969477,
0.079328686,
0.0365071483,
0.0161211044,
-0.0436454602,
-0.0405286178,
-0.0107672047,
0.0625415668,
0.0529069565,
-0.0292565655,
-0.0246111844,
0.0287019555,
-0.0304803289,
-0.0018692126,
-0.0489206314,
0.0407052524,
-0.0183503013,
-0.0196243133,
-0.0191384461,
0.0205841307,
-0.0489306711,
0.0224802215,
0.0412398092,
-0.0198496524,
0.0326636471,
0.0089851161,
-0.0289884321,
0.0180784725,
0.06581112,
0.0121141858,
0.0195250288,
0.0505832471,
-0.0362077504,
-0.0155416103,
-0.0272094067,
-0.0266380962,
0.0008352324,
0.051196862,
-0.0715994164,
-0.0636225566,
-0.0249675196,
-0.0194484666,
-0.0164217558,
0.0542126149,
-0.0151384491,
-0.0565782189,
-0.047917299,
0.009337456,
-0.0199767146,
-0.0061134207,
-0.0142517155,
0.041196011,
-0.0134310918,
0.0176553708,
0.0460873581,
-0.0138503127,
0.0205760673,
-0.0585087873,
0.0196778532,
-0.0097152591,
-0.007705397,
0.0005760575,
0.0167303793,
0.0185864102,
-0.0450886711,
-0.0412736237,
-0.0935302228,
0.0306277983,
-0.0404553562,
0.0009802835,
0.0232237224,
-0.043621432,
0.0147134718,
-0.0151875643,
-0.0083688674,
-0.0204561017,
-0.0235196576,
-0.0168141369,
0.0666309595,
-0.0447602831,
0.0313617289,
-0.0621769093,
-0.0093240757,
-0.0060195681,
0.0576190166,
0.0424392261,
-0.0259963516,
-0.0745031387,
0.0085171675,
-0.0226056669,
-0.0620073788,
-0.0074054142,
0.0138067519,
0.032862287,
0.0101258708,
0.056141872,
0.0228511579,
0.0209351871,
0.0325781368,
0.0608906597,
-0.0084723951,
-0.0127838096,
-0.0263278447,
-0.0051124925,
0.0623614788,
0.0083275363,
-0.0409011245,
0.041390311,
0.0507721826,
-0.0245303456,
0.0316397585,
-0.0205733161,
-0.0210103728,
-0.0323384367,
0.0011061495,
-0.0812937096,
-0.0141614424,
0.008041204,
0.0001809631,
-0.0299537387,
-0.0414283015,
0.0685571283,
-0.0400605053,
0.031600561,
-0.0248609241,
-0.0462822877,
-0.0767825842,
0.0089835208,
-0.0144670736,
-0.0029943131,
-0.0109783839,
-0.0040612845,
-0.002976747,
0.0150329024,
-0.0009633849,
0.0104712183,
0.0845347866,
-0.0415552855,
-0.0008010124,
0.0060796663,
-0.0134895127,
-0.0267468859,
-0.0194780938,
-0.0040069381,
0.0371025391,
0.0176296197,
-0.0084540974,
-0.0208658241,
-0.0137401763,
0.0428034589,
0.0013347754,
0.0065748217,
-0.0430920199,
-0.0036208257,
0.0565039031,
0.0770911574,
0.0228995197,
0.0165127926,
-0.0155504337,
0.0197263341,
0.047327958,
0.0103366505,
0.0223119184,
-0.0593742207,
0.0253378786,
-0.0297628343,
-0.0320362076,
0.0037389619,
-0.0005565831,
0.025295347,
-0.0221585911,
0.0056990599,
0.1207566038,
-0.0050848676,
-0.0391619168,
-0.021418618,
-0.0490747839,
-0.0060956469,
-0.015075909,
-0.0296069328,
-0.0506596044,
-0.0440478176,
-0.0101956557,
0.0343934558,
0.0401365571,
-0.0281513277,
0.0056556589,
0.0096513079,
0.0133764204,
-0.0018958288,
-0.006963246,
-0.0265139882,
-0.0975145102,
0.0325868726,
-0.0224402919,
-0.0228782911,
0.0138804642,
0.0083151273,
-0.0004769147,
0.0099574095,
-0.0600363724,
-0.0370349325,
-0.0379275791,
-0.0572742783,
0.0621611066,
0.0231541302,
0.0107829953,
-0.0003538789,
-0.0128648421,
0.0049733729,
-0.0225745253,
-0.0103356512,
0.0170480944,
0.0556681864,
-0.0414949395,
0.0221897271,
-0.0325669721,
0.0365949757,
-0.0223099422,
-0.0587749556,
0.017279461,
0.0625958368,
-0.0471145548,
-0.0071530403,
-0.0115871718,
0.0215218365,
-0.0130246859,
0.0886985809,
0.0595044829,
-0.0138355782,
0.0064241239,
-0.0257609673,
0.0504447445,
0.0297844876,
-0.0041766856,
-0.0380748473,
-0.013470443,
-0.0367684327,
-0.0796196833,
-0.0622207075,
-0.0185769144,
-0.0263134316,
-0.0155665344,
0.0278674494,
0.0277214237,
-0.060087081,
-0.023008693,
0.0732795149,
-0.0232290067,
-0.02238377,
-0.1001228839,
0.0067766355,
0.0142114386,
-0.0237593092,
-0.0021528506,
0.0283819586,
-0.0682500899,
-0.0305546857,
0.0112445923,
-0.0473720059,
0.0036360058,
-0.0044026556,
-0.024332149,
-0.0574041605,
-0.0016589923,
0.0256437175,
-0.0568431132,
0.0764864683,
0.0198020916,
0.0271516945,
-0.0087102326,
0.0284378529,
-0.0714346841,
0.0233721137,
-0.0237856694,
0.0539829135,
-0.0479058698,
-0.0497629195,
-0.0281120557,
-0.0089950506,
0.0747383982,
0.0087905936,
-0.0009644139,
-0.0445952043,
-0.0420135185,
0.0080656111,
-0.016608825,
-0.0098612728,
0.011949732,
-0.0026291779,
-0.0431239307,
-0.0375816561,
0.0581676029,
-0.0328172892,
0.0503233634,
-0.0345993154,
0.0042177052,
-0.0120150289,
-0.0140522504,
-0.0757712349,
0.0013425846,
-0.0113309724,
0.0038918364,
-0.039553266,
0.0182233211,
0.0131451646,
0.033860337,
0.0039093411,
0.0055301138,
-0.0062308731,
0.0362461098,
-0.0678939447,
0.0001355775,
0.0116004944,
0.0632515624,
0.0516250096,
0.0179979689,
0.0577410311,
-0.0083116386,
-0.0199843328,
-0.0426478162,
0.0732257664,
0.0270703007,
-0.0000665444,
-0.0352867059,
0.0417026915,
-0.0180210229,
0.0356392115,
0.0725481957,
-0.051572863,
-0.022670228,
0.013190777,
-0.0058167875,
-0.0176092461,
0.0127298124,
-0.004303698,
0.0502614863,
-0.046146974,
0.0133561585,
-0.0454717278,
0.0104874447,
0.0759812519,
-0.0055060959,
-0.0059714485,
0.0229475312,
0.0316881016,
0.0591167696,
-0.0295657609,
0.0182364155,
-0.0399874002,
0.0014179681,
-0.0105786491,
-0.0098314881,
-0.0462065674,
-6.707479499e-33,
-0.0395455435,
-0.0587898828,
-0.0138859851,
0.0298778247,
0.0072505241,
0.0403015353,
-0.0630538613,
0.0332905166,
0.0273697674,
0.0272774454,
0.0436283536,
0.070046939,
0.0019358647,
-0.0052720155,
-0.0165738668,
-0.0292350035,
0.0451292656,
0.0326539017,
-0.0132483663,
0.0010401868,
0.0201773737,
-0.0036818145,
0.0085399905,
-0.0993756875,
0.0563964732,
-0.0019864668,
0.013938549,
-0.0060631596,
0.0855340213,
0.0373921916,
-0.0381573103,
0.0514896512,
0.0578805171,
-0.0465918258,
-0.003547292,
0.0164632201,
-0.0577082969,
-0.0776887238,
-0.0234009493,
-0.071993649,
-0.049735073,
-0.0610940792,
0.041935619,
0.0366994664,
-0.0046822708,
-0.0258551389,
0.078986451,
0.010889871,
-0.0224889852,
-0.0469328091,
-0.0579179227,
0.0653183162,
-0.0391842574,
-0.022055747,
0.0293514207,
-0.0248866435,
0.0037855746,
0.0515155941,
-0.0386464559,
0.0316650979,
-0.0152414925,
0.0267773774,
0.0200587772,
-0.03663636,
-0.0386473313,
0.0891173035,
-0.0022497724,
0.0238194037,
-0.0363509208,
-0.0133873764,
0.0121627245,
0.0196352098,
0.0774085447,
0.0109223565,
0.0140882879,
0.0393799692,
-0.0723729134,
0.0875173286,
-0.0179490726,
0.027505463,
0.0223605521,
0.0271968935,
0.007313753,
0.0103113148,
-0.0165217295,
-0.003459061,
-0.0440004729,
-0.0122644035,
-0.0252629425,
-0.008761121,
-0.0249461494,
-0.0212358981,
-0.0009881976,
0.0125486581,
0.0138177834,
0.0594052896,
-0.0122041833,
0.0211666562,
0.0440676995,
0.0100319209,
-0.0487576276,
-0.001118773,
0.0188255552,
0.0264699198,
0.0582444519,
-0.0322096236,
0.0341475531,
-0.0310355481,
0.0009682877,
-0.011092036,
0.0048555257,
-0.0374151878,
-0.0231595431,
-0.0234214794,
-0.0029398939,
0.0038063605,
-0.01907821,
0.0793791115,
0.0074078245,
0.0390939936,
-0.0029774304,
-0.0543384813,
-0.0239119194,
0.0169611052,
-0.0265116356,
0.0298546143,
0.0060712816,
0.0438324884,
0.0368982777,
-0.0404359251,
-0.0123638203,
-0.004952583,
2.583e-7,
0.0411897711,
0.0317087546,
0.0063263811,
-0.0143982023,
-0.0072618071,
0.0385012031,
-0.0339112729,
0.0036277636,
-0.0180826019,
-0.0564877428,
-0.0124332989,
0.0535560101,
0.0699607804,
0.0422381386,
-0.0457544886,
0.0174814183,
-0.0675238818,
0.0056614969,
-0.030591907,
0.0220562536,
-0.0032296272,
0.0339664742,
-0.0001515773,
0.0053077256,
0.0273933429,
-0.016748745,
0.0494201519,
-0.0650598034,
-0.0405731946,
0.0229206365,
0.0877993703,
0.0218861457,
0.0242142025,
-0.0428627059,
0.0011233173,
-0.0019491125,
0.0510017201,
0.0449360199,
0.0425235182,
-0.0177831147,
-0.0257577766,
-0.0318601504,
0.0129293799,
-0.0056112865,
0.0460979231,
-0.0520111322,
-0.0362097099,
-0.0594535358,
0.0029250309,
0.0277711339,
0.0561841764,
-0.0018752733,
-0.0180527307,
-0.0088587059,
-0.006675459,
-0.0325391069,
0.0079823732,
-0.0457471609,
-0.0647813231,
0.0257492084,
-0.0271558873,
0.000194095,
-0.0178380441,
-0.0132256458,
0.0343291461,
-0.0765601844,
0.0498304889,
2.048063807e-34,
0.0551627316,
-0.0218445994,
-0.0433717258,
0.0134542668,
0.0097333128,
0.0106229195,
-0.0869921893,
-0.0137977665,
-0.0105296364,
-0.0362616181,
0.0394664258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14583v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14583v2 | Natural Language Decompositions of Implicit Content Enable Better Text Representations | 2023-05-23T23:45:20 | 2023-10-25T00:08:17 | Alexander Hoyle, Rupak Sarkar, Pranav Goel, Philip Resnik | cs.CL | cs.CL | When people interpret text, they rely on inferences that go beyond the
observed language itself. Inspired by this observation, we introduce a method
for the analysis of text that takes implicitly communicated content explicitly
into account. We use a large language model to produce sets of propositions
that are inferentially related to the text that has been observed, then
validate the plausibility of the generated content via human judgments.
Incorporating these explicit representations of implicit content proves useful
in multiple problem settings that involve the human interpretation of
utterances: assessing the similarity of arguments, making sense of a body of
opinion data, and modeling legislative behavior. Our results suggest that
modeling the meanings behind observed language, rather than the literal text
alone, is a valuable direction for NLP and particularly its applications to
social science. | [
0.0141725028,
0.0691493824,
-0.0072279428,
0.0374410786,
-0.0403196067,
0.0125109116,
-0.0087710815,
0.0305599831,
0.0546929874,
-0.0883812308,
0.0178079065,
0.0307492688,
0.0215832796,
0.0397215784,
0.0170594677,
-0.0538147651,
0.0175044294,
0.010296992,
0.052066341,
0.0244461559,
0.0336478353,
0.018643992,
0.0275987703,
0.0531732589,
-0.0227960795,
-0.0245941803,
-0.0233794078,
-0.0130231623,
-0.0003105002,
-0.0175967291,
-0.0189604182,
0.0339429229,
0.0253279228,
-0.0000035768,
0.0000018938,
0.0038810957,
-0.0040220302,
-0.0036446564,
0.0060002906,
0.0523169599,
0.0418815017,
-0.0167802889,
0.0232400838,
-0.0130491704,
-0.0507918224,
0.0243296307,
0.0160341542,
0.0497373007,
0.0688670799,
0.029327048,
-0.021121636,
0.0057967254,
-0.0372356549,
0.0097784558,
-0.0120990127,
-0.012307303,
0.0477804467,
-0.0075813821,
-0.0451551601,
0.0382513776,
0.0137503911,
0.0113620916,
0.0017117346,
-0.0112694753,
-0.0233291276,
0.0233786292,
0.002860226,
-0.0193146653,
-0.0000756129,
0.0103785731,
0.0557484627,
-0.0487988554,
0.04251853,
-0.0578877404,
-0.0151232416,
0.0620837919,
-0.0195863843,
0.0506710373,
-0.0248374473,
0.0325008035,
0.0536852367,
0.0474653579,
0.0221636947,
0.0246927161,
0.0317798071,
0.0582930483,
-0.0238438919,
-0.0205916744,
-0.0027302105,
0.0054763118,
-0.0043921638,
-0.0556421094,
0.0239792336,
0.011868638,
0.0238239896,
0.0464485846,
-0.0342924334,
-0.0333554223,
0.0414354056,
-0.1074388325,
0.0229357146,
0.0218613837,
0.0090779075,
0.0666516498,
-0.0031070311,
0.0148874568,
-0.0292365476,
-0.0279791374,
-0.009839409,
-0.0268313922,
-0.0182942543,
-0.0370673537,
-0.0301762726,
0.0372711644,
-0.0327281952,
0.0097889202,
0.0079555074,
-0.0171859339,
-0.0473867357,
-0.0075777867,
-0.0422294475,
0.0214498788,
-0.0247320887,
0.0186759252,
-0.0723436475,
0.0035370088,
-0.0210017972,
0.043736767,
-0.0472088829,
-0.0005474736,
0.0291327536,
0.0308622997,
0.0006717579,
0.0264997259,
-0.0170453191,
0.0679592267,
-0.0046417355,
0.0173419584,
-0.0083346693,
-0.0895491838,
-0.0387513041,
0.0019450592,
-0.0011010265,
-0.0620669238,
0.0009499194,
0.0002438749,
0.0045212307,
-0.0627422109,
-0.0159442201,
0.0312438402,
-0.0395979621,
0.0561769828,
0.0264041815,
-0.0015936311,
0.0064421431,
0.0300531723,
0.004352618,
0.0360403247,
0.0045532673,
0.0386852883,
0.0144990208,
0.0299464278,
-0.0209621489,
-0.0042096651,
0.0395894051,
0.0183322076,
-0.0274117533,
0.035459049,
-0.0361851715,
-0.0214601718,
-0.015505204,
0.0681932196,
-0.0015384527,
-0.0312616453,
0.0356753469,
0.0878100619,
-0.0434602052,
0.0532884188,
0.0474756919,
0.0413624346,
0.0312631913,
0.021146344,
0.0033696655,
0.0214016028,
-0.0364311859,
-0.0510771871,
0.0350959599,
-0.0059193633,
-0.0156307761,
-0.0616649538,
-0.0330058374,
0.0064795115,
0.0756329969,
-0.0046737217,
0.0252931248,
0.0051480392,
-0.0179765858,
0.0014471447,
0.0452538207,
-0.0268869232,
-0.001896924,
-0.0439526215,
0.0539356545,
0.0199070945,
0.0239980388,
-0.0092442557,
0.0554633811,
-0.0213205926,
0.0372843556,
0.0698852316,
0.0406931154,
-0.0402224883,
-0.0442987494,
0.004292734,
-0.034169931,
0.0118321581,
0.0425878391,
0.0237001404,
0.0051789982,
-0.0224344861,
0.0318907537,
0.0044415356,
-0.0175511446,
0.06467814,
-0.0249121133,
0.0074293409,
0.0110921403,
0.0095256409,
0.0327767208,
0.0334614031,
0.0142971575,
0.010153438,
0.0280405469,
-0.0317786783,
-0.0541783348,
-0.0006823614,
-0.0306279827,
0.0005848032,
-0.000178659,
-0.0929560885,
-0.042313613,
-0.0130431671,
-0.0234001409,
0.0019042917,
0.0262024589,
-0.0886742398,
0.0155693376,
-0.0473666713,
-0.0418282077,
-0.0094854757,
-0.0428828634,
-0.0107020466,
0.0709014609,
0.0028388447,
0.0066896253,
0.0215339996,
-0.0641310588,
0.0556989722,
-0.0011120838,
0.0011517495,
-0.0466440246,
0.0045458591,
0.0141695412,
0.0480989888,
-0.0149241416,
-0.0083781909,
-0.0166169088,
-0.0643436909,
-0.0290678907,
-0.0036431297,
-0.0202111155,
0.0325523503,
-0.0250550658,
0.0284260828,
0.0142598907,
-0.0163694154,
-0.0277755316,
-0.022082381,
-0.0124017838,
0.0583056174,
-0.0280430149,
0.0284592304,
-0.0307918563,
0.0067587034,
-0.0814394802,
0.0635425597,
0.0378492177,
-0.0240919106,
-0.0316846371,
0.04316324,
-0.0381798781,
0.017001994,
-0.0184571333,
-0.0332351662,
0.0158081446,
0.0157352332,
0.0369410217,
0.0534427427,
0.0130230244,
0.045921348,
0.0507121757,
0.0059015029,
-0.0658874959,
-0.0272506643,
-0.0524794199,
0.0415255316,
0.0105227949,
-0.0733950511,
0.0344114341,
0.0741691366,
0.051096037,
-0.0099244472,
-0.0729638934,
0.0729159787,
-0.0612252057,
-0.0192146152,
-0.0358840823,
-0.0510050058,
0.0051950822,
0.0345020443,
-0.0196279753,
-0.0370534807,
0.0793836787,
-0.0091748666,
0.065592505,
-0.0294401124,
-0.0123799155,
-0.0285504423,
0.0669171512,
-0.0224462524,
0.002214442,
0.0135367624,
0.0247467179,
-0.0027049012,
-0.040033143,
0.0251447763,
-0.0174925998,
0.0623890795,
-0.0453409515,
0.0363950431,
0.0131684216,
-0.0322414413,
-0.0232730154,
-0.0901354328,
-0.0102489321,
0.0041301954,
-0.0012775707,
-0.0015591133,
-0.0033688282,
0.0089053493,
0.0133186169,
-0.0162219554,
0.0247326214,
-0.009972563,
-0.0233746786,
-0.0020228997,
0.0046475725,
-0.0165948588,
0.0181475859,
-0.0339683257,
-0.0126964413,
0.0638674572,
-0.0250871684,
0.0344559886,
-0.0508941822,
-0.0079974039,
-0.040782094,
0.0003808727,
0.0125386156,
0.0038709922,
0.0263340343,
-0.0496530309,
0.0158280842,
0.0823467225,
0.0384551324,
-0.0446809717,
0.023658935,
-0.0260248855,
-0.0311689787,
0.0259856638,
-0.0112797692,
-0.0518909916,
-0.0222664028,
-0.0026805571,
-0.045959726,
-0.0495568104,
-0.0583518445,
-0.0002961202,
-0.074679628,
0.0121192904,
-0.0133884121,
0.0353416093,
-0.0116413813,
-0.0901131108,
0.0287748948,
0.0011882865,
-0.0521816462,
-0.0342693366,
0.0131985312,
-0.0023980867,
0.0087747956,
-0.0480677187,
-0.008267126,
0.0354757868,
-0.0173852686,
0.018357249,
0.0055197263,
0.096630998,
0.0099664805,
0.0037869553,
0.0334433056,
-0.0393648148,
-0.0173743423,
0.0168635938,
0.0233442206,
-0.0147051141,
0.0104498221,
-0.069463186,
0.04124083,
-0.0138096828,
-0.0370184742,
-0.0053843213,
0.0499620177,
-0.0425011665,
-0.0321602672,
-0.0552599169,
0.0241329335,
0.0219428893,
0.1140975654,
0.0362838767,
0.0013475502,
-0.0082011381,
-0.0435176045,
0.0143652875,
0.0106130652,
-0.0702140629,
0.0164544638,
0.0092430441,
0.0044223457,
-0.0346828997,
-0.037190564,
0.002504502,
-0.0210570972,
0.0164282173,
-0.0044169738,
0.0643916652,
-0.0479633994,
-0.0410396904,
0.0327148773,
-0.0202517398,
0.0069731222,
0.0635355935,
-0.047861971,
-0.0337446108,
0.0071800305,
-0.0470033325,
0.0566068701,
-0.0467996188,
-0.0431551598,
0.002103796,
-0.0187968276,
0.0176229905,
0.0117589887,
0.0039873924,
-0.0231190119,
0.0473102778,
0.051820416,
-0.0535692088,
0.0191470981,
-0.0066028326,
0.0424330123,
0.0428928174,
0.0442041382,
-0.0101166209,
0.0375404619,
-0.0029253,
0.0138452845,
-0.0291063134,
-0.0139686475,
0.0297225006,
0.0025492264,
0.0078301886,
0.0080537722,
-0.0368809775,
-0.0231135506,
-0.0635241866,
-0.0582186952,
-0.0364812836,
-0.0161019973,
0.009968644,
-0.0144993439,
0.0013059409,
-0.075267598,
0.0347355716,
-0.0350852795,
0.0745934993,
-0.0176768191,
0.0477600135,
0.0598184317,
0.0263726823,
-0.0220185556,
-0.0291443616,
-0.0032892567,
0.0198789593,
-0.0690490082,
-0.0011137495,
-0.0030964636,
0.0049120132,
0.0450069793,
0.0228767563,
-0.0180404633,
-0.0195311569,
-0.0486386977,
-0.035493467,
-0.0166063588,
-0.0021827314,
-0.0200789198,
-0.0244414788,
0.0344807729,
-0.0412034392,
-0.0054750056,
0.0169439651,
0.0466031916,
0.0039981198,
-0.0464215912,
0.0335211717,
0.0016147625,
-0.0388043039,
0.0161866844,
0.0444788635,
-0.0195527151,
0.0339096747,
0.025084354,
-0.0291865431,
-0.0391639546,
-0.0178432781,
0.0401448905,
0.0301763881,
-0.0241556354,
-0.0043334891,
-0.0459192246,
-0.0351656675,
0.0152342711,
0.0346893631,
0.0276837833,
0.0123208007,
0.0066528488,
0.062960133,
0.0051161358,
0.0066323001,
-0.0412592739,
0.0545211211,
-0.0506687388,
-0.0179252122,
-0.0399518423,
-6.168739418e-33,
-0.0298316032,
-0.0806408748,
-0.0109120086,
0.035395205,
-0.0008290085,
0.0650509596,
-0.0753361583,
-0.007744066,
0.0195217635,
0.0625924319,
0.0286341924,
0.0449046642,
0.0056190635,
-0.024779994,
-0.0026141054,
-0.0139844101,
0.042211812,
-0.0265660435,
-0.0289370902,
-0.0082444241,
0.0341375954,
-0.039343711,
0.0165299922,
-0.0770277306,
0.0717179179,
0.019674236,
-0.008149473,
-0.0083786426,
0.0092117246,
0.0500607044,
-0.0677265897,
0.028711902,
0.0409714654,
0.0098249791,
-0.0035652518,
0.0808603615,
-0.0702798963,
-0.0141787436,
0.0291413683,
-0.0330197029,
-0.048253078,
0.0096431626,
0.0434391424,
0.0155307166,
-0.0514807962,
0.0166946892,
0.0733408257,
-0.0151144974,
0.047312133,
-0.0428623669,
-0.0295015201,
0.0353162251,
-0.0452485122,
0.0181721002,
0.0298249237,
0.0445612445,
-0.0175319742,
0.0503882542,
-0.0460117683,
0.0228563845,
-0.0251487903,
0.0012433407,
0.0022100366,
-0.0736825839,
0.0349832177,
0.0965030417,
-0.0018850224,
-0.0047533461,
-0.0948614478,
-0.0173223745,
0.047154177,
-0.010917671,
0.0282726027,
0.0503868796,
0.032219436,
-0.013169759,
-0.0746517032,
0.0306960866,
0.0445595346,
-0.014549857,
0.0634379834,
-0.0154744191,
-0.0377111249,
-0.0253558382,
-0.0547333919,
-0.0582503192,
-0.0224106573,
-0.0156628992,
0.0065252604,
0.007368837,
-0.0337951146,
0.0082859183,
0.0207687374,
-0.0618705079,
0.0136929275,
0.0065899971,
-0.0008654473,
-0.0081227161,
0.0203951541,
0.0140996529,
-0.0628421903,
-0.0118923141,
-0.014574429,
0.0059457398,
0.0483499654,
-0.0008798605,
-0.0027076544,
-0.0133291464,
-0.0442971624,
-0.0160022192,
-0.0124289384,
-0.0435949601,
-0.0264689475,
0.0201864913,
0.0533669107,
0.0585991256,
0.0169322751,
0.0195278451,
-0.02037392,
-0.0022498812,
0.0163146928,
-0.0029712215,
0.0070193997,
0.0062842336,
-0.0316041298,
-0.0428836383,
-0.0074278172,
-0.0348390639,
0.0408889912,
-0.0386234336,
-0.0166342836,
0.0166168995,
2.506e-7,
0.0377465449,
0.0702658668,
0.0106259333,
0.0058784117,
0.0171367675,
0.0554672554,
0.015122883,
0.0255695321,
-0.0306954309,
-0.0705584586,
-0.008015845,
0.0065865614,
0.020232413,
0.0385400206,
-0.0681368783,
0.0407106988,
-0.0513160527,
-0.0437842794,
-0.033262521,
0.024578847,
0.045360852,
0.0553223751,
0.0471254811,
0.0165082589,
-0.0310281459,
0.0045824451,
0.0693456754,
-0.0242534503,
-0.0396333523,
-0.0112769194,
0.0137269776,
-0.0270177443,
0.0003035263,
0.0356241055,
0.0030285614,
-0.0085948659,
0.025883235,
0.0619476587,
-0.0161687508,
-0.0093239974,
-0.0455311611,
-0.0340463817,
0.0128073236,
-0.0061332127,
0.03546004,
-0.0750038326,
-0.0565999113,
-0.0526338704,
-0.0253026821,
-0.0131646274,
0.0078084394,
0.0543401539,
-0.0265227631,
0.0183151923,
-0.0058751232,
-0.0016178105,
-0.0003251832,
-0.0567669794,
-0.0236200783,
-0.0377483889,
-0.0604717284,
0.0022027858,
-0.0261128768,
0.0532477722,
0.0386333726,
-0.0782607198,
0.0134937624,
2.420309808e-34,
0.0352357738,
0.0019671626,
-0.0139522674,
-0.0191699099,
0.055193834,
0.0233456809,
0.0147312991,
0.0167231988,
0.0411432795,
-0.0758050382,
-0.0094525283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14580v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14580v2 | Evaluating OpenAI's Whisper ASR for Punctuation Prediction and Topic Modeling of life histories of the Museum of the Person | 2023-05-23T23:37:29 | 2023-05-26T12:09:55 | Lucas Rafael Stefanel Gris, Ricardo Marcacini, Arnaldo Candido Junior, Edresson Casanova, Anderson Soares, Sandra Maria Aluísio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems play a key role in applications
involving human-machine interactions. Despite their importance, ASR models for
the Portuguese language proposed in the last decade have limitations in
relation to the correct identification of punctuation marks in automatic
transcriptions, which hinder the use of transcriptions by other systems,
models, and even by humans. However, recently Whisper ASR was proposed by
OpenAI, a general-purpose speech recognition model that has generated great
expectations in dealing with such limitations. This chapter presents the first
study on the performance of Whisper for punctuation prediction in the
Portuguese language. We present an experimental evaluation considering both
theoretical aspects involving pausing points (comma) and complete ideas
(exclamation, question, and fullstop), as well as practical aspects involving
transcript-based topic modeling - an application dependent on punctuation marks
for promising performance. We analyzed experimental results from videos of
Museum of the Person, a virtual museum that aims to tell and preserve people's
life histories, thus discussing the pros and cons of Whisper in a real-world
scenario. Although our experiments indicate that Whisper achieves
state-of-the-art results, we conclude that some punctuation marks require
improvements, such as exclamation, semicolon and colon. | [
0.0100076189,
0.0652982593,
-0.0432240814,
0.0269584842,
-0.0185153801,
-0.0115347505,
0.0254823249,
0.0033558076,
-0.0099523095,
-0.0128079038,
-0.0146837691,
0.0021635317,
0.0275954548,
0.0001374677,
-0.0095715113,
-0.0653932244,
0.0438518338,
-0.0429916158,
-0.0050903377,
0.0154398596,
0.0003882226,
-0.0137035456,
-0.0432660542,
0.0701146945,
-0.0054489025,
-0.0107054431,
-0.0181157179,
-0.0084648058,
0.0244203154,
0.0064372355,
-0.0203755926,
-0.0049525872,
-0.0304423776,
0.0638785884,
0.00000157,
-0.0479888096,
-0.0148795154,
-0.0136898588,
0.0033570176,
-0.0035029829,
0.0173380859,
0.0262202416,
-0.0405595936,
0.0426125154,
-0.0148127563,
0.0070392801,
0.0325669795,
0.0189520512,
0.0061441008,
0.0465444289,
-0.0299002845,
-0.035552524,
0.0512478463,
0.0089919344,
0.0205635466,
0.0059900708,
0.007394894,
-0.0432104431,
-0.0062010838,
-0.0371562317,
0.0148727307,
0.0887192041,
-0.0106390417,
-0.0250982568,
-0.020894032,
0.0147374487,
-0.0391662382,
-0.0540151484,
-0.0410584621,
-0.0039416314,
0.0126446337,
0.0141675593,
0.056330841,
0.0244749431,
-0.0203740261,
-0.0392388478,
-0.0625135452,
0.0102748321,
-0.0161216054,
0.0003588029,
0.0274501573,
0.0455040038,
0.0045454097,
-0.011765209,
0.0516141616,
-0.0257247519,
0.0080331611,
-0.0166120995,
-0.0205361359,
-0.0157244708,
0.0195477214,
-0.0076301289,
0.0576443896,
-0.001351456,
0.0166603383,
-0.0004703845,
-0.0117196264,
-0.0182821378,
0.0108976597,
-0.0635834783,
0.0041706343,
0.0281003285,
-0.0621957444,
0.0280306879,
0.022872122,
0.0304786768,
-0.01690045,
-0.0525439382,
-0.0131182466,
-0.0030543155,
-0.0237548929,
-0.010215627,
-0.0371717922,
0.0244221333,
0.0035832252,
-0.052604124,
-0.0483918898,
-0.0008935012,
0.0441144109,
-0.0146943145,
-0.0038769068,
-0.0253624581,
-0.0119211748,
0.0168986637,
-0.01688537,
0.0034211925,
-0.029233925,
0.0400718339,
-0.0065423348,
-0.0347922929,
0.0137164015,
0.0510679409,
0.0140001178,
0.0112630418,
-0.0168590453,
0.0113712279,
-0.0243469141,
-0.0298915338,
-0.0193231832,
-0.0302071813,
-0.0524477996,
-0.062779136,
0.0066313222,
-0.0003009875,
0.0039249258,
0.0118652955,
-0.0201248601,
-0.0236018859,
0.0177700445,
-0.0054744286,
0.0262122992,
0.0688406602,
-0.0100812996,
-0.001947181,
0.0719814226,
-0.0172012821,
-0.0181214567,
0.0105055086,
0.0811763257,
-0.0011299778,
0.0344058387,
0.0572297238,
0.0242887009,
0.0588499792,
-0.033151526,
-0.0278779864,
-0.0197343435,
0.0063991821,
0.02494023,
0.0539225638,
-0.0128206965,
0.0923430771,
0.0164078195,
0.0090193283,
0.042447418,
0.0311749876,
-0.003601915,
0.0275456719,
0.0431049764,
-0.0056135613,
0.0383529589,
0.007296456,
0.0350741409,
-0.0430444852,
0.0207689404,
0.0264923479,
0.0333191194,
-0.0203942135,
-0.0055960612,
-0.0265292991,
-0.0142844338,
-0.0548721217,
0.011675247,
-0.0184520707,
0.0060691303,
-0.0110186795,
-0.057427641,
0.0183807295,
-0.0123718735,
-0.0683912188,
-0.0309557393,
-0.0445967875,
0.0476654619,
0.0842548981,
0.0400382318,
-0.0324374288,
0.0028232157,
-0.0412827954,
-0.0017301181,
0.0305942651,
0.0063781594,
-0.0120950351,
0.0383957326,
-0.0631442443,
0.04515744,
0.0635218695,
0.021087762,
0.0183841344,
-0.0008455234,
0.0363463387,
0.0151983444,
-0.0093711382,
0.0284337196,
0.0371296331,
-0.0101648252,
0.0133244907,
-0.0361516103,
-0.0005183298,
0.0314864703,
0.0475017168,
-0.0053099552,
-0.010142345,
0.0669429004,
-0.048965808,
0.0513738878,
0.0508778132,
-0.080845505,
-0.0224450883,
0.0180111583,
-0.0244371872,
0.0328932405,
0.0504013561,
0.0676653087,
-0.0622174628,
-0.0344445407,
-0.0443542562,
0.0681424141,
-0.0331976227,
0.0470685549,
0.0029615513,
0.0343344808,
0.0120093254,
0.0117440596,
0.0017419996,
-0.0207858346,
-0.0080748284,
-0.0320858546,
0.050180316,
-0.0827384219,
-0.0457294919,
0.0236569345,
-0.0244378857,
-0.0051316065,
0.014279305,
-0.0226369016,
-0.0238074157,
-0.0043685348,
-0.1500957459,
-0.0059762835,
-0.0252157375,
0.0007546181,
-0.0622517206,
0.0008981724,
-0.0458860062,
-0.0262508746,
0.0225596242,
0.0352606922,
-0.0417780727,
-0.0217981972,
0.0311793014,
0.0169352051,
-0.0513111614,
-0.053021647,
0.0100694336,
-0.0096166702,
0.0427298285,
0.03288012,
-0.0634028912,
-0.0418492965,
0.0352019928,
0.0038935482,
0.026633285,
-0.0070864731,
-0.0392918363,
0.047701031,
0.0036263515,
0.0787237734,
0.0448449068,
-0.0282646511,
0.0180840492,
0.0004324453,
0.0116203278,
-0.0112467725,
-0.0159943346,
0.0099192923,
0.046843186,
-0.0304464009,
0.0666091889,
-0.0110234423,
0.0127875749,
0.0096091414,
0.0636731312,
-0.0413882993,
-0.0075675128,
0.0107443035,
-0.0035961438,
0.0505507179,
-0.0421391018,
-0.0740679875,
0.0267153643,
0.0312908664,
0.0169374682,
0.0233706012,
-0.0447256304,
-0.0265536439,
-0.0222999174,
-0.0074454667,
-0.0273681264,
0.0708652511,
-0.012926871,
-0.0163491052,
0.054265596,
-0.0816349089,
-0.0152630163,
0.0458006188,
-0.0007206525,
-0.020016158,
-0.025383411,
-0.0043000253,
0.0073288311,
0.0418006629,
-0.0527453795,
-0.018909296,
-0.0176855978,
-0.0603532717,
0.0151202949,
0.0000479726,
-0.0043810476,
-0.0516133234,
0.031913273,
-0.0121133476,
0.076057978,
-0.0183566995,
0.0306367446,
-0.0308225621,
0.0311147515,
0.0153220817,
0.007389945,
-0.0177413523,
-0.0300230253,
0.0338962674,
-0.0128547223,
0.0132264812,
0.0109892981,
-0.0114885876,
-0.0138667189,
0.0166531708,
-0.010702231,
-0.0752795637,
0.0219895635,
0.0649228171,
-0.0343136713,
-0.0000105123,
0.0802941471,
0.0162409805,
-0.0477704071,
-0.0110821975,
-0.0047670803,
0.0180778261,
-0.0005871341,
-0.0115844216,
-0.0488382205,
-0.0269925389,
0.0377887674,
0.0501151048,
0.0157649647,
0.0047529419,
0.0103021897,
-0.0772231668,
0.0381063111,
-0.0013692513,
-0.0749899447,
0.0080429539,
-0.0151326694,
-0.0247802995,
-0.0318912715,
-0.0185299721,
0.0098663643,
-0.005517317,
-0.0240482334,
0.0167363267,
-0.0766598806,
-0.0517037846,
0.0034276131,
-0.0491592921,
0.0625422448,
0.0508435369,
0.0649944544,
0.0330554619,
-0.0345769152,
0.0162655264,
-0.0038025703,
0.0419484489,
-0.027851535,
0.0513530299,
-0.0080384677,
-0.0066937176,
-0.0089328298,
0.0324587971,
0.0167378299,
-0.0161518492,
0.0460378267,
0.0411346816,
-0.0353271216,
0.0204657912,
-0.0195975825,
0.0202257149,
0.0040357597,
0.0471125357,
0.0158107188,
-0.0404326394,
-0.0151836919,
-0.0020114849,
0.0423552059,
-0.0074207932,
0.0153606953,
-0.0524679534,
-0.039156042,
-0.0574261583,
-0.084742412,
-0.0500100665,
0.0295092501,
0.0189889353,
0.0309541989,
-0.0233067982,
-0.0198448282,
0.0693537071,
-0.0332378969,
-0.0428108871,
0.0059411987,
-0.0241259355,
-0.0511477105,
0.0093241623,
0.0287155956,
-0.0356869288,
-0.0078952899,
-0.019336516,
-0.0804979652,
-0.0646655709,
0.0805741102,
0.0384760462,
0.0286967177,
0.048437573,
-0.0023962853,
-0.0346319079,
-0.0236983467,
0.031159183,
-0.0608825274,
-0.0166413207,
0.0108884759,
-0.0040175817,
-0.0194107722,
0.0171963796,
0.0085913893,
-0.0053475685,
-0.075021401,
0.0407678522,
-0.0886039436,
-0.0640175864,
-0.0409241132,
-0.012302096,
0.0847556442,
-0.0404226705,
-0.0731550157,
-0.033971902,
0.0346842632,
-0.0209548846,
0.0620673187,
-0.0069942013,
-0.0023081372,
-0.0065002479,
0.0253549907,
-0.0351733677,
-0.0449431241,
-0.0553890429,
-0.0418367125,
-0.0378156565,
0.0242775418,
0.0578638203,
0.0192960389,
0.0019044287,
0.0151463589,
0.0141230486,
0.1156370342,
0.0436245576,
0.0173165929,
-0.0086083943,
0.0164250825,
-0.0201886781,
0.0202636812,
0.0181300826,
0.0009296858,
-0.0273907278,
0.0090907551,
-0.0182667095,
0.103788197,
0.0698437691,
0.0049303654,
0.0657549202,
-0.0015864483,
0.0158768892,
-0.0166544765,
0.0225128923,
-0.0098887738,
-0.0153782368,
-0.0321804248,
-0.0060994769,
-0.0377072543,
0.0422006734,
0.0031730104,
-0.0020320062,
0.0003628087,
0.0189177934,
0.0043446524,
-0.0523957945,
0.0214306265,
0.0217272248,
0.0134685049,
-0.0350916348,
-0.0130290845,
-0.0262439623,
-0.0136084631,
0.0636285022,
0.0105035016,
0.0065645329,
-0.0345131084,
0.0255026743,
0.0162718873,
-0.0196132716,
-0.0196570773,
-0.032230895,
-0.036873024,
-0.0103552742,
-0.001452921,
-0.0134757105,
-5.012882802e-33,
-0.0251001418,
-0.0069064908,
0.0119405389,
0.0793215111,
-0.0349120684,
-0.0096715977,
-0.0441078022,
0.0241151359,
0.0236206949,
-0.0473631322,
-0.0231337715,
-0.0019469671,
0.0413156562,
-0.0183264166,
0.0376478285,
-0.0355228484,
0.0700934082,
-0.0315887779,
-0.0005355077,
-0.0349209644,
0.0045492714,
0.0821427107,
0.007806899,
-0.0748707652,
0.0057353587,
-0.0563052781,
-0.024162557,
-0.0103049073,
0.0694592595,
0.074835144,
0.0104708252,
0.0119778579,
-0.0434560962,
0.0096031195,
-0.0080401925,
-0.0049504736,
-0.0597908571,
-0.0069230092,
0.0199302863,
0.0823401213,
0.0234538969,
-0.0504595339,
0.0288789626,
-0.0075137028,
-0.0578462817,
0.0320423916,
0.0436115861,
-0.0288825519,
0.0244806651,
-0.0198172703,
-0.0480863042,
0.0030440583,
-0.0021087413,
-0.0471302345,
0.0943129659,
0.0202966984,
0.0186657719,
-0.0622395091,
-0.031381242,
0.0354764275,
0.0151584316,
0.038811449,
0.0247003362,
-0.0336815603,
-0.0241645016,
0.0312723182,
0.0756771713,
-0.031758897,
-0.0099797519,
-0.0119148353,
0.0562536567,
0.0248371009,
0.0227643959,
0.0236063749,
0.0225392617,
-0.0004092165,
-0.0185612701,
-0.0310912784,
0.043350555,
-0.0254833754,
0.0094351703,
0.0540111139,
-0.0500517637,
0.0093185557,
-0.013749117,
-0.0095545696,
0.0087588159,
-0.0293289069,
0.0414229147,
-0.0042372011,
0.0206600148,
0.0176088773,
0.0681833848,
-0.008052906,
0.0038463701,
-0.0403859653,
-0.017134469,
0.0375034735,
-0.0248772632,
0.0326648057,
-0.0734620243,
-0.0205355939,
0.0353907868,
0.0197575577,
0.0482726805,
-0.0037950687,
-0.0195601378,
0.0199417174,
-0.0499928258,
-0.0061975508,
0.0501042157,
-0.03466703,
-0.007189896,
-0.0038790123,
0.0287547614,
0.0200134832,
0.0234649871,
0.0261532366,
0.0162422378,
0.0453045741,
-0.0359941274,
-0.0725743994,
0.0169063993,
0.0112562114,
-0.0723185688,
-0.0085765831,
-0.0192308258,
0.0263387319,
-0.0275290087,
-0.0375641771,
-0.0194476917,
0.0114373714,
2.332e-7,
0.0001808354,
0.0713482201,
0.0313324668,
-0.0048478306,
-0.0018747021,
-0.0092586009,
0.0005769934,
-0.0170471072,
0.0004379095,
0.0506571457,
0.040932145,
-0.0271414518,
0.0876730457,
0.0070394352,
-0.1553872377,
-0.0238769464,
-0.0505542159,
0.0200067256,
-0.0899773091,
0.0287774671,
0.0175004359,
0.0722681656,
-0.0037178919,
0.0094032502,
-0.0475486554,
0.0034599339,
0.0361231677,
0.0094266282,
-0.0597008653,
-0.0128753977,
0.0289554615,
0.01856995,
-0.0589481816,
-0.0089272745,
0.0224542394,
0.0011964665,
0.0661009252,
0.0294302758,
-0.0021445814,
-0.0292749498,
0.0467572734,
0.0606516749,
-0.0583999269,
-0.0231935512,
0.041770149,
0.0739852488,
0.0092012556,
-0.0229028463,
0.0145697547,
-0.0078848358,
0.0326702967,
-0.0032596427,
0.0068977731,
-0.0055493331,
-0.0066473386,
-0.0080489358,
-0.0145802526,
-0.0140661858,
-0.0340803377,
-0.0131295035,
-0.0348097272,
-0.0002080973,
-0.018970903,
-0.0233255997,
-0.0123496372,
-0.0606912933,
-0.0040436876,
1.734809945e-34,
0.0122528626,
-0.0311281271,
-0.0159113798,
0.0361223519,
0.0129584409,
-0.0131141013,
0.0359502397,
0.0568998195,
0.0139837461,
-0.0068024471,
-0.0272348765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14578v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14578v2 | Connecting the Dots: What Graph-Based Text Representations Work Best for Text Classification Using Graph Neural Networks? | 2023-05-23T23:31:24 | 2024-01-22T14:13:51 | Margarita Bugueño, Gerard de Melo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the success of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) for structure-aware machine
learning, many studies have explored their use for text classification, but
mostly in specific domains with limited data characteristics. Moreover, some
strategies prior to GNNs relied on graph mining and classical machine learning,
making it difficult to assess their effectiveness in modern settings. This work
extensively investigates graph representation methods for text classification,
identifying practical implications and open challenges. We compare different
graph construction schemes using a variety of GNN architectures and setups
across five datasets, encompassing short and long documents as well as
unbalanced scenarios in diverse domains. Two Transformer-based large language
models are also included to complement the study. The results show that i)
although the effectiveness of graphs depends on the textual input features and
domain, simple graph constructions perform better the longer the documents are,
ii) graph representations are especially beneficial for longer documents,
outperforming Transformer-based models, iii) graph methods are particularly
efficient at solving the task. | [
0.0335147046,
0.0077635208,
0.0016431574,
0.0336117633,
-0.0461738557,
-0.0078335702,
0.0048675155,
0.015491195,
0.085108012,
-0.0687651336,
-0.0205870457,
-0.0353218392,
0.0250451714,
0.0398038141,
0.0133851357,
-0.018817747,
-0.0063831853,
0.0049816575,
-0.002282155,
0.0086863395,
0.0009104032,
0.0515113808,
0.0578131638,
0.0185421258,
-0.0059349132,
-0.017637305,
-0.0038261192,
0.0202395152,
-0.0453241579,
-0.0141186221,
-0.0004189662,
0.0179182217,
0.0288727097,
0.0398257077,
0.0000017044,
0.0185310449,
-0.0036370053,
0.0008021803,
-0.0249846242,
0.0127678541,
0.0705672428,
-0.0753582567,
0.0345705077,
0.0134490877,
-0.0277064592,
-0.0748422071,
0.0202104561,
0.0429896861,
0.0127670607,
0.0908744931,
-0.0385378785,
-0.052123975,
0.0423400849,
-0.0402336121,
-0.0154683338,
-0.0391049162,
0.0344161689,
-0.0077625918,
0.0227121711,
0.0288442839,
-0.0627327785,
-0.0027967202,
0.0301835909,
-0.027579423,
0.0560718141,
0.0218604486,
-0.0067248926,
0.0306755621,
0.0152207604,
0.0901843011,
-0.0120736547,
-0.0388412997,
0.0084314505,
-0.0292528961,
0.0141245751,
0.0251450688,
-0.0199036133,
-0.020879712,
0.0082808509,
0.0268813036,
-0.0170148425,
-0.0088592283,
0.0710399076,
-0.0021884644,
-0.042995587,
0.0409583971,
-0.0457086042,
0.007426681,
0.0173025839,
0.0051253946,
-0.0142931053,
-0.0349353366,
0.0046750386,
0.0310823321,
0.015051851,
-0.0191058926,
-0.0251900386,
-0.0342981108,
-0.0052305129,
-0.0580502078,
0.0212337803,
-0.0317070931,
0.0260727368,
0.0374249071,
-0.0196313411,
0.0435890406,
-0.0350338183,
0.0539350212,
-0.0365644246,
-0.0078094043,
-0.0664744526,
0.0075982045,
-0.0502875932,
0.02552226,
0.0289428644,
-0.0626113936,
-0.0424169302,
0.0373648964,
-0.0111014564,
0.002753475,
0.0210960843,
0.044148691,
0.0348305367,
-0.0043374794,
0.0406100079,
0.0339350067,
0.030216001,
0.0221407171,
-0.0270007588,
0.0373948254,
0.0124859819,
0.0444484353,
0.06040214,
-0.0158554278,
0.008533366,
0.0533652268,
0.0329763107,
-0.0515156835,
0.0014397531,
-0.0202194452,
-0.0320758335,
-0.0499554314,
0.0454993881,
-0.0665410087,
0.0409315787,
0.0396904647,
-0.0157790091,
-0.047275003,
0.0125792557,
0.000749832,
-0.0440238416,
0.0547364391,
0.0128546804,
0.00020498,
0.0254013948,
-0.0133867748,
-0.0041628946,
0.0138731785,
0.0410983972,
0.0418041237,
0.0226903446,
-0.0019247682,
-0.0196763314,
0.0085990839,
0.0352736823,
-0.0257955305,
0.035765741,
-0.0114328917,
-0.054635454,
0.0069731926,
-0.0084027722,
0.0373391919,
-0.0252688117,
-0.0346714221,
0.0455043018,
0.0409270413,
0.0188059341,
0.0212053191,
0.0173199177,
0.0418547057,
-0.0286236349,
0.0074829129,
-0.0512014143,
-0.0243315622,
0.0090293577,
0.0132709928,
-0.0342519581,
-0.0479827374,
-0.0297249462,
0.0087667778,
-0.0094119133,
-0.0446162187,
0.1324451566,
-0.0046765837,
0.0814456865,
0.015258003,
-0.0349382609,
0.0179660972,
0.0107991267,
-0.0111151803,
0.000001574,
0.0002215345,
-0.0215291996,
0.0234996416,
0.0228071827,
0.0045509334,
-0.0071321442,
-0.0015408462,
0.0324041694,
-0.0289448015,
0.0570315346,
-0.0175515674,
-0.0171428956,
-0.0535024889,
-0.0409554988,
-0.0251248963,
-0.0109482249,
0.0041630259,
-0.0226936229,
-0.0040776376,
0.0379199721,
-0.091673404,
-0.0351546071,
0.0113240574,
0.0388177335,
0.007713343,
0.0623077117,
0.0084142527,
-0.0112623908,
0.0253228247,
0.0154779293,
0.0126581024,
0.0472718291,
-0.01349648,
-0.0334752016,
-0.0466504619,
-0.0456324108,
-0.0392297953,
0.0094826827,
-0.0088201715,
-0.0080273692,
0.0328546017,
-0.0418952033,
-0.0268397685,
0.0426644795,
-0.0887944028,
0.0294926036,
0.0141102709,
0.0006133519,
-0.0282279588,
0.033493191,
-0.0086293695,
0.0509419255,
0.012747121,
-0.007745856,
-0.0209525228,
0.0012351667,
0.0224823691,
-0.0448493473,
-0.0169730112,
0.0198133215,
0.0117339222,
-0.0028809567,
0.0319747217,
-0.0172791556,
-0.0024767898,
0.0067945998,
-0.0863462836,
-0.0158088394,
-0.0205601268,
0.0179239046,
-0.0141361626,
0.0039888211,
0.0476791114,
-0.016427679,
-0.0670595095,
0.0222282931,
0.0163176656,
0.0039192624,
0.0176826827,
-0.0147161521,
-0.008551389,
-0.0117305592,
-0.0722614452,
-0.0347308777,
0.1189410165,
0.0253722016,
-0.0654833391,
-0.0127298897,
0.034982305,
0.0145004485,
-0.0001393853,
-0.0165270548,
0.0115683405,
-0.0250394382,
-0.008687757,
0.0156842023,
0.0385870971,
-0.0099021783,
0.0368263945,
0.0320235603,
0.0263217874,
-0.0210361052,
-0.0381473936,
-0.0645208508,
0.0490260348,
-0.0444445349,
-0.0222331434,
-0.0123409564,
0.013629646,
0.0168717131,
-0.0099454839,
-0.0288486872,
-0.0092723165,
-0.0130464863,
0.040035218,
0.0003020426,
-0.0492571592,
0.0401698016,
-0.0451133661,
-0.0252600312,
-0.0190199576,
0.0509876981,
-0.0025115181,
0.0113388365,
0.0098918434,
-0.0511696637,
-0.0849456713,
0.0671270415,
0.0789947435,
0.0119244531,
0.0088909939,
-0.0235014912,
-0.0196555573,
-0.0031198303,
0.0125556048,
-0.0167461131,
0.0357168801,
0.0345788412,
0.0440843441,
-0.0116321202,
-0.0178423245,
0.0077267014,
-0.0123084327,
-0.0077069881,
0.0451857671,
0.0416641906,
-0.0154669108,
-0.0094188927,
0.0156788714,
-0.0286631454,
0.0294928774,
-0.0215988811,
-0.0045564207,
-0.0132648125,
0.0633402988,
0.0170097984,
-0.0157918409,
0.0013923133,
-0.0440250635,
-0.0055912016,
0.0409438312,
0.0071546598,
0.0110581992,
-0.0530373231,
-0.014607762,
-0.0063192993,
-0.0179164633,
-0.0372323841,
-0.0235386174,
0.0170549788,
-0.0678195804,
0.0071550612,
0.076697126,
0.011077825,
-0.0733896345,
-0.0030398411,
0.0438087434,
0.0002072416,
-0.0066899122,
0.0024317347,
-0.073715657,
-0.0038331535,
-0.0201227423,
0.0118999463,
0.0253489465,
-0.0259797405,
0.0174444877,
-0.0497613475,
0.019449288,
0.0384127647,
0.0149304895,
-0.0390335731,
-0.054657992,
-0.0254427716,
-0.0043065511,
-0.0140922386,
-0.0632241666,
-0.0279312041,
-0.0413185842,
0.0080445949,
-0.0566347167,
-0.0021969529,
0.0092886174,
0.0000708934,
-0.0281918328,
-0.0163524114,
0.0441589989,
-0.0058119842,
0.0021189919,
0.0636978894,
0.0408071019,
-0.0131420474,
0.0110869426,
0.0577855594,
0.0227940213,
0.0393475071,
-0.0201204251,
-0.0038155599,
-0.0483589843,
-0.022433551,
-0.0486307368,
0.0927981734,
-0.0205832124,
-0.071026668,
-0.0138055058,
-0.0266305786,
-0.0050177621,
0.0016667367,
0.0271438528,
-0.0234168284,
-0.068835102,
-0.0346947834,
0.0370759517,
-0.0460201874,
-0.029450072,
0.035412401,
-0.015156514,
0.0144150769,
-0.0291454028,
-0.0343510062,
-0.0093593644,
-0.0289387051,
-0.0153685212,
-0.0014412685,
0.0774307773,
-0.0531146303,
-0.0777245909,
-0.0118802907,
-0.0009646843,
0.0309550017,
-0.0157930031,
-0.0019596133,
0.0341255069,
-0.0157070961,
-0.0153040513,
0.0078237178,
-0.0918711051,
-0.0546981357,
-0.0260849968,
-0.025006773,
0.0058881189,
0.0190988481,
-0.010647634,
-0.040088091,
0.0681307316,
0.0342408679,
-0.023415057,
-0.0041664825,
0.0009716212,
-0.0488643311,
-0.0383595154,
0.0306133032,
-0.0674314648,
0.030312838,
0.012978673,
-0.0035297109,
-0.0203807894,
-0.0335419029,
-0.0247027166,
0.0125826821,
0.0329083949,
0.0360119939,
0.0026884894,
-0.0450387411,
-0.0008049101,
-0.0224191379,
-0.011070204,
-0.0019046018,
-0.0308754668,
0.0365169644,
0.0032916588,
-0.0291503631,
-0.0054904865,
0.0118277362,
0.0364522114,
-0.0362989865,
0.0156639982,
0.0145483008,
-0.0458123423,
0.0318499431,
0.0388914496,
-0.0128637338,
0.0142008346,
0.0289501511,
0.007998581,
-0.0203637425,
0.0096937101,
0.0086147757,
-0.0017760991,
-0.0844621062,
0.0079163387,
-0.0922079533,
0.0074952547,
-0.0159238055,
-0.0380614772,
0.0494083688,
-0.0139531353,
0.0137066226,
-0.0140415737,
-0.0207120702,
-0.0546584129,
0.0879185051,
0.0042133033,
-0.0529738925,
0.0062926202,
0.0120938346,
-0.0233135838,
0.0389966629,
0.0358508192,
0.0833278149,
-0.0043709087,
0.0444619246,
-0.0596010387,
-0.0312147308,
-0.0286961384,
-0.0062679513,
0.0446300209,
0.0025827894,
0.0005921932,
-0.0441638865,
-0.0557896905,
0.0672459081,
-0.049956847,
0.0209572576,
-0.002678253,
0.0025750052,
0.0058661369,
0.0318629518,
0.0107312603,
-0.0609764792,
0.0381541029,
-0.016532883,
-0.0185318477,
-0.0219290648,
-5.494472185e-33,
0.0378469341,
-0.0761025921,
-0.0200397409,
0.0535894968,
-0.0461303778,
0.0475978702,
-0.0427647941,
-0.0296489503,
-0.0253903028,
0.0408263244,
-0.0104169007,
0.0256804675,
-0.0135216098,
0.0462157279,
-0.0295518599,
-0.0226023961,
0.0323557891,
-0.007480768,
0.0031287747,
0.041449897,
0.052572228,
0.0358553082,
0.0303536188,
-0.0953104049,
0.0192422625,
-0.0371160693,
0.0437700562,
-0.0393878184,
0.049379576,
0.0720203072,
0.0007388002,
0.0748034269,
0.0563917495,
0.0198405106,
0.002837169,
0.0442539454,
-0.0771958008,
-0.0049210517,
-0.060813617,
0.0291290563,
-0.0186177511,
-0.0244302806,
0.0514784604,
0.0198642816,
0.0377279297,
-0.0636660084,
0.0786832124,
0.0322714336,
-0.0536566451,
-0.0308993347,
-0.0285665058,
0.0439850651,
-0.0024775246,
0.0036646659,
0.0184093695,
0.0261000078,
0.0112181995,
0.0085398406,
-0.0906469822,
0.0069393255,
-0.0527790859,
-0.0115709929,
-0.0242143068,
0.0112067852,
-0.0041046045,
0.0353992246,
-0.0078397272,
0.0185241438,
-0.0443167053,
0.011526187,
0.0196506586,
0.0348761007,
0.0157682616,
0.0126235448,
-0.0063544614,
-0.0389520675,
-0.1052687913,
-0.0112763215,
0.0101987123,
0.0173871145,
0.013172036,
0.022220375,
-0.0193555206,
-0.0523442514,
0.0034126975,
-0.0422843471,
-0.021154318,
-0.0346045457,
-0.0261328854,
0.0009885184,
-0.0127175059,
0.0347810797,
0.0137997447,
-0.0965669677,
-0.0409752801,
0.0956411958,
0.0006843063,
0.0637888461,
-0.0009194939,
-0.0080126785,
-0.037499927,
-0.0290917158,
0.0164470114,
0.0091997879,
0.018024778,
-0.0053952625,
0.0814252198,
0.0281776991,
-0.0233025346,
-0.0203537066,
-0.0152161866,
-0.0279170293,
-0.029843349,
0.0543648191,
0.0389434695,
0.0564265475,
-0.0002908668,
0.0790796354,
0.0185049456,
0.0372188985,
0.0235015098,
0.0203322489,
0.0355374925,
0.0389955156,
-0.018964937,
-0.0306853428,
-0.0146232396,
0.0676886067,
0.0527844839,
-0.0574892871,
-0.0203834772,
-0.0196632594,
2.426e-7,
0.0800002888,
0.0521385223,
0.0578413159,
0.0200911891,
0.0374085195,
0.028911721,
0.0057363249,
0.0512430593,
-0.0305630267,
0.0347582996,
0.044206664,
0.0213439744,
-0.0045384811,
0.0235529244,
-0.0663012341,
0.0565428138,
-0.1024639979,
-0.0057696686,
-0.0089528756,
0.0254690275,
0.0428501591,
0.0575483032,
0.02086813,
-0.0243074037,
-0.0165736638,
-0.0524646193,
0.0731310993,
-0.0169473607,
0.0154065508,
0.0204811301,
-0.018480964,
-0.0061525051,
-0.027431827,
0.0045876112,
-0.0179370809,
0.0479699373,
0.0437310338,
0.0266057849,
-0.030174898,
0.0067885215,
0.0144618256,
-0.0170924924,
0.0017985624,
-0.0118706431,
0.0596139655,
-0.0846249461,
-0.0314026363,
-0.0241997577,
-0.0141213331,
-0.0298864022,
0.0192933008,
0.0091277426,
0.0087130526,
0.0400943011,
0.0336145833,
-0.0417050235,
0.0159956012,
-0.0785152912,
0.0277536176,
0.0225173179,
-0.0077537522,
0.0213614926,
-0.0146789886,
0.0334098302,
0.0586454459,
-0.0135244476,
0.0122768413,
2.085322616e-34,
0.0112467092,
0.0041522766,
-0.0384385251,
-0.0201099645,
-0.0052241446,
-0.0370039679,
0.0100977439,
0.009906373,
0.013413677,
-0.1048349589,
-0.0146682039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14577v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14577v2 | Difference-Masking: Choosing What to Mask in Continued Pretraining | 2023-05-23T23:31:02 | 2023-10-17T21:03:10 | Alex Wilf, Syeda Nahida Akter, Leena Mathur, Paul Pu Liang, Sheryl Mathew, Mengrou Shou, Eric Nyberg, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The self-supervised objective of masking-and-predicting has led to promising
performance gains on a variety of downstream tasks. However, while most
approaches randomly mask tokens, there is strong intuition that deciding what
to mask can substantially improve learning outcomes. We investigate this in
continued pretraining setting in which pretrained models continue to pretrain
on domain-specific data before performing some downstream task. We introduce
Difference-Masking, a masking strategy that automatically chooses what to mask
during continued pretraining by considering what makes a task domain different
from the pretraining domain. Empirically, we find that Difference-Masking
outperforms baselines on continued pretraining settings across four diverse
language-only and multimodal video tasks. | [
-0.0077294637,
0.0465591699,
-0.0155368187,
0.0020375603,
0.0055484097,
0.0118938861,
0.0613577887,
0.0087509844,
-0.0330452807,
-0.0436335951,
-0.0168031529,
-0.0203157049,
-0.0482643284,
0.0513670444,
0.0117557198,
-0.0771800131,
0.052845329,
-0.0192471109,
-0.0239271633,
0.0081065632,
-0.0094220582,
-0.0286732409,
-0.0042075147,
0.0117333364,
-0.0382588543,
-0.0326316468,
-0.0074396734,
-0.0197003223,
0.0173535161,
-0.0415761806,
0.0604379475,
0.0603191219,
0.0423083529,
0.0039517097,
0.0000021323,
-0.0538933761,
-0.0037794134,
-0.0310902335,
-0.0467622094,
0.0115203205,
-0.0228482448,
0.0228213053,
0.0239205714,
-0.0027675356,
-0.0336711854,
-0.0343233012,
0.0320133381,
0.0239235181,
0.0516116992,
0.0144984825,
-0.0306652728,
-0.0178177636,
-0.0229440015,
-0.0368846096,
0.0060385587,
-0.0257331412,
0.0006571499,
-0.0305713024,
-0.0871194378,
-0.0449190587,
-0.0472969189,
0.0137459543,
0.0412092581,
0.0257835966,
0.0206555184,
0.0459467694,
0.0105017228,
-0.0319569223,
-0.0160360001,
0.0240640044,
-0.0598624051,
-0.0086251339,
-0.0121467449,
-0.0351345539,
0.024766909,
-0.0252332296,
-0.0161457118,
0.0086192032,
0.0045900312,
0.0028788776,
-0.038502004,
0.0439920686,
0.0232388731,
0.0050775977,
-0.0478857122,
-0.0078456299,
-0.0000430529,
0.0045135412,
0.0048047537,
0.0239169355,
-0.0094119236,
-0.0865709931,
0.0394493043,
0.0114588859,
-0.0166420024,
-0.0143088717,
-0.0697632134,
-0.0415763333,
-0.044639729,
0.0143460408,
0.0443368033,
0.0351116471,
-0.0945898667,
0.0142885493,
-0.0274441708,
0.032421127,
0.0000918903,
0.045637738,
-0.0115897013,
0.0327371769,
-0.047512453,
-0.0091637643,
-0.0430471338,
0.0633236542,
-0.0297594257,
0.0068486212,
-0.0028028407,
0.0157031845,
-0.0533064939,
-0.0038304413,
-0.0029346892,
0.0132062361,
-0.05538816,
0.0011069973,
-0.016285805,
-0.0101132896,
-0.0342835039,
0.0506420359,
0.0250833929,
-0.0280574728,
-0.0221714173,
-0.014414479,
-0.0067115002,
-0.0535616502,
0.0305763632,
0.0712883249,
-0.0347914435,
-0.0172383767,
-0.012837369,
0.0039424598,
0.0338603593,
-0.0434764549,
0.08526133,
-0.0041691484,
0.025165312,
-0.0023384523,
0.0365373977,
-0.0434207544,
-0.0431646891,
-0.0296519529,
0.0394816585,
0.0982898846,
0.0217899252,
-0.0213131793,
0.0181947518,
0.0261590015,
-0.0585556813,
0.061203517,
-0.0142400041,
0.0022580156,
0.0571960248,
-0.018838197,
0.0083232988,
0.0277092531,
0.0327937864,
-0.0036698682,
-0.0384363607,
-0.0008237718,
0.0539663173,
-0.0092569645,
0.0557265282,
-0.0585195683,
-0.0462979749,
-0.0372332595,
0.041394107,
0.0553640574,
0.012952215,
-0.0042863763,
0.0359941497,
-0.0158571526,
0.0132761924,
0.0706352741,
-0.0513179563,
0.0192429628,
0.024078764,
-0.0330898762,
-0.0301830173,
0.0300851818,
-0.0565377176,
-0.0524826162,
0.0221527535,
-0.0219932981,
0.0365991443,
0.0155624347,
0.0463983156,
0.0315049477,
-0.0271833092,
0.0334098525,
0.0186322536,
-0.0304425936,
0.0526174679,
-0.0698759779,
-0.0113448855,
0.02343948,
-0.0195986778,
-0.0376625396,
-0.046033293,
0.0028600807,
0.0736758932,
-0.0177299958,
0.0182604175,
-0.0031058739,
0.0862703845,
-0.0388423465,
-0.0665971562,
-0.0481090732,
0.005621288,
0.0136710284,
0.0074884943,
0.0189695321,
0.0055563571,
-0.0022654445,
0.032423649,
0.0519718491,
-0.0472030863,
-0.0280868467,
0.029254334,
0.0057254578,
0.0237393249,
-0.0339435786,
-0.0133563923,
-0.0202511903,
0.0041576275,
-0.0260460209,
-0.0061353431,
0.0233541001,
-0.0641146377,
-0.0255521014,
0.0296166986,
-0.0176063608,
-0.0170888063,
0.0759130567,
-0.0287570842,
-0.0019513017,
0.0192740057,
0.0642826334,
0.0350982137,
-0.0200462937,
0.005226803,
0.0149085904,
0.025930481,
0.007597744,
-0.0029168485,
0.0273129307,
-0.0313150138,
-0.0335823931,
-0.0018487389,
0.0284995474,
-0.0042427741,
0.0246044137,
-0.0218980834,
-0.0320801176,
-0.019923538,
0.0013341219,
0.0119609637,
-0.0591407157,
0.0267210845,
-0.0496425368,
-0.0062533892,
-0.0276112724,
-0.0110406866,
0.0129761323,
-0.0018342722,
-0.0261973273,
-0.0735358074,
0.0131549798,
-0.026104955,
-0.026373256,
0.0088121528,
-0.0115898354,
0.0287987106,
0.0351449177,
-0.0222517997,
-0.0175780077,
0.029606279,
0.0243242811,
-0.0223054402,
-0.053466443,
-0.0173179694,
0.0191548411,
-0.0169115532,
0.0663361773,
-0.0179900657,
-0.0164940152,
0.0100145228,
-0.0064687678,
0.0459665917,
0.0487149991,
0.0115726842,
0.0195424259,
0.0578444153,
-0.0121225221,
-0.0236309394,
0.0078174975,
-0.0474405698,
-0.0246590748,
-0.018441109,
0.0043022837,
0.0232246574,
0.0391349085,
-0.0083801346,
-0.0208809245,
-0.0587834716,
0.0029139933,
-0.0587922782,
-0.0372738279,
-0.0589585714,
0.0188256297,
-0.0094327517,
0.0421550535,
-0.026415227,
-0.0309805255,
0.0651655421,
0.039060805,
-0.0127855772,
-0.0112591572,
0.0098317815,
0.0201981682,
0.0448983125,
0.0117437672,
-0.00935716,
0.0253828578,
-0.0427415557,
-0.0552886352,
-0.0033765896,
0.0230065696,
0.0195579547,
-0.003230528,
-0.0421353839,
-0.0225778054,
-0.0137191629,
-0.0302718543,
-0.0444115922,
-0.0502336286,
0.0277337246,
-0.0223687664,
-0.0296371989,
0.0303577241,
0.0031251339,
-0.0076823784,
-0.0160410162,
0.0837103724,
-0.0198656283,
0.0001901031,
0.0019529326,
-0.0018789937,
-0.0073566069,
0.0173069779,
-0.0019506508,
-0.0727236718,
0.0463992059,
0.0237018932,
0.0931292027,
-0.0315601304,
-0.007546403,
0.05317064,
0.0272743292,
-0.0039555137,
-0.0092323767,
0.0362499394,
0.0355069116,
-0.0357943065,
-0.0242903456,
0.0742275789,
-0.0031541064,
-0.0104395533,
-0.0085265348,
-0.0145614417,
0.0026584733,
0.0479049236,
0.0109981671,
-0.0716818273,
-0.0184797738,
0.0037224926,
0.0163211916,
0.0412876718,
0.0060054692,
-0.019085668,
-0.0788138062,
0.0616058633,
0.0131660514,
-0.0449326485,
0.0214963667,
0.0046996144,
0.0005100961,
-0.0184409209,
-0.0294324495,
-0.0306039397,
-0.015997,
-0.0188178252,
0.0339080133,
-0.0318361223,
-0.0649503917,
0.0255325306,
-0.0366821997,
-0.0376083963,
0.0558189042,
-0.0446234196,
-0.0137695437,
-0.0379539318,
0.0741755366,
-0.0188268684,
0.0113829859,
-0.0118367607,
0.0950732604,
-0.0017236273,
-0.017850576,
0.0225632843,
-0.0011667967,
0.0320738591,
-0.0772165209,
0.0339895599,
0.010137599,
0.0029712205,
-0.0281903949,
-0.0058352714,
-0.0167122092,
0.0173988249,
0.0255888309,
0.004050015,
-0.0572325289,
-0.0250207577,
0.0162483752,
0.0269546658,
-0.0482110791,
0.0119556328,
-0.0046346011,
-0.0614931211,
-0.0074475827,
-0.0122156665,
-0.0238608532,
0.0257695969,
0.0396158434,
0.004493495,
-0.022393845,
-0.0139888152,
0.0231514964,
-0.0779238045,
0.0580366887,
-0.001575653,
0.0067040981,
-0.0506729931,
-0.0372678936,
0.0267530624,
-0.0085994545,
-0.0182894561,
-0.0065330449,
-0.0568885915,
-0.0206926316,
0.0467887744,
0.0517850667,
0.0151841091,
0.0984117016,
0.0366201997,
-0.0345324576,
0.0494109616,
0.0043495614,
-0.0162829775,
0.0485369042,
0.0874192342,
-0.0765741989,
-0.0072558653,
-0.0150544709,
-0.0312191527,
0.0438625664,
0.0349129438,
-0.0156355519,
0.016724091,
0.0614194199,
0.0061752042,
-0.051638037,
0.1210359037,
-0.0298946016,
0.0239310972,
-0.0387412347,
0.0144842621,
-0.0191131923,
-0.0046877027,
-0.033167921,
-0.0054804189,
0.0185777098,
0.0363684222,
0.0095276656,
0.0743200183,
-0.0304985531,
0.0051303953,
-0.0875273719,
-0.0391379856,
-0.0206559245,
0.0476444066,
-0.0011499054,
0.0363981836,
0.0152110774,
-0.0053369198,
0.0580416545,
0.0085488437,
-0.0285316613,
0.0203596242,
0.0413886718,
0.0558189638,
-0.0204165597,
0.0494863056,
-0.0272582266,
-0.025962349,
-0.0427570976,
-0.0186080746,
0.0215463024,
-0.0377246514,
0.000773344,
0.0091823833,
-0.0156117119,
-0.008891508,
0.0150217284,
-0.0036735183,
-0.0032085855,
0.0060310569,
-0.0167793855,
-0.0118456688,
-0.0134198386,
0.0728050992,
0.0159406774,
0.0568491928,
-0.0187174715,
0.0107130744,
-0.0400703736,
-0.0129001848,
0.0524492897,
0.039703384,
0.008955867,
-0.0031557127,
0.0064354111,
-0.057154499,
-0.0168645475,
-0.0210046228,
0.0013629583,
0.0614039935,
0.0406444408,
0.0250031147,
-0.027964754,
-0.0457288064,
-0.0125642223,
-0.0001573255,
0.0816413015,
-0.0027420265,
0.0306942817,
-6.786799654e-33,
-0.0376919731,
0.0217178632,
0.0267033111,
0.0036662747,
-0.0063379891,
0.0078618387,
-0.0124472454,
-0.0120611424,
0.0264636874,
0.0197807569,
-0.0058399681,
0.0169617124,
0.0393328704,
0.0168761145,
0.0253285486,
-0.0148185035,
0.0834165812,
-0.0144413263,
-0.011322977,
-0.0070633544,
-0.0064008837,
0.0515035279,
0.0548571795,
-0.0717339218,
-0.0177606735,
0.0157710612,
-0.0419252925,
-0.0288082473,
0.0161910597,
0.0254911687,
-0.0175916161,
-0.0300411526,
0.0097275004,
-0.0449846424,
-0.079902336,
-0.0230534133,
-0.0963947698,
-0.0577182174,
-0.0251662787,
0.0396176018,
-0.0752810612,
-0.0008120789,
0.0255318433,
-0.0079763075,
-0.0544830896,
-0.0251776371,
0.0322203264,
-0.0025112885,
0.0416486003,
-0.0004733145,
-0.0488003679,
-0.0027706393,
-0.0044026687,
-0.0392565988,
0.0593174025,
0.0394593142,
0.027335573,
-0.018951131,
-0.083741352,
0.0175546724,
-0.0013448279,
0.0052464632,
0.0568424948,
0.0468982421,
0.016839128,
0.0446742922,
0.0740370899,
-0.0300242584,
0.053651046,
0.0218833759,
0.0428026579,
0.0116699245,
-0.0092720576,
-0.0106016695,
0.0888779685,
-0.043825455,
-0.0826811641,
0.0119907875,
-0.1248441413,
-0.00559997,
-0.029211022,
0.0304724835,
0.0544374213,
-0.0120710582,
-0.0238412712,
0.0052253278,
-0.0118346829,
-0.003087458,
0.0706963241,
0.0318544544,
0.0077573378,
0.0372235887,
0.0702668875,
-0.0353503227,
-0.0126400404,
-0.0015276046,
-0.0432029031,
0.0192957092,
0.0233176723,
0.0091478582,
-0.0327509679,
-0.0228957888,
0.064471297,
0.0128515279,
0.0376898237,
-0.0125275254,
0.0397761948,
0.0573038049,
-0.0371697284,
-0.01444194,
-0.0243259799,
0.0200382974,
0.0867589638,
0.0351016596,
0.0424388722,
0.0483350679,
-0.0399942584,
0.0544448011,
0.0295368452,
-0.0934523866,
-0.0398048423,
0.0174215976,
0.0228857063,
0.0638874695,
0.0020635214,
-0.0099757547,
-0.0315460525,
-0.0215050858,
0.0667598099,
-0.0574209951,
-0.0353266373,
-0.0031189234,
2.737e-7,
-0.0168654826,
0.0156086795,
0.0016797036,
-0.0142260334,
0.0078341765,
0.0465828069,
-0.0397637226,
0.0235058237,
0.0238990411,
0.0185419489,
-0.0054610539,
0.037032906,
0.0060660304,
0.009829158,
0.0260458998,
-0.0219238866,
0.0044410503,
-0.0227195546,
-0.0465486012,
-0.0027868864,
-0.0092861047,
0.0602894798,
0.0431285538,
-0.00197246,
0.0440355241,
-0.0163450725,
0.0682626292,
-0.0292623714,
0.0148650128,
-0.0168275405,
-0.028310284,
0.0480894782,
-0.0099609438,
0.0366811752,
-0.0596698001,
-0.0111859785,
0.0200062487,
0.0192134939,
-0.0179791432,
0.0004366773,
-0.0218868367,
0.0916861892,
0.0074976562,
-0.0246215612,
0.0658387989,
-0.0775858238,
0.0041788397,
-0.0311312694,
-0.0377772227,
0.0012586943,
0.0302202515,
-0.005792357,
-0.0229347982,
0.0246727429,
0.0328700207,
0.0702652633,
-0.0684446096,
-0.0936933756,
-0.0282807313,
0.0246003475,
-0.0457796343,
-0.0022056999,
-0.0183435436,
0.004772387,
0.0202904288,
-0.0249341335,
-0.0131762596,
2.102945848e-34,
-0.0057274117,
-0.002036314,
0.017856285,
0.005325295,
-0.0198101141,
-0.0113860574,
-0.0042745871,
0.0035339755,
-0.0139227984,
0.0388491228,
-0.0218140427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14576v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14576v2 | Parameter-Efficient Language Model Tuning with Active Learning in Low-Resource Settings | 2023-05-23T23:27:20 | 2023-10-23T13:58:26 | Josip Jukić, Jan Šnajder | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have ignited a surge in demand for
effective fine-tuning techniques, particularly in low-resource domains and
languages. Active learning (AL), a set of algorithms designed to decrease
labeling costs by minimizing label complexity, has shown promise in confronting
the labeling bottleneck. In parallel, adapter modules designed for
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) have demonstrated notable potential in
low-resource settings. However, the interplay between AL and adapter-based PEFT
remains unexplored. We present an empirical study of PEFT behavior with AL in
low-resource settings for text classification tasks. Our findings affirm the
superiority of PEFT over full-fine tuning (FFT) in low-resource settings and
demonstrate that this advantage persists in AL setups. We further examine the
properties of PEFT and FFT through the lens of forgetting dynamics and
instance-level representations, where we find that PEFT yields more stable
representations of early and middle layers compared to FFT. Our research
underscores the synergistic potential of AL and PEFT in low-resource settings,
paving the way for advancements in efficient and effective fine-tuning. | [
0.0239904728,
0.0211648438,
-0.0073398342,
0.0135240257,
0.0055991989,
0.0403664894,
0.0515176281,
-0.0177726131,
0.0018676694,
-0.0567235425,
-0.048897244,
-0.0409698077,
0.0238210596,
0.0119061498,
-0.0004784226,
-0.0276163314,
0.0573118366,
-0.0156357419,
0.0343697108,
-0.0217290632,
0.0091093872,
-0.0060296976,
0.0010121495,
0.0212789662,
0.0195369869,
0.0192229785,
0.0027266112,
0.0085174106,
0.0110289836,
0.0298930965,
0.0494763292,
0.0698476434,
0.0126292538,
0.0608748496,
0.0000021049,
-0.0238991771,
-0.0333772562,
-0.0093403095,
-0.0143535919,
0.0849239081,
0.049202092,
0.0601179264,
-0.0217717309,
0.0099172983,
-0.0189296007,
-0.0820905045,
0.0812974572,
0.0250627436,
0.0431225635,
0.0402135625,
-0.0062009855,
0.0013244824,
0.0089643449,
-0.0454765484,
-0.0153007442,
-0.0468529388,
0.0203603283,
-0.0746022537,
-0.0381124988,
-0.0312833488,
-0.0170501079,
0.044649832,
0.0067180367,
0.0205137637,
-0.0153330965,
0.0309624746,
-0.046925392,
-0.0352937877,
0.0188727379,
0.0416374952,
-0.0325750187,
-0.0360470414,
-0.0072688553,
-0.0450736135,
-0.0298151579,
0.0416821614,
0.0001124784,
-0.0006003147,
0.0002588476,
0.0168637335,
0.0462198742,
-0.0395958424,
0.0486046523,
0.0133984387,
-0.0083852634,
-0.0050425497,
0.0161286052,
-0.0281683765,
0.0293482244,
0.0082127564,
-0.0328181088,
-0.0058534699,
0.0107679563,
0.0096260374,
-0.0041819741,
0.0210509747,
-0.0535900146,
-0.0582594909,
0.0033013292,
-0.0583356917,
0.0634715706,
0.0390404575,
-0.0061141774,
0.0350662805,
-0.0562690087,
-0.0049371175,
0.0302060768,
0.0240413547,
-0.0376347639,
0.0079568233,
-0.04745939,
-0.021306375,
-0.0712791532,
0.015943313,
0.0042633,
0.0094260564,
-0.0253874678,
0.02641996,
-0.0041429885,
0.0031308171,
-0.026678171,
-0.0140172252,
-0.0499342009,
0.0053214007,
0.003727711,
0.0512258597,
0.0124308672,
0.0091047231,
-0.0400122479,
-0.0475744568,
-0.0029914516,
0.00950424,
0.017813338,
-0.0324883536,
0.0314110443,
0.0549112745,
-0.0054142834,
-0.0774197876,
-0.0413279496,
0.0261590295,
0.0099312114,
-0.0511017554,
-0.0102065178,
-0.0251947269,
-0.0002681113,
0.0296556763,
0.0361435339,
-0.0646935701,
-0.0113841165,
0.0186110847,
-0.0371334441,
0.051599972,
-0.0068670022,
-0.0065166741,
0.0529283583,
0.0003481524,
0.0573459342,
0.0725813881,
0.016796466,
0.0241575446,
0.039789632,
-0.0452799127,
-0.0192775521,
0.0531853177,
0.0125844916,
0.0179910865,
-0.046167817,
-0.0071405917,
0.0293532535,
-0.0370844975,
-0.0277915448,
0.0019529837,
-0.0102925068,
0.0059960485,
0.0705824569,
-0.001775021,
0.0134482188,
0.0192066077,
0.0069517819,
-0.0100833634,
0.0373320244,
-0.0154601121,
-0.0423171744,
0.0256050676,
-0.0227991659,
-0.007851827,
0.0086490428,
0.0488125607,
-0.0570798628,
-0.0345535204,
-0.0180480089,
-0.0369227976,
-0.019332476,
0.0430727266,
0.0440581813,
0.0131128188,
-0.0219463184,
0.0947464183,
0.0533436649,
-0.0034499697,
-0.0220229067,
-0.0596617162,
-0.0279885121,
0.0110094743,
0.0107373558,
-0.0674849227,
-0.0493071564,
-0.0041224398,
0.0703274757,
0.0132349208,
0.0736192763,
-0.0016447385,
0.0186131522,
-0.0508391671,
-0.0387770124,
0.0243291259,
0.0315582938,
0.0003586632,
0.0370433182,
-0.0033106145,
0.0192669742,
-0.0526177958,
-0.078039296,
0.0292072725,
-0.0137593504,
-0.0372925773,
0.0316494294,
0.0247824844,
0.0123699754,
-0.0156531017,
-0.030799197,
-0.0205546077,
0.0148111377,
-0.0008839263,
0.0267081838,
-0.0022606705,
-0.0263430644,
0.0415398292,
-0.0036838243,
0.0439874753,
0.0007827951,
0.019688081,
-0.0417466722,
-0.0570406914,
-0.0119664511,
-0.0126025211,
0.0260431841,
-0.0407815054,
0.0178673249,
-0.0687163174,
0.0302685238,
-0.0384571776,
0.0361747406,
0.007807015,
0.0156266745,
0.0088970577,
0.0013197365,
0.0297234394,
0.0050228671,
-0.0452471823,
-0.0037215941,
0.016595643,
0.009020024,
0.0077705355,
-0.004805713,
-0.0158889368,
-0.0196266826,
-0.0395933501,
0.0237360448,
-0.0417137891,
-0.013137985,
0.0120042106,
0.0430277698,
0.0061201304,
-0.0138864405,
-0.0083946129,
0.0570878573,
-0.035607826,
0.0400457494,
-0.0034332629,
-0.001971765,
-0.034695711,
-0.0206099041,
-0.019975733,
0.0262766927,
0.0334532745,
-0.0109611517,
-0.0195889268,
-0.0641990304,
-0.0032392179,
-0.0093371933,
0.0194745641,
0.002312999,
-0.0265507232,
-0.0100865178,
-0.0243770368,
-0.0107870148,
0.0596910752,
-0.0113920113,
0.0541784391,
0.0360182002,
0.0297497418,
-0.0315855592,
0.0206052288,
-0.0547184721,
-0.0172603242,
-0.0373506956,
0.0256349705,
-0.0283096004,
0.0936743915,
-0.034938015,
0.011021887,
-0.0400792509,
0.0101380544,
-0.0315650813,
-0.0014845048,
-0.0094423816,
0.0370772183,
-0.0170993209,
0.008058277,
-0.0116574289,
-0.0979986638,
0.0722479001,
-0.0109804589,
-0.0197207127,
-0.0458699092,
-0.0339168757,
-0.0185628012,
0.0113979355,
0.0488578901,
0.0114441356,
0.0262044389,
-0.0102365464,
-0.0663504899,
-0.0180793423,
0.0278164875,
-0.0187801365,
0.0447967798,
-0.0262070317,
0.0017759999,
-0.0290326271,
-0.0306566432,
-0.0135537898,
-0.039632529,
-0.0176471137,
0.0320494473,
-0.0273254085,
-0.0323749594,
-0.0410315283,
0.0396444686,
0.0259407572,
0.0600374229,
-0.0058247582,
-0.01084546,
-0.0101174107,
0.031769082,
0.0329322331,
0.0014315243,
0.0123835243,
-0.0568534136,
-0.000483115,
0.0031448351,
0.0191358346,
-0.0179633964,
-0.0026414851,
-0.0005470477,
0.0476771332,
-0.0293649752,
-0.0311760325,
0.0079369843,
0.0435397625,
-0.0592335127,
-0.0388028324,
0.1085639223,
0.0226868503,
-0.084797278,
-0.0149137732,
0.0321085565,
0.0466030389,
0.0161084328,
0.0313147642,
-0.0141263427,
-0.0379727371,
-0.0050321193,
0.0802012458,
0.0203743018,
0.0050821565,
0.0044065327,
-0.0576320924,
0.0182839874,
0.0280770287,
-0.0481449105,
0.0106611587,
-0.0456653759,
0.0011401916,
-0.0243595149,
0.0221633017,
-0.0136925615,
0.0048721158,
0.0245181751,
0.0510793701,
-0.018907439,
-0.0364648774,
0.0080315582,
0.0112801082,
0.051414635,
0.0258580036,
-0.0353733599,
-0.0317256488,
-0.029075129,
0.058082331,
-0.0694933236,
-0.0072224848,
-0.0543375537,
-0.0102188708,
0.0192725677,
-0.0203873329,
0.0262293853,
-0.0047560371,
-0.0128188329,
-0.0195919871,
-0.0085331816,
0.0587878712,
-0.0296327937,
0.0153685436,
0.0206090994,
-0.0431357436,
-0.0103056151,
0.0407019071,
0.0395895988,
-0.0680210069,
-0.0255844146,
0.0054660686,
0.010280814,
-0.0412147306,
-0.0187913831,
-0.0049915821,
-0.0392708778,
-0.0414505936,
0.0159454197,
0.0000194212,
0.0335553624,
0.0617385618,
0.0097355014,
0.0318901129,
-0.0045633526,
0.0083443373,
-0.0462703779,
-0.0050373645,
-0.0398212112,
0.0191426799,
-0.0350326411,
-0.0877554193,
0.0593750142,
-0.0591239184,
-0.0164281037,
0.0009331335,
-0.0523898005,
-0.0603360981,
0.0868099704,
0.0353341363,
0.0234791059,
0.0553217269,
0.001098016,
-0.0684934407,
0.0312988758,
0.0660519078,
0.0228781402,
0.0413400158,
0.0204404388,
-0.0539145358,
-0.0202812944,
0.0291754324,
-0.0518224202,
0.0087637687,
0.0954455137,
0.0175539926,
-0.0173967369,
-0.062486127,
-0.0078583127,
-0.0115574142,
0.0908870697,
-0.0328934342,
-0.0649026632,
-0.032154385,
0.0414326079,
0.0502916276,
-0.0162505284,
-0.0249016602,
-0.0332842469,
0.0077033397,
0.0584402904,
-0.0288318451,
0.0433426015,
0.0596171059,
0.0724990293,
0.0070911576,
0.0484882072,
-0.0288641807,
0.0047639646,
0.0173068978,
0.028686095,
-0.0183131117,
0.0444080867,
0.0500330888,
0.0462501086,
-0.0439339243,
0.0679200366,
0.0171131343,
0.0389855951,
-0.0731820986,
0.0352186896,
-0.0516758598,
-0.0677945912,
-0.0491896048,
0.0153399678,
0.0427486636,
-0.053144373,
0.0352955461,
-0.0304299649,
-0.0318388753,
-0.0129832886,
-0.0120908814,
0.0528474301,
0.0034830694,
0.0243092068,
0.0229144786,
-0.019615449,
0.0312373322,
0.0597978458,
0.0259359907,
0.0500156991,
0.0122847119,
0.0083219204,
-0.0219722278,
-0.0030850482,
0.0056633297,
0.0021204136,
-0.0289202332,
-0.0040795254,
-0.0419189408,
-0.0503834151,
-0.0083451215,
-0.0689535663,
0.0003813828,
-0.0358644798,
0.0317038335,
0.0551653095,
0.0121099502,
0.0233093537,
-0.029801663,
-0.0177695975,
0.0388569981,
-0.0011788707,
0.0283275507,
-6.6895297e-33,
-0.0265560038,
0.0192738082,
-0.0128720179,
0.028500814,
-0.0066096885,
0.03608381,
-0.0290960036,
-0.008070128,
-0.0093571031,
-0.0131497877,
-0.0049106693,
-0.0216184985,
0.0302585308,
0.0218395926,
-0.0220431853,
-0.009890195,
0.0566229932,
-0.0142289186,
-0.005163718,
0.0487021245,
0.0300756507,
0.0332059115,
0.0459292494,
-0.0491919927,
-0.031412065,
0.0012506051,
0.0029607264,
0.0035896101,
-0.0056931362,
0.0274532177,
-0.0165590569,
0.0538278483,
-0.0010478066,
-0.0272340234,
-0.0170670189,
-0.0259829331,
-0.1110557169,
-0.010680682,
-0.0075137787,
0.0405328237,
0.0097989766,
0.0079082027,
0.049665384,
0.0169798862,
-0.0333329961,
-0.0088687204,
0.0379291512,
-0.0149908634,
-0.0738729984,
-0.0368627124,
-0.0622530207,
0.0349743851,
-0.000065523,
0.0099857487,
0.0357633382,
-0.0313211158,
-0.0165205132,
0.0070781866,
-0.0902552158,
-0.0233860966,
0.016793957,
0.0444790721,
0.0032432843,
0.0661076009,
-0.0027337472,
0.023082627,
0.0834575742,
0.0261000451,
0.0183352157,
0.0549687892,
0.0597480461,
-0.0161331687,
0.0125985714,
-0.0105291614,
0.0240812078,
-0.0679779053,
-0.0510032028,
-0.0186376926,
0.028467251,
-0.001805941,
0.0454934239,
0.0190051999,
-0.0192044191,
-0.030867951,
-0.033380419,
0.026295742,
-0.0392426774,
-0.0120257456,
0.0007944702,
0.0228376966,
-0.0640255958,
-0.0108994031,
0.0243032575,
-0.029644398,
0.0115869883,
-0.0179680288,
0.01332522,
0.0290867686,
-0.0041995198,
-0.0109683713,
-0.0654132515,
-0.0874491632,
-0.0149760088,
0.0008801935,
0.0055146809,
-0.0053366651,
0.0482019745,
0.0694256499,
-0.0735507309,
0.0074035842,
-0.0120097576,
-0.0160892829,
0.0453491732,
0.078181982,
0.0067317938,
-0.0032673511,
0.0075408481,
0.025150938,
0.0264029596,
-0.0461097844,
-0.0207229778,
-0.0193594787,
-0.0141128795,
0.0212026797,
-0.0220672674,
0.0044883192,
-0.0299296901,
0.002893216,
0.0149412919,
-0.0942471102,
0.0134001663,
0.0104085775,
2.881e-7,
0.0381424539,
0.0523379818,
-0.031776879,
-0.0617960691,
0.0395933092,
0.0560809709,
-0.0255011562,
-0.0137166642,
0.0171317253,
0.0701298714,
0.0085025346,
0.002931688,
0.045040261,
0.0257074907,
-0.0786746889,
0.0012699472,
-0.037529964,
0.0826341584,
-0.0208695456,
0.0314468704,
-0.0181981437,
0.1081734076,
0.0251110941,
-0.0301801711,
0.0092368945,
-0.0672327578,
0.0461685918,
-0.012907452,
0.0370661765,
0.0224982556,
-0.0166359246,
0.0492253378,
-0.0265466459,
0.0094321072,
-0.0554309413,
-0.0018200697,
-0.0162418485,
0.0701742023,
0.0020904022,
-0.0156905837,
0.014022937,
0.0031020243,
0.0117229335,
-0.0418601558,
0.0931914598,
-0.0637516677,
-0.0358167924,
0.0134557458,
-0.0012367399,
-0.0305850059,
0.0234026257,
0.0078540826,
-0.0329196304,
0.0354035459,
-0.0113236848,
-0.0012248568,
-0.0537397899,
-0.1046043187,
-0.0229485873,
0.0076223235,
-0.0188930519,
-0.0606585331,
-0.0472212322,
-0.0103577487,
0.0496899746,
-0.0141702527,
0.015705321,
3.003467045e-34,
0.0467015393,
-0.0320322476,
0.0065599806,
0.0247078445,
-0.0130993025,
-0.0077711372,
0.0338243768,
0.0326239429,
-0.0097172046,
-0.0722045228,
-0.0028620923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14574v1 | Detecting and Mitigating Indirect Stereotypes in Word Embeddings | 2023-05-23T23:23:49 | 2023-05-23T23:23:49 | Erin George, Joyce Chew, Deanna Needell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Societal biases in the usage of words, including harmful stereotypes, are
frequently learned by common word embedding methods. These biases manifest not
only between a word and an explicit marker of its stereotype, but also between
words that share related stereotypes. This latter phenomenon, sometimes called
"indirect bias,'' has resisted prior attempts at debiasing. In this paper, we
propose a novel method called Biased Indirect Relationship Modification (BIRM)
to mitigate indirect bias in distributional word embeddings by modifying biased
relationships between words before embeddings are learned. This is done by
considering how the co-occurrence probability of a given pair of words changes
in the presence of words marking an attribute of bias, and using this to
average out the effect of a bias attribute. To evaluate this method, we perform
a series of common tests and demonstrate that measures of bias in the word
embeddings are reduced in exchange for minor reduction in the semantic quality
of the embeddings. In addition, we conduct novel tests for measuring indirect
stereotypes by extending the Word Embedding Association Test (WEAT) with new
test sets for indirect binary gender stereotypes. With these tests, we
demonstrate the presence of more subtle stereotypes not addressed by previous
work. The proposed method is able to reduce the presence of some of these new
stereotypes, serving as a crucial next step towards non-stereotyped word
embeddings. | [
0.0221260972,
0.0960031524,
-0.0169641636,
0.0335006602,
0.0131850438,
0.0200216491,
0.0083884904,
-0.0194119345,
0.0315371007,
-0.0492476113,
-0.0367599279,
-0.0287005771,
0.0420470759,
0.0171016175,
0.0479046963,
-0.0271888245,
0.0552511066,
0.1006712914,
0.0285309814,
-0.0415159948,
0.0286559556,
0.0163315926,
0.0057359044,
0.0174685959,
-0.0648605675,
-0.0133673372,
0.0821012333,
-0.0430424698,
-0.023352582,
-0.0310946666,
0.0447712801,
0.0546561256,
0.0399915464,
-0.0153371533,
0.0000019438,
-0.0663506389,
0.0354449376,
-0.0021038442,
0.0176785309,
0.002642479,
0.05924429,
-0.0323063172,
0.0032922779,
0.021281207,
-0.020847287,
-0.0489216559,
0.0581410602,
0.0285058673,
-0.01645834,
-0.0129826814,
-0.0067935479,
-0.0357415304,
-0.0701548308,
-0.0234584901,
0.0198837239,
0.0324315056,
0.0373762846,
-0.0303746946,
-0.0951757133,
-0.0432798974,
-0.0791165158,
-0.0150308609,
-0.0089403717,
0.0647487864,
0.048151426,
0.0575708225,
-0.0297400933,
-0.0463766195,
0.0312663615,
0.0497409068,
0.0177649725,
-0.0157767795,
-0.011623214,
-0.003444606,
0.0128041208,
0.0616125129,
0.0140771056,
0.0005534657,
0.016715711,
-0.0031580441,
-0.0177403763,
0.0129003655,
0.0245966762,
0.0393984616,
-0.0394700989,
0.0210959148,
0.041531343,
-0.0422226377,
0.0041137217,
0.0114092212,
0.0052469759,
0.0034156772,
-0.0246630274,
-0.0469656438,
0.01972837,
0.0196179729,
-0.0303376764,
-0.0081863375,
0.0306557752,
-0.0517350882,
0.0008746987,
0.0062706931,
-0.0138617354,
0.0133585082,
-0.0387145318,
-0.0084568048,
0.0231609102,
0.012074071,
0.0022169107,
0.0120174168,
-0.0047731223,
-0.0044876169,
0.0122226505,
-0.0108420234,
0.0468298271,
0.0040843762,
-0.037026912,
-0.0091389967,
-0.0619361363,
-0.0019833441,
-0.0023537094,
0.0711795464,
-0.0263303313,
0.0178818498,
-0.037319798,
-0.0114354966,
-0.0746592879,
0.0233251806,
-0.1063377336,
-0.028719468,
-0.0080777407,
-0.0010477067,
0.0038946015,
-0.0391363241,
0.00095456,
0.049575448,
0.0158567149,
-0.0492433757,
0.01211139,
-0.006784244,
-0.0259102918,
-0.0148447705,
0.0123842508,
-0.0100769093,
0.0282886699,
-0.0117817298,
0.0205401275,
-0.0555016398,
-0.0124517549,
0.0129796062,
-0.0820676237,
0.0857130587,
0.0635629743,
-0.0188500434,
0.0266687423,
0.0297513902,
-0.0360233374,
0.0659954175,
0.0371084176,
-0.0237675589,
0.0242679939,
-0.0106585557,
-0.0426169299,
0.0110229319,
0.0697927848,
-0.0059191794,
-0.0118675465,
0.034179654,
0.0064751278,
0.026906861,
0.0704058483,
0.0127471322,
-0.0031445373,
-0.0366688557,
0.0403674841,
0.037227653,
0.0047298172,
0.0271079149,
0.0252647698,
0.0175180268,
-0.0390577279,
0.0242524426,
-0.0755854622,
-0.0111004077,
0.0276896972,
-0.0308356024,
-0.004317028,
0.0696777478,
-0.0128973713,
0.014074306,
0.0009519026,
-0.003485234,
0.0638284311,
-0.0410812646,
0.0142004676,
0.0674062818,
-0.0056731296,
0.0771571398,
0.0588631108,
-0.0128073338,
0.0070302039,
-0.0106286937,
0.0222612377,
0.0007432343,
0.0431066789,
0.0131433634,
0.0092082685,
-0.0060009188,
-0.0522740744,
0.0356817953,
0.0149493627,
-0.0071579646,
-0.0090290718,
-0.0277993437,
-0.0155389095,
0.0335134342,
0.0452080555,
0.032479614,
0.0451825559,
0.0438633338,
0.0185224768,
-0.0321362466,
0.0231669825,
0.038059622,
-0.0088762827,
-0.0563847907,
0.0171568934,
0.0491850041,
0.026298577,
0.0057490058,
-0.0515013337,
0.0012854261,
0.0042187837,
0.0103272684,
-0.0096136257,
0.0498371348,
-0.0742820129,
-0.0296165086,
-0.0124073839,
-0.0759337917,
-0.0321530886,
0.0292248186,
-0.0154839428,
0.0204199236,
0.054495886,
-0.0120381899,
0.0634898767,
-0.040569026,
-0.0370309576,
-0.0433100574,
0.0693397149,
0.0101566771,
0.0462794453,
-0.0278700609,
-0.0286997147,
-0.0103638358,
-0.0198580846,
0.0265036877,
0.017338492,
-0.0409538113,
0.0051614069,
0.008977022,
-0.021376634,
0.0175292939,
-0.0305625498,
-0.0539245047,
0.0093622217,
-0.0694993064,
-0.0185624231,
0.0072941096,
-0.0179999545,
0.0017567058,
0.0020859619,
-0.008692774,
-0.0194294732,
-0.0145901013,
-0.0180574693,
-0.0227384567,
0.0605469383,
0.0136824399,
-0.0575074479,
-0.0124631468,
-0.0166229531,
-0.001600696,
-0.0423260853,
0.0690109804,
0.0011331585,
0.0029466508,
-0.0203131977,
0.0035255891,
-0.0785694644,
-0.0030260989,
0.0351394191,
-0.006716961,
0.0141089577,
0.0623543896,
0.0638960302,
0.0320381857,
0.0204669125,
0.0211023521,
0.076814048,
-0.0157032553,
-0.0327484012,
-0.0332926176,
-0.0259191897,
0.0212572049,
0.0572174452,
-0.0643502325,
-0.0660689622,
0.0366696343,
0.0542835146,
-0.0327045768,
-0.0496290177,
0.0632638559,
-0.039240323,
-0.0360183194,
-0.0044008158,
-0.0196076781,
-0.0316173248,
-0.0363121852,
-0.039849475,
-0.0450061634,
0.0354771577,
0.0249597076,
0.0206370335,
-0.0329298563,
0.0265777409,
0.005468375,
0.0085419919,
0.0025169654,
0.0174630098,
0.0002118069,
-0.0047406247,
-0.0586414933,
-0.0520447008,
0.0295825265,
-0.0251100231,
-0.0178401563,
-0.0026052124,
-0.0160984751,
0.021698745,
-0.0416129641,
-0.046850726,
-0.0765303224,
-0.0039827395,
-0.0038145673,
-0.0005864259,
-0.0113778803,
0.0003803679,
-0.0149357282,
-0.0091233887,
-0.0364547484,
0.0148668839,
-0.0098377271,
0.0204999298,
0.008834471,
0.0279436614,
-0.0178529508,
0.0011353123,
0.052152168,
-0.0316967331,
0.0242119431,
-0.0118600251,
0.0182586648,
-0.0182968713,
0.0084394775,
-0.0099270251,
-0.0220922604,
0.0311213285,
-0.0257546082,
0.0040320023,
0.0288984217,
-0.0070721204,
0.0599558204,
0.0286577288,
-0.0424051844,
0.0456637926,
0.0390241034,
0.0069584693,
0.0311661512,
-0.0235206913,
-0.0943008438,
-0.0134118265,
0.0026182465,
-0.0234750081,
-0.0196554847,
-0.0505404919,
-0.041741807,
-0.1147273555,
-0.0347118378,
0.0066452567,
0.0043426002,
-0.011068684,
-0.0409775265,
0.0071181254,
-0.0040813885,
0.0404022001,
-0.0515977517,
0.0137795424,
0.0160112828,
-0.0343710966,
-0.0382127054,
-0.0400169306,
0.0320586376,
-0.0307104141,
0.0411850624,
0.0085075656,
0.0640518069,
-0.0213666521,
0.0154204816,
0.0157920998,
-0.0514185913,
-0.0343127176,
-0.0381899066,
0.0386667065,
-0.0749192983,
-0.0259930883,
-0.0047397208,
0.0022777095,
0.0361410007,
0.0178760048,
-0.0154470503,
0.0417827331,
0.0249876194,
-0.0438332409,
-0.0648903772,
-0.0007892516,
0.0055348803,
0.0971133709,
0.0127086751,
-0.0160266701,
0.032481987,
-0.0157719124,
-0.0131184002,
0.0844281837,
-0.0280757006,
-0.0074467347,
-0.0122357309,
0.0142639158,
-0.0670243949,
-0.068656005,
0.0209655613,
-0.0083037671,
0.0225925837,
-0.041037932,
-0.0118957637,
-0.0195077844,
-0.0947652683,
0.0104215406,
0.0054673548,
0.0215852931,
0.0546825491,
-0.0083297165,
0.0356598906,
-0.0118781319,
-0.0497044772,
0.0052481755,
-0.0020661848,
-0.0411248989,
0.0356651917,
0.0005050493,
0.0044135619,
0.0490217768,
-0.0199707709,
-0.0125271874,
0.0862639248,
0.0292560514,
-0.0058631827,
0.0206948891,
0.0104698054,
0.0245650262,
0.0273472629,
0.0360481218,
-0.035297174,
0.0368033536,
0.0031749145,
0.006762845,
0.0132450648,
-0.0104618035,
-0.0158567708,
0.0016103702,
0.0330985747,
-0.0431965664,
0.0413465239,
-0.0453782566,
-0.0401115641,
-0.0420108661,
-0.0340142846,
0.0404066518,
-0.0162464883,
0.0337838829,
0.0237355735,
-0.0573577993,
-0.0147648472,
-0.0459274165,
0.0499841683,
-0.0014175806,
-0.0004597143,
0.0662693605,
0.0143042803,
-0.016087506,
0.0189788975,
-0.0189901385,
0.0099498592,
-0.0464594811,
0.014864957,
0.0058880281,
0.0141065819,
0.0011028099,
0.0069087865,
-0.0623635985,
-0.0017187431,
0.0071900124,
0.0357987881,
0.00060298,
0.0190488994,
-0.0030535506,
-0.0760445371,
0.0193095002,
-0.0193889029,
-0.0017254991,
0.024560621,
-0.005264272,
-0.0347990617,
-0.0177333113,
0.0549099259,
-0.0019712613,
-0.0194544233,
0.0220717583,
0.0488162972,
0.0046637799,
0.0724967718,
-0.0506199971,
-0.0455777906,
-0.0290949494,
0.0141969696,
0.068976365,
-0.0049668755,
-0.0101385619,
0.0150922993,
-0.0811971873,
-0.0757470205,
-0.0042194198,
-0.0201615244,
0.0244581234,
0.0203508902,
0.0108472919,
0.0324619934,
-0.0028997231,
-0.0040516187,
0.0164672155,
0.0078745922,
-0.0249100178,
-0.0215734001,
-0.0175692234,
-6.269125901e-33,
-0.0082163736,
-0.0212879032,
-0.0248950813,
-0.0586673059,
-0.0249253009,
0.0078379624,
-0.003763665,
-0.0100200633,
-0.038090039,
0.0410511717,
0.0049653393,
0.0151153877,
0.0051714908,
-0.0462139472,
0.0109160049,
0.0150721027,
0.0344581679,
-0.0043833349,
-0.044634223,
-0.03884051,
0.0144029409,
0.0349686146,
0.046877943,
-0.0645740181,
0.0604779981,
0.0145786637,
-0.0152602429,
-0.0029964587,
0.0264987145,
0.0206101481,
-0.0632524192,
0.0668385774,
0.03348957,
0.023082437,
-0.0003111343,
0.0968377963,
-0.0920154601,
-0.0414935462,
0.0379249528,
0.0219390597,
0.0266314726,
0.0224296078,
-0.0049240212,
0.0165044069,
-0.0486583896,
-0.0262656882,
0.0334508978,
0.01295383,
0.0141485408,
0.0173983574,
-0.0614164658,
0.0002511764,
0.0148628308,
0.0207239501,
0.0213783253,
-0.0463773869,
0.0485674888,
0.0027511055,
-0.0200224444,
0.0215336494,
-0.0716207698,
-0.0382053517,
0.0153887691,
0.0010490849,
0.0188211109,
0.0697191134,
0.0437680595,
0.0085820174,
0.0076706866,
-0.0594657324,
0.0467923842,
-0.0570900738,
0.0009474934,
0.0737947822,
0.0606912784,
-0.0287024248,
-0.0080478964,
-0.0268127155,
0.069158107,
0.0210774355,
0.0322381891,
0.0032896213,
-0.0982307494,
-0.0337137431,
-0.0404271893,
-0.0429688767,
-0.0231330153,
-0.0581176728,
0.0314811282,
0.0155113805,
-0.0189663786,
0.0042233793,
-0.0123910569,
-0.0447939187,
-0.030073734,
0.0376074724,
-0.0205254722,
-0.0529480428,
0.0185898785,
-0.0178570133,
-0.0331234969,
0.0127940737,
0.0172451455,
0.0490725748,
0.0089472057,
0.0056415512,
0.0172034483,
-0.0051392098,
-0.0588806458,
-0.0187548641,
-0.0087177707,
-0.0735053271,
0.0099711604,
-0.0017244604,
0.0453986302,
0.0659929439,
-0.0190877561,
-0.0280995965,
0.0746032596,
0.0220548715,
-0.0103818085,
0.0392139032,
-0.0058160266,
0.059148144,
-0.0130415419,
-0.0378394984,
0.007534185,
-0.0157637019,
0.0295913313,
-0.0754581317,
-0.0146656446,
-0.0621959046,
2.597e-7,
0.0059001101,
0.0774496496,
-0.0059159985,
0.0500547551,
0.0108584771,
0.0145701412,
0.0470210612,
0.0393201299,
-0.0089547336,
-0.006939508,
-0.0025807845,
0.029516831,
-0.0126491608,
0.0348219872,
-0.0350351892,
-0.0071277199,
-0.0725079626,
0.0328050442,
-0.0000297988,
-0.0309958737,
0.0290005635,
0.0779784396,
0.0366702452,
-0.0027527823,
-0.044576101,
-0.0525568686,
0.0153362919,
-0.014102662,
0.0183970369,
-0.0397120602,
-0.0346419662,
0.0199155416,
0.0183375403,
0.0138803236,
-0.0063880393,
0.0272423699,
0.0215488467,
-0.0277991313,
-0.0290588289,
0.0290274918,
-0.0307205822,
0.0284024533,
-0.0089180022,
-0.0430882648,
0.0471889861,
-0.0241847299,
-0.0393675603,
-0.0152050965,
-0.0324545428,
0.0279011652,
0.1019679978,
0.0024827395,
-0.0308668856,
-0.0272486787,
0.0395595692,
0.0447967313,
-0.011480785,
-0.0913264379,
-0.0065002879,
0.0332779549,
-0.0252845958,
-0.0523749627,
0.0229305103,
0.0003778872,
0.0406665616,
-0.0223965216,
0.022746237,
1.939541113e-34,
0.0201933365,
0.0022776765,
0.0532776527,
-0.0385888405,
0.032917086,
-0.0347130485,
0.0104810251,
-0.0196934026,
0.0746898502,
-0.0415854529,
0.0070873182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14571v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14571v2 | From Characters to Words: Hierarchical Pre-trained Language Model for Open-vocabulary Language Understanding | 2023-05-23T23:22:20 | 2023-05-30T03:36:13 | Li Sun, Florian Luisier, Kayhan Batmanghelich, Dinei Florencio, Cha Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current state-of-the-art models for natural language understanding require a
preprocessing step to convert raw text into discrete tokens. This process known
as tokenization relies on a pre-built vocabulary of words or sub-word
morphemes. This fixed vocabulary limits the model's robustness to spelling
errors and its capacity to adapt to new domains. In this work, we introduce a
novel open-vocabulary language model that adopts a hierarchical two-level
approach: one at the word level and another at the sequence level. Concretely,
we design an intra-word module that uses a shallow Transformer architecture to
learn word representations from their characters, and a deep inter-word
Transformer module that contextualizes each word representation by attending to
the entire word sequence. Our model thus directly operates on character
sequences with explicit awareness of word boundaries, but without biased
sub-word or word-level vocabulary. Experiments on various downstream tasks show
that our method outperforms strong baselines. We also demonstrate that our
hierarchical model is robust to textual corruption and domain shift. | [
0.0171681605,
0.0871411785,
0.0144331399,
0.0346124321,
-0.0090292301,
0.0172501802,
0.0115287751,
-0.0008361301,
-0.0235515758,
-0.0597380437,
-0.025785055,
-0.0839625224,
0.0061551793,
0.0807309747,
0.004482368,
-0.0384222716,
0.0778953508,
-0.0348412097,
-0.0295706969,
0.0241985768,
-0.0003382475,
0.0278168544,
0.0070600258,
0.046906244,
-0.0095744319,
-0.0370500572,
-0.0157610718,
-0.0033842977,
-0.014728901,
-0.0171694905,
0.0183056425,
0.044633951,
0.0665242597,
0.0599825419,
0.0000019337,
-0.0297627002,
-0.0653549805,
-0.0186174009,
-0.0289125796,
-0.0020981042,
0.049300544,
-0.0333798677,
0.0002679302,
0.0071542975,
-0.0085215522,
-0.0365335457,
0.0334267356,
0.0623651296,
0.060461048,
0.0340058915,
-0.0083016502,
-0.0541017018,
0.0129857389,
-0.0227816347,
-0.020060448,
-0.0304124448,
0.0151397558,
-0.0548361689,
-0.0299052373,
-0.0056096097,
-0.0374730453,
0.0053984122,
0.0067497389,
-0.0085602561,
0.0120033845,
0.0189137124,
0.014678359,
-0.0537204333,
-0.0120318644,
0.1092150137,
-0.0659216344,
-0.0149873551,
-0.022557959,
-0.013518109,
0.0095171845,
-0.0022043227,
-0.0143744526,
0.0466877855,
0.0122736935,
0.0190043338,
0.020997934,
0.0409463346,
0.0302286595,
0.0317215919,
-0.0953322873,
0.0444564223,
0.0276602432,
-0.0084166247,
-0.0251315162,
-0.0079158759,
-0.0094575081,
-0.0580853634,
0.0323233642,
0.0575591438,
-0.0439199135,
0.0550942048,
-0.0290817879,
-0.0424859822,
-0.0087834373,
-0.0248271357,
0.0036382466,
0.0353491679,
-0.0561830178,
0.0185049269,
-0.0160902813,
0.0270398632,
-0.0066838739,
0.0302660465,
-0.0219356101,
-0.0279112197,
-0.0038613181,
-0.0202951245,
-0.0557265803,
0.0293046329,
-0.0713094696,
-0.0148492325,
0.0080414778,
0.0160857104,
0.0284036938,
-0.038525667,
0.0164146442,
0.0167327169,
-0.0464057662,
-0.0318925343,
-0.0137370257,
0.0519781373,
-0.0092851901,
0.0178848058,
0.0164488032,
-0.0320723355,
-0.0435297489,
0.0238311384,
0.0331647173,
-0.0082770549,
-0.0123181371,
0.0838766992,
-0.0006192767,
-0.0837492198,
-0.0288500283,
-0.0157436486,
0.0024812054,
-0.0178369395,
-0.012573245,
-0.0395095721,
0.0084536541,
-0.021938175,
0.0014554835,
-0.0415608585,
0.0137073901,
0.0280245077,
-0.0574843064,
0.0789148137,
-0.0519206114,
-0.0470704883,
-0.0020491176,
0.0223994609,
0.0689059272,
0.0266550761,
0.0278355666,
0.0117068691,
0.02312175,
-0.0098731425,
-0.0116349431,
0.0451880544,
-0.0119516291,
-0.0640046299,
-0.0160429291,
0.0119710071,
0.0149100991,
0.0664790496,
0.0376781411,
0.0623962432,
-0.0225864835,
-0.0052563543,
0.031566713,
0.0734969303,
0.0299854986,
0.0144668687,
0.061956998,
0.0195774827,
-0.0311500654,
0.0067938431,
-0.0278847124,
0.0196852982,
0.0267050769,
-0.0004865481,
-0.0059519173,
0.0312840715,
-0.0350775942,
-0.0224106032,
-0.0193358604,
-0.0234552175,
-0.0038848736,
-0.0413154848,
0.0661097988,
0.0512920469,
-0.0915309116,
0.0779214352,
0.0538779423,
-0.0513736382,
0.0406723358,
-0.0304348767,
0.0538022928,
0.0585773997,
0.0406548493,
-0.0316596031,
-0.0082776053,
-0.0459196344,
0.000944538,
0.0628546029,
-0.0000553204,
-0.0214613788,
0.0031292841,
-0.054598961,
0.0086399009,
-0.0079128658,
0.0040977024,
0.0419547781,
-0.0324392579,
-0.0331304483,
0.0136602577,
-0.035355188,
-0.0116990171,
0.0720171705,
-0.0295044761,
-0.0151094841,
-0.0089262575,
0.0021101278,
0.0199396964,
0.0057191993,
-0.0248531662,
0.0061484249,
0.0172682535,
-0.0226462819,
-0.0142296664,
-0.0155534782,
-0.0858169198,
-0.0266173892,
0.0169896744,
-0.0177418422,
-0.0134263728,
0.024619367,
-0.0372179002,
-0.0320129059,
0.0264051408,
-0.0182555504,
0.0567496382,
-0.0761325061,
0.0238186009,
0.0270087142,
0.0451774932,
-0.0406421684,
0.0604153536,
-0.018848246,
-0.0008891968,
-0.0105327871,
0.0039963545,
0.0308538768,
0.0076747607,
-0.0128528597,
0.024467675,
-0.0407067351,
0.0032965781,
-0.004877138,
0.0044894703,
-0.0341827758,
-0.0156469718,
-0.0697667524,
-0.0040644538,
-0.036784865,
0.0060909479,
0.0182548538,
0.0456756316,
0.0025876812,
-0.0249500852,
-0.0063431459,
0.0272935871,
0.0224138629,
-0.0182914697,
0.0621609837,
-0.0128223542,
0.0013286117,
-0.0359311551,
0.0014678604,
-0.0268443562,
0.0793238282,
-0.0113012595,
-0.0079352194,
-0.0307537653,
0.0006683051,
-0.007216895,
0.0350801125,
0.009809115,
-0.0405754186,
0.0123985456,
-0.0245222263,
0.0587551259,
0.0435451567,
0.0506528132,
0.0621283539,
0.0277397614,
-0.0425789282,
-0.0211527832,
-0.0091434149,
0.0017062698,
-0.004890834,
-0.0026902307,
0.024563605,
0.0021544704,
0.1244334131,
-0.0315690637,
-0.0020577929,
-0.0486928187,
-0.0117449164,
-0.0258722715,
-0.025006691,
-0.0396985002,
-0.0077288705,
-0.047554329,
0.01354024,
-0.0643253922,
-0.0045187385,
0.0453661829,
-0.0589015521,
0.0038910178,
-0.0463455804,
0.0072313985,
-0.0418054797,
0.0294931978,
-0.0024749921,
0.0198118892,
0.014503126,
-0.0617939979,
-0.0568681285,
0.0367547274,
-0.0627613887,
-0.0368565246,
0.0521928258,
-0.0497290567,
-0.0080941021,
-0.00231166,
0.0294508766,
-0.0606367886,
-0.0481510721,
-0.0209073666,
0.0294979811,
0.0385215208,
-0.0300293583,
-0.03194407,
0.0085569052,
-0.0196002815,
0.0790554211,
0.0304120593,
0.0182641726,
-0.0388585068,
0.0385499783,
0.0271328148,
0.0229345188,
0.028464945,
-0.0382426009,
0.0457367785,
0.0385957249,
-0.0124982018,
-0.0508482866,
-0.0197854768,
0.0071263527,
0.0300516579,
-0.0549377985,
-0.0036456403,
0.0007182237,
0.0275606327,
-0.0446538702,
-0.0545921735,
0.1454761326,
0.0429723188,
-0.0349660031,
0.0074508484,
-0.0089059332,
0.0109662069,
0.0016780575,
-0.0073331646,
-0.0826060325,
-0.0538494177,
0.001599906,
-0.0251604803,
0.0526385792,
-0.0453836583,
0.0040499945,
-0.08912386,
0.0096230796,
-0.0340003259,
-0.0523116067,
-0.0013577652,
0.0092842011,
0.0118142078,
0.0046203774,
0.0475326553,
0.0215315241,
-0.0213886667,
-0.0276294537,
0.0154561242,
0.0028201081,
-0.0162310507,
0.027938921,
-0.0576027706,
0.0171003211,
0.0276349839,
0.0315085128,
0.0015246434,
-0.0082048047,
0.0201819986,
-0.0555002131,
0.0193785243,
0.0084861889,
0.0196166076,
-0.0302913152,
-0.0222535599,
-0.0168773886,
0.0081022754,
-0.0764434859,
-0.0317006335,
-0.0597417988,
0.0497557893,
-0.0018536173,
-0.0015505444,
0.000836091,
0.0024010425,
0.0032374063,
0.051865682,
0.0071429149,
-0.056522619,
-0.0293331705,
-0.0141200759,
-0.0011255905,
-0.0321725197,
-0.017603578,
0.0146278348,
0.0057937498,
-0.0101814186,
-0.0719471127,
-0.0380660631,
0.0356813446,
0.0225403439,
-0.00775166,
-0.0209033545,
-0.0307516642,
-0.0049854959,
-0.04287434,
0.0463020802,
-0.0091470787,
0.0214741472,
-0.0796227828,
0.0090367338,
0.0184950456,
-0.0331764705,
-0.0517427735,
0.0400017165,
-0.0360698886,
-0.0194734354,
0.0516553111,
0.0394038111,
0.0146484515,
0.0204606913,
-0.0375778116,
-0.0238775332,
0.0608822294,
-0.005994963,
-0.0475031696,
0.002792418,
0.0243048333,
0.0002237852,
-0.0239149369,
0.033650279,
-0.022406131,
0.0137521848,
0.0086239679,
0.0150436312,
0.0125664165,
-0.0604062416,
0.0385363922,
-0.0318722688,
0.0673136711,
-0.0197166279,
0.0110498052,
-0.0537548997,
0.0062860316,
-0.013632115,
-0.0075586597,
-0.0238762684,
-0.0036855754,
0.0541732386,
-0.0142407781,
-0.0135432547,
0.0060945135,
-0.0283289328,
0.0363578461,
0.0179984607,
0.0115791215,
0.0306211896,
0.0379277691,
0.0028504219,
0.0120745655,
-0.0005374117,
0.0101155024,
-0.0547702052,
0.0290836375,
-0.031626936,
0.0444816984,
-0.0148522379,
0.0311085526,
-0.0103640612,
0.0395642146,
-0.0418646112,
0.0186161809,
-0.0275292452,
0.0229347404,
0.027482206,
-0.0277584512,
-0.0171928219,
0.01233277,
0.0055337274,
-0.0031368078,
0.0210845768,
-0.0315148011,
-0.0326439366,
0.0232864395,
0.0211187452,
-0.0022666196,
-0.0281878132,
0.067216523,
0.0365178734,
0.0330814272,
-0.0118936766,
0.0229559559,
-0.0388888679,
0.0198008101,
0.0338266194,
0.0601618849,
-0.0303954687,
0.0255321171,
-0.0474851429,
-0.0571191572,
0.0351925753,
0.0157845598,
0.0076646795,
0.0360597856,
0.0434605889,
0.0476144068,
-0.0034150053,
0.0203853957,
-0.0217984281,
0.0139533384,
0.039696794,
-0.0474966802,
0.0123729017,
-6.652889541e-33,
-0.0551672615,
0.0044247569,
-0.0247690845,
-0.0116803795,
-0.0449573286,
0.0013094806,
-0.0400436148,
0.0011697471,
-0.0012033875,
0.0103347348,
-0.00704695,
0.0404988192,
0.0036232728,
0.0214605294,
-0.0074328943,
-0.0257605631,
0.0648472309,
-0.0134967705,
0.0126552153,
-0.0118118394,
0.0601804554,
0.0818436891,
0.0858913213,
-0.0014851831,
0.0053434083,
-0.0285661295,
0.0162746739,
0.0258179698,
0.0233792532,
0.0297322087,
-0.037266776,
0.0279675126,
0.0191785004,
0.0008062798,
-0.0133964363,
0.0635347068,
-0.1178279519,
0.0019795932,
0.0192792341,
0.0136251664,
-0.0322803445,
-0.0517966673,
0.0263758823,
-0.0224666372,
0.0558868349,
-0.0206689164,
0.0257210694,
0.016447559,
0.0167869069,
0.0060605905,
-0.0980501696,
0.0207126196,
0.000422392,
-0.0249980893,
-0.0078550251,
0.0206808913,
0.0153424162,
0.0138800526,
-0.0282764882,
-0.0127128446,
-0.0034543474,
0.0338064134,
0.0334265418,
0.0337839089,
-0.0627649352,
0.0579946712,
-0.0223915763,
-0.0494678281,
-0.0420795046,
0.0134396432,
0.0408611558,
0.0277284067,
0.0361965336,
0.0330387987,
0.032121174,
-0.0043657525,
-0.0740324855,
0.0229179561,
-0.0339880101,
0.0541135073,
-0.0219424348,
0.0191854499,
0.0365427546,
0.0169233382,
-0.0299516581,
-0.0298441406,
-0.0327902474,
-0.0092074769,
0.0305053126,
0.007389301,
-0.0324377902,
0.0058948174,
0.0749685541,
-0.0262667313,
0.0245022122,
0.008749675,
0.0406716168,
-0.0159096885,
-0.0151059395,
0.0700246319,
-0.043590337,
-0.0600083061,
0.0487255901,
0.0028586141,
-0.0184634682,
0.0084335627,
0.0189730152,
-0.0002644869,
-0.042932231,
0.0044469642,
-0.0303527769,
0.0142068882,
-0.0364361182,
0.084778443,
0.0480979346,
0.0130076045,
-0.0203810129,
0.0620157123,
0.0037281411,
-0.0210954677,
-0.0169856958,
0.0125165461,
-0.0083549311,
0.0344064906,
-0.0397403836,
-0.0095684063,
0.0059434026,
-0.004898651,
0.0344650894,
-0.0737546608,
0.0080512417,
0.0403559543,
2.648e-7,
0.075700067,
0.0273332112,
0.0524731986,
-0.0198875703,
0.0092104506,
0.0053063584,
0.0128473137,
0.0439071767,
-0.0446510129,
-0.0160834417,
0.0079342416,
0.0095999893,
0.0117918095,
-0.0043363967,
-0.1008449644,
-0.0121104373,
-0.0416538604,
0.0106168939,
-0.0415905677,
-0.014897842,
0.0780843422,
0.1244120225,
-0.0348730907,
-0.0190143697,
-0.015756106,
-0.0217923336,
0.051597096,
0.0082541192,
0.0021477221,
0.0061583635,
0.024919169,
0.031745322,
-0.0114499126,
0.0201757699,
-0.015509516,
0.0326548889,
0.0616074204,
0.0177792441,
-0.04078665,
0.0001943424,
0.0171204321,
-0.0274889115,
-0.0096654147,
-0.0548032187,
0.0520416535,
-0.0737664923,
-0.0073920786,
-0.0273478534,
-0.047274854,
0.0052024457,
-0.0152143436,
-0.015661126,
-0.0024724607,
0.0487292223,
0.034527041,
-0.0129495673,
-0.0156401135,
-0.106077075,
-0.0023800139,
-0.0291452333,
-0.0239083935,
0.0154111087,
-0.0385413021,
-0.0311514307,
0.0587668717,
-0.0148395803,
-0.0058808229,
2.256919077e-34,
0.0330610014,
0.0009066573,
-0.0195209626,
0.0312202107,
0.0322946645,
-0.0237802751,
0.0268999096,
0.0001985034,
0.0104471166,
-0.1049152464,
0.0077627818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14569v1 | Few-shot Unified Question Answering: Tuning Models or Prompts? | 2023-05-23T23:14:38 | 2023-05-23T23:14:38 | Srijan Bansal, Semih Yavuz, Bo Pang, Meghana Bhat, Yingbo Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question-answering (QA) tasks often investigate specific question types,
knowledge domains, or reasoning skills, leading to specialized models catering
to specific categories of QA tasks. While recent research has explored the idea
of unified QA models, such models are usually explored for high-resource
scenarios and require re-training to extend their capabilities. To overcome
these drawbacks, the paper explores the potential of two paradigms of tuning,
model, and prompts, for unified QA under a low-resource setting. The paper
provides an exhaustive analysis of their applicability using 16 QA datasets,
revealing that prompt tuning can perform as well as model tuning in a few-shot
setting with a good initialization. The study also shows that parameter-sharing
results in superior few-shot performance, simple knowledge transfer techniques
for prompt initialization can be effective, and prompt tuning achieves a
significant performance boost from pre-training in a low-resource regime. The
research offers insights into the advantages and limitations of prompt tuning
for unified QA in a few-shot setting, contributing to the development of
effective and efficient systems in low-resource scenarios. | [
0.0466751866,
-0.0093426025,
-0.0043987907,
-0.0037614787,
0.0089330394,
0.0298405848,
0.0564928614,
-0.0348778591,
-0.0460967682,
-0.0472279228,
-0.0451420508,
-0.0052163485,
-0.0425360724,
-0.0299368091,
0.00397164,
-0.0620857254,
0.0915617645,
-0.0165943224,
0.0194912497,
-0.01825561,
-0.0029998103,
-0.0062125148,
-0.0271285325,
0.0173204076,
0.0215253122,
-0.062334571,
-0.0141599169,
0.0089145331,
0.0152005423,
0.0007673543,
0.0144282021,
0.0626616478,
0.0179674421,
-0.0121076405,
0.0000020132,
-0.0633988008,
-0.0023710441,
-0.0123428376,
-0.0812148601,
0.0001862072,
-0.0194037966,
0.0182789955,
0.04789019,
0.0367288813,
-0.0385417268,
0.0058064428,
0.0180536751,
-0.0331746154,
0.0158552155,
0.0447066389,
0.0202698875,
-0.0172709655,
-0.0324374475,
-0.0084356032,
0.0083405776,
-0.0836120769,
0.0162898824,
0.0036560306,
0.0176304057,
0.0222290028,
-0.0399339721,
0.010204698,
0.0163673833,
0.0363403931,
0.0119250668,
0.0173001997,
-0.0590466671,
-0.0033769473,
-0.041059833,
0.0601938479,
0.0005766196,
-0.0098005524,
-0.0123494901,
-0.0144093437,
0.0314630792,
0.0236671381,
-0.0636653081,
0.0004811009,
-0.0031553663,
-0.048549436,
-0.022921307,
-0.0013564778,
-0.0264130626,
0.0129985316,
0.0038796645,
0.0215760563,
0.0002714025,
-0.0538317934,
-0.004235527,
-0.0212522112,
-0.0294719953,
-0.0791433603,
-0.0365315787,
0.1093319282,
-0.0322349779,
0.0147922924,
-0.0358377099,
-0.0218807198,
0.0423507206,
0.030937355,
0.0312464982,
0.0463358574,
0.0075978558,
0.0618209466,
-0.0094569093,
0.0625297502,
0.0205882117,
0.0151500413,
-0.0569995195,
-0.0158830564,
-0.0771499053,
-0.0336806737,
-0.0590850599,
0.0364554934,
-0.0092617488,
-0.0062159933,
-0.0194218084,
0.0522959232,
0.0425186828,
-0.0295143891,
-0.0050397534,
0.0329304934,
-0.0272107925,
0.0098205311,
-0.0391043089,
0.068207182,
-0.095646508,
0.0283409432,
0.0165099241,
-0.0658103898,
-0.0370514132,
0.0022598275,
0.0353920162,
-0.0156655777,
0.0225691441,
0.0249871239,
-0.02782101,
-0.0462205149,
-0.0049638455,
-0.0551182032,
-0.0004271194,
-0.041285824,
-0.0165228322,
-0.0354767255,
0.0609059185,
0.0339590795,
-0.0091280341,
0.0242028311,
-0.0284242257,
0.0368664414,
-0.0169492047,
0.0565037318,
-0.0132616907,
0.0443541184,
0.0255863219,
0.0115374392,
-0.0174442772,
0.0690223202,
-0.0038829602,
-0.0020046874,
0.0488857478,
-0.0129789338,
0.0052196537,
-0.0200204365,
0.0254884139,
0.0002797163,
0.0065293084,
0.0728628635,
0.0351311527,
-0.0061019463,
0.0426684916,
-0.0049083363,
-0.0327397622,
-0.0228776652,
0.0209724698,
0.0579924509,
0.0216648821,
-0.0078013288,
0.0518212952,
0.0074778707,
0.0264062751,
0.0041310103,
-0.0403784774,
0.0453631133,
-0.0289277509,
0.0085919285,
0.0151524972,
0.0251129866,
-0.0849849731,
0.0030684897,
0.0021346104,
0.0090263775,
-0.0507009849,
0.0439470932,
0.0059831962,
0.0244527161,
-0.0157822873,
0.0551447198,
0.0031344343,
0.0146908723,
-0.0161946118,
-0.0496151671,
0.0596915931,
0.0368621051,
0.0238118786,
-0.0255997684,
-0.0599179901,
-0.0089729587,
0.0831407979,
-0.0036000749,
0.0407632329,
-0.0307735037,
0.0251637772,
-0.0221138392,
-0.022069497,
-0.0524054021,
-0.0073572337,
0.0365000255,
0.0129375514,
0.0294181481,
-0.0189840887,
-0.0225849394,
0.0334433988,
0.0059631281,
-0.0017013629,
-0.0527446866,
-0.0035401962,
0.0181245655,
-0.000262322,
0.0186132807,
-0.0116791679,
0.0143034607,
0.0036152184,
0.0072426144,
-0.0005701319,
-0.0028506948,
-0.0199595653,
-0.0198450349,
0.0096626543,
0.0159983523,
-0.002602679,
0.0335047469,
-0.043942567,
-0.0550751053,
-0.0014592072,
-0.0030074511,
-0.0208627786,
-0.0288131312,
-0.0284017529,
-0.0127040185,
-0.0091595659,
-0.041454453,
0.0708194524,
0.0207565241,
0.0235461555,
0.0216880199,
0.021503957,
0.0147417551,
-0.0749091953,
0.0233539753,
-0.0456819274,
-0.0138807315,
-0.0027556221,
0.0045353784,
0.0018924598,
-0.0350960121,
0.0010850152,
-0.0771245286,
0.0407812819,
-0.0205297787,
0.034149766,
0.0498242117,
0.0067808228,
-0.0226520412,
-0.0329387635,
-0.0466052145,
0.0330794901,
0.0297388248,
0.0592934862,
0.0161472056,
0.0389360413,
0.0174798742,
-0.0177137386,
-0.0032952274,
-0.0111600114,
0.0019072335,
0.0144487424,
0.0071518002,
-0.0409242474,
0.0053690858,
-0.038537167,
0.0104675246,
0.0227549654,
-0.0354835279,
0.0141776297,
0.0345476307,
-0.0025339357,
0.0818293914,
-0.012152113,
-0.0226536356,
0.0265851598,
0.013732099,
-0.0364252701,
0.0568247139,
-0.018087294,
-0.0530524515,
0.006463056,
0.0001562758,
0.0203212034,
0.0682083443,
0.0123902997,
0.0026579807,
-0.0402046703,
0.0706511885,
0.0034823578,
-0.036886625,
-0.0676940233,
0.0066796103,
0.0114127202,
0.0466639064,
-0.0131148668,
-0.0061432309,
0.062970005,
0.0289064143,
0.0015489799,
-0.0520802215,
-0.0010787846,
-0.0492280945,
0.011117748,
-0.0213989634,
0.0088823959,
-0.000120699,
-0.0051359199,
-0.0615395717,
-0.0385587774,
0.0182112195,
0.0038251225,
-0.0097445929,
-0.0094028423,
0.0053866939,
-0.0418676324,
-0.0606677495,
-0.0320947915,
-0.0583317317,
-0.0270273425,
0.0359315984,
-0.0419553928,
0.0054410263,
-0.0077215014,
0.0143929115,
0.0301112123,
-0.0073035271,
-0.0328748077,
-0.0216560345,
-0.0349210352,
0.0589967556,
0.079517439,
0.0381165445,
0.0045486321,
-0.0042698383,
0.077260308,
0.0352235474,
0.0336356275,
0.0091626225,
0.011140734,
-0.027627226,
-0.0023386762,
-0.0550368205,
-0.0208695512,
0.0368687846,
0.0735455751,
-0.0388316736,
-0.0229452197,
0.1081751436,
0.046410501,
-0.0030990101,
-0.0174331106,
-0.028813269,
0.0053216303,
0.0532229319,
0.0641556978,
-0.0967085958,
-0.0557654686,
-0.0271873027,
0.0654128864,
-0.0202540066,
-0.0319178142,
-0.0014208549,
-0.1065998524,
0.0234948266,
-0.0376576446,
-0.0737483725,
-0.0034054364,
-0.0403654426,
0.0032771365,
-0.0046269726,
0.0336173438,
0.0187799204,
-0.0339118615,
0.0236440431,
0.0447623953,
0.0222370829,
-0.0182635263,
0.0716836676,
-0.0256011374,
0.0265357327,
0.051024314,
-0.0118922982,
-0.0052967942,
-0.0256681349,
-0.0171915572,
-0.0425257608,
0.055209998,
-0.0008018306,
0.0213987548,
-0.034919817,
-0.003432727,
-0.0176004451,
0.029779695,
0.0004704952,
-0.0076882415,
0.0239097141,
0.0655307993,
-0.0168956257,
-0.0026525464,
-0.0329079442,
-0.0027636692,
0.0095830299,
0.0838716254,
0.0485694855,
-0.0495603867,
-0.0460846201,
0.036824327,
-0.0427386686,
-0.0754839629,
-0.0119205639,
0.0281486139,
0.016214598,
0.004472909,
-0.0523361564,
-0.0639412105,
0.0643312037,
0.0310522672,
-0.0278744251,
0.0287837815,
-0.0376442447,
0.0458449945,
-0.0263980739,
0.0184459779,
-0.0675871521,
-0.0233203433,
-0.0502613075,
-0.0120426556,
0.0409190953,
-0.0185803324,
-0.0222959314,
-0.0304837674,
-0.0645291731,
-0.0119448872,
0.0010414352,
0.0729880035,
0.022233041,
0.0012997346,
-0.0166993961,
-0.0730442107,
0.0324167423,
0.0331479497,
-0.0255260859,
0.0413658954,
-0.0103986906,
0.0136157591,
-0.0236404855,
0.0302492566,
-0.0799712837,
0.0340431146,
0.0117141688,
0.0105792684,
-0.0650316551,
-0.0337860882,
0.0347410031,
-0.0031941556,
-0.0018042095,
0.0526819453,
-0.0224192105,
0.0142741436,
0.037529584,
0.0051643276,
0.0060632639,
-0.0049871942,
-0.0257355459,
-0.0021353515,
-0.0412909575,
0.0124335438,
-0.0144820195,
-0.026003994,
0.0409524217,
-0.0615761206,
-0.0057390733,
0.0395698398,
0.0078112995,
-0.0219151471,
0.0071882238,
-0.0356558114,
0.0131662749,
0.0169813689,
0.0484892391,
0.0114376275,
0.0602693185,
0.0241327472,
0.0099251103,
-0.0356361233,
0.0270113982,
-0.0873844996,
-0.0992499962,
0.0136704035,
0.00434798,
0.0078650266,
0.0187552813,
-0.042928569,
0.0265509114,
-0.0204148255,
-0.0026055702,
-0.0211078208,
0.0281941835,
-0.0066309264,
0.0951538235,
0.0438375473,
-0.0036689956,
0.0040135286,
0.0846625045,
-0.0234288834,
0.0723399818,
0.0073020305,
-0.0121974535,
-0.0253286753,
0.0093375174,
-0.0034060138,
0.011689269,
0.0075987037,
0.0305746254,
-0.065723829,
-0.0011715913,
-0.0009022904,
-0.002982782,
-0.0136685902,
0.001676723,
0.04796483,
0.0410267822,
0.0019025148,
-0.066278331,
-0.0237939656,
0.0200799573,
-0.0536931753,
-0.0118739689,
0.0103545431,
-6.455538734e-33,
-0.0348571613,
-0.0005358839,
0.0429151915,
-0.0315138921,
0.0370375291,
-0.0131192869,
0.0038132498,
-0.0028178636,
-0.0763398781,
-0.0194022954,
-0.0383488759,
-0.0022690289,
0.0140788853,
-0.0147283198,
0.0264551509,
-0.0512853898,
0.0099273045,
-0.0263219122,
-0.0370750464,
0.013021959,
0.0479450822,
0.0270526055,
0.0253846757,
0.033374235,
-0.034269359,
-0.0164383147,
0.0094834482,
0.0372043215,
-0.0088219,
0.0507255606,
0.0001443005,
0.0137022762,
0.055355005,
-0.045160342,
0.0084529081,
0.0641795844,
-0.0719360784,
-0.0810033381,
0.024409879,
-0.0092393206,
-0.0501104183,
-0.0468059406,
-0.0129586468,
-0.0103729209,
0.0320469402,
-0.0339961015,
0.0127593344,
-0.0027165043,
-0.0142252529,
-0.0434343815,
-0.0433599949,
-0.0097770235,
-0.0046037734,
-0.0588683039,
-0.0457445756,
0.0989634767,
-0.0267755464,
0.0131818661,
-0.0249161664,
-0.0318386182,
0.0490996577,
0.0289110951,
0.0350453816,
0.0303116366,
-0.0273487046,
0.0091236616,
0.0336039551,
-0.0029338517,
0.0113095772,
-0.0080602523,
-0.0284245517,
0.0141708134,
0.0395622998,
0.0460417122,
0.0379628316,
0.0023630543,
-0.0909631252,
0.0216777418,
0.0162677895,
0.0603390895,
0.0153892785,
0.0076095718,
-0.0232126266,
0.0000032004,
-0.0586074516,
0.0226789862,
-0.0570221506,
-0.0229678061,
0.0684076995,
0.0189710259,
-0.0465123579,
-0.0102949189,
0.0565534458,
-0.0285831708,
0.0437562391,
0.0226445328,
0.007316024,
0.0370467044,
-0.0020396521,
0.0012519964,
-0.082587868,
0.0072513274,
0.0426244512,
0.0123302741,
0.0227243081,
0.0269980319,
0.0275570843,
0.0098956488,
-0.0402729213,
-0.0134397689,
-0.0140482709,
0.0425164588,
-0.0044096014,
-0.0069379262,
0.0209264699,
0.0587575734,
-0.0149308722,
0.0245541297,
0.010911582,
-0.0694552511,
-0.0035856564,
-0.0033275608,
-0.0094942413,
0.0034901046,
-0.0154099865,
0.0180243831,
-0.0220727455,
0.0324826352,
-0.0431311391,
-0.0282866117,
-0.0053648534,
0.05167,
2.683e-7,
0.0481620654,
0.0057667419,
0.0039978656,
0.0377439633,
0.0400126837,
0.0068832152,
0.0210102405,
0.0370107032,
0.0436144508,
-0.0182272419,
0.0171070509,
0.0339069925,
0.0034102376,
0.0098793264,
-0.0750814006,
-0.0120817618,
-0.0430782549,
0.0258180108,
-0.0458807237,
-0.0406970307,
0.0309085306,
0.0589738004,
-0.0166799501,
0.0014304174,
-0.0103885988,
-0.0417456888,
0.0454436056,
0.017337596,
-0.0041666673,
0.0145321041,
0.0316711776,
0.0294337366,
-0.001190637,
0.0697486475,
0.0104244854,
0.0201034918,
-0.0242951307,
0.0507229902,
-0.0190049,
-0.061729759,
-0.0217622574,
-0.0204208717,
0.0123557923,
-0.0651243478,
0.114230074,
-0.0798795968,
-0.0267880205,
-0.0153995566,
0.0017434894,
0.0117814075,
0.0081525203,
-0.0103514381,
-0.0118496977,
-0.0033892093,
0.0233503636,
0.0178716183,
-0.0117599266,
-0.0781468675,
0.0401896611,
0.033001978,
-0.003342716,
-0.047111351,
-0.0311303418,
-0.0365880504,
0.0173710044,
-0.0777402744,
-0.0172966179,
1.980673772e-34,
0.0090087261,
-0.0092823496,
0.0488464683,
0.0317663476,
-0.0231995229,
0.0058974978,
-0.0199804753,
-0.0279323142,
0.0655940697,
-0.094477877,
-0.0091607412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14564v1 | PEARL: Prompting Large Language Models to Plan and Execute Actions Over Long Documents | 2023-05-23T23:06:04 | 2023-05-23T23:06:04 | Simeng Sun, Yang Liu, Shuohang Wang, Chenguang Zhu, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Strategies such as chain-of-thought prompting improve the performance of
large language models (LLMs) on complex reasoning tasks by decomposing input
examples into intermediate steps. However, it remains unclear how to apply such
methods to reason over long input documents, in which both the decomposition
and the output of each intermediate step are non-trivial to obtain. In this
work, we propose PEARL, a prompting framework to improve reasoning over long
documents, which consists of three stages: action mining, plan formulation, and
plan execution. More specifically, given a question about a long document,
PEARL decomposes the question into a sequence of actions (e.g., SUMMARIZE,
FIND_EVENT, FIND_RELATION) and then executes them over the document to obtain
the answer. Each stage of PEARL is implemented via zero-shot or few-shot
prompting of LLMs (in our work, GPT-4) with minimal human input. We evaluate
PEARL on a challenging subset of the QuALITY dataset, which contains questions
that require complex reasoning over long narrative texts. PEARL outperforms
zero-shot and chain-of-thought prompting on this dataset, and ablation
experiments show that each stage of PEARL is critical to its performance.
Overall, PEARL is a first step towards leveraging LLMs to reason over long
documents. | [
0.0144331353,
0.0478552729,
-0.0049157273,
0.038999524,
-0.0431129113,
0.0353487097,
0.0032217102,
-0.0161712002,
0.0245963819,
-0.0294909757,
0.0165998563,
0.0003422418,
-0.0092658009,
0.039837189,
-0.0175652932,
-0.0679618716,
0.0304664522,
-0.0525925942,
0.0409668311,
0.0181460232,
0.013348531,
0.029669825,
-0.0072066491,
0.0393305533,
0.014519779,
-0.0320735723,
-0.0546593927,
-0.0238401853,
0.0114093507,
-0.029109776,
-0.0376829281,
0.0270038676,
0.044439245,
0.0137642799,
0.0000019009,
-0.0631967634,
0.010803123,
-0.015618545,
-0.0423253886,
-0.0050058821,
-0.01821802,
-0.0189296193,
0.0305939242,
0.0088665988,
-0.0284348875,
-0.0002880195,
-0.0333401337,
0.09460067,
0.0492491238,
0.0924078003,
-0.0033234179,
-0.0339429416,
0.0024794566,
-0.0136756757,
0.0401207544,
-0.0453548469,
-0.0128639732,
0.0087261032,
0.0677099824,
0.0373548567,
-0.0100098373,
0.0203246735,
0.0474142097,
-0.0515385494,
-0.0325162783,
0.0493803658,
-0.0238267593,
0.0083678998,
0.0076343361,
0.0739434883,
0.0014218851,
0.0101429513,
0.0212229025,
-0.0080476403,
0.0137415268,
-0.0094252257,
-0.070763357,
0.039948795,
-0.0166797992,
-0.0064078807,
0.041281648,
-0.0096994573,
0.0387050584,
-0.0026747971,
-0.0205182787,
0.0548520945,
-0.0137127433,
-0.0381091908,
0.0001960151,
-0.0074997544,
-0.0200641844,
-0.0856818929,
0.0078062927,
0.0932030454,
-0.0724917054,
0.0151374815,
-0.0309635252,
0.0185200479,
0.0153810792,
-0.0037826614,
0.0031470733,
0.0324954353,
0.016628148,
0.1058280542,
-0.0293785203,
0.0365094021,
-0.0003189555,
0.0075936005,
-0.0542087257,
0.0081312694,
-0.0576081239,
0.0208000168,
-0.030073069,
0.0244702771,
-0.0449061133,
-0.0501233451,
0.0132464664,
0.0439700671,
0.0272177681,
0.0437080003,
0.0192667339,
0.0027076427,
0.0291212164,
-0.0454472899,
-0.0570853911,
0.0194974449,
-0.0697575212,
0.0055600312,
0.0140649294,
0.0134582873,
-0.0281948484,
0.0013807887,
0.0238401815,
-0.0051927133,
-0.0044506029,
0.0206694361,
-0.0189950615,
-0.0329701155,
-0.0513006821,
-0.0450730175,
0.0167369172,
-0.0661873147,
-0.0264457874,
-0.0640768707,
0.0300778951,
0.0152588729,
-0.0287692491,
0.0236435421,
0.0073421928,
0.0329258367,
-0.0112800673,
0.0589273982,
0.0469407961,
0.0191006605,
0.0077341134,
0.0278661065,
-0.0338260867,
0.0571276434,
0.0406174846,
0.0361565948,
0.022187952,
0.0291758385,
0.010208807,
0.0339838006,
-0.0010668357,
0.0092308139,
0.0154194012,
0.0340310223,
-0.0045473063,
0.0491164401,
0.0127702486,
0.0461463258,
-0.0369522758,
-0.0076335431,
0.0200515743,
0.0695606694,
0.0015122783,
-0.0140524711,
0.0597441047,
0.0040622349,
-0.0074333036,
0.011652871,
-0.0538912192,
0.0349882618,
-0.029401429,
-0.0035123618,
0.0160186607,
-0.0050672921,
-0.0364969485,
-0.0449185111,
-0.004569835,
0.0121208197,
-0.0080288118,
0.0233560335,
0.0134889539,
0.0166571885,
-0.0498503633,
0.0164954569,
-0.0149785867,
-0.0405353457,
0.0151870651,
-0.0402945727,
0.0845585689,
0.0738823637,
0.0809195042,
-0.0451045521,
-0.0169827789,
-0.0325218663,
0.0466761142,
0.0010683755,
0.0306971073,
-0.0521090664,
0.003259283,
-0.0462720096,
-0.0339711495,
-0.0378190987,
-0.0024453588,
-0.0187209286,
0.016251063,
-0.0058733588,
0.012001045,
-0.0178203061,
-0.0000080397,
0.0311634857,
-0.0458871536,
-0.0490263961,
-0.0096432054,
0.0090970686,
-0.0134263933,
0.0141736427,
0.0157028828,
0.0237987936,
0.0256004017,
-0.0421403684,
-0.0354680605,
-0.0073708049,
-0.0298505053,
-0.0672940835,
0.0405068882,
-0.0136500085,
-0.0457087979,
-0.0298415702,
-0.0444888473,
-0.0598246157,
-0.0113431932,
-0.0140632521,
-0.0011976389,
-0.010962558,
0.0118426457,
0.0334180333,
-0.0378586203,
-0.0246970393,
0.0910967216,
-0.0023152651,
0.0130892992,
0.0289193019,
0.0009589096,
0.0074989842,
-0.0410791114,
-0.0007563315,
0.0269386191,
0.0257098526,
-0.0186295919,
0.0445394255,
0.0159866214,
-0.0610118508,
-0.0407537967,
-0.091558069,
0.0230393559,
-0.027444914,
0.0135412933,
0.0160184167,
0.0116738901,
-0.0121107241,
-0.0107789999,
-0.0665370822,
0.0004905488,
0.0263004452,
0.0034066204,
0.0363044851,
0.0230791792,
0.0092698764,
-0.0126123158,
-0.0085210269,
-0.0302204993,
0.0444327928,
0.0226135198,
0.0085198497,
-0.051940091,
0.0450552925,
-0.0096367896,
-0.0007149366,
-0.0260195434,
0.0211108644,
0.0473720953,
-0.0681815073,
0.0644435361,
0.0840746462,
-0.0062770024,
0.00332986,
0.0560676865,
-0.005978378,
-0.0610924363,
0.0425235443,
-0.0164163131,
0.0211484134,
-0.0262744017,
-0.0100430511,
0.0142053328,
0.0488922372,
-0.0315483436,
0.0133114224,
-0.0270751007,
-0.0012248789,
0.0227663815,
0.006315215,
-0.0245989934,
-0.0497257859,
0.0103279948,
0.0580356456,
-0.0246147607,
-0.0125320032,
0.0616100319,
-0.0096043749,
-0.0177690461,
-0.0455756262,
0.0112772984,
-0.0672885329,
0.1160175055,
-0.012043789,
-0.0139304269,
-0.0358502679,
-0.0143423676,
-0.0319179595,
-0.0287255365,
0.0055532451,
-0.0182173904,
0.0518863648,
-0.0456845611,
0.0032436072,
-0.0055860109,
-0.0330857038,
-0.0441771187,
-0.0361943617,
-0.0552200191,
-0.002426659,
-0.0285138916,
-0.0037322829,
-0.0343580693,
-0.0187067706,
0.0358049087,
0.06471394,
-0.0091331778,
-0.0287373718,
-0.0189797096,
0.0345721282,
0.0621343926,
-0.0056684939,
0.0249847714,
-0.0553596579,
0.0923493281,
0.0466976576,
0.0228418913,
0.0029012747,
-0.0189188197,
0.0053193765,
-0.0040393402,
-0.0257036053,
0.0015323579,
0.0190668888,
0.0238674842,
-0.0802416876,
-0.0019623013,
0.1442764997,
0.0474393182,
-0.0586894974,
-0.0137036154,
-0.0413968377,
0.0328663662,
0.0236429013,
0.0313456878,
-0.0539117679,
-0.0475640744,
0.0234721787,
-0.0223698448,
0.0095605496,
-0.0476409122,
0.0015285145,
-0.104327634,
0.0464424454,
-0.0149261914,
0.0181239024,
0.022915408,
-0.0550171211,
0.0032336158,
0.0176934339,
-0.0154805528,
0.0312276911,
-0.0138328979,
-0.0096970508,
-0.0288826991,
-0.0135652134,
0.0000592619,
0.0475158617,
-0.0323753841,
0.0080138538,
0.0307751689,
0.0459926166,
0.0298121423,
-0.0112074735,
0.0269946735,
0.0134022823,
-0.0054429672,
-0.0102338716,
0.051986482,
0.0012486598,
0.0196671393,
-0.0336513817,
0.0628877804,
-0.0337533578,
-0.0317261331,
0.040376354,
0.0813804492,
-0.0317894034,
-0.0327371322,
-0.0377812795,
0.0062060528,
-0.0282857902,
0.0864312127,
0.0203707069,
-0.0027926522,
-0.0526078977,
-0.00712955,
-0.0460357703,
-0.0578733012,
-0.0120876031,
-0.0109862499,
0.0205773097,
0.0449566469,
-0.0523107648,
-0.0651018694,
0.0717936009,
0.0329428837,
-0.0110128913,
0.0018356667,
0.0008006794,
-0.0001289377,
-0.0252965353,
0.0356766507,
-0.0253947489,
0.0262403432,
-0.0280094631,
0.0197290629,
0.0141098723,
-0.0047033727,
0.0143829528,
0.0328719057,
-0.0719673783,
-0.0314028673,
-0.0406320766,
0.0131932832,
0.0186604075,
0.053339038,
-0.0236341972,
-0.0333564803,
0.0320982859,
0.0084398901,
-0.0467624851,
0.0015958271,
0.0081969043,
0.0401329696,
-0.0056554358,
0.0459515639,
-0.0369434208,
0.003147424,
-0.0355707109,
0.0561678521,
-0.0604441352,
-0.0296232905,
0.0083628362,
0.0132351462,
-0.0037312061,
-0.0015692787,
0.0101952422,
-0.0465031937,
0.0109611535,
-0.0369838588,
-0.0307948813,
-0.0357768573,
0.0411912464,
0.0347736143,
-0.0272731222,
0.0016048339,
0.0041839592,
-0.0285337344,
-0.0049561304,
-0.0184843559,
0.0125987455,
0.0418005846,
-0.0132782152,
0.033811368,
-0.016313253,
-0.0138398018,
-0.0088607473,
-0.0113226566,
0.0401913747,
-0.0083805872,
0.0744943693,
0.0523631461,
0.0137389665,
-0.0252676457,
-0.0069980314,
-0.0952364355,
-0.0630658045,
0.0481879786,
0.0315694064,
0.0191306807,
-0.0228933226,
0.0219738111,
-0.0375701673,
-0.0117935548,
-0.0056246915,
0.0200843345,
0.0266523473,
-0.0415577888,
0.0263742898,
0.0653892606,
-0.0061107329,
0.0093471119,
0.0424396172,
-0.0455992818,
0.0496661887,
0.040583916,
-0.0083893044,
-0.0402241498,
-0.059028212,
-0.0013746584,
0.0427190401,
-0.0219989251,
0.0185213108,
-0.0725378469,
-0.0237063356,
-0.0044744709,
0.0081482381,
-0.0309814736,
-0.0214306097,
0.026295023,
0.0417148881,
0.0165852029,
-0.0009885877,
-0.0450498164,
0.0176794864,
-0.0458179861,
-0.0682938248,
-0.0214701779,
-5.595548169e-33,
-0.0112178512,
-0.0523773432,
0.0716975331,
0.0082522584,
-0.008490894,
0.0112419734,
-0.0528010465,
0.0106721753,
0.0123005351,
0.0480816625,
-0.0348551944,
0.0307373498,
-0.011567831,
0.0059924657,
0.0061210133,
-0.026351409,
0.0238969903,
-0.0116532557,
-0.0514604039,
0.0278436616,
0.0577064492,
-0.0016239829,
-0.0311443191,
-0.0129649378,
0.0091793938,
-0.0132433567,
-0.0130142132,
0.0486020222,
-0.0183161423,
0.0558114275,
-0.0224163644,
-0.0074714227,
0.0302097891,
-0.0172504783,
-0.0130753657,
0.0596960448,
-0.0941473544,
-0.0367384255,
0.0241998564,
-0.03492973,
-0.0683918595,
-0.0347823687,
-0.0200346112,
0.010182092,
0.0253630001,
-0.0492832549,
0.029369412,
-0.0192071311,
-0.0373099744,
-0.0172555223,
-0.0412002616,
0.0153598385,
-0.0378526151,
-0.0547959693,
0.04434615,
0.0317676216,
0.0127377557,
0.028040519,
0.0080844443,
-0.0014967646,
-0.0037193454,
0.0260492172,
0.0153797772,
-0.0017471531,
-0.011637154,
0.0673281625,
-0.0002763682,
-0.0004402232,
-0.052074939,
0.0380042568,
0.0036845591,
0.0446463563,
0.0317324549,
0.0160118993,
0.0270594899,
0.0521247908,
-0.0645907298,
0.0404706448,
0.0242329556,
0.0512426458,
0.0143233659,
-0.0101118488,
-0.0171294976,
-0.0127062425,
-0.0586272813,
0.0321459509,
-0.037414033,
0.01834305,
0.0174168292,
0.036430236,
0.0097148102,
-0.0422301702,
0.0366528705,
-0.0168156028,
0.0112513825,
0.0652078539,
-0.0260397252,
0.0111814411,
0.0100912852,
0.0323614962,
-0.0347419381,
0.0145474514,
0.0250946898,
-0.0054620495,
0.0062911478,
0.0172547549,
0.040907491,
0.012095849,
-0.0531087704,
-0.0069412231,
-0.0420654044,
0.0258512031,
-0.0379064605,
-0.005129186,
0.0175031163,
0.0221299361,
-0.0134594729,
0.0401569568,
-0.0168638732,
-0.0216565616,
-0.0254065171,
-0.0182914454,
-0.0066298051,
-0.0120249866,
-0.0193209145,
-0.0053025875,
-0.0303933434,
0.0150849754,
0.0400962494,
-0.0666779578,
0.0089392103,
0.0371574461,
2.479e-7,
-0.0007277018,
0.0359774306,
0.0405056216,
0.0625848919,
0.0030591681,
0.0239560585,
-0.0205060039,
-0.0084641697,
0.0208019298,
-0.0471052751,
0.0207663458,
0.061276827,
0.029229328,
0.0363156311,
-0.1228563786,
0.0035415739,
-0.0441313051,
-0.0471402332,
-0.0815172642,
-0.0389579758,
0.0850887969,
0.0622765422,
0.0203728452,
-0.0189144649,
0.0152555667,
-0.0548892915,
0.0564768165,
-0.0064301165,
-0.0343608111,
0.0159019008,
0.0352985226,
-0.0097387731,
-0.0065154601,
0.0010844938,
0.0046271165,
0.0184931587,
-0.0103682559,
0.0806245282,
0.0256340243,
-0.0038926662,
-0.0213450491,
-0.0430856943,
0.0130279651,
-0.0226738807,
0.0915953666,
-0.0219786931,
-0.0150327785,
-0.0021895382,
0.0000277195,
-0.0336057134,
-0.0084822038,
0.0098051848,
-0.0063692001,
0.0300172362,
0.0092141042,
-0.0246305056,
0.0330672227,
-0.1093376055,
-0.0212739706,
-0.0027355405,
-0.0152611304,
-0.0102454266,
-0.04355352,
0.0230517834,
0.0120233716,
-0.0844195262,
-0.0155098075,
2.344947992e-34,
0.0420908593,
-0.0130334347,
0.0001425047,
0.0217232909,
0.0600218512,
-0.0047958563,
-0.023232678,
0.0086178277,
0.0537059307,
-0.1128621325,
-0.0239319708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14556v1 | Unraveling ChatGPT: A Critical Analysis of AI-Generated Goal-Oriented Dialogues and Annotations | 2023-05-23T22:31:01 | 2023-05-23T22:31:01 | Tiziano Labruna, Sofia Brenna, Andrea Zaninello, Bernardo Magnini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large pre-trained language models have exhibited unprecedented capabilities
in producing high-quality text via prompting techniques. This fact introduces
new possibilities for data collection and annotation, particularly in
situations where such data is scarce, complex to gather, expensive, or even
sensitive. In this paper, we explore the potential of these models to generate
and annotate goal-oriented dialogues, and conduct an in-depth analysis to
evaluate their quality. Our experiments employ ChatGPT, and encompass three
categories of goal-oriented dialogues (task-oriented, collaborative, and
explanatory), two generation modes (interactive and one-shot), and two
languages (English and Italian). Based on extensive human-based evaluations, we
demonstrate that the quality of generated dialogues and annotations is on par
with those generated by humans. | [
0.0659562871,
0.0267914105,
-0.0129503123,
0.0249557551,
-0.0259569585,
0.0041615125,
-0.0121117011,
-0.0360552371,
-0.0005744484,
-0.0426945761,
-0.0526810624,
-0.0179658961,
-0.0049008629,
0.0434017479,
0.0056879129,
-0.0679894686,
0.0343450569,
-0.0048483321,
0.0354897603,
0.0189630296,
0.0557710528,
0.0240631495,
-0.0300018974,
0.0761179999,
-0.0573798195,
-0.0172370747,
-0.0481612794,
-0.0167282987,
-0.008231625,
-0.0093775894,
0.0224477202,
0.0575200692,
0.0236490127,
0.0082927132,
0.0000017712,
-0.0263531897,
0.0329167694,
-0.025941981,
-0.0189914182,
-0.010536233,
0.0405860916,
0.0305882432,
-0.0174975824,
0.0247727465,
-0.053933613,
-0.0003939759,
0.0435753241,
0.0461831093,
0.0922804624,
0.1003250927,
-0.0165027604,
0.0009805619,
-0.0094151953,
-0.0236496404,
-0.0052132718,
-0.0331420824,
-0.0365293361,
0.0335603319,
0.0003070335,
0.0274401475,
0.0436375551,
0.0251971595,
0.0201372653,
-0.0861211792,
-0.0061871316,
0.0185623523,
-0.0565550998,
-0.0489296913,
-0.0299926233,
0.0751838759,
0.0126214474,
-0.0132485339,
-0.0047459849,
-0.0085823433,
0.0299326219,
-0.029179126,
-0.0503190458,
0.0396338627,
0.0056616585,
0.0080873007,
0.0292956587,
0.0469908305,
-0.0055863783,
-0.0134398602,
0.0313971154,
0.0221040025,
-0.0051608081,
-0.0178566761,
-0.0036751525,
0.0207232181,
-0.0169455949,
-0.1042128652,
-0.0100926384,
0.0358017869,
-0.053215608,
0.0299947653,
-0.0432439782,
-0.0034048015,
0.0236603189,
-0.0499583781,
0.0363498181,
0.028602697,
-0.0190138239,
0.032697089,
0.0314094536,
0.0245775022,
0.0171615425,
0.0204324462,
-0.0346623659,
-0.0021307413,
-0.0438871868,
-0.016819654,
-0.0484151244,
0.0287381262,
-0.0464028753,
-0.03578059,
-0.0171926916,
0.0570615306,
0.0030857455,
0.027853841,
0.0142502962,
-0.0075031789,
-0.0392055809,
-0.0023476779,
-0.0263094697,
-0.023245519,
-0.0477625281,
-0.0051675243,
0.0367524177,
-0.0480924994,
0.0134116579,
0.0452184193,
-0.0195593648,
-0.005754333,
-0.0393959023,
0.0626339391,
-0.0211916752,
-0.0093831848,
-0.0015921417,
-0.0516406149,
-0.0200728923,
-0.0630890429,
-0.0101824617,
-0.0157022439,
0.0481789634,
-0.010179067,
-0.0206692442,
-0.0089780958,
0.022106383,
0.0338483974,
0.0112804677,
0.045771908,
-0.0153553318,
0.010661467,
0.0404205844,
-0.0013590461,
-0.025142312,
0.0555192456,
0.0444138534,
0.0412318558,
0.0373450741,
0.015334731,
0.0223736893,
0.0289812088,
0.0180274658,
-0.014847259,
0.0389383733,
0.0228657443,
-0.0321965516,
0.0459552556,
-0.0068214526,
0.0827729926,
-0.0372035243,
0.0206031222,
0.0545256026,
0.058821965,
0.0159816518,
0.016427191,
0.0543425344,
0.0421497636,
0.0154753597,
0.0259050392,
-0.038791541,
0.0333888829,
-0.0040818718,
-0.0140124988,
0.0365178473,
-0.0276589319,
-0.0308837388,
-0.0829824284,
-0.0037355702,
-0.0195927061,
0.0111063272,
-0.0122652827,
0.0231807772,
0.0320229977,
-0.042415414,
-0.0206566378,
0.0140118496,
-0.0694815814,
-0.0021757036,
-0.0465386659,
0.0453253351,
0.0705165341,
0.0618683994,
-0.0150432978,
-0.0600449219,
-0.0048465468,
0.0266038608,
0.0691985711,
0.0921372473,
-0.0415356271,
-0.0064399815,
-0.0245274696,
-0.0053302213,
-0.0430798866,
0.0093191154,
0.0134557541,
0.0101282503,
-0.0339064561,
0.015833864,
0.0007221055,
-0.059956301,
0.0360427238,
-0.0171130262,
0.0140376985,
-0.0004702249,
-0.0050680619,
0.0023613721,
0.0421230644,
-0.0241585393,
0.0259734448,
0.021214895,
-0.0082161622,
-0.0071494346,
0.045605205,
-0.047066804,
-0.04512484,
0.0025444629,
-0.0307997558,
-0.0181515217,
-0.0066433134,
-0.0197963063,
-0.0503241234,
-0.0074222176,
-0.0472856015,
0.0219607521,
-0.0453298762,
0.0048824889,
0.0192901157,
-0.0135595417,
-0.0291849338,
0.022975713,
0.0267095622,
-0.0345258266,
0.0166414399,
0.0101256035,
0.0361614712,
-0.031274043,
-0.0069382573,
0.0305804126,
0.0121105146,
-0.0066023637,
0.0640543923,
0.0334538594,
-0.0432021879,
-0.0219729785,
-0.1329338849,
0.017787436,
-0.0485834219,
0.0103482697,
0.0344001986,
-0.013385538,
0.0036481388,
-0.0032239386,
-0.0839861408,
0.0031211011,
0.0315847024,
-0.0043266867,
0.0660684481,
0.0385012366,
0.0364171304,
-0.060991466,
0.0242567379,
-0.0012502171,
0.0176371709,
0.0617956221,
-0.0244713463,
-0.0423816331,
0.0303315241,
-0.038165424,
0.007462915,
-0.0001029472,
-0.0413931012,
0.0619815402,
0.0118608363,
0.0599906854,
0.0425315872,
0.0387019776,
0.0745823383,
0.016301224,
0.0034096539,
-0.0456035249,
0.0156390853,
-0.0345766395,
-0.0160005856,
-0.0194592308,
-0.0233232304,
0.0521496199,
0.0427896827,
0.0030565369,
0.034067709,
-0.0831876174,
0.0401295871,
-0.0219668038,
-0.017066421,
-0.0175154153,
-0.0258937199,
-0.0219265427,
0.0494600199,
-0.0166596696,
-0.0265632905,
0.0639201179,
-0.0189911518,
-0.025901787,
-0.0469597727,
-0.0016717138,
-0.0255912673,
0.0635432601,
-0.0075940005,
0.0233842377,
-0.0099518057,
-0.0068098805,
-0.0225328729,
0.006327319,
0.0195618644,
-0.0152695896,
0.0250840131,
-0.0575092547,
-0.0061873896,
0.0063752295,
-0.0407043584,
-0.0597501062,
-0.0538910702,
-0.0075501516,
-0.0070970454,
0.0509033687,
-0.0116949147,
0.0052404162,
0.0102952598,
-0.0074079405,
0.0524415597,
-0.0187508333,
-0.0079761948,
-0.0181262065,
0.0112626636,
0.0384333879,
-0.0067065656,
-0.0099404221,
-0.0149214277,
0.0632402003,
0.0422019176,
-0.0075874152,
0.004717919,
-0.0259706788,
-0.0333028659,
0.0027039091,
-0.0203083362,
-0.0388173908,
-0.0014405616,
0.0747363269,
-0.0346764065,
-0.0233280715,
0.1396429092,
0.0345121026,
-0.0483900942,
-0.0042576827,
-0.0083358856,
0.0422342233,
-0.0050595906,
0.022422703,
-0.0854417607,
-0.0113099767,
-0.0166700538,
0.0033472844,
-0.0232642666,
-0.0171425957,
-0.0345782153,
-0.1042245179,
0.0494902879,
-0.0170273352,
-0.0131285759,
0.0380460434,
-0.0060371193,
-0.0174538977,
0.0000161216,
0.0143123278,
-0.0176296812,
0.0169898979,
0.0124288844,
0.020775212,
-0.0537883453,
-0.0291071124,
0.012137197,
-0.0215801876,
0.0791144595,
0.0896995217,
0.072131969,
0.0290104672,
0.0176750422,
0.0737219006,
0.0411128029,
0.0065231957,
0.0225322787,
0.0615931004,
-0.0196682494,
-0.0198688898,
-0.0236020572,
0.013939295,
-0.0044686925,
-0.0157164633,
0.0361190587,
0.0002847679,
-0.0662291199,
0.0348690636,
-0.0118378671,
0.0496161543,
0.0259348769,
0.0847906247,
0.0500365905,
-0.0571271293,
-0.0230104979,
-0.0285599157,
0.0173151754,
-0.0809751526,
-0.0244893543,
0.0011165199,
-0.0250431076,
-0.0058628414,
-0.1037276685,
-0.1060411856,
0.046895083,
-0.007740974,
0.0108259646,
-0.0511157177,
0.0132773472,
-0.0112290746,
0.0049086884,
0.0227840412,
-0.0184254907,
-0.0099384226,
-0.057191059,
-0.0495527796,
-0.0049132267,
-0.0324085541,
0.0017286083,
0.0370826386,
-0.0664838254,
-0.0608494468,
-0.0223693158,
0.0668829679,
0.0173262041,
0.0428068042,
-0.0102848997,
-0.0320809558,
-0.0363493487,
-0.0010735801,
0.0011502511,
-0.0257718358,
0.0226238333,
0.0442101546,
-0.0065839482,
0.0354304574,
-0.0078407601,
0.031790752,
-0.024738837,
0.0258685369,
-0.0097679449,
-0.0659035742,
0.0395675637,
0.001359645,
0.0439531282,
-0.0255195983,
-0.0003015611,
-0.0530735292,
-0.0227246471,
-0.0855756775,
-0.0343674012,
-0.0625578463,
0.0079693329,
-0.0120629976,
-0.0087633366,
0.0128777288,
-0.0106554339,
-0.0866315439,
0.0341294222,
-0.0283281691,
-0.0229387097,
0.0153382169,
-0.007012683,
-0.0035379156,
-0.000690284,
-0.03329641,
0.0461514406,
0.0024821069,
0.0315331183,
-0.0151314344,
0.0644977987,
0.018615162,
-0.0310510155,
0.0479470789,
0.0508728661,
-0.035757225,
-0.0526570827,
-0.0226808097,
0.0443032794,
0.0507868752,
0.0089556063,
0.0657680184,
-0.0689992607,
0.0048284899,
-0.0056846761,
0.0613894202,
0.0184698142,
-0.0489378422,
0.0030231811,
-0.0033108394,
-0.0370373875,
-0.0196899362,
0.0596919917,
-0.0273264144,
0.00476162,
0.0318557881,
-0.0031215269,
-0.0624949858,
-0.0159238856,
0.0210838653,
0.0170311239,
-0.0091573251,
0.0087551242,
-0.032044705,
-0.0229221825,
-0.0244829766,
0.0363996327,
-0.0146506727,
-0.0068264189,
0.0491986088,
0.0386498906,
-0.0307836644,
0.0128013249,
-0.0673460886,
0.0032683786,
-0.0506735481,
-0.0053822566,
-0.0239603315,
-5.325804174e-33,
-0.0321989767,
-0.0431374535,
0.0427701846,
0.0339963958,
-0.0343608074,
-0.0083974032,
-0.0447433814,
0.0322833993,
-0.0029091348,
0.024989374,
-0.0009886315,
0.0056795618,
0.004721072,
0.0199685842,
-0.0170229226,
-0.0251780152,
0.0389485732,
-0.0215380359,
-0.0441857167,
0.0628840551,
0.0212547742,
-0.0205598511,
0.0261592511,
-0.0733479336,
0.066121839,
-0.0294633191,
-0.0449753553,
0.0246775281,
0.0162124969,
0.0609899312,
-0.0210042913,
0.0385794267,
0.0158548187,
-0.0160963088,
-0.0251763687,
0.0480192937,
-0.0182625726,
-0.0430316627,
0.0249167643,
0.0018128774,
-0.0548535362,
-0.0197004359,
-0.0255150218,
-0.0358471349,
0.0067829383,
0.0305919219,
0.0282041114,
0.0035450596,
0.0079273051,
-0.0110240085,
-0.0831342414,
0.0238697082,
-0.0263356827,
-0.0753156394,
0.0191657748,
0.057461787,
0.0160146784,
-0.0405373722,
-0.0185885895,
0.0579015538,
-0.0069072591,
0.0028145202,
0.0473694727,
0.0106914192,
-0.0113336332,
0.0609359369,
0.0234905705,
0.0598640591,
-0.0193061493,
0.0214316286,
-0.0173433907,
0.0366722792,
0.0252139065,
0.0561350286,
-0.0244905017,
0.005743145,
-0.0238267202,
0.0397276022,
0.0109969741,
-0.0218549483,
-0.0023105552,
-0.0127264205,
-0.0452007055,
-0.0123679321,
-0.0379890539,
0.0059974357,
0.0014198008,
-0.0429804251,
0.0242156629,
-0.0070629073,
0.0009355295,
-0.0102281449,
0.0100848544,
-0.0159484521,
0.0088637397,
0.0022572328,
-0.06523332,
0.0122000268,
-0.024088636,
0.0151903341,
-0.0412657894,
-0.0071151792,
0.0356339253,
0.0131508261,
0.0177084431,
0.0362636708,
0.040360231,
0.0087791868,
-0.0241936222,
0.0123515166,
-0.0326211601,
0.0592268147,
-0.0306991916,
-0.0111115007,
0.0082293712,
0.0013226265,
-0.0424861349,
0.0660117939,
0.0262512788,
0.0083386116,
-0.0494125038,
-0.0332852565,
0.0114043988,
-0.0157619938,
-0.0341245271,
0.0162395351,
-0.0242641959,
0.0095455777,
0.0185412038,
-0.0464596041,
-0.0103410967,
-0.0285160486,
2.327e-7,
0.0428062305,
0.039538525,
0.0470741764,
0.0452283323,
0.0045844591,
0.0282699745,
-0.0061066416,
0.0253326632,
-0.0095224697,
0.0109352814,
0.0257357527,
0.0252502747,
0.0492511094,
0.0352213569,
-0.0700240061,
-0.0381073505,
-0.0611415654,
-0.0424068868,
-0.0526305772,
0.0142457699,
0.0959288701,
0.0366168767,
0.0005596515,
0.0062714531,
-0.0272431262,
-0.0314242914,
0.068544589,
-0.0354733355,
-0.0687927455,
0.0599792153,
0.0428276956,
0.0119517222,
-0.0119196521,
0.0005661793,
-0.0156052513,
-0.0110288989,
0.0112199616,
0.0664750487,
0.0025575629,
-0.0582095683,
0.0130175371,
0.0065467027,
0.014947908,
-0.0403610356,
0.0391704738,
-0.0868473575,
-0.0268565714,
-0.0336862281,
0.0160837788,
-0.0133927763,
0.0188975725,
-0.0412780941,
-0.016379986,
0.0170049071,
0.0217667352,
0.0017581788,
0.016869463,
-0.052674748,
-0.0347982571,
-0.0030633856,
-0.0444230102,
-0.0433112308,
-0.0315611996,
0.0112639014,
-0.0066307695,
-0.0188794397,
0.014546915,
1.810788206e-34,
0.0481043719,
-0.0080457674,
0.01640906,
0.0241786819,
0.0515384972,
0.0254245978,
0.0041056136,
0.0034508614,
0.0353473611,
-0.0303000193,
-0.0182575043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14555v1 | All Roads Lead to Rome? Exploring the Invariance of Transformers' Representations | 2023-05-23T22:30:43 | 2023-05-23T22:30:43 | Yuxin Ren, Qipeng Guo, Zhijing Jin, Shauli Ravfogel, Mrinmaya Sachan, Bernhard Schölkopf, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformer models bring propelling advances in various NLP tasks, thus
inducing lots of interpretability research on the learned representations of
the models. However, we raise a fundamental question regarding the reliability
of the representations. Specifically, we investigate whether transformers learn
essentially isomorphic representation spaces, or those that are sensitive to
the random seeds in their pretraining process. In this work, we formulate the
Bijection Hypothesis, which suggests the use of bijective methods to align
different models' representation spaces. We propose a model based on invertible
neural networks, BERT-INN, to learn the bijection more effectively than other
existing bijective methods such as the canonical correlation analysis (CCA). We
show the advantage of BERT-INN both theoretically and through extensive
experiments, and apply it to align the reproduced BERT embeddings to draw
insights that are meaningful to the interpretability research. Our code is at
https://github.com/twinkle0331/BERT-similarity. | [
0.0083579347,
0.0698539913,
-0.0397974402,
0.0564782768,
-0.0048190663,
0.0222849902,
-0.0174648706,
0.0052121873,
-0.014732332,
-0.0134539027,
-0.0576421469,
-0.0036493996,
-0.0128826508,
-0.0238568168,
0.0238638278,
-0.0364951976,
0.0262660999,
0.0159289222,
-0.0562703125,
0.0070958082,
-0.0154759493,
-0.0383662209,
-0.0152932173,
0.0530840047,
-0.0157599244,
-0.0131736975,
-0.0055788225,
-0.0212495551,
0.0099760275,
0.0052795662,
-0.0241109096,
0.0490763225,
0.0361139178,
0.0693111122,
0.0000016965,
-0.0084166788,
-0.0208916627,
0.0153999841,
-0.0328293256,
-0.0206294078,
-0.0398899205,
-0.0266269874,
0.0029910463,
-0.0099785151,
-0.0260238051,
0.0134515371,
0.0760791004,
0.076767236,
0.0525593497,
0.050618086,
-0.0105643105,
-0.0488875657,
0.0238123368,
-0.0109480685,
0.0041843839,
0.0163770225,
-0.0191848334,
-0.015512676,
-0.0590640791,
0.0252207927,
-0.0504014343,
0.0009344976,
0.0299626235,
0.0217060987,
0.0058811596,
0.0294582248,
-0.062876977,
-0.0497855917,
-0.0038492465,
0.0521246605,
-0.0247121658,
-0.0286086407,
-0.0175292492,
0.0322151221,
0.021754384,
0.0449871607,
-0.0290800277,
0.0053278711,
0.021937456,
0.0469721816,
-0.0038349719,
0.0135830119,
0.038244646,
-0.0334873497,
-0.0279146135,
0.0373405814,
0.0330173112,
-0.0117586441,
-0.0217339359,
0.0320626274,
-0.0258495025,
0.0018789473,
-0.0234122556,
0.0225108694,
0.0092896521,
0.0198766049,
-0.0157259125,
-0.0327074118,
0.0091667278,
-0.0493238084,
0.0731049702,
0.0354786515,
-0.0476623178,
0.0115769319,
-0.0620492212,
0.0979202464,
-0.0653847158,
0.0872011334,
-0.0352663323,
-0.021005528,
-0.0870743468,
-0.0467100777,
-0.0540261492,
0.0234796889,
0.0148818679,
-0.0206003822,
-0.0401214547,
0.0322310664,
-0.0325578563,
0.0062038559,
0.0128593314,
0.0301726926,
-0.0498942696,
0.0393863805,
0.005627057,
0.0545641035,
-0.0264984518,
0.0062412545,
-0.0281907972,
-0.0355889834,
-0.0360798985,
0.0149505641,
0.0023231762,
-0.0092530334,
0.0054154466,
0.0944217145,
0.0224010702,
-0.0496293344,
-0.0030759289,
0.0227573477,
-0.0430253744,
-0.0128671769,
0.0548070334,
-0.0433656536,
0.0347938575,
0.0349663235,
0.0205721967,
-0.0572917759,
-0.0039439104,
-0.0097336378,
-0.0184065271,
0.0892708823,
0.0345843248,
-0.0148110818,
-0.01814905,
-0.0169061348,
-0.0235847533,
0.0522568859,
0.0325873345,
0.001806914,
0.0252925046,
-0.0343199149,
0.0263574384,
0.0151508776,
0.0290801432,
-0.0146618234,
-0.0231315605,
-0.0210694037,
0.0225783288,
0.0294657256,
0.0119372662,
0.0575971305,
-0.0270987954,
-0.0341188163,
0.047836937,
0.0320193172,
0.0377177596,
0.0535413176,
0.0432051159,
-0.018882934,
0.0121123586,
0.0367379263,
-0.0620744117,
0.0206463095,
0.0049743257,
-0.0094880434,
-0.0406543948,
0.0021284095,
-0.0492251478,
-0.0096408688,
-0.019570224,
-0.0104555152,
-0.022721475,
-0.0573659129,
0.0601131059,
0.0522843897,
-0.0201683771,
0.0995650217,
0.011623526,
-0.0620137677,
0.0010127662,
-0.0228826907,
-0.0210390016,
0.006623372,
0.0147372736,
-0.0107930759,
0.0013623198,
-0.0042140153,
-0.0531946868,
0.0229357295,
-0.0057725888,
-0.0030690862,
0.0158155896,
-0.0148482136,
-0.020749893,
-0.0185156595,
0.0516771786,
0.025565356,
-0.025935892,
-0.0553987697,
0.009541803,
-0.0848950893,
0.0054348218,
0.048090592,
-0.0422060937,
-0.0211022962,
-0.0054454203,
0.027395688,
0.0197957009,
0.0044459905,
-0.013209491,
0.029732123,
0.0487391688,
-0.0481325798,
-0.0222214255,
0.0593727827,
-0.0322638676,
-0.0492744483,
0.0184608791,
-0.0791623741,
-0.0218944903,
0.0815947428,
-0.013727014,
-0.0264969599,
0.0269438773,
-0.0740938857,
0.0781027377,
-0.0246813092,
0.0045172498,
-0.0319131054,
0.015036297,
-0.020053871,
0.0643796101,
-0.0104960687,
0.0357737802,
0.0029839778,
-0.041486647,
0.0290272571,
0.0015669835,
-0.0535407588,
0.0023671677,
-0.0048297397,
-0.0038693957,
0.0010291425,
-0.0448704399,
-0.0254734084,
-0.0520157069,
-0.0680460706,
-0.0173771679,
-0.0295702238,
0.0256982576,
0.0570097826,
-0.0096652973,
0.0494140796,
0.001898609,
-0.0218306854,
-0.0040484923,
-0.0143844923,
0.0214287303,
0.0613458976,
-0.0128880814,
-0.037745066,
-0.0031664148,
-0.0261707716,
-0.0439601205,
0.1016998217,
-0.0175603498,
0.0151741104,
-0.0433157347,
-0.0040424936,
0.021511497,
0.0105978055,
-0.0209922548,
-0.0428058058,
0.031292256,
0.0142652495,
0.0234184079,
0.0183837079,
0.0189837813,
0.0831815526,
-0.0073016435,
0.021534143,
-0.040512912,
-0.0231310297,
-0.0520038642,
-0.0235061459,
-0.0512046441,
-0.037678849,
-0.0017266402,
0.0671872422,
-0.0182247069,
-0.0113712838,
-0.0652356967,
-0.0180285089,
-0.0176440571,
-0.0033762045,
0.0004036957,
-0.0357694775,
-0.0227661841,
0.0284907278,
-0.0128076179,
-0.0491339341,
0.0492575243,
-0.0329113193,
-0.0062547862,
-0.0253704675,
0.0281890761,
-0.0559569225,
0.0739863366,
0.0383721218,
0.0048964247,
0.0090692267,
-0.0357360244,
-0.0553546585,
-0.0058289361,
0.0140353655,
-0.0215390716,
0.0587802082,
-0.0004613048,
-0.0132119181,
-0.0083888732,
-0.0281247403,
-0.0572849512,
-0.0506416671,
0.0234951973,
0.0475470126,
0.0446139798,
-0.0264567081,
-0.0806218311,
-0.0026753033,
0.0200202167,
-0.0018222684,
0.0100956196,
-0.0115194414,
-0.021336982,
0.0436688885,
0.0067673111,
0.0438011102,
0.0478321835,
-0.014992455,
-0.0241109375,
0.0139222266,
0.0249193106,
0.0236285925,
-0.0698624775,
0.0425023735,
-0.0080817752,
-0.0145884557,
-0.0345664285,
-0.0211264528,
0.0227199066,
0.0014239942,
-0.0409160629,
0.0862818956,
0.0221475549,
-0.0333418362,
0.0434674099,
-0.0185289029,
-0.0063610431,
0.0241643991,
0.0037138928,
-0.0301252902,
-0.0207005981,
-0.0009783328,
0.0074636177,
0.0104876673,
-0.0223949589,
0.0213259608,
-0.0858029872,
-0.0043162941,
-0.022835115,
-0.0050010309,
-0.0588289946,
-0.0442435779,
0.0101741254,
-0.0316524617,
0.0194032993,
-0.0192138366,
-0.015484618,
0.024719514,
0.0542883463,
0.0018236999,
-0.0223352406,
-0.0290452503,
-0.022454951,
0.0224877708,
0.0788784027,
0.0521726012,
-0.0582977347,
-0.0439184532,
-0.0396107771,
-0.0431203283,
-0.0067845494,
0.0286724605,
0.0618619956,
0.0172518939,
-0.0525118001,
-0.012210412,
0.0151536399,
-0.0405830592,
-0.0303328689,
-0.0661981925,
0.0765536129,
-0.0157925524,
-0.0366003364,
-0.0186206754,
-0.0147008784,
-0.0163869094,
0.0897553191,
0.0472909734,
-0.0224395227,
-0.0014065554,
-0.0140107479,
0.0547180213,
-0.0006312903,
-0.0377818756,
0.0242158268,
0.0376323126,
-0.0476451963,
-0.0594290197,
-0.0194998179,
-0.0084948717,
0.0395809487,
0.0207428001,
-0.0410313383,
0.0088442089,
-0.030643234,
-0.0229256488,
0.0443069004,
0.0123527497,
-0.0079427399,
-0.0430777967,
-0.0215188339,
0.0495818518,
-0.0024592888,
-0.0596045218,
-0.0148545727,
-0.0577409007,
-0.0267204512,
0.0559109189,
0.0330353193,
0.0270045381,
0.0147923958,
0.0082907295,
0.0244488604,
0.0225272011,
0.0691640079,
-0.0030035612,
0.0156335477,
0.0438468531,
-0.0099914763,
0.0104170246,
0.0568359047,
-0.0265522879,
0.0206428189,
0.0271079466,
0.0450706705,
-0.014796339,
-0.0096618338,
0.0380226225,
-0.0224920493,
0.0472280942,
0.026530154,
0.0215103999,
-0.0069479612,
0.0117490832,
0.0026154816,
-0.018554233,
-0.0390541553,
-0.0091778003,
0.0195863266,
0.0301609486,
-0.0272674598,
0.0196940079,
0.0065143458,
0.0377676152,
-0.0033629211,
0.0035320946,
0.030645743,
0.0110637881,
-0.0482849218,
0.0358477272,
-0.0125637045,
0.0049082153,
0.004709926,
0.0205851141,
-0.0069898977,
0.0151018277,
0.0420813374,
0.0332817547,
-0.0618503354,
0.006147678,
-0.079576619,
-0.0292780604,
-0.0156638715,
-0.0045384546,
0.0160743389,
-0.0467310175,
0.0481812954,
-0.0446150526,
0.0140696038,
0.0112238331,
0.0157733466,
0.0203714892,
0.0185779054,
0.0452974103,
0.0044170362,
0.0083987666,
-0.0590625852,
0.0820531547,
-0.0398634821,
0.0502128862,
-0.0439689308,
-0.0199499484,
-0.0386786088,
-0.0142691778,
0.0665277317,
-0.0201804116,
0.00849183,
0.0180818439,
-0.0380028114,
-0.0492137186,
0.0504052974,
0.0010152805,
0.0263895262,
-0.019404592,
0.0259356387,
0.0634987354,
0.0083063291,
0.0026069821,
-0.0105273174,
0.021421643,
0.0258118678,
-0.0091262115,
-0.0492223576,
-5.668399064e-33,
-0.0250867829,
-0.0344593525,
-0.0344698094,
-0.0350752324,
0.0121320384,
-0.0050088842,
-0.0365443677,
-0.0063046697,
-0.0498204939,
0.0322820656,
0.0011642224,
0.0168595109,
0.0069573936,
0.0429223143,
0.0214818753,
-0.0501985028,
0.0375223272,
0.0262186844,
-0.0117885247,
0.0004408482,
0.0545301065,
0.022593705,
0.0892619565,
-0.0481012724,
0.0224253908,
-0.0144368876,
0.0218387172,
0.0135413781,
0.0126919169,
0.0779851377,
-0.0157686919,
0.0272048507,
0.0331356116,
-0.0421039127,
-0.0084721027,
0.0063697877,
-0.08015991,
-0.0380428396,
-0.0023050073,
0.0326799192,
-0.0252029672,
-0.0111656282,
0.0721928328,
-0.03708997,
-0.0070551718,
-0.0245284662,
0.0350971036,
-0.0078244964,
-0.0068748551,
-0.0004658274,
-0.0686837658,
-0.0233646315,
-0.0193053484,
-0.0371978581,
0.0039306437,
0.0520898066,
-0.0143621555,
0.0496858954,
-0.0573784299,
-0.0247642938,
-0.0149745727,
0.0225741826,
0.0336257741,
0.0069301897,
0.0016832937,
0.0683103576,
0.0071339402,
-0.053575594,
-0.0232935064,
-0.0523074493,
0.0216260683,
0.0562425517,
0.0653893203,
0.0272228979,
0.0418926477,
0.0164438821,
-0.0503803194,
0.0266175754,
-0.0147965066,
0.0265651364,
0.0517296381,
-0.0148218563,
-0.0236961599,
0.0015216535,
-0.0282253884,
-0.0548942015,
-0.0196932033,
-0.0227542091,
-0.0072358684,
-0.0357864797,
-0.016443992,
0.0474564247,
0.0297758505,
-0.0731156319,
-0.0151811782,
0.0410872586,
-0.0009174169,
0.0248701684,
0.009955056,
0.0079647889,
-0.0111155156,
-0.0642579198,
0.0202170275,
0.0461068079,
0.0338682048,
0.0127950935,
0.0984991789,
-0.0139699029,
-0.0290474053,
-0.0102681965,
-0.0393619463,
-0.0442120209,
-0.0340411663,
0.044339776,
0.0293510463,
0.0163728315,
-0.0312530547,
-0.0083514564,
0.0293331984,
0.0409941562,
-0.0151093388,
0.0289172642,
0.0073060812,
0.0177467149,
0.0036293506,
-0.0413340628,
-0.0321233086,
0.0501715019,
0.0032687176,
-0.0619601607,
-0.0097688381,
0.0007439192,
2.524e-7,
0.1053290516,
-0.00157649,
0.0490984134,
-0.0260468516,
0.0401134379,
0.0376337469,
-0.0296249855,
0.0512970425,
0.0101138242,
-0.0187926088,
-0.0036933168,
0.0072990814,
-0.0009606811,
0.014541599,
-0.0376777612,
-0.038356822,
-0.078434065,
0.0044779452,
0.0027377247,
0.0525109619,
0.0766612515,
0.1177729368,
0.003925879,
-0.0037443843,
0.0148757668,
0.0260776095,
0.0806740597,
-0.0444523804,
0.0437099449,
0.0012152458,
-0.015134952,
-0.0276081413,
0.0248450339,
0.0198981967,
-0.0023722777,
0.0421087742,
0.0253760889,
-0.0202917196,
-0.0007082844,
-0.0605188683,
-0.0203719344,
-0.0240814574,
0.0135004893,
-0.0603122078,
0.024122132,
-0.0917922929,
-0.0799371898,
0.0073563717,
-0.0506962314,
0.0312988684,
0.0301972609,
0.0165294372,
-0.0056493655,
0.0126778362,
0.0241955817,
-0.0023762616,
0.0050966111,
-0.0537318699,
-0.0124082463,
-0.0189397316,
-0.0700913742,
-0.0390088186,
-0.0351318009,
-0.0411864705,
0.0646958351,
-0.0289525725,
-0.0033955742,
2.208196444e-34,
-0.001742469,
0.0182342548,
0.0391068943,
0.0383595116,
-0.0046327012,
-0.0252794437,
0.0286575593,
-0.0061616297,
0.010017884,
-0.065724723,
-0.0185527951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14552v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14552v2 | Sources of Hallucination by Large Language Models on Inference Tasks | 2023-05-23T22:24:44 | 2023-10-22T21:22:29 | Nick McKenna, Tianyi Li, Liang Cheng, Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Mark Johnson, Mark Steedman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are claimed to be capable of Natural Language
Inference (NLI), necessary for applied tasks like question answering and
summarization. We present a series of behavioral studies on several LLM
families (LLaMA, GPT-3.5, and PaLM) which probe their behavior using controlled
experiments. We establish two biases originating from pretraining which predict
much of their behavior, and show that these are major sources of hallucination
in generative LLMs. First, memorization at the level of sentences: we show
that, regardless of the premise, models falsely label NLI test samples as
entailing when the hypothesis is attested in training data, and that entities
are used as ``indices'' to access the memorized data. Second, statistical
patterns of usage learned at the level of corpora: we further show a similar
effect when the premise predicate is less frequent than that of the hypothesis
in the training data, a bias following from previous studies. We demonstrate
that LLMs perform significantly worse on NLI test samples which do not conform
to these biases than those which do, and we offer these as valuable controls
for future LLM evaluation. | [
0.0265313629,
0.0553782173,
-0.0142958555,
0.0148118297,
-0.0405898876,
0.0464966632,
-0.0089460518,
-0.0187068619,
0.0171693377,
-0.0457300767,
-0.0205156542,
-0.0243166313,
0.0201401394,
-0.049906712,
0.0515832566,
-0.0304249097,
0.0559709221,
-0.0502678528,
-0.0353337303,
-0.0316292718,
-0.0151492376,
-0.0007551764,
0.0191446543,
0.0078347567,
0.004330453,
-0.0158191435,
0.0169316847,
-0.0480279699,
-0.0159380212,
0.0038779783,
-0.0119583746,
0.0496805385,
0.0208408628,
0.0519014411,
0.0000020011,
-0.075307779,
0.0067288284,
-0.0209381934,
-0.017767325,
0.0368681662,
0.0188055448,
-0.0085337702,
0.014314577,
0.0084491596,
-0.0220957864,
-0.0448483899,
0.0300965402,
0.0774210691,
0.0374968573,
0.0458051227,
0.0132729365,
-0.0745797157,
0.0462350994,
-0.0163394064,
0.0399123468,
-0.0144326296,
0.0583736189,
0.0394225903,
-0.0170950852,
-0.037829224,
-0.0136539098,
0.0317505375,
0.0380129367,
0.0569759049,
-0.0132904025,
0.0672833398,
-0.0723448694,
-0.0099264123,
0.0262489133,
0.0363612212,
-0.0058192443,
-0.0602455623,
-0.0145625575,
0.03188923,
0.0192216393,
0.0316084102,
-0.0460895859,
0.0606659167,
-0.0288970508,
0.0277900044,
0.0653607696,
-0.0162808653,
0.0455175228,
0.0198755264,
-0.0707137212,
0.067971386,
0.0339511111,
-0.0496575683,
0.0299758092,
0.0346995145,
-0.0385514423,
-0.0642246604,
-0.007571118,
0.019624738,
-0.0141856167,
0.0237911642,
-0.0025008132,
-0.0135495644,
0.0337342881,
-0.071160391,
-0.0003763572,
0.0211833045,
-0.0280280001,
0.0556018464,
-0.0850002021,
0.0401871726,
-0.0415055081,
0.0543161891,
-0.0374527164,
-0.0318641178,
-0.0304748807,
-0.0458489954,
-0.0187715366,
0.0606797859,
0.0175529178,
-0.0062765353,
-0.0157749765,
0.0176503398,
-0.0074236281,
-0.0060773087,
-0.0338179953,
0.0104653565,
-0.0136742182,
-0.0145142945,
-0.0701999515,
0.0259457529,
-0.0520827658,
0.0377981067,
0.0042883772,
-0.0683031902,
-0.038530618,
0.0079569425,
-0.0081842132,
-0.0105234357,
0.0249319319,
0.0292082466,
-0.0012886573,
-0.0285089854,
-0.0479080305,
-0.0248290878,
-0.0067711375,
-0.087930277,
0.0195903275,
-0.0675345883,
0.0107753891,
0.0319559872,
0.004343926,
-0.0174111854,
0.0004198998,
0.0269064512,
-0.0448031835,
0.0639127865,
0.0231224466,
0.0226543639,
0.0450305641,
0.0234013405,
-0.0059497738,
0.0702383146,
-0.0023156591,
0.0244186819,
0.0059137167,
-0.0086198794,
0.0352001674,
0.033123333,
-0.0057197032,
0.0064900266,
-0.0014207235,
-0.0034283297,
0.0273476318,
0.0064056446,
0.0544874333,
0.0747789294,
-0.02913999,
-0.0140504492,
0.0669854358,
0.0616445728,
-0.0177065805,
0.0122376289,
0.050753016,
-0.0382163636,
0.0345868953,
0.0910658613,
-0.0661894232,
-0.0022189009,
-0.046120096,
0.0264931135,
0.0500113517,
0.0143884495,
-0.0383670144,
-0.0493585393,
-0.000872944,
0.0007780979,
-0.0344645791,
0.0289253704,
0.0343518406,
0.033288084,
-0.0298574902,
0.0545708798,
0.0489081293,
-0.0236194395,
0.0022532064,
-0.0523499884,
0.0440323986,
0.0488852784,
0.0254380964,
-0.0060719671,
0.0300065912,
0.0039890502,
0.0210801177,
0.0163827501,
0.0488624908,
-0.0047249291,
-0.0134836677,
-0.0006585307,
0.0142025147,
-0.0204375293,
0.057596378,
0.0182892457,
-0.0016988437,
0.0019775843,
0.0210672263,
-0.0420788638,
-0.0357463025,
0.0504319482,
-0.0294310898,
-0.0526917428,
-0.041175805,
-0.0156336147,
0.0218748208,
-0.0207115486,
-0.0194811132,
0.0258239172,
0.0188030489,
-0.0433077663,
-0.022180073,
0.0137269842,
-0.0466135368,
-0.0592837036,
0.0060906513,
-0.020240929,
-0.011928102,
0.0085179908,
-0.0168967787,
-0.0326058902,
0.0042342884,
-0.04992944,
0.0718607083,
-0.0480731018,
0.0198321063,
0.000209658,
0.0284784473,
-0.0171309095,
0.1145294011,
-0.0226323474,
0.0123555167,
0.0249159895,
0.0227743797,
-0.0113210659,
-0.0168765187,
-0.0006256786,
0.0365542695,
0.0382200815,
-0.0035752703,
-0.006713511,
-0.0542997569,
-0.0549287498,
-0.0235107206,
-0.1006788313,
0.0097808521,
-0.0311117284,
0.0135106649,
0.0235689972,
-0.0146575142,
-0.0279444326,
-0.0084614288,
-0.013434507,
-0.0339558721,
0.0249564573,
0.0538155921,
0.0103130229,
-0.0017960727,
0.0024572103,
-0.0262501314,
0.0040069357,
-0.0320071094,
0.0630468503,
-0.0268773921,
-0.0221473277,
-0.0778760538,
0.0568374954,
-0.042810481,
-0.0044379495,
-0.0083496235,
-0.0066510644,
0.0199333839,
-0.0141887954,
0.0696671084,
0.1082846075,
0.0003014637,
0.0118216993,
0.0775640383,
0.0000650725,
-0.0343338773,
-0.0246680751,
-0.0266271736,
-0.0259764921,
-0.0173183661,
-0.0472584218,
-0.0118752457,
0.0666667968,
0.0254344381,
-0.0016896209,
-0.0379671715,
0.0375481211,
-0.0446398519,
-0.0221383367,
0.01668543,
-0.0106208371,
-0.0269119516,
0.0256253146,
-0.0160716828,
-0.0477874018,
0.0581369363,
-0.0143168466,
-0.0007909954,
-0.054585509,
0.0081478544,
-0.036493592,
0.0198562201,
0.0466906503,
0.0058966056,
0.0023614061,
-0.0120956805,
-0.0645345151,
-0.0067800437,
-0.0037051141,
-0.0173469502,
0.0253729802,
-0.0347435102,
-0.0028710722,
0.0056110858,
-0.0288437791,
-0.0505346768,
-0.0303255003,
-0.0467162095,
-0.0084451037,
-0.0226069074,
0.0342149511,
-0.0235208552,
-0.0160207823,
0.0353511125,
0.0071823983,
-0.0298823975,
-0.0218685288,
-0.0215716306,
0.029230224,
0.0614976138,
0.0001495423,
0.0569260307,
-0.0367999002,
0.0272863545,
0.0659360662,
0.0234494973,
0.0276965648,
-0.0169238877,
0.0075400076,
0.0022007534,
-0.0506830327,
-0.0319560356,
0.0163061731,
0.0315155461,
-0.0581680909,
0.0008906675,
0.1079433784,
0.0280144773,
-0.0360586643,
0.0080457823,
-0.0056884633,
0.0763975903,
0.0072626034,
-0.0145407394,
-0.0765277743,
-0.0258322358,
-0.0026009334,
-0.0086580059,
-0.0327806398,
-0.0277310126,
0.0009258544,
-0.1382127553,
0.0105345314,
0.0125751868,
-0.0317145474,
-0.0039559277,
-0.0599942356,
0.0149324583,
0.0178142302,
0.0226316415,
0.0130898897,
-0.0174484774,
-0.0034750316,
0.024977427,
-0.0364692174,
-0.0250289198,
0.0217654537,
-0.0236035753,
0.0140176443,
0.0564327314,
0.0189267807,
-0.029043112,
-0.0307937618,
0.0283386931,
-0.032788679,
-0.0020987655,
0.0133203771,
0.0389043093,
0.0097385151,
0.0081778904,
-0.0182095133,
0.0332949311,
-0.0127528394,
0.0006304356,
-0.0047139442,
0.0621726178,
-0.0106642619,
-0.081027545,
0.0084534045,
0.0115393447,
-0.0446542501,
0.090981409,
0.0362187736,
-0.0149837937,
-0.0506093092,
-0.0258817207,
0.0028850306,
0.0128482115,
-0.0518150181,
0.0503536128,
0.0329751484,
-0.0219726916,
-0.0713464096,
-0.0732676014,
0.040826086,
0.0045963135,
0.0002008037,
0.0630155951,
-0.0285658762,
-0.006678306,
0.0123045119,
0.0426622964,
-0.0449087992,
-0.0226625036,
-0.0255931057,
-0.0291827451,
0.0573541112,
-0.0208235458,
-0.0100307968,
0.0234342888,
-0.0901171044,
-0.064814955,
0.0193929374,
0.0457724854,
0.0281842612,
0.0478049181,
0.0072957133,
-0.0413433015,
0.0411220714,
0.0195302125,
-0.0044489312,
0.0667618513,
-0.0048069409,
-0.0006739192,
0.01923538,
0.0330117606,
-0.0176377445,
0.0194169469,
0.0174751375,
0.0014702176,
-0.0182279199,
-0.0035523358,
0.0577983446,
0.0108194491,
-0.0010719767,
-0.0168390796,
0.0070508253,
-0.0125509752,
0.0064154123,
0.001122817,
-0.0204306766,
0.0018036563,
0.0010817536,
0.0367856063,
0.0291154701,
0.0008415667,
-0.0079622176,
0.0091916528,
0.0255801026,
-0.0103343539,
-0.0318139754,
0.0287163612,
-0.0031528489,
0.0286378153,
-0.0043197321,
-0.0591980852,
-0.0157998633,
-0.0179652181,
0.0694497824,
0.0030157242,
0.0477722697,
0.004300579,
-0.0298698004,
-0.0371635742,
-0.0064045992,
-0.0873722881,
-0.0705865845,
0.0035473087,
0.0335714817,
0.0380031019,
-0.0344355293,
0.0318562761,
-0.0471905507,
-0.0011976511,
-0.0099463323,
-0.0268890206,
0.0322258323,
-0.0166244563,
0.0082281483,
0.0121717341,
-0.0269444976,
0.0019262002,
0.0891388431,
0.0410429686,
0.0793228596,
0.0104818391,
-0.0033065949,
-0.0162160918,
-0.0649943799,
-0.0303279348,
-0.0281727724,
-0.0072296644,
-0.0217149258,
-0.0666347817,
-0.0712266788,
-0.0292112399,
-0.016961934,
0.0046110628,
-0.041889295,
0.0150742205,
0.0531988628,
-0.0186575111,
-0.0390363038,
-0.0246091634,
0.0183721334,
0.0253438409,
0.0260445252,
-0.0233049709,
-6.502738505e-33,
-0.0159595106,
-0.0159400646,
0.0132505903,
-0.0322396718,
-0.0013414288,
-0.0231031012,
-0.0304437373,
0.0083556958,
-0.0321883559,
0.0081683137,
-0.0151382703,
0.0211579353,
0.0147913992,
0.0022095982,
0.0002137782,
-0.0288846213,
0.0324247181,
0.0021414622,
-0.0396364033,
0.0209138505,
0.0325498171,
0.0061981813,
0.0660439804,
-0.0363349989,
0.0268053152,
-0.0387220494,
0.002310378,
-0.0024092009,
-0.0581908152,
0.0268138759,
-0.0451638438,
0.0399626382,
0.0325050056,
-0.0368697084,
-0.0123366751,
0.0222528409,
-0.0597041883,
-0.0313649289,
0.0428862311,
0.016692996,
-0.0212029088,
-0.0383431911,
0.0560004376,
-0.0189221501,
-0.0076746461,
0.0031718365,
0.0192224272,
-0.0286160614,
-0.0294158924,
0.0058488147,
-0.0675610751,
0.0008848213,
0.0272999797,
0.0049687377,
-0.0124216424,
0.0037534968,
-0.0146758221,
-0.0013583702,
-0.0386399403,
-0.0038296317,
0.0395987369,
0.0036881836,
0.0289795958,
0.0199122187,
0.0235293098,
0.0755321756,
0.0509665795,
0.0085914386,
-0.0315950215,
-0.032554321,
0.0050572138,
0.0144039588,
0.0145847695,
0.0041804151,
0.0776796266,
0.0341327526,
-0.040162757,
-0.0045502065,
-0.0198772866,
0.0264639519,
0.0636395589,
-0.031894777,
-0.042691227,
-0.0407612063,
-0.0460360944,
0.0359775163,
-0.0194015019,
-0.010633029,
0.0262245983,
0.0038811364,
0.0004299298,
-0.024782408,
0.032665208,
-0.0416923873,
-0.0274816062,
0.0247218926,
-0.0407219082,
0.0030346853,
-0.0016788746,
0.0253430605,
-0.0414288826,
0.0168715008,
-0.0027905987,
0.0153891183,
0.0138322953,
0.0194023177,
0.0330941603,
-0.0272194669,
-0.0472280718,
-0.0001163422,
-0.0440867692,
-0.0136184953,
0.0128533272,
0.0035416677,
0.0787915811,
0.0232706666,
0.0090467306,
-0.0032805568,
0.03020625,
-0.0012643771,
-0.0497732833,
0.0344885886,
-0.0136803715,
0.0198017899,
-0.0223501213,
-0.0089597991,
-0.0394483134,
0.0342302024,
0.0339573361,
-0.0687446892,
-0.0071344138,
0.0227120779,
2.764e-7,
0.0393257439,
0.0419162475,
-0.0137591911,
0.0111751212,
0.0125853885,
0.0120071527,
0.0092758629,
-0.0025415057,
0.0600229315,
-0.034908656,
-0.0099630328,
0.0535093173,
0.048473224,
0.0432844311,
-0.1037313789,
-0.0038996297,
-0.0208946187,
0.0180676468,
-0.0707051232,
-0.01914859,
0.0318895839,
0.1059751883,
-0.0072875591,
-0.0094536403,
0.0132233091,
-0.077525571,
0.085998334,
0.003593036,
-0.0019434248,
0.0281908102,
0.0297451802,
0.0390836522,
0.0136062503,
0.058744505,
0.0306203384,
-0.0224947426,
0.0158675015,
0.0155209173,
0.0159956198,
-0.0384260453,
-0.0374517441,
-0.0502746031,
0.0099817049,
-0.0733132064,
0.1057946905,
-0.0633785054,
-0.0286751781,
0.0147385243,
-0.0105113145,
-0.0373134725,
0.031843625,
0.0053495555,
-0.002594413,
0.0246010907,
-0.0159775708,
0.0015662201,
-0.00594731,
-0.0740865171,
-0.0121569652,
0.0165199656,
-0.0395996608,
-0.0769176483,
-0.0143451486,
0.0054207398,
0.0113263866,
-0.0675029531,
0.0178982466,
2.783090553e-34,
0.0246902611,
-0.0025180229,
0.0345358811,
0.0529021285,
0.0336494818,
-0.02380413,
0.0472809374,
0.0140074883,
0.0148915723,
-0.0902952477,
0.0069285845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14548v1 | Interpretable Automatic Fine-grained Inconsistency Detection in Text Summarization | 2023-05-23T22:11:47 | 2023-05-23T22:11:47 | Hou Pong Chan, Qi Zeng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing factual consistency evaluation approaches for text summarization
provide binary predictions and limited insights into the weakness of
summarization systems. Therefore, we propose the task of fine-grained
inconsistency detection, the goal of which is to predict the fine-grained types
of factual errors in a summary. Motivated by how humans inspect factual
inconsistency in summaries, we propose an interpretable fine-grained
inconsistency detection model, FineGrainFact, which explicitly represents the
facts in the documents and summaries with semantic frames extracted by semantic
role labeling, and highlights the related semantic frames to predict
inconsistency. The highlighted semantic frames help verify predicted error
types and correct inconsistent summaries. Experiment results demonstrate that
our model outperforms strong baselines and provides evidence to support or
refute the summary. | [
0.0745918155,
-0.0139362775,
0.0041803513,
0.0477363132,
-0.0144867674,
0.0379495807,
-0.0488273539,
-0.0425778665,
-0.0392231122,
-0.0602276437,
0.0199311301,
0.0162343364,
0.0495844968,
0.0049038203,
-0.0074795512,
-0.0686805844,
0.0838310495,
0.0030864293,
0.0489762053,
-0.0017804796,
0.0482373573,
0.011357611,
-0.0106683429,
0.0260602403,
0.0099270167,
-0.015675297,
0.0160232261,
0.0035114733,
0.0475867577,
-0.0179241933,
0.0096302098,
0.0338800102,
-0.002244866,
0.0840476081,
0.0000017591,
-0.0529155172,
-0.0304515641,
0.0114883538,
-0.028675219,
0.0348384827,
0.0160142202,
-0.0180213805,
0.0043023047,
-0.0364685729,
0.0034952126,
-0.0084416773,
0.0045327013,
0.0724055022,
0.0879953876,
0.0345236138,
0.0079019638,
-0.0047660987,
-0.0308595765,
-0.0000081233,
-0.0138056129,
-0.0304977931,
0.0014302838,
0.0553100444,
-0.0300747398,
0.0281587988,
0.0003981922,
-0.0185581222,
-0.01816977,
-0.0057644839,
-0.03775746,
-0.0123723038,
-0.0614900403,
-0.0096976571,
0.0334888026,
0.0372118093,
0.0488238186,
-0.023069961,
0.0059870998,
-0.0002015573,
0.0270415284,
0.0213616714,
-0.0033695477,
0.0416584201,
-0.0426320285,
0.0113218771,
0.0390820988,
0.0246140957,
-0.0166937392,
0.0286473576,
-0.012592054,
0.038902618,
-0.0271323044,
-0.0271856654,
-0.0546286404,
0.017880505,
-0.0173942819,
-0.0358526558,
-0.0092348736,
-0.0015182551,
-0.0184599292,
-0.0265428573,
-0.078609772,
-0.0305203889,
0.0642575696,
-0.0230905209,
-0.0197125804,
-0.0318170711,
-0.0521083176,
0.0436565392,
-0.0094212582,
0.0359871425,
0.0599591397,
0.0171736758,
-0.0069958461,
-0.019908363,
-0.0322620459,
-0.0001770543,
-0.0328675434,
0.024127271,
-0.0454838313,
-0.0078801,
-0.028464932,
-0.0158833414,
-0.0614792891,
0.061431352,
-0.0421340689,
-0.0340283364,
0.0005670128,
-0.0133369006,
-0.0653764531,
0.027532557,
-0.0244308636,
0.0123287681,
0.0086612934,
-0.0260182507,
-0.0083837556,
-0.0001924229,
-0.0170669071,
0.0138290403,
-0.0239216518,
-0.0137154544,
-0.005102572,
0.0225708093,
-0.0462792926,
-0.0672666058,
-0.0474583618,
-0.0532521904,
-0.0535008833,
-0.0609874018,
-0.0291107576,
-0.0027672471,
-0.0003753719,
0.0034962245,
0.0053944979,
0.0121990992,
-0.052474916,
0.0357480831,
-0.0742020458,
-0.0217873696,
0.0440240093,
-0.002212066,
0.0237462483,
0.0380730145,
0.0090245232,
0.0091602327,
0.0727529228,
0.050535135,
-0.0352077149,
-0.0424762294,
-0.0215124171,
-0.0031221735,
0.0539599247,
-0.0130782984,
-0.0241650902,
-0.0063552964,
0.0189216603,
0.0389339887,
-0.0208804496,
-0.0181844402,
0.0327307507,
-0.00410651,
0.0116920378,
-0.0199612435,
0.0226516332,
0.0338983424,
0.0525792837,
0.0747136995,
-0.0334558114,
-0.000136099,
-0.0328330062,
0.038360443,
0.0439703502,
0.0387923904,
0.0055797547,
-0.0690043569,
-0.0226476565,
0.0089368522,
-0.0033279234,
-0.0450016782,
0.0299727228,
0.028669063,
-0.0229921415,
0.0409498662,
0.0328346714,
-0.0341578163,
0.0135824503,
0.004261428,
0.0151491771,
0.0490610972,
0.0253676772,
-0.0339962319,
-0.0297742821,
-0.0122056156,
0.0225029383,
0.0035257903,
0.0622949302,
-0.021166008,
-0.0263481233,
-0.022566922,
-0.0104000838,
-0.0133286165,
0.062404573,
-0.0398562476,
-0.0342980474,
-0.0223983563,
0.0430614054,
-0.0168503691,
-0.0721990764,
0.0139491241,
0.0556924455,
0.0177207869,
-0.039314393,
-0.0001891143,
0.0092958035,
0.0254907645,
-0.0365602635,
0.000196617,
0.0040166276,
0.0285707507,
0.0056405296,
-0.0019954341,
-0.000116376,
-0.0120689962,
0.017369993,
-0.0435086228,
-0.040144749,
-0.0126875481,
-0.0743756741,
-0.0305640344,
0.0012743279,
-0.0547019318,
-0.0710808113,
-0.0260231476,
0.0357428864,
-0.0023755932,
-0.0025035357,
-0.0193871334,
0.0431757607,
0.009016485,
0.0216924511,
0.0259244926,
-0.0215226244,
0.0232939851,
-0.0459783711,
-0.0130947828,
0.0267254263,
-0.0039621731,
0.0236378629,
0.0495234989,
-0.021079611,
-0.0123333428,
-0.0126277264,
-0.0492994003,
-0.0156775545,
-0.0215764586,
0.0153387683,
0.0795237198,
-0.0319690555,
0.0129098753,
-0.0041009653,
0.0412857458,
0.0056490796,
0.0133128297,
0.0037219792,
0.0555977747,
0.0135101797,
0.0441458933,
-0.0487700291,
0.0096511729,
-0.0193176623,
0.0540179908,
0.0487634093,
-0.0258599836,
-0.0864878893,
-0.0277084801,
-0.0199273471,
-0.0044601248,
0.0060674394,
-0.0071981675,
-0.0096459044,
0.0460704379,
-0.0131243216,
0.0256620217,
0.0458920971,
0.0732040927,
0.02425831,
-0.0261268783,
-0.0089744125,
-0.034542568,
-0.0011054102,
0.0292509608,
-0.0088810883,
-0.0363183059,
0.0501312464,
0.0308530834,
0.0064235493,
0.0309748277,
-0.0028776405,
0.0381839946,
-0.063788183,
-0.0052709845,
0.0108249951,
-0.0351080485,
0.0162734203,
0.0524007566,
-0.0417775884,
0.0359722078,
0.0622622073,
-0.0415161699,
0.0558991097,
-0.0558781698,
-0.0106264008,
-0.0335802808,
0.005795538,
0.0107755978,
0.0280551445,
0.0109768882,
0.0017691562,
-0.0413782299,
-0.0299801081,
0.093835555,
-0.0024685999,
0.0981987193,
-0.0692921877,
-0.0062916265,
-0.0029843017,
-0.0084844576,
-0.0002559885,
-0.0556266904,
-0.0213035177,
0.0058719032,
0.0073604789,
-0.0021132049,
-0.082603313,
-0.0046788887,
0.0140957097,
0.0291286726,
-0.0140439337,
-0.0152623914,
-0.0161536522,
0.0292433761,
0.0464386009,
0.0412781984,
0.072181873,
-0.0261807907,
0.0139031978,
0.0481541753,
-0.0658709109,
0.0114696901,
0.0039139539,
-0.0313180685,
-0.036244344,
-0.0751963854,
-0.0205945633,
-0.0378082618,
0.0661410838,
-0.0727016181,
0.0017784145,
0.0940983817,
0.0182956979,
0.0317249708,
-0.0025189233,
-0.0068924669,
-0.0106184436,
0.0003125448,
-0.0076043513,
-0.0534832329,
-0.0287219491,
0.0081425309,
0.029427385,
-0.0181262959,
-0.0270467643,
0.0268922765,
-0.0721554384,
0.0406228565,
0.0281095728,
-0.0438371897,
-0.0404830687,
-0.0064349067,
0.0434187092,
-0.0159584004,
0.0271741841,
0.0413795523,
-0.0375435948,
0.0158197936,
0.0055262176,
-0.0632314458,
-0.0334156752,
-0.0140003171,
-0.0207033996,
0.0195524208,
0.0494029894,
0.0070200195,
-0.0191307012,
0.049710311,
0.0100103198,
-0.039271351,
-0.0068428847,
0.0186203588,
0.102797389,
0.0059574367,
0.0180418212,
-0.0303204209,
0.0171967894,
0.0519988947,
-0.0388276502,
-0.0097390777,
0.0186857712,
-0.0002102749,
-0.0293404832,
-0.0180102121,
0.0439936444,
-0.0107700238,
0.055123046,
0.0224689152,
0.0529650412,
-0.058422178,
-0.0412663743,
-0.0005411725,
-0.0207233392,
0.0124806864,
0.0243486054,
-0.0125832036,
-0.0050591594,
-0.0709245726,
-0.0656626597,
-0.0210114513,
-0.05626183,
-0.0090905521,
-0.0126901092,
0.041808892,
-0.0123306829,
-0.0517802574,
-0.0317739807,
-0.000057507,
0.0158520788,
0.0138304587,
0.0132258134,
0.0374539904,
0.0061363485,
-0.0209941957,
0.0232449379,
-0.0404272936,
-0.0101887519,
0.0272658952,
0.0143848136,
0.0181191228,
0.0602133013,
-0.0179969128,
0.0082963919,
0.0385181159,
0.0820660591,
-0.0167043824,
0.0699297413,
0.0053157979,
-0.0218497291,
-0.027991157,
-0.0016987869,
-0.0601094887,
0.0165848769,
-0.0692879111,
0.0162143894,
-0.0288310926,
-0.0571398847,
0.0214234702,
0.0371304005,
0.0298826918,
0.0258288309,
0.0303590223,
-0.0298548657,
0.0027816407,
0.002682131,
-0.0524533466,
0.0035233852,
0.0205758438,
-0.0450250916,
-0.0178289823,
0.0127578527,
0.0422979295,
0.0027209588,
0.0252388809,
-0.0161170363,
-0.002861771,
-0.0273193941,
0.0377343856,
-0.0370300896,
-0.0148391984,
-0.0595866218,
-0.0300298054,
-0.0332227424,
0.0193089582,
0.0062838048,
0.0097283786,
0.0534943938,
-0.0164216124,
-0.0248022899,
0.000186597,
-0.074595876,
0.0237790346,
-0.0493920296,
0.0040687406,
0.0139392018,
-0.0432019867,
0.0847093761,
-0.0349826925,
-0.0104199229,
-0.0361075439,
0.01767423,
0.041293662,
0.0068574268,
-0.0080931727,
0.0388520099,
0.0150371091,
0.0079640867,
0.0627157018,
-0.0421230569,
0.0310878679,
0.0024776286,
-0.063640222,
-0.0228536092,
-0.0704664215,
-0.0919529349,
0.0365259536,
0.0043845316,
-0.0467911437,
-0.1011354029,
-0.0032169858,
0.0552368388,
0.0403819494,
0.0599798411,
0.0010251475,
-0.021598015,
0.0389695279,
0.0329717062,
-0.0010198464,
-0.0366386287,
-0.025719896,
-0.0167353656,
0.0178597514,
-0.0175064392,
-5.646821028e-33,
-0.0621943846,
-0.045919165,
-0.0605770536,
0.0077287056,
-0.0300521702,
0.0188212618,
-0.055548422,
-0.0420734882,
0.0116953393,
0.0873941034,
0.0549112,
0.0290039256,
0.016539149,
-0.0047099022,
-0.0103245787,
0.010698841,
0.0885908231,
0.0559775643,
-0.0152531546,
-0.0056544063,
0.0669865906,
-0.0454103164,
0.0451418459,
-0.0729330108,
0.0774453357,
-0.0274599642,
-0.0399393328,
-0.0017822632,
-0.0027690607,
0.041370865,
0.0333726369,
0.0327737369,
0.0299068876,
-0.0216783453,
-0.0534104593,
-0.0444987938,
-0.0888499692,
-0.05513376,
0.0353910998,
-0.0019847418,
-0.0215928536,
0.001571577,
0.0305469129,
-0.019858459,
0.0097197108,
-0.0448046215,
0.0588940382,
-0.0576552041,
0.0041327979,
-0.0226732548,
-0.0666586831,
0.0488371775,
-0.0202435665,
0.0211424772,
-0.0356885903,
0.017334085,
0.0212203283,
-0.0034818763,
-0.0301286951,
0.0029113777,
0.0294729192,
0.0179993249,
-0.0005621249,
-0.0083553484,
-0.0417145491,
0.0948954225,
-0.0262293555,
0.0190202631,
-0.0474215001,
0.0051835226,
-0.0326481238,
0.0172548778,
0.0236673374,
0.0811702535,
0.0653604716,
0.0383332819,
-0.0361183472,
0.030990107,
-0.0665931255,
0.0675347671,
0.0185070261,
-0.0340538509,
-0.0246182941,
-0.0009618161,
-0.0673141554,
0.0105102984,
-0.0203335304,
0.0115122572,
-0.0238506775,
-0.0195659921,
-0.023291355,
0.0478357375,
-0.0082215779,
-0.038050212,
0.0208963696,
-0.0238187127,
-0.0419188887,
-0.0146837551,
0.0051539768,
-0.009665858,
0.0117922435,
0.0046326504,
0.0262468792,
0.0184945483,
0.0230044257,
0.0210739542,
0.0846540704,
-0.0463989042,
-0.0263164993,
0.0381784886,
0.0296476297,
0.0055182502,
-0.0436415635,
-0.0416148007,
0.0169151369,
-0.0097343931,
-0.0283332281,
0.0300195199,
-0.0006283795,
0.0008682878,
0.0064627049,
0.0507558659,
-0.0007348175,
0.0344714783,
-0.0036844192,
0.0250974931,
-0.0034351295,
-0.0054342342,
0.0045623761,
-0.0122747729,
0.0392729715,
0.0206724796,
2.411e-7,
0.0426007919,
0.052952107,
0.055713959,
-0.0491066575,
-0.0028523074,
0.0439520404,
-0.0039025072,
0.0209415667,
-0.0194615386,
-0.0065529547,
0.0283614714,
0.037122786,
0.0399674773,
0.0574074909,
-0.0138253355,
0.0218467806,
-0.0578702986,
-0.0615915991,
-0.0243962556,
-0.0037482602,
0.0850989074,
0.0132213086,
0.0197333805,
0.0039432966,
0.0067956094,
-0.0552878864,
0.0294486582,
-0.0034703205,
-0.0089837229,
0.0243403781,
0.0483078472,
-0.0054575475,
0.0237224717,
0.0181532614,
-0.0212994795,
-0.0467169173,
0.0148624117,
0.001206305,
-0.0027230585,
0.067761533,
-0.0389191099,
-0.0058032712,
0.0416428857,
-0.0021856537,
0.0233025607,
-0.0784232393,
-0.0124796582,
-0.0510949716,
-0.0536221415,
0.0233868454,
-0.0047676829,
0.0230244342,
-0.0349482447,
0.0398565829,
-0.0230218042,
0.0220276378,
-0.0124568241,
-0.0461499318,
-0.0064143818,
0.045795761,
0.0154610546,
-0.0362622999,
0.0222804602,
-0.0104900422,
0.0166206118,
-0.0612959154,
0.0268628933,
2.149789757e-34,
0.0944095105,
-0.0002681843,
-0.0168831851,
-0.0458462909,
0.0612596162,
0.0015214171,
-0.0633977205,
0.0071714725,
-0.0203225762,
-0.0178612899,
0.0243537761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14546v1 | On the Transferability of Whisper-based Representations for "In-the-Wild" Cross-Task Downstream Speech Applications | 2023-05-23T22:02:55 | 2023-05-23T22:02:55 | Vamsikrishna Chemudupati, Marzieh Tahaei, Heitor Guimaraes, Arthur Pimentel, Anderson Avila, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Boxing Chen, Tiago Falk | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Large self-supervised pre-trained speech models have achieved remarkable
success across various speech-processing tasks. The self-supervised training of
these models leads to universal speech representations that can be used for
different downstream tasks, ranging from automatic speech recognition (ASR) to
speaker identification. Recently, Whisper, a transformer-based model was
proposed and trained on large amount of weakly supervised data for ASR; it
outperformed several state-of-the-art self-supervised models. Given the
superiority of Whisper for ASR, in this paper we explore the transferability of
the representation for four other speech tasks in SUPERB benchmark. Moreover,
we explore the robustness of Whisper representation for ``in the wild'' tasks
where speech is corrupted by environment noise and room reverberation.
Experimental results show Whisper achieves promising results across tasks and
environmental conditions, thus showing potential for cross-task real-world
deployment. | [
-0.0511134006,
0.0161227416,
0.0107288556,
0.0280739982,
-0.020133242,
-0.024506161,
0.0701065883,
-0.0247704703,
0.0191358272,
-0.0302154403,
-0.098931089,
0.0065223775,
-0.0076594558,
0.0020818971,
0.0478349216,
-0.0355774239,
0.0267108884,
-0.080439657,
-0.0200564098,
-0.0234102253,
-0.0022579525,
-0.0274067037,
-0.0378059708,
0.05775721,
-0.0191758871,
-0.0255068522,
-0.0002316656,
0.0010722135,
-0.0059983153,
0.0152017716,
-0.0006708743,
0.0127702747,
0.0541926771,
0.0155924167,
0.0000019559,
0.0078225676,
-0.0351109952,
0.0070462157,
-0.0663395301,
-0.0222559888,
0.0104273949,
0.0402909108,
-0.0254617352,
0.0172749422,
-0.0182631593,
-0.031231897,
0.007726544,
0.0684528425,
0.0533221625,
0.0420453921,
-0.0036865859,
-0.0265610535,
0.0372894704,
0.0006667375,
-0.0024978823,
-0.02796668,
-0.0209320784,
-0.046190396,
-0.0417617708,
-0.0268229861,
-0.0239147488,
0.055112768,
-0.0154232187,
-0.0267778859,
0.0213341862,
-0.0314613841,
-0.0508991592,
0.0017183751,
-0.0443576872,
0.0435470641,
-0.0454687513,
-0.0316964686,
0.0191956665,
0.0187477674,
-0.0147948368,
-0.0211582687,
-0.0346045196,
-0.0268960334,
0.0409597233,
-0.0120068816,
-0.0668360591,
0.0738240406,
0.02654198,
-0.0497270338,
-0.0071052471,
0.0197008029,
-0.0006103367,
-0.0075847893,
-0.0081824725,
-0.0360166654,
0.0205792133,
0.0158293527,
0.0566648133,
0.0042491695,
-0.0192124564,
-0.0395190343,
-0.0477947891,
-0.0612833574,
-0.0556125566,
-0.0155314151,
0.0403622352,
0.0315486789,
-0.0799890608,
0.0120041771,
-0.0461682342,
0.0560561679,
-0.0176015142,
0.0340277515,
-0.0071431766,
-0.0107214656,
-0.0188126899,
0.0189477243,
-0.0698414445,
0.0435836092,
-0.0314071178,
-0.0476108156,
-0.0374722928,
0.0215185266,
-0.0677698255,
-0.0171369426,
0.0456051901,
-0.0019871683,
-0.0581828915,
-0.0291044172,
0.0528899319,
0.0426958166,
0.0768186599,
0.0560319945,
0.023117274,
-0.0528543815,
-0.0254792012,
0.0224517174,
0.0558903627,
0.0079388507,
-0.0125419926,
0.1094035581,
0.0068866992,
-0.0240643527,
-0.0324257165,
0.0347942933,
-0.0225666929,
-0.035670083,
0.0039840466,
-0.0166915543,
0.0188799463,
-0.0087840063,
0.0221731756,
-0.0581505746,
-0.0044688433,
-0.0346544236,
0.0217163209,
0.0721284822,
0.0114074703,
0.0007567609,
0.0397712663,
0.0022160811,
-0.0442430489,
-0.0051954836,
0.0503008366,
0.0139204692,
0.0133272139,
-0.0741493702,
0.0149350083,
0.0409828573,
0.0224315431,
0.0003223914,
0.0038411682,
0.0041345125,
0.0331960768,
-0.0035098814,
0.0288449731,
0.030894978,
-0.0089130169,
-0.051694598,
0.08398173,
0.0515380576,
0.0697652623,
0.0191268064,
0.0479294732,
0.0287277326,
-0.0246284343,
-0.0144599332,
-0.023348337,
0.014965591,
-0.0312200654,
-0.0261295941,
0.0447477289,
0.0278473068,
-0.0486405492,
0.0008097794,
0.0352986567,
-0.0382843725,
-0.0159373414,
0.0347204581,
0.05041207,
0.0470107794,
-0.0493604094,
0.086063534,
0.0125127304,
-0.0703851059,
0.0138313463,
-0.0453455299,
0.0042261733,
0.0251090992,
-0.0197817069,
-0.0299198832,
0.0010771623,
-0.0541078784,
0.0032926959,
-0.0078253588,
-0.0312707014,
0.0315028057,
0.0720296055,
-0.014380699,
-0.0420095697,
0.0172673538,
-0.0104551362,
0.0431560948,
-0.0308848545,
0.0027070078,
0.0201188643,
-0.0382203981,
0.0121574337,
-0.0180379879,
-0.0015686351,
-0.0344352424,
0.0545812473,
0.0103601106,
0.0651520416,
0.0091603268,
-0.0099712647,
-0.0036541256,
0.040254496,
-0.0192011613,
0.0009574502,
0.0418714955,
-0.0866234079,
-0.0054076239,
0.0261435974,
-0.0043976489,
0.0349135883,
0.0686406419,
0.0200241767,
-0.0529628806,
0.0651846454,
-0.0202615466,
0.0510095544,
-0.0243167076,
0.0472028777,
0.039864216,
0.0356444716,
0.0463131219,
-0.0399050452,
0.0543089621,
-0.0175797623,
-0.0639725327,
0.0455138832,
0.0045333463,
-0.0578476861,
-0.032326635,
-0.0356253535,
-0.0533103049,
0.0298476368,
-0.022341188,
-0.0319026709,
-0.0107706646,
-0.0080305031,
-0.0415079966,
-0.0113670286,
-0.0362599716,
-0.0104853697,
-0.0110308118,
0.0202306788,
0.0135229994,
-0.0454902612,
-0.0171990152,
0.0176084079,
-0.0261063017,
-0.0046194931,
-0.0519808158,
-0.0186964739,
0.0036699637,
-0.0155019313,
0.0059161698,
0.0233748276,
0.0008321328,
-0.0320150889,
-0.0040945057,
-0.0463362597,
0.0414979346,
0.0606771223,
0.033044707,
-0.0000558391,
-0.0158842616,
-0.0037831706,
0.0078114243,
0.0735210851,
0.009755834,
0.0165238306,
-0.026482489,
0.0026702133,
-0.0308135021,
-0.0467486568,
-0.0020138195,
-0.0066337818,
0.0103665814,
-0.0200234558,
0.0499947481,
-0.0183694325,
0.0110175265,
0.0246509966,
0.0035274094,
-0.0210507978,
-0.0260092076,
-0.009004171,
-0.0405981503,
-0.0015626528,
-0.0237110686,
-0.0041726823,
-0.0077544115,
0.0115569839,
0.0027956141,
-0.0155319972,
-0.0940697938,
-0.0315923765,
0.0238863546,
-0.0739924461,
0.0037575183,
0.0044927821,
-0.0156336147,
0.0081481058,
0.0088096028,
-0.0371081494,
-0.0082458183,
0.0040698973,
0.0017944598,
-0.0415495522,
0.0226355679,
-0.0068957997,
-0.0059223557,
-0.0073799179,
-0.0429243967,
-0.0267627593,
-0.0306424871,
0.0229297113,
0.0125569617,
0.0231239386,
-0.0209668353,
-0.0456338972,
0.0870292559,
0.0111060822,
0.0619782321,
0.0021195207,
-0.0047280141,
-0.0254381113,
0.0347363949,
0.0235182792,
0.0477512926,
0.0339716189,
0.0467648208,
0.0386959687,
0.0146081578,
0.091814369,
-0.0113335438,
-0.0848608613,
0.008661448,
0.0285810046,
0.0009072417,
-0.0069476138,
0.0240476169,
0.0783065781,
-0.0458681062,
-0.0028037536,
0.0831655711,
-0.033371333,
-0.0358197242,
0.0047515985,
0.0063209157,
-0.0500083081,
0.0022563357,
-0.0160839595,
-0.0006661789,
-0.0067532784,
0.0398432277,
0.0389616862,
0.0359188877,
0.0062637315,
0.0135235991,
-0.0663387328,
0.0528164245,
0.0318339132,
-0.0131302811,
-0.0371415913,
-0.0257787816,
-0.0058813412,
-0.0595703572,
0.0846642628,
-0.0181689337,
-0.0364836343,
-0.0463858992,
0.0244743954,
-0.0655146763,
-0.0116462186,
0.0214440636,
-0.0336605012,
0.0644744039,
0.0339650698,
-0.0211267415,
0.0241829082,
-0.0129279131,
-0.0023784274,
0.0306389276,
0.017180521,
-0.0010006378,
0.0375723541,
0.0176240169,
-0.0294975024,
0.0200942308,
0.0143732922,
-0.0460433997,
-0.0132337436,
-0.0026803459,
0.0519878343,
-0.0254158061,
-0.0108499341,
0.0156695582,
0.0189264528,
0.0308474414,
0.05743251,
0.0035782703,
-0.0030391209,
-0.0012271744,
0.0283822883,
0.0358724184,
0.0220533144,
-0.0514380969,
-0.0171324443,
-0.0104210544,
-0.0450438261,
0.0001472227,
0.0114551391,
0.0099845184,
0.0446007885,
0.0200209301,
-0.0118835038,
0.0338927694,
0.0087707639,
-0.0347736813,
-0.0123158898,
-0.0204858948,
0.0153891258,
-0.025630435,
-0.0411017351,
0.0766966566,
-0.0285231546,
-0.009294657,
-0.0051637497,
-0.0624670908,
-0.0157706346,
0.0528241247,
0.0251522213,
0.011797077,
0.0449838527,
-0.0278512966,
-0.0047635669,
0.0815631598,
-0.0055947215,
-0.1206299961,
0.0176527705,
0.1013513505,
-0.0024228015,
-0.0072816471,
0.0383063816,
-0.0684276745,
0.052153483,
0.0294208359,
-0.0126524772,
-0.0079744561,
-0.0667943954,
0.000049882,
-0.0130210603,
0.0761427507,
0.0401633345,
0.0343359746,
-0.0191376749,
0.0460119024,
-0.025811404,
0.0485529043,
-0.0458864607,
-0.004062301,
0.0205184184,
0.0047546532,
0.004638514,
0.027827302,
-0.0354049951,
-0.0093457773,
-0.0625680983,
0.0352313817,
0.0117989564,
-0.013719921,
-0.0031045161,
0.0250056237,
0.0100439182,
0.032191325,
0.0881865323,
0.0005235587,
0.0146403387,
-0.0193162858,
-0.0194581877,
0.0273803659,
0.00242888,
0.0316969678,
-0.0666142628,
-0.0439128503,
-0.0219373554,
0.0262731928,
-0.009548354,
0.0030124313,
0.0396994874,
0.0143464301,
0.0268328525,
-0.025529135,
0.0394847877,
-0.0166726131,
0.0264288783,
-0.0052558552,
-0.0177361351,
-0.0122688264,
0.0409527868,
0.0311427917,
0.0022585846,
0.0253625754,
-0.0048340568,
0.0553365946,
-0.0484981574,
-0.0521197729,
-0.0155248735,
-0.0037962538,
-0.0039283289,
-0.0203556158,
0.0284971576,
-0.0635588169,
0.0396846682,
-0.0533007272,
0.0033106541,
-0.0180072691,
0.0126118446,
0.0000502184,
-0.0105711585,
-0.0054413453,
0.0117829042,
-0.0536907762,
0.0127794752,
0.0129875988,
0.0416977964,
-6.028477228e-33,
-0.0584781319,
0.0223322548,
0.0043229493,
0.028421551,
0.0069146845,
-0.0111898798,
-0.0406107455,
0.0183174927,
0.0348436013,
-0.0210867748,
-0.0324078128,
0.0218265429,
0.0391585715,
0.017761495,
-0.0036556355,
-0.0017475698,
0.129738465,
-0.0190388672,
0.02827112,
0.0175196435,
0.0386718549,
0.0555722229,
0.0248257872,
-0.0891364515,
-0.0632559136,
0.0087430682,
-0.027773343,
-0.062700808,
0.0315951556,
-0.0082849171,
0.0055571087,
0.0325700007,
-0.0378020145,
-0.0279351696,
-0.0572449714,
0.0259126127,
-0.0749674588,
0.0133989183,
-0.0654883608,
0.0436632559,
0.0035143215,
-0.0183884762,
0.0534319319,
0.0077156248,
-0.0470160916,
-0.0367482342,
0.0163822733,
-0.00576055,
0.0237521604,
-0.0492737964,
-0.0213445425,
-0.0000119979,
-0.0325424634,
-0.0423537828,
0.0785364956,
0.0377929397,
-0.0318805166,
-0.0390043408,
-0.108969979,
0.0346746221,
-0.0107194399,
0.0442463383,
0.0325420648,
0.0096496288,
0.0050332425,
0.0101786023,
0.0957778469,
-0.0438481756,
0.0412568972,
-0.0413979143,
0.0395794548,
0.0722884908,
0.0322505087,
-0.0074155899,
-0.0050678048,
-0.0212530326,
-0.0416180678,
-0.0028476247,
-0.009765218,
0.0158773158,
0.0224241465,
0.0606138892,
-0.027250303,
0.0103320079,
-0.0450647287,
-0.0445179455,
-0.004675685,
-0.0307223741,
0.0660444871,
-0.0008660309,
0.0061286013,
0.0261775963,
0.0582061373,
-0.0458421856,
0.0044168732,
-0.0242687929,
-0.0006173064,
-0.0257688388,
-0.0218022484,
0.0238805972,
-0.0130954636,
-0.0462322086,
0.0772183388,
0.0422793813,
0.0173141453,
-0.0295777544,
-0.0044313152,
0.0926001295,
-0.0636417791,
-0.0314331725,
0.0026475366,
0.012892087,
0.0181175321,
0.0120716579,
0.0416609347,
-0.0064263637,
-0.0156140253,
0.0267994199,
-0.04058595,
0.012664739,
0.0012149727,
0.0282726269,
0.0183140039,
0.0268583093,
-0.0527264588,
-0.007393003,
-0.0471035056,
-0.0131250657,
0.0416259319,
-0.0309943575,
0.000870301,
-0.0108997282,
2.761e-7,
-0.0546479262,
0.0006218361,
0.0178586021,
-0.04656763,
0.0153428838,
0.0169512387,
-0.0197936036,
0.0023950569,
-0.0094779935,
0.0206746291,
0.0028997289,
0.007202121,
0.0733404309,
0.0128823193,
-0.0678273514,
-0.0135675492,
-0.0692359507,
0.021678675,
0.0106366016,
0.0236047022,
-0.0059829317,
0.0746508986,
0.0009449609,
-0.0173212364,
0.0109983785,
-0.021737799,
0.0423974544,
-0.0279410612,
0.0035125099,
0.0201288741,
-0.0089327134,
0.0153586967,
-0.0267047994,
-0.001545581,
-0.0344406515,
0.0351780094,
0.016439518,
0.038650319,
-0.00764575,
-0.0916871727,
-0.0189883225,
0.0668988973,
0.0043591908,
0.0088817375,
0.0519350693,
-0.0688722581,
-0.024170801,
-0.0302853268,
-0.0506022908,
-0.0013516706,
-0.0150649892,
0.0115764411,
0.0422237664,
-0.0016443694,
0.0029379365,
0.021400569,
-0.027385205,
-0.0621531792,
0.030579865,
0.0038312555,
-0.0649693236,
-0.0072491495,
-0.0373800397,
-0.0095479563,
0.0284207687,
0.0182545148,
0.0017005323,
1.994473204e-34,
-0.0075579043,
0.0166947991,
0.0220674202,
0.0108025167,
-0.0473822244,
-0.036731869,
0.0252546407,
0.01583777,
-0.002314443,
-0.0371779501,
-0.06224408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14540v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14540v1 | LLMs as Factual Reasoners: Insights from Existing Benchmarks and Beyond | 2023-05-23T21:50:06 | 2023-05-23T21:50:06 | Philippe Laban, Wojciech Kryściński, Divyansh Agarwal, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Shafiq Joty, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the recent appearance of LLMs in practical settings, having methods that
can effectively detect factual inconsistencies is crucial to reduce the
propagation of misinformation and improve trust in model outputs. When testing
on existing factual consistency benchmarks, we find that a few large language
models (LLMs) perform competitively on classification benchmarks for factual
inconsistency detection compared to traditional non-LLM methods. However, a
closer analysis reveals that most LLMs fail on more complex formulations of the
task and exposes issues with existing evaluation benchmarks, affecting
evaluation precision. To address this, we propose a new protocol for
inconsistency detection benchmark creation and implement it in a 10-domain
benchmark called SummEdits. This new benchmark is 20 times more cost-effective
per sample than previous benchmarks and highly reproducible, as we estimate
inter-annotator agreement at about 0.9. Most LLMs struggle on SummEdits, with
performance close to random chance. The best-performing model, GPT-4, is still
8\% below estimated human performance, highlighting the gaps in LLMs' ability
to reason about facts and detect inconsistencies when they occur. | [
0.0350688659,
0.0313587077,
0.024963323,
0.0619514994,
-0.0405775271,
0.0221713688,
0.0190202873,
-0.0377535708,
-0.0417581163,
-0.0598315522,
-0.0031861113,
-0.0491261743,
0.0427488089,
-0.0313481838,
0.0128471749,
-0.0056372364,
0.0822156593,
-0.0067453627,
0.0161084756,
-0.0120179504,
0.0063056485,
0.0247768667,
-0.0313178822,
0.0229038205,
-0.0212372448,
-0.0329911001,
0.0046092081,
-0.022539705,
0.0399250798,
-0.0116817234,
0.0039371173,
0.0219964739,
0.026267048,
0.1129474118,
0.0000020425,
-0.0618571565,
-0.0108414609,
0.0249502361,
-0.0790359452,
0.0449664406,
-0.0214557424,
0.0130407326,
-0.0337586664,
0.0092581687,
-0.006816112,
0.0018389147,
0.0165235493,
0.0501782969,
0.0879725069,
0.0781294107,
0.0172249991,
-0.0314708017,
0.0150972866,
-0.0096387248,
-0.0138840331,
-0.0348929577,
0.0173314624,
0.0418781452,
-0.0383618027,
-0.0104665365,
0.0053721415,
0.0121211847,
0.0198745765,
-0.0277745742,
-0.0162961185,
0.0320591182,
-0.0440455638,
-0.0246319827,
0.0203700196,
0.0363150984,
0.035468284,
-0.03802564,
-0.000678963,
0.003126025,
-0.0116578219,
0.0063142194,
0.0116327582,
0.0490423962,
-0.0470809191,
0.0301130377,
0.0233694185,
-0.021617705,
0.0662252977,
0.0424897745,
-0.0094971331,
0.0928989798,
-0.0117366575,
-0.0358267277,
0.0025088654,
0.0276494175,
-0.0246071555,
-0.0930429026,
-0.0277260989,
0.0225854833,
-0.0543980524,
0.0124102468,
-0.0435375981,
0.0127783511,
0.0363256894,
-0.0555885658,
0.0082266666,
0.0301443581,
-0.0333907753,
0.0685344487,
-0.0085846446,
0.0667739809,
0.0061436677,
0.0548004694,
0.0328691751,
-0.0175520238,
-0.043843437,
0.0041143848,
0.0368984751,
0.0126965716,
-0.0021290581,
0.0296148676,
-0.0374821685,
0.0142318867,
-0.0410691425,
0.0515463874,
0.0034028948,
-0.0214296654,
0.0236307308,
-0.024571998,
-0.0852532834,
0.0276872776,
0.0093134232,
0.0260119811,
0.0204212368,
-0.0926523209,
-0.0167924836,
0.0204872638,
-0.0675794706,
0.0072762514,
-0.0039226012,
0.0022290309,
-0.0069924667,
-0.0144419093,
-0.0680056065,
-0.0235735644,
-0.0306705516,
-0.1099518985,
-0.0440029241,
-0.0653540716,
0.0079813479,
-0.024253495,
-0.0123018865,
-0.0442677438,
0.0031534515,
-0.0083163073,
-0.0086392257,
0.0697392374,
-0.0435998477,
0.007917867,
0.0516581163,
0.0108022243,
-0.0203648396,
0.0432975218,
0.0353527814,
-0.0352748185,
0.0439451449,
0.0376623422,
-0.0150913689,
-0.0323023982,
0.006921052,
0.0126195475,
0.0310178343,
-0.0114151109,
-0.0159183368,
0.0520420633,
0.0385625474,
0.056943249,
-0.009646018,
-0.0595541783,
0.0683622435,
0.003076287,
0.007496031,
-0.0020352777,
0.0468392484,
-0.0111498442,
0.0436897911,
0.0094687883,
-0.064158015,
0.0257464889,
-0.0102580376,
0.0095002055,
0.0681350306,
0.0342079625,
-0.0229914859,
-0.0766067505,
-0.0435458459,
0.0057941647,
-0.0386936404,
-0.0105841914,
0.022067301,
-0.041795928,
-0.0114267794,
0.060307879,
0.039116092,
-0.068379432,
-0.0134203788,
-0.0540842786,
0.0366883501,
0.0591988377,
0.030299034,
-0.0109116146,
-0.0351710059,
-0.0385276452,
0.0165278986,
0.0406945311,
0.0729369,
-0.0166074038,
0.024396034,
-0.0436750241,
-0.0288715567,
-0.0193606857,
0.0531492643,
0.0198713038,
0.0077424403,
-0.0067788605,
0.0072465595,
-0.0526295789,
-0.0170495287,
0.0420406051,
-0.0232586972,
0.0180000495,
-0.0179932527,
-0.0068352548,
0.0351583213,
0.0216856096,
-0.0425782427,
0.0044513647,
0.016595481,
0.0250111576,
-0.01495812,
-0.0129870139,
-0.0034297246,
-0.0105731562,
0.0907760784,
0.0051441831,
-0.0482694134,
0.0022534081,
-0.0603328198,
-0.0277078021,
-0.00175883,
-0.0404089652,
-0.0133145517,
-0.0605258048,
0.041904036,
-0.0137927355,
0.0121456543,
0.0055804495,
0.0494790897,
-0.0200786218,
-0.0112236449,
0.0052308766,
0.0172372404,
0.0298345014,
-0.0615683272,
0.0069810706,
0.0242635086,
0.0097508896,
0.0243212208,
-0.0038747441,
-0.0322042033,
-0.0183612499,
-0.0229582395,
-0.0475382134,
-0.0130725019,
-0.0302334949,
0.0335913226,
0.0100478102,
-0.0552773401,
0.0049576261,
0.0026645092,
0.0198455174,
-0.000303911,
0.0065240297,
0.0055819331,
0.0599211268,
-0.0141406264,
0.0013356293,
-0.0466007367,
0.0273034349,
-0.0280716661,
0.0358326472,
0.0207401887,
-0.0253046062,
-0.0829378366,
0.0043361126,
-0.0981241837,
0.0126344981,
0.0053086909,
-0.0104496963,
0.042610094,
0.0404269993,
-0.0022213124,
0.0422899164,
0.0144295618,
0.0260797907,
0.0747270733,
-0.0145488549,
-0.0506447777,
0.0175521821,
0.0090026706,
-0.0034163969,
-0.0271183867,
-0.0234656315,
0.0054055932,
0.0349241123,
-0.0037072212,
-0.0097760269,
-0.0268420875,
0.0031158417,
-0.0143137807,
-0.0133658508,
-0.0087168319,
-0.020020688,
-0.0109847458,
0.0742148831,
-0.0281290263,
-0.0275776237,
0.0772037879,
-0.0709086135,
0.0341890939,
-0.0334093757,
-0.0258562937,
-0.0201801118,
-0.0087581435,
-0.0532040447,
0.0024255144,
0.0067845751,
0.0176626798,
-0.0213032532,
-0.0251590498,
0.0705971643,
-0.033960823,
0.0804804936,
-0.0760658607,
0.0428810604,
0.0124925319,
-0.037766967,
-0.042061571,
-0.0484383106,
-0.0410857014,
-0.0129115805,
-0.0530351326,
-0.024313299,
-0.0535955206,
-0.0336096101,
0.0248613227,
0.0449406691,
0.0286437143,
-0.0192567464,
0.0072301477,
-0.0225079898,
-0.0087881526,
0.0480588228,
0.0901598111,
-0.018935902,
0.0318990685,
0.0530601926,
-0.0250482131,
0.0010249234,
-0.0370804816,
-0.0239222553,
-0.0283859875,
-0.0202517062,
-0.0402612574,
-0.0024112519,
0.0594843142,
-0.0579522662,
0.0005467265,
0.1361209303,
0.0224152487,
-0.0001607423,
-0.0353126675,
-0.0217977259,
0.0227283612,
0.0274000242,
-0.0153676495,
-0.0703804567,
-0.0357864536,
0.0284341779,
0.0334848426,
-0.0165639855,
-0.0263279658,
-0.0289151985,
-0.0967200249,
0.0412308946,
0.0117742801,
-0.0189720951,
-0.0136005431,
-0.0450832769,
0.009099951,
-0.0124603109,
0.0503336452,
0.0184125658,
0.0315142237,
-0.0085003143,
0.0301057659,
-0.0508919954,
-0.0746319592,
0.0407939851,
-0.0237073805,
0.0695511922,
0.0319819301,
0.0455861725,
0.019827839,
-0.0710516199,
0.0245564058,
0.0162001029,
-0.0274918526,
0.0055987984,
0.0520179532,
-0.0096778953,
-0.0058095586,
-0.0318945646,
-0.0208634678,
-0.0014245179,
-0.004817233,
-0.0411381572,
0.0799214318,
-0.0303575974,
-0.0071806125,
-0.0061808475,
0.0210253112,
-0.0361272208,
0.0732387304,
0.0128619373,
0.0373696499,
-0.0438879095,
-0.038747713,
-0.0090121264,
-0.006332194,
0.0031080374,
0.0285062697,
0.0010036514,
-0.0287344884,
-0.0619586743,
-0.028106004,
-0.0367626473,
0.0123510221,
-0.0409669243,
-0.0255537871,
0.0266263839,
-0.0022047106,
-0.0120786931,
0.0033883743,
-0.035103403,
0.0356644727,
-0.04229597,
0.0332930237,
0.0062228111,
-0.0114564532,
0.0046173814,
0.0125903767,
-0.0788811073,
-0.0884870365,
-0.0024812336,
0.0144522376,
0.0265510846,
0.0480698906,
-0.0262431502,
-0.0274058208,
0.0029536805,
0.0304569714,
-0.0033551883,
0.0556934252,
0.0426813364,
-0.0363555811,
-0.0163189508,
0.0233500823,
-0.0358313508,
-0.006991209,
-0.0051644985,
0.0140912132,
-0.0293012038,
-0.0422577672,
0.0335625187,
0.0194810741,
0.0549585931,
-0.01483355,
-0.0006829326,
-0.0159684867,
0.0133788949,
0.0032084661,
-0.0203119684,
0.0055415011,
0.0335835963,
-0.0133448672,
-0.0290342588,
-0.0099538006,
0.0033743342,
-0.0196371507,
0.0323626623,
0.0205618385,
-0.0314957872,
-0.0100849532,
0.0273578428,
-0.0216258056,
-0.0187431909,
-0.032166563,
-0.0068946867,
-0.0088890698,
0.0326478295,
0.0191522185,
0.0428909883,
0.0319697,
0.0061988453,
0.0146133546,
-0.021837987,
-0.0754377767,
-0.0344163589,
0.0008959391,
0.0137217855,
0.0850380138,
0.0249651447,
0.0744420141,
-0.0156403221,
-0.0060005886,
-0.0289040972,
0.008485429,
0.0166431256,
0.0077592693,
0.03145843,
0.0125789056,
-0.0179166757,
0.0158203151,
0.0545674413,
-0.0337051079,
0.056098327,
-0.0125579908,
-0.0379649922,
-0.014056595,
-0.0584202334,
-0.0856174603,
0.0073911878,
-0.0202155598,
-0.0218451526,
-0.0707003474,
-0.0483064018,
0.030914871,
0.0429123156,
0.0142171429,
-0.0151614603,
-0.0220257603,
0.0773781464,
-0.0076450254,
-0.0140897445,
-0.026963491,
-0.0255148225,
-0.0054208743,
0.0206585638,
-0.0135738142,
-6.364165354e-33,
-0.0414787754,
-0.0277254898,
0.0132046379,
-0.0127400728,
-0.0287938621,
0.0099979369,
-0.0291571803,
0.0008766261,
-0.0285254195,
0.0757089704,
0.0237422772,
0.051680129,
0.0236608665,
-0.0298442002,
-0.0006049572,
-0.0372350253,
0.0571911,
0.0297817439,
-0.0508597717,
-0.0183943007,
0.0735550374,
-0.0440850332,
0.0652489737,
-0.080670312,
0.0665810183,
0.0060548657,
-0.0381488465,
0.0526419878,
-0.0480235629,
0.0525543988,
0.0228866991,
0.0490860604,
0.0117771719,
-0.0243935343,
-0.0152790407,
-0.0560342334,
-0.0327020027,
-0.0294868033,
0.0397479497,
0.0004583397,
-0.0078786397,
-0.0270865858,
0.0185428523,
0.0192958936,
-0.0340599976,
-0.030394135,
0.0015753558,
-0.0248197354,
0.0014002799,
0.0303174909,
-0.0204292983,
0.0434354618,
-0.0062032687,
0.0008031336,
-0.0162108485,
-0.009002924,
-0.0040999311,
-0.0126002962,
-0.1096829847,
0.0003023143,
-0.0065730782,
-0.0015679977,
0.0836510584,
-0.0280485786,
-0.0476762354,
0.0909309313,
0.0033872782,
0.0228100382,
-0.0498103499,
0.004192892,
-0.0239985827,
0.0021670556,
0.0738303289,
0.0899111032,
0.0196500458,
0.0196682215,
-0.07682015,
0.0278578755,
0.0109113762,
0.0318334587,
0.027237419,
0.00911335,
-0.0303991549,
-0.0036852944,
-0.0434142314,
0.0324854255,
-0.0191505346,
-0.0062872516,
0.0181196984,
0.0040374245,
0.0325058252,
-0.0118948631,
-0.0015272718,
-0.0268026665,
-0.0080457218,
0.0056579369,
-0.0113895535,
-0.0180758834,
0.0124243554,
-0.0017613462,
-0.0403933562,
0.0284285266,
0.0140778888,
0.0372067951,
0.0137676178,
-0.0037157263,
0.0449321754,
-0.0023199855,
-0.0413110442,
0.0214260034,
-0.0290409829,
0.0079140989,
-0.0354526863,
-0.0188094489,
0.0111920033,
-0.0078418609,
-0.0282273255,
0.0401817784,
-0.0160427317,
0.0234576594,
-0.0147525212,
0.0153435655,
-0.0068110926,
0.0371733457,
0.0080227507,
0.0166244321,
-0.0287859533,
0.0118283238,
0.0154622151,
-0.0259037204,
0.0071207727,
0.0100456541,
2.689e-7,
0.0184090659,
0.0450006053,
0.0197721124,
-0.0281383097,
0.0148121668,
0.04572694,
-0.038593404,
-0.0181025323,
-0.016265031,
-0.050531365,
-0.0343852118,
0.0433751196,
0.0746210366,
0.0643292516,
-0.0059769219,
-0.005530735,
-0.0856207088,
-0.0434760116,
-0.0342618451,
-0.0185022503,
0.0494796298,
0.0488057435,
0.0626537278,
-0.0246603712,
0.0235889051,
-0.0081990594,
0.0498898737,
0.0176585335,
-0.0246867836,
0.0115833515,
0.0983774811,
-0.003981634,
0.0417909436,
0.0233155489,
-0.011297198,
-0.0083992127,
-0.0238177329,
0.0301219206,
-0.013076487,
0.006043674,
-0.0626926273,
-0.0241742674,
0.0167257749,
-0.0314377993,
0.0453982837,
0.0002151634,
-0.0206431374,
-0.023065621,
-0.0080264211,
0.000771077,
0.0496400893,
0.0132288178,
-0.0107675483,
0.0219288655,
-0.0160585232,
0.0000330149,
-0.0085411798,
-0.0578242876,
-0.023433445,
0.0141592016,
-0.0269433092,
-0.0701963678,
0.010564263,
0.0078976294,
0.0663789138,
-0.0507705845,
-0.0017804381,
2.143616804e-34,
0.0430649742,
-0.0031335317,
0.0198990405,
-0.0017327437,
0.0594982691,
0.0250946488,
-0.0419771597,
-0.0231686588,
-0.0012522532,
0.00233787,
0.0300999507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14538v1 | Cascaded Beam Search: Plug-and-Play Terminology-Forcing For Neural Machine Translation | 2023-05-23T21:48:02 | 2023-05-23T21:48:02 | Frédéric Odermatt, Béni Egressy, Roger Wattenhofer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a plug-and-play approach for translation with terminology
constraints. Terminology constraints are an important aspect of many modern
translation pipelines. In both specialized domains and newly emerging domains
(such as the COVID-19 pandemic), accurate translation of technical terms is
crucial. Recent approaches often train models to copy terminologies from the
input into the output sentence by feeding the target terminology along with the
input. But this requires expensive training whenever the underlying language
model is changed or the system should specialize to a new domain. We propose
Cascade Beam Search, a plug-and-play terminology-forcing approach that requires
no training. Cascade Beam Search has two parts: 1) logit manipulation to
increase the probability of target terminologies and 2) a cascading beam setup
based on grid beam search, where beams are grouped by the number of
terminologies they contain. We evaluate the performance of our approach by
competing against the top submissions of the WMT21 terminology translation
task. Our plug-and-play approach performs on par with the winning submissions
without using a domain-specific language model and with no additional training. | [
0.0472218394,
0.0234899279,
0.0040067625,
-0.0018687251,
-0.0415827632,
-0.0138327982,
0.0270968843,
0.0095696896,
-0.0342744365,
0.011806028,
-0.040942423,
-0.05169205,
-0.0017975499,
0.0507196039,
0.0390111245,
-0.059635438,
0.0627087951,
0.0030957912,
-0.097201854,
0.0114073055,
-0.0361442529,
0.0127880825,
-0.017656751,
0.0257064831,
-0.0298289917,
0.0067476556,
0.0126894535,
0.0474986024,
0.007451694,
-0.0111603858,
0.0562161542,
-0.0091559673,
0.0440426841,
0.0682274178,
0.0000022438,
-0.0365453735,
-0.0502311699,
0.0116618536,
0.0132029774,
0.0123186922,
0.0549485274,
-0.0553318821,
0.0202556252,
0.0240904242,
-0.0356412828,
-0.0286048669,
0.0658499002,
0.0134662865,
0.0595416278,
0.0719389915,
-0.0064577037,
-0.0451831892,
0.0119811902,
-0.0681344569,
0.0088236127,
-0.084850505,
-0.0373306982,
-0.0187782347,
0.0036138494,
0.055699233,
0.0103419954,
0.0984274,
-0.0020596988,
-0.0094748391,
0.0532225408,
0.0153265717,
0.0153215341,
-0.0342294909,
-0.0080669904,
0.0528807044,
0.0082709137,
-0.0033891161,
-0.0039265328,
-0.0265204851,
-0.0154622896,
-0.0026344827,
-0.0371135734,
0.0005709824,
-0.0010472659,
-0.0279549658,
0.015720902,
0.0267081857,
0.0389955975,
-0.0055057039,
-0.0326363891,
0.0407709181,
0.0288465284,
-0.0539340414,
-0.0279535484,
-0.0287884604,
0.0118579827,
-0.0141715901,
0.0476260707,
0.0052601341,
-0.0367173776,
0.051112473,
-0.033873722,
0.021925509,
0.0165667962,
-0.0653991401,
-0.0198457129,
0.036788106,
0.0425911546,
0.0406023711,
-0.0050152065,
0.0208123904,
-0.0539306775,
0.0105896611,
-0.1022144929,
-0.0319888294,
-0.068638511,
-0.0028719965,
-0.0706686452,
-0.0241070855,
-0.0272157546,
-0.0104382802,
-0.0442686677,
-0.0162987523,
0.0020809653,
-0.02606708,
0.0126133403,
-0.0074396785,
-0.0835775435,
0.0071867579,
0.0159025453,
0.0394755267,
0.002411495,
-0.0478441603,
0.0179063771,
-0.0231840983,
-0.0412316695,
0.0309081674,
-0.0585197955,
-0.0397357009,
-0.0138469376,
0.083545655,
-0.0042438181,
-0.033179272,
0.0195513479,
-0.0197929461,
-0.0306509398,
0.0187531579,
0.0379039496,
-0.0346808881,
0.0612527803,
0.0054747146,
-0.005599279,
-0.0264002457,
0.0131068919,
-0.0071333223,
-0.0497680046,
0.0641885847,
-0.0135477511,
-0.0273013078,
0.0710517988,
0.0320782103,
-0.0142327948,
0.019198807,
0.0153122395,
0.0562579408,
0.0136236018,
0.0124243395,
-0.0083870431,
0.0432498008,
-0.0035523172,
0.0126983104,
-0.0437572747,
-0.0021079862,
0.0286504831,
0.0561348312,
0.0299113654,
0.0119419647,
-0.0188314263,
0.0345921181,
0.0209393669,
0.0471092947,
0.0609793998,
0.0214685574,
0.0356333889,
-0.0140000451,
-0.0426173359,
-0.0164384544,
0.0056976923,
0.0198119953,
-0.0107424567,
-0.025613362,
0.039792195,
0.0005553715,
-0.007305095,
-0.0198105983,
0.0009307942,
0.0436120667,
-0.0161165558,
-0.0325870886,
0.0315989517,
0.0067234831,
-0.0419338122,
0.0992853791,
0.0074723791,
-0.0266230963,
0.0220176391,
-0.0557927117,
-0.0997627974,
0.0428653024,
0.0869457126,
-0.0208343361,
-0.1117912307,
0.0036154592,
-0.0103043905,
0.0864042565,
0.0753786415,
0.0163943488,
-0.0252311304,
-0.0435690358,
-0.0236061998,
-0.0035510566,
0.0144500183,
0.022218978,
0.019086238,
0.0187641494,
0.0307456013,
0.011183843,
-0.0759117529,
0.0443620011,
-0.0307617243,
-0.0414072052,
0.0141559727,
-0.0131551828,
0.0231464729,
-0.0083465818,
-0.0290588178,
0.0112569733,
0.0055174101,
-0.0453107655,
-0.0495375618,
0.014496481,
-0.0447885469,
0.0160964765,
0.0168671459,
-0.0319439806,
0.0094150752,
-0.0308152139,
-0.0575095788,
-0.0025502793,
0.0072984728,
-0.0321669169,
-0.000761568,
-0.0199552607,
0.0144881457,
0.0156040117,
0.0097052045,
-0.0478635989,
0.0379195921,
0.0024198832,
0.0008370403,
-0.0332529843,
-0.0098828208,
0.0122290105,
-0.0055865603,
-0.016734479,
0.0313707702,
0.0151620619,
0.0291734748,
0.0253784247,
0.0051279059,
0.0168866124,
-0.0221113041,
-0.033886794,
0.0324847512,
0.0116024408,
0.003052982,
0.0447285883,
0.054532975,
0.0068893568,
-0.0015316507,
-0.0033236481,
0.042729035,
-0.0072407401,
0.0142962821,
0.0133293159,
0.0251977481,
-0.0006035983,
-0.0286253691,
-0.0260615945,
-0.015733948,
0.0099960892,
0.0253140684,
-0.0544201583,
-0.0854987428,
0.0685150474,
-0.0300778989,
-0.0095804473,
-0.0059226817,
-0.0529394597,
0.0000945703,
-0.0210654549,
-0.0130980192,
0.0398678742,
0.0228117891,
-0.0022821203,
0.0544336066,
0.0005939087,
-0.0534909889,
0.0222525075,
-0.019540675,
-0.043154683,
0.0247922093,
-0.0388468467,
0.0805115774,
0.035825856,
-0.0050758892,
0.0098990109,
-0.0305929463,
-0.0309360269,
0.0002654431,
-0.0406345129,
-0.0367133841,
0.0205731913,
-0.0133540891,
0.0088857263,
-0.0038268811,
-0.0089193666,
0.0573347658,
-0.0065045594,
0.0276663974,
-0.0790258646,
-0.0400681831,
-0.0221777894,
0.013200203,
-0.0417829715,
0.0277062971,
0.0131576844,
-0.0084280269,
-0.0337208658,
-0.0002938403,
0.0095185526,
-0.0118831834,
0.0283609591,
-0.0299745798,
0.0142940572,
-0.0345776938,
-0.003192855,
-0.0476606898,
0.020488603,
0.0467501245,
0.0232089479,
0.0491702855,
-0.0410024486,
-0.0541676991,
0.0270261448,
0.0273855478,
0.1030886322,
0.0068514082,
-0.0160990302,
-0.0211578887,
0.0301472191,
0.0063427617,
-0.0105394693,
0.0095443055,
-0.0343972631,
-0.0196674764,
-0.001250498,
-0.0127650388,
-0.0353158265,
-0.0331090279,
-0.0380479097,
0.0580481291,
-0.0493366569,
-0.0602745749,
-0.0285828691,
0.0287055969,
-0.0685961992,
-0.0049665081,
0.0803863853,
0.0383280851,
-0.0404665433,
-0.0006591802,
-0.0157396402,
0.0078685544,
0.0132719101,
0.0666056648,
-0.0740830526,
-0.0104049882,
0.008987342,
0.0475491434,
0.0447073393,
0.0127021857,
-0.0346479304,
-0.0505154245,
0.0475635193,
0.0397778861,
0.0067309248,
-0.0114806229,
-0.0076275878,
-0.0246633403,
-0.0210110899,
0.0147787314,
-0.005070332,
0.0190390907,
-0.0188314747,
-0.0127261523,
0.0309366547,
-0.0617426112,
0.0203730762,
-0.0511402003,
0.0445727631,
0.0626534894,
0.0159292258,
-0.0047056028,
-0.022553293,
0.0427002646,
-0.0115247564,
0.0322194621,
-0.0181436129,
0.0070546446,
0.0174225345,
-0.0157928392,
0.0253927484,
-0.0466142744,
-0.0086069265,
0.0074287429,
0.0164660513,
0.0685895532,
-0.0193153322,
0.0377456211,
-0.0340583175,
0.0083878292,
0.0119535625,
0.058449015,
0.0056749596,
-0.0131925102,
0.0019357555,
-0.0380517133,
-0.0125780292,
-0.0460974351,
-0.0482695587,
-0.0200272165,
-0.0754637271,
-0.0596089475,
-0.08732903,
-0.013747599,
0.0106834928,
0.0497840047,
0.0077796523,
-0.0176732186,
-0.0180941932,
0.0032703078,
-0.034326598,
0.0537424199,
-0.0130552361,
-0.0059610358,
-0.0573210046,
0.0100425221,
0.0597122274,
-0.0087441849,
-0.0278252661,
0.0978038758,
0.0114495307,
-0.069110468,
-0.0112275556,
0.0436788909,
0.0249576047,
0.0313440077,
-0.0561017953,
0.0028569261,
0.0246689077,
0.0792333856,
0.0116729988,
-0.0026652394,
0.0226501562,
-0.0191294774,
-0.045588728,
0.0095159346,
-0.0392890126,
0.0089102574,
-0.0057891281,
0.0874643922,
-0.026606245,
-0.0186839327,
0.0526045747,
-0.0144357048,
0.0285993926,
-0.0429315716,
-0.076048471,
-0.0334825702,
0.0106547289,
0.0459337868,
-0.0107559701,
-0.0274207033,
0.000772484,
0.0412671342,
-0.0121700382,
0.0225746538,
0.0543414615,
-0.0210585464,
-0.0108944327,
-0.0155283939,
-0.0183084495,
-0.050344348,
0.0555361025,
-0.001698703,
0.0065270038,
0.0019086227,
0.0131883463,
0.000241904,
0.0067009879,
-0.0532699749,
0.0159465447,
0.0264372099,
0.0369827524,
-0.0303103607,
0.0440106131,
-0.0650433376,
-0.0334104151,
-0.0437066257,
0.0174308196,
0.0753931925,
0.0358098671,
0.0356343165,
-0.0334237628,
-0.035943415,
-0.0055045336,
-0.010523011,
-0.0067816009,
0.0001434883,
-0.0143924179,
0.0214903466,
0.0148184644,
-0.0175217167,
0.0603050441,
-0.0117145712,
0.0508172736,
0.0066574644,
0.0077375718,
-0.0013662254,
-0.0403443612,
0.0539451167,
-0.02645473,
-0.0251269471,
0.0047059292,
-0.0504972525,
-0.0364038125,
0.0233194958,
0.0144300628,
-0.034957476,
0.0190289039,
0.0340675488,
0.0793434158,
-0.016394088,
-0.0143935615,
-0.0236102547,
0.0124682365,
0.0212314501,
-0.0405007228,
-0.0298416577,
-7.11754703e-33,
-0.0427655093,
-0.0029049704,
0.0251764506,
0.020874735,
-0.0444559976,
-0.0059198518,
-0.0136618447,
-0.0425993837,
-0.0094508119,
-0.0018091176,
-0.0147875994,
0.0243737958,
0.0150361294,
-0.0150374426,
0.0274755806,
0.0278793611,
0.0575627685,
0.0106034502,
-0.0190990716,
0.0350613445,
0.0389674269,
0.0419819728,
0.077502124,
-0.0595345609,
0.0442949161,
0.0014165585,
-0.0142348185,
0.0192936845,
-0.0033405372,
0.0007589133,
-0.0053294129,
0.01678982,
0.0139028411,
-0.0717878342,
-0.0145901265,
-0.0281457324,
-0.0629219636,
-0.0088123903,
0.0057464088,
-0.0028288143,
-0.0046363692,
-0.0885234028,
0.058228191,
-0.0275514014,
-0.0341946483,
-0.0006616506,
0.0063000885,
-0.0401767418,
-0.0294357091,
-0.0092469184,
-0.064117752,
0.0079507949,
0.0223173499,
-0.0184116811,
-0.0170719996,
0.0436238199,
-0.012133305,
0.0016802176,
-0.0721841902,
0.0412915424,
0.0168903358,
0.1056586653,
0.0711393058,
0.018305866,
-0.0100626685,
0.0282328855,
0.0218311772,
-0.0426695012,
0.0432468615,
-0.0562146753,
0.025622895,
-0.0049086581,
0.0452988409,
0.0210077334,
0.0890696123,
-0.0061544478,
-0.0568206273,
0.0344619416,
-0.0249860231,
0.0601370372,
-0.0009404517,
0.0285712276,
-0.0306653548,
0.0071745776,
-0.0004360909,
-0.0099544693,
-0.0458124578,
-0.0604872592,
0.0193150621,
0.0518611893,
-0.0074033695,
0.0051636449,
0.037375357,
0.005680827,
0.0550093018,
0.0052001043,
0.0500742942,
-0.0134870075,
-0.0164721254,
0.0594321899,
0.0138133634,
-0.0451387167,
-0.0030746451,
0.0172952078,
0.0112449089,
0.0045282594,
-0.0008737905,
0.046172224,
-0.0145789208,
0.0028659669,
-0.0352571532,
-0.03990357,
-0.0471523628,
0.0276440103,
0.0095306961,
0.0176951364,
0.0109465588,
0.0133775938,
0.0398656353,
-0.005621681,
-0.0232955758,
0.0018616839,
0.0058489251,
0.0549869537,
-0.0460736342,
0.051539842,
-0.0387159809,
0.0102006197,
0.004486423,
-0.057351388,
-0.0431063101,
-0.0113104172,
3.136e-7,
0.0472731069,
0.0979195759,
-0.0119109759,
0.0551804937,
-0.0218924377,
-0.0065121748,
-0.0380499177,
0.0337383188,
-0.0247282684,
-0.0006707615,
0.0141649377,
0.011295747,
0.035112083,
0.022960566,
-0.1057348326,
-0.0115689356,
-0.0279201269,
0.040143583,
-0.0420019776,
-0.0341220014,
0.0701941326,
0.0837883428,
-0.0062116985,
-0.0057249633,
-0.0462647974,
-0.0325351432,
0.0473466851,
0.0127735082,
-0.0386741534,
0.0401500128,
0.0211754777,
0.0443571247,
-0.0529219881,
0.0065076719,
-0.051615525,
-0.0005834686,
0.0245862305,
0.0763859451,
-0.0016848498,
-0.0353942439,
-0.0021682316,
-0.0062398068,
0.0106839724,
-0.0172640216,
-0.0131457783,
-0.0633800849,
0.0188447423,
0.0181948654,
-0.0213702042,
0.0594774038,
0.0203445945,
-0.0492469296,
-0.046102535,
-0.0172764789,
0.0137968371,
0.0283245426,
-0.0449308977,
-0.0523775928,
0.0258524269,
0.0169573482,
-0.0235624202,
-0.0341291241,
-0.0285280589,
0.004006661,
0.0292016305,
0.0001841734,
-0.0044392445,
3.150401543e-34,
0.0577119589,
0.0022210618,
-0.0114191705,
0.0086019188,
0.0159410555,
-0.0012254001,
-0.0744650215,
0.0366263352,
0.0300753545,
-0.0549971163,
-0.0340782516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14536v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14536v2 | MathDial: A Dialogue Tutoring Dataset with Rich Pedagogical Properties Grounded in Math Reasoning Problems | 2023-05-23T21:44:56 | 2023-10-23T12:00:01 | Jakub Macina, Nico Daheim, Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Tanmay Sinha, Manu Kapur, Iryna Gurevych, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL | While automatic dialogue tutors hold great potential in making education
personalized and more accessible, research on such systems has been hampered by
a lack of sufficiently large and high-quality datasets. Collecting such
datasets remains challenging, as recording tutoring sessions raises privacy
concerns and crowdsourcing leads to insufficient data quality. To address this,
we propose a framework to generate such dialogues by pairing human teachers
with a Large Language Model (LLM) prompted to represent common student errors.
We describe how we use this framework to collect MathDial, a dataset of 3k
one-to-one teacher-student tutoring dialogues grounded in multi-step math
reasoning problems. While models like GPT-3 are good problem solvers, they fail
at tutoring because they generate factually incorrect feedback or are prone to
revealing solutions to students too early. To overcome this, we let teachers
provide learning opportunities to students by guiding them using various
scaffolding questions according to a taxonomy of teacher moves. We demonstrate
MathDial and its extensive annotations can be used to finetune models to be
more effective tutors (and not just solvers). We confirm this by automatic and
human evaluation, notably in an interactive setting that measures the trade-off
between student solving success and telling solutions. The dataset is released
publicly. | [
0.0048617679,
0.0568554997,
-0.0226335414,
0.0469796769,
-0.0276356749,
0.0076159975,
0.0358718038,
-0.0564201213,
-0.0247800201,
-0.0218693931,
0.0027340229,
0.0220519267,
0.0115150567,
0.005588783,
0.033878725,
-0.0923222378,
-0.0289864503,
-0.032597851,
0.0161381289,
0.0153280906,
0.0015617571,
0.0043077599,
-0.0691536069,
0.0389436521,
-0.0308913663,
-0.0562361889,
-0.0301643983,
-0.0524562001,
0.013134581,
0.0020177206,
0.0126780802,
0.0751713365,
-0.004832156,
0.0115187382,
0.0000020988,
-0.0358972363,
0.0005301725,
-0.0211664829,
-0.0561376661,
0.0037224879,
-0.0258009415,
0.0481246971,
0.0193431303,
0.0141379898,
-0.0712218508,
0.0385892764,
0.0208301097,
-0.0084136073,
0.1164180189,
0.0480084717,
0.0327485576,
-0.0055921213,
0.0234522987,
0.0088385846,
0.0644764602,
-0.0637616664,
0.0093126539,
0.0624855235,
0.0281801075,
0.0132292882,
-0.0540536717,
0.0251531564,
0.0479229093,
-0.0558666177,
-0.0076720351,
-0.0336610936,
-0.0459236205,
-0.001564236,
-0.0062112757,
0.1098648906,
0.0521927662,
-0.0167322978,
-0.0096421689,
-0.0004712678,
0.050599061,
0.0509263277,
-0.066779837,
0.0145717692,
-0.0289792921,
-0.0057756966,
-0.0397972651,
-0.0358427614,
-0.0117144883,
0.0099500632,
0.0327515975,
0.0255866386,
-0.0304211266,
-0.0149042178,
-0.047545068,
0.0314668044,
-0.027891282,
-0.0340779871,
0.0402097106,
0.0416545644,
-0.0092832306,
0.0209199991,
-0.0487620197,
-0.047103066,
-0.0188712478,
0.023875637,
0.0311315078,
0.0718123615,
0.0031490009,
0.0257091653,
0.0338266753,
0.053150475,
0.0152748125,
0.0289719682,
-0.0214358661,
0.0209708624,
-0.0380107947,
0.0079201544,
-0.0537619665,
0.0253382288,
0.0185840428,
0.0405488051,
-0.0205083601,
-0.000236911,
-0.0644426122,
0.0597523972,
-0.0233887229,
-0.0093030939,
-0.0151620908,
-0.0314370766,
-0.0282252226,
0.01739184,
-0.0395843983,
0.0203286614,
0.0440056361,
-0.0572330989,
-0.0299280565,
-0.0034664443,
-0.0143250879,
0.0072980714,
-0.0100325486,
0.037370611,
-0.009447109,
0.0113860453,
-0.0008380932,
-0.0524745248,
0.0461956672,
-0.0218242053,
-0.0181302056,
-0.0747893751,
0.0541159548,
0.0088576414,
-0.0180987045,
-0.0457816049,
0.0196575075,
0.0191492662,
0.0322064012,
0.0663680732,
-0.0129421661,
-0.0050495793,
0.059984453,
0.029530758,
-0.0742124543,
0.0423449017,
0.0564085394,
-0.0291438904,
0.0351913646,
-0.036097303,
0.0645078346,
0.0070985188,
0.0522928014,
0.0193064455,
0.0319703631,
0.0304229446,
0.0166645441,
0.0366116203,
-0.0416129567,
0.0101132458,
-0.0334397778,
-0.0255236197,
0.0095579578,
0.0654186979,
-0.0684136972,
0.0338682942,
0.0010180637,
0.0258294158,
0.0520911328,
-0.0124085043,
-0.0672698095,
0.0175275765,
-0.0335375033,
-0.0346567556,
0.0382664539,
-0.030222619,
-0.0082970802,
-0.0798931196,
-0.0017271925,
0.01735189,
-0.0191335157,
0.0327043645,
0.034135025,
-0.0054911259,
0.0121031879,
0.0733879209,
-0.0048231855,
-0.0438958518,
-0.0123178679,
-0.0580301173,
0.062958464,
0.0106051182,
0.0617086515,
-0.0544730313,
-0.0495324582,
-0.0307761692,
0.0674429387,
-0.0175468978,
0.0209322292,
-0.0183656029,
-0.0011826332,
-0.0257818792,
-0.011940565,
-0.024601493,
0.0121538192,
-0.0109898131,
0.0579838157,
-0.0107827755,
0.0180954952,
-0.0260720849,
0.0059065889,
0.0117030395,
-0.049558688,
-0.0582318492,
-0.0047172843,
0.0058187754,
-0.0164206494,
0.0231982954,
0.0218337085,
0.017010076,
0.0046742731,
0.0148820207,
0.0005543532,
-0.0092369346,
-0.0641328618,
-0.039904166,
0.0449202061,
-0.0645082965,
-0.0163424425,
-0.0104631847,
-0.0523968637,
-0.011485287,
0.0506142043,
-0.0265252274,
0.0040577375,
0.0122420052,
0.0133885164,
0.0007625095,
-0.0447743163,
0.022122113,
0.0234447718,
0.034742903,
0.0282397531,
0.0088404985,
0.0166372824,
0.0214772113,
-0.0426987335,
0.0424404927,
-0.0317405723,
-0.0177154467,
0.0358231775,
-0.0203270894,
0.0035684737,
-0.0676542819,
0.0174846277,
-0.0129154306,
0.0023712215,
0.0096557988,
0.0435871333,
0.0120421695,
-0.0359610841,
-0.0102564786,
-0.0419484936,
-0.0640815571,
-0.0213608835,
0.0074125775,
-0.0322734192,
0.0270865615,
0.0392736271,
-0.0071017453,
-0.0549242049,
-0.0245834403,
-0.0366323367,
0.0177021604,
0.0406706892,
0.0525803752,
-0.0418461487,
0.0212116446,
-0.0205109529,
0.010609,
-0.0221386999,
0.0035925414,
0.0189656336,
-0.0300266854,
0.0026047714,
0.0578296632,
-0.0081461258,
0.0694326609,
-0.0186562948,
-0.0483182073,
-0.0661371499,
0.0092464052,
0.0068066004,
-0.0214630421,
0.0006042126,
-0.0363065526,
-0.024518678,
0.0337100886,
-0.0162363034,
-0.0241740402,
-0.0366750807,
0.0787755474,
0.0181958545,
0.0295881405,
-0.0574736856,
-0.0204299837,
0.0251837466,
0.0387369022,
-0.0122229056,
-0.0271242838,
0.0898208767,
0.0168262534,
-0.0282580536,
-0.0274953507,
0.0053062746,
-0.0388627425,
0.0187978353,
-0.0102753583,
-0.0164706185,
-0.0599298738,
-0.0034224966,
-0.0013986689,
-0.0314788036,
0.0831587538,
-0.0593064018,
0.042349495,
-0.076640524,
-0.0246914066,
-0.0033119267,
-0.0336834639,
-0.0317025334,
0.008737877,
-0.023542935,
-0.010463628,
0.0057048453,
-0.0360089578,
-0.0245257579,
-0.0529673025,
0.0100279702,
0.0015850698,
-0.0332227945,
-0.0374042802,
0.0017800727,
-0.0134078544,
-0.0106588947,
0.0103157545,
0.0161647312,
-0.0491418242,
0.0886762142,
0.0489417948,
0.0796505064,
-0.0108118486,
0.0184791964,
-0.0025335951,
0.017647652,
0.0070596845,
-0.0096192556,
0.0300075747,
0.034107022,
-0.1081088111,
-0.0076219612,
0.079168044,
0.0308836251,
-0.0315232687,
-0.022927219,
-0.0565474927,
-0.0090921829,
-0.0025140364,
0.011488921,
-0.1319656968,
-0.0290410835,
-0.0084773134,
0.0343979783,
0.0014527772,
-0.0407313146,
-0.0027917405,
-0.1027920544,
0.0270239841,
0.0450712107,
-0.0116607351,
-0.0077322824,
-0.0407002382,
-0.0136486106,
-0.0098202266,
0.0030322841,
-0.0053771543,
0.0066910768,
0.046034053,
0.0398537032,
-0.004518908,
-0.0251656547,
-0.0114953173,
-0.0012460878,
0.0067266817,
0.0059460769,
0.0159962978,
-0.0046728738,
-0.0753161386,
-0.0041144923,
0.08274398,
-0.068081066,
0.0160079598,
0.0420240872,
-0.006084824,
-0.0206408855,
-0.0247957911,
0.101912111,
-0.072580941,
-0.0386076309,
0.0760518312,
0.0744998381,
-0.0049080369,
0.0450519174,
-0.009506356,
0.0244109426,
0.0284673069,
0.0504190251,
0.0343624838,
-0.0102344397,
0.0207323749,
-0.0756500065,
0.0051028975,
-0.0510468036,
-0.015399619,
0.0188240353,
0.038125053,
0.0398259349,
-0.0118325567,
-0.0328345932,
0.083986491,
0.0268499907,
0.0011132993,
-0.0384211168,
0.0075691496,
0.0278698672,
0.001417482,
0.0602300577,
-0.0128270853,
0.0251349472,
-0.077457577,
-0.0083953394,
-0.0242149383,
-0.0178245921,
-0.0293604005,
0.0469549298,
-0.1075010672,
-0.0448313095,
-0.0319085456,
0.0346532539,
0.0167237855,
0.0128472112,
0.0298400484,
-0.0010851186,
-0.0287046637,
0.0075973617,
-0.0079860622,
-0.0346135944,
0.0253804531,
0.033748392,
0.0188978165,
0.0088638812,
-0.0078503918,
-0.0355189517,
-0.0251300242,
0.0002272388,
-0.0525903888,
-0.0263244119,
0.0312137753,
0.0042372029,
0.0122843673,
0.0450253934,
0.0061691389,
-0.0112516666,
0.039624963,
-0.0464307554,
-0.03373193,
-0.0524490885,
0.0163508393,
0.014465441,
-0.060015142,
0.0269031432,
-0.0015771718,
-0.0005167657,
0.055768922,
-0.0029286842,
0.0706692189,
0.0115483971,
-0.011945853,
0.043343544,
-0.0257586595,
0.0189886242,
-0.0014646382,
0.0309126526,
0.0576987676,
0.0239281096,
0.0971816927,
0.0358381458,
0.0240676962,
0.043840792,
-0.0112912571,
-0.0086712381,
-0.1294035017,
-0.0176027119,
0.0499448441,
-0.0093309814,
0.0195949394,
-0.020756172,
-0.0289816521,
-0.0040861918,
0.0137495939,
0.0399588346,
-0.0001414376,
-0.0234083366,
0.0205069315,
0.0269546434,
0.0424438864,
-0.0195443761,
0.0353445709,
-0.0337301418,
0.0271092094,
-0.0049442248,
-0.0101574371,
-0.0096445931,
-0.0047906502,
0.0271699838,
0.0121817309,
0.0396202654,
-0.0022176518,
-0.0442258492,
-0.0514922142,
-0.0603594333,
0.0297322553,
-0.0277550444,
-0.0083748354,
0.0466412157,
0.0418494307,
-0.031532079,
-0.00536511,
-0.0179761201,
0.0598997846,
-0.0464264303,
-0.046841234,
-0.0091858217,
-5.182734022e-33,
-0.0479511432,
-0.0565361194,
0.0219262335,
0.0763885826,
0.0363746434,
-0.0400972068,
-0.0131817693,
0.051822722,
-0.0068403361,
0.0362611972,
0.0101041626,
0.0460424721,
-0.0113817146,
0.0298275631,
0.0056286254,
0.0005445615,
0.0040398147,
-0.0261399131,
-0.0156002026,
0.0396033116,
0.0050991047,
-0.0213483106,
0.0396538861,
-0.0618313812,
0.0535604618,
-0.0286265668,
-0.0055987425,
0.0368658341,
-0.0472047478,
0.0372541063,
0.0108680809,
0.0374232084,
-0.0110041564,
-0.0193639733,
-0.0156974718,
0.0190540608,
-0.0126598338,
-0.0554015711,
-0.0027686839,
0.019218022,
-0.0746975541,
-0.0250337478,
-0.0043824576,
-0.0032177297,
-0.0207186434,
-0.0246942192,
0.0489258431,
-0.0229928326,
0.0150587969,
0.0318804607,
-0.0017321302,
0.0150027983,
-0.0899744257,
-0.0924889073,
0.0044756425,
0.0582737327,
0.0078694075,
-0.0404156446,
-0.0245595612,
0.0510183871,
0.0780250356,
-0.0044745468,
0.0326026902,
-0.016320115,
-0.0087081455,
0.0077419304,
0.0299769994,
-0.0103164492,
-0.0102938972,
-0.0264217164,
-0.0145548386,
0.0702844486,
0.0802698061,
0.0240189396,
0.0155402208,
0.0256640799,
-0.0235772114,
0.0320556387,
0.012785119,
-0.014734596,
-0.0200194791,
-0.02644624,
-0.0609910563,
-0.0065915463,
-0.0712984279,
-0.0192705542,
-0.0090918643,
-0.0105326101,
0.0211239643,
-0.029077325,
-0.0017294181,
0.0169446561,
-0.0080193933,
-0.0240646377,
-0.032733582,
0.0233750548,
0.0037408848,
-0.0064526494,
-0.0149534913,
0.0076324432,
-0.0272682309,
-0.0078666918,
0.0020781716,
-0.0071611721,
0.0396365412,
0.0158365425,
0.020194592,
0.0006746593,
-0.0346305035,
-0.0095603503,
-0.0523981266,
0.0149402237,
0.0334044434,
0.0038233155,
0.0201224834,
0.0248453096,
-0.0244070105,
0.0821280554,
-0.0018135536,
-0.0221832469,
-0.0207718089,
-0.0023653125,
-0.0284327511,
-0.0446330532,
-0.0157479607,
-0.0483220667,
-0.0270162839,
-0.0235889405,
0.0231074803,
-0.0271678939,
0.0110864192,
-0.02724481,
2.631e-7,
0.0098643685,
0.0123471236,
0.0444948226,
0.0050708307,
0.0039159032,
0.0551900379,
-0.0227564536,
-0.0153408209,
0.0369523689,
-0.0284608975,
-0.0066995891,
0.0441317745,
0.0484904721,
0.0582924709,
-0.0391952917,
-0.0026863595,
-0.0202077068,
-0.016744595,
-0.0539871901,
0.0239493363,
0.0867729932,
0.0179478563,
0.0489911772,
0.022793062,
-0.0068579875,
-0.0196485575,
0.0218187738,
-0.0298576206,
-0.0211138297,
0.0339443237,
0.0206170063,
-0.0276021995,
0.0187122244,
-0.0000096665,
-0.0179934818,
0.0055652922,
-0.0083240755,
0.042851638,
0.0326784886,
-0.012792578,
-0.0352904983,
-0.0181649867,
-0.0017070395,
-0.0092143752,
-0.0040984843,
-0.0370484106,
-0.0182039905,
0.0506200902,
-0.0090458449,
-0.0563273132,
0.0144700818,
-0.0132982852,
0.0228505731,
-0.0133663053,
0.0135217356,
-0.0280208569,
0.0375056155,
-0.0067434683,
-0.0098259868,
0.0053959005,
-0.0450743809,
-0.0143185081,
-0.0277023669,
-0.0137619395,
-0.0082308445,
0.0139199542,
0.0108533092,
1.912409808e-34,
0.0076331976,
-0.0106877582,
0.0643743798,
0.0433773547,
0.0410914272,
-0.0057344488,
-0.0114736371,
0.0239458103,
0.0687849745,
-0.0132113108,
-0.0276645944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14534v2 | Detecting Propaganda Techniques in Code-Switched Social Media Text | 2023-05-23T21:37:26 | 2024-03-15T18:26:48 | Muhammad Umar Salman, Asif Hanif, Shady Shehata, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Propaganda is a form of communication intended to influence the opinions and
the mindset of the public to promote a particular agenda. With the rise of
social media, propaganda has spread rapidly, leading to the need for automatic
propaganda detection systems. Most work on propaganda detection has focused on
high-resource languages, such as English, and little effort has been made to
detect propaganda for low-resource languages. Yet, it is common to find a mix
of multiple languages in social media communication, a phenomenon known as
code-switching. Code-switching combines different languages within the same
text, which poses a challenge for automatic systems. With this in mind, here we
propose the novel task of detecting propaganda techniques in code-switched
text. To support this task, we create a corpus of 1,030 texts code-switching
between English and Roman Urdu, annotated with 20 propaganda techniques, which
we make publicly available. We perform a number of experiments contrasting
different experimental setups, and we find that it is important to model the
multilinguality directly (rather than using translation) as well as to use the
right fine-tuning strategy. The code and the dataset are publicly available at
https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/propaganda-codeswitched-text | [
0.0398006849,
0.0467242971,
-0.0305325482,
0.033674825,
-0.0379411466,
0.0286842193,
0.004027802,
0.0236577243,
0.0324106701,
-0.0207383651,
-0.004674912,
0.0026004463,
0.0369831324,
-0.0082803676,
0.0339596495,
-0.0047815167,
0.0338201858,
0.0323843211,
0.0114755686,
-0.0188872758,
0.0536101311,
0.0664251745,
0.0075232526,
0.0222559497,
-0.0374837033,
-0.0344116986,
0.0452603959,
0.0049407706,
0.0385844633,
-0.0050007533,
0.0429056771,
0.0351023227,
-0.0015283682,
0.0503451414,
0.0000016301,
0.001533641,
-0.0310689043,
-0.0198733751,
0.0192592107,
0.0144270789,
0.1146157086,
-0.0583735555,
-0.0223175902,
0.010727644,
-0.0490369201,
0.0441470258,
0.068602927,
0.0159178898,
0.0641299263,
0.1184168607,
-0.0081850579,
-0.0428982861,
-0.0324039124,
0.014403576,
-0.0186069123,
0.0098919375,
0.0490436442,
-0.0545072816,
-0.0201437995,
0.0236791298,
-0.0184732322,
0.0395031385,
-0.0180539489,
-0.0012593354,
-0.0900615156,
-0.06663315,
-0.0108225374,
-0.0225900803,
0.01378462,
0.0119529059,
-0.094106108,
-0.0738173276,
0.0506480932,
-0.0175064038,
-0.00897469,
-0.0059621339,
0.0079779737,
0.0318066664,
-0.0235655475,
0.0255640019,
0.057073582,
0.003153356,
0.0413949192,
0.0024684425,
-0.0297263414,
0.0091476208,
-0.0220939834,
-0.0322552696,
0.0283067133,
-0.0128594544,
0.0059937057,
-0.0355585627,
0.0162995141,
-0.00123908,
0.0098165367,
0.0277807377,
-0.0425877124,
-0.1111670882,
0.0261357315,
-0.0982439443,
-0.0216299072,
0.0195442606,
-0.0116425874,
-0.002288691,
-0.0175914932,
-0.0172506813,
-0.0068603489,
0.0069086547,
0.0223784726,
0.0191507768,
-0.0140405968,
0.0117549449,
-0.0347875059,
-0.0234235618,
0.0368073545,
0.0300647933,
-0.0587896667,
-0.0101258522,
-0.0411946401,
0.0211175419,
-0.028455846,
-0.0256049111,
0.0153864762,
0.0070452825,
0.0650842562,
0.0509806648,
-0.0241585337,
-0.0077564539,
-0.0558676757,
-0.0278106257,
0.0164703671,
0.061332278,
-0.032021217,
-0.0199807175,
-0.0009578924,
0.026551798,
-0.0042830748,
0.0202717334,
-0.0348840356,
-0.0156217488,
-0.026706595,
-0.0495205186,
0.002461056,
-0.0554229915,
-0.0045970841,
0.0254515633,
0.0145247113,
-0.0680280924,
0.0079703154,
0.0308177285,
-0.0558144264,
0.0647622645,
0.0366942696,
-0.010131456,
0.0417140983,
0.0402858667,
0.0091037313,
0.1038674414,
0.0073998966,
0.0675575063,
0.0715659037,
-0.0093354713,
0.0281877778,
0.0661642477,
0.0299845375,
0.0238936115,
0.0061475672,
-0.0126534048,
-0.00134609,
-0.0199599918,
-0.0124702435,
0.015899742,
-0.0064609093,
-0.0400209501,
0.0069903582,
-0.0117864301,
-0.013349738,
-0.0126533117,
0.0579520836,
0.0401891656,
0.0163022,
0.0332495086,
-0.0048458464,
-0.0260963663,
-0.0059791165,
-0.0673072785,
0.0106520122,
0.0531571582,
-0.0058497619,
0.0013897242,
-0.0015499633,
-0.0202460233,
0.0658114627,
-0.0550347716,
0.0181682874,
0.0283243507,
-0.0372541808,
-0.0041006301,
0.0483184159,
0.0177085139,
0.0293354001,
-0.0391222872,
-0.00712759,
0.0420290157,
0.0246870536,
-0.0186691601,
0.0922483429,
-0.0378562324,
0.0401466042,
0.0430299602,
0.0189978629,
-0.017570518,
-0.0515579395,
0.0156722926,
0.0010200896,
-0.0344707966,
0.0069461656,
0.0177904163,
0.0550387427,
0.0641327426,
-0.0205163844,
0.0337045453,
-0.0465636589,
-0.0029502122,
0.04249385,
0.0140404506,
-0.0257257577,
0.0301255919,
0.0281687733,
0.0070786886,
-0.0279623643,
-0.0366048217,
0.0046788058,
-0.0211498141,
-0.0186491925,
0.0144839408,
0.0252267402,
-0.0268389769,
-0.0253537558,
-0.0748122036,
-0.0640667528,
0.0471134409,
-0.0150397485,
0.0193647649,
0.1032117531,
-0.0446374267,
0.0524635501,
-0.0154269384,
0.006685575,
-0.0327493995,
0.0170934498,
0.004241846,
0.0289388262,
-0.0019815895,
-0.002972268,
0.0070688464,
-0.055957295,
0.0259461906,
0.0447334498,
0.0212164428,
-0.0045142923,
-0.0145886634,
0.0125846611,
0.0232039243,
-0.0081085879,
0.00703655,
-0.0344188102,
-0.0399406962,
-0.0474903733,
-0.0440928228,
0.0200547334,
0.0391326398,
0.0125642596,
0.0025675318,
0.0311248954,
-0.044627443,
0.0010624228,
-0.0230823308,
0.0333524048,
0.0238058474,
-0.0341748148,
0.003643563,
0.0020244427,
0.0460381024,
-0.0313455425,
0.0377882421,
0.0191538744,
-0.0597320497,
-0.0361095816,
-0.0200565495,
-0.0085795578,
-0.0070632636,
-0.0335938632,
-0.0666491166,
0.0261690952,
0.0190873351,
0.0056783408,
0.0317704156,
0.0220203605,
0.0231396556,
0.0255553722,
0.0302058496,
-0.0451720096,
-0.0412622839,
-0.0227216035,
0.0026156446,
-0.022447411,
-0.060309004,
0.0297335684,
0.0214141794,
0.0490947179,
0.0135973757,
-0.0414732248,
-0.0092887701,
-0.0518836938,
-0.0154605554,
0.0230942573,
-0.0184414014,
-0.0013962754,
0.0238712318,
0.0015263165,
-0.0218970217,
0.0364997759,
0.0044753854,
0.035968896,
-0.032142777,
-0.0243684109,
-0.0035780761,
-0.0325494483,
-0.0069057918,
0.0594150499,
0.027227506,
-0.0190602411,
-0.0024371082,
-0.0114129474,
0.010266386,
-0.0088346759,
-0.0260365698,
-0.0066456203,
0.0082806386,
0.0288868882,
-0.0277025122,
-0.0201843716,
-0.0964382067,
-0.0062481309,
-0.0588121191,
0.0397525951,
-0.0501522683,
-0.00251632,
-0.0112404609,
0.0177130494,
-0.0063692052,
-0.0070934505,
0.0172473174,
0.0089460732,
0.0010742494,
-0.0092164353,
-0.1003965139,
-0.0003202699,
-0.0043666488,
-0.06409356,
0.0501648486,
-0.0497642569,
0.0267133676,
-0.0082968669,
-0.0250493474,
0.0061413995,
-0.0107656149,
-0.0020288387,
-0.0454623252,
0.0020136214,
-0.0151399253,
0.0318316109,
0.035835892,
0.0268518757,
-0.0541253798,
0.0045713894,
0.0036959341,
-0.0012987158,
0.000823081,
0.0005138107,
-0.1225319058,
0.0005875249,
-0.0048563932,
0.0231102146,
-0.0567524321,
0.0109319389,
-0.0170455817,
-0.0607875325,
-0.0125146657,
0.0281153191,
-0.0033845091,
-0.0391999893,
-0.0528559834,
-0.0171809271,
-0.0132912407,
-0.0537429489,
-0.0591505282,
0.008735694,
-0.0066739256,
-0.0169367343,
-0.0266777258,
-0.0155662317,
-0.0195499565,
0.0127802743,
0.0090476526,
0.0477977097,
0.0382452533,
-0.0243400112,
-0.0169601962,
0.024378268,
-0.0113884844,
-0.0358269289,
-0.0454050563,
0.0668636709,
-0.0368580446,
-0.0411927551,
0.0241301805,
0.030309733,
0.0000245694,
0.0118103223,
0.0247352719,
0.026984185,
0.0298873652,
-0.0688336045,
0.0011546799,
0.0351338834,
0.0670824274,
0.0380740538,
0.0199974086,
-0.0588927455,
0.0018704679,
-0.0713389218,
-0.0022840847,
-0.0561082214,
-0.0706229657,
-0.0257810913,
-0.0180924572,
-0.0482784323,
-0.0574816577,
0.0014160962,
-0.0130582331,
0.0025069469,
0.0320691615,
-0.0035364856,
-0.0152303912,
-0.0129615599,
-0.0287711676,
-0.048535753,
-0.0100553725,
0.0557000153,
-0.0127612082,
-0.0418336391,
-0.0223668721,
-0.0251635741,
0.0188222639,
-0.0030277828,
-0.083317101,
-0.0645674169,
0.022041956,
-0.0029965213,
0.008847761,
0.0349802785,
-0.0252092034,
-0.0203938577,
0.0265336335,
0.0327563137,
-0.0309039932,
0.0196914971,
0.0463232696,
0.0282679144,
0.0116072921,
0.0359872766,
0.0118787671,
0.0013276843,
0.0431279279,
-0.0776517838,
-0.1111313999,
0.0422304533,
-0.0071840957,
-0.0103427544,
0.002480214,
-0.0393404253,
-0.0520666651,
-0.0301963426,
-0.025554236,
-0.0167028643,
-0.0510422699,
0.0131952073,
0.0031348001,
0.0314056762,
-0.0032607764,
-0.00137163,
0.0309084896,
-0.0317447558,
-0.0022289932,
0.0142624173,
0.057265386,
0.0358651653,
0.1067163125,
0.0139864143,
0.0037562284,
0.012352786,
0.0687458292,
0.0108207325,
0.029044522,
-0.0076994123,
-0.0041805338,
0.0160348732,
-0.0244701523,
0.085652031,
0.0261148755,
0.0203172825,
-0.0243239179,
0.0112328893,
0.0012439365,
0.0440685116,
0.0086355684,
0.0844569951,
0.0089125587,
-0.0150639787,
0.0095006293,
0.0078978762,
-0.0265805125,
-0.0182145052,
-0.0307476353,
-0.02497641,
-0.0332782492,
0.0183041114,
0.0290169287,
-0.0265660007,
0.0187089648,
0.0773015842,
-0.0509390309,
-0.0209572278,
0.0049575274,
0.046885699,
0.0315743834,
0.0277646948,
-0.0017000252,
-0.0426379144,
-0.0442403518,
-0.0009892872,
-0.0216986611,
0.0058648447,
0.002036863,
-0.0196514018,
0.074769482,
0.0088663455,
0.0658332631,
-0.0733660087,
0.0159134846,
0.0222219508,
-0.0616465285,
0.0075846254,
-5.692329924e-33,
0.0542043746,
-0.0403601415,
-0.0411649309,
0.0113196019,
0.0144633697,
-0.0315212607,
0.0074056955,
0.0007151684,
-0.027934093,
0.012679385,
0.0209507272,
0.022537861,
0.0013421244,
-0.033594247,
-0.0172870979,
0.014822349,
0.0258835778,
0.0085219545,
-0.0468733869,
0.0272657331,
0.081876494,
-0.0325680077,
0.0446168706,
-0.0762646794,
0.0568242222,
-0.0032921224,
-0.0613591857,
-0.0327988453,
0.0244973637,
0.0221761167,
0.0125631746,
0.0303192548,
0.0370392688,
0.002457221,
0.0081354184,
0.0756003559,
0.0114928195,
-0.0104842428,
0.0627507716,
0.0401532315,
0.0160476919,
-0.0354763642,
0.0290211122,
-0.0404429175,
-0.009500646,
0.0157588869,
0.031056229,
0.0053785061,
0.0657625347,
0.0124079557,
-0.0924131274,
0.0282610971,
-0.0412121788,
0.0127378972,
-0.0144331977,
0.0690505877,
0.0507153012,
0.0769835785,
-0.0759163648,
0.0416696779,
-0.0338571072,
0.0163592715,
0.0217152257,
-0.0464983732,
-0.0294328928,
0.0240364932,
-0.0027214494,
0.0179919694,
-0.0026511438,
0.0519329533,
0.0106713297,
-0.0014011553,
0.056753695,
0.0837044716,
0.0357954912,
-0.0799400434,
-0.0705730245,
-0.0126265083,
0.0584580116,
-0.0183721706,
-0.0046132822,
-0.0243006255,
-0.0339947082,
-0.0269760024,
-0.0025240949,
-0.0717051923,
-0.0158725847,
-0.0427738801,
-0.0116564743,
-0.0053576012,
-0.0331033245,
0.0560167357,
0.0184526648,
-0.0405062698,
-0.0028506094,
0.0374143757,
-0.043109268,
0.0296434928,
0.0124751981,
0.0687254369,
-0.0601254366,
-0.0074670305,
0.0157164913,
0.0155889448,
0.0545105152,
0.006480631,
0.0740983039,
0.0271817427,
-0.0612416752,
-0.0053566257,
0.0094950832,
0.0169969797,
-0.0333402753,
0.00382422,
0.0093898978,
0.0171754342,
-0.0041441964,
-0.0386062749,
0.0087312367,
-0.0008337973,
-0.0021669006,
-0.0422447622,
-0.0364615209,
0.0490162969,
-0.0389894769,
-0.0179479904,
-0.0377569348,
0.0434739701,
0.0264336597,
-0.1173835397,
0.0054569785,
-0.0296295397,
2.403e-7,
0.0428943522,
0.0465131402,
-0.0265363399,
0.0243340004,
0.0327178761,
0.0136431037,
0.0058006351,
0.0097019989,
-0.03411825,
-0.0421678647,
-0.0492423326,
0.0146865612,
0.0322687589,
0.0192664415,
-0.0718759522,
0.011644314,
0.0057380395,
0.0050824326,
-0.0645326301,
0.0100206826,
0.0057627833,
0.0751807839,
0.0312153753,
-0.0026138085,
-0.0162936747,
-0.0019191587,
0.0376943611,
0.0291661378,
-0.0173733775,
0.0055782828,
-0.0263147186,
-0.0316829197,
0.0015539916,
-0.024431413,
-0.0069107669,
-0.0171597619,
-0.0083957659,
0.0423103683,
0.0450490192,
0.0000029111,
-0.0191224199,
-0.0444862582,
-0.0258876923,
-0.0584533811,
0.0492618419,
0.0121221468,
-0.0066544153,
-0.0374702439,
0.0090963589,
0.0125369756,
0.019857049,
-0.0231661387,
-0.0470551252,
0.0099747945,
0.0231542513,
0.0281422473,
-0.008701738,
-0.0639604703,
0.0102938684,
-0.011103983,
-0.0171094891,
-0.0312483609,
0.0066676461,
0.0088282917,
0.019845238,
-0.0124092335,
0.0247617699,
1.854678571e-34,
0.0733165443,
-0.0579007715,
0.0023909202,
-0.038163472,
0.0395098366,
0.0036493938,
-0.0440144278,
-0.001157788,
0.0193646401,
0.0039914716,
0.0000798371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14533v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14533v1 | How to Choose How to Choose Your Chatbot: A Massively Multi-System MultiReference Data Set for Dialog Metric Evaluation | 2023-05-23T21:33:43 | 2023-05-23T21:33:43 | Huda Khayrallah, Zuhaib Akhtar, Edward Cohen, João Sedoc | cs.CL | cs.CL | We release MMSMR, a Massively Multi-System MultiReference dataset to enable
future work on metrics and evaluation for dialog. Automatic metrics for
dialogue evaluation should be robust proxies for human judgments; however, the
verification of robustness is currently far from satisfactory. To quantify the
robustness correlation and understand what is necessary in a test set, we
create and release an 8-reference dialog dataset by extending single-reference
evaluation sets and introduce this new language learning conversation dataset.
We then train 1750 systems and evaluate them on our novel test set and the
DailyDialog dataset. We release the novel test set, and model hyper parameters,
inference outputs, and metric scores for each system on a variety of datasets. | [
0.0527954213,
0.068993412,
-0.018249182,
0.0098156342,
-0.0270660017,
0.0289734118,
0.0296048317,
-0.0173765346,
0.0526458137,
-0.0345633626,
-0.0791572109,
-0.0291541182,
0.0002885482,
0.0492431782,
0.0283778552,
-0.0726202428,
0.0531062335,
-0.0148790497,
0.0078650601,
0.0238140859,
0.0087053711,
0.0230388157,
-0.0439132378,
0.0688335672,
-0.0472846143,
-0.0247293413,
-0.0113029256,
0.0142795742,
0.0233023074,
-0.0255707745,
-0.0070890579,
0.0424081683,
-0.0021236462,
0.0449487008,
0.0000016781,
-0.0428173654,
0.0338202566,
-0.0312841311,
-0.0556849428,
-0.0374922082,
0.0384915136,
0.0143492082,
0.0163549706,
0.0301818904,
-0.0371149071,
-0.0205079578,
0.0349966176,
0.039543815,
0.0721924603,
0.0838748217,
-0.0088260742,
-0.0003536993,
-0.0158367194,
-0.0130094634,
-0.0351591334,
-0.0916956067,
-0.0177323148,
0.0604832023,
0.0132885817,
0.0005428547,
0.0153601123,
-0.0045612324,
0.0180301704,
-0.0580890998,
0.0025404186,
-0.0039187009,
-0.0498548225,
-0.0440639704,
-0.0064991834,
0.1194875166,
0.0339454599,
0.0312141739,
-0.010516908,
0.006609269,
0.0062202159,
-0.0539898239,
-0.0362890922,
-0.0151971392,
0.0139012421,
-0.0200183801,
-0.0650331005,
0.0045871818,
0.0107270153,
0.0229773279,
0.0095347604,
0.0206078272,
-0.0006163013,
-0.0055190311,
0.0164777786,
0.0080419146,
-0.0036248136,
-0.0633135363,
-0.0008238657,
0.0104614692,
-0.0922561437,
0.0163263865,
-0.0484314822,
-0.0026124977,
0.0185393468,
-0.0562982038,
-0.0256189723,
0.0223270897,
-0.0063776798,
0.0747366101,
0.0138180386,
0.0773155168,
0.0005901586,
0.0101237148,
-0.0176431295,
-0.0290831812,
-0.0669204667,
0.0234917384,
-0.0272275507,
0.0381659269,
-0.0261158925,
-0.0344233438,
-0.0703160986,
0.0565444306,
-0.0173479468,
0.0066939183,
0.0090631433,
0.0198964383,
-0.0344352685,
-0.0029174972,
-0.0510118976,
0.0315098912,
-0.0568091944,
0.0249310639,
0.031946633,
-0.0666995123,
-0.0177075416,
0.0587793812,
0.001241,
-0.0196730271,
-0.0127964262,
0.1237447783,
0.0017428343,
-0.0280471407,
0.0120237386,
-0.0181603152,
-0.0424312986,
-0.079116188,
-0.0245448966,
-0.0076656342,
0.0320221521,
-0.0048861257,
-0.0020349962,
-0.017985696,
0.0036497919,
0.0005906749,
0.0120041585,
0.0368799195,
0.0477464087,
-0.0236355197,
-0.0006599468,
0.0066764746,
-0.0597968437,
0.0710612535,
0.0295982976,
0.0359228179,
0.0684277862,
0.0006644653,
0.018285444,
0.0236325767,
-0.0094126938,
0.0052020247,
0.0070356373,
0.0523847826,
0.0021247899,
0.0405140333,
-0.005713759,
0.0528914481,
-0.0615665838,
-0.0490458384,
0.0697706044,
0.0237190463,
0.0010046202,
0.012549297,
0.0216996856,
-0.0050248783,
0.0212706085,
-0.0084433639,
-0.0310458988,
0.0374968946,
-0.0153498575,
-0.0162258446,
0.0467212945,
0.0125095677,
-0.0358811095,
-0.055202242,
0.0191332921,
-0.0155929886,
-0.0191460438,
0.0173259769,
0.0434370674,
-0.016287839,
-0.0426896848,
0.0210697986,
-0.0142210852,
-0.0480182916,
-0.0306103136,
-0.0481334887,
0.0323406085,
0.0343167111,
0.0587166212,
-0.0219903402,
-0.0193432868,
-0.0355956145,
0.0167689156,
0.0433527082,
0.0534855127,
-0.0408349186,
0.0760806128,
-0.0554585867,
-0.0078365067,
0.0092040142,
-0.006347972,
0.028601801,
0.004279423,
-0.0034378672,
0.0063158148,
0.0124126133,
0.0113498205,
-0.0067152898,
0.0113825183,
0.003111585,
0.0261237305,
-0.0110820951,
0.0717835128,
0.0165093858,
-0.0214356948,
-0.0169719551,
0.0112284692,
0.0181269236,
-0.0017904103,
0.0288907662,
-0.0480962321,
-0.0594645143,
0.0328399688,
-0.0261602066,
-0.0493304953,
0.0492203645,
-0.0315827988,
-0.0379885472,
0.0157748442,
-0.044892624,
0.0093585607,
-0.0278598703,
0.0209913477,
-0.0087470505,
0.0130605679,
-0.0055084997,
0.0223403554,
0.0057176468,
0.0033171014,
0.0113430964,
0.0488150716,
0.0200629979,
-0.0523384102,
-0.0269930437,
0.0141736791,
-0.0155090941,
0.0049287877,
0.016946638,
-0.0001854,
-0.0717024803,
-0.046908848,
-0.1052302495,
-0.0040147081,
0.0063150949,
-0.0159457512,
0.0092223622,
-0.0005472192,
0.0174079854,
-0.0408586524,
-0.0182958264,
0.0040371735,
0.0418739542,
0.0224529337,
0.0471619852,
0.0033609304,
-0.0207101479,
-0.0513230264,
-0.0057141576,
0.0096492106,
0.0667518303,
-0.0060135429,
0.0173818301,
-0.0314318389,
0.0029364231,
-0.0590184703,
0.0143533312,
-0.0212565642,
-0.0600533821,
0.0456879139,
0.0200742129,
0.0155576421,
0.090987809,
0.0427290499,
0.0218287464,
0.0132708224,
0.0215159934,
-0.0570984818,
0.0163497552,
0.0132224876,
-0.0171150155,
-0.0257322695,
-0.0150013966,
-0.014814687,
-0.0020136798,
0.0109236753,
0.0321238823,
-0.0164021887,
0.0508022383,
0.0077141947,
-0.0606544428,
-0.0207161102,
0.0036083353,
-0.0268477444,
0.0258283075,
-0.0155497557,
-0.06333711,
0.0966094658,
-0.0026791717,
-0.0284288339,
-0.0254211687,
-0.026454756,
-0.0137331067,
0.0402071401,
-0.033868622,
0.0121218972,
-0.0023924392,
-0.0265917797,
-0.0555560477,
-0.0365612246,
0.030227324,
-0.045193363,
0.0413710773,
-0.0221644267,
-0.0170601737,
0.0055501158,
-0.0681667998,
-0.0480413884,
-0.0147620812,
-0.0338238403,
-0.0014144785,
0.0212135129,
-0.0280776322,
-0.0818551555,
-0.0138288951,
0.0255814753,
0.0030751913,
0.0043127541,
0.0016699517,
0.0079817837,
0.0326380357,
0.0441757888,
0.0415228419,
0.0211118888,
-0.010130533,
0.0518476889,
0.02050725,
0.0245976653,
0.0088998219,
-0.0207634829,
-0.006986632,
-0.0101469904,
0.025217317,
0.0263141841,
-0.0161382016,
0.057440877,
-0.0047415649,
-0.0080360686,
0.1220055819,
0.0042546107,
-0.0265133809,
-0.0106027415,
-0.0124936523,
0.0366771445,
0.0283960216,
0.0027463208,
-0.0567215458,
-0.0383362584,
0.0216831956,
0.0200876519,
-0.0251644682,
-0.0456328839,
0.0145787634,
-0.0666633397,
0.0021535,
-0.0145113459,
-0.0553210117,
-0.0592198707,
-0.0341204181,
0.0148329474,
-0.0718130767,
0.0419145115,
0.0014610556,
0.0350682549,
-0.0119023034,
-0.0112517308,
0.0024716887,
0.003434075,
0.0621308014,
-0.0051041986,
0.0721329227,
0.0304656718,
0.0623808131,
0.0507500209,
0.0003979835,
0.0076210992,
0.0175649021,
-0.0197288264,
-0.0022608794,
0.075351879,
-0.009300027,
-0.0383087285,
-0.0729765072,
0.0049809692,
0.022975143,
0.0094772922,
-0.003397407,
0.0056188996,
-0.015611426,
0.0232622139,
-0.0070808637,
0.0464745574,
0.0382841453,
0.0705687106,
0.0236398913,
-0.040199589,
-0.0290933289,
-0.0184215233,
-0.0310538001,
-0.0408913977,
-0.0169744957,
-0.0104668858,
-0.0236141868,
0.0277927369,
-0.0868422687,
-0.0467723683,
-0.0099828029,
0.0496646613,
-0.0170617905,
-0.0534487292,
-0.0062451735,
0.0397315919,
0.0398975648,
0.0266675409,
-0.0318904519,
0.002032585,
-0.0641282797,
0.0059662727,
0.0722438991,
-0.0075015593,
-0.0185964853,
0.0823338479,
-0.0417241529,
-0.0363613293,
-0.0378217027,
0.0482760854,
0.0255394261,
0.0172474422,
-0.0126182102,
-0.0071006068,
-0.0029297147,
-0.017108243,
-0.0328473598,
-0.0212033335,
0.0725573674,
0.0600369461,
-0.0171304606,
0.0481011793,
-0.0535400435,
0.0243613776,
-0.015730055,
0.0098053906,
-0.0249272212,
-0.0768953338,
-0.0090688309,
0.0210785121,
0.0120569272,
0.0239617042,
-0.0166310389,
-0.0107056489,
0.0358592197,
-0.0372313447,
-0.0160946529,
-0.053469047,
0.0136704966,
0.0292373355,
-0.0053176391,
-0.0060691759,
-0.0067961346,
-0.017136991,
0.0645010397,
0.0164482221,
-0.0193642434,
0.0373782404,
0.0183191821,
-0.014891658,
-0.0187927205,
-0.0490072519,
-0.002485085,
-0.0075761704,
0.0002340252,
0.0161096156,
0.0675882772,
0.0191036537,
-0.0275617242,
0.0444370434,
0.0282702744,
-0.0776909813,
-0.0147493854,
-0.0265420936,
0.0338304602,
0.0092585143,
0.0168411378,
0.0657782629,
-0.0134661738,
0.0178537536,
-0.0218945406,
0.0736860186,
-0.0146328742,
-0.0090194205,
-0.0072640735,
0.0374710597,
-0.0154169016,
0.0310738143,
0.0592011511,
-0.0205899701,
0.0249967091,
-0.0074334871,
-0.0188663825,
-0.041227743,
-0.0281166006,
-0.0131092342,
0.0036004679,
0.0040203994,
-0.0039463216,
-0.0294394232,
-0.0526840165,
0.0008355858,
0.0330427103,
0.0024741904,
0.0252074394,
0.0218797456,
0.0452582352,
0.0082554249,
-0.0054965112,
-0.0462800041,
-0.0052020075,
-0.0158287529,
0.006698709,
-0.0228222311,
-5.49193128e-33,
-0.0188610405,
-0.0279875901,
-0.0076192771,
-0.0243402794,
-0.0461030714,
-0.0325252637,
-0.0253947061,
0.0026363854,
-0.0536126643,
0.0011769726,
0.0054046959,
0.0340200141,
0.0084406175,
0.0288276318,
-0.00806964,
-0.0394628458,
0.0465954356,
-0.0225032736,
-0.0260962453,
0.0426423922,
0.0364376083,
-0.0055450448,
0.0368365012,
-0.0926915929,
0.0130888885,
0.0178434551,
-0.0031588983,
0.0455974638,
0.0145954452,
0.0624171905,
-0.0029689055,
0.0461676866,
0.0068105832,
-0.0260427184,
-0.0134667903,
0.0257719979,
-0.0568220317,
-0.0309278201,
0.0146636404,
0.0184541792,
0.0085682292,
-0.0154276313,
-0.0120196389,
-0.0304424129,
0.0225551762,
-0.0256205946,
0.0121651022,
-0.0240712091,
-0.0081581939,
0.009569901,
-0.0194885805,
0.0290251654,
-0.0579660982,
-0.0562694333,
-0.0305168591,
0.1121845767,
0.0126824128,
0.0082859024,
-0.0117375134,
0.0253555682,
-0.0418496728,
-0.0143568059,
0.0286381189,
0.0164826829,
0.0287571251,
0.0600797385,
0.0223792903,
0.0345401391,
-0.0019182732,
-0.0617948398,
-0.0084853349,
0.0542624295,
0.0517624468,
0.0966719612,
-0.0286996346,
-0.0097538261,
-0.0746565759,
0.0096913613,
0.0451595932,
0.0311359428,
0.0030684792,
0.0154084181,
-0.0245786607,
0.0317017511,
-0.0291926507,
-0.0234391689,
-0.0429989249,
-0.0378768668,
0.0237762332,
0.0102874376,
0.0098956972,
-0.0134572918,
0.0355034918,
-0.0369065665,
0.0088338414,
0.0396531709,
0.0000952635,
0.0097164372,
0.007861644,
-0.0009786763,
-0.001425196,
-0.0120084928,
0.0662331656,
0.0533174388,
0.0354141518,
-0.0226154756,
0.0172998086,
0.0047663567,
-0.0410004668,
-0.0115933437,
-0.0183486808,
0.0254597068,
-0.0409399569,
0.0091772405,
0.0092675146,
-0.0203765035,
-0.0397359058,
0.0509560369,
-0.0491074957,
0.0197281111,
-0.0420937687,
-0.035770718,
0.0250849556,
0.0056664767,
-0.0529352725,
-0.0298006944,
-0.0288214814,
-0.0357825048,
0.0131144896,
-0.0379785746,
-0.0053590536,
-0.0290742237,
2.398e-7,
-0.0323281288,
0.0353695713,
0.0208890736,
0.0260742567,
0.0210667383,
0.0468537956,
-0.0210532099,
0.0310735274,
0.0164088998,
-0.0413119718,
0.015708657,
-0.0040687602,
0.0614379458,
0.014486949,
-0.091605559,
-0.036485713,
-0.0616807789,
-0.0485763401,
-0.0027313191,
-0.0244149528,
0.0841782242,
0.1027576253,
0.0211671982,
0.0209455211,
-0.0053401678,
-0.0503170341,
0.0432693884,
-0.0238503776,
-0.012994648,
0.0048499014,
0.0747761056,
-0.0097291395,
0.022548737,
0.0364097096,
0.0001081093,
0.0033406417,
0.0278193597,
0.0858777538,
0.0098296097,
-0.091673784,
-0.009077929,
-0.0007322226,
0.0157535579,
-0.038052123,
0.0460629538,
-0.0340004116,
-0.0375291929,
-0.0407014377,
-0.0384697914,
-0.0264632702,
0.0740537792,
-0.0359393544,
-0.0145197567,
0.0387217551,
0.004140324,
-0.0121815084,
0.0303167813,
-0.0832590982,
-0.0154937822,
0.0155740185,
-0.0615789779,
-0.0823452771,
0.0005226717,
-0.0479112603,
0.0266277194,
-0.0199653879,
0.0212027524,
1.547792812e-34,
0.0556484647,
-0.0099958321,
0.0302694738,
0.0424476974,
0.0535240099,
-0.027878508,
0.0010448699,
-0.0374346673,
0.0549491197,
-0.062770769,
0.0087598125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14521v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14521v3 | Few-shot Adaptation to Distribution Shifts By Mixing Source and Target Embeddings | 2023-05-23T20:49:45 | 2024-05-29T22:38:13 | Yihao Xue, Ali Payani, Yu Yang, Baharan Mirzasoleiman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Pretrained machine learning models need to be adapted to distribution shifts
when deployed in new target environments. When obtaining labeled data from the
target distribution is expensive, few-shot adaptation with only a few examples
from the target distribution becomes essential. In this work, we propose
MixPro, a lightweight and highly data-efficient approach for few-shot
adaptation. MixPro first generates a relatively large dataset by mixing
(linearly combining) pre-trained embeddings of large source data with those of
the few target examples. This process preserves important features of both
source and target distributions, while mitigating the specific noise in the
small target data. Then, it trains a linear classifier on the mixed embeddings
to effectively adapts the model to the target distribution without overfitting
the small target data. Theoretically, we demonstrate the advantages of MixPro
over previous methods. Our experiments, conducted across various model
architectures on 8 datasets featuring different types of distribution shifts,
reveal that MixPro can outperform baselines by up to 7\%, with only 2-4 target
examples. | [
-0.0280514117,
0.0768614411,
-0.0078692865,
-0.017037861,
0.0478482209,
-0.0002179208,
0.0127279488,
-0.0140625965,
-0.0772700831,
-0.0290737003,
-0.0192642268,
0.0328576528,
-0.0567545295,
0.0079625547,
0.0255554877,
-0.0426637903,
0.0218676273,
0.030160442,
-0.039452482,
0.0128523083,
-0.0123361461,
-0.0173059106,
0.0040282686,
0.0037802509,
-0.0079433806,
0.0223159473,
-0.0333970673,
0.0501408242,
0.0574053898,
-0.0255703088,
0.0358778089,
0.0149087897,
0.042364791,
0.0197939426,
0.0000020466,
-0.0067554424,
-0.0132026756,
-0.0003777267,
-0.0600027703,
0.0136422375,
0.0365021974,
-0.0602563024,
-0.0116544059,
-0.0061369599,
-0.0039491747,
-0.0628898591,
0.0610329583,
0.0252638329,
0.0447504595,
0.0601672381,
-0.029240014,
-0.029356651,
-0.0058740801,
-0.0184687749,
0.0326109231,
-0.0377504565,
0.021470651,
-0.0284272321,
-0.0530300625,
-0.0149212116,
-0.0447993614,
0.0097017903,
0.0086594364,
0.0557308383,
0.0327929668,
0.0473587811,
-0.0660686418,
0.0285892747,
-0.04530783,
0.0735116825,
-0.0917491019,
-0.0466985367,
-0.0260724872,
-0.0580353811,
0.0114821028,
-0.0227799397,
-0.013866514,
-0.0675760359,
0.0514572747,
0.0156039605,
-0.0811406076,
0.0320024155,
0.0260583311,
-0.0080265608,
-0.0811373442,
0.0006998432,
-0.0145310424,
-0.0176298842,
0.0110404594,
-0.0253538974,
0.0228488855,
-0.0083790524,
-0.0410293192,
0.0123493262,
0.0091569209,
-0.0255449712,
-0.0815083236,
-0.0382520072,
-0.0080946665,
0.0024124305,
0.0757271796,
0.0303989947,
-0.089024879,
0.0491145886,
-0.0443840697,
-0.0121841067,
-0.0243981648,
0.0345132239,
-0.0302353986,
0.028057754,
-0.0475648269,
0.0386072733,
-0.0103514176,
0.0118222171,
-0.008585575,
0.0013465643,
-0.0319971628,
0.0550544523,
0.0074556735,
0.0038423259,
-0.0127939237,
0.0295359064,
-0.0355647206,
0.0055046482,
0.0536900461,
0.0570890866,
-0.0275903065,
0.0300169811,
0.0237462968,
-0.0146374442,
-0.0208985843,
0.0149565209,
0.012002252,
-0.0149653321,
0.0274002645,
0.0998912305,
0.027795868,
-0.0287636835,
-0.0522254184,
0.0623890273,
-0.0019992287,
-0.0003533985,
0.0184411593,
-0.0149851758,
0.0146318758,
-0.0205860417,
0.0084300367,
-0.0190597642,
-0.0117245857,
-0.0379312783,
-0.0437676162,
0.1028193533,
0.0157031026,
-0.0017546411,
0.0328015648,
-0.0349700078,
-0.0286269058,
0.0782190338,
0.0101923104,
-0.0050173285,
0.0141226808,
-0.0339270718,
0.0162461177,
0.0199938137,
0.0203060266,
0.0351722501,
-0.0103638778,
0.0006556772,
-0.0360013619,
0.0083748763,
0.0733673424,
-0.0760273114,
-0.0093286075,
-0.0584885255,
0.0486184806,
-0.000675679,
0.0562871881,
-0.0047719893,
0.0106530376,
0.0021903005,
-0.0649180487,
-0.0342501216,
-0.0411239527,
0.0539640747,
-0.0584496669,
-0.0465923063,
-0.0302098822,
0.052704528,
-0.0633691326,
-0.0127698593,
0.0236488655,
-0.0104970941,
-0.0303155947,
-0.005729252,
0.045366779,
-0.0126314452,
-0.0032444508,
0.0569997691,
0.0495438091,
0.0088409856,
-0.0144373598,
-0.0232436005,
-0.0132543352,
-0.0005644726,
0.0001423806,
-0.0608677268,
-0.0213999059,
-0.0307554584,
0.047997348,
-0.0128236506,
0.0323590487,
0.0198978968,
0.0506061539,
-0.0117141493,
-0.0449182838,
-0.0208285525,
0.0191474445,
0.0506415404,
-0.010036109,
-0.004122295,
0.0172918625,
-0.0768471286,
0.0508081615,
0.0248261746,
-0.0043715122,
-0.0203333739,
0.0597433336,
0.0425449647,
0.0343833938,
-0.039012555,
-0.0223361254,
-0.0200510863,
0.0143386628,
-0.0120885158,
-0.0070880298,
0.0255435463,
0.0193467643,
-0.0096834088,
0.0113848066,
0.0107894158,
0.0658460334,
0.0016420037,
-0.0760381669,
-0.0113158561,
0.0367853194,
0.0171305649,
0.0228732508,
0.0016921953,
0.0016231299,
-0.0074931779,
0.0491788238,
-0.0451834239,
0.0093560703,
0.0047622276,
-0.0493073352,
-0.0448672362,
-0.007192967,
0.0394011401,
0.015897166,
0.010786429,
-0.0185201596,
-0.0087106386,
0.018013237,
-0.0028720363,
-0.0203065854,
-0.0107482718,
0.0090858918,
0.0098097734,
0.0218602829,
-0.0134211853,
0.0113532199,
0.0235809181,
0.0067403815,
-0.0237850379,
-0.0273084734,
-0.0123844426,
0.0660554692,
-0.0500744358,
-0.0011512892,
0.0226644129,
0.0238745101,
0.0283256304,
-0.0281177294,
0.0070730676,
0.0134236943,
0.0634482205,
-0.0464717299,
-0.0104456116,
-0.0551189706,
-0.0133784031,
-0.0072498573,
0.0121312281,
-0.0131083746,
-0.0426111855,
-0.0582567081,
0.0115984678,
0.0279422812,
0.0638059601,
-0.0066490206,
0.014765555,
0.036762286,
0.0131234443,
-0.0225804448,
0.0144655351,
-0.0171508603,
-0.0385180973,
-0.0210458487,
0.0043243272,
-0.0224481728,
0.0032210138,
-0.0302901827,
-0.0127498209,
-0.0462941676,
0.0109082563,
-0.0001441434,
-0.0173240323,
-0.063288264,
0.0624513365,
-0.0072377813,
-0.0044442005,
-0.0189088099,
-0.0388592817,
0.0497392453,
0.0202807672,
0.0240619797,
-0.0268563442,
-0.0547440238,
0.0043863109,
-0.0332855582,
0.0095713306,
0.0114504863,
-0.0179873519,
0.0204960331,
-0.0637956038,
-0.0281834528,
0.0245037246,
0.0055377828,
-0.0000254874,
0.0194412824,
-0.0249501523,
-0.0219306182,
-0.0175568871,
-0.0256346092,
-0.0928563848,
0.0198216122,
0.0006359191,
-0.0598417707,
-0.0232663248,
-0.0751589164,
0.024102591,
0.0271571837,
0.0809655339,
-0.008936869,
-0.0077732611,
-0.0074967695,
0.0047363578,
0.0081144338,
-0.0210953373,
-0.020702282,
-0.0144371437,
0.0022763025,
-0.0190232638,
0.0484898537,
0.0149031049,
-0.076578714,
0.0187695492,
0.0024818419,
0.0014965478,
-0.0234373007,
0.0083304094,
0.0617116168,
-0.006264064,
0.0250331257,
0.0297014825,
0.0111038703,
-0.0248146355,
0.0103735067,
-0.0058256537,
0.0397346802,
0.0297181141,
0.0459707044,
-0.0829679742,
-0.025397541,
-0.0022490777,
0.0137383034,
0.0223392919,
-0.0117086256,
-0.0012356347,
-0.0791224018,
0.0379288122,
0.0332559645,
-0.069015108,
-0.0210957099,
-0.0328741409,
0.0232189111,
-0.0248732436,
-0.0003640455,
-0.005268286,
0.0048600086,
-0.0313308239,
0.0428536944,
-0.0321812071,
-0.0743625388,
-0.0075007817,
-0.0373855643,
0.0132765761,
0.0539177991,
-0.0078703137,
-0.0210298672,
0.0121455155,
0.0125316791,
-0.0125267738,
0.0024314353,
0.0375518575,
0.1016315669,
-0.0083169006,
-0.0031815353,
0.076809153,
0.0051226141,
-0.0166370366,
-0.016344456,
0.0213385113,
0.052875299,
-0.0141816596,
-0.0040197037,
-0.0436192676,
-0.0182630941,
0.0378754996,
0.0071040499,
0.0128434319,
-0.0298223421,
-0.0062374733,
0.0006458933,
-0.0002880202,
-0.0004639358,
0.0263424516,
0.0751227662,
-0.051183071,
-0.1220109463,
-0.055378709,
0.0107202316,
-0.004217559,
0.0597217828,
0.0192979164,
-0.0698077977,
-0.0528699197,
0.0013789017,
-0.0497723855,
0.0006532835,
0.0061205719,
0.0319353342,
-0.0122226113,
-0.0181814209,
0.0342647173,
-0.0084556164,
-0.0021407509,
-0.0411885306,
-0.0604412109,
-0.027536178,
-0.0056173205,
0.0606528111,
0.0062905489,
0.0448291972,
-0.0209546536,
-0.0158068966,
0.1132739708,
0.0707646236,
0.0278610624,
0.0309424978,
0.0587569065,
-0.0656231716,
-0.0101450393,
-0.0083197169,
-0.0590500385,
0.0656984672,
0.0406854711,
-0.0690250844,
-0.0232566502,
0.0133987749,
-0.0169460233,
-0.0401849411,
0.0829810053,
-0.019760089,
-0.0519912951,
0.0146716051,
0.0354650691,
-0.0096430304,
0.0095377332,
0.0001371745,
-0.0616581514,
0.0201368574,
0.0007310082,
-0.0012009054,
0.0264035556,
0.0196568239,
0.0657446161,
-0.0573105477,
-0.0005413966,
0.0348997377,
0.0538716689,
-0.0129138129,
0.0447741039,
0.0302067436,
-0.01322765,
0.0074796253,
0.0274199955,
-0.0082555376,
-0.016201064,
0.0286243185,
0.0314361677,
-0.0416378155,
0.0401288234,
-0.0499392599,
0.0176224653,
-0.0351853408,
0.0083292462,
0.0620727092,
-0.0275367517,
0.0026517625,
0.0371628106,
-0.0347807668,
-0.0305601712,
0.0246285088,
-0.0077087115,
-0.0044501568,
0.0243438128,
0.0227574315,
-0.0165912248,
0.0240789223,
0.0331302322,
0.0497961566,
0.057173349,
-0.0200832877,
0.0239425693,
-0.0463242829,
0.0649753138,
0.0478444472,
0.0226548202,
0.0168638341,
0.0217446964,
-0.027464075,
-0.0422953218,
0.017358765,
-0.0151859457,
0.0141451983,
0.0245777871,
0.0079468768,
0.0325970724,
-0.009310877,
0.002157066,
-0.0268111676,
-0.0209296122,
0.0123017449,
0.0069262129,
0.0556607507,
-6.249940363e-33,
-0.0115177762,
0.0226015728,
-0.0057910234,
-0.0406084135,
-0.0030049349,
0.005577541,
0.0040121134,
-0.0214964412,
-0.0084133688,
-0.010047216,
-0.0328282192,
0.005009471,
0.0096036876,
-0.0096997265,
-0.0132309031,
-0.0037921129,
0.0537599474,
-0.0328354202,
-0.0413497239,
-0.0005501145,
-0.00167971,
0.0453557335,
0.0337481163,
-0.0570696704,
-0.0793498158,
0.0623164736,
-0.0262111798,
-0.0460874327,
0.0297914501,
0.0237910151,
0.0322109051,
0.049080044,
-0.0019203736,
0.0264735743,
-0.0372068398,
-0.0035115902,
-0.0431956835,
-0.0011600881,
-0.0506868884,
0.0408602208,
0.0240011662,
-0.0079533746,
0.0103207892,
-0.0023720008,
0.037687473,
-0.0319574401,
0.0428409018,
-0.062582761,
-0.0184623282,
-0.0058757775,
-0.0324072316,
0.0411384702,
-0.005157663,
-0.0203404389,
0.012713897,
0.0370144397,
0.0508040227,
0.0299870558,
-0.0621812902,
0.0153947892,
0.0105626602,
0.0161944777,
0.0236442406,
0.0495746695,
0.0168000963,
0.0478265695,
0.0063285227,
-0.0513218045,
0.0262020975,
-0.0443511531,
0.0551021881,
0.0086853113,
0.0075538787,
0.0699484646,
0.0671942979,
-0.0654222369,
-0.06996537,
0.0161566362,
0.0089588575,
-0.0215050243,
-0.0014649905,
0.0516207777,
-0.0173656903,
-0.0068864147,
0.0043109911,
-0.0141236484,
0.0001411564,
-0.0504476465,
0.0486824587,
0.0185823683,
-0.0110440636,
0.0488061607,
0.0363850407,
-0.0499466546,
0.0186545067,
0.0245775543,
-0.0439925343,
-0.0012742098,
-0.0000700234,
0.0052449307,
-0.0091488697,
-0.0502213761,
0.0787850618,
0.010478423,
0.0200338978,
-0.0104607958,
0.0701608136,
0.0686744303,
-0.0531204939,
-0.0172938034,
0.0002430707,
-0.0275797397,
0.0033096033,
0.0400572605,
-0.019871546,
0.0158262067,
0.0020776156,
0.02464954,
0.002989505,
-0.0419819057,
0.012486646,
0.0448243506,
-0.0111576999,
0.0380237214,
-0.0638953298,
-0.0122876335,
-0.0009832756,
-0.0039375597,
0.0025876616,
-0.0766935349,
-0.0151615292,
-0.0551592372,
2.844e-7,
0.0347861983,
0.0281073283,
-0.015123032,
-0.0426822267,
-0.0066156439,
0.0066805803,
-0.0530949831,
0.0517517254,
-0.0194214899,
-0.0431589261,
0.0410758182,
0.0167957433,
0.0106275333,
0.0344633274,
-0.0484619848,
0.0054062684,
-0.0119782286,
0.0417392142,
-0.0584272482,
-0.0288726836,
0.040424712,
0.1244628355,
0.0509006269,
-0.01351225,
0.0604130216,
0.0089074215,
0.0374676138,
-0.0280996338,
0.0087249437,
-0.0343147181,
-0.0059291604,
0.0245845206,
-0.0222327355,
0.0310244393,
-0.0520757698,
0.038830664,
-0.0066202739,
0.0166613366,
-0.056409955,
-0.0271508154,
-0.0224570464,
0.0440359935,
-0.0124719664,
-0.0120564802,
0.0388170518,
-0.1067809537,
-0.0260783266,
-0.0228841733,
-0.1056039706,
0.0113870455,
0.0335789397,
0.0019837997,
-0.013152726,
-0.0246836636,
0.0263576228,
0.019624522,
-0.01558246,
-0.0825910345,
0.0141219916,
0.0714936703,
-0.01142265,
-0.0123802144,
-0.018735081,
-0.0673836619,
0.0710417628,
-0.0080761509,
0.0011146872,
2.551494288e-34,
0.0247382894,
0.0043403399,
0.0288795289,
-0.0249955151,
-0.0377798788,
-0.0082393773,
0.0011177617,
-0.0079965563,
0.0613563992,
-0.0065540243,
0.0036866276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14507v1 | Deduction under Perturbed Evidence: Probing Student Simulation Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T20:26:03 | 2023-05-23T20:26:03 | Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore whether Large Language Models (LLMs) are capable of logical
reasoning with distorted facts, which we call Deduction under Perturbed
Evidence (DUPE). DUPE presents a unique challenge to LLMs since they typically
rely on their parameters, which encode mostly accurate information, to reason
and make inferences. However, in DUPE, LLMs must reason over manipulated or
falsified evidence present in their prompts, which can result in false
conclusions that are valid only under the manipulated evidence. Our goal with
DUPE is to determine whether LLMs can arrive at these false conclusions and
identify whether the dominant factor influencing the deduction process is the
encoded data in the parameters or the manipulated evidence in the prompts. To
evaluate the DUPE capabilities of LLMs, we create a DUPEd version of the
StrategyQA dataset, where facts are manipulated to reverse the answer to the
question. Our findings show that even the most advanced GPT models struggle to
reason on manipulated facts - showcasing poor DUPE skills - with accuracy
dropping by 45% compared to the original dataset. We also investigate prompt
settings inspired from student simulation models, which mitigate the accuracy
drop to some extent. Our findings have practical implications for understanding
the performance of LLMs in real-world applications such as student simulation
models that involve reasoning over inaccurate information. | [
0.0289832968,
0.0370931104,
-0.0253270157,
0.0436166786,
-0.0735490695,
0.0118668946,
0.024723351,
-0.0152670154,
-0.0079803383,
-0.0352304056,
0.0158920288,
0.0027131175,
0.0081516011,
-0.0014387507,
0.0228744093,
-0.0301579442,
0.0672014132,
-0.0737594441,
0.0276042838,
-0.0299126152,
-0.0144502735,
0.0065352246,
-0.0034927833,
0.0123837227,
-0.0056343358,
-0.0218732059,
-0.019575648,
0.0007118371,
0.0183930155,
0.0081341965,
-0.0225589294,
0.0686635673,
0.0101550529,
0.0689757019,
0.0000021061,
-0.0454537906,
0.011290676,
-0.0181681868,
-0.1025028974,
0.0649479851,
0.0288200304,
0.0370606929,
-0.0231187008,
0.0283754058,
-0.0302120131,
-0.0376796052,
0.0328662246,
0.0086133033,
0.0450151376,
0.0742529109,
0.0217622165,
-0.0278022476,
-0.0136580719,
-0.0107500311,
0.0297943261,
-0.0182709564,
0.0457639284,
0.0423699468,
0.0434843004,
0.0275324266,
-0.0050111488,
0.0095840143,
0.0698820353,
0.020219028,
-0.0990090966,
0.0478710085,
-0.0292008761,
0.0100892708,
0.0156257693,
0.0352066234,
-0.0218760893,
-0.0575064234,
-0.0081696426,
-0.0039740107,
0.0320681632,
0.0575498268,
0.0009932921,
0.0515306666,
-0.0387769006,
0.011062298,
0.0559556372,
-0.0094547095,
0.0556562766,
0.0136710359,
-0.0200285465,
0.0418750234,
-0.0000881445,
-0.0327183977,
-0.0103129027,
0.008465712,
-0.0259135049,
-0.045487944,
-0.035787113,
0.0183991268,
-0.0435752831,
0.0411873572,
-0.0512603633,
-0.0025722433,
0.0424051359,
-0.0100986091,
0.0460659824,
0.0186089817,
0.0197689012,
0.0703314021,
-0.0038910487,
0.0120362295,
-0.0482326597,
0.0450240634,
0.006952161,
-0.0094150603,
-0.018430138,
-0.0263608415,
-0.0085965861,
0.005350105,
0.013545787,
0.0262823459,
0.0203226563,
-0.0105779152,
-0.0386787988,
0.0303531829,
-0.0322881006,
0.0046147224,
-0.0298351198,
-0.0475839265,
-0.0738325119,
0.0342970043,
-0.0375432633,
0.0536565483,
0.0356629416,
-0.0781160817,
-0.0261805058,
-0.0028764463,
-0.0242210012,
-0.0095088659,
0.0313279405,
0.0473549254,
-0.013540349,
0.016500907,
-0.0337304585,
-0.0533579625,
-0.0010033693,
-0.0792990774,
0.0000651029,
-0.0837407112,
0.0389701873,
0.0091949767,
-0.039836552,
-0.0455752388,
0.0012007531,
0.0277479347,
-0.0256635342,
0.0721425116,
-0.0034352802,
0.0033852125,
0.0343286991,
0.030352084,
-0.0477457531,
0.0694010779,
0.0027004643,
0.0344226845,
0.0046255658,
0.0078182649,
0.0406626016,
0.0278687794,
0.0402657911,
0.0187755898,
-0.0290313363,
0.0023806682,
0.0020097205,
0.0261854902,
0.0053246138,
0.0316917486,
-0.059379179,
-0.0157455057,
0.0774618909,
0.0053493502,
-0.0327980481,
0.0109057976,
0.0445399657,
-0.0230362825,
0.0354527794,
0.0314878598,
-0.0737527236,
0.0013924179,
0.0065622758,
0.0181174856,
0.0165578332,
0.0225602742,
-0.011826518,
-0.0467785075,
0.0137376953,
-0.0056809424,
-0.0247591659,
0.0466596,
-0.0000598924,
0.0029124091,
-0.0117520792,
0.0289459024,
0.0288091544,
-0.009555297,
-0.0269398335,
-0.0691590905,
0.0400751345,
0.0306978952,
0.0668341815,
-0.0297164414,
-0.0149464188,
-0.0192783084,
-0.0160009991,
0.035192091,
0.0767054185,
-0.0026657281,
-0.0271379594,
-0.0110196667,
-0.0103344796,
-0.0238323752,
0.0490366369,
0.0267575588,
0.0226775445,
-0.0079493588,
0.0057559293,
-0.0141695943,
0.0161504429,
0.0243453123,
-0.0547331572,
-0.0293807816,
-0.0397080518,
-0.0327808037,
0.0092871534,
-0.0258854404,
-0.0271647535,
0.0068538501,
0.0279300585,
0.0077505158,
0.0033048592,
-0.0049786209,
-0.0461057276,
-0.0475843996,
0.029195331,
-0.0508682989,
-0.0308284238,
0.0042519369,
-0.0226824936,
-0.0158832446,
0.0298052784,
-0.029139407,
0.016603481,
-0.015591668,
0.0145230237,
-0.0271282047,
0.0126443692,
-0.0091129327,
0.0776411891,
0.0176274944,
0.0142254392,
0.0324033536,
0.0003505549,
-0.0161568299,
-0.0363987386,
0.0278354641,
0.0081587145,
0.028511418,
-0.0047007496,
-0.0010685482,
-0.0347469077,
-0.0369158685,
-0.029504383,
-0.0433900468,
0.0071746823,
-0.0167369023,
0.0083685322,
0.0297003202,
-0.0352531075,
-0.037143182,
-0.0032701688,
-0.0189699922,
-0.0345214903,
0.0074069644,
0.0136078391,
0.0110399062,
-0.0166132525,
0.0213142168,
-0.0100168269,
0.0037863699,
-0.0314802229,
0.034208212,
0.0106077436,
0.0362568013,
-0.0690791756,
0.0081543764,
-0.0247759875,
0.0263975281,
0.0012557619,
0.0170320142,
0.0473096482,
-0.0023906059,
0.0487892218,
0.0914931893,
-0.0212409552,
0.0015464006,
0.0735644624,
-0.0096766511,
-0.0720454305,
0.0162309967,
-0.0104235066,
0.0032987292,
-0.0531975478,
-0.061223913,
-0.0479663089,
0.0348544903,
0.0125331897,
0.00091986,
-0.0215327535,
0.0820070803,
-0.0033920102,
-0.0374710821,
0.0115069924,
-0.0159672108,
-0.008201438,
0.036687199,
-0.0089009581,
-0.0276074801,
0.0854353905,
-0.0082062911,
0.041417513,
-0.0493549928,
0.0333552957,
0.0067408453,
0.0481951907,
-0.0092681041,
-0.0257785879,
0.0159175787,
0.0214181971,
-0.0363008529,
-0.0098252632,
0.0620532148,
-0.0548703149,
0.0235037543,
-0.0879155174,
-0.0292445961,
-0.007451179,
-0.0214787796,
-0.0571852624,
-0.0442737862,
-0.0269025601,
-0.009386451,
-0.0208177343,
-0.0115928529,
-0.0482438654,
-0.0540026352,
0.0391011201,
0.0403099284,
0.0020473949,
0.0002634083,
-0.0363194793,
-0.0119465198,
0.0620472394,
0.0051557096,
0.0275446549,
-0.0461498834,
0.0340468958,
0.0567956567,
-0.0030720714,
0.0188740585,
-0.0050742775,
-0.0053104213,
-0.0187682975,
0.0128119458,
0.0055829636,
0.033323288,
0.026985554,
-0.0753888786,
-0.0216312557,
0.1001650989,
0.0344046615,
-0.0131220547,
-0.0197719261,
-0.0283395369,
0.0533052497,
0.0055245836,
-0.0026897702,
-0.1057067513,
-0.0412977748,
0.0222360864,
-0.0109260892,
-0.0475890189,
-0.0446442887,
-0.0126590813,
-0.137101993,
0.0322099291,
0.0045459019,
0.0307149589,
-0.00532735,
-0.0689038783,
0.002152099,
-0.0098408088,
0.0395580307,
-0.0011418982,
0.0293481275,
0.0161406696,
0.0197565332,
0.0162025057,
-0.0381045975,
0.0546129569,
-0.0013139116,
0.0731425956,
-0.0031766752,
-0.0060442295,
-0.0195464808,
-0.0686207414,
0.0252273344,
0.000684418,
-0.0214723833,
0.0070002903,
0.0097423131,
0.0128948456,
-0.0013918794,
-0.026098758,
0.0145096863,
-0.0095066596,
-0.0392420329,
0.0285487846,
0.100367412,
-0.0044668033,
-0.0544203632,
-0.0291928872,
-0.0233513769,
-0.0096304845,
0.0739261955,
0.014896621,
-0.0209218655,
-0.0360227861,
-0.0364510119,
-0.0401184745,
0.0270521324,
-0.0502799638,
0.0238064211,
0.03291348,
0.0168377254,
0.0022407139,
-0.0329865031,
0.0280297957,
0.0049140933,
-0.011394131,
0.0096424362,
0.0041835965,
-0.0003214742,
-0.008939717,
0.0152899195,
-0.0619904548,
0.0382023156,
-0.0074317059,
0.0277122557,
-0.047891099,
-0.0137908738,
-0.0008862543,
0.0287390668,
-0.0530702248,
-0.0707890168,
0.0462367088,
0.0279561616,
0.0343025811,
0.0284862667,
-0.0087464321,
-0.0321122222,
0.0093540447,
-0.0092743058,
0.0037611271,
0.0123929149,
0.0451924801,
-0.0498691313,
0.0146794766,
0.0228058044,
0.0330325328,
0.037838012,
0.0283628963,
-0.0025326605,
-0.0610184222,
-0.0060729841,
0.0470052846,
0.0243193544,
0.039434623,
0.0139307948,
-0.0211654846,
-0.0169344712,
0.0224046167,
-0.0445032455,
-0.0235138759,
0.0272091534,
-0.0180718079,
0.0330222473,
-0.006158262,
0.0096502164,
-0.0609117486,
-0.0231072865,
0.0043912092,
0.0175458007,
0.0045545921,
0.0299677812,
0.0348317362,
0.0323508047,
-0.0602888949,
-0.0205370225,
0.0250618309,
-0.0280807838,
0.083288379,
0.0028934469,
0.0733145103,
0.0424060933,
-0.0273455977,
0.0028512978,
-0.0201343168,
-0.0743871331,
-0.0549975224,
0.0378048271,
0.0451176874,
0.0161783323,
0.0033393896,
-0.0039700107,
-0.0565844253,
0.0068691447,
-0.0151888309,
-0.0096102217,
0.0397478528,
-0.0426466987,
0.0483530387,
0.0207436159,
-0.0270668939,
0.0157366768,
0.058508262,
-0.0041508102,
0.0546835959,
-0.0096439589,
0.0187789425,
-0.0125475079,
-0.0306581948,
-0.0137205711,
0.0057284292,
-0.0011270491,
0.0019601875,
-0.084679842,
-0.0894094184,
-0.0216843132,
0.0470980518,
0.0028924511,
-0.0332283489,
-0.0282772873,
0.065334335,
-0.0176035389,
-0.0219134279,
-0.0109200291,
0.0763424709,
0.0194959417,
-0.0022749337,
-0.0242280457,
-6.269200838e-33,
-0.0145204486,
-0.0154858083,
0.0236773342,
-0.0263111833,
0.0112983286,
0.0040421709,
-0.0163178481,
0.0230730902,
-0.058957871,
0.0364851467,
-0.0292996429,
0.0331379212,
0.0205817036,
0.0041874163,
-0.0129322913,
-0.0490369163,
0.0084487433,
0.0098503828,
-0.0371093154,
0.0078416327,
0.0334907807,
-0.0536288023,
0.0386489369,
-0.0639681518,
0.0530482084,
-0.0321896337,
-0.0148867955,
0.0154089639,
-0.1209363714,
0.0315217674,
-0.01329525,
0.0362309963,
-0.0132355038,
-0.0912416428,
0.0055708122,
0.014103326,
-0.0193546172,
-0.0424755439,
0.0491486974,
-0.0184912924,
-0.0293984357,
-0.0449541397,
-0.0066490253,
0.0281056445,
-0.0352484062,
-0.0245694928,
-0.0128555829,
-0.0419881195,
0.0134870764,
0.0353990942,
-0.0585883111,
0.0424211286,
0.0064080027,
-0.0040466478,
-0.0021456957,
0.0221676379,
-0.0163462497,
-0.0302766077,
-0.0680275932,
0.0247338675,
0.0670912936,
-0.0105435085,
0.0655208826,
-0.0245825797,
-0.0043199188,
0.0561465994,
0.0336593576,
0.0300930999,
-0.0467348024,
-0.0176783465,
0.0124397743,
0.0500690825,
0.0769268945,
0.067187652,
0.0441891961,
-0.0000078914,
-0.0701851621,
-0.0259528533,
0.0449068025,
0.0057255034,
0.0402513705,
-0.0246699248,
-0.045728419,
-0.0229297206,
-0.0733130053,
0.0173731092,
-0.0155851236,
-0.0101174088,
0.0100237671,
0.0123307779,
-0.0072382963,
-0.001605476,
-0.0199372452,
-0.0295869187,
-0.0058472203,
-0.0020137958,
-0.0047562816,
-0.0206020828,
-0.0233294517,
0.0491585284,
-0.045381248,
-0.0168090649,
0.0389399566,
-0.0168782845,
0.0094359973,
0.0367954336,
0.0402585752,
0.0084004691,
-0.051457338,
-0.0117342956,
-0.0432057902,
0.030323742,
0.0190385375,
-0.0427085795,
0.0754682422,
0.0154900933,
-0.0067607882,
-0.0706800297,
0.0303036999,
-0.0155947711,
-0.0289460085,
0.0503003076,
-0.0321997106,
0.0035256955,
0.0152497385,
-0.0035369021,
-0.0515057072,
-0.0172089916,
-0.0159287881,
-0.0431842953,
-0.0072285556,
0.0193035696,
2.743e-7,
0.0404695608,
0.0422838926,
0.0045516593,
0.0371026732,
0.0303009506,
0.0542015992,
-0.0104223434,
0.0049172738,
0.065491423,
-0.0722168162,
-0.0112435883,
0.0497861467,
0.024255164,
0.0626626387,
-0.0707671493,
-0.0041976371,
-0.0287876893,
-0.0246007424,
-0.0632114708,
0.0059583471,
0.0486814976,
0.0782568455,
0.0395336933,
-0.0064756875,
0.0130382199,
-0.0080334023,
0.0300990585,
-0.0321254581,
-0.0063017006,
-0.0039403322,
0.0447459258,
-0.0371155627,
0.013860587,
0.0662800595,
0.011096159,
-0.0063497121,
-0.0459849276,
0.043414548,
0.0018761751,
-0.0152334087,
-0.0566583276,
-0.0809545442,
0.0144844232,
-0.0958236605,
0.0816272572,
-0.0151780648,
-0.0088676782,
-0.0227345489,
-0.0011034887,
-0.0290372837,
0.0242700428,
0.003080071,
-0.0371069275,
-0.0061314357,
0.0058299284,
0.0258286018,
0.0051155174,
-0.0369935744,
-0.0318799019,
0.0060365894,
-0.0450202748,
-0.0527399108,
-0.0200791713,
-0.010067868,
0.0618633516,
-0.0654592961,
0.0330994725,
2.520101013e-34,
0.031651821,
-0.0038596119,
0.0474914126,
-0.0104730027,
0.0448104255,
0.0002495965,
0.0365756787,
0.025119476,
0.0362056419,
-0.0530650914,
-0.0270672552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14502v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14502v2 | RetICL: Sequential Retrieval of In-Context Examples with Reinforcement Learning | 2023-05-23T20:15:56 | 2024-04-16T17:25:25 | Alexander Scarlatos, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent developments in large pre-trained language models have enabled
unprecedented performance on a variety of downstream tasks. Achieving best
performance with these models often leverages in-context learning, where a
model performs a (possibly new) task given one or more examples. However,
recent work has shown that the choice of examples can have a large impact on
task performance and that finding an optimal set of examples is non-trivial.
While there are many existing methods for selecting in-context examples, they
generally score examples independently, ignoring the dependency between them
and the order in which they are provided to the model. In this work, we propose
Retrieval for In-Context Learning (RetICL), a learnable method for modeling and
optimally selecting examples sequentially for in-context learning. We frame the
problem of sequential example selection as a Markov decision process and train
an example retriever using reinforcement learning. We evaluate RetICL on math
word problem solving and scientific question answering tasks and show that it
consistently outperforms or matches heuristic and learnable baselines. We also
use case studies to show that RetICL implicitly learns representations of
problem solving strategies. | [
0.010699816,
0.0150497342,
0.0075817304,
-0.0020116039,
-0.0392387174,
0.002889056,
0.0066487947,
0.0041227508,
-0.0302669387,
-0.0544671081,
-0.0246046316,
-0.008697371,
-0.0476550274,
0.0055966564,
0.0054415986,
-0.0591390431,
0.0510748699,
-0.0482521243,
0.0302293412,
0.0176152308,
-0.0101559805,
-0.0050119148,
-0.0360364057,
0.0574980527,
-0.0087172585,
-0.0309601258,
-0.0076581445,
-0.0346164294,
0.0054108677,
-0.0564422533,
0.0603829958,
0.0192100164,
0.0601143874,
-0.0022808113,
0.0000019471,
-0.04848985,
-0.0339913666,
-0.0065724333,
-0.0478234328,
-0.0517081097,
-0.0046052621,
0.0155999977,
0.0055013378,
0.024931835,
-0.0758296475,
-0.0231632628,
0.0323550701,
0.0326654166,
0.027908897,
0.0834329128,
0.0034034506,
0.0203420017,
-0.0300780553,
-0.034421239,
0.0697328746,
-0.0309751611,
0.0001802368,
0.0243856013,
0.0285409912,
0.0150107201,
-0.016747579,
0.0233955476,
0.0424285755,
0.0243591871,
-0.0304209087,
0.0403494276,
-0.0145146251,
0.0221542343,
-0.0349190831,
0.0810835212,
-0.0490161553,
-0.0174953025,
-0.0017605666,
-0.0285863783,
-0.0048917923,
0.0111771114,
-0.0535975285,
-0.0011617247,
0.0008788062,
0.0318075716,
0.0149429468,
0.0362582281,
0.0197763462,
-0.0037441088,
-0.0334445462,
0.0535227843,
-0.0183650963,
-0.0453373082,
0.0301695783,
-0.0117328512,
-0.0174422935,
-0.0254534222,
0.0062809358,
0.0287931114,
-0.0593307763,
0.0399997085,
-0.0278549213,
-0.0253975615,
-0.0135299452,
0.0013650673,
0.0591799542,
0.0607113913,
0.0193094369,
0.0611307658,
-0.0036240066,
0.0273020174,
-0.0141855739,
0.0103928549,
-0.0185105074,
0.0200830456,
-0.0512374341,
0.0066350326,
-0.0792602822,
0.0479741469,
-0.0132270781,
-0.0210398063,
-0.0158665031,
0.0345216468,
-0.0295524728,
-0.0148910442,
-0.0131216776,
0.0188335422,
-0.0576385707,
0.0099681551,
-0.0449418314,
-0.0146732992,
-0.0495718159,
0.0056644389,
0.0350442603,
-0.0411251746,
-0.0320060663,
-0.0370347016,
-0.0012018391,
-0.0581342503,
0.010586679,
0.1004782841,
-0.0185747296,
-0.0694537833,
0.013619991,
-0.0196169838,
0.0331979655,
-0.0527493544,
0.0051893517,
-0.050808467,
0.0081598237,
0.0041894396,
-0.0300563779,
-0.0173310153,
0.024335131,
0.0488126464,
0.0032059317,
0.0626366585,
0.0416225381,
-0.0199514329,
0.009983398,
0.0074964133,
-0.0399628803,
0.0576864704,
0.0133875348,
-0.010354762,
0.03632994,
0.0252374876,
0.0328078642,
0.0054500904,
0.0642275289,
0.010493774,
-0.0182535239,
0.0432241186,
0.0041303271,
0.0344898179,
0.0155194337,
-0.0040968601,
-0.0624063648,
0.0032687183,
0.0222895574,
0.0720136389,
0.0161885954,
-0.0233963002,
0.0281696562,
0.0073278714,
-0.0104758451,
-0.007034908,
-0.0650679097,
0.0462120399,
-0.0134709608,
0.0006285213,
0.0031708186,
-0.0192124881,
-0.0421526879,
-0.0486573316,
0.0327360854,
0.0012064577,
-0.0107814437,
0.0516352914,
0.065772064,
0.0323767923,
-0.0576473549,
0.0117874825,
0.0161365606,
-0.027328454,
-0.043126829,
-0.0280256681,
0.0660897791,
0.022151893,
0.0522248894,
-0.1004166305,
-0.0251523908,
-0.0071230484,
0.0074849739,
-0.0236910246,
0.0547297224,
-0.0256093759,
0.0352082737,
-0.02850632,
-0.0274229459,
-0.0345821753,
-0.007333694,
0.0179785006,
0.072849907,
0.0287731346,
0.0060755475,
0.0037293073,
-0.0068338071,
0.0356751569,
-0.0363304988,
-0.0719102845,
0.0222555641,
0.0145250401,
0.028597869,
-0.0487790667,
-0.0008645607,
0.0237959474,
0.0255670417,
-0.0225970913,
0.0333555304,
0.0166677199,
-0.1046616584,
-0.0731661916,
0.003188119,
-0.019192487,
-0.0204390232,
0.0095377574,
-0.017264463,
-0.0245947,
0.0098367222,
-0.0218612906,
0.0639731288,
-0.0140461121,
-0.0054234178,
0.0273826383,
-0.0245100148,
-0.0412252545,
0.0691686049,
0.0080141788,
0.0491074137,
0.0047238502,
-0.0039733131,
-0.0249399077,
-0.0557638556,
0.0149354292,
-0.0262781717,
-0.0131416228,
0.0287839007,
0.0431089774,
0.0008341295,
-0.050229717,
0.0021911417,
-0.0194992963,
0.0151836034,
-0.0298000481,
0.0038379137,
-0.0045156218,
0.0100980923,
-0.0037254812,
-0.0688339919,
-0.02388677,
-0.0053734002,
0.0138841122,
0.0317441523,
0.0218160525,
0.0454594456,
0.0255874209,
-0.0567569174,
-0.0298146252,
-0.0083899209,
0.0390292853,
-0.0377175584,
0.0575250499,
-0.0153339673,
0.0329467393,
-0.0031716761,
0.0438796617,
-0.0334698148,
0.025093317,
0.0405292884,
-0.0730362609,
0.033580929,
0.0784221143,
-0.0075824214,
0.0971735865,
0.0271984469,
-0.0159950629,
-0.1003814787,
0.0377448872,
-0.0427042022,
0.0004726026,
-0.0013846273,
0.019178031,
0.025469793,
0.0474509746,
-0.0271470081,
0.0044255005,
-0.0296016373,
0.0436135568,
0.0064567793,
-0.0289817862,
-0.0535244085,
0.0236401949,
-0.0166988317,
0.0374943875,
-0.0207820609,
-0.0429750085,
0.0703301951,
0.0539801903,
-0.0085894763,
-0.0758815855,
-0.0169077069,
-0.0015616171,
0.0413090847,
0.010160285,
-0.0108666215,
-0.0276498776,
-0.0341928415,
-0.0483118072,
-0.0187134165,
0.0235540625,
-0.0315628015,
0.0469342135,
-0.0186669547,
0.021752011,
0.0023036578,
-0.0572219491,
-0.0808716193,
-0.0088191032,
0.0006979075,
0.0242668223,
-0.0481212363,
0.0124327168,
-0.0532086417,
-0.0168919489,
0.0492320806,
0.0480725542,
-0.0088527994,
-0.0333325826,
-0.0152169978,
0.0086004604,
0.037723951,
0.0197997913,
0.0234700516,
-0.0382491276,
0.0106656253,
0.0431251191,
0.1009282023,
-0.0413177311,
-0.0273970757,
0.0146634113,
0.01798556,
-0.0790475607,
-0.0003533048,
0.0799414441,
0.0062783663,
-0.092130363,
-0.0541743189,
0.0620771684,
0.0450217836,
-0.0373033583,
-0.0107349148,
-0.0075748204,
-0.0102731874,
0.0558252148,
0.0614986494,
-0.0561130159,
-0.0306445509,
0.0264178999,
0.0162057262,
0.0107522476,
-0.0314712338,
0.0072504161,
-0.1316035837,
0.0325205214,
-0.008461047,
-0.0676497146,
-0.0136959199,
-0.022472661,
0.000804184,
0.0056516835,
-0.0136480667,
0.0404490978,
-0.0291683264,
0.0284881759,
0.0146433525,
0.0366486125,
-0.0359725282,
0.0427925177,
-0.0249514449,
-0.0126526961,
0.0574676692,
-0.0159604121,
-0.0037210833,
-0.0303266346,
0.0010209595,
-0.0081778979,
-0.0006743221,
-0.0051896139,
0.0332122482,
-0.0149946501,
-0.019459825,
-0.0130912373,
0.045735389,
-0.0221798904,
-0.0560746454,
-0.0032069199,
0.0764630511,
-0.0378694125,
0.0193783324,
-0.0264411531,
-0.028773997,
0.069525376,
0.057046216,
0.0018783596,
-0.0419499353,
-0.0758001506,
-0.0072709136,
0.0193221159,
-0.0472182073,
0.0185973179,
-0.0103179133,
0.0059059574,
0.0562909208,
-0.0464325547,
-0.0506762415,
0.0426667631,
0.092376098,
-0.0142469639,
-0.0111106718,
0.0100490255,
0.0215240996,
-0.0703985468,
0.0345051698,
-0.0003144068,
0.014848046,
-0.0488441996,
0.0007496583,
-0.0063999677,
-0.0281444713,
-0.0463033356,
-0.0187068284,
-0.0096977269,
-0.0355999172,
-0.0075618117,
0.0971244872,
0.015738735,
0.0416644029,
-0.0004351397,
-0.022113774,
0.0713822544,
-0.0016183149,
-0.0435595177,
-0.0140694501,
0.048104208,
0.015538455,
0.0115358559,
0.0285579618,
-0.0637895539,
0.0142106768,
-0.0077254255,
0.0412230119,
-0.0372930393,
0.0254175086,
0.0346079916,
-0.0588567741,
0.0280539393,
0.0186394453,
0.0194788296,
-0.0336048976,
0.0346589163,
-0.0011620902,
-0.0169401597,
-0.0339208581,
0.0279761851,
-0.0050381636,
-0.0193734653,
0.0116134509,
-0.0186114125,
-0.0028397215,
0.0330215953,
-0.0171903539,
0.0107170111,
0.0438677371,
0.0171957761,
0.0317608267,
0.0306128096,
0.0022196251,
0.0186415445,
0.0043767923,
0.0646409988,
-0.0283482466,
0.0625554994,
0.0469755344,
0.0092039267,
-0.039018698,
-0.0154428547,
-0.0795682371,
-0.0228801817,
-0.0002006877,
0.0022838144,
0.0609769151,
-0.0457598493,
-0.0089217257,
-0.0250395406,
-0.0150767257,
-0.0128883589,
0.0148562463,
-0.0076800119,
-0.0154676549,
0.0181931313,
0.0523339547,
0.0164459348,
-0.0036171644,
0.0680210739,
-0.0195073243,
0.0263121016,
0.0255173724,
0.0163208637,
-0.0315241404,
0.0148072597,
0.0437268279,
0.0470233932,
0.0096353693,
-0.004121759,
-0.0142058721,
-0.0460592769,
0.0050858511,
0.0361950174,
-0.0579045154,
-0.0163297635,
0.0485519134,
0.0499486029,
-0.0037491764,
-0.0229050256,
-0.0439226627,
0.0181219503,
-0.0621774942,
-0.0283316728,
-0.0164200533,
-5.610379968e-33,
-0.0101342732,
-0.0250126161,
0.0336770453,
0.0100802463,
0.0271088295,
0.0174374115,
-0.055733569,
-0.015316139,
0.0047227493,
0.0209781937,
-0.0331319012,
0.0079645067,
0.0104856612,
0.0176154058,
0.0092794476,
0.0005937584,
0.0035304741,
-0.0204165988,
-0.0256166942,
0.0072572501,
0.0314178802,
0.0469886698,
0.0477268547,
-0.0519888811,
-0.0190518834,
0.0028706153,
0.0335701779,
0.016417658,
-0.0371148102,
0.0559405126,
0.001847438,
0.0116044674,
0.0131725557,
-0.0481704473,
-0.0247157682,
0.0323195867,
-0.1077236161,
-0.073375009,
-0.0273622163,
-0.0092816353,
-0.0805252045,
0.0031848329,
0.0055797831,
-0.0012160351,
0.0104647679,
0.0074934494,
0.0169825628,
-0.0078731878,
-0.0512217768,
-0.0249854494,
-0.0306177195,
-0.0022096813,
-0.0077567613,
-0.0373551957,
0.0363695882,
0.0218337085,
0.0056343405,
-0.0009264364,
-0.0275193248,
-0.0008503922,
0.0032370668,
0.0265452731,
-0.007146317,
0.0260910448,
0.023087794,
0.0509273969,
-0.0013828318,
-0.0211243499,
0.047670126,
-0.0507889166,
0.0252752174,
0.0568036586,
-0.0180325825,
0.0130490474,
0.0688677281,
0.0269449297,
-0.0664130077,
0.0215966944,
0.0359247029,
0.0606948361,
0.0134380301,
0.0152649665,
-0.0437358096,
-0.0002051787,
-0.0584284477,
0.0108556459,
-0.0361563936,
-0.0354959853,
0.0762928277,
0.0426320322,
0.0005974453,
0.0186631903,
0.053474199,
-0.0171754826,
-0.0351666175,
0.0318677574,
-0.052930899,
-0.0181637667,
-0.0016797564,
0.0169543885,
-0.0669091642,
-0.0245819651,
0.000069852,
-0.0219729543,
-0.0072691129,
0.0214561503,
0.0070796716,
0.0231165029,
-0.0754954144,
-0.0135315768,
-0.0167603996,
0.0474993847,
0.0361470021,
0.0166907944,
0.0440006517,
0.0193810035,
-0.0011599596,
0.0461599827,
0.0109859779,
-0.0822411403,
-0.046866823,
-0.0085979886,
-0.0142990155,
0.0070400713,
-0.0052158884,
-0.001140735,
-0.0395621695,
0.0550707653,
0.0275448114,
-0.0445833616,
0.0033124229,
0.0509593971,
2.588e-7,
0.019551022,
0.0356503241,
0.0224315133,
0.0326384678,
0.0191669855,
0.0326341316,
-0.0243607964,
-0.002670608,
0.0083523253,
0.0249226391,
0.0018322475,
0.0373285487,
0.023075236,
0.0256674923,
-0.0439581797,
0.0020575996,
-0.0601569898,
0.0051335036,
-0.0191956274,
-0.0356490575,
0.0091011543,
0.0809600949,
0.0183922481,
0.0072027966,
0.0043171491,
-0.0449722223,
0.0667794049,
-0.0288960133,
0.0312805064,
0.0063123428,
-0.0202887133,
0.0376834236,
-0.00625529,
-0.011225732,
-0.0259468909,
0.0431664884,
-0.0029135048,
0.0467222035,
-0.0002541793,
-0.069727011,
-0.016957907,
0.0122092878,
0.008077478,
-0.0193605758,
0.0536820292,
-0.121470578,
0.0130389826,
-0.0192422383,
-0.0108249392,
-0.0453637615,
0.0018027528,
0.0149145881,
-0.0015028368,
-0.0015036974,
0.0061805355,
0.0214171894,
-0.0088771479,
-0.11544054,
-0.0218927208,
0.0527546518,
-0.0037713756,
0.0283013191,
-0.0462666973,
-0.0030891539,
0.0108385012,
-0.0066152522,
-0.0240338277,
2.158534103e-34,
0.0126986681,
0.0008689082,
0.0272653177,
0.0651302263,
-0.0107443267,
-0.016795747,
-0.0221480019,
0.027145179,
0.0673035905,
-0.0417676978,
-0.042313382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14499v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14499v2 | NAIL: Lexical Retrieval Indices with Efficient Non-Autoregressive Decoders | 2023-05-23T20:09:52 | 2023-10-23T14:46:34 | Livio Baldini Soares, Daniel Gillick, Jeremy R. Cole, Tom Kwiatkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Neural document rerankers are extremely effective in terms of accuracy.
However, the best models require dedicated hardware for serving, which is
costly and often not feasible. To avoid this serving-time requirement, we
present a method of capturing up to 86% of the gains of a Transformer
cross-attention model with a lexicalized scoring function that only requires
10-6% of the Transformer's FLOPs per document and can be served using commodity
CPUs. When combined with a BM25 retriever, this approach matches the quality of
a state-of-the art dual encoder retriever, that still requires an accelerator
for query encoding. We introduce NAIL (Non-Autoregressive Indexing with
Language models) as a model architecture that is compatible with recent
encoder-decoder and decoder-only large language models, such as T5, GPT-3 and
PaLM. This model architecture can leverage existing pre-trained checkpoints and
can be fine-tuned for efficiently constructing document representations that do
not require neural processing of queries. | [
0.0116136186,
0.0509519018,
0.0128449211,
0.0316790268,
-0.0045188339,
0.0183393955,
-0.0171286054,
0.0172368307,
0.0257901885,
-0.0423025973,
-0.0550010502,
-0.009273191,
-0.0346655175,
0.0476749167,
-0.0142184608,
-0.0090158144,
0.0416686833,
0.0241603907,
0.0128883785,
-0.0019446464,
-0.0137950871,
0.0135390703,
0.0213333331,
0.0013976544,
0.0132049536,
-0.027469486,
-0.0306254011,
0.0149723878,
-0.0157842226,
-0.0151776839,
0.0171453785,
0.0052640135,
0.0364693478,
0.0727872252,
0.000002163,
0.0074365814,
-0.0509261154,
0.0092252372,
-0.0069605736,
-0.004348204,
0.0574530065,
-0.0504266322,
0.0111332992,
-0.0029128185,
-0.0143786306,
-0.0278557912,
0.0328417718,
0.0253310911,
0.0506106615,
0.0725064129,
-0.0093587879,
-0.0462323986,
0.0511510968,
-0.048417218,
-0.0112931626,
-0.0610980801,
-0.0211704969,
-0.0089379204,
0.0223424267,
0.051715225,
-0.0410483405,
0.0655865148,
0.0266508795,
-0.0022165179,
0.0189242922,
0.0252182297,
-0.0005616712,
0.0324690007,
-0.0284750499,
0.0210926048,
-0.0539116338,
-0.0192995518,
0.0007400547,
0.0128425239,
-0.0263722278,
-0.0292316619,
-0.0484065004,
0.0161214694,
-0.0005457207,
0.0170603916,
0.0294961426,
0.0394724272,
0.0438226871,
-0.008284336,
-0.0063346298,
0.0333975703,
0.0249052849,
-0.0191318411,
0.0057250997,
0.0334905237,
0.0408071168,
0.0170152541,
0.0503994487,
0.0026990203,
0.0078185964,
0.0023681335,
-0.0147289978,
-0.0308724716,
0.0037002561,
-0.0479174294,
0.0276717599,
0.0505055338,
-0.0084014013,
0.054941535,
-0.055712115,
0.0334937721,
-0.0409826711,
0.0144928666,
-0.0423221141,
-0.0314746462,
0.0178543758,
-0.0277172979,
-0.047195781,
0.0324809179,
-0.0165422354,
-0.0524863228,
0.0032835349,
0.0227305461,
0.0254286416,
-0.0455570556,
0.0216451306,
0.0228666011,
-0.0450633019,
-0.0316197574,
-0.0055447244,
0.0516651906,
-0.0111091053,
-0.0400308929,
0.0087476913,
-0.0673268437,
-0.0269616656,
-0.0171742998,
0.003208542,
-0.0293385107,
0.0043146685,
0.0224037021,
-0.0397447459,
-0.057327792,
0.0125823878,
0.0023361617,
0.0176550131,
-0.0173200537,
0.0004214381,
-0.0284558143,
0.0321709886,
0.0311393179,
0.0250404067,
-0.0470587015,
-0.0013773717,
0.0443984866,
-0.0296290889,
0.0005147269,
0.0515243411,
-0.0446069054,
0.0319703929,
-0.0053565088,
0.0140041774,
0.0435361601,
0.0032636067,
0.0612466671,
0.0401684083,
0.0084185936,
-0.0219079051,
-0.0007057788,
0.0124200145,
-0.0394639224,
0.0047270046,
-0.0032797109,
-0.0099405618,
0.0228664987,
0.0560143441,
0.0268099438,
-0.0405462012,
-0.0577824824,
0.0253024213,
0.05616723,
0.0355737545,
0.0339855403,
-0.0196370892,
-0.0199401267,
-0.0354920141,
-0.0269482061,
-0.009009691,
0.0622064658,
0.0041514453,
-0.0004631191,
0.0653320625,
0.0188021492,
-0.0325319879,
-0.0142201371,
0.0125679607,
0.0171408337,
-0.0158591848,
0.0328887403,
0.0341621265,
-0.0093995482,
-0.0418027267,
0.0715577155,
-0.0247385688,
-0.0404666737,
0.0057514086,
-0.02864068,
-0.0331275463,
0.0647389591,
0.0759495795,
-0.0206809472,
0.004302267,
0.0077839438,
-0.0121081369,
0.0309105199,
0.0193484016,
0.0088620698,
-0.0022391207,
-0.0735451579,
-0.0134356106,
-0.02748725,
0.0073075606,
0.0584630221,
0.0124176014,
0.0324887522,
0.0339946561,
-0.0301154722,
-0.0020146077,
0.0164737757,
-0.0008196405,
-0.0634746179,
0.0157791115,
-0.0228708144,
0.0130971987,
-0.0024775073,
-0.0002865037,
0.0272928551,
0.0694443956,
-0.0379107185,
0.0047568632,
-0.055227235,
-0.0420626551,
-0.0190575607,
-0.0047066542,
-0.0167202745,
0.0381875634,
0.0684837252,
-0.019801002,
-0.026385475,
0.0195953771,
-0.0214716662,
0.0484336242,
-0.0562320463,
0.0234811995,
0.0147757567,
0.0213980284,
-0.027082894,
0.0359680355,
-0.0181598198,
0.0408827327,
-0.0207800083,
-0.0198330805,
-0.0235963278,
-0.0474066809,
-0.0389227457,
0.0181104727,
0.0053736777,
0.0199880265,
0.0264205057,
-0.0188868809,
0.0039957673,
-0.0327641256,
-0.073364906,
0.004523376,
-0.0379104353,
-0.0139668752,
0.0063407728,
0.0236627571,
0.0276712403,
-0.0347825624,
-0.0306954645,
-0.0236949697,
0.0050120768,
0.0413209423,
-0.0115359509,
-0.0388773158,
0.0176723506,
-0.0128990933,
-0.0822066292,
0.019065829,
0.0458688438,
-0.0247188881,
-0.0083636893,
-0.0240250602,
-0.0249453913,
0.0130237117,
0.0172290467,
-0.0320102163,
0.0066837175,
-0.0002289218,
-0.0328284763,
-0.0056458563,
0.0885947272,
0.0088817496,
0.0406057462,
0.0184632782,
-0.0143609578,
-0.0791733637,
0.0178500321,
-0.0154750189,
-0.0009930636,
0.0142680462,
0.0069264793,
0.0131215537,
0.0476218536,
-0.0238974094,
0.0252935756,
-0.0249313228,
-0.0269634891,
0.0211860593,
-0.0331986882,
-0.0590454079,
0.0068492265,
-0.0241104048,
0.0023908166,
-0.0246451609,
-0.0176418871,
0.0468431413,
-0.0058758906,
-0.0096353283,
-0.0297643486,
0.0196797699,
-0.0444547758,
0.0366941057,
0.0244605299,
0.0245855637,
-0.0634467527,
-0.0467408746,
0.0343656391,
0.0435862429,
0.0028753239,
-0.0616569221,
0.0400908329,
0.0323260203,
0.0294852816,
-0.0154686393,
-0.0463463478,
-0.0244748443,
-0.0127149504,
-0.0083060618,
-0.0029274104,
0.0512380823,
0.0056821923,
-0.0569561757,
0.045891095,
0.0301349927,
0.0954376906,
-0.039765574,
-0.0051158825,
-0.0024871156,
0.0644315183,
0.0239528455,
-0.0238341782,
0.0007570786,
-0.0225832555,
-0.0178002026,
0.0694734082,
0.0364022516,
-0.0338049904,
-0.0130346464,
0.02049491,
0.0683563054,
-0.0412899628,
-0.0233482402,
-0.01499628,
-0.0592877939,
-0.0851911455,
-0.0534482636,
0.0691731498,
0.0192408264,
-0.0899451301,
-0.0388164781,
-0.0304611735,
-0.0053673382,
0.0174860768,
0.0397818089,
-0.0532999076,
-0.0233578198,
0.0181644596,
0.0301056635,
0.0185673274,
0.0032810173,
-0.0071779294,
-0.097660698,
0.0590759553,
-0.0053457273,
0.0100730788,
-0.0151748452,
-0.052476123,
-0.0303601995,
0.0029063462,
-0.0166952685,
0.0691000596,
-0.0029326745,
-0.0144694112,
-0.0058197849,
0.0345537513,
-0.008727747,
0.0004057297,
-0.0146725243,
-0.0327777974,
0.0499429144,
0.01273611,
0.0117654987,
-0.0607398711,
0.0052664671,
-0.02914083,
0.0031548077,
-0.0080443528,
0.0411559753,
-0.0739055499,
0.0109144505,
-0.0144779542,
-0.0156021612,
-0.0259361826,
0.0403958187,
-0.0494151041,
0.0702576488,
-0.0308212582,
0.0310559273,
-0.0240237843,
-0.0625642017,
-0.0577747971,
0.0446396619,
-0.0013850833,
0.0060180142,
-0.0430752486,
-0.0316504315,
0.0215950571,
-0.0460701622,
-0.0373991504,
0.0047690854,
-0.0013093373,
-0.0596101135,
-0.0410792716,
-0.0381755978,
-0.0222738162,
0.0216268525,
-0.0174341612,
-0.0128999436,
-0.002169746,
-0.0289431345,
-0.0853883997,
-0.0024912735,
-0.0244023111,
-0.006742748,
-0.0840505138,
0.0447546914,
0.0574444234,
-0.0071321479,
-0.0369352996,
0.02412479,
-0.0436954945,
-0.0270322096,
0.0250651166,
0.0415730886,
0.0116916848,
0.0083298497,
-0.0183478221,
-0.0446869768,
0.0340668745,
0.0426478274,
-0.0388391167,
-0.0195832811,
0.0131328823,
-0.0646498725,
-0.0358103365,
0.0222945139,
-0.0685997233,
0.0244534202,
-0.0428987555,
0.0253743809,
-0.0164405033,
-0.0523681939,
0.009167498,
-0.0098490072,
0.0555759929,
0.0195479281,
0.028630564,
-0.0158377942,
0.048005309,
-0.0379957743,
-0.0035712791,
-0.0179451965,
-0.0034251006,
0.0524766855,
-0.0263475087,
-0.0354452059,
0.0602889657,
0.0635976866,
0.004177371,
-0.057989873,
0.0066898754,
-0.037594419,
0.0067441282,
-0.0471740663,
-0.005699805,
-0.0530402586,
0.0151691809,
0.0160057582,
0.0716388226,
-0.0492844768,
0.0171534475,
0.0236408189,
-0.0118960459,
-0.0470576435,
0.0520388484,
-0.0845858827,
-0.011844662,
-0.0461762287,
-0.0229393151,
0.0554465204,
-0.0390861519,
0.0505506992,
0.0167896505,
-0.0186017379,
-0.0162218735,
-0.0167470332,
0.048823487,
-0.0449914299,
-0.0226643831,
0.0431489646,
0.0127994809,
0.0035205863,
0.0642127618,
-0.0147657497,
-0.0194262732,
0.0217733867,
-0.0546156429,
-0.0200278684,
-0.0058594896,
0.0084196888,
0.0214615781,
0.004320452,
-0.0407132879,
0.0155081218,
-0.0077434047,
0.055143781,
-0.0053679799,
-0.0176145993,
-0.0498992018,
0.01501441,
0.0652112514,
0.0065826504,
-0.0501269437,
-0.0524918512,
0.0459390841,
-0.0391626023,
-0.0302638896,
-0.0139290867,
-6.757651802e-33,
-0.0124845468,
0.0227916688,
-0.0110039134,
-0.0095751146,
-0.0266090073,
0.051838614,
-0.0264956765,
-0.0480698608,
0.0119873667,
-0.01312418,
-0.0483390018,
0.0379075631,
0.0174366944,
0.0282684695,
0.0393327288,
0.0203524679,
0.0664636567,
-0.0061263139,
-0.0219550245,
0.0175804384,
0.0577219091,
0.0762727782,
0.0365752168,
0.0044782581,
-0.0063025067,
-0.0009793796,
0.0385199413,
-0.0434476957,
0.0359147824,
0.029148886,
-0.0347717479,
0.0297558792,
0.0163357276,
-0.0877910331,
-0.001116496,
0.0133156097,
-0.1255933344,
0.0030032569,
-0.0408007093,
0.0110509647,
0.008065355,
-0.0092982966,
0.0267801657,
0.0376567245,
-0.0075402283,
-0.0237884335,
-0.0023949684,
0.0025816965,
-0.059561152,
-0.0617415421,
0.002680782,
0.0259569548,
0.0205587745,
-0.0056130108,
0.0699365288,
0.0275123809,
-0.0043691555,
0.0596406274,
-0.1040906981,
-0.0150651047,
-0.0285173599,
0.0795784369,
0.0440918915,
0.025030734,
-0.0000492714,
0.0555991307,
0.0203493573,
-0.0135352556,
-0.002928528,
-0.0018203605,
0.0343328491,
0.0094581814,
0.0253201891,
0.0051962086,
0.0776840076,
-0.0025000887,
-0.0493235588,
0.0504656509,
0.0434183367,
0.0628505945,
0.0707157329,
0.0509731211,
-0.0599584244,
-0.0127741229,
0.0041705337,
-0.0156994741,
-0.0353132822,
-0.0292143561,
0.036562629,
0.0320500843,
0.0118484227,
0.0258798078,
0.0778471902,
-0.0133974086,
0.0140606342,
0.0539255887,
0.0429069847,
0.0070668049,
-0.0003765821,
0.0402038731,
-0.0146345971,
0.019343514,
-0.0003622573,
-0.0112531055,
-0.0225337427,
-0.0302384514,
-0.0126668634,
0.0119804591,
-0.0800051838,
-0.013758515,
-0.014201615,
-0.0041652122,
-0.0084474022,
0.0706766024,
0.0190141089,
-0.0056861872,
-0.0017024183,
0.0726768449,
-0.0149193639,
0.026277326,
-0.0147567056,
-0.0222401489,
0.0341905318,
-0.0044108932,
0.0078213187,
0.0413760804,
-0.0301975459,
0.052774962,
0.0047653732,
-0.079250738,
-0.0064492431,
0.0514125451,
2.982e-7,
0.0321375579,
0.0580230542,
0.0400435627,
0.0101989359,
0.0191078894,
-0.0064741955,
0.0286429897,
0.0753341764,
0.0214757714,
0.0044712741,
0.0126850717,
0.0117109297,
0.0579583645,
0.0289766546,
-0.0908161923,
0.0082336403,
-0.0813070983,
-0.0044651683,
-0.001020874,
-0.0767363235,
0.0076965075,
0.0693420023,
-0.0444353968,
0.017914759,
0.0250048563,
-0.0321512409,
0.0694108084,
0.016531745,
-0.0099461367,
-0.0258644763,
0.0687431172,
0.0386175178,
-0.010985543,
-0.0228614155,
-0.010493095,
0.0554743409,
0.0292257704,
0.0584786572,
-0.0339890122,
-0.0850745216,
0.0135828061,
0.0026367977,
-0.0220648516,
-0.0451427959,
0.0614752844,
-0.0249389242,
0.0028911866,
-0.0055010458,
-0.0591070354,
0.0166323949,
0.0065748612,
-0.0022118753,
-0.0322497934,
0.0279263016,
0.0254988987,
-0.0165314972,
0.0098754168,
-0.0912223533,
-0.0218266416,
0.0160745066,
-0.0277144592,
0.0355912969,
-0.0628374517,
-0.0329153128,
-0.0028042693,
-0.0358477011,
-0.0232672282,
2.680974991e-34,
0.0830322653,
-0.0081742322,
0.013441694,
0.045259513,
0.0194011237,
-0.0022831454,
0.0116774114,
0.0112768188,
-0.0010838591,
-0.1201179996,
-0.0430722721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14497v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14497v2 | Self-Polish: Enhance Reasoning in Large Language Models via Problem Refinement | 2023-05-23T19:58:30 | 2024-04-18T07:27:00 | Zhiheng Xi, Senjie Jin, Yuhao Zhou, Rui Zheng, Songyang Gao, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To enhance the multi-step reasoning capabilities of large language models,
researchers have extensively explored prompting methods, notably the
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) method which explicitly elicits human-like rationales.
However, they have inadvertently overlooked the potential of enhancing model
reasoning performance by formulating higher-quality problems. In this work, we
start from the problem side and propose Self-Polish (SP), a novel method that
facilitates the model's reasoning by guiding it to progressively refine the
given problems to be more comprehensible and solvable. We also explore several
automatic prompting varients and propose the Self-Polish prompt bank for the
community. SP is orthogonal to all other prompting methods of answer/reasoning
side like CoT, allowing for seamless integration with state-of-the-art
techniques for further improvement. Thorough experiments show that the proposed
method attains notable and consistent effectiveness on five reasoning
benchmarks across different models. Furthermore, our method also showcases
impressive performance on robustness evaluation. Codes and prompts are
available at https://github.com/WooooDyy/Self-Polish. | [
0.0247993302,
0.0469418205,
-0.018965628,
0.0443135723,
-0.0436383225,
0.0091873342,
0.0135053648,
-0.0113852676,
0.0101383161,
0.0023848705,
0.0160538647,
0.0239634365,
-0.0156217488,
0.0378741622,
0.0163835138,
-0.0701461732,
0.030093126,
-0.0694616958,
0.0179819074,
-0.032227952,
0.011090233,
0.0175733045,
-0.0183518343,
0.0212674271,
0.0277679265,
-0.0640231371,
-0.0334648602,
-0.0019961451,
-0.0226057861,
-0.0499427915,
-0.015792409,
0.085443899,
-0.0203407835,
0.0207889583,
0.0000026085,
-0.0790111274,
-0.0288278796,
-0.0046668886,
-0.0624337271,
0.004155512,
0.0014699769,
0.0190960858,
0.0041820789,
0.0283290688,
-0.0399218127,
0.0317278467,
0.0187716242,
0.0396054722,
0.0888980478,
0.0174045637,
0.0051449086,
-0.0408308618,
0.0003674576,
0.0145481536,
-0.0027261311,
-0.0187899377,
-0.0087126615,
0.0253051184,
0.0637865737,
0.0199650787,
-0.0028045769,
0.0409896523,
0.0580520667,
-0.058146175,
0.0075544775,
0.0146183362,
-0.0090177022,
-0.0535327196,
-0.0085663293,
0.0542150624,
-0.0073697139,
-0.0325804427,
-0.0367829911,
-0.0012447244,
0.0247914419,
0.0365323611,
-0.0547098815,
0.0388635695,
-0.0076406128,
-0.0063689686,
0.019488221,
0.0259073265,
0.0232380163,
0.0124123972,
-0.0107096527,
0.1278610379,
0.0147111816,
-0.0116298646,
-0.0024249041,
-0.0164148472,
-0.0017620657,
-0.0820294172,
0.0229729209,
0.0742146894,
-0.0646009222,
-0.0029377069,
0.0189986024,
0.0155557515,
0.0276638344,
0.0049619772,
0.0103735877,
0.0515262596,
-0.0201251153,
0.0735825077,
-0.026613025,
0.028093392,
-0.0182988346,
0.0056230044,
-0.036180798,
-0.0008135843,
-0.0568100363,
-0.0147440685,
-0.0676542073,
0.0235422682,
-0.00611265,
0.0236495957,
-0.0003520449,
0.0415973924,
-0.0072411415,
0.0212538913,
0.0129832672,
0.0020758347,
0.0277470127,
-0.0387554727,
-0.0334493332,
0.04846102,
-0.0968059897,
-0.0179682244,
0.0236445609,
-0.0339284986,
0.0005773398,
-0.0152072208,
-0.0109765548,
-0.0234538633,
0.0049547758,
0.024112206,
0.0047425586,
0.022789631,
-0.0238281116,
-0.0541466326,
-0.0106326845,
-0.0519782379,
-0.0277103521,
-0.0941596925,
0.0068647177,
0.0360466763,
-0.0093012005,
-0.0604010671,
-0.0025053702,
0.0121128839,
-0.0018465278,
0.0734919608,
-0.0771195814,
0.0173986256,
0.0187452603,
0.0289711207,
-0.0264758654,
0.0425362885,
0.0188072268,
0.0089740111,
0.0429440364,
-0.01306511,
0.0364370272,
0.0164285284,
0.0054706079,
-0.0173774529,
0.0014487859,
0.0377194434,
-0.0084376009,
0.0251908395,
-0.019107081,
0.0371433347,
-0.0060779797,
0.0141369514,
0.02267804,
0.0425882451,
0.0073614516,
0.0261220094,
0.0256644208,
-0.0183875989,
0.0160550382,
0.0180411525,
-0.0354362354,
0.0454302356,
-0.0511873662,
0.0041306699,
0.0101106297,
0.0277360138,
-0.0207512137,
-0.0545808785,
0.0012929046,
0.0330798328,
0.0351445004,
0.0220027305,
0.0212690067,
0.0202130172,
0.0161897466,
0.0357541591,
0.0320846289,
-0.0430112965,
-0.0203909315,
-0.0629763305,
0.0939154029,
0.0592750981,
0.050488323,
-0.0202813372,
-0.0251978803,
-0.0157947689,
0.0266101509,
-0.0011662632,
0.0244237557,
-0.0217756499,
-0.0502978042,
-0.0237633772,
-0.0302003454,
-0.0168330614,
0.0044145067,
0.0075846189,
0.0003996711,
-0.0214837063,
-0.0056465999,
-0.0075470824,
-0.0024549926,
0.0047795856,
0.0045311125,
0.0081213275,
-0.0286345296,
0.0175152402,
-0.0165485684,
0.0329056792,
0.0210700817,
0.0452476442,
0.0153722847,
-0.0385898165,
-0.0101926103,
0.0147295957,
-0.0595833845,
-0.0379123464,
0.0500095561,
0.0024771236,
-0.0566064343,
-0.0176252685,
-0.0037128069,
-0.0254009962,
0.0237399191,
-0.014781191,
-0.0100257881,
-0.0203086175,
0.0342476964,
-0.0226177722,
-0.0229211096,
-0.0274003465,
0.067549482,
0.0278645717,
0.0041593178,
0.0259127673,
0.0471250415,
0.0400721319,
-0.0520666316,
-0.0045651281,
0.0473704636,
-0.0060339738,
-0.0198975652,
0.0340847336,
0.0471387953,
-0.0660693571,
0.0040751938,
-0.0720304549,
-0.0292066969,
-0.0164736137,
0.0021964544,
0.0027438446,
0.028358493,
-0.0088911662,
-0.0353360288,
-0.0553665683,
-0.034155976,
0.0232731253,
0.0360511094,
0.0263173319,
0.0033292896,
-0.0187174361,
0.0160054024,
-0.0155165801,
-0.0165209044,
0.0344476961,
0.0143715879,
0.0139718195,
-0.0695051774,
0.0205826778,
-0.0514871478,
-0.0180783104,
0.0197873879,
-0.0136111276,
0.0342242569,
-0.0250151698,
0.0743384883,
0.0454062633,
-0.008293584,
-0.0022768569,
0.0587156266,
-0.0257995222,
-0.050380934,
0.0165276844,
0.0063536293,
0.0221385527,
0.0199409984,
-0.0346309394,
-0.0239761397,
0.0606820136,
-0.0332319848,
-0.0012958146,
-0.0714066327,
0.0684660748,
-0.0319992229,
-0.0020297868,
-0.0596858226,
-0.0496917032,
0.0102251153,
0.0861876905,
-0.0137584358,
-0.0269789193,
0.0993954912,
-0.0258363336,
-0.0192239024,
-0.0224606227,
-0.0008785788,
-0.0336173996,
0.0923701301,
-0.0108724227,
0.0130414823,
0.0126719559,
-0.001068744,
-0.0285220202,
-0.0326531306,
0.0484412387,
-0.0208203215,
0.0175584108,
-0.0581529029,
-0.0180648603,
0.0111983791,
-0.0598978996,
-0.0363522284,
-0.0313262977,
-0.0648828819,
0.0039730952,
-0.0068303682,
0.0009501041,
0.0582258403,
0.0055556274,
0.0475258082,
0.0362922773,
-0.0196390655,
-0.016037548,
-0.0130446022,
0.0233543366,
0.0344087183,
0.0321373306,
0.0529910587,
-0.0208407119,
0.0678410679,
0.0572438575,
0.044205863,
-0.0223117229,
-0.0226356983,
0.0365894437,
0.0041034506,
-0.0080907475,
-0.0228018835,
0.017378334,
0.0459412262,
-0.0783961192,
-0.0215150043,
0.1154761538,
0.0531756021,
-0.0300998259,
0.0130862305,
-0.0871424749,
0.0532711446,
0.0356245339,
0.0593970716,
-0.0669608563,
-0.0379934087,
0.0432782769,
0.0020172044,
-0.0030458113,
-0.0472339652,
-0.0155258393,
-0.1094083413,
0.0446799323,
-0.0130971503,
-0.0064310692,
-0.0134163722,
-0.0404511206,
-0.0124949999,
0.0287632272,
-0.0118890461,
0.0570287965,
0.0049478337,
0.0101354476,
0.0173090342,
-0.0231305826,
-0.013215729,
0.0344949514,
-0.0371225514,
0.0373291001,
0.0472164266,
0.017891841,
0.0294505674,
-0.0639408827,
0.0254369173,
-0.0086296424,
-0.0038960811,
-0.038663432,
-0.0083536273,
0.0458311662,
0.0011058773,
-0.0293214582,
0.0310289934,
-0.0211098194,
-0.0639622509,
0.0401132815,
0.1154089049,
-0.0063877129,
-0.0069618002,
0.0028297429,
-0.0059743267,
-0.0182887167,
0.0673164353,
0.041115243,
-0.0339891501,
-0.0204437468,
-0.0586621463,
-0.0558033958,
-0.0305824336,
-0.0600187592,
0.0061449674,
0.0316257626,
0.0119666196,
-0.0520461574,
-0.0433876216,
0.0501981601,
0.0507429503,
-0.0000309126,
-0.0173812211,
-0.0016487795,
0.0155000407,
0.008185016,
0.0465462394,
-0.051751852,
0.0197173599,
-0.0725867897,
0.0402204394,
-0.035053812,
-0.0376118198,
-0.0115664797,
-0.005447553,
-0.0208650846,
-0.0420670509,
0.0092551755,
0.0525168367,
0.0316552818,
0.0209646616,
-0.0352436379,
-0.0634326115,
-0.0019402588,
0.0039761444,
-0.0710133985,
-0.0444438644,
0.0125478227,
0.0114458418,
0.0072309827,
0.0391805246,
-0.0252838638,
0.0135099916,
-0.0243465304,
0.0474258624,
-0.0149548892,
-0.0495013706,
0.0607810654,
0.0757642537,
-0.0064275288,
-0.00379343,
-0.0173172969,
-0.0389123447,
0.0258551501,
-0.0354598463,
-0.0672359392,
-0.027294185,
0.0594788603,
-0.0159570482,
-0.0619732551,
0.0262232404,
-0.0265062973,
-0.0213669147,
0.0105322106,
-0.0115000429,
0.020926673,
0.0125158522,
0.0416983664,
0.0480492339,
-0.0163604766,
0.0002761372,
0.003367207,
0.0078614959,
0.0476604924,
-0.0199044794,
0.0890346617,
0.0374218561,
-0.0298150461,
-0.0440849401,
0.0173772294,
-0.0552935861,
-0.0840925798,
0.0456390195,
0.0238409787,
0.0194220357,
0.0005501951,
0.0060195704,
-0.0209323466,
-0.031149134,
0.0156918634,
0.0066026426,
0.0616189651,
-0.0573671758,
0.0231984742,
0.042346213,
-0.0011453499,
-0.0122322841,
0.0213668719,
-0.0697851703,
0.0078232596,
0.0151807442,
0.0086423261,
-0.0396750495,
-0.0075246654,
-0.0549339466,
0.0036011175,
-0.0302648526,
0.0118886502,
-0.0832387656,
-0.0607573651,
-0.0332270227,
0.0297919251,
-0.0260625165,
0.0098385066,
0.0391492583,
0.0544417538,
-0.004160095,
-0.0201692861,
-0.0220771413,
0.0463716388,
-0.0119907027,
-0.0223051403,
-0.0103822118,
-6.787218424e-33,
-0.0089675449,
-0.0451546907,
0.0377348885,
-0.0237780772,
0.0258565973,
-0.0527222008,
-0.0875942111,
0.0368290208,
-0.0098706149,
0.044578433,
-0.0481216349,
-0.0157162864,
0.0052471096,
-0.0117661618,
0.0210318007,
-0.0050171022,
0.0276241172,
0.0176170133,
-0.0486831106,
0.0245310627,
0.0096852081,
-0.0096274056,
-0.0129215363,
-0.0352711268,
0.0445500575,
-0.0178406332,
-0.0316572674,
0.0593864359,
-0.0442288555,
0.0490798391,
-0.0068906602,
0.0074433032,
0.0256194435,
-0.0503864959,
-0.0091918521,
0.0189572331,
-0.0566520803,
-0.0459090769,
0.028288871,
-0.026924368,
-0.0895865038,
-0.0400915332,
-0.0016352361,
0.0038438069,
0.0050547202,
0.0241945293,
0.0140809808,
-0.0252910908,
0.0164193362,
0.0343802311,
-0.042021066,
0.0092036622,
-0.0349502787,
-0.0512525328,
0.0147869978,
0.063691318,
-0.0200243108,
0.0032343343,
-0.0214536488,
0.0341181681,
0.044331532,
0.0111226747,
0.0639832169,
-0.0243280958,
-0.0314124785,
0.013095988,
-0.0102148866,
-0.0106686773,
-0.0223671235,
0.0238699373,
-0.0144811282,
0.039376691,
0.1183642149,
0.0300816819,
-0.0079722526,
0.0390278734,
-0.0471437946,
0.0235968288,
0.0354390293,
0.0400255956,
0.0142522389,
0.0060264333,
-0.02241005,
-0.025210334,
-0.0487985425,
-0.0159405544,
-0.0500901639,
-0.0241528507,
0.0208224785,
-0.0318279453,
-0.0510296747,
-0.0241785534,
0.0194776375,
-0.0047902693,
-0.0428843722,
0.0291807931,
-0.0077335518,
0.010123821,
0.005416011,
0.0593686476,
0.0045778919,
0.0241558664,
-0.0226051286,
-0.0031061736,
0.0281320047,
0.0298676249,
0.0157623477,
-0.0000744887,
-0.0551146902,
-0.0012524746,
-0.0613291785,
0.0268367175,
0.0015782184,
0.0144836577,
0.0213247389,
0.0135952439,
-0.0114910705,
0.0514574535,
0.0305138472,
-0.0172292106,
-0.0536624119,
0.0393888503,
0.0214948356,
0.0129412981,
0.0053320951,
-0.0059447647,
-0.0449250191,
0.0453015789,
0.0274169408,
-0.0236211959,
-0.0100571048,
0.0117332675,
3.088e-7,
0.0208285172,
0.0481405072,
0.0060083061,
0.0006168596,
0.0217883289,
0.0428044014,
-0.0285237953,
-0.0607500896,
0.0303860027,
-0.0420005284,
-0.0201574117,
0.0491250902,
0.0296871625,
0.0611413158,
-0.0826252997,
0.000789526,
-0.057534039,
-0.0018689424,
-0.0474893041,
-0.0028136759,
0.0506442524,
0.0440955348,
0.0176403113,
-0.0095311608,
-0.0061863754,
-0.017602941,
0.0095718587,
-0.0016544054,
0.0059169238,
0.0217160434,
-0.0011128808,
-0.0181472078,
0.0208422299,
0.0158941615,
0.0049126232,
-0.0118676992,
-0.012698655,
0.0239250213,
0.0098180687,
0.0164347049,
-0.0159089491,
-0.0286111925,
0.0133981798,
-0.1046806872,
0.0764726549,
-0.0340160541,
-0.029678626,
-0.0021267589,
0.0192116927,
-0.0416853465,
0.0135130566,
-0.0194034707,
-0.0348725766,
0.00625154,
0.0027143045,
-0.005255843,
-0.0033371397,
-0.0558761917,
-0.0467378087,
-0.007594429,
-0.0177173503,
-0.0171057377,
-0.0489550121,
-0.0016338784,
0.0137653556,
-0.0851164684,
-0.0015231168,
3.005530129e-34,
0.0299721025,
0.0112597421,
0.0475937873,
0.0153784091,
0.0549011938,
0.0068244589,
-0.0129650719,
0.0110647352,
0.0504534468,
-0.0804130211,
-0.0451877452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14493v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14493v4 | Do prompt positions really matter? | 2023-05-23T19:45:45 | 2024-06-28T12:04:53 | Junyu Mao, Stuart E. Middleton, Mahesan Niranjan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt-based models have gathered a lot of attention from researchers due to
their remarkable advancements in the fields of zero-shot and few-shot learning.
Developing an effective prompt template plays a critical role. However, prior
studies have mainly focused on prompt vocabulary searching or embedding
initialization within a predefined template with the prompt position fixed. In
this empirical study, we conduct the most comprehensive analysis to date of
prompt position for diverse Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Our
findings quantify the substantial impact prompt position has on model
performance. We observe that the prompt positions used in prior studies are
often sub-optimal, and this observation is consistent even in widely used
instruction-tuned models. These findings suggest prompt position optimisation
as a valuable research direction to augment prompt engineering methodologies
and prompt position-aware instruction tuning as a potential way to build more
robust models in the future. | [
0.0502397418,
-0.0026498232,
-0.0023987766,
0.0078548426,
-0.0403197035,
0.005747865,
0.0592436343,
-0.0273915194,
-0.0202485044,
-0.0580551662,
-0.0147470636,
-0.0522786081,
-0.0051899953,
0.0105268508,
-0.0060227835,
-0.0410844535,
0.0735551491,
0.0001710875,
0.0161586627,
0.024257876,
-0.040294975,
-0.0220833421,
-0.0435924716,
0.0472475328,
0.0015577109,
-0.0322756954,
-0.0430990607,
0.0365468003,
0.0060215774,
-0.0343300439,
0.0086203292,
0.0702694356,
-0.0144131184,
0.0236866437,
0.0000019217,
-0.0485041663,
-0.0143084563,
-0.0140933134,
-0.0667497143,
0.009945753,
0.021693578,
-0.0144756613,
0.0003805454,
0.0103498613,
-0.0152090685,
-0.0199040454,
0.0392373651,
0.013889486,
0.0194222126,
0.0814536288,
0.0018245294,
-0.0020125827,
-0.0131426295,
-0.0243304353,
0.0308427606,
-0.0406904183,
-0.0097966697,
-0.0953991488,
0.0200208072,
0.0695419684,
-0.0482062325,
0.044707004,
0.0058810259,
0.0218878817,
0.0490226708,
0.0420945883,
0.016996501,
-0.0673095137,
-0.0637837648,
0.0353596993,
-0.016463533,
0.0150730107,
-0.0065968442,
-0.0513900965,
0.0306366552,
0.0063256538,
-0.0209502187,
0.0492253341,
-0.008836301,
-0.0207423214,
-0.0056235092,
-0.0028378486,
-0.02416596,
0.0039252546,
-0.0110879056,
0.0635145605,
0.0033245522,
-0.0531602651,
0.0045434572,
0.0086233234,
-0.0288889818,
-0.0361498557,
-0.0167980045,
0.0283723455,
-0.0599638671,
0.0365228243,
-0.0192046259,
-0.0086840177,
0.0239235498,
0.0172023848,
0.0855012089,
0.0733645186,
-0.0117339995,
0.0315806605,
-0.0250638351,
0.0436137207,
0.0083512031,
0.0123103047,
-0.0199899152,
0.0628838465,
-0.0373708718,
-0.0334868059,
-0.0483541638,
-0.0013776335,
-0.040964175,
-0.0468476452,
-0.0240903944,
0.071594134,
0.0218680482,
0.0075525865,
-0.0190474726,
0.0236480664,
-0.0245171953,
0.0345283411,
-0.0137624843,
0.0117226839,
-0.0574462228,
0.0042958409,
0.0397657976,
-0.0561581068,
-0.0426127799,
-0.0176483691,
0.0095585147,
-0.0421190672,
-0.0224255472,
-0.0162458532,
0.000734871,
-0.0826671869,
0.0070922645,
-0.0244699568,
-0.0165193826,
-0.0162017941,
0.0208151061,
-0.0104563525,
0.0393389091,
0.0204470791,
0.02179344,
-0.0110534746,
-0.0112298792,
0.0594052188,
-0.0275527835,
0.0887045935,
0.0090612452,
0.0091825174,
-0.0132379225,
0.0020296795,
-0.0016876182,
0.0706700459,
-0.0310302377,
0.0226938762,
0.0506605916,
-0.0130295064,
-0.0123678949,
0.0100731347,
0.0020298138,
-0.0268183332,
-0.0156659409,
0.0108922692,
0.0521999188,
0.0311971698,
0.0202701744,
-0.0059085987,
-0.0299501866,
0.0204322319,
0.0139992228,
0.0797562376,
-0.0071371552,
-0.061584089,
0.0673020184,
0.0227177963,
-0.0346627161,
0.0105897794,
-0.0506407954,
-0.0049584364,
-0.0482864119,
0.0128470333,
0.0110929813,
0.0006779537,
-0.0155902477,
-0.0214329585,
-0.0170912575,
0.0229913872,
-0.0371716283,
0.0106916223,
-0.0113281058,
0.0176487919,
-0.0643875003,
0.0240009669,
-0.009532203,
-0.0187326316,
-0.0466176346,
-0.0273285005,
0.0135332393,
0.0582777075,
0.0220797472,
-0.0286236666,
-0.0472504087,
-0.0039090011,
0.0606882833,
0.0411627069,
0.0682524517,
-0.0073068123,
0.0173421651,
-0.0228187591,
-0.0697264746,
-0.0275717005,
0.0165659487,
0.0129507333,
0.0285812132,
0.0022393814,
0.0166751351,
0.0451338626,
-0.0255191419,
0.0539714359,
-0.0307301152,
-0.0694114938,
-0.0071298266,
0.046514608,
0.0121508194,
0.003941929,
-0.011927031,
0.028201431,
0.0217921603,
0.0143078789,
0.0396853909,
-0.0271142107,
-0.0846633017,
-0.0438018329,
0.009909519,
0.0130890664,
0.0011414487,
-0.0037962745,
-0.0515615381,
-0.0210063085,
-0.0331954509,
-0.0072625945,
-0.007310539,
0.0015607007,
0.0418576859,
-0.0012780481,
0.0063309451,
-0.0603155494,
0.0578820445,
0.0120545216,
0.0546766445,
0.0768567771,
0.0404703803,
0.0123984981,
-0.0534276403,
-0.0447450243,
-0.0160926785,
-0.0227005873,
-0.0216602236,
0.0529265143,
0.0049030427,
-0.0527467951,
-0.0205201618,
-0.0929676816,
0.0142930066,
-0.0133137675,
-0.0236261841,
0.0181870367,
0.0120852096,
-0.0496385954,
-0.0387780592,
0.010636,
-0.0245866906,
-0.0044348026,
0.0639832467,
0.0376642719,
0.0317797549,
-0.029288277,
-0.0213835593,
-0.0269401632,
-0.0137722008,
0.0388160907,
0.0111026736,
-0.0145606529,
-0.0426957458,
0.0503524467,
0.0184454601,
0.0152991414,
0.0201351028,
0.0218907986,
0.0378286876,
-0.0041082976,
0.017480934,
0.0949142128,
0.0003853208,
0.0729802549,
0.0110474238,
0.009015739,
-0.0626916587,
0.0335414298,
-0.040814776,
-0.0286254697,
0.020478528,
-0.0022191922,
0.0282918867,
0.1002676934,
-0.003980462,
-0.0281414036,
-0.0626223087,
0.023672089,
-0.0243645608,
-0.0047185211,
-0.0956468806,
-0.017511487,
-0.0322990641,
0.0738453791,
-0.0306907129,
-0.0552604496,
0.0528047495,
-0.0080415029,
0.0300102904,
-0.0343436673,
0.0248346366,
-0.0190563537,
0.004832685,
0.0208253562,
-0.0068736742,
0.0308508556,
-0.0350851938,
-0.0720907375,
0.0248471498,
0.0382290222,
0.0010860297,
-0.0176386144,
0.0122033944,
-0.0175272468,
-0.0313584208,
-0.0258863922,
-0.0620854758,
-0.087127246,
0.0149748102,
0.0113352705,
0.0236208867,
0.0338002332,
-0.0150796147,
-0.0157817919,
0.0121729085,
0.0476931036,
-0.0008527185,
-0.0170320217,
-0.0546135753,
0.0128628369,
0.0333026275,
-0.0058931573,
0.0160127059,
-0.0177253131,
0.0532668903,
0.016039338,
0.0478130728,
0.0051856553,
0.0006377381,
0.0127893034,
0.0600483716,
-0.0978597552,
-0.037615791,
0.0583400913,
0.0448677875,
-0.0396887474,
-0.0291053783,
0.1047382876,
0.0661454275,
-0.0372097045,
-0.0022022233,
0.0144470148,
0.0362444669,
0.0634396821,
0.0215026345,
-0.0643008649,
-0.0104157012,
0.0218278989,
0.0395355448,
-0.039163366,
-0.0135469511,
-0.041691903,
-0.1218464971,
0.0351994634,
-0.0361333489,
-0.0089382548,
0.0134097682,
-0.0526864231,
-0.0049175969,
0.0134363687,
0.0213276222,
0.0290316753,
-0.0615956075,
0.0251584221,
0.029122306,
0.0015548659,
-0.0598175116,
0.0119230542,
-0.0426451005,
0.0298740957,
0.0473283492,
-0.0194002297,
0.0156546291,
-0.0234955791,
0.0242669806,
-0.0073133735,
0.0430165194,
0.003195964,
0.018079441,
-0.0352690406,
0.0021844965,
-0.0102365362,
0.0082138386,
-0.0272685997,
-0.0386927463,
-0.0090096015,
0.0645737723,
-0.0173081364,
0.0204098225,
-0.0530165844,
0.0098598152,
0.0220119171,
0.0685958937,
0.0549076423,
-0.0515959375,
-0.0402229428,
-0.0179270543,
0.0005252584,
-0.0546920262,
-0.020214757,
0.0090500824,
-0.0086775552,
-0.0180062801,
-0.0375041999,
-0.0584481917,
0.0271727294,
0.0512191914,
0.0169407837,
-0.007053419,
-0.0813688934,
-0.0072154873,
-0.0289163664,
0.0492055938,
0.0163700711,
0.0201465338,
-0.1046777666,
0.0069780322,
0.0230968837,
-0.0227883738,
-0.0311348438,
-0.0103963027,
-0.0339146778,
-0.0381050967,
0.0210362859,
0.0403682105,
0.0172419604,
0.0431006625,
-0.0168232694,
-0.0448312126,
0.0673413649,
0.0529586561,
-0.0061154538,
0.0070446432,
-0.0023375021,
-0.0103251124,
-0.0238930639,
-0.0011503589,
-0.0224172957,
0.0112317018,
0.0322389267,
0.0409253538,
0.0292224176,
-0.0508120656,
0.0346613042,
0.0357188322,
0.1066272184,
-0.0200643744,
-0.0501294471,
-0.044793319,
0.0059770904,
0.0046803257,
-0.0120561644,
-0.0067947889,
-0.007612728,
0.0265856702,
-0.0328427851,
-0.0147558386,
0.0188473016,
-0.0281240139,
0.0711291656,
-0.0629171431,
0.0122671211,
-0.0119260941,
-0.0223792773,
0.0115748402,
0.0405292884,
-0.0230258722,
0.0624285601,
-0.0026347877,
0.0341037661,
-0.000253997,
0.081719093,
0.0248521455,
0.0322976299,
-0.027325701,
0.0561490059,
-0.080718182,
-0.0234042164,
-0.0048109712,
0.0264889281,
0.0251364671,
-0.0607880577,
-0.0183120091,
-0.0114237769,
-0.012299953,
0.0053687776,
-0.0007872907,
0.0406323373,
-0.0626580864,
0.0248462949,
0.0449026451,
0.0003952025,
-0.0278381538,
0.0571183898,
0.0007682312,
0.0409405865,
-0.0012931026,
-0.0093753515,
-0.0246777069,
0.0228226501,
0.0490269773,
0.0151956975,
-0.0351607017,
0.0290208366,
-0.0815616176,
-0.023714073,
0.0104853893,
-0.0097024441,
-0.0116989957,
0.0004647689,
0.0418967083,
0.0535533801,
-0.0070425514,
-0.0096854679,
-0.0355212055,
0.0088670319,
-0.0017289957,
-0.0323922485,
-0.014157705,
-6.028174538e-33,
-0.0435140766,
0.0119539723,
0.0204640087,
-0.0133146374,
-0.0045406767,
0.010048788,
0.0055026649,
0.0284342226,
-0.0091749337,
-0.0127175758,
-0.0680142716,
0.0075596934,
0.0301291104,
-0.0028232464,
0.014118392,
-0.0023621975,
0.0297898687,
-0.0200356245,
-0.0563114509,
-0.0382657573,
0.0377775691,
0.0471652187,
0.0255628582,
0.0372144654,
0.0296751522,
0.0299786851,
0.0234345719,
0.0022631772,
-0.0008556819,
0.0473014414,
-0.0206261333,
0.0232154913,
0.0230788328,
-0.0592317767,
-0.01699448,
0.0593627729,
-0.0438346453,
-0.0485120118,
0.0194939636,
0.0437630899,
-0.0551641211,
-0.0547813401,
0.0030631411,
-0.037517067,
-0.0215151478,
-0.0085816896,
0.0216122195,
-0.0041903034,
-0.0439944454,
-0.0093354005,
-0.0664401576,
-0.0134815844,
-0.0136538232,
-0.0572777316,
0.0281334873,
0.0653607249,
0.020785071,
0.0100800982,
-0.0230569094,
0.0038661058,
0.0330817476,
0.0435194895,
0.0337253846,
0.0199551955,
-0.0050172913,
0.056332875,
0.046731472,
0.0192904994,
-0.0084601911,
-0.0337108076,
0.0177157577,
0.0049257255,
-0.0029188734,
-0.0211103056,
0.0611217506,
0.0034201096,
-0.0345456675,
0.0226204731,
0.0230385493,
0.0283938628,
0.0518841483,
-0.0166362934,
-0.0465765074,
-0.0358186662,
-0.0520746745,
-0.0326800533,
-0.0363604128,
-0.0091239065,
0.0706109852,
0.0277819391,
-0.0268757381,
-0.0308743361,
0.0708868429,
-0.0019143926,
0.0313476548,
0.0143298097,
-0.0061898958,
0.0229906589,
0.0000021446,
0.0194422994,
-0.0627594516,
-0.0286097862,
0.0111159012,
-0.0133511759,
0.0106328949,
0.006078226,
0.0208665635,
0.0178579558,
-0.0690246001,
-0.0115406457,
-0.0281448979,
0.0276305061,
0.0026752248,
0.0302410871,
0.0609974936,
0.0236917529,
-0.0272439141,
0.0627400503,
0.0274514407,
-0.0351321362,
-0.0055733221,
0.0088373972,
-0.0216164459,
0.0058672284,
0.0105414689,
0.0006663266,
-0.0009689899,
0.0775820315,
0.0023845262,
-0.0411225036,
-0.0257961936,
0.0272648577,
2.685e-7,
0.0418354943,
0.025590552,
0.0368688963,
0.0273293834,
0.0018561636,
-0.001642694,
-0.0152852656,
0.0157162808,
-0.0070126108,
-0.0128357382,
-0.012329598,
0.0033922486,
0.0010618073,
-0.0055722804,
-0.1056843102,
0.0067873839,
-0.0541673712,
0.0626605153,
-0.0631386936,
0.0072309971,
0.0465898998,
0.0466023088,
-0.0554137826,
0.0148928761,
-0.0026642848,
0.0144398538,
0.0343738869,
-0.0222849697,
0.0287727714,
0.0042810519,
0.0332379788,
-0.0129605066,
0.0206666868,
0.0368504524,
-0.0093892794,
0.0269803405,
0.0143751334,
0.0347001068,
0.0117268534,
-0.0418896526,
-0.0062764171,
-0.0150287505,
-0.0176154319,
-0.0619591661,
0.0706589222,
-0.0822359324,
0.0098063489,
-0.0201491266,
-0.0555312112,
-0.0014758282,
0.0456759371,
-0.0052625095,
0.003549566,
0.0088235009,
0.0070585255,
0.008627994,
-0.0399442539,
-0.0888527855,
-0.0022271078,
-0.0047780024,
-0.0011121826,
-0.0270973332,
-0.0287414622,
-0.0175109096,
0.0429614298,
-0.0568261184,
-0.052082967,
2.565585068e-34,
0.0219458472,
-0.0079228999,
0.0666204169,
0.0244012885,
-0.0139674628,
-0.0181741901,
-0.0066805827,
0.0243225414,
0.0471097082,
-0.0882506147,
-0.0468369722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14492v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14492v2 | Sociocultural Norm Similarities and Differences via Situational Alignment and Explainable Textual Entailment | 2023-05-23T19:43:47 | 2023-10-23T00:53:01 | Sky CH-Wang, Arkadiy Saakyan, Oliver Li, Zhou Yu, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Designing systems that can reason across cultures requires that they are
grounded in the norms of the contexts in which they operate. However, current
research on developing computational models of social norms has primarily
focused on American society. Here, we propose a novel approach to discover and
compare descriptive social norms across Chinese and American cultures. We
demonstrate our approach by leveraging discussions on a Chinese Q&A platform
(Zhihu) and the existing SocialChemistry dataset as proxies for contrasting
cultural axes, align social situations cross-culturally, and extract social
norms from texts using in-context learning. Embedding Chain-of-Thought
prompting in a human-AI collaborative framework, we build a high-quality
dataset of 3,069 social norms aligned with social situations across Chinese and
American cultures alongside corresponding free-text explanations. To test the
ability of models to reason about social norms across cultures, we introduce
the task of explainable social norm entailment, showing that existing models
under 3B parameters have significant room for improvement in both automatic and
human evaluation. Further analysis of cross-cultural norm differences based on
our dataset shows empirical alignment with the social orientations framework,
revealing several situational and descriptive nuances in norms across these
cultures. | [
0.054377865,
0.0470570289,
-0.0102277184,
0.0214472171,
-0.0162186865,
0.0275803022,
0.0373031124,
-0.0120240813,
0.047179468,
0.0103510171,
-0.0205508657,
-0.0326294079,
0.0278134458,
0.014185722,
-0.0212342292,
-0.0271157715,
0.0118173677,
0.0265058149,
0.0439573191,
-0.0150683392,
0.0558733381,
0.0520019978,
0.0177985262,
0.0248535965,
0.0143703772,
-0.0047428641,
0.0019914019,
-0.0101166619,
0.0639405176,
-0.0286401231,
0.0293084197,
0.055497624,
0.0312309656,
0.0006823916,
0.0000021151,
-0.0626495183,
-0.0040708059,
-0.0101957368,
0.0248136465,
0.0073500215,
0.0340508111,
-0.0349479131,
0.0196955074,
-0.0082099596,
-0.0646790639,
0.0189969428,
0.0225459747,
0.0655037239,
0.0320515111,
0.0304970555,
-0.0147991171,
-0.0284946021,
-0.0438480228,
-0.0118432138,
-0.0289459657,
-0.018265333,
0.0314299911,
0.0436958745,
-0.0276361015,
0.0093828263,
-0.0071433405,
-0.0295354053,
0.010239467,
-0.0338034406,
-0.0137688462,
-0.0000736821,
-0.0022227871,
-0.0276273023,
0.0124621522,
0.1031340286,
0.0703863725,
-0.0586015247,
0.0337368064,
0.0062399027,
-0.0091457944,
0.0516743287,
-0.0249942634,
0.0362873673,
-0.0285817496,
0.0310678426,
0.0532844588,
0.0028477702,
0.025161529,
0.0440908037,
0.0031688493,
0.0721240491,
-0.0449901856,
-0.0237911008,
-0.0603297949,
-0.0259479769,
-0.038538523,
-0.0427244604,
0.0356879644,
0.0202830099,
-0.0297143646,
0.0074257152,
0.0175276976,
0.0272872914,
0.026309384,
-0.0029562621,
-0.0001983743,
0.0511574522,
-0.0116308425,
0.0449757986,
0.0154201314,
0.0213920232,
0.0027471457,
0.0054454519,
-0.016259687,
-0.0535131171,
-0.0722528026,
0.0194285717,
0.0437697396,
-0.0042886022,
-0.0215024482,
0.0180102531,
-0.034825217,
-0.0010642408,
-0.0741092637,
0.0367930643,
-0.0064509767,
-0.0109828897,
0.0083921729,
-0.0010937104,
-0.0254874937,
-0.0046433178,
-0.0729642361,
0.0346611924,
-0.0110784052,
-0.0044089747,
0.0198209435,
-0.0301559865,
0.024594048,
0.0048361327,
0.0011706364,
0.0177416485,
0.0177604295,
0.0433771089,
-0.0233515836,
-0.0275975391,
-0.0069872737,
-0.0169638824,
-0.0128602507,
-0.0434310101,
0.054177355,
0.0145989358,
0.0054768836,
-0.031497851,
0.0337916128,
0.0446573496,
-0.0113227284,
0.0371730514,
0.0376695991,
0.0107636927,
0.0440990962,
0.0514670797,
-0.0130098732,
0.0337764882,
0.0221272539,
-0.0039093927,
0.0786316842,
0.0028644823,
-0.0213355199,
-0.0267924778,
0.0140393898,
-0.0208026618,
-0.0086634271,
0.038882941,
-0.0098660951,
-0.0109297456,
-0.0191273335,
0.0575612783,
-0.0162205677,
-0.0033464124,
0.0154326595,
0.1232677326,
-0.0330570228,
0.0249804091,
0.0204904191,
-0.0037714886,
-0.014770885,
0.0098381247,
-0.0320778824,
0.0226150006,
-0.0271341335,
-0.0292710643,
-0.0195445661,
0.0568606481,
-0.0227257609,
-0.0677084178,
-0.0058415532,
0.0042356304,
0.0630424023,
-0.0079488894,
0.0078045917,
-0.0209477916,
0.019341303,
-0.0476696491,
0.0460737534,
-0.0669800416,
-0.0414007753,
-0.0094904955,
0.1055585667,
0.0657176599,
0.0303301793,
-0.0215098411,
0.0488132723,
-0.014384388,
0.0606658235,
0.0260067768,
0.0124595454,
-0.0293516517,
-0.0286617577,
-0.035037484,
-0.0305123478,
0.0393909477,
-0.0096415784,
-0.0309969913,
0.0495531633,
0.0126709677,
0.0029814935,
0.0029817882,
-0.0581303053,
0.0198411569,
-0.021623427,
0.0181847755,
-0.0263782777,
0.0390209928,
0.012979419,
0.0440873057,
0.0011414962,
-0.0066738254,
-0.0100140981,
-0.0325464308,
-0.0462542921,
0.0618482977,
-0.0739123598,
-0.0069333678,
0.0303431563,
-0.0699600652,
-0.0290945061,
0.0220921282,
-0.0364464037,
-0.0280558001,
-0.0190286972,
0.0393714532,
0.0213900898,
-0.0403831787,
-0.0450911894,
-0.0232927371,
-0.0005140585,
-0.0130473431,
0.0502947494,
-0.0286310818,
-0.0172433946,
0.0102445707,
-0.0245461389,
0.0323890261,
0.0254474282,
-0.0029989434,
-0.0133265881,
-0.0165880583,
-0.0208935887,
0.0310409572,
0.0228111334,
-0.033189781,
0.0313770436,
-0.0850929096,
-0.0126511361,
-0.0229978394,
0.0141125424,
0.0399541892,
-0.0120242843,
0.0132649643,
-0.022695085,
-0.065854162,
0.0272824746,
-0.0050447844,
0.0200441759,
0.0849387124,
-0.0525639467,
0.0044321539,
-0.018186342,
-0.0112672467,
-0.0491221994,
0.0514104366,
0.0087779416,
-0.010774361,
-0.0210332144,
-0.0158502795,
-0.0835514069,
-0.0021203742,
-0.0247847568,
-0.0447376445,
-0.003939047,
0.04778767,
0.0577999018,
0.0500078611,
0.0423239693,
0.0125519317,
0.0336114243,
0.0512507968,
-0.0296427011,
-0.0461927354,
-0.0113350581,
0.050350219,
0.0169163924,
-0.079800725,
-0.0334646665,
0.0382844582,
-0.0046889507,
0.0059567112,
-0.0500132516,
0.0277681388,
-0.0339730717,
-0.0236481111,
-0.0435137898,
-0.0537827797,
0.0256967582,
0.081087172,
-0.0407181494,
-0.0249523725,
0.0743869543,
0.0168764684,
0.0054240879,
-0.0085575311,
-0.0516359992,
-0.0373208821,
0.0577301569,
-0.0244913083,
0.0430167578,
0.0021443283,
-0.0029883878,
-0.0322782882,
-0.0259622019,
0.075451456,
-0.0165204667,
0.039146468,
-0.0425995886,
-0.0254647154,
-0.0072336793,
-0.0225010924,
-0.0176243316,
-0.014890587,
-0.0164646972,
0.0223441683,
-0.019413311,
-0.0329396538,
0.0917341188,
0.0339156687,
0.0361686088,
-0.0182247683,
0.025985714,
-0.0091508403,
-0.0048636906,
0.0048603583,
0.047374513,
-0.0071000988,
-0.0012155217,
-0.0174954049,
0.0453117415,
0.0459003188,
0.0317906737,
-0.0246825777,
0.02436704,
-0.0040951809,
-0.0121398494,
0.0143025257,
0.0176174846,
0.0003876546,
0.0651708171,
-0.0259973221,
0.0161703657,
0.1000997499,
0.0258060433,
-0.0297960825,
0.0012990363,
-0.0289871581,
0.0105626388,
0.0113040218,
0.0096936049,
-0.116934076,
0.0003495831,
-0.0015446229,
0.0098084901,
-0.0175556317,
-0.0520469472,
0.015610897,
-0.0756660774,
0.0083123287,
-0.0069220997,
-0.0221251249,
-0.0411229134,
-0.0556723289,
0.0022940531,
-0.0308793001,
0.0013494182,
-0.0168988742,
0.0337085202,
-0.0224362817,
0.0016532665,
-0.0369774774,
-0.0129950894,
0.0719944015,
-0.0563529283,
0.0299374275,
0.0216660164,
0.0656835511,
0.0320486575,
-0.0668503195,
-0.0127506377,
-0.0055255,
-0.0173826367,
0.0113120563,
-0.0144954612,
0.0194182526,
0.0094466396,
-0.0672870502,
0.0642227829,
-0.0348640978,
-0.0452692397,
0.0165960006,
0.0819789544,
0.0051082415,
-0.0476323403,
-0.0185439959,
0.0313268937,
0.0009546847,
0.091203779,
0.0166733377,
-0.0257573891,
-0.0063808891,
-0.0443288721,
-0.0469795503,
-0.0178634524,
-0.0221820716,
-0.0181574803,
-0.012702914,
-0.0242965706,
-0.0795521215,
-0.0419675149,
-0.0252559856,
0.0122315977,
0.0290241614,
-0.063064754,
0.0531547554,
0.0071346313,
-0.0246681832,
-0.0024911114,
-0.0395712666,
-0.0094606495,
0.0512110703,
0.0103933988,
-0.0090116346,
-0.0103653846,
-0.0046889787,
-0.0287916772,
0.0213705115,
-0.0320254453,
-0.0106598139,
-0.0167590883,
0.0059547191,
0.0452055521,
-0.0069399257,
0.0261159036,
0.0231732745,
0.0064775837,
-0.0199209601,
-0.0157433189,
0.0437350571,
0.0100545278,
0.0287973862,
0.0345893577,
-0.0095714889,
0.0203132443,
0.001336262,
0.013149661,
-0.0895888507,
-0.0366779454,
0.0343066044,
-0.0092019998,
-0.0164475758,
0.0217266511,
-0.0581769422,
-0.0582077317,
-0.0147881256,
-0.0251902863,
-0.038404543,
-0.007439476,
-0.0047197044,
0.0150744505,
-0.0379740931,
-0.018020086,
0.0437988527,
-0.0011579292,
0.0302639641,
-0.0692902058,
0.0292800739,
0.019413393,
0.0969203338,
-0.0557251126,
-0.0220765211,
-0.0219010729,
0.0121692074,
-0.0142543977,
0.0387999564,
-0.0281888116,
0.1145426705,
0.0362371318,
-0.0095681334,
0.0427986607,
0.019787997,
-0.0804128349,
-0.0120639112,
0.0068710097,
-0.0469233021,
0.0167056452,
-0.0382453427,
0.0369153209,
0.0029052165,
-0.0131180333,
0.0221952721,
0.0922842324,
-0.0044114995,
-0.0472238734,
-0.0004005403,
0.0085252831,
-0.0304517038,
0.0297914874,
0.0499074459,
-0.0898243412,
-0.0081913518,
0.0701107308,
-0.0471746698,
0.0002027986,
-0.0018600316,
0.060759671,
0.0294686444,
-0.018582724,
-0.003972691,
-0.0524653643,
-0.0610683709,
-0.0430844687,
0.0162971336,
-0.0071097738,
0.0147213722,
0.0029391272,
0.0648538023,
-0.0112634869,
-0.0301185921,
-0.0363365896,
-0.000177967,
-0.0787450001,
0.0044431998,
-0.0360105373,
-6.230222915e-33,
-0.0223226305,
-0.0620015189,
-0.0146589922,
-0.0088001182,
0.0020563588,
-0.0303586386,
-0.0684654564,
-0.0122873336,
-0.0572723895,
0.0627347156,
-0.0113566276,
0.0330883339,
-0.0021327413,
-0.0091907633,
0.0266426355,
-0.0261965077,
-0.0033228276,
0.0004799972,
-0.0093790004,
0.0384122021,
0.0725350231,
-0.0110765537,
0.0467471853,
-0.0855781808,
0.0615173951,
0.0010519917,
-0.0097752549,
0.0238221437,
0.0122626387,
0.0213701352,
-0.0197702255,
0.0275826734,
0.0373898521,
0.0055759773,
0.0126839075,
0.072862111,
-0.0852536932,
-0.0445379354,
0.0231821425,
-0.0494167246,
-0.0371440947,
-0.007272481,
-0.0043737935,
-0.0333746225,
0.0211530421,
0.0278558657,
0.0791861042,
-0.0220467187,
0.0457192771,
0.0106561538,
-0.0511552319,
0.0178883467,
-0.0473517813,
0.0050598043,
-0.0263593718,
0.0721141249,
0.0132209761,
0.02010631,
-0.0469101146,
0.0345388651,
-0.0216809213,
-0.0122647509,
0.0634874403,
-0.0358208902,
0.0241868552,
0.0298535712,
0.0023144651,
0.0353351012,
-0.0568487868,
-0.0289053991,
-0.0015799843,
0.0248079579,
0.0356845297,
0.0834442899,
-0.0191671047,
-0.0221049059,
-0.1005109176,
0.0161311161,
0.0534379594,
-0.0337657593,
0.0009499501,
0.0096850134,
-0.0641385689,
-0.026134504,
0.011706993,
-0.008660174,
-0.0231474116,
-0.0205107331,
0.0041552321,
-0.0288141798,
-0.0629154965,
-0.0263476539,
-0.0032407995,
-0.0512669384,
-0.0202629287,
0.0498119853,
0.0246020518,
-0.0665766597,
0.0388637446,
-0.0144790141,
-0.0712067708,
-0.0304962508,
-0.0246214028,
0.0147916535,
0.0292208437,
0.0206522997,
0.0536313802,
-0.0027828491,
-0.0243071374,
-0.0201169979,
-0.0335445851,
-0.0228776056,
-0.0426556729,
-0.0203663241,
0.0094713951,
0.0288153347,
-0.0064693219,
0.0117851663,
0.0692813247,
0.0283318423,
-0.0464464501,
-0.0331030041,
-0.0504431799,
-0.0218429342,
-0.0137967281,
-0.0334464721,
-0.0245479606,
0.0467336215,
0.0543727539,
0.0078209788,
-0.0176518783,
-0.0117356377,
2.659e-7,
-0.0052869814,
0.0040855049,
0.029439481,
0.0299862493,
-0.0057569011,
0.0284717847,
0.0209931601,
0.0375970975,
-0.0225004554,
-0.0425641797,
0.0649586022,
0.0432708785,
0.0596416481,
0.027557604,
-0.029764181,
-0.041479025,
-0.0658514276,
-0.0547495522,
-0.0071252715,
0.0216293857,
0.0222801976,
0.0166082866,
-0.0013856678,
0.012964447,
-0.0022278989,
-0.0103033045,
0.0257109068,
-0.0614993982,
0.0278825201,
0.0103785442,
0.0189810228,
-0.0557221249,
0.0192642063,
0.0247417912,
0.002578303,
0.0136851165,
0.0240793768,
0.0533490218,
-0.0065323343,
-0.0017753157,
-0.0287014656,
-0.0159217902,
0.0432355255,
-0.1038512588,
0.0559994616,
0.0065286458,
-0.0265067555,
-0.0218174774,
0.0186013244,
-0.0250033233,
0.0221943036,
0.0181505959,
0.0063798088,
-0.0157112014,
0.0069885738,
0.0173366498,
0.0378833041,
-0.0355738811,
-0.0218806267,
-0.0148676215,
0.0178950448,
-0.0517124683,
0.0013089032,
-0.007987001,
-0.0046988232,
-0.0055196504,
0.0043049934,
2.363984343e-34,
-0.0064064874,
-0.0171484705,
-0.0090996148,
0.0060228314,
0.0664037094,
0.0009115303,
-0.0219387021,
-0.0186158046,
0.0481111556,
-0.0352105424,
-0.0119106611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14489v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14489v2 | Are Large Language Models Robust Coreference Resolvers? | 2023-05-23T19:38:28 | 2023-11-15T04:51:27 | Nghia T. Le, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work on extending coreference resolution across domains and languages
relies on annotated data in both the target domain and language. At the same
time, pre-trained large language models (LMs) have been reported to exhibit
strong zero- and few-shot learning abilities across a wide range of NLP tasks.
However, prior work mostly studied this ability using artificial sentence-level
datasets such as the Winograd Schema Challenge. In this paper, we assess the
feasibility of prompt-based coreference resolution by evaluating
instruction-tuned language models on difficult, linguistically-complex
coreference benchmarks (e.g., CoNLL-2012). We show that prompting for
coreference can outperform current unsupervised coreference systems, although
this approach appears to be reliant on high-quality mention detectors. Further
investigations reveal that instruction-tuned LMs generalize surprisingly well
across domains, languages, and time periods; yet continued fine-tuning of
neural models should still be preferred if small amounts of annotated examples
are available. | [
0.0521366298,
0.0019458856,
0.0132378843,
0.0190539509,
-0.0237841923,
0.0098306602,
0.0179221295,
-0.0204152931,
0.0581631772,
-0.0597990975,
-0.0471208282,
-0.0102799926,
-0.0537456945,
-0.0388934538,
0.0130305393,
-0.01630532,
0.0627773702,
-0.0382876843,
0.037086606,
0.007536381,
0.0009958212,
-0.0032518082,
-0.0124773029,
0.0363903269,
-0.0285049807,
-0.0329378434,
0.0102215605,
-0.0111821676,
-0.0171836708,
-0.0250176769,
0.0135241058,
0.0749280825,
-0.0048202765,
0.0475048833,
0.0000018691,
-0.0502634235,
0.006927772,
-0.0135009624,
-0.0342906341,
0.0342330001,
0.0078859963,
0.0008851906,
0.0196613781,
-0.005353603,
-0.0327158198,
-0.0203981772,
0.0210442897,
0.0589315817,
0.0711226612,
0.0523728654,
0.0015341023,
-0.0103523396,
0.01324083,
-0.0513800569,
-0.0664519295,
-0.1007299051,
0.0027776561,
-0.0138564641,
0.0043308064,
0.0435536802,
0.0016124245,
0.0583283491,
0.014377106,
0.0010207623,
0.0234653298,
0.0379661992,
-0.0759036541,
-0.0125069497,
-0.0198016036,
0.0972206369,
0.0152173629,
0.013942671,
0.00530174,
-0.0046165776,
-0.0239953157,
-0.0361315757,
-0.0211808644,
-0.0137417205,
0.0133370282,
0.0108247194,
0.0164028816,
-0.0002539145,
-0.0132294493,
0.0096403509,
-0.0137061598,
0.0856817216,
-0.0001853828,
-0.0102841519,
0.0807028934,
0.0282427426,
-0.0527984984,
-0.0809000134,
0.0305983052,
0.0198871121,
-0.0505873486,
0.0283350796,
-0.0471619889,
0.032303825,
0.0090059396,
-0.05979966,
0.0440045148,
-0.0030108567,
-0.057204973,
0.0585188232,
-0.0295187309,
0.0500886701,
-0.031716302,
0.0237883776,
0.0043402812,
-0.0342330076,
-0.0443432182,
0.0248034131,
-0.0619033203,
0.0480094589,
-0.0558843948,
-0.0353118069,
-0.0363009423,
-0.0085361069,
0.0132402824,
0.0202864315,
-0.0071934485,
-0.0098287901,
-0.0398959704,
-0.0102824606,
-0.0383774377,
0.0410838537,
-0.0253180359,
0.0013659596,
-0.0280979089,
-0.0690125674,
-0.01403262,
-0.0004941073,
0.0049929642,
-0.0610572957,
0.0081810411,
0.0332107656,
0.0054412098,
-0.0513242818,
-0.0097127873,
-0.0453421585,
-0.0477741733,
-0.047617808,
-0.0160428435,
-0.055267442,
0.0171180964,
0.0095220758,
0.0053062313,
-0.106911242,
0.0473666526,
0.0418529734,
-0.0503144376,
0.0717338994,
-0.0025477577,
-0.0037226598,
-0.0062170788,
-0.0247461759,
0.0434782095,
0.0518901385,
-0.0080073737,
0.0314859785,
0.0422502421,
0.0263399724,
-0.0013952295,
0.0370627381,
0.0443175659,
0.0193985794,
0.0277962685,
0.009344561,
-0.0294242632,
-0.0018516176,
0.0193610862,
0.0723524317,
0.0187384915,
-0.0193382986,
0.0387935825,
0.0572848953,
-0.0349838547,
-0.0298543274,
0.0115545057,
0.0030887518,
0.0040448396,
0.0224146526,
-0.0731976479,
0.0177170169,
-0.0114984829,
-0.0287074372,
0.0673613697,
-0.0124265999,
-0.0385279655,
-0.0245749056,
-0.0174764656,
0.0188887939,
-0.0462727137,
0.0201917887,
0.0549130775,
0.0134383161,
-0.0413203537,
0.0414761752,
0.0415491946,
-0.0199443884,
-0.0110886041,
-0.0082789194,
-0.0132475551,
0.0065381327,
0.0290599372,
0.0043580527,
-0.0414015912,
-0.0221021753,
0.0914954171,
0.0635989234,
0.0458560474,
-0.0130415531,
0.0459750257,
-0.0060769208,
-0.0146604553,
-0.0003122234,
0.0208538491,
0.0206017885,
0.0457760245,
-0.0233870745,
0.0146752782,
-0.0086369868,
-0.0362233371,
0.016313551,
-0.0269068927,
-0.0432465412,
0.004583715,
0.0339051224,
0.0111506516,
0.0322411172,
-0.0247820746,
0.0004887253,
0.0226773657,
-0.0358439274,
0.0008310876,
0.00048273,
-0.055538334,
-0.0150506729,
0.0275233183,
-0.0144144697,
-0.031026978,
-0.0422171727,
-0.0186331924,
-0.0387880132,
-0.0149044562,
-0.0114373686,
0.0380254239,
-0.0227407105,
0.0171663612,
0.0182271563,
0.0106674172,
-0.05379894,
0.0506011099,
-0.0006493498,
0.0197685957,
0.0584276989,
0.0225085728,
0.0115388241,
-0.0439232551,
-0.042553138,
-0.0132251279,
-0.0118591702,
0.0044245669,
0.0431896858,
0.0093993414,
-0.0495056137,
-0.0047063846,
-0.0693769678,
0.0133079635,
-0.0235298909,
-0.0089696534,
0.0063559809,
-0.0060870419,
0.0071886629,
-0.0433511063,
0.0001666681,
0.0006728404,
0.0159235857,
0.0308419615,
0.0252614729,
0.0350772105,
0.0027494724,
-0.0555271693,
-0.0073226667,
-0.0361480154,
0.0204122458,
0.008379437,
-0.0258697104,
-0.0097426847,
0.0437462293,
-0.0016131152,
0.0443887822,
0.0163543411,
-0.0020548867,
-0.0039322963,
-0.0069680605,
0.0239076801,
0.0541055538,
-0.0355281979,
0.0256623048,
0.0115875416,
-0.0726581216,
-0.0634560511,
0.0415580124,
-0.0020937535,
-0.0933093056,
-0.0286570266,
0.0148384115,
0.0379944369,
0.0783863962,
-0.0061108116,
-0.0173468087,
-0.0498116538,
0.0169203859,
-0.0322697423,
-0.0134865893,
-0.0137387114,
0.0166011117,
-0.0191371292,
0.0629020557,
-0.0401417948,
0.0071175131,
0.0436178632,
-0.037266966,
0.0016713031,
-0.0097826542,
-0.003985968,
-0.0344532579,
0.0520871989,
0.0124338008,
0.0000625014,
0.0919405967,
-0.0642600134,
-0.0185927991,
0.0023851593,
-0.0152802048,
-0.004059894,
0.0564978905,
-0.0324177779,
0.0401977524,
-0.0042166538,
-0.0300453026,
-0.062293075,
-0.0255085584,
-0.0697489977,
-0.0082225455,
-0.009613716,
0.0389581732,
-0.0092385123,
0.0043649916,
0.00773763,
0.0399544314,
0.0044017127,
0.001144556,
-0.050512746,
0.0441418029,
0.0362836644,
0.0048457473,
-0.008527888,
-0.0238677561,
0.0155968321,
0.0169135351,
0.0271173958,
0.0031639668,
-0.0136447893,
-0.010349392,
0.0324082971,
-0.0608601682,
-0.0299564023,
0.0070817405,
0.0773279592,
-0.0328343771,
-0.0455330461,
0.1352833509,
0.0306846369,
-0.0501745418,
-0.0184837319,
0.0232844539,
-0.0246828124,
0.039791923,
0.0146655478,
-0.0426765233,
-0.0587531179,
0.0047470611,
-0.0210284255,
0.0267759673,
-0.0512480773,
-0.0131147616,
-0.1440069675,
0.0086694574,
-0.026655212,
-0.06083351,
-0.0314827375,
-0.0190726873,
0.0340974107,
-0.0251985993,
0.0231908951,
-0.0010052224,
-0.0231611133,
0.013704231,
0.0048169652,
0.0191574581,
-0.0081582721,
0.0427093469,
-0.0766729861,
0.0527505279,
0.0662689358,
0.0356784575,
0.0342422314,
0.0349743329,
0.0297148395,
-0.0321747698,
0.0025789046,
-0.0120694386,
0.0475352965,
-0.0178677794,
-0.0337674655,
0.0179254021,
0.0233081486,
0.0089768628,
0.0014703268,
0.0319798328,
0.0231115222,
0.0008675971,
0.0293878764,
-0.0005960818,
0.0300559662,
-0.0036592528,
0.0659004226,
0.037071269,
-0.0240281429,
-0.0243769232,
-0.0182235111,
0.0247787535,
-0.0548411645,
-0.0573181137,
0.007903886,
-0.0310792942,
0.0276492648,
-0.0637599155,
-0.0462893434,
0.0451667048,
0.0201561935,
0.0262261648,
-0.0021435264,
0.0205930732,
0.0341360271,
-0.0178690888,
0.0184157938,
-0.0721088871,
-0.0092857089,
-0.1232587323,
0.0137570193,
0.0898914486,
0.0483403504,
-0.0382887833,
0.0756859779,
-0.0641289428,
-0.0414834954,
-0.0092438525,
0.0212733131,
0.0104652895,
0.0197128318,
-0.0487770066,
-0.0559349731,
-0.0079481276,
0.0446775593,
-0.0336824395,
0.0178798623,
0.005429734,
-0.001340529,
-0.0210456792,
0.066010803,
-0.0303619839,
0.0508429743,
0.0293685123,
0.0455721989,
-0.0161047056,
-0.0843012109,
0.0231203511,
0.022771053,
0.0682912916,
0.0110852867,
-0.0087700309,
-0.0105817877,
0.017892791,
-0.0031355752,
-0.0218587685,
-0.0101204179,
0.0025400787,
-0.0232119132,
0.0047516269,
-0.0004972088,
0.0091143884,
-0.0252418891,
0.1062954292,
-0.0260136947,
-0.0145386513,
0.0239654817,
-0.0289392266,
-0.0158411078,
0.0119127026,
-0.0100098951,
0.0404297486,
0.0524984226,
0.06226594,
-0.0318174697,
0.0200434737,
-0.0022553089,
-0.0121421833,
-0.0046736049,
-0.0153962495,
-0.0585344695,
-0.0188635886,
-0.0338580646,
0.02426132,
0.0895385966,
-0.0242732298,
0.0640477389,
-0.0124792866,
-0.0166680627,
-0.0230986662,
-0.0017257916,
-0.0069747888,
0.0003019204,
0.0070484169,
0.0152233513,
0.0056659728,
0.0342056155,
0.0611630864,
0.0243738741,
0.0209580455,
0.0666704327,
0.0120724589,
-0.0479451455,
-0.0264976751,
-0.0424903929,
0.0076778382,
0.0072337268,
0.075163804,
-0.0407829098,
-0.043707259,
0.0539945774,
-0.0292097069,
-0.0339505747,
0.0060214065,
0.0250067972,
0.0294543914,
0.026679134,
-0.0207524411,
-0.043629542,
0.016383959,
0.0299892407,
-0.048844818,
-0.0340610109,
-6.081118069e-33,
-0.0892280191,
-0.0072576664,
0.0089822933,
-0.0118464883,
0.013656335,
0.0179580934,
-0.0482789166,
0.0277043134,
-0.0390012451,
0.0012784333,
-0.042342905,
0.0020984842,
0.019929627,
0.0303163994,
0.0051562493,
-0.0202913061,
0.0690319389,
0.0061206874,
-0.0095430966,
0.0192814954,
0.0411253907,
0.0350655504,
0.062491715,
-0.047424987,
0.0129169384,
0.0273947902,
0.0077442359,
0.0213888567,
0.0456674062,
0.0332578123,
-0.0246165451,
0.0337654315,
-0.0050102863,
-0.0395461991,
-0.0041088304,
0.0070207049,
-0.126600191,
-0.0243234467,
0.0294189919,
0.0128979124,
0.0395756662,
-0.0485028811,
0.0247056652,
-0.0362011418,
-0.0161359943,
0.005432413,
0.0416803882,
-0.0048050615,
-0.0058230814,
-0.0235979129,
-0.0534093119,
0.0160554554,
0.0047346409,
-0.0297535826,
0.0199622642,
0.0552353002,
-0.0164442044,
0.0348554291,
-0.0401145592,
0.0273333993,
0.004077259,
0.0466010198,
0.0133953486,
-0.0132854739,
-0.004177067,
0.0469664857,
0.010683937,
-0.0052982066,
-0.0100747626,
-0.0012709514,
0.0415985025,
0.0373614132,
-0.0010292922,
0.0930385888,
0.0093424721,
0.0218244847,
-0.0361833088,
-0.0059914091,
0.0365345366,
0.0205078442,
0.0255635865,
-0.0167779867,
-0.0225480217,
-0.0228757448,
-0.0479232259,
-0.0335754119,
-0.0402280539,
-0.0399519093,
0.040523041,
-0.0012071168,
-0.0204745922,
0.0414133966,
0.0501860604,
-0.0399172157,
-0.0546909757,
0.022888992,
0.0348425061,
0.017374821,
0.0012329676,
0.0384286679,
-0.066767551,
-0.0081000049,
-0.0073708361,
0.001788766,
0.0206850376,
-0.0051519279,
0.0285775196,
-0.0245379433,
-0.0809767395,
-0.0142153567,
-0.0233068019,
0.0347312316,
-0.0481265523,
0.0118012056,
0.0232631993,
0.0117770266,
-0.0068549053,
0.0642385855,
0.0143447919,
-0.010061156,
-0.0291410685,
-0.0312798135,
0.0241111834,
0.032518819,
-0.0052165766,
-0.0029086035,
-0.0154406652,
0.0215118863,
-0.0140092308,
-0.0487616509,
-0.0187648144,
-0.018989075,
2.496e-7,
0.0107835904,
0.0668887645,
0.0253142137,
0.0140304314,
-0.0219536386,
0.0039686547,
-0.006780928,
0.0164136551,
0.0250039063,
-0.0330145545,
-0.0124337263,
0.0290460903,
0.0096818032,
0.0229329634,
-0.0913862586,
0.0037024289,
-0.0533996709,
0.0046982896,
-0.0481913425,
-0.0339314975,
-0.0023719524,
0.0926870331,
0.0204157829,
0.0090349149,
-0.0281441845,
-0.0335140415,
0.0379715152,
-0.0218824036,
-0.0162445717,
0.0150659224,
-0.0165346581,
0.0662734509,
-0.0224277526,
0.0303561855,
0.0171990991,
0.0287132096,
0.0337842926,
0.078019321,
0.03094876,
-0.051876992,
-0.0151903778,
-0.003266454,
0.0089362953,
-0.0069031124,
0.0740699098,
-0.1061211824,
-0.0177932866,
-0.0365488194,
-0.0455233678,
0.0046672435,
-0.0180537812,
-0.0010291046,
0.0011149803,
0.0193395969,
-0.0019811501,
0.0111282831,
-0.0246794168,
-0.0662514567,
-0.0219363011,
0.024863746,
0.0140678585,
-0.0325264968,
-0.0141479122,
-0.0507166684,
-0.0508375205,
-0.0261361226,
0.012770256,
2.159192564e-34,
0.0498353019,
0.0163529571,
0.0230178908,
0.0393470936,
-0.0045202845,
0.0024937638,
-0.0443008505,
-0.0158987958,
0.020415945,
-0.0363071486,
0.005214904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14483v1 | Language Model Self-improvement by Reinforcement Learning Contemplation | 2023-05-23T19:25:52 | 2023-05-23T19:25:52 | Jing-Cheng Pang, Pengyuan Wang, Kaiyuan Li, Xiong-Hui Chen, Jiacheng Xu, Zongzhang Zhang, Yang Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable performance across
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, fine-tuning these
models often necessitates substantial supervision, which can be expensive and
time-consuming to obtain. This paper introduces a novel unsupervised method
called LanguageModel Self-Improvement by Reinforcement Learning Contemplation
(SIRLC) that improves LLMs without reliance on external labels. Our approach is
grounded in the observation that it is simpler for language models to assess
text quality than to generate text. Building on this insight, SIRLC assigns
LLMs dual roles as both student and teacher. As a student, the LLM generates
answers to unlabeled questions, while as a teacher, it evaluates the generated
text and assigns scores accordingly. The model parameters are updated using
reinforcement learning to maximize the evaluation score. We demonstrate that
SIRLC can be applied to various NLP tasks, such as reasoning problems, text
generation, and machine translation. Our experiments show that SIRLC
effectively improves LLM performance without external supervision, resulting in
a 5.6% increase in answering accuracy for reasoning tasks and a rise in
BERTScore from 0.82 to 0.86 for translation tasks. Furthermore, SIRLC can be
applied to models of different sizes, showcasing its broad applicability. | [
0.0543058664,
0.0634030998,
-0.0091997776,
0.0080717308,
-0.052808322,
0.008064677,
0.0272259898,
-0.0295248106,
-0.0011317033,
-0.0466858596,
-0.0434807278,
-0.022338504,
-0.0274295155,
-0.0080044679,
0.0134376734,
-0.0515698232,
0.0363717154,
-0.067019932,
0.0303056352,
-0.0049470537,
-0.022954477,
-0.0010459067,
-0.0098717008,
0.0218337681,
0.0010035632,
-0.0298090596,
0.0022227988,
-0.0059937928,
-0.0005922871,
-0.0079382602,
0.0329957008,
0.0826598853,
0.0015709564,
0.0155994352,
0.0000021642,
-0.0597585514,
-0.0268848725,
-0.0164428353,
0.0290436,
-0.0005824141,
0.0529737025,
0.0137749352,
-0.0275183395,
0.0443235785,
-0.0473540537,
0.0214465335,
-0.0057333163,
0.0524614081,
0.0788061097,
0.0719490051,
0.0148418667,
0.0008802807,
-0.0021089951,
-0.0029837515,
0.0262422878,
-0.0234980118,
0.009538346,
0.0542613454,
0.0067798365,
0.0008672251,
-0.031115381,
0.0534341484,
0.0489696227,
-0.0592269376,
0.0242785048,
0.0361900143,
0.000225322,
-0.0301367212,
-0.0143174035,
0.0219834428,
-0.0119985696,
-0.0311766975,
0.0059562884,
-0.0063127847,
0.0229052305,
0.0112337163,
-0.0094167721,
0.0248825364,
0.0306809302,
0.0214985833,
0.0335961878,
0.000370454,
0.0013719761,
0.02488162,
-0.011881548,
0.0614481419,
-0.0050638639,
-0.0608407855,
-0.0012762797,
0.0185752511,
0.001762435,
-0.0619346425,
0.0074338429,
0.0523155406,
-0.0437315293,
0.0279140398,
-0.0478726476,
-0.0217039902,
0.0021430859,
-0.0234319028,
0.0342270844,
0.0426802635,
0.0166396536,
0.0473865047,
-0.0442965552,
0.0515464433,
0.0226089042,
0.0500224791,
-0.0547710098,
0.0198128056,
-0.0561020821,
-0.0191618651,
-0.0515429713,
0.0404003337,
-0.0012082796,
-0.0123671116,
-0.0318252593,
0.0357139856,
-0.0011147171,
0.0044111097,
0.015541072,
0.0229566228,
-0.0273918379,
-0.0087580532,
-0.0823441148,
0.0152026517,
-0.0329756923,
-0.0141382627,
0.0250772536,
-0.0491695665,
0.0078302184,
-0.0207180325,
0.0071896492,
-0.0125301098,
0.0218901299,
0.0720263124,
-0.0298194569,
-0.0374968387,
-0.0336904973,
-0.0175481904,
-0.0261826627,
-0.0751741827,
-0.0167400017,
-0.0783817098,
-0.0186149683,
-0.0140819652,
-0.006538678,
-0.0159812961,
0.0237086769,
0.0270544123,
0.0098031759,
0.0677570105,
-0.0144528877,
0.0210822131,
0.0475272164,
-0.0095778964,
0.020842066,
0.0713204145,
0.0609698631,
0.0153929349,
0.0078944331,
-0.0001384086,
0.0259638354,
0.013943268,
0.0116687138,
0.0218121037,
-0.0428098105,
0.0090366174,
-0.0124217933,
0.0411997288,
-0.0015142944,
0.0590364896,
-0.003854983,
0.0474845245,
0.0552169606,
0.0504739434,
0.006373784,
0.0170479883,
0.0153105874,
0.022219792,
0.0115968511,
0.0044363365,
-0.0258475617,
0.0594593324,
-0.002512665,
0.0042028534,
0.0444706902,
-0.0097011523,
-0.0069207409,
-0.1026497781,
-0.0139788315,
-0.0109307757,
0.0267873537,
0.0270876642,
0.0526307635,
0.0318348706,
-0.0139617408,
-0.0130496658,
0.013419359,
-0.0324998945,
0.0226541907,
-0.0627758577,
0.0674298331,
0.0905004069,
0.0721374378,
-0.0380863175,
-0.0367703438,
-0.044653099,
-0.0165112931,
0.066144608,
0.0514473133,
-0.0119246626,
-0.0303857103,
-0.028414391,
-0.0328912511,
-0.0346769057,
0.0090843393,
0.0028550127,
0.0134446407,
0.0065733832,
0.0167279616,
-0.0205901954,
-0.0935649425,
0.0479680598,
-0.0307867527,
-0.0601904094,
0.0518031158,
0.0027861805,
0.0114668785,
0.0060218652,
-0.0137529867,
0.0233348142,
0.0074830502,
-0.0123456409,
-0.0497032367,
-0.027127916,
-0.0630368143,
-0.0424351133,
0.03579133,
-0.0223428123,
-0.0179129373,
0.0075069596,
-0.0226411447,
-0.0628552213,
0.0056478996,
-0.0633577481,
0.0114712426,
-0.0434420146,
0.0397956297,
-0.0258172322,
-0.0362582915,
-0.0527548678,
0.0470471345,
-0.0059110653,
0.0289391745,
0.0222239979,
0.0230276491,
0.0066485517,
-0.0366308726,
-0.0067454069,
-0.0351079814,
-0.006089231,
0.0326641724,
0.076138638,
0.0729057863,
-0.062675789,
-0.0516225323,
-0.0320608802,
0.0012562774,
-0.026582256,
0.0037827906,
0.0297214445,
0.0025919317,
-0.0185774323,
-0.0301574022,
-0.0364727639,
-0.044367291,
0.0532304123,
0.0060836836,
0.052126158,
-0.0219278336,
0.0377503484,
-0.0569207668,
-0.0074810665,
-0.0017275119,
0.0038021558,
0.0279977564,
0.0332135335,
-0.0644253269,
0.0240651816,
-0.0588398799,
0.018890677,
0.0356082767,
-0.0712027401,
0.027897682,
-0.0311516076,
0.0712695345,
0.0644800812,
0.034171354,
0.018538719,
0.0774857476,
0.0067051998,
-0.0826997086,
0.0463118479,
-0.0222009271,
-0.0310590509,
0.0040018209,
-0.0406889357,
0.0124033792,
0.0702057257,
-0.0089672739,
-0.0216618851,
-0.0615163557,
0.0706539527,
-0.0395885333,
-0.0388423316,
-0.0373357758,
0.0339072943,
-0.0045640902,
0.052297771,
-0.0280323979,
-0.0605147816,
0.1025899351,
0.0089115426,
0.0175538771,
-0.0673040971,
0.0006612805,
-0.0301914439,
0.0473500118,
-0.0028406689,
0.0269949846,
0.0098758386,
-0.0078351665,
-0.054387141,
-0.0090797469,
0.0269651692,
-0.0447051153,
0.0225498509,
-0.0485832281,
0.0053847618,
0.0322125591,
-0.0183672961,
-0.0782145932,
-0.0052054375,
-0.0267198831,
-0.0011294025,
0.0052852412,
0.0087357163,
-0.0079546282,
-0.0127960797,
0.0555694625,
0.0439828821,
-0.0332489423,
-0.0315953195,
-0.0045196135,
0.0031374914,
0.055139564,
-0.0007306795,
0.0437645391,
-0.0464616604,
0.0581813306,
0.0188334528,
0.0291244611,
0.0129575795,
-0.0052792435,
-0.0033796134,
0.0120718274,
-0.0359288491,
0.0172373708,
0.029044712,
0.0408464037,
-0.0826092958,
-0.0683602691,
0.144488126,
0.0697303787,
-0.001019893,
-0.0101394784,
-0.0625207573,
0.0215197764,
0.0399373211,
0.0515458845,
-0.0275108907,
-0.0194453131,
-0.00025426,
0.038849663,
-0.0046079475,
-0.0186226349,
-0.0087401904,
-0.1199295819,
0.0105471434,
-0.010188086,
-0.0299707372,
0.0335795879,
-0.0368613973,
-0.0363762639,
-0.003708618,
-0.0003308843,
0.0135183558,
-0.0081698606,
0.0193017703,
0.0254912246,
-0.0208092816,
-0.0591163263,
0.0050104554,
-0.0247446634,
0.0582948923,
0.0790458545,
0.0302810967,
0.0029630901,
-0.0619767383,
0.0310903229,
0.0002410102,
0.0033815182,
-0.0220449604,
0.0219161697,
0.0041191913,
-0.0197427813,
-0.0212133247,
0.0289084129,
-0.0060202125,
0.0008748386,
0.0204108395,
0.0420406796,
0.0057078809,
-0.0146430042,
-0.0203308817,
-0.0152306315,
-0.01211611,
0.0839558691,
0.0219255872,
-0.0682753772,
-0.0332060121,
-0.0313144401,
-0.0290682688,
-0.0582186282,
-0.0228909403,
-0.0012290301,
-0.0055330666,
0.0186815877,
-0.0925801992,
-0.0346620269,
0.0476163737,
0.0104069151,
0.0025695413,
-0.0191345494,
0.0152279893,
0.0065092389,
-0.0326608643,
-0.0046672761,
-0.0425304323,
0.0012670802,
-0.0632186234,
-0.0056585949,
0.0147145959,
-0.0414906703,
-0.0018602108,
-0.0217432231,
-0.0633242875,
-0.0665520951,
-0.0275210682,
0.0780519694,
0.0117284786,
0.0382304899,
-0.0288603995,
-0.0625226349,
0.034593448,
0.022004446,
-0.0695693269,
-0.0130555118,
0.0092022708,
0.0303733665,
0.0089931097,
0.0328098647,
-0.0235116761,
0.0324171521,
0.0208117682,
0.0552475452,
-0.0049393494,
-0.0189412031,
0.0374284387,
0.0226305593,
0.0241172668,
-0.0185598526,
0.0098417643,
-0.0333167799,
-0.0019285765,
-0.0266290437,
-0.0376546085,
-0.0315681025,
0.0197205041,
0.0416642725,
-0.0198313054,
0.0012820018,
0.0124298083,
-0.0407049507,
0.0158890206,
0.0114579285,
-0.0063592317,
-0.0005065012,
0.0106923617,
0.0077380748,
-0.0007671629,
-0.0078975195,
0.0008339467,
0.0220382735,
0.0254531354,
0.0042711026,
0.0509658977,
0.0164808892,
0.0060671228,
0.0140571576,
0.0137917288,
-0.0569168255,
-0.0433809273,
-0.0184777379,
0.0431149006,
0.044265002,
0.0303012989,
0.0398450345,
-0.0261562932,
-0.0127759669,
-0.0032449164,
-0.0002953483,
0.0177949686,
-0.0203380175,
0.0113987112,
0.0093977386,
-0.0102425003,
-0.0148553131,
0.0376090296,
0.0125034684,
0.0009007264,
-0.0017446827,
0.0064279921,
-0.0559642911,
0.0127950236,
-0.0179726109,
0.0209572688,
-0.0091950214,
0.0362047143,
-0.0083240541,
-0.0686229095,
-0.0197086055,
0.0729037821,
0.009488075,
-0.0374320708,
0.048154451,
0.0233351458,
-0.0417633466,
-0.0031590762,
-0.0705743134,
-0.0044001509,
0.0042730444,
-0.0259215645,
-0.0074989679,
-6.648487315e-33,
-0.0224455409,
-0.046164602,
0.0409330688,
-0.0114891231,
-0.0070290794,
0.0004293312,
-0.0446265638,
-0.0019913153,
0.0329760462,
0.0198716875,
-0.0180675816,
0.0105478214,
-0.0114732897,
0.0275491122,
0.0356637985,
-0.0094290692,
0.0627630278,
-0.0122067537,
-0.0523846559,
-0.0006528653,
-0.0030759033,
0.0302236676,
0.0444616415,
-0.0379872844,
0.0105200903,
0.0147127705,
-0.0231864881,
0.0428742208,
-0.0071727047,
0.0537787303,
-0.015003874,
0.0094463183,
0.0176251214,
-0.0548842214,
-0.0201959927,
0.0173517428,
-0.0688551143,
-0.0473976508,
-0.0053970772,
-0.0232077725,
-0.0958973095,
-0.031749282,
0.0376450941,
0.0060602427,
-0.0201742165,
0.0431666709,
0.0469812118,
-0.0248751119,
-0.0210143775,
0.0039454796,
-0.0469187573,
-0.0001829205,
-0.0202211086,
-0.0543618798,
0.0187028591,
0.0529239923,
-0.0293789618,
-0.0193387009,
-0.0116162878,
0.0265592765,
0.063038379,
0.0429886691,
0.0650276467,
0.0309728179,
-0.0056019868,
0.0272776186,
-0.012443033,
0.010178009,
0.000213338,
-0.0459528267,
0.0512472391,
0.0203655828,
0.0658377334,
0.0220657773,
0.0011800252,
-0.0031063384,
-0.0403713025,
0.0422076657,
0.0205818154,
0.0288069248,
0.0201319996,
-0.0039730086,
-0.0052841576,
-0.0179581456,
-0.084189482,
-0.0040915413,
-0.0418726839,
-0.0158152897,
0.0405641161,
0.0422590598,
-0.0650168061,
-0.0611043982,
-0.0020157506,
-0.0309972502,
-0.0145964753,
-0.0122388881,
-0.0392859131,
0.0229591839,
-0.0101911901,
0.0058025662,
-0.0726318955,
0.0098295026,
0.0023230561,
0.0243446212,
-0.019420512,
0.0281264037,
0.0256361384,
0.0216983072,
-0.0862801224,
0.0200929381,
-0.0396182761,
0.0552891307,
-0.0109728388,
-0.0240341723,
0.0027260566,
-0.0161183793,
-0.0234808065,
0.0625711977,
0.0263540316,
-0.0298753586,
-0.0340289846,
-0.0038235001,
0.011244541,
0.0129217561,
-0.0195903555,
0.0126862554,
-0.0441583246,
0.0670741573,
0.0172454659,
-0.057426393,
-0.0028608486,
0.0136192199,
2.904e-7,
0.0071605602,
0.0867055506,
0.0025280495,
0.0259655416,
0.0223094765,
0.0526361279,
-0.0158573762,
0.0087078987,
0.0299712457,
0.0045864978,
0.002363028,
0.0243772008,
0.0532809272,
0.0246607419,
-0.0596878082,
0.0002676738,
-0.0875753686,
0.037334919,
-0.0365947671,
-0.0167018622,
0.0436392613,
0.0356584676,
0.0190710407,
-0.0170355756,
-0.0124657601,
-0.0108473971,
0.075692825,
-0.013998962,
-0.0253036749,
0.0471478961,
0.0420952626,
0.0739957988,
0.005898979,
-0.0149774654,
-0.0284607299,
0.0081716478,
-0.0177096482,
0.0549761318,
0.024927102,
-0.0002873864,
0.0235641282,
0.0066024777,
0.012825869,
-0.0572008081,
0.0714588761,
-0.0960964635,
-0.0003082614,
-0.0102660349,
0.0140558835,
-0.0234730244,
0.0475712717,
-0.0369798578,
-0.0788884535,
0.0234665461,
0.0094931899,
0.0132140201,
-0.0057499609,
-0.0536279008,
-0.0325905345,
-0.0138366101,
0.0001891387,
0.0103900814,
-0.0595855191,
0.0223726984,
-0.0271843672,
-0.0819503814,
0.0133450245,
2.395023363e-34,
0.0321287103,
-0.0159504004,
0.0224762429,
-0.0139051974,
0.009559107,
0.0306069497,
-0.0280335788,
-0.022178553,
0.0322848968,
-0.0376605131,
-0.032841403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14482v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14482v2 | Is a Prestigious Job the same as a Prestigious Country? A Case Study on Multilingual Sentence Embeddings and European Countries | 2023-05-23T19:24:42 | 2023-10-25T09:13:34 | Jindřich Libovický | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study how multilingual sentence representations capture European countries
and occupations and how this differs across European languages. We prompt the
models with templated sentences that we machine-translate into 12 European
languages and analyze the most prominent dimensions in the embeddings.Our
analysis reveals that the most prominent feature in the embedding is the
geopolitical distinction between Eastern and Western Europe and the country's
economic strength in terms of GDP. When prompted specifically for job prestige,
the embedding space clearly distinguishes high and low-prestige jobs. The
occupational dimension is uncorrelated with the most dominant country
dimensions in three out of four studied models. The exception is a small
distilled model that exhibits a connection between occupational prestige and
country of origin, which is a potential source of nationality-based
discrimination. Our findings are consistent across languages. | [
0.0119233234,
0.0632046983,
-0.0256026108,
0.034490902,
-0.0046268101,
0.0142733203,
0.021267252,
-0.0388501436,
-0.0043051778,
-0.0247489884,
0.0309984367,
-0.01340828,
-0.0019229548,
-0.0231522247,
0.0669487491,
-0.0494202189,
0.0426856093,
0.0144096045,
0.0233470239,
-0.03465252,
0.0038627528,
0.0162692573,
0.0165020693,
0.0766969696,
-0.0085479543,
0.0025084331,
0.0625448748,
-0.0404580086,
0.0474138856,
0.0265890732,
-0.0082834465,
0.0203917287,
0.0277683884,
-0.0114561096,
0.000001645,
-0.0286185723,
0.0084891627,
-0.0088578779,
0.0502127483,
-0.0067672478,
0.016913835,
-0.0566608123,
0.0015043386,
0.0127357794,
-0.0224114861,
-0.0030534207,
0.0197100341,
0.0193812288,
0.0302003901,
0.0248821154,
-0.0036365471,
-0.0294183958,
-0.0674398169,
-0.0370657071,
-0.0985062942,
-0.0052977097,
0.0199030861,
-0.0209637675,
-0.0666688457,
0.058512155,
-0.0365492664,
0.0242703892,
-0.0084885983,
0.025579311,
0.0081630275,
0.0288367346,
0.0012328833,
0.0150110554,
0.0371089987,
0.0115934871,
0.0145594664,
0.0191545784,
-0.0057723224,
0.0127593987,
0.0187184773,
0.0099967821,
-0.0132462634,
0.0501579642,
0.0240828935,
0.0349797904,
0.0574850887,
0.0413802043,
0.003180882,
0.0045956196,
-0.0336998031,
0.0747119859,
0.0101230526,
-0.0776748583,
0.0071037202,
0.0307102855,
0.0107988631,
-0.0277581047,
0.0133242654,
-0.0121029671,
-0.0202063024,
-0.0086212894,
0.0126368022,
0.0095277093,
0.0300349928,
-0.0365694724,
-0.0039941301,
0.0101260999,
-0.0358848497,
0.0241642799,
-0.0050613778,
0.0323376581,
-0.024927754,
-0.0018665377,
-0.0318967551,
-0.0596594624,
-0.0578639768,
-0.0441188365,
0.0014780363,
-0.0117381159,
-0.0024962856,
0.014010475,
-0.0503673144,
-0.0205425322,
-0.0402424037,
0.0615155734,
-0.0349893793,
-0.0094781248,
-0.0144232325,
0.0309902243,
-0.0405274034,
0.043683473,
-0.0575973243,
-0.0063407817,
-0.0519226901,
0.0223920532,
0.0326845609,
0.0026250114,
-0.0084626526,
-0.0336807556,
-0.0027574406,
0.0449381955,
0.01498535,
0.0244556181,
0.0429630652,
-0.0338695161,
-0.0189741403,
-0.0471038707,
0.0321054943,
-0.0466663726,
0.0306790937,
0.0001120311,
-0.004221567,
-0.0531531833,
0.0008933806,
0.0144268256,
-0.0826686099,
0.0166211706,
0.020645462,
-0.0083999168,
-0.0143180219,
-0.0206525587,
-0.0162190646,
0.0632098243,
-0.007257964,
0.0122905001,
0.0631228313,
-0.0265370682,
0.0131946905,
0.0421324633,
-0.0397119112,
-0.0340682231,
-0.0205426589,
0.0142237889,
-0.0023130837,
0.0267096423,
0.0665484741,
-0.0052161608,
-0.0113368034,
0.0436256081,
0.0466427207,
0.0475431532,
0.0391506627,
0.0068455338,
0.0331471488,
-0.0090962267,
-0.0721287504,
0.0508524589,
-0.0319411233,
-0.0375538208,
0.030646069,
0.0096067376,
-0.0314706527,
0.0674757585,
-0.0131280189,
0.004425019,
0.0075735492,
-0.0008594919,
0.0346648358,
-0.0026748569,
0.0580209792,
-0.0318429396,
-0.0053564222,
0.0493431427,
0.0267512016,
-0.0553303659,
-0.0313361809,
0.0470044538,
-0.00811016,
0.0419742465,
-0.0339101292,
0.0103398664,
0.0471486263,
-0.0333996229,
0.0083064437,
0.0610743128,
0.0546198189,
-0.0263159536,
0.0314556845,
-0.0202157628,
-0.014990909,
-0.0254590157,
0.0225871932,
0.0227388982,
0.0007927864,
0.0431725979,
0.0369881466,
-0.0528591871,
0.0212222934,
0.00234548,
0.0154121425,
0.0254848134,
-0.0131273558,
0.0385236517,
-0.0492607541,
0.0336954147,
-0.0142658884,
-0.0001688358,
-0.0021123064,
-0.0796212181,
0.0064480593,
0.0280701779,
-0.0590960272,
0.00373876,
-0.0109246299,
-0.0704699531,
-0.0463782176,
-0.007345811,
-0.0206833724,
-0.0041140243,
0.0234039817,
0.0406632684,
0.0454350896,
-0.0202719662,
-0.0259364508,
-0.0537712313,
0.0504638925,
-0.0293182489,
0.0529664457,
-0.0085232398,
0.0367462523,
0.0142046241,
-0.0277678054,
0.031798441,
-0.0309443753,
-0.0347097218,
0.0178126041,
0.0028869736,
0.0075922259,
0.0367969722,
-0.026073331,
0.0146073895,
0.0101316962,
-0.0843091831,
0.0166744776,
-0.0201154035,
0.0083622029,
0.0311872717,
-0.0142010776,
0.0109637873,
0.0138243316,
-0.0445870906,
-0.031898547,
0.0034259374,
0.052977968,
0.0461291932,
-0.0141728437,
0.0332657062,
-0.000466296,
-0.0122949313,
-0.0495951697,
0.0231629442,
-0.046053648,
0.0041867341,
-0.0496189818,
0.0105940383,
-0.0654897019,
-0.0083033415,
-0.0272535719,
-0.0360033587,
-0.002188144,
0.0482749976,
0.0603709109,
0.049428951,
-0.0169825554,
0.0345503762,
0.0611977242,
-0.0223292243,
0.0188080594,
-0.0167887248,
0.0030010215,
0.0898287147,
-0.0564133637,
-0.0398845449,
-0.0158912633,
0.044363115,
0.0151805701,
-0.0110482844,
-0.0218518879,
0.0170633867,
-0.0887174159,
-0.0217067879,
-0.0609799773,
0.0249639731,
-0.0058280886,
0.0798128173,
0.0125463242,
0.0029093064,
-0.0011518401,
0.0078175478,
0.0236183126,
0.041311916,
-0.0561451241,
-0.0177555662,
0.0595251471,
0.0048315926,
0.0420744866,
-0.0268427413,
-0.0406463668,
-0.0461986624,
-0.0236071162,
0.0160667058,
-0.0020935668,
-0.0000295589,
-0.0041571953,
-0.0637606829,
-0.0215507317,
-0.0596368723,
-0.0046357396,
-0.0652237982,
-0.0361618437,
0.0593527257,
0.0040051877,
-0.010149003,
-0.0287455264,
0.0227514133,
0.0391192622,
-0.0228399727,
-0.0063368157,
0.033302404,
-0.0376315527,
0.0458568111,
0.0528304651,
0.0572978444,
-0.0011453265,
-0.0143357823,
-0.0132624554,
-0.0312765986,
-0.0600835346,
0.0205933414,
0.0098440694,
-0.0275626611,
0.0268206131,
-0.0718613267,
-0.0615778528,
-0.0221929494,
0.0381192751,
-0.0342013314,
0.006858435,
0.0774319842,
0.0008923707,
0.0157545824,
0.0514020845,
-0.0030815231,
0.0030577795,
0.0448741019,
0.0410275199,
-0.0889266878,
0.0369621739,
0.0129609201,
-0.0706981719,
-0.0453302078,
0.0048180819,
-0.0360251255,
-0.1253983974,
0.0395039171,
-0.0081636487,
-0.0288142115,
-0.0141264675,
-0.0054147262,
-0.0387413837,
-0.0098182894,
0.0120005822,
-0.0257291533,
0.0020747343,
0.0037474926,
0.003560679,
-0.0710074455,
-0.0718476847,
0.0239685532,
-0.0532963648,
0.0084389085,
0.0099599743,
0.0627115145,
-0.0272256676,
-0.0404281206,
-0.040829353,
0.0112369945,
-0.0035901316,
0.0150842108,
0.0218152795,
-0.0070417235,
-0.0618496835,
-0.0205090754,
-0.036133524,
0.0156172439,
0.0066910139,
0.01546581,
0.0709294006,
0.0115180593,
-0.0020818682,
0.0037481617,
-0.0000573892,
-0.010213485,
0.0567266941,
-0.0049103778,
-0.0620193258,
-0.0116031691,
-0.0430207923,
0.012516438,
-0.000073664,
-0.0307931453,
0.0562019795,
-0.0239653643,
-0.0583883151,
-0.0124243489,
-0.0868017972,
0.0534461774,
0.0140561219,
0.0223753061,
-0.0133057712,
0.0005225271,
-0.0212211553,
-0.0127349673,
0.0151483715,
-0.0326653346,
0.0382819027,
0.0180472825,
0.0088255508,
0.0232332256,
0.0110460408,
-0.0518740341,
-0.0510282554,
0.0016750821,
-0.0329393186,
-0.0079848394,
0.0077237845,
0.0112350024,
0.0475266464,
-0.0007150751,
-0.0302105751,
0.0587186664,
-0.0057511744,
-0.006494679,
0.032351207,
0.0387870558,
-0.0108052241,
0.0100509729,
0.0193318836,
-0.0286019985,
0.0279566366,
-0.0131054753,
0.0275514238,
-0.0149516547,
-0.0240120478,
0.0114542954,
-0.0256416742,
0.052597113,
-0.041456975,
0.0011390765,
-0.0621038377,
-0.0516483411,
-0.0627271235,
-0.0447757654,
0.0001672746,
-0.0256626513,
0.0477587581,
0.016230192,
0.0215782449,
-0.0277899634,
-0.0057015708,
0.0052160793,
-0.0630961061,
0.0201301929,
-0.0175827667,
0.0069188219,
0.0012495599,
0.0347230397,
-0.0239648391,
0.0080794562,
0.0004016228,
0.0336347409,
-0.0310697649,
-0.0071312063,
-0.0041539008,
-0.0011332916,
-0.0237856582,
0.0327829272,
-0.0413207747,
0.0172352362,
0.0303959996,
-0.0114841023,
0.1020843834,
-0.0875657052,
0.0665183067,
0.029142594,
-0.0221720003,
0.0171382111,
0.0013868941,
0.0038340024,
-0.0647311434,
0.0300289784,
-0.025659997,
-0.0425644964,
0.0192325227,
0.0617938489,
0.0031095741,
-0.0180002712,
0.0078051826,
-0.0441547185,
-0.0233061649,
-0.0064706206,
0.0548227355,
0.0199435744,
-0.0256269742,
-0.0148803918,
-0.0980412513,
-0.0626704693,
-0.0066118427,
0.0038050348,
-0.0465823598,
-0.0154089285,
-0.0014002302,
0.0459183678,
0.0161884986,
0.0058109756,
-0.0715934336,
-0.0383441262,
-0.0046109012,
-0.0168619752,
-0.0116564818,
-5.630426923e-33,
-0.0063593001,
-0.00652275,
0.001792474,
-0.0478846058,
-0.0140071688,
0.0275557321,
0.0197040588,
0.0045437026,
-0.0510907657,
0.0331796296,
-0.0220888369,
-0.0329951905,
0.0125179868,
0.0169417243,
0.0619847924,
0.0245394129,
0.0216126535,
0.0422349982,
0.0098461118,
0.0105921794,
0.0320692547,
0.0303933602,
0.1287573874,
-0.055047635,
0.0483714826,
0.0123717496,
-0.0118153123,
0.0104334028,
0.0805361792,
0.0340997763,
-0.0288996994,
0.0650613979,
0.028330151,
-0.0742667094,
-0.0207327772,
0.0484878793,
-0.0540816821,
-0.0509664826,
0.0378067121,
0.0194957554,
0.0160366427,
-0.0563454218,
-0.0182330888,
-0.015138166,
0.0112545034,
0.0023666548,
0.0712488145,
0.0124888951,
0.0049344236,
0.0162311755,
-0.0835904852,
-0.0062223636,
-0.0339067131,
0.0673448443,
0.0250023901,
0.0581139177,
0.0268744975,
0.0601524375,
-0.0509643294,
0.0214184299,
-0.0252314676,
0.0305905547,
0.0533724278,
-0.0139727434,
0.0178125221,
0.0531309433,
-0.0020478729,
0.0332205445,
-0.007081416,
0.0021091476,
0.0462075174,
0.0018829831,
0.0089105517,
0.0655633509,
0.0057020234,
-0.0309153702,
-0.0575022139,
-0.0384591259,
0.0487857461,
-0.0036480301,
-0.0011822571,
-0.0141348261,
0.0135506783,
-0.0434330143,
-0.0258232746,
-0.0447648652,
0.0068331384,
-0.0365866274,
0.0387818329,
-0.0160288606,
0.047777012,
0.0276198536,
0.0446172878,
-0.0650102496,
-0.0450587571,
0.019246174,
-0.0391409956,
-0.0043974207,
0.032270804,
0.0334802791,
-0.0527859442,
-0.0322256275,
-0.0502036512,
0.0375523344,
0.0318788774,
0.0443773568,
0.0195216015,
-0.0128056752,
-0.0455056429,
-0.011134184,
-0.0285812896,
-0.0315056145,
-0.0343599543,
-0.0040754122,
0.0332711376,
-0.0145923486,
-0.0130358506,
-0.0268291738,
0.0875135511,
0.0025575166,
-0.0007160425,
-0.0232778266,
0.0094918348,
0.0339139774,
0.0002166065,
-0.0172215607,
-0.0189955737,
0.0591270849,
0.0619340055,
-0.0238925405,
-0.0299176723,
-0.0227328464,
2.334e-7,
0.0583823137,
0.0559903309,
-0.0349046737,
0.0227558743,
0.0138625745,
0.0181145109,
-0.004287499,
0.0533105917,
-0.0239720047,
0.0273608118,
-0.0042585563,
-0.0094871046,
0.0311297514,
0.037060257,
-0.1059007421,
0.0270965546,
-0.0754068941,
-0.0046002176,
-0.0609199665,
0.0320113711,
0.0629903898,
0.0609596819,
0.0450296029,
0.0126056224,
-0.0469851829,
-0.0490396768,
0.0592870973,
-0.0420418419,
-0.0091325911,
-0.0184596535,
0.002706154,
0.0249992572,
0.0252653379,
0.0272322893,
0.0232737381,
0.0560986698,
0.0628477484,
0.0225455444,
-0.0022240421,
0.0254883096,
-0.0182005726,
-0.049251359,
-0.0161067955,
-0.0757522732,
0.0526082665,
-0.0533419363,
-0.0617754124,
-0.081259273,
-0.0231748428,
0.0387541763,
0.0709951892,
0.0112239271,
-0.0453405678,
-0.0201637261,
0.0300817303,
0.0062285406,
0.0000066659,
-0.0277960282,
-0.0427022129,
0.0321919769,
-0.0116792684,
-0.0265774969,
0.0301663391,
-0.0053673596,
0.0439193025,
-0.0270334203,
0.003601966,
2.149580602e-34,
0.0288776625,
0.0354365185,
0.0335246921,
0.0227346923,
0.0451903753,
0.0013245683,
-0.0026419866,
-0.0050811991,
-0.0098482901,
-0.0147370258,
-0.0122186206
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.